id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13967v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13967v3
|
DeTox: Toxic Subspace Projection for Model Editing
| 2024-05-22T20:08:48 | 2024-05-28T19:55:16 |
Rheeya Uppaal, Apratim Dey, Yiting He, Yiqiao Zhong, Junjie Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent alignment algorithms such as direct preference optimization (DPO) have
been developed to improve the safety of large language models (LLMs) by
training these models to match human behaviors exemplified by preference data.
However, these methods are both computationally intensive and lacking in
controllability and transparency, making them prone to jailbreaking and
inhibiting their widespread use. Furthermore, these tuning-based methods
require large-scale preference data for training and are susceptible to noisy
preference data. In this paper, we introduce a tuning-free alignment
alternative (DeTox) and demonstrate its effectiveness under the use case of
toxicity reduction. Grounded on theory from factor analysis, DeTox is a
sample-efficient model editing approach that identifies a toxic subspace in the
model parameter space and reduces model toxicity by projecting away the
detected subspace. The toxic sub-space is identified by extracting preference
data embeddings from the language model, and removing non-toxic information
from these embeddings. We show that DeTox is more sample-efficient than DPO,
further showcasing greater robustness to noisy data. Finally, we establish both
theoretical and empirical connections between DeTox and DPO, showing that DeTox
can be interpreted as a denoised version of a single DPO step.
|
[
-0.03269441798329353,
-0.35314860939979553,
0.7397088408470154,
-0.2752157747745514,
-0.18377946317195892,
0.0957784578204155,
-0.18686240911483765,
-0.14035139977931976,
0.013973241671919823,
0.6820938587188721,
-0.6058366298675537,
-0.7746412754058838,
-0.22050710022449493,
-0.04474468529224396,
-0.22609595954418182,
0.8703778386116028,
0.22649066150188446,
0.0064500365406274796,
-0.22498351335525513,
0.07446310669183731,
-0.5538463592529297,
-0.2929735481739044,
-0.6382278800010681,
-0.11964385211467743,
0.7224794030189514,
0.5221889615058899,
0.9972495436668396,
0.901049792766571,
0.4496290981769562,
0.2909514605998993,
-0.3764718174934387,
0.2643759548664093,
-0.824335515499115,
0.1840163916349411,
-0.4443872272968292,
-0.44987910985946655,
-0.5066149830818176,
0.1905577927827835,
0.3114387094974518,
0.4032304286956787,
-0.11293099075555801,
-0.05493031442165375,
-0.2577698826789856,
0.8790571093559265,
-0.799644947052002,
-0.1591300517320633,
-0.9955068826675415,
0.15760628879070282,
-0.038471758365631104,
-0.12033619731664658,
-0.6611927151679993,
-0.32879316806793213,
-0.2402515858411789,
-0.7784972786903381,
-0.08892584592103958,
-0.07265505939722061,
0.9032939076423645,
0.8043496012687683,
-0.4532385766506195,
0.15109452605247498,
-0.7940645217895508,
0.9703665375709534,
-0.7889562845230103,
0.5303351879119873,
0.29776865243911743,
-0.03142214193940163,
-0.27794045209884644,
-0.2959938943386078,
-0.22899465262889862,
-0.14107052981853485,
0.0987112745642662,
0.13457682728767395,
-0.15216344594955444,
0.5245652794837952,
0.20056815445423126,
0.2174154669046402,
-0.3794654905796051,
0.34634554386138916,
-0.2780284881591797,
-0.222969189286232,
0.7242566347122192,
0.1703699231147766,
0.5383449792861938,
-0.24265141785144806,
-0.4156893789768219,
0.11805383116006851,
-0.8801376223564148,
-0.35575172305107117,
0.5697755217552185,
0.45689693093299866,
0.027436111122369766,
0.3314231038093567,
0.021006550639867783,
0.4602716267108917,
0.20973660051822662,
-0.02526067942380905,
0.3745135962963104,
-0.060107871890068054,
-0.2720502018928528,
-0.08192171901464462,
0.762813150882721,
0.7281748056411743,
0.1693885773420334,
-0.1725884974002838,
0.24124974012374878,
0.060307279229164124,
0.6839889287948608,
-0.8426707983016968,
-0.4215698838233948,
0.49315527081489563,
-0.5953451991081238,
-0.8441633582115173,
-0.4734569787979126,
-1.108388066291809,
-0.5409123301506042,
-0.3899573087692261,
0.11293341964483261,
-0.6024921536445618,
-0.2436155527830124,
0.2683626711368561,
-0.08682017773389816,
-0.12787160277366638,
0.30053767561912537,
-0.8332772850990295,
0.0929761454463005,
0.6782540678977966,
0.867975652217865,
-0.12811651825904846,
0.32920241355895996,
-0.651877760887146,
0.11455396562814713,
-0.56181800365448,
0.49338433146476746,
-0.9330365061759949,
-0.5597533583641052,
-0.17796590924263,
-0.2932673692703247,
0.08583452552556992,
-0.7590509057044983,
0.7861430048942566,
-0.47420448064804077,
-0.00552690215408802,
-0.45706143975257874,
-0.5019029974937439,
-0.1349576711654663,
-0.12213781476020813,
-0.5665967464447021,
0.94179767370224,
-0.03288702666759491,
-0.8080209493637085,
0.4333969056606293,
-0.6108106374740601,
0.13595420122146606,
-0.2133103609085083,
0.14669018983840942,
-0.44491076469421387,
0.30465757846832275,
0.09995356947183609,
-0.04104084521532059,
0.23306435346603394,
0.31976667046546936,
-0.6573246717453003,
-0.3440033197402954,
0.02966310828924179,
-0.22289292514324188,
0.7887113690376282,
0.5866178870201111,
0.02058030664920807,
0.56080162525177,
-0.8561276793479919,
-0.048828598111867905,
-0.16697190701961517,
-0.19718614220619202,
-0.8610076904296875,
0.4131127595901489,
-0.11741764098405838,
0.47707313299179077,
-0.06104230880737305,
-0.7346472144126892,
0.39706724882125854,
-0.3718678653240204,
0.25685811042785645,
1.0823692083358765,
0.1170090064406395,
0.4683960974216461,
-0.3002859354019165,
0.5491250157356262,
0.17424781620502472,
0.3424232602119446,
0.4589326083660126,
-0.2514977753162384,
-0.7122265100479126,
-0.6027323603630066,
0.18693187832832336,
0.6412756443023682,
-0.7212800979614258,
0.45047083497047424,
-0.37108469009399414,
-0.5347799062728882,
-0.547980546951294,
0.34867656230926514,
0.4523416757583618,
0.7109987139701843,
0.47191712260246277,
-0.14131644368171692,
-0.5772440433502197,
-1.1297080516815186,
-0.2665155827999115,
-0.139694482088089,
-0.003913271706551313,
0.3859425485134125,
0.2556890845298767,
-0.24811774492263794,
0.693585216999054,
-0.749208390712738,
-0.15894047915935516,
0.028154384344816208,
-0.3410988748073578,
0.02397749572992325,
0.5365434288978577,
0.7098063826560974,
-0.3195611536502838,
-0.5432995557785034,
-0.13475024700164795,
-0.4843003451824188,
-0.5337777137756348,
-0.1103992834687233,
-0.7393954992294312,
-0.3015609383583069,
0.504574179649353,
-0.28702232241630554,
0.2958625555038452,
0.42803671956062317,
-0.15458817780017853,
0.5309457182884216,
-0.04386050999164581,
-0.01731305755674839,
-0.8412548303604126,
0.2325815111398697,
-0.13430927693843842,
-0.18969722092151642,
-1.202912449836731,
0.1949196755886078,
0.1949596107006073,
-0.2783728241920471,
-0.6922604441642761,
0.4404934346675873,
-0.26713162660598755,
0.5044371485710144,
-0.179942786693573,
0.09244565665721893,
0.05772174894809723,
0.40441253781318665,
0.29900065064430237,
0.6404728889465332,
0.3120494782924652,
-0.39521336555480957,
-0.2738952934741974,
0.6310606598854065,
-0.15173551440238953,
0.32118117809295654,
-0.30628082156181335,
0.4072708785533905,
-0.32522323727607727,
-0.028925485908985138,
-0.900562584400177,
0.09107151627540588,
0.41681939363479614,
0.08933635801076889,
0.3638785481452942,
-0.10106249153614044,
-0.23883885145187378,
-0.07952241599559784,
-0.5858681797981262,
0.4363667368888855,
0.5154813528060913,
-0.546220064163208,
0.030679894611239433,
0.37997591495513916,
0.017000120133161545,
-0.6929222345352173,
-0.4720102846622467,
-0.011036223731935024,
-0.6243405938148499,
-0.20194771885871887,
0.39022350311279297,
-0.1959381103515625,
-0.401012122631073,
-0.168186753988266,
-0.1566988080739975,
-0.12523236870765686,
0.2532479465007782,
0.1800227165222168,
0.3907759487628937,
0.35579535365104675,
0.27413055300712585,
0.47662410140037537,
-0.2610096037387848,
-0.05431003496050835,
0.280551940202713,
0.2828702926635742,
0.3425712585449219,
-0.06501585245132446,
-0.5088948011398315,
0.5526182651519775,
0.7173852920532227,
-0.1666284203529358,
0.4891246259212494,
0.06457100063562393,
-0.143315851688385,
-0.31389090418815613,
-0.2304360419511795,
0.021512819454073906,
-0.5828366279602051,
0.36611998081207275,
-0.04248121380805969,
-0.5662279725074768,
0.46551674604415894,
-0.18651050329208374,
0.1756671816110611,
0.12991759181022644,
0.36985108256340027,
0.24425019323825836,
1.122970461845398,
0.47714754939079285,
-0.09665874391794205,
0.8332534432411194,
0.060742687433958054,
0.3411957323551178,
-1.042398452758789,
0.14501610398292542,
-0.39982491731643677,
-0.6000226140022278,
-0.44565966725349426,
-0.5601174235343933,
0.5408140420913696,
-0.17632846534252167,
-0.5451337695121765,
0.10608997195959091,
-0.7094143629074097,
0.5807831883430481,
0.525336742401123,
0.4091891348361969,
0.4921375811100006,
0.01823444850742817,
-0.20738950371742249,
-0.5048904418945312,
-0.38688573241233826,
-0.32645383477211,
1.047521948814392,
0.4177165627479553,
0.8071608543395996,
0.05701172351837158,
0.8563310503959656,
-0.10896068811416626,
0.4125979542732239,
-0.9298267364501953,
0.5021381378173828,
-0.5314241647720337,
-0.8622458577156067,
0.024748746305704117,
-0.42989760637283325,
-0.5362458825111389,
0.41793563961982727,
-0.1630905270576477,
-0.9003517031669617,
0.6376730799674988,
0.16349366307258606,
-0.37697526812553406,
0.648909866809845,
-0.656635582447052,
0.6930792927742004,
-0.2474658489227295,
-0.6170073747634888,
-0.2782955765724182,
-0.5046136975288391,
0.5292733907699585,
-0.0859532579779625,
0.31450527906417847,
-0.2728790044784546,
-0.05649811401963234,
0.4293201267719269,
-0.5749523043632507,
0.7686175107955933,
-0.28309139609336853,
-0.3360849618911743,
0.06546329706907272,
0.5104694366455078,
0.31858721375465393,
-0.0514163114130497,
-0.5247824192047119,
0.24201074242591858,
0.10913781821727753,
0.08025947958230972,
-0.524761974811554,
0.6639386415481567,
-0.72712242603302,
-0.570302426815033,
-0.20578116178512573,
-0.9460166692733765,
-0.4773763120174408,
0.3109571933746338,
0.09484551101922989,
0.09373164921998978,
0.014292970299720764,
-0.1487337350845337,
0.5065732002258301,
-0.8870426416397095,
0.08282950520515442,
0.3600016236305237,
-0.46707913279533386,
-0.36061370372772217,
0.9414465427398682,
-0.13053812086582184,
0.5745741128921509,
0.39259073138237,
0.41309061646461487,
-0.141475647687912,
-0.5700578093528748,
-0.1386645883321762,
0.3118141293525696,
-0.5093579292297363,
-0.2944519817829132,
-0.459081768989563,
-0.14178451895713806,
-0.07763048261404037,
-0.2175491750240326,
-0.6665616035461426,
-0.29025033116340637,
-0.4254727065563202,
-0.3928161859512329,
0.40421852469444275,
0.37590906023979187,
-0.4218602478504181,
0.13484139740467072,
-0.7470170855522156,
0.2311982661485672,
-0.06841506063938141,
0.6137849688529968,
-0.22769756615161896,
-0.30056557059288025,
-0.06542558968067169,
0.11690763384103775,
-0.4502074420452118,
-1.1217399835586548,
0.7856239676475525,
0.2380586713552475,
0.4143344461917877,
0.8280066847801208,
0.3157564401626587,
0.9001861214637756,
-0.6469621062278748,
0.6475509405136108,
-0.027232078835368156,
-1.1052590608596802,
0.6563724875450134,
-0.6772736310958862,
0.017306005582213402,
0.9540499448776245,
0.25495514273643494,
-0.6713133454322815,
-0.5517177581787109,
-0.24444580078125,
-0.8413394093513489,
0.4967007040977478,
-0.07980649173259735,
0.2340380996465683,
-0.20185448229312897,
0.6261212825775146,
0.3299027979373932,
0.34597140550613403,
-0.5023245215415955,
-0.227479487657547,
-0.02490386553108692,
-0.30542150139808655,
0.21398112177848816,
-0.49744293093681335,
-0.288326233625412,
-0.5404278039932251,
0.7563584446907043,
0.16271567344665527,
0.16859184205532074,
0.07906635105609894,
0.07485169172286987,
-0.30172961950302124,
0.4246653616428375,
0.3414693772792816,
0.17242954671382904,
-0.6969513893127441,
0.02568969875574112,
-0.0444006621837616,
-0.3443998396396637,
0.33782249689102173,
-0.47286972403526306,
-0.4150000214576721,
-0.11792882531881332,
-0.049659986048936844,
0.7092259526252747,
0.28890082240104675,
-0.7689508199691772,
0.2774830162525177,
0.07543325424194336,
-0.37859466671943665,
0.2221301794052124,
0.23083071410655975,
-0.13820648193359375,
-0.21418626606464386,
-0.3547830283641815,
0.0869777500629425,
0.3973798453807831,
-0.2782462239265442,
0.17885692417621613,
0.59835284948349,
-0.6950891613960266,
-0.1693371832370758,
1.0852965116500854,
0.39653143286705017,
0.07731812447309494,
0.8017433881759644,
0.039073631167411804,
-0.21525385975837708,
0.17546841502189636,
0.34424152970314026,
1.070251703262329,
-0.3827165961265564,
0.4182946979999542,
0.5156409740447998,
0.1591319739818573,
0.36794376373291016,
0.2517218589782715,
0.23028841614723206,
-0.9437085390090942,
-0.44534289836883545,
-0.4869479537010193,
-0.3162895739078522,
0.5162335634231567,
-0.845997154712677,
0.15159590542316437,
-0.6946849822998047,
-0.15000440180301666,
-0.18976327776908875,
-0.3162553310394287,
-0.22329190373420715,
-0.05004645138978958,
0.16246728599071503,
0.8785432577133179,
-1.080852746963501,
0.7171271443367004,
0.4257550835609436,
-0.10967731475830078,
-0.5918193459510803,
-0.085969477891922,
0.5270484685897827,
-0.46619415283203125,
0.5545547008514404,
0.12190541625022888,
-0.00324234995059669,
-0.1493765115737915,
-0.5501798987388611,
-1.0775119066238403,
0.5791764259338379,
0.784008264541626,
-0.6691519021987915,
-0.153823122382164,
-0.19919732213020325,
0.6818684339523315,
0.06153010204434395,
0.0997278168797493,
0.5728397369384766,
0.47346994280815125,
-0.007233062293380499,
-0.7077659368515015,
0.3259972035884857,
-0.3886915445327759,
0.16123360395431519,
0.19703423976898193,
-0.8074637055397034,
0.5049268007278442,
-0.2204027622938156,
-0.3775879442691803,
0.03529442846775055,
0.21218781173229218,
-0.06494200974702835,
-0.2572316825389862,
0.8047256469726562,
0.7198956608772278,
0.7148483395576477,
0.15104171633720398,
0.7620123028755188,
-0.5124702453613281,
0.3737655282020569,
1.1394168138504028,
-0.5573515892028809,
0.7537087202072144,
0.6363875865936279,
-0.13123270869255066,
0.6988701224327087,
0.6155216693878174,
0.1542334258556366,
0.9715732932090759,
0.2659584581851959,
-0.261247456073761,
-0.4664701521396637,
-0.20364446938037872,
-0.27291253209114075,
0.4838939905166626,
0.3171706199645996,
-0.48504865169525146,
-0.32139769196510315,
-0.2532954514026642,
0.3493323028087616,
0.07650474458932877,
-0.18394169211387634,
0.687791645526886,
0.003408429678529501,
-0.5034385323524475,
0.4660479724407196,
-0.33874285221099854,
0.450297474861145,
-0.4124218225479126,
-0.03679521754384041,
-0.13975673913955688,
0.33719155192375183,
-0.33079302310943604,
-0.39122456312179565,
0.6541444063186646,
-0.1373841017484665,
0.013061883859336376,
-0.3995650112628937,
0.6864639520645142,
-0.5022896528244019,
-0.47270962595939636,
0.47151103615760803,
0.32785627245903015,
-0.028768543154001236,
0.10261616110801697,
-0.6637884974479675,
0.02389421872794628,
0.16931375861167908,
-0.1886052042245865,
0.4128250777721405,
-0.16249899566173553,
0.10597652941942215,
0.710960328578949,
0.7056078314781189,
0.302713543176651,
-0.24950408935546875,
-0.023852625861763954,
0.9189990758895874,
-0.4158003330230713,
-0.2962518632411957,
-0.774846613407135,
0.7361068725585938,
-0.0380094051361084,
-0.10306388884782791,
0.5901150703430176,
0.5378016829490662,
0.555103063583374,
-0.18835529685020447,
0.8157164454460144,
0.20301005244255066,
0.47327572107315063,
-0.5397889614105225,
0.7654610872268677,
-0.6869760751724243,
0.2592449486255646,
-0.5982195734977722,
-0.5304262638092041,
-0.5515964031219482,
0.670271635055542,
-0.5014781355857849,
-0.12210241705179214,
0.655484139919281,
1.1386713981628418,
0.01978498324751854,
-0.287539541721344,
0.35115811228752136,
0.4180779457092285,
0.5635562539100647,
0.5961344838142395,
0.5973430871963501,
-0.03706523776054382,
0.2252001315355301,
-0.5940424799919128,
-0.3317859172821045,
-0.03752545267343521,
-1.046679973602295,
-0.7285639643669128,
-0.3427893817424774,
-0.3974623680114746,
-0.2763478457927704,
-0.12338804453611374,
0.8086010813713074,
0.6158580780029297,
-0.7933025360107422,
0.06464755535125732,
-0.016180619597434998,
0.33016353845596313,
-0.5435037016868591,
-0.2600655257701874,
0.23246030509471893,
-0.19091373682022095,
-0.9887838363647461,
0.6157211661338806,
0.37822067737579346,
-0.3552650213241577,
0.0479581318795681,
0.34517574310302734,
-0.21372005343437195,
0.2695937156677246,
0.45474356412887573,
0.12467607855796814,
-0.5438443422317505,
-0.8809122443199158,
-0.1433291882276535,
0.20069430768489838,
0.31734344363212585,
0.6048294305801392,
-0.3405348062515259,
0.9237170815467834,
0.6236057281494141,
0.19560541212558746,
0.13161976635456085,
0.4271283745765686,
0.6943554282188416,
-0.7306604981422424,
0.2921636700630188,
0.047434963285923004,
0.24555262923240662,
0.12220104783773422,
-0.6954650282859802,
0.5097305178642273,
-0.012393949553370476,
-0.5937034487724304,
-0.9332449436187744,
0.4150715470314026,
-1.172069787979126,
-0.3301407992839813,
1.4730867147445679,
0.08508726209402084,
-0.10327117145061493,
-0.11056960374116898,
-0.5082444548606873,
0.21921871602535248,
-0.5612089037895203,
0.9675628542900085,
0.4370480477809906,
-0.30646660923957825,
0.030855190008878708,
-0.671430230140686,
0.6814211010932922,
0.3575035035610199,
-0.8000613451004028,
0.38334307074546814,
0.8529503345489502,
0.6271069645881653,
0.07076417654752731,
0.5728675723075867,
-0.3105531930923462,
-0.1417768895626068,
-0.09210057556629181,
0.17564520239830017,
-0.27518540620803833,
-0.19904136657714844,
-0.44002580642700195,
-0.16644173860549927,
-0.00887676514685154,
-0.24409224092960358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13966v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13966v1
|
On the Brittle Foundations of ReAct Prompting for Agentic Large Language Models
| 2024-05-22T20:05:49 | 2024-05-22T20:05:49 |
Mudit Verma, Siddhant Bhambri, Subbarao Kambhampati
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The reasoning abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) remain a topic of
debate. Some methods such as ReAct-based prompting, have gained popularity for
claiming to enhance sequential decision-making abilities of agentic LLMs.
However, it is unclear what is the source of improvement in LLM reasoning with
ReAct based prompting. In this paper we examine these claims of ReAct based
prompting in improving agentic LLMs for sequential decision-making. By
introducing systematic variations to the input prompt we perform a sensitivity
analysis along the claims of ReAct and find that the performance is minimally
influenced by the "interleaving reasoning trace with action execution" or the
content of the generated reasoning traces in ReAct, contrary to original claims
and common usage. Instead, the performance of LLMs is driven by the similarity
between input example tasks and queries, implicitly forcing the prompt designer
to provide instance-specific examples which significantly increases the
cognitive burden on the human. Our investigation shows that the perceived
reasoning abilities of LLMs stem from the exemplar-query similarity and
approximate retrieval rather than any inherent reasoning abilities.
|
[
-0.2560441493988037,
-0.855549693107605,
1.0576540231704712,
0.027193928137421608,
-0.02110178768634796,
0.2045874148607254,
-0.33080601692199707,
-0.22154107689857483,
-0.05059081315994263,
0.10814309120178223,
-0.6656841039657593,
-0.23384584486484528,
-0.1904624104499817,
0.4996592104434967,
-0.03315718099474907,
0.5152302384376526,
0.04005866125226021,
-0.18174314498901367,
-0.46395882964134216,
-0.08562564849853516,
-0.6126399636268616,
-0.31245866417884827,
-0.7866266369819641,
-0.5254983901977539,
0.7096171975135803,
0.4629232585430145,
0.7172678709030151,
0.23686756193637848,
0.07046657055616379,
0.3875923156738281,
-0.22697874903678894,
0.050705257803201675,
-0.38287538290023804,
0.527335524559021,
-0.51479572057724,
-0.7929970622062683,
-0.14623335003852844,
-0.20904900133609772,
0.6878370046615601,
0.4158012270927429,
0.07427649199962616,
0.047013189643621445,
0.011942326091229916,
0.5278644561767578,
-0.6045989990234375,
0.15214914083480835,
-0.6541802287101746,
-0.18847963213920593,
0.10255387425422668,
-0.3475074768066406,
-0.9700517654418945,
-0.08882974088191986,
-0.010831775143742561,
-0.36896049976348877,
0.15304023027420044,
0.18313951790332794,
0.3229275345802307,
0.504549503326416,
-0.46129757165908813,
-0.2521899342536926,
-0.5198014378547668,
0.5343713164329529,
-0.6713538765907288,
0.07023083418607712,
0.3171588182449341,
0.21049268543720245,
-0.3030703365802765,
-0.582854688167572,
-0.6467583775520325,
-0.49131351709365845,
-0.09703561663627625,
-0.01350884698331356,
-0.03750301152467728,
0.19355516135692596,
0.7448134422302246,
-0.08647129684686661,
-0.5545694828033447,
0.32375219464302063,
0.1830587536096573,
-0.2753625512123108,
0.4418228566646576,
0.3915237486362457,
0.16249297559261322,
-0.10805632174015045,
-0.29658082127571106,
-0.34073078632354736,
-0.8475619554519653,
0.42229658365249634,
0.20532342791557312,
0.5831984281539917,
-0.195070281624794,
0.4854253828525543,
-0.44337937235832214,
0.7754110097885132,
0.09916019439697266,
0.04237596318125725,
0.08653545379638672,
-0.15614917874336243,
0.058669984340667725,
-0.10816137492656708,
0.5703670978546143,
0.3785359263420105,
0.6065658926963806,
0.28136521577835083,
-0.1842118352651596,
0.2215537577867508,
0.17948271334171295,
-0.6958571076393127,
0.040846019983291626,
0.2923116087913513,
-0.3217621445655823,
-0.03886973485350609,
-0.14714345335960388,
-0.4336150288581848,
-0.6583501100540161,
-0.33162224292755127,
0.3187732398509979,
-0.17842797935009003,
-0.13848499953746796,
-0.18965865671634674,
-0.2307875007390976,
0.22958840429782867,
0.5011352896690369,
-0.7380847334861755,
0.24636250734329224,
0.7428475618362427,
0.6001192331314087,
-0.3046635389328003,
-0.24554170668125153,
-0.6114218235015869,
-0.2973496913909912,
-0.4514070153236389,
1.0910718441009521,
-0.6719164252281189,
-0.39674538373947144,
0.023470886051654816,
0.004154144320636988,
-0.08601684868335724,
-0.719596266746521,
0.25876614451408386,
-0.590034008026123,
-0.31059983372688293,
-0.7173904180526733,
-0.26204270124435425,
-0.13991954922676086,
0.22179707884788513,
-0.6539422273635864,
0.9572629332542419,
0.08782579749822617,
-0.43517938256263733,
0.386258065700531,
-0.28872647881507874,
-0.5808192491531372,
0.18026703596115112,
-0.403997004032135,
0.028479771688580513,
0.20802120864391327,
0.15318335592746735,
0.3001505732536316,
-0.44262731075286865,
0.18424208462238312,
-0.3690798878669739,
-0.31045910716056824,
0.6028006672859192,
-0.4080643951892853,
0.5970889925956726,
0.12306676059961319,
-0.31080079078674316,
0.4732455611228943,
-0.5657824277877808,
0.11394501477479935,
0.037173982709646225,
-0.25469833612442017,
-0.37659046053886414,
0.12133274227380753,
-0.6035990715026855,
0.3298596441745758,
0.04925994202494621,
-0.14304296672344208,
0.1306854784488678,
-0.3339386582374573,
0.3509415090084076,
1.100054383277893,
0.22715631127357483,
0.5096609592437744,
-0.4850253462791443,
0.707015335559845,
-0.24984228610992432,
0.1226830780506134,
-0.3204195499420166,
-0.5327489376068115,
-0.4564773738384247,
-0.21003317832946777,
-0.028414074331521988,
0.3682359457015991,
-0.9118027687072754,
-0.1847631186246872,
-0.1891423612833023,
-0.11919378489255905,
-0.1380545198917389,
-0.014989271759986877,
0.48491495847702026,
0.7696748971939087,
0.05482559651136398,
0.015421782620251179,
-0.2120925933122635,
-0.747727632522583,
-0.3979242444038391,
-0.4256136417388916,
0.34313032031059265,
0.3978147506713867,
0.42572689056396484,
0.2449198067188263,
1.0718493461608887,
-0.2489456832408905,
0.5131316781044006,
-0.1284012496471405,
-0.10116662830114365,
0.19974704086780548,
0.021376607939600945,
0.3728703558444977,
-0.6836190223693848,
-0.7969589233398438,
-0.16561011970043182,
-0.49434274435043335,
-0.36826011538505554,
-0.009321271441876888,
-0.05101305991411209,
0.43409299850463867,
0.7641421556472778,
-0.9001270532608032,
0.3640510141849518,
0.13668444752693176,
-0.5460586547851562,
0.7828356623649597,
-0.10590303689241409,
0.147622749209404,
-0.7211292386054993,
-0.07733858376741409,
-0.2184278815984726,
-0.179209902882576,
-0.38064560294151306,
0.22283942997455597,
0.04241805523633957,
-0.08915950357913971,
-0.5367909073829651,
0.9765884280204773,
-0.4719219505786896,
-0.11556503176689148,
-0.425111323595047,
0.14322373270988464,
-0.11225096881389618,
0.4256380796432495,
-0.045418042689561844,
0.9965086579322815,
0.4153279960155487,
-0.7514280080795288,
0.2595367431640625,
0.037642206996679306,
-0.09895092248916626,
0.7333341240882874,
-0.6893199682235718,
0.10538879036903381,
-0.12735505402088165,
0.3239876329898834,
-1.302740454673767,
-0.11324691027402878,
0.19244368374347687,
-0.3190760910511017,
0.216430202126503,
0.07030004262924194,
-0.44373592734336853,
-0.6212417483329773,
-0.29765501618385315,
0.33837080001831055,
0.7174341082572937,
-0.5751960873603821,
0.732305109500885,
-0.2863038182258606,
-0.5379564166069031,
-0.6704877018928528,
-0.30511072278022766,
-0.15972939133644104,
-0.12142881751060486,
-0.5329031348228455,
-0.026614751666784286,
-0.5123043656349182,
-0.7785040736198425,
0.035756926983594894,
-0.24087214469909668,
0.28130823373794556,
0.055972617119550705,
0.3663041889667511,
0.23353278636932373,
-0.21395689249038696,
0.48767900466918945,
0.03768382593989372,
-0.1314612329006195,
0.24325528740882874,
0.06157713010907173,
0.4626721739768982,
0.0011295925360172987,
-0.4575888514518738,
-0.43992123007774353,
0.1903611272573471,
0.6327168941497803,
-0.10932260751724243,
0.540136992931366,
-0.19944486021995544,
0.13986459374427795,
-0.6899099349975586,
-0.5342780947685242,
-0.6517061591148376,
-0.5116750001907349,
-0.04687277972698212,
-0.7949521541595459,
-0.9448317885398865,
0.7655688524246216,
-0.3931259214878082,
-0.21901951730251312,
0.5233128666877747,
0.6050507426261902,
0.022893236950039864,
1.0556669235229492,
-0.06561870872974396,
0.13311496376991272,
0.43080881237983704,
0.18142157793045044,
-0.2996354401111603,
-0.6887691020965576,
-0.1652473509311676,
-0.6668241620063782,
-0.2508760690689087,
-0.2627078592777252,
-0.5598045587539673,
0.009061993099749088,
-0.42728540301322937,
-0.43846115469932556,
-0.21110567450523376,
-0.43255895376205444,
0.4050244390964508,
0.3111210763454437,
0.06454309076070786,
0.28400394320487976,
0.0439775213599205,
-0.3781956732273102,
0.2347283959388733,
-0.8136730194091797,
-0.17922136187553406,
0.8399612307548523,
0.014395520091056824,
0.9823585152626038,
0.058444369584321976,
0.24372850358486176,
0.4183533489704132,
0.1320337951183319,
-0.9369493126869202,
0.7855445742607117,
0.3128523826599121,
-0.5022162199020386,
-0.30081215500831604,
-0.439541757106781,
-1.0748399496078491,
0.40332454442977905,
-0.10333161801099777,
-0.5861412286758423,
0.19250325858592987,
0.11904696375131607,
-0.3880389332771301,
-0.19289809465408325,
-0.7142801284790039,
0.5006300806999207,
-0.07319134473800659,
-0.47786420583724976,
-0.4176095128059387,
-0.6371985673904419,
0.009070808067917824,
0.1905953288078308,
0.26378265023231506,
-0.10527720302343369,
-0.15231136977672577,
0.27019158005714417,
-0.7216254472732544,
1.009975552558899,
-0.14751850068569183,
-0.27974873781204224,
0.7105483412742615,
0.3070647716522217,
1.0762178897857666,
-0.2331499308347702,
-0.3468118906021118,
-0.4335933029651642,
-0.5200024843215942,
-0.15359076857566833,
-0.9034038186073303,
0.7237257957458496,
-0.3536812663078308,
-1.0096665620803833,
-0.1843297779560089,
-0.61844402551651,
-0.30637484788894653,
0.06437252461910248,
0.18858745694160461,
0.6312590837478638,
0.020601024851202965,
0.05586545541882515,
0.7217051386833191,
-0.0732574313879013,
0.6343272924423218,
0.7627415657043457,
-0.08440688252449036,
-0.1410604566335678,
0.5598618388175964,
0.10110510885715485,
0.4636874794960022,
0.31108176708221436,
0.3772609531879425,
-0.5747231245040894,
-0.2837761342525482,
-0.23943087458610535,
0.44988521933555603,
-1.0024980306625366,
-0.10564462840557098,
-0.26852530241012573,
0.14928247034549713,
-0.26857730746269226,
-0.3199126720428467,
-0.1552092730998993,
-0.2806456983089447,
-0.18411284685134888,
-0.3083846867084503,
0.5917966365814209,
0.8010369539260864,
0.19966693222522736,
0.09829036891460419,
-0.3407052755355835,
0.29660630226135254,
0.5232020616531372,
0.2704201340675354,
0.3894084095954895,
-0.5604060888290405,
0.053887225687503815,
-0.3556447923183441,
0.1913115233182907,
-0.7678723335266113,
-0.10528112202882767,
-0.05266478657722473,
0.7078561186790466,
0.20389549434185028,
0.3989608883857727,
0.34538090229034424,
-0.45083579421043396,
0.7388955950737,
-0.07760943472385406,
-0.64995938539505,
0.6319656372070312,
-0.40606018900871277,
0.6390790939331055,
0.4306638538837433,
0.10206020623445511,
-0.09162787348031998,
-0.3785053491592407,
-0.49010908603668213,
-0.5685921907424927,
0.8321877717971802,
-0.2039114534854889,
0.15321364998817444,
-0.20959413051605225,
0.42157596349716187,
0.1160079687833786,
0.03666701912879944,
-0.4742189049720764,
-0.23305675387382507,
0.3603123128414154,
-0.08336682617664337,
0.05650774762034416,
-0.3042882978916168,
-0.13471028208732605,
-0.19583161175251007,
0.5431675910949707,
-0.4096742272377014,
-0.08976179361343384,
0.3019416034221649,
-0.1849610060453415,
-0.10053091496229172,
0.3012308180332184,
0.7264887094497681,
0.5892820358276367,
0.28654420375823975,
0.3552519381046295,
0.3289974331855774,
-0.11684150248765945,
0.4360577166080475,
-0.11551190167665482,
-0.18041960895061493,
-0.2524375319480896,
0.3064798414707184,
0.8878557682037354,
0.050326116383075714,
-0.8438026309013367,
0.3884769678115845,
0.07181643694639206,
-0.06026739254593849,
-0.11839572340250015,
0.27404478192329407,
-0.05837038904428482,
0.5102513432502747,
0.4072960615158081,
-0.0021885805763304234,
0.08278026431798935,
-0.5196281671524048,
-0.009852787479758263,
0.4487479329109192,
-0.33695676922798157,
-0.1981569081544876,
0.5231544375419617,
0.21601518988609314,
-0.4918959438800812,
0.6869699358940125,
-0.2749657928943634,
-0.3221490681171417,
0.7511056661605835,
0.6966790556907654,
0.6110749840736389,
-0.45690470933914185,
0.2818535566329956,
0.3753422796726227,
0.22174286842346191,
-0.21217887103557587,
0.4989948570728302,
-0.2710185945034027,
-0.5185375213623047,
-0.7195855975151062,
-0.17063702642917633,
-0.28943827748298645,
-0.22091971337795258,
-0.3555217683315277,
0.12994873523712158,
-0.544917643070221,
-0.4357028901576996,
-0.41906556487083435,
-0.29648005962371826,
-0.3915921151638031,
0.17263883352279663,
0.05618314817547798,
0.986814558506012,
-0.6646572947502136,
0.31985488533973694,
0.7222330570220947,
-0.22105689346790314,
-1.1243878602981567,
-0.11156343668699265,
0.1647457778453827,
-0.7602954506874084,
0.62992924451828,
-0.06581946462392807,
-0.33178141713142395,
-0.001158231752924621,
-0.5700725317001343,
-0.7766157984733582,
0.7629056572914124,
0.6479686498641968,
-0.4469602108001709,
0.12012708187103271,
-0.12833094596862793,
0.47372040152549744,
-0.2668240964412689,
0.39694392681121826,
0.36281687021255493,
0.4748885929584503,
0.24145260453224182,
-0.7702672481536865,
0.6968457698822021,
-0.31091663241386414,
0.010908241383731365,
0.10393987596035004,
-0.7584847211837769,
0.9990236759185791,
-0.5889441967010498,
-0.25742441415786743,
0.0329081267118454,
0.26046016812324524,
0.47040948271751404,
0.36619195342063904,
0.4175369143486023,
0.4668859839439392,
0.8897850513458252,
0.0706057995557785,
1.4080313444137573,
0.026180565357208252,
-0.06015712395310402,
1.3319478034973145,
-0.462980717420578,
0.8922946453094482,
0.2697124481201172,
-0.17881269752979279,
1.1153767108917236,
0.49714896082878113,
0.23756839334964752,
0.2828604280948639,
0.14059819281101227,
-0.3636476993560791,
-0.2900776267051697,
-0.2220887988805771,
-0.30935052037239075,
0.19895276427268982,
0.4748527407646179,
-0.4309367835521698,
-0.06942238658666611,
0.047035250812768936,
-0.15473057329654694,
0.10655135661363602,
-0.4352359175682068,
0.8550204634666443,
0.2548390328884125,
-1.1193232536315918,
0.6975652575492859,
-0.5320866703987122,
0.20437195897102356,
-0.5052697062492371,
-0.05730118229985237,
-0.019642788916826248,
-0.17630775272846222,
-0.1334391087293625,
-0.8206680417060852,
-0.1679190993309021,
-0.2795444428920746,
-0.4499567151069641,
-0.09906383603811264,
0.9917500615119934,
0.0694001168012619,
0.24255819618701935,
0.3626749515533447,
0.5529173016548157,
0.12200148403644562,
-0.2836155593395233,
-0.6024717092514038,
0.22899512946605682,
-0.22715246677398682,
-0.5294725298881531,
0.13698559999465942,
0.5239310264587402,
-0.41903743147850037,
0.8118025064468384,
0.54678875207901,
-0.06490444391965866,
-0.13086268305778503,
0.4365592300891876,
0.7392334938049316,
-0.6227992177009583,
-0.5783282518386841,
-1.0618187189102173,
0.6408776640892029,
-0.02453969605267048,
0.07732736319303513,
0.7306116819381714,
0.20315349102020264,
0.298454225063324,
-0.1529218554496765,
0.7982096076011658,
0.09406263381242752,
0.3385631740093231,
-0.5088249444961548,
0.4089844524860382,
-0.4150370955467224,
0.14423106610774994,
-0.025316722691059113,
-0.9324427843093872,
0.04441988468170166,
0.20045897364616394,
-0.46698302030563354,
0.30545035004615784,
0.92865389585495,
0.8996472954750061,
0.45859482884407043,
-0.2302207350730896,
0.36244675517082214,
0.5193104147911072,
0.02707773633301258,
0.3407096266746521,
1.229414939880371,
0.33680930733680725,
0.2933339476585388,
0.35614633560180664,
-0.17052851617336273,
-0.505480945110321,
-0.6599659323692322,
-0.897911548614502,
-0.5334381461143494,
-0.20651419460773468,
-0.3934761583805084,
-0.1139293685555458,
0.8156644105911255,
0.4704693555831909,
-0.5101087689399719,
0.042535506188869476,
-0.3444244861602783,
0.44979214668273926,
-0.19519667327404022,
-0.2513848543167114,
0.2402154952287674,
-0.47063419222831726,
-0.5506640076637268,
0.5675281882286072,
0.16698653995990753,
0.04838934540748596,
0.025021232664585114,
-0.19047755002975464,
-0.035758186131715775,
0.3504018187522888,
0.8589144349098206,
0.6102113723754883,
-0.9227875471115112,
-0.3733578622341156,
0.05631779506802559,
-0.1520690768957138,
0.028476035222411156,
0.7803933620452881,
-1.1248654127120972,
0.7064886093139648,
0.7512812614440918,
0.37860843539237976,
0.24334365129470825,
0.21226505935192108,
0.46890968084335327,
-0.6139490604400635,
0.17714795470237732,
0.09829267114400864,
0.1971401870250702,
0.27117854356765747,
-0.3839952051639557,
0.4451962411403656,
0.2828584313392639,
-0.5230461359024048,
-0.6785959005355835,
0.411655992269516,
-0.9174327850341797,
-0.5863001346588135,
1.4019020795822144,
0.1335177719593048,
-0.3067483603954315,
-0.12566611170768738,
-0.4772433340549469,
0.07780861854553223,
-0.6811896562576294,
0.32562142610549927,
0.7403033375740051,
-0.46820271015167236,
-0.17895977199077606,
-0.26738083362579346,
0.42851731181144714,
0.4707257151603699,
-0.6283522248268127,
0.26626041531562805,
0.6903636455535889,
0.23653891682624817,
0.07796202600002289,
0.9189521670341492,
0.053071942180395126,
0.3959923982620239,
0.32633283734321594,
-0.10825755447149277,
0.05348832905292511,
-0.4044836461544037,
-0.549310028553009,
0.30512508749961853,
0.6470752358436584,
0.443226158618927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13954v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13954v1
|
What is Your Data Worth to GPT? LLM-Scale Data Valuation with Influence Functions
| 2024-05-22T19:39:05 | 2024-05-22T19:39:05 |
Sang Keun Choe, Hwijeen Ahn, Juhan Bae, Kewen Zhao, Minsoo Kang, Youngseog Chung, Adithya Pratapa, Willie Neiswanger, Emma Strubell, Teruko Mitamura, Jeff Schneider, Eduard Hovy, Roger Grosse, Eric Xing
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are trained on a vast amount of human-written
data, but data providers often remain uncredited. In response to this issue,
data valuation (or data attribution), which quantifies the contribution or
value of each data to the model output, has been discussed as a potential
solution. Nevertheless, applying existing data valuation methods to recent LLMs
and their vast training datasets has been largely limited by prohibitive
compute and memory costs. In this work, we focus on influence functions, a
popular gradient-based data valuation method, and significantly improve its
scalability with an efficient gradient projection strategy called LoGra that
leverages the gradient structure in backpropagation. We then provide a
theoretical motivation of gradient projection approaches to influence functions
to promote trust in the data valuation process. Lastly, we lower the barrier to
implementing data valuation systems by introducing LogIX, a software package
that can transform existing training code into data valuation code with minimal
effort. In our data valuation experiments, LoGra achieves competitive accuracy
against more expensive baselines while showing up to 6,500x improvement in
throughput and 5x reduction in GPU memory usage when applied to
Llama3-8B-Instruct and the 1B-token dataset.
|
[
-0.1583784967660904,
-0.3884076476097107,
0.562140703201294,
0.2475103884935379,
-0.29787611961364746,
-0.06945480406284332,
-0.038646306842565536,
-0.46047577261924744,
0.28186923265457153,
0.2702144682407379,
0.12201006710529327,
-0.4212881028652191,
-0.7976875901222229,
-0.5094294548034668,
-0.436509907245636,
1.103126049041748,
0.12345840781927109,
0.30684876441955566,
-0.12914374470710754,
-0.15878750383853912,
-0.12699301540851593,
-0.8817791938781738,
-0.8573392033576965,
-0.35893478989601135,
0.7627691030502319,
0.3070979714393616,
0.6779015064239502,
0.5857510566711426,
0.31873977184295654,
0.11755330860614777,
-0.05950017645955086,
-0.22402194142341614,
-0.8512914180755615,
-0.21237359941005707,
-0.1096547394990921,
-0.682179868221283,
-0.544365406036377,
0.05875255912542343,
0.7536830902099609,
0.5774239897727966,
-0.2966878414154053,
0.4314020276069641,
-0.09453925490379333,
0.9540806412696838,
-0.6106353402137756,
0.5493898987770081,
-0.7774438261985779,
-0.06298784911632538,
-0.3759542405605316,
-0.16579581797122955,
-0.38229846954345703,
-0.7542505264282227,
-0.1267717480659485,
-0.34795358777046204,
-0.11114875227212906,
0.035169050097465515,
0.7514716982841492,
0.24857990443706512,
-0.31856605410575867,
-0.05809514969587326,
-0.6878071427345276,
0.8163286447525024,
-0.46163782477378845,
0.34820252656936646,
0.47386130690574646,
0.2073620855808258,
0.0789714902639389,
-0.7990657091140747,
-0.2555239200592041,
-0.02121145650744438,
-0.08459945768117905,
-0.1948014795780182,
-0.21125254034996033,
-0.02464660443365574,
0.30700749158859253,
0.6096529960632324,
-0.17348238825798035,
0.16321763396263123,
-0.2811185419559479,
-0.27031898498535156,
0.7563363909721375,
0.2124834805727005,
-0.01792706549167633,
0.2484120875597,
-0.15496842563152313,
-0.4150722026824951,
-1.2001311779022217,
0.05746087431907654,
0.4601133465766907,
0.2990241050720215,
0.23326896131038666,
0.41570043563842773,
0.050878703594207764,
0.6632978320121765,
0.11063097417354584,
-0.12857139110565186,
0.23042625188827515,
-0.2814287841320038,
-0.4049713611602783,
0.12487969547510147,
0.5335898995399475,
0.4483431279659271,
0.37296777963638306,
-0.19402673840522766,
-0.16155841946601868,
0.12279009819030762,
0.09720718115568161,
-1.188821792602539,
-0.29846999049186707,
-0.04230787977576256,
-0.4358086884021759,
-0.4407624304294586,
-0.0758511871099472,
-0.852484941482544,
-0.45942527055740356,
-0.20169924199581146,
0.6064189076423645,
-0.10501011461019516,
-0.21418879926204681,
0.2511976361274719,
-0.06467776000499725,
0.304597407579422,
0.7535070776939392,
-1.163902759552002,
0.4661996364593506,
0.5612444877624512,
0.8563446998596191,
-0.08571584522724152,
0.0684337243437767,
-0.7270871996879578,
0.030426926910877228,
-0.5940122604370117,
0.5861626863479614,
-0.7167916893959045,
-0.7935166358947754,
-0.13740192353725433,
-0.17139828205108643,
-0.1454169899225235,
-0.5823651552200317,
0.5158489346504211,
-0.6228001713752747,
-0.06334474682807922,
-0.38076266646385193,
-0.601341962814331,
-0.19636335968971252,
-0.22531616687774658,
-0.9039967656135559,
1.0045740604400635,
0.3171275854110718,
-0.654926598072052,
0.768345057964325,
-0.5618625283241272,
-0.5103190541267395,
0.17080269753932953,
-0.2473352998495102,
-0.36953115463256836,
-0.05056124925613403,
0.34082475304603577,
0.6422597169876099,
-0.31354227662086487,
0.2596052289009094,
-0.0909641832113266,
-0.26292893290519714,
0.20481355488300323,
-0.49313685297966003,
0.32010820508003235,
0.05999709665775299,
-0.28082704544067383,
-0.05344964191317558,
-0.7379459738731384,
0.0916825607419014,
-0.2732335925102234,
-0.37755629420280457,
-0.4951728582382202,
-0.04682619124650955,
-0.08092856407165527,
-0.07195588946342468,
0.07454932481050491,
-0.46331819891929626,
0.42743057012557983,
-0.04271264374256134,
0.208286315202713,
0.9184542894363403,
0.14710716903209686,
0.5567459464073181,
-0.18173421919345856,
0.6262626051902771,
-0.23474033176898956,
0.05054035037755966,
0.012210831977427006,
-0.7063427567481995,
-0.2789459526538849,
-0.45186614990234375,
0.40692979097366333,
0.23343968391418457,
-0.32345181703567505,
-0.2341022491455078,
-0.35794389247894287,
-0.39862602949142456,
-0.5584798455238342,
0.2586851119995117,
0.0942070484161377,
0.6541911959648132,
0.3743175268173218,
-0.13465403020381927,
-0.23549826443195343,
-1.1203904151916504,
-0.23844748735427856,
-0.32816919684410095,
-0.20053716003894806,
0.4214284121990204,
0.2935396134853363,
-0.03982869163155556,
0.6634701490402222,
-0.6621530055999756,
-0.2871069610118866,
0.036169152706861496,
0.0483747236430645,
0.43685391545295715,
0.36850839853286743,
0.6406465768814087,
-0.7028349041938782,
-0.6064153909683228,
0.1162533387541771,
-0.4633541703224182,
0.013820570893585682,
0.006302558816969395,
-0.09963904321193695,
0.016423705965280533,
0.17817102372646332,
-0.5831488370895386,
0.47304993867874146,
0.6350369453430176,
-0.2692595422267914,
0.3726595938205719,
-0.145049586892128,
0.42823174595832825,
-0.5712307691574097,
0.31321075558662415,
0.1805899292230606,
-0.32560524344444275,
-0.43646863102912903,
-0.29605063796043396,
0.12113042175769806,
0.0898430123925209,
-0.12937556207180023,
0.48073047399520874,
-0.1165461465716362,
0.08231253921985626,
0.04482296481728554,
-0.12094505876302719,
-0.10455133020877838,
0.3391459286212921,
-0.12443119287490845,
0.9844387769699097,
0.6276688575744629,
-0.6604663729667664,
0.3831081986427307,
0.11218586564064026,
-0.6972547769546509,
0.7050614356994629,
-0.6158298850059509,
0.33465343713760376,
0.10925547778606415,
0.3474114239215851,
-0.9251703023910522,
0.03537097945809364,
0.23752222955226898,
-0.28077906370162964,
0.3800692558288574,
-0.6110065579414368,
-0.5569506883621216,
0.041857581585645676,
-0.36389267444610596,
0.22748437523841858,
0.5884204506874084,
-0.9204855561256409,
0.40441733598709106,
0.5457795262336731,
-0.2585286796092987,
-0.8086137771606445,
-0.8411740064620972,
0.14082999527454376,
-0.6266381740570068,
-0.5815431475639343,
0.3024057447910309,
0.032260339707136154,
-0.536491870880127,
0.037119362503290176,
0.05602141469717026,
-0.08345251530408859,
-0.17204096913337708,
0.35533612966537476,
0.3354611098766327,
-0.04673561453819275,
0.3818182647228241,
0.1670835167169571,
-0.13073326647281647,
0.23888656497001648,
-0.5494850277900696,
0.294893354177475,
-0.23410005867481232,
-0.1921921819448471,
-0.047046300023794174,
-0.06622917205095291,
0.5059988498687744,
0.06828905642032623,
0.7790316939353943,
0.46928173303604126,
-0.11515874415636063,
-0.31504786014556885,
-0.4047653377056122,
-0.0320570133626461,
-0.45604076981544495,
0.34763848781585693,
-0.3237214982509613,
-0.8416387438774109,
0.5323945879936218,
0.005675224121659994,
0.03794838488101959,
0.5643107891082764,
0.7808332443237305,
0.3470190167427063,
0.8914100527763367,
0.5562348961830139,
-0.764414370059967,
0.5227959156036377,
-0.20566090941429138,
0.11828980594873428,
-0.6592468023300171,
-0.3674020767211914,
-0.33764129877090454,
-0.34619835019111633,
-0.3218494951725006,
-0.604732871055603,
0.28603577613830566,
0.015506786294281483,
-0.14762923121452332,
0.015205476433038712,
-0.3611088991165161,
0.2566428780555725,
0.45725756883621216,
0.21328037977218628,
0.6221047639846802,
0.1768934279680252,
0.47940394282341003,
-0.03340764716267586,
-0.6820021867752075,
-0.3592063784599304,
1.6944475173950195,
0.5539715886116028,
1.4060548543930054,
-0.039604879915714264,
0.36135101318359375,
0.6063683032989502,
0.802364706993103,
-1.0566505193710327,
0.40754395723342896,
-0.008480848744511604,
-0.35696327686309814,
-0.5539568662643433,
-0.5768373012542725,
-0.9456289410591125,
0.14063580334186554,
0.13530895113945007,
-0.9653376936912537,
0.3254176080226898,
0.4253385066986084,
-0.0371723435819149,
0.547523021697998,
-0.6737267971038818,
0.4903464913368225,
-0.15485882759094238,
-0.6765664219856262,
-0.6145728826522827,
-0.20470932126045227,
0.31081047654151917,
-0.3667197823524475,
0.10444294661283493,
0.09729606658220291,
-0.03385869786143303,
0.9731884002685547,
-0.5500917434692383,
0.6693494319915771,
-0.4561130702495575,
-0.5229701399803162,
0.2607201337814331,
0.1110444888472557,
0.6771941781044006,
0.44509264826774597,
-0.3270827531814575,
0.09607863426208496,
-0.1118403896689415,
-0.22760681807994843,
-0.8366920948028564,
0.881676197052002,
-0.37292027473449707,
-0.7085485458374023,
-0.028764106333255768,
-0.39879921078681946,
-0.1871362179517746,
-0.11323186755180359,
0.14085319638252258,
0.5777009725570679,
-0.3008611500263214,
0.22239045798778534,
0.5941624045372009,
0.16898706555366516,
0.3328907787799835,
0.06281114369630814,
-0.4420245885848999,
-0.38879382610321045,
1.0888899564743042,
0.15536752343177795,
0.45478129386901855,
0.42536449432373047,
0.2813665270805359,
-0.49699071049690247,
-0.4164680242538452,
-0.7685006260871887,
0.07667147368192673,
-0.7607266902923584,
-0.22432683408260345,
-0.34671148657798767,
0.14378881454467773,
0.07105390727519989,
-0.17569933831691742,
-0.49395498633384705,
-0.7324613928794861,
-0.016722220927476883,
-0.4691697955131531,
0.8614925146102905,
0.8312087059020996,
-0.23306727409362793,
0.19590778648853302,
-0.39667096734046936,
-0.23385009169578552,
0.37245094776153564,
0.5566776990890503,
-0.01335753221064806,
-0.5106813907623291,
-0.6923788189888,
-0.05787484720349312,
0.12919721007347107,
-0.4429735243320465,
0.5353617668151855,
0.10945848375558853,
0.7060132026672363,
0.4115917682647705,
-0.24332007765769958,
0.5726186037063599,
-0.29615870118141174,
0.6765897870063782,
-0.001443964894860983,
-1.0705853700637817,
0.2266935557126999,
-0.059317369014024734,
-0.19774062931537628,
0.4950562119483948,
0.4749164283275604,
-0.3203117251396179,
-0.05807121843099594,
-0.7295411229133606,
-0.6601143479347229,
0.27520042657852173,
0.1189788356423378,
0.16582848131656647,
0.5177000761032104,
0.5563772916793823,
0.11247795820236206,
0.5119221806526184,
-0.5740412473678589,
-0.3336896300315857,
-0.2456882894039154,
-0.05841568112373352,
-0.410374253988266,
0.0018501350423321128,
-0.3402407467365265,
-0.36603108048439026,
0.4441443383693695,
-0.22747373580932617,
0.22451530396938324,
0.0328727588057518,
0.052440520375967026,
-0.053984642028808594,
0.20390889048576355,
0.16669777035713196,
0.7583849430084229,
-0.2573224902153015,
0.06724409013986588,
0.30723610520362854,
-0.6984171867370605,
0.17061060667037964,
0.04404963180422783,
-0.08335381001234055,
-0.12170854955911636,
0.12913529574871063,
0.8165884017944336,
0.03741373494267464,
-0.2605615556240082,
0.45261988043785095,
0.09981042146682739,
-0.21203617751598358,
0.24564994871616364,
-0.06574301421642303,
-0.03165692090988159,
0.07476119697093964,
0.4431188404560089,
-0.24562321603298187,
0.20251594483852386,
-0.3830748498439789,
0.320747047662735,
0.5075883865356445,
-0.29795920848846436,
-0.37494221329689026,
0.7087566256523132,
0.014369943179190159,
0.0887703225016594,
0.6255106329917908,
0.22506031394004822,
-0.4509526789188385,
0.5202749967575073,
0.3650890290737152,
0.6633149981498718,
-0.2582702040672302,
0.2686298191547394,
0.21271447837352753,
0.1592843234539032,
-0.26579251885414124,
0.05881261080503464,
-0.04211706668138504,
-0.7602946162223816,
-0.44806185364723206,
-0.4389476478099823,
-0.6361560225486755,
0.16671951115131378,
-0.6897993683815002,
0.26372188329696655,
-0.6508704423904419,
-0.17713473737239838,
-0.11892600357532501,
-0.05173281207680702,
-0.6018738746643066,
0.4161887764930725,
-0.04141887649893761,
0.7503697276115417,
-0.7700653076171875,
1.0355780124664307,
0.39044955372810364,
-0.2523926794528961,
-0.9830461740493774,
-0.021863412111997604,
-0.2736094892024994,
-1.1188888549804688,
1.0465713739395142,
-0.191046804189682,
-0.3608997166156769,
0.1957218199968338,
-0.8012689352035522,
-0.7450011372566223,
1.0282340049743652,
0.509284496307373,
-0.45695167779922485,
0.20645152032375336,
-0.1447950303554535,
0.5212984681129456,
-0.4162113070487976,
0.13273242115974426,
0.5416496396064758,
0.547681987285614,
0.1719045490026474,
-0.6638487577438354,
0.06715763360261917,
-0.06871874630451202,
-0.18496254086494446,
0.45420417189598083,
-0.7147160172462463,
0.5955812931060791,
-0.3464375138282776,
-0.03814516216516495,
-0.3210505247116089,
0.2902275621891022,
0.061301976442337036,
0.1715988963842392,
0.4900364577770233,
0.5033354163169861,
1.0025925636291504,
0.09305880963802338,
1.3104628324508667,
-0.4063480794429779,
0.4371935725212097,
0.7991762161254883,
0.03357724845409393,
0.8218632340431213,
0.5510854721069336,
-0.6298841238021851,
0.5967792272567749,
0.63701331615448,
-0.21266566216945648,
0.48388102650642395,
0.4711760878562927,
-0.3127689063549042,
0.023662062361836433,
0.007749865762889385,
-0.44673678278923035,
-0.06837493926286697,
0.596676230430603,
-0.5521855354309082,
0.1100236251950264,
-0.3807021677494049,
0.34747180342674255,
-0.1694931834936142,
-0.589228093624115,
0.3199775516986847,
0.3321296274662018,
-0.2969568371772766,
0.4373704791069031,
-0.2882566452026367,
0.28018373250961304,
-0.9152451753616333,
-0.09796585887670517,
-0.3732438087463379,
0.2578197121620178,
-0.5330277681350708,
-0.8063711524009705,
0.05686748027801514,
-0.2229570895433426,
0.08059792965650558,
-0.28182587027549744,
0.6821177005767822,
-0.3336593806743622,
-0.5281030535697937,
0.3579943776130676,
0.37158021330833435,
0.10992991179227829,
-0.31291064620018005,
-0.16764818131923676,
0.022225121036171913,
-0.07277470827102661,
-0.35980403423309326,
0.5570045709609985,
0.20677880942821503,
0.03088884800672531,
0.8582353591918945,
0.5903050899505615,
0.4258313477039337,
-0.1417718529701233,
0.24865230917930603,
1.0522691011428833,
-0.6092714071273804,
-0.2839992344379425,
-0.9587717652320862,
0.3812386691570282,
0.00919011328369379,
-0.22708192467689514,
0.9201295375823975,
0.7968328595161438,
0.583906888961792,
0.10763273388147354,
1.0200438499450684,
0.19884859025478363,
0.1757277101278305,
-0.6740428805351257,
0.5777729153633118,
-0.39493435621261597,
0.47214475274086,
-0.6250188946723938,
-0.8997577428817749,
-0.4107946455478668,
0.5873201489448547,
-0.5660215616226196,
-0.06504607945680618,
0.45207491517066956,
0.7868155837059021,
0.28190135955810547,
0.00998727511614561,
0.38182684779167175,
0.11131766438484192,
0.41220608353614807,
0.6251201629638672,
0.7925744652748108,
-0.29583436250686646,
0.45328599214553833,
-0.0792856514453888,
-0.5836514234542847,
0.056225042790174484,
-0.8578528165817261,
-0.8381261825561523,
-0.3832954466342926,
-0.39600127935409546,
-0.5865687131881714,
0.10245265811681747,
0.6087648868560791,
0.8063089847564697,
-0.6694886684417725,
-0.39264896512031555,
-0.0019253587815910578,
0.18267270922660828,
-0.1103518009185791,
-0.2224985510110855,
0.6688810586929321,
-0.11957165598869324,
-0.8050864934921265,
0.3235913813114166,
0.35468900203704834,
-0.0028550580609589815,
-0.3961082100868225,
-0.1366584599018097,
0.1672179251909256,
-0.10293064266443253,
0.6647222638130188,
0.30482208728790283,
-0.13879995048046112,
-0.36845263838768005,
-0.18590345978736877,
-0.0020829595159739256,
0.3926546275615692,
1.0659024715423584,
-0.8390465378761292,
0.3316776752471924,
0.21889294683933258,
0.7738134860992432,
1.1257740259170532,
0.36299848556518555,
0.8957833051681519,
-0.19854077696800232,
-0.007958277128636837,
-0.008692195639014244,
0.1385926753282547,
0.294357031583786,
-0.8657546639442444,
0.7249734997749329,
0.3312465250492096,
-0.763232409954071,
-0.6363035440444946,
0.05793566629290581,
-0.8210806250572205,
0.20353533327579498,
1.2405993938446045,
-0.1910112053155899,
0.019136913120746613,
0.13163453340530396,
-0.22390347719192505,
-0.45242515206336975,
-0.833208441734314,
0.6981856822967529,
0.6322329640388489,
-0.4265393316745758,
-0.19440431892871857,
-0.4894343912601471,
0.8680217862129211,
0.4023849070072174,
-0.6844962239265442,
0.12278454750776291,
0.38062983751296997,
0.1744333952665329,
-0.1777019500732422,
0.6557758450508118,
-0.36278703808784485,
-0.31564003229141235,
0.1661691516637802,
-0.276181161403656,
0.13067501783370972,
-0.188089981675148,
-0.4935496747493744,
0.13218048214912415,
0.31443873047828674,
-0.22811268270015717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13929v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13929v2
|
Vikhr: The Family of Open-Source Instruction-Tuned Large Language Models for Russian
| 2024-05-22T18:58:58 | 2024-06-19T17:32:23 |
Aleksandr Nikolich, Konstantin Korolev, Artem Shelmanov, Igor Kiselev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
There has been a surge in the development of various Large Language Models
(LLMs). However, text generation for languages other than English often faces
significant challenges, including poor generation quality and the reduced
computational performance due to the disproportionate representation of tokens
in model's vocabulary. In this work, we address these issues and introduce
Vikhr, a new state-of-the-art open-source instruction-tuned LLM designed
specifically for the Russian language. Unlike previous efforts for Russian that
utilize computationally inexpensive LoRA adapters on top of English-oriented
models, Vikhr features an adapted tokenizer vocabulary and undergoes the
continued pre-training and instruction tuning of all weights. This approach not
only enhances the model's performance but also significantly improves its
computational and contextual efficiency. The remarkable performance of Vikhr
across various Russian-language benchmarks can also be attributed to our
efforts in expanding instruction datasets and corpora for continued
pre-training. Vikhr not only sets the new state of the art among open-source
LLMs for Russian, but even outperforms some proprietary closed-source models on
certain benchmarks. The model weights, instruction sets, and code are publicly
available
|
[
0.16038459539413452,
-0.568041980266571,
0.2047608494758606,
0.2010830193758011,
-0.5558810830116272,
0.2526317238807678,
-0.5763420462608337,
0.012048352509737015,
-0.15651372075080872,
0.5234748125076294,
-0.13644184172153473,
-0.6746007204055786,
-0.4733542203903198,
-0.16164129972457886,
-0.24556586146354675,
1.1062633991241455,
-0.11012295633554459,
0.49643710255622864,
-0.25890839099884033,
-0.03997782990336418,
-0.5024318099021912,
-0.5363911986351013,
-0.18963466584682465,
-0.366211473941803,
0.5544513463973999,
0.6307097673416138,
0.4757782816886902,
0.808643102645874,
0.6433579921722412,
0.37303784489631653,
-0.04747450351715088,
-0.13013046979904175,
-0.49709969758987427,
0.3382956385612488,
-0.03570997714996338,
-0.5909014344215393,
-0.3844853341579437,
-0.7006596922874451,
0.9707371592521667,
0.12422411143779755,
-0.39098814129829407,
0.3188222348690033,
-0.1005815714597702,
0.7754467129707336,
-0.7538356184959412,
-0.05878043174743652,
-0.7549796104431152,
-0.10230626910924911,
-0.31998327374458313,
-0.08242443203926086,
-0.4130871891975403,
-0.5332432985305786,
0.01701267436146736,
-0.5299500226974487,
0.197312131524086,
-0.2070714384317398,
0.6470123529434204,
0.10607970505952835,
-0.08930325508117676,
-0.18596795201301575,
-0.8119810223579407,
0.8681368827819824,
-0.6203924417495728,
0.5294471383094788,
0.03955227509140968,
0.5096268653869629,
-0.005264729261398315,
-0.8678891658782959,
-0.4805909991264343,
-0.010542266070842743,
0.1860058456659317,
-0.1756221354007721,
-0.20909014344215393,
-0.08172737061977386,
-0.09084635972976685,
0.5246129631996155,
-0.46896517276763916,
-0.021795198321342468,
-0.7076045870780945,
-0.23660781979560852,
0.24818788468837738,
0.262457013130188,
0.25046324729919434,
0.0996708869934082,
-0.01296819094568491,
0.017956241965293884,
-0.8165615797042847,
-0.05305388942360878,
0.4502030313014984,
0.3662511110305786,
-0.22725965082645416,
0.8278546929359436,
-0.43338942527770996,
0.8856807351112366,
0.018058080226182938,
-0.043343327939510345,
0.15647925436496735,
-0.2779567837715149,
-0.1505473107099533,
0.16507981717586517,
0.593569278717041,
0.05826006457209587,
0.2978830635547638,
-0.014208218082785606,
-0.20934872329235077,
0.13815519213676453,
0.25851067900657654,
-1.0541704893112183,
-0.39343780279159546,
-0.1591339111328125,
-0.2393590211868286,
-0.46736958622932434,
-0.21869641542434692,
-0.8038730621337891,
-0.1851576715707779,
-0.3521762788295746,
0.579295814037323,
-0.4075675904750824,
-0.1636132448911667,
0.15012860298156738,
0.25576773285865784,
0.5819656848907471,
0.19331373274326324,
-1.0236684083938599,
0.33467262983322144,
0.8284435272216797,
0.8897874355316162,
-0.08935707062482834,
-0.14969244599342346,
-0.9742721319198608,
-0.1430450677871704,
-0.47904810309410095,
0.6114065051078796,
-0.9880353212356567,
-0.3656989336013794,
0.28267115354537964,
-0.032882656902074814,
0.41482749581336975,
-0.32967251539230347,
0.30723148584365845,
-0.560312032699585,
0.11406437307596207,
-0.172264963388443,
-0.23791006207466125,
0.23288443684577942,
0.07766129821538925,
-0.37370312213897705,
0.9873319268226624,
0.24537262320518494,
-0.6463159918785095,
0.40908291935920715,
-0.4575013220310211,
-0.6047606468200684,
0.4032391905784607,
-0.06994761526584625,
-0.5554462671279907,
0.440424382686615,
0.05951881408691406,
0.3567596971988678,
-0.4015902578830719,
0.011767723597586155,
0.18460364639759064,
-0.24579468369483948,
0.22405292093753815,
-0.08021898567676544,
0.1306939721107483,
0.2540656626224518,
-0.06841915100812912,
0.46669530868530273,
-0.850793719291687,
0.28823989629745483,
-0.03944643586874008,
-0.7090423703193665,
-0.3473320007324219,
0.04203746095299721,
0.19738614559173584,
-0.08617851138114929,
0.40124720335006714,
-0.592857837677002,
0.14477752149105072,
-0.6577137112617493,
0.5737527012825012,
0.7411383390426636,
-0.2947044372558594,
0.5110757946968079,
-0.14707651734352112,
0.6423550248146057,
0.009907875210046768,
0.10234479606151581,
-0.5278770327568054,
-0.16708792746067047,
-1.1960461139678955,
-0.3880258798599243,
0.512324333190918,
0.3352256715297699,
-0.6325743198394775,
0.16175559163093567,
-0.5684031844139099,
-0.552456259727478,
-0.8433496952056885,
0.17786464095115662,
0.6589917540550232,
0.23904384672641754,
0.19231079518795013,
0.01266997680068016,
-0.499024897813797,
-0.7764692306518555,
-0.300857275724411,
0.19779248535633087,
0.3030555248260498,
0.029381023719906807,
0.5090702176094055,
0.054069116711616516,
0.8411757349967957,
-0.364175945520401,
-0.0024667386896908283,
-0.3595350682735443,
-0.055972497910261154,
0.09064839780330658,
0.5543942451477051,
0.12430249899625778,
-0.6570971012115479,
-0.906585156917572,
0.5595000386238098,
-0.16835322976112366,
0.07839029282331467,
0.39481937885284424,
-0.15264689922332764,
0.6265485286712646,
0.3793731927871704,
-0.4827578067779541,
0.16709277033805847,
0.6039159297943115,
-0.24856308102607727,
0.5157368779182434,
-0.39906373620033264,
0.0795978456735611,
-1.4833369255065918,
0.13467471301555634,
-0.2933690845966339,
-0.24102619290351868,
-0.6420214176177979,
0.10647600144147873,
0.10219628363847733,
-0.23239688575267792,
-0.60732102394104,
0.6064198017120361,
-0.5020599961280823,
0.04024440050125122,
-0.24111437797546387,
-0.08169939368963242,
-0.31008806824684143,
0.09468672424554825,
-0.1190144270658493,
1.0152455568313599,
0.6786838173866272,
-0.51540207862854,
0.3228246569633484,
0.2179754227399826,
-0.8181548118591309,
0.4147360622882843,
-0.810434103012085,
0.21382011473178864,
-0.2466745674610138,
-0.19047267735004425,
-0.7030606865882874,
-0.4807458817958832,
0.18110398948192596,
-0.5908880233764648,
0.541394054889679,
-0.31443318724632263,
-0.29411983489990234,
-0.05768963322043419,
-0.06878446042537689,
0.3084346354007721,
0.9796180725097656,
-0.6505138278007507,
0.6949635148048401,
0.19949209690093994,
-0.3315655589103699,
-0.8838790655136108,
-0.549450695514679,
-0.10471893101930618,
-0.06811824440956116,
-0.5149281024932861,
0.08190659433603287,
-0.2362622171640396,
-0.31844812631607056,
0.05670859292149544,
-0.16923487186431885,
-0.20269857347011566,
-0.24041320383548737,
0.043615344911813736,
0.2314959615468979,
-0.6068583130836487,
0.18301226198673248,
0.18731053173542023,
-0.11330542713403702,
-0.20627810060977936,
-0.4705793559551239,
0.7439985871315002,
-0.2999497056007385,
-0.165657177567482,
-0.18575812876224518,
0.09272750467061996,
0.7068594694137573,
-0.6462996602058411,
0.8398563861846924,
0.5352528095245361,
-0.24186469614505768,
-0.5014108419418335,
-0.5312387347221375,
0.18065738677978516,
-0.5391696691513062,
0.6356011033058167,
-0.3340608477592468,
-1.244728684425354,
0.15476423501968384,
-0.047493450343608856,
0.18418137729167938,
0.1401338130235672,
0.8129737973213196,
0.3065863847732544,
0.8890823125839233,
0.7947512865066528,
-0.20221461355686188,
0.4806337356567383,
0.10826309025287628,
0.13677145540714264,
-0.6079012155532837,
-0.23275448381900787,
-0.6856798529624939,
-0.0964270755648613,
-0.48439672589302063,
-0.5357397198677063,
0.2577287256717682,
-0.012743390165269375,
-0.2071905881166458,
0.03696303442120552,
-0.5735758543014526,
0.9243063926696777,
0.3151692748069763,
-0.21048188209533691,
0.1339126080274582,
0.27394282817840576,
-0.16082915663719177,
-0.201528400182724,
-0.6875415444374084,
-0.5004656314849854,
1.197425127029419,
-0.03715530410408974,
0.927514374256134,
0.11515776067972183,
0.5451885461807251,
0.15226642787456512,
0.36386024951934814,
-0.7777446508407593,
0.4383382201194763,
-0.3507806360721588,
-0.507358968257904,
-0.17457427084445953,
-0.37054452300071716,
-0.8606731295585632,
0.1881898194551468,
-0.3483183681964874,
-0.70169597864151,
-0.42942479252815247,
0.4960404932498932,
-0.1237928494811058,
0.12247715890407562,
-0.46799007058143616,
0.7964561581611633,
-0.18979617953300476,
-0.6910022497177124,
-0.41255977749824524,
-0.33887261152267456,
0.44500988721847534,
-0.31557968258857727,
0.09424883127212524,
0.08584820479154587,
-0.10371709614992142,
0.4078865051269531,
-0.5415257811546326,
0.5907098650932312,
-0.1214507445693016,
-0.1511276513338089,
0.1426199972629547,
-0.1022128015756607,
0.6277527809143066,
-0.060457561165094376,
-0.011083902791142464,
-0.0006832957733422518,
-0.1524934619665146,
-0.2534288167953491,
-0.4889513850212097,
1.0123850107192993,
-0.8596404194831848,
-0.5692825317382812,
-0.26932844519615173,
-0.357808381319046,
0.11039038002490997,
0.3960147798061371,
0.34901729226112366,
0.700249195098877,
-0.46280425786972046,
0.7421653866767883,
0.6776482462882996,
-0.518877387046814,
0.09945930540561676,
0.6611118912696838,
-0.46803948283195496,
-0.7838236689567566,
1.2329362630844116,
-0.04341494292020798,
0.34682026505470276,
0.7399981021881104,
0.41759368777275085,
0.010437152348458767,
-0.5897973775863647,
-0.4120892882347107,
0.23168310523033142,
-0.6740090847015381,
-0.19348469376564026,
-0.5375006198883057,
-0.27512845396995544,
-0.2573070824146271,
-0.36722978949546814,
-0.45830658078193665,
-0.2335769683122635,
-0.24506115913391113,
0.17014867067337036,
0.477604478597641,
0.7866318821907043,
0.03695257753133774,
0.6883565783500671,
-0.7958924174308777,
0.20739103853702545,
0.30629947781562805,
0.6183736324310303,
-0.2545877993106842,
-0.4937100112438202,
-0.646997332572937,
-0.02012462355196476,
-0.2208753377199173,
-0.3137361705303192,
0.38425520062446594,
0.3041430711746216,
0.3077022433280945,
0.08018830418586731,
-0.13966180384159088,
0.32091355323791504,
-0.9513266086578369,
0.7769452333450317,
0.20380829274654388,
-1.0333797931671143,
0.3458033800125122,
-0.5516291856765747,
0.6231262683868408,
0.29648861289024353,
0.038369640707969666,
-0.5298455357551575,
-0.0010089082643389702,
0.032836880534887314,
-0.724758505821228,
0.873437762260437,
0.1438385546207428,
0.45737895369529724,
0.08635618537664413,
0.34673547744750977,
0.2278590053319931,
0.24422381818294525,
-0.5583361387252808,
-0.12176447361707687,
-0.4055977463722229,
-0.537189781665802,
-0.2868490517139435,
-0.3671227991580963,
0.32910606265068054,
-0.24048738181591034,
0.8674318790435791,
-0.058619171380996704,
0.07963297516107559,
-0.08530870825052261,
-0.23394711315631866,
-0.34296712279319763,
0.585780680179596,
0.8504816889762878,
0.6138759255409241,
0.24881409108638763,
-0.12763023376464844,
0.3320876657962799,
-0.7669222950935364,
0.17680804431438446,
-0.09893737733364105,
-0.16277985274791718,
-0.034688904881477356,
0.012482007034122944,
0.9476596713066101,
0.3519064784049988,
-0.7771384119987488,
0.5629218816757202,
-0.18863588571548462,
-0.2679714858531952,
-0.47788724303245544,
0.2717154920101166,
0.20024508237838745,
0.2928187847137451,
0.06916318833827972,
-0.1533058136701584,
-0.28669968247413635,
-0.19370660185813904,
0.04616612568497658,
0.506953239440918,
-0.4212190806865692,
-0.5892717838287354,
0.5705366730690002,
0.38929954171180725,
-0.8761318922042847,
0.4732517898082733,
0.21267953515052795,
-0.5497932434082031,
0.23128917813301086,
0.6780722141265869,
0.8742625713348389,
-0.4860646724700928,
0.1985408067703247,
0.43008092045783997,
0.48335203528404236,
-0.11703077703714371,
0.6485869884490967,
-0.09081969410181046,
-0.4273219108581543,
-0.5540291666984558,
-1.0360736846923828,
-0.26296451687812805,
0.4933793842792511,
-0.5450237393379211,
0.5996754169464111,
-0.5122851729393005,
-0.029201975092291832,
-0.2315834015607834,
-0.2961251437664032,
-0.563979983329773,
0.018042344599962234,
-0.061580728739500046,
0.8112457394599915,
-0.3878680169582367,
0.9354546070098877,
0.7508916854858398,
0.10680606216192245,
-0.31563788652420044,
-0.10476385802030563,
-0.24698176980018616,
-0.6389557719230652,
0.7116461992263794,
0.06404116749763489,
-0.3200991153717041,
0.40691348910331726,
-0.609704852104187,
-1.0189096927642822,
0.82588791847229,
0.4814135432243347,
-0.8437901139259338,
0.11639107018709183,
0.2569679915904999,
0.5182828903198242,
-0.2250674068927765,
-0.24192161858081818,
0.28138288855552673,
0.3515113592147827,
-0.0052132755517959595,
-0.575080156326294,
-0.31590497493743896,
-0.42125698924064636,
0.02809569612145424,
0.7566763758659363,
-0.833504319190979,
0.8131682276725769,
-0.20141465961933136,
-0.15025345981121063,
0.544282078742981,
0.7635236382484436,
0.03329084813594818,
-0.19170188903808594,
0.1536884754896164,
0.32989394664764404,
0.4446321725845337,
0.043593183159828186,
0.7655822038650513,
-0.5625088810920715,
-0.10773113369941711,
1.0878651142120361,
-0.21769407391548157,
1.0470848083496094,
0.4216476380825043,
0.10012445598840714,
0.4894239604473114,
-0.015892967581748962,
-0.009913566522300243,
0.51938396692276,
0.5452185869216919,
-0.5202149748802185,
-0.3381759524345398,
0.00958834495395422,
-0.38776880502700806,
0.5799646973609924,
0.32227036356925964,
-0.28007015585899353,
-0.006138595286756754,
-0.10570350289344788,
-0.048724811524152756,
0.1896745264530182,
-0.34110018610954285,
0.7613759636878967,
-0.1259535253047943,
-0.6547186970710754,
0.5425127148628235,
0.11727041006088257,
0.6571463346481323,
-0.9614611268043518,
-0.10685275495052338,
-0.02843424677848816,
0.5462926030158997,
0.06796589493751526,
-0.2681068480014801,
0.0284630935639143,
0.41218337416648865,
-0.15067021548748016,
0.007702370174229145,
0.8928980231285095,
-0.6265955567359924,
-0.77618008852005,
-0.1370241492986679,
0.27902817726135254,
-0.015335433185100555,
0.36331337690353394,
-0.13855275511741638,
0.279477596282959,
-0.07803045958280563,
-0.2582131028175354,
0.39684078097343445,
0.47944653034210205,
0.11544576287269592,
0.5216799974441528,
0.7064142823219299,
0.2751219570636749,
0.2540685832500458,
-0.24336625635623932,
0.8848641514778137,
-0.548278272151947,
-0.45072123408317566,
-0.834918200969696,
0.7677807211875916,
0.12427053600549698,
-0.5845802426338196,
0.6668739914894104,
0.6959249377250671,
0.8576939702033997,
-0.3322446346282959,
1.0731258392333984,
0.2333226203918457,
0.4934372007846832,
-0.6426547169685364,
1.0710973739624023,
-0.6315301656723022,
-0.11064951121807098,
-0.06847667694091797,
-1.0050413608551025,
-0.19536960124969482,
0.5695859789848328,
-0.04925726726651192,
-0.06888933479785919,
0.46325165033340454,
0.820717990398407,
-0.16899363696575165,
-0.3102055788040161,
0.4526321291923523,
0.34986358880996704,
0.13390770554542542,
0.23953956365585327,
0.9687108397483826,
-0.16320836544036865,
0.7379612326622009,
0.025848131626844406,
-0.01340177096426487,
-0.1602151244878769,
-0.876067578792572,
-1.1398802995681763,
-0.6933249831199646,
-0.15958009660243988,
0.013226947747170925,
0.35559046268463135,
0.9622321724891663,
0.6742871999740601,
-0.6493908762931824,
-0.27345389127731323,
-0.20124654471874237,
-0.12691619992256165,
0.3003310263156891,
-0.12647712230682373,
-0.024936538189649582,
-0.5530621409416199,
-0.629618227481842,
0.48855775594711304,
0.21768523752689362,
-0.09002320468425751,
-0.34148842096328735,
-0.3692489564418793,
0.11162400990724564,
0.23976607620716095,
0.5734050273895264,
0.17308665812015533,
-0.689144492149353,
-0.16365446150302887,
0.2367256134748459,
-0.026242194697260857,
0.1641673892736435,
0.8970806002616882,
-0.6572701930999756,
0.6760755181312561,
0.5827039480209351,
0.738645076751709,
0.5467470288276672,
-0.2547522187232971,
0.8173825740814209,
-0.7006281018257141,
-0.03249441087245941,
0.007485722191631794,
0.19543719291687012,
0.5856384038925171,
-0.08462559431791306,
0.10126226395368576,
-0.09297671914100647,
-0.6071141958236694,
-0.9778082966804504,
0.14853230118751526,
-0.5813478231430054,
-0.08625876903533936,
1.1817179918289185,
0.14380718767642975,
-0.4547826945781708,
0.14174294471740723,
-0.36431869864463806,
0.4070430099964142,
-0.4061831831932068,
0.6726779341697693,
0.7882700562477112,
0.6341224908828735,
-0.22319552302360535,
-0.3884587287902832,
0.46953877806663513,
0.2316497564315796,
-0.7322461605072021,
0.3280787765979767,
0.5880395174026489,
0.3776731491088867,
-0.11796308308839798,
0.4311651289463043,
-0.005111756734549999,
0.40507379174232483,
-0.07922583818435669,
0.28887397050857544,
-0.2219753861427307,
-0.545728325843811,
-0.5649034380912781,
-0.0848909541964531,
0.30795830488204956,
-0.1566968709230423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13923v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13923v2
|
Why Not Transform Chat Large Language Models to Non-English?
| 2024-05-22T18:53:25 | 2024-05-31T07:22:45 |
Xiang Geng, Ming Zhu, Jiahuan Li, Zhejian Lai, Wei Zou, Shuaijie She, Jiaxin Guo, Xiaofeng Zhao, Yinglu Li, Yuang Li, Chang Su, Yanqing Zhao, Xinglin Lyu, Min Zhang, Jiajun Chen, Hao Yang, Shujian Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The scarcity of non-English data limits the development of non-English large
language models (LLMs). Transforming English-centric LLMs to non-English has
been identified as an effective and resource-efficient method. Previous works
start from base LLMs and perform knowledge distillation (KD) with data
generated by stronger LLMs, e.g. GPT-4. Compared to base LLMs, chat LLMs are
further optimized for advanced abilities, e.g. multi-turn conversation and
human preference alignment, and thus more powerful in both helpfulness and
safety. However, transforming a chat LLM involves two critical issues: (1) How
can we effectively transfer advanced abilities without their supervised data?
(2) How can we prevent the original knowledge from catastrophic forgetting
during transformation? We target these issues by introducing a simple framework
called TransLLM. For the first issue, TransLLM divides the transfer problem
into some common sub-tasks with the translation chain-of-thought, which uses
the translation as the bridge between English and non-English step-by-step. We
further enhance the performance of sub-tasks with publicly available data. For
the second issue, we propose a method comprising two synergistic components:
low-rank adaptation for training to maintain the original LLM parameters, and
recovery KD, which utilizes data generated by the chat LLM itself to recover
the original knowledge from the frozen parameters. In the experiments, we
transform the LLaMA-2-chat-7B to the Thai language. Our method, using only
single-turn data, outperforms strong baselines and ChatGPT on multi-turn
benchmark MT-bench. Furthermore, our method, without safety data, rejects more
harmful queries of safety benchmark AdvBench than both ChatGPT and GPT-4.
|
[
-0.21697990596294403,
-0.5687472820281982,
0.4768144190311432,
0.12109141796827316,
-0.3718531131744385,
0.350796103477478,
-0.5958117842674255,
-0.6280934810638428,
0.20620819926261902,
0.6445661187171936,
-0.4209448993206024,
-0.46231698989868164,
-0.7295697927474976,
0.014701470732688904,
-0.48026055097579956,
1.0563491582870483,
-0.15973050892353058,
0.002836091909557581,
-0.09763839840888977,
-0.25766512751579285,
-0.5254178047180176,
-0.5689225792884827,
-0.8922101855278015,
-0.3230588734149933,
0.43972790241241455,
0.702721893787384,
0.5401040315628052,
0.22897900640964508,
0.4661441147327423,
0.21022607386112213,
0.05497482046484947,
0.38197898864746094,
-0.9388479590415955,
0.013186318799853325,
-0.19373579323291779,
-0.7311712503433228,
-0.5250120759010315,
-0.01923273131251335,
0.4937242865562439,
0.8007694482803345,
0.07642839103937149,
0.02024107612669468,
0.24286434054374695,
0.8982965350151062,
-0.4051860570907593,
0.41650399565696716,
-0.7679627537727356,
-0.0024520321749150753,
-0.1653016060590744,
-0.1799471378326416,
-0.5796610116958618,
-0.17192593216896057,
0.09348803758621216,
-0.45981019735336304,
-0.007872593589127064,
0.17997606098651886,
0.6152233481407166,
0.15359780192375183,
-0.5749085545539856,
-0.10194355994462967,
-1.2627352476119995,
0.8908230066299438,
-0.5164245963096619,
0.582065224647522,
0.5237409472465515,
0.4035780131816864,
-0.2652829587459564,
-0.4497099816799164,
-0.3251775801181793,
-0.11111246794462204,
0.049291495233774185,
0.24359500408172607,
-0.2233230620622635,
-0.06730824708938599,
-0.014422304928302765,
0.23334309458732605,
-0.46802711486816406,
0.427255243062973,
-0.6883115768432617,
-0.2716498374938965,
0.8482256531715393,
-0.053355131298303604,
0.20863328874111176,
0.19399842619895935,
-0.24909023940563202,
-0.20705123245716095,
-0.9283809661865234,
-0.0778038278222084,
0.09500192105770111,
0.44489678740501404,
-0.14390958845615387,
0.44413328170776367,
-0.13058307766914368,
0.17953898012638092,
0.1243503987789154,
-0.5308882594108582,
0.1977374404668808,
-0.3259744644165039,
0.08954167366027832,
0.06456686556339264,
0.8099578022956848,
0.3819774389266968,
0.332027792930603,
-0.36875104904174805,
0.07273251563310623,
-0.16855911910533905,
0.02228124439716339,
-0.6599372029304504,
-0.12197168171405792,
0.09687741100788116,
-0.1922593116760254,
0.04502687230706215,
-0.3236544132232666,
-0.7033652663230896,
-0.22708235681056976,
-0.1677168309688568,
0.2989575266838074,
-0.4901137053966522,
-0.4290967881679535,
0.13064457476139069,
0.2883462905883789,
0.3013831675052643,
0.49494725465774536,
-0.795438826084137,
0.19801659882068634,
0.48405805230140686,
0.7360782623291016,
-0.4873356223106384,
-0.19791772961616516,
-0.16033151745796204,
0.3801707923412323,
-0.562431812286377,
0.5414848327636719,
-0.25643694400787354,
-0.527855634689331,
-0.08346344530582428,
0.3131028711795807,
-0.1553797870874405,
-0.47157683968544006,
0.3798061013221741,
-0.40277954936027527,
0.49749279022216797,
-0.1936390995979309,
-0.29810839891433716,
-0.1922159343957901,
0.23927338421344757,
-0.5718802213668823,
0.824564516544342,
-0.15429013967514038,
-0.5988029837608337,
0.17791955173015594,
-0.6917278170585632,
-0.6835293173789978,
-0.1350676566362381,
0.16313624382019043,
-0.27687084674835205,
0.0988268181681633,
0.3809555768966675,
0.28628990054130554,
-0.34726715087890625,
0.19604240357875824,
-0.33125439286231995,
-0.1638876497745514,
0.21864008903503418,
-0.6629384756088257,
0.4978596270084381,
0.10544848442077637,
-0.032214242964982986,
-0.22372816503047943,
-0.41868212819099426,
-0.05746186524629593,
0.03637200966477394,
-0.4552035927772522,
-0.31570538878440857,
-0.013338452205061913,
-0.11276190727949142,
0.20406129956245422,
0.3064667284488678,
-0.4163508415222168,
0.11710064113140106,
-0.4880898892879486,
0.5193021297454834,
0.5801902413368225,
-0.08184074610471725,
0.8887786865234375,
-0.37646573781967163,
0.5015036463737488,
0.24004624783992767,
0.15823979675769806,
0.15767401456832886,
-0.4325900077819824,
-0.937488853931427,
-0.12715187668800354,
0.264761745929718,
0.6706426739692688,
-1.0773786306381226,
0.18189586699008942,
-0.5290406346321106,
-0.5914958119392395,
-0.542814314365387,
0.20373037457466125,
0.09102727472782135,
0.38720446825027466,
0.5758695006370544,
-0.1261131465435028,
-0.5731270909309387,
-0.9017093777656555,
-0.1360589563846588,
-0.5480282306671143,
0.016846001148223877,
0.11791310459375381,
0.14676950871944427,
-0.17852140963077545,
0.6229274272918701,
-0.21622058749198914,
-0.30543267726898193,
-0.6344661116600037,
-0.11494970321655273,
0.04382424056529999,
0.5517629981040955,
0.500801682472229,
-0.7326834201812744,
-0.6421680450439453,
0.2234371155500412,
-0.6555274128913879,
-0.06956267356872559,
-0.2985193133354187,
-0.3725956678390503,
0.3464929759502411,
0.513282299041748,
-0.7325180768966675,
0.3698224425315857,
0.5728425979614258,
0.12676019966602325,
0.14209559559822083,
-0.1378624439239502,
0.19864244759082794,
-1.4317482709884644,
-0.04214433580636978,
-0.27680933475494385,
-0.3683898150920868,
-0.7076762914657593,
-0.14876286685466766,
0.034215327352285385,
-0.23185858130455017,
-0.5036833882331848,
0.6934786438941956,
-0.6302782297134399,
0.05765197053551674,
-0.31070590019226074,
0.010622473433613777,
-0.07331004738807678,
0.5739906430244446,
0.09895570576190948,
0.5505208969116211,
0.4505491554737091,
-0.5805240273475647,
0.2888111472129822,
0.34613674879074097,
-0.011450103484094143,
0.6171702146530151,
-0.26526501774787903,
0.38408222794532776,
-0.26646801829338074,
0.1819298416376114,
-0.8853485584259033,
0.09085713326931,
0.29429617524147034,
-0.3594740629196167,
0.6285092234611511,
-0.36401405930519104,
-0.3169633448123932,
-0.1849384605884552,
-0.14736798405647278,
0.18892301619052887,
0.8875989317893982,
-0.3537095785140991,
0.5252607464790344,
0.3476601243019104,
-0.2889570891857147,
-0.4824897348880768,
-0.8335843086242676,
0.4168170988559723,
-0.47774362564086914,
-0.4667566120624542,
0.2369203269481659,
-0.023438410833477974,
-0.07705939561128616,
0.04545268788933754,
-0.28021275997161865,
-0.11254113167524338,
0.1003970056772232,
0.06989991664886475,
0.2605954110622406,
-0.11643895506858826,
0.15669584274291992,
0.20306611061096191,
-0.20492836833000183,
-0.1094074696302414,
-0.44876089692115784,
0.337997704744339,
0.19142113626003265,
-0.3626623749732971,
-0.2805106043815613,
0.42180585861206055,
0.8565925359725952,
-0.0581262931227684,
0.8675829768180847,
0.45328468084335327,
-0.27454352378845215,
-0.2536548376083374,
-0.6175613403320312,
-0.1857438087463379,
-0.4003225862979889,
0.6371022462844849,
-0.2013745754957199,
-0.8848587274551392,
0.41974782943725586,
-0.2273629903793335,
0.32512107491493225,
0.18520425260066986,
0.5136871337890625,
-0.21865716576576233,
0.8651751279830933,
0.840465784072876,
-0.20502939820289612,
0.41429537534713745,
-0.057929009199142456,
0.4918074905872345,
-0.5554216504096985,
-0.12897531688213348,
-0.30727076530456543,
-0.5350519418716431,
-0.6029483079910278,
-0.4340073764324188,
0.5576233863830566,
0.06550618261098862,
0.08792071044445038,
0.4043787121772766,
-0.07130332291126251,
0.28845587372779846,
0.11845165491104126,
0.1586177796125412,
0.4854292571544647,
0.19962789118289948,
0.31742364168167114,
-0.30856603384017944,
-0.752504289150238,
-0.46216481924057007,
1.2760851383209229,
0.3771432936191559,
0.9484798908233643,
0.11417156457901001,
0.7578742504119873,
-0.060251783579587936,
0.4074535071849823,
-0.8816908001899719,
0.6924880743026733,
-0.2533023953437805,
-0.4960762560367584,
-0.3359368145465851,
-0.4647926986217499,
-1.0787389278411865,
0.28909605741500854,
-0.1826222985982895,
-0.48818159103393555,
-0.08180700242519379,
-0.050056010484695435,
0.14874157309532166,
0.4192425012588501,
-0.9462262988090515,
0.5047559142112732,
-0.4304250478744507,
-0.3281782567501068,
-0.2777436375617981,
-0.355407178401947,
0.43828877806663513,
-0.5149801969528198,
0.4814245104789734,
-0.226104736328125,
-0.030604412779211998,
0.8327951431274414,
-0.35305875539779663,
0.9727731943130493,
-0.11955475807189941,
-0.23189501464366913,
0.14975720643997192,
0.2547071874141693,
0.5316875576972961,
0.043006233870983124,
0.05279988422989845,
0.3250771164894104,
-0.023767881095409393,
-0.40137219429016113,
-0.7237464189529419,
0.5730287432670593,
-0.8634586930274963,
-1.0174660682678223,
-0.038027938455343246,
-0.712003767490387,
-0.5592819452285767,
0.0475287139415741,
0.11586493998765945,
-0.02982817031443119,
-0.06241339445114136,
0.3371399939060211,
0.48850905895233154,
-0.10427716374397278,
0.33669841289520264,
0.7499934434890747,
-0.224514901638031,
-0.09130696952342987,
0.7607020139694214,
0.34453195333480835,
0.48949819803237915,
0.4894021153450012,
0.07977349311113358,
-0.3947998583316803,
-0.791107177734375,
-0.3053660988807678,
0.32446807622909546,
-0.703258216381073,
-0.15665476024150848,
-0.5823032855987549,
-0.3131706714630127,
-0.4344526529312134,
0.004819388501346111,
-0.7072628140449524,
-0.44417911767959595,
-0.3999756872653961,
-0.22660213708877563,
0.40676501393318176,
0.45901066064834595,
-0.23427146673202515,
-0.033212676644325256,
-0.8330685496330261,
0.1431128829717636,
0.21788781881332397,
-0.005522679537534714,
-0.04314252734184265,
-0.8071930408477783,
-0.33303430676460266,
0.27319690585136414,
-0.2013193964958191,
-0.771858274936676,
0.5036067366600037,
0.33943748474121094,
0.5798307061195374,
0.028407489880919456,
0.3040662407875061,
0.8217336535453796,
-0.5366666913032532,
0.5608168244361877,
0.13857296109199524,
-0.6702671647071838,
0.44976621866226196,
0.08608540892601013,
0.11147958785295486,
0.52886962890625,
0.685815155506134,
-0.7584670782089233,
-0.49719804525375366,
-0.3858083486557007,
-0.8762465715408325,
0.6798142194747925,
0.20662108063697815,
0.302249938249588,
0.2537863850593567,
0.2024904042482376,
0.3834073543548584,
0.03295077756047249,
-0.7021045684814453,
-0.05767938494682312,
-0.09821394830942154,
-0.12966737151145935,
-0.1604134738445282,
-0.0912526398897171,
-0.004046004265546799,
-0.22997620701789856,
0.6908223628997803,
-0.12532515823841095,
0.08560792356729507,
0.06943900883197784,
-0.3297426998615265,
-0.022029640153050423,
0.5059771537780762,
0.1755349040031433,
0.6102732419967651,
0.18125341832637787,
0.2781245708465576,
0.5002156496047974,
-0.4524015486240387,
0.3392172157764435,
-0.17390596866607666,
-0.037304867058992386,
-0.1778452843427658,
0.4869634807109833,
0.6520022749900818,
0.32952946424484253,
-0.3638905882835388,
0.3036282956600189,
0.003012110246345401,
-0.19923290610313416,
-0.09349803626537323,
0.05104053393006325,
0.3568284511566162,
0.21410784125328064,
0.33434605598449707,
-0.10083582997322083,
-0.316141277551651,
-0.6364383697509766,
-0.06606069207191467,
0.23836272954940796,
-0.19206301867961884,
-0.5951482057571411,
0.5713363289833069,
0.33707481622695923,
-0.11561954021453857,
0.474141389131546,
-0.10288668423891068,
-0.32791760563850403,
0.21470297873020172,
0.6428809762001038,
0.744922399520874,
-0.3219201862812042,
0.22424283623695374,
0.28098931908607483,
0.49752500653266907,
-0.3023720681667328,
0.1688530594110489,
0.08789241313934326,
-0.8281146883964539,
-0.6167584657669067,
-0.36527007818222046,
-0.4142666459083557,
0.2227676957845688,
-0.5168575644493103,
0.36479857563972473,
-0.34141919016838074,
0.023487376049160957,
-0.25514593720436096,
-0.22310316562652588,
-0.7023168206214905,
-0.26014232635498047,
0.16223110258579254,
0.708748459815979,
-1.002608299255371,
0.8935895562171936,
0.640987753868103,
-0.1916302591562271,
-0.700043797492981,
-0.12472066283226013,
-0.2559022903442383,
-1.0141998529434204,
0.5301638245582581,
-0.25904980301856995,
0.13429103791713715,
-0.0005663978517986834,
-0.6858878135681152,
-0.924674391746521,
1.057420253753662,
0.6869935989379883,
-0.7828058004379272,
-0.116950124502182,
0.48256856203079224,
0.5800644755363464,
-0.13442659378051758,
0.04122992604970932,
0.5204778909683228,
0.42575645446777344,
0.3567257523536682,
-1.4722942113876343,
-0.06071778014302254,
0.029883811250329018,
0.04924779385328293,
0.15348733961582184,
-0.7069076299667358,
0.5667505264282227,
-0.13515658676624298,
-0.4777373969554901,
-0.22084949910640717,
0.4912232458591461,
-0.10760064423084259,
0.06919842958450317,
0.2672189474105835,
0.3689410090446472,
0.7245835065841675,
-0.06563073396682739,
0.6608541011810303,
-0.1976645439863205,
0.17619651556015015,
0.8446130752563477,
-0.6390752792358398,
0.8154033422470093,
0.6938430070877075,
-0.29611313343048096,
0.26033687591552734,
0.3994702994823456,
0.4530607759952545,
0.5620242953300476,
-0.15597335994243622,
-0.0697888731956482,
-0.34323427081108093,
0.06237664073705673,
-0.3320797383785248,
0.694756805896759,
0.45684513449668884,
0.013893543742597103,
-0.4550987780094147,
0.23617331683635712,
0.2911824584007263,
-0.016758855432271957,
-0.24021390080451965,
1.038397192955017,
0.27020689845085144,
-0.5049254298210144,
0.7652272582054138,
0.021564096212387085,
0.6590413451194763,
-0.6342674493789673,
0.11433175206184387,
-0.4598599374294281,
0.13945361971855164,
-0.2334250956773758,
-0.66405189037323,
0.5121445059776306,
-0.008961633779108524,
-0.04877439886331558,
-0.47700682282447815,
0.7555916905403137,
-0.7856929898262024,
-0.5574302673339844,
0.2342059165239334,
0.977021336555481,
0.37166786193847656,
0.17448076605796814,
-0.5844279527664185,
-0.06884665787220001,
0.11290620267391205,
-0.10155311971902847,
0.577928364276886,
0.6421447396278381,
-0.3451024293899536,
0.7285799980163574,
0.7376427054405212,
0.2428906112909317,
-0.12656648457050323,
-0.2903597950935364,
0.7775286436080933,
-0.5582598447799683,
-0.5035906434059143,
-0.8062257766723633,
0.30865100026130676,
0.19807250797748566,
0.05901401489973068,
0.7347666025161743,
0.43777427077293396,
0.8201289176940918,
0.014581291005015373,
0.968371570110321,
0.14260004460811615,
0.4004754424095154,
-0.6991420984268188,
0.8198556900024414,
-0.4046144187450409,
0.32461172342300415,
0.028346020728349686,
-0.9202746748924255,
-0.023523565381765366,
0.25981563329696655,
-0.47957172989845276,
-0.11722814291715622,
0.8398483395576477,
0.6409332156181335,
-0.051895711570978165,
-0.04809698089957237,
0.5793513059616089,
0.25982022285461426,
0.5860168933868408,
1.0808578729629517,
0.881168782711029,
-0.4136585295200348,
0.9326145648956299,
-0.12198816239833832,
-0.14577892422676086,
-0.03745051845908165,
-0.8423992395401001,
-1.015707015991211,
-0.5527558326721191,
-0.527995765209198,
-0.29845571517944336,
-0.05684800446033478,
0.8002963662147522,
0.8254063129425049,
-0.7569326758384705,
-0.28322654962539673,
0.20701301097869873,
0.1780344396829605,
-0.027293238788843155,
-0.16080772876739502,
0.19233612716197968,
-0.24465496838092804,
-0.8220517039299011,
0.6554132699966431,
0.331150084733963,
0.2894718647003174,
-0.3962293565273285,
-0.07158411294221878,
0.0682067796587944,
-0.18626248836517334,
0.6687995195388794,
0.4175747036933899,
-0.4586476683616638,
-0.4166840612888336,
-0.053221698850393295,
0.03562455251812935,
0.09384670108556747,
0.5847516655921936,
-0.679169774055481,
0.18389473855495453,
0.30139461159706116,
0.8576933741569519,
0.7201566100120544,
-0.42593851685523987,
0.7076175808906555,
-0.7868438363075256,
0.39425840973854065,
0.2424589842557907,
0.3006410598754883,
0.506420910358429,
-0.3726819157600403,
0.5011793971061707,
0.2530279755592346,
-0.3096088767051697,
-0.8299477696418762,
0.17699478566646576,
-0.7860572934150696,
-0.1814146488904953,
1.3874502182006836,
-0.04485274478793144,
-0.3236366808414459,
-0.3667917847633362,
-0.21480035781860352,
0.19817326962947845,
-0.21298210322856903,
0.703198254108429,
0.784049391746521,
-0.1300971359014511,
-0.3400646150112152,
-0.4693223237991333,
0.45313358306884766,
0.2975512146949768,
-0.8936097025871277,
0.24294887483119965,
0.1122581735253334,
0.5027685761451721,
-0.01033758744597435,
0.7057953476905823,
-0.3620406687259674,
0.02034386806190014,
-0.34891700744628906,
0.015534507110714912,
-0.034939900040626526,
-0.1926484853029251,
-0.20766586065292358,
-0.00516202487051487,
0.16759586334228516,
-0.22845032811164856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13911v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13911v1
|
TOPA: Extend Large Language Models for Video Understanding via Text-Only Pre-Alignment
| 2024-05-22T18:35:10 | 2024-05-22T18:35:10 |
Wei Li, Hehe Fan, Yongkang Wong, Mohan Kankanhalli, Yi Yang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in image understanding have benefited from the extensive
use of web image-text pairs. However, video understanding remains a challenge
despite the availability of substantial web video-text data. This difficulty
primarily arises from the inherent complexity of videos and the inefficient
language supervision in recent web-collected video-text datasets. In this
paper, we introduce Text-Only Pre-Alignment (TOPA), a novel approach to extend
large language models (LLMs) for video understanding, without the need for
pre-training on real video data. Specifically, we first employ an advanced LLM
to automatically generate Textual Videos comprising continuous textual frames,
along with corresponding annotations to simulate real video-text data. Then,
these annotated textual videos are used to pre-align a language-only LLM with
the video modality. To bridge the gap between textual and real videos, we
employ the CLIP model as the feature extractor to align image and text
modalities. During text-only pre-alignment, the continuous textual frames,
encoded as a sequence of CLIP text features, are analogous to continuous CLIP
image features, thus aligning the LLM with real video representation. Extensive
experiments, including zero-shot evaluation and finetuning on various video
understanding tasks, demonstrate that TOPA is an effective and efficient
framework for aligning video content with LLMs. In particular, without training
on any video data, the TOPA-Llama2-13B model achieves a Top-1 accuracy of 51.0%
on the challenging long-form video understanding benchmark, Egoschema. This
performance surpasses previous video-text pre-training approaches and proves
competitive with recent GPT-3.5-based video agents.
|
[
-0.38330820202827454,
-0.7730264067649841,
0.6250313520431519,
0.05582123622298241,
-0.6402191519737244,
-0.08857601135969162,
-0.5043888688087463,
-0.1980411857366562,
0.3169879615306854,
0.657371997833252,
-0.7741948366165161,
-0.5833325386047363,
-0.9717124104499817,
-0.12630455195903778,
-0.5164791941642761,
0.9643265604972839,
-0.17072419822216034,
-0.0948902815580368,
-0.1438325196504593,
-0.07769230008125305,
-0.40077099204063416,
-0.24813774228096008,
-0.13689319789409637,
-0.062320105731487274,
0.25348737835884094,
0.28761738538742065,
0.9083268046379089,
0.8999708294868469,
0.6631971597671509,
0.37076064944267273,
0.09817008674144745,
0.2466316968202591,
-0.601759135723114,
-0.19964107871055603,
-0.1965370625257492,
-0.2603541910648346,
-0.6058403253555298,
-0.1682509034872055,
0.5856479406356812,
0.2450871765613556,
0.034523021429777145,
0.2685895562171936,
-0.22440314292907715,
0.40215593576431274,
-0.7127118110656738,
-0.22952865064144135,
-0.7327784299850464,
0.029835540801286697,
-0.1315157562494278,
-0.33518216013908386,
-0.20711107552051544,
-0.09408140182495117,
0.3164978325366974,
-1.074369192123413,
0.01977536268532276,
-0.3279297947883606,
1.3509149551391602,
0.7295200228691101,
-0.2783224582672119,
0.00001626699486223515,
-0.6137805581092834,
0.7721584439277649,
-0.3861760199069977,
0.6302706599235535,
0.5759026408195496,
0.4168969690799713,
0.22945040464401245,
-0.40682464838027954,
-0.8631815910339355,
0.1730407327413559,
0.12708021700382233,
0.13046026229858398,
-0.22203581035137177,
0.0839971974492073,
0.06395960599184036,
0.3617740273475647,
-0.8251095414161682,
0.40151268243789673,
0.019895102828741074,
-0.033663030713796616,
0.2704884111881256,
-0.17749518156051636,
0.587118923664093,
-0.05625063180923462,
-0.5895746946334839,
-0.20539496839046478,
-0.6588618159294128,
-0.23804433643817902,
-0.023456532508134842,
-0.06939581036567688,
-0.3105998635292053,
0.6232962012290955,
0.2537151575088501,
0.5444433689117432,
0.11449047178030014,
-0.34639424085617065,
0.11990310996770859,
-0.3949061334133148,
-0.8286548256874084,
-0.07252804934978485,
0.8009143471717834,
0.441615492105484,
0.6383461356163025,
-0.10746517777442932,
0.15035246312618256,
0.1983998864889145,
0.22173930704593658,
-0.8968892097473145,
0.0016747392946854234,
-0.000739404815249145,
-0.3714040517807007,
-0.19030533730983734,
-0.003642816562205553,
-0.5708639621734619,
-0.1911604404449463,
-0.41079410910606384,
0.8488034009933472,
-0.18172885477542877,
-0.2847861647605896,
0.051927972584962845,
0.3126204311847687,
0.6149235367774963,
0.38136303424835205,
-0.894246518611908,
0.2774181067943573,
0.4757881462574005,
0.8117008805274963,
-0.06233413144946098,
-0.5847585797309875,
-0.656120240688324,
0.48561379313468933,
-0.5056405067443848,
0.7637929916381836,
-0.36402300000190735,
0.2925267815589905,
0.13592348992824554,
0.13688750565052032,
0.2628294825553894,
-0.34166067838668823,
0.21234185993671417,
-0.5266069769859314,
0.3170528709888458,
0.08740810304880142,
-0.4170858561992645,
-0.2118242383003235,
0.3618661165237427,
-0.5970091223716736,
0.8133798241615295,
-0.27493003010749817,
-0.48094281554222107,
0.3879140615463257,
-0.33501532673835754,
-0.15051445364952087,
-0.3365718424320221,
-0.29118046164512634,
-0.4009574353694916,
-0.11704877763986588,
0.7210082411766052,
0.23562796413898468,
-0.25951871275901794,
0.6366005539894104,
-0.15993942320346832,
-0.18045559525489807,
0.16440244019031525,
-0.5322877764701843,
0.1458277702331543,
-0.07768305391073227,
-0.1822693943977356,
0.28219491243362427,
-0.5383642911911011,
-0.2347647249698639,
-0.01780996471643448,
0.4247760772705078,
-0.14444687962532043,
-0.08441781252622604,
0.027412181720137596,
0.36935311555862427,
0.3792473375797272,
-0.41325661540031433,
0.21759262681007385,
-0.1611754298210144,
0.020229291170835495,
0.9017700552940369,
-0.33184072375297546,
0.5965585708618164,
-0.04005850479006767,
0.6417730450630188,
-0.17528897523880005,
0.13765519857406616,
-0.5225588083267212,
-0.046252500265836716,
-0.5382528305053711,
-0.5107977986335754,
0.07303987443447113,
0.7338182926177979,
-0.6217713952064514,
0.4144169092178345,
-0.5664654970169067,
-0.2917874753475189,
-0.4427967071533203,
0.5845237374305725,
0.6283488273620605,
0.4040699899196625,
0.5166276097297668,
-0.40708431601524353,
-0.7621113657951355,
-0.7506637573242188,
0.05842699855566025,
-0.08728764951229095,
-0.18033108115196228,
0.07644305378198624,
0.1755986511707306,
-0.13728442788124084,
0.8391656875610352,
-0.6612290143966675,
-0.7140462398529053,
-0.25124847888946533,
-0.022376693785190582,
0.1295621693134308,
0.2988027036190033,
0.5229803323745728,
-0.7593141794204712,
-0.30826807022094727,
0.12169810384511948,
-0.9846808314323425,
-0.1695111095905304,
-0.16596893966197968,
-0.40828993916511536,
-0.2287549376487732,
0.43253618478775024,
-0.7303504347801208,
0.38442733883857727,
0.7011168599128723,
-0.24014687538146973,
0.16993007063865662,
-0.18565672636032104,
0.22356216609477997,
-1.1152294874191284,
-0.12405998259782791,
0.16891802847385406,
-0.44122347235679626,
-0.6897484064102173,
-0.107352115213871,
-0.1585565060377121,
-0.15792663395404816,
-0.5027353167533875,
0.5072289109230042,
-0.32946959137916565,
-0.38176313042640686,
-0.39883556962013245,
0.4352325201034546,
0.015877757221460342,
0.5073283314704895,
0.603271484375,
0.8031351566314697,
0.6887864470481873,
-0.48936226963996887,
0.01470479927957058,
0.681437075138092,
-0.42088764905929565,
0.3884561061859131,
-0.3800797164440155,
-0.001258612028323114,
-0.2526172399520874,
0.19785192608833313,
-0.8231819868087769,
-0.39015302062034607,
-0.10820082575082779,
-0.5156863331794739,
0.283168226480484,
-0.2310151904821396,
-0.10626798123121262,
0.1419530212879181,
-0.27992862462997437,
0.5993402600288391,
0.40697064995765686,
-0.5878363251686096,
0.6513295769691467,
0.48886603116989136,
-0.31569403409957886,
-1.0052224397659302,
-0.677421510219574,
0.1934448629617691,
-0.21046645939350128,
-0.7431796193122864,
0.6040454506874084,
0.053362805396318436,
0.053369928151369095,
-0.129033163189888,
-0.22000889480113983,
-0.5934997797012329,
-0.16272518038749695,
-0.01272721029818058,
0.3798731565475464,
-0.37843582034111023,
0.03529483824968338,
-0.008806781843304634,
0.017162488773465157,
-0.4018421173095703,
-0.25948482751846313,
0.36487454175949097,
0.252543568611145,
-0.0061124032363295555,
-0.8319322466850281,
0.3602457344532013,
0.5497763156890869,
-0.3278979957103729,
0.4829716086387634,
0.5553730726242065,
-0.5968217253684998,
0.22951512038707733,
-0.6149565577507019,
0.024999501183629036,
-0.43407106399536133,
0.580431342124939,
-0.26957622170448303,
-0.7703651189804077,
0.34189528226852417,
0.1860535740852356,
-0.03621155023574829,
0.06763193011283875,
0.5126305222511292,
-0.3091197609901428,
0.7308329939842224,
1.0493261814117432,
0.05788696929812431,
0.9314727783203125,
-0.17704257369041443,
0.10892550647258759,
-0.3711263835430145,
-0.08982402831315994,
-0.13116386532783508,
-0.04435281455516815,
-0.2740320563316345,
-0.5122855305671692,
0.14278429746627808,
0.27022022008895874,
-0.3421168625354767,
0.4908914268016815,
-0.05742315202951431,
0.905245840549469,
-0.1331169307231903,
0.2013416737318039,
0.25139448046684265,
0.17545022070407867,
0.4402559697628021,
-0.2334691882133484,
-0.3180745840072632,
-0.5763065814971924,
0.8898323774337769,
0.4975247383117676,
0.864829421043396,
0.3528406620025635,
0.4705463945865631,
0.186018705368042,
0.2027474194765091,
-0.8123612999916077,
0.5139017105102539,
-0.518319308757782,
-0.19832146167755127,
-0.32206791639328003,
-0.10762854665517807,
-0.7247368097305298,
0.22271941602230072,
-0.3317943811416626,
-0.7157526016235352,
-0.24674655497074127,
0.35529473423957825,
-0.2571639120578766,
0.32769104838371277,
-0.4882679283618927,
1.0719753503799438,
-0.46348899602890015,
-0.49485063552856445,
0.007256340701133013,
-0.5308364629745483,
0.4221492111682892,
-0.12295027077198029,
0.49383115768432617,
0.12037282437086105,
-0.21378804743289948,
0.613361120223999,
-0.5988083481788635,
0.6231206655502319,
-0.10570309311151505,
-0.35704073309898376,
0.2906712591648102,
0.031763963401317596,
0.3525007665157318,
-0.29336485266685486,
0.5505371689796448,
-0.0722881555557251,
-0.16132870316505432,
-0.3218824565410614,
-0.823883056640625,
0.3208092749118805,
-0.8393334150314331,
-0.5519722700119019,
-0.1096392497420311,
-0.3051983714103699,
-0.10248668491840363,
0.22303704917430878,
0.12493900209665298,
0.342923104763031,
-0.2074427306652069,
0.03961869329214096,
0.7933342456817627,
-0.246160626411438,
0.39930301904678345,
0.3277539908885956,
-0.5009949207305908,
-0.7667315006256104,
0.9621081948280334,
-0.13142922520637512,
0.29550665616989136,
0.7562471628189087,
-0.00439645629376173,
-0.47141262888908386,
-0.5927035808563232,
-0.7280740737915039,
0.21009214222431183,
-0.6087372303009033,
-0.28047075867652893,
-0.5041825175285339,
0.045347243547439575,
-0.45189422369003296,
-0.24611766636371613,
-0.47271257638931274,
-0.24226947128772736,
-0.2978104054927826,
-0.5577386617660522,
0.23852483928203583,
0.5239199995994568,
-0.0081112589687109,
0.7981089949607849,
-0.9709230661392212,
0.7006621956825256,
0.4216514825820923,
0.2962251901626587,
-0.18028515577316284,
-0.7637775540351868,
-0.2278391420841217,
-0.4039668142795563,
-0.40024128556251526,
-0.972355306148529,
0.4671819508075714,
0.45922964811325073,
0.1940031796693802,
0.7003646492958069,
-0.6144852042198181,
1.1811816692352295,
-0.570072591304779,
0.8412760496139526,
0.4019489586353302,
-1.1993591785430908,
0.5054358839988708,
-0.43842965364456177,
0.17860817909240723,
0.5134208798408508,
0.521416962146759,
-0.2898181080818176,
-0.011717479676008224,
-0.11794793605804443,
-0.6059595346450806,
0.5372189283370972,
0.43398287892341614,
0.1228780522942543,
0.12346935272216797,
0.18826620280742645,
0.19711410999298096,
-0.0996321514248848,
-0.9812113046646118,
0.1325143426656723,
-0.49480652809143066,
-0.566517174243927,
-0.1430864930152893,
0.009839356876909733,
0.040570467710494995,
-0.028663625940680504,
0.5834870934486389,
-0.2903903126716614,
0.10539834201335907,
0.27450239658355713,
-0.8527677655220032,
-0.13234582543373108,
0.20639252662658691,
0.6063678860664368,
0.7818382978439331,
-0.13794530928134918,
-0.006006256211549044,
0.12049882113933563,
-0.6009671092033386,
0.459296852350235,
-0.07180846482515335,
-0.04395622760057449,
-0.23446956276893616,
0.5737724900245667,
0.8472252488136292,
0.39045748114585876,
-0.7955804467201233,
0.8420941233634949,
0.10777189582586288,
-0.13107264041900635,
-0.3111151158809662,
-0.39567115902900696,
-0.35765907168388367,
0.1080145612359047,
0.4515068233013153,
-0.4413430094718933,
-0.25976336002349854,
-0.5238662958145142,
0.5174327492713928,
0.47657498717308044,
-0.33941349387168884,
-0.42041194438934326,
0.41502392292022705,
0.07456260174512863,
-0.19084617495536804,
0.1951911449432373,
0.07478050142526627,
-0.5600847005844116,
0.6336566209793091,
0.5962966680526733,
0.7836164236068726,
-0.1366230696439743,
0.3858237564563751,
0.25023895502090454,
0.2979613244533539,
-0.13729725778102875,
0.3177429437637329,
-0.13503816723823547,
-0.8053869009017944,
-1.1258437633514404,
-0.5567306280136108,
-0.42801108956336975,
0.3156043589115143,
-0.5777269005775452,
0.4115092158317566,
-0.3245190978050232,
-0.02221720479428768,
-0.12019436061382294,
-0.32335400581359863,
-0.6160995960235596,
0.4722804129123688,
0.4214501976966858,
0.7585073709487915,
-0.9698922038078308,
0.9299823641777039,
0.4860392212867737,
-0.38030514121055603,
-0.6209897994995117,
-0.061138611286878586,
-0.10056231170892715,
-0.6712503433227539,
0.4396902918815613,
0.379995197057724,
-0.22577770054340363,
-0.11690381169319153,
-0.628515899181366,
-0.9607070088386536,
1.0540319681167603,
0.5325997471809387,
-0.49528563022613525,
-0.3498953878879547,
0.09230221807956696,
0.4678914546966553,
-0.4768487513065338,
0.5628196001052856,
0.3509182631969452,
0.25442618131637573,
0.15272481739521027,
-1.024869680404663,
-0.14176888763904572,
-0.1048213541507721,
-0.29970917105674744,
0.34353330731391907,
-0.5143896341323853,
0.4856471121311188,
-0.09376568347215652,
-0.24915090203285217,
0.20314405858516693,
0.9926735162734985,
-0.051776666194200516,
0.2597658932209015,
0.5115236043930054,
0.8094953894615173,
0.5374953150749207,
0.21890269219875336,
0.6858187913894653,
0.08695273846387863,
0.2383856624364853,
1.3637396097183228,
-0.10712898522615433,
0.8049702048301697,
0.4912528097629547,
-0.10693886131048203,
0.6403955221176147,
0.5793207883834839,
0.16703200340270996,
0.5546692609786987,
-0.1313905119895935,
0.02089865691959858,
-0.6948859691619873,
-0.147452250123024,
-0.12134028226137161,
0.9058333039283752,
0.14969342947006226,
-0.34800922870635986,
-0.235193133354187,
0.10609724372625351,
-0.09399542957544327,
0.3569537103176117,
-0.6528616547584534,
1.0519740581512451,
-0.11273264139890671,
-0.6746470928192139,
0.5206982493400574,
-0.3430611491203308,
0.7566695809364319,
-0.8009039759635925,
0.03592713177204132,
-0.04873078316450119,
-0.03164852038025856,
-0.2688694894313812,
-0.7558777332305908,
0.26709243655204773,
0.7190729379653931,
-0.22881217300891876,
-0.0871330201625824,
0.4913088083267212,
-0.6558434367179871,
-0.2537020146846771,
0.3282700479030609,
0.4168429374694824,
0.26544189453125,
0.012949654832482338,
-0.2805774509906769,
0.13354700803756714,
-0.1085868775844574,
-0.022633228451013565,
0.47845062613487244,
0.28674936294555664,
-0.22411812841892242,
0.40625837445259094,
0.5326615571975708,
-0.1269073486328125,
0.04338999465107918,
0.11352626979351044,
0.6880998611450195,
-0.8264461159706116,
-0.3494354784488678,
-0.9819127917289734,
0.31415632367134094,
0.09640705585479736,
-0.20194126665592194,
0.08644357323646545,
0.3656257092952728,
0.9258877635002136,
-0.003328916849568486,
0.5448642373085022,
0.23191212117671967,
-0.09138096868991852,
-0.9771696329116821,
0.45481157302856445,
-0.5075954794883728,
-0.19507412612438202,
-0.5541120171546936,
-1.0540035963058472,
-0.364982932806015,
0.5413539409637451,
-0.21775810420513153,
-0.37720465660095215,
0.6163949370384216,
0.6933133006095886,
-0.29301178455352783,
-0.15292519330978394,
0.40256500244140625,
0.31353649497032166,
0.3312644064426422,
0.6934365034103394,
0.6303774118423462,
-0.5039765238761902,
0.9689276814460754,
-0.09433892369270325,
-0.41840553283691406,
0.34264078736305237,
-1.1729729175567627,
-0.9533965587615967,
-0.2759262025356293,
-0.11530135571956635,
0.040457699447870255,
-0.05691800266504288,
1.0428801774978638,
0.8113057017326355,
-0.5132153034210205,
-0.1598801165819168,
0.03079492226243019,
0.005074044689536095,
-0.0330415703356266,
-0.14983157813549042,
0.49923574924468994,
0.026107674464583397,
-0.7470375299453735,
0.5753194689750671,
0.2755601704120636,
0.23027487099170685,
-0.16334134340286255,
-0.13799023628234863,
-0.31128543615341187,
0.2477874904870987,
0.619616687297821,
0.4145110547542572,
-0.7530479431152344,
-0.4074268639087677,
0.1065606027841568,
0.13307024538516998,
0.4257316589355469,
0.8267975449562073,
-0.7087408900260925,
0.3107038736343384,
0.4170544445514679,
1.0114468336105347,
0.8172768354415894,
0.2896646559238434,
0.625934362411499,
-0.6181172132492065,
0.2548654079437256,
-0.20859462022781372,
0.3043992817401886,
0.4828561544418335,
-0.30204474925994873,
0.2584824562072754,
-0.08270180225372314,
-0.3312019407749176,
-0.7475496530532837,
0.45116645097732544,
-1.218885898590088,
-0.06767787039279938,
0.7887185215950012,
-0.36114221811294556,
-0.20599673688411713,
0.36885976791381836,
-0.198903426527977,
0.5721063613891602,
-0.12675635516643524,
0.5435289740562439,
0.7020943760871887,
0.12547852098941803,
-0.5845215320587158,
-0.3220946490764618,
0.3486991226673126,
0.6819241046905518,
-0.9739216566085815,
0.07005340605974197,
0.4107293486595154,
0.16573087871074677,
-0.0805889368057251,
0.5538985133171082,
-0.006621236447244883,
0.45727020502090454,
-0.5264061689376831,
-0.05239664763212204,
-0.1164800226688385,
-0.6857026815414429,
-0.37728413939476013,
0.05594911798834801,
-0.2688162922859192,
-0.34300512075424194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13907v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13907v2
|
Just rephrase it! Uncertainty estimation in closed-source language models via multiple rephrased queries
| 2024-05-22T18:28:26 | 2024-06-16T13:49:53 |
Adam Yang, Chen Chen, Konstantinos Pitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
State-of-the-art large language models are sometimes distributed as
open-source software but are also increasingly provided as a closed-source
service. These closed-source large-language models typically see the widest
usage by the public, however, they often do not provide an estimate of their
uncertainty when responding to queries. As even the best models are prone to
``hallucinating" false information with high confidence, a lack of a reliable
estimate of uncertainty limits the applicability of these models in critical
settings. We explore estimating the uncertainty of closed-source LLMs via
multiple rephrasings of an original base query. Specifically, we ask the model,
multiple rephrased questions, and use the similarity of the answers as an
estimate of uncertainty. We diverge from previous work in i) providing rules
for rephrasing that are simple to memorize and use in practice ii) proposing a
theoretical framework for why multiple rephrased queries obtain calibrated
uncertainty estimates. Our method demonstrates significant improvements in the
calibration of uncertainty estimates compared to the baseline and provides
intuition as to how query strategies should be designed for optimal test
calibration.
|
[
-0.16164053976535797,
-0.8108800053596497,
0.9226093888282776,
-0.04924651235342026,
-0.2277957648038864,
-0.07875819504261017,
-0.4707794189453125,
-0.3830799162387848,
0.04912000149488449,
0.7636417150497437,
-0.6455017328262329,
-0.5567947626113892,
-0.47772619128227234,
-0.010770872235298157,
-0.13723145425319672,
0.34130236506462097,
-0.07841642200946808,
0.23003056645393372,
-0.13414420187473297,
-0.2598961293697357,
-0.1030387133359909,
-0.6676068902015686,
-0.18105541169643402,
-0.12956759333610535,
0.7049987316131592,
0.3431660234928131,
0.8336086869239807,
0.3606625497341156,
0.5200619101524353,
0.15181824564933777,
-0.11855040490627289,
0.06207159161567688,
-0.46410316228866577,
0.49073511362075806,
-0.07971416413784027,
-0.6909177899360657,
0.09922603517770767,
-0.022432034835219383,
0.858360767364502,
1.1123325824737549,
-0.37946417927742004,
0.21882875263690948,
-0.19231249392032623,
0.7178731560707092,
-1.1562614440917969,
-0.10630254447460175,
-0.8066373467445374,
-0.004458981100469828,
-0.06648442894220352,
0.053953804075717926,
-0.5775725841522217,
-0.6524778604507446,
0.10468373447656631,
-0.5884903073310852,
-0.07430227100849152,
0.07082122564315796,
0.6023536324501038,
0.3415736258029938,
-0.04715387523174286,
-0.16428297758102417,
-0.8127855658531189,
1.0201318264007568,
-0.8157444000244141,
0.5657799243927002,
0.4126881957054138,
0.47745704650878906,
-0.179125115275383,
-0.767650842666626,
-0.3991360068321228,
-0.5028935074806213,
0.15601687133312225,
-0.05373938009142876,
-0.07737163454294205,
-0.08734162896871567,
0.29269173741340637,
0.3786505162715912,
-0.27283671498298645,
-0.07031620293855667,
-0.38811859488487244,
-0.3442683815956116,
0.5461889505386353,
-0.11534620821475983,
-0.11228454113006592,
0.14480625092983246,
-0.33302462100982666,
0.07655873149633408,
-0.8916894793510437,
-0.23867610096931458,
0.3354596495628357,
0.30315300822257996,
0.3987136781215668,
0.7030956745147705,
-0.24703210592269897,
0.7760211229324341,
-0.07780065387487411,
-0.07780955731868744,
0.25873520970344543,
-0.38745740056037903,
-0.35241469740867615,
-0.35271725058555603,
0.7443093061447144,
0.3356107771396637,
0.16947811841964722,
-0.1597593128681183,
-0.22922682762145996,
-0.4236989915370941,
0.3078957498073578,
-0.4313639998435974,
-0.060702741146087646,
0.1766698956489563,
0.06358414143323898,
-0.16394484043121338,
-0.012032177299261093,
-0.7173534035682678,
-0.4395096004009247,
-0.17514659464359283,
0.36445122957229614,
-0.14535969495773315,
-0.2914147973060608,
0.05066319927573204,
-0.09437166899442673,
0.0037308484315872192,
0.3955584764480591,
-0.2757033705711365,
0.15665870904922485,
0.5761042833328247,
0.5884816646575928,
0.0886610746383667,
-0.3371362090110779,
-0.3450400233268738,
0.03905213251709938,
-0.5538888573646545,
0.6257739067077637,
-0.5587295293807983,
-0.4292390048503876,
-0.020102957263588905,
-0.07157765328884125,
0.07108429074287415,
-0.4482264220714569,
0.5401529669761658,
-0.7010596394538879,
0.3240671753883362,
-0.38809528946876526,
-0.54183030128479,
-0.03177672252058983,
0.2375800758600235,
-0.7838529944419861,
1.0325239896774292,
0.1388978660106659,
-0.8798827528953552,
0.11332208663225174,
0.10301630198955536,
-0.031288422644138336,
-0.26927563548088074,
-0.14240090548992157,
-0.3326929211616516,
0.3261672556400299,
0.10954514145851135,
-0.0446368046104908,
-0.4330919086933136,
0.13467618823051453,
-0.5546929836273193,
-0.30315613746643066,
0.4632754623889923,
-0.6729773283004761,
0.6088932156562805,
0.3407781422138214,
0.11814761906862259,
0.03482016548514366,
-0.43460315465927124,
0.43807706236839294,
-0.197932630777359,
-0.3209732472896576,
-0.254699170589447,
-0.18483392894268036,
-0.2633484899997711,
-0.22792671620845795,
0.41430091857910156,
-0.4633968770503998,
0.011682904325425625,
-0.5318288207054138,
0.21695320308208466,
0.6600897312164307,
0.16518747806549072,
0.48737454414367676,
-0.44422227144241333,
0.5917632579803467,
-0.30846452713012695,
0.24042899906635284,
0.042370300740003586,
-0.4651245176792145,
-0.2539712190628052,
-0.19590704143047333,
0.41882988810539246,
0.4646138548851013,
-0.38543179631233215,
0.09163684397935867,
-0.2107437402009964,
-0.7162991762161255,
-0.69704669713974,
0.04863804206252098,
0.3871789872646332,
0.5368126630783081,
0.3417917788028717,
-0.006001145113259554,
-0.5830788016319275,
-0.9041367769241333,
-0.611525297164917,
-0.2107318490743637,
-0.010253735817968845,
0.26069375872612,
0.3530246913433075,
0.014715027064085007,
0.63198322057724,
-0.645971417427063,
0.3132474422454834,
0.0483868271112442,
0.21853964030742645,
0.10121746361255646,
0.3366253077983856,
0.2927077114582062,
-0.785691499710083,
-0.3756932318210602,
-0.1864607334136963,
-0.4342716932296753,
-0.11427934467792511,
0.23297053575515747,
-0.2037670910358429,
0.29113316535949707,
0.5233252048492432,
-0.574459433555603,
0.34411749243736267,
0.5629570484161377,
0.38938719034194946,
0.9134353995323181,
-0.2269447296857834,
0.19763590395450592,
-1.1227161884307861,
0.09256041049957275,
-0.24605031311511993,
-0.19829943776130676,
-0.48128947615623474,
0.6736589670181274,
0.09699073433876038,
0.12822382152080536,
-0.3752267360687256,
0.4636389911174774,
-0.5906785130500793,
-0.12790104746818542,
-0.34977275133132935,
0.4406571686267853,
0.1354161947965622,
0.0906413123011589,
-0.0945764034986496,
0.8308841586112976,
0.6818064451217651,
-0.3821834325790405,
0.46520644426345825,
-0.2938482165336609,
-0.46697404980659485,
0.4295538365840912,
-0.5031083226203918,
0.0975819081068039,
-0.039192572236061096,
0.20109573006629944,
-1.0380244255065918,
-0.2521858513355255,
0.39602991938591003,
-0.554222047328949,
0.15627102553844452,
-0.26117122173309326,
-0.3133322596549988,
-0.2867446839809418,
-0.31528735160827637,
0.41016885638237,
0.38983646035194397,
-0.30658087134361267,
0.4985882341861725,
0.3556436002254486,
-0.07517112046480179,
-1.0449930429458618,
-0.9417297840118408,
0.07534973323345184,
-0.05430013686418533,
-0.5592809319496155,
0.15157900750637054,
-0.26302680373191833,
-0.4449929893016815,
0.04418230429291725,
-0.6029251217842102,
-0.562890887260437,
0.19445167481899261,
0.2691718637943268,
0.04356883466243744,
-0.42264524102211,
0.40343034267425537,
-0.1401069462299347,
0.16739176213741302,
0.05529171973466873,
-0.1947750449180603,
0.45989635586738586,
-0.12475807964801788,
-0.8985567092895508,
-0.354791522026062,
0.47712159156799316,
0.6207846403121948,
-0.19310753047466278,
0.7228748202323914,
0.1570395529270172,
-0.5863929986953735,
0.012724397704005241,
-0.8482984304428101,
-0.061729174107313156,
-0.4005230665206909,
0.06277282536029816,
-0.5885683298110962,
-0.8114904165267944,
0.6777207851409912,
0.03045745939016342,
0.03887968510389328,
0.37046879529953003,
0.5308777689933777,
-0.19188553094863892,
0.5823917388916016,
0.5009586811065674,
0.1305583268404007,
0.31973132491111755,
0.27157819271087646,
0.14530286192893982,
-0.6127371191978455,
-0.05138356611132622,
-0.7851196527481079,
0.07383470982313156,
-0.5761391520500183,
-0.6149123907089233,
0.11403784155845642,
0.12961745262145996,
-0.2201976776123047,
0.08839749544858932,
-0.18666748702526093,
0.47007185220718384,
0.6600471138954163,
0.2508254647254944,
0.4782344102859497,
0.12825515866279602,
-0.11628730595111847,
-0.028546256944537163,
-0.36186927556991577,
-0.47974348068237305,
1.122697353363037,
0.1609218418598175,
1.0021071434020996,
0.25805366039276123,
0.7913627624511719,
-0.05527287721633911,
0.5343221426010132,
-0.8002699613571167,
0.1602296531200409,
0.3173554837703705,
-0.7738473415374756,
-0.3887949287891388,
-0.7671589851379395,
-0.7041112184524536,
0.36811283230781555,
0.049886416643857956,
-0.7023634314537048,
0.10318585485219955,
0.0525328665971756,
-0.45543619990348816,
0.24869710206985474,
-0.695188045501709,
0.5873824954032898,
0.021965524181723595,
-0.08398838341236115,
0.02336045727133751,
-0.5187644362449646,
0.37007197737693787,
-0.3341447114944458,
0.35298699140548706,
-0.020817600190639496,
-0.16522668302059174,
0.32393568754196167,
-0.44131985306739807,
0.6367149949073792,
0.09250153601169586,
-0.1070704534649849,
0.43062588572502136,
0.24181851744651794,
0.48945352435112,
0.13006579875946045,
-0.6737462282180786,
0.11747553199529648,
0.2846812605857849,
-0.41683080792427063,
-0.7795184254646301,
0.6913143992424011,
-0.4845505952835083,
-0.9900628328323364,
-0.41395628452301025,
-0.5652191638946533,
-0.21154692769050598,
0.4054732024669647,
0.41032448410987854,
0.08993341028690338,
-0.1686783730983734,
0.2769945561885834,
0.5027378797531128,
-0.06566362828016281,
0.03531932458281517,
0.5399575233459473,
-0.11805780977010727,
-0.4435712993144989,
0.27676647901535034,
0.34169718623161316,
0.7263278961181641,
0.3176032602787018,
0.21473746001720428,
-0.29316359758377075,
-0.47194021940231323,
-0.31750622391700745,
0.385738730430603,
-0.7850373387336731,
0.011335683986544609,
-0.3348454236984253,
-0.19543376564979553,
-0.6056729555130005,
0.022293556481599808,
-0.4853149652481079,
-0.5086460709571838,
-0.24311266839504242,
-0.24042478203773499,
0.27666524052619934,
0.6365589499473572,
-0.10731067508459091,
0.24844855070114136,
-0.5682055354118347,
0.16331838071346283,
0.0771167129278183,
0.4969027638435364,
-0.34474286437034607,
-0.8538543581962585,
-0.07860872894525528,
0.5839507579803467,
0.03071977198123932,
-1.2247227430343628,
0.2365570068359375,
0.06637255847454071,
0.7768194079399109,
-0.014780747704207897,
0.41188880801200867,
0.6762309074401855,
-0.4271275997161865,
0.767754316329956,
0.08478105813264847,
-0.6916801929473877,
0.28590860962867737,
0.1103261262178421,
0.1848839819431305,
0.8703444600105286,
0.4429962635040283,
-0.43846091628074646,
-0.49301451444625854,
-0.4557745158672333,
-0.7438945174217224,
0.36828675866127014,
0.0071172211319208145,
0.21609976887702942,
0.1600050926208496,
0.44688257575035095,
-0.0414687879383564,
0.38069167733192444,
-0.5721339583396912,
-0.3386540114879608,
0.03495432436466217,
-0.19084614515304565,
0.054273948073387146,
-0.42714810371398926,
-0.42608386278152466,
0.028314800933003426,
0.4636762738227844,
0.08547414094209671,
0.1325923055410385,
0.18858809769153595,
-0.20376381278038025,
-0.30555081367492676,
0.3705157935619354,
0.6811411380767822,
1.0010920763015747,
-0.4336804449558258,
0.28717073798179626,
0.2444581538438797,
-0.462639182806015,
0.00003147467941744253,
0.014097989536821842,
-0.2400941401720047,
0.1656288504600525,
0.20101751387119293,
0.37959912419319153,
0.34634652733802795,
-0.7652814984321594,
0.44748830795288086,
0.02674083784222603,
-0.1341148018836975,
-0.6389155387878418,
-0.18314824998378754,
0.21483096480369568,
0.19776475429534912,
0.28214922547340393,
0.10734602063894272,
-0.1778344213962555,
-0.5268169641494751,
0.42595693469047546,
0.365296334028244,
-0.40976881980895996,
0.08556436002254486,
0.3391493856906891,
-0.23151038587093353,
-0.32813578844070435,
0.4706854522228241,
0.0009699370129965246,
-0.3862011432647705,
0.4590870141983032,
0.3123893737792969,
0.8050367832183838,
-0.2932524085044861,
0.032706066966056824,
0.3692739009857178,
0.6909582614898682,
-0.5264001488685608,
0.4936060309410095,
0.2132187783718109,
-0.7883661389350891,
-0.49871376156806946,
-0.456802636384964,
-0.7997072339057922,
0.03901544585824013,
-0.8612707853317261,
0.021649720147252083,
-0.4892882704734802,
-0.23631109297275543,
-0.2032254934310913,
-0.07731057703495026,
-0.3600893020629883,
0.12112827599048615,
-0.0010990091832354665,
1.0960203409194946,
-0.632686197757721,
0.6177762746810913,
0.4568488299846649,
-0.6301243901252747,
-0.9720464944839478,
0.2913574278354645,
-0.07437499612569809,
-0.7147549986839294,
0.1624828279018402,
0.05516522377729416,
-0.30840378999710083,
-0.1439664512872696,
-0.6398428678512573,
-1.0512442588806152,
0.8407851457595825,
0.6442679762840271,
-0.42885762453079224,
0.0740036889910698,
0.06552882492542267,
0.5906993746757507,
-0.2583613097667694,
0.3333299160003662,
0.493808776140213,
0.6682040691375732,
0.2614264488220215,
-0.8776983618736267,
0.04764867201447487,
0.08789073675870895,
-0.29682838916778564,
0.06100626662373543,
-0.19898734986782074,
0.9761840105056763,
-0.3900766968727112,
-0.3962773084640503,
0.2587037682533264,
0.5336844325065613,
0.2883279323577881,
0.4157571792602539,
0.2857173979282379,
0.5962625741958618,
1.154340386390686,
-0.08549221605062485,
1.1265579462051392,
-0.3744509518146515,
0.49692586064338684,
1.5255976915359497,
-0.26208585500717163,
1.1019859313964844,
0.5142731666564941,
-0.2120194435119629,
0.25675642490386963,
0.8280898928642273,
0.11465974897146225,
0.33655354380607605,
0.3711031377315521,
-0.2568649351596832,
-0.31980687379837036,
0.04288701340556145,
-0.6056006550788879,
-0.00655628927052021,
0.39726945757865906,
-0.5061843991279602,
-0.3598524034023285,
-0.2589114308357239,
0.055485524237155914,
0.2612558603286743,
-0.046985793858766556,
0.4290895164012909,
0.27112048864364624,
-0.7639228701591492,
0.7330484390258789,
0.04518059641122818,
0.2253158837556839,
-0.34519773721694946,
0.23595447838306427,
-0.3240547776222229,
-0.16756074130535126,
-0.07438495755195618,
-0.9821946620941162,
0.3703114092350006,
-0.04905466362833977,
-0.09267208725214005,
-0.0036811030004173517,
0.27382099628448486,
-0.48135697841644287,
-0.7324077486991882,
0.1031484380364418,
0.6895918250083923,
0.35215359926223755,
-0.6238089203834534,
-0.7605792880058289,
0.09716861695051193,
0.00985730905085802,
-0.37920063734054565,
-0.019188884645700455,
0.48512041568756104,
0.23084771633148193,
0.9728556871414185,
0.39198896288871765,
0.1857578307390213,
0.38174930214881897,
0.1263616383075714,
0.723571240901947,
-0.5639815330505371,
0.06629341095685959,
-0.6836933493614197,
0.25599637627601624,
0.052263468503952026,
-0.2429177165031433,
0.7614732384681702,
0.40558215975761414,
0.831474781036377,
-0.0015603636857122183,
0.831026554107666,
0.21945205330848694,
0.6029810309410095,
-0.4624054729938507,
0.5059245228767395,
-0.6746971607208252,
0.49471917748451233,
-0.029578721150755882,
-0.8389401435852051,
-0.420636922121048,
0.4582103192806244,
-0.47066769003868103,
0.08752677589654922,
0.6317621469497681,
1.1762237548828125,
0.0948450043797493,
-0.014795362018048763,
0.4469146132469177,
0.3676098883152008,
0.0024302515666931868,
0.36875247955322266,
0.7472984790802002,
-0.33199363946914673,
0.51185542345047,
-0.5487922430038452,
-0.09815728664398193,
-0.2758692502975464,
-0.8795101642608643,
-0.33353549242019653,
-0.47556471824645996,
-0.17138603329658508,
-0.41323116421699524,
0.08371948450803757,
0.7946010828018188,
0.4078647792339325,
-0.7672975063323975,
-0.1131606251001358,
0.14203070104122162,
0.5902431607246399,
-0.2926541268825531,
-0.179331436753273,
0.1943962723016739,
-0.2507064640522003,
-0.6888530254364014,
0.4194752275943756,
-0.08364617079496384,
-0.18757390975952148,
-0.3787866532802582,
0.28398072719573975,
-0.29673662781715393,
0.3095483183860779,
0.19144324958324432,
0.35015299916267395,
-0.9173697829246521,
-0.5547266602516174,
0.19979387521743774,
-0.5111997127532959,
0.027750123292207718,
0.3968733549118042,
-0.34296903014183044,
0.6408522129058838,
0.5681178569793701,
0.6876735687255859,
0.23044662177562714,
0.2923884987831116,
0.7027955055236816,
-0.8537718653678894,
-0.13021807372570038,
0.35820382833480835,
0.15992987155914307,
0.39049723744392395,
-0.32315754890441895,
0.4104679822921753,
0.2139868438243866,
-0.4834243953227997,
-1.1132136583328247,
0.6391745209693909,
-0.8815342783927917,
-0.42754456400871277,
1.117495059967041,
-0.3826726973056793,
-0.24635083973407745,
-0.08667715638875961,
-0.027298541739583015,
0.11880190670490265,
-0.24920861423015594,
0.5234231352806091,
0.9450122714042664,
0.12107038497924805,
-0.30494028329849243,
-0.7205792665481567,
0.14863266050815582,
0.2893652617931366,
-0.40716126561164856,
0.3296947777271271,
0.5767340660095215,
0.5553622841835022,
0.24780769646167755,
0.518515408039093,
-0.05091021955013275,
0.2149815559387207,
0.048065654933452606,
0.008252698928117752,
0.1422007977962494,
-0.11925946921110153,
-0.21944424510002136,
0.3284699618816376,
0.3306483328342438,
0.006868942640721798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13873v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13873v1
|
FiDeLiS: Faithful Reasoning in Large Language Model for Knowledge Graph Question Answering
| 2024-05-22T17:56:53 | 2024-05-22T17:56:53 |
Yuan Sui, Yufei He, Nian Liu, Xiaoxin He, Kun Wang, Bryan Hooi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
While large language models (LLMs) have achieved significant success in
various applications, they often struggle with hallucinations, especially in
scenarios that require deep and responsible reasoning. These issues could be
partially mitigate by integrating external knowledge graphs (KG) in LLM
reasoning. However, the method of their incorporation is still largely
unexplored. In this paper, we propose a retrieval-exploration interactive
method, FiDelis to handle intermediate steps of reasoning grounded by KGs.
Specifically, we propose Path-RAG module for recalling useful intermediate
knowledge from KG for LLM reasoning. We incorporate the logic and common-sense
reasoning of LLMs and topological connectivity of KGs into the knowledge
retrieval process, which provides more accurate recalling performance.
Furthermore, we propose to leverage deductive reasoning capabilities of LLMs as
a better criterion to automatically guide the reasoning process in a stepwise
and generalizable manner. Deductive verification serve as precise indicators
for when to cease further reasoning, thus avoiding misleading the chains of
reasoning and unnecessary computation. Extensive experiments show that our
method, as a training-free method with lower computational cost and better
generality outperforms the existing strong baselines in three benchmarks.
|
[
-0.20209752023220062,
-0.8859444260597229,
1.1666206121444702,
-0.17981934547424316,
-0.19942115247249603,
0.046672720462083817,
-0.14318309724330902,
-0.25814056396484375,
0.20868831872940063,
0.654586136341095,
-0.608774721622467,
-0.6266776919364929,
-0.4018615186214447,
-0.027311179786920547,
-0.26950040459632874,
0.33045831322669983,
-0.23932208120822906,
-0.030513916164636612,
-0.5203614234924316,
-0.19760560989379883,
-0.4207874834537506,
-0.3435855507850647,
-0.6863874793052673,
-0.4181794822216034,
0.5370994210243225,
0.37214502692222595,
0.6475638151168823,
0.21866922080516815,
0.31803402304649353,
0.346357524394989,
-0.30853697657585144,
0.6959371566772461,
-0.5906907320022583,
0.538388729095459,
-0.5582035779953003,
-0.5912668704986572,
-0.23704825341701508,
-0.31288421154022217,
0.7532067894935608,
0.6665474772453308,
0.08737622946500778,
0.00533038005232811,
-0.09111713618040085,
0.7373896241188049,
-0.42267030477523804,
0.2836991846561432,
-0.7444833517074585,
-0.07189851254224777,
-0.008395107463002205,
-0.2718842625617981,
-0.7971128225326538,
-0.6972494721412659,
-0.1050000935792923,
-0.6466537117958069,
-0.31406405568122864,
-0.03540804609656334,
0.511001706123352,
0.3681429326534271,
-0.5662834048271179,
-0.3434526026248932,
-0.8318035006523132,
0.5918569564819336,
-0.5398662686347961,
0.6483756899833679,
0.56023108959198,
0.6963504552841187,
-0.4160732328891754,
-1.0304105281829834,
-0.5713475942611694,
-0.26804032921791077,
-0.28662729263305664,
-0.15885484218597412,
0.0913112685084343,
0.08912432938814163,
0.4388439953327179,
0.039687857031822205,
-0.4180104434490204,
-0.3983403444290161,
-0.38057783246040344,
-0.2868782877922058,
0.4148767590522766,
0.336997926235199,
-0.026974042877554893,
-0.023552097380161285,
-0.12191536277532578,
-0.03255709633231163,
-1.1574957370758057,
0.1158691868185997,
0.11524615436792374,
0.04812963306903839,
0.30871251225471497,
0.5665543079376221,
-0.4307979941368103,
0.794550895690918,
-0.14029376208782196,
-0.18637698888778687,
0.16367125511169434,
-0.08622612804174423,
-0.08942366391420364,
-0.24719266593456268,
0.509036660194397,
-0.02936389669775963,
0.41873544454574585,
-0.4578196108341217,
0.05107474699616432,
-0.24947550892829895,
0.27791306376457214,
-0.6922723054885864,
-0.2586265206336975,
0.15300552546977997,
-0.21640567481517792,
0.047934237867593765,
-0.054961785674095154,
-0.5189882516860962,
-0.35309144854545593,
-0.39673325419425964,
0.5129112601280212,
-0.8719728589057922,
0.02051747590303421,
0.029084380716085434,
0.005369794089347124,
0.3961680829524994,
0.5842916369438171,
-0.47479426860809326,
0.21598711609840393,
0.7966992855072021,
0.5053341388702393,
0.11724469065666199,
-0.05357516184449196,
-0.856066107749939,
0.5282196402549744,
-0.4356154203414917,
0.6864779591560364,
-0.7788510918617249,
-0.40969324111938477,
-0.06591393798589706,
0.1291648894548416,
-0.1776340752840042,
-0.32068824768066406,
0.7734599113464355,
-0.9707228541374207,
-0.0803690105676651,
-0.7989322543144226,
-0.6430827975273132,
-0.6241042017936707,
0.6200791001319885,
-0.4267007112503052,
0.9627153873443604,
0.059526171535253525,
-0.9149445295333862,
-0.08268416672945023,
-0.22627288103103638,
-0.2571844458580017,
0.020690681412816048,
-0.3454281985759735,
0.09368562698364258,
-0.17148856818675995,
0.30446159839630127,
0.24258895218372345,
-0.333729088306427,
0.4023462235927582,
-0.4264124929904938,
-0.6023115515708923,
0.3385227620601654,
-0.3061176538467407,
0.8555561304092407,
0.17474044859409332,
-0.2180851697921753,
0.029314864426851273,
-0.5266938805580139,
0.18051627278327942,
0.03993069380521774,
-0.15877224504947662,
-0.6032352447509766,
0.22447927296161652,
-0.871709942817688,
0.1397181749343872,
0.2446182370185852,
-0.29640287160873413,
0.5225940346717834,
-0.5027133822441101,
0.06713160872459412,
0.8938999176025391,
0.2604593336582184,
0.3021220564842224,
-0.24736133217811584,
0.38425588607788086,
-0.027946677058935165,
0.24326388537883759,
-0.12855520844459534,
-0.6024315357208252,
-1.0371074676513672,
-0.10246573388576508,
0.06609953939914703,
0.4201085865497589,
-1.1779249906539917,
0.07644352316856384,
-0.2916979491710663,
-0.4446532130241394,
-0.4041367173194885,
0.08063016086816788,
0.299383282661438,
0.6371136903762817,
0.5082774758338928,
0.28199198842048645,
-0.1454302966594696,
-0.6369337439537048,
-0.15375684201717377,
-0.47644466161727905,
0.04950079321861267,
0.6067423820495605,
0.5367870926856995,
-0.44154199957847595,
0.9537087678909302,
-0.7013727426528931,
-0.041464801877737045,
-0.10664135217666626,
-0.05106613412499428,
0.42071104049682617,
0.09713923186063766,
0.3199036121368408,
-0.8256885409355164,
-0.49747055768966675,
-0.05124398693442345,
-0.7226090431213379,
-0.12392562627792358,
0.061513397842645645,
-0.37370094656944275,
0.08101671934127808,
0.5642042756080627,
-0.7188828587532043,
0.22418011724948883,
0.18940462172031403,
-0.4633198380470276,
0.45803865790367126,
-0.253282368183136,
0.3308233916759491,
-0.8361358046531677,
0.2730220556259155,
-0.5878522992134094,
-0.25174903869628906,
-0.37389203906059265,
0.2888146638870239,
0.07851157337427139,
0.2456745058298111,
-0.19722750782966614,
0.6788551807403564,
-0.2101220041513443,
-0.08916997164487839,
-0.08226515352725983,
0.292373925447464,
0.3395133316516876,
0.46397534012794495,
-0.09051071852445602,
0.6450293064117432,
0.5371640920639038,
-0.5338664650917053,
0.5989086031913757,
0.237227201461792,
-0.029995327815413475,
0.3841482400894165,
-0.4034128487110138,
0.4407138228416443,
-0.3529518246650696,
0.2905395030975342,
-1.1804076433181763,
0.0012173376744613051,
0.45475393533706665,
-0.3939526081085205,
0.3778914511203766,
-0.3161185085773468,
-0.5551778078079224,
-0.5103892087936401,
-0.2156582623720169,
0.26821479201316833,
0.5705539584159851,
-0.719664990901947,
0.8674728274345398,
0.24173131585121155,
-0.028642086312174797,
-0.5157262086868286,
-0.18395471572875977,
-0.10805601626634598,
-0.30355677008628845,
-0.7856336832046509,
0.21019448339939117,
-0.22905737161636353,
-0.48788708448410034,
-0.015779294073581696,
-0.04045933112502098,
-0.07404105365276337,
0.09083617478609085,
0.0643957108259201,
0.1448071449995041,
-0.04453122988343239,
0.3237276077270508,
0.21196462213993073,
-0.13939706981182098,
0.28928765654563904,
-0.49208498001098633,
0.38988783955574036,
-0.25463369488716125,
-0.71322101354599,
-0.004060104954987764,
0.169603630900383,
0.5448800921440125,
-0.19775477051734924,
0.5826175808906555,
0.4577781558036804,
-0.47452443838119507,
-0.1580941081047058,
-0.701839804649353,
-0.11746564507484436,
-0.5253186225891113,
-0.0811309963464737,
-0.5657224059104919,
-0.8009192943572998,
0.6264466643333435,
-0.28854653239250183,
-0.13781504333019257,
0.5224947929382324,
0.39766812324523926,
-0.056532394140958786,
0.8771498799324036,
0.23425240814685822,
0.19049283862113953,
-0.24319380521774292,
-0.4355815052986145,
0.15676721930503845,
-0.8869221210479736,
-0.7771362066268921,
-0.6470151543617249,
-0.07935285568237305,
-0.1830865740776062,
-0.910516619682312,
0.5372058749198914,
0.3014557957649231,
-0.1239166259765625,
0.11606741696596146,
-0.2635442316532135,
0.559733510017395,
0.35496392846107483,
0.1008460745215416,
0.5671769380569458,
-0.28186410665512085,
-0.6017627120018005,
-0.08694278448820114,
-0.5418404340744019,
-0.33883777260780334,
0.8067488670349121,
0.1615419089794159,
0.9634563326835632,
0.269148051738739,
0.733196496963501,
-0.05924126133322716,
0.34699180722236633,
-0.7290881276130676,
0.7420276403427124,
-0.0021998686715960503,
-0.40719783306121826,
-0.37613922357559204,
-0.7227598428726196,
-0.5182003974914551,
0.33520159125328064,
0.07077322900295258,
-0.993608832359314,
0.08681332319974899,
0.03787818178534508,
-0.34126490354537964,
0.3790844976902008,
-0.27213162183761597,
0.5679502487182617,
-0.17849312722682953,
-0.5128253102302551,
-0.30918458104133606,
-0.6560140252113342,
0.5558457374572754,
-0.06159441918134689,
0.2252865731716156,
0.12614820897579193,
0.18182125687599182,
0.5725541710853577,
-0.2499508410692215,
0.7420335412025452,
-0.3640879988670349,
-0.026075441390275955,
0.6777091026306152,
0.4850430190563202,
0.9179383516311646,
0.21130315959453583,
-0.14541469514369965,
-0.16430602967739105,
0.10191111266613007,
0.108470618724823,
-0.8374215960502625,
0.8548778295516968,
-0.4496742784976959,
-0.8642006516456604,
-0.31984609365463257,
-0.45755645632743835,
-0.5716395378112793,
0.17599385976791382,
-0.14753316342830658,
0.33357590436935425,
-0.09671655297279358,
0.24408963322639465,
1.0723974704742432,
-0.38474392890930176,
-0.007148544304072857,
0.5995898246765137,
-0.5248332023620605,
-0.4188138544559479,
0.7561402320861816,
0.17264118790626526,
0.004953365307301283,
0.5646884441375732,
0.4343244731426239,
-0.4379429221153259,
-0.4564393162727356,
-0.41018998622894287,
0.3348127603530884,
-0.9876216650009155,
-0.372393935918808,
-0.9530044794082642,
-0.3902311623096466,
-0.3616831600666046,
-0.1273399144411087,
-0.29582422971725464,
-0.5340554714202881,
-0.056042369455099106,
-0.052526190876960754,
0.47569540143013,
0.6668328046798706,
0.07010192424058914,
-0.05358074605464935,
-0.9249425530433655,
0.49259066581726074,
0.5455650091171265,
0.22612915933132172,
0.1141609326004982,
-0.5860968232154846,
-0.15717972815036774,
0.12881624698638916,
-0.2950265109539032,
-0.9943398237228394,
0.21630506217479706,
-0.07831301540136337,
0.8989542722702026,
0.5725836157798767,
0.13849692046642303,
0.6763332486152649,
-0.4505453407764435,
0.5238568186759949,
-0.23425538837909698,
-0.7539371848106384,
0.5065267086029053,
-0.42830443382263184,
0.18765243887901306,
0.6683023571968079,
0.6827197670936584,
-0.4251198470592499,
-0.38492295145988464,
-0.45463117957115173,
-0.6820463538169861,
0.4985247254371643,
0.18990646302700043,
-0.17898589372634888,
-0.2572353780269623,
0.5434529185295105,
0.0122075779363513,
-0.15222203731536865,
-0.4779771566390991,
0.023883156478405,
0.20354191958904266,
-0.08577771484851837,
0.2664538025856018,
-0.33944255113601685,
-0.22576817870140076,
-0.6441377401351929,
0.9134424328804016,
-0.33278515934944153,
0.15001541376113892,
0.28753718733787537,
-0.04033324122428894,
-0.10974222421646118,
-0.0025678477250039577,
0.19822193682193756,
0.7814682722091675,
-0.20066536962985992,
0.29081520438194275,
0.4806972146034241,
-0.19741089642047882,
0.10253333300352097,
0.055188924074172974,
-0.2173592746257782,
-0.018769998103380203,
0.2607380747795105,
0.3868473470211029,
0.1899450570344925,
-0.6565837264060974,
0.5634693503379822,
-0.007158793043345213,
0.08545740693807602,
-0.5203197598457336,
0.17324534058570862,
0.476412296295166,
0.6502541303634644,
0.2673400044441223,
-0.3215957581996918,
0.21079158782958984,
-0.4371466338634491,
0.1585978865623474,
0.5261675715446472,
-0.4851037561893463,
-0.11309781670570374,
0.5367405414581299,
-0.024390606209635735,
-0.15666182339191437,
0.882891058921814,
-0.3197302520275116,
-0.7448462247848511,
0.4555422067642212,
0.44324198365211487,
0.7945990562438965,
-0.2511810064315796,
0.32204383611679077,
0.40199896693229675,
0.3711033761501312,
0.005958463530987501,
0.3741609454154968,
-0.02137054316699505,
-0.5662265419960022,
-0.6112962961196899,
-0.7264163494110107,
-0.4365413188934326,
-0.11054288595914841,
-0.16915395855903625,
0.3150283992290497,
-0.1330445408821106,
0.11394099146127701,
-0.4335159659385681,
0.01713276095688343,
-0.44159993529319763,
0.014091667719185352,
0.14205510914325714,
1.1809842586517334,
-0.6129223704338074,
1.1893123388290405,
0.34663692116737366,
-0.22674748301506042,
-0.8331624269485474,
-0.03786412999033928,
-0.09746652096509933,
-0.6209715008735657,
0.7902604341506958,
0.14545896649360657,
-0.3395707607269287,
-0.1972428858280182,
-0.31974565982818604,
-0.913369357585907,
1.3334219455718994,
0.39117303490638733,
-0.30660849809646606,
-0.19961270689964294,
0.08373900502920151,
0.4791787266731262,
-0.2166605293750763,
0.1929304003715515,
0.48908329010009766,
0.668907642364502,
0.7621787190437317,
-0.43964284658432007,
0.2920635938644409,
0.05153152719140053,
-0.36901047825813293,
0.2847770154476166,
-0.6158154606819153,
0.7735418081283569,
-0.3223229646682739,
-0.023875292390584946,
0.21214060485363007,
0.5825550556182861,
0.36860981583595276,
0.28501439094543457,
0.3973768651485443,
0.6461971402168274,
1.0418305397033691,
-0.033917855471372604,
0.9120157361030579,
-0.21821321547031403,
0.21039946377277374,
1.0734363794326782,
-0.3017933964729309,
0.6158535480499268,
0.5175732374191284,
-0.16898690164089203,
0.6093578934669495,
0.3119998574256897,
0.3524373769760132,
0.5871790051460266,
0.2389189749956131,
-0.2860679030418396,
-0.5208703279495239,
0.0327727273106575,
-0.4152853786945343,
0.310464084148407,
0.5583421587944031,
-0.4254288673400879,
-0.2343353033065796,
-0.2677097022533417,
0.013481473550200462,
-0.11751434206962585,
-0.1686914563179016,
0.630071222782135,
0.19342640042304993,
-0.9647467732429504,
0.47875523567199707,
0.04180506616830826,
-0.1357116997241974,
-0.8662042021751404,
-0.45444998145103455,
-0.44013580679893494,
0.1116771474480629,
0.05078650638461113,
-0.7661508321762085,
0.639653742313385,
-0.23882147669792175,
0.26635873317718506,
-0.13114087283611298,
1.0533987283706665,
-0.3926393389701843,
-0.41172391176223755,
0.4909636080265045,
0.48673826456069946,
0.17052561044692993,
-0.08953949809074402,
-0.3787534534931183,
-0.0810202956199646,
0.0029420440550893545,
-0.4003103971481323,
0.05981600284576416,
0.7317719459533691,
-0.18292495608329773,
0.8109135627746582,
0.5336475372314453,
-0.150991752743721,
-0.10168319195508957,
0.06733539700508118,
1.3239941596984863,
-0.6592974662780762,
-0.3741806149482727,
-0.8539955019950867,
0.3312023878097534,
-0.15745909512043,
0.2391783595085144,
0.666945219039917,
0.5263441205024719,
0.4726329743862152,
0.08611094206571579,
0.45729634165763855,
0.029133955016732216,
0.3387204110622406,
-0.8866814374923706,
0.6868969202041626,
-0.2929997444152832,
0.4062759280204773,
-0.24518297612667084,
-0.9625144004821777,
-0.13301940262317657,
0.7259081602096558,
-0.4347054362297058,
-0.07999840378761292,
0.86509108543396,
0.7208778858184814,
-0.16565978527069092,
0.09844371676445007,
0.3405139148235321,
0.571246325969696,
0.3778574764728546,
0.7844444513320923,
1.0183979272842407,
-0.13775861263275146,
0.6102389693260193,
-0.1053771823644638,
-0.18051590025424957,
-0.046709369868040085,
-0.8025023937225342,
-0.8394327759742737,
-0.5438627004623413,
-0.034517183899879456,
-0.5785128474235535,
0.18502897024154663,
0.5943504571914673,
0.24656832218170166,
-0.46567800641059875,
0.10391181707382202,
0.07765884697437286,
0.5560669302940369,
0.009199986234307289,
-0.1968887746334076,
0.4475564956665039,
-0.3829347491264343,
-0.3741057217121124,
0.6717990636825562,
0.30489641427993774,
-0.20811817049980164,
-0.5402873158454895,
-0.3767410218715668,
-0.3348073363304138,
0.30412107706069946,
0.4907636344432831,
0.05882200971245766,
-0.5932144522666931,
-0.6684642434120178,
0.24298100173473358,
0.05801378935575485,
-0.12580132484436035,
0.9056061506271362,
-1.1198387145996094,
0.5188843011856079,
0.8274264335632324,
0.6381255984306335,
0.9262862205505371,
-0.19780303537845612,
0.41277292370796204,
-0.4160374402999878,
-0.0529366098344326,
0.3185729384422302,
0.5451333522796631,
0.27494457364082336,
-0.3506883978843689,
0.6775441765785217,
0.30844518542289734,
-0.4647272229194641,
-0.5712623596191406,
0.43561238050460815,
-0.8130269050598145,
-0.4303402900695801,
1.3115311861038208,
-0.4832487106323242,
-0.2339024841785431,
-0.2276359349489212,
-0.2871549725532532,
0.18610338866710663,
0.1809001863002777,
0.7663722038269043,
0.7302126288414001,
-0.1313873529434204,
0.2292761653661728,
-0.44380277395248413,
0.3813976049423218,
0.07151997834444046,
-0.74676114320755,
0.1279934197664261,
0.6689232587814331,
0.21194033324718475,
0.12492130696773529,
0.9316355586051941,
-0.3043827414512634,
0.00414721155539155,
-0.12285616248846054,
-0.5244653820991516,
-0.22360961139202118,
-0.7677218914031982,
0.08845016360282898,
0.1643158197402954,
0.2026216834783554,
0.3582431674003601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13872v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13872v2
|
Image-of-Thought Prompting for Visual Reasoning Refinement in Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-05-22T17:56:51 | 2024-05-29T02:24:36 |
Qiji Zhou, Ruochen Zhou, Zike Hu, Panzhong Lu, Siyang Gao, Yue Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Recent advancements in Chain-of-Thought (CoT) and related rationale-based
works have significantly improved the performance of Large Language Models
(LLMs) in complex reasoning tasks. With the evolution of Multimodal Large
Language Models (MLLMs), enhancing their capability to tackle complex
multimodal reasoning problems is a crucial frontier. However, incorporating
multimodal rationales in CoT has yet to be thoroughly investigated. We propose
the Image-of-Thought (IoT) prompting method, which helps MLLMs to extract
visual rationales step-by-step. Specifically, IoT prompting can automatically
design critical visual information extraction operations based on the input
images and questions. Each step of visual information refinement identifies
specific visual rationales that support answers to complex visual reasoning
questions. Beyond the textual CoT, IoT simultaneously utilizes visual and
textual rationales to help MLLMs understand complex multimodal information. IoT
prompting has improved zero-shot visual reasoning performance across various
visual understanding tasks in different MLLMs. Moreover, the step-by-step
visual feature explanations generated by IoT prompting elucidate the visual
reasoning process, aiding in analyzing the cognitive processes of large
multimodal models
|
[
-0.747246503829956,
-1.1914607286453247,
0.9252688884735107,
0.08656378835439682,
-0.6010123491287231,
-0.2601301074028015,
-0.3306506872177124,
-0.30653679370880127,
-0.10928987711668015,
0.46442121267318726,
-0.9144635200500488,
-0.21011096239089966,
-0.2932698428630829,
0.18330691754817963,
-0.058146629482507706,
0.40967339277267456,
-0.23615995049476624,
0.11344779282808304,
-0.3011406660079956,
0.011598160490393639,
-0.8521241545677185,
0.018576281145215034,
-0.6599359512329102,
0.024391543120145798,
0.8374338746070862,
0.4652690887451172,
0.4171048104763031,
0.30324721336364746,
0.5855384469032288,
0.28223755955696106,
0.31253111362457275,
0.5594746470451355,
-0.23073938488960266,
0.3579750657081604,
-0.28355929255485535,
-0.47732439637184143,
-0.30664950609207153,
-0.13491907715797424,
0.3924703896045685,
0.29201483726501465,
0.25677207112312317,
0.3643326461315155,
-0.24496027827262878,
0.7260799407958984,
-0.8596816062927246,
0.2408837378025055,
-0.7223243713378906,
-0.11286424100399017,
0.3351874053478241,
-0.7896735668182373,
-0.7247449159622192,
-0.006147129461169243,
0.2527829110622406,
-0.6427954435348511,
-0.000898542464710772,
0.17449894547462463,
0.7201172113418579,
0.4363785684108734,
-0.31549516320228577,
-0.08311497420072556,
-0.6378574967384338,
0.7916454076766968,
-0.2803749442100525,
0.49331769347190857,
0.3149860203266144,
0.31074029207229614,
-0.10127536207437515,
-0.5314974188804626,
-0.9428256154060364,
-0.30917590856552124,
0.06704133003950119,
0.2925691604614258,
-0.34752851724624634,
-0.07770851999521255,
0.6777169704437256,
-0.16356989741325378,
-0.47269266843795776,
-0.31728312373161316,
-0.30598750710487366,
0.1294604241847992,
0.33548957109451294,
-0.10160582512617111,
0.21209074556827545,
-0.0906754583120346,
-0.7722265124320984,
-0.1795244812965393,
-0.6824309229850769,
0.058163996785879135,
-0.267166405916214,
-0.06427258253097534,
0.08590305596590042,
0.5253864526748657,
-0.25687268376350403,
0.693128228187561,
0.11784449964761734,
-0.16522717475891113,
0.12529292702674866,
-0.3689843416213989,
-0.24255473911762238,
-0.07594864070415497,
0.651507556438446,
0.7465549111366272,
0.3505033552646637,
0.3825555741786957,
-0.17769192159175873,
0.049759842455387115,
0.2509336769580841,
-0.6628322601318359,
-0.08014146983623505,
0.3144412934780121,
-0.5445170402526855,
-0.043529000133275986,
-0.10985135287046432,
-0.760761559009552,
-0.3886566758155823,
-0.6033456921577454,
0.5291274189949036,
-0.5802289843559265,
-0.3702813684940338,
0.05185379460453987,
-0.3825693726539612,
0.2989657521247864,
1.0616352558135986,
-0.5721441507339478,
-0.49813219904899597,
0.17351065576076508,
0.49251610040664673,
0.23603373765945435,
-0.29324355721473694,
-0.37673988938331604,
0.2443855106830597,
-0.28476887941360474,
1.2609443664550781,
-0.5740655660629272,
-0.17178964614868164,
-0.20165538787841797,
-0.14750924706459045,
-0.06677775084972382,
-0.28206658363342285,
0.3387630581855774,
-0.5814051032066345,
0.13610728085041046,
-0.5168460607528687,
-0.24424628913402557,
-0.4671502411365509,
0.9629907608032227,
-0.652873158454895,
0.6466166377067566,
-0.33039432764053345,
-0.6790511608123779,
0.5002685189247131,
-0.9744628667831421,
-0.06803405284881592,
0.2542840838432312,
-0.42362838983535767,
-0.16430972516536713,
-0.056129537522792816,
0.9389544725418091,
0.532300591468811,
-0.4430869221687317,
0.007576662115752697,
-0.6276501417160034,
-0.1589195430278778,
0.5062798857688904,
-0.88426673412323,
0.5680490136146545,
0.47254908084869385,
-0.5029594898223877,
0.3195423483848572,
-0.42513805627822876,
0.35593435168266296,
0.22458629310131073,
0.09459434449672699,
-0.11479693651199341,
-0.13514477014541626,
-0.19370007514953613,
0.30670979619026184,
0.21244359016418457,
-0.4251157343387604,
0.35584890842437744,
0.4297657012939453,
0.4504801034927368,
0.8702924847602844,
0.08833445608615875,
0.09387575089931488,
-0.13634583353996277,
0.5666581392288208,
0.2444911152124405,
0.49835291504859924,
-0.8272504806518555,
-0.6453955769538879,
-0.7886806726455688,
-0.7352672815322876,
0.03106963075697422,
0.6216010451316833,
-1.3004828691482544,
0.001032317173667252,
-0.15562286972999573,
-0.19053925573825836,
-0.5280542373657227,
-0.1125400960445404,
0.25354382395744324,
0.5734677314758301,
0.43657809495925903,
0.15323752164840698,
-0.2881169617176056,
-0.8709290623664856,
-0.012022553943097591,
-0.13201342523097992,
0.2489769458770752,
0.34612128138542175,
0.564898669719696,
-0.28458738327026367,
0.8880770802497864,
-0.521471381187439,
0.06275232881307602,
-0.17555809020996094,
0.32490700483322144,
-0.19238680601119995,
0.3606433868408203,
0.2915148437023163,
-1.0305196046829224,
-0.19278943538665771,
0.1867295503616333,
-0.7809224128723145,
0.03275921195745468,
-0.4060652256011963,
-0.28916630148887634,
0.1300732046365738,
0.6718990802764893,
-0.8107278943061829,
0.7882688641548157,
0.11523350328207016,
-0.22559870779514313,
0.7635518908500671,
-0.2275162637233734,
0.6617228984832764,
-0.8865348696708679,
0.1341720074415207,
-0.1356879025697708,
-0.13848790526390076,
-0.22170361876487732,
0.1015448346734047,
0.14234144985675812,
-0.023983873426914215,
-0.3889232873916626,
0.6430739164352417,
-0.5654640793800354,
0.2791750729084015,
-0.18517200648784637,
0.34352460503578186,
0.2500327229499817,
0.5094423294067383,
0.18386141955852509,
0.6319805383682251,
0.8176327347755432,
-0.38388851284980774,
0.6264305114746094,
-0.014605581760406494,
-0.2827441692352295,
0.8133854269981384,
-0.30291759967803955,
0.14795251190662384,
-0.5223684906959534,
0.39833950996398926,
-1.2053916454315186,
-0.2248392105102539,
0.10636202245950699,
-0.2419314682483673,
-0.04731792211532593,
-0.23912571370601654,
-0.6453617215156555,
-0.5416316986083984,
-0.3050857484340668,
0.7135837078094482,
0.2817460894584656,
-0.7898922562599182,
0.7421034574508667,
-0.10577470809221268,
-0.11036437749862671,
-0.5849010944366455,
-0.4711167812347412,
0.04857384040951729,
-0.19367407262325287,
-0.7865538001060486,
-0.10479269921779633,
-0.14898811280727386,
-0.26660025119781494,
0.026635030284523964,
0.2540072202682495,
0.009005939587950706,
-0.2022770792245865,
0.09512878209352493,
0.7905223369598389,
-0.30432581901550293,
0.3071024715900421,
-0.09396911412477493,
-0.08171522617340088,
0.07002914696931839,
-0.4025348722934723,
0.3916511535644531,
-0.44492095708847046,
-0.6008689403533936,
-0.7009884119033813,
0.40697821974754333,
0.8625575304031372,
-0.5165928602218628,
0.2385968416929245,
0.8153879642486572,
-0.2870213985443115,
-0.10483750700950623,
-0.9630688428878784,
-0.44505417346954346,
-0.43123990297317505,
0.15793031454086304,
-0.5085834264755249,
-0.718597948551178,
0.28151804208755493,
-0.31531015038490295,
-0.07484583556652069,
0.10490138828754425,
0.7085847854614258,
-0.5986279845237732,
1.426753044128418,
0.18136727809906006,
0.5420100092887878,
0.7193268537521362,
-0.4139794409275055,
0.330890953540802,
-0.897323489189148,
-0.3228747546672821,
0.01706012338399887,
-0.36798620223999023,
-0.2206617146730423,
-0.6104757785797119,
0.5570438504219055,
0.17680741846561432,
0.09372802823781967,
-0.11270341277122498,
-0.37300658226013184,
0.7990595102310181,
0.4448779225349426,
0.42264747619628906,
0.1968139410018921,
0.2981218993663788,
-0.23198862373828888,
0.3027368485927582,
-0.6450254321098328,
-0.44499310851097107,
0.6920737028121948,
0.04471045359969139,
0.9453813433647156,
-0.025584738701581955,
0.3365912139415741,
-0.10720542073249817,
0.35041743516921997,
-0.8652961850166321,
0.6768181324005127,
0.2633484899997711,
-0.5312012434005737,
-0.12783052027225494,
-0.26846417784690857,
-1.033553957939148,
0.35198748111724854,
-0.3953556418418884,
-0.7568984031677246,
0.3208983838558197,
0.5376066565513611,
-0.5301671624183655,
0.21129901707172394,
-0.9910475015640259,
0.7178829312324524,
-0.3399464190006256,
-0.4357448220252991,
-0.580460786819458,
-0.45878687500953674,
0.37611594796180725,
0.30333212018013,
0.20658183097839355,
0.05959869548678398,
0.1469159722328186,
0.23255851864814758,
-0.32885727286338806,
0.7440058588981628,
-0.0695393905043602,
-0.007131961174309254,
0.5227806568145752,
0.06840287148952484,
0.4241941273212433,
0.0024238249752670527,
0.20525099337100983,
-0.2243093103170395,
-0.10056968033313751,
-0.37915274500846863,
-0.9246694445610046,
0.6461465954780579,
-0.23281142115592957,
-0.7597094774246216,
-0.030800115317106247,
-0.6614794135093689,
-0.2673296630382538,
0.3256220519542694,
0.32311150431632996,
0.6601664423942566,
0.428806334733963,
0.3033931851387024,
0.7778254151344299,
0.016913214698433876,
0.4068995416164398,
0.03594932332634926,
-0.4318995773792267,
-0.5925619602203369,
0.7377487421035767,
-0.11007580161094666,
0.42523396015167236,
0.34562233090400696,
0.23865996301174164,
-0.5450380444526672,
-0.3351992070674896,
-0.7067221999168396,
0.08975298702716827,
-0.9937198758125305,
-0.15832209587097168,
-0.5104610919952393,
0.24017433822155,
-0.01369031798094511,
-0.28405919671058655,
-0.06949427723884583,
-0.20984457433223724,
-0.07249299436807632,
0.13293348252773285,
0.6599344611167908,
0.4529078006744385,
0.38607344031333923,
-0.1534799486398697,
-0.8168087601661682,
0.4377741813659668,
0.6113847494125366,
0.3326084017753601,
0.3407781720161438,
-0.17606747150421143,
0.03505713865160942,
0.24618321657180786,
-0.3615766167640686,
-0.6534571647644043,
-0.1377202421426773,
-0.3016255795955658,
0.3780553638935089,
0.5250505805015564,
-0.028837837278842926,
1.1802974939346313,
-0.32382330298423767,
0.7367691993713379,
0.5550015568733215,
-0.6273874044418335,
0.7716940641403198,
-0.42100390791893005,
0.6897380352020264,
0.3929409086704254,
0.181453675031662,
-0.2181377410888672,
-0.14767515659332275,
-0.5001670718193054,
-0.7289685010910034,
0.40981632471084595,
0.08978714793920517,
-0.1669682115316391,
-0.16286630928516388,
0.04109283164143562,
-0.042207829654216766,
0.03289486840367317,
-0.7295931577682495,
0.20771975815296173,
-0.260597288608551,
-0.027136271819472313,
0.5284493565559387,
-0.030935995280742645,
-0.1255309134721756,
-0.3141937553882599,
0.5105452537536621,
-0.4047935903072357,
0.4005364179611206,
0.6552786827087402,
-0.2241787314414978,
-0.13421322405338287,
0.3917505443096161,
0.8856322765350342,
0.7858783602714539,
0.04365451633930206,
0.2464243322610855,
0.13830068707466125,
-0.21728205680847168,
-0.06986940652132034,
-0.3259527385234833,
-0.021601269021630287,
-0.22975672781467438,
0.43432578444480896,
1.0867396593093872,
-0.18942761421203613,
-0.9358202815055847,
0.5332551002502441,
-0.3082294762134552,
-0.19943958520889282,
-0.12960030138492584,
-0.08964766561985016,
-0.040475212037563324,
0.4882245659828186,
0.30716636776924133,
0.38445889949798584,
-0.018519042059779167,
-0.6616116762161255,
-0.024082420393824577,
0.5481616854667664,
-0.24838125705718994,
0.07105759531259537,
0.28610825538635254,
0.12091729044914246,
0.04297121241688728,
0.7672514915466309,
-0.011535869911313057,
-0.503851056098938,
0.48775872588157654,
0.5258281826972961,
0.8723349571228027,
0.20562946796417236,
0.1352604627609253,
0.3832256495952606,
0.3219829499721527,
0.05489884689450264,
0.7202228307723999,
-0.29450148344039917,
-0.6334772109985352,
-0.7513635158538818,
-0.10707078874111176,
-0.20163992047309875,
0.14438463747501373,
-0.3773241639137268,
0.4283124804496765,
-0.6418330073356628,
-0.3596775233745575,
0.0395817831158638,
-0.7931119203567505,
-0.7201892733573914,
0.3542444407939911,
0.5025492906570435,
0.7613494992256165,
-0.21560551226139069,
0.5923209190368652,
0.6289652585983276,
-0.41004812717437744,
-0.9667144417762756,
0.04557771608233452,
-0.03321041911840439,
-0.812389075756073,
0.9050068259239197,
0.30959293246269226,
-0.67740398645401,
-0.016049185767769814,
-0.7415557503700256,
-0.5821899175643921,
1.0983083248138428,
0.4509609341621399,
-0.5473519563674927,
0.34072408080101013,
-0.2198987752199173,
0.3263782262802124,
-0.553930938243866,
0.5623499155044556,
-0.03992128372192383,
0.7233573794364929,
0.41371840238571167,
-0.7342011332511902,
0.17111200094223022,
-0.44300612807273865,
-0.034449126571416855,
0.25637656450271606,
-0.47691720724105835,
0.716015636920929,
-0.7117478847503662,
-0.0941467136144638,
-0.13108447194099426,
0.2354535013437271,
0.3506059944629669,
0.16353735327720642,
0.8607599139213562,
0.4292182922363281,
0.7252810001373291,
0.004585429560393095,
1.0695034265518188,
-0.005053473636507988,
0.11090145260095596,
0.9119810461997986,
-0.2794671356678009,
1.1250152587890625,
0.7826988697052002,
0.2373443841934204,
0.6814396977424622,
0.3909773826599121,
-0.030731769278645515,
0.3500378131866455,
-0.359144926071167,
-0.43222561478614807,
-0.5462016463279724,
-0.14004430174827576,
-0.30111435055732727,
0.4886232316493988,
0.5104975700378418,
-0.2942448854446411,
-0.20330965518951416,
0.2299433946609497,
-0.3297204375267029,
-0.333444744348526,
-0.474283903837204,
0.8507581353187561,
-0.11382158100605011,
-1.0923806428909302,
0.9649654626846313,
-0.4970567226409912,
0.2499009072780609,
-0.421882301568985,
-0.319487988948822,
0.2405151128768921,
0.21131522953510284,
-0.20651046931743622,
-1.02535879611969,
-0.1772916615009308,
0.043914929032325745,
-0.31527236104011536,
-0.39364632964134216,
0.5856172442436218,
-0.584342360496521,
-0.4820762872695923,
0.07687000930309296,
0.30618470907211304,
-0.039052173495292664,
-0.30259454250335693,
-0.8701593279838562,
0.10735749453306198,
0.11768875271081924,
-0.22451142966747284,
-0.0710754245519638,
0.6949027180671692,
-0.4331265687942505,
1.0063844919204712,
1.0544744729995728,
-0.3475044071674347,
0.0010116742923855782,
0.28638726472854614,
0.8495465517044067,
-0.6284009218215942,
-0.3988170921802521,
-1.0569499731063843,
0.793336033821106,
-0.22375965118408203,
-0.19624577462673187,
0.43373802304267883,
0.038459740579128265,
0.7156125903129578,
-0.49170321226119995,
0.7216119170188904,
-0.05353361368179321,
-0.05933121591806412,
-0.8138442039489746,
0.4169105887413025,
-0.7840473651885986,
0.17898404598236084,
-0.24502332508563995,
-0.768444836139679,
-0.2745569348335266,
0.760487973690033,
-0.4547218978404999,
-0.02468070201575756,
1.086507797241211,
0.866424560546875,
-0.00281354459002614,
0.35587286949157715,
0.2798802852630615,
0.1341715157032013,
0.288562148809433,
0.2413875311613083,
1.1248698234558105,
0.0033404568675905466,
0.4290182292461395,
-0.14511583745479584,
-0.4249522387981415,
-0.24959583580493927,
-1.1686877012252808,
-0.8206796050071716,
-0.578295886516571,
-0.3525558114051819,
-0.130956768989563,
-0.3072303831577301,
1.2447636127471924,
0.7404190897941589,
-0.5221863985061646,
0.020287957042455673,
-0.03914535045623779,
-0.0007628711173310876,
-0.3127819299697876,
-0.26405876874923706,
0.20792704820632935,
-0.2559443712234497,
-0.3534252643585205,
0.21697953343391418,
0.6875295639038086,
0.039973072707653046,
-0.24958232045173645,
0.11257913708686829,
-0.5660247206687927,
0.11845076829195023,
1.0261170864105225,
-0.07651345431804657,
-1.1580374240875244,
-0.2186601459980011,
0.011508995667099953,
0.10908681154251099,
0.13238760828971863,
0.8918168544769287,
-0.7544106245040894,
0.9867019653320312,
0.5549250841140747,
0.26526278257369995,
0.4529411494731903,
-0.10834458470344543,
0.488744854927063,
-0.42638930678367615,
0.28836771845817566,
0.19716425240039825,
0.6531897187232971,
0.19727428257465363,
-0.4140048623085022,
0.11709669232368469,
0.16034556925296783,
-0.27627795934677124,
-0.6763995885848999,
0.5183525085449219,
-1.288392424583435,
-0.3591509759426117,
0.9329929351806641,
-0.14968055486679077,
-0.5549520254135132,
0.0106092793866992,
-0.9274146556854248,
-0.1770620048046112,
-0.41767728328704834,
0.7645903825759888,
0.829692006111145,
-0.27711576223373413,
-0.8357107043266296,
-0.3139195144176483,
0.13782493770122528,
0.5482202172279358,
-1.021965503692627,
0.2472936511039734,
0.5479288101196289,
-0.12979447841644287,
0.3433586061000824,
0.39218926429748535,
-0.13858945667743683,
0.8282998204231262,
-0.03223631903529167,
0.034222815185785294,
-0.10368557274341583,
-0.3977928161621094,
0.16017957031726837,
-0.03496498242020607,
0.00034428894286975265,
-0.09085874259471893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13868v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13868v1
|
Automatically Identifying Local and Global Circuits with Linear Computation Graphs
| 2024-05-22T17:50:04 | 2024-05-22T17:50:04 |
Xuyang Ge, Fukang Zhu, Wentao Shu, Junxuan Wang, Zhengfu He, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Circuit analysis of any certain model behavior is a central task in
mechanistic interpretability. We introduce our circuit discovery pipeline with
sparse autoencoders (SAEs) and a variant called skip SAEs. With these two
modules inserted into the model, the model's computation graph with respect to
OV and MLP circuits becomes strictly linear. Our methods do not require linear
approximation to compute the causal effect of each node. This fine-grained
graph enables identifying both end-to-end and local circuits accounting for
either logits or intermediate features. We can scalably apply this pipeline
with a technique called Hierarchical Attribution. We analyze three kind of
circuits in GPT2-Small, namely bracket, induction and Indirect Object
Identification circuits. Our results reveal new findings underlying existing
discoveries.
|
[
-0.307185560464859,
-0.673380434513092,
0.8217675685882568,
-0.1844022423028946,
0.1422269493341446,
0.005393921863287687,
0.2870270311832428,
-0.4519856572151184,
0.3055889904499054,
0.13338226079940796,
-0.7508809566497803,
0.012114041484892368,
-0.638972818851471,
-0.24223117530345917,
-0.6707103848457336,
0.7119887471199036,
-0.3094673156738281,
-0.1981775313615799,
0.04238205775618553,
-0.06354618817567825,
-0.37033963203430176,
-0.48187345266342163,
-0.5864192247390747,
-0.4586009085178375,
0.7106341123580933,
-0.09278035908937454,
0.5915679335594177,
0.8798737525939941,
0.20983624458312988,
0.30949485301971436,
-0.03845444694161415,
-0.08427340537309647,
-0.1574638932943344,
-0.2054823786020279,
-0.36476781964302063,
-0.1752976030111313,
-0.35474997758865356,
-0.19664600491523743,
0.4387807548046112,
0.8459619879722595,
0.27900588512420654,
0.3635578155517578,
0.10539933294057846,
0.4826849400997162,
-0.7703381776809692,
0.3171881437301636,
-0.6540635228157043,
0.1632900834083557,
-0.1892029494047165,
-0.4142700731754303,
-0.4475044310092926,
-0.08756065368652344,
-0.1881527155637741,
-0.39868050813674927,
0.5945277810096741,
-0.004002948757261038,
0.8505546450614929,
0.2764874994754791,
-0.6049720048904419,
-0.6406137347221375,
-0.9060852527618408,
0.5470247864723206,
-0.16736388206481934,
0.3515528738498688,
0.10449212044477463,
0.4076269567012787,
-0.12139400839805603,
-1.0561273097991943,
-0.09307745844125748,
-0.06568145006895065,
-0.564360499382019,
-0.23673292994499207,
-0.3742035925388336,
0.2347245216369629,
0.3082459568977356,
0.44275838136672974,
-0.5888871550559998,
0.05844395235180855,
-0.5370050072669983,
-0.6082422137260437,
0.3156305253505707,
0.3535306751728058,
0.2973032295703888,
-0.4354911744594574,
-0.11890121549367905,
0.46055302023887634,
-0.7233055233955383,
-0.04030754417181015,
0.3478650450706482,
0.21145831048488617,
0.09791523963212967,
0.4468529224395752,
0.015848364681005478,
0.5611543655395508,
0.002220994560047984,
0.3456651270389557,
0.014321092516183853,
-0.6643555760383606,
-0.4285709261894226,
-0.06052127480506897,
0.7733823657035828,
-0.21493887901306152,
0.22973328828811646,
-0.1717996746301651,
-0.1356574147939682,
-0.11820506304502487,
0.1608487069606781,
-0.716167688369751,
-0.6279473304748535,
-0.07505018264055252,
-0.8063594102859497,
-0.26577168703079224,
-0.04208036884665489,
-0.5556259751319885,
-0.3646106719970703,
-0.34808993339538574,
0.5195280909538269,
0.07975241541862488,
-0.06384872645139694,
-0.1768137812614441,
-0.15125662088394165,
0.09962408244609833,
-0.005092805717140436,
-1.2550318241119385,
0.7670121192932129,
0.34259840846061707,
1.1387704610824585,
0.08351830393075943,
-0.1505674421787262,
-0.7109623551368713,
0.12116638571023941,
-0.2644929885864258,
0.629601776599884,
-0.3811919689178467,
-0.06590069085359573,
-0.24564579129219055,
0.3823324143886566,
-0.11542031168937683,
-0.47819840908050537,
0.34081587195396423,
-0.5269655585289001,
-0.17554208636283875,
-0.4856073558330536,
-0.19493478536605835,
0.08778795599937439,
-0.45375996828079224,
-0.6510969996452332,
1.0066778659820557,
0.2445879578590393,
-0.7308011054992676,
0.2389144003391266,
-0.7021302580833435,
-0.5113809108734131,
-0.4991878569126129,
-0.37904092669487,
-0.2717081308364868,
0.20103807747364044,
0.3362124562263489,
0.3657476007938385,
-0.24647371470928192,
0.10057947784662247,
-0.37215137481689453,
-0.43375343084335327,
-0.1650633066892624,
-0.6257003545761108,
0.8772274255752563,
0.38416576385498047,
-0.2941755950450897,
0.34563547372817993,
-0.8386054039001465,
-0.1109829843044281,
0.09635502099990845,
0.4141829311847687,
-0.2323823869228363,
0.32559487223625183,
-0.15175369381904602,
0.4007117748260498,
0.030735336244106293,
-0.36577048897743225,
0.2154897153377533,
-0.20139886438846588,
1.0158839225769043,
0.9005596041679382,
0.3111419379711151,
0.5970324277877808,
0.20884761214256287,
0.2139986753463745,
-0.15401974320411682,
0.38187217712402344,
-0.3027159571647644,
-0.5887172222137451,
-0.7874917387962341,
-0.2358866184949875,
0.24112296104431152,
0.5567663908004761,
-0.33931484818458557,
0.5965988636016846,
0.10245928168296814,
-0.1135624498128891,
-0.10182001441717148,
0.018867511302232742,
0.13772223889827728,
0.3462793231010437,
0.42881229519844055,
-0.32639870047569275,
-0.5218038558959961,
-1.018198013305664,
-0.15850485861301422,
-0.07243765890598297,
-0.5888319611549377,
0.3125436007976532,
0.577576220035553,
-0.26008957624435425,
0.9526174664497375,
-0.5997274518013,
-0.20843900740146637,
0.10810449719429016,
0.38140609860420227,
0.2254510372877121,
0.5922867059707642,
0.5028447508811951,
-0.2054383009672165,
-0.08569616824388504,
0.01756528578698635,
-0.9218012690544128,
-0.1625068187713623,
-0.27971351146698,
-0.0659947618842125,
-0.35088154673576355,
0.7897555828094482,
-0.39966878294944763,
0.6720268130302429,
-0.09408022463321686,
-0.11925662308931351,
0.31997793912887573,
-0.19865186512470245,
0.0625474825501442,
-0.4128847122192383,
-0.04011155664920807,
-0.009295282885432243,
-0.15188804268836975,
-0.4631434679031372,
-0.15248924493789673,
0.07594577223062515,
0.014471504837274551,
0.00004708973574452102,
0.5399320125579834,
-0.5740032196044922,
-0.72934490442276,
0.022649232298135757,
-0.12485732138156891,
-0.06368623673915863,
0.6147481799125671,
-0.20399968326091766,
0.7136061191558838,
0.648095428943634,
-0.4350040555000305,
0.31738778948783875,
-0.20963618159294128,
-0.17407825589179993,
0.04302585870027542,
-0.7759897112846375,
0.19547957181930542,
-0.24218574166297913,
0.10342461615800858,
-1.0727958679199219,
-0.38925546407699585,
0.4531046748161316,
-0.28104209899902344,
0.2858995497226715,
-0.6073815822601318,
-0.6307719349861145,
-0.5522133708000183,
-0.16871492564678192,
0.5631005764007568,
0.48655086755752563,
-0.7322985529899597,
0.6780412793159485,
0.1369495838880539,
-0.1987728327512741,
-0.22172872722148895,
-0.5483872294425964,
-0.30524519085884094,
0.062469251453876495,
-0.610379695892334,
-0.13401517271995544,
0.16968636214733124,
-0.1915818154811859,
-0.05885390564799309,
-0.21906355023384094,
-0.4879525303840637,
0.0503135621547699,
0.36808499693870544,
0.2815607786178589,
-0.2912527918815613,
0.12202680855989456,
0.25188085436820984,
-0.40831777453422546,
0.36828505992889404,
-0.5759643316268921,
0.43294334411621094,
-0.4351378381252289,
-0.6760870218276978,
-0.6407299041748047,
0.2972003221511841,
0.4877413809299469,
-0.1096247062087059,
0.11999843269586563,
0.5534979104995728,
-0.6735526323318481,
0.06106511130928993,
-0.08927888423204422,
-0.1751621812582016,
-0.5619633793830872,
0.32393425703048706,
-0.3972252309322357,
-0.5841144919395447,
0.7838171720504761,
-0.11330538243055344,
-0.3726962208747864,
0.8363770842552185,
0.5889313817024231,
0.1616509109735489,
1.1827521324157715,
0.43861156702041626,
-0.3227737843990326,
0.31651532649993896,
-0.3855913579463959,
0.5761553645133972,
-0.5875310897827148,
-0.1905374974012375,
-0.40569019317626953,
-0.3447895646095276,
-0.4232383370399475,
-0.42116355895996094,
0.4733135998249054,
0.2215200811624527,
-0.5223121643066406,
0.1442330926656723,
-0.6660046577453613,
0.7386295199394226,
0.26362329721450806,
-0.11524604260921478,
0.24734047055244446,
0.2563544809818268,
-0.2843695282936096,
-0.11903539299964905,
-0.8061628341674805,
-0.1890874207019806,
0.8683916330337524,
0.485795795917511,
0.6792994737625122,
-0.31266117095947266,
0.48080432415008545,
0.4999551475048065,
0.2501367926597595,
-0.7299951314926147,
0.20468291640281677,
0.07553129643201828,
-0.5819458365440369,
-0.10565066337585449,
-0.36846357583999634,
-0.842625081539154,
-0.0203867070376873,
0.12965871393680573,
-1.2452938556671143,
0.5527688264846802,
0.3111630082130432,
-0.48479440808296204,
0.47917479276657104,
-0.8882352709770203,
1.0116164684295654,
-0.08148737996816635,
-0.4283973276615143,
-0.041065894067287445,
-0.6208087801933289,
0.5435687303543091,
0.21307556331157684,
0.297048419713974,
0.3210005462169647,
0.38434112071990967,
0.3784194588661194,
-0.6673405170440674,
0.7600651383399963,
-0.22533144056797028,
0.12982387840747833,
0.6392099857330322,
0.22838914394378662,
0.7005676031112671,
0.1170915737748146,
0.22136232256889343,
0.11601877957582474,
-0.15051613748073578,
-0.49803343415260315,
-0.7840087413787842,
0.9891039729118347,
-0.6085875034332275,
-0.014597896486520767,
-0.41743218898773193,
-0.4262593388557434,
0.050288476049900055,
0.19726130366325378,
0.5014172196388245,
0.7652788758277893,
0.1933608502149582,
-0.33512160181999207,
0.5662065744400024,
0.08488820493221283,
0.33023861050605774,
-0.12708695232868195,
-0.18260136246681213,
-0.12076209485530853,
1.1568964719772339,
0.2119000405073166,
0.22651365399360657,
-0.060568347573280334,
-0.026074327528476715,
-0.2184949666261673,
-0.4643867313861847,
-0.5949760675430298,
0.1138283759355545,
-0.9348589777946472,
0.027303973212838173,
-0.4416629672050476,
-0.512384295463562,
0.013935700990259647,
-0.4481675624847412,
-0.5063366293907166,
-0.6264188885688782,
-0.4243257939815521,
-0.09752068668603897,
0.037851542234420776,
1.1288141012191772,
-0.23945249617099762,
0.20188072323799133,
-0.49785152077674866,
0.5000176429748535,
0.5250425934791565,
0.4382838308811188,
0.3126259744167328,
-0.31903141736984253,
-0.14678210020065308,
-0.2538135051727295,
-0.3621693551540375,
-0.6387715339660645,
-0.004328562878072262,
-0.07097035646438599,
0.4632946252822876,
0.5739078521728516,
-0.2986350953578949,
0.916716456413269,
-0.501684308052063,
0.6094301342964172,
0.24463723599910736,
-1.210216760635376,
0.6445870399475098,
-0.259198397397995,
-0.24857494235038757,
0.16199630498886108,
0.3298272490501404,
-0.07163058966398239,
-0.09145087003707886,
-0.7318621873855591,
-0.9542126059532166,
0.384111225605011,
0.5645586848258972,
-0.24552695453166962,
-0.024245280772447586,
0.7204669117927551,
-0.1053914874792099,
-0.0701616033911705,
-0.7606179714202881,
-0.47455450892448425,
-0.15409670770168304,
-0.12239336967468262,
0.3414001166820526,
-0.13753511011600494,
-0.020107327029109,
-0.38307908177375793,
0.26231008768081665,
-0.06993120908737183,
0.6875479221343994,
0.32056915760040283,
-0.06472744047641754,
-0.33148935437202454,
0.03799831494688988,
0.06373881548643112,
0.6028964519500732,
-0.36986541748046875,
0.40648165345191956,
0.10800078511238098,
-0.11803952604532242,
0.16476598381996155,
0.07450106739997864,
-0.3223370611667633,
0.1210135668516159,
0.6841222047805786,
0.666195273399353,
0.09580858051776886,
-0.23071609437465668,
0.46210992336273193,
0.06281574070453644,
-0.20278775691986084,
-0.3189307749271393,
0.20851340889930725,
-0.27824005484580994,
0.33184975385665894,
0.24102407693862915,
0.48705431818962097,
0.7180102467536926,
-0.6093229055404663,
0.4120437204837799,
0.5479214191436768,
-0.6356510519981384,
-0.44863221049308777,
0.9037014245986938,
-0.09258604049682617,
-0.0665067806839943,
0.5476007461547852,
-0.44647419452667236,
-0.2375248223543167,
0.8095906972885132,
0.2608383595943451,
0.9641396403312683,
0.01842891052365303,
-0.04610452800989151,
0.6016851663589478,
0.6301602125167847,
0.1609870046377182,
-0.22353734076023102,
-0.20443835854530334,
-0.28540095686912537,
-0.6034520864486694,
-0.44207167625427246,
0.013872889801859856,
0.19850771129131317,
-1.0080442428588867,
0.3417004346847534,
-0.7042478919029236,
0.3206288516521454,
0.5285359025001526,
-0.19413067400455475,
-0.4608827233314514,
0.09089863300323486,
0.21374723315238953,
0.626434326171875,
-1.270890474319458,
1.014998435974121,
0.03448932245373726,
-0.28356486558914185,
-0.5926233530044556,
-0.11293531209230423,
0.2743851840496063,
-0.7026485204696655,
0.7882406711578369,
0.04824153333902359,
-0.3954523801803589,
-0.015685830265283585,
-0.49832481145858765,
-0.9643453359603882,
1.2174489498138428,
0.08899267017841339,
-0.32859593629837036,
-0.06548788398504257,
-0.2826769948005676,
0.3743029534816742,
-0.41714900732040405,
0.6428019404411316,
0.8749001622200012,
0.27311164140701294,
0.37669408321380615,
-0.8667038679122925,
0.08605960756540298,
-0.2925635278224945,
-0.0026760597247630358,
0.5659140944480896,
-0.19754381477832794,
1.0119454860687256,
-0.27472686767578125,
-0.15292279422283173,
0.21454307436943054,
0.5422844886779785,
-0.037759583443403244,
0.5931328535079956,
0.4809552729129791,
-0.10179901123046875,
0.9373771548271179,
-0.051578644663095474,
0.9594415426254272,
-0.09531763941049576,
0.7131250500679016,
1.1452478170394897,
-0.17275281250476837,
0.361664354801178,
0.33457526564598083,
-0.416293203830719,
0.5697271227836609,
0.638885498046875,
-0.1588946431875229,
0.5745531320571899,
0.47233104705810547,
-0.0017053523333743215,
-0.1504964977502823,
0.26713690161705017,
-0.2639990448951721,
-0.009307339787483215,
0.5629256367683411,
-0.7065122127532959,
-0.37402525544166565,
-0.24700307846069336,
-0.12155121564865112,
-0.4238220751285553,
-0.5591119527816772,
0.274839848279953,
-0.19421274960041046,
-0.17178742587566376,
0.7499988675117493,
0.009415718726813793,
0.12390317767858505,
-0.6730899810791016,
-0.14934243261814117,
0.009155666455626488,
0.1949327439069748,
-0.39879506826400757,
-0.47061726450920105,
0.7606900334358215,
-0.2816893756389618,
-0.44449523091316223,
-0.07997211068868637,
1.1064584255218506,
0.03631740063428879,
-0.5604068040847778,
0.4684283435344696,
0.3382461965084076,
0.11904870718717575,
-0.1042722687125206,
-0.3185901641845703,
-0.16615861654281616,
0.031224101781845093,
-0.16715358197689056,
0.3461773991584778,
0.5040524005889893,
-0.35436514019966125,
0.6120474338531494,
0.5078088045120239,
-0.14883774518966675,
0.2757095992565155,
0.06454426050186157,
1.0820069313049316,
-0.7637485861778259,
-0.18311811983585358,
-0.7690570950508118,
0.3749603033065796,
-0.1228276938199997,
-0.08484355360269547,
0.5628324747085571,
0.6564299464225769,
0.5215811729431152,
0.00842272024601698,
0.9214983582496643,
-0.20868493616580963,
0.19658827781677246,
-0.6632548570632935,
0.16457895934581757,
-0.4282575249671936,
0.5723564028739929,
-0.236220583319664,
-0.6174216866493225,
-0.27351099252700806,
0.7940776348114014,
-0.2591599225997925,
-0.11275213211774826,
0.9245991706848145,
0.8394891023635864,
-0.6580444574356079,
0.09843362122774124,
-0.04648212343454361,
0.5769566893577576,
0.24650800228118896,
0.6567528247833252,
0.7189934253692627,
-0.6340612173080444,
0.4818418323993683,
-0.16474491357803345,
-0.4161175489425659,
0.0271416325122118,
-0.8223865628242493,
-0.8536599278450012,
-0.39167240262031555,
-0.21095703542232513,
-0.3509315252304077,
-0.1474473774433136,
0.6851392984390259,
0.7265596389770508,
-0.9827584624290466,
-0.21617072820663452,
-0.6828613877296448,
0.3509379029273987,
-0.2335454672574997,
-0.18025074899196625,
0.6272868514060974,
-0.5100727677345276,
-0.28108346462249756,
0.36520323157310486,
0.6449989080429077,
-0.15965141355991364,
-0.3349679410457611,
-0.12678492069244385,
-0.01650172658264637,
0.022991903126239777,
0.6403107643127441,
0.46141159534454346,
-0.6924517154693604,
-0.4016989469528198,
-0.11278821527957916,
0.26603999733924866,
0.07923855632543564,
1.3167060613632202,
-0.8002036809921265,
0.47100698947906494,
0.30756059288978577,
0.12424653023481369,
0.7363453507423401,
-0.24777700006961823,
0.43225163221359253,
-0.7591966986656189,
0.45504772663116455,
-0.11058156937360764,
0.5829641819000244,
-0.0693662092089653,
-0.43647903203964233,
0.6117110848426819,
0.7026952505111694,
-0.7822741270065308,
-0.6545619964599609,
0.4664536714553833,
-0.8256207704544067,
-0.17957359552383423,
0.8616325855255127,
-0.10480672121047974,
-0.06179894506931305,
-0.5492127537727356,
-0.0024560538586229086,
0.008451757952570915,
0.051600247621536255,
0.4828828275203705,
0.5722081065177917,
-0.6062537431716919,
-0.04397798702120781,
-0.958971381187439,
0.4129124879837036,
-0.05596611648797989,
-0.5714802145957947,
0.17643620073795319,
0.5804904103279114,
0.30452239513397217,
0.3772710859775543,
0.7913429141044617,
-0.003347752382978797,
0.18152467906475067,
0.1745792180299759,
-0.23535063862800598,
0.04789184778928757,
-0.6159650087356567,
-0.2757779657840729,
0.06887336820363998,
-0.046078868210315704,
-0.11767695844173431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13845v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13845v2
|
Semantic Density: Uncertainty Quantification in Semantic Space for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-22T17:13:49 | 2024-05-25T07:20:46 |
Xin Qiu, Risto Miikkulainen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the widespread application of Large Language Models (LLMs) to various
domains, concerns regarding the trustworthiness of LLMs in safety-critical
scenarios have been raised, due to their unpredictable tendency to hallucinate
and generate misinformation. Existing LLMs do not have an inherent
functionality to provide the users with an uncertainty metric for each response
it generates, making it difficult to evaluate trustworthiness. Although a
number of works aim to develop uncertainty quantification methods for LLMs,
they have fundamental limitations, such as being restricted to classification
tasks, requiring additional training and data, considering only lexical instead
of semantic information, and being prompt-wise but not response-wise. A new
framework is proposed in this paper to address these issues. Semantic density
extracts uncertainty information for each response from a probability
distribution perspective in semantic space. It has no restriction on task types
and is "off-the-shelf" for new models and tasks. Experiments on seven
state-of-the-art LLMs, including the latest Llama 3 and Mixtral-8x22B models,
on four free-form question-answering benchmarks demonstrate the superior
performance and robustness of semantic density compared to prior approaches.
|
[
-0.35363495349884033,
-0.9779435396194458,
0.9339549541473389,
0.2934039235115051,
-0.2250649333000183,
-0.20416393876075745,
-0.17049342393875122,
-0.5347228646278381,
0.23964062333106995,
0.5582032799720764,
-0.34552302956581116,
-0.6288048028945923,
-0.9692681431770325,
-0.050050847232341766,
-0.7277804017066956,
0.46316227316856384,
-0.11206670850515366,
-0.08357717096805573,
-0.42535117268562317,
-0.0947226881980896,
-0.13216941058635712,
-0.5856186151504517,
-0.3694083094596863,
0.08905032277107239,
0.46967363357543945,
0.18406732380390167,
0.9895897507667542,
0.35386985540390015,
0.6110305786132812,
0.22919055819511414,
-0.11792010813951492,
-0.10506391525268555,
-0.1569131314754486,
0.20810721814632416,
0.05525655299425125,
-0.25747159123420715,
-0.3944633901119232,
-0.2982517182826996,
0.7868301272392273,
0.9255558252334595,
-0.22508971393108368,
-0.19426359236240387,
-0.16490402817726135,
0.24640463292598724,
-0.8557319045066833,
0.12905967235565186,
-0.7613032460212708,
0.02392706461250782,
0.03868810087442398,
-0.04068632051348686,
-0.17670507729053497,
-0.2640497386455536,
0.39839792251586914,
-0.7502649426460266,
-0.041840191930532455,
0.19273491203784943,
0.5826975703239441,
0.471365749835968,
-0.4376986026763916,
-0.3237974941730499,
-0.7355364561080933,
0.7383275628089905,
-0.6156326532363892,
0.6687034964561462,
0.570936918258667,
0.16113582253456116,
-0.2832399606704712,
-0.37633180618286133,
-0.7111071348190308,
-0.23531846702098846,
0.3380691111087799,
-0.06241782382130623,
0.08082549273967743,
0.05638110637664795,
-0.15503311157226562,
0.13969482481479645,
-0.5166518688201904,
0.320500910282135,
0.13613371551036835,
-0.3942956328392029,
0.5484620928764343,
0.14546464383602142,
0.1694069653749466,
-0.19617460668087006,
-0.4525439739227295,
-0.37480276823043823,
-0.5448412895202637,
-0.266833633184433,
0.3356805741786957,
-0.022527558729052544,
-0.07178447395563126,
0.8985399007797241,
-0.46654149889945984,
0.6090415716171265,
-0.4371812045574188,
-0.2771858870983124,
0.12904559075832367,
-0.19732262194156647,
-0.13732588291168213,
-0.05617094039916992,
0.762872040271759,
0.3093099594116211,
0.15318724513053894,
-0.20869942009449005,
-0.187285378575325,
0.0496748611330986,
0.08466287702322006,
-0.5840898752212524,
0.11353711038827896,
0.6150582432746887,
-0.03208225592970848,
-0.36059683561325073,
-0.0395345538854599,
-0.6300366520881653,
-0.5718598961830139,
0.049334391951560974,
0.5714576840400696,
-0.6480733156204224,
-0.5175010561943054,
0.5335026383399963,
-0.017581839114427567,
0.205452099442482,
0.38212257623672485,
-0.7378798723220825,
0.28694164752960205,
0.5617262721061707,
0.5358440279960632,
-0.49689972400665283,
-0.24427929520606995,
-0.14531949162483215,
0.3272910416126251,
-0.4091699719429016,
0.7460288405418396,
-0.46108829975128174,
-0.41078317165374756,
0.08073337376117706,
-0.221402108669281,
0.17169825732707977,
-0.4636431932449341,
0.4309239089488983,
-0.5874505639076233,
-0.24413496255874634,
0.006423211190849543,
-0.755428671836853,
0.08369556814432144,
0.2707354426383972,
-0.6517032384872437,
1.0523416996002197,
0.3657417893409729,
-0.6740136742591858,
0.568247377872467,
-0.15880833566188812,
-0.195939838886261,
0.20692236721515656,
-0.12271635234355927,
-0.1779124140739441,
0.14183056354522705,
-0.10838978737592697,
0.6386556029319763,
-0.199777290225029,
0.35031017661094666,
-0.6953758001327515,
-0.0705738514661789,
0.5950011014938354,
-0.4068167805671692,
0.369793176651001,
0.3701271116733551,
0.037724077701568604,
0.018644150346517563,
-0.9855814576148987,
0.20371593534946442,
-0.004656802397221327,
-0.1433255523443222,
-0.5060696005821228,
0.11609264463186264,
-0.0714186280965805,
0.2260751873254776,
0.5202058553695679,
-0.599956214427948,
-0.5116921663284302,
-0.524116039276123,
0.1683090329170227,
0.5270055532455444,
0.05011077970266342,
0.5898787975311279,
-0.1567121148109436,
0.26049160957336426,
0.34624701738357544,
0.22512401640415192,
0.6396765112876892,
-0.5456351637840271,
-0.5303601026535034,
-0.15601883828639984,
-0.006410859525203705,
0.668545663356781,
-0.526275098323822,
0.8534170985221863,
-0.3595563471317291,
-0.43979859352111816,
-0.2090914100408554,
0.18668949604034424,
0.03310982882976532,
0.3198094069957733,
0.1553853303194046,
-0.09702743589878082,
-0.32378628849983215,
-0.6210429072380066,
0.1413031369447708,
-0.35558265447616577,
-0.08702018111944199,
0.13513325154781342,
0.4635237455368042,
-0.3086746335029602,
1.0428886413574219,
-0.5242173075675964,
-0.02972300723195076,
-0.2274274230003357,
-0.24573765695095062,
-0.3445585072040558,
0.2908685505390167,
0.16521169245243073,
-0.8945603966712952,
-0.02082415483891964,
-0.10867899656295776,
-0.71756911277771,
0.12969602644443512,
0.31235551834106445,
-0.10848625004291534,
0.3492543697357178,
0.3016870617866516,
-1.089858055114746,
0.3613356053829193,
0.6862004399299622,
-0.16713090240955353,
0.35356664657592773,
-0.29407766461372375,
-0.16461102664470673,
-1.1669986248016357,
-0.21925140917301178,
-0.04901353269815445,
0.07029334455728531,
-0.4529648721218109,
0.08580341935157776,
0.04240378364920616,
0.002829010831192136,
-0.6121188402175903,
0.72939133644104,
-0.008331998251378536,
-0.306838721036911,
-0.11120976507663727,
0.5167648196220398,
0.0010752654634416103,
-0.05790315568447113,
0.26425662636756897,
0.4409731924533844,
0.5841148495674133,
-0.7189652323722839,
0.3908653259277344,
0.2701358199119568,
-0.5919910073280334,
0.4452909231185913,
-0.5908550024032593,
-0.3715944290161133,
-0.09646333009004593,
0.16220948100090027,
-0.9225472211837769,
-0.6042892336845398,
0.07947906106710434,
-0.4338652491569519,
0.010470923036336899,
0.2304385006427765,
-0.7396599650382996,
-0.15547606348991394,
-0.13003259897232056,
0.39452025294303894,
0.5093493461608887,
-0.00006752680928912014,
0.41681233048439026,
0.4946330487728119,
-0.03601738065481186,
-0.5658940076828003,
-0.6712594628334045,
-0.12194018810987473,
-0.390636682510376,
-0.9011948704719543,
0.03028411976993084,
-0.1849355697631836,
-0.6472885012626648,
0.06638200581073761,
-0.34363994002342224,
-0.3837296962738037,
0.5608994960784912,
0.1723705530166626,
0.13668915629386902,
0.06351680308580399,
0.34852758049964905,
0.11702985316514969,
-0.13639579713344574,
0.14906568825244904,
-0.35439184308052063,
0.47719377279281616,
0.06288814544677734,
-0.48441967368125916,
-0.12024326622486115,
0.41064453125,
0.3286116421222687,
0.02708829753100872,
0.879223108291626,
0.6085920929908752,
-0.5856558680534363,
-0.36076635122299194,
-0.5488782525062561,
-0.1805994063615799,
-0.44794610142707825,
0.5355849862098694,
-0.28735390305519104,
-1.273358941078186,
0.5656970739364624,
0.12478909641504288,
-0.3096259534358978,
0.533082127571106,
0.6396700143814087,
-0.16183680295944214,
0.7141513228416443,
0.5874223113059998,
0.16808222234249115,
0.08999016880989075,
0.21812704205513,
0.36300936341285706,
-0.4129704236984253,
-0.23081918060779572,
-0.6070168614387512,
0.22422191500663757,
-0.48823246359825134,
-0.5599428415298462,
0.48719659447669983,
0.08716671168804169,
-0.06996092945337296,
0.0963187888264656,
-0.25061047077178955,
0.1850273758172989,
0.10606471449136734,
-0.04034225270152092,
0.2906654477119446,
0.0644628256559372,
0.10008890926837921,
0.1676311194896698,
-0.40078413486480713,
-0.5051442384719849,
0.8969558477401733,
0.3816143870353699,
0.9473649859428406,
0.259380966424942,
0.6295108199119568,
-0.01015293225646019,
-0.18962764739990234,
-0.7644003033638,
0.6930118799209595,
0.027934052050113678,
-0.5790818929672241,
-0.783414900302887,
-0.6203903555870056,
-0.8748131990432739,
0.23187457025051117,
-0.3288348913192749,
-0.8164896965026855,
-0.01466040313243866,
-0.1480809450149536,
-0.4506949484348297,
0.16569893062114716,
-0.7062535881996155,
0.5590618252754211,
-0.09366942197084427,
0.09954433143138885,
-0.08575079590082169,
-0.7505128979682922,
0.26316508650779724,
-0.39756274223327637,
0.20978643000125885,
-0.5246522426605225,
-0.40190649032592773,
0.5344072580337524,
-0.4061830937862396,
0.8535051941871643,
-0.05405660346150398,
-0.5572783946990967,
0.4740335941314697,
0.2756718695163727,
0.650650143623352,
0.24105775356292725,
-0.0261096078902483,
0.07861553132534027,
0.3935861587524414,
-0.2474476546049118,
-0.6138857007026672,
0.840418815612793,
-0.8824545741081238,
-0.4808410108089447,
-0.24132095277309418,
-0.9368216395378113,
-0.7269064784049988,
0.1531764417886734,
0.3400811553001404,
0.26972493529319763,
-0.04520292207598686,
0.15639643371105194,
1.0940816402435303,
-0.45798686146736145,
0.22349883615970612,
0.27457576990127563,
0.09374911338090897,
-0.18380625545978546,
0.7268341779708862,
0.21064651012420654,
0.42010021209716797,
0.6749289631843567,
0.20937791466712952,
-0.5756326913833618,
-0.7917400598526001,
0.03194328024983406,
-0.04597504064440727,
-0.9326562285423279,
0.0003368763136677444,
-0.8662180304527283,
-0.358257532119751,
-0.5291102528572083,
-0.1672053039073944,
-0.3510988652706146,
-0.7744476795196533,
-0.19196142256259918,
-0.29847535490989685,
0.6153329014778137,
0.5969083309173584,
0.18650515377521515,
0.3308376371860504,
-0.6335058212280273,
0.08292447030544281,
0.20164556801319122,
0.6294710636138916,
-0.2856563329696655,
-0.2633965015411377,
-0.07416858524084091,
0.046394433826208115,
0.1498440057039261,
-0.6652365326881409,
0.38063669204711914,
-0.07738695293664932,
0.5344271659851074,
0.12339392304420471,
0.3692079782485962,
0.37816107273101807,
-0.08397848159074783,
0.7906712293624878,
0.08671369403600693,
-0.7897019982337952,
0.3612614572048187,
-0.3096565902233124,
-0.05577066168189049,
0.4503958523273468,
0.4159420430660248,
-0.20038212835788727,
-0.6324860453605652,
-0.6321684718132019,
-0.8635789752006531,
0.21966436505317688,
0.1794365793466568,
0.23259608447551727,
-0.2874494194984436,
0.4022793769836426,
0.10676579922437668,
0.23346726596355438,
-0.4595993459224701,
0.04277690500020981,
-0.11153499037027359,
-0.5103167295455933,
-0.16443198919296265,
-0.4922129809856415,
-0.05888719484210014,
0.11955380439758301,
0.317342072725296,
-0.10072781145572662,
0.33376479148864746,
0.1907288134098053,
-0.27682870626449585,
-0.0004267112526576966,
0.4162899851799011,
0.62612384557724,
0.5540727972984314,
-0.2633287012577057,
0.45378556847572327,
0.4995090365409851,
-0.5622869729995728,
0.25487464666366577,
-0.13089317083358765,
0.008924519643187523,
-0.21993917226791382,
0.20459555089473724,
0.47437670826911926,
0.3034535348415375,
-0.8199304342269897,
0.646429181098938,
0.10581456124782562,
-0.3916608989238739,
-0.7272231578826904,
0.20634610950946808,
0.08143453299999237,
0.12117677181959152,
0.051600269973278046,
-0.20296511054039001,
0.14051182568073273,
-0.07964996993541718,
0.23228879272937775,
0.5125343799591064,
-0.297387957572937,
0.023153604939579964,
0.41549259424209595,
-0.08579365164041519,
0.12311840057373047,
0.329150527715683,
-0.1083298847079277,
0.03710678219795227,
0.5443882942199707,
0.42441466450691223,
0.7719064950942993,
0.035160936415195465,
0.19437000155448914,
-0.00458189332857728,
0.2707277834415436,
-0.22899778187274933,
0.4303160309791565,
0.15165092051029205,
-1.1150321960449219,
-0.52712082862854,
-0.8312587141990662,
-0.5687008500099182,
-0.07647169381380081,
-0.5487591028213501,
0.00370107707567513,
-0.6295034289360046,
-0.2727408707141876,
-0.41735902428627014,
-0.047634147107601166,
-0.3250206708908081,
0.2829992473125458,
0.11119586229324341,
1.0969996452331543,
-0.500373899936676,
0.8683398962020874,
0.39585795998573303,
-0.10437649488449097,
-0.6804212927818298,
-0.14277486503124237,
-0.15076623857021332,
-0.801226019859314,
0.4954422414302826,
-0.19542790949344635,
-0.21199458837509155,
-0.005864501465111971,
-0.5526033043861389,
-1.1217237710952759,
1.15449857711792,
0.31251516938209534,
-0.2545739710330963,
-0.02069181203842163,
0.5291121602058411,
0.42358338832855225,
-0.2790012061595917,
-0.14101317524909973,
0.4612725079059601,
0.3781031668186188,
0.20456784963607788,
-0.6171877384185791,
0.07700004428625107,
0.19658392667770386,
0.2624971866607666,
0.1261029690504074,
-0.5202692747116089,
0.6866810321807861,
-0.02029806561768055,
-0.07022133469581604,
0.29445967078208923,
0.6828957200050354,
0.4210662841796875,
-0.013440733775496483,
0.473897784948349,
0.761949896812439,
0.8204902410507202,
-0.2331106811761856,
1.3432464599609375,
-0.3374366760253906,
0.2610359191894531,
0.7478370070457458,
-0.6395136117935181,
1.1083179712295532,
0.5979266166687012,
0.013827658258378506,
0.2499881386756897,
0.5413544178009033,
0.33645185828208923,
0.43466469645500183,
0.3129185140132904,
-0.45929765701293945,
-0.48450154066085815,
-0.14162099361419678,
-0.17157481610774994,
0.25463640689849854,
0.724320113658905,
0.09203213453292847,
-0.17971999943256378,
-0.09236849099397659,
-0.020684463903307915,
-0.22777411341667175,
0.06505794823169708,
0.6385579109191895,
0.19500073790550232,
-0.3651805520057678,
0.4484250545501709,
0.024904511868953705,
0.4711630642414093,
-0.8772110939025879,
0.2988988161087036,
-0.060959089547395706,
0.09213536977767944,
-0.09513848274946213,
-1.1009658575057983,
0.40454134345054626,
-0.3567351996898651,
0.021442070603370667,
-0.0058316937647759914,
0.6882360577583313,
-0.2684228718280792,
-0.40483400225639343,
0.43218716979026794,
0.5935174226760864,
0.1354513168334961,
-0.08017782121896744,
-0.3320009708404541,
0.3398110568523407,
-0.6015602946281433,
-0.25415483117103577,
0.5892875790596008,
0.7731098532676697,
-0.23099306225776672,
1.0260045528411865,
0.35795512795448303,
0.10746559500694275,
0.3090040981769562,
-0.008216621354222298,
0.5333893299102783,
-0.40044155716896057,
-0.37113770842552185,
-0.5514297485351562,
0.24877452850341797,
0.05919788032770157,
-0.4103219509124756,
0.784376859664917,
0.0392136350274086,
0.7945709228515625,
0.039173442870378494,
0.7845047116279602,
-0.14026571810245514,
0.252091646194458,
-0.6635217666625977,
0.6095353960990906,
-0.4452642500400543,
0.2650591731071472,
-0.30321210622787476,
-0.9197680354118347,
-0.6238547563552856,
0.6745761036872864,
-0.18659590184688568,
0.07918235659599304,
0.86493319272995,
0.876921534538269,
0.23755145072937012,
-0.058939378708601,
0.7049395442008972,
0.055415332317352295,
0.04367438703775406,
0.5960438847541809,
1.0126495361328125,
-0.1464049071073532,
0.6249135732650757,
-0.34897443652153015,
-0.027188215404748917,
-0.06715956330299377,
-0.8022069931030273,
-0.6441228985786438,
-0.7469264268875122,
-0.26937827467918396,
-0.45019373297691345,
-0.2453267127275467,
0.8055453896522522,
0.7575660943984985,
-0.6065381169319153,
-0.14604391157627106,
-0.09399030357599258,
0.18039073050022125,
0.12997159361839294,
-0.1934821754693985,
0.30597808957099915,
-0.3881233036518097,
-0.39581364393234253,
0.22195729613304138,
0.22510260343551636,
0.49003931879997253,
-0.45539528131484985,
-0.22956418991088867,
0.25997376441955566,
0.22696609795093536,
0.6898435950279236,
-0.1494792252779007,
-0.8808137774467468,
-0.6994113922119141,
0.03635326027870178,
-0.3536701798439026,
-0.4089500308036804,
0.3417963981628418,
-0.33281639218330383,
-0.0002780369541142136,
0.4319196343421936,
0.8147031664848328,
0.209441676735878,
-0.3345626890659332,
0.3366377055644989,
-0.6989896297454834,
0.2549474835395813,
0.18999244272708893,
0.4567228853702545,
0.23988257348537445,
-0.501261293888092,
0.25739407539367676,
0.1799672693014145,
-0.3524788022041321,
-0.6088051795959473,
0.3619138300418854,
-1.273512601852417,
-0.22081026434898376,
1.5790621042251587,
0.10574541240930557,
-0.3828378915786743,
-0.30914318561553955,
0.1930091232061386,
-0.11457355320453644,
-0.26814010739326477,
0.6328448057174683,
1.0346968173980713,
0.1682274490594864,
-0.16411997377872467,
-0.6399587988853455,
0.5182227492332458,
0.3946438729763031,
-0.8480225801467896,
0.06177305057644844,
0.5718868374824524,
0.4647789001464844,
0.06357396394014359,
0.5058404803276062,
-0.30278751254081726,
0.04763108491897583,
0.05131557583808899,
0.031998779624700546,
0.2612461447715759,
-0.35213133692741394,
-0.17352566123008728,
0.37462496757507324,
0.42381203174591064,
0.27077826857566833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13828v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13828v1
|
Babysit A Language Model From Scratch: Interactive Language Learning by Trials and Demonstrations
| 2024-05-22T16:57:02 | 2024-05-22T16:57:02 |
Ziqiao Ma, Zekun Wang, Joyce Chai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Humans are efficient language learners and inherently social creatures. Our
language development is largely shaped by our social interactions, for example,
the demonstration and feedback from caregivers. Contrary to human language
learning, recent advancements in large language models have primarily adopted a
non-interactive training paradigm, and refined pre-trained models through
feedback afterward. In this work, we aim to examine how corrective feedback
from interactions influences neural language acquisition from the ground up
through systematically controlled experiments, assessing whether it contributes
to learning efficiency in language models. We introduce a
trial-and-demonstration (TnD) learning framework that incorporates three
components: student trials, teacher demonstrations, and a reward conditioned on
language competence at various developmental stages. Our experiments reveal
that the TnD approach accelerates word acquisition for student models of equal
and smaller numbers of parameters, and we highlight the significance of both
trials and demonstrations. We further show that the teacher's choices of words
influence students' word-specific learning efficiency, and a
practice-makes-perfect effect is evident by a strong correlation between the
frequency of words in trials and their respective learning curves. Our findings
suggest that interactive language learning, with teacher demonstrations and
student trials, can facilitate efficient word learning in language models.
|
[
0.04644022509455681,
-1.0002906322479248,
0.48897990584373474,
0.2516436278820038,
-0.1716623604297638,
0.1707502156496048,
-0.42878612875938416,
-0.17350155115127563,
0.01978554204106331,
-0.01972436159849167,
-0.12057007849216461,
-0.10002128034830093,
-0.6037298440933228,
-0.12529724836349487,
-0.3003884255886078,
0.8140046000480652,
0.1165560930967331,
0.29581278562545776,
-0.11860980838537216,
0.00991924200206995,
-0.18886923789978027,
-0.38394132256507874,
-1.0852240324020386,
-0.6010916233062744,
0.840843915939331,
0.6301947236061096,
0.5158230066299438,
0.834788978099823,
0.14097118377685547,
0.44339072704315186,
0.03166438639163971,
-0.024278514087200165,
-0.4191341996192932,
0.17451193928718567,
-0.13016334176063538,
-0.7257792353630066,
-0.10906346887350082,
0.2394571602344513,
0.4067498445510864,
1.113332986831665,
-0.5778618454933167,
-0.16019323468208313,
0.2662297487258911,
0.5377029180526733,
-0.4319861829280853,
0.3107733130455017,
-0.349228173494339,
-0.010791079141199589,
0.09805712103843689,
-0.09876357018947601,
-0.5625180006027222,
-0.7147513628005981,
0.04816853627562523,
-0.6973491311073303,
0.1486409604549408,
-0.2627872824668884,
0.6051380634307861,
-0.1675236076116562,
-0.35034042596817017,
-0.5385986566543579,
-0.7800114154815674,
0.7215347290039062,
-0.674315869808197,
0.5192514061927795,
0.44395750761032104,
0.05684444308280945,
-0.37360242009162903,
-0.8791046142578125,
-0.7089486122131348,
-0.7054495215415955,
-0.03596886619925499,
0.006875013001263142,
0.18421196937561035,
0.1796308010816574,
0.4227908253669739,
0.07033877074718475,
-0.1341155767440796,
0.18555395305156708,
-0.460370272397995,
0.012094959616661072,
0.4004506468772888,
-0.06331747770309448,
0.6545467972755432,
-0.1328004002571106,
-0.004492643754929304,
-0.39792680740356445,
-0.7284740209579468,
0.35622164607048035,
0.4823254942893982,
0.6654196977615356,
-0.17540167272090912,
0.6082994341850281,
-0.1413927972316742,
0.5756136775016785,
0.02201748639345169,
-0.01928805187344551,
0.09724603593349457,
-0.18223746120929718,
0.11924365162849426,
-0.19374175369739532,
0.5622913241386414,
0.03264370560646057,
0.46506422758102417,
-0.5222288966178894,
-0.39700257778167725,
0.2997860014438629,
0.49282947182655334,
-0.707103431224823,
-0.22973012924194336,
-0.09703662246465683,
-0.3078588545322418,
-0.5850912928581238,
-0.0450885146856308,
-0.6496661305427551,
-0.3294491767883301,
-0.42554616928100586,
0.9455877542495728,
-0.526838481426239,
-0.4258471429347992,
0.18905657529830933,
-0.33314934372901917,
0.23642218112945557,
0.318744957447052,
-0.9898000955581665,
0.5603760480880737,
0.6123340129852295,
0.5375016331672668,
-0.16610394418239594,
-0.4596109688282013,
-0.7156472206115723,
-0.3213612139225006,
-0.6928876638412476,
0.5084971189498901,
-0.3718947172164917,
-0.37419623136520386,
0.18995891511440277,
-0.0904097706079483,
-0.2794811725616455,
-0.5734456181526184,
-0.12209828943014145,
-0.7074708342552185,
0.3761850893497467,
-0.3641747534275055,
-0.587971031665802,
-0.18469339609146118,
-0.017056843265891075,
-0.4514221251010895,
0.7228569388389587,
0.19733916223049164,
-0.5236427187919617,
0.5993116497993469,
-0.7352367639541626,
-0.739230215549469,
0.2249123901128769,
-0.12761352956295013,
-0.13365538418293,
0.4612049460411072,
-0.35782158374786377,
0.2911788523197174,
0.32018840312957764,
0.22606943547725677,
-0.1413261890411377,
-0.357020765542984,
0.3065641522407532,
-0.08493827283382416,
0.6343028545379639,
0.03398248925805092,
-0.8871206641197205,
0.05180314555764198,
-0.77247154712677,
0.017033573240041733,
0.310001015663147,
-0.6208335757255554,
-0.45045945048332214,
0.0671088695526123,
-0.1319267749786377,
0.10100970417261124,
-0.1723409742116928,
-0.5319985747337341,
0.24943788349628448,
-0.31354695558547974,
0.23069947957992554,
0.5315175652503967,
0.16294462978839874,
0.4443691372871399,
-0.3656282126903534,
0.5826194286346436,
-0.16711893677711487,
0.04964344948530197,
-0.25724658370018005,
-0.15391942858695984,
-1.0951462984085083,
0.1114831194281578,
0.5202341675758362,
0.11413808912038803,
-1.0021637678146362,
-0.12605427205562592,
0.07464258372783661,
-0.24369904398918152,
-0.45602601766586304,
0.28286734223365784,
0.5565961003303528,
0.27444007992744446,
0.08332447707653046,
-0.7458714842796326,
-0.16014112532138824,
-0.6127018928527832,
-0.06972534954547882,
-0.31063684821128845,
0.03530401736497879,
0.15948733687400818,
0.19896136224269867,
0.2777988016605377,
0.5726341605186462,
-0.1669463962316513,
-0.010811368934810162,
-0.6043866872787476,
0.48439472913742065,
-0.19496072828769684,
0.533538281917572,
0.48062852025032043,
-0.5098431706428528,
-0.237747922539711,
-0.22001752257347107,
-0.41777503490448,
-0.07404767721891403,
-0.1246497705578804,
0.020652860403060913,
0.13665293157100677,
0.6305004358291626,
-0.446100115776062,
0.39530566334724426,
0.32253605127334595,
-0.3641889989376068,
0.3890198767185211,
-0.6506871581077576,
0.02892344258725643,
-0.8019689917564392,
-0.1659233272075653,
-0.22990632057189941,
-0.2821522057056427,
-0.9258484244346619,
0.2391275316476822,
0.1565510630607605,
0.29033929109573364,
-0.4687051773071289,
0.2992161810398102,
-0.43211057782173157,
-0.0008638934814371169,
-0.5970308184623718,
0.2188386619091034,
-0.25954946875572205,
0.600278913974762,
0.21784207224845886,
0.7694229483604431,
0.23175734281539917,
-0.737677276134491,
-0.01719263568520546,
-0.19835016131401062,
-0.3021412491798401,
0.16363763809204102,
-0.8320462107658386,
0.38025566935539246,
-0.005951595026999712,
-0.33835193514823914,
-1.062234878540039,
-0.17832866311073303,
0.04132858291268349,
-0.40651553869247437,
0.5455060601234436,
0.3396177589893341,
-0.5485367178916931,
-0.005619914270937443,
-0.03732351213693619,
-0.04275486618280411,
0.6610500812530518,
-0.5517343878746033,
0.3566731810569763,
0.29359954595565796,
-0.13500292599201202,
-0.038699883967638016,
-0.41090792417526245,
-0.08299699425697327,
0.18343932926654816,
-0.033033549785614014,
-0.03923237323760986,
-0.08996139466762543,
-0.37572336196899414,
-0.11998619139194489,
0.15878278017044067,
0.047157030552625656,
0.3319881856441498,
0.31751778721809387,
-0.05605274811387062,
-0.08980342000722885,
0.3526863157749176,
-0.09201439470052719,
0.11712303757667542,
0.18702514469623566,
-0.002754900138825178,
0.773573100566864,
-0.05829498916864395,
-0.4124029874801636,
-0.20056800544261932,
0.014836074784398079,
0.4743174612522125,
-0.010519594885408878,
0.6652134656906128,
0.15133410692214966,
-0.3790481388568878,
-0.3972071707248688,
-0.3622800409793854,
-0.5393425226211548,
-0.5057248473167419,
0.28669968247413635,
-0.20161931216716766,
-0.6609302163124084,
0.15459559857845306,
-0.10565435886383057,
0.2099532186985016,
-0.07215343415737152,
0.2971968650817871,
-0.06651400029659271,
0.9904406070709229,
0.9895111918449402,
0.43935197591781616,
0.7239220142364502,
-0.3318651616573334,
0.07059609889984131,
-0.6670636534690857,
-0.27551841735839844,
-0.4014863967895508,
-0.19535747170448303,
-0.38565775752067566,
-0.41129767894744873,
-0.07544749975204468,
0.30250442028045654,
-0.0931750237941742,
0.30031561851501465,
0.029333410784602165,
0.3494056761264801,
0.656397819519043,
0.4164925515651703,
0.2454255074262619,
-0.10456681996583939,
-0.5976428389549255,
-0.18327264487743378,
-0.8633800745010376,
-0.4519825279712677,
0.9684717059135437,
0.08485567569732666,
0.5132989883422852,
0.032309651374816895,
0.8611343502998352,
0.09306114166975021,
0.8086951375007629,
-0.7814585566520691,
0.5505266785621643,
0.05248913913965225,
-0.358418345451355,
-0.17245039343833923,
-0.2527486979961395,
-0.9559718370437622,
0.1784864217042923,
-0.16046977043151855,
-0.6195344924926758,
0.23870794475078583,
0.1282305270433426,
-0.3669111430644989,
0.061122018843889236,
-0.9321696162223816,
0.6861335039138794,
-0.4089753329753876,
-0.7759202718734741,
-0.4920750856399536,
-0.44029945135116577,
0.19914139807224274,
-0.12435644119977951,
0.3361533284187317,
0.3839716911315918,
0.06815017759799957,
0.6767139434814453,
-0.45186564326286316,
0.9659337997436523,
-0.4087834060192108,
0.024255089461803436,
0.2026054561138153,
0.4138156473636627,
0.2688251733779907,
-0.2588194012641907,
-0.02908208966255188,
-0.4521936774253845,
-0.44618290662765503,
-0.3873227536678314,
-0.7373752593994141,
0.45269590616226196,
-0.6768291592597961,
-0.5400843024253845,
-0.3135623335838318,
-0.398825466632843,
-0.18599720299243927,
0.11407399922609329,
-0.16480159759521484,
0.4470350444316864,
-0.20064516365528107,
0.354245126247406,
0.554574191570282,
-0.29471591114997864,
0.6575356721878052,
0.8161736726760864,
-0.6256923079490662,
-0.17919094860553741,
0.8641805052757263,
0.19131460785865784,
0.8647987842559814,
-0.0774688646197319,
0.3720531761646271,
-0.15121489763259888,
-0.5875365138053894,
-0.23241613805294037,
0.2503150999546051,
-0.6902980208396912,
0.31790784001350403,
-0.6426849365234375,
-0.13064424693584442,
-0.16750451922416687,
-0.11863179504871368,
-0.43007880449295044,
-0.4087488055229187,
-0.09934351593255997,
-0.39041876792907715,
0.07283014804124832,
1.1584547758102417,
-0.413711816072464,
0.6063238382339478,
-0.3566034436225891,
0.31335294246673584,
0.7276537418365479,
0.22125259041786194,
0.36301910877227783,
-0.48407188057899475,
-0.01737220399081707,
0.23506753146648407,
-0.31209805607795715,
-0.8410081267356873,
0.23028786480426788,
0.24851593375205994,
0.5685786008834839,
0.5193912982940674,
-0.2161821871995926,
0.4604071378707886,
-0.456850528717041,
0.8209229707717896,
0.088139608502388,
-0.8296222686767578,
0.3573625385761261,
-0.25978055596351624,
0.2275932878255844,
0.46880391240119934,
0.31203633546829224,
-0.5933017730712891,
-0.5022575855255127,
-0.8817093372344971,
-0.7692813873291016,
0.7886479496955872,
-0.08453941345214844,
0.48277339339256287,
-0.07729025930166245,
0.5281111598014832,
0.11404168605804443,
0.4465849995613098,
-0.7102147936820984,
-0.03559607267379761,
-0.05344663932919502,
0.052958305925130844,
-0.04600987955927849,
-0.19132345914840698,
-0.032398637384176254,
-0.24786946177482605,
0.6740680932998657,
-0.1868329644203186,
-0.08083648234605789,
0.053534962236881256,
-0.2524918019771576,
-0.20045676827430725,
0.21968206763267517,
0.45698776841163635,
0.6853278279304504,
0.08162932842969894,
0.11510338634252548,
0.0994584932923317,
-0.479528546333313,
0.181764155626297,
-0.1162848174571991,
-0.26543617248535156,
-0.05893632024526596,
0.5320402979850769,
0.8235447406768799,
0.5892693400382996,
-0.4722270965576172,
0.6417720913887024,
-0.3750011622905731,
-0.22641465067863464,
-0.009986573830246925,
0.406588077545166,
0.42077064514160156,
0.16493605077266693,
0.17225661873817444,
-0.11725716292858124,
-0.031587399542331696,
-0.7079629302024841,
0.47889038920402527,
0.28909334540367126,
-0.5159854888916016,
-0.5526542067527771,
0.5742078423500061,
-0.0162094384431839,
-0.7816343307495117,
0.7434196472167969,
-0.367077112197876,
-0.694250762462616,
0.8395463228225708,
0.6709735989570618,
0.7175835371017456,
-0.46531492471694946,
0.598357081413269,
0.2507246434688568,
0.27216675877571106,
-0.21462146937847137,
0.4913315773010254,
-0.37692880630493164,
-0.8600137233734131,
-0.4109552502632141,
-0.6556285619735718,
-0.5979477763175964,
0.2318316102027893,
-0.7664564251899719,
0.1460743397474289,
-0.4967350363731384,
0.018205026164650917,
0.22720593214035034,
0.19870296120643616,
-0.6815900802612305,
0.2442924678325653,
0.14705587923526764,
0.8087202310562134,
-0.967743992805481,
0.9312410354614258,
0.6761313080787659,
-0.48523613810539246,
-1.3224616050720215,
-0.07165570557117462,
-0.2735719680786133,
-0.7076009511947632,
0.9046992659568787,
0.20963643491268158,
-0.06805086135864258,
0.28667303919792175,
-0.6566596627235413,
-0.5908065438270569,
0.4824296236038208,
0.08729231357574463,
-0.4334047734737396,
0.10160622745752335,
0.021530374884605408,
0.7522850036621094,
-0.4018474221229553,
0.4998816251754761,
0.4293808937072754,
0.21787045896053314,
0.09676424413919449,
-0.47959670424461365,
-0.09831396490335464,
-0.24389085173606873,
0.11966244131326675,
-0.0813760757446289,
-0.45214560627937317,
0.4417060613632202,
-0.6996055245399475,
-0.20547567307949066,
0.0999903455376625,
0.7168281674385071,
0.2943212687969208,
0.1323471963405609,
0.8618832230567932,
0.346722811460495,
0.34647080302238464,
-0.14828282594680786,
1.074963927268982,
-0.2354901134967804,
0.0538792759180069,
0.9070400595664978,
-0.27160510420799255,
0.9318053126335144,
0.7222896218299866,
-0.1512916088104248,
0.5452184081077576,
0.468750536441803,
0.4768828749656677,
0.6102939248085022,
0.5892994403839111,
-0.1335422396659851,
-0.30721789598464966,
-0.20627248287200928,
0.03882131725549698,
0.3211916387081146,
0.28905701637268066,
-0.2452380508184433,
-0.23195025324821472,
0.2936832904815674,
0.13145078718662262,
0.31876635551452637,
0.05902048200368881,
0.8494600653648376,
0.1848718374967575,
-0.8156577348709106,
0.2086830586194992,
-0.1802794337272644,
0.45807474851608276,
-0.7549281120300293,
-0.335931658744812,
-0.3428071439266205,
0.18894408643245697,
0.11416424065828323,
-0.18997569382190704,
0.035602398216724396,
-0.09346657991409302,
0.11169017851352692,
-0.3101256191730499,
0.39407089352607727,
-0.8068329691886902,
-0.22420020401477814,
0.4392523169517517,
0.6261343359947205,
0.0847044438123703,
0.33382728695869446,
-0.35217106342315674,
-0.02949466183781624,
-0.21758511662483215,
-0.6981273293495178,
0.5059765577316284,
0.28238433599472046,
0.08710974454879761,
0.4289684593677521,
0.8964896202087402,
0.484257310628891,
0.3667111396789551,
0.26137062907218933,
0.8360764384269714,
-0.3610614538192749,
-0.29601672291755676,
-0.5698810815811157,
0.41685229539871216,
-0.024252841249108315,
-0.1635621190071106,
0.6339092254638672,
0.3169226050376892,
0.9158777594566345,
-0.10069390386343002,
0.7159874439239502,
-0.25764545798301697,
0.5364266037940979,
-0.290580689907074,
0.7207218408584595,
-0.6260921955108643,
-0.03355734050273895,
-0.0388130359351635,
-0.5674236416816711,
-0.14336587488651276,
0.7618139982223511,
-0.2567143440246582,
0.2168755829334259,
0.7759172916412354,
0.7920730113983154,
-0.006046658381819725,
0.098699189722538,
0.310962975025177,
0.16187146306037903,
0.3814026713371277,
0.20844486355781555,
0.8960442543029785,
-0.2717505395412445,
0.173089399933815,
-0.7820062637329102,
-0.3874526917934418,
-0.04345107823610306,
-0.8826659917831421,
-0.7012652158737183,
-0.44187188148498535,
-0.392745703458786,
-0.4478215277194977,
0.44052091240882874,
1.211834192276001,
0.6472405791282654,
-0.7809407711029053,
-0.5189471244812012,
-0.4799879789352417,
0.08326084166765213,
-0.3607206642627716,
-0.27271562814712524,
0.35948821902275085,
-0.9388495683670044,
-0.939070463180542,
0.4865723252296448,
0.00013618306547868997,
0.05297920107841492,
-0.17108415067195892,
-0.043154120445251465,
-0.2647547721862793,
0.1840209662914276,
0.4399266242980957,
0.3323635458946228,
-0.29381391406059265,
-0.3110279142856598,
0.17531323432922363,
-0.393348753452301,
-0.10515470802783966,
0.9431573152542114,
-0.7498595118522644,
0.6300297975540161,
0.4990001320838928,
0.5932976007461548,
0.26762446761131287,
-0.1770154982805252,
0.9137849807739258,
-0.48946428298950195,
0.24472565948963165,
-0.07073377072811127,
0.13148638606071472,
0.4762163460254669,
-0.1406928300857544,
0.2573558986186981,
0.35603731870651245,
-0.38543298840522766,
-0.7471556067466736,
0.07758905738592148,
-0.297834575176239,
-0.06156552955508232,
1.2007334232330322,
-0.21387502551078796,
-0.38983264565467834,
-0.02688250131905079,
-0.17649653553962708,
0.6123225688934326,
-0.2100561261177063,
1.0965863466262817,
0.7461066842079163,
0.06169125437736511,
-0.15540280938148499,
-0.7269983291625977,
0.6513681411743164,
0.5871111154556274,
-0.6083195805549622,
-0.08007263392210007,
0.26463937759399414,
0.41392648220062256,
0.21582381427288055,
0.5991061329841614,
-0.08840855956077576,
0.3099345266819,
-0.01938198134303093,
0.39995476603507996,
-0.03501563519239426,
-0.4775512218475342,
-0.6390429735183716,
0.08464079350233078,
0.39276885986328125,
-0.29513320326805115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13820v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13820v1
|
Towards Comprehensive and Efficient Post Safety Alignment of Large Language Models via Safety Patching
| 2024-05-22T16:51:07 | 2024-05-22T16:51:07 |
Weixiang Zhao, Yulin Hu, Zhuojun Li, Yang Deng, Yanyan Zhao, Bing Qin, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Safety alignment of large language models (LLMs) has been gaining increasing
attention. However, current safety-aligned LLMs suffer from the fragile and
imbalanced safety mechanisms, which can still be induced to generate unsafe
responses, exhibit over-safety by rejecting safe user inputs, and fail to
preserve general utility after safety alignment. To this end, we propose a
novel post safety alignment (PSA) method to address these inherent and emerging
safety challenges, including safety enhancement, over-safety mitigation, and
utility preservation. In specific, we introduce \textsc{SafePatching}, a novel
framework for comprehensive and efficient PSA, where two distinct safety
patches are developed on the harmful data to enhance safety and mitigate
over-safety concerns, and then seamlessly integrated into the target LLM
backbone without compromising its utility. Extensive experiments show that
\textsc{SafePatching} achieves a more comprehensive and efficient PSA than
baseline methods. It even enhances the utility of the backbone, further
optimizing the balance between being helpful and harmless in current aligned
LLMs. Also, \textsc{SafePatching} demonstrates its superiority in continual PSA
scenarios.
|
[
0.01093791238963604,
-0.5025824308395386,
0.4198867380619049,
0.2261115312576294,
-0.4904504716396332,
0.4322341978549957,
0.12686990201473236,
-0.5808629989624023,
0.2804821729660034,
0.6737911701202393,
-0.432552695274353,
-0.5292148590087891,
-0.42739009857177734,
-0.40593960881233215,
-0.2149409055709839,
0.8145796060562134,
-0.19498199224472046,
-0.26547256112098694,
0.09799337387084961,
-0.07346592098474503,
-0.4950300455093384,
-0.575035572052002,
-0.7195173501968384,
-0.15564119815826416,
0.4583435356616974,
0.22972379624843597,
0.6327236890792847,
0.6822502017021179,
0.6743667125701904,
0.36773863434791565,
-0.07538027316331863,
0.37531235814094543,
-0.4429914057254791,
0.12021399289369583,
-0.41586604714393616,
-0.1963379979133606,
-0.9808412790298462,
-0.26763832569122314,
0.6041467189788818,
0.48411163687705994,
-0.24672995507717133,
-0.046328019350767136,
0.487677663564682,
0.6654839515686035,
-1.1327537298202515,
-0.03954966738820076,
-0.7363824844360352,
-0.07094351202249527,
-0.2729681730270386,
-0.4473213851451874,
-0.4784248471260071,
-0.7959003448486328,
-0.09457749873399734,
-0.46393460035324097,
-0.4709632098674774,
-0.055978287011384964,
0.7445337772369385,
0.09380080550909042,
-0.47014716267585754,
0.22920368611812592,
-0.5180262327194214,
0.8044131994247437,
-0.7056837677955627,
0.05126732587814331,
0.18992723524570465,
0.36700674891471863,
-0.39477017521858215,
-0.2718207538127899,
-0.41840654611587524,
0.22184817492961884,
0.0032149283215403557,
-0.2420656532049179,
-0.022064685821533203,
0.07341574877500534,
0.08947301656007767,
0.17159876227378845,
-0.5744287967681885,
0.3380163609981537,
0.041751258075237274,
-0.32953941822052,
0.6334297060966492,
0.16844481229782104,
0.5084311962127686,
0.10837201029062271,
-0.7071455121040344,
-0.11132960021495819,
-1.2814826965332031,
0.022906862199306488,
0.4273591935634613,
0.4666421711444855,
-0.1399979144334793,
0.46762213110923767,
-0.3849398195743561,
0.6665195226669312,
-0.06529516726732254,
-0.26758942008018494,
0.5726449489593506,
-0.47630298137664795,
-0.1560499221086502,
0.1410139799118042,
0.9923805594444275,
0.6568032503128052,
0.2971692979335785,
-0.2423936277627945,
-0.21935993432998657,
0.18789829313755035,
0.388991117477417,
-0.4874456226825714,
-0.16916759312152863,
0.12584756314754486,
-0.06326214969158173,
-0.847648561000824,
-0.031465496867895126,
-0.9224855899810791,
-0.5807528495788574,
-0.285122811794281,
0.35913175344467163,
-0.18054154515266418,
-0.31727874279022217,
0.4494267404079437,
0.6169418096542358,
0.3266337215900421,
0.1542394608259201,
-0.9816606044769287,
0.06754515320062637,
1.025974154472351,
0.8530462980270386,
0.010469948872923851,
-0.2389463633298874,
-0.7765701413154602,
0.6064369082450867,
-0.4749957323074341,
0.9188337922096252,
-0.27897095680236816,
0.07994656264781952,
0.3478527069091797,
0.30704185366630554,
-0.026887834072113037,
-0.041419584304094315,
0.5481938719749451,
-0.5549255013465881,
-0.08672762662172318,
-0.4562561511993408,
-0.12484612315893173,
0.18145719170570374,
0.3209295868873596,
-0.40058478713035583,
0.7973920106887817,
-0.26658007502555847,
-0.9346425533294678,
0.3386213183403015,
-0.15183408558368683,
-0.6578673124313354,
-0.33705437183380127,
0.119026318192482,
-0.6427634358406067,
-0.215390145778656,
0.2718883156776428,
0.351809561252594,
-0.00901925191283226,
0.2769506275653839,
-0.6306514739990234,
-0.3372705280780792,
0.24743764102458954,
-0.20824147760868073,
0.7759328484535217,
0.08090223371982574,
-0.3381986916065216,
0.3524268865585327,
-0.5650736093521118,
-0.002542775357142091,
0.016781624406576157,
-0.3324039876461029,
-0.5376538634300232,
0.11128160357475281,
0.026443399488925934,
0.5806867480278015,
0.4896197021007538,
-0.6009566783905029,
0.25574514269828796,
-0.5314271450042725,
0.1690157800912857,
1.1792937517166138,
-0.27393707633018494,
0.6005412936210632,
-0.5080167055130005,
0.3550962209701538,
-0.3615507185459137,
0.4925164580345154,
-0.1410224735736847,
-0.09257551282644272,
-0.44358521699905396,
-0.352103590965271,
0.13514968752861023,
0.903826117515564,
-0.5476272106170654,
1.0915942192077637,
-0.26078492403030396,
-0.4536316990852356,
-0.2526663541793823,
0.0853118821978569,
0.7339380979537964,
0.4457134008407593,
0.2543219327926636,
-0.500323474407196,
-0.5942800641059875,
-0.8424525856971741,
-0.26327458024024963,
-0.12259507924318314,
-0.1334155648946762,
-0.16392385959625244,
-0.21656087040901184,
-0.16932088136672974,
0.7202115058898926,
-0.49706020951271057,
-0.20770785212516785,
-0.1366988867521286,
-0.11346212029457092,
-0.06931596249341965,
0.8558552861213684,
0.6457446813583374,
-0.2370743453502655,
-0.3928787410259247,
0.10435447841882706,
-0.7120557427406311,
-0.3503051698207855,
-0.10634390264749527,
-0.5169914364814758,
0.5309501886367798,
0.5831823945045471,
-0.6730563044548035,
0.06327717751264572,
0.7102055549621582,
-0.3813609778881073,
0.3015177547931671,
-0.04695368930697441,
0.4102541208267212,
-1.3961567878723145,
0.17308567464351654,
-0.18483662605285645,
-0.3216235041618347,
-0.6836263537406921,
0.1500341147184372,
0.25766074657440186,
0.024834265932440758,
-0.6784724593162537,
0.20600350201129913,
-0.45084965229034424,
0.019553963094949722,
-0.3985564410686493,
0.10933312028646469,
-0.16914886236190796,
0.24318502843379974,
-0.16759590804576874,
0.4007057547569275,
0.6851798892021179,
-0.15458635985851288,
0.08746200799942017,
0.2024552971124649,
-0.26853010058403015,
0.4684222638607025,
-0.49893856048583984,
0.4742676019668579,
-0.07442138344049454,
0.4378913342952728,
-0.9765190482139587,
-0.1256990283727646,
0.41533219814300537,
0.1855989396572113,
0.5431920289993286,
-0.31280267238616943,
-0.6790308952331543,
0.003945242613554001,
-0.6899351477622986,
0.44164612889289856,
0.470625638961792,
-0.42658090591430664,
0.5493495464324951,
0.7844252586364746,
-0.503929615020752,
-0.8834083676338196,
-0.4421977400779724,
0.10908185690641403,
-0.37093526124954224,
-0.6764061450958252,
0.21054591238498688,
-0.014952625147998333,
-0.015350323170423508,
-0.4610128700733185,
-0.293978750705719,
0.16670572757720947,
0.260098397731781,
0.09916718304157257,
0.5396347045898438,
-0.07527804374694824,
-0.23136506974697113,
0.31135907769203186,
-0.686698317527771,
-0.16397030651569366,
-0.001792333205230534,
0.627517580986023,
-0.06613718718290329,
-0.4761793315410614,
-0.5350766777992249,
0.4594549834728241,
0.6863521337509155,
-0.32017630338668823,
0.678139328956604,
-0.015972403809428215,
-0.5157133936882019,
0.21856103837490082,
-0.6912909746170044,
-0.3340579867362976,
-0.5337908267974854,
0.15721997618675232,
-0.03392526134848595,
-0.8741099834442139,
0.3002893030643463,
-0.05911581218242645,
0.5269521474838257,
-0.00019355416588950902,
-0.02301989682018757,
-0.1699250489473343,
0.9957696795463562,
0.7211822271347046,
-0.25139835476875305,
0.39190515875816345,
0.5143601894378662,
0.6440879106521606,
-0.4158244729042053,
-0.14094549417495728,
-0.6713045239448547,
-0.26617372035980225,
-0.4796513319015503,
-0.456124484539032,
0.14134575426578522,
0.4093952775001526,
-0.38333702087402344,
0.6396694183349609,
-0.376186728477478,
0.8219423890113831,
0.15710189938545227,
0.14882521331310272,
0.2567305862903595,
0.08243352174758911,
0.244350865483284,
-0.030557988211512566,
-0.3037283718585968,
-0.5949369668960571,
0.9114115238189697,
0.4578486680984497,
0.8660268783569336,
0.2448267936706543,
0.6487590074539185,
-0.3196766972541809,
0.23924057185649872,
-0.31362852454185486,
0.804218053817749,
-0.4368833601474762,
-0.1678789108991623,
-0.24932438135147095,
-0.28194519877433777,
-0.6331150531768799,
0.2904905676841736,
-0.6018909811973572,
-0.9489297866821289,
0.0737311914563179,
0.571732759475708,
-0.4028066098690033,
0.5223678350448608,
-0.5656230449676514,
0.8909283876419067,
-0.3131588399410248,
-0.453798770904541,
-0.22253085672855377,
-0.9408969879150391,
0.5552524328231812,
-0.34253764152526855,
0.2568456828594208,
-0.12783785164356232,
0.07446134835481644,
0.5157544016838074,
-0.3273952901363373,
0.9838345050811768,
-0.01484659407287836,
-0.37861594557762146,
-0.2114732563495636,
0.07605159282684326,
1.0398521423339844,
-0.3304313123226166,
0.061120204627513885,
0.05693190172314644,
-0.03155301883816719,
-0.6252632141113281,
-0.42505979537963867,
0.8585519194602966,
-0.21881012618541718,
-0.44671186804771423,
-0.664146900177002,
-0.7144729495048523,
-0.6037900447845459,
0.39102086424827576,
-0.17985017597675323,
0.22341947257518768,
0.01916215382516384,
0.0871402770280838,
0.7947437167167664,
-0.46012917160987854,
0.5248987078666687,
0.7362207174301147,
-0.097621388733387,
-0.346655011177063,
0.811343252658844,
0.03297930955886841,
0.3271859884262085,
0.5209218859672546,
0.008230946026742458,
-0.4007611572742462,
-0.825462818145752,
-0.2520633935928345,
0.2328953891992569,
-0.5513003468513489,
-0.3058732748031616,
-0.7723305821418762,
-0.10165947675704956,
-0.4890616238117218,
-0.6182363033294678,
-0.46451056003570557,
-0.33976203203201294,
0.10833350569009781,
-0.46957749128341675,
0.24020618200302124,
0.470700740814209,
-0.21572384238243103,
0.16105996072292328,
-0.9277887940406799,
0.2042088657617569,
0.23237186670303345,
0.5519106984138489,
-0.2993910312652588,
-0.04235803708434105,
0.06982852518558502,
-0.2789780795574188,
-0.25839763879776,
-0.697062611579895,
0.07495563477277756,
-0.2897815704345703,
0.43044739961624146,
0.43542999029159546,
0.3453899025917053,
0.6076623797416687,
-0.7545758485794067,
0.6262430548667908,
0.5750956535339355,
-0.8726810812950134,
0.5571563243865967,
-0.5382207632064819,
0.08869016170501709,
0.7514414191246033,
0.0678766742348671,
-0.39194339513778687,
-0.47963762283325195,
-0.14001864194869995,
-1.423780083656311,
0.5679193735122681,
-0.04813333973288536,
0.2318771481513977,
-0.13585442304611206,
0.0260289516299963,
0.03420273959636688,
0.1259864717721939,
-0.6480951309204102,
0.03648390248417854,
0.06991312652826309,
-0.12300239503383636,
-0.048153333365917206,
-0.5802094340324402,
-0.40124133229255676,
0.20545917749404907,
0.9877068400382996,
-0.2198701649904251,
-0.2289186269044876,
-0.4273802638053894,
0.033809397369623184,
-0.2813870906829834,
0.545365035533905,
0.7339254021644592,
0.6941186785697937,
-0.10679931193590164,
0.3835497200489044,
0.20561760663986206,
-0.16529324650764465,
0.3121304214000702,
0.1382601261138916,
-0.13687735795974731,
-0.48275026679039,
0.36842507123947144,
0.4298609793186188,
0.49990180134773254,
-0.5674483776092529,
0.509194016456604,
0.17078500986099243,
0.18626582622528076,
0.13667038083076477,
-0.01970674656331539,
0.10432886332273483,
0.0723627358675003,
0.02894674614071846,
0.26875293254852295,
-0.16755984723567963,
-0.4296262860298157,
0.45276114344596863,
0.5106926560401917,
-0.3222944438457489,
-0.12244610488414764,
0.3778168559074402,
0.29943498969078064,
-0.2553179860115051,
0.04626953974366188,
0.2734662592411041,
-0.34975457191467285,
0.3066677451133728,
0.4592951238155365,
0.9762710332870483,
-0.7186251878738403,
0.07900345325469971,
0.25938332080841064,
0.6354712843894958,
-0.33277300000190735,
0.3294360637664795,
0.24997065961360931,
-0.4574055075645447,
-0.6176686882972717,
-0.6402633190155029,
-0.19484928250312805,
0.023183897137641907,
-0.4034947156906128,
0.2291906625032425,
-0.4645575284957886,
0.21727877855300903,
-0.46259260177612305,
-0.4836680591106415,
-0.08845088630914688,
-0.0039263758808374405,
-0.10515279322862625,
0.8847746253013611,
-1.2220137119293213,
0.8370304107666016,
0.472758024930954,
-0.0013520907377824187,
-0.8977866172790527,
0.33957207202911377,
0.19562660157680511,
-0.5061286687850952,
-0.11326336115598679,
0.22926011681556702,
-0.25852492451667786,
-0.4730047285556793,
-0.033390577882528305,
-0.9411792755126953,
0.844764232635498,
0.913866400718689,
-1.1021076440811157,
-0.013762147165834904,
0.29003459215164185,
0.40790387988090515,
0.027138376608490944,
-0.23820506036281586,
0.5438713431358337,
0.33487850427627563,
0.07166854292154312,
-1.0480979681015015,
0.6025893688201904,
-0.3159405291080475,
-0.018162289634346962,
0.432219922542572,
-0.5990684032440186,
0.3288135230541229,
0.08929099887609482,
-0.06571436673402786,
0.2580106854438782,
0.3872245252132416,
0.6994121670722961,
0.33486407995224,
0.8749619126319885,
0.6918280720710754,
0.6093527674674988,
-0.19882218539714813,
0.8856983184814453,
-0.1654338240623474,
0.23293361067771912,
1.1446160078048706,
-0.4604152739048004,
0.8709743022918701,
0.7259503602981567,
-0.056167688220739365,
0.1327616423368454,
0.5796517133712769,
0.6027801036834717,
0.9794328808784485,
0.23394589126110077,
-0.4184316098690033,
-0.4480879306793213,
0.014052928425371647,
-0.6146436929702759,
0.13035167753696442,
-0.14090245962142944,
-0.2273673266172409,
-0.20578962564468384,
-0.18744488060474396,
0.23095349967479706,
0.000982134835794568,
-0.16389918327331543,
0.9296703338623047,
0.07055151462554932,
-0.7300443053245544,
0.40743836760520935,
-0.271360844373703,
0.6773478388786316,
-0.7186957597732544,
0.08084239810705185,
-0.15437616407871246,
0.2293132245540619,
-0.28151440620422363,
-0.8729844093322754,
0.6882488131523132,
-0.0911841094493866,
-0.044037461280822754,
-0.39036470651626587,
0.6375612020492554,
-0.5527592897415161,
-0.226289764046669,
0.4402160346508026,
-0.26472052931785583,
-0.18269778788089752,
0.16500288248062134,
-0.43170157074928284,
0.3379470407962799,
-0.29172274470329285,
-0.09302496910095215,
0.7433918714523315,
0.21272118389606476,
-0.22456495463848114,
0.42048200964927673,
0.6793359518051147,
-0.09934847801923752,
-0.03189225122332573,
0.03544970229268074,
0.9224953055381775,
-0.3757477402687073,
-0.9236363768577576,
-0.6873345375061035,
0.8921859264373779,
-0.23634536564350128,
0.07943835854530334,
0.4949033856391907,
0.3429729640483856,
0.43511706590652466,
-0.08886419981718063,
0.7725868225097656,
0.11658956110477448,
0.26927873492240906,
-0.8142297863960266,
0.9239258766174316,
-0.3682060241699219,
0.5220881104469299,
-0.8933311104774475,
-0.867241382598877,
-0.686560869216919,
0.4639928340911865,
-0.2711540758609772,
-0.24475730955600739,
0.6330040693283081,
1.1413278579711914,
-0.1938527375459671,
-0.11221960186958313,
0.27070122957229614,
0.12522773444652557,
0.5060195326805115,
0.7097334265708923,
0.6446516513824463,
-0.3162345886230469,
0.5198051929473877,
-0.3681141436100006,
-0.6075937747955322,
-0.03896067291498184,
-1.3705693483352661,
-0.7490527033805847,
-0.36825063824653625,
-0.4546926021575928,
-0.5734145641326904,
0.4458567202091217,
0.8271260261535645,
0.7783516049385071,
-1.1490670442581177,
0.2058502435684204,
-0.20744840800762177,
0.003566007362678647,
-0.3137500584125519,
-0.17719528079032898,
0.5056501626968384,
-0.18834801018238068,
-0.5578076839447021,
0.7779470682144165,
0.6286619305610657,
0.11128512769937515,
-0.048258617520332336,
0.02826555073261261,
-0.018807996064424515,
0.1721215397119522,
0.5392965078353882,
0.48589587211608887,
-0.6053832173347473,
-0.7465276718139648,
-0.30806592106819153,
-0.2353629171848297,
-0.27307218313217163,
0.7989454865455627,
-0.25136974453926086,
0.23950381577014923,
0.8168925642967224,
0.9578577876091003,
-0.013782828114926815,
-0.10966958850622177,
0.9523250460624695,
-0.8098720908164978,
0.2766570746898651,
-0.07671231031417847,
0.6470214128494263,
0.49006617069244385,
-0.4470301866531372,
0.3294091820716858,
-0.035153355449438095,
-0.431937038898468,
-1.0839051008224487,
0.5166332721710205,
-1.406926155090332,
-0.06721549481153488,
1.0980095863342285,
-0.342366099357605,
0.09658505767583847,
-0.3173013925552368,
-0.3448012173175812,
0.22042879462242126,
-0.2936200797557831,
1.185281753540039,
0.34823769330978394,
0.34111472964286804,
-0.23520292341709137,
-0.004778948612511158,
0.4759168326854706,
0.6529890298843384,
-1.198537826538086,
0.3278349041938782,
0.3847663998603821,
0.41212236881256104,
0.1441996991634369,
0.7268410921096802,
-0.46247750520706177,
0.41382837295532227,
-0.6016719937324524,
-0.1520693302154541,
0.11247696727514267,
-0.4056459069252014,
-0.4983668923377991,
0.5249334573745728,
-0.13012024760246277,
-0.4146381616592407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13816v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13816v2
|
Getting More from Less: Large Language Models are Good Spontaneous Multilingual Learners
| 2024-05-22T16:46:19 | 2024-06-18T16:30:01 |
Shimao Zhang, Changjiang Gao, Wenhao Zhu, Jiajun Chen, Xin Huang, Xue Han, Junlan Feng, Chao Deng, Shujian Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive language
capabilities. While most of the existing LLMs have very unbalanced performance
across different languages, multilingual alignment based on translation
parallel data is an effective method to enhance the LLMs' multilingual
capabilities. In this work, we discover and comprehensively investigate the
spontaneous multilingual alignment improvement of LLMs. We find that LLMs
instruction-tuned on the question translation data (i.e. without annotated
answers) are able to encourage the alignment between English and a wide range
of languages, even including those unseen during instruction-tuning.
Additionally, we utilize different settings and mechanistic interpretability
methods to analyze the LLM's performance in the multilingual scenario
comprehensively. Our work suggests that LLMs have enormous potential for
improving multilingual alignment efficiently with great language and task
generalization.
|
[
-0.18949876725673676,
-0.7682939171791077,
0.582879364490509,
0.1372671276330948,
-0.07584185898303986,
0.3068808317184448,
-0.7108001112937927,
-0.4851636290550232,
0.253793865442276,
0.12723128497600555,
-0.7467315196990967,
-0.3795422911643982,
-0.5757948160171509,
0.17804689705371857,
-0.2912895381450653,
0.8759905099868774,
0.01074307132512331,
0.4493672251701355,
-0.2846166789531708,
-0.28989121317863464,
-0.5481047034263611,
-0.2393786609172821,
-0.28362327814102173,
-0.3145255148410797,
0.7331648468971252,
0.4857828617095947,
0.6304316520690918,
0.8942602276802063,
0.4476117789745331,
0.3495808243751526,
0.0026805726811289787,
0.3608230650424957,
-0.6229050755500793,
-0.031848836690187454,
-0.04040757566690445,
-0.683238685131073,
-0.6237789392471313,
-0.179094135761261,
1.015173316001892,
0.7937341928482056,
-0.3385949730873108,
0.060207005590200424,
0.26395606994628906,
0.6848809123039246,
-0.41325119137763977,
0.06778670847415924,
-0.6115652322769165,
-0.07055611908435822,
-0.5005651712417603,
0.025969011709094048,
-0.5393656492233276,
-0.2651849687099457,
-0.07319332659244537,
-0.8543902039527893,
0.013828063383698463,
0.12620700895786285,
0.7590727806091309,
0.17507676780223846,
-0.6836822032928467,
-0.09119567275047302,
-0.7381777167320251,
1.0020723342895508,
-0.6781888604164124,
0.7307757139205933,
-0.04834611341357231,
0.20268090069293976,
-0.050862930715084076,
-0.19270190596580505,
-0.697907030582428,
0.051468126475811005,
-0.00611776253208518,
0.11846669018268585,
0.2838088572025299,
-0.05380231514573097,
0.18668299913406372,
0.35021430253982544,
-0.8344173431396484,
0.45401015877723694,
-0.059429410845041275,
-0.21721850335597992,
0.5527046322822571,
0.3285615146160126,
0.40726590156555176,
0.28222543001174927,
-0.23847709596157074,
-0.02579406276345253,
-0.8565545082092285,
0.011756662279367447,
0.46237507462501526,
0.41625145077705383,
-0.46813297271728516,
0.6971836686134338,
0.04571999981999397,
1.0770207643508911,
-0.19514711201190948,
-0.45611533522605896,
0.1169181540608406,
-0.6479904651641846,
0.04485613480210304,
-0.003814208321273327,
0.5145431160926819,
0.3235430121421814,
0.3118482530117035,
-0.1398976594209671,
0.03945785015821457,
-0.10554731637239456,
-0.18984822928905487,
-0.6629617810249329,
0.12411118298768997,
0.05881921574473381,
-0.21075379848480225,
0.16217033565044403,
-0.04018646478652954,
-0.5465496182441711,
-0.29631298780441284,
-0.8013126850128174,
0.043647438287734985,
-0.3289816677570343,
-0.25083136558532715,
0.08919253945350647,
0.2085321545600891,
0.3682277202606201,
0.5428558588027954,
-0.9799306392669678,
0.016143376007676125,
0.8736507296562195,
0.7595573663711548,
-0.31702837347984314,
-0.6289526224136353,
-0.5769028663635254,
0.33648720383644104,
-0.5895949602127075,
0.5217462778091431,
-0.6174952983856201,
0.19706137478351593,
0.08746170252561569,
0.27030467987060547,
-0.39234060049057007,
-0.3010818660259247,
0.12276012450456619,
-0.7083823084831238,
0.1855170726776123,
-0.5947149395942688,
-0.739408552646637,
-0.156061589717865,
0.3568311929702759,
-0.5977665185928345,
0.6542490720748901,
-0.342641144990921,
-0.46844616532325745,
0.3895524740219116,
-0.36098575592041016,
-0.4986605942249298,
-0.044727519154548645,
-0.08258331567049026,
-0.022396866232156754,
0.17469462752342224,
0.2209199219942093,
0.24853850901126862,
-0.37114983797073364,
0.3700830042362213,
-0.35798656940460205,
-0.3436516225337982,
0.347349613904953,
-0.6228291392326355,
0.6553353071212769,
0.12170249223709106,
-0.06560122221708298,
0.09799209982156754,
-0.5530678033828735,
-0.1479196846485138,
-0.0332556776702404,
-0.45411381125450134,
-0.17154616117477417,
-0.03331919014453888,
-0.13822627067565918,
0.3022250831127167,
0.5213184356689453,
-0.5427821278572083,
0.4385182857513428,
-0.4450555443763733,
0.09881964325904846,
0.7358626127243042,
-0.4081411361694336,
0.6584911346435547,
-0.26550257205963135,
0.5502471923828125,
-0.050759099423885345,
0.021519120782613754,
-0.22817499935626984,
-0.525788426399231,
-0.7473565340042114,
-0.37453940510749817,
0.46905040740966797,
0.6856790781021118,
-0.6785100102424622,
0.07622954994440079,
-0.5462759733200073,
-0.14316211640834808,
-0.7564082145690918,
0.7561489343643188,
0.4442230463027954,
0.5100806951522827,
0.2910916805267334,
0.011499716900289059,
-0.3775410056114197,
-0.7997013330459595,
-0.20558565855026245,
0.38357824087142944,
0.21196319162845612,
0.05959723889827728,
-0.005008703097701073,
-0.14768363535404205,
0.4285808205604553,
-0.4509188234806061,
-0.21243099868297577,
-0.4383644759654999,
-0.042272716760635376,
0.3634709119796753,
0.484584242105484,
0.33387863636016846,
-0.5366491675376892,
-0.7989225387573242,
0.40409305691719055,
-0.8160474896430969,
0.18839502334594727,
-0.06438615918159485,
-0.301948219537735,
0.4620581567287445,
0.4993763566017151,
-0.6302695274353027,
-0.13445787131786346,
0.6929497718811035,
0.07805376499891281,
0.24713872373104095,
-0.37977901101112366,
0.1481570452451706,
-1.0546883344650269,
-0.0916212722659111,
-0.054336562752723694,
-0.2315790355205536,
-0.6417607069015503,
0.16328935325145721,
0.4600631892681122,
0.031128602102398872,
-0.4613214433193207,
0.5800226926803589,
-0.7873581051826477,
0.02561318129301071,
-0.2863394320011139,
0.30642396211624146,
-0.11977515369653702,
0.3768695890903473,
0.043646227568387985,
0.607822060585022,
0.6932151317596436,
-0.3610842227935791,
0.34074345231056213,
0.12474970519542694,
-0.4549243450164795,
0.42272084951400757,
-0.25025784969329834,
0.1788487285375595,
-0.33857932686805725,
0.12614749372005463,
-1.0035854578018188,
-0.6059351563453674,
-0.22226165235042572,
-0.16582895815372467,
0.7633011937141418,
-0.12502747774124146,
-0.5525454878807068,
-0.15551476180553436,
-0.25235676765441895,
0.4537495970726013,
0.2929525673389435,
-0.6483876705169678,
0.39103153347969055,
0.20450474321842194,
-0.27488380670547485,
-0.7771872878074646,
-0.6521170139312744,
0.04007302224636078,
-0.1071687787771225,
-0.5960111618041992,
0.03800546005368233,
-0.11233178526163101,
-0.22153468430042267,
-0.2654675841331482,
-0.029680751264095306,
0.034283146262168884,
0.040969543159008026,
-0.15874454379081726,
0.5118190050125122,
-0.5271551012992859,
0.31343185901641846,
0.2647804021835327,
-0.0435824990272522,
-0.31198689341545105,
-0.2512889504432678,
0.6894614696502686,
0.08700532466173172,
-0.4875732958316803,
-0.5425562262535095,
0.3029906451702118,
0.5999254584312439,
-0.2631720304489136,
1.0085958242416382,
0.5185547471046448,
-0.23812852799892426,
-0.015086700208485126,
-0.726813554763794,
-0.1165165901184082,
-0.4615769684314728,
0.39396166801452637,
-0.28844356536865234,
-1.0535520315170288,
0.41361770033836365,
0.03611176460981369,
0.14118483662605286,
0.2544766962528229,
0.5723414421081543,
-0.09910822659730911,
1.3332430124282837,
0.7581707835197449,
-0.2932102084159851,
0.2782590091228485,
0.1679157316684723,
0.16010089218616486,
-0.7092750668525696,
-0.29126429557800293,
-0.3215726912021637,
-0.5833938717842102,
-0.6603537797927856,
-0.5178861021995544,
0.2811000645160675,
0.2550271153450012,
0.013923858292400837,
0.21432210505008698,
-0.2024388313293457,
0.73401939868927,
0.2970302700996399,
-0.039137013256549835,
0.33442196249961853,
0.03276016190648079,
-0.19476135075092316,
-0.4221426844596863,
-0.7131648063659668,
-0.36494389176368713,
1.0829811096191406,
0.13440829515457153,
0.766711950302124,
0.4560422897338867,
0.46389180421829224,
-0.35030120611190796,
0.43780532479286194,
-0.5749897956848145,
0.2931027412414551,
-0.30556148290634155,
-0.645916223526001,
-0.3998008668422699,
-0.44902434945106506,
-0.8645925521850586,
0.3676019310951233,
-0.32817429304122925,
-0.7529082298278809,
-0.07363588362932205,
0.2749841511249542,
-0.253907710313797,
0.07761257886886597,
-0.6959001421928406,
0.9040213823318481,
-0.6051645278930664,
-0.60976642370224,
-0.2751545310020447,
-0.5897632241249084,
0.6506674289703369,
-0.41992875933647156,
0.4866957664489746,
-0.07690702378749847,
-0.2526680529117584,
0.4146130681037903,
-0.31279629468917847,
0.8063554167747498,
-0.10834791511297226,
-0.47513827681541443,
-0.0824006199836731,
-0.12502790987491608,
0.6969467997550964,
0.08218489587306976,
-0.05454709753394127,
0.09056724607944489,
-0.1987118422985077,
-0.566420316696167,
-0.714927613735199,
1.112757921218872,
-0.6958305239677429,
-0.6571014523506165,
-0.11604846268892288,
-0.9940174221992493,
-0.2763955593109131,
0.2560286223888397,
0.16370011866092682,
0.28465279936790466,
-0.05836879462003708,
0.1518479436635971,
0.6596695184707642,
-0.23663948476314545,
0.6373717188835144,
0.8050004243850708,
-0.46145954728126526,
-0.2967333197593689,
1.1659331321716309,
0.3378349244594574,
0.33659040927886963,
0.7974587082862854,
0.15833723545074463,
-0.5781598091125488,
-0.4264252185821533,
-0.7308926582336426,
0.47415152192115784,
-0.4884563684463501,
-0.0384100116789341,
-0.6775851845741272,
0.2779161036014557,
-0.6129721999168396,
-0.16050100326538086,
-0.3832680583000183,
-0.47584041953086853,
-0.08541648089885712,
-0.11223285645246506,
0.1568368524312973,
0.608001708984375,
-0.04847606271505356,
0.34982502460479736,
-0.9531099796295166,
0.09881541132926941,
0.31328263878822327,
0.052875369787216187,
0.10293172299861908,
-0.5701287984848022,
-0.3648243546485901,
0.17547820508480072,
-0.22349543869495392,
-0.6358954310417175,
0.36912715435028076,
0.3465559780597687,
0.523989200592041,
0.6033645272254944,
-0.2878563404083252,
1.056552767753601,
-0.6932507157325745,
0.5309162139892578,
0.2844403386116028,
-0.9326441287994385,
0.13158002495765686,
-0.41136837005615234,
0.5269308090209961,
0.43080440163612366,
0.46318912506103516,
-0.5026249289512634,
-0.4052920341491699,
-0.06931205093860626,
-0.7562750577926636,
0.7591205835342407,
-0.2080901861190796,
0.23630140721797943,
0.15266020596027374,
0.2089919149875641,
0.12729276716709137,
0.31632569432258606,
-0.7647138237953186,
-0.28779080510139465,
0.20631073415279388,
-0.3628270626068115,
-0.5687739849090576,
-0.1565844863653183,
-0.21550564467906952,
-0.39321771264076233,
0.6351211071014404,
-0.2410774976015091,
-0.011358505114912987,
-0.37142297625541687,
-0.45403164625167847,
-0.2616628408432007,
0.304768443107605,
1.019067406654358,
0.7000911235809326,
0.18128973245620728,
0.16939310729503632,
0.40919214487075806,
-0.12478560954332352,
0.38536563515663147,
0.07424680888652802,
-0.018389737233519554,
-0.20408566296100616,
0.584243893623352,
0.7356577515602112,
0.3507266044616699,
-0.7211923599243164,
0.47866135835647583,
0.028041278943419456,
0.07789436727762222,
-0.06481719762086868,
-0.00856110267341137,
0.5728640556335449,
0.21295084059238434,
0.16600646078586578,
-0.15827345848083496,
-0.29660552740097046,
-0.3617205023765564,
0.09912501275539398,
0.637346625328064,
-0.23080620169639587,
-0.4577423632144928,
0.7084450721740723,
0.030659427866339684,
-0.12387865036725998,
0.6189002990722656,
-0.22827297449111938,
-0.2750440537929535,
0.3962651789188385,
0.7517369389533997,
0.3466878831386566,
-0.4399849474430084,
0.03713187575340271,
0.3829520046710968,
0.5485032200813293,
-0.2488313615322113,
0.28946352005004883,
-0.10530973225831985,
-0.8966649174690247,
-1.076554775238037,
-0.6312355995178223,
-0.2518395483493805,
0.07101666182279587,
-0.6875403523445129,
0.3531862199306488,
-0.12470503896474838,
0.33811625838279724,
-0.07489857077598572,
-0.11132564395666122,
-0.5629239678382874,
-0.06096263229846954,
0.12016335874795914,
0.6786944270133972,
-0.9472125768661499,
1.2019659280776978,
0.7777049541473389,
-0.01012368779629469,
-1.0161359310150146,
-0.12140215933322906,
0.3064359724521637,
-0.9383751153945923,
0.6220313310623169,
0.3353029191493988,
0.09785643219947815,
0.06095711514353752,
-0.4353543221950531,
-1.1089519262313843,
0.8664039373397827,
0.8860747814178467,
-1.2073153257369995,
0.11770755797624588,
0.42464718222618103,
0.5455021262168884,
-0.13359583914279938,
0.11347443610429764,
0.2799847424030304,
0.5769699215888977,
0.005013617221266031,
-0.722465991973877,
-0.1299239993095398,
-0.12441786378622055,
-0.20107606053352356,
0.532734215259552,
-0.7014627456665039,
0.793061375617981,
-0.18186192214488983,
-0.06278739124536514,
0.10001778602600098,
0.5979990363121033,
0.1307782232761383,
0.2477431297302246,
0.13724012672901154,
0.7503190636634827,
0.9324953556060791,
-0.07335840165615082,
1.1071799993515015,
-0.49992579221725464,
0.25843504071235657,
1.3477658033370972,
-0.7327102422714233,
0.7648450136184692,
0.4996061623096466,
-0.025896873325109482,
0.17112304270267487,
0.47138094902038574,
0.1459612399339676,
0.2813147008419037,
-0.050179917365312576,
-0.27459049224853516,
-0.610439121723175,
-0.14043836295604706,
-0.3147752583026886,
0.3586483597755432,
0.18967993557453156,
-0.07880596071481705,
-0.1831226795911789,
0.19709113240242004,
0.08933591842651367,
0.070967897772789,
-0.11456483602523804,
0.6739801168441772,
0.04604733735322952,
-0.7374163866043091,
0.6717122793197632,
-0.08235006034374237,
0.7401238679885864,
-0.4751758575439453,
0.026676397770643234,
-0.40077725052833557,
0.2284981906414032,
-0.28787416219711304,
-0.3106701970100403,
0.19432280957698822,
0.07494223117828369,
-0.3044065535068512,
-0.25599634647369385,
0.2721317410469055,
-0.8636220693588257,
-0.7113043069839478,
0.3789883255958557,
0.7195666432380676,
0.10327967256307602,
0.2828124165534973,
-0.4793434739112854,
0.11869454383850098,
0.07264689356088638,
-0.06281320005655289,
0.7416330575942993,
0.4967534840106964,
-0.055567674338817596,
0.5432313680648804,
0.7205712199211121,
0.2446991354227066,
0.2799176871776581,
0.059687189757823944,
0.5359837412834167,
-0.5799081921577454,
-0.14264273643493652,
-0.9927855134010315,
0.481158971786499,
-0.006615319289267063,
-0.13959909975528717,
1.0387417078018188,
0.7846723198890686,
1.0200468301773071,
-0.06389115750789642,
0.39388564229011536,
0.24610435962677002,
0.5280205011367798,
-0.7260476350784302,
0.5725773572921753,
-0.7912952303886414,
0.31789112091064453,
-0.16281352937221527,
-1.063563585281372,
-0.36980512738227844,
0.26661089062690735,
-0.17665618658065796,
-0.3114491403102875,
0.6876823902130127,
0.9494091868400574,
-0.16904914379119873,
-0.12746095657348633,
0.5591933131217957,
0.13533765077590942,
0.06037715822458267,
0.4775845408439636,
0.9623860120773315,
-0.16964441537857056,
0.40394023060798645,
-0.14517676830291748,
-0.21223478019237518,
0.13965864479541779,
-0.8225971460342407,
-0.7585998177528381,
-0.2866048812866211,
-0.2638097107410431,
0.0028000895399600267,
-0.07749377936124802,
0.9670850038528442,
0.5378769040107727,
-0.8839923739433289,
-0.534487247467041,
-0.17218941450119019,
0.3453807234764099,
-0.26036080718040466,
-0.1709377020597458,
0.09007886797189713,
-0.604591429233551,
-1.0589829683303833,
0.7504523992538452,
0.31839683651924133,
0.03720580413937569,
0.06084198132157326,
-0.2836162745952606,
-0.5108499526977539,
-0.07107064872980118,
0.5543568134307861,
0.275911420583725,
-0.6730806231498718,
-0.003782478626817465,
0.2956416606903076,
-0.19506585597991943,
-0.004219650756567717,
0.7712635397911072,
-0.09333339333534241,
0.5065916180610657,
0.42910686135292053,
0.804749071598053,
0.35379818081855774,
0.020051615312695503,
0.7073672413825989,
-0.8012168407440186,
0.3630845844745636,
-0.16765795648097992,
0.47602322697639465,
0.34134015440940857,
-0.2997535467147827,
0.1857428252696991,
0.15659688413143158,
-0.49717622995376587,
-0.8869122862815857,
0.02204829268157482,
-0.7379254102706909,
-0.2137349545955658,
1.0642962455749512,
-0.16801832616329193,
-0.03590898588299751,
0.12456361204385757,
0.04349762201309204,
0.4378739297389984,
-0.24118949472904205,
0.5372876524925232,
0.8928062319755554,
-0.10753871500492096,
-0.21944813430309296,
-0.5665860772132874,
0.25164371728897095,
0.7592361569404602,
-0.7786818742752075,
0.0385148748755455,
0.6162375807762146,
0.18729446828365326,
0.16120685636997223,
0.3053266108036041,
-0.11824566125869751,
0.10372129082679749,
-0.44896313548088074,
0.015088186599314213,
0.1978965401649475,
-0.479009747505188,
-0.7049019932746887,
0.07528071850538254,
0.33855873346328735,
-0.05113451927900314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13803v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13803v2
|
Sunnie: An Anthropomorphic LLM-Based Conversational Agent for Mental Well-Being Activity Recommendation
| 2024-05-22T16:30:24 | 2024-06-14T03:54:31 |
Siyi Wu, Feixue Han, Bingsheng Yao, Tianyi Xie, Xuan Zhao, Dakuo Wang
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
A longstanding challenge in mental well-being support is the reluctance of
people to adopt psychologically beneficial activities, often due to lack of
motivation, low perceived trustworthiness, and limited personalization of
recommendations. Chatbots have shown promise in promoting positive mental
health practices, yet their rigid interaction flows and less human-like
conversational experiences present significant limitations. In this work, we
explore whether the anthropomorphic design (both LLM's persona design and
conversational experience design) can enhance users' perception of the system
and their willingness to adopt mental well-being activity recommendations. To
this end, we introduce Sunnie, an anthropomorphic LLM-based conversational
agent designed to offer personalized well-being support through multi-turn
conversation and recommend practical actions grounded in positive psychology
and social psychology. An empirical user study comparing the user experience
with Sunnie and with a traditional survey-based activity recommendation system
suggests that the anthropomorphic characteristics of Sunnie significantly
enhance users' perception of the system and the overall usability;
nevertheless, users' willingness to adopt activity recommendations did not
change significantly.
|
[
-0.5738238096237183,
-0.8546077609062195,
0.6960325837135315,
0.41425228118896484,
-0.48420366644859314,
0.07415734231472015,
-0.08220461010932922,
-0.5826115608215332,
1.0085139274597168,
0.28886210918426514,
-1.0421103239059448,
-0.5514273643493652,
-0.3919885754585266,
-0.002961245132610202,
0.14143995940685272,
0.9299520254135132,
0.3820796608924866,
-0.2419453263282776,
-0.07656236737966537,
-0.15573175251483917,
-0.6661397218704224,
-0.24734288454055786,
-0.6853569746017456,
-0.58775794506073,
0.5461772680282593,
0.3307308554649353,
1.2523950338363647,
-0.21033963561058044,
0.21588021516799927,
0.2724827527999878,
0.3074226677417755,
0.3536713719367981,
-0.5161969661712646,
0.40969374775886536,
-0.1946174055337906,
-0.3377176821231842,
-0.6985095143318176,
-0.11483079940080643,
-0.08795831352472305,
0.23697753250598907,
-0.6355234384536743,
0.2817126214504242,
0.02528339996933937,
0.5930891036987305,
-0.5443852543830872,
0.08558901399374008,
-0.1847369372844696,
-0.01513210404664278,
-0.00950427446514368,
-0.00004047524998895824,
-0.09860317409038544,
-0.2880423963069916,
-0.07317441701889038,
-0.6695567965507507,
-0.38143643736839294,
0.1492733210325241,
0.3810635507106781,
0.30741292238235474,
-0.3596011996269226,
-0.18918108940124512,
-0.9538840651512146,
0.6285539865493774,
-0.779344916343689,
0.3360714912414551,
0.7996128797531128,
0.2675035893917084,
-0.3725018799304962,
0.07759734243154526,
-0.5351561903953552,
-0.23283584415912628,
-0.1373739093542099,
0.12129867076873779,
-0.3062998354434967,
0.12709160149097443,
0.14305588603019714,
0.3840079605579376,
-0.49516385793685913,
-0.3406530022621155,
0.09322551637887955,
-0.17771565914154053,
0.769940972328186,
0.130036860704422,
0.72151118516922,
-0.20238421857357025,
-0.2804550230503082,
0.23348869383335114,
-0.5009019374847412,
0.4346926510334015,
0.09412943571805954,
-0.14915432035923004,
-0.2922125458717346,
0.8083548545837402,
-0.21699412167072296,
0.1962781548500061,
-0.013161253184080124,
-0.41071557998657227,
-0.027088282629847527,
0.08555179089307785,
-0.2901023030281067,
0.016961753368377686,
0.5818721652030945,
0.6600514054298401,
0.14112965762615204,
-0.27308547496795654,
-0.0989096388220787,
0.07524105906486511,
0.5493661761283875,
-0.9502951502799988,
-0.3373725712299347,
0.23155882954597473,
-0.5075643658638,
0.0268927663564682,
0.3075663447380066,
-0.37829819321632385,
-0.8883467316627502,
-0.27151790261268616,
0.2965151369571686,
-0.7741155028343201,
-0.3777848482131958,
0.20907281339168549,
-0.08454479277133942,
-0.03143886849284172,
0.44606563448905945,
-0.6784847378730774,
0.41846951842308044,
0.4628680944442749,
0.9338576793670654,
-0.2095886468887329,
0.1327812224626541,
-0.18279717862606049,
0.22841832041740417,
-0.28381115198135376,
0.902258038520813,
-0.7456894516944885,
-0.8572515249252319,
-0.04747352376580238,
0.15537330508232117,
0.08528807759284973,
-0.4306918978691101,
0.5341936349868774,
-0.3915490210056305,
0.2310733050107956,
-0.30103597044944763,
-0.37788504362106323,
-0.34623071551322937,
0.3920252025127411,
-0.4227462708950043,
0.7397900819778442,
0.2556315064430237,
-0.5756320953369141,
0.25584813952445984,
-0.8690980672836304,
-0.7339397072792053,
0.24473752081394196,
-0.1665586680173874,
-0.29452618956565857,
0.30278223752975464,
0.1711021512746811,
0.3761892020702362,
-0.18712081015110016,
-0.09465791285037994,
-0.6857900619506836,
-0.6402598023414612,
0.7747271060943604,
-0.3137355446815491,
0.8019019961357117,
0.06116929650306702,
-0.4728589355945587,
0.41670581698417664,
-0.3694206178188324,
-0.0021006918977946043,
-0.013942033052444458,
0.02864452451467514,
-0.39664483070373535,
0.3916464149951935,
-0.05104641616344452,
0.3442542552947998,
0.32175174355506897,
-0.6347683072090149,
0.007626637816429138,
-0.44730478525161743,
0.1750049740076065,
0.8750289678573608,
0.4311152398586273,
0.2803865671157837,
-0.8711350560188293,
0.6346411108970642,
-0.32024404406547546,
0.44583505392074585,
0.07307150214910507,
-0.6042611002922058,
-0.3636334538459778,
-0.9672589302062988,
-0.4747651219367981,
0.6826627254486084,
-0.5184270739555359,
0.5666146278381348,
0.12054529041051865,
-0.4238438308238983,
-0.383340060710907,
0.321157306432724,
-0.07144035398960114,
-0.0625433400273323,
0.15628203749656677,
-0.45449554920196533,
-0.4132275879383087,
-0.9021815061569214,
-0.0223014447838068,
-0.49320611357688904,
-0.15839695930480957,
0.7544156908988953,
0.004756559152156115,
-0.6700276732444763,
0.7407180666923523,
-0.4833139181137085,
-0.31870943307876587,
0.043600864708423615,
-0.271541565656662,
0.3030334413051605,
-0.0713510513305664,
0.3213047683238983,
-0.5660885572433472,
-0.5020679235458374,
-0.09529802203178406,
-0.674707293510437,
-0.040486786514520645,
-0.17110852897167206,
-0.49288010597229004,
-0.19223488867282867,
-0.1474081426858902,
-1.0707257986068726,
0.5349576473236084,
0.2736228108406067,
-0.5348609089851379,
0.5122045278549194,
-0.055988166481256485,
0.4023648798465729,
-1.2010811567306519,
0.03614821657538414,
0.028000757098197937,
-0.3697473108768463,
-0.47372597455978394,
-0.31564196944236755,
-0.3524894416332245,
-0.2745361328125,
-0.2782455384731293,
0.7046048641204834,
-0.021470623090863228,
0.1964501589536667,
-0.703004002571106,
-0.18049338459968567,
-0.16063237190246582,
0.4938233196735382,
-0.14418873190879822,
1.07825767993927,
0.772254467010498,
-0.49574029445648193,
0.41098639369010925,
0.5007337927818298,
-0.11690998822450638,
0.9703444242477417,
-0.7114083766937256,
0.2707570195198059,
-0.030968796461820602,
0.428065687417984,
-1.0583181381225586,
-0.25974738597869873,
0.5695980191230774,
-0.23430758714675903,
-0.16813045740127563,
0.4589616060256958,
-0.34507033228874207,
-0.20909598469734192,
-0.7680907845497131,
0.38933953642845154,
0.6023650765419006,
-0.20690743625164032,
0.5062921643257141,
0.5350953936576843,
-0.4525288939476013,
-0.058965299278497696,
-0.004649498965591192,
0.2747777998447418,
-0.5433531999588013,
-0.4888792037963867,
0.5687059760093689,
-0.19948454201221466,
-0.3479408919811249,
-0.14933419227600098,
-0.15633101761341095,
0.44239896535873413,
0.08629608154296875,
0.9880806803703308,
0.5376641750335693,
0.024883773177862167,
0.35339584946632385,
-0.06549885123968124,
-0.09475728869438171,
0.3331349194049835,
0.11046569794416428,
0.570775032043457,
-0.3075507879257202,
-0.6405616998672485,
-0.9248388409614563,
0.5518659949302673,
0.6292166113853455,
-0.03136850893497467,
0.6602646112442017,
0.4836209714412689,
-0.6123587489128113,
0.19217202067375183,
-0.6951044797897339,
-0.5138307809829712,
-0.5217195749282837,
0.08087696880102158,
-0.2102869600057602,
-0.6322098970413208,
0.30601227283477783,
-0.2559398114681244,
0.11934419721364975,
-0.1074071153998375,
0.783881664276123,
-0.5475740432739258,
1.3122005462646484,
0.6747903227806091,
-0.3672737777233124,
0.7294974327087402,
0.15168431401252747,
0.40431612730026245,
-0.7750586867332458,
-0.15029765665531158,
0.012088666670024395,
-0.48818233609199524,
-0.5373227596282959,
-0.30121666193008423,
0.3182825446128845,
-0.16365720331668854,
-0.5590139031410217,
0.06896268576383591,
-0.4807142913341522,
-0.11002553254365921,
0.3369453549385071,
0.6930587887763977,
0.20006851851940155,
0.045493122190237045,
0.09088058024644852,
-0.245543971657753,
-0.3517806828022003,
-0.8676314949989319,
0.40078213810920715,
0.16890603303909302,
0.916015625,
0.46905896067619324,
0.6883389949798584,
0.8829846382141113,
0.7784212827682495,
-0.709030270576477,
0.6232607960700989,
0.17445728182792664,
-0.7909878492355347,
-0.42723554372787476,
0.040705908089876175,
-0.9247435927391052,
-0.0477224625647068,
-0.6340831518173218,
-1.225311517715454,
0.206782266497612,
-0.10654934495687485,
-0.2830145061016083,
0.045603957027196884,
-0.32679373025894165,
0.4104369580745697,
-0.3270305395126343,
-0.4061937928199768,
-0.819549024105072,
-0.37489601969718933,
0.20819853246212006,
0.2516171336174011,
0.3977193236351013,
-0.7809977531433105,
-0.0043417224660515785,
0.5059522390365601,
-0.2235841602087021,
1.0345191955566406,
-0.17395128309726715,
-0.0005441980320028961,
0.2908974289894104,
0.42824023962020874,
0.507234513759613,
0.512711763381958,
-0.41143831610679626,
-0.2912643551826477,
0.09492771327495575,
-0.5744912624359131,
-0.8954459428787231,
0.5080586075782776,
-0.9546846747398376,
-1.0744259357452393,
-0.2769606113433838,
-0.34047871828079224,
-0.4152127802371979,
0.16019609570503235,
-0.12621697783470154,
-0.07541438937187195,
-0.683181881904602,
0.06859371066093445,
0.2748388946056366,
-0.1612572968006134,
0.02523738145828247,
0.36914780735969543,
-0.5766922831535339,
-0.6959560513496399,
0.8762145042419434,
-0.5120616555213928,
-0.20697543025016785,
0.08874376118183136,
-0.013520104810595512,
-0.4539271891117096,
0.045152708888053894,
-0.3596947491168976,
0.5023269057273865,
-0.34062430262565613,
-0.23374906182289124,
-0.24658514559268951,
-0.1351272016763687,
-0.040803711861371994,
-0.26174601912498474,
-0.06945523619651794,
-0.3080895245075226,
-0.2797900140285492,
-0.21088601648807526,
0.4395601451396942,
0.6543892025947571,
0.07070403546094894,
0.43753063678741455,
-0.3300841152667999,
0.4520247280597687,
0.37955498695373535,
0.2555347979068756,
-0.08041903376579285,
-0.2109248787164688,
-0.2092030942440033,
0.24708864092826843,
-0.6952559947967529,
-1.118521809577942,
0.16766467690467834,
0.3808629810810089,
0.6502273082733154,
0.8302607536315918,
0.42634040117263794,
0.6022221446037292,
-0.33943837881088257,
0.50850510597229,
0.5303400158882141,
-0.5062732696533203,
0.4763509929180145,
-0.2391347438097,
0.03167146444320679,
0.5518471598625183,
0.2903134822845459,
-0.7817002534866333,
-0.3682604730129242,
-0.5103961825370789,
-0.4967697262763977,
0.4852999746799469,
0.3889586925506592,
0.6652805209159851,
-0.08742594718933105,
0.4610083997249603,
0.3568880259990692,
0.412349134683609,
-0.6372051239013672,
-0.3753727674484253,
-0.5199587941169739,
0.05860079824924469,
-0.12439004331827164,
-0.227251797914505,
-0.3843224048614502,
-0.06306380033493042,
0.9539381861686707,
-0.14706185460090637,
0.5518490672111511,
0.10963762551546097,
0.193806990981102,
-0.10988593846559525,
0.5264094471931458,
0.28303325176239014,
0.33671313524246216,
-0.303343266248703,
0.2801680862903595,
0.39647918939590454,
-0.19051222503185272,
0.4146445691585541,
0.06972412019968033,
0.054580431431531906,
-0.3342364430427551,
-0.00539567694067955,
0.5923161506652832,
0.15325231850147247,
-0.6055219769477844,
0.2898614704608917,
-0.05870720371603966,
0.10658647119998932,
-0.10405071824789047,
0.6559171080589294,
0.5135471224784851,
0.4962092339992523,
0.36762797832489014,
-0.059629958122968674,
0.5873148441314697,
-0.713505208492279,
0.07172880321741104,
0.8970780968666077,
-0.6663309335708618,
-0.40470725297927856,
0.4116470217704773,
0.23647558689117432,
-1.1661821603775024,
0.5605507493019104,
-0.18868963420391083,
-0.22982989251613617,
0.11065910756587982,
0.7503021955490112,
0.8086254000663757,
-0.19780929386615753,
0.7407525181770325,
0.07129766792058945,
0.07658372819423676,
0.398494154214859,
0.37059012055397034,
-0.5179123282432556,
-0.5655509233474731,
-0.08538422733545303,
-0.40320101380348206,
-0.6329811811447144,
-0.18990124762058258,
-0.4489932656288147,
0.1130203977227211,
-0.46289703249931335,
-0.8806889653205872,
-0.2748759388923645,
0.1258975714445114,
-0.4773944616317749,
0.06697599589824677,
0.24002501368522644,
0.5568673014640808,
-0.5308525562286377,
0.5487357974052429,
1.1592204570770264,
-0.0033228392712771893,
-0.4215840995311737,
0.15746429562568665,
-0.006605869624763727,
-0.8365082740783691,
-0.2579836845397949,
0.29206323623657227,
-0.5704730153083801,
-0.2571652829647064,
-0.12342800945043564,
-0.5837054252624512,
1.276603102684021,
0.5587852001190186,
-0.035750020295381546,
0.3135339021682739,
0.1855291873216629,
0.5855821967124939,
-0.3197869658470154,
0.2681187689304352,
0.04113508388400078,
0.5092437863349915,
0.11778552085161209,
-0.5241879820823669,
0.3467249274253845,
-0.6218414306640625,
0.1452162116765976,
0.003668540855869651,
-0.9137680530548096,
0.013258843682706356,
-0.3195193409919739,
-0.44778233766555786,
0.16028504073619843,
0.6378270983695984,
0.7262811660766602,
0.4875667989253998,
0.597449541091919,
0.016334038227796555,
1.0196830034255981,
0.47817254066467285,
0.7847650051116943,
-0.4544529616832733,
0.06275138258934021,
0.6018730998039246,
-0.5679947137832642,
0.7119503617286682,
0.4941147565841675,
-0.46385785937309265,
1.0000767707824707,
0.789842963218689,
0.42405301332473755,
0.5172355771064758,
0.02571868896484375,
-0.8111671209335327,
-0.5729215741157532,
-0.33080393075942993,
-0.1524609625339508,
0.18525804579257965,
0.4504397213459015,
0.017630310729146004,
-0.1886950135231018,
0.2120395451784134,
-0.2646523118019104,
0.04702691361308098,
0.15078014135360718,
0.6771337389945984,
0.3909483253955841,
-0.6106842756271362,
0.24018670618534088,
0.08224526047706604,
0.47760578989982605,
-0.4002733826637268,
-0.11798413842916489,
-0.034757211804389954,
0.05277528986334801,
-0.3209052085876465,
-0.528989315032959,
0.20028135180473328,
-0.3195529878139496,
-0.18059739470481873,
-0.10508494079113007,
1.2032132148742676,
0.234913632273674,
-0.6417375802993774,
0.15945257246494293,
0.9427244663238525,
0.17034898698329926,
-0.2678477168083191,
-0.9328863620758057,
-0.12362691015005112,
-0.19175636768341064,
-0.21590624749660492,
0.30867889523506165,
0.27555710077285767,
-0.2642275094985962,
0.944078266620636,
0.8601629137992859,
-0.10991350561380386,
-0.5285964012145996,
-0.22047561407089233,
0.8128882646560669,
-0.7557298541069031,
-0.3473188281059265,
-1.049134373664856,
0.2936308979988098,
-0.05645914748311043,
-0.16456396877765656,
0.7214450836181641,
0.5321499109268188,
-0.11527866870164871,
0.042249251157045364,
0.6147393584251404,
-0.20495866239070892,
0.19689862430095673,
-0.031124519184231758,
0.6705387830734253,
-0.5634631514549255,
0.4266781806945801,
-0.06936802715063095,
-1.0401811599731445,
0.023067764937877655,
1.1034541130065918,
-0.3156543970108032,
0.16991986334323883,
0.33328157663345337,
0.9283120036125183,
-0.08451177924871445,
0.383597195148468,
0.35334473848342896,
-0.1321493238210678,
0.506589949131012,
0.5610831379890442,
1.055840015411377,
0.2919430732727051,
-0.014989533461630344,
-0.21720464527606964,
-0.40733200311660767,
-0.4397990107536316,
-0.5585428476333618,
-1.0940505266189575,
-0.4683379828929901,
-0.1882874071598053,
-0.2971824109554291,
0.4064909815788269,
1.3705589771270752,
0.9988171458244324,
-0.6147582530975342,
-0.3906612992286682,
0.038993950933218,
0.31192928552627563,
-0.2451452910900116,
-0.2077542543411255,
0.21600118279457092,
-0.04240540415048599,
-0.19414842128753662,
0.2590196430683136,
0.7046833038330078,
-0.05225246399641037,
-0.35907334089279175,
-0.43452689051628113,
-0.004111188929527998,
0.45896169543266296,
0.6671461462974548,
0.3682292103767395,
-0.7758702039718628,
-0.17758923768997192,
0.41382041573524475,
-0.33344462513923645,
0.2964233458042145,
0.6955814957618713,
-0.8204013109207153,
0.19855940341949463,
-0.25134581327438354,
0.2670849561691284,
0.5960991978645325,
0.2639407515525818,
0.5701526999473572,
-0.196419358253479,
0.0715513601899147,
0.22326721251010895,
0.12283535301685333,
0.10809043049812317,
-0.6727713346481323,
0.3518274128437042,
-0.09972629696130753,
-0.5687605738639832,
-0.40733104944229126,
0.3114342987537384,
-1.0425176620483398,
-0.1762848049402237,
1.1508815288543701,
-0.16860966384410858,
-0.2873341739177704,
-0.2490977644920349,
-1.1425467729568481,
0.06300640851259232,
-0.7263176441192627,
1.3347711563110352,
0.9639477729797363,
-0.9108535051345825,
-0.07841780036687851,
-0.38587281107902527,
0.2753503620624542,
0.547206699848175,
-0.9243425726890564,
-0.160395547747612,
0.4555436372756958,
0.2129388302564621,
0.030487308278679848,
0.8467758893966675,
0.40255841612815857,
0.536232054233551,
-0.4743276834487915,
-0.10677038133144379,
-0.04526109620928764,
0.19664473831653595,
0.34474945068359375,
-0.13831216096878052,
0.539723813533783,
-0.05543661117553711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13798v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13798v1
|
Slaves to the Law of Large Numbers: An Asymptotic Equipartition Property for Perplexity in Generative Language Models
| 2024-05-22T16:23:40 | 2024-05-22T16:23:40 |
Raghu Mudumbai, Tyler Bell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, math.IT
|
We propose a new asymptotic equipartition property for the perplexity of a
large piece of text generated by a language model and present theoretical
arguments for this property. Perplexity, defined as a inverse likelihood
function, is widely used as a performance metric for training language models.
Our main result states that the logarithmic perplexity of any large text
produced by a language model must asymptotically converge to the average
entropy of its token distributions. This means that language models are
constrained to only produce outputs from a ``typical set", which we show, is a
vanishingly small subset of all possible grammatically correct outputs. We
present preliminary experimental results from an open-source language model to
support our theoretical claims. This work has possible practical applications
for understanding and improving ``AI detection" tools and theoretical
implications for the uniqueness, predictability and creative potential of
generative models.
|
[
-0.33898088335990906,
-0.5757399797439575,
0.5173656344413757,
0.2968751788139343,
-0.5263383388519287,
-0.24993032217025757,
-0.24967913329601288,
-0.20201629400253296,
0.23379431664943695,
0.5356477499008179,
-0.31902167201042175,
-0.24715586006641388,
-0.6779500842094421,
0.07665149122476578,
-1.109567403793335,
0.9546117782592773,
0.24067386984825134,
-0.16470839083194733,
-0.4243951439857483,
-0.263277143239975,
0.1576898992061615,
-0.9687663316726685,
-0.26444321870803833,
0.05527791008353233,
0.35704365372657776,
0.2968079149723053,
0.8836113214492798,
0.6643471717834473,
0.4764762222766876,
0.44089606404304504,
0.10538560897111893,
-0.3865799009799957,
-0.6027196645736694,
0.45339635014533997,
-0.145318865776062,
-0.6978572607040405,
-0.23618100583553314,
-0.04555865004658699,
0.8902276158332825,
0.8766562342643738,
-0.06523002684116364,
-0.10074340552091599,
-0.10739360749721527,
0.6818022727966309,
-0.47796642780303955,
-0.32892918586730957,
-0.6825374364852905,
0.14278855919837952,
-0.456015020608902,
-0.06023510918021202,
-0.26943373680114746,
-0.21351374685764313,
-0.034726832062006,
-0.5373925566673279,
0.4042642116546631,
0.1791384071111679,
0.6560007929801941,
0.2710792124271393,
-0.33458736538887024,
-0.4667659401893616,
-0.7378514409065247,
0.670386552810669,
-0.8757101893424988,
0.183787003159523,
0.26393356919288635,
0.22175702452659607,
0.039843250066041946,
-0.8035413026809692,
-0.983384370803833,
-0.5735587477684021,
0.26043233275413513,
-0.05443718284368515,
-0.2073461413383484,
-0.0062003368511796,
0.6186363697052002,
0.47058767080307007,
-0.6362125873565674,
0.3728243112564087,
-0.10830401629209518,
0.19959613680839539,
0.8028791546821594,
0.40127378702163696,
0.371103435754776,
0.26504623889923096,
0.011803287081420422,
-0.14217349886894226,
-0.6514660716056824,
-0.06966421753168106,
1.0324926376342773,
0.12212089449167252,
-0.2096114307641983,
0.6911177039146423,
-0.1537313610315323,
0.5157371163368225,
-0.265687495470047,
0.190207839012146,
0.12002512067556381,
-0.13058553636074066,
-0.06391990184783936,
-0.01249196007847786,
0.9066562056541443,
-0.18433700501918793,
0.22722019255161285,
-0.2629610300064087,
-0.3911951780319214,
-0.3159210681915283,
0.059334784746170044,
-0.7733996510505676,
-0.3693877160549164,
0.12676292657852173,
-0.15371491014957428,
-0.34009572863578796,
0.4007323682308197,
-0.40438106656074524,
-0.6822542548179626,
0.0022050468251109123,
0.19801482558250427,
-0.13055409491062164,
-0.33251914381980896,
0.14066295325756073,
-0.1777413934469223,
0.10985767841339111,
0.22310177981853485,
-0.924238920211792,
0.3238767981529236,
0.7902204394340515,
0.5491250157356262,
0.054208554327487946,
-0.5748330950737,
-0.5211308598518372,
0.022578971460461617,
-0.34766948223114014,
0.5196400880813599,
-0.5841630101203918,
-0.09146329760551453,
0.05346375331282616,
-0.08491601794958115,
0.19095104932785034,
-0.6037051677703857,
0.23239289224147797,
-0.6930877566337585,
-0.2745620906352997,
0.09496831893920898,
-0.5585867762565613,
0.1249919906258583,
-0.10130221396684647,
-0.809141993522644,
0.19369255006313324,
-0.1822916865348816,
-0.5909866690635681,
0.27461281418800354,
-0.5984558463096619,
-0.6819412112236023,
0.08326072990894318,
-0.285946249961853,
-0.6533562541007996,
0.39852309226989746,
-0.403171181678772,
0.18286393582820892,
-0.6224009394645691,
0.3369003236293793,
-0.7005597352981567,
-0.21447508037090302,
0.6682692170143127,
-0.6999050974845886,
1.0591473579406738,
0.3220430612564087,
-0.2951653301715851,
0.20127013325691223,
-0.6103488206863403,
-0.24770653247833252,
0.28964653611183167,
-0.48624187707901,
-0.24349606037139893,
0.04579528048634529,
-0.04018270969390869,
-0.15448413789272308,
0.10183985531330109,
-0.3770948648452759,
0.22144372761249542,
-0.3534276485443115,
0.296407014131546,
0.7387916445732117,
-0.40790221095085144,
0.4420781135559082,
-0.040039148181676865,
0.5682788491249084,
0.34884005784988403,
-0.12294387072324753,
-0.06199666112661362,
-0.5109120011329651,
-0.839162290096283,
-0.2503993809223175,
0.5789562463760376,
0.4508126676082611,
-0.5708626508712769,
0.717366099357605,
-0.30861160159111023,
-0.1811465471982956,
-0.2276884764432907,
0.13017311692237854,
0.3168416917324066,
-0.0760192945599556,
-0.14576846361160278,
-0.4274892210960388,
-0.5921899676322937,
-0.7731548547744751,
-0.5743796825408936,
-0.15415915846824646,
-0.33518698811531067,
0.08702479302883148,
0.6263519525527954,
0.12782959640026093,
0.696015477180481,
-0.3626507520675659,
-0.01772363856434822,
-0.10126493871212006,
0.23238041996955872,
0.23565781116485596,
0.6406588554382324,
0.41114452481269836,
-0.9289355874061584,
-0.2771642804145813,
0.14149340987205505,
-1.1112256050109863,
-0.03809764236211777,
0.038710277527570724,
0.11478455364704132,
0.19795750081539154,
0.7926564812660217,
-0.5446916222572327,
0.645514965057373,
0.1485392451286316,
-0.6163193583488464,
0.5955138802528381,
-0.2520737946033478,
-0.18763738870620728,
-1.0016076564788818,
0.18012802302837372,
-0.17142586410045624,
-0.3553363084793091,
-0.6243482828140259,
0.46611255407333374,
-0.24305669963359833,
-0.34437766671180725,
-0.06474509090185165,
0.2929095923900604,
-0.26682931184768677,
-0.24772672355175018,
-0.24813313782215118,
-0.06963387876749039,
-0.482173353433609,
0.05631651356816292,
-0.12957234680652618,
0.4970463216304779,
0.5106583833694458,
-0.48655349016189575,
0.8160262703895569,
0.12813186645507812,
-0.14471721649169922,
0.40854302048683167,
-0.5569900274276733,
0.1981118619441986,
-0.2713176906108856,
0.021858224645256996,
-0.9485623836517334,
-0.4023159146308899,
-0.14938212931156158,
-0.5805438160896301,
0.12336724251508713,
0.07214101403951645,
-0.6085954308509827,
-0.4258969724178314,
-0.22590811550617218,
0.7536511421203613,
0.585545003414154,
-0.3052169680595398,
0.4252825379371643,
0.2140377312898636,
-0.029320061206817627,
-0.7119365930557251,
-0.6564096212387085,
0.15188385546207428,
-0.26900652050971985,
-0.6117786169052124,
-0.12407443672418594,
-0.017100848257541656,
-0.5812257528305054,
0.086286760866642,
0.2892395853996277,
-0.08488243073225021,
0.20177270472049713,
0.3082142770290375,
-0.08616993576288223,
-0.4872870147228241,
0.31029221415519714,
-0.005522840656340122,
0.12741221487522125,
0.1333375722169876,
-0.40500375628471375,
0.730997622013092,
-0.08126870542764664,
-0.6496384739875793,
-0.18140223622322083,
0.45435959100723267,
0.7680639624595642,
-0.0184505395591259,
0.7445935606956482,
0.268453985452652,
-0.3346320688724518,
-0.09668639302253723,
-0.4786907732486725,
-0.14138495922088623,
-0.47826555371284485,
0.7685385942459106,
-0.5849480032920837,
-0.6824391484260559,
0.8147756457328796,
0.22985580563545227,
-0.10993704199790955,
0.5949302315711975,
0.6482040286064148,
0.10734140127897263,
0.7755746245384216,
0.6315485835075378,
-0.2980719208717346,
0.3036033511161804,
-0.29173544049263,
0.4944409132003784,
-0.4422744810581207,
-0.025753308087587357,
-0.6904977560043335,
-0.3181826174259186,
-0.5743706822395325,
-0.21770885586738586,
0.15596938133239746,
0.31296345591545105,
-0.6031460762023926,
0.0845198780298233,
0.05870664864778519,
0.6215789914131165,
0.7637135982513428,
-0.06299673020839691,
0.4581998586654663,
0.11624342203140259,
-0.12436097115278244,
0.1651916652917862,
-0.5866814255714417,
-0.3441801369190216,
1.1642147302627563,
0.11671970039606094,
0.7127436399459839,
0.4399956464767456,
0.7683932781219482,
0.21519896388053894,
0.25443610548973083,
-0.7588510513305664,
0.5129024386405945,
-0.3635598123073578,
-0.7320089936256409,
-0.893448531627655,
-0.5289870500564575,
-1.1020092964172363,
-0.004013493191450834,
-0.12728679180145264,
-0.7026681900024414,
0.1064516082406044,
0.04658851400017738,
-0.28835204243659973,
0.565293550491333,
-0.4506653845310211,
0.7879936099052429,
0.030091624706983566,
-0.49213603138923645,
-0.28402960300445557,
-0.5354189276695251,
0.34313225746154785,
-0.19130107760429382,
-0.1467735767364502,
0.0985528975725174,
-0.1798451989889145,
0.6835054159164429,
-0.8283493518829346,
0.7034640312194824,
-0.032571423798799515,
-0.1239905133843422,
0.4039856791496277,
0.02749631740152836,
0.6149795651435852,
0.04101695492863655,
-0.04855121672153473,
-0.20700855553150177,
-0.41118019819259644,
-0.7383806109428406,
-0.5993014574050903,
0.7263815999031067,
-0.765091061592102,
-1.00235116481781,
-0.24367442727088928,
-0.7836624383926392,
0.04565587639808655,
0.17046590149402618,
0.6380007863044739,
0.4318552315235138,
0.1047925353050232,
0.4068751931190491,
0.6757765412330627,
-0.3935398459434509,
0.6047273278236389,
0.42936527729034424,
-0.1243952065706253,
-0.19292086362838745,
1.2550427913665771,
0.34277379512786865,
0.17567476630210876,
0.06294597685337067,
-0.0015532077522948384,
-0.224861279129982,
-0.6654045581817627,
-0.4431089162826538,
0.1535523235797882,
-0.7132425308227539,
-0.002381029771640897,
-0.5103480815887451,
-0.4098799228668213,
-0.5086950659751892,
-0.17537161707878113,
-0.1457565426826477,
-0.6233639121055603,
-0.36426544189453125,
0.11746323108673096,
0.173385888338089,
0.8755047917366028,
-0.005881595425307751,
0.00639957282692194,
-0.5144252777099609,
0.22904665768146515,
0.7117791771888733,
0.39873600006103516,
0.2864638566970825,
-0.9895380735397339,
-0.1386989951133728,
-0.21487528085708618,
-0.48148366808891296,
-0.7538045048713684,
0.19771912693977356,
0.14696843922138214,
0.3728733956813812,
0.7191261649131775,
0.3282565772533417,
0.3804616332054138,
-0.30205535888671875,
0.4747946858406067,
0.5755211710929871,
-0.973328173160553,
0.11672031134366989,
-0.507493793964386,
0.1975831538438797,
0.1666220873594284,
0.34271958470344543,
-0.228199765086174,
-0.8198122382164001,
-0.8388717770576477,
-0.8932437896728516,
0.40583938360214233,
0.34739920496940613,
0.5205057263374329,
0.25313955545425415,
0.13728907704353333,
0.023440128192305565,
0.5075716972351074,
-0.9223290681838989,
-0.22265440225601196,
-0.2004656344652176,
-0.2649805545806885,
-0.07377777248620987,
-0.24242039024829865,
-0.12142105400562286,
-0.2435358762741089,
0.3788643479347229,
0.07497373223304749,
0.4137401580810547,
-0.013481611385941505,
-0.21089565753936768,
-0.12006969004869461,
0.10502491891384125,
0.794988214969635,
0.749802827835083,
0.22840705513954163,
0.29076072573661804,
0.13032163679599762,
-0.512944757938385,
0.3628677725791931,
0.219244122505188,
-0.09719979017972946,
-0.2558775544166565,
0.48586827516555786,
0.7457333207130432,
-0.35812845826148987,
-0.6776074767112732,
0.7471068501472473,
0.28401899337768555,
-0.2663610577583313,
-0.7217869162559509,
-0.020889099687337875,
0.1556086540222168,
0.448309987783432,
0.6029091477394104,
-0.011107542552053928,
0.3567001223564148,
-0.6967578530311584,
0.18620732426643372,
0.5357926487922668,
-0.18209725618362427,
-0.41989973187446594,
0.8501933217048645,
0.1907694935798645,
-0.4450015127658844,
0.9051545858383179,
-0.6320647597312927,
-0.5635539293289185,
0.9828808903694153,
0.7353410124778748,
0.8446391820907593,
-0.11648502200841904,
-0.1929815411567688,
0.15807496011257172,
0.28831401467323303,
-0.033044833689928055,
0.04782242700457573,
0.1197284534573555,
-0.7678548097610474,
-0.2414308786392212,
-0.6408599019050598,
-0.018198583275079727,
0.1185552179813385,
-0.42552369832992554,
0.24268874526023865,
-0.5689168572425842,
0.000044417709432309493,
0.24544739723205566,
-0.4675765037536621,
-0.31392449140548706,
-0.09697111696004868,
0.3096385598182678,
0.5340593457221985,
-0.9020756483078003,
0.8494443893432617,
0.6902304887771606,
-0.54518061876297,
-0.6081510782241821,
0.3013469874858856,
-0.18793171644210815,
-0.5742418766021729,
0.6740960478782654,
0.046949222683906555,
0.0724993646144867,
0.16622798144817352,
-0.8109307289123535,
-0.3812409043312073,
0.7124638557434082,
0.7923036217689514,
-0.5011889338493347,
0.0024686474353075027,
0.408657044172287,
0.5033842325210571,
-0.3719635009765625,
-0.01649879477918148,
0.6033308506011963,
0.25962144136428833,
0.13968265056610107,
-0.8445195555686951,
0.24241001904010773,
-0.43767690658569336,
0.05334215983748436,
0.31116583943367004,
-0.37661245465278625,
0.9030281901359558,
-0.43521010875701904,
-0.07662643492221832,
0.43419700860977173,
0.7362803220748901,
0.21824967861175537,
0.3848308324813843,
0.3818921744823456,
0.9446180462837219,
0.6071380376815796,
-0.07867979258298874,
1.2444970607757568,
-0.0043580783531069756,
0.40671440958976746,
0.8017463684082031,
-0.1453341841697693,
0.7449846863746643,
0.4615407884120941,
-0.5811412930488586,
0.37557387351989746,
0.034490689635276794,
0.07225373387336731,
0.10654690861701965,
0.8819773197174072,
-0.5050961375236511,
-0.2182007133960724,
-0.03143223002552986,
-0.2476891577243805,
0.1782236248254776,
0.1514141708612442,
-0.5545372366905212,
0.10038752853870392,
0.09028778970241547,
0.018784886226058006,
0.272970050573349,
-0.3981775641441345,
0.7972152829170227,
0.18311670422554016,
-0.48593801259994507,
0.7900778651237488,
-0.22234311699867249,
0.5204395055770874,
-0.16502980887889862,
0.09887799620628357,
-0.29432570934295654,
0.1928255409002304,
-0.2695333957672119,
-0.6459251046180725,
0.20356254279613495,
-0.05991639941930771,
-0.18677949905395508,
0.3665553033351898,
0.35988837480545044,
-0.45444998145103455,
-0.5818043351173401,
-0.03214224427938461,
0.19601255655288696,
0.38445141911506653,
-0.23927247524261475,
-0.20380054414272308,
-0.15744276344776154,
-0.044267114251852036,
-0.30448025465011597,
0.33630919456481934,
0.7715108394622803,
0.02765573002398014,
0.6719990372657776,
0.342360258102417,
0.052675727754831314,
0.43406641483306885,
-0.018592718988656998,
0.9170506000518799,
-0.5079220533370972,
-0.5849946737289429,
-1.0380852222442627,
0.4218968451023102,
-0.32557305693626404,
-0.37241819500923157,
0.5646477937698364,
0.6376379728317261,
0.7589662671089172,
-0.3155364394187927,
0.905765175819397,
-0.13118234276771545,
0.09594979137182236,
-0.29362550377845764,
0.7546250224113464,
-0.4886971414089203,
0.30276861786842346,
-0.2066563069820404,
-0.8990874290466309,
-0.3509105443954468,
0.41019198298454285,
-0.5542019605636597,
-0.05843855068087578,
0.787156343460083,
0.7567985653877258,
-0.12447327375411987,
-0.020612560212612152,
0.7964786291122437,
0.28575387597084045,
0.03511352464556694,
0.44513893127441406,
0.9209455251693726,
-0.2979690730571747,
0.5961389541625977,
-0.0027550035156309605,
-0.07546684145927429,
-0.25456205010414124,
-0.516949474811554,
-0.8214024901390076,
-0.8789252638816833,
-0.1306222826242447,
-0.5669240951538086,
-0.014655910432338715,
0.8404636979103088,
0.34326475858688354,
-0.9780101180076599,
-0.6340492367744446,
-0.500834584236145,
0.14081938564777374,
-0.08813709020614624,
-0.13831783831119537,
0.23020364344120026,
-0.3606613576412201,
-0.7094725966453552,
-0.33623868227005005,
0.14583760499954224,
0.3956848084926605,
-0.31905946135520935,
-0.25489872694015503,
0.016942620277404785,
0.18158724904060364,
0.48301756381988525,
0.40860727429389954,
-0.6021077632904053,
0.20477695763111115,
-0.47523748874664307,
-0.11918956786394119,
-0.1902787834405899,
1.1517547369003296,
-0.35482463240623474,
0.47183874249458313,
0.5809239149093628,
0.7337791323661804,
0.37279683351516724,
-0.07385274767875671,
0.7224632501602173,
-0.7001261115074158,
0.6494218707084656,
0.4586055874824524,
0.26151129603385925,
0.1017656922340393,
-0.2998858690261841,
0.3128635585308075,
0.4323902428150177,
-0.33965712785720825,
-1.0883773565292358,
0.5298062562942505,
-0.4147295355796814,
-0.28892576694488525,
1.0028659105300903,
-0.5376620888710022,
-0.2193431705236435,
-0.21430493891239166,
0.24714013934135437,
0.28993186354637146,
-0.3664129972457886,
0.8325436115264893,
0.5762542486190796,
0.18473362922668457,
0.04438525065779686,
-0.40826427936553955,
0.41161808371543884,
0.6000456213951111,
-0.7386178374290466,
0.21410492062568665,
0.18997590243816376,
-0.024284519255161285,
0.4197704792022705,
0.33934786915779114,
-0.14671574532985687,
0.4920524060726166,
0.22853760421276093,
0.010563752613961697,
0.05467638373374939,
-0.196846604347229,
-0.6466993093490601,
0.35872575640678406,
0.584015429019928,
0.12318441271781921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13792v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13792v1
|
xRAG: Extreme Context Compression for Retrieval-augmented Generation with One Token
| 2024-05-22T16:15:17 | 2024-05-22T16:15:17 |
Xin Cheng, Xun Wang, Xingxing Zhang, Tao Ge, Si-Qing Chen, Furu Wei, Huishuai Zhang, Dongyan Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
This paper introduces xRAG, an innovative context compression method tailored
for retrieval-augmented generation. xRAG reinterprets document embeddings in
dense retrieval--traditionally used solely for retrieval--as features from the
retrieval modality. By employing a modality fusion methodology, xRAG seamlessly
integrates these embeddings into the language model representation space,
effectively eliminating the need for their textual counterparts and achieving
an extreme compression rate. In xRAG, the only trainable component is the
modality bridge, while both the retriever and the language model remain frozen.
This design choice allows for the reuse of offline-constructed document
embeddings and preserves the plug-and-play nature of retrieval augmentation.
Experimental results demonstrate that xRAG achieves an average improvement of
over 10% across six knowledge-intensive tasks, adaptable to various language
model backbones, ranging from a dense 7B model to an 8x7B Mixture of Experts
configuration. xRAG not only significantly outperforms previous context
compression methods but also matches the performance of uncompressed models on
several datasets, while reducing overall FLOPs by a factor of 3.53. Our work
pioneers new directions in retrieval-augmented generation from the perspective
of multimodality fusion, and we hope it lays the foundation for future
efficient and scalable retrieval-augmented systems
|
[
-0.572936475276947,
-0.5790383219718933,
0.13860401511192322,
0.012093440629541874,
-0.4080030620098114,
0.12257768958806992,
-0.3497123420238495,
-0.3838180601596832,
0.6122718453407288,
0.38384053111076355,
-0.35750073194503784,
-0.2794661223888397,
-0.353838711977005,
-0.17284834384918213,
-0.7282021641731262,
0.8675282001495361,
0.14345280826091766,
-0.16146370768547058,
0.09778010100126266,
-0.27022433280944824,
-0.5757843852043152,
-0.6622003316879272,
-0.4096168577671051,
-0.07617288082838058,
0.3389686644077301,
0.15541966259479523,
0.667839765548706,
0.7905718088150024,
0.18943679332733154,
0.2697536051273346,
-0.05092044919729233,
0.05834447592496872,
-0.6199263334274292,
0.6096090078353882,
-0.17121900618076324,
-0.29873332381248474,
-0.3808871805667877,
-0.23822592198848724,
1.0104615688323975,
0.4690738618373871,
-0.36252620816230774,
0.09441670030355453,
-0.047728102654218674,
0.37236344814300537,
-0.9546877145767212,
-0.014863919466733932,
-0.805208146572113,
0.22425247728824615,
-0.5162996649742126,
-0.5672886371612549,
-0.35320326685905457,
0.18853811919689178,
-0.4064849615097046,
-0.7340899705886841,
0.18409794569015503,
0.637003481388092,
0.5030479431152344,
0.3967694938182831,
-0.3861064016819,
0.015523565001785755,
-0.4076671302318573,
0.5501939654350281,
-0.18171215057373047,
0.7116827964782715,
0.17647069692611694,
0.4579657316207886,
0.05809486284852028,
-0.9843708276748657,
-0.9482223391532898,
0.1463996022939682,
0.08436133712530136,
-0.05160168185830116,
-0.2937670946121216,
0.09877338260412216,
0.14671330153942108,
0.5349782109260559,
-0.5645101070404053,
0.01106981560587883,
-0.30547311902046204,
0.05000091344118118,
0.4660017192363739,
0.1711752712726593,
0.2425835281610489,
-0.5264800786972046,
-0.6619817614555359,
-0.4672439396381378,
-0.9119316935539246,
-0.15985703468322754,
0.227085679769516,
0.4028991460800171,
0.20445416867733002,
0.41003137826919556,
-0.25711995363235474,
0.6964280605316162,
-0.02318025566637516,
0.052658043801784515,
0.29128298163414,
-0.5500353574752808,
-0.20339307188987732,
0.383929580450058,
0.5912585854530334,
0.15977732837200165,
-0.7474893927574158,
-0.18579351902008057,
-0.46143776178359985,
0.002699716482311487,
0.3872392475605011,
-0.6222279667854309,
0.0401574932038784,
0.16242212057113647,
-0.41381412744522095,
-0.54927659034729,
0.13194327056407928,
-0.8035029768943787,
-0.33455929160118103,
-0.03871623054146767,
0.5859994292259216,
-0.24984204769134521,
-0.1819496601819992,
0.26640474796295166,
-0.4575541019439697,
0.1726406216621399,
-0.0006246339762583375,
-0.8360691070556641,
0.20851682126522064,
0.7670218348503113,
0.6780140399932861,
0.003085250733420253,
-0.32057973742485046,
-0.9514881372451782,
0.390298992395401,
-0.13067303597927094,
0.971580982208252,
-0.8605406880378723,
-0.5288589000701904,
0.09844475239515305,
-0.2228117138147354,
0.19974231719970703,
-0.49353307485580444,
1.2720062732696533,
-0.6245725154876709,
0.267937034368515,
-0.28720173239707947,
-0.5069323182106018,
-0.19122008979320526,
0.20808309316635132,
-0.7647600769996643,
1.2876060009002686,
0.4532814919948578,
-0.7269437909126282,
0.5826002359390259,
-0.6244838237762451,
-0.13815593719482422,
0.44774237275123596,
-0.45659756660461426,
0.03326989337801933,
0.2754441201686859,
-0.0035690502263605595,
0.39267417788505554,
-0.5023406744003296,
0.07120580226182938,
-0.11944961547851562,
-0.5196868777275085,
-0.05221099033951759,
-0.3765043020248413,
0.5694618225097656,
0.07507774978876114,
-0.2647114098072052,
0.04037611559033394,
-0.575891375541687,
0.2949371039867401,
-0.04280780628323555,
-0.6203129291534424,
-0.4900725483894348,
-0.3015894591808319,
0.523783266544342,
0.5007323026657104,
0.06752251833677292,
-0.7432689070701599,
0.5784302949905396,
-0.24807557463645935,
0.3660832941532135,
0.602755606174469,
-0.29369494318962097,
0.5587753653526306,
-0.4459640085697174,
0.6144812703132629,
-0.3859657347202301,
-0.00046871957601979375,
-0.5702660083770752,
-0.12522318959236145,
-0.4254164695739746,
-0.3423769772052765,
0.39956900477409363,
0.27624404430389404,
-0.8216385841369629,
0.649527370929718,
-0.7879441380500793,
-0.2978738844394684,
-0.6478592157363892,
0.05641022324562073,
0.5935409665107727,
0.6775457262992859,
0.4878518283367157,
-0.3224114775657654,
-0.840246319770813,
-0.5993764996528625,
-0.06296655535697937,
-0.16190338134765625,
0.08326098322868347,
0.3340631127357483,
0.35207539796829224,
-0.19117853045463562,
0.8885461688041687,
-0.5054132342338562,
-0.4809069037437439,
-0.39699387550354004,
0.15171919763088226,
-0.0644136443734169,
0.6941312551498413,
0.5292705297470093,
-1.142187237739563,
-0.395631343126297,
-0.02487562783062458,
-0.532403290271759,
-0.24486465752124786,
0.10415223985910416,
-0.13448022305965424,
0.24253173172473907,
0.2903732359409332,
-0.7339803576469421,
0.23158708214759827,
0.6581137180328369,
-0.35854119062423706,
0.6134047508239746,
-0.23837833106517792,
0.21430903673171997,
-0.9992985129356384,
0.4513145387172699,
-0.4469701647758484,
-0.4082254469394684,
-0.629705548286438,
0.6786147952079773,
0.28220799565315247,
-0.27845531702041626,
-0.5069133639335632,
1.0841102600097656,
-0.34038475155830383,
0.01553503330796957,
-0.362510621547699,
0.2997494339942932,
0.21928353607654572,
0.42650339007377625,
-0.09127656370401382,
0.8450767397880554,
0.3434775173664093,
-0.27504774928092957,
0.3129346966743469,
0.5399447083473206,
-0.38746461272239685,
0.7002087235450745,
-0.7056146860122681,
0.1099916324019432,
-0.33332279324531555,
0.827945351600647,
-0.653986930847168,
-0.3566340506076813,
0.07716455310583115,
-0.31525883078575134,
0.6401751041412354,
-0.0979161411523819,
-0.5585552453994751,
-0.0735902339220047,
-0.5654837489128113,
0.5534456968307495,
0.5785062909126282,
-0.7249619960784912,
0.5993196964263916,
0.49554380774497986,
-0.17354275286197662,
-0.8393990397453308,
-0.6948894262313843,
0.4800603985786438,
-0.13855817914009094,
-0.6286490559577942,
1.1214016675949097,
-0.15603862702846527,
0.014457793906331062,
-0.0280817449092865,
-0.11617299914360046,
-0.05862630531191826,
-0.15818920731544495,
0.18034060299396515,
0.15366774797439575,
0.20027020573616028,
0.1953088939189911,
0.6515793204307556,
-0.3417155146598816,
-0.37230992317199707,
-0.45854416489601135,
0.7414724230766296,
0.40883105993270874,
-0.28514420986175537,
-0.02257234789431095,
0.8640955686569214,
0.451749324798584,
-0.2380695790052414,
0.6160709857940674,
0.7428123950958252,
-0.3707117438316345,
-0.1403665542602539,
-0.6047614216804504,
-0.10014902800321579,
-0.4829670488834381,
0.3480277955532074,
-0.5139061808586121,
-1.0544317960739136,
0.28375184535980225,
0.1362057328224182,
0.12608709931373596,
0.053998105227947235,
0.4307551085948944,
0.2825033366680145,
1.2237248420715332,
0.7225235104560852,
-0.1038595587015152,
0.5765666365623474,
-0.3522703945636749,
0.12416084110736847,
-1.2214841842651367,
-0.293307900428772,
-0.6504666209220886,
-0.41363897919654846,
-0.20842579007148743,
-0.6738110184669495,
0.684746265411377,
0.2541247308254242,
-0.02677144855260849,
0.35650691390037537,
-0.61812824010849,
0.3961198627948761,
0.46530836820602417,
0.032862454652786255,
0.3180522322654724,
0.03788119927048683,
-0.10358304530382156,
0.07181236147880554,
-1.0351510047912598,
-0.2003045529127121,
0.9661187529563904,
-0.1353258341550827,
0.5401175022125244,
0.2675398588180542,
0.6970951557159424,
0.433052122592926,
0.07473145425319672,
-0.7651482224464417,
0.4629492163658142,
0.029458140954375267,
-0.8458893299102783,
-0.0787648931145668,
-0.43397146463394165,
-1.0648231506347656,
0.4126434624195099,
-0.39659547805786133,
-0.6293907165527344,
0.29179060459136963,
0.028801122680306435,
-0.42237868905067444,
0.2285541594028473,
-0.21505612134933472,
0.5788637399673462,
0.12442412227392197,
-0.45609521865844727,
-0.3518681824207306,
-0.765441358089447,
0.37965935468673706,
-0.2815442681312561,
0.11774296313524246,
0.20747606456279755,
-0.4198901355266571,
0.639005184173584,
-0.4302414059638977,
0.4276112914085388,
-0.13507775962352753,
-0.008159898221492767,
0.013259928673505783,
0.009969670325517654,
0.5468725562095642,
0.13265763223171234,
-0.28608453273773193,
-0.18554240465164185,
0.02459639683365822,
-0.5601012706756592,
-0.9840995073318481,
0.8205393552780151,
-0.3658967614173889,
-0.5872763395309448,
-0.03443213924765587,
-0.6834673881530762,
0.07484982162714005,
0.34145259857177734,
0.34278449416160583,
1.0267425775527954,
-0.09902752935886383,
0.37673288583755493,
0.6493541598320007,
-0.030169863253831863,
0.43008166551589966,
0.2576412260532379,
-0.3256782591342926,
-0.5526052713394165,
0.9748802185058594,
0.30431321263313293,
-0.1712886542081833,
0.6967190504074097,
0.05021992325782776,
-0.5604767799377441,
-0.29529809951782227,
-0.7592808604240417,
-0.034412529319524765,
-0.801604151725769,
-0.5314428210258484,
-0.9440950155258179,
0.2874515950679779,
-0.4895261824131012,
-0.4805184304714203,
-0.3278124928474426,
-0.903826892375946,
0.14344383776187897,
0.014985110610723495,
0.045462921261787415,
0.4800891578197479,
-0.21275201439857483,
0.19488652050495148,
-1.1119613647460938,
0.1298249214887619,
0.11855056881904602,
0.03755424916744232,
0.07092540711164474,
-0.63088458776474,
-0.27949026226997375,
-0.14088048040866852,
-0.2710701823234558,
-0.8834708333015442,
0.46108001470565796,
0.5009814500808716,
0.6389883756637573,
0.4710828363895416,
0.43972134590148926,
0.7028499245643616,
-0.37061119079589844,
0.8663643598556519,
-0.030292361974716187,
-0.96973717212677,
0.27831587195396423,
-0.2734573185443878,
0.09437719732522964,
0.5664047002792358,
0.45288988947868347,
-0.6445553302764893,
0.07779540866613388,
-0.6635428071022034,
-0.9699153900146484,
0.32225799560546875,
0.01068467553704977,
0.6170943975448608,
-0.10776688158512115,
0.45270341634750366,
0.3088090419769287,
0.43164414167404175,
-0.3011193871498108,
-0.17693643271923065,
-0.11742353439331055,
-0.06856968998908997,
0.2486654818058014,
-0.3010461628437042,
-0.3267986476421356,
-0.22129762172698975,
0.56900954246521,
-0.3156227469444275,
0.44727787375450134,
0.16440823674201965,
-0.14482299983501434,
0.017047632485628128,
0.3529730439186096,
0.49076613783836365,
0.24242915213108063,
0.035599298775196075,
0.2783953547477722,
0.16930001974105835,
-0.2870011627674103,
0.3054622709751129,
0.27578431367874146,
-0.022046981379389763,
0.09285551309585571,
0.18691103160381317,
0.7368156909942627,
0.5340570211410522,
-0.8545693159103394,
0.6422384977340698,
-0.1832931488752365,
0.15197527408599854,
-0.17048197984695435,
0.08920546621084213,
-0.5941422581672668,
0.1618233025074005,
0.6707392930984497,
0.0427759513258934,
0.31851306557655334,
-0.5744960904121399,
0.18678715825080872,
0.49408379197120667,
-0.38808324933052063,
-0.4060884416103363,
0.8226056098937988,
0.17294128239154816,
-0.0711916983127594,
0.46448495984077454,
-0.40740281343460083,
-0.6685764789581299,
-0.23913727700710297,
0.6339080333709717,
0.734802782535553,
-0.059977270662784576,
-0.04965231195092201,
0.23314625024795532,
-0.1424275040626526,
-0.1314825415611267,
0.3632444739341736,
-0.7145168781280518,
-0.6261618733406067,
-0.4948148727416992,
-0.6154915690422058,
-0.3033791482448578,
-0.46736258268356323,
-0.7303332686424255,
0.41745465993881226,
-0.056117888540029526,
-0.12109297513961792,
-0.47319281101226807,
0.017572686076164246,
-0.3593904376029968,
-0.003992547746747732,
-0.12305520474910736,
1.315035104751587,
-0.5482854247093201,
0.8505713939666748,
0.8232821822166443,
-0.47829121351242065,
-0.6245993375778198,
-0.3141029477119446,
0.06946670264005661,
-0.5601418018341064,
0.5597172975540161,
0.04883166030049324,
-0.03155602142214775,
0.25431981682777405,
-0.3478279113769531,
-0.8388605713844299,
1.146042823791504,
0.34814953804016113,
-0.15582230687141418,
-0.31250280141830444,
-0.3613017201423645,
0.1776537448167801,
-0.2757680118083954,
0.3236972391605377,
0.39184239506721497,
0.5426918864250183,
-0.041832372546195984,
-0.8286932110786438,
0.3653619587421417,
-0.6619770526885986,
0.028063848614692688,
0.44804954528808594,
-0.601394534111023,
0.702165961265564,
0.22482125461101532,
-0.4069300889968872,
0.27151066064834595,
0.4936835765838623,
0.40445539355278015,
-0.04767988994717598,
0.38948526978492737,
0.8711084723472595,
0.8527666926383972,
0.15475167334079742,
1.3308889865875244,
-0.8168582320213318,
0.2789173126220703,
0.933725893497467,
-0.28476405143737793,
1.0749441385269165,
0.5774309635162354,
0.240518718957901,
0.4531301259994507,
0.03615564852952957,
0.35432931780815125,
0.36690792441368103,
-0.1324213445186615,
-0.7488371133804321,
-0.13197223842144012,
-0.6303632259368896,
-0.6325259208679199,
0.6262220740318298,
0.29540470242500305,
-0.3657970428466797,
-0.1389807015657425,
0.25502777099609375,
0.34149274230003357,
-0.15391036868095398,
-0.0482628270983696,
0.3835999369621277,
-0.29512980580329895,
-0.5632776618003845,
0.8632659912109375,
0.14661702513694763,
0.9249933958053589,
-0.5470249652862549,
-0.03943236917257309,
-0.16338971257209778,
-0.1606859415769577,
-0.3712233304977417,
-0.6945765614509583,
0.31050702929496765,
-0.20930854976177216,
-0.2667677402496338,
-0.5410175323486328,
0.9448153972625732,
-0.3857493996620178,
-0.10310663282871246,
0.09647782891988754,
0.5752712488174438,
0.060574084520339966,
-0.2973189949989319,
-0.46152475476264954,
0.6125067472457886,
-0.24583883583545685,
-0.2943930923938751,
0.599407970905304,
0.2581886053085327,
0.07844549417495728,
0.6268346309661865,
0.6446314454078674,
0.10521797835826874,
0.14130999147891998,
-0.2395377904176712,
1.4323678016662598,
-0.5097135901451111,
-0.4150809347629547,
-0.29899799823760986,
0.5052618980407715,
-0.08252324908971786,
-0.42457810044288635,
0.5954374074935913,
0.5258676409721375,
0.917869508266449,
0.32697126269340515,
0.8450895547866821,
-0.45047590136528015,
0.23706531524658203,
-0.44968435168266296,
0.8117370009422302,
-0.7842968702316284,
0.17204967141151428,
-0.26281821727752686,
-0.9464226365089417,
-0.4387323260307312,
0.38379546999931335,
0.2477046102285385,
0.025794198736548424,
0.6473427414894104,
1.024267554283142,
-0.25693538784980774,
-0.035197045654058456,
0.4905577301979065,
-0.10608256608247757,
0.29943376779556274,
0.3070819079875946,
0.6590798497200012,
-0.6939724087715149,
0.686968207359314,
-0.27159690856933594,
-0.24180854856967926,
-0.2732030153274536,
-0.7545308470726013,
-0.26512837409973145,
-0.8436635136604309,
-0.11673229187726974,
-0.18237365782260895,
0.0011230155359953642,
1.213027834892273,
0.9685744643211365,
-0.09264039993286133,
0.04560469835996628,
0.12567363679409027,
-0.11761723458766937,
-0.13442383706569672,
-0.2237914800643921,
0.16127927601337433,
-0.4236195385456085,
-0.8857524394989014,
0.7821445465087891,
0.4562561511993408,
-0.24693305790424347,
-0.5988704562187195,
-0.047946441918611526,
0.0828382596373558,
-0.12385280430316925,
0.699133038520813,
0.2689519226551056,
-0.3861251771450043,
-0.1545243114233017,
0.02289487048983574,
0.06924134492874146,
0.09781650453805923,
1.1611571311950684,
-1.2812094688415527,
0.5300540924072266,
1.0188302993774414,
0.7212221622467041,
0.25728535652160645,
0.04405758157372475,
0.6071025729179382,
-0.9764285683631897,
0.2619744837284088,
0.16975511610507965,
0.5868579745292664,
0.23551136255264282,
-0.2668851315975189,
0.4086999297142029,
0.13006268441677094,
-0.6196500062942505,
-1.1953529119491577,
0.2500886619091034,
-0.8978534936904907,
-0.11099402606487274,
0.9274711608886719,
-0.2061549425125122,
-0.20165511965751648,
-0.24011972546577454,
-0.4915904998779297,
0.1102873757481575,
-0.5935749411582947,
0.7716749310493469,
0.13043197989463806,
-0.0651165321469307,
-0.2853105664253235,
-0.3888913691043854,
0.2613922655582428,
0.6093807220458984,
-0.5533485412597656,
0.08110443502664566,
0.4268414378166199,
-0.3381437063217163,
0.33072733879089355,
0.5361679792404175,
-0.2329038828611374,
0.46407899260520935,
0.27681681513786316,
0.14238885045051575,
-0.2444867491722107,
-0.28278249502182007,
-0.571161150932312,
0.6437140703201294,
-0.13168475031852722,
0.3091566562652588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13769v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13769v1
|
Do Language Models Enjoy Their Own Stories? Prompting Large Language Models for Automatic Story Evaluation
| 2024-05-22T15:56:52 | 2024-05-22T15:56:52 |
Cyril Chhun, Fabian M. Suchanek, Chloé Clavel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Storytelling is an integral part of human experience and plays a crucial role
in social interactions. Thus, Automatic Story Evaluation (ASE) and Generation
(ASG) could benefit society in multiple ways, but they are challenging tasks
which require high-level human abilities such as creativity, reasoning and deep
understanding. Meanwhile, Large Language Models (LLM) now achieve
state-of-the-art performance on many NLP tasks. In this paper, we study whether
LLMs can be used as substitutes for human annotators for ASE. We perform an
extensive analysis of the correlations between LLM ratings, other automatic
measures, and human annotations, and we explore the influence of prompting on
the results and the explainability of LLM behaviour. Most notably, we find that
LLMs outperform current automatic measures for system-level evaluation but
still struggle at providing satisfactory explanations for their answers.
|
[
-0.5964921712875366,
-0.5348330736160278,
0.8094337582588196,
0.4578154385089874,
-0.21295391023159027,
-0.07111202925443649,
-0.503783106803894,
-0.8092045783996582,
0.17519955337047577,
0.4733019173145294,
-0.6145540475845337,
-0.22779478132724762,
-0.4469095468521118,
0.4950253367424011,
-0.44585347175598145,
0.8246734142303467,
-0.13634657859802246,
-0.10000862181186676,
-0.49087387323379517,
0.02040381357073784,
-0.6980095505714417,
-0.6006215214729309,
-0.7386529445648193,
-0.5894571542739868,
0.7466913461685181,
0.18424396216869354,
0.8137275576591492,
0.718880295753479,
0.12891143560409546,
0.3657459020614624,
-0.000546781113371253,
0.07759194076061249,
-0.04996614530682564,
0.29869988560676575,
-0.014936077408492565,
-0.3793136179447174,
-0.23226477205753326,
0.2234119176864624,
0.5888133645057678,
0.8896194696426392,
0.2023741602897644,
0.32833346724510193,
0.38877198100090027,
0.7087209820747375,
-0.3113001585006714,
0.2890155613422394,
-0.16658855974674225,
0.12412868440151215,
0.11329774558544159,
-0.20599490404129028,
-0.4752567708492279,
-0.3298261761665344,
0.3255794942378998,
-0.44895294308662415,
0.15518313646316528,
0.18196673691272736,
0.5523099303245544,
0.2313481718301773,
-0.4346846640110016,
-0.6910160779953003,
-0.7260732054710388,
0.6281039118766785,
-0.6062095165252686,
0.005131195764988661,
0.4266820549964905,
0.13110120594501495,
-0.041479941457509995,
-0.2991653382778168,
-0.650749683380127,
-0.7577797174453735,
-0.28703486919403076,
-0.0763472244143486,
-0.3683528006076813,
-0.048211660236120224,
0.40726566314697266,
0.3459179699420929,
-0.4214985966682434,
0.6769180297851562,
-0.1508050411939621,
-0.05195830389857292,
0.9604865312576294,
0.33206886053085327,
0.4530269205570221,
-0.5071659088134766,
-0.399672269821167,
-0.059527527540922165,
-0.7307640314102173,
0.24711474776268005,
0.6020303964614868,
0.02809312753379345,
0.030109234154224396,
0.5472643971443176,
-0.15332980453968048,
0.5467194318771362,
-0.08430426567792892,
0.3885902166366577,
0.11220306158065796,
-0.10518735647201538,
-0.10195695608854294,
0.11443741619586945,
1.0527228116989136,
0.5833922028541565,
0.7018542289733887,
-0.04871426150202751,
-0.42185527086257935,
0.09253814816474915,
0.1799665093421936,
-0.42828258872032166,
-0.1111653745174408,
0.04878629371523857,
-0.47434771060943604,
-0.48320090770721436,
-0.2269527018070221,
-0.6567249298095703,
-0.7380276322364807,
-0.30125892162323,
0.625927746295929,
-0.16827400028705597,
-0.17614494264125824,
0.1532467156648636,
-0.2939894497394562,
0.10233072936534882,
0.5658926367759705,
-1.1502646207809448,
0.2150459885597229,
0.5718324780464172,
0.6861268877983093,
-0.3188297748565674,
-0.5311167240142822,
-0.5416879653930664,
-0.1658484786748886,
-0.5506239533424377,
0.9301797747612,
-0.5001665353775024,
-0.5737192034721375,
0.11099918186664581,
-0.06847739964723587,
-0.013944732025265694,
-0.5973770022392273,
0.40682604908943176,
-0.34633639454841614,
0.2721621096134186,
-0.499337375164032,
-0.5007592439651489,
-0.27643683552742004,
0.16568252444267273,
-0.590004026889801,
0.7684184908866882,
-0.2808348834514618,
-0.5394512414932251,
0.35096219182014465,
-0.9636344909667969,
-0.3796999454498291,
0.1303785741329193,
-0.0064189862459897995,
0.04774622991681099,
0.4469105005264282,
0.6414342522621155,
0.5293218493461609,
-0.5454996228218079,
0.39056769013404846,
-0.16986405849456787,
-0.46868136525154114,
0.6519613862037659,
-0.7618383765220642,
0.745150089263916,
0.14445358514785767,
-0.2306898534297943,
0.2409585416316986,
-0.5346512794494629,
-0.1997261792421341,
0.28620192408561707,
-0.2628234922885895,
-0.2606360912322998,
0.023094063624739647,
-0.10892428457736969,
0.23758798837661743,
0.20052389800548553,
-0.3506845235824585,
0.23707717657089233,
-0.38526564836502075,
0.4624616205692291,
0.8926844596862793,
0.1791084259748459,
0.29784584045410156,
-0.5742963552474976,
0.8470970392227173,
-0.3264232873916626,
-0.06250221282243729,
-0.6320322155952454,
-0.6292413473129272,
-0.7386015057563782,
-0.025526661425828934,
0.2625245749950409,
0.19315403699874878,
-0.463561087846756,
0.25320279598236084,
-0.06945120543241501,
-0.42013251781463623,
-0.5493387579917908,
0.23637212812900543,
0.12625594437122345,
0.24214939773082733,
0.1745893806219101,
-0.30426454544067383,
-0.4397510588169098,
-0.7184019684791565,
-0.48319926857948303,
-0.43942809104919434,
-0.3246110677719116,
0.3374273180961609,
0.46228790283203125,
-0.056351423263549805,
1.0590537786483765,
-0.11423488706350327,
-0.006957007572054863,
-0.4806504547595978,
0.28504008054733276,
0.039063356816768646,
0.30390864610671997,
0.35671260952949524,
-0.49440470337867737,
-0.40112537145614624,
-0.2864614725112915,
-0.9224178791046143,
-0.6701714992523193,
-0.35047417879104614,
0.40262994170188904,
0.3870215117931366,
0.40933170914649963,
-0.5462521910667419,
0.35234060883522034,
0.5016255974769592,
-0.3538130819797516,
0.9830475449562073,
-0.4606746733188629,
0.21449165046215057,
-0.49473869800567627,
-0.012596373446285725,
0.05744864046573639,
-0.3008698523044586,
-0.5420348644256592,
-0.16849958896636963,
-0.19527600705623627,
-0.15994009375572205,
-0.18475866317749023,
0.91316819190979,
-0.6491143107414246,
-0.3900653123855591,
-0.3121500313282013,
0.41265377402305603,
0.06682706624269485,
0.0967550277709961,
0.23272356390953064,
0.523674488067627,
0.7009170055389404,
-0.6364286541938782,
0.37384510040283203,
0.27026745676994324,
-0.44552308320999146,
0.18276618421077728,
-0.6971880197525024,
0.1965314745903015,
-0.18501389026641846,
0.21471114456653595,
-0.901458203792572,
-0.3376842439174652,
-0.006029618438333273,
-0.49031057953834534,
-0.019567275419831276,
0.03445018082857132,
-0.8622506856918335,
-0.6391173005104065,
-0.2920151352882385,
-0.30689263343811035,
0.6087969541549683,
-0.9014400243759155,
0.3544784486293793,
0.13853029906749725,
-0.2821333408355713,
-0.20299525558948517,
-0.5646150708198547,
0.5077521204948425,
-0.4417690932750702,
-0.6678747534751892,
-0.09850138425827026,
-0.2048378586769104,
-0.37404412031173706,
-0.09708012640476227,
0.1697891354560852,
0.23540781438350677,
0.2531454265117645,
0.5332616567611694,
0.3499023914337158,
-0.3839508295059204,
0.28051644563674927,
-0.21632587909698486,
-0.2752475440502167,
0.37366044521331787,
0.019821593537926674,
0.6161353588104248,
-0.15472355484962463,
-0.48404231667518616,
-0.7038425207138062,
0.37972232699394226,
0.2402104139328003,
-0.3558850586414337,
0.5705122947692871,
0.4376909136772156,
-0.11321347206830978,
-0.02286776714026928,
-0.8229228258132935,
-0.3192504048347473,
-0.5155736207962036,
0.1250208616256714,
-0.2339182049036026,
-1.0987530946731567,
0.4925674796104431,
0.14196012914180756,
0.02403181605041027,
0.6289801597595215,
0.618435800075531,
-0.29469093680381775,
1.1716787815093994,
0.50546795129776,
-0.04481475055217743,
0.37798306345939636,
0.17577922344207764,
0.12642203271389008,
-0.6147376894950867,
0.112086221575737,
-0.4480191171169281,
-0.3690568804740906,
-0.5182026624679565,
-0.0492873378098011,
0.26188457012176514,
0.1392020732164383,
0.049721211194992065,
-0.04464028775691986,
-0.3235386312007904,
0.5483824014663696,
0.32934340834617615,
-0.4173954427242279,
0.635732114315033,
-0.14188478887081146,
0.2951127588748932,
0.11761024594306946,
-0.6600664258003235,
-0.8835318088531494,
0.8446540236473083,
0.5802671909332275,
0.7679263353347778,
-0.2621338963508606,
0.8945383429527283,
0.212596133351326,
0.445626437664032,
-0.7575137615203857,
0.7040615677833557,
-0.03380153700709343,
-0.4614466726779938,
-0.4234628677368164,
-0.2753981351852417,
-1.0112298727035522,
0.07884896546602249,
-0.3266203999519348,
-1.0928455591201782,
0.05437624081969261,
0.2957358658313751,
-0.7138682007789612,
-0.03949471935629845,
-0.79082190990448,
0.8421536087989807,
-0.17689171433448792,
0.11638489365577698,
-0.2891215682029724,
-0.3791370093822479,
0.31635308265686035,
-0.05902465432882309,
0.27952539920806885,
-0.06479087471961975,
0.1251136064529419,
0.8778350353240967,
-0.14230461418628693,
0.9096866846084595,
-0.17220406234264374,
-0.02517811581492424,
0.455692857503891,
0.2845056653022766,
0.40686115622520447,
0.0648709088563919,
-0.20502544939517975,
0.004195587243884802,
-0.1756294220685959,
0.15268105268478394,
-0.7412514686584473,
0.8146185874938965,
-0.5030086040496826,
-1.1125603914260864,
-0.3262753188610077,
-0.6563631296157837,
-0.23235519230365753,
-0.11221129447221756,
-0.006289917044341564,
0.3229660093784332,
0.07548489421606064,
0.3587368428707123,
0.29105302691459656,
-0.429910272359848,
0.8457424640655518,
0.5127571225166321,
-0.500499427318573,
0.05358843505382538,
0.5856236815452576,
0.1313343495130539,
0.33501991629600525,
-0.17136207222938538,
0.6026552319526672,
-0.34357497096061707,
-0.41330039501190186,
-0.7123653888702393,
0.23498690128326416,
-0.6340808272361755,
0.09369072318077087,
-0.9408107995986938,
-0.06769859045743942,
-0.1657821238040924,
-0.31889674067497253,
-0.12768326699733734,
-0.30898621678352356,
-0.2198299765586853,
-0.289406955242157,
0.38142603635787964,
1.1208258867263794,
-0.1934039294719696,
0.20782096683979034,
-0.8423683643341064,
0.10694129765033722,
0.5340111255645752,
0.16649873554706573,
0.3584097623825073,
-0.43934112787246704,
-0.12137143313884735,
-0.17239327728748322,
-0.07831325381994247,
-0.9251618981361389,
0.33661243319511414,
0.01941845566034317,
0.4099584221839905,
0.1810058206319809,
-0.04207916557788849,
0.47692689299583435,
-0.5604104399681091,
0.9197008609771729,
-0.029063018038868904,
-0.8714122176170349,
0.3158659040927887,
-0.2548231780529022,
0.36458733677864075,
0.17699234187602997,
0.3713478446006775,
-0.8042172193527222,
-0.40405574440956116,
-0.47843918204307556,
-0.6548930406570435,
0.7432022094726562,
0.02936573512852192,
0.48346808552742004,
-0.04463502764701843,
0.3937779664993286,
0.19882112741470337,
0.22623243927955627,
-0.9527708292007446,
-0.10148725658655167,
0.09787669777870178,
0.029540659859776497,
-0.21421852707862854,
-0.4402117133140564,
0.22347742319107056,
0.1810545176267624,
0.46384483575820923,
-0.013960425741970539,
0.16153353452682495,
0.17751774191856384,
-0.061335593461990356,
-0.4340798556804657,
0.32983046770095825,
0.1582815945148468,
0.5856687426567078,
0.192220076918602,
0.11104989796876907,
0.3124842047691345,
0.11271259188652039,
0.07075095921754837,
0.07428396493196487,
-0.027261419221758842,
-0.052013058215379715,
0.48243531584739685,
0.8852143883705139,
0.15107494592666626,
-0.8355976939201355,
0.6063078045845032,
-0.03163657337427139,
-0.0074707744643092155,
-0.39779284596443176,
0.2719813585281372,
0.3609672784805298,
0.2919991612434387,
0.4796021282672882,
-0.19246000051498413,
0.08503207564353943,
-0.8059989213943481,
0.016569331288337708,
0.38999098539352417,
-0.3631528913974762,
-0.27547940611839294,
0.6269349455833435,
0.017093205824494362,
-0.6016435623168945,
0.33594802021980286,
-0.25655654072761536,
-0.38927721977233887,
0.6176850199699402,
0.6389066576957703,
0.8700011968612671,
-0.27078333497047424,
0.4167764186859131,
0.18682657182216644,
0.45443493127822876,
-0.24143697321414948,
-0.0716954916715622,
-0.06227809563279152,
-0.7138156294822693,
-0.7421991229057312,
-0.8228235840797424,
-0.37125203013420105,
0.1569371074438095,
-0.5576376914978027,
0.38298675417900085,
-0.25550350546836853,
0.20027919113636017,
0.24307800829410553,
-0.19264060258865356,
-0.754177451133728,
0.2519926130771637,
0.5042205452919006,
0.7868496775627136,
-0.9147458076477051,
0.697441577911377,
0.5057064294815063,
-0.4010588526725769,
-0.865403950214386,
0.08689099550247192,
-0.014687852934002876,
-0.6232185363769531,
0.6895051002502441,
0.4496152400970459,
0.039908185601234436,
-0.08819058537483215,
-0.3094102740287781,
-0.5378445982933044,
0.6602031588554382,
0.3576323390007019,
-0.5533639192581177,
-0.31167319416999817,
0.023119816556572914,
0.9219813346862793,
-0.6570867300033569,
0.2883950173854828,
0.4065103232860565,
0.6491072177886963,
-0.08710744231939316,
-1.0757532119750977,
0.03431878983974457,
-0.010447361506521702,
0.07494089007377625,
-0.1923535019159317,
-0.40708523988723755,
0.4482836425304413,
-0.408868670463562,
-0.052849650382995605,
0.09358160197734833,
0.6140182614326477,
0.28401440382003784,
0.42868316173553467,
0.8808627128601074,
-0.15969091653823853,
0.4540856182575226,
0.12105012685060501,
1.2867636680603027,
-0.050017815083265305,
0.10836618393659592,
1.0632176399230957,
-0.2916490435600281,
0.8535096049308777,
0.27641695737838745,
-0.034479882568120956,
0.4523892104625702,
0.6571740508079529,
-0.04806787893176079,
-0.14898084104061127,
0.2403487265110016,
-0.11009351909160614,
-0.47058337926864624,
0.030066819861531258,
0.0005617660353891551,
0.6088272333145142,
0.2602158784866333,
-0.5105419754981995,
-0.13582585752010345,
0.24585123360157013,
-0.09895993024110794,
0.19566276669502258,
-0.3987479507923126,
0.818754255771637,
0.25915053486824036,
-0.8436778783798218,
0.34944048523902893,
-0.15875059366226196,
0.478583425283432,
-0.5217483043670654,
0.18516910076141357,
-0.021438341587781906,
-0.42025479674339294,
-0.12642721831798553,
-0.9859211444854736,
0.3891458213329315,
0.2581453025341034,
0.019014129415154457,
-0.4878633916378021,
0.6504129767417908,
-0.3052954375743866,
-0.308412104845047,
0.32709500193595886,
0.6119471192359924,
0.2837328612804413,
-0.27125948667526245,
-0.397064208984375,
-0.041599445044994354,
0.05220295116305351,
-0.6109136939048767,
0.32829272747039795,
0.4736253321170807,
-0.18861185014247894,
0.8932161927223206,
0.6369740962982178,
-0.08102531731128693,
-0.12275144457817078,
0.16047430038452148,
0.6496890187263489,
-0.8156889081001282,
-0.49032649397850037,
-1.1658849716186523,
0.5245495438575745,
0.01599184051156044,
-0.14459647238254547,
0.8875534534454346,
0.287210077047348,
0.43921706080436707,
-0.1712484359741211,
0.7748641967773438,
0.12970145046710968,
0.3853323757648468,
-0.48849251866340637,
0.8090026378631592,
-0.504073441028595,
0.3012073040008545,
-0.24201753735542297,
-1.063807725906372,
-0.2821166515350342,
0.47675570845603943,
-0.4904826879501343,
0.1408090740442276,
0.6052483916282654,
0.5298424363136292,
0.3844267725944519,
0.33913636207580566,
0.48548346757888794,
0.28885161876678467,
0.40923449397087097,
0.16153587400913239,
1.2563836574554443,
0.2316557765007019,
0.3848605751991272,
0.0573427677154541,
-0.1626390963792801,
-0.2234763354063034,
-1.0058221817016602,
-1.0423011779785156,
-0.6508078575134277,
-0.42857322096824646,
-0.020550673827528954,
-0.05493920296430588,
1.1853467226028442,
0.2515163719654083,
-0.5820038318634033,
-0.2748331129550934,
0.15062309801578522,
0.08511704206466675,
-0.03600963577628136,
-0.17384202778339386,
0.160457044839859,
-0.4969298839569092,
-0.7382867336273193,
0.6196603178977966,
0.41183558106422424,
0.012101505883038044,
-0.6582524180412292,
0.06835845857858658,
0.16589368879795074,
0.12174566090106964,
0.4622341990470886,
0.10813865065574646,
-0.8707068562507629,
-0.6241815090179443,
-0.1658858358860016,
0.13213378190994263,
0.10275430977344513,
0.7965580821037292,
-0.8907287120819092,
0.4847181737422943,
0.2213420420885086,
0.44211745262145996,
0.38754573464393616,
-0.16936174035072327,
0.7442839741706848,
-0.5093757510185242,
-0.12406719475984573,
0.15992888808250427,
0.42480847239494324,
0.5115322470664978,
-0.3767074942588806,
0.38341885805130005,
-0.0905848890542984,
-0.7655596733093262,
-0.9633188843727112,
0.10494613647460938,
-0.5003040432929993,
0.15226876735687256,
1.2764947414398193,
-0.19715575873851776,
-0.3006732165813446,
0.006534008774906397,
-0.4006662666797638,
-0.00021485686011146754,
-0.3371065557003021,
0.8729965090751648,
0.988290548324585,
-0.20596225559711456,
-0.4460529088973999,
-0.9082759022712708,
0.53965163230896,
0.39867621660232544,
-0.7070796489715576,
0.38154929876327515,
0.4541252553462982,
0.1562875509262085,
0.2214481234550476,
0.6228442192077637,
0.05119890347123146,
0.24451227486133575,
-0.2775163948535919,
0.05470505729317665,
-0.17774464190006256,
-0.1732841432094574,
-0.6386618614196777,
0.07510368525981903,
0.46595460176467896,
0.25834915041923523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14899v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.14899v1
|
DETAIL: Task DEmonsTration Attribution for Interpretable In-context Learning
| 2024-05-22T15:52:52 | 2024-05-22T15:52:52 |
Zijian Zhou, Xiaoqiang Lin, Xinyi Xu, Alok Prakash, Daniela Rus, Bryan Kian Hsiang Low
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In-context learning (ICL) allows transformer-based language models that are
pre-trained on general text to quickly learn a specific task with a few "task
demonstrations" without updating their parameters, significantly boosting their
flexibility and generality. ICL possesses many distinct characteristics from
conventional machine learning, thereby requiring new approaches to interpret
this learning paradigm. Taking the viewpoint of recent works showing that
transformers learn in context by formulating an internal optimizer, we propose
an influence function-based attribution technique, DETAIL, that addresses the
specific characteristics of ICL. We empirically verify the effectiveness of our
approach for demonstration attribution while being computationally efficient.
Leveraging the results, we then show how DETAIL can help improve model
performance in real-world scenarios through demonstration reordering and
curation. Finally, we experimentally prove the wide applicability of DETAIL by
showing our attribution scores obtained on white-box models are transferable to
black-box models in improving model performance.
|
[
-0.07916085422039032,
-0.4916357696056366,
0.5449137687683105,
0.30801674723625183,
-0.3405524790287018,
-0.22868502140045166,
-0.16948969662189484,
-0.32441213726997375,
-0.2451336532831192,
0.4633638262748718,
-0.5927728414535522,
-0.3030814230442047,
-0.5789445042610168,
-0.18084484338760376,
-0.7255165576934814,
1.0273535251617432,
-0.25036853551864624,
-0.26304545998573303,
-0.6828181743621826,
0.11003518104553223,
-0.20023414492607117,
-0.4292075037956238,
-0.6649998426437378,
-0.6958313584327698,
0.28085216879844666,
0.84119713306427,
0.2890215218067169,
0.532848060131073,
0.2862718105316162,
0.24943561851978302,
0.22711333632469177,
0.1617777794599533,
-0.45071107149124146,
-0.05350080132484436,
-0.286441445350647,
-0.734131395816803,
0.022786496207118034,
-0.01950697787106037,
0.6357928514480591,
0.6960541605949402,
0.030163459479808807,
0.31394636631011963,
0.4724428355693817,
0.11188235878944397,
-0.7864448428153992,
0.43205150961875916,
-0.7089800238609314,
-0.08343886584043503,
0.08515036106109619,
-0.21485504508018494,
-0.9303769469261169,
-0.16863738000392914,
0.1429736614227295,
-0.48098376393318176,
0.31666186451911926,
-0.13963603973388672,
0.6783608198165894,
0.5491378307342529,
-0.5730165839195251,
-0.2590794563293457,
-0.9125027060508728,
1.1352603435516357,
-0.5834826231002808,
0.34999650716781616,
0.3498212993144989,
0.3351653814315796,
0.04750498756766319,
-1.1038618087768555,
-0.3586808145046234,
-0.3312910497188568,
-0.6451523303985596,
-0.010061425156891346,
-0.127229705452919,
-0.28937163949012756,
0.3021080195903778,
0.00915503315627575,
0.09200578927993774,
-0.043400730937719345,
-0.20583204925060272,
0.027158105745911598,
0.4520114064216614,
0.07198464125394821,
-0.021918678656220436,
-0.0327172689139843,
-0.4815399944782257,
-0.3377472758293152,
-0.9203678965568542,
0.5749184489250183,
0.00492429081350565,
0.22113275527954102,
-0.32957378029823303,
0.17788736522197723,
-0.11176812648773193,
0.5995431542396545,
0.3647150993347168,
-0.015793953090906143,
0.1087934598326683,
-0.12165180593729019,
-0.3379242420196533,
0.0654243752360344,
0.4918808043003082,
0.06974666565656662,
-0.12797275185585022,
-0.33674684166908264,
-0.25702938437461853,
-0.1789228469133377,
0.6244670748710632,
-1.1056255102157593,
-0.16281510889530182,
-0.16033686697483063,
-0.5623994469642639,
-0.508556604385376,
0.3390618860721588,
-0.45273357629776,
-0.10686356574296951,
-0.4985862970352173,
0.6601409912109375,
-0.23197706043720245,
-0.14232535660266876,
-0.21976763010025024,
0.032898351550102234,
0.2549923062324524,
0.3248578906059265,
-0.694389820098877,
0.43586722016334534,
0.6279386878013611,
0.7000430822372437,
-0.4026097059249878,
-0.2642967998981476,
-0.5954812169075012,
0.3170863389968872,
-0.1993778944015503,
0.6658334732055664,
-0.6036330461502075,
-0.2869170010089874,
-0.04432248696684837,
0.10036617517471313,
-0.05773288011550903,
-0.6623392701148987,
0.582939863204956,
-0.34560683369636536,
0.09099361300468445,
-0.15681393444538116,
-0.5010048747062683,
-0.2460673451423645,
-0.009481984190642834,
-0.5313719511032104,
0.8316235542297363,
0.25633567571640015,
-0.5821728110313416,
0.7772505283355713,
-1.1045116186141968,
-0.7182705402374268,
0.0462857149541378,
-0.304859459400177,
-0.5161976218223572,
0.2279663383960724,
0.16405075788497925,
0.7901287078857422,
-0.07352611422538757,
0.40338054299354553,
-0.013011842034757137,
-0.4732513427734375,
0.44613927602767944,
-0.6260563135147095,
0.6718472242355347,
0.08515118807554245,
-0.7649484872817993,
0.4343876838684082,
-0.6319614052772522,
-0.05197690799832344,
-0.11427603662014008,
-0.15228137373924255,
-0.34671348333358765,
0.2761997878551483,
0.05141107738018036,
0.17710283398628235,
-0.06684347242116928,
-0.40528830885887146,
-0.027378614991903305,
-0.44230490922927856,
0.31934261322021484,
0.4201264977455139,
0.0055716149508953094,
0.46737560629844666,
-0.005406652577221394,
0.6312634348869324,
-0.015236507169902325,
0.2252163141965866,
-0.23702307045459747,
-0.12122322618961334,
-0.6192253828048706,
-0.21748511493206024,
0.017758311703801155,
0.28584498167037964,
-0.716525673866272,
0.17601871490478516,
-0.19015510380268097,
-0.504741907119751,
-0.3646944463253021,
0.053588949143886566,
0.7032089829444885,
1.014493703842163,
0.44109317660331726,
-0.10958639532327652,
-0.2789466977119446,
-1.1981502771377563,
-0.3268290162086487,
0.017558271065354347,
-0.1601172685623169,
0.3601664900779724,
0.5235870480537415,
-0.04369961470365524,
0.9100552797317505,
-0.5382418632507324,
-0.08345518261194229,
-0.35921409726142883,
0.30154621601104736,
0.1361607015132904,
0.5572426319122314,
0.4561941623687744,
-1.1658973693847656,
-0.8014260530471802,
0.01687643863260746,
-0.7128447890281677,
-0.1054583340883255,
-0.04636630788445473,
-0.03314909711480141,
-0.19731010496616364,
1.0238587856292725,
-0.20803415775299072,
0.6257532835006714,
0.372214138507843,
-0.4015466570854187,
0.510299801826477,
-0.20641611516475677,
0.2453705221414566,
-0.8852072954177856,
-0.008753168396651745,
0.050427407026290894,
-0.27972930669784546,
-0.7961119413375854,
0.11444103717803955,
0.5571168661117554,
0.023167157545685768,
-0.7181935906410217,
0.6416571140289307,
-0.12464795261621475,
0.23846766352653503,
-0.3352413475513458,
-0.18315066397190094,
0.010476677678525448,
0.46731191873550415,
0.07523706555366516,
0.818654477596283,
0.5963757038116455,
-0.7570129036903381,
-0.038616079837083817,
0.1304711401462555,
-0.6605044007301331,
0.5163586139678955,
-0.5773404240608215,
0.01688258722424507,
0.007422535214573145,
0.2976531684398651,
-1.0923494100570679,
-0.437624990940094,
0.23003563284873962,
-0.06048230454325676,
0.4407651424407959,
-0.14842212200164795,
-0.37729811668395996,
-0.017041489481925964,
-0.0025027585215866566,
0.44469016790390015,
0.43971875309944153,
-0.8737556338310242,
0.633880615234375,
-0.01908136159181595,
0.22905956208705902,
-0.5237147212028503,
-0.7402233481407166,
-0.25530996918678284,
-0.6855630278587341,
-0.31432726979255676,
0.9157583713531494,
0.1715504378080368,
-0.4392654001712799,
-0.12305294722318649,
0.05637834593653679,
-0.19266869127750397,
0.2943423092365265,
0.47336897253990173,
-0.05750006064772606,
-0.080475814640522,
0.3300790786743164,
0.15824224054813385,
-0.021282751113176346,
0.31914451718330383,
0.09821511805057526,
0.23184551298618317,
-0.05016322433948517,
-0.6290061473846436,
-0.597532331943512,
0.35699018836021423,
0.34123462438583374,
-0.09921212494373322,
0.6386327743530273,
0.4297367036342621,
-0.30262935161590576,
-0.5040082931518555,
-0.20823177695274353,
-0.6573856472969055,
-0.5335313677787781,
0.6187542080879211,
-0.3921540081501007,
-0.41693612933158875,
0.4110584557056427,
-0.285836398601532,
0.0358821339905262,
0.44154131412506104,
0.31734293699264526,
0.05343768745660782,
0.9815890789031982,
1.0029206275939941,
-0.02409716695547104,
0.906550943851471,
-0.23758704960346222,
0.02564079873263836,
-0.7054778933525085,
-0.3617166578769684,
-0.391976535320282,
-0.3560560345649719,
-0.04998059198260307,
-0.33561378717422485,
0.32844340801239014,
0.1888468712568283,
-0.22652100026607513,
0.38224220275878906,
-0.383548378944397,
0.5792093873023987,
0.5195099115371704,
0.4667496979236603,
0.17449860274791718,
-0.021009130403399467,
0.2696634531021118,
-0.12982240319252014,
-0.4861520230770111,
-0.48103752732276917,
1.0316169261932373,
0.11482281982898712,
0.7297617793083191,
0.030722778290510178,
0.4775739908218384,
0.3920971155166626,
0.7994195818901062,
-0.6671024560928345,
0.25248318910598755,
-0.18002234399318695,
-0.2985035181045532,
-0.39275845885276794,
-0.09265656024217606,
-0.7330731153488159,
0.174335777759552,
0.07888298481702805,
-0.8856999278068542,
0.0609789714217186,
0.5057414174079895,
-0.03179720789194107,
0.10032960027456284,
-0.9483972787857056,
1.057628870010376,
-0.17877750098705292,
-0.44220367074012756,
-0.38316628336906433,
-0.4337228238582611,
0.25477135181427,
-0.18846522271633148,
0.149960458278656,
0.43614068627357483,
-0.09898512065410614,
0.699130654335022,
-0.3017118573188782,
1.2860374450683594,
-0.4649026691913605,
-0.2113233506679535,
0.26676157116889954,
-0.010916455648839474,
0.8618285059928894,
-0.0345226414501667,
-0.23729299008846283,
-0.32322582602500916,
-0.5386479496955872,
-0.11114797741174698,
-0.9990423321723938,
0.5656564235687256,
-0.4685382544994354,
-0.5011628270149231,
0.4260992407798767,
-0.5449406504631042,
-0.2375258356332779,
-0.007316038943827152,
0.5340425372123718,
0.7571912407875061,
-0.0436050184071064,
0.5469481348991394,
0.5248501300811768,
0.04668664559721947,
0.5285668969154358,
0.4155905544757843,
-0.01292957179248333,
0.204647958278656,
0.8766030073165894,
-0.29165780544281006,
0.5722782611846924,
0.6341988444328308,
0.37873587012290955,
-0.2949770987033844,
-0.49220800399780273,
-0.3275960385799408,
-0.11986323446035385,
-1.133613109588623,
-0.11211580038070679,
-0.5684396624565125,
0.09835118800401688,
-0.10632569342851639,
-0.6134371757507324,
-0.3188973069190979,
-0.10179595649242401,
-0.3736810088157654,
-0.05580442398786545,
0.16396689414978027,
0.8763754367828369,
0.4554812014102936,
0.8199779391288757,
-0.1183571070432663,
-0.049401767551898956,
0.2654963433742523,
0.23733431100845337,
0.18073171377182007,
-0.8499660491943359,
-0.576810896396637,
-0.10404934734106064,
-0.6388601064682007,
-0.7140139937400818,
0.2544454336166382,
0.3144958019256592,
0.855867326259613,
0.5564988255500793,
0.09029091894626617,
0.8141341805458069,
-0.21283505856990814,
0.6611724495887756,
0.05591518431901932,
-1.323755145072937,
0.6417627334594727,
0.08154825866222382,
0.30535009503364563,
0.4508988857269287,
0.576380729675293,
-0.28285282850265503,
-0.5764304995536804,
-0.9040196537971497,
-0.8694880604743958,
0.935082733631134,
0.0651032030582428,
0.1702243685722351,
0.31842899322509766,
0.5185762643814087,
0.26269370317459106,
0.24663318693637848,
-0.8779234886169434,
-0.3236074447631836,
-0.3329237997531891,
-0.3247821629047394,
-0.3319067060947418,
-0.028769945725798607,
0.009792258962988853,
-0.4341292679309845,
0.6439683437347412,
-0.46740904450416565,
0.2379416525363922,
0.06492073088884354,
-0.46559056639671326,
0.006340453866869211,
0.16676029562950134,
0.7124928832054138,
0.9865296483039856,
-0.005128444172441959,
0.2630041539669037,
0.4473976492881775,
-0.1405511498451233,
0.026919662952423096,
-0.06195838376879692,
-0.24142862856388092,
-0.1240062341094017,
0.7827475070953369,
0.8963639736175537,
0.6856344938278198,
-0.5174885988235474,
0.7984079718589783,
0.12780112028121948,
-0.20249035954475403,
-0.20797394216060638,
0.22677332162857056,
-0.02927343174815178,
0.45982861518859863,
0.47328710556030273,
0.04946838319301605,
0.4288218915462494,
-0.48704206943511963,
0.5794655084609985,
0.42371323704719543,
-1.071265697479248,
-0.39612555503845215,
0.6929957866668701,
-0.0612836591899395,
-0.338149756193161,
0.2830985486507416,
-0.10279620438814163,
-0.5993806719779968,
0.8580264449119568,
0.929348349571228,
0.8078622817993164,
-0.2900072932243347,
0.19528266787528992,
0.23788753151893616,
-0.14332890510559082,
-0.09362971037626266,
-0.13807612657546997,
-0.2940240204334259,
-0.5788813233375549,
-0.6199909448623657,
-0.1661248505115509,
-0.448917955160141,
0.0730920135974884,
-0.7671847939491272,
0.43614935874938965,
-0.12137570977210999,
0.27312442660331726,
0.09998633712530136,
-0.3354182839393616,
-0.713006317615509,
0.2971811294555664,
-0.05936264991760254,
0.6202214956283569,
-1.0846617221832275,
1.0140550136566162,
0.7319395542144775,
-0.17779240012168884,
-0.8699014186859131,
0.2608996629714966,
-0.3159225285053253,
-0.6467970013618469,
1.140705943107605,
0.40219420194625854,
-0.2994040846824646,
-0.05363009497523308,
-0.9048910140991211,
-0.7632818222045898,
1.1112302541732788,
0.561684250831604,
-0.14163826406002045,
0.22257471084594727,
-0.13313768804073334,
0.33021974563598633,
-0.9580392241477966,
0.4933384656906128,
0.23115114867687225,
0.36106255650520325,
-0.05892062559723854,
-0.6821166276931763,
0.3168858587741852,
0.034832388162612915,
-0.3129828870296478,
0.16967272758483887,
-0.41005122661590576,
0.7027032971382141,
-0.17576755583286285,
-0.1661146730184555,
-0.4989745616912842,
0.8602389693260193,
-0.024239610880613327,
0.2755114734172821,
0.8605714440345764,
-0.15621699392795563,
0.5870876312255859,
0.1023288369178772,
1.235456109046936,
-0.022008655592799187,
0.23748351633548737,
1.2822579145431519,
0.1962582916021347,
0.8524360656738281,
0.7190942764282227,
-0.15306755900382996,
0.7766386270523071,
0.253907173871994,
0.07289565354585648,
0.9012728333473206,
0.21379949152469635,
-0.29841941595077515,
-0.2524731755256653,
-0.14924973249435425,
0.13107448816299438,
0.46274635195732117,
0.4014900028705597,
-0.7484090328216553,
-0.16284213960170746,
0.2967160940170288,
0.02824459597468376,
0.16291962563991547,
-0.2785761058330536,
0.6532705426216125,
0.009928157553076744,
-0.7287919521331787,
0.37689730525016785,
-0.14963094890117645,
0.7302505970001221,
-0.660510778427124,
-0.33019396662712097,
0.13302794098854065,
0.5201612114906311,
-0.3028847873210907,
-0.5832571983337402,
0.5336207151412964,
-0.31151074171066284,
-0.3999898135662079,
-0.546799898147583,
0.7246120572090149,
-0.4179202914237976,
-0.5099944472312927,
0.29854339361190796,
0.1202964037656784,
0.16441650688648224,
-0.4213789105415344,
-0.4039733409881592,
-0.30756375193595886,
0.2975742220878601,
-0.2642263174057007,
0.24857664108276367,
0.40722930431365967,
-0.44430866837501526,
0.8191362023353577,
0.2325068563222885,
-0.33845239877700806,
-0.19761578738689423,
-0.07768438011407852,
0.7990165948867798,
-0.4660384953022003,
-0.3419780433177948,
-1.0191251039505005,
0.7759571075439453,
-0.2127234786748886,
-0.3226822316646576,
0.6675062775611877,
0.4813258647918701,
1.0336869955062866,
-0.2979479730129242,
0.8204096555709839,
-0.07706532627344131,
0.40628138184547424,
-0.4001949429512024,
0.5602672696113586,
-0.8426696062088013,
0.06442081928253174,
-0.3113275170326233,
-0.593852162361145,
-0.2921786308288574,
0.47048354148864746,
-0.334281861782074,
-0.171650692820549,
0.7173492312431335,
0.6236233711242676,
-0.5685322880744934,
-0.017798935994505882,
0.3712664842605591,
-0.05418369546532631,
0.5684104561805725,
0.2910584807395935,
0.6934913992881775,
-0.2993854582309723,
0.6237732768058777,
-0.6553149819374084,
-0.39254704117774963,
-0.3042562007904053,
-1.1616969108581543,
-0.8103004693984985,
-0.755730390548706,
-0.439120888710022,
0.13813582062721252,
-0.31964150071144104,
0.7881841659545898,
1.017925500869751,
-0.757091760635376,
-0.3382681906223297,
-0.0663534477353096,
0.06959572434425354,
-0.7584397196769714,
-0.2788935899734497,
0.6407807469367981,
-0.5640912055969238,
-0.7588902711868286,
0.5107941627502441,
-0.19252075254917145,
-0.08866771310567856,
-0.15137238800525665,
-0.05421154201030731,
0.1819761097431183,
-0.30976518988609314,
0.8783604502677917,
0.00020188120834063739,
-0.8523958921432495,
-0.3672664165496826,
-0.32712313532829285,
0.13122086226940155,
0.0910426527261734,
1.1963082551956177,
-0.7967391610145569,
0.18390265107154846,
0.11268264800310135,
0.46818631887435913,
0.7581539750099182,
0.13842561841011047,
0.7795460820198059,
-1.0276157855987549,
0.2595829665660858,
0.022050917148590088,
0.2620893716812134,
0.2843370735645294,
-0.6107379198074341,
0.30343082547187805,
-0.14583192765712738,
-0.4691688120365143,
-0.5977638363838196,
0.3912176489830017,
-0.6704201102256775,
-0.32051193714141846,
1.0019123554229736,
-0.37907353043556213,
-0.10712426900863647,
-0.196969673037529,
-0.026143738999962807,
0.28941506147384644,
-0.48017388582229614,
0.6822396516799927,
0.40575575828552246,
-0.30669504404067993,
-0.13559667766094208,
-0.6407704949378967,
0.814720869064331,
0.48773103952407837,
-0.8675671815872192,
0.3369120657444,
0.010037769563496113,
0.15209725499153137,
0.1499650776386261,
0.2203805148601532,
0.08365882188081741,
-0.0806320309638977,
-0.16569820046424866,
0.046561095863580704,
-0.12131296843290329,
-0.4223003089427948,
-0.22207824885845184,
0.2755875289440155,
0.1339445561170578,
-0.1147933378815651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13754v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13754v1
|
Grounding Toxicity in Real-World Events across Languages
| 2024-05-22T15:38:53 | 2024-05-22T15:38:53 |
Wondimagegnhue Tsegaye Tufa, Ilia Markov, Piek Vossen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media conversations frequently suffer from toxicity, creating
significant issues for users, moderators, and entire communities. Events in the
real world, like elections or conflicts, can initiate and escalate toxic
behavior online. Our study investigates how real-world events influence the
origin and spread of toxicity in online discussions across various languages
and regions. We gathered Reddit data comprising 4.5 million comments from 31
thousand posts in six different languages (Dutch, English, German, Arabic,
Turkish and Spanish). We target fifteen major social and political world events
that occurred between 2020 and 2023. We observe significant variations in
toxicity, negative sentiment, and emotion expressions across different events
and language communities, showing that toxicity is a complex phenomenon in
which many different factors interact and still need to be investigated. We
will release the data for further research along with our code.
|
[
-0.4083445966243744,
-1.120374321937561,
0.631725013256073,
0.6685454249382019,
-0.36234337091445923,
-0.04514047130942345,
-0.021025165915489197,
-0.9732900857925415,
0.4005969166755676,
0.27923277020454407,
-0.5451046228408813,
-0.41293981671333313,
-0.6951600909233093,
0.003361825365573168,
-0.12765055894851685,
1.1024610996246338,
0.12989430129528046,
0.05455220863223076,
-0.01945251226425171,
-0.48064276576042175,
-0.2610948383808136,
-0.9111511707305908,
-0.6979411244392395,
-0.35997459292411804,
1.2044239044189453,
0.46710506081581116,
0.5769003629684448,
0.25466352701187134,
0.6744978427886963,
0.22803382575511932,
-0.3289574980735779,
-0.11849601566791534,
-0.6993734240531921,
0.3329489529132843,
-0.589466392993927,
-0.5316805839538574,
-0.12891270220279694,
0.02860538475215435,
0.09588281065225601,
0.21763230860233307,
-0.043190211057662964,
0.19334900379180908,
-0.19820243120193481,
0.6490394473075867,
-0.7768227458000183,
0.14796163141727448,
-0.4501047730445862,
0.26191115379333496,
-0.05809252709150314,
-0.28954482078552246,
-0.17391487956047058,
-0.6025401949882507,
0.0716947689652443,
-0.5155510902404785,
-0.193840891122818,
-0.4679465591907501,
1.0144538879394531,
-0.151079460978508,
-0.8525024056434631,
-0.5203016996383667,
-0.7432291507720947,
0.7355350852012634,
-0.44040578603744507,
0.17987363040447235,
0.31345120072364807,
0.22850236296653748,
-0.15284813940525055,
-0.5704408288002014,
-0.5435147285461426,
-0.01206381805241108,
-0.0038370811380445957,
0.14632028341293335,
-0.09218785911798477,
-0.12596797943115234,
0.211306631565094,
-0.1528516709804535,
-0.28316226601600647,
-0.21648792922496796,
-0.3863344192504883,
-0.0000349214460584335,
0.640137255191803,
0.17943377792835236,
0.9061762094497681,
-0.21592247486114502,
-0.05939114838838577,
0.05939728766679764,
-1.0077542066574097,
-0.2624524235725403,
0.5719867944717407,
0.08307284861803055,
-0.40527108311653137,
0.3574744462966919,
-0.05380783975124359,
0.3001876175403595,
-0.2140001356601715,
0.20531003177165985,
-0.12055491656064987,
-0.4137122929096222,
0.08936584740877151,
0.027897320687770844,
0.7472272515296936,
1.036108136177063,
0.4480906128883362,
0.10292898118495941,
0.3462038040161133,
0.49651843309402466,
0.23534388840198517,
-1.0147165060043335,
-0.0650368183851242,
0.2485625296831131,
-0.35767361521720886,
-0.6870677471160889,
0.10741112381219864,
-1.005277395248413,
-0.8259766697883606,
-0.01827266253530979,
0.2583923637866974,
0.2575804889202118,
-0.4532957375049591,
-0.06938838958740234,
-0.30756959319114685,
0.16225139796733856,
0.3651981055736542,
-0.2923513650894165,
0.049118734896183014,
0.5578708052635193,
0.7896102070808411,
0.07242603600025177,
-0.06823155283927917,
-0.47383734583854675,
-0.07269667834043503,
-0.3761809170246124,
0.926865816116333,
-0.6359010934829712,
-0.13645276427268982,
0.278156578540802,
0.08004092425107956,
0.32712674140930176,
-0.6105949282646179,
0.7410922050476074,
-0.7445852160453796,
0.2510908246040344,
-0.6084608435630798,
0.008373776450753212,
-0.029477298259735107,
0.3705025911331177,
-0.4281648099422455,
0.8127583861351013,
-0.500972330570221,
-0.9589734077453613,
0.4587790071964264,
-0.536323606967926,
-0.6049174070358276,
-0.11366728693246841,
0.06104377657175064,
-0.3022160530090332,
0.07634184509515762,
-0.19792380928993225,
0.32905998826026917,
-0.10987140238285065,
0.2481895238161087,
-0.40780916810035706,
-0.4145157039165497,
0.2334262579679489,
0.035065293312072754,
0.8137118220329285,
0.31323543190956116,
-0.5138910412788391,
0.23055683076381683,
-0.6446121335029602,
-0.3720202147960663,
0.1982874572277069,
-0.24511954188346863,
-0.6129206418991089,
0.511449933052063,
0.2898974120616913,
0.9025954604148865,
-0.15771573781967163,
-0.7417185306549072,
-0.1237933412194252,
-0.2755054533481598,
0.6791155338287354,
0.37270283699035645,
0.8725312352180481,
0.28174686431884766,
-0.5300419926643372,
0.383853018283844,
0.3645314574241638,
0.2824820578098297,
0.11100492626428604,
-0.7576215863227844,
-0.553384006023407,
0.5913886427879333,
-0.271735817193985,
0.7327005863189697,
-0.40444114804267883,
0.1349770426750183,
-0.16691051423549652,
-0.7145055532455444,
-0.03150773420929909,
-0.4055159389972687,
0.2484419047832489,
0.17685766518115997,
0.1025957241654396,
0.10030882805585861,
-0.7669026255607605,
-0.6246002316474915,
-0.4991709887981415,
-0.4276004135608673,
0.23586519062519073,
0.4325447976589203,
0.30594420433044434,
-0.40535464882850647,
0.7226206064224243,
-0.46864745020866394,
-0.38970237970352173,
-0.024285750463604927,
0.4437626004219055,
-0.21697069704532623,
0.14566680788993835,
0.6147040128707886,
-0.9345974922180176,
-0.9302664995193481,
0.1897890269756317,
-0.8401147127151489,
-0.4049799144268036,
-0.2434099167585373,
-0.34302809834480286,
0.11934308707714081,
0.7067627906799316,
-0.20192213356494904,
0.14232531189918518,
0.7621901631355286,
-0.4470559060573578,
0.32782283425331116,
0.11654330790042877,
0.5893276929855347,
-1.0712229013442993,
-0.18316422402858734,
0.10216578096151352,
-0.02531270869076252,
-0.7488582730293274,
0.05097809433937073,
0.08748050779104233,
0.017401929944753647,
-1.0140496492385864,
0.57234126329422,
-0.0680481493473053,
0.42027148604393005,
-0.05506584793329239,
0.3798830211162567,
0.003838789416477084,
-0.05691960081458092,
0.18550044298171997,
0.49572452902793884,
0.3762384355068207,
-0.5949659943580627,
0.1780657321214676,
0.05642775818705559,
-0.39345839619636536,
0.5178408622741699,
-0.44202855229377747,
-0.1672794222831726,
-0.3721095025539398,
0.39546212553977966,
-0.8672059178352356,
-0.3290421664714813,
0.23641832172870636,
-0.49576571583747864,
-0.4729510247707367,
-0.31869110465049744,
-0.45572373270988464,
-0.1116107925772667,
-0.2284117341041565,
0.14185985922813416,
0.26764124631881714,
-0.14575038850307465,
0.45462706685066223,
0.867847740650177,
-0.20623043179512024,
-0.44758695363998413,
-0.8687633275985718,
0.35652390122413635,
-0.5106023550033569,
-0.6482462882995605,
-0.0566994808614254,
-0.10893995314836502,
-0.8366156816482544,
0.023824265226721764,
0.015488930977880955,
-0.18266689777374268,
0.09731373190879822,
0.44656869769096375,
-0.4289645850658417,
0.12371136248111725,
0.08177126199007034,
0.06553691625595093,
0.1344442516565323,
0.5123440027236938,
0.2653428912162781,
0.548160195350647,
-0.015097544528543949,
-0.09719565510749817,
-0.375034362077713,
0.5362545251846313,
0.9859285354614258,
-0.002659701043739915,
1.0917317867279053,
0.27453455328941345,
-0.47338318824768066,
-0.1357123702764511,
-0.3798476457595825,
-0.24122865498065948,
-0.47073835134506226,
0.4187910854816437,
0.0068693566136062145,
-0.6913322806358337,
1.1094592809677124,
-0.006496640387922525,
0.10135358572006226,
0.26289358735084534,
0.7276737689971924,
-0.22006843984127045,
1.271016001701355,
0.26831746101379395,
0.05493014678359032,
0.6884690523147583,
0.17632944881916046,
0.29526740312576294,
-0.23713700473308563,
-0.24300669133663177,
-0.42972293496131897,
-0.24670960009098053,
-0.6724266409873962,
-0.3684512674808502,
0.2890070676803589,
-0.24697153270244598,
-0.24102619290351868,
0.09968268126249313,
-0.22853100299835205,
0.8005108833312988,
0.06267961859703064,
-0.04003245010972023,
0.28372058272361755,
-0.013162576593458652,
-0.034964654594659805,
-0.519889771938324,
-0.5971032977104187,
-0.5115612745285034,
0.5010111927986145,
0.2299233078956604,
0.6428952813148499,
0.29784199595451355,
0.5105904936790466,
0.46568989753723145,
0.7550950646400452,
-0.4189179837703705,
0.3306489586830139,
0.1777603179216385,
-0.9641334414482117,
0.01509211864322424,
-0.2422824651002884,
-0.8945367932319641,
0.4184275269508362,
-0.2703852951526642,
-0.31818345189094543,
0.3085043728351593,
0.054161880165338516,
-0.02923467382788658,
0.21015435457229614,
-0.730408787727356,
0.7046090364456177,
-0.10358461737632751,
-0.5169772505760193,
-0.3807070851325989,
-0.8371635675430298,
0.33735916018486023,
-0.020524373278021812,
0.9010920524597168,
-0.2617054283618927,
0.1346302032470703,
0.6998847723007202,
-0.09540227055549622,
1.1111035346984863,
-0.09857847541570663,
-0.39030468463897705,
0.518684446811676,
0.10612969100475311,
0.6416754722595215,
0.2700532078742981,
-0.042891841381788254,
0.17912742495536804,
0.01031423732638359,
-0.41550174355506897,
-0.13046690821647644,
1.0358608961105347,
-0.9903720617294312,
-0.20845367014408112,
-0.47107911109924316,
-0.09144340455532074,
-0.10605451464653015,
-0.053702469915151596,
0.46018674969673157,
0.05508505553007126,
-0.4042716324329376,
0.03767441585659981,
0.4932137429714203,
-0.43069034814834595,
0.2319840043783188,
0.630162239074707,
-0.19153405725955963,
-0.24974022805690765,
1.1390372514724731,
0.3495689332485199,
0.34971755743026733,
0.08539783209562302,
0.47626176476478577,
0.09641829878091812,
-0.08586374670267105,
-0.31128886342048645,
0.30751070380210876,
-0.9089600443840027,
-0.2980727255344391,
-0.8557004928588867,
0.03758310154080391,
-0.1329425424337387,
-0.46982917189598083,
-0.3535744845867157,
-0.19139140844345093,
-0.2749539315700531,
-0.4542871117591858,
0.21719901263713837,
0.8847611546516418,
-0.22900579869747162,
0.29957515001296997,
-1.1527639627456665,
0.08945053070783615,
0.2700517475605011,
0.5828384757041931,
-0.10258045047521591,
-0.22605416178703308,
-0.10531382262706757,
0.12627670168876648,
-0.18802563846111298,
-1.4752626419067383,
0.27128589153289795,
0.16596542298793793,
0.27417054772377014,
0.5987933874130249,
0.31329891085624695,
0.8559899926185608,
-0.4274592101573944,
0.9357119798660278,
-0.2154877483844757,
-0.6018415689468384,
0.6801907420158386,
-0.8940122127532959,
0.04554634913802147,
0.49998971819877625,
0.6445242762565613,
-1.2809977531433105,
-0.862687349319458,
-0.6722328066825867,
-0.9272351861000061,
0.7179369330406189,
0.048264890909194946,
0.6776689291000366,
-0.5156100988388062,
0.2776329815387726,
-0.21152417361736298,
-0.1502230167388916,
-1.1449313163757324,
-0.5373157262802124,
0.10050106793642044,
0.25583213567733765,
0.31774017214775085,
-0.6812954545021057,
-0.40522289276123047,
-0.12554123997688293,
0.6703330278396606,
0.35416164994239807,
-0.15158675611019135,
0.024012329056859016,
-0.22823618352413177,
-0.8186519742012024,
0.2691226005554199,
0.7452965974807739,
0.6185739040374756,
-0.15898112952709198,
0.3257150948047638,
0.11358044296503067,
-0.5078413486480713,
0.3283845782279968,
-0.4056996703147888,
-0.15028543770313263,
-0.23815736174583435,
0.3635615110397339,
0.3755396604537964,
0.48435044288635254,
-0.9353156685829163,
0.4868321716785431,
-0.24453787505626678,
-0.29045370221138,
-0.20032744109630585,
-0.16166093945503235,
0.4864744246006012,
0.14172764122486115,
0.2966780960559845,
-0.18409331142902374,
0.004487146157771349,
-0.9636160731315613,
0.45706939697265625,
0.0395236574113369,
-0.5629869699478149,
-0.5174173712730408,
0.5987212061882019,
0.6116122007369995,
-0.02614639326930046,
0.26160648465156555,
-0.25953564047813416,
-0.6021877527236938,
0.6788546442985535,
0.6339331269264221,
0.3630406856536865,
-0.14889010787010193,
0.39037033915519714,
0.675003707408905,
0.3286246955394745,
0.2052815854549408,
0.43070995807647705,
0.40933844447135925,
-0.7742872834205627,
-0.4211733341217041,
-0.6261075139045715,
-0.4023703634738922,
0.3227488696575165,
-0.4887657165527344,
0.25819677114486694,
-0.4267957806587219,
-0.29176008701324463,
-0.24115216732025146,
0.05022890865802765,
-0.1973409503698349,
0.06846924871206284,
0.3172090947628021,
0.6149868965148926,
-1.756433367729187,
0.3381720781326294,
1.0643917322158813,
-0.35234975814819336,
-0.09405096620321274,
0.05622628331184387,
0.26057055592536926,
-0.2494519203901291,
0.7708055973052979,
0.16021403670310974,
-0.006883630529046059,
-0.09494782239198685,
-0.502024233341217,
-0.8555945158004761,
0.39267706871032715,
0.08648476749658585,
-0.3593733608722687,
0.23325155675411224,
0.16088268160820007,
0.9244199395179749,
-0.013719223439693451,
-0.01911880262196064,
0.3122096657752991,
0.6384586095809937,
0.02881128154695034,
-0.6347164511680603,
-0.06579860299825668,
-0.3483232259750366,
-0.2330210953950882,
0.24973632395267487,
-0.844463050365448,
0.5425788760185242,
0.050212010741233826,
-0.6468752026557922,
-0.6636044979095459,
0.39887332916259766,
0.17153476178646088,
0.29453492164611816,
0.294342964887619,
0.3194299638271332,
0.3205972909927368,
-0.1491590142250061,
0.8710394501686096,
-0.3783309757709503,
0.2392900288105011,
0.7575882077217102,
-0.39589136838912964,
0.7708766460418701,
0.380747526884079,
-0.13762645423412323,
0.8479259014129639,
0.6963732242584229,
0.4642162621021271,
0.32701805233955383,
0.22060658037662506,
-0.4670839011669159,
-0.3479818105697632,
-0.37227487564086914,
-0.22144430875778198,
0.10314855724573135,
0.6263891458511353,
-0.16057418286800385,
-0.6301860809326172,
0.34564587473869324,
0.3018345236778259,
0.2135992795228958,
-0.09237942099571228,
0.8469355702400208,
0.0053560310043394566,
-0.7145927548408508,
0.19291181862354279,
0.1181565597653389,
0.6604974865913391,
-0.3983868956565857,
-0.17115838825702667,
-0.3018031418323517,
0.06700418144464493,
-0.32698550820350647,
-0.902554452419281,
0.763961136341095,
0.002451266860589385,
0.08422168344259262,
-0.2400778830051422,
0.7725226283073425,
-0.23118199408054352,
-0.22200211882591248,
0.7670493721961975,
0.6703307032585144,
0.13483723998069763,
-0.46769949793815613,
-0.6128552556037903,
0.42746421694755554,
-0.22129106521606445,
-0.41056668758392334,
0.7825904488563538,
0.5828244686126709,
-0.5247673392295837,
0.6271153092384338,
0.7398449182510376,
0.1394917070865631,
0.3936173617839813,
0.1464126855134964,
0.7806437015533447,
-0.5648093819618225,
-0.437989741563797,
-0.8252649903297424,
0.5474001169204712,
-0.047658227384090424,
-0.1259017437696457,
0.7100819945335388,
0.40332430601119995,
0.6072880029678345,
0.06892924010753632,
0.8131040930747986,
-0.45873814821243286,
0.23477725684642792,
0.06576374173164368,
1.0217394828796387,
-0.5126698017120361,
-0.10170286893844604,
-0.24066774547100067,
-0.6342427730560303,
-0.661958634853363,
0.6942901611328125,
-0.22015097737312317,
-0.30003178119659424,
0.4487288296222687,
0.539985716342926,
0.32878661155700684,
-0.25997063517570496,
0.26103243231773376,
0.372753769159317,
0.6226863265037537,
0.17266720533370972,
1.1729941368103027,
-0.2545236051082611,
0.6534237861633301,
-0.47217506170272827,
-0.11236585676670074,
-0.5084131956100464,
-1.0171395540237427,
-0.7337383031845093,
-0.6180136203765869,
-0.46898362040519714,
-0.6063142418861389,
0.21417897939682007,
0.7594835162162781,
0.27941471338272095,
-0.9249064922332764,
-0.040620677173137665,
-0.3070410490036011,
0.5342055559158325,
-0.010652639903128147,
-0.38684937357902527,
0.10098248720169067,
-0.3873325288295746,
-0.7847755551338196,
-0.1311475932598114,
0.22352126240730286,
-0.1029679924249649,
0.08569507300853729,
0.18592461943626404,
-0.4192691445350647,
0.32755884528160095,
1.1151045560836792,
0.3664414882659912,
-0.4285513460636139,
-0.5649626851081848,
-0.033224042505025864,
-0.3556438088417053,
-0.021834008395671844,
0.7554627060890198,
-0.5298434495925903,
0.3204050660133362,
0.9831153154373169,
-0.0047555952332913876,
0.061068058013916016,
0.13280627131462097,
0.5868539214134216,
-0.7187735438346863,
0.2521284520626068,
0.31077176332473755,
-0.03644060343503952,
0.23182787001132965,
-0.452938973903656,
0.37232065200805664,
0.4270132780075073,
-0.6947693824768066,
-0.9789202213287354,
0.2611112594604492,
-0.6517357230186462,
-0.3318363428115845,
1.3579360246658325,
0.1907173991203308,
0.09355594217777252,
-0.3800962567329407,
-0.18119284510612488,
0.19209933280944824,
-0.30825650691986084,
1.1423217058181763,
1.0782690048217773,
-0.3370656371116638,
-0.015293608419597149,
-0.8776218891143799,
0.6563621759414673,
0.12674807012081146,
-1.0504668951034546,
0.39295780658721924,
0.6677857041358948,
0.3699171543121338,
0.19606833159923553,
0.638248085975647,
-0.23191426694393158,
0.43509769439697266,
-0.14255593717098236,
-0.03227571025490761,
0.6191143989562988,
-0.41884568333625793,
-0.1131020188331604,
0.3393678665161133,
-0.08249133825302124,
0.4229412376880646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13684v1
|
CrossCheckGPT: Universal Hallucination Ranking for Multimodal Foundation Models
| 2024-05-22T14:25:41 | 2024-05-22T14:25:41 |
Guangzhi Sun, Potsawee Manakul, Adian Liusie, Kunat Pipatanakul, Chao Zhang, Phil Woodland, Mark Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal foundation models are prone to hallucination, generating outputs
that either contradict the input or are not grounded by factual information.
Given the diversity in architectures, training data and instruction tuning
techniques, there can be large variations in systems' susceptibility to
hallucinations. To assess system hallucination robustness, hallucination
ranking approaches have been developed for specific tasks such as image
captioning, question answering, summarization, or biography generation.
However, these approaches typically compare model outputs to gold-standard
references or labels, limiting hallucination benchmarking for new domains. This
work proposes "CrossCheckGPT", a reference-free universal hallucination ranking
for multimodal foundation models. The core idea of CrossCheckGPT is that the
same hallucinated content is unlikely to be generated by different independent
systems, hence cross-system consistency can provide meaningful and accurate
hallucination assessment scores. CrossCheckGPT can be applied to any model or
task, provided that the information consistency between outputs can be measured
through an appropriate distance metric. Focusing on multimodal large language
models that generate text, we explore two information consistency measures:
CrossCheck-explicit and CrossCheck-implicit. We showcase the applicability of
our method for hallucination ranking across various modalities, namely the
text, image, and audio-visual domains. Further, we propose the first
audio-visual hallucination benchmark, "AVHalluBench", and illustrate the
effectiveness of CrossCheckGPT, achieving correlations of 98% and 89% with
human judgements on MHaluBench and AVHalluBench, respectively.
|
[
-0.7294626832008362,
-0.7164683938026428,
0.4817224144935608,
0.37331321835517883,
-0.19288992881774902,
-0.17261643707752228,
-0.1554407924413681,
-0.6573473811149597,
0.39081165194511414,
0.39757969975471497,
-0.4662492275238037,
-0.6006104946136475,
-0.7103504538536072,
-0.07211284339427948,
-0.5866938829421997,
0.934687077999115,
-0.033622585237026215,
-0.009693430736660957,
-0.4439952075481415,
-0.20919960737228394,
-0.5257275700569153,
-0.5004059672355652,
-0.1489117592573166,
-0.35621407628059387,
0.45663973689079285,
0.06861025840044022,
0.9516635537147522,
0.2800096869468689,
0.4892638027667999,
0.2642824053764343,
0.41725796461105347,
0.10255712270736694,
-0.45478466153144836,
0.2549104690551758,
-0.3745201826095581,
0.1394992172718048,
-0.2676587700843811,
-0.03654990345239639,
0.3637382984161377,
0.6097220182418823,
0.09989506006240845,
-0.06988176703453064,
0.07726065814495087,
0.4349063038825989,
-0.8375413417816162,
0.12027046084403992,
-0.61746746301651,
0.11828727275133133,
0.18376566469669342,
-0.5637958645820618,
-0.4227283298969269,
-0.4839702546596527,
0.12532512843608856,
-0.15841510891914368,
0.41133618354797363,
-0.0031784982420504093,
0.7190449833869934,
0.4511394202709198,
-0.33598592877388,
-0.34682580828666687,
-0.5839656591415405,
0.5441979765892029,
-0.26846474409103394,
0.9523388147354126,
0.5878891944885254,
0.3223935663700104,
0.13463439047336578,
-0.5488718152046204,
-0.48025447130203247,
-0.5329050421714783,
-0.1880115568637848,
0.005325762089341879,
-0.16844037175178528,
-0.028381234034895897,
0.1778300255537033,
0.3366793394088745,
-0.889039933681488,
-0.3399255573749542,
-0.08768963813781738,
-0.5278878211975098,
0.3826785087585449,
-0.053985845297575,
0.31421613693237305,
-0.1453104168176651,
-0.5017865896224976,
-0.38418495655059814,
-0.5201743245124817,
-0.17212699353694916,
0.1954997032880783,
0.1400652378797531,
0.1894138753414154,
0.766200602054596,
-0.46129342913627625,
0.49418362975120544,
0.14014331996440887,
-0.03827380761504173,
0.24875129759311676,
-0.552501380443573,
-0.28122276067733765,
0.24994562566280365,
0.7153627276420593,
0.41200754046440125,
0.11140832304954529,
-0.6661245226860046,
-0.16665183007717133,
0.3613857626914978,
0.41727975010871887,
-0.8294957280158997,
-0.5100316405296326,
0.11835218220949173,
-0.3934391438961029,
-0.22354097664356232,
0.296653687953949,
-0.9185227155685425,
-0.41530871391296387,
-0.20479312539100647,
0.79095858335495,
-0.4495532810688019,
-0.22017601132392883,
0.04096663370728493,
0.13247346878051758,
0.009623744525015354,
0.15871074795722961,
-0.9495232701301575,
0.2556394338607788,
0.3060314655303955,
0.8337972164154053,
-0.4534766674041748,
-0.5941368937492371,
-0.580629289150238,
0.12899863719940186,
-0.19418340921401978,
0.897476315498352,
-0.5705829858779907,
-0.20490476489067078,
-0.12167123705148697,
0.2676698565483093,
-0.049199312925338745,
-0.5194954872131348,
0.39491432905197144,
-0.09402556717395782,
-0.07320009171962738,
-0.33326905965805054,
-0.3003509044647217,
-0.34854042530059814,
0.27729085087776184,
-0.794185996055603,
1.0504024028778076,
0.04567199945449829,
-0.8343305587768555,
0.5400720834732056,
-0.15591047704219818,
-0.337335467338562,
-0.1555117815732956,
-0.3328315019607544,
-0.3116256892681122,
-0.07940525561571121,
0.2050064206123352,
0.5802592635154724,
-0.2619611620903015,
0.36306872963905334,
-0.3407514691352844,
-0.5346733331680298,
-0.03972756117582321,
-0.46347707509994507,
0.5011134743690491,
-0.25016775727272034,
-0.9643914699554443,
0.16154347360134125,
-0.7679669857025146,
0.2263893187046051,
-0.17223858833312988,
-0.17892318964004517,
-0.45553267002105713,
-0.25174739956855774,
0.4044605493545532,
0.3869781792163849,
-0.13768510520458221,
-0.35892367362976074,
0.09585051238536835,
0.2670874297618866,
0.10166747123003006,
0.6186581254005432,
-0.08532693237066269,
-0.02818857692182064,
-0.4461250305175781,
0.26344797015190125,
-0.21491600573062897,
-0.08070120960474014,
-0.06499715149402618,
-0.5132374167442322,
-0.8095634579658508,
-0.2769638001918793,
0.266908198595047,
0.5761277675628662,
-0.6019494533538818,
0.6127198338508606,
-0.3869361877441406,
-0.5695987343788147,
-0.40421971678733826,
-0.03678425773978233,
0.5083150863647461,
0.14943568408489227,
0.5439462065696716,
-0.5447902083396912,
-0.4640596807003021,
-0.906145453453064,
-0.09301915019750595,
-0.11490839719772339,
0.04463248699903488,
0.2726745307445526,
0.6977925300598145,
-0.626805305480957,
0.456725150346756,
-0.12636205554008484,
-0.3076448142528534,
0.23421691358089447,
0.38431316614151,
-0.44070303440093994,
0.4931657314300537,
0.2803676724433899,
-0.7981140613555908,
-0.2139127105474472,
-0.00617476599290967,
-0.825444221496582,
-0.06490205228328705,
-0.14565345644950867,
-0.12639972567558289,
0.3053697347640991,
0.398011714220047,
-0.7084011435508728,
0.6189066767692566,
0.7687503695487976,
-0.5651891827583313,
0.6491694450378418,
-0.030724331736564636,
0.6315258741378784,
-0.6934547424316406,
0.23513178527355194,
-0.23005051910877228,
-0.329353928565979,
-0.30421850085258484,
-0.04518214240670204,
-0.07185032218694687,
0.008718971163034439,
-0.08374281972646713,
0.48619669675827026,
-0.3109840750694275,
-0.3262036144733429,
0.0029927431605756283,
0.1475721150636673,
-0.1848154515028,
0.603679358959198,
0.28873512148857117,
0.6261544227600098,
0.41524311900138855,
-0.4457210600376129,
0.5096927881240845,
0.2261027991771698,
-0.4684380292892456,
0.6579092741012573,
-0.4787798523902893,
0.18603354692459106,
0.21865211427211761,
0.16853752732276917,
-1.233016014099121,
-0.14815281331539154,
0.09160563349723816,
-0.5137866735458374,
0.051924336701631546,
0.3485962152481079,
-0.4665587842464447,
0.2664159834384918,
-0.21206878125667572,
0.5693601965904236,
0.07854457199573517,
-0.6149847507476807,
0.5221253037452698,
0.20915375649929047,
-0.09901699423789978,
-0.6644490957260132,
-0.5440738201141357,
0.07105493545532227,
0.22463886439800262,
-0.8807516694068909,
0.41287145018577576,
-0.31046441197395325,
0.018351495265960693,
0.04577689617872238,
-0.3495492935180664,
0.08328413218259811,
-0.3847121298313141,
0.5326299667358398,
-0.06506452709436417,
-0.1435098499059677,
0.21943530440330505,
-0.0016763668972998857,
-0.09135285764932632,
-0.048130933195352554,
-0.0994337648153305,
0.6915364861488342,
-0.2697145342826843,
-0.6716061234474182,
-0.19091664254665375,
0.5520504713058472,
0.6569042801856995,
-0.03863814100623131,
0.4661697447299957,
0.8896922469139099,
-0.48856988549232483,
-0.07262400537729263,
-0.7771506309509277,
-0.43077877163887024,
-0.33812129497528076,
0.3547942340373993,
-0.5735646486282349,
-0.8052247166633606,
0.4535078704357147,
0.15306133031845093,
-0.16595172882080078,
0.3229418098926544,
0.7644177079200745,
0.4687442481517792,
1.0862464904785156,
0.6873629689216614,
0.09554723650217056,
0.051139481365680695,
0.04121239110827446,
0.248016357421875,
-0.36208778619766235,
-0.5041304230690002,
-0.5004872679710388,
-0.13778847455978394,
-0.6497302651405334,
-0.31527504324913025,
0.015722626820206642,
-0.031024467200040817,
0.0028020774479955435,
0.29408949613571167,
-0.5767369866371155,
0.4329463839530945,
0.5305342078208923,
0.12781749665737152,
0.5333709716796875,
0.26812416315078735,
-0.4634176194667816,
-0.05338408425450325,
-0.3780789375305176,
-0.31002622842788696,
0.8217498660087585,
0.03079083003103733,
0.9332273006439209,
0.10681179910898209,
0.6278848052024841,
0.4954286813735962,
0.1937495470046997,
-0.4785081744194031,
0.47706499695777893,
0.1171044334769249,
-0.577633798122406,
-0.5721576809883118,
-0.3664795160293579,
-0.6709148287773132,
0.49682384729385376,
-0.4349420368671417,
-0.7847815752029419,
0.3425033390522003,
-0.10474862903356552,
-0.09054642170667648,
0.19933553040027618,
-0.3909810781478882,
0.9445041418075562,
-0.041739530861377716,
-0.5195313096046448,
-0.09052383899688721,
-0.5823280811309814,
0.4912886917591095,
0.001904073404148221,
-0.10925047844648361,
0.029697438701987267,
0.20592977106571198,
0.5038593411445618,
-0.004872716031968594,
0.7547248601913452,
0.19811514019966125,
-0.1414920836687088,
-0.11489841341972351,
0.42101913690567017,
0.39750486612319946,
0.16150683164596558,
0.237034872174263,
0.4149390459060669,
0.16980578005313873,
-0.2571123242378235,
-0.5616427659988403,
1.0388120412826538,
-0.6063013076782227,
-0.34989428520202637,
-0.49091091752052307,
-0.7168067097663879,
-0.35377779603004456,
0.2929137647151947,
0.5522060394287109,
0.2808309495449066,
-0.3610324561595917,
0.47778573632240295,
0.8512871265411377,
-0.08703255653381348,
0.14049363136291504,
0.17130370438098907,
-0.2813204824924469,
-0.507075846195221,
1.057971477508545,
-0.01791265979409218,
0.32153886556625366,
0.49143823981285095,
-0.11061558127403259,
-0.45197340846061707,
-0.1933632791042328,
-0.3807770013809204,
0.1280468851327896,
-1.0815272331237793,
0.010766972787678242,
-0.9179689288139343,
-0.3161849081516266,
-0.6486790776252747,
-0.2118920087814331,
-0.3349458873271942,
-0.4723100960254669,
0.33572763204574585,
-0.15636081993579865,
-0.027925025671720505,
0.5572308897972107,
-0.18983347713947296,
-0.3320770561695099,
-0.427007257938385,
0.6161731481552124,
0.5340972542762756,
0.5959517955780029,
-0.018294936046004295,
-0.06883621960878372,
0.014151296578347683,
-0.17330172657966614,
-0.3709024488925934,
-0.7731698155403137,
0.08847643435001373,
-0.030591042712330818,
0.763641357421875,
0.3595260679721832,
-0.06252121180295944,
0.6486445665359497,
-0.21561619639396667,
0.6184512972831726,
0.2524462044239044,
-1.0489805936813354,
0.2835181951522827,
-0.12131107598543167,
0.2568107843399048,
0.6096511483192444,
0.5143905878067017,
-0.5980256795883179,
-0.5074501037597656,
-0.43864476680755615,
-0.6289659738540649,
0.32685285806655884,
0.4745207130908966,
-0.2671175003051758,
0.13618099689483643,
-0.15475621819496155,
0.5449789762496948,
0.17472904920578003,
-1.017383337020874,
-0.06355999410152435,
-0.6629728078842163,
-0.08975256234407425,
-0.2777467370033264,
-0.1740514189004898,
-0.224403977394104,
-0.3337317705154419,
0.6978574395179749,
-0.10016103833913803,
0.37210148572921753,
0.31441381573677063,
-0.3863433301448822,
-0.1848931461572647,
0.13560298085212708,
0.8784562349319458,
0.8326014280319214,
-0.3424306809902191,
0.46910831332206726,
-0.13354480266571045,
-0.64017254114151,
0.242389976978302,
0.11954566836357117,
-0.22955331206321716,
0.3140343725681305,
0.43306171894073486,
0.8258931040763855,
0.39577561616897583,
-0.6779849529266357,
0.5523630976676941,
-0.141065314412117,
-0.31698551774024963,
-0.02597994916141033,
-0.03976389020681381,
-0.06664001941680908,
0.25582513213157654,
0.07842589914798737,
0.04852794110774994,
0.2659439742565155,
-0.6008079648017883,
0.5225923657417297,
0.5342223048210144,
-0.7496910095214844,
-0.13669179379940033,
0.6809751391410828,
0.030349016189575195,
-0.09731738269329071,
0.572278618812561,
0.07996109127998352,
-0.2808730900287628,
0.31829702854156494,
0.5519152879714966,
1.185944676399231,
-0.4649655222892761,
0.3747345209121704,
0.24700069427490234,
0.7693477272987366,
-0.23128163814544678,
0.33062300086021423,
-0.32344311475753784,
-0.532527506351471,
-0.08449393510818481,
-0.6734476089477539,
-0.3920164406299591,
0.26801976561546326,
-0.48653489351272583,
0.2548270523548126,
-0.28944000601768494,
-0.06355904042720795,
0.10789807885885239,
-0.21409133076667786,
-0.5679252743721008,
0.40750983357429504,
-0.020506931468844414,
0.5025015473365784,
-0.9342418313026428,
0.7305782437324524,
0.4700378179550171,
-0.5431995987892151,
-0.30041277408599854,
0.21876001358032227,
-0.09274446964263916,
-0.5368515849113464,
0.4953756630420685,
0.4296514391899109,
-0.47138696908950806,
-0.2255377620458603,
-0.2992747128009796,
-0.7421178817749023,
1.1453782320022583,
0.3852587938308716,
-0.2919621765613556,
-0.03816963732242584,
0.27600353956222534,
0.34207162261009216,
-0.4899820387363434,
0.2999233603477478,
0.43784964084625244,
0.6426689624786377,
0.1565130054950714,
-0.9399968385696411,
0.5654853582382202,
-0.40204912424087524,
-0.03787977993488312,
0.21197393536567688,
-0.4957065284252167,
0.7888574004173279,
-0.2811637818813324,
-0.10842011868953705,
0.12053760886192322,
0.34055033326148987,
0.3341023325920105,
0.35621747374534607,
0.543138861656189,
0.6736189126968384,
0.5063151717185974,
-0.1792295277118683,
0.8639741539955139,
-0.19652242958545685,
0.29813751578330994,
0.953773558139801,
-0.1545356959104538,
0.6501114368438721,
0.644392728805542,
0.17137770354747772,
0.3843626081943512,
0.5682352185249329,
-0.2041478008031845,
0.7628979086875916,
0.040583256632089615,
0.0144124124199152,
-0.5205952525138855,
0.06619410216808319,
-0.736341118812561,
0.4321441948413849,
-0.08685220777988434,
-0.41244402527809143,
-0.23781457543373108,
0.04523536190390587,
-0.33355143666267395,
-0.29507943987846375,
0.11982980370521545,
0.5819926261901855,
-0.06169343367218971,
-0.7433604598045349,
0.9100033044815063,
-0.18083128333091736,
0.37234923243522644,
-0.44609829783439636,
-0.34869149327278137,
-0.2688126266002655,
0.1222134605050087,
-0.263144850730896,
-0.40018337965011597,
0.15899096429347992,
-0.33414986729621887,
-0.42173683643341064,
0.10968978703022003,
0.5858058929443359,
-0.6490729451179504,
-0.48112955689430237,
0.594866931438446,
0.36019203066825867,
0.3325013816356659,
-0.3217098116874695,
-0.3901025950908661,
0.23011048138141632,
-0.05608740076422691,
-0.22775958478450775,
0.358380526304245,
0.4015621244907379,
-0.2935115098953247,
0.6929455995559692,
0.5913164019584656,
-0.13142365217208862,
0.2103278934955597,
0.0760262981057167,
0.7189595103263855,
-0.8004492521286011,
-0.4935449957847595,
-0.6998636722564697,
0.25134024024009705,
0.03842870891094208,
-0.4172506630420685,
0.7834547162055969,
0.5487672686576843,
1.0541391372680664,
-0.017834631726145744,
0.8394497632980347,
-0.034600015729665756,
0.15898244082927704,
-0.6275461912155151,
0.8302076458930969,
-0.7549048662185669,
-0.054774172604084015,
-0.6995639801025391,
-1.3875315189361572,
-0.31164881587028503,
0.6293081045150757,
0.11030789464712143,
0.17936518788337708,
1.07978093624115,
0.9307984709739685,
-0.36298084259033203,
0.21344077587127686,
0.6524602174758911,
0.02019147016108036,
0.028458122164011,
0.6201203465461731,
0.7221125364303589,
-0.43204545974731445,
0.7536503076553345,
-0.4460211396217346,
-0.33106768131256104,
-0.392992228269577,
-0.7855453491210938,
-1.1247464418411255,
-0.814448356628418,
-0.1893198937177658,
-0.5228719115257263,
0.1992359459400177,
0.48742252588272095,
0.8673465251922607,
-1.0145387649536133,
-0.12109298259019852,
0.1672675460577011,
0.007833476178348064,
-0.5312241315841675,
-0.22054630517959595,
0.5945202112197876,
-0.0478656068444252,
-0.47256404161453247,
0.19360847771167755,
0.423188716173172,
-0.031139058992266655,
-0.6425402164459229,
-0.213317409157753,
-0.16934894025325775,
0.08541273325681686,
0.6375698447227478,
0.0028307088650763035,
-1.0785623788833618,
-0.42223674058914185,
0.14166204631328583,
-0.26238328218460083,
0.018202999606728554,
0.9586126208305359,
-0.6326347589492798,
0.6187343001365662,
0.719856321811676,
0.7478120923042297,
0.5725730061531067,
-0.10684694349765778,
0.2558079659938812,
-0.48829564452171326,
0.05900750681757927,
0.13479629158973694,
0.24753569066524506,
0.42070817947387695,
-0.38202160596847534,
0.6003214716911316,
0.2839675545692444,
-0.5865371227264404,
-0.8798302412033081,
0.08774229884147644,
-1.0761982202529907,
-0.24074512720108032,
1.0586010217666626,
0.11845115572214127,
0.1441071331501007,
-0.20674878358840942,
-0.20223945379257202,
0.09681923687458038,
-0.2885003089904785,
1.3286956548690796,
1.022926688194275,
-0.15981902182102203,
-0.3199649453163147,
-0.5832713842391968,
0.5334652066230774,
0.45239290595054626,
-0.9075761437416077,
0.10008610039949417,
0.5528237819671631,
0.20287908613681793,
0.5147562026977539,
0.5583227276802063,
-0.2178996503353119,
0.48441535234451294,
0.2332422137260437,
0.31150758266448975,
0.047178760170936584,
-0.7106941938400269,
-0.02027291990816593,
0.42247700691223145,
-0.4864843487739563,
0.029437297955155373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13640v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13640v1
|
Knowledge Graph Reasoning with Self-supervised Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-05-22T13:39:33 | 2024-05-22T13:39:33 |
Ying Ma, Owen Burns, Mingqiu Wang, Gang Li, Nan Du, Laurent El Shafey, Liqiang Wang, Izhak Shafran, Hagen Soltau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Reinforcement learning (RL) is an effective method of finding reasoning
pathways in incomplete knowledge graphs (KGs). To overcome the challenges of a
large action space, a self-supervised pre-training method is proposed to warm
up the policy network before the RL training stage. To alleviate the
distributional mismatch issue in general self-supervised RL (SSRL), in our
supervised learning (SL) stage, the agent selects actions based on the policy
network and learns from generated labels; this self-generation of labels is the
intuition behind the name self-supervised. With this training framework, the
information density of our SL objective is increased and the agent is prevented
from getting stuck with the early rewarded paths. Our self-supervised RL (SSRL)
method improves the performance of RL by pairing it with the wide coverage
achieved by SL during pretraining, since the breadth of the SL objective makes
it infeasible to train an agent with that alone. We show that our SSRL model
meets or exceeds current state-of-the-art results on all Hits@k and mean
reciprocal rank (MRR) metrics on four large benchmark KG datasets. This SSRL
method can be used as a plug-in for any RL architecture for a KGR task. We
adopt two RL architectures, i.e., MINERVA and MultiHopKG as our baseline RL
models and experimentally show that our SSRL model consistently outperforms
both baselines on all of these four KG reasoning tasks. Full code for the paper
available at
https://github.com/owenonline/Knowledge-Graph-Reasoning-with-Self-supervised-Reinforcement-Learning.
|
[
-0.3929738998413086,
-0.4901410639286041,
0.4532366394996643,
0.16086667776107788,
0.06462430953979492,
-0.003285801038146019,
0.15188837051391602,
-0.10324399918317795,
0.1727694272994995,
0.6891887187957764,
-0.8050081133842468,
-0.5979851484298706,
-0.42006000876426697,
0.03431805595755577,
0.03650014474987984,
1.0250160694122314,
-0.23290510475635529,
-0.18986231088638306,
-0.30800455808639526,
-0.24151276051998138,
-0.25619351863861084,
-0.38249894976615906,
-0.6569995284080505,
-0.6890337467193604,
0.7407000064849854,
0.13316091895103455,
0.5807666778564453,
0.637995183467865,
0.1063072606921196,
0.35470035672187805,
0.23795118927955627,
0.4833426773548126,
-0.4673119783401489,
0.30653658509254456,
-0.23801381886005402,
-0.007027846295386553,
-0.25528445839881897,
0.1252792328596115,
0.4086565375328064,
0.1877257376909256,
-0.23211871087551117,
0.05308295786380768,
0.014653286896646023,
0.9358529448509216,
-0.7939044833183289,
0.43603280186653137,
-0.09937243163585663,
0.43276527523994446,
0.1422480046749115,
-0.10999320447444916,
-0.6224799752235413,
-0.27596983313560486,
-0.07014802098274231,
-0.8634095191955566,
-0.006334294099360704,
0.15455211699008942,
0.6405021548271179,
0.5856195092201233,
-0.5710936188697815,
-0.1495901197195053,
-0.6119915843009949,
0.48475533723831177,
-0.4354206919670105,
0.6186679601669312,
0.3410743772983551,
0.6423798203468323,
-0.1887374073266983,
-0.8617022037506104,
-0.30563074350357056,
-0.3313409090042114,
-0.39363840222358704,
0.4075929522514343,
0.11620829999446869,
0.06897445023059845,
0.3776094317436218,
-0.2916679084300995,
-0.6756117939949036,
0.01152533758431673,
-0.22956661880016327,
-0.40262579917907715,
0.7222446799278259,
0.22650429606437683,
-0.07272962480783463,
-0.24122393131256104,
-0.5640674233436584,
-0.2779899537563324,
-0.5549623370170593,
0.06982242316007614,
0.35976892709732056,
0.4302390515804291,
0.16700266301631927,
0.29053065180778503,
-0.5655105710029602,
0.8100884556770325,
-0.03730640187859535,
-0.1266455352306366,
0.2854680120944977,
-0.24159710109233856,
-0.20612478256225586,
0.046444542706012726,
0.9585009813308716,
0.04079271852970123,
0.3583007752895355,
-0.1515079140663147,
-0.17405147850513458,
-0.22676780819892883,
0.37290090322494507,
-0.6563574075698853,
-0.5015295743942261,
0.0806274339556694,
-0.30155259370803833,
-0.2426157295703888,
-0.26161012053489685,
-0.29931876063346863,
-0.1702832132577896,
-0.40658825635910034,
0.553092360496521,
-0.5409833192825317,
-0.45954445004463196,
-0.11703596264123917,
-0.07625827938318253,
0.06374634802341461,
0.3827052712440491,
-0.6008050441741943,
0.1512841433286667,
0.31606337428092957,
0.469062477350235,
-0.16799141466617584,
-0.6012863516807556,
-0.280804842710495,
0.3661910593509674,
-0.5911993384361267,
0.787347137928009,
-0.021637678146362305,
-0.12767772376537323,
-0.17110474407672882,
-0.26121845841407776,
-0.37963834404945374,
-0.3992670178413391,
0.033782705664634705,
-0.8978057503700256,
0.10269729793071747,
-0.32042697072029114,
-0.666767418384552,
0.016972120851278305,
0.5460221171379089,
-0.3901878893375397,
0.9328898191452026,
0.12458280473947525,
-0.711468517780304,
0.49561360478401184,
-0.7669016122817993,
-0.5357630252838135,
0.0553697794675827,
-0.1560904085636139,
-0.5786131024360657,
-0.6853761076927185,
0.34828704595565796,
0.5347029566764832,
0.2674732506275177,
0.20919650793075562,
-0.6302192807197571,
-0.12519516050815582,
0.1088181808590889,
-0.06845196336507797,
0.5945785045623779,
0.6143953800201416,
-0.06325195729732513,
0.273063063621521,
-0.44823983311653137,
0.5021702647209167,
0.213011234998703,
-0.12169822305440903,
-0.16009990870952606,
-0.09983742982149124,
-0.622893214225769,
0.4315436780452728,
0.2332870215177536,
-0.14033693075180054,
0.08787401765584946,
-0.12486094981431961,
0.2118135392665863,
0.8368000388145447,
0.06159532070159912,
0.3390496075153351,
0.062056511640548706,
0.5248745083808899,
0.10297955572605133,
0.48330727219581604,
0.12096195667982101,
-0.09105522930622101,
-0.5586938261985779,
-0.24090364575386047,
0.4065548777580261,
0.36821579933166504,
-0.934486448764801,
0.38559865951538086,
0.07399708777666092,
-0.39191991090774536,
-0.3632316291332245,
0.02935938350856304,
0.6988222599029541,
0.7154167294502258,
0.5922612547874451,
0.11333563923835754,
-0.17537818849086761,
-0.7851696610450745,
-0.25512558221817017,
-0.0591234490275383,
0.38078048825263977,
0.5521203279495239,
0.4377404451370239,
-0.12227171659469604,
1.3055599927902222,
-0.6297374367713928,
-0.5273325443267822,
-0.41620978713035583,
0.23875397443771362,
0.0022337837144732475,
0.425832062959671,
0.4125455617904663,
-0.6468656659126282,
-0.6616843342781067,
-0.09278083592653275,
-1.261175513267517,
0.13931262493133545,
0.18468768894672394,
-0.1805504411458969,
0.20435450971126556,
0.7037925124168396,
-0.5414601564407349,
0.5811806321144104,
0.2400042712688446,
-0.38932543992996216,
0.6317331194877625,
-0.5833820104598999,
0.22478531301021576,
-0.6274961829185486,
-0.19495737552642822,
0.04267016053199768,
-0.3581250011920929,
-0.5584261417388916,
0.01696835458278656,
0.14265087246894836,
-0.09297031164169312,
-0.3686470687389374,
0.5086862444877625,
-0.2878022789955139,
-0.40843674540519714,
-0.25343745946884155,
0.143825963139534,
0.11361683160066605,
0.6372738480567932,
0.1038600504398346,
0.8583238124847412,
0.4906023442745209,
-0.8009822964668274,
0.5429888963699341,
0.2720390856266022,
-0.05153890699148178,
0.3083995282649994,
-0.4979971945285797,
-0.07473766058683395,
-0.23362934589385986,
0.5545006990432739,
-0.8322158455848694,
0.02952803671360016,
0.5497161746025085,
-0.33145004510879517,
0.3407899737358093,
-0.2935274541378021,
-0.2994735538959503,
-0.6029409766197205,
0.2918010652065277,
0.3906351327896118,
0.3747742176055908,
-0.6097770929336548,
0.7853583693504333,
0.13932590186595917,
0.45334818959236145,
-0.7506866455078125,
-0.27414095401763916,
-0.29655686020851135,
-0.214721217751503,
-0.4804062843322754,
0.0015221532667055726,
-0.024265309795737267,
0.09497696906328201,
0.23592165112495422,
-0.15136492252349854,
-0.07036589831113815,
0.1226406842470169,
0.13714393973350525,
0.032917458564043045,
-0.06578413397073746,
0.43033382296562195,
-0.11097846925258636,
-0.4993946850299835,
0.12740880250930786,
-0.6189730167388916,
0.3574824631214142,
-0.11012643575668335,
-0.5381420850753784,
-0.3684958517551422,
-0.1516045182943344,
0.08526434004306793,
-0.15959331393241882,
0.6907589435577393,
0.5137834548950195,
0.2034558653831482,
-0.3665618896484375,
-0.3990781307220459,
-0.1636430025100708,
-0.47770699858665466,
0.1633351445198059,
-0.6284970045089722,
-0.7586985230445862,
0.3062688112258911,
-0.24042247235774994,
-0.30520710349082947,
0.3989405930042267,
0.16615819931030273,
-0.26832157373428345,
1.0142232179641724,
0.23017805814743042,
0.00136815186124295,
0.26539772748947144,
-0.39688989520072937,
0.21897956728935242,
-0.6818169355392456,
-0.27830684185028076,
-0.18602555990219116,
0.017605679109692574,
-0.46293824911117554,
-0.19222469627857208,
0.46544358134269714,
0.02433200366795063,
-0.5706052780151367,
0.271057665348053,
-0.6008555293083191,
0.4810512661933899,
0.590487539768219,
0.23413559794425964,
0.044118624180555344,
-0.2359205037355423,
-0.39834389090538025,
0.14055298268795013,
-1.020845651626587,
0.017778918147087097,
1.0255866050720215,
0.24763169884681702,
0.8371577262878418,
-0.12065467238426208,
1.0674008131027222,
0.7562711238861084,
0.265550434589386,
-0.254232794046402,
0.6083277463912964,
0.14520007371902466,
-0.5109298229217529,
-0.7396663427352905,
-0.7173924446105957,
-0.9796736240386963,
0.5302764773368835,
-0.05184183642268181,
-0.35622310638427734,
-0.1764644980430603,
0.4563038647174835,
-0.26826101541519165,
0.10820727050304413,
-0.6905256509780884,
1.2679529190063477,
-0.3627387285232544,
-0.21006697416305542,
-0.3158623278141022,
-0.8031304478645325,
0.3289089500904083,
0.2520166039466858,
0.25322556495666504,
-0.10729558020830154,
0.5037654638290405,
0.6970415115356445,
-0.5156331062316895,
0.6448054909706116,
-0.560360848903656,
0.13419248163700104,
0.4385308027267456,
0.06987442821264267,
0.6868693828582764,
-0.18529756367206573,
0.2142106592655182,
-0.14447474479675293,
-0.09263496845960617,
-0.4789268672466278,
-1.030225157737732,
0.5351566076278687,
-1.0691860914230347,
-0.577518105506897,
-0.4880557358264923,
-0.5228431820869446,
-0.3086700141429901,
0.2567809522151947,
-0.031546857208013535,
0.35059472918510437,
0.15456992387771606,
-0.1838611215353012,
0.838965117931366,
0.019582977518439293,
0.12642282247543335,
0.6521783471107483,
-0.5291755795478821,
-0.44533756375312805,
0.9486304521560669,
0.18570126593112946,
0.39576494693756104,
0.19127900898456573,
0.22151365876197815,
-0.6890944838523865,
-0.37602075934410095,
-0.31719619035720825,
0.155893936753273,
-0.9642515182495117,
-0.26342812180519104,
-0.8284780383110046,
-0.6095213294029236,
-0.8063076138496399,
0.10447198152542114,
-0.4468836486339569,
-0.23151510953903198,
-0.10194334387779236,
-0.11553648114204407,
0.2760237455368042,
0.8424289226531982,
-0.42081546783447266,
0.2174740731716156,
-0.3225869834423065,
0.4494687616825104,
0.6052577495574951,
0.22181378304958344,
0.03721988946199417,
-0.43235769867897034,
-0.19455498456954956,
-0.11734478175640106,
-0.04903021454811096,
-0.6344322562217712,
0.1831890493631363,
-0.22634229063987732,
0.8363350629806519,
0.39733806252479553,
0.34347841143608093,
0.6595842242240906,
-0.2722856402397156,
0.30526334047317505,
0.2388075590133667,
-0.4446035921573639,
0.7570512294769287,
-0.26506534218788147,
0.07093668729066849,
0.39694297313690186,
0.4877393841743469,
-0.1885460913181305,
-0.29119542241096497,
-0.8664882183074951,
-0.5690693259239197,
0.7461514472961426,
0.11378473043441772,
-0.49101775884628296,
-0.0015864359447732568,
0.36687931418418884,
-0.25567886233329773,
0.15550032258033752,
-0.9151186943054199,
-0.41721469163894653,
-0.6456248760223389,
-0.14049863815307617,
-0.10080435872077942,
-0.11528884619474411,
-0.24049311876296997,
-0.1529744565486908,
0.9288240075111389,
-0.42352551221847534,
0.08638644218444824,
0.2749062776565552,
-0.08858585357666016,
0.06750913709402084,
0.10145086795091629,
0.3497942090034485,
0.5512152910232544,
-0.110275499522686,
0.06301536411046982,
0.2660260796546936,
0.10017900913953781,
0.2949533462524414,
0.10638612508773804,
-0.1334008425474167,
-0.5671480298042297,
0.2994953691959381,
0.7774874567985535,
0.19179098308086395,
-0.3039979338645935,
0.5284505486488342,
0.02066706120967865,
-0.3421056270599365,
-0.32337403297424316,
0.26441752910614014,
-0.024841805920004845,
0.6221160888671875,
0.137568861246109,
-0.02024308405816555,
-0.05133310332894325,
-0.18504895269870758,
0.4102623760700226,
0.5797046422958374,
-0.5709133148193359,
0.2340831607580185,
0.33394497632980347,
-0.13625676929950714,
-0.07592052221298218,
0.7994785308837891,
-0.5938507914543152,
-0.6974324584007263,
0.6336246728897095,
0.6973552703857422,
0.4835517704486847,
-0.1335603892803192,
0.6702319383621216,
0.3238345980644226,
0.17307081818580627,
-0.050864867866039276,
-0.0982479378581047,
-0.35362863540649414,
-0.9518505334854126,
-0.5294591784477234,
-0.49575209617614746,
-0.29514217376708984,
-0.19815924763679504,
-0.6040003299713135,
-0.12249995768070221,
-0.43753698468208313,
0.047032397240400314,
-0.41594231128692627,
-0.026943910866975784,
-0.5930195450782776,
0.4134593605995178,
-0.07495768368244171,
0.8882481455802917,
-1.0224367380142212,
0.9396119713783264,
0.3723788559436798,
-0.4628008306026459,
-1.2661105394363403,
-0.25672388076782227,
-0.34184032678604126,
-1.0181864500045776,
1.1607853174209595,
-0.028964562341570854,
-0.2537432610988617,
0.16704198718070984,
-0.3841210603713989,
-1.0480849742889404,
1.3592790365219116,
-0.04310811311006546,
-0.18117034435272217,
0.12505246698856354,
0.14044047892093658,
0.44829660654067993,
-0.4594692587852478,
0.2936476767063141,
0.4221852123737335,
0.5513903498649597,
0.5705187320709229,
-0.4962153732776642,
0.062148742377758026,
0.1950187236070633,
-0.24498023092746735,
0.1926954984664917,
-0.7909020185470581,
0.6900004744529724,
-0.2133515328168869,
0.16094064712524414,
-0.31557950377464294,
1.014289140701294,
0.6786686182022095,
0.4458092153072357,
0.6252810955047607,
0.9099510312080383,
0.6832672953605652,
-0.002275763312354684,
0.988947868347168,
-0.25806212425231934,
0.5628880262374878,
0.9946709871292114,
-0.4667452275753021,
0.24603573977947235,
0.0016773847164586186,
-0.2967027425765991,
0.5937126278877258,
0.4985778033733368,
0.05529288575053215,
0.8179177045822144,
0.1482456922531128,
0.03182927146553993,
-0.9075121283531189,
0.03202863410115242,
-0.4457448720932007,
0.13151469826698303,
0.18603459000587463,
-0.04594319686293602,
-0.6257679462432861,
0.15354475378990173,
-0.19675588607788086,
0.08831609040498734,
-0.3702751696109772,
0.8376850485801697,
-0.033876895904541016,
-0.8266075253486633,
0.23429279029369354,
-0.4207218587398529,
-0.004888795781880617,
-0.9224705696105957,
0.0051619745790958405,
-0.13835161924362183,
0.23882798850536346,
-0.09062261879444122,
-0.8931208848953247,
0.08369796723127365,
-0.5726689696311951,
0.00814872793853283,
-0.401001900434494,
1.1169332265853882,
-0.19510062038898468,
-0.1649715155363083,
0.5629820227622986,
0.6048130989074707,
0.17768576741218567,
0.18077154457569122,
-1.0142438411712646,
-0.33797210454940796,
-0.0703878402709961,
-0.3322790861129761,
0.6721243262290955,
0.6914359927177429,
0.04851645603775978,
1.2143833637237549,
0.6049873232841492,
-0.09168235957622528,
0.09496117383241653,
0.15660658478736877,
0.9226704835891724,
-0.6285655498504639,
-0.7694993019104004,
-0.5638304352760315,
0.19098761677742004,
-0.21041329205036163,
0.009459637105464935,
0.684783935546875,
0.43762826919555664,
0.49232298135757446,
0.04161322861909866,
0.760956883430481,
-0.03396029397845268,
0.5115320086479187,
-0.6706178188323975,
0.6033204197883606,
-0.3778446614742279,
-0.12167911976575851,
-0.03381725400686264,
-0.42567503452301025,
-0.0480412058532238,
0.8027405142784119,
-0.6018329858779907,
0.3477330803871155,
0.6694432497024536,
0.6925113201141357,
-0.010511411353945732,
-0.11020057648420334,
0.45370668172836304,
0.13109663128852844,
0.26854413747787476,
0.3527732193470001,
0.9896275401115417,
-0.15849649906158447,
0.6904184818267822,
-0.17361852526664734,
-0.05352575331926346,
0.003552028676494956,
-0.9005386829376221,
-0.9851451516151428,
-0.30490729212760925,
-0.41219639778137207,
-0.6560786962509155,
0.45531967282295227,
0.6982771158218384,
0.8233628273010254,
-0.6072466373443604,
0.03524812310934067,
-0.23018789291381836,
0.5209988355636597,
-0.41890963912010193,
-0.2745257318019867,
0.41938865184783936,
-0.8358160853385925,
0.14605028927326202,
0.5123755931854248,
0.16936957836151123,
-0.05281853303313255,
-0.5258637070655823,
-0.6005545854568481,
-0.2519416809082031,
-0.33690088987350464,
0.3440086543560028,
0.48788338899612427,
-0.5533679723739624,
-0.2823558449745178,
-0.3697877824306488,
-0.1298948973417282,
-0.08811783790588379,
0.6952211260795593,
-1.1202664375305176,
0.22807073593139648,
0.14587371051311493,
0.41010090708732605,
0.9429621696472168,
0.1223524659872055,
0.2582038640975952,
-0.773413360118866,
-0.15118251740932465,
0.02356569655239582,
0.20442456007003784,
0.0747564509510994,
-0.29606008529663086,
0.5736836194992065,
0.35848936438560486,
-0.9083065986633301,
-0.42229944467544556,
0.5517841577529907,
-0.6201028227806091,
-0.46460720896720886,
0.9892923831939697,
-0.4173368513584137,
-0.3208478093147278,
-0.12110176682472229,
0.13856475055217743,
0.3125270903110504,
-0.31695234775543213,
0.7715311646461487,
0.3604612350463867,
-0.5457686185836792,
-0.25263097882270813,
-0.23767341673374176,
0.7107067108154297,
0.18821164965629578,
-0.8002229332923889,
0.054749976843595505,
0.3884087800979614,
0.43125784397125244,
0.12331550568342209,
0.995324432849884,
0.2883877158164978,
0.11047355085611343,
-0.09237316995859146,
-0.03532880172133446,
-0.547353982925415,
-0.7083187699317932,
0.13911178708076477,
0.29754874110221863,
0.017105069011449814,
-0.05228255316615105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13622v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13622v1
|
Automated Evaluation of Retrieval-Augmented Language Models with Task-Specific Exam Generation
| 2024-05-22T13:14:11 | 2024-05-22T13:14:11 |
Gauthier Guinet, Behrooz Omidvar-Tehrani, Anoop Deoras, Laurent Callot
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
We propose a new method to measure the task-specific accuracy of
Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models (RAG). Evaluation is performed by
scoring the RAG on an automatically-generated synthetic exam composed of
multiple choice questions based on the corpus of documents associated with the
task. Our method is an automated, cost-efficient, interpretable, and robust
strategy to select the optimal components for a RAG system. We leverage Item
Response Theory (IRT) to estimate the quality of an exam and its
informativeness on task-specific accuracy. IRT also provides a natural way to
iteratively improve the exam by eliminating the exam questions that are not
sufficiently informative about a model's ability. We demonstrate our approach
on four new open-ended Question-Answering tasks based on Arxiv abstracts,
StackExchange questions, AWS DevOps troubleshooting guides, and SEC filings. In
addition, our experiments reveal more general insights into factors impacting
RAG performance like size, retrieval mechanism, prompting and fine-tuning. Most
notably, our findings show that choosing the right retrieval algorithms often
leads to bigger performance gains than simply using a larger language model.
|
[
-0.45515409111976624,
-0.9414415955543518,
0.31562525033950806,
-0.04580283910036087,
-0.1214265376329422,
-0.0038453801535069942,
-0.2638087868690491,
-0.4636922776699066,
0.22151316702365875,
0.5560131072998047,
-0.3012031316757202,
-0.10449229180812836,
-0.3117406964302063,
0.3633778989315033,
-0.5474737882614136,
1.1075148582458496,
-0.051468461751937866,
-0.05508005619049072,
-0.2776312530040741,
-0.12227633595466614,
-0.5328899025917053,
-0.22344326972961426,
-0.7116941213607788,
-0.12776555120944977,
0.53932785987854,
0.20966556668281555,
0.4802481532096863,
0.6365189552307129,
1.012499451637268,
0.23612020909786224,
-0.07514239102602005,
0.1347358524799347,
-0.27891770005226135,
0.23036302626132965,
-0.4406576156616211,
-0.257118821144104,
-0.44752049446105957,
0.08936163783073425,
0.46589481830596924,
0.5335045456886292,
-0.35952404141426086,
0.6917443871498108,
0.13317176699638367,
0.5843874216079712,
-0.8059222102165222,
-0.22177650034427643,
-0.6895146369934082,
-0.0770515650510788,
-0.09060239046812057,
-0.4645526707172394,
-0.7167794704437256,
-0.1773499995470047,
0.14955013990402222,
-0.4570484161376953,
0.20661388337612152,
0.22624754905700684,
0.8853623867034912,
0.2899709939956665,
-0.33091214299201965,
-0.4823720157146454,
-0.7849921584129333,
0.7979139685630798,
-0.4238812029361725,
0.4567561149597168,
0.4802533984184265,
0.3314555585384369,
0.04022219777107239,
-0.6640234589576721,
-0.38288798928260803,
-0.5526047945022583,
-0.189630925655365,
0.38588473200798035,
0.09979379922151566,
0.1319912075996399,
0.12170092761516571,
0.5031006932258606,
-0.7441176772117615,
-0.2023373246192932,
-0.26365020871162415,
0.09568893909454346,
0.5780572891235352,
0.25992774963378906,
0.23449598252773285,
-0.3470199406147003,
-0.25083357095718384,
-0.3821878433227539,
-0.29763609170913696,
-0.017272567376494408,
0.24683138728141785,
0.2526780962944031,
0.4318165183067322,
0.6139855980873108,
-0.05859845504164696,
0.8994261622428894,
0.12276997417211533,
0.057970140129327774,
0.04880218952894211,
-0.45558473467826843,
-0.2214295119047165,
-0.5715603828430176,
0.485663503408432,
0.18879379332065582,
-0.1496444046497345,
-0.3156329393386841,
-0.5161210894584656,
-0.11155308783054352,
0.8385756611824036,
-0.6837548613548279,
0.004324913490563631,
0.4465402662754059,
-0.47171327471733093,
-0.3378685712814331,
-0.08623144030570984,
-0.7493774890899658,
-0.4069617688655853,
-0.3680109679698944,
0.8022753000259399,
-0.15462994575500488,
-0.21545104682445526,
-0.13053205609321594,
-0.12441045790910721,
0.3001041114330292,
0.2926165759563446,
-0.3304973244667053,
0.6087273359298706,
0.6712972521781921,
0.47876057028770447,
-0.43697142601013184,
-0.16277214884757996,
-0.8522947430610657,
-0.20819224417209625,
-0.5920471549034119,
1.0055888891220093,
-0.5202284455299377,
-0.29580456018447876,
-0.28281378746032715,
-0.21509285271167755,
-0.1656801551580429,
-0.6088694334030151,
0.5054634213447571,
-0.9356027841567993,
0.4012356102466583,
-0.1354023516178131,
-0.528003990650177,
-0.21232391893863678,
0.5961480736732483,
-0.6287516951560974,
1.0743184089660645,
0.28244248032569885,
-0.6477603912353516,
0.09931334108114243,
-0.8806872367858887,
-0.2598518431186676,
0.06339340656995773,
0.08883552998304367,
-0.15310336649417877,
0.12359152734279633,
-0.09753487259149551,
0.2360788732767105,
-0.7383167147636414,
0.041789233684539795,
0.09292418509721756,
-0.3847362995147705,
0.26549506187438965,
-0.18282940983772278,
0.6904588937759399,
0.30628320574760437,
-0.254477858543396,
0.030461756512522697,
-0.5604622960090637,
0.47117453813552856,
0.06578751653432846,
-0.37376222014427185,
-0.459139883518219,
-0.04499680548906326,
-0.03145609796047211,
-0.15466299653053284,
0.362434446811676,
-0.45257440209388733,
0.04940389096736908,
-0.385561466217041,
-0.2994239926338196,
0.7584651708602905,
0.11814103275537491,
0.34364160895347595,
-0.3482315242290497,
0.8546770215034485,
-0.45218726992607117,
0.3556526303291321,
-0.06919748336076736,
-0.2492446005344391,
-0.6827104091644287,
-0.14386336505413055,
0.6928942799568176,
0.7761495113372803,
-0.5736439824104309,
0.18518786132335663,
-0.06943295896053314,
-0.6693320870399475,
-0.6096289157867432,
-0.10723576694726944,
0.7578863501548767,
0.6701803207397461,
0.2632494270801544,
-0.6198046207427979,
-0.49651601910591125,
-0.7374292016029358,
-0.32567185163497925,
-0.3644114136695862,
-0.05248374491930008,
0.6228092908859253,
0.6032169461250305,
-0.1735941767692566,
0.7557217478752136,
-0.6014942526817322,
-0.1336260735988617,
0.007187799084931612,
0.39761433005332947,
0.14805001020431519,
0.260297030210495,
0.3470657467842102,
-0.8457509279251099,
-0.46262553334236145,
0.1395418643951416,
-0.36978811025619507,
-0.24807314574718475,
0.09063605219125748,
-0.10316728055477142,
0.5198409557342529,
0.1870734989643097,
-0.28609585762023926,
0.2808420658111572,
0.4592832028865814,
-0.3419669568538666,
0.8475214838981628,
-0.33720317482948303,
0.569236159324646,
-0.9245986342430115,
0.47268328070640564,
-0.12379743158817291,
-0.05643297731876373,
-0.5228284001350403,
0.6454957723617554,
0.17735466361045837,
-0.048190075904130936,
-0.06745559722185135,
0.9118326306343079,
-0.43603092432022095,
-0.4571758508682251,
-0.404803603887558,
0.24224543571472168,
0.1534155309200287,
0.3895304799079895,
-0.18151600658893585,
0.937839686870575,
0.014995218254625797,
-0.6941558122634888,
0.06122196093201637,
0.23507839441299438,
-0.34211432933807373,
0.663504958152771,
-0.616676390171051,
0.5127407312393188,
-0.08749141544103622,
0.021644342690706253,
-1.1514592170715332,
-0.08413351327180862,
-0.1656690537929535,
-0.6495528817176819,
0.27751073241233826,
-0.07388395816087723,
-0.42047572135925293,
-0.3225206434726715,
-0.16646671295166016,
0.24459831416606903,
0.6297137141227722,
-0.2649085819721222,
0.6862817406654358,
0.42947787046432495,
-0.2112269550561905,
-0.8472164273262024,
-0.2057935893535614,
-0.12584809958934784,
-0.08393267542123795,
-0.449047714471817,
0.23215897381305695,
-0.3242957592010498,
-0.4981502294540405,
0.03042629174888134,
-0.23868034780025482,
-0.3340270519256592,
0.30547258257865906,
-0.10549084097146988,
0.30725255608558655,
-0.0640493854880333,
0.19836193323135376,
-0.2470521330833435,
-0.011991715990006924,
-0.016142211854457855,
-0.030597835779190063,
0.44880521297454834,
-0.1983615905046463,
-0.33767586946487427,
-0.024191243574023247,
0.3468407094478607,
0.331373006105423,
-0.7248649001121521,
0.3106418251991272,
0.4488869905471802,
-0.25395894050598145,
-0.17831173539161682,
-0.7274216413497925,
-0.43198755383491516,
-0.4418831169605255,
0.41721415519714355,
-0.45013877749443054,
-0.4686185419559479,
0.6752403378486633,
0.2521021068096161,
0.326095849275589,
0.5197546482086182,
0.3836473226547241,
-0.13344642519950867,
1.1293809413909912,
0.501706600189209,
0.23575818538665771,
0.3680253028869629,
-0.27211859822273254,
0.09105007350444794,
-1.0130890607833862,
0.11871244758367538,
-0.9142140746116638,
-0.11578579246997833,
-0.46301332116127014,
-0.5000158548355103,
0.5355292558670044,
-0.0757516473531723,
-0.329959511756897,
0.3755953907966614,
-0.7462456822395325,
0.4759405255317688,
0.4645218551158905,
0.0015195925952866673,
0.3270581066608429,
-0.23740538954734802,
-0.02037365920841694,
0.18904997408390045,
-0.42189452052116394,
-0.48812711238861084,
1.247687816619873,
0.094745934009552,
0.5317304134368896,
-0.07080712169408798,
0.6244200468063354,
0.4500148892402649,
0.5772446393966675,
-0.7637279033660889,
0.5457127690315247,
-0.18562211096286774,
-0.728641927242279,
-0.4967647194862366,
-0.5239046216011047,
-0.995729386806488,
0.2758379876613617,
-0.02211342751979828,
-0.6223922371864319,
-0.16339492797851562,
0.06341353803873062,
-0.3191635012626648,
-0.05922769755125046,
-0.6959822773933411,
0.6720103621482849,
-0.18097691237926483,
-0.2288956642150879,
-0.262361079454422,
-0.4287244975566864,
0.18054528534412384,
-0.2839322090148926,
0.27698034048080444,
0.2021973580121994,
-0.24380438029766083,
1.0585243701934814,
-0.07311782985925674,
0.38498231768608093,
-0.1263427585363388,
0.034011173993349075,
0.47137296199798584,
0.5113216638565063,
0.6278989315032959,
-0.28051578998565674,
-0.47909384965896606,
-0.28388091921806335,
0.22385382652282715,
-0.16225144267082214,
-0.8477689623832703,
0.3795188069343567,
-0.4621608853340149,
-0.6635249853134155,
-0.39380040764808655,
-0.6630041003227234,
-0.1946604996919632,
0.29806801676750183,
-0.0055900332517921925,
0.6153032779693604,
-0.162515789270401,
0.04207586497068405,
0.5357183218002319,
-0.23610273003578186,
0.1108190044760704,
0.9283568859100342,
-0.19901853799819946,
-0.4841139316558838,
0.8341890573501587,
0.2114536613225937,
0.34184589982032776,
0.40787017345428467,
0.32658931612968445,
-0.25209498405456543,
-0.562650740146637,
-0.40861937403678894,
0.22245948016643524,
-0.6247472167015076,
-0.31594184041023254,
-0.5608301758766174,
0.009374148212373257,
-0.2457307130098343,
0.032156724482774734,
-0.4283842444419861,
-0.36449968814849854,
-0.07282225042581558,
0.12606002390384674,
0.3311561942100525,
0.7582849860191345,
0.09527533501386642,
0.029423749074339867,
-0.7689180970191956,
0.3263344466686249,
0.22723618149757385,
0.4538601040840149,
-0.040502820163965225,
-0.8878552913665771,
-0.23859542608261108,
-0.038341179490089417,
-0.35031071305274963,
-0.8955258727073669,
0.24348513782024384,
0.04967864230275154,
0.41600358486175537,
0.0066437022760510445,
0.2146649956703186,
0.6819683909416199,
-0.5367306470870972,
0.6894774436950684,
-0.2559988498687744,
-0.8101511001586914,
0.4642547070980072,
-0.39951691031455994,
0.04297792166471481,
0.557293176651001,
0.1919700652360916,
-0.42810627818107605,
-0.40609484910964966,
-0.6628225445747375,
-0.824393093585968,
0.639043927192688,
0.1132257953286171,
0.011830659583210945,
-0.11133977025747299,
0.3872840404510498,
0.02006080187857151,
0.1469133496284485,
-0.31397852301597595,
-0.1812787801027298,
0.40438559651374817,
-0.16063560545444489,
0.1209440603852272,
-0.20619617402553558,
-0.1854919195175171,
0.022898729890584946,
0.8243772387504578,
-0.1958160251379013,
0.5167365074157715,
0.27121102809906006,
-0.054154884070158005,
-0.22456271946430206,
0.27342215180397034,
0.40645718574523926,
0.836962103843689,
-0.45215970277786255,
-0.17383742332458496,
0.24193595349788666,
-0.5366681218147278,
0.10168877989053726,
0.12270817160606384,
-0.11480405181646347,
-0.07933181524276733,
0.03990109637379646,
0.2952463626861572,
-0.20519667863845825,
-0.9497288465499878,
0.4257972538471222,
-0.09686197340488434,
0.016813989728689194,
-0.39767986536026,
-0.022447699680924416,
-0.30457794666290283,
0.18805375695228577,
0.5644177794456482,
-0.11232341825962067,
0.5002505779266357,
-0.4274686574935913,
0.43112581968307495,
0.5151743292808533,
-0.3022841811180115,
-0.10987085103988647,
0.43240582942962646,
0.13979217410087585,
-0.5738890171051025,
0.5047325491905212,
-0.414141446352005,
-0.4349983334541321,
0.8281720280647278,
0.4243820309638977,
0.9508004188537598,
-0.488096684217453,
0.28818246722221375,
0.4720593988895416,
0.3934321105480194,
-0.08720797300338745,
0.5171326994895935,
0.1290375292301178,
-0.47145190834999084,
-0.6770443916320801,
-0.6675994992256165,
-0.798804521560669,
0.17226280272006989,
-0.7928787469863892,
0.12022411823272705,
-0.18026694655418396,
-0.10126328468322754,
-0.14869719743728638,
0.27077680826187134,
-0.522902250289917,
0.5550706386566162,
-0.40218138694763184,
0.8755372166633606,
-0.39852169156074524,
0.28997841477394104,
0.8868880271911621,
-0.4268653094768524,
-0.8333601951599121,
0.028794024139642715,
-0.4300524890422821,
-0.5677086114883423,
0.6045234799385071,
-0.0704432874917984,
-0.023832518607378006,
-0.010830399580299854,
-0.05992056429386139,
-1.1094259023666382,
0.8724826574325562,
0.11566338688135147,
-0.09534528851509094,
-0.06857310980558395,
-0.18602555990219116,
0.6845902800559998,
-0.19069243967533112,
0.8052607178688049,
0.47814643383026123,
0.37736737728118896,
-0.31829971075057983,
-1.2899787425994873,
-0.07260377705097198,
-0.4263700246810913,
0.07039158791303635,
0.5023103356361389,
-0.3210214376449585,
0.7637537121772766,
-0.17848853766918182,
-0.08818859606981277,
0.18367651104927063,
0.4205288887023926,
0.22004905343055725,
0.3137141168117523,
0.74638432264328,
0.47199997305870056,
0.7634704113006592,
0.07892036437988281,
1.368559718132019,
-0.3996789753437042,
0.4366702437400818,
1.1176286935806274,
-0.3360941410064697,
1.0760867595672607,
0.39689239859580994,
-0.10371743142604828,
0.289413183927536,
0.4821148216724396,
0.0952986478805542,
0.32387059926986694,
0.3446069657802582,
0.05103810131549835,
-0.03009902313351631,
-0.23919016122817993,
-0.09998616576194763,
0.6074710488319397,
0.22647397220134735,
-0.37563198804855347,
-0.17200714349746704,
0.18710649013519287,
-0.32030370831489563,
0.13613244891166687,
-0.2105465829372406,
0.849656879901886,
-0.3110153377056122,
-1.0582702159881592,
0.6802146434783936,
0.01027450431138277,
0.30914121866226196,
-0.4322871267795563,
-0.050758957862854004,
-0.2200920432806015,
0.16936518251895905,
-0.01239333301782608,
-0.7041802406311035,
0.5384118556976318,
0.24606536328792572,
-0.12002988159656525,
-0.2515234649181366,
0.705804705619812,
-0.20237058401107788,
-0.3306775391101837,
0.1847456693649292,
0.5479860305786133,
0.2744482159614563,
-0.14255064725875854,
-0.6915595531463623,
-0.08026173710823059,
-0.12162365019321442,
-0.7045255899429321,
0.2851761281490326,
0.1649971902370453,
-0.04040875285863876,
0.6355581879615784,
0.4253477454185486,
-0.03344738855957985,
-0.23735137283802032,
-0.15494707226753235,
0.5130576491355896,
-0.4571768343448639,
-0.425639808177948,
-0.30410486459732056,
0.5987517833709717,
0.03217936307191849,
-0.16076314449310303,
0.5705322027206421,
0.5889420509338379,
0.847407877445221,
-0.06673178821802139,
0.6902872323989868,
-0.22121566534042358,
1.0945478677749634,
-0.21961849927902222,
0.5968112945556641,
-0.868965744972229,
0.191857248544693,
-0.4227176904678345,
-0.8756127953529358,
0.03531643748283386,
0.46443989872932434,
-0.29895973205566406,
0.1264297217130661,
0.9024084806442261,
0.9446929693222046,
0.09635171294212341,
-0.1493832916021347,
0.2583383619785309,
0.050995200872421265,
0.1064642071723938,
0.08661268651485443,
0.6888436675071716,
-0.7320968508720398,
0.7363651394844055,
-0.3333483934402466,
-0.31351444125175476,
-0.1774684488773346,
-0.7433645129203796,
-0.4256046414375305,
-0.9321397542953491,
-0.41963568329811096,
-0.5029628872871399,
0.16147466003894806,
0.7046570181846619,
0.30549362301826477,
-0.5562244057655334,
-0.4660375416278839,
0.06663607805967331,
0.04010920971632004,
-0.440524697303772,
-0.29521894454956055,
0.5147928595542908,
-0.5639523267745972,
-0.7563002109527588,
0.2334778904914856,
0.037889569997787476,
-0.2528285086154938,
-0.13981612026691437,
0.1851322501897812,
-0.1376112997531891,
0.3763537108898163,
0.6841613054275513,
0.14218401908874512,
-0.5382493734359741,
-0.2801916003227234,
0.5696473717689514,
-0.15549489855766296,
-0.10772551596164703,
0.6024855375289917,
-0.6746168732643127,
0.5563037991523743,
0.7888974547386169,
0.8979294896125793,
0.2056848406791687,
0.1383124440908432,
0.5205166935920715,
-0.5967685580253601,
-0.326799601316452,
0.6021387577056885,
0.09577788412570953,
0.12425211817026138,
-0.372350811958313,
0.9276025891304016,
-0.2143079936504364,
-0.857015073299408,
-1.1915199756622314,
0.10536910593509674,
-0.8311766386032104,
-0.21322298049926758,
1.204719066619873,
-0.09018468111753464,
-0.34017491340637207,
0.058095041662454605,
-0.2766984701156616,
0.1741539090871811,
-0.09502311795949936,
0.9752011299133301,
0.4634058177471161,
-0.04181664064526558,
0.002995894057676196,
-0.7506327033042908,
0.5112224817276001,
0.671100914478302,
-0.9839209318161011,
0.1150374561548233,
0.4234362840652466,
0.24191415309906006,
0.4925829768180847,
0.6352648138999939,
-0.1515922099351883,
0.6179704070091248,
-0.2602945864200592,
0.2698241174221039,
0.15777386724948883,
-0.2700216472148895,
-0.22342662513256073,
0.18691609799861908,
0.12815015017986298,
-0.21229040622711182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13602v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13602v1
|
COTET: Cross-view Optimal Transport for Knowledge Graph Entity Typing
| 2024-05-22T12:53:12 | 2024-05-22T12:53:12 |
Zhiwei Hu, Víctor Gutiérrez-Basulto, Zhiliang Xiang, Ru Li, Jeff Z. Pan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Knowledge graph entity typing (KGET) aims to infer missing entity type
instances in knowledge graphs. Previous research has predominantly centered
around leveraging contextual information associated with entities, which
provides valuable clues for inference. However, they have long ignored the dual
nature of information inherent in entities, encompassing both high-level
coarse-grained cluster knowledge and fine-grained type knowledge. This paper
introduces Cross-view Optimal Transport for knowledge graph Entity Typing
(COTET), a method that effectively incorporates the information on how types
are clustered into the representation of entities and types. COTET comprises
three modules: i) Multi-view Generation and Encoder, which captures structured
knowledge at different levels of granularity through entity-type,
entity-cluster, and type-cluster-type perspectives; ii) Cross-view Optimal
Transport, transporting view-specific embeddings to a unified space by
minimizing the Wasserstein distance from a distributional alignment
perspective; iii) Pooling-based Entity Typing Prediction, employing a mixture
pooling mechanism to aggregate prediction scores from diverse neighbors of an
entity. Additionally, we introduce a distribution-based loss function to
mitigate the occurrence of false negatives during training. Extensive
experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of COTET when compared to existing
baselines.
|
[
-0.7333433628082275,
-0.40851739048957825,
0.5454078912734985,
0.1084555834531784,
-0.24452157318592072,
0.1512455940246582,
0.16180895268917084,
-0.2945561408996582,
0.5362226366996765,
0.542435884475708,
-0.2972678244113922,
-0.4625725746154785,
-0.3996906876564026,
-0.33104392886161804,
-0.5090774893760681,
0.8151805400848389,
-0.18520553410053253,
-0.3315201699733734,
-0.5032578706741333,
0.0052598086185753345,
-0.11080215871334076,
-0.33235451579093933,
-0.5021237730979919,
-0.2528263032436371,
0.5630205273628235,
0.28442248702049255,
0.4439662992954254,
0.5578103065490723,
0.10145614296197891,
0.18103818595409393,
0.28054410219192505,
0.16459986567497253,
-0.5173516273498535,
-0.09667401760816574,
-0.2972286343574524,
-0.31742143630981445,
-0.21854829788208008,
-0.27824869751930237,
0.4632643461227417,
0.7902225852012634,
-0.049077581614255905,
0.09309624135494232,
0.17956677079200745,
0.6979494690895081,
-0.8468882441520691,
0.309030681848526,
-0.5441944599151611,
0.2736920118331909,
-0.43899619579315186,
-0.23884479701519012,
-0.3578663766384125,
-0.3162839710712433,
0.45162689685821533,
-0.7708051800727844,
0.21795570850372314,
0.48066189885139465,
0.6494024395942688,
0.2257842868566513,
-1.037608027458191,
0.1250450611114502,
-0.34231632947921753,
0.40053340792655945,
-0.023623621091246605,
0.675905704498291,
0.26576584577560425,
0.3716065287590027,
0.13555899262428284,
-0.6292745471000671,
-0.2909697890281677,
-0.041452981531620026,
-0.276029497385025,
0.3374457061290741,
0.09313205629587173,
0.31359151005744934,
-0.17987987399101257,
0.12814661860466003,
-0.5560003519058228,
0.05262570455670357,
-0.03665081784129143,
-0.5262570977210999,
0.48850762844085693,
-0.1944216936826706,
0.2158685028553009,
-0.31388241052627563,
-0.4750292897224426,
0.07030398398637772,
-0.8201661705970764,
-0.1142897754907608,
0.2775355875492096,
0.06858651340007782,
0.03813735023140907,
0.641579806804657,
-0.23722173273563385,
0.8231539130210876,
0.1358390599489212,
-0.015751082450151443,
0.07674974948167801,
-0.2868976294994354,
-0.16697920858860016,
0.24831967055797577,
0.5156084895133972,
0.4652571976184845,
-0.11093547940254211,
-0.5776839256286621,
-0.011029265820980072,
-0.1239175945520401,
0.28163275122642517,
-0.7302191257476807,
-0.3429497182369232,
0.0399712398648262,
-0.37657430768013,
-0.34667590260505676,
-0.3369775712490082,
-1.1459758281707764,
-0.5765752196311951,
-0.1433684080839157,
0.3029932975769043,
-0.5774339437484741,
-0.3567948639392853,
-0.42172181606292725,
-0.31579187512397766,
-0.22514072060585022,
0.4387798011302948,
-0.8237442970275879,
0.25673919916152954,
0.29233747720718384,
0.6726677417755127,
-0.3889494240283966,
-0.08136914670467377,
-0.4463372528553009,
0.5976081490516663,
0.04948773980140686,
1.045061469078064,
-0.4928421378135681,
-0.3894115090370178,
0.05684077739715576,
-0.3826572000980377,
-0.5719216465950012,
-0.2526576519012451,
0.37748390436172485,
-0.6275570392608643,
-0.27613502740859985,
-0.5382553339004517,
-0.943900465965271,
-0.3491113483905792,
0.49036943912506104,
-0.6612215638160706,
0.8958120346069336,
0.6207379698753357,
-1.1246877908706665,
0.484023779630661,
-0.7058553695678711,
-0.5106903910636902,
0.04303571209311485,
-0.29713377356529236,
-0.22020350396633148,
-0.17056795954704285,
0.19622153043746948,
0.24443140625953674,
-0.13374818861484528,
0.040891021490097046,
-0.5203110575675964,
0.21402449905872345,
-0.04409105330705643,
0.0028918248135596514,
0.299570769071579,
0.0192389115691185,
-0.15760010480880737,
-0.24261896312236786,
-0.9149318337440491,
0.0655563622713089,
-0.1807514727115631,
-0.14869742095470428,
-0.7364172339439392,
-0.03173433616757393,
-0.10891234874725342,
0.24115678668022156,
-0.01312121283262968,
-0.6173830628395081,
0.13787351548671722,
-0.06095099821686745,
0.24936196208000183,
0.7477743625640869,
0.3092299699783325,
0.7917116284370422,
0.038196198642253876,
0.41064709424972534,
0.3920936584472656,
0.08068236708641052,
0.6104559898376465,
-0.3739778697490692,
-0.577888548374176,
-0.04458354040980339,
0.30797886848449707,
0.5997213125228882,
-1.4011573791503906,
0.27450746297836304,
-0.4344065189361572,
-0.49636486172676086,
-0.2546719014644623,
-0.136290043592453,
0.2759822905063629,
0.9744836688041687,
0.558068037033081,
-0.13592398166656494,
-0.21901549398899078,
-1.0378847122192383,
-0.2053014039993286,
0.0196467824280262,
0.41218122839927673,
0.523448646068573,
0.4993515908718109,
-0.09954451024532318,
0.9566761255264282,
-0.7185604572296143,
-0.06424155831336975,
-0.38489511609077454,
-0.080714151263237,
-0.43619173765182495,
0.4213164150714874,
0.7926046252250671,
-1.1739273071289062,
-0.6271162629127502,
0.2332809716463089,
-0.4584115445613861,
0.23900626599788666,
0.07073535025119781,
-0.4846585988998413,
-0.05681968852877617,
0.1704387217760086,
-0.5192164778709412,
0.5066151022911072,
0.5288137793540955,
-0.2547425925731659,
0.3958735764026642,
0.18068340420722961,
0.1944529116153717,
-1.023252010345459,
-0.10826517641544342,
0.01915842853486538,
-0.4303058981895447,
-0.4290487468242645,
-0.2191675305366516,
0.17943526804447174,
-0.09651319682598114,
-0.2617350220680237,
0.6026782989501953,
-0.3187842071056366,
-0.3331013321876526,
0.1112503930926323,
0.46238771080970764,
-0.03612342104315758,
0.5285568237304688,
0.18347781896591187,
0.6527721881866455,
0.5292684435844421,
-0.7342501282691956,
0.2846749722957611,
0.2116844803094864,
-0.16376455128192902,
1.1692728996276855,
-0.04924764111638069,
0.13194695115089417,
-0.14889158308506012,
0.289887398481369,
-0.760188102722168,
-0.03983565419912338,
-0.012753398157656193,
-0.20173659920692444,
0.5386026501655579,
-0.5552124977111816,
-0.1004614606499672,
-0.4843681752681732,
-0.022818513214588165,
0.5193862318992615,
0.24589529633522034,
-0.3971557915210724,
0.8437756299972534,
0.5168910622596741,
0.21387824416160583,
-0.5477067828178406,
-0.6431354284286499,
-0.2149791717529297,
-0.07056010514497757,
-0.8119326233863831,
0.48552802205085754,
0.2774585783481598,
0.2022348791360855,
0.42384859919548035,
-0.3561212420463562,
-0.259055495262146,
-0.04049631580710411,
0.08806104958057404,
0.05616312846541405,
-0.19037678837776184,
0.1224297285079956,
0.5796170234680176,
-0.15194901823997498,
-0.193230539560318,
-0.9150214195251465,
0.4928949475288391,
0.18166425824165344,
-0.5141950845718384,
0.014078736305236816,
0.24617351591587067,
0.1658068597316742,
-0.15208525955677032,
0.8733044862747192,
0.6193310022354126,
-0.2743046283721924,
-0.15186606347560883,
-0.4442158043384552,
0.11176355183124542,
-0.3968493640422821,
0.5982217192649841,
-0.4972182810306549,
-0.7668564915657043,
0.4625602662563324,
-0.2677753269672394,
-0.11002325266599655,
0.45215311646461487,
0.03753608837723732,
-0.016079116612672806,
0.47952476143836975,
0.5646255016326904,
-0.19742830097675323,
0.34254175424575806,
-0.49619561433792114,
0.41601619124412537,
-1.0494132041931152,
-0.17708471417427063,
-0.4025236964225769,
-0.3519571125507355,
-0.6099398732185364,
-0.23561424016952515,
0.6850264668464661,
-0.0634583830833435,
-0.27471625804901123,
0.37360242009162903,
-0.35959258675575256,
0.3641780912876129,
0.6652157306671143,
0.2601013779640198,
0.2110309600830078,
-0.003600581781938672,
-0.6386975049972534,
0.0759894847869873,
-0.853325366973877,
0.2018328458070755,
0.9824368357658386,
-0.12057105451822281,
0.5047135353088379,
-0.033567287027835846,
1.1111059188842773,
0.26050132513046265,
0.5441938638687134,
-0.5140660405158997,
0.4925250709056854,
-0.28053799271583557,
-0.48487672209739685,
-0.41133689880371094,
-0.6662836670875549,
-0.5662878155708313,
0.42807528376579285,
-0.005903572775423527,
-0.8748159408569336,
0.3501860201358795,
0.5138192772865295,
-0.14673002064228058,
0.7445521354675293,
-0.6870987415313721,
1.0289100408554077,
0.06155211105942726,
-0.1363767385482788,
-0.12127073854207993,
-0.8065569996833801,
0.4379376173019409,
-0.09391985833644867,
0.18592393398284912,
0.269043505191803,
0.04064924642443657,
0.5687273144721985,
-0.4487053453922272,
0.587527871131897,
-0.4366934895515442,
0.22476109862327576,
0.34328532218933105,
0.3907591998577118,
0.7118180990219116,
0.03312615305185318,
0.07339568436145782,
-0.24315527081489563,
-0.09677846729755402,
-0.4291248917579651,
-0.7005271911621094,
0.6484346389770508,
-0.8581861257553101,
-0.163206085562706,
0.04155365750193596,
-0.46647462248802185,
-0.45811304450035095,
0.2746686339378357,
0.7398526072502136,
0.6302421689033508,
-0.11262135207653046,
-0.05627744272351265,
0.8677694797515869,
-0.15549199283123016,
0.2197580635547638,
0.12471930682659149,
-0.14935414493083954,
-0.4950088858604431,
1.1638609170913696,
0.4407019317150116,
0.6355422139167786,
1.0799106359481812,
-0.028948908671736717,
-0.6225829720497131,
-0.5647500157356262,
-0.7653450965881348,
0.0390230230987072,
-0.8971170783042908,
-0.298431396484375,
-0.8797763586044312,
-0.39855143427848816,
-0.5033310651779175,
-0.31068864464759827,
-0.6265133023262024,
-0.5746210217475891,
-0.04619010537862778,
-0.3848459720611572,
0.14604878425598145,
0.18127122521400452,
-0.03758472949266434,
0.21952460706233978,
-0.7517196536064148,
0.06505552679300308,
0.5770894289016724,
0.25190046429634094,
0.17751823365688324,
-0.13855530321598053,
-0.22044846415519714,
0.019145069643855095,
-0.32947078347206116,
-0.7957658171653748,
0.18517577648162842,
0.0006512156687676907,
0.6279700398445129,
0.24970251321792603,
0.22832898795604706,
0.6866727471351624,
-0.24149763584136963,
0.6046265363693237,
0.2193833589553833,
-0.6293248534202576,
0.42359113693237305,
-0.2323686182498932,
-0.31955307722091675,
0.6644631028175354,
0.4887317419052124,
-0.7389334440231323,
-0.24187929928302765,
-0.6650242209434509,
-0.7241050004959106,
0.314553827047348,
0.3585174083709717,
-0.49950090050697327,
0.0354134775698185,
0.2554756999015808,
0.06125279515981674,
0.38730835914611816,
-0.7310768961906433,
-0.4570433795452118,
-0.5365723371505737,
-0.25305861234664917,
0.15503107011318207,
0.06456867605447769,
-0.03061234951019287,
-0.06280964612960815,
0.8104026317596436,
-0.2068510800600052,
0.4601180851459503,
0.4237930476665497,
-0.43562832474708557,
0.11165211349725723,
0.047955222427845,
0.39539915323257446,
0.48732537031173706,
-0.046799592673778534,
0.41771379113197327,
0.02803456038236618,
-0.58647620677948,
0.14321686327457428,
0.3699013292789459,
-0.5374606847763062,
-0.16202537715435028,
0.1280495673418045,
0.8963896632194519,
0.1690981537103653,
0.040204912424087524,
0.5194084048271179,
0.3311501741409302,
-0.009131073951721191,
-0.2158556580543518,
-0.10906998068094254,
0.11701252311468124,
0.12472743541002274,
-0.062494657933712006,
0.33574602007865906,
0.39868709444999695,
-0.01670861430466175,
0.04188758134841919,
0.24669760465621948,
-0.540055513381958,
-0.2209589183330536,
0.5907785892486572,
0.47283393144607544,
0.14209137856960297,
0.6353964805603027,
-0.5783225893974304,
-0.5344619154930115,
0.6050677299499512,
0.3080657720565796,
0.9449483752250671,
-0.11355981975793839,
0.5500927567481995,
0.1942073255777359,
0.24877353012561798,
0.05506855621933937,
-0.14540131390094757,
-0.04744977131485939,
-1.017808437347412,
-0.1748807281255722,
-0.5415595173835754,
-0.16017872095108032,
-0.36313602328300476,
-0.4675295054912567,
0.02220373973250389,
0.04337422549724579,
-0.11287493258714676,
-0.11117484420537949,
-0.05699840560555458,
-0.9401060938835144,
-0.04669000953435898,
0.019053254276514053,
1.136930227279663,
-0.8616424798965454,
0.8104172348976135,
0.6420793533325195,
-0.5209959745407104,
-0.8301247358322144,
-0.27170872688293457,
0.09346385300159454,
-1.0296436548233032,
0.3039745092391968,
-0.10742173343896866,
0.13602761924266815,
0.33943676948547363,
-0.27485477924346924,
-1.0736256837844849,
1.2118183374404907,
0.09446724504232407,
-0.4243677854537964,
-0.24579231441020966,
0.2745632231235504,
0.00827841181308031,
-0.33114880323410034,
0.12295276671648026,
0.4745897948741913,
0.6553304195404053,
0.20524626970291138,
-0.8172891139984131,
0.07985641807317734,
0.20770494639873505,
0.19834987819194794,
0.6177752614021301,
-0.8674727082252502,
0.45450180768966675,
0.05547688528895378,
0.14674989879131317,
-0.26348376274108887,
0.608505368232727,
-0.008229751139879227,
0.31657910346984863,
0.7542847394943237,
0.9012320041656494,
0.8465639352798462,
0.09334976226091385,
1.1497342586517334,
-0.16120582818984985,
0.445504754781723,
0.9298509359359741,
-0.41203469038009644,
0.243723064661026,
0.4382658898830414,
-0.10939385741949081,
0.5072924494743347,
0.7425769567489624,
0.2968202829360962,
0.893955647945404,
0.15317893028259277,
-0.282758891582489,
-0.24938492476940155,
-0.023237820714712143,
-0.49140429496765137,
0.01348057296127081,
0.30761733651161194,
-0.2699960768222809,
-0.3815351724624634,
0.10630883276462555,
0.10294374078512192,
-0.3129795491695404,
-0.4250609576702118,
0.5783994793891907,
0.09727150201797485,
-0.6831142902374268,
0.056718047708272934,
-0.2933422029018402,
0.16815850138664246,
-0.41820329427719116,
0.18182553350925446,
-0.39506471157073975,
-0.0862293615937233,
-0.2110237032175064,
-0.7969959378242493,
0.04019242152571678,
-0.7106139659881592,
-0.09842005372047424,
-0.05866697058081627,
0.9624050259590149,
-0.5243479013442993,
-0.324069619178772,
0.28698304295539856,
0.5265807509422302,
-0.020500080659985542,
-0.3397273123264313,
-0.4689541459083557,
-0.6108126044273376,
0.08094632625579834,
-0.35137322545051575,
0.5988903641700745,
0.8313377499580383,
-0.1769402176141739,
0.729832649230957,
0.2997092604637146,
0.04254748299717903,
0.30623945593833923,
0.09938772767782211,
0.9929541945457458,
-0.3676038384437561,
-0.7415239214897156,
-0.46185529232025146,
0.4242672622203827,
-0.48824745416641235,
-0.21078960597515106,
0.4000126123428345,
0.7624520659446716,
0.545901894569397,
-0.10364299267530441,
1.0107365846633911,
-0.288922518491745,
0.4125089943408966,
-0.5648084878921509,
0.5063743591308594,
-0.3233222961425781,
-0.14672532677650452,
-0.41200166940689087,
-1.0254058837890625,
-0.0009109271923080087,
0.27147117257118225,
-0.4532405138015747,
0.025729278102517128,
0.9870092868804932,
0.521462619304657,
-0.3812330663204193,
0.047416917979717255,
0.1334419697523117,
0.07821162045001984,
0.35260269045829773,
0.6558862924575806,
0.45763933658599854,
-0.17834345996379852,
0.5080838203430176,
-0.5278290510177612,
-0.18671771883964539,
-0.28714612126350403,
-0.7377938032150269,
-0.796729564666748,
-0.5176994800567627,
-0.46030038595199585,
-0.392325758934021,
-0.057300589978694916,
0.6695514917373657,
0.8688731789588928,
-0.3680744171142578,
0.08244436234235764,
-0.11023767292499542,
0.4378759562969208,
-0.16020937263965607,
-0.23987962305545807,
0.6421197056770325,
-0.12835900485515594,
-0.057416148483753204,
-0.06404944509267807,
0.4115990996360779,
0.17659088969230652,
-0.10068560391664505,
0.12938350439071655,
-0.1067342534661293,
-0.31767216324806213,
0.6936114430427551,
0.09907305985689163,
-0.14924830198287964,
-0.6226058602333069,
-0.023844681680202484,
0.07476438581943512,
-0.01800900138914585,
0.7568304538726807,
-0.5446911454200745,
0.2100593000650406,
0.45920243859291077,
0.8936991095542908,
0.9358798861503601,
0.009139316156506538,
0.3680591881275177,
-0.8285847902297974,
0.11676490306854248,
0.27694109082221985,
0.49406898021698,
0.06503933668136597,
-0.5794779062271118,
0.6157813668251038,
0.7563086152076721,
-0.45066338777542114,
-0.3795287013053894,
0.3720170557498932,
-1.1992067098617554,
0.10770361125469208,
1.0425385236740112,
-0.10400506854057312,
-0.43817710876464844,
-0.2844651937484741,
-0.024970078840851784,
0.09146136045455933,
-0.4496420919895172,
0.47377508878707886,
0.5500310063362122,
-0.41819581389427185,
-0.23913931846618652,
-0.3662222623825073,
0.480457603931427,
-0.12474209815263748,
-1.0530338287353516,
-0.2853160798549652,
0.334644615650177,
0.4730139672756195,
0.1715683490037918,
0.8381786346435547,
0.09957269579172134,
-0.08540402352809906,
0.1379416584968567,
0.05462172254920006,
0.04976942762732506,
-0.2653336226940155,
0.6844376921653748,
0.2124290019273758,
-0.33851850032806396,
-0.27256345748901367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13578v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13578v1
|
ConTrans: Weak-to-Strong Alignment Engineering via Concept Transplantation
| 2024-05-22T12:15:52 | 2024-05-22T12:15:52 |
Weilong Dong, Xinwei Wu, Renren Jin, Shaoyang Xu, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Ensuring large language models (LLM) behave consistently with human goals,
values, and intentions is crucial for their safety but yet computationally
expensive. To reduce the computational cost of alignment training of LLMs,
especially for those with a huge number of parameters, and to reutilize learned
value alignment, we propose ConTrans, a novel framework that enables
weak-to-strong alignment transfer via concept transplantation. From the
perspective of representation engineering, ConTrans refines concept vectors in
value alignment from a source LLM (usually a weak yet aligned LLM). The refined
concept vectors are then reformulated to adapt to the target LLM (usually a
strong yet unaligned base LLM) via affine transformation. In the third step,
ConTrans transplants the reformulated concept vectors into the residual stream
of the target LLM. Experiments demonstrate the successful transplantation of a
wide range of aligned concepts from 7B models to 13B and 70B models across
multiple LLMs and LLM families. Remarkably, ConTrans even surpasses
instruction-tuned models in terms of truthfulness. Experiment results validate
the effectiveness of both inter-LLM-family and intra-LLM-family concept
transplantation. Our work successfully demonstrates an alternative way to
achieve weak-to-strong alignment generalization and control.
|
[
-0.13748441636562347,
-0.24563422799110413,
0.4114854335784912,
-0.20476239919662476,
-0.39415261149406433,
0.16057612001895905,
-0.18171414732933044,
-0.1774742156267166,
0.3651144802570343,
0.584444522857666,
-0.8047256469726562,
-0.21163056790828705,
-0.4883434772491455,
-0.05188005417585373,
-0.5177503824234009,
1.1650722026824951,
-0.2716882526874542,
0.050561267882585526,
-0.004632547963410616,
-0.0888051837682724,
-0.35386529564857483,
-0.16538141667842865,
-0.13161620497703552,
-0.3077477812767029,
0.47460415959358215,
0.3933769166469574,
0.8504126667976379,
0.9644462466239929,
0.5475916266441345,
0.2991134524345398,
-0.0956624448299408,
0.12225789576768875,
-0.7315309047698975,
-0.04084651917219162,
-0.6638586521148682,
-0.38680383563041687,
-0.5868369340896606,
0.011274022981524467,
0.4228145182132721,
1.0512276887893677,
0.07199135422706604,
0.03364763781428337,
0.2461140751838684,
0.5045972466468811,
-0.7170384526252747,
-0.21531367301940918,
-0.8605770468711853,
-0.3146124482154846,
-0.08820777386426926,
0.12148528546094894,
-0.19634446501731873,
-0.37316930294036865,
0.20603837072849274,
-0.8636009693145752,
0.3037606179714203,
-0.0299262385815382,
1.1724625825881958,
0.43051430583000183,
-0.43233785033226013,
-0.16916893422603607,
-0.8118995428085327,
0.8584547638893127,
-0.6145893931388855,
0.4629017412662506,
-0.10553210228681564,
0.12992843985557556,
-0.3510746657848358,
-0.5592619776725769,
-0.6611225008964539,
0.07741041481494904,
-0.04447223246097565,
0.16284948587417603,
-0.07266271859407425,
0.09250196069478989,
0.00019230521866120398,
0.2801663875579834,
-0.5408714413642883,
0.14169879257678986,
-0.524545431137085,
-0.24203547835350037,
0.7630495429039001,
-0.0011349491542205215,
0.2167375683784485,
-0.07796528935432434,
-0.8076725602149963,
-0.22193804383277893,
-0.9839135408401489,
-0.3845895826816559,
0.35337743163108826,
0.5805137157440186,
-0.0804280936717987,
0.7231894731521606,
0.005828387103974819,
0.6664475798606873,
0.23182091116905212,
0.02634473517537117,
0.24305671453475952,
-0.6699707508087158,
-0.15921969711780548,
0.25097134709358215,
0.7405880689620972,
0.11117591708898544,
0.18966823816299438,
-0.25274986028671265,
-0.14432533085346222,
0.21711848676204681,
0.6096267700195312,
-0.7941067218780518,
-0.01747044548392296,
-0.13015475869178772,
-0.32812419533729553,
-0.37639808654785156,
0.17757661640644073,
-0.7357646822929382,
-0.305988609790802,
-0.5961617231369019,
0.45961710810661316,
-0.4567042887210846,
-0.20622530579566956,
0.3010850250720978,
-0.011522420682013035,
0.3716312050819397,
0.2845241129398346,
-1.0616791248321533,
0.3070743978023529,
0.8987977504730225,
0.705729603767395,
-0.3543398380279541,
-0.19297099113464355,
-0.1295975297689438,
0.40325066447257996,
-0.6121874451637268,
0.5842722058296204,
-0.28519129753112793,
-0.3218088746070862,
-0.3274184465408325,
-0.0273198913782835,
0.026571277529001236,
-0.3771435618400574,
0.6179572343826294,
-0.38395991921424866,
0.016924133524298668,
-0.35097023844718933,
-0.5998660326004028,
-0.05094197764992714,
0.023472687229514122,
-0.5325953364372253,
0.3694007396697998,
0.23311415314674377,
-0.5556517839431763,
0.04848594591021538,
-0.36462998390197754,
-0.4215547442436218,
-0.062906414270401,
-0.2205895185470581,
-0.5536879897117615,
0.3275814652442932,
-0.10258617252111435,
0.39662113785743713,
-0.4915124475955963,
0.23031510412693024,
-0.6074766516685486,
-0.4093639850616455,
0.20588482916355133,
-0.3113499581813812,
0.6873239278793335,
0.22495828568935394,
-0.21572765707969666,
0.20651941001415253,
-0.630061149597168,
-0.136825829744339,
-0.05763469636440277,
0.20575933158397675,
-0.629566490650177,
-0.2684938907623291,
-0.3535342514514923,
0.3516172170639038,
0.2552351951599121,
-0.6186986565589905,
0.48744893074035645,
-0.7098569869995117,
0.3329254388809204,
0.7850098609924316,
-0.3026055097579956,
0.762475311756134,
-0.3733355402946472,
0.31258276104927063,
-0.039378196001052856,
-0.04772253334522247,
0.2789209485054016,
-0.2022233009338379,
-0.6882120370864868,
-0.3986586928367615,
0.2792015075683594,
0.5115483403205872,
-0.839311420917511,
0.670691967010498,
-0.6650283932685852,
-0.2054702341556549,
-0.7765392661094666,
0.46704161167144775,
0.27598556876182556,
0.7413381934165955,
0.557313084602356,
-0.31832993030548096,
-0.7157620191574097,
-1.06791353225708,
-0.062401507049798965,
-0.5146825909614563,
-0.09984231740236282,
-0.10338466614484787,
0.4442332088947296,
-0.23427075147628784,
0.8526304364204407,
-0.5114776492118835,
-0.4245222508907318,
-0.16157333552837372,
0.17952778935432434,
0.05301443114876747,
0.6126266121864319,
0.3520912230014801,
-0.8284915089607239,
-0.08987293392419815,
0.0760030448436737,
-0.5676508545875549,
-0.15978573262691498,
-0.44524094462394714,
-0.14580674469470978,
-0.1568758338689804,
0.5941860675811768,
-0.5757044553756714,
0.4363856911659241,
0.5421086549758911,
-0.2659100890159607,
0.3696717619895935,
0.09422273188829422,
-0.12845368683338165,
-1.4352262020111084,
0.22420531511306763,
-0.23797860741615295,
-0.24981315433979034,
-0.4568786025047302,
-0.13214010000228882,
0.16061638295650482,
0.007463980931788683,
-0.6290533542633057,
0.6224297285079956,
-0.4363342523574829,
0.03246759623289108,
-0.4095480144023895,
0.1533517986536026,
0.08695770800113678,
0.3589670956134796,
-0.05038943514227867,
0.7143886089324951,
0.42023900151252747,
-0.4652489423751831,
0.6137513518333435,
0.6204575300216675,
0.009385698474943638,
1.0980730056762695,
-0.5367066264152527,
0.11333798617124557,
-0.14655360579490662,
0.2910522520542145,
-0.8110440969467163,
0.07635466009378433,
0.457645982503891,
-0.2074131965637207,
0.4338788092136383,
-0.28320279717445374,
0.09128100425004959,
-0.2585376501083374,
-0.2166709005832672,
0.3054664731025696,
0.5310730338096619,
-0.47189590334892273,
0.7657592296600342,
0.08166222274303436,
-0.23266848921775818,
-0.6338944435119629,
-0.7893227338790894,
0.13895508646965027,
-0.2955021262168884,
-0.4498973488807678,
0.6376270651817322,
0.06786003708839417,
-0.05226004123687744,
0.4741075038909912,
-0.2959722876548767,
0.1890455186367035,
0.039334096014499664,
0.10416465252637863,
0.45197802782058716,
-0.3449191451072693,
0.15588797628879547,
0.24054540693759918,
-0.28755882382392883,
-0.24634215235710144,
-0.7739445567131042,
0.0039183697663247585,
0.014941953122615814,
-0.5854390859603882,
-0.27067527174949646,
0.22318758070468903,
0.6132421493530273,
-0.10225125402212143,
0.7717785239219666,
0.3488081097602844,
-0.46179112792015076,
-0.3767051696777344,
-0.20430631935596466,
-0.23547686636447906,
-0.46671536564826965,
0.6125584244728088,
-0.5066797733306885,
-0.6754970550537109,
0.15734055638313293,
-0.6096133589744568,
0.14021295309066772,
0.5019004344940186,
0.32094770669937134,
-0.3271273374557495,
0.7532193064689636,
0.7790483236312866,
0.00902080349624157,
0.3050035536289215,
-0.1788383424282074,
0.12500832974910736,
-0.9927980899810791,
-0.052092038094997406,
-0.3801109492778778,
-0.6791349649429321,
-0.46359771490097046,
-0.37445005774497986,
0.022485213354229927,
0.30548781156539917,
-0.21932044625282288,
0.7652848958969116,
-0.3773440718650818,
0.31505003571510315,
0.07207097113132477,
0.011422007344663143,
0.13763131201267242,
-0.2640564739704132,
-0.19171003997325897,
-0.0882745012640953,
-0.5387941598892212,
-0.5932503938674927,
1.1766873598098755,
0.1728798896074295,
1.1582558155059814,
0.2150271236896515,
0.8616275787353516,
-0.20449279248714447,
0.7960910201072693,
-0.9364748001098633,
0.5307185053825378,
-0.8055921196937561,
-0.3976868987083435,
-0.3216719925403595,
-0.6812957525253296,
-0.9338089823722839,
0.17838890850543976,
-0.32764700055122375,
-0.6485058665275574,
0.47342437505722046,
0.20750947296619415,
-0.40148770809173584,
0.4711080491542816,
-0.5380861163139343,
0.8440722227096558,
-0.6342027187347412,
-0.4267825186252594,
-0.19812549650669098,
-0.8555809259414673,
0.4583932161331177,
-0.38702407479286194,
-0.03389115631580353,
0.020460056141018867,
-0.08833648264408112,
0.4590122401714325,
-0.4644237756729126,
0.835565984249115,
0.1426042765378952,
-0.35662955045700073,
0.026324793696403503,
0.20788702368736267,
0.5990443229675293,
-0.29348742961883545,
-0.12368486076593399,
0.037187084555625916,
-0.12492897361516953,
-0.284906268119812,
-1.1007930040359497,
0.790833055973053,
-0.8340260982513428,
-0.7615841627120972,
-0.15619821846485138,
-0.6730747222900391,
-0.2746891677379608,
0.280349463224411,
-0.044629890471696854,
-0.022007176652550697,
-0.4756767749786377,
0.3147198557853699,
0.7342227697372437,
0.05713620036840439,
-0.0576527863740921,
0.2829323410987854,
0.011451663449406624,
-0.4514952003955841,
1.1271088123321533,
-0.07978853583335876,
0.6433115005493164,
0.5422949194908142,
0.3203883171081543,
-0.4359646737575531,
-0.48135560750961304,
-0.6054264307022095,
0.24720750749111176,
-0.5197802186012268,
-0.43641915917396545,
-0.28286683559417725,
-0.39430469274520874,
-0.3461824655532837,
-0.29719728231430054,
-0.9326310753822327,
-0.5817950963973999,
-0.5182717442512512,
-0.15883731842041016,
0.042570747435092926,
0.6667991876602173,
-0.17742064595222473,
0.3508085012435913,
-0.5426012873649597,
0.686979353427887,
0.48018211126327515,
0.4650852382183075,
-0.4211033582687378,
-0.753226637840271,
0.07857071608304977,
0.43880927562713623,
-0.4963077902793884,
-0.8422492742538452,
0.15604804456233978,
0.14052066206932068,
0.42469504475593567,
0.27609023451805115,
0.02035066857933998,
0.9369062781333923,
-0.38362956047058105,
0.3254479169845581,
0.44746479392051697,
-1.2846158742904663,
0.26849064230918884,
0.10261069983243942,
-0.046034958213567734,
0.6682807207107544,
0.24582847952842712,
-0.5777029991149902,
-0.06873326748609543,
-0.6423161029815674,
-0.6912721395492554,
0.5640566945075989,
0.27795588970184326,
0.1895282119512558,
0.4834367334842682,
0.641523003578186,
0.21169628202915192,
0.0552973598241806,
-0.3548569083213806,
-0.15601502358913422,
-0.6501289010047913,
-0.9327914714813232,
-0.03957461938261986,
0.20650459825992584,
-0.20900017023086548,
-0.051540352404117584,
0.961587131023407,
-0.4806824326515198,
-0.04497063159942627,
0.19982017576694489,
-0.07148046791553497,
-0.12508052587509155,
0.28320059180259705,
0.6929721236228943,
0.2748435139656067,
0.05458850413560867,
0.5575803518295288,
0.24986650049686432,
-0.2368956059217453,
0.5915217995643616,
0.29018262028694153,
-0.2978987693786621,
-0.41286587715148926,
0.18869954347610474,
0.9731306433677673,
0.23231416940689087,
-0.17851221561431885,
0.6561777591705322,
-0.012524696998298168,
-0.14393572509288788,
0.2020033746957779,
0.08943171054124832,
0.342042475938797,
0.07507259398698807,
0.010673423297703266,
0.3872435688972473,
-0.2801457345485687,
-0.4861672818660736,
0.53110671043396,
0.624602198600769,
-0.6300890445709229,
-0.6338416934013367,
0.6759243607521057,
0.2993934154510498,
-0.1832258105278015,
0.5176620483398438,
-0.032677650451660156,
-0.5120732188224792,
0.3063048720359802,
0.7213037610054016,
1.0204486846923828,
-0.40507009625434875,
0.21883642673492432,
0.15934635698795319,
0.3520706593990326,
-0.33935776352882385,
0.1178189367055893,
0.3066108524799347,
-1.034171462059021,
-0.4363095164299011,
-0.4684721529483795,
-0.25523388385772705,
0.12575268745422363,
-0.35563111305236816,
0.602002739906311,
-0.33606284856796265,
-0.05900474637746811,
-0.08888392150402069,
-0.26722463965415955,
-0.5096322894096375,
0.1306631863117218,
0.3007889986038208,
0.5772444009780884,
-1.0371922254562378,
0.8595404028892517,
0.762663722038269,
-0.5014249682426453,
-0.9292880892753601,
-0.0013742244336754084,
0.22155870497226715,
-0.6095638275146484,
0.6549057960510254,
-0.2899540662765503,
-0.37565648555755615,
-0.020246829837560654,
-0.7189303636550903,
-1.0725688934326172,
1.0119379758834839,
0.8862203359603882,
-0.8694834113121033,
-0.12348435074090958,
0.38152867555618286,
0.5818410515785217,
-0.31964513659477234,
-0.16325697302818298,
0.14827941358089447,
0.3278001546859741,
0.5287538766860962,
-0.8751810789108276,
0.35429051518440247,
0.004785255528986454,
-0.03215073049068451,
0.22636976838111877,
-0.6058632731437683,
0.5230114459991455,
-0.21110709011554718,
-0.34728357195854187,
0.33568817377090454,
0.8948096036911011,
0.24602191150188446,
-0.1638522446155548,
0.5328070521354675,
0.6075975894927979,
0.6860209703445435,
-0.013267663307487965,
0.6441413164138794,
-0.1380978375673294,
0.16535139083862305,
1.0520031452178955,
-0.593597948551178,
0.5763701796531677,
0.8296096324920654,
0.16120027005672455,
0.5283634662628174,
0.0764562338590622,
0.07523175328969955,
0.4269777238368988,
0.6350785493850708,
0.13030847907066345,
-0.3288966417312622,
-0.2537272870540619,
-0.08689527213573456,
0.48243340849876404,
0.35293179750442505,
-0.15068702399730682,
-0.15334837138652802,
-0.10620306432247162,
-0.21328070759773254,
0.19041523337364197,
0.021518448367714882,
0.7723283171653748,
0.4674689769744873,
-0.5575356483459473,
0.7006420493125916,
-0.05018521472811699,
0.6462886333465576,
-0.8162720203399658,
-0.021663883700966835,
-0.060075793415308,
0.45701247453689575,
-0.11878364533185959,
-0.7712566256523132,
0.7077950239181519,
-0.3563019931316376,
0.015992438420653343,
-0.6448655128479004,
0.8711634874343872,
-0.7293838858604431,
-0.480532705783844,
0.22520171105861664,
0.43229594826698303,
-0.15028847754001617,
0.3203553855419159,
-0.7520251870155334,
0.03304893150925636,
-0.08316855877637863,
0.1234133318066597,
0.09246639907360077,
0.5332580804824829,
-0.41702526807785034,
0.6290327310562134,
0.6471085548400879,
0.5654080510139465,
-0.2518106698989868,
0.025083234533667564,
0.9109305143356323,
-0.5506312251091003,
-0.30154797434806824,
-0.8300429582595825,
0.3318813145160675,
0.1699989289045334,
-0.3060467541217804,
0.38696712255477905,
0.44139453768730164,
0.884835958480835,
0.1673993468284607,
0.6698651909828186,
0.17991842329502106,
0.2743110656738281,
-0.4190899431705475,
0.7655235528945923,
-0.5862056612968445,
0.17279836535453796,
-0.5033238530158997,
-0.7462750673294067,
-0.3152140974998474,
0.47011569142341614,
-0.24548682570457458,
-0.24287231266498566,
0.46948567032814026,
0.8020138144493103,
-0.47575557231903076,
0.08250346034765244,
0.23851792514324188,
0.16950447857379913,
0.39390626549720764,
0.7402055263519287,
1.0441557168960571,
-0.4734167754650116,
0.6144471168518066,
-0.12905541062355042,
-0.2040669471025467,
0.1801685392856598,
-0.8081357479095459,
-0.6502031683921814,
-0.548478901386261,
-0.5296453237533569,
-0.25103023648262024,
0.22891351580619812,
1.0059865713119507,
0.8994460105895996,
-0.9306625723838806,
-0.23264576494693756,
-0.25199228525161743,
0.3365868926048279,
-0.4309312105178833,
-0.10782543569803238,
0.48637136816978455,
-0.045059025287628174,
-0.49106934666633606,
0.48992520570755005,
0.21588601171970367,
0.3918486535549164,
-0.17166434228420258,
-0.24568675458431244,
-0.1680278778076172,
0.1623307466506958,
0.07629162073135376,
0.3663618862628937,
-0.6446601152420044,
-0.5094305276870728,
0.037507038563489914,
-0.4024962782859802,
-0.04056527838110924,
0.8791191577911377,
-0.7282422780990601,
0.2818284332752228,
0.5364252924919128,
1.1377742290496826,
0.3244309723377228,
0.332937628030777,
0.8889790177345276,
-0.8216912150382996,
-0.019475417211651802,
0.38158801198005676,
0.242798313498497,
0.5380755662918091,
-0.31306058168411255,
0.18332849442958832,
0.569293737411499,
-0.00835159607231617,
-0.7366599440574646,
0.6165440678596497,
-0.8866734504699707,
-0.44323471188545227,
1.1103678941726685,
-0.0192026998847723,
-0.22974446415901184,
-0.17390066385269165,
-0.12501518428325653,
0.6863470673561096,
0.01862880028784275,
0.690344512462616,
0.34805646538734436,
0.06478758156299591,
-0.03955009579658508,
0.02319776453077793,
0.43504488468170166,
0.8629418015480042,
-0.892641544342041,
0.20477394759655,
0.19522087275981903,
0.38979458808898926,
0.27353987097740173,
0.002506003249436617,
-0.23060500621795654,
-0.1215905249118805,
-0.3918253779411316,
0.2801310420036316,
-0.08713947236537933,
-0.2562344968318939,
-0.28833702206611633,
-0.09598707407712936,
-0.2891440987586975,
-0.20785118639469147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13576v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13576v1
|
FlashRAG: A Modular Toolkit for Efficient Retrieval-Augmented Generation Research
| 2024-05-22T12:12:40 | 2024-05-22T12:12:40 |
Jiajie Jin, Yutao Zhu, Xinyu Yang, Chenghao Zhang, Zhicheng Dou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
With the advent of Large Language Models (LLMs), the potential of Retrieval
Augmented Generation (RAG) techniques have garnered considerable research
attention. Numerous novel algorithms and models have been introduced to enhance
various aspects of RAG systems. However, the absence of a standardized
framework for implementation, coupled with the inherently intricate RAG
process, makes it challenging and time-consuming for researchers to compare and
evaluate these approaches in a consistent environment. Existing RAG toolkits
like LangChain and LlamaIndex, while available, are often heavy and unwieldy,
failing to meet the personalized needs of researchers. In response to this
challenge, we propose FlashRAG, an efficient and modular open-source toolkit
designed to assist researchers in reproducing existing RAG methods and in
developing their own RAG algorithms within a unified framework. Our toolkit
implements 12 advanced RAG methods and has gathered and organized 32 benchmark
datasets. Our toolkit has various features, including customizable modular
framework, rich collection of pre-implemented RAG works, comprehensive
datasets, efficient auxiliary pre-processing scripts, and extensive and
standard evaluation metrics. Our toolkit and resources are available at
https://github.com/RUC-NLPIR/FlashRAG.
|
[
-0.47405070066452026,
-0.5612980723381042,
0.27616187930107117,
0.43938377499580383,
-0.26390817761421204,
0.49472495913505554,
-0.24300165474414825,
-0.056573882699012756,
0.487626850605011,
0.2821328341960907,
-0.2320924997329712,
-0.27762508392333984,
-0.2739517092704773,
0.15523087978363037,
-0.8337307572364807,
1.0336005687713623,
0.11611820012331009,
-0.027295254170894623,
0.051070600748062134,
-0.2938251793384552,
-0.3504265248775482,
-0.007092318031936884,
-0.5045619010925293,
-0.2740037143230438,
0.8474106192588806,
0.41401538252830505,
0.42511674761772156,
0.4647662341594696,
0.48602625727653503,
0.30347907543182373,
-0.32267674803733826,
0.17397281527519226,
-0.6743316054344177,
0.5822391510009766,
-0.34003520011901855,
-0.06782367080450058,
-0.595361053943634,
-0.39783307909965515,
0.7265810966491699,
0.34414801001548767,
-0.4168417453765869,
0.7609347105026245,
-0.09230618923902512,
0.5381351709365845,
-1.053622841835022,
-0.4309155344963074,
-0.7308696508407593,
0.07786285132169724,
-0.7711573243141174,
-0.6232028007507324,
-0.45368343591690063,
-0.39974746108055115,
-0.2367982566356659,
-0.4855958819389343,
0.48218294978141785,
0.21753111481666565,
0.21237821877002716,
0.1194671019911766,
-0.27310097217559814,
-0.2508339583873749,
-0.7076248526573181,
0.7535602450370789,
-0.5904600024223328,
0.21015259623527527,
0.13142737746238708,
0.5746325254440308,
-0.2869585454463959,
-1.0226460695266724,
-0.6221601366996765,
0.10428860783576965,
0.021458765491843224,
0.10353484004735947,
-0.09648282080888748,
-0.3173264265060425,
0.17300236225128174,
0.6043336391448975,
-0.7018735408782959,
0.1631709784269333,
-0.2827661335468292,
0.08738292753696442,
0.5066795349121094,
0.38085564970970154,
0.2776476740837097,
-0.45857861638069153,
-0.3097829520702362,
-0.16720643639564514,
-0.8532658219337463,
-0.45163968205451965,
0.48529040813446045,
0.30740952491760254,
0.32406142354011536,
0.6982998251914978,
-0.16017669439315796,
0.5383909940719604,
0.08894772827625275,
-0.2045878767967224,
0.36891940236091614,
-0.3147386908531189,
0.012199540622532368,
-0.09586089104413986,
0.7147529125213623,
-0.03342932090163231,
-0.35710078477859497,
-0.1988619565963745,
-0.7021170258522034,
-0.4357735216617584,
0.43373388051986694,
-0.7581042051315308,
-0.050138942897319794,
0.23221340775489807,
-0.34490492939949036,
-0.5065433382987976,
-0.07906817644834518,
-1.1265021562576294,
-0.6034035682678223,
0.04442758858203888,
0.5493019819259644,
-0.2317807972431183,
-0.5296225547790527,
-0.2664954960346222,
-0.44625988602638245,
0.18764880299568176,
0.20170053839683533,
-0.7105911374092102,
0.27602440118789673,
0.9871984124183655,
1.0075258016586304,
-0.3606830835342407,
-0.19677957892417908,
-0.7408328652381897,
0.23136776685714722,
-0.22445794939994812,
1.0185908079147339,
-0.6377878785133362,
-0.5878141522407532,
0.09524219483137131,
-0.26131436228752136,
0.07903607934713364,
-0.7423185110092163,
0.5417067408561707,
-0.754150927066803,
0.059742674231529236,
-0.00561627559363842,
-0.41196662187576294,
0.014295699074864388,
-0.05150360241532326,
-0.8027559518814087,
1.3089038133621216,
0.18594390153884888,
-0.9233222603797913,
0.2344503551721573,
-0.44693809747695923,
-0.4714983105659485,
0.5496911406517029,
-0.06725051999092102,
-0.3387822210788727,
0.3960212767124176,
0.11890039592981339,
0.37082791328430176,
-0.5778259634971619,
0.44310519099235535,
-0.16230109333992004,
-0.5502213835716248,
0.14756827056407928,
-0.23883682489395142,
0.6518830060958862,
0.37761029601097107,
-0.4294170141220093,
0.2935231029987335,
-0.7084145545959473,
0.13495129346847534,
0.00011497385276015848,
-0.5907765030860901,
-0.38522523641586304,
0.059968914836645126,
0.3918030261993408,
-0.29205918312072754,
0.28401732444763184,
-0.3094463646411896,
0.16585642099380493,
-0.13884875178337097,
-0.0038161331322044134,
0.851158618927002,
-0.2580708861351013,
0.500342607498169,
-0.30094245076179504,
0.7442687749862671,
-0.2702682316303253,
-0.12280122190713882,
-0.44503703713417053,
-0.17008253931999207,
-0.8013595938682556,
-0.30299243330955505,
0.46551939845085144,
0.38515278697013855,
-0.9009630680084229,
0.3008478879928589,
-0.41072916984558105,
-0.5603154897689819,
-0.6927196979522705,
0.26024723052978516,
0.5663388967514038,
0.4736277163028717,
0.41164395213127136,
-0.29557156562805176,
-0.7036731243133545,
-0.7569723725318909,
-0.24421007931232452,
0.13863684237003326,
-0.10374666005373001,
0.18086275458335876,
0.4526706337928772,
-0.145778089761734,
0.894109845161438,
-0.34400543570518494,
-0.0876038447022438,
-0.4679742157459259,
0.43391796946525574,
0.20310458540916443,
0.3327784240245819,
0.38019222021102905,
-0.7831994891166687,
-0.42302998900413513,
0.13094422221183777,
-0.4488932192325592,
-0.4866095185279846,
0.27925118803977966,
-0.028274139389395714,
0.20757603645324707,
0.2543710768222809,
-0.3906782269477844,
0.34558388590812683,
0.510077714920044,
-0.13222290575504303,
0.8471159934997559,
0.015319706872105598,
0.18403755128383636,
-1.1414871215820312,
0.7178240418434143,
-0.3513156771659851,
-0.3912707567214966,
-0.7480560541152954,
0.323310524225235,
0.09119375795125961,
-0.022521253675222397,
-0.358228862285614,
1.1050434112548828,
-0.35109347105026245,
-0.38561415672302246,
-0.49066072702407837,
0.19515761733055115,
-0.24656139314174652,
0.007007449399679899,
-0.25489628314971924,
1.2327488660812378,
0.07038941234350204,
-0.44774937629699707,
0.07691735774278641,
0.04883458837866783,
-0.5048418641090393,
0.6003391742706299,
-0.7108603119850159,
0.1626812368631363,
-0.1384340226650238,
0.3837367594242096,
-0.5598303079605103,
-0.4690700173377991,
0.022604472935199738,
-0.17620766162872314,
0.39795660972595215,
-0.1514996737241745,
-0.7263374328613281,
-0.31394824385643005,
-0.5817937254905701,
0.5729501247406006,
0.7027015686035156,
-0.8509732484817505,
0.5537763237953186,
0.6383412480354309,
-0.336104154586792,
-1.096648097038269,
-0.1960267722606659,
0.05696602538228035,
-0.3487054407596588,
-0.32918083667755127,
0.3232903480529785,
-0.08372775465250015,
-0.3016502559185028,
-0.02146032266318798,
-0.16129714250564575,
-0.05411497876048088,
-0.15612125396728516,
0.03133516386151314,
0.007216477766633034,
-0.19012154638767242,
0.13495846092700958,
0.11807262152433395,
-0.24518324434757233,
-0.47471892833709717,
0.1011301651597023,
0.6275129318237305,
0.02157837152481079,
-0.16530439257621765,
0.2313961386680603,
0.23048719763755798,
0.21463005244731903,
-0.23378883302211761,
0.3338189125061035,
0.9217250347137451,
0.09035224467515945,
-0.7731823921203613,
-0.9250926971435547,
0.11633455753326416,
-0.565242350101471,
0.26722121238708496,
-0.17998458445072174,
-1.0037671327590942,
0.3944131135940552,
-0.2136039137840271,
0.2944287061691284,
0.23069843649864197,
0.8030357956886292,
0.018171461299061775,
0.7590548396110535,
0.4872457981109619,
0.020646249875426292,
0.41928336024284363,
-0.07367435842752457,
-0.02706236019730568,
-1.2620028257369995,
-0.036943137645721436,
-0.5624105334281921,
-0.5762335062026978,
-0.18927855789661407,
-0.7859444618225098,
0.45527568459510803,
0.1827058643102646,
-0.25197020173072815,
0.2511764168739319,
-0.5072837471961975,
0.5941278338432312,
0.37535667419433594,
-0.2761663496494293,
0.4144876301288605,
-0.04692091420292854,
-0.02048128843307495,
0.25884005427360535,
-0.7977559566497803,
-0.41493695974349976,
1.0443882942199707,
-0.10608302801847458,
0.8383785486221313,
0.19370006024837494,
0.8114049434661865,
0.3026549816131592,
0.6121354699134827,
-0.5027322769165039,
0.893720805644989,
-0.2126152217388153,
-0.8156576752662659,
-0.08518189191818237,
-0.5585594773292542,
-1.2587149143218994,
0.45947957038879395,
-0.030855242162942886,
-0.5275425314903259,
0.16115987300872803,
0.24024416506290436,
-0.03907255828380585,
0.39818036556243896,
-0.346240371465683,
0.48392823338508606,
0.0017006747657433152,
-0.42991530895233154,
-0.3827066421508789,
-0.3287794589996338,
0.6899083256721497,
-0.28560981154441833,
0.3084877133369446,
-0.2168068140745163,
-0.25044509768486023,
0.7275707125663757,
-0.49795156717300415,
0.5122144222259521,
-0.1455942839384079,
0.08153214305639267,
0.23939457535743713,
0.20765987038612366,
0.33896899223327637,
0.02405467815697193,
-0.30450814962387085,
-0.2868986129760742,
-0.1627601683139801,
-0.2270151823759079,
-0.5495709180831909,
0.8666166663169861,
-0.24260343611240387,
-0.478993684053421,
-0.31602898240089417,
-0.5345691442489624,
0.12373656034469604,
0.38244685530662537,
0.07924281805753708,
0.5941738486289978,
-0.29965704679489136,
0.1957606077194214,
0.6450272798538208,
-0.43766528367996216,
0.5861417651176453,
0.5499410629272461,
-0.7583794593811035,
-0.5200823545455933,
1.1144016981124878,
-0.0062866429798305035,
-0.08690597116947174,
0.35350459814071655,
0.2589127719402313,
0.0072012655436992645,
-0.5740109086036682,
-0.5057864189147949,
0.10673275589942932,
-0.6753172278404236,
-0.6577169895172119,
-0.5250150561332703,
0.023642154410481453,
-0.20285391807556152,
-0.22061213850975037,
-0.3457305133342743,
-0.720244288444519,
-0.06206820160150528,
0.12249010801315308,
0.5973893404006958,
0.7957398295402527,
-0.20808567106723785,
0.2983592450618744,
-0.6626539826393127,
0.49021682143211365,
0.2140418142080307,
0.3294000029563904,
0.39415252208709717,
-0.4162507653236389,
-0.23356711864471436,
-0.4448293447494507,
-0.2745080888271332,
-0.6335433721542358,
0.4902280271053314,
0.16428570449352264,
0.519660234451294,
0.037504278123378754,
-0.006746747996658087,
0.9922419190406799,
-0.8139411211013794,
0.5617927312850952,
-0.09387737512588501,
-0.7458915114402771,
0.48328080773353577,
-0.40941065549850464,
0.4000946283340454,
0.7874773144721985,
0.2738790512084961,
-0.34524962306022644,
-0.3778253197669983,
-0.5149484276771545,
-1.2377071380615234,
0.43459469079971313,
0.028977902606129646,
0.04010859131813049,
-0.10315635800361633,
0.2019122838973999,
0.2885683476924896,
0.34078601002693176,
-0.3123667538166046,
-0.10071837157011032,
0.07696861028671265,
-0.15527349710464478,
0.05495469272136688,
-0.285898894071579,
-0.23276211321353912,
-0.04166574403643608,
0.628281831741333,
-0.08196192979812622,
-0.0027116781566292048,
-0.05133529379963875,
-0.33155903220176697,
-0.13734625279903412,
0.5017857551574707,
0.41774964332580566,
0.6847116947174072,
-0.13340523838996887,
0.26762914657592773,
0.2987156808376312,
-0.6797415018081665,
0.20414765179157257,
0.09472650289535522,
-0.5331002473831177,
0.20094792544841766,
0.27328580617904663,
0.36174866557121277,
0.7219530940055847,
-0.8777472376823425,
0.4297042489051819,
-0.05025070160627365,
0.13988104462623596,
-0.45259130001068115,
0.1467186063528061,
0.031454578042030334,
0.2777553200721741,
0.6457284092903137,
-0.11483646184206009,
0.3691064119338989,
-0.30549657344818115,
0.2756596803665161,
0.4451983571052551,
0.16193586587905884,
-0.42315295338630676,
0.48964017629623413,
0.12600357830524445,
-0.5822898149490356,
0.3801666498184204,
-0.34505465626716614,
-0.2637845575809479,
0.1451227366924286,
0.5144098997116089,
1.0896605253219604,
-0.28858673572540283,
0.26057931780815125,
0.42675384879112244,
0.02701582759618759,
-0.40424826741218567,
0.23027074337005615,
-0.15432265400886536,
-0.21101537346839905,
-0.5887108445167542,
-1.1132030487060547,
-0.39190083742141724,
-0.1089881956577301,
-0.6039724946022034,
0.2915997803211212,
-0.33876872062683105,
-0.1970931589603424,
-0.20711322128772736,
-0.1732390969991684,
-0.5771116018295288,
-0.3400977849960327,
-0.22643053531646729,
1.1207634210586548,
-0.19639918208122253,
0.7278006076812744,
0.5818615555763245,
-0.1740826666355133,
-0.5920878052711487,
-0.1632603406906128,
0.21715818345546722,
-0.6474156379699707,
0.7307179570198059,
0.012939081527292728,
-0.26439985632896423,
-0.014665300026535988,
-0.26872286200523376,
-0.8868995308876038,
1.3472763299942017,
-0.007343207485973835,
-0.43327218294143677,
0.08774036169052124,
-0.3247813880443573,
0.5382410883903503,
-0.24299809336662292,
0.4225914776325226,
0.5185467600822449,
0.5426366329193115,
0.19419972598552704,
-1.0631262063980103,
-0.02314920350909233,
-0.3722773492336273,
0.14371120929718018,
0.4699505567550659,
-0.5927951335906982,
0.7132193446159363,
0.07210060954093933,
-0.35106340050697327,
0.3905160129070282,
0.4930034577846527,
0.5837659239768982,
0.3704635500907898,
0.321061909198761,
0.7407021522521973,
0.6336919069290161,
0.09335500001907349,
1.0541796684265137,
-0.1351049393415451,
0.2174472212791443,
1.2328667640686035,
-0.44311854243278503,
1.2386704683303833,
0.3366563022136688,
-0.037138551473617554,
0.4937005341053009,
-0.016963470727205276,
0.016789065673947334,
0.39491182565689087,
0.21138422191143036,
-0.6132683157920837,
0.11823651194572449,
0.026160793378949165,
-0.2305750697851181,
0.1397130787372589,
0.30274561047554016,
-0.10975384712219238,
-0.40472710132598877,
-0.0457339771091938,
-0.014342842623591423,
-0.10462485253810883,
-0.31976228952407837,
0.7299810647964478,
-0.04275617003440857,
-0.5880489945411682,
0.44660887122154236,
-0.10855414718389511,
1.0700104236602783,
-0.6465103626251221,
0.11462155729532242,
-0.44633087515830994,
0.07493134588003159,
-0.38020074367523193,
-0.6961244940757751,
0.36849772930145264,
0.37220439314842224,
-0.015488783828914165,
-0.31104952096939087,
0.9726176261901855,
-0.18887299299240112,
-0.4498791992664337,
0.05826373025774956,
0.6285194754600525,
0.2243562936782837,
0.5883638262748718,
-0.5492491722106934,
0.4498210549354553,
-0.3264436721801758,
-0.554500937461853,
0.5867481231689453,
0.3148443400859833,
0.16516627371311188,
0.7458394169807434,
0.5448683500289917,
0.23836907744407654,
0.20853596925735474,
0.07911434769630432,
0.967742383480072,
-0.7233279347419739,
0.013857903890311718,
-0.5013302564620972,
0.6419292092323303,
-0.18629975616931915,
-0.37937337160110474,
0.965137243270874,
0.8026764988899231,
0.6430402398109436,
-0.0008828815189190209,
0.5844627022743225,
-0.4028467833995819,
0.9404599070549011,
-0.32239124178886414,
0.7552930116653442,
-0.6438050270080566,
0.44401854276657104,
-0.3381540775299072,
-1.0904018878936768,
-0.3453066349029541,
0.4695848226547241,
0.09879179298877716,
0.0750642716884613,
0.4092409610748291,
0.9712047576904297,
-0.23547346889972687,
-0.10502362996339798,
-0.0031830717343837023,
0.09284181147813797,
0.33758416771888733,
-0.09074806421995163,
0.8245165944099426,
-0.07073694467544556,
0.5358613729476929,
-0.14980952441692352,
-0.17550313472747803,
-0.3854532539844513,
-0.904930055141449,
-0.7075845003128052,
-0.5839449167251587,
-0.007495161145925522,
-0.10760751366615295,
0.18759997189044952,
0.7229633927345276,
0.5596754550933838,
-0.4493781328201294,
-0.532191812992096,
0.1991318166255951,
0.22226987779140472,
0.05481784790754318,
-0.2820252776145935,
0.17075908184051514,
-0.5716992616653442,
-0.6632780432701111,
0.7573571801185608,
0.3952859938144684,
-0.301297128200531,
-0.5116905570030212,
0.06199519708752632,
-0.13811147212982178,
-0.10947127640247345,
0.7311632633209229,
0.541333019733429,
-0.47211596369743347,
-0.039746735244989395,
-0.122391477227211,
0.05638952553272247,
-0.08063027262687683,
1.2200779914855957,
-1.100486159324646,
0.41217660903930664,
0.7554989457130432,
0.6991543769836426,
0.6074711680412292,
0.022644683718681335,
0.5810527801513672,
-0.9495900273323059,
0.12495795637369156,
0.4445740282535553,
0.18287800252437592,
0.3540993332862854,
0.08973057568073273,
0.8239485621452332,
-0.2234390825033188,
-0.8565361499786377,
-1.3076955080032349,
0.051682740449905396,
-0.8459973931312561,
-0.3373069763183594,
1.0574294328689575,
0.09990487992763519,
-0.229329451918602,
-0.1050986647605896,
-0.07525962591171265,
-0.0336771234869957,
-0.39960384368896484,
0.6529937982559204,
0.19915124773979187,
-0.0498589351773262,
-0.17989200353622437,
-0.6850569844245911,
0.48095253109931946,
0.2864089012145996,
-0.712253987789154,
0.14779436588287354,
0.5245087742805481,
0.2716136872768402,
0.3073490560054779,
0.7931065559387207,
-0.15546095371246338,
0.3925687372684479,
-0.03275790810585022,
0.08264356851577759,
0.013951991684734821,
-0.261159211397171,
-0.35925930738449097,
0.3912763297557831,
-0.0722617357969284,
0.5955315232276917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13568v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13568v1
|
CPE-Identifier: Automated CPE identification and CVE summaries annotation with Deep Learning and NLP
| 2024-05-22T12:05:17 | 2024-05-22T12:05:17 |
Wanyu Hu, Vrizlynn L. L. Thing
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With the drastic increase in the number of new vulnerabilities in the
National Vulnerability Database (NVD) every year, the workload for NVD analysts
to associate the Common Platform Enumeration (CPE) with the Common
Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVE) summaries becomes increasingly laborious
and slow. The delay causes organisations, which depend on NVD for vulnerability
management and security measurement, to be more vulnerable to zero-day attacks.
Thus, it is essential to come out with a technique and tool to extract the CPEs
in the CVE summaries accurately and quickly. In this work, we propose the
CPE-Identifier system, an automated CPE annotating and extracting system, from
the CVE summaries. The system can be used as a tool to identify CPE entities
from new CVE text inputs. Moreover, we also automate the data generating and
labeling processes using deep learning models. Due to the complexity of the CVE
texts, new technical terminologies appear frequently. To identify novel words
in future CVE texts, we apply Natural Language Processing (NLP) Named Entity
Recognition (NER), to identify new technical jargons in the text. Our proposed
model achieves an F1 score of 95.48%, an accuracy score of 99.13%, a precision
of 94.83%, and a recall of 96.14%. We show that it outperforms prior works on
automated CVE-CPE labeling by more than 9% on all metrics.
|
[
-0.5731377601623535,
-0.5604985356330872,
0.24201545119285583,
0.2727581262588501,
-0.45659366250038147,
0.4228368401527405,
-0.02962419018149376,
-0.5348220467567444,
0.28097906708717346,
0.6069839596748352,
-0.284182071685791,
-0.7211545705795288,
-0.5806738138198853,
0.2413886934518814,
-0.5537599325180054,
0.8948308229446411,
0.10843607783317566,
-0.4461020231246948,
-0.06475237011909485,
0.0941869392991066,
-0.624106764793396,
-0.75440514087677,
-0.5859665274620056,
0.0008754867012612522,
0.31270164251327515,
0.16470390558242798,
0.08570592850446701,
0.5062752962112427,
0.7782708406448364,
0.2478334903717041,
0.10251310467720032,
0.04458951577544212,
0.0017867410788312554,
-0.3205362558364868,
-0.03658382222056389,
-0.1129644364118576,
-0.5632699728012085,
-0.23948924243450165,
0.2331968992948532,
0.35116568207740784,
0.24306295812129974,
0.2288292646408081,
0.16546355187892914,
0.5543614625930786,
-0.7570672035217285,
0.3208508789539337,
-0.69923996925354,
0.11873264610767365,
-0.057347189635038376,
-0.31538382172584534,
-0.43578261137008667,
-0.28440019488334656,
0.4366918206214905,
-0.6768277287483215,
0.17236581444740295,
-0.3915676772594452,
0.816776692867279,
0.12394511699676514,
-0.20216242969036102,
-0.22062459588050842,
-0.44360846281051636,
0.7382788062095642,
-0.5394346117973328,
0.11197596788406372,
-0.13587579131126404,
0.39495691657066345,
0.10192661732435226,
-0.3798189163208008,
-0.4212891161441803,
-0.3009152114391327,
0.06867022067308426,
-0.12102688103914261,
0.17394323647022247,
-0.1298554539680481,
0.03131917119026184,
0.2550045847892761,
-0.5077376961708069,
0.46669575572013855,
-0.42584341764450073,
-0.3799949288368225,
0.7373097538948059,
0.06546911597251892,
0.17917737364768982,
-0.23812581598758698,
-0.6262561082839966,
0.0979524627327919,
-0.41346776485443115,
-0.09191206097602844,
0.2979303002357483,
0.36144912242889404,
-0.27111154794692993,
0.3115352690219879,
-0.2577875852584839,
0.5676161050796509,
0.17472003400325775,
-0.28018930554389954,
0.618736982345581,
-0.3067682683467865,
-0.5912532806396484,
0.25112131237983704,
0.8455401062965393,
0.6124704480171204,
0.1531965285539627,
-0.14112615585327148,
-0.10875551402568817,
-0.09524170309305191,
0.2187923938035965,
-0.6250172853469849,
-0.572333037853241,
0.19161660969257355,
-0.32613492012023926,
-0.6359704732894897,
0.4325525462627411,
-0.8426668047904968,
-0.4150480031967163,
-0.4184587001800537,
0.08397487550973892,
-0.47873958945274353,
-0.22295871376991272,
-0.02313961088657379,
-0.5282829999923706,
0.6689321994781494,
0.5455865859985352,
-0.4917532503604889,
0.37501367926597595,
0.8542786240577698,
0.72054123878479,
-0.5225948691368103,
0.1545814573764801,
-0.49091944098472595,
0.0201055146753788,
-0.18224814534187317,
0.7277576923370361,
-0.4774465560913086,
-0.37981247901916504,
-0.14693689346313477,
0.3387913703918457,
0.041676077991724014,
-0.5271487236022949,
0.41849589347839355,
-0.3927394449710846,
0.18945197761058807,
-0.1836586594581604,
-0.5697933435440063,
-0.1737692803144455,
0.508152186870575,
-0.6452803611755371,
0.8371730446815491,
-0.08050680160522461,
-0.796042799949646,
0.4505160450935364,
-0.5698394775390625,
-0.07386354357004166,
0.5634710788726807,
-0.17515437304973602,
-0.4179140627384186,
-0.07643019407987595,
0.46629437804222107,
0.4709923267364502,
-0.49961012601852417,
0.24082745611667633,
-0.14763325452804565,
-0.17009282112121582,
0.23747830092906952,
-0.3045562207698822,
0.8092385530471802,
-0.1413075178861618,
-0.09933958202600479,
-0.1861899197101593,
-0.8673693537712097,
-0.09289190918207169,
0.07494474947452545,
-0.21762725710868835,
-0.2991688549518585,
-0.148646742105484,
0.10251861810684204,
0.03414769098162651,
0.5315952897071838,
-0.7077939510345459,
0.3036653995513916,
-0.6885734796524048,
0.2950722575187683,
0.6012158393859863,
0.6189584732055664,
0.449127733707428,
0.020406274124979973,
0.4382071793079376,
0.009362641721963882,
0.3906092941761017,
-0.24609534442424774,
-0.46294456720352173,
-0.37373048067092896,
-0.49075940251350403,
0.5333296060562134,
1.0933457612991333,
-0.6122499108314514,
0.7442758679389954,
-0.19492922723293304,
-0.6807174682617188,
0.022483989596366882,
0.03443184494972229,
0.38391512632369995,
0.6694343686103821,
0.42182308435440063,
-0.7386411428451538,
-0.5783534646034241,
-1.044211506843567,
-0.14467324316501617,
-0.11462042480707169,
-0.36769041419029236,
0.22044675052165985,
0.49526217579841614,
-0.2348203957080841,
0.8455270528793335,
-0.5130072236061096,
-0.1600484549999237,
-0.023759907111525536,
0.24195072054862976,
0.17875038087368011,
0.5261109471321106,
0.6373343467712402,
-0.8973708152770996,
-0.3323802649974823,
0.0788981094956398,
-0.7288365960121155,
-0.13733181357383728,
-0.34220069646835327,
0.18553271889686584,
0.07652359455823898,
0.5708712935447693,
0.07833408564329147,
0.22560632228851318,
-0.09497835487127304,
0.15156640112400055,
0.5077434778213501,
-0.0980326235294342,
0.09841228276491165,
-0.883277952671051,
0.031923118978738785,
0.32576605677604675,
0.08908575773239136,
-0.412746399641037,
0.06044260039925575,
0.25921088457107544,
-0.15749651193618774,
-0.7888765931129456,
0.3378196060657501,
-0.3503824770450592,
0.3280743658542633,
-0.08551627397537231,
0.4524401128292084,
0.1561298370361328,
0.3907136023044586,
0.06493058055639267,
0.32009708881378174,
0.7156859636306763,
-0.8799659609794617,
0.4167848825454712,
0.17262421548366547,
-0.11789055168628693,
0.5898498296737671,
-0.6125496029853821,
0.04745248705148697,
-0.18063892424106598,
0.08453011512756348,
-0.4701835513114929,
-0.1934022158384323,
0.3327440619468689,
-0.3934842348098755,
0.3286568224430084,
-0.28688564896583557,
-0.2783651351928711,
-0.3829404413700104,
-0.41797032952308655,
0.3746896982192993,
0.23363065719604492,
-0.49134373664855957,
0.5406652688980103,
0.7622084617614746,
-0.16122637689113617,
-0.7281471490859985,
-0.6494141221046448,
0.4111662805080414,
-0.2327568680047989,
-0.2053966373205185,
0.47937020659446716,
-0.1122516617178917,
-0.15958891808986664,
-0.26686516404151917,
-0.00424104044213891,
-0.5023077726364136,
0.34303218126296997,
0.3705930709838867,
0.6125956773757935,
-0.17814955115318298,
0.3140449523925781,
-0.05089518800377846,
-0.4867704510688782,
0.12631067633628845,
-0.4116091728210449,
0.27002090215682983,
-0.13851968944072723,
-0.09876330196857452,
-0.6823488473892212,
0.39370524883270264,
0.4043149948120117,
-0.5610453486442566,
0.47057193517684937,
0.38945528864860535,
-0.6641812324523926,
-0.012148278765380383,
-0.5193741321563721,
0.18404290080070496,
-0.42645934224128723,
0.31375008821487427,
-0.28401660919189453,
-0.5699930191040039,
0.35695329308509827,
-0.17255938053131104,
0.07068819552659988,
0.9623977541923523,
0.32918304204940796,
0.26132506132125854,
0.39372020959854126,
0.9287278652191162,
-0.34816786646842957,
0.35532036423683167,
-0.27877694368362427,
0.3477376103401184,
-0.8406596779823303,
-0.4704318940639496,
-0.4478682279586792,
0.009687546640634537,
-0.6718326807022095,
-0.3092106878757477,
0.16506977379322052,
-0.008758269250392914,
-0.09514407813549042,
0.806664228439331,
-1.149887204170227,
0.5982422232627869,
0.17133477330207825,
-0.16569259762763977,
0.011287858709692955,
-0.3985384702682495,
-0.016667434945702553,
0.10631245374679565,
-0.061848510056734085,
-0.7662941217422485,
1.0697386264801025,
0.2892359495162964,
0.3569835424423218,
-0.032134391367435455,
0.986656129360199,
0.3866540193557739,
0.34537172317504883,
-0.365147203207016,
0.6824638247489929,
-0.11312463134527206,
-0.2104044109582901,
0.03850913420319557,
-0.11864587664604187,
-0.6198445558547974,
-0.38742661476135254,
-0.4242868423461914,
-0.9729934334754944,
0.6597115397453308,
-0.07959835976362228,
-0.5255361199378967,
0.055928394198417664,
-0.5891316533088684,
0.8267463445663452,
-0.268632173538208,
0.13748133182525635,
0.09017600119113922,
-0.5323604941368103,
0.3464786410331726,
-0.33970072865486145,
0.044856272637844086,
-0.28348344564437866,
-0.20955626666545868,
0.5951852798461914,
-0.2882364094257355,
0.8198300004005432,
-0.1814679056406021,
-0.08722233772277832,
0.36723142862319946,
-0.11388634145259857,
0.44192633032798767,
0.5174703001976013,
-0.09849650412797928,
0.4109765887260437,
-0.11373113095760345,
-0.1980181783437729,
-0.30442771315574646,
0.8348457217216492,
-0.5198494791984558,
-0.17423859238624573,
-0.5137692093849182,
0.050157953053712845,
0.358143150806427,
0.2137288898229599,
0.39535826444625854,
0.519939124584198,
-0.5633676648139954,
0.0016271810745820403,
0.7546241283416748,
-0.6513718962669373,
0.6457259058952332,
0.5387736558914185,
0.23638756573200226,
-0.5552705526351929,
1.1216883659362793,
0.16126419603824615,
0.06882821023464203,
0.952006995677948,
-0.15269699692726135,
0.036565620452165604,
-0.5655734539031982,
-0.3648742735385895,
-0.09102272987365723,
-0.5685304403305054,
-0.430400013923645,
-0.8650431036949158,
-0.42240121960639954,
-0.3310723602771759,
-0.646055281162262,
-0.18030069768428802,
-0.4736041724681854,
-0.42713797092437744,
-0.23279477655887604,
0.29777127504348755,
0.46720460057258606,
0.2608673870563507,
0.01838083565235138,
-0.7101874351501465,
0.4304960072040558,
0.30351895093917847,
0.2156759649515152,
-0.35460367798805237,
-0.10641954094171524,
-0.019939176738262177,
-0.29810261726379395,
-0.24116399884223938,
-1.08919358253479,
0.6424015760421753,
0.14013102650642395,
0.5074391961097717,
0.10875680297613144,
0.09660492837429047,
0.22273403406143188,
-0.16900286078453064,
0.9360654354095459,
0.24673576653003693,
-0.9979058504104614,
0.7760103344917297,
-0.10183471441268921,
0.24115398526191711,
0.7586813569068909,
0.19032198190689087,
-0.3290739059448242,
-0.4810572564601898,
-0.7848337888717651,
-1.2512069940567017,
0.03930024057626724,
-0.08987110108137131,
-0.22214052081108093,
-0.4205178916454315,
0.5573209524154663,
0.21894609928131104,
0.275500625371933,
-0.7037658095359802,
-0.06505512446165085,
-0.047260481864213943,
-0.13717833161354065,
0.18194900453090668,
-0.1303424835205078,
0.1607300490140915,
0.08579121530056,
0.8452222347259521,
-0.2774507999420166,
0.2566594183444977,
0.40732377767562866,
-0.21672573685646057,
0.3318744897842407,
0.2320510596036911,
0.3137092888355255,
0.3010254204273224,
-0.2312842607498169,
-0.09905499219894409,
0.4405911862850189,
-0.3682813048362732,
-0.1301291286945343,
0.10079000145196915,
-0.10201219469308853,
0.09820098429918289,
0.32849928736686707,
0.18332824110984802,
-0.03639308363199234,
-0.7828848958015442,
0.9005260467529297,
-0.23378363251686096,
-0.1842978298664093,
-1.0680471658706665,
0.19574126601219177,
-0.34125348925590515,
0.04891815781593323,
0.33808550238609314,
0.251255065202713,
0.3082181513309479,
-0.18396075069904327,
0.42626309394836426,
0.38800135254859924,
-0.6365934610366821,
-0.009807270020246506,
0.5474663972854614,
0.40013429522514343,
-0.5414179563522339,
0.47565406560897827,
-0.4455930292606354,
-0.26512911915779114,
1.1362966299057007,
0.014689777046442032,
1.2777323722839355,
-0.024904925376176834,
0.0836920514702797,
0.5143485069274902,
0.6746976375579834,
0.14867402613162994,
0.2309497594833374,
0.06960665434598923,
-0.336181104183197,
-0.535869836807251,
-0.627607524394989,
-0.26108109951019287,
0.09901556372642517,
-0.6693522930145264,
0.6614459753036499,
-0.726807713508606,
0.1612207591533661,
0.3587054908275604,
-0.040110137313604355,
-0.9212449193000793,
0.24781830608844757,
0.4073992371559143,
1.155932068824768,
-1.0459980964660645,
0.6182896494865417,
0.1276271492242813,
-0.4565768539905548,
-0.4141078293323517,
-0.11939191073179245,
0.14878222346305847,
-0.3562208414077759,
0.5604668259620667,
0.43890881538391113,
0.2957894802093506,
-0.34506985545158386,
-0.3587205111980438,
-0.63084876537323,
1.0829883813858032,
0.23611228168010712,
-0.785977840423584,
0.36592718958854675,
-0.04298877343535423,
0.4341375529766083,
-0.6581656336784363,
0.205758199095726,
0.43203920125961304,
0.5598656535148621,
-0.46657246351242065,
-0.9802534580230713,
0.025467203930020332,
-0.45865705609321594,
-0.1923942118883133,
0.5276336073875427,
-0.35298284888267517,
0.5934085249900818,
-0.09248903393745422,
-0.21216481924057007,
-0.11459413915872574,
0.5286923050880432,
-0.17271345853805542,
0.3358449339866638,
0.4808061122894287,
0.5215601325035095,
0.82716965675354,
-0.09756406396627426,
0.8826923370361328,
-0.22524802386760712,
0.12714657187461853,
1.2147384881973267,
-0.11955022066831589,
0.7572517991065979,
0.12817297875881195,
0.30279749631881714,
0.7395451068878174,
0.38828399777412415,
-0.5414178967475891,
0.3776688873767853,
0.17358562350273132,
-0.3963095247745514,
-0.013926563784480095,
0.05067356675863266,
-0.2303975373506546,
0.2804517149925232,
0.4752143919467926,
-0.6429357528686523,
-0.11592025309801102,
0.21123522520065308,
-0.2811177670955658,
0.026732653379440308,
-0.25633057951927185,
1.0953189134597778,
-0.0862404927611351,
-0.3204823136329651,
0.3191942572593689,
0.15638764202594757,
0.5104991793632507,
-0.3510567545890808,
-0.07627309113740921,
0.4577063322067261,
0.10652761161327362,
-0.20715875923633575,
-0.45985284447669983,
0.36131206154823303,
-0.05175783485174179,
-0.17302651703357697,
-0.07798982411623001,
0.6199761033058167,
-0.13182318210601807,
-0.681908905506134,
0.28187432885169983,
0.18529239296913147,
0.0012349315220490098,
-0.22804906964302063,
-0.69237220287323,
-0.11340504884719849,
-0.10112059861421585,
0.15465033054351807,
0.2355215847492218,
0.5343871116638184,
-0.03848907724022865,
0.49137136340141296,
0.5548748970031738,
-0.17216871678829193,
-0.08806271851062775,
0.021682031452655792,
0.8784663677215576,
-0.7699951529502869,
-0.5559830069541931,
-0.9376904964447021,
0.5495263934135437,
-0.6323593854904175,
-0.6038306951522827,
0.6562726497650146,
0.7936257719993591,
0.6303775906562805,
0.06382488459348679,
0.9189674854278564,
0.04787219315767288,
0.39093509316444397,
-0.04968192055821419,
0.1487616002559662,
-0.05816839635372162,
0.6341147422790527,
-0.4009203016757965,
-0.6110051274299622,
-0.4545682370662689,
0.17605793476104736,
-0.2082103043794632,
-0.566027820110321,
0.5839709043502808,
0.7585706114768982,
0.19614540040493011,
-0.05823506414890289,
-0.14838407933712006,
0.10220501571893692,
0.492100328207016,
0.6896538138389587,
0.09254248440265656,
-0.5868226885795593,
0.33503809571266174,
-0.3775888979434967,
-0.32432326674461365,
-0.34190261363983154,
-1.3286265134811401,
-0.699857234954834,
-0.47847220301628113,
-0.9944803714752197,
-0.045854777097702026,
0.0030288915149867535,
0.7938502430915833,
0.3843708634376526,
-0.8903451561927795,
0.3000847399234772,
-0.3462252616882324,
0.06561736017465591,
-0.42221200466156006,
-0.3128167390823364,
0.3589610159397125,
-0.09578476846218109,
-0.4057650566101074,
0.516597330570221,
0.8790177702903748,
-0.017123814672231674,
-0.29597997665405273,
0.2207484245300293,
0.022458482533693314,
0.1447654813528061,
0.42407721281051636,
0.5053282976150513,
-0.5236261487007141,
-0.42769527435302734,
-0.07039976865053177,
-0.003365122014656663,
-0.07266060262918472,
0.6794803738594055,
-1.1490195989608765,
0.4584498405456543,
0.5099776983261108,
0.6687728762626648,
0.1438724845647812,
-0.3277570903301239,
0.5822127461433411,
-0.8736816644668579,
0.10510498285293579,
0.4283182919025421,
0.3072457015514374,
0.31723982095718384,
-0.6287165880203247,
0.37812095880508423,
0.22783531248569489,
-0.43740034103393555,
-0.7299789190292358,
0.08244498074054718,
-1.2581417560577393,
-0.2792537212371826,
0.6192235946655273,
0.03361724317073822,
-0.5026074647903442,
-0.515184223651886,
-0.13529716432094574,
0.08874765783548355,
-0.2939155101776123,
0.6968497037887573,
0.16879631578922272,
0.18564791977405548,
-0.13364902138710022,
-0.4988006055355072,
0.2346954196691513,
-0.2806771993637085,
-0.7259071469306946,
0.07692427188158035,
0.20254187285900116,
0.1422988474369049,
0.5131381750106812,
0.598125696182251,
-0.31478869915008545,
0.2945691645145416,
-0.21121308207511902,
0.4878087639808655,
0.036828089505434036,
-0.34966176748275757,
-0.3043099641799927,
0.663008987903595,
-0.22034162282943726,
-0.24472878873348236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13548v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13548v2
|
ECLIPSE: Semantic Entropy-LCS for Cross-Lingual Industrial Log Parsing
| 2024-05-22T11:33:29 | 2024-05-24T05:39:24 |
Wei Zhang, Xianfu Cheng, Yi Zhang, Jian Yang, Hongcheng Guo, Zhoujun Li, Xiaolin Yin, Xiangyuan Guan, Xu Shi, Liangfan Zheng, Bo Zhang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Log parsing, a vital task for interpreting the vast and complex data produced
within software architectures faces significant challenges in the transition
from academic benchmarks to the industrial domain. Existing log parsers, while
highly effective on standardized public datasets, struggle to maintain
performance and efficiency when confronted with the sheer scale and diversity
of real-world industrial logs. These challenges are two-fold: 1) massive log
templates: The performance and efficiency of most existing parsers will be
significantly reduced when logs of growing quantities and different lengths; 2)
Complex and changeable semantics: Traditional template-matching algorithms
cannot accurately match the log templates of complicated industrial logs
because they cannot utilize cross-language logs with similar semantics. To
address these issues, we propose ECLIPSE, Enhanced Cross-Lingual Industrial log
Parsing with Semantic Entropy-LCS, since cross-language logs can robustly parse
industrial logs. On the one hand, it integrates two efficient data-driven
template-matching algorithms and Faiss indexing. On the other hand, driven by
the powerful semantic understanding ability of the Large Language Model (LLM),
the semantics of log keywords were accurately extracted, and the retrieval
space was effectively reduced. Notably, we launch a Chinese and English
cross-platform industrial log parsing benchmark ECLIPSE- BENCH to evaluate the
performance of mainstream parsers in industrial scenarios. Our experimental
results across public benchmarks and ECLIPSE- BENCH underscore the superior
performance and robustness of our proposed ECLIPSE. Notably, ECLIPSE both
delivers state-of-the-art performance when compared to strong baselines and
preserves a significant edge in processing efficiency.
|
[
0.02106398530304432,
-0.14716657996177673,
0.5777538418769836,
0.638789176940918,
-0.44743311405181885,
-0.01688573881983757,
-0.16816772520542145,
-0.9874523282051086,
0.11960535496473312,
0.4046594202518463,
-0.2973611354827881,
-0.9656221270561218,
-0.3468386232852936,
0.15868495404720306,
-0.3506719172000885,
0.8563854694366455,
-0.10802213102579117,
0.1389453411102295,
-0.03807670995593071,
-0.24755869805812836,
-0.24503247439861298,
-0.23290392756462097,
-0.7191930413246155,
0.10095904022455215,
0.5830287337303162,
0.13702841103076935,
0.38456717133522034,
0.8496890664100647,
0.35235437750816345,
0.2850041091442108,
-0.05568959191441536,
-0.11567721515893936,
-0.05100925266742706,
0.3014236390590668,
-0.35532352328300476,
-0.5954906940460205,
-0.6167308688163757,
-0.5269055962562561,
0.44404223561286926,
0.6027678847312927,
-0.02247634157538414,
0.27330127358436584,
0.04013253003358841,
0.515605628490448,
-0.8834360837936401,
0.22091716527938843,
-0.9443570971488953,
0.16264966130256653,
-0.4443737864494324,
-0.34385955333709717,
-0.4575718343257904,
0.09684417396783829,
-0.09450036287307739,
-0.8386409282684326,
0.23895028233528137,
0.33908364176750183,
0.9468026161193848,
0.27197059988975525,
-0.33051827549934387,
-0.0005873761838302016,
-0.5102574229240417,
0.9361332654953003,
-0.7045381665229797,
0.8243025541305542,
0.1098376139998436,
0.21527622640132904,
0.09069696068763733,
-1.112216591835022,
-0.19302529096603394,
0.12446790188550949,
-0.06444712728261948,
0.3013695776462555,
0.2141357660293579,
0.1490701287984848,
-0.08244138211011887,
0.43368518352508545,
-0.7802693247795105,
0.5635102987289429,
-0.27556657791137695,
-0.10683493316173553,
0.5467405319213867,
0.6257582902908325,
0.3813433349132538,
-0.08167890459299088,
-0.4188443720340729,
-0.3309440314769745,
-0.4763498306274414,
-0.0730690136551857,
0.09231850504875183,
0.18055905401706696,
0.16151757538318634,
0.29976046085357666,
-0.33467233180999756,
0.5643665194511414,
-0.4424647390842438,
-0.2491154670715332,
0.21094809472560883,
-0.2047584354877472,
-0.5369092226028442,
0.4110826253890991,
0.5362854599952698,
0.5291378498077393,
-0.5351115465164185,
-0.31421390175819397,
-0.22204384207725525,
0.13271111249923706,
-0.04627261683344841,
-0.5931618809700012,
-0.3093254566192627,
0.47938254475593567,
-0.45860642194747925,
-0.19985541701316833,
0.07514113187789917,
-0.862633228302002,
-0.35492995381355286,
-0.21345166862010956,
-0.07005375623703003,
-0.22758710384368896,
-0.37520578503608704,
0.525646448135376,
-0.6637008190155029,
0.3655296564102173,
0.5696809887886047,
-0.8627413511276245,
0.06465934962034225,
1.2986630201339722,
0.8264776468276978,
0.08932629227638245,
-0.20842550694942474,
-0.42599940299987793,
0.7993381023406982,
-0.3952479362487793,
0.3922087252140045,
-0.5588979125022888,
0.07696639001369476,
-0.3247706890106201,
-0.006739296019077301,
0.06083042547106743,
-0.7126753926277161,
0.5701826810836792,
-0.573326826095581,
0.14571315050125122,
-0.09602136164903641,
-0.4636666476726532,
-0.1908295750617981,
0.20946882665157318,
-0.5591765642166138,
1.1678568124771118,
0.007598318159580231,
-0.9595142602920532,
0.8675981760025024,
-0.32578033208847046,
-0.15972626209259033,
0.1537441611289978,
-0.21427330374717712,
-0.16475248336791992,
0.03429379686713219,
0.021208690479397774,
0.35022491216659546,
-0.7152726650238037,
0.29318350553512573,
-0.5091500282287598,
0.1258004754781723,
-0.4746323525905609,
-0.5359804034233093,
0.9645865559577942,
0.42921483516693115,
-0.441595196723938,
-0.09678218513727188,
-0.9446520209312439,
0.02707945741713047,
-0.0725654736161232,
-0.15273302793502808,
-0.9742829203605652,
-0.04143284261226654,
0.2420809268951416,
0.2558163106441498,
0.5546947717666626,
-0.7786133885383606,
-0.004049080424010754,
-0.4437735974788666,
-0.11943602561950684,
0.7750672101974487,
-0.40515562891960144,
-0.04847310110926628,
0.05177721753716469,
0.23280631005764008,
0.1892288625240326,
0.14187940955162048,
-0.10225022584199905,
-0.2791628837585449,
-0.7634845972061157,
-0.5836951732635498,
0.11837434768676758,
0.9423434138298035,
-0.5945314168930054,
0.7224717736244202,
-0.31811803579330444,
-0.7774755954742432,
-0.5940260291099548,
0.4733869135379791,
0.44257912039756775,
0.2848662734031677,
0.28171613812446594,
-0.6147517561912537,
-0.834874153137207,
-0.8138802647590637,
-0.653187096118927,
-0.4500589072704315,
-0.6926060914993286,
0.14181920886039734,
-0.012946481816470623,
-0.18922999501228333,
0.822550892829895,
-0.5603593587875366,
-0.18176478147506714,
-0.050373997539281845,
0.3114432394504547,
0.19490616023540497,
0.4716803729534149,
0.4345133900642395,
-0.7248042225837708,
-0.7462749481201172,
0.7419140338897705,
-0.972070038318634,
-0.3198701739311218,
-0.21192508935928345,
-0.21340437233448029,
0.26416903734207153,
0.824664294719696,
-0.5471349954605103,
0.3136155903339386,
0.6092393398284912,
-0.6039397120475769,
0.4368232190608978,
0.1066230982542038,
-0.2535046935081482,
-1.131299376487732,
0.3401144742965698,
-0.05717261880636215,
-0.25731518864631653,
-0.17469367384910583,
0.1110701784491539,
-0.0507546029984951,
0.1421528458595276,
-0.7467197775840759,
0.4362863600254059,
-0.250589519739151,
-0.3539842367172241,
0.14797060191631317,
-0.022298116236925125,
0.6288031935691833,
0.37309613823890686,
0.15831507742404938,
0.5756487250328064,
0.7330052256584167,
-0.6785681843757629,
0.6889585852622986,
-0.21150541305541992,
-0.38249415159225464,
0.45041555166244507,
-0.45726796984672546,
-0.32861006259918213,
-0.12618079781532288,
0.3814131021499634,
-0.73589688539505,
0.07421388477087021,
0.06612000614404678,
-0.048159774392843246,
0.20513322949409485,
0.09950600564479828,
-0.6119440197944641,
0.00011746815289370716,
-0.47287729382514954,
0.47433069348335266,
0.169857919216156,
-0.6919044852256775,
0.808050274848938,
0.02554231323301792,
-0.1852693110704422,
-0.5703691244125366,
-0.6642037630081177,
0.3041979670524597,
-0.5697484612464905,
-0.8564276099205017,
0.4075140953063965,
0.3040500283241272,
-0.4551347494125366,
0.24279196560382843,
-0.4766594469547272,
-0.14072540402412415,
0.15460531413555145,
-0.33567944169044495,
0.17051386833190918,
-0.7084949016571045,
-0.13027578592300415,
-0.008071281015872955,
-0.29779553413391113,
0.09345705062150955,
-0.6323959827423096,
0.3522355556488037,
-0.08546669781208038,
-0.30201202630996704,
-0.6320942640304565,
0.10053509473800659,
0.8252992630004883,
-0.10210287570953369,
0.9418730735778809,
0.624674916267395,
-0.1616646945476532,
-0.02516271360218525,
-0.449413001537323,
0.1126832440495491,
-0.5332118272781372,
0.47146689891815186,
-0.37994882464408875,
-0.5233199000358582,
0.5532646179199219,
-0.4138556718826294,
0.5819239616394043,
0.5673007369041443,
0.2702047824859619,
0.1079505905508995,
1.075089454650879,
0.45810824632644653,
-0.24722930788993835,
0.26755431294441223,
0.11945891380310059,
0.35263025760650635,
-0.8558149933815002,
-0.2213483601808548,
-0.797234058380127,
-0.034297920763492584,
-0.4649446904659271,
-0.23390521109104156,
0.33764174580574036,
0.04545513540506363,
-0.19346921145915985,
0.43913987278938293,
-0.2960934340953827,
0.436311811208725,
0.26256513595581055,
-0.2892444431781769,
0.44305163621902466,
-0.3118647038936615,
-0.2550080716609955,
-0.02926359698176384,
-0.753724217414856,
-0.41868168115615845,
0.5698922872543335,
0.399164080619812,
0.8148466944694519,
0.049042027443647385,
0.4862288236618042,
-0.06645191460847855,
0.05185567960143089,
-0.3960275650024414,
0.4849679172039032,
-0.45631173253059387,
-0.5435473918914795,
-0.46487683057785034,
-0.29557114839553833,
-1.0772416591644287,
0.6265674829483032,
0.3328782618045807,
-0.9345027208328247,
0.24662497639656067,
0.003321042750030756,
0.048480626195669174,
0.803931474685669,
-0.8184079527854919,
1.1633268594741821,
-0.5042207837104797,
-0.46033117175102234,
-0.1916772425174713,
-0.6344602108001709,
0.46367040276527405,
-0.18841980397701263,
0.24694809317588806,
-0.11962492018938065,
-0.20029859244823456,
0.6715286374092102,
-0.591754674911499,
0.9078851342201233,
-0.1279192864894867,
-0.49609386920928955,
0.03392611816525459,
0.07415850460529327,
0.5394200086593628,
0.20956924557685852,
-0.17623664438724518,
0.38936084508895874,
0.19429613649845123,
-0.42031028866767883,
-0.7179235219955444,
0.5185419321060181,
-0.4432638883590698,
-0.779827356338501,
-0.34065765142440796,
-0.14024822413921356,
-0.0014917564112693071,
0.18096914887428284,
0.3610149323940277,
0.12075749039649963,
-0.06979075819253922,
0.4857182204723358,
0.4384746849536896,
-0.5022224187850952,
0.0958964079618454,
0.5037674903869629,
-0.24201932549476624,
-0.1777307391166687,
1.0812791585922241,
-0.10002420842647552,
0.06997669488191605,
0.6585205793380737,
-0.057500239461660385,
-0.017568716779351234,
-0.09856240451335907,
-0.5791791081428528,
-0.0873592346906662,
-0.7345490455627441,
-0.433059960603714,
-0.7150256633758545,
-0.1228846088051796,
-0.2594793736934662,
-0.48248884081840515,
-0.6814132928848267,
-0.5312530994415283,
-0.18280011415481567,
-0.13416552543640137,
0.4042469561100006,
0.3233824372291565,
0.007606294006109238,
-0.2362930029630661,
-1.0926192998886108,
0.22878746688365936,
0.26119107007980347,
0.7391059398651123,
0.2170880138874054,
0.1201903223991394,
-0.4964559078216553,
-0.18719424307346344,
-0.13872306048870087,
-0.3476060926914215,
0.3345772325992584,
0.002499337773770094,
0.3052784204483032,
0.6372767090797424,
0.2645488679409027,
0.885747492313385,
-0.4336189031600952,
0.9023882150650024,
0.19536906480789185,
-1.0284786224365234,
0.39448282122612,
-0.08965270221233368,
0.06446647644042969,
0.4651738703250885,
0.07870916277170181,
-0.7996149659156799,
-1.0312994718551636,
-0.6501067876815796,
-1.6040654182434082,
0.8264870047569275,
0.1305023431777954,
-0.17706264555454254,
0.3010111451148987,
-0.21534954011440277,
0.3852318823337555,
-0.17644263803958893,
-0.4563685953617096,
-0.047854743897914886,
-0.21620602905750275,
-0.25709840655326843,
0.19912846386432648,
0.11334235966205597,
0.06322062760591507,
-0.3466445505619049,
0.8392051458358765,
0.18039700388908386,
-0.24229060113430023,
0.08943787217140198,
0.09526865184307098,
-0.13964316248893738,
0.11031500995159149,
0.11576300114393234,
0.42073991894721985,
-0.2862759828567505,
0.27925899624824524,
0.47929608821868896,
-0.4369370937347412,
-0.08365830779075623,
-0.2759796380996704,
0.04771441966295242,
0.26530054211616516,
0.3814438283443451,
0.9684013724327087,
0.006957485806196928,
-0.9135358333587646,
0.058996669948101044,
-0.16730724275112152,
0.06045738607645035,
-0.4136705994606018,
0.26571205258369446,
0.06871257722377777,
0.22801466286182404,
0.3391979932785034,
-0.2116222232580185,
0.4381754398345947,
-0.2637022137641907,
0.0844661146402359,
0.23370333015918732,
0.1435934454202652,
-0.2584908604621887,
0.86646568775177,
0.32915711402893066,
0.06479943543672562,
0.32528582215309143,
0.1461745798587799,
-0.3779526948928833,
0.8769704103469849,
0.47209271788597107,
1.1508300304412842,
-0.0056381989270448685,
-0.14022894203662872,
0.12189097702503204,
0.41121917963027954,
-0.013042344711720943,
0.0077229770831763744,
-0.1488541066646576,
-0.4247274696826935,
-0.4181789755821228,
-0.7363336086273193,
-0.49823033809661865,
0.10258527845144272,
-0.6648107767105103,
0.5842286348342896,
-0.40881019830703735,
0.37058350443840027,
-0.08329205960035324,
-0.26856938004493713,
-0.5914602875709534,
0.39998573064804077,
0.00025307247415184975,
1.1541451215744019,
-0.9229124188423157,
0.6771894097328186,
0.6399872899055481,
-0.15180246531963348,
-0.6620672345161438,
0.1049279123544693,
-0.09451893717050552,
-0.48158708214759827,
0.7090280652046204,
0.1625303477048874,
0.0004759120929520577,
-0.2714633643627167,
-0.14060115814208984,
-0.9503461718559265,
1.2520853281021118,
0.3433486223220825,
-0.5602006912231445,
0.035273920744657516,
0.26503443717956543,
0.6027822494506836,
0.014588612131774426,
-0.03426538035273552,
0.6125469207763672,
0.5784549117088318,
-0.12476304918527603,
-1.1089385747909546,
0.08740425854921341,
-0.272034615278244,
0.1841847449541092,
0.43434596061706543,
-0.8758420944213867,
0.6476531028747559,
0.7661963701248169,
-0.25977393984794617,
-0.1916581690311432,
0.8037717342376709,
0.3471684753894806,
0.8814278841018677,
0.5810815691947937,
0.946898341178894,
0.780487060546875,
0.3198948800563812,
0.8636602163314819,
-0.6955894827842712,
0.15296214818954468,
0.7407506704330444,
-0.7555734515190125,
0.7878896594047546,
0.44469839334487915,
-0.04913793131709099,
0.771516740322113,
0.4904235005378723,
0.4050826132297516,
0.35421037673950195,
-0.14470434188842773,
-0.5619794726371765,
-0.1642989069223404,
-0.1798013597726822,
-0.44076573848724365,
0.32540199160575867,
0.634640097618103,
-0.24377280473709106,
-0.5176016092300415,
-0.18356436491012573,
0.04248950630426407,
-0.3109542429447174,
-0.06962817907333374,
0.9028469324111938,
0.1486329734325409,
-0.42024365067481995,
0.5831230282783508,
0.4943639636039734,
0.6070473194122314,
-0.6941745281219482,
0.1390354484319687,
-0.07753509283065796,
0.10300735384225845,
-0.36322447657585144,
-0.6572710871696472,
0.6788467168807983,
0.2023010402917862,
0.11561678349971771,
-0.3311229944229126,
0.5286533236503601,
-0.18909099698066711,
-0.32992392778396606,
0.5907379388809204,
-0.02784949727356434,
0.1696317344903946,
0.3779047429561615,
-0.4428965449333191,
0.15635403990745544,
-0.08184576034545898,
-0.2096068263053894,
0.4051400423049927,
1.2440177202224731,
-0.20937451720237732,
0.34973108768463135,
0.6367767453193665,
-0.023091420531272888,
0.08213196694850922,
-0.24639469385147095,
0.9733284115791321,
-0.80052649974823,
-0.6625850796699524,
-0.6893978714942932,
0.6721871495246887,
-0.156659796833992,
-0.3394245207309723,
0.8348330855369568,
1.0458158254623413,
1.2072404623031616,
0.011998468078672886,
0.7706639766693115,
-0.052321113646030426,
0.12991715967655182,
-0.9698179364204407,
0.21521584689617157,
-0.8869256377220154,
0.6142613291740417,
-0.4812653064727783,
-1.074023962020874,
-0.533348798751831,
0.2645851969718933,
0.07814980298280716,
-0.3657732605934143,
0.795270562171936,
0.7236674427986145,
-0.3272184729576111,
-0.08747085928916931,
0.3246656060218811,
0.1689923256635666,
0.40155959129333496,
0.5607154965400696,
0.35437026619911194,
-0.17368966341018677,
0.478490948677063,
-0.11849620193243027,
-0.006527888588607311,
-0.4105609655380249,
-0.9321010112762451,
-0.30513468384742737,
-0.5069273114204407,
-0.177983358502388,
-0.2983495593070984,
-0.13287480175495148,
0.843078076839447,
0.2979939579963684,
-0.77481609582901,
-0.3935767412185669,
-0.36125555634498596,
0.11904735863208771,
-0.3252273201942444,
-0.2975173592567444,
0.39771488308906555,
-0.5869670510292053,
-0.6481541991233826,
0.350765198469162,
0.7426176071166992,
-0.37645918130874634,
-0.21762046217918396,
-0.23833666741847992,
0.09650964289903641,
0.10314581543207169,
0.6151660084724426,
0.3588850796222687,
-0.6812636256217957,
-0.21539105474948883,
-0.21183857321739197,
-0.2982213497161865,
0.006799426861107349,
0.7548010945320129,
-0.617802619934082,
0.2820006310939789,
0.8749837875366211,
0.9033330678939819,
0.3955107033252716,
-0.22300080955028534,
0.6511185765266418,
-1.0052218437194824,
0.6016511917114258,
0.2580798268318176,
0.4080343544483185,
0.24951551854610443,
-0.6031904220581055,
0.5283434391021729,
0.36211106181144714,
-0.1875600963830948,
-0.9015787243843079,
0.17914001643657684,
-0.6776829361915588,
-0.5701049566268921,
0.9076125025749207,
-0.12725819647312164,
-0.4729911684989929,
-0.5187946557998657,
-0.2505832314491272,
0.21323908865451813,
-0.16957218945026398,
0.7936508655548096,
0.7643570303916931,
0.01028483547270298,
0.1015554666519165,
-0.08740290999412537,
0.37524867057800293,
0.9595116972923279,
-0.6947843432426453,
0.46675562858581543,
0.3662935197353363,
-0.04682695493102074,
0.22740361094474792,
0.44585689902305603,
-0.08848170936107635,
0.3234352469444275,
0.22145962715148926,
0.07989389449357986,
0.45334377884864807,
-0.5044965147972107,
-0.1326024979352951,
-0.07549704611301422,
0.27566540241241455,
-0.12916862964630127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13546v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13546v2
|
Knowledge-Driven Cross-Document Relation Extraction
| 2024-05-22T11:30:59 | 2024-06-18T08:20:19 |
Monika Jain, Raghava Mutharaju, Kuldeep Singh, Ramakanth Kavuluru
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Relation extraction (RE) is a well-known NLP application often treated as a
sentence- or document-level task. However, a handful of recent efforts explore
it across documents or in the cross-document setting (CrossDocRE). This is
distinct from the single document case because different documents often focus
on disparate themes, while text within a document tends to have a single goal.
Linking findings from disparate documents to identify new relationships is at
the core of the popular literature-based knowledge discovery paradigm in
biomedicine and other domains. Current CrossDocRE efforts do not consider
domain knowledge, which are often assumed to be known to the reader when
documents are authored. Here, we propose a novel approach, KXDocRE, that embed
domain knowledge of entities with input text for cross-document RE. Our
proposed framework has three main benefits over baselines: 1) it incorporates
domain knowledge of entities along with documents' text; 2) it offers
interpretability by producing explanatory text for predicted relations between
entities 3) it improves performance over the prior methods.
|
[
-0.27161386609077454,
-0.3341098129749298,
1.0310447216033936,
-0.013602079823613167,
-0.1261102259159088,
0.23674973845481873,
0.013556735590100288,
-0.8172414302825928,
0.36453989148139954,
0.48159027099609375,
-0.5538859963417053,
-0.650968611240387,
-0.7419193983078003,
0.07908398658037186,
-0.38534727692604065,
1.1348545551300049,
-0.17422957718372345,
-0.11954078823328018,
-0.7874807119369507,
-0.19783788919448853,
-0.06371934711933136,
-0.15984104573726654,
-0.5344207882881165,
-0.6595795154571533,
0.7585338950157166,
0.2749081254005432,
0.5541636943817139,
0.6500964760780334,
0.3176532983779907,
0.091971255838871,
0.1891891360282898,
0.15866893529891968,
-0.14975422620773315,
0.45028379559516907,
-0.7853665947914124,
-0.5490925908088684,
-0.2942136228084564,
0.04346589371562004,
0.253287136554718,
0.92890465259552,
0.21376857161521912,
-0.08262042701244354,
0.010409770533442497,
0.38562047481536865,
-0.7421553134918213,
0.337876558303833,
-0.6162370443344116,
0.10119542479515076,
-0.13407091796398163,
-0.2299254834651947,
-0.16300253570079803,
-0.02459513023495674,
0.4206870496273041,
-0.9697214365005493,
0.4940825402736664,
-0.02314305678009987,
1.0069608688354492,
0.046521592885255814,
-0.44079306721687317,
-0.7604644894599915,
-0.5754431486129761,
0.6326687932014465,
-0.3324226140975952,
0.8858744502067566,
0.3341746926307678,
0.09888201206922531,
0.005648527294397354,
-1.0925971269607544,
-0.5022899508476257,
0.06610502302646637,
-0.3988259732723236,
0.26194465160369873,
-0.04652005061507225,
-0.46256256103515625,
0.1366048902273178,
0.4949961304664612,
-0.24439001083374023,
-0.20067723095417023,
-0.19145497679710388,
-0.05739399045705795,
0.4788983166217804,
0.12186311930418015,
0.46686384081840515,
-0.2147558629512787,
-0.2860991656780243,
0.040099818259477615,
-0.679572343826294,
-0.03958026319742203,
-0.19431595504283905,
0.13751937448978424,
0.05033031478524208,
0.44457608461380005,
-0.031120900064706802,
0.16595175862312317,
0.2173549085855484,
-0.1679294854402542,
0.2589777708053589,
-0.5275877714157104,
-0.0636637732386589,
-0.022171031683683395,
0.8878753185272217,
0.2510851323604584,
0.10461951792240143,
-0.6369229555130005,
0.12245851010084152,
-0.11786532402038574,
0.3251349925994873,
-0.5946372747421265,
-0.2093091607093811,
0.25387972593307495,
-0.6296798586845398,
-0.3397201895713806,
-0.19826793670654297,
-0.9402135610580444,
-0.3671857714653015,
-0.29742589592933655,
-0.05038951709866524,
-0.7334298491477966,
-0.2432214915752411,
-0.3915298283100128,
-0.46843618154525757,
0.2481796145439148,
0.37496960163116455,
-0.9004954099655151,
0.42245230078697205,
0.7724014520645142,
0.7215598821640015,
-0.26871660351753235,
-0.27758294343948364,
-0.6224345564842224,
0.5590959787368774,
0.04646625369787216,
0.7185344099998474,
-0.7564674615859985,
-0.7646564841270447,
0.05726722627878189,
0.1722000390291214,
0.056500304490327835,
-0.25872185826301575,
0.7502421140670776,
-0.5443652868270874,
0.3294629156589508,
-0.28155454993247986,
-0.5813080072402954,
0.1584736853837967,
0.1333499252796173,
-0.7566565871238708,
0.9263967275619507,
0.4479960501194,
-0.870924174785614,
0.621863603591919,
-0.23614467680454254,
-0.6086056232452393,
-0.024145759642124176,
-0.5982473492622375,
-0.4793106019496918,
-0.01888541877269745,
0.5690381526947021,
0.5001750588417053,
-0.62830650806427,
0.09156908094882965,
-0.42835718393325806,
0.2620161175727844,
-0.08835802227258682,
0.43153539299964905,
0.8594939112663269,
0.14392052590847015,
-0.07365123927593231,
-0.34189173579216003,
-0.9060078859329224,
-0.06426558643579483,
0.05071854591369629,
-0.2184733748435974,
-1.1592167615890503,
-0.21076582372188568,
-0.07308201491832733,
0.4934873878955841,
0.02524973452091217,
-0.9078763723373413,
0.17295268177986145,
-0.4015648663043976,
0.2185484766960144,
0.09150380641222,
0.3264535367488861,
0.798143744468689,
-0.15696439146995544,
0.5988974571228027,
-0.01264598872512579,
-0.08996567130088806,
-0.3214736580848694,
-0.492472380399704,
-0.2855243980884552,
-0.15215617418289185,
0.45633867383003235,
0.3804519474506378,
-1.0666632652282715,
0.13752979040145874,
-0.32017698884010315,
-0.6091684103012085,
-0.3785492479801178,
0.2514025866985321,
0.48142310976982117,
0.9909986853599548,
0.5275465250015259,
-0.0729951560497284,
-0.4311743378639221,
-0.8065338134765625,
-0.38810011744499207,
-0.004133771639317274,
-0.15697607398033142,
0.4925795793533325,
0.5456801056861877,
-0.29002219438552856,
1.0524861812591553,
-0.8460683226585388,
-0.5525527596473694,
-0.19592179358005524,
0.2333909422159195,
0.03403036668896675,
0.35611236095428467,
0.5865574479103088,
-0.9230895638465881,
-0.8615276217460632,
0.43901538848876953,
-0.9857607483863831,
-0.3418537676334381,
-0.13270412385463715,
-0.2662324607372284,
-0.1920616179704666,
0.7593767642974854,
-0.6224587559700012,
0.3704175353050232,
0.1937830150127411,
-0.042688481509685516,
0.27783137559890747,
-0.06401853263378143,
-0.05315294489264488,
-1.3380101919174194,
0.25989919900894165,
0.13666433095932007,
-0.31136661767959595,
-0.38554027676582336,
-0.05445872247219086,
0.5093856453895569,
-0.2346731722354889,
-0.22337345778942108,
0.6126810312271118,
-0.7466687560081482,
-0.04155436158180237,
-0.011262400075793266,
0.4467798173427582,
0.3800094723701477,
0.37185633182525635,
0.5572823882102966,
0.2474481165409088,
0.46211355924606323,
-0.36164307594299316,
0.10087477415800095,
0.6866238713264465,
0.0955323725938797,
0.9094308614730835,
-0.5613624453544617,
-0.09178980439901352,
0.08925468474626541,
0.22407343983650208,
-0.5522988438606262,
0.2087930142879486,
0.4073409140110016,
-0.8058404326438904,
0.3806575834751129,
-0.1736580729484558,
-0.09871116280555725,
0.10084876418113708,
-0.3162098526954651,
0.35117751359939575,
0.047926850616931915,
-0.5606504082679749,
0.9553179144859314,
0.5202635526657104,
-0.4233720302581787,
-0.6529117822647095,
-0.4481286406517029,
0.06762394309043884,
0.10064160078763962,
-0.6182253360748291,
0.9088816046714783,
0.5298337936401367,
-0.10237222909927368,
0.5020325779914856,
-0.21743687987327576,
-0.37011775374412537,
-0.21528130769729614,
0.5519155859947205,
0.054997850209474564,
-0.08646927773952484,
0.3350507616996765,
0.39182066917419434,
-0.2029954195022583,
0.3206626772880554,
-0.23268792033195496,
0.18080495297908783,
0.6456234455108643,
-0.052145522087812424,
-0.1071714460849762,
1.0247235298156738,
0.7058296203613281,
-0.4316611588001251,
0.47867581248283386,
0.5696666836738586,
-0.6114843487739563,
-0.31725043058395386,
-0.12224531918764114,
0.09755688160657883,
-0.2884783148765564,
0.2849975824356079,
-0.677977442741394,
-0.5719443559646606,
0.5489158034324646,
-0.39003902673721313,
0.11070431023836136,
0.6695272326469421,
0.37571898102760315,
-0.15836095809936523,
0.4370631277561188,
0.9588400721549988,
-0.09958028793334961,
0.26921120285987854,
-0.21154215931892395,
0.20544883608818054,
-1.1893748044967651,
-0.5892838835716248,
-0.7951244115829468,
0.04798717424273491,
-0.3075682520866394,
-0.37009888887405396,
0.12440969794988632,
-0.07668313384056091,
0.32331934571266174,
0.5901756882667542,
-0.07017647475004196,
-0.013691544532775879,
0.47398585081100464,
0.05931507796049118,
0.5465574860572815,
-0.1284521073102951,
-0.42517444491386414,
-0.14970232546329498,
-0.7388638257980347,
-0.14882344007492065,
1.3290345668792725,
0.21938695013523102,
0.7965888381004333,
-0.20591433346271515,
1.171188473701477,
0.18968133628368378,
0.5895318388938904,
-0.7568074464797974,
0.0068732211366295815,
-0.06094428896903992,
-0.40230804681777954,
-0.18941214680671692,
-0.38301241397857666,
-1.3739843368530273,
0.03896211087703705,
-0.46867889165878296,
-0.6452338695526123,
0.7004314064979553,
-0.16510425508022308,
-0.3278322219848633,
-0.0039291116409003735,
-0.4206666946411133,
0.6276198029518127,
-0.08268160372972488,
-0.6142637133598328,
0.08568520098924637,
-0.6951688528060913,
0.2689412236213684,
-0.27886781096458435,
0.05373195931315422,
0.3259080946445465,
-0.2797089219093323,
0.6199278235435486,
-0.591478705406189,
0.4445386826992035,
0.12867853045463562,
-0.3075230121612549,
0.005135690327733755,
-0.03294133394956589,
0.43694251775741577,
0.4685928523540497,
0.061854518949985504,
0.11127717792987823,
0.21251215040683746,
-0.08978702872991562,
-0.9364822506904602,
0.9263509511947632,
-0.538727879524231,
-0.37371641397476196,
-0.46039965748786926,
-0.6823232173919678,
-0.5974159240722656,
0.42820367217063904,
0.04116812348365784,
0.32493647933006287,
-0.2395419180393219,
0.262381374835968,
0.6113812923431396,
-0.2689296007156372,
0.17265458405017853,
0.637078583240509,
-0.18720290064811707,
-0.5610846281051636,
0.6111409664154053,
-0.0023955528158694506,
0.2061571627855301,
0.8012314438819885,
-0.029146993532776833,
-0.46109992265701294,
-0.12195264548063278,
-0.2120969146490097,
0.35147058963775635,
-0.6493423581123352,
-0.20479343831539154,
-1.1522585153579712,
-0.04497329890727997,
-0.7967113852500916,
-0.19638270139694214,
-0.29081282019615173,
-0.3365951478481293,
-0.11590313166379929,
0.10434161126613617,
-0.07237640023231506,
0.31734010577201843,
-0.0634971559047699,
-0.00939006544649601,
-1.1733648777008057,
0.5542367100715637,
0.13249868154525757,
0.13503804802894592,
-0.0961776003241539,
0.05404975637793541,
-0.39500343799591064,
-0.21213340759277344,
-0.1235051080584526,
-1.0876861810684204,
0.3743613362312317,
0.16186518967151642,
0.8506481647491455,
0.16170711815357208,
-0.04226790368556976,
0.3936505615711212,
-0.4028199315071106,
0.37357795238494873,
0.12255828082561493,
-0.7919083833694458,
0.7826915979385376,
-0.27955925464630127,
0.17309421300888062,
0.6428242921829224,
0.8904454708099365,
-0.6252906918525696,
-0.35309073328971863,
-1.0435397624969482,
-0.7701915502548218,
0.5593110918998718,
0.45196959376335144,
-0.2079361230134964,
0.05353258550167084,
0.4542264938354492,
0.29630181193351746,
0.16879062354564667,
-0.39966073632240295,
-0.16694413125514984,
0.06552532315254211,
-0.2188754677772522,
0.12937110662460327,
-0.018814612179994583,
-0.1450372040271759,
-0.032266050577163696,
0.6655731201171875,
-0.07484019547700882,
0.12780237197875977,
0.6693565249443054,
-0.36429035663604736,
-0.02717866562306881,
-0.08342427015304565,
0.2200538069009781,
0.7642922401428223,
-0.23396949470043182,
0.1861506551504135,
-0.26747310161590576,
-0.5915883779525757,
-0.1222837045788765,
0.2787976861000061,
-0.18238720297813416,
0.3657168447971344,
0.6731578707695007,
0.04266276955604553,
0.1720903217792511,
-0.3497190773487091,
0.4701688289642334,
-0.19279198348522186,
-0.41975080966949463,
0.013867322355508804,
-0.12838557362556458,
0.276233971118927,
0.337655246257782,
0.2169332504272461,
-0.05283494293689728,
0.1348569691181183,
-0.7507418990135193,
0.6391968131065369,
0.3435017168521881,
-0.4953781068325043,
-0.022973384708166122,
0.7565467357635498,
0.4687376022338867,
-0.219184011220932,
0.35543760657310486,
0.06990686804056168,
-0.44472500681877136,
0.5281327962875366,
0.4411380887031555,
0.7537662982940674,
-0.056356996297836304,
0.2124241143465042,
0.3747578561306,
0.03933223336935043,
0.2705878019332886,
-0.023282866925001144,
-0.47214797139167786,
-0.8065142631530762,
-0.2465367466211319,
-0.4349709153175354,
-0.38730430603027344,
0.05702389031648636,
-0.8295289874076843,
0.37422502040863037,
-0.29040974378585815,
0.08893505483865738,
0.47580230236053467,
0.20473237335681915,
-0.6211279630661011,
0.4917216897010803,
-0.1372084766626358,
1.0024586915969849,
-0.9417831897735596,
1.2037572860717773,
0.6163799166679382,
-0.7933369874954224,
-0.5776329636573792,
0.1436539739370346,
-0.2247733473777771,
-0.7447899580001831,
0.842132031917572,
-0.395785927772522,
0.07942666858434677,
-0.1333158165216446,
-0.06085832789540291,
-0.8096523284912109,
1.3323334455490112,
0.13834795355796814,
-0.5297400951385498,
-0.18528959155082703,
0.18220990896224976,
0.5367885231971741,
-0.7132000923156738,
0.017954882234334946,
0.44025030732154846,
0.15970364212989807,
0.00468870997428894,
-0.6672120690345764,
0.40752556920051575,
-0.5275645852088928,
-0.21742676198482513,
0.506144106388092,
-0.23402659595012665,
0.7178523540496826,
0.06022326648235321,
-0.13284191489219666,
-0.122318796813488,
0.6964631080627441,
0.03582591190934181,
0.7523669600486755,
0.4666472375392914,
0.8022271394729614,
0.7156652212142944,
0.1045096144080162,
1.146907091140747,
-0.3220948576927185,
0.24036426842212677,
1.6565160751342773,
-0.507344663143158,
0.4900699555873871,
0.8584176301956177,
-0.1136731505393982,
0.5923787355422974,
0.44023779034614563,
0.012235053814947605,
0.6595577597618103,
-0.17448660731315613,
-0.10452063381671906,
-0.2207578718662262,
-0.17308387160301208,
-0.5682026147842407,
0.2716602385044098,
0.4238155484199524,
-1.2188727855682373,
-0.47425997257232666,
-0.22245079278945923,
0.1847115457057953,
0.07160456478595734,
-0.1358613818883896,
0.7042421698570251,
0.3079277575016022,
-0.7696725726127625,
0.048146799206733704,
-0.1395891159772873,
0.16685906052589417,
-0.5437301397323608,
-0.373998761177063,
-0.18407711386680603,
0.1041913777589798,
-0.3197377622127533,
-0.866973340511322,
0.4834691882133484,
-0.26575419306755066,
-0.675741970539093,
-0.13027459383010864,
1.127158284187317,
-0.5224058032035828,
-0.3445839583873749,
0.4654439091682434,
1.0607191324234009,
-0.1295395791530609,
-0.2657889723777771,
-0.5966600775718689,
-0.3097513020038605,
0.017927022650837898,
0.09620364010334015,
0.40331390500068665,
0.8484013676643372,
-0.32605862617492676,
0.5092982053756714,
0.8210152387619019,
0.11559491604566574,
-0.3655841648578644,
-0.03538069874048233,
1.1053236722946167,
-0.5205278992652893,
-0.43724969029426575,
-0.6076249480247498,
0.2865205407142639,
-0.5854587554931641,
-0.4100020229816437,
0.6880818605422974,
0.6043592095375061,
0.696929395198822,
-0.056020963937044144,
1.1399487257003784,
-0.3837950527667999,
0.6287459135055542,
-0.275526225566864,
0.6713671088218689,
-0.6234733462333679,
0.13193534314632416,
-0.5667520761489868,
-0.7369294166564941,
-0.2253846973180771,
0.2688465416431427,
-0.31599804759025574,
-0.2859037518501282,
1.1449778079986572,
0.5591214299201965,
-0.16309191286563873,
-0.0032331240363419056,
0.18019220232963562,
-0.17018401622772217,
0.3903675675392151,
0.8343201279640198,
0.5849052667617798,
-0.515808641910553,
0.7368055582046509,
-0.49395352602005005,
-0.20479626953601837,
0.2525325417518616,
-0.8651874661445618,
-0.8579099774360657,
-0.7036994695663452,
-0.47217848896980286,
-0.26049137115478516,
0.03658498823642731,
0.46066397428512573,
0.5399991869926453,
-0.384890615940094,
0.2616669237613678,
-0.034962691366672516,
0.3531433045864105,
-0.24671393632888794,
-0.21886830031871796,
0.4478173553943634,
-0.2783282995223999,
-0.7678489089012146,
0.12642715871334076,
0.32187044620513916,
-0.40597182512283325,
-0.1009921208024025,
-0.034906499087810516,
-0.5772980451583862,
-0.2038872092962265,
0.49825501441955566,
0.3599007725715637,
-0.20523469150066376,
0.007144317962229252,
-0.004465254954993725,
-0.18453927338123322,
0.06651964783668518,
1.1340181827545166,
-1.0035486221313477,
0.2737109363079071,
0.5868770480155945,
0.9188967943191528,
0.6457933187484741,
-0.08744160830974579,
1.0148547887802124,
-0.7950491905212402,
-0.2952492833137512,
0.20752805471420288,
0.4441853165626526,
0.1950167566537857,
-0.675826907157898,
0.8088052868843079,
0.49844011664390564,
-0.34486353397369385,
-0.41228070855140686,
0.17623642086982727,
-0.9916831851005554,
-0.338679701089859,
0.9661622643470764,
-0.5957304239273071,
-0.34705498814582825,
-0.41493329405784607,
-0.2527385354042053,
0.32121679186820984,
-0.4636869728565216,
0.6909902095794678,
0.46252015233039856,
-0.2961137592792511,
-0.32109156250953674,
-0.29436036944389343,
0.501763641834259,
0.2685500979423523,
-1.0496797561645508,
-0.1444852501153946,
0.2308807671070099,
0.3653533160686493,
0.6812711358070374,
0.5225328803062439,
-0.3893994092941284,
0.31514808535575867,
0.15749195218086243,
0.04778522625565529,
-0.052792809903621674,
-0.15246546268463135,
0.3479280173778534,
0.40943339467048645,
-0.48009148240089417,
-0.061938341706991196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13541v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13541v1
|
Annotation-Efficient Preference Optimization for Language Model Alignment
| 2024-05-22T11:23:03 | 2024-05-22T11:23:03 |
Yuu Jinnai, Ukyo Honda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Preference optimization is a standard approach to fine-tuning large language
models to align with human preferences. The quality, diversity, and quantity of
the preference dataset are critical to the effectiveness of preference
optimization. However, obtaining a large amount of high-quality and diverse
preference annotations is difficult in many applications. This raises the
question of how to use the limited annotation budget to create an effective
preference dataset. To this end, we propose Annotation-Efficient Preference
Optimization (AEPO). Instead of exhaustively annotating preference over all
available response texts, AEPO selects a subset of responses that maximizes
quality and diversity from the available responses, and then annotates
preference over the selected ones. In this way, AEPO focuses the annotation
budget on labeling preference over a smaller subset of responses with diversity
and of high quality. We evaluate the performance of Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO) using AEPO and show that it outperforms models trained using
a standard DPO with the same annotation budget. Our code is available at
https://github.com/CyberAgentAILab/annotation-efficient-po
|
[
-0.7270790934562683,
-0.38072770833969116,
0.27595531940460205,
0.17287179827690125,
-0.3818376958370209,
-0.07863346487283707,
-0.40212392807006836,
-0.6029214859008789,
0.2381940633058548,
0.5259538888931274,
-0.3414905369281769,
-0.2963178753852844,
-0.43627652525901794,
0.29745590686798096,
0.06581877171993256,
0.8532740473747253,
0.004288428463041782,
-0.20225252211093903,
-0.4319995939731598,
-0.21132226288318634,
-0.2762046158313751,
-0.5176072120666504,
-0.7156358361244202,
-0.3449064791202545,
0.30453231930732727,
0.5925683975219727,
0.7032696604728699,
1.1370322704315186,
0.6351807117462158,
0.2555522322654724,
-0.11409462243318558,
0.460945188999176,
-0.37981119751930237,
0.13644304871559143,
0.02898379974067211,
-0.1153489425778389,
-0.4888845980167389,
-0.1493719220161438,
0.47179922461509705,
0.6634791493415833,
0.15101468563079834,
0.22646084427833557,
0.11017506569623947,
0.7114784717559814,
-0.8467283844947815,
0.053740765899419785,
-0.6856125593185425,
-0.10497237741947174,
-0.12708352506160736,
-0.15664921700954437,
-0.3013763725757599,
-0.5702580809593201,
0.4066934883594513,
-0.9931967854499817,
-0.25025618076324463,
0.38950419425964355,
0.9228739738464355,
0.40019625425338745,
-0.20109470188617706,
-0.19773772358894348,
-0.7208271622657776,
0.9447996616363525,
-0.4044662117958069,
0.3808199167251587,
0.6648499965667725,
0.005934009328484535,
0.06497060507535934,
-0.24052032828330994,
-0.5117114782333374,
-0.136675164103508,
0.002958616940304637,
0.07247628271579742,
-0.021139424294233322,
0.28736263513565063,
0.12529033422470093,
0.37538793683052063,
-0.3839249908924103,
0.3826821744441986,
0.05298245698213577,
-0.320110946893692,
0.7471300363540649,
-0.060492776334285736,
0.16833679378032684,
0.025713909417390823,
-0.3920486271381378,
-0.03638027608394623,
-0.2760617434978485,
0.08612596988677979,
0.6436349153518677,
0.4780164361000061,
0.24708618223667145,
0.5033083558082581,
-0.4791117012500763,
0.8995991945266724,
0.16299477219581604,
-0.25303950905799866,
0.5062766075134277,
-0.19848407804965973,
-0.07181063294410706,
0.19924266636371613,
0.7059743404388428,
0.5088934302330017,
0.4680991470813751,
-0.08442690968513489,
-0.2755521535873413,
0.10672406852245331,
0.22988800704479218,
-0.7482845783233643,
-0.09364686906337738,
0.30246731638908386,
-0.28830331563949585,
-0.5090157389640808,
-0.33119240403175354,
-0.9465766549110413,
-0.23563839495182037,
-0.49813634157180786,
0.24411927163600922,
-0.2153281271457672,
-0.21425558626651764,
0.23799870908260345,
-0.019068222492933273,
-0.09286434948444366,
0.4257164001464844,
-1.3494518995285034,
0.28056883811950684,
0.6644606590270996,
0.7799864411354065,
-0.18882162868976593,
-0.12982980906963348,
-0.5026829838752747,
0.037588443607091904,
-0.12744836509227753,
0.909776508808136,
-0.8132926821708679,
-0.44284868240356445,
0.05645539239048958,
-0.5295459628105164,
0.08721457421779633,
-0.5270996689796448,
0.9260784387588501,
-0.4174343943595886,
0.07903969287872314,
-0.4000779390335083,
-0.6671755313873291,
-0.02456755004823208,
0.17648543417453766,
-0.6445574760437012,
1.0581308603286743,
0.02599669247865677,
-0.8700553178787231,
0.5337255001068115,
-0.7734413743019104,
-0.2766663134098053,
0.0662010982632637,
-0.07994627207517624,
-0.44964516162872314,
-0.05142517387866974,
0.3284059166908264,
0.21188998222351074,
-0.25932154059410095,
0.1706218719482422,
-0.6237427592277527,
-0.2475505769252777,
0.1628996580839157,
0.048899002373218536,
0.580281674861908,
0.3858300745487213,
-0.23157000541687012,
0.2818883955478668,
-0.8115062117576599,
-0.14650709927082062,
0.18940448760986328,
-0.3590005934238434,
-0.7535386085510254,
0.04865351691842079,
0.04432089999318123,
0.01066521555185318,
0.4397546648979187,
-0.6545049548149109,
0.5004404187202454,
-0.5680062174797058,
0.2750830352306366,
1.0050615072250366,
-0.2827957570552826,
0.7722575664520264,
-0.08448678255081177,
0.38829153776168823,
-0.34620973467826843,
0.39346805214881897,
0.15043509006500244,
-0.47961199283599854,
-0.6574752330780029,
-0.521831750869751,
0.3993523418903351,
0.4619724750518799,
-0.29859331250190735,
0.7421708106994629,
-0.18488135933876038,
-0.24922603368759155,
-0.7367912530899048,
0.11203289777040482,
0.3015623688697815,
0.7982651591300964,
0.34469369053840637,
-0.21929679811000824,
-0.47352197766304016,
-1.3196425437927246,
-0.1849054992198944,
-0.24190708994865417,
0.24643607437610626,
0.40455004572868347,
0.24043408036231995,
-0.028021860867738724,
1.1762033700942993,
-0.7743092775344849,
-0.11479219794273376,
-0.09449198096990585,
-0.12478801608085632,
-0.11896487325429916,
0.40026023983955383,
0.7096490859985352,
-0.8176317811012268,
-0.40976759791374207,
0.06821884214878082,
-0.08085814118385315,
-0.5312744975090027,
0.10492594540119171,
-0.4687333106994629,
0.1400594264268875,
-0.1614917367696762,
-0.2527775168418884,
0.007831454277038574,
0.6326398253440857,
-0.06901010125875473,
0.30448606610298157,
0.06281581521034241,
0.1926845759153366,
-1.122942328453064,
0.28448644280433655,
0.023505685850977898,
-0.23576857149600983,
-0.5711055397987366,
-0.2787645757198334,
0.06278154253959656,
-0.10109817981719971,
-0.2114035040140152,
0.7285217642784119,
-0.2485698163509369,
0.08074650168418884,
-0.38319841027259827,
0.16120865941047668,
0.182077556848526,
0.5101043581962585,
0.2622874081134796,
0.7153010368347168,
0.3928435742855072,
-0.44022831320762634,
0.13587625324726105,
0.37306442856788635,
0.013012001290917397,
0.23218747973442078,
-0.4912804663181305,
0.36344537138938904,
-0.17548388242721558,
-0.04460630938410759,
-1.0128464698791504,
-0.291334867477417,
0.41943883895874023,
-0.14954009652137756,
0.3936872184276581,
-0.30966320633888245,
-0.3298434317111969,
-0.08839218318462372,
-0.4628373384475708,
0.4107840955257416,
0.35418978333473206,
-0.7399137020111084,
0.33492010831832886,
0.7085631489753723,
-0.15956303477287292,
-0.8849393725395203,
-0.3346870243549347,
-0.37704694271087646,
-0.3788950443267822,
-0.2916429936885834,
0.491609662771225,
-0.11353719234466553,
-0.21359772980213165,
-0.13506007194519043,
-0.13330873847007751,
-0.07479304820299149,
0.23065035045146942,
0.1052517369389534,
0.29772043228149414,
0.16566155850887299,
0.19035562872886658,
0.13865192234516144,
-0.3093508780002594,
-0.2674129903316498,
-0.351011723279953,
0.7249941229820251,
-0.12679210305213928,
-0.20668324828147888,
-0.289741575717926,
0.45222437381744385,
0.3553096354007721,
-0.5546815395355225,
0.4098106324672699,
0.30604273080825806,
-0.40420255064964294,
-0.07971969991922379,
-0.6144976615905762,
-0.007963473908603191,
-0.4653277099132538,
0.38719800114631653,
-0.38539057970046997,
-0.9345315098762512,
0.4141542315483093,
-0.011123034171760082,
0.38858214020729065,
0.49669596552848816,
0.25011661648750305,
0.14797762036323547,
1.1808103322982788,
0.3906295597553253,
-0.3271600306034088,
0.7867028713226318,
0.09918145835399628,
-0.01423659361898899,
-0.752875804901123,
0.00922095961868763,
-0.8506620526313782,
-0.35167181491851807,
-0.5820062160491943,
-0.0009600680787116289,
0.025560980662703514,
0.2648579776287079,
-0.3357315957546234,
0.19730326533317566,
-0.9358400702476501,
0.41399455070495605,
0.7961961030960083,
-0.03884139284491539,
0.2928276062011719,
0.16694758832454681,
0.08900457620620728,
-0.19603131711483002,
-0.48350289463996887,
-0.7495704889297485,
1.1972235441207886,
0.40720757842063904,
0.450639009475708,
-0.12904345989227295,
1.041912317276001,
-0.08480467647314072,
0.19691358506679535,
-0.7802311182022095,
0.48012059926986694,
-0.24734903872013092,
-0.4659935534000397,
-0.32542431354522705,
-0.48199087381362915,
-0.7382181882858276,
0.19678930938243866,
-0.3727858364582062,
-0.966046154499054,
0.3662450909614563,
0.576423168182373,
-0.40936028957366943,
0.10418760776519775,
-0.7856467962265015,
0.9666731357574463,
-0.43127304315567017,
-0.32414010167121887,
-0.028634127229452133,
-0.42921045422554016,
0.039159853011369705,
-0.1658259630203247,
-0.017724154517054558,
-0.44495418667793274,
-0.2219894677400589,
0.7705263495445251,
-0.14437654614448547,
0.5720305442810059,
-0.18179315328598022,
0.1387874186038971,
0.1141292005777359,
-0.15747186541557312,
0.3928430676460266,
0.08931026607751846,
-0.2805522084236145,
0.16287192702293396,
-0.20021550357341766,
-0.2506544291973114,
-0.38353002071380615,
0.6529263854026794,
-0.8808627724647522,
-0.47856733202934265,
-0.3777990937232971,
-0.2870972454547882,
-0.285134494304657,
0.33216577768325806,
0.23030032217502594,
0.35790225863456726,
0.03487857058644295,
-0.051327213644981384,
0.5294080376625061,
-0.2527352273464203,
0.33786824345588684,
0.10692311823368073,
-0.3435485064983368,
-0.7997855544090271,
0.75006502866745,
0.15247730910778046,
0.31230825185775757,
0.541867196559906,
0.5209225416183472,
-0.47783535718917847,
-0.6610919237136841,
-0.5182130336761475,
0.047482412308454514,
-0.5762656927108765,
-0.2286500334739685,
-0.6246864795684814,
0.2614353597164154,
-0.3759160339832306,
-0.23386737704277039,
-0.68199622631073,
-0.7191521525382996,
-0.15643757581710815,
-0.04279877245426178,
0.5030565857887268,
0.16670548915863037,
0.02738483063876629,
0.0791514664888382,
-0.47147881984710693,
0.1770191639661789,
0.35155239701271057,
0.46062934398651123,
-0.3018295168876648,
-0.3624025881290436,
-0.1517179012298584,
0.01875552348792553,
-0.3446597754955292,
-0.8779389262199402,
0.15560835599899292,
0.25196853280067444,
0.6079221963882446,
0.4289205074310303,
0.3801337778568268,
0.6528096795082092,
-0.21562711894512177,
0.5091068148612976,
0.02847370319068432,
-0.9769627451896667,
0.870824933052063,
-0.29893729090690613,
0.29081809520721436,
1.0415513515472412,
0.42530685663223267,
-0.2522943615913391,
-0.1410500556230545,
-0.4306768476963043,
-1.157653570175171,
0.6445976495742798,
0.18190892040729523,
0.06101871654391289,
-0.09180331975221634,
0.5706982612609863,
0.2766973376274109,
0.23765511810779572,
-0.6109284162521362,
-0.4203413724899292,
-0.15976577997207642,
-0.21785549819469452,
0.08346500247716904,
-0.4009043872356415,
-0.23032519221305847,
-0.15583014488220215,
0.7845430970191956,
-0.3045216202735901,
0.13856466114521027,
0.2399987429380417,
0.14642713963985443,
-0.20402668416500092,
0.2600058615207672,
0.6911268830299377,
0.5104014873504639,
-0.4438391327857971,
-0.07261265814304352,
0.08291944861412048,
-0.4262079894542694,
-0.04914671555161476,
0.3204871416091919,
-0.40367424488067627,
-0.07721038907766342,
0.05945642292499542,
1.0004733800888062,
-0.10233351588249207,
-0.5403681397438049,
0.34990590810775757,
-0.09189654141664505,
-0.054474689066410065,
-0.10863296687602997,
0.06247257813811302,
0.020263800397515297,
-0.024947229772806168,
0.15724141895771027,
0.03752024099230766,
0.41614046692848206,
-0.23312965035438538,
-0.08490023016929626,
0.4219246804714203,
-0.13071970641613007,
-0.035549648106098175,
0.7134605050086975,
0.515097975730896,
-0.3439792990684509,
0.5407997369766235,
-0.06480386853218079,
-0.5302833318710327,
0.4436185359954834,
0.4759112298488617,
1.0655776262283325,
-0.15759406983852386,
0.018144147470593452,
0.5161002278327942,
0.16979168355464935,
-0.07959384471178055,
0.09066855907440186,
-0.17912070453166962,
-0.9520776867866516,
-0.3336455821990967,
-0.8209424614906311,
-0.6760041117668152,
-0.00276573677547276,
-0.7869496941566467,
0.3859420716762543,
-0.524755597114563,
-0.4301413893699646,
0.1564669907093048,
0.08699285238981247,
-0.6781235337257385,
0.27571117877960205,
0.2781212627887726,
0.634916365146637,
-0.7831425666809082,
0.7134078741073608,
1.0088063478469849,
-0.4014906883239746,
-0.6548420190811157,
-0.0916750505566597,
-0.13725446164608002,
-0.8080683946609497,
0.5858286023139954,
0.3099144399166107,
-0.1010979413986206,
0.05003361403942108,
-0.057376474142074585,
-0.8766829371452332,
0.7066083550453186,
0.683044970035553,
-0.822812557220459,
0.3371967077255249,
0.16640618443489075,
0.4228738844394684,
-0.5124370455741882,
0.3051166236400604,
0.4389428496360779,
0.4731520116329193,
-0.19913114607334137,
-1.1172140836715698,
-0.06981401145458221,
-0.29246920347213745,
0.039097126573324203,
0.43894654512405396,
-0.7977828979492188,
0.24616912007331848,
0.09432365745306015,
-0.008010541088879108,
-0.30509114265441895,
0.4632556736469269,
0.2462819367647171,
0.22124122083187103,
0.8019106388092041,
0.6315319538116455,
0.7389361262321472,
-0.17310501635074615,
0.9826375246047974,
-0.4130288362503052,
0.4779115617275238,
1.0264301300048828,
-0.28902363777160645,
0.9032514691352844,
0.700273871421814,
-0.0959857925772667,
-0.09927302598953247,
0.8531964421272278,
0.21154090762138367,
0.5987409353256226,
0.10188848525285721,
-0.19835293292999268,
-0.35274603962898254,
-0.40666258335113525,
-0.34014588594436646,
0.5824888348579407,
-0.105328269302845,
-0.30589574575424194,
0.2421044558286667,
-0.23743289709091187,
-0.005993051454424858,
0.14752960205078125,
-0.1869416981935501,
0.972804844379425,
-0.22502043843269348,
-0.7633534669876099,
0.5497374534606934,
-0.2432003915309906,
0.6002106070518494,
-0.5149373412132263,
0.15429559350013733,
-0.2483127862215042,
0.06474398076534271,
-0.17400239408016205,
-0.6413153409957886,
0.25261810421943665,
-0.09631980210542679,
-0.21190808713436127,
-0.30096134543418884,
0.7175677418708801,
-0.5080594420433044,
-0.256539523601532,
0.25373193621635437,
-0.05398589372634888,
-0.14643330872058868,
-0.05731676518917084,
-0.6770154237747192,
0.2370571494102478,
0.11849501729011536,
-0.5434681177139282,
0.3568909466266632,
0.028103390708565712,
0.03254153952002525,
0.5369489789009094,
0.5551775097846985,
0.2034931480884552,
-0.3046795725822449,
0.12000047415494919,
0.745853066444397,
-0.24213258922100067,
-0.6209584474563599,
-0.986707866191864,
0.5174618363380432,
-0.5305011868476868,
-0.7691479325294495,
0.46025046706199646,
0.7644109725952148,
1.040666937828064,
0.010691673494875431,
0.8777886033058167,
0.23959292471408844,
0.40807637572288513,
-0.4125868082046509,
0.3645605742931366,
-0.5892592072486877,
0.17069239914417267,
-0.48474225401878357,
-1.2840189933776855,
-0.4659000039100647,
0.8798853754997253,
-0.5322232246398926,
0.026431897655129433,
0.32923421263694763,
0.6261624693870544,
0.04716496169567108,
0.11825501918792725,
0.0770350992679596,
-0.4141363501548767,
0.22219108045101166,
0.3961009681224823,
0.6577919721603394,
-0.0463467575609684,
0.38381657004356384,
-0.7257324457168579,
-0.43000343441963196,
-0.25495007634162903,
-1.0438306331634521,
-0.6726287007331848,
-0.5296162366867065,
-0.5843563675880432,
-0.14521828293800354,
0.11101063340902328,
1.5338789224624634,
0.8350768089294434,
-0.7323484420776367,
-0.06605513393878937,
0.046522509306669235,
-0.13242129981517792,
-0.11453467607498169,
-0.18766643106937408,
0.40988829731941223,
-0.30024755001068115,
-1.0262154340744019,
0.0010921377688646317,
0.4467916190624237,
0.07787635177373886,
0.016345040872693062,
-0.08862205594778061,
-0.06655808538198471,
-0.0452737957239151,
0.3782491087913513,
0.31674325466156006,
-0.6779772043228149,
-0.584984302520752,
-0.06060359627008438,
-0.04233971983194351,
0.2367236316204071,
0.633671760559082,
-0.13814714550971985,
0.8600313067436218,
0.6323750019073486,
0.9965960383415222,
0.3673678934574127,
0.15443426370620728,
0.6649029850959778,
-0.638778567314148,
0.17458325624465942,
0.36422184109687805,
0.41335824131965637,
0.4041755497455597,
-0.4454193711280823,
0.45098844170570374,
0.0763004869222641,
-0.7407102584838867,
-0.9004537463188171,
0.33377206325531006,
-1.1713237762451172,
-0.03219838812947273,
1.2860326766967773,
-0.00594949908554554,
-0.07420963793992996,
0.09387922286987305,
-0.6245042085647583,
0.16931770741939545,
-0.7678541541099548,
0.9355713725090027,
0.6556711196899414,
-0.3521491587162018,
-0.04908529296517372,
-0.30636513233184814,
0.7021813988685608,
0.60918790102005,
-0.7852927446365356,
0.18124854564666748,
0.4800667464733124,
0.11794012039899826,
0.25569120049476624,
0.7886852025985718,
0.14554646611213684,
-0.012902628630399704,
-0.13705335557460785,
0.3564499318599701,
-0.22419431805610657,
-0.09720715880393982,
-0.2610394060611725,
0.14149925112724304,
0.5002349019050598,
-0.5982826948165894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13536v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13536v1
|
Attention Mechanisms Don't Learn Additive Models: Rethinking Feature Importance for Transformers
| 2024-05-22T11:14:00 | 2024-05-22T11:14:00 |
Tobias Leemann, Alina Fastowski, Felix Pfeiffer, Gjergji Kasneci
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We address the critical challenge of applying feature attribution methods to
the transformer architecture, which dominates current applications in natural
language processing and beyond. Traditional attribution methods to explainable
AI (XAI) explicitly or implicitly rely on linear or additive surrogate models
to quantify the impact of input features on a model's output. In this work, we
formally prove an alarming incompatibility: transformers are structurally
incapable to align with popular surrogate models for feature attribution,
undermining the grounding of these conventional explanation methodologies. To
address this discrepancy, we introduce the Softmax-Linked Additive Log-Odds
Model (SLALOM), a novel surrogate model specifically designed to align with the
transformer framework. Unlike existing methods, SLALOM demonstrates the
capacity to deliver a range of faithful and insightful explanations across both
synthetic and real-world datasets. Showing that diverse explanations computed
from SLALOM outperform common surrogate explanations on different tasks, we
highlight the need for task-specific feature attributions rather than a
one-size-fits-all approach.
|
[
-0.4087511897087097,
-0.46717560291290283,
0.5059806108474731,
-0.0026870369911193848,
-0.019784102216362953,
-0.14207051694393158,
-0.02365788444876671,
-0.4078041911125183,
-0.07501039654016495,
0.19609281420707703,
-0.868692934513092,
-0.08150579780340195,
-0.6730866432189941,
-0.09627282619476318,
-0.5515082478523254,
1.461984395980835,
0.008325603790581226,
-0.4481242001056671,
-0.3885667026042938,
-0.3830765187740326,
-0.13572368025779724,
-0.36285164952278137,
-0.717576265335083,
-0.406821072101593,
0.644331693649292,
0.34883150458335876,
1.1677913665771484,
0.7780024409294128,
0.6694155335426331,
0.34936824440956116,
-0.025437673553824425,
-0.031929511576890945,
-0.44482123851776123,
-0.2287767380475998,
-0.05866026505827904,
-0.815727174282074,
-0.6364554166793823,
0.10386970639228821,
0.5225781202316284,
0.677513599395752,
0.11086401343345642,
0.35809704661369324,
0.10501226037740707,
0.3753126561641693,
-0.8262338638305664,
0.2134699672460556,
-0.8071507215499878,
-0.10169439017772675,
-0.12870271503925323,
0.0024617649614810944,
-0.2994531989097595,
-0.29621005058288574,
0.14112943410873413,
-0.6136159300804138,
1.0262442827224731,
-0.16937676072120667,
0.8106550574302673,
0.7866092324256897,
-0.16478264331817627,
-0.28951171040534973,
-0.8857247233390808,
0.812680721282959,
-0.3260331153869629,
0.23925882577896118,
0.19111455976963043,
0.18210120499134064,
0.2706287205219269,
-0.5515235066413879,
-0.5378321409225464,
-0.09611450135707855,
-0.31301116943359375,
0.13817492127418518,
-0.14583906531333923,
0.0536193884909153,
0.11880390346050262,
0.3305378258228302,
-0.4107241928577423,
0.23978258669376373,
-0.4468204379081726,
-0.17091567814350128,
0.72737056016922,
0.4128400385379791,
0.01390347070991993,
0.024083491414785385,
-0.4755678176879883,
-0.05040388181805611,
-0.6087138056755066,
0.34471774101257324,
0.261785626411438,
0.3782199025154114,
-0.295073926448822,
0.38509616255760193,
0.23959510028362274,
0.5020714998245239,
0.372871994972229,
0.23528364300727844,
0.11459682136774063,
-0.15323850512504578,
-0.02944522351026535,
0.43599674105644226,
0.7163176536560059,
0.04924126714468002,
0.2886895537376404,
-0.35892534255981445,
-0.015984442085027695,
0.41395601630210876,
0.5830129981040955,
-0.23432008922100067,
0.01462629996240139,
0.3140518069267273,
-0.2088727205991745,
-0.4371820092201233,
-0.042518626898527145,
-0.7898522019386292,
-0.2943090796470642,
0.044784996658563614,
0.4098150432109833,
0.12239335477352142,
-0.26950013637542725,
0.07515120506286621,
-0.08010032027959824,
0.37792065739631653,
0.09741151332855225,
-1.0688679218292236,
0.3407491147518158,
0.934140682220459,
0.7133727669715881,
-0.3599514663219452,
-0.46167439222335815,
-0.3363969326019287,
0.25806596875190735,
-0.23230375349521637,
0.8661292791366577,
-0.7235777378082275,
-0.0626663938164711,
0.008158978074789047,
0.009583667851984501,
-0.29895657300949097,
-0.44968196749687195,
0.732094407081604,
-0.313869833946228,
0.18006226420402527,
0.13092775642871857,
-0.2579682171344757,
-0.21902978420257568,
-0.17780250310897827,
-0.8365822434425354,
0.8794209361076355,
0.2398030310869217,
-0.6391090750694275,
0.6079163551330566,
-0.8732593655586243,
-0.6429072022438049,
-0.06209549680352211,
-0.019723184406757355,
-0.6786044836044312,
0.5818617343902588,
0.2027323842048645,
0.2651623487472534,
-0.23426972329616547,
0.6193162798881531,
-0.4526004195213318,
-0.47041839361190796,
0.3739374279975891,
-0.9466506242752075,
0.7376963496208191,
-0.284453421831131,
-0.6024090051651001,
0.2541067600250244,
-0.660460889339447,
-0.35284483432769775,
0.06852198392152786,
0.014234324917197227,
-0.008681008592247963,
0.015778828412294388,
-0.16218557953834534,
0.18078427016735077,
0.0072364057414233685,
-0.4304748475551605,
-0.09609264880418777,
-0.31907394528388977,
0.49201706051826477,
0.7200770378112793,
-0.46316811442375183,
0.545479953289032,
-0.11361084133386612,
0.6146968007087708,
0.11382484436035156,
0.3147273063659668,
-0.2672956883907318,
-0.520358681678772,
-0.8251428008079529,
-0.29850101470947266,
0.08348552882671356,
0.5128442049026489,
-0.35199692845344543,
0.012857728637754917,
-0.6799802184104919,
-0.4764314293861389,
-0.9158126711845398,
0.013150528073310852,
0.4499622583389282,
0.4868757724761963,
0.30818799138069153,
-0.2305484265089035,
-0.3470539450645447,
-1.120801329612732,
-0.5448761582374573,
-0.4352981150150299,
-0.1377081423997879,
0.265035480260849,
0.2510157823562622,
0.015765715390443802,
0.9176657795906067,
-0.47600874304771423,
-0.33748987317085266,
-0.4556919038295746,
0.20069167017936707,
0.2026139795780182,
0.3577064573764801,
0.3575208783149719,
-0.9315980672836304,
-0.20881138741970062,
-0.08031515777111053,
-0.714634895324707,
0.049515657126903534,
-0.3002479076385498,
0.34550684690475464,
-0.10299449414014816,
0.42036911845207214,
-1.1320403814315796,
0.551487386226654,
0.3946757912635803,
-0.22211796045303345,
0.24095991253852844,
0.02277350053191185,
-0.0022582344245165586,
-0.4712989926338196,
-0.07271634042263031,
0.29224875569343567,
-0.1915043443441391,
-0.8469547033309937,
0.03134234994649887,
-0.05998627468943596,
-0.2863309383392334,
-0.4485885202884674,
0.6603249907493591,
-0.19172093272209167,
0.004940618760883808,
-0.3494211733341217,
0.2611038386821747,
0.09842751920223236,
0.8452197909355164,
-0.05500923469662666,
0.6119310259819031,
0.6850026845932007,
-0.712282121181488,
0.19983042776584625,
0.3254648447036743,
0.01803659275174141,
0.449920654296875,
-0.7861117720603943,
-0.21418391168117523,
-0.2728405296802521,
0.23083937168121338,
-1.291025996208191,
-0.3370298445224762,
0.2433142066001892,
-0.7753749489784241,
0.5120722055435181,
-0.14526641368865967,
-0.08332455903291702,
-0.38418808579444885,
-0.4029053747653961,
0.6904807686805725,
0.5861425995826721,
-0.44501993060112,
0.8669671416282654,
0.28876689076423645,
-0.11065921187400818,
-0.5131469368934631,
-0.7211900353431702,
-0.042354732751846313,
-0.817427933216095,
-0.6022962927818298,
0.4362834095954895,
0.4081871807575226,
-0.09741801023483276,
0.18376584351062775,
-0.21422792971134186,
-0.13714952766895294,
0.1932964026927948,
0.28550398349761963,
0.2763296365737915,
-0.5581943988800049,
0.10281894356012344,
-0.22492265701293945,
-0.8092834949493408,
0.16592207551002502,
0.11114487797021866,
-0.08277957886457443,
0.05722765251994133,
-0.5611894726753235,
-0.541094183921814,
0.19162333011627197,
0.913252592086792,
0.006480642128735781,
0.8640227317810059,
0.8604329228401184,
-0.17412494122982025,
0.17041034996509552,
-0.571456253528595,
-0.3095844089984894,
-0.5025308132171631,
0.5659357309341431,
-0.2803490459918976,
-0.8487513661384583,
0.666738748550415,
0.14903081953525543,
0.22023777663707733,
0.8442770838737488,
0.39856043457984924,
0.08240269124507904,
1.4366284608840942,
0.9241796731948853,
-0.18579691648483276,
0.26914167404174805,
-0.007969968020915985,
0.49074608087539673,
-0.9679937362670898,
-0.06448554992675781,
-0.6089513897895813,
-0.39971497654914856,
-0.8150920271873474,
-0.1641819179058075,
0.20318050682544708,
-0.42122045159339905,
-0.25949206948280334,
0.4540312588214874,
-0.4142693877220154,
0.1903264820575714,
0.5094186067581177,
0.06232871860265732,
0.2630847096443176,
-0.07434206455945969,
0.7068687677383423,
-0.2758497893810272,
-1.099488615989685,
-0.20506207644939423,
0.9209959506988525,
0.4794194996356964,
0.8910371661186218,
-0.11501110345125198,
0.16150198876857758,
0.3501864969730377,
0.5988227128982544,
-0.7366318702697754,
0.31735703349113464,
-0.32509109377861023,
-0.8976683616638184,
-0.43429815769195557,
-0.2646769881248474,
-0.8800071477890015,
0.1910838931798935,
0.012960722669959068,
-0.8894252777099609,
0.36537694931030273,
0.46779516339302063,
-0.5826377272605896,
0.2256947159767151,
-0.9373195171356201,
1.0031404495239258,
-0.09757757186889648,
-0.6298473477363586,
-0.17827194929122925,
-0.441080778837204,
0.6002482771873474,
-0.16113661229610443,
0.31560441851615906,
-0.009766163304448128,
-0.1635638177394867,
0.5443229079246521,
-0.08190830051898956,
1.2071478366851807,
-0.02693772502243519,
-0.14101336896419525,
0.38916173577308655,
-0.14833948016166687,
0.6091707944869995,
-0.0007473764708265662,
-0.06274276226758957,
0.1844787448644638,
-0.8350766897201538,
-0.37146899104118347,
-1.0174992084503174,
0.5758958458900452,
-0.646317720413208,
-1.0237797498703003,
-0.04126531630754471,
-0.5486121773719788,
-0.08586926013231277,
-0.3485037088394165,
0.4655143618583679,
0.6081427931785583,
0.20432890951633453,
0.21754829585552216,
0.5581696033477783,
0.13203933835029602,
0.39385008811950684,
0.23767626285552979,
0.4270317554473877,
-0.07340315729379654,
1.3131630420684814,
-0.08253248035907745,
0.40196487307548523,
0.11065903306007385,
-0.0476081445813179,
-0.2627898156642914,
-0.4071851968765259,
-0.39513683319091797,
0.2692275643348694,
-0.7118660807609558,
-0.12382698804140091,
-0.7074004411697388,
-0.3395906686782837,
-0.12186171859502792,
-0.54881352186203,
-0.5894105434417725,
-0.516579270362854,
-0.23726165294647217,
-0.22684432566165924,
0.30813363194465637,
0.6801326274871826,
0.1435428261756897,
0.5266299247741699,
-0.7641533017158508,
0.5480915904045105,
0.3524899482727051,
0.4777969717979431,
0.21773529052734375,
-0.8808872103691101,
-0.49388134479522705,
-0.030450861901044846,
-0.4186882972717285,
-0.6489312052726746,
0.013924849219620228,
0.40222716331481934,
0.8019466996192932,
0.3955458700656891,
-0.08095238357782364,
0.8553004264831543,
-0.324648916721344,
0.7775951623916626,
0.04811945557594299,
-1.0274957418441772,
0.3821241557598114,
-0.03252937272191048,
0.33039402961730957,
0.387318879365921,
0.5006386041641235,
-0.09236133098602295,
-0.8018410205841064,
-1.140200138092041,
-0.9521389007568359,
1.0463621616363525,
0.4364992380142212,
0.46662843227386475,
0.21280664205551147,
0.3498454689979553,
0.19637462496757507,
0.15236778557300568,
-0.8899497985839844,
-0.34396761655807495,
-0.18812669813632965,
-0.4246680736541748,
-0.32394057512283325,
-0.18416815996170044,
0.059835802763700485,
-0.16041439771652222,
0.6685750484466553,
-0.19758173823356628,
0.21914465725421906,
0.20529891550540924,
-0.2067941278219223,
-0.30348342657089233,
-0.056887101382017136,
0.5446762442588806,
0.5246827602386475,
0.234659805893898,
0.14462320506572723,
0.3135673701763153,
-0.38765251636505127,
0.1735251545906067,
0.14458680152893066,
-0.15455453097820282,
0.19716759026050568,
0.819212794303894,
1.1046684980392456,
0.5698287487030029,
-0.2937108278274536,
0.388212114572525,
0.09088384360074997,
-0.1154523491859436,
0.12909872829914093,
0.4483802318572998,
-0.05271607264876366,
0.20256870985031128,
0.5263226628303528,
0.1983630210161209,
0.19986867904663086,
-0.390846848487854,
0.19598335027694702,
0.6203938126564026,
-1.1274492740631104,
-0.6122677326202393,
0.9214381575584412,
0.17048056423664093,
-0.4523782432079315,
0.4433954656124115,
0.2607343792915344,
-0.6631731390953064,
0.8737494349479675,
0.2394615113735199,
1.2325775623321533,
-0.43227139115333557,
0.28031912446022034,
0.28797686100006104,
0.47283434867858887,
0.06771029531955719,
-0.4935726225376129,
-0.0053674024529755116,
-0.5898287892341614,
-0.5084326267242432,
-0.24229930341243744,
-0.19462276995182037,
0.21747182309627533,
-0.46128106117248535,
0.3198508620262146,
0.0004992338945157826,
-0.2542257606983185,
0.3089248239994049,
-0.5900179147720337,
-0.7514052391052246,
0.23336772620677948,
0.07059809565544128,
0.4783717691898346,
-1.2712266445159912,
0.04761938750743866,
0.4008297622203827,
-0.24046647548675537,
-0.5268752574920654,
0.1764237880706787,
-0.06460534781217575,
-1.0055841207504272,
0.3569067716598511,
0.27949148416519165,
-0.07854744046926498,
0.06313078850507736,
-0.6207476854324341,
-0.8847476243972778,
0.6608202457427979,
0.43794316053390503,
0.05051588639616966,
-0.003679137909784913,
0.36266782879829407,
0.5292107462882996,
-0.4731985330581665,
0.44335344433784485,
0.5744526386260986,
0.5299650430679321,
0.12442515790462494,
-0.8201285600662231,
0.07789121568202972,
-0.08984096348285675,
-0.25272613763809204,
0.2573499083518982,
-0.6584908962249756,
0.5184862017631531,
-0.46076729893684387,
-0.09100469946861267,
-0.44571495056152344,
0.6934757232666016,
-0.0007613960769958794,
0.36597713828086853,
0.4180039167404175,
0.45601698756217957,
0.14195489883422852,
-0.06171166151762009,
1.156334400177002,
-0.01666424050927162,
0.4249081015586853,
1.052011251449585,
-0.09718650579452515,
0.37080857157707214,
0.40752795338630676,
-0.38001975417137146,
0.4279640018939972,
0.5061321258544922,
-0.004139409866183996,
0.4057596027851105,
-0.046286456286907196,
-0.1916240155696869,
-0.38586580753326416,
-0.1448393166065216,
-0.05420520529150963,
0.5471632480621338,
0.47073423862457275,
-0.44836464524269104,
-0.47316551208496094,
-0.06713750213384628,
-0.2069355696439743,
-0.2440621703863144,
-0.2564428448677063,
0.9371768832206726,
0.018156208097934723,
-0.8967487215995789,
0.6026908159255981,
-0.3887485861778259,
0.48056721687316895,
-0.6426308155059814,
0.04907454922795296,
-0.2948298752307892,
0.48981204628944397,
-0.34588223695755005,
-0.7983319163322449,
0.5872188210487366,
0.08370611071586609,
-0.27707552909851074,
-0.04509277269244194,
0.6380881667137146,
-0.25925126671791077,
-0.7671633958816528,
-0.01984642818570137,
0.2934255003929138,
0.08369652926921844,
-0.07518315315246582,
-0.7398526072502136,
0.0013683406868949533,
-0.029734784737229347,
-0.45924314856529236,
0.2023899406194687,
0.6189824342727661,
-0.3228730857372284,
1.0380197763442993,
0.3300356864929199,
-0.3615124821662903,
-0.017520811408758163,
-0.11020554602146149,
0.8577696084976196,
-0.46472489833831787,
-0.22028006613254547,
-1.2050485610961914,
1.1401972770690918,
0.19607952237129211,
-0.3231041133403778,
0.5228303074836731,
0.4504711627960205,
0.48930132389068604,
-0.08023039996623993,
0.7584354877471924,
0.29396089911460876,
0.05996571481227875,
-0.2275696098804474,
0.3313080370426178,
-0.6090482473373413,
0.1337529867887497,
-0.1877565234899521,
-1.1111184358596802,
-0.2906005382537842,
0.19030559062957764,
-0.1564236432313919,
0.26591894030570984,
0.5893877744674683,
0.6463990211486816,
-0.5577948093414307,
-0.002635024022310972,
0.20456700026988983,
0.23250414431095123,
0.2429695874452591,
0.5649521350860596,
0.5585645437240601,
-0.5304139256477356,
0.9516931772232056,
0.102836973965168,
-0.3911063075065613,
-0.326576292514801,
-0.8137279152870178,
-0.7477230429649353,
-0.5671189427375793,
-0.6592786312103271,
-0.06947442144155502,
0.015485160052776337,
0.2720567286014557,
0.7044346928596497,
-0.7607402801513672,
0.10908086597919464,
-0.25343626737594604,
0.45579278469085693,
-0.2896682620048523,
-0.28567227721214294,
0.4322470724582672,
-0.5192192792892456,
-0.5431548953056335,
-0.034701377153396606,
0.30820998549461365,
-0.04823620617389679,
-0.48824790120124817,
0.2366522252559662,
0.13501247763633728,
0.13801631331443787,
0.2689516544342041,
0.29420801997184753,
-0.8635210990905762,
-0.39345982670783997,
0.05506471171975136,
0.07278504967689514,
0.27141422033309937,
1.0459568500518799,
-1.005261778831482,
0.10735747963190079,
0.28743475675582886,
0.6625462770462036,
0.357243150472641,
0.07476411759853363,
0.7883676290512085,
-0.5158222913742065,
0.27030837535858154,
-0.04708795249462128,
-0.003923673648387194,
0.4838206171989441,
-0.673643171787262,
0.42086830735206604,
0.19836947321891785,
-0.29890480637550354,
-0.777374804019928,
0.3002018630504608,
-0.5818427801132202,
0.1215628981590271,
0.7656012177467346,
-0.2334088236093521,
-0.4452570676803589,
-0.43310415744781494,
0.1603192389011383,
0.26274099946022034,
-0.12976109981536865,
1.0586142539978027,
0.6935598850250244,
-0.17438842356204987,
-0.308269739151001,
-0.47869381308555603,
0.7681532502174377,
0.5554782152175903,
-0.5253961086273193,
0.5290324687957764,
0.10231204330921173,
-0.13244964182376862,
0.48850321769714355,
0.26245734095573425,
0.05888523533940315,
0.4436696171760559,
0.21133628487586975,
-0.31124669313430786,
0.049707747995853424,
-0.5327717065811157,
-0.46800461411476135,
0.2127768099308014,
-0.18320053815841675,
-0.1434631049633026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13529v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13529v1
|
The correlation between nativelike selection and prototypicality: a multilingual onomasiological case study using semantic embedding
| 2024-05-22T10:55:26 | 2024-05-22T10:55:26 |
Huasheng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In native speakers' lexical choices, a concept can be more readily expressed
by one expression over another grammatical one, a phenomenon known as
nativelike selection (NLS). In previous research, arbitrary chunks such as
collocations have been considered crucial for this phenomenon. However, this
study examines the possibility of analyzing the semantic motivation and
deducibility behind some NLSs by exploring the correlation between NLS and
prototypicality, specifically the onomasiological hypothesis of Grondelaers and
Geeraerts (2003, Towards a pragmatic model of cognitive onomasiology. In Hubert
Cuyckens, Ren\'e Dirven & John R. Taylor (eds.), Cognitive approaches to
lexical semantics, 67-92. Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton). They hypothesized that
"[a] referent is more readily named by a lexical item if it is a salient member
of the category denoted by that item". To provide a preliminary investigation
of this important but rarely explored phenomenon, a series of innovative
methods and procedures, including the use of semantic embedding and
interlingual comparisons, is designed. Specifically, potential NLSs are
efficiently discovered through an automatic exploratory analysis using topic
modeling techniques, and then confirmed by manual inspection through frame
semantics. Finally, to account for the NLS in question, cluster analysis and
behavioral profile analysis are conducted to uncover a language-specific
prototype for the Chinese verb shang 'harm', providing supporting evidence for
the correlation between NLS and prototypicality.
|
[
-0.5672763586044312,
-1.064536213874817,
0.508730947971344,
0.14469707012176514,
-0.288634330034256,
-0.0935254916548729,
-0.2592732310295105,
-0.6632477045059204,
0.8860138058662415,
0.20776180922985077,
-0.17679400742053986,
-0.4082430303096771,
-0.3468632400035858,
0.2535054385662079,
-0.3206508457660675,
0.8444979190826416,
0.1793227642774582,
-0.3222457766532898,
-0.13814185559749603,
-0.2709982991218567,
-0.4976039230823517,
-0.5517462491989136,
-0.5864177346229553,
-0.05744292959570885,
0.45646464824676514,
0.17721982300281525,
0.9182164072990417,
0.6815261244773865,
0.37659937143325806,
0.2569747567176819,
-0.27053302526474,
-0.074140265583992,
-0.0826791524887085,
0.15899533033370972,
0.04406328871846199,
-0.6658958196640015,
-0.17478202283382416,
0.166616752743721,
0.45438525080680847,
0.87880539894104,
0.07643178105354309,
-0.012926310300827026,
-0.00009186651732306927,
0.22625039517879486,
-0.6592695116996765,
-0.04170547053217888,
-0.7932529449462891,
0.3845325708389282,
-0.5449895858764648,
-0.1894916445016861,
-0.17629140615463257,
-0.48247089982032776,
0.4623292088508606,
-0.6582221388816833,
0.3197275400161743,
-0.03857703134417534,
0.8742180466651917,
-0.10374881327152252,
-0.33160507678985596,
-0.3711259365081787,
-0.47307083010673523,
0.8656477928161621,
-0.5657638311386108,
0.39788538217544556,
0.47634080052375793,
0.025093724951148033,
0.14585094153881073,
-0.48705634474754333,
-0.3688647449016571,
-0.6218016743659973,
-0.2812032997608185,
0.10756362229585648,
-0.19456709921360016,
0.1363283097743988,
0.16489176452159882,
0.5643075108528137,
-0.7270919680595398,
0.3189064860343933,
-0.2829446792602539,
-0.4286614656448364,
0.5208253264427185,
-0.06525653600692749,
0.5525334477424622,
-0.34260475635528564,
-0.42308974266052246,
0.22481821477413177,
-0.7065045833587646,
-0.0017717131413519382,
0.2721773684024811,
0.48350146412849426,
-0.06983780860900879,
0.5238813161849976,
-0.3014705777168274,
0.9841226935386658,
-0.40024545788764954,
-0.40711063146591187,
0.4321402609348297,
-0.38028672337532043,
0.22379811108112335,
0.23218446969985962,
0.5889168381690979,
0.3763851225376129,
0.283777117729187,
-0.33557602763175964,
0.057106416672468185,
0.3693118393421173,
0.021782269701361656,
-0.28847160935401917,
-0.09055372327566147,
0.14155681431293488,
-0.47904399037361145,
-0.23168200254440308,
0.36218735575675964,
-0.5710219740867615,
0.06811153143644333,
-0.13972383737564087,
0.2395004779100418,
-0.3974788188934326,
-0.43311387300491333,
0.15661875903606415,
-0.22965370118618011,
0.13440410792827606,
-0.1894555538892746,
-1.121067762374878,
0.11419015377759933,
0.6814360022544861,
0.9864140748977661,
-0.4642033278942108,
-0.4149428606033325,
-0.1424281895160675,
0.16771182417869568,
-0.4450325667858124,
0.9370625615119934,
-0.6117983460426331,
-0.5424221754074097,
0.20007260143756866,
-0.30989158153533936,
-0.07220405340194702,
-0.6403419375419617,
0.3886527717113495,
-0.31143075227737427,
0.009039418771862984,
-0.22982755303382874,
-0.27737000584602356,
-0.3050196170806885,
0.37225106358528137,
-0.6159392595291138,
0.9783570766448975,
-0.16432850062847137,
-0.5096187591552734,
0.7449144124984741,
-0.33363017439842224,
-0.4218333065509796,
-0.008471546694636345,
-0.3439827561378479,
-0.1624280959367752,
0.17932209372520447,
-0.243430957198143,
0.44445669651031494,
-0.19777028262615204,
0.22695805132389069,
-0.25346943736076355,
-0.09253890067338943,
0.16559627652168274,
-0.08316943049430847,
0.6010679006576538,
0.3004920482635498,
-0.09684639424085617,
-0.09916310012340546,
-0.5181130766868591,
-0.10381165891885757,
0.25796201825141907,
-0.08950616419315338,
-0.9696880578994751,
-0.08501032739877701,
-0.33452320098876953,
0.12565213441848755,
0.23280900716781616,
-0.7165186405181885,
0.09949276596307755,
-0.39888522028923035,
0.23936839401721954,
0.16005119681358337,
0.16135349869728088,
0.2958804965019226,
-0.45373767614364624,
0.3542982041835785,
-0.2466951161623001,
0.3264012634754181,
-0.29423555731773376,
-0.7581858038902283,
-0.6163859963417053,
-0.10093439370393753,
0.15960539877414703,
0.345862478017807,
-0.4726920425891876,
0.2695145905017853,
-0.03479873761534691,
-0.42771726846694946,
-0.5944119095802307,
0.14010415971279144,
0.4321299195289612,
0.22696100175380707,
0.24848508834838867,
-0.5506641268730164,
-0.40927577018737793,
-1.125688076019287,
-0.1364353448152542,
-0.3497537076473236,
0.11212046444416046,
0.20229403674602509,
0.0735451802611351,
0.10242444276809692,
1.1967862844467163,
-0.5778200626373291,
-0.4673510491847992,
-0.09424973279237747,
0.06301459670066833,
0.20123235881328583,
0.3396615982055664,
0.9864900708198547,
-0.8833022117614746,
-0.30997148156166077,
0.12695644795894623,
-0.6512037515640259,
-0.2465275675058365,
-0.163261279463768,
-0.12190678715705872,
-0.05633093789219856,
0.8225452899932861,
-0.34787753224372864,
0.5355973243713379,
0.35327598452568054,
-0.25747790932655334,
0.7676845192909241,
-0.19224348664283752,
-0.3789917528629303,
-0.9712743759155273,
-0.020054595544934273,
0.028356771916151047,
0.4126157760620117,
-0.6224400997161865,
0.3928252160549164,
-0.2611647844314575,
0.17564690113067627,
-0.3110705316066742,
0.33014532923698425,
-0.3869284689426422,
-0.1279635727405548,
-0.09150904417037964,
0.4377844035625458,
-0.021403538063168526,
0.2265687733888626,
0.43707165122032166,
0.33892297744750977,
0.43406882882118225,
-0.8945598602294922,
0.2693367302417755,
0.2766195833683014,
-0.26832449436187744,
0.41061148047447205,
-0.7037181258201599,
-0.20463518798351288,
-0.009089155122637749,
-0.1765633076429367,
-0.97609543800354,
0.0804576575756073,
-0.2516171932220459,
-0.33639663457870483,
-0.21933035552501678,
-0.11298827826976776,
-0.6251786947250366,
-0.08375459909439087,
-0.2544805705547333,
0.39782091975212097,
0.25691086053848267,
-0.3466035723686218,
0.12005241215229034,
0.4283923804759979,
-0.20101594924926758,
-0.02883857674896717,
-0.7422794699668884,
0.02363646775484085,
-0.43344351649284363,
-0.3222791254520416,
0.5680675506591797,
0.12443991005420685,
-0.5821384787559509,
-0.06341232359409332,
0.08597217500209808,
0.18523816764354706,
0.2979414761066437,
-0.17555595934391022,
0.41324037313461304,
-0.3549315929412842,
0.34076136350631714,
0.07055214047431946,
-0.2521909177303314,
0.08538920432329178,
-0.12788386642932892,
0.5108988881111145,
0.015992077067494392,
-0.37321823835372925,
-0.009179330430924892,
0.4971082806587219,
0.33408665657043457,
-0.4484518766403198,
0.46521955728530884,
0.5582894682884216,
-0.18184974789619446,
0.06161456182599068,
-0.6481168270111084,
-0.19642402231693268,
-0.37310531735420227,
0.37484049797058105,
-0.3763085603713989,
-0.6777859926223755,
0.5802805423736572,
0.08784196525812149,
0.16554796695709229,
0.3071230947971344,
0.24324680864810944,
0.33282631635665894,
0.6266846656799316,
0.4326591193675995,
0.10668966919183731,
0.4928051233291626,
-0.23391449451446533,
0.07375410944223404,
-0.9347347617149353,
-0.4232455790042877,
-0.467793732881546,
-0.11393198370933533,
-0.9140375256538391,
-0.29647505283355713,
0.5575503706932068,
-0.18916018307209015,
-0.005290864501148462,
0.2269269973039627,
-0.2730633616447449,
0.3071449398994446,
0.4154680669307709,
-0.2337903380393982,
0.37976354360580444,
-0.0769713968038559,
-0.6429082751274109,
-0.09364840388298035,
-0.6412190794944763,
-0.5243093967437744,
0.766954779624939,
0.15845510363578796,
0.4029847979545593,
0.5806155204772949,
0.7952433824539185,
-0.0853073000907898,
-0.03554467484354973,
-0.9582394957542419,
0.6411067247390747,
-0.23928628861904144,
-0.5483087301254272,
-0.06601501256227493,
0.041331589221954346,
-1.3822535276412964,
0.47560304403305054,
-0.5505949258804321,
-1.1842156648635864,
0.27209293842315674,
-0.045384205877780914,
-0.5818498134613037,
0.22027252614498138,
-0.5156844854354858,
0.8425202369689941,
-0.12048844993114471,
-0.1932009607553482,
-0.02407396212220192,
-0.521760106086731,
0.32849615812301636,
-0.08589521795511246,
0.29880133271217346,
-0.173921599984169,
-0.24671337008476257,
0.7087728381156921,
-0.2036845088005066,
0.8426982164382935,
0.19270934164524078,
-0.3164423704147339,
0.3483176529407501,
0.49316757917404175,
-0.11724454164505005,
0.058565184473991394,
-0.20079772174358368,
0.07537861168384552,
0.0888492688536644,
-0.2711400091648102,
-0.6272275447845459,
0.6699728965759277,
-0.5159977674484253,
-0.7959802746772766,
-0.24879303574562073,
-0.3511120080947876,
-0.36644795536994934,
0.11776139587163925,
0.37933972477912903,
0.49151989817619324,
-0.47138532996177673,
0.055885184556245804,
0.5351242423057556,
-0.15306775271892548,
0.6535597443580627,
0.44444072246551514,
-0.6806180477142334,
0.08553607761859894,
1.1175864934921265,
0.21200565993785858,
0.6295470595359802,
0.419312447309494,
0.5523759722709656,
-0.14813284575939178,
-0.5335963368415833,
-0.02936527691781521,
0.2710641622543335,
-0.45961061120033264,
0.1593722254037857,
-0.5007362961769104,
-0.05546075478196144,
-0.22875776886940002,
-0.35410189628601074,
-0.3625946640968323,
-0.349147766828537,
-0.06541528552770615,
-0.1501966416835785,
0.27628663182258606,
0.7033613324165344,
-0.15385667979717255,
0.17208541929721832,
-0.6324607729911804,
0.1986105740070343,
0.4774572551250458,
0.08971669524908066,
0.32471176981925964,
-0.3915490210056305,
0.04954904690384865,
-0.18684297800064087,
-0.18608474731445312,
-0.8859944939613342,
0.3335588276386261,
0.2830723524093628,
0.9233273863792419,
0.9918856620788574,
0.041398003697395325,
0.5686900615692139,
-0.12113817036151886,
0.8055594563484192,
-0.011631505563855171,
-0.5925114750862122,
0.7379807829856873,
-0.33581507205963135,
0.20553545653820038,
0.4866237938404083,
0.49131688475608826,
-0.8030524253845215,
-0.6391022801399231,
-0.713631272315979,
-0.8676266670227051,
0.2614838480949402,
0.03853156790137291,
0.35723021626472473,
-0.5514952540397644,
0.12347854673862457,
0.5554560422897339,
-0.1283446103334427,
-0.6024990081787109,
-0.3537207543849945,
0.0450313501060009,
0.4323497712612152,
-0.20299558341503143,
-0.18853536248207092,
0.1425541788339615,
-0.06081049516797066,
0.4333856403827667,
-0.097955122590065,
0.2726987302303314,
0.32878386974334717,
-0.09067032486200333,
0.43243828415870667,
0.18204043805599213,
0.4467221796512604,
0.28829410672187805,
-0.1317700743675232,
0.32092520594596863,
0.06568410247564316,
-0.6062991619110107,
-0.15661633014678955,
-0.06460859626531601,
-0.4829122722148895,
0.5738153457641602,
0.5445551872253418,
0.5802368521690369,
0.45157232880592346,
-0.3756004273891449,
0.277635782957077,
0.3918628990650177,
0.1901199072599411,
-0.3280148208141327,
-0.14900141954421997,
-0.15858151018619537,
-0.25212472677230835,
0.4187527298927307,
-0.13263210654258728,
0.3345051109790802,
-0.9141455292701721,
0.022590981796383858,
0.5988080501556396,
-0.32885876297950745,
-0.45490485429763794,
0.35626164078712463,
0.07759153097867966,
-0.15802150964736938,
0.5197243690490723,
-0.5473574995994568,
-0.4232535660266876,
0.649147629737854,
0.6862530708312988,
0.7128165364265442,
-0.27084335684776306,
0.45296478271484375,
0.632463812828064,
0.19925731420516968,
0.0717499852180481,
0.11080394685268402,
-0.07742935419082642,
-1.0374282598495483,
-0.2712675631046295,
-0.6359111666679382,
-0.0744195356965065,
-0.15149129927158356,
-0.9678335785865784,
0.23905357718467712,
-0.3235431909561157,
-0.3139316439628601,
0.10372557491064072,
-0.4270896911621094,
-0.3631945550441742,
0.0008900974062271416,
0.362503319978714,
0.7847633957862854,
-1.0853246450424194,
0.5961206555366516,
0.8372324109077454,
-0.394893079996109,
-0.6013732552528381,
0.25362807512283325,
0.2470061182975769,
-0.8231757283210754,
0.7546601295471191,
-0.008932680822908878,
0.25252193212509155,
-0.1282448023557663,
0.11338844150304794,
-1.0908477306365967,
0.7869971394538879,
0.13658533990383148,
-0.05503621697425842,
-0.006009913049638271,
0.18203996121883392,
0.5069817900657654,
-0.37543627619743347,
0.30875566601753235,
0.7580544352531433,
0.2585545778274536,
0.14537368714809418,
-1.228865385055542,
0.011416013352572918,
-0.16476677358150482,
0.32136714458465576,
0.29625391960144043,
-0.6662524938583374,
0.8935050368309021,
-0.5383703112602234,
-0.14036118984222412,
0.2197110652923584,
0.5075623989105225,
0.37132978439331055,
0.18791086971759796,
0.3265511393547058,
0.41655850410461426,
0.5006593465805054,
-0.08980464190244675,
1.0468045473098755,
-0.15869109332561493,
0.09575141966342926,
0.6714414954185486,
0.04208002984523773,
0.9156348705291748,
0.766399085521698,
-0.39586594700813293,
0.6426577568054199,
0.6955426335334778,
0.11903516948223114,
0.6047827005386353,
0.20605595409870148,
-0.3845316469669342,
-0.12267029285430908,
-0.6828153729438782,
-0.34373536705970764,
1.0585089921951294,
0.5349138379096985,
-0.2894991934299469,
-0.24594971537590027,
-0.013966944068670273,
0.05157158151268959,
0.06652285903692245,
-0.29843276739120483,
0.875895619392395,
0.06700826436281204,
-0.732694149017334,
0.32291877269744873,
-0.14650249481201172,
0.8645232915878296,
-0.8803163766860962,
-0.010821915231645107,
-0.1508096307516098,
-0.4183488190174103,
-0.3381582498550415,
-0.6511749029159546,
0.5187169313430786,
-0.43914198875427246,
0.29109087586402893,
0.10683511197566986,
0.47962433099746704,
-0.271848201751709,
-0.2170025110244751,
0.26564881205558777,
0.859089195728302,
0.35189276933670044,
0.22333428263664246,
-0.2960526943206787,
0.0436495803296566,
-0.09696213155984879,
0.07479207217693329,
0.4137619137763977,
0.30412158370018005,
-0.3748111426830292,
0.4035325348377228,
0.6718936562538147,
0.45885729789733887,
0.006411045324057341,
0.11209665238857269,
0.43969616293907166,
-0.5600037574768066,
-0.7648652195930481,
-0.9071705341339111,
0.24331682920455933,
0.04762386530637741,
-0.5933006405830383,
0.8121787905693054,
0.5730919241905212,
0.9724640250205994,
-0.07705187052488327,
0.6500053405761719,
-0.21580855548381805,
0.18933604657649994,
-0.6575681567192078,
0.4335852861404419,
-0.3701256513595581,
0.19950465857982635,
-0.44933021068573,
-1.0224956274032593,
-0.4291270077228546,
0.7740985155105591,
-0.43977218866348267,
-0.0850766971707344,
0.8262901902198792,
0.6341649293899536,
0.03165104240179062,
0.09395703673362732,
0.452753484249115,
0.0002749089617282152,
-0.2443273961544037,
0.32249003648757935,
0.8081006407737732,
0.0212850458920002,
0.22833247482776642,
-0.5275330543518066,
-0.2813446521759033,
-0.15286844968795776,
-0.8286651968955994,
-0.6299148201942444,
-0.8815025091171265,
-0.5362228155136108,
0.03413015604019165,
-0.16139912605285645,
1.0100799798965454,
0.3847261071205139,
-0.6710855960845947,
-0.26135966181755066,
0.15144042670726776,
0.13325443863868713,
-0.3423742651939392,
-0.24112845957279205,
0.33725568652153015,
-0.4863164722919464,
-0.6690760254859924,
0.1944049596786499,
0.162735253572464,
0.25234276056289673,
-0.30739083886146545,
0.3208886384963989,
-0.27538663148880005,
-0.2126588225364685,
0.7942977547645569,
0.44626477360725403,
-1.0474978685379028,
-0.2402927726507187,
-0.09736978262662888,
0.1255682110786438,
-0.026816699653863907,
0.8747958540916443,
-0.7865302562713623,
0.6706012487411499,
0.09299055486917496,
0.18865752220153809,
-0.07052084058523178,
-0.33607324957847595,
0.524729311466217,
-0.8740003705024719,
0.47858351469039917,
0.22136394679546356,
0.536772608757019,
0.15485118329524994,
-0.21442049741744995,
0.4184085726737976,
0.33853551745414734,
-0.03167303651571274,
-0.5627495050430298,
0.502831757068634,
-0.9243902564048767,
-0.32468998432159424,
1.4356638193130493,
-0.10817071795463562,
0.03890233859419823,
-0.4486331641674042,
-0.36354607343673706,
0.08466148376464844,
-0.1163380965590477,
0.9370697736740112,
0.5806068181991577,
-0.22506222128868103,
0.19981975853443146,
-0.7008196115493774,
0.4027341604232788,
0.5936504602432251,
-0.4429287016391754,
-0.2574527859687805,
0.12125389277935028,
0.13612525165081024,
0.7844219207763672,
0.16061735153198242,
-0.1887086182832718,
0.38363659381866455,
0.0940280556678772,
-0.052551254630088806,
0.05451546609401703,
0.20851261913776398,
-0.1337691694498062,
0.08093654364347458,
0.36284416913986206,
-0.3397456705570221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13522v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13522v2
|
Beyond Trend and Periodicity: Guiding Time Series Forecasting with Textual Cues
| 2024-05-22T10:45:50 | 2024-05-24T15:10:27 |
Zhijian Xu, Yuxuan Bian, Jianyuan Zhong, Xiangyu Wen, Qiang Xu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This work introduces a novel Text-Guided Time Series Forecasting (TGTSF)
task. By integrating textual cues, such as channel descriptions and dynamic
news, TGTSF addresses the critical limitations of traditional methods that rely
purely on historical data. To support this task, we propose TGForecaster, a
robust baseline model that fuses textual cues and time series data using
cross-attention mechanisms. We then present four meticulously curated benchmark
datasets to validate the proposed framework, ranging from simple periodic data
to complex, event-driven fluctuations. Our comprehensive evaluations
demonstrate that TGForecaster consistently achieves state-of-the-art
performance, highlighting the transformative potential of incorporating textual
information into time series forecasting. This work not only pioneers a novel
forecasting task but also establishes a new benchmark for future research,
driving advancements in multimodal data integration for time series models.
|
[
-0.09378918260335922,
-0.42831650376319885,
0.5167950987815857,
0.23473046720027924,
-0.5083065629005432,
0.331869900226593,
-0.03029242344200611,
-0.3542599380016327,
0.3419644236564636,
0.36327484250068665,
-1.047315239906311,
-0.588467001914978,
-0.5788657665252686,
-0.16856996715068817,
-0.7372438311576843,
1.227649450302124,
0.0633791834115982,
-0.1547202616930008,
-0.05197081342339516,
0.16667261719703674,
-0.5725761651992798,
-0.10625796020030975,
-0.2217402458190918,
-0.3313595950603485,
0.5559169054031372,
0.20904472470283508,
0.6814256906509399,
0.9288819432258606,
0.1940845102071762,
0.15421965718269348,
0.24829643964767456,
0.5642960071563721,
-0.5125822424888611,
0.16090676188468933,
-0.07531161606311798,
-0.14650855958461761,
-0.3618406057357788,
0.0615825355052948,
0.5151413083076477,
0.547034740447998,
-0.139169380068779,
0.36440324783325195,
-0.01722930371761322,
0.08697070926427841,
-0.1429966688156128,
0.26155877113342285,
-0.35860103368759155,
0.2959946095943451,
-0.5475902557373047,
-0.734423816204071,
-0.46789947152137756,
-0.3915576636791229,
0.37101152539253235,
-0.7688022255897522,
0.3298811912536621,
0.28412413597106934,
0.8010523319244385,
0.6867753863334656,
-0.5894010663032532,
0.13607291877269745,
-0.8420288562774658,
1.2017244100570679,
-0.39829379320144653,
0.5077774524688721,
0.3331229090690613,
0.2460215985774994,
0.23778486251831055,
-0.7941026091575623,
0.1558639109134674,
0.12057146430015564,
-0.07350137084722519,
0.038396697491407394,
-0.11457488685846329,
-0.4358268082141876,
0.11482813209295273,
0.24685363471508026,
-0.4823787808418274,
-0.2991744577884674,
0.0062833200208842754,
0.2425725758075714,
0.43110916018486023,
0.3483934998512268,
0.02498790994286537,
-0.15797166526317596,
-0.6621446013450623,
0.10703917592763901,
-0.016667796298861504,
-0.16967764496803284,
-0.08337201923131943,
0.2907218635082245,
-0.43755918741226196,
0.3182263970375061,
0.33513203263282776,
0.36851248145103455,
0.15637433528900146,
-0.05444824695587158,
0.02921583689749241,
-0.3506501019001007,
-0.2540064752101898,
0.17118552327156067,
0.5217921733856201,
0.7540404796600342,
0.3454926013946533,
-0.5286964178085327,
0.11094547808170319,
-0.04288394749164581,
0.43395188450813293,
-0.6965959668159485,
-0.2941681444644928,
0.23454982042312622,
-0.4231607913970947,
-0.7365626692771912,
-0.0476304367184639,
-1.506502389907837,
-0.5117743611335754,
-0.48084720969200134,
0.0513090044260025,
-0.3875451385974884,
-0.198868528008461,
-0.3179521858692169,
-0.42745524644851685,
-0.17512689530849457,
0.34561070799827576,
-1.1279405355453491,
0.31454703211784363,
0.746798574924469,
0.9208645820617676,
-0.28711917996406555,
-0.10693978518247604,
-0.7419267892837524,
0.4380428194999695,
-0.30988529324531555,
0.879463255405426,
-0.6584867238998413,
-0.6846581101417542,
-0.05053452402353287,
-0.1787259578704834,
0.08436127752065659,
0.043020427227020264,
0.37219688296318054,
-0.4476998448371887,
0.22872783243656158,
-0.1130390539765358,
-0.39356034994125366,
-0.11497776955366135,
0.20592842996120453,
-0.760198175907135,
1.4363853931427002,
0.06180906668305397,
-0.7794217467308044,
0.7815861701965332,
-0.39488065242767334,
-0.28622356057167053,
-0.06009601429104805,
-0.05721008777618408,
-0.26543742418289185,
-0.11425565183162689,
0.6656889319419861,
0.37060248851776123,
-0.4403364658355713,
0.8781517148017883,
-0.6686393618583679,
-0.05077693611383438,
0.08688767999410629,
-0.9388009905815125,
0.3104754686355591,
-0.03886265680193901,
-0.48318707942962646,
0.17312228679656982,
-0.6971031427383423,
0.02232735976576805,
-0.11378871649503708,
0.3691987097263336,
-0.34086722135543823,
0.3057194948196411,
0.5926331877708435,
-0.12062358856201172,
0.05708637461066246,
-0.24425359070301056,
0.3452744781970978,
0.008149576373398304,
0.5999118685722351,
0.8227066993713379,
0.13819247484207153,
0.4415864944458008,
-0.6086368560791016,
0.5060405731201172,
-0.41159185767173767,
0.25947296619415283,
-0.5640454292297363,
-0.18347083032131195,
-0.2201564460992813,
-0.14177069067955017,
0.19571685791015625,
0.6654543876647949,
-0.6888028979301453,
-0.06321363151073456,
-0.5524007678031921,
-0.7320703864097595,
0.09145919978618622,
0.004744629375636578,
0.008467148058116436,
0.48042914271354675,
0.5455306768417358,
0.2583256661891937,
-0.6173809170722961,
-0.21429049968719482,
-0.4582405984401703,
-0.06207236275076866,
-0.02665223926305771,
0.1313195377588272,
-0.026107171550393105,
-0.08920292556285858,
0.8499963879585266,
-0.6832323670387268,
-0.062048595398664474,
-0.09674191474914551,
0.6319329142570496,
0.3365073502063751,
0.05522238463163376,
0.7289301156997681,
-0.8556118011474609,
-0.1309499591588974,
0.013396496884524822,
-0.7943328022956848,
-0.2377990186214447,
-0.24162954092025757,
0.015895888209342957,
-0.12678706645965576,
0.6623287200927734,
-0.15024513006210327,
0.4272034168243408,
0.7478550672531128,
-0.7408836483955383,
0.3613044321537018,
0.12885558605194092,
0.10654886811971664,
-1.1776856184005737,
0.009141488000750542,
0.3112736940383911,
-0.33350059390068054,
-0.6258568167686462,
-0.6873114705085754,
-0.07813271135091782,
-0.21217486262321472,
-0.01768883317708969,
1.0246549844741821,
-0.1523476243019104,
0.17344225943088531,
0.02536141499876976,
-0.18549472093582153,
0.03989199548959732,
0.41855958104133606,
0.02387971244752407,
0.5892584323883057,
-0.03421884775161743,
-0.3785393536090851,
0.4244453012943268,
0.42955678701400757,
-0.2822369635105133,
0.4783889949321747,
-0.5699471831321716,
-0.24418768286705017,
-0.07694616168737411,
-0.014045906253159046,
-0.9564352631568909,
-0.2984394431114197,
0.002823521615937352,
-0.16396120190620422,
0.5385858416557312,
0.02934420481324196,
-0.09888412058353424,
-0.11246952414512634,
-0.4618781805038452,
0.5910651683807373,
0.23310904204845428,
-0.59898841381073,
0.9731261134147644,
0.015680627897381783,
-0.2927223742008209,
-0.5672042965888977,
-0.8623970150947571,
0.15162260830402374,
-0.43821069598197937,
-0.39672112464904785,
0.7498437762260437,
0.03720737621188164,
-0.2363949716091156,
-0.10668585449457169,
-0.4129764437675476,
0.030630139634013176,
0.00210956996306777,
0.240815669298172,
0.5796629190444946,
0.0051384372636675835,
0.25715547800064087,
-0.06369425356388092,
-0.16340063512325287,
0.006041862070560455,
-0.6944912672042847,
0.3632155656814575,
0.3965914249420166,
-0.07923053205013275,
-0.4533312916755676,
0.3797047734260559,
0.5263031125068665,
-0.2097383588552475,
0.2639043629169464,
0.7388909459114075,
-0.24076081812381744,
-0.25848886370658875,
-0.5362289547920227,
-0.13945196568965912,
-0.46114352345466614,
0.15164612233638763,
0.12321333587169647,
-0.6433410048484802,
0.10751032829284668,
0.11161515861749649,
0.3390885293483734,
0.3292582929134369,
0.24551810324192047,
-0.06917434930801392,
0.8350948095321655,
0.5457548499107361,
0.09621220082044601,
1.072486400604248,
-0.02793259732425213,
-0.11784759163856506,
-0.3787005841732025,
-0.42228788137435913,
-0.4078899025917053,
-0.23546913266181946,
-0.5226651430130005,
-0.3563814163208008,
0.3146520256996155,
-0.4241996705532074,
-0.44001781940460205,
0.09978679567575455,
-0.27947166562080383,
-0.013360070995986462,
0.5684436559677124,
0.18897683918476105,
0.3321797847747803,
0.06010740250349045,
0.15630541741847992,
-0.4728708267211914,
-0.5174808502197266,
-0.46353858709335327,
1.285345435142517,
0.3543088436126709,
0.9981208443641663,
-0.21543601155281067,
0.21665029227733612,
0.9166353344917297,
0.5945114493370056,
-0.6694576740264893,
0.1766849309206009,
-0.5014113187789917,
-0.43769997358322144,
-0.2842678725719452,
-0.24941793084144592,
-0.4960620105266571,
-0.013585950247943401,
-0.1979222446680069,
-0.6105442047119141,
0.3893827199935913,
0.16826783120632172,
-0.28663039207458496,
0.3177403509616852,
-0.43251484632492065,
0.967369556427002,
-0.36978277564048767,
-0.5775660872459412,
0.11304153501987457,
-0.33043646812438965,
0.042058490216732025,
-0.1107901781797409,
0.3690301775932312,
-0.3815363049507141,
-0.5416595935821533,
0.5926214456558228,
-0.28055137395858765,
0.9058745503425598,
-0.02860335260629654,
-0.15675373375415802,
-0.3956923186779022,
-0.18221521377563477,
0.47389379143714905,
0.23813112080097198,
-0.2892078757286072,
0.13708922266960144,
0.19560755789279938,
-0.43753620982170105,
-0.3031988739967346,
0.4745742976665497,
-0.6005024313926697,
-0.36026373505592346,
-0.6060884594917297,
-0.6182243824005127,
-0.6840768456459045,
0.24102048575878143,
0.17775335907936096,
1.1083791255950928,
-0.5920516848564148,
0.07698018848896027,
0.6456576585769653,
0.41888460516929626,
0.8296619057655334,
0.1294597089290619,
-0.22955980896949768,
-0.8520744442939758,
0.7966828942298889,
-0.06751170754432678,
0.12033915519714355,
0.9621381759643555,
0.10914833843708038,
-0.3751118779182434,
-0.3482312858104706,
-0.5974744558334351,
0.07346881926059723,
-0.2985515892505646,
-0.045980166643857956,
-0.4550038278102875,
0.19736029207706451,
-0.12638334929943085,
-0.19836191833019257,
-0.1462351232767105,
-0.14516699314117432,
-0.6525245904922485,
-0.12353957444429398,
0.3920154869556427,
0.6654587388038635,
0.47767895460128784,
0.38643091917037964,
-1.0776591300964355,
0.2883254587650299,
0.40216150879859924,
0.46205615997314453,
0.09947977215051651,
-0.10902121663093567,
-0.35812264680862427,
-0.14874516427516937,
-0.5002703070640564,
-0.8341169357299805,
0.7059173583984375,
0.12131740897893906,
0.3851962387561798,
0.6597897410392761,
0.05664993077516556,
0.7503552436828613,
-0.7005501389503479,
0.9752877354621887,
0.09633967280387878,
-1.0420796871185303,
0.3328556716442108,
-0.9667186737060547,
0.4952745735645294,
0.1821632832288742,
0.2536923587322235,
-0.7550249099731445,
-0.1892048716545105,
-0.38767698407173157,
-0.5343237519264221,
0.9548780918121338,
0.11703530699014664,
-0.09009940922260284,
0.11018609255552292,
-0.08281315863132477,
0.37418144941329956,
0.6067341566085815,
-0.34275439381599426,
-0.1361505091190338,
-0.7520995736122131,
-0.5244201421737671,
-0.5299447774887085,
-0.2591533958911896,
-0.17359210550785065,
0.08570580184459686,
0.38745468854904175,
-0.2768222689628601,
0.2909982204437256,
0.15238218009471893,
0.2283032089471817,
-0.2936263382434845,
0.1928107887506485,
0.5318899154663086,
0.6930075287818909,
-0.36600038409233093,
-0.2720627784729004,
0.014817402698099613,
-0.5541165471076965,
-0.035625651478767395,
0.7015838623046875,
-0.23315288126468658,
0.27879610657691956,
0.7204077839851379,
0.890837550163269,
0.7715405225753784,
-0.37180280685424805,
-0.036584921181201935,
0.013142512179911137,
-0.13635456562042236,
-0.38640084862709045,
-0.2736242711544037,
-0.19976010918617249,
0.4577524960041046,
0.9178400039672852,
0.2410680502653122,
0.11440089344978333,
-0.42164525389671326,
-0.006272897124290466,
0.11874551326036453,
-0.6047948598861694,
-0.33908480405807495,
1.2735075950622559,
0.4375051259994507,
0.1707339882850647,
0.18483613431453705,
0.429964542388916,
-0.28932297229766846,
0.6611743569374084,
0.08983913064002991,
1.0083751678466797,
-0.35921546816825867,
0.29323676228523254,
-0.08869078010320663,
0.25601378083229065,
-0.23190172016620636,
0.3320885896682739,
-0.21024656295776367,
-0.11842893809080124,
-0.506589412689209,
-0.518974244594574,
-0.4096928536891937,
-0.12074233591556549,
-0.725167989730835,
0.5071587562561035,
-0.44903138279914856,
-0.5265586972236633,
0.36552000045776367,
0.010538012720644474,
-0.33349722623825073,
0.45911407470703125,
0.21011854708194733,
1.1974751949310303,
-0.7389748692512512,
0.6838687062263489,
0.5064382553100586,
0.09405036270618439,
-0.5367853045463562,
0.43873685598373413,
0.32555994391441345,
-0.5532568097114563,
0.1676715612411499,
0.20790190994739532,
0.11579511314630508,
0.05329446494579315,
-0.3587195575237274,
-1.012715458869934,
1.3191735744476318,
0.27141842246055603,
-0.2963116765022278,
-0.5852370262145996,
-0.11798710376024246,
0.3298855423927307,
-0.4416808784008026,
0.228138729929924,
0.30723652243614197,
0.7974382638931274,
0.3095974028110504,
-0.7249581217765808,
-0.1484927386045456,
-0.4316995143890381,
0.10099030286073685,
0.8481508493423462,
-0.7691935896873474,
0.6810528635978699,
0.13408415019512177,
-0.08790338784456253,
0.28051087260246277,
0.7671630382537842,
-0.28482508659362793,
1.019399642944336,
0.35130560398101807,
0.20644459128379822,
0.6777988076210022,
-0.5027763247489929,
0.9988148808479309,
-0.046133872121572495,
0.1865454912185669,
1.0451552867889404,
-0.04601147025823593,
0.41139689087867737,
0.49143823981285095,
-0.101779043674469,
0.6876058578491211,
0.7174083590507507,
-0.4752449095249176,
0.7812103629112244,
-0.6916069388389587,
-0.0002228670782642439,
-0.5353646278381348,
-0.6035529971122742,
-0.44823402166366577,
0.2420225441455841,
0.5381960272789001,
-0.43022677302360535,
-0.3250879645347595,
0.08490937203168869,
0.06841828674077988,
0.16183146834373474,
-0.6069103479385376,
0.5610042214393616,
0.10398294776678085,
-0.6902216672897339,
0.0965106263756752,
-0.34744104743003845,
0.6603880524635315,
-0.8255555033683777,
-0.071193628013134,
-0.06127246841788292,
0.20671871304512024,
-0.1912541389465332,
-0.5863476395606995,
0.40336790680885315,
-0.04707195237278938,
-0.4227263927459717,
-0.750828206539154,
0.2646102011203766,
-0.4907592236995697,
-0.43338409066200256,
0.25980570912361145,
0.23369228839874268,
-0.6352344155311584,
0.19707565009593964,
-0.11120207607746124,
0.10203874856233597,
0.07177839428186417,
-0.1617402881383896,
-0.21510253846645355,
0.5342069268226624,
-0.2572353780269623,
0.6172052025794983,
0.4353751838207245,
-0.24705193936824799,
-0.09185454994440079,
-0.10272223502397537,
0.6575048565864563,
-1.0774236917495728,
-0.7595113515853882,
-0.7435788512229919,
0.4946284294128418,
-0.16157470643520355,
-0.2966163754463196,
0.7909495234489441,
0.3166441023349762,
0.31141653656959534,
-0.1006612777709961,
0.7688705325126648,
0.37059342861175537,
0.6996423602104187,
-0.47075048089027405,
0.23146112263202667,
-0.8495040535926819,
0.2169932872056961,
-0.313042014837265,
-0.752896249294281,
-0.16647781431674957,
-0.5082029104232788,
-0.471994012594223,
0.22877544164657593,
0.7751790285110474,
-0.043770864605903625,
-0.20333078503608704,
0.7067599892616272,
0.08122224360704422,
0.0561550073325634,
0.17421755194664001,
0.26443344354629517,
0.5007362961769104,
-0.09448602050542831,
0.9572862386703491,
-0.15261870622634888,
-0.1909707486629486,
-0.4756752848625183,
-1.2675268650054932,
-1.2590656280517578,
-0.38450509309768677,
0.019489577040076256,
-0.06694047898054123,
0.20026449859142303,
1.089690089225769,
0.6999458074569702,
-0.8515561819076538,
-0.2077295333147049,
0.0783667042851448,
-0.1251116842031479,
-0.5190606117248535,
-0.22324350476264954,
0.3785306215286255,
-0.11366714537143707,
-0.9431180953979492,
0.27661722898483276,
0.25011950731277466,
0.24463406205177307,
-0.14575140178203583,
0.3350536525249481,
0.1382707804441452,
0.10046930611133575,
0.3693324029445648,
0.0637005940079689,
-0.4182031452655792,
0.058123983442783356,
0.2561776041984558,
0.004965680185705423,
-0.2383449822664261,
0.9108347296714783,
-0.6919921040534973,
0.3271409571170807,
0.2961323857307434,
0.45261040329933167,
0.8615000247955322,
0.14978283643722534,
0.9439816474914551,
-0.8356466889381409,
0.0916866660118103,
0.20530349016189575,
0.10135425627231598,
0.2946493625640869,
-0.4796369969844818,
0.49304068088531494,
0.3743734359741211,
-0.30798444151878357,
-0.7543739676475525,
-0.09291904419660568,
-1.03665030002594,
0.030670765787363052,
0.7965483665466309,
0.24958772957324982,
-0.12162218987941742,
-0.3132117688655853,
0.009247412905097008,
0.23188045620918274,
-0.7431493997573853,
0.6643505096435547,
0.8826274871826172,
0.2143881916999817,
-0.36179468035697937,
-0.7347428202629089,
0.538508951663971,
0.17228016257286072,
-0.7511703372001648,
0.14903612434864044,
0.43858802318573,
-0.022716663777828217,
-0.1356266736984253,
-0.006432658527046442,
0.08959335833787918,
0.3497174084186554,
0.015125631354749203,
-0.5603818893432617,
-0.4918419122695923,
-0.4995526969432831,
0.034392423927783966,
0.27698978781700134,
-0.4697566330432892,
0.01630745269358158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13517v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13517v1
|
WaterPool: A Watermark Mitigating Trade-offs among Imperceptibility, Efficacy and Robustness
| 2024-05-22T10:22:20 | 2024-05-22T10:22:20 |
Baizhou Huang, Xiaojun Wan
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
With the increasing use of large language models (LLMs) in daily life,
concerns have emerged regarding their potential misuse and societal impact.
Watermarking is proposed to trace the usage of specific models by injecting
patterns into their generated texts. An ideal watermark should produce outputs
that are nearly indistinguishable from those of the original LLM
(imperceptibility), while ensuring a high detection rate (efficacy), even when
the text is partially altered (robustness). Despite many methods having been
proposed, none have simultaneously achieved all three properties, revealing an
inherent trade-off. This paper utilizes a key-centered scheme to unify existing
watermarking techniques by decomposing a watermark into two distinct modules: a
key module and a mark module. Through this decomposition, we demonstrate for
the first time that the key module significantly contributes to the trade-off
issues observed in prior methods. Specifically, this reflects the conflict
between the scale of the key sampling space during generation and the
complexity of key restoration during detection. To this end, we introduce
\textbf{WaterPool}, a simple yet effective key module that preserves a complete
key sampling space required by imperceptibility while utilizing semantics-based
search to improve the key restoration process. WaterPool can integrate with
most watermarks, acting as a plug-in. Our experiments with three well-known
watermarking techniques show that WaterPool significantly enhances their
performance, achieving near-optimal imperceptibility and markedly improving
efficacy and robustness (+12.73\% for KGW, +20.27\% for EXP, +7.27\% for ITS).
|
[
-0.3213465213775635,
-0.5320033431053162,
0.5239825248718262,
-0.31733593344688416,
-0.7372862696647644,
0.16198323667049408,
0.014324110932648182,
-0.3995077311992645,
-0.046156737953424454,
0.5403907299041748,
-0.4068959057331085,
-0.26368895173072815,
-0.6000341176986694,
-0.21131101250648499,
-0.5233493447303772,
0.5643196105957031,
0.008541123010218143,
-0.25660768151283264,
0.00011990521306870505,
-0.3761705160140991,
-0.24827633798122406,
-0.4052690267562866,
-0.7957010865211487,
-0.5186987519264221,
0.3811904788017273,
0.016567662358283997,
0.8411151170730591,
0.9945594668388367,
0.42282021045684814,
0.16562584042549133,
-0.3880496025085449,
0.04944547638297081,
-0.3473425805568695,
0.27634453773498535,
-0.36600568890571594,
-0.3002898395061493,
-0.09035145491361618,
0.06430051475763321,
0.5952638387680054,
0.34955278038978577,
0.33655866980552673,
0.14431536197662354,
0.25401735305786133,
1.0136069059371948,
-1.2507132291793823,
0.38432765007019043,
-0.8101858496665955,
0.2224930226802826,
-0.3394489586353302,
-0.41187959909439087,
-0.3231659233570099,
0.0316377729177475,
-0.05268106237053871,
-0.39228227734565735,
-0.03716004267334938,
-0.05681219324469566,
0.8535095453262329,
0.21423743665218353,
-0.13996955752372742,
-0.006171674933284521,
-0.7472562193870544,
0.7820033431053162,
-1.0094212293624878,
0.09508521854877472,
0.36468517780303955,
0.18032723665237427,
-0.21197016537189484,
-0.724907398223877,
-0.6785401105880737,
0.2030225545167923,
0.18140918016433716,
0.2983277142047882,
-0.261021226644516,
0.027930306270718575,
0.1873498111963272,
0.41951751708984375,
-0.3255700469017029,
-0.16814996302127838,
0.1346256285905838,
-0.36693817377090454,
0.5883675813674927,
0.1064668595790863,
0.46949389576911926,
0.2170458436012268,
-0.07143080979585648,
-0.1680077165365219,
-1.025054931640625,
0.3121342957019806,
0.42081117630004883,
0.5806493163108826,
0.2632661461830139,
0.3396475613117218,
-0.12442129850387573,
0.7967232465744019,
-0.3936918079853058,
-0.4312921166419983,
-0.15548795461654663,
-0.059993814677000046,
-0.0770033523440361,
0.04631173238158226,
0.4906563460826874,
0.2677537202835083,
0.28889191150665283,
-0.11903517693281174,
-0.3098428249359131,
0.060008157044649124,
0.0474308617413044,
-0.7042832374572754,
-0.18062129616737366,
0.12447446584701538,
-0.5826167464256287,
-0.3967372477054596,
0.12407759577035904,
-0.36646246910095215,
-0.46928930282592773,
-0.20249579846858978,
0.9220954775810242,
-0.19914695620536804,
-0.3606722354888916,
0.10858536511659622,
-0.3950919508934021,
0.2182517796754837,
0.18598614633083344,
-0.47940847277641296,
0.2682754099369049,
0.715519905090332,
0.9686760902404785,
-0.3346513509750366,
0.14404414594173431,
-0.38062068819999695,
0.7126753330230713,
-0.1865793615579605,
0.7937013506889343,
-0.803950309753418,
-0.2740963101387024,
0.19371972978115082,
-0.06579224020242691,
-0.04866362735629082,
-0.564932107925415,
0.3115943968296051,
-0.7487287521362305,
0.2257475107908249,
-0.02313176542520523,
-1.0143918991088867,
-0.23521873354911804,
0.09178011119365692,
-1.0876216888427734,
0.6537841558456421,
0.1447191834449768,
-0.946906328201294,
0.1942988783121109,
-0.5395381450653076,
-0.4273800849914551,
0.2818780541419983,
0.2862240672111511,
-0.7929584383964539,
-0.04529156535863876,
-0.2383667230606079,
0.29879388213157654,
-0.021304218098521233,
-0.19886188209056854,
-0.4996417462825775,
-0.6157045364379883,
0.5235537886619568,
-0.38952434062957764,
0.6427639722824097,
0.06354507058858871,
-0.553779125213623,
-0.29117459058761597,
-0.7467745542526245,
0.26925888657569885,
0.13896967470645905,
-0.5378826260566711,
-0.6017038226127625,
0.10167323052883148,
0.027421141043305397,
0.12468995898962021,
0.2279944270849228,
-0.4313105046749115,
-0.2466483861207962,
-0.18793316185474396,
0.8194655776023865,
0.8396840691566467,
0.2660502791404724,
0.4206901788711548,
-0.5272022485733032,
0.5557023882865906,
-0.14271260797977448,
0.38969194889068604,
-0.20742815732955933,
-0.6041089296340942,
-0.5822902917861938,
-0.8831875920295715,
0.32451143860816956,
0.3708968758583069,
-0.6644046306610107,
0.35940229892730713,
-0.12470253556966782,
-0.43149274587631226,
-0.2914115786552429,
0.24890927970409393,
0.4292606711387634,
0.483860582113266,
0.39057737588882446,
-0.4245380759239197,
-0.035855814814567566,
-0.9233342409133911,
-0.7106871604919434,
-0.2598315477371216,
0.17208050191402435,
0.24343495070934296,
0.27911141514778137,
0.1053534671664238,
1.127176284790039,
-0.4377010464668274,
-0.43476301431655884,
-0.35701632499694824,
-0.4326021075248718,
0.26784610748291016,
0.4140779972076416,
0.2579183876514435,
-0.9695271253585815,
-0.5846282839775085,
-0.34664714336395264,
-0.12408111989498138,
-0.2591310739517212,
0.05599159002304077,
-0.1562078297138214,
0.3469325602054596,
0.4116241931915283,
-0.6960158944129944,
0.7051091194152832,
0.5735964775085449,
-0.31246551871299744,
0.261372447013855,
-0.1826062798500061,
-0.04810936003923416,
-0.8175478577613831,
0.24103406071662903,
-0.4419320523738861,
-0.2407381683588028,
-0.6347911953926086,
0.26467981934547424,
0.3773873746395111,
-0.020657537505030632,
-0.27431443333625793,
0.6643211841583252,
-0.2976307272911072,
0.26664412021636963,
-0.583012044429779,
-0.08709880709648132,
0.23677809536457062,
0.2729370594024658,
-0.0466180145740509,
0.5787798762321472,
0.30525264143943787,
-0.45460808277130127,
0.021694127470254898,
-0.09847280383110046,
-0.13900025188922882,
0.4036390483379364,
-0.5822833776473999,
0.12900134921073914,
-0.20425866544246674,
-0.0034342599101364613,
-1.4003140926361084,
0.2276517152786255,
0.18729117512702942,
-0.12757767736911774,
0.5564573407173157,
-0.3680613338947296,
-0.5468485951423645,
-0.04205453395843506,
-0.673687219619751,
0.2836936414241791,
0.5838056802749634,
-0.3624263405799866,
0.5358754992485046,
0.40005922317504883,
-0.17721101641654968,
-0.4804926812648773,
-0.6382336020469666,
0.09875111281871796,
-0.38185688853263855,
-0.3684687316417694,
0.5149070024490356,
-0.009953165426850319,
-0.08623059093952179,
0.19477355480194092,
-0.2972269058227539,
-0.3249453902244568,
0.28283464908599854,
0.34455591440200806,
0.3096061646938324,
0.14558394253253937,
-0.009197685867547989,
0.13348393142223358,
-0.5530027747154236,
-0.23399432003498077,
-0.28052183985710144,
0.41822370886802673,
0.4194713830947876,
-0.5138741135597229,
-0.40177422761917114,
0.224285289645195,
0.8237212300300598,
-0.2183620184659958,
0.7550669312477112,
0.04652642831206322,
-0.5423793196678162,
-0.22910378873348236,
-0.43822309374809265,
-0.1262986660003662,
-0.5084230303764343,
-0.032531727105379105,
-0.07499119639396667,
-1.0213747024536133,
0.6418280601501465,
-0.005412362050265074,
0.10886374115943909,
0.24717411398887634,
0.37520262598991394,
-0.0012756759533658624,
0.6498789191246033,
0.3846176266670227,
-0.4019061028957367,
0.7718316912651062,
-0.2341897040605545,
0.7405471205711365,
-0.7965981960296631,
0.08330340683460236,
-0.4309483766555786,
-0.26207172870635986,
-0.36436033248901367,
-0.08116073161363602,
0.25192806124687195,
0.04241307079792023,
-0.0736997127532959,
0.6060960292816162,
-0.4785814583301544,
0.536836564540863,
0.48901689052581787,
0.18977560102939606,
0.5153709650039673,
0.11536899209022522,
-0.17770841717720032,
-0.2727104723453522,
-0.6868097186088562,
-0.6369982957839966,
1.1271735429763794,
-0.015537651255726814,
0.42098385095596313,
0.10638908296823502,
0.6603555679321289,
0.4715817868709564,
0.3811763525009155,
-0.5149667859077454,
0.45649254322052,
0.07576934248209,
-0.9006692171096802,
-0.47606703639030457,
-0.3268939256668091,
-1.0631742477416992,
0.5249485969543457,
-0.2161433845758438,
-0.5636069774627686,
-0.20989550650119781,
0.152883380651474,
-0.28034481406211853,
0.4869154989719391,
-0.5467159152030945,
0.6781694889068604,
0.2612457573413849,
-0.8415032625198364,
-0.25693321228027344,
-0.38716983795166016,
0.08660918474197388,
-0.371815025806427,
0.6497634649276733,
-0.28206393122673035,
-0.22924338281154633,
0.45011577010154724,
-0.6096423864364624,
0.3965877592563629,
-0.45133528113365173,
-0.18872080743312836,
0.20139797031879425,
0.28160732984542847,
0.5451919436454773,
-0.10392406582832336,
0.09781899303197861,
-0.2321680635213852,
-0.014416526071727276,
-0.4009288549423218,
-0.4804578721523285,
0.5630147457122803,
-0.5003112554550171,
-0.4838380515575409,
-0.23430350422859192,
-0.46597787737846375,
-0.23444634675979614,
0.3906099200248718,
0.12657763063907623,
0.4583747386932373,
0.17800989747047424,
-0.06383148580789566,
0.7899889945983887,
-0.4035317897796631,
1.012447714805603,
0.6125518679618835,
0.20637167990207672,
-0.49541956186294556,
0.9161295890808105,
0.4016569256782532,
0.3772051930427551,
0.5687081217765808,
0.23002749681472778,
-0.3636893630027771,
-0.6808786988258362,
0.009071447886526585,
0.17697349190711975,
-0.7128447890281677,
-0.47585487365722656,
-0.4090326726436615,
-0.33835339546203613,
-0.08441102504730225,
-0.2190014123916626,
-0.3809429407119751,
-0.6818962097167969,
-0.07859836518764496,
0.013851052150130272,
0.31225472688674927,
0.3056274950504303,
-0.23326922953128815,
0.18873967230319977,
-0.7539985179901123,
0.20132224261760712,
0.6547743082046509,
0.43382659554481506,
0.17360064387321472,
-0.7282834649085999,
-0.08567599952220917,
-0.056481800973415375,
-0.2913917899131775,
-0.6479727625846863,
0.3555929958820343,
0.4813368618488312,
0.6676549315452576,
0.599669873714447,
0.20934802293777466,
0.4952305555343628,
-0.44520410895347595,
0.5578824281692505,
0.12176429480314255,
-1.2102972269058228,
0.4401928186416626,
-0.039351947605609894,
0.3017246425151825,
0.4842030704021454,
0.01987520605325699,
-0.44631800055503845,
-0.7094602584838867,
-0.7295131087303162,
-1.3456106185913086,
0.24928362667560577,
0.5198819637298584,
0.28446027636528015,
0.36337268352508545,
0.43085286021232605,
-0.011656586080789566,
0.17173036932945251,
-0.6612955331802368,
-0.20217090845108032,
-0.031557630747556686,
-0.2010553777217865,
0.1364458203315735,
-0.39705783128738403,
0.012081781402230263,
-0.20635922253131866,
0.9226194024085999,
0.02434770204126835,
0.14426420629024506,
0.08372978866100311,
-0.26093918085098267,
0.07058676332235336,
0.18468846380710602,
0.36219292879104614,
0.4760044515132904,
-0.041291214525699615,
0.5135922431945801,
-0.2625812888145447,
-0.6096288561820984,
0.4386623799800873,
-0.12612344324588776,
-0.5106828808784485,
0.1030600443482399,
0.904536783695221,
0.26912379264831543,
0.1870850920677185,
-0.6244708895683289,
0.5983728170394897,
0.025578806176781654,
0.1310591995716095,
-0.0754743292927742,
0.3641562759876251,
0.35055121779441833,
0.11889493465423584,
0.5943829417228699,
-0.20817722380161285,
0.17935234308242798,
-0.3284860849380493,
0.15324461460113525,
0.7177848219871521,
-0.3102889657020569,
-0.13622333109378815,
0.5529226660728455,
-0.1501884013414383,
-0.25249069929122925,
0.1881020963191986,
0.13086608052253723,
-0.611842691898346,
0.4329192638397217,
0.415910005569458,
0.9335371851921082,
-0.13924811780452728,
-0.027946358546614647,
0.2516809105873108,
0.27711284160614014,
-0.040534816682338715,
0.3049238622188568,
-0.2500057518482208,
-0.9748396873474121,
-0.24065403640270233,
-0.3668983280658722,
-0.48947855830192566,
0.16018222272396088,
-0.6809571385383606,
-0.15287795662879944,
-0.5251030325889587,
-0.34172773361206055,
0.011370777152478695,
0.09370506554841995,
-0.3325885534286499,
-0.05891672149300575,
0.12295340746641159,
0.9249686598777771,
-0.8351040482521057,
0.7200441956520081,
0.5597383379936218,
-0.04623161628842354,
-0.6312494277954102,
-0.053680676966905594,
-0.048816222697496414,
-0.9107763171195984,
0.13675713539123535,
0.3311110734939575,
-0.06651183217763901,
0.044092219322919846,
-0.7379277944564819,
-0.9393248558044434,
1.1457825899124146,
0.556003212928772,
-0.42690226435661316,
0.7112553119659424,
0.44343456625938416,
0.3816072940826416,
-0.15137511491775513,
-0.2161274403333664,
0.5215446352958679,
0.6335116028785706,
-0.2141834944486618,
-0.6541479825973511,
0.45251643657684326,
-0.3867875337600708,
0.3754200339317322,
0.07842671126127243,
-0.5941717028617859,
0.4100022315979004,
0.20768648386001587,
-0.32943540811538696,
0.20054449141025543,
-0.060326509177684784,
0.43665677309036255,
0.021819470450282097,
0.6053777933120728,
0.6516302227973938,
0.5387676358222961,
-0.14608833193778992,
0.9756487607955933,
-0.6127959489822388,
0.4551510512828827,
0.7275565266609192,
-0.45859816670417786,
0.8211236000061035,
0.9514272212982178,
-0.333076149225235,
0.2899687588214874,
0.34071630239486694,
0.23945628106594086,
1.056537389755249,
0.40074676275253296,
-0.6244052648544312,
-0.46821433305740356,
-0.19863097369670868,
-0.26023486256599426,
0.07271674275398254,
0.15438257157802582,
-0.4009847640991211,
-0.23751676082611084,
-0.30015403032302856,
0.1923820674419403,
-0.08602806180715561,
-0.24615398049354553,
0.6703686714172363,
0.1972275823354721,
-0.2892967462539673,
0.09417670965194702,
-0.06587826460599899,
0.5523679852485657,
-0.6464974284172058,
-0.05874035879969597,
-0.4169224202632904,
0.5612202286720276,
-0.13350464403629303,
-0.6121705174446106,
0.07115035504102707,
-0.2943434715270996,
-0.09502092003822327,
-0.3886990249156952,
1.1443880796432495,
-0.5164180994033813,
-0.0830732211470604,
0.38828936219215393,
0.2237367331981659,
-0.11720829457044601,
-0.3941505253314972,
-0.6260533332824707,
0.288215309381485,
-0.1387893110513687,
-0.4101560413837433,
0.34427890181541443,
0.2601027488708496,
0.22226743400096893,
0.8375027775764465,
0.7173821330070496,
0.1964140385389328,
-0.04744500294327736,
-0.01637452282011509,
0.7975419163703918,
-0.41596874594688416,
-0.381689190864563,
-1.156384825706482,
0.502467155456543,
-0.1847982108592987,
0.04957040771842003,
0.7695636749267578,
0.5910854935646057,
0.6134020686149597,
-0.15775494277477264,
1.1083132028579712,
0.2276546210050583,
0.2558211088180542,
-0.40357285737991333,
0.9819045662879944,
-0.4319934844970703,
0.03286716341972351,
-0.6849732398986816,
-1.0832425355911255,
-0.6288884878158569,
0.7269510626792908,
0.17112374305725098,
-0.19465599954128265,
0.5296304821968079,
0.8817973136901855,
0.09608134627342224,
-0.0705796629190445,
0.4408203959465027,
-0.301877498626709,
0.5038848519325256,
0.6737244725227356,
0.89076828956604,
-0.4563046097755432,
0.45632845163345337,
-0.1974366009235382,
-0.3598049581050873,
-0.13726641237735748,
-1.0341843366622925,
-0.7310118079185486,
-0.514535129070282,
-0.7496660947799683,
-0.38173848390579224,
0.11239936202764511,
0.45882874727249146,
0.622969925403595,
-0.920579731464386,
0.06466937065124512,
-0.08929849416017532,
0.3147255480289459,
-0.29314807057380676,
-0.2358202487230301,
0.46356984972953796,
-0.0577545166015625,
-0.22444619238376617,
-0.04820093885064125,
0.7552157640457153,
0.505685567855835,
-0.15501625835895538,
-0.1279475837945938,
0.13783259689807892,
0.3890884518623352,
0.39836055040359497,
0.20643626153469086,
-0.20484058558940887,
-0.4495006203651428,
-0.20103111863136292,
-0.11933901160955429,
-0.2096664011478424,
0.9136296510696411,
-0.4828616976737976,
0.4177201986312866,
0.5325416326522827,
0.5917957425117493,
0.5705357193946838,
-0.5252530574798584,
0.29959985613822937,
-0.40047693252563477,
0.26517564058303833,
0.00006865681643830612,
0.6069127321243286,
0.48558810353279114,
-0.12691998481750488,
0.5781204104423523,
0.6288741230964661,
-0.05753247067332268,
-0.8975635170936584,
0.14877259731292725,
-0.7139625549316406,
-0.4932863116264343,
1.1192944049835205,
-0.5981982350349426,
-0.14794334769248962,
-0.2851714491844177,
-0.06089406460523605,
0.2131137102842331,
-0.06711816787719727,
1.064409852027893,
1.0362831354141235,
0.1682693511247635,
-0.07054135948419571,
-0.20857444405555725,
0.45479097962379456,
0.3310231864452362,
-0.5080614686012268,
0.04240220785140991,
0.11008106917142868,
0.5504661202430725,
0.029868770390748978,
0.5419095158576965,
-0.4055667221546173,
0.06012139096856117,
-0.2656633257865906,
-0.00932239554822445,
-0.15802384912967682,
0.1110389307141304,
-0.26188501715660095,
0.4191816449165344,
0.10865689814090729,
-0.19515271484851837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13516v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13516v2
|
LIRE: listwise reward enhancement for preference alignment
| 2024-05-22T10:21:50 | 2024-06-04T08:21:05 |
Mingye Zhu, Yi Liu, Lei Zhang, Junbo Guo, Zhendong Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recently, tremendous strides have been made to align the generation of Large
Language Models (LLMs) with human values to mitigate toxic or unhelpful
content. Leveraging Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) proves
effective and is widely adopted by researchers. However, implementing RLHF is
complex, and its sensitivity to hyperparameters renders achieving stable
performance and scalability challenging. Furthermore, prevailing approaches to
preference alignment primarily concentrate on pairwise comparisons, with
limited exploration into multi-response scenarios, thereby overlooking the
potential richness within the candidate pool. For the above reasons, we propose
a new approach: Listwise Reward Enhancement for Preference Alignment (LIRE), a
gradient-based reward optimization approach that incorporates the offline
rewards of multiple responses into a streamlined listwise framework, thus
eliminating the need for online sampling during training. LIRE is
straightforward to implement, requiring minimal parameter tuning, and
seamlessly aligns with the pairwise paradigm while naturally extending to
multi-response scenarios. Moreover, we introduce a self-enhancement algorithm
aimed at iteratively refining the reward during training. Our experiments
demonstrate that LIRE consistently outperforms existing methods across several
benchmarks on dialogue and summarization tasks, with good transferability to
out-of-distribution data, assessed using proxy reward models and human
annotators.
|
[
-0.40639519691467285,
-0.15257877111434937,
0.14039558172225952,
0.0578150674700737,
0.050189342349767685,
0.16823911666870117,
-0.46404093503952026,
-0.383566677570343,
0.5356807112693787,
0.6053292751312256,
-0.6815134286880493,
0.07686591148376465,
-0.48675891757011414,
-0.2268572300672531,
-0.02000449411571026,
1.378176212310791,
0.1513376384973526,
-0.1522592157125473,
-0.10873237252235413,
-0.5472118854522705,
-0.3229420483112335,
-0.5026772022247314,
-0.6051430702209473,
-0.4990346133708954,
0.9303068518638611,
0.6627350449562073,
0.396189421415329,
0.5333986282348633,
0.43729716539382935,
0.18713822960853577,
0.21517068147659302,
0.5477108955383301,
-0.7125667333602905,
0.24318072199821472,
-0.20287303626537323,
-0.022900234907865524,
-0.5703835487365723,
-0.09738732874393463,
0.4833148419857025,
0.2988375127315521,
-0.4067206084728241,
0.14824558794498444,
0.36162683367729187,
1.1542527675628662,
-0.9204679727554321,
-0.049269478768110275,
-0.403053343296051,
-0.2950320839881897,
0.11396347731351852,
-0.36621662974357605,
-0.28522780537605286,
-0.45888230204582214,
0.20808570086956024,
-0.5329220294952393,
-0.3080158233642578,
0.08763555437326431,
0.8652735352516174,
0.4490286111831665,
-0.15587571263313293,
-0.01527037750929594,
-0.5211881995201111,
0.8263651132583618,
-0.6604142785072327,
0.37662002444267273,
0.2917361855506897,
0.14253853261470795,
-0.007214507553726435,
-0.2765055000782013,
-0.22060756385326385,
-0.023219969123601913,
0.01190178282558918,
0.29398980736732483,
0.19004206359386444,
0.1454165279865265,
0.05598300322890282,
0.4053915739059448,
-0.5872783064842224,
0.2904321253299713,
0.11171071976423264,
-0.2198501080274582,
0.6885225176811218,
-0.035547465085983276,
-0.04429017752408981,
0.04241614416241646,
-0.449471652507782,
-0.5534090995788574,
-0.4021678566932678,
0.6305464506149292,
0.45552858710289,
0.47429904341697693,
-0.07585535943508148,
0.389363557100296,
-0.1966789960861206,
0.8417133688926697,
0.2695772349834442,
-0.29339611530303955,
0.21145495772361755,
-0.270073801279068,
0.018837042152881622,
0.24953916668891907,
0.8028420209884644,
0.7575234770774841,
0.09041285514831543,
0.010807614773511887,
-0.366956889629364,
-0.01031997986137867,
0.026952730491757393,
-0.8076149821281433,
-0.12723295390605927,
0.3411089777946472,
-0.4136255383491516,
-0.5107084512710571,
-0.010542637668550014,
-0.8211955428123474,
-0.8449764251708984,
-0.15536659955978394,
0.2947377860546112,
0.015729451552033424,
-0.27643129229545593,
0.19791142642498016,
-0.08180178701877594,
0.03190607950091362,
0.252714067697525,
-1.4024041891098022,
0.278606653213501,
0.59853196144104,
0.5236896872520447,
-0.4669259786605835,
-0.282717227935791,
-1.0922887325286865,
0.13712136447429657,
0.06175801530480385,
0.9347013235092163,
-0.424092561006546,
-0.21503984928131104,
-0.0322866216301918,
-0.24412596225738525,
-0.01279982179403305,
-0.4784826934337616,
0.6538917422294617,
-0.29485493898391724,
0.40621140599250793,
-0.25976327061653137,
-0.5928637385368347,
0.06663452088832855,
0.350262850522995,
-0.7744154930114746,
1.235211730003357,
0.34275421500205994,
-0.9385095238685608,
0.4612925350666046,
-0.6732836961746216,
-0.15189971029758453,
-0.12833856046199799,
-0.31746605038642883,
-0.4434605538845062,
-0.2878934442996979,
0.3870173990726471,
0.17903867363929749,
-0.23703046143054962,
0.2642621099948883,
-0.2830929756164551,
-0.41086065769195557,
0.3713953197002411,
-0.14317266643047333,
0.18763276934623718,
0.010063487105071545,
-0.5448283553123474,
0.7822575569152832,
-0.5169041156768799,
0.09351293742656708,
-0.07844594866037369,
-0.3423590064048767,
-0.37850967049598694,
0.009777725674211979,
0.006970101501792669,
0.3495086431503296,
0.2819436490535736,
-0.431614488363266,
0.4256013333797455,
-0.7712180614471436,
0.19480659067630768,
0.9866539239883423,
-0.04906710609793663,
0.8545825481414795,
-0.7076606750488281,
0.39998680353164673,
-0.3098520338535309,
0.3061598241329193,
0.1708206981420517,
-0.23005910217761993,
-0.6627353429794312,
-0.445311039686203,
0.30794140696525574,
0.5418672561645508,
-0.30915677547454834,
0.7184240221977234,
-0.39923903346061707,
-0.2269579917192459,
-0.7254028916358948,
0.35949915647506714,
0.29395443201065063,
0.5654605031013489,
0.4457581341266632,
-0.3055013120174408,
-0.5989758968353271,
-0.9369162917137146,
-0.286659300327301,
-0.27213627099990845,
0.18582125008106232,
0.49719002842903137,
-0.0033155293203890324,
-0.1285504698753357,
0.9154981374740601,
-0.3565041124820709,
-0.3687300980091095,
-0.49612781405448914,
0.07711043953895569,
0.3382742404937744,
0.35163414478302,
0.16007813811302185,
-0.4851427674293518,
-0.3434588611125946,
-0.06831824034452438,
-0.27341219782829285,
-0.10019924491643906,
-0.1968814879655838,
-0.205276757478714,
0.2399384081363678,
0.07644081860780716,
0.04740505293011665,
0.22634924948215485,
0.6259555220603943,
-0.08186845481395721,
0.19077882170677185,
-0.22023850679397583,
0.276606023311615,
-0.8723816275596619,
0.0870823934674263,
-0.08935879915952682,
-0.41376248002052307,
-0.32666072249412537,
-0.3583254814147949,
0.12969306111335754,
0.28731805086135864,
-0.27042829990386963,
0.8823195695877075,
-0.12404440343379974,
-0.0826454758644104,
-0.47753599286079407,
0.1515960693359375,
0.026042390614748,
0.6580771803855896,
0.31775474548339844,
0.668110191822052,
0.04087744280695915,
-0.5781344175338745,
0.27291935682296753,
0.24904954433441162,
-0.25173768401145935,
0.46620652079582214,
-0.3290651738643646,
0.11473321169614792,
-0.07267219573259354,
0.3748829960823059,
-0.8102928400039673,
-0.09549824148416519,
0.4395696222782135,
-0.2523399591445923,
0.06300618499517441,
-0.0811772271990776,
0.007027928251773119,
0.014342251233756542,
-0.7974845767021179,
0.37689104676246643,
0.4415852129459381,
-0.8236531615257263,
0.486665815114975,
0.4077340364456177,
-0.09236255288124084,
-1.101506233215332,
-0.26227909326553345,
-0.2531561851501465,
-0.47511905431747437,
-0.2948635220527649,
0.3838445544242859,
-0.41506311297416687,
-0.2132776826620102,
-0.44258081912994385,
-0.1398879438638687,
0.3729749619960785,
0.10193207114934921,
0.1716042309999466,
0.4462532699108124,
0.17429031431674957,
0.08672402054071426,
-0.15766052901744843,
-0.22190363705158234,
-0.3072505593299866,
-0.42002934217453003,
0.5479203462600708,
-0.18423403799533844,
-0.03344263136386871,
-0.20185524225234985,
0.1493898332118988,
0.14404594898223877,
-0.4039822518825531,
0.4251433312892914,
0.5429134964942932,
-0.019993195310235023,
-0.25936833024024963,
-0.6998041868209839,
-0.5382570624351501,
-0.46441274881362915,
0.170603409409523,
-0.05142270028591156,
-1.0308111906051636,
0.20119254291057587,
0.029981622472405434,
0.2305532693862915,
0.014146794565021992,
0.47576892375946045,
-0.15050312876701355,
1.0318673849105835,
0.5153752565383911,
-0.45379117131233215,
0.8186086416244507,
-0.14606843888759613,
0.1416119635105133,
-0.8230008482933044,
-0.09111760556697845,
-0.3328435719013214,
-0.5264884829521179,
-0.566660463809967,
-0.08814388513565063,
0.29243728518486023,
0.16147583723068237,
-0.4292100667953491,
0.12651453912258148,
-0.673944890499115,
0.352043479681015,
0.4568190276622772,
0.2387361079454422,
0.23791761696338654,
0.10359802842140198,
0.042883746325969696,
-0.21185649931430817,
-0.7819690704345703,
-0.22562003135681152,
0.9366511106491089,
0.24140900373458862,
0.9323272705078125,
0.10895156860351562,
0.9770155549049377,
0.3317561745643616,
0.3600720167160034,
-0.8439458012580872,
0.27034780383110046,
-0.0011307403910905123,
-0.16794538497924805,
-0.6016737222671509,
-0.35728833079338074,
-0.8907368779182434,
0.10969968885183334,
-0.3708331286907196,
-1.011946201324463,
0.3730231523513794,
0.3567064106464386,
-0.6274315118789673,
0.17504671216011047,
-0.24307622015476227,
0.814659059047699,
-0.6999057531356812,
-0.8643355965614319,
-0.12891729176044464,
-0.7439970374107361,
0.21676190197467804,
0.13467736542224884,
0.4450477957725525,
-0.15880846977233887,
-0.022867120802402496,
0.8229541778564453,
-0.27540329098701477,
0.5846020579338074,
-0.04846636950969696,
-0.2573837637901306,
-0.2381218671798706,
0.07149667292833328,
0.6752552390098572,
0.19061335921287537,
-0.10876189917325974,
-0.37582993507385254,
0.022914426401257515,
-0.34837108850479126,
-0.8459405899047852,
0.7831238508224487,
-0.7698165774345398,
-0.44826292991638184,
-0.4982477128505707,
-0.6942716836929321,
-0.4056549072265625,
0.05337103456258774,
0.1950269192457199,
0.36523690819740295,
-0.04736043140292168,
-0.24284915626049042,
0.7204453349113464,
-0.12768006324768066,
0.5223230719566345,
0.34282591938972473,
-0.5348817110061646,
-0.7183263301849365,
1.2260533571243286,
-0.3680140972137451,
0.36169713735580444,
0.6192110776901245,
0.4672147333621979,
-0.6760345101356506,
-0.16324123740196228,
-0.4873480498790741,
0.2805885076522827,
-0.6332066059112549,
-0.014034410007297993,
-0.3928930461406708,
-0.005818777717649937,
-0.27120909094810486,
-0.27906516194343567,
-0.3923870921134949,
-0.5758039951324463,
0.004524736199527979,
0.018224461004137993,
0.31388261914253235,
0.5360347032546997,
-0.2596244215965271,
0.16197603940963745,
-0.7708800435066223,
0.07820959389209747,
0.38060662150382996,
0.34548214077949524,
-0.09378008544445038,
-0.6287274360656738,
-0.2918202579021454,
-0.039682433009147644,
-0.05738458409905434,
-0.5760940909385681,
0.39592233300209045,
0.09638497233390808,
0.5317407250404358,
0.49397552013397217,
0.19704927504062653,
0.6741780042648315,
-0.07126807421445847,
0.5088815689086914,
0.4435724914073944,
-0.6450720429420471,
0.5309392213821411,
-0.24157387018203735,
0.007067225407809019,
0.9263054132461548,
0.2039870321750641,
-0.6083289384841919,
0.007829364389181137,
-0.5604203343391418,
-0.9056068658828735,
0.6053354144096375,
-0.1963660717010498,
-0.2687085270881653,
0.2733743190765381,
0.20798134803771973,
0.23601919412612915,
0.13372841477394104,
-0.8374428749084473,
-0.28454867005348206,
-0.40491166710853577,
-0.25685915350914,
-0.3202432096004486,
-0.12002190202474594,
-0.3885461091995239,
-0.19122178852558136,
0.7896881103515625,
-0.38593336939811707,
0.021535199135541916,
0.2005978524684906,
-0.12178760766983032,
-0.08460955321788788,
0.5689990520477295,
0.6664706468582153,
0.3902696669101715,
-0.5732463598251343,
0.055553603917360306,
-0.03520350903272629,
0.13670757412910461,
0.3164106011390686,
0.041372150182724,
0.03915340080857277,
-0.4640338122844696,
0.021901125088334084,
1.0053850412368774,
0.3242524266242981,
-0.8119629621505737,
0.72418612241745,
-0.2954670190811157,
-0.10298305749893188,
-0.1456916332244873,
0.20381206274032593,
-0.05058901757001877,
0.20168130099773407,
0.04446176812052727,
-0.038532763719558716,
0.21044610440731049,
-0.3270229697227478,
0.1790062040090561,
0.4176598787307739,
-0.7089240550994873,
0.1209600493311882,
0.4474036693572998,
0.20252573490142822,
-0.300674706697464,
0.3617016077041626,
-0.16227328777313232,
-0.4371439218521118,
0.16866885125637054,
0.34985649585723877,
0.6456258893013,
-0.11893978714942932,
0.32277223467826843,
0.5642978549003601,
0.03549351915717125,
-0.2858870327472687,
0.2927997410297394,
-0.2664673626422882,
-0.9809393286705017,
-0.32353389263153076,
-0.37685510516166687,
-0.48404446244239807,
0.10599663108587265,
-0.728263258934021,
0.23424898087978363,
-0.3610595166683197,
-0.07054132223129272,
-0.14761219918727875,
-0.190752774477005,
-0.20199595391750336,
-0.035874225199222565,
0.20066146552562714,
0.5073190331459045,
-0.5735999941825867,
0.8308365345001221,
0.588741660118103,
-0.648068904876709,
-0.942214846611023,
-0.08285573124885559,
-0.013672824017703533,
-0.7882543802261353,
0.6497801542282104,
0.13674668967723846,
-0.43840065598487854,
0.15183930099010468,
-0.06358794122934341,
-0.6818752288818359,
0.9021385312080383,
0.23375655710697174,
-0.7310904264450073,
-0.03750809654593468,
0.011293799616396427,
0.20120330154895782,
-0.40683555603027344,
0.6957141757011414,
0.6111581921577454,
0.5747765898704529,
-0.12989498674869537,
-0.9565368294715881,
-0.06842923164367676,
-0.17777234315872192,
-0.17626971006393433,
0.30202627182006836,
-0.7579817175865173,
0.25496402382850647,
-0.10035177320241928,
0.17652355134487152,
0.018097667023539543,
0.42209964990615845,
0.4778822362422943,
-0.06036235764622688,
0.8271912336349487,
0.39743301272392273,
0.8986203670501709,
0.11587703227996826,
0.9708707332611084,
-0.43341881036758423,
0.19381208717823029,
1.3610492944717407,
-0.530782163143158,
0.8347295522689819,
0.5954247117042542,
0.0644819512963295,
0.5876357555389404,
0.8610185384750366,
0.2592101991176605,
0.704975962638855,
0.18836751580238342,
-0.2846604585647583,
-0.46562817692756653,
-0.5653250217437744,
-0.24204568564891815,
0.2962765693664551,
0.11149749904870987,
-0.06533317267894745,
0.002584171947091818,
-0.07533172518014908,
-0.22956402599811554,
0.24949753284454346,
-0.32250094413757324,
0.9738799333572388,
-0.10163753479719162,
-1.039366364479065,
0.7615196704864502,
-0.15728750824928284,
0.9671491980552673,
-0.6425326466560364,
-0.04036987945437431,
-0.3273431360721588,
0.3608245253562927,
-0.5137718915939331,
-0.5732431411743164,
-0.2805042266845703,
-0.3779238760471344,
-0.18120765686035156,
-0.427949994802475,
0.7386751174926758,
-0.6244863867759705,
-0.016246087849140167,
0.6023768186569214,
0.5324317216873169,
-0.16740551590919495,
0.05888984724879265,
-0.8332861065864563,
0.013027172535657883,
0.2084183394908905,
-0.09049618244171143,
0.6179535984992981,
-0.3826825022697449,
-0.2168773114681244,
0.6595190763473511,
0.5889164209365845,
0.22465021908283234,
-0.3581859767436981,
0.5615975856781006,
0.7489696741104126,
-0.5008975863456726,
-0.760242760181427,
-0.7757440209388733,
0.554060161113739,
-0.2737232446670532,
-0.2046552151441574,
0.4287846088409424,
0.7432388067245483,
0.6993545889854431,
0.21509407460689545,
0.8443728089332581,
0.29936811327934265,
0.6836156845092773,
-0.40168964862823486,
0.3530511260032654,
-0.5771465301513672,
0.4233378469944,
-0.35454753041267395,
-0.9094088077545166,
-0.12427633255720139,
0.6446377635002136,
-0.2300012856721878,
-0.0529150664806366,
0.7255192995071411,
0.9531715512275696,
0.08328243345022202,
-0.16359028220176697,
0.16684649884700775,
-0.38994258642196655,
0.21030555665493011,
0.6872943043708801,
1.1415433883666992,
-0.040255796164274216,
0.44144299626350403,
-0.2940099537372589,
-0.4127168655395508,
-0.21466666460037231,
-0.9579188227653503,
-0.7292511463165283,
-0.5257968306541443,
-0.19366367161273956,
-0.6378661394119263,
0.2531616985797882,
1.4303568601608276,
0.681260347366333,
-0.8705929517745972,
-0.7427563071250916,
0.1861160695552826,
0.1622513085603714,
-0.48944568634033203,
-0.16709637641906738,
0.3328763544559479,
-0.280396044254303,
-0.4740718901157379,
0.5848410725593567,
0.4979487657546997,
-0.19080331921577454,
-0.15359166264533997,
-0.6559087634086609,
-0.31046542525291443,
-0.05664386227726936,
0.24586142599582672,
0.5105963945388794,
-0.6478221416473389,
-0.3715539276599884,
0.15261998772621155,
-0.1803915798664093,
0.4130196273326874,
0.9987098574638367,
-0.7755681872367859,
0.4373423159122467,
0.5229043960571289,
0.9856175184249878,
0.5900173187255859,
0.21129511296749115,
0.6303313970565796,
-0.5479547381401062,
0.03409751132130623,
0.17482644319534302,
0.4100175201892853,
0.3292384743690491,
-0.4426717460155487,
0.5207793712615967,
-0.010847633704543114,
-0.7615253329277039,
-0.7039353251457214,
0.3409098982810974,
-1.1819895505905151,
-0.0883760079741478,
1.0929259061813354,
0.16414839029312134,
0.0191902257502079,
-0.03273800015449524,
-0.41148877143859863,
0.17927126586437225,
-0.7983536124229431,
0.7602141499519348,
0.4662632346153259,
-0.5958876609802246,
-0.36884865164756775,
-0.19912855327129364,
0.8134045600891113,
0.8907113671302795,
-0.8309517502784729,
0.2187568098306656,
0.4732806384563446,
0.15832841396331787,
-0.24828645586967468,
0.8584777116775513,
0.11513561010360718,
0.2949230968952179,
-0.828959047794342,
0.4268025755882263,
0.0408303327858448,
-0.10221937298774719,
-0.5996024012565613,
-0.08308310061693192,
0.6078779101371765,
0.0486520417034626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13514v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13514v1
|
Joint Optimization of Streaming and Non-Streaming Automatic Speech Recognition with Multi-Decoder and Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-05-22T10:17:30 | 2024-05-22T10:17:30 |
Muhammad Shakeel, Yui Sudo, Yifan Peng, Shinji Watanabe
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
End-to-end (E2E) automatic speech recognition (ASR) can operate in two modes:
streaming and non-streaming, each with its pros and cons. Streaming ASR
processes the speech frames in real-time as it is being received, while
non-streaming ASR waits for the entire speech utterance; thus, professionals
may have to operate in either mode to satisfy their application. In this work,
we present joint optimization of streaming and non-streaming ASR based on
multi-decoder and knowledge distillation. Primarily, we study 1) the encoder
integration of these ASR modules, followed by 2) separate decoders to make the
switching mode flexible, and enhancing performance by 3) incorporating
similarity-preserving knowledge distillation between the two modular encoders
and decoders. Evaluation results show 2.6%-5.3% relative character error rate
reductions (CERR) on CSJ for streaming ASR, and 8.3%-9.7% relative CERRs for
non-streaming ASR within a single model compared to multiple standalone
modules.
|
[
-0.5494672060012817,
-0.4387560188770294,
0.2368830442428589,
-0.215284526348114,
-0.5750560760498047,
0.2097446322441101,
-0.47073400020599365,
-0.48268669843673706,
0.16791459918022156,
0.1926404982805252,
-0.3672015070915222,
0.07574345916509628,
-0.8781436085700989,
0.3234362304210663,
-0.4277895390987396,
0.6284792423248291,
-0.21362920105457306,
0.151723250746727,
-0.35348910093307495,
-0.35181403160095215,
-0.3075285255908966,
-0.445934534072876,
-0.8977283239364624,
-0.44547298550605774,
0.12483952194452286,
0.07389561831951141,
0.1121620312333107,
0.6896968483924866,
0.22027111053466797,
0.3748176395893097,
-0.10339087247848511,
0.4121549427509308,
-0.3073031008243561,
0.40964412689208984,
0.12020725756883621,
-0.3049886226654053,
-0.15419168770313263,
-0.42209434509277344,
0.5654144287109375,
0.20704101026058197,
-0.18996267020702362,
0.3204203248023987,
0.28231745958328247,
0.898292064666748,
-0.9332142472267151,
0.4280748963356018,
-0.4541711211204529,
-0.025995410978794098,
-0.16797198355197906,
-0.3123573958873749,
-0.17067784070968628,
-0.19793975353240967,
0.2479463815689087,
-0.5197259187698364,
0.0258178673684597,
-0.21100880205631256,
0.6093702912330627,
0.7713745832443237,
-0.27364322543144226,
-0.2864980101585388,
-0.9942227602005005,
0.6754603385925293,
-0.589872419834137,
0.7147558331489563,
0.372991144657135,
0.6537366509437561,
0.270638644695282,
-0.5295032262802124,
-0.7695866823196411,
0.18062299489974976,
0.08891119807958603,
0.41174018383026123,
-0.4579072594642639,
0.13921913504600525,
0.21931728720664978,
0.17888791859149933,
-0.5698556900024414,
-0.07924000173807144,
-0.384509801864624,
-0.3684861361980438,
0.683369517326355,
-0.18551306426525116,
-0.06356050074100494,
0.3849920332431793,
-0.1964401751756668,
-0.14787860214710236,
-0.21549853682518005,
0.25218579173088074,
0.3011109232902527,
0.1903361827135086,
0.027071265503764153,
0.3318873345851898,
-0.2965123951435089,
0.6878066062927246,
0.21083390712738037,
-0.49058789014816284,
0.4226572811603546,
-0.20813797414302826,
-0.08758814632892609,
0.3713124096393585,
0.6337246298789978,
0.21882866322994232,
0.15471649169921875,
-0.22379741072654724,
-0.42153313755989075,
0.2953663170337677,
0.05377282574772835,
-0.4811546504497528,
-0.2329345941543579,
0.3213414251804352,
-0.483851820230484,
0.13610029220581055,
-0.07241548597812653,
-0.6148307919502258,
0.055992357432842255,
-0.800913393497467,
0.8323456048965454,
-0.37833917140960693,
-0.42963922023773193,
0.028926007449626923,
-0.48359617590904236,
0.12772607803344727,
0.2995665669441223,
-0.8490995764732361,
0.6375772356987,
0.32958388328552246,
0.8889109492301941,
0.029185527935624123,
0.07513035833835602,
-0.744813859462738,
0.4735194444656372,
0.2120385766029358,
0.7773324251174927,
-0.34958335757255554,
-0.3548387885093689,
-0.3795180320739746,
-0.3216639757156372,
-0.41782423853874207,
-0.5707219839096069,
0.45030930638313293,
-0.6017512083053589,
-0.23824991285800934,
-0.12475590407848358,
-0.76214998960495,
-0.5469111800193787,
-0.09683720767498016,
-0.7871904969215393,
0.6716846823692322,
-0.40263620018959045,
-0.5740764737129211,
0.37358763813972473,
-0.7949141263961792,
-0.5634667873382568,
-0.0051710293628275394,
-0.08325153589248657,
-0.5216007232666016,
0.046269096434116364,
0.2543332874774933,
0.06614851951599121,
-0.3292546272277832,
0.09080375730991364,
0.10398557782173157,
-0.1879059374332428,
0.042499881237745285,
-0.6821150183677673,
0.39748358726501465,
0.4373592436313629,
-0.5151703357696533,
0.024196820333600044,
-0.7198843955993652,
0.031525030732154846,
-0.2318768948316574,
-0.6526547074317932,
-0.12228208780288696,
0.555923342704773,
0.23309721052646637,
0.17816221714019775,
0.3085722327232361,
-0.6234455704689026,
-0.3337772786617279,
-0.10195570439100266,
0.7342844009399414,
0.31078702211380005,
-0.07823630422353745,
0.26650726795196533,
-0.37302106618881226,
0.18378576636314392,
0.2278880476951599,
0.25315937399864197,
0.23712120950222015,
-0.46340498328208923,
-0.8769680261611938,
-0.32828783988952637,
0.26035499572753906,
0.7452985048294067,
-0.8641048073768616,
0.603880763053894,
-0.08633589744567871,
-0.3047926127910614,
-0.7983100414276123,
0.05393948778510094,
0.624137282371521,
0.44131794571876526,
0.7351740598678589,
-0.08047699183225632,
-0.5630009770393372,
-0.7365683913230896,
-0.3089483678340912,
-0.11691654473543167,
0.05214100703597069,
0.005468193907290697,
0.1382567137479782,
0.03771375119686127,
0.9679783582687378,
-0.2981190085411072,
-0.43209272623062134,
-0.4014728367328644,
0.06536416709423065,
0.13648740947246552,
0.23245178163051605,
0.31443163752555847,
-0.880388617515564,
-0.7787201404571533,
0.05956102907657623,
-0.47442352771759033,
-0.022029822692275047,
0.08481979370117188,
0.32421523332595825,
0.5570110082626343,
0.41795873641967773,
-0.12136708945035934,
0.47939079999923706,
0.5809881687164307,
0.22249844670295715,
0.2218039482831955,
-0.3121219277381897,
0.0965350940823555,
-0.895448625087738,
-0.026960890740156174,
-0.07095497101545334,
-0.1884690821170807,
-0.8463830947875977,
-0.2821151614189148,
0.08291330188512802,
0.05693589150905609,
-0.27984580397605896,
0.06705650687217712,
-0.7940149307250977,
0.07118367403745651,
-0.3605334758758545,
-0.00824733916670084,
0.014682505279779434,
0.4484616219997406,
0.278412789106369,
0.740961492061615,
0.9338293075561523,
-0.6519944071769714,
0.5355616807937622,
0.11150524765253067,
-0.1499989777803421,
0.12890969216823578,
-0.4705325961112976,
0.29858270287513733,
-0.3462238013744354,
0.1157969981431961,
-0.8566152453422546,
0.13405299186706543,
-0.10885406285524368,
-0.4639056622982025,
0.7456840872764587,
-0.36575737595558167,
-0.4021538496017456,
-0.19195330142974854,
-0.24050618708133698,
0.28304457664489746,
0.7213500738143921,
-0.5001588463783264,
0.596351146697998,
0.628645122051239,
0.14961697161197662,
-0.33992451429367065,
-0.6370460987091064,
-0.08198405802249908,
-0.3229665458202362,
-0.5523707270622253,
0.316096693277359,
0.12447217106819153,
-0.025366777554154396,
-0.04937676712870598,
-0.3287605047225952,
-0.10366746038198471,
-0.41452524065971375,
-0.04881645366549492,
0.016978468745946884,
-0.1280214637517929,
-0.24466173350811005,
0.4536645710468292,
-0.42663171887397766,
-0.22572417557239532,
-0.5350661873817444,
0.31436407566070557,
0.17477527260780334,
-0.4288232624530792,
-0.8460817337036133,
0.6090187430381775,
0.4009857177734375,
-0.27463430166244507,
0.6500965356826782,
0.699242353439331,
-0.36567017436027527,
-0.1103300005197525,
-0.8765972852706909,
-0.19472311437129974,
-0.5311632752418518,
0.11854933202266693,
-0.4675208330154419,
-0.8350719213485718,
0.447169691324234,
-0.002535319421440363,
-0.022504564374685287,
0.3102762699127197,
0.39852291345596313,
-0.06047684699296951,
0.7197758555412292,
0.23656035959720612,
-0.11810522526502609,
0.4571879506111145,
-0.3018246293067932,
0.3406963050365448,
-0.9456855058670044,
-0.3665807545185089,
-0.29933634400367737,
-0.5163235664367676,
-0.40396353602409363,
-0.491142600774765,
0.8234154582023621,
0.1756904274225235,
0.2540299594402313,
0.4628748893737793,
-0.5620959401130676,
0.49933403730392456,
0.6447730660438538,
0.0012009600177407265,
0.3569696545600891,
0.09952425211668015,
0.035691820085048676,
0.0006473501562140882,
-0.6700154542922974,
-0.334225058555603,
1.1305190324783325,
0.08748047053813934,
0.6051462292671204,
0.2021401971578598,
0.7900441884994507,
0.06679941713809967,
-0.7333502173423767,
-0.8068686127662659,
0.3809182345867157,
-0.5463104248046875,
-0.34682130813598633,
-0.5330221056938171,
-0.40491577982902527,
-0.5188112258911133,
0.2564815282821655,
-0.03446962684392929,
-0.442772775888443,
0.3178710639476776,
0.4198545515537262,
-0.30758383870124817,
0.3559947907924652,
-0.8348533511161804,
0.2974674105644226,
-0.077670156955719,
-0.1369224637746811,
-0.37064042687416077,
-1.0352391004562378,
-0.15103784203529358,
-0.09175483882427216,
0.05533406510949135,
0.07701238989830017,
0.046004168689250946,
0.6120817065238953,
-0.30600449442863464,
0.368353009223938,
-0.5567236542701721,
0.3814507722854614,
0.5597279071807861,
-0.33487170934677124,
0.40776950120925903,
-0.0681019201874733,
-0.11472297459840775,
0.32508111000061035,
0.32368993759155273,
0.02767968736588955,
-0.5324227213859558,
0.2843584418296814,
-1.0479000806808472,
-0.30731356143951416,
-0.3200007379055023,
-0.05618830397725105,
-0.18735799193382263,
-0.020778758451342583,
0.46335119009017944,
0.7479794025421143,
0.058530036360025406,
0.10894785821437836,
0.8379480242729187,
0.03920505568385124,
0.8791204690933228,
0.4068189859390259,
0.3339473307132721,
-0.46869397163391113,
1.0874286890029907,
0.3933981955051422,
0.5729334950447083,
0.7794501185417175,
0.10472936183214188,
-0.8485405445098877,
-0.9193271398544312,
-0.6287067532539368,
-0.08232548087835312,
-0.4706752300262451,
-0.28833627700805664,
-0.8481288552284241,
-0.5889101624488831,
-0.5771540403366089,
0.12490048259496689,
-0.4108096659183502,
-0.46579334139823914,
-0.5736100077629089,
0.2535814046859741,
0.6205447316169739,
0.32560765743255615,
-0.3902927041053772,
0.05988040566444397,
-0.8715642690658569,
0.5130046606063843,
0.4228276312351227,
0.12469596415758133,
-0.0006583734066225588,
-0.5873112082481384,
-0.27305975556373596,
0.128617063164711,
-0.21831990778446198,
-0.7340847253799438,
0.4242713749408722,
0.9248604774475098,
0.7087888121604919,
0.6629483103752136,
0.3299955129623413,
0.8536635041236877,
-0.65497225522995,
0.2588207423686981,
0.25634777545928955,
-0.8813133239746094,
0.4899427890777588,
-0.040380317717790604,
0.2438630759716034,
0.8333372473716736,
0.15906347334384918,
-0.4120403826236725,
-0.22998479008674622,
0.15389437973499298,
-0.9195995330810547,
0.8839583396911621,
0.3491435647010803,
-0.2469702512025833,
0.3387337625026703,
0.10116880387067795,
0.15289470553398132,
0.1847550868988037,
-0.18253761529922485,
-0.34671247005462646,
-0.4989783465862274,
-0.0239858441054821,
-0.008011945523321629,
-0.04135794937610626,
-0.08145071566104889,
-0.5823833346366882,
0.6444926857948303,
-0.021174494177103043,
0.45689353346824646,
0.09475629776716232,
-0.24803344905376434,
-0.11824105679988861,
0.2099858671426773,
0.4303010106086731,
0.2319013476371765,
-0.1434776782989502,
-0.03678513690829277,
0.2682477831840515,
-0.5893595814704895,
0.15456674993038177,
0.10592427104711533,
-0.014032192528247833,
0.13524992763996124,
0.12156259268522263,
1.2237120866775513,
-0.09900931268930435,
-0.44226881861686707,
0.3520299196243286,
0.011445204727351665,
-0.37084922194480896,
-0.5874349474906921,
0.25248104333877563,
0.24159614741802216,
0.4271060526371002,
0.40639805793762207,
0.342712938785553,
0.5882161855697632,
-0.25872620940208435,
0.0779782235622406,
0.2502898871898651,
0.05574074387550354,
-0.3378547132015228,
0.6930330991744995,
0.3342829644680023,
-0.21066914498806,
0.49633586406707764,
-0.37892040610313416,
-0.49887320399284363,
0.4368972182273865,
0.5533732771873474,
1.1318707466125488,
-0.3653937876224518,
-0.13022559881210327,
0.4677482843399048,
-0.12348926812410355,
-0.054723210632801056,
0.3884890675544739,
-0.47161781787872314,
-0.6894153952598572,
-0.2532183825969696,
-0.9647594094276428,
-0.320026695728302,
-0.2482503056526184,
-0.9462207555770874,
0.6135610938072205,
-0.06730920821428299,
-0.16433818638324738,
0.03323085233569145,
-0.0845516175031662,
-0.3341091275215149,
0.049705397337675095,
0.30411168932914734,
0.5059990882873535,
-0.5565115809440613,
1.239398717880249,
0.5158885717391968,
-0.13400958478450775,
-0.7753133773803711,
0.03167502209544182,
0.4341907799243927,
-0.5209361910820007,
0.20640352368354797,
0.09863021969795227,
-0.569438099861145,
0.2075861692428589,
0.25497472286224365,
-0.9715756773948669,
1.3801687955856323,
0.16029465198516846,
-1.092810869216919,
-0.04597080871462822,
0.10301269590854645,
0.4574032723903656,
-0.06221882626414299,
0.23414459824562073,
0.5878812074661255,
0.5174105167388916,
0.5950683951377869,
-1.4504116773605347,
-0.3561825156211853,
-0.3728358745574951,
0.08501803129911423,
0.4912242889404297,
-0.783205509185791,
0.5863749384880066,
-0.009280409663915634,
-0.3451633155345917,
-0.5095760226249695,
0.3668527901172638,
0.12907522916793823,
0.43028655648231506,
0.6380650401115417,
0.5213436484336853,
0.1816328912973404,
-0.020495278760790825,
0.3303939402103424,
-0.2262018918991089,
0.17467093467712402,
0.845085620880127,
-0.27038443088531494,
1.057893991470337,
0.6102709770202637,
-0.38918712735176086,
0.09076693654060364,
0.32755380868911743,
0.0688006579875946,
1.0963308811187744,
-0.02223491482436657,
-0.6877956986427307,
-0.0636310875415802,
0.3118669092655182,
-0.41224533319473267,
0.6045582294464111,
0.4120766222476959,
-0.013110199943184853,
-0.19320112466812134,
0.08843106776475906,
-0.07593268156051636,
-0.10549280792474747,
-0.2092374563217163,
1.3921390771865845,
0.08665912598371506,
-0.473746657371521,
0.6265958547592163,
-0.0031986767426133156,
0.9225477576255798,
-0.6606531739234924,
0.2099049836397171,
0.08939137309789658,
0.1651534140110016,
-0.31811487674713135,
-0.26547643542289734,
0.9067351222038269,
0.047499243170022964,
-0.3658979535102844,
-0.2269175797700882,
0.6599214673042297,
-0.6058903932571411,
-0.23338273167610168,
0.6185936331748962,
0.3201776444911957,
0.25783175230026245,
-0.1594030112028122,
-0.45428889989852905,
0.13282041251659393,
-0.02341599203646183,
-0.0002468563034199178,
0.4749017655849457,
0.17808221280574799,
0.16626183688640594,
0.41499069333076477,
0.7471638917922974,
0.23241637647151947,
0.41127777099609375,
0.2626660168170929,
1.0095051527023315,
-0.12287408113479614,
-0.6330392360687256,
-0.9354318976402283,
0.34517374634742737,
0.09217748790979385,
0.021140502765774727,
0.311251163482666,
0.7311160564422607,
0.7417675852775574,
0.009343968704342842,
0.8277860879898071,
-0.25955453515052795,
0.5583757758140564,
-0.6170793771743774,
1.0075726509094238,
-0.5248042941093445,
0.024414993822574615,
-0.2407020479440689,
-0.8861787915229797,
-0.10023541748523712,
0.6718860268592834,
0.010979559272527695,
-0.05229866877198219,
0.5670673847198486,
0.5877886414527893,
-0.06852591037750244,
0.29102998971939087,
0.4489739239215851,
-0.27496394515037537,
0.15419721603393555,
0.7922242283821106,
0.5384585857391357,
-0.4646294414997101,
0.5380329489707947,
-0.15848897397518158,
-0.34842362999916077,
-0.08504702895879745,
-0.5631064176559448,
-0.7215619683265686,
-0.9483281970024109,
-0.5234553813934326,
0.2452230304479599,
0.3151409924030304,
0.97463059425354,
0.6206272840499878,
-0.9292004704475403,
-0.47684603929519653,
0.10464752465486526,
-0.40062564611434937,
-0.40609195828437805,
-0.14068613946437836,
0.17290686070919037,
-0.2536371648311615,
-0.738849937915802,
0.6247602105140686,
0.5641083121299744,
-0.06356047838926315,
0.04553678631782532,
-0.26811179518699646,
-0.27988332509994507,
0.12089858949184418,
0.5923303961753845,
0.1602180004119873,
-0.6521080136299133,
-0.15626387298107147,
-0.22330418229103088,
0.4763367176055908,
0.08016569167375565,
0.6391839385032654,
-0.6902543306350708,
0.7859103679656982,
0.7193215489387512,
0.5009677410125732,
0.9376190304756165,
0.01742083765566349,
0.4077341854572296,
-0.5370510816574097,
0.04981967434287071,
0.35312220454216003,
0.2275831252336502,
0.1684534102678299,
-0.1753884255886078,
0.053767234086990356,
0.24542789161205292,
-0.7326202988624573,
-0.5629193782806396,
0.16042497754096985,
-1.0471315383911133,
0.04300187900662422,
1.0144286155700684,
-0.2067296802997589,
0.1846524327993393,
-0.6098044514656067,
0.10622963309288025,
0.7764866948127747,
-0.7250787019729614,
0.5680861473083496,
0.5399190187454224,
-0.7767834663391113,
-0.3061946630477905,
-0.5782803297042847,
0.5967154502868652,
0.050425343215465546,
-0.5891159772872925,
-0.21173767745494843,
0.4167766869068146,
0.4155861735343933,
0.0054006860591471195,
0.5374938249588013,
-0.1203538104891777,
0.019305642694234848,
0.06846518069505692,
-0.13787229359149933,
-0.47936245799064636,
-0.4496821165084839,
-0.39912739396095276,
-0.13213112950325012,
-0.20018257200717926,
-0.6763386726379395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13511v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13511v2
|
Latent Space Alignment for Semantic Channel Equalization
| 2024-05-22T10:12:32 | 2024-06-04T10:13:13 |
Tomás Hüttebräucker, Mohamed Sana, Emilio Calvanese Strinati
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT
|
We relax the constraint of a shared language between agents in a semantic and
goal-oriented communication system to explore the effect of language mismatch
in distributed task solving. We propose a mathematical framework, which
provides a modelling and a measure of the semantic distortion introduced in the
communication when agents use distinct languages. We then propose a new
approach to semantic channel equalization with proven effectiveness through
numerical evaluations.
|
[
-0.3927016258239746,
-0.7872247099876404,
0.5234417915344238,
0.5946269035339355,
0.01971389912068844,
0.10577170550823212,
-0.011984552256762981,
-0.36537957191467285,
0.5119699239730835,
0.4836404025554657,
-0.89700847864151,
-0.23854020237922668,
-0.9296156764030457,
-0.27696022391319275,
0.02397235855460167,
0.6495644450187683,
-0.2972150444984436,
0.34776046872138977,
-0.24670006334781647,
-0.3420364260673523,
-1.0375709533691406,
-0.16795653104782104,
-0.2012844979763031,
-0.39920443296432495,
0.18595294654369354,
0.363025426864624,
1.2463115453720093,
0.23816993832588196,
0.9191668033599854,
0.4101569354534149,
0.04235555976629257,
0.12019399553537369,
-0.6524032950401306,
0.11227022111415863,
-0.3903038799762726,
-0.18326008319854736,
-0.6483871936798096,
-0.12714090943336487,
0.8699728846549988,
1.2124053239822388,
-0.11685507744550705,
-0.3023604452610016,
-0.1857416182756424,
0.5278674364089966,
-0.6206737756729126,
-0.19107386469841003,
-0.5723438858985901,
-0.04509526118636131,
0.19786804914474487,
-0.3665025234222412,
0.10968354344367981,
-0.09721526503562927,
0.4311913251876831,
-1.2077974081039429,
0.10501928627490997,
-0.2631394565105438,
1.011412501335144,
0.872122049331665,
-0.2086496502161026,
-0.3201066255569458,
-1.0072486400604248,
0.9164779782295227,
-0.6179899573326111,
0.6213856935501099,
0.07769647240638733,
0.2503576874732971,
-0.4636598825454712,
-0.2867988049983978,
-0.7529457807540894,
0.21098293364048004,
-0.09796921163797379,
0.29754218459129333,
-0.1776595413684845,
0.1727825403213501,
0.00428781658411026,
-0.02509433589875698,
-0.6736834645271301,
-0.11752358078956604,
-0.3492269515991211,
-0.28962942957878113,
0.5811517238616943,
0.06781046092510223,
0.5743170380592346,
0.13600851595401764,
-0.4608910381793976,
0.05592804774641991,
-0.4999943971633911,
-0.3720618784427643,
0.5004248023033142,
0.34772515296936035,
0.0411682166159153,
0.6537854075431824,
-0.13376721739768982,
0.7604348063468933,
0.049560949206352234,
0.11944030225276947,
0.28843042254447937,
-0.3286016285419464,
-0.19167141616344452,
0.2576914429664612,
0.41186264157295227,
0.5734328627586365,
-0.10564647614955902,
-0.3193104565143585,
-0.13247932493686676,
0.6289651393890381,
0.3712989091873169,
-0.3580908179283142,
0.3865843415260315,
0.11050603538751602,
-0.21709777414798737,
0.17501066625118256,
0.07971195876598358,
-0.0843413770198822,
0.06822519749403,
-0.5555257797241211,
0.5640692710876465,
-0.24142807722091675,
-0.26517942547798157,
0.49722012877464294,
-0.2960762679576874,
0.2400650680065155,
0.41534334421157837,
-0.8109390735626221,
0.7158316969871521,
0.8675312995910645,
0.48059597611427307,
-0.16861630976200104,
-0.5266109704971313,
-0.07140947878360748,
0.29105013608932495,
-0.3667927384376526,
0.5555744767189026,
-0.41153889894485474,
-0.21350108087062836,
-0.33948421478271484,
0.13100630044937134,
-0.1653064638376236,
-0.3208211064338684,
0.36308372020721436,
-0.9119951128959656,
0.3018082082271576,
-0.06867324560880661,
-0.7648396492004395,
0.15924566984176636,
0.03813115134835243,
-0.5338104963302612,
0.5612877011299133,
0.32050177454948425,
-0.4619608521461487,
0.33267542719841003,
-0.4412922263145447,
0.18583716452121735,
0.06849893927574158,
-0.29111552238464355,
-0.39884617924690247,
0.06363441050052643,
-0.06918727606534958,
0.03579743951559067,
0.06261888891458511,
0.6598221659660339,
-0.2291397750377655,
-0.32977792620658875,
0.41849684715270996,
-0.2721913456916809,
0.5248298645019531,
0.436855286359787,
-0.36275339126586914,
0.2537349760532379,
-0.46313995122909546,
0.29529526829719543,
-0.16080041229724884,
-0.01349873561412096,
-0.49934282898902893,
0.15333989262580872,
-0.013575405813753605,
0.3747445046901703,
0.5125930905342102,
-0.8121466040611267,
0.1984466314315796,
-0.8681479096412659,
0.080248162150383,
0.5090173482894897,
-0.22565430402755737,
0.7874694466590881,
-0.05310062691569328,
0.27735787630081177,
-0.013501693494617939,
0.06819339841604233,
0.6536280512809753,
-0.3031541109085083,
-0.6503205895423889,
0.1515883058309555,
0.04986012727022171,
0.5591959953308105,
-0.41245949268341064,
0.4474555253982544,
-0.6215400099754333,
-0.09303797036409378,
-0.645957350730896,
0.1138141006231308,
0.44800764322280884,
-0.010016988962888718,
0.046862270683050156,
-0.5492801666259766,
-0.47749873995780945,
-1.0045255422592163,
0.10183478891849518,
0.029261406511068344,
0.08658614009618759,
0.2964681386947632,
0.13244746625423431,
-0.43776586651802063,
0.9613620042800903,
-0.4912137985229492,
-0.361288458108902,
0.04893088713288307,
-0.053331270813941956,
0.07039881497621536,
0.7460072040557861,
0.44013914465904236,
-0.9504998922348022,
-0.3123146593570709,
-0.0027489138301461935,
-0.7353058457374573,
-0.36349838972091675,
-0.06877423077821732,
-0.547471284866333,
0.054961394518613815,
0.4419814646244049,
-0.5482401847839355,
0.6043570637702942,
0.766983687877655,
-0.8803215622901917,
-0.03641700744628906,
-0.25605618953704834,
0.44038793444633484,
-0.8952397704124451,
-0.2982063293457031,
-0.3423003554344177,
-0.20428156852722168,
-0.7413707375526428,
-0.07216078042984009,
-0.17181377112865448,
-0.31154903769493103,
-0.28338244557380676,
0.3192923069000244,
-0.4427438974380493,
-0.35971295833587646,
-0.5889195203781128,
0.6575415730476379,
-0.08844757080078125,
0.40322184562683105,
0.1944284588098526,
0.42186740040779114,
0.3400495946407318,
-0.3645331859588623,
0.3103368282318115,
0.527828574180603,
0.31073617935180664,
0.7389811277389526,
-0.8824338912963867,
-0.1270695924758911,
-0.18832992017269135,
0.16947126388549805,
-1.0359617471694946,
-0.02440713532269001,
0.24455004930496216,
-0.9266900420188904,
0.0818965807557106,
0.180110365152359,
0.11662343144416809,
-0.01898529939353466,
0.33595460653305054,
0.783015251159668,
0.10210701823234558,
-0.2514420747756958,
0.1859579235315323,
0.464001327753067,
0.08900034427642822,
-0.9630842804908752,
-0.514499306678772,
-0.0608261376619339,
-0.025283608585596085,
-1.3062174320220947,
0.7973417639732361,
-0.18987886607646942,
-0.4091087281703949,
0.3724835515022278,
-0.3982745110988617,
-0.21261776983737946,
0.12704001367092133,
0.3316916823387146,
0.3267582356929779,
-0.5313064455986023,
0.025234952569007874,
0.07163017243146896,
-0.25239038467407227,
-0.209796741604805,
-0.8181306719779968,
0.44601717591285706,
-0.24467547237873077,
-0.8411460518836975,
-0.32478731870651245,
0.7250896096229553,
0.22548334300518036,
0.18186569213867188,
0.9801051616668701,
0.3503871560096741,
-0.5321282744407654,
0.11305259168148041,
-0.44172051548957825,
0.026689400896430016,
-0.48906803131103516,
0.40289679169654846,
-0.457698792219162,
-1.169779896736145,
0.7019611597061157,
0.15369416773319244,
-0.23056814074516296,
0.48320090770721436,
0.3885997235774994,
0.1413261741399765,
1.0830018520355225,
1.089678406715393,
0.2812764346599579,
0.43245211243629456,
-0.07288365811109543,
0.5473389029502869,
-0.5164191722869873,
-0.15278461575508118,
-0.48698166012763977,
-0.28240877389907837,
-0.6293205618858337,
-0.5903704166412354,
-0.05930323153734207,
0.6521831154823303,
-0.0873248279094696,
0.47032350301742554,
-0.6749759316444397,
0.47851696610450745,
0.1932591199874878,
-0.15513746440410614,
0.0747213140130043,
-0.015447955578565598,
0.09114417433738708,
-0.5137998461723328,
-0.6967639923095703,
-0.5998955368995667,
0.6134363412857056,
0.34435635805130005,
0.7804210782051086,
0.5404645204544067,
0.5453550219535828,
0.2375645935535431,
-0.0616285502910614,
-0.7003212571144104,
0.3163784146308899,
0.08644158393144608,
-0.5583219528198242,
-0.7794472575187683,
-0.2974199056625366,
-1.2099006175994873,
0.25633206963539124,
0.05600369721651077,
-0.8910311460494995,
0.3916926085948944,
-0.060525503009557724,
0.17320111393928528,
-0.1525784730911255,
-0.6804730296134949,
1.1254172325134277,
-0.25923165678977966,
-0.315125048160553,
-0.38479435443878174,
-0.8335005640983582,
-0.16217024624347687,
0.12009575963020325,
0.06807979196310043,
-0.2866012752056122,
-0.212163507938385,
0.8146827816963196,
-0.9753203392028809,
0.6305867433547974,
-0.3234906494617462,
-0.22375084459781647,
0.24102221429347992,
-0.15865403413772583,
0.38632842898368835,
-0.07327686995267868,
0.3184836506843567,
0.07319971919059753,
-0.0421871617436409,
-0.940287172794342,
-0.9275178909301758,
0.8095501065254211,
-1.290807843208313,
-0.676049530506134,
-0.16744495928287506,
-0.7572696208953857,
-0.3050808310508728,
0.2446659654378891,
0.08219389617443085,
0.23390862345695496,
-0.40757301449775696,
-0.2748344838619232,
0.6155818700790405,
-0.07867544144392014,
0.2098415344953537,
0.7872574925422668,
0.16392596065998077,
-0.2156689465045929,
0.9737092852592468,
-0.00843823328614235,
0.7321013808250427,
0.5066028237342834,
-0.26045745611190796,
-0.11061497777700424,
-0.46269434690475464,
-0.2786124050617218,
0.2530654966831207,
-0.9998303651809692,
0.059482019394636154,
-0.6975239515304565,
-0.33571961522102356,
-0.6955212354660034,
-0.5903106331825256,
-0.5729068517684937,
-0.7283724546432495,
-0.08677472919225693,
0.2824307978153229,
-0.1356339007616043,
0.7460560202598572,
-0.15426473319530487,
0.876153826713562,
-0.6617682576179504,
0.15530745685100555,
-0.03759055584669113,
0.5739272236824036,
-0.5118828415870667,
-0.33351102471351624,
-0.19475750625133514,
0.21751727163791656,
-0.2636773884296417,
-0.9843946099281311,
0.3948010504245758,
-0.11950410902500153,
1.0658416748046875,
0.024104667827486992,
-0.36103540658950806,
0.7647774815559387,
-0.31136205792427063,
0.5322844386100769,
0.40805724263191223,
-1.3117586374282837,
0.5454273819923401,
-0.3531337082386017,
0.12234718352556229,
0.19841524958610535,
0.13491983711719513,
-0.8927300572395325,
-0.6248809099197388,
-0.9116190671920776,
-0.8043754696846008,
0.7874788641929626,
0.6977572441101074,
-0.05484466627240181,
0.17355279624462128,
0.2090347409248352,
-0.07829183340072632,
0.05699034407734871,
-0.5770546197891235,
-0.3451758921146393,
-0.3538694679737091,
-0.33548054099082947,
-0.27533888816833496,
-0.223062202334404,
-0.10842547565698624,
0.04668114334344864,
0.7020850777626038,
-0.0551636777818203,
0.6485314965248108,
0.4087047874927521,
-0.3547193109989166,
-0.37929192185401917,
0.4149376451969147,
0.9285542964935303,
0.9148334264755249,
-0.08608771115541458,
0.030261801555752754,
0.029282011091709137,
-0.3985634744167328,
0.4285542964935303,
0.2309022843837738,
0.08796415477991104,
0.14412878453731537,
0.2480623573064804,
0.9999299645423889,
0.18344353139400482,
-0.41609975695610046,
0.7582923769950867,
-0.16440331935882568,
-0.2329058200120926,
-0.16853764653205872,
-0.1884627640247345,
0.16459748148918152,
0.2988659739494324,
0.02954947203397751,
0.3774404525756836,
0.043962955474853516,
-0.0761650875210762,
0.3661891520023346,
0.7844498157501221,
-0.6945056915283203,
-0.12358039617538452,
0.5059136748313904,
0.2674406170845032,
-0.36860138177871704,
0.4015766680240631,
-0.2168159931898117,
-0.7120578289031982,
0.85160231590271,
0.7190911173820496,
0.5923041701316833,
-0.2647481858730316,
0.20930172502994537,
-0.03524376451969147,
0.40999704599380493,
0.19977261126041412,
0.17743460834026337,
-0.038084063678979874,
-1.2517451047897339,
-0.6538252830505371,
-0.6003766059875488,
-0.12808170914649963,
-0.27984383702278137,
-0.43035566806793213,
0.26357078552246094,
-0.017324013635516167,
-0.03433430939912796,
0.34196680784225464,
0.10855930298566818,
-0.4571100175380707,
0.147134929895401,
0.252899169921875,
0.4394020140171051,
-1.0578997135162354,
0.6325624585151672,
0.7640052437782288,
-0.11148667335510254,
-1.028699278831482,
-0.1910339742898941,
-0.07233645021915436,
-0.8212332129478455,
0.9800340533256531,
-0.3028162717819214,
-0.4494343101978302,
-0.1993134617805481,
-0.374582976102829,
-1.3902956247329712,
0.8226861357688904,
0.26086437702178955,
-0.45405134558677673,
0.2766866981983185,
0.4950965940952301,
0.7788497805595398,
-0.6583457589149475,
0.16476663947105408,
0.3319796621799469,
0.2907894253730774,
0.43236181139945984,
-1.2270781993865967,
0.034079961478710175,
-0.4473753571510315,
0.11851293593645096,
0.6696890592575073,
-0.45072051882743835,
0.6479997038841248,
0.14159062504768372,
-0.2372785061597824,
-0.006300611887127161,
0.8438758254051208,
0.08026531338691711,
0.3167937397956848,
0.39747175574302673,
0.5222832560539246,
0.5038891434669495,
-0.2039789855480194,
0.5178915858268738,
-0.021944349631667137,
0.5043606162071228,
1.0313032865524292,
-0.13251063227653503,
0.23165082931518555,
0.7678833603858948,
-0.06207651272416115,
0.17210085690021515,
0.4250859320163727,
0.40529417991638184,
0.49777233600616455,
0.41539910435676575,
-0.09551870077848434,
-0.12022548913955688,
-0.30502554774284363,
-0.3430226147174835,
0.30067136883735657,
0.6590725779533386,
0.08287524431943893,
-0.23214906454086304,
0.08526405692100525,
-0.4272061586380005,
0.2980906367301941,
-0.175730898976326,
0.8026310801506042,
-0.2627040445804596,
-0.7362828254699707,
0.6381627321243286,
0.08362190425395966,
0.6236624717712402,
-0.4031645357608795,
0.0807877629995346,
0.08620313555002213,
0.40525567531585693,
-0.42263317108154297,
-0.6699615120887756,
0.8612110614776611,
-0.4482627809047699,
-0.22958174347877502,
-0.32030054926872253,
0.9717660546302795,
-0.6639373898506165,
-0.19969390332698822,
0.6006935834884644,
0.6513296961784363,
0.18311664462089539,
0.4055573046207428,
-0.6937038898468018,
0.3468368351459503,
-0.1647855043411255,
0.02880651131272316,
-0.04679848626255989,
0.49627307057380676,
-0.35234153270721436,
0.382839173078537,
0.16979576647281647,
0.2197805792093277,
0.4107223451137543,
0.22294683754444122,
0.7671840190887451,
-0.4829312860965729,
-0.5753104090690613,
-0.4307437539100647,
0.2585795819759369,
-0.23270688951015472,
-0.13880962133407593,
0.703188419342041,
0.3473397195339203,
1.1912297010421753,
0.19014780223369598,
0.5204731822013855,
-0.2340758889913559,
0.18300212919712067,
-0.30523303151130676,
0.24121639132499695,
-0.654555082321167,
0.44593027234077454,
-0.6540628671646118,
-0.9904031157493591,
-0.3045960068702698,
0.560824990272522,
-0.4027942717075348,
-0.16839152574539185,
0.7820812463760376,
0.970298171043396,
-0.2640151083469391,
-0.0032788554672151804,
0.4631975293159485,
-0.24659456312656403,
0.21757671236991882,
0.7656652331352234,
1.2016279697418213,
-0.6148096919059753,
0.37705478072166443,
-0.17051716148853302,
-0.23487462103366852,
-0.010982593521475792,
-0.4882766008377075,
-0.4888562262058258,
-0.7318527102470398,
-0.5052680373191833,
-0.5495661497116089,
0.2679782509803772,
0.6328578591346741,
0.7459505796432495,
-0.6580319404602051,
-0.32300591468811035,
-0.4029388427734375,
0.39669665694236755,
-0.040494270622730255,
-0.23381976783275604,
0.0927293598651886,
-0.3195769190788269,
-0.654176652431488,
-0.007958848029375076,
0.45541831851005554,
0.3416212201118469,
-0.1766955554485321,
-0.5706812143325806,
-0.08649026602506638,
0.15516749024391174,
0.15174829959869385,
0.06276915222406387,
-0.9165202379226685,
-0.4078098237514496,
0.13857585191726685,
-0.5387403964996338,
0.05093199759721756,
1.0620737075805664,
-0.4046189486980438,
0.32398679852485657,
0.6363715529441833,
0.6382458209991455,
0.28001201152801514,
-0.07254062592983246,
0.8496005535125732,
-0.7757801413536072,
0.6081539392471313,
0.1551358848810196,
0.04216815531253815,
0.31091800332069397,
-0.6188374757766724,
0.25602754950523376,
0.2901877164840698,
-0.6398535370826721,
-0.34409505128860474,
0.2932462692260742,
-1.213989496231079,
-0.5817248225212097,
0.7939490675926208,
-0.09355813264846802,
-0.2931501865386963,
-0.0978618636727333,
-0.0779343768954277,
0.5056626200675964,
-0.2882600426673889,
0.3480748236179352,
0.8944306373596191,
-0.017572466284036636,
0.41149234771728516,
-0.40353643894195557,
0.42191120982170105,
0.9743981957435608,
-0.6681962609291077,
-0.302188903093338,
0.7673407793045044,
0.18970473110675812,
0.4045705795288086,
0.916519820690155,
-0.05148743465542793,
0.24269449710845947,
0.17819714546203613,
-0.01803399622440338,
0.5543641448020935,
-0.3413780927658081,
-0.26070791482925415,
-0.29258447885513306,
0.1599801927804947,
-0.19438526034355164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13448v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13448v1
|
Distilling Instruction-following Abilities of Large Language Models with Task-aware Curriculum Planning
| 2024-05-22T08:38:26 | 2024-05-22T08:38:26 |
Yuanhao Yue, Chengyu Wang, Jun Huang, Peng Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The process of instruction tuning aligns pre-trained large language models
(LLMs) with open-domain instructions and human-preferred responses. While
several studies have explored autonomous approaches to distilling and
annotating instructions from more powerful proprietary LLMs, such as ChatGPT,
they often neglect the impact of task distributions and the varying difficulty
of instructions of the training sets. This oversight can lead to imbalanced
knowledge capabilities and poor generalization powers of small student LLMs. To
address this challenge, we introduce Task-Aware Curriculum Planning for
Instruction Refinement (TAPIR), a multi-round distillation framework with
balanced task distributions and dynamic difficulty adjustment. This approach
utilizes an oracle LLM to select instructions that are difficult for a student
LLM to follow and distill instructions with balanced task distributions. By
incorporating curriculum planning, our approach systematically escalates the
difficulty levels, progressively enhancing the student LLM's capabilities. We
rigorously evaluate TAPIR using two widely recognized benchmarks, including
AlpacaEval 2.0 and MT-Bench. The empirical results demonstrate that the student
LLMs, trained with our method and less training data, outperform larger
instruction-tuned models and strong distillation baselines. The improvement is
particularly notable in complex tasks, such as logical reasoning and code
generation.
|
[
-0.3887661397457123,
-0.6956838965415955,
0.3164568543434143,
0.07843165099620819,
-0.057759176939725876,
0.30273565649986267,
-0.5112622976303101,
-0.043029386550188065,
-0.17779609560966492,
0.7139626741409302,
-0.7297812700271606,
-0.41439908742904663,
-0.7623395323753357,
-0.05110519751906395,
-0.0980626791715622,
0.9643020629882812,
-0.17209705710411072,
-0.0028392658568918705,
-0.03802942857146263,
0.20087872445583344,
-0.9531427621841431,
-0.21544240415096283,
-0.34080949425697327,
-0.5484413504600525,
0.2704767882823944,
0.8147051334381104,
0.10119330883026123,
0.6737526059150696,
0.5108098983764648,
0.262641042470932,
0.03492223471403122,
0.5129193663597107,
-0.4909578263759613,
0.14857758581638336,
-0.1474485993385315,
-0.4011222720146179,
-0.49479806423187256,
-0.09492690116167068,
0.27792882919311523,
0.7367167472839355,
-0.24928756058216095,
0.3902946412563324,
0.5374382138252258,
0.884154736995697,
-0.810381293296814,
0.4587983787059784,
-0.7571408748626709,
-0.22393880784511566,
-0.1994468867778778,
-0.1351478099822998,
-0.5916053056716919,
-0.3715795576572418,
0.3100084662437439,
-0.49006056785583496,
0.524235725402832,
0.0358673520386219,
0.40649688243865967,
0.6586564183235168,
-0.09216777980327606,
-0.4735645055770874,
-0.7018061876296997,
0.9687464237213135,
-0.4913868010044098,
0.14403724670410156,
0.5307618379592896,
0.2863020896911621,
-0.33626729249954224,
-0.5841572284698486,
-0.2888565957546234,
-0.019927939400076866,
0.04571054130792618,
0.06706368923187256,
0.019121268764138222,
0.2478349208831787,
0.4036315679550171,
0.4064983129501343,
-0.26562368869781494,
0.07317739725112915,
-0.6766362190246582,
-0.07645408064126968,
0.20059457421302795,
0.1883450597524643,
-0.08449887484312057,
0.20734333992004395,
-0.29534390568733215,
-0.1707271933555603,
-0.7966283559799194,
0.10211656987667084,
0.3081497848033905,
0.5590845346450806,
0.29672253131866455,
0.5755618810653687,
-0.28149285912513733,
0.8145738244056702,
0.415381520986557,
-0.3223860263824463,
0.024468177929520607,
-0.20904789865016937,
-0.2231181114912033,
0.12351257354021072,
0.31892138719558716,
-0.03225376829504967,
0.20874762535095215,
0.18583343923091888,
-0.15484507381916046,
-0.16678264737129211,
0.5224888324737549,
-0.9606818556785583,
-0.5716083645820618,
-0.02289586327970028,
-0.09788302332162857,
0.10026964545249939,
-0.17386968433856964,
-0.5492209196090698,
-0.27831655740737915,
-0.7011905908584595,
0.31225070357322693,
-0.5966365337371826,
0.09785571694374084,
0.22783058881759644,
0.12209605425596237,
-0.02330145053565502,
0.5942646265029907,
-1.1802791357040405,
0.2375580221414566,
0.7221206426620483,
0.4621245265007019,
-0.1889825165271759,
-0.25900381803512573,
-0.4711940884590149,
0.2737120985984802,
-0.005455805920064449,
0.706587553024292,
-0.6285518407821655,
-0.3254449665546417,
-0.1331244558095932,
-0.10064613074064255,
-0.07443512976169586,
-0.7646971940994263,
0.4872875213623047,
-0.3289365768432617,
-0.16865718364715576,
-0.4423043131828308,
-0.49706634879112244,
-0.23449204862117767,
0.18539243936538696,
-0.5460821390151978,
1.0471949577331543,
-0.004932250361889601,
-0.5302891135215759,
0.5200781226158142,
-0.5379683971405029,
-0.5093159079551697,
-0.1033882275223732,
0.024600287899374962,
-0.3082008361816406,
0.0029175833333283663,
0.38121461868286133,
0.48249804973602295,
-0.33397001028060913,
0.3281537592411041,
0.021916253492236137,
-0.4572577178478241,
-0.3888988494873047,
-0.1871597021818161,
0.5232465267181396,
0.1939450055360794,
-0.5173822641372681,
0.17579783499240875,
-0.6554696559906006,
0.16641588509082794,
-0.23087765276432037,
-0.49161040782928467,
-0.3474847376346588,
0.08949573338031769,
-0.40284809470176697,
-0.04990978166460991,
0.141225665807724,
-0.25824326276779175,
0.5260696411132812,
-0.08404985815286636,
0.3826107084751129,
0.7800429463386536,
-0.11796841770410538,
0.45920106768608093,
-0.18373391032218933,
0.327390193939209,
-0.17341142892837524,
-0.051754701882600784,
-0.5464447736740112,
-0.38179606199264526,
-0.9778458476066589,
-0.5096912384033203,
-0.12992887198925018,
0.6124632358551025,
-0.6089357733726501,
0.27963754534721375,
0.11135251820087433,
-0.5314768552780151,
-0.5999439358711243,
0.438346803188324,
0.5590062737464905,
0.5563178062438965,
0.7161733508110046,
-0.28978464007377625,
-0.41002094745635986,
-0.6962816119194031,
0.08096883445978165,
0.007729998789727688,
0.16022075712680817,
-0.01730842888355255,
0.3008806109428406,
0.13463371992111206,
0.6545310616493225,
-0.8171684741973877,
-0.5295180082321167,
-0.34828487038612366,
0.5027782320976257,
0.14835436642169952,
0.4330889880657196,
-0.002011584583669901,
-0.4632536768913269,
-0.7053542733192444,
-0.16521261632442474,
-0.253106951713562,
-0.36017295718193054,
-0.09935351461172104,
-0.16788150370121002,
-0.07039061188697815,
0.4423784017562866,
-0.11964552104473114,
0.3034588694572449,
0.15475238859653473,
0.01698286272585392,
0.5723942518234253,
-0.4404541552066803,
0.12282715737819672,
-0.8694728016853333,
-0.24063818156719208,
-0.01343473233282566,
0.1372014433145523,
-0.5140877962112427,
0.00638398015871644,
0.30199578404426575,
0.07802516222000122,
-0.32461848855018616,
0.29221856594085693,
-0.8449232578277588,
0.27301833033561707,
-0.5730606913566589,
-0.15391163527965546,
0.08336728811264038,
0.5656840801239014,
0.16787849366664886,
0.9628506898880005,
0.3360220193862915,
-0.4742051959037781,
0.2524259090423584,
0.22137820720672607,
-0.43271830677986145,
0.5400708317756653,
-0.5324819684028625,
-0.07288461923599243,
0.10237657278776169,
0.25576213002204895,
-0.8842350840568542,
-0.051113154739141464,
-0.03370963782072067,
0.19740059971809387,
0.7481182217597961,
-0.1879156082868576,
-0.15429796278476715,
-0.403488427400589,
-0.14001280069351196,
0.2617867588996887,
0.4357863664627075,
-0.49963414669036865,
0.5056496858596802,
0.13060767948627472,
-0.20263917744159698,
-0.9300338625907898,
-0.6329662799835205,
-0.2383650690317154,
-0.06279832869768143,
-0.21972523629665375,
0.40075257420539856,
-0.10884511470794678,
-0.10989030450582504,
-0.2119215577840805,
-0.38905224204063416,
-0.34305480122566223,
-0.11057129502296448,
0.45323535799980164,
0.36710643768310547,
-0.09367510676383972,
-0.030701184645295143,
0.2720048129558563,
-0.08832450956106186,
-0.1175374910235405,
-0.31414103507995605,
0.532275378704071,
0.01917840912938118,
-0.7425437569618225,
-0.4446752667427063,
0.007005772553384304,
0.39980998635292053,
-0.4019125699996948,
0.36464759707450867,
0.45426371693611145,
-0.03957259654998779,
-0.4729996621608734,
-0.8704123497009277,
-0.3158717751502991,
-0.4679185152053833,
0.3805941939353943,
-0.30259808897972107,
-1.0313447713851929,
0.23716291785240173,
-0.20680087804794312,
0.3831510841846466,
-0.03229781240224838,
0.6383317112922668,
0.04086357355117798,
0.49643033742904663,
0.8076400756835938,
0.012123347260057926,
0.45672306418418884,
-0.37357163429260254,
0.25224897265434265,
-0.8554408550262451,
-0.25211620330810547,
-0.4952070415019989,
-0.43505167961120605,
-0.3327198624610901,
-0.8076608777046204,
0.09470739960670471,
0.05696123093366623,
-0.31796082854270935,
0.4753722548484802,
-0.7457720041275024,
0.7326074838638306,
0.9343148469924927,
0.023924745619297028,
0.31263282895088196,
-0.057613082230091095,
-0.07131227105855942,
-0.06707032769918442,
-0.5589131712913513,
-0.5649703145027161,
1.1886404752731323,
0.0016002885531634092,
0.9286420941352844,
-0.33031660318374634,
0.9241448044776917,
0.07793612778186798,
0.3979359269142151,
-0.5982576608657837,
0.6007838249206543,
-0.3123268783092499,
-0.6622959971427917,
-0.2781689465045929,
-0.0768134668469429,
-0.5626229047775269,
0.08347738534212112,
-0.21565958857536316,
-0.6939519643783569,
-0.0011867289431393147,
0.35803452134132385,
-0.3430904448032379,
0.36461514234542847,
-0.9885880947113037,
0.6802578568458557,
-0.07694412767887115,
-0.4639852046966553,
-0.2849297821521759,
-0.40444284677505493,
0.3627146780490875,
-0.324747234582901,
0.04561956599354744,
-0.3975411057472229,
0.07692133635282516,
0.3146904408931732,
-0.36535945534706116,
1.0105890035629272,
-0.22764265537261963,
0.048511892557144165,
0.6627562046051025,
0.09293121099472046,
0.4272367060184479,
-0.3063018023967743,
-0.05004352703690529,
-0.13454027473926544,
-0.26704686880111694,
-0.3714955151081085,
-0.42001089453697205,
0.7646737098693848,
-0.5728178024291992,
-1.0169132947921753,
-0.09049602597951889,
-0.9035826921463013,
-0.18308451771736145,
0.19838114082813263,
0.11390332132577896,
0.15024904906749725,
-0.1698402762413025,
-0.05613741651177406,
0.8817248940467834,
-0.012233511544764042,
0.4530698359012604,
0.4792269766330719,
0.19637025892734528,
-0.07727037370204926,
1.0094321966171265,
0.3052155375480652,
0.45970237255096436,
0.4525962769985199,
-0.07473775744438171,
-0.04478258639574051,
-0.8021130561828613,
-0.473868727684021,
-0.07895836234092712,
-0.6066132187843323,
-0.18361009657382965,
-0.30991825461387634,
-0.0929754376411438,
-0.18711267411708832,
-0.4506896734237671,
-0.49203434586524963,
-0.3448595702648163,
-0.29053324460983276,
-0.0014831533189862967,
0.13127441704273224,
0.6129298806190491,
0.14571096003055573,
0.38906750082969666,
-0.6692572236061096,
0.1751246452331543,
0.3922748565673828,
0.182956263422966,
0.017567453905940056,
-0.6890062093734741,
-0.16615334153175354,
0.10754705965518951,
-0.6309845447540283,
-0.560021162033081,
0.2298775613307953,
0.30600398778915405,
0.384631484746933,
0.2936325669288635,
0.28563451766967773,
0.9868131279945374,
-0.8237560391426086,
0.5152720808982849,
0.1674463003873825,
-0.8303022980690002,
0.6446855664253235,
0.0024829076137393713,
0.403189480304718,
0.7651949524879456,
0.29673391580581665,
-0.03348647430539131,
-0.6695579290390015,
-0.13408365845680237,
-0.8581971526145935,
0.8961082100868225,
-0.1357119232416153,
0.23769357800483704,
0.00973071251064539,
0.26581254601478577,
0.4398360252380371,
0.18970352411270142,
-0.34926438331604004,
-0.153410866856575,
-0.12377902120351791,
-0.1779356300830841,
0.1426578313112259,
-0.24955406785011292,
-0.08496599644422531,
-0.278110533952713,
0.7461968064308167,
-0.07867390662431717,
-0.1849868893623352,
-0.2430766522884369,
-0.0329834520816803,
0.03505786508321762,
0.46684783697128296,
0.5246319770812988,
0.8207080364227295,
-0.23111003637313843,
0.08932586759328842,
0.32054704427719116,
-0.8055639266967773,
0.3344883918762207,
0.2290453314781189,
-0.027342382818460464,
-0.48366591334342957,
0.31717535853385925,
0.5986461043357849,
0.27691972255706787,
-0.6784683465957642,
0.16684341430664062,
0.044407617300748825,
-0.2136937975883484,
0.05035550892353058,
0.5162648558616638,
0.09735654294490814,
0.5119389295578003,
0.49044743180274963,
-0.07401899993419647,
0.033195577561855316,
-0.19318436086177826,
0.11827323585748672,
0.22030165791511536,
-0.26672860980033875,
-0.15991808474063873,
0.46159234642982483,
0.2752884030342102,
-0.024351730942726135,
0.5551723837852478,
-0.11809312552213669,
-0.1589970737695694,
0.5783255696296692,
0.6368427276611328,
0.7552600502967834,
-0.41143858432769775,
0.1506197601556778,
0.4863485097885132,
0.3989100456237793,
-0.31816455721855164,
0.13193091750144958,
-0.20238731801509857,
-0.4523765742778778,
-0.6909578442573547,
-0.5634753108024597,
-0.5493986010551453,
-0.050544578582048416,
-0.76337069272995,
0.3730955719947815,
-0.48912960290908813,
0.05497341603040695,
0.06724640727043152,
0.002150979358702898,
-0.45104295015335083,
0.12063927203416824,
-0.04833412170410156,
0.7599545121192932,
-0.671697735786438,
0.9693062901496887,
0.8192608952522278,
-0.3149179518222809,
-1.0230334997177124,
-0.04667673259973526,
0.1479637175798416,
-0.9384742379188538,
0.8848562240600586,
0.12200821936130524,
-0.030569102615118027,
-0.055294472724199295,
-0.15177012979984283,
-0.5267505049705505,
1.1922435760498047,
0.3376602232456207,
-0.8898170590400696,
-0.14297805726528168,
0.17611975967884064,
0.3549906611442566,
-0.2566765248775482,
0.2117607295513153,
0.5694653391838074,
0.24781450629234314,
0.5306746959686279,
-0.912014365196228,
-0.12056580185890198,
0.05948813632130623,
-0.1679205745458603,
0.5666670203208923,
-0.5188719630241394,
0.7501644492149353,
-0.4924990236759186,
-0.029933718964457512,
-0.277351975440979,
0.6605885028839111,
0.12007322907447815,
0.3683689832687378,
0.23440510034561157,
0.7563079595565796,
0.7592223882675171,
-0.32698628306388855,
0.40112242102622986,
-0.3143021762371063,
-0.004414093215018511,
1.5517079830169678,
-0.25002697110176086,
0.7637691497802734,
0.652286946773529,
-0.2781117558479309,
0.28100302815437317,
0.5439298748970032,
-0.013835708610713482,
0.6020941734313965,
0.2910253405570984,
-0.28895488381385803,
-0.15962471067905426,
0.05531096085906029,
-0.3317904472351074,
0.49474966526031494,
0.31855911016464233,
-0.14156576991081238,
-0.3386549949645996,
0.09754287451505661,
-0.006523035001009703,
0.2085634469985962,
-0.3939720690250397,
0.568862795829773,
-0.1854407638311386,
-0.7771278619766235,
0.712864339351654,
-0.13604672253131866,
0.5521525144577026,
-0.5030522346496582,
-0.21981510519981384,
-0.060851819813251495,
0.28716790676116943,
-0.07198641449213028,
-0.7178546190261841,
0.2588191628456116,
0.20396549999713898,
-0.3591848611831665,
-0.47013425827026367,
0.6630364656448364,
-0.6355524063110352,
-0.33293417096138,
0.04848804324865341,
0.6120667457580566,
-0.11445105820894241,
0.03349651023745537,
-0.4140172004699707,
0.08376309275627136,
0.29903644323349,
-0.22502508759498596,
0.4617907702922821,
0.5293894410133362,
-0.11598948389291763,
0.7247712016105652,
0.48388439416885376,
0.06072838231921196,
0.13686831295490265,
-0.12341929972171783,
1.0466852188110352,
-0.2211451381444931,
0.02814527228474617,
-0.7552940249443054,
0.5860898494720459,
0.15922120213508606,
-0.30968543887138367,
0.39276087284088135,
0.456543505191803,
1.0853298902511597,
-0.1466471403837204,
0.5607092380523682,
-0.009427168406546116,
0.4878159761428833,
-0.30738529562950134,
0.4041796624660492,
-0.21097634732723236,
0.5836040377616882,
-0.13140077888965607,
-1.2165639400482178,
-0.06301584094762802,
0.46517178416252136,
-0.6023330688476562,
-0.11150489747524261,
0.4907732307910919,
0.7251583337783813,
-0.18279293179512024,
0.0528532899916172,
0.1082114651799202,
-0.16877813637256622,
0.2505033314228058,
0.5459222197532654,
0.6149203181266785,
0.18670353293418884,
0.5534501075744629,
-0.4764133393764496,
-0.42059388756752014,
-0.15219727158546448,
-0.9724727272987366,
-1.0631098747253418,
-0.5422263741493225,
-0.2983672618865967,
0.2237204611301422,
0.17877599596977234,
0.9872113466262817,
0.6896646618843079,
-0.7381014823913574,
-0.45048221945762634,
-0.06289967149496078,
0.019927090033888817,
-0.23432132601737976,
-0.1366577446460724,
0.35636427998542786,
-0.7031765580177307,
-0.8673595190048218,
0.3453172445297241,
0.2950616180896759,
-0.17675626277923584,
-0.07926090061664581,
0.03834182024002075,
-0.15054211020469666,
0.0008936753147281706,
0.43366050720214844,
0.23755326867103577,
-0.8623192310333252,
-0.18014878034591675,
0.0838719829916954,
-0.1940905600786209,
-0.07547219097614288,
0.9911487698554993,
-0.4540351331233978,
0.8698254227638245,
0.1641252189874649,
0.7103971242904663,
0.6385787129402161,
-0.09400130063295364,
0.3097515106201172,
-0.7967526912689209,
0.2858221232891083,
0.2697259485721588,
0.18741266429424286,
0.028800638392567635,
-0.10877028107643127,
0.4072304368019104,
-0.1900155246257782,
-0.6175154447555542,
-0.5473181009292603,
0.006270536221563816,
-0.8942703008651733,
-0.18833477795124054,
0.7836112380027771,
-0.5106592178344727,
0.1633445918560028,
-0.06417190283536911,
-0.5082708597183228,
0.29326486587524414,
-0.3356143832206726,
0.9966251254081726,
0.9396209120750427,
-0.2875416874885559,
-0.06977434456348419,
-0.6909279227256775,
0.39535677433013916,
0.3433707356452942,
-0.7108792662620544,
0.42365676164627075,
0.6990249156951904,
0.046810831874608994,
0.095154769718647,
0.5317241549491882,
0.12949800491333008,
0.0832446813583374,
-0.26303812861442566,
0.19510914385318756,
-0.5476085543632507,
-0.545229971408844,
0.38599562644958496,
0.16403456032276154,
0.2653106153011322,
-0.23296961188316345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13432v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13432v1
|
Disperse-Then-Merge: Pushing the Limits of Instruction Tuning via Alignment Tax Reduction
| 2024-05-22T08:18:19 | 2024-05-22T08:18:19 |
Tingchen Fu, Deng Cai, Lemao Liu, Shuming Shi, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Supervised fine-tuning (SFT) on instruction-following corpus is a crucial
approach toward the alignment of large language models (LLMs). However, the
performance of LLMs on standard knowledge and reasoning benchmarks tends to
suffer from deterioration at the latter stage of the SFT process, echoing the
phenomenon of alignment tax. Through our pilot study, we put a hypothesis that
the data biases are probably one cause behind the phenomenon. To address the
issue, we introduce a simple disperse-then-merge framework. To be concrete, we
disperse the instruction-following data into portions and train multiple
sub-models using different data portions. Then we merge multiple models into a
single one via model merging techniques. Despite its simplicity, our framework
outperforms various sophisticated methods such as data curation and training
regularization on a series of standard knowledge and reasoning benchmarks.
|
[
-0.6614972949028015,
-0.6413159966468811,
0.3115602433681488,
-0.14786456525325775,
-0.1412632316350937,
0.10682502388954163,
-0.49859341979026794,
-0.21619649231433868,
-0.11657734960317612,
0.8027822375297546,
-0.6599307656288147,
-0.38039955496788025,
-0.7205860018730164,
-0.3234027028083801,
-0.7641635537147522,
1.1220941543579102,
0.022072985768318176,
0.19336046278476715,
-0.23124556243419647,
-0.10613562911748886,
-0.4636993408203125,
-0.1357133537530899,
-0.7665777206420898,
0.05458113178610802,
0.2647435963153839,
0.6690950989723206,
0.6981294751167297,
1.0722147226333618,
0.4875839650630951,
0.2653466463088989,
-0.01875777542591095,
0.47663870453834534,
-0.6429257988929749,
0.05345907807350159,
-0.11532673984766006,
-0.5757423043251038,
-0.0880558118224144,
-0.1337665468454361,
0.8603315353393555,
1.0586098432540894,
-0.24874509871006012,
-0.05123399570584297,
0.44741055369377136,
0.7130773663520813,
-0.841519296169281,
-0.09262362122535706,
-0.3865372836589813,
-0.18426914513111115,
-0.307640939950943,
-0.005037861410528421,
-0.6221391558647156,
-0.5064302086830139,
-0.005378387868404388,
-0.5064916014671326,
0.34786975383758545,
-0.046337079256772995,
0.6008493304252625,
0.7401628494262695,
-0.37801000475883484,
-0.08287650346755981,
-0.7241413593292236,
0.9333291053771973,
-0.576712429523468,
0.5835766792297363,
0.1306653618812561,
0.09650260210037231,
-0.2060939520597458,
-0.47798952460289,
-0.313610315322876,
0.04149386286735535,
-0.03051416389644146,
-0.044472068548202515,
-0.24475263059139252,
0.08216316998004913,
0.16804879903793335,
0.1825634390115738,
-0.5555858612060547,
0.20493024587631226,
-0.6374737620353699,
0.010388553142547607,
0.630462110042572,
0.14080698788166046,
0.0472082681953907,
0.2167799323797226,
-0.5146582722663879,
-0.24981558322906494,
-0.7367709279060364,
-0.20479442179203033,
0.34012046456336975,
0.3689994812011719,
0.18253810703754425,
0.6319354176521301,
-0.07980570942163467,
0.9593498706817627,
0.3509753942489624,
-0.0414741151034832,
-0.1901833564043045,
-0.41199326515197754,
-0.31660234928131104,
0.207976832985878,
0.6366099715232849,
0.4034397304058075,
0.21461878716945648,
0.023893631994724274,
-0.16630220413208008,
0.017130091786384583,
0.3546323776245117,
-0.7322537302970886,
-0.39445769786834717,
-0.005766341928392649,
-0.29493623971939087,
-0.20003123581409454,
-0.11856553703546524,
-0.40725216269493103,
-0.2986278235912323,
-0.7570273280143738,
0.01955331861972809,
-0.6212572455406189,
-0.16747941076755524,
0.02541547454893589,
-0.11680835485458374,
0.147987499833107,
0.35472044348716736,
-1.1413971185684204,
0.42474469542503357,
1.0696555376052856,
0.5753270983695984,
-0.35720717906951904,
-0.31172770261764526,
-0.5467373728752136,
0.22122593224048615,
-0.4665435552597046,
0.9010946750640869,
-0.47770392894744873,
-0.39431676268577576,
-0.14702902734279633,
-0.1739305853843689,
-0.22531940042972565,
-0.7540044784545898,
0.38995739817619324,
-0.5661909580230713,
0.2393004298210144,
-0.4009741544723511,
-1.0529366731643677,
0.023486264050006866,
0.11629559844732285,
-0.5261239409446716,
1.1107412576675415,
0.5111291408538818,
-0.6478676199913025,
0.6358340382575989,
-0.27493196725845337,
-0.46960964798927307,
0.14229516685009003,
-0.20408357679843903,
-0.1960611194372177,
0.06401602178812027,
0.09425108879804611,
0.4023379385471344,
-0.28341811895370483,
0.30363693833351135,
-0.278474360704422,
-0.5428264737129211,
-0.38223108649253845,
-0.393880158662796,
0.8478655219078064,
0.4068869650363922,
-0.27861589193344116,
0.02772049605846405,
-0.681364119052887,
0.01892162300646305,
-0.4041386842727661,
-0.4072422683238983,
-0.5679020881652832,
-0.0014795660972595215,
-0.06380922347307205,
-0.16188053786754608,
0.23499228060245514,
-0.19779665768146515,
0.6964457631111145,
-0.2603755295276642,
0.26705846190452576,
0.8523244261741638,
-0.19915060698986053,
1.0385551452636719,
-0.31942468881607056,
0.6311617493629456,
0.06922490894794464,
0.15552090108394623,
0.0518471784889698,
-0.40548670291900635,
-0.7793759703636169,
-0.25557202100753784,
0.35402658581733704,
0.6194445490837097,
-0.5705651640892029,
0.2800607979297638,
-0.37292346358299255,
-0.5494647026062012,
-0.6777689456939697,
0.3616553843021393,
0.29811131954193115,
0.5996063947677612,
0.45307132601737976,
-0.09006311744451523,
-0.5547470450401306,
-0.8743991255760193,
-0.19973449409008026,
0.10789180546998978,
0.021206418052315712,
-0.04711176082491875,
0.11751415580511093,
-0.25024744868278503,
0.9464659094810486,
-0.6121172308921814,
-0.31318631768226624,
-0.013349574990570545,
0.1899842470884323,
-0.059066370129585266,
0.8502574563026428,
0.4367235600948334,
-0.7270714640617371,
-0.48398151993751526,
0.21403288841247559,
-0.3087109327316284,
-0.288727730512619,
-0.1086634024977684,
-0.32387804985046387,
0.4161421060562134,
0.7418868541717529,
-0.503291666507721,
0.34177669882774353,
0.5858879685401917,
-0.029170334339141846,
0.39397284388542175,
-0.023826852440834045,
0.2742477357387543,
-1.1829545497894287,
-0.4909919798374176,
-0.20939910411834717,
-0.05496000126004219,
-0.3093540370464325,
0.027473807334899902,
0.24849529564380646,
0.27155613899230957,
-0.2750723659992218,
0.24768471717834473,
-0.4833777844905853,
0.009039311669766903,
-0.43854865431785583,
-0.15450380742549896,
-0.06009449437260628,
0.17443329095840454,
-0.08821415901184082,
0.9468841552734375,
0.23522818088531494,
-0.6291350722312927,
0.12521038949489594,
0.06451445817947388,
-0.30872824788093567,
0.7509145140647888,
-0.2014513611793518,
-0.28314003348350525,
-0.08198460936546326,
0.1729755997657776,
-1.1209168434143066,
-0.2790970206260681,
0.033019207417964935,
-0.040733229368925095,
0.5340648889541626,
-0.3825710117816925,
-0.3926045596599579,
-0.1344020515680313,
-0.3506380021572113,
0.4632720649242401,
0.6816765666007996,
-0.576673686504364,
0.5446320176124573,
0.12404155731201172,
-0.012686875648796558,
-0.7901888489723206,
-0.8289480805397034,
-0.3138637840747833,
-0.21459703147411346,
-0.8664403557777405,
0.6156478524208069,
-0.16924238204956055,
-0.03312484547495842,
0.25775638222694397,
-0.033186789602041245,
-0.0823756530880928,
-0.07316847890615463,
-0.17754822969436646,
0.16163407266139984,
-0.4905749559402466,
-0.06494630128145218,
0.7316425442695618,
0.037956807762384415,
-0.21815533936023712,
-0.6078185439109802,
0.37082815170288086,
0.22542627155780792,
-0.5509427785873413,
-0.2944939136505127,
0.42188969254493713,
0.45215117931365967,
-0.05740682780742645,
0.9635114073753357,
0.5616180300712585,
-0.2617647647857666,
-0.4476613700389862,
-0.8084521889686584,
-0.08513619750738144,
-0.4699925184249878,
0.2080485075712204,
-0.19333535432815552,
-1.0998297929763794,
0.40981295704841614,
-0.3953733444213867,
0.3639451563358307,
0.2805492579936981,
0.3242662847042084,
-0.125973641872406,
1.117370367050171,
0.6600443124771118,
0.04133244603872299,
0.8238072991371155,
-0.4540475904941559,
0.22999262809753418,
-0.7503716945648193,
-0.15718616545200348,
-0.4329572021961212,
-0.2094287872314453,
-0.615851879119873,
-0.503750741481781,
0.017768070101737976,
0.576957643032074,
-0.3687063157558441,
0.5085213780403137,
-0.7279000878334045,
0.8449963927268982,
0.5417681336402893,
-0.041470762342214584,
0.08889564871788025,
-0.09060395509004593,
0.1353391706943512,
-0.020368533208966255,
-0.749871015548706,
-0.30856266617774963,
0.9810488224029541,
-0.1709779053926468,
0.7784748077392578,
0.046147484332323074,
1.1337740421295166,
0.1903575211763382,
0.44342461228370667,
-0.8227786421775818,
0.47757983207702637,
-0.622875988483429,
-0.17809218168258667,
-0.28275856375694275,
-0.5046847462654114,
-0.8108773231506348,
0.30465495586395264,
0.12442950159311295,
-0.43516382575035095,
0.3098873198032379,
0.18267802894115448,
-0.40544775128364563,
0.20806825160980225,
-1.131834626197815,
0.8245133757591248,
0.007186096161603928,
-0.46384134888648987,
-0.03598721697926521,
-0.4509489834308624,
0.6350100040435791,
-0.15131674706935883,
0.4098607003688812,
0.09388495236635208,
-0.13395649194717407,
0.7310917973518372,
-0.7528954148292542,
0.7141281962394714,
-0.11318245530128479,
-0.2057293802499771,
0.19431138038635254,
0.14919674396514893,
0.4129990041255951,
-0.38765475153923035,
0.06797721982002258,
-0.16752435266971588,
0.19328396022319794,
-0.4596797525882721,
-0.7455510497093201,
0.7111349701881409,
-0.6601803302764893,
-0.5607174634933472,
-0.018580880016088486,
-0.6310960054397583,
-0.07895854115486145,
0.303526908159256,
0.41502368450164795,
0.2572520077228546,
0.044388409703969955,
0.07123958319425583,
0.7976986765861511,
0.35054925084114075,
0.07672617584466934,
0.31957390904426575,
-0.0746777281165123,
-0.4720684587955475,
0.7818024754524231,
0.44590306282043457,
0.5292896628379822,
0.24111615121364594,
0.09493553638458252,
-0.2639331519603729,
-0.5578218698501587,
-0.40044474601745605,
0.03377481922507286,
-0.806765079498291,
-0.5137872695922852,
-0.41016480326652527,
-0.15438015758991241,
-0.6809902787208557,
-0.5646887421607971,
-0.5551878809928894,
-0.3777461051940918,
-0.5245689153671265,
0.05335181578993797,
0.3694988787174225,
0.8490598201751709,
-0.16627033054828644,
0.7445838451385498,
-0.9948501586914062,
-0.028351081535220146,
-0.07852735370397568,
0.15911231935024261,
-0.09151249378919601,
-0.6963141560554504,
-0.2991587817668915,
0.11548960208892822,
-0.34318244457244873,
-0.6902077198028564,
0.26856279373168945,
0.07858850806951523,
0.395478218793869,
0.6178677678108215,
-0.0013878891477361321,
1.1025811433792114,
-0.4870182275772095,
0.6966102123260498,
0.09454265236854553,
-0.9746525883674622,
0.4081631600856781,
-0.32173898816108704,
0.21610046923160553,
0.7200720906257629,
0.3607085943222046,
-0.1322254091501236,
-0.7197327017784119,
-0.5923131108283997,
-0.9763262867927551,
0.9099423885345459,
-0.1368347555398941,
0.03140317648649216,
-0.045671772211790085,
0.3693842589855194,
0.09709962457418442,
0.04692971706390381,
-0.23001176118850708,
-0.2269737869501114,
0.2338455468416214,
-0.5118620991706848,
0.08528264611959457,
-0.20782268047332764,
-0.12188529968261719,
-0.48671209812164307,
0.6640948057174683,
-0.042340394109487534,
-0.16911017894744873,
-0.2749113142490387,
-0.1582348495721817,
-0.03926829993724823,
0.20227442681789398,
0.6496999859809875,
0.42312487959861755,
-0.04595101252198219,
0.025105461478233337,
0.12201138585805893,
-0.3744032084941864,
0.11439591646194458,
0.15805469453334808,
-0.2725357115268707,
-0.40094029903411865,
0.43461155891418457,
0.5359009504318237,
0.6644477248191833,
-0.37448692321777344,
0.4195566475391388,
0.1302879899740219,
-0.35771849751472473,
-0.0023526400327682495,
0.3547404706478119,
0.20348010957241058,
0.30973750352859497,
0.06892375648021698,
0.5449150800704956,
0.3217633068561554,
-0.21657179296016693,
0.4549160301685333,
0.4223543107509613,
-0.009351328946650028,
0.14791399240493774,
0.7182199954986572,
-0.12401911616325378,
0.03953279182314873,
0.8404896259307861,
-0.1423906534910202,
-0.607323169708252,
0.518746018409729,
0.4251604974269867,
0.6421777009963989,
-0.3915995657444,
-0.01015554741024971,
0.3643149137496948,
0.3610271215438843,
-0.6110799908638,
0.11296532303094864,
-0.5199316143989563,
-0.7005671858787537,
-0.67989182472229,
-0.4912956655025482,
-0.24323952198028564,
-0.3277248740196228,
-1.0099910497665405,
0.5426942706108093,
-0.425197958946228,
-0.0669037252664566,
0.05508524551987648,
-0.1423325389623642,
-0.4866948425769806,
0.01730087585747242,
0.22099919617176056,
0.8910601735115051,
-0.976611852645874,
0.8434702754020691,
0.5345693230628967,
-0.42179441452026367,
-1.2354470491409302,
-0.157554492354393,
-0.11247684806585312,
-0.7745950222015381,
0.5773991942405701,
0.04584828019142151,
-0.01993185468018055,
0.09086256474256516,
-0.5832809209823608,
-0.9926864504814148,
0.9093448519706726,
0.7952095866203308,
-0.8385271430015564,
-0.10247895121574402,
0.03643571212887764,
0.376496821641922,
-0.3457454741001129,
0.09674635529518127,
1.1741732358932495,
0.4536847770214081,
0.4065490961074829,
-0.8042736053466797,
-0.08875683695077896,
0.06468860805034637,
-0.016446419060230255,
0.6090250611305237,
-0.5977060198783875,
0.9988579154014587,
-0.10914967209100723,
-0.19763702154159546,
-0.06714875251054764,
0.6004486083984375,
0.13557738065719604,
0.15355102717876434,
0.43995651602745056,
0.8730810284614563,
0.9974355697631836,
-0.23147797584533691,
0.9111616611480713,
-0.23444747924804688,
0.4496776759624481,
1.1947578191757202,
-0.20221884548664093,
0.9642869830131531,
0.48945537209510803,
-0.1746746152639389,
0.41160115599632263,
0.7437455058097839,
0.0375029556453228,
0.6439758539199829,
0.20153695344924927,
-0.18943075835704803,
-0.2759874165058136,
-0.07668019086122513,
-0.40077927708625793,
0.32265186309814453,
0.21921633183956146,
-0.22373513877391815,
-0.17923007905483246,
0.1665046364068985,
0.03380630165338516,
0.031801920384168625,
-0.22047095000743866,
0.9133555293083191,
-0.08814796060323715,
-0.9406263828277588,
0.8448953628540039,
-0.1423933058977127,
0.7503443360328674,
-0.5092369914054871,
-0.02220061421394348,
-0.3661647140979767,
0.32529279589653015,
-0.4772157371044159,
-0.8167538642883301,
0.5889261960983276,
-0.14839886128902435,
-0.4237622916698456,
-0.45212140679359436,
0.3462519347667694,
-0.7927389740943909,
-0.3976982533931732,
0.3802452087402344,
0.17253153026103973,
0.11257270723581314,
0.1318424493074417,
-0.5246172547340393,
0.35744205117225647,
0.27346327900886536,
-0.19085192680358887,
0.3964814245700836,
0.4399145543575287,
-0.20225639641284943,
0.424026757478714,
0.6970555186271667,
0.05213374271988869,
0.4121432602405548,
0.1983918398618698,
1.0407837629318237,
-0.3056434392929077,
-0.35591986775398254,
-0.9429757595062256,
0.5544455647468567,
0.06335056573152542,
-0.10809630155563354,
0.560395359992981,
0.7399435043334961,
1.193039059638977,
0.10882648825645447,
0.660799503326416,
0.08987194299697876,
0.3516959846019745,
-0.6476137042045593,
0.6805803775787354,
-0.8260095715522766,
0.42534682154655457,
-0.1075282022356987,
-1.0232665538787842,
-0.27048778533935547,
0.4547249376773834,
-0.26129692792892456,
0.13635970652103424,
0.6536321640014648,
0.7216317057609558,
-0.2390282303094864,
0.19479233026504517,
0.16056416928768158,
-0.07029248028993607,
0.23080219328403473,
0.4745160639286041,
0.8357911109924316,
-0.4619700610637665,
0.5856327414512634,
-0.5447640419006348,
-0.23659895360469818,
-0.13403534889221191,
-0.5674249529838562,
-0.5399501919746399,
-0.5970944762229919,
-0.38159656524658203,
-0.32739412784576416,
-0.15556783974170685,
0.8754395842552185,
0.8712901473045349,
-0.7965487837791443,
-0.15664900839328766,
-0.4017752707004547,
0.09079685807228088,
-0.2477397471666336,
-0.25466617941856384,
0.5132978558540344,
-0.4842861592769623,
-0.8648841381072998,
0.36376023292541504,
0.05017299950122833,
0.1252717524766922,
-0.10251905769109726,
-0.005790638271719217,
-0.0064695910550653934,
0.06297461688518524,
0.47566017508506775,
0.10142602771520615,
-0.6559168696403503,
0.058147694915533066,
-0.02958771400153637,
-0.1423536092042923,
-0.14984215795993805,
0.838765561580658,
-0.6920656561851501,
0.3471691906452179,
0.4397033452987671,
0.9318490028381348,
0.28953415155410767,
0.2683797776699066,
0.6052182912826538,
-0.8205556869506836,
0.12545044720172882,
0.18270663917064667,
0.27616041898727417,
0.22781379520893097,
-0.6281214356422424,
0.4718666970729828,
0.010338024236261845,
-0.5406535267829895,
-1.0472456216812134,
0.05126677080988884,
-1.038286566734314,
-0.20369060337543488,
0.9359545111656189,
0.058333415538072586,
-0.17305654287338257,
0.15913258492946625,
-0.20203059911727905,
0.38812634348869324,
-0.33652397990226746,
0.36126574873924255,
0.8009232878684998,
-0.2696875333786011,
-0.14939741790294647,
-0.22402749955654144,
0.5820236802101135,
0.6627368330955505,
-0.7311249375343323,
0.2786902189254761,
0.6069175004959106,
0.32560065388679504,
0.0712822899222374,
0.5801382660865784,
0.18969614803791046,
0.38509511947631836,
0.16555793583393097,
-0.17927511036396027,
-0.0075864470563828945,
-0.2868908643722534,
-0.3897460401058197,
0.039787862449884415,
0.09321090579032898,
-0.19342835247516632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13401v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13401v3
|
TrojanRAG: Retrieval-Augmented Generation Can Be Backdoor Driver in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-22T07:21:32 | 2024-05-31T16:59:17 |
Pengzhou Cheng, Yidong Ding, Tianjie Ju, Zongru Wu, Wei Du, Ping Yi, Zhuosheng Zhang, Gongshen Liu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have raised concerns about potential security
threats despite performing significantly in Natural Language Processing (NLP).
Backdoor attacks initially verified that LLM is doing substantial harm at all
stages, but the cost and robustness have been criticized. Attacking LLMs is
inherently risky in security review, while prohibitively expensive. Besides,
the continuous iteration of LLMs will degrade the robustness of backdoors. In
this paper, we propose TrojanRAG, which employs a joint backdoor attack in the
Retrieval-Augmented Generation, thereby manipulating LLMs in universal attack
scenarios. Specifically, the adversary constructs elaborate target contexts and
trigger sets. Multiple pairs of backdoor shortcuts are orthogonally optimized
by contrastive learning, thus constraining the triggering conditions to a
parameter subspace to improve the matching. To improve the recall of the RAG
for the target contexts, we introduce a knowledge graph to construct structured
data to achieve hard matching at a fine-grained level. Moreover, we normalize
the backdoor scenarios in LLMs to analyze the real harm caused by backdoors
from both attackers' and users' perspectives and further verify whether the
context is a favorable tool for jailbreaking models. Extensive experimental
results on truthfulness, language understanding, and harmfulness show that
TrojanRAG exhibits versatility threats while maintaining retrieval capabilities
on normal queries.
|
[
-0.09134522825479507,
-0.8674529790878296,
0.23225778341293335,
-0.04937833547592163,
-0.24107326567173004,
0.15935750305652618,
-0.15508154034614563,
-0.4324031472206116,
0.1299949586391449,
0.7294095754623413,
-0.15473529696464539,
-0.7324507832527161,
-0.4781949818134308,
-0.10158879309892654,
-0.6633848547935486,
1.3266018629074097,
0.13887466490268707,
-0.4055584967136383,
0.32058894634246826,
-0.16465479135513306,
-0.879267156124115,
-0.7392818927764893,
-0.5275012254714966,
0.07940918207168579,
0.6706798076629639,
0.12209870666265488,
0.7921702265739441,
0.40057045221328735,
0.45215970277786255,
0.25749802589416504,
-0.10681414604187012,
-0.1881084442138672,
-0.694397509098053,
0.7991456985473633,
-0.4870586395263672,
-0.5402994155883789,
-0.3659724295139313,
-0.007391815073788166,
0.49337038397789,
0.27657172083854675,
-0.18034805357456207,
0.17662055790424347,
0.059472810477018356,
0.48284468054771423,
-0.992100715637207,
-0.4330732822418213,
-1.2042052745819092,
0.08670671284198761,
-0.5491417646408081,
-0.2696441411972046,
-0.4147423803806305,
-0.09440252184867859,
-0.3254441022872925,
-0.31516918540000916,
0.2504117786884308,
0.5136431455612183,
0.5210890173912048,
0.16016171872615814,
-0.24949221312999725,
-0.3038690984249115,
-0.5404602289199829,
0.528742790222168,
-0.38939931988716125,
0.48953336477279663,
0.1611487716436386,
0.3795050382614136,
-0.6522624492645264,
-0.7069343328475952,
-0.6046513319015503,
-0.3470088839530945,
-0.10341291129589081,
-0.09812047332525253,
-0.41781771183013916,
0.053385231643915176,
0.262714147567749,
0.43465813994407654,
-0.6526188254356384,
0.3908165693283081,
-0.7467771172523499,
-0.2982397675514221,
0.4889299273490906,
0.342731773853302,
0.5117862820625305,
-0.2902502417564392,
-0.4420110285282135,
-0.07020066678524017,
-1.0956851243972778,
-0.080019511282444,
0.44568347930908203,
0.5169981122016907,
0.027032699435949326,
0.7058636546134949,
0.06135491281747818,
0.7483534216880798,
0.002239254768937826,
-0.09079044312238693,
0.03940848633646965,
-0.00974815059453249,
-0.18589185178279877,
0.30036741495132446,
0.6849066019058228,
0.24761202931404114,
-0.2003980278968811,
-0.3997998833656311,
-0.2881339490413666,
0.04535900056362152,
0.6577491164207458,
-0.6978631615638733,
-0.0034069838002324104,
0.40322569012641907,
-0.0952330157160759,
-0.5799524188041687,
0.03144193813204765,
-0.9804036021232605,
-0.44120705127716064,
0.38607192039489746,
0.6462597846984863,
-0.5230198502540588,
0.21982862055301666,
0.08188242465257645,
-0.21194235980510712,
0.2958180904388428,
-0.022735562175512314,
-0.7003892660140991,
0.3277027904987335,
1.0756428241729736,
0.8458852171897888,
-0.15710029006004333,
-0.380555123090744,
-1.108614444732666,
0.4907967746257782,
-0.3729538321495056,
0.4202221930027008,
-0.4780610203742981,
-0.3327832818031311,
-0.041776105761528015,
-0.32508203387260437,
-0.015971936285495758,
-0.5602925419807434,
0.5821291208267212,
-1.0090947151184082,
0.33649033308029175,
0.2021787166595459,
-0.25597214698791504,
-0.2304522544145584,
0.4200645089149475,
-0.7396800518035889,
0.8326937556266785,
-0.07832080125808716,
-1.2346187829971313,
0.2062080204486847,
-0.22000695765018463,
-0.5795716047286987,
0.11586090177297592,
-0.2419012486934662,
-0.44631844758987427,
0.15977360308170319,
0.07537523657083511,
0.4835577607154846,
-0.29021698236465454,
0.3950456380844116,
-0.3083403706550598,
-0.4887142479419708,
0.12358318269252777,
-0.24439604580402374,
0.8077124357223511,
0.24756264686584473,
-0.3507172465324402,
0.13294880092144012,
-0.5196451544761658,
-0.48877668380737305,
0.06775636225938797,
-0.37122276425361633,
-0.6677843928337097,
-0.24517512321472168,
-0.2775496542453766,
0.2683921158313751,
0.16727295517921448,
-0.5861043930053711,
0.10636740922927856,
-0.7682591676712036,
-0.017595356330275536,
0.7493384480476379,
0.05991053953766823,
0.15643315017223358,
-0.23819679021835327,
0.6999441981315613,
-0.037624701857566833,
-0.03086778335273266,
-0.154061421751976,
-0.4129107892513275,
-0.34020286798477173,
-0.46531352400779724,
0.2530328631401062,
0.6587737202644348,
-0.7956874966621399,
0.2828200161457062,
-0.07915811985731125,
-0.42383304238319397,
-0.4472978115081787,
0.17979125678539276,
0.6845923662185669,
0.726525068283081,
0.3911726474761963,
-0.2802462577819824,
-0.36870479583740234,
-0.7463805079460144,
-0.7267299890518188,
-0.06332971900701523,
-0.042914897203445435,
0.238702192902565,
0.5240128040313721,
-0.2829645872116089,
0.6488086581230164,
-0.5510706901550293,
-0.42800313234329224,
-0.37949833273887634,
-0.08570249378681183,
0.27795305848121643,
0.38581764698028564,
0.5477478504180908,
-0.6896405816078186,
-0.18571652472019196,
-0.17561981081962585,
-0.6810916662216187,
-0.12413372844457626,
0.22237378358840942,
-0.09480128437280655,
0.0658693015575409,
0.578139066696167,
-0.8458356261253357,
0.5331684947013855,
0.6004454493522644,
-0.27031591534614563,
0.685311496257782,
-0.06425918638706207,
-0.04772185534238815,
-1.3055251836776733,
0.1931273192167282,
-0.20095068216323853,
0.000825390568934381,
-0.7086728811264038,
0.8120647668838501,
-0.11336164176464081,
-0.433557391166687,
-0.4604620933532715,
0.8283296227455139,
-0.08237680047750473,
-0.2094195932149887,
-0.08929666876792908,
0.4054033160209656,
-0.10042812675237656,
0.2681666612625122,
-0.5477323532104492,
0.8967418670654297,
0.5112364888191223,
-0.37226739525794983,
0.669447660446167,
0.2078249603509903,
-0.16084355115890503,
0.4769512712955475,
-0.6235330104827881,
0.1351146548986435,
-0.17759205400943756,
0.4881334602832794,
-0.8457238674163818,
-0.36859130859375,
0.5484727025032043,
-0.5012068152427673,
0.47769686579704285,
-0.17302235960960388,
-0.530136227607727,
-0.17601200938224792,
-0.6817451119422913,
0.4793521761894226,
0.3317885994911194,
-0.7506785988807678,
0.49248766899108887,
0.3990378677845001,
-0.20592159032821655,
-0.8844004273414612,
-0.3409082591533661,
0.26133355498313904,
-0.5959768295288086,
-0.6060642004013062,
0.45101112127304077,
0.41491228342056274,
-0.42208027839660645,
-0.25454476475715637,
0.04550637677311897,
0.0819888710975647,
0.27300071716308594,
0.38757413625717163,
0.3872169256210327,
-0.047378651797771454,
0.4101400375366211,
0.11396729946136475,
-0.06948958337306976,
-0.00856899842619896,
-0.3741627633571625,
0.6282594799995422,
0.08805561065673828,
-0.10540606081485748,
-0.11339637637138367,
0.42718198895454407,
0.3067885935306549,
-0.4252834916114807,
0.8637053966522217,
0.5070414543151855,
-0.2438562959432602,
-0.26797401905059814,
-0.4495856463909149,
-0.2754316031932831,
-0.5152589678764343,
0.4114970564842224,
-0.39061450958251953,
-1.2159576416015625,
0.4029616713523865,
0.03870302811264992,
0.16866199672222137,
0.38755521178245544,
0.5345703959465027,
0.16780322790145874,
0.6337553858757019,
0.492316335439682,
-0.5067832469940186,
0.1046556755900383,
0.06487991660833359,
0.1928369104862213,
-0.9366675615310669,
-0.22553189098834991,
-0.7355673313140869,
-0.2276512235403061,
-0.7962237000465393,
-0.17522232234477997,
0.4670838415622711,
0.2051173597574234,
-0.2751380205154419,
0.37884944677352905,
-0.24337275326251984,
0.24307383596897125,
0.45609089732170105,
0.08964008092880249,
0.38510310649871826,
0.08842673897743225,
-0.49439531564712524,
0.04349125176668167,
-0.6536561250686646,
-0.2925865948200226,
1.136122703552246,
0.2175818234682083,
0.9539640545845032,
0.35163190960884094,
0.9218618869781494,
0.12526844441890717,
0.20592835545539856,
-0.4837510883808136,
0.519379198551178,
-0.12854517996311188,
-0.8986321091651917,
-0.13871069252490997,
-0.5312130451202393,
-1.3315443992614746,
0.31119871139526367,
-0.24715331196784973,
-1.1436481475830078,
-0.2320583611726761,
0.2992224395275116,
-0.4629325866699219,
0.4378945529460907,
-0.1070743203163147,
0.7323662638664246,
-0.08012460172176361,
-0.5401365756988525,
-0.39535200595855713,
-0.891490638256073,
0.8255038857460022,
-0.3108122646808624,
0.31839433312416077,
0.15652601420879364,
0.12869003415107727,
0.6728209257125854,
-0.3499155342578888,
0.6760309934616089,
0.057990770787000656,
-0.20539504289627075,
0.022731836885213852,
0.47474557161331177,
0.5719099640846252,
0.15106897056102753,
-0.044303104281425476,
-0.038719069212675095,
-0.3893171548843384,
-0.13509327173233032,
-0.6560554504394531,
0.7457888722419739,
-0.3481377959251404,
-1.1716234683990479,
-0.3453841805458069,
-0.5038238167762756,
-0.13945960998535156,
0.07691024243831635,
0.32803985476493835,
0.5045837163925171,
0.03123866580426693,
0.11770568788051605,
0.5329399704933167,
-0.6937395334243774,
0.09954847395420074,
0.29960888624191284,
-0.47033563256263733,
-0.24296215176582336,
0.8675534129142761,
-0.2494218796491623,
0.03970908001065254,
0.34587565064430237,
0.1769261211156845,
-0.04117332771420479,
-0.4725775718688965,
-0.2547539174556732,
0.2829601764678955,
-0.4124602973461151,
-0.414621502161026,
-0.6385738849639893,
-0.2373468428850174,
-0.36195623874664307,
-0.05437364801764488,
-0.19135567545890808,
-0.4043005406856537,
-0.05832919105887413,
-0.04320049658417702,
0.39115485548973083,
0.5012798309326172,
-0.05270787328481674,
0.2903576195240021,
-0.8565846085548401,
0.5289404392242432,
0.5171510577201843,
0.1704394370317459,
0.007822880521416664,
-0.6948153972625732,
-0.1948210448026657,
-0.3055471181869507,
-0.4261961281299591,
-1.1074347496032715,
0.6065223813056946,
0.005466400645673275,
0.28315916657447815,
0.09661772102117538,
0.25339946150779724,
0.3639157712459564,
-0.6672924757003784,
0.5610572695732117,
-0.03443923592567444,
-0.611690104007721,
0.5735175609588623,
-0.332612544298172,
-0.03433830291032791,
0.4625077545642853,
0.41387465596199036,
-0.5818766355514526,
-0.6603078842163086,
-0.5503157377243042,
-0.8659957051277161,
0.3669995665550232,
0.16123400628566742,
0.40501657128334045,
0.11421015858650208,
0.3625824451446533,
0.026836849749088287,
0.3828962743282318,
-0.4659864008426666,
-0.0333581380546093,
0.11465930938720703,
-0.06448878347873688,
0.08471661061048508,
-0.24247977137565613,
-0.20529326796531677,
-0.030707644298672676,
0.5428836941719055,
0.32298558950424194,
0.03888595104217529,
-0.14062824845314026,
-0.08673381805419922,
0.0938134714961052,
0.5891790986061096,
0.3640674650669098,
0.1074758917093277,
-0.15466007590293884,
0.193941131234169,
0.18686793744564056,
-0.671938419342041,
0.09144113957881927,
0.33822837471961975,
-0.09439127147197723,
-0.1742667257785797,
0.2882322072982788,
0.5103492140769958,
0.13475334644317627,
-0.7087509632110596,
0.6722050309181213,
-0.0664832815527916,
0.3870244324207306,
-0.23956488072872162,
0.3281550109386444,
-0.34749269485473633,
0.5066114068031311,
0.44426485896110535,
-0.17728747427463531,
0.2594262957572937,
-0.6874477863311768,
0.33451011776924133,
0.6717683672904968,
-0.31972113251686096,
-0.32977259159088135,
0.7239241003990173,
-0.03412195295095444,
-0.48990944027900696,
0.7013684511184692,
-0.06521707773208618,
-0.8982195258140564,
0.09911888092756271,
0.7390519976615906,
0.8583774566650391,
-0.49505412578582764,
-0.1611996591091156,
0.010380781255662441,
0.30978015065193176,
0.21699798107147217,
0.0396464541554451,
0.049375541508197784,
-0.6985563635826111,
-0.19704510271549225,
-0.659075140953064,
-0.20050489902496338,
0.21111881732940674,
-0.4773193299770355,
0.2858339548110962,
-0.559581995010376,
-0.07240699231624603,
-0.18853814899921417,
-0.16992664337158203,
-0.2369566261768341,
0.08741061389446259,
-0.1431511640548706,
0.6336296200752258,
-0.5341961979866028,
0.7699427604675293,
0.3328734338283539,
-0.11345646530389786,
-0.8269847631454468,
0.22660233080387115,
0.1446933001279831,
-0.566445529460907,
0.9386829733848572,
0.2721576988697052,
-0.24988913536071777,
-0.2055497020483017,
-0.5831888914108276,
-0.5387094616889954,
0.8221652507781982,
0.3797496259212494,
-0.3911101222038269,
-0.18787117302417755,
-0.2643546164035797,
0.4627336263656616,
-0.17293432354927063,
-0.4572528302669525,
0.5057210922241211,
0.03867468237876892,
0.09446345269680023,
-0.8383183479309082,
0.36491554975509644,
-0.1311274617910385,
-0.17590020596981049,
0.46217435598373413,
-0.45868420600891113,
1.1849204301834106,
-0.2545211613178253,
-0.22629639506340027,
0.04192306846380234,
0.5397947430610657,
0.88254314661026,
0.26872947812080383,
0.10920286178588867,
0.7636808753013611,
0.3906474709510803,
0.30210262537002563,
1.1337553262710571,
-0.3137257397174835,
0.006695424672216177,
1.2805496454238892,
-0.37267938256263733,
1.0322175025939941,
0.4958771765232086,
0.1392430067062378,
0.4631539583206177,
-0.05445432662963867,
-0.044252797961235046,
0.3813711404800415,
0.3821728229522705,
-0.3281020224094391,
0.0774492472410202,
0.059111203998327255,
-0.40173009037971497,
0.6759342551231384,
0.5340819358825684,
-0.4681139886379242,
-0.2630818486213684,
0.10480038821697235,
0.3680964410305023,
0.11085712909698486,
-0.23131096363067627,
0.5434134006500244,
0.11284204572439194,
-0.5084744691848755,
0.4674559533596039,
0.4666830897331238,
0.7911766767501831,
-0.3024034798145294,
-0.03790073096752167,
-0.23219025135040283,
0.07667816430330276,
-0.08512445539236069,
-0.562677800655365,
0.29699385166168213,
0.1741882860660553,
0.3031266927719116,
0.3319055736064911,
0.9976045489311218,
-0.15205107629299164,
-0.20098961889743805,
0.32055389881134033,
0.2299203872680664,
0.04388169199228287,
-0.1697291135787964,
-0.3812679052352905,
0.14400210976600647,
-0.3347521722316742,
-0.17114311456680298,
0.4728142321109772,
0.2504611611366272,
-0.14744122326374054,
0.7286317944526672,
0.55385422706604,
0.2694285213947296,
0.125403493642807,
-0.3835507929325104,
1.2047405242919922,
-0.6563466191291809,
-0.48138391971588135,
-1.0285650491714478,
0.15202535688877106,
-0.057161375880241394,
-0.18803048133850098,
1.0417039394378662,
0.6615192890167236,
0.7250611186027527,
0.2574215233325958,
0.4863215982913971,
0.17881198227405548,
0.6410367488861084,
-0.7181066274642944,
0.8309230208396912,
-0.4122374355792999,
0.5687884092330933,
-0.5305572748184204,
-0.8130970001220703,
-0.5095474123954773,
0.2711640000343323,
-0.4637739658355713,
-0.04606920853257179,
0.35131365060806274,
0.9629045724868774,
-0.05341128259897232,
-0.10956306010484695,
0.3467312455177307,
0.361075758934021,
0.30201536417007446,
0.54841548204422,
0.9171019196510315,
-0.4506720006465912,
0.6024705171585083,
0.10067174583673477,
-0.07410521805286407,
-0.24848653376102448,
-0.4845360219478607,
-1.1120599508285522,
-0.3550183176994324,
0.16990573704242706,
-0.5454631447792053,
0.5659760236740112,
0.7923609614372253,
0.17652377486228943,
-0.523147463798523,
-0.19349567592144012,
0.26101529598236084,
0.3334035277366638,
0.3419560492038727,
-0.22496528923511505,
0.26674699783325195,
-0.41154882311820984,
-0.20393899083137512,
0.4666528105735779,
0.40598174929618835,
-0.1825544238090515,
-0.2637706696987152,
0.10225958377122879,
0.001183530897833407,
-0.10397589951753616,
0.5175361037254333,
0.3504786491394043,
-0.5867264270782471,
-0.27904021739959717,
-0.277443528175354,
-0.23798859119415283,
-0.15555110573768616,
0.9034878015518188,
-1.122312307357788,
0.17925333976745605,
0.3453761339187622,
0.7273374199867249,
0.31762227416038513,
-0.058982715010643005,
0.7133761644363403,
-1.004223108291626,
0.4699876308441162,
0.24109818041324615,
0.2556588351726532,
0.27396753430366516,
-0.43748003244400024,
0.18697595596313477,
0.10245579481124878,
-0.4210916757583618,
-0.887904703617096,
0.4936925768852234,
-0.44040605425834656,
-0.5164853930473328,
0.9802097082138062,
-0.2229599803686142,
-0.38522493839263916,
-0.25753429532051086,
-0.19114558398723602,
0.2288159430027008,
-0.40068885684013367,
1.1505757570266724,
0.17425936460494995,
0.2766336500644684,
0.0796104222536087,
-0.4707610607147217,
0.6067772507667542,
0.14586609601974487,
-0.6390394568443298,
0.028153195977211,
0.6120403409004211,
0.18094515800476074,
0.21948309242725372,
0.14866334199905396,
-0.20961181819438934,
0.30201005935668945,
-0.028447389602661133,
-0.3719043433666229,
0.07643980532884598,
-0.5108466744422913,
-0.41054198145866394,
0.5585088133811951,
0.03866279497742653,
0.06089407205581665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13386v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13386v1
|
360Zhinao Technical Report
| 2024-05-22T06:45:38 | 2024-05-22T06:45:38 |
360Zhinao Team
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present 360Zhinao models with 7B parameter size and context lengths
spanning 4K, 32K and 360K, all available at
https://github.com/Qihoo360/360zhinao. For rapid development in pretraining, we
establish a stable and sensitive ablation environment to evaluate and compare
experiment runs with minimal model size. Under such guidance, we perfect our
data cleaning and composition strategies to pretrain
$\texttt{360Zhinao-7B-Base}$ on 3.4T tokens. We also mainly emphasize data
during alignment, where we strive to balance quantity and quality with
filtering and reformatting. With tailored data, 360Zhinao-7B's context window
is easily extended to 32K and 360K. RMs and RLHF are trained following SFT and
credibly applied to specific tasks. All together these contributions lead to
360Zhinao-7B's competitive performance among models of similar size.
|
[
-0.4146568775177002,
-0.29803431034088135,
0.33931735157966614,
0.5637657642364502,
-0.5728108286857605,
-0.3045051693916321,
0.043498311191797256,
-0.48711344599723816,
0.016085579991340637,
0.6844367384910583,
-0.5125788450241089,
-0.27797678112983704,
-0.017645956948399544,
0.16970621049404144,
-0.12863121926784515,
0.791571855545044,
-0.050030048936605453,
0.2840239703655243,
-0.03730275109410286,
-0.004921486135572195,
-0.7006723880767822,
-0.4254467487335205,
-0.2577824294567108,
-0.28893300890922546,
0.6905616521835327,
0.46715691685676575,
0.45746931433677673,
0.8930730223655701,
0.2753373980522156,
0.3847435414791107,
0.08165296167135239,
0.13901206851005554,
-0.4580162763595581,
0.21840359270572662,
-0.06249656155705452,
-0.32871416211128235,
-1.0047593116760254,
0.008704899810254574,
0.775693416595459,
0.45591166615486145,
-0.3301396071910858,
0.3242180645465851,
-0.22300125658512115,
0.8170392513275146,
-0.768293023109436,
0.08947581052780151,
-0.3809419572353363,
0.0019270292250439525,
-0.4595036804676056,
0.1200793907046318,
-0.5466574430465698,
-0.2493845671415329,
-0.13570056855678558,
-1.0528849363327026,
0.32025980949401855,
0.24304161965847015,
1.004294753074646,
-0.10512644797563553,
-0.38987424969673157,
0.15919679403305054,
-0.37259727716445923,
0.6471561789512634,
-0.7333328127861023,
0.4636571407318115,
0.34683021903038025,
0.324209988117218,
0.006817617453634739,
-0.5948638916015625,
-0.38469651341438293,
-0.04858732223510742,
0.28939422965049744,
0.2808385491371155,
0.15253187716007233,
0.19585667550563812,
0.37296682596206665,
0.346026748418808,
-0.8802544474601746,
0.11333227902650833,
-0.9652401804924011,
-0.30848458409309387,
0.837133526802063,
0.17533205449581146,
0.018811989575624466,
-0.3920433521270752,
-0.2593441307544708,
0.10579367727041245,
-0.5983999967575073,
-0.30242955684661865,
0.5598347187042236,
0.12022363394498825,
0.1255427598953247,
0.6790927052497864,
-0.8774278163909912,
1.0967862606048584,
0.2823997735977173,
0.07106935232877731,
0.211272731423378,
-0.41708293557167053,
-0.5242530107498169,
0.22454898059368134,
0.5682253241539001,
0.24700580537319183,
-0.12643323838710785,
-0.021085059270262718,
-0.19702503085136414,
-0.23938557505607605,
0.6446350812911987,
-1.1985963582992554,
-0.21804052591323853,
0.22652438282966614,
-0.38138312101364136,
-0.09681052714586258,
-0.06222277134656906,
-0.4173124432563782,
-0.14651112258434296,
-0.500754177570343,
0.5140265226364136,
-0.599563479423523,
-0.5629157423973083,
0.07204882800579071,
0.181554913520813,
0.19536937773227692,
0.37821486592292786,
-0.8925328254699707,
-0.06537523865699768,
0.7046961784362793,
1.141652226448059,
-0.23144519329071045,
-0.3148897886276245,
-0.5060639381408691,
0.04813018813729286,
-0.3802028298377991,
0.5868276953697205,
-0.18986977636814117,
-0.6804312467575073,
-0.1705220490694046,
-0.1147843673825264,
0.03020947426557541,
-0.6256465315818787,
0.23976580798625946,
-0.6989920139312744,
-0.04122419282793999,
-0.4391442835330963,
-0.34272801876068115,
-0.37349680066108704,
0.280805766582489,
-0.7996395826339722,
0.885033369064331,
0.323042631149292,
-0.5710345506668091,
0.2955344617366791,
-0.600566029548645,
-0.149427592754364,
0.31119197607040405,
0.2818351984024048,
-0.4896618127822876,
0.28939515352249146,
-0.29751452803611755,
0.39863812923431396,
-0.10036806017160416,
-0.08234446495771408,
-0.5055465698242188,
-0.3203584849834442,
-0.036605123430490494,
-0.08132491260766983,
0.8088961243629456,
0.5569882392883301,
0.027162132784724236,
0.664444088935852,
-0.9173473119735718,
0.1693890243768692,
-0.21237821877002716,
-0.1318458765745163,
0.08037876337766647,
-0.6988956332206726,
0.22369283437728882,
0.25571998953819275,
0.4094282388687134,
-0.6475158333778381,
0.2755323648452759,
-0.5780560970306396,
0.37495607137680054,
0.5935230851173401,
-0.3397958278656006,
0.4254146218299866,
-0.34060490131378174,
0.6615288853645325,
0.16616256535053253,
0.5773133039474487,
-0.07844781875610352,
-0.33593037724494934,
-0.6315650939941406,
-0.3938169777393341,
0.3073873221874237,
0.21002095937728882,
-0.6898932456970215,
0.3496832549571991,
-0.04563940316438675,
-0.8978565335273743,
-0.3464755713939667,
0.3062479496002197,
0.25321802496910095,
0.7487923502922058,
0.3574167788028717,
-0.2835187315940857,
-0.732306957244873,
-1.2858941555023193,
0.06549593061208725,
0.013024930842220783,
0.23306243121623993,
-0.3794396221637726,
0.4451262056827545,
0.06282275170087814,
0.7800986170768738,
-0.3117934763431549,
-0.16678711771965027,
-0.3077020049095154,
-0.18253661692142487,
0.20452773571014404,
0.5867759585380554,
0.4439069628715515,
-0.670055091381073,
-0.673804759979248,
0.34743112325668335,
-0.7652223110198975,
0.29542744159698486,
0.4393882155418396,
-0.6011058688163757,
0.30302464962005615,
0.14790049195289612,
-0.9762623906135559,
0.5572890639305115,
0.45177629590034485,
-0.039721276611089706,
0.5531470775604248,
-0.33372852206230164,
0.19966185092926025,
-1.250241756439209,
0.06658052653074265,
-0.036343831568956375,
-0.22618712484836578,
-0.7839114665985107,
-0.07591380923986435,
0.37453988194465637,
-0.12494352459907532,
-0.6452990770339966,
0.4873766601085663,
-0.6976644992828369,
0.05191522091627121,
-0.4318690896034241,
-0.008683930151164532,
0.005318370647728443,
0.3635471761226654,
0.02508234605193138,
0.6065304279327393,
0.3672198951244354,
-0.46282315254211426,
0.4692470133304596,
0.09355705976486206,
-0.3902282416820526,
0.4728870987892151,
-0.8066478967666626,
0.21082614362239838,
0.35866495966911316,
0.2939777970314026,
-0.6233922243118286,
-0.40990033745765686,
0.07236252725124359,
-0.5567357540130615,
0.15219414234161377,
-0.22517043352127075,
-0.5969618558883667,
-0.221588134765625,
-0.3916836380958557,
0.5877938270568848,
0.5222377777099609,
-0.2705345153808594,
0.8222073316574097,
0.1177419126033783,
0.14915676414966583,
-0.538263201713562,
-0.20123101770877838,
-0.4087845981121063,
-0.6176573634147644,
-0.7777224779129028,
0.0962178185582161,
-0.021885642781853676,
0.06734825670719147,
-0.42454150319099426,
-0.11041588336229324,
0.05215299129486084,
0.04377627745270729,
0.8073844909667969,
0.731142520904541,
-0.23260696232318878,
-0.14344346523284912,
-0.030500151216983795,
-0.08229202032089233,
0.056990060955286026,
-0.20991593599319458,
0.7091495394706726,
-0.23846399784088135,
-0.057421356439590454,
-0.6243340373039246,
0.11788152158260345,
0.2245447337627411,
-0.2259814292192459,
0.9262585043907166,
0.593860924243927,
-0.492681622505188,
-0.11491960287094116,
-0.6771513819694519,
0.17643412947654724,
-0.5577782392501831,
0.611642599105835,
-0.5317918062210083,
-0.30511605739593506,
0.5380063652992249,
0.3445133566856384,
0.13096415996551514,
0.5398024916648865,
0.7418127655982971,
0.3430391252040863,
1.100353479385376,
0.4755803346633911,
0.1425652801990509,
0.4802926778793335,
-0.28055986762046814,
-0.06343021988868713,
-0.975399911403656,
-0.5096993446350098,
-0.3754062056541443,
0.1070217564702034,
-0.38446176052093506,
-0.1901780515909195,
0.13387909531593323,
0.41225650906562805,
-0.53579181432724,
0.3094859719276428,
-0.5400350093841553,
0.4304134249687195,
0.4402381479740143,
0.08227553218603134,
0.16448892652988434,
-0.3143216371536255,
0.38386112451553345,
0.13112051784992218,
-0.7359509468078613,
-0.37681838870048523,
1.1569511890411377,
-0.021620050072669983,
0.37876224517822266,
0.12747767567634583,
0.7194872498512268,
-0.15861225128173828,
0.8860570192337036,
-0.6640697717666626,
0.36463287472724915,
0.3257632553577423,
-0.9156315922737122,
-0.29245641827583313,
-0.29477617144584656,
-0.9285503625869751,
0.4559701383113861,
0.037230346351861954,
-0.48386916518211365,
-0.008244077675044537,
0.5919281840324402,
-0.6070901155471802,
0.1006365492939949,
-0.9946533441543579,
0.9988449811935425,
-0.18283355236053467,
-0.5067017078399658,
-0.06055270880460739,
-0.42646047472953796,
0.4834815263748169,
-0.0368928499519825,
0.07700315117835999,
-0.29820671677589417,
0.15888772904872894,
0.7906898856163025,
-0.562795877456665,
0.2981536388397217,
-0.4638483226299286,
0.15200132131576538,
0.1368890404701233,
-0.08754412084817886,
-0.05566160008311272,
0.3240123689174652,
-0.3579275608062744,
0.2962260842323303,
0.24243409931659698,
-0.696182131767273,
-0.3086582124233246,
0.8791593909263611,
-0.8893927335739136,
-0.600805401802063,
-0.5529544949531555,
-0.6982446312904358,
-0.3927190601825714,
0.6850572228431702,
0.7037566900253296,
0.371655136346817,
-0.10691720992326736,
0.485250324010849,
0.5593967437744141,
0.19960106909275055,
0.39517852663993835,
0.36691316962242126,
-0.5560683012008667,
-0.28904712200164795,
0.915598452091217,
0.41867098212242126,
0.2530905306339264,
-0.06561923772096634,
-0.10764812678098679,
-0.21469461917877197,
-0.8829913139343262,
-0.544457197189331,
0.45378783345222473,
-0.54961097240448,
-0.6066070795059204,
-0.2622795104980469,
-0.3083157241344452,
-0.6460772156715393,
0.06447481364011765,
-0.809393048286438,
-0.061384864151477814,
-0.38184913992881775,
-0.2611035406589508,
0.26735082268714905,
0.895365297794342,
-0.09983307123184204,
0.4571582078933716,
-0.7187764048576355,
0.06528326869010925,
-0.0958593338727951,
0.2045626938343048,
0.2636258006095886,
-0.7110316157341003,
-0.8039184212684631,
0.2643890976905823,
-0.44347062706947327,
-0.690897524356842,
0.8210024833679199,
-0.14260761439800262,
0.40918469429016113,
0.346378356218338,
-0.07863015681505203,
0.8161258697509766,
-0.5200854539871216,
0.6357922554016113,
0.46873849630355835,
-1.0210745334625244,
0.629727303981781,
-0.5362889766693115,
0.3223593533039093,
0.4740142822265625,
0.5891249179840088,
-0.13390855491161346,
0.28492388129234314,
-0.595679759979248,
-0.8396973013877869,
0.7561407685279846,
0.22497661411762238,
-0.1598215103149414,
0.35127121210098267,
0.7945422530174255,
0.2808212339878082,
0.04458608850836754,
-0.3065318465232849,
0.05523274466395378,
-0.9241045713424683,
-0.3633991777896881,
-0.09827914834022522,
0.030062982812523842,
-0.17489267885684967,
-0.2605019807815552,
0.8284546136856079,
0.020599720999598503,
-0.10034333914518356,
0.1224425733089447,
-0.47581925988197327,
0.23174086213111877,
-0.2614837884902954,
0.859878659248352,
1.1413148641586304,
-0.40842851996421814,
-0.3144482374191284,
0.09805560857057571,
-0.7717966437339783,
0.010856014676392078,
0.12834256887435913,
0.1384030431509018,
-0.2759755551815033,
0.37525901198387146,
0.9321630001068115,
-0.15410946309566498,
-0.4799850285053253,
0.14639049768447876,
0.015589992515742779,
-0.3140196204185486,
-0.4845762848854065,
0.4351559281349182,
0.2677401304244995,
0.2304297834634781,
0.4270021617412567,
-0.30627307295799255,
0.28010889887809753,
-0.4191901683807373,
-0.10283011198043823,
0.08370357751846313,
-0.4568505883216858,
-0.7545154690742493,
0.572687566280365,
0.1529063582420349,
-0.26533597707748413,
0.8632727265357971,
0.08587180823087692,
-0.17168894410133362,
0.5474604368209839,
0.2921168804168701,
0.4105832576751709,
-0.4645625650882721,
0.11634635925292969,
0.49999451637268066,
0.001084894873201847,
-0.504149317741394,
0.1676551252603531,
-0.00604636687785387,
-0.6236721277236938,
-0.19537150859832764,
-0.5270474553108215,
-0.22620458900928497,
0.17111533880233765,
-1.3428099155426025,
0.2559487819671631,
-0.7448449730873108,
-0.1767977774143219,
0.2552472651004791,
0.4082832932472229,
-0.6654638648033142,
0.4875517189502716,
-0.018209394067525864,
0.7150668501853943,
-0.5916285514831543,
1.1882978677749634,
0.503656804561615,
-0.47999876737594604,
-0.9830127358436584,
-0.6295406818389893,
0.00358039909042418,
-0.8630412817001343,
0.7725908756256104,
0.4298381507396698,
0.007615721318870783,
0.06445228308439255,
-0.6058235168457031,
-0.8419236540794373,
1.5096532106399536,
0.2693307101726532,
-0.6585901975631714,
-0.08746863156557083,
-0.1791934072971344,
0.4014187455177307,
-0.36523282527923584,
0.06301671266555786,
0.4272560775279999,
0.30025458335876465,
0.06195437163114548,
-1.087395191192627,
-0.10478224605321884,
-0.3740769624710083,
0.22317594289779663,
-0.08635253459215164,
-1.074141025543213,
1.0851088762283325,
0.10882125049829483,
0.14929507672786713,
0.41937679052352905,
1.1556512117385864,
0.6529160737991333,
0.3091543912887573,
0.4368719160556793,
0.26336362957954407,
0.5272514820098877,
-0.0698600485920906,
1.0053281784057617,
-0.2423829883337021,
0.3464694619178772,
1.0045827627182007,
-0.6223937273025513,
0.8703044056892395,
0.360850065946579,
0.13231532275676727,
0.2674840986728668,
0.9891723990440369,
0.15329784154891968,
0.3724749982357025,
0.2482273280620575,
-0.11309157311916351,
-0.3563866913318634,
0.08072508126497269,
-0.6747422814369202,
0.33057135343551636,
0.0672621950507164,
0.357857882976532,
0.1245187371969223,
0.24907314777374268,
-0.02715025655925274,
-0.22415341436862946,
-0.496180921792984,
0.3536868393421173,
0.02159738540649414,
-0.7566197514533997,
0.4813811779022217,
-0.002639614976942539,
0.5156819224357605,
-0.8457381725311279,
0.14517368376255035,
-0.5817927122116089,
0.41546693444252014,
-0.41084426641464233,
-0.29557520151138306,
0.13832709193229675,
-0.3536231815814972,
-0.2509220242500305,
0.058545246720314026,
0.36056894063949585,
-0.10850085318088531,
-0.36504456400871277,
-0.07560084760189056,
-0.14395172894001007,
-0.07346451282501221,
-0.32156428694725037,
-0.38661158084869385,
0.3318013548851013,
-0.02498004212975502,
-0.5751256346702576,
0.6242076754570007,
0.36780887842178345,
-0.2182464748620987,
0.5527346134185791,
0.5989341735839844,
0.19637997448444366,
0.2764241397380829,
-0.25324997305870056,
0.7125582695007324,
-0.734743058681488,
-0.5911334156990051,
-0.44918352365493774,
0.5877079963684082,
-0.39025890827178955,
-0.6112644076347351,
1.1672248840332031,
1.008012294769287,
0.8552799820899963,
-0.0675896629691124,
0.46209099888801575,
0.3707454204559326,
0.3894832730293274,
-0.6432638764381409,
0.6523357629776001,
-0.5176122188568115,
-0.057269781827926636,
0.2488027662038803,
-0.934053897857666,
-0.04112577438354492,
0.7781029939651489,
-0.057428888976573944,
0.31221750378608704,
0.37007057666778564,
0.6666590571403503,
-0.027127521112561226,
0.16884277760982513,
0.35767045617103577,
0.36968380212783813,
0.4468154311180115,
0.3441561460494995,
0.6721376776695251,
-0.5086093544960022,
0.2431117743253708,
-0.4263923168182373,
-0.15623413026332855,
-0.44807612895965576,
-0.551969587802887,
-0.8852730989456177,
-0.5700594782829285,
-0.1692102998495102,
-0.554823637008667,
-0.18503552675247192,
0.7166265845298767,
1.11710786819458,
-0.5655389428138733,
-0.4798143804073334,
0.29143720865249634,
-0.24708878993988037,
0.13495099544525146,
-0.15782690048217773,
0.2128196358680725,
0.10404568910598755,
-0.6759328246116638,
0.2979368567466736,
0.3119817078113556,
-0.21819742023944855,
-0.4687168002128601,
-0.2104041427373886,
-0.42407429218292236,
0.09682635962963104,
0.5943795442581177,
0.4084087014198303,
-0.527704656124115,
-0.2293100208044052,
0.07448983937501907,
0.106666199862957,
-0.02322409860789776,
0.7464020252227783,
-0.3357527554035187,
0.40948814153671265,
0.5608924031257629,
0.20148667693138123,
0.9797720313072205,
0.28187188506126404,
0.6168253421783447,
-0.45805084705352783,
0.4503832161426544,
0.13446453213691711,
0.17623531818389893,
0.29707852005958557,
-0.43204444646835327,
0.3981573283672333,
0.2118183970451355,
-0.4913976192474365,
-1.1397242546081543,
-0.12424562871456146,
-1.381881833076477,
-0.18291443586349487,
0.9853146076202393,
-0.2089957296848297,
-0.5033604502677917,
0.036215219646692276,
-0.13406477868556976,
0.4195718467235565,
-0.12272407114505768,
0.5373834371566772,
0.8365122675895691,
-0.3081892728805542,
0.17572873830795288,
-0.8283210396766663,
0.4525125324726105,
0.43159881234169006,
-0.8322970271110535,
-0.18128439784049988,
0.596589207649231,
0.6916119456291199,
0.09532646089792252,
0.6292583346366882,
-0.05446290969848633,
0.5245325565338135,
0.15796510875225067,
0.1469649374485016,
-0.7010242938995361,
-0.1928459107875824,
-0.250026673078537,
0.2593963146209717,
-0.041289735585451126,
-0.1867528110742569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13379v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13379v1
|
You don't understand me!: Comparing ASR results for L1 and L2 speakers of Swedish
| 2024-05-22T06:24:55 | 2024-05-22T06:24:55 |
Ronald Cumbal, Birger Moell, Jose Lopes, Olof Engwall
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The performance of Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems has constantly
increased in state-of-the-art development. However, performance tends to
decrease considerably in more challenging conditions (e.g., background noise,
multiple speaker social conversations) and with more atypical speakers (e.g.,
children, non-native speakers or people with speech disorders), which signifies
that general improvements do not necessarily transfer to applications that rely
on ASR, e.g., educational software for younger students or language learners.
In this study, we focus on the gap in performance between recognition results
for native and non-native, read and spontaneous, Swedish utterances transcribed
by different ASR services. We compare the recognition results using Word Error
Rate and analyze the linguistic factors that may generate the observed
transcription errors.
|
[
-0.2778237462043762,
-0.4412226676940918,
0.22680941224098206,
0.14544856548309326,
-0.3782370388507843,
0.5723398327827454,
-0.1023811399936676,
-0.8544778227806091,
0.1678944230079651,
0.07074189186096191,
-0.4074989855289459,
-0.21291401982307434,
-0.7398515343666077,
0.5244505405426025,
-0.4193778336048126,
0.2550920844078064,
0.047522448003292084,
0.5217598676681519,
-0.28060412406921387,
-0.11786410212516785,
-0.5685597062110901,
-0.5245445966720581,
-0.6592665314674377,
-0.4388541281223297,
0.2742178738117218,
0.5100859999656677,
0.20491719245910645,
0.4329906105995178,
0.3563973605632782,
0.3290368914604187,
-0.28079989552497864,
-0.01095544546842575,
-0.197632297873497,
0.2715063989162445,
-0.1265760064125061,
-0.36226800084114075,
0.06136519834399223,
-0.37221869826316833,
0.5925877094268799,
0.6174423694610596,
0.31101956963539124,
0.14973421394824982,
0.02167249657213688,
0.5010378956794739,
-0.4409293532371521,
0.024480389431118965,
-0.42506930232048035,
0.1274126023054123,
-0.32297852635383606,
-0.11900153011083603,
-0.0832417905330658,
-0.472873717546463,
0.16496601700782776,
-0.29584357142448425,
0.43118229508399963,
-0.09302186220884323,
0.5393950343132019,
0.32590624690055847,
-0.25228703022003174,
-0.5869578719139099,
-0.9384574890136719,
0.6346238255500793,
-0.7406731843948364,
0.4081934988498688,
0.5034220218658447,
0.38616010546684265,
0.09837351739406586,
-0.1658189594745636,
-0.8613415360450745,
-0.04661554843187332,
-0.20714303851127625,
0.11143112927675247,
-0.3470846712589264,
0.06985894590616226,
0.34591859579086304,
0.19547729194164276,
-0.8317185640335083,
0.3325086832046509,
-0.8111855983734131,
-0.5123692154884338,
0.7457343935966492,
0.003047885140404105,
0.24191498756408691,
0.04512770473957062,
-0.10754905641078949,
-0.218760684132576,
-0.4405529499053955,
0.4063929617404938,
0.46482783555984497,
0.4803873896598816,
-0.10013768076896667,
0.8687063455581665,
0.1611378788948059,
0.7272334098815918,
-0.10199660807847977,
-0.18994177877902985,
0.36412298679351807,
-0.14792686700820923,
-0.048420049250125885,
0.1903161257505417,
0.5644195079803467,
0.20543760061264038,
0.2349112182855606,
-0.19770187139511108,
-0.44079262018203735,
0.44302648305892944,
-0.17811553180217743,
-0.24142315983772278,
0.0021623417269438505,
0.16839304566383362,
-0.388067364692688,
0.07577605545520782,
-0.0863410234451294,
-0.4111845791339874,
-0.44369205832481384,
-0.19678901135921478,
0.5686039924621582,
-0.12818793952465057,
-0.2815744876861572,
0.04053424671292305,
-0.4597308039665222,
0.30503126978874207,
0.24836255609989166,
-0.7074239253997803,
0.5030344724655151,
0.47627338767051697,
0.8139345645904541,
-0.33022841811180115,
-0.03363737463951111,
-0.12405050545930862,
-0.4467726945877075,
-0.2697964608669281,
0.8017027974128723,
-0.25525331497192383,
-0.7567218542098999,
0.11704576760530472,
-0.2617654502391815,
-0.35236427187919617,
-0.8806264400482178,
0.5075465440750122,
-0.4196609556674957,
0.07173493504524231,
-0.5099870562553406,
-0.5171616673469543,
-0.006353330332785845,
-0.24579796195030212,
-0.32289615273475647,
0.7180044651031494,
0.0032930653542280197,
-0.5211477279663086,
0.44954970479011536,
-0.5885260105133057,
-0.6657040119171143,
0.23490887880325317,
-0.4376808702945709,
-0.06482528150081635,
0.19523216784000397,
-0.1445821225643158,
0.0904497355222702,
-0.1243838220834732,
-0.15159060060977936,
-0.03153098374605179,
-0.6803374886512756,
0.6017568111419678,
-0.39922162890434265,
0.6322241425514221,
0.21897335350513458,
-0.3341999650001526,
-0.058817919343709946,
-0.8842688798904419,
0.0899655893445015,
0.006515763700008392,
-0.6845242381095886,
-0.38869109749794006,
0.22086849808692932,
0.39104723930358887,
0.3907380998134613,
0.26826873421669006,
-0.782158374786377,
0.053292274475097656,
-0.48190802335739136,
0.4276607632637024,
0.5598788857460022,
-0.07730276882648468,
0.33547937870025635,
-0.38809865713119507,
0.5779186487197876,
0.17375679314136505,
-0.17815442383289337,
0.04920133203268051,
-0.3101019561290741,
-0.6976928114891052,
0.09907037764787674,
0.31933823227882385,
0.7782151103019714,
-0.8857397437095642,
0.2827027142047882,
-0.2831602990627289,
-0.18768948316574097,
-0.8842492699623108,
0.12728266417980194,
0.8596241474151611,
0.4635644555091858,
0.3910830020904541,
-0.25572332739830017,
-0.7857834696769714,
-0.992182195186615,
-0.6895545721054077,
-0.5083276033401489,
-0.36804133653640747,
0.5087098479270935,
0.1430935114622116,
-0.21481041610240936,
0.8688260912895203,
-0.1610405594110489,
-0.3917638957500458,
-0.4299161732196808,
0.039016224443912506,
0.16213928163051605,
0.5040339231491089,
0.24461697041988373,
-0.6630359888076782,
-0.678799569606781,
-0.10417288541793823,
-0.42071640491485596,
-0.3553540110588074,
0.1586976796388626,
0.7471013069152832,
0.6551737189292908,
0.6456785202026367,
-0.21285556256771088,
0.19870251417160034,
0.5849330425262451,
-0.7831385731697083,
0.38038358092308044,
-0.3638509213924408,
0.04750868305563927,
-0.5970829725265503,
0.05339781567454338,
-0.15808257460594177,
-0.13534995913505554,
-0.7083870768547058,
-0.4881632626056671,
0.05724590644240379,
-0.11759887635707855,
-0.300039678812027,
0.5534164309501648,
-0.5749211311340332,
-0.4865942895412445,
0.07518637925386429,
0.1577875316143036,
-0.20995473861694336,
0.21649061143398285,
-0.23029176890850067,
1.1578618288040161,
0.48485755920410156,
-0.6189321875572205,
-0.15915820002555847,
0.47854456305503845,
-0.5910590887069702,
0.4025518298149109,
-0.8453835248947144,
0.3787172734737396,
-0.14969493448734283,
-0.2497553527355194,
-1.3144289255142212,
-0.26785609126091003,
0.1934075951576233,
-0.9366198182106018,
0.549416184425354,
0.1365077942609787,
-0.4647223651409149,
-0.4329856336116791,
0.00026596197858452797,
0.22024458646774292,
0.7061238884925842,
-0.32469993829727173,
0.4750750958919525,
0.45318737626075745,
-0.30286070704460144,
-0.6037078499794006,
-1.0519920587539673,
0.12427123636007309,
-0.11151770502328873,
-0.48482808470726013,
-0.0731157436966896,
0.00764458067715168,
-0.6154385805130005,
-0.06643097847700119,
-0.43113642930984497,
-0.20466408133506775,
0.07104121148586273,
0.3256602883338928,
-0.11906211078166962,
-0.4710000455379486,
0.0918361097574234,
0.2385476678609848,
-0.033813271671533585,
-0.023527054116129875,
0.025148607790470123,
0.40394312143325806,
0.04221098870038986,
-0.32840201258659363,
-0.5215200781822205,
0.33240506052970886,
0.7623162865638733,
0.022675426676869392,
0.5544779896736145,
0.10562285035848618,
-0.22392073273658752,
0.16901622712612152,
-0.7889291644096375,
-0.16747835278511047,
-0.4452643096446991,
0.08338821679353714,
-0.5569145083427429,
-0.7830567955970764,
0.6880024075508118,
0.3552340865135193,
-0.15339134633541107,
0.3571604788303375,
0.09582550823688507,
-0.4007088541984558,
0.9926609396934509,
0.3449685871601105,
0.02848772145807743,
0.5217517018318176,
0.05978880077600479,
0.14076422154903412,
-0.5882948040962219,
-0.32441622018814087,
-0.8247265219688416,
-0.48753443360328674,
-0.555256187915802,
-0.27396079897880554,
0.16244259476661682,
0.01449534110724926,
0.055046457797288895,
0.3439439535140991,
-0.20019347965717316,
0.449077844619751,
0.39879652857780457,
-0.15168961882591248,
0.3532021641731262,
0.09336747974157333,
0.014937097206711769,
-0.3615618944168091,
-0.7019418478012085,
-0.4083780348300934,
0.6910879611968994,
0.32456690073013306,
0.725681722164154,
0.518601655960083,
0.5975462794303894,
0.7274391651153564,
-0.21017467975616455,
-0.6531453132629395,
0.35435861349105835,
-0.5157907605171204,
-0.48498091101646423,
-0.4756082594394684,
-0.4265190064907074,
-0.9916555881500244,
0.32847973704338074,
-0.2645758390426636,
-0.5614411234855652,
0.49222344160079956,
0.25003737211227417,
-0.22249692678451538,
0.030256714671850204,
-0.8046921491622925,
0.4958994388580322,
-0.10599023848772049,
0.1464456468820572,
0.005917600356042385,
-0.741334855556488,
-0.158543661236763,
-0.1239457055926323,
0.3755434453487396,
-0.11173494905233383,
0.01193943526595831,
0.7278441786766052,
-0.16614192724227905,
0.6593353152275085,
-0.6140565276145935,
0.12250076979398727,
0.286154180765152,
-0.13383495807647705,
0.2131374180316925,
-0.4352044463157654,
0.058604296296834946,
0.28237032890319824,
0.05087649077177048,
-0.25101107358932495,
-0.42474886775016785,
0.4128863513469696,
-0.9609435200691223,
-0.40015459060668945,
-0.47992706298828125,
-0.12150943279266357,
-0.12638847529888153,
0.26431185007095337,
0.6303663849830627,
0.3744896948337555,
-0.33213359117507935,
0.030316898599267006,
0.5133482813835144,
-0.22807544469833374,
0.3656821846961975,
0.8096561431884766,
0.027463790029287338,
-0.1742401272058487,
0.9229426980018616,
0.6723172068595886,
0.37719547748565674,
0.20972076058387756,
0.05143093690276146,
-0.7124409675598145,
-0.7113339900970459,
-0.5064714550971985,
0.16975240409374237,
-0.9116451740264893,
0.08118489384651184,
-0.9084778428077698,
-0.009383687749505043,
-0.7119700312614441,
-0.16531842947006226,
-0.07559109479188919,
-0.6062966585159302,
-0.3683212697505951,
0.05435863137245178,
0.22061285376548767,
0.9298617839813232,
-0.2674497961997986,
0.3850570023059845,
-0.46745312213897705,
0.1560807079076767,
0.09445898979902267,
0.149922713637352,
-0.13975249230861664,
-0.8261183500289917,
-0.04429922625422478,
-0.06280265748500824,
0.055900689214468,
-0.9122433662414551,
0.4143986701965332,
0.5039678812026978,
0.4690955579280853,
0.3247377872467041,
0.11891448497772217,
0.7392416000366211,
-0.44508031010627747,
0.7681013941764832,
0.039050742983818054,
-1.2088816165924072,
0.36742714047431946,
0.007928924635052681,
0.43681877851486206,
0.5637239217758179,
-0.0645856112241745,
-0.7635493874549866,
-0.36253684759140015,
-0.5030664205551147,
-0.9987329244613647,
0.7932913303375244,
0.17922867834568024,
0.019063415005803108,
0.2104043811559677,
0.18029189109802246,
0.0018132185796275735,
0.036542922258377075,
-0.3673061430454254,
-0.41273584961891174,
0.07153063267469406,
0.04970498010516167,
-0.6634671688079834,
-0.32460716366767883,
0.10029243677854538,
-0.20832054316997528,
0.5481552481651306,
0.09314809739589691,
0.3646352291107178,
0.40203526616096497,
-0.4406076669692993,
-0.33936652541160583,
0.24889126420021057,
1.0356037616729736,
0.5041519999504089,
-0.02802514284849167,
0.13611984252929688,
0.383454293012619,
-0.7275123000144958,
0.24946905672550201,
0.016107749193906784,
-0.07931429147720337,
0.5164823532104492,
0.6038316488265991,
0.7891021370887756,
0.4392494559288025,
-0.8625742793083191,
0.5652942061424255,
-0.4641096889972687,
-0.12701533734798431,
-0.6207337379455566,
0.14466869831085205,
-0.019919490441679955,
0.37100857496261597,
0.5154613852500916,
0.33849966526031494,
0.20105770230293274,
-0.2637600302696228,
-0.04927162081003189,
0.20273464918136597,
-0.37664344906806946,
-0.2613300085067749,
0.5494115948677063,
0.2831059694290161,
-0.7649750113487244,
0.5007719397544861,
-0.14741389453411102,
-0.5410634875297546,
0.750089704990387,
0.649935245513916,
0.9014912843704224,
-0.3932717442512512,
-0.052847862243652344,
0.45187491178512573,
0.34047117829322815,
-0.10934903472661972,
0.7478259801864624,
-0.2254856675863266,
-0.7275080680847168,
-0.1557408720254898,
-0.4820464551448822,
-0.5133811235427856,
0.024028029292821884,
-1.0460352897644043,
0.23839344084262848,
-0.3465622663497925,
-0.12802700698375702,
0.19926117360591888,
-0.1124044805765152,
-0.6199162006378174,
0.11695757508277893,
-0.04670325294137001,
0.873963475227356,
-1.1387627124786377,
0.6459272503852844,
0.6034452319145203,
-0.16462291777133942,
-0.5469325184822083,
0.1470257192850113,
0.12743979692459106,
-0.6184382438659668,
0.5549274682998657,
0.08566881716251373,
-0.26895672082901,
0.0287656020373106,
-0.31960126757621765,
-0.762738823890686,
0.767291247844696,
0.03048723377287388,
-0.8317623138427734,
0.1997036188840866,
0.1409519463777542,
0.8064853549003601,
-0.1790696233510971,
-0.11438844352960587,
0.5853025317192078,
0.35786837339401245,
0.21318933367729187,
-1.0105959177017212,
-0.4187765419483185,
-0.2653768062591553,
0.052280083298683167,
0.0673922449350357,
-0.20646275579929352,
0.8538710474967957,
-0.3238738477230072,
-0.6597768068313599,
0.0050150444731116295,
0.29484644532203674,
-0.03080788441002369,
0.708071768283844,
0.41492751240730286,
0.09019134938716888,
0.6657832264900208,
-0.17943468689918518,
0.8851945996284485,
-0.06520887464284897,
0.10331595689058304,
1.0515512228012085,
-0.27030783891677856,
1.0512391328811646,
0.4688001275062561,
-0.42448174953460693,
-0.049490101635456085,
0.6255380511283875,
-0.039418965578079224,
0.49931085109710693,
0.11491725593805313,
-0.4316936135292053,
0.05335533246397972,
0.2092936784029007,
-0.46344178915023804,
0.3980719745159149,
0.5955117344856262,
-0.2686455547809601,
0.14530688524246216,
0.0597376711666584,
-0.23253358900547028,
0.2181490957736969,
-0.24366822838783264,
1.1451972723007202,
0.10233563929796219,
-0.4647206664085388,
0.8178084492683411,
-0.08204154670238495,
0.7594743371009827,
-0.39141932129859924,
0.25014621019363403,
-0.15163561701774597,
0.295428603887558,
-0.4184911847114563,
-0.6177222728729248,
0.7039144039154053,
0.2685777246952057,
-0.4048062860965729,
-0.1300848126411438,
0.7709118127822876,
-0.4306860566139221,
-0.18972694873809814,
0.5015343427658081,
0.5976049900054932,
0.7452637553215027,
0.21946357190608978,
-0.5868563055992126,
0.33884692192077637,
0.017901981249451637,
0.2932843863964081,
0.059107422828674316,
0.08300077170133591,
0.06515198200941086,
0.4634808897972107,
0.6502286791801453,
0.17675688862800598,
0.15382958948612213,
0.1629325896501541,
0.5311344861984253,
-0.3783304989337921,
-0.32196909189224243,
-0.7985808849334717,
0.5047762393951416,
0.05015174672007561,
-0.5912033915519714,
0.7480005025863647,
0.640441358089447,
0.8758091926574707,
-0.3930371105670929,
0.9080827832221985,
-0.13519775867462158,
1.101060390472412,
-0.24270164966583252,
0.8520313501358032,
-0.5875420570373535,
0.24171078205108643,
-0.2382572591304779,
-0.7163887023925781,
-0.23071199655532837,
0.8709588646888733,
-0.2503718137741089,
-0.24024897813796997,
0.34755608439445496,
0.6133595705032349,
0.11008108407258987,
-0.14348356425762177,
0.7390566468238831,
0.5804348587989807,
0.17678149044513702,
0.07017546892166138,
0.7924200296401978,
-0.27041229605674744,
0.14919081330299377,
0.06425611674785614,
-0.20179882645606995,
-0.3379264175891876,
-0.3191194534301758,
-0.8177311420440674,
-0.7148936986923218,
-0.1712748259305954,
-0.6531661152839661,
0.34395986795425415,
1.050695776939392,
0.13628949224948883,
-1.105645775794983,
-0.2872712314128876,
0.02472732961177826,
0.07392094284296036,
-0.14121940732002258,
-0.13270322978496552,
0.11257269233465195,
-0.02663908712565899,
-0.5559645891189575,
0.7561032772064209,
0.03527839854359627,
0.3180626928806305,
-0.14696800708770752,
-0.19240592420101166,
0.11168938875198364,
0.23792876303195953,
0.33670946955680847,
0.8525034785270691,
-0.7913628220558167,
-0.02567295916378498,
0.18594348430633545,
-0.11918200552463531,
0.10836265981197357,
0.5872759222984314,
-0.4960087239742279,
0.646070659160614,
0.5659692287445068,
0.46695223450660706,
0.3990996778011322,
-0.05237319692969322,
0.4327063262462616,
-0.5862171649932861,
0.02613714337348938,
0.41520482301712036,
0.03324363753199577,
0.5200256705284119,
-0.24630512297153473,
0.24825121462345123,
0.284070760011673,
-0.5587528944015503,
-1.0615326166152954,
0.20589348673820496,
-0.6740956902503967,
0.017532609403133392,
1.011060118675232,
-0.20142048597335815,
0.19240470230579376,
-0.7321038842201233,
-0.23069868981838226,
0.20247076451778412,
-0.40869140625,
0.8321969509124756,
0.7339145541191101,
-0.4049854278564453,
0.12191145122051239,
-0.5400030612945557,
0.5971410870552063,
0.38095998764038086,
-0.28723496198654175,
-0.17831820249557495,
0.36069872975349426,
0.6040323376655579,
0.30925193428993225,
0.7262336015701294,
-0.030849650502204895,
0.2491733729839325,
0.25317949056625366,
0.06735058128833771,
0.20217111706733704,
-0.13946221768856049,
-1.1602534055709839,
-0.21145354211330414,
0.3554573953151703,
-0.38598182797431946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13358v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13358v1
|
AdpQ: A Zero-shot Calibration Free Adaptive Post Training Quantization Method for LLMs
| 2024-05-22T05:32:11 | 2024-05-22T05:32:11 |
Alireza Ghaffari, Sharareh Younesian, Vahid Partovi Nia, Boxing Chen, Masoud Asgharian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The ever-growing computational complexity of Large Language Models (LLMs)
necessitates efficient deployment strategies. The current state-of-the-art
approaches for Post-training Quantization (PTQ) often require calibration to
achieve the desired accuracy. This paper presents AdpQ, a novel zero-shot
adaptive PTQ method for LLMs that achieves the state-of-the-art performance in
low-precision quantization (e.g. 3-bit) without requiring any calibration data.
Inspired by Adaptive LASSO regression model, our proposed approach tackles the
challenge of outlier activations by separating salient weights using an
adaptive soft-thresholding method. Guided by Adaptive LASSO, this method
ensures that the quantized weights distribution closely follows the originally
trained weights and eliminates the need for calibration data entirely, setting
our method apart from popular approaches such as SpQR and AWQ. Furthermore, our
method offers an additional benefit in terms of privacy preservation by
eliminating any calibration or training data. We also delve deeper into the
information-theoretic underpinnings of the proposed method. We demonstrate that
it leverages the Adaptive LASSO to minimize the Kullback-Leibler divergence
between the quantized weights and the originally trained weights. This
minimization ensures the quantized model retains the Shannon information
content of the original model to a great extent, guaranteeing efficient
deployment without sacrificing accuracy or information. Our results achieve the
same accuracy as the existing methods on various LLM benchmarks while the
quantization time is reduced by at least 10x, solidifying our contribution to
efficient and privacy-preserving LLM deployment.
|
[
0.0710063949227333,
-0.5483437776565552,
0.32536596059799194,
-0.022690726444125175,
-0.4166521430015564,
0.04200579226016998,
0.07477974891662598,
0.006287524942308664,
-0.11691488325595856,
0.4275068938732147,
-0.23313528299331665,
-0.6527040600776672,
-0.5645171999931335,
-0.20731326937675476,
-0.018897810950875282,
0.8078365325927734,
0.04126931354403496,
0.11200030148029327,
0.07836704701185226,
-0.39616918563842773,
-0.27097901701927185,
-0.30722424387931824,
-0.7136245369911194,
0.21977326273918152,
0.21688631176948547,
0.18688419461250305,
0.8032181262969971,
0.6283285617828369,
0.11660647392272949,
0.1715061217546463,
-0.2677105665206909,
0.29192885756492615,
-0.3361785113811493,
0.05615825578570366,
0.2943728268146515,
-0.7139070630073547,
-0.7442429065704346,
-0.2630474269390106,
1.0072838068008423,
0.5042303204536438,
-0.20807614922523499,
0.21142426133155823,
-0.04885736107826233,
0.9516590237617493,
-1.3160526752471924,
-0.09850567579269409,
-0.8002527952194214,
0.0952177494764328,
0.2120433747768402,
-0.26380887627601624,
-0.23187284171581268,
-0.5957806706428528,
-0.1813945770263672,
-0.6020600199699402,
0.2709397077560425,
-0.32642418146133423,
0.34991371631622314,
0.3810625672340393,
-0.802135169506073,
0.14885401725769043,
-0.546000063419342,
0.9794695377349854,
-0.7893053889274597,
0.4409136176109314,
0.22941288352012634,
0.07220112532377243,
-0.05831015110015869,
-0.18779611587524414,
-0.40222251415252686,
0.06448154896497726,
0.39620906114578247,
0.14535315334796906,
-0.14779381453990936,
0.07648426294326782,
0.12304463982582092,
0.2681606411933899,
-0.9444978833198547,
0.05827723443508148,
-0.2251797318458557,
-0.1566174179315567,
0.5046495795249939,
-0.04326871037483215,
-0.027893148362636566,
0.25541892647743225,
-0.4606911540031433,
-0.10261832177639008,
-0.8472045660018921,
0.25145381689071655,
0.3730548322200775,
0.11938179284334183,
-0.02413911744952202,
0.14540226757526398,
-0.35326606035232544,
0.8106820583343506,
-0.04079543799161911,
-0.1106775552034378,
0.25085049867630005,
-0.1423439383506775,
-0.3448975384235382,
0.28575029969215393,
0.8154876232147217,
0.22818481922149658,
0.09091641008853912,
0.08242888748645782,
-0.04160172492265701,
-0.06843198090791702,
-0.017466958612203598,
-0.7867933511734009,
-0.2501595914363861,
0.29761621356010437,
-0.10667015612125397,
-0.3234509229660034,
-0.3700729310512543,
-0.3069557249546051,
-0.39036959409713745,
0.03747853264212608,
0.7783221006393433,
-0.4787446856498718,
-0.13457144796848297,
0.30669522285461426,
0.11210465431213379,
0.3835500180721283,
0.5656939148902893,
-0.8265392184257507,
0.21072563529014587,
0.545787513256073,
0.8753659725189209,
0.14141084253787994,
-0.08108261227607727,
-0.7430864572525024,
0.14771369099617004,
-0.6537438035011292,
0.38581588864326477,
0.005028237588703632,
-0.03876674920320511,
-0.11977124214172363,
-0.004367203917354345,
-0.1085951179265976,
-0.4219132661819458,
0.4383517801761627,
-0.827792763710022,
0.07554405182600021,
0.13217975199222565,
-0.3228917419910431,
-0.42137637734413147,
0.22463516891002655,
-0.29041561484336853,
0.9569191336631775,
0.2122402787208557,
-0.49626773595809937,
0.4799835979938507,
-0.42211055755615234,
0.009863356128334999,
0.2301475703716278,
0.1950312852859497,
-0.532362163066864,
0.27891507744789124,
0.41053467988967896,
0.26185107231140137,
-0.10782313346862793,
-0.05791883170604706,
-0.42612558603286743,
-0.800264835357666,
0.3278299570083618,
-0.4469720125198364,
1.023510456085205,
0.07570981234312057,
-0.22176849842071533,
0.08025975525379181,
-0.8842611908912659,
0.3428790271282196,
0.05492210388183594,
-0.17659907042980194,
-0.3707752823829651,
-0.17500445246696472,
-0.42821207642555237,
0.07399909198284149,
0.1704232543706894,
-0.54361891746521,
0.21883538365364075,
-0.7578673958778381,
0.3436430096626282,
0.6626288890838623,
0.0641753152012825,
0.732447624206543,
-0.3852958679199219,
0.606070339679718,
-0.07649192959070206,
0.2656264305114746,
-0.1912713646888733,
-0.15593954920768738,
-0.6857720017433167,
-0.6495551466941833,
0.6602990627288818,
0.6892848014831543,
-0.530771017074585,
0.4746119976043701,
-0.3549177646636963,
-0.4170628488063812,
-0.7985591888427734,
0.18294624984264374,
0.21544145047664642,
0.3458443582057953,
0.27183476090431213,
-0.36231958866119385,
-0.346812903881073,
-0.5414337515830994,
-0.12917812168598175,
-0.2170369178056717,
-0.530981719493866,
0.14120715856552124,
0.09815677255392075,
0.13903754949569702,
0.7142887115478516,
-0.4513566493988037,
-0.30970966815948486,
0.20106586813926697,
0.1823074370622635,
0.16456995904445648,
0.4340682625770569,
0.585665225982666,
-0.5809243321418762,
-0.6008108854293823,
-0.3503550887107849,
-0.5260115265846252,
-0.150735005736351,
0.02459004893898964,
-0.2707434296607971,
0.24951249361038208,
0.03302476555109024,
-0.474964439868927,
0.1715642809867859,
0.5940138697624207,
-0.18243932723999023,
0.30241215229034424,
-0.2612752914428711,
0.36500927805900574,
-0.7492808103561401,
0.1132289320230484,
-0.24376362562179565,
-0.5542275309562683,
-0.6718655824661255,
0.10330464690923691,
0.3345561623573303,
-0.19425807893276215,
-0.8316086530685425,
0.566183865070343,
-0.31971755623817444,
0.1692008674144745,
-0.4473799765110016,
0.2012101411819458,
0.2977757751941681,
0.5308796763420105,
0.012120155617594719,
0.5403847098350525,
0.7121331095695496,
-0.5427396893501282,
0.5623558759689331,
0.19339026510715485,
-0.07811079919338226,
0.7292248010635376,
-0.5026870965957642,
0.232472226023674,
-0.3927973210811615,
0.22127681970596313,
-1.0093262195587158,
0.3937847316265106,
0.3459952175617218,
-0.5420036315917969,
0.17116571962833405,
-0.6655963063240051,
-0.42381900548934937,
0.11237894743680954,
-0.9149191379547119,
0.6185420751571655,
0.6386548280715942,
-0.19525614380836487,
0.2059437781572342,
0.2604997158050537,
-0.15419599413871765,
-0.5854522585868835,
-0.4512215852737427,
-0.15655136108398438,
-0.38583385944366455,
-0.42924031615257263,
0.3075118660926819,
-0.15333814918994904,
0.12307658046483994,
-0.3856293559074402,
-0.2719958424568176,
-0.20475105941295624,
0.262584388256073,
0.03504779934883118,
0.2283264845609665,
-0.1819523572921753,
0.08259224891662598,
-0.10275604575872421,
-0.16906535625457764,
-0.2222777158021927,
-0.2892912030220032,
0.12121785432100296,
-0.004667607601732016,
-0.10336564481258392,
-0.4091348946094513,
0.14667555689811707,
0.48359668254852295,
-0.08346434682607651,
0.8360978960990906,
0.7860224843025208,
-0.4434484541416168,
-0.23179006576538086,
-0.37608739733695984,
-0.01957925595343113,
-0.4341620206832886,
0.32657304406166077,
-0.1984819620847702,
-0.8247508406639099,
0.3145640790462494,
0.06450842320919037,
0.025341326370835304,
0.05689135938882828,
0.45736202597618103,
0.10179716348648071,
1.199875831604004,
0.7424253225326538,
0.21827001869678497,
0.5694931745529175,
-0.0531083382666111,
0.1529039442539215,
-0.9652143120765686,
0.10668517649173737,
-0.13352160155773163,
-0.19361287355422974,
-0.3692981004714966,
-0.5880011916160583,
0.577199399471283,
0.6479457020759583,
-0.5695064663887024,
0.16794294118881226,
-0.5319737792015076,
0.2352183312177658,
0.6882058382034302,
0.2653696537017822,
0.4093720316886902,
0.0030555943958461285,
0.3280898630619049,
-0.10152258723974228,
-0.6147708892822266,
-0.2599375545978546,
1.2422723770141602,
0.23392970860004425,
0.858515739440918,
0.25511953234672546,
0.2961142063140869,
0.3840203583240509,
0.06472848355770111,
-0.9815809726715088,
0.4778256118297577,
-0.12119635939598083,
-0.05065625533461571,
-0.44101864099502563,
-0.6815493702888489,
-0.6613593697547913,
0.5144705176353455,
-0.1549549549818039,
-0.7286998629570007,
0.36746782064437866,
0.29871782660484314,
-0.888150691986084,
0.10888064652681351,
-0.6359221339225769,
0.8282989859580994,
-0.1370241492986679,
-0.4176529049873352,
0.09068349748849869,
-0.5798536539077759,
0.3661087155342102,
-0.37911340594291687,
0.11113845556974411,
-0.5968667268753052,
-0.4282878041267395,
0.8832935094833374,
-0.3797834515571594,
0.43269073963165283,
-0.376322478055954,
-0.18414302170276642,
0.3529176712036133,
0.36077606678009033,
0.698142409324646,
0.08640129119157791,
-0.2650447189807892,
-0.019088583067059517,
0.5169339179992676,
-0.5809592008590698,
-0.715472400188446,
0.5923006534576416,
-0.6217609643936157,
-0.3995584547519684,
-0.4792832136154175,
-0.6585301756858826,
-0.4307152032852173,
-0.05868110805749893,
-0.16781960427761078,
0.07516701519489288,
0.08548146486282349,
0.32863420248031616,
0.6259084939956665,
-0.27102237939834595,
0.5123982429504395,
1.1585673093795776,
0.21942304074764252,
-0.6927372813224792,
0.791377067565918,
0.0971236452460289,
0.26292264461517334,
0.6320896744728088,
0.07718001306056976,
-0.5005612373352051,
-0.6852710247039795,
-0.5702441930770874,
0.21412931382656097,
-0.47005966305732727,
-0.6977563500404358,
-0.5976731181144714,
-0.10093779116868973,
-0.5912436842918396,
-0.26126793026924133,
-0.527716338634491,
-0.6658855676651001,
-0.273297518491745,
0.23679803311824799,
0.6416869759559631,
-0.16823238134384155,
-0.11008934676647186,
0.6441933512687683,
-0.905389130115509,
0.21391569077968597,
0.4512355327606201,
0.20609508454799652,
-0.2555493712425232,
-1.0093265771865845,
-0.33703285455703735,
0.3915659189224243,
-0.4082576036453247,
-0.7108592391014099,
0.49756309390068054,
0.5651466846466064,
0.029664352536201477,
0.17640382051467896,
0.4628022611141205,
0.683678150177002,
-0.28200775384902954,
0.6898996233940125,
0.022756867110729218,
-1.071008324623108,
0.522964358329773,
-0.23799383640289307,
0.5811701416969299,
0.5181230306625366,
0.5163697004318237,
-0.4647713899612427,
-0.06728789955377579,
-0.39476457238197327,
-0.9726497530937195,
0.7975055575370789,
-0.17196078598499298,
0.2396268993616104,
0.5173545479774475,
0.4060545563697815,
-0.26968806982040405,
0.41979172825813293,
-0.8447756767272949,
-0.04264210909605026,
-0.006850511766970158,
-0.2950136661529541,
0.20535676181316376,
-0.5299935936927795,
-0.1579054892063141,
0.06596934050321579,
0.8479219675064087,
-0.5223848223686218,
0.15661323070526123,
-0.06191511079668999,
-0.31735777854919434,
-0.42062461376190186,
0.34601929783821106,
0.23670467734336853,
0.6632280945777893,
-0.5858697891235352,
0.11626327782869339,
0.413994163274765,
-0.31084510684013367,
0.4920188784599304,
0.17471733689308167,
-0.37544119358062744,
-0.1678990125656128,
0.029165903106331825,
0.7917344570159912,
0.21130326390266418,
-0.7985184192657471,
1.1761282682418823,
-0.03601996973156929,
-0.2884625792503357,
-0.12457545101642609,
0.14722536504268646,
-0.4003343880176544,
0.2832021713256836,
0.554266095161438,
-0.018925048410892487,
0.15283800661563873,
-0.22953636944293976,
0.2343360334634781,
0.6106421947479248,
-0.5824010968208313,
-0.30241429805755615,
0.8584060072898865,
-0.21857424080371857,
0.045878734439611435,
0.2989683151245117,
-0.15647393465042114,
-0.1811981052160263,
0.24923744797706604,
0.3975234627723694,
0.788924515247345,
-0.49328646063804626,
0.426046222448349,
0.17493252456188202,
0.147466242313385,
0.037328846752643585,
0.4426403343677521,
-0.17799383401870728,
-0.7311899065971375,
-0.6175177693367004,
-0.9184595942497253,
-0.4094321131706238,
0.23104873299598694,
-0.42039400339126587,
0.4561639130115509,
-0.5758391618728638,
0.00126172648742795,
-0.3185254633426666,
0.04704618826508522,
-0.30277228355407715,
0.26041874289512634,
0.21267840266227722,
0.5947775840759277,
-0.8736371994018555,
0.7719996571540833,
0.4933271110057831,
0.14341840147972107,
-0.39357906579971313,
-0.2353716790676117,
-0.04067465662956238,
-0.9105632901191711,
0.2373431771993637,
-0.13261155784130096,
0.05086800456047058,
0.4322595000267029,
-0.17065510153770447,
-1.004321575164795,
1.0890151262283325,
0.7458100914955139,
-0.25503289699554443,
0.012760900892317295,
0.08130709826946259,
0.40393009781837463,
0.05868138372898102,
0.4717164933681488,
0.31075915694236755,
-0.09629009664058685,
0.3841201066970825,
-0.7710886597633362,
0.290219783782959,
-0.0029924376867711544,
0.19854241609573364,
0.23312710225582123,
-0.74009770154953,
0.5404432415962219,
-0.018373485654592514,
-0.16249628365039825,
0.09241297096014023,
0.30542194843292236,
0.40231388807296753,
-0.10885129868984222,
0.4690101444721222,
0.35930347442626953,
0.3956463634967804,
0.09730733186006546,
0.42926424741744995,
-0.4299883246421814,
0.4423745274543762,
0.9450119733810425,
-0.3065928518772125,
0.7845643758773804,
0.28174346685409546,
-0.48134681582450867,
0.040371622890233994,
0.5027328729629517,
0.15981218218803406,
0.6913325190544128,
0.3332551419734955,
-0.8013935089111328,
-0.12233297526836395,
-0.22572045028209686,
-0.3220501244068146,
0.5356221199035645,
0.12109783291816711,
-0.1774868667125702,
-0.30060938000679016,
0.013688958249986172,
-0.10399006307125092,
-0.3185325562953949,
-0.45182517170906067,
0.77302086353302,
0.050529032945632935,
-0.2854495644569397,
1.1415717601776123,
0.17276470363140106,
0.7232910394668579,
-0.7980296015739441,
-0.023718860000371933,
-0.10874239355325699,
0.24922169744968414,
-0.12540064752101898,
-0.35803964734077454,
0.23833344876766205,
-0.2453426718711853,
0.05887260288000107,
-0.37491053342819214,
0.5844510197639465,
-0.5641366839408875,
-0.4721076786518097,
-0.06071105971932411,
0.5645203590393066,
-0.021622780710458755,
-0.5322465896606445,
-0.6619905829429626,
0.0090645682066679,
-0.17404630780220032,
-0.17059284448623657,
0.5185995101928711,
0.465344101190567,
0.05826021358370781,
0.3839559257030487,
0.622355580329895,
0.2677360773086548,
0.10481879860162735,
-0.14206793904304504,
0.6013309359550476,
-0.5287035703659058,
-0.4949272871017456,
-0.7995561361312866,
0.5005000829696655,
0.5177823305130005,
-0.05110128968954086,
0.7481565475463867,
0.5269836783409119,
0.6427015662193298,
0.11342685669660568,
0.46107298135757446,
0.2390773892402649,
0.49605682492256165,
-0.45227718353271484,
0.5575535893440247,
-0.6385141015052795,
0.31130483746528625,
-0.16903704404830933,
-0.8615168333053589,
-0.813187301158905,
0.5522614121437073,
-0.28495049476623535,
-0.10145587474107742,
0.29366207122802734,
1.0343286991119385,
0.0678715631365776,
-0.38642585277557373,
0.5946967005729675,
0.048847977072000504,
-0.07062917947769165,
0.8676641583442688,
0.6144185066223145,
-0.9930323958396912,
0.7815800309181213,
-0.15478543937206268,
-0.5663501024246216,
-0.22173826396465302,
-0.907249391078949,
-0.3958962559700012,
-0.1577688455581665,
-0.6836715340614319,
-0.24924510717391968,
0.33445826172828674,
0.6985706090927124,
0.8424423336982727,
-0.8573943972587585,
-0.05414259806275368,
-0.00747096911072731,
0.11047085374593735,
-0.3592388331890106,
-0.27021995186805725,
0.5835176706314087,
-0.026049233973026276,
-0.8531823754310608,
0.4208199977874756,
0.36415183544158936,
0.31071937084198,
-0.0016319470014423132,
0.05318775400519371,
-0.16650353372097015,
-0.009960127994418144,
0.5902678966522217,
0.394317626953125,
-0.29233431816101074,
-0.1238868460059166,
-0.11879948526620865,
0.05672799423336983,
0.29247578978538513,
0.5534707903862,
-1.0639495849609375,
0.6254178881645203,
0.47257089614868164,
0.4293728172779083,
0.43132975697517395,
0.13509579002857208,
0.5256905555725098,
-0.9461718201637268,
0.5141357779502869,
0.413631796836853,
0.01577288657426834,
0.36832818388938904,
-0.398416668176651,
0.2916734218597412,
0.32892531156539917,
-0.5421536564826965,
-1.0567805767059326,
0.012397210113704205,
-0.7078500390052795,
-0.10624074190855026,
0.7901408076286316,
-0.29848358035087585,
-0.1779891401529312,
0.008263067342340946,
-0.10645598918199539,
0.22441929578781128,
-0.4053193926811218,
0.7865617871284485,
0.07374777644872665,
-0.14737479388713837,
-0.6903433203697205,
-0.4272843301296234,
0.5700041055679321,
0.5093828439712524,
-0.2418312430381775,
0.09024683386087418,
0.3244852125644684,
0.3065848648548126,
-0.2491627335548401,
0.9032542109489441,
-0.20695817470550537,
0.34815356135368347,
-0.08880414068698883,
0.09424683451652527,
-0.09484467655420303,
0.061376601457595825,
-0.7786319851875305,
0.18783815205097198,
0.2701130509376526,
-0.45723989605903625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13350v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13350v2
|
Efficacy of ByT5 in Multilingual Translation of Biblical Texts for Underrepresented Languages
| 2024-05-22T05:12:35 | 2024-05-30T18:42:45 |
Corinne Aars, Lauren Adams, Xiaokan Tian, Zhaoyu Wang, Colton Wismer, Jason Wu, Pablo Rivas, Korn Sooksatra, Matthew Fendt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
This study presents the development and evaluation of a ByT5-based
multilingual translation model tailored for translating the Bible into
underrepresented languages. Utilizing the comprehensive Johns Hopkins
University Bible Corpus, we trained the model to capture the intricate nuances
of character-based and morphologically rich languages. Our results, measured by
the BLEU score and supplemented with sample translations, suggest the model can
improve accessibility to sacred texts. It effectively handles the distinctive
biblical lexicon and structure, thus bridging the linguistic divide. The study
also discusses the model's limitations and suggests pathways for future
enhancements, focusing on expanding access to sacred literature across
linguistic boundaries.
|
[
-0.18591813743114471,
-0.2777114510536194,
0.43767836689949036,
0.33999189734458923,
-0.5214784145355225,
0.07577461749315262,
-0.35279515385627747,
-0.8838721513748169,
-0.37707239389419556,
0.3122187852859497,
-0.25465574860572815,
-0.4114879369735718,
-0.9411898851394653,
0.33226698637008667,
-0.5898998975753784,
0.8135905861854553,
0.30910080671310425,
0.361459881067276,
0.4312572777271271,
-0.35634878277778625,
-0.5656232237815857,
-0.2378300130367279,
0.001865430036559701,
-0.3063820004463196,
0.3200076222419739,
0.42755308747291565,
1.0385957956314087,
0.5451938509941101,
0.8631081581115723,
0.39484214782714844,
-0.3925487697124481,
-0.025454476475715637,
-0.48653411865234375,
-0.10280030965805054,
-0.27090370655059814,
-0.5933322310447693,
-0.4022737443447113,
-0.04560641571879387,
1.046091914176941,
0.9161531329154968,
-0.048517972230911255,
0.262019544839859,
0.1324499398469925,
0.2841801941394806,
-0.31508874893188477,
0.03371160477399826,
-0.8017421364784241,
-0.12661415338516235,
-0.6065918207168579,
-0.12164397537708282,
-0.6183794736862183,
-0.4166286885738373,
0.3069089949131012,
-0.49213218688964844,
0.3863295018672943,
0.058942750096321106,
0.392193466424942,
0.21271859109401703,
-0.5822593569755554,
-0.3063627779483795,
-0.4975655972957611,
1.248447299003601,
-0.6072242259979248,
0.9089710712432861,
0.14839331805706024,
0.1369810402393341,
0.09726131707429886,
-0.6689123511314392,
-0.27610036730766296,
-0.16833217442035675,
-0.13513079285621643,
0.4789997339248657,
-0.17271588742733002,
-0.11380667984485626,
0.25526225566864014,
0.6463240385055542,
-0.6524897217750549,
-0.14980687201023102,
-0.8669155836105347,
0.2671129107475281,
0.48366767168045044,
-0.17499226331710815,
0.644728422164917,
-0.7692043781280518,
-0.6026172637939453,
-0.16101056337356567,
-0.4160596430301666,
0.09335815161466599,
0.08827885240316391,
0.6074312329292297,
-0.17135858535766602,
0.4409182071685791,
0.2614362835884094,
0.15913492441177368,
-0.40083223581314087,
-0.10929763317108154,
0.25419896841049194,
-0.6166495084762573,
-0.25687742233276367,
0.34225332736968994,
0.5147988200187683,
0.3538179099559784,
0.4217624366283417,
-0.3215025067329407,
-0.17663824558258057,
0.13064910471439362,
0.6452135443687439,
-0.8988792896270752,
0.1665341705083847,
-0.047475531697273254,
-0.7788206338882446,
-0.31287097930908203,
-0.32149389386177063,
-0.38054490089416504,
-0.4729606807231903,
0.1517544686794281,
-0.029875703155994415,
-0.7499791383743286,
-0.09748964756727219,
0.159194216132164,
-0.19390809535980225,
-0.22928988933563232,
0.6004194617271423,
-0.993374228477478,
0.3056899309158325,
0.17062824964523315,
0.7994354367256165,
-0.11313806474208832,
-0.35474833846092224,
-0.09201239049434662,
0.3871515989303589,
-0.2581900954246521,
0.6635594367980957,
-0.6766380667686462,
-0.8023466467857361,
-0.023163266479969025,
-0.06358679383993149,
0.03790495917201042,
-0.42500630021095276,
1.0656474828720093,
-0.4164171814918518,
-0.052135221660137177,
-0.5134812593460083,
-0.5522774457931519,
-0.7347207069396973,
0.127365380525589,
-0.75357586145401,
0.6085010170936584,
0.22531263530254364,
-0.4227316677570343,
0.46045783162117004,
-0.9454694390296936,
-0.02464146539568901,
0.5307996273040771,
-0.05635504424571991,
-0.44070810079574585,
0.519494891166687,
0.20095838606357574,
0.053004227578639984,
-0.3165058195590973,
0.12098882347345352,
-0.2914450466632843,
-0.47120267152786255,
0.2794114351272583,
-0.7785341143608093,
0.675597071647644,
0.2275717705488205,
-0.06809946894645691,
0.21069680154323578,
-0.7199023962020874,
0.2509332001209259,
0.011395024135708809,
-0.3967903256416321,
-0.6384897828102112,
-0.0655868723988533,
0.802152693271637,
0.011911801062524319,
0.09190264344215393,
-0.6641819477081299,
0.380283385515213,
-0.4839544892311096,
0.11583779752254486,
0.19250041246414185,
-0.37496304512023926,
0.5938977599143982,
0.020587405189871788,
0.507941484451294,
0.05002734437584877,
0.12035273015499115,
-0.1732320338487625,
-0.6477013230323792,
-0.1153440997004509,
-0.21026374399662018,
0.430253267288208,
0.5635164976119995,
-0.30981507897377014,
-0.0108976811170578,
-0.43078553676605225,
-0.5182183384895325,
-0.7817173004150391,
0.18594025075435638,
0.5480560064315796,
0.11261433362960815,
0.9323159456253052,
-0.7267333269119263,
-0.18082214891910553,
-0.7524586915969849,
-0.3078790605068207,
-0.037058524787425995,
0.187834694981575,
0.10798616707324982,
0.5735505223274231,
-0.17991209030151367,
0.13386963307857513,
-0.027118051424622536,
-0.4737255871295929,
-0.48293471336364746,
0.11579535901546478,
0.10020298510789871,
0.6147249341011047,
0.7420477867126465,
-0.8274762630462646,
-0.6431919932365417,
0.5525609254837036,
-0.8245416283607483,
-0.013907654210925102,
-0.09359539300203323,
0.37828806042671204,
-0.284442275762558,
0.20545494556427002,
-0.3273731470108032,
0.8166210651397705,
0.5873062610626221,
-0.4030107855796814,
0.22889184951782227,
-0.28816893696784973,
0.6417379379272461,
-0.965965986251831,
0.14522545039653778,
-0.03730829060077667,
-0.4768213927745819,
-0.44070571660995483,
0.10986339300870895,
0.473741352558136,
-0.15667009353637695,
-0.5102892518043518,
0.5612115859985352,
-0.5948788523674011,
-0.04128658398985863,
-0.20907729864120483,
0.04054804891347885,
-0.2973666787147522,
0.12442576140165329,
0.00655355304479599,
1.068052887916565,
0.11382318288087845,
-0.19413231313228607,
0.11191804707050323,
0.913428544998169,
-0.3028762936592102,
0.5432655811309814,
-0.4892730712890625,
-0.23030789196491241,
0.029407000169157982,
0.14845123887062073,
-0.7917171716690063,
-0.003258867422118783,
0.12252754718065262,
-0.4013253450393677,
0.4136238396167755,
-0.3658908009529114,
-0.30754512548446655,
0.13552729785442352,
-0.06784467399120331,
0.7959152460098267,
0.24289725720882416,
-0.1493905931711197,
0.41354843974113464,
0.02342870645225048,
-0.3249688446521759,
-0.598942220211029,
-0.7894859313964844,
0.18649083375930786,
-0.3620252013206482,
-0.7836453914642334,
0.6340010762214661,
-0.07744824141263962,
-0.1433180719614029,
-0.1455855667591095,
-0.04275115206837654,
-0.10627827793359756,
0.03383316844701767,
-0.1004844382405281,
-0.11502402275800705,
-0.3872520327568054,
-0.11971689015626907,
0.21673035621643066,
-0.05172627791762352,
-0.1756841391324997,
-0.22131192684173584,
-0.023325514048337936,
-0.2438688725233078,
-0.3823368549346924,
-0.3972051739692688,
0.9474494457244873,
0.6078466176986694,
-0.5664250254631042,
0.6837425827980042,
0.5838944911956787,
-0.32799461483955383,
-0.06663309782743454,
-0.31819313764572144,
-0.0802769735455513,
-0.40032410621643066,
0.6032755970954895,
-0.5178838968276978,
-0.42946019768714905,
0.8678494095802307,
-0.2720995247364044,
-0.01452920213341713,
0.2170945703983307,
0.6662765741348267,
0.062335629016160965,
0.5991740822792053,
0.5941002368927002,
0.4859268069267273,
0.6634002923965454,
-0.119985431432724,
-0.14993730187416077,
-0.6231029033660889,
0.016552364453673363,
-0.5689154863357544,
-0.37487611174583435,
-0.8324674367904663,
-0.4338654577732086,
0.5575904846191406,
0.22074301540851593,
0.4266359806060791,
0.21515889465808868,
-0.2868098318576813,
0.48616594076156616,
0.7824331521987915,
0.04249829798936844,
0.6604043245315552,
0.12598975002765656,
-0.206176295876503,
-0.6658573150634766,
-0.6438241004943848,
-0.7361587285995483,
1.2005921602249146,
0.4600049555301666,
0.48356086015701294,
0.6440048813819885,
0.5801819562911987,
0.4944705069065094,
0.6549755930900574,
-0.6175298094749451,
0.1195998266339302,
-0.597438395023346,
-1.0333691835403442,
-0.4608505368232727,
-0.05355804041028023,
-0.9948985576629639,
0.45630571246147156,
-0.05518896132707596,
-0.78985196352005,
0.3421327769756317,
-0.14735305309295654,
-0.36995911598205566,
0.1856936365365982,
-1.0423423051834106,
1.179206371307373,
-0.0928230881690979,
-0.27079543471336365,
-0.542588472366333,
-0.8367646336555481,
0.2782904803752899,
-0.3597230613231659,
0.16466891765594482,
0.300321102142334,
0.24629494547843933,
0.360179603099823,
-0.04531165584921837,
0.8775370121002197,
0.2949276864528656,
-0.06941492855548859,
0.1795019805431366,
0.014233875088393688,
0.19821088016033173,
0.10636071115732193,
-0.1543199121952057,
0.32249167561531067,
0.17418299615383148,
-0.638137936592102,
-0.6571680903434753,
0.40911611914634705,
-0.7770158052444458,
-0.3275236189365387,
-0.6261212229728699,
-0.9645721316337585,
-0.04140640050172806,
0.39949023723602295,
0.006962636020034552,
0.40297549962997437,
-0.4515247941017151,
0.4687441885471344,
0.687394380569458,
-0.4243338704109192,
0.4980332553386688,
0.5232843160629272,
-0.3539279103279114,
-0.6273138523101807,
0.6697666049003601,
0.48331812024116516,
0.28220024704933167,
0.28375935554504395,
0.21981164813041687,
-0.7920351624488831,
-0.8258204460144043,
-0.8113319277763367,
0.19191278517246246,
-0.9236714243888855,
0.06207544356584549,
-0.19224846363067627,
-0.09220059961080551,
-0.4210937023162842,
-0.14014370739459991,
-0.5616816282272339,
-0.22717507183551788,
-0.005535630043596029,
0.03860723599791527,
-0.05965982377529144,
0.8795631527900696,
0.012027348391711712,
0.7575671076774597,
-1.2649472951889038,
0.2030366063117981,
-0.23581843078136444,
0.21386969089508057,
-0.255956768989563,
-0.7108045220375061,
-0.2930355370044708,
-0.20791837573051453,
-0.6611220240592957,
-1.1889485120773315,
0.42468467354774475,
-0.1354740858078003,
0.28937917947769165,
0.10809455066919327,
-0.07419739663600922,
0.8497102856636047,
-0.7162593603134155,
0.26429063081741333,
0.38030025362968445,
-1.0898600816726685,
0.1930876523256302,
-0.6765262484550476,
0.6159608364105225,
0.29142892360687256,
0.2434099018573761,
-0.7040011286735535,
-0.5889800786972046,
-0.8018444180488586,
-0.593207597732544,
0.6478942632675171,
0.7861055731773376,
0.13998940587043762,
0.17047753930091858,
-0.009563563391566277,
0.2668322026729584,
0.36104264855384827,
-1.0078827142715454,
-0.137429341673851,
-0.3300977051258087,
-0.14084964990615845,
0.10185934603214264,
-0.28893476724624634,
0.19762548804283142,
-0.3369719088077545,
0.4957914352416992,
0.04422722011804581,
-0.020575303584337234,
0.257788747549057,
-0.35573601722717285,
-0.32476702332496643,
0.6726821660995483,
0.8928161859512329,
0.8732354640960693,
-0.2838387191295624,
-0.07768364995718002,
0.3471162021160126,
-0.7996532320976257,
-0.1422501802444458,
0.3662334680557251,
-0.4000350832939148,
0.07329338788986206,
0.5257313847541809,
0.5239022970199585,
0.18997809290885925,
-0.06346538662910461,
0.18149860203266144,
-0.10634363442659378,
0.2717602252960205,
-0.2827395796775818,
-0.23662598431110382,
0.057667024433612823,
0.726308286190033,
0.43145039677619934,
0.3961412012577057,
0.35980963706970215,
-0.5443659424781799,
0.1884354203939438,
0.2719116806983948,
-0.5415133237838745,
-0.49265748262405396,
0.9209921360015869,
0.314386248588562,
-0.12139909714460373,
0.46411365270614624,
0.020224282518029213,
-0.49079442024230957,
0.23969820141792297,
0.740461528301239,
0.5543167591094971,
-0.6996651887893677,
-0.02095041051506996,
0.16836097836494446,
0.6362566351890564,
0.23191750049591064,
0.436284601688385,
0.07810530811548233,
-0.49456924200057983,
-0.5156107544898987,
-0.562267005443573,
-0.20015805959701538,
0.07485334575176239,
-0.44033282995224,
0.21092763543128967,
0.147603839635849,
-0.3119122385978699,
0.07948628067970276,
0.04912303760647774,
-0.6285819411277771,
0.47078680992126465,
0.27271056175231934,
0.67127525806427,
-0.6808927655220032,
0.9359803199768066,
0.8127093315124512,
-0.8690561652183533,
-0.6758807301521301,
-0.1744442582130432,
-0.14808806777000427,
-0.610196590423584,
0.5358495116233826,
-0.05557192489504814,
-0.02862604148685932,
0.44222259521484375,
-0.19595091044902802,
-0.7101584076881409,
0.9114295244216919,
0.6554253697395325,
-0.5959440469741821,
-0.27233198285102844,
0.38846251368522644,
0.5660344362258911,
0.10035276412963867,
0.5257594585418701,
0.11311721801757812,
0.7003093957901001,
-0.04657602310180664,
-1.2918682098388672,
-0.16695185005664825,
-0.13622795045375824,
0.0034705393481999636,
0.19232507050037384,
-0.6518964767456055,
0.19857166707515717,
-0.205516517162323,
0.005099628586322069,
0.1259598284959793,
1.044525384902954,
0.14769455790519714,
0.16334721446037292,
0.13510353863239288,
0.3780529499053955,
0.8613574504852295,
0.09088500589132309,
1.2291449308395386,
-0.25424885749816895,
0.5289108157157898,
0.6841999888420105,
0.15736693143844604,
0.4589138925075531,
0.4918723404407501,
-0.1585598886013031,
-0.043033402413129807,
0.3079400360584259,
-0.016862010583281517,
0.46502700448036194,
0.10086189210414886,
-0.5411931872367859,
-0.4359721541404724,
-0.5083218812942505,
-0.7517441511154175,
0.45552608370780945,
0.37292274832725525,
-0.6793507933616638,
-0.28526878356933594,
-0.0828910693526268,
0.057187315076589584,
0.257694810628891,
-0.25817838311195374,
0.22494827210903168,
0.5450686812400818,
-0.46263936161994934,
0.5638836026191711,
0.3084326982498169,
0.17239859700202942,
-0.5442969799041748,
-0.1068040207028389,
-0.20438247919082642,
0.4201892018318176,
-0.1989022046327591,
-0.6587607860565186,
0.5901312828063965,
0.020835479721426964,
-0.3145301938056946,
-0.5668657422065735,
0.7374714612960815,
-0.53924161195755,
-0.8901513814926147,
0.4916134774684906,
1.0050199031829834,
0.22885766625404358,
0.04748265817761421,
-0.7405472993850708,
0.10798967629671097,
0.021557439118623734,
-0.13328202068805695,
-0.048199448734521866,
0.8978826999664307,
-0.6820997595787048,
0.7036113142967224,
0.554671049118042,
0.09389020502567291,
0.3086063861846924,
0.4838603436946869,
0.5768306851387024,
-0.9263281226158142,
-0.5283598899841309,
-0.8857313394546509,
0.7235979437828064,
0.20211124420166016,
-0.48266252875328064,
0.7566540837287903,
0.6035992503166199,
0.746645450592041,
-0.2584124207496643,
0.7652459144592285,
0.21277226507663727,
0.16142946481704712,
-0.20301343500614166,
1.099854588508606,
-0.7486992478370667,
-0.025674469769001007,
-0.6155518293380737,
-0.9295778274536133,
-0.4911132752895355,
0.5697040557861328,
-0.339063435792923,
0.051869459450244904,
1.0635446310043335,
0.40339896082878113,
-0.6551201343536377,
0.03756840154528618,
0.7511497139930725,
0.26472434401512146,
0.18683935701847076,
0.21106727421283722,
0.7727764248847961,
-0.728164553642273,
0.6864088773727417,
0.2877117991447449,
-0.06023199111223221,
0.15479198098182678,
-0.5586661696434021,
-0.9540974497795105,
-0.28965044021606445,
-0.17878511548042297,
-0.3358249068260193,
0.30425798892974854,
0.7469379901885986,
0.5276576280593872,
-0.8026701807975769,
-0.37503206729888916,
0.11182588338851929,
-0.020772814750671387,
-0.3000486195087433,
-0.032243482768535614,
0.22167648375034332,
-0.25058385729789734,
-1.0598101615905762,
0.6568965911865234,
0.29780349135398865,
0.16696348786354065,
-0.35718533396720886,
-0.042425449937582016,
-0.16967523097991943,
0.02075887843966484,
0.5232234597206116,
-0.36861610412597656,
-0.925441324710846,
-0.27170348167419434,
0.12076011300086975,
-0.17007730901241302,
0.403349906206131,
0.5057945251464844,
-0.31174689531326294,
0.4079614579677582,
0.3098972737789154,
0.6596084833145142,
0.4384824335575104,
0.27416542172431946,
0.775233268737793,
-0.6730765104293823,
0.08741355687379837,
0.062473975121974945,
0.5065783858299255,
0.3699693977832794,
-0.13752873241901398,
0.44689419865608215,
0.5609266757965088,
-0.37050890922546387,
-0.5955027937889099,
0.3586595058441162,
-1.269386887550354,
-0.08440607041120529,
0.9130766987800598,
-0.2406991571187973,
0.05072043463587761,
-0.37225306034088135,
-0.17482900619506836,
0.5032861232757568,
-0.6088948249816895,
0.8978481888771057,
1.064965009689331,
0.646635890007019,
-0.27380144596099854,
-0.9428665637969971,
0.30971482396125793,
0.555335283279419,
-0.5580713748931885,
-0.12099231779575348,
0.34093889594078064,
0.1068149283528328,
0.35652410984039307,
0.41175296902656555,
-0.34616363048553467,
0.3927285373210907,
-0.028164302930235863,
0.2608259320259094,
0.2749048173427582,
-0.1917000114917755,
0.044762127101421356,
0.30566152930259705,
0.2265641987323761,
0.045081768184900284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13344v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13344v1
|
Contextualized Automatic Speech Recognition with Dynamic Vocabulary
| 2024-05-22T05:03:39 | 2024-05-22T05:03:39 |
Yui Sudo, Yosuke Fukumoto, Muhammad Shakeel, Yifan Peng, Shinji Watanabe
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Deep biasing (DB) improves the performance of end-to-end automatic speech
recognition (E2E-ASR) for rare words or contextual phrases using a bias list.
However, most existing methods treat bias phrases as sequences of subwords in a
predefined static vocabulary, which can result in ineffective learning of the
dependencies between subwords. More advanced techniques address this problem by
incorporating additional text data, which increases the overall workload. This
paper proposes a dynamic vocabulary where phrase-level bias tokens can be added
during the inference phase. Each bias token represents an entire bias phrase
within a single token, thereby eliminating the need to learn the dependencies
between the subwords within the bias phrases. This method can be applied to
various architectures because it only extends the embedding and output layers
in common E2E-ASR architectures. Experimental results demonstrate that the
proposed method improves the performance of bias phrases on English and
Japanese datasets.
|
[
-0.5362509489059448,
-0.789866030216217,
0.051758721470832825,
0.1206941306591034,
-0.444609671831131,
0.326017290353775,
-0.23359939455986023,
-0.4757329821586609,
0.433003306388855,
0.3514426648616791,
-0.37381511926651,
-0.285042405128479,
-0.5751510858535767,
-0.11790049076080322,
-0.457082599401474,
0.7780759334564209,
-0.17804646492004395,
0.19865162670612335,
0.07296539098024368,
-0.3555205762386322,
-0.8386408090591431,
-0.3355376422405243,
-0.5802369713783264,
-0.35274192690849304,
0.23430615663528442,
0.2050410360097885,
0.5088788866996765,
0.8976846933364868,
0.08084814995527267,
0.2561672329902649,
-0.3389799892902374,
0.17666368186473846,
-0.040513258427381516,
0.4924052059650421,
-0.3013092875480652,
-0.2915600538253784,
-0.3448711931705475,
-0.09044887125492096,
0.7499054074287415,
0.6323327422142029,
-0.1254521757364273,
-0.04927544295787811,
0.12965919077396393,
0.43835967779159546,
-0.5131606459617615,
0.18149787187576294,
-0.9625068306922913,
0.3790072798728943,
-0.3591037690639496,
-0.11421065777540207,
-0.06678259372711182,
0.20359055697917938,
0.7364179491996765,
-0.5324571132659912,
0.028173433616757393,
-0.2573273777961731,
0.6936790943145752,
0.6733210682868958,
-0.3447455167770386,
-0.5206453800201416,
-0.48212239146232605,
0.6501632928848267,
-0.4324171543121338,
0.36500999331474304,
0.033938929438591,
0.2752094864845276,
0.2101709097623825,
-0.6550464630126953,
-0.5102905035018921,
-0.027520431205630302,
0.0545661523938179,
0.08326437324285507,
0.21579667925834656,
-0.03303851932287216,
0.2457066774368286,
0.18227410316467285,
-0.005573503207415342,
0.21098190546035767,
-0.014979858882725239,
-0.24713632464408875,
0.3247588276863098,
0.018342530354857445,
0.23219478130340576,
0.033421676605939865,
-0.2977394461631775,
0.023286066949367523,
-0.5310553312301636,
-0.19373337924480438,
0.1317111998796463,
0.48842528462409973,
-0.3361511528491974,
0.28205326199531555,
-0.10033994168043137,
0.4694159924983978,
0.5521288514137268,
0.07192103564739227,
0.731857419013977,
-0.13456085324287415,
-0.22422781586647034,
0.43599358201026917,
0.3243919610977173,
0.12457870692014694,
0.13403330743312836,
-0.19471654295921326,
-0.06988120824098587,
-0.0015430140774697065,
0.1910516768693924,
-0.7110052704811096,
-0.15936650335788727,
0.22654740512371063,
-0.3142895996570587,
-0.29395562410354614,
0.05514301359653473,
-1.134413719177246,
-0.5373392701148987,
-0.42518454790115356,
0.289000540971756,
-0.2542118728160858,
-0.2122376412153244,
-0.17642845213413239,
-0.19233949482440948,
0.19841571152210236,
0.23873081803321838,
-0.45632216334342957,
0.18460150063037872,
0.4006716012954712,
0.8399388194084167,
-0.3792230486869812,
0.05208412930369377,
-0.7478141188621521,
0.3313470184803009,
-0.26423585414886475,
0.44637981057167053,
-0.8374153971672058,
-0.4140334129333496,
0.2180851548910141,
-0.050871770828962326,
0.1955098807811737,
-0.6634758114814758,
0.6160281896591187,
-0.5699722170829773,
0.32291701436042786,
-0.328961580991745,
-0.6039552688598633,
-0.027841860428452492,
-0.11153127998113632,
-0.5652884244918823,
0.8430368304252625,
-0.395888090133667,
-0.7604005932807922,
0.8540868163108826,
-0.6551536321640015,
-0.7753798365592957,
0.03353344649076462,
-0.6880184412002563,
-0.3481822907924652,
0.04063529893755913,
0.3823789656162262,
0.3501262366771698,
0.0573069229722023,
0.5461367964744568,
-0.014505279250442982,
-0.2765940725803375,
0.23610208928585052,
-0.644661545753479,
0.49370548129081726,
0.3016246557235718,
-0.836141049861908,
-0.10997344553470612,
-0.9713719487190247,
-0.15261879563331604,
-0.2901512086391449,
-0.649621844291687,
-0.5235404372215271,
0.49983763694763184,
0.006293368525803089,
0.11415809392929077,
0.16859693825244904,
-0.30779528617858887,
-0.03355903923511505,
-0.6867314577102661,
0.3326406478881836,
0.6626450419425964,
-0.3175041079521179,
0.7065438628196716,
0.17886005342006683,
0.22438332438468933,
0.2968669831752777,
-0.4624192416667938,
-0.3222951889038086,
-0.20895643532276154,
-0.8761290907859802,
-0.6125779151916504,
0.3882148861885071,
0.7313303351402283,
-0.8812307715415955,
0.7637466192245483,
-0.280728816986084,
0.019337818026542664,
-0.34522929787635803,
0.06065279617905617,
0.5737460851669312,
0.6352142691612244,
0.4006062150001526,
-0.3625611960887909,
-0.8379921317100525,
-0.8111527562141418,
-0.5510056614875793,
0.33500936627388,
-0.21345441043376923,
0.7203690409660339,
0.1208563819527626,
-0.3038221299648285,
0.8585468530654907,
-0.3015385568141937,
-0.5318472385406494,
0.024146050214767456,
0.21694326400756836,
0.2860476076602936,
0.46475914120674133,
0.41549763083457947,
-0.7222685217857361,
-0.6627358794212341,
-0.20919770002365112,
-0.5213457942008972,
-0.21269090473651886,
-0.18838225305080414,
-0.18748562037944794,
-0.03085889108479023,
0.5584047436714172,
-0.44526156783103943,
0.11864577978849411,
0.15646012127399445,
-0.38139843940734863,
0.016671113669872284,
0.07005757838487625,
-0.38212910294532776,
-1.0864055156707764,
-0.21160060167312622,
-0.055502865463495255,
-0.1910933554172516,
-0.7336370944976807,
0.031287193298339844,
-0.20852303504943848,
0.1413027048110962,
-0.4697940945625305,
0.6931604743003845,
-0.7600592374801636,
-0.14303073287010193,
-0.37098047137260437,
0.0685758888721466,
-0.09119150787591934,
0.08612007647752762,
0.2765904664993286,
0.8440893292427063,
0.8330856561660767,
-0.7296903133392334,
0.4085701107978821,
0.1462973654270172,
-0.35730502009391785,
0.38918164372444153,
-0.4771908223628998,
0.24246534705162048,
-0.20144914090633392,
0.5720723271369934,
-0.4951641261577606,
-0.2460937201976776,
-0.09584780037403107,
-0.3699289858341217,
0.8889411091804504,
-0.0035043801181018353,
-0.0550730898976326,
-0.25519946217536926,
-0.19226203858852386,
0.48406606912612915,
0.4436771869659424,
-0.7755608558654785,
0.6380719542503357,
0.9361958503723145,
0.1114816814661026,
-0.9373230338096619,
-0.8852043151855469,
0.3267059922218323,
-0.49602267146110535,
-0.1970125436782837,
0.8487052321434021,
0.4432239830493927,
-0.18959026038646698,
-0.101963110268116,
-0.17238007485866547,
-0.030477121472358704,
-0.19123131036758423,
0.002751897322013974,
-0.15174195170402527,
-0.0621144063770771,
0.2559453845024109,
0.24099615216255188,
0.032795604318380356,
-0.11818075180053711,
-0.6669431924819946,
0.7825096845626831,
0.12729071080684662,
0.07005295157432556,
-0.40831029415130615,
0.4108341634273529,
0.5776367783546448,
-0.05621766299009323,
0.3305146098136902,
0.9272107481956482,
-0.560839831829071,
-0.34980157017707825,
-0.5896250009536743,
-0.05281321331858635,
-0.5430114269256592,
0.7088207602500916,
-0.5742676854133606,
-0.8948918581008911,
0.540748655796051,
0.09609925746917725,
0.0007297687698155642,
0.15633049607276917,
0.8717708587646484,
0.03462005779147148,
0.9455037713050842,
0.1990302950143814,
-0.38911929726600647,
0.7248082756996155,
-0.050163086503744125,
0.040196679532527924,
-0.9886714220046997,
-0.1561967432498932,
-0.18535540997982025,
-0.49906787276268005,
-0.7391252517700195,
-0.8635474443435669,
0.3568825125694275,
-0.19989176094532013,
-0.40750446915626526,
0.02556408941745758,
-0.7241140007972717,
0.16972357034683228,
0.5884881019592285,
0.1900794357061386,
-0.15446650981903076,
0.31912967562675476,
-0.44795581698417664,
-0.10289627313613892,
-0.3721516728401184,
-0.24605707824230194,
0.9124821424484253,
0.5524150729179382,
0.6746817231178284,
0.0822390764951706,
0.46360448002815247,
0.5025855898857117,
-0.09111441671848297,
-0.8906822204589844,
0.4014703631401062,
-0.512722373008728,
-0.6897180080413818,
-0.44826024770736694,
-0.17389605939388275,
-0.6560041308403015,
0.2817724943161011,
-0.00343753001652658,
-0.563504695892334,
0.4476105868816376,
0.43158069252967834,
-0.40550166368484497,
0.06138705462217331,
-0.37881991267204285,
0.14193418622016907,
-0.22430896759033203,
-0.5359381437301636,
-0.25658974051475525,
-0.5968732237815857,
0.009169910103082657,
-0.016740653663873672,
0.08888723701238632,
-0.022866398096084595,
-0.317629873752594,
0.9489142298698425,
-0.48241761326789856,
0.8825596570968628,
-0.6472667455673218,
-0.01232117973268032,
0.33755815029144287,
-0.2385321408510208,
0.6821893453598022,
0.164383664727211,
-0.2040104866027832,
0.08117817342281342,
-0.38051390647888184,
-0.24131794273853302,
-0.35358187556266785,
0.7518725395202637,
-0.6227819323539734,
-0.3052075207233429,
-0.4333043694496155,
-0.5419883728027344,
-0.5103693604469299,
0.14252272248268127,
0.11239560693502426,
0.5296849012374878,
-0.017186172306537628,
0.23186327517032623,
0.8470917344093323,
-0.6484283804893494,
0.3930169939994812,
0.4683820605278015,
0.19267018139362335,
-0.4387091398239136,
0.7357728481292725,
0.2684805691242218,
-0.15216350555419922,
0.5371755957603455,
0.26549625396728516,
-0.3901158273220062,
-0.3542289435863495,
-0.7026056051254272,
-0.1333494484424591,
-0.3347078263759613,
-0.0023428271524608135,
-0.9736528992652893,
-0.17597147822380066,
-0.3541443645954132,
-0.19007086753845215,
-0.3446638882160187,
-0.36994820833206177,
-0.4057818651199341,
-0.2522144317626953,
0.34552550315856934,
0.0754169151186943,
-0.007730135694146156,
0.21245263516902924,
-0.4066023528575897,
0.32536351680755615,
0.4496487081050873,
0.31383320689201355,
0.019766047596931458,
-0.6498416662216187,
-0.21381640434265137,
-0.06080538034439087,
-0.06938065588474274,
-0.7817889451980591,
0.5724867582321167,
0.5840619206428528,
0.5986493825912476,
0.4950457811355591,
-0.14857403934001923,
0.7908837199211121,
-0.9585802555084229,
0.815799355506897,
0.2498822808265686,
-1.1474870443344116,
0.5995107889175415,
-0.49150457978248596,
0.2524712383747101,
0.4964240491390228,
0.11204846948385239,
-0.14732618629932404,
-0.13915327191352844,
-0.25974899530410767,
-1.2214574813842773,
0.5330238342285156,
-0.23400676250457764,
0.6520892977714539,
0.046594277024269104,
0.5734995603561401,
0.06824684888124466,
0.4892581105232239,
-0.42732545733451843,
-0.2988615334033966,
-0.3267202079296112,
-0.4753236770629883,
0.22040598094463348,
-0.3720206320285797,
-0.15402700006961823,
-0.5473193526268005,
0.4391714334487915,
-0.2084801346063614,
0.5679313540458679,
0.05675031989812851,
-0.10248860716819763,
0.1036653071641922,
0.14043168723583221,
0.298056960105896,
0.2723310887813568,
-0.09643790870904922,
0.2534986138343811,
0.4866781532764435,
-0.5849226713180542,
0.03827642649412155,
0.11480116099119186,
-0.5650099515914917,
0.24854804575443268,
0.10433713346719742,
0.9818233251571655,
0.16908060014247894,
-0.6600308418273926,
0.4059174358844757,
0.3099527955055237,
0.08181718736886978,
-0.6930049657821655,
0.09146299213171005,
-0.14470195770263672,
0.25666743516921997,
0.361537903547287,
-0.169307678937912,
0.4072572886943817,
-0.791990339756012,
0.6411522030830383,
0.5880195498466492,
-0.764424741268158,
-0.06711536645889282,
0.7034833431243896,
0.5934059023857117,
-0.10894186794757843,
0.32061469554901123,
-0.05132493004202843,
-0.7640082240104675,
0.5262744426727295,
0.432761549949646,
0.9225673675537109,
-0.3580370545387268,
-0.14215737581253052,
0.19229532778263092,
-0.04832473024725914,
0.1456693857908249,
0.41903817653656006,
-0.1940356194972992,
-0.9256051778793335,
-0.4366730749607086,
-0.6656975746154785,
-0.1841384470462799,
0.23118598759174347,
-0.6440085768699646,
0.5275945663452148,
-0.3997291028499603,
-0.2815321385860443,
-0.160254567861557,
-0.0036633166018873453,
-0.7014526128768921,
0.521531879901886,
0.3506128191947937,
0.7323605418205261,
-0.5572777986526489,
1.0436179637908936,
0.7857266068458557,
-0.1144004836678505,
-0.5648967027664185,
0.29889997839927673,
0.2111450433731079,
-0.8599894642829895,
0.7342252731323242,
0.17274078726768494,
-0.09778392314910889,
-0.21455299854278564,
-0.1809108555316925,
-1.1623313426971436,
1.052947759628296,
-0.05719764530658722,
-0.648344099521637,
-0.20775094628334045,
0.007591718807816505,
0.5150299668312073,
-0.5542635917663574,
0.20900650322437286,
0.603801429271698,
0.4214252531528473,
0.09277354925870895,
-0.9136085510253906,
0.10681061446666718,
-0.2434261441230774,
-0.04328114539384842,
-0.08366336673498154,
-0.5287228226661682,
0.824976921081543,
0.21133923530578613,
-0.07872974872589111,
-0.25232258439064026,
0.9325836896896362,
-0.08585003018379211,
0.3401319980621338,
0.708644449710846,
0.46318140625953674,
0.7774497866630554,
-0.11642550677061081,
0.5795204043388367,
-0.36072179675102234,
0.07153487205505371,
1.4633541107177734,
-0.4308338463306427,
0.6686905026435852,
0.260314017534256,
-0.07939452677965164,
0.45696204900741577,
0.3584914207458496,
-0.007821561768651009,
0.9038884043693542,
0.3981238305568695,
-0.3072334825992584,
0.021995989605784416,
-0.2657356858253479,
-0.39567089080810547,
0.675040602684021,
0.7016333341598511,
-0.6342877745628357,
0.10565996915102005,
0.1843952238559723,
0.3079943060874939,
-0.0637718066573143,
-0.2455195188522339,
0.8194723129272461,
0.23366013169288635,
-0.4747878909111023,
0.3451930582523346,
-0.060911063104867935,
1.1611027717590332,
-0.19190993905067444,
0.15074554085731506,
-0.004578983876854181,
0.3059208393096924,
-0.17287597060203552,
-0.4810831844806671,
0.5006647109985352,
0.18605470657348633,
-0.21120977401733398,
-0.15962529182434082,
0.7544822692871094,
-0.593657374382019,
-0.505035936832428,
0.41963618993759155,
0.48049184679985046,
-0.04173283651471138,
0.2545108497142792,
-0.6625335812568665,
-0.0020111436024308205,
-0.16283540427684784,
-0.23486566543579102,
0.4256921112537384,
0.47888413071632385,
0.08617524057626724,
0.5064730644226074,
0.33197838068008423,
0.30902764201164246,
0.2739662528038025,
0.3403396010398865,
0.9949346780776978,
-0.31997865438461304,
-0.7730722427368164,
-0.6300075650215149,
0.482929527759552,
-0.5363388657569885,
-0.2143985778093338,
0.5491130948066711,
0.4335430860519409,
0.6858991980552673,
0.2862164080142975,
1.1039073467254639,
-0.13535262644290924,
0.9787911772727966,
-0.545286238193512,
0.6435943841934204,
-0.5405587553977966,
0.4883653521537781,
-0.5135915279388428,
-0.6406012773513794,
-0.25864073634147644,
0.8423621654510498,
-0.08941053599119186,
0.08063008636236191,
0.4021497070789337,
0.4988420009613037,
-0.1343265175819397,
-0.287888765335083,
0.1979752629995346,
0.5010449886322021,
0.4151758551597595,
0.23833690583705902,
0.5722435712814331,
-0.19552931189537048,
0.13363799452781677,
-0.04059765487909317,
-0.3183577060699463,
-0.16100874543190002,
-0.8735837340354919,
-0.8341759443283081,
-0.4426107108592987,
-0.42143285274505615,
-0.4575803875923157,
0.276816189289093,
1.0437803268432617,
0.8411975502967834,
-0.9505404233932495,
-0.005149137228727341,
-0.18270857632160187,
-0.08848964422941208,
-0.05365113914012909,
-0.29019463062286377,
0.47721341252326965,
-0.4273357093334198,
-0.9065685272216797,
0.5665616989135742,
0.07668519020080566,
-0.3372938930988312,
-0.26886090636253357,
0.003228231566026807,
0.033936817198991776,
0.32996633648872375,
0.6809532046318054,
0.05121602490544319,
-0.667086124420166,
-0.46417030692100525,
-0.22424569725990295,
0.3393612504005432,
-0.08546382188796997,
0.8995668888092041,
-0.9590409398078918,
0.4985588490962982,
0.535826563835144,
0.8289122581481934,
0.4783403277397156,
-0.03017093613743782,
0.7750769853591919,
-0.8422860503196716,
0.41539716720581055,
0.3790087103843689,
0.3886551260948181,
0.2867683470249176,
-0.27020931243896484,
0.2735059857368469,
0.25858375430107117,
-0.20783589780330658,
-0.880510687828064,
0.36175158619880676,
-0.7756979465484619,
-0.28090333938598633,
1.232539176940918,
-0.08821847289800644,
0.2625839114189148,
-0.2995540201663971,
-0.022598426789045334,
0.5503368973731995,
-0.5806077718734741,
0.8576484322547913,
0.44236230850219727,
-0.09799595177173615,
-0.03992394730448723,
-0.41803380846977234,
0.5830655694007874,
0.5232775211334229,
-0.42531928420066833,
-0.10499806702136993,
0.5847397446632385,
0.22879181802272797,
0.12444461137056351,
0.5381815433502197,
-0.17468677461147308,
-0.1654629111289978,
-0.16256779432296753,
-0.254382461309433,
0.08716125041246414,
-0.31423020362854004,
-0.2928415834903717,
0.06941714137792587,
-0.29712560772895813,
-0.366463840007782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13329v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13329v1
|
High Performance P300 Spellers Using GPT2 Word Prediction With Cross-Subject Training
| 2024-05-22T04:15:41 | 2024-05-22T04:15:41 |
Nithin Parthasarathy, James Soetedjo, Saarang Panchavati, Nitya Parthasarathy, Corey Arnold, Nader Pouratian, William Speier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SY, eess.SP, eess.SY
|
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) severely impairs patients' ability to
communicate, often leading to a decline in their quality of life within a few
years of diagnosis. The P300 speller brain-computer interface (BCI) offers an
alternative communication method by interpreting a subject's EEG response to
characters presented on a grid interface.
This paper addresses the common speed limitations encountered in training
efficient P300-based multi-subject classifiers by introducing innovative
"across-subject" classifiers. We leverage a combination of the
second-generation Generative Pre-Trained Transformer (GPT2) and Dijkstra's
algorithm to optimize stimuli and suggest word completion choices based on
typing history. Additionally, we employ a multi-layered smoothing technique to
accommodate out-of-vocabulary (OOV) words.
Through extensive simulations involving random sampling of EEG data from
subjects, we demonstrate significant speed enhancements in typing passages
containing rare and OOV words. These optimizations result in approximately 10%
improvement in character-level typing speed and up to 40% improvement in
multi-word prediction. We demonstrate that augmenting standard row/column
highlighting techniques with layered word prediction yields close-to-optimal
performance.
Furthermore, we explore both "within-subject" and "across-subject" training
techniques, showing that speed improvements are consistent across both
approaches.
|
[
-0.6096566915512085,
-0.5013853311538696,
0.6971385478973389,
0.3293534219264984,
-0.07248149067163467,
0.15474438667297363,
-0.19509099423885345,
-0.5799793004989624,
0.15607388317584991,
0.045668814331293106,
-0.27352485060691833,
-0.29152992367744446,
-0.8721948862075806,
-0.10931456834077835,
0.053899019956588745,
0.5906823873519897,
-0.26501455903053284,
0.25637972354888916,
0.04023442789912224,
-0.10778070986270905,
-0.5521255135536194,
-0.4027511477470398,
-0.6903181076049805,
-0.4467848241329193,
0.6306512951850891,
0.44701552391052246,
0.4615081250667572,
0.1641039252281189,
0.3214007019996643,
0.28542402386665344,
-0.280626505613327,
-0.003542980644851923,
-0.11762568354606628,
0.1191280335187912,
-0.0017245005583390594,
-0.4122637212276459,
-0.7325292825698853,
-0.16528044641017914,
0.6035793423652649,
0.8211941123008728,
-0.2598535120487213,
0.05764121934771538,
0.29512810707092285,
0.5533861517906189,
-0.8544578552246094,
0.04450593888759613,
-0.4090997576713562,
0.2849656939506531,
-0.5207840204238892,
-0.06028132885694504,
-0.5676309466362,
-0.03982693701982498,
0.1381518840789795,
-0.6558826565742493,
0.2622247636318207,
0.5665470957756042,
0.6997194290161133,
-0.03792097419500351,
-0.24778354167938232,
0.04116407036781311,
-0.5034831762313843,
0.344613641500473,
-0.4316321313381195,
0.7947876453399658,
0.5169524550437927,
0.3314603269100189,
-0.10970424860715866,
-0.6500135064125061,
-0.7639713883399963,
-0.1371735781431198,
-0.022325728088617325,
0.3199757933616638,
-0.4854213297367096,
0.5099732875823975,
0.459576278924942,
0.1367720365524292,
-0.881100058555603,
0.3008310794830322,
-0.7362977862358093,
-0.4806043207645416,
0.5150420069694519,
0.013986107893288136,
0.3225052058696747,
0.20605193078517914,
0.11377175152301788,
0.02728934958577156,
-0.670992910861969,
-0.09723126143217087,
0.5844976902008057,
0.10432202368974686,
0.2686728239059448,
0.8619176745414734,
-0.09554769098758698,
0.6359357237815857,
0.2131025791168213,
0.01883835904300213,
0.6638616919517517,
0.19662755727767944,
0.04088130220770836,
0.29269230365753174,
0.39302924275398254,
0.335405170917511,
0.12921307981014252,
-0.6985568404197693,
0.03702431544661522,
0.22094298899173737,
0.3378148078918457,
-0.6239022612571716,
-0.4770512878894806,
0.30155670642852783,
-0.3905981481075287,
0.37382233142852783,
-0.09136036783456802,
-0.8189669847488403,
-0.5471534132957458,
-0.35949432849884033,
0.459601491689682,
-0.7598241567611694,
-0.2563791275024414,
-0.016980720683932304,
-0.3843521177768707,
-0.02527373656630516,
0.25762516260147095,
-0.8414298892021179,
0.21670503914356232,
0.2626630663871765,
0.8769100904464722,
-0.1520332247018814,
-0.6886124014854431,
-0.7377671003341675,
0.4500975012779236,
-0.21516919136047363,
1.2066209316253662,
-0.32781094312667847,
-0.2647354304790497,
-0.19610369205474854,
0.024439698085188866,
-0.23608103394508362,
-0.5588169693946838,
0.3643183708190918,
-0.4867600202560425,
0.048819947987794876,
-0.32057276368141174,
-0.6269752383232117,
-0.09658405929803848,
-0.49867329001426697,
-0.5246260762214661,
1.005519986152649,
0.0662718117237091,
-0.7716634273529053,
0.8281301259994507,
-0.6788944005966187,
-0.9172741174697876,
0.5055834650993347,
0.19699817895889282,
-0.357025146484375,
0.42507243156433105,
0.11112172901630402,
0.4262036383152008,
0.15202179551124573,
-0.1348511278629303,
-0.45166319608688354,
-0.6950273513793945,
-0.25305548310279846,
-0.10910190641880035,
0.010414895601570606,
-0.03781169280409813,
-0.24307595193386078,
0.0999729111790657,
-0.7229323387145996,
0.15625633299350739,
-0.26383596658706665,
-0.29183080792427063,
-0.10845013707876205,
0.018282020464539528,
0.2624489963054657,
0.3662550449371338,
-0.12068775296211243,
-0.7863462567329407,
-0.083383709192276,
-0.3307955861091614,
0.4597626328468323,
0.5586652755737305,
-0.4297657012939453,
0.3851192891597748,
-0.23752813041210175,
0.4039759337902069,
0.12413506209850311,
-0.0337364487349987,
0.06288186460733414,
-0.7234268188476562,
-0.6573578119277954,
-0.3412063419818878,
0.07906650751829147,
0.842399001121521,
-0.8295535445213318,
0.7022565007209778,
-0.13629215955734253,
-0.5524328351020813,
-0.7667492032051086,
-0.06309963017702103,
0.3083847165107727,
0.2732519507408142,
0.7838228344917297,
-0.3914446234703064,
-0.41223928332328796,
-0.8746508955955505,
-0.4724484384059906,
-0.030798576772212982,
-0.43486544489860535,
0.2512763440608978,
0.08952611684799194,
-0.16328293085098267,
0.6057925224304199,
-0.7368344068527222,
-0.5003467202186584,
-0.3458908796310425,
0.7380259037017822,
-0.3638102412223816,
0.3240450918674469,
-0.06858736276626587,
-0.4301653802394867,
-0.2721225917339325,
-0.29635512828826904,
-0.4236825704574585,
0.026403484866023064,
0.17522338032722473,
0.06286757439374924,
0.42246952652931213,
0.6320584416389465,
-0.28467196226119995,
0.6602127552032471,
0.36535340547561646,
-0.35737842321395874,
0.2629868686199188,
-0.7858648300170898,
-0.04281620308756828,
-0.6013284921646118,
0.09294192492961884,
0.4382571280002594,
0.19522057473659515,
-0.5927574634552002,
-0.4501868188381195,
0.24389903247356415,
-0.1324722170829773,
-0.45618510246276855,
0.2841896712779999,
-0.6811297535896301,
-0.14824868738651276,
-0.5106195211410522,
0.020393066108226776,
-0.28917521238327026,
0.5661971569061279,
0.22553300857543945,
1.1343095302581787,
0.6614875793457031,
-0.4703267216682434,
0.1588699072599411,
0.3536961078643799,
-0.3749798834323883,
0.7965905666351318,
-0.6901111602783203,
0.46222954988479614,
-0.5702476501464844,
0.28117790818214417,
-0.9985648393630981,
-0.027942009270191193,
-0.10715379565954208,
-0.17757682502269745,
0.5566366314888,
0.2685062289237976,
-0.5094020366668701,
-0.9236751198768616,
-0.04357125610113144,
0.24297674000263214,
0.4559755027294159,
-0.3950914144515991,
0.9563522934913635,
0.4639403522014618,
-0.19324646890163422,
-0.15430177748203278,
-1.0093426704406738,
0.16764432191848755,
-0.13642668724060059,
-0.46623679995536804,
0.4995391070842743,
0.06859967857599258,
0.27389800548553467,
-0.2839946746826172,
-0.2560601234436035,
0.06367754191160202,
-0.18133684992790222,
0.44335922598838806,
0.06179855018854141,
0.0845806673169136,
0.27748703956604004,
0.47947096824645996,
-0.14374081790447235,
-0.26901406049728394,
-0.13679203391075134,
0.6910080313682556,
-0.17953357100486755,
-0.31327271461486816,
-0.6375332474708557,
0.3526364266872406,
0.43707719445228577,
-0.2507728040218353,
0.8298530578613281,
0.6940282583236694,
-0.4056316614151001,
-0.0025048856623470783,
-0.9357808828353882,
-0.3595694899559021,
-0.5036311745643616,
0.8144283890724182,
-0.7685223817825317,
-0.7520895004272461,
0.24895353615283966,
-0.26970812678337097,
-0.6237895488739014,
0.15670789778232574,
0.21352189779281616,
-0.2869366407394409,
1.0157943964004517,
0.5599145889282227,
0.08765984326601028,
0.30769965052604675,
0.05852822959423065,
0.4090958535671234,
-1.3272967338562012,
-0.41940003633499146,
-0.07331029325723648,
-0.32275390625,
-0.47459086775779724,
-0.14543110132217407,
0.5047811269760132,
0.12841574847698212,
-0.3689800500869751,
0.5558682680130005,
-0.570797860622406,
0.24847103655338287,
0.8602864742279053,
0.6875753402709961,
-0.17456047236919403,
0.004423116333782673,
-0.16564418375492096,
-0.2377198040485382,
-0.6542620062828064,
-0.34726834297180176,
1.3490517139434814,
0.3621283769607544,
0.37264105677604675,
-0.24342136085033417,
0.3192020654678345,
0.21942643821239471,
0.3486393988132477,
-0.6378984451293945,
0.5349541306495667,
-0.38977324962615967,
-0.41846826672554016,
-0.3582422137260437,
0.041473835706710815,
-0.7023308873176575,
0.108590267598629,
-0.3474850058555603,
-1.0040698051452637,
0.24571123719215393,
0.22435937821865082,
-0.7148478627204895,
0.40867534279823303,
-0.8512951135635376,
0.8152909278869629,
-0.05790673941373825,
-0.4835757911205292,
-0.4162901043891907,
-0.8342591524124146,
0.07397031784057617,
-0.10675924271345139,
-0.19076849520206451,
-0.05559912323951721,
0.09345786273479462,
0.6832783818244934,
-0.01799858920276165,
0.40164679288864136,
-0.25500085949897766,
-0.01113808061927557,
-0.039908815175294876,
-0.30274590849876404,
0.2555856704711914,
-0.31843581795692444,
-0.008286607451736927,
0.49189692735671997,
-0.19052985310554504,
-0.4029969274997711,
-0.35259130597114563,
0.3995877802371979,
-0.7590455412864685,
-0.45915478467941284,
-0.5991034507751465,
-0.5078890919685364,
-0.5889809131622314,
-0.008231556974351406,
0.49088555574417114,
0.42107483744621277,
-0.05892949551343918,
-0.25752192735671997,
0.6329148411750793,
-0.25496962666511536,
0.39681440591812134,
0.4537162482738495,
0.26977458596229553,
-0.5689583420753479,
1.1515718698501587,
0.47300660610198975,
0.021813323721289635,
0.33451998233795166,
-0.24141564965248108,
-0.2609351575374603,
-0.6394246816635132,
-0.43883195519447327,
0.2671448290348053,
-0.47291773557662964,
0.1202196255326271,
-0.7316045761108398,
-0.0707305297255516,
-0.5033884644508362,
-0.09446168690919876,
-0.015262548811733723,
-0.07809579372406006,
-0.018425902351737022,
-0.08937663584947586,
-0.054737888276576996,
0.43596524000167847,
-0.014564446173608303,
0.7632371783256531,
-0.35123300552368164,
0.5088706612586975,
0.33440569043159485,
0.6025111675262451,
-0.15164344012737274,
-0.42519474029541016,
-0.04471438378095627,
-0.19785213470458984,
-0.6002534031867981,
-1.0079972743988037,
0.2801685333251953,
0.14225491881370544,
0.5309127569198608,
0.12256080657243729,
-0.2292661815881729,
0.7248650789260864,
-0.8718132376670837,
0.5028711557388306,
0.27277636528015137,
-1.0925085544586182,
0.47167932987213135,
0.10007258504629135,
0.20307569205760956,
0.7001001834869385,
0.3908114433288574,
-0.7453240156173706,
-0.31132885813713074,
-0.3375941514968872,
-1.2094000577926636,
1.0317211151123047,
0.1257626861333847,
-0.385720819234848,
0.14655868709087372,
0.43601980805397034,
0.11189936846494675,
0.27202868461608887,
-0.10652347654104233,
-0.4539964199066162,
-0.17185840010643005,
-0.19431667029857635,
-0.27164438366889954,
-0.3447277843952179,
0.15208370983600616,
-0.4764949083328247,
0.9519380331039429,
-0.2586769163608551,
0.7491668462753296,
0.14573542773723602,
-0.1999841034412384,
-0.11599849164485931,
0.13931111991405487,
0.5548684597015381,
0.6694613099098206,
-0.18435759842395782,
0.09564948081970215,
0.5999599695205688,
-0.8275598287582397,
0.06260887533426285,
0.6221314072608948,
0.05603516846895218,
-0.20332275331020355,
0.1425061821937561,
1.2887253761291504,
-0.10359065234661102,
-0.48536473512649536,
0.45456555485725403,
0.021089226007461548,
-0.15598370134830475,
-0.11453013122081757,
-0.280424028635025,
0.03117380104959011,
0.2599705159664154,
0.3752153515815735,
0.25853022933006287,
0.3143332302570343,
-0.2779553234577179,
0.23824477195739746,
0.25902339816093445,
-0.1985238641500473,
-0.3141034245491028,
0.9658423662185669,
0.10442904382944107,
-0.30336782336235046,
0.7061255574226379,
-0.33806702494621277,
-0.48043814301490784,
0.3879418969154358,
0.36528000235557556,
1.004436731338501,
-0.3304511308670044,
0.11660917103290558,
0.17518781125545502,
0.19148756563663483,
-0.28695395588874817,
0.48090529441833496,
-0.0785372406244278,
-0.7892511487007141,
-0.317807137966156,
-0.41940173506736755,
-0.4054199457168579,
0.0864301547408104,
-0.603366494178772,
0.4451819360256195,
-0.19231215119361877,
-0.3110921382904053,
0.2848587930202484,
-0.05158873274922371,
-0.7468137145042419,
0.4959317743778229,
0.549061119556427,
0.8811286687850952,
-0.8694241642951965,
1.0236988067626953,
0.9595210552215576,
-0.47276705503463745,
-0.724226176738739,
0.49969542026519775,
-0.23769830167293549,
-0.7334386706352234,
0.6192265748977661,
0.3353506326675415,
0.04291357845067978,
0.11183209717273712,
0.12190189957618713,
-0.6690086722373962,
1.2136062383651733,
0.2820888161659241,
-0.8984429836273193,
-0.23448476195335388,
0.2996916174888611,
0.471493661403656,
0.24825167655944824,
0.781567394733429,
0.545518159866333,
0.5651203393936157,
0.1368684470653534,
-1.1073107719421387,
0.09318685531616211,
-0.036828115582466125,
0.39371880888938904,
0.11689173430204391,
-0.7103774547576904,
0.3441731929779053,
-0.05254434049129486,
-0.09496887028217316,
-0.03500900790095329,
1.1591264009475708,
0.4362810552120209,
0.5164782404899597,
0.5180660486221313,
0.719441294670105,
0.9936994314193726,
-0.24609516561031342,
0.717566192150116,
-0.7478640675544739,
0.030216911807656288,
0.9008663892745972,
-0.6533461809158325,
0.7871189713478088,
0.5700823664665222,
-0.3465310335159302,
0.378185898065567,
0.33219584822654724,
-0.01910831220448017,
0.5739427208900452,
0.6040135622024536,
-0.47067704796791077,
-0.22513163089752197,
0.2628830671310425,
-0.35027989745140076,
0.3306995630264282,
0.1702011525630951,
-0.03776165097951889,
0.043089210987091064,
0.82911616563797,
0.028494320809841156,
0.13451655209064484,
-0.275547057390213,
0.6687787771224976,
-0.19644606113433838,
-0.7812569737434387,
0.1336018443107605,
0.1830090880393982,
0.9700269103050232,
-0.3834758400917053,
0.28215810656547546,
-0.0670589953660965,
0.5956177115440369,
0.0010563727701082826,
-0.7389252781867981,
0.2909945845603943,
-0.5216286182403564,
-0.020167697221040726,
-0.07020619511604309,
0.6016996502876282,
-0.6309494376182556,
-0.5873017311096191,
0.3593910038471222,
0.2285512238740921,
0.22969113290309906,
-0.47672396898269653,
-0.35723957419395447,
0.012804733589291573,
-0.698314905166626,
-0.1490909457206726,
0.38583898544311523,
0.3432614803314209,
-0.08827574551105499,
0.5230001211166382,
0.021057141944766045,
0.36857712268829346,
0.014579595997929573,
-0.10310385376214981,
0.9105888605117798,
-0.4355373680591583,
-0.4026143252849579,
-0.5588278770446777,
0.15262775123119354,
-0.0868557021021843,
-0.4887186586856842,
0.6669521927833557,
0.8566488027572632,
0.6488777995109558,
0.021957531571388245,
0.7966183423995972,
0.025494344532489777,
0.5397083759307861,
-0.28094446659088135,
0.8627916574478149,
-0.4127359092235565,
-0.3642979562282562,
-0.21996095776557922,
-0.771619975566864,
-0.23398582637310028,
0.5395575761795044,
-0.578692615032196,
0.28936511278152466,
1.0991525650024414,
0.619389533996582,
0.11493871361017227,
0.4975472688674927,
0.1808365136384964,
0.12235003709793091,
0.0826970636844635,
0.8328301310539246,
0.3321707546710968,
-0.48447686433792114,
0.15316453576087952,
-0.3767673969268799,
-0.48251625895500183,
0.11300507932901382,
-0.6270100474357605,
-0.8452721834182739,
-0.5831008553504944,
-0.6042333245277405,
-0.4213411808013916,
0.6810845732688904,
0.6409631967544556,
0.8546366095542908,
-0.9254786968231201,
-0.04426350072026253,
-0.420240581035614,
-0.391175240278244,
-0.4740900695323944,
-0.13658349215984344,
0.6006250381469727,
-0.21897193789482117,
-0.5586652159690857,
0.5170532464981079,
0.12278161197900772,
0.028089137747883797,
-0.041468724608421326,
0.04874485358595848,
-0.00007666213059565052,
-0.09595484286546707,
0.59613436460495,
0.19766223430633545,
-0.5995992422103882,
-0.24331824481487274,
-0.11452029645442963,
0.14369064569473267,
0.09304771572351456,
0.7715805768966675,
-0.8594547510147095,
0.16933110356330872,
0.28855881094932556,
0.27321213483810425,
0.7114060521125793,
-0.15178629755973816,
0.516516387462616,
-0.30186378955841064,
0.1971132755279541,
0.13451069593429565,
0.37094947695732117,
0.23470662534236908,
-0.538477897644043,
0.09880395233631134,
0.42358332872390747,
-0.4978245198726654,
-0.5838028788566589,
-0.06924762576818466,
-0.727023184299469,
-0.3549216687679291,
1.3032060861587524,
-0.053894490003585815,
-0.13633418083190918,
-0.2856488823890686,
-0.568443238735199,
0.44178247451782227,
-0.4186805188655853,
0.7489933967590332,
0.740697979927063,
-0.29883015155792236,
-0.0836317166686058,
-0.3764023780822754,
0.37731269001960754,
0.6386563181877136,
-0.7721351385116577,
-0.13921284675598145,
0.4466762840747833,
0.12053640186786652,
0.13515587151050568,
0.4552707374095917,
0.18357020616531372,
0.22733251750469208,
-0.15939109027385712,
0.6029610633850098,
-0.20606961846351624,
-0.5976243019104004,
-0.37989485263824463,
0.5863500833511353,
-0.20693626999855042,
-0.3473023772239685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13326v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13326v1
|
Mosaic IT: Enhancing Instruction Tuning with Data Mosaics
| 2024-05-22T04:08:20 | 2024-05-22T04:08:20 |
Ming Li, Pei Chen, Chenguang Wang, Hongyu Zhao, Yijun Liang, Yupeng Hou, Fuxiao Liu, Tianyi Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Finetuning large language models with a variety of instruction-response pairs
has enhanced their capability to understand and follow instructions. Current
instruction tuning primarily relies on teacher models or human intervention to
generate and refine the instructions and responses, which are costly,
non-sustainable, and may lack diversity. In this paper, we introduce Mosaic
Instruction Tuning (Mosaic-IT), a human/model-free method that can efficiently
create rich and diverse augmentations from existing instruction tuning data to
enhance the finetuned LLM.Mosaic-IT randomly concatenates multiple instruction
data into one and trains the model to produce the corresponding responses with
predefined higher-level meta-instructions to strengthen its multi-step
instruction-following and format-following skills. Our extensive evaluations
demonstrate a superior performance and training efficiency of Mosaic-IT, which
achieves consistent performance improvements over various benchmarks and an 80%
reduction in training costs compared with original instruction tuning. Our
codes and data are available at https://github.com/tianyi-lab/Mosaic-IT.
|
[
-0.3860182464122772,
-0.5423661470413208,
-0.1050182580947876,
0.3690214157104492,
-0.2354256957769394,
0.16327092051506042,
-0.3382413387298584,
-0.05841612443327904,
0.05458149313926697,
0.616222620010376,
-0.8061277270317078,
-0.6888747215270996,
-0.4865935742855072,
-0.15426239371299744,
-0.2259366512298584,
0.7593529224395752,
0.28577616810798645,
0.5140904188156128,
-0.028483325615525246,
0.15484334528446198,
-0.6590418219566345,
0.20583468675613403,
-0.39125972986221313,
-0.09051964432001114,
0.49660834670066833,
1.1650220155715942,
0.6659976840019226,
1.3886606693267822,
0.4255320131778717,
0.30259233713150024,
0.23284150660037994,
0.6382877826690674,
-0.5979164242744446,
-0.1555006206035614,
-0.15175649523735046,
-0.4413343071937561,
-0.5305613279342651,
0.05193191021680832,
0.8255210518836975,
0.7591419816017151,
-0.19000668823719025,
0.4349205195903778,
0.2903177738189697,
0.9616597294807434,
-0.8406782150268555,
0.1804785579442978,
-0.5510272979736328,
0.08325249701738358,
-0.26635244488716125,
-0.4704764783382416,
-0.655752420425415,
-0.679051399230957,
-0.3042783737182617,
-0.6594358086585999,
0.321546345949173,
0.03571135550737381,
0.2687757611274719,
0.43944817781448364,
-0.281154602766037,
-0.13213562965393066,
-0.5684807896614075,
0.6320703625679016,
-0.5504304766654968,
0.26635053753852844,
0.4895687699317932,
0.3200925588607788,
-0.08781355619430542,
-0.39405709505081177,
-0.3099144995212555,
-0.20949313044548035,
0.18330532312393188,
0.2799205780029297,
0.15873152017593384,
0.020843179896473885,
0.18679654598236084,
0.6893076300621033,
-0.39912211894989014,
0.09214574098587036,
-0.3974977731704712,
-0.025456370785832405,
0.5044962763786316,
0.6195959448814392,
0.47051143646240234,
0.3610776364803314,
-0.17913411557674408,
-0.4237998425960541,
-0.8260020017623901,
0.165399432182312,
0.5446227192878723,
0.31534242630004883,
-0.17103612422943115,
0.6828776001930237,
-0.14980971813201904,
0.9112618565559387,
0.18505613505840302,
0.026082761585712433,
0.17170527577400208,
-0.3759039640426636,
-0.03345032408833504,
-0.018285255879163742,
0.48183637857437134,
0.5036585927009583,
0.27795299887657166,
-0.2854614853858948,
0.0332498773932457,
-0.0644448772072792,
0.27382639050483704,
-1.0412144660949707,
-0.33493277430534363,
-0.30724987387657166,
-0.24390603601932526,
-0.05360083281993866,
0.12012738734483719,
-0.66457200050354,
-0.3182441294193268,
-0.5481123924255371,
0.3115965723991394,
-0.719357430934906,
-0.0013011920964345336,
0.23641324043273926,
-0.027114303782582283,
0.3413228988647461,
0.2050449550151825,
-1.3292113542556763,
0.21084171533584595,
0.7841469049453735,
0.5594545602798462,
-0.1287831962108612,
-0.4256417453289032,
-0.8164534568786621,
0.24094326794147491,
-0.6024394631385803,
0.7188695073127747,
-0.9922600388526917,
-0.37934020161628723,
-0.27896061539649963,
-0.019375070929527283,
-0.2960658073425293,
-0.5715407729148865,
0.3000129163265228,
-0.4706205427646637,
0.2616168260574341,
-0.27345627546310425,
-0.7397045493125916,
-0.10124153643846512,
0.059283167123794556,
-0.7870845198631287,
0.616029679775238,
0.1872798353433609,
-0.551291823387146,
0.2240186482667923,
-0.7280957698822021,
-0.5247888565063477,
-0.048453547060489655,
0.11531797051429749,
-0.46914148330688477,
0.015670234337449074,
0.4173261523246765,
0.26009640097618103,
-0.4986882507801056,
-0.08155913650989532,
-0.17550349235534668,
-0.8191163539886475,
-0.2255755364894867,
-0.4679814875125885,
0.6937592625617981,
0.19194398820400238,
-0.24303632974624634,
0.1810392439365387,
-1.127898097038269,
0.2251710295677185,
-0.18756666779518127,
-0.7925190329551697,
-0.025807194411754608,
-0.0932137593626976,
-0.26989802718162537,
-0.3696983754634857,
0.21416325867176056,
-0.4696057140827179,
0.6595495939254761,
-0.47777339816093445,
0.12042893469333649,
0.7687172293663025,
-0.05447642132639885,
0.91583251953125,
-0.40353846549987793,
0.4161284267902374,
-0.019405532628297806,
0.16619226336479187,
-0.683552622795105,
-0.5930333137512207,
-0.7221514582633972,
-0.5902541279792786,
0.3356674611568451,
0.7216589450836182,
-0.7858951687812805,
0.24768424034118652,
-0.20418953895568848,
-0.3005056381225586,
-1.0786272287368774,
0.3573059141635895,
0.4626663625240326,
0.5329139232635498,
0.5271136164665222,
-0.28707998991012573,
-0.6314098238945007,
-0.7295224666595459,
-0.3598254919052124,
0.5038347244262695,
-0.18049511313438416,
0.17758719623088837,
0.11438016593456268,
-0.2577323615550995,
0.6548967361450195,
-0.3105510175228119,
-0.08523014932870865,
0.16916818916797638,
0.2909766435623169,
0.12031257897615433,
0.7460118532180786,
0.14404532313346863,
-0.29223304986953735,
-0.7800928950309753,
-0.04893035441637039,
-0.36840203404426575,
-0.05747782811522484,
-0.0004054852470289916,
-0.19474773108959198,
-0.06057346239686012,
0.07293037325143814,
-0.014501478523015976,
0.2549978494644165,
0.4977710247039795,
-0.3800881803035736,
0.18130606412887573,
-0.43112313747406006,
0.5127454996109009,
-1.265388011932373,
-0.19650492072105408,
-0.2653999626636505,
-0.06821439415216446,
-0.564254105091095,
0.2197229266166687,
0.4672301411628723,
0.10666687786579132,
-0.12352137267589569,
0.15893664956092834,
-0.6249083280563354,
-0.1098143681883812,
-0.3147714138031006,
-0.3808388411998749,
-0.14544013142585754,
0.5627977252006531,
-0.197702094912529,
1.2359192371368408,
0.5384339690208435,
-0.40952685475349426,
0.30332714319229126,
0.24224530160427094,
-0.6726672649383545,
0.2178952544927597,
-0.26288902759552,
0.2522098124027252,
-0.121595099568367,
-0.29397937655448914,
-0.9283300042152405,
-0.36753958463668823,
0.36909639835357666,
-0.05000624060630798,
0.5703184008598328,
-0.1652502566576004,
-0.4138873815536499,
-0.20313876867294312,
-0.5146880745887756,
0.19325223565101624,
0.5080569982528687,
-0.7579324841499329,
0.5675695538520813,
-0.025382187217473984,
0.12038735300302505,
-0.7368125319480896,
-0.5719417929649353,
0.16785374283790588,
0.045145612210035324,
-0.7547951936721802,
0.430205762386322,
-0.40921562910079956,
-0.043119147419929504,
-0.17055708169937134,
-0.01664900593459606,
-0.15815798938274384,
0.219293475151062,
0.1272740215063095,
0.24420927464962006,
-0.4352739751338959,
-0.10828648507595062,
0.3667781949043274,
-0.14767222106456757,
-0.3650778532028198,
-0.21151913702487946,
0.4534262716770172,
0.04235309734940529,
-0.5137186050415039,
-0.6159901022911072,
0.47482752799987793,
0.4112774133682251,
-0.36395710706710815,
0.7300181984901428,
0.7792053818702698,
0.1001509428024292,
-0.3286762833595276,
-0.47959595918655396,
-0.30499887466430664,
-0.5057248473167419,
0.3176220655441284,
-0.15446293354034424,
-0.8298140168190002,
0.22207818925380707,
-0.1603412926197052,
0.3450726270675659,
-0.12023472785949707,
0.5484491586685181,
-0.23776043951511383,
1.3067015409469604,
0.6558822989463806,
-0.1918403059244156,
0.8639225363731384,
-0.17184148728847504,
-0.2960290312767029,
-0.8042059540748596,
-0.16414159536361694,
-0.24903054535388947,
-0.4682312607765198,
-0.5527042150497437,
-0.6028863191604614,
0.3173576593399048,
-0.10167422145605087,
-0.4564369022846222,
0.2936161160469055,
-0.6643517017364502,
0.8944253921508789,
0.8776092529296875,
0.4286845922470093,
0.3109777569770813,
0.026856601238250732,
-0.013130410574376583,
-0.060302406549453735,
-0.7311500310897827,
-0.457454115152359,
1.0529831647872925,
0.10488859564065933,
1.005440354347229,
0.0393303819000721,
0.6132656335830688,
0.20443536341190338,
0.42907193303108215,
-0.4527209401130676,
0.39336279034614563,
-0.3977084457874298,
-0.17456918954849243,
-0.11402386426925659,
-0.4712402820587158,
-0.6755367517471313,
0.15771549940109253,
-0.4533238410949707,
-0.5869676470756531,
-0.07730420678853989,
0.4524463415145874,
-0.375005304813385,
0.2775914967060089,
-0.9296500086784363,
0.6065796613693237,
-0.09030817449092865,
-0.6574457287788391,
-0.2150491625070572,
-0.5487152934074402,
0.4921616315841675,
0.2155347764492035,
0.025191424414515495,
0.10764361917972565,
-0.03791937977075577,
0.33835846185684204,
-0.2668636739253998,
0.9492225050926208,
-0.07496611773967743,
-0.2027982771396637,
0.11654443293809891,
0.1669876128435135,
0.493632435798645,
-0.10140339285135269,
-0.1687496453523636,
-0.23920615017414093,
-0.3218306601047516,
-0.4302542507648468,
-0.5087310075759888,
0.6766694188117981,
-0.9025187492370605,
-0.8767686486244202,
0.42363399267196655,
-1.0118155479431152,
-0.19288022816181183,
0.020616553723812103,
0.23559576272964478,
0.35702580213546753,
0.03983313590288162,
0.35451292991638184,
0.8983493447303772,
-0.16767366230487823,
0.3421323001384735,
0.5933818817138672,
0.2162034660577774,
-0.7073529958724976,
1.1182209253311157,
-0.07975860685110092,
0.1566925048828125,
0.47450047731399536,
0.16575510799884796,
0.12607671320438385,
-0.44756102561950684,
-0.7885950803756714,
-0.13298223912715912,
-0.533955454826355,
-0.3198279142379761,
-0.17761068046092987,
0.04513072967529297,
-0.20998720824718475,
0.01843295618891716,
-0.47074973583221436,
-0.42577359080314636,
-0.6106182336807251,
0.11831196397542953,
0.21958255767822266,
0.4853912591934204,
-0.08793643116950989,
0.5178266167640686,
-0.977688729763031,
0.32692286372184753,
0.5819793939590454,
0.573017954826355,
-0.10249433666467667,
-0.6004490852355957,
-0.4461267292499542,
0.451638400554657,
-0.47605639696121216,
-0.8140947818756104,
0.2513132691383362,
0.5712787508964539,
0.4611528217792511,
0.5650395154953003,
-0.2716556489467621,
0.9956714510917664,
-0.846615731716156,
0.637658953666687,
0.007025689817965031,
-1.0198521614074707,
0.3239787817001343,
-0.2723558247089386,
0.4199987053871155,
0.3729243874549866,
0.12975896894931793,
-0.08424659073352814,
-0.32441195845603943,
0.026689544320106506,
-0.687109112739563,
0.9967543482780457,
0.016517996788024902,
0.29469504952430725,
0.04541230574250221,
0.44930005073547363,
0.31023260951042175,
0.0496038943529129,
-0.3939877152442932,
-0.31930604577064514,
-0.451654851436615,
-0.5394423604011536,
0.0798032283782959,
-0.218075692653656,
-0.28254878520965576,
-0.5260544419288635,
0.6971026062965393,
-0.3239568769931793,
0.2325853854417801,
-0.41884228587150574,
-0.18815363943576813,
-0.4015128016471863,
0.16174691915512085,
0.8553730845451355,
0.47011590003967285,
-0.0215616337954998,
-0.05314727872610092,
0.22173824906349182,
-0.4633195698261261,
-0.0666327178478241,
-0.11578620970249176,
0.056993793696165085,
-0.5019848346710205,
0.42816904187202454,
0.9070491194725037,
0.3742712736129761,
-0.35433322191238403,
0.30030718445777893,
-0.12722955644130707,
-0.21063204109668732,
0.19381380081176758,
0.7956366539001465,
0.38316211104393005,
0.5817311406135559,
0.17400875687599182,
0.20720277726650238,
0.2050439566373825,
-0.3903113007545471,
0.17755447328090668,
0.5847094058990479,
-0.09082206338644028,
-0.19460436701774597,
0.6127225160598755,
0.048027921468019485,
-0.5299059152603149,
0.7717818021774292,
0.08580247312784195,
-0.11572135239839554,
0.6463435292243958,
0.9262198209762573,
0.5360841751098633,
-0.4429311156272888,
0.25318408012390137,
0.5243524312973022,
0.28589510917663574,
-0.09056562185287476,
0.4097839891910553,
-0.5587483048439026,
-0.7028258442878723,
-0.5136326551437378,
-0.2236141860485077,
-0.44772639870643616,
-0.16682741045951843,
-0.8334348201751709,
0.19931040704250336,
-0.5345337390899658,
0.3335975110530853,
-0.258922815322876,
-0.1978001892566681,
-0.4253957271575928,
0.023281726986169815,
0.30365434288978577,
1.1728899478912354,
-0.5336008667945862,
0.8682497143745422,
0.4970506727695465,
-0.31819772720336914,
-0.7509101033210754,
-0.10515151172876358,
-0.11438271403312683,
-1.1321607828140259,
0.42687737941741943,
0.20022691786289215,
-0.20193924009799957,
0.22704197466373444,
-0.8973045945167542,
-0.6657500267028809,
1.3035794496536255,
0.7339501976966858,
-0.8633298277854919,
-0.011434955522418022,
0.4389619827270508,
0.3571114242076874,
-0.5559708476066589,
0.37164828181266785,
0.5945053696632385,
0.4274944067001343,
0.4698910415172577,
-0.4421525299549103,
-0.1505274474620819,
-0.44564002752304077,
0.08964300900697708,
0.14578263461589813,
-0.5403933525085449,
0.9103282690048218,
-0.31729093194007874,
-0.30279937386512756,
0.3709997534751892,
0.4664316773414612,
-0.13205958902835846,
0.12332843244075775,
0.26611489057540894,
0.6427628993988037,
0.8507615327835083,
-0.05845113471150398,
0.6964276432991028,
-0.7620362043380737,
0.07719358801841736,
1.21266770362854,
0.13601063191890717,
0.51360023021698,
0.253176748752594,
0.3244019150733948,
0.4819428622722626,
0.6673077940940857,
-0.24568402767181396,
0.7793413400650024,
0.12604644894599915,
-0.4010128080844879,
-0.4936152398586273,
0.31520670652389526,
-0.34399595856666565,
0.35659119486808777,
0.3764794170856476,
-0.4354136288166046,
-0.22655336558818817,
0.090107761323452,
-0.30360478162765503,
0.2179807722568512,
-0.5481113791465759,
1.1124731302261353,
-0.2997686266899109,
-0.712306022644043,
0.6980112195014954,
-0.03461361676454544,
0.5640043020248413,
-0.4311601519584656,
-0.37243276834487915,
-0.33833274245262146,
0.14398029446601868,
-0.23183606564998627,
-0.6874817609786987,
0.15202835202217102,
-0.005078921094536781,
-0.2820132374763489,
-0.15155665576457977,
0.3170028030872345,
-0.6747148036956787,
-0.323910653591156,
-0.1662539690732956,
0.21394965052604675,
-0.32055413722991943,
0.3120018243789673,
-0.5657320022583008,
-0.18516723811626434,
0.19928421080112457,
-0.15324950218200684,
0.23999552428722382,
0.29295673966407776,
0.14488087594509125,
0.7193983197212219,
0.5534952878952026,
-0.07464861124753952,
0.24950183928012848,
0.03254459798336029,
1.1050302982330322,
-0.5632343888282776,
-0.1905195266008377,
-0.9467330574989319,
0.75745689868927,
-0.017203591763973236,
-0.16302689909934998,
0.6019154787063599,
0.4836486577987671,
0.7552894949913025,
-0.31896308064460754,
0.3922964334487915,
0.5083988308906555,
0.2952565550804138,
-0.5676982402801514,
0.5617297291755676,
-0.3261793255805969,
0.5397083163261414,
-0.0743897557258606,
-0.9559343457221985,
-0.36890527606010437,
0.516496479511261,
-0.22820866107940674,
-0.08794423192739487,
0.17235584557056427,
1.0790834426879883,
-0.3201952874660492,
0.44691959023475647,
0.39337581396102905,
-0.057331208139657974,
-0.06767798960208893,
0.5127769708633423,
0.952496349811554,
-0.20164424180984497,
0.3183901906013489,
-0.29605647921562195,
-0.36260026693344116,
-0.00688947131857276,
-0.7145082950592041,
-0.9362807273864746,
-0.4092893600463867,
-0.13298197090625763,
0.04196421056985855,
0.17037013173103333,
1.152737021446228,
0.7000823020935059,
-0.7866999506950378,
-0.2285441905260086,
-0.2119579017162323,
0.2141418159008026,
-0.34605538845062256,
-0.1746327131986618,
0.15749862790107727,
-0.6688615679740906,
-0.8824072480201721,
0.6799226999282837,
0.2206420749425888,
-0.12288656830787659,
0.06233822554349899,
-0.06307957321405411,
0.08748779445886612,
0.10523392260074615,
0.406293660402298,
0.17416158318519592,
-0.21174356341362,
-0.08543252944946289,
0.14259777963161469,
-0.07067512720823288,
0.31610599160194397,
0.7136196494102478,
-0.4978701174259186,
0.6927923560142517,
0.17413081228733063,
0.9068854451179504,
0.5469838976860046,
0.04307805746793747,
0.6166078448295593,
-0.9046733379364014,
-0.20042406022548676,
-0.03686143457889557,
0.26936763525009155,
0.35852405428886414,
-0.4110165536403656,
0.36471790075302124,
-0.15730702877044678,
-0.41277995705604553,
-0.419075071811676,
0.12026070058345795,
-0.5441528558731079,
-0.1304958015680313,
0.8661768436431885,
-0.12013252824544907,
-0.24229568243026733,
0.3295759856700897,
-0.36959606409072876,
0.4232805669307709,
-0.32137972116470337,
1.0984231233596802,
0.3183795213699341,
0.008633606135845184,
-0.3156163692474365,
-0.18548592925071716,
0.28118887543678284,
0.32491302490234375,
-0.7499977946281433,
-0.004706177394837141,
0.5121368169784546,
0.4011062681674957,
-0.037353746592998505,
0.17079052329063416,
0.10545041412115097,
0.6509427428245544,
-0.11816229671239853,
0.12063320726156235,
-0.5217829942703247,
-0.3423675000667572,
-0.13672678172588348,
0.24421946704387665,
-0.10661562532186508,
-0.5573784112930298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13325v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13325v2
|
DEGAP: Dual Event-Guided Adaptive Prefixes for Templated-Based Event Argument Extraction with Slot Querying
| 2024-05-22T03:56:55 | 2024-06-15T15:40:49 |
Guanghui Wang, Dexi Liu, Jian-Yun Nie, Qizhi Wan, Rong Hu, Xiping Liu, Wanlong Liu, Jiaming Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Recent advancements in event argument extraction (EAE) involve incorporating
useful auxiliary information into models during training and inference, such as
retrieved instances and event templates. These methods face two challenges: (1)
the retrieval results may be irrelevant and (2) templates are developed
independently for each event without considering their possible relationship.
In this work, we propose DEGAP to address these challenges through a simple yet
effective components: dual prefixes, i.e. learnable prompt vectors, where the
instance-oriented prefix and template-oriented prefix are trained to learn
information from different event instances and templates. Additionally, we
propose an event-guided adaptive gating mechanism, which can adaptively
leverage possible connections between different events and thus capture
relevant information from the prefix. Finally, these event-guided prefixes
provide relevant information as cues to EAE model without retrieval. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that our method achieves new state-of-the-art
performance on four datasets (ACE05, RAMS, WIKIEVENTS, and MLEE). Further
analysis shows the impact of different components.
|
[
-0.329292356967926,
-0.9692116379737854,
0.51410311460495,
-0.1823796182870865,
-0.7719444036483765,
-0.05900268629193306,
-0.027030285447835922,
-0.24124868214130402,
0.3034403920173645,
-0.11754483729600906,
-0.517206072807312,
-0.323487251996994,
-0.5974611043930054,
-0.13563913106918335,
0.12353334575891495,
0.7352028489112854,
0.15154477953910828,
-0.03026546724140644,
-0.10609237849712372,
-0.23808510601520538,
-0.8765419721603394,
-0.45694050192832947,
-1.225380778312683,
0.02943543717265129,
0.612578809261322,
0.5321020483970642,
0.09850247949361801,
0.49444928765296936,
0.02047894150018692,
0.12493246048688889,
-0.11461199820041656,
0.3749878406524658,
-0.0074693309143185616,
0.3292633593082428,
-0.34461238980293274,
-0.09982538223266602,
-0.6517233848571777,
0.021919099614024162,
0.39091432094573975,
0.20207317173480988,
-0.3671692907810211,
-0.06561876088380814,
0.2292262464761734,
0.3490278720855713,
-0.8248932361602783,
0.15115584433078766,
-1.0406904220581055,
-0.011560259386897087,
-0.36770907044410706,
-0.31016242504119873,
-0.4330426752567291,
0.17381469905376434,
-0.21628916263580322,
-0.6834932565689087,
0.3120373487472534,
-0.28534266352653503,
0.7251877188682556,
0.0031892459373921156,
-0.3854590356349945,
-0.33467763662338257,
-0.5069352388381958,
0.4102880358695984,
-0.6802696585655212,
0.2864718735218048,
0.11360873281955719,
0.16343824565410614,
-0.17420189082622528,
-0.9381944537162781,
-0.47982487082481384,
0.03428800776600838,
0.3246539831161499,
0.3628899157047272,
-0.3513852655887604,
-0.02281939424574375,
0.41143545508384705,
-0.16397815942764282,
-0.469772607088089,
0.49964162707328796,
-0.069051094353199,
0.25618675351142883,
0.7181695699691772,
0.09124766290187836,
0.1677393764257431,
-0.019935734570026398,
-0.4983493983745575,
-0.009446808136999607,
-0.6873394250869751,
0.03069933131337166,
0.22147443890571594,
0.24307312071323395,
0.08325034379959106,
0.03317229822278023,
0.01921972446143627,
0.7454415559768677,
0.5531744956970215,
0.40390723943710327,
-0.18407772481441498,
-0.02571319416165352,
-0.3167046904563904,
0.11800594627857208,
0.7163605093955994,
0.16578856110572815,
-0.21413928270339966,
-0.3540900647640228,
0.38345643877983093,
-0.04188073053956032,
0.259244829416275,
-0.723258912563324,
-0.21192549169063568,
0.1560574471950531,
-0.17825603485107422,
-0.18727385997772217,
0.17133618891239166,
-1.4227840900421143,
-0.6552243232727051,
-0.13083414733409882,
0.3921046555042267,
-0.257172167301178,
-0.3676292300224304,
0.2135981172323227,
-0.5165622234344482,
0.49761873483657837,
0.45141682028770447,
-1.0477670431137085,
0.15494585037231445,
0.8496401906013489,
0.70330411195755,
-0.3024272322654724,
0.0013234899379312992,
-1.3190737962722778,
0.34084683656692505,
-0.12346203625202179,
1.0187623500823975,
-1.0081058740615845,
-0.5401908159255981,
-0.1975628286600113,
-0.12070891261100769,
-0.21009255945682526,
-0.26275551319122314,
0.9094319343566895,
-0.7403138279914856,
0.08878901600837708,
-0.5664032101631165,
-0.7681945562362671,
-0.3235224187374115,
-0.13714514672756195,
-0.5054929852485657,
0.9394036531448364,
-0.3836386799812317,
-0.3880908787250519,
0.7938115000724792,
-0.5833352208137512,
-0.38001179695129395,
0.3506196439266205,
-0.4993716776371002,
-0.19875383377075195,
0.4376341700553894,
0.6356226205825806,
0.38268736004829407,
-0.12606346607208252,
0.1398562341928482,
-0.6153224110603333,
-0.005418695975095034,
-0.4043709337711334,
-0.43974512815475464,
0.4543479382991791,
-0.16619175672531128,
-0.5469686388969421,
0.08251051604747772,
-1.0541890859603882,
0.04741685092449188,
0.12963028252124786,
0.026276782155036926,
-0.5365453958511353,
0.5917522311210632,
-0.3779081702232361,
0.3254556655883789,
-0.2752097249031067,
-0.4411523640155792,
0.6675328016281128,
-0.2631726562976837,
0.20965074002742767,
0.9029795527458191,
0.18798650801181793,
0.32592111825942993,
0.1861019879579544,
0.6819123029708862,
0.3069410026073456,
-0.3245465159416199,
-0.14529183506965637,
-0.6506479382514954,
-0.5777053833007812,
-0.34302419424057007,
0.21162645518779755,
0.5614684224128723,
-0.6709676384925842,
0.5384650826454163,
0.082770437002182,
-0.33585816621780396,
-0.22821469604969025,
-0.036864329129457474,
-0.05133813992142677,
0.8402922749519348,
0.5029723048210144,
-0.3086671829223633,
-0.6734963655471802,
-0.5371730327606201,
-0.3348734974861145,
-0.36526820063591003,
0.04791239649057388,
0.23254653811454773,
0.0373845100402832,
0.2923029065132141,
0.581366240978241,
-0.6198998093605042,
-0.18028812110424042,
-0.09616867452859879,
0.5246138572692871,
-0.01074975822120905,
0.3084760308265686,
0.6547297239303589,
-0.5149760842323303,
-0.43574467301368713,
-0.08847800642251968,
-0.5017656683921814,
-0.4652826488018036,
-0.46768781542778015,
-0.1623343676328659,
0.12103523313999176,
0.40691620111465454,
-0.4461745619773865,
0.7353110313415527,
0.021426068618893623,
-0.6578811407089233,
0.5868130922317505,
-0.02618703618645668,
-0.05876561626791954,
-1.0334681272506714,
-0.11312369257211685,
-0.1389187127351761,
-0.11652159690856934,
-0.5621772408485413,
-0.07354464381933212,
0.008969313465058804,
0.09234669804573059,
-0.08125180006027222,
0.9010516405105591,
-0.5885614156723022,
0.3468734920024872,
-0.5756836533546448,
0.23181413114070892,
0.3953748643398285,
0.26685595512390137,
0.37489888072013855,
0.6135130524635315,
0.8339267373085022,
-0.7945587635040283,
0.4601810574531555,
0.37874263525009155,
-0.027119105681777,
0.8538135290145874,
-0.48020660877227783,
0.6583948731422424,
-0.3200961947441101,
0.06452514976263046,
-0.8126266598701477,
0.1756051629781723,
0.24785415828227997,
-0.24423927068710327,
0.5833684206008911,
-0.6767322421073914,
0.09437710791826248,
-0.15555831789970398,
-0.37305259704589844,
0.18440565466880798,
0.5374696850776672,
-0.9103066325187683,
0.717229425907135,
0.3920309543609619,
-0.39824944734573364,
-0.4608064889907837,
-0.15280961990356445,
0.4029187858104706,
-0.5614842772483826,
-0.550146758556366,
0.41500094532966614,
0.09230557829141617,
0.10064958035945892,
-0.11362508684396744,
-0.32270482182502747,
-0.14847838878631592,
0.16538476943969727,
0.10430330783128738,
0.06987716257572174,
-0.4723528325557709,
0.3353467583656311,
0.07734896242618561,
-0.24227610230445862,
-0.06864979863166809,
-0.48234328627586365,
0.2873409390449524,
0.09036530554294586,
-0.5185872912406921,
-0.3797195255756378,
0.8561070561408997,
0.22931034862995148,
-0.3801094591617584,
0.596558153629303,
0.7647647261619568,
-0.45835986733436584,
-0.40220630168914795,
-0.6318376064300537,
-0.213066965341568,
-0.4609143137931824,
0.44720393419265747,
-0.5816459059715271,
-0.47124236822128296,
0.6361585855484009,
-0.04686129465699196,
0.3486632704734802,
0.49627625942230225,
0.447497695684433,
0.00874798372387886,
1.0979435443878174,
0.14482179284095764,
0.16050955653190613,
0.6276373863220215,
0.10998371988534927,
-0.004652665928006172,
-0.9435100555419922,
-0.19315257668495178,
-0.4666435718536377,
-0.39508765935897827,
0.07027071714401245,
-0.5786979794502258,
0.22989428043365479,
0.6255307793617249,
0.09398780763149261,
0.04628907889127731,
-0.39316409826278687,
0.36213043332099915,
0.43715110421180725,
-0.24777713418006897,
0.23007245361804962,
0.0727519541978836,
-0.1307111531496048,
-0.2797975242137909,
-0.767615795135498,
-0.4660158157348633,
0.6497682332992554,
-0.1514553278684616,
0.7553943395614624,
0.11518873274326324,
0.5770599842071533,
0.29594168066978455,
-0.1356971114873886,
-0.7315351366996765,
0.49740102887153625,
-0.11380819976329803,
-0.2764994204044342,
0.10208265483379364,
-0.2119472622871399,
-1.0839532613754272,
0.6577653288841248,
-0.07220719009637833,
-1.2817115783691406,
0.6616016626358032,
0.15814143419265747,
-0.3824644088745117,
0.7344313263893127,
-0.5925702452659607,
0.7881237268447876,
-0.25416430830955505,
-0.5474311709403992,
-0.24054400622844696,
-0.20038922131061554,
-0.08242019265890121,
0.11523515731096268,
-0.2607836425304413,
-0.23275406658649445,
-0.15229029953479767,
0.9893869161605835,
-0.03149121254682541,
0.6164101958274841,
-0.5534036755561829,
0.0770832896232605,
0.4200787842273712,
0.11646007746458054,
0.8529191613197327,
0.5449723601341248,
-0.3290102183818817,
-0.02162778191268444,
-0.04820767417550087,
-0.22284607589244843,
-0.7366741895675659,
0.6636956930160522,
-0.22605955600738525,
-1.073417067527771,
-0.46231284737586975,
-0.015782734379172325,
-0.373188316822052,
0.06429557502269745,
-0.004568565636873245,
0.8083573579788208,
-0.49063244462013245,
0.02216978557407856,
0.39931046962738037,
-0.05463136360049248,
0.8461576104164124,
0.821712851524353,
0.300405889749527,
-0.24770484864711761,
0.5499207973480225,
-0.17200395464897156,
-0.20410041511058807,
0.12985242903232574,
0.20156089961528778,
-0.5059508681297302,
-0.6534743309020996,
-1.0123353004455566,
-0.04385973513126373,
-0.6691058278083801,
-0.3858875632286072,
-0.9026728272438049,
0.14681518077850342,
-0.24858136475086212,
-0.33516526222229004,
-0.20497408509254456,
-0.7268012762069702,
-0.7452963590621948,
-0.5781657099723816,
0.2499896138906479,
0.29920724034309387,
-0.415326863527298,
0.13863874971866608,
-0.8783553242683411,
0.42220818996429443,
0.510909914970398,
0.26198557019233704,
-0.019641852006316185,
-0.4381294548511505,
0.19187593460083008,
-0.10739855468273163,
-0.5968285202980042,
-1.3618024587631226,
0.17670835554599762,
0.6154531240463257,
0.600917398929596,
0.6157596707344055,
0.06622370332479477,
1.0542879104614258,
-0.7429534196853638,
0.8174850940704346,
0.13517867028713226,
-0.880788266658783,
0.7780841588973999,
-0.1792350560426712,
-0.014960848726332188,
0.5325862169265747,
0.03011796995997429,
-0.60556560754776,
0.05447237193584442,
-0.8668989539146423,
-0.9245917797088623,
0.8845707774162292,
-0.22929315268993378,
0.09206376224756241,
-0.26926809549331665,
0.6574755311012268,
0.31538575887680054,
-0.05456600710749626,
-0.4343900680541992,
-0.03747698664665222,
0.07240000367164612,
0.026427753269672394,
0.3131347596645355,
-0.4967697858810425,
-0.05949465185403824,
-0.2598499357700348,
0.7369205355644226,
-0.24695131182670593,
0.28498291969299316,
0.10178162157535553,
0.08044532686471939,
0.010117408819496632,
0.4865586757659912,
0.3845852017402649,
0.661716639995575,
-0.0779600590467453,
0.15469859540462494,
0.3728986084461212,
-0.41879549622535706,
0.266702800989151,
0.41084522008895874,
-0.18927137553691864,
0.24353836476802826,
0.14461007714271545,
1.0798795223236084,
-0.05588235333561897,
-0.10109204053878784,
0.2954505681991577,
-0.2536733150482178,
0.04741698130965233,
-0.02148493193089962,
0.21311822533607483,
-0.04951107129454613,
0.12277178466320038,
0.4124167561531067,
-0.23363849520683289,
0.05288052186369896,
-0.09111836552619934,
0.5454921126365662,
0.6694679260253906,
-0.6297303438186646,
-0.7017452120780945,
1.016007423400879,
0.5459365248680115,
-0.02320796065032482,
0.44819849729537964,
-0.3807973861694336,
-0.17757482826709747,
0.6758579611778259,
0.6318360567092896,
1.2387977838516235,
-0.25280216336250305,
0.1914268136024475,
0.4612327516078949,
0.09778019040822983,
0.3229828476905823,
0.4644993245601654,
0.0018759638769552112,
-0.4544823169708252,
-0.3327232897281647,
-0.5127367973327637,
-0.07568708062171936,
0.5557306408882141,
-0.8921758532524109,
0.4711112678050995,
-0.1674298793077469,
-0.1739431470632553,
0.32683685421943665,
-0.05391695350408554,
-0.5785243511199951,
-0.1683982014656067,
0.4734461307525635,
1.1196027994155884,
-0.8252827525138855,
0.6760868430137634,
1.1169804334640503,
-0.10279197245836258,
-0.5265872478485107,
-0.15779639780521393,
0.08721587061882019,
-0.39911094307899475,
0.22492994368076324,
0.01796138845384121,
0.027238503098487854,
0.17362602055072784,
0.12159715592861176,
-0.6152300834655762,
0.7535033822059631,
0.1886942833662033,
-0.38432779908180237,
-0.1870361715555191,
-0.3228767216205597,
0.07497262954711914,
-0.2702197730541229,
0.29745766520500183,
0.25909367203712463,
0.5595235228538513,
0.20366694033145905,
-0.5257256627082825,
0.1646033376455307,
-0.053029853850603104,
-0.18509981036186218,
0.3591659665107727,
-0.4439944326877594,
0.2934304475784302,
-0.02573879435658455,
-0.527772068977356,
-0.2541087567806244,
0.90952467918396,
0.07971862703561783,
0.4282519817352295,
0.39164119958877563,
0.6760063171386719,
0.911126434803009,
-0.148182213306427,
0.7424622774124146,
0.19784574210643768,
0.1830015778541565,
1.3400062322616577,
-0.6205073595046997,
0.6519619822502136,
0.36074137687683105,
-0.03961595520377159,
0.4723116457462311,
0.3622610569000244,
0.13908787071704865,
0.717504620552063,
-0.06969336420297623,
-0.5489839911460876,
-0.5654508471488953,
0.23179994523525238,
-0.4688486158847809,
0.7298294305801392,
0.6806807518005371,
-0.011850187554955482,
-0.6930927634239197,
-0.08453748375177383,
0.04454762488603592,
-0.25934627652168274,
-0.2963389456272125,
1.0436043739318848,
0.17973394691944122,
-0.7868016958236694,
0.3541349470615387,
0.20376087725162506,
0.3192884027957916,
-0.8409997224807739,
-0.2626584768295288,
-0.1771228164434433,
0.10056663304567337,
0.07226759195327759,
-0.3539745807647705,
0.37267208099365234,
0.0783410519361496,
-0.15194666385650635,
0.12127431482076645,
0.9319331645965576,
-0.31111595034599304,
-0.4129841923713684,
0.2066880613565445,
0.6332862973213196,
-0.2814885377883911,
-0.011671976186335087,
-0.6985279321670532,
-0.18888424336910248,
-0.13675594329833984,
-0.5335875153541565,
0.3837859034538269,
0.30899882316589355,
-0.12465041130781174,
0.2390095591545105,
0.4365026652812958,
0.15571919083595276,
0.16506166756153107,
-0.052124761044979095,
0.8302636742591858,
-0.5871923565864563,
-0.6955466866493225,
-1.1565566062927246,
0.5240498185157776,
-0.346307635307312,
-0.275721937417984,
0.5592542886734009,
0.42141276597976685,
0.24407997727394104,
0.011495215818285942,
0.5868887901306152,
-0.25887417793273926,
0.049133915454149246,
-0.6047463417053223,
0.215519517660141,
-0.45177173614501953,
0.20601379871368408,
-0.13225039839744568,
-0.47409045696258545,
-0.20974187552928925,
0.5249994993209839,
-0.11885493993759155,
0.018303614109754562,
0.47422319650650024,
0.5937466025352478,
-0.5194467306137085,
0.3010588586330414,
0.26045069098472595,
-0.059006281197071075,
0.7208636403083801,
0.7915990948677063,
0.7783827185630798,
-0.18198750913143158,
0.1047770231962204,
0.26871997117996216,
-0.3431153893470764,
-0.2850918471813202,
-1.3030768632888794,
-0.7061446309089661,
-0.6471006870269775,
-0.8462334275245667,
-0.11663506180047989,
0.24887573719024658,
0.6831754446029663,
0.7264048457145691,
-0.9080941677093506,
0.28203457593917847,
0.04731117933988571,
0.139219269156456,
-0.5443388223648071,
-0.22269582748413086,
0.810861349105835,
-0.5109053254127502,
-0.6177986264228821,
0.9345669746398926,
0.4650614559650421,
-0.159596249461174,
0.5763852596282959,
0.3829481899738312,
-0.45876798033714294,
0.3501480221748352,
0.5510562062263489,
0.6115854978561401,
-0.4666896462440491,
-0.5783506035804749,
-0.49292248487472534,
0.25140613317489624,
0.2502947449684143,
0.8556826114654541,
-0.9276576042175293,
0.6573383808135986,
0.47594666481018066,
0.6776955127716064,
0.5045722126960754,
0.17680932581424713,
0.6329932808876038,
-1.2186040878295898,
0.4040755033493042,
0.28073999285697937,
0.44197967648506165,
-0.10310101509094238,
-0.39225518703460693,
0.510873556137085,
0.34789109230041504,
-0.32441946864128113,
-0.7056756615638733,
0.45656242966651917,
-1.1457148790359497,
-0.13468758761882782,
1.2414591312408447,
-0.18359749019145966,
0.17357060313224792,
-0.26575034856796265,
-0.3097679615020752,
0.2228645235300064,
-0.2707023024559021,
0.7709748148918152,
0.6024116277694702,
-0.32873085141181946,
-0.1723880022764206,
-0.45646440982818604,
0.7742138504981995,
0.4406338930130005,
-0.8418889045715332,
0.29780104756355286,
0.6773616075515747,
0.15076135098934174,
-0.24256998300552368,
0.7167916893959045,
-0.03504565730690956,
0.4626515805721283,
0.023236164823174477,
-0.16035331785678864,
-0.48039019107818604,
-0.21481770277023315,
-0.6320217251777649,
0.18948107957839966,
-0.10884179919958115,
-0.4177476465702057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13319v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13319v1
|
''You should probably read this'': Hedge Detection in Text
| 2024-05-22T03:25:35 | 2024-05-22T03:25:35 |
Denys Katerenchuk, Rivka Levitan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Humans express ideas, beliefs, and statements through language. The manner of
expression can carry information indicating the author's degree of confidence
in their statement. Understanding the certainty level of a claim is crucial in
areas such as medicine, finance, engineering, and many others where errors can
lead to disastrous results. In this work, we apply a joint model that leverages
words and part-of-speech tags to improve hedge detection in text and achieve a
new top score on the CoNLL-2010 Wikipedia corpus.
|
[
-0.3965924382209778,
-0.8302462697029114,
0.6378202438354492,
-0.3043239712715149,
-0.39663997292518616,
0.13127374649047852,
-0.01984499581158161,
-0.9113470315933228,
0.2920442819595337,
0.29290157556533813,
-0.3774566054344177,
-0.8045908808708191,
-0.674638569355011,
-0.15746097266674042,
-0.5107934474945068,
0.8714568614959717,
0.19627238810062408,
-0.06594660133123398,
-0.06596104055643082,
0.22221523523330688,
-0.3066897392272949,
-0.25895237922668457,
-0.6684479713439941,
-0.18720930814743042,
0.5150704979896545,
0.36635085940361023,
0.7632004022598267,
0.758004903793335,
0.30623987317085266,
0.31976965069770813,
-0.10482852905988693,
-0.22074425220489502,
-0.22441761195659637,
0.14610379934310913,
-0.40271785855293274,
-0.6766120195388794,
-0.2756172716617584,
0.28609585762023926,
0.4863298833370209,
0.4292040765285492,
-0.25905072689056396,
-0.18948930501937866,
-0.20493705570697784,
0.14558634161949158,
-0.5005597472190857,
0.19629956781864166,
-0.6142231822013855,
-0.1936938464641571,
-0.5532822012901306,
0.11088559031486511,
-0.30411994457244873,
-0.20073702931404114,
0.21599134802818298,
-0.7437568306922913,
0.04263276606798172,
0.16268233954906464,
1.084586262702942,
0.18247205018997192,
-0.2658945322036743,
-0.25493475794792175,
-0.16079773008823395,
0.5075469017028809,
-0.7001089453697205,
0.3483862280845642,
0.5587507486343384,
0.16423656046390533,
-0.12761925160884857,
-0.6846283674240112,
-0.7730811238288879,
-0.35119786858558655,
-0.3167007863521576,
0.1339496523141861,
-0.5459343194961548,
0.28575411438941956,
0.5121580958366394,
0.14924384653568268,
-0.2005225270986557,
-0.016484638676047325,
0.06026312708854675,
-0.5977963209152222,
0.5271925330162048,
-0.3005986511707306,
0.5643159747123718,
-0.2790416181087494,
-0.25876548886299133,
-0.3967481851577759,
-0.49330031871795654,
0.21556031703948975,
0.5443505048751831,
-0.14103247225284576,
0.022014014422893524,
0.4693971872329712,
-0.2006741166114807,
0.6637049317359924,
0.10868245363235474,
-0.14297501742839813,
0.018576238304376602,
-0.08894025534391403,
-0.07163956016302109,
0.3079540431499481,
0.41778364777565,
0.58034747838974,
0.3239896595478058,
-0.23672690987586975,
-0.1040748879313469,
0.3000755310058594,
0.10424159467220306,
-0.4032329320907593,
-0.4409623146057129,
0.02625672146677971,
-0.5998274683952332,
-0.29877570271492004,
0.030063718557357788,
-0.7338374257087708,
-0.45712897181510925,
0.09988168627023697,
0.48949822783470154,
-0.6314741373062134,
-0.38129371404647827,
0.34158891439437866,
-0.6914862394332886,
0.32070082426071167,
0.035836245864629745,
-0.6552039384841919,
0.25598686933517456,
0.7551880478858948,
0.6657547354698181,
0.18078802525997162,
-0.2120712250471115,
-0.5842934846878052,
0.3502521216869354,
-0.3839578926563263,
1.151663899421692,
-0.45069044828414917,
-0.5180041193962097,
-0.04236479848623276,
-0.11489477008581161,
0.011234953999519348,
-0.11299899220466614,
0.9177617430686951,
-0.403445839881897,
0.29655155539512634,
-0.46878984570503235,
-0.639619767665863,
-0.25204601883888245,
0.24058903753757477,
-0.7628782987594604,
0.6866269111633301,
0.049508918076753616,
-1.3035509586334229,
0.554130494594574,
-0.5819617509841919,
-0.6097217202186584,
0.12019132822751999,
-0.05084073171019554,
-0.23402106761932373,
0.06383875012397766,
-0.03613120689988136,
0.25426772236824036,
-0.09172289073467255,
0.11908585578203201,
-0.2261468470096588,
-0.0840669497847557,
0.7335460186004639,
-0.34020334482192993,
0.4507357180118561,
0.05898183956742287,
-0.3449685871601105,
-0.07812965661287308,
-0.607860803604126,
0.11166104674339294,
-0.3573267161846161,
-0.23784729838371277,
-0.7515656352043152,
0.4854297339916229,
-0.11474454402923584,
0.028058340772986412,
0.32827913761138916,
-0.924728274345398,
0.13972319662570953,
-0.8301599621772766,
0.21790069341659546,
0.429358571767807,
0.09080468118190765,
0.2441990077495575,
-0.4992871582508087,
0.3750407099723816,
-0.15417888760566711,
-0.2485235333442688,
0.03065449744462967,
-0.5230600237846375,
-0.7022598385810852,
-0.04793066531419754,
0.6506515741348267,
0.6353144645690918,
-0.4936785101890564,
0.4761330783367157,
0.1405809372663498,
-0.4419521391391754,
-0.5055463910102844,
-0.30589303374290466,
0.306747704744339,
0.8519585728645325,
0.284829705953598,
-0.14492307603359222,
-0.5237278342247009,
-0.9411113262176514,
-0.6776099801063538,
-0.34664538502693176,
-0.1306779384613037,
-0.12232080101966858,
0.19416294991970062,
0.05100541189312935,
1.1228383779525757,
-0.6999914050102234,
0.005144360940903425,
-0.248457670211792,
0.5822632908821106,
0.16294214129447937,
0.4100649654865265,
0.6113582253456116,
-0.8689064383506775,
-0.44437915086746216,
0.1501237004995346,
-0.28974291682243347,
-0.0771356001496315,
0.034072745591402054,
-0.4418228268623352,
-0.25688618421554565,
0.5680391192436218,
-0.7258870005607605,
0.4821368455886841,
0.1666289120912552,
-0.440958708524704,
0.25066062808036804,
-0.24928249418735504,
0.039696887135505676,
-1.1318739652633667,
-0.047407664358615875,
0.4720836579799652,
-0.3668888509273529,
-0.39861488342285156,
-0.2798495590686798,
-0.08848632127046585,
0.3555596172809601,
-0.03528894856572151,
0.22994624078273773,
-0.1980796456336975,
0.17894361913204193,
-0.2854610085487366,
0.02444601058959961,
-0.1919018030166626,
-0.08795688301324844,
-0.008751695044338703,
0.9085504412651062,
0.7134192585945129,
-0.32432883977890015,
-0.03877061977982521,
-0.04245539754629135,
-0.5708500742912292,
0.7324531078338623,
-0.5303714871406555,
-0.11535028368234634,
-0.26784586906433105,
0.07354079931974411,
-1.1615666151046753,
-0.5532433390617371,
0.1312822550535202,
-0.5536542534828186,
0.586277425289154,
0.21639122068881989,
-0.22250792384147644,
-0.2446257472038269,
-0.4537334144115448,
-0.34814780950546265,
0.3995496332645416,
-0.11441460996866226,
0.49796950817108154,
1.0100375413894653,
0.04568729177117348,
-0.837388277053833,
-0.6816785931587219,
0.30915728211402893,
-0.295583575963974,
-0.5112103223800659,
0.9593344926834106,
0.10877407342195511,
-0.5535128712654114,
0.06026340648531914,
-0.14811405539512634,
-0.12303122878074646,
0.3643394708633423,
0.07624097913503647,
0.19846510887145996,
-0.0470011830329895,
0.2549844980239868,
0.06700277328491211,
-0.5032252669334412,
0.4740349352359772,
-0.44257596135139465,
0.2896178364753723,
0.11484703421592712,
-0.10308879613876343,
-0.5146574378013611,
0.7081011533737183,
0.16179251670837402,
-0.08497512340545654,
0.38561418652534485,
0.8660835027694702,
-0.6098488569259644,
-0.20518910884857178,
-0.33763188123703003,
-0.0051159304566681385,
-0.4819379448890686,
0.34168827533721924,
-0.20646058022975922,
-0.785919725894928,
0.26474735140800476,
-0.2898302376270294,
-0.3872317373752594,
1.0697550773620605,
0.2777939736843109,
-0.8108351826667786,
1.2117197513580322,
1.2203829288482666,
-0.21216952800750732,
0.44186997413635254,
-0.04231800511479378,
0.31697356700897217,
-0.3481811285018921,
-0.08200784772634506,
-0.7115603685379028,
-0.29148367047309875,
-0.9397394061088562,
-0.17633448541164398,
0.1879822462797165,
0.4800419211387634,
0.024567753076553345,
0.39080652594566345,
-0.6322697997093201,
0.7531554698944092,
0.7465269565582275,
0.08997038006782532,
0.09389392286539078,
-0.0453772135078907,
-0.42638054490089417,
-0.031071027740836143,
-0.40595436096191406,
-0.6752250790596008,
0.4978311061859131,
0.44104498624801636,
0.8400304913520813,
0.1958976686000824,
0.6059418320655823,
0.6410380601882935,
0.4407907724380493,
-0.77280592918396,
0.5328245162963867,
-0.25853845477104187,
-0.5551351308822632,
-0.18393006920814514,
-0.004682488273829222,
-0.8177676200866699,
-0.20895977318286896,
-0.344138503074646,
-1.2488398551940918,
0.12235730141401291,
0.15459226071834564,
-0.4152207672595978,
0.32450491189956665,
-0.7592536807060242,
0.8997563719749451,
-0.17356503009796143,
0.0886574387550354,
-0.3769029974937439,
-0.7106961011886597,
0.12522561848163605,
0.043405886739492416,
0.22274625301361084,
-0.33918604254722595,
-0.35279810428619385,
0.9723942279815674,
-0.38777703046798706,
0.848145067691803,
-0.1589510589838028,
-0.11046694964170456,
0.5791338682174683,
-0.12982314825057983,
0.5210119485855103,
0.0538935624063015,
-0.12409599870443344,
0.08356191962957382,
0.13774940371513367,
-0.08600357174873352,
-0.1848844289779663,
0.4290621280670166,
-0.6467429995536804,
-0.692229151725769,
-0.653633713722229,
-0.49293234944343567,
-0.21180708706378937,
0.07942527532577515,
0.4740949273109436,
-0.06360698491334915,
-0.43977731466293335,
-0.147164449095726,
0.6771316528320312,
0.005720015149563551,
0.5255982279777527,
0.2698669731616974,
0.07482501119375229,
-0.34315353631973267,
0.5369726419448853,
0.11268523335456848,
-0.05422614887356758,
0.5155063271522522,
0.4390919804573059,
-0.7875881791114807,
-0.588320255279541,
-0.25441601872444153,
0.24542275071144104,
-0.667637288570404,
-0.3255102336406708,
-0.7193961143493652,
-0.056235749274492264,
-0.3187142610549927,
-0.11406804621219635,
0.268545925617218,
-0.28011560440063477,
-0.32675984501838684,
-0.41372111439704895,
0.7594529986381531,
1.0740201473236084,
-0.4538649320602417,
0.7011599540710449,
-0.5544803142547607,
0.10291613638401031,
0.5394510626792908,
0.24052222073078156,
-0.2548145651817322,
-0.01775781251490116,
-0.3009044826030731,
0.18358950316905975,
-0.16537430882453918,
-1.4473623037338257,
0.3888617157936096,
-0.023668531328439713,
0.8261809349060059,
0.23977144062519073,
-0.07841081917285919,
0.3219750225543976,
-0.3102981150150299,
0.5396916270256042,
0.32826337218284607,
-1.1735934019088745,
0.5456534624099731,
-0.3876122534275055,
0.04651859402656555,
0.5181140899658203,
0.6322190761566162,
-0.7393943071365356,
-0.12162397801876068,
-0.7513320446014404,
-0.40059682726860046,
0.4123464822769165,
-0.16998714208602905,
0.20027883350849152,
-0.21771802008152008,
0.25172561407089233,
-0.1463509052991867,
0.036226555705070496,
-0.6221501231193542,
-0.013199377804994583,
0.06911136955022812,
-0.35690292716026306,
0.1492127925157547,
-0.4284783601760864,
-0.12124107033014297,
-0.24384963512420654,
0.4910264015197754,
-0.13558374345302582,
0.33835098147392273,
0.16877664625644684,
0.01983644813299179,
-0.22607602179050446,
0.35836464166641235,
0.23657594621181488,
0.6001867055892944,
-0.22946599125862122,
0.32528531551361084,
0.3217390477657318,
-0.7129830121994019,
0.02123168483376503,
0.3380804657936096,
-0.1545027643442154,
0.26570844650268555,
0.3732953369617462,
0.3293303847312927,
0.2253710925579071,
-0.4473976194858551,
0.5509454607963562,
0.05745190382003784,
-0.07590354979038239,
0.06551434844732285,
0.48769211769104004,
0.41959142684936523,
0.27125662565231323,
0.2886740565299988,
0.27678030729293823,
0.3166846036911011,
-0.6230557560920715,
0.6193245649337769,
0.5262553095817566,
-0.42604219913482666,
-0.1225382462143898,
0.602073073387146,
0.16806256771087646,
-0.4594602882862091,
0.16017551720142365,
-0.4925393760204315,
-0.8950774669647217,
0.5652504563331604,
0.7143439650535583,
0.7036381363868713,
-0.04917372018098831,
0.32733583450317383,
0.37918832898139954,
0.1258823573589325,
-0.06166009604930878,
0.5736281871795654,
-0.00021184298384469002,
-0.7796605825424194,
-0.7302936911582947,
-0.5600348114967346,
-0.4354056715965271,
-0.16881228983402252,
-0.38886430859565735,
0.40864449739456177,
-0.18202754855155945,
-0.528263509273529,
0.6450951099395752,
0.06041456758975983,
-0.3620680868625641,
0.2165365219116211,
0.321714848279953,
1.188044786453247,
-0.700951099395752,
1.16289222240448,
0.48561710119247437,
-0.4401257336139679,
-0.8578066825866699,
0.4520966410636902,
-0.16833248734474182,
-0.5655906200408936,
0.5341197848320007,
0.2850840389728546,
-0.38923463225364685,
0.20958034694194794,
-0.7775976061820984,
-1.013237476348877,
0.8586016297340393,
0.29611578583717346,
-0.6316452026367188,
-0.18158118426799774,
-0.3474326431751251,
0.2869238555431366,
-0.34827283024787903,
0.3452737033367157,
0.55930095911026,
0.5832565426826477,
0.005111252889037132,
-0.7477842569351196,
-0.22712503373622894,
0.13724488019943237,
-0.29842785000801086,
0.4193946421146393,
-0.23875993490219116,
1.356552004814148,
-0.10694291442632675,
-0.4626186788082123,
-0.025649283081293106,
0.7835820913314819,
-0.19497841596603394,
0.407181054353714,
0.6986912488937378,
0.564590573310852,
1.2284801006317139,
-0.19910071790218353,
1.100406527519226,
-0.41689154505729675,
0.30084481835365295,
0.9757925868034363,
0.017752671614289284,
1.0823261737823486,
-0.0031856743153184652,
-0.36032992601394653,
0.8743799328804016,
0.8204225301742554,
0.25867706537246704,
0.52275550365448,
0.3574468195438385,
-0.48677879571914673,
-0.45713382959365845,
-0.4983276128768921,
-0.37675806879997253,
0.7077893614768982,
0.7899103164672852,
-0.44366785883903503,
-0.40102946758270264,
-0.009990669786930084,
0.2530498802661896,
0.22745798528194427,
-0.3454190194606781,
0.7463577389717102,
-0.0925249382853508,
-0.7021374106407166,
-0.03320787101984024,
0.2878611385822296,
1.0462899208068848,
-0.5842865705490112,
-0.3134297728538513,
0.21654827892780304,
-0.029760679230093956,
0.06464331597089767,
-1.223113775253296,
0.4235268831253052,
0.19078920781612396,
-0.1129312589764595,
-0.19668559730052948,
1.3924272060394287,
-0.39506280422210693,
-0.34383076429367065,
0.11055205762386322,
0.48796141147613525,
0.2202243208885193,
-0.053017158061265945,
-0.7890810966491699,
-0.4050002694129944,
0.10255006700754166,
0.15704037249088287,
0.05485841631889343,
0.5013718605041504,
-0.12949377298355103,
0.2147580236196518,
0.8697541356086731,
0.10725347697734833,
-0.363101989030838,
-0.22969341278076172,
0.8263781666755676,
-0.7733563780784607,
-0.617115318775177,
-0.9365321397781372,
0.20383287966251373,
-0.7978581786155701,
-0.34328967332839966,
0.669407844543457,
0.39542311429977417,
0.8546570539474487,
0.38428792357444763,
0.8566164374351501,
-0.17038939893245697,
0.7791674137115479,
-0.5417221784591675,
1.048804521560669,
-0.07719934731721878,
-0.2002408653497696,
-0.20795567333698273,
-0.46381884813308716,
-0.1368561089038849,
1.116199016571045,
-0.46902593970298767,
-0.16150018572807312,
0.6547086238861084,
0.547051727771759,
0.16280916333198547,
0.11845874786376953,
0.33617323637008667,
0.26581960916519165,
-0.10799203813076019,
0.3851558268070221,
0.9562094807624817,
-0.23547421395778656,
0.3123091459274292,
-0.32680827379226685,
-0.01130780391395092,
0.05954461172223091,
-1.1418448686599731,
-0.5105701088905334,
-0.42643508315086365,
-0.46096178889274597,
-0.650795042514801,
-0.16212639212608337,
0.5304043292999268,
0.7137571573257446,
-0.606815755367279,
-0.11945168673992157,
-0.23745094239711761,
0.35825055837631226,
-0.003881636308506131,
-0.14130860567092896,
0.23760777711868286,
-0.1210964024066925,
-0.5932542681694031,
0.14344272017478943,
0.37873873114585876,
0.39548274874687195,
-0.2145622968673706,
0.08106168359518051,
-0.6468583941459656,
0.254475861787796,
0.18224790692329407,
0.17658454179763794,
-0.5012992024421692,
-0.6102651953697205,
0.04572717845439911,
-0.4257294833660126,
-0.08310530334711075,
0.7528069019317627,
-0.8676856756210327,
0.4748283326625824,
0.5640148520469666,
0.44026869535446167,
0.4542348384857178,
0.05026152357459068,
0.5945467948913574,
-0.3554303050041199,
-0.03817056864500046,
0.2437506914138794,
0.44500207901000977,
0.3600761890411377,
-0.6097093820571899,
0.3732560873031616,
0.3214038610458374,
-0.2717114984989166,
-0.24446219205856323,
0.08010178804397583,
-0.9161124229431152,
-0.41579124331474304,
0.5493302345275879,
-0.16657935082912445,
-0.5996037125587463,
-0.24651214480400085,
-0.5072140693664551,
0.3940119445323944,
-0.39097023010253906,
0.5749216675758362,
1.1821799278259277,
-0.03918031230568886,
0.11019610613584518,
-0.4952540099620819,
0.9091565012931824,
0.2329973727464676,
-0.9260718822479248,
-0.1742171049118042,
0.36728858947753906,
0.24165968596935272,
0.26985788345336914,
0.6473625302314758,
0.5209464430809021,
0.2662666440010071,
0.26015418767929077,
-0.20144355297088623,
0.42476463317871094,
0.07356752455234528,
0.09928213804960251,
0.1842619627714157,
0.14467523992061615,
-0.4846023619174957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13292v1
|
Metadata Integration for Spam Reviews Detection on Vietnamese E-commerce Websites
| 2024-05-22T02:19:13 | 2024-05-22T02:19:13 |
Co Van Dinh, Son T. Luu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The problem of detecting spam reviews (opinions) has received significant
attention in recent years, especially with the rapid development of e-commerce.
Spam reviews are often classified based on comment content, but in some cases,
it is insufficient for models to accurately determine the review label. In this
work, we introduce the ViSpamReviews v2 dataset, which includes metadata of
reviews with the objective of integrating supplementary attributes for spam
review classification. We propose a novel approach to simultaneously integrate
both textual and categorical attributes into the classification model. In our
experiments, the product category proved effective when combined with deep
neural network (DNN) models, while text features performed well on both DNN
models and the model achieved state-of-the-art performance in the problem of
detecting spam reviews on Vietnamese e-commerce websites, namely PhoBERT.
Specifically, the PhoBERT model achieves the highest accuracy when combined
with product description features generated from the SPhoBert model, which is
the combination of PhoBERT and SentenceBERT. Using the macro-averaged F1 score,
the task of classifying spam reviews achieved 87.22% (an increase of 1.64%
compared to the baseline), while the task of identifying the type of spam
reviews achieved an accuracy of 73.49% (an increase of 1.93% compared to the
baseline).
|
[
-0.6535217761993408,
-0.7341295480728149,
0.31700924038887024,
0.5361708402633667,
-0.4769655168056488,
-0.022821571677923203,
0.07496213912963867,
-0.6431592702865601,
0.22629554569721222,
1.0639772415161133,
-0.32606270909309387,
-0.87335604429245,
-0.6350601315498352,
0.14007093012332916,
-0.3470264673233032,
1.4247989654541016,
0.11147551983594894,
-0.043025292456150055,
-0.029815515503287315,
-0.23365530371665955,
-0.16856899857521057,
-0.5884232521057129,
-0.06884366273880005,
-0.0935273990035057,
0.7037277817726135,
0.28714194893836975,
0.5051217675209045,
0.08987344056367874,
0.745140790939331,
0.21802997589111328,
0.1816946417093277,
0.9329083561897278,
-0.3242936432361603,
0.03273213654756546,
-0.25451165437698364,
-0.23987247049808502,
-0.6627103090286255,
0.29346010088920593,
0.30179834365844727,
0.15962450206279755,
-0.08652632683515549,
0.47354981303215027,
0.34202560782432556,
0.6550639271736145,
-0.5009039044380188,
0.09965979307889938,
-0.3214062452316284,
0.07810275256633759,
0.4401355981826782,
-0.6096471548080444,
-0.5203097462654114,
-0.4548315107822418,
0.38620132207870483,
-0.5426375865936279,
0.03172127157449722,
-0.1141742393374443,
0.8562591671943665,
0.22554843127727509,
-0.6513286828994751,
-0.10892128199338913,
-0.9219064712524414,
0.7421984076499939,
-0.36153435707092285,
0.20184192061424255,
0.3004273474216461,
0.12800541520118713,
-0.047621142119169235,
-0.5484346151351929,
-0.4123820662498474,
-0.1498863697052002,
-0.2700498700141907,
0.3534368574619293,
-0.3611234724521637,
-0.022117579355835915,
-0.08559590578079224,
0.3400672972202301,
-0.6904616355895996,
0.017423728480935097,
-0.44565609097480774,
-0.19035431742668152,
0.6848630905151367,
0.1941431611776352,
-0.1777004450559616,
-0.37994319200515747,
-0.9417687654495239,
-0.04710109904408455,
-0.4056433141231537,
-0.030551137402653694,
0.4928305745124817,
0.05790756270289421,
0.14884361624717712,
0.5880552530288696,
-0.4478091299533844,
0.623386561870575,
0.12521007657051086,
-0.2435273379087448,
0.4102901816368103,
-0.28863781690597534,
-0.4917740225791931,
-0.13959260284900665,
0.9062963724136353,
0.7121080756187439,
-0.029472272843122482,
0.31514260172843933,
-0.39962106943130493,
0.030712740495800972,
0.5452200770378113,
-0.8703297972679138,
-0.22034327685832977,
0.4404298961162567,
-0.7654716968536377,
-0.651340663433075,
0.821819007396698,
-0.5886448621749878,
-0.6656049489974976,
-0.27443358302116394,
0.5865119099617004,
0.03795454278588295,
-0.743539571762085,
0.6142985224723816,
-0.18306441605091095,
0.030208317562937737,
0.5750319361686707,
0.08692877739667892,
0.38325390219688416,
1.0494624376296997,
0.7448775768280029,
-0.3457733690738678,
-0.38865184783935547,
-0.5159827470779419,
-0.06201506406068802,
-0.046030908823013306,
1.0659666061401367,
-0.36811336874961853,
-0.2129911184310913,
0.10222604125738144,
0.3145289123058319,
0.23465463519096375,
-0.7884197235107422,
0.2544417381286621,
-0.7739159464836121,
0.20231176912784576,
0.2551772892475128,
-0.5207566618919373,
-0.7497541308403015,
0.7987433671951294,
-0.8359924554824829,
1.2900631427764893,
0.3721714913845062,
-0.8090047240257263,
0.42950934171676636,
-0.3208010792732239,
-0.306766152381897,
-0.0516086220741272,
0.6796686053276062,
-0.798853874206543,
0.18258684873580933,
-0.10199630260467529,
0.6479177474975586,
-0.35433101654052734,
0.23481765389442444,
-0.49119123816490173,
-0.27315154671669006,
0.8482444882392883,
-0.29903653264045715,
0.7619516253471375,
0.21733984351158142,
-0.5421887040138245,
0.03458768129348755,
-0.8064011931419373,
-0.11925488710403442,
-0.2718884348869324,
-0.4103330075740814,
-0.3473617136478424,
-0.5293986201286316,
0.46920883655548096,
0.41439366340637207,
0.0493125282227993,
-0.26030364632606506,
0.2751362919807434,
-0.19098609685897827,
-0.2638084292411804,
0.6476825475692749,
0.4462263882160187,
0.40845608711242676,
-0.22617393732070923,
0.5213472247123718,
0.3554922044277191,
0.45809534192085266,
0.052858222275972366,
-0.6364275217056274,
-0.978265106678009,
-0.28099146485328674,
0.2970018684864044,
0.70877605676651,
-0.6565489768981934,
0.818729817867279,
-0.30695074796676636,
-0.6327401995658875,
-0.6037265062332153,
0.19263958930969238,
0.2509452998638153,
0.2691415250301361,
0.3361737132072449,
-0.5153204202651978,
-0.43954652547836304,
-0.8686037063598633,
-0.2383362352848053,
-0.5343967080116272,
-0.26579028367996216,
0.3345504403114319,
0.5348459482192993,
-0.3337985873222351,
0.7343144416809082,
-0.4918431043624878,
-0.6419671177864075,
-0.2217606157064438,
0.2931167781352997,
0.18189816176891327,
0.20700109004974365,
0.28008317947387695,
-1.019569754600525,
-0.5455260276794434,
0.14314109086990356,
-0.4459047019481659,
-0.36681827902793884,
0.041530247777700424,
-0.034109655767679214,
0.07482302933931351,
-0.2056097388267517,
-0.45175275206565857,
0.35367974638938904,
0.12284986674785614,
-0.23115895688533783,
0.5125812292098999,
0.02659016288816929,
0.4388193190097809,
-0.9202879071235657,
-0.1929161548614502,
0.5548150539398193,
-0.43099430203437805,
-0.5447523593902588,
-0.2781611382961273,
-0.07079771161079407,
0.28510403633117676,
-0.728090226650238,
0.4053739309310913,
-0.17801834642887115,
0.13909344375133514,
-0.6088946461677551,
-0.004947918467223644,
0.5271791815757751,
0.5527673363685608,
0.5251988768577576,
0.09750984609127045,
0.2953342795372009,
-0.8492408990859985,
0.824046790599823,
-0.15451382100582123,
-0.36685416102409363,
0.8435866832733154,
-0.4224667549133301,
0.012001235038042068,
0.1336131989955902,
0.4617632329463959,
-0.8636377453804016,
-0.059172745794057846,
0.7116168141365051,
-0.7235429286956787,
0.0892949104309082,
-0.20093770325183868,
-0.7991542220115662,
-0.2048545479774475,
-0.6851973533630371,
-0.04595302417874336,
0.32822465896606445,
-0.47444477677345276,
0.6690921187400818,
0.7042601108551025,
0.23586566746234894,
-0.5497846007347107,
-0.4701078236103058,
0.0713367760181427,
-0.44133293628692627,
-0.5538896322250366,
0.1503789871931076,
0.29903990030288696,
-0.1044694110751152,
0.16050110757350922,
0.16165390610694885,
-0.03289496526122093,
0.039418309926986694,
0.048264581710100174,
0.14438912272453308,
-0.275691956281662,
0.09273713827133179,
-0.2956628203392029,
-0.3057008385658264,
0.08029695600271225,
-0.628827691078186,
0.207193061709404,
-0.1424759179353714,
-0.024816647171974182,
-0.6678935885429382,
0.3278181850910187,
0.6137372851371765,
-0.27268317341804504,
0.6246067881584167,
0.8597432971000671,
-0.2815020680427551,
-0.6128981113433838,
-0.7774197459220886,
-0.41060712933540344,
-0.3585064113140106,
0.5117447972297668,
-0.0744929164648056,
-0.6982887983322144,
-0.042603500187397,
0.02276533469557762,
-0.2586861550807953,
0.3308517634868622,
0.6346864700317383,
-0.10511907190084457,
1.19597327709198,
0.9555690884590149,
-0.02223123610019684,
0.32911330461502075,
-0.34846872091293335,
0.22510504722595215,
-0.6611955761909485,
-0.49310117959976196,
-0.29302912950515747,
-0.3638269603252411,
-0.8209471702575684,
-0.6777211427688599,
0.20647960901260376,
-0.38260605931282043,
-0.18658871948719025,
0.22762329876422882,
-0.8330762982368469,
0.1473827362060547,
0.6405074000358582,
0.39810895919799805,
0.2901928126811981,
0.4592404365539551,
0.34171876311302185,
0.09114295989274979,
-0.5308120250701904,
-0.5535725951194763,
0.986807107925415,
0.4729311168193817,
0.7350250482559204,
-0.0673242136836052,
0.35605475306510925,
0.5800539255142212,
0.632206916809082,
-0.8663313388824463,
0.5832257270812988,
-0.11118922382593155,
-0.3985685706138611,
0.15227514505386353,
-0.11948179453611374,
-0.5215698480606079,
0.39855948090553284,
-0.1322825849056244,
-0.48370161652565,
0.32010674476623535,
-0.23495663702487946,
-0.32844945788383484,
0.21802069246768951,
-0.325290322303772,
0.6590986847877502,
-0.29661160707473755,
-0.6142110228538513,
-0.1753385365009308,
-0.5751764178276062,
0.4257098436355591,
0.11243869364261627,
0.03588486090302467,
-0.1379479467868805,
-0.29325026273727417,
0.634783148765564,
-0.5631950497627258,
0.8414134383201599,
-0.16694803535938263,
-0.12995848059654236,
0.6207704544067383,
0.022337479516863823,
0.3359689712524414,
0.2467319369316101,
0.4411190152168274,
0.2278793752193451,
-0.4167776107788086,
0.006710912566632032,
-0.6638833284378052,
0.592014729976654,
-0.6962926983833313,
-0.5473321676254272,
-0.7495799660682678,
-0.1602107584476471,
-0.19341568648815155,
-0.012386045418679714,
-0.07679267972707748,
-0.12328483909368515,
-0.01429317332804203,
0.27847930788993835,
0.9595825672149658,
-0.23154711723327637,
-0.2461506575345993,
0.9060426950454712,
-0.37422436475753784,
-0.7795131802558899,
1.1655422449111938,
0.027594130486249924,
-0.08796650916337967,
0.40487784147262573,
0.21304522454738617,
-0.3178672194480896,
-0.2338331639766693,
-0.34244000911712646,
0.24172917008399963,
-0.7371180057525635,
-0.5688748955726624,
-1.1499080657958984,
-0.3679336905479431,
-0.16986994445323944,
0.46306222677230835,
-0.18254534900188446,
-0.25277596712112427,
-0.3058740794658661,
-0.33736467361450195,
0.47044000029563904,
0.8545453548431396,
-0.040899742394685745,
0.35768499970436096,
-1.0885530710220337,
0.33115512132644653,
0.1553085893392563,
0.33166179060935974,
-0.01457124948501587,
-0.5758872032165527,
-0.5227447748184204,
-0.10957663506269455,
-0.30289021134376526,
-1.1437259912490845,
0.3459065556526184,
-0.185416579246521,
0.1918262541294098,
0.5441294312477112,
-0.07145412266254425,
0.40289318561553955,
0.09290827810764313,
0.7512761950492859,
-0.1008279100060463,
-0.48362839221954346,
0.44384413957595825,
-0.09688987582921982,
-0.060920752584934235,
0.21350035071372986,
0.5352213382720947,
-0.5061654448509216,
-0.4713612496852875,
-0.40600085258483887,
-0.6899473667144775,
0.7627382874488831,
0.14111405611038208,
-0.07293975353240967,
0.20962625741958618,
0.005790582858026028,
0.42594820261001587,
0.45413103699684143,
-0.8617218732833862,
-0.15379223227500916,
-0.08914457261562347,
0.06365834176540375,
0.1060488298535347,
-0.5514952540397644,
0.11733221262693405,
-0.17110419273376465,
1.0234172344207764,
0.15102224051952362,
-0.10942381620407104,
0.16973547637462616,
-0.5191001892089844,
0.2698241174221039,
0.0938357263803482,
0.30536264181137085,
0.3865870535373688,
-0.06269232928752899,
0.27065202593803406,
-0.22917863726615906,
-0.5953355431556702,
0.2603828012943268,
0.062177278101444244,
-0.2479303926229477,
0.3839925229549408,
0.0786575898528099,
0.43829259276390076,
0.08139917254447937,
-0.30316784977912903,
0.636429488658905,
-0.1297275722026825,
-0.09700224548578262,
-0.14351436495780945,
-0.17135803401470184,
-0.22599902749061584,
0.3529275357723236,
0.33550789952278137,
0.0040992312133312225,
0.7156877517700195,
-0.2300713062286377,
0.30938100814819336,
0.1326633244752884,
-0.6144938468933105,
-0.3533571660518646,
0.22320832312107086,
0.3474992513656616,
-0.1220032349228859,
0.3525453507900238,
0.009915895760059357,
-0.8973908424377441,
0.7034256458282471,
0.23586337268352509,
1.3481742143630981,
-0.34824591875076294,
0.5421176552772522,
0.3909224569797516,
0.5747460126876831,
-0.0486573800444603,
0.17508983612060547,
-0.3382798135280609,
-0.5410575270652771,
0.08310884982347488,
-0.8216707110404968,
-0.3446701169013977,
0.23021577298641205,
-0.5379142761230469,
0.6625593304634094,
-0.23713377118110657,
-0.35218578577041626,
0.0037895087152719498,
0.17054787278175354,
-0.6046614646911621,
0.4906921982765198,
0.18083779513835907,
0.5734652876853943,
-0.8675586581230164,
0.5726536512374878,
0.57154381275177,
-0.47266000509262085,
-0.42390307784080505,
-0.1861216127872467,
0.22427770495414734,
-0.13977962732315063,
0.6269544363021851,
0.7487941980361938,
-0.5430229902267456,
-0.3914957344532013,
-0.25639230012893677,
-0.2846943140029907,
0.6012079119682312,
-0.10364238917827606,
-0.24732811748981476,
0.6181078553199768,
0.45550593733787537,
0.7348031997680664,
-0.582509458065033,
0.16526204347610474,
0.5381268858909607,
0.5531105995178223,
-0.1344093531370163,
-0.7364199161529541,
-0.12949441373348236,
-0.6012189984321594,
-0.08265910297632217,
-0.03982434421777725,
-0.6912142634391785,
0.6074936985969543,
0.2741875648498535,
-0.11279959231615067,
-0.1099102720618248,
0.5939878225326538,
0.15574249625205994,
0.49796125292778015,
0.5678914785385132,
0.44531750679016113,
0.5274466276168823,
0.010629147291183472,
0.8348829746246338,
-0.10805243998765945,
0.5488621592521667,
0.913246750831604,
-0.3656744360923767,
0.7636505365371704,
0.3086997866630554,
-0.14562661945819855,
0.5315828919410706,
1.1064810752868652,
-0.4100560247898102,
0.3986540734767914,
0.29911527037620544,
-0.4960264265537262,
-0.15895026922225952,
-0.26366275548934937,
-0.37820321321487427,
0.44418248534202576,
0.4020020663738251,
-0.4255376160144806,
0.2077697217464447,
0.16704462468624115,
-0.01416248269379139,
-0.21228083968162537,
-0.4602448344230652,
1.1844455003738403,
0.06353132426738739,
-0.7865121364593506,
0.3345412313938141,
0.19379031658172607,
0.8881375193595886,
-0.35707688331604004,
-0.2649126350879669,
-0.06835418939590454,
0.43743813037872314,
-0.509946882724762,
-0.9119290709495544,
0.18826046586036682,
0.21220345795154572,
-0.2755272686481476,
-0.29194554686546326,
1.0533748865127563,
-0.5492885708808899,
-0.8068281412124634,
0.39543285965919495,
0.5599532723426819,
0.11690137535333633,
-0.31983482837677,
-0.6937143802642822,
-0.09983030706644058,
-0.44827935099601746,
-0.4730899930000305,
-0.003936710301786661,
0.4851197302341461,
-0.08172857761383057,
0.28329673409461975,
0.641224205493927,
-0.014732202515006065,
-0.0979829952120781,
0.0805518850684166,
0.8098950386047363,
-0.4580780267715454,
-0.8742327094078064,
-0.9370993375778198,
0.6135845184326172,
-0.5807767510414124,
-0.0657087117433548,
0.8696908950805664,
0.9359790682792664,
0.8877078890800476,
-0.3109268248081207,
0.817248523235321,
0.4715012311935425,
0.519238293170929,
-0.24379776418209076,
0.8470336198806763,
-0.7129536867141724,
0.4156230092048645,
-0.24999597668647766,
-1.2319148778915405,
-0.5235016345977783,
0.4766848683357239,
0.011606541462242603,
0.022550899535417557,
0.6768587231636047,
0.9094642400741577,
-0.18103425204753876,
-0.30813679099082947,
0.1914309710264206,
0.18161867558956146,
0.13238923251628876,
0.4142470955848694,
1.087636947631836,
-0.4613747000694275,
0.5478143095970154,
-0.3781040906906128,
-0.20470531284809113,
-0.6991513967514038,
-0.5914883613586426,
-1.0654137134552002,
-0.38142889738082886,
-0.517433226108551,
-0.9806877374649048,
-0.07921130955219269,
0.7035114169120789,
0.6079764366149902,
-0.7946707010269165,
-0.33174461126327515,
0.5405653119087219,
0.3632110357284546,
-0.35016125440597534,
-0.28449583053588867,
0.28111040592193604,
0.09258556365966797,
-0.7770676016807556,
-0.24397782981395721,
0.9188403487205505,
-0.17953766882419586,
-0.6733503937721252,
0.008205623365938663,
-0.07533778995275497,
0.19719938933849335,
0.6451854705810547,
-0.262111097574234,
-0.7938591837882996,
-0.07282008230686188,
0.3552013635635376,
-0.2723519206047058,
0.22416426241397858,
0.9748539328575134,
-0.8166800737380981,
0.6106328368186951,
0.5864516496658325,
0.4463859796524048,
0.45949068665504456,
-0.06564371287822723,
0.3663128912448883,
-0.47119665145874023,
0.2104448676109314,
0.4560600519180298,
0.12857875227928162,
0.4450095295906067,
-0.38920608162879944,
0.33480313420295715,
0.1921156644821167,
-0.28873172402381897,
-0.8890445828437805,
0.06558432430028915,
-0.9517536759376526,
-0.06179260462522507,
1.216587781906128,
-0.19126036763191223,
-0.5275043845176697,
-0.25420692563056946,
-0.4384767711162567,
-0.07746223360300064,
-0.30731916427612305,
0.967411458492279,
0.759555459022522,
0.07658825069665909,
-0.17662326991558075,
-0.22854141891002655,
0.3366309106349945,
-0.05388566106557846,
-0.8625637292861938,
-0.22658002376556396,
0.6017102599143982,
0.39927977323532104,
-0.03401578590273857,
0.4875422418117523,
-0.0630759596824646,
0.8785979747772217,
-0.3773980438709259,
-0.27866384387016296,
-0.12873432040214539,
-0.5463854670524597,
-0.38460806012153625,
0.44440340995788574,
-0.3180401027202606,
-0.19180616736412048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00014v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00014v2
|
KU-DMIS at EHRSQL 2024:Generating SQL query via question templatization in EHR
| 2024-05-22T02:15:57 | 2024-06-19T16:21:46 |
Hajung Kim, Chanhwi Kim, Hoonick Lee, Kyochul Jang, Jiwoo Lee, Kyungjae Lee, Gangwoo Kim, Jaewoo Kang
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Transforming natural language questions into SQL queries is crucial for
precise data retrieval from electronic health record (EHR) databases. A
significant challenge in this process is detecting and rejecting unanswerable
questions that request information beyond the database's scope or exceed the
system's capabilities. In this paper, we introduce a novel text-to-SQL
framework that robustly handles out-of-domain questions and verifies the
generated queries with query execution.Our framework begins by standardizing
the structure of questions into a templated format. We use a powerful large
language model (LLM), fine-tuned GPT-3.5 with detailed prompts involving the
table schemas of the EHR database system. Our experimental results demonstrate
the effectiveness of our framework on the EHRSQL-2024 benchmark benchmark, a
shared task in the ClinicalNLP workshop. Although a straightforward fine-tuning
of GPT shows promising results on the development set, it struggled with the
out-of-domain questions in the test set. With our framework, we improve our
system's adaptability and achieve competitive performances in the official
leaderboard of the EHRSQL-2024 challenge.
|
[
-0.3169749081134796,
-1.1680173873901367,
0.8096945285797119,
-0.40833044052124023,
-0.37089771032333374,
-0.10645849257707596,
0.029256293550133705,
-0.2720194160938263,
0.0431831069290638,
0.8924006819725037,
-0.4577842950820923,
-0.7322837114334106,
-0.15133169293403625,
0.14808641374111176,
-0.22193600237369537,
0.9828736186027527,
-0.11707001179456711,
-0.14682526886463165,
-0.5033305883407593,
-0.31462427973747253,
-0.2781131863594055,
-0.8943179845809937,
-0.3263579308986664,
-0.2480805218219757,
0.07334703952074051,
0.5041980743408203,
0.4644656181335449,
0.3670809864997864,
0.6235030293464661,
0.1462278664112091,
0.03241827338933945,
0.2953399419784546,
-0.20770585536956787,
0.5375517010688782,
-0.010302092880010605,
-0.38961854577064514,
-0.5600336790084839,
-0.845628023147583,
0.6015457510948181,
0.5221801400184631,
-0.5980405211448669,
0.13940933346748352,
-0.10201460123062134,
1.0753154754638672,
-0.3939463198184967,
0.05269714444875717,
-0.8703646659851074,
-0.009013822302222252,
-0.5640337467193604,
-0.37357303500175476,
-0.49654683470726013,
-0.36468368768692017,
-0.06696117669343948,
-0.17952439188957214,
0.24571067094802856,
0.2975221574306488,
0.9707094430923462,
0.3200635313987732,
-0.7292359471321106,
-0.16419652104377747,
-0.7541371583938599,
0.20023703575134277,
-0.690609872341156,
0.6950130462646484,
0.5427313446998596,
0.6514192223548889,
-0.28521740436553955,
-0.8018119931221008,
-0.4607713520526886,
0.10774141550064087,
-0.17313270270824432,
-0.043639276176691055,
-0.047564584761857986,
-0.002538179513067007,
0.11569622904062271,
0.21270640194416046,
-0.8780128955841064,
-0.14491160213947296,
-0.11042533814907074,
0.1556147187948227,
0.5485731363296509,
0.44384971261024475,
0.2699184715747833,
-0.2350577563047409,
0.00473554665222764,
0.16312645375728607,
-0.7795971632003784,
-0.21762876212596893,
-0.26505908370018005,
0.18636026978492737,
0.1351732611656189,
0.74760502576828,
-0.3289492428302765,
0.6830441355705261,
0.28604546189308167,
0.3714033365249634,
0.10207973420619965,
-0.25452256202697754,
-0.2028277963399887,
0.19931134581565857,
0.5969964861869812,
0.3448542654514313,
-0.2867237329483032,
-0.3650103211402893,
-0.23796774446964264,
-0.2779391407966614,
0.3574351966381073,
-0.8149522542953491,
-0.29188063740730286,
0.6847554445266724,
-0.23681935667991638,
0.02991807647049427,
-0.013494845479726791,
-0.9510309100151062,
-0.3495751917362213,
0.007813028059899807,
0.3564789891242981,
-0.5584501028060913,
-0.16875456273555756,
0.1762704700231552,
0.18449650704860687,
0.22929418087005615,
0.012441983446478844,
-0.8622832298278809,
0.6755189299583435,
0.5309264063835144,
0.3585149943828583,
-0.3133337199687958,
0.21277566254138947,
-0.5726789236068726,
0.3306252658367157,
-0.29845479130744934,
0.7952914237976074,
-0.1710207164287567,
-0.4706137180328369,
-0.007275454234331846,
0.05586743354797363,
-0.26327160000801086,
-0.8041380047798157,
0.3974565267562866,
-0.908277153968811,
0.40317821502685547,
-0.385809063911438,
-0.8418814539909363,
0.2309415191411972,
0.6313242316246033,
-0.4748343527317047,
1.180634617805481,
0.23394154012203217,
-0.6372673511505127,
0.414846271276474,
-0.7653617858886719,
-0.24387554824352264,
0.5270126461982727,
-0.3407917618751526,
-0.7796264886856079,
-0.1417456865310669,
0.28057587146759033,
0.24780645966529846,
-0.4602236747741699,
0.21317410469055176,
-0.015331360511481762,
-0.12187302112579346,
0.0958547368645668,
0.10757621377706528,
0.3329922556877136,
0.12280555814504623,
-0.2947376072406769,
-0.039526570588350296,
-0.7505092024803162,
0.6855852603912354,
0.27802297472953796,
-0.39941325783729553,
-0.28602150082588196,
0.15379966795444489,
-0.13738581538200378,
0.02792380005121231,
-0.057615023106336594,
-0.39313578605651855,
-0.29958805441856384,
-0.6636337637901306,
0.3466092348098755,
0.17579735815525055,
0.5303810834884644,
0.29511627554893494,
-0.33365049958229065,
0.6242155432701111,
-0.08838221430778503,
0.14247643947601318,
0.06853113323450089,
-0.444265753030777,
-0.4953077435493469,
-0.04507193714380264,
0.0849756971001625,
0.4680125117301941,
-0.9674942493438721,
0.7464801073074341,
-0.1971040517091751,
-0.5798659324645996,
-0.3635362386703491,
-0.32829660177230835,
0.16820883750915527,
0.8844290375709534,
0.7626535892486572,
-0.05158686265349388,
-0.31508561968803406,
-0.6250864863395691,
-0.37849268317222595,
-0.3032446801662445,
-0.13694867491722107,
0.3160248100757599,
0.5600524544715881,
-0.09051989763975143,
0.8538699746131897,
-0.5814156532287598,
-0.3350309133529663,
-0.1704050600528717,
-0.10530547797679901,
0.22880764305591583,
0.3947276771068573,
0.26718756556510925,
-0.8703747987747192,
-0.6771678328514099,
0.21479903161525726,
-0.894534707069397,
0.09578629583120346,
0.3803083300590515,
-0.27441734075546265,
0.2545602023601532,
0.6212428212165833,
-0.6692941188812256,
0.2993849515914917,
0.026704173535108566,
-0.4970370829105377,
0.40796881914138794,
-0.37478479743003845,
0.4209415316581726,
-0.9669938683509827,
0.24764680862426758,
-0.26968786120414734,
-0.08106972277164459,
-0.7185350656509399,
0.15873819589614868,
0.28649547696113586,
-0.2517763674259186,
-0.32151246070861816,
0.19874079525470734,
-0.3469955325126648,
0.1990938037633896,
0.2413155734539032,
-0.21882107853889465,
0.32006919384002686,
0.14370828866958618,
-0.064121313393116,
0.41377854347229004,
0.29015660285949707,
-0.5594720244407654,
0.39810675382614136,
0.6580566763877869,
-0.3424309492111206,
0.9780234098434448,
-0.7874370813369751,
0.4362037181854248,
-0.3400711715221405,
0.171035036444664,
-0.6537426710128784,
-0.4003581404685974,
0.1696673482656479,
-0.26296910643577576,
0.25342482328414917,
-0.3080068528652191,
-0.6678098440170288,
-0.4466732442378998,
-0.04790634661912918,
0.3701219856739044,
0.6016013026237488,
-0.3067861795425415,
0.6831697821617126,
0.47340109944343567,
-0.35710567235946655,
-0.0845731869339943,
-0.6185207366943359,
0.048541102558374405,
-0.3960490822792053,
-0.6098490357398987,
0.7475900053977966,
-0.0643855407834053,
-0.287850946187973,
0.05577204003930092,
0.08936315774917603,
-0.5377696752548218,
-0.4184548854827881,
-0.13138921558856964,
0.3690052032470703,
-0.5046202540397644,
0.3209531009197235,
0.36426404118537903,
0.2847406268119812,
0.3594733774662018,
-0.24790406227111816,
0.43083471059799194,
-0.07203914225101471,
-0.7915267944335938,
-0.30695661902427673,
0.5452019572257996,
0.5040720701217651,
-0.4421115219593048,
0.5255141258239746,
-0.023095404729247093,
-0.5733842253684998,
-0.10593972355127335,
-0.5661898851394653,
-0.37172314524650574,
-0.4368685781955719,
0.5706197023391724,
-0.3274857997894287,
-0.8403049111366272,
0.3018629848957062,
-0.0186301376670599,
0.045362070202827454,
0.39965319633483887,
0.5520980358123779,
-0.005719703156501055,
1.0076707601547241,
0.25914937257766724,
0.5278258323669434,
-0.12573547661304474,
0.31516033411026,
0.06474121659994125,
-0.6163695454597473,
-0.6807641983032227,
-0.6940035223960876,
0.3391752243041992,
-0.5151001811027527,
-0.4398447275161743,
0.9013391137123108,
-0.293597549200058,
-0.283601850271225,
0.1284957230091095,
-0.6543735861778259,
0.5082064867019653,
-0.02480572648346424,
0.41307199001312256,
0.3902800977230072,
-0.08201874047517776,
-0.13815195858478546,
-0.3543652892112732,
-0.534860372543335,
-0.3639269471168518,
1.016538381576538,
0.06262236833572388,
0.37183189392089844,
0.3367447555065155,
0.7460247874259949,
0.1726793497800827,
0.10371987521648407,
-0.39957213401794434,
0.510214626789093,
0.015526052564382553,
-0.8683246970176697,
-0.4703405499458313,
-0.45540353655815125,
-0.8958662748336792,
0.364608496427536,
-0.22073522210121155,
-0.5901924967765808,
-0.07072527706623077,
0.17685678601264954,
-0.4160545766353607,
0.4273889660835266,
-0.6036856770515442,
0.9105611443519592,
-0.24731911718845367,
-0.3327617049217224,
0.2626137435436249,
-0.7624699473381042,
0.041467200964689255,
-0.35256481170654297,
0.1911422610282898,
-0.1426696479320526,
0.051798898726701736,
0.46917176246643066,
-0.5242811441421509,
0.33376070857048035,
-0.1631123274564743,
-0.03819221258163452,
0.2975236475467682,
0.11524259299039841,
0.45879074931144714,
0.2493256777524948,
-0.39308685064315796,
-0.22164276242256165,
0.5737047791481018,
-0.3549644947052002,
-0.5611481666564941,
0.4655475318431854,
-0.15920250117778778,
-0.5143800377845764,
-0.3561716079711914,
-0.3194117546081543,
-0.6724867820739746,
0.5219721794128418,
0.2771158814430237,
0.55921870470047,
-0.4986896216869354,
0.07431600242853165,
0.815351665019989,
-0.35384705662727356,
-0.1598292589187622,
0.7128706574440002,
-0.13150912523269653,
-0.1356368511915207,
0.5181199312210083,
0.04152490198612213,
0.1974964588880539,
0.6805597543716431,
0.0613938644528389,
-0.7334953546524048,
-0.6079480051994324,
-0.6976329684257507,
0.2290031462907791,
-0.6899073719978333,
-0.2511872947216034,
-0.6504296064376831,
-0.15210992097854614,
-0.4892379343509674,
0.1784326732158661,
-0.2786771357059479,
-0.1214066669344902,
-0.15791508555412292,
-0.0009740780806168914,
0.41266560554504395,
0.6335912346839905,
0.4976940155029297,
-0.15119634568691254,
-1.0626152753829956,
0.17037087678909302,
0.21297915279865265,
0.34388792514801025,
-0.41574180126190186,
-0.5796202421188354,
0.028168627992272377,
-0.175571009516716,
-0.2356307953596115,
-0.8199241757392883,
0.37615618109703064,
0.3634764552116394,
0.29964205622673035,
-0.0871424525976181,
0.5574568510055542,
0.4585525691509247,
-0.8631499409675598,
0.673032820224762,
-0.0862158015370369,
-0.6768461465835571,
0.7758159637451172,
-0.41935181617736816,
0.37873703241348267,
0.8238639235496521,
0.29581061005592346,
-0.2817453145980835,
-0.1914074569940567,
-0.5562335848808289,
-0.9985141158103943,
0.3636311888694763,
0.18764600157737732,
-0.001344905118457973,
-0.15449295938014984,
0.6494896411895752,
0.06180606409907341,
0.21486960351467133,
-0.0849875956773758,
-0.3310844600200653,
0.06353126466274261,
-0.1677362322807312,
0.30091702938079834,
-0.22133000195026398,
-0.10242783278226852,
-0.3146279752254486,
0.4997257888317108,
-0.1674218475818634,
0.3431936502456665,
0.21313610672950745,
0.10952943563461304,
-0.38075974583625793,
0.6752462983131409,
0.07041699439287186,
0.6255491375923157,
-0.531677782535553,
0.14043699204921722,
0.3898724615573883,
-0.3040035665035248,
-0.07737821340560913,
0.460414320230484,
-0.20375469326972961,
0.15885326266288757,
-0.1876233071088791,
0.3773769438266754,
-0.07597412168979645,
-0.6215524077415466,
0.2646854817867279,
-0.3060055375099182,
-0.37408900260925293,
-0.10717759281396866,
-0.23951326310634613,
0.08549191057682037,
-0.17490550875663757,
0.24411319196224213,
-0.2773047983646393,
0.1796504110097885,
-0.21334253251552582,
0.6021198630332947,
0.2768181562423706,
-0.687109112739563,
-0.25472328066825867,
0.9713993668556213,
-0.04233824089169502,
-0.1019362285733223,
0.6680856347084045,
-0.05564015731215477,
-0.36500468850135803,
0.4156127870082855,
0.6048976182937622,
0.3010306656360626,
-0.27061864733695984,
0.21677668392658234,
0.253590852022171,
0.05228354409337044,
-0.01088839489966631,
0.790008544921875,
0.18517330288887024,
-0.510478138923645,
-0.18756383657455444,
-0.19316700100898743,
-0.604729413986206,
0.04777342081069946,
-0.9652933478355408,
0.313760370016098,
-0.19198821485042572,
-0.29279109835624695,
0.018460607156157494,
-0.38525325059890747,
-0.46858978271484375,
0.3337145149707794,
-0.3430022597312927,
0.5860587358474731,
-0.3902588188648224,
0.8259196877479553,
0.9999698400497437,
-0.2070545107126236,
-0.6809810996055603,
-0.04685741290450096,
-0.0719391256570816,
-0.6078444123268127,
0.2330455631017685,
-0.15272553265094757,
0.2987094521522522,
0.22357076406478882,
-0.2657790780067444,
-0.44374293088912964,
1.0154221057891846,
0.3770652711391449,
-0.3062843978404999,
-0.2145431488752365,
0.6199761629104614,
0.5875352025032043,
0.09154956787824631,
-0.10875158756971359,
0.7955703735351562,
0.33633702993392944,
0.05231531709432602,
-0.8932760953903198,
0.3743000030517578,
-0.18926268815994263,
-0.3139131963253021,
0.7555732727050781,
-0.1805115044116974,
0.5364522337913513,
-0.24918235838413239,
-0.11281968653202057,
0.05437803640961647,
0.523996889591217,
0.37820157408714294,
0.49435728788375854,
0.29790717363357544,
0.4308866262435913,
0.8106598258018494,
-0.22111840546131134,
0.9987795352935791,
-0.20351135730743408,
0.23770564794540405,
1.0064488649368286,
-0.7937512397766113,
0.7505055665969849,
0.6787082552909851,
-0.362796813249588,
0.4185158610343933,
0.29990002512931824,
0.2602618336677551,
0.6205958127975464,
0.2358156144618988,
-0.39810410141944885,
-0.16182710230350494,
-0.3025471270084381,
-0.7916436195373535,
0.09284202754497528,
0.47163456678390503,
-0.04752612113952637,
-0.23889926075935364,
-0.24742598831653595,
0.0428570993244648,
0.3396781086921692,
0.14620329439640045,
0.8893559575080872,
0.20929376780986786,
-0.6428242325782776,
0.5588155388832092,
-0.03449247404932976,
0.1689978837966919,
-0.6452733278274536,
-0.019845055416226387,
-0.13482791185379028,
0.299515962600708,
-0.11406821757555008,
-0.6646913886070251,
0.5421350598335266,
-0.08043279498815536,
0.0978422537446022,
-0.019918717443943024,
0.7912592887878418,
-0.4548271894454956,
-0.14956802129745483,
-0.1478048712015152,
0.7435396909713745,
0.050540823489427567,
-0.28647318482398987,
-0.7895335555076599,
-0.1738516390323639,
-0.198449969291687,
-0.05860160291194916,
0.5107167363166809,
0.9240019917488098,
0.015839828178286552,
0.307718962430954,
0.43075689673423767,
0.2307419776916504,
-0.27017584443092346,
0.06744524091482162,
0.8568474650382996,
-0.3693119287490845,
-0.5006048679351807,
-0.7164067625999451,
0.3664885461330414,
-0.0541287362575531,
-0.24501003324985504,
0.5607074499130249,
0.6117644309997559,
0.3828389346599579,
-0.004710576497018337,
0.5760639905929565,
-0.22060973942279816,
0.8402686715126038,
-0.5482988357543945,
0.9083390831947327,
-0.5764369368553162,
0.2525627017021179,
-0.20475251972675323,
-0.4624674320220947,
-0.5134233236312866,
0.01362672634422779,
-0.1703341156244278,
-0.031893305480480194,
0.9350362420082092,
0.7540339827537537,
0.3386306166648865,
0.045064713805913925,
0.4102497100830078,
-0.13852964341640472,
0.5600519776344299,
0.37722110748291016,
0.554648220539093,
-0.6129889488220215,
0.5799915790557861,
-0.22495810687541962,
-0.00859882403165102,
0.014208332635462284,
-0.7296753525733948,
-0.7377640604972839,
-0.5477612614631653,
-0.4218710958957672,
-0.727415144443512,
0.3301980793476105,
0.8639192581176758,
0.6311375498771667,
-0.9691295623779297,
0.056292347609996796,
-0.06539639830589294,
-0.0942312479019165,
-0.13896912336349487,
-0.2413254976272583,
0.7101894021034241,
-0.005507584661245346,
-0.1986798793077469,
0.3608953356742859,
0.3071517050266266,
0.036667436361312866,
0.27704954147338867,
0.07882726192474365,
-0.029613759368658066,
-0.06865231692790985,
0.5279409885406494,
0.30498525500297546,
-0.18561773002147675,
0.03873361647129059,
0.3726978302001953,
-0.06683745235204697,
0.10300890356302261,
0.6687749624252319,
-0.4512527287006378,
0.440626323223114,
0.33460450172424316,
0.7055269479751587,
0.5032587051391602,
0.12222226709127426,
0.4234538972377777,
-0.7789896726608276,
-0.3216722011566162,
0.7136989235877991,
0.078823022544384,
0.40108364820480347,
-0.6503171920776367,
0.2728046178817749,
0.05385306477546692,
-0.787935197353363,
-0.8372498154640198,
0.2246159464120865,
-0.6087433099746704,
-0.00766987819224596,
1.0527602434158325,
0.22358183562755585,
-0.03927098959684372,
-0.7584709525108337,
-0.012146822176873684,
-0.01843571662902832,
-0.29828914999961853,
0.7796962857246399,
0.3075534403324127,
-0.4734809696674347,
-0.0484086349606514,
-0.6871002316474915,
0.6116390824317932,
0.6006987690925598,
-1.3115699291229248,
0.052262917160987854,
0.3735377788543701,
0.2529815137386322,
-0.410766065120697,
1.0143377780914307,
-0.7369509935379028,
0.27471521496772766,
-0.4816751480102539,
-0.12182629853487015,
0.2491052746772766,
0.30160972476005554,
0.05047553777694702,
0.30155548453330994,
0.22522562742233276,
-0.05402051657438278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13274v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13274v1
|
DiffNorm: Self-Supervised Normalization for Non-autoregressive Speech-to-speech Translation
| 2024-05-22T01:10:39 | 2024-05-22T01:10:39 |
Weiting Tan, Jingyu Zhang, Lingfeng Shen, Daniel Khashabi, Philipp Koehn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Non-autoregressive Transformers (NATs) are recently applied in direct
speech-to-speech translation systems, which convert speech across different
languages without intermediate text data. Although NATs generate high-quality
outputs and offer faster inference than autoregressive models, they tend to
produce incoherent and repetitive results due to complex data distribution
(e.g., acoustic and linguistic variations in speech). In this work, we
introduce DiffNorm, a diffusion-based normalization strategy that simplifies
data distributions for training NAT models. After training with a
self-supervised noise estimation objective, DiffNorm constructs normalized
target data by denoising synthetically corrupted speech features. Additionally,
we propose to regularize NATs with classifier-free guidance, improving model
robustness and translation quality by randomly dropping out source information
during training. Our strategies result in a notable improvement of about +7
ASR-BLEU for English-Spanish (En-Es) and +2 ASR-BLEU for English-French (En-Fr)
translations on the CVSS benchmark, while attaining over 14x speedup for En-Es
and 5x speedup for En-Fr translations compared to autoregressive baselines.
|
[
-0.5876947045326233,
-0.5468836426734924,
-0.15476645529270172,
0.6523512005805969,
-0.4021921157836914,
-0.16409078240394592,
-0.35761600732803345,
0.02704653888940811,
0.17921680212020874,
0.33735010027885437,
-0.4788860082626343,
-0.47931134700775146,
-0.9201477766036987,
0.31600821018218994,
-0.8258771896362305,
0.8560583591461182,
0.10876132547855377,
0.15248356759548187,
0.21188358962535858,
-0.02147381380200386,
-0.16762076318264008,
-0.05603358522057533,
-0.6658766269683838,
-0.1604917198419571,
0.23192378878593445,
0.19432421028614044,
0.6554012298583984,
0.6662435531616211,
0.3556863069534302,
0.31518885493278503,
-0.1914505511522293,
0.1233854666352272,
-0.5729518532752991,
0.27929621934890747,
-0.2098507434129715,
-0.3494728207588196,
-0.3258976340293884,
0.1543823480606079,
0.8259767889976501,
0.7023404240608215,
-0.45873743295669556,
0.16409172117710114,
0.0066400691866874695,
0.8598218560218811,
-0.35992538928985596,
0.2047235369682312,
-0.4760661721229553,
0.17669354379177094,
-0.1274423748254776,
-0.03340078145265579,
-0.2139507234096527,
-0.3887026906013489,
-0.05110112577676773,
-0.31113025546073914,
0.583227276802063,
-0.20762485265731812,
0.48684951663017273,
0.8407445549964905,
-0.42168277502059937,
-0.06949873268604279,
-1.0774121284484863,
0.9408727288246155,
-0.8614928126335144,
0.7085573673248291,
0.28791728615760803,
0.3601958751678467,
-0.34333088994026184,
-0.45096200704574585,
-0.564099907875061,
0.15216012299060822,
-0.1891523003578186,
0.36278533935546875,
-0.6903768181800842,
-0.05016443133354187,
0.04367150366306305,
0.4945160448551178,
-0.576781690120697,
0.1604328751564026,
-0.36844193935394287,
-0.1704271137714386,
0.8840758800506592,
-0.24590818583965302,
-0.018578626215457916,
0.033775415271520615,
-0.2583129405975342,
-0.27820661664009094,
-0.21454745531082153,
-0.2963404059410095,
0.4781323969364166,
0.33759090304374695,
-0.3999486267566681,
0.23395735025405884,
-0.4788578748703003,
0.8642138838768005,
0.4329686462879181,
-0.3406467139720917,
0.6013776063919067,
-0.3767765760421753,
-0.2557235658168793,
0.1711013913154602,
0.9488508701324463,
0.1900065541267395,
0.054688140749931335,
-0.4379671812057495,
-0.3261396586894989,
-0.07565169781446457,
-0.08357472717761993,
-0.5771178007125854,
-0.3477209210395813,
-0.0610421746969223,
-0.36339983344078064,
-0.2716478109359741,
-0.3465421497821808,
-0.8878219127655029,
0.20629817247390747,
-0.41117149591445923,
0.3991638123989105,
-0.11940460652112961,
-0.4881833493709564,
0.19779148697853088,
-0.03484801948070526,
0.09138727188110352,
0.3704555332660675,
-0.7505438327789307,
0.43512970209121704,
-0.07417627424001694,
0.9234943389892578,
-0.5212034583091736,
-0.09196771681308746,
-0.691094696521759,
0.06736492365598679,
-0.6234182119369507,
0.5508313775062561,
-0.06317319720983505,
-0.5063880085945129,
-0.3201225697994232,
0.027910076081752777,
-0.10764393210411072,
-0.6054185628890991,
0.48473018407821655,
-0.28618142008781433,
0.2220931500196457,
0.18633995950222015,
-0.36089611053466797,
-0.13739114999771118,
-0.037222910672426224,
-0.481265127658844,
1.029367446899414,
-0.012849473394453526,
-0.5531018972396851,
0.004353562835603952,
-0.5866005420684814,
-0.6416776776313782,
-0.2734333276748657,
0.03473815694451332,
-0.4584270715713501,
0.25658532977104187,
0.21745075285434723,
0.5092383623123169,
-0.20118944346904755,
0.4121028184890747,
0.17077404260635376,
-0.09364890307188034,
-0.10979112982749939,
-0.7964579463005066,
0.6435432434082031,
0.4636642038822174,
-0.5741879940032959,
-0.30271685123443604,
-0.8532317280769348,
-0.4210415184497833,
-0.06473865360021591,
-0.14550712704658508,
-0.2118062973022461,
-0.17421765625476837,
-0.1041005477309227,
0.347745418548584,
0.055471546947956085,
-0.46658408641815186,
-0.03333791717886925,
-0.5818930268287659,
0.30641329288482666,
0.5541477799415588,
-0.10503440350294113,
0.8490012288093567,
-0.3126314580440521,
0.41820013523101807,
0.36779919266700745,
0.201848566532135,
0.16381368041038513,
-0.6642721891403198,
-0.8175926208496094,
-0.5280143618583679,
0.3350907266139984,
0.4360279142856598,
-0.5069442987442017,
0.4416784644126892,
-0.16465690732002258,
-0.57160884141922,
-0.6924628019332886,
0.2961462736129761,
0.16825121641159058,
0.9908101558685303,
0.960071325302124,
-0.39323627948760986,
-0.3939800262451172,
-0.8861586451530457,
-0.07959921658039093,
0.07608116418123245,
-0.10537794232368469,
-0.26806190609931946,
0.07664712518453598,
-0.7687113285064697,
0.9081634879112244,
-0.19240164756774902,
-0.6201475858688354,
0.09119990468025208,
0.4239179193973541,
0.24826452136039734,
0.6475851535797119,
0.30494895577430725,
-0.7920033931732178,
-0.7655696272850037,
-0.16219577193260193,
-0.287594199180603,
-0.33325204253196716,
-0.16322734951972961,
-0.1274893879890442,
0.15302234888076782,
0.7401021718978882,
-0.16261881589889526,
0.6288378238677979,
0.7622246146202087,
0.24209536612033844,
0.08108621835708618,
-0.3847200572490692,
-0.04975118115544319,
-1.0998382568359375,
-0.06627875566482544,
0.18175016343593597,
-0.5637670159339905,
-0.8947104215621948,
-0.6153272986412048,
-0.016621073707938194,
0.18627296388149261,
-0.5325886607170105,
0.44415760040283203,
-0.5622091293334961,
0.12704500555992126,
-0.1819293051958084,
0.3104146420955658,
-0.022391922771930695,
0.10944778472185135,
0.16823920607566833,
0.7637497186660767,
0.6641674637794495,
-0.7810313105583191,
0.36852794885635376,
0.41115814447402954,
0.18562480807304382,
0.5987745523452759,
-0.3992435038089752,
0.05408187210559845,
-0.46742233633995056,
0.2822836637496948,
-1.1268926858901978,
0.22092440724372864,
0.1331213414669037,
-0.34200742840766907,
0.5869099497795105,
-0.37458211183547974,
-0.5140256881713867,
-0.014340754598379135,
0.016521241515874863,
0.2241106629371643,
0.8497674465179443,
-0.5773205757141113,
0.41862568259239197,
0.3457941710948944,
-0.02770894020795822,
-0.35992515087127686,
-1.0268839597702026,
0.037474624812603,
-0.24995629489421844,
-0.522881031036377,
0.44143131375312805,
-0.21820053458213806,
-0.1694054752588272,
-0.19747941195964813,
-0.28735122084617615,
-0.23576892912387848,
0.04268990829586983,
-0.023031732067465782,
-0.02692538872361183,
-0.014647815376520157,
0.16690462827682495,
0.5649048089981079,
-0.23033301532268524,
-0.1392851024866104,
-0.3215620219707489,
0.2899721562862396,
0.004416106268763542,
-0.21055300533771515,
-0.5767912268638611,
0.3223344087600708,
0.17131048440933228,
-0.14737063646316528,
0.43653905391693115,
0.845390796661377,
-0.16472381353378296,
-0.28767189383506775,
-0.7515993714332581,
-0.3200509548187256,
-0.4809384346008301,
0.03287789225578308,
-0.20849433541297913,
-0.6283705830574036,
0.22337569296360016,
-0.2478092461824417,
0.2256907820701599,
0.5453357696533203,
0.6180142760276794,
-0.19871480762958527,
0.8479717969894409,
0.31517547369003296,
-0.21199414134025574,
0.417106032371521,
-0.45779699087142944,
0.19505739212036133,
-0.7756214737892151,
-0.0985172688961029,
-0.27483242750167847,
-0.5298274755477905,
-0.6512203812599182,
-0.923668622970581,
0.1887028068304062,
0.16617126762866974,
0.28268879652023315,
0.4357079863548279,
-0.7193304896354675,
0.19280873239040375,
0.47151505947113037,
-0.32452645897865295,
0.5860111713409424,
0.28727221488952637,
0.08739498257637024,
-0.19961373507976532,
-0.7144067883491516,
-0.13402427732944489,
1.0019999742507935,
0.31313082575798035,
1.0721724033355713,
0.20833720266819,
1.0557119846343994,
0.3995262086391449,
0.2785402238368988,
-0.5731638073921204,
0.18146441876888275,
-0.45856034755706787,
-0.31947365403175354,
-0.5175308585166931,
-0.7717577219009399,
-1.0636041164398193,
0.31004878878593445,
0.015517069026827812,
-0.12414668500423431,
0.5940077304840088,
0.17077761888504028,
-0.06887292116880417,
0.10359907150268555,
-0.5251256823539734,
0.4042509198188782,
-0.031717557460069656,
0.02216051146388054,
-0.1130433976650238,
-0.6759303212165833,
0.10795583575963974,
-0.22791355848312378,
0.5335983037948608,
-0.14071224629878998,
0.043426528573036194,
0.6099779605865479,
0.03397681191563606,
0.8067671060562134,
-0.31728219985961914,
-0.1873285174369812,
0.18299171328544617,
0.2999333441257477,
0.4423033893108368,
0.2528567314147949,
-0.0024236051831394434,
0.7070155143737793,
-0.10151537507772446,
-0.26183244585990906,
-0.4684711694717407,
0.7613375186920166,
-0.8267638087272644,
-0.45712435245513916,
-0.4113001227378845,
-0.49705252051353455,
-0.19946306943893433,
0.12561887502670288,
0.4247516393661499,
0.13421177864074707,
-0.034062113612890244,
0.09815511852502823,
1.0463078022003174,
0.17800888419151306,
0.5677133798599243,
0.895440399646759,
0.020491670817136765,
-0.2839468717575073,
0.9010016322135925,
0.31983715295791626,
0.5327804088592529,
0.2820897400379181,
0.24561187624931335,
-0.6842039227485657,
-0.78623366355896,
-0.4502485990524292,
0.3969558775424957,
-0.6113324761390686,
-0.2545802593231201,
-0.7542147636413574,
-0.3039821982383728,
-0.7246552109718323,
0.13635872304439545,
-0.7117099165916443,
-0.5628907084465027,
-0.6445366740226746,
0.02705998718738556,
0.3562142252922058,
0.4031127989292145,
-0.7149112820625305,
0.32915666699409485,
-0.5290332436561584,
0.6472402215003967,
0.4068964421749115,
0.1640353500843048,
-0.36221346259117126,
-1.1832290887832642,
-0.13200737535953522,
0.30840131640434265,
-0.14962895214557648,
-0.7437469959259033,
0.7769486904144287,
0.435412734746933,
0.6244817972183228,
0.18089543282985687,
0.23689201474189758,
0.8820325136184692,
-0.5433564186096191,
0.4809826612472534,
0.34270793199539185,
-0.8068971633911133,
0.5984730124473572,
-0.034409746527671814,
0.299927294254303,
0.5766496658325195,
0.30686870217323303,
-0.7160640358924866,
-0.5555708408355713,
-0.5392507910728455,
-0.6946508288383484,
0.5239964127540588,
0.4228290319442749,
0.3108295500278473,
-0.2553974688053131,
0.3637680113315582,
-0.030120134353637695,
0.2705947756767273,
-0.4954952001571655,
-0.6268801093101501,
-0.5816030502319336,
-0.16902819275856018,
-0.4020826816558838,
0.18865276873111725,
-0.19283589720726013,
-0.3386698365211487,
0.8013765215873718,
-0.0933641791343689,
-0.05284800007939339,
0.635115385055542,
-0.3600810766220093,
-0.14420825242996216,
0.14016379415988922,
0.5885083675384521,
-0.044900987297296524,
0.02569475769996643,
0.10182596743106842,
0.2367551326751709,
-0.37618106603622437,
0.40961581468582153,
0.20473194122314453,
-0.32189643383026123,
0.498222291469574,
-0.15627802908420563,
0.5877189636230469,
0.08989563584327698,
-0.23533995449543,
0.6102973818778992,
-0.3060413599014282,
-0.3309643864631653,
-0.35999777913093567,
-0.06102991849184036,
0.11595495790243149,
0.12799763679504395,
0.2609661817550659,
0.3370499014854431,
0.432075560092926,
0.011692706495523453,
0.30679699778556824,
0.3143647313117981,
-0.44470250606536865,
-0.42659637331962585,
0.6457704305648804,
0.193461075425148,
-0.30416396260261536,
0.4145931899547577,
-0.37167462706565857,
0.1965106874704361,
0.15305836498737335,
0.5433107614517212,
0.9864651560783386,
-0.7452068328857422,
0.34371376037597656,
0.3651949465274811,
0.3589201271533966,
-0.5540158748626709,
0.009974014014005661,
-0.19732655584812164,
-0.47711604833602905,
-0.4284714460372925,
-0.8394775390625,
-0.22024352848529816,
-0.00030126297497190535,
-0.7968500852584839,
0.23665791749954224,
-0.17424477636814117,
-0.09651031345129013,
-0.3432965874671936,
-0.5373064875602722,
-0.7113280892372131,
0.3138978183269501,
0.07064840197563171,
0.6455418467521667,
-0.8901416063308716,
1.0126926898956299,
0.2228941172361374,
-0.18395136296749115,
-0.507102906703949,
0.01419199351221323,
-0.17387212812900543,
-0.3892997205257416,
0.6575683951377869,
-0.3157971501350403,
-0.3626805543899536,
0.4100421965122223,
-0.14334173500537872,
-1.1690644025802612,
0.8557103276252747,
0.5755760669708252,
-0.9622290730476379,
0.014838914386928082,
0.40081918239593506,
0.6450014114379883,
-0.11710420250892639,
0.04141410067677498,
0.6215516328811646,
0.4229719638824463,
0.21753406524658203,
-0.9901657104492188,
-0.3636772930622101,
0.018988894298672676,
0.22802025079727173,
0.14238713681697845,
-0.6318396329879761,
0.6733932495117188,
0.2984992563724518,
-0.2473175823688507,
-0.4299077093601227,
0.6203673481941223,
-0.3579055368900299,
0.09972231835126877,
0.5817368030548096,
0.5752130746841431,
0.5508942008018494,
0.007084702607244253,
0.3746967315673828,
-0.3352791965007782,
0.35573747754096985,
1.2484925985336304,
0.11853566765785217,
0.6321485638618469,
0.8282675743103027,
-0.1433742791414261,
0.2900916337966919,
0.3006570041179657,
0.06497432291507721,
0.7611519694328308,
0.26754331588745117,
-0.26775598526000977,
-0.04947211593389511,
0.32730934023857117,
-0.4029081165790558,
0.4172816872596741,
0.22964882850646973,
-0.25924941897392273,
-0.7085362672805786,
0.17516715824604034,
-0.1804271787405014,
0.3411456346511841,
-0.008991147391498089,
0.8894638419151306,
0.18299555778503418,
-0.28337347507476807,
1.0031795501708984,
0.0812058076262474,
0.9025358557701111,
-0.4769919812679291,
0.13753993809223175,
-0.575757622718811,
-0.10686291754245758,
-0.34715813398361206,
-0.2288331389427185,
0.8391198515892029,
0.008751217275857925,
-0.21135364472866058,
-0.6092712879180908,
0.18609187006950378,
-0.6968729496002197,
-0.5719438195228577,
0.38230234384536743,
0.42695268988609314,
0.30056115984916687,
-0.03777815029025078,
-0.7831259965896606,
-0.2042955756187439,
0.017669878900051117,
-0.17269116640090942,
0.3375137448310852,
0.43749675154685974,
0.07386375218629837,
0.5193178057670593,
0.8595267534255981,
0.23258964717388153,
0.5444154143333435,
0.10858244448900223,
0.669775664806366,
-0.17273515462875366,
-0.30760636925697327,
-0.7787230014801025,
0.4426251947879791,
-0.02135074883699417,
-0.1446138471364975,
0.9782543182373047,
0.6046435832977295,
0.8669838309288025,
0.008678048849105835,
0.5954099893569946,
0.2757565379142761,
0.696985125541687,
-0.1831122487783432,
0.6979947686195374,
-0.4683326482772827,
0.1940627247095108,
-0.1127001941204071,
-0.8372951149940491,
-0.39700448513031006,
0.9275981187820435,
-0.18907107412815094,
-0.3867611289024353,
0.22465525567531586,
0.8347578048706055,
-0.25064653158187866,
-0.408637672662735,
0.6577470302581787,
0.27608391642570496,
0.5450669527053833,
-0.07566648721694946,
0.34044620394706726,
-0.6799177527427673,
0.6674514412879944,
-0.5013308525085449,
-0.3931137025356293,
-0.016520341858267784,
-0.6967517137527466,
-0.8000190258026123,
-0.44131550192832947,
-0.7130432724952698,
-0.20661324262619019,
-0.20868828892707825,
0.5969797372817993,
0.814354658126831,
-0.7619612216949463,
-0.42727962136268616,
-0.4768016040325165,
-0.0022931566927582026,
-0.2115137279033661,
-0.17517246305942535,
-0.011758996173739433,
-0.7465641498565674,
-0.9088156819343567,
0.9341831207275391,
0.3669375777244568,
0.3981001079082489,
-0.5701474547386169,
-0.14287713170051575,
-0.09860580414533615,
0.35377374291419983,
0.2567814290523529,
0.17322343587875366,
-0.6037715673446655,
0.15665343403816223,
-0.13924987614154816,
-0.07972992211580276,
0.42649370431900024,
0.16052821278572083,
-0.6857844591140747,
0.9495338797569275,
0.37373805046081543,
0.30364951491355896,
0.9409923553466797,
-0.13289830088615417,
0.4093197286128998,
-0.8508082628250122,
0.5869143605232239,
0.5009865760803223,
0.12184394896030426,
0.4729802906513214,
-0.3202630281448364,
0.36342763900756836,
0.18308886885643005,
-0.413266658782959,
-0.9277997612953186,
0.27244383096694946,
-0.6551221013069153,
0.132725790143013,
1.1746811866760254,
-0.12623386085033417,
-0.22557857632637024,
-0.22760456800460815,
0.07853332906961441,
0.4292272627353668,
-0.5117199420928955,
0.9610015153884888,
0.3434678316116333,
0.021911855787038803,
-0.02487272396683693,
-0.40203553438186646,
0.7894842624664307,
0.3423207700252533,
-0.4685465395450592,
-0.08278758078813553,
0.28087007999420166,
0.5572083592414856,
0.20193105936050415,
0.6395514011383057,
-0.2971962094306946,
-0.006324622314423323,
-0.3711356520652771,
-0.021778782829642296,
0.18732167780399323,
-0.1185821145772934,
-0.7315914630889893,
-0.38091203570365906,
-0.14591093361377716,
-0.3050214350223541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13272v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13272v1
|
A Multilingual Similarity Dataset for News Article Frame
| 2024-05-22T01:01:04 | 2024-05-22T01:01:04 |
Xi Chen, Mattia Samory, Scott Hale, David Jurgens, Przemyslaw A. Grabowicz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Understanding the writing frame of news articles is vital for addressing
social issues, and thus has attracted notable attention in the fields of
communication studies. Yet, assessing such news article frames remains a
challenge due to the absence of a concrete and unified standard dataset that
considers the comprehensive nuances within news content.
To address this gap, we introduce an extended version of a large labeled news
article dataset with 16,687 new labeled pairs. Leveraging the pairwise
comparison of news articles, our method frees the work of manual identification
of frame classes in traditional news frame analysis studies. Overall we
introduce the most extensive cross-lingual news article similarity dataset
available to date with 26,555 labeled news article pairs across 10 languages.
Each data point has been meticulously annotated according to a codebook
detailing eight critical aspects of news content, under a human-in-the-loop
framework. Application examples demonstrate its potential in unearthing country
communities within global news coverage, exposing media bias among news
outlets, and quantifying the factors related to news creation. We envision that
this news similarity dataset will broaden our understanding of the media
ecosystem in terms of news coverage of events and perspectives across
countries, locations, languages, and other social constructs. By doing so, it
can catalyze advancements in social science research and applied methodologies,
thereby exerting a profound impact on our society.
|
[
-0.40418124198913574,
-0.537852942943573,
0.3577412962913513,
0.2673710882663727,
-0.31354066729545593,
0.23535923659801483,
-0.3733147382736206,
-0.5479145646095276,
0.6369901299476624,
0.34724152088165283,
-0.3858834505081177,
-0.5379597544670105,
-0.6134829521179199,
0.2347566783428192,
-0.6601269841194153,
1.07217276096344,
-0.20307010412216187,
0.0848381370306015,
-0.04299735650420189,
-0.508666455745697,
-0.031972941011190414,
-0.3156682252883911,
-0.32788005471229553,
-0.12949100136756897,
0.5628684163093567,
0.23448485136032104,
0.7329105138778687,
0.45328956842422485,
0.42579206824302673,
0.1961510181427002,
-0.03690385818481445,
0.057881779968738556,
-0.6155114769935608,
-0.3081648051738739,
-0.0961352065205574,
-0.1457400918006897,
-0.24653472006320953,
0.08119384199380875,
0.8491037487983704,
0.8875774145126343,
0.26150619983673096,
0.6280866861343384,
0.152237668633461,
0.8372450470924377,
-0.3208957612514496,
0.1131756603717804,
-0.43455785512924194,
0.2657604515552521,
-0.438747763633728,
-0.0659383088350296,
-0.12774063646793365,
-0.4824896454811096,
-0.03896597400307655,
-0.6247459053993225,
0.21817748248577118,
0.16902212798595428,
0.8362601399421692,
-0.25901052355766296,
-0.8111559152603149,
-0.12411554157733917,
-0.2343026101589203,
0.3400794267654419,
-0.42908838391304016,
0.6332226395606995,
0.015433376654982567,
-0.106753408908844,
0.013234961777925491,
-0.22393056750297546,
-0.6834668517112732,
0.31110894680023193,
-0.10198447853326797,
-0.09397605806589127,
-0.17284290492534637,
-0.40773075819015503,
0.18030330538749695,
0.28874990344047546,
-0.9665026068687439,
-0.23308627307415009,
-0.8080705404281616,
-0.23237498104572296,
0.5526514649391174,
0.04931056126952171,
0.4025574326515198,
-0.3403521776199341,
-0.4906185567378998,
-0.038312025368213654,
-0.6344844102859497,
0.11394643783569336,
0.6978806853294373,
0.18810813128948212,
-0.43613994121551514,
0.5389990210533142,
-0.4923771917819977,
0.7070463299751282,
-0.2932453453540802,
-0.0767734944820404,
0.8562061786651611,
-0.1657310277223587,
-0.03267553076148033,
0.24467547237873077,
0.6373315453529358,
1.0277307033538818,
0.2185644954442978,
-0.1725558489561081,
0.06626199930906296,
0.033717840909957886,
0.10787482559680939,
-0.519347608089447,
0.12194270640611649,
-0.38220643997192383,
-0.6206454634666443,
-0.31899887323379517,
0.3203355073928833,
-0.923882007598877,
-0.34708842635154724,
-0.52327960729599,
0.15223494172096252,
0.14066532254219055,
-0.43460342288017273,
0.10418995469808578,
-0.12442672252655029,
0.4754510521888733,
-0.24986739456653595,
-0.5088887214660645,
0.10429730266332626,
0.9622868299484253,
0.863697350025177,
-0.41020146012306213,
-0.4435916244983673,
-0.17319250106811523,
0.07574549317359924,
-0.6771465539932251,
0.7867986559867859,
-0.7008587121963501,
0.22908617556095123,
0.01999511569738388,
0.2829367220401764,
0.11532595008611679,
-0.22318017482757568,
0.316090852022171,
-0.667156994342804,
0.27211859822273254,
-0.30168241262435913,
-0.457867830991745,
-0.24797144532203674,
0.40416377782821655,
-1.0593446493148804,
0.831760585308075,
0.0907614603638649,
-0.9274981021881104,
0.4126362204551697,
-0.2386372983455658,
-0.6653753519058228,
-0.4608341157436371,
0.020548373460769653,
-0.3861187696456909,
0.22264911234378815,
0.28125980496406555,
0.4840947389602661,
-0.1259932816028595,
0.5689746141433716,
-0.655575156211853,
-0.44774314761161804,
0.2117053121328354,
-0.4521317481994629,
0.7464292645454407,
0.22339186072349548,
-0.0010114975739270449,
-0.10851791501045227,
-0.8892829418182373,
-0.01013837568461895,
-0.2330901026725769,
-0.24087989330291748,
-0.71327805519104,
-0.5673732757568359,
0.22760972380638123,
0.21554356813430786,
0.0863305926322937,
-0.6916305422782898,
-0.06372817605733871,
-0.1117032915353775,
0.41901442408561707,
0.47707685828208923,
0.021670399233698845,
0.48286980390548706,
-0.3091769516468048,
0.3340875506401062,
-0.09806861728429794,
-0.016070451587438583,
-0.47290417551994324,
-0.31457018852233887,
-0.3664378821849823,
0.28137072920799255,
0.49202239513397217,
0.412930428981781,
-0.7299244999885559,
0.17888103425502777,
-0.606814980506897,
-0.18532845377922058,
-0.5528726577758789,
0.1445309817790985,
0.6062315106391907,
0.36524343490600586,
0.073561891913414,
-0.4258311688899994,
-0.7399488687515259,
-0.9164624810218811,
-0.5328205823898315,
0.2340347170829773,
0.21412841975688934,
-0.20467668771743774,
0.19463370740413666,
0.20187300443649292,
0.7453086376190186,
-0.3252590298652649,
-0.188701793551445,
-0.1543724238872528,
0.06735222786664963,
0.23297996819019318,
0.15879058837890625,
0.5102132558822632,
-1.0345662832260132,
-0.4571339786052704,
-0.06420706957578659,
-0.9974527359008789,
-0.11346985399723053,
-0.14103490114212036,
-0.2716505527496338,
0.36635109782218933,
0.742974042892456,
-0.13891296088695526,
0.24536451697349548,
0.7938633561134338,
-0.4917212724685669,
0.21282264590263367,
0.11527964472770691,
0.5402853488922119,
-1.2398332357406616,
0.1000363752245903,
0.15514802932739258,
-0.1585465669631958,
-0.3727976679801941,
0.020033253356814384,
0.09412144124507904,
-0.4498008191585541,
-0.4886574149131775,
0.689355731010437,
-0.48375561833381653,
-0.45607733726501465,
-0.16379418969154358,
0.24664847552776337,
0.20863452553749084,
0.49267858266830444,
-0.0334743894636631,
0.5549248456954956,
0.39833423495292664,
0.04758528620004654,
0.6438482403755188,
0.22412317991256714,
-0.8693636655807495,
0.6157572269439697,
-0.3598949611186981,
0.04070892184972763,
-0.5311847925186157,
0.47497549653053284,
-0.7257744669914246,
-0.210676908493042,
0.2050168663263321,
-0.37959691882133484,
0.051465410739183426,
0.1810680627822876,
-0.2936134338378906,
-0.30428430438041687,
-0.4344180226325989,
0.3856889605522156,
-0.05374947190284729,
-0.4110255837440491,
-0.022478463128209114,
0.6504625082015991,
-0.5180765390396118,
-0.7643036246299744,
-0.7110938429832458,
0.47593626379966736,
-0.355128675699234,
-0.6088815331459045,
0.2529022693634033,
0.179245725274086,
-0.2551485002040863,
0.5106703639030457,
-0.20501285791397095,
-0.24380460381507874,
-0.1620096117258072,
-0.1026000827550888,
0.15370719134807587,
-0.54315185546875,
0.400064080953598,
0.1641819030046463,
-0.2520497441291809,
-0.06406240910291672,
-0.05358640477061272,
0.14450764656066895,
-0.12427019327878952,
-0.1756550371646881,
-0.08115632086992264,
0.8199545741081238,
0.39988642930984497,
-0.4420824944972992,
0.48048457503318787,
0.6869535446166992,
-0.4238264262676239,
0.1655241698026657,
-0.41104504466056824,
0.11025507003068924,
-0.2725617289543152,
0.6088120937347412,
-0.39589470624923706,
-0.8935611248016357,
0.3695983588695526,
0.3314156234264374,
-0.1401223987340927,
0.25795769691467285,
0.2255561649799347,
0.27639105916023254,
0.5267506241798401,
0.6834812164306641,
-0.49180474877357483,
0.30538660287857056,
-0.02272871322929859,
0.2286844402551651,
-0.5571818351745605,
-0.18851512670516968,
-0.2013181447982788,
-0.6585992574691772,
-0.16230563819408417,
-0.3004165589809418,
0.20951658487319946,
-0.09295447915792465,
-0.16079367697238922,
0.4350356161594391,
-0.20226234197616577,
0.9204240441322327,
0.37314462661743164,
0.04738672077655792,
0.5745218396186829,
0.17159734666347504,
0.23872308433055878,
-0.04433488845825195,
-0.5085126757621765,
-0.4951555132865906,
1.2123991250991821,
0.03457477688789368,
0.758215069770813,
-0.03353840857744217,
0.6369205117225647,
0.4840076267719269,
0.37125229835510254,
-0.31036847829818726,
0.2441667765378952,
-0.09881679713726044,
-0.6135465502738953,
-0.30720388889312744,
-0.40416404604911804,
-0.7759181261062622,
0.30211859941482544,
-0.326930433511734,
-0.5573770403862,
0.12321926653385162,
-0.33108416199684143,
-0.38234275579452515,
0.3950938582420349,
-0.742195725440979,
0.8533304929733276,
-0.08737411350011826,
-0.2220793217420578,
-0.26999643445014954,
-0.7617658972740173,
0.417557030916214,
-0.3125080466270447,
0.6428950428962708,
-0.40170052647590637,
0.028934039175510406,
0.8458660840988159,
0.27805426716804504,
0.7783614993095398,
0.19480033218860626,
-0.28686439990997314,
0.16648951172828674,
-0.41854584217071533,
-0.1082005724310875,
0.2045673280954361,
-0.23044341802597046,
0.2411709725856781,
0.06129840388894081,
-0.29931125044822693,
-0.4246387779712677,
0.9772759079933167,
-0.5239670276641846,
-0.3617483377456665,
-0.30050739645957947,
-0.5869039297103882,
-0.09422606229782104,
0.3017471134662628,
0.09184666723012924,
0.9358731508255005,
-0.3486182987689972,
0.3046492338180542,
0.43999189138412476,
-0.14222966134548187,
0.5974131226539612,
0.4869021475315094,
-0.23311887681484222,
-0.3776234984397888,
0.9912371635437012,
0.12476760894060135,
-0.22096119821071625,
0.4757018983364105,
-0.1991342455148697,
-0.3367862105369568,
-0.009670422412455082,
-0.6965407729148865,
-0.013259743340313435,
-0.5737887024879456,
-0.36538946628570557,
-0.4493282735347748,
0.0058547756634652615,
-0.25548800826072693,
-0.2139614075422287,
-0.11864650249481201,
-0.44847428798675537,
0.03711371496319771,
-0.41160473227500916,
0.25114262104034424,
0.7737971544265747,
-0.08733098208904266,
-0.029036549851298332,
-0.901605486869812,
0.5739192962646484,
0.0747075006365776,
0.7353428602218628,
-0.029610585421323776,
-0.14309260249137878,
-0.3306068181991577,
0.09718263149261475,
-0.3511783480644226,
-0.9804624319076538,
0.12896327674388885,
0.39321088790893555,
0.6664205193519592,
0.2690393328666687,
0.3280761241912842,
0.6366758942604065,
-0.6522839665412903,
0.5661507248878479,
0.18807092308998108,
-0.8991625905036926,
0.16394607722759247,
-0.2714175283908844,
0.05256775766611099,
0.4802592098712921,
0.4635530710220337,
-0.9053367376327515,
-0.37396425008773804,
-0.49237141013145447,
-0.7578097581863403,
0.4539491832256317,
-0.14453698694705963,
0.5477199554443359,
-0.08369049429893494,
0.25008222460746765,
0.33846479654312134,
0.24721044301986694,
-0.896369218826294,
-0.1530490517616272,
-0.08224979788064957,
-0.3550642430782318,
-0.1518014371395111,
-0.12495332956314087,
-0.13757851719856262,
-0.1000564694404602,
0.6524271368980408,
-0.2610597312450409,
0.07870162278413773,
0.17576751112937927,
-0.32293030619621277,
-0.22905389964580536,
0.5386714935302734,
0.3700467348098755,
0.9171640872955322,
0.29266223311424255,
0.3451577126979828,
0.25261855125427246,
-0.11776862293481827,
0.19492901861667633,
0.3258911669254303,
-0.1704656332731247,
0.15091586112976074,
0.50294429063797,
0.785112738609314,
0.5848241448402405,
-0.5895934104919434,
0.7123698592185974,
-0.00016631570179015398,
-0.15800844132900238,
-0.23446723818778992,
-0.30975696444511414,
0.21756063401699066,
0.6130138039588928,
0.4337676167488098,
-0.015492369420826435,
0.2128431499004364,
-0.7708913087844849,
0.5956096053123474,
0.22577929496765137,
-0.6737301349639893,
-0.2302228957414627,
0.4636622965335846,
0.38004639744758606,
-0.2137284129858017,
0.268650621175766,
-0.2918983995914459,
-0.40480804443359375,
0.6533181667327881,
0.4425486624240875,
0.3739131689071655,
0.1797012984752655,
0.3545994162559509,
0.3284987211227417,
0.11700291186571121,
-0.2929094135761261,
0.12945882976055145,
0.19015681743621826,
-0.7408273816108704,
-0.497923880815506,
-0.6318191885948181,
-0.01721397042274475,
-0.0210830420255661,
-0.8976513743400574,
0.29019030928611755,
0.06006964296102524,
0.0922166034579277,
0.0033663460053503513,
0.1671726405620575,
-0.4509478509426117,
0.062120966613292694,
0.5990684032440186,
0.9410535097122192,
-1.2813109159469604,
0.7591290473937988,
0.8637157678604126,
0.00007543595711467788,
-0.48266708850860596,
0.07094982266426086,
0.31042346358299255,
-0.6467190384864807,
0.002706942381337285,
0.5730251669883728,
0.20838497579097748,
-0.29706916213035583,
-0.16077476739883423,
-0.7644359469413757,
0.954119861125946,
0.5339126586914062,
-0.6717559695243835,
-0.13206152617931366,
0.15529270470142365,
0.4475761651992798,
-0.5859960913658142,
-0.12521350383758545,
0.45508816838264465,
0.5241415500640869,
-0.2741301953792572,
-0.9118357300758362,
0.054666176438331604,
-0.5775746703147888,
0.02637685276567936,
0.343243271112442,
-0.923262357711792,
0.5509830713272095,
-0.4608120620250702,
-0.0315411239862442,
-0.08521692454814911,
0.6587822437286377,
-0.10282289236783981,
0.7108377814292908,
0.3167739510536194,
0.5628228187561035,
0.6213022470474243,
0.04986622557044029,
0.6154376864433289,
-0.40660229325294495,
0.4440322816371918,
1.1022796630859375,
-0.31488046050071716,
0.6184957027435303,
0.16210412979125977,
-0.053659502416849136,
0.42075395584106445,
0.376919686794281,
-0.1592276394367218,
0.4102034568786621,
0.1313108205795288,
-0.06959052383899689,
-0.21472686529159546,
-0.020629268139600754,
-0.6358127593994141,
0.4494364559650421,
0.07564195245504379,
-0.37254098057746887,
-0.5653018951416016,
0.3925110399723053,
0.11782272905111313,
0.4237114191055298,
-0.4104824364185333,
0.5722683668136597,
0.1438995599746704,
-0.46224552392959595,
0.15071655809879303,
-0.11966201663017273,
0.6679399013519287,
-0.4300520718097687,
0.061938486993312836,
-0.21363277733325958,
0.04058072343468666,
-0.13344082236289978,
-1.1111994981765747,
0.8503819108009338,
0.036709949374198914,
-0.3252544403076172,
-0.19470129907131195,
0.6193594932556152,
-0.7496099472045898,
-0.7109543681144714,
0.2801071107387543,
0.41309288144111633,
0.07401153445243835,
0.025167398154735565,
-0.39814382791519165,
0.4034619927406311,
0.07732177525758743,
-0.3245774209499359,
0.31544506549835205,
0.6747722625732422,
-0.2823277711868286,
0.31671589612960815,
0.3684881627559662,
0.01606863923370838,
0.1291186511516571,
-0.11314649879932404,
0.7657876014709473,
-0.7167928814888,
-0.5099183320999146,
-0.5837487578392029,
-0.02804596722126007,
-0.2840036451816559,
-0.6150469779968262,
0.6653133630752563,
0.9657543897628784,
1.1272834539413452,
0.054050102829933167,
0.8487864136695862,
-0.13716600835323334,
0.5973117351531982,
-0.4863582253456116,
0.8399940133094788,
-0.5313193798065186,
-0.090924471616745,
-0.38840147852897644,
-0.8685623407363892,
-0.49076104164123535,
0.3571417033672333,
-0.20662614703178406,
-0.3551119863986969,
0.5304107666015625,
0.7272759079933167,
-0.25763076543807983,
0.4564804136753082,
0.15265719592571259,
-0.016371091827750206,
-0.19874760508537292,
0.6530943512916565,
0.6139077544212341,
-0.33124464750289917,
0.8815568685531616,
-0.13639198243618011,
-0.19340984523296356,
0.17857636511325836,
-0.9667851328849792,
-0.9717739224433899,
-0.8097156286239624,
-0.1676405966281891,
-0.12263213098049164,
0.543034553527832,
0.9208469986915588,
0.5225332975387573,
-0.730433464050293,
0.01964690163731575,
0.5114539265632629,
0.39710262417793274,
-0.27532508969306946,
-0.20487646758556366,
0.532900869846344,
-0.14768369495868683,
-0.6075055003166199,
-0.03926900029182434,
0.1491377353668213,
-0.29602378606796265,
-0.04848755896091461,
0.13595689833164215,
-0.0149947265163064,
-0.3352857232093811,
0.619879424571991,
0.27837541699409485,
-0.42930668592453003,
-0.5082952976226807,
-0.10764389485120773,
-0.02479124628007412,
0.09517613798379898,
1.0250170230865479,
-0.7018476724624634,
0.28511735796928406,
0.4671420156955719,
0.6147279739379883,
0.27523359656333923,
-0.20219720900058746,
0.5031649470329285,
-0.9758102893829346,
0.4018849730491638,
-0.24948656558990479,
0.40790191292762756,
0.6007176041603088,
-0.2013065367937088,
0.3642381727695465,
0.17652350664138794,
-0.17292381823062897,
-0.6168190240859985,
0.19278089702129364,
-0.9106886386871338,
-0.2346632331609726,
1.208855152130127,
-0.23835618793964386,
-0.21426606178283691,
-0.24124862253665924,
-0.15843334794044495,
0.32677024602890015,
-0.4917263686656952,
0.8534024953842163,
0.7244723439216614,
0.32368606328964233,
-0.38080698251724243,
-0.4267633855342865,
0.08411205559968948,
-0.12893785536289215,
-0.7443997859954834,
0.1574954092502594,
0.37813451886177063,
0.4442249834537506,
-0.005847131833434105,
0.6053932309150696,
-0.2196083664894104,
0.06077747792005539,
-0.21550020575523376,
-0.10275616496801376,
-0.08185850083827972,
-0.3805233836174011,
-0.25239086151123047,
0.4003525376319885,
-0.7459043860435486,
0.02231171540915966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13245v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13245v2
|
A Survey of Robotic Language Grounding: Tradeoffs between Symbols and Embeddings
| 2024-05-21T23:12:03 | 2024-06-22T13:03:53 |
Vanya Cohen, Jason Xinyu Liu, Raymond Mooney, Stefanie Tellex, David Watkins
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With large language models, robots can understand language more flexibly and
more capable than ever before. This survey reviews and situates recent
literature into a spectrum with two poles: 1) mapping between language and some
manually defined formal representation of meaning, and 2) mapping between
language and high-dimensional vector spaces that translate directly to
low-level robot policy. Using a formal representation allows the meaning of the
language to be precisely represented, limits the size of the learning problem,
and leads to a framework for interpretability and formal safety guarantees.
Methods that embed language and perceptual data into high-dimensional spaces
avoid this manually specified symbolic structure and thus have the potential to
be more general when fed enough data but require more data and computing to
train. We discuss the benefits and tradeoffs of each approach and finish by
providing directions for future work that achieves the best of both worlds.
|
[
-0.30986976623535156,
-0.6389421224594116,
0.7354981303215027,
-0.03471418470144272,
0.021801918745040894,
0.4259452521800995,
-0.2827548384666443,
-0.34281712770462036,
0.284313827753067,
0.6262754797935486,
-0.20523519814014435,
-0.605362057685852,
-0.8761399984359741,
-0.14619213342666626,
-0.1969841867685318,
0.6780069470405579,
-0.32196521759033203,
-0.22683890163898468,
-0.19343222677707672,
-0.31323865056037903,
-0.5174652934074402,
-0.8247224688529968,
-0.2873251736164093,
-0.5229786038398743,
0.3496902287006378,
0.26032885909080505,
1.3341612815856934,
0.8660115599632263,
0.6223310232162476,
0.26925694942474365,
0.026998182758688927,
-0.09013506770133972,
-0.2652527689933777,
0.04688642546534538,
-0.21380415558815002,
-0.46596142649650574,
-0.2562435269355774,
0.1884089857339859,
0.5801647901535034,
1.1938648223876953,
0.14882683753967285,
-0.15885001420974731,
-0.3511470556259155,
0.7108889222145081,
-0.7725068926811218,
0.36231544613838196,
-0.2946079969406128,
0.5769103765487671,
0.17199410498142242,
-0.19634678959846497,
-0.2936430871486664,
-0.235281303524971,
0.01105024479329586,
-0.5971354842185974,
-0.432348370552063,
-0.01721416972577572,
1.0642473697662354,
0.45555195212364197,
-0.5228180885314941,
-0.4512694180011749,
-0.8352531790733337,
0.9320300221443176,
-0.3289494812488556,
0.7068236470222473,
0.7191725373268127,
0.5446382761001587,
-0.06711909174919128,
-0.3773791193962097,
-0.5303189158439636,
-0.5274850130081177,
-0.03210294991731644,
0.2314022034406662,
-0.20155668258666992,
0.34556838870048523,
0.3923967182636261,
0.16096262633800507,
-0.3818727433681488,
0.09492741525173187,
-0.24756872653961182,
-0.13455621898174286,
0.41790395975112915,
-0.10782545804977417,
0.49042877554893494,
-0.06993741542100906,
-0.28502199053764343,
-0.6705904006958008,
-0.8447048664093018,
-0.05177519470453262,
0.48905181884765625,
0.4815816879272461,
-0.09594991058111191,
0.7257251143455505,
-0.18673531711101532,
0.7045482993125916,
-0.23324352502822876,
0.05133786052465439,
0.2374100536108017,
-0.14090989530086517,
-0.11851292103528976,
-0.41226109862327576,
0.5723795294761658,
0.31365054845809937,
0.4094790518283844,
-0.572934091091156,
-0.19113723933696747,
0.3255021274089813,
0.35562705993652344,
-0.12128548324108124,
-0.07055887579917908,
0.27958032488822937,
-0.3936725854873657,
-0.14164738357067108,
0.34446096420288086,
-0.40063217282295227,
-0.2913692593574524,
-0.622422993183136,
0.18702062964439392,
-0.24799910187721252,
-0.24783048033714294,
0.5100496411323547,
-0.3327023386955261,
0.3019684851169586,
0.2364678680896759,
-0.7847623229026794,
0.4463883340358734,
0.722100555896759,
0.7620784640312195,
0.2668016850948334,
-0.09254160523414612,
-0.2811487913131714,
0.46029743552207947,
-0.5623046159744263,
0.5084667205810547,
-0.7846636176109314,
-0.10775819420814514,
0.3896702826023102,
0.05091783404350281,
0.19922488927841187,
-0.3484418988227844,
0.5209488272666931,
-0.5220517516136169,
0.15775369107723236,
-0.22726869583129883,
-0.2914491891860962,
-0.43093341588974,
0.14119060337543488,
-0.698241651058197,
0.8504300117492676,
0.27778369188308716,
-0.39657920598983765,
0.4882441461086273,
-0.41368362307548523,
-0.605354905128479,
-0.1683792918920517,
-0.4146468937397003,
-0.020231693983078003,
-0.13366509974002838,
-0.09775763005018234,
0.6947370767593384,
-0.18180276453495026,
0.16181743144989014,
-0.12247484177350998,
-0.19574515521526337,
0.0326356366276741,
0.13435004651546478,
0.5459620952606201,
0.3719668686389923,
-0.37695950269699097,
0.027768103405833244,
-0.4136621356010437,
-0.0292737428098917,
0.17223230004310608,
-0.21274004876613617,
-0.3995768427848816,
0.41869160532951355,
0.06707743555307388,
0.5317384600639343,
0.2334098219871521,
-0.18804167211055756,
0.09756969660520554,
-0.4951968193054199,
0.4234474301338196,
0.5613453388214111,
-0.5332710146903992,
0.972801148891449,
-0.1932980716228485,
0.8171411752700806,
-0.2277645766735077,
-0.17569804191589355,
-0.14145128428936005,
-0.2198164463043213,
-0.5642691254615784,
-0.13524781167507172,
0.1421533077955246,
0.6640893816947937,
-0.7506641745567322,
1.0692768096923828,
-0.07345472276210785,
-0.24883857369422913,
-0.3935823440551758,
0.15505479276180267,
0.37826141715049744,
-0.07551220804452896,
0.2512280344963074,
-0.15370339155197144,
-0.5914247632026672,
-0.8602105379104614,
-0.05165819451212883,
-0.2128221094608307,
-0.21328510344028473,
0.3487901985645294,
0.526262640953064,
-0.3885212540626526,
0.9430924654006958,
-0.43147391080856323,
-0.2200421541929245,
-0.33525437116622925,
-0.2802174687385559,
0.10811524093151093,
0.42791861295700073,
0.6254937648773193,
-0.7570705413818359,
-0.13029161095619202,
0.25713595747947693,
-1.0743937492370605,
0.183659166097641,
-0.29140621423721313,
-0.17951591312885284,
-0.013008570298552513,
0.6303084492683411,
-0.6504709720611572,
0.22849316895008087,
0.7661527991294861,
-0.17865140736103058,
-0.23908749222755432,
-0.11698853224515915,
0.029192376881837845,
-0.6878966689109802,
0.026028577238321304,
-0.15041880309581757,
-0.2854686975479126,
-0.5084919929504395,
0.49082159996032715,
-0.15089163184165955,
-0.20854990184307098,
-0.3206981122493744,
0.45630571246147156,
-0.4522641599178314,
-0.35062769055366516,
-0.3387007415294647,
0.5355252623558044,
-0.11957880109548569,
0.24154700338840485,
0.26101216673851013,
0.35214555263519287,
0.6158221364021301,
-0.5222269296646118,
0.3569689393043518,
0.3166196942329407,
0.048057109117507935,
0.020889349281787872,
-0.7802609801292419,
0.2344798892736435,
0.012127402238547802,
0.5255364179611206,
-1.0818836688995361,
-0.23744936287403107,
0.6322405934333801,
-0.3312143385410309,
-0.008055638521909714,
-0.11902301013469696,
-0.6441947221755981,
-0.3399502635002136,
-0.3636374771595001,
0.271009236574173,
0.752156674861908,
-0.3311150372028351,
0.5119837522506714,
0.8135823011398315,
0.1695845127105713,
-0.5287397503852844,
-0.7343788146972656,
0.23149502277374268,
-0.1016770452260971,
-0.6540757417678833,
0.020152246579527855,
0.5545153021812439,
-0.47368767857551575,
-0.07428823411464691,
-0.07608012109994888,
-0.017122363671660423,
0.19542764127254486,
0.3906581997871399,
-0.11298372596502304,
-0.0716395303606987,
0.22148160636425018,
0.18781812489032745,
-0.5334177017211914,
0.18352922797203064,
-0.31166180968284607,
0.6385839581489563,
-0.07787156850099564,
-0.37891826033592224,
-0.17299120128154755,
0.3490557074546814,
0.47057613730430603,
-0.02047165296971798,
0.8387985825538635,
0.40006372332572937,
-0.48812487721443176,
-0.2090497463941574,
0.10376166552305222,
-0.2102264016866684,
-0.4942610263824463,
0.18752411007881165,
-0.3975376486778259,
-0.8192511796951294,
0.3684021234512329,
-0.49563348293304443,
0.1130233034491539,
0.44691094756126404,
0.5235862731933594,
-0.2552044987678528,
0.8436216711997986,
0.7624220252037048,
-0.15493051707744598,
0.4320042133331299,
-0.2778477072715759,
0.511839747428894,
-0.3792181611061096,
-0.09948326647281647,
-0.6240609288215637,
-0.20116721093654633,
-0.5704168677330017,
-0.6767489314079285,
0.08132155984640121,
0.028098300099372864,
-0.2280428111553192,
0.6232635378837585,
-0.5478492379188538,
0.39463862776756287,
0.4135511517524719,
-0.15106691420078278,
0.00379351619631052,
0.10204402357339859,
0.15949904918670654,
-0.016120264306664467,
-0.67987060546875,
-0.9816690683364868,
0.9042003750801086,
0.5687232613563538,
0.6820492148399353,
-0.12119051814079285,
0.35659316182136536,
0.25944551825523376,
-0.32744544744491577,
-0.826647937297821,
0.4587363302707672,
-0.23918747901916504,
-0.38078293204307556,
-0.4389474093914032,
-0.19385859370231628,
-1.0981905460357666,
0.3872348368167877,
-0.3606078624725342,
-0.35637885332107544,
-0.1540551334619522,
0.00422360934317112,
0.15678168833255768,
0.39624568819999695,
-0.5179659724235535,
0.4617719352245331,
-0.06890907138586044,
0.02079785242676735,
-0.24638405442237854,
-1.0657228231430054,
-0.004217383451759815,
0.21742722392082214,
0.4073668420314789,
-0.14795570075511932,
-0.02605331689119339,
0.8061409592628479,
-0.040816664695739746,
0.9393710494041443,
-0.23211394250392914,
-0.47076696157455444,
0.19790935516357422,
0.04084339737892151,
0.502830982208252,
-0.25364670157432556,
0.07762070000171661,
0.3137129545211792,
0.021565694361925125,
-0.5714335441589355,
-0.6003326773643494,
0.16806910932064056,
-0.9809334874153137,
-0.3937791585922241,
-0.5057950019836426,
-0.636969804763794,
-0.258427232503891,
-0.04858160763978958,
-0.05317113921046257,
0.09355276077985764,
-0.02748761512339115,
0.23447354137897491,
0.513617992401123,
-0.6014347672462463,
0.00949886254966259,
-0.04710543900728226,
-0.2226872742176056,
-0.04816460609436035,
0.8424670100212097,
-0.08599643409252167,
0.304273396730423,
0.7320662140846252,
0.13838127255439758,
-0.24138028919696808,
-0.1885841339826584,
-0.27363070845603943,
0.17949934303760529,
-0.8834657669067383,
0.060122955590486526,
-0.7075254917144775,
-0.08347055315971375,
-0.4319951832294464,
-0.8553652167320251,
-0.48658594489097595,
-0.6727486848831177,
0.07524892687797546,
-0.2836005389690399,
0.3656761050224304,
0.8355075716972351,
-0.21997831761837006,
0.5120992660522461,
-0.4649364650249481,
0.5782337188720703,
-0.11557546257972717,
0.09511542320251465,
-0.3070237338542938,
-0.22426296770572662,
-0.3153808116912842,
0.2134173959493637,
-0.08054140210151672,
-0.5806008577346802,
0.11003565043210983,
-0.17445062100887299,
0.49494510889053345,
0.41487768292427063,
-0.013694919645786285,
0.476056843996048,
-0.6124035120010376,
0.6173837184906006,
0.196236714720726,
-1.0315680503845215,
0.7821437120437622,
-0.44074997305870056,
-0.012075230479240417,
0.3299858868122101,
0.5111935138702393,
-0.7605768442153931,
-0.6718528270721436,
-0.5130887031555176,
-1.0436183214187622,
0.33708542585372925,
0.16605067253112793,
0.4950946867465973,
0.053946830332279205,
0.20290954411029816,
0.12326040118932724,
0.15461313724517822,
-0.5911954641342163,
-0.17783904075622559,
-0.08779248595237732,
-0.16671216487884521,
-0.23980382084846497,
0.13332760334014893,
-0.5360657572746277,
-0.11362025141716003,
-0.04309767857193947,
-0.10056346654891968,
0.6388245224952698,
-0.4596138298511505,
-0.29329535365104675,
-0.07316482812166214,
0.054992999881505966,
0.33499154448509216,
0.5575946569442749,
-0.011447826400399208,
0.35875964164733887,
0.010914181359112263,
-0.2502565383911133,
0.2561061382293701,
-0.3894290030002594,
-0.011052661575376987,
0.05447167530655861,
0.7318826913833618,
0.5422198176383972,
0.04108200594782829,
-0.7495152950286865,
0.35865575075149536,
0.5815197229385376,
-0.3024270832538605,
-0.23767320811748505,
0.11144077777862549,
-0.22092759609222412,
0.0909925177693367,
0.07953086495399475,
-0.04560320824384689,
0.1246301457285881,
-0.630487859249115,
0.22738052904605865,
0.4814029037952423,
-0.21596917510032654,
-0.38598188757896423,
0.4862491488456726,
0.07727529108524323,
-0.12590138614177704,
0.40678590536117554,
0.12528422474861145,
-0.48392781615257263,
0.783841609954834,
0.4521123468875885,
0.6198093295097351,
0.08061959594488144,
0.4803881049156189,
0.17138023674488068,
0.5788031816482544,
-0.0468389056622982,
0.3229941129684448,
-0.06261707097291946,
-0.9045282602310181,
-0.30702027678489685,
-0.22249233722686768,
-0.7522844076156616,
-0.3886716067790985,
-0.6575842499732971,
0.004555427934974432,
-0.7487850785255432,
-0.048416439443826675,
-0.26916229724884033,
-0.06892868876457214,
-0.5759623646736145,
0.29163920879364014,
0.20673784613609314,
0.48623377084732056,
-1.2890719175338745,
0.5678575038909912,
0.9614815711975098,
-0.5913543105125427,
-0.5540300011634827,
-0.07397869229316711,
-0.17756718397140503,
-0.8285113573074341,
0.9689745306968689,
-0.10253970324993134,
-0.6333646178245544,
-0.3530098795890808,
-0.7422638535499573,
-0.9040889739990234,
0.834272563457489,
0.5166643261909485,
-0.2687971293926239,
-0.011279389262199402,
0.3230786621570587,
0.5411165952682495,
-0.09759692847728729,
0.004618394188582897,
0.4019095003604889,
0.6202546954154968,
-0.03673721104860306,
-0.5840865969657898,
0.2483954280614853,
0.09862588346004486,
0.10237450897693634,
0.19140668213367462,
-0.5844082236289978,
0.7071892023086548,
0.2738937437534332,
-0.5529446005821228,
-0.2390725314617157,
0.4443848133087158,
0.17155975103378296,
0.1882636398077011,
0.41520506143569946,
0.41448888182640076,
0.6355762481689453,
-0.2582778334617615,
1.1980974674224854,
-0.43638375401496887,
0.32241079211235046,
0.5465052723884583,
-0.3643874228000641,
0.7028566002845764,
0.5106114149093628,
-0.5270545482635498,
0.5062081813812256,
0.5242040753364563,
0.1311095803976059,
0.6365508437156677,
0.46499618887901306,
0.08640338480472565,
-0.27044543623924255,
-0.11547622829675674,
-0.5011228919029236,
0.4194125235080719,
0.4673311710357666,
-0.13460995256900787,
-0.20307043194770813,
0.19887445867061615,
0.057563845068216324,
0.42407670617103577,
0.20093020796775818,
0.5044149160385132,
0.09543720632791519,
-0.1644526571035385,
0.36382201313972473,
0.0757896825671196,
0.44008174538612366,
-0.37770795822143555,
-0.30570465326309204,
-0.052142880856990814,
0.07277214527130127,
-0.23048803210258484,
-0.912077784538269,
0.3874826431274414,
-0.39077305793762207,
0.07566972076892853,
-0.8392354846000671,
0.6837212443351746,
-0.25562965869903564,
-0.09460830688476562,
0.546531617641449,
0.6362813711166382,
0.33682453632354736,
0.35909339785575867,
-0.5845582485198975,
0.26314476132392883,
-0.5184853076934814,
-0.05535748228430748,
0.1923639327287674,
0.6726827621459961,
-0.036540161818265915,
0.83866286277771,
0.6189046502113342,
0.12765978276729584,
-0.05011475086212158,
-0.03737815096974373,
0.9466263055801392,
-0.8296876549720764,
-0.5306955575942993,
-0.48688817024230957,
0.3177643120288849,
0.29577067494392395,
-0.26896005868911743,
0.6914857029914856,
0.18880261480808258,
0.9384256601333618,
-0.19461162388324738,
0.8012102842330933,
-0.23975972831249237,
0.15253840386867523,
-0.8523195385932922,
0.5529556274414062,
-0.4196350872516632,
-0.1324244886636734,
-0.5381098389625549,
-0.7071364521980286,
-0.6836563944816589,
1.2830640077590942,
-0.43646836280822754,
0.08715811371803284,
0.6883193254470825,
0.3862350881099701,
0.047427333891391754,
-0.42724883556365967,
0.5562362670898438,
-0.12327227741479874,
0.24212141335010529,
0.525139570236206,
1.2216613292694092,
-0.43954896926879883,
0.02167462557554245,
0.05634618550539017,
-0.11529754102230072,
-0.15043224394321442,
-0.5163918733596802,
-0.9031234383583069,
-0.6956743001937866,
-0.26089921593666077,
-0.28107669949531555,
0.12518522143363953,
0.8030275702476501,
0.7875186800956726,
-0.6290183067321777,
-0.39691993594169617,
-0.0833561047911644,
0.3970906734466553,
-0.14132744073867798,
-0.10697687417268753,
0.3360191285610199,
-0.4520089328289032,
-0.6498110294342041,
0.34270650148391724,
0.32152441143989563,
-0.16688525676727295,
-0.2623065412044525,
-0.39616915583610535,
-0.11632101982831955,
-0.0998547375202179,
0.8879923820495605,
0.5118439793586731,
-0.8389350175857544,
-0.6839115023612976,
0.05824653059244156,
-0.2574825882911682,
0.06050299108028412,
0.8105922937393188,
-0.7623144388198853,
0.22649958729743958,
0.42475634813308716,
0.9151171445846558,
0.004102400504052639,
-0.2768380045890808,
0.8328404426574707,
-0.5565741062164307,
0.6131803393363953,
0.2722145617008209,
0.18057775497436523,
0.04646829888224602,
-0.2041144073009491,
0.8140769004821777,
-0.023272400721907616,
-0.3285272717475891,
-0.6431589126586914,
0.5105339288711548,
-1.1502755880355835,
-0.3149120807647705,
1.258853793144226,
-0.09516528993844986,
0.13905073702335358,
-0.2622706890106201,
-0.15992973744869232,
0.32123926281929016,
-0.10485467314720154,
0.5783612132072449,
0.7839807868003845,
0.12392792850732803,
0.026793764904141426,
-0.8219913244247437,
0.2531507611274719,
0.36438611149787903,
-0.7429884672164917,
-0.1684364676475525,
0.48365601897239685,
-0.16393446922302246,
0.2550525665283203,
0.3869451582431793,
0.028168508782982826,
0.04349682480096817,
0.12918293476104736,
0.23678523302078247,
0.3342030644416809,
-0.6745039820671082,
-0.40930071473121643,
0.15526969730854034,
0.0342145711183548,
-0.39313453435897827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13233v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13233v1
|
MELD-ST: An Emotion-aware Speech Translation Dataset
| 2024-05-21T22:40:38 | 2024-05-21T22:40:38 |
Sirou Chen, Sakiko Yahata, Shuichiro Shimizu, Zhengdong Yang, Yihang Li, Chenhui Chu, Sadao Kurohashi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emotion plays a crucial role in human conversation. This paper underscores
the significance of considering emotion in speech translation. We present the
MELD-ST dataset for the emotion-aware speech translation task, comprising
English-to-Japanese and English-to-German language pairs. Each language pair
includes about 10,000 utterances annotated with emotion labels from the MELD
dataset. Baseline experiments using the SeamlessM4T model on the dataset
indicate that fine-tuning with emotion labels can enhance translation
performance in some settings, highlighting the need for further research in
emotion-aware speech translation systems.
|
[
-0.44339144229888916,
-0.5962674617767334,
0.21578986942768097,
0.3045969009399414,
-0.5365375280380249,
0.18461598455905914,
-0.25581514835357666,
-0.4643484354019165,
0.25559213757514954,
0.31731441617012024,
-0.460279643535614,
-0.730800986289978,
-0.7567840218544006,
0.18757256865501404,
-0.46951404213905334,
1.3122775554656982,
-0.3346864879131317,
0.10154286026954651,
-0.08155462145805359,
-0.4596593976020813,
-0.21577423810958862,
-0.5713858604431152,
-0.685565173625946,
-0.12589694559574127,
0.6968131065368652,
0.5657671689987183,
0.6975581049919128,
0.44434037804603577,
0.7065131664276123,
0.17048943042755127,
0.016273608431220055,
-0.1705351322889328,
-0.5835992097854614,
0.4107835590839386,
0.057358574122190475,
-0.45587190985679626,
-0.6697275638580322,
-0.022834502160549164,
0.5476999878883362,
0.3856554329395294,
-0.16197910904884338,
0.0750972330570221,
-0.12313611060380936,
0.7787157297134399,
-0.25301796197891235,
-0.04910307750105858,
-0.20829202234745026,
0.42816585302352905,
-0.7153196334838867,
0.05548151955008507,
-0.4074297845363617,
-0.47446349263191223,
0.2254214733839035,
-0.19262753427028656,
0.032503675669431686,
0.18699373304843903,
0.5236889719963074,
0.4731955826282501,
-0.7658581733703613,
0.050939470529556274,
-0.706310510635376,
0.44658544659614563,
-0.5767942070960999,
0.376412570476532,
0.2450893372297287,
0.1573295146226883,
0.036702726036310196,
-0.45149704813957214,
-0.5802335739135742,
0.4680107831954956,
0.08950523287057877,
0.45779335498809814,
-0.2478329837322235,
0.3990303874015808,
0.31516221165657043,
0.6372067332267761,
-0.7684765458106995,
-0.11970208585262299,
-0.16237202286720276,
0.08633933961391449,
0.8835801482200623,
0.14509940147399902,
0.6335695385932922,
-0.12684006989002228,
-0.08555801212787628,
-0.1275261491537094,
-0.34110990166664124,
-0.03801834210753441,
0.2573285400867462,
0.2615968585014343,
-0.5429638624191284,
0.7252709865570068,
0.09376271069049835,
0.599759578704834,
-0.28960075974464417,
0.20842613279819489,
0.5292215347290039,
-0.1614338606595993,
-0.3838110864162445,
0.3844192624092102,
0.797362208366394,
0.40068385004997253,
0.39426934719085693,
-0.07425043731927872,
-0.18626433610916138,
0.4178333282470703,
0.08818361908197403,
-0.5747793912887573,
-0.12816666066646576,
0.2994982600212097,
-0.1551894247531891,
-0.14483056962490082,
-0.21019388735294342,
-0.9417712688446045,
-0.14631973206996918,
-0.38519516587257385,
0.2852543592453003,
-0.42152294516563416,
-0.3518329858779907,
0.027069002389907837,
-0.16517864167690277,
-0.1070784404873848,
0.06198437884449959,
-0.7327947616577148,
0.1180848628282547,
0.44551971554756165,
0.6911305785179138,
-0.3270165026187897,
-0.09223278611898422,
-0.31574350595474243,
-0.03163359314203262,
-0.4585297107696533,
0.5127792954444885,
-0.6985745429992676,
-0.6920787692070007,
-0.12491276860237122,
0.011182313784956932,
-0.3720836341381073,
-0.38150984048843384,
0.9429680109024048,
-0.01512184739112854,
0.056498151272535324,
-0.3005372881889343,
-0.5426187515258789,
-0.2674315869808197,
-0.057942479848861694,
-0.363606721162796,
1.1427583694458008,
0.3629344403743744,
-0.9049899578094482,
0.09137381613254547,
-0.6860710978507996,
-0.9794065356254578,
0.09504025429487228,
0.10842949897050858,
-0.3252412676811218,
0.4127649664878845,
0.01380092278122902,
0.37316960096359253,
-0.11956275254487991,
0.1914806365966797,
-0.22843681275844574,
0.00219880067743361,
0.3020155429840088,
-0.30767232179641724,
0.2100224643945694,
0.4978101849555969,
-0.45512956380844116,
0.10153330117464066,
-0.553000807762146,
-0.3122251629829407,
0.04948573559522629,
-0.3032951354980469,
-0.5256407856941223,
-0.00296937208622694,
0.028298912569880486,
0.394162654876709,
0.14882536232471466,
-0.527338445186615,
-0.07234308123588562,
-0.4996967911720276,
0.3019391596317291,
0.7034797072410583,
-0.15322846174240112,
0.3402951657772064,
0.09106891602277756,
0.8299154043197632,
0.40938588976860046,
0.09204716235399246,
-0.27342528104782104,
-0.7676103115081787,
-0.7923373579978943,
-0.045764122158288956,
0.2613856792449951,
0.8147196769714355,
-0.7610511779785156,
0.2874363958835602,
-0.16870175302028656,
-0.4455620348453522,
-1.3216652870178223,
-0.2591218054294586,
0.5156691670417786,
0.648962140083313,
0.3172735571861267,
-0.17484280467033386,
-0.4121699333190918,
-0.9400076270103455,
-0.2118556648492813,
0.2593267261981964,
0.1301436424255371,
0.5856285691261292,
0.25445181131362915,
-0.42739149928092957,
0.6970531940460205,
-0.2200484722852707,
-0.05581876263022423,
-0.02027975022792816,
0.44961535930633545,
-0.20882181823253632,
0.47255751490592957,
0.44490310549736023,
-0.886258602142334,
-0.7121648192405701,
0.3651838004589081,
-0.6270238161087036,
-0.30971524119377136,
0.1132022961974144,
-0.5915146470069885,
0.20106884837150574,
0.08134900778532028,
-0.46534180641174316,
0.5117916464805603,
0.944840133190155,
-0.4235510528087616,
0.19360746443271637,
-0.08139045536518097,
0.6479462385177612,
-1.423760175704956,
0.1295243799686432,
-0.04199625551700592,
-0.4027349352836609,
-0.9259521961212158,
-0.38150495290756226,
-0.020703837275505066,
-0.2705767750740051,
-0.6513106822967529,
0.4063582122325897,
-0.21080319583415985,
-0.45841801166534424,
-0.00612410344183445,
0.5509300231933594,
-0.16290663182735443,
0.22160378098487854,
-0.04032397270202637,
0.7783346772193909,
0.5870164632797241,
-0.43324440717697144,
0.5044010281562805,
0.5720733404159546,
-0.24204498529434204,
1.0881623029708862,
-0.19168531894683838,
0.2349667102098465,
-0.2995532155036926,
0.12398166954517365,
-0.900720477104187,
-0.2338775247335434,
0.19609251618385315,
-0.38219451904296875,
0.3854902386665344,
-0.0026490045711398125,
-0.2564418613910675,
-0.5720592737197876,
0.18660090863704681,
0.5703510046005249,
0.35396429896354675,
-0.12400462478399277,
0.5056073665618896,
0.4763951897621155,
-0.8848042488098145,
-0.14068281650543213,
-0.9178224205970764,
0.31224146485328674,
-0.2569127678871155,
-0.6346200704574585,
0.2538769543170929,
-0.2679702639579773,
-0.07486031949520111,
-0.09744962304830551,
-0.06896331161260605,
0.2630232274532318,
-0.048233095556497574,
0.38753631711006165,
0.09784775227308273,
-0.16730767488479614,
0.0733284130692482,
0.2804507911205292,
-0.12365217506885529,
-0.029210824519395828,
0.11506260186433792,
0.45081213116645813,
-0.00195352453738451,
-0.28909724950790405,
-0.4603790044784546,
0.6884855628013611,
0.8670616149902344,
-0.22851325571537018,
0.36168742179870605,
0.8225640654563904,
-0.40364667773246765,
0.0671369805932045,
-0.14476065337657928,
0.12382809072732925,
-0.35844141244888306,
0.3035026788711548,
-0.6220380663871765,
-0.9521294236183167,
0.44935891032218933,
-0.016901714727282524,
-0.09698335081338882,
0.4974781274795532,
0.4579002559185028,
-0.4857929050922394,
1.524358868598938,
0.31627127528190613,
-0.5435773730278015,
0.4926735758781433,
0.16192062199115753,
0.36740440130233765,
-1.0022155046463013,
-0.06213921681046486,
-0.6657004356384277,
-0.904771625995636,
-0.4576234221458435,
-0.39686328172683716,
0.17952489852905273,
-0.2312600165605545,
-0.07213922590017319,
0.233669713139534,
-0.48567870259284973,
0.13472582399845123,
0.40114733576774597,
-0.16345544159412384,
-0.09074702858924866,
-0.12836621701717377,
0.08485819399356842,
-0.4448922574520111,
-0.4547269940376282,
-0.1526031792163849,
0.6760395169258118,
0.16610509157180786,
0.5419860482215881,
0.060588035732507706,
0.4597378373146057,
0.38394370675086975,
0.20416425168514252,
-0.6326391100883484,
0.4082295894622803,
-0.591352105140686,
-0.4102294147014618,
-0.03985393047332764,
-0.8094423413276672,
-0.8566641211509705,
0.05671302601695061,
-0.09464040398597717,
-0.5742468237876892,
0.11562100052833557,
0.1333969533443451,
-0.061482202261686325,
0.07932642847299576,
-0.8050256371498108,
1.059537649154663,
-0.6024368405342102,
0.20561173558235168,
-0.41236963868141174,
-0.8583968877792358,
0.4169888198375702,
-0.0896366536617279,
0.3192926347255707,
-0.4790286719799042,
0.44972825050354004,
0.8528888821601868,
0.03893831744790077,
0.4729560911655426,
-0.17269998788833618,
-0.1748184710741043,
-0.01811000145971775,
0.2446315735578537,
0.5667641758918762,
-0.38042256236076355,
-0.13855047523975372,
0.03206588700413704,
-0.21872201561927795,
-0.20883767306804657,
-0.2135390341281891,
0.5814069509506226,
-0.5485523343086243,
-0.2724657654762268,
-0.2432113140821457,
-0.8353742361068726,
-0.22094835340976715,
0.00948092620819807,
0.43365558981895447,
0.20624926686286926,
-0.27702757716178894,
0.002833183389157057,
0.8373199105262756,
-0.3322307765483856,
0.31887316703796387,
0.32847967743873596,
-0.26507073640823364,
-0.48169174790382385,
0.9049862027168274,
0.0886935293674469,
0.45286107063293457,
0.2746729552745819,
-0.06830041110515594,
-0.37149378657341003,
-0.008341360837221146,
-0.6277057528495789,
0.16245926916599274,
-0.5179558396339417,
-0.18664266169071198,
-0.716745138168335,
-0.01587149314582348,
-0.5633454322814941,
-0.38688206672668457,
-0.5000885725021362,
-0.2589326798915863,
-0.4158116281032562,
-0.46629592776298523,
0.5680288076400757,
0.6837870478630066,
0.12623627483844757,
0.3130107522010803,
-0.9700810313224792,
0.5855161547660828,
0.2272699922323227,
0.34718504548072815,
-0.5529149174690247,
-0.5789198279380798,
-0.1695108562707901,
0.38621363043785095,
0.08519776165485382,
-0.9910202622413635,
0.6869961023330688,
0.4308386743068695,
0.31748008728027344,
0.5994167923927307,
0.28436949849128723,
0.7371861934661865,
-0.4722661077976227,
0.8929117321968079,
0.13882750272750854,
-1.1167998313903809,
0.9480774998664856,
-0.3689563274383545,
0.34631773829460144,
0.30949586629867554,
0.29014959931373596,
-1.0880831480026245,
-0.49176332354545593,
-0.6843258142471313,
-1.002295732498169,
0.9499847888946533,
0.22673818469047546,
-0.044580794870853424,
0.07839063555002213,
0.12373960018157959,
-0.06315457075834274,
0.4828479588031769,
-0.2823196053504944,
-0.44394832849502563,
-0.002035562414675951,
-0.7725923657417297,
-0.45534417033195496,
-0.2838881015777588,
-0.24535490572452545,
-0.19881875813007355,
0.5523143410682678,
0.1425025910139084,
0.47092071175575256,
0.039500512182712555,
-0.07662586122751236,
-0.3725968301296234,
0.3892020881175995,
0.772055447101593,
-0.3220600485801697,
-0.24203439056873322,
0.270102322101593,
0.1333654373884201,
-0.4013553857803345,
0.21888728439807892,
0.15348544716835022,
0.03632437437772751,
0.12668532133102417,
-0.2995111644268036,
1.328984260559082,
0.3599577844142914,
-0.542951762676239,
0.5362027287483215,
0.0023829315323382616,
-0.09447644650936127,
0.2957030236721039,
-0.22250701487064362,
0.24911855161190033,
0.22650955617427826,
-0.12065799534320831,
0.2750746011734009,
0.23837395012378693,
-0.3764083683490753,
0.3172614872455597,
0.07475197315216064,
-0.6538049578666687,
-0.6319144368171692,
0.8332220911979675,
0.5570341944694519,
-0.3693998456001282,
0.5037962198257446,
-0.1750565469264984,
-0.8174359798431396,
0.49097684025764465,
0.6071210503578186,
1.0481820106506348,
-0.8078449964523315,
0.2742564380168915,
0.14617517590522766,
0.2094692438840866,
-0.09136873483657837,
0.5884844064712524,
-0.07739271223545074,
-0.4834841787815094,
-0.2336980104446411,
-0.6915691494941711,
-0.548390805721283,
-0.4966186285018921,
-0.9772310256958008,
0.13390955328941345,
0.16131491959095,
-0.3424220681190491,
-0.3474096953868866,
-0.5208981037139893,
-0.6565054059028625,
0.5437470078468323,
0.6154161691665649,
0.6404406428337097,
-1.1131311655044556,
0.9546928405761719,
0.6918477416038513,
-0.07580969482660294,
-0.4531949758529663,
-0.5566442012786865,
0.08557598292827606,
-0.4878722131252289,
0.16518445312976837,
-0.04967847466468811,
-0.12262816727161407,
0.4595506191253662,
-0.25701162219047546,
-0.6934234499931335,
0.8789278864860535,
0.5465722680091858,
-0.7509564757347107,
0.4964219331741333,
0.3634292483329773,
0.6219438314437866,
-0.3911309242248535,
-0.07731060683727264,
0.8517363667488098,
0.5893751382827759,
-0.02519827149808407,
-0.8182024955749512,
-0.33035939931869507,
-0.440238893032074,
0.06873629242181778,
0.3855980932712555,
-0.47659724950790405,
0.5686216950416565,
0.0020109948236495256,
-0.4904264807701111,
-0.4251566529273987,
0.47266441583633423,
0.024310683831572533,
0.47482606768608093,
0.35805150866508484,
0.8968534469604492,
0.747667133808136,
-0.5495157837867737,
0.8558138608932495,
-0.27744945883750916,
0.0009730292949825525,
0.9752050042152405,
-0.4641273021697998,
1.068293809890747,
0.28129616379737854,
-0.23265278339385986,
0.014236362650990486,
0.8614618182182312,
0.251510888338089,
0.43617844581604004,
0.05761129409074783,
-0.5630452632904053,
-0.06325232237577438,
-0.32654833793640137,
-0.5017819404602051,
0.1507260799407959,
0.6897784471511841,
-0.28398898243904114,
0.24094511568546295,
0.5983404517173767,
0.23112894594669342,
-0.2346055805683136,
-0.23438866436481476,
0.956766664981842,
0.36787813901901245,
-0.5270730257034302,
0.1670384705066681,
-0.19322815537452698,
0.7368367910385132,
-0.4979233145713806,
0.36487942934036255,
-0.6326704621315002,
-0.1409158855676651,
-0.2877359986305237,
-1.00928795337677,
0.43717125058174133,
0.3386586010456085,
-0.13703706860542297,
-0.40199920535087585,
0.4175748825073242,
-1.0660403966903687,
-0.27653083205223083,
0.4239766001701355,
0.12931667268276215,
0.48707109689712524,
-0.15002402663230896,
-0.5752352476119995,
0.21853937208652496,
0.4300841987133026,
-0.35010209679603577,
0.31543809175491333,
0.7347869873046875,
0.17224526405334473,
0.5198054313659668,
0.38957786560058594,
0.17807310819625854,
0.23168420791625977,
0.2589828073978424,
0.4035418629646301,
-0.9302152991294861,
-0.5396232604980469,
-0.5749124884605408,
0.860305905342102,
0.1522190421819687,
-0.38160496950149536,
0.47651031613349915,
0.5383415818214417,
0.5848652124404907,
-0.017445556819438934,
1.1643620729446411,
-0.10142751783132553,
0.48007142543792725,
-0.22718177735805511,
0.6515200734138489,
-0.47120052576065063,
-0.38935020565986633,
-0.6236420273780823,
-0.7922480702400208,
-0.36207735538482666,
0.545831561088562,
-0.10846979171037674,
-0.27991387248039246,
0.5888408422470093,
0.5217894315719604,
0.09346707910299301,
0.34211626648902893,
0.49631017446517944,
0.37044912576675415,
0.16911084949970245,
0.5929548740386963,
0.4254201650619507,
-0.6059207320213318,
0.47397464513778687,
-0.17903463542461395,
0.029761383309960365,
-0.37350139021873474,
-0.7344273328781128,
-0.27750247716903687,
-0.6679987907409668,
-0.6224251389503479,
-0.1293899267911911,
-0.042604945600032806,
0.6593347191810608,
0.4967837333679199,
-0.8342435359954834,
0.00353600992821157,
0.050998374819755554,
-0.06419578194618225,
-0.21217584609985352,
-0.18475796282291412,
0.11804774403572083,
-0.14303843677043915,
-0.900619626045227,
0.6265909671783447,
0.6289544105529785,
0.5829737782478333,
0.2747539281845093,
-0.3436194360256195,
0.00802698452025652,
0.05755845084786415,
0.702974259853363,
0.21443204581737518,
-0.5367709398269653,
-0.26292848587036133,
-0.28707748651504517,
-0.35144779086112976,
0.15887318551540375,
0.6424298882484436,
-0.12638869881629944,
0.8065138459205627,
0.6301408410072327,
0.6629135608673096,
0.7110440135002136,
0.15296490490436554,
0.9170369505882263,
-1.0415244102478027,
0.1516561210155487,
0.2235807627439499,
0.33455759286880493,
0.5359784960746765,
-0.29337042570114136,
0.599376916885376,
0.33523136377334595,
-0.8522995114326477,
-0.8209224939346313,
0.16665998101234436,
-1.2067234516143799,
0.3273829519748688,
0.9316444396972656,
-0.33958950638771057,
-0.04492088407278061,
-0.0018077943241223693,
-0.4251925051212311,
0.6528329253196716,
-0.5489488840103149,
0.4468013346195221,
0.88206547498703,
-0.08808392286300659,
-0.5085809230804443,
-0.6905489563941956,
0.6479882597923279,
0.5781176686286926,
-0.9918986558914185,
0.3444698452949524,
0.5296146273612976,
-0.23520901799201965,
-0.1705174297094345,
0.5634418725967407,
0.01140268612653017,
0.010590190067887306,
-0.00120141776278615,
0.4847818911075592,
0.5662606954574585,
-0.11909671127796173,
-0.38377994298934937,
-0.2513475716114044,
-0.23435719311237335,
-0.3550352454185486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13226v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13226v1
|
Dataset Decomposition: Faster LLM Training with Variable Sequence Length Curriculum
| 2024-05-21T22:26:01 | 2024-05-21T22:26:01 |
Hadi Pouransari, Chun-Liang Li, Jen-Hao Rick Chang, Pavan Kumar Anasosalu Vasu, Cem Koc, Vaishaal Shankar, Oncel Tuzel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are commonly trained on datasets consisting of
fixed-length token sequences. These datasets are created by randomly
concatenating documents of various lengths and then chunking them into
sequences of a predetermined target length. However, this method of
concatenation can lead to cross-document attention within a sequence, which is
neither a desirable learning signal nor computationally efficient.
Additionally, training on long sequences becomes computationally prohibitive
due to the quadratic cost of attention. In this study, we introduce dataset
decomposition, a novel variable sequence length training technique, to tackle
these challenges. We decompose a dataset into a union of buckets, each
containing sequences of the same size extracted from a unique document. During
training, we use variable sequence length and batch size, sampling
simultaneously from all buckets with a curriculum. In contrast to the
concat-and-chunk baseline, which incurs a fixed attention cost at every step of
training, our proposed method incurs a penalty proportional to the actual
document lengths at each step, resulting in significant savings in training
time. We train an 8k context-length 1B model at the same cost as a 2k
context-length model trained with the baseline approach. Experiments on a
web-scale corpus demonstrate that our approach significantly enhances
performance on standard language evaluations and long-context benchmarks,
reaching target accuracy 3x faster compared to the baseline. Our method not
only enables efficient pretraining on long sequences but also scales
effectively with dataset size. Lastly, we shed light on a critical yet less
studied aspect of training large language models: the distribution and
curriculum of sequence lengths, which results in a non-negligible difference in
performance.
|
[
-0.3940409719944,
-0.541259765625,
0.29090696573257446,
0.15208083391189575,
-0.4944700300693512,
0.11826103180646896,
-0.4490857720375061,
-0.14339525997638702,
-0.05513012409210205,
0.6004758477210999,
-0.7075122594833374,
-0.4623064398765564,
-0.4594759941101074,
0.05491447076201439,
-0.6531493663787842,
0.7705889344215393,
0.2293512225151062,
0.025536835193634033,
-0.3824138641357422,
-0.11993875354528427,
-0.3433487117290497,
-0.40761783719062805,
-0.5148332118988037,
-0.08646142482757568,
0.7344608306884766,
0.31848934292793274,
0.17031130194664001,
1.2340532541275024,
0.6046876311302185,
0.23312778770923615,
-0.034048039466142654,
0.16257649660110474,
-0.940365731716156,
0.25418615341186523,
0.07024690508842468,
-0.35375624895095825,
-0.11476071923971176,
-0.03477533161640167,
0.9745015501976013,
0.9695709347724915,
0.012639190070331097,
0.5195878744125366,
0.013938083313405514,
0.9765501618385315,
-0.8329851627349854,
0.20169369876384735,
-0.4053736627101898,
0.04828937351703644,
-0.3849661946296692,
-0.2761152386665344,
-0.5706096291542053,
-0.21481376886367798,
0.13811950385570526,
-0.40186870098114014,
0.4332082271575928,
-0.09535142034292221,
0.4887118339538574,
0.5091971158981323,
-0.19984328746795654,
-0.03394266590476036,
-0.6236061453819275,
0.8659443259239197,
-0.3804098963737488,
0.5660596489906311,
0.17449651658535004,
0.19800886511802673,
-0.016067324206233025,
-0.5321967601776123,
-0.5417495369911194,
0.26182663440704346,
0.11349622905254364,
-0.005527506582438946,
0.2118031531572342,
0.09166959673166275,
0.5207780003547668,
0.5734933018684387,
-0.8192001581192017,
0.15942659974098206,
-0.533401608467102,
-0.059235457330942154,
0.47745776176452637,
0.2623547911643982,
-0.05583689734339714,
-0.11557348817586899,
-0.22349482774734497,
-0.19965414702892303,
-0.8331172466278076,
-0.04203898832201958,
0.4364340007305145,
0.4718530774116516,
-0.0027807436417788267,
0.4766624867916107,
-0.0683998167514801,
0.6979488134384155,
0.09460765868425369,
-0.42560645937919617,
0.15019017457962036,
-0.4368317425251007,
-0.35642439126968384,
0.11918368190526962,
0.5699329376220703,
0.27001631259918213,
0.24402093887329102,
-0.1475623995065689,
-0.09056919068098068,
0.22953565418720245,
0.13814988732337952,
-0.9514303207397461,
-0.1217365637421608,
0.323189914226532,
-0.3184400200843811,
-0.07003242522478104,
-0.4169890880584717,
-0.49146467447280884,
-0.18490095436573029,
-0.6133397817611694,
-0.03488652780652046,
-0.5366994738578796,
0.3631182909011841,
0.3071081042289734,
0.10711394995450974,
0.4737958312034607,
0.33351293206214905,
-0.9174057245254517,
0.3272916376590729,
0.9120144248008728,
0.764049232006073,
-0.23706842958927155,
-0.10068245232105255,
-1.0065611600875854,
-0.07193075120449066,
-0.2986305356025696,
0.5860342383384705,
-0.46916285157203674,
-0.2948509454727173,
0.07180151343345642,
-0.22022846341133118,
-0.08386612683534622,
-0.5857970118522644,
0.27626925706863403,
-0.5940452218055725,
0.1920109987258911,
0.020495127886533737,
-0.8498960137367249,
0.05827813968062401,
0.26477712392807007,
-0.7737091779708862,
1.0573993921279907,
0.3626624643802643,
-0.8254242539405823,
0.27871695160865784,
-0.4057426154613495,
-0.6048009991645813,
0.15290644764900208,
-0.19982989132404327,
-0.527086615562439,
-0.07672260701656342,
0.26124292612075806,
0.6005662679672241,
-0.5764241218566895,
0.27750158309936523,
-0.24219171702861786,
-0.5322701930999756,
0.01979968696832657,
-0.35586705803871155,
0.7060860991477966,
-0.02097214385867119,
-0.07047475874423981,
-0.07073547691106796,
-0.9875360131263733,
0.04608331248164177,
-0.11448676884174347,
-0.695613443851471,
-0.25971129536628723,
-0.1626431941986084,
0.14163237810134888,
0.1375790238380432,
0.10016150027513504,
-0.3743177056312561,
0.2647457420825958,
-0.597990870475769,
0.043361544609069824,
0.7229162454605103,
0.014404544606804848,
0.5767055749893188,
-0.1736498326063156,
0.5515467524528503,
-0.10667049139738083,
0.02091432921588421,
-0.4821937084197998,
0.19078859686851501,
-0.9875415563583374,
-0.6445630192756653,
0.554655134677887,
0.2971274256706238,
-0.7194948196411133,
0.44964277744293213,
-0.6316239833831787,
-0.18630743026733398,
-0.6507103443145752,
0.23954768478870392,
0.6498302817344666,
0.5182262063026428,
0.30698370933532715,
-0.5128792524337769,
-0.6199049949645996,
-0.795796811580658,
-0.04598665237426758,
0.17873457074165344,
-0.2690829634666443,
-0.05268455296754837,
0.3066011369228363,
-0.1127806231379509,
0.9064886569976807,
-0.5951544046401978,
-0.2962338924407959,
-0.3438134789466858,
0.04173678904771805,
0.1927749067544937,
0.2546389698982239,
0.39140382409095764,
-0.5120754241943359,
-0.41846418380737305,
-0.34919223189353943,
-0.4416453540325165,
0.029752351343631744,
-0.28316280245780945,
0.02357848361134529,
0.3157194256782532,
0.43622273206710815,
-0.4723813533782959,
0.41554442048072815,
0.2970231771469116,
0.049221694469451904,
0.4091344177722931,
-0.06241283938288689,
-0.385863721370697,
-0.9099990129470825,
0.09245775640010834,
0.07781628519296646,
-0.22904136776924133,
-0.517039954662323,
-0.10226569324731827,
0.23472380638122559,
-0.02947716787457466,
-0.6391146183013916,
0.5233815908432007,
-0.6499301195144653,
-0.3612552583217621,
-0.24455581605434418,
-0.034593258053064346,
-0.04129556193947792,
0.7037320137023926,
0.027487188577651978,
0.7414969205856323,
0.4647509455680847,
-0.6628351807594299,
0.2862815856933594,
0.3284949064254761,
-0.6489049196243286,
0.5020102858543396,
-0.23077350854873657,
0.20941539108753204,
-0.2524661421775818,
0.38281646370887756,
-0.7348833084106445,
-0.06378061324357986,
-0.002131382003426552,
-0.2133403867483139,
0.46195724606513977,
-0.11485472321510315,
-0.5864309072494507,
-0.36033573746681213,
-0.6436068415641785,
0.46557265520095825,
0.3262089788913727,
-0.520105242729187,
0.27100232243537903,
0.31318292021751404,
-0.07043652981519699,
-0.7507579922676086,
-0.6705144643783569,
-0.12970098853111267,
-0.35180333256721497,
-0.508305549621582,
0.3241814076900482,
-0.34660154581069946,
-0.20107626914978027,
-0.3066577911376953,
-0.21520690619945526,
0.06218428909778595,
-0.006531175225973129,
0.15916544198989868,
0.09296737611293793,
-0.18071682751178741,
0.2391076236963272,
-0.13991203904151917,
-0.22190414369106293,
-0.0630732923746109,
-0.24607796967029572,
0.6481055021286011,
0.14576800167560577,
-0.0794253945350647,
-0.2894323170185089,
0.5782456994056702,
0.6417301893234253,
-0.42192351818084717,
0.6641073822975159,
0.5398202538490295,
-0.2871481776237488,
-0.4617069661617279,
-0.4312256872653961,
0.01148538663983345,
-0.47038015723228455,
0.32956692576408386,
-0.20921097695827484,
-1.0108813047409058,
0.38984954357147217,
-0.04109971225261688,
0.0711241364479065,
0.03417361155152321,
0.5742694735527039,
0.10091127455234528,
0.4631679356098175,
0.7813381552696228,
-0.3939710855484009,
0.6820745468139648,
-0.5670347809791565,
0.28007131814956665,
-0.9553649425506592,
-0.08692942559719086,
-0.3750627040863037,
-0.2996194660663605,
-0.4491480886936188,
-0.8625956177711487,
0.0849226713180542,
-0.3360399305820465,
-0.3919527232646942,
0.07613226026296616,
-0.2557709515094757,
0.7599596381187439,
0.46849510073661804,
0.131912961602211,
0.01875673420727253,
-0.04498026520013809,
0.19066965579986572,
0.2040657103061676,
-0.7153850197792053,
-0.0894235372543335,
1.3972465991973877,
0.25986552238464355,
0.6944676637649536,
-0.16130724549293518,
1.0107853412628174,
0.2460879534482956,
0.2036246508359909,
-1.2199435234069824,
0.6032297015190125,
-0.2726891040802002,
-0.09880949556827545,
-0.645007312297821,
-0.5117341876029968,
-1.028920292854309,
0.16372260451316833,
0.12443487346172333,
-0.609769880771637,
0.10606791824102402,
-0.10666811466217041,
-0.42186346650123596,
-0.03691302612423897,
-0.4869184195995331,
0.6378757953643799,
-0.08844196051359177,
-0.5036771893501282,
-0.03314025700092316,
-1.0030368566513062,
0.32137250900268555,
-0.4407244324684143,
0.14878909289836884,
-0.18666547536849976,
0.16105210781097412,
0.9138327240943909,
-0.5418723821640015,
0.7128652930259705,
0.07028158754110336,
-0.11143898963928223,
0.20096255838871002,
-0.06305303424596786,
0.3693898618221283,
-0.01154100988060236,
0.054912496358156204,
-0.0365455187857151,
-0.38122430443763733,
-0.4664291441440582,
-0.48406022787094116,
0.6122884154319763,
-0.6430289149284363,
-0.4659076929092407,
-0.28097212314605713,
-0.7415035367012024,
-0.22212743759155273,
0.18426935374736786,
0.11017099767923355,
0.6064724922180176,
-0.12785054743289948,
0.3798973560333252,
1.0140066146850586,
0.04447237029671669,
0.7027071714401245,
0.42313122749328613,
0.193964883685112,
-0.375862181186676,
0.5732458829879761,
0.25214648246765137,
0.2275274395942688,
0.6647197008132935,
-0.05431843176484108,
-0.30716297030448914,
-0.64475417137146,
-0.04191263020038605,
0.25199949741363525,
-0.8215060234069824,
-0.34842193126678467,
-0.580430269241333,
-0.22738070785999298,
-0.3560129404067993,
-0.1927434206008911,
-0.5437344908714294,
-0.27633634209632874,
-0.18173186480998993,
-0.16926509141921997,
0.16485901176929474,
0.2885598838329315,
0.03632469102740288,
0.4601329565048218,
-0.6825481057167053,
0.4315745532512665,
0.22513137757778168,
0.3873245418071747,
-0.0797615796327591,
-0.4806573688983917,
-0.5981869697570801,
-0.22270715236663818,
-0.025979463011026382,
-0.42584773898124695,
0.5918423533439636,
0.1762702614068985,
0.3098936080932617,
0.28826895356178284,
0.15100933611392975,
0.8615750670433044,
-0.6783105731010437,
0.4950639307498932,
0.14611852169036865,
-0.9254331588745117,
0.30784720182418823,
-0.4477699100971222,
0.608573853969574,
0.6606530547142029,
0.34546059370040894,
-0.5773168206214905,
-0.2816232740879059,
-0.5547923445701599,
-1.2293999195098877,
0.8772154450416565,
0.09852384030818939,
0.007623735815286636,
-0.1246650218963623,
0.2694915533065796,
0.20246455073356628,
0.07456625252962112,
-0.3457549810409546,
-0.3614487946033478,
0.35665470361709595,
-0.34288156032562256,
-0.3588557839393616,
-0.46336036920547485,
-0.2625507712364197,
-0.3164936602115631,
0.4856826663017273,
-0.31297940015792847,
0.35690608620643616,
-0.1789252907037735,
-0.44347426295280457,
0.18129712343215942,
0.07220160961151123,
0.4042493999004364,
0.6958327293395996,
-0.34037235379219055,
0.1294039934873581,
-0.08450962603092194,
-0.49558591842651367,
0.2345762997865677,
0.005269037559628487,
0.1668223738670349,
-0.08965522050857544,
0.5602306127548218,
0.6935900449752808,
0.3770018517971039,
-0.6291465163230896,
0.49288442730903625,
-0.24103118479251862,
-0.14765219390392303,
-0.2343195527791977,
-0.0356108620762825,
0.15863348543643951,
0.2820751368999481,
0.3093293309211731,
-0.35089418292045593,
0.09019484370946884,
-0.4008997976779938,
0.4376077651977539,
-0.17932502925395966,
0.007102147210389376,
-0.08963406831026077,
0.21724039316177368,
0.12233248353004456,
-0.2266838252544403,
0.9431485533714294,
0.09209217131137848,
-0.3095802068710327,
0.8405185341835022,
0.41480502486228943,
0.8731148838996887,
-0.17927518486976624,
0.1509905904531479,
0.2546307444572449,
0.023837948217988014,
-0.23505957424640656,
0.08166748285293579,
-0.19282327592372894,
-0.5121589303016663,
-0.504891574382782,
-0.8476274013519287,
-0.3682709038257599,
0.47238394618034363,
-0.7503349781036377,
0.31672775745391846,
-0.4298742413520813,
0.2309330254793167,
0.15057267248630524,
0.10530876368284225,
-0.9842922687530518,
0.3877307176589966,
0.39220133423805237,
0.7889017462730408,
-0.7605249881744385,
0.8848129510879517,
0.22982904314994812,
-0.15608735382556915,
-0.8092138767242432,
0.22593869268894196,
-0.10573036223649979,
-0.551237165927887,
0.6945132613182068,
0.6447858214378357,
0.16505765914916992,
0.004154623486101627,
-0.36119914054870605,
-1.0710039138793945,
0.9536926746368408,
0.5338972806930542,
-0.7582173347473145,
0.09624764323234558,
0.373636931180954,
0.508520781993866,
-0.37663745880126953,
-0.02071000263094902,
0.7666625380516052,
0.1968821883201599,
0.0323910191655159,
-0.6587356328964233,
0.015440886840224266,
-0.1019192636013031,
0.20413298904895782,
0.3188571333885193,
-0.7131981253623962,
0.7007841467857361,
-0.014197343960404396,
-0.17984792590141296,
-0.15623274445533752,
0.6222753524780273,
0.015387961640954018,
0.1423242688179016,
0.25925353169441223,
0.5678129196166992,
0.9391434192657471,
0.02980690635740757,
0.9595332741737366,
-0.24622628092765808,
0.5158446431159973,
1.401663899421692,
-0.39903223514556885,
0.7351353764533997,
0.5886812806129456,
-0.12401183694601059,
0.18669357895851135,
0.8148366808891296,
0.19193971157073975,
0.8064255714416504,
0.5851172208786011,
-0.3167012929916382,
-0.3552553355693817,
0.10283439606428146,
-0.09530017524957657,
0.5154075026512146,
0.40510237216949463,
-0.3187037408351898,
-0.3865078091621399,
0.19407585263252258,
0.02925572544336319,
-0.010455367155373096,
-0.28095176815986633,
0.7385958433151245,
0.04366299510002136,
-0.6372230648994446,
0.9703664183616638,
-0.12347836047410965,
0.4651647210121155,
-0.48946085572242737,
0.18110327422618866,
-0.611943781375885,
0.5206494331359863,
0.05052405595779419,
-0.6040248870849609,
0.20045822858810425,
0.0646234005689621,
-0.45833486318588257,
-0.45204663276672363,
0.3211773931980133,
-0.5587860345840454,
-0.32928115129470825,
0.1741226464509964,
0.24880656599998474,
-0.0004117547068744898,
0.019083665683865547,
-0.4062093198299408,
0.22980628907680511,
-0.11793393641710281,
-0.46971964836120605,
0.5199426412582397,
0.46677166223526,
-0.22479498386383057,
0.8304662704467773,
0.6249771118164062,
-0.3251396417617798,
0.04450901970267296,
0.14220045506954193,
1.2049529552459717,
-0.712633490562439,
-0.3979282081127167,
-0.8385517001152039,
0.501645565032959,
0.03224354237318039,
0.004739089403301477,
0.4860750436782837,
1.0125458240509033,
1.0793132781982422,
-0.21862629055976868,
0.8078014254570007,
0.22652967274188995,
0.38251081109046936,
-0.5430766344070435,
0.34242311120033264,
-0.2787102162837982,
0.39106154441833496,
0.04493590444326401,
-0.7822161316871643,
-0.585911750793457,
0.3799709677696228,
-0.40451687574386597,
-0.2981002926826477,
0.8331714868545532,
0.4972880780696869,
0.04555121809244156,
-0.4342418611049652,
0.26475057005882263,
-0.1474079191684723,
0.30120325088500977,
0.7112736701965332,
0.4805399477481842,
-0.27706873416900635,
0.4576359689235687,
-0.2619546949863434,
-0.07232610136270523,
-0.3852592706680298,
-0.7191481590270996,
-1.09424889087677,
-0.38066592812538147,
-0.3872896432876587,
-0.0035901314113289118,
0.2877751886844635,
0.7628090381622314,
0.4994358718395233,
-0.45040959119796753,
-0.22852395474910736,
0.12741902470588684,
0.09168840944766998,
-0.06980814039707184,
-0.21649500727653503,
0.6782320737838745,
-0.37458664178848267,
-0.7448136806488037,
0.4064263105392456,
0.40971052646636963,
-0.17972904443740845,
-0.1864425390958786,
0.05654102936387062,
-0.3298870921134949,
0.12070932239294052,
0.7137088179588318,
0.19836953282356262,
-0.32910001277923584,
-0.3485523760318756,
0.0004239612026140094,
-0.2102978676557541,
0.3416963815689087,
0.7831069231033325,
-0.9040124416351318,
0.5213184952735901,
0.6004544496536255,
0.887826144695282,
0.9268813133239746,
-0.0585128590464592,
0.5806953310966492,
-1.224934458732605,
0.34157416224479675,
0.27269768714904785,
0.3693792521953583,
0.3735704720020294,
-0.549763023853302,
0.7019494771957397,
0.2309892624616623,
-0.27234262228012085,
-0.8920688629150391,
0.12692756950855255,
-1.219550371170044,
-0.1639728844165802,
1.1502338647842407,
-0.3607427477836609,
-0.5979210734367371,
0.14932282269001007,
-0.06073823943734169,
0.4565926790237427,
-0.24745990335941315,
0.7388390302658081,
0.5760536789894104,
0.09176894277334213,
-0.21848611533641815,
-0.2562374472618103,
0.3324682414531708,
0.22363685071468353,
-0.7118021845817566,
0.47735998034477234,
0.6372973918914795,
0.40218842029571533,
0.04239726439118385,
0.6370044350624084,
-0.031474027782678604,
0.27579692006111145,
-0.05679420009255409,
0.12406577914953232,
-0.060767125338315964,
-0.484902560710907,
-0.37844112515449524,
0.2013305276632309,
-0.3162855803966522,
-0.3401208221912384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13219v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13219v1
|
How Reliable AI Chatbots are for Disease Prediction from Patient Complaints?
| 2024-05-21T22:00:13 | 2024-05-21T22:00:13 |
Ayesha Siddika Nipu, K M Sajjadul Islam, Praveen Madiraju
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Artificial Intelligence (AI) chatbots leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs)
are gaining traction in healthcare for their potential to automate patient
interactions and aid clinical decision-making. This study examines the
reliability of AI chatbots, specifically GPT 4.0, Claude 3 Opus, and Gemini
Ultra 1.0, in predicting diseases from patient complaints in the emergency
department. The methodology includes few-shot learning techniques to evaluate
the chatbots' effectiveness in disease prediction. We also fine-tune the
transformer-based model BERT and compare its performance with the AI chatbots.
Results suggest that GPT 4.0 achieves high accuracy with increased few-shot
data, while Gemini Ultra 1.0 performs well with fewer examples, and Claude 3
Opus maintains consistent performance. BERT's performance, however, is lower
than all the chatbots, indicating limitations due to limited labeled data.
Despite the chatbots' varying accuracy, none of them are sufficiently reliable
for critical medical decision-making, underscoring the need for rigorous
validation and human oversight. This study reflects that while AI chatbots have
potential in healthcare, they should complement, not replace, human expertise
to ensure patient safety. Further refinement and research are needed to improve
AI-based healthcare applications' reliability for disease prediction.
|
[
0.302381694316864,
-0.6525484323501587,
0.9060694575309753,
-0.03967445343732834,
-0.023742152377963066,
0.1666412353515625,
-0.0019752467051148415,
-0.7991007566452026,
0.21726593375205994,
0.4110608994960785,
-0.24967773258686066,
-0.3799551725387573,
-0.7275169491767883,
0.20904302597045898,
-0.5155888795852661,
0.9958928823471069,
0.31499287486076355,
0.3696863353252411,
-0.3667603135108948,
0.2646816074848175,
-0.5396463871002197,
-0.4948548972606659,
-1.1118885278701782,
-0.5637816786766052,
0.47715142369270325,
0.41090893745422363,
0.8540918827056885,
0.19323931634426117,
0.9116826057434082,
0.32722803950309753,
0.24184320867061615,
0.04912632703781128,
-0.47425204515457153,
0.23997868597507477,
0.549473226070404,
-0.7163354158401489,
-0.28746309876441956,
-0.3623228371143341,
0.014187023043632507,
0.3654797077178955,
-0.19113771617412567,
-0.2102043777704239,
0.016091009601950645,
0.6931502819061279,
0.16431759297847748,
0.4470245838165283,
-0.7986305356025696,
0.231362447142601,
-0.18415439128875732,
-0.07325892895460129,
-0.4036122262477875,
-0.33021384477615356,
0.5076940655708313,
-0.3328222930431366,
0.04911478981375694,
0.06330307573080063,
0.9583543539047241,
0.6151033639907837,
-0.16665272414684296,
-0.3408496677875519,
-0.9347478747367859,
0.42128920555114746,
-0.7215650081634521,
0.24185824394226074,
0.8605829477310181,
0.6768987774848938,
-0.1864115595817566,
-0.8274279236793518,
-0.2850872874259949,
-0.5834482908248901,
-0.15363910794258118,
0.35334670543670654,
-0.5354958176612854,
0.15252254903316498,
0.21915382146835327,
0.03206339105963707,
-0.5358538627624512,
0.407254159450531,
-0.5073526501655579,
-0.4215107858181,
0.583479642868042,
0.23796889185905457,
0.43691715598106384,
-0.37776196002960205,
-0.24521900713443756,
0.17769914865493774,
-0.8292075991630554,
-0.10252008587121964,
0.04080469161272049,
0.12950176000595093,
-0.2588960826396942,
0.33407074213027954,
0.015341599471867085,
0.39558109641075134,
0.10272824019193649,
-0.41822537779808044,
0.2952055037021637,
0.07122044265270233,
-0.2619783282279968,
0.056233931332826614,
1.0188900232315063,
0.39586716890335083,
0.24720999598503113,
-0.3450455367565155,
-0.06947630643844604,
-0.03867048770189285,
0.6129800081253052,
-0.5092354416847229,
-0.767724335193634,
0.7404057383537292,
-0.5296395421028137,
-0.29240188002586365,
-0.17733903229236603,
-0.547447919845581,
-0.582711398601532,
0.0175126064568758,
0.2012639343738556,
-0.8428798317909241,
-0.1221284493803978,
-0.25179237127304077,
0.11967440694570541,
-0.108512282371521,
0.6910189390182495,
-0.663480818271637,
0.06960054486989975,
0.5064047574996948,
0.6469172239303589,
-0.2721465229988098,
-0.06770730018615723,
-0.3622444272041321,
-0.1564021110534668,
-0.2994203567504883,
1.0716869831085205,
-0.2476322501897812,
-0.5712502598762512,
-0.01430694293230772,
-0.18135900795459747,
-0.2413025200366974,
-0.7156505584716797,
0.8259789347648621,
-0.027246098965406418,
-0.1100807711482048,
0.1883941888809204,
-0.5918847918510437,
0.02764435112476349,
0.3738763928413391,
-0.5940820574760437,
0.4927411377429962,
0.18934954702854156,
-0.47734224796295166,
0.2926432490348816,
-0.5722957253456116,
-0.4764004349708557,
0.5022380352020264,
-0.3285449743270874,
-0.7514122128486633,
0.03456278145313263,
0.22579896450042725,
0.5018459558486938,
-0.25992223620414734,
0.057131603360176086,
-0.1846642792224884,
-0.26120609045028687,
0.25511664152145386,
-0.6108073592185974,
0.34492892026901245,
0.1087559387087822,
-0.13242855668067932,
0.20495879650115967,
-0.405221164226532,
-0.0034855196718126535,
0.08615017682313919,
-0.11270078271627426,
0.18362276256084442,
0.5150634050369263,
-0.1607312560081482,
0.06520930677652359,
-0.06986872106790543,
-0.3310385048389435,
0.0974380150437355,
-0.5337597727775574,
0.4589950442314148,
0.7027581334114075,
-0.04922999069094658,
-0.07179315388202667,
-0.7418456077575684,
0.6096099019050598,
0.1310930997133255,
0.39563941955566406,
-0.27740928530693054,
-0.9755228757858276,
-0.6594410538673401,
-0.2019728571176529,
0.39748257398605347,
0.6140381693840027,
-0.7712811231613159,
0.40236136317253113,
-0.4053434133529663,
-0.6754379272460938,
-0.5718476176261902,
-0.17835748195648193,
0.18713830411434174,
0.6808310747146606,
0.34830912947654724,
0.010545122437179089,
-0.284199595451355,
-0.7001242637634277,
0.059093788266181946,
-0.6928256154060364,
-0.19113631546497345,
0.7022241353988647,
0.21022948622703552,
-0.6412418484687805,
0.5743898153305054,
-0.04174432158470154,
-0.5032903552055359,
-0.5044317841529846,
0.1142624169588089,
0.11236508190631866,
0.2765604257583618,
0.5939235091209412,
-0.4403465688228607,
-0.5774260759353638,
0.09372537583112717,
-0.6773279309272766,
0.18958735466003418,
-0.020430736243724823,
0.40295642614364624,
0.4172435998916626,
-0.029124710708856583,
-0.5480449795722961,
0.7102795243263245,
0.854771077632904,
0.12465927004814148,
0.36409154534339905,
-0.2877332270145416,
0.010970034636557102,
-0.8676761984825134,
-0.0814947634935379,
0.11540878564119339,
-0.3688727915287018,
-0.7848761081695557,
-0.5448729395866394,
-0.2375316619873047,
-0.07956723868846893,
-0.3366844356060028,
0.31495770812034607,
0.04487783834338188,
0.2868211567401886,
-0.22923658788204193,
-0.2496797889471054,
-0.5416292548179626,
-0.05391113460063934,
-0.10725569725036621,
0.4698842465877533,
0.7385767102241516,
-0.3396915793418884,
0.4759746789932251,
0.1429171860218048,
-0.3599487245082855,
0.43566516041755676,
-1.0937919616699219,
0.41214683651924133,
0.09228120744228363,
0.4052302837371826,
-1.0506737232208252,
-0.5190911889076233,
0.338852196931839,
-0.7288637161254883,
0.2786909341812134,
-0.21728552877902985,
-0.5006699562072754,
-0.7756665349006653,
0.010636549443006516,
-0.03761735185980797,
0.6530417799949646,
-0.17280952632427216,
0.535955548286438,
0.44338053464889526,
-0.2674742043018341,
-0.24819724261760712,
-0.6697768568992615,
0.12556828558444977,
0.07710348069667816,
-0.5211622714996338,
-0.10656602680683136,
0.08808083087205887,
-0.15578612685203552,
-0.17414060235023499,
-0.029736651107668877,
-0.043401267379522324,
0.16966864466667175,
0.8147298693656921,
0.4503520131111145,
0.09436748921871185,
0.2961464822292328,
-0.3028820753097534,
-0.21564997732639313,
0.016114845871925354,
0.04117273539304733,
0.5768667459487915,
-0.17258623242378235,
-0.8176366686820984,
-0.9287198185920715,
0.2814355492591858,
0.7142142057418823,
0.21720674633979797,
0.4430922269821167,
0.25854092836380005,
-0.4792020618915558,
0.28286242485046387,
-0.575846791267395,
-0.5433250665664673,
-0.37305372953414917,
0.3627368211746216,
-0.16783036291599274,
-0.6863003373146057,
0.38627544045448303,
0.11131872236728668,
0.15644648671150208,
0.5821388959884644,
0.5823260545730591,
-0.5792863965034485,
1.1926177740097046,
0.463183730840683,
-0.4176173210144043,
-0.025229843333363533,
0.05382547527551651,
0.27711594104766846,
-0.12434401363134384,
-0.2664538621902466,
-0.7187752723693848,
-0.4131915867328644,
-0.8048613667488098,
-0.09880877286195755,
0.9301255941390991,
-0.40796852111816406,
-0.08323384076356888,
-0.026117078959941864,
-0.46012595295906067,
0.16894803941249847,
0.5581412315368652,
0.44670939445495605,
0.18058224022388458,
-0.001310449093580246,
0.22423703968524933,
0.0367157906293869,
-0.7998283505439758,
-0.4709724485874176,
1.170624852180481,
0.5646858215332031,
0.8821559548377991,
-0.006922051776200533,
0.7663803100585938,
0.41707074642181396,
0.4389115273952484,
-0.8653610944747925,
0.10587922483682632,
-0.17089267075061798,
-0.44018998742103577,
-0.36730673909187317,
-0.5168177485466003,
-1.2170437574386597,
-0.3930927813053131,
-0.31908929347991943,
-0.7659378051757812,
-0.40532687306404114,
0.3305331766605377,
-0.7749660015106201,
0.19998551905155182,
-0.757826566696167,
0.6396855711936951,
-0.547065794467926,
0.17005304992198944,
-0.2857610285282135,
-0.9801812171936035,
-0.024955041706562042,
-0.05600019916892052,
-0.0481170117855072,
-0.29528895020484924,
0.40986204147338867,
0.5717974901199341,
-0.5233728885650635,
1.0353748798370361,
0.22816196084022522,
-0.0578148178756237,
0.02707848511636257,
-0.04292571172118187,
0.5101993680000305,
0.17079117894172668,
-0.16092588007450104,
0.5936067700386047,
-0.03534136712551117,
-0.26449185609817505,
-0.2570250928401947,
0.49441277980804443,
-1.0739128589630127,
-0.5784169435501099,
-0.5085507035255432,
-0.15835702419281006,
-0.5215607285499573,
0.13748744130134583,
0.3930453360080719,
0.4011634886264801,
-0.08570984750986099,
0.0011569435009732842,
0.23326604068279266,
-0.18140672147274017,
0.2454904168844223,
0.32408490777015686,
0.12026741355657578,
-0.12194181978702545,
0.8285520672798157,
-0.09765148162841797,
0.033528607338666916,
0.4339854419231415,
0.24618791043758392,
-0.034864962100982666,
-0.6894190311431885,
-0.5229896903038025,
0.01841769926249981,
-0.3934940695762634,
-0.6089959740638733,
-0.6864206790924072,
-0.7133702635765076,
-0.32310786843299866,
0.15507285296916962,
-0.40762823820114136,
0.0025967468973249197,
-0.30068400502204895,
0.05277320370078087,
0.514026939868927,
1.0136282444000244,
0.19189971685409546,
0.19349488615989685,
-1.2280588150024414,
0.2278159111738205,
0.3271970748901367,
0.2273884266614914,
-0.28391119837760925,
-0.31962260603904724,
-0.12270564585924149,
0.1890821009874344,
-0.33533740043640137,
-0.8754616379737854,
0.3266427516937256,
0.09860455989837646,
0.6174361705780029,
0.6810157895088196,
0.09675419330596924,
0.2403109222650528,
-0.5228735208511353,
0.9694016575813293,
0.44296950101852417,
-0.5604961514472961,
0.5980073809623718,
-0.336616575717926,
0.01911173388361931,
0.4854503870010376,
0.4734589755535126,
-0.6003586649894714,
-0.5510228872299194,
-0.8267898559570312,
-0.5216718912124634,
0.5895657539367676,
0.1863020658493042,
0.14486581087112427,
-0.05199028179049492,
0.11052753776311874,
0.1976308822631836,
-0.16588401794433594,
-0.2582549750804901,
-0.43418678641319275,
-0.04457750916481018,
-0.2508847415447235,
-0.029188767075538635,
-0.1941979080438614,
-0.16856542229652405,
-0.08843353390693665,
0.3887122869491577,
-0.20784872770309448,
0.6201053261756897,
0.13067488372325897,
0.2777614891529083,
-0.38945016264915466,
0.19809743762016296,
0.6312554478645325,
0.7311070561408997,
-0.14512161910533905,
-0.14799553155899048,
0.029717635363340378,
-0.5268643498420715,
-0.25139719247817993,
0.19642286002635956,
0.07232359051704407,
0.33515307307243347,
0.4371018409729004,
0.6701924204826355,
-0.06648128479719162,
-0.8243484497070312,
0.5202711820602417,
-0.11493100970983505,
-0.1305609792470932,
-0.47633618116378784,
0.08944395929574966,
-0.14129458367824554,
0.12846294045448303,
0.15816468000411987,
0.42961740493774414,
0.02637665905058384,
-0.4085249900817871,
0.28908219933509827,
0.395610511302948,
-0.606329619884491,
-0.3802185654640198,
0.7052066922187805,
0.5471357107162476,
-0.45589786767959595,
1.0255059003829956,
0.11504638940095901,
-0.5075150728225708,
0.6279541850090027,
0.3246469795703888,
0.659620463848114,
-0.3147852420806885,
0.2963952422142029,
0.13384640216827393,
0.21634945273399353,
-0.15582971274852753,
0.09370934218168259,
0.591192901134491,
-0.6961842775344849,
-0.40812164545059204,
-0.18253162503242493,
-0.9894161820411682,
0.16468356549739838,
-0.19981816411018372,
0.288043737411499,
-0.380004346370697,
-0.42159584164619446,
-0.021004624664783478,
-0.15269532799720764,
-0.5816307067871094,
0.14858390390872955,
0.5108580589294434,
0.6863390803337097,
-0.4687648117542267,
0.739060640335083,
0.6670019626617432,
-0.22937016189098358,
-1.0459721088409424,
0.3482652008533478,
0.23885159194469452,
-1.2457889318466187,
0.3575630784034729,
0.15354208648204803,
0.2776407301425934,
-0.3529199957847595,
-0.5443435311317444,
-0.6584986448287964,
0.7301387786865234,
0.3751640319824219,
-0.8512721657752991,
-0.0010380558669567108,
0.24738524854183197,
0.7600085735321045,
0.03395349159836769,
0.741105318069458,
0.4012593924999237,
0.3948404788970947,
0.35294121503829956,
-1.5024337768554688,
-0.28041547536849976,
-0.05524067580699921,
-0.36043450236320496,
0.07837538421154022,
-0.6621913313865662,
0.44834277033805847,
-0.6316397190093994,
-0.051326584070920944,
0.29072654247283936,
0.43369126319885254,
0.04769556224346161,
0.2646125555038452,
0.42111119627952576,
0.6033211946487427,
1.0069085359573364,
-0.4121248126029968,
1.2883368730545044,
-0.4680481553077698,
0.19975601136684418,
0.763702392578125,
-0.33272334933280945,
0.7857720255851746,
0.023234903812408447,
-0.3912983238697052,
0.44512370228767395,
0.480599582195282,
0.002272111363708973,
0.27958616614341736,
0.02945576049387455,
-0.11469881981611252,
-0.166960671544075,
0.1980113983154297,
-0.3859851062297821,
0.5739607810974121,
0.5166525840759277,
-0.41918453574180603,
0.05186787247657776,
-0.011703112162649632,
-0.0026566223241388798,
-0.5329680442810059,
-0.10054764896631241,
1.029679536819458,
0.006064120214432478,
-0.675877571105957,
0.5523640513420105,
-0.3089641034603119,
0.38014036417007446,
-0.530989408493042,
-0.11751589924097061,
-0.13924077153205872,
0.3136988878250122,
-0.22917704284191132,
-0.5835917592048645,
0.13275015354156494,
-0.11690529435873032,
-0.0705348327755928,
0.07637981325387955,
0.8207235336303711,
-0.13097354769706726,
-0.6196617484092712,
-0.15088939666748047,
0.6876097321510315,
0.6022999286651611,
0.0025683233980089426,
-0.8514521718025208,
0.09422841668128967,
0.03343365713953972,
0.27218741178512573,
0.13876666128635406,
0.07581572234630585,
0.2218320369720459,
0.8379791975021362,
0.5198819041252136,
0.3303649127483368,
-0.34312576055526733,
0.10913024097681046,
0.601427435874939,
-0.32567113637924194,
-0.019517993554472923,
-0.8623132705688477,
0.32214322686195374,
-0.030154429376125336,
-0.26020386815071106,
0.424722820520401,
0.1336442083120346,
0.23273101449012756,
0.036713022738695145,
1.1207855939865112,
0.07473649084568024,
0.7859676480293274,
-0.3350539207458496,
1.0430399179458618,
-0.33670738339424133,
0.27889513969421387,
-0.04034719616174698,
-0.18486282229423523,
-0.5114691853523254,
0.4461618959903717,
-0.25899332761764526,
0.2452353686094284,
0.626859188079834,
0.39655664563179016,
0.34934309124946594,
0.2029828280210495,
0.5052931904792786,
0.503387987613678,
0.5688161253929138,
0.6740900874137878,
0.896651566028595,
-0.2321309596300125,
0.4886054992675781,
-0.2830810546875,
-0.1450888067483902,
-0.6866068243980408,
-0.48422157764434814,
-0.7232353687286377,
-0.10314983874559402,
-0.40607747435569763,
-0.4289478063583374,
0.35022926330566406,
1.011017084121704,
0.9724318385124207,
-0.9419464468955994,
0.2894325256347656,
0.07780981808900833,
0.022939225658774376,
-0.13597355782985687,
-0.1145651713013649,
0.42124441266059875,
-0.48434582352638245,
-0.6144340634346008,
0.28930163383483887,
0.4492276608943939,
0.2155381441116333,
0.0279860757291317,
-0.03282779082655907,
0.6651278138160706,
-0.18577219545841217,
0.3816208243370056,
0.36978650093078613,
-0.9252059459686279,
-0.4063554108142853,
-0.007677759509533644,
-0.43024659156799316,
0.31223055720329285,
0.4166828393936157,
-0.7748191356658936,
0.2745012640953064,
0.0885096862912178,
0.7418996691703796,
-0.06905146688222885,
0.06378108263015747,
0.48894086480140686,
-0.2601587176322937,
-0.3004706799983978,
0.6581283211708069,
0.6437414288520813,
0.29993540048599243,
-0.4619683027267456,
0.3343764841556549,
0.1868627369403839,
-0.8741185069084167,
-0.4226365387439728,
-0.15852117538452148,
-0.937592089176178,
0.19373412430286407,
1.262452244758606,
-0.20823442935943604,
0.015202617272734642,
-0.35171207785606384,
-0.3707588016986847,
-0.1509961187839508,
-0.7252554893493652,
1.1171456575393677,
0.3174288868904114,
-0.8798059225082397,
-0.13101834058761597,
-0.5686283707618713,
0.6206148862838745,
0.44872426986694336,
-1.0321133136749268,
-0.1817336231470108,
0.41957205533981323,
0.06859371066093445,
0.3567822575569153,
0.6944179534912109,
-0.06740991026163101,
0.48683321475982666,
-0.2988245189189911,
-0.31416887044906616,
0.26029402017593384,
-0.26055917143821716,
-0.015169719234108925,
-0.09286727011203766,
0.0947406217455864,
-0.14757107198238373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13216v1
|
Equipping Transformer with Random-Access Reading for Long-Context Understanding
| 2024-05-21T21:41:07 | 2024-05-21T21:41:07 |
Chenghao Yang, Zi Yang, Nan Hua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Long-context modeling presents a significant challenge for transformer-based
large language models (LLMs) due to the quadratic complexity of the
self-attention mechanism and issues with length extrapolation caused by
pretraining exclusively on short inputs. Existing methods address computational
complexity through techniques such as text chunking, the kernel approach, and
structured attention, and tackle length extrapolation problems through
positional encoding, continued pretraining, and data engineering. These
approaches typically require $\textbf{sequential access}$ to the document,
necessitating reading from the first to the last token. We contend that for
goal-oriented reading of long documents, such sequential access is not
necessary, and a proficiently trained model can learn to omit hundreds of less
pertinent tokens. Inspired by human reading behaviors and existing empirical
observations, we propose $\textbf{random access}$, a novel reading strategy
that enables transformers to efficiently process long documents without
examining every token. Experimental results from pretraining, fine-tuning, and
inference phases validate the efficacy of our method.
|
[
-0.3469558656215668,
-0.5673107504844666,
0.7971832156181335,
0.30907002091407776,
-0.5849300622940063,
0.09243524074554443,
-0.2726896405220032,
-0.6423195004463196,
-0.03929007425904274,
0.5937211513519287,
-0.8114606142044067,
-0.3001081645488739,
-0.6406918168067932,
0.25804394483566284,
-0.647201657295227,
0.911708652973175,
-0.09427390992641449,
-0.3381001651287079,
-0.15285393595695496,
-0.020774656906723976,
-0.370272696018219,
-0.4729878902435303,
-0.5935945510864258,
-0.35031116008758545,
0.8689593076705933,
0.5663604140281677,
0.540623664855957,
0.6931930184364319,
0.40027737617492676,
0.24385179579257965,
-0.10054515302181244,
-0.08295932412147522,
-0.679351806640625,
0.16872358322143555,
-0.12728099524974823,
-0.730216920375824,
-0.16964875161647797,
-0.16972845792770386,
0.8465949892997742,
0.530646562576294,
0.07135801762342453,
0.16119030117988586,
0.0011498612584546208,
0.614631175994873,
-0.3899036645889282,
0.020986098796129227,
-0.5214965343475342,
0.25383278727531433,
-0.3893964886665344,
-0.36254453659057617,
-0.7377618551254272,
0.20031845569610596,
0.2579144835472107,
-0.6243115663528442,
0.4361175000667572,
0.3442424237728119,
0.6263024210929871,
0.36564135551452637,
-0.544285774230957,
-0.26688504219055176,
-1.0217859745025635,
0.8996709585189819,
-0.28627389669418335,
0.6605734825134277,
0.5176639556884766,
0.2878076136112213,
-0.013668314553797245,
-0.8077475428581238,
-0.7991493940353394,
-0.039175741374492645,
-0.28706327080726624,
0.06703419983386993,
0.06007400527596474,
0.05755065754055977,
0.3051084876060486,
0.11950190365314484,
-0.340912789106369,
0.26999253034591675,
-0.30171915888786316,
0.024775860831141472,
0.3434966802597046,
0.043030112981796265,
-0.07334273308515549,
-0.28737691044807434,
-0.6094988584518433,
-0.2192857563495636,
-0.5309156775474548,
0.16294483840465546,
0.21235473453998566,
-0.03714829683303833,
-0.11953084915876389,
0.5051637291908264,
0.005330258049070835,
0.6943557262420654,
0.13234521448612213,
-0.002880765125155449,
0.20447108149528503,
-0.14177557826042175,
-0.3193790316581726,
-0.08253912627696991,
0.5470869541168213,
-0.07904782891273499,
0.17349961400032043,
-0.5533870458602905,
-0.2270202487707138,
-0.6848782896995544,
0.49154138565063477,
-0.6777902841567993,
0.19471721351146698,
0.449149489402771,
-0.28676360845565796,
-0.22893616557121277,
-0.08206261694431305,
-0.7688156366348267,
-0.21531617641448975,
-0.5241435766220093,
0.37810182571411133,
-0.39199745655059814,
0.20892292261123657,
0.03463936969637871,
-0.07117858529090881,
0.43037083745002747,
0.1710594743490219,
-1.2071223258972168,
0.17679063975811005,
0.7561537027359009,
0.8839083909988403,
-0.3552018702030182,
-0.5841039419174194,
-0.6293259263038635,
0.237986758351326,
0.0739821195602417,
0.9216269254684448,
-0.47762125730514526,
-0.3827733099460602,
-0.28963348269462585,
0.015978239476680756,
-0.09228222817182541,
-0.030071811750531197,
0.7749534845352173,
-0.8623540997505188,
0.042771439999341965,
0.03157537803053856,
-0.49743732810020447,
0.03724170848727226,
0.03351641446352005,
-0.6627260446548462,
0.9504871368408203,
0.13684210181236267,
-0.6845606565475464,
0.3824935853481293,
-0.6608248949050903,
-0.5422332882881165,
-0.08479517698287964,
-0.1391034573316574,
-0.3613278269767761,
0.45375707745552063,
0.43371081352233887,
0.47310206294059753,
-0.10846734791994095,
0.24922217428684235,
-0.07239650189876556,
-0.3664448857307434,
0.12698979675769806,
-0.7480146884918213,
0.3706366717815399,
0.21344077587127686,
-0.30664727091789246,
0.24390186369419098,
-0.8538915514945984,
-0.15287859737873077,
0.25031229853630066,
-0.07093704491853714,
-0.41163140535354614,
0.2784251272678375,
0.23157523572444916,
0.18966947495937347,
0.16079795360565186,
-0.5734736919403076,
0.24277396500110626,
-0.548542320728302,
0.3693216145038605,
0.9951054453849792,
-0.3530859053134918,
0.8093249797821045,
-0.13185010850429535,
0.36238518357276917,
0.18438927829265594,
0.17449630796909332,
-0.6146944761276245,
0.06795745342969894,
-0.8172705769538879,
-0.3981113135814667,
0.253006249666214,
0.23199273645877838,
-0.4365026354789734,
0.37578558921813965,
-0.572252094745636,
-0.35081759095191956,
-0.3464161455631256,
0.192884624004364,
0.17920032143592834,
0.5662221312522888,
0.5067569017410278,
-0.21164578199386597,
-0.2476997673511505,
-0.7906442880630493,
-0.3189869225025177,
0.21393808722496033,
-0.29914942383766174,
0.4156976342201233,
0.4192459285259247,
-0.3535061776638031,
1.2029130458831787,
-0.7283734083175659,
-0.38536500930786133,
-0.42499932646751404,
0.22623437643051147,
0.35498759150505066,
0.21347825229167938,
0.14613497257232666,
-0.869392991065979,
-0.24794359505176544,
-0.192315936088562,
-0.5591437220573425,
0.05829910188913345,
-0.5882763266563416,
-0.18739430606365204,
0.0483638234436512,
0.7133684158325195,
-0.6006752848625183,
0.3042766749858856,
0.43408429622650146,
-0.171528160572052,
0.34340789914131165,
-0.2984142005443573,
-0.35191527009010315,
-1.0585682392120361,
0.11404331028461456,
-0.0560588538646698,
-0.5078740119934082,
-0.6717103123664856,
0.21892249584197998,
0.28308555483818054,
-0.10281187295913696,
-0.46037209033966064,
0.7292330265045166,
-0.6999006867408752,
-0.08862581104040146,
-0.35451674461364746,
0.013751043938100338,
0.15262801945209503,
0.5631905198097229,
0.33492007851600647,
0.784074604511261,
0.08926030993461609,
-0.2659282088279724,
-0.06137598305940628,
0.241619274020195,
-0.3427537679672241,
0.34494850039482117,
-0.7040458917617798,
0.4116308391094208,
-0.4418206810951233,
0.6425389051437378,
-0.912079930305481,
-0.17876271903514862,
0.1530030071735382,
-0.025364873930811882,
0.4849306046962738,
0.02892397716641426,
-0.4552622437477112,
-0.5545128583908081,
-0.05611416697502136,
0.7074200510978699,
0.2500571012496948,
-0.768548846244812,
0.9681540131568909,
0.16488680243492126,
-0.11360331624746323,
-0.8048271536827087,
-0.5294365286827087,
0.08316934108734131,
-0.0268853846937418,
-0.5957444310188293,
0.4249928295612335,
-0.06540095806121826,
0.21856464445590973,
-0.4111359119415283,
-0.35458871722221375,
-0.22869186103343964,
0.020416736602783203,
0.3050070106983185,
-0.020906802266836166,
-0.010292678140103817,
0.18577902019023895,
0.059239137917757034,
-0.3419194519519806,
0.035252418369054794,
-0.3509206175804138,
0.5645796060562134,
0.037648431956768036,
-0.3829801082611084,
-0.26845064759254456,
0.5133450031280518,
0.6597281098365784,
-0.22020447254180908,
0.6381024122238159,
0.5948154330253601,
-0.1947030872106552,
-0.5201055407524109,
-0.5377634167671204,
-0.26191455125808716,
-0.5279917120933533,
0.5123974084854126,
-0.532817006111145,
-1.0806043148040771,
0.5189835429191589,
-0.03248744457960129,
0.06323808431625366,
0.18679143488407135,
0.511299729347229,
-0.39786404371261597,
0.5772977471351624,
0.9290489554405212,
-0.3169635534286499,
0.6789326667785645,
-0.010218091309070587,
0.37435922026634216,
-0.7534661889076233,
-0.08056675642728806,
-0.4634547531604767,
-0.4846700429916382,
-0.09703318029642105,
-0.5213599801063538,
0.20086435973644257,
-0.06283789873123169,
-0.06416486948728561,
0.3797909617424011,
-0.3660709261894226,
0.8388938307762146,
0.5816668272018433,
0.2070181667804718,
0.556099534034729,
0.08466136455535889,
-0.16758516430854797,
-0.030547384172677994,
-0.46299439668655396,
-0.1036180928349495,
1.0578439235687256,
0.5783443450927734,
0.9209660291671753,
-0.26023295521736145,
0.8384432792663574,
0.183768168091774,
0.39402052760124207,
-1.0692317485809326,
0.29170775413513184,
0.22875116765499115,
-0.5814366936683655,
-0.7670558094978333,
-0.31011664867401123,
-0.9335986971855164,
0.2787775695323944,
0.22247572243213654,
-0.7043209075927734,
0.3045904338359833,
0.06043393537402153,
-0.2900068461894989,
0.25663426518440247,
-0.6175428628921509,
0.7332783341407776,
-0.19049274921417236,
-0.158164381980896,
-0.20825137197971344,
-0.9737443923950195,
0.2323235422372818,
-0.5387669801712036,
0.3276490867137909,
0.26868802309036255,
0.041997358202934265,
0.5115220546722412,
-0.2640154957771301,
0.8693587779998779,
0.07243993133306503,
-0.3056279718875885,
0.22348245978355408,
-0.20962199568748474,
0.8328371644020081,
0.1139511913061142,
0.1498386412858963,
0.23599493503570557,
-0.056290242820978165,
-0.38491833209991455,
-0.5731393098831177,
0.2985202372074127,
-0.9266045689582825,
-0.5206950902938843,
-0.6298901438713074,
-0.7406353950500488,
-0.09796634316444397,
0.5331129431724548,
0.3377067744731903,
0.3558780550956726,
-0.1561589390039444,
0.3121184706687927,
0.682699978351593,
-0.013252358883619308,
0.5150678753852844,
0.48500868678092957,
0.07090066373348236,
-0.007614028640091419,
0.7603162527084351,
0.029260938987135887,
0.2648039758205414,
0.8050259947776794,
0.10056377947330475,
-0.5648043155670166,
-0.5959435701370239,
-0.24292849004268646,
0.30741703510284424,
-0.6491149663925171,
0.10176794230937958,
-0.9469821453094482,
-0.21985244750976562,
-0.09927543997764587,
-0.19077058136463165,
-0.33386901021003723,
-0.14064061641693115,
-0.3978525698184967,
-0.0882296934723854,
0.05686712637543678,
0.46436765789985657,
0.11549828201532364,
0.7516162991523743,
-0.8667832016944885,
0.6764089465141296,
0.236512690782547,
0.618940532207489,
0.22029854357242584,
-0.5979586243629456,
-0.43349888920783997,
-0.19648176431655884,
-0.3647163212299347,
-0.5216498970985413,
0.3484118580818176,
0.11591183394193649,
0.17330437898635864,
0.29496443271636963,
-0.0018563981866464019,
0.6440549492835999,
-0.9857116341590881,
0.3581424951553345,
0.037082239985466,
-0.8954694867134094,
0.2157672494649887,
-0.4003797769546509,
0.5107417106628418,
0.6901445984840393,
0.3568039834499359,
-0.6026960015296936,
-0.28770217299461365,
-0.2494853436946869,
-1.0470056533813477,
0.7509384155273438,
0.17165642976760864,
0.22029049694538116,
-0.1276504397392273,
0.31525787711143494,
0.021933771669864655,
0.030086228623986244,
-0.7181349396705627,
-0.043610524386167526,
-0.10745255649089813,
-0.29167744517326355,
-0.29588258266448975,
-0.40313637256622314,
-0.05526023730635643,
-0.18642738461494446,
0.272097110748291,
-0.18661591410636902,
0.39058032631874084,
0.3330762982368469,
-0.6131430864334106,
-0.06847327202558517,
0.5067411661148071,
0.810528576374054,
0.6566122174263,
-0.31449103355407715,
0.02529510110616684,
0.14094315469264984,
-0.9183796048164368,
0.2606428563594818,
0.09265774488449097,
-0.029375212267041206,
-0.15674331784248352,
0.20776692032814026,
0.619834303855896,
0.5282872319221497,
-0.55665522813797,
0.4611012041568756,
-0.3132168650627136,
0.00994050595909357,
-0.5961267352104187,
-0.17868565022945404,
0.12234409153461456,
0.18090610206127167,
0.8019164204597473,
-0.09118828177452087,
-0.09178419411182404,
-0.13654012978076935,
0.4228285849094391,
0.11388793587684631,
-0.4126468300819397,
-0.22947344183921814,
0.6489402651786804,
0.17215436697006226,
-0.24952076375484467,
0.7294199466705322,
0.2169058471918106,
-0.129562646150589,
0.5752252340316772,
0.7083593606948853,
0.9629168510437012,
0.06373409181833267,
-0.09500405937433243,
0.024728897958993912,
0.3267512023448944,
-0.19413451850414276,
-0.14125190675258636,
-0.377104789018631,
-0.5555985569953918,
-0.6970576047897339,
-0.8843164443969727,
-0.46228501200675964,
0.1361760050058365,
-0.6460506916046143,
0.29848513007164,
-0.29111409187316895,
0.041825223714113235,
-0.06007859855890274,
-0.3102811276912689,
-0.9315982460975647,
0.29617342352867126,
0.06035863980650902,
1.0152668952941895,
-0.42222797870635986,
0.8915520310401917,
-0.033463846892118454,
-0.005286449566483498,
-0.6385276317596436,
0.2009740173816681,
-0.35709795355796814,
-0.7551870346069336,
0.6334688663482666,
0.40768277645111084,
-0.07019861042499542,
0.4510536193847656,
-0.3863552212715149,
-0.9308598637580872,
1.0805811882019043,
0.05762369558215141,
-1.067765712738037,
-0.5438823699951172,
0.3380480110645294,
0.3893308639526367,
-0.025560006499290466,
0.4032840430736542,
0.5652853846549988,
0.4069989323616028,
-0.02290460467338562,
-0.47876274585723877,
-0.05700661242008209,
0.11776400357484818,
-0.20298191905021667,
0.26862645149230957,
-0.6777489185333252,
0.3708829879760742,
-0.285651832818985,
-0.25334852933883667,
-0.020224593579769135,
1.223787784576416,
-0.0018836780218407512,
0.22196686267852783,
0.6838312149047852,
0.6922052502632141,
0.6505888104438782,
0.29226258397102356,
1.3085161447525024,
-0.3644505739212036,
0.557660698890686,
1.558040976524353,
-0.2181457132101059,
0.8532782196998596,
0.683113694190979,
-0.06337948143482208,
0.20905765891075134,
0.3571794033050537,
0.06264769285917282,
0.5468416213989258,
0.14459644258022308,
-0.41001519560813904,
-0.2762443423271179,
0.23863306641578674,
-0.15186209976673126,
0.44272273778915405,
0.22515206038951874,
-0.5712640881538391,
-0.3239672780036926,
0.11910616606473923,
-0.20519325137138367,
-0.361017107963562,
-0.08750928938388824,
0.5290055871009827,
0.4669342637062073,
-0.6119021773338318,
0.4171712398529053,
-0.0010967710986733437,
0.6699368953704834,
-0.6945667266845703,
0.3263799250125885,
-0.028366882354021072,
0.1650707721710205,
0.07450559735298157,
-0.7629358172416687,
0.3485197424888611,
0.017699474468827248,
-0.47943124175071716,
-0.41311880946159363,
0.5367664694786072,
-0.15687821805477142,
-0.5581222772598267,
0.24647006392478943,
0.3874252736568451,
-0.05205756053328514,
-0.11218178272247314,
-0.3093847334384918,
-0.10933201760053635,
-0.34897539019584656,
-0.736379086971283,
0.5674819350242615,
0.42350369691848755,
-0.05033126100897789,
0.6867534518241882,
0.7690710425376892,
-0.2653302848339081,
-0.019553957507014275,
0.2640661895275116,
0.7285892367362976,
-0.729758620262146,
-0.6043996214866638,
-0.9673477411270142,
0.34389665722846985,
0.15775829553604126,
-0.3861013650894165,
0.5617325305938721,
0.42242974042892456,
0.805064857006073,
-0.06626246869564056,
0.6577399969100952,
0.24615991115570068,
0.22571763396263123,
-0.2879629135131836,
0.7758463025093079,
-0.4254258871078491,
-0.0434870719909668,
-0.18799588084220886,
-0.9397915005683899,
-0.36731886863708496,
0.5185269117355347,
-0.41734766960144043,
-0.17425450682640076,
0.7645232677459717,
0.48841312527656555,
-0.5034306049346924,
0.11136002093553543,
0.3712608516216278,
0.40659570693969727,
0.4871363937854767,
0.5703912973403931,
0.6236116886138916,
-0.25972115993499756,
0.6168059706687927,
-0.08980539441108704,
-0.2337677776813507,
-0.15202224254608154,
-1.068342685699463,
-1.0599300861358643,
-0.41292673349380493,
0.43684956431388855,
-0.11760464310646057,
-0.0177829097956419,
0.90373295545578,
0.5203254818916321,
-0.5524865388870239,
0.0026871557347476482,
-0.21312031149864197,
0.17847785353660583,
0.01856224052608013,
-0.17033705115318298,
0.45190513134002686,
-0.5039258003234863,
-0.8360705971717834,
0.4118584096431732,
0.33292335271835327,
-0.03634852170944214,
-0.2570914030075073,
0.2687593102455139,
0.1270395964384079,
0.06156405806541443,
0.7705641388893127,
0.452452152967453,
-0.4773975908756256,
-0.40318456292152405,
0.3070085942745209,
-0.1990954875946045,
0.25129908323287964,
0.8378998637199402,
-0.7363052368164062,
0.4472975730895996,
0.5446556806564331,
0.9360753893852234,
0.8735798001289368,
0.21725043654441833,
0.5747905969619751,
-0.6930372714996338,
0.24866360425949097,
0.28338438272476196,
0.31755387783050537,
-0.09276805073022842,
-0.5963818430900574,
0.210904061794281,
0.04812173172831535,
-0.7324264645576477,
-0.7846804857254028,
0.323921263217926,
-1.1962217092514038,
-0.06304056197404861,
0.961376428604126,
0.01493161078542471,
-0.6793216466903687,
-0.14942608773708344,
-0.17645950615406036,
0.18172599375247955,
-0.3902972638607025,
0.8726848363876343,
0.7718652486801147,
0.08865918964147568,
-0.21120446920394897,
-0.5827817320823669,
0.22485141456127167,
0.4845826327800751,
-0.6657395362854004,
0.13550640642642975,
0.20810213685035706,
0.27511128783226013,
0.0902705043554306,
0.7273051142692566,
0.022221926599740982,
-0.015219466760754585,
-0.4371563792228699,
-0.2390274703502655,
-0.17289677262306213,
-0.8364574313163757,
-0.48460060358047485,
0.20928896963596344,
-0.21854248642921448,
0.23603114485740662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13209v1
|
Investigating Symbolic Capabilities of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-21T21:24:34 | 2024-05-21T21:24:34 |
Neisarg Dave, Daniel Kifer, C. Lee Giles, Ankur Mali
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Prompting techniques have significantly enhanced the capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs) across various complex tasks, including reasoning,
planning, and solving math word problems. However, most research has
predominantly focused on language-based reasoning and word problems, often
overlooking the potential of LLMs in handling symbol-based calculations and
reasoning. This study aims to bridge this gap by rigorously evaluating LLMs on
a series of symbolic tasks, such as addition, multiplication, modulus
arithmetic, numerical precision, and symbolic counting. Our analysis
encompasses eight LLMs, including four enterprise-grade and four open-source
models, of which three have been pre-trained on mathematical tasks. The
assessment framework is anchored in Chomsky's Hierarchy, providing a robust
measure of the computational abilities of these models. The evaluation employs
minimally explained prompts alongside the zero-shot Chain of Thoughts
technique, allowing models to navigate the solution process autonomously. The
findings reveal a significant decline in LLMs' performance on context-free and
context-sensitive symbolic tasks as the complexity, represented by the number
of symbols, increases. Notably, even the fine-tuned GPT3.5 exhibits only
marginal improvements, mirroring the performance trends observed in other
models. Across the board, all models demonstrated a limited generalization
ability on these symbol-intensive tasks. This research underscores LLMs'
challenges with increasing symbolic complexity and highlights the need for
specialized training, memory and architectural adjustments to enhance their
proficiency in symbol-based reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.3424120545387268,
-0.946369469165802,
0.8753819465637207,
0.4300149381160736,
-0.22061961889266968,
0.05578875541687012,
-0.3004045784473419,
-0.39695537090301514,
-0.1683163195848465,
0.2806098759174347,
-0.6190078854560852,
-0.4249652028083801,
-0.7593105435371399,
0.496141254901886,
-0.2513008415699005,
0.6627034544944763,
-0.15561418235301971,
0.11899304389953613,
-0.11405397206544876,
-0.05080121383070946,
-0.7868532538414001,
-0.6461877822875977,
-0.5422418117523193,
-0.24159309267997742,
0.4704663157463074,
-0.0018752975156530738,
0.7219898104667664,
0.5246454477310181,
0.4151029586791992,
0.33869636058807373,
-0.20115049183368683,
0.041397564113140106,
-0.3986665606498718,
0.2209675908088684,
0.00020493846386671066,
-0.49644121527671814,
-0.5958378314971924,
-0.057198673486709595,
0.7881021499633789,
0.772515594959259,
0.08488339185714722,
0.2761662006378174,
0.08449403196573257,
0.6227720975875854,
-0.5399284958839417,
0.602917492389679,
-0.6862698197364807,
-0.10105953365564346,
-0.05133020132780075,
-0.07360038161277771,
-0.4373502731323242,
-0.2341824471950531,
0.052461907267570496,
-0.7800609469413757,
-0.15907177329063416,
-0.0682373046875,
0.47874119877815247,
0.24219517409801483,
-0.34378165006637573,
-0.4180029034614563,
-0.6034457087516785,
1.0501242876052856,
-0.5790256261825562,
0.36692216992378235,
0.38977864384651184,
0.20188386738300323,
-0.14689739048480988,
-0.41016000509262085,
-0.3860970437526703,
-0.5898231267929077,
0.17208603024482727,
-0.13372577726840973,
-0.5355948209762573,
0.06955752521753311,
0.8465440273284912,
0.06428758800029755,
-0.5156927108764648,
0.0354921780526638,
-0.3495665490627289,
-0.06231434643268585,
0.4397486448287964,
0.38219571113586426,
0.3651321232318878,
-0.11093289405107498,
-0.024644974619150162,
-0.15945500135421753,
-0.8034928441047668,
-0.0924706682562828,
0.22027315199375153,
0.3683375120162964,
-0.18807539343833923,
0.6628470420837402,
-0.2630865275859833,
0.8084852695465088,
-0.21162104606628418,
0.09851408004760742,
-0.0867045447230339,
-0.25866469740867615,
-0.42044544219970703,
-0.06933610886335373,
0.6846402883529663,
-0.07371388375759125,
0.6089248061180115,
0.14013034105300903,
-0.34568503499031067,
0.2902761697769165,
0.1846214085817337,
-0.7059019804000854,
-0.11948521435260773,
0.08023279160261154,
-0.061799004673957825,
-0.02479487657546997,
-0.198626309633255,
-0.11296436190605164,
-0.40829768776893616,
-0.45806482434272766,
0.5568962693214417,
-0.563085675239563,
-0.09415270388126373,
0.3591008186340332,
-0.10095421969890594,
-0.05978510528802872,
0.6103819608688354,
-0.7185550332069397,
0.17373520135879517,
0.9221007227897644,
0.8825911283493042,
0.2304372936487198,
-0.2013365775346756,
-0.5317388772964478,
0.10033021867275238,
-0.6115338802337646,
0.522075355052948,
-0.7114565372467041,
-0.4446244239807129,
-0.07674535363912582,
-0.12553530931472778,
-0.1187133640050888,
-0.5332117676734924,
0.44846266508102417,
-0.4663022458553314,
-0.14638778567314148,
-0.829121470451355,
-0.39414042234420776,
-0.3169296681880951,
0.4470338821411133,
-0.8137933611869812,
0.9703050255775452,
0.04843863099813461,
-0.5812963843345642,
0.09108276665210724,
-0.7179423570632935,
-0.29243987798690796,
0.21347491443157196,
-0.4083651900291443,
0.04377589374780655,
0.4568980932235718,
0.3144418001174927,
0.5685241222381592,
-0.5743713974952698,
0.28003567457199097,
-0.3602524399757385,
-0.5105027556419373,
0.38163110613822937,
-0.3578011691570282,
0.9074114561080933,
-0.030959101393818855,
-0.3612367808818817,
0.3367565870285034,
-0.46537864208221436,
-0.0714341476559639,
0.31729134917259216,
-0.048676975071430206,
-0.5225116610527039,
-0.11901865154504776,
-0.3615858256816864,
0.3592786490917206,
0.12218594551086426,
-0.1490253359079361,
0.3684060871601105,
-0.38339531421661377,
0.3589426279067993,
0.9652501344680786,
-0.22906774282455444,
0.1485554426908493,
-0.3549779951572418,
0.7987446784973145,
-0.16401176154613495,
-0.027872221544384956,
-0.25856563448905945,
-0.5011547207832336,
-0.8757544755935669,
-0.2689523994922638,
-0.07178172469139099,
0.4291110634803772,
-0.885466456413269,
0.25243058800697327,
-0.45195549726486206,
-0.4292845129966736,
-0.15685193240642548,
0.20970419049263,
0.4543231129646301,
0.2856001853942871,
0.2635743319988251,
-0.03962516412138939,
-0.3235396444797516,
-0.7966791987419128,
-0.33223801851272583,
-0.3837631642818451,
-0.1777203530073166,
0.042360443621873856,
0.7962232232093811,
0.11444682627916336,
0.5139632821083069,
-0.2814609706401825,
0.029495442286133766,
-0.279887855052948,
0.2883797287940979,
0.24454869329929352,
0.062188923358917236,
0.23424749076366425,
-0.25316309928894043,
-0.24386797845363617,
-0.028775624930858612,
-0.8333282470703125,
-0.2846173644065857,
-0.21406374871730804,
0.10863570123910904,
0.3242168724536896,
0.35913780331611633,
-0.8551824688911438,
0.07997037470340729,
0.4743761718273163,
-0.32188233733177185,
0.8952851295471191,
-0.004701149649918079,
0.07186371833086014,
-0.7119898796081543,
0.1580011248588562,
0.006819257512688637,
0.1676790863275528,
-0.6894344091415405,
0.0800745040178299,
0.2055588811635971,
-0.037256672978401184,
-0.3652854561805725,
0.727043628692627,
-0.7830526232719421,
-0.16921918094158173,
-0.12437520176172256,
0.09965887665748596,
-0.3244718015193939,
0.32619932293891907,
0.013067299500107765,
0.7925407290458679,
0.6685165166854858,
-0.6264578104019165,
0.21550120413303375,
-0.15556444227695465,
-0.34499111771583557,
0.5666145086288452,
-0.8404211401939392,
0.15994222462177277,
0.11214318871498108,
0.06685933470726013,
-0.9440961480140686,
-0.04476092755794525,
0.1147356703877449,
-0.17780578136444092,
0.07092532515525818,
0.1267266869544983,
-0.9434722065925598,
-0.36236804723739624,
-0.36586156487464905,
0.525355339050293,
0.5202391147613525,
-0.2166285365819931,
0.5810253620147705,
-0.0008537500398233533,
-0.2812819182872772,
-0.36266472935676575,
-0.3712230622768402,
0.15548239648342133,
-0.12470785528421402,
-0.6629626154899597,
-0.14334286749362946,
0.013422301970422268,
-0.5075891017913818,
-0.1982540339231491,
-0.2583834230899811,
0.2641295790672302,
0.2114376723766327,
0.17856676876544952,
0.4734025001525879,
-0.12199968844652176,
0.2140102982521057,
-0.05542408674955368,
-0.06455361098051071,
0.4711684584617615,
-0.18424314260482788,
0.593643069267273,
-0.4626392126083374,
-0.616400420665741,
-0.28066176176071167,
0.08274360001087189,
0.7512681484222412,
-0.24011529982089996,
0.4948346018791199,
0.38329488039016724,
-0.436611145734787,
-0.3418152332305908,
-0.5274608731269836,
-0.2851489782333374,
-0.4832019507884979,
0.5188772678375244,
-0.495362251996994,
-1.1337555646896362,
0.5085970759391785,
0.07040414214134216,
0.23781755566596985,
0.447356253862381,
0.6877521872520447,
0.25744348764419556,
1.2235361337661743,
0.3334486186504364,
0.048177022486925125,
0.22321511805057526,
-0.20267663896083832,
0.19094422459602356,
-0.7726112008094788,
-0.19540995359420776,
-0.49159881472587585,
-0.12877672910690308,
-0.2948909401893616,
-0.705037534236908,
0.4914902150630951,
0.1463293582201004,
-0.47790321707725525,
0.23143994808197021,
-0.4016804099082947,
0.3663623034954071,
0.2268713414669037,
-0.22207242250442505,
0.4273250102996826,
0.06588206440210342,
-0.11379628628492355,
0.0935279130935669,
-0.6276171207427979,
-0.5323317050933838,
0.8859090209007263,
0.39615610241889954,
0.8343837857246399,
-0.02432766929268837,
0.2425317019224167,
-0.0018721561646088958,
0.33263927698135376,
-0.9423552751541138,
1.043782353401184,
0.06501168012619019,
-0.40878093242645264,
-0.4057142436504364,
-0.536990761756897,
-0.8798544406890869,
0.2632821798324585,
0.027401698753237724,
-0.7058180570602417,
-0.2669820487499237,
0.10963719338178635,
-0.2667559087276459,
0.16299064457416534,
-0.40096041560173035,
0.6202942132949829,
-0.34922006726264954,
-0.08341454714536667,
-0.45436370372772217,
-0.32828763127326965,
0.5451380014419556,
-0.24210569262504578,
0.21351005136966705,
-0.1999397575855255,
-0.2917686700820923,
0.7663323879241943,
-0.188110813498497,
0.9472944736480713,
0.12161397933959961,
-0.5373631715774536,
0.10003329068422318,
0.5357517004013062,
0.6083526611328125,
-0.2707289159297943,
0.011514002457261086,
0.3779503107070923,
0.003994151018559933,
-0.3300460875034332,
-0.7867365479469299,
0.6943434476852417,
-0.4994731843471527,
-0.9059910774230957,
-0.5385841727256775,
-0.8599935173988342,
-0.4223226308822632,
0.08447626233100891,
-0.22961711883544922,
0.28322333097457886,
-0.050320811569690704,
0.13850431144237518,
0.5457242727279663,
-0.3006170988082886,
0.417481005191803,
0.35610705614089966,
-0.19808639585971832,
-0.31089723110198975,
0.6604813933372498,
0.28720909357070923,
0.4649565517902374,
0.06444957852363586,
0.23049892485141754,
-0.3785741627216339,
-0.2352023720741272,
-0.5181645750999451,
0.544127345085144,
-0.7711940407752991,
0.03503505140542984,
-0.48376259207725525,
-0.01423210185021162,
-0.27516719698905945,
-0.19051046669483185,
-0.08887086063623428,
-0.48809608817100525,
-0.21087227761745453,
0.010527142323553562,
0.3259921073913574,
0.8176857233047485,
0.36552393436431885,
0.11148815602064133,
-0.706759512424469,
0.12296007573604584,
0.2920185923576355,
0.19105680286884308,
0.35587024688720703,
-0.44513964653015137,
-0.170220747590065,
-0.06356339901685715,
-0.300152063369751,
-1.0271031856536865,
0.2169037163257599,
-0.2099134922027588,
0.44798412919044495,
0.37919607758522034,
-0.10095826536417007,
0.853317379951477,
-0.35225269198417664,
0.797298789024353,
0.26769912242889404,
-1.1876615285873413,
0.40548428893089294,
-0.5731502175331116,
0.6978223919868469,
-0.03557531535625458,
0.4437013268470764,
-0.498076468706131,
-0.42710813879966736,
-0.44391414523124695,
-0.44753485918045044,
0.6777960658073425,
0.3256981670856476,
0.18802186846733093,
-0.20109477639198303,
0.16834807395935059,
-0.2896835207939148,
0.1344318836927414,
-0.5084312558174133,
-0.0012286208802834153,
0.20084434747695923,
0.0375378280878067,
0.049445636570453644,
-0.1749444603919983,
-0.12517917156219482,
-0.3289340138435364,
0.511469304561615,
-0.1306619644165039,
0.09323855489492416,
-0.11598862707614899,
-0.06042484939098358,
-0.07991363108158112,
0.45474523305892944,
0.6972958445549011,
0.7967728972434998,
0.22906538844108582,
0.2193133682012558,
0.49304431676864624,
-0.3496209383010864,
0.0862707793712616,
-0.00771185290068388,
0.006953442469239235,
-0.08267973363399506,
0.5254590511322021,
0.8164415955543518,
0.2985254228115082,
-0.8632182478904724,
0.19981959462165833,
0.10441819578409195,
-0.25249892473220825,
-0.12644654512405396,
0.0790608674287796,
0.28894898295402527,
0.15625348687171936,
0.3295341432094574,
-0.29392510652542114,
0.049171917140483856,
-0.5131755471229553,
-0.20042437314987183,
0.7517484426498413,
-0.21758580207824707,
-0.48895347118377686,
0.3136688470840454,
-0.13795314729213715,
-0.14809386432170868,
0.6480808258056641,
-0.0742262676358223,
-0.531391441822052,
0.6848469376564026,
0.6648980379104614,
0.9320526123046875,
-0.30699560046195984,
0.1335366666316986,
0.2970118224620819,
0.602192223072052,
-0.2923124134540558,
0.517590343952179,
-0.14680907130241394,
-0.37411224842071533,
-0.6645670533180237,
-0.5275585651397705,
-0.24406304955482483,
0.2451886534690857,
-0.38829100131988525,
0.2686363160610199,
-0.6017525792121887,
-0.3048354685306549,
-0.20735609531402588,
0.07883398979902267,
-0.5664236545562744,
-0.03723864629864693,
0.03799227252602577,
0.8083525896072388,
-0.8367434740066528,
0.5642628073692322,
0.7614498138427734,
-0.18223027884960175,
-1.011688232421875,
-0.2955431044101715,
0.18409879505634308,
-0.7778468132019043,
0.9469574093818665,
0.35296279191970825,
-0.29504838585853577,
-0.10166382789611816,
-0.35552680492401123,
-0.6734402775764465,
0.8905007839202881,
0.7542389631271362,
-0.5378795862197876,
-0.11587391793727875,
0.35371217131614685,
0.6227361559867859,
-0.005340528674423695,
0.2903936207294464,
0.3999830186367035,
0.5703828930854797,
0.1739090532064438,
-1.1902683973312378,
0.47015970945358276,
-0.2778526842594147,
0.25060391426086426,
0.3646698594093323,
-0.31938475370407104,
0.968953013420105,
-0.20002242922782898,
-0.38140925765037537,
0.04609543830156326,
0.49943679571151733,
0.7072651386260986,
0.018311424180865288,
0.5496242642402649,
0.4886031746864319,
0.6731758713722229,
-0.07158643752336502,
1.1605855226516724,
-0.3589012920856476,
0.1165546327829361,
0.6909670233726501,
-0.23003628849983215,
0.7166319489479065,
0.5023530125617981,
-0.10517559945583344,
0.2836039662361145,
0.3467543125152588,
-0.006352007854729891,
-0.1609828919172287,
0.49437862634658813,
-0.41497620940208435,
-0.4863918721675873,
-0.1865387260913849,
-0.334892213344574,
0.11001885682344437,
0.5109466910362244,
-0.2859205901622772,
-0.3316453695297241,
-0.23932674527168274,
0.1363658756017685,
-0.24090780317783356,
-0.3869110643863678,
0.4615151584148407,
0.365060955286026,
-0.6721752882003784,
0.7865208983421326,
-0.031551606953144073,
0.3492911159992218,
-0.6968702077865601,
-0.21225027740001678,
0.03344987332820892,
0.0000912497125682421,
0.1017996072769165,
-0.7040280699729919,
0.2275419384241104,
0.07160817086696625,
0.1762634813785553,
-0.24825948476791382,
0.5314992666244507,
-0.09690145403146744,
-0.7194810509681702,
0.2164996713399887,
0.7071977853775024,
0.13131606578826904,
-0.370792031288147,
-0.6977357268333435,
0.4891892075538635,
-0.3161909282207489,
-0.26488205790519714,
0.31054365634918213,
0.5793709754943848,
-0.5954188108444214,
0.8503046035766602,
0.8048344850540161,
0.16730336844921112,
-0.07472283393144608,
0.21686206758022308,
0.7960227131843567,
-0.6478114724159241,
-0.41258060932159424,
-1.2753899097442627,
0.1862591654062271,
0.1573786586523056,
-0.20316748321056366,
0.9899927973747253,
0.3363005220890045,
0.7946503758430481,
-0.2654394209384918,
0.6049942374229431,
0.2086016684770584,
-0.17702747881412506,
-0.55916428565979,
0.5180962085723877,
-0.5035603642463684,
0.43811580538749695,
-0.5073665380477905,
-0.8542651534080505,
-0.4424291253089905,
0.6170469522476196,
-0.6449096202850342,
0.2587857246398926,
0.7225603461265564,
0.8123399019241333,
0.11176041513681412,
0.051751747727394104,
0.5076743960380554,
0.2659794092178345,
0.29549428820610046,
0.7420361638069153,
1.1047672033309937,
0.0035713750403374434,
0.39522936940193176,
-0.010207075625658035,
-0.1961275339126587,
0.015832675620913506,
-0.8852664828300476,
-1.2109580039978027,
-0.5464219450950623,
-0.15249912440776825,
-0.13503298163414001,
0.06145382672548294,
0.8621842861175537,
0.5242847800254822,
-0.5265032649040222,
-0.5081788301467896,
-0.11944595724344254,
-0.05047672241926193,
-0.21423256397247314,
-0.18297439813613892,
0.4235072433948517,
-0.32566002011299133,
-0.5733001232147217,
0.2586189806461334,
0.4857589304447174,
-0.009740768000483513,
-0.4541081488132477,
-0.032102953642606735,
0.1185184121131897,
0.26571497321128845,
0.886376142501831,
0.1348693072795868,
-1.0873851776123047,
-0.1647680103778839,
0.42161256074905396,
-0.03347872197628021,
-0.2981402277946472,
0.9308198094367981,
-0.6695827841758728,
0.3183416426181793,
0.6178664565086365,
0.5803057551383972,
0.05310816690325737,
-0.01796850375831127,
0.5292830467224121,
-0.3953934609889984,
-0.156706303358078,
0.2623682916164398,
0.4237171411514282,
0.2370184063911438,
-0.17005817592144012,
0.2642399072647095,
0.16616719961166382,
-0.31215837597846985,
-0.8396070003509521,
0.3011166453361511,
-0.954360842704773,
-0.35461902618408203,
1.2212132215499878,
0.000863516703248024,
-0.12301354855298996,
-0.016717271879315376,
-0.26357704401016235,
0.11567668616771698,
-0.3316963315010071,
0.8217028975486755,
0.9168208241462708,
-0.2544470429420471,
-0.18123891949653625,
-0.7297438383102417,
0.3123369812965393,
0.7567609548568726,
-0.8039870858192444,
0.3961121439933777,
0.7824360728263855,
0.12684956192970276,
0.14728571474552155,
0.5995768904685974,
-0.20332123339176178,
0.3066585958003998,
-0.1737404763698578,
-0.10455571860074997,
-0.37376856803894043,
-0.40505537390708923,
-0.6443728804588318,
0.1555638313293457,
0.16126814484596252,
0.2522159814834595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13203v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13203v1
|
Modeling Real-Time Interactive Conversations as Timed Diarized Transcripts
| 2024-05-21T21:14:31 | 2024-05-21T21:14:31 |
Garrett Tanzer, Gustaf Ahdritz, Luke Melas-Kyriazi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Chatbots built upon language models have exploded in popularity, but they
have largely been limited to synchronous, turn-by-turn dialogues. In this paper
we present a simple yet general method to simulate real-time interactive
conversations using pretrained text-only language models, by modeling timed
diarized transcripts and decoding them with causal rejection sampling. We
demonstrate the promise of this method with two case studies: instant messenger
dialogues and spoken conversations, which require generation at about 30 tok/s
and 20 tok/s respectively to maintain real-time interactivity. These
capabilities can be added into language models using relatively little data and
run on commodity hardware.
|
[
0.03452819958329201,
-1.4607713222503662,
0.727997899055481,
0.5903286933898926,
-0.24622952938079834,
0.44021233916282654,
-0.04586217924952507,
-0.6412809491157532,
0.3033744692802429,
0.7005196809768677,
-0.9525831937789917,
0.004079115577042103,
-0.11979126930236816,
-0.02507941611111164,
-0.7058423757553101,
0.7881540060043335,
0.1950044184923172,
0.07308819890022278,
0.01116171758621931,
0.2988041341304779,
-0.15111099183559418,
-0.7533900737762451,
-0.6739472150802612,
-0.3582155406475067,
0.24303148686885834,
0.38777628540992737,
0.7868980765342712,
0.44262638688087463,
0.1770532876253128,
0.2782652676105499,
-0.016335774213075638,
0.07897192984819412,
-0.5474368929862976,
0.35587775707244873,
0.35635843873023987,
-0.47876667976379395,
-0.423274964094162,
0.39717161655426025,
0.5846572518348694,
0.6770361661911011,
-0.20375673472881317,
0.09783326834440231,
-0.1289318948984146,
0.020539503544569016,
-0.355697363615036,
0.11378935724496841,
-0.5329193472862244,
0.2716185748577118,
-0.010147398337721825,
-0.42877620458602905,
-0.7955774664878845,
-0.4427146315574646,
0.27015531063079834,
-0.6324104070663452,
0.1144561618566513,
-0.12249155342578888,
0.8343740105628967,
-0.036791540682315826,
-0.3114432394504547,
-0.3679765462875366,
-1.5600522756576538,
0.6175975799560547,
-0.9423975348472595,
0.32413750886917114,
0.42134830355644226,
0.4059882164001465,
-0.17450059950351715,
-0.9751645922660828,
-0.9208493232727051,
-0.8541969656944275,
-0.2974712550640106,
0.3124009668827057,
0.16513681411743164,
0.3157438039779663,
0.32135629653930664,
0.016943324357271194,
-0.3352755606174469,
0.15277667343616486,
-0.053098734468221664,
0.019931966438889503,
0.4124847948551178,
0.5986377596855164,
0.38586315512657166,
-0.10766302794218063,
-0.13795240223407745,
-0.0941467136144638,
-0.3250962197780609,
0.05223698914051056,
0.5148290395736694,
0.09273597598075867,
-0.4322907030582428,
0.6470069885253906,
-0.29456037282943726,
0.9028086066246033,
-0.007317220326513052,
-0.15384957194328308,
-0.2227931022644043,
-0.8016404509544373,
-0.13829603791236877,
-0.16509057581424713,
0.9089556932449341,
0.18649929761886597,
0.37911319732666016,
0.02122424729168415,
0.18249021470546722,
-0.1456349641084671,
0.10050240159034729,
-1.0096287727355957,
-0.4096742868423462,
0.5315331220626831,
-0.35306763648986816,
-0.4224832057952881,
-0.14531590044498444,
-0.7492611408233643,
0.2380591630935669,
-0.25538182258605957,
0.277495414018631,
-0.25333499908447266,
-0.0937289297580719,
0.14685308933258057,
0.021954713389277458,
0.04379548877477646,
0.3890354037284851,
-0.5143100619316101,
0.3029577434062958,
0.28956013917922974,
0.816623866558075,
0.14418815076351166,
-0.14621928334236145,
-0.7779384255409241,
0.06678959727287292,
-0.2893277406692505,
0.45686280727386475,
-0.6339693069458008,
-0.7050508856773376,
-0.11650090664625168,
-0.14978404343128204,
-0.14359118044376373,
-0.06006212159991264,
0.19177770614624023,
-0.7186829447746277,
0.5608095526695251,
0.44137126207351685,
-0.4680759608745575,
0.2949677109718323,
0.18553905189037323,
-0.5059725046157837,
0.6086159348487854,
0.16981567442417145,
-0.7328705191612244,
-0.05076020583510399,
-0.6830883026123047,
-0.45938384532928467,
0.05019375681877136,
0.09939644485712051,
-0.46306970715522766,
-0.36902716755867004,
0.057309698313474655,
0.3852212131023407,
-0.1415369063615799,
0.6925570964813232,
-0.3078778088092804,
-0.43258926272392273,
0.4858691990375519,
-0.8342679738998413,
0.7889402508735657,
0.513028085231781,
-0.38057389855384827,
-0.06430158019065857,
-0.9482877850532532,
0.20508147776126862,
0.10139420628547668,
-0.25971177220344543,
-0.14977191388607025,
0.3353084325790405,
0.0060619632713496685,
0.25566643476486206,
-0.07890966534614563,
-0.7782022356987,
0.1408156454563141,
-0.5780689716339111,
0.49732452630996704,
0.2948809564113617,
0.11168445646762848,
0.4733569324016571,
-0.24470339715480804,
0.6084500551223755,
0.18788893520832062,
0.3539448380470276,
-0.5022919774055481,
-0.26557809114456177,
-0.9210536479949951,
-0.2400023192167282,
0.27993130683898926,
0.9755797386169434,
-0.9820258617401123,
0.41643205285072327,
-0.43911564350128174,
-0.6756202578544617,
-0.5879278779029846,
-0.3069383203983307,
0.6046303510665894,
0.4070129096508026,
0.09195934236049652,
-0.3601721525192261,
-0.28205883502960205,
-0.535545825958252,
-0.21429838240146637,
-0.5841881632804871,
-0.4570884704589844,
0.4874182641506195,
0.0263652540743351,
-0.11732160300016403,
1.1934609413146973,
-0.39629095792770386,
0.14261281490325928,
-0.22469167411327362,
0.570434033870697,
-0.08207755535840988,
0.37123772501945496,
0.4802953004837036,
-0.5816138982772827,
-0.48221683502197266,
-0.4847443699836731,
-0.5018721222877502,
-0.3470976650714874,
-0.5622216463088989,
0.07137639075517654,
-0.02091919258236885,
0.9535403251647949,
-0.4938395619392395,
0.7181205749511719,
0.7439000010490417,
-0.32881245017051697,
0.7319136261940002,
0.005433421116322279,
0.42223668098449707,
-0.9287089109420776,
0.047633953392505646,
-0.4854869544506073,
-0.42586979269981384,
-0.9500199556350708,
-0.47467416524887085,
-0.19369034469127655,
-0.38854584097862244,
-0.9787581562995911,
0.9866766333580017,
-0.49291566014289856,
0.18205143511295319,
-0.1328151524066925,
0.25558358430862427,
-0.11550431698560715,
0.48432138562202454,
0.4126739799976349,
0.7110676169395447,
0.11744613945484161,
-1.0538653135299683,
0.297630250453949,
0.4346921741962433,
-0.4698503613471985,
0.2680215835571289,
-0.9888721704483032,
-0.01849663443863392,
-0.14579930901527405,
0.6372035145759583,
-0.958280622959137,
-0.3742520809173584,
0.21536625921726227,
-0.40015870332717896,
-0.011517108418047428,
-0.28717145323753357,
-0.4843009412288666,
-0.408838152885437,
0.07228081673383713,
0.7051427960395813,
0.4981759190559387,
-0.41139402985572815,
0.4661678671836853,
0.1702331304550171,
-0.3612423241138458,
-0.17452983558177948,
-0.40161779522895813,
-0.022444047033786774,
0.07755695283412933,
-0.3029935956001282,
0.3906286060810089,
-0.5341579914093018,
-0.31358638405799866,
-0.31724247336387634,
0.6041857600212097,
-0.03854956850409508,
0.1195993646979332,
0.4717978835105896,
0.20134150981903076,
0.2978346049785614,
-0.22322233021259308,
-0.08010692894458771,
-0.03193245083093643,
-0.2558406889438629,
0.0944581851363182,
0.7885074615478516,
0.5420995354652405,
-0.887195348739624,
-0.8497845530509949,
0.44579169154167175,
0.583318293094635,
-0.041436128318309784,
0.6456522941589355,
0.5834184288978577,
0.06479284912347794,
0.18592005968093872,
-0.3953827917575836,
-0.763593316078186,
-0.45126545429229736,
0.165122851729393,
-0.32686689496040344,
-0.8660231232643127,
0.5956664085388184,
0.13244183361530304,
0.5305436253547668,
-0.19021543860435486,
0.6510502099990845,
-0.03437437862157822,
1.1896491050720215,
0.38717329502105713,
0.1913398653268814,
1.026119351387024,
0.17532381415367126,
0.5809520483016968,
-0.242906391620636,
-0.2763213813304901,
-0.4640437960624695,
-0.091606505215168,
-0.4069076478481293,
-0.3062087595462799,
0.3957666754722595,
0.07557607442140579,
-0.14996744692325592,
0.2560443580150604,
-0.07690328359603882,
0.35011398792266846,
0.7887329459190369,
0.07317916303873062,
0.24478866159915924,
-0.183492511510849,
-0.11006134003400803,
-0.12473607063293457,
-0.7806212306022644,
-0.3652958571910858,
0.5885552763938904,
0.290115088224411,
0.9481965899467468,
-0.4539344906806946,
0.23959779739379883,
0.24626849591732025,
0.2839632034301758,
-0.6391116380691528,
0.7257081270217896,
0.37717172503471375,
-0.7486187815666199,
-0.18480344116687775,
-0.58588045835495,
-0.7519280314445496,
-0.08360045403242111,
-0.29642391204833984,
-0.7068326473236084,
-0.2602097988128662,
0.2491045445203781,
-0.5101545453071594,
0.42515918612480164,
-0.710077166557312,
0.5380575060844421,
-0.0912947878241539,
-0.21954114735126495,
-0.11998561769723892,
-0.9166582226753235,
0.5172404646873474,
0.04634024575352669,
0.33243536949157715,
-0.3296408951282501,
0.6763655543327332,
0.7145633101463318,
-0.4722483456134796,
1.0652072429656982,
-0.08888286352157593,
0.09106513857841492,
0.7133517861366272,
0.6741658449172974,
0.5577723979949951,
0.16780103743076324,
0.069440558552742,
-0.048681341111660004,
0.21830861270427704,
-0.4460555911064148,
-0.45087966322898865,
0.35073569416999817,
-0.6846440434455872,
-0.26225435733795166,
-0.023516502231359482,
-0.40232667326927185,
-0.15204299986362457,
-0.0015231157885864377,
0.13837961852550507,
0.5190009474754333,
-0.6073756217956543,
-0.19838395714759827,
0.16066031157970428,
-0.16826985776424408,
0.7876648306846619,
0.8971789479255676,
-0.28208309412002563,
-0.09927093982696533,
0.5205646753311157,
-0.10912090539932251,
0.6291577219963074,
0.5958285331726074,
-0.1366184800863266,
-0.022158537060022354,
0.03200383856892586,
-0.43513911962509155,
0.09616074711084366,
-0.14192308485507965,
0.07098941504955292,
-1.340739130973816,
-0.5743440985679626,
-0.2899476885795593,
-0.1417190134525299,
-0.6802589893341064,
-0.6496579647064209,
-0.3570442199707031,
-0.011148467659950256,
0.41512662172317505,
0.47961074113845825,
0.007359649520367384,
0.9818574786186218,
-1.4175608158111572,
0.44767579436302185,
0.6432151794433594,
0.4131845235824585,
0.0010213955538347363,
-0.5786259770393372,
-0.1569538414478302,
0.434958279132843,
-0.07863866537809372,
-0.7305444478988647,
0.5895335674285889,
0.30036410689353943,
0.2786696255207062,
0.36005330085754395,
0.264277845621109,
0.643843412399292,
-0.7203719615936279,
1.0229520797729492,
-0.05859426409006119,
-0.853243887424469,
0.4951938986778259,
-0.1378241777420044,
0.292164146900177,
0.30309924483299255,
0.3014737069606781,
-0.723006010055542,
-0.818661630153656,
-0.6686624884605408,
-0.6290856003761292,
0.8501966595649719,
0.49959513545036316,
0.3927929997444153,
-0.2715286910533905,
0.2081746757030487,
-0.014695635065436363,
0.11620915681123734,
-0.6054306626319885,
-0.19586046040058136,
0.043339069932699203,
-0.11032872647047043,
-0.16041162610054016,
-0.5336453914642334,
0.0464300662279129,
-0.15390990674495697,
0.4476211965084076,
0.22022710740566254,
0.5959814190864563,
0.20621836185455322,
-0.0523262694478035,
0.0504746288061142,
0.22892120480537415,
0.5924726724624634,
0.2867415249347687,
-0.4068889319896698,
0.045688334852457047,
-0.13294796645641327,
-0.6576125025749207,
0.37670087814331055,
-0.12410832941532135,
-0.31174346804618835,
0.36708134412765503,
0.21200354397296906,
0.9774977564811707,
0.4705953896045685,
-0.802734375,
0.2941718101501465,
-0.4352102279663086,
-0.002152347471565008,
-0.2220301777124405,
-0.05888490751385689,
-0.05158980190753937,
0.021338097751140594,
0.023557929322123528,
-0.4028368890285492,
-0.2384805530309677,
-0.4570924937725067,
0.3406914174556732,
0.25860559940338135,
-0.6209156513214111,
-0.5696910619735718,
1.0551469326019287,
0.47253432869911194,
-0.6117891669273376,
0.966029167175293,
-0.0486680343747139,
-0.41404715180397034,
0.37074968218803406,
0.6002073287963867,
0.8320220708847046,
-0.3125671148300171,
0.4542357921600342,
0.36384516954421997,
-0.08261468261480331,
0.039717599749565125,
0.05288850516080856,
-0.18189209699630737,
-0.6975643038749695,
-0.5379975438117981,
-0.6629915833473206,
-0.8116328716278076,
0.17676562070846558,
-0.3318210542201996,
0.23596961796283722,
-0.1600799560546875,
-0.3877139389514923,
0.017806895077228546,
-0.3615236282348633,
-0.531928300857544,
0.107980877161026,
-0.2777564525604248,
0.7060638070106506,
-1.0172094106674194,
0.8355292081832886,
0.12370721250772476,
-0.09843193739652634,
-0.564998984336853,
-0.1347063034772873,
-0.30337804555892944,
-0.6950094103813171,
0.3534267246723175,
-0.17860345542430878,
-0.09329784661531448,
0.30687251687049866,
-0.7817291617393494,
-0.3437141478061676,
0.6577115654945374,
0.2044954150915146,
-0.595112144947052,
-0.3983708322048187,
0.08292828500270844,
0.5212059617042542,
-0.1270889937877655,
0.7449109554290771,
0.6084672808647156,
0.22420383989810944,
0.20841923356056213,
-1.110817790031433,
-0.4997732937335968,
-0.4102573096752167,
-0.24022965133190155,
-0.04885117709636688,
-0.5589854717254639,
0.8266807794570923,
-0.07592286914587021,
-0.41587597131729126,
0.13175459206104279,
0.6916429400444031,
0.3349762558937073,
0.2871239483356476,
0.5340504050254822,
0.116190604865551,
0.1274590790271759,
-0.011305572465062141,
0.9730638861656189,
-0.5994496941566467,
0.059396348893642426,
1.1272960901260376,
-0.26247259974479675,
0.627916693687439,
0.34963953495025635,
-0.11830238252878189,
0.31945475935935974,
0.6354289054870605,
0.5143848061561584,
0.5076208710670471,
-0.014795615337789059,
-0.563499927520752,
-0.4629061818122864,
-0.23243151605129242,
-0.048104893416166306,
0.4277813732624054,
0.4454072117805481,
0.06353283673524857,
-0.1367119699716568,
0.24018394947052002,
0.12944641709327698,
-0.014111197553575039,
0.15827398002147675,
0.8911109566688538,
0.011615591123700142,
-0.8303206562995911,
0.4089146852493286,
-0.07719557732343674,
0.5829833745956421,
-0.5753515362739563,
-0.18781433999538422,
-0.29072892665863037,
-0.12846413254737854,
0.20812934637069702,
-0.7325238585472107,
0.21445663273334503,
-0.009580017998814583,
-0.03850547969341278,
-0.4278499484062195,
0.6273353695869446,
-0.7294790744781494,
-0.39932486414909363,
0.2977689504623413,
0.7014418840408325,
0.28093868494033813,
0.03035467118024826,
-0.3755943179130554,
-0.028270244598388672,
-0.08383721113204956,
-0.4363499581813812,
0.0660872757434845,
0.11251744627952576,
-0.18772435188293457,
0.9437825679779053,
0.7257651686668396,
0.0007103171665221453,
0.2953495979309082,
0.16127489507198334,
0.6478363871574402,
-0.6273670792579651,
-0.7642410397529602,
-0.8831655979156494,
0.3681260943412781,
0.12106639891862869,
0.2256404608488083,
0.5965532660484314,
0.2942405045032501,
0.657368540763855,
-0.14448893070220947,
0.648497998714447,
-0.09795206040143967,
0.8428242802619934,
-0.4937089681625366,
0.8676266670227051,
-0.20471738278865814,
-0.036082036793231964,
-0.21340039372444153,
-0.6832268834114075,
-0.15627437829971313,
0.3129691183567047,
0.08929268270730972,
-0.018172774463891983,
0.18942789733409882,
0.545876681804657,
-0.2328137457370758,
-0.019978484138846397,
0.37365418672561646,
0.19722479581832886,
0.7213905453681946,
0.4011762738227844,
0.9299938082695007,
-0.2218070924282074,
0.5618662238121033,
-0.20567280054092407,
-0.20414234697818756,
-0.6775287389755249,
-0.8594586253166199,
-0.9417832493782043,
-0.6495795249938965,
-0.16957612335681915,
-0.4376564621925354,
0.07364007085561752,
0.8081479072570801,
0.9228004813194275,
-0.5560303926467896,
-0.16244536638259888,
-0.05538599565625191,
-0.03574833273887634,
0.004554285202175379,
-0.2567046880722046,
-0.10914573818445206,
-0.13685013353824615,
-1.0969696044921875,
0.5184763073921204,
0.12432502955198288,
0.7253319025039673,
-0.066145159304142,
0.12977856397628784,
-0.04910166934132576,
0.5904011130332947,
0.7536523938179016,
0.5156949162483215,
-0.3201647698879242,
-0.36212947964668274,
0.08819785714149475,
-0.3786979615688324,
-0.17966100573539734,
1.0021376609802246,
-1.0097261667251587,
0.6775380373001099,
0.5225873589515686,
0.013633503578603268,
0.839963972568512,
0.3337995707988739,
0.8676896095275879,
-0.8674154877662659,
0.7122128009796143,
0.4142065942287445,
-0.3671928942203522,
-0.049471426755189896,
-0.06450524926185608,
0.2541598975658417,
0.21692171692848206,
-0.5683355331420898,
-0.8969401121139526,
0.5020653009414673,
-0.7705991268157959,
0.048150792717933655,
0.8475338220596313,
-0.22045794129371643,
-0.0402025543153286,
-0.27555233240127563,
-0.32176777720451355,
0.7007819414138794,
0.023499367758631706,
0.830255389213562,
0.4013826847076416,
-0.1022903099656105,
-0.023747840896248817,
-0.6208263635635376,
0.6644732356071472,
0.16554653644561768,
-0.7669274806976318,
0.2195097655057907,
0.45393961668014526,
0.008004685863852501,
0.026654493063688278,
1.287042498588562,
-0.18491515517234802,
-0.0157037153840065,
0.1256442666053772,
-0.03070598654448986,
0.07800158858299255,
-0.5680288672447205,
0.13625265657901764,
-0.1759161353111267,
-0.20430871844291687,
-0.10510103404521942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13181v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13181v1
|
Comparative Analysis of Different Efficient Fine Tuning Methods of Large Language Models (LLMs) in Low-Resource Setting
| 2024-05-21T20:08:52 | 2024-05-21T20:08:52 |
Krishna Prasad Varadarajan Srinivasan, Prasanth Gumpena, Madhusudhana Yattapu, Vishal H. Brahmbhatt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In the domain of large language models (LLMs), arXiv:2305.16938 showed that
few-shot full-model fine-tuning -- namely Vanilla Fine Tuning (FT) and
Pattern-Based Fine Tuning (PBFT) --, and In-Context Learning (ICL) generalize
similarly on Out-Of-Domain (OOD) datasets, but vary in terms of task
adaptation. However, they both pose challenges, especially in term of memory
requirements. In this paper, we further try to push the understanding of
different fine-tuning strategies for LLM and aim to bring a myriad of these on
the same pedestal for an elaborate comparison with full-model fine-tuning on
two diverse datasets. To that end, we conducted a series of experiments,
beginning with state-of-the-art methods like vanilla fine-tuning and
Pattern-Based Fine-Tuning (PBFT) on pre-trained models across two datasets,
COLA and MNLI. We then investigate adaptive fine-tuning and the efficiency of
LoRA adapters in a few-shot setting. Finally, we also compare an alternative
approach that has gained recent popularity -- context distillation -- with the
vanilla FT and PBFT with and without few-shot setup.
Our findings suggest that these alternative strategies that we explored can
exhibit out-of-domain generalization comparable to that of vanilla FT and PBFT.
PBFT under-performs Vanilla FT on out-of-domain (OOD) data, emphasizing the
need for effective prompts. Further, our adaptive-fine tuning and LoRA
experiments perform comparable or slightly worse than the standard fine-tunings
as anticipated, since standard fine-tunings involve tuning the entire model.
Finally, our context distillation experiments out-perform the standard
fine-tuning methods. These findings underscore that eventually the choice of an
appropriate fine-tuning method depends on the available resources (memory,
compute, data) and task adaptability.
|
[
-0.47757795453071594,
-1.1210325956344604,
0.4495111107826233,
-0.03899126499891281,
-0.2730620503425598,
-0.08651022613048553,
-0.6944343447685242,
-0.435783326625824,
-0.3887753486633301,
0.2911897897720337,
-0.47287553548812866,
-0.29057177901268005,
-0.34996315836906433,
0.16579024493694305,
0.05648783966898918,
0.8527088761329651,
-0.14306426048278809,
-0.06872157007455826,
-0.008312945254147053,
-0.29253140091896057,
-0.7385956645011902,
-0.2881939709186554,
-0.8794007897377014,
-0.4222044050693512,
0.5645145177841187,
0.5664191246032715,
0.40460729598999023,
0.575142502784729,
0.5207353234291077,
0.233154296875,
-0.2695779800415039,
0.45633789896965027,
-0.9513524770736694,
-0.1113509014248848,
-0.35440918803215027,
-0.3946610987186432,
-0.28158047795295715,
-0.17635592818260193,
0.39517706632614136,
0.6050781607627869,
-0.05707266181707382,
0.29698309302330017,
0.35366326570510864,
0.8046698570251465,
-1.0458821058273315,
0.04066426306962967,
-1.0203200578689575,
-0.08073391765356064,
-0.15528982877731323,
-0.31165996193885803,
-0.3225623369216919,
-0.00010699047561502084,
0.02567359060049057,
-0.5042199492454529,
0.1351255625486374,
0.32581132650375366,
0.6789980530738831,
0.3988950550556183,
-0.1951456069946289,
-0.269537091255188,
-0.8376657366752625,
1.0284855365753174,
-0.8488038778305054,
0.1631614863872528,
0.34459778666496277,
0.2747577726840973,
-0.28605854511260986,
-0.4263058304786682,
-0.37109965085983276,
0.009533906355500221,
0.010847965255379677,
-0.053470462560653687,
-0.2974274158477783,
0.04866848513484001,
0.41168180108070374,
0.41713446378707886,
-0.1965281069278717,
0.5459370017051697,
-0.17084968090057373,
0.05107968673110008,
0.30233216285705566,
0.260097861289978,
-0.2045152187347412,
0.19528087973594666,
-0.17165006697177887,
-0.010821802541613579,
-0.9161909818649292,
0.0363183319568634,
0.05917417258024216,
0.7322295308113098,
-0.22917744517326355,
0.3372587263584137,
-0.5004804730415344,
1.0260411500930786,
0.36309486627578735,
-0.4127371907234192,
-0.08024010807275772,
-0.45264139771461487,
-0.4660910367965698,
-0.032971810549497604,
0.5791402459144592,
0.3678310215473175,
0.4574418067932129,
-0.0510123185813427,
-0.30060362815856934,
-0.176982119679451,
-0.029378289356827736,
-1.0390193462371826,
-0.10381881147623062,
-0.09346240758895874,
-0.5913670659065247,
0.04838893562555313,
-0.4472791850566864,
-0.5368119478225708,
-0.42209163308143616,
-0.5611549019813538,
0.6531649827957153,
-0.47969701886177063,
0.016018584370613098,
0.2120797485113144,
0.20281444489955902,
0.27236229181289673,
0.42069748044013977,
-1.0655072927474976,
0.3713444471359253,
0.6942696571350098,
1.0451624393463135,
-0.37636271119117737,
-0.18937018513679504,
-0.6808961629867554,
-0.045090723782777786,
-0.30866700410842896,
0.7638076543807983,
-0.3656929135322571,
-0.2565493583679199,
-0.16418150067329407,
-0.1212427169084549,
-0.16522592306137085,
-0.8289153575897217,
0.4205135405063629,
-0.46056342124938965,
-0.18718984723091125,
-0.5509123206138611,
-0.4855991005897522,
-0.21841898560523987,
0.07847362756729126,
-0.45363932847976685,
0.8505910634994507,
0.07122242450714111,
-0.547823429107666,
0.5755109190940857,
-0.712704598903656,
-0.4743816554546356,
-0.3653044104576111,
0.10890898108482361,
-0.28612154722213745,
0.62923663854599,
0.13594654202461243,
0.6632461547851562,
-0.6357015371322632,
-0.1959022879600525,
-0.3592972159385681,
-0.627781867980957,
0.031030869111418724,
-0.5310986638069153,
0.529836118221283,
0.4729806184768677,
-0.18232302367687225,
-0.05369751900434494,
-0.8457939624786377,
0.04541664198040962,
0.1197819635272026,
-0.4348037540912628,
-0.4665547013282776,
0.10215330868959427,
-0.04540049284696579,
0.023793190717697144,
0.0827457383275032,
-0.3013196289539337,
0.17480261623859406,
-0.5182681679725647,
0.7524951696395874,
0.6989262700080872,
0.034387391060590744,
0.531015932559967,
-0.5122106075286865,
0.12199582904577255,
0.13170716166496277,
0.01785377413034439,
-0.2930580675601959,
-0.03870376572012901,
-0.8540052771568298,
-0.3594299852848053,
0.3071172833442688,
0.4208025336265564,
-0.47765183448791504,
0.1384573131799698,
-0.11535178124904633,
-0.2432546615600586,
-0.43761125206947327,
0.42408183217048645,
0.43169042468070984,
0.5898274779319763,
0.40873777866363525,
-0.21237678825855255,
-0.32575157284736633,
-0.796910285949707,
-0.182834193110466,
0.14044681191444397,
0.21245229244232178,
0.5149498581886292,
0.4598447382450104,
0.13688549399375916,
0.8744470477104187,
-0.47008633613586426,
-0.3316463232040405,
-0.17990726232528687,
-0.08133914321660995,
0.41291841864585876,
0.29646074771881104,
0.7557461261749268,
-0.4506087601184845,
-0.8051718473434448,
0.2600141167640686,
-0.38213610649108887,
-0.07730448991060257,
0.11476282775402069,
0.08073531836271286,
0.5185898542404175,
0.4684716463088989,
-0.3044951558113098,
0.20987263321876526,
0.5309695601463318,
-0.10771999508142471,
0.21144722402095795,
-0.30119121074676514,
0.1979086995124817,
-0.9205484390258789,
-0.0029931669123470783,
-0.08841803669929504,
-0.24493969976902008,
-0.691177487373352,
0.01810465194284916,
0.06581749767065048,
0.10890840739011765,
-0.6778890490531921,
0.6487196087837219,
-0.6045357584953308,
0.08249904960393906,
-0.5486207604408264,
-0.05479828268289566,
-0.07984951883554459,
0.6102567911148071,
-0.12380754202604294,
0.9290957450866699,
0.5771480798721313,
-0.800125241279602,
0.15599216520786285,
-0.08210553973913193,
-0.6127784252166748,
0.5325960516929626,
-0.5022982954978943,
0.2397363930940628,
-0.07965631037950516,
-0.030012572184205055,
-0.9843549132347107,
-0.014358175918459892,
0.045650117099285126,
0.13311022520065308,
0.44629228115081787,
-0.1994909942150116,
-0.6534721255302429,
0.06587951630353928,
-0.2089904546737671,
0.47060850262641907,
0.7195913791656494,
-0.5905728340148926,
0.3736995458602905,
-0.006233145482838154,
0.07074066251516342,
-0.4176773428916931,
-0.5933395028114319,
-0.26497897505760193,
-0.731058657169342,
-0.43104228377342224,
0.31093594431877136,
-0.17086955904960632,
-0.42998170852661133,
-0.19893822073936462,
-0.2560596168041229,
0.026143813505768776,
0.3442583978176117,
0.006659470498561859,
-0.10242301225662231,
-0.5592477321624756,
-0.015066899359226227,
-0.039080776274204254,
-0.005002581514418125,
-0.46910762786865234,
-0.15920022130012512,
0.5106920599937439,
-0.17341269552707672,
-0.26355260610580444,
-0.4006090760231018,
0.13130098581314087,
0.32632380723953247,
-0.0022882455959916115,
0.8143473267555237,
0.4510062336921692,
-0.2753885090351105,
-0.43145695328712463,
-0.6889083385467529,
-0.22615660727024078,
-0.47767704725265503,
0.29964369535446167,
-0.4849528670310974,
-0.9345983862876892,
0.5951656699180603,
-0.35581931471824646,
0.05307408794760704,
0.21245144307613373,
0.8101342916488647,
-0.08870422095060349,
0.6439393758773804,
0.7831456065177917,
-0.2300058901309967,
0.6614572405815125,
-0.2467714548110962,
0.24087709188461304,
-0.8151819109916687,
0.3471706807613373,
-0.5746668577194214,
-0.5487200021743774,
-0.5354150533676147,
-0.38389694690704346,
0.2592799663543701,
0.5905330181121826,
-0.24500678479671478,
0.2705487012863159,
-0.16149507462978363,
0.795414924621582,
0.38692671060562134,
-0.018840061500668526,
0.48427364230155945,
0.18250007927417755,
0.10524590313434601,
0.10857924073934555,
-0.9520939588546753,
-0.2733454406261444,
1.007414698600769,
0.12657271325588226,
0.9361661076545715,
0.11352904886007309,
0.4604240655899048,
-0.018337292596697807,
0.03775332123041153,
-0.9444147348403931,
0.27375876903533936,
-0.5450565218925476,
-0.49401307106018066,
-0.38256946206092834,
-0.25938835740089417,
-0.8890579342842102,
0.36685505509376526,
-0.22851522266864777,
-0.732071578502655,
0.23801039159297943,
0.47264909744262695,
-0.7905006408691406,
0.32354938983917236,
-0.9603636264801025,
0.7522242069244385,
-0.20326952636241913,
-0.605941653251648,
-0.39984074234962463,
-0.327072411775589,
0.0716872289776802,
-0.3431658446788788,
0.1503935158252716,
-0.28691717982292175,
0.02729332074522972,
0.3560282289981842,
-0.23690956830978394,
0.9395096898078918,
-0.18473264575004578,
-0.18946342170238495,
0.31518590450286865,
0.00577178318053484,
0.6274978518486023,
-0.04319899529218674,
-0.2372218519449234,
0.20246772468090057,
0.14151722192764282,
-0.33875858783721924,
-0.4877716600894928,
0.9684487581253052,
-0.758266270160675,
-0.6717382669448853,
-0.14562398195266724,
-0.6011385917663574,
-0.44941627979278564,
0.23389454185962677,
0.3290609121322632,
0.36132296919822693,
-0.24503353238105774,
0.5451105237007141,
0.8862060308456421,
-0.27035829424858093,
0.5833223462104797,
0.7927286624908447,
0.06625249981880188,
0.08068227022886276,
0.7683359384536743,
0.20777900516986847,
0.5477437376976013,
0.6001001000404358,
0.35756543278694153,
0.08089426159858704,
-0.8892478942871094,
-0.27011433243751526,
0.1262262612581253,
-0.5078408718109131,
-0.42323631048202515,
-0.2342734932899475,
-0.006792592350393534,
-0.20140130817890167,
-0.18741431832313538,
-0.44262152910232544,
-0.13767507672309875,
-0.47521141171455383,
0.29444777965545654,
0.7207068204879761,
0.20939745008945465,
0.05665472149848938,
0.5410500764846802,
-0.4226401746273041,
0.4365094006061554,
0.06554298102855682,
0.463565856218338,
0.09547719359397888,
-0.7132247090339661,
-0.4558717608451843,
0.16233213245868683,
-0.2947382926940918,
-0.2368030995130539,
0.031110046431422234,
0.6248282790184021,
0.32205870747566223,
0.37596094608306885,
-0.06550832837820053,
1.1712560653686523,
-0.6812002658843994,
0.5304206609725952,
-0.060772836208343506,
-0.7411836385726929,
0.4400585889816284,
-0.3331826329231262,
0.43196338415145874,
0.8077148199081421,
0.14205771684646606,
-0.29639875888824463,
0.11913613229990005,
-0.028542760759592056,
-0.7848137617111206,
0.9059565663337708,
-0.06436273455619812,
0.1589611917734146,
0.18014468252658844,
0.561521589756012,
0.3459642827510834,
-0.03517194092273712,
-0.35535910725593567,
-0.19514626264572144,
0.16991731524467468,
-0.025761689990758896,
-0.3526529371738434,
-0.19955837726593018,
-0.10007981210947037,
-0.23849721252918243,
0.4847186505794525,
-0.3573501408100128,
-0.0458345040678978,
-0.19421067833900452,
-0.20855428278446198,
-0.31496745347976685,
0.33609768748283386,
0.561427652835846,
0.7873244881629944,
-0.26194003224372864,
-0.07659603655338287,
0.640388548374176,
-0.10655663162469864,
-0.007541128434240818,
-0.2186153531074524,
-0.16778706014156342,
-0.3208252787590027,
0.3819718658924103,
1.2420434951782227,
0.30542153120040894,
-0.6529383659362793,
0.20864413678646088,
0.0742766261100769,
-0.1613067239522934,
0.04359645023941994,
0.4875686466693878,
0.12661835551261902,
0.30976346135139465,
0.08099648356437683,
0.0016275139059871435,
-0.01752040721476078,
-0.7705375552177429,
-0.3420071601867676,
0.639431893825531,
-0.13898983597755432,
-0.24906840920448303,
0.36447277665138245,
0.04217877984046936,
-0.10561008751392365,
0.30224624276161194,
-0.02310228906571865,
0.338140070438385,
0.41377270221710205,
0.6460571885108948,
0.6116234660148621,
0.03706032410264015,
-0.30590561032295227,
0.21228329837322235,
0.02375316433608532,
-0.36306318640708923,
0.18622294068336487,
-0.1679457426071167,
-0.8184651136398315,
-0.5682386159896851,
-0.8383851647377014,
-0.13514605164527893,
0.5532296299934387,
-0.47115811705589294,
0.3493632674217224,
-0.4926565885543823,
-0.11599351465702057,
0.0041020652279257774,
0.1905413568019867,
-0.7960442304611206,
-0.07103443890810013,
-0.017720816656947136,
1.1216578483581543,
-0.6932695508003235,
0.9666675329208374,
0.7058467268943787,
0.0391627661883831,
-0.4824090898036957,
0.07224086672067642,
0.09496185928583145,
-0.8573721647262573,
0.4367625415325165,
-0.19843712449073792,
-0.3160105347633362,
0.06336220353841782,
-0.2887498140335083,
-1.0046900510787964,
1.1904860734939575,
0.4648430049419403,
-0.8923876285552979,
0.1155073419213295,
-0.05670684576034546,
0.6898770332336426,
-0.27758288383483887,
-0.13658267259597778,
0.9081436991691589,
0.34934890270233154,
0.12069396674633026,
-1.1523102521896362,
-0.025457028299570084,
0.19465669989585876,
0.31859058141708374,
0.24040749669075012,
-0.9524899125099182,
0.8311697244644165,
-0.13996237516403198,
-0.22235187888145447,
0.24907921254634857,
0.42026403546333313,
0.15496893227100372,
0.2507847547531128,
0.5172889828681946,
0.4010414481163025,
0.4598851799964905,
-0.10192643851041794,
0.7834277153015137,
-0.3518460988998413,
0.3332595229148865,
1.179874062538147,
-0.4543263614177704,
0.8625133633613586,
0.7074063420295715,
-0.20202898979187012,
-0.04828633368015289,
0.5970372557640076,
0.08861052244901657,
0.8393765687942505,
0.2848908603191376,
0.03282902017235756,
-0.19771209359169006,
-0.057138439267873764,
-0.2540099322795868,
0.5570964217185974,
0.3742486536502838,
-0.10740035772323608,
-0.29923900961875916,
0.11796657741069794,
-0.11484698951244354,
-0.016943249851465225,
-0.5335537195205688,
1.0558840036392212,
0.33332890272140503,
-0.6302515268325806,
1.0177268981933594,
0.20773647725582123,
0.8861004114151001,
-0.5451101660728455,
0.2455204874277115,
-0.37721067667007446,
0.4646615982055664,
-0.1103115826845169,
-0.3750721514225006,
0.20936600863933563,
0.18186622858047485,
-0.3285449743270874,
-0.2213899791240692,
0.7254047989845276,
-0.19829003512859344,
-0.244052454829216,
0.21509137749671936,
0.5588192939758301,
-0.11396234482526779,
-0.026982493698596954,
-0.5802325010299683,
0.20483548939228058,
-0.15388110280036926,
-0.34780025482177734,
0.6709634065628052,
0.7244702577590942,
-0.18701009452342987,
0.5456535816192627,
0.4649665951728821,
0.29547402262687683,
-0.11754114925861359,
0.055587250739336014,
0.7129482626914978,
-0.5269330143928528,
-0.2641955316066742,
-1.0647951364517212,
0.05383583530783653,
0.3510666489601135,
-0.3072616755962372,
0.7823010683059692,
0.5178897976875305,
0.948910653591156,
-0.16720695793628693,
0.6483321785926819,
-0.039230234920978546,
0.46452224254608154,
-0.9424957633018494,
0.40607136487960815,
-0.7267102003097534,
0.25171563029289246,
-0.13125453889369965,
-1.0026789903640747,
-0.17727668583393097,
0.5981929898262024,
-0.2825404405593872,
0.11412546038627625,
0.6156033873558044,
0.8786189556121826,
-0.520723819732666,
-0.20311953127384186,
0.42503052949905396,
0.48010119795799255,
-0.021301258355379105,
0.7176854610443115,
0.7355040907859802,
-0.22586075961589813,
0.3072377145290375,
-0.23345322906970978,
-0.16305530071258545,
-0.5249317288398743,
-1.0884140729904175,
-0.9915683269500732,
-0.4778898358345032,
-0.16277998685836792,
-0.004753713496029377,
0.17485074698925018,
0.9643281102180481,
0.753810465335846,
-1.046971082687378,
-0.36481839418411255,
0.14532393217086792,
-0.08671406656503677,
-0.3448556065559387,
-0.1323198527097702,
0.2465452253818512,
-0.42658326029777527,
-0.708959698677063,
0.40427103638648987,
0.3845270276069641,
-0.041050542145967484,
0.023061254993081093,
0.014186426997184753,
0.043153226375579834,
0.10915002971887589,
0.8594043850898743,
0.26734766364097595,
-0.7565727829933167,
-0.2951078414916992,
-0.09684499353170395,
0.06906803697347641,
0.2203580141067505,
0.8580516576766968,
-0.6495292782783508,
0.18257996439933777,
0.5384635329246521,
0.5015605092048645,
0.5478613376617432,
-0.04174208641052246,
0.33439165353775024,
-0.7049548029899597,
0.2394910603761673,
-0.16332873702049255,
0.2745360732078552,
0.16242167353630066,
-0.1618383377790451,
0.4156590402126312,
-0.07231543213129044,
-0.5379523634910583,
-0.8162206411361694,
0.3008561134338379,
-0.8724779486656189,
-0.6007013320922852,
1.2513452768325806,
0.07281436026096344,
-0.09622136503458023,
0.026494095101952553,
-0.35521557927131653,
0.06418289989233017,
-0.3830133080482483,
0.8973548412322998,
0.7316372394561768,
-0.40889081358909607,
0.006921798922121525,
-0.6861279010772705,
0.7371475696563721,
0.30077841877937317,
-0.5647270083427429,
0.3029875159263611,
0.3977947533130646,
0.47138604521751404,
-0.11715333163738251,
0.5629397034645081,
0.2126600295305252,
0.014053916558623314,
-0.3781810998916626,
-0.6186195015907288,
-0.21193479001522064,
-0.27665039896965027,
-0.5123612284660339,
0.07948685437440872,
0.32117730379104614,
0.10893362015485764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13179v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13179v4
|
RAG-RLRC-LaySum at BioLaySumm: Integrating Retrieval-Augmented Generation and Readability Control for Layman Summarization of Biomedical Texts
| 2024-05-21T20:03:40 | 2024-06-24T18:13:16 |
Yuelyu Ji, Zhuochun Li, Rui Meng, Sonish Sivarajkumar, Yanshan Wang, Zeshui Yu, Hui Ji, Yushui Han, Hanyu Zeng, Daqing He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces the RAG-RLRC-LaySum framework, designed to make complex
biomedical research understandable to laymen through advanced Natural Language
Processing (NLP) techniques. Our Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) solution,
enhanced by a reranking method, utilizes multiple knowledge sources to ensure
the precision and pertinence of lay summaries. Additionally, our Reinforcement
Learning for Readability Control (RLRC) strategy improves readability, making
scientific content comprehensible to non-specialists. Evaluations using the
publicly accessible PLOS and eLife datasets show that our methods surpass Plain
Gemini model, demonstrating a 20% increase in readability scores, a 15%
improvement in ROUGE-2 relevance scores, and a 10% enhancement in factual
accuracy. The RAG-RLRC-LaySum framework effectively democratizes scientific
knowledge, enhancing public engagement with biomedical discoveries.
|
[
-0.10683335363864899,
-0.43928036093711853,
0.37167075276374817,
0.17985931038856506,
-0.3493216037750244,
0.45359987020492554,
-0.08802329003810883,
-0.6383346915245056,
0.693106472492218,
0.4826488196849823,
-0.144740492105484,
-0.4786030352115631,
-0.6112315058708191,
0.4341350197792053,
-0.19724522531032562,
1.2844196557998657,
-0.034321367740631104,
-0.06212666258215904,
-0.6189212203025818,
-0.4040166437625885,
0.09531860798597336,
-0.13001152873039246,
-0.3189312517642975,
-0.5993847250938416,
0.9333330392837524,
0.3781890571117401,
0.6827486157417297,
0.9193804264068604,
0.8633053302764893,
0.22241036593914032,
-0.5479297041893005,
0.6007311344146729,
-0.6621339917182922,
0.2724377512931824,
-0.4408440887928009,
-0.4195610582828522,
-0.7225593328475952,
-0.1190318614244461,
0.5915204286575317,
0.9040109515190125,
-0.22956755757331848,
0.1571681648492813,
-0.052299562841653824,
1.0131189823150635,
-0.8056340217590332,
0.015174288302659988,
-0.04332251101732254,
0.13279886543750763,
-0.11036079376935959,
-0.807690441608429,
-0.814421534538269,
-0.43090295791625977,
0.0009140834445133805,
-0.8798556923866272,
0.28583356738090515,
0.06966182589530945,
0.5552766919136047,
0.4150998592376709,
-0.5680180191993713,
-0.46457159519195557,
-0.46155598759651184,
0.7251786589622498,
-0.6984286308288574,
0.30097249150276184,
0.4721282422542572,
-0.05223465710878372,
-0.4214783310890198,
-0.9366469979286194,
-0.13845336437225342,
-0.26001864671707153,
-0.3902987837791443,
0.6458231210708618,
0.3133885860443115,
-0.021045593544840813,
0.10927700251340866,
0.2069135457277298,
-0.6626026034355164,
-0.28852587938308716,
-0.7524407505989075,
-0.0011089338222518563,
0.6769038438796997,
-0.13018688559532166,
0.22835682332515717,
-0.35276323556900024,
-0.32039013504981995,
-0.031336709856987,
-0.5052943229675293,
0.07875459641218185,
-0.0925394594669342,
0.10522881895303726,
-0.007678644265979528,
0.7729982733726501,
-0.2594389021396637,
0.46404045820236206,
-0.12644748389720917,
-0.33314046263694763,
0.4143039286136627,
-0.18114259839057922,
-0.05884382128715515,
0.1625334471464157,
0.4621178209781647,
0.1159951388835907,
-0.04612019658088684,
-0.174748957157135,
0.13867032527923584,
-0.2826538681983948,
0.5299690365791321,
-0.7139100432395935,
-0.042191553860902786,
0.449200838804245,
-0.6912000179290771,
-0.5230278968811035,
0.07118634879589081,
-0.680955171585083,
-0.45458126068115234,
-0.3614477217197418,
0.3201078474521637,
-0.49980834126472473,
-0.11747181415557861,
0.12979760766029358,
-0.3045746684074402,
0.28679749369621277,
0.4523133933544159,
-0.5314538478851318,
0.2807391881942749,
0.7007682919502258,
0.9456393718719482,
-0.4989176094532013,
-0.19300627708435059,
-0.5903933644294739,
0.5948948860168457,
-0.29624584317207336,
0.900221049785614,
-0.21855856478214264,
-0.6599550843238831,
-0.3057692050933838,
-0.13809101283550262,
-0.062151387333869934,
-0.3406376838684082,
0.5534559488296509,
-0.4625386893749237,
0.24164946377277374,
-0.09750360995531082,
-0.5808391571044922,
-0.18636919558048248,
-0.0464407242834568,
-0.47745978832244873,
0.5663967132568359,
-0.22074563801288605,
-1.0146148204803467,
0.31422510743141174,
-0.5097041130065918,
-0.8121007680892944,
0.2145000845193863,
-0.17194730043411255,
-0.4917917549610138,
0.1715298444032669,
0.0688801109790802,
0.3729502260684967,
0.13934940099716187,
0.3709983825683594,
-0.09412938356399536,
-0.30503445863723755,
0.20253032445907593,
0.05267230421304703,
0.5882911086082458,
0.4154980778694153,
-0.2060154378414154,
0.23218242824077606,
-0.8346236944198608,
0.1105550229549408,
-0.27686020731925964,
-0.4288662075996399,
-0.31298771500587463,
0.1931648999452591,
-0.2014298290014267,
-0.14258813858032227,
0.091461680829525,
-0.25353938341140747,
-0.019795294851064682,
-0.505607008934021,
0.11607731878757477,
0.6273477077484131,
-0.12169056385755539,
0.6425003409385681,
-0.5297013521194458,
0.3965405523777008,
-0.2522822916507721,
-0.09013666957616806,
-0.3293904960155487,
-0.3240809440612793,
-0.5412667989730835,
-0.657085120677948,
0.44155052304267883,
0.6960071325302124,
-0.626453161239624,
0.19370758533477783,
-0.10327673703432083,
-0.42106160521507263,
-0.38718485832214355,
-0.25191083550453186,
0.6464998722076416,
0.6929062604904175,
0.7058842182159424,
-0.27665162086486816,
-0.43446084856987,
-0.7454878091812134,
-0.4664019048213959,
-0.10226643085479736,
-0.11200277507305145,
0.46207815408706665,
0.5544973611831665,
-0.41206130385398865,
0.8817878365516663,
-0.5434985160827637,
-0.13428735733032227,
-0.33837181329727173,
0.6350688934326172,
0.24809731543064117,
0.6242101788520813,
0.012972058728337288,
-0.9096062183380127,
-0.22345995903015137,
0.16973398625850677,
-0.9319054484367371,
-0.3230700194835663,
0.1555904746055603,
-0.019466707482933998,
0.18995320796966553,
0.6606780886650085,
-0.2559360861778259,
0.6886512637138367,
0.28757244348526,
-0.38446858525276184,
0.5293355584144592,
-0.5879299640655518,
0.43134358525276184,
-1.1004621982574463,
0.559160053730011,
-0.2812133729457855,
-0.6092807650566101,
-0.43280553817749023,
0.15801593661308289,
0.10819234699010849,
-0.016586726531386375,
-0.2000228613615036,
0.4518629312515259,
-0.24888038635253906,
-0.33645787835121155,
-0.26556628942489624,
0.11098043620586395,
0.24017441272735596,
0.06208958849310875,
0.2183905988931656,
0.9228314757347107,
-0.24491611123085022,
-0.7742388844490051,
-0.03814718499779701,
0.5480308532714844,
0.03337538614869118,
0.4900427758693695,
-1.0330523252487183,
-0.32460615038871765,
-0.6501418352127075,
0.5950332880020142,
-0.5817848443984985,
-0.5488994717597961,
0.03466679900884628,
-0.7592537999153137,
0.35461509227752686,
0.28924620151519775,
0.10280603915452957,
0.06768937408924103,
-0.3268212378025055,
0.266269713640213,
0.4248630702495575,
-0.4110943078994751,
0.8875823616981506,
0.3545113205909729,
-0.3867824375629425,
-0.8698183298110962,
-0.7510572075843811,
-0.15372195839881897,
0.16953574120998383,
-0.4874117076396942,
0.5074342489242554,
-0.20159275829792023,
-0.17030571401119232,
-0.1289997696876526,
-0.09279821813106537,
-0.03787413612008095,
-0.1281510293483734,
0.31987977027893066,
0.18208351731300354,
0.13137616217136383,
0.09666690975427628,
0.19839441776275635,
-0.38783156871795654,
-0.07357403635978699,
0.12756672501564026,
-0.004354465287178755,
0.12217219173908234,
-0.12090346217155457,
-0.17111307382583618,
0.3024002015590668,
0.33147183060646057,
-0.2836715579032898,
0.5979093909263611,
0.4496747553348541,
-0.03117021918296814,
-0.1670859456062317,
-0.19175420701503754,
-0.2188446968793869,
-0.39605188369750977,
0.25791966915130615,
-0.03073229268193245,
-0.9415984153747559,
0.5118717551231384,
-0.40878745913505554,
0.35741984844207764,
0.38017651438713074,
0.4593333899974823,
-0.613124430179596,
0.7420540452003479,
0.6447749137878418,
0.5201859474182129,
0.0787455216050148,
-0.045380834490060806,
-0.05667771399021149,
-0.7028547525405884,
-0.5672112703323364,
-0.6003664135932922,
-0.32083195447921753,
-0.5550268292427063,
-0.7472794651985168,
0.5128565430641174,
0.19661737978458405,
0.04421801120042801,
0.03918355330824852,
-0.5174283981323242,
0.5457105040550232,
0.37358513474464417,
0.3164857029914856,
0.6711698770523071,
-0.13862256705760956,
-0.44298630952835083,
-0.06025198474526405,
-0.6926770806312561,
-0.3974267840385437,
0.8279990553855896,
0.4442065954208374,
0.7211408615112305,
0.2164325714111328,
0.7236450910568237,
0.6012416481971741,
0.43485429883003235,
-0.5947929620742798,
0.44910991191864014,
-0.29296642541885376,
-0.5121986269950867,
-0.052863799035549164,
-0.7135675549507141,
-0.8748081922531128,
0.20035004615783691,
-0.32273295521736145,
-0.16393743455410004,
0.4980306327342987,
0.3268442451953888,
-0.27202272415161133,
0.09435229748487473,
-0.40877968072891235,
0.2839495539665222,
0.05531349033117294,
-0.2501225769519806,
-0.34265393018722534,
-1.0516141653060913,
0.5047191381454468,
0.20328709483146667,
0.5825393795967102,
0.04960382357239723,
-0.2568242847919464,
0.6971643567085266,
-0.1620468646287918,
0.599082350730896,
0.29840031266212463,
0.16477583348751068,
-0.042197201400995255,
0.12636816501617432,
0.43050137162208557,
0.4209211766719818,
0.08901132643222809,
-0.1398252248764038,
0.0445268414914608,
-0.6727480292320251,
-0.22051677107810974,
0.3906034529209137,
-0.66473388671875,
0.08298223465681076,
-0.8861530423164368,
-0.6017072200775146,
-0.10703735798597336,
0.14676165580749512,
0.33771345019340515,
0.45661598443984985,
-0.3725133538246155,
0.4516605734825134,
1.22939932346344,
-0.5577272176742554,
-0.033237896859645844,
0.6886289119720459,
-0.3080414831638336,
-0.8273078799247742,
0.8896088004112244,
-0.19770437479019165,
0.26839083433151245,
0.5985049605369568,
0.1766846925020218,
-0.13522180914878845,
-0.45817461609840393,
-0.1247888132929802,
0.3511165976524353,
-0.48664116859436035,
-0.3187411427497864,
-0.7915194034576416,
-0.2053317278623581,
-0.5985453724861145,
-0.4677990674972534,
-0.24080561101436615,
-0.5053865909576416,
-0.4800761640071869,
-0.17421074211597443,
0.40864813327789307,
0.9286455512046814,
-0.6234498620033264,
0.27400630712509155,
-0.5880968570709229,
0.7326863408088684,
0.05735829472541809,
0.39099636673927307,
-0.5755907297134399,
-0.732508659362793,
-0.26138901710510254,
-0.19797439873218536,
0.08784467726945877,
-0.7029211521148682,
0.45321720838546753,
0.20114873349666595,
0.25137099623680115,
0.05838310346007347,
-0.05948684364557266,
0.3605998158454895,
-0.49589720368385315,
0.2995937168598175,
0.11009135842323303,
-0.6673944592475891,
0.4318440556526184,
-0.5196803212165833,
0.3190852403640747,
0.843035876750946,
0.33764925599098206,
-0.4724392890930176,
-0.2627689838409424,
-0.6722230315208435,
-1.0606822967529297,
0.4403139650821686,
0.14252205193042755,
-0.5300461053848267,
0.11438054591417313,
0.5650667548179626,
0.11740117520093918,
0.2224208116531372,
-0.3536648750305176,
-0.21382761001586914,
-0.22615912556648254,
-0.2784274220466614,
-0.07422850281000137,
-0.569533109664917,
-0.3457556962966919,
0.059148307889699936,
0.8581045269966125,
-0.29596179723739624,
-0.06785012036561966,
0.675291121006012,
-0.2913478910923004,
-0.12437925487756729,
0.31466081738471985,
1.0118510723114014,
0.9535510540008545,
-0.6002804040908813,
0.17079605162143707,
0.002643038285896182,
-0.831840991973877,
-0.11062055081129074,
0.15094301104545593,
-0.4308571219444275,
0.02019415982067585,
0.649457573890686,
0.3187224268913269,
0.31321728229522705,
-0.7221306562423706,
0.17049092054367065,
-0.12402819842100143,
-0.48737645149230957,
-0.10971155762672424,
-0.01304604671895504,
0.09483279287815094,
0.1527804434299469,
0.4796708822250366,
0.146185040473938,
0.2937203347682953,
-0.0963752418756485,
0.5893018245697021,
0.17035920917987823,
-0.3240959346294403,
0.045414894819259644,
0.5795588493347168,
0.35145947337150574,
-0.016581427305936813,
0.08770311623811722,
-0.04911620542407036,
-0.1925078183412552,
0.6372703909873962,
0.46873149275779724,
0.4330371022224426,
-0.2199295610189438,
0.6691864728927612,
0.6194972395896912,
0.26610878109931946,
-0.27708524465560913,
0.35952243208885193,
0.13859707117080688,
-0.4286665916442871,
-0.9773868918418884,
-0.6366214752197266,
-0.7834065556526184,
-0.33664610981941223,
-0.8707646131515503,
0.028631791472434998,
-0.5433045029640198,
0.09312623739242554,
0.024187790229916573,
0.00914868712425232,
0.12802067399024963,
0.3630848228931427,
-0.3151237368583679,
0.8259645104408264,
-0.5696935057640076,
0.30234163999557495,
0.48945820331573486,
-0.3502792418003082,
-0.5521328449249268,
-0.3402335047721863,
-0.07660047709941864,
-0.4491937458515167,
0.6449850797653198,
-0.13174080848693848,
-0.24178360402584076,
0.08198539912700653,
-0.7132115364074707,
-0.8219256401062012,
1.2907774448394775,
-0.016893817111849785,
-0.4018821120262146,
0.19556798040866852,
-0.14315538108348846,
0.5918850898742676,
-0.0464184395968914,
0.4127209484577179,
0.40344008803367615,
0.5948492884635925,
0.3685225248336792,
-0.7647292017936707,
-0.3730497658252716,
-0.17470058798789978,
-0.370975136756897,
0.21555735170841217,
-0.5926571488380432,
0.511143147945404,
-0.4327555000782013,
0.0046493117697536945,
-0.01967567391693592,
1.0423952341079712,
0.7494019865989685,
0.7237905859947205,
0.07100329548120499,
0.6244495511054993,
0.7956376671791077,
0.010890115983784199,
0.9659544229507446,
0.10109387338161469,
0.2100745439529419,
1.200838327407837,
-0.13607414066791534,
0.6618582606315613,
0.5661495923995972,
-0.1713164895772934,
0.5737102031707764,
0.2616640031337738,
0.4359264075756073,
0.4191548228263855,
0.11554776877164841,
-0.25190097093582153,
-0.027484087273478508,
-0.42503488063812256,
-0.5392824411392212,
0.2278682440519333,
0.37543973326683044,
-0.2783486843109131,
-0.019961142912507057,
-0.10719943791627884,
0.1306997686624527,
0.48071256279945374,
-0.2962057590484619,
0.9352351427078247,
0.3175722062587738,
-0.384525865316391,
0.2285575270652771,
0.034213535487651825,
0.6639741063117981,
-0.8520283699035645,
-0.1789143830537796,
-0.2792755663394928,
0.10888135433197021,
-0.46137315034866333,
-0.6745495796203613,
0.4696400761604309,
-0.05468529462814331,
-0.5155394077301025,
-0.2396346479654312,
0.9843464493751526,
-0.41565555334091187,
-0.44049257040023804,
0.15126889944076538,
0.5425198078155518,
0.22921383380889893,
0.6463052034378052,
-0.6114431619644165,
-0.11554048955440521,
-0.008822264149785042,
-0.3697989881038666,
0.37752899527549744,
0.25946375727653503,
0.13942836225032806,
0.7169927358627319,
0.9514882564544678,
0.3834769129753113,
-0.24428214132785797,
0.011040839366614819,
0.6431210041046143,
-0.736171305179596,
-0.41040554642677307,
-0.2911094129085541,
0.41332295536994934,
-0.2468274086713791,
-0.20634639263153076,
0.42927825450897217,
0.552280843257904,
0.2991473078727722,
0.013976373709738255,
0.6201958060264587,
-0.20011167228221893,
1.167500376701355,
-0.30006304383277893,
0.9371821880340576,
-0.50589519739151,
-0.04873660206794739,
-0.06542836874723434,
-0.36222127079963684,
-0.6066294312477112,
0.7944945693016052,
0.05431006848812103,
0.10140576213598251,
0.8097647428512573,
0.4191983938217163,
0.07222114503383636,
-0.05158202350139618,
0.11890072375535965,
0.2232075333595276,
0.297900915145874,
0.05018516629934311,
0.32360678911209106,
-0.15611609816551208,
0.24127870798110962,
-0.10988221317529678,
-0.541856586933136,
-0.25107067823410034,
-1.1934928894042969,
-0.7920257449150085,
-0.15755772590637207,
-0.102351613342762,
-0.7157624363899231,
0.45475199818611145,
0.7842032313346863,
0.38128283619880676,
-0.8729453682899475,
-0.19610042870044708,
-0.08120909333229065,
0.18617339432239532,
-0.16185446083545685,
-0.23210826516151428,
0.524732232093811,
-0.4712730050086975,
-0.30888062715530396,
0.5044576525688171,
0.5991660952568054,
-0.22623391449451447,
-0.11051985621452332,
-0.22858338057994843,
-0.45272740721702576,
0.11034180223941803,
0.5336514115333557,
0.7851966023445129,
-0.2665386199951172,
0.2894079387187958,
0.08897852897644043,
-0.33661597967147827,
-0.1700373888015747,
1.0076603889465332,
-0.9474229216575623,
0.39093926548957825,
0.8574648499488831,
0.8072643280029297,
0.3310622572898865,
0.3717643618583679,
0.6640013456344604,
-0.5896247029304504,
0.19584140181541443,
0.5598430633544922,
-0.004626651760190725,
0.15159308910369873,
-0.39082038402557373,
0.8304141163825989,
0.18092738091945648,
-0.9543201923370361,
-0.6937347650527954,
0.2390296757221222,
-1.1302201747894287,
-0.4653022289276123,
0.9487340450286865,
0.07554659247398376,
-0.3758472800254822,
-0.21768781542778015,
-0.2129630446434021,
0.4065569341182709,
-0.33528149127960205,
0.6741443276405334,
0.07647160440683365,
-0.08020060509443283,
0.08871869742870331,
-0.6891734004020691,
0.8808237910270691,
0.7053717970848083,
-1.1500598192214966,
0.011758887208998203,
0.4547455608844757,
0.1430734544992447,
0.1617514193058014,
0.8534047603607178,
-0.26249319314956665,
0.38978442549705505,
-0.6281014680862427,
0.1814330667257309,
-0.13303664326667786,
-0.48588940501213074,
-0.21178346872329712,
-0.04468972235918045,
-0.284004807472229,
0.48468467593193054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13144v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13144v2
|
Mamo: a Mathematical Modeling Benchmark with Solvers
| 2024-05-21T18:29:54 | 2024-06-30T05:42:24 |
Xuhan Huang, Qingning Shen, Yan Hu, Anningzhe Gao, Benyou Wang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Mathematical modeling involves representing real-world phenomena, systems, or
problems using mathematical expressions and equations to analyze, understand,
and predict their behavior. Given that this process typically requires
experienced experts, there is an interest in exploring whether Large Language
Models (LLMs) can undertake mathematical modeling to potentially decrease human
labor. To evaluate of LLMs in mathematical modeling, we introduce a new
benchmark, Mamo, that transcends traditional result-oriented assessments.
Unlike conventional methods that primarily assess LLMs based on the accuracy of
solutions to mathematical problems, our approach offers deeper insight into the
modeling process itself. By focusing on the processes LLMs undertake rather
than the correctness of their final solutions, Mamo pioneers a novel evaluation
paradigm. This shift underscores the importance of understanding the inherent
modeling capabilities of LLMs, paving the way for a more nuanced and
comprehensive analysis of their problem-solving strategies. Our work marks a
significant advancement in the field, suggesting a new direction for future
research by emphasizing the evaluation of LLMs' modeling processes over the
mere correctness of answers. This benchmark not only facilitates a better
understanding of LLMs' mathematical modeling capabilities but also sets a new
standard for evaluating their performance in complex problem-solving scenarios.
|
[
-0.3214232325553894,
-0.7612940073013306,
0.6355624794960022,
0.2589544951915741,
-0.15465107560157776,
0.061962105333805084,
-0.22888363897800446,
-0.40021103620529175,
-0.3060818910598755,
0.4811900556087494,
-0.5834994316101074,
-0.28647610545158386,
-0.7529902458190918,
0.19220462441444397,
-0.15463857352733612,
0.4755472242832184,
-0.05706807225942612,
0.3818480968475342,
-0.9349229335784912,
0.01476475689560175,
-0.41007494926452637,
-0.5033994317054749,
-0.5987796187400818,
-0.6340306401252747,
0.49021053314208984,
0.012429066933691502,
0.6715383529663086,
0.7116012573242188,
0.8326069116592407,
0.41888123750686646,
-0.1342177391052246,
0.18116748332977295,
-0.4070829153060913,
0.26612088084220886,
-0.028985947370529175,
-0.5144243240356445,
-0.584689736366272,
0.02921084500849247,
0.550919771194458,
1.0667309761047363,
-0.19906260073184967,
0.4428125023841858,
-0.08393638581037521,
0.6043692231178284,
-0.7481741309165955,
0.37571415305137634,
-0.5518286824226379,
0.08252519369125366,
-0.26003751158714294,
-0.05798855796456337,
-0.20289024710655212,
-0.5764517188072205,
0.007995213381946087,
-0.4295744299888611,
-0.024535687640309334,
-0.18292935192584991,
0.5243626236915588,
0.10560604929924011,
-0.5289206504821777,
-0.23587878048419952,
-0.695456326007843,
1.0468370914459229,
-0.8602098226547241,
0.261883020401001,
0.05436442419886589,
0.7729120254516602,
-0.3419092297554016,
-0.3304043114185333,
-0.3246816098690033,
-0.24001458287239075,
0.4313609302043915,
0.0584326907992363,
-0.15155495703220367,
-0.2399900257587433,
0.23593659698963165,
0.4369349181652069,
-0.3328355550765991,
0.002305317437276244,
-0.38158705830574036,
-0.18745718896389008,
0.868073046207428,
0.5251035690307617,
-0.03880472481250763,
0.11751311272382736,
-0.316005676984787,
0.017499035224318504,
-0.5351502895355225,
-0.15152819454669952,
0.24949268996715546,
0.10024113208055496,
0.14142052829265594,
0.6818802952766418,
-0.2709841728210449,
0.6355602741241455,
-0.7478234171867371,
-0.45239701867103577,
0.27325671911239624,
0.05334926024079323,
-0.29461994767189026,
-0.4230937361717224,
0.6514270901679993,
0.45048782229423523,
0.34173938632011414,
0.09946572780609131,
-0.5215162634849548,
0.324554979801178,
0.21996475756168365,
-0.8296952247619629,
0.1935424506664276,
-0.2483321577310562,
-0.575772225856781,
-0.4082905948162079,
-0.185079425573349,
-0.8211019039154053,
-0.4521203339099884,
-0.34386342763900757,
0.6126750707626343,
0.030354682356119156,
-0.28797411918640137,
0.3914525508880615,
0.22645235061645508,
-0.020593199878931046,
0.5125681757926941,
-0.5181553959846497,
0.6110879778862,
1.1184624433517456,
0.959810733795166,
-0.08399508893489838,
0.02557285688817501,
-0.48137712478637695,
-0.1921215057373047,
-0.6144943237304688,
0.8678044080734253,
-0.7279160618782043,
-0.8959568738937378,
0.05313512310385704,
-0.287029892206192,
0.07413148134946823,
-0.9317888021469116,
0.9043270945549011,
-0.4246905446052551,
-0.0003557422896847129,
-0.22320538759231567,
-0.698120653629303,
-0.29200780391693115,
0.43101948499679565,
-0.48894643783569336,
1.00636887550354,
0.0292035099118948,
-0.0742299035191536,
0.03198739141225815,
-0.8930782675743103,
-0.17354974150657654,
-0.11705984175205231,
-0.08115515857934952,
-0.46795374155044556,
0.6240124106407166,
0.009535536170005798,
0.3463653326034546,
-0.9636577367782593,
0.22049954533576965,
-0.5096296072006226,
-0.2538900077342987,
0.653435468673706,
-0.5924543738365173,
0.41585013270378113,
0.44175323843955994,
0.14983133971691132,
0.020394854247570038,
-0.9158973097801208,
0.20576807856559753,
0.3336193859577179,
-0.22261838614940643,
-0.271663635969162,
0.12232434749603271,
-0.29317334294319153,
0.395316481590271,
0.46916064620018005,
-0.4653894305229187,
0.2854129374027252,
-0.24896112084388733,
0.3353068232536316,
0.7516673803329468,
-0.13629449903964996,
0.14932875335216522,
-0.5953660607337952,
0.8249962329864502,
-0.3755117654800415,
0.25770431756973267,
-0.36151424050331116,
-0.6241441369056702,
-0.8359127044677734,
-0.27648597955703735,
0.1902730017900467,
0.23746918141841888,
-0.2536871135234833,
-0.08240833133459091,
-0.2511163055896759,
-0.8107290267944336,
-0.4130500257015228,
0.3073662221431732,
0.7319191694259644,
0.5618379712104797,
0.18244151771068573,
-0.2380470633506775,
-0.4855189323425293,
-1.0345526933670044,
-0.42240190505981445,
0.14983052015304565,
-0.19443248212337494,
0.4002181887626648,
0.49246296286582947,
-0.03562494367361069,
0.7081784009933472,
-0.5662226676940918,
-0.1804955154657364,
-0.015333784744143486,
0.32615283131599426,
0.3930063545703888,
0.3095855116844177,
0.27727046608924866,
-0.6405090689659119,
-0.21975073218345642,
0.06315595656633377,
-0.7280710935592651,
-0.5050951838493347,
0.3739532232284546,
-0.03313308581709862,
-0.07103507220745087,
0.36636364459991455,
-0.42748114466667175,
0.12859037518501282,
0.6821766495704651,
-0.06297984719276428,
0.6346490383148193,
-0.1972024142742157,
0.12416620552539825,
-0.7703008055686951,
0.0637674406170845,
-0.11598009616136551,
-0.04685450717806816,
-0.3048701286315918,
-0.11088322848081589,
0.03014100156724453,
-0.438710480928421,
-0.36099302768707275,
0.7009170055389404,
-0.6125586628913879,
-0.669738233089447,
-0.18678973615169525,
0.07226894795894623,
0.12931863963603973,
0.029713930562138557,
-0.34073972702026367,
0.9892939925193787,
0.4251245856285095,
-0.5635733008384705,
0.5119547247886658,
-0.0743250846862793,
-0.6711942553520203,
0.5817423462867737,
-0.9193673729896545,
0.2722243070602417,
0.20166973769664764,
-0.20000234246253967,
-0.92961186170578,
0.09758920222520828,
-0.14861983060836792,
-0.42564722895622253,
-0.10429457575082779,
-0.13126122951507568,
-0.6601116061210632,
-0.5560818314552307,
-0.031207934021949768,
0.4524637460708618,
0.5956338047981262,
-0.14978434145450592,
0.7269924283027649,
0.33086904883384705,
-0.27123773097991943,
-0.38614240288734436,
-0.44557663798332214,
-0.026174219325184822,
-0.07732995599508286,
-0.685944676399231,
0.18010050058364868,
-0.15447287261486053,
-0.588638961315155,
-0.12789861857891083,
-0.3868444561958313,
-0.2621001601219177,
0.42592674493789673,
0.17698314785957336,
0.40235114097595215,
-0.42013564705848694,
0.19381466507911682,
-0.11541298031806946,
-0.5230745077133179,
0.4584003686904907,
-0.0693097934126854,
0.636375367641449,
-0.03896760195493698,
-0.5732628703117371,
-0.3097769618034363,
0.1859607994556427,
0.7597910761833191,
-0.6738384962081909,
0.47037753462791443,
0.010081627406179905,
-0.5562678575515747,
-0.028676066547632217,
-0.6537362933158875,
0.11366914212703705,
-0.46412065625190735,
0.34809890389442444,
-0.7317298054695129,
-0.5620628595352173,
0.5737380385398865,
-0.5228809118270874,
0.11266370117664337,
0.3771516978740692,
0.7777238488197327,
0.168257474899292,
1.241671085357666,
0.567569375038147,
0.2824961543083191,
0.2452724128961563,
-0.033826857805252075,
0.09566166251897812,
-0.8709835410118103,
-0.5284630656242371,
-0.8020943999290466,
-0.2512566149234772,
-0.05718401446938515,
-0.7607864141464233,
0.37470370531082153,
0.10159725695848465,
0.12223472446203232,
0.15593355894088745,
-0.2284247726202011,
0.6575546860694885,
0.01907963678240776,
-0.2595537006855011,
0.5624877214431763,
-0.3695167601108551,
-0.4088694751262665,
-0.226693257689476,
-0.37536704540252686,
-0.9334673285484314,
1.2558292150497437,
0.2760399878025055,
0.7753763198852539,
0.13067561388015747,
0.35565292835235596,
0.3033943176269531,
0.7389344573020935,
-0.800666868686676,
0.6499025225639343,
0.10149279236793518,
-0.6394195556640625,
-0.08769974857568741,
-0.5886732935905457,
-0.9519610404968262,
0.6341615319252014,
-0.32803642749786377,
-0.47829145193099976,
-0.18010006844997406,
-0.09410205483436584,
-0.10771074146032333,
0.1709427386522293,
-0.4834118187427521,
0.9784883856773376,
-0.47671592235565186,
-0.37463492155075073,
-0.45297959446907043,
0.027551840990781784,
0.3434981405735016,
-0.15169784426689148,
0.5393007397651672,
-0.7691066861152649,
-0.5502741932868958,
0.5491378307342529,
-0.5042309165000916,
0.4366084635257721,
-0.03543136641383171,
-0.2998006045818329,
0.04964488372206688,
0.37006402015686035,
0.18159793317317963,
-0.004930779803544283,
-0.5861457586288452,
0.18538826704025269,
-0.08361861109733582,
-0.4489785134792328,
-0.8202465772628784,
0.8033451437950134,
-0.6171820163726807,
-0.5932320356369019,
-0.2951555848121643,
-0.7245019674301147,
-0.4105376899242401,
0.20906493067741394,
-0.20141242444515228,
0.48922666907310486,
-0.2910744249820709,
0.21968020498752594,
0.4794718325138092,
-0.037065327167510986,
0.2942134141921997,
0.6781125664710999,
-0.5595349669456482,
-0.4051411747932434,
0.5665977001190186,
0.20598071813583374,
0.18088196218013763,
0.4803597629070282,
0.3355135917663574,
-0.39155182242393494,
-0.6617710590362549,
-0.31276920437812805,
0.16894426941871643,
-0.7392005324363708,
-0.25160083174705505,
-0.38949650526046753,
-0.00016077843611128628,
-0.08661052584648132,
-0.05078232288360596,
-0.6591289043426514,
-0.27936258912086487,
-0.036056023091077805,
0.2822781503200531,
0.026707708835601807,
0.6135711669921875,
0.28723832964897156,
0.06164715439081192,
-0.8402977585792542,
0.10918259620666504,
0.526384711265564,
0.44861701130867004,
-0.041517533361911774,
-0.48621171712875366,
-0.21924035251140594,
-0.07518614828586578,
-0.4384559094905853,
-0.49842196702957153,
0.35648617148399353,
0.13761213421821594,
0.8535175919532776,
0.41546180844306946,
-0.09153076261281967,
0.7977401614189148,
-0.6054356694221497,
0.44176116585731506,
0.10282645374536514,
-1.2602952718734741,
0.46642300486564636,
-0.3211253583431244,
0.22741471230983734,
0.16823476552963257,
0.3505593240261078,
-0.4071408808231354,
0.0831417515873909,
-0.30492597818374634,
-0.3985658884048462,
0.14366844296455383,
0.20305629074573517,
0.40302059054374695,
-0.06898786127567291,
0.31384745240211487,
0.2643108367919922,
0.3811861574649811,
-0.3758433163166046,
-0.0041226535104215145,
0.26517489552497864,
-0.013393649831414223,
-0.29605674743652344,
-0.4485151767730713,
-0.2193470150232315,
0.007751272525638342,
0.418700635433197,
0.0407700315117836,
0.2467694878578186,
-0.05996343865990639,
-0.1846844106912613,
-0.1975145936012268,
0.24011366069316864,
0.8098879456520081,
1.15255868434906,
-0.007278087083250284,
0.030582880601286888,
0.2720690667629242,
-0.03635004907846451,
0.07573205977678299,
0.1014053151011467,
0.15849930047988892,
0.16649311780929565,
0.3881611227989197,
0.4374972879886627,
0.5367482900619507,
-0.9864309430122375,
0.512147843837738,
0.04721341282129288,
-0.26719731092453003,
-0.1939409226179123,
0.22886857390403748,
0.19150498509407043,
0.2548398971557617,
0.5903056263923645,
0.20250555872917175,
0.2132275551557541,
-0.4358905851840973,
-0.034547798335552216,
0.530809760093689,
-0.1559928059577942,
-0.25865328311920166,
0.5487515926361084,
0.42813077569007874,
-0.6772048473358154,
0.26831862330436707,
0.11306817829608917,
-0.4559703767299652,
0.9351163506507874,
0.6839369535446167,
0.6576787233352661,
-0.3689052164554596,
-0.08763802796602249,
0.28986459970474243,
0.11210361868143082,
-0.07851417362689972,
0.14362822473049164,
-0.0076205232180655,
-0.6172610521316528,
-0.4897013008594513,
-0.6327437162399292,
-0.7694435119628906,
-0.038683898746967316,
-0.8719159960746765,
0.3763536512851715,
-0.641918957233429,
-0.37107524275779724,
0.144801065325737,
0.22480273246765137,
-0.4343651235103607,
0.28204822540283203,
0.17081110179424286,
0.8570144772529602,
-0.6088870167732239,
0.7395719885826111,
0.770058274269104,
-0.014677372761070728,
-0.08049342781305313,
-0.5078194737434387,
0.1648637354373932,
-0.9311795830726624,
0.6595675349235535,
0.37786659598350525,
-0.43144845962524414,
-0.21439611911773682,
-0.2133893370628357,
-0.8265987038612366,
1.1396669149398804,
0.5842161774635315,
-0.7716074585914612,
0.3930980861186981,
0.008132204413414001,
0.5929378271102905,
-0.6540418863296509,
0.3671707510948181,
0.21624751389026642,
0.3141702711582184,
-0.020051470026373863,
-0.9619879722595215,
-0.13523201644420624,
-0.48386600613594055,
0.5237065553665161,
0.394758403301239,
-0.6975764036178589,
1.1913248300552368,
-0.22603905200958252,
-0.13133813440799713,
0.37120211124420166,
0.5236473679542542,
0.26054590940475464,
0.5176063179969788,
0.43408259749412537,
0.36885231733322144,
0.7752050161361694,
-0.29687443375587463,
1.2244787216186523,
-0.09383600950241089,
0.5145004987716675,
0.8974214792251587,
-0.5157192349433899,
0.9922924041748047,
0.35497868061065674,
-0.5287657380104065,
0.4081832766532898,
0.4164678752422333,
-0.09149806946516037,
0.2129674106836319,
0.5744309425354004,
-0.3424295485019684,
-0.6225964426994324,
-0.18988388776779175,
-0.5977526307106018,
0.47880232334136963,
0.29331308603286743,
-0.2198231965303421,
-0.18459151685237885,
-0.13874433934688568,
0.067122682929039,
0.6138461828231812,
-0.4862137734889984,
0.4283568561077118,
0.12683939933776855,
-0.27211007475852966,
0.45065343379974365,
0.0343334823846817,
0.5238305926322937,
-0.6197354197502136,
-0.026299817487597466,
-0.2893354296684265,
0.3661412000656128,
0.0056573753245174885,
-0.5049268007278442,
0.4813406467437744,
0.1440337747335434,
-0.20317253470420837,
-0.17367903888225555,
0.44032520055770874,
-0.08367736637592316,
-0.8945621252059937,
0.3322431743144989,
0.5990219712257385,
0.16455739736557007,
-0.06896098703145981,
-0.743288516998291,
0.46049076318740845,
-0.45834460854530334,
-0.13849665224552155,
0.17099784314632416,
0.47591593861579895,
-0.0925212875008583,
1.1929560899734497,
0.9436866641044617,
-0.09811580181121826,
0.045996908098459244,
0.189503476023674,
0.7146786451339722,
-0.584048330783844,
-0.17895852029323578,
-0.9845862984657288,
0.3179367780685425,
-0.1637972593307495,
-0.49688592553138733,
0.8204069137573242,
0.8649423122406006,
0.7914437651634216,
-0.19805499911308289,
0.5848414301872253,
0.36735835671424866,
0.5946526527404785,
-0.6276919841766357,
0.5694509148597717,
-0.7688483595848083,
0.4757603704929352,
-0.32464107871055603,
-1.2268614768981934,
-0.49031734466552734,
0.7092377543449402,
-0.6654036641120911,
0.2120675891637802,
0.46203115582466125,
0.5678666830062866,
0.08486819267272949,
-0.14805088937282562,
0.7770374417304993,
0.11100740730762482,
0.29326575994491577,
0.598278284072876,
1.2097551822662354,
-0.3972892761230469,
0.7543873190879822,
-0.11940938234329224,
-0.09516157954931259,
-0.45464664697647095,
-1.0928497314453125,
-0.8802486062049866,
-0.21398068964481354,
-0.2279280126094818,
0.06168137863278389,
0.025943011045455933,
0.9033475518226624,
0.6842564344406128,
-0.6281648874282837,
-0.6036235690116882,
0.1023445799946785,
0.2565799653530121,
-0.38908249139785767,
-0.14870785176753998,
-0.19418926537036896,
-0.34622955322265625,
-0.9280254244804382,
0.36961233615875244,
0.5257746577262878,
-0.058798450976610184,
-0.39825406670570374,
-0.14210663735866547,
0.11471966654062271,
0.3610328435897827,
0.6105506420135498,
-0.01821400783956051,
-0.6905238628387451,
0.16781730949878693,
0.09170126914978027,
-0.10763141512870789,
0.2095360904932022,
1.0312020778656006,
-0.4930800497531891,
0.6583499908447266,
0.3457505404949188,
0.8447110056877136,
0.5480955243110657,
-0.16252680122852325,
0.7396703362464905,
-0.1060844212770462,
0.11524553596973419,
0.24642091989517212,
0.4986814260482788,
0.40140101313591003,
0.08951829373836517,
0.6026855707168579,
0.22171829640865326,
-0.4570509195327759,
-1.0075714588165283,
0.14844539761543274,
-0.7620515823364258,
-0.0664500966668129,
0.678974449634552,
-0.3528013825416565,
-0.21376082301139832,
0.13936081528663635,
-0.1362764686346054,
-0.009752096608281136,
-0.17043264210224152,
0.8743492960929871,
0.7785581350326538,
0.043614424765110016,
-0.26244765520095825,
-0.8427408337593079,
-0.08487332612276077,
0.5923455953598022,
-0.8709352612495422,
-0.033696189522743225,
0.4051298499107361,
0.3545072376728058,
0.08253805339336395,
0.3445042371749878,
-0.49128779768943787,
0.190097838640213,
0.003643670352175832,
0.021874794736504555,
-0.43970412015914917,
-0.11707045137882233,
-0.3666209280490875,
0.1346086710691452,
0.17438636720180511,
-0.2769774794578552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13135v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13135v1
|
Dataset Mention Extraction in Scientific Articles Using Bi-LSTM-CRF Model
| 2024-05-21T18:12:37 | 2024-05-21T18:12:37 |
Tong Zeng, Daniel Acuna
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Datasets are critical for scientific research, playing an important role in
replication, reproducibility, and efficiency. Researchers have recently shown
that datasets are becoming more important for science to function properly,
even serving as artifacts of study themselves. However, citing datasets is not
a common or standard practice in spite of recent efforts by data repositories
and funding agencies. This greatly affects our ability to track their usage and
importance. A potential solution to this problem is to automatically extract
dataset mentions from scientific articles. In this work, we propose to achieve
such extraction by using a neural network based on a Bi-LSTM-CRF architecture.
Our method achieves F1 = 0.885 in social science articles released as part of
the Rich Context Dataset. We discuss the limitations of the current datasets
and propose modifications to the model to be done in the future.
|
[
-0.295648992061615,
-0.5660205483436584,
0.4229174554347992,
0.2102886438369751,
-0.6170942187309265,
-0.3376038670539856,
-0.4098998010158539,
-0.7797528505325317,
0.3998958170413971,
0.37956514954566956,
-0.19017867743968964,
-0.25244683027267456,
-0.7131248116493225,
0.43365389108657837,
-0.7351194620132446,
1.1061724424362183,
0.13079357147216797,
0.33579763770103455,
-0.41684848070144653,
-0.07823611795902252,
-0.1396602839231491,
-0.36552807688713074,
-0.1399790495634079,
-0.46807414293289185,
1.0645228624343872,
0.14911890029907227,
0.3142020106315613,
1.0112972259521484,
0.6680614352226257,
0.22204743325710297,
-0.22860194742679596,
0.29005804657936096,
-0.34673014283180237,
0.09207842499017715,
-0.3422923684120178,
-0.20725344121456146,
-0.43583977222442627,
-0.10261072218418121,
0.7376599311828613,
0.9504756331443787,
0.31827840209007263,
0.28209683299064636,
0.21473179757595062,
0.5294572710990906,
-0.14161580801010132,
0.46526846289634705,
-0.6832071542739868,
-0.05798261985182762,
-0.23742307722568512,
-0.3775878846645355,
-0.2467370480298996,
-0.4430210292339325,
0.5412474274635315,
-0.5322166681289673,
0.19931374490261078,
0.1669272631406784,
0.8295885324478149,
-0.25034505128860474,
-0.2588375508785248,
-0.12018785625696182,
-0.6662676334381104,
0.8060382008552551,
-0.8109250068664551,
0.2555420696735382,
0.2832787334918976,
-0.056160278618335724,
-0.11009304970502853,
-0.9161381721496582,
-0.30948662757873535,
-0.1850138157606125,
-0.17996619641780853,
-0.22324101626873016,
0.039790548384189606,
-0.24690335988998413,
0.21167738735675812,
0.19681207835674286,
-0.31174930930137634,
-0.3668152391910553,
-0.7275016903877258,
0.055878497660160065,
0.7144579887390137,
0.08218900114297867,
-0.1470033824443817,
-0.41855931282043457,
-0.4254307448863983,
0.1899896115064621,
-0.7737622261047363,
-0.3516794741153717,
-0.08806708455085754,
0.6826657056808472,
0.18201805651187897,
0.7228862047195435,
-0.18160991370677948,
0.6165168881416321,
-0.284572571516037,
0.4042569100856781,
0.4181627333164215,
-0.8242151737213135,
-0.11267068237066269,
0.36340153217315674,
0.742388904094696,
0.3064979016780853,
0.5484285950660706,
-0.46212226152420044,
-0.012106450274586678,
-0.31429174542427063,
0.14855201542377472,
-0.760433554649353,
-0.3107249438762665,
0.055441249161958694,
-0.4277099668979645,
-0.3837225139141083,
0.2832564115524292,
-0.9039338827133179,
-0.5975650548934937,
-0.46325990557670593,
0.16795870661735535,
-0.27071359753608704,
-0.253246009349823,
-0.2590879499912262,
-0.08828536421060562,
-0.06498721241950989,
0.3742383122444153,
-0.3904094994068146,
-0.012579298578202724,
0.6240657567977905,
0.9329630732536316,
-0.2960820496082306,
-0.2763969898223877,
-0.2490982711315155,
0.19018571078777313,
-0.14198091626167297,
0.9538999795913696,
-0.47963154315948486,
-0.2769632339477539,
-0.007996974512934685,
0.1629382073879242,
-0.12098663300275803,
-0.509747326374054,
0.27906328439712524,
-0.7559995055198669,
-0.08916105329990387,
-0.4284335970878601,
-0.8685981035232544,
-0.2357957661151886,
0.2669570744037628,
-0.9645510315895081,
1.0063308477401733,
0.04942891001701355,
-0.9140339493751526,
0.42771732807159424,
-0.6667283177375793,
-0.5475981831550598,
0.23991815745830536,
-0.031551241874694824,
-0.4107876718044281,
-0.12176057696342468,
0.12791995704174042,
0.5079158544540405,
-0.3727043569087982,
0.7737534046173096,
-0.6707204580307007,
-0.2561022937297821,
0.5989819765090942,
-0.23968486487865448,
0.7574770450592041,
0.18706366419792175,
-0.11658202111721039,
0.1080085039138794,
-0.821211040019989,
-0.11784838885068893,
-0.038635432720184326,
-0.34747299551963806,
-0.6239103674888611,
-0.01570276729762554,
0.3127813935279846,
0.04455632343888283,
0.20074822008609772,
-0.4610317051410675,
0.09275490045547485,
-0.20539383590221405,
0.5199005007743835,
0.5207056999206543,
0.5587669014930725,
0.5818716287612915,
-0.2399325668811798,
0.07290246337652206,
0.27425655722618103,
-0.08940759301185608,
-0.13050027191638947,
-0.4274393618106842,
-0.5000780820846558,
-0.23021812736988068,
0.8716108798980713,
0.2692785859107971,
-0.5734655261039734,
0.6069668531417847,
-0.5157044529914856,
-0.44765594601631165,
-0.26284050941467285,
0.3448520302772522,
0.08561403304338455,
0.8404181599617004,
0.38604655861854553,
-0.044508419930934906,
-0.9532394409179688,
-0.886268675327301,
-0.43582093715667725,
0.1436610221862793,
0.015467831864953041,
0.5730044841766357,
0.7297279238700867,
0.05124632269144058,
1.3109571933746338,
-0.290002703666687,
-0.09815363585948944,
-0.3105916380882263,
0.16006582975387573,
0.41826027631759644,
0.5503593683242798,
0.26742103695869446,
-1.0256496667861938,
-0.22187967598438263,
-0.19158026576042175,
-1.0128146409988403,
0.007954349741339684,
-0.12821811437606812,
-0.19763027131557465,
-0.18559516966342926,
0.43279603123664856,
-0.6424962282180786,
0.4989161491394043,
-0.25688108801841736,
-0.29617342352867126,
0.5597059726715088,
0.2520081400871277,
-0.1255890429019928,
-1.1563533544540405,
0.5741491317749023,
0.48550504446029663,
-0.3043239414691925,
-0.5952422022819519,
-0.5137060284614563,
0.16364572942256927,
0.04961346089839935,
-0.560981810092926,
0.5683612823486328,
-0.5579512715339661,
-0.22202818095684052,
-0.14171037077903748,
0.23064552247524261,
0.2375013530254364,
0.19902709126472473,
0.3447655439376831,
0.3629584014415741,
0.4100114405155182,
-0.8304467797279358,
0.34400275349617004,
0.4536765217781067,
-0.6208772659301758,
0.3358616828918457,
-0.7823504209518433,
-0.17556461691856384,
0.005198154132813215,
0.3188594877719879,
-0.35251572728157043,
-0.06346818059682846,
0.31148427724838257,
-0.30518028140068054,
0.012709232047200203,
0.10254818201065063,
-0.5886052846908569,
-0.187759131193161,
-0.13147467374801636,
0.23888744413852692,
-0.03219258785247803,
-0.3608335852622986,
0.3182953894138336,
0.47489503026008606,
-0.3101252317428589,
-0.3118877410888672,
-0.5964465141296387,
0.2848908007144928,
-0.2602338492870331,
-0.30611494183540344,
0.2838037610054016,
-0.1953623741865158,
-0.152202770113945,
0.2697545289993286,
-0.09675969183444977,
-0.04646532982587814,
0.1215100809931755,
0.27440395951271057,
0.5934316515922546,
-0.19174562394618988,
0.25512203574180603,
-0.37761908769607544,
0.06508166342973709,
0.1894206404685974,
0.06502821296453476,
0.2646058201789856,
-0.11812277883291245,
0.1171165257692337,
-0.4007308781147003,
0.4276781380176544,
0.24389412999153137,
-0.25410231947898865,
0.6364578604698181,
0.41998153924942017,
-0.5806048512458801,
-0.12866057455539703,
-0.26182079315185547,
-0.5765111446380615,
-0.3777725398540497,
0.7026151418685913,
0.30473077297210693,
-0.4660090506076813,
0.6094012260437012,
-0.23172201216220856,
0.08672724664211273,
0.4563038647174835,
0.24268241226673126,
-0.23663447797298431,
0.6371315717697144,
0.35377129912376404,
-0.2133316695690155,
0.760921061038971,
-0.35729825496673584,
0.1688917875289917,
-0.9374924302101135,
-0.5342292785644531,
-0.8163915872573853,
-0.40718668699264526,
0.039553552865982056,
-0.024557476863265038,
0.16038279235363007,
0.08238054066896439,
-0.15426653623580933,
0.6136707067489624,
-0.5519989132881165,
0.22694113850593567,
0.5785526633262634,
0.2898564636707306,
0.3355579674243927,
0.37011581659317017,
0.18300828337669373,
0.20058158040046692,
-0.8025599718093872,
-0.5192127227783203,
0.8715611696243286,
0.2586143910884857,
0.5158421397209167,
-0.38899490237236023,
0.7108553051948547,
0.5408085584640503,
0.7447959780693054,
-0.8193875551223755,
0.6746821403503418,
0.2527068555355072,
-0.7699946165084839,
-0.24462275207042694,
-0.5025498270988464,
-0.9861637353897095,
-0.04581274464726448,
-0.24599456787109375,
-0.6015962362289429,
0.7532487511634827,
-0.08897562325000763,
-0.3968496024608612,
0.0493120439350605,
-0.1807308793067932,
0.49879828095436096,
-0.01184763852506876,
-0.39778968691825867,
-0.0016899557085707784,
-0.7574496269226074,
0.13483776152133942,
0.0527622289955616,
0.38807085156440735,
-0.04189254343509674,
0.22121131420135498,
1.176314353942871,
-0.058443401008844376,
0.8833067417144775,
-0.2840055823326111,
0.11866311728954315,
0.4697057008743286,
-0.08854827284812927,
0.6355961561203003,
0.3024163842201233,
-0.3540304899215698,
0.4580608308315277,
-0.0034649213775992393,
-0.11370790749788284,
-0.23815606534481049,
0.6262301206588745,
-0.4595501124858856,
-0.27953433990478516,
-0.6515884399414062,
-0.8248672485351562,
-0.18927639722824097,
0.34255853295326233,
0.1131344810128212,
0.4014160931110382,
-0.14637446403503418,
0.6405888795852661,
0.6571366786956787,
0.35826748609542847,
0.8260071277618408,
0.3346916437149048,
0.17173856496810913,
-0.8073666095733643,
0.6539885997772217,
0.43892624974250793,
-0.25470981001853943,
-0.1355251967906952,
0.0009768009185791016,
-0.22811159491539001,
-0.5165876150131226,
-0.3809014558792114,
0.21617071330547333,
-0.6179094910621643,
-0.6747758984565735,
-0.6301996111869812,
-0.44081294536590576,
-0.38901254534721375,
0.09019654244184494,
-0.2113010734319687,
-0.49113449454307556,
-0.7865243554115295,
-0.21033450961112976,
0.46215710043907166,
0.6119109988212585,
0.01651374250650406,
0.05208909139037132,
-0.9945217967033386,
0.07509267330169678,
-0.1613466590642929,
0.43108609318733215,
0.16722556948661804,
-0.44264382123947144,
-0.8270984292030334,
0.15279130637645721,
0.06864621490240097,
-0.8570449948310852,
0.43112659454345703,
0.3638196885585785,
0.708173394203186,
0.29692724347114563,
0.10354920476675034,
0.7032615542411804,
-0.44755852222442627,
0.7581855058670044,
0.1309141218662262,
-0.39252838492393494,
0.3464150130748749,
-0.32719719409942627,
-0.13627727329730988,
0.7080695033073425,
0.33858951926231384,
-0.2836425006389618,
0.06073756143450737,
-0.7215943932533264,
-1.1161774396896362,
0.6702556014060974,
0.03463217616081238,
0.11733479797840118,
-0.2072531133890152,
0.449770450592041,
0.19678927958011627,
0.478952020406723,
-0.8653845191001892,
-0.2663433849811554,
-0.1497805118560791,
-0.24227340519428253,
0.1461581587791443,
-0.24985653162002563,
-0.5087880492210388,
-0.3042280972003937,
0.877298891544342,
0.0254440326243639,
0.3416565954685211,
0.6276125907897949,
-0.3833087384700775,
-0.09670868515968323,
0.06819209456443787,
0.6143392324447632,
0.8105925917625427,
-0.20222237706184387,
0.23481816053390503,
-0.24763396382331848,
-0.5557893514633179,
-0.4333920478820801,
0.33757004141807556,
-0.4004657566547394,
0.19946415722370148,
0.3938652575016022,
0.41399797797203064,
0.36651861667633057,
-0.4902018904685974,
0.40558740496635437,
0.27426671981811523,
-0.3394496738910675,
-0.46947601437568665,
-0.019669463858008385,
0.26494908332824707,
0.5495156645774841,
0.6985710263252258,
0.2905806303024292,
0.21966177225112915,
-0.2185000777244568,
0.6069071888923645,
0.2200034111738205,
-0.5115063190460205,
-0.5137325525283813,
0.24945299327373505,
0.16684459149837494,
-0.19063681364059448,
0.5980699062347412,
0.15913984179496765,
-0.4089629352092743,
0.8495036959648132,
0.6036997437477112,
0.8059502840042114,
0.2130616456270218,
0.18980664014816284,
0.43945059180259705,
0.026031501591205597,
-0.3353903293609619,
0.18802253901958466,
-0.20360617339611053,
-0.53131103515625,
-0.05221831053495407,
-0.7159974575042725,
-0.19409054517745972,
0.15837348997592926,
-0.6650880575180054,
0.30273377895355225,
-0.3541231155395508,
-0.26045751571655273,
0.3357554078102112,
0.10943086445331573,
-0.6875597238540649,
0.12633182108402252,
0.25878655910491943,
1.0956997871398926,
-0.8600834608078003,
0.8819189071655273,
0.496185302734375,
-0.39946573972702026,
-0.6807028651237488,
-0.5132015943527222,
-0.3737110197544098,
-0.22149658203125,
0.7662848830223083,
0.0050869048573076725,
0.3229042887687683,
0.04246753454208374,
-0.81390380859375,
-0.906667172908783,
1.2929540872573853,
0.2703518569469452,
-0.6410093903541565,
0.044747818261384964,
0.051359809935092926,
0.46406006813049316,
-0.9352114200592041,
0.13807637989521027,
0.21760161221027374,
0.8713632822036743,
0.0713268294930458,
-0.42933738231658936,
0.08981361985206604,
-0.5949969291687012,
-0.08226266503334045,
-0.2738475501537323,
-0.4295342266559601,
0.7389141917228699,
-0.057226285338401794,
0.21466222405433655,
0.07879886776208878,
0.8793432116508484,
0.5843073129653931,
0.8557587265968323,
0.39126914739608765,
0.05978571996092796,
0.623183012008667,
0.1385333389043808,
0.6545630097389221,
-0.3523430824279785,
0.45713701844215393,
1.206986427307129,
-0.6110935211181641,
0.6772160530090332,
0.8943064212799072,
-0.020369062200188637,
0.3909352123737335,
0.9199555516242981,
-0.6321200132369995,
0.6763949990272522,
0.13147085905075073,
-0.11766870319843292,
-0.18826764822006226,
-0.3089470863342285,
-0.5310053825378418,
0.18556341528892517,
0.5357378721237183,
-1.0972174406051636,
-0.38515132665634155,
-0.1813298761844635,
0.17876528203487396,
-0.2521657347679138,
-0.45097196102142334,
0.776170015335083,
0.45838481187820435,
-0.5986049771308899,
0.19748559594154358,
-0.35862916707992554,
0.2712046802043915,
-0.45708030462265015,
-0.32262617349624634,
-0.1477791965007782,
0.005632020533084869,
-0.4023658335208893,
-0.47921615839004517,
0.2501084804534912,
0.0309604462236166,
-0.3825586438179016,
-0.0814928263425827,
0.9610326886177063,
-0.6745518445968628,
-0.6743512153625488,
0.23292139172554016,
0.5149962306022644,
0.17959868907928467,
0.10432355105876923,
-0.7471922039985657,
-0.20709367096424103,
-0.04101977124810219,
-0.9583802223205566,
0.27773788571357727,
0.2525285482406616,
-0.020218847319483757,
0.40062493085861206,
0.7768494486808777,
0.4872874915599823,
-0.06757070124149323,
0.0852007046341896,
1.1102819442749023,
-0.7977746725082397,
-0.4162950813770294,
-0.8705760836601257,
0.4246678352355957,
-0.4957261085510254,
-0.18196909129619598,
0.7278388142585754,
0.6994929313659668,
0.2544770836830139,
-0.03222730755805969,
0.8861293792724609,
-0.17134827375411987,
0.466341495513916,
0.03749942407011986,
0.9095295071601868,
-0.3478381037712097,
0.5346847772598267,
-0.19113774597644806,
-1.0813952684402466,
-0.5261062979698181,
0.4817144274711609,
-0.2118520885705948,
0.16475224494934082,
0.6264299154281616,
0.6500738263130188,
-0.15916618704795837,
0.449764221906662,
-0.129622682929039,
0.3138469159603119,
0.12857890129089355,
-0.05711705610156059,
0.3014410138130188,
-0.3228200078010559,
0.5783436894416809,
-0.46287471055984497,
0.06691175699234009,
-0.37795963883399963,
-1.2876819372177124,
-0.8438568711280823,
-0.5652296543121338,
-0.5301132798194885,
-0.47368690371513367,
0.06210922822356224,
0.9591702222824097,
0.6282180547714233,
-1.0087945461273193,
-0.0025373336393386126,
-0.049042943865060806,
-0.056736771017313004,
-0.3294597268104553,
-0.25112825632095337,
0.7701895833015442,
-0.16530269384384155,
-0.37930434942245483,
0.4340035319328308,
0.05808097869157791,
-0.2229580283164978,
-0.1986202746629715,
0.1626635640859604,
-0.6201015710830688,
0.0838041603565216,
0.2922300100326538,
0.30723991990089417,
-0.15492099523544312,
-0.3869051933288574,
0.12651300430297852,
-0.196661576628685,
0.1069578230381012,
0.8220543265342712,
-0.987454354763031,
0.09943821281194687,
0.511515200138092,
0.6225247383117676,
0.41887542605400085,
0.01811733841896057,
0.39145344495773315,
-0.6167669892311096,
-0.14361009001731873,
0.4656792879104614,
0.576233983039856,
0.4084279537200928,
-0.6073396801948547,
0.5105720162391663,
0.5500468015670776,
-0.6423777937889099,
-1.2036635875701904,
-0.2350478172302246,
-1.224047303199768,
-0.05106882378458977,
1.0576320886611938,
-0.24494190514087677,
-0.7769076824188232,
-0.268743097782135,
0.17780353128910065,
0.5296953320503235,
-0.5560188293457031,
0.9809443354606628,
0.6177144050598145,
-0.05064178630709648,
-0.24528925120830536,
-0.4206012189388275,
0.34332627058029175,
0.2595060169696808,
-0.6123167872428894,
0.46472787857055664,
0.3210747539997101,
0.48888280987739563,
0.3008824288845062,
0.2117670476436615,
-0.4485045373439789,
0.2745843231678009,
-0.15473908185958862,
0.32372424006462097,
-0.5626033544540405,
-0.3492085635662079,
-0.1422668993473053,
0.21561114490032196,
-0.3316444158554077,
0.1533646285533905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13131v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13131v1
|
Atomic Self-Consistency for Better Long Form Generations
| 2024-05-21T18:05:44 | 2024-05-21T18:05:44 |
Raghuveer Thirukovalluru, Yukun Huang, Bhuwan Dhingra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work has aimed to improve LLM generations by filtering out
hallucinations, thereby improving the precision of the information in
responses. Correctness of a long-form response, however, also depends on the
recall of multiple pieces of information relevant to the question. In this
paper, we introduce Atomic Self-Consistency (ASC), a technique for improving
the recall of relevant information in an LLM response. ASC follows recent work,
Universal Self-Consistency (USC) in using multiple stochastic samples from an
LLM to improve the long-form response. Unlike USC which only focuses on
selecting the best single generation, ASC picks authentic subparts from the
samples and merges them into a superior composite answer. Through extensive
experiments and ablations, we show that merging relevant subparts of multiple
samples performs significantly better than picking a single sample. ASC
demonstrates significant gains over USC on multiple factoids and open-ended QA
datasets - ASQA, QAMPARI, QUEST, ELI5 with ChatGPT and Llama2. Our analysis
also reveals untapped potential for enhancing long-form generations using
approach of merging multiple samples.
|
[
-0.4605449438095093,
-0.5732247233390808,
0.612052857875824,
0.2509975731372833,
0.02555156499147415,
0.2640213072299957,
-0.1731029748916626,
-0.6008234024047852,
0.5014563798904419,
0.30454832315444946,
-0.5037358403205872,
-0.3334897458553314,
-0.256239116191864,
0.4692632853984833,
-0.23837800323963165,
0.6442610621452332,
-0.21427883207798004,
-0.18742376565933228,
-0.3898950219154358,
-0.39422765374183655,
-0.35248973965644836,
-0.4219364821910858,
-0.8729058504104614,
-0.4430082440376282,
0.41887569427490234,
0.3763224482536316,
0.5971410870552063,
0.7140336036682129,
0.28835833072662354,
0.2853865623474121,
0.1868990808725357,
0.47366100549697876,
-0.4164571166038513,
0.33698776364326477,
-0.26367586851119995,
-0.09766186028718948,
-0.5676952004432678,
-0.13795089721679688,
0.7858620882034302,
0.47297874093055725,
-0.3989667594432831,
-0.02545229159295559,
0.3581647574901581,
0.7124254703521729,
-0.7247034311294556,
-0.24855786561965942,
-0.355974942445755,
0.04383636265993118,
-0.18785059452056885,
-0.29730528593063354,
-0.3622194826602936,
-0.3802746534347534,
-0.41697028279304504,
-0.2930555045604706,
0.298349529504776,
-0.2021845430135727,
0.5597819089889526,
0.3051578104496002,
-0.5704099535942078,
-0.10604450851678848,
-0.8168690204620361,
0.4512733817100525,
-0.8027762174606323,
0.6011078953742981,
0.4502198398113251,
0.17207233607769012,
-0.36946725845336914,
-0.3199569582939148,
-0.6417673826217651,
-0.27287548780441284,
0.18033467233181,
0.5247424840927124,
0.06766090542078018,
0.2814253270626068,
0.1621067225933075,
0.3938569128513336,
-0.46280816197395325,
0.1692977398633957,
-0.4084315896034241,
-0.5443165898323059,
0.7202654480934143,
0.144705668091774,
0.03377412632107735,
-0.12643584609031677,
-0.44330137968063354,
-0.17535747587680817,
-0.8605732321739197,
0.0011648531071841717,
0.2972632646560669,
0.20618665218353271,
0.32149022817611694,
0.6730356812477112,
-0.5239027738571167,
0.20441435277462006,
0.23788130283355713,
-0.06174656003713608,
0.15333840250968933,
-0.5525756478309631,
0.09962296485900879,
0.18840426206588745,
0.7114372849464417,
0.005432050675153732,
0.010560267604887486,
-0.09167535603046417,
-0.039464320987463,
-0.06876159459352493,
0.37442174553871155,
-0.6316477656364441,
-0.215660959482193,
0.3413727879524231,
-0.550317645072937,
0.3131531774997711,
0.12148929387331009,
-0.6568021774291992,
-0.12442828714847565,
-0.5076388120651245,
0.47314614057540894,
-0.3864874839782715,
-0.06774037331342697,
0.0864761471748352,
-0.050924599170684814,
0.06536148488521576,
0.35095179080963135,
-0.9174968600273132,
0.21853718161582947,
0.45988890528678894,
0.5966301560401917,
-0.3425370156764984,
-0.5516147017478943,
-0.37154027819633484,
0.354446679353714,
-0.4632418751716614,
1.1211178302764893,
-0.1309284269809723,
-0.5178649425506592,
-0.24186600744724274,
-0.2723938226699829,
0.2767246663570404,
-1.048953652381897,
-0.102147676050663,
-0.34980034828186035,
0.05117790773510933,
-0.21260175108909607,
-0.5011887550354004,
0.19202424585819244,
0.15358683466911316,
-0.5684385299682617,
1.098763108253479,
0.11280085891485214,
-0.2947063148021698,
0.31501638889312744,
-0.2174978405237198,
-0.26607590913772583,
-0.17732669413089752,
-0.47342827916145325,
-0.48936727643013,
0.26180392503738403,
0.05352801829576492,
0.041382595896720886,
0.11960452795028687,
0.027723779901862144,
-0.7133463025093079,
-0.15686868131160736,
0.2702752649784088,
-0.5645129084587097,
0.4522051215171814,
0.46053317189216614,
-0.33506304025650024,
0.058929622173309326,
-0.6784932613372803,
0.22753497958183289,
-0.2545525133609772,
-0.5442624688148499,
-0.07678119093179703,
-0.15019074082374573,
-0.5353298187255859,
0.17628028988838196,
0.4349426031112671,
-0.609951913356781,
0.3263472020626068,
0.022533750161528587,
0.27970805764198303,
0.973939836025238,
0.18963328003883362,
0.16553446650505066,
-0.5404009222984314,
0.40146929025650024,
0.25540271401405334,
0.04424205422401428,
-0.043677106499671936,
-0.2049826681613922,
-0.7684916257858276,
-0.15876910090446472,
0.22263382375240326,
0.14695043861865997,
-0.6652060151100159,
0.5630006790161133,
-0.0596865639090538,
-0.13943007588386536,
-0.583347737789154,
0.3984391987323761,
0.20476001501083374,
0.22554297745227814,
0.5947933793067932,
-0.5846391916275024,
-0.7317511439323425,
-1.0074739456176758,
-0.1271367073059082,
-0.2734915018081665,
-0.0961407795548439,
0.18454228341579437,
0.17373047769069672,
-0.36564016342163086,
1.1044889688491821,
-0.32903626561164856,
-0.13225315511226654,
0.14286205172538757,
0.3577641248703003,
-0.008115284144878387,
0.5774312019348145,
-0.11728451400995255,
-0.40819239616394043,
-0.4049925208091736,
-0.29711320996284485,
-0.9057064056396484,
-0.056805871427059174,
-0.32319867610931396,
-0.2259884923696518,
0.3477056324481964,
0.610787570476532,
-0.5662310719490051,
0.37862512469291687,
0.29579976201057434,
-0.20857681334018707,
0.5402456521987915,
-0.5304293036460876,
0.5201646089553833,
-1.09548020362854,
-0.21156051754951477,
-0.21560624241828918,
-0.30554261803627014,
-0.46884292364120483,
0.06284867227077484,
0.383634090423584,
0.3806288242340088,
-0.29389604926109314,
0.49529844522476196,
-0.5633706450462341,
0.029893208295106888,
-0.5009273290634155,
-0.04843080788850784,
-0.19140589237213135,
0.08701258897781372,
-0.26488298177719116,
1.0234360694885254,
0.16177721321582794,
-0.606262743473053,
0.24375391006469727,
0.20800861716270447,
0.24776330590248108,
0.6509988903999329,
-0.45431140065193176,
0.47744038701057434,
-0.48823413252830505,
0.37984201312065125,
-0.9694960117340088,
-0.10362904518842697,
0.08812354505062103,
-0.44804707169532776,
0.3002166748046875,
0.45142585039138794,
-0.4387987554073334,
-0.45456019043922424,
-0.49760156869888306,
0.5590868592262268,
0.4977303743362427,
-0.7968886494636536,
1.0955867767333984,
-0.08466167747974396,
-0.06698877364397049,
-0.6156054139137268,
-0.37144753336906433,
-0.08943735063076019,
-0.08451749384403229,
-0.4208581745624542,
0.1343439817428589,
-0.56729656457901,
-0.07912691682577133,
-0.2158249020576477,
-0.5524712800979614,
0.09084957838058472,
-0.0663665235042572,
0.3185625970363617,
0.2757461667060852,
-0.37924885749816895,
0.25995540618896484,
-0.07392255961894989,
-0.06546495109796524,
-0.14851120114326477,
0.04439643770456314,
0.6232765913009644,
0.1252823770046234,
-0.367648720741272,
-0.656670093536377,
0.48508355021476746,
0.34412091970443726,
0.09470150619745255,
0.4308217167854309,
0.076319620013237,
-0.2937634289264679,
-0.2586730122566223,
-0.946994423866272,
-0.4780733585357666,
-0.4868498146533966,
-0.09085045754909515,
-0.5960942506790161,
-1.030914068222046,
0.7354007363319397,
0.045018166303634644,
-0.07243730872869492,
0.6783891916275024,
0.26253893971443176,
-0.31659290194511414,
0.9450896382331848,
0.4081629514694214,
-0.25073111057281494,
0.2841338813304901,
-0.09718743711709976,
-0.014978555962443352,
-0.8126900792121887,
-0.2932179272174835,
-0.39614957571029663,
-0.0957099199295044,
-0.2214905470609665,
-0.4245869219303131,
0.27804553508758545,
0.2245900183916092,
-0.34323009848594666,
0.09541243314743042,
-0.33747488260269165,
0.4704701900482178,
0.6298449039459229,
0.3446960747241974,
0.6996467113494873,
-0.04546547308564186,
0.2558344304561615,
0.13575637340545654,
-0.37802842259407043,
-0.271328866481781,
1.1225793361663818,
0.29503723978996277,
0.9853000640869141,
0.15752913057804108,
1.1698095798492432,
0.22148540616035461,
0.21977490186691284,
-0.38830840587615967,
0.5702285170555115,
-0.184380903840065,
-0.6804912686347961,
-0.44852086901664734,
-0.7173793911933899,
-1.112771987915039,
0.21239511668682098,
-0.2546361982822418,
-0.4134717285633087,
0.15265361964702606,
0.3213886022567749,
-0.7961864471435547,
0.02309669554233551,
-0.16492055356502533,
0.3577839434146881,
-0.1969376802444458,
-0.2455393671989441,
-0.4147644639015198,
-0.5368654727935791,
0.12910014390945435,
-0.24350029230117798,
-0.21316386759281158,
-0.28471991419792175,
0.19709163904190063,
0.6787292957305908,
-0.28895145654678345,
0.5748095512390137,
0.1559523046016693,
-0.20323839783668518,
0.4964440166950226,
-0.06363289058208466,
0.38622164726257324,
0.00699065113440156,
0.1892206370830536,
0.24810859560966492,
-0.14929305016994476,
-0.41176095604896545,
-0.7165343165397644,
0.6932048201560974,
-0.8624207973480225,
-0.7562894225120544,
-0.3835184574127197,
-0.4725516140460968,
-0.13808190822601318,
0.2192283421754837,
0.1932995468378067,
0.3479776382446289,
-0.17284953594207764,
0.30163654685020447,
0.8226926326751709,
0.28875866532325745,
0.35607099533081055,
0.5410304665565491,
0.016908898949623108,
-0.602091908454895,
0.5036517381668091,
0.47717684507369995,
0.41814249753952026,
-0.01669974811375141,
0.10294118523597717,
-0.4996325969696045,
-0.523077666759491,
-0.37111151218414307,
0.43322059512138367,
-0.5689454078674316,
-0.5482474565505981,
-0.763102650642395,
-0.4293113052845001,
-0.927776575088501,
-0.10950426757335663,
-0.5031671524047852,
-0.2497144490480423,
-0.28413906693458557,
-0.075444795191288,
0.03862975537776947,
0.6602798104286194,
-0.5575535893440247,
0.08122428506612778,
-0.8090241551399231,
0.9222245812416077,
0.6597152948379517,
0.2632977366447449,
0.011100778356194496,
-0.38191455602645874,
0.10058619827032089,
0.30069729685783386,
-0.45446518063545227,
-0.778872013092041,
-0.023509593680500984,
0.38235002756118774,
0.7697893381118774,
0.5022286176681519,
0.11748445779085159,
1.1302324533462524,
-0.3632260262966156,
0.644647479057312,
0.25440144538879395,
-0.9285814762115479,
0.6315277814865112,
-0.19189749658107758,
0.4533521831035614,
1.0147898197174072,
0.35342761874198914,
-0.5521608591079712,
-0.649616003036499,
-0.8226009607315063,
-0.9798669815063477,
0.27499279379844666,
0.029456643387675285,
-0.14520083367824554,
-0.19549421966075897,
0.4862062931060791,
0.15806905925273895,
0.0592336542904377,
-0.44019782543182373,
-0.1272365152835846,
-0.23505643010139465,
-0.5318196415901184,
-0.24677616357803345,
-0.2419230043888092,
-0.3487933874130249,
0.06679917871952057,
0.6376341581344604,
-0.25158414244651794,
0.0993819460272789,
0.37079375982284546,
0.12999758124351501,
-0.084616519510746,
0.207566499710083,
0.38546836376190186,
0.5862640142440796,
-0.12464091926813126,
0.6147134304046631,
0.425933301448822,
-0.24614042043685913,
0.382901668548584,
-0.1498546451330185,
-0.020318936556577682,
-0.3892456591129303,
0.18354862928390503,
0.12284505367279053,
-0.19091904163360596,
-0.6017705798149109,
0.21194855868816376,
0.08519953489303589,
-0.10054001212120056,
-0.5211644172668457,
0.28126007318496704,
-0.12754639983177185,
0.3818413317203522,
0.5211848616600037,
-0.06507383286952972,
0.3579683303833008,
-1.0740801095962524,
0.5079466104507446,
0.5751703977584839,
0.03362029418349266,
-0.035896819084882736,
0.7418352365493774,
-0.268375426530838,
-0.10419393330812454,
1.0875957012176514,
0.07513800263404846,
-0.204834446310997,
0.6999593377113342,
0.9207034707069397,
0.6556228995323181,
-0.5183771252632141,
0.17844945192337036,
0.37054336071014404,
-0.10207805782556534,
-0.6811013221740723,
0.3218955993652344,
-0.317097544670105,
-0.7848016619682312,
-0.17276206612586975,
-0.34627583622932434,
-0.4361502230167389,
-0.20297761261463165,
-0.7559544444084167,
-0.18682311475276947,
-0.6115110516548157,
-0.13370321691036224,
-0.2699317932128906,
-0.007767874281853437,
-0.34114426374435425,
0.30283090472221375,
0.15318265557289124,
0.7056765556335449,
-0.8904909491539001,
0.8152508735656738,
0.31047266721725464,
-0.4994068741798401,
-1.0909379720687866,
-0.06712659448385239,
0.023429976776242256,
-0.7994640469551086,
0.2748495042324066,
0.12841248512268066,
-0.32572630047798157,
-0.11247438192367554,
-0.4894639253616333,
-1.252502202987671,
1.1560485363006592,
0.161326602101326,
-0.2424326092004776,
0.11495894938707352,
0.1057850643992424,
0.5984377861022949,
-0.3889300227165222,
0.3202309310436249,
0.630678653717041,
0.3547927439212799,
0.37838199734687805,
-0.9112110137939453,
0.19218206405639648,
-0.140760600566864,
0.12965120375156403,
0.29627272486686707,
-0.9268969297409058,
0.613713264465332,
-0.23719142377376556,
-0.4550105035305023,
0.25549569725990295,
1.3272591829299927,
0.8377916216850281,
0.5895856022834778,
0.45685237646102905,
0.7040126323699951,
0.856311023235321,
0.08758503943681717,
0.45195886492729187,
-0.23196284472942352,
0.3378808796405792,
1.361916184425354,
-0.1512732356786728,
1.0973174571990967,
0.5345345735549927,
-0.2894377112388611,
0.39142000675201416,
0.6126325130462646,
-0.04390867054462433,
0.3665221929550171,
0.0992807149887085,
-0.3306065797805786,
-0.29141098260879517,
0.04058428108692169,
-0.5159306526184082,
0.44401925802230835,
-0.12777017056941986,
0.10927668958902359,
-0.09578575193881989,
0.08873195946216583,
0.0086883045732975,
0.08746151626110077,
-0.3326041102409363,
0.8890665173530579,
0.06379247456789017,
-0.7307711243629456,
0.5433867573738098,
-0.5378281474113464,
0.8668158054351807,
-0.540169894695282,
-0.12400082498788834,
-0.5857144594192505,
0.1070956364274025,
-0.39823001623153687,
-0.6440792679786682,
0.19327175617218018,
-0.5997082591056824,
-0.400376558303833,
-0.13528591394424438,
0.5916510224342346,
-0.7236648797988892,
-0.09222069382667542,
0.2512683570384979,
0.2853139638900757,
0.3107716143131256,
-0.007383458316326141,
-0.20854239165782928,
-0.03350453078746796,
0.013679467141628265,
0.07422929257154465,
0.33196747303009033,
0.22919811308383942,
0.26913705468177795,
0.6822022199630737,
0.577223539352417,
0.31874576210975647,
0.1876666396856308,
-0.1856698840856552,
0.559929370880127,
-0.9180434942245483,
-0.29128938913345337,
-0.6828854084014893,
0.3982367515563965,
-0.23581114411354065,
-0.3311012089252472,
1.0224188566207886,
0.8284823298454285,
0.8432062864303589,
0.08207948505878448,
0.5207093954086304,
0.2026873677968979,
0.5018408894538879,
-0.6269298791885376,
0.526032567024231,
-0.55232834815979,
0.06436191499233246,
0.3382608890533447,
-1.0614203214645386,
-0.05646345764398575,
0.596306562423706,
0.2393830120563507,
0.3512301743030548,
0.8449311256408691,
0.6941636800765991,
0.21519950032234192,
0.08516207337379456,
0.2823886573314667,
0.2708761692047119,
0.43305060267448425,
0.5599446892738342,
0.8782604932785034,
-0.32358837127685547,
0.17368218302726746,
-0.3066844642162323,
-0.20622313022613525,
-0.10652738809585571,
-0.4335741102695465,
-0.4423117935657501,
-0.43850624561309814,
-0.3715629577636719,
-0.7792815566062927,
0.2673187255859375,
1.1779314279556274,
0.5405853986740112,
-0.8255050182342529,
-0.2187301218509674,
0.19184987246990204,
-0.17228887975215912,
-0.30559632182121277,
-0.1494307667016983,
0.20164844393730164,
-0.4724879562854767,
-0.4817390739917755,
0.6602909564971924,
0.4313449561595917,
0.3860700726509094,
-0.23628473281860352,
0.024059180170297623,
0.16572187840938568,
0.26333293318748474,
0.41960230469703674,
0.648762047290802,
-0.6342577338218689,
-0.7496723532676697,
-0.023529784753918648,
-0.20471297204494476,
0.5675567388534546,
0.725155234336853,
-0.8994302749633789,
0.465043306350708,
0.27081042528152466,
0.4807961881160736,
0.3383238911628723,
0.4440332055091858,
0.3980245292186737,
-0.3160669207572937,
-0.3595907986164093,
0.2960212826728821,
0.19989009201526642,
0.12865911424160004,
-0.5991707444190979,
0.5279797911643982,
-0.07028664648532867,
-0.887083113193512,
-0.4842974543571472,
0.3487332761287689,
-1.2544153928756714,
-0.3721327483654022,
1.1969457864761353,
0.149983212351799,
-0.05925364792346954,
-0.1992466002702713,
-0.0017837261548265815,
0.3198586106300354,
-0.5773031115531921,
1.3415672779083252,
0.5150860548019409,
-0.59501713514328,
0.002137627685442567,
-0.16238602995872498,
0.26440665125846863,
0.6113918423652649,
-1.0062443017959595,
0.14755718410015106,
0.7112763524055481,
0.3897125720977783,
0.3282693922519684,
1.1928069591522217,
-0.05664387345314026,
0.26139214634895325,
0.05752146616578102,
0.07437212765216827,
0.17087985575199127,
-0.6650702953338623,
-0.5301084518432617,
0.5112669467926025,
0.1396791636943817,
-0.03329802677035332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13127v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13127v1
|
Towards Retrieval-Augmented Architectures for Image Captioning
| 2024-05-21T18:02:07 | 2024-05-21T18:02:07 |
Sara Sarto, Marcella Cornia, Lorenzo Baraldi, Alessandro Nicolosi, Rita Cucchiara
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
The objective of image captioning models is to bridge the gap between the
visual and linguistic modalities by generating natural language descriptions
that accurately reflect the content of input images. In recent years,
researchers have leveraged deep learning-based models and made advances in the
extraction of visual features and the design of multimodal connections to
tackle this task. This work presents a novel approach towards developing image
captioning models that utilize an external kNN memory to improve the generation
process. Specifically, we propose two model variants that incorporate a
knowledge retriever component that is based on visual similarities, a
differentiable encoder to represent input images, and a kNN-augmented language
model to predict tokens based on contextual cues and text retrieved from the
external memory. We experimentally validate our approach on COCO and nocaps
datasets and demonstrate that incorporating an explicit external memory can
significantly enhance the quality of captions, especially with a larger
retrieval corpus. This work provides valuable insights into retrieval-augmented
captioning models and opens up new avenues for improving image captioning at a
larger scale.
|
[
-0.4144556224346161,
-0.2719087302684784,
0.4421679377555847,
-0.07267411053180695,
-0.4962977468967438,
0.06351432204246521,
-0.14193236827850342,
-0.6771635413169861,
0.2334379404783249,
0.5599165558815002,
0.0287336315959692,
-0.08096063137054443,
-0.5061588883399963,
0.16131728887557983,
-0.22179140150547028,
0.48754608631134033,
-0.2257300764322281,
0.3229732811450958,
-0.6374033093452454,
-0.36611106991767883,
-0.8042160868644714,
-0.4040932357311249,
-0.36894166469573975,
0.1604650467634201,
0.5983000993728638,
0.2559777498245239,
0.6679503321647644,
0.5969465374946594,
0.673705518245697,
0.2618613839149475,
0.13481590151786804,
0.3781849145889282,
-0.10237106680870056,
0.06452620029449463,
0.07221383601427078,
-0.610022783279419,
0.461410790681839,
-0.3677447736263275,
0.45419469475746155,
0.25523605942726135,
0.21857869625091553,
-0.10383673012256622,
-0.36242175102233887,
0.8742390275001526,
-0.7268292903900146,
0.6511042714118958,
-0.7022801041603088,
0.22347964346408844,
0.07824788987636566,
-0.3412097692489624,
-0.39593857526779175,
-0.04198679327964783,
0.27272751927375793,
-0.5785181522369385,
0.24891319870948792,
0.36646729707717896,
0.9573368430137634,
-0.020927682518959045,
-0.2944249212741852,
-0.35244154930114746,
-0.44328609108924866,
0.49268078804016113,
-0.5817364454269409,
0.5973719358444214,
0.4698670208454132,
0.6368985176086426,
0.26197853684425354,
-0.7216697335243225,
-0.5308110117912292,
-0.5397763848304749,
-0.352491170167923,
0.10499071329832077,
0.23447872698307037,
-0.16735704243183136,
0.012128888629376888,
0.6474550366401672,
-0.07385747879743576,
-0.22080865502357483,
-0.685941755771637,
-0.1697484701871872,
0.414674311876297,
-0.017420271411538124,
0.34379085898399353,
-0.4687204658985138,
-0.5258263945579529,
-0.12202700972557068,
-0.7109838724136353,
-0.05063924938440323,
0.1439264565706253,
0.5620126724243164,
-0.16146959364414215,
0.8416800498962402,
-0.30855226516723633,
0.45183753967285156,
-0.05699051171541214,
0.29443687200546265,
0.17763817310333252,
-0.347432941198349,
-0.010531734675168991,
0.12331722676753998,
0.5776296854019165,
0.4424121081829071,
0.06167096644639969,
-0.47075095772743225,
-0.2686428725719452,
-0.07770318537950516,
0.6320509910583496,
-0.6601821184158325,
-0.6858646869659424,
-0.23563021421432495,
-0.5442697405815125,
-0.3411582410335541,
0.1996917426586151,
-0.8451815843582153,
-0.5121373534202576,
-0.5333908796310425,
0.7030764222145081,
-0.583115816116333,
-0.012800074182450771,
-0.43416494131088257,
-0.19590453803539276,
0.27895021438598633,
0.14762935042381287,
-0.5509021282196045,
0.24002230167388916,
0.10518497973680496,
0.9253264665603638,
-0.2615654170513153,
0.11737620085477829,
-0.4388725459575653,
0.3127097487449646,
-0.4271727204322815,
0.7536078691482544,
-0.7651937007904053,
-0.1291254460811615,
0.2402276247739792,
0.08662837743759155,
0.20994675159454346,
-0.5701424479484558,
0.10840508341789246,
-1.3261457681655884,
-0.010144650004804134,
-0.5681439638137817,
-0.3196221888065338,
-0.4114188849925995,
0.5133537650108337,
-1.173421025276184,
0.6710662245750427,
-0.0490698479115963,
-0.7316703796386719,
0.3307163417339325,
-0.8925923109054565,
-0.6180012226104736,
0.1345536857843399,
-0.3065277934074402,
-0.35815107822418213,
0.31366968154907227,
0.5702447295188904,
0.27563053369522095,
-0.21460694074630737,
0.04182808846235275,
-0.13293500244617462,
-0.3121167719364166,
0.4467358887195587,
-0.3133133351802826,
0.08911114931106567,
0.22473393380641937,
0.11305657029151917,
0.13096441328525543,
-0.4976482093334198,
-0.1367986798286438,
0.4088634252548218,
-0.40237340331077576,
-0.4055776000022888,
-0.24738933145999908,
-0.16999496519565582,
0.11801283061504364,
0.3866216838359833,
-0.6794245839118958,
0.06904147565364838,
-0.3320784568786621,
0.5077914595603943,
0.6286396980285645,
0.18084943294525146,
0.7684128284454346,
-0.2623195946216583,
0.3846702575683594,
0.38581201434135437,
0.10079079121351242,
-0.8230684399604797,
-0.30260926485061646,
-0.7534099221229553,
-0.15606442093849182,
0.25186705589294434,
0.29190191626548767,
-1.353948712348938,
-0.24457867443561554,
-0.3813639283180237,
-0.13943998515605927,
-0.6292608380317688,
0.25046640634536743,
0.5075079798698425,
0.6837261915206909,
0.4813540577888489,
-0.5547884702682495,
-0.4933393895626068,
-1.0859407186508179,
0.21400970220565796,
0.15489189326763153,
0.3023945093154907,
1.0425951480865479,
0.3444456458091736,
-0.022407004609704018,
0.6352635025978088,
-0.36868810653686523,
-0.4221644103527069,
-0.04989376664161682,
-0.20279616117477417,
-0.00760047510266304,
0.32409903407096863,
0.3444351553916931,
-1.2535145282745361,
-0.5130261778831482,
0.12368091940879822,
-0.7196691036224365,
0.5396736264228821,
-0.00592653127387166,
-0.22976896166801453,
0.34619876742362976,
0.43807464838027954,
-0.87172931432724,
0.35983872413635254,
-0.056363485753536224,
0.2797582447528839,
0.7783759236335754,
-0.31380021572113037,
0.4567660987377167,
-0.8387631177902222,
0.24992910027503967,
-0.22138960659503937,
0.04740957170724869,
-0.06404493749141693,
0.5732828974723816,
0.13602283596992493,
-0.21619156002998352,
-0.647025465965271,
0.6424698233604431,
-0.770569384098053,
-0.3110387623310089,
-0.18094460666179657,
0.037880897521972656,
0.32053712010383606,
0.5403943061828613,
0.30960530042648315,
0.7187597751617432,
0.7960943579673767,
-0.5961319804191589,
0.5401942729949951,
0.3794623613357544,
-0.5383889079093933,
0.3926451504230499,
-0.4535696506500244,
0.2225428819656372,
-0.4823651909828186,
-0.008174758404493332,
-1.3153575658798218,
-0.38824331760406494,
0.1134793609380722,
-0.4139164388179779,
0.5766798257827759,
-0.44590240716934204,
-0.7954056859016418,
-0.5623976588249207,
-0.21022427082061768,
0.5207456350326538,
0.43855512142181396,
-0.8379229307174683,
0.7654305696487427,
0.001407148432917893,
-0.09120960533618927,
-0.5188338756561279,
-0.7426286935806274,
0.24497805535793304,
-0.1668730080127716,
-0.29759320616722107,
0.19003985822200775,
0.0591389499604702,
0.24146942794322968,
0.1628151684999466,
-0.01438649371266365,
-0.2619870901107788,
-0.42035818099975586,
0.316622257232666,
0.48296281695365906,
-0.38621246814727783,
0.31706732511520386,
-0.0003057061694562435,
0.19952036440372467,
-0.12996675074100494,
-0.2384273260831833,
0.49522849917411804,
-0.07800419628620148,
-0.1690824329853058,
-0.32605069875717163,
0.3033275306224823,
0.5054929852485657,
-0.4537571370601654,
0.81431645154953,
0.5372059345245361,
-0.30914539098739624,
0.3783128261566162,
-0.7409812211990356,
-0.2632088363170624,
-0.49148279428482056,
0.23650778830051422,
-0.5865464210510254,
-0.7217313647270203,
0.5905155539512634,
-0.00318145751953125,
-0.2556946873664856,
0.20168903470039368,
0.17531536519527435,
-0.42990046739578247,
0.761211097240448,
0.37999430298805237,
0.012206564657390118,
0.5288225412368774,
-0.4274573028087616,
0.0019620293751358986,
-1.031354308128357,
-0.40872085094451904,
0.07825189083814621,
-0.4373233914375305,
-0.14141534268856049,
-0.48836538195610046,
0.11761133372783661,
0.1593644618988037,
-0.3161051273345947,
0.5115644931793213,
-0.47868335247039795,
0.6254851222038269,
0.6660898327827454,
0.24713988602161407,
0.16161441802978516,
0.4613755941390991,
-0.5745642185211182,
-0.13759419322013855,
-0.7877005934715271,
-0.2816001772880554,
1.0294818878173828,
0.012801934964954853,
0.5609691143035889,
-0.017017440870404243,
0.4309249818325043,
0.2998873293399811,
0.5078293681144714,
-0.5054734349250793,
0.4300491213798523,
-0.19089049100875854,
-0.612773060798645,
0.08279192447662354,
-0.4519469738006592,
-0.8946452736854553,
0.12765447795391083,
-0.04294378310441971,
-0.45419126749038696,
0.08492117375135422,
0.1929267942905426,
-0.30238646268844604,
0.4550309181213379,
-0.5913156867027283,
0.8402010202407837,
-0.47709763050079346,
-0.302564412355423,
-0.06278716027736664,
-0.8789708018302917,
0.3736149072647095,
0.2779046595096588,
0.12413743883371353,
0.3510747253894806,
-0.14707055687904358,
0.33544546365737915,
-0.09350404888391495,
0.8251397609710693,
-0.38857752084732056,
0.1077721044421196,
0.7920524477958679,
0.36018070578575134,
0.36550623178482056,
-0.0022790853399783373,
0.04083272069692612,
0.12897968292236328,
0.08039072901010513,
-0.15832239389419556,
-0.6883071064949036,
0.8762778639793396,
-0.6104697585105896,
-0.15024076402187347,
0.07981842756271362,
-0.7296334505081177,
-0.07480501383543015,
0.24388891458511353,
0.035291507840156555,
0.6876047253608704,
0.13681666553020477,
0.2338532954454422,
0.4366382658481598,
-0.64043790102005,
0.48608314990997314,
0.38067826628685,
-0.16697601974010468,
-1.0032711029052734,
1.1162446737289429,
0.04384322464466095,
0.18647626042366028,
0.8179953694343567,
0.09347075968980789,
-0.6794898509979248,
-0.3557772934436798,
-0.6776990294456482,
0.15594135224819183,
-0.9300261735916138,
-0.7395526170730591,
-0.5499860048294067,
-0.13151775300502777,
-0.35491830110549927,
-0.12430349737405777,
-0.4315478205680847,
-0.3956419825553894,
-0.263048380613327,
-0.13789594173431396,
0.6912299394607544,
0.4984532296657562,
0.09516555070877075,
0.30652084946632385,
-0.9647001028060913,
0.6659353971481323,
0.21738727390766144,
0.7131720185279846,
0.628679096698761,
-0.45102664828300476,
-0.2517355680465698,
0.0965186133980751,
-0.21892620623111725,
-0.578258216381073,
0.5432612895965576,
0.18547607958316803,
0.38544565439224243,
0.3688397705554962,
0.11992034316062927,
0.8052682280540466,
-0.7041616439819336,
0.8369752168655396,
0.34956231713294983,
-0.2307085245847702,
0.5783017873764038,
-0.1874580979347229,
0.1407536119222641,
0.45704424381256104,
0.3260296881198883,
-0.1770014464855194,
0.02061421051621437,
-0.4239010810852051,
-0.8750853538513184,
0.3489571511745453,
0.03984072431921959,
0.5573867559432983,
-0.32347604632377625,
0.6135689616203308,
0.31075796484947205,
0.4083423912525177,
-0.8350105285644531,
-0.042904503643512726,
-0.2910427451133728,
-0.27370813488960266,
0.1787761151790619,
-0.16704991459846497,
-0.14613130688667297,
-0.11320023983716965,
0.3069339692592621,
-0.14150835573673248,
0.7627076506614685,
0.25392863154411316,
-0.3482905328273773,
0.038582589477300644,
0.03612344712018967,
0.4215189218521118,
0.26757553219795227,
0.06948776543140411,
0.36250627040863037,
0.013067512772977352,
-0.14356213808059692,
-0.09965888410806656,
0.10183107107877731,
-0.17783889174461365,
-0.03667682036757469,
0.07717342674732208,
0.7773375511169434,
0.3144170343875885,
-0.8870875239372253,
0.5122043490409851,
0.12770883738994598,
0.12162677943706512,
-0.4374660849571228,
-0.2388405054807663,
0.03414863720536232,
0.22753407061100006,
0.4760611653327942,
0.2561458349227905,
0.1381714642047882,
-0.5790877938270569,
0.3903769254684448,
0.5349247455596924,
-0.7038940191268921,
-0.21100997924804688,
0.6526618599891663,
-0.0186017956584692,
-0.1766609102487564,
0.693205714225769,
-0.24350757896900177,
-0.3341163694858551,
0.6370567679405212,
0.6047524809837341,
0.40929558873176575,
0.44845110177993774,
0.03651542216539383,
0.3712003231048584,
0.2080690860748291,
0.03767608478665352,
0.31468042731285095,
-0.26607173681259155,
-0.628319501876831,
-0.4470253586769104,
-0.6292977929115295,
0.01088688150048256,
-0.067332424223423,
-0.4737674295902252,
-0.10198137909173965,
-0.40749964118003845,
0.07944770902395248,
-0.47899386286735535,
-0.23174183070659637,
-0.9575337171554565,
0.16862893104553223,
0.2952900528907776,
0.817542314529419,
-0.39439061284065247,
0.46274298429489136,
0.6430850625038147,
-0.9329100251197815,
-0.46552443504333496,
-0.6241343021392822,
-0.5839994549751282,
-0.7923371195793152,
0.9052296280860901,
0.4072486162185669,
0.36455780267715454,
-0.19546855986118317,
-0.7027977705001831,
-1.0288007259368896,
1.204973816871643,
0.30049121379852295,
-0.3986819386482239,
0.10172732174396515,
0.1101037934422493,
0.4151015281677246,
-0.5767427682876587,
0.0007342049502767622,
-0.1342771202325821,
0.34442809224128723,
0.40694230794906616,
-0.527152955532074,
0.13752782344818115,
-0.2710047662258148,
0.19750352203845978,
0.08059190213680267,
-0.4673886001110077,
0.36412787437438965,
-0.6340764164924622,
-0.2659243047237396,
0.6745635867118835,
0.804467499256134,
0.23720161616802216,
0.3579420745372772,
0.07262104004621506,
0.6038265824317932,
0.26954013109207153,
0.18682020902633667,
1.4610165357589722,
-0.1184420958161354,
-0.24573826789855957,
1.3827414512634277,
-0.16873523592948914,
1.071351170539856,
0.6686677932739258,
0.07026570290327072,
0.5982490181922913,
0.28891631960868835,
-0.25106555223464966,
0.9155099987983704,
-0.05766909942030907,
-0.05132879316806793,
-0.040429335087537766,
-0.3913436830043793,
-0.17341315746307373,
0.08989384770393372,
0.21131494641304016,
-0.9076586961746216,
0.133757084608078,
0.3553813397884369,
-0.7894054055213928,
0.16965825855731964,
-0.4813595712184906,
0.9649566411972046,
0.10766206681728363,
-0.4263051152229309,
0.259403258562088,
-0.11007581651210785,
0.6100713610649109,
-0.2393886297941208,
-0.26166945695877075,
0.007726767100393772,
0.034774236381053925,
0.0969589352607727,
-0.7257577776908875,
0.18818561732769012,
-0.3001243472099304,
-0.1540955901145935,
0.09656179696321487,
0.8563742637634277,
-0.6211216449737549,
-0.5666425228118896,
0.0650005042552948,
0.2451152354478836,
0.21462814509868622,
-0.17108787596225739,
-0.4406745135784149,
-0.050535283982753754,
-0.3830772638320923,
0.23753774166107178,
0.15853619575500488,
0.2844275236129761,
-0.010235152207314968,
0.6997271180152893,
0.7420050501823425,
-0.13306091725826263,
0.3916316032409668,
0.3074209690093994,
0.7708264589309692,
-0.4819672107696533,
-0.4878130257129669,
-0.616977870464325,
0.4938485622406006,
-0.026536399498581886,
0.3926141560077667,
0.6428106427192688,
0.774052619934082,
0.5820044875144958,
-0.664281964302063,
0.5643943548202515,
-0.14991220831871033,
0.07398417592048645,
-0.41679951548576355,
0.6166398525238037,
-0.38462403416633606,
-0.12667971849441528,
-0.25079819560050964,
-0.7968665957450867,
-0.21930480003356934,
0.44470417499542236,
-0.24382345378398895,
0.02337489277124405,
0.269481897354126,
0.8280990123748779,
-0.2860226631164551,
-0.0923762321472168,
0.20777033269405365,
-0.06092846766114235,
0.09350614249706268,
0.42825254797935486,
1.033179759979248,
-0.7674585580825806,
0.8603148460388184,
-0.5289885401725769,
0.4966243803501129,
-0.05289079248905182,
-0.75771164894104,
-0.7605596780776978,
-0.6298355460166931,
-0.39157113432884216,
-0.010847830213606358,
0.007890645414590836,
0.47362834215164185,
0.6617681980133057,
-0.7545037865638733,
0.29014143347740173,
-0.15806567668914795,
-0.09735056757926941,
-0.11628223210573196,
-0.32384058833122253,
0.5056941509246826,
-0.36246997117996216,
-0.19820818305015564,
0.19743597507476807,
0.2871335744857788,
0.17258377373218536,
-0.18989844620227814,
-0.26399317383766174,
-0.23738300800323486,
0.030859140679240227,
0.8319066762924194,
0.30423951148986816,
-0.8074933886528015,
-0.3576456904411316,
0.1965298354625702,
0.08340662717819214,
0.4129704236984253,
0.6643516421318054,
-0.9372317790985107,
0.7633585333824158,
0.28822457790374756,
0.9261151552200317,
0.5405412912368774,
0.09875740110874176,
0.36189377307891846,
-1.0594886541366577,
-0.05434633418917656,
0.07837022840976715,
0.35960623621940613,
0.7363625764846802,
-0.3709477484226227,
0.23108461499214172,
0.06829748302698135,
-0.1316547840833664,
-0.6092740297317505,
0.12637700140476227,
-1.007572889328003,
-0.09661627560853958,
0.7759398221969604,
-0.1357344090938568,
-0.19242329895496368,
0.23232504725456238,
-0.4928206503391266,
0.1295938342809677,
-0.4019904136657715,
0.927313506603241,
0.4379279315471649,
0.056279003620147705,
-0.6753728985786438,
-0.5099046230316162,
0.10663573443889618,
0.01428816094994545,
-0.49194085597991943,
-0.07155580073595047,
0.5861552357673645,
0.22608844935894012,
0.5355368852615356,
0.16984769701957703,
-0.6895580887794495,
0.5048396587371826,
-0.07514345645904541,
0.035234175622463226,
-0.5405852198600769,
-0.4677756726741791,
-0.17521099746227264,
0.36581969261169434,
-0.1215578243136406,
-0.44079092144966125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12981v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12981v1
|
Reducing Transformer Key-Value Cache Size with Cross-Layer Attention
| 2024-05-21T17:59:29 | 2024-05-21T17:59:29 |
William Brandon, Mayank Mishra, Aniruddha Nrusimha, Rameswar Panda, Jonathan Ragan Kelly
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Key-value (KV) caching plays an essential role in accelerating decoding for
transformer-based autoregressive large language models (LLMs). However, the
amount of memory required to store the KV cache can become prohibitive at long
sequence lengths and large batch sizes. Since the invention of the transformer,
two of the most effective interventions discovered for reducing the size of the
KV cache have been Multi-Query Attention (MQA) and its generalization,
Grouped-Query Attention (GQA). MQA and GQA both modify the design of the
attention block so that multiple query heads can share a single key/value head,
reducing the number of distinct key/value heads by a large factor while only
minimally degrading accuracy. In this paper, we show that it is possible to
take Multi-Query Attention a step further by also sharing key and value heads
between adjacent layers, yielding a new attention design we call Cross-Layer
Attention (CLA). With CLA, we find that it is possible to reduce the size of
the KV cache by another 2x while maintaining nearly the same accuracy as
unmodified MQA. In experiments training 1B- and 3B-parameter models from
scratch, we demonstrate that CLA provides a Pareto improvement over the
memory/accuracy tradeoffs which are possible with traditional MQA, enabling
inference with longer sequence lengths and larger batch sizes than would
otherwise be possible
|
[
-0.5470276474952698,
-0.3714081048965454,
0.42577165365219116,
0.28243085741996765,
-0.30531567335128784,
-0.03884289041161537,
-0.16563211381435394,
-0.4246862828731537,
0.3056793510913849,
0.5785316228866577,
-0.48529210686683655,
-0.279475599527359,
-0.5920716524124146,
-0.3426196277141571,
-0.3499782681465149,
0.49901315569877625,
0.05749281868338585,
-0.2609468996524811,
-0.11573408544063568,
-0.26404279470443726,
-0.5087701082229614,
-0.539162278175354,
-0.7610476613044739,
-0.17768700420856476,
0.789507269859314,
0.39903587102890015,
0.700034499168396,
0.7242412567138672,
0.4235170781612396,
0.18855229020118713,
-0.1159459725022316,
0.21644550561904907,
-0.625564455986023,
0.2111770212650299,
-0.04638812318444252,
-0.5929177403450012,
-0.4639008343219757,
-0.1567084789276123,
0.5928006768226624,
0.363610178232193,
0.03272513672709465,
0.292913019657135,
-0.060875970870256424,
1.0599032640457153,
-1.0684154033660889,
0.35142457485198975,
-0.6764992475509644,
0.01533685065805912,
-0.019735274836421013,
-0.3245878219604492,
-0.7053446769714355,
0.039046596735715866,
0.127516508102417,
-0.4536091685295105,
0.47251811623573303,
-0.08238908648490906,
0.7900707125663757,
0.5664703249931335,
-0.3498538136482239,
0.1343628317117691,
-0.76642245054245,
0.9290266633033752,
-0.43738946318626404,
0.7432873845100403,
0.2680054306983948,
0.27061590552330017,
0.11033943295478821,
-0.7203921675682068,
-0.4154861867427826,
0.16500385105609894,
-0.10704239457845688,
0.16865648329257965,
-0.24984587728977203,
0.07447130978107452,
0.24369856715202332,
0.3432174324989319,
-0.26832315325737,
-0.11177107691764832,
-0.38746893405914307,
-0.3074943423271179,
0.3739701211452484,
0.23007197678089142,
-0.0484897680580616,
0.15317559242248535,
-0.22256271541118622,
-0.39626559615135193,
-0.9745292663574219,
0.28813132643699646,
0.022218085825443268,
0.23515096306800842,
0.262655645608902,
0.24685576558113098,
-0.43259546160697937,
0.32083287835121155,
0.40519917011260986,
0.0009289626614190638,
0.10319362580776215,
-0.4128005802631378,
-0.2576690912246704,
0.054441556334495544,
0.42429444193840027,
0.43733251094818115,
0.18957264721393585,
-0.3544696569442749,
0.018133921548724174,
0.00779152475297451,
0.5628848075866699,
-0.9336446523666382,
-0.38393518328666687,
0.27346304059028625,
-0.6244691014289856,
0.03369983658194542,
-0.12122480571269989,
-0.9008101224899292,
0.014494175091385841,
-0.22908098995685577,
0.29391399025917053,
0.18807022273540497,
0.23425471782684326,
0.10142684727907181,
-0.02072329632937908,
0.5159150958061218,
0.23771537840366364,
-1.026972770690918,
0.33701756596565247,
0.33335423469543457,
0.6902512311935425,
-0.12580986320972443,
-0.20399433374404907,
-0.6546812057495117,
0.4075988531112671,
-0.07372201979160309,
0.6779358983039856,
-0.6416970491409302,
-0.29320088028907776,
-0.34910181164741516,
0.05917404219508171,
-0.06957142055034637,
-0.47124335169792175,
0.2893608510494232,
-1.0284531116485596,
-0.08050524443387985,
-0.5941743850708008,
-0.25071051716804504,
-0.1379946619272232,
0.08252006769180298,
-1.071571946144104,
0.9811605215072632,
-0.015498831868171692,
-0.5471651554107666,
0.38565894961357117,
-0.3811591863632202,
-0.547761857509613,
-0.3229852318763733,
-0.021980877965688705,
-0.675615668296814,
0.268454909324646,
0.767497181892395,
0.33194366097450256,
-0.5812562108039856,
-0.12337815761566162,
-0.1994764804840088,
-0.4279409945011139,
-0.04320497065782547,
-0.4351637065410614,
0.36524900794029236,
-0.045705921947956085,
-0.47678089141845703,
0.07159356027841568,
-0.47161439061164856,
0.2293672412633896,
0.10219106823205948,
-0.2791435420513153,
-0.18421483039855957,
-0.0747607871890068,
-0.1464429348707199,
0.48691049218177795,
0.09476517885923386,
-0.35740265250205994,
0.11030144989490509,
-0.35099518299102783,
0.5213795304298401,
0.5587449669837952,
0.05210017040371895,
0.6612916588783264,
-0.28860288858413696,
0.4590561091899872,
0.31443050503730774,
0.3436945974826813,
-0.23109282553195953,
-0.417571485042572,
-1.1155753135681152,
-0.15311181545257568,
0.28326138854026794,
0.1965831220149994,
-0.3932335674762726,
0.17761394381523132,
-0.3567593991756439,
-0.4186473488807678,
-0.8903594613075256,
0.15371188521385193,
0.39579612016677856,
0.3151521384716034,
0.7308445572853088,
-0.39190682768821716,
-0.218193918466568,
-1.00271475315094,
-0.3018404543399811,
0.07297319918870926,
0.0053502037189900875,
0.6069791316986084,
0.15239037573337555,
-0.05129031464457512,
0.8272431492805481,
-0.5585225820541382,
-0.4025360643863678,
-0.08657442778348923,
-0.05664265155792236,
0.009049915708601475,
0.40021029114723206,
0.27522286772727966,
-0.8177826404571533,
-0.6649060249328613,
-0.11802970618009567,
-0.02298455312848091,
-0.09135010838508606,
-0.1980437934398651,
-0.15657217800617218,
0.19767315685749054,
0.5041547417640686,
-0.7439264059066772,
0.6409712433815002,
0.4163919687271118,
-0.012285207398235798,
0.294178307056427,
-0.04482386261224747,
0.1439543515443802,
-0.8172339200973511,
0.10184136778116226,
-0.3195236027240753,
-0.12395897507667542,
-0.6214205026626587,
0.012539990246295929,
0.4266470670700073,
0.15015801787376404,
-0.6272866725921631,
0.5944852232933044,
-0.6726242303848267,
-0.16846145689487457,
-0.4171580374240875,
-0.017692066729068756,
0.31477901339530945,
0.8399802446365356,
-0.001312109874561429,
0.896064281463623,
0.36487671732902527,
-0.6783589124679565,
0.14693869650363922,
0.198394775390625,
0.06758828461170197,
0.31946974992752075,
-0.7262921929359436,
0.42112112045288086,
-0.1708698868751526,
0.49242573976516724,
-0.9837715029716492,
0.19604957103729248,
-0.005533902440220118,
-0.37200960516929626,
0.24803470075130463,
-0.1877833902835846,
-0.44983118772506714,
-0.2940731346607208,
-0.45558857917785645,
0.8107986450195312,
0.4285752475261688,
-0.8077464699745178,
0.8762223124504089,
0.32091301679611206,
0.11702616512775421,
-0.7685766816139221,
-0.8434757590293884,
-0.04768510162830353,
-0.14647720754146576,
-0.650424599647522,
0.6474366188049316,
0.016135169193148613,
0.28065067529678345,
0.030640803277492523,
-0.5285166501998901,
-0.25679680705070496,
-0.28706681728363037,
0.06286798417568207,
0.08997663855552673,
-0.20404931902885437,
0.3142753541469574,
0.1528347134590149,
-0.3700456917285919,
0.16500596702098846,
-0.42235198616981506,
0.7222110033035278,
-0.09588877111673355,
-0.3102269768714905,
-0.489108145236969,
0.3666645884513855,
0.8876497149467468,
-0.5620339512825012,
0.8242653608322144,
0.5823273062705994,
-0.2550543546676636,
-0.2635866701602936,
-0.8107373118400574,
-0.4103127121925354,
-0.46907535195350647,
0.0776081308722496,
-0.5180016160011292,
-1.0256094932556152,
0.9320443868637085,
0.06866707652807236,
-0.2106829732656479,
0.4868012070655823,
0.6468915939331055,
0.15703868865966797,
0.8618850708007812,
0.2783845365047455,
-0.5879395604133606,
0.3485514521598816,
-0.24916806817054749,
0.3531159460544586,
-1.1530225276947021,
-0.2050541490316391,
-0.47506794333457947,
-0.7039380669593811,
-0.4395432472229004,
-0.6266453266143799,
0.399411141872406,
-0.21140584349632263,
-0.1671682894229889,
0.16675998270511627,
-0.48376771807670593,
0.7341540455818176,
0.5557886958122253,
0.3488823473453522,
0.28050607442855835,
-0.21735434234142303,
0.047943469136953354,
0.0011950990883633494,
-0.6675017476081848,
0.07783268392086029,
1.2300211191177368,
0.25581854581832886,
0.9267813563346863,
-0.14741221070289612,
0.509721577167511,
0.005828018765896559,
0.011285516433417797,
-0.8131850957870483,
0.32803472876548767,
-0.10760940611362457,
-0.5630772709846497,
-0.31882116198539734,
-0.49215543270111084,
-0.9666057229042053,
0.530298113822937,
0.35491907596588135,
-0.5732647776603699,
0.2889383137226105,
0.31891292333602905,
-0.41273197531700134,
0.32023942470550537,
-0.5491149425506592,
0.8396545648574829,
0.05101080983877182,
-0.44435402750968933,
-0.40889957547187805,
-0.8873750567436218,
0.3148716688156128,
0.00131698464974761,
-0.23782825469970703,
0.25260841846466064,
-0.07444148510694504,
0.543448805809021,
-0.3036201000213623,
0.8118016123771667,
-0.20376424491405487,
-0.09092486649751663,
0.27900928258895874,
-0.24038833379745483,
0.8557158708572388,
0.0810011476278305,
0.3648832142353058,
-0.141293466091156,
-0.23508870601654053,
-0.6209757328033447,
-0.7102503776550293,
0.7551704049110413,
-0.6777920126914978,
-0.6068356037139893,
0.04530319571495056,
-0.8467965126037598,
-0.26658517122268677,
0.14497525990009308,
0.10045570135116577,
0.2964135706424713,
0.10890292376279831,
0.6593480706214905,
1.1291917562484741,
-0.05258200317621231,
0.46089282631874084,
0.3336044251918793,
0.22441141307353973,
-0.3199601471424103,
0.597003161907196,
0.1339799463748932,
0.6296802163124084,
0.6843945384025574,
0.12881600856781006,
-0.38702860474586487,
-0.377558171749115,
-0.08854977041482925,
0.12257161736488342,
-0.8196684718132019,
-0.29299837350845337,
-0.9454214572906494,
-0.32134178280830383,
-0.2982335686683655,
-0.10092207789421082,
-0.7459919452667236,
-0.4274919629096985,
-0.17384842038154602,
0.19441840052604675,
0.2308642864227295,
0.024521533399820328,
0.2080565243959427,
0.673164427280426,
-0.9428560733795166,
0.49589911103248596,
0.45979347825050354,
0.36112716794013977,
0.40262794494628906,
-0.5032476782798767,
-0.395411878824234,
-0.16667072474956512,
-0.19430848956108093,
-0.5406200885772705,
0.4665517508983612,
0.05721080303192139,
0.5723852515220642,
0.22374427318572998,
0.14646869897842407,
0.8308650255203247,
-0.3837994337081909,
0.48685377836227417,
-0.07213202118873596,
-1.1392165422439575,
0.33348914980888367,
-0.0053617930971086025,
0.7309032678604126,
0.5522344708442688,
-0.023960581049323082,
-0.6238688826560974,
-0.35727062821388245,
-0.5413491725921631,
-1.023707389831543,
0.740175187587738,
0.1484290063381195,
0.041367966681718826,
0.1967332661151886,
0.34352907538414,
-0.16696619987487793,
0.11410661786794662,
-0.6349499225616455,
-0.3553696572780609,
-0.13377827405929565,
0.02820751816034317,
0.12274271994829178,
-0.23151877522468567,
-0.007814654149115086,
-0.22213801741600037,
0.5648305416107178,
-0.2317640632390976,
0.4952635169029236,
0.17422297596931458,
-0.24537554383277893,
-0.14599460363388062,
0.3327312767505646,
0.5644338726997375,
0.3904185891151428,
-0.13129816949367523,
0.32534778118133545,
0.35383355617523193,
-0.5853211879730225,
0.14364904165267944,
-0.17751845717430115,
0.021070655435323715,
-0.26756247878074646,
0.019492197781801224,
0.8081924915313721,
0.27721336483955383,
-0.3114892244338989,
0.4337645173072815,
-0.2311263233423233,
-0.0839264914393425,
0.14524520933628082,
-0.06335009634494781,
0.33605679869651794,
0.3648897409439087,
0.29395437240600586,
-0.08646143972873688,
0.16422763466835022,
-0.1781310886144638,
0.3645268976688385,
0.40569329261779785,
-0.22274728119373322,
-0.14532512426376343,
0.7232635021209717,
0.031768787652254105,
0.19009141623973846,
0.555062472820282,
0.1135236993432045,
-0.6407129764556885,
0.7660096287727356,
0.5335133075714111,
1.0146421194076538,
-0.41598016023635864,
-0.12161237746477127,
0.14436161518096924,
0.6304910778999329,
-0.09449683874845505,
0.22764550149440765,
-0.31760862469673157,
-0.6139042377471924,
-0.4230043590068817,
-0.2771728038787842,
-0.3344196379184723,
0.3431739807128906,
-0.8712339997291565,
0.0017531252233311534,
-0.38822072744369507,
0.006163865327835083,
-0.14260627329349518,
0.04890207201242447,
-0.8678439855575562,
0.42324092984199524,
-0.19677339494228363,
0.5964546203613281,
-0.6563994884490967,
1.0548995733261108,
0.10878537595272064,
-0.3626045882701874,
-0.6705978512763977,
0.18039873242378235,
-0.21960824728012085,
-0.8303965926170349,
0.6316418647766113,
0.31044235825538635,
-0.23610974848270416,
0.05792579799890518,
-0.20695984363555908,
-1.113108515739441,
1.2008968591690063,
0.14536911249160767,
-0.6195659041404724,
-0.11818350851535797,
0.30990421772003174,
0.34081509709358215,
-0.33195778727531433,
0.16972006857395172,
0.7201454639434814,
0.5397137999534607,
0.13637515902519226,
-0.725662887096405,
0.20110473036766052,
-0.042409006506204605,
0.0699363723397255,
0.5429084300994873,
-1.0426100492477417,
0.7891252040863037,
-0.04732230678200722,
-0.1815309375524521,
-0.40016043186187744,
0.7075163722038269,
0.03873111680150032,
0.02627347968518734,
0.5522675514221191,
0.7626184225082397,
0.5349916219711304,
0.013297337107360363,
0.865354061126709,
-0.47733134031295776,
0.29163703322410583,
1.232956886291504,
-0.12267757207155228,
0.7856405973434448,
0.7453904151916504,
-0.09228495508432388,
0.06748826801776886,
0.3321699798107147,
0.091518335044384,
0.8245390057563782,
0.11835338175296783,
-0.11158106476068497,
-0.2653254568576813,
0.132254496216774,
-0.3891725540161133,
0.32696735858917236,
0.34258419275283813,
-0.48241540789604187,
-0.13069690763950348,
-0.14804352819919586,
-0.16962504386901855,
-0.4975084066390991,
-0.3505067527294159,
0.6227356791496277,
0.056783583015203476,
-0.655998170375824,
0.5901253819465637,
-0.2097855806350708,
0.3450377881526947,
-0.3518815040588379,
0.220315620303154,
-0.25212791562080383,
0.402535617351532,
-0.052561596035957336,
-0.5141011476516724,
0.3585905134677887,
-0.36852508783340454,
-0.6370937824249268,
-0.16261859238147736,
0.782870888710022,
-0.5735840201377869,
-0.16041086614131927,
0.5388097167015076,
0.3304360806941986,
-0.18080876767635345,
-0.4217302203178406,
-0.45667439699172974,
0.25460702180862427,
-0.1512947529554367,
-0.5178834795951843,
0.45280784368515015,
0.30977773666381836,
0.01789224147796631,
0.6660786867141724,
0.6930160522460938,
-0.11844826489686966,
0.44791465997695923,
0.2644418179988861,
1.2609779834747314,
-0.8064498901367188,
-0.6277920007705688,
-0.7061707973480225,
0.40953701734542847,
0.12317147850990295,
-0.08084872364997864,
0.4943506717681885,
0.45547595620155334,
0.829348087310791,
-0.10025738179683685,
0.6822302341461182,
0.3535889685153961,
0.1609208732843399,
-0.5744468569755554,
0.5993340015411377,
-0.4843665063381195,
0.2410539984703064,
-0.029575886204838753,
-1.0862400531768799,
-0.4256264269351959,
0.2681063711643219,
-0.0574207566678524,
0.1446060836315155,
0.9023465514183044,
0.8004319667816162,
-0.23047402501106262,
-0.16637252271175385,
0.2926156222820282,
-0.023156939074397087,
0.6135817766189575,
0.9291753768920898,
0.5151717066764832,
-0.6783841848373413,
0.8473188877105713,
-0.30665597319602966,
-0.033748283982276917,
-0.3328244686126709,
-0.6573935747146606,
-0.968777060508728,
-0.3930710256099701,
-0.007373888976871967,
-0.086417555809021,
0.030550867319107056,
0.45960959792137146,
0.7368684411048889,
-0.8445827960968018,
0.016955604776740074,
-0.041349414736032486,
-0.0742088034749031,
-0.34237349033355713,
-0.2085253745317459,
0.6262736916542053,
-0.5246418118476868,
-0.6495516896247864,
0.3987487256526947,
0.49685245752334595,
-0.11584355682134628,
-0.32087400555610657,
0.025735311210155487,
-0.1052984893321991,
0.2694110572338104,
0.5892362594604492,
0.13759349286556244,
-0.9363080263137817,
-0.36761850118637085,
0.2768653631210327,
-0.1592438817024231,
0.43103355169296265,
0.925866961479187,
-0.8750092387199402,
0.550256073474884,
0.5365443229675293,
1.1317273378372192,
1.0021865367889404,
0.0014615540858358145,
0.5645692348480225,
-0.8033150434494019,
0.012864813208580017,
0.10746444761753082,
0.2672450542449951,
0.02217075042426586,
-0.5625867247581482,
0.26892995834350586,
0.022027278319001198,
-0.7468403577804565,
-0.4748617708683014,
0.16557028889656067,
-1.1371803283691406,
-0.05826285481452942,
0.8288260102272034,
-0.019257767125964165,
-0.3137776553630829,
-0.05894959345459938,
-0.1627817302942276,
0.2904829978942871,
-0.6713547110557556,
0.8725126385688782,
0.7938562631607056,
-0.023446809500455856,
-0.5551151633262634,
-0.37183478474617004,
0.5518139004707336,
0.8371809720993042,
-0.8540714979171753,
0.4362068772315979,
0.2296416014432907,
-0.08275974541902542,
0.15784797072410583,
0.45185837149620056,
-0.13760626316070557,
0.459110826253891,
-0.11436399072408676,
-0.05353126302361488,
0.15358808636665344,
-0.7252245545387268,
-0.2530219554901123,
0.315817266702652,
-0.3185562491416931,
-0.36115801334381104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12939v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12939v1
|
Aggregation of Reasoning: A Hierarchical Framework for Enhancing Answer Selection in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-21T17:12:19 | 2024-05-21T17:12:19 |
Zhangyue Yin, Qiushi Sun, Qipeng Guo, Zhiyuan Zeng, Xiaonan Li, Tianxiang Sun, Cheng Chang, Qinyuan Cheng, Ding Wang, Xiaofeng Mou, Xipeng Qiu, XuanJing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in Chain-of-Thought prompting have facilitated
significant breakthroughs for Large Language Models (LLMs) in complex reasoning
tasks. Current research enhances the reasoning performance of LLMs by sampling
multiple reasoning chains and ensembling based on the answer frequency.
However, this approach fails in scenarios where the correct answers are in the
minority. We identify this as a primary factor constraining the reasoning
capabilities of LLMs, a limitation that cannot be resolved solely based on the
predicted answers. To address this shortcoming, we introduce a hierarchical
reasoning aggregation framework AoR (Aggregation of Reasoning), which selects
answers based on the evaluation of reasoning chains. Additionally, AoR
incorporates dynamic sampling, adjusting the number of reasoning chains in
accordance with the complexity of the task. Experimental results on a series of
complex reasoning tasks show that AoR outperforms prominent ensemble methods.
Further analysis reveals that AoR not only adapts various LLMs but also
achieves a superior performance ceiling when compared to current methods.
|
[
-0.5393054485321045,
-1.2109606266021729,
0.7648208737373352,
0.07464709132909775,
0.00512020755559206,
0.3862135410308838,
-0.07312966138124466,
-0.6215256452560425,
0.07616481930017471,
0.45477423071861267,
-0.26011815667152405,
-0.15272848308086395,
-0.5861350893974304,
0.13321369886398315,
-0.30876263976097107,
0.8269451856613159,
0.01014731265604496,
-0.24172033369541168,
-0.5696806311607361,
-0.21057558059692383,
-0.175994873046875,
-0.5562105774879456,
-0.9128221273422241,
-0.5427671670913696,
0.485795795917511,
0.4098508954048157,
0.7551499009132385,
0.744073748588562,
0.6548435688018799,
0.3685053288936615,
-0.4263569116592407,
0.5983211994171143,
-0.2617603540420532,
0.3938518166542053,
-0.24693900346755981,
-0.46633169054985046,
-0.8782979846000671,
-0.4630679488182068,
0.7821596264839172,
0.910431444644928,
-0.3426544964313507,
0.12913134694099426,
-0.047468237578868866,
0.7299137711524963,
-0.8497564792633057,
-0.005842984188348055,
-0.7818994522094727,
-0.14008976519107819,
-0.061736706644296646,
-0.23227636516094208,
-0.28584182262420654,
-0.23113815486431122,
0.18772105872631073,
-0.4635886549949646,
-0.11179899424314499,
0.24624985456466675,
0.19839182496070862,
0.27111679315567017,
-0.3733679950237274,
-0.34524568915367126,
-0.7336596250534058,
0.8272514939308167,
-0.42876923084259033,
0.12776103615760803,
0.2764296233654022,
0.25300198793411255,
-0.06963155418634415,
-0.5195562839508057,
-0.4440389573574066,
-0.03517333045601845,
0.07415132224559784,
0.15985654294490814,
-0.20232370495796204,
0.1713961362838745,
0.1341569721698761,
0.5327746868133545,
-0.5540667176246643,
0.026534385979175568,
-0.13941937685012817,
0.0564531609416008,
0.526500940322876,
0.26616334915161133,
0.0980016216635704,
0.19644173979759216,
-0.22498652338981628,
0.02085263282060623,
-0.48646265268325806,
0.029504671692848206,
0.10568179935216904,
0.08110406994819641,
0.1987980604171753,
0.5666317939758301,
-0.2961728274822235,
1.127219796180725,
0.2792219817638397,
-0.1558932662010193,
0.010134514421224594,
-0.05332043021917343,
-0.25171375274658203,
0.08152978122234344,
0.5712000727653503,
-0.01427930872887373,
0.2573383152484894,
0.047500696033239365,
-0.24269801378250122,
-0.08681539446115494,
0.021778728812932968,
-0.41433385014533997,
-0.1757926642894745,
0.5026589035987854,
-0.3812043368816376,
-0.17683656513690948,
0.005402899347245693,
-0.804702877998352,
-0.17674583196640015,
-0.12292592227458954,
0.22540217638015747,
-0.08172858506441116,
-0.2776424288749695,
0.2887202799320221,
-0.2966974675655365,
-0.12952807545661926,
0.47123613953590393,
-0.7646163702011108,
0.5863254070281982,
0.6430647373199463,
0.5793055295944214,
-0.3828393518924713,
-0.3909338414669037,
-0.7908074855804443,
0.20813675224781036,
-0.40530043840408325,
1.1557214260101318,
-0.8104494214057922,
-0.23143519461154938,
-0.08325359970331192,
-0.5432303547859192,
-0.12391054630279541,
-0.8285003304481506,
0.3113929331302643,
-0.898392379283905,
-0.08885717391967773,
-0.19256190955638885,
-0.4484066069126129,
0.019545558840036392,
0.5007630586624146,
-0.788936972618103,
1.1961119174957275,
0.022576382383704185,
-0.7164231538772583,
0.07836995273828506,
-0.5433841347694397,
-0.5242583155632019,
0.13523437082767487,
-0.17669513821601868,
-0.05007628723978996,
0.016527308151125908,
0.3851306140422821,
0.14471805095672607,
-0.5560359358787537,
0.35381853580474854,
-0.42407768964767456,
-0.2834809124469757,
0.4166601598262787,
-0.3428580164909363,
0.593567430973053,
0.46363380551338196,
0.004569120705127716,
0.24802179634571075,
-0.5441813468933105,
0.1539263278245926,
0.04350274056196213,
-0.5402252078056335,
-0.41270071268081665,
0.22335538268089294,
-0.5454838871955872,
0.2124146968126297,
0.25441116094589233,
-0.18763968348503113,
0.30075520277023315,
-0.28957971930503845,
0.3374632000923157,
0.7052881121635437,
0.07679975032806396,
0.6199976801872253,
-0.643873393535614,
0.7607635259628296,
-0.04406125098466873,
-0.1150318831205368,
0.0027852782513946295,
-0.4635140895843506,
-0.7745897173881531,
-0.11627863347530365,
0.16737550497055054,
0.7332503199577332,
-0.8708596229553223,
0.6053335666656494,
-0.29571735858917236,
-0.29434773325920105,
-0.32486531138420105,
0.18270444869995117,
0.41128113865852356,
0.3930177688598633,
0.3750075101852417,
-0.05282355844974518,
-0.48528018593788147,
-0.7082825303077698,
-0.2854911684989929,
-0.6288291215896606,
0.06492295861244202,
0.21844482421875,
0.4684479236602783,
0.19811609387397766,
0.8593720197677612,
-0.6420360803604126,
-0.01196460984647274,
-0.4364277720451355,
0.01411944068968296,
0.2983868718147278,
0.19535695016384125,
0.2405868023633957,
-0.8109001517295837,
-0.10277669876813889,
0.05445317551493645,
-0.7127269506454468,
-0.17386473715305328,
0.02782125398516655,
-0.3529452681541443,
-0.019136425107717514,
0.4884853959083557,
-0.7307752966880798,
-0.07075223326683044,
0.5207657217979431,
-0.14110758900642395,
0.5304945111274719,
-0.13623711466789246,
0.07021158188581467,
-0.8136786222457886,
-0.09566930681467056,
-0.06436347961425781,
-0.09431574493646622,
-0.4017011821269989,
0.30447813868522644,
-0.21133270859718323,
0.22508127987384796,
-0.17885898053646088,
0.7205196619033813,
-0.5524526238441467,
-0.01506972685456276,
-0.3093152642250061,
0.2945946455001831,
-0.012945529073476791,
0.4056861102581024,
0.08436807990074158,
0.5762125253677368,
0.6210190057754517,
-0.9239518046379089,
0.6525933742523193,
0.3194606304168701,
-0.4954574704170227,
0.5365220308303833,
-0.550299882888794,
0.10499665141105652,
-0.2369452714920044,
0.49795499444007874,
-0.9752053022384644,
-0.37268680334091187,
-0.07058101892471313,
-0.3925524055957794,
0.08460894227027893,
-0.011258390732109547,
-0.5360556840896606,
-0.48941680788993835,
-0.019560927525162697,
0.6088024973869324,
0.43396228551864624,
-0.5447384119033813,
0.8612436056137085,
0.5592170357704163,
-0.353011816740036,
-0.5856161117553711,
-0.6930757164955139,
-0.16718319058418274,
-0.21487677097320557,
-0.5322752594947815,
0.1226024329662323,
-0.1829034835100174,
-0.807559072971344,
0.037105124443769455,
-0.37042468786239624,
-0.14493755996227264,
0.06588643789291382,
-0.3640046715736389,
0.16495266556739807,
-0.19133006036281586,
0.5063351392745972,
0.28349563479423523,
-0.040123846381902695,
0.1485346555709839,
-0.5098084211349487,
0.4820791184902191,
-0.2202763855457306,
-0.5709031224250793,
0.1917487531900406,
0.560857355594635,
0.687378466129303,
-0.5453141927719116,
0.6417404413223267,
0.03899182379245758,
-0.31085267663002014,
-0.324244886636734,
-0.6908994913101196,
-0.05735311284661293,
-0.4418926537036896,
0.42678484320640564,
-0.47578322887420654,
-1.2251160144805908,
0.6071844100952148,
-0.021278321743011475,
0.17290548980236053,
0.422072172164917,
0.6010098457336426,
0.10317305475473404,
1.3280137777328491,
0.0027365030255168676,
-0.08279340714216232,
0.3400435447692871,
-0.04246527701616287,
0.2084752768278122,
-0.8226546049118042,
-0.20596735179424286,
-0.6251312494277954,
-0.156892791390419,
-0.4277396500110626,
-0.6202887296676636,
0.5643882751464844,
0.17639777064323425,
-0.37385520339012146,
-0.35551130771636963,
-0.43270930647850037,
0.5414911508560181,
0.3862324059009552,
0.17795751988887787,
0.5411897301673889,
0.11364451795816422,
-0.04714592546224594,
0.6123978495597839,
-1.0356231927871704,
-0.3152790069580078,
0.5212299227714539,
0.19606049358844757,
0.853148341178894,
0.302051842212677,
0.31276947259902954,
0.18209169805049896,
0.07974899560213089,
-0.802680253982544,
0.8259707689285278,
-0.18033836781978607,
-0.7990595102310181,
-0.5574526190757751,
-0.6047729849815369,
-0.8304160237312317,
0.5957702398300171,
-0.08619388937950134,
-0.7313933372497559,
0.19012482464313507,
0.2742478847503662,
-0.45915308594703674,
0.3923951983451843,
-0.34625694155693054,
0.39333903789520264,
-0.2924897372722626,
-0.2514704465866089,
-0.1959713250398636,
-0.5890617966651917,
0.2737272083759308,
-0.16689655184745789,
0.34679269790649414,
0.01788276992738247,
-0.06454254686832428,
0.5236413478851318,
-0.2993026077747345,
0.6456480622291565,
0.11138202995061874,
-0.277920126914978,
0.7033213973045349,
0.1407877802848816,
0.7068111300468445,
-0.20805366337299347,
-0.4977514445781708,
-0.16246303915977478,
-0.27736765146255493,
-0.3918100893497467,
-0.809468686580658,
0.6867361068725586,
-0.4269614815711975,
-0.9319624304771423,
-0.36098769307136536,
-0.813404381275177,
-0.5092214345932007,
0.11480602622032166,
0.17578727006912231,
0.4844955503940582,
0.024250270798802376,
0.38430312275886536,
0.7714061737060547,
0.10143037885427475,
0.2305537313222885,
0.15773430466651917,
-0.3500673174858093,
-0.44728410243988037,
0.45105767250061035,
0.15613949298858643,
0.6267217397689819,
0.6514853835105896,
0.3700273334980011,
-0.44788241386413574,
-0.6133212447166443,
-0.4249793291091919,
0.0010185969294980168,
-0.8334598541259766,
-0.14787010848522186,
-0.8515493869781494,
-0.21047693490982056,
-0.27171748876571655,
-0.06131025776267052,
-0.011766472831368446,
-0.5511670708656311,
0.06620948761701584,
-0.26844197511672974,
0.34082889556884766,
0.4614916145801544,
0.11114651709794998,
0.05982952564954758,
-0.8714184165000916,
0.4563038647174835,
0.6734528541564941,
0.317590594291687,
0.395492821931839,
-0.4959404766559601,
-0.08038737624883652,
0.05660054087638855,
-0.11113820970058441,
-0.6611400842666626,
0.003064841963350773,
0.1866856813430786,
0.8110801577568054,
0.2853771448135376,
0.17877240478992462,
0.9555206894874573,
-0.36553600430488586,
0.5877609848976135,
0.07383028417825699,
-0.7320751547813416,
0.6631983518600464,
-0.5122972726821899,
0.6379849910736084,
0.45243600010871887,
0.2508560121059418,
-0.1271279752254486,
-0.7433359622955322,
-0.6184110045433044,
-0.9427850246429443,
0.5560624599456787,
0.16645289957523346,
0.020473936572670937,
-0.3405531644821167,
0.19677609205245972,
-0.22913965582847595,
0.096258245408535,
-0.4510607421398163,
-0.22998085618019104,
0.32744574546813965,
-0.13142816722393036,
0.1583123505115509,
-0.24831005930900574,
-0.1185130700469017,
-0.32829487323760986,
0.7170335650444031,
-0.32336726784706116,
0.11007122695446014,
0.24896742403507233,
0.0354209765791893,
-0.5236614942550659,
0.3903971314430237,
0.17365635931491852,
0.8697207570075989,
0.01120131928473711,
0.3042720556259155,
0.5014066100120544,
-0.23109667003154755,
0.04692956805229187,
0.012816056609153748,
-0.023929307237267494,
-0.34986162185668945,
0.5819050073623657,
0.735320508480072,
-0.0960412472486496,
-0.8091947436332703,
0.14439436793327332,
0.26441723108291626,
-0.277342289686203,
-0.20864509046077728,
0.442583292722702,
0.05383402109146118,
0.2670137286186218,
0.6361989974975586,
0.21525955200195312,
0.26798728108406067,
-0.6882142424583435,
0.004446903243660927,
0.3904765844345093,
-0.2349630445241928,
0.18395735323429108,
0.5220293402671814,
0.041435107588768005,
-0.3449491858482361,
0.6936769485473633,
-0.026573872193694115,
-0.5153300762176514,
0.8389393091201782,
0.6762117743492126,
0.6040316224098206,
-0.43717557191848755,
-0.07828018069267273,
0.25340402126312256,
0.19449500739574432,
-0.4052902162075043,
0.31797584891319275,
-0.13024522364139557,
-1.0590490102767944,
-0.796683669090271,
-0.6161331534385681,
-0.4149675667285919,
0.0939895510673523,
-0.784848153591156,
-0.1626460701227188,
-0.2141638994216919,
-0.10900463163852692,
-0.10366488248109818,
-0.22863595187664032,
-0.07501111924648285,
0.46504974365234375,
0.018197637051343918,
0.994909405708313,
-0.710059404373169,
0.6463467478752136,
1.1045012474060059,
-0.07335356622934341,
-0.7374411821365356,
0.1840747892856598,
-0.01791456714272499,
-0.6141520738601685,
0.37414324283599854,
-0.09104165434837341,
-0.5485569834709167,
0.11918007582426071,
-0.5299161672592163,
-0.9502543807029724,
0.8067212104797363,
0.24111346900463104,
-0.3999483287334442,
0.09525108337402344,
-0.11679768562316895,
0.6778809428215027,
-0.546497642993927,
0.16387821733951569,
0.6759400963783264,
0.43886929750442505,
0.6994259357452393,
-0.8739190697669983,
-0.0798216313123703,
-0.48342427611351013,
-0.12095627933740616,
0.3023499548435211,
-0.5725517868995667,
0.7906790375709534,
-0.29786232113838196,
0.15869644284248352,
0.12332669645547867,
0.689678430557251,
0.9884341359138489,
0.18483670055866241,
0.8391349911689758,
0.47701752185821533,
0.9835946559906006,
-0.036704886704683304,
1.2527323961257935,
-0.025584086775779724,
0.016221795231103897,
1.1656516790390015,
-0.41686034202575684,
0.8521497845649719,
0.35793137550354004,
-0.2555201053619385,
0.5705192685127258,
0.6193479895591736,
0.2754462957382202,
0.2615710198879242,
0.22194606065750122,
-0.4463191628456116,
-0.8103448152542114,
-0.17908595502376556,
-0.25739625096321106,
0.4810525178909302,
0.540556013584137,
-0.05199189484119415,
0.02309943176805973,
-0.24208688735961914,
-0.2172752171754837,
0.12358404695987701,
-0.54926997423172,
0.8529486656188965,
0.1692182868719101,
-1.21097731590271,
0.44928598403930664,
-0.27125686407089233,
0.2559012472629547,
-0.4507465660572052,
-0.20230528712272644,
-0.031148966401815414,
0.3192412257194519,
-0.1889040172100067,
-1.03519606590271,
0.2613942325115204,
0.037822481244802475,
-0.3099682927131653,
-0.19898201525211334,
0.8881478309631348,
-0.4242165982723236,
-0.5900330543518066,
0.3571070432662964,
0.8670720458030701,
-0.0011794022284448147,
-0.09762945026159286,
-0.4819481670856476,
-0.13822390139102936,
-0.22457130253314972,
-0.3266213834285736,
0.32812586426734924,
0.7768731713294983,
-0.319070965051651,
0.9398914575576782,
0.6642696261405945,
0.19913607835769653,
-0.13993844389915466,
0.12417476624250412,
1.01962149143219,
-0.34355220198631287,
-0.6758898496627808,
-0.8628270626068115,
0.4935401976108551,
-0.20569580793380737,
-0.1675408035516739,
0.5597477555274963,
0.5132754445075989,
0.6390466094017029,
0.10023535788059235,
0.8624308705329895,
-0.04023125022649765,
0.5720047950744629,
-0.663947582244873,
0.21656925976276398,
-0.6650141477584839,
0.6196187138557434,
-0.2336561679840088,
-0.9836244583129883,
-0.48068666458129883,
0.729623019695282,
-0.4563044011592865,
0.3760219216346741,
0.8463398218154907,
0.5200033187866211,
-0.006784594617784023,
0.10375243425369263,
0.19750124216079712,
0.2792607545852661,
0.11516775190830231,
0.5422272682189941,
1.1982356309890747,
0.06273188441991806,
0.7425920963287354,
0.1497086137533188,
-0.42213913798332214,
-0.1256992667913437,
-0.8740354180335999,
-0.788338303565979,
-0.2744918167591095,
-0.2778736352920532,
-0.2720167934894562,
0.14088746905326843,
0.8484709858894348,
0.6144342422485352,
-0.812087893486023,
-0.4025140404701233,
-0.2660515606403351,
0.3753856420516968,
-0.5502749085426331,
-0.19351579248905182,
0.2200736701488495,
-0.3184225261211395,
-0.5916167497634888,
0.3369424641132355,
0.3164028227329254,
-0.30225515365600586,
-0.05304352566599846,
-0.022044463083148003,
-0.37293195724487305,
0.21512407064437866,
0.7630510926246643,
0.009510715492069721,
-0.6977235078811646,
-0.07820330560207367,
0.11930660903453827,
0.13076399266719818,
0.09995883703231812,
0.7624267339706421,
-0.6236332058906555,
0.3168349266052246,
0.7779673337936401,
0.5076279044151306,
0.3353157639503479,
0.26736658811569214,
0.42654451727867126,
-0.5661329627037048,
-0.06037411466240883,
0.37711092829704285,
0.3871437907218933,
-0.029972342774271965,
-0.33380094170570374,
0.47162941098213196,
-0.02705381065607071,
-0.6324257850646973,
-0.5275357365608215,
0.47274351119995117,
-1.0154950618743896,
-0.6254073977470398,
1.411024570465088,
0.0656510442495346,
-0.1334373652935028,
-0.43427738547325134,
-0.08879780769348145,
0.04878205806016922,
-0.3995000720024109,
0.7460114359855652,
0.8429976105690002,
-0.479719877243042,
-0.34824496507644653,
-0.2905515730381012,
0.045745767652988434,
0.37658238410949707,
-1.0266908407211304,
0.13672694563865662,
0.7276476621627808,
-0.11119896173477173,
0.35086187720298767,
0.9430723190307617,
-0.17639431357383728,
0.3592298626899719,
-0.09410044550895691,
-0.34030672907829285,
0.09693275392055511,
-0.5067859888076782,
-0.25053298473358154,
0.5596553087234497,
0.35480037331581116,
0.20819281041622162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12933v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12933v2
|
Skin-in-the-Game: Decision Making via Multi-Stakeholder Alignment in LLMs
| 2024-05-21T17:04:44 | 2024-06-02T18:48:56 |
Bilgehan Sel, Priya Shanmugasundaram, Mohammad Kachuee, Kun Zhou, Ruoxi Jia, Ming Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in tasks such
as summarization, arithmetic reasoning, and question answering. However, they
encounter significant challenges in the domain of moral reasoning and ethical
decision-making, especially in complex scenarios with multiple stakeholders.
This paper introduces the Skin-in-the-Game (SKIG) framework, aimed at enhancing
moral reasoning in LLMs by exploring decisions' consequences from multiple
stakeholder perspectives. Central to SKIG's mechanism is simulating
accountability for actions, which, alongside empathy exercises and risk
assessment, is pivotal to its effectiveness. We validate SKIG's performance
across various moral reasoning benchmarks with proprietary and opensource LLMs,
and investigate its crucial components through extensive ablation analyses.
|
[
-0.1659298986196518,
-0.5145947933197021,
0.712344765663147,
-0.0507163442671299,
-0.27447861433029175,
0.36214521527290344,
0.10696880519390106,
-0.5538533926010132,
-0.0940241739153862,
0.8958218097686768,
-0.4245266914367676,
-0.7142745852470398,
-0.47428083419799805,
-0.23635947704315186,
0.12585324048995972,
0.9329569339752197,
-0.0916038528084755,
0.06075764819979668,
-0.41172248125076294,
-0.6405820846557617,
-0.3188117742538452,
-0.43821385502815247,
-0.893040657043457,
-0.5619000792503357,
0.41330286860466003,
0.5205451846122742,
0.6665320992469788,
0.8636776208877563,
0.5815542340278625,
0.3791468143463135,
0.001660695648752153,
0.04451988264918327,
-0.3225961923599243,
0.1559525579214096,
-0.5554642677307129,
-0.4883991777896881,
-0.5526254177093506,
0.4988802969455719,
0.15147900581359863,
0.2213069498538971,
-0.369402140378952,
0.2617054283618927,
-0.03199577331542969,
0.7081796526908875,
-0.5998817086219788,
-0.08761008083820343,
-0.39997223019599915,
-0.09613680094480515,
0.09783792495727539,
0.10529444366693497,
-0.27824699878692627,
-0.3335348963737488,
0.27107903361320496,
-0.5271825790405273,
-0.21539729833602905,
0.058584947139024734,
0.6077823638916016,
0.2850009799003601,
-0.5665053725242615,
-0.34617042541503906,
-0.24146221578121185,
0.8494945168495178,
-0.9416614770889282,
0.10935843735933304,
0.3304213285446167,
-0.06691998243331909,
0.04829852283000946,
-0.4217883050441742,
-0.2433261126279831,
0.04958157241344452,
0.1177484467625618,
0.2728102207183838,
0.2974766790866852,
0.26847052574157715,
0.3131210505962372,
0.021801862865686417,
0.036906395107507706,
0.16496172547340393,
0.1655726581811905,
-0.0690818578004837,
0.7888009548187256,
0.07200463861227036,
0.004561766050755978,
-0.1340065747499466,
-0.8025802969932556,
0.031699176877737045,
-1.0101966857910156,
0.5119087100028992,
0.563196063041687,
0.1733352094888687,
-0.1699259728193283,
0.6751141548156738,
0.34880542755126953,
0.4993782341480255,
0.15748143196105957,
-0.13923847675323486,
0.03248605132102966,
-0.16680246591567993,
-0.27244341373443604,
0.4763142168521881,
0.4318639039993286,
0.8901565670967102,
0.25228366255760193,
0.2990676462650299,
0.027310963720083237,
0.014165772125124931,
0.30865511298179626,
-0.8653022646903992,
0.18105681240558624,
0.6395749449729919,
-0.6871510744094849,
-0.569345235824585,
0.17984265089035034,
-0.6672212481498718,
-0.8350608944892883,
-0.3791576325893402,
0.2741261422634125,
-0.41715681552886963,
-0.5371708273887634,
0.5507959723472595,
-0.24581368267536163,
0.520745575428009,
0.4831234812736511,
-0.3566463887691498,
0.22036954760551453,
1.0282166004180908,
0.6918383240699768,
0.05046534165740013,
-0.1468808948993683,
-0.8566462993621826,
0.6476577520370483,
-0.531734824180603,
0.5267631411552429,
-0.7053983211517334,
-0.20845256745815277,
-0.13315334916114807,
-0.3374183177947998,
0.022746525704860687,
-0.2616809904575348,
0.6293104290962219,
-0.21497058868408203,
-0.10658439248800278,
-0.6803701519966125,
-0.8914111256599426,
-0.38419321179389954,
0.589250922203064,
-0.463846892118454,
0.6297985911369324,
-0.10652052611112595,
-0.7833343744277954,
0.7921992540359497,
-0.7516851425170898,
-0.21065481007099152,
0.17118871212005615,
-0.29967454075813293,
-0.5889651775360107,
0.5125284194946289,
0.10722608864307404,
0.3465808928012848,
-0.4511491060256958,
0.3760887086391449,
-0.5866069197654724,
-0.5068351030349731,
0.4949558675289154,
0.08611751347780228,
0.871734619140625,
-0.0737508237361908,
-0.497658908367157,
0.2267850935459137,
-0.30619189143180847,
-0.06653822213411331,
0.009131099097430706,
-0.16858023405075073,
-0.43453043699264526,
0.4499073922634125,
-0.2499854415655136,
0.4263571500778198,
0.03833432123064995,
-0.4400458335876465,
0.1333894431591034,
-0.24385017156600952,
0.5159546732902527,
1.0235931873321533,
-0.03578299283981323,
0.4761247932910919,
-0.5183963775634766,
0.3595750331878662,
0.05136296525597572,
0.4697411060333252,
-0.25706714391708374,
-0.39957696199417114,
-0.6327792406082153,
-0.3508474826812744,
0.3479549288749695,
0.5720493793487549,
-0.5672452449798584,
0.2465827763080597,
0.1586114466190338,
-0.2622828781604767,
-0.510153591632843,
-0.2299685776233673,
0.600533127784729,
0.2924445569515228,
-0.04542870447039604,
-0.3330836296081543,
0.029415791854262352,
-0.7243446111679077,
-0.7777091860771179,
-0.6869118809700012,
0.2401869297027588,
0.7425031065940857,
0.39065420627593994,
0.025219019502401352,
0.7956218123435974,
-0.004450139123946428,
-0.3628685772418976,
0.056010231375694275,
0.1118425577878952,
0.23464615643024445,
0.5077096819877625,
0.5241252183914185,
-0.9737619161605835,
-0.31065458059310913,
0.27392324805259705,
-0.6851959228515625,
-0.05503694340586662,
-0.11764220148324966,
-0.12493211030960083,
0.06952172517776489,
0.49416738748550415,
-0.5787253975868225,
0.5216138958930969,
0.6609594821929932,
-0.582362174987793,
0.5342071056365967,
-0.18987783789634705,
0.6992248892784119,
-0.6978212594985962,
-0.057100746780633926,
0.17121420800685883,
-0.24699582159519196,
-0.5363078713417053,
0.300273597240448,
0.08976591378450394,
0.29585978388786316,
-0.4906368851661682,
0.5785898566246033,
-0.23188349604606628,
-0.1914018839597702,
-0.12669917941093445,
0.07189405709505081,
0.143644317984581,
0.09032630920410156,
0.007108449935913086,
0.857332170009613,
0.7937926650047302,
-0.49595844745635986,
0.31967151165008545,
0.30305659770965576,
-0.3413236439228058,
1.0273736715316772,
-0.6331781148910522,
0.2581756114959717,
-0.10126525908708572,
0.06550505012273788,
-0.7038202285766602,
-0.14718829095363617,
0.3129371702671051,
-0.17513641715049744,
0.0013417877489700913,
-0.779691755771637,
-0.6646914482116699,
-0.12113004177808762,
-0.45134806632995605,
0.6148000955581665,
0.32690346240997314,
-0.444914311170578,
1.1548899412155151,
0.7914799451828003,
-0.09929685294628143,
-0.7539170384407043,
-0.3713325560092926,
0.23266522586345673,
-1.081822156906128,
-0.5722697973251343,
0.15586398541927338,
0.024858780205249786,
-0.6431276798248291,
-0.19678552448749542,
-0.2275509238243103,
0.2687913775444031,
0.028126534074544907,
0.2685892581939697,
0.14951381087303162,
-0.1673515886068344,
0.04922201484441757,
-0.09506961703300476,
-0.21905766427516937,
0.2091522067785263,
-0.42707058787345886,
-0.0013420457253232598,
-0.5266491174697876,
-0.7718913555145264,
0.11813784390687943,
0.40213701128959656,
0.5925255417823792,
-0.6042842268943787,
0.26682931184768677,
0.1431759148836136,
-0.294366717338562,
0.0006254604668356478,
-0.8479004502296448,
0.18835899233818054,
-0.54485023021698,
-0.16609206795692444,
-0.15681667625904083,
-1.060819149017334,
0.8374683856964111,
-0.6819236278533936,
0.18350094556808472,
0.10591302812099457,
0.4195583462715149,
-0.3325951099395752,
1.0955195426940918,
0.6482449769973755,
0.2730347812175751,
0.12374075502157211,
0.13349087536334991,
0.028778698295354843,
-0.7512844800949097,
-0.4278770983219147,
-0.17168323695659637,
-0.3599328100681305,
-0.6659395694732666,
-0.7987663745880127,
0.4546259641647339,
0.275778591632843,
-0.6046338081359863,
0.2202727496623993,
-0.5102704167366028,
0.8287168145179749,
0.3326958417892456,
0.1943041831254959,
0.1226588562130928,
-0.27274054288864136,
-0.3416457772254944,
-0.15385702252388,
-0.5373325943946838,
-0.7254722714424133,
0.7176740169525146,
0.527854859828949,
0.6513314843177795,
0.2819603979587555,
0.9295922517776489,
0.049382533878088,
0.6783929467201233,
-0.6750199198722839,
0.5106101036071777,
-0.22282028198242188,
-0.6345512270927429,
-0.19941484928131104,
-0.27046284079551697,
-0.5714285969734192,
0.5260167717933655,
-0.18775369226932526,
-0.8682241439819336,
0.39583900570869446,
-0.029593661427497864,
-0.5386841893196106,
0.4001164138317108,
-0.5160157680511475,
0.6994423270225525,
-0.6163797974586487,
-0.7357767820358276,
-0.3822891116142273,
-0.7785752415657043,
0.28741738200187683,
0.05165356397628784,
0.5870405435562134,
-0.5768173933029175,
-0.40748167037963867,
0.6169987320899963,
-0.08213916420936584,
0.859859824180603,
-0.32319962978363037,
-0.25541213154792786,
0.49095144867897034,
0.24184128642082214,
0.4613933265209198,
0.42074596881866455,
-0.32402321696281433,
0.2260253131389618,
0.008810577914118767,
-0.11251197010278702,
-0.11083637177944183,
0.7396001815795898,
-0.3267977237701416,
-0.752900242805481,
-0.7998787760734558,
-0.44587236642837524,
-0.4317059814929962,
0.10982947051525116,
-0.312569797039032,
0.01104412879794836,
-0.48918417096138,
0.003349380102008581,
0.9387913346290588,
-0.605741024017334,
0.32779115438461304,
0.46510049700737,
-0.4301430881023407,
-0.6284789443016052,
0.6287985444068909,
-0.4226363003253937,
0.11962185800075531,
-0.2021951675415039,
0.6320775151252747,
-0.4232720136642456,
-0.32304251194000244,
-0.4081799387931824,
0.46781137585639954,
-0.6945069432258606,
-0.5608858466148376,
-0.3563554883003235,
-0.031123271211981773,
0.25667110085487366,
-0.37461522221565247,
-0.3251335620880127,
0.09801246225833893,
-0.041638314723968506,
-0.23827114701271057,
0.44672006368637085,
0.900124192237854,
-0.19149228930473328,
0.3223627805709839,
-0.8404184579849243,
0.18438023328781128,
0.04557046294212341,
0.7453539371490479,
-0.5246079564094543,
0.0327080562710762,
-0.08512219041585922,
0.08248673379421234,
-0.04060681164264679,
-0.825413703918457,
0.03313256800174713,
0.001521302736364305,
0.4567844569683075,
0.5223861336708069,
-0.24641625583171844,
0.7431892156600952,
-0.7029709815979004,
0.5535368919372559,
0.6076273322105408,
-1.2362172603607178,
0.22412574291229248,
-0.6623001098632812,
-0.03926587849855423,
0.667233407497406,
-0.14918160438537598,
-0.457732617855072,
-0.3679015636444092,
-0.8418052792549133,
-0.663651168346405,
0.7898719906806946,
0.11894986033439636,
0.07753258943557739,
0.17852631211280823,
0.5474487543106079,
0.18186965584754944,
0.4245977997779846,
-0.4311865270137787,
0.05001544952392578,
-0.034196071326732635,
0.13810040056705475,
-0.2255879044532776,
-0.23628008365631104,
-0.6519935727119446,
-0.11308252066373825,
0.2612670361995697,
-0.2902805805206299,
-0.32945773005485535,
-0.04337793216109276,
0.23714382946491241,
-0.31189242005348206,
0.04105106368660927,
0.4015824794769287,
0.7094142436981201,
0.01987643726170063,
-0.017774702981114388,
0.11254830658435822,
-0.017413582652807236,
0.29337647557258606,
-0.03635364770889282,
0.2918614149093628,
-0.39847511053085327,
0.2741299867630005,
0.33244866132736206,
0.393277108669281,
-0.601313054561615,
0.8646835684776306,
-0.18639235198497772,
-0.475646436214447,
0.006671795155853033,
-0.04471943899989128,
0.3428025543689728,
0.7198841571807861,
0.16875946521759033,
0.08346429467201233,
0.1350533664226532,
-0.3423830568790436,
0.4950222969055176,
0.5251926183700562,
-0.14417652785778046,
0.26757800579071045,
0.6731755137443542,
0.2354145646095276,
-0.24004556238651276,
0.42770102620124817,
0.32669466733932495,
-0.535152018070221,
0.8400565981864929,
0.06783542037010193,
0.7543122172355652,
-0.2973879277706146,
0.5436825752258301,
0.20194865763187408,
0.37292051315307617,
-0.2609608769416809,
0.29506027698516846,
0.3140239417552948,
-0.7689418792724609,
-1.0375176668167114,
-0.37021002173423767,
-0.5973735451698303,
-0.1521795690059662,
-0.6602082252502441,
0.13922235369682312,
-0.5532830953598022,
-0.38770347833633423,
-0.07047612220048904,
-0.04582580551505089,
-0.6068629622459412,
0.11138861626386642,
0.002381417201831937,
0.7879803776741028,
-0.7845258712768555,
0.3922277092933655,
0.5844020247459412,
-0.19255775213241577,
-0.5163469910621643,
0.13144737482070923,
0.04288678988814354,
-0.9106631278991699,
0.4290248453617096,
0.2663717269897461,
-0.24369895458221436,
-0.26392698287963867,
-0.8751994967460632,
-0.6472610235214233,
0.9071477055549622,
0.8784074783325195,
-0.4065002202987671,
0.14370745420455933,
0.11651289463043213,
0.2507816255092621,
-0.5423976182937622,
-0.06057260185480118,
0.6209093332290649,
0.8509718775749207,
0.26914888620376587,
-0.8039233088493347,
-0.1474931687116623,
0.1779899150133133,
-0.33276990056037903,
0.19105850160121918,
-0.5843150615692139,
0.7273555397987366,
-0.575171709060669,
-0.02926480770111084,
-0.19645966589450836,
0.33893078565597534,
0.8261542320251465,
0.416339248418808,
0.7989140152931213,
0.46760210394859314,
0.6241517663002014,
-0.22840721905231476,
0.89846271276474,
-0.14300008118152618,
0.2587253451347351,
0.6711944937705994,
-0.6241692304611206,
0.365764319896698,
0.5916848182678223,
0.09131761640310287,
0.3834989368915558,
0.6994280815124512,
0.24035273492336273,
0.4056245982646942,
0.3354969322681427,
-0.30945608019828796,
-0.6513347029685974,
-0.21442432701587677,
-0.13841940462589264,
0.7930342555046082,
0.6625512838363647,
-0.11731907725334167,
-0.2040042281150818,
-0.3296445608139038,
-0.16978028416633606,
0.13808611035346985,
-0.3402917683124542,
1.041481852531433,
0.30168023705482483,
-0.47131842374801636,
-0.17394351959228516,
0.06907831132411957,
0.3334055244922638,
-0.4555511474609375,
-0.5389900207519531,
0.08027908951044083,
0.21837474405765533,
-0.09828246384859085,
-1.1013104915618896,
0.09778733551502228,
-0.01725461520254612,
0.2750031054019928,
-0.6630551218986511,
0.7552101016044617,
-0.4400191605091095,
-0.39145272970199585,
0.4393402338027954,
0.6748148202896118,
0.07509052753448486,
0.028258882462978363,
-1.2906204462051392,
0.37705209851264954,
-0.3727307915687561,
-0.23253300786018372,
0.32636919617652893,
0.7639652490615845,
-0.032980777323246,
0.5638411641120911,
0.6027730107307434,
0.14431336522102356,
-0.378692626953125,
0.08306080847978592,
0.7774261236190796,
-0.5113078951835632,
-0.4919165074825287,
-1.1166568994522095,
0.7350252866744995,
-0.4014275074005127,
0.02707638218998909,
0.6705966591835022,
0.6430408358573914,
0.5318570137023926,
0.31666335463523865,
0.8151562809944153,
0.004965874366462231,
0.08533868193626404,
-0.6270924806594849,
0.5614861249923706,
-0.5267689228057861,
0.09141641855239868,
-0.3684883713722229,
-0.6097185611724854,
-0.23971769213676453,
0.953032374382019,
-0.0992819294333458,
0.19209185242652893,
0.46488863229751587,
0.38922587037086487,
-0.043645504862070084,
0.020733783021569252,
0.3699357211589813,
-0.26336759328842163,
0.4383058547973633,
0.4898200035095215,
0.9818029403686523,
-0.1481681764125824,
0.0704740434885025,
0.15987059473991394,
-0.3903105556964874,
0.006480205804109573,
-1.663615107536316,
-0.8955405950546265,
-0.5106275677680969,
-0.38410520553588867,
-0.5543646812438965,
-0.049730829894542694,
0.7589580416679382,
0.662951648235321,
-0.6089475154876709,
-0.5587142705917358,
-0.04576030373573303,
0.2994188666343689,
-0.49986958503723145,
-0.108906090259552,
0.3001546561717987,
-0.053874511271715164,
-0.3904249966144562,
0.24799540638923645,
0.6791268587112427,
-0.21789900958538055,
-0.01488979160785675,
-0.31895333528518677,
-0.1794508397579193,
0.5246222019195557,
0.5863100290298462,
-0.09021711349487305,
-0.8677860498428345,
-0.5915853977203369,
-0.23941101133823395,
0.044107433408498764,
0.08563622832298279,
1.3589532375335693,
-0.521701991558075,
0.3416861295700073,
-0.08059021830558777,
0.6387941837310791,
0.3424462676048279,
0.3723050653934479,
0.7652007341384888,
-0.30910682678222656,
-0.07673253864049911,
0.38942039012908936,
0.37004703283309937,
0.3202204406261444,
-0.35254842042922974,
0.5790562629699707,
-0.18538013100624084,
-0.6084275245666504,
-0.6726161241531372,
0.44632574915885925,
-0.7337881922721863,
-0.3947286307811737,
1.4023113250732422,
-0.3151514530181885,
0.0000676447234582156,
-0.06641668826341629,
-0.4255285859107971,
0.06320992112159729,
-0.2721831798553467,
0.544839084148407,
0.9207055568695068,
-0.17546802759170532,
-0.36771783232688904,
-0.40715640783309937,
0.7325496077537537,
0.09535996615886688,
-0.8578479886054993,
0.593080997467041,
0.6752147078514099,
0.34543099999427795,
0.07203009724617004,
0.7472409605979919,
-0.24903622269630432,
0.17238962650299072,
-0.2836040258407593,
-0.15813465416431427,
0.02298559993505478,
-0.2649105191230774,
-0.29843536019325256,
0.05808369815349579,
0.0325888991355896,
0.09773530066013336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12929v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12929v1
|
Code-mixed Sentiment and Hate-speech Prediction
| 2024-05-21T16:56:36 | 2024-05-21T16:56:36 |
Anjali Yadav, Tanya Garg, Matej Klemen, Matej Ulcar, Basant Agarwal, Marko Robnik Sikonja
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Code-mixed discourse combines multiple languages in a single text. It is
commonly used in informal discourse in countries with several official
languages, but also in many other countries in combination with English or
neighboring languages. As recently large language models have dominated most
natural language processing tasks, we investigated their performance in
code-mixed settings for relevant tasks. We first created four new bilingual
pre-trained masked language models for English-Hindi and English-Slovene
languages, specifically aimed to support informal language. Then we performed
an evaluation of monolingual, bilingual, few-lingual, and massively
multilingual models on several languages, using two tasks that frequently
contain code-mixed text, in particular, sentiment analysis and offensive
language detection in social media texts. The results show that the most
successful classifiers are fine-tuned bilingual models and multilingual models,
specialized for social media texts, followed by non-specialized massively
multilingual and monolingual models, while huge generative models are not
competitive. For our affective problems, the models mostly perform slightly
better on code-mixed data compared to non-code-mixed data.
|
[
-0.44792377948760986,
-0.8007773160934448,
0.09653288125991821,
0.4858950674533844,
-0.31570762395858765,
0.5929712057113647,
-0.3887312412261963,
-0.8161229491233826,
0.2688072919845581,
0.3902616798877716,
-0.30173560976982117,
-0.532801628112793,
-0.7388603687286377,
0.21385513246059418,
-0.40789639949798584,
1.3740606307983398,
0.19294260442256927,
0.5316751599311829,
0.026739519089460373,
-0.19544638693332672,
-0.2648251950740814,
-1.017256498336792,
-0.3119470477104187,
-0.3447842299938202,
0.5587504506111145,
0.18213903903961182,
1.0321849584579468,
0.14529456198215485,
0.5399301648139954,
0.285602867603302,
-0.0933322086930275,
-0.031168092042207718,
-0.459734171628952,
0.06989838927984238,
-0.03937005624175072,
-0.40770280361175537,
-0.42603954672813416,
-0.1108199879527092,
0.13425379991531372,
0.5280151963233948,
0.06393052637577057,
-0.06127959489822388,
0.06495947390794754,
0.3142850995063782,
-0.5719300508499146,
0.22803011536598206,
-0.6535282135009766,
0.23075687885284424,
-0.20601993799209595,
-0.10020019859075546,
-0.3981921970844269,
-0.5506294369697571,
-0.10710645467042923,
-0.1960485279560089,
-0.09765826165676117,
-0.06805438548326492,
0.5179083943367004,
0.0420774444937706,
-0.46255525946617126,
-0.5689107179641724,
-0.7071123123168945,
0.8943984508514404,
-0.7784880995750427,
0.22415296733379364,
0.5660331845283508,
-0.07209163159132004,
0.25896766781806946,
-0.21420753002166748,
-0.5840674042701721,
-0.15001769363880157,
-0.22863677144050598,
0.2695253789424896,
-0.31751957535743713,
0.2716675400733948,
0.1997741311788559,
0.305345743894577,
-0.649681806564331,
0.36811399459838867,
-0.5613609552383423,
-0.22236871719360352,
0.7259854078292847,
0.16105809807777405,
0.45788487792015076,
-0.3820195496082306,
-0.17906004190444946,
0.40435856580734253,
-0.43756499886512756,
-0.0563034787774086,
0.6934624314308167,
0.5053668022155762,
-0.38631004095077515,
0.6658264994621277,
-0.12402831763029099,
0.8463679552078247,
-0.2547034025192261,
-0.3300509452819824,
0.390983521938324,
-0.2944149374961853,
-0.23844008147716522,
-0.10421762615442276,
0.9356544613838196,
0.36894309520721436,
0.719375729560852,
-0.0825498029589653,
-0.34636759757995605,
0.6645695567131042,
0.16481201350688934,
-0.7249718308448792,
-0.1567632257938385,
0.1720339059829712,
-0.47145599126815796,
-0.5252556204795837,
-0.38769516348838806,
-1.1414785385131836,
-0.45020392537117004,
-0.4039384722709656,
0.021465642377734184,
-0.3644459843635559,
-0.3907822072505951,
0.18373320996761322,
0.0835384652018547,
0.060043707489967346,
0.15471775829792023,
-0.6324991583824158,
0.30721718072891235,
0.49814537167549133,
0.8227993845939636,
-0.4219634234905243,
-0.17366738617420197,
-0.24935242533683777,
-0.40667229890823364,
-0.2900097370147705,
0.6354063749313354,
-0.9523612856864929,
-0.4004865884780884,
0.3731187880039215,
-0.28191155195236206,
-0.11353571712970734,
-0.45147499442100525,
0.6126803159713745,
-0.6862711906433105,
0.225059375166893,
0.08721864223480225,
-0.17120780050754547,
-0.07664354145526886,
0.2949465215206146,
-0.569786548614502,
1.0752558708190918,
0.07011298090219498,
-1.0410093069076538,
0.25926679372787476,
-0.44616401195526123,
-0.7044177055358887,
0.029152818024158478,
-0.06929771602153778,
-0.4133434593677521,
0.04911456257104874,
-0.10124991834163666,
0.5638455748558044,
-0.06989551335573196,
0.4480859041213989,
-0.3772847056388855,
-0.4838871955871582,
0.38160282373428345,
-0.19391128420829773,
0.8054558038711548,
0.5313159227371216,
-0.39176759123802185,
0.11737717688083649,
-0.8064296245574951,
0.025153009220957756,
0.06125444173812866,
-0.2574627995491028,
-0.4533988833427429,
0.13529762625694275,
0.45718106627464294,
0.6153837442398071,
0.06825786828994751,
-0.6003258228302002,
-0.07480029761791229,
-0.4647005498409271,
0.34297975897789,
0.5764617919921875,
-0.19399626553058624,
0.3210470974445343,
-0.12280473858118057,
0.9864044785499573,
0.34973272681236267,
-0.06560223549604416,
-0.025143543258309364,
-0.7250614762306213,
-0.6566475033760071,
-0.09186282753944397,
0.024675805121660233,
0.764460027217865,
-0.963950514793396,
0.05241238325834274,
-0.0075200083665549755,
-0.4448655843734741,
-0.4461676776409149,
-0.11205394566059113,
0.9019573926925659,
-0.09928849339485168,
0.3756069540977478,
-0.31733953952789307,
-0.9054588079452515,
-0.8378410935401917,
-0.4419662058353424,
-0.17024274170398712,
0.3292103111743927,
0.22857896983623505,
0.39597445726394653,
-0.36881354451179504,
0.6784636378288269,
-0.4574861228466034,
0.13504409790039062,
-0.3391076922416687,
0.4266989529132843,
0.10675839334726334,
0.2572701573371887,
0.4855322241783142,
-0.9396268725395203,
-0.8165739178657532,
0.02790019102394581,
-0.47154784202575684,
-0.09141477942466736,
0.23724745213985443,
0.2972932755947113,
0.5177483558654785,
0.2319391667842865,
-0.050781067460775375,
0.4144519865512848,
1.0714572668075562,
-0.24294540286064148,
0.6713831424713135,
0.24196036159992218,
0.40505924820899963,
-1.0832284688949585,
-0.2963230609893799,
0.20407287776470184,
-0.18593187630176544,
-1.001797080039978,
0.06889183074235916,
-0.04281165078282356,
-0.29713889956474304,
-0.5954214930534363,
0.21127524971961975,
-0.34223470091819763,
-0.004712908063083887,
-0.21395233273506165,
-0.1539505273103714,
-0.28134968876838684,
0.6414066553115845,
0.28108373284339905,
0.8089209794998169,
0.6010794043540955,
-0.4019278287887573,
0.10467220842838287,
-0.06450407952070236,
-0.48885679244995117,
0.260140061378479,
-0.5074440836906433,
0.3401723802089691,
-0.20943109691143036,
-0.014815492555499077,
-1.056646704673767,
-0.3248961567878723,
0.15068259835243225,
-0.5051337480545044,
0.2739783525466919,
-0.2792004644870758,
-0.4566003382205963,
-0.34325969219207764,
-0.1387435644865036,
0.7702680826187134,
0.39411890506744385,
-0.24461066722869873,
0.30969274044036865,
0.653485894203186,
-0.3224160671234131,
-0.594779372215271,
-1.0929380655288696,
0.13120250403881073,
-0.16102351248264313,
-0.4993245303630829,
0.05383238196372986,
-0.23605172336101532,
-0.45950037240982056,
-0.22139900922775269,
0.30588260293006897,
-0.5886414051055908,
-0.05259513482451439,
0.4701337218284607,
0.41437801718711853,
-0.12637032568454742,
-0.08602973073720932,
-0.09089621156454086,
0.17601263523101807,
0.062050942331552505,
0.03645700588822365,
0.7756224274635315,
-0.1690046191215515,
-0.1412772685289383,
0.2602590322494507,
0.6284685730934143,
0.4764309525489807,
-0.370816707611084,
0.819389283657074,
0.5302817225456238,
-0.3433053195476532,
-0.14950546622276306,
-0.42149287462234497,
0.2616228461265564,
-0.40705588459968567,
0.3896723687648773,
-0.24566440284252167,
-1.2431796789169312,
0.6953920722007751,
0.46190643310546875,
-0.22631248831748962,
0.03641346096992493,
0.8084942102432251,
0.3112901747226715,
1.3439995050430298,
0.5654558539390564,
-0.5245658755302429,
0.40893521904945374,
0.25484636425971985,
0.6565554738044739,
-0.061167337000370026,
-0.1190730407834053,
-0.8134607672691345,
0.09185962378978729,
-1.0530952215194702,
-0.6253417730331421,
0.2909097969532013,
-0.15773476660251617,
-0.05634142458438873,
0.37907031178474426,
-0.49258971214294434,
0.4540446698665619,
0.19432683289051056,
-0.013300023972988129,
0.35155776143074036,
0.14242208003997803,
-0.10944619029760361,
-0.309145450592041,
-0.637735903263092,
-0.42733100056648254,
0.9933587312698364,
0.314028263092041,
0.7934911251068115,
-0.14392390847206116,
0.7291327118873596,
0.29425132274627686,
0.37217822670936584,
-0.8254954814910889,
0.38515645265579224,
-0.26731839776039124,
-0.8000354766845703,
0.2529047727584839,
-0.4934564232826233,
-0.5686559677124023,
0.23849204182624817,
-0.18421153724193573,
-0.6048657894134521,
0.04922987148165703,
0.07106932997703552,
-0.1894644796848297,
0.2791522145271301,
-0.8174331188201904,
0.644325315952301,
-0.1062050461769104,
-0.22921422123908997,
-0.17325295507907867,
-0.5556790828704834,
0.6813188195228577,
-0.25428926944732666,
0.9662399291992188,
0.0380462221801281,
0.008868916891515255,
0.6908584833145142,
0.041392501443624496,
1.017796516418457,
0.05175892636179924,
-0.18236586451530457,
0.2637826204299927,
0.08540762215852737,
0.3528914749622345,
-0.1131964921951294,
-0.28830334544181824,
0.5574413537979126,
-0.20322589576244354,
-0.34150242805480957,
-0.1625910997390747,
0.5688229203224182,
-0.8430646657943726,
-0.18680451810359955,
-0.4283865988254547,
-0.41827720403671265,
-0.22894060611724854,
0.1835024505853653,
0.4631902575492859,
0.4356997311115265,
-0.25110238790512085,
-0.09225961565971375,
0.6337947845458984,
-0.500187873840332,
0.43662121891975403,
0.5430210828781128,
-0.44894465804100037,
-0.3765023350715637,
1.0051357746124268,
0.11605700105428696,
0.3925962746143341,
0.11913131922483444,
-0.05076616629958153,
0.17937342822551727,
-0.5310583710670471,
-0.28028184175491333,
-0.11806339770555496,
-0.6617917418479919,
-0.3340558409690857,
-1.0578124523162842,
-0.31618866324424744,
-0.3508317470550537,
-0.3482154607772827,
-0.40172669291496277,
-0.217144176363945,
-0.026251763105392456,
-0.08094954490661621,
0.05121895670890808,
0.8905068635940552,
0.1444483995437622,
0.09583678841590881,
-0.6434018611907959,
0.4873273968696594,
-0.017478490248322487,
0.604944109916687,
-0.2599778473377228,
-0.403406023979187,
-0.34248897433280945,
0.2665422558784485,
-0.04747682437300682,
-1.1270372867584229,
0.622393012046814,
0.04240765422582626,
0.0804964005947113,
0.18197385966777802,
-0.0258161723613739,
0.4989606738090515,
-0.4571201503276825,
0.9245256185531616,
0.31647753715515137,
-0.8920332789421082,
0.3179927170276642,
-0.6032472252845764,
0.1514570564031601,
0.35482391715049744,
0.6319989562034607,
-0.6286917924880981,
-0.893258273601532,
-0.29773882031440735,
-0.744808554649353,
0.7716403603553772,
0.18516211211681366,
0.372935950756073,
-0.46375948190689087,
-0.22170943021774292,
0.14481772482395172,
0.2783881723880768,
-1.4679239988327026,
-0.5016902089118958,
-0.32339373230934143,
-0.11620324850082397,
-0.06889864802360535,
-0.5900974869728088,
0.07474806904792786,
-0.37734556198120117,
0.41942480206489563,
-0.05437437817454338,
0.3673049807548523,
-0.1772625744342804,
-0.1232878714799881,
-0.3380897343158722,
0.577698290348053,
0.5958723425865173,
0.500381350517273,
-0.11907351762056351,
0.11789414286613464,
-0.023937851190567017,
-0.39882513880729675,
0.10278716683387756,
0.0039024045690894127,
-0.1928619146347046,
0.16093452274799347,
0.37149980664253235,
0.8507195115089417,
0.5747195482254028,
-0.7424017786979675,
0.469513475894928,
-0.025474952533841133,
-0.17875686287879944,
-0.2805521786212921,
-0.11655477434396744,
0.057330287992954254,
-0.04907257854938507,
0.09000290185213089,
0.37070849537849426,
0.28967535495758057,
-0.7474996447563171,
0.06509722024202347,
0.36967217922210693,
-0.4181877076625824,
-0.3462368845939636,
0.34571948647499084,
0.0847535952925682,
-0.41915807127952576,
0.043773103505373,
-0.44467467069625854,
-1.1123440265655518,
0.5966238379478455,
0.6707819104194641,
0.7799105048179626,
-0.3001173436641693,
0.4442959427833557,
0.4674417972564697,
0.33895009756088257,
0.04174896329641342,
0.4300934076309204,
0.09533470124006271,
-0.9339126944541931,
-0.4672203063964844,
-0.8587256669998169,
-0.2989904284477234,
-0.06376513093709946,
-0.7977837920188904,
0.2952065169811249,
-0.2877045273780823,
-0.014248563908040524,
0.06072276830673218,
-0.03272492438554764,
-0.7521253824234009,
0.3365180194377899,
0.4184000492095947,
0.4856707453727722,
-1.0894999504089355,
0.8969246745109558,
0.7551606893539429,
-0.3494639992713928,
-0.8390470147132874,
-0.11174879968166351,
0.043796032667160034,
-0.8649483919143677,
0.5925642848014832,
0.2499576359987259,
-0.15291017293930054,
-0.0928773581981659,
-0.5031945705413818,
-0.7001994848251343,
0.27186065912246704,
0.015473722480237484,
-0.49246037006378174,
0.19279974699020386,
0.4519854187965393,
0.9439951777458191,
-0.410416841506958,
0.3899442255496979,
0.5246860980987549,
0.2638244926929474,
-0.05606261268258095,
-0.9997156858444214,
-0.3558655083179474,
-0.5253519415855408,
-0.13091924786567688,
0.32608479261398315,
-0.440637469291687,
0.890496015548706,
0.05524013191461563,
-0.17056919634342194,
-0.3442205488681793,
0.3717988133430481,
0.020686622709035873,
0.44892606139183044,
0.3605199158191681,
0.41733989119529724,
0.3256305456161499,
-0.04134535416960716,
1.111068844795227,
-0.44193175435066223,
0.2540779411792755,
1.0007927417755127,
-0.31197094917297363,
0.7389514446258545,
0.09333546459674835,
-0.2916826605796814,
0.6257513165473938,
0.44333940744400024,
0.22713349759578705,
0.32096001505851746,
0.17504535615444183,
-0.23839640617370605,
0.07204260677099228,
-0.24187126755714417,
-0.3366495966911316,
0.6728833913803101,
0.23473075032234192,
-0.3448426425457001,
-0.02788415551185608,
0.1976643204689026,
0.2570329010486603,
0.2531946897506714,
-0.4057069420814514,
0.8900443911552429,
0.0335293672978878,
-0.9641081094741821,
0.6061933040618896,
0.2578487694263458,
1.2546504735946655,
-0.3972025215625763,
0.10451769083738327,
-0.3301786184310913,
-0.207118958234787,
-0.5094884037971497,
-0.7704583406448364,
0.6017956137657166,
0.5613254308700562,
-0.27150610089302063,
-0.2874220311641693,
0.8565981984138489,
-0.7515431642532349,
-0.614619791507721,
0.754501461982727,
0.28062763810157776,
0.03533105552196503,
-0.013849637471139431,
-0.734276533126831,
0.26137301325798035,
0.14155414700508118,
-0.22628462314605713,
0.5799503922462463,
0.31542086601257324,
0.05173391476273537,
0.45224717259407043,
0.46356502175331116,
0.2138773500919342,
0.44111087918281555,
0.3190723657608032,
1.0735085010528564,
-0.5799092650413513,
-0.5712970495223999,
-0.8375539183616638,
0.5679597854614258,
0.002512349747121334,
-0.3096398711204529,
0.8443986773490906,
0.6713603734970093,
1.017235279083252,
-0.07248370349407196,
0.9554796814918518,
-0.06694849580526352,
0.47790664434432983,
-0.43537023663520813,
0.4014301896095276,
-0.41122737526893616,
0.03785246983170509,
-0.7987250089645386,
-0.7964935898780823,
-0.29546448588371277,
0.5210611820220947,
-0.4327271282672882,
0.16208329796791077,
0.622472882270813,
0.9032360911369324,
0.006662525236606598,
0.2131374478340149,
0.48900124430656433,
0.1331861913204193,
0.1275169849395752,
0.5049421191215515,
0.8629317283630371,
-0.2108355015516281,
0.4714622497558594,
-0.4612135589122772,
-0.20552274584770203,
-0.022973397746682167,
-0.699515700340271,
-0.9664130806922913,
-0.396764874458313,
-0.20531952381134033,
-0.5003645420074463,
-0.024864861741662025,
0.8238924741744995,
0.6062578558921814,
-0.9913367629051208,
-0.32939237356185913,
-0.00650659017264843,
0.15802517533302307,
0.27130767703056335,
-0.3198637068271637,
-0.26880866289138794,
-0.39556884765625,
-0.80778568983078,
0.23100236058235168,
0.47736620903015137,
-0.28112098574638367,
-0.1489788442850113,
-0.08904507011175156,
-0.2922106385231018,
0.27769163250923157,
0.7381117343902588,
0.02928301878273487,
-0.6102335453033447,
-0.10601862519979477,
-0.028560437262058258,
-0.5062291622161865,
0.06045755743980408,
1.115669846534729,
-0.4407395124435425,
0.582481861114502,
0.2924664318561554,
0.3732682466506958,
0.28789055347442627,
-0.04403027892112732,
0.44714075326919556,
-0.76973956823349,
0.5740931630134583,
0.6204344034194946,
0.3809232711791992,
0.30446216464042664,
-0.3733043968677521,
0.380901038646698,
0.13055217266082764,
-0.47864654660224915,
-0.8939325213432312,
0.3279321789741516,
-0.7743327021598816,
-0.37782734632492065,
1.395869493484497,
-0.2030549943447113,
0.1467313915491104,
-0.47679266333580017,
-0.14927151799201965,
0.2568109631538391,
-0.31048935651779175,
0.5798568725585938,
0.8226003646850586,
0.20523715019226074,
-0.11264733225107193,
-0.5493646860122681,
0.5620450973510742,
0.48725438117980957,
-0.7119901180267334,
-0.08263818174600601,
0.7181225419044495,
0.015058848075568676,
0.13482709228992462,
0.8337449431419373,
-0.14364482462406158,
0.19193905591964722,
-0.05684344097971916,
0.16578543186187744,
0.15552237629890442,
-0.2976728677749634,
-0.5844690799713135,
0.30149728059768677,
0.07714854925870895,
0.2711346745491028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12915v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12915v1
|
G-DIG: Towards Gradient-based DIverse and hiGh-quality Instruction Data Selection for Machine Translation
| 2024-05-21T16:38:13 | 2024-05-21T16:38:13 |
Xingyuan Pan, Luyang Huang, Liyan Kang, Zhicheng Liu, Yu Lu, Shanbo Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable abilities in
general scenarios. Instruction finetuning empowers them to align with humans in
various tasks. Nevertheless, the Diversity and Quality of the instruction data
remain two main challenges for instruction finetuning. With regard to this, in
this paper, we propose a novel gradient-based method to automatically select
high-quality and diverse instruction finetuning data for machine translation.
Our key innovation centers around analyzing how individual training examples
influence the model during training. Specifically, we select training examples
that exert beneficial influences on the model as high-quality ones by means of
Influence Function plus a small high-quality seed dataset. Moreover, to enhance
the diversity of the training data we maximize the variety of influences they
have on the model by clustering on their gradients and resampling. Extensive
experiments on WMT22 and FLORES translation tasks demonstrate the superiority
of our methods, and in-depth analysis further validates their effectiveness and
generalization.
|
[
-0.42185500264167786,
-0.7794298529624939,
0.15513835847377777,
0.19895391166210175,
-0.26516392827033997,
0.14016938209533691,
-0.46031245589256287,
0.028086569160223007,
0.034420501440763474,
0.38127848505973816,
-0.6138147115707397,
-1.007124423980713,
-0.9304830431938171,
-0.01644962653517723,
-0.5069236159324646,
1.0477572679519653,
-0.08476617187261581,
0.6431484818458557,
0.189663827419281,
-0.24024614691734314,
-0.3482968509197235,
-0.10454462468624115,
-0.37456926703453064,
-0.19481419026851654,
0.21376286447048187,
0.5158545970916748,
0.5351049900054932,
0.9410015344619751,
0.6906301975250244,
0.2518686056137085,
-0.09927485883235931,
0.5113272070884705,
-0.7950785160064697,
0.22544249892234802,
-0.1619032621383667,
-0.5543297529220581,
-0.2592509090900421,
-0.017460566014051437,
0.7129212617874146,
0.7101491093635559,
-0.13575708866119385,
0.21770335733890533,
0.25840485095977783,
0.6192799806594849,
-0.4491480588912964,
-0.1979215294122696,
-0.7108372449874878,
0.2880103886127472,
-0.058843646198511124,
0.026841064915060997,
-0.29404598474502563,
-0.6558390259742737,
-0.0486682653427124,
-0.4922133684158325,
0.5795432925224304,
-0.1406337469816208,
0.6390683054924011,
0.4224218428134918,
-0.38320624828338623,
-0.32840174436569214,
-0.6288418173789978,
1.0244656801223755,
-0.5092664361000061,
0.5106931328773499,
0.30571842193603516,
0.4982144236564636,
-0.06772251427173615,
-0.5426691174507141,
-0.2654799818992615,
-0.03973790258169174,
0.174217090010643,
0.08279053866863251,
0.2805156707763672,
-0.021002821624279022,
0.07511313259601593,
0.8519338965415955,
-0.38482773303985596,
0.42878150939941406,
-0.2043650597333908,
-0.11457248032093048,
0.3786262273788452,
0.22292572259902954,
0.4187925457954407,
0.2588725984096527,
-0.2152848094701767,
-0.2597307860851288,
-0.7045701146125793,
0.03676300495862961,
0.4942401945590973,
0.3689909279346466,
-0.2125653326511383,
0.5543456673622131,
-0.38927462697029114,
0.7396247386932373,
0.10860532522201538,
-0.02298196777701378,
0.450156033039093,
-0.3181430697441101,
-0.2782670557498932,
-0.40324169397354126,
0.8370671272277832,
0.29244574904441833,
0.21657182276248932,
-0.25838711857795715,
-0.35650911927223206,
-0.25526759028434753,
-0.011081243865191936,
-0.9489548802375793,
-0.030740154907107353,
0.016229800879955292,
-0.4220086932182312,
-0.13903726637363434,
0.17708541452884674,
-1.1169778108596802,
-0.325513631105423,
-0.5502158403396606,
0.05061754584312439,
-0.22568871080875397,
0.31423380970954895,
0.1512930542230606,
0.037945620715618134,
0.043358348309993744,
0.3408381938934326,
-1.1582108736038208,
0.12288884818553925,
0.5306198596954346,
0.6908782124519348,
-0.3965905010700226,
-0.3735005855560303,
-0.9401503205299377,
-0.08625072985887527,
-0.19845440983772278,
0.31744813919067383,
-0.811897337436676,
-0.5017128586769104,
0.1574903428554535,
0.018959397450089455,
-0.09964011609554291,
-0.5848346948623657,
0.6478994488716125,
-0.4327270984649658,
0.3447780907154083,
-0.19696108996868134,
-0.5383495092391968,
-0.14285066723823547,
0.149990975856781,
-0.5623990297317505,
0.9482548832893372,
0.466004878282547,
-0.6001675724983215,
0.33618858456611633,
-0.21605996787548065,
-0.6393207311630249,
-0.06853606551885605,
-0.39350956678390503,
-0.3637964725494385,
0.09021122753620148,
0.6258866190910339,
0.6358251571655273,
-0.5136584043502808,
0.2970070540904999,
-0.040660031139850616,
-0.33188170194625854,
-0.1470881700515747,
-0.3876754343509674,
0.6613307595252991,
0.1023993194103241,
-0.4189421236515045,
0.1581629365682602,
-0.7379899621009827,
-0.06384655833244324,
-0.03680816665291786,
-0.6653298139572144,
-0.22792410850524902,
-0.2512277364730835,
-0.3282022178173065,
0.30855560302734375,
0.06506814807653427,
-0.3840104043483734,
0.5917844176292419,
-0.18227873742580414,
0.17781272530555725,
0.6434831023216248,
0.11209093779325485,
0.7262447476387024,
-0.129817932844162,
0.889281690120697,
-0.11228734254837036,
0.11191172152757645,
0.03508536517620087,
-0.5081816911697388,
-0.7371804118156433,
-0.43885982036590576,
0.5208489894866943,
0.8067691326141357,
-0.7475979328155518,
0.3870628774166107,
-0.47587284445762634,
-0.30149346590042114,
-1.129014253616333,
0.47691717743873596,
0.43654632568359375,
0.45965802669525146,
0.7769768238067627,
-0.13332851231098175,
-0.25523605942726135,
-0.690639078617096,
-0.0370846726000309,
0.6828199625015259,
-0.20898866653442383,
0.470345675945282,
0.22202782332897186,
-0.6103387475013733,
0.5679426193237305,
-0.6299686431884766,
-0.4191635251045227,
-0.19695492088794708,
0.10691669583320618,
0.34438496828079224,
0.5772437453269958,
0.5862523317337036,
-0.43225622177124023,
-0.6561446785926819,
0.24254107475280762,
-0.5159879326820374,
-0.0837010070681572,
-0.2492968738079071,
-0.6123840808868408,
-0.328687459230423,
0.5159328579902649,
-0.3854070007801056,
0.012115122750401497,
0.6671566367149353,
0.055096935480833054,
0.21519653499126434,
-0.21041500568389893,
0.32507142424583435,
-0.988364577293396,
-0.1077076718211174,
0.25966209173202515,
0.03264564648270607,
-0.5037760138511658,
0.09881673753261566,
0.0986633151769638,
0.17806392908096313,
-0.375946968793869,
0.4504520893096924,
-0.43822282552719116,
0.05630826577544212,
0.15489761531352997,
-0.054131463170051575,
-0.1211414560675621,
0.47044727206230164,
-0.2891523540019989,
0.7856349945068359,
0.6150761246681213,
-0.6892209053039551,
0.2703339159488678,
0.43966570496559143,
-0.6290200352668762,
0.2668778896331787,
-0.4856501817703247,
0.15432557463645935,
-0.14227412641048431,
0.0014834334142506123,
-0.8765127062797546,
-0.12695324420928955,
0.39226073026657104,
-0.17364190518856049,
0.5942776203155518,
-0.5319075584411621,
-0.29753947257995605,
-0.18680298328399658,
-0.1656551957130432,
0.15212281048297882,
0.603967547416687,
-0.6354994773864746,
0.28934842348098755,
0.2618907690048218,
-0.3568626940250397,
-0.7486790418624878,
-0.541835367679596,
-0.06392539292573929,
-0.19042882323265076,
-0.3631076514720917,
0.317306250333786,
-0.09227149188518524,
0.007756659295409918,
-0.31620919704437256,
0.04362238198518753,
-0.12059131264686584,
0.10266806930303574,
-0.048174839466810226,
0.23018229007720947,
-0.16086958348751068,
-0.14894923567771912,
0.6238561868667603,
0.031367093324661255,
-0.1990623027086258,
-0.5444563031196594,
0.5774554014205933,
0.23116075992584229,
-0.3130737245082855,
-0.33222997188568115,
0.28987255692481995,
0.519578754901886,
-0.6333808302879333,
0.47785815596580505,
0.9691601395606995,
-0.022732434794306755,
-0.8169251084327698,
-0.1895926594734192,
-0.17412030696868896,
-0.4399398863315582,
0.6676394939422607,
-0.0857829824090004,
-0.9756416082382202,
0.3653820753097534,
-0.04816508665680885,
0.22044147551059723,
0.3394269049167633,
0.6795105934143066,
-0.003356372006237507,
1.0056087970733643,
0.27551504969596863,
-0.48692619800567627,
0.7509204149246216,
-0.6664459109306335,
-0.15418517589569092,
-0.9465941786766052,
-0.03178013116121292,
-0.6353183388710022,
-0.5908755660057068,
-0.500313937664032,
-0.6569547057151794,
0.07560541480779648,
0.07196164131164551,
-0.15583182871341705,
-0.042466770857572556,
-0.5193568468093872,
0.36281266808509827,
0.646895170211792,
0.03852132707834244,
0.057047344744205475,
0.40945932269096375,
-0.29582810401916504,
-0.011023836210370064,
-0.46848103404045105,
-0.3375532329082489,
1.2432397603988647,
0.3016839921474457,
0.9844532012939453,
0.03864561393857002,
0.6755370497703552,
0.27757471799850464,
0.3461848795413971,
-0.7025328278541565,
0.467267245054245,
-0.6795568466186523,
-0.2581080496311188,
-0.4039052426815033,
-0.7099958658218384,
-1.0778870582580566,
0.39361968636512756,
-0.18252550065517426,
-0.34889113903045654,
-0.042201749980449677,
0.10136308521032333,
-0.24264591932296753,
0.14443080127239227,
-0.46289995312690735,
0.5846519470214844,
-0.25452154874801636,
-0.2570842504501343,
-0.1404971182346344,
-0.6863729953765869,
0.27047035098075867,
0.06222335249185562,
0.14848113059997559,
-0.0311714019626379,
0.18792492151260376,
0.4621357321739197,
-0.005304547026753426,
0.7684183716773987,
-0.3416183888912201,
-0.3834272027015686,
0.19005826115608215,
0.2356071025133133,
0.6850164532661438,
-0.10430920869112015,
-0.0834842100739479,
0.08534367382526398,
-0.7276790738105774,
-0.1421033889055252,
-0.5782893896102905,
0.717671811580658,
-0.7749177813529968,
-0.4956170618534088,
0.4161849319934845,
-0.5237584710121155,
-0.36740195751190186,
0.27080237865448,
0.4819004535675049,
0.3712819516658783,
-0.12804673612117767,
0.4310794770717621,
0.7174042463302612,
-0.2423105239868164,
0.1750068962574005,
0.19574986398220062,
-0.11514358967542648,
-0.6374961137771606,
1.2896003723144531,
0.16174465417861938,
0.4447843134403229,
0.5668082237243652,
0.14617040753364563,
-0.13780833780765533,
-1.0556660890579224,
-0.8295542001724243,
0.1463100016117096,
-0.8732817769050598,
-0.14511726796627045,
-0.6618397831916809,
-0.05613187700510025,
-0.12981051206588745,
-0.07381944358348846,
-0.24785585701465607,
-0.3323998749256134,
-0.4892336428165436,
-0.13200743496418,
-0.07435908913612366,
0.5676265358924866,
0.31215742230415344,
0.35934531688690186,
-0.9959508180618286,
0.4560372531414032,
0.4614431858062744,
0.32005614042282104,
-0.14060132205486298,
-0.7105386257171631,
-0.5207478404045105,
0.3215268850326538,
-0.33859267830848694,
-0.5339668989181519,
0.40979230403900146,
0.3845914602279663,
0.9046574234962463,
0.43137693405151367,
-0.3193380534648895,
0.17776072025299072,
-0.6476134061813354,
0.6257210373878479,
-0.05754554271697998,
-0.6255323886871338,
0.4704120457172394,
-0.48435884714126587,
0.1402033269405365,
0.6686902642250061,
0.42541617155075073,
-0.3406131863594055,
-0.41529175639152527,
-0.299390971660614,
-0.8648466467857361,
0.4382549226284027,
0.12960952520370483,
0.10224880278110504,
0.16430261731147766,
0.15446212887763977,
0.4795924425125122,
0.29189470410346985,
-0.22470761835575104,
-0.3919023871421814,
-0.09219726175069809,
-0.5371703505516052,
-0.1229073628783226,
-0.00359875475987792,
-0.11341629922389984,
-0.2339133769273758,
0.5481034517288208,
-0.20440222322940826,
0.03151024132966995,
-0.1963040828704834,
-0.23797310888767242,
-0.022377971559762955,
0.2628307342529297,
0.5716677904129028,
0.3256955146789551,
-0.026629559695720673,
-0.19217635691165924,
0.1753401756286621,
-0.7854889631271362,
0.23578421771526337,
0.0842442587018013,
-0.33873414993286133,
0.11127757281064987,
0.3028750419616699,
0.8561036586761475,
0.049075834453105927,
-0.25193363428115845,
0.3667314946651459,
-0.05115191265940666,
-0.10726932436227798,
0.5066930055618286,
0.5494060516357422,
-0.15285322070121765,
0.0654156282544136,
0.1721799224615097,
0.1378719061613083,
0.15137161314487457,
-0.0351753830909729,
0.15393052995204926,
0.37615135312080383,
-0.34077081084251404,
-0.23774875700473785,
0.47896361351013184,
0.5133216977119446,
-0.24049565196037292,
0.7983159422874451,
-0.45525243878364563,
-0.3914642035961151,
0.6168564558029175,
0.37920424342155457,
0.8451517224311829,
-0.4555743932723999,
0.22155171632766724,
0.4630466103553772,
0.18909484148025513,
-0.3313513994216919,
0.2823740541934967,
0.18743187189102173,
-0.6494062542915344,
-0.3600439131259918,
-0.4451306164264679,
-0.2858405113220215,
0.1386243849992752,
-0.9455426335334778,
0.24168123304843903,
-0.32178500294685364,
-0.12492123246192932,
-0.42208123207092285,
-0.22701793909072876,
-0.9512892365455627,
0.4101090729236603,
0.11271153390407562,
0.6932172179222107,
-0.7339505553245544,
0.9334693551063538,
0.5520706176757812,
-0.17799940705299377,
-0.36907732486724854,
0.19036956131458282,
-0.11158343404531479,
-0.9327496886253357,
0.6589779853820801,
-0.07263211905956268,
-0.0956592932343483,
0.4775373637676239,
-0.512408971786499,
-0.7468882203102112,
1.0327513217926025,
0.5208695530891418,
-0.7949149012565613,
0.034120842814445496,
0.0833519697189331,
0.31485816836357117,
-0.4583834409713745,
-0.048196036368608475,
0.5450968742370605,
0.19327645003795624,
0.14605996012687683,
-0.42602381110191345,
-0.3027249276638031,
-0.2246171087026596,
-0.051083214581012726,
0.24314352869987488,
-0.5108721852302551,
0.8589652180671692,
-0.24903783202171326,
-0.20933519303798676,
-0.07231814414262772,
0.5877772569656372,
0.06650778651237488,
-0.16649647057056427,
0.2903767228126526,
0.542443037033081,
0.987574577331543,
-0.0077743930742144585,
1.0487711429595947,
-0.3882558047771454,
0.5498569011688232,
1.3552563190460205,
0.1320253610610962,
0.6032362580299377,
0.2966494560241699,
-0.23974817991256714,
0.1495029181241989,
0.6485359072685242,
-0.3541049659252167,
0.734858512878418,
0.4779292941093445,
-0.1024407297372818,
-0.11425710469484329,
-0.12429415434598923,
-0.5996900200843811,
0.2654155492782593,
0.44326767325401306,
-0.522232174873352,
-0.16735628247261047,
-0.11256971955299377,
-0.15688060224056244,
-0.11455859243869781,
-0.3499227464199066,
0.4396876394748688,
-0.04758735001087189,
-0.5555683970451355,
0.5892766714096069,
0.13599944114685059,
0.6852492690086365,
-0.46916431188583374,
-0.06110411137342453,
-0.6690603494644165,
-0.01791124977171421,
-0.1238747164607048,
-0.7085862755775452,
-0.24109162390232086,
-0.06448337435722351,
-0.1358335018157959,
-0.24767808616161346,
0.24416790902614594,
-0.7238727807998657,
-0.4051622152328491,
0.04481659084558487,
0.5967142581939697,
-0.17276056110858917,
0.16872863471508026,
-0.5631939172744751,
0.006529565900564194,
0.36911332607269287,
-0.2832358181476593,
0.39506658911705017,
0.6462908983230591,
0.10060210525989532,
0.6771420240402222,
0.6476348042488098,
0.3191549777984619,
0.260825514793396,
0.31657645106315613,
0.7876526713371277,
-0.44112446904182434,
-0.49784016609191895,
-0.7600134015083313,
0.6640658378601074,
-0.060431718826293945,
-0.6114526987075806,
0.6665092706680298,
0.46018245816230774,
0.8860865831375122,
-0.3466135859489441,
0.9074758887290955,
0.38383913040161133,
0.3660678565502167,
-0.7329838871955872,
0.5855007171630859,
-0.26677507162094116,
0.28570443391799927,
-0.15489701926708221,
-1.0604830980300903,
-0.28454500436782837,
0.517295241355896,
-0.3338008224964142,
0.11056527495384216,
0.5553500652313232,
0.7283309102058411,
-0.32077914476394653,
-0.09778393059968948,
0.13348835706710815,
0.02159152925014496,
0.4653751850128174,
0.4000140130519867,
0.79599529504776,
-0.20133104920387268,
0.408965140581131,
0.051320064812898636,
-0.16377121210098267,
-0.3539524972438812,
-0.6176926493644714,
-1.016198754310608,
-0.4130518436431885,
-0.29703566431999207,
-0.06192273274064064,
-0.2221985012292862,
1.0867273807525635,
0.6741131544113159,
-0.9815961122512817,
0.03973470255732536,
-0.14018568396568298,
0.24583883583545685,
-0.19508816301822662,
-0.10551135241985321,
0.4424827992916107,
-0.5016626119613647,
-1.064349889755249,
0.6064990758895874,
0.07769545912742615,
0.383295476436615,
-0.18082818388938904,
-0.2324056774377823,
0.023324953392148018,
-0.3981897830963135,
0.37933996319770813,
-0.03570026531815529,
-0.4590255916118622,
0.03848749026656151,
-0.030185000970959663,
-0.5000203251838684,
0.1274537593126297,
0.7174038887023926,
-0.26746034622192383,
0.4101634919643402,
0.5149874687194824,
1.3629391193389893,
0.220828577876091,
0.06930506974458694,
0.5771215558052063,
-0.8215684294700623,
0.006708149332553148,
0.3228515684604645,
0.3191263675689697,
0.3544909656047821,
-0.35574954748153687,
0.5527605414390564,
0.1273307353258133,
-0.509682297706604,
-0.4594985544681549,
0.1033920869231224,
-0.5811215043067932,
0.030108558014035225,
1.5081753730773926,
-0.28662651777267456,
0.12391991913318634,
0.22576072812080383,
-0.4425991177558899,
0.22535379230976105,
-0.42373141646385193,
0.8016261458396912,
0.6638431549072266,
0.27930235862731934,
0.06848382204771042,
-0.8311529159545898,
0.40860211849212646,
0.33919355273246765,
-0.6884909272193909,
-0.06182423606514931,
0.4666680097579956,
0.13072769343852997,
-0.34595176577568054,
0.0019481085473671556,
0.20932337641716003,
-0.07056106626987457,
-0.2846466600894928,
0.016444841399788857,
-0.17250238358974457,
-0.3782823979854584,
-0.37093350291252136,
0.17027948796749115,
-0.052443552762269974,
-0.5149979591369629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12910v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12910v1
|
Topic Modelling Case Law Using a Large Language Model and a New Taxonomy for UK Law: AI Insights into Summary Judgment
| 2024-05-21T16:30:25 | 2024-05-21T16:30:25 |
Holli Sargeant, Ahmed Izzidien, Felix Steffek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
This paper addresses a critical gap in legal analytics by developing and
applying a novel taxonomy for topic modelling summary judgment cases in the
United Kingdom. Using a curated dataset of summary judgment cases, we use the
Large Language Model Claude 3 Opus to explore functional topics and trends. We
find that Claude 3 Opus correctly classified the topic with an accuracy of
87.10%. The analysis reveals distinct patterns in the application of summary
judgments across various legal domains. As case law in the United Kingdom is
not originally labelled with keywords or a topic filtering option, the findings
not only refine our understanding of the thematic underpinnings of summary
judgments but also illustrate the potential of combining traditional and
AI-driven approaches in legal classification. Therefore, this paper provides a
new and general taxonomy for UK law. The implications of this work serve as a
foundation for further research and policy discussions in the field of judicial
administration and computational legal research methodologies.
|
[
-0.3618248701095581,
-0.5528373718261719,
0.8361628651618958,
-0.08645071089267731,
-0.5878182053565979,
-0.203853040933609,
0.03428028151392937,
-0.4215218424797058,
0.43320298194885254,
0.8831824660301208,
0.07016827166080475,
-0.43474501371383667,
-0.5805059671401978,
-0.22910094261169434,
-0.8195317387580872,
0.8934710025787354,
0.24290598928928375,
0.4204540550708771,
-0.46708282828330994,
-0.526337742805481,
-0.4779038429260254,
-0.8424602746963501,
-0.4906763434410095,
-0.15746749937534332,
0.6010524034500122,
0.23210684955120087,
0.5883322954177856,
0.2824609577655792,
0.773177444934845,
0.29668423533439636,
-0.38180771470069885,
-0.31332507729530334,
-0.21189098060131073,
-0.22812186181545258,
-0.32738906145095825,
-0.7665941715240479,
-0.9081331491470337,
0.06991374492645264,
0.2816728949546814,
0.6449469923973083,
-0.4289994239807129,
-0.33098673820495605,
-0.06811726093292236,
0.8918662667274475,
-0.6687608957290649,
0.19998125731945038,
-0.3534027934074402,
0.1577514410018921,
-0.13272404670715332,
-0.03740808367729187,
-0.391237735748291,
-0.0857933759689331,
0.3279424011707306,
-0.29841136932373047,
0.3425436019897461,
0.012396953999996185,
0.5052503347396851,
0.09890245646238327,
-0.7403345108032227,
-0.36580902338027954,
-0.41225963830947876,
0.622351348400116,
-0.6379529237747192,
0.3046223521232605,
0.2962188422679901,
0.3376404047012329,
0.2780044376850128,
-0.942232608795166,
-0.4525933861732483,
-0.45055368542671204,
-0.4118053913116455,
0.28792309761047363,
-0.455824613571167,
0.16021032631397247,
-0.09021875262260437,
0.10349336266517639,
-0.5718867182731628,
0.3236006200313568,
-0.6258022785186768,
-0.3504061698913574,
0.8427520990371704,
0.19726096093654633,
0.09163063019514084,
-0.35571184754371643,
0.28394779562950134,
0.23850923776626587,
-0.7903190851211548,
-0.11776480823755264,
0.4359464645385742,
0.3320222496986389,
-0.2513761818408966,
0.364877849817276,
-0.09984734654426575,
0.7711533308029175,
-0.3808015286922455,
-0.1825593113899231,
0.1455564945936203,
-0.04658288508653641,
0.130650132894516,
0.1800137311220169,
0.7906925678253174,
0.7451102137565613,
0.11777922511100769,
0.14083440601825714,
-0.16677983105182648,
-0.11052209138870239,
0.506192147731781,
-0.5732308626174927,
-0.1007198691368103,
0.39348214864730835,
-0.7288994193077087,
-0.21070970594882965,
0.3643794059753418,
-0.4291761815547943,
-0.6435137987136841,
-0.40388885140419006,
-0.09789261221885681,
-0.045684587210416794,
-0.12902244925498962,
0.3538327217102051,
-0.16087034344673157,
0.45757001638412476,
0.643608808517456,
-0.696580171585083,
0.2670154869556427,
0.9760468006134033,
0.4910922944545746,
-0.007243356667459011,
-0.15830877423286438,
-0.3811006546020508,
0.07389011234045029,
-0.35515013337135315,
0.7550666332244873,
-0.5329177379608154,
-0.44556763768196106,
0.2642594873905182,
0.15247955918312073,
0.6137645244598389,
-0.4368516802787781,
0.6626603007316589,
-0.7634520530700684,
0.4500807523727417,
-0.022029118612408638,
-0.4313502609729767,
-0.4121778607368469,
0.2441348284482956,
-0.7361102104187012,
0.21001897752285004,
-0.07713138312101364,
-0.7935872673988342,
0.92502361536026,
-0.9717078804969788,
-0.738105833530426,
0.18649666011333466,
-0.512025773525238,
-0.3978540301322937,
0.16183502972126007,
-0.09551995247602463,
0.5852510929107666,
-0.5759648084640503,
0.7417860627174377,
-0.3240292966365814,
-0.11057627201080322,
0.0006817667162977159,
-0.19040778279304504,
0.7266930937767029,
0.4666442573070526,
0.13405051827430725,
0.2305316925048828,
-0.35188180208206177,
-0.5754792094230652,
-0.25826454162597656,
-0.019730279222130775,
-0.3408608138561249,
0.5712093710899353,
-0.010143164545297623,
0.1074400320649147,
0.32234281301498413,
-0.2895689010620117,
0.15529581904411316,
-0.16440829634666443,
0.7520579099655151,
0.25997546315193176,
0.17320843040943146,
0.3179822266101837,
-0.27899831533432007,
0.4989182651042938,
-0.04587315022945404,
-0.05980663001537323,
-0.03601786866784096,
-0.7505313158035278,
-0.5028245449066162,
-0.0802503228187561,
0.7701834440231323,
0.7600274682044983,
-0.4293875992298126,
0.4210357964038849,
-0.3161628842353821,
-0.26127201318740845,
-0.2752550542354584,
-0.34069356322288513,
0.005593546666204929,
0.004597675055265427,
0.2047983556985855,
-0.5218047499656677,
-0.4739052951335907,
-1.3259261846542358,
-0.31901949644088745,
-0.6194462180137634,
-0.09814541041851044,
0.5179868936538696,
0.6633129119873047,
-0.27601778507232666,
0.9760516285896301,
-0.3693150579929352,
-0.2838209867477417,
-0.4867004156112671,
0.6016035079956055,
0.45741620659828186,
0.27418577671051025,
0.704475998878479,
-1.2552895545959473,
-0.12974469363689423,
0.29658547043800354,
-0.797343373298645,
-0.010872717946767807,
-0.20585845410823822,
0.14179112017154694,
0.08198774605989456,
0.49886786937713623,
-0.2730470895767212,
0.5108585357666016,
-0.5153622031211853,
-0.5973439812660217,
0.3594605326652527,
-0.18506649136543274,
0.37990236282348633,
-1.0589221715927124,
-0.0980895534157753,
0.11416207998991013,
-0.4732121527194977,
-0.5239952802658081,
0.3309118449687958,
0.2450999915599823,
0.13761132955551147,
-0.8489482998847961,
0.3627704083919525,
-0.22223122417926788,
-0.17830440402030945,
-0.5079994201660156,
0.1039363220334053,
-0.06091826409101486,
0.09861038625240326,
-0.1252131164073944,
0.4832811653614044,
0.5815154910087585,
-0.506898045539856,
0.5186001062393188,
0.19846725463867188,
-0.12043466418981552,
0.7334506511688232,
-0.2981398105621338,
-0.3300919532775879,
-0.10981637984514236,
0.07285833358764648,
-0.4982205033302307,
-0.596053421497345,
-0.15149514377117157,
-0.3560033440589905,
0.5090970993041992,
-0.47825920581817627,
-0.5202269554138184,
-0.5672767758369446,
-0.2597660720348358,
0.18991398811340332,
0.6250689625740051,
0.04755889251828194,
0.8384227752685547,
0.682039737701416,
-0.4132535755634308,
-0.4442618191242218,
-0.7137928009033203,
0.31419724225997925,
-0.7951065301895142,
-0.23017948865890503,
0.45906931161880493,
0.29390522837638855,
-0.7540398240089417,
0.17474769055843353,
0.09472795575857162,
-0.4374210834503174,
0.20427945256233215,
-0.009300311096012592,
-0.04284852370619774,
-0.03116576559841633,
-0.06931528449058533,
-0.20831958949565887,
0.101439468562603,
0.4263733923435211,
0.005914442706853151,
0.42354679107666016,
0.05695408582687378,
-0.33680328726768494,
-0.5350157618522644,
0.5317070484161377,
0.8220878839492798,
0.036898043006658554,
0.07562006264925003,
-0.28878188133239746,
-0.22602519392967224,
0.09308438748121262,
-0.3723539710044861,
0.059005867689847946,
-0.4016932547092438,
0.3914221227169037,
-0.34178465604782104,
-0.8951472043991089,
0.49515828490257263,
0.31184542179107666,
0.19978679716587067,
0.857975423336029,
0.7330994606018066,
-0.22284266352653503,
0.49084973335266113,
0.8492988348007202,
-0.5730684995651245,
0.40596452355384827,
-0.3136574923992157,
0.2861669361591339,
-0.3945882022380829,
0.016046790406107903,
-0.49524158239364624,
0.04551135003566742,
-0.6905701160430908,
-0.2179851531982422,
0.30902594327926636,
0.14167486131191254,
-0.018424568697810173,
0.18985921144485474,
-0.028560897335410118,
0.6686875820159912,
0.59434574842453,
0.031147032976150513,
0.1302824765443802,
-0.121037058532238,
-0.07121973484754562,
0.35918691754341125,
-0.42491966485977173,
-0.5763655304908752,
1.2070759534835815,
0.0819915309548378,
0.33466285467147827,
0.32703959941864014,
0.6436431407928467,
1.116992473602295,
0.29828041791915894,
-0.930616021156311,
0.6418235301971436,
-0.3835844397544861,
-0.5542786717414856,
0.019061509519815445,
-0.3934718072414398,
-1.0002810955047607,
0.30742573738098145,
-0.015108617022633553,
-0.8569995164871216,
0.10558589547872543,
-0.12021055072546005,
-0.5124693512916565,
0.33933767676353455,
-0.32821837067604065,
0.563476026058197,
-0.1981888711452484,
-0.7448623776435852,
-0.5250357389450073,
-0.5672925114631653,
0.34771260619163513,
-0.2825266420841217,
0.33412057161331177,
0.07814718037843704,
0.21534056961536407,
0.8846893310546875,
-0.6456272006034851,
0.6545566320419312,
-0.1776888370513916,
-0.36982211470603943,
0.6244394779205322,
-0.07035285979509354,
0.22180010378360748,
0.11972266435623169,
0.03683922812342644,
-0.036476172506809235,
0.06586934626102448,
-0.5238953828811646,
-0.8048169612884521,
0.3076450824737549,
-0.5123245716094971,
-0.7776281237602234,
-0.649549663066864,
-0.43554988503456116,
-0.15916979312896729,
0.10441140085458755,
0.012030444107949734,
0.5692219734191895,
-0.19106747210025787,
0.29077744483947754,
0.08831082284450531,
-0.09178636968135834,
0.5786087512969971,
1.0852144956588745,
-0.22599947452545166,
-0.49419018626213074,
0.9835272431373596,
0.20052030682563782,
-0.4046434760093689,
0.5931417346000671,
0.09537764638662338,
-0.3588573634624481,
-0.9316325783729553,
-0.06510353833436966,
0.16142010688781738,
-0.6869555711746216,
-0.14767241477966309,
-0.5426982045173645,
0.01678570732474327,
-0.40057069063186646,
-0.2584737539291382,
-0.015514838509261608,
-0.6469503045082092,
-0.09485239535570145,
-0.06042192131280899,
0.4641776978969574,
1.029504656791687,
-0.10190087556838989,
0.3546111583709717,
-0.4868351221084595,
0.43108513951301575,
0.3299003541469574,
0.332343190908432,
-0.5403282046318054,
-0.7054820656776428,
-0.08265620470046997,
-0.21490448713302612,
-0.42185238003730774,
-0.6190169453620911,
0.454261839389801,
-0.09205298870801926,
0.5628122687339783,
0.7119122743606567,
0.004615859128534794,
0.3453596234321594,
-0.6705577969551086,
1.0527340173721313,
0.26670873165130615,
-0.6201059818267822,
0.6414210796356201,
-0.5808455348014832,
-0.18085390329360962,
0.5384897589683533,
0.4403455853462219,
-0.3940328061580658,
-0.3328366279602051,
-0.7070565223693848,
-1.1062984466552734,
0.7500259876251221,
0.16087593138217926,
0.26694369316101074,
0.3347931206226349,
0.42062079906463623,
0.12154942750930786,
0.4046115577220917,
-0.5032163858413696,
-0.055645473301410675,
0.24157491326332092,
0.10746589303016663,
-0.17858977615833282,
-0.3091530203819275,
-0.04637611657381058,
-0.6196469068527222,
0.6806647777557373,
-0.04149963706731796,
0.3729841411113739,
-0.08354324847459793,
-0.18426263332366943,
0.5568354725837708,
0.29908934235572815,
0.5618264675140381,
0.8616166710853577,
-0.27776217460632324,
-0.21570272743701935,
0.040833450853824615,
-0.4483885169029236,
0.23587633669376373,
0.22458599507808685,
-0.20567883551120758,
-0.2629247009754181,
0.7708022594451904,
0.47324883937835693,
-0.14322243630886078,
-0.4932039678096771,
0.6383450031280518,
-0.27090802788734436,
-0.7617536783218384,
-0.41532987356185913,
-0.06161171570420265,
-0.21349114179611206,
0.19105903804302216,
0.2964811325073242,
-0.09729667752981186,
0.7620961666107178,
-0.7742924094200134,
0.6268333792686462,
0.0854131281375885,
-0.3355322480201721,
0.035395942628383636,
0.6488456130027771,
0.3321579396724701,
-0.16286590695381165,
0.2499728798866272,
-0.30868247151374817,
-0.49606120586395264,
0.6994121670722961,
-0.05280144885182381,
0.9311079978942871,
0.3086186349391937,
0.15801018476486206,
-0.17491331696510315,
0.02630385383963585,
-0.11994615197181702,
0.6486304402351379,
-0.27076059579849243,
-0.5637091994285583,
-0.41408300399780273,
-0.4964079260826111,
-0.7476323246955872,
0.08223211020231247,
-0.8481082916259766,
0.20630453526973724,
-0.1096409261226654,
0.011382808908820152,
0.12085359543561935,
-0.10686099529266357,
-0.3106077313423157,
0.1407013237476349,
0.16367901861667633,
0.7651513814926147,
-0.5978145003318787,
0.8339040279388428,
0.7020328044891357,
-0.24979715049266815,
-0.1842910796403885,
0.4029035270214081,
0.2714485824108124,
-0.1738346517086029,
0.3933596909046173,
0.16105243563652039,
-0.13379493355751038,
-0.39224687218666077,
-0.4942817687988281,
-0.5188620686531067,
0.8246488571166992,
0.11368940770626068,
-0.44874876737594604,
0.18288911879062653,
0.16742388904094696,
0.6458256840705872,
-0.3114541471004486,
0.28840842843055725,
0.9069642424583435,
0.20718134939670563,
0.17211449146270752,
-0.7793062329292297,
-0.5372293591499329,
-0.5683044195175171,
-0.4368493854999542,
0.420674204826355,
-0.6093560457229614,
0.5667093992233276,
0.026823870837688446,
0.11338755488395691,
-0.018925825133919716,
0.5988256335258484,
0.015948455780744553,
0.3681078851222992,
0.2594853341579437,
0.7181196808815002,
0.8092016577720642,
-0.36223137378692627,
1.415907382965088,
-0.62257319688797,
0.40067973732948303,
1.0044816732406616,
-0.7484053373336792,
0.7288825511932373,
0.22861197590827942,
-0.5175094604492188,
0.4337218999862671,
0.726969838142395,
-0.016170697286725044,
0.6336738467216492,
0.44378432631492615,
-0.1247367188334465,
-0.047345105558633804,
-0.104857437312603,
-0.17187561094760895,
0.7889885306358337,
0.5377403497695923,
-0.42365697026252747,
-0.11272862553596497,
0.03932841494679451,
-0.048155102878808975,
-0.09503219276666641,
-0.6676555275917053,
1.0688501596450806,
-0.16290612518787384,
-0.7000954151153564,
0.17853789031505585,
0.28556132316589355,
0.424296498298645,
-0.5431784391403198,
-0.08592481911182404,
-0.5163553357124329,
-0.02381839230656624,
-0.08797364681959152,
-0.8807414174079895,
0.31160566210746765,
0.15825141966342926,
-0.1589079201221466,
-0.4430140554904938,
0.3188522458076477,
0.1916530281305313,
-0.6675272583961487,
0.31381967663764954,
0.5484371185302734,
0.47498100996017456,
0.10833598673343658,
-0.6286925673484802,
-0.33137452602386475,
-0.026370586827397346,
-0.10977870970964432,
0.08377721160650253,
0.6229784488677979,
-0.37600409984588623,
0.4744414985179901,
0.07022665441036224,
0.10965623706579208,
-0.35088974237442017,
0.32161155343055725,
0.9367331266403198,
-1.0961583852767944,
-0.9586561918258667,
-0.8036227822303772,
0.5237851738929749,
-0.3529636263847351,
-0.2882002592086792,
0.42497819662094116,
0.7898354530334473,
0.5753503441810608,
0.3476063013076782,
0.9160494208335876,
-0.29244616627693176,
0.5993943214416504,
-0.8255422115325928,
0.8040871620178223,
-0.6496143937110901,
0.36690351366996765,
-0.25922197103500366,
-0.7498181462287903,
-0.5155259966850281,
0.4620819687843323,
-0.48286041617393494,
0.08303400129079819,
0.6085072755813599,
0.5289889574050903,
-0.3384016454219818,
0.25848111510276794,
0.5834030508995056,
0.3982495665550232,
0.0932302474975586,
0.20458601415157318,
0.8505239486694336,
0.05949117988348007,
-0.03235858306288719,
-0.02218589372932911,
-0.03907986730337143,
-0.3021043837070465,
-0.5496505498886108,
-0.7056864500045776,
-0.3611880838871002,
-0.19328849017620087,
-0.10864228010177612,
-0.08763351291418076,
0.516431987285614,
0.7597690224647522,
-1.1543186902999878,
-0.5654125213623047,
-0.445294052362442,
-0.007982609793543816,
0.2426614612340927,
-0.21126727759838104,
0.4760916531085968,
-0.20781168341636658,
-0.355478435754776,
0.40480393171310425,
0.13408727943897247,
-0.1445062756538391,
-0.26116499304771423,
0.08259464800357819,
-0.19800755381584167,
-0.015019034035503864,
0.8733546137809753,
0.04275142028927803,
-1.0439621210098267,
-0.017173312604427338,
-0.8170009851455688,
0.18402287364006042,
0.178896963596344,
1.319841980934143,
-0.5685932636260986,
0.32067111134529114,
0.3375905454158783,
0.49290037155151367,
0.49228838086128235,
0.08228662610054016,
0.8543853759765625,
-0.6410651206970215,
0.26028013229370117,
0.39285415410995483,
1.2131917476654053,
0.043693315237760544,
-0.2206186205148697,
0.6823532581329346,
0.26197919249534607,
-0.32889851927757263,
-0.6455430388450623,
0.33705517649650574,
-0.7565586566925049,
-0.7395457029342651,
0.8217873573303223,
-0.06467446684837341,
-0.2506776452064514,
-0.3391290307044983,
-0.20617343485355377,
-0.2513749599456787,
-0.5519698262214661,
0.7379514575004578,
0.792995274066925,
-0.22509318590164185,
-0.13619373738765717,
-1.0001527070999146,
0.19791264832019806,
0.26050350069999695,
-0.8148656487464905,
-0.14616014063358307,
0.938461422920227,
-0.04294582083821297,
0.36848387122154236,
0.42515647411346436,
-0.14555911719799042,
0.29811543226242065,
-0.25569167733192444,
0.1542120724916458,
0.5149862766265869,
-0.5501805543899536,
-0.6335005164146423,
0.5475803017616272,
-0.18915018439292908,
0.2728789448738098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12900v1
|
Adversarial DPO: Harnessing Harmful Data for Reducing Toxicity with Minimal Impact on Coherence and Evasiveness in Dialogue Agents
| 2024-05-21T16:14:55 | 2024-05-21T16:14:55 |
San Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Recent advancements in open-domain dialogue systems have been propelled by
the emergence of high-quality large language models (LLMs) and various
effective training methodologies. Nevertheless, the presence of toxicity within
these models presents a significant challenge that can potentially diminish the
user experience. In this study, we introduce an innovative training algorithm,
an improvement upon direct preference optimization (DPO), called adversarial
DPO (ADPO). The ADPO algorithm is designed to train models to assign higher
probability distributions to preferred responses and lower distributions to
unsafe responses, which are self-generated using the toxic control token. We
demonstrate that ADPO enhances the model's resilience against harmful
conversations while minimizing performance degradation. Furthermore, we
illustrate that ADPO offers a more stable training procedure compared to the
traditional DPO. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first adaptation of
the DPO algorithm that directly incorporates harmful data into the generative
model, thereby reducing the need to artificially create safe dialogue data.
|
[
-0.24397052824497223,
-0.7634669542312622,
0.42452681064605713,
-0.05156206712126732,
-0.18902985751628876,
0.051012687385082245,
0.09754619002342224,
-0.34446048736572266,
-0.17024733126163483,
0.7570339441299438,
-0.5217463374137878,
-0.35251563787460327,
-0.5513976812362671,
-0.07175717502832413,
-0.0399332195520401,
1.1571574211120605,
0.4056883156299591,
0.12664707005023956,
-0.14708779752254486,
0.01378968358039856,
-0.167924702167511,
-0.8240661025047302,
-1.269805908203125,
-0.40837356448173523,
0.4858913719654083,
0.25034502148628235,
1.0914818048477173,
0.4311109781265259,
0.30123165249824524,
0.3410200774669647,
-0.34037262201309204,
0.21314193308353424,
-0.9577553272247314,
0.2634192407131195,
-0.18967409431934357,
-0.5333675742149353,
-0.5950997471809387,
0.05912814289331436,
0.0012013355735689402,
0.35799822211265564,
-0.25049903988838196,
-0.35235318541526794,
0.05745851993560791,
0.6905691623687744,
-0.6726158261299133,
0.11098025739192963,
-0.9068925976753235,
0.210628941655159,
0.41580501198768616,
-0.566001296043396,
-0.7798877954483032,
-0.2425556629896164,
0.40708762407302856,
-0.8019527792930603,
-0.18921200931072235,
-0.20376165211200714,
0.5024425387382507,
0.3757357597351074,
-0.42185452580451965,
-0.44346463680267334,
-0.8006272912025452,
0.6888606548309326,
-0.48104989528656006,
-0.04084932804107666,
0.25962576270103455,
0.05289003625512123,
-0.5420781970024109,
-0.27576813101768494,
-0.4789782762527466,
-0.34530535340309143,
0.189132422208786,
0.2779611349105835,
-0.33605438470840454,
0.48562946915626526,
-0.03413882479071617,
0.13221530616283417,
-0.23952201008796692,
0.2549363076686859,
0.10705775767564774,
-0.2693158686161041,
0.768763542175293,
0.41303685307502747,
0.3431548774242401,
-0.03208081051707268,
-0.568437933921814,
-0.19408512115478516,
-0.7378932237625122,
-0.14699970185756683,
0.6296564340591431,
0.2572872042655945,
0.21826322376728058,
0.08035553991794586,
-0.12985116243362427,
0.4062710702419281,
0.13385172188282013,
-0.12637318670749664,
0.017358066514134407,
-0.014087370596826077,
-0.09464000910520554,
0.10973988473415375,
1.0834537744522095,
0.4304268956184387,
0.17390121519565582,
0.006194089073687792,
0.17693354189395905,
0.1034860908985138,
0.5347813963890076,
-0.8768389821052551,
-0.4112924039363861,
0.19231267273426056,
-0.2657630145549774,
-1.0674937963485718,
-0.5312554240226746,
-0.7925302982330322,
-0.7946996092796326,
-0.023030126467347145,
0.33613401651382446,
-0.5088075995445251,
-0.21698753535747528,
0.22996412217617035,
0.03496478497982025,
-0.3805464208126068,
0.41827234625816345,
-0.9319904446601868,
0.3571062982082367,
0.5510911345481873,
0.6088138222694397,
-0.11723366379737854,
-0.06118716299533844,
-0.5803730487823486,
0.10598879307508469,
-0.4748953878879547,
0.4501444697380066,
-0.4822508990764618,
-0.6103599667549133,
-0.16728654503822327,
-0.2997688353061676,
0.019991319626569748,
-0.6729286313056946,
0.7551620602607727,
-0.6898845434188843,
0.29046544432640076,
-0.037844739854335785,
-0.17111355066299438,
-0.11503967642784119,
0.3000865578651428,
-0.4036206007003784,
0.4816698729991913,
-0.12164102494716644,
-0.8827857971191406,
0.17478498816490173,
-0.5710128545761108,
-0.27398771047592163,
-0.24143864214420319,
0.002523637842386961,
-0.5897027254104614,
-0.1749257743358612,
0.14720766246318817,
0.17075690627098083,
-0.06662102043628693,
0.2591691315174103,
-0.7377787828445435,
-0.3539637327194214,
0.322122186422348,
-0.802602231502533,
1.013370394706726,
0.42980989813804626,
-0.1665511429309845,
0.25821611285209656,
-0.7217565774917603,
-0.11611910909414291,
0.3492124676704407,
-0.36086422204971313,
-0.6593437194824219,
0.1190902441740036,
-0.5290200710296631,
0.3588068187236786,
-0.15655694901943207,
-0.5682486295700073,
-0.02020392380654812,
-0.6448278427124023,
0.35252052545547485,
1.2165154218673706,
0.1953841596841812,
0.42343705892562866,
-0.3432326018810272,
0.4085814654827118,
0.23564819991588593,
0.5397382974624634,
0.2073889523744583,
-0.277218759059906,
-0.7978286743164062,
-0.21022261679172516,
-0.20060379803180695,
0.6180873513221741,
-1.1007505655288696,
0.5918673276901245,
-0.176531583070755,
-0.4742911159992218,
-0.25423142313957214,
-0.00768550019711256,
0.5409271121025085,
0.8174504637718201,
0.12171951681375504,
-0.4059411585330963,
-0.40294894576072693,
-0.7805670499801636,
0.011393317021429539,
-0.5693966150283813,
0.06739149987697601,
0.6045295000076294,
0.19245605170726776,
-0.24812985956668854,
0.5992123484611511,
-0.7438381314277649,
-0.08883219212293625,
-0.08139370381832123,
-0.21695050597190857,
-0.1312258541584015,
0.27339571714401245,
0.6271084547042847,
-0.6145651936531067,
-0.5740798711776733,
-0.32500699162483215,
-0.5332186818122864,
-0.06472509354352951,
-0.07384617626667023,
-0.4486508369445801,
0.014585021883249283,
0.15938891470432281,
-0.4336264729499817,
0.22505848109722137,
0.5644633769989014,
-0.19051781296730042,
0.4605565667152405,
-0.12023540586233139,
0.1214466467499733,
-0.9500502347946167,
-0.07806118577718735,
-0.29178184270858765,
-0.12649129331111908,
-0.9422711730003357,
-0.24468491971492767,
-0.3523491621017456,
-0.5269238352775574,
-0.7402029633522034,
0.31737491488456726,
-0.00815193634480238,
0.53987717628479,
-0.37999263405799866,
0.0731780156493187,
0.17071624100208282,
0.624316394329071,
0.17966221272945404,
0.81180739402771,
0.5536588430404663,
-0.7931735515594482,
0.5281003713607788,
0.7297742366790771,
0.10167853534221649,
0.47552549839019775,
-0.45212486386299133,
0.4127506613731384,
-0.16066384315490723,
0.36292460560798645,
-0.6781441569328308,
0.002211417770013213,
0.6183874011039734,
-0.3305366635322571,
0.2771865725517273,
-0.19796477258205414,
-0.16625036299228668,
-0.2290608137845993,
-0.5685005187988281,
0.25460702180862427,
0.44025668501853943,
-0.6790650486946106,
-0.032418832182884216,
0.6075751185417175,
-0.282814085483551,
-0.6678715348243713,
-0.419209361076355,
0.21247904002666473,
-0.5174934267997742,
-0.5643240809440613,
0.0889054387807846,
-0.2697882354259491,
-0.09539707005023956,
-0.28895238041877747,
-0.03235318884253502,
0.048502448946237564,
0.37562447786331177,
0.12662027776241302,
0.23997712135314941,
0.350374311208725,
0.15772005915641785,
-0.03419799357652664,
-0.27721869945526123,
0.23816093802452087,
0.11661393940448761,
0.5251157283782959,
0.11005877703428268,
-0.1674596667289734,
-0.5712149143218994,
0.3640095293521881,
0.6663991212844849,
0.11620438098907471,
0.7712602019309998,
-0.009322895668447018,
0.057818032801151276,
-0.38754206895828247,
0.07955607771873474,
-0.18025515973567963,
-0.5663171410560608,
0.4299359619617462,
-0.2945721447467804,
-0.4840758740901947,
0.3318882882595062,
-0.1348007619380951,
-0.24038155376911163,
0.11556044220924377,
0.4728125035762787,
0.3139326274394989,
1.3811681270599365,
0.2895600497722626,
-0.29334360361099243,
0.8479297757148743,
-0.19218270480632782,
0.12820546329021454,
-0.6823236346244812,
-0.10561421513557434,
-0.1372838318347931,
0.11537378281354904,
-0.41268616914749146,
-0.21864134073257446,
0.6689093112945557,
-0.2846451997756958,
-0.5965769290924072,
0.02815239317715168,
-0.6421813368797302,
0.2253548949956894,
0.5103273391723633,
0.5206540822982788,
0.33073654770851135,
0.1665525734424591,
-0.021912992000579834,
0.03374101594090462,
-0.8873207569122314,
-0.5657020807266235,
1.1239120960235596,
0.6135813593864441,
1.1959058046340942,
0.0762883797287941,
0.6330302953720093,
0.11871808022260666,
0.16227324306964874,
-0.8800634741783142,
0.6813086867332458,
-0.21065226197242737,
-0.6098245978355408,
-0.17941264808177948,
-0.7534629106521606,
-0.8826926350593567,
0.39692479372024536,
-0.16636618971824646,
-0.5849707126617432,
0.2749965786933899,
0.2077384889125824,
-0.4690774083137512,
0.27274900674819946,
-0.7014204263687134,
0.6196556687355042,
-0.3428395092487335,
-0.4807765781879425,
-0.2403714954853058,
-0.4387153089046478,
0.31271594762802124,
0.08968272060155869,
-0.04028414562344551,
-0.14465774595737457,
-0.0015606065280735493,
0.4468117356300354,
-0.4780285060405731,
0.9288122653961182,
-0.25252994894981384,
-0.30827757716178894,
0.4385155439376831,
0.21917416155338287,
0.7161831259727478,
0.10376166552305222,
-0.39752501249313354,
0.0003238340141251683,
-0.3289721608161926,
-0.21749868988990784,
-0.5013187527656555,
0.7252592444419861,
-1.0553430318832397,
-0.7867564558982849,
-0.4833013117313385,
-0.4493069648742676,
-0.47445395588874817,
0.09814988821744919,
0.19413164258003235,
0.2660914957523346,
-0.4866463541984558,
0.06923699378967285,
0.7992000579833984,
-0.6578933000564575,
0.08159903436899185,
0.6662436723709106,
0.2871589958667755,
-0.6838825345039368,
0.968541145324707,
-0.17951400578022003,
0.8421728610992432,
0.11181216686964035,
0.4192485809326172,
-0.26557716727256775,
-0.7271296977996826,
-0.3511742949485779,
-0.1698707491159439,
-0.7306899428367615,
-0.2900810241699219,
-0.6003950238227844,
-0.2750817537307739,
-0.3180299401283264,
0.03604983538389206,
-0.47657954692840576,
-0.2154395431280136,
-0.41987383365631104,
-0.10395494848489761,
0.1968727856874466,
0.4331988990306854,
-0.024249009788036346,
0.1787981390953064,
-0.6252375245094299,
0.15919964015483856,
0.5865590572357178,
0.45122668147087097,
-0.08089173585176468,
-0.43333175778388977,
0.038106951862573624,
0.503761351108551,
-0.7771779894828796,
-0.8701310753822327,
0.4288805425167084,
0.263343870639801,
0.5811936855316162,
0.5288452506065369,
0.6453145742416382,
0.3993928134441376,
-0.33424505591392517,
0.5673825740814209,
0.2891465425491333,
-0.6562267541885376,
0.8101251125335693,
-0.6605108976364136,
-0.07787612080574036,
0.636269211769104,
0.4153488278388977,
-0.4687112271785736,
-0.4739670157432556,
-0.5906379222869873,
-0.6971069574356079,
0.9986425638198853,
0.3117024302482605,
0.45808902382850647,
-0.20299412310123444,
0.1697722226381302,
0.14939351379871368,
0.20802302658557892,
-0.49145105481147766,
-0.26769083738327026,
-0.2720450162887573,
-0.1914377212524414,
-0.03455260768532753,
-0.46167612075805664,
-0.7385240793228149,
0.1529102474451065,
0.9347599148750305,
-0.14463089406490326,
0.14789511263370514,
0.2820450961589813,
0.11583961546421051,
-0.24718695878982544,
0.38013121485710144,
0.3275950253009796,
0.07747229933738708,
-0.21823981404304504,
0.029813850298523903,
0.07643938809633255,
-0.5119563341140747,
0.4420796036720276,
0.04355921968817711,
-0.36017799377441406,
-0.4674597978591919,
0.011750912293791771,
0.9621321558952332,
-0.11947382986545563,
-0.6854304075241089,
0.6104186773300171,
-0.2963479161262512,
-0.11243130266666412,
-0.046689532697200775,
0.40847310423851013,
-0.39926475286483765,
-0.003487611887976527,
0.05954510718584061,
0.2558593153953552,
0.47009018063545227,
-0.7053604125976562,
0.21567471325397491,
0.51723712682724,
-0.4142146408557892,
-0.14969713985919952,
0.644206702709198,
0.783128023147583,
-0.03888176381587982,
0.305637389421463,
-0.16710925102233887,
-0.6482614874839783,
0.35098856687545776,
0.4921122193336487,
0.9338741302490234,
-0.28999730944633484,
0.4997197985649109,
0.14661741256713867,
-0.01928558200597763,
0.16861389577388763,
-0.07022273540496826,
0.13387493789196014,
-0.9467806220054626,
0.029904179275035858,
-0.38128581643104553,
-0.6484838128089905,
0.3655620515346527,
-0.5574496388435364,
0.009590794332325459,
-0.6314765810966492,
-0.26285481452941895,
-0.07047628611326218,
0.010789883323013783,
-0.15061041712760925,
0.2139902412891388,
0.1903100460767746,
0.4612846374511719,
-0.8988655805587769,
0.5181236267089844,
0.45413675904273987,
-0.11048220843076706,
-0.3549407124519348,
0.03476203978061676,
0.20899422466754913,
-0.928924560546875,
0.42616531252861023,
-0.04771662503480911,
-0.29132741689682007,
-0.12140493839979172,
-0.25284305214881897,
-0.5752651691436768,
0.795940101146698,
0.7133048176765442,
-0.3416691720485687,
0.3000730276107788,
0.16945280134677887,
0.8333214521408081,
-0.20593373477458954,
0.1733643263578415,
0.3581927418708801,
-0.057506006211042404,
0.4267740845680237,
-0.8070762753486633,
0.19964103400707245,
-0.2959337830543518,
-0.01813877746462822,
0.031085185706615448,
-0.9331496357917786,
0.37379688024520874,
-0.24578772485256195,
-0.37964683771133423,
0.0012790908804163337,
0.09471724182367325,
0.11278947442770004,
0.16899628937244415,
0.7931092977523804,
0.5838434100151062,
0.5953559279441833,
-0.014816449023783207,
1.02213454246521,
-0.2597610652446747,
0.25989535450935364,
1.1039903163909912,
-0.18106794357299805,
0.5273482799530029,
0.27716121077537537,
-0.14416803419589996,
0.2698580026626587,
0.5374994277954102,
0.315715491771698,
0.8747127056121826,
0.35432782769203186,
-0.6894010305404663,
-0.25838741660118103,
-0.3371454179286957,
-0.25870710611343384,
0.5196170210838318,
0.29668667912483215,
-0.4032529592514038,
-0.01981845125555992,
0.16815613210201263,
0.1518544703722,
0.1743556559085846,
-0.203892782330513,
1.2227588891983032,
-0.030718829482793808,
-0.6424131393432617,
0.9033570885658264,
-0.4735749065876007,
0.5296687483787537,
-0.4940522015094757,
0.18943741917610168,
-0.06305958330631256,
0.5611952543258667,
-0.011207659728825092,
-0.5924991369247437,
0.33898594975471497,
-0.2156440168619156,
0.10234691202640533,
-0.28527310490608215,
0.821890115737915,
-0.468538761138916,
-0.010467082262039185,
0.5860694050788879,
0.13892154395580292,
-0.16372165083885193,
-0.13709178566932678,
-0.979583203792572,
0.06022883206605911,
-0.01809225231409073,
-0.4041867256164551,
0.3475179672241211,
0.24666041135787964,
0.2898300886154175,
1.0154329538345337,
0.5742350220680237,
0.18540707230567932,
-0.2637800872325897,
0.17432548105716705,
1.212458848953247,
-0.3041342794895172,
-0.5323354601860046,
-0.7230778336524963,
0.39188358187675476,
-0.2330501675605774,
0.013256851583719254,
0.5791157484054565,
0.3173302710056305,
0.5609372854232788,
0.07629965245723724,
0.9746280312538147,
0.2518872916698456,
0.34106990694999695,
-0.27640894055366516,
0.779434323310852,
-0.2709154188632965,
0.3947290778160095,
-0.30324631929397583,
-0.4290424883365631,
-0.11771277338266373,
0.3248189687728882,
-0.4503234326839447,
-0.11977626383304596,
0.3616023361682892,
0.8454319834709167,
0.2720829248428345,
-0.10661928355693817,
0.36349520087242126,
0.37681373953819275,
0.69785475730896,
0.9068663120269775,
0.9879805445671082,
-0.3705688714981079,
1.11051344871521,
-0.508607029914856,
-0.5116664171218872,
-0.2437642365694046,
-0.5942644476890564,
-1.044671654701233,
-0.1424555480480194,
-0.19367654621601105,
-0.49311384558677673,
0.3828992545604706,
0.5858960747718811,
0.6341375708580017,
-0.7130405306816101,
0.22796626389026642,
-0.3371554911136627,
0.16360756754875183,
0.014110060408711433,
-0.20472587645053864,
0.09801169484853745,
-0.31470581889152527,
-0.877697229385376,
0.5285499691963196,
0.2603917419910431,
0.38119861483573914,
-0.17189213633537292,
-0.3372580111026764,
0.08225814998149872,
0.2551056742668152,
0.6526053547859192,
0.14852719008922577,
-0.44210323691368103,
-0.627342939376831,
-0.1944308578968048,
-0.2902536988258362,
0.013256685808300972,
0.4510402977466583,
-0.40496858954429626,
1.0504295825958252,
0.5341308116912842,
0.4305729568004608,
0.13995595276355743,
0.11312263458967209,
0.9993877410888672,
-0.531906008720398,
0.38634005188941956,
0.48112738132476807,
0.0714375451207161,
0.24088738858699799,
-0.8726035356521606,
0.4332115054130554,
0.12657643854618073,
-0.5618202686309814,
-0.8027341961860657,
0.6223086714744568,
-0.6854651570320129,
-0.3402203619480133,
1.2184522151947021,
-0.36533454060554504,
0.04094257205724716,
-0.25930681824684143,
-0.6500105261802673,
0.2732142210006714,
-0.6424592137336731,
1.2256518602371216,
0.413820743560791,
-0.2695349156856537,
0.19018428027629852,
-0.1711777001619339,
0.8849111199378967,
0.3655144274234772,
-0.7973650097846985,
0.2598924934864044,
0.44638925790786743,
0.38526520133018494,
0.11515918374061584,
0.7925947308540344,
-0.13836582005023956,
0.16879743337631226,
0.3443603515625,
-0.1885242760181427,
-0.3105852007865906,
-0.2113996148109436,
-0.41998690366744995,
0.10995244234800339,
0.06593932211399078,
-0.4491734802722931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12884v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12884v1
|
Investigating Persuasion Techniques in Arabic: An Empirical Study Leveraging Large Language Models
| 2024-05-21T15:55:09 | 2024-05-21T15:55:09 |
Abdurahmman Alzahrani, Eyad Babkier, Faisal Yanbaawi, Firas Yanbaawi, Hassan Alhuzali
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the current era of digital communication and widespread use of social
media, it is crucial to develop an understanding of persuasive techniques
employed in written text. This knowledge is essential for effectively
discerning accurate information and making informed decisions. To address this
need, this paper presents a comprehensive empirical study focused on
identifying persuasive techniques in Arabic social media content. To achieve
this objective, we utilize Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) and leverage the
ArAlEval dataset, which encompasses two tasks: binary classification to
determine the presence or absence of persuasion techniques, and multi-label
classification to identify the specific types of techniques employed in the
text. Our study explores three different learning approaches by harnessing the
power of PLMs: feature extraction, fine-tuning, and prompt engineering
techniques. Through extensive experimentation, we find that the fine-tuning
approach yields the highest results on the aforementioned dataset, achieving an
f1-micro score of 0.865 and an f1-weighted score of 0.861. Furthermore, our
analysis sheds light on an interesting finding. While the performance of the
GPT model is relatively lower compared to the other approaches, we have
observed that by employing few-shot learning techniques, we can enhance its
results by up to 20\%. This offers promising directions for future research and
exploration in this topic\footnote{Upon Acceptance, the source code will be
released on GitHub.}.
|
[
-0.5800581574440002,
-1.0953538417816162,
0.5443167090415955,
0.22367940843105316,
-0.4271688461303711,
0.12591445446014404,
-0.13595055043697357,
0.045536693185567856,
-0.16662748157978058,
0.32056283950805664,
-0.3753255009651184,
-1.0740082263946533,
-0.7187696695327759,
-0.026019718497991562,
-0.43373459577560425,
1.1537137031555176,
-0.24035967886447906,
0.12800098955631256,
0.17357409000396729,
-0.03564007952809334,
-0.33294618129730225,
-0.6205546259880066,
-0.7178308963775635,
-0.17615725100040436,
0.7566816210746765,
0.8228994607925415,
0.6624259352684021,
0.3793090879917145,
0.1600821614265442,
0.18445269763469696,
-0.08732777088880539,
-0.07896024733781815,
-0.3709973394870758,
-0.18494912981987,
-0.08866603672504425,
-0.345663845539093,
0.0739896297454834,
0.21035893261432648,
0.6672081351280212,
0.3733803331851959,
-0.04791200906038284,
0.38082781434059143,
0.28508082032203674,
0.6372690796852112,
-0.7523429989814758,
-0.14735446870326996,
-0.6494823694229126,
0.021663764491677284,
-0.3334234654903412,
-0.2038789540529251,
-0.3207571506500244,
-0.49144813418388367,
-0.06813564896583557,
-0.16772232949733734,
0.13156729936599731,
0.03396732732653618,
0.8156260848045349,
0.03514227271080017,
-0.7425382733345032,
-0.604252278804779,
-0.8363261818885803,
0.8050692677497864,
-0.6844102740287781,
0.0878264307975769,
0.5739042162895203,
0.3109646141529083,
0.11281190812587738,
-0.6093224287033081,
-0.6178718209266663,
-0.4229672849178314,
0.18656323850154877,
-0.0535937137901783,
-0.23746450245380402,
-0.06851541996002197,
0.25151264667510986,
0.04831598699092865,
-0.40551865100860596,
0.2287885695695877,
0.06932330131530762,
-0.14028410613536835,
0.5938692688941956,
-0.19054609537124634,
0.34913215041160583,
-0.19416724145412445,
-0.30272188782691956,
-0.3984939754009247,
-0.9695273637771606,
0.3902438282966614,
0.7576516270637512,
0.1214447170495987,
-0.2140689492225647,
0.5961076617240906,
-0.2065756469964981,
0.3889878988265991,
0.20867474377155304,
-0.1479787677526474,
-0.23075121641159058,
-0.30065369606018066,
0.04368242621421814,
0.2169414907693863,
0.7067819237709045,
0.05283033847808838,
0.35597363114356995,
0.4050072729587555,
-0.2985989451408386,
0.15487900376319885,
0.011551562696695328,
-1.0238664150238037,
-0.35154879093170166,
0.07678031921386719,
-0.8743603229522705,
-0.4170893132686615,
0.1627136617898941,
-0.6835001111030579,
-0.6413117051124573,
-0.040950093418359756,
0.49637696146965027,
-0.5709670782089233,
-0.28778785467147827,
0.12781071662902832,
-0.03248951584100723,
0.3381170630455017,
0.21658912301063538,
-0.7041549682617188,
0.09321977198123932,
0.6711887717247009,
0.817292332649231,
0.0600745864212513,
0.051801055669784546,
-0.3148258924484253,
-0.018819376826286316,
-0.5670109987258911,
0.922387421131134,
-0.9422581791877747,
-0.5021946430206299,
0.37887778878211975,
-0.4738119840621948,
0.062538281083107,
-0.5783559083938599,
1.0285042524337769,
-0.5831478834152222,
-0.07467900216579437,
-0.3242259621620178,
-0.5552749633789062,
-0.3590376675128937,
0.17039982974529266,
-0.664198100566864,
0.6307538151741028,
-0.2720804512500763,
-0.6189193725585938,
0.378720760345459,
-0.6642530560493469,
-0.4503864347934723,
-0.18541604280471802,
-0.252571165561676,
-0.5959190726280212,
0.11943921446800232,
0.361735999584198,
0.4425138831138611,
-0.16504929959774017,
0.0878782644867897,
0.03178118169307709,
-0.1067458912730217,
0.5623551607131958,
-0.6152090430259705,
0.4870135188102722,
0.4825487732887268,
-0.4512515366077423,
0.32980161905288696,
-0.6341404914855957,
-0.29352903366088867,
0.17353028059005737,
-0.17936135828495026,
-0.47866129875183105,
0.0919981449842453,
-0.05775997042655945,
0.3389759361743927,
0.19388693571090698,
-0.41526302695274353,
0.0887075811624527,
-0.26169368624687195,
0.19970844686031342,
0.6318639516830444,
0.32388240098953247,
0.3285951614379883,
-0.5930054783821106,
0.8253827691078186,
-0.0012275655753910542,
0.018191589042544365,
0.0010854988358914852,
-0.3749045729637146,
-0.4985419511795044,
-0.25939831137657166,
0.41486936807632446,
0.29176345467567444,
-0.8956905007362366,
0.11674220860004425,
0.1905331015586853,
-0.6275550723075867,
-0.4677627384662628,
0.31481826305389404,
0.33813634514808655,
0.4391924738883972,
0.23218008875846863,
0.11640673875808716,
-0.35713890194892883,
-0.8677409887313843,
-0.5499493479728699,
-0.15023890137672424,
0.12559711933135986,
0.03269289806485176,
0.6360824704170227,
0.1394035369157791,
0.8037630319595337,
-0.22766558825969696,
-0.10581851005554199,
-0.4941764175891876,
0.6593655347824097,
0.13197296857833862,
0.2772858142852783,
0.6509828567504883,
-0.9593706727027893,
-0.8833854794502258,
-0.029078716412186623,
-0.5288051962852478,
-0.3070262372493744,
-0.10155130177736282,
0.1359241008758545,
0.2670905292034149,
0.32389578223228455,
-0.49591895937919617,
0.7865647077560425,
0.5311715602874756,
-0.30307134985923767,
0.729722797870636,
0.3722696900367737,
0.37474367022514343,
-0.797829270362854,
-0.22771038115024567,
0.49529239535331726,
0.14219409227371216,
-0.7335093021392822,
-0.07442258298397064,
-0.08836404234170914,
-0.18226563930511475,
-0.6065871715545654,
0.5531564354896545,
-0.4434114694595337,
0.5829581618309021,
-0.6512840390205383,
-0.47951802611351013,
-0.1779356598854065,
0.16636018455028534,
0.24164098501205444,
0.822894275188446,
0.5232826471328735,
-0.655814528465271,
-0.08671915531158447,
0.19717943668365479,
-0.5687999129295349,
0.36066532135009766,
-0.7272897362709045,
0.32357242703437805,
-0.2353430837392807,
0.1498161256313324,
-1.3438843488693237,
-0.03010716661810875,
0.4352360963821411,
-0.4440232515335083,
0.03700544312596321,
-0.28019657731056213,
-0.54731684923172,
0.011215174570679665,
-0.4355052709579468,
0.14822061359882355,
0.5250359773635864,
-0.3477781414985657,
0.6585983037948608,
0.19524797797203064,
-0.644039511680603,
-0.35047414898872375,
-0.07386762648820877,
0.029724245890975,
-0.7066542506217957,
-0.4580049216747284,
0.2341829538345337,
0.18134067952632904,
-0.5111312866210938,
-0.3448142111301422,
-0.139261394739151,
0.22603781521320343,
0.04348369315266609,
0.4451656639575958,
0.02550567127764225,
-0.16584435105323792,
0.15815076231956482,
0.2716354727745056,
-0.11494702100753784,
0.10051686316728592,
-0.012304280884563923,
0.8231526017189026,
-0.1376161426305771,
-0.4259324371814728,
-0.7496051788330078,
0.5552076697349548,
0.13854677975177765,
-0.2186804860830307,
1.0829769372940063,
0.7414144277572632,
-0.17932745814323425,
0.02888474240899086,
-0.79875648021698,
-0.4106072783470154,
-0.512863278388977,
0.32881614565849304,
-0.4232806861400604,
-0.6261582970619202,
0.25015443563461304,
-0.5748756527900696,
-0.0693870559334755,
0.343002587556839,
0.484313428401947,
-0.05475601553916931,
1.556679368019104,
0.5618168115615845,
-0.2079293131828308,
0.5996409058570862,
-0.21226099133491516,
0.144142746925354,
-0.20387063920497894,
-0.1041707694530487,
-0.8667391538619995,
-0.36629101634025574,
-0.528702437877655,
-0.010718308389186859,
0.45551809668540955,
0.30256187915802,
-0.4035205841064453,
-0.11898361146450043,
-0.12580695748329163,
0.24136322736740112,
0.6121528148651123,
0.0687437430024147,
0.292349636554718,
0.5587813854217529,
-0.16405360400676727,
-0.014480357989668846,
-0.6526752710342407,
-1.2005547285079956,
0.9195910692214966,
0.46517080068588257,
0.6895943284034729,
0.33856722712516785,
0.7312622666358948,
0.4455742835998535,
0.5860902070999146,
-0.7053335905075073,
0.7929250001907349,
0.0890049859881401,
-0.4117293357849121,
-0.37928032875061035,
-0.2987346947193146,
-1.1571601629257202,
0.07348978519439697,
-0.6103412508964539,
-0.44344934821128845,
0.02847207337617874,
0.06483379751443863,
-0.24038022756576538,
0.22776886820793152,
-0.7133477926254272,
0.7612016201019287,
-0.387177050113678,
-0.42654210329055786,
-0.49721595644950867,
-0.40977486968040466,
-0.07621326297521591,
-0.05632561445236206,
0.22082194685935974,
-0.07278177887201309,
-0.009329439140856266,
0.980802059173584,
-0.2898043096065521,
0.9399385452270508,
-0.33147093653678894,
-0.2949512302875519,
0.4034566581249237,
-0.13822755217552185,
0.5713112354278564,
-0.17872147262096405,
-0.11827977001667023,
0.12477206438779831,
-0.09044371545314789,
-0.5157361030578613,
-0.5548375844955444,
0.6514506936073303,
-0.9281898736953735,
-0.7853033542633057,
-0.3520773649215698,
-0.3679043650627136,
-0.26666736602783203,
-0.0005921013071201742,
0.16166844964027405,
0.3086204528808594,
-0.4359748661518097,
0.23911850154399872,
0.5283980965614319,
-0.4031076729297638,
0.4805990159511566,
0.6308337450027466,
-0.21404077112674713,
-0.24300655722618103,
1.1232166290283203,
0.17119482159614563,
0.05133765563368797,
0.34625476598739624,
0.5181389451026917,
-0.5173248052597046,
-0.9123635292053223,
-0.206640362739563,
0.36658281087875366,
-0.6193634867668152,
0.01111641339957714,
-0.2249024510383606,
-0.05459786579012871,
-0.6906805038452148,
0.000012208273801661562,
0.005239278543740511,
-0.15962348878383636,
-0.30442696809768677,
-0.1597675234079361,
0.18641111254692078,
0.8854087591171265,
0.16632266342639923,
0.76380455493927,
-0.7812795042991638,
0.22262200713157654,
0.24826477468013763,
-0.15026028454303741,
0.05266736447811127,
-0.45543450117111206,
-0.19266296923160553,
0.26327425241470337,
-0.6820076107978821,
-1.190397024154663,
0.5534191727638245,
-0.022180665284395218,
0.5018815994262695,
0.7924573421478271,
0.1688302755355835,
0.3641667068004608,
-0.30611318349838257,
0.750440239906311,
0.09001438319683075,
-0.8149468302726746,
0.6944380402565002,
-0.32264795899391174,
0.17089885473251343,
0.6305065751075745,
1.2004212141036987,
-0.1940828263759613,
-0.08361183106899261,
-0.5980403423309326,
-0.8093202114105225,
0.19969625771045685,
0.16091643273830414,
0.09519465267658234,
-0.001776859862729907,
0.31588515639305115,
0.31548598408699036,
0.520132839679718,
-0.5407921671867371,
-0.39880260825157166,
-0.1828024834394455,
-0.4074532687664032,
-0.05791053548455238,
-0.46007266640663147,
-0.11760305613279343,
-0.21314232051372528,
0.8291837573051453,
0.08934801071882248,
-0.2894153296947479,
-0.05015862360596657,
-0.2532123029232025,
0.17029999196529388,
0.46257370710372925,
0.492997944355011,
0.696510374546051,
-0.04867686703801155,
0.030752182006835938,
-0.23093968629837036,
-0.5079994201660156,
0.37095314264297485,
0.3913700580596924,
-0.39368218183517456,
0.005377883557230234,
0.12717534601688385,
0.7862330675125122,
-0.29004335403442383,
-0.4022080600261688,
0.2815006673336029,
0.07446059584617615,
-0.23870715498924255,
-0.21247881650924683,
-0.21618518233299255,
-0.061418525874614716,
0.20371682941913605,
0.7686930894851685,
-0.2401338517665863,
0.13966916501522064,
-0.6201726794242859,
-0.13138185441493988,
0.7531213164329529,
-0.2843320071697235,
-0.28044208884239197,
0.303028404712677,
0.33754026889801025,
-0.4835446774959564,
0.16109398007392883,
0.03918755054473877,
-0.30771520733833313,
0.41116204857826233,
0.4548238515853882,
0.4504549205303192,
-0.4741218388080597,
0.6688006520271301,
0.05719343200325966,
0.1096506416797638,
0.03861178085207939,
0.045883871614933014,
-0.27293866872787476,
-0.8485838770866394,
-0.36363574862480164,
-0.43535906076431274,
-0.49137139320373535,
0.40807992219924927,
-0.4201914072036743,
0.12456239014863968,
-0.520408034324646,
-0.36080554127693176,
0.211583212018013,
0.2881118655204773,
-0.4963638484477997,
0.011996252462267876,
0.2420894354581833,
0.8791117072105408,
-1.1427499055862427,
0.616479218006134,
1.1341211795806885,
-0.5186359286308289,
-0.881726086139679,
0.2831727862358093,
0.1760479062795639,
-0.6526226997375488,
0.514864981174469,
0.2205054610967636,
-0.43209341168403625,
0.23178724944591522,
-1.0880558490753174,
-0.38539838790893555,
0.4784604609012604,
0.31708329916000366,
-0.3854764401912689,
0.287894070148468,
0.32409361004829407,
0.23932920396327972,
-0.41889938712120056,
0.23411159217357635,
0.5220039486885071,
0.6125183701515198,
0.0973019152879715,
-0.4761514961719513,
0.032723866403102875,
-0.3616582453250885,
-0.16958172619342804,
-0.03044339083135128,
-0.4109537899494171,
0.5474364161491394,
-0.04109951853752136,
-0.30800846219062805,
0.2856912612915039,
0.8935979008674622,
0.5042799115180969,
0.6295281052589417,
0.5829925537109375,
0.09492575377225876,
0.5316284894943237,
0.17225152254104614,
0.9985527396202087,
-0.3860941231250763,
-0.13944315910339355,
0.506930947303772,
-0.5164827108383179,
0.7479541301727295,
0.48167815804481506,
0.06030597910284996,
0.812679648399353,
0.5072900056838989,
0.43800094723701477,
0.5476910471916199,
0.2332547903060913,
-0.6577219367027283,
-0.30529484152793884,
-0.49696633219718933,
-0.2990676462650299,
0.4350041151046753,
0.48621705174446106,
-0.2901175022125244,
-0.0857878252863884,
0.3903694450855255,
0.1536835879087448,
0.449746698141098,
-0.4710175096988678,
0.8941038250923157,
0.09360438585281372,
-0.6639219522476196,
0.40890267491340637,
0.25085386633872986,
0.6741874814033508,
-0.7554426193237305,
-0.3783133924007416,
0.04169511795043945,
-0.017430299893021584,
-0.08160741627216339,
-0.7481912970542908,
-0.1238255724310875,
-0.011342789977788925,
0.08374249935150146,
-0.3892720341682434,
1.0695701837539673,
-0.2848265469074249,
-0.537456750869751,
-0.25338467955589294,
0.6294710636138916,
0.1503029316663742,
-0.3888479173183441,
-0.7040649652481079,
0.08121035993099213,
-0.005664674565196037,
-0.11770203709602356,
0.48251909017562866,
0.4876857101917267,
-0.11036791652441025,
0.5141732692718506,
0.8652496933937073,
0.2760140597820282,
-0.3511120080947876,
0.384265273809433,
0.795673131942749,
-0.7499136328697205,
-0.33415544033050537,
-1.09469473361969,
0.28658372163772583,
-0.19943873584270477,
-0.24631954729557037,
1.2672480344772339,
0.398408979177475,
0.6399452686309814,
-0.134470134973526,
0.8891007900238037,
0.3302554488182068,
0.5891056656837463,
-0.6631507277488708,
0.6576877236366272,
-0.22430185973644257,
0.32857197523117065,
-0.4157313406467438,
-0.6245434284210205,
0.018920671194791794,
0.7706180810928345,
-0.7784552574157715,
0.1624828428030014,
0.4916307330131531,
0.8325797915458679,
0.40217143297195435,
0.23336364328861237,
0.1690380722284317,
0.2639015316963196,
0.2864295244216919,
0.2345578372478485,
1.329880714416504,
0.10728377848863602,
0.5990075469017029,
-0.18063780665397644,
-0.3134053349494934,
-0.024590816348791122,
-0.8522621393203735,
-1.0574804544448853,
-0.5173971652984619,
-0.4707602262496948,
-0.4019119441509247,
0.34771716594696045,
0.946195125579834,
0.462761253118515,
-0.6870410442352295,
-0.2665010392665863,
0.0944582149386406,
0.1609627604484558,
-0.22836719453334808,
-0.19656847417354584,
0.514428973197937,
-0.018764564767479897,
-0.5230275392532349,
0.07570168375968933,
-0.06150730326771736,
0.14538712799549103,
-0.14376722276210785,
0.04700355604290962,
-0.5194960236549377,
0.16648443043231964,
0.6113211512565613,
0.3639521598815918,
-0.4459439218044281,
-0.09682028740644455,
-0.09706870466470718,
0.12669970095157623,
-0.0811358094215393,
0.9313663840293884,
-0.8024599552154541,
-0.18369358777999878,
0.2964330315589905,
0.48217684030532837,
0.38739922642707825,
0.522853672504425,
0.33501410484313965,
-0.580695629119873,
0.07363149523735046,
0.2881641387939453,
0.15652163326740265,
0.38504815101623535,
-0.09654901176691055,
0.06416473537683487,
-0.07696591317653656,
-0.4833396375179291,
-0.4905116558074951,
0.3524170219898224,
-0.6680960655212402,
-0.41067737340927124,
1.5344181060791016,
0.12447734922170639,
-0.06305843591690063,
-0.47087913751602173,
-0.7537800669670105,
0.24966736137866974,
-0.7166354656219482,
0.9976456761360168,
0.8839733600616455,
0.022675924003124237,
-0.22862671315670013,
-0.37965041399002075,
0.5640620589256287,
0.7112547755241394,
-0.5510566830635071,
-0.47231438755989075,
0.40257230401039124,
0.2694430649280548,
0.024155592545866966,
0.633707582950592,
0.17129306495189667,
0.10746168345212936,
-0.25623223185539246,
-0.1666848063468933,
0.03292587772011757,
-0.40579283237457275,
-0.4225018620491028,
0.5569846034049988,
0.3455476760864258,
-0.10140962153673172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12875v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12875v1
|
Diffusion-RSCC: Diffusion Probabilistic Model for Change Captioning in Remote Sensing Images
| 2024-05-21T15:44:31 | 2024-05-21T15:44:31 |
Xiaofei Yu, Yitong Li, Jie Ma
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Remote sensing image change captioning (RSICC) aims at generating human-like
language to describe the semantic changes between bi-temporal remote sensing
image pairs. It provides valuable insights into environmental dynamics and land
management. Unlike conventional change captioning task, RSICC involves not only
retrieving relevant information across different modalities and generating
fluent captions, but also mitigating the impact of pixel-level differences on
terrain change localization. The pixel problem due to long time span decreases
the accuracy of generated caption. Inspired by the remarkable generative power
of diffusion model, we propose a probabilistic diffusion model for RSICC to
solve the aforementioned problems. In training process, we construct a noise
predictor conditioned on cross modal features to learn the distribution from
the real caption distribution to the standard Gaussian distribution under the
Markov chain. Meanwhile, a cross-mode fusion and a stacking self-attention
module are designed for noise predictor in the reverse process. In testing
phase, the well-trained noise predictor helps to estimate the mean value of the
distribution and generate change captions step by step. Extensive experiments
on the LEVIR-CC dataset demonstrate the effectiveness of our Diffusion-RSCC and
its individual components. The quantitative results showcase superior
performance over existing methods across both traditional and newly augmented
metrics. The code and materials will be available online at
https://github.com/Fay-Y/Diffusion-RSCC.
|
[
-0.37034371495246887,
-0.5055853128433228,
0.4691901206970215,
-0.005424123723059893,
-0.4450819194316864,
0.0009612215217202902,
-0.09045757353305817,
-0.14836443960666656,
0.10051853954792023,
0.3085136115550995,
-0.6548606753349304,
-0.46093136072158813,
-0.7868146300315857,
-0.1741810292005539,
-0.39670249819755554,
0.820683479309082,
-0.21599465608596802,
0.31660398840904236,
-0.13008280098438263,
-0.08741793036460876,
-0.33718493580818176,
0.24719585478305817,
-0.5698934197425842,
0.16739913821220398,
0.39663559198379517,
0.0820402204990387,
0.8568457961082458,
0.1955774873495102,
0.46740826964378357,
0.1896125227212906,
-0.25513437390327454,
0.09095100313425064,
-0.09425562620162964,
0.21868614852428436,
-0.16838626563549042,
-0.37476715445518494,
0.10872511565685272,
-0.12084099650382996,
0.8674060702323914,
0.302261084318161,
-0.4637190103530884,
-0.03781506419181824,
-0.2674633264541626,
0.7281249165534973,
-0.6309773325920105,
0.4832422733306885,
-0.6125630140304565,
0.12787288427352905,
-0.22442007064819336,
-0.48828238248825073,
-0.1816568374633789,
0.15445901453495026,
-0.00867323949933052,
-0.7399052977561951,
0.8712626099586487,
0.20336878299713135,
0.8230662941932678,
0.34138229489326477,
0.0017248006770387292,
-0.00048010313184931874,
-0.8066807389259338,
0.8300989866256714,
-0.7659564018249512,
0.38376864790916443,
0.42698994278907776,
0.49930691719055176,
-0.23304788768291473,
-0.3889009356498718,
-0.6075854301452637,
-0.3627346158027649,
0.20477572083473206,
0.45361244678497314,
0.019271157681941986,
-0.22908039391040802,
-0.07328592985868454,
0.32283371686935425,
-0.4173773527145386,
-0.20217503607273102,
-0.6794503331184387,
-0.1571161299943924,
0.518845796585083,
0.19415241479873657,
0.15947522222995758,
-0.1805478185415268,
-0.3703811466693878,
-0.03876331076025963,
-0.7468032836914062,
-0.11004441231489182,
0.43672826886177063,
0.37034469842910767,
-0.5543738007545471,
0.28966328501701355,
-0.31756001710891724,
0.6387566924095154,
-0.06667046248912811,
0.04514913633465767,
0.16036102175712585,
-0.338862806558609,
-0.044199138879776,
-0.2892116606235504,
0.6804240345954895,
0.27772900462150574,
-0.12190099060535431,
-0.05819793790578842,
-0.30057477951049805,
-0.10062749683856964,
0.0846543088555336,
-0.4759577810764313,
-0.5545082092285156,
0.03305979445576668,
-0.5917927622795105,
-0.503910481929779,
0.22573518753051758,
-0.8408002853393555,
-0.3665498197078705,
-0.3593877851963043,
0.267484188079834,
-0.0964994803071022,
-0.5915251970291138,
0.20805196464061737,
-0.041965022683143616,
0.19409942626953125,
0.5412019491195679,
-0.46245667338371277,
0.3637377917766571,
0.2824171781539917,
1.203609824180603,
-0.37452220916748047,
-0.21319518983364105,
-0.4088837504386902,
0.018791550770401955,
-0.3491073250770569,
1.0651708841323853,
-0.6569429636001587,
-0.23190613090991974,
-0.3347291052341461,
0.2577935457229614,
0.12717606127262115,
-0.5148588418960571,
0.14126816391944885,
-0.9735057950019836,
0.19587090611457825,
0.012794479727745056,
0.055662818253040314,
-0.0031857446301728487,
-0.06864243000745773,
-0.8732573986053467,
0.7959074378013611,
0.45468881726264954,
-0.807478129863739,
0.3229616582393646,
-0.9397902488708496,
-0.46791213750839233,
0.19700056314468384,
0.23118920624256134,
-1.0165653228759766,
-0.3182699680328369,
0.10537856072187424,
0.310138076543808,
-0.3754118084907532,
0.13425606489181519,
-0.07912255823612213,
0.08999026566743851,
0.4892362952232361,
-0.23616500198841095,
0.3404467701911926,
0.6808969378471375,
-0.14503635466098785,
0.3144221603870392,
-0.24296781420707703,
-0.603029727935791,
-0.03671365603804588,
-0.08811910450458527,
0.09379996359348297,
0.3820180892944336,
0.22831036150455475,
0.0869058147072792,
-0.27922502160072327,
-0.4396054446697235,
-0.1734548807144165,
0.003242272650822997,
0.6395501494407654,
0.6040447354316711,
0.5132297873497009,
0.8221834897994995,
-0.36617934703826904,
0.7047432065010071,
0.6548282504081726,
0.4599445164203644,
-0.07918744534254074,
-0.678772509098053,
-0.19445593655109406,
-0.28695929050445557,
0.552038311958313,
0.3466038703918457,
-0.6072273850440979,
0.03096194937825203,
-0.09318658709526062,
-0.2693460285663605,
-0.1650639921426773,
0.058282751590013504,
-0.14796102046966553,
0.35143783688545227,
0.4772752821445465,
-0.5097559690475464,
-0.38556843996047974,
-0.571307361125946,
0.2424793392419815,
0.21570119261741638,
-0.042184412479400635,
0.007175121456384659,
0.44326528906822205,
-0.21271395683288574,
0.8538645505905151,
-0.5849258899688721,
-0.5935296416282654,
-0.36860883235931396,
0.3494047522544861,
-0.24521338939666748,
0.41508543491363525,
0.4284543991088867,
-1.2613677978515625,
-0.5191419720649719,
-0.23158055543899536,
-0.15461918711662292,
-0.1608135849237442,
-0.6419984102249146,
-0.14524473249912262,
0.28138116002082825,
0.6257473230361938,
-0.5953425168991089,
0.6493130326271057,
0.6079258322715759,
0.02187655121088028,
0.6968094706535339,
-0.24023596942424774,
0.5263768434524536,
-0.9380038976669312,
-0.37888896465301514,
0.4559241533279419,
-0.22463726997375488,
-0.16408154368400574,
0.2024928331375122,
-0.20815908908843994,
-0.05159639194607735,
-0.5872217416763306,
0.09195657074451447,
-0.8757140040397644,
-0.2947509288787842,
-0.09929998219013214,
0.13334979116916656,
-0.4197262227535248,
0.28229570388793945,
0.3241155445575714,
0.7325564622879028,
0.9973751306533813,
-0.6526932716369629,
0.31062325835227966,
-0.00007943446689750999,
-0.5009669661521912,
0.44165077805519104,
-0.3364499509334564,
-0.47365981340408325,
-0.4646402597427368,
0.38355758786201477,
-1.2834969758987427,
-0.04149137809872627,
0.683359682559967,
-0.46293744444847107,
0.18067292869091034,
-0.4187987744808197,
-0.4465036690235138,
-0.06839735060930252,
-0.08934210985898972,
0.3835254907608032,
0.5543164610862732,
-0.20094886422157288,
0.7079738974571228,
0.19048269093036652,
-0.2362443208694458,
-0.04536290466785431,
-0.9171317219734192,
0.22262610495090485,
-0.025663167238235474,
-0.19192753732204437,
0.39022865891456604,
-0.2382885068655014,
-0.01617720164358616,
0.29162800312042236,
0.024162696674466133,
-0.16410991549491882,
-0.1308179646730423,
0.5689300298690796,
0.0658322349190712,
-0.02677123434841633,
-0.09434511512517929,
0.11822640150785446,
-0.22953571379184723,
0.0023894309997558594,
-0.22087855637073517,
0.34578970074653625,
0.12192351371049881,
-0.258903443813324,
-0.6886550784111023,
0.1563817709684372,
0.5420451760292053,
-0.30501052737236023,
0.7549213767051697,
0.46960359811782837,
-0.13347257673740387,
-0.11587457358837128,
-0.22399397194385529,
-0.18323464691638947,
-0.33692362904548645,
0.5054947137832642,
-0.2294131964445114,
-0.4125243127346039,
0.750855028629303,
-0.301254540681839,
-0.14174312353134155,
0.38526013493537903,
0.4894721508026123,
-0.234843447804451,
0.6124019026756287,
0.28445538878440857,
0.08829226344823837,
0.8926050066947937,
-0.5580768585205078,
-0.038816407322883606,
-0.7770316004753113,
-0.11637349426746368,
-0.12031254917383194,
-0.3802417516708374,
-0.28399309515953064,
-0.9947981238365173,
0.2395501434803009,
-0.15413548052310944,
-0.0790005624294281,
0.3305358290672302,
-0.5142635107040405,
0.4501779079437256,
0.22495298087596893,
0.27814364433288574,
0.15318816900253296,
0.4280727505683899,
0.3871757984161377,
-0.12675513327121735,
-0.49933335185050964,
-0.06682029366493225,
0.8667997121810913,
0.2706424295902252,
0.9772933125495911,
0.27749162912368774,
0.4318704903125763,
0.9518798589706421,
0.4020732641220093,
-0.44645464420318604,
0.588101327419281,
0.11419396102428436,
-0.24814532697200775,
-0.3544115424156189,
-0.46499374508857727,
-0.9875754714012146,
0.19838042557239532,
-0.26464346051216125,
0.061349574476480484,
0.04688261076807976,
0.11686559021472931,
-0.16297465562820435,
0.7246172428131104,
-0.25982028245925903,
0.47696420550346375,
0.10584770888090134,
-0.1280425637960434,
-0.5673407912254333,
-0.9584033489227295,
0.09375502914190292,
0.08568032085895538,
0.31382063031196594,
0.1570361852645874,
-0.15721775591373444,
0.5684072375297546,
-0.14527705311775208,
0.9578573107719421,
-0.46989479660987854,
0.1124924048781395,
0.6259449124336243,
0.5316460728645325,
0.40775254368782043,
0.0675157681107521,
0.18093743920326233,
0.17760871350765228,
0.021678123623132706,
-0.3967306613922119,
-0.5181213617324829,
0.5078928470611572,
-0.8436840772628784,
-0.2201945185661316,
-0.5727136135101318,
-0.42396658658981323,
0.3420203924179077,
-0.15724577009677887,
0.2594705820083618,
0.2692433297634125,
-0.11409363895654678,
-0.2414698451757431,
0.7369071841239929,
-0.13121290504932404,
0.18128721415996552,
0.7337517738342285,
0.10832438617944717,
-0.48851436376571655,
0.9794095754623413,
0.09826331585645676,
0.5170989632606506,
0.5134723782539368,
0.3872465193271637,
-0.13983483612537384,
-0.8446916341781616,
-0.4350127577781677,
0.3010159432888031,
-0.43031883239746094,
-0.5936597585678101,
-0.49850159883499146,
-0.2485942393541336,
-0.33881616592407227,
-0.30916526913642883,
-0.10496023297309875,
-0.21491138637065887,
-0.5829074382781982,
-0.019061436876654625,
0.5121829509735107,
0.7269576787948608,
-0.3610851466655731,
0.5956752300262451,
-0.4716378152370453,
0.5773460268974304,
0.057664889842271805,
0.18929649889469147,
-0.038765594363212585,
-0.9083148837089539,
-0.13826416432857513,
0.21838590502738953,
-0.2860594689846039,
-0.8573283553123474,
0.6718929409980774,
0.2501125633716583,
0.4277523159980774,
0.17947347462177277,
0.13644616305828094,
0.3341672718524933,
-0.08232180774211884,
0.9939000606536865,
0.3090699017047882,
-0.7413976788520813,
0.44407325983047485,
-0.3003089427947998,
0.19965970516204834,
0.10376104712486267,
0.19136178493499756,
-0.5430367588996887,
-0.4838450253009796,
-0.6712304353713989,
-0.6249380111694336,
0.5146144032478333,
-0.06375676393508911,
-0.0074438005685806274,
0.12029317021369934,
0.38829123973846436,
0.03762614354491234,
0.06371200829744339,
-0.7024472951889038,
0.0560145229101181,
-0.25503310561180115,
-0.12187762558460236,
0.24030283093452454,
-0.13110804557800293,
-0.25245925784111023,
-0.12151011824607849,
0.6671784520149231,
0.09602516889572144,
0.3466152250766754,
0.3752821683883667,
-0.19286033511161804,
-0.5059438347816467,
0.2383284568786621,
0.854957640171051,
0.3625839352607727,
-0.03795764222741127,
0.1738065481185913,
0.18354302644729614,
-0.48727017641067505,
-0.15006369352340698,
-0.10707803815603256,
-0.28273409605026245,
-0.10951756685972214,
0.19259022176265717,
0.5261428356170654,
0.23426471650600433,
-0.31410256028175354,
0.7928171157836914,
0.16511183977127075,
-0.5313412547111511,
-0.45061421394348145,
-0.22271141409873962,
0.0834006667137146,
0.1966509371995926,
0.41505154967308044,
0.7822047472000122,
0.28289249539375305,
-0.17945951223373413,
0.026117950677871704,
0.3136114776134491,
-0.2964630126953125,
-0.4220474362373352,
0.798596203327179,
0.0612516887485981,
-0.0023770490661263466,
0.31242865324020386,
-0.5897554755210876,
-0.5076186656951904,
0.7222201824188232,
0.2790996730327606,
0.7604885697364807,
-0.13477672636508942,
0.7492454051971436,
0.4013684093952179,
0.22770512104034424,
-0.3920752704143524,
0.0729382112622261,
-0.6070186495780945,
-0.6701797246932983,
-0.3728311359882355,
-0.21504321694374084,
-0.3314144015312195,
-0.31869345903396606,
-0.4725548326969147,
0.17832180857658386,
-0.5360629558563232,
0.0787583664059639,
-0.29359617829322815,
-0.34194231033325195,
-0.5396053791046143,
0.11293812841176987,
0.10774942487478256,
0.6007237434387207,
-1.3214300870895386,
0.5123858451843262,
0.49880123138427734,
-0.6326482892036438,
-0.23653559386730194,
-0.054967280477285385,
-0.25318291783332825,
-0.3767158091068268,
0.7948725819587708,
-0.3431583344936371,
-0.3438451588153839,
-0.23896609246730804,
-1.0138272047042847,
-0.6728553175926208,
1.141210913658142,
-0.15198439359664917,
-0.6526244878768921,
0.5447663068771362,
0.11293467879295349,
0.49525779485702515,
-0.4087029993534088,
0.09477856010198593,
0.059884943068027496,
0.42785775661468506,
0.4368212819099426,
-0.2718939483165741,
-0.013730072416365147,
0.3160592317581177,
0.3429880142211914,
0.10306257754564285,
-0.6704075336456299,
0.7746667265892029,
-0.7342724800109863,
-0.6589578986167908,
0.3159685432910919,
0.9189958572387695,
0.00181803188752383,
0.3039460778236389,
0.8606835007667542,
0.5123741626739502,
0.24749523401260376,
-0.09447424113750458,
0.6341374516487122,
0.005023083183914423,
0.5231662392616272,
0.972598135471344,
-0.3042031526565552,
0.9521219730377197,
0.5107998251914978,
-0.47289812564849854,
1.051592230796814,
0.6913684010505676,
-0.13303537666797638,
1.0868746042251587,
0.45978060364723206,
-0.5367616415023804,
-0.3541155159473419,
0.3177087903022766,
-0.22146084904670715,
-0.20796294510364532,
0.13993953168392181,
-0.38211020827293396,
-0.3210355043411255,
0.21903038024902344,
-0.3789604902267456,
0.2233399599790573,
-0.15128718316555023,
0.5102819800376892,
-0.22192899882793427,
-0.2972472608089447,
0.17591094970703125,
0.16073369979858398,
0.942605197429657,
-0.7300133109092712,
-0.2147725522518158,
-0.14596639573574066,
-0.17177924513816833,
-0.47608810663223267,
-1.1506367921829224,
0.3242512047290802,
-0.48837918043136597,
-0.5037744045257568,
-0.3023999035358429,
0.21396052837371826,
-0.6169206500053406,
-0.4689185619354248,
-0.10258246958255768,
-0.04841335117816925,
0.46649739146232605,
-0.03219611197710037,
-0.7779287695884705,
0.19333811104297638,
-0.006201834883540869,
-0.1336965709924698,
0.3573523163795471,
0.2734347879886627,
-0.1097923144698143,
0.7220130562782288,
0.8677237629890442,
0.5530797839164734,
0.04430191591382027,
0.35258597135543823,
0.8212860822677612,
-0.4098466634750366,
-0.5653409957885742,
-0.23364412784576416,
0.491678923368454,
0.11043034493923187,
0.05328904837369919,
0.239750936627388,
0.5127659440040588,
0.47218871116638184,
-0.5881384611129761,
0.7540314197540283,
-0.24288634955883026,
0.373544305562973,
-0.4951169192790985,
0.5241047739982605,
-0.3083510994911194,
0.3158157169818878,
-0.06589066982269287,
-0.7484936118125916,
-0.5231308341026306,
0.6821432709693909,
-0.4656897783279419,
0.0041879271157085896,
0.5055127143859863,
1.531496524810791,
-0.23595722019672394,
-0.16541287302970886,
0.23536226153373718,
0.08671616017818451,
0.23195847868919373,
0.38643887639045715,
0.877345621585846,
-0.6076555252075195,
0.4375118911266327,
0.03978631645441055,
-0.3255577087402344,
0.15954744815826416,
-0.9624449610710144,
-0.3268369436264038,
-1.020236849784851,
-1.0438989400863647,
-0.428573876619339,
0.06334178149700165,
0.43920254707336426,
0.8214396834373474,
-1.0216623544692993,
0.0987122431397438,
-0.41274264454841614,
0.11338208615779877,
-0.5626215934753418,
-0.3585646450519562,
0.2048027664422989,
-0.03762146458029747,
-0.3986011743545532,
0.03229209780693054,
0.1971769630908966,
0.25615525245666504,
-0.6412182450294495,
-0.319987028837204,
-0.06524099409580231,
-0.17054075002670288,
0.23455345630645752,
0.4145199954509735,
-0.9205296635627747,
-0.0989094078540802,
-0.4398277997970581,
0.04179315268993378,
0.10105271637439728,
0.876315176486969,
-0.7213624119758606,
0.4306875765323639,
0.6057631373405457,
0.22094017267227173,
0.8014686107635498,
0.06331924349069595,
0.0468168631196022,
-0.5826151967048645,
0.11260119080543518,
-0.09634248167276382,
0.1695866584777832,
0.54153972864151,
-0.41966712474823,
0.3446901738643646,
0.6347262859344482,
-0.6303234696388245,
-0.5971914529800415,
0.17329034209251404,
-1.3522393703460693,
-0.27566593885421753,
1.3237899541854858,
0.03201422840356827,
-0.14825937151908875,
-0.18039005994796753,
-0.4332536458969116,
-0.021447263658046722,
-0.5701016187667847,
0.7034324407577515,
0.3463329076766968,
0.1393832266330719,
-0.9332810640335083,
-0.2948165237903595,
0.3085939586162567,
0.13870248198509216,
-0.4553035795688629,
0.310567170381546,
0.6426830291748047,
0.9630632400512695,
0.03897808492183685,
0.48200860619544983,
-0.44241923093795776,
0.28110530972480774,
0.021376825869083405,
0.3612513542175293,
-0.20780456066131592,
-0.2638569176197052,
-0.28420132398605347,
0.10546214133501053,
-0.023907676339149475,
-0.2775474190711975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12856v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12856v2
|
LLM Processes: Numerical Predictive Distributions Conditioned on Natural Language
| 2024-05-21T15:13:12 | 2024-05-25T22:07:48 |
James Requeima, John Bronskill, Dami Choi, Richard E. Turner, David Duvenaud
|
stat.ML
|
stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Machine learning practitioners often face significant challenges in formally
integrating their prior knowledge and beliefs into predictive models, limiting
the potential for nuanced and context-aware analyses. Moreover, the expertise
needed to integrate this prior knowledge into probabilistic modeling typically
limits the application of these models to specialists. Our goal is to build a
regression model that can process numerical data and make probabilistic
predictions at arbitrary locations, guided by natural language text which
describes a user's prior knowledge. Large Language Models (LLMs) provide a
useful starting point for designing such a tool since they 1) provide an
interface where users can incorporate expert insights in natural language and
2) provide an opportunity for leveraging latent problem-relevant knowledge
encoded in LLMs that users may not have themselves. We start by exploring
strategies for eliciting explicit, coherent numerical predictive distributions
from LLMs. We examine these joint predictive distributions, which we call LLM
Processes, over arbitrarily-many quantities in settings such as forecasting,
multi-dimensional regression, black-box optimization, and image modeling. We
investigate the practical details of prompting to elicit coherent predictive
distributions, and demonstrate their effectiveness at regression. Finally, we
demonstrate the ability to usefully incorporate text into numerical
predictions, improving predictive performance and giving quantitative structure
that reflects qualitative descriptions. This lets us begin to explore the rich,
grounded hypothesis space that LLMs implicitly encode.
|
[
-0.4304153621196747,
-0.9376294016838074,
0.9585297703742981,
0.2556959390640259,
-0.19113382697105408,
-0.018881402909755707,
-0.37158480286598206,
-0.4150891900062561,
-0.014145907014608383,
0.8923715353012085,
-0.5569660663604736,
-0.47765207290649414,
-0.5829881429672241,
-0.0017091850750148296,
-0.3942995071411133,
0.9584468007087708,
-0.22930628061294556,
0.2090207040309906,
-0.2928144037723541,
0.3267052471637726,
-0.1465146690607071,
-0.7531819939613342,
-0.6065129637718201,
-0.5196608901023865,
0.5272694826126099,
-0.028054147958755493,
0.8680582046508789,
0.5030317306518555,
0.5033292770385742,
0.2715303897857666,
0.06829430907964706,
0.11824625730514526,
-0.42741596698760986,
0.4718056917190552,
0.06772160530090332,
-0.509044349193573,
-0.15373669564723969,
-0.13727468252182007,
0.6994325518608093,
0.8479105234146118,
-0.24526098370552063,
0.028945164754986763,
0.11668030917644501,
0.41674739122390747,
-0.4937732219696045,
0.4970898926258087,
-0.6719836592674255,
0.05874408781528473,
0.011717401444911957,
-0.1906723827123642,
-0.4518483877182007,
-0.3400934934616089,
0.1004951223731041,
-0.3774581849575043,
0.1288709044456482,
-0.1547665297985077,
0.21810251474380493,
0.402415007352829,
-0.20411238074302673,
-0.26369109749794006,
-0.9316449165344238,
0.9317325949668884,
-0.6407106518745422,
0.29453837871551514,
0.6523609757423401,
0.36210116744041443,
-0.45808613300323486,
-0.6825242638587952,
-0.3283432126045227,
-0.33829745650291443,
0.10729779303073883,
-0.015024719759821892,
-0.07861162722110748,
0.21252918243408203,
0.2965734601020813,
-0.03739014267921448,
-0.3579563498497009,
0.13661018013954163,
-0.18709561228752136,
0.015649961307644844,
0.8883626461029053,
0.3205336928367615,
-0.14920316636562347,
0.05398770794272423,
-0.2428368479013443,
0.08217242360115051,
-0.44682854413986206,
-0.21814388036727905,
0.34136420488357544,
0.49313896894454956,
-0.22187988460063934,
0.65556800365448,
-0.10140401124954224,
0.5825821757316589,
-0.3336847126483917,
-0.3942970633506775,
-0.028982488438487053,
-0.0873136818408966,
-0.3840365409851074,
-0.14718984067440033,
0.8770616054534912,
-0.03501724824309349,
0.47894740104675293,
-0.11227645725011826,
-0.4375993609428406,
-0.07967591285705566,
0.1535702496767044,
-0.7871682047843933,
-0.2922479212284088,
0.22748105227947235,
-0.27542614936828613,
-0.23404641449451447,
-0.2075778841972351,
-0.600936233997345,
-0.38449153304100037,
-0.7472212314605713,
0.17186442017555237,
-0.36097252368927,
-0.15456996858119965,
0.20706507563591003,
-0.05595463886857033,
-0.25789695978164673,
0.47450172901153564,
-1.0040053129196167,
0.4347415864467621,
0.7150707840919495,
0.6195433139801025,
-0.062338780611753464,
-0.02517537772655487,
-0.2182273417711258,
0.27345380187034607,
-0.3507773280143738,
0.7696900963783264,
-0.705594539642334,
-0.29048848152160645,
0.3670693635940552,
-0.22570189833641052,
0.014277635142207146,
-0.6159948706626892,
0.3842823803424835,
-0.6318870186805725,
-0.07026776671409607,
0.07081706821918488,
-0.6137474775314331,
-0.20457367599010468,
0.04936233162879944,
-0.5751326680183411,
0.8730055093765259,
-0.048166219145059586,
-0.7900813221931458,
0.21305522322654724,
-0.5144095420837402,
-0.35068926215171814,
0.04505322128534317,
-0.1177600622177124,
-0.24235181510448456,
0.32025572657585144,
0.1720605194568634,
0.9547086358070374,
-0.4590194523334503,
0.6035894751548767,
-0.6470685601234436,
-0.05041655898094177,
0.43777740001678467,
-0.6575929522514343,
0.38127464056015015,
0.4257516860961914,
0.1274665892124176,
0.05439578741788864,
-0.6344172358512878,
-0.09407198429107666,
-0.07197489589452744,
-0.14245197176933289,
-0.22593475878238678,
0.18428726494312286,
0.07014703005552292,
0.017367711290717125,
0.2621946334838867,
0.0516546368598938,
0.31581228971481323,
-0.34216785430908203,
0.33704009652137756,
0.637773334980011,
0.19350160658359528,
0.699978232383728,
-0.07819966971874237,
0.7145074605941772,
-0.06830358505249023,
-0.045044366270303726,
-0.3164069950580597,
-0.568309485912323,
-0.3245525658130646,
-0.26978400349617004,
-0.04223135858774185,
0.6646412014961243,
-0.8654490113258362,
0.005563502199947834,
0.12785126268863678,
-0.40255430340766907,
-0.1594829261302948,
0.3345162570476532,
0.04742235690355301,
0.3837345838546753,
0.08061253279447556,
0.2757677137851715,
-0.7783424258232117,
-0.7813876867294312,
0.061375975608825684,
-0.2587580680847168,
-0.241722971200943,
0.10142052918672562,
0.5016487240791321,
-0.32789117097854614,
0.8059102892875671,
-0.8347602486610413,
0.02769293077290058,
-0.17524665594100952,
0.4647330045700073,
0.47941067814826965,
0.09223654866218567,
0.22330307960510254,
-0.8083732724189758,
-0.28951892256736755,
0.014422127977013588,
-1.058769941329956,
-0.10353090614080429,
-0.2031271904706955,
-0.03590109199285507,
0.2991252839565277,
0.6384180784225464,
-0.5952380895614624,
0.29964539408683777,
0.5897864103317261,
-0.029779409989714622,
0.6686136722564697,
-0.4081873297691345,
-0.16391360759735107,
-1.100685954093933,
-0.30076614022254944,
0.5000126957893372,
-0.16698119044303894,
-0.6184547543525696,
-0.10297530144453049,
-0.2444380521774292,
-0.0699569582939148,
-0.38826531171798706,
0.6771371364593506,
-0.36287984251976013,
-0.24636085331439972,
-0.22369764745235443,
-0.24642837047576904,
-0.3254641592502594,
0.15415333211421967,
0.4851002097129822,
0.7117885947227478,
0.5660367608070374,
-0.6675240397453308,
0.20011477172374725,
-0.041112009435892105,
-0.34197619557380676,
0.326860249042511,
-0.5542758107185364,
-0.2305954396724701,
-0.32296448945999146,
0.1628885269165039,
-1.0276318788528442,
-0.4274381399154663,
0.0645957663655281,
-0.3835633397102356,
0.25902673602104187,
-0.26842984557151794,
-0.7617100477218628,
-0.38465359807014465,
0.03146432340145111,
0.1693805307149887,
0.6552320718765259,
-0.13218417763710022,
0.476228803396225,
0.45833420753479004,
-0.4724656343460083,
-0.4358941614627838,
-0.7316859364509583,
0.07034235447645187,
-0.35188719630241394,
-0.6445184946060181,
0.21524904668331146,
-0.13204562664031982,
-0.6213556528091431,
-0.0806402862071991,
0.4278157949447632,
-0.3432464301586151,
0.22140194475650787,
0.3263099789619446,
0.38998040556907654,
-0.30521872639656067,
0.29929471015930176,
-0.006300054956227541,
-0.10746975243091583,
0.3487226963043213,
-0.4981589913368225,
0.3710482716560364,
0.19904926419258118,
-0.2658189535140991,
-0.2986688017845154,
0.2093908190727234,
0.48302528262138367,
0.18095357716083527,
0.9153537750244141,
0.7687361240386963,
-0.696597158908844,
-0.27630841732025146,
-0.5340905785560608,
-0.3436740040779114,
-0.4288778007030487,
0.3305814266204834,
-0.37376171350479126,
-0.8901064991950989,
0.6861408352851868,
-0.11145392060279846,
-0.043745171278715134,
0.1898406594991684,
0.7660219669342041,
-0.3391816020011902,
1.3227978944778442,
0.7425669431686401,
0.06077631562948227,
0.461381733417511,
-0.3009779751300812,
0.26738956570625305,
-0.5104796290397644,
-0.25585976243019104,
-0.48693495988845825,
0.04522917419672012,
-0.4880129098892212,
-0.867455005645752,
0.2308853417634964,
0.3184753358364105,
-0.31205740571022034,
-0.06855703145265579,
-0.2544160485267639,
0.4100194275379181,
0.3065328299999237,
-0.14065130054950714,
0.05438605323433876,
0.3623858392238617,
-0.18134070932865143,
-0.2548668086528778,
-0.5348336696624756,
-0.7877758145332336,
0.9285561442375183,
0.5890588164329529,
1.1906087398529053,
-0.2744097113609314,
0.7566784024238586,
0.35609787702560425,
0.6392151713371277,
-0.7285783290863037,
0.47387611865997314,
-0.2054787129163742,
-0.29846709966659546,
-0.29956233501434326,
-0.39117223024368286,
-0.9038892984390259,
0.052242714911699295,
-0.3080209791660309,
-0.7931706309318542,
-0.18463745713233948,
0.09879235923290253,
-0.20311404764652252,
0.5095893144607544,
-0.596703290939331,
0.5019147396087646,
-0.19390958547592163,
-0.4951757788658142,
-0.09426736831665039,
-0.32902780175209045,
0.5405523180961609,
-0.3885171413421631,
0.531204879283905,
-0.14274324476718903,
-0.1590590626001358,
0.5028437972068787,
-0.22917987406253815,
1.11916184425354,
-0.24009552597999573,
-0.22681476175785065,
0.4063553810119629,
0.13719582557678223,
0.4790993928909302,
0.18692250549793243,
-0.45936426520347595,
0.031192410737276077,
-0.09423085302114487,
-0.20584338903427124,
-0.6272993087768555,
0.5567600727081299,
-0.8682680130004883,
-0.4977377653121948,
-0.2328767627477646,
-0.7022099494934082,
-0.25157395005226135,
-0.06016026809811592,
0.10588015615940094,
0.17043694853782654,
-0.08310092985630035,
-0.07367846369743347,
0.7486523389816284,
-0.18190117180347443,
0.39648860692977905,
0.16341741383075714,
-0.41512197256088257,
-0.6415473222732544,
0.6143174171447754,
0.09576696902513504,
0.1305772364139557,
0.5558607578277588,
0.24190852046012878,
-0.7170758843421936,
-0.8958126902580261,
-0.09339696913957596,
0.32470160722732544,
-0.7477279305458069,
-0.19640174508094788,
-0.6662458181381226,
-0.21529097855091095,
-0.5284852385520935,
-0.40389564633369446,
0.008718017488718033,
-0.20953677594661713,
-0.6374543309211731,
-0.13100315630435944,
0.48217496275901794,
1.0479401350021362,
-0.02051565982401371,
0.5019299387931824,
-0.8377548456192017,
0.339521199464798,
0.08214475959539413,
0.15066608786582947,
-0.008373353630304337,
-0.4582756757736206,
-0.295747846364975,
0.14838480949401855,
-0.16355237364768982,
-0.7479752898216248,
0.9997358918190002,
-0.07224200665950775,
0.7211565375328064,
0.36929836869239807,
-0.006495380774140358,
0.6207116842269897,
-0.39985358715057373,
0.6454992890357971,
0.28494030237197876,
-0.5884295105934143,
0.48822101950645447,
-0.624565839767456,
0.16623401641845703,
0.28680890798568726,
0.7424263954162598,
-0.277923583984375,
-0.4729638993740082,
-0.4663865268230438,
-0.7410985231399536,
0.4879908859729767,
-0.05476171150803566,
0.21249638497829437,
-0.2710181772708893,
0.4732867181301117,
0.20636923611164093,
0.4125199317932129,
-0.6202025413513184,
-0.026820972561836243,
0.15334399044513702,
-0.3508968949317932,
-0.4002869725227356,
-0.4868265986442566,
0.027501821517944336,
-0.13241174817085266,
0.4354984164237976,
-0.35566818714141846,
0.18048527836799622,
-0.037311188876628876,
0.017814576625823975,
-0.03239332512021065,
0.014755606651306152,
0.6169639229774475,
0.5767648220062256,
-0.2158457338809967,
0.20790177583694458,
0.18640801310539246,
-0.23987199366092682,
0.11290718615055084,
0.10743431001901627,
-0.07334057986736298,
-0.10844585299491882,
0.44895362854003906,
0.7642213106155396,
0.4660532772541046,
-0.5463066101074219,
0.037778500467538834,
-0.10436257719993591,
-0.35676664113998413,
-0.7088874578475952,
-0.09103258699178696,
0.458659827709198,
0.4322226345539093,
0.5513321161270142,
0.06903546303510666,
0.19119909405708313,
-0.45506569743156433,
0.24412551522254944,
0.4270753264427185,
-0.28365394473075867,
-0.3401658833026886,
0.7215147018432617,
-0.09884434193372726,
-0.2920762896537781,
0.6127638220787048,
-0.21063677966594696,
-0.3364536762237549,
0.6616349816322327,
0.6900918483734131,
0.9073718786239624,
0.0382770299911499,
0.3147769272327423,
0.40447741746902466,
0.006387604866176844,
-0.41067901253700256,
0.3708055317401886,
0.07216615229845047,
-0.6474024057388306,
-0.8185411095619202,
-1.020218849182129,
-0.36221060156822205,
-0.053426824510097504,
-0.5083215832710266,
0.3760872483253479,
-0.598851203918457,
-0.40548503398895264,
0.14877383410930634,
-0.15752632915973663,
-0.7212284803390503,
0.1402781754732132,
0.6899036169052124,
0.8459174633026123,
-1.0597054958343506,
0.7237496972084045,
0.6645075678825378,
-0.2826511561870575,
-0.5438043475151062,
-0.2373100072145462,
-0.05405275151133537,
-0.8344115018844604,
0.9654638171195984,
-0.063105508685112,
0.16498297452926636,
-0.2577769160270691,
-0.6273675560951233,
-0.8957090377807617,
0.7338629961013794,
0.5665901303291321,
-0.44359689950942993,
0.032975487411022186,
0.29253140091896057,
0.6334596276283264,
-0.42544326186180115,
0.330387145280838,
0.3926244378089905,
0.5461716651916504,
0.44413018226623535,
-0.6052079796791077,
-0.14032702147960663,
0.20288211107254028,
0.08803698420524597,
0.3176307678222656,
-0.06789030134677887,
0.8232434391975403,
-0.4664578437805176,
-0.057903390377759933,
0.10285723209381104,
0.7972812652587891,
0.5029063820838928,
0.5056384801864624,
0.07195223867893219,
0.5041665434837341,
0.9017799496650696,
-0.03700656071305275,
1.2976425886154175,
-0.12034720927476883,
0.18222080171108246,
0.9761536717414856,
-0.3022729456424713,
1.213984727859497,
0.5180392861366272,
-0.5301696062088013,
0.444312185049057,
0.6848016381263733,
0.07069257646799088,
0.37651151418685913,
0.35718095302581787,
-0.5681765079498291,
-0.34505125880241394,
-0.21744577586650848,
-0.0632757917046547,
0.07393203675746918,
0.7228870987892151,
-0.3961762487888336,
-0.10581815242767334,
-0.037303972989320755,
-0.14142481982707977,
0.2641783356666565,
-0.42054814100265503,
0.7389034032821655,
0.40889832377433777,
-0.668701708316803,
0.48170962929725647,
-0.1034792810678482,
0.7012110352516174,
-0.6640675067901611,
-0.12105528265237808,
0.02680252492427826,
0.0652756616473198,
-0.25869157910346985,
-1.2258703708648682,
0.4225693643093109,
-0.11207487434148788,
-0.3825054466724396,
-0.5585934519767761,
0.8412899971008301,
-0.46191301941871643,
-0.9552281498908997,
0.2882155478000641,
0.5135559439659119,
0.3735979199409485,
-0.17829099297523499,
-0.634736180305481,
0.07043176889419556,
-0.013668237254023552,
-0.22233763337135315,
0.45057982206344604,
0.6620584726333618,
-0.18549387156963348,
0.8850286602973938,
0.8644425272941589,
0.2655409276485443,
0.044055890291929245,
0.4595942199230194,
0.5668522119522095,
-0.7076234817504883,
-0.30299484729766846,
-0.9962125420570374,
0.3974991738796234,
0.24956396222114563,
0.15013952553272247,
0.5175202488899231,
0.3175283968448639,
0.4419408440589905,
-0.18787668645381927,
0.9678179621696472,
0.49391865730285645,
0.23172447085380554,
-0.7019726037979126,
0.39970406889915466,
-0.29894399642944336,
0.23909178376197815,
-0.09510017186403275,
-0.9028531312942505,
-0.5414133667945862,
0.5650139451026917,
-0.49544140696525574,
0.047306712716817856,
0.43208587169647217,
0.49132972955703735,
0.18965479731559753,
0.0033999094739556313,
0.5570386052131653,
0.11647993326187134,
0.34491437673568726,
0.41118907928466797,
1.0122432708740234,
0.0327305793762207,
0.20691068470478058,
-0.2401629537343979,
0.007540190126746893,
-0.3221239745616913,
-1.1072384119033813,
-0.8571584224700928,
-0.48159441351890564,
-0.3337845504283905,
-0.16339148581027985,
-0.12115714699029922,
0.8431769013404846,
0.83599454164505,
-0.5834869742393494,
-0.38516494631767273,
-0.21796812117099762,
0.17959105968475342,
0.20589473843574524,
-0.23360517621040344,
-0.010704726912081242,
-0.5130059123039246,
-0.6892266273498535,
0.15295279026031494,
0.2845945656299591,
0.48399949073791504,
-0.5059379935264587,
-0.12348725646734238,
0.23366405069828033,
-0.019907528534531593,
0.7972519397735596,
0.14237937331199646,
-0.7338833212852478,
0.08305653184652328,
0.07584622502326965,
-0.009841468185186386,
-0.2639470100402832,
0.7226682901382446,
-0.886151909828186,
0.17910601198673248,
0.6577572822570801,
0.6407802104949951,
0.6395681500434875,
-0.1781802773475647,
0.9348559975624084,
-0.607758104801178,
0.2414509803056717,
0.4122307598590851,
0.4807957410812378,
0.3600914776325226,
-0.38211679458618164,
0.483233779668808,
-0.0780182033777237,
-0.5639775395393372,
-0.9003916382789612,
0.11843675374984741,
-0.761599063873291,
-0.33803263306617737,
1.2326362133026123,
0.019717754796147346,
-0.3163866102695465,
-0.13121441006660461,
-0.08928544074296951,
0.0976477637887001,
-0.3687780797481537,
0.4940911829471588,
0.7279999852180481,
-0.2887989580631256,
-0.221962571144104,
-0.932142436504364,
0.40552452206611633,
0.03575720638036728,
-0.8052332401275635,
0.2948667109012604,
0.4236532747745514,
0.15010643005371094,
-0.06422138214111328,
0.4822656214237213,
0.02843627892434597,
-0.13646429777145386,
0.02587321773171425,
0.029187366366386414,
0.19635067880153656,
-0.29696524143218994,
-0.4368019700050354,
0.32411038875579834,
0.32329896092414856,
0.42466920614242554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12819v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12819v1
|
Large Language Models Meet NLP: A Survey
| 2024-05-21T14:24:01 | 2024-05-21T14:24:01 |
Libo Qin, Qiguang Chen, Xiachong Feng, Yang Wu, Yongheng Zhang, Yinghui Li, Min Li, Wanxiang Che, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT have shown impressive
capabilities in Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, a systematic
investigation of their potential in this field remains largely unexplored. This
study aims to address this gap by exploring the following questions: (1) How
are LLMs currently applied to NLP tasks in the literature? (2) Have traditional
NLP tasks already been solved with LLMs? (3) What is the future of the LLMs for
NLP? To answer these questions, we take the first step to provide a
comprehensive overview of LLMs in NLP. Specifically, we first introduce a
unified taxonomy including (1) parameter-frozen application and (2)
parameter-tuning application to offer a unified perspective for understanding
the current progress of LLMs in NLP. Furthermore, we summarize the new
frontiers and the associated challenges, aiming to inspire further
groundbreaking advancements. We hope this work offers valuable insights into
the {potential and limitations} of LLMs in NLP, while also serving as a
practical guide for building effective LLMs in NLP.
|
[
-0.5564202070236206,
-0.7920374870300293,
0.6213548183441162,
0.23424622416496277,
-0.30741816759109497,
0.2146308571100235,
-0.5376551747322083,
-0.5862550139427185,
0.13719667494297028,
0.7987810969352722,
-0.6670861840248108,
-0.4921591579914093,
-0.838371992111206,
0.14593876898288727,
-0.5669909119606018,
0.8496782779693604,
0.09022314101457596,
-0.15610429644584656,
0.015091856010258198,
0.12138699740171432,
-0.5704405903816223,
-0.674180269241333,
-0.8295758962631226,
-0.47063252329826355,
0.6535339951515198,
0.27006959915161133,
0.7936879396438599,
0.47316601872444153,
0.6000451445579529,
0.3227041959762573,
-0.5082980990409851,
0.15694069862365723,
-0.4186691641807556,
0.5119998455047607,
0.0353207029402256,
-0.5238690972328186,
-0.5129684805870056,
0.01363100204616785,
0.9100990295410156,
0.9988502860069275,
-0.2286273092031479,
0.08898225426673889,
0.049365997314453125,
0.48062509298324585,
-0.2711823582649231,
0.27360084652900696,
-0.9128888249397278,
0.14117370545864105,
-0.31071335077285767,
-0.3915611207485199,
-0.3456742465496063,
0.09147503226995468,
0.16604331135749817,
-0.1469847410917282,
0.04336295649409294,
0.37062492966651917,
0.5069987177848816,
0.18874436616897583,
-0.5841920971870422,
-0.42411696910858154,
-0.8309229016304016,
0.966320812702179,
-0.985764741897583,
0.4586195647716522,
0.13715802133083344,
0.15440668165683746,
-0.6358886361122131,
-0.8249489665031433,
-0.3536556363105774,
-0.27433356642723083,
0.12483617663383484,
-0.16695347428321838,
-0.15366540849208832,
0.13304924964904785,
0.2063302993774414,
0.4634159803390503,
-0.7315493226051331,
0.6430054903030396,
-0.07235101610422134,
0.1494618058204651,
0.6033608317375183,
0.43134167790412903,
0.34440675377845764,
-0.06448151171207428,
-0.24521249532699585,
0.3266274333000183,
-0.6248819231987,
-0.3559599816799164,
-0.10378001630306244,
0.4571070373058319,
-0.028117110952734947,
0.6955050230026245,
-0.08765970915555954,
0.9331720471382141,
-0.4747961759567261,
-0.03315844014286995,
-0.2017461359500885,
-0.09373242408037186,
-0.26648232340812683,
-0.2250158190727234,
0.9738591313362122,
0.3472259044647217,
0.2931705117225647,
-0.23994982242584229,
-0.07672584056854248,
-0.46744802594184875,
-0.045361872762441635,
-0.5527338981628418,
0.04236358404159546,
0.28666383028030396,
-0.2768062353134155,
-0.1299014538526535,
-0.45839723944664,
-0.932904064655304,
-0.537193238735199,
-0.48129668831825256,
-0.02487206645309925,
-0.0673205628991127,
-0.4540359675884247,
0.40703558921813965,
0.10207517445087433,
0.541695237159729,
0.4430932402610779,
-1.1395426988601685,
0.389602392911911,
1.0644997358322144,
0.9530340433120728,
-0.27789175510406494,
-0.2071906477212906,
-0.3964991271495819,
0.04724963754415512,
-0.42994990944862366,
0.8033090829849243,
-0.5073571801185608,
-0.20035585761070251,
0.3543267846107483,
-0.1285312920808792,
0.03829829394817352,
-0.43738898634910583,
0.6040205359458923,
-0.6839123368263245,
0.235494926571846,
-0.1854608654975891,
-0.7669709920883179,
-0.11829394102096558,
0.5538884997367859,
-0.6042805314064026,
0.8887894749641418,
-0.3501199185848236,
-0.7417436242103577,
0.13714037835597992,
-0.6158130168914795,
-0.15378794074058533,
0.28208354115486145,
0.10850993543863297,
-0.06403931975364685,
0.1780209243297577,
0.17416724562644958,
0.8039183616638184,
-0.7520020604133606,
0.3650263249874115,
-0.15207375586032867,
-0.20669330656528473,
0.3036133348941803,
-0.5662112832069397,
0.6744638681411743,
0.17386475205421448,
0.20193691551685333,
0.14682132005691528,
-0.49713391065597534,
0.16842076182365417,
0.11456581950187683,
-0.45058971643447876,
-0.017298541963100433,
0.3119817078113556,
0.24353057146072388,
0.19398589432239532,
0.36928871273994446,
-0.3134883940219879,
0.45087242126464844,
-0.44543659687042236,
0.7365671396255493,
0.6259838938713074,
-0.1847371906042099,
0.30276796221733093,
-0.024224761873483658,
0.717790424823761,
-0.5838505625724792,
0.0027265388052910566,
-0.3030286133289337,
-0.6173279881477356,
-0.8009822368621826,
-0.04472819343209267,
0.520980715751648,
0.4038192629814148,
-0.384780615568161,
0.48614397644996643,
-0.14307601749897003,
-0.48663416504859924,
-0.09394878894090652,
0.13786830008029938,
-0.03057863377034664,
0.07234705984592438,
0.26020339131355286,
0.051336366683244705,
-0.6430341005325317,
-0.7170654535293579,
-0.26120564341545105,
-0.1202988252043724,
-0.2048320323228836,
0.06375167518854141,
0.34767642617225647,
-0.14669716358184814,
0.7521112561225891,
-0.47424089908599854,
-0.2797449827194214,
-0.6899317502975464,
0.0289410762488842,
0.48056212067604065,
0.18484832346439362,
0.1592121422290802,
-0.8225415349006653,
-0.5334100127220154,
-0.043211422860622406,
-0.6238532066345215,
-0.05576401203870773,
0.03533835709095001,
0.23979099094867706,
0.11394857615232468,
0.9842733144760132,
-0.9577181935310364,
-0.14811904728412628,
0.9494112133979797,
-0.010235587134957314,
0.5186807513237,
-0.16368776559829712,
-0.20316137373447418,
-1.151166319847107,
-0.17464137077331543,
0.008345982059836388,
-0.32834991812705994,
-0.8665074110031128,
0.2179691195487976,
-0.23281057178974152,
-0.1507520228624344,
-0.40860748291015625,
0.7403144836425781,
-0.5986801385879517,
-0.07841096818447113,
-0.4046245515346527,
0.3550545275211334,
-0.45250824093818665,
0.29157236218452454,
-0.023772619664669037,
0.4404480457305908,
0.8150420188903809,
-0.4295334815979004,
0.46927231550216675,
0.0942675769329071,
-0.2811228632926941,
0.146208718419075,
-0.765931248664856,
0.18668706715106964,
-0.10790005326271057,
0.4222964644432068,
-0.8964350819587708,
-0.27018147706985474,
0.07391087710857391,
-0.4022866487503052,
0.41111570596694946,
-0.35312017798423767,
-0.9074692726135254,
-0.4294421374797821,
-0.06759446859359741,
0.16011765599250793,
0.6095941066741943,
-0.38827234506607056,
0.6243543028831482,
0.4917030930519104,
-0.37557151913642883,
-0.5001592636108398,
-0.564903199672699,
0.6277451515197754,
-0.30645638704299927,
-0.5379963517189026,
0.13596111536026,
-0.005479839164763689,
-0.34397006034851074,
-0.2331412434577942,
0.09896786510944366,
-0.03916781768202782,
0.06852025538682938,
0.04561609402298927,
0.14174963533878326,
-0.3584016263484955,
0.2505543828010559,
-0.3236529231071472,
-0.17471717298030853,
0.10642565786838531,
-0.22823768854141235,
0.9902763366699219,
-0.2469562143087387,
-0.30267050862312317,
-0.26233169436454773,
0.41985780000686646,
0.42374464869499207,
-0.3821660578250885,
0.7209258079528809,
0.5081785321235657,
-0.40303170680999756,
-0.22474129498004913,
-0.6751074194908142,
0.1640048325061798,
-0.49936240911483765,
0.6276209950447083,
-0.11754016578197479,
-1.358265995979309,
0.5401528477668762,
-0.3308112621307373,
0.4106081426143646,
0.37176942825317383,
0.9090569019317627,
-0.08611944317817688,
1.0458236932754517,
0.87496018409729,
-0.1449236273765564,
0.3104451298713684,
0.042361848056316376,
0.46489766240119934,
-0.9583198428153992,
-0.11335613578557968,
-0.6629151105880737,
-0.21212166547775269,
-0.8003843426704407,
-0.44892239570617676,
0.18234974145889282,
0.2799314856529236,
-0.020830845460295677,
0.2616441249847412,
-0.19088175892829895,
0.4935424327850342,
0.35000455379486084,
-0.4121764898300171,
0.4862861633300781,
-0.30662909150123596,
0.22676178812980652,
0.018336275592446327,
-0.8044363260269165,
-0.5835904479026794,
0.9470221400260925,
0.5274519920349121,
0.6873278617858887,
-0.007523573003709316,
0.4763830006122589,
-0.024842381477355957,
0.085201196372509,
-0.9347785711288452,
0.8454596400260925,
-0.24150508642196655,
-0.7139922380447388,
-0.5413222908973694,
-0.22679302096366882,
-1.1725540161132812,
0.5130592584609985,
-0.23312094807624817,
-0.9961749315261841,
-0.4027283787727356,
0.08738771080970764,
-0.017180124297738075,
0.5096479058265686,
-0.422160804271698,
0.7357297539710999,
-0.295034259557724,
0.022466925904154778,
-0.08557458966970444,
-0.5981782674789429,
0.4018203318119049,
-0.1831296980381012,
0.3020123541355133,
-0.5050004124641418,
-0.2014288455247879,
0.6736282110214233,
-0.2105664610862732,
0.7972162365913391,
0.09959620982408524,
-0.3785407841205597,
0.18106608092784882,
-0.10797115415334702,
0.49987107515335083,
0.0703151747584343,
-0.1265936940908432,
0.28119054436683655,
0.1031159982085228,
-0.15220916271209717,
-0.5335120558738708,
0.7311201095581055,
-0.1936197429895401,
-0.7163437008857727,
-0.5421041250228882,
-0.8448910713195801,
-0.554633617401123,
0.27692848443984985,
-0.061044104397296906,
0.1207880824804306,
-0.10910405218601227,
0.331344872713089,
0.7404469847679138,
-0.43694764375686646,
0.6565366387367249,
0.5621615052223206,
-0.7122637629508972,
0.016014082357287407,
0.5270442366600037,
-0.08661384135484695,
0.29358795285224915,
0.5864356756210327,
0.2197052240371704,
-0.2719570994377136,
-0.988696813583374,
-0.20797057449817657,
0.35624125599861145,
-0.618861734867096,
-0.017041832208633423,
-0.5967552661895752,
-0.40276268124580383,
-0.2801850736141205,
-0.061600808054208755,
-0.40448883175849915,
-0.020527062937617302,
-0.3400234282016754,
0.25633057951927185,
0.3968472480773926,
0.7676355242729187,
0.1804012507200241,
0.360702246427536,
-0.8037481307983398,
0.28984367847442627,
0.3125457465648651,
0.42839181423187256,
-0.007242240943014622,
-0.5630879402160645,
-0.025277666747570038,
0.05710868537425995,
0.08947274088859558,
-0.47447365522384644,
0.5658653378486633,
0.14642925560474396,
0.4817146062850952,
0.10161539912223816,
-0.11480105668306351,
0.40598708391189575,
-0.8404871225357056,
0.93443363904953,
0.2338123619556427,
-0.6472114324569702,
0.29907312989234924,
-0.6289673447608948,
0.45867297053337097,
0.17956891655921936,
0.43856367468833923,
-1.0425976514816284,
-0.45032578706741333,
-0.29841554164886475,
-1.0182734727859497,
0.49777787923812866,
0.08027010411024094,
0.5667750835418701,
0.09001433104276657,
0.31715959310531616,
-0.05929676070809364,
0.13515184819698334,
-0.7089425325393677,
-0.19840911030769348,
0.52308189868927,
-0.025710755959153175,
-0.3581431806087494,
-0.3587932288646698,
0.17254352569580078,
-0.006278890650719404,
0.40004345774650574,
-0.027518482878804207,
0.15810588002204895,
-0.43870922923088074,
0.16051824390888214,
-0.07319504767656326,
0.471256285905838,
0.37751081585884094,
0.7302992939949036,
-0.19594117999076843,
0.05434576794505119,
0.31582772731781006,
-0.21588924527168274,
-0.17956914007663727,
-0.02393234707415104,
-0.04952235519886017,
0.029554272070527077,
0.5341829061508179,
0.6945691108703613,
0.25755584239959717,
-0.8832337856292725,
0.39804983139038086,
-0.11244402080774307,
-0.25674453377723694,
-0.4975087344646454,
0.10497716814279556,
0.5713003873825073,
0.3953388035297394,
0.3427177965641022,
-0.3120380640029907,
-0.10754760354757309,
-0.6500093340873718,
-0.09016934037208557,
0.7452020049095154,
-0.3488900363445282,
-0.044325411319732666,
0.5442960262298584,
-0.11848495900630951,
-0.612262487411499,
0.6093575954437256,
0.08709356188774109,
-0.5197318196296692,
0.46681660413742065,
0.5121892690658569,
0.7310458421707153,
-0.020386677235364914,
-0.016417264938354492,
0.031235987320542336,
0.3153170645236969,
-0.3346945345401764,
0.16737741231918335,
0.23140786588191986,
-0.7195537090301514,
-0.9014264345169067,
-0.8891265392303467,
-0.60395348072052,
0.4538813531398773,
-0.493511438369751,
0.4243508279323578,
-0.3283385634422302,
0.023831764236092567,
0.10476353019475937,
-0.10262367129325867,
-0.483539342880249,
0.14394181966781616,
0.2897997498512268,
0.94001704454422,
-0.4902297556400299,
0.7893027067184448,
0.5046138167381287,
-0.0164271742105484,
-0.6166982054710388,
0.043168436735868454,
-0.010254791006445885,
-0.7805987000465393,
0.4496024549007416,
-0.04133334383368492,
0.14060530066490173,
0.09541244059801102,
-0.6954871416091919,
-1.0259671211242676,
0.7407053709030151,
0.3476194143295288,
-0.6463289260864258,
-0.32507792115211487,
0.4047383666038513,
0.7332732677459717,
0.028224967420101166,
0.0173219982534647,
0.5686982274055481,
0.4092130959033966,
0.16020172834396362,
-1.0211073160171509,
-0.23493333160877228,
-0.07901784777641296,
0.15030857920646667,
0.43466824293136597,
-0.6079613566398621,
0.7800818681716919,
0.059137795120477676,
0.06127843260765076,
0.2812657654285431,
0.6885479688644409,
0.17303098738193512,
-0.16535960137844086,
0.3469713032245636,
0.3593323826789856,
0.4767579436302185,
-0.1599494069814682,
0.9496339559555054,
-0.1736677885055542,
0.41490525007247925,
1.20986008644104,
-0.29237663745880127,
1.1395031213760376,
0.3800847828388214,
-0.45926594734191895,
0.025181330740451813,
0.7605137825012207,
-0.18146547675132751,
0.030960308387875557,
0.46381035447120667,
-0.33299165964126587,
-0.406948059797287,
-0.15695570409297943,
-0.3376540541648865,
0.5520754456520081,
0.5894063711166382,
-0.24192224442958832,
-0.41488343477249146,
0.059543948620557785,
-0.021629050374031067,
-0.1799820363521576,
-0.48391401767730713,
0.7377927899360657,
0.35509517788887024,
-0.5481701493263245,
0.5375622510910034,
0.264218807220459,
0.839909553527832,
-0.7734572887420654,
0.016788046807050705,
-0.05613403022289276,
-0.028035903349518776,
-0.000038805654185125604,
-1.0066787004470825,
0.21655641496181488,
0.08347857743501663,
0.06327109038829803,
-0.35742613673210144,
0.6854058504104614,
-0.34540966153144836,
-0.5687294602394104,
0.36834219098091125,
0.5340027809143066,
0.29940053820610046,
-0.14071589708328247,
-0.5603594779968262,
0.0696931779384613,
-0.2596965730190277,
-0.41655197739601135,
0.5590745210647583,
0.5470191240310669,
0.16340959072113037,
1.0002042055130005,
0.4120193421840668,
0.23910953104496002,
0.3193589448928833,
0.10043010115623474,
0.7140553593635559,
-0.7530390024185181,
-0.09836956113576889,
-0.8971711993217468,
0.321496844291687,
0.22352537512779236,
-0.3883798122406006,
0.7249799966812134,
0.3423108458518982,
0.6067202091217041,
0.12940913438796997,
0.670531690120697,
-0.03712945803999901,
0.693920373916626,
-0.7298402786254883,
0.5788297653198242,
-0.5760480165481567,
0.3163047134876251,
-0.30409765243530273,
-1.0695550441741943,
-0.7034143209457397,
0.21311931312084198,
-0.23417578637599945,
0.04888390004634857,
0.6312617063522339,
0.6875059604644775,
0.11177638918161392,
0.13567771017551422,
0.48547035455703735,
0.20983567833900452,
0.41456472873687744,
0.4622499644756317,
0.9509792923927307,
-0.20468656718730927,
0.4918224513530731,
0.05138493701815605,
0.012117823585867882,
-0.18075858056545258,
-1.0631673336029053,
-0.9713495373725891,
-0.5616088509559631,
-0.2360004186630249,
0.14373180270195007,
-0.03518039360642433,
0.867495596408844,
0.5571679472923279,
-0.7074117660522461,
-0.37414082884788513,
-0.36748647689819336,
-0.028469186276197433,
0.17316880822181702,
-0.12197398394346237,
0.2540239095687866,
-0.5160819292068481,
-0.8569150567054749,
0.39493826031684875,
0.3107597827911377,
-0.05128715559840202,
-0.4830651581287384,
0.16283899545669556,
-0.3458859324455261,
0.09512948989868164,
0.8664359450340271,
0.3375307321548462,
-0.9131922721862793,
-0.05816253647208214,
-0.07211336493492126,
0.06488176435232162,
0.048190124332904816,
0.7806733846664429,
-0.25621938705444336,
0.09934549778699875,
0.4442436397075653,
0.7133861184120178,
0.6035280227661133,
-0.3293398320674896,
0.59373939037323,
-0.5698564052581787,
-0.048661019653081894,
0.42008623480796814,
0.4013107717037201,
0.2555253803730011,
-0.009747371077537537,
0.4246729910373688,
-0.31440314650535583,
-0.7981643080711365,
-0.8877325654029846,
0.34107866883277893,
-1.1645970344543457,
-0.3449747562408447,
1.3575564622879028,
0.12259736657142639,
0.18100637197494507,
-0.16236501932144165,
-0.19413650035858154,
0.01737803779542446,
-0.03354564309120178,
0.5901672840118408,
0.9382845759391785,
-0.20114761590957642,
-0.4407866597175598,
-0.9797442555427551,
0.4088916778564453,
0.2976708710193634,
-0.851963222026825,
0.3694600760936737,
0.38883042335510254,
0.060375042259693146,
-0.10123331099748611,
0.49171942472457886,
-0.03907489776611328,
-0.2769067585468292,
-0.31125879287719727,
-0.07784496992826462,
0.24221520125865936,
-0.21256287395954132,
-0.40689975023269653,
0.2769310474395752,
0.5145061612129211,
0.2333661913871765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13095v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13095v1
|
Presentations are not always linear! GNN meets LLM for Document-to-Presentation Transformation with Attribution
| 2024-05-21T13:52:33 | 2024-05-21T13:52:33 |
Himanshu Maheshwari, Sambaran Bandyopadhyay, Aparna Garimella, Anandhavelu Natarajan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Automatically generating a presentation from the text of a long document is a
challenging and useful problem. In contrast to a flat summary, a presentation
needs to have a better and non-linear narrative, i.e., the content of a slide
can come from different and non-contiguous parts of the given document.
However, it is difficult to incorporate such non-linear mapping of content to
slides and ensure that the content is faithful to the document. LLMs are prone
to hallucination and their performance degrades with the length of the input
document. Towards this, we propose a novel graph based solution where we learn
a graph from the input document and use a combination of graph neural network
and LLM to generate a presentation with attribution of content for each slide.
We conduct thorough experiments to show the merit of our approach compared to
directly using LLMs for this task.
|
[
0.06503183394670486,
-0.7422105073928833,
0.7914092540740967,
0.0998852476477623,
-0.53170245885849,
0.24361363053321838,
0.08482146263122559,
-0.3651277422904968,
0.6840610504150391,
0.2668887972831726,
-0.36151280999183655,
-0.5699495673179626,
-0.7693364024162292,
-0.07734216004610062,
-0.9366779923439026,
1.027474045753479,
-0.2460809051990509,
-0.1254831701517105,
-0.6333906650543213,
-0.013769922778010368,
-0.16563555598258972,
-0.18947573006153107,
-0.7520185708999634,
-1.1173585653305054,
0.7030828595161438,
0.15093950927257538,
0.6488408446311951,
0.6851515173912048,
0.1444273293018341,
0.21845197677612305,
0.17030146718025208,
0.43156394362449646,
-0.5653398036956787,
-0.11653968691825867,
-0.1502200812101364,
-0.25459229946136475,
-0.42890816926956177,
0.0571451336145401,
0.6081868410110474,
0.77269047498703,
0.18128299713134766,
0.1428384780883789,
0.3111656606197357,
0.578224778175354,
-0.12007924169301987,
0.304964154958725,
-0.5457620024681091,
0.2691861391067505,
0.131993368268013,
-0.40066027641296387,
-0.4602975845336914,
-0.5469638109207153,
-0.24347347021102905,
-0.907524824142456,
0.17481926083564758,
0.01774519681930542,
0.8710612654685974,
0.0005207875510677695,
-0.5423246026039124,
-0.5034685134887695,
-0.720960259437561,
0.3098004162311554,
-0.3562943935394287,
0.25645166635513306,
0.0047254110686481,
0.15729805827140808,
-0.11184141784906387,
-1.2403795719146729,
-0.3930395841598511,
-0.151576966047287,
0.10981650650501251,
0.1805656999349594,
-0.11797045916318893,
-0.11326924711465836,
0.013200946152210236,
0.09605701267719269,
-0.5953440070152283,
0.26315537095069885,
-0.35865074396133423,
-0.3706011474132538,
0.5493394732475281,
0.1972455233335495,
0.3883625864982605,
-0.40537697076797485,
-0.5185055732727051,
-0.11680563539266586,
-0.4210561513900757,
-0.2782467007637024,
0.3405042290687561,
0.15729399025440216,
0.007869061082601547,
0.5317407250404358,
0.2945285737514496,
0.4994221329689026,
0.2308260053396225,
-0.3668874502182007,
0.09636661410331726,
-0.28370794653892517,
-0.164463609457016,
0.45608994364738464,
0.9577950239181519,
0.7128553986549377,
0.18989139795303345,
-0.452652245759964,
-0.08567879348993301,
-0.13719245791435242,
0.3398224115371704,
-0.7759768962860107,
-0.390206515789032,
-0.15996453166007996,
-0.6763501763343811,
-0.538188099861145,
-0.2447868287563324,
-0.752107560634613,
-0.5918492078781128,
-0.47413578629493713,
0.5333930850028992,
-0.32955020666122437,
0.1263217031955719,
-0.2665060758590698,
-0.0992354303598404,
-0.016116995364427567,
0.7550691962242126,
-0.9014464616775513,
0.3993745446205139,
0.42029839754104614,
1.3433889150619507,
-0.36039289832115173,
-0.19658032059669495,
-0.7193432450294495,
0.44613757729530334,
-0.4669387936592102,
0.754749059677124,
-0.12905548512935638,
-0.5829543471336365,
0.026612255722284317,
-0.23102332651615143,
-0.009886560961604118,
-0.466718465089798,
0.2338261902332306,
-0.274447500705719,
0.4079777002334595,
0.24203984439373016,
-0.6637453436851501,
0.0949735939502716,
0.2114909142255783,
-0.6479860544204712,
0.6302098631858826,
0.30868759751319885,
-0.5351026058197021,
0.05127020552754402,
-0.5138376951217651,
-0.5961014628410339,
0.13161058723926544,
-0.7706135511398315,
-0.5424609184265137,
0.07164257764816284,
0.24651844799518585,
0.18019041419029236,
-0.0023788290563970804,
0.12943804264068604,
0.09930131584405899,
-0.34610605239868164,
0.19334661960601807,
-0.4155887961387634,
0.33207204937934875,
-0.07103540748357773,
0.004954626318067312,
0.49540698528289795,
-0.9845752120018005,
0.06720582395792007,
0.27291539311408997,
-0.5314594507217407,
0.19793270528316498,
0.1419944167137146,
0.05275712162256241,
0.38573166728019714,
0.3689705729484558,
-0.31630754470825195,
0.2551378905773163,
-0.351993590593338,
0.5166945457458496,
0.944710373878479,
0.0207282155752182,
0.711498498916626,
-0.4812528192996979,
0.5111832022666931,
-0.23577848076820374,
0.059543970972299576,
0.014270502142608166,
-0.5740547776222229,
-0.6301448941230774,
0.10728473216295242,
0.043806042522192,
0.5226039886474609,
-1.0239336490631104,
-0.003687242977321148,
-0.6200060248374939,
-0.1416562795639038,
0.019254017621278763,
0.4537486433982849,
0.1988096684217453,
1.000063419342041,
0.2776365578174591,
-0.46817639470100403,
-0.3365844488143921,
-0.7051575183868408,
0.1213231086730957,
-0.3766952455043793,
-0.4264098107814789,
0.4617380201816559,
0.39512109756469727,
0.00585986627265811,
0.684199869632721,
-0.4915992021560669,
-0.5110976099967957,
-0.3471370339393616,
0.40900030732154846,
0.4532897472381592,
0.20789824426174164,
0.4332071542739868,
-0.6612641215324402,
-0.6954939365386963,
0.15375807881355286,
-1.2461812496185303,
0.004968085326254368,
-0.5697354078292847,
0.029025321826338768,
0.22325611114501953,
0.863670289516449,
-0.5017087459564209,
0.7328531742095947,
0.4884713292121887,
-0.12122140824794769,
0.5004264116287231,
-0.5517810583114624,
-0.27524563670158386,
-1.1945832967758179,
0.013440766371786594,
-0.13014118373394012,
-0.5401796698570251,
-0.5133969783782959,
-0.33194297552108765,
0.1322152018547058,
-0.6655040979385376,
-0.4963507056236267,
0.4788143038749695,
-0.4399735629558563,
-0.23452246189117432,
-0.5134581327438354,
0.6146429777145386,
0.4698531925678253,
0.4787568151950836,
-0.41745978593826294,
0.6199774146080017,
0.21292147040367126,
-0.40148165822029114,
0.9367794990539551,
0.7550273537635803,
-0.2729070782661438,
0.5631235837936401,
-0.42917799949645996,
0.44193071126937866,
-0.17494630813598633,
0.5500528812408447,
-0.7597730159759521,
-0.28907307982444763,
0.5813422799110413,
-0.4412655830383301,
0.5999047160148621,
-0.09207038581371307,
-0.5359448194503784,
-0.25238221883773804,
-0.4516521394252777,
0.17090095579624176,
0.37304428219795227,
-0.4970491826534271,
0.8776647448539734,
-0.19731508195400238,
-0.1223490759730339,
-0.34142568707466125,
-0.7937985062599182,
0.6293748021125793,
-0.07498560100793839,
-1.1574984788894653,
0.759612500667572,
-0.007133954204618931,
-0.08725770562887192,
-0.0004679937264882028,
-0.12062493711709976,
0.3388507068157196,
-0.03289526700973511,
0.42050138115882874,
0.33184200525283813,
-0.20915934443473816,
0.1907324343919754,
-0.10979484766721725,
-0.2921887934207916,
0.13570702075958252,
-0.6858515739440918,
0.5862904787063599,
0.13419480621814728,
-0.5845733284950256,
-0.5401270389556885,
0.7267231941223145,
0.2750774919986725,
0.3661167025566101,
0.5691400170326233,
0.5268937349319458,
-0.3248758614063263,
-0.06405366957187653,
-0.017789851874113083,
-0.03262763470411301,
-0.43169209361076355,
0.6003709435462952,
-0.0920286774635315,
-0.4646230936050415,
0.7029382586479187,
-0.22780388593673706,
-0.24604539573192596,
0.40481770038604736,
0.45328572392463684,
-0.24376727640628815,
0.6482643485069275,
0.7222670912742615,
-0.14173878729343414,
0.5766692757606506,
-0.21687279641628265,
0.28619953989982605,
-0.6828299760818481,
-0.4338669180870056,
-0.06547556817531586,
-0.7406021952629089,
-0.2792987525463104,
-0.28049686551094055,
0.515559196472168,
0.13641081750392914,
-0.03184054419398308,
-0.04193417355418205,
-0.5073604583740234,
0.42732542753219604,
0.3650454580783844,
0.4013500213623047,
0.3960493206977844,
0.23708151280879974,
-0.11390338093042374,
0.14798597991466522,
-0.6483296155929565,
-0.5939986109733582,
1.1434524059295654,
0.3279936611652374,
0.8993213772773743,
-0.041087910532951355,
0.9298042058944702,
0.3095458149909973,
0.24689540266990662,
-0.9024916887283325,
0.7414826154708862,
-0.2088109701871872,
-0.06539808958768845,
-0.5776500701904297,
-0.5074735283851624,
-0.9947123527526855,
0.013554639182984829,
-0.13132064044475555,
-1.265578031539917,
-0.13192109763622284,
0.0243135467171669,
0.03422861546278,
0.44514933228492737,
-0.5953068733215332,
0.5476047992706299,
-0.4769384562969208,
-0.5196757316589355,
0.05422188341617584,
-0.661720871925354,
-0.03969290852546692,
-0.24369855225086212,
0.15992829203605652,
0.04969242960214615,
0.14749743044376373,
0.82510906457901,
-0.4819923937320709,
0.6382360458374023,
0.03449344262480736,
-0.23937886953353882,
0.1489444226026535,
0.19977430999279022,
0.8074882626533508,
0.027038628235459328,
-0.17307008802890778,
-0.16068287193775177,
-0.750085711479187,
-0.12393590062856674,
-1.1340028047561646,
0.7568627595901489,
-0.8667547702789307,
-0.7158612012863159,
-0.13564711809158325,
-0.5892166495323181,
0.10988853871822357,
0.33960971236228943,
0.39238840341567993,
0.7180995941162109,
-0.30193036794662476,
-0.017304887995123863,
0.43287909030914307,
-0.10077299177646637,
0.4391295313835144,
-0.3201846480369568,
-0.7054338455200195,
-0.649523913860321,
1.1181747913360596,
0.16507962346076965,
0.5276541113853455,
0.29754185676574707,
0.15246868133544922,
-0.43783998489379883,
-0.9385117292404175,
-0.5100807547569275,
0.22556020319461823,
-1.2699319124221802,
-0.029539499431848526,
-0.29428961873054504,
-0.5811273455619812,
-0.40616244077682495,
-0.5117548704147339,
-0.18057182431221008,
-0.6212368607521057,
-0.8874963521957397,
-0.206466943025589,
-0.039646029472351074,
0.8615092635154724,
-0.10620395839214325,
0.06287164986133575,
-0.5179002285003662,
0.41804319620132446,
0.4140585958957672,
0.11376910656690598,
-0.04371604323387146,
-0.6295267939567566,
-0.27173957228660583,
-0.18417038023471832,
-0.8691191673278809,
-0.6321161389350891,
0.5846412777900696,
0.4471588432788849,
0.6186423301696777,
0.36484766006469727,
-0.24951907992362976,
0.41878607869148254,
-0.4795011878013611,
0.775878369808197,
0.9055312275886536,
-0.7276389002799988,
0.6540152430534363,
-0.32053351402282715,
0.24391543865203857,
0.14927658438682556,
0.4064694344997406,
-0.6029165983200073,
-0.15605053305625916,
-0.6673722267150879,
-1.2364592552185059,
0.5565447211265564,
0.4604829251766205,
0.11237047612667084,
0.372782438993454,
0.44136807322502136,
0.03691418841481209,
0.1117740273475647,
-0.8026111721992493,
-0.30020830035209656,
-0.8605437874794006,
-0.3000457286834717,
-0.32095083594322205,
0.002172974869608879,
-0.3904215395450592,
-0.03846259042620659,
0.39274969696998596,
-0.503814160823822,
0.578488826751709,
0.16845600306987762,
-0.24356232583522797,
-0.15214425325393677,
-0.05207614228129387,
0.7825440168380737,
1.08968985080719,
-0.3277450501918793,
0.3216581642627716,
0.04955025017261505,
-0.3951738178730011,
0.20055647194385529,
0.018154889345169067,
-0.17277583479881287,
0.2716304659843445,
0.5759385228157043,
1.0153493881225586,
0.21102039515972137,
0.09267561137676239,
0.5340184569358826,
0.02216300740838051,
-0.7070023417472839,
-0.23297271132469177,
-0.2310301959514618,
0.2958615720272064,
0.09430048614740372,
0.5309609174728394,
-0.239694282412529,
-0.2085753083229065,
-0.6300392150878906,
0.3876436948776245,
0.11137495189905167,
-0.4666593670845032,
-0.01118418388068676,
0.9664482474327087,
0.3404987156391144,
-0.8971529603004456,
0.9489256739616394,
0.08208443969488144,
-0.43966853618621826,
0.541187584400177,
0.7977167963981628,
0.7253421545028687,
0.32437050342559814,
0.5587483644485474,
0.09465497732162476,
-0.17513443529605865,
0.4125617444515228,
-0.16049562394618988,
-0.021327003836631775,
-0.519538402557373,
-0.2633715867996216,
-0.3996071219444275,
-0.49199220538139343,
0.17276978492736816,
-0.3273376524448395,
0.16814909875392914,
-0.7183831334114075,
-0.026418909430503845,
0.15792226791381836,
-0.031411062926054,
-0.08842193335294724,
0.089817576110363,
0.6458190083503723,
0.7757344245910645,
-0.6248828768730164,
0.6789829134941101,
0.37724289298057556,
-0.5191957950592041,
-0.5771803855895996,
-0.12260597199201584,
0.06672407686710358,
-0.9008136987686157,
0.7781772613525391,
0.12972670793533325,
-0.04067717865109444,
0.03647715225815773,
-0.630802571773529,
-0.5035918951034546,
1.4906260967254639,
0.592657208442688,
-0.21286149322986603,
-0.5109362006187439,
0.5673453211784363,
0.3364218473434448,
-0.6166377663612366,
0.011820705607533455,
-0.241957426071167,
0.27872583270072937,
0.5722582340240479,
-0.8338825106620789,
0.036369387060403824,
-0.16776959598064423,
0.09002287685871124,
0.10372920334339142,
-0.4221777021884918,
0.7714915871620178,
0.07161000370979309,
-0.20998820662498474,
-0.11246287077665329,
0.832024872303009,
0.12376181781291962,
0.6282951831817627,
0.2861250936985016,
0.11310185492038727,
1.0035910606384277,
0.10429902374744415,
1.0373812913894653,
-0.08669086545705795,
0.20990987122058868,
1.3112517595291138,
-0.19034071266651154,
0.3081943094730377,
0.6063354015350342,
0.06662061810493469,
0.6060068607330322,
0.3296245038509369,
-0.07342105358839035,
0.38120564818382263,
0.4734972417354584,
-0.27841997146606445,
-0.27469706535339355,
-0.20025143027305603,
-0.2184944748878479,
0.1674821525812149,
0.2931978106498718,
-0.6895448565483093,
-0.6797941327095032,
-0.03046264871954918,
-0.04184660688042641,
0.3320399522781372,
-0.5002087950706482,
0.7196256518363953,
0.5479744076728821,
-0.13340044021606445,
0.5995705723762512,
-0.13398177921772003,
0.28988876938819885,
-0.7849441170692444,
0.12316160649061203,
-0.052556224167346954,
0.09760094434022903,
-0.4858018159866333,
-0.8960938453674316,
0.3977915942668915,
-0.44313934445381165,
-0.21050937473773956,
-0.7977390289306641,
1.176820993423462,
-0.1510804146528244,
-0.5322859883308411,
0.4933731257915497,
0.31954583525657654,
0.21502423286437988,
-0.037211865186691284,
-0.5715219974517822,
-0.16661079227924347,
0.058152079582214355,
-0.20395293831825256,
0.6948951482772827,
0.46085038781166077,
-0.20163187384605408,
0.8489978909492493,
0.529867947101593,
-0.12602351605892181,
0.14333082735538483,
0.3328531086444855,
0.9986475110054016,
-0.395481139421463,
-0.43594008684158325,
-0.8577023148536682,
0.3858238756656647,
-0.29459771513938904,
-0.08073702454566956,
0.5899346470832825,
0.7898077368736267,
0.4211568534374237,
0.08879269659519196,
0.675392746925354,
0.4059116244316101,
-0.09497826546430588,
-0.7298606038093567,
1.0502766370773315,
-0.5807000994682312,
-0.18302322924137115,
-0.3422711193561554,
-0.8559728264808655,
-0.27796536684036255,
0.49977225065231323,
-0.019216232001781464,
-0.3376796841621399,
0.933390736579895,
0.48008349537849426,
-0.07294631004333496,
-0.10037411749362946,
0.5873614549636841,
-0.10309459269046783,
0.7521364688873291,
0.8026317358016968,
0.6892112493515015,
-0.47149327397346497,
1.0030901432037354,
0.14620622992515564,
-0.12488570809364319,
-0.2908254563808441,
-1.160377860069275,
-0.7691797614097595,
-0.5270240902900696,
-0.5485571622848511,
-0.6287984251976013,
0.02668198011815548,
0.549245297908783,
0.4197714924812317,
-0.3004416227340698,
-0.26273077726364136,
-0.1292048841714859,
0.2922945022583008,
0.21750105917453766,
-0.13384941220283508,
0.5587436556816101,
-0.07918674498796463,
-0.25625503063201904,
0.5231466889381409,
0.43982118368148804,
0.45332735776901245,
-0.25447216629981995,
-0.25931280851364136,
-0.3097686469554901,
0.05416341871023178,
0.4979395270347595,
0.3198833167552948,
-0.17455914616584778,
-0.5577324628829956,
-0.3264940083026886,
-0.10800600051879883,
0.706731379032135,
0.7200344800949097,
-0.5755960941314697,
0.3153568208217621,
0.37416979670524597,
0.3734680712223053,
1.118137240409851,
-0.10333053767681122,
0.6583665609359741,
-0.8953064680099487,
0.006250492762774229,
0.17350077629089355,
0.1921386569738388,
0.41574826836586,
-0.4735938608646393,
0.3795980215072632,
0.4519887864589691,
-0.45019271969795227,
-0.42438530921936035,
0.38852179050445557,
-1.4012694358825684,
-0.17956596612930298,
1.0339958667755127,
-0.21272782981395721,
-0.39067092537879944,
-0.08743695914745331,
-0.035475365817546844,
0.5112685561180115,
-0.23182888329029083,
0.8314808011054993,
0.6973950862884521,
-0.41697609424591064,
-0.10029188543558121,
-0.17695192992687225,
0.14454622566699982,
-0.2814488410949707,
-0.7114408016204834,
-0.30319052934646606,
0.23813000321388245,
0.14602188766002655,
0.6013594269752502,
0.7564601898193359,
-0.1372094750404358,
0.05545688420534134,
0.09158369153738022,
-0.15581351518630981,
-0.6255550384521484,
-0.2948324680328369,
-0.12245047092437744,
0.4906199872493744,
-0.17469963431358337,
-0.25370997190475464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12801v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12801v1
|
Comparing Neighbors Together Makes it Easy: Jointly Comparing Multiple Candidates for Efficient and Effective Retrieval
| 2024-05-21T13:51:48 | 2024-05-21T13:51:48 |
Jonghyun Song, Cheyon Jin, Wenlong Zhao, Jay-Yoon Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
A common retrieve-and-rerank paradigm involves retrieving a broad set of
relevant candidates using a scalable bi-encoder, followed by expensive but more
accurate cross-encoders to a limited candidate set. However, this small subset
often leads to error propagation from the bi-encoders, thereby restricting the
performance of the overall pipeline. To address these issues, we propose the
Comparing Multiple Candidates (CMC) framework, which compares a query and
multiple candidate embeddings jointly through shallow self-attention layers.
While providing contextualized representations, CMC is scalable enough to
handle multiple comparisons simultaneously, where comparing 2K candidates takes
only twice as long as comparing 100. Practitioners can use CMC as a lightweight
and effective reranker to improve top-1 accuracy. Moreover, when integrated
with another retriever, CMC reranking can function as a virtually enhanced
retriever. This configuration adds only negligible latency compared to using a
single retriever (virtual), while significantly improving recall at K
(enhanced).} Through experiments, we demonstrate that CMC, as a virtually
enhanced retriever, significantly improves Recall@k (+6.7, +3.5%-p for R@16,
R@64) compared to the initial retrieval stage on the ZeSHEL dataset. Meanwhile,
we conduct experiments for direct reranking on entity, passage, and dialogue
ranking. The results indicate that CMC is not only faster (11x) than
cross-encoders but also often more effective, with improved prediction
performance in Wikipedia entity linking (+0.7%-p) and DSTC7 dialogue ranking
(+3.3%-p). The code and link to datasets are available at
https://github.com/yc-song/cmc
|
[
-0.5616002082824707,
-0.28839248418807983,
0.8176831007003784,
0.1553911417722702,
-0.1708156317472458,
0.15762464702129364,
-0.3222905099391937,
-0.25589922070503235,
0.552491307258606,
0.23140661418437958,
-0.2368668168783188,
-0.787510871887207,
-0.7763551473617554,
0.1481865495443344,
-0.33854085206985474,
0.6596020460128784,
0.44806814193725586,
0.10122109204530716,
-0.4920201003551483,
-0.5346855521202087,
-0.31119465827941895,
-0.44027477502822876,
-0.6113714575767517,
0.14001861214637756,
0.9481599926948547,
0.4641689956188202,
0.690211296081543,
0.6637366414070129,
0.5464407205581665,
0.35846081376075745,
0.009439322166144848,
0.2855801582336426,
-0.744238018989563,
0.40594926476478577,
-0.35562241077423096,
-0.20397073030471802,
-0.1666172593832016,
-0.002777619520202279,
0.5586695075035095,
0.5969429016113281,
-0.11447053402662277,
0.03881527855992317,
-0.003484521061182022,
1.0128926038742065,
-1.2091951370239258,
-0.113376185297966,
-0.9142090082168579,
0.04591668024659157,
-0.32623589038848877,
-0.3324587345123291,
-0.2784755825996399,
-0.5503746867179871,
0.1485147774219513,
-0.33850303292274475,
0.44858860969543457,
0.16514188051223755,
0.49317219853401184,
0.21783621609210968,
-0.6657765507698059,
-0.1335412859916687,
-0.17998912930488586,
0.6540495157241821,
-0.4518638253211975,
0.7753791213035583,
0.2024422287940979,
0.4498659074306488,
0.23240025341510773,
-0.7506296038627625,
-0.33525845408439636,
-0.10134085267782211,
-0.18619027733802795,
0.555107593536377,
0.10523124784231186,
-0.05705917254090309,
0.0949239581823349,
0.6307731866836548,
-0.4902213513851166,
-0.18878664076328278,
-0.33052706718444824,
-0.24295032024383545,
0.2231770008802414,
0.16535340249538422,
-0.13676311075687408,
-0.18577823042869568,
-0.37631943821907043,
-0.41702547669410706,
-0.7345851063728333,
-0.18093684315681458,
0.3699594736099243,
0.4485563039779663,
0.32130956649780273,
0.5153046250343323,
-0.5299088358879089,
0.6781291961669922,
0.29828301072120667,
0.32679495215415955,
0.3957293629646301,
-0.7849737405776978,
0.2349277287721634,
0.11354437470436096,
0.7456458806991577,
0.4321334958076477,
-0.16198964416980743,
-0.42961519956588745,
-0.053551897406578064,
0.09350167959928513,
0.5986489653587341,
-0.8814024329185486,
-0.3974161148071289,
0.01828434318304062,
-0.7750707268714905,
-0.08767558634281158,
0.3876197338104248,
-0.9348417520523071,
-0.29389962553977966,
-0.30491694808006287,
0.6694270968437195,
0.022269733250141144,
-0.05416787788271904,
0.027876442298293114,
-0.13622088730335236,
0.17134404182434082,
-0.2079600989818573,
-0.7729430794715881,
0.3985104262828827,
0.7155455946922302,
0.8691117763519287,
-0.39326220750808716,
-0.4356324374675751,
-0.8059491515159607,
-0.05956516042351723,
-0.3607931435108185,
0.8477657437324524,
-0.736937940120697,
-0.2523275315761566,
-0.024920204654335976,
-0.07201910763978958,
-0.036646462976932526,
-0.7826642394065857,
0.46109896898269653,
-0.6626062393188477,
0.07227889448404312,
-0.5678662061691284,
-0.45622122287750244,
0.27697083353996277,
0.4643712639808655,
-0.9941802024841309,
0.994681179523468,
-0.033901989459991455,
-0.9562631845474243,
0.41885340213775635,
-0.1272871494293213,
-0.2878114581108093,
-0.3478311598300934,
-0.30242007970809937,
-0.6050214767456055,
0.028114918619394302,
0.4436560273170471,
0.3977062404155731,
-0.21567435562610626,
-0.20051521062850952,
-0.4910467267036438,
-0.6790432333946228,
-0.2719651758670807,
-0.11071961373090744,
0.562829852104187,
0.20184959471225739,
-0.44963836669921875,
-0.02019856870174408,
-0.4996783137321472,
0.4583198130130768,
-0.06643935292959213,
-0.5608304738998413,
-0.4495980441570282,
-0.08389907330274582,
-0.4497867226600647,
0.29789426922798157,
0.23577871918678284,
-0.6356844305992126,
0.034726355224847794,
-0.2572590112686157,
0.06856247037649155,
0.5663562417030334,
0.01235823892056942,
0.6159585118293762,
-0.16468946635723114,
0.269906610250473,
0.05254008248448372,
0.05680669844150543,
-0.16204403340816498,
-0.17236503958702087,
-0.6472286581993103,
-0.15433137118816376,
0.40785083174705505,
0.3203788995742798,
-0.7606102824211121,
0.4697921872138977,
-0.4585152566432953,
-0.5404444336891174,
-0.9529909491539001,
0.056881681084632874,
0.5652742385864258,
0.3027609884738922,
0.6872027516365051,
-0.44104111194610596,
-0.4201483130455017,
-0.964755117893219,
-0.4187188744544983,
0.09023342281579971,
-0.07042510062456131,
0.5327355861663818,
0.10968964546918869,
0.004318182356655598,
0.7462472319602966,
-0.41038981080055237,
-0.42289331555366516,
0.02614370360970497,
-0.12305634468793869,
0.19878646731376648,
0.3070981502532959,
0.3761192560195923,
-0.9058188199996948,
-0.8331031799316406,
-0.15196354687213898,
-0.6149695515632629,
0.09278212487697601,
0.13739939033985138,
-0.4590935707092285,
-0.0689617171883583,
0.43250149488449097,
-0.2670147120952606,
0.5602900385856628,
0.5349522233009338,
-0.24813902378082275,
0.2635491192340851,
-0.25537794828414917,
0.86002117395401,
-1.0379756689071655,
-0.03988019749522209,
-0.3213673233985901,
-0.13683649897575378,
-0.10893406718969345,
0.16646188497543335,
0.46069446206092834,
0.0375373438000679,
-0.11972541362047195,
0.1032295823097229,
-0.5715609788894653,
-0.38226133584976196,
-0.06174848601222038,
0.5853123664855957,
0.12603317201137543,
0.4373641312122345,
-0.03219626098871231,
0.8585235476493835,
0.4612615704536438,
-0.5916109085083008,
0.2835555672645569,
0.15088818967342377,
-0.3076213002204895,
0.8613683581352234,
-0.6168431639671326,
0.4843953251838684,
-0.12729932367801666,
0.1942063271999359,
-0.9061742424964905,
0.27749642729759216,
-0.12044885754585266,
-0.5880919694900513,
0.21860525012016296,
-0.1582796275615692,
-0.4496076703071594,
-0.25518330931663513,
-0.74810791015625,
0.504534900188446,
-0.022578824311494827,
-1.1370365619659424,
0.48977822065353394,
0.3284931778907776,
0.0857575312256813,
-0.8710830211639404,
-0.5517395734786987,
0.1276421695947647,
-0.028615092858672142,
-0.4594257175922394,
0.7485852241516113,
-0.15120796859264374,
0.14209401607513428,
0.1941724270582199,
-0.33126407861709595,
-0.009684763848781586,
-0.18264488875865936,
0.14109021425247192,
0.09562194347381592,
-0.10375337302684784,
0.19488655030727386,
-0.021796049550175667,
-0.3332260251045227,
-0.12119925022125244,
-0.3944152295589447,
0.2720573842525482,
-0.14623019099235535,
-0.5349883437156677,
0.027479656040668488,
0.5237966775894165,
0.4943748116493225,
-0.45847630500793457,
0.8592676520347595,
0.6584331393241882,
-0.12001625448465347,
0.3004312813282013,
-0.9731215238571167,
-0.3265623152256012,
-0.4363481104373932,
0.31661537289619446,
-0.6242469549179077,
-1.0879712104797363,
0.4935111105442047,
-0.0038246246986091137,
-0.01787971891462803,
0.4044398367404938,
0.35426124930381775,
0.3039306700229645,
1.0810697078704834,
0.40633776783943176,
-0.46059805154800415,
0.30631551146507263,
-0.17108969390392303,
0.4049462676048279,
-0.9174612164497375,
-0.5204295516014099,
-0.9525689482688904,
-0.4156514108181,
-0.8163367509841919,
-0.4925040900707245,
0.38995036482810974,
-0.08981912583112717,
-0.21084967255592346,
0.68963623046875,
-0.7932183146476746,
0.7885549664497375,
0.6970717906951904,
0.17885297536849976,
0.3889392018318176,
0.14153914153575897,
-0.6330804228782654,
-0.4537407159805298,
-0.6735263466835022,
0.047992024570703506,
1.2208715677261353,
-0.1475880891084671,
0.6129944920539856,
0.37772223353385925,
1.0935790538787842,
0.10384737700223923,
0.010566250421106815,
-0.4889161288738251,
0.2796629071235657,
-0.2833348512649536,
-0.8707255721092224,
-0.16198799014091492,
-0.7547144889831543,
-0.9235393404960632,
0.8081760406494141,
-0.5216931700706482,
-0.48123449087142944,
0.44455909729003906,
-0.12916149199008942,
-0.21021927893161774,
0.4925433099269867,
-0.519802451133728,
0.956371545791626,
-0.15794940292835236,
-0.7398890852928162,
-0.5464918613433838,
-0.7431060671806335,
0.04553816467523575,
-0.04144178330898285,
-0.14214424788951874,
0.10184317082166672,
-0.17101402580738068,
0.45406773686408997,
-0.05023518204689026,
0.09837939590215683,
-0.050175365060567856,
0.3834201395511627,
0.18777072429656982,
0.10413122177124023,
0.4983513355255127,
0.06867709010839462,
-0.32218220829963684,
0.05921303480863571,
0.016327403485774994,
-0.46124517917633057,
-0.7633586525917053,
1.1972414255142212,
-0.5493148565292358,
-0.3261856138706207,
-0.2481565624475479,
0.11243719607591629,
-0.043705109506845474,
0.302081823348999,
0.1857290416955948,
0.5399196147918701,
-0.26339733600616455,
0.7468951940536499,
0.6804407238960266,
-0.09153146296739578,
0.07785963267087936,
0.38914212584495544,
-0.019321247935295105,
-0.7249542474746704,
1.0186330080032349,
-0.06842736154794693,
0.16392160952091217,
0.5529623627662659,
-0.021326707676053047,
-0.5202878713607788,
-0.4135197699069977,
-0.17348672449588776,
0.18275056779384613,
-0.6966103315353394,
-0.3692743480205536,
-1.0741984844207764,
-0.06320643424987793,
-0.5716440677642822,
0.02564595639705658,
-0.8679320216178894,
-0.138877272605896,
0.22844654321670532,
-0.04021657630801201,
-0.16786950826644897,
0.683715283870697,
-0.2245868742465973,
-0.060116805136203766,
-0.5627415776252747,
0.3816470503807068,
0.5034645199775696,
0.5489559173583984,
0.06327461451292038,
-0.2697790861129761,
-0.4109399616718292,
-0.3382299840450287,
-0.23032037913799286,
-0.7298967242240906,
-0.06928293406963348,
-0.012022454291582108,
0.8922188878059387,
0.24657246470451355,
0.10642673820257187,
0.9470005631446838,
-0.48269280791282654,
0.39203929901123047,
0.0774848610162735,
-0.7592012882232666,
0.4239633083343506,
0.07472706586122513,
0.45796284079551697,
1.2821850776672363,
0.5268428921699524,
-0.48243141174316406,
-0.09993400424718857,
-0.506900429725647,
-0.9325239658355713,
0.4322729706764221,
0.33072444796562195,
-0.2071545422077179,
-0.44408199191093445,
0.21229177713394165,
-0.07238802313804626,
0.19578510522842407,
-0.34339237213134766,
-0.5994110703468323,
-0.20147408545017242,
-0.12335074692964554,
-0.02184850536286831,
-0.40337643027305603,
0.16773954033851624,
-0.12365448474884033,
0.4499899744987488,
-0.1673341691493988,
0.44078707695007324,
0.4117409288883209,
-0.0012519203592091799,
0.2185906320810318,
0.13942112028598785,
-0.06006605178117752,
0.45788872241973877,
-0.2686372399330139,
0.42511025071144104,
0.31277719140052795,
-0.1524348109960556,
-0.19627226889133453,
0.07491528987884521,
0.35848990082740784,
0.05283355712890625,
0.2812442481517792,
0.22678516805171967,
0.7112391591072083,
-0.18066874146461487,
0.5960489511489868,
-0.3160105347633362,
-0.19752636551856995,
-0.009843524545431137,
-0.18720439076423645,
0.37866130471229553,
0.26387879252433777,
0.2727353572845459,
0.062355171889066696,
0.6235790252685547,
-0.45629405975341797,
0.3409929573535919,
0.5749894380569458,
-0.2568523585796356,
0.08076567202806473,
0.6022893786430359,
0.25574421882629395,
-0.15123450756072998,
0.8843704462051392,
-0.18490558862686157,
-0.6577225923538208,
0.4980030059814453,
0.3678302466869354,
0.4517475664615631,
-0.07456391304731369,
-0.1663675606250763,
0.9130200147628784,
0.188712015748024,
-0.23638194799423218,
-0.2387910634279251,
-0.5265776515007019,
-0.537906289100647,
-0.16916951537132263,
-0.16130132973194122,
-0.3085997998714447,
-0.41482338309288025,
-0.9009709358215332,
0.0059937783516943455,
-0.2630407512187958,
-0.2982482612133026,
-0.039013635367155075,
0.3686305582523346,
-0.8905475735664368,
-0.10949655622243881,
-0.10948773473501205,
0.7065202593803406,
-0.4367385804653168,
0.6523163914680481,
0.49858158826828003,
-0.2900794446468353,
-0.5678719878196716,
0.008759762160480022,
0.14752233028411865,
-0.30049264430999756,
0.17845389246940613,
0.36785128712654114,
-0.571907103061676,
-0.09159345179796219,
-0.3832337558269501,
-0.9577322602272034,
1.3038663864135742,
0.13039730489253998,
-0.7079208493232727,
0.2589421570301056,
-0.3037487268447876,
0.41663357615470886,
-0.5750873684883118,
0.6466917991638184,
0.5483726859092712,
0.35551583766937256,
0.12619437277317047,
-0.7352525591850281,
-0.012554068118333817,
-0.11675646156072617,
-0.09227468073368073,
0.22604595124721527,
-0.7733080983161926,
0.6973627805709839,
-0.2541441321372986,
-0.3494008779525757,
0.09144598990678787,
0.6817486882209778,
0.4436616897583008,
0.6269372701644897,
0.5919486284255981,
0.6334288120269775,
0.6918072700500488,
0.05839592218399048,
0.9261302351951599,
-0.27414560317993164,
0.49051815271377563,
1.3926247358322144,
-0.20223161578178406,
0.8596426248550415,
0.33262941241264343,
-0.31329458951950073,
0.5730936527252197,
0.4387489855289459,
0.20178033411502838,
0.7337871789932251,
0.07372362166643143,
-0.09714284539222717,
-0.6518464684486389,
-0.017467381432652473,
-0.5045801401138306,
0.24568916857242584,
-0.03208649158477783,
-0.38396504521369934,
-0.24843275547027588,
-0.49511048197746277,
-0.3646315336227417,
0.5709996223449707,
0.02237219735980034,
0.644413948059082,
0.0511486679315567,
-0.6342891454696655,
0.0422578789293766,
-0.04138113930821419,
0.9223078489303589,
-0.30989786982536316,
-0.16131924092769623,
-0.38096514344215393,
0.31058207154273987,
-0.14641889929771423,
-0.614196240901947,
0.09348132461309433,
-0.3803985118865967,
-0.26115021109580994,
0.06134527921676636,
0.8033813834190369,
-0.667140007019043,
-0.2547672986984253,
0.8189336061477661,
0.6481097936630249,
0.23184369504451752,
-0.28965359926223755,
-0.8327714800834656,
0.28223079442977905,
0.04882112517952919,
-0.018092749640345573,
0.3976556360721588,
0.3776806890964508,
0.28393688797950745,
0.6240522861480713,
0.5438893437385559,
-0.034079499542713165,
0.1257469207048416,
0.3574009835720062,
1.0205914974212646,
-0.7567009925842285,
-0.32934266328811646,
-0.5776544213294983,
0.07331163436174393,
-0.41570332646369934,
-0.02542077749967575,
0.7715296149253845,
0.8816839456558228,
1.0982223749160767,
0.17342013120651245,
0.1746121197938919,
-0.1263856291770935,
0.6649523973464966,
-0.19001850485801697,
0.6508457064628601,
-0.7502521276473999,
0.18103714287281036,
-0.20673887431621552,
-1.2499099969863892,
-0.15076419711112976,
0.728300929069519,
-0.08158975094556808,
0.42669677734375,
0.9050068259239197,
1.086801290512085,
-0.22752736508846283,
-0.2867164611816406,
0.4198768734931946,
-0.18542104959487915,
0.19186055660247803,
0.664814829826355,
0.716907799243927,
-0.6282218098640442,
0.8947607278823853,
-0.3942093551158905,
0.2645801603794098,
-0.18126067519187927,
-0.5762424468994141,
-0.9799168109893799,
-0.4719959795475006,
-0.2899138033390045,
-0.3385789692401886,
0.3594890534877777,
0.7687644958496094,
0.8723466396331787,
-0.6623795628547668,
0.09496484696865082,
0.40115734934806824,
0.31333404779434204,
-0.17332352697849274,
-0.19510255753993988,
0.39724379777908325,
-0.2368963360786438,
-0.7853391170501709,
0.6835311055183411,
0.33653029799461365,
-0.4538083076477051,
-0.2839236557483673,
-0.18560510873794556,
-0.4198598563671112,
-0.3178548514842987,
0.4062950909137726,
-0.05867409706115723,
-0.4794206917285919,
-0.3801659345626831,
0.0915524885058403,
-0.49067193269729614,
0.04431918263435364,
0.9647497534751892,
-1.2553372383117676,
0.7751955389976501,
0.5554249882698059,
0.8544726967811584,
0.729124903678894,
0.24264059960842133,
0.17617900669574738,
-0.5863505601882935,
-0.3443393409252167,
0.026351938024163246,
0.0787738710641861,
0.48294246196746826,
-0.32825225591659546,
0.8407388925552368,
0.06519325077533722,
-0.7213330864906311,
-0.3433290123939514,
-0.11053215712308884,
-0.7513128519058228,
-0.10102968662977219,
0.6331517100334167,
-0.14434714615345,
-0.011971114203333855,
0.040276043117046356,
0.05253467336297035,
0.1811923235654831,
-0.41068094968795776,
0.8799146413803101,
0.47415122389793396,
0.30217140913009644,
0.004709076136350632,
-0.4601892828941345,
0.08642446994781494,
0.6489483118057251,
-0.41765037178993225,
-0.16649752855300903,
0.34494590759277344,
0.4661986827850342,
0.10007178783416748,
0.7025802731513977,
-0.37399497628211975,
0.19851036369800568,
0.219517782330513,
-0.1403426229953766,
-0.13619999587535858,
-0.5509114265441895,
-0.26077091693878174,
0.30032992362976074,
-0.11917533725500107,
-0.3320118188858032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12788v1
|
What Have We Achieved on Non-autoregressive Translation?
| 2024-05-21T13:38:15 | 2024-05-21T13:38:15 |
Yafu Li, Huajian Zhang, Jianhao Yan, Yongjing Yin, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances have made non-autoregressive (NAT) translation comparable to
autoregressive methods (AT). However, their evaluation using BLEU has been
shown to weakly correlate with human annotations. Limited research compares
non-autoregressive translation and autoregressive translation comprehensively,
leaving uncertainty about the true proximity of NAT to AT. To address this gap,
we systematically evaluate four representative NAT methods across various
dimensions, including human evaluation. Our empirical results demonstrate that
despite narrowing the performance gap, state-of-the-art NAT still underperforms
AT under more reliable evaluation metrics. Furthermore, we discover that
explicitly modeling dependencies is crucial for generating natural language and
generalizing to out-of-distribution sequences.
|
[
-0.3395140767097473,
-0.5346100926399231,
0.2573838233947754,
0.31307122111320496,
-0.20237332582473755,
0.255557656288147,
-0.3336707651615143,
-0.9111884236335754,
0.14678800106048584,
0.27119022607803345,
-0.19893932342529297,
-0.17311829328536987,
-0.705781877040863,
0.4966251850128174,
-0.5246736407279968,
0.6783995032310486,
-0.007566795218735933,
-0.25404271483421326,
-0.1450432687997818,
-0.24046307802200317,
-0.40175074338912964,
-0.32188183069229126,
-0.250716894865036,
-0.5588854551315308,
0.23752735555171967,
0.26828819513320923,
0.7912753820419312,
0.7012867331504822,
0.6935878396034241,
0.22209200263023376,
0.01911398023366928,
0.3058638572692871,
-0.19343316555023193,
0.05902519077062607,
-0.26629167795181274,
-0.181901216506958,
-0.3500412106513977,
0.23088973760604858,
0.9630560278892517,
0.6946873068809509,
0.14213383197784424,
0.368743360042572,
-0.02751738391816616,
1.0502711534500122,
-0.7938944101333618,
0.03060036338865757,
-0.38723206520080566,
0.013272971846163273,
-0.14586599171161652,
-0.07066554576158524,
-0.5046802759170532,
-0.6115738153457642,
0.3256174623966217,
-0.09297390282154083,
0.5173752903938293,
0.1595655381679535,
0.8189599514007568,
0.5880537033081055,
-0.7401291131973267,
-0.077884241938591,
-0.9874486327171326,
0.74467933177948,
-0.6908366680145264,
0.6821504831314087,
0.5789399743080139,
0.16285890340805054,
-0.35985681414604187,
-0.26086127758026123,
-0.240849569439888,
-0.4761444628238678,
-0.23212973773479462,
0.19882766902446747,
-0.3480595648288727,
-0.07234014570713043,
0.1125762090086937,
0.7398474812507629,
-0.6104280948638916,
0.13512364029884338,
-0.15760664641857147,
-0.13815495371818542,
1.1258925199508667,
0.04570981115102768,
0.01423010416328907,
-0.3534267842769623,
-0.331285297870636,
-0.13986486196517944,
-0.44303807616233826,
-0.1187182068824768,
0.3976072072982788,
0.1799083948135376,
-0.20235562324523926,
0.5262005925178528,
-0.40947815775871277,
0.8961505889892578,
0.1740511804819107,
0.30392366647720337,
0.417664110660553,
-0.44491201639175415,
-0.08991630375385284,
-0.20652511715888977,
1.2010327577590942,
0.30480846762657166,
-0.09792104363441467,
-0.5996177792549133,
-0.2379463016986847,
-0.19206394255161285,
0.1833571493625641,
-0.354848712682724,
-0.33665767312049866,
-0.029068995267152786,
-0.47341787815093994,
-0.1630438268184662,
-0.08858776837587357,
-0.9167565107345581,
-0.1835595667362213,
-0.04073607921600342,
0.33416682481765747,
-0.266213983297348,
-0.36119285225868225,
-0.3795616328716278,
-0.0028174836188554764,
0.1594754308462143,
0.3335481584072113,
-0.8730711936950684,
0.3522263765335083,
0.12396754324436188,
1.053572416305542,
-0.28330644965171814,
-0.2003086805343628,
-0.5505720973014832,
-0.0960952639579773,
-0.7386125922203064,
0.8615328669548035,
-0.13687433302402496,
-0.32688307762145996,
-0.3535655736923218,
-0.15619362890720367,
-0.09924931079149246,
-0.5868615508079529,
0.3319609761238098,
-0.3032981753349304,
0.0013946887338533998,
-0.4772503674030304,
-0.4803323447704315,
-0.4153895378112793,
-0.05999305099248886,
-0.7656792998313904,
0.878284215927124,
0.15502554178237915,
-0.6031412482261658,
0.3895842134952545,
-0.7624930143356323,
-0.69624924659729,
-0.034082721918821335,
0.23940281569957733,
-0.37201058864593506,
0.5410850644111633,
0.05606255680322647,
0.0960286408662796,
-0.5409180521965027,
0.26083463430404663,
-0.0663723573088646,
-0.092071533203125,
0.385601282119751,
-0.7207204103469849,
0.506453275680542,
0.06756641715765,
-0.5936647653579712,
-0.22260205447673798,
-0.6406115889549255,
-0.15283198654651642,
-0.023095596581697464,
-0.16576431691646576,
-0.18880541622638702,
-0.14316792786121368,
-0.06051599606871605,
0.36956700682640076,
0.06861411780118942,
-0.6112608313560486,
0.017619671300053596,
-0.5177156925201416,
0.5252701044082642,
0.410001277923584,
-0.014530484564602375,
0.6702776551246643,
-0.151540607213974,
0.4316460192203522,
-0.2797771692276001,
0.1607232689857483,
0.0929865837097168,
-0.6750227808952332,
-0.594916582107544,
-0.051887817680835724,
0.48643481731414795,
0.49923986196517944,
-0.5233913064002991,
0.4045758843421936,
-0.12701766192913055,
-0.6306385397911072,
-0.38943323493003845,
0.19510145485401154,
0.7633023262023926,
0.6699169278144836,
0.781188428401947,
-0.7251437902450562,
-0.24345576763153076,
-0.982261061668396,
-0.2621375322341919,
-0.5625056028366089,
0.3169001042842865,
0.10798303782939911,
0.381073921918869,
-0.2538996636867523,
0.7423702478408813,
-0.278714120388031,
-0.2238103747367859,
0.035421356558799744,
0.7480756640434265,
-0.07411336153745651,
0.39003631472587585,
0.4696435034275055,
-0.56162029504776,
-0.45934000611305237,
0.10967918485403061,
-0.7009541392326355,
-0.3594944179058075,
-0.023612644523382187,
-0.26001599431037903,
0.6452474594116211,
0.23224970698356628,
-0.5076570510864258,
0.862408459186554,
0.7025801539421082,
-0.15063446760177612,
0.4436262845993042,
-0.30657458305358887,
0.2686834931373596,
-0.6146049499511719,
0.38584035634994507,
0.11827584356069565,
-0.48637449741363525,
-0.5823716521263123,
-0.34951260685920715,
0.28487589955329895,
0.2703263461589813,
-0.35083770751953125,
0.7007348537445068,
-0.7169672250747681,
-0.5237224102020264,
-0.23939378559589386,
-0.0514511875808239,
0.19390934705734253,
-0.035403501242399216,
0.30282190442085266,
0.6200274229049683,
0.18652668595314026,
-0.5755971074104309,
0.44156935811042786,
0.48889583349227905,
-0.14833110570907593,
0.304255872964859,
-0.5689345002174377,
0.18891003727912903,
0.010954382829368114,
0.41874203085899353,
-0.8846004009246826,
-0.0636272206902504,
0.34532642364501953,
-0.574687123298645,
0.5707600116729736,
-0.23568668961524963,
-0.6064174771308899,
-0.36443740129470825,
-0.030446870252490044,
0.41888901591300964,
0.6406834125518799,
-0.3678244352340698,
0.2049398422241211,
0.1458035260438919,
0.23659548163414001,
-0.425146222114563,
-1.10996413230896,
0.42378538846969604,
-0.1269197165966034,
-0.34189271926879883,
0.12944799661636353,
0.1328054815530777,
-0.20492945611476898,
0.02711193822324276,
-0.14065825939178467,
-0.09980521351099014,
0.07572873681783676,
0.05290772020816803,
0.08036983013153076,
-0.07891057431697845,
0.08007367700338364,
-0.14461685717105865,
-0.17253650724887848,
-0.0076476894319057465,
-0.3007960617542267,
0.09213197231292725,
-0.22623737156391144,
-0.2454497218132019,
-0.4607033133506775,
0.4403345286846161,
0.2602217197418213,
-0.4327253997325897,
0.48187124729156494,
0.630959689617157,
-0.269971638917923,
0.056072648614645004,
-0.8253554701805115,
-0.04622801020741463,
-0.378717303276062,
0.024994708597660065,
-0.005310981534421444,
-0.4338001310825348,
0.25120991468429565,
0.152963325381279,
0.052473034709692,
0.3548634350299835,
0.5697109699249268,
-0.02101469784975052,
0.6039145588874817,
0.4633599817752838,
0.11326360702514648,
0.3879565894603729,
-0.3348850905895233,
0.20814047753810883,
-1.023508071899414,
-0.04065823554992676,
-0.24192601442337036,
-0.3900773525238037,
-0.7112323641777039,
-0.3800232708454132,
0.018536537885665894,
0.20684345066547394,
0.22174127399921417,
0.6964807510375977,
-0.42911604046821594,
0.174147367477417,
0.5298171639442444,
-0.2369527816772461,
0.3849625885486603,
-0.23643489181995392,
0.1733722686767578,
-0.04490285739302635,
-0.7513733506202698,
-0.38693782687187195,
1.068435788154602,
0.13452690839767456,
0.4795829653739929,
0.2663467526435852,
0.8312221169471741,
0.5442804098129272,
0.6401283740997314,
-0.5615217089653015,
0.23793745040893555,
-0.3437832295894623,
-0.782721221446991,
-0.37730830907821655,
-0.7448408007621765,
-1.1222273111343384,
0.11776924133300781,
-0.19491393864154816,
-0.7464079260826111,
0.5715155601501465,
0.4291799068450928,
-0.2470499575138092,
0.18828417360782623,
-0.8196055293083191,
0.8552255630493164,
-0.488060861825943,
-0.4755682051181793,
0.1953829675912857,
-0.8850793242454529,
0.2290315479040146,
-0.15977850556373596,
0.25752168893814087,
-0.22923853993415833,
0.07668851315975189,
0.3628959357738495,
-0.3084418475627899,
0.695900022983551,
-0.098777636885643,
-0.055683817714452744,
0.38408347964286804,
0.2870495319366455,
0.2577053904533386,
0.08984274417161942,
-0.12429434806108475,
0.5371549129486084,
-0.3652788996696472,
-0.431415855884552,
-0.5745397806167603,
0.5403407216072083,
-0.6532976627349854,
-0.3386363983154297,
-0.6264742612838745,
-0.5482161045074463,
-0.14589348435401917,
0.15966621041297913,
0.6360267996788025,
0.36185818910598755,
-0.4121876358985901,
-0.34892401099205017,
0.39811328053474426,
-0.22256675362586975,
0.8133185505867004,
0.5551674365997314,
-0.06629326939582825,
-0.689482569694519,
0.9281545877456665,
0.31019818782806396,
0.5361921787261963,
0.5462707281112671,
0.2275637537240982,
-0.7326046228408813,
-0.49626827239990234,
-0.862524688243866,
0.4655286371707916,
-0.6026678681373596,
-0.32842403650283813,
-0.6544495224952698,
-0.07984994351863861,
-0.5895428657531738,
-0.07794706523418427,
-0.6009533405303955,
-0.5267270803451538,
-0.09073041379451752,
0.008486606180667877,
0.42294591665267944,
1.0172134637832642,
-0.6152175664901733,
-0.02988191694021225,
-0.9429041147232056,
0.34071633219718933,
0.1722724288702011,
0.1331954300403595,
-0.08603572100400925,
-0.4797472655773163,
-0.543285071849823,
0.0346093624830246,
-0.33414968848228455,
-0.9887611865997314,
0.5748663544654846,
0.36465415358543396,
0.4883197546005249,
-0.009624634869396687,
0.1694311797618866,
0.690134584903717,
-0.5848905444145203,
0.7330003380775452,
0.2040652483701706,
-1.083890438079834,
0.5955477356910706,
-0.11084666848182678,
0.41868856549263,
0.5957976579666138,
0.19434775412082672,
-0.2732917070388794,
-0.39670345187187195,
-0.7080800533294678,
-0.9076153635978699,
0.45104849338531494,
0.5612649321556091,
-0.1528710126876831,
-0.253147155046463,
0.38379189372062683,
0.04992859810590744,
0.33754682540893555,
-0.45916783809661865,
-0.23834897577762604,
-0.3965170383453369,
0.2896152436733246,
-0.5270289778709412,
0.10296811908483505,
0.33142849802970886,
-0.11335959285497665,
0.5874261260032654,
0.08173459023237228,
0.32410648465156555,
0.5620344877243042,
-0.2951817810535431,
-0.6058991551399231,
0.011819927021861076,
0.5359644889831543,
0.46445232629776,
-0.2523871660232544,
0.03780144825577736,
0.18508078157901764,
-0.30972328782081604,
0.4253615438938141,
0.20824195444583893,
-0.3600444495677948,
0.3728750944137573,
0.5910438895225525,
0.7443163990974426,
-0.22272765636444092,
-0.2149566262960434,
0.5445077419281006,
-0.23174478113651276,
-0.10910813510417938,
-0.34810447692871094,
-0.1928260624408722,
-0.15901270508766174,
0.1309109777212143,
0.2128124088048935,
0.3570307791233063,
0.3705851137638092,
-0.2890532910823822,
0.13213784992694855,
0.39582309126853943,
-0.462848961353302,
-0.5661529302597046,
0.7461734414100647,
0.32411840558052063,
-0.41606542468070984,
0.5585790276527405,
-0.6079031229019165,
-0.26850345730781555,
0.37202173471450806,
0.45805585384368896,
1.2011522054672241,
-0.4482591152191162,
0.3336752653121948,
0.39910998940467834,
0.6086565256118774,
-0.2733120620250702,
0.15769760310649872,
-0.21509265899658203,
-0.35117414593696594,
-0.7945618629455566,
-0.6249585151672363,
-0.4299863874912262,
-0.16367875039577484,
-0.8753572106361389,
0.10656050592660904,
-0.13320046663284302,
-0.548255980014801,
-0.28141236305236816,
-0.05811464414000511,
-0.6581950187683105,
0.3165700435638428,
0.13125301897525787,
0.560524046421051,
-1.1126359701156616,
0.7428966164588928,
1.041243076324463,
-0.5600868463516235,
-0.4063669741153717,
0.33592909574508667,
-0.1638777107000351,
-0.2510868012905121,
0.7859726548194885,
0.054750360548496246,
-0.2823646664619446,
0.09663699567317963,
-0.07955081760883331,
-1.158806562423706,
0.7991363406181335,
0.38461974263191223,
-0.3157164454460144,
0.019814660772681236,
0.2086402177810669,
0.7908973097801208,
0.04842919111251831,
0.21576383709907532,
0.5988366007804871,
0.5555545687675476,
-0.07606089115142822,
-1.196439266204834,
-0.01991603709757328,
-0.24167543649673462,
0.2298014760017395,
0.5210458636283875,
-1.046167254447937,
0.3610049784183502,
0.002752832602709532,
-0.16485467553138733,
-0.13582955300807953,
0.7866621017456055,
-0.30693894624710083,
0.41792741417884827,
0.2582816183567047,
0.6095635890960693,
0.47578465938568115,
0.038761671632528305,
1.0441803932189941,
-0.13373422622680664,
0.27399715781211853,
1.1566033363342285,
-0.15945491194725037,
0.6760203242301941,
0.34662064909935,
-0.18974006175994873,
0.367490291595459,
0.6280726790428162,
0.12426352500915527,
0.562019407749176,
0.2806012034416199,
-0.12782272696495056,
-0.21370182931423187,
-0.1705639511346817,
-0.27486148476600647,
0.4171956479549408,
0.3605221211910248,
-0.4372319281101227,
-0.22905293107032776,
-0.17895416915416718,
-0.3251320719718933,
0.09556475281715393,
-0.01820407807826996,
0.8039772510528564,
0.30400633811950684,
-0.7951930165290833,
0.9566032290458679,
-0.05036422237753868,
0.4472130835056305,
-0.21535973250865936,
-0.04699298366904259,
-0.3564963638782501,
-0.2192952185869217,
-0.33669114112854004,
-0.4350717067718506,
0.7239336967468262,
0.08814670145511627,
-0.1731042116880417,
-0.1934703290462494,
0.4560927450656891,
-0.2395215481519699,
-0.37372326850891113,
0.5116873383522034,
0.6293686628341675,
0.3567582070827484,
0.2770713269710541,
-0.5303270816802979,
-0.26640719175338745,
-0.10345595329999924,
-0.21305085718631744,
0.11611785739660263,
0.5010079741477966,
-0.21436235308647156,
0.459176242351532,
0.5331350564956665,
0.23087461292743683,
0.3911924958229065,
-0.16462768614292145,
0.28223732113838196,
-0.6272374391555786,
-0.170713409781456,
-0.9116465449333191,
0.24797849357128143,
0.053263019770383835,
-0.4555559754371643,
0.9497281312942505,
0.5148337483406067,
0.7376689910888672,
0.22967533767223358,
0.8305959701538086,
-0.08085253834724426,
0.20383480191230774,
-0.24406692385673523,
0.43364161252975464,
-0.45543357729911804,
-0.006059755105525255,
-0.46035119891166687,
-1.1285170316696167,
-0.42972686886787415,
0.6501764059066772,
-0.5413975119590759,
-0.21748271584510803,
0.7289854288101196,
0.2148752510547638,
0.025988420471549034,
-0.093378946185112,
0.3809886872768402,
0.027103375643491745,
0.20758695900440216,
0.42995622754096985,
0.9444004893302917,
-0.5387218594551086,
0.37801918387413025,
-0.40811973810195923,
-0.326177179813385,
-0.19427484273910522,
-1.1810836791992188,
-0.8894157409667969,
-0.38789695501327515,
-0.661216139793396,
-0.33894872665405273,
0.24198879301548004,
0.9466423392295837,
0.6842806935310364,
-0.666242778301239,
-0.34118106961250305,
-0.3820880949497223,
-0.12687230110168457,
-0.3677974045276642,
-0.154027059674263,
0.3144342601299286,
-0.3395341634750366,
-0.580172061920166,
0.6166486144065857,
0.37108901143074036,
0.33070072531700134,
-0.3761923611164093,
-0.052374307066202164,
-0.32315143942832947,
0.04247324913740158,
0.34004470705986023,
0.4829862415790558,
-0.5663983821868896,
-0.1928761899471283,
-0.02619892731308937,
0.07418296486139297,
0.28399670124053955,
0.4373507797718048,
-0.6878038048744202,
0.5566331148147583,
0.6743857860565186,
0.6005755066871643,
0.531984269618988,
0.30062079429626465,
0.7855104207992554,
-0.6776390075683594,
0.020566100254654884,
0.30131980776786804,
0.1274719387292862,
0.7384688258171082,
-0.40401706099510193,
0.6489447355270386,
0.24293465912342072,
-0.8984676599502563,
-0.7220279574394226,
0.5198657512664795,
-0.3932114541530609,
0.22039465606212616,
1.177089810371399,
-0.30284008383750916,
-0.23030395805835724,
-0.3836335837841034,
0.37844446301460266,
0.49336522817611694,
-0.5399011373519897,
0.7718784809112549,
0.6811821460723877,
-0.5308510661125183,
-0.023410066962242126,
-0.6306061148643494,
0.38268518447875977,
0.43780019879341125,
-0.4690565764904022,
0.14420336484909058,
0.582817018032074,
0.045117586851119995,
0.29008495807647705,
0.6581418514251709,
-0.17098863422870636,
0.19565780460834503,
-0.22059856355190277,
0.10351619124412537,
0.06566179543733597,
-0.15703153610229492,
-0.44560450315475464,
-0.5833307504653931,
0.45694395899772644,
-0.054183878004550934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12775v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12775v1
|
Unsupervised Multimodal Clustering for Semantics Discovery in Multimodal Utterances
| 2024-05-21T13:24:07 | 2024-05-21T13:24:07 |
Hanlei Zhang, Hua Xu, Fei Long, Xin Wang, Kai Gao
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Discovering the semantics of multimodal utterances is essential for
understanding human language and enhancing human-machine interactions. Existing
methods manifest limitations in leveraging nonverbal information for discerning
complex semantics in unsupervised scenarios. This paper introduces a novel
unsupervised multimodal clustering method (UMC), making a pioneering
contribution to this field. UMC introduces a unique approach to constructing
augmentation views for multimodal data, which are then used to perform
pre-training to establish well-initialized representations for subsequent
clustering. An innovative strategy is proposed to dynamically select
high-quality samples as guidance for representation learning, gauged by the
density of each sample's nearest neighbors. Besides, it is equipped to
automatically determine the optimal value for the top-$K$ parameter in each
cluster to refine sample selection. Finally, both high- and low-quality samples
are used to learn representations conducive to effective clustering. We build
baselines on benchmark multimodal intent and dialogue act datasets. UMC shows
remarkable improvements of 2-6\% scores in clustering metrics over
state-of-the-art methods, marking the first successful endeavor in this domain.
The complete code and data are available at https://github.com/thuiar/UMC.
|
[
-0.502444326877594,
-0.5610499382019043,
0.6721674799919128,
0.11913085728883743,
-0.22238849103450775,
0.20599666237831116,
-0.38836905360221863,
-0.08716780692338943,
0.35712406039237976,
0.16692841053009033,
-0.54964280128479,
-0.9269877076148987,
-0.5393321514129639,
-0.271593302488327,
-0.14080072939395905,
0.45947661995887756,
0.3072631359100342,
-0.003695341758430004,
-0.7796260118484497,
-0.5403871536254883,
-0.4457746744155884,
-0.26791295409202576,
-0.05570167675614357,
-0.1247260794043541,
0.386299729347229,
0.6007776856422424,
0.3760506510734558,
0.23880043625831604,
0.1377284824848175,
0.3829735815525055,
-0.1337810456752777,
0.46456146240234375,
-0.21338345110416412,
0.16540242731571198,
0.16998527944087982,
-0.3647298812866211,
0.018365494906902313,
-0.07849445194005966,
0.7650047540664673,
1.1311190128326416,
-0.40398845076560974,
-0.17819641530513763,
-0.10165663063526154,
0.3918167054653168,
-0.7414538860321045,
0.5404743552207947,
-0.5161482691764832,
0.022229677066206932,
-0.2758992314338684,
-0.45828044414520264,
-0.5957321524620056,
0.14133168756961823,
0.08695444464683533,
-0.602403461933136,
0.07578861713409424,
0.07516665011644363,
0.18286706507205963,
0.18163467943668365,
-0.9448683857917786,
-0.019596902653574944,
-0.48687565326690674,
0.9759432077407837,
-0.40734750032424927,
0.6270129084587097,
0.1378728449344635,
0.2677316665649414,
-0.299095094203949,
-0.5677938461303711,
-0.6561128497123718,
-0.33831459283828735,
-0.13294973969459534,
0.17456038296222687,
-0.21005575358867645,
0.1863231509923935,
0.06729480624198914,
0.26756763458251953,
-0.6027988791465759,
0.013555399142205715,
0.011631275527179241,
-0.495585173368454,
0.09644443541765213,
0.08282602578401566,
0.23640064895153046,
-0.27152329683303833,
-0.4153411388397217,
-0.3443264663219452,
-0.3835397958755493,
0.16736938059329987,
-0.017404019832611084,
0.2510853707790375,
-0.021294036880135536,
0.5667442083358765,
-0.3884895443916321,
0.3675945997238159,
-0.12424031645059586,
-0.1800209879875183,
0.6131985187530518,
-0.3391152024269104,
0.2457486242055893,
0.10688799619674683,
0.6203126311302185,
0.448160856962204,
-0.08165397495031357,
-0.1720452904701233,
0.15120290219783783,
0.3318242132663727,
0.31057071685791016,
-0.4456081688404083,
-0.18556828796863556,
-0.1466318964958191,
-0.6068387627601624,
-0.29572373628616333,
0.45986104011535645,
-0.7124758958816528,
-0.387755811214447,
-0.3667698800563812,
0.40360578894615173,
-0.24752750992774963,
-0.4428543150424957,
-0.31082773208618164,
-0.05653325468301773,
-0.12761461734771729,
0.08350057154893875,
-0.8942564725875854,
0.04933534562587738,
0.12959571182727814,
0.5487440824508667,
-0.25823473930358887,
-0.19824063777923584,
-0.4692675769329071,
0.27850472927093506,
-0.325485497713089,
1.026038408279419,
-0.8274323344230652,
-0.5488877296447754,
-0.10384581238031387,
0.2395450323820114,
0.07712815701961517,
-0.48029688000679016,
0.47636649012565613,
-0.18692146241664886,
-0.014906873926520348,
0.10021050274372101,
-0.39650627970695496,
-0.3288980722427368,
0.025220997631549835,
-0.49229827523231506,
0.9012327194213867,
0.08358905464410782,
-0.5570626854896545,
0.5060296654701233,
-0.9276763796806335,
-0.4871198534965515,
-0.11426186561584473,
-0.2916867434978485,
-0.16048528254032135,
0.3762025833129883,
0.4468778073787689,
0.5552563071250916,
0.07157160341739655,
0.07694651186466217,
-0.34987112879753113,
-0.006821508519351482,
0.511451005935669,
-0.5592215061187744,
0.16527196764945984,
0.22540517151355743,
-0.15073665976524353,
0.4319557249546051,
-0.9284728169441223,
0.17845335602760315,
0.01598869077861309,
-0.05678457394242287,
-0.44469812512397766,
0.02162771485745907,
0.054410420358181,
0.0643586739897728,
0.11123941093683243,
-0.7523735761642456,
-0.09676303714513779,
-0.1549091935157776,
0.49048399925231934,
0.6881392598152161,
-0.10895730555057526,
0.7370599508285522,
0.061110928654670715,
0.10717368125915527,
0.4654807150363922,
0.2990199327468872,
-0.6056017875671387,
-0.366098016500473,
-0.5975394248962402,
-0.2704787850379944,
0.29580894112586975,
0.09287102520465851,
-0.7208648920059204,
0.4888496994972229,
-0.16746672987937927,
-0.30904337763786316,
-0.4623889625072479,
-0.10671691596508026,
0.16373810172080994,
0.24986590445041656,
0.45445606112480164,
-0.4627789258956909,
-0.4192597568035126,
-0.9323973655700684,
0.1572740226984024,
0.051452647894620895,
-0.057373858988285065,
0.4198671877384186,
0.04672608897089958,
-0.718302309513092,
1.0527726411819458,
-0.5443355441093445,
-0.5546627044677734,
-0.20077981054782867,
0.5405864715576172,
-0.10517137497663498,
0.5048787593841553,
0.3121858835220337,
-0.9609262347221375,
-0.14434775710105896,
0.0916895791888237,
-0.5351778268814087,
0.010004382580518723,
0.07261615991592407,
-0.03211209550499916,
0.16488929092884064,
0.5615294575691223,
-0.5056923031806946,
0.4999177157878876,
0.5649862289428711,
-0.16832131147384644,
0.17064552009105682,
-0.44996997714042664,
0.45961064100265503,
-1.106105089187622,
-0.06545619666576385,
-0.13145223259925842,
-0.2922700047492981,
-0.461396723985672,
-0.3098682165145874,
-0.029902495443820953,
-0.0523800291121006,
-0.19159770011901855,
0.18191517889499664,
-0.5517518520355225,
-0.08733713626861572,
-0.33593231439590454,
0.06546404957771301,
-0.2201768457889557,
0.7804189920425415,
-0.00564991170540452,
0.42688310146331787,
0.6200452446937561,
-0.5258678793907166,
0.415714830160141,
0.40608692169189453,
-0.517228364944458,
0.6262739896774292,
-0.2065051645040512,
0.1339530199766159,
-0.2164033055305481,
0.295107901096344,
-1.1180570125579834,
-0.3051835000514984,
-0.1962335705757141,
-0.7302542328834534,
0.1055055633187294,
-0.10820630192756653,
-0.5501406788825989,
-0.0865030512213707,
-0.033441923558712006,
0.6100270748138428,
0.3646794259548187,
-0.7738847136497498,
0.968737781047821,
0.827311635017395,
-0.05756950378417969,
-0.30265188217163086,
-0.5052658915519714,
-0.10785779356956482,
-0.08472799509763718,
-0.6153693199157715,
0.4256705343723297,
-0.06562833487987518,
0.21926847100257874,
-0.15610836446285248,
-0.20854781568050385,
0.03903180733323097,
-0.2413671910762787,
0.5812168717384338,
0.007345488760620356,
0.24597376585006714,
0.1646081805229187,
0.2683502435684204,
-0.5105828642845154,
-0.08943933993577957,
-0.2265542894601822,
0.5283947587013245,
-0.07708711177110672,
-0.681654691696167,
-0.4315038025379181,
0.5998178124427795,
0.6025791764259338,
-0.2776450514793396,
0.37227529287338257,
0.9095536470413208,
-0.2686070501804352,
-0.03394734114408493,
-0.6768897771835327,
-0.43990442156791687,
-0.4004269242286682,
0.2935806214809418,
-0.22053098678588867,
-1.1192739009857178,
0.31794750690460205,
-0.5680874586105347,
-0.18511265516281128,
0.21427568793296814,
0.5234203338623047,
-0.13279247283935547,
1.551236629486084,
0.759728193283081,
0.03598108887672424,
0.5366388559341431,
-0.11295127868652344,
0.2910728454589844,
-0.6484195590019226,
-0.7009865641593933,
-0.2736511528491974,
-0.2968515157699585,
-0.6634976267814636,
-0.6470715403556824,
0.820482075214386,
-0.36451318860054016,
0.39169472455978394,
0.06472232192754745,
-0.3062882423400879,
0.4612869322299957,
0.7113739252090454,
-0.03980611637234688,
0.48663702607154846,
0.1693505048751831,
-0.5974709987640381,
-0.08025146275758743,
-0.5426349639892578,
-0.1587977558374405,
0.964036762714386,
0.08507172018289566,
0.8155981302261353,
0.15482717752456665,
0.36162325739860535,
0.3027770221233368,
-0.19280444085597992,
-0.6653465032577515,
0.636365532875061,
0.01951966993510723,
-0.20903280377388,
-0.11417538672685623,
-0.6578769683837891,
-1.0066832304000854,
0.4976099729537964,
-0.5408177375793457,
-0.7273562550544739,
0.19648627936840057,
0.034555498510599136,
-0.2591838836669922,
0.03660719096660614,
-0.7843825221061707,
0.9161115288734436,
-0.100412517786026,
-0.023862391710281372,
-0.6627986431121826,
-1.0132607221603394,
-0.14397357404232025,
0.32262134552001953,
0.251249223947525,
-0.18296441435813904,
0.27134695649147034,
0.6631121635437012,
-0.06795381754636765,
0.7652237415313721,
-0.4217778146266937,
0.10945171117782593,
0.18265020847320557,
-0.03743639960885048,
0.09979885071516037,
0.20894765853881836,
0.6737423539161682,
0.20875999331474304,
0.1890961080789566,
-0.32503125071525574,
-0.8272467255592346,
0.8873569965362549,
-0.38667914271354675,
0.015312653966248035,
-0.3342512547969818,
-0.6032326221466064,
-0.5403384566307068,
0.1918671876192093,
-0.09567692130804062,
0.891221284866333,
-0.37734001874923706,
0.49736836552619934,
0.6126786470413208,
-0.037682171911001205,
0.38043490052223206,
0.5626330971717834,
-0.12561482191085815,
-0.30585429072380066,
1.0819909572601318,
-0.3008914589881897,
-0.037336740642786026,
0.6786046028137207,
0.16238759458065033,
-0.6317237615585327,
-0.4194555878639221,
-0.24785038828849792,
0.0658777579665184,
-0.6095137596130371,
0.022904502227902412,
-0.7291959524154663,
0.19501759111881256,
-0.4775948226451874,
0.2080984115600586,
-0.39792659878730774,
-0.2299247682094574,
-0.10215055197477341,
-0.12673352658748627,
0.08584688603878021,
0.5664236545562744,
-0.33647629618644714,
0.3725680112838745,
-0.8389973044395447,
0.305023729801178,
0.4338398277759552,
0.2939974069595337,
-0.11336133629083633,
-0.08233441412448883,
-0.14044874906539917,
0.1607273519039154,
-0.32103320956230164,
-0.43572312593460083,
0.23510313034057617,
0.04131227731704712,
0.7446766495704651,
0.924233078956604,
0.021219488233327866,
0.5055418610572815,
-0.23453819751739502,
0.5569705963134766,
0.4029203951358795,
-0.6373640894889832,
0.4256570041179657,
-0.15386654436588287,
0.5100430250167847,
0.5717889666557312,
0.20034034550189972,
-0.6460814476013184,
0.011712358333170414,
-0.6864044070243835,
-0.8025227785110474,
0.5436403155326843,
0.17582273483276367,
0.024169227108359337,
-0.11556857079267502,
-0.183735191822052,
0.1315607875585556,
0.41647613048553467,
-0.38575562834739685,
-0.25826719403266907,
-0.0921219065785408,
-0.2519768476486206,
-0.22704145312309265,
-0.32766589522361755,
-0.21601083874702454,
-0.38300400972366333,
0.21696864068508148,
-0.4286845028400421,
0.5044351816177368,
-0.14472010731697083,
-0.4240286350250244,
0.13182154297828674,
0.3972388207912445,
0.4999823570251465,
0.5890750885009766,
-0.06308525800704956,
0.4036930203437805,
0.0381225161254406,
-0.14917303621768951,
-0.12173890322446823,
0.05048937350511551,
0.4848257005214691,
-0.06498970091342926,
0.2268020063638687,
0.94168621301651,
0.5976735353469849,
-0.9791640043258667,
0.7361615300178528,
-0.1751798540353775,
-0.004558098968118429,
-0.4337226450443268,
-0.23045507073402405,
-0.1868515908718109,
0.3613612949848175,
0.3334575593471527,
0.2873370051383972,
0.31771576404571533,
-0.7050259113311768,
0.2506098449230194,
0.603515088558197,
-0.46125519275665283,
-0.34489724040031433,
0.20457972586154938,
0.3099156618118286,
0.38768836855888367,
0.4921175241470337,
-0.24160648882389069,
-0.32817342877388,
0.08566372841596603,
0.31838423013687134,
0.3739694356918335,
-0.26761144399642944,
0.387319415807724,
0.008719419129192829,
-0.10742606967687607,
0.2128966897726059,
-0.05014181137084961,
-0.6282256841659546,
-0.8264685869216919,
-0.3597643971443176,
-0.4291277527809143,
-0.14666762948036194,
-0.30194270610809326,
-0.6209381818771362,
-0.13200658559799194,
0.049694471061229706,
-0.17822197079658508,
-0.15527629852294922,
-0.39781808853149414,
-0.2507040798664093,
-0.06928201019763947,
0.2435338795185089,
0.23736083507537842,
-0.7063747644424438,
0.5853873491287231,
0.799639880657196,
-0.0654509961605072,
-0.48045724630355835,
-0.24849337339401245,
0.2852775454521179,
-0.7025396227836609,
0.17244774103164673,
0.29552143812179565,
-0.14773792028427124,
0.072685606777668,
-0.41526076197624207,
-0.6787391901016235,
1.1507468223571777,
0.09033943712711334,
-0.23114018142223358,
0.09953254461288452,
0.2554788887500763,
0.28429365158081055,
-0.540652334690094,
0.5460004210472107,
0.5790566802024841,
0.5186941623687744,
0.4605596363544464,
-0.7844111323356628,
-0.20198224484920502,
-0.25111261010169983,
0.1821727305650711,
0.3701819181442261,
-0.3266127407550812,
0.41933393478393555,
-0.3270806670188904,
-0.313631534576416,
0.05483290180563927,
0.8437206745147705,
0.049220506101846695,
0.43274760246276855,
0.8261995911598206,
0.7865822911262512,
0.6192851066589355,
-0.2656807005405426,
0.5026884078979492,
0.14566940069198608,
0.28232717514038086,
0.680406928062439,
-0.09077457338571548,
0.6180137395858765,
0.5830827951431274,
-0.034459590911865234,
0.6286535263061523,
0.39737579226493835,
0.2249900847673416,
0.7323877215385437,
-0.010072166100144386,
-0.4367983639240265,
-0.4697531759738922,
-0.47784554958343506,
-0.05833389237523079,
0.7960237860679626,
0.4608154892921448,
0.0309629924595356,
-0.2984648644924164,
0.5862371921539307,
-0.26713481545448303,
0.1588948369026184,
-0.13134989142417908,
1.1451003551483154,
-0.060677915811538696,
-0.3708246052265167,
0.14033323526382446,
-0.21494315564632416,
0.8355840444564819,
-0.5551180839538574,
-0.23594866693019867,
0.026069331914186478,
0.18995852768421173,
-0.24386103451251984,
-0.6498623490333557,
-0.031052544713020325,
-0.5055208206176758,
-0.27648302912712097,
0.003420302178710699,
0.4925696849822998,
-0.7626936435699463,
-0.14171943068504333,
0.4233018457889557,
0.27483558654785156,
0.04095614328980446,
-0.39825475215911865,
-0.29850709438323975,
0.03566335141658783,
-0.051879677921533585,
0.2808096408843994,
0.4101521372795105,
0.3928295373916626,
-0.17542338371276855,
0.6353123784065247,
0.791930615901947,
-0.36138758063316345,
0.11086404323577881,
0.49410003423690796,
0.8909360766410828,
-0.4740976095199585,
-0.5656964182853699,
-0.3202296793460846,
0.6762790679931641,
-0.17791789770126343,
-0.023326802998781204,
0.45450887084007263,
0.35716724395751953,
0.9466259479522705,
-0.1023557260632515,
0.6093373894691467,
-0.19717271625995636,
0.589859127998352,
-0.6043005585670471,
0.43884286284446716,
-0.7225648760795593,
-0.25750431418418884,
-0.23362894356250763,
-0.9283320307731628,
-0.2420676350593567,
0.6257901191711426,
0.145827054977417,
0.18327674269676208,
0.8988771438598633,
1.0739079713821411,
-0.20169322192668915,
0.17924651503562927,
0.5215988159179688,
0.21023572981357574,
0.285385400056839,
0.30250322818756104,
1.0963339805603027,
0.05668806657195091,
0.5814958214759827,
-0.36765915155410767,
-0.6121698021888733,
-0.15842117369174957,
-0.6630808711051941,
-0.8028659224510193,
-1.2018506526947021,
-0.017316630110144615,
0.08054269850254059,
-0.4144362211227417,
1.0562340021133423,
1.0156396627426147,
-0.733847439289093,
-0.08687849342823029,
0.13029059767723083,
-0.12211315333843231,
-0.2190132439136505,
-0.23392558097839355,
0.11217646300792694,
-0.3030017912387848,
-0.6845038533210754,
0.842720627784729,
0.38216716051101685,
-0.011731053702533245,
-0.26612764596939087,
-0.012214005924761295,
-0.28262442350387573,
-0.2915169596672058,
0.9018054008483887,
0.08547995984554291,
-0.6781485676765442,
-0.1282614916563034,
-0.16805320978164673,
0.41517987847328186,
0.08071798831224442,
1.1592836380004883,
-0.7605385780334473,
0.6547709107398987,
0.31352919340133667,
0.5794868469238281,
0.4499788284301758,
-0.005530642811208963,
0.23254862427711487,
-1.0320708751678467,
0.35762879252433777,
0.1120096817612648,
0.49171212315559387,
0.36068227887153625,
0.10314100980758667,
0.05528838932514191,
0.4087229073047638,
-0.527104914188385,
-0.5460666418075562,
0.29131099581718445,
-1.5687017440795898,
-0.14723800122737885,
0.9213033318519592,
0.3059549033641815,
-0.1494535207748413,
-0.08162826299667358,
-0.46168699860572815,
0.06425310671329498,
-0.7463785409927368,
0.6467466354370117,
0.38692131638526917,
-0.22250179946422577,
-0.23653925955295563,
-0.1343763917684555,
0.17579437792301178,
0.4437633156776428,
-0.7534448504447937,
-0.06381115317344666,
0.6284843683242798,
0.020884471014142036,
0.4490344822406769,
0.27629217505455017,
-0.3606340289115906,
0.08747617900371552,
-0.26514720916748047,
0.23654505610466003,
-0.1134343221783638,
-0.6663270592689514,
0.026940345764160156,
0.2719500660896301,
-0.12591254711151123,
-0.35537728667259216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12744v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12744v1
|
The Echoes of Multilinguality: Tracing Cultural Value Shifts during LM Fine-tuning
| 2024-05-21T12:55:15 | 2024-05-21T12:55:15 |
Rochelle Choenni, Anne Lauscher, Ekaterina Shutova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Texts written in different languages reflect different culturally-dependent
beliefs of their writers. Thus, we expect multilingual LMs (MLMs), that are
jointly trained on a concatenation of text in multiple languages, to encode
different cultural values for each language. Yet, as the 'multilinguality' of
these LMs is driven by cross-lingual sharing, we also have reason to belief
that cultural values bleed over from one language into another. This limits the
use of MLMs in practice, as apart from being proficient in generating text in
multiple languages, creating language technology that can serve a community
also requires the output of LMs to be sensitive to their biases (Naous et al.,
2023). Yet, little is known about how cultural values emerge and evolve in MLMs
(Hershcovich et al., 2022a). We are the first to study how languages can exert
influence on the cultural values encoded for different test languages, by
studying how such values are revised during fine-tuning. Focusing on the
fine-tuning stage allows us to study the interplay between value shifts when
exposed to new linguistic experience from different data sources and languages.
Lastly, we use a training data attribution method to find patterns in the
fine-tuning examples, and the languages that they come from, that tend to
instigate value shifts.
|
[
-0.5887390971183777,
-0.3907381296157837,
0.11310995370149612,
0.05306634679436684,
-0.08891021460294724,
0.12680701911449432,
-0.37048330903053284,
-0.9058468341827393,
0.3436228036880493,
0.5360021591186523,
-0.5739584565162659,
-0.06951434165239334,
-0.7244079113006592,
0.16320845484733582,
0.013485482893884182,
1.2730507850646973,
-0.12204424291849136,
0.3300330340862274,
0.30786678194999695,
-0.6575204730033875,
-0.2845248878002167,
-0.7172249555587769,
-0.4982384145259857,
-0.34538590908050537,
0.676374614238739,
0.5838878154754639,
0.6359056830406189,
0.49915415048599243,
0.3828137516975403,
0.08183809369802475,
-0.13983014225959778,
0.3317999243736267,
-0.8188061714172363,
0.14745298027992249,
-0.18026405572891235,
-0.7123845219612122,
-0.11760575324296951,
0.26270702481269836,
0.7046507596969604,
0.7086600661277771,
0.1893264800310135,
0.6035493016242981,
0.2691224217414856,
0.8289879560470581,
-0.6592474579811096,
0.13461264967918396,
-0.7451722025871277,
0.035811226814985275,
-0.42980721592903137,
-0.46165111660957336,
-0.3207840025424957,
-0.5491985082626343,
-0.2634629011154175,
-0.38603487610816956,
0.1313086301088333,
-0.23223301768302917,
1.0102061033248901,
0.14950256049633026,
-0.7534781098365784,
-0.4878969192504883,
-0.7131586074829102,
1.0885930061340332,
-0.2661336362361908,
0.4570937156677246,
0.4436127841472626,
0.017347266897559166,
0.13679543137550354,
-0.4706169068813324,
-0.4984809458255768,
0.22373545169830322,
0.0153086818754673,
0.0330510176718235,
0.39926397800445557,
-0.36658746004104614,
0.06089749559760094,
0.6159923076629639,
-0.0908292755484581,
0.11044847965240479,
-0.5337963104248047,
-0.03455637767910957,
0.5874866247177124,
0.26566043496131897,
0.3036922812461853,
0.10321778804063797,
-0.2022136151790619,
-0.2593962252140045,
-0.8870826959609985,
0.4481019675731659,
0.4083898067474365,
0.6819740533828735,
0.02399788238108158,
0.25171366333961487,
0.01966036483645439,
0.3236748278141022,
0.0479808934032917,
-0.3818358778953552,
0.37778759002685547,
-0.7329892516136169,
0.11522698402404785,
0.19682073593139648,
0.529711127281189,
0.5692564249038696,
0.8712314963340759,
0.2892557382583618,
0.016510307788848877,
-0.02865661308169365,
0.03607594966888428,
-0.8938772678375244,
0.13560611009597778,
-0.10066332668066025,
-0.8919835686683655,
-0.2831854820251465,
-0.07053806632757187,
-0.6537719964981079,
-0.541704535484314,
-0.3890324532985687,
0.1382860243320465,
-0.2615625858306885,
-0.5938085317611694,
0.10026344656944275,
-0.025582337751984596,
0.38704052567481995,
0.04663060978055,
-1.3265661001205444,
0.09898293763399124,
0.5352784991264343,
0.6974226236343384,
-0.09449739754199982,
-0.6275476813316345,
-0.2941358983516693,
-0.03905632719397545,
-0.46688592433929443,
0.4453052878379822,
-0.6276322603225708,
-0.5324862599372864,
0.3055684566497803,
0.31319546699523926,
0.05601595714688301,
-0.5258582234382629,
0.47680607438087463,
-0.5064896941184998,
0.15987156331539154,
-0.6484003067016602,
-0.3378646969795227,
-0.06021206080913544,
0.2963961660861969,
-0.7463072538375854,
1.0796858072280884,
-0.14193099737167358,
-0.5046281218528748,
0.8462954759597778,
-0.4156091809272766,
-0.47981756925582886,
-0.14619489014148712,
-0.30652180314064026,
-0.312000036239624,
0.23130236566066742,
-0.02856050245463848,
0.3634968101978302,
-0.1373342126607895,
-0.05150390416383743,
-0.3462105989456177,
-0.4132923483848572,
0.25668132305145264,
-0.7956310510635376,
0.9905642867088318,
0.40610602498054504,
-0.3955439329147339,
-0.16167937219142914,
-0.7273670434951782,
0.2369575947523117,
-0.12154971808195114,
-0.4520283639431,
-0.37233230471611023,
-0.09513908624649048,
0.22483457624912262,
0.539152204990387,
0.12277982383966446,
-0.3328002989292145,
0.13057087361812592,
-0.1261700689792633,
0.014971496537327766,
0.7374277114868164,
-0.034941140562295914,
0.41053614020347595,
-0.4396883249282837,
0.5835762619972229,
0.10969427973031998,
0.222300723195076,
-0.44159841537475586,
-0.4541834592819214,
-0.8019716143608093,
0.037031229585409164,
-0.02299298532307148,
0.547191321849823,
-0.3751801550388336,
-0.2783563733100891,
-0.042227864265441895,
-0.4920143187046051,
-1.2783766984939575,
0.3412528336048126,
0.14955055713653564,
-0.025254763662815094,
0.3824876546859741,
-0.1498078554868698,
-0.3485407829284668,
-0.9657924175262451,
-0.5603942275047302,
-0.04437024146318436,
0.15239080786705017,
0.09173078835010529,
0.31561732292175293,
-0.16546575725078583,
0.5187463760375977,
-0.30477696657180786,
-0.4132593870162964,
0.007544633466750383,
0.23327010869979858,
0.1668834239244461,
0.5185345411300659,
0.5391075611114502,
-0.7424889206886292,
-0.8661454319953918,
0.31836625933647156,
-0.6316699981689453,
-0.13215018808841705,
-0.3352857828140259,
-0.0024764640256762505,
0.5643671154975891,
0.4735110104084015,
-0.008110183291137218,
0.23336400091648102,
0.8831954002380371,
-0.3585917055606842,
0.6034212112426758,
-0.1833445131778717,
0.5971040725708008,
-1.306718111038208,
-0.003964699804782867,
-0.261827677488327,
0.15882903337478638,
-0.5645500421524048,
0.03006567247211933,
0.16980671882629395,
0.19713126122951508,
-0.294503390789032,
0.6082339286804199,
-0.7611255645751953,
0.20162536203861237,
-0.2843032777309418,
-0.23008280992507935,
0.07795336097478867,
0.21854250133037567,
0.11892136931419373,
0.6491565704345703,
0.24193868041038513,
-0.5180379152297974,
-0.04035283997654915,
-0.02266232855618,
-0.4503207802772522,
0.9053487181663513,
-0.05041365325450897,
-0.05639570206403732,
-0.09312723577022552,
-0.12749789655208588,
-0.7527436017990112,
0.3019617795944214,
-0.05908089503645897,
-0.39062631130218506,
0.29274266958236694,
-0.45641854405403137,
-0.422446608543396,
0.2633185386657715,
-0.22152310609817505,
0.5424473285675049,
0.44783809781074524,
-0.5038089752197266,
0.2264823615550995,
0.5377933382987976,
-0.24389411509037018,
-0.8343037962913513,
-0.8488507866859436,
0.15344029664993286,
-0.4814802408218384,
-0.6080791354179382,
-0.17407768964767456,
-0.28352174162864685,
-0.5121465921401978,
-0.3672833740711212,
0.2005392163991928,
-0.20310379564762115,
0.2827272117137909,
0.061593856662511826,
-0.1448301076889038,
-0.3856212794780731,
0.2805384695529938,
0.21199746429920197,
-0.18948403000831604,
0.1997804045677185,
-0.4302273094654083,
0.3008972108364105,
-0.4255322813987732,
-0.27505943179130554,
-0.17539481818675995,
0.7589955925941467,
0.7102406024932861,
-0.584892749786377,
1.1161994934082031,
1.0291539430618286,
-0.3134608566761017,
-0.08861090242862701,
-0.5668877363204956,
-0.2609299421310425,
-0.4555149972438812,
0.32770612835884094,
-0.6337708830833435,
-0.7655336260795593,
0.8527646660804749,
0.05807683989405632,
0.071404367685318,
0.3819325864315033,
0.7302514910697937,
-0.1529804915189743,
0.8424592018127441,
0.7001753449440002,
0.003511982038617134,
0.534981369972229,
-0.11531870812177658,
0.049957673996686935,
-0.49772384762763977,
-0.1362479329109192,
-0.6127689480781555,
-0.49529317021369934,
-1.1586140394210815,
-0.42496350407600403,
0.3485673666000366,
0.19587349891662598,
-0.03469916433095932,
-0.38512787222862244,
-0.22990351915359497,
0.7772435545921326,
0.5202298760414124,
-0.3210624158382416,
0.38654524087905884,
0.0010144265834242105,
0.008837297558784485,
-0.3326241672039032,
-0.611465334892273,
-0.6892160773277283,
1.0813581943511963,
0.34096696972846985,
0.8569117188453674,
0.19854772090911865,
0.45622944831848145,
-0.007393418811261654,
0.4044297933578491,
-0.6444522738456726,
-0.02659693732857704,
-0.18188846111297607,
-0.7482410669326782,
-0.2734072804450989,
-0.05815526470541954,
-1.1485213041305542,
0.46587517857551575,
-0.2611899673938751,
-0.5427508354187012,
0.3633538782596588,
0.2727072834968567,
-0.10584229230880737,
0.47530868649482727,
-0.6184712648391724,
0.9877801537513733,
-0.26849037408828735,
-0.6420453786849976,
-0.1788271963596344,
-0.7793532013893127,
0.2528817355632782,
-0.15568822622299194,
0.5177478194236755,
-0.04101812466979027,
0.2441021203994751,
0.536261260509491,
0.16289901733398438,
1.0739240646362305,
-0.03447785601019859,
-0.6049506664276123,
0.09486964344978333,
0.3572084307670593,
0.21219947934150696,
0.23772430419921875,
-0.19560018181800842,
0.38118627667427063,
0.39207738637924194,
-0.6287584900856018,
-0.12913233041763306,
0.826359748840332,
-0.7480638027191162,
-0.2855237126350403,
-0.37612298130989075,
-0.6433913111686707,
-0.11800028383731842,
0.3363858163356781,
0.22140975296497345,
0.23803603649139404,
-0.18063794076442719,
0.12174079567193985,
0.868975818157196,
-0.1282193958759308,
0.271367609500885,
0.5787734985351562,
-0.2588236629962921,
-0.16071921586990356,
0.9615802764892578,
0.37203750014305115,
0.6776788830757141,
0.18808086216449738,
0.31451472640037537,
-0.09109044820070267,
-0.29603326320648193,
-0.6476551294326782,
0.1271435171365738,
-0.8457602262496948,
0.18658746778964996,
-0.22741739451885223,
0.14684565365314484,
-0.27232202887535095,
-0.4142722487449646,
-0.5256103277206421,
-0.1818302422761917,
-0.3142069876194,
-0.0935760885477066,
0.28783920407295227,
0.8087987303733826,
-0.15899516642093658,
-0.08321196585893631,
-1.0720341205596924,
-0.1327686756849289,
-0.04900234192609787,
0.5348433256149292,
-0.1817300021648407,
-0.43880391120910645,
-0.8759666085243225,
0.4022008180618286,
-0.10503233224153519,
-0.7800998687744141,
0.310398668050766,
0.17973892390727997,
0.5676316618919373,
0.5426814556121826,
-0.16069547832012177,
0.9077014327049255,
-0.4680684804916382,
0.9477301836013794,
-0.19770418107509613,
-0.9121255278587341,
0.2752564549446106,
-0.2905109226703644,
0.4950000047683716,
0.7829620838165283,
0.44814568758010864,
-1.2359989881515503,
-0.5759120583534241,
-0.4841292202472687,
-0.7196008563041687,
0.6025058031082153,
-0.2554582953453064,
0.3399427831172943,
-0.06601583957672119,
0.2471168488264084,
0.5348420143127441,
0.22290171682834625,
-0.8141456246376038,
-0.5044780373573303,
-0.27140676975250244,
-0.15782003104686737,
-0.4358179271221161,
-0.3576812446117401,
-0.18390586972236633,
-0.18902163207530975,
0.3034151792526245,
-0.4496400058269501,
-0.057886503636837006,
0.06134199723601341,
-0.2959102392196655,
-0.3321603536605835,
0.3732059597969055,
0.8924375176429749,
0.690396249294281,
-0.038543637841939926,
0.4861319959163666,
0.3069439232349396,
-0.4485860764980316,
0.11056777834892273,
-0.22548161447048187,
-0.12387266755104065,
-0.020145226269960403,
0.31914713978767395,
0.8045850992202759,
0.005630041006952524,
-0.3294016122817993,
0.09816356003284454,
0.08337637782096863,
-0.007750163786113262,
-0.3807036578655243,
-0.21331340074539185,
0.16462555527687073,
0.09871132671833038,
0.2669644355773926,
0.08399655669927597,
-0.048624828457832336,
-0.8978428244590759,
0.1792943924665451,
0.38994142413139343,
-0.7385334372520447,
-0.44958192110061646,
0.5074295997619629,
0.26215457916259766,
-0.1670222133398056,
0.5205326676368713,
-0.17896857857704163,
-0.512215793132782,
0.48171931505203247,
0.4215099811553955,
0.6437393426895142,
-0.45234307646751404,
-0.014066750183701515,
0.2693391740322113,
0.5865834355354309,
0.1287948042154312,
0.42353108525276184,
0.1552475392818451,
-1.1025965213775635,
-0.3912522494792938,
-0.5003756880760193,
-0.1013607382774353,
-0.10305419564247131,
-0.9847724437713623,
0.18054316937923431,
0.2348480224609375,
0.03907731547951698,
-0.24545155465602875,
0.05104275047779083,
-0.6547444462776184,
0.1565355360507965,
0.37251362204551697,
0.6687480807304382,
-1.0664294958114624,
0.8876928687095642,
0.492074191570282,
-0.37425926327705383,
-0.5222630500793457,
0.1365937441587448,
0.2427801787853241,
-0.9449635744094849,
0.8762503266334534,
0.19231188297271729,
-0.32383209466934204,
-0.10443795472383499,
0.04046923294663429,
-0.7226952910423279,
0.8303200006484985,
0.22603538632392883,
-0.20367296040058136,
0.4494868516921997,
0.5991343259811401,
0.6806476712226868,
-0.282957524061203,
0.4074806571006775,
0.5439208745956421,
0.5643764734268188,
-0.37662872672080994,
-1.2386200428009033,
-0.2051229625940323,
-0.18657828867435455,
-0.19703707098960876,
0.45797449350357056,
-0.7854220271110535,
0.9112288355827332,
-0.2772700786590576,
-0.1438242793083191,
-0.3242970407009125,
0.3178035616874695,
-0.09815630316734314,
0.32039955258369446,
0.29179269075393677,
0.06696135550737381,
1.0014653205871582,
-0.04365011304616928,
1.0216777324676514,
-0.6955646872520447,
0.33354127407073975,
1.0157550573349,
-0.26228368282318115,
0.8043639063835144,
0.9659324288368225,
0.04541109874844551,
0.40709590911865234,
0.7534711956977844,
0.13269324600696564,
0.30467647314071655,
0.2421044111251831,
-0.1515379250049591,
-0.07738961279392242,
-0.2958643436431885,
-0.5184080004692078,
0.45925700664520264,
0.30295974016189575,
-0.5394424796104431,
0.09140511602163315,
0.02429315634071827,
0.38794630765914917,
0.191858172416687,
-0.4227356016635895,
0.7582616209983826,
0.09528420120477676,
-0.8546285033226013,
0.9079093337059021,
-0.15995359420776367,
0.7158735394477844,
-0.7459021806716919,
0.07951105386018753,
-0.4247846305370331,
0.47871753573417664,
-0.20274457335472107,
-1.0218037366867065,
0.4218539297580719,
-0.2197902649641037,
-0.44663405418395996,
-0.8887400031089783,
0.38979020714759827,
-0.8830814361572266,
-0.53928142786026,
0.4132155776023865,
0.7589173316955566,
0.11728374660015106,
0.09355835616588593,
-0.4959087669849396,
0.12640151381492615,
0.19798439741134644,
-0.28850358724594116,
0.4565679430961609,
0.5830392241477966,
-0.2307230830192566,
0.4764731824398041,
0.5376058220863342,
0.17084792256355286,
0.2855098247528076,
0.22275276482105255,
0.21068471670150757,
-0.6523083448410034,
-0.4081512987613678,
-0.911453366279602,
0.5521689653396606,
0.14278484880924225,
-0.7470638751983643,
0.8708758354187012,
0.5501747727394104,
1.3087882995605469,
-0.08922888338565826,
0.722194492816925,
0.2523951828479767,
0.15641821920871735,
-0.5875502228736877,
1.0063694715499878,
-0.7628879547119141,
0.08580630272626877,
-0.1704237014055252,
-0.5594425201416016,
-0.14332766830921173,
0.46348077058792114,
0.12147824466228485,
-0.005622149910777807,
0.8302931785583496,
0.7007191777229309,
0.16114690899848938,
0.05891105532646179,
0.23951713740825653,
0.09971154481172562,
0.34403982758522034,
0.3225014805793762,
0.8342723846435547,
-0.34945547580718994,
0.5467138886451721,
-0.22318598628044128,
-0.1430857628583908,
-0.0734705924987793,
-0.7444584369659424,
-0.557433545589447,
-0.7453463673591614,
-0.1181882992386818,
-0.4922421872615814,
-0.11539588868618011,
0.9808304905891418,
0.5157210230827332,
-0.8718372583389282,
-0.7482435703277588,
0.4563196897506714,
0.053988710045814514,
-0.6320597529411316,
-0.22163699567317963,
0.1392863392829895,
-0.5384103059768677,
-0.9832316040992737,
0.20445525646209717,
0.05378834903240204,
0.1130698174238205,
-0.4527088403701782,
-0.17701415717601776,
-0.22694799304008484,
0.03518036752939224,
0.730532169342041,
0.16108381748199463,
-0.5966519117355347,
-0.3719239830970764,
0.052617382258176804,
-0.238810732960701,
0.1670566201210022,
0.9685635566711426,
-0.31406664848327637,
0.6113609671592712,
0.31026697158813477,
0.6143196821212769,
0.43572768568992615,
-0.5174862742424011,
0.7513967752456665,
-0.7793015837669373,
0.11219168454408646,
0.0347520187497139,
0.34779560565948486,
0.21557706594467163,
-0.2574394941329956,
0.34137457609176636,
0.20049135386943817,
-0.5625823736190796,
-0.868483304977417,
0.4691573977470398,
-0.6073071360588074,
-0.2795148193836212,
1.2296781539916992,
0.1178525760769844,
0.3426786959171295,
-0.24963732063770294,
-0.18959584832191467,
0.2646730840206146,
-0.07934606820344925,
0.9929302930831909,
1.003575086593628,
-0.042924243956804276,
-0.06651776283979416,
-0.6042057275772095,
0.8791140913963318,
0.7067276239395142,
-0.6450628638267517,
0.21782781183719635,
0.29301100969314575,
0.40920698642730713,
0.2426694929599762,
0.5088121891021729,
-0.0598783940076828,
0.10699612647294998,
-0.019861288368701935,
0.21571782231330872,
0.18230557441711426,
-0.06138444319367409,
-0.5350932478904724,
0.19230371713638306,
0.3768671751022339,
-0.20997010171413422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12715v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12715v1
|
RecGPT: Generative Pre-training for Text-based Recommendation
| 2024-05-21T12:16:20 | 2024-05-21T12:16:20 |
Hoang Ngo, Dat Quoc Nguyen
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
We present the first domain-adapted and fully-trained large language model,
RecGPT-7B, and its instruction-following variant, RecGPT-7B-Instruct, for
text-based recommendation. Experimental results on rating prediction and
sequential recommendation tasks show that our model, RecGPT-7B-Instruct,
outperforms previous strong baselines. We are releasing our RecGPT models as
well as their pre-training and fine-tuning datasets to facilitate future
research and downstream applications in text-based recommendation. Public
"huggingface" links to our RecGPT models and datasets are available at:
https://github.com/VinAIResearch/RecGPT
|
[
-0.4606901705265045,
-0.6674713492393494,
0.5188929438591003,
0.399854451417923,
-0.28613701462745667,
-0.13465599715709686,
-0.09914655983448029,
-0.2084885537624359,
0.018982695415616035,
0.7882280349731445,
-0.8484906554222107,
-0.5645442008972168,
-0.538288414478302,
-0.07146257162094116,
-0.568662166595459,
1.5306077003479004,
0.02379741705954075,
0.14624343812465668,
-0.2721397280693054,
0.051114220172166824,
-0.7425622344017029,
-0.7186676263809204,
-0.6949471235275269,
-0.7164178490638733,
0.5531927943229675,
0.3101321756839752,
0.3637385070323944,
0.25289294123649597,
0.5015328526496887,
0.2182975858449936,
0.22174549102783203,
-0.17902760207653046,
-0.5640923380851746,
-0.003101407317444682,
-0.43394455313682556,
-0.08855637162923813,
-0.5168646574020386,
0.04716026410460472,
0.44852861762046814,
0.693595826625824,
-0.5584568977355957,
0.20152410864830017,
0.10349595546722412,
1.0846093893051147,
-0.3169972002506256,
0.3019656836986542,
-0.4061848521232605,
-0.06185556575655937,
-0.04514921084046364,
-0.19462212920188904,
-0.7187833189964294,
-0.5105197429656982,
0.638249397277832,
-0.6830392479896545,
0.5674148797988892,
0.14222021400928497,
0.518836259841919,
0.16750271618366241,
-0.26289457082748413,
-0.29656028747558594,
-0.6210784912109375,
0.45613768696784973,
-0.277433842420578,
0.7106238007545471,
0.5411773324012756,
0.11416816711425781,
-0.3217513859272003,
-1.2177375555038452,
-0.39409035444259644,
-0.6126666069030762,
0.022584887221455574,
0.02521243691444397,
-0.19160696864128113,
0.1773868203163147,
0.2024962604045868,
0.5933642387390137,
-0.8248735070228577,
-0.28972506523132324,
-0.22133971750736237,
0.14088739454746246,
0.1990409940481186,
-0.31241846084594727,
0.2607407569885254,
0.39145469665527344,
-0.47816118597984314,
-0.05283176526427269,
-0.7612578272819519,
-0.4158284068107605,
0.10506198555231094,
0.3177061975002289,
-0.2053689956665039,
0.4813395142555237,
-0.4567587375640869,
0.8262907266616821,
0.44465866684913635,
0.5795220732688904,
0.39347684383392334,
-0.3091965317726135,
-0.4260939061641693,
0.1402401328086853,
0.596300482749939,
0.2698214054107666,
0.5987219214439392,
-0.0038607476744800806,
-0.1471358835697174,
-0.006842263974249363,
0.5234658718109131,
-0.9513848423957825,
-0.7079992890357971,
-0.3441547155380249,
-0.4459589421749115,
-0.292693555355072,
0.157269686460495,
-0.5992092490196228,
-0.4748181700706482,
-0.2848951518535614,
0.472546249628067,
-0.3470529019832611,
-0.2792157530784607,
0.5080334544181824,
0.14292782545089722,
0.011078220792114735,
0.36931419372558594,
-1.0982338190078735,
0.40275198221206665,
0.5014428496360779,
0.7170785069465637,
-0.21634528040885925,
-0.4734041094779968,
-0.40569573640823364,
-0.09420530498027802,
-0.011412650346755981,
1.1025809049606323,
-0.6454029679298401,
-0.5346657633781433,
0.1838059276342392,
0.2393324375152588,
0.14003726840019226,
-0.49400877952575684,
0.7761115431785583,
-0.5733060836791992,
0.35018518567085266,
-0.199968621134758,
-0.4997354745864868,
-0.3756214678287506,
0.3306557238101959,
-0.7674450874328613,
1.086191177368164,
0.488724946975708,
-0.7123198509216309,
0.4426204562187195,
-0.7661206126213074,
-0.529141902923584,
0.042932964861392975,
0.23904213309288025,
-0.40005743503570557,
-0.07607685029506683,
0.3209816813468933,
0.4732606112957001,
-0.38604408502578735,
0.10730987042188644,
-0.33467209339141846,
-0.28525251150131226,
-0.12566691637039185,
-0.4155307114124298,
0.31175312399864197,
0.07791012525558472,
-0.03473241254687309,
0.4190479815006256,
-0.622058093547821,
-0.18630805611610413,
0.215028315782547,
-0.24376815557479858,
-0.07246796041727066,
-0.12790542840957642,
0.2076067179441452,
-0.1794801652431488,
0.41218456625938416,
-0.4231148958206177,
0.487783282995224,
-0.45557910203933716,
0.5519387125968933,
0.7909230589866638,
-0.047984570264816284,
0.4005318284034729,
-0.4718067944049835,
0.6183030605316162,
-0.17088937759399414,
-0.003960128873586655,
-0.34317830204963684,
-0.3409346044063568,
-0.5958956480026245,
0.22218957543373108,
0.4397415816783905,
0.5694278478622437,
-0.8723340034484863,
0.3252316117286682,
-0.08668641000986099,
-0.6974886655807495,
-0.13397717475891113,
-0.03449033573269844,
0.4692421555519104,
0.1540462076663971,
0.412739634513855,
-0.5380591750144958,
-0.5470399856567383,
-0.5855076909065247,
-0.19147850573062897,
-0.334736168384552,
0.18159866333007812,
0.0912737250328064,
0.35018765926361084,
-0.5436362624168396,
0.6545113921165466,
-0.767081081867218,
-0.24526222050189972,
-0.5030109286308289,
0.07758811861276627,
0.33007290959358215,
0.39496690034866333,
0.5748030543327332,
-0.7651227116584778,
-0.633579671382904,
0.01395308319479227,
-0.26117566227912903,
-0.1570756584405899,
0.14994746446609497,
-0.2379629909992218,
-0.09171131998300552,
0.358305960893631,
-0.6131662726402283,
0.24457576870918274,
0.7137788534164429,
-0.34011948108673096,
0.5995123386383057,
-0.32889506220817566,
0.26179322600364685,
-1.1247198581695557,
-0.20494894683361053,
0.3127425014972687,
-0.48236051201820374,
-0.5131387114524841,
-0.3685585856437683,
-0.23330791294574738,
-0.1524241864681244,
-0.188424751162529,
0.5001092553138733,
-0.28070348501205444,
0.06341493129730225,
-0.31432491540908813,
-0.05372803658246994,
-0.15129220485687256,
0.5446895956993103,
0.25832614302635193,
0.8553065657615662,
0.4234262704849243,
-0.5916991829872131,
0.44068923592567444,
0.5503169298171997,
-0.5985902547836304,
0.3570381999015808,
-0.8739457726478577,
0.315859317779541,
-0.0278168898075819,
0.5003219842910767,
-0.803769588470459,
-0.15568846464157104,
0.2905831038951874,
-0.33232730627059937,
0.2723051905632019,
-0.584453821182251,
-0.3289584815502167,
-0.2523238956928253,
-0.05169583112001419,
0.6577287912368774,
0.4530796706676483,
-0.7273496389389038,
0.34112638235092163,
0.34009742736816406,
-0.4880427420139313,
-0.6264812350273132,
-0.30580946803092957,
-0.27840614318847656,
0.08749312907457352,
-0.1345575600862503,
0.5683714747428894,
-0.3757518529891968,
0.4242793917655945,
-0.1538383811712265,
0.07339166104793549,
-0.1625199168920517,
-0.30331796407699585,
0.4131777286529541,
0.14465206861495972,
-0.08797521889209747,
0.07878749817609787,
-0.16651193797588348,
-0.19681201875209808,
-0.07205697149038315,
-0.8096752166748047,
0.8411165475845337,
-0.2991390526294708,
-0.24573421478271484,
-0.31941646337509155,
0.14219336211681366,
0.3649508059024811,
-0.24503253400325775,
0.42362111806869507,
0.7257602214813232,
-0.3093128204345703,
-0.3719823658466339,
-0.5375067591667175,
-0.1044861450791359,
-0.5066553950309753,
0.617671012878418,
-0.2754465639591217,
-1.073386311531067,
-0.15400812029838562,
-0.19353759288787842,
-0.04869796335697174,
0.2562573254108429,
0.7584805488586426,
0.20696060359477997,
0.7444043159484863,
0.888982355594635,
-0.16183733940124512,
0.9776611328125,
-0.18544453382492065,
0.09440313279628754,
-0.49690812826156616,
-0.06629467755556107,
-0.3940819799900055,
0.33960816264152527,
-0.806817352771759,
-0.06449376791715622,
-0.023617016151547432,
-0.01142797525972128,
-0.5395438075065613,
0.4982440173625946,
-0.7552129030227661,
0.5049687623977661,
0.6987280249595642,
0.198893204331398,
0.055852632969617844,
0.018592797219753265,
0.04337356239557266,
0.22335566580295563,
-0.5818684697151184,
-0.30355551838874817,
0.969560980796814,
0.22176000475883484,
0.911373496055603,
-0.12853503227233887,
0.4142419099807739,
0.6445600986480713,
0.7188760638237,
-0.6727990508079529,
0.3662988543510437,
-0.4858635663986206,
-0.51503986120224,
-0.019547704607248306,
-0.219668447971344,
-0.9624812602996826,
-0.06341078877449036,
-0.22560802102088928,
-0.37248098850250244,
-0.14114201068878174,
0.47408080101013184,
-0.20990200340747833,
0.1001676544547081,
-0.8179238438606262,
1.132570505142212,
-0.07847905158996582,
0.0019268044270575047,
-0.087980255484581,
-0.2846486568450928,
0.1227756068110466,
0.07765742391347885,
-0.18059852719306946,
-0.05415911227464676,
0.4569886326789856,
0.8383036851882935,
0.05315926671028137,
0.7924400568008423,
-0.2777649760246277,
0.05948689207434654,
0.2866572439670563,
0.1416778564453125,
0.5759040713310242,
0.08364852517843246,
0.037564896047115326,
0.08998330682516098,
0.13587772846221924,
-0.17820586264133453,
-0.5476173758506775,
0.7278822660446167,
-0.6829280257225037,
-0.5798467993736267,
-0.5670075416564941,
-0.047119952738285065,
-0.27134063839912415,
0.5169994235038757,
0.39252737164497375,
0.4795335829257965,
-0.6440770626068115,
0.32018691301345825,
0.7564224600791931,
-0.32402095198631287,
0.06410185992717743,
0.41541194915771484,
-0.5564211010932922,
-0.6846380233764648,
0.9073047637939453,
-0.2792670428752899,
0.06159127503633499,
0.6634042859077454,
0.1300569325685501,
-0.5041743516921997,
-0.7753279209136963,
-0.35152891278266907,
0.14043958485126495,
-0.444261759519577,
-0.05331725999712944,
-0.5194783210754395,
-0.17774857580661774,
-0.4077813923358917,
-0.1407097578048706,
-0.5625512599945068,
-0.08279141783714294,
-0.09383992105722427,
-0.30100953578948975,
0.32484203577041626,
1.2805635929107666,
0.3186952769756317,
0.5837786197662354,
-0.7349146604537964,
0.3155266344547272,
0.199430450797081,
0.8887481689453125,
-0.24919523298740387,
-0.4858300983905792,
-0.5004776120185852,
-0.04199962690472603,
-0.3469911515712738,
-0.4756116271018982,
0.38204413652420044,
0.05220883712172508,
0.48358070850372314,
0.11819449067115784,
-0.039931438863277435,
0.0855385884642601,
-0.8847154378890991,
0.768991231918335,
0.3367779850959778,
-0.634257435798645,
0.5276430249214172,
-0.5625167489051819,
0.35806387662887573,
0.6163914799690247,
0.41891103982925415,
-0.44633767008781433,
0.3060340881347656,
-0.40877291560173035,
-0.607579231262207,
0.5741490125656128,
0.09529662877321243,
0.19116240739822388,
-0.000029386161259026267,
0.5306440591812134,
0.4560951292514801,
0.37820714712142944,
-0.7524793744087219,
-0.28396040201187134,
-0.43073099851608276,
-0.34807541966438293,
-0.3759910762310028,
-0.646187961101532,
0.2677329480648041,
-0.08937938511371613,
0.7627223134040833,
0.16082635521888733,
0.4665999710559845,
0.19742900133132935,
-0.15462008118629456,
0.06315172463655472,
0.2029160112142563,
0.750466525554657,
0.5714523196220398,
-0.44002997875213623,
-0.36773398518562317,
-0.013058108277618885,
-0.8476166725158691,
0.2364676296710968,
0.41164854168891907,
-0.033224835991859436,
-0.14118219912052155,
0.16952821612358093,
1.04608952999115,
0.1636374294757843,
-0.32745757699012756,
0.4728391766548157,
-0.26310598850250244,
-0.1971110701560974,
-0.6356456279754639,
-0.0942559763789177,
-0.06016088277101517,
-0.04616188630461693,
0.05462690070271492,
-0.0657874122262001,
0.27270954847335815,
-0.46188345551490784,
0.49319586157798767,
0.23815493285655975,
-0.8058390617370605,
-0.31853899359703064,
0.5741882920265198,
0.5737916231155396,
-0.30322161316871643,
0.6593435406684875,
0.0582137256860733,
-0.5063798427581787,
0.06904146075248718,
0.5902329683303833,
1.2752710580825806,
-0.1511501669883728,
0.32480743527412415,
0.31925007700920105,
0.26368388533592224,
-0.5379368662834167,
-0.03359071910381317,
-0.07026829570531845,
-0.9526910185813904,
-0.33950814604759216,
-0.8080785870552063,
-0.49064216017723083,
0.05922839045524597,
-0.7126534581184387,
0.2806386649608612,
-0.5083903670310974,
-0.33871981501579285,
0.06517063826322556,
-0.011793000623583794,
-0.6225020289421082,
0.3236401677131653,
-0.2064414620399475,
0.9003942608833313,
-0.4643438160419464,
0.9771289825439453,
0.9587716460227966,
-0.37905019521713257,
-0.3832395672798157,
0.06743292510509491,
-0.3134761452674866,
-0.6743476986885071,
0.4282078146934509,
0.2511886656284332,
-0.37304943799972534,
0.3148387670516968,
-0.5246676802635193,
-0.556763231754303,
0.8874473571777344,
0.46921488642692566,
-0.602698028087616,
0.019103938713669777,
-0.2974916994571686,
0.35102424025535583,
-0.6046128273010254,
0.20648866891860962,
0.45484188199043274,
0.32917067408561707,
-0.02625535987317562,
-0.9934306740760803,
-0.10956567525863647,
-0.2811813950538635,
-0.06315869837999344,
0.4446534812450409,
-0.4852850139141083,
0.5653588771820068,
-0.30023887753486633,
-0.04198449105024338,
0.2561238706111908,
0.7344688177108765,
0.20190386474132538,
0.3749595582485199,
0.6057155132293701,
0.5767604112625122,
0.3630467355251312,
-0.09880098700523376,
1.332613468170166,
-0.14787866175174713,
0.39105522632598877,
1.3874403238296509,
-0.325447142124176,
0.7994002103805542,
0.036203533411026,
-0.30702340602874756,
0.6695716977119446,
0.9178428649902344,
-0.1515267789363861,
0.6990897059440613,
0.12414605915546417,
-0.3844563364982605,
-0.05423123762011528,
-0.09764103591442108,
-0.5632634162902832,
0.004197391681373119,
0.16818465292453766,
-0.41060537099838257,
-0.010979202575981617,
-0.0007549559813924134,
-0.2588617503643036,
-0.008537905290722847,
-0.2918335497379303,
0.938150942325592,
0.18541201949119568,
-0.7380902767181396,
0.431470662355423,
-0.08209385722875595,
0.7074300646781921,
-0.7025029063224792,
-0.3855859041213989,
-0.08245785534381866,
0.3218400776386261,
-0.042766742408275604,
-0.9836903810501099,
-0.24722136557102203,
-0.09216616302728653,
-0.6116629242897034,
-0.30572137236595154,
0.7351081371307373,
-0.6171019077301025,
-0.4271935224533081,
0.31914329528808594,
0.19017165899276733,
0.004519572481513023,
-0.31329596042633057,
-0.7382603287696838,
-0.1968955546617508,
0.23061661422252655,
-0.3795609176158905,
0.34720656275749207,
0.38185182213783264,
0.013257288374006748,
0.8520344495773315,
0.7397375702857971,
0.004692699294537306,
-0.23300929367542267,
0.4335523247718811,
0.7166273593902588,
-0.7372353672981262,
-0.47552257776260376,
-0.6777299046516418,
0.3390151262283325,
0.2506597638130188,
-0.3235304355621338,
0.3330700099468231,
0.4223863482475281,
1.239207148551941,
-0.40626516938209534,
0.9664491415023804,
0.11611570417881012,
0.5072601437568665,
-0.6064497232437134,
0.6864945888519287,
-0.16800493001937866,
0.054955463856458664,
-0.1685682237148285,
-1.2551988363265991,
-0.18577416241168976,
0.4228428304195404,
-0.2731616199016571,
0.6569104790687561,
0.711948573589325,
0.7272472977638245,
-0.07863749563694,
-0.03639445826411247,
0.2813856303691864,
0.19982756674289703,
0.17499519884586334,
0.48049020767211914,
0.719616711139679,
-0.24043703079223633,
0.4389099180698395,
-0.23705528676509857,
-0.23358012735843658,
-0.27769196033477783,
-0.9295083284378052,
-1.0078381299972534,
-0.7936229705810547,
-0.32200881838798523,
-0.333597868680954,
0.3553774356842041,
1.0643447637557983,
0.7414913773536682,
-0.8770174384117126,
-0.0985773503780365,
-0.361232191324234,
-0.040156472474336624,
-0.14773698151111603,
-0.16836796700954437,
0.38427287340164185,
-0.014651024714112282,
-0.5817983746528625,
0.355457067489624,
0.1266404688358307,
0.2875623106956482,
-0.08328397572040558,
-0.025553708896040916,
-0.15436968207359314,
-0.16200576722621918,
0.8477345705032349,
0.20569482445716858,
-0.41540706157684326,
-0.16374072432518005,
-0.3489547669887543,
0.07512424141168594,
-0.05115779861807823,
1.131605863571167,
-0.6878235936164856,
0.2766795754432678,
0.4487479627132416,
0.6185451149940491,
0.6651231050491333,
0.2622215747833252,
1.1074827909469604,
-0.5134866833686829,
0.11579335480928421,
-0.032822225242853165,
0.2715481221675873,
0.45051395893096924,
-0.3064658045768738,
0.6106064915657043,
0.1635035276412964,
-0.7267831563949585,
-0.7426291108131409,
0.31398382782936096,
-1.237099528312683,
0.08583290129899979,
1.0311003923416138,
-0.2807164192199707,
0.18703541159629822,
0.007795525249093771,
-0.5415048003196716,
0.24936646223068237,
-0.5811780691146851,
0.5819323658943176,
0.7317500710487366,
0.01909072883427143,
-0.37219634652137756,
-0.6619855761528015,
0.7305804491043091,
0.14253166317939758,
-0.7028429508209229,
0.36548519134521484,
0.40264517068862915,
0.40165573358535767,
-0.24527578055858612,
0.7835822105407715,
0.016267165541648865,
0.31769368052482605,
-0.16205154359340668,
0.24780414998531342,
-0.19278068840503693,
-0.40867531299591064,
-0.25596946477890015,
0.12824954092502594,
0.4279439449310303,
-0.148359477519989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12712v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12712v1
|
From Human-to-Human to Human-to-Bot Conversations in Software Engineering
| 2024-05-21T12:04:55 | 2024-05-21T12:04:55 |
Ranim Khojah, Francisco Gomes de Oliveira Neto, Philipp Leitner
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Software developers use natural language to interact not only with other
humans, but increasingly also with chatbots. These interactions have different
properties and flow differently based on what goal the developer wants to
achieve and who they interact with. In this paper, we aim to understand the
dynamics of conversations that occur during modern software development after
the integration of AI and chatbots, enabling a deeper recognition of the
advantages and disadvantages of including chatbot interactions in addition to
human conversations in collaborative work. We compile existing conversation
attributes with humans and NLU-based chatbots and adapt them to the context of
software development. Then, we extend the comparison to include LLM-powered
chatbots based on an observational study. We present similarities and
differences between human-to-human and human-to-bot conversations, also
distinguishing between NLU- and LLM-based chatbots. Furthermore, we discuss how
understanding the differences among the conversation styles guides the
developer on how to shape their expectations from a conversation and
consequently support the communication within a software team. We conclude that
the recent conversation styles that we observe with LLM-chatbots can not
replace conversations with humans due to certain attributes regarding social
aspects despite their ability to support productivity and decrease the
developers' mental load.
|
[
-0.5456311106681824,
-0.8844851851463318,
0.3219772279262543,
0.34162309765815735,
0.1106761023402214,
0.7945699691772461,
-0.3545539081096649,
-1.02572500705719,
0.17993488907814026,
0.5492678284645081,
-0.7302044034004211,
-0.16231907904148102,
-0.09510581940412521,
0.23877163231372833,
-0.2186548113822937,
0.8989494442939758,
-0.0055455658584833145,
-0.014892409555613995,
-0.49372386932373047,
-0.1229570060968399,
-0.7439253926277161,
-0.6707931756973267,
-0.5947896242141724,
-0.3934893310070038,
0.21801292896270752,
0.228915274143219,
1.0730148553848267,
0.10772907733917236,
0.6003893613815308,
0.4717746376991272,
-0.01228304486721754,
-0.09059471637010574,
-0.48102590441703796,
0.37193095684051514,
0.16377238929271698,
-0.799077033996582,
-0.4058595299720764,
0.03303627297282219,
-0.06572242081165314,
0.6019222736358643,
-0.08755408972501755,
0.197838693857193,
0.36777010560035706,
0.7664541006088257,
-0.22986772656440735,
0.4282968044281006,
-0.41606324911117554,
0.2497340738773346,
0.015372304245829582,
-0.30913054943084717,
-0.34398332238197327,
-0.283845454454422,
0.2627885341644287,
-0.44383084774017334,
0.11354364454746246,
-0.04184916988015175,
0.7583950161933899,
0.4536500573158264,
-0.13672339916229248,
-0.6394760608673096,
-1.0484092235565186,
0.8202869296073914,
-0.7562360763549805,
0.29766571521759033,
0.3201312720775604,
0.20330870151519775,
-0.6286779642105103,
-0.15098130702972412,
-0.5827947854995728,
-0.43598803877830505,
-0.19804778695106506,
0.127298504114151,
-0.059612203389406204,
0.3069876730442047,
0.02056266739964485,
0.18461596965789795,
-0.5840206742286682,
0.28630518913269043,
-0.6037310361862183,
-0.15055613219738007,
1.039469838142395,
0.20434172451496124,
0.49602681398391724,
-0.08110912144184113,
-0.09443794935941696,
0.07175648212432861,
-0.38189730048179626,
0.058441489934921265,
0.42188751697540283,
0.10212212800979614,
-0.4829188287258148,
0.286258339881897,
0.09282564371824265,
0.6435018181800842,
-0.15186649560928345,
-0.10572526603937149,
0.19022974371910095,
-0.41921818256378174,
-0.13089407980442047,
-0.24876460433006287,
0.7076727151870728,
0.5072876811027527,
0.6016891002655029,
-0.40541452169418335,
0.12613633275032043,
0.2673531770706177,
0.5040326118469238,
-0.14318054914474487,
-0.3008217215538025,
0.3559662103652954,
-0.45550116896629333,
-0.5275732278823853,
0.019879983738064766,
-0.5762335658073425,
-0.7093844413757324,
-0.4448843002319336,
-0.03290683776140213,
0.12184304744005203,
-0.3382549583911896,
-0.15278013050556183,
-0.15557599067687988,
0.6526459455490112,
0.508915901184082,
-0.6385732889175415,
0.5314481854438782,
0.9800902009010315,
0.41210782527923584,
-0.16590510308742523,
-0.2732066214084625,
-0.13610662519931793,
-0.16794805228710175,
-0.41640570759773254,
0.6727553606033325,
-0.1306988149881363,
-0.7113537192344666,
-0.28390175104141235,
-0.4825590252876282,
0.31266865134239197,
-0.6462206244468689,
-0.09101620316505432,
-0.13649390637874603,
0.6194981932640076,
0.23391184210777283,
-0.135671928524971,
-0.07544355094432831,
0.28762581944465637,
-0.12626492977142334,
0.7525807023048401,
0.009436032734811306,
-0.3937603831291199,
0.21975721418857574,
-0.9872118830680847,
-0.5452417731285095,
0.26753148436546326,
-0.5681344866752625,
-0.13690298795700073,
0.11769063770771027,
-0.2715071141719818,
0.3107144832611084,
-0.5704100131988525,
0.21829019486904144,
-0.22736752033233643,
-0.35279911756515503,
0.47125136852264404,
0.04921872913837433,
0.7609256505966187,
0.21387514472007751,
-0.22442886233329773,
0.31988000869750977,
-0.4549567699432373,
0.01741056516766548,
0.10997951030731201,
-0.14756067097187042,
0.06421678513288498,
0.46864914894104004,
-0.10743652284145355,
0.27342796325683594,
0.04579558223485947,
-0.3167698085308075,
0.1232956126332283,
-0.48210984468460083,
0.6511878967285156,
0.7628164291381836,
-0.10453900694847107,
0.8233434557914734,
-0.5171198844909668,
0.4969981014728546,
-0.2467147409915924,
0.546349048614502,
-0.12087661027908325,
-0.7502103447914124,
-0.5456098318099976,
0.10134615749120712,
-0.12722517549991608,
0.8202713131904602,
-0.3421442210674286,
0.4142361283302307,
-0.21972689032554626,
-0.4769895672798157,
-0.7144811153411865,
0.4240955114364624,
0.08937482535839081,
0.3766406178474426,
0.020259495824575424,
-0.5595657825469971,
-0.6526781916618347,
-0.5774710178375244,
-0.18952147662639618,
-0.746702253818512,
-0.2583465874195099,
0.7184158563613892,
0.19505032896995544,
-0.21779848635196686,
1.5044792890548706,
-0.2969658374786377,
-0.022577574476599693,
-0.6248258948326111,
0.06844963133335114,
-0.0738687515258789,
0.4410863518714905,
0.39216864109039307,
-0.9843036532402039,
-0.5858906507492065,
0.044909339398145676,
-0.9162979125976562,
0.029803186655044556,
-0.5008203387260437,
-0.17285794019699097,
0.4076128900051117,
0.5752357244491577,
-0.5239230990409851,
0.5594820380210876,
0.4916400611400604,
-0.16322247684001923,
0.2705327868461609,
0.04924965649843216,
0.03425487130880356,
-1.1516203880310059,
-0.35925906896591187,
0.04797663912177086,
-0.0861368179321289,
-0.7522823810577393,
0.03318974748253822,
-0.35598433017730713,
-0.2336658537387848,
-0.4969397187232971,
0.49868813157081604,
-0.43760934472084045,
-0.3784528970718384,
-0.13934431970119476,
0.5654221773147583,
-0.15198002755641937,
0.5069446563720703,
-0.13496622443199158,
0.8182424902915955,
0.5860673785209656,
-0.6241769194602966,
0.661587119102478,
0.5758295655250549,
-0.046849966049194336,
0.6016747355461121,
-0.8343648910522461,
0.4706488847732544,
-0.06251239776611328,
0.3175627887248993,
-0.8633427023887634,
-0.09408235549926758,
0.2018989771604538,
-0.8841642737388611,
-0.014639530330896378,
0.01599440537393093,
-0.821195662021637,
-0.5522544980049133,
-0.6194244027137756,
-0.14146699011325836,
0.607230007648468,
0.1043471246957779,
0.5963242650032043,
0.5142831802368164,
-0.4855233132839203,
-0.08836972713470459,
-0.8563998937606812,
0.5184609293937683,
-0.23716026544570923,
-1.185625433921814,
0.2691207826137543,
-0.20725029706954956,
-0.8481873869895935,
-0.29474833607673645,
0.1779332160949707,
-0.2930357754230499,
0.5442029237747192,
0.5558799505233765,
0.7177536487579346,
-0.2949662208557129,
0.11796187609434128,
-0.4056881070137024,
-0.14332956075668335,
0.21728554368019104,
0.3959527313709259,
0.7307465076446533,
-0.041002415120601654,
-0.4008345901966095,
-0.6407039165496826,
0.33840879797935486,
0.3741185665130615,
0.027305349707603455,
0.7353012561798096,
0.42065897583961487,
0.05234934762120247,
0.449806809425354,
-0.6824511289596558,
-0.5840187072753906,
-0.5027437210083008,
0.33291757106781006,
-0.002373666502535343,
-0.8608077168464661,
0.6213377118110657,
-0.15013504028320312,
0.48467501997947693,
0.15301837027072906,
0.34313252568244934,
-0.7078239917755127,
0.9585357904434204,
0.9669618010520935,
-0.23956698179244995,
0.6210145354270935,
0.15552112460136414,
0.16709569096565247,
-0.6151391267776489,
-0.20862480998039246,
-0.5725486278533936,
-0.5907325744628906,
-0.6882246732711792,
0.08292412012815475,
0.11311300098896027,
0.06864659488201141,
-0.17307385802268982,
0.3956165015697479,
-0.519059419631958,
0.23233871161937714,
0.2005380094051361,
-0.20529837906360626,
0.20492805540561676,
-0.48826560378074646,
0.5792466998100281,
-0.11737507581710815,
-0.4866456687450409,
-0.4361753761768341,
0.7105953097343445,
0.22204257547855377,
0.7685129046440125,
0.2584410607814789,
0.7605596780776978,
0.5131775140762329,
0.22253382205963135,
-0.7396429181098938,
0.6730213761329651,
0.5418676137924194,
-0.39260298013687134,
-0.21736659109592438,
-0.22942934930324554,
-0.961523711681366,
-0.026914823800325394,
-0.4676828384399414,
-1.0413340330123901,
-0.4080248177051544,
-0.11293628066778183,
-0.18771801888942719,
-0.027620865032076836,
-1.0417741537094116,
0.8747336268424988,
-0.5390663743019104,
-0.043943941593170166,
-0.4879104495048523,
-1.0491329431533813,
0.09536673873662949,
0.0275710616260767,
0.3465435802936554,
-0.24131175875663757,
0.23220890760421753,
0.34534114599227905,
-0.2550370693206787,
1.081833004951477,
0.3561716377735138,
-0.2036154866218567,
0.49349743127822876,
0.0629553273320198,
0.4050973057746887,
-0.20342524349689484,
0.0002474891080055386,
0.03438843786716461,
-0.29419752955436707,
-0.38463178277015686,
-0.5904797911643982,
0.21691225469112396,
-0.9427109360694885,
-0.8304187655448914,
-0.1612633466720581,
-0.5905103087425232,
-0.04259162396192551,
-0.21041004359722137,
-0.11031447350978851,
0.10185276716947556,
-0.2927217185497284,
-0.008261347189545631,
0.06093580275774002,
-0.6227911114692688,
0.4717872440814972,
0.2573637366294861,
-0.40342527627944946,
0.23763881623744965,
0.5444885492324829,
-0.27138033509254456,
0.5786987543106079,
0.14942312240600586,
0.09511055797338486,
0.13987383246421814,
-0.06113943085074425,
-0.22824408113956451,
0.09392927587032318,
-0.4028848707675934,
0.06507763266563416,
-0.5773096680641174,
-0.2521226704120636,
-0.46730417013168335,
-0.5977917313575745,
-0.16137824952602386,
-0.21041303873062134,
-0.3658496141433716,
0.12964028120040894,
0.6540470719337463,
0.9217557907104492,
0.30208149552345276,
0.11364887654781342,
-1.0201969146728516,
0.16607427597045898,
-0.023318568244576454,
-0.049721404910087585,
0.1084601953625679,
-0.25112056732177734,
0.12647579610347748,
0.06962853670120239,
-0.6829404830932617,
-0.8403069972991943,
0.14638936519622803,
-0.03284633904695511,
0.4788955748081207,
-0.04542035982012749,
0.1574481576681137,
0.6653042435646057,
0.025533070787787437,
1.0857595205307007,
0.06492694467306137,
-0.7611503601074219,
0.7294540405273438,
-0.11980103701353073,
0.1541096717119217,
0.3425705134868622,
0.04903954267501831,
-0.8921602368354797,
-0.6034459471702576,
-0.597000777721405,
-0.7712523341178894,
0.5541631579399109,
0.2795432209968567,
0.45191025733947754,
0.39339348673820496,
0.1614460051059723,
-0.0012492105597630143,
0.24936284124851227,
-0.555779755115509,
-0.2945537269115448,
0.4087914228439331,
-0.012711427174508572,
0.09533225744962692,
0.11276256293058395,
-0.08564512431621552,
-0.15557540953159332,
0.030215848237276077,
0.044611070305109024,
0.38964900374412537,
-0.28654468059539795,
-0.16983520984649658,
0.08122144639492035,
0.4944915175437927,
0.5962613821029663,
0.6727542877197266,
0.14181092381477356,
-0.2216280698776245,
0.3358638882637024,
-0.24810966849327087,
-0.2994798719882965,
-0.20260868966579437,
0.2677590847015381,
-0.2908317744731903,
0.24101263284683228,
0.5774816274642944,
0.19527724385261536,
-0.6838783025741577,
0.2165735512971878,
-0.032807640731334686,
-0.0655851885676384,
-0.24157845973968506,
0.33942264318466187,
0.2841719686985016,
0.46634694933891296,
0.34893688559532166,
0.31139513850212097,
-0.052184026688337326,
-0.9817787408828735,
-0.0338246151804924,
0.48903295397758484,
-0.472657710313797,
-0.35559430718421936,
0.40865519642829895,
0.7157557010650635,
-1.0005640983581543,
0.7012896537780762,
-0.14365534484386444,
-0.4561663269996643,
0.7238501310348511,
0.2972073256969452,
1.0764933824539185,
0.27168428897857666,
0.31701529026031494,
-0.2852979898452759,
-0.10848651081323624,
0.3781925141811371,
0.36049994826316833,
-0.36265280842781067,
-0.7006963491439819,
-0.45517945289611816,
0.058262139558792114,
-0.8712982535362244,
-0.423060804605484,
-0.2996256351470947,
0.348720520734787,
-0.3286746144294739,
-0.2512987554073334,
0.2155281901359558,
0.019827520474791527,
-0.5661792755126953,
-0.4461454153060913,
0.08938904851675034,
0.3237599730491638,
-0.24469450116157532,
0.4992164671421051,
0.8107033371925354,
-0.43921107053756714,
-0.45411694049835205,
-0.04378187283873558,
0.3015720546245575,
-0.6107710599899292,
0.6513019800186157,
0.005290469154715538,
-0.1691358983516693,
-0.11747303605079651,
-0.7446496486663818,
-0.29166772961616516,
1.0530622005462646,
0.11660118401050568,
-0.28761085867881775,
-0.08308606594800949,
0.3273817300796509,
0.8594484329223633,
-0.10015616565942764,
0.2893941402435303,
0.03447197377681732,
0.19426150619983673,
0.028268523514270782,
-1.419027328491211,
-0.3894493579864502,
-0.16200925409793854,
0.007293198723345995,
0.2841009795665741,
-0.7604725360870361,
0.5137274861335754,
-0.3484035134315491,
-0.24806831777095795,
0.14013561606407166,
0.6191409230232239,
0.13190636038780212,
0.342591255903244,
0.2289648950099945,
-0.4436139464378357,
0.6154806613922119,
-0.0391889251768589,
0.9184311628341675,
-0.6731751561164856,
0.1150921955704689,
0.8314968347549438,
-0.5430566072463989,
0.7231886386871338,
0.6048380732536316,
-0.5516500473022461,
0.506943941116333,
0.38330358266830444,
-0.01001336332410574,
-0.18451429903507233,
0.4428393542766571,
-0.24494940042495728,
0.22157536447048187,
-0.06476743519306183,
-0.27691736817359924,
0.344555526971817,
0.23896387219429016,
0.10248598456382751,
0.14174796640872955,
0.14926336705684662,
0.12963110208511353,
0.09319300204515457,
-0.018165510147809982,
1.1500048637390137,
0.1578022688627243,
-0.5715555548667908,
0.29158875346183777,
-0.20927122235298157,
1.0290565490722656,
-0.20605045557022095,
0.14759424328804016,
-0.07667935639619827,
0.22543443739414215,
-0.36158621311187744,
-1.1501030921936035,
0.5539421439170837,
0.11669328808784485,
0.0323057621717453,
-0.3181476593017578,
0.6960039734840393,
-0.012210735119879246,
-0.07037190347909927,
0.30531731247901917,
0.7522421479225159,
0.4073936641216278,
-0.056413643062114716,
-0.8728968501091003,
0.12611238658428192,
-0.08722303807735443,
0.11180131137371063,
0.46828317642211914,
0.17908911406993866,
0.012825097888708115,
0.9411078691482544,
0.5658311247825623,
-0.20700982213020325,
-0.07622910290956497,
-0.006273017264902592,
0.8084264397621155,
-0.653564453125,
-0.35883548855781555,
-0.9596611857414246,
0.4554238021373749,
-0.0496007539331913,
-0.28604596853256226,
0.6568650007247925,
0.345834344625473,
0.651558518409729,
0.09033671021461487,
0.6410036683082581,
-0.22687003016471863,
0.3053726255893707,
-0.11135163903236389,
0.7351258993148804,
-0.21437282860279083,
0.2586876451969147,
-0.5443077683448792,
-0.8409922122955322,
-0.19995050132274628,
0.6813498139381409,
-0.047087330371141434,
0.0867120549082756,
0.14816318452358246,
0.6434484720230103,
0.30685514211654663,
0.37439069151878357,
0.08719811588525772,
0.08962143957614899,
0.5694738626480103,
0.3514906167984009,
1.0277392864227295,
-0.14596980810165405,
0.5370428562164307,
-0.005594996269792318,
-0.06607652455568314,
-0.16632018983364105,
-0.5776875615119934,
-0.6854827404022217,
-0.5512649416923523,
-0.3781617283821106,
-0.39435580372810364,
0.08504972606897354,
1.1953904628753662,
0.474508136510849,
-0.5395374298095703,
-0.6455795168876648,
-0.26450735330581665,
0.32316476106643677,
0.06319363415241241,
-0.3174568712711334,
-0.4490946829319,
-0.4383428394794464,
-0.5436126589775085,
0.2250303477048874,
0.5260319113731384,
0.20352886617183685,
-0.6213117241859436,
-0.3599284887313843,
0.027059445157647133,
-0.018059348687529564,
0.6002558469772339,
0.7451869249343872,
-0.6056800484657288,
-0.1259501725435257,
0.17597955465316772,
-0.33420896530151367,
0.5796136260032654,
0.6817772388458252,
-0.9641400575637817,
0.1719280481338501,
0.41599705815315247,
0.6279708743095398,
0.3312593400478363,
-0.040262941271066666,
0.9032023549079895,
-0.6072518229484558,
0.38480663299560547,
0.22001662850379944,
-0.23064319789409637,
0.40633657574653625,
-0.3543471693992615,
0.6843103170394897,
0.1499149203300476,
-0.7677155137062073,
-0.7879498600959778,
0.31562307476997375,
-0.813010036945343,
-0.039372820407152176,
0.855010986328125,
0.19094158709049225,
0.2508442997932434,
-0.5507214665412903,
-0.5806776285171509,
0.09971512109041214,
-0.4275650680065155,
0.8525484204292297,
0.6359363198280334,
-0.7247539758682251,
-0.3750191032886505,
-0.7206463813781738,
0.4843812882900238,
0.28620439767837524,
-1.0412852764129639,
-0.1150755062699318,
0.14922142028808594,
-0.13889586925506592,
0.42845624685287476,
0.6969858407974243,
0.07144954800605774,
0.056907668709754944,
-0.061490658670663834,
0.1049659475684166,
0.38724198937416077,
-0.001086818054318428,
0.23812225461006165,
-0.20498324930667877,
0.2599231004714966,
-0.158845454454422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12705v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12705v1
|
Multimodal Adaptive Inference for Document Image Classification with Anytime Early Exiting
| 2024-05-21T11:52:14 | 2024-05-21T11:52:14 |
Omar Hamed, Souhail Bakkali, Marie-Francine Moens, Matthew Blaschko, Jordy Van Landeghem
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This work addresses the need for a balanced approach between performance and
efficiency in scalable production environments for visually-rich document
understanding (VDU) tasks. Currently, there is a reliance on large document
foundation models that offer advanced capabilities but come with a heavy
computational burden. In this paper, we propose a multimodal early exit (EE)
model design that incorporates various training strategies, exit layer types
and placements. Our goal is to achieve a Pareto-optimal balance between
predictive performance and efficiency for multimodal document image
classification. Through a comprehensive set of experiments, we compare our
approach with traditional exit policies and showcase an improved
performance-efficiency trade-off. Our multimodal EE design preserves the
model's predictive capabilities, enhancing both speed and latency. This is
achieved through a reduction of over 20% in latency, while fully retaining the
baseline accuracy. This research represents the first exploration of multimodal
EE design within the VDU community, highlighting as well the effectiveness of
calibration in improving confidence scores for exiting at different layers.
Overall, our findings contribute to practical VDU applications by enhancing
both performance and efficiency.
|
[
-0.4150383472442627,
-0.5785053968429565,
0.8332259654998779,
0.17038872838020325,
-0.14833968877792358,
0.00856759212911129,
-0.35795876383781433,
-0.4231286644935608,
-0.4036637544631958,
0.15101978182792664,
-0.4713333547115326,
-0.16021136939525604,
-0.7876728177070618,
-0.25847265124320984,
-0.27642571926116943,
0.5079857707023621,
-0.25341299176216125,
-0.0657881498336792,
-0.5763466358184814,
-0.20543211698532104,
-0.34975379705429077,
-0.1827315241098404,
-0.7527139186859131,
-0.18502694368362427,
0.7221088409423828,
0.3649008870124817,
0.4096122086048126,
0.7397229671478271,
0.20117226243019104,
0.4033339023590088,
0.04592054709792137,
0.3271830379962921,
-0.28720855712890625,
-0.1393410861492157,
-0.0655977874994278,
-0.3411163091659546,
-0.3453262746334076,
0.021643036976456642,
0.25357484817504883,
0.45068472623825073,
-0.3018089830875397,
-0.18592748045921326,
0.11119356006383896,
0.262580543756485,
-0.9008872509002686,
0.41761088371276855,
-0.2815625071525574,
0.15224727988243103,
-0.1861279159784317,
-0.3852076232433319,
-1.157633900642395,
0.04849648475646973,
-0.04660676419734955,
-0.9077364206314087,
0.22478049993515015,
-0.005528001580387354,
0.9322682619094849,
0.07178982347249985,
-0.5801838636398315,
-0.20231863856315613,
-0.4948331415653229,
0.9033784866333008,
-0.2627345323562622,
0.9664385318756104,
0.14452379941940308,
0.38606691360473633,
0.08136197179555893,
-0.8015339374542236,
-0.7038792967796326,
0.11149684339761734,
0.1412806510925293,
0.4764499068260193,
-0.34591084718704224,
0.00799285713583231,
0.0037585676182061434,
0.027258558198809624,
-0.46699920296669006,
0.32154223322868347,
-0.30308935046195984,
-0.20686258375644684,
-0.03798150271177292,
-0.15138450264930725,
0.06622403860092163,
-0.13753947615623474,
-0.5996487736701965,
-0.4752386212348938,
0.15304920077323914,
0.415416955947876,
0.14633376896381378,
-0.14651747047901154,
-0.17838332056999207,
0.2637735903263092,
0.005153011996299028,
0.5727667808532715,
-0.03867252916097641,
-0.27444273233413696,
0.4951546788215637,
-0.12923860549926758,
-0.25525012612342834,
-0.29011741280555725,
0.40786394476890564,
0.6471542119979858,
-0.24953335523605347,
-0.09010143578052521,
-0.3349640965461731,
0.2973601520061493,
0.40967056155204773,
-0.9047619104385376,
-0.1219479963183403,
0.12357526272535324,
-0.768220067024231,
-0.2942034900188446,
-0.15239454805850983,
-0.8905865550041199,
-0.32618606090545654,
-0.49003100395202637,
0.5779378414154053,
-0.7779968976974487,
-0.22240856289863586,
-0.06446454674005508,
-0.266275554895401,
0.2741571068763733,
0.9662564396858215,
-0.39799243211746216,
0.03513369336724281,
0.20947788655757904,
0.9343798160552979,
-0.000667674234136939,
-0.34656068682670593,
-1.0812143087387085,
0.1249128207564354,
-0.13159748911857605,
0.8196502923965454,
-0.5692353248596191,
-0.3969820737838745,
-0.1109704077243805,
0.1964767873287201,
-0.2028595507144928,
0.07503272593021393,
0.8260897994041443,
-0.715690553188324,
0.4430670440196991,
0.33124008774757385,
-0.22653253376483917,
-0.5122690796852112,
0.27905264496803284,
-0.6699547171592712,
0.4474373161792755,
0.06444545090198517,
-0.5938782095909119,
0.606473982334137,
-0.6963329911231995,
-0.16989025473594666,
-0.11650729179382324,
-0.01782985031604767,
-0.4895656704902649,
0.3159389793872833,
0.3609079420566559,
0.607361376285553,
-0.1621226817369461,
-0.1711128205060959,
-0.6019009351730347,
-0.29918670654296875,
-0.06868302077054977,
-0.6079446077346802,
0.4628124535083771,
0.594393253326416,
-0.12126148492097855,
-0.10918978601694107,
-1.0829436779022217,
0.23788627982139587,
0.01600341498851776,
-0.4872349798679352,
-0.5393792390823364,
0.06402388215065002,
0.3816702663898468,
0.3643961250782013,
0.12028086930513382,
-0.49506738781929016,
-0.02836381457746029,
0.24624764919281006,
0.08074893802404404,
1.101420521736145,
-0.3518105745315552,
0.7190701961517334,
-0.27110278606414795,
0.4272269010543823,
0.23119214177131653,
0.2963927090167999,
-0.5442560315132141,
-0.3825910687446594,
-0.6657077670097351,
-0.7752565741539001,
0.204596608877182,
0.3389336168766022,
-0.9813354015350342,
0.07811624556779861,
-0.32339879870414734,
-0.5602113008499146,
-0.1723201721906662,
0.15609101951122284,
0.5191013216972351,
0.6219927668571472,
0.3665449321269989,
-0.518802285194397,
-0.20459651947021484,
-0.6305004954338074,
0.1497359722852707,
-0.21174825727939606,
0.13113132119178772,
0.30736416578292847,
0.22881107032299042,
-0.39841940999031067,
0.5323184728622437,
-0.4686645269393921,
-0.20516540110111237,
0.004946261178702116,
0.6156618595123291,
0.3348275125026703,
0.39184829592704773,
0.5451400876045227,
-1.056939959526062,
-0.2585829198360443,
0.2782614827156067,
-0.8479414582252502,
-0.035848572850227356,
-0.5353178381919861,
-0.2601749897003174,
0.13207267224788666,
0.37363308668136597,
-0.5003473162651062,
0.46346068382263184,
0.4862830638885498,
-0.25735995173454285,
0.16507837176322937,
-0.464852511882782,
0.3384633958339691,
-0.8356043100357056,
-0.3999331593513489,
0.4692028760910034,
-0.05322710797190666,
-0.4805294871330261,
-0.01648290455341339,
0.7419784069061279,
-0.23535172641277313,
-0.580986738204956,
0.5127423405647278,
-0.7028682231903076,
-0.05234747752547264,
-0.05365869775414467,
-0.1301371306180954,
0.6687217950820923,
0.4489562511444092,
0.39027833938598633,
0.5531609654426575,
0.47050878405570984,
-0.6821224689483643,
-0.11114451289176941,
0.15091681480407715,
-0.23356041312217712,
0.898194432258606,
-0.1976400464773178,
0.10169389098882675,
-0.5968061685562134,
0.25383731722831726,
-1.2022879123687744,
-0.312551349401474,
-0.0874502956867218,
-0.5636417269706726,
0.6930366158485413,
-0.1361900269985199,
-0.030154038220643997,
-0.3513737618923187,
-0.5173921585083008,
0.16351370513439178,
0.3404706120491028,
-0.7645448446273804,
1.2161976099014282,
-0.18241295218467712,
-0.001654371153563261,
-0.5872160196304321,
-0.6692847013473511,
-0.07557398080825806,
-0.11076970398426056,
-0.9473052024841309,
0.39661553502082825,
-0.09758656471967697,
0.01059264037758112,
0.0034900507889688015,
0.07205533981323242,
-0.2655852138996124,
-0.0316370390355587,
0.37071290612220764,
0.3268857002258301,
-0.20117256045341492,
0.1616535782814026,
0.22638580203056335,
-0.09043938666582108,
-0.1864480972290039,
-0.05144849047064781,
0.26811566948890686,
-0.09255874156951904,
-0.31992462277412415,
-0.3399861752986908,
0.5097436308860779,
0.9732080698013306,
-0.3585015535354614,
0.9471672177314758,
1.0927499532699585,
-0.342586874961853,
-0.16546083986759186,
-0.6538702845573425,
0.1524890512228012,
-0.44713619351387024,
0.364292174577713,
-0.6107988357543945,
-0.034008026123046875,
0.44105952978134155,
-0.10500737279653549,
0.25127652287483215,
0.33757275342941284,
0.44590941071510315,
-0.5003130435943604,
0.7554066181182861,
0.8825569748878479,
0.6780158877372742,
0.8202558755874634,
-0.44429993629455566,
0.014485448598861694,
-0.8035839200019836,
-0.4933142066001892,
-0.38985881209373474,
-0.08416133373975754,
-0.25957703590393066,
-0.48158374428749084,
0.5167155265808105,
0.09596312046051025,
0.11004509031772614,
0.15228348970413208,
-0.15812262892723083,
0.31731101870536804,
0.4778166711330414,
0.5558872818946838,
-0.019855184480547905,
0.039143070578575134,
-0.08459681272506714,
-0.016300514340400696,
-0.6864382028579712,
-0.264495313167572,
1.1200000047683716,
0.4199325144290924,
0.988044023513794,
0.2972293794155121,
0.6849713325500488,
0.4260937571525574,
0.44058680534362793,
-0.5520602464675903,
0.2275020033121109,
-0.24159899353981018,
-0.19001343846321106,
-0.08441142737865448,
-0.2504323422908783,
-0.6156886219978333,
0.4686289131641388,
-0.2676122486591339,
-0.4394514262676239,
0.7207326889038086,
-0.037011414766311646,
-0.28034162521362305,
0.18531334400177002,
-1.373704433441162,
1.0571147203445435,
-0.39496442675590515,
-0.8178793787956238,
0.013694827444851398,
-0.46637028455734253,
0.4645695984363556,
-0.3345390260219574,
0.5103012919425964,
0.22897735238075256,
-0.23755253851413727,
0.5601213574409485,
-0.30516284704208374,
0.5627893209457397,
-0.31302952766418457,
0.22423198819160461,
0.032432667911052704,
-0.07965290546417236,
0.5288650393486023,
-0.19295251369476318,
-0.40142741799354553,
0.06310896575450897,
-0.23438557982444763,
-0.42567092180252075,
-0.45792436599731445,
0.6242420077323914,
-0.943784236907959,
0.09989699721336365,
-0.41251230239868164,
-0.3290781080722809,
-0.08780042082071304,
0.35140880942344666,
0.2879035174846649,
0.8185101747512817,
0.19980044662952423,
0.4680068790912628,
0.8071380853652954,
-0.3470483124256134,
0.8495588898658752,
0.33278581500053406,
0.11858663707971573,
-0.3261748254299164,
0.9276451468467712,
-0.0050110649317502975,
0.11929678916931152,
0.3715440630912781,
0.20670239627361298,
-0.9095364809036255,
-0.6658955812454224,
-0.625342607498169,
-0.19033488631248474,
-1.187442421913147,
-0.0758003517985344,
-0.8698956966400146,
0.05518787354230881,
-0.5037341117858887,
-0.4835113286972046,
-0.23328185081481934,
0.11954090744256973,
-0.6335592865943909,
0.1661335527896881,
-0.07275301218032837,
0.27153071761131287,
-0.11509629338979721,
0.3540118932723999,
-0.8791583180427551,
0.3199752867221832,
0.2823297083377838,
0.34824255108833313,
-0.006700958590954542,
-0.6197906136512756,
-0.08207570761442184,
-0.5699182152748108,
-0.6311864256858826,
-0.8407639861106873,
0.1656373143196106,
0.49666959047317505,
1.0367505550384521,
0.7854752540588379,
0.0614497996866703,
0.568707287311554,
-0.21017812192440033,
0.47121956944465637,
0.7376861572265625,
-0.6441100835800171,
0.21672941744327545,
-0.30032995343208313,
0.1418866515159607,
0.3886261582374573,
0.4592076539993286,
-0.22426946461200714,
0.27919113636016846,
-0.35357609391212463,
-0.7719685435295105,
0.695185124874115,
0.03634060546755791,
-0.13600783050060272,
0.10199416428804398,
-0.14340604841709137,
0.2665870189666748,
0.19350285828113556,
-0.7890896797180176,
0.2457575500011444,
-0.5333995223045349,
-0.07529975473880768,
-0.2021666169166565,
-0.18520262837409973,
0.16840359568595886,
-0.053740493953228,
0.3869023323059082,
-0.38230621814727783,
0.3931879699230194,
-0.0834788829088211,
-0.44781607389450073,
0.04843193292617798,
0.3047252893447876,
0.6270057559013367,
0.8851379156112671,
-0.365578830242157,
0.07573691010475159,
-0.05734216794371605,
-0.14814411103725433,
0.4102613925933838,
0.11811459809541702,
0.14973199367523193,
-0.09764402359724045,
0.572346031665802,
0.7470252513885498,
0.12791799008846283,
-0.40570053458213806,
0.7497972846031189,
-0.40130987763404846,
-0.2553378641605377,
-0.18383947014808655,
-0.11861179769039154,
-0.2883477509021759,
0.3306264877319336,
0.3087204098701477,
0.4307968020439148,
0.1569748818874359,
-0.6061435341835022,
0.36300650238990784,
0.055299971252679825,
0.02685176581144333,
0.0906827300786972,
0.9998404383659363,
0.4061315357685089,
0.043836671859025955,
0.5352073907852173,
-0.2904132008552551,
-0.2054276168346405,
0.4941393733024597,
0.19548872113227844,
0.8530437350273132,
-0.0381523035466671,
0.2934698760509491,
0.08159171789884567,
0.28811949491500854,
0.19293640553951263,
0.027058031409978867,
-0.25993889570236206,
-0.6307491660118103,
-0.3836343288421631,
-0.7690179347991943,
-0.32152438163757324,
-0.06579120457172394,
-0.6760956645011902,
0.40018707513809204,
-0.47371259331703186,
-0.20407013595104218,
0.09667093306779861,
-0.287304162979126,
-0.8806972503662109,
0.5381455421447754,
0.5244544148445129,
0.9073225855827332,
-0.8075613379478455,
0.6281651854515076,
0.6881284117698669,
-0.37321141362190247,
-0.2177622765302658,
-0.16824111342430115,
0.18465667963027954,
-0.4996463656425476,
0.6019766926765442,
0.4924136698246002,
-0.28720182180404663,
-0.3215605914592743,
-0.11973640322685242,
-0.26604795455932617,
1.2220606803894043,
0.1452643871307373,
-0.4061155915260315,
-0.2670741081237793,
-0.5265293121337891,
0.18471640348434448,
-0.3426358103752136,
0.7989218831062317,
0.137746199965477,
0.5720837116241455,
0.2631695866584778,
-0.3206644356250763,
-0.40922942757606506,
-0.46395596861839294,
0.35004517436027527,
-0.029728882014751434,
-0.7490827441215515,
1.1399215459823608,
-0.19082392752170563,
-0.05969389155507088,
-0.008974025025963783,
0.6572643518447876,
-0.11292964220046997,
0.8484008312225342,
0.9791348576545715,
0.6417949199676514,
0.5343284010887146,
-0.17141777276992798,
1.2590336799621582,
-0.053769711405038834,
0.05978890880942345,
0.9519175291061401,
-0.06011822819709778,
0.6371521353721619,
0.6305162906646729,
0.14459212124347687,
0.423469603061676,
0.9222021698951721,
0.33649539947509766,
0.930308997631073,
-0.40338364243507385,
-0.13845838606357574,
-0.5479992032051086,
0.015873922035098076,
-0.33240583539009094,
0.6511567234992981,
0.28639841079711914,
-0.29918211698532104,
-0.3216298818588257,
0.3669976592063904,
-0.2879040241241455,
0.08334861695766449,
-0.35248154401779175,
0.4733405113220215,
-0.3223113417625427,
-0.4509613811969757,
0.25230029225349426,
0.23847755789756775,
0.6344906091690063,
-0.6584205031394958,
-0.05113985762000084,
-0.17788046598434448,
0.41095614433288574,
-0.16785259544849396,
-0.7993065118789673,
-0.1488136500120163,
-0.25416135787963867,
-0.26984894275665283,
-0.5228197574615479,
0.6763503551483154,
-0.17546680569648743,
-0.5245195627212524,
0.4727709889411926,
0.48468494415283203,
-0.13249561190605164,
0.152213916182518,
-0.5470069646835327,
0.4907437264919281,
-0.19027206301689148,
-0.4374624788761139,
0.2711392939090729,
0.6881904602050781,
-0.0355599969625473,
0.45889702439308167,
0.896393358707428,
-0.2066836804151535,
0.48274168372154236,
-0.11989995092153549,
0.9785484075546265,
-0.21353060007095337,
-0.8012082576751709,
-0.472209632396698,
0.6977965235710144,
-0.2663138210773468,
-0.21749655902385712,
0.34904587268829346,
0.35057830810546875,
0.7803674936294556,
-0.2599548399448395,
0.6862931251525879,
-0.1079116240143776,
-0.019672328606247902,
-0.8062983155250549,
0.5048481822013855,
-1.125633716583252,
-0.10760238766670227,
-0.577928900718689,
-0.8182206749916077,
0.04507559537887573,
0.446403443813324,
-0.1755354255437851,
0.1295311152935028,
0.7082885503768921,
0.5200556516647339,
-0.5343518853187561,
-0.2364770919084549,
0.5268819332122803,
-0.08445047587156296,
0.6818622946739197,
0.7821084260940552,
0.6761819124221802,
-0.38472023606300354,
0.6298907399177551,
-0.47053614258766174,
-0.5290992856025696,
-0.36247238516807556,
-1.1305021047592163,
-0.5879386067390442,
-0.5397123694419861,
-0.2238079309463501,
-0.2808184325695038,
-0.1980682611465454,
0.4641851484775543,
1.0444880723953247,
-0.3125409781932831,
0.29683202505111694,
0.3503258526325226,
-0.033282242715358734,
-0.19136682152748108,
-0.20718300342559814,
0.11598856002092361,
-0.2066078782081604,
-0.758703351020813,
0.2965644598007202,
0.3538316488265991,
-0.09696786850690842,
-0.01898493990302086,
-0.30636483430862427,
-0.26034021377563477,
-0.0020205092150717974,
0.7998538017272949,
0.17190688848495483,
-0.6000642776489258,
-0.17917615175247192,
-0.13945946097373962,
-0.07350151240825653,
0.07832086086273193,
0.4919886589050293,
-0.41769731044769287,
0.9824122190475464,
0.4922773540019989,
1.0119942426681519,
0.5633797645568848,
-0.022433029487729073,
0.21213717758655548,
-0.575391948223114,
0.41197776794433594,
-0.11869871616363525,
0.6921033263206482,
0.12664015591144562,
-0.2897997200489044,
0.5492216944694519,
0.383845716714859,
-0.18227596580982208,
-0.7698805332183838,
-0.29812684655189514,
-1.2926419973373413,
-0.13277092576026917,
0.6631062626838684,
-0.34438127279281616,
-0.5789227485656738,
0.1085406094789505,
-0.239371657371521,
0.1018284261226654,
-0.5832469463348389,
0.413039892911911,
0.806770920753479,
-0.19914522767066956,
-0.8457708358764648,
-0.5688358545303345,
-0.3073224127292633,
0.12175831943750381,
-0.864461362361908,
-0.2821502983570099,
0.6305675506591797,
-0.1771135777235031,
0.41779372096061707,
0.6941462755203247,
0.018481895327568054,
0.7643992900848389,
0.18991431593894958,
0.22650328278541565,
-0.3826890289783478,
-0.8537425994873047,
-0.19922275841236115,
0.5578779578208923,
-0.022809654474258423,
-0.6222957968711853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12701v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12701v1
|
OLAPH: Improving Factuality in Biomedical Long-form Question Answering
| 2024-05-21T11:50:16 | 2024-05-21T11:50:16 |
Minbyul Jeong, Hyeon Hwang, Chanwoong Yoon, Taewhoo Lee, Jaewoo Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the medical domain, numerous scenarios necessitate the long-form
generation ability of large language models (LLMs). Specifically, when
addressing patients' questions, it is essential that the model's response
conveys factual claims, highlighting the need for an automated method to
evaluate those claims. Thus, we introduce MedLFQA, a benchmark dataset
reconstructed using long-form question-answering datasets related to the
biomedical domain. We use MedLFQA to facilitate the automatic evaluations of
factuality. We also propose OLAPH, a simple and novel framework that enables
the improvement of factuality through automatic evaluations. The OLAPH
framework iteratively trains LLMs to mitigate hallucinations using sampling
predictions and preference optimization. In other words, we iteratively set the
highest-scoring response as a preferred response derived from sampling
predictions and train LLMs to align with the preferred response that improves
factuality. We highlight that, even on evaluation metrics not used during
training, LLMs trained with our OLAPH framework demonstrate significant
performance improvement in factuality. Our findings reveal that a 7B LLM
trained with our OLAPH framework can provide long answers comparable to the
medical experts' answers in terms of factuality. We believe that our work could
shed light on gauging the long-text generation ability of LLMs in the medical
domain. Our code and datasets are available at
https://github.com/dmis-lab/OLAPH}{https://github.com/dmis-lab/OLAPH.
|
[
-0.10281220078468323,
-1.037889838218689,
1.115197777748108,
-0.2237422913312912,
-0.11681059747934341,
0.12105230987071991,
-0.3424713611602783,
-0.695911169052124,
0.2402985543012619,
0.6145516037940979,
-0.32892197370529175,
-0.47375452518463135,
-0.5416292548179626,
0.25622594356536865,
-0.09235022217035294,
1.2764768600463867,
-0.1553969532251358,
0.1446044147014618,
-0.5430907607078552,
-0.621156632900238,
-0.15037868916988373,
-0.5107549428939819,
-0.5029141902923584,
-0.2899540662765503,
0.7913733124732971,
0.21047452092170715,
0.6750366687774658,
0.6791833639144897,
0.6241868734359741,
0.2770693302154541,
0.14178794622421265,
0.4491805136203766,
-0.513662576675415,
0.2923137843608856,
-0.11272729933261871,
-0.37338581681251526,
-0.5938106179237366,
-0.180893674492836,
0.7320171594619751,
1.0217307806015015,
-0.305056631565094,
0.37190696597099304,
-0.32555070519447327,
0.8428236246109009,
-0.4568944573402405,
0.05132388696074486,
-0.5002034306526184,
0.025669081136584282,
-0.10681568086147308,
-0.35408955812454224,
-0.3637011647224426,
-0.6274765133857727,
0.2902390956878662,
-0.426029235124588,
0.2869641184806824,
0.4858434498310089,
0.6544363498687744,
0.5339246988296509,
-0.4394054114818573,
-0.32358869910240173,
-0.6539731025695801,
0.5556820034980774,
-0.8634320497512817,
0.32767975330352783,
0.4143694043159485,
0.5449931621551514,
-0.1804041713476181,
-0.7429702281951904,
-0.570186197757721,
-0.4820443093776703,
-0.045567288994789124,
0.1539185345172882,
0.0721907839179039,
0.2303369641304016,
0.4209946095943451,
0.5281921625137329,
-0.7946662306785583,
0.017516184598207474,
-0.6170243620872498,
-0.20603446662425995,
0.563991904258728,
0.20886440575122833,
0.20489566028118134,
-0.03249622881412506,
-0.30323660373687744,
0.3027629554271698,
-0.7295786142349243,
-0.16302096843719482,
-0.0017363748047500849,
0.05176210403442383,
0.12397745996713638,
0.7735780477523804,
-0.15841564536094666,
0.4770834147930145,
0.0468447171151638,
-0.3375384211540222,
0.50070720911026,
-0.09022354334592819,
-0.34439030289649963,
0.21182990074157715,
0.4946185350418091,
0.34784114360809326,
-0.28758591413497925,
-0.24193990230560303,
-0.18497511744499207,
0.053602494299411774,
0.41713494062423706,
-0.960943341255188,
-0.014537544921040535,
0.7963625192642212,
-0.6205335855484009,
-0.24464130401611328,
-0.14711998403072357,
-0.5833664536476135,
-0.605671226978302,
-0.3819708824157715,
0.47272881865501404,
-0.5395119190216064,
-0.03361542150378227,
0.5493752956390381,
0.059808921068906784,
0.008233803324401379,
0.4953988492488861,
-0.5474162697792053,
0.5167940855026245,
0.4642236828804016,
0.4559256434440613,
-0.33236098289489746,
-0.11143990606069565,
-0.7830663919448853,
0.0397479273378849,
-0.4996773600578308,
0.8357424139976501,
-0.03330714628100395,
-0.13087838888168335,
0.09253440052270889,
-0.08352658897638321,
-0.1062968373298645,
-0.807125449180603,
0.7788794636726379,
-0.5367433428764343,
0.5521164536476135,
-0.3518500328063965,
-0.7256267666816711,
-0.027712970972061157,
0.41819724440574646,
-0.6329505443572998,
0.8012778759002686,
-0.01410430297255516,
-0.6758338809013367,
0.3176480531692505,
-0.968273401260376,
-0.3977392315864563,
0.0064145964570343494,
-0.3799256980419159,
-0.6581212282180786,
0.21536609530448914,
0.224417045712471,
0.24299004673957825,
-0.4860503077507019,
0.46416783332824707,
-0.25645312666893005,
-0.11343052983283997,
0.5115708708763123,
-0.35298842191696167,
0.600642740726471,
0.13209420442581177,
-0.42154747247695923,
0.1615179032087326,
-0.9225351810455322,
0.12238888442516327,
0.22821883857250214,
-0.42194586992263794,
0.02246285043656826,
-0.0039458912797272205,
-0.22504524886608124,
0.006974840071052313,
0.0007655079825781286,
-0.8860810995101929,
-0.034654829651117325,
-0.7320033311843872,
0.16520068049430847,
0.6234304904937744,
0.0028008362278342247,
0.1412060409784317,
-0.690082311630249,
0.37298786640167236,
-0.0692022368311882,
0.08136381953954697,
-0.09768027812242508,
-0.3982568681240082,
-0.6272220015525818,
-0.5849520564079285,
0.2850213944911957,
0.3598938286304474,
-0.6800752878189087,
0.5127725601196289,
-0.22223734855651855,
-0.10112314671278,
-0.826869547367096,
-0.001225019572302699,
0.32097509503364563,
1.0589144229888916,
0.636293351650238,
-0.21481990814208984,
-0.5260360240936279,
-0.9385068416595459,
-0.051302604377269745,
-0.3884296715259552,
0.014575878158211708,
0.3868328332901001,
0.6706146597862244,
-0.2977331280708313,
0.9540069699287415,
-0.7985509634017944,
-0.1122933104634285,
0.011953518725931644,
0.2887340486049652,
0.22901317477226257,
0.1548691838979721,
0.5563002824783325,
-0.697360098361969,
-0.18168514966964722,
-0.31671249866485596,
-0.7796038389205933,
-0.1390097439289093,
-0.03962153196334839,
-0.13341863453388214,
0.5806724429130554,
0.1761578470468521,
-0.9789283871650696,
0.49163806438446045,
0.28143689036369324,
-0.293349951505661,
0.8405531048774719,
-0.41553959250450134,
0.4915144145488739,
-0.850040853023529,
0.4212372303009033,
-0.46191707253456116,
-0.36522549390792847,
-0.42286521196365356,
0.08066390454769135,
-0.10222660005092621,
-0.07432304322719574,
-0.23282252252101898,
0.659429132938385,
-0.23784896731376648,
0.11101025342941284,
-0.3645273745059967,
0.026559846475720406,
0.20517811179161072,
0.3002391755580902,
-0.06956629455089569,
0.6209107041358948,
0.36562278866767883,
-0.3599262833595276,
0.4291190803050995,
0.446750670671463,
-0.44188472628593445,
0.572542130947113,
-0.7396658062934875,
0.14259184896945953,
-0.4481378495693207,
0.5833262205123901,
-0.9483424425125122,
-0.5931896567344666,
0.3143419623374939,
-0.5454248189926147,
0.2164594978094101,
0.14510847628116608,
-0.749336838722229,
-0.5967192053794861,
-0.365877240896225,
0.3376787006855011,
0.697681188583374,
-0.6232543587684631,
0.39239585399627686,
0.14460591971874237,
-0.1891864538192749,
-0.6008139252662659,
-0.4786681830883026,
0.1723228245973587,
-0.06815347075462341,
-0.6289507150650024,
0.2479301244020462,
-0.45766696333885193,
-0.25631511211395264,
-0.18856921792030334,
-0.2418745458126068,
-0.16465911269187927,
-0.031039375811815262,
0.08681505918502808,
0.4173290431499481,
-0.45799246430397034,
0.604347825050354,
0.14302757382392883,
0.09293993562459946,
0.4828413128852844,
-0.1914944350719452,
0.21859018504619598,
-0.06277704983949661,
-0.5138404965400696,
-0.11134111881256104,
0.41571447253227234,
0.527559757232666,
-0.2986129820346832,
0.8583045601844788,
0.3488141596317291,
-0.42353102564811707,
-0.12355636060237885,
-0.7546191811561584,
-0.2568989098072052,
-0.4054113030433655,
0.47217607498168945,
-0.05081404745578766,
-0.788662850856781,
0.2277691811323166,
-0.10814661532640457,
0.2541217505931854,
0.46966424584388733,
0.7539758086204529,
-0.4117124378681183,
1.0074198246002197,
0.3782351315021515,
0.25263017416000366,
-0.3573094308376312,
0.08766404539346695,
0.12507280707359314,
-0.4193418622016907,
-0.14493189752101898,
-0.4064663350582123,
0.01642671786248684,
-0.35107529163360596,
-0.6720802783966064,
0.6748286485671997,
-0.4708540737628937,
-0.14963358640670776,
-0.3721800148487091,
-0.2742187976837158,
0.3275555372238159,
0.1905033439397812,
0.446368545293808,
0.37721332907676697,
0.007641886360943317,
-0.06015729904174805,
0.1324004977941513,
-0.6640425324440002,
-0.5239791870117188,
1.2193337678909302,
0.6337296962738037,
0.6197110414505005,
0.09132901579141617,
0.699669599533081,
0.22747348248958588,
0.41362011432647705,
-0.8535445332527161,
0.4713422954082489,
0.15404585003852844,
-0.8446516990661621,
-0.2967508137226105,
-0.5681467056274414,
-1.0138953924179077,
-0.005477384198457003,
-0.3922976553440094,
-0.385650634765625,
-0.114631786942482,
0.277567058801651,
-0.7866165041923523,
0.2926073372364044,
-0.24194222688674927,
0.48174557089805603,
-0.4071780741214752,
-0.25662901997566223,
-0.24734987318515778,
-1.082054615020752,
0.34205445647239685,
-0.27043381333351135,
0.0804545059800148,
-0.09963283687829971,
-0.08260492980480194,
0.6543657183647156,
-0.5370845198631287,
0.805939793586731,
-0.05544428527355194,
-0.3313390910625458,
0.173349991440773,
-0.2853902578353882,
0.13135290145874023,
0.15222109854221344,
-0.14704450964927673,
0.07447005063295364,
0.08011007308959961,
-0.4734683334827423,
-0.7264220118522644,
0.47521811723709106,
-0.6396162509918213,
-0.6389465928077698,
-0.46572360396385193,
-0.5727258324623108,
-0.5269001126289368,
0.14961060881614685,
0.1636429876089096,
0.6326759457588196,
-0.4452235698699951,
0.22775223851203918,
1.0927515029907227,
-0.49194273352622986,
-0.10842473059892654,
0.454471230506897,
-0.41923075914382935,
-0.5476173758506775,
0.5415140390396118,
0.026544304564595222,
0.25537896156311035,
0.25344976782798767,
0.37019458413124084,
-0.4293736219406128,
-0.5436065196990967,
-0.6327875256538391,
0.5388026237487793,
-0.7378250956535339,
-0.343476802110672,
-0.7480823397636414,
-0.35416147112846375,
-0.5428845882415771,
0.11755508929491043,
-0.14415714144706726,
-0.5583155155181885,
0.046516768634319305,
-0.17750510573387146,
0.30736613273620605,
0.5473949909210205,
0.0471888929605484,
-0.020550431683659554,
-0.8605838418006897,
0.8853675723075867,
0.2625114321708679,
0.38997358083724976,
-0.35953328013420105,
-0.5947061777114868,
-0.2792813181877136,
0.10588628053665161,
-0.22646018862724304,
-0.599692702293396,
0.04610453546047211,
0.23293672502040863,
0.5005565881729126,
0.31610745191574097,
0.2761138677597046,
0.430581659078598,
-0.8165944814682007,
0.5695744156837463,
0.23452427983283997,
-0.4882216453552246,
0.5451095104217529,
-0.20992660522460938,
0.23825332522392273,
0.705679178237915,
0.4177754819393158,
-0.2378738969564438,
-0.35428112745285034,
-0.603917121887207,
-0.6512979865074158,
0.4617503881454468,
0.31618037819862366,
-0.10546872019767761,
-0.10209163278341293,
0.3940759599208832,
0.5223855972290039,
0.4769138991832733,
-0.3893446922302246,
-0.2828695476055145,
-0.04427565634250641,
-0.5356056094169617,
0.0383915901184082,
-0.3304848074913025,
-0.6873379349708557,
-0.2201876938343048,
0.5582727193832397,
-0.3567579686641693,
0.3718351125717163,
0.49213898181915283,
-0.1663568913936615,
-0.2394724041223526,
0.302020400762558,
0.5943822860717773,
0.968232274055481,
-0.40767669677734375,
0.06412121653556824,
0.22132964432239532,
-0.42802128195762634,
-0.07247703522443771,
0.26985883712768555,
-0.0392252616584301,
0.12050683051347733,
0.42023956775665283,
0.7048570513725281,
-0.18683768808841705,
-1.0156171321868896,
0.4333151876926422,
0.08746293187141418,
-0.36151885986328125,
-0.2754463255405426,
-0.04516594111919403,
-0.13587376475334167,
0.09211120754480362,
0.3410141170024872,
0.20228146016597748,
0.40613654255867004,
-0.6904112100601196,
0.16639629006385803,
0.12263736128807068,
-0.05624006688594818,
-0.1464645266532898,
0.588614284992218,
0.15185482800006866,
0.00819859653711319,
0.4807186424732208,
0.3594273626804352,
-0.36398568749427795,
0.6696922183036804,
0.6348893642425537,
0.6253260970115662,
-0.11441364139318466,
0.23966479301452637,
0.3269751965999603,
0.0646817535161972,
0.028295841068029404,
0.4128887355327606,
0.06387864798307419,
-0.4733044505119324,
-0.4924924075603485,
-0.4974614381790161,
-0.5483274459838867,
0.16505727171897888,
-0.5542421936988831,
0.1390087604522705,
-0.48888933658599854,
-0.35467812418937683,
-0.015105568803846836,
-0.020877990871667862,
-0.45278406143188477,
0.5561959147453308,
0.3029826283454895,
0.8602430820465088,
-0.4379400312900543,
0.6600969433784485,
0.7199999094009399,
-0.2746499180793762,
-0.3752632141113281,
0.029788590967655182,
-0.006780188996344805,
-0.7657506465911865,
0.5190559029579163,
0.2510088086128235,
-0.300957590341568,
-0.5069145560264587,
-0.8998465538024902,
-0.6677916049957275,
0.951342761516571,
0.4417685568332672,
-0.3670867085456848,
-0.07633151859045029,
0.47712406516075134,
0.7901400923728943,
-0.3453896939754486,
0.06319163739681244,
0.46174731850624084,
0.36987483501434326,
0.0576704777777195,
-0.8643874526023865,
0.17023999989032745,
0.00876279454678297,
-0.42522165179252625,
0.06310181319713593,
-0.4394451081752777,
0.4017362892627716,
-0.6413674354553223,
-0.011081003583967686,
0.4880051612854004,
0.6675035357475281,
0.5573304891586304,
0.5899931192398071,
0.47412383556365967,
0.39654502272605896,
1.2575268745422363,
0.18136881291866302,
1.0217220783233643,
-0.1646483838558197,
0.18706999719142914,
1.2968910932540894,
-0.4676162302494049,
0.691381573677063,
0.5092328190803528,
-0.02589159831404686,
0.3649994730949402,
0.4042748212814331,
0.117528036236763,
0.24728240072727203,
0.4092791676521301,
-0.24308723211288452,
-0.22895623743534088,
-0.03110089898109436,
-0.49160319566726685,
0.2688952684402466,
0.19839513301849365,
-0.4678196609020233,
-0.1396663784980774,
0.20893025398254395,
0.11321315169334412,
0.21468302607536316,
-0.03306405618786812,
0.6302152276039124,
0.1594580113887787,
-0.5595399141311646,
0.8084468245506287,
-0.15461118519306183,
0.2867795526981354,
-0.695092499256134,
-0.23012447357177734,
-0.23423731327056885,
-0.007363427430391312,
-0.2482515573501587,
-0.6774020791053772,
0.18291045725345612,
0.047038495540618896,
-0.4107738435268402,
0.013390305452048779,
0.6931028366088867,
-0.4750281870365143,
-0.3905491828918457,
-0.005029029678553343,
0.49893322587013245,
0.1849646419286728,
0.1646387130022049,
-0.7547062635421753,
-0.07429838925600052,
-0.272775262594223,
-0.11868034303188324,
0.12858326733112335,
0.4291323721408844,
0.08061780780553818,
0.6539475917816162,
0.5684375166893005,
0.28575965762138367,
-0.22088217735290527,
0.030452977865934372,
0.8248730897903442,
-0.5070062875747681,
-0.06517067551612854,
-0.5779430866241455,
0.44157329201698303,
-0.35908669233322144,
-0.22861844301223755,
0.4453624486923218,
0.6385221481323242,
0.3234713673591614,
-0.2112051248550415,
0.7305753231048584,
-0.0022600668016821146,
1.1149442195892334,
-0.7056760191917419,
1.0348626375198364,
-0.657802939414978,
0.1420864313840866,
0.1198735311627388,
-0.6777389049530029,
-0.40664875507354736,
0.29530608654022217,
-0.22910089790821075,
-0.12767763435840607,
0.9814776182174683,
0.5828995704650879,
-0.015494079329073429,
-0.10961727797985077,
0.44333547353744507,
0.6549793481826782,
0.2479410320520401,
0.3236705958843231,
0.8026912808418274,
-0.45296740531921387,
0.26964226365089417,
0.07847381383180618,
-0.29577770829200745,
-0.20579560101032257,
-0.6870924234390259,
-0.9242314100265503,
-0.30042949318885803,
-0.4545688331127167,
-0.5556541085243225,
0.3906410038471222,
1.2855390310287476,
0.46530380845069885,
-0.7623623013496399,
-0.013815871439874172,
0.5010275840759277,
-0.07676582038402557,
0.03629254177212715,
-0.13808989524841309,
0.6524177193641663,
-0.4992758333683014,
-0.3801116943359375,
0.40771612524986267,
0.34643110632896423,
-0.058852341026067734,
-0.08501515537500381,
-0.002237859182059765,
0.039006344974040985,
0.4938185513019562,
0.746895968914032,
0.3576332628726959,
-0.5962517261505127,
-0.3595968782901764,
0.09693969786167145,
-0.3577437400817871,
0.5073257088661194,
0.6239994168281555,
-0.8349178433418274,
0.5154082775115967,
0.1679554432630539,
0.9756008386611938,
0.20397262275218964,
0.007247758563607931,
0.6185133457183838,
-0.36770686507225037,
-0.2576614320278168,
0.4812227189540863,
0.3853362798690796,
0.31364715099334717,
-0.4456567168235779,
0.4906780421733856,
0.15407173335552216,
-0.7394493222236633,
-0.9901453256607056,
0.06174461171030998,
-1.0608738660812378,
-0.3240717649459839,
1.0705726146697998,
-0.1063130646944046,
-0.4786563217639923,
-0.27980130910873413,
-0.5795106887817383,
0.10675033181905746,
-0.153511181473732,
1.1328603029251099,
0.3674851655960083,
-0.17789648473262787,
0.3425304889678955,
-0.7259271144866943,
0.6080820560455322,
0.6360669136047363,
-1.2380039691925049,
0.06786434352397919,
0.7923631072044373,
0.3721804618835449,
-0.039022013545036316,
0.8375709652900696,
-0.25121715664863586,
0.6261329054832458,
-0.37867408990859985,
0.03521681949496269,
0.11849744617938995,
-0.3782811760902405,
-0.1517009288072586,
0.10183223336935043,
0.1515045017004013,
-0.04359092190861702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12689v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12689v2
|
Spotting AI's Touch: Identifying LLM-Paraphrased Spans in Text
| 2024-05-21T11:22:27 | 2024-05-29T07:09:59 |
Yafu Li, Zhilin Wang, Leyang Cui, Wei Bi, Shuming Shi, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
AI-generated text detection has attracted increasing attention as powerful
language models approach human-level generation. Limited work is devoted to
detecting (partially) AI-paraphrased texts. However, AI paraphrasing is
commonly employed in various application scenarios for text refinement and
diversity. To this end, we propose a novel detection framework, paraphrased
text span detection (PTD), aiming to identify paraphrased text spans within a
text. Different from text-level detection, PTD takes in the full text and
assigns each of the sentences with a score indicating the paraphrasing degree.
We construct a dedicated dataset, PASTED, for paraphrased text span detection.
Both in-distribution and out-of-distribution results demonstrate the
effectiveness of PTD models in identifying AI-paraphrased text spans.
Statistical and model analysis explains the crucial role of the surrounding
context of the paraphrased text spans. Extensive experiments show that PTD
models can generalize to versatile paraphrasing prompts and multiple
paraphrased text spans. We release our resources at
https://github.com/Linzwcs/PASTED.
|
[
-0.19966088235378265,
-0.809389054775238,
0.5495830774307251,
0.4309312701225281,
-0.3297870457172394,
0.1526336669921875,
0.371085524559021,
-0.4594559073448181,
0.07871443033218384,
0.7468731999397278,
-0.44118446111679077,
-0.3223913609981537,
-0.5450191497802734,
0.40842488408088684,
-0.8921130895614624,
1.0577462911605835,
-0.23364658653736115,
-0.3952684998512268,
-0.5283121466636658,
-0.09206471592187881,
0.25091680884361267,
-0.22736996412277222,
-0.4085533618927002,
-0.09802593290805817,
0.40913358330726624,
0.5530961155891418,
0.4477540850639343,
0.9915900826454163,
0.4013376832008362,
0.2491617500782013,
-0.3134167492389679,
0.2917357087135315,
0.006502358242869377,
0.11198169738054276,
0.23927341401576996,
-0.3760633170604706,
-0.10867000371217728,
-0.10279316455125809,
0.7090182900428772,
0.3112521171569824,
0.2480178028345108,
-0.202797994017601,
0.28839269280433655,
0.4490033686161041,
-0.5843159556388855,
-0.0703524723649025,
-0.5134183764457703,
0.04090261459350586,
-0.2848297655582428,
-0.17035110294818878,
-0.42731761932373047,
-0.3678230345249176,
0.149034783244133,
-0.22082962095737457,
0.13828450441360474,
-0.052480924874544144,
0.7624081373214722,
0.33185631036758423,
-0.5353268980979919,
-0.3656146228313446,
-0.19064068794250488,
0.4454948306083679,
-0.5296281576156616,
0.06530536711215973,
0.48611530661582947,
-0.0811038687825203,
0.4947977364063263,
-0.9896880388259888,
-0.7279072403907776,
-0.4821815490722656,
-0.050804253667593,
-0.20655977725982666,
-0.19160772860050201,
0.0141987893730402,
0.07817946374416351,
0.35817134380340576,
-0.4021768271923065,
-0.2111651599407196,
-0.06766906380653381,
-0.11208916455507278,
0.3222351670265198,
0.1174839660525322,
0.7560136318206787,
-0.1701197475194931,
-0.6189934611320496,
0.001069128280505538,
-0.4507662355899811,
0.031944822520017624,
0.07647453993558884,
-0.03557470440864563,
-0.23986172676086426,
0.5313816666603088,
-0.2643393576145172,
0.5942085981369019,
0.04256109520792961,
0.14928212761878967,
0.010908725671470165,
-0.48238107562065125,
-0.023608345538377762,
-0.3559587299823761,
0.9932552576065063,
0.35089680552482605,
0.6191321015357971,
-0.2786318063735962,
-0.04169623181223869,
-0.30025672912597656,
0.14309504628181458,
-0.6054942607879639,
-0.41857820749282837,
-0.44536617398262024,
-0.5435197353363037,
-0.586374044418335,
0.24284707009792328,
-0.7965522408485413,
-0.6895707845687866,
-0.03954946622252464,
0.15651440620422363,
-0.5800246000289917,
-0.0011976812966167927,
-0.08261130005121231,
-0.4551369249820709,
0.2068697065114975,
-0.04174220934510231,
-0.8105344772338867,
0.3019656836986542,
0.6429215669631958,
1.132262945175171,
-0.5244198441505432,
-0.8180093765258789,
-0.2852829098701477,
0.09254396706819534,
-0.13863590359687805,
1.094009518623352,
-0.5860784649848938,
-0.45697975158691406,
-0.10113164782524109,
-0.23487579822540283,
-0.3622308373451233,
-0.7605339884757996,
0.7744321823120117,
-0.2859787940979004,
0.07256840169429779,
-0.14365153014659882,
-0.6718184947967529,
0.20088891685009003,
0.23785625398159027,
-0.8883848190307617,
1.249564290046692,
0.024329958483576775,
-1.3066109418869019,
0.35483524203300476,
-0.6163164377212524,
-0.6306905746459961,
0.0953245609998703,
0.07956535369157791,
-0.5672597885131836,
0.09502200782299042,
0.34624627232551575,
0.45870962738990784,
-0.1450110524892807,
0.1135660856962204,
-0.38823312520980835,
-0.19126543402671814,
0.32666537165641785,
-0.6039093136787415,
0.7597858905792236,
0.18047794699668884,
-0.2576310932636261,
0.20194420218467712,
-0.697848916053772,
-0.23547431826591492,
-0.15064463019371033,
-0.20254427194595337,
-0.5959027409553528,
-0.13894158601760864,
0.3386204242706299,
0.2318853735923767,
0.5380756258964539,
-0.3182038962841034,
-0.0901605635881424,
0.0073556797578930855,
0.31364697217941284,
0.49524810910224915,
0.3548007607460022,
0.4999420940876007,
-0.44341224431991577,
0.7418053150177002,
-0.2742798924446106,
0.048006922006607056,
-0.403883159160614,
-0.2490939199924469,
-0.4101630449295044,
-0.4330047070980072,
-0.12073454260826111,
0.501041829586029,
-0.9320993423461914,
0.6884485483169556,
0.0732368677854538,
-0.4999980330467224,
-0.49605700373649597,
0.20753175020217896,
0.5076402425765991,
0.8110859990119934,
0.5622317790985107,
0.2610379159450531,
-0.24187752604484558,
-0.8219066858291626,
-0.9094229936599731,
-0.2617422044277191,
-0.09522606432437897,
0.16017207503318787,
0.5298222899436951,
0.026593394577503204,
1.197221279144287,
-0.333564430475235,
-0.05212319269776344,
-0.4696159064769745,
0.2040030062198639,
-0.33920636773109436,
0.2917729616165161,
0.4776943027973175,
-1.1314293146133423,
-0.7781545519828796,
-0.20108702778816223,
-0.8340896964073181,
-0.7239757180213928,
-0.18031366169452667,
-0.03783660754561424,
-0.2770735025405884,
0.9816323518753052,
-0.7096211910247803,
0.40305179357528687,
0.20636120438575745,
-0.6887962818145752,
0.6089183688163757,
-0.24060574173927307,
0.16630372405052185,
-1.1781607866287231,
0.28553926944732666,
0.19000841677188873,
-0.25093913078308105,
-0.4396163821220398,
0.24444063007831573,
0.3433111011981964,
0.09520851820707321,
-0.34691014885902405,
0.48610466718673706,
-0.36372795701026917,
-0.015981389209628105,
-0.7673553824424744,
0.01037215068936348,
0.19966159760951996,
-0.03192204236984253,
0.017021378502249718,
1.0014797449111938,
0.16253842413425446,
-0.539069414138794,
0.24031893908977509,
0.3826746940612793,
-0.2570360600948334,
0.747312068939209,
-0.679275631904602,
0.06172438710927963,
0.21222901344299316,
0.44937562942504883,
-1.0027542114257812,
-0.15724606812000275,
0.28368741273880005,
-0.34541574120521545,
-0.29881373047828674,
0.020119043067097664,
-0.5714570879936218,
-0.34259524941444397,
-0.6255834102630615,
0.5134934782981873,
0.10526298731565475,
-0.7379822134971619,
0.4967455565929413,
0.2876611649990082,
-0.2971017360687256,
-0.40669041872024536,
-0.49526816606521606,
0.3869883716106415,
-0.457837849855423,
-0.5930408835411072,
0.43678000569343567,
-0.11256520450115204,
-0.1985945701599121,
-0.1313711404800415,
-0.0223341416567564,
-0.3414002060890198,
0.47562122344970703,
0.005893812980502844,
0.05703221634030342,
0.07158034294843674,
-0.25887390971183777,
0.3858528733253479,
-0.030496152117848396,
0.20182013511657715,
-0.019707441329956055,
0.6881283521652222,
0.19597910344600677,
-0.2471148818731308,
-0.8367412686347961,
0.4169023036956787,
0.9258224368095398,
-0.3367248773574829,
0.44392696022987366,
0.6420470476150513,
-0.34628915786743164,
-0.14800894260406494,
-0.10793492197990417,
-0.20017707347869873,
-0.4935787618160248,
0.2545934319496155,
-0.3997932970523834,
-0.5451421737670898,
0.3348734676837921,
0.03346749395132065,
-0.1392802745103836,
0.3659719228744507,
0.36823657155036926,
-0.3094269037246704,
0.7254582047462463,
0.8907589912414551,
-0.4630987346172333,
0.6575347185134888,
0.04670875892043114,
-0.12394354492425919,
-0.6600586175918579,
-0.19857357442378998,
-0.730189859867096,
-0.257412314414978,
-0.28429219126701355,
-0.2639283239841461,
0.2924693524837494,
0.12963080406188965,
0.05412830412387848,
0.4285365641117096,
-0.3122579753398895,
0.8167228698730469,
0.883709192276001,
0.2739679217338562,
0.35405856370925903,
-0.1896992325782776,
0.018466802313923836,
0.0785968080163002,
-0.1510728895664215,
-0.6215391755104065,
0.8759149312973022,
0.17594031989574432,
0.3719359040260315,
-0.44460734724998474,
0.8985166549682617,
0.7846938967704773,
-0.00817833375185728,
-0.4913947284221649,
0.7069827318191528,
-0.12639354169368744,
-0.20869265496730804,
-0.030558336526155472,
-0.2844438850879669,
-0.6388199925422668,
0.10243082046508789,
0.0642121359705925,
-0.6878382563591003,
-0.18749123811721802,
-0.008533541113138199,
-0.22394020855426788,
0.35494154691696167,
-0.4136337339878082,
1.0156581401824951,
-0.07484865188598633,
-0.049030009657144547,
-0.07901310175657272,
-0.7963570952415466,
0.23093613982200623,
-0.011473044753074646,
-0.03145686537027359,
-0.07948395609855652,
-0.2606225311756134,
1.008799433708191,
-0.41586896777153015,
0.8689857125282288,
-0.2793042063713074,
-0.10152090340852737,
0.38564804196357727,
0.08124154061079025,
0.4198713004589081,
-0.1432398557662964,
0.030215565115213394,
-0.5088582038879395,
-0.12836916744709015,
-0.42848795652389526,
-0.16121147572994232,
0.600627601146698,
-0.3467164635658264,
-0.06795533746480942,
-0.18556512892246246,
-0.721632719039917,
-0.14272210001945496,
0.23192912340164185,
0.4574354887008667,
-0.010422316379845142,
-0.21267536282539368,
0.11408865451812744,
0.4629972279071808,
0.04777080565690994,
0.7414188981056213,
0.031050778925418854,
0.07798345386981964,
-0.3215204179286957,
0.7475080490112305,
-0.5480747222900391,
0.17788054049015045,
0.4790682792663574,
0.1586044281721115,
-0.2972877621650696,
-0.506423830986023,
-0.5621416568756104,
0.2594088017940521,
-0.4590011537075043,
-0.03572791442275047,
-0.770666778087616,
0.0427224338054657,
-0.2909555435180664,
-0.35402780771255493,
0.018007459118962288,
-0.14047271013259888,
-0.6152858138084412,
-0.3601647913455963,
0.5082167387008667,
0.5271235108375549,
0.06623049825429916,
0.6637011766433716,
-0.7152013778686523,
0.6530179381370544,
0.09988284111022949,
-0.1441313773393631,
-0.2249019294977188,
-0.5809570550918579,
-0.14329752326011658,
-0.07819526642560959,
-0.30737239122390747,
-0.9020717740058899,
0.6276647448539734,
0.2967531681060791,
0.1951208859682083,
0.5710709095001221,
0.26027703285217285,
0.17464302480220795,
-0.38727453351020813,
0.8350375294685364,
-0.046035896986722946,
-1.1593834161758423,
0.2830584645271301,
-0.3900597393512726,
0.2934414744377136,
0.6943599581718445,
0.5253852605819702,
-0.6769374012947083,
-0.6353070735931396,
-0.5949223637580872,
-0.9881255626678467,
0.5563840866088867,
-0.1152786836028099,
0.3913612961769104,
-0.10976624488830566,
0.29757067561149597,
0.1581346094608307,
0.18447273969650269,
-0.9749025106430054,
-0.054647378623485565,
0.2272820770740509,
-0.734282374382019,
0.20957665145397186,
-0.24236445128917694,
-0.005346748977899551,
0.14491693675518036,
0.1486707627773285,
-0.15289272367954254,
0.181906595826149,
0.020296573638916016,
-0.46446865797042847,
0.26470422744750977,
-0.05991818755865097,
0.49744918942451477,
0.4965113401412964,
0.07497633993625641,
0.3314630389213562,
0.011798855848610401,
-0.40419813990592957,
-0.0555056668817997,
0.28581392765045166,
-0.3242241442203522,
0.18909338116645813,
0.7651157975196838,
0.5586838722229004,
0.06115669012069702,
-0.810802698135376,
0.7044357061386108,
0.29154297709465027,
-0.14403250813484192,
0.025219973176717758,
-0.19173598289489746,
-0.002077893353998661,
0.3793419897556305,
0.7728776931762695,
-0.007882815785706043,
0.40672433376312256,
-0.2197476178407669,
0.8002198338508606,
0.2607843577861786,
-0.39023399353027344,
-0.49221235513687134,
0.7818244099617004,
0.2022799849510193,
-0.500670850276947,
0.5243000984191895,
0.15678301453590393,
-0.8915480375289917,
0.9157464504241943,
0.5739879012107849,
0.9430639147758484,
-0.10900939255952835,
0.3922058045864105,
-0.4544431269168854,
0.035115569829940796,
-0.018170904368162155,
0.13072578608989716,
-0.5506353378295898,
-0.7136995792388916,
-0.015502586960792542,
-0.357387512922287,
-0.46685153245925903,
-0.04059362784028053,
-0.7550426125526428,
0.28304556012153625,
-0.35238611698150635,
0.18918299674987793,
0.02479063719511032,
-0.46504658460617065,
-0.05397719144821167,
0.1765127331018448,
0.30582714080810547,
0.9519208073616028,
-1.296874761581421,
0.8526835441589355,
0.3153998553752899,
-0.26246392726898193,
-0.3798961043357849,
0.7324177622795105,
-0.07536289095878601,
-0.9742787480354309,
0.30083540081977844,
0.3689109981060028,
-0.24580909311771393,
0.28213438391685486,
-0.485323429107666,
-0.1853034496307373,
0.9696203470230103,
0.21977248787879944,
0.07366778701543808,
-0.42930346727371216,
0.13435101509094238,
0.49426892399787903,
-0.09274306148290634,
0.32555174827575684,
0.768247663974762,
0.47149142622947693,
-0.2849135398864746,
-1.0165985822677612,
-0.10802166163921356,
-0.17164906859397888,
-0.2440161257982254,
0.14033544063568115,
-0.4549793004989624,
0.8943848609924316,
0.030055128037929535,
0.30948957800865173,
0.4716130793094635,
0.7078879475593567,
0.4411497712135315,
0.8636797070503235,
0.48905041813850403,
0.479098916053772,
0.42864829301834106,
0.17865367233753204,
1.0608291625976562,
-0.48431023955345154,
0.1470286250114441,
0.6939458847045898,
-0.13208626210689545,
0.7808363437652588,
0.62300705909729,
-0.10116612911224365,
0.3855316638946533,
0.48730137944221497,
0.032622650265693665,
0.6755790114402771,
0.04404907301068306,
-0.6033425331115723,
0.05178046226501465,
-0.19688378274440765,
-0.19011954963207245,
0.374335378408432,
0.20069390535354614,
-0.7409079074859619,
-0.33262982964515686,
0.3265538215637207,
0.3481898605823517,
0.5468172430992126,
-0.15010719001293182,
0.8460245728492737,
-0.004124784842133522,
-0.6615958213806152,
0.35366755723953247,
0.10642733424901962,
1.0070432424545288,
-0.3227788805961609,
0.1100873053073883,
-0.5164898633956909,
0.29568377137184143,
-0.032392725348472595,
-0.7875298261642456,
0.292868047952652,
0.249935120344162,
-0.14065471291542053,
-0.5194225907325745,
0.6610340476036072,
-0.5806437134742737,
-0.3180752098560333,
0.37208399176597595,
0.5722454190254211,
0.016802042722702026,
-0.4529511630535126,
-0.750219464302063,
-0.13162434101104736,
0.18800969421863556,
-0.18549500405788422,
0.28636184334754944,
0.7314232587814331,
-0.15168273448944092,
0.7481210827827454,
0.2854290008544922,
-0.3048863112926483,
0.22204306721687317,
-0.16389726102352142,
0.7385527491569519,
-0.5677831768989563,
-0.7275572419166565,
-1.2552324533462524,
0.142562597990036,
-0.2425537407398224,
-0.501482367515564,
0.8730133175849915,
0.6788440346717834,
0.3959110975265503,
-0.24693891406059265,
0.9111931920051575,
-0.057617079466581345,
0.5314338207244873,
-0.3124714493751526,
0.7606483101844788,
-0.30601733922958374,
-0.006493526045233011,
-0.5238417983055115,
-0.6370870471000671,
-0.37857046723365784,
0.5821534991264343,
-0.13916878402233124,
0.030145971104502678,
0.6229851245880127,
0.48530375957489014,
-0.2521466016769409,
0.05407373607158661,
-0.014127729460597038,
-0.19035227596759796,
0.2867833375930786,
0.32704025506973267,
1.0382745265960693,
-0.22770944237709045,
0.8631430268287659,
-0.12391278147697449,
-0.16753771901130676,
-0.2785349488258362,
-0.826404869556427,
-0.7574231028556824,
-0.6865014433860779,
-0.38333961367607117,
-0.15348444879055023,
-0.08262381702661514,
0.5978977680206299,
0.4454766511917114,
-0.5250597596168518,
-0.2659647762775421,
-0.6098795533180237,
0.04984423518180847,
-0.2162182480096817,
-0.30560222268104553,
0.5118333697319031,
-0.31770917773246765,
-0.9259398579597473,
0.6766651272773743,
0.017416134476661682,
0.0758230909705162,
0.3100681006908417,
0.16425538063049316,
-0.49591323733329773,
0.10888537019491196,
0.17969463765621185,
0.3785686194896698,
-0.3569127321243286,
-0.20033910870552063,
0.12489000707864761,
-0.30574923753738403,
-0.1833571046590805,
0.9194818735122681,
-0.5876839756965637,
-0.17944440245628357,
0.5308301448822021,
1.0031709671020508,
0.5072539448738098,
0.2998489737510681,
0.4620058834552765,
-0.9880192875862122,
-0.0014500283868983388,
0.3511238396167755,
0.2091113030910492,
0.3064728081226349,
-0.046341318637132645,
0.16651226580142975,
0.5304020047187805,
-0.49265000224113464,
-0.7963775396347046,
0.10560890287160873,
-0.8537831902503967,
-0.34499070048332214,
1.1699085235595703,
-0.4411940574645996,
-0.0459403395652771,
-0.11988133192062378,
-0.529869794845581,
0.23882339894771576,
-0.2880271077156067,
0.7356209754943848,
0.5389920473098755,
-0.12898404896259308,
-0.3479212522506714,
0.06486443430185318,
0.6711875200271606,
0.5832768678665161,
-1.025101661682129,
0.29167988896369934,
0.47382402420043945,
0.3226834535598755,
-0.17076487839221954,
0.6126405000686646,
0.18034815788269043,
0.36701884865760803,
-0.17088809609413147,
-0.08911077678203583,
-0.10967226326465607,
-0.3783571720123291,
-0.23507298529148102,
0.3385644853115082,
-0.02517659217119217,
-0.5931904315948486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12669v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12669v2
|
A Survey on Multi-modal Machine Translation: Tasks, Methods and Challenges
| 2024-05-21T10:34:47 | 2024-05-23T03:56:56 |
Huangjun Shen, Liangying Shao, Wenbo Li, Zhibin Lan, Zhanyu Liu, Jinsong Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, multi-modal machine translation has attracted significant
interest in both academia and industry due to its superior performance. It
takes both textual and visual modalities as inputs, leveraging visual context
to tackle the ambiguities in source texts. In this paper, we begin by offering
an exhaustive overview of 99 prior works, comprehensively summarizing
representative studies from the perspectives of dominant models, datasets, and
evaluation metrics. Afterwards, we analyze the impact of various factors on
model performance and finally discuss the possible research directions for this
task in the future. Over time, multi-modal machine translation has developed
more types to meet diverse needs. Unlike previous surveys confined to the early
stage of multi-modal machine translation, our survey thoroughly concludes these
emerging types from different aspects, so as to provide researchers with a
better understanding of its current state.
|
[
-0.3841150104999542,
-0.7765964865684509,
0.5496800541877747,
0.2049654871225357,
-0.27213940024375916,
0.04302491247653961,
-0.20266371965408325,
-0.562725305557251,
-0.20062273740768433,
0.36018529534339905,
-0.5442916750907898,
-0.29145973920822144,
-0.900696337223053,
0.5320177674293518,
-0.3025452792644501,
0.8022162914276123,
-0.2549354135990143,
0.4458805322647095,
-0.20703914761543274,
-0.3262605667114258,
-0.7589589953422546,
-0.7108625173568726,
-0.002099499572068453,
0.06805161386728287,
0.6157062649726868,
0.12139174342155457,
0.6177852749824524,
0.4379783868789673,
0.7099064588546753,
0.38728228211402893,
-0.00382191501557827,
0.4786304533481598,
-0.1503148227930069,
0.494803786277771,
0.14969401061534882,
-0.404032826423645,
-0.34078726172447205,
0.09963167458772659,
0.8630385398864746,
0.5934368968009949,
0.3166646361351013,
0.14505796134471893,
-0.004501913674175739,
0.4396279454231262,
-0.5248966217041016,
0.04864068701863289,
-0.40596142411231995,
-0.04388623312115669,
-0.4707435667514801,
-0.2470952868461609,
-0.5019638538360596,
0.04983893036842346,
0.032467711716890335,
-0.37705904245376587,
-0.023646900430321693,
0.2709365785121918,
0.4527122974395752,
0.3990589678287506,
-1.399949312210083,
-0.24969582259655,
-0.8724519610404968,
0.9961863160133362,
-0.4830150604248047,
0.7622336149215698,
0.03651867434382439,
0.581657886505127,
0.1416676938533783,
-0.6069026589393616,
-0.33563685417175293,
-0.20131701231002808,
-0.07774993777275085,
0.2377554476261139,
-0.07752657681703568,
-0.2714674472808838,
0.17838026583194733,
0.4434281885623932,
-0.4488031566143036,
-0.06349202245473862,
-0.5402751564979553,
-0.097982257604599,
0.3387063145637512,
0.3625200390815735,
0.4063206911087036,
-0.5025843977928162,
-0.5998206734657288,
-0.15857525169849396,
-0.28622689843177795,
0.1556386947631836,
0.054118964821100235,
0.026861855760216713,
-0.09800772368907928,
0.8640689849853516,
-0.17343024909496307,
0.9624329209327698,
-0.4199616014957428,
-0.25303915143013,
0.344906210899353,
-1.0965979099273682,
-0.24342383444309235,
-0.5154486298561096,
0.8912495970726013,
0.463739275932312,
-0.3092738091945648,
-0.14426183700561523,
-0.3800920248031616,
-0.34969380497932434,
0.4462836682796478,
-0.43480393290519714,
0.2812782824039459,
-0.043193113058805466,
-0.7631713151931763,
-0.16742925345897675,
-0.1403961181640625,
-0.7394536137580872,
-0.2983200252056122,
-0.5875377655029297,
0.318779319524765,
-0.4959147274494171,
-0.30107975006103516,
-0.15841007232666016,
-0.07672353088855743,
0.08973799645900726,
0.7210335731506348,
-0.37974920868873596,
-0.1953919678926468,
0.3643995523452759,
0.97935551404953,
-0.3213762938976288,
-0.3811822235584259,
-0.16962260007858276,
0.07034841179847717,
-0.015188086777925491,
0.6405120491981506,
-0.5863310694694519,
-0.37964093685150146,
-0.0756167471408844,
0.20227158069610596,
-0.5978507995605469,
-0.19718614220619202,
0.5975056290626526,
-0.4836151599884033,
0.5186284780502319,
-0.5505843162536621,
-0.033114444464445114,
-0.7303098440170288,
0.518036425113678,
-0.7724989056587219,
0.8094608187675476,
-0.13971967995166779,
-0.6409971714019775,
0.3910802900791168,
-0.6045494079589844,
-0.45152294635772705,
-0.2630961239337921,
-0.21020588278770447,
-0.3024657666683197,
0.34134408831596375,
0.37883031368255615,
0.5776156187057495,
-0.591519296169281,
0.22984158992767334,
0.03373158723115921,
0.12641125917434692,
0.6746199131011963,
-0.8018407821655273,
0.6208513975143433,
0.5674965381622314,
-0.30269408226013184,
0.32717621326446533,
-0.5271255373954773,
-0.2089989334344864,
-0.07201981544494629,
-0.2421276569366455,
-0.358649343252182,
-0.06143205985426903,
0.6075621843338013,
0.7594692707061768,
0.2802833020687103,
-0.3294183313846588,
0.35493990778923035,
0.11904487758874893,
0.5455095171928406,
0.3140917420387268,
0.06081070005893707,
0.3896225094795227,
-0.29156798124313354,
0.8812069892883301,
0.17898526787757874,
0.23762422800064087,
-0.4081002175807953,
-0.6849951148033142,
-0.4746999144554138,
-0.3342404365539551,
0.44292739033699036,
0.4840962588787079,
-0.8930661678314209,
-0.03323821350932121,
-0.15570439398288727,
-0.405018150806427,
-0.6501619815826416,
0.029311150312423706,
0.26902303099632263,
0.3928608298301697,
0.4664760231971741,
-0.23708786070346832,
-0.1871282458305359,
-1.013521671295166,
-0.07622620463371277,
0.07023490965366364,
0.21868614852428436,
0.44741785526275635,
0.5211384296417236,
-0.21598610281944275,
0.39382046461105347,
-0.21416710317134857,
-0.16659100353717804,
-0.16599637269973755,
0.45022979378700256,
-0.15022557973861694,
0.4471462070941925,
0.6565463542938232,
-1.0564180612564087,
-0.22068649530410767,
0.2620450258255005,
-0.8280787467956543,
0.1341283619403839,
-0.31003084778785706,
0.06973722577095032,
0.1436242163181305,
0.47306010127067566,
-0.46032777428627014,
-0.03016773611307144,
0.7151030898094177,
-0.12552163004875183,
0.32371556758880615,
-0.04259076341986656,
0.9266794323921204,
-1.1402677297592163,
0.48769792914390564,
-0.05368215963244438,
-0.2801295816898346,
-0.46796002984046936,
0.28095418214797974,
0.23794160783290863,
-0.15654975175857544,
-0.5078145265579224,
0.07040754705667496,
-0.7270956039428711,
0.05667614936828613,
-0.11589635163545609,
-0.037778012454509735,
-0.060386206954717636,
0.2780170440673828,
-0.18354779481887817,
0.8013499975204468,
0.3676982820034027,
-0.3021790087223053,
0.33327192068099976,
0.12389668822288513,
-0.10792670398950577,
0.599732518196106,
-0.49781012535095215,
-0.12208284437656403,
-0.17767179012298584,
0.1667383462190628,
-1.0512887239456177,
-0.07667440921068192,
0.5618789792060852,
-0.33253568410873413,
0.36894404888153076,
0.003396828891709447,
-0.4089790880680084,
-0.19145764410495758,
-0.05189044028520584,
0.6791349649429321,
0.12973807752132416,
0.17636895179748535,
0.5220820307731628,
0.112972691655159,
-0.26589512825012207,
-0.6050595045089722,
-0.5615471601486206,
0.4483088254928589,
-0.15192370116710663,
-0.5305383801460266,
0.23638591170310974,
-0.12368936836719513,
-0.1800437867641449,
-0.16316556930541992,
-0.017563223838806152,
-0.13649724423885345,
0.02694077417254448,
0.1006963774561882,
0.10638430714607239,
-0.22642752528190613,
-0.07872971147298813,
0.057998593896627426,
-0.011609959416091442,
-0.13226860761642456,
0.033580657094717026,
0.17901206016540527,
-0.1400838941335678,
-0.5379776954650879,
-0.3533591330051422,
0.7039073705673218,
1.030214548110962,
-0.7105602622032166,
0.48238322138786316,
0.9318456649780273,
-0.2353590726852417,
0.3147936165332794,
-0.5245323181152344,
0.055276140570640564,
-0.3090713620185852,
0.5833032727241516,
-0.5914631485939026,
-0.6249435544013977,
0.2837825417518616,
-0.21692581474781036,
-0.046206191182136536,
0.5023763179779053,
0.8129674792289734,
0.0757310539484024,
1.249895453453064,
0.6894120573997498,
0.02163044922053814,
0.4229811131954193,
-0.07356463372707367,
0.1892663687467575,
-0.7971314787864685,
-0.7500389814376831,
-0.6170344948768616,
-0.401199609041214,
-0.43489816784858704,
-0.7216481566429138,
0.7216941714286804,
0.029367174953222275,
0.549340546131134,
0.47857987880706787,
-0.42849040031433105,
-0.25837862491607666,
0.4607643783092499,
-0.08234590291976929,
0.6787201166152954,
-0.2617897391319275,
-0.12913329899311066,
-0.2562345862388611,
-0.5673703551292419,
-0.5022518634796143,
1.0987902879714966,
0.38597607612609863,
0.5144379734992981,
0.34331896901130676,
0.14301306009292603,
0.21115973591804504,
0.13093985617160797,
-0.8115634918212891,
0.16659283638000488,
0.18241600692272186,
-0.8921552896499634,
-0.25837448239326477,
-0.36327308416366577,
-0.8343718647956848,
0.7757869362831116,
-0.19751618802547455,
-0.20666852593421936,
0.14862915873527527,
-0.057821616530418396,
0.18570439517498016,
0.03562753275036812,
-0.5706222653388977,
1.1094688177108765,
-0.6624200344085693,
-0.12492693215608597,
-0.1900722086429596,
-0.9831990599632263,
0.5572760105133057,
-0.09172448515892029,
0.40467369556427,
0.11589396744966507,
-0.29564395546913147,
0.371884822845459,
0.0791950672864914,
0.4830133318901062,
0.025214478373527527,
-0.1863030046224594,
0.03627876937389374,
-0.08979162573814392,
0.21083906292915344,
0.02158498950302601,
0.19643959403038025,
0.18924719095230103,
0.2125726193189621,
-0.17677943408489227,
-0.43919119238853455,
0.3743928074836731,
-0.46760642528533936,
-0.2077915519475937,
-0.4439358413219452,
-0.8303095698356628,
-0.22262683510780334,
0.42426446080207825,
0.28832074999809265,
0.43694743514060974,
-0.1312546730041504,
0.4131036698818207,
0.35698947310447693,
-0.06615076214075089,
0.5613334774971008,
0.3109521269798279,
-0.1260603368282318,
-0.5300573706626892,
0.8380945324897766,
0.2712957561016083,
0.13648800551891327,
0.5494962930679321,
-0.23372943699359894,
-0.33341342210769653,
-0.6937706470489502,
-1.1285475492477417,
-0.009685007855296135,
-0.44312652945518494,
-0.23114649951457977,
-0.979201078414917,
0.2592152953147888,
-0.5283492207527161,
0.01745452918112278,
-0.47520625591278076,
-0.33132046461105347,
-0.1234336569905281,
0.3747049868106842,
0.062491290271282196,
0.9056025743484497,
0.23133474588394165,
0.09324432909488678,
-0.7927001714706421,
0.4552847146987915,
0.13855110108852386,
0.07920052111148834,
-0.04972333088517189,
-0.15193575620651245,
-0.273404061794281,
0.059426695108413696,
-0.48408231139183044,
-1.1065784692764282,
0.34501224756240845,
-0.18941889703273773,
0.7929282188415527,
0.2827889025211334,
-0.09886838495731354,
0.47993382811546326,
-0.5153337717056274,
0.8828653693199158,
0.2652193009853363,
-0.6385213732719421,
0.3143518269062042,
-0.5338688492774963,
0.31507524847984314,
0.46689915657043457,
0.7514640092849731,
-0.7920381426811218,
-0.24431228637695312,
-0.05818748474121094,
-0.8346052169799805,
0.5707269906997681,
0.3223612606525421,
-0.16989700496196747,
0.4421863257884979,
-0.1692366600036621,
0.2870917022228241,
0.6383156180381775,
-0.6613632440567017,
-0.28772762417793274,
-0.30794405937194824,
-0.036325886845588684,
-0.3574570417404175,
0.05526815727353096,
-0.1285095065832138,
-0.15702742338180542,
0.28381314873695374,
0.014425626955926418,
0.2027762234210968,
-0.054164811968803406,
-0.6041564345359802,
0.10268554836511612,
0.48021650314331055,
1.0176984071731567,
0.6803810596466064,
-0.03096465766429901,
0.2491762787103653,
-0.046320416033267975,
-0.2180784046649933,
0.074864961206913,
0.22399410605430603,
-0.32845014333724976,
-0.011244074441492558,
0.26198846101760864,
0.643732488155365,
0.22659063339233398,
-0.47862035036087036,
0.6234883069992065,
0.12117791920900345,
0.007855203934013844,
0.032124221324920654,
-0.4915006160736084,
-0.09656762331724167,
0.3091495633125305,
0.32942137122154236,
0.6216614246368408,
0.4706328213214874,
-0.49148795008659363,
-0.15040801465511322,
0.4582604765892029,
-0.5442259311676025,
-0.48777779936790466,
0.907220721244812,
0.23661980032920837,
0.020879190415143967,
0.17298178374767303,
0.08285171538591385,
-0.3611343801021576,
0.19850465655326843,
0.4246104061603546,
0.73894864320755,
0.06783079355955124,
0.10172364860773087,
-0.042012907564640045,
0.5674583911895752,
0.003633301006630063,
0.09352166950702667,
-0.2028033286333084,
-0.0759381353855133,
-0.4503086507320404,
-0.3860611021518707,
-0.28801023960113525,
0.12719856202602386,
-0.5506386160850525,
0.17236559092998505,
0.2345891147851944,
-0.4580872058868408,
-0.10167228430509567,
-0.354055792093277,
-0.8189550042152405,
0.09282888472080231,
0.06763046234846115,
0.5385251045227051,
-0.842559278011322,
0.4990110695362091,
1.259546160697937,
-0.8702952861785889,
-0.011531516909599304,
-0.23293130099773407,
0.27228716015815735,
-0.3866271674633026,
0.3645544648170471,
-0.06489355862140656,
-0.40249937772750854,
-0.08192615211009979,
-0.3054732382297516,
-0.8276695609092712,
1.0014076232910156,
0.09637914597988129,
-0.15087741613388062,
-0.2291470617055893,
0.1537952572107315,
0.27283525466918945,
-0.2045692503452301,
0.3070094883441925,
0.1156565248966217,
0.7483823895454407,
-0.3843546509742737,
-1.0781453847885132,
0.02221238613128662,
-0.5181393027305603,
0.1479833573102951,
-0.006014382466673851,
-0.8672138452529907,
0.8628902435302734,
0.30066978931427,
-0.0470120944082737,
0.16542990505695343,
0.4582674205303192,
-0.24445480108261108,
0.4271330237388611,
0.36870571970939636,
0.09977898001670837,
0.241188183426857,
0.040885038673877716,
0.8725441098213196,
-0.3200165331363678,
0.05441265553236008,
0.5889034867286682,
0.03993178531527519,
0.5603308081626892,
0.7667039632797241,
-0.07716648280620575,
0.05745316669344902,
0.5871534943580627,
-0.0952337384223938,
0.33692169189453125,
-0.15276813507080078,
-0.055541958659887314,
-0.4809208810329437,
-0.31448379158973694,
-0.8244023323059082,
0.7014817595481873,
0.15829350054264069,
-0.5218139290809631,
-0.21962863206863403,
0.4736323952674866,
-0.0889212116599083,
0.14148110151290894,
0.019795814529061317,
0.5919696688652039,
-0.06406166404485703,
-0.597625195980072,
0.3400450348854065,
0.5378909707069397,
0.7504995465278625,
-0.5279236435890198,
-0.07993325591087341,
0.07711870968341827,
-0.27751386165618896,
0.12484732270240784,
-0.37930336594581604,
0.04805557429790497,
-0.2879737317562103,
-0.47259074449539185,
-0.816186785697937,
0.5956944823265076,
-0.3669488728046417,
-0.4586305022239685,
-0.03873433917760849,
1.1306571960449219,
0.17080600559711456,
-0.23777209222316742,
-0.5941423177719116,
0.34961360692977905,
-0.10351597517728806,
-0.21235868334770203,
0.16596946120262146,
0.6822604537010193,
-0.1102292537689209,
0.48564574122428894,
0.27462947368621826,
-0.20523671805858612,
0.4398532509803772,
-0.1986447423696518,
0.6694271564483643,
-0.8904765844345093,
-0.1736704707145691,
-0.4713217318058014,
0.8237289190292358,
0.03759157285094261,
-0.7122327089309692,
1.1050076484680176,
0.6915698647499084,
0.7972504496574402,
-0.44578927755355835,
0.7604162693023682,
-0.0861651822924614,
0.2504451274871826,
-0.4686933755874634,
0.7763776183128357,
-0.8579229116439819,
-0.1687440127134323,
-0.5214602947235107,
-0.7754392027854919,
-0.2615312933921814,
0.21221782267093658,
-0.1073659285902977,
0.09665413945913315,
0.915483295917511,
0.4163152575492859,
-0.14491845667362213,
-0.03286009654402733,
0.29081425070762634,
-0.20093972980976105,
0.13756577670574188,
0.2546309232711792,
1.0072728395462036,
-0.6836290955543518,
0.670876145362854,
-0.19922283291816711,
-0.18124178051948547,
-0.4721534848213196,
-0.7508938312530518,
-0.49481138586997986,
-0.9100387692451477,
-0.11107520759105682,
0.1823863834142685,
-0.17645996809005737,
0.623045802116394,
0.7511004209518433,
-0.6628462672233582,
-0.27041104435920715,
0.4776593744754791,
0.18078307807445526,
-0.45262831449508667,
-0.09143238514661789,
0.050920892506837845,
-0.5204881429672241,
-1.0733767747879028,
0.5617128610610962,
0.1642586886882782,
-0.008064190857112408,
-0.33921509981155396,
0.08583127707242966,
-0.48906210064888,
-0.4210905134677887,
0.8889620900154114,
-0.07300961017608643,
-0.8484309911727905,
0.0803394541144371,
0.48334550857543945,
-0.2621649205684662,
-0.054932061582803726,
1.1882514953613281,
-0.29559510946273804,
0.7075321078300476,
0.6765003800392151,
0.6444203853607178,
0.48367345333099365,
0.057685285806655884,
0.6887191534042358,
-0.47077715396881104,
-0.04709535092115402,
-0.02377159893512726,
0.16120712459087372,
0.2656933069229126,
-0.10508234798908234,
0.3085832893848419,
0.5062606930732727,
-0.4908181130886078,
-0.7982009649276733,
0.27427640557289124,
-1.3150956630706787,
-0.3788410425186157,
0.9343034625053406,
0.14953242242336273,
0.1709170937538147,
-0.25014105439186096,
-0.34407326579093933,
0.4194799065589905,
-0.19225317239761353,
0.45100390911102295,
0.7534135580062866,
-0.20581446588039398,
-0.15063412487506866,
-1.0164226293563843,
0.17288656532764435,
0.5023291707038879,
-0.5444546341896057,
-0.18112030625343323,
1.0343694686889648,
-0.10893368721008301,
0.10236498713493347,
0.38872718811035156,
-0.5090509653091431,
0.041084304451942444,
-0.04160100594162941,
-0.025859853252768517,
-0.27428779006004333,
-0.6137692332267761,
-0.5055954456329346,
0.5271624326705933,
0.10293088853359222,
-0.2859160304069519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12656v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12656v1
|
Retrieval-Augmented Language Model for Extreme Multi-Label Knowledge Graph Link Prediction
| 2024-05-21T10:10:56 | 2024-05-21T10:10:56 |
Yu-Hsiang Lin, Huang-Ting Shieh, Chih-Yu Liu, Kuang-Ting Lee, Hsiao-Cheng Chang, Jing-Lun Yang, Yu-Sheng Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Extrapolation in Large language models (LLMs) for open-ended inquiry
encounters two pivotal issues: (1) hallucination and (2) expensive training
costs. These issues present challenges for LLMs in specialized domains and
personalized data, requiring truthful responses and low fine-tuning costs.
Existing works attempt to tackle the problem by augmenting the input of a
smaller language model with information from a knowledge graph (KG). However,
they have two limitations: (1) failing to extract relevant information from a
large one-hop neighborhood in KG and (2) applying the same augmentation
strategy for KGs with different characteristics that may result in low
performance. Moreover, open-ended inquiry typically yields multiple responses,
further complicating extrapolation. We propose a new task, the extreme
multi-label KG link prediction task, to enable a model to perform extrapolation
with multiple responses using structured real-world knowledge. Our retriever
identifies relevant one-hop neighbors by considering entity, relation, and
textual data together. Our experiments demonstrate that (1) KGs with different
characteristics require different augmenting strategies, and (2) augmenting the
language model's input with textual data improves task performance
significantly. By incorporating the retrieval-augmented framework with KG, our
framework, with a small parameter size, is able to extrapolate based on a given
KG. The code can be obtained on GitHub:
https://github.com/exiled1143/Retrieval-Augmented-Language-Model-for-Multi-Label-Knowledge-Graph-Link-Prediction.git
|
[
-0.44603654742240906,
-1.116548776626587,
0.5525099635124207,
-0.13917170464992523,
-0.00814364105463028,
0.08163938671350479,
-0.18197572231292725,
-0.8594639301300049,
0.6058003902435303,
0.6100208163261414,
-0.4839152991771698,
-0.452843576669693,
-0.4283013641834259,
-0.017020471394062042,
-0.151363804936409,
0.7791811227798462,
0.13279730081558228,
-0.18628661334514618,
-0.17270909249782562,
-0.17516444623470306,
-0.1233493834733963,
-0.6891025900840759,
-0.3226626515388489,
-0.474214106798172,
0.6288211941719055,
0.38143715262413025,
0.8626124858856201,
0.5607567429542542,
0.17973670363426208,
0.18232786655426025,
-0.2069839984178543,
0.45758065581321716,
-0.5379462838172913,
0.25684383511543274,
0.10650888830423355,
-0.2544536888599396,
-0.424209326505661,
-0.07287222892045975,
0.6950531601905823,
0.8873013257980347,
0.0902891457080841,
0.10399450361728668,
-0.19834938645362854,
0.5757209062576294,
-0.423732191324234,
0.34782737493515015,
-0.7011802792549133,
-0.12750540673732758,
0.09992635995149612,
-0.15579238533973694,
-0.48235225677490234,
-0.33432433009147644,
0.3531898558139801,
-0.6138028502464294,
-0.04698684811592102,
0.3491378128528595,
0.6196319460868835,
-0.1050485223531723,
-0.4100077748298645,
-0.275260329246521,
-0.46016982197761536,
0.35163673758506775,
-0.4370834529399872,
0.7323352098464966,
0.6838563680648804,
0.23841482400894165,
-0.2437032014131546,
-0.6352209448814392,
-0.5261440873146057,
-0.5326002240180969,
-0.12072372436523438,
0.06140594929456711,
0.026516351848840714,
0.11353453248739243,
0.27303609251976013,
0.14999878406524658,
-0.39114341139793396,
0.025193527340888977,
-0.19991227984428406,
-0.13040974736213684,
0.3254454731941223,
0.040262673050165176,
0.0820130854845047,
-0.03645576536655426,
-0.31949087977409363,
-0.16597050428390503,
-0.8024057745933533,
0.006264467258006334,
0.6070643663406372,
0.5412387251853943,
0.2256476730108261,
0.7698008418083191,
-0.5598565340042114,
0.8797808885574341,
-0.3066549301147461,
0.07786178588867188,
0.5226008892059326,
0.012246783822774887,
0.18203894793987274,
-0.0009515765123069286,
0.725717306137085,
0.26285600662231445,
0.16115787625312805,
-0.25695449113845825,
-0.21651500463485718,
-0.341500848531723,
-0.10440324246883392,
-0.6157196164131165,
-0.4939099848270416,
0.06437649577856064,
-0.08180420100688934,
-0.10661441087722778,
-0.16596493124961853,
-0.719029426574707,
-0.369368314743042,
-0.2156989872455597,
0.45865029096603394,
-0.5533382296562195,
-0.14731481671333313,
-0.13298486173152924,
0.046631984412670135,
-0.39943915605545044,
0.1542132943868637,
-0.537039041519165,
0.09483739733695984,
0.2978605628013611,
0.7951950430870056,
0.07548096776008606,
-0.4718590974807739,
-0.7708983421325684,
0.47746363282203674,
-0.08000701665878296,
0.8751692771911621,
-1.1503139734268188,
-0.37719252705574036,
-0.017350632697343826,
-0.07956907153129578,
0.13272614777088165,
-0.3953697681427002,
0.5316128134727478,
-1.0830540657043457,
-0.17074565589427948,
-0.20479340851306915,
-0.5483075976371765,
-0.2272268682718277,
0.5393227934837341,
-0.9358537793159485,
1.265114426612854,
0.19087611138820648,
-0.6871350407600403,
-0.06719279289245605,
-0.614707350730896,
-0.38285380601882935,
0.19054320454597473,
-0.07554006576538086,
-0.21021027863025665,
-0.1019807904958725,
0.3401101529598236,
0.4241707921028137,
-0.3052639067173004,
0.21625207364559174,
-0.556215226650238,
-0.26973623037338257,
0.19867250323295593,
-0.3735775053501129,
0.3752388060092926,
-0.06451673805713654,
0.13906407356262207,
0.017700789496302605,
-1.014891505241394,
0.3363291323184967,
-0.05628730356693268,
-0.6223598122596741,
-0.6228988766670227,
-0.1853492110967636,
-0.07934271544218063,
0.30262133479118347,
0.2771953344345093,
-0.6682962775230408,
0.3499048352241516,
-0.477881520986557,
-0.06867965310811996,
0.750988245010376,
-0.1491640955209732,
0.26422667503356934,
-0.15190713107585907,
0.5336527824401855,
-0.2720503807067871,
0.011529890820384026,
-0.33834585547447205,
-0.5951133966445923,
-0.3612925410270691,
-0.14814913272857666,
0.29399511218070984,
0.27656349539756775,
-1.004455804824829,
0.15868332982063293,
-0.5577731132507324,
-0.4897506833076477,
-0.5039047002792358,
0.04678339138627052,
0.5434226989746094,
0.6737419366836548,
0.7131415009498596,
0.008185330778360367,
-0.5793156027793884,
-0.5983104705810547,
-0.28984612226486206,
-0.3830675184726715,
0.08786891400814056,
0.6517144441604614,
0.4100329577922821,
-0.18249636888504028,
0.9047735929489136,
-0.9330859780311584,
-0.37079674005508423,
-0.15597465634346008,
0.15332332253456116,
0.2845557928085327,
0.19749577343463898,
0.004119614139199257,
-1.0160949230194092,
-0.8103957176208496,
0.18615558743476868,
-0.5099778771400452,
-0.048730943351984024,
0.3748026490211487,
-0.018753627315163612,
-0.18307286500930786,
0.3011360168457031,
-0.4317818582057953,
0.13609108328819275,
0.7136864066123962,
-0.13084030151367188,
0.8666568398475647,
-0.20106641948223114,
-0.014282340183854103,
-0.8583315014839172,
0.05865867808461189,
0.040603213012218475,
-0.11469478905200958,
-0.6294789910316467,
0.3612826466560364,
0.17870859801769257,
0.04551259055733681,
-0.1871986836194992,
0.8159241080284119,
-0.4449133276939392,
-0.005805240944027901,
-0.29443368315696716,
0.21040186285972595,
-0.04679713770747185,
0.6047176718711853,
0.169381245970726,
0.6405245065689087,
0.41309961676597595,
-0.551364004611969,
0.7182472944259644,
0.2512761354446411,
-0.255376398563385,
0.14568054676055908,
-0.5173723101615906,
0.31320086121559143,
-0.0932675376534462,
0.3720676898956299,
-0.9050514101982117,
-0.30894818902015686,
0.012590590864419937,
-0.6581554412841797,
0.33548375964164734,
-0.2951122224330902,
-0.7326279282569885,
-0.3777320384979248,
-0.38258126378059387,
0.3787781298160553,
0.14825588464736938,
-0.7748073935508728,
0.76796555519104,
0.5038295388221741,
-0.13384194672107697,
-0.6781080961227417,
-0.41602224111557007,
0.08479693531990051,
0.16329896450042725,
-0.4148705005645752,
0.31735846400260925,
-0.25995689630508423,
0.19891873002052307,
0.17374369502067566,
0.082791768014431,
-0.03991292789578438,
-0.19780099391937256,
0.10089381039142609,
0.3297607898712158,
0.07802234590053558,
0.3063271641731262,
0.15963731706142426,
-0.11804596334695816,
0.034566763788461685,
-0.4729970395565033,
0.605198860168457,
-0.0239240825176239,
-0.47465676069259644,
0.15729323029518127,
0.27185916900634766,
0.456477552652359,
-0.21363873779773712,
0.8178656697273254,
0.52685546875,
-0.39637941122055054,
0.06016748771071434,
-0.7528347969055176,
-0.11190716922283173,
-0.4476359486579895,
0.6446638703346252,
-0.8963841199874878,
-0.8538458943367004,
0.5393317341804504,
-0.3337051272392273,
-0.21370363235473633,
0.16428808867931366,
0.35267016291618347,
0.07831081748008728,
1.210976243019104,
0.7396381497383118,
-0.005682134069502354,
0.27160167694091797,
-0.30760201811790466,
0.15072929859161377,
-1.296574592590332,
-0.6875529885292053,
-0.4580805003643036,
-0.039931703358888626,
-0.4393790364265442,
-0.351833701133728,
0.7067398428916931,
0.23249691724777222,
0.04369034245610237,
0.3483699858188629,
-0.3098205029964447,
0.5924724340438843,
0.6768152713775635,
0.44463270902633667,
0.5952325463294983,
0.3370780050754547,
-0.693889856338501,
0.033088091760873795,
-0.7405130863189697,
-0.14638353884220123,
1.2092654705047607,
0.13134241104125977,
0.8761858940124512,
0.25049707293510437,
0.35186299681663513,
0.05072242394089699,
0.4829687774181366,
-0.7622841000556946,
0.5049484372138977,
0.07591549307107925,
-0.5606442093849182,
-0.4428061246871948,
-0.6193427443504333,
-0.7488602995872498,
0.3991553783416748,
-0.20796078443527222,
-0.899291455745697,
-0.12186478823423386,
0.08664605021476746,
-0.017365921288728714,
0.33228302001953125,
-0.4914304316043854,
0.3511255979537964,
-0.0735238641500473,
-0.39762115478515625,
0.11704698950052261,
-0.899111807346344,
0.22257395088672638,
-0.3240388035774231,
0.35253337025642395,
0.026009706780314445,
-0.0037434182595461607,
0.6576895117759705,
-0.23763936758041382,
0.7375895380973816,
-0.03354403376579285,
-0.09014645963907242,
0.3230634331703186,
0.0630737692117691,
1.179782748222351,
-0.1087702289223671,
-0.3646112084388733,
-0.2530765235424042,
-0.182762011885643,
-0.29545605182647705,
-0.7636878490447998,
0.8461483716964722,
-0.7445927858352661,
-0.4930655062198639,
-0.03287737816572189,
-0.7959322929382324,
-0.6762041449546814,
0.2106502205133438,
0.10345203429460526,
0.5858685970306396,
0.13812415301799774,
0.11352390050888062,
0.6982237100601196,
-0.18241876363754272,
0.08251087367534637,
0.6733545064926147,
-0.49221765995025635,
-0.5371819138526917,
1.145696997642517,
0.3170611560344696,
0.25613167881965637,
0.6487791538238525,
0.37105706334114075,
-0.7921290993690491,
-0.3845042884349823,
-0.5722358822822571,
0.1890062540769577,
-0.9509199261665344,
-0.25849035382270813,
-1.1323661804199219,
0.011928506195545197,
-0.5876354575157166,
0.22568057477474213,
-0.2553309202194214,
-0.4202631711959839,
-0.013219289481639862,
-0.2510261833667755,
0.5445263981819153,
0.6659291386604309,
-0.14873240888118744,
0.11710502207279205,
-1.065546989440918,
0.21639786660671234,
0.1389075666666031,
0.5554924607276917,
0.23439310491085052,
-0.590502917766571,
-0.4511466324329376,
0.13115723431110382,
-0.0862753614783287,
-1.0039091110229492,
0.34358298778533936,
0.2608047127723694,
0.6073995232582092,
0.13459062576293945,
0.3626532256603241,
0.8316001296043396,
-0.5729795694351196,
0.4225797951221466,
0.37277647852897644,
-0.49664047360420227,
0.41664987802505493,
-0.2484607696533203,
0.1649773269891739,
0.37535160779953003,
0.8244763016700745,
-0.46264562010765076,
-0.333619624376297,
-0.3805271089076996,
-1.1444876194000244,
0.6602065563201904,
0.04247549921274185,
0.2876055836677551,
-0.08949538320302963,
0.3087702691555023,
0.12391398102045059,
0.16798357665538788,
-0.7419410943984985,
-0.46810054779052734,
0.243051677942276,
-0.0665857344865799,
0.15136612951755524,
-0.38859522342681885,
-0.07850371301174164,
-0.3632819652557373,
0.9248867034912109,
-0.44031450152397156,
0.1797313541173935,
0.0528545007109642,
-0.15100154280662537,
-0.22890645265579224,
0.1772756427526474,
0.08876080065965652,
0.6064602732658386,
-0.1802416890859604,
0.2645398676395416,
0.2722927927970886,
-0.43325817584991455,
0.144419863820076,
0.4695083796977997,
-0.011996159330010414,
0.03572686016559601,
0.22019121050834656,
0.7031119465827942,
0.006612465251237154,
-0.8803170919418335,
0.32859790325164795,
0.29589971899986267,
0.14362718164920807,
-0.029746154323220253,
-0.3075143098831177,
0.06984871625900269,
0.34144309163093567,
0.6292734146118164,
-0.2088480293750763,
0.20991940796375275,
-0.5353634357452393,
0.19028329849243164,
0.4192154109477997,
-0.6175166368484497,
-0.3015589118003845,
0.6257389783859253,
-0.008094537071883678,
-0.1327621191740036,
0.5553849339485168,
-0.39320048689842224,
-0.8652797341346741,
0.392374187707901,
0.7958478331565857,
0.44205373525619507,
-0.17342212796211243,
0.12601381540298462,
0.26106521487236023,
0.17961713671684265,
0.06244710832834244,
0.16888682544231415,
0.020759517326951027,
-0.7043223977088928,
-0.716192364692688,
-0.7529541254043579,
-0.4416557848453522,
0.14303576946258545,
-0.5257184505462646,
0.15473859012126923,
0.06944787502288818,
-0.07585243880748749,
-0.3311099410057068,
0.09647857397794724,
-0.39267292618751526,
0.2669330835342407,
-0.011322271078824997,
0.8232319951057434,
-0.6379130482673645,
0.9092504382133484,
1.114284634590149,
-0.4050675332546234,
-0.8496899604797363,
-0.19368170201778412,
-0.3095581531524658,
-0.8223114609718323,
0.6864267587661743,
0.11517857760190964,
-0.3271319568157196,
0.28176072239875793,
-0.3327960968017578,
-1.14610755443573,
0.9103477597236633,
0.29611536860466003,
-0.4514341652393341,
-0.2719859480857849,
0.07330884784460068,
0.39946550130844116,
-0.3014185130596161,
0.5576826333999634,
0.2710641622543335,
0.2960278391838074,
0.397934228181839,
-0.8901316523551941,
0.2103327214717865,
-0.24886581301689148,
-0.05319490283727646,
0.27489835023880005,
-0.543944239616394,
0.6190253496170044,
-0.4178808033466339,
0.13129153847694397,
0.029587214812636375,
0.6028842329978943,
0.4629474878311157,
0.21613654494285583,
0.35139402747154236,
0.6747717261314392,
0.7549241185188293,
0.26155176758766174,
1.0508980751037598,
-0.5160170197486877,
0.646924614906311,
1.3858412504196167,
-0.25179582834243774,
0.8365283608436584,
0.29460087418556213,
-0.3378906548023224,
0.2908667325973511,
0.5267512798309326,
0.23032531142234802,
0.5487581491470337,
0.019522586837410927,
-0.3403903841972351,
-0.05058548226952553,
-0.4694097638130188,
-0.5474995970726013,
0.14052999019622803,
0.4557405710220337,
-0.4585667848587036,
-0.10325026512145996,
0.10952149331569672,
-0.10182240605354309,
-0.13645027577877045,
-0.23141410946846008,
0.5186641216278076,
-0.1892278641462326,
-0.5259883403778076,
0.42277973890304565,
0.04420456290245056,
0.4251459836959839,
-0.628902792930603,
-0.2678079307079315,
-0.0061495606787502766,
-0.04523863270878792,
-0.070550836622715,
-0.7522551417350769,
-0.04054494947195053,
-0.21716225147247314,
-0.13704189658164978,
0.08357250690460205,
0.8154972195625305,
-0.6635276675224304,
-0.43525758385658264,
0.5811116695404053,
0.6371477842330933,
0.20824386179447174,
-0.3317558169364929,
-0.5893509984016418,
0.04721767455339432,
0.012242300435900688,
-0.6209385991096497,
0.46305784583091736,
0.35100966691970825,
0.05219471454620361,
0.9422138929367065,
0.8875769376754761,
0.13849906623363495,
0.3021043837070465,
0.11721773445606232,
1.3354178667068481,
-0.3907310962677002,
-0.43077513575553894,
-0.7446411848068237,
0.07851319015026093,
0.011417202651500702,
-0.04885166138410568,
0.5994556546211243,
0.7499065399169922,
0.871758759021759,
0.20686616003513336,
0.8524937033653259,
-0.04834991320967674,
0.45078861713409424,
-0.572289228439331,
0.42180413007736206,
-0.6089072227478027,
0.35839009284973145,
-0.41033583879470825,
-1.1095025539398193,
-0.24772490561008453,
0.2087569683790207,
-0.231294646859169,
0.1320669949054718,
0.6703936457633972,
0.8716275691986084,
-0.03170037642121315,
0.11976534873247147,
0.5515108108520508,
0.3748435080051422,
0.25289398431777954,
0.4395088255405426,
0.8722804188728333,
-0.31526193022727966,
0.9424664974212646,
-0.3695654273033142,
-0.2616127133369446,
-0.1945512443780899,
-0.6167532205581665,
-0.608702540397644,
-0.577593207359314,
-0.16699248552322388,
-0.5373477935791016,
0.14006657898426056,
1.0757607221603394,
0.612898051738739,
-0.4252713918685913,
0.01894236169755459,
0.12178076058626175,
0.11923503130674362,
0.032983679324388504,
-0.234383225440979,
0.5477019548416138,
-0.20463840663433075,
-0.8317399024963379,
0.5172518491744995,
0.18462450802326202,
-0.0612356923520565,
-0.20090197026729584,
-0.1182340607047081,
-0.5190218091011047,
-0.29346510767936707,
0.9405526518821716,
0.1810888797044754,
-0.6002614498138428,
-0.24465078115463257,
0.16172926127910614,
0.1515517383813858,
-0.05952249839901924,
0.6226798892021179,
-1.0143787860870361,
0.8351303339004517,
0.3308153748512268,
0.8365469574928284,
0.5599126219749451,
0.037603169679641724,
0.36582016944885254,
-0.9428234100341797,
-0.35564038157463074,
0.20036426186561584,
0.22872567176818848,
0.17741702497005463,
-0.5614405870437622,
0.6365512609481812,
0.3297395706176758,
-0.3694572150707245,
-0.7265186309814453,
0.46473240852355957,
-0.46381834149360657,
-0.19752497971057892,
1.3138008117675781,
-0.426016628742218,
-0.10068739950656891,
-0.3175875246524811,
-0.10548431426286697,
0.27027854323387146,
-0.5720802545547485,
0.48120397329330444,
0.6551253199577332,
-0.40219414234161377,
-0.06797492504119873,
-0.5959340929985046,
-0.03685496747493744,
0.25633159279823303,
-0.4626469612121582,
0.09952773153781891,
0.6148523688316345,
0.04810798168182373,
0.2846401333808899,
0.5600966811180115,
0.054644081741571426,
-0.0975080281496048,
-0.06401889771223068,
-0.19921474158763885,
-0.4592333436012268,
-0.510759711265564,
0.026556404307484627,
0.41858887672424316,
0.06977005302906036,
0.1726650595664978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12630v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12630v1
|
Exploration of Masked and Causal Language Modelling for Text Generation
| 2024-05-21T09:33:31 | 2024-05-21T09:33:31 |
Nicolo Micheletti, Samuel Belkadi, Lifeng Han, Goran Nenadic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionised the field of Natural
Language Processing (NLP) and have achieved state-of-the-art performance in
practically every task in this field. However, the prevalent approach used in
text generation, Causal Language Modelling (CLM), which generates text
sequentially from left to right, inherently limits the freedom of the model,
which does not decide when and where each token is generated. In contrast,
Masked Language Modelling (MLM), primarily used for language understanding
tasks, can generate tokens anywhere in the text and any order. This paper
conducts an extensive comparison of MLM and CLM approaches for text generation
tasks. To do so, we pre-train several language models of comparable sizes on
three different datasets, namely 1) medical discharge summaries, 2) movie plot
synopses, and 3) authorship verification datasets. To assess the quality of the
generations, we first employ quantitative metrics and then perform a
qualitative human evaluation to analyse coherence and grammatical correctness.
In addition, we evaluate the usefulness of the generated texts by using them in
three different downstream tasks: 1) Entity Recognition, 2) Text
Classification, and 3) Authorship Verification. The results show that MLM
consistently outperforms CLM in text generation across all datasets, with
higher quantitative scores and better coherence in the generated text. The
study also finds \textit{no strong correlation} between the quality of the
generated text and the performance of the models in the downstream tasks. With
this study, we show that MLM for text generation has great potential for future
research and provides direction for future studies in this area.
|
[
-0.07625174522399902,
-0.8450127840042114,
0.4863300025463104,
0.31691470742225647,
-0.2702465057373047,
-0.013711770065128803,
-0.25634637475013733,
-0.5310022234916687,
-0.055899180471897125,
0.8824387788772583,
-0.5506982207298279,
-0.6182872653007507,
-0.5468645691871643,
0.4050983786582947,
-0.5767025947570801,
0.9698368906974792,
0.03723447397351265,
0.08141198009252548,
-0.4070354700088501,
0.09115041792392731,
-0.6928577423095703,
-0.6871240735054016,
-0.8397448658943176,
-0.3707753121852875,
0.5473397970199585,
0.017996985465288162,
0.4752039909362793,
0.6957443952560425,
0.4116978943347931,
0.2635003924369812,
0.07600951939821243,
0.31172052025794983,
-0.5602349638938904,
0.48254266381263733,
-0.16838157176971436,
-0.26250919699668884,
-0.2232132852077484,
-0.07410743087530136,
0.5947060585021973,
0.6091065406799316,
0.31224876642227173,
0.2278033047914505,
0.22603099048137665,
0.6022489070892334,
-0.4975406229496002,
0.04307762160897255,
-0.7470200061798096,
0.00212232512421906,
-0.16277557611465454,
-0.29865461587905884,
-0.6330054998397827,
-0.39025989174842834,
0.03757127374410629,
-0.24960777163505554,
0.42733368277549744,
0.2537045180797577,
0.8905345797538757,
0.10648743063211441,
-0.5683097243309021,
-0.7498778700828552,
-0.8981313109397888,
0.8369113206863403,
-0.8772658109664917,
0.18611209094524384,
0.18091687560081482,
0.03762727975845337,
-0.24174010753631592,
-0.8149779438972473,
-0.6470338702201843,
-0.31012439727783203,
-0.199666827917099,
0.11329727619886398,
-0.021362103521823883,
0.05573076009750366,
0.21014976501464844,
0.29032906889915466,
-0.6706154346466064,
0.45082467794418335,
-0.14515097439289093,
-0.28000208735466003,
0.7640294432640076,
0.24522888660430908,
0.4465143382549286,
-0.3779619038105011,
-0.5511617660522461,
-0.06827956438064575,
-1.0084857940673828,
-0.09704320877790451,
0.5794081091880798,
0.23156429827213287,
-0.010826796293258667,
0.7043270468711853,
-0.17759518325328827,
0.8631115555763245,
-0.04122740402817726,
-0.39124545454978943,
-0.13258089125156403,
-0.5815637707710266,
-0.3948228657245636,
0.03847723454236984,
1.0880838632583618,
0.1293165534734726,
0.2772340774536133,
-0.056260015815496445,
-0.16209018230438232,
-0.04009014740586281,
0.12772008776664734,
-0.7733310461044312,
0.050101783126592636,
0.2809404134750366,
-0.38417473435401917,
-0.36496350169181824,
-0.09173953533172607,
-0.4888671338558197,
-0.45590656995773315,
-0.40293970704078674,
0.28619736433029175,
-0.1356574296951294,
-0.1178981140255928,
0.08249776810407639,
0.13497063517570496,
0.09107399731874466,
0.16895118355751038,
-0.7605802416801453,
0.06603354960680008,
0.6846671104431152,
0.5830637216567993,
-0.4498577415943146,
-0.09229446202516556,
-0.5460536479949951,
0.13741837441921234,
-0.38479486107826233,
0.4885799288749695,
-0.1134427860379219,
-0.046450261026620865,
0.3632950186729431,
-0.35346493124961853,
-0.2779613733291626,
-0.5790289044380188,
0.5489922761917114,
-0.5597930550575256,
0.45473915338516235,
0.06728273630142212,
-0.6218521595001221,
-0.04778062924742699,
0.05587265267968178,
-0.6980991959571838,
0.9447060823440552,
-0.24353273212909698,
-0.8625900745391846,
0.6931915879249573,
-0.3057165741920471,
-0.48005515336990356,
0.11883444339036942,
-0.36984124779701233,
-0.7081655263900757,
-0.10426382720470428,
0.13112208247184753,
0.9998437762260437,
-0.43081995844841003,
1.0322847366333008,
-0.05378216877579689,
-0.04251914098858833,
0.45063063502311707,
-0.489581435918808,
0.6288633346557617,
0.21041768789291382,
-0.5907663106918335,
0.15016505122184753,
-0.9467940926551819,
-0.24260197579860687,
-0.04806270822882652,
-0.13890592753887177,
-0.2370469868183136,
0.07659220695495605,
0.25539639592170715,
0.6178223490715027,
0.05169718712568283,
-0.34113383293151855,
-0.3333797752857208,
-0.43741530179977417,
0.3449154794216156,
0.559592604637146,
0.26725220680236816,
0.20518532395362854,
-0.24142135679721832,
0.3609164357185364,
0.04075495898723602,
-0.1364278942346573,
-0.48210403323173523,
-0.6055607795715332,
-0.8825011849403381,
-0.32219165563583374,
0.3659130334854126,
0.4543621242046356,
-0.7729749083518982,
0.48864099383354187,
-0.22312544286251068,
-0.2653404176235199,
-0.2143726348876953,
0.15933625400066376,
0.5900804400444031,
0.48490041494369507,
0.03764262795448303,
-0.15980537235736847,
-0.5377911329269409,
-0.8709944486618042,
-0.43856102228164673,
-0.20438864827156067,
-0.057393670082092285,
0.2225084900856018,
0.4682742953300476,
-0.1593811959028244,
1.015785813331604,
-0.3828464150428772,
-0.07889601588249207,
-0.3352946639060974,
0.27408623695373535,
0.027536679059267044,
0.5189417004585266,
0.24742749333381653,
-0.7706591486930847,
-0.4154255986213684,
-0.08731354773044586,
-1.008611798286438,
-0.28827834129333496,
-0.5862160325050354,
-0.074569471180439,
0.49828794598579407,
0.7384029030799866,
-0.5624238848686218,
0.37482139468193054,
0.6123272776603699,
-0.3691864311695099,
0.6616623997688293,
-0.05937042459845543,
0.04100704565644264,
-1.3592069149017334,
0.3747256100177765,
-0.11426869034767151,
-0.47869813442230225,
-0.9597495198249817,
0.067070871591568,
-0.08303917944431305,
-0.2734871208667755,
-0.4179416000843048,
0.620448648929596,
-0.7021691799163818,
0.049132075160741806,
-0.29719141125679016,
0.26253730058670044,
-0.05473899468779564,
0.47417008876800537,
-0.012874712236225605,
0.489990234375,
0.3289858400821686,
-0.5426571369171143,
0.03680222108960152,
-0.07517014443874359,
-0.5395079255104065,
0.15578106045722961,
-0.4973911643028259,
-0.02006160095334053,
-0.09628009051084518,
0.07004982978105545,
-1.1255336999893188,
-0.3449135720729828,
0.13284827768802643,
-0.2715965509414673,
0.48449793457984924,
0.37157824635505676,
-0.7689894437789917,
-0.2449951022863388,
-0.058552250266075134,
0.2927740812301636,
0.5139402151107788,
-0.3481282889842987,
0.22908706963062286,
0.17698657512664795,
-0.3932645618915558,
-0.532832682132721,
-0.5499893426895142,
0.35614362359046936,
-0.3227846920490265,
-0.6949207186698914,
0.19623741507530212,
0.11290888488292694,
-0.39427363872528076,
-0.30632728338241577,
0.12625624239444733,
0.1234407126903534,
0.13105736672878265,
0.3268123269081116,
0.21746821701526642,
-0.20212684571743011,
0.06750228255987167,
0.21686430275440216,
-0.13525690138339996,
0.1443217694759369,
-0.26850196719169617,
0.502740740776062,
0.5014854073524475,
-0.2194989174604416,
-0.27884531021118164,
0.4352814853191376,
0.3526455760002136,
-0.05752796307206154,
0.9964438080787659,
0.6485458016395569,
-0.33929815888404846,
-0.31535837054252625,
-0.7152731418609619,
-0.15566948056221008,
-0.3936735987663269,
0.2048850804567337,
-0.06661549210548401,
-1.1355007886886597,
0.4242602288722992,
0.0383489727973938,
0.14469078183174133,
0.614700198173523,
0.8278116583824158,
0.15676651895046234,
0.8206282258033752,
0.7097540497779846,
0.14793294668197632,
0.30901452898979187,
0.11963848769664764,
0.44406789541244507,
-0.36385390162467957,
-0.171214297413826,
-0.5082491636276245,
0.1238926351070404,
-0.748936116695404,
-0.3422612249851227,
0.17670144140720367,
0.3124261796474457,
-0.06448589265346527,
0.22394901514053345,
-0.24896664917469025,
0.16634662449359894,
0.49840298295021057,
-0.03238922730088234,
0.5185291767120361,
0.1372087299823761,
-0.1915532946586609,
0.09278412908315659,
-0.7623699307441711,
-0.8805447816848755,
1.0569406747817993,
0.19659434258937836,
0.33108270168304443,
-0.23175695538520813,
0.6806941628456116,
0.2812677323818207,
0.5464886426925659,
-0.14157672226428986,
0.6097944974899292,
-0.1565178781747818,
-0.6243377327919006,
-0.2847464680671692,
-0.41245442628860474,
-0.9706754684448242,
0.21654415130615234,
-0.5346752405166626,
-0.6253324151039124,
-0.016616161912679672,
0.14258460700511932,
-0.17311520874500275,
0.16259153187274933,
-0.6563869714736938,
0.6342045068740845,
0.04166880249977112,
-0.5839373469352722,
0.12870824337005615,
-0.8018816113471985,
0.7459637522697449,
-0.458059698343277,
0.16631068289279938,
0.06339609622955322,
0.16945020854473114,
0.7162923812866211,
-0.3979768753051758,
1.0438507795333862,
0.1705072969198227,
-0.45519083738327026,
0.38707369565963745,
0.005408478435128927,
0.5123095512390137,
0.0461890771985054,
-0.1640939861536026,
0.305148184299469,
-0.46892082691192627,
-0.20069868862628937,
-0.3175050616264343,
0.8019562363624573,
-0.5841328501701355,
-0.6287115812301636,
-0.1877906322479248,
-0.5558907985687256,
-0.0031625134870409966,
0.3700683116912842,
0.5875357985496521,
0.5922503471374512,
-0.16792476177215576,
-0.03859953209757805,
0.5369751453399658,
-0.6358145475387573,
0.5597981810569763,
0.2861064672470093,
-0.32660242915153503,
-0.4546836018562317,
0.7671729922294617,
0.005565502680838108,
0.5311716198921204,
0.6108997464179993,
0.06647416204214096,
-0.2860414385795593,
-0.6039326786994934,
-0.6249948143959045,
0.21692432463169098,
-0.496783584356308,
-0.23163488507270813,
-0.955225944519043,
-0.4028014838695526,
-0.4697229564189911,
-0.2229040414094925,
0.03206204995512962,
-0.36796918511390686,
-0.3601962625980377,
-0.026905309408903122,
0.11409492045640945,
0.7790061235427856,
0.14482975006103516,
0.20601874589920044,
-0.5481564998626709,
0.3675898015499115,
0.13461153209209442,
-0.031300660222768784,
0.11525970697402954,
-0.13171066343784332,
-0.3758196532726288,
-0.06306784600019455,
-0.41068270802497864,
-0.8164513111114502,
0.5075057148933411,
-0.05644633620977402,
0.31379061937332153,
0.4085712134838104,
-0.15626192092895508,
0.3957602083683014,
-0.6021929383277893,
1.0898298025131226,
0.31401118636131287,
-0.8374823927879333,
0.2758053243160248,
-0.5091915726661682,
0.20444363355636597,
0.36603817343711853,
0.2578130066394806,
-0.39551830291748047,
-0.9592382311820984,
-0.5117319822311401,
-0.9320361614227295,
0.45493340492248535,
0.7703666090965271,
-0.053181957453489304,
0.07695484161376953,
0.347650945186615,
0.49900296330451965,
0.48439955711364746,
-0.9555563926696777,
-0.3264493942260742,
0.16131368279457092,
-0.30607083439826965,
-0.46689531207084656,
-0.3496977686882019,
0.25696247816085815,
0.24690037965774536,
0.6025115847587585,
0.09740861505270004,
0.103037990629673,
0.26123255491256714,
-0.1644088327884674,
0.022551964968442917,
0.2774949073791504,
0.9487597942352295,
0.6102010011672974,
0.07446514815092087,
0.19114886224269867,
-0.1344974786043167,
-0.5084590315818787,
0.16012997925281525,
-0.11877711117267609,
-0.46297991275787354,
0.27344363927841187,
0.7037516832351685,
0.8827911019325256,
0.04495512321591377,
-0.5969311594963074,
0.48381999135017395,
0.10841604322195053,
-0.2636276185512543,
0.013716812245547771,
0.012987479567527771,
0.1479129046201706,
-0.04684637486934662,
0.32304292917251587,
0.010030316188931465,
0.042210184037685394,
-0.3339709937572479,
0.08826112747192383,
0.3910658061504364,
-0.19178810715675354,
-0.11880620568990707,
0.840561032295227,
0.1818552315235138,
-0.39132562279701233,
0.3646533787250519,
-0.10555598884820938,
-0.31144577264785767,
0.6381130218505859,
0.797834575176239,
1.160324215888977,
0.054627783596515656,
0.26257121562957764,
0.3925808072090149,
0.40191322565078735,
-0.03818677365779877,
-0.08088783174753189,
-0.10982909053564072,
-0.601227343082428,
-0.735369086265564,
-0.7613798975944519,
-0.22812114655971527,
0.41918569803237915,
-0.36065924167633057,
0.2104102075099945,
0.01686115935444832,
-0.06751593202352524,
-0.08835387974977493,
-0.09098097681999207,
-0.6220669746398926,
0.33348792791366577,
0.056120168417692184,
0.6048251390457153,
-0.9539834856987,
0.5334637761116028,
0.31610462069511414,
-0.11955786496400833,
-0.787656843662262,
0.12888272106647491,
-0.279310405254364,
-0.5514066219329834,
0.7701616883277893,
0.3514656722545624,
-0.05912020429968834,
0.023180624470114708,
-0.40330976247787476,
-0.5062202215194702,
1.0035429000854492,
0.2569858431816101,
-0.5985562205314636,
0.0476723238825798,
0.6576054096221924,
0.8332350254058838,
-0.4409027397632599,
0.08915550261735916,
0.23549677431583405,
0.1731424182653427,
-0.15644872188568115,
-0.6905649900436401,
0.2703509032726288,
-0.05169955641031265,
0.26171478629112244,
0.18118247389793396,
-0.3597007393836975,
0.7934759259223938,
-0.04893452674150467,
-0.5719267129898071,
0.3098798990249634,
0.5976935625076294,
0.44856762886047363,
0.5064881443977356,
0.25328660011291504,
0.16888092458248138,
0.5916356444358826,
0.08083953708410263,
1.0508172512054443,
-0.42805469036102295,
0.20233389735221863,
0.9402598142623901,
-0.440599262714386,
0.6438387036323547,
0.45227736234664917,
0.2009236067533493,
0.47789549827575684,
0.47230806946754456,
0.2181084305047989,
0.19417570531368256,
0.4781849980354309,
-0.249591663479805,
-0.1753540337085724,
-0.03744782507419586,
-0.1826860010623932,
0.1353163719177246,
-0.01780799962580204,
-0.7205761075019836,
-0.08007130026817322,
0.23771069943904877,
0.09642314910888672,
0.29786446690559387,
-0.2604597806930542,
0.8873694539070129,
0.2549751102924347,
-0.9040834307670593,
0.4915637671947479,
0.2614564597606659,
0.5753740072250366,
-0.4316163957118988,
0.07337454706430435,
-0.26116952300071716,
-0.013912307098507881,
-0.0435648187994957,
-0.40474340319633484,
0.2332628071308136,
0.31717538833618164,
-0.2910192012786865,
-0.5944193601608276,
1.1355671882629395,
-0.622200608253479,
-0.6605040431022644,
-0.0000055566802075190935,
0.5899546146392822,
0.16886606812477112,
0.08650310337543488,
-0.38583093881607056,
-0.07528369128704071,
-0.014130799099802971,
-0.11704987287521362,
0.20827652513980865,
0.35287442803382874,
-0.2135361284017563,
0.5984172821044922,
0.7446153163909912,
0.14066016674041748,
0.2916206419467926,
0.0702926442027092,
0.47802990674972534,
-0.6306881904602051,
-0.43933436274528503,
-1.1793042421340942,
0.44042468070983887,
-0.10932102054357529,
-0.35269641876220703,
1.0434869527816772,
0.7391365170478821,
0.7366534471511841,
-0.34346744418144226,
0.6115826368331909,
0.2565268576145172,
0.37834128737449646,
-0.9045110940933228,
0.8803126215934753,
-0.2308705747127533,
0.2319774180650711,
-0.6070062518119812,
-0.8582526445388794,
-0.5938749313354492,
0.09791500121355057,
-0.15247313678264618,
0.005466099828481674,
0.6857814788818359,
0.8066413998603821,
0.20502682030200958,
-0.04549381881952286,
0.46609336137771606,
0.2197675108909607,
0.2967844307422638,
0.4349587857723236,
0.8955067992210388,
-0.4792321026325226,
0.25817570090293884,
0.14176832139492035,
0.0011273592244833708,
-0.15256251394748688,
-0.9552980661392212,
-1.209382176399231,
-0.6934539079666138,
-0.24160490930080414,
-0.30822911858558655,
0.053611479699611664,
0.5846502184867859,
0.5139959454536438,
-0.6283178329467773,
-0.327245831489563,
-0.47210341691970825,
0.23796430230140686,
-0.0967174768447876,
-0.27085644006729126,
0.37932753562927246,
-0.38392919301986694,
-0.6160825490951538,
0.06485241651535034,
0.3771026134490967,
-0.0957987979054451,
-0.5669535398483276,
0.023009074851870537,
-0.16291899979114532,
0.23697230219841003,
0.8453144431114197,
-0.12772350013256073,
-0.6723387241363525,
-0.06452754884958267,
-0.039823271334171295,
-0.4540521204471588,
-0.16936735808849335,
1.0950026512145996,
-0.7184653282165527,
0.2910073697566986,
0.5441367626190186,
0.5518345832824707,
0.5140761137008667,
-0.14920546114444733,
0.7766000032424927,
-0.7632918953895569,
-0.12750275433063507,
0.02382562682032585,
0.05108571797609329,
0.47956156730651855,
-0.5551878809928894,
0.27275627851486206,
0.16917604207992554,
-0.6228005290031433,
-1.0139131546020508,
0.3044241964817047,
-0.8206579089164734,
-0.22353646159172058,
1.344760537147522,
-0.002647862071171403,
0.0020976930391043425,
-0.23596884310245514,
-0.20516669750213623,
0.5294842720031738,
-0.008053389377892017,
0.6127321720123291,
0.5885394215583801,
0.05310588702559471,
0.18465858697891235,
-0.48156416416168213,
0.604525089263916,
0.38379624485969543,
-0.9185196161270142,
0.05903548374772072,
0.4222051203250885,
0.13889776170253754,
0.1317092925310135,
0.6010381579399109,
-0.036405518651008606,
-0.11109773069620132,
-0.1268942505121231,
0.05542637035250664,
-0.0280208270996809,
-0.3185884356498718,
-0.28703755140304565,
0.402519166469574,
-0.19502919912338257,
0.09913834929466248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12619v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12619v1
|
MentalQA: An Annotated Arabic Corpus for Questions and Answers of Mental Healthcare
| 2024-05-21T09:16:38 | 2024-05-21T09:16:38 |
Hassan Alhuzali, Ashwag Alasmari, Hamad Alsaleh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Mental health disorders significantly impact people globally, regardless of
background, education, or socioeconomic status. However, access to adequate
care remains a challenge, particularly for underserved communities with limited
resources. Text mining tools offer immense potential to support mental
healthcare by assisting professionals in diagnosing and treating patients. This
study addresses the scarcity of Arabic mental health resources for developing
such tools. We introduce MentalQA, a novel Arabic dataset featuring
conversational-style question-and-answer (QA) interactions. To ensure data
quality, we conducted a rigorous annotation process using a well-defined schema
with quality control measures. Data was collected from a question-answering
medical platform. The annotation schema for mental health questions and
corresponding answers draws upon existing classification schemes with some
modifications. Question types encompass six distinct categories: diagnosis,
treatment, anatomy \& physiology, epidemiology, healthy lifestyle, and provider
choice. Answer strategies include information provision, direct guidance, and
emotional support. Three experienced annotators collaboratively annotated the
data to ensure consistency. Our findings demonstrate high inter-annotator
agreement, with Fleiss' Kappa of $0.61$ for question types and $0.98$ for
answer strategies. In-depth analysis revealed insightful patterns, including
variations in question preferences across age groups and a strong correlation
between question types and answer strategies. MentalQA offers a valuable
foundation for developing Arabic text mining tools capable of supporting mental
health professionals and individuals seeking information.
|
[
-0.7478880286216736,
-0.7815814018249512,
0.7286205887794495,
0.03249058127403259,
-0.19960741698741913,
-0.013760879635810852,
0.13679051399230957,
-0.506229817867279,
0.3376407325267792,
0.4803432822227478,
-0.7967846989631653,
-0.7555897235870361,
-0.7768954634666443,
0.17331847548484802,
-0.24522003531455994,
1.254044532775879,
-0.18333084881305695,
0.05795690789818764,
-0.08112746477127075,
-0.27800992131233215,
-0.26378631591796875,
-0.6906978487968445,
-0.7591574788093567,
-0.018810482695698738,
0.6346153020858765,
0.4435512125492096,
1.136286735534668,
-0.06563543528318405,
0.29630935192108154,
0.19150970876216888,
0.09899100661277771,
0.5420690774917603,
0.08728239685297012,
0.1253882497549057,
-0.05481909587979317,
-0.23543289303779602,
-0.31098029017448425,
-0.19071944057941437,
0.019777411594986916,
0.3252342641353607,
-0.3344942331314087,
0.6189829111099243,
-0.2719895839691162,
0.6000965237617493,
-0.5642232894897461,
0.03291160985827446,
-0.22627390921115875,
0.1945764571428299,
-0.4997812807559967,
0.027613060548901558,
0.3495561480522156,
-0.573924720287323,
-0.04962575063109398,
-0.46821078658103943,
-0.09258650243282318,
-0.1641083061695099,
0.7195446491241455,
0.6120404601097107,
-0.5919000506401062,
-0.48649153113365173,
-0.5183115601539612,
0.3823094069957733,
-0.48902595043182373,
0.0005541733698919415,
0.9334512948989868,
0.4713737964630127,
-0.09209026396274567,
-0.5320199131965637,
-0.6832236647605896,
0.2704944312572479,
-0.27409231662750244,
0.021939292550086975,
-0.23501494526863098,
0.040108900517225266,
0.2840268611907959,
0.3655233383178711,
-0.41013526916503906,
-0.5426986813545227,
-0.21236053109169006,
-0.352571040391922,
0.5972177386283875,
0.30576056241989136,
0.8467200994491577,
-0.2084452211856842,
0.1807301938533783,
0.33907967805862427,
-0.3793030083179474,
0.32823631167411804,
0.0012664883397519588,
-0.07563339173793793,
-0.04250895977020264,
0.8500112295150757,
-0.35334211587905884,
0.22211965918540955,
-0.09448525309562683,
-0.16547754406929016,
-0.11871210485696793,
-0.057146113365888596,
0.03414640575647354,
0.22765040397644043,
0.4852510690689087,
0.48102298378944397,
0.28547173738479614,
-0.10776521265506744,
-0.01759631186723709,
-0.08631236106157303,
0.4799688458442688,
-0.8814627528190613,
-0.3870285451412201,
0.6332914233207703,
-0.44500231742858887,
0.3440702557563782,
-0.12508127093315125,
-0.5179142355918884,
-0.5964391231536865,
-0.1352224498987198,
0.32488590478897095,
-0.6583952903747559,
-0.2124582827091217,
0.06761916726827621,
0.02086375094950199,
0.022931551560759544,
0.3544461131095886,
-0.7798529267311096,
0.40932631492614746,
0.411626398563385,
0.7208571434020996,
0.3036835193634033,
0.3489128649234772,
-0.21992509067058563,
-0.033369433134794235,
-0.35598811507225037,
0.6376675963401794,
-0.4754501283168793,
-0.33582058548927307,
0.3487618863582611,
-0.15637074410915375,
0.16748890280723572,
-0.6273642778396606,
0.7748571634292603,
-0.4920876920223236,
0.20429342985153198,
-0.6623032689094543,
-0.2908649146556854,
-0.40614020824432373,
0.1269647628068924,
-0.6952637434005737,
1.021672248840332,
0.5220562815666199,
-1.2089626789093018,
0.15196342766284943,
-0.708732008934021,
-0.2649874985218048,
0.4383585453033447,
-0.448433518409729,
-0.14979104697704315,
-0.06176353245973587,
0.6705344915390015,
0.31604892015457153,
-0.31769251823425293,
0.09041093289852142,
-0.10934771597385406,
-0.5193594098091125,
0.7039709091186523,
-0.17685449123382568,
0.7900972366333008,
0.248976930975914,
-0.27539193630218506,
0.0783287063241005,
-0.6680749654769897,
0.271150141954422,
0.033236224204301834,
-0.0856751799583435,
-0.3924662172794342,
0.033537738025188446,
0.34022215008735657,
0.5375886559486389,
0.22835657000541687,
-0.5571275353431702,
0.0012955573620274663,
-0.330780565738678,
0.21255849301815033,
0.21959899365901947,
0.5464173555374146,
-0.2553192675113678,
-0.8498867750167847,
0.7477313876152039,
0.022596847265958786,
0.11863871663808823,
0.2366112619638443,
-0.6421158313751221,
-0.5358790755271912,
-0.6801427602767944,
-0.02576739713549614,
0.7190753221511841,
-0.8921442627906799,
0.28708595037460327,
0.07893508672714233,
-0.6773772239685059,
-1.1229784488677979,
-0.02530481293797493,
0.11997124552726746,
0.2825520634651184,
0.6990556716918945,
-0.10696408897638321,
-0.5389858484268188,
-0.9504255652427673,
-0.06575284153223038,
-0.23207290470600128,
-0.05881546810269356,
0.35896891355514526,
0.43789544701576233,
-0.5446744561195374,
0.9074206352233887,
-0.5050140023231506,
-0.3156976103782654,
0.024287588894367218,
0.22553586959838867,
0.05357116460800171,
0.08473247289657593,
0.3502523601055145,
-0.6852622032165527,
-0.3921828269958496,
-0.0644121766090393,
-0.5861063003540039,
-0.24433067440986633,
0.060956522822380066,
-0.44666287302970886,
0.025062933564186096,
-0.06527536362409592,
-0.6976264715194702,
0.5054367780685425,
0.1571301966905594,
-0.37093672156333923,
0.5022754073143005,
0.16590352356433868,
0.26099780201911926,
-1.0321637392044067,
0.1782025545835495,
-0.06314452737569809,
-0.0628075823187828,
-0.46546751260757446,
-0.09995998442173004,
-0.12914694845676422,
-0.08431548625230789,
-0.18901918828487396,
0.4135512113571167,
0.2008441835641861,
0.5132850408554077,
-0.22542446851730347,
-0.2101668417453766,
-0.2655377686023712,
0.2531055212020874,
-0.2466256320476532,
1.0640876293182373,
0.17447039484977722,
-0.1794888824224472,
0.23043395578861237,
0.6137259602546692,
-0.2953316271305084,
0.7844613790512085,
-0.429969847202301,
0.1967548280954361,
-0.2705840468406677,
0.06294246762990952,
-0.7938417792320251,
-0.289313405752182,
0.6438682079315186,
-0.4572978913784027,
-0.2146756500005722,
0.20626430213451385,
-0.509834885597229,
-0.12522776424884796,
-0.13067921996116638,
0.42323970794677734,
0.11412104964256287,
-0.02049797587096691,
0.21473774313926697,
0.673163652420044,
-0.7059469819068909,
-0.6936073303222656,
-0.2779691815376282,
0.041768550872802734,
-0.3857201933860779,
-0.2266240119934082,
0.33026066422462463,
-0.07452152669429779,
-0.4603062570095062,
0.16313517093658447,
-0.23864617943763733,
-0.37844792008399963,
0.21468225121498108,
0.6905676126480103,
0.13138070702552795,
-0.08594724535942078,
0.5803823471069336,
0.3780403733253479,
0.08701763302087784,
0.49575871229171753,
-0.055389244109392166,
0.5563477873802185,
-0.18354301154613495,
-0.2977699339389801,
-0.4147831201553345,
1.0387498140335083,
0.4792569875717163,
-0.41348910331726074,
0.8635047078132629,
0.7691193222999573,
-0.9747417569160461,
0.18216268718242645,
-0.49181175231933594,
0.03819884732365608,
-0.3935478925704956,
0.283328652381897,
-0.4012705385684967,
-0.8871560096740723,
0.4818871021270752,
0.2127842903137207,
0.03427457809448242,
0.5080943703651428,
0.717158854007721,
-0.36877959966659546,
1.1793991327285767,
0.38247135281562805,
-0.1483796089887619,
-0.18397264182567596,
0.1871083378791809,
0.3377322852611542,
-0.3890118896961212,
-0.2581321895122528,
-0.406156986951828,
-0.2589035630226135,
-0.6791877150535583,
-0.2649546265602112,
0.4372413158416748,
0.08339419215917587,
-0.5643815994262695,
-0.20173120498657227,
-0.5154191255569458,
-0.20292195677757263,
0.514013409614563,
0.383429616689682,
0.20520085096359253,
-0.06580285727977753,
-0.27360859513282776,
-0.4368700087070465,
-0.4370020925998688,
-0.9632136821746826,
0.8666058778762817,
0.31991803646087646,
0.36241236329078674,
0.425424724817276,
0.7164818048477173,
0.6330329775810242,
0.6375746726989746,
-0.6574210524559021,
0.3450928330421448,
0.3951036334037781,
-0.874051034450531,
-0.3887999355792999,
-0.15918050706386566,
-0.8087526559829712,
-0.07793686538934708,
-0.47438961267471313,
-0.7475060820579529,
-0.07151400297880173,
-0.30262693762779236,
-0.6809923052787781,
0.18456169962882996,
-0.054115839302539825,
0.551098644733429,
-0.22716012597084045,
0.17880581319332123,
-0.1156344935297966,
-0.6105569005012512,
0.25033438205718994,
-0.37533676624298096,
0.2617095112800598,
-0.49901220202445984,
0.009034496732056141,
0.9269415140151978,
-0.5876579880714417,
0.3644973039627075,
-0.07381453365087509,
-0.08506446331739426,
0.4017295241355896,
-0.034409403800964355,
-0.35226765275001526,
0.5614126324653625,
0.09717783331871033,
-0.02614833228290081,
0.8799785375595093,
-0.5700512528419495,
-0.7058315873146057,
0.2531771659851074,
-1.098433494567871,
-0.6979376077651978,
-0.7090350985527039,
-0.6382702589035034,
-0.6148881316184998,
0.12659992277622223,
0.03057662397623062,
0.22414357960224152,
0.05429661646485329,
-0.2991577386856079,
0.38303038477897644,
-0.34740719199180603,
-0.10162904113531113,
0.3746357262134552,
-0.3326675295829773,
-0.4505566656589508,
0.6280776858329773,
0.2597280740737915,
-0.4544145464897156,
0.20148436725139618,
-0.16873596608638763,
-0.3493163287639618,
-0.3604593276977539,
-0.49019497632980347,
0.44842132925987244,
-0.6519798040390015,
-0.22544905543327332,
-0.6347287893295288,
-0.752355694770813,
-0.22157856822013855,
0.13188327848911285,
0.20070676505565643,
-0.3763998746871948,
-0.1687643975019455,
-0.2825758755207062,
0.7529717087745667,
0.5074077844619751,
0.15255343914031982,
0.2225293070077896,
-0.8579043745994568,
0.27590519189834595,
0.37026822566986084,
0.19012145698070526,
0.0368986539542675,
-0.0864773616194725,
-0.365183562040329,
0.11572933197021484,
-0.2988876402378082,
-1.4286104440689087,
0.3314329981803894,
0.17257682979106903,
0.22650006413459778,
0.5256100296974182,
0.6461795568466187,
0.7703638672828674,
-0.3031599819660187,
0.5602562427520752,
-0.06608450412750244,
-0.7389142513275146,
0.5775466561317444,
-0.1543715000152588,
0.27957847714424133,
0.7755594849586487,
1.1260160207748413,
-1.0966309309005737,
-0.26468563079833984,
-0.5018265843391418,
-0.8107534050941467,
0.5041407346725464,
0.2739253044128418,
0.05414104834198952,
-0.3571253716945648,
0.676461935043335,
0.16801226139068604,
0.2917971909046173,
-0.17988836765289307,
-0.5128290057182312,
-0.31225335597991943,
-0.6667685508728027,
0.18380357325077057,
-0.36901992559432983,
-0.5460436940193176,
-0.23490352928638458,
0.6544515490531921,
-0.06204984709620476,
0.4456997811794281,
0.5782883763313293,
-0.04542692005634308,
-0.08343727886676788,
0.48220834136009216,
0.07786323875188828,
0.631942629814148,
-0.4168647229671478,
0.1388280987739563,
0.22505703568458557,
-0.6495787501335144,
0.30806899070739746,
0.4397943317890167,
-0.1510586142539978,
0.06480918079614639,
0.051248662173748016,
0.38296663761138916,
-0.30563274025917053,
-1.1311265230178833,
0.16695034503936768,
-0.23352228105068207,
-0.12504084408283234,
-0.5528649687767029,
0.10455619543790817,
0.09737879782915115,
0.3482978343963623,
0.5530413389205933,
-0.42328089475631714,
0.43917104601860046,
-0.41277825832366943,
0.39794373512268066,
0.41595587134361267,
-0.7756282687187195,
-0.0791483074426651,
0.3438552916049957,
-0.1321459263563156,
-0.4402067959308624,
0.7505958080291748,
-0.06302817165851593,
-0.3635881841182709,
0.2472989559173584,
0.3011931777000427,
0.39380943775177,
0.08495134860277176,
0.6140209436416626,
0.14827026426792145,
0.21724174916744232,
0.5251070857048035,
0.9595794081687927,
-0.1941329389810562,
-0.5170642137527466,
-0.03390852361917496,
-0.5202913284301758,
-0.7346018552780151,
0.24871571362018585,
-0.8255454897880554,
-0.11657878756523132,
-0.5789842009544373,
-0.6818764805793762,
-0.11349109560251236,
0.5367255806922913,
-0.6769081950187683,
0.6855099201202393,
0.4198951721191406,
0.8050364255905151,
-0.49613022804260254,
0.6333236694335938,
1.1479904651641846,
-0.6209763288497925,
-0.6314946413040161,
0.16612398624420166,
0.06963107734918594,
-0.6434479355812073,
-0.06647584587335587,
0.2802840769290924,
-0.009324162267148495,
-0.13887257874011993,
-0.26521584391593933,
-0.8380830883979797,
0.9135487079620361,
0.027522683143615723,
-0.0075893644243478775,
-0.022817447781562805,
0.396142840385437,
0.49860337376594543,
-0.15902212262153625,
0.5667847394943237,
0.6372339129447937,
0.40343189239501953,
-0.22909723222255707,
-0.5308302640914917,
0.30557483434677124,
-0.6980931162834167,
-0.21231816709041595,
0.12048058956861496,
-0.3386856019496918,
0.5360603332519531,
-0.19870802760124207,
-0.5522172451019287,
0.3054271936416626,
0.6584998965263367,
0.35310009121894836,
0.37042027711868286,
0.2615576386451721,
0.6097806096076965,
1.1730642318725586,
-0.04946981742978096,
0.6691654324531555,
-0.5615320205688477,
-0.04451500251889229,
0.8055547475814819,
-0.1702638417482376,
0.8005905151367188,
0.1952250748872757,
-0.4006766676902771,
0.6722016930580139,
0.948752760887146,
0.40931063890457153,
0.32478001713752747,
0.40473172068595886,
-0.6503980159759521,
-0.2390632927417755,
-0.625881016254425,
-0.47453227639198303,
0.218805193901062,
0.6398887038230896,
0.03410087898373604,
-0.013196890242397785,
-0.08514849841594696,
0.3715466558933258,
0.13778698444366455,
-0.11515446752309799,
0.5210152268409729,
0.13077892363071442,
-0.411266028881073,
0.3312576711177826,
0.37940898537635803,
0.2063465416431427,
-0.5468266606330872,
-0.015777744352817535,
-0.21157623827457428,
-0.23056332767009735,
-0.3075898289680481,
-0.8231635093688965,
0.4844851791858673,
0.06891795247793198,
-0.24026550352573395,
0.3157830536365509,
0.6685275435447693,
-0.3329960107803345,
-0.7121037840843201,
-0.1511410027742386,
0.869929850101471,
0.21366769075393677,
-0.3695492148399353,
-0.6320706605911255,
-0.3999803960323334,
-0.2922315001487732,
0.3163495361804962,
0.3440462052822113,
0.6392740607261658,
-0.5023044347763062,
0.6045350432395935,
0.5375016331672668,
0.2156035453081131,
-0.20686352252960205,
-0.20169903337955475,
0.6599830389022827,
-0.7642772793769836,
-0.15745890140533447,
-0.5834861397743225,
0.28907454013824463,
-0.08940213173627853,
-0.5688194632530212,
0.6039463877677917,
0.19221997261047363,
0.43504130840301514,
0.19990693032741547,
0.8242884874343872,
0.1311451643705368,
0.7039600014686584,
-0.17401672899723053,
1.0793339014053345,
-0.585268497467041,
-0.2867931127548218,
-0.04507334530353546,
-0.5087010264396667,
-0.24669760465621948,
0.6843416690826416,
-0.2354407012462616,
-0.13857385516166687,
0.5108235478401184,
0.5701452493667603,
0.5261389017105103,
0.29771316051483154,
-0.09498335421085358,
0.0004920369246974587,
0.28620466589927673,
0.6426918506622314,
1.0071864128112793,
-0.29877904057502747,
0.1376904398202896,
-0.32839566469192505,
-0.10973111540079117,
0.04172523319721222,
-0.20924857258796692,
-0.83352130651474,
-0.6149635314941406,
-0.33582741022109985,
-0.19668914377689362,
0.3563271760940552,
1.4367643594741821,
0.5686613917350769,
-0.9746587872505188,
-0.002492709783837199,
0.5527061223983765,
0.07625994086265564,
-0.38568487763404846,
-0.15111003816127777,
0.5148740410804749,
-0.0012801431585103273,
-0.3075069785118103,
-0.28166115283966064,
0.21403224766254425,
0.022827882319688797,
-0.1742011457681656,
0.23342305421829224,
-0.32372984290122986,
0.42102259397506714,
0.3581761121749878,
0.26138994097709656,
-0.7582104802131653,
-0.009738544002175331,
-0.020585594698786736,
-0.3589109778404236,
0.09990283846855164,
0.38245049118995667,
-0.7261092066764832,
0.21223163604736328,
-0.22826933860778809,
1.0274293422698975,
0.09188671410083771,
0.11768272519111633,
0.16330590844154358,
-0.38978463411331177,
-0.16542132198810577,
0.5139232873916626,
0.288043737411499,
0.22797521948814392,
-0.48660722374916077,
0.162923201918602,
-0.1097874715924263,
-0.37769386172294617,
-0.30563145875930786,
0.043895430862903595,
-0.7160536050796509,
-0.13901810348033905,
0.7535231113433838,
-0.18679127097129822,
0.058845724910497665,
-0.6565228700637817,
-0.9337905645370483,
0.38961687684059143,
-0.4304850101470947,
1.2352269887924194,
1.0211818218231201,
-0.24649548530578613,
-0.35953935980796814,
-0.5972384810447693,
0.7437394261360168,
0.6052071452140808,
-0.9013802409172058,
-0.47206470370292664,
0.27911970019340515,
0.0021948718931525946,
-0.23822635412216187,
0.8628790378570557,
-0.06748189777135849,
0.4546625018119812,
-0.4314518868923187,
0.016457505524158478,
0.18418169021606445,
-0.002678664866834879,
0.0027134499978274107,
0.3317621350288391,
0.25461286306381226,
0.03114362247288227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12617v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12617v1
|
Quantifying Emergence in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-21T09:12:20 | 2024-05-21T09:12:20 |
Hang Chen, Xinyu Yang, Jiaying Zhu, Wenya Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Emergence, broadly conceptualized as the ``intelligent'' behaviors of LLMs,
has recently been studied and proved challenging to quantify due to the lack of
a measurable definition. Most commonly, it has been estimated statistically
through model performances across extensive datasets and tasks, which consumes
significant resources. In addition, such estimation is difficult to interpret
and may not accurately reflect the models' intrinsic emergence. In this work,
we propose a quantifiable solution for estimating emergence. Inspired by
emergentism in dynamics, we quantify the strength of emergence by comparing the
entropy reduction of the macroscopic (semantic) level with that of the
microscopic (token) level, both of which are derived from the representations
within the transformer block. Using a low-cost estimator, our quantification
method demonstrates consistent behaviors across a suite of LMs (GPT-2, GEMMA,
etc.) under both in-context learning (ICL) and natural sentences. Empirical
results show that (1) our method gives consistent measurements which align with
existing observations based on performance metrics, validating the
effectiveness of our emergence quantification; (2) our proposed metric uncovers
novel emergence patterns such as the correlations between the variance of our
metric and the number of ``shots'' in ICL, which further suggests a new way of
interpreting hallucinations in LLMs; (3) we offer a potential solution towards
estimating the emergence of larger and closed-resource LMs via smaller LMs like
GPT-2. Our codes are available at:
https://github.com/Zodiark-ch/Emergence-of-LLMs/.
|
[
-0.23601679503917694,
-1.0319210290908813,
0.6790390014648438,
0.26244306564331055,
-0.22425466775894165,
0.23463863134384155,
-0.4701695442199707,
-0.5212754607200623,
0.14182282984256744,
-0.0007541186059825122,
-0.46067506074905396,
-0.22180698812007904,
-0.5938425660133362,
0.17903244495391846,
-0.44877296686172485,
0.7852650880813599,
0.3920081555843353,
-0.2123766541481018,
-0.41048669815063477,
0.23371754586696625,
-0.2511788308620453,
-0.0778813585639,
-0.7256354093551636,
-0.3008021414279938,
0.5086863040924072,
0.07765257358551025,
0.5100067257881165,
0.534784197807312,
0.4062589704990387,
0.33897486329078674,
-0.41523346304893494,
0.40444955229759216,
-0.3279109597206116,
0.1774837225675583,
-0.07691771537065506,
-0.4523226022720337,
-0.17774619162082672,
-0.1995866447687149,
0.9126603007316589,
0.5896154642105103,
-0.22843796014785767,
0.2649655342102051,
0.37634968757629395,
0.2950241267681122,
-0.42463141679763794,
0.17518968880176544,
-0.8505111336708069,
0.21187572181224823,
-0.14214977622032166,
-0.28259924054145813,
-0.496759831905365,
-0.1969897747039795,
0.1262155920267105,
-0.2716526389122009,
-0.12689349055290222,
-0.008641451597213745,
0.5576279759407043,
0.2186596840620041,
-0.24128448963165283,
-0.3274470269680023,
-1.0911084413528442,
0.7445576786994934,
-0.628883957862854,
0.360836923122406,
-0.03884655237197876,
0.05571116507053375,
-0.39435333013534546,
-0.8797171711921692,
-0.6132915616035461,
-0.3828313946723938,
-0.031672153621912,
-0.08525726944208145,
-0.3806546926498413,
-0.20409704744815826,
0.14503276348114014,
0.2508541941642761,
-0.5186935067176819,
0.40773069858551025,
-0.18999210000038147,
-0.07807368785142899,
0.3266201913356781,
0.36389970779418945,
0.5656086802482605,
-0.0799606516957283,
-0.40658894181251526,
0.1080036535859108,
-0.542935311794281,
0.16007442772388458,
0.1419314444065094,
0.2431948333978653,
-0.19985385239124298,
0.3818458616733551,
0.23774172365665436,
0.4130038619041443,
0.030413394793868065,
-0.3768308758735657,
0.06374721974134445,
-0.2554672062397003,
-0.11040171980857849,
0.10644069314002991,
0.8693174123764038,
-0.12499025464057922,
0.22586418688297272,
-0.23426739871501923,
-0.33301207423210144,
-0.20472964644432068,
0.21535249054431915,
-0.8539367318153381,
-0.24107185006141663,
0.14044125378131866,
-0.26554811000823975,
-0.3110719919204712,
0.18176598846912384,
-0.7273896336555481,
-0.6634719967842102,
-0.2009153813123703,
0.5641931891441345,
-0.5925487279891968,
-0.5406247973442078,
-0.19853299856185913,
0.07310669124126434,
0.5679309964179993,
0.06226405128836632,
-0.8063477873802185,
0.27955979108810425,
0.788021981716156,
1.144624948501587,
-0.27795466780662537,
-0.2074286788702011,
-0.20203794538974762,
-0.05417861044406891,
-0.5012130737304688,
0.7442542910575867,
-0.24906089901924133,
-0.23402370512485504,
-0.17204952239990234,
-0.08926137536764145,
-0.0016409342642873526,
-0.7404342293739319,
0.14406311511993408,
-0.5318254828453064,
-0.06981808692216873,
0.1028592512011528,
-0.7764142155647278,
-0.001126716728322208,
0.14978161454200745,
-0.5027824640274048,
1.0052080154418945,
0.030038747936487198,
-0.5723786354064941,
0.4093785285949707,
-0.7540607452392578,
-0.32065412402153015,
0.44518718123435974,
-0.3336520195007324,
-0.33453336358070374,
0.448702335357666,
-0.07176554203033447,
0.44250813126564026,
-0.31335926055908203,
0.2768363058567047,
-0.14835073053836823,
-0.03972036764025688,
0.661624550819397,
-0.5934886932373047,
0.9022908210754395,
0.12739475071430206,
-0.38869720697402954,
0.04701829329133034,
-0.9814075231552124,
0.3135235011577606,
0.2444569319486618,
-0.331488698720932,
-0.294668972492218,
0.31627464294433594,
-0.38728010654449463,
-0.002504287287592888,
0.3197503089904785,
-0.3175559937953949,
0.17013493180274963,
-0.5316210985183716,
0.5127453207969666,
0.7472689747810364,
0.290210485458374,
0.31772080063819885,
-0.005467727314680815,
0.3754613399505615,
0.21847324073314667,
0.06552799791097641,
-0.13762551546096802,
-0.40639975666999817,
-0.599819004535675,
-0.6504418253898621,
0.054506950080394745,
0.38900551199913025,
-0.5608509182929993,
0.7013770937919617,
-0.5679371953010559,
-0.5429781675338745,
-0.14335884153842926,
0.10232985019683838,
0.24338704347610474,
0.21578030288219452,
0.2891985774040222,
0.025188103318214417,
-0.42042145133018494,
-0.7213853597640991,
-0.10793555527925491,
-0.16098137199878693,
-0.306522935628891,
0.15481308102607727,
0.5926551818847656,
-0.27210763096809387,
1.2123632431030273,
-0.3435102105140686,
0.16981588304042816,
-0.12729710340499878,
0.29527565836906433,
0.33227798342704773,
0.4811097979545593,
0.3074868619441986,
-0.4551430940628052,
-0.32467225193977356,
0.030887888744473457,
-0.9095858931541443,
-0.05585840344429016,
-0.015366781502962112,
0.20335842669010162,
0.0985390916466713,
0.6236239075660706,
-0.533534049987793,
0.055281415581703186,
0.5143492817878723,
-0.2899917960166931,
0.6130273938179016,
-0.2386476993560791,
-0.28171566128730774,
-1.1573200225830078,
-0.15603971481323242,
-0.023759331554174423,
-0.006396702490746975,
-0.8155826926231384,
0.2049376368522644,
0.017827941104769707,
0.25271841883659363,
-0.5094878673553467,
0.35454261302948,
-0.46753501892089844,
-0.2480299472808838,
-0.06308872252702713,
0.22184860706329346,
-0.26306647062301636,
0.39491182565689087,
-0.11444642394781113,
0.7998582124710083,
0.5787146091461182,
-0.7307473421096802,
0.16317075490951538,
-0.20734450221061707,
-0.8237584233283997,
0.24746400117874146,
-0.6976444721221924,
0.0983474925160408,
-0.15136754512786865,
0.0956600233912468,
-0.8695802092552185,
-0.22396965324878693,
0.20180629193782806,
-0.38825592398643494,
0.2886485755443573,
-0.1590137630701065,
-0.7394662499427795,
-0.1978524625301361,
-0.007869333028793335,
0.4986412823200226,
0.6034819483757019,
-0.5368805527687073,
0.7316902875900269,
0.13000021874904633,
-0.08247358351945877,
-0.20948219299316406,
-0.41002845764160156,
0.2203376442193985,
-0.5170368552207947,
-0.5239696502685547,
0.1301897019147873,
-0.04397101327776909,
-0.5537554025650024,
-0.18605907261371613,
0.10209234058856964,
0.0070133088156580925,
0.32514405250549316,
0.10972309112548828,
0.09500602632761002,
-0.38299354910850525,
0.29893985390663147,
0.003175310790538788,
0.044550132006406784,
0.40363749861717224,
-0.6899040341377258,
0.74542236328125,
-0.33368980884552,
-0.23546525835990906,
-0.23985907435417175,
-0.23748691380023956,
0.8559932708740234,
-0.21644140779972076,
0.9922555685043335,
0.7019235491752625,
-0.4810188412666321,
-0.5703141093254089,
-0.14905020594596863,
-0.11413104087114334,
-0.5021705031394958,
0.5245183706283569,
-0.23175938427448273,
-0.585838794708252,
0.7913286685943604,
-0.10642038285732269,
-0.20135468244552612,
0.4095044434070587,
0.6521826386451721,
-0.005217467434704304,
0.8187320828437805,
0.43666738271713257,
0.32808029651641846,
0.5098865628242493,
-0.39159300923347473,
0.31889599561691284,
-0.8909783959388733,
-0.5327314734458923,
-0.11731724441051483,
-0.2524838149547577,
-0.609863817691803,
-0.4411970376968384,
0.7958381772041321,
0.2980128824710846,
-0.17092429101467133,
0.060276586562395096,
-0.20157185196876526,
0.4456433951854706,
0.29684528708457947,
0.20379863679409027,
0.24415470659732819,
-0.015470359474420547,
-0.13686351478099823,
0.03600412607192993,
-0.5758944153785706,
-0.4768545627593994,
0.885201096534729,
0.3353174328804016,
0.62300705909729,
0.6021696329116821,
0.5429511666297913,
0.24969294667243958,
0.20704211294651031,
-0.9279783368110657,
0.6157310605049133,
0.08509670943021774,
-0.20111624896526337,
-0.6491520404815674,
-0.6263868808746338,
-1.1190048456192017,
0.189286008477211,
-0.30043649673461914,
-1.2089389562606812,
0.04101233929395676,
-0.057776227593421936,
-0.6079999804496765,
0.3829529583454132,
-0.4282885193824768,
0.5786515474319458,
-0.33892205357551575,
-0.34874629974365234,
-0.19365093111991882,
-0.44578585028648376,
0.5087109804153442,
-0.3572864830493927,
0.24600949883460999,
-0.18318913877010345,
-0.22719262540340424,
0.7740379571914673,
-0.4208509922027588,
0.9438638091087341,
-0.027317017316818237,
-0.61576908826828,
0.5656309127807617,
0.24271191656589508,
0.5896798968315125,
0.10207464545965195,
0.3098395764827728,
0.1318027228116989,
-0.0013756458647549152,
-0.11264070123434067,
-0.8776954412460327,
0.4979029595851898,
-0.6711038947105408,
-0.3235207498073578,
-0.040604349225759506,
-0.4662529528141022,
-0.19025658071041107,
0.07435724139213562,
0.2502889335155487,
0.6202980875968933,
-0.21200168132781982,
0.31163108348846436,
0.8434668779373169,
-0.3889787495136261,
0.7340318560600281,
0.6082693338394165,
-0.28289636969566345,
-0.2911304235458374,
1.1340036392211914,
0.33136701583862305,
0.39440998435020447,
0.4543677270412445,
0.5232058167457581,
-0.18801450729370117,
-0.5860947966575623,
-0.13891467452049255,
-0.022687148302793503,
-0.4552992582321167,
-0.06538890302181244,
-0.6126407980918884,
-0.4815627336502075,
-0.049109019339084625,
0.16913670301437378,
-0.3164360523223877,
-0.08482218533754349,
-0.3402813971042633,
-0.03221381828188896,
0.317787766456604,
0.726000964641571,
-0.12495222687721252,
0.36319413781166077,
-0.7940280437469482,
-0.16931214928627014,
0.42860332131385803,
0.243925079703331,
0.4388718008995056,
-0.829204797744751,
-0.5773733258247375,
0.06324884295463562,
-0.1810411959886551,
-0.6101564168930054,
0.426593542098999,
0.43370792269706726,
0.4554930627346039,
0.9553846716880798,
-0.06377523392438889,
0.5460415482521057,
-0.6037964224815369,
0.9467606544494629,
0.1849985420703888,
-0.8736988306045532,
0.5600882172584534,
-0.3514203429222107,
0.18667098879814148,
0.044697925448417664,
0.3387496769428253,
-0.16826698184013367,
-0.5434316396713257,
-0.7353513836860657,
-0.8888035416603088,
0.24483387172222137,
0.1704424023628235,
0.2261490523815155,
-0.26743894815444946,
0.26606321334838867,
-0.047822948545217514,
0.04904557764530182,
-0.8102423548698425,
-0.0614408515393734,
0.33705928921699524,
-0.12933754920959473,
-0.121456079185009,
-0.35486555099487305,
0.03629060834646225,
-0.37075915932655334,
0.29361817240715027,
-0.04171965643763542,
0.280477911233902,
-0.1015615463256836,
-0.3263852298259735,
-0.024289852008223534,
0.16489218175411224,
0.7482786774635315,
0.6954215168952942,
-0.12753990292549133,
0.4423474371433258,
0.0945715680718422,
-0.4867461323738098,
0.2366861253976822,
-0.39108002185821533,
-0.1809864640235901,
-0.10475985705852509,
0.7793185114860535,
0.6259331107139587,
0.4221799969673157,
-0.8606406450271606,
0.4498620629310608,
0.22612856328487396,
-0.015549710020422935,
-0.6131998896598816,
0.15638437867164612,
-0.0966433435678482,
0.6597625017166138,
0.5180873870849609,
-0.1389688402414322,
-0.07462634891271591,
-0.5886799097061157,
0.22981581091880798,
0.5777620077133179,
-0.3606967329978943,
-0.547727644443512,
0.3687324523925781,
-0.013467960059642792,
-0.5027892589569092,
0.5968717932701111,
-0.5197237133979797,
-0.3723624646663666,
0.7342859506607056,
0.805647075176239,
1.1645148992538452,
0.028892965987324715,
0.09472442418336868,
0.35575413703918457,
0.47261616587638855,
-0.13121594488620758,
-0.19876866042613983,
0.06746220588684082,
-1.0941879749298096,
-0.40719398856163025,
-0.7928712368011475,
0.07057120651006699,
0.236952543258667,
-0.5563986897468567,
-0.01072431355714798,
-0.38781824707984924,
-0.15048204362392426,
0.01111780945211649,
-0.06460047513246536,
-0.4000368118286133,
-0.1673114001750946,
0.30429044365882874,
0.7353729605674744,
-0.8268945813179016,
0.630023717880249,
0.3889174163341522,
-0.333239883184433,
-0.6408084034919739,
0.18853233754634857,
-0.025721723213791847,
-0.8732016682624817,
0.6081117391586304,
0.02212047390639782,
-0.26615259051322937,
0.38966184854507446,
-0.688987672328949,
-1.0370911359786987,
1.3134536743164062,
0.2020491063594818,
-0.3755917251110077,
0.21500732004642487,
-0.12563814222812653,
0.6857628226280212,
-0.4048684239387512,
0.12012194097042084,
0.5962337851524353,
0.33300891518592834,
-0.12611962854862213,
-0.4858090281486511,
-0.027103392407298088,
0.045931264758110046,
0.03783322125673294,
0.34027230739593506,
-0.3654745817184448,
0.6835678219795227,
-0.43642231822013855,
-0.59288090467453,
0.18461383879184723,
0.7913200259208679,
-0.033804234117269516,
0.11464257538318634,
0.5223966836929321,
0.4689922630786896,
0.9875158071517944,
0.02807530388236046,
0.8241214752197266,
-0.6069504618644714,
0.4332968592643738,
1.1075516939163208,
0.03223549202084541,
0.8640225529670715,
0.4715811610221863,
-0.48579591512680054,
0.6113541722297668,
0.558185338973999,
-0.0938938781619072,
0.36691245436668396,
0.4744528830051422,
-0.4765251576900482,
-0.11680054664611816,
-0.09099145233631134,
0.09033326804637909,
0.46410268545150757,
0.5882228016853333,
-0.3736598789691925,
0.03365424647927284,
0.030607324093580246,
0.010908911935985088,
-0.19354376196861267,
-0.36121809482574463,
1.085522174835205,
0.112608902156353,
-0.31890445947647095,
0.5042777061462402,
-0.11579877883195877,
0.4301215410232544,
-0.5304960012435913,
0.19203634560108185,
-0.25779449939727783,
-0.017988981679081917,
-0.11699287593364716,
-0.7472062110900879,
0.09522227942943573,
-0.01079073641449213,
-0.16201795637607574,
0.08369769901037216,
0.2853943407535553,
-0.46301645040512085,
-0.6507863998413086,
0.18511904776096344,
0.8223918080329895,
0.28647246956825256,
0.2574116885662079,
-0.14434628188610077,
-0.11553246527910233,
-0.33724603056907654,
-0.21788743138313293,
0.4339737296104431,
0.7386199235916138,
-0.024294760078191757,
0.7372737526893616,
0.43644025921821594,
0.07991348952054977,
0.22642089426517487,
-0.08898700028657913,
0.47411105036735535,
-0.3664480745792389,
-0.23460209369659424,
-1.5029346942901611,
0.43613746762275696,
0.052701517939567566,
-0.38487932085990906,
0.6481552124023438,
0.35478904843330383,
0.4988607168197632,
0.004853673279285431,
0.4989953637123108,
-0.23823726177215576,
0.034553997218608856,
-0.6311324834823608,
0.6084376573562622,
-0.5012037754058838,
0.4306422770023346,
-0.16869443655014038,
-1.0857962369918823,
-0.06201636791229248,
0.357098788022995,
0.02398568019270897,
-0.12353826314210892,
0.7202951908111572,
0.8984631299972534,
0.0674050822854042,
-0.33692148327827454,
0.4084119498729706,
0.6092061996459961,
0.11867356300354004,
0.2703796327114105,
1.0652270317077637,
0.06949759274721146,
0.3619164526462555,
0.05321978032588959,
-0.4163419008255005,
-0.09901414066553116,
-0.9739527702331543,
-0.5170727968215942,
-0.519461989402771,
-0.2631804943084717,
-0.4119068682193756,
-0.2125716507434845,
1.2180594205856323,
0.30181390047073364,
-0.6668733358383179,
-0.2690754234790802,
-0.20918957889080048,
0.21682265400886536,
-0.5255402326583862,
-0.3128816485404968,
0.35932084918022156,
-0.5970024466514587,
-0.49804794788360596,
0.4713396728038788,
0.305768221616745,
0.19493800401687622,
-0.5707328915596008,
-0.10996738821268082,
0.005034351721405983,
0.34987887740135193,
0.8718606233596802,
0.3146028518676758,
-0.7513490915298462,
-0.42883428931236267,
-0.14715689420700073,
-0.03281586617231369,
-0.05798542872071266,
0.7343180775642395,
-0.5646827220916748,
0.2164478302001953,
0.15190550684928894,
0.6266265511512756,
0.10168322175741196,
-0.23243467509746552,
0.4541017711162567,
-0.859571635723114,
-0.05774249508976936,
0.06971590220928192,
0.24846668541431427,
0.004191076848655939,
-0.19582480192184448,
0.4842609763145447,
0.39258843660354614,
-0.3686268627643585,
-1.0211379528045654,
0.359672486782074,
-0.7092040777206421,
-0.23879674077033997,
1.2091141939163208,
-0.10028468072414398,
-0.1179409846663475,
0.19286075234413147,
0.40837404131889343,
0.08823803067207336,
-0.13351981341838837,
0.8671618700027466,
0.504376232624054,
-0.23893053829669952,
-0.19154277443885803,
-0.4387184679508209,
0.5147194862365723,
-0.10696716606616974,
-0.6266761422157288,
-0.01558755338191986,
0.31149452924728394,
0.1693599671125412,
0.35029318928718567,
0.20442302525043488,
0.09781058877706528,
-0.22770994901657104,
0.07496411353349686,
-0.020276468247175217,
0.11528221517801285,
-0.39983493089675903,
-0.3621745705604553,
0.19207213819026947,
0.07336686551570892,
-0.09560494869947433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12612v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12612v1
|
Tagengo: A Multilingual Chat Dataset
| 2024-05-21T09:06:36 | 2024-05-21T09:06:36 |
Peter Devine
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Open source large language models (LLMs) have shown great improvements in
recent times. However, many of these models are focused solely on popular
spoken languages. We present a high quality dataset of more than 70k
prompt-response pairs in 74 languages which consist of human generated prompts
and synthetic responses. We use this dataset to train a state-of-the-art open
source English LLM to chat multilingually. We evaluate our model on MT-Bench
chat benchmarks in 6 languages, finding that our multilingual model outperforms
previous state-of-the-art open source LLMs across each language. We further
find that training on more multilingual data is beneficial to the performance
in a chosen target language (Japanese) compared to simply training on only data
in that language. These results indicate the necessity of training on large
amounts of high quality multilingual data to make a more accessible LLM.
|
[
-0.26143571734428406,
-0.41833001375198364,
0.0447806790471077,
0.4836495518684387,
-0.1731477826833725,
0.19149187207221985,
-0.5973296761512756,
-0.6561914682388306,
0.09966341406106949,
0.4173225462436676,
-0.542622983455658,
-0.5771902799606323,
-0.2993565499782562,
0.1981857270002365,
0.056442741304636,
0.9069814682006836,
0.13157474994659424,
0.5829266309738159,
-0.08248516917228699,
-0.28161266446113586,
-0.8634933829307556,
-0.3898952901363373,
-0.8862686157226562,
-0.4568623900413513,
0.7480353713035583,
0.5569758415222168,
0.2976142168045044,
0.5137319564819336,
0.3815053105354309,
0.2847363352775574,
0.25271308422088623,
0.3535239100456238,
-0.6839308142662048,
0.1540665328502655,
-0.08722354471683502,
-0.7811258435249329,
-0.39032161235809326,
-0.15534143149852753,
0.6006675362586975,
0.5168173909187317,
-0.1775161772966385,
0.026857731863856316,
0.06125088408589363,
0.2941119372844696,
-0.17836318910121918,
0.5012998580932617,
-0.782771110534668,
-0.12438958883285522,
-0.2439572960138321,
0.005749627482146025,
-0.833732008934021,
-0.2364158183336258,
-0.1637289822101593,
-0.8603675961494446,
-0.10213993489742279,
0.20406866073608398,
0.7515142560005188,
0.059301961213350296,
-0.37168994545936584,
-0.42047807574272156,
-0.7277982831001282,
0.8346723914146423,
-0.5441770553588867,
0.7116408348083496,
0.43378281593322754,
0.5366493463516235,
-0.14879362285137177,
-0.14961279928684235,
-0.27460920810699463,
-0.16704799234867096,
-0.06621095538139343,
0.2523503005504608,
0.08228093385696411,
-0.0583486407995224,
0.039593394845724106,
0.10979931801557541,
-0.7898980975151062,
0.5562148690223694,
-0.08431275933980942,
-0.19895634055137634,
0.6712951064109802,
0.13002580404281616,
0.28913038969039917,
-0.12444128096103668,
-0.45114898681640625,
-0.14000345766544342,
-0.7451099157333374,
-0.060412462800741196,
0.5572473406791687,
0.596724808216095,
-0.15029238164424896,
0.404199481010437,
-0.05496060848236084,
0.6158555150032043,
-0.5465294122695923,
-0.6837119460105896,
0.2511530816555023,
-0.28627318143844604,
0.059552982449531555,
-0.02754020504653454,
1.0293490886688232,
0.47574329376220703,
0.4964669942855835,
-0.26564425230026245,
-0.01772296242415905,
-0.03156297653913498,
-0.29497283697128296,
-0.7640010118484497,
-0.021896297112107277,
0.23349213600158691,
-0.139829620718956,
0.192951500415802,
-0.20728172361850739,
-0.8637831211090088,
-0.4098757803440094,
-0.19526910781860352,
-0.04856624826788902,
-0.6055929064750671,
-0.375673770904541,
0.14193838834762573,
0.07681885361671448,
0.1125379204750061,
0.4097537100315094,
-0.6881764531135559,
-0.04174797236919403,
0.5810920000076294,
0.8294126987457275,
-0.05187368392944336,
-0.5729368329048157,
-0.38623368740081787,
0.19713154435157776,
-0.46749088168144226,
0.7578867077827454,
-0.6134932637214661,
-0.5504752993583679,
0.1585526168346405,
0.1411852389574051,
-0.10996459424495697,
-0.5264884829521179,
0.6816979050636292,
-0.37525051832199097,
0.2728967070579529,
-0.0540962889790535,
-0.4851585626602173,
-0.020576519891619682,
0.29070204496383667,
-0.5040817260742188,
1.0439703464508057,
-0.25449466705322266,
-0.5191760063171387,
0.3995705544948578,
-0.6329890489578247,
-0.4336215555667877,
0.3597870171070099,
0.06488689035177231,
0.0050461553037166595,
-0.23112601041793823,
0.30834150314331055,
0.5284780263900757,
-0.3746585547924042,
0.3554001748561859,
-0.3176477551460266,
-0.12454361468553543,
0.41247543692588806,
-0.24566195905208588,
0.44894060492515564,
0.4825630187988281,
0.22920162975788116,
0.037073343992233276,
-0.8311038017272949,
-0.037168558686971664,
0.2726234495639801,
-0.49386945366859436,
-0.5923562049865723,
0.058968231081962585,
-0.07701907306909561,
0.360421359539032,
0.1966620683670044,
-0.8706986904144287,
0.17739354074001312,
-0.6264721155166626,
0.48170191049575806,
0.6446980237960815,
-0.2098899483680725,
0.24951651692390442,
-0.30730435252189636,
0.38990992307662964,
-0.023714665323495865,
-0.03697380796074867,
-0.7133752703666687,
-0.5574389100074768,
-0.695239782333374,
-0.5154072642326355,
0.19689945876598358,
0.7413461804389954,
-1.0049928426742554,
0.2488826960325241,
-0.4308018386363983,
-0.47147321701049805,
-0.8781148791313171,
0.17115600407123566,
0.4633961617946625,
0.43611347675323486,
-0.04460746422410011,
-0.04168333858251572,
-0.5757080316543579,
-0.8217372298240662,
-0.033832743763923645,
-0.26448944211006165,
-0.17810960114002228,
0.47520995140075684,
0.2483723759651184,
-0.03261654078960419,
0.59884113073349,
-0.25584176182746887,
-0.17843201756477356,
-0.36325401067733765,
-0.06466292589902878,
0.41401979327201843,
0.3352757692337036,
0.4889896810054779,
-0.4343133568763733,
-0.6033672094345093,
0.31903982162475586,
-0.7390439510345459,
-0.007808912545442581,
-0.044596318155527115,
-0.3110772669315338,
0.30676013231277466,
0.1278192698955536,
-0.5610001683235168,
-0.2680718004703522,
0.6819294691085815,
0.2135252058506012,
0.07749202102422714,
-0.20894120633602142,
0.3703123927116394,
-1.7333637475967407,
0.11728360503911972,
0.09486889839172363,
-0.1749923676252365,
-0.6123744249343872,
0.05821821466088295,
0.05681744962930679,
-0.3465527594089508,
-0.6200353503227234,
0.8149670362472534,
-0.46471238136291504,
-0.07247386127710342,
-0.19864337146282196,
0.3620987832546234,
-0.2043202519416809,
0.4433450996875763,
0.08014250546693802,
0.8293225169181824,
0.6138200759887695,
-0.40828660130500793,
0.6236555576324463,
0.524432897567749,
-0.39424794912338257,
0.7893283367156982,
-0.6992912888526917,
0.2536624073982239,
-0.22147215902805328,
0.13062097132205963,
-1.3994412422180176,
-0.620272696018219,
0.0878501832485199,
-0.6351046562194824,
0.5203995704650879,
-0.3236062526702881,
-0.6250538229942322,
-0.4879440367221832,
-0.24356035888195038,
-0.09095121175050735,
0.3097551167011261,
-0.7163849472999573,
0.2734310030937195,
0.44140565395355225,
-0.2622062861919403,
-0.7217580676078796,
-0.756409227848053,
0.07650415599346161,
-0.27731120586395264,
-0.7131664752960205,
-0.20655380189418793,
-0.2605494260787964,
0.05868063494563103,
-0.4254382252693176,
0.32575127482414246,
-0.03538351133465767,
0.022925453260540962,
0.31666117906570435,
0.32318824529647827,
-0.02124045416712761,
0.4421217441558838,
-0.3911372125148773,
-0.1663537323474884,
-0.13703766465187073,
-0.1878891885280609,
1.0133907794952393,
0.1589633822441101,
-0.23548872768878937,
-0.35538598895072937,
0.470502108335495,
0.30464982986450195,
-0.40020638704299927,
0.7822513580322266,
0.4680163562297821,
-0.273261159658432,
-0.2887895405292511,
-0.3450358510017395,
0.10292354226112366,
-0.43799489736557007,
0.43756765127182007,
-0.5840839743614197,
-0.9219473600387573,
0.7501901984214783,
-0.03681265190243721,
0.3602279722690582,
0.060574471950531006,
0.6811778545379639,
-0.15647763013839722,
1.090189814567566,
0.4443988502025604,
-0.39064842462539673,
0.4516112506389618,
0.20109716057777405,
0.060025546699762344,
-0.3163263201713562,
-0.4446169137954712,
-0.7527931928634644,
-0.15147599577903748,
-0.6816809773445129,
-0.23838429152965546,
0.23629875481128693,
-0.07103438675403595,
-0.00044012305443175137,
0.36011573672294617,
-0.16786406934261322,
0.627086877822876,
0.4402996599674225,
0.07574352622032166,
0.40413203835487366,
0.016605515033006668,
0.13097932934761047,
-0.18608792126178741,
-0.8306852579116821,
-0.4638412296772003,
1.1357204914093018,
0.4538554549217224,
1.1480658054351807,
0.04346827417612076,
0.44933420419692993,
-0.16059160232543945,
0.3098888695240021,
-0.7935534119606018,
0.44495633244514465,
-0.07362504303455353,
-0.7386384010314941,
-0.13490554690361023,
-0.666134774684906,
-1.168511986732483,
0.14907759428024292,
-0.08813975006341934,
-0.545615553855896,
-0.46008723974227905,
-0.049018483608961105,
0.08376920223236084,
0.1637890636920929,
-0.9053928852081299,
0.6638525724411011,
-0.24431158602237701,
-0.12370089441537857,
-0.020194372162222862,
-0.6628808975219727,
0.5014569163322449,
-0.2327539175748825,
0.42669519782066345,
-0.47363367676734924,
-0.0242755226790905,
0.6926051378250122,
-0.051689378917217255,
0.7956634163856506,
-0.0773819237947464,
-0.279377281665802,
0.05412670597434044,
0.0038404737133532763,
0.4601271152496338,
0.30137622356414795,
0.06017052382230759,
0.27576562762260437,
-0.23632529377937317,
-0.4672355353832245,
-0.2835681140422821,
0.9735168814659119,
-1.0595848560333252,
-0.35207122564315796,
-0.15449684858322144,
-0.8084279894828796,
-0.44555801153182983,
0.1722075194120407,
0.2046346515417099,
0.4384227693080902,
-0.22163286805152893,
0.17000147700309753,
0.4991617202758789,
-0.5053351521492004,
0.5467318892478943,
0.7673646807670593,
-0.4076584577560425,
-0.5801831483840942,
0.8944984674453735,
0.16273744404315948,
0.36820122599601746,
0.44406330585479736,
-0.05712839961051941,
-0.34603074193000793,
-0.25298207998275757,
-0.7575458288192749,
0.5041939616203308,
-0.7140941023826599,
-0.24989931285381317,
-0.6179534196853638,
0.034295324236154556,
-0.453264057636261,
0.1595117747783661,
-0.433856725692749,
-0.029028626158833504,
0.08730834722518921,
0.006185712292790413,
0.42287853360176086,
0.6046766042709351,
0.20996025204658508,
0.4346214830875397,
-0.9897457361221313,
0.017752135172486305,
0.040460385382175446,
0.44331374764442444,
-0.22497761249542236,
-0.3645920753479004,
-0.3345782458782196,
0.22784852981567383,
0.0977267250418663,
-0.7405088543891907,
0.4701352119445801,
0.43523073196411133,
0.8655441403388977,
0.15914028882980347,
-0.16232050955295563,
0.4957793354988098,
-0.666132390499115,
0.7376295924186707,
0.19746950268745422,
-0.5390681624412537,
0.6824669241905212,
-0.6481682658195496,
0.3339712619781494,
0.33030277490615845,
0.9985674619674683,
-0.8828145861625671,
-0.22489532828330994,
-0.22788621485233307,
-0.3282695412635803,
0.8783612251281738,
-0.13584311306476593,
0.2989569306373596,
0.039669282734394073,
0.05587838590145111,
0.3571544587612152,
0.30761805176734924,
-0.5704452395439148,
-0.1589180827140808,
-0.12593227624893188,
-0.2107856422662735,
-0.46379896998405457,
0.08767252415418625,
-0.21207870543003082,
0.04220838472247124,
0.687639594078064,
-0.38672980666160583,
0.3405684530735016,
-0.30392986536026,
0.02652760222554207,
-0.02455907315015793,
0.3760725259780884,
0.4051852226257324,
0.4700392186641693,
-0.08749604970216751,
-0.11973991990089417,
0.23507839441299438,
-0.2548033595085144,
0.24689941108226776,
0.24040170013904572,
0.11540476232767105,
0.13729135692119598,
0.37506234645843506,
1.023303747177124,
0.10187456756830215,
-0.8117983937263489,
0.33169665932655334,
-0.04361848533153534,
0.032000817358493805,
0.0251699797809124,
-0.04653822258114815,
0.3365756571292877,
0.10208060592412949,
0.13314126431941986,
-0.2408992499113083,
-0.22012895345687866,
-0.6737688779830933,
0.10347891598939896,
0.2755312919616699,
-0.0677223652601242,
-0.4007982611656189,
0.6307761669158936,
0.44545602798461914,
-0.19045181572437286,
0.5381774306297302,
0.024514198303222656,
-0.24802085757255554,
0.2843363285064697,
0.6413892507553101,
0.3933972418308258,
-0.5813204050064087,
0.32389408349990845,
0.6589632034301758,
0.31296300888061523,
0.007941721938550472,
0.2920154631137848,
0.21353968977928162,
-0.8467478156089783,
-0.760758101940155,
-0.506565272808075,
-0.6539560556411743,
0.20305085182189941,
-0.38409915566444397,
0.4665599763393402,
-0.1716543734073639,
-0.023934416472911835,
-0.030132604762911797,
0.015498669818043709,
-0.5480696558952332,
0.049010083079338074,
0.17163735628128052,
0.9179022908210754,
-0.8699074983596802,
1.0411591529846191,
0.7527443766593933,
-0.2836732566356659,
-0.7375524044036865,
-0.610919713973999,
-0.12607607245445251,
-1.2071871757507324,
0.4784529209136963,
0.228263720870018,
0.19556979835033417,
0.06533974409103394,
-0.5371088981628418,
-0.7469733357429504,
0.913831889629364,
0.622044026851654,
-0.6742328405380249,
-0.018070382997393608,
0.45001545548439026,
0.6076146960258484,
-0.41385340690612793,
0.4645860493183136,
0.2601543366909027,
0.2028416097164154,
0.24558241665363312,
-1.0582361221313477,
-0.49916571378707886,
-0.2753055691719055,
0.11837846040725708,
0.4790390729904175,
-0.9964995384216309,
0.4801691770553589,
0.18721328675746918,
-0.3136294484138489,
0.10633052885532379,
0.456596702337265,
0.14984044432640076,
0.1568746268749237,
0.2939724028110504,
0.4547921121120453,
0.7346798181533813,
-0.5573633909225464,
1.0091495513916016,
-0.5173695087432861,
0.26858842372894287,
1.1391310691833496,
-0.6091899275779724,
0.8996614217758179,
0.21327058970928192,
-0.1121397316455841,
0.024446766823530197,
0.8318668007850647,
0.13700829446315765,
0.35290542244911194,
0.031457580626010895,
-0.2261684387922287,
-0.25404977798461914,
-0.5834868550300598,
-0.28269410133361816,
0.4153231978416443,
0.3652082681655884,
0.03678520768880844,
-0.33469828963279724,
0.5153676867485046,
0.3039873540401459,
0.06829183548688889,
-0.2141285091638565,
0.8591898679733276,
-0.08038605749607086,
-0.7238752841949463,
0.5720619559288025,
-0.131541445851326,
0.8850694298744202,
-0.9209793210029602,
0.1594984084367752,
-0.540023148059845,
0.10145331919193268,
-0.09094671905040741,
-0.917122483253479,
0.030963411554694176,
0.2182762771844864,
0.07883907854557037,
-0.2179943323135376,
0.7771591544151306,
-0.6913397908210754,
-0.2378348559141159,
0.4191717505455017,
0.6306754946708679,
0.4811617136001587,
0.2049940675497055,
-0.5123192667961121,
0.10558953881263733,
-0.07935177534818649,
-0.11830700188875198,
0.29121771454811096,
0.38207730650901794,
0.05711684748530388,
0.817837655544281,
0.791986882686615,
0.08691363781690598,
0.22119054198265076,
0.29540133476257324,
0.7750930190086365,
-0.32921290397644043,
-0.44026994705200195,
-0.6113936305046082,
0.40623417496681213,
-0.12884043157100677,
-0.5776331424713135,
1.0325493812561035,
0.5521684288978577,
1.2028405666351318,
-0.06507594883441925,
0.7409961223602295,
0.17756997048854828,
0.8922849893569946,
-0.5144423246383667,
0.48459580540657043,
-0.46875450015068054,
-0.013005164451897144,
0.0019262757850810885,
-0.929071307182312,
-0.2031647115945816,
0.28412142395973206,
-0.06315423548221588,
-0.06496532261371613,
0.28004390001296997,
0.8846917748451233,
0.18492266535758972,
0.11044635623693466,
0.5934461951255798,
0.0775386244058609,
0.46189627051353455,
0.935171902179718,
1.1975418329238892,
-0.3799995481967926,
0.6258728504180908,
-0.13090655207633972,
-0.12196847796440125,
-0.036517590284347534,
-0.7060142159461975,
-1.1729357242584229,
-0.5837633013725281,
-0.0768609344959259,
-0.15548115968704224,
-0.09184984862804413,
1.007779836654663,
0.8368502259254456,
-0.7769747972488403,
-0.48264268040657043,
0.3409522473812103,
-0.20087981224060059,
0.2130596935749054,
-0.13685624301433563,
-0.31456097960472107,
-0.5645478963851929,
-1.0989680290222168,
0.7048977613449097,
0.0852302759885788,
0.07178596407175064,
-0.25418543815612793,
-0.2589383125305176,
-0.40063467621803284,
-0.020202480256557465,
0.577685534954071,
0.13817961513996124,
-0.44634759426116943,
-0.2204161286354065,
0.3327198624610901,
-0.3126014173030853,
0.416728675365448,
0.5654033422470093,
-0.3016491234302521,
0.6868724822998047,
0.5666165351867676,
0.7009128332138062,
0.39462870359420776,
-0.2514417767524719,
0.611988365650177,
-1.0952409505844116,
0.49840644001960754,
-0.032132383435964584,
0.486356258392334,
0.5073355436325073,
-0.07563630491495132,
0.657598614692688,
0.22620342671871185,
-0.6597758531570435,
-0.7683423757553101,
0.059448156505823135,
-0.9134219884872437,
-0.14063715934753418,
1.176436185836792,
-0.3492739796638489,
-0.19079923629760742,
0.04013329744338989,
-0.5902498364448547,
0.25274860858917236,
-0.6215749979019165,
0.13025407493114471,
1.0439106225967407,
0.1132979542016983,
-0.3935571312904358,
-0.7912318706512451,
0.1151438057422638,
0.21787220239639282,
-1.0946635007858276,
-0.0012214278103783727,
0.4963412582874298,
0.21990647912025452,
0.14637097716331482,
0.46370628476142883,
0.14997367560863495,
-0.05287926644086838,
-0.04110141843557358,
0.2861096262931824,
-0.1103752925992012,
-0.5125558376312256,
-0.4720087945461273,
0.008750401437282562,
0.15968357026576996,
-0.3592422306537628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12604v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12604v2
|
Tiny Refinements Elicit Resilience: Toward Efficient Prefix-Model Against LLM Red-Teaming
| 2024-05-21T08:57:44 | 2024-06-17T18:52:45 |
Jiaxu Liu, Xiangyu Yin, Sihao Wu, Jianhong Wang, Meng Fang, Xinping Yi, Xiaowei Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the proliferation of red-teaming strategies for Large Language Models
(LLMs), the deficiency in the literature about improving the safety and
robustness of LLM defense strategies is becoming increasingly pronounced. This
paper introduces the LLM-based \textbf{sentinel} model as a plug-and-play
prefix module designed to reconstruct the input prompt with just a few ($<30$)
additional tokens, effectively reducing toxicity in responses from target LLMs.
The sentinel model naturally overcomes the \textit{parameter inefficiency} and
\textit{limited model accessibility} for fine-tuning large target models. We
employ an interleaved training regimen using Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO)
to optimize both red team and sentinel models dynamically, incorporating a
value head-sharing mechanism inspired by the multi-agent centralized critic to
manage the complex interplay between agents. Our extensive experiments across
text-to-text and text-to-image demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in
mitigating toxic outputs, even when dealing with larger models like
\texttt{Llama-2}, \texttt{GPT-3.5} and \texttt{Stable-Diffusion}, highlighting
the potential of our framework in enhancing safety and robustness in various
applications.
|
[
-0.2815935015678406,
-0.7460328936576843,
0.5588982701301575,
-0.029646122828125954,
-0.1507774293422699,
0.1381642073392868,
-0.2682815492153168,
-0.3255741000175476,
0.1292736828327179,
0.3091207444667816,
-0.8493005037307739,
-0.16505232453346252,
-0.3958339989185333,
0.3240845203399658,
-0.03133590146899223,
1.1598044633865356,
0.4267461597919464,
-0.2045358270406723,
-0.012293437495827675,
-0.3244878947734833,
-0.574812650680542,
-0.3637758791446686,
-1.182836651802063,
-0.23616686463356018,
0.7318838834762573,
0.6496256589889526,
0.8575990796089172,
0.3069509267807007,
0.7595506310462952,
0.29963240027427673,
-0.4075896441936493,
0.324547678232193,
-0.6377103924751282,
0.24260573089122772,
-0.49513542652130127,
-0.5047165155410767,
-0.5871357321739197,
-0.19513928890228271,
0.5211977362632751,
0.14153285324573517,
0.06312274932861328,
0.134651780128479,
0.16758988797664642,
0.35527217388153076,
-0.7123669981956482,
-0.010390014387667179,
-1.019560694694519,
-0.3049173653125763,
0.010853649117052555,
0.001619152957573533,
-0.7130988240242004,
-0.032388836145401,
0.0494135320186615,
-0.5528067350387573,
-0.06546419858932495,
0.12968562543392181,
0.9362258911132812,
0.40619519352912903,
-0.18773075938224792,
0.17674756050109863,
-0.5206072926521301,
0.8695263862609863,
-0.5856055021286011,
-0.23967339098453522,
0.20619778335094452,
0.38393232226371765,
-0.23667147755622864,
-1.026214361190796,
-0.29705727100372314,
-0.2756950259208679,
-0.15266740322113037,
0.22532659769058228,
-0.568957507610321,
0.23432843387126923,
0.04161335900425911,
-0.019237538799643517,
-0.33488985896110535,
0.33846011757850647,
-0.13645417988300323,
-0.2381936013698578,
0.5427045226097107,
0.4398484230041504,
0.17701967060565948,
0.150213822722435,
-0.50755375623703,
0.0988456979393959,
-1.0030579566955566,
-0.38484987616539,
-0.007037220057100058,
0.6548641920089722,
-0.08339560031890869,
0.23745743930339813,
-0.06687956303358078,
0.5542427897453308,
0.1274304836988449,
-0.10553627461194992,
-0.13274149596691132,
-0.5665364861488342,
-0.07630659639835358,
-0.40503114461898804,
0.6987969875335693,
0.4116704761981964,
0.07170664519071579,
-0.0877348855137825,
-0.31798189878463745,
0.14235834777355194,
0.6004665493965149,
-0.8883352279663086,
-0.132892444729805,
0.1008913591504097,
-0.3165501356124878,
-0.5831108093261719,
-0.3008594214916229,
-0.5240964293479919,
-0.37751585245132446,
-0.14336858689785004,
0.6408035755157471,
-0.5114892721176147,
-0.10679230839014053,
-0.031265709549188614,
0.09285759925842285,
-0.11192037165164948,
0.2717415392398834,
-0.6727094054222107,
0.15021869540214539,
0.7800800800323486,
1.0529745817184448,
-0.1280372142791748,
-0.26183179020881653,
-0.6737875938415527,
-0.0052042268216609955,
-0.028834719210863113,
0.8937285542488098,
-0.4627682864665985,
-0.45467719435691833,
-0.17010775208473206,
-0.052043620496988297,
-0.006537025328725576,
-0.6680389642715454,
0.4233451783657074,
-0.568080484867096,
-0.05800430104136467,
-0.11053432524204254,
-0.13563016057014465,
0.03521890565752983,
0.4451759457588196,
-0.6010544300079346,
0.6388719081878662,
0.0749787911772728,
-0.787049412727356,
0.05443086102604866,
-0.763596773147583,
-0.128689706325531,
0.027985218912363052,
0.056005917489528656,
-0.6471014618873596,
0.2238750457763672,
-0.011981734074652195,
0.1048874631524086,
-0.4121445417404175,
-0.12700851261615753,
-0.44489625096321106,
-0.42415887117385864,
0.09215506911277771,
-0.22675009071826935,
0.6264702677726746,
0.4009817838668823,
0.008736112155020237,
0.6264423727989197,
-0.44355496764183044,
0.203813374042511,
0.1213097870349884,
-0.20838595926761627,
-0.16721181571483612,
-0.12439773976802826,
-0.2645152509212494,
0.14391520619392395,
-0.019226018339395523,
-0.23939375579357147,
-0.0003634383901953697,
-0.29244548082351685,
0.6544723510742188,
0.7463252544403076,
0.29476210474967957,
0.6254388689994812,
-0.7928367853164673,
0.6350021362304688,
-0.23853951692581177,
0.5748301148414612,
-0.34358611702919006,
-0.40221741795539856,
-0.7592736482620239,
-0.8413820266723633,
0.300262451171875,
0.4071032404899597,
-0.9285809993743896,
0.19002178311347961,
-0.1605272889137268,
-0.5590149760246277,
-0.5194072127342224,
-0.23334495723247528,
0.6030420064926147,
0.5547890663146973,
0.38459768891334534,
-0.16147646307945251,
-0.49089476466178894,
-1.0022755861282349,
-0.14389938116073608,
-0.48729997873306274,
0.029525278136134148,
0.04996141791343689,
0.5781478881835938,
-0.41619873046875,
1.1143546104431152,
-0.4245038330554962,
-0.13508716225624084,
-0.2289329320192337,
0.059340499341487885,
0.013071876019239426,
0.29384055733680725,
0.5568337440490723,
-0.5105355978012085,
-0.4465862810611725,
-0.36938080191612244,
-0.35866159200668335,
-0.4680598974227905,
-0.0907549038529396,
-0.1439407914876938,
0.1658109724521637,
0.6185204386711121,
-0.5413203835487366,
0.30570167303085327,
0.4736050069332123,
-0.3787914216518402,
0.7603778839111328,
-0.05317681282758713,
-0.26314955949783325,
-0.9280563592910767,
0.1711663007736206,
-0.15454739332199097,
-0.36893168091773987,
-0.759860634803772,
0.7675167918205261,
0.0505562350153923,
-0.1173027902841568,
-0.9172446131706238,
0.7279613018035889,
-0.33966517448425293,
0.34749332070350647,
-0.549552857875824,
0.0651540458202362,
0.013969185762107372,
0.15855006873607635,
-0.05049951374530792,
1.0834592580795288,
0.267366886138916,
-0.7208507061004639,
0.06200963258743286,
0.048689838498830795,
0.217503622174263,
0.901948094367981,
-0.8986145257949829,
0.12078862637281418,
-0.03998299688100815,
0.18448495864868164,
-0.846665620803833,
-0.060625024139881134,
0.28388872742652893,
-0.3028031587600708,
0.2982819676399231,
-0.37996312975883484,
-0.6300026774406433,
-0.18376263976097107,
-0.43068259954452515,
0.47894689440727234,
0.5193090438842773,
-0.48952239751815796,
0.5103008151054382,
0.39279666543006897,
-0.21712008118629456,
-0.23149201273918152,
-0.6636377573013306,
0.19245709478855133,
-0.6895104646682739,
-0.7428067922592163,
0.4044342637062073,
-0.34375178813934326,
-0.5045109987258911,
-0.24526266753673553,
0.08204402774572372,
-0.12431513518095016,
0.3646359145641327,
0.20500686764717102,
0.3511883318424225,
0.05485350638628006,
0.43261027336120605,
-0.2654644250869751,
-0.5488113760948181,
-0.07328096032142639,
-0.10781093686819077,
0.43311479687690735,
-0.4088963568210602,
-0.3105495572090149,
-0.25063735246658325,
0.27448785305023193,
0.6631750464439392,
-0.15540798008441925,
0.7410187721252441,
0.41822707653045654,
-0.08495388180017471,
-0.30597084760665894,
-0.300978422164917,
-0.8455960750579834,
-0.5498694181442261,
0.4038757085800171,
-0.18752992153167725,
-1.0339540243148804,
0.4590836465358734,
-0.2981739044189453,
0.10074123740196228,
0.2621379792690277,
0.6008027195930481,
-0.03520262613892555,
0.4224977195262909,
0.6692496538162231,
-0.08335336297750473,
0.5113527774810791,
-0.10888512432575226,
-0.027073519304394722,
-0.7044584155082703,
-0.012864338234066963,
-0.2954791188240051,
-0.3127610683441162,
-0.19841600954532623,
-0.528800368309021,
0.7270378470420837,
-0.18979786336421967,
-0.6468349695205688,
0.2701724171638489,
-0.509114682674408,
0.6311997771263123,
0.41832995414733887,
0.23124663531780243,
0.2963259518146515,
0.016950557008385658,
-0.1940595507621765,
-0.28575342893600464,
-0.9274632930755615,
-0.5463794469833374,
0.8602597713470459,
0.6073474287986755,
0.8615532517433167,
0.4035961627960205,
0.6751911640167236,
0.21470898389816284,
0.4168640375137329,
-0.7662860155105591,
0.735640287399292,
0.12090254575014114,
-0.5638151168823242,
-0.0933350920677185,
-0.3200610280036926,
-1.0410456657409668,
0.38096222281455994,
-0.3764544129371643,
-0.504091203212738,
-0.04393365606665611,
0.13640421628952026,
-0.7950689196586609,
0.15469497442245483,
-0.7962888479232788,
0.5631405115127563,
0.04082682728767395,
-0.6942090392112732,
-0.30590689182281494,
-0.6583333015441895,
0.4147978723049164,
-0.3046380281448364,
0.1456766426563263,
0.038849614560604095,
-0.5521687865257263,
0.33809694647789,
-0.7474140524864197,
1.1116808652877808,
0.19207383692264557,
0.03120281733572483,
0.5274671316146851,
0.26551198959350586,
0.686959445476532,
0.19445401430130005,
-0.15176409482955933,
-0.004993977025151253,
-0.4291943311691284,
-0.3844093382358551,
-0.2928656041622162,
0.5421199798583984,
-0.49622878432273865,
-0.7294178009033203,
-0.43350115418434143,
-0.5417943000793457,
-0.15018026530742645,
0.28877681493759155,
0.3066689968109131,
0.024321671575307846,
-0.1366891711950302,
0.017331935465335846,
0.8096708655357361,
-0.12742169201374054,
0.7811880707740784,
1.004822850227356,
0.014196297153830528,
-0.7199996709823608,
0.6367397904396057,
-0.0761856883764267,
0.7964136600494385,
0.18309462070465088,
0.056202735751867294,
-0.108980193734169,
-0.5254387855529785,
0.06703850626945496,
0.535503625869751,
-0.48167598247528076,
-0.7810270190238953,
-0.20193910598754883,
-0.34966421127319336,
0.14577332139015198,
-0.1282886117696762,
-0.4901256263256073,
-0.37778475880622864,
-0.4215278625488281,
-0.21683834493160248,
0.5914831757545471,
0.5117347240447998,
-0.3098682463169098,
0.5954405665397644,
-0.6804136037826538,
-0.033519286662340164,
0.3915506601333618,
0.10808245837688446,
-0.09272854030132294,
-0.8523187041282654,
-0.20020897686481476,
-0.05785936117172241,
-0.4475896656513214,
-0.6964889764785767,
0.3097240924835205,
0.07319203019142151,
0.21005259454250336,
0.18986748158931732,
0.3924688994884491,
0.5549201369285583,
-0.5189228653907776,
0.7197664976119995,
0.24175311625003815,
-0.7399960160255432,
0.6303874254226685,
-0.5335038304328918,
0.4550737738609314,
0.6944571733474731,
0.000853291479870677,
-0.18812382221221924,
-0.4536343514919281,
-0.8047614693641663,
-0.9553825855255127,
0.6595852971076965,
0.33136802911758423,
-0.002441052347421646,
-0.23227667808532715,
0.3143906593322754,
-0.26794344186782837,
-0.09581216424703598,
-0.5946979522705078,
-0.0009496125858277082,
0.3018674850463867,
-0.09527948498725891,
0.3073616921901703,
-0.6182796955108643,
-0.5413628816604614,
0.13205581903457642,
0.6433632969856262,
-0.2992212474346161,
0.2707369029521942,
0.06203039735555649,
-0.004171101842075586,
0.13173344731330872,
0.2707204520702362,
0.8139234185218811,
0.20803554356098175,
-0.08236870169639587,
0.22379153966903687,
0.5506531000137329,
-0.3942887783050537,
0.37428945302963257,
-0.23159000277519226,
-0.36190545558929443,
-0.12535785138607025,
0.5101023316383362,
0.3698092997074127,
0.18920433521270752,
-0.6343111991882324,
0.48932912945747375,
-0.13343210518360138,
0.027492837980389595,
-0.1087241992354393,
0.13383126258850098,
-0.10845377296209335,
0.38755902647972107,
0.08166742324829102,
0.2501548230648041,
-0.21207745373249054,
-0.4883536100387573,
0.3766911029815674,
0.45683538913726807,
-0.3749043345451355,
-0.3242650628089905,
0.6353513598442078,
0.46490582823753357,
-0.2540346682071686,
0.2966768443584442,
-0.3652244210243225,
-0.3309744596481323,
0.5926864147186279,
0.5815120935440063,
0.897668182849884,
-0.2143166959285736,
0.07679886370897293,
0.39454159140586853,
0.544783890247345,
-0.1453009843826294,
0.15086132287979126,
0.4569297432899475,
-0.45175376534461975,
-0.24074769020080566,
-0.14791303873062134,
-0.4349859356880188,
0.11672108620405197,
-0.340950071811676,
0.30129867792129517,
-0.836055338382721,
-0.691737949848175,
-0.3839116096496582,
-0.07059145718812943,
-0.3206138610839844,
-0.06067212298512459,
0.030570607632398605,
1.2016483545303345,
-0.8037290573120117,
0.5776147842407227,
0.7421940565109253,
-0.6660786867141724,
-0.550892174243927,
0.07419805228710175,
0.4074597954750061,
-0.791396975517273,
0.6670178771018982,
-0.0554167740046978,
-0.1847313940525055,
-0.06275934725999832,
-0.39774903655052185,
-0.8888740539550781,
1.307212471961975,
0.5765137672424316,
-0.578643798828125,
0.04856095090508461,
-0.0788072794675827,
0.5715662240982056,
-0.35622838139533997,
0.5431398153305054,
0.5691208243370056,
0.4331914484500885,
0.018611997365951538,
-0.9577792882919312,
0.33482325077056885,
0.0013047936372458935,
0.23449452221393585,
-0.13741590082645416,
-1.300162672996521,
0.6645858287811279,
-0.448698490858078,
-0.36213818192481995,
0.34990447759628296,
0.5759798288345337,
0.5428752899169922,
0.14459434151649475,
0.5106493234634399,
0.8150030970573425,
0.7407024502754211,
-0.1835031658411026,
0.9492814540863037,
-0.27321574091911316,
0.13919875025749207,
1.2831084728240967,
-0.11980462074279785,
0.9382122755050659,
0.37390264868736267,
-0.07585141062736511,
0.4362391233444214,
0.39811593294143677,
0.10823563486337662,
0.7191943526268005,
0.28205886483192444,
-0.6372362971305847,
-0.19538374245166779,
-0.3643496036529541,
-0.21127647161483765,
0.2205706238746643,
0.29369282722473145,
-0.29033800959587097,
-0.3079192638397217,
-0.19017083942890167,
0.470687597990036,
0.22853192687034607,
-0.4242297410964966,
0.7965558767318726,
0.28194522857666016,
-0.6435434818267822,
0.6361891627311707,
0.018800770863890648,
0.7742348909378052,
-0.6882038712501526,
0.3409592807292938,
-0.46487176418304443,
0.40671834349632263,
-0.20654702186584473,
-0.5919954180717468,
0.6467246413230896,
0.05087331682443619,
-0.36806902289390564,
-0.043363627046346664,
0.9015905857086182,
-0.26917359232902527,
-0.09750343859195709,
0.2754018306732178,
0.2397185117006302,
-0.2051698863506317,
-0.20007525384426117,
-0.7991507649421692,
0.4497736692428589,
-0.20323880016803741,
0.2103431522846222,
0.4588295817375183,
0.40846627950668335,
-0.0782429575920105,
0.8655496835708618,
0.36201220750808716,
0.029687609523534775,
-0.2989518344402313,
-0.06897177547216415,
1.0726585388183594,
-0.3994286060333252,
-0.36127930879592896,
-1.09841787815094,
0.7854682207107544,
-0.13284316658973694,
0.035682473331689835,
0.7204130291938782,
0.2869376838207245,
0.4128561317920685,
-0.08367490768432617,
0.6176016926765442,
0.25861653685569763,
0.32249966263771057,
-0.33842870593070984,
0.8661690950393677,
-0.3516157567501068,
0.5490656495094299,
-0.038766048848629,
-0.6432875394821167,
-0.4468298852443695,
0.3780378997325897,
0.01657264493405819,
0.0067575853317976,
0.7610730528831482,
1.2046054601669312,
0.12773580849170685,
-0.3528731167316437,
0.2023824155330658,
0.2719060480594635,
0.3591225743293762,
0.7570644617080688,
0.8947860598564148,
-0.28635552525520325,
0.8123185634613037,
0.06287138909101486,
-0.4171673655509949,
-0.3698802888393402,
-1.069744348526001,
-0.895226001739502,
-0.11908457428216934,
-0.4787663221359253,
-0.6298356056213379,
0.2987763583660126,
0.7720547914505005,
0.8991921544075012,
-0.5893958210945129,
0.125276118516922,
-0.16046573221683502,
0.17272743582725525,
-0.08212108910083771,
-0.2273414134979248,
0.0150524927303195,
-0.715427815914154,
-0.38867929577827454,
0.44307181239128113,
0.3949936330318451,
0.21130844950675964,
-0.0266260989010334,
-0.19467248022556305,
0.09982260316610336,
0.40008440613746643,
0.6455968618392944,
0.5677998661994934,
-0.6801838278770447,
-0.446882963180542,
-0.21964436769485474,
-0.28829967975616455,
-0.3081674575805664,
0.4130421280860901,
-0.8464030623435974,
0.38537508249282837,
0.33130544424057007,
0.6416346430778503,
-0.16290877759456635,
-0.0780513733625412,
0.5762025713920593,
-1.0111364126205444,
0.33231261372566223,
0.3546505570411682,
0.37440502643585205,
0.19595758616924286,
-0.1844916045665741,
0.9295374155044556,
0.3156740963459015,
-0.6393299698829651,
-0.960570752620697,
0.5668298006057739,
-0.7303619384765625,
-0.3593194782733917,
1.3994412422180176,
-0.27684861421585083,
-0.12972010672092438,
0.07194600999355316,
-0.39236143231391907,
-0.10044632107019424,
-0.41212227940559387,
0.9140130281448364,
0.4313947558403015,
0.14621654152870178,
-0.2605723440647125,
-0.01585555262863636,
0.5800108313560486,
0.5396731495857239,
-0.7650061249732971,
0.07939513027667999,
0.47471901774406433,
0.33954381942749023,
0.28826698660850525,
0.6122282147407532,
-0.16609132289886475,
0.3829120099544525,
0.0959051102399826,
-0.23049695789813995,
-0.37032291293144226,
-0.5353788137435913,
-0.5207784175872803,
0.03880361467599869,
0.3503493070602417,
-0.2553902864456177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12591v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12591v1
|
Unlocking Data-free Low-bit Quantization with Matrix Decomposition for KV Cache Compression
| 2024-05-21T08:35:10 | 2024-05-21T08:35:10 |
Peiyu Liu, Ze-Feng Gao, Wayne Xin Zhao, Yipeng Ma, Tao Wang, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Key-value~(KV) caching is an important technique to accelerate the inference
of large language models~(LLMs), but incurs significant memory overhead. To
compress the size of KV cache, existing methods often compromise precision or
require extra data for calibration, limiting their practicality in LLM
deployment. In this paper, we introduce \textbf{DecoQuant}, a novel data-free
low-bit quantization technique based on tensor decomposition methods, to
effectively compress KV cache. Our core idea is to adjust the outlier
distribution of the original matrix by performing tensor decomposition, so that
the quantization difficulties are migrated from the matrix to decomposed local
tensors. Specially, we find that outliers mainly concentrate on small local
tensors, while large tensors tend to have a narrower value range. Based on this
finding, we propose to apply low-bit quantization to the large tensor, while
maintaining high-precision representation for the small tensor. Furthermore, we
utilize the proposed quantization method to compress the KV cache of LLMs to
accelerate the inference and develop an efficient dequantization kernel
tailored specifically for DecoQuant. Through extensive experiments, DecoQuant
demonstrates remarkable efficiency gains, showcasing up to a $\sim$75\%
reduction in memory footprint while maintaining comparable generation quality.
|
[
-0.292130708694458,
-0.4992055594921112,
0.2737961709499359,
-0.05883632227778435,
-0.6962732672691345,
0.12926876544952393,
-0.15897762775421143,
0.0638708844780922,
0.25480854511260986,
0.27175959944725037,
-0.3387182056903839,
-0.630442202091217,
-0.33146482706069946,
-0.37755998969078064,
-0.2441103160381317,
0.4110064208507538,
-0.03526032343506813,
-0.02528594806790352,
-0.32505589723587036,
-0.05845201015472412,
-0.5384886860847473,
-0.3331888020038605,
-0.5448397994041443,
-0.005355441942811012,
-0.018505845218896866,
0.5328847169876099,
0.5888329744338989,
0.7555642127990723,
0.4401125907897949,
0.2496846467256546,
-0.18297037482261658,
0.01993747428059578,
-0.6336695551872253,
0.37550994753837585,
0.44466695189476013,
-0.7691024541854858,
-0.3833758533000946,
-0.41065913438796997,
0.8319467902183533,
0.22741734981536865,
-0.23107542097568512,
0.22317998111248016,
-0.06095990911126137,
1.0164158344268799,
-1.3054752349853516,
0.3184038996696472,
-0.48717454075813293,
0.048573218286037445,
-0.20046192407608032,
-0.08380643278360367,
-0.5099978446960449,
-0.48483553528785706,
-0.35733678936958313,
-0.6583170890808105,
0.615205705165863,
-0.45321762561798096,
0.6138198375701904,
0.5943365097045898,
-0.2839033603668213,
0.31008201837539673,
-0.6720853447914124,
0.8319026827812195,
-0.4645291268825531,
0.5814282298088074,
0.40292230248451233,
0.31825169920921326,
-0.11858295649290085,
-0.6603102684020996,
-0.4854327440261841,
0.24520738422870636,
0.17262092232704163,
0.12848074734210968,
-0.48667800426483154,
0.07832062244415283,
0.050925593823194504,
0.772514820098877,
-0.5405555963516235,
-0.06954978406429291,
-0.2918432056903839,
-0.21777886152267456,
0.09794776886701584,
0.24205216765403748,
-0.043902914971113205,
-0.08565830439329147,
-0.3019409477710724,
-0.5379977226257324,
-1.071793556213379,
0.030713791027665138,
0.2752508521080017,
0.022653015330433846,
-0.12553094327449799,
0.23102566599845886,
-0.5996189713478088,
0.33025431632995605,
-0.09854570031166077,
0.08571023494005203,
-0.05534110590815544,
-0.07529179006814957,
-0.42152488231658936,
0.24644143879413605,
0.5263288617134094,
0.26873138546943665,
0.03571036830544472,
-0.0010008218232542276,
-0.25883373618125916,
0.3692339360713959,
0.001937297871336341,
-1.2619682550430298,
-0.7245347499847412,
0.13941197097301483,
-0.6967998743057251,
-0.23837007582187653,
-0.3155778646469116,
-0.7303110361099243,
-0.321348637342453,
0.12371978908777237,
0.6407554745674133,
-0.21363937854766846,
-0.2413705587387085,
0.1989198476076126,
-0.05366498604416847,
0.08142602443695068,
0.33214500546455383,
-0.7783335447311401,
0.19542889297008514,
0.5473887920379639,
0.8492425680160522,
0.17579586803913116,
0.4531727731227875,
-0.731703519821167,
0.007935027591884136,
-0.4471958577632904,
0.4134678840637207,
-0.2995264232158661,
-0.49538516998291016,
-0.16494017839431763,
-0.30276578664779663,
0.44748756289482117,
-0.6361829042434692,
0.27721402049064636,
-0.9195112586021423,
-0.4982151985168457,
-0.5084167122840881,
-0.2477777898311615,
-0.11524706333875656,
0.2663256824016571,
-1.145971655845642,
0.9029877185821533,
0.1915036141872406,
-0.715094804763794,
0.3240011930465698,
-0.41453057527542114,
-0.051714058965444565,
-0.0028565467800945044,
0.08265308290719986,
-0.6029395461082458,
0.4698338806629181,
0.5118078589439392,
0.2334757298231125,
-0.5964267253875732,
-0.023015109822154045,
-0.27924084663391113,
-0.6271432042121887,
0.26676255464553833,
-0.6836273074150085,
0.7533474564552307,
0.32956889271736145,
-0.0866563692688942,
-0.252995103597641,
-0.7743653655052185,
0.1964433193206787,
-0.04365801066160202,
-0.37763509154319763,
-0.4799686670303345,
-0.18357303738594055,
-0.39651352167129517,
0.026832224801182747,
0.11362539231777191,
-0.42080506682395935,
0.3100026845932007,
-0.3663731515407562,
0.2511030435562134,
0.7628000974655151,
0.15554815530776978,
0.6014060378074646,
-0.1321205347776413,
0.6220313310623169,
0.3295242488384247,
0.0562269501388073,
-0.05469655618071556,
-0.2795495390892029,
-1.1290384531021118,
-0.7688578963279724,
0.6699686050415039,
0.23895497620105743,
-0.9472255706787109,
0.027357429265975952,
-0.6753416657447815,
-0.45328235626220703,
-0.9788628220558167,
-0.09791011363267899,
0.44279173016548157,
0.3244633972644806,
0.38528504967689514,
-0.218891441822052,
-0.4447854161262512,
-0.9375439882278442,
0.037972673773765564,
-0.1709609478712082,
-0.11934617906808853,
-0.31031158566474915,
0.38726305961608887,
-0.036349084228277206,
0.8992815017700195,
-0.6764402389526367,
-0.18925154209136963,
0.2881535291671753,
0.34216853976249695,
-0.026889652013778687,
0.7403057813644409,
-0.011083162389695644,
-0.598457932472229,
-0.3586157560348511,
-0.36970072984695435,
-0.3519490659236908,
0.17766627669334412,
0.2115572988986969,
-0.17525789141654968,
0.3261605203151703,
0.44977110624313354,
-0.6441954374313354,
0.8629903793334961,
0.40508440136909485,
0.03821374103426933,
0.2793135643005371,
-0.24546167254447937,
0.1729927957057953,
-1.0977954864501953,
0.21890617907047272,
-0.4504097104072571,
-0.27902936935424805,
-0.5171425938606262,
0.1385151445865631,
0.3429560661315918,
0.010657968930900097,
-0.358519583940506,
0.18174348771572113,
-0.3608534038066864,
0.08100640028715134,
-0.12399522960186005,
-0.2266373485326767,
0.00991977658122778,
0.35929256677627563,
0.001822130405344069,
0.7950290441513062,
0.2848145067691803,
-0.5012049674987793,
0.09264075011014938,
0.16569212079048157,
-0.6599104404449463,
0.2518639862537384,
-0.36869773268699646,
0.2531633973121643,
-0.3065170347690582,
0.3425852358341217,
-1.0562187433242798,
0.3404555022716522,
-0.1129569336771965,
-0.4363071918487549,
0.2693765461444855,
-0.7055466175079346,
-0.8764632940292358,
0.15765242278575897,
-0.636299729347229,
0.9011204838752747,
0.6080945134162903,
-0.5551825761795044,
0.17979702353477478,
0.20739813148975372,
0.1452084630727768,
-0.7440801858901978,
-0.8910126686096191,
-0.22511278092861176,
-0.23313099145889282,
-0.5584657192230225,
0.41366884112358093,
-0.20023493468761444,
-0.26847177743911743,
0.0838303491473198,
-0.3466061055660248,
-0.1488277167081833,
0.02150656469166279,
0.12274344265460968,
0.12853841483592987,
-0.4384881854057312,
0.2607385814189911,
0.2926972508430481,
-0.5224853157997131,
0.00006574894359800965,
-0.2506145238876343,
0.5634147524833679,
-0.2681412398815155,
-0.14068491756916046,
-0.11781806498765945,
0.3706144392490387,
0.5389842987060547,
-0.10730503499507904,
0.5557403564453125,
0.6451079249382019,
-0.6159608364105225,
-0.16156089305877686,
-0.4018961787223816,
-0.26889437437057495,
-0.5060309767723083,
0.010438759811222553,
-0.41409239172935486,
-0.8654279708862305,
0.7726178169250488,
-0.07012072950601578,
-0.2949446141719818,
0.3495102822780609,
0.6856021285057068,
0.2662654221057892,
0.910880982875824,
0.4504369795322418,
-0.1191924661397934,
0.2850787341594696,
-0.9085844159126282,
0.21108461916446686,
-0.880562961101532,
0.04399443417787552,
-0.5061343312263489,
-0.6812613606452942,
-0.7734576463699341,
-0.7101855278015137,
0.5046048164367676,
0.4439046382904053,
-0.16530129313468933,
0.051996443420648575,
-0.44246578216552734,
0.6852279305458069,
0.5773392915725708,
0.11151540279388428,
0.4153941571712494,
0.0922766700387001,
-0.10002576559782028,
-0.17746812105178833,
-0.48818933963775635,
0.1871282458305359,
0.9611760973930359,
-0.055704161524772644,
0.9817625284194946,
0.3094511330127716,
0.8936142921447754,
0.13908833265304565,
0.23307201266288757,
-0.8247250914573669,
0.4638516306877136,
-0.05613202601671219,
-0.5059977769851685,
-0.050690628588199615,
-0.7335896492004395,
-0.9298379421234131,
0.2633630633354187,
-0.017130142077803612,
-0.8010321855545044,
0.5451181530952454,
0.247682586312294,
-0.3994391858577728,
0.30427438020706177,
-0.6192454099655151,
0.6769387722015381,
0.5715920329093933,
-0.16681545972824097,
-0.40088674426078796,
-0.6085461378097534,
0.4757908880710602,
0.13517996668815613,
-0.06601542979478836,
-0.0016073810402303934,
0.06982654333114624,
0.7932186722755432,
-0.7538593411445618,
0.5468383431434631,
-0.4299820065498352,
-0.243399977684021,
0.366662859916687,
0.6717146039009094,
0.8102237582206726,
0.3638377785682678,
0.1418846994638443,
0.031512513756752014,
0.1690571904182434,
-0.4786289632320404,
-0.7607682347297668,
0.8502321839332581,
-0.6288744211196899,
-0.37653449177742004,
-0.09204858541488647,
-0.532966136932373,
-0.27896198630332947,
0.13572372496128082,
0.4008761942386627,
0.40136393904685974,
0.14286398887634277,
0.36255860328674316,
0.8954720497131348,
-0.054814860224723816,
0.6021019816398621,
0.46884459257125854,
0.30812570452690125,
-0.8592814207077026,
1.0333348512649536,
0.0654170885682106,
0.3249043822288513,
0.8794822692871094,
0.17680300772190094,
-0.3154912292957306,
-0.43712809681892395,
-0.23562154173851013,
-0.050050389021635056,
-1.058373212814331,
-0.9003167748451233,
-0.19065935909748077,
-0.014637364074587822,
-0.22837983071804047,
-0.3092048168182373,
-0.7621306777000427,
-0.8124929070472717,
-0.13558518886566162,
0.12588703632354736,
0.4770793914794922,
-0.032558392733335495,
-0.33140334486961365,
0.5624515414237976,
-0.8826659917831421,
0.546016275882721,
0.24775439500808716,
0.17819859087467194,
0.09117090702056885,
-0.2362801879644394,
-0.47375595569610596,
0.15578843653202057,
-0.2163119614124298,
-0.5997716784477234,
0.5494012832641602,
-0.07638203352689743,
-0.0725904032588005,
0.4938386380672455,
0.5167722105979919,
1.0800411701202393,
0.1293460577726364,
0.5841524600982666,
-0.011329968459904194,
-1.161919355392456,
0.26510730385780334,
-0.011259502731263638,
0.5516399145126343,
0.7121137380599976,
0.0727795958518982,
-0.477223664522171,
-0.22324125468730927,
-0.6493235230445862,
-1.0915076732635498,
0.5293543338775635,
0.26241832971572876,
-0.09765460342168808,
-0.003520350670441985,
0.18809889256954193,
-0.06475543975830078,
0.19994033873081207,
-0.44713425636291504,
-0.4179282784461975,
0.04464421048760414,
-0.17348119616508484,
0.11810469627380371,
-0.33820730447769165,
0.19826887547969818,
-0.3234614133834839,
0.5414390563964844,
-0.16432097554206848,
0.7834277153015137,
0.14473570883274078,
-0.5225877165794373,
-0.31972402334213257,
0.29703113436698914,
0.5761625170707703,
0.22377759218215942,
-0.4378759264945984,
0.5632899403572083,
0.1858372539281845,
-0.7419558763504028,
0.2964678406715393,
-0.09489903599023819,
-0.2264764904975891,
-0.04457209259271622,
-0.12451290339231491,
0.5046502351760864,
0.2621583044528961,
-0.304144948720932,
0.5229977965354919,
-0.4188513457775116,
0.08243020623922348,
-0.08194313198328018,
-0.26561933755874634,
0.06227954477071762,
0.3028557002544403,
0.29068663716316223,
-0.1098903939127922,
0.20899921655654907,
0.0029118775855749846,
0.03554953634738922,
0.48976609110832214,
-0.32534921169281006,
-0.37271779775619507,
0.6427899599075317,
-0.05027016997337341,
0.2615353465080261,
0.9008011221885681,
-0.31967321038246155,
-0.2766270637512207,
0.3594381809234619,
0.5236778259277344,
1.2519675493240356,
-0.17554548382759094,
-0.1105630025267601,
0.27452823519706726,
0.35310447216033936,
0.06915925443172455,
0.6036579608917236,
-0.5552221536636353,
-0.6138999462127686,
-0.752431333065033,
-0.5708815455436707,
-0.07036109268665314,
0.43679872155189514,
-0.7668942809104919,
0.23776230216026306,
-0.27028971910476685,
0.08753205090761185,
-0.37537890672683716,
0.1959283947944641,
-0.6099825501441956,
0.06220035254955292,
-0.0500529482960701,
0.8332252502441406,
-0.5925230383872986,
1.1567655801773071,
0.05036439374089241,
-0.12193961441516876,
-0.42027586698532104,
-0.12502887845039368,
-0.08004888147115707,
-0.7403920292854309,
0.7488037943840027,
0.04209979623556137,
-0.05239255726337433,
0.35946565866470337,
-0.29793110489845276,
-0.7842373251914978,
1.121115803718567,
0.824725329875946,
-0.2282591611146927,
0.1944652497768402,
0.29905766248703003,
0.16647712886333466,
0.24131782352924347,
0.078693687915802,
0.514172375202179,
0.3713758885860443,
0.005502774845808744,
-0.4848484396934509,
0.48427507281303406,
-0.2669067680835724,
0.12167679518461227,
0.9077439308166504,
-0.48485541343688965,
0.7729640007019043,
-0.005957426968961954,
-0.38920503854751587,
0.19511231780052185,
0.6043651103973389,
0.03890947997570038,
-0.06864964962005615,
0.34739571809768677,
1.1142401695251465,
0.6079918146133423,
-0.10869479924440384,
0.5618855953216553,
-0.23815439641475677,
0.5107648968696594,
0.6673712730407715,
0.2297293096780777,
0.9499832391738892,
0.5906926989555359,
-0.05315651372075081,
0.38271811604499817,
0.372877836227417,
0.38565587997436523,
0.829490065574646,
0.4386311173439026,
-0.6799030900001526,
-0.318143755197525,
0.23022758960723877,
-0.3000526428222656,
0.4446229338645935,
0.4455500543117523,
-0.09204765409231186,
-0.49211418628692627,
-0.2966555058956146,
0.17668858170509338,
-0.749908983707428,
-0.36888131499290466,
0.5791155695915222,
-0.01978757604956627,
-0.42206698656082153,
1.2117565870285034,
0.11272601038217545,
0.3263230621814728,
-0.2806973159313202,
-0.16799888014793396,
-0.40319421887397766,
0.4459145665168762,
0.0596492663025856,
-0.2593466639518738,
0.2038317173719406,
-0.3281521201133728,
-0.24088048934936523,
-0.2160593867301941,
0.8220763802528381,
-0.3694325089454651,
-0.09190366417169571,
-0.3536231815814972,
0.2092038094997406,
0.02782399021089077,
-0.42120417952537537,
0.05393840745091438,
0.1457296758890152,
-0.1796797662973404,
-0.2086893767118454,
0.470571905374527,
0.386764258146286,
-0.21430224180221558,
0.5712037682533264,
0.6916029453277588,
0.0003189567069057375,
0.07622262835502625,
-0.41528674960136414,
0.9613068103790283,
-0.7289026975631714,
-0.535424530506134,
-0.8902990818023682,
0.6341223120689392,
0.37482360005378723,
-0.20312774181365967,
0.43583524227142334,
0.7825623154640198,
0.6140813231468201,
-0.1601797342300415,
0.4418453574180603,
0.20094119012355804,
-0.19652089476585388,
-0.7655569911003113,
0.8660145998001099,
-0.3572607636451721,
0.20837564766407013,
-0.11414527148008347,
-0.7374407052993774,
-0.49821293354034424,
0.49911364912986755,
0.11939100921154022,
-0.2022075653076172,
0.672825038433075,
0.9725555777549744,
-0.06079842150211334,
-0.22185909748077393,
0.46272847056388855,
-0.0014202863676473498,
0.4132334291934967,
0.7120054364204407,
0.73399418592453,
-0.7283080220222473,
0.8010165691375732,
-0.44601091742515564,
-0.07941038906574249,
-0.43772080540657043,
-0.9465954899787903,
-0.4221813976764679,
-0.7760186791419983,
-0.3822605609893799,
-0.45689746737480164,
-0.1504923701286316,
0.5996378660202026,
0.7220263481140137,
-0.6070940494537354,
0.1062251552939415,
-0.36549755930900574,
0.19017422199249268,
-0.14960940182209015,
-0.2912129759788513,
0.6582419872283936,
-0.1276969611644745,
-0.5306925773620605,
0.47679734230041504,
0.3164052665233612,
0.1517069786787033,
-0.3328986167907715,
-0.06366477161645889,
0.33483555912971497,
-0.0473933145403862,
0.41168344020843506,
0.18892766535282135,
-0.24197600781917572,
-0.11227906495332718,
0.07989409565925598,
0.18414562940597534,
0.17659048736095428,
1.161759376525879,
-1.3837183713912964,
0.7983326315879822,
0.9111629128456116,
0.5627254247665405,
0.9891108870506287,
-0.34659096598625183,
0.31246697902679443,
-1.230131983757019,
0.24179627001285553,
0.2524062395095825,
0.28267067670822144,
0.08185282349586487,
-0.27056625485420227,
0.26440662145614624,
0.2817201316356659,
-0.4431404173374176,
-1.0726194381713867,
0.12979251146316528,
-0.9976558089256287,
-0.010376888327300549,
0.9925976991653442,
0.06112758070230484,
-0.36686989665031433,
0.10556256026029587,
0.06675685942173004,
0.5110668540000916,
-0.5169583559036255,
1.0030310153961182,
0.47137030959129333,
0.29241079092025757,
-0.24423477053642273,
-0.34787532687187195,
0.7122523188591003,
0.3586439788341522,
-0.46237125992774963,
0.43155327439308167,
0.2917161285877228,
0.067109115421772,
0.15953487157821655,
0.6217713356018066,
-0.263589471578598,
0.4878147542476654,
0.22920429706573486,
0.24415408074855804,
0.012686418369412422,
-0.04889405518770218,
-0.5895472168922424,
0.010181427001953125,
0.13136409223079681,
-0.5444618463516235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12579v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12579v2
|
Mining the Explainability and Generalization: Fact Verification Based on Self-Instruction
| 2024-05-21T08:23:54 | 2024-05-23T08:02:37 |
Guangyao Lu, Yulin Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fact-checking based on commercial LLMs has become mainstream. Although these
methods offer high explainability, it falls short in accuracy compared to
traditional fine-tuning approaches, and data security is also a significant
concern. In this paper, we propose a self-instruction based fine-tuning
approach for fact-checking that balances accuracy and explainability. Our
method consists of Data Augmentation and Improved DPO fine-tuning. The former
starts by instructing the model to generate both positive and negative
explanations based on claim-evidence pairs and labels, then sampling the
dataset according to our customized difficulty standards. The latter employs
our proposed improved DPO to fine-tune the model using the generated samples.
We fine-tune the smallest-scale LLaMA-7B model and evaluate it on the
challenging fact-checking datasets FEVEROUS and HOVER, utilizing four
fine-tuning methods and three few-shot learning methods for comparison. The
experiments demonstrate that our approach not only retains accuracy comparable
to, or even surpassing, traditional fine-tuning methods, but also generates
fluent explanation text. Moreover, it also exhibit high generalization
performance. Our method is the first to leverage self-supervised learning for
fact-checking and innovatively combines contrastive learning and improved DPO
in fine-tuning LLMs, as shown in the experiments.
|
[
-0.21345244348049164,
-0.7797938585281372,
0.7773312330245972,
-0.33265921473503113,
-0.5555482506752014,
0.0036137797869741917,
-0.14362572133541107,
-0.13176141679286957,
-0.15290281176567078,
0.5580483078956604,
-0.6227559447288513,
-0.7521551251411438,
-0.7227842211723328,
0.26518985629081726,
-0.2266065627336502,
1.1816492080688477,
-0.026351366192102432,
-0.2640015184879303,
-0.19385354220867157,
-0.02910998836159706,
-0.3626169264316559,
-0.2889184355735779,
-0.3897918164730072,
-0.3785664737224579,
0.2945235073566437,
0.9058876633644104,
0.6565806865692139,
1.3788756132125854,
0.39739492535591125,
0.34138503670692444,
-0.05221542343497276,
0.7883933186531067,
-0.5134239792823792,
-0.35710498690605164,
-0.4451133608818054,
-0.5795597434043884,
-0.48821261525154114,
-0.06699556112289429,
0.19497376680374146,
0.27831193804740906,
-0.2711983025074005,
0.4261433184146881,
-0.05682888999581337,
0.6276770234107971,
-0.5506337285041809,
0.32350343465805054,
-0.8866364359855652,
-0.253395676612854,
0.026547884568572044,
-0.44529974460601807,
-0.1380075067281723,
-0.4904510974884033,
-0.18653737008571625,
-0.6285002827644348,
0.7158139944076538,
0.24603015184402466,
0.8476113080978394,
0.5783323049545288,
-0.43415558338165283,
-0.6841833591461182,
-0.4176998734474182,
0.6774791479110718,
-0.7359137535095215,
0.12563002109527588,
0.3004935681819916,
0.20626159012317657,
-0.2208372950553894,
-0.4856022894382477,
-0.7777915596961975,
-0.004221800249069929,
-0.27307263016700745,
0.02660142071545124,
-0.052319448441267014,
0.06241543963551521,
0.19095829129219055,
0.6380433440208435,
-0.40863391757011414,
0.27459439635276794,
-0.41920679807662964,
-0.26421424746513367,
0.6698826551437378,
0.2081606686115265,
0.11313429474830627,
-0.3634471297264099,
-0.40334761142730713,
0.14763963222503662,
-0.705443799495697,
0.07753341645002365,
0.28485578298568726,
0.26539021730422974,
-0.08204329758882523,
0.4563560485839844,
-0.6324428915977478,
0.5742997527122498,
0.4701286554336548,
-0.4544699192047119,
-0.0953206792473793,
-0.32951071858406067,
-0.4957384467124939,
0.2639524042606354,
0.44460904598236084,
0.5970649719238281,
-0.0757579579949379,
-0.21966572105884552,
0.0002908723254222423,
-0.004744467791169882,
-0.034592289477586746,
-1.0029125213623047,
-0.197440043091774,
0.28746065497398376,
-0.6025310754776001,
-0.557679295539856,
-0.11271197348833084,
-0.7931046485900879,
-0.6204085350036621,
-0.5496179461479187,
0.6671070456504822,
-0.4553050398826599,
0.059310123324394226,
0.37418025732040405,
0.20638372004032135,
0.11866579204797745,
0.41562944650650024,
-1.0488988161087036,
-0.031059158965945244,
0.941740095615387,
0.7615829110145569,
-0.005394435953348875,
-0.14000119268894196,
-0.44738665223121643,
0.21503899991512299,
-0.4605556130409241,
0.7782144546508789,
-0.4239303469657898,
0.08019046485424042,
-0.3051348626613617,
-0.08513874560594559,
0.10626392066478729,
-0.569385826587677,
0.6256371736526489,
-0.4422479569911957,
0.13274776935577393,
-0.3528175354003906,
-0.7909256815910339,
-0.5262967944145203,
0.4478268623352051,
-0.2906854450702667,
0.6419682502746582,
-0.3210866153240204,
-0.707040011882782,
0.4524751305580139,
-0.5672374963760376,
-0.38287651538848877,
-0.2647683918476105,
-0.11678541451692581,
-0.6330690979957581,
0.15653254091739655,
0.6097193956375122,
0.5991454124450684,
-0.18674828112125397,
0.4018692672252655,
-0.3699752688407898,
-0.39393913745880127,
0.10796251147985458,
-0.32293373346328735,
0.5297098159790039,
0.38304147124290466,
-0.41803497076034546,
-0.03207109123468399,
-1.134389877319336,
-0.21762427687644958,
0.04993421956896782,
-0.25796857476234436,
-0.1104278638958931,
0.00778479827567935,
-1.1442002058029175,
-0.07311654090881348,
0.5245121717453003,
-0.5413448810577393,
0.22466237843036652,
-0.4006309509277344,
0.35290831327438354,
0.7853127121925354,
0.04949282854795456,
0.23008577525615692,
-0.3747400939464569,
0.07326214760541916,
0.3158915638923645,
0.4279448688030243,
-0.4594530165195465,
-0.07399823516607285,
-1.0403716564178467,
-0.30150628089904785,
0.26824384927749634,
0.6349422335624695,
-0.5106315612792969,
0.5053331851959229,
-0.06581994891166687,
-0.32412847876548767,
-0.5461819171905518,
0.41728609800338745,
0.27147364616394043,
1.0104838609695435,
0.6810157299041748,
0.1798757016658783,
-0.40316346287727356,
-0.8710731267929077,
-0.3044857680797577,
0.010896464809775352,
0.1299106329679489,
0.10997448861598969,
0.39513489603996277,
-0.2275591343641281,
0.7232220768928528,
-0.4698798954486847,
-0.2514173984527588,
0.04422689601778984,
0.19015774130821228,
0.5223743915557861,
0.3979080319404602,
0.2485216110944748,
-0.3200531005859375,
-0.10439184308052063,
-0.08938699215650558,
-0.8072231411933899,
-0.029056431725621223,
-0.1080809086561203,
0.23629280924797058,
0.03713516145944595,
0.4247763752937317,
-0.42064398527145386,
0.39999106526374817,
0.07774131000041962,
-0.30898165702819824,
0.2289116084575653,
-0.5317271947860718,
0.4489075839519501,
-0.6966183185577393,
-0.4123665392398834,
-0.14434976875782013,
-0.21841652691364288,
-0.44246748089790344,
0.10484510660171509,
0.1438075751066208,
0.014411941170692444,
-0.10907024145126343,
-0.0359581857919693,
-0.39753156900405884,
0.33187469840049744,
-0.6341161727905273,
0.0006800605333410203,
0.09454642981290817,
0.3033142685890198,
-0.4009934663772583,
0.6367138028144836,
0.668302059173584,
-0.932474672794342,
0.3643770217895508,
-0.016785860061645508,
-0.3813026249408722,
0.3743925988674164,
-0.6449750065803528,
0.0886976420879364,
-0.28722432255744934,
0.054752618074417114,
-0.9838460087776184,
-0.3352348804473877,
0.22087940573692322,
-0.18139110505580902,
0.2899322807788849,
-0.5328738689422607,
-0.5120283961296082,
-0.18068435788154602,
-0.25484853982925415,
-0.11300536245107651,
0.5532165169715881,
-1.0429996252059937,
0.5048626065254211,
0.05823925882577896,
-0.03106181137263775,
-0.6642456650733948,
-0.21235030889511108,
0.0042961277067661285,
-0.44179168343544006,
-0.6470717787742615,
0.27137231826782227,
-0.03563012182712555,
-0.1456979662179947,
-0.32253655791282654,
-0.5164498686790466,
-0.038664646446704865,
0.3568038046360016,
0.1911378651857376,
0.15414975583553314,
-0.1954679638147354,
0.3076172173023224,
0.37737756967544556,
-0.15506640076637268,
0.09362376481294632,
0.10645613074302673,
0.04333840683102608,
-0.24505288898944855,
-0.3653466999530792,
-0.6732910871505737,
-0.12784171104431152,
0.2926677167415619,
-0.02679045870900154,
0.5626142024993896,
0.5276479125022888,
-0.096733458340168,
-0.28861933946609497,
-0.7584004402160645,
-0.433872789144516,
-0.5210120677947998,
-0.015000549145042896,
-0.4771369397640228,
-0.7590224146842957,
0.38782912492752075,
-0.5555021166801453,
0.12705083191394806,
0.6410290598869324,
0.538816511631012,
-0.14516806602478027,
0.9478132128715515,
0.49822521209716797,
0.11326738446950912,
0.13807448744773865,
-0.10087605565786362,
0.15359488129615784,
-0.3210386633872986,
-0.3661655783653259,
-0.38300076127052307,
-0.1726527363061905,
-0.624183714389801,
-0.31127774715423584,
0.30385249853134155,
0.15269839763641357,
-0.1669764220714569,
-0.0941753089427948,
-0.5642956495285034,
0.8077059388160706,
0.4235217273235321,
0.3603867292404175,
0.7315424084663391,
0.08016543835401535,
0.26166534423828125,
0.21141085028648376,
-0.6450133323669434,
-0.6458882689476013,
1.0548268556594849,
0.401616632938385,
1.1612112522125244,
0.0843561515212059,
0.9235628843307495,
0.48778805136680603,
0.056765224784612656,
-0.47087204456329346,
0.4040890336036682,
-0.38250020146369934,
-0.47592034935951233,
-0.32551509141921997,
-0.4760628044605255,
-0.7663024663925171,
0.22462168335914612,
-0.31245195865631104,
-0.35905808210372925,
0.1948765069246292,
0.7620241641998291,
-0.5465235114097595,
0.16148905456066132,
-0.9331187605857849,
0.6042219400405884,
-0.45840150117874146,
-0.36679336428642273,
-0.7000313997268677,
-0.39963650703430176,
0.5990561246871948,
0.29238012433052063,
0.4962601065635681,
-0.430243581533432,
-0.00036366446875035763,
0.39768385887145996,
-0.5631000995635986,
1.0996434688568115,
-0.2261362224817276,
-0.2003983110189438,
0.16232720017433167,
0.10892175883054733,
0.5169870257377625,
0.43852517008781433,
-0.20413124561309814,
0.15043239295482635,
-0.06593255698680878,
-0.194769024848938,
-0.8883521556854248,
0.8316470384597778,
-0.8032623529434204,
-1.0547912120819092,
-0.246665820479393,
-0.3453448712825775,
0.041113246232271194,
0.11856938153505325,
0.16505049169063568,
0.44971656799316406,
0.0824483186006546,
0.18563306331634521,
1.0142987966537476,
-0.016613688319921494,
0.011281045153737068,
1.001238226890564,
0.12152691185474396,
-0.3358984887599945,
1.2368134260177612,
0.10298469662666321,
-0.19668574631214142,
0.5541608333587646,
0.6314533352851868,
-0.36410143971443176,
-0.8971933722496033,
-0.6737164258956909,
0.10078668594360352,
-0.6808265447616577,
-0.4468514323234558,
-0.2908706068992615,
0.1028565987944603,
-0.36266908049583435,
0.17995114624500275,
-0.3256303071975708,
-0.5117116570472717,
-0.5496037006378174,
-0.11642380803823471,
0.5436999797821045,
0.7775795459747314,
-0.26746800541877747,
0.2941732108592987,
-0.43162810802459717,
0.9054298996925354,
0.5346004366874695,
0.560825526714325,
-0.2939983010292053,
-1.0188082456588745,
-0.2863970696926117,
0.12336530536413193,
-0.31764766573905945,
-0.7582857012748718,
-0.16546986997127533,
0.36464810371398926,
0.44988343119621277,
0.48596838116645813,
0.29976189136505127,
0.7199162840843201,
-0.2166624665260315,
0.4030355215072632,
-0.11177824437618256,
-0.9277483820915222,
0.9582871794700623,
0.06461213529109955,
-0.22355221211910248,
0.5575652718544006,
0.2443983405828476,
0.1565011888742447,
-0.14462749660015106,
-0.7351908087730408,
-0.5656403303146362,
0.6415947675704956,
-0.05132853239774704,
-0.06670328229665756,
0.11579927057027817,
0.8988425731658936,
0.4730461835861206,
0.05657103657722473,
-0.4707723557949066,
-0.446635365486145,
-0.5035332441329956,
-0.4574876129627228,
-0.013287252746522427,
-0.4407525360584259,
-0.37587788701057434,
-0.18308024108409882,
0.8067997694015503,
-0.3522295355796814,
-0.37830281257629395,
0.3275413513183594,
-0.3124740719795227,
-0.025874152779579163,
0.5813567638397217,
0.5112623572349548,
0.760373055934906,
-0.2980915904045105,
0.47251689434051514,
0.494512677192688,
-0.1409059315919876,
0.17596493661403656,
0.2614714503288269,
-0.4112165868282318,
-0.14656011760234833,
0.24778367578983307,
0.7789081335067749,
0.0653904378414154,
-0.23962922394275665,
0.36991018056869507,
0.09364534914493561,
-0.12192392349243164,
0.2516309916973114,
0.6520861387252808,
-0.12000590562820435,
0.2406810224056244,
0.2039538472890854,
-0.14798717200756073,
0.4530179798603058,
-0.6001552939414978,
0.009916366077959538,
0.27750810980796814,
0.1590312421321869,
-0.14321239292621613,
0.4620225429534912,
0.2512686848640442,
0.19319280982017517,
0.251753568649292,
-0.32270169258117676,
-0.2902628481388092,
0.6704667210578918,
0.462464302778244,
0.2857135236263275,
-0.08725602924823761,
0.21426409482955933,
0.5336889624595642,
0.5645326375961304,
-0.0055551654659211636,
0.21064648032188416,
-0.18711820244789124,
-0.5001593828201294,
-0.46927377581596375,
-0.450591117143631,
-0.7311945557594299,
0.38869309425354004,
-0.5051236748695374,
0.18493898212909698,
-0.5447928309440613,
0.19162164628505707,
0.2545720636844635,
0.19870968163013458,
-0.506945788860321,
0.6249979734420776,
0.003377140499651432,
0.7630380988121033,
-0.8345409631729126,
0.4904295802116394,
0.42871421575546265,
-0.22601960599422455,
-0.5234725475311279,
-0.1151718944311142,
0.011102911084890366,
-1.1640664339065552,
0.41632938385009766,
0.22928836941719055,
-0.3633194863796234,
-0.19617153704166412,
-0.7368155717849731,
-0.7807939648628235,
1.189529538154602,
0.7044918537139893,
-0.9088199138641357,
0.3311883211135864,
0.07614661753177643,
0.5302258133888245,
-0.20341205596923828,
0.11019078642129898,
0.8721300363540649,
0.452544629573822,
0.17914171516895294,
-0.3878817856311798,
0.23052100837230682,
0.30312788486480713,
-0.46074047684669495,
-0.2747519910335541,
-0.877760112285614,
0.5843841433525085,
-0.6941882967948914,
-0.23747865855693817,
-0.22063110768795013,
1.0460370779037476,
0.17414620518684387,
0.6833227276802063,
0.6403698325157166,
0.6485527753829956,
1.0380115509033203,
0.02934284135699272,
0.7746604681015015,
-0.3840975761413574,
0.41962170600891113,
1.3261569738388062,
0.19614851474761963,
0.32680535316467285,
0.2196206897497177,
-0.05544987693428993,
0.7854939103126526,
0.6303221583366394,
-0.19881737232208252,
0.38766783475875854,
0.1218096986413002,
-0.07646223157644272,
-0.6172038316726685,
0.04918291047215462,
-0.23532350361347198,
0.547602653503418,
0.374664843082428,
-0.29885730147361755,
-0.41182926297187805,
-0.2582457363605499,
-0.00042921368731185794,
0.14056487381458282,
-0.5460343956947327,
0.9658751487731934,
-0.17091494798660278,
-0.6554616689682007,
0.6601386070251465,
0.08188772201538086,
0.4490357041358948,
-0.2879596948623657,
-0.11440317332744598,
-0.2869645655155182,
0.2626951038837433,
-0.4980468153953552,
-0.9028078317642212,
0.18884322047233582,
0.20668262243270874,
-0.4571719467639923,
0.17061585187911987,
0.8927431702613831,
-0.4223540723323822,
-0.3441196382045746,
-0.23943443596363068,
0.3427063524723053,
0.13647563755512238,
-0.035832181572914124,
-0.6891940236091614,
0.07890315353870392,
0.151495099067688,
0.08016600459814072,
0.12648768723011017,
0.6476611495018005,
0.19825565814971924,
0.7851398587226868,
0.5336778163909912,
-0.2683282792568207,
-0.09633777290582657,
0.061728693544864655,
0.7321758270263672,
-0.5104525089263916,
-0.4543090760707855,
-1.2491228580474854,
0.2051565945148468,
-0.10909387469291687,
-0.12811431288719177,
0.732105016708374,
0.7133722901344299,
0.47964659333229065,
-0.04143794625997543,
0.7496323585510254,
0.15116742253303528,
0.7452779412269592,
-0.7684077024459839,
0.3928578794002533,
-0.42599567770957947,
0.31798407435417175,
0.34194350242614746,
-0.16043685376644135,
-0.02862267754971981,
0.4705798327922821,
-0.2430577278137207,
-0.23625008761882782,
0.3668752610683441,
0.9532341957092285,
-0.3633032441139221,
0.04327644407749176,
0.23895502090454102,
0.5537062883377075,
0.10042227059602737,
0.17783038318157196,
0.6842010021209717,
-0.39578676223754883,
0.7601044178009033,
-0.5343259572982788,
-0.4415101110935211,
-0.49730584025382996,
-1.2026541233062744,
-1.1016201972961426,
-0.09336493909358978,
-0.6232550740242004,
-0.15330487489700317,
0.0804029032588005,
0.5135731101036072,
0.8121086955070496,
-0.9449177980422974,
0.28842729330062866,
-0.03611413761973381,
0.7943517565727234,
-0.09584677219390869,
-0.15349772572517395,
0.49620094895362854,
-0.5712946057319641,
-0.40256449580192566,
0.603382408618927,
0.2603183686733246,
0.07318641990423203,
0.008285499177873135,
0.11450287699699402,
0.29596543312072754,
0.2785198390483856,
0.46771883964538574,
0.2363748699426651,
-0.8365172147750854,
-0.4163403809070587,
-0.3437759578227997,
0.17532649636268616,
0.145422101020813,
0.7772562503814697,
-0.519452691078186,
0.6279762983322144,
0.25424548983573914,
0.5360586047172546,
0.46389684081077576,
0.2670077681541443,
0.15169653296470642,
-0.5735387206077576,
-0.3653627336025238,
-0.4552304446697235,
0.35978949069976807,
0.45851799845695496,
-0.7200065851211548,
0.30677834153175354,
0.17206203937530518,
-0.6854972839355469,
-0.6047372817993164,
0.23503990471363068,
-0.995066225528717,
-0.18614111840724945,
0.7191781997680664,
-0.05039631947875023,
-0.20812787115573883,
-0.20688080787658691,
-0.25213873386383057,
0.4749510586261749,
-0.3488655090332031,
1.4706079959869385,
0.41984623670578003,
-0.3935075104236603,
-0.1220804825425148,
-0.08536352217197418,
0.6779439449310303,
0.13759905099868774,
-0.9552382230758667,
0.4018752872943878,
0.393576979637146,
0.7696679830551147,
0.013609862886369228,
0.18752093613147736,
0.1717933565378189,
0.39756909012794495,
-0.1889781504869461,
-0.14632172882556915,
-0.5918278098106384,
-0.2571411430835724,
-0.30698105692863464,
0.15664100646972656,
0.04611552506685257,
-0.31721362471580505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13085v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13085v1
|
Multi-domain Knowledge Graph Collaborative Pre-training and Prompt Tuning for Diverse Downstream Tasks
| 2024-05-21T08:22:14 | 2024-05-21T08:22:14 |
Yichi Zhang, Binbin Hu, Zhuo Chen, Lingbing Guo, Ziqi Liu, Zhiqiang Zhang, Lei Liang, Huajun Chen, Wen Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge graphs (KGs) provide reliable external knowledge for a wide variety
of AI tasks in the form of structured triples. Knowledge graph pre-training
(KGP) aims to pre-train neural networks on large-scale KGs and provide unified
interfaces to enhance different downstream tasks, which is a key direction for
KG management, maintenance, and applications. Existing works often focus on
purely research questions in open domains, or they are not open source due to
data security and privacy in real scenarios. Meanwhile, existing studies have
not explored the training efficiency and transferability of KGP models in
depth. To address these problems, We propose a framework MuDoK to achieve
multi-domain collaborative pre-training and efficient prefix prompt tuning to
serve diverse downstream tasks like recommendation and text understanding. Our
design is a plug-and-play prompt learning approach that can be flexibly adapted
to different downstream task backbones. In response to the lack of open-source
benchmarks, we constructed a new multi-domain KGP benchmark called KPI with two
large-scale KGs and six different sub-domain tasks to evaluate our method and
open-sourced it for subsequent research. We evaluated our approach based on
constructed KPI benchmarks using diverse backbone models in heterogeneous
downstream tasks. The experimental results show that our framework brings
significant performance gains, along with its generality, efficiency, and
transferability.
|
[
-0.629469096660614,
-0.28514760732650757,
0.5415202379226685,
0.2269131988286972,
-0.17471496760845184,
0.11697061359882355,
-0.2575131356716156,
-0.15682531893253326,
0.053140368312597275,
0.27528467774391174,
-0.8108333945274353,
-0.5096527934074402,
-0.7430016398429871,
0.12854401767253876,
0.268118292093277,
0.9882214665412903,
-0.09711796045303345,
-0.12644833326339722,
-0.3775795102119446,
-0.3148878812789917,
-0.7504773736000061,
-0.37491580843925476,
-0.7855274677276611,
-0.27465155720710754,
0.8511644601821899,
0.515342652797699,
0.3894973397254944,
0.11463899910449982,
0.1855713427066803,
0.2816503643989563,
0.3072003424167633,
0.5370627045631409,
-0.526390790939331,
0.20457644760608673,
-0.2716911733150482,
-0.09571242332458496,
-0.4703952372074127,
0.14842376112937927,
0.3633645176887512,
0.8408753871917725,
0.1396794617176056,
0.24341271817684174,
0.5138680934906006,
0.795264482498169,
-0.8556773066520691,
0.539035975933075,
-0.39840856194496155,
-0.07200226932764053,
-0.04883696138858795,
-0.12406502664089203,
-0.5112171769142151,
-0.473477303981781,
0.2766975462436676,
-1.138984203338623,
0.07371038943529129,
0.17970000207424164,
0.7326593399047852,
0.318827360868454,
-0.5276975035667419,
-0.25802138447761536,
-0.29712650179862976,
0.45945432782173157,
-0.44114765524864197,
0.5728679895401001,
0.39587944746017456,
0.5155666470527649,
-0.059565138071775436,
-1.148657202720642,
-0.4701344668865204,
-0.10525444895029068,
-0.3596544563770294,
0.11853376775979996,
0.019942622631788254,
-0.000632869778200984,
0.05383622273802757,
0.0881839469075203,
-0.5319989323616028,
-0.0313476026058197,
0.07968681305646896,
-0.3888419568538666,
0.33175626397132874,
0.060594502836465836,
0.043618809431791306,
0.14727932214736938,
-0.3072131276130676,
-0.17709222435951233,
-0.43576928973197937,
0.2669561505317688,
0.403311550617218,
0.5820484757423401,
-0.08233529329299927,
0.2286163568496704,
-0.5635503530502319,
0.8462684154510498,
0.16129839420318604,
-0.09405329823493958,
0.43092799186706543,
-0.5251551866531372,
-0.00833859946578741,
-0.2809962034225464,
0.713123083114624,
0.21298840641975403,
0.2718486189842224,
-0.46687567234039307,
0.11705190688371658,
-0.2837819755077362,
0.4797690808773041,
-0.8373219966888428,
-0.5642054080963135,
-0.01244542095810175,
-0.3123166859149933,
-0.1211782842874527,
-0.33093443512916565,
-0.5607072114944458,
-0.5627056360244751,
-0.6317517161369324,
0.6258220076560974,
-0.6282116174697876,
-0.3047344982624054,
-0.07867234200239182,
-0.13045404851436615,
-0.33167850971221924,
0.40854156017303467,
-0.7974209785461426,
0.09900208562612534,
0.41153886914253235,
0.7692979574203491,
-0.16624797880649567,
-0.5625439882278442,
-0.6469694972038269,
0.2909577488899231,
-0.020419854670763016,
0.842850923538208,
-0.41694870591163635,
-0.33003348112106323,
-0.12716607749462128,
0.12021750211715698,
-0.4973408877849579,
-0.2755787968635559,
0.34226447343826294,
-0.8261550068855286,
0.15073008835315704,
-0.37077417969703674,
-0.5958882570266724,
-0.46272894740104675,
0.4751255214214325,
-0.5522085428237915,
0.7021669745445251,
0.3354966640472412,
-0.7495757937431335,
0.6620296835899353,
-0.7973584532737732,
-0.6649636626243591,
0.10123524814844131,
0.004114161245524883,
-0.35214388370513916,
-0.4023180902004242,
0.43803349137306213,
0.6255746483802795,
-0.2168487012386322,
0.34182173013687134,
-0.5073156952857971,
-0.0014354679733514786,
-0.36692729592323303,
0.039010196924209595,
0.6255931854248047,
0.15259991586208344,
-0.09004656225442886,
0.3750854432582855,
-0.7911095023155212,
0.3753521144390106,
-0.1448889821767807,
-0.2007310837507248,
-0.47570663690567017,
-0.3501667380332947,
-0.3277265429496765,
0.08801566809415817,
0.18523626029491425,
-0.13475900888442993,
0.4011909067630768,
-0.011640062555670738,
0.23296675086021423,
0.7825814485549927,
0.09922876954078674,
0.5562055706977844,
-0.21392466127872467,
0.5044600963592529,
-0.0028968709520995617,
0.3290462791919708,
-0.156767338514328,
-0.6667968034744263,
-0.38422366976737976,
-0.46950700879096985,
0.4896808862686157,
0.29464444518089294,
-1.037488341331482,
0.4327455759048462,
-0.3857646882534027,
-0.5068034529685974,
-0.19991672039031982,
0.14596599340438843,
0.23890331387519836,
0.8844226598739624,
0.44274866580963135,
-0.4195801317691803,
-0.15682131052017212,
-0.5064447522163391,
-0.3468630015850067,
0.07769819349050522,
0.03080528788268566,
0.7104474306106567,
0.2246038168668747,
-0.1849709302186966,
1.166473627090454,
-0.7411386966705322,
-0.4232814908027649,
-0.10642075538635254,
0.44463711977005005,
0.07435030490159988,
0.42107364535331726,
0.47052082419395447,
-0.9132452607154846,
-0.8412083387374878,
-0.03258134797215462,
-0.5385844111442566,
-0.08296116441488266,
0.2302783727645874,
-0.4686254858970642,
-0.2554810047149658,
0.3666742742061615,
-0.6577344536781311,
0.04852036386728287,
0.5012080669403076,
-0.3105592727661133,
0.5528968572616577,
-0.02927960269153118,
0.3806155025959015,
-1.310250997543335,
0.3007924258708954,
-0.3330559730529785,
-0.11174646764993668,
-0.5985163450241089,
-0.17853067815303802,
0.21571454405784607,
-0.16465254127979279,
-0.18375802040100098,
0.6329216957092285,
-0.22674697637557983,
0.06634989380836487,
-0.015852274373173714,
-0.00017073321214411408,
0.22981823980808258,
0.8724031448364258,
-0.05711432546377182,
0.767569363117218,
0.575171709060669,
-1.0578230619430542,
0.3576209545135498,
0.3360239863395691,
-0.2598109543323517,
0.5463570952415466,
-0.3484898507595062,
0.22886091470718384,
0.08075403422117233,
0.32750293612480164,
-0.9437850117683411,
-0.2630138099193573,
0.45643794536590576,
-0.3977142572402954,
0.29703131318092346,
-0.47470831871032715,
-0.422046422958374,
-0.32174575328826904,
-0.04964958503842354,
0.4573539197444916,
0.3741854131221771,
-0.6734866499900818,
0.810892641544342,
0.1918409764766693,
-0.30471134185791016,
-0.6900035738945007,
0.07122021913528442,
-0.3258953392505646,
-0.07086467742919922,
-0.7553467750549316,
0.39720168709754944,
-0.05725408345460892,
0.4021819233894348,
0.1420918107032776,
-0.09487222135066986,
-0.29382604360580444,
0.14290361106395721,
0.37341880798339844,
0.04562516510486603,
-0.2384154349565506,
0.27038612961769104,
0.17866143584251404,
-0.1658422201871872,
-0.17329835891723633,
-0.8147174715995789,
0.5635929703712463,
0.11597578972578049,
-0.36178624629974365,
-0.13526903092861176,
-0.017649028450250626,
0.4546301066875458,
-0.39424607157707214,
0.6933978796005249,
0.9068321585655212,
-0.029153412207961082,
-0.35060355067253113,
-0.3127545118331909,
-0.10654877871274948,
-0.547791063785553,
0.16265460848808289,
-0.46001338958740234,
-1.0163041353225708,
0.24931871891021729,
-0.9341714382171631,
-0.1122504398226738,
0.24131223559379578,
0.37520506978034973,
0.10305661708116531,
0.8286404013633728,
0.812426745891571,
-0.16280417144298553,
0.34203898906707764,
-0.2724573016166687,
0.32679957151412964,
-0.5954490303993225,
-0.23459209501743317,
-0.4987000823020935,
-0.13931207358837128,
-0.0428050234913826,
-0.0760229080915451,
0.4944521188735962,
0.43540331721305847,
-0.3917592763900757,
0.24177142977714539,
-0.28964462876319885,
0.4067564308643341,
0.8152409791946411,
0.041002124547958374,
0.10704846680164337,
-0.08680225163698196,
-0.4690314829349518,
0.24953626096248627,
-0.9278474450111389,
-0.12878099083900452,
1.1081773042678833,
-0.1755184531211853,
0.31866633892059326,
0.0714418813586235,
0.45758917927742004,
0.4489680826663971,
0.4509914815425873,
-0.6200701594352722,
0.38592469692230225,
0.016153864562511444,
-0.2698652446269989,
-0.4056195318698883,
-0.6022053956985474,
-0.842951238155365,
0.09754055738449097,
-0.21320132911205292,
-0.5788634419441223,
0.000008350231837539468,
0.399601012468338,
-0.38437438011169434,
0.25380274653434753,
-1.0030375719070435,
1.2069517374038696,
0.0390993095934391,
-0.21169441938400269,
-0.04173845052719116,
-0.7366209626197815,
0.4086863100528717,
-0.20492376387119293,
0.14109325408935547,
-0.13491033017635345,
0.23949095606803894,
0.531480073928833,
-0.3851456046104431,
0.742957353591919,
-0.4830763638019562,
0.0622369721531868,
0.2898624539375305,
-0.10528796166181564,
0.5880607962608337,
0.23917503654956818,
0.026909640058875084,
0.17871859669685364,
-0.2749324440956116,
-0.33890172839164734,
-0.6987804174423218,
0.5239273905754089,
-0.9275035262107849,
-0.28714919090270996,
0.022950727492570877,
-0.6339769959449768,
-0.9166987538337708,
0.5597373843193054,
0.28156113624572754,
0.5634076595306396,
0.04207472503185272,
-0.0730312243103981,
0.3567037582397461,
-0.13093118369579315,
0.24975180625915527,
0.5515038967132568,
0.06371009349822998,
-0.48635339736938477,
1.0025182962417603,
-0.1472170054912567,
0.2461143434047699,
0.38549843430519104,
0.06705319136381149,
-0.3894444704055786,
-0.44841596484184265,
-0.5979381799697876,
-0.1984429955482483,
-0.8386025428771973,
-0.2585884928703308,
-0.7435594797134399,
-0.05484446510672569,
-0.8328990936279297,
-0.12562806904315948,
-0.2235877811908722,
-0.24318064749240875,
-0.18011142313480377,
0.23053769767284393,
0.46013352274894714,
0.5438212752342224,
-0.006074360106140375,
0.34170061349868774,
-1.0293810367584229,
0.3743995428085327,
0.5661221742630005,
0.7077152729034424,
0.2985697090625763,
-0.28349143266677856,
-0.4503396451473236,
-0.22283348441123962,
-0.34027260541915894,
-0.4170214831829071,
0.08560403436422348,
0.23880800604820251,
0.6130202412605286,
0.2984856367111206,
0.3633366525173187,
0.47391626238822937,
-0.6843425035476685,
0.7149583101272583,
0.24145418405532837,
-0.7149147987365723,
0.3484579622745514,
-0.2796476185321808,
0.3610233962535858,
0.865385115146637,
0.9558441042900085,
-0.33811190724372864,
0.030024120584130287,
-0.40469518303871155,
-0.738179624080658,
0.8904911875724792,
0.07032134383916855,
-0.12327148020267487,
0.39194223284721375,
0.2819513976573944,
0.6015757918357849,
0.5196573734283447,
-0.2314981371164322,
-0.33180227875709534,
-0.3360418975353241,
-0.3042711615562439,
-0.25303560495376587,
0.15491142868995667,
-0.24050942063331604,
-0.25761622190475464,
0.8347485661506653,
-0.524652898311615,
0.08314163982868195,
-0.09292269498109818,
-0.23478466272354126,
0.32823553681373596,
0.06305690109729767,
0.21586845815181732,
0.6095649003982544,
0.03413459286093712,
0.06358059495687485,
-0.0498269759118557,
-0.7505030035972595,
0.2352212816476822,
0.3514779806137085,
-0.011388554237782955,
-0.28931525349617004,
0.27780604362487793,
0.8785500526428223,
0.01879234053194523,
-0.24856097996234894,
0.5545194149017334,
-0.13382472097873688,
-0.31815600395202637,
0.20322781801223755,
0.15472039580345154,
0.15959182381629944,
0.34306249022483826,
0.11901751905679703,
0.48825064301490784,
0.07484308630228043,
-0.2043018639087677,
0.13894954323768616,
0.2151886522769928,
-0.24351437389850616,
-0.23498377203941345,
0.49833086133003235,
0.4198119640350342,
-0.1503569334745407,
0.6057994961738586,
-0.4732903242111206,
-0.5333594679832458,
0.36261722445487976,
0.15642423927783966,
0.7932589650154114,
-0.04971686005592346,
0.4473066031932831,
0.19657525420188904,
-0.0980018824338913,
0.08738341182470322,
0.07037936896085739,
-0.499751478433609,
-0.8260343670845032,
-0.5383458733558655,
-0.48369285464286804,
-0.4843207597732544,
0.16332559287548065,
-0.42073825001716614,
0.23366135358810425,
-0.20228758454322815,
-0.22704407572746277,
0.09491774439811707,
-0.14747898280620575,
-0.8092345595359802,
0.2402748465538025,
-0.062044065445661545,
0.7323350310325623,
-0.6023034453392029,
0.8787718415260315,
0.7951883673667908,
-0.3245779573917389,
-1.0748944282531738,
-0.032232072204351425,
-0.2999403476715088,
-0.7579283714294434,
0.6945334076881409,
0.2258467674255371,
-0.15912766754627228,
0.3768565058708191,
-0.3878616988658905,
-0.9566531181335449,
1.1846143007278442,
0.35707569122314453,
-0.2289201319217682,
-0.02622557431459427,
0.09926389157772064,
0.15628603100776672,
-0.29321569204330444,
0.10080564022064209,
0.055570684373378754,
0.5362856984138489,
0.07592450827360153,
-0.896353542804718,
0.08478741347789764,
-0.24895153939723969,
-0.37341564893722534,
0.19769473373889923,
-0.7929815053939819,
0.8370600938796997,
-0.019424308091402054,
0.007718960288912058,
-0.20052048563957214,
0.3718078136444092,
0.13489489257335663,
0.5275725722312927,
0.7951922416687012,
0.521324634552002,
0.8747134804725647,
0.15620359778404236,
0.9045349955558777,
-0.6749146580696106,
0.15137936174869537,
1.0417473316192627,
-0.47880932688713074,
0.1977633535861969,
0.15187203884124756,
-0.056817974895238876,
0.4701176881790161,
0.624011218547821,
0.19444268941879272,
1.0678025484085083,
0.012018016539514065,
-0.3079430162906647,
-0.24924476444721222,
-0.11616883426904678,
-0.470437616109848,
-0.044529423117637634,
0.1425248384475708,
-0.15684083104133606,
-0.23443366587162018,
0.10303912311792374,
-0.1236962154507637,
-0.320451021194458,
-0.42450302839279175,
0.7617568373680115,
0.07964744418859482,
-0.8366382718086243,
0.4059622883796692,
-0.18010202050209045,
0.48163628578186035,
-1.0220437049865723,
-0.07679889351129532,
-0.016032524406909943,
0.19744329154491425,
-0.10474180430173874,
-0.4208332598209381,
-0.12931619584560394,
-0.279707133769989,
-0.2503892779350281,
-0.33209407329559326,
1.0528128147125244,
-0.12015923857688904,
0.009176182560622692,
0.33007746934890747,
0.7417880892753601,
-0.15487433969974518,
-0.2936006784439087,
-0.4964766502380371,
-0.41869887709617615,
-0.09029969573020935,
-0.38986238837242126,
0.46090248227119446,
0.6034318208694458,
0.04601125791668892,
0.6399433612823486,
0.6680359840393066,
-0.14608636498451233,
0.08894304186105728,
0.33855849504470825,
1.0213924646377563,
-0.1514599770307541,
-0.8041703701019287,
-0.3991057276725769,
0.43162205815315247,
-0.15552915632724762,
-0.594978928565979,
0.8220943808555603,
0.37741097807884216,
0.980320155620575,
-0.18529066443443298,
0.9512650370597839,
-0.07330217212438583,
0.3319353461265564,
-0.5713924765586853,
0.8579961061477661,
-0.4633059799671173,
-0.18463169038295746,
-0.26917141675949097,
-0.8346047401428223,
-0.06665460020303726,
0.08009372651576996,
-0.24876709282398224,
0.23700997233390808,
0.78568035364151,
0.4355809688568115,
-0.3081011474132538,
0.3307224214076996,
0.08023570477962494,
-0.07924220710992813,
0.11948742717504501,
0.3910534679889679,
0.6546749472618103,
0.05284405127167702,
0.6529978513717651,
-0.28940892219543457,
-0.1427077203989029,
-0.02952757477760315,
-0.9515489339828491,
-0.9150235652923584,
-0.7113627195358276,
-0.24786576628684998,
-0.13283966481685638,
0.12387801706790924,
0.6495479941368103,
1.1335240602493286,
-0.6698611974716187,
0.234446719288826,
-0.1999107301235199,
0.07770225405693054,
-0.3022204339504242,
-0.19996686279773712,
0.528191328048706,
-0.7985622882843018,
-0.17596571147441864,
0.4440248906612396,
0.07441077381372452,
-0.17995519936084747,
0.07654101401567459,
-0.1854989379644394,
-0.0018031110521405935,
-0.3025205433368683,
0.6684858798980713,
0.15808238089084625,
-0.027793265879154205,
-0.2909548580646515,
-0.0870942696928978,
0.08429815620183945,
-0.20468133687973022,
1.023438572883606,
-0.9766844511032104,
0.2320714145898819,
0.37726375460624695,
1.0712276697158813,
0.4887217581272125,
-0.0404391847550869,
0.653078019618988,
-1.1437264680862427,
0.026273690164089203,
0.09047029912471771,
0.13701987266540527,
0.23105621337890625,
-0.4207443296909332,
0.5684698820114136,
0.4496663510799408,
-0.5693673491477966,
-0.47703731060028076,
0.26280948519706726,
-0.7887563109397888,
-0.40566757321357727,
0.9000676870346069,
-0.4900527596473694,
0.18059156835079193,
-0.33952128887176514,
-0.10042557865381241,
0.4065752923488617,
-0.3120895028114319,
0.5486904978752136,
0.785304605960846,
-0.280924528837204,
0.2125767171382904,
-0.3518234193325043,
0.7833550572395325,
0.32819101214408875,
-0.7957139015197754,
-0.07353244721889496,
0.30485716462135315,
0.19731341302394867,
0.18689623475074768,
0.864193320274353,
0.373793363571167,
0.010702756233513355,
0.07570379227399826,
-0.0022278171963989735,
-0.45925194025039673,
-0.5620888471603394,
0.021381905302405357,
0.4646869897842407,
-0.05710906907916069,
-0.1992170512676239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12564v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12564v1
|
ProtT3: Protein-to-Text Generation for Text-based Protein Understanding
| 2024-05-21T08:06:13 | 2024-05-21T08:06:13 |
Zhiyuan Liu, An Zhang, Hao Fei, Enzhi Zhang, Xiang Wang, Kenji Kawaguchi, Tat-Seng Chua
|
q-bio.QM
|
q-bio.QM, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Language Models (LMs) excel in understanding textual descriptions of
proteins, as evident in biomedical question-answering tasks. However, their
capability falters with raw protein data, such as amino acid sequences, due to
a deficit in pretraining on such data. Conversely, Protein Language Models
(PLMs) can understand and convert protein data into high-quality
representations, but struggle to process texts. To address their limitations,
we introduce ProtT3, a framework for Protein-to-Text Generation for Text-based
Protein Understanding. ProtT3 empowers an LM to understand protein sequences of
amino acids by incorporating a PLM as its protein understanding module,
enabling effective protein-to-text generation. This collaboration between PLM
and LM is facilitated by a cross-modal projector (i.e., Q-Former) that bridges
the modality gap between the PLM's representation space and the LM's input
space. Unlike previous studies focusing on protein property prediction and
protein-text retrieval, we delve into the largely unexplored field of
protein-to-text generation. To facilitate comprehensive benchmarks and promote
future research, we establish quantitative evaluations for protein-text
modeling tasks, including protein captioning, protein question-answering, and
protein-text retrieval. Our experiments show that ProtT3 substantially
surpasses current baselines, with ablation studies further highlighting the
efficacy of its core components. Our code is available at
https://github.com/acharkq/ProtT3.
|
[
-0.17693179845809937,
-0.6726773381233215,
0.7369658350944519,
-0.009570376016199589,
-0.42936286330223083,
0.06652622669935226,
0.12586553394794464,
-0.5582294464111328,
-0.12075953185558319,
0.4310922622680664,
-0.4768573045730591,
-0.2584538757801056,
-0.4729340672492981,
0.4111447334289551,
-0.3898177742958069,
1.110335111618042,
-0.14257198572158813,
0.17647665739059448,
-0.26579341292381287,
0.10196901112794876,
-0.2641206383705139,
-0.20296743512153625,
-0.19478625059127808,
-0.45078229904174805,
0.5605030655860901,
0.5488176941871643,
0.8166828751564026,
0.687502920627594,
0.6696716547012329,
0.1451098769903183,
0.2179630696773529,
0.1278582215309143,
-0.2723363935947418,
0.052639156579971313,
0.036913782358169556,
-0.4937686622142792,
-0.7392567992210388,
0.08147123456001282,
0.6213690638542175,
0.5695802569389343,
0.4602944254875183,
-0.012048622593283653,
0.10510057955980301,
0.7965958118438721,
-0.5966625809669495,
0.16561610996723175,
-0.3859460651874542,
0.06973901391029358,
-0.4220181703567505,
-0.4080890119075775,
-0.5191874504089355,
-0.16438399255275726,
0.2859872281551361,
-0.4689789414405823,
0.48576095700263977,
0.1978374868631363,
0.7459334135055542,
-0.1615961343050003,
-0.5090541839599609,
-0.20759913325309753,
-0.5254577994346619,
0.37660303711891174,
-0.6336359977722168,
0.5556026697158813,
0.6682360172271729,
0.3252406418323517,
-0.208378866314888,
-0.9797507524490356,
-0.826400637626648,
-0.36969807744026184,
-0.06634904444217682,
0.5237129926681519,
-0.044529881328344345,
0.12198325246572495,
-0.18751291930675507,
0.5065672397613525,
-1.058308482170105,
-0.2822522222995758,
-0.2823047637939453,
0.14146146178245544,
0.2508540749549866,
-0.28725388646125793,
0.4140909016132355,
-0.4241357445716858,
0.07598353177309036,
0.03480454534292221,
-0.8102350234985352,
-0.38320332765579224,
0.09890460968017578,
0.218063622713089,
0.18572990596294403,
0.8192750811576843,
0.031782038509845734,
0.7707549333572388,
-0.1671132743358612,
0.37070316076278687,
0.05781538039445877,
-0.36794668436050415,
-0.25329020619392395,
-0.045211248099803925,
0.8624438643455505,
0.4106060564517975,
0.04236084967851639,
-0.3237115144729614,
0.10282357037067413,
-0.47866278886795044,
0.19377197325229645,
-0.8508630394935608,
-0.3792893588542938,
0.6650276780128479,
-0.5023461580276489,
-0.11349297314882278,
0.1714993715286255,
-0.47952398657798767,
-0.3234868347644806,
0.14448657631874084,
0.6908272504806519,
-0.7561471462249756,
-0.10675894469022751,
0.2951434552669525,
-0.17342068254947662,
-0.026342900469899178,
0.04948800429701805,
-0.6264206171035767,
0.22874729335308075,
0.34300896525382996,
1.0953774452209473,
-0.14292407035827637,
-0.33561772108078003,
-0.6164270043373108,
0.6834867000579834,
0.04487735405564308,
0.7192991971969604,
-0.35566195845603943,
-0.2673284411430359,
-0.2438274770975113,
-0.19250547885894775,
0.08936141431331635,
-0.5427848100662231,
0.0847185030579567,
-0.6203569769859314,
0.23278872668743134,
-0.042153507471084595,
-0.6558102369308472,
-0.1311860829591751,
-0.0676666796207428,
-0.8785616755485535,
0.5235815048217773,
0.15277108550071716,
-0.9409664869308472,
-0.003213160904124379,
-0.9199327230453491,
-0.41209936141967773,
0.4931238889694214,
-0.2589227855205536,
-0.4423002600669861,
0.2447681427001953,
0.015199909918010235,
0.44769784808158875,
-0.6400105953216553,
0.3290410339832306,
-0.05400431901216507,
-0.18573203682899475,
0.5617932677268982,
0.09833879768848419,
0.1402246206998825,
0.28979724645614624,
-0.10767602175474167,
0.1688772439956665,
-0.6204650402069092,
0.06014507636427879,
0.12798748910427094,
-0.26772138476371765,
0.06353411078453064,
0.3135165572166443,
0.11710486561059952,
0.017760133370757103,
0.08178187906742096,
-0.4949599802494049,
0.09714895486831665,
-0.33990877866744995,
0.777402400970459,
0.33955010771751404,
-0.05363846942782402,
0.4257848858833313,
-0.4310568571090698,
0.29290464520454407,
0.005300561431795359,
-0.01193950418382883,
-0.1607656478881836,
-0.40743783116340637,
-0.5174473524093628,
-0.13931037485599518,
0.32135331630706787,
0.4686204195022583,
-0.886319100856781,
0.2685145139694214,
-0.23265577852725983,
-0.3734646737575531,
-0.39719876646995544,
-0.10629826784133911,
0.3537626266479492,
0.4484153389930725,
0.8950216770172119,
0.03185213357210159,
-0.5871089100837708,
-1.0108705759048462,
-0.4389951825141907,
-0.3551165461540222,
-0.4464867115020752,
-0.0348985530436039,
0.6866718530654907,
-0.10801882296800613,
1.0565398931503296,
-0.4556047022342682,
-0.3080787658691406,
-0.787860095500946,
0.40056490898132324,
-0.02836301550269127,
0.7026669383049011,
0.09371277689933777,
-0.8877184987068176,
-0.319326788187027,
0.04028783738613129,
-0.5792375206947327,
-0.05484488606452942,
-0.15003252029418945,
-0.15006674826145172,
-0.27852389216423035,
0.272212415933609,
-0.47337400913238525,
0.08938541263341904,
0.5581820607185364,
-0.3010953366756439,
0.5167977213859558,
-0.012412025593221188,
0.018191341310739517,
-1.1874741315841675,
0.35394278168678284,
0.06540971994400024,
-0.45297932624816895,
-0.7794694900512695,
-0.10180393606424332,
0.10279223322868347,
-0.07118493318557739,
-0.5325303077697754,
0.5635699033737183,
-0.35097628831863403,
-0.1602359563112259,
-0.30193257331848145,
0.16433162987232208,
0.19994768500328064,
0.13549770414829254,
0.2917722761631012,
0.8391202688217163,
0.11165954172611237,
-0.43426603078842163,
-0.04997413977980614,
0.486101359128952,
-0.16383996605873108,
0.06438842415809631,
-0.7414421439170837,
0.1116030216217041,
0.06277256458997726,
0.31807994842529297,
-0.557548463344574,
-0.5711924433708191,
0.40906086564064026,
-0.6851542592048645,
0.06626924872398376,
0.1668790578842163,
-0.5458402633666992,
-0.24423174560070038,
-0.47613897919654846,
0.4689510762691498,
0.22302024066448212,
-0.14718084037303925,
0.656175434589386,
0.04975064843893051,
-0.20437055826187134,
-0.27875733375549316,
-0.8593436479568481,
0.03376244381070137,
0.19589650630950928,
-0.44323644042015076,
0.6690332293510437,
-0.15748052299022675,
0.03578544408082962,
-0.026968635618686676,
-0.29158440232276917,
-0.15956857800483704,
-0.2266494184732437,
0.002358495956286788,
-0.03311045840382576,
0.13320298492908478,
0.04201813414692879,
-0.02321438305079937,
-0.1451757699251175,
-0.10862601548433304,
-0.45142263174057007,
0.4923489987850189,
-0.25088492035865784,
-0.0738786980509758,
-0.43633973598480225,
0.5858091115951538,
0.2438947707414627,
-0.27481594681739807,
0.6826115250587463,
0.49757733941078186,
-0.33024272322654724,
0.045066166669130325,
-0.07867898046970367,
-0.26509109139442444,
-0.42983317375183105,
0.7184481620788574,
-0.523587703704834,
-0.8575088381767273,
0.31992483139038086,
-0.03940945491194725,
-0.08908235281705856,
0.38437479734420776,
0.31173643469810486,
-0.4720480740070343,
1.0599312782287598,
0.755912721157074,
0.8884208798408508,
0.38206204771995544,
-0.1962878406047821,
0.2533537745475769,
-0.8354935646057129,
-0.4537126123905182,
-0.424600213766098,
-0.2893925905227661,
-0.3488849103450775,
-0.5665154457092285,
0.3534145951271057,
0.4621783494949341,
-0.25102564692497253,
0.43518590927124023,
-0.1569904386997223,
0.45670175552368164,
0.5800402164459229,
0.4031333029270172,
0.29309019446372986,
-0.17311781644821167,
0.03866200149059296,
-0.15718021988868713,
-0.7651170492172241,
-0.6813455820083618,
0.7415837049484253,
0.42605435848236084,
0.3763951063156128,
0.24580979347229004,
0.5297967791557312,
0.26498547196388245,
0.32264992594718933,
-0.7478917837142944,
0.5919939875602722,
-0.30957743525505066,
-0.27732759714126587,
0.061727654188871384,
-0.48152482509613037,
-0.5904771089553833,
-0.15407802164554596,
-0.16646048426628113,
-0.5926700234413147,
0.08923192322254181,
0.3750896453857422,
-0.22146746516227722,
0.17047812044620514,
-0.6123895645141602,
0.9722049236297607,
-0.25928059220314026,
-0.6263211965560913,
0.1905059516429901,
-0.8258731365203857,
0.31789958477020264,
-0.34446263313293457,
0.152123361825943,
0.02716779336333275,
-0.10780245065689087,
0.8699681162834167,
-0.5444818735122681,
0.6095420718193054,
0.08427714556455612,
-0.07706384360790253,
0.20215056836605072,
0.6344696283340454,
0.20715132355690002,
0.3456726670265198,
-0.057205330580472946,
-0.18827515840530396,
0.017381452023983,
-0.4425742030143738,
-0.5496735572814941,
0.3807796537876129,
-0.7058541774749756,
-0.32074639201164246,
-0.22102424502372742,
-0.6529552340507507,
-0.34138116240501404,
0.25603339076042175,
0.4971482753753662,
0.4446089267730713,
0.18309286236763,
0.30163565278053284,
0.44698095321655273,
-0.38089925050735474,
0.28391239047050476,
0.511141836643219,
-0.25937366485595703,
-0.6457186341285706,
0.956111490726471,
-0.04445287212729454,
0.2391747087240219,
0.8297684192657471,
0.060263268649578094,
-0.45121389627456665,
-0.8834139108657837,
-0.08725812286138535,
0.27382954955101013,
-0.4985625147819519,
-0.5708027482032776,
-0.7122566103935242,
-0.07514048367738724,
-0.2572193741798401,
-0.27397269010543823,
-0.40098556876182556,
-0.4105204641819,
-0.3153339624404907,
-0.08186445385217667,
0.3210170269012451,
0.7167415022850037,
-0.1737411618232727,
0.6722337603569031,
-1.1534488201141357,
0.6210495829582214,
0.06794751435518265,
0.44614100456237793,
-0.39793631434440613,
-0.3112542927265167,
-0.437775194644928,
-0.030554192140698433,
-0.5003743171691895,
-1.4062776565551758,
0.5063952207565308,
0.4994319975376129,
0.14991480112075806,
-0.0564592219889164,
0.00009979338938137516,
0.3511214554309845,
-0.4310550391674042,
0.8308513760566711,
0.28388580679893494,
-1.2160096168518066,
0.9973682165145874,
-0.3315332531929016,
0.48914098739624023,
0.4447816014289856,
0.584425687789917,
-0.41597893834114075,
-0.7287519574165344,
-0.46158096194267273,
-0.9255930781364441,
0.6717068552970886,
0.6725589036941528,
-0.39542925357818604,
-0.3710739314556122,
0.47607630491256714,
0.3974929451942444,
0.06555216759443283,
-1.2006995677947998,
0.14409425854682922,
-0.46624818444252014,
-0.5268212556838989,
0.04642212390899658,
-0.31474027037620544,
-0.011123540811240673,
0.11255292594432831,
0.5599610805511475,
-0.4333224296569824,
0.5624552369117737,
0.4766903519630432,
-0.4392511248588562,
0.03479123115539551,
0.31152451038360596,
0.37646520137786865,
0.6530106067657471,
-0.6747908592224121,
0.5356592535972595,
-0.2887907922267914,
-0.6316460967063904,
-0.09822472184896469,
0.20869654417037964,
0.02182645909488201,
-0.15999215841293335,
0.6353771090507507,
0.5798475742340088,
-0.3264290690422058,
-0.7017947435379028,
0.3521050810813904,
-0.095515176653862,
-0.4639708697795868,
0.43950551748275757,
-0.23000136017799377,
0.0255136601626873,
0.228388249874115,
0.5945568680763245,
-0.055054888129234314,
0.29871702194213867,
-0.464692622423172,
0.34868016839027405,
-0.0768715888261795,
-0.28705069422721863,
-0.5433984398841858,
0.9610939621925354,
0.3851052224636078,
-0.23832301795482635,
0.45979273319244385,
0.050391923636198044,
-0.40284407138824463,
0.3315938115119934,
0.8798846006393433,
0.9101633429527283,
0.0924893468618393,
0.32623690366744995,
0.20175990462303162,
0.09152457118034363,
-0.07606153935194016,
0.6550561785697937,
0.018892228603363037,
-0.5608152151107788,
-0.5401507019996643,
-0.6240997314453125,
-0.28967663645744324,
0.4059443771839142,
-0.42824864387512207,
0.13128608465194702,
-0.2581096291542053,
-0.20561140775680542,
-0.023383814841508865,
0.07122952491044998,
-0.3168753683567047,
0.18952524662017822,
-0.163302481174469,
0.9750205278396606,
-0.7970919609069824,
0.8815114498138428,
0.769142210483551,
-0.6729568243026733,
-0.3471812605857849,
0.2658335864543915,
-0.23563580214977264,
-0.21410013735294342,
0.7839434146881104,
0.3670191168785095,
-0.11556653678417206,
0.4010845720767975,
-0.4735710620880127,
-0.3256717622280121,
0.9827665090560913,
0.4729098975658417,
-0.6510404944419861,
-0.03163069859147072,
0.41430509090423584,
0.40686914324760437,
-0.21236424148082733,
0.32305052876472473,
0.5019627809524536,
0.44598543643951416,
-0.1404591053724289,
-0.6599536538124084,
0.1421932429075241,
-0.31580498814582825,
0.0008409596048295498,
-0.017187373712658882,
-0.5237278938293457,
0.72846519947052,
-0.16358323395252228,
-0.06501912325620651,
0.07145906239748001,
0.895565927028656,
0.4574722647666931,
-0.0006277816137298942,
0.03326038271188736,
-0.031228968873620033,
0.39395803213119507,
-0.14227205514907837,
0.9476045966148376,
-0.09766151010990143,
0.07966919243335724,
1.123139500617981,
-0.2533246576786041,
0.9296384453773499,
0.6142680644989014,
-0.037860751152038574,
0.10583394020795822,
0.5926770567893982,
0.2221074253320694,
0.569760262966156,
0.2707933485507965,
-0.19023168087005615,
-0.23024502396583557,
-0.09894154220819473,
-0.4683797061443329,
0.3302119970321655,
0.2074326127767563,
-0.2936919331550598,
-0.03498246520757675,
0.2408151775598526,
-0.0972750261425972,
0.1260491907596588,
0.0278607327491045,
0.7048094272613525,
-0.05718672275543213,
-0.2656765282154083,
0.3173567056655884,
0.06049017980694771,
0.20482906699180603,
-0.6767818331718445,
-0.19875365495681763,
-0.4277806580066681,
0.047037817537784576,
-0.05845251679420471,
-1.0965232849121094,
0.42431125044822693,
0.07151246070861816,
-0.3373628854751587,
-0.34195467829704285,
0.5244964361190796,
-0.4397636950016022,
-0.2905292809009552,
0.23223435878753662,
0.7340039610862732,
0.11325118690729141,
0.010359502397477627,
-0.6351686716079712,
0.18691708147525787,
-0.10727794468402863,
-0.3538672924041748,
0.1696193516254425,
0.2934934198856354,
0.13130402565002441,
0.5540112853050232,
0.1921658217906952,
0.10577305406332016,
-0.3860752582550049,
-0.007361372467130423,
0.7631747126579285,
-0.7893466949462891,
-0.18641126155853271,
-0.8989527821540833,
0.3473776876926422,
0.13776716589927673,
-0.05102216452360153,
0.3421092629432678,
0.8210773468017578,
0.720860481262207,
-0.34271225333213806,
0.9151970744132996,
-0.3021121621131897,
0.37700334191322327,
-0.7136081457138062,
0.7535308003425598,
-0.6555821299552917,
0.13046050071716309,
-0.06301970779895782,
-0.780364453792572,
-0.858855128288269,
0.689475417137146,
-0.07474323362112045,
0.060306668281555176,
0.9900286197662354,
0.6034127473831177,
0.16243845224380493,
0.19225525856018066,
0.01647457294166088,
0.3125092089176178,
0.6672898530960083,
0.6665587425231934,
0.866214394569397,
-0.6737393736839294,
0.7005548477172852,
0.08417674154043198,
-0.11522099375724792,
-0.13237379491329193,
-1.0655863285064697,
-0.7055338025093079,
-0.6912379860877991,
-0.30970486998558044,
-0.40488359332084656,
0.4481094181537628,
0.796994149684906,
0.6543999314308167,
-0.6841987371444702,
-0.3357956111431122,
-0.6334658861160278,
-0.27343806624412537,
-0.19452889263629913,
-0.1913207620382309,
0.4286310076713562,
-0.16049525141716003,
-0.6363690495491028,
0.5052897930145264,
0.351441353559494,
0.4011278450489044,
0.16750988364219666,
-0.23716937005519867,
-0.4684085547924042,
-0.08455381542444229,
0.5995134115219116,
0.3814060688018799,
-0.5539189577102661,
-0.1851503700017929,
0.035303179174661636,
0.07173741608858109,
0.04108281061053276,
0.8738000392913818,
-0.743246853351593,
0.2901511788368225,
0.6982030868530273,
0.5057181715965271,
0.41757506132125854,
-0.137671560049057,
1.203651785850525,
-0.8333128690719604,
-0.2321387678384781,
0.3018232583999634,
0.010722290724515915,
0.3684748411178589,
-0.1843836009502411,
0.4664844870567322,
0.2006247490644455,
-0.4567417502403259,
-0.7756105661392212,
0.28134843707084656,
-1.0449820756912231,
-0.5813799500465393,
0.8658020496368408,
0.130514994263649,
-0.19421608746051788,
-0.05053066462278366,
-0.27902260422706604,
0.6786297559738159,
-0.09553499519824982,
0.5260884165763855,
0.3669416010379791,
-0.47746169567108154,
-0.32347571849823,
-0.8283047676086426,
0.8607015013694763,
0.5178125500679016,
-0.9759149551391602,
0.44667765498161316,
0.408168226480484,
-0.14913231134414673,
-0.11606495827436447,
0.8283481597900391,
-0.10475459694862366,
0.3760559558868408,
-0.2327563464641571,
0.04442497715353966,
-0.3240862190723419,
-0.5529426336288452,
0.09923937171697617,
0.19315515458583832,
0.043168842792510986,
0.001164993504062295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13084v1
|
The 2nd FutureDial Challenge: Dialog Systems with Retrieval Augmented Generation (FutureDial-RAG)
| 2024-05-21T07:35:21 | 2024-05-21T07:35:21 |
Yucheng Cai, Si Chen, Yi Huang, Junlan Feng, Zhijian Ou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The 2nd FutureDial Challenge: Dialog Systems with Retrieval Augmented
Generation (FutureDial-RAG), Co-located with SLT 2024
|
[
-0.18832486867904663,
-0.4136993885040283,
0.5084654688835144,
-0.0375499427318573,
-0.12933920323848724,
0.6461734771728516,
0.7124574780464172,
-0.9331856369972229,
0.44777652621269226,
1.0576015710830688,
-1.129664421081543,
0.24938428401947021,
-0.25995272397994995,
0.19021455943584442,
-0.28605642914772034,
0.8196293115615845,
0.07311025261878967,
0.17203916609287262,
-0.5218275189399719,
-0.15284302830696106,
-0.8485981225967407,
-0.6461725831031799,
-0.5710594654083252,
-0.49517562985420227,
-0.022425701841711998,
0.4459458887577057,
0.5555478930473328,
-0.3667963743209839,
0.3503648340702057,
0.3505014181137085,
0.032578542828559875,
0.3997117877006531,
-0.3275974988937378,
0.5741972327232361,
-0.07963881641626358,
-0.14039435982704163,
-0.6435506939888,
-0.07171354442834854,
0.2714429199695587,
0.21362659335136414,
0.27874529361724854,
0.5670260787010193,
-0.2989121675491333,
0.6198374032974243,
-0.3469908833503723,
0.10296367853879929,
-0.5238630175590515,
0.2415553331375122,
-0.08967509120702744,
-0.8136820793151855,
-0.522742509841919,
-0.43057191371917725,
0.20618554949760437,
-0.5046164989471436,
0.07904262095689774,
0.5154041647911072,
0.9110153317451477,
0.32122671604156494,
-0.5955705642700195,
-0.6057919263839722,
-0.5389589667320251,
0.6801968216896057,
-0.3509616553783417,
0.6886008977890015,
0.4337204098701477,
0.15295009315013885,
-0.15812456607818604,
-0.7252815365791321,
-0.37739142775535583,
-0.1047649160027504,
0.25427111983299255,
0.27237072587013245,
0.1741742193698883,
-0.016110610216856003,
0.017691586166620255,
-0.021229514852166176,
-0.5989360213279724,
-0.28550800681114197,
-0.3295763432979584,
-0.6590030789375305,
0.3948831558227539,
0.39622822403907776,
-0.12797802686691284,
-0.2951752543449402,
-0.5440292358398438,
0.1972212940454483,
-0.684444785118103,
-0.426146537065506,
0.25036531686782837,
-0.07622908800840378,
0.145565927028656,
0.6005814075469971,
0.12354571372270584,
0.37039220333099365,
0.18409463763237,
-0.14220741391181946,
0.5303940176963806,
-0.8532524108886719,
0.132048562169075,
-0.15620458126068115,
0.1654442399740219,
0.4527026116847992,
-0.25651785731315613,
0.2680467665195465,
-0.5050663948059082,
-0.5345642566680908,
-0.04273567348718643,
-0.5642077922821045,
-0.012036667205393314,
0.09417963027954102,
-0.5643972754478455,
-0.22572258114814758,
-0.32847651839256287,
-0.8237939476966858,
-0.388489693403244,
-0.2881014943122864,
0.47893890738487244,
0.05583290010690689,
-0.4858293831348419,
-0.3908742666244507,
-0.27419236302375793,
0.23809148371219635,
0.5798441767692566,
-0.9466497898101807,
0.42738938331604004,
0.8878283500671387,
0.6271886825561523,
0.062375474721193314,
0.2719651758670807,
-0.5583175420761108,
0.3230486214160919,
-0.20193837583065033,
0.9746693968772888,
-0.6492068767547607,
-0.8873240947723389,
-0.19110004603862762,
-0.06663597375154495,
0.17516401410102844,
-0.7903445363044739,
0.5713282227516174,
-0.9643892645835876,
0.5780853033065796,
-0.3245701193809509,
-0.5115392208099365,
0.15310871601104736,
0.10922858119010925,
-0.3472708761692047,
1.2183103561401367,
0.34608328342437744,
-0.5121458172798157,
0.12833480536937714,
-0.7661350965499878,
-0.14316615462303162,
0.7395710945129395,
-0.41466987133026123,
-0.4327835738658905,
0.2584385275840759,
-0.31541311740875244,
-0.19980363547801971,
-0.39089739322662354,
0.11733391880989075,
-0.17455239593982697,
-0.2512754499912262,
-0.1966886967420578,
-0.7642713189125061,
0.6456938982009888,
0.40635499358177185,
-0.33146268129348755,
0.03502260148525238,
-0.6708987355232239,
0.48580119013786316,
0.3411030173301697,
-0.11712897568941116,
-0.0605025589466095,
-0.2141178846359253,
0.21587269008159637,
0.15074343979358673,
0.9644720554351807,
-0.5173367261886597,
0.10265838354825974,
0.08309289067983627,
0.17834703624248505,
0.882906436920166,
0.1585044413805008,
0.3046521842479706,
-0.34787315130233765,
0.6324271559715271,
-0.12724705040454865,
0.4145277142524719,
-0.22942663729190826,
-0.6295862197875977,
-0.8661285638809204,
0.5035151243209839,
-0.06336807459592819,
1.1771595478057861,
-1.2235513925552368,
0.09779014438390732,
-0.02654966339468956,
-0.18098120391368866,
0.10431523621082306,
-0.22971263527870178,
0.6346529126167297,
0.5009076595306396,
0.21856346726417542,
-0.31024739146232605,
-0.8742754459381104,
-0.8736773133277893,
0.05445590987801552,
-0.49610501527786255,
0.5215067267417908,
0.8006983995437622,
0.6268352270126343,
-0.2935498058795929,
0.7319281697273254,
-0.3801649510860443,
-0.03491366282105446,
0.022242199629545212,
0.16378839313983917,
0.02473415434360504,
0.5159478187561035,
0.12659022212028503,
-1.5011284351348877,
-0.6337066292762756,
-0.2679295837879181,
-0.6050798892974854,
-0.31894075870513916,
0.07594528049230576,
0.27790793776512146,
0.5818148255348206,
0.6794199347496033,
-0.5946362018585205,
0.43458038568496704,
0.6059277057647705,
-0.5407822132110596,
1.1792622804641724,
-0.2714811861515045,
0.1773892045021057,
-0.9931442737579346,
-0.3136032819747925,
-0.5107411742210388,
-0.558081328868866,
-0.5423546433448792,
-0.3227619528770447,
-0.11213614791631699,
-0.5597290992736816,
-0.3398038148880005,
0.7959427833557129,
-0.6398219466209412,
-0.5714967846870422,
-0.21121415495872498,
-0.12339100986719131,
-0.07233402878046036,
0.13084949553012848,
-0.271902471780777,
1.551997423171997,
-0.20966920256614685,
-0.35432106256484985,
0.6219838857650757,
0.4964736998081207,
-0.3098560869693756,
0.7066963315010071,
-0.6544560790061951,
0.4691613018512726,
0.13275279104709625,
0.8734597563743591,
-0.5445568561553955,
-0.46729812026023865,
0.126595139503479,
-0.8482799530029297,
0.04996609687805176,
0.10295846313238144,
-0.6042803525924683,
-0.576252281665802,
-0.10182636976242065,
0.6650371551513672,
0.5447093844413757,
-0.46202704310417175,
0.6917692422866821,
0.6724072098731995,
-0.482740581035614,
-0.5617510080337524,
-0.23153549432754517,
0.4464877247810364,
-0.15477995574474335,
-0.49956685304641724,
0.2841963469982147,
-0.33412742614746094,
-0.31984367966651917,
-0.157601997256279,
0.0018276518676429987,
0.13643726706504822,
-0.15492533147335052,
0.2530169188976288,
0.36578765511512756,
0.06624148041009903,
-0.016933713108301163,
0.04278568923473358,
-0.4682888388633728,
0.008093159645795822,
-0.5557911396026611,
0.908326268196106,
-0.21843574941158295,
-0.4623700678348541,
-0.5971964001655579,
0.8742449879646301,
0.5648226141929626,
-0.07113322615623474,
0.23947733640670776,
0.5916244387626648,
-0.3131083846092224,
0.29927146434783936,
-0.9123695492744446,
-0.17984884977340698,
-0.5965988636016846,
0.45917466282844543,
-0.736958920955658,
-1.2356009483337402,
0.43971484899520874,
-0.4636734127998352,
0.23129938542842865,
0.41315457224845886,
0.7692779302597046,
-0.2307872325181961,
1.280767560005188,
0.7453932166099548,
0.25980645418167114,
0.6839357614517212,
-0.09278351068496704,
0.10201820731163025,
-1.082026720046997,
-0.5467270612716675,
-0.37894299626350403,
0.3309900164604187,
-0.36121344566345215,
-0.31748542189598083,
0.6636767387390137,
0.1140388697385788,
-0.4709837734699249,
0.5185737013816833,
-0.4463622272014618,
0.29584330320358276,
0.7524248361587524,
0.05157453939318657,
0.260068416595459,
-0.17667055130004883,
-0.2120535522699356,
-0.2264954000711441,
-0.253920316696167,
-0.5713755488395691,
0.8511650562286377,
0.17493166029453278,
0.3565908372402191,
0.2808034121990204,
1.0034050941467285,
0.5850136280059814,
-0.1421957165002823,
-0.260591059923172,
0.9760932326316833,
-0.12353536486625671,
-0.7372927069664001,
-0.24760888516902924,
-0.22771863639354706,
-0.7823219299316406,
0.09490006417036057,
0.019182614982128143,
-1.0341838598251343,
0.09447649866342545,
0.26306506991386414,
-0.3785908818244934,
-0.03600073605775833,
-0.7729746103286743,
0.37959206104278564,
-0.33630654215812683,
-0.3512488901615143,
-0.18871788680553436,
-0.8579493165016174,
0.048072680830955505,
0.009266990236938,
0.31351301074028015,
-0.18804411590099335,
-0.23351794481277466,
0.5391463041305542,
-0.5515788197517395,
0.4327312707901001,
-0.43668824434280396,
-0.26632970571517944,
0.5205482840538025,
0.0024206077214330435,
0.7858757972717285,
0.5077537298202515,
0.04069138690829277,
-0.6372170448303223,
0.17952293157577515,
-0.25153401494026184,
-0.32882100343704224,
0.5190898776054382,
-0.3286114037036896,
-0.8503509759902954,
-0.5579873323440552,
-0.634946882724762,
-0.2623578608036041,
0.4579916000366211,
0.40276268124580383,
1.2004929780960083,
-0.16290105879306793,
-0.18717233836650848,
0.8887090086936951,
-0.26588886976242065,
0.3181806802749634,
0.2864305078983307,
-0.5453564524650574,
-0.6651827096939087,
1.4497065544128418,
-0.05921730026602745,
0.5333500504493713,
0.475773423910141,
-0.08866514265537262,
-0.5782979130744934,
-0.6875760555267334,
-0.49929654598236084,
-0.12213931232690811,
-0.46996116638183594,
-0.2637292146682739,
-0.8025318384170532,
-0.34210896492004395,
-0.8965141773223877,
-0.22438381612300873,
-0.48476436734199524,
-0.6737167835235596,
-0.596974790096283,
0.29470905661582947,
0.2980371415615082,
0.9608537554740906,
-0.437961220741272,
-0.09061170369386673,
-0.9910596609115601,
0.49113932251930237,
0.508076548576355,
0.20269504189491272,
-0.3549192547798157,
-0.5722548365592957,
-0.12006797641515732,
0.07761210203170776,
-0.7309290170669556,
-0.518662691116333,
0.39950451254844666,
0.002081835176795721,
0.18596766889095306,
-0.2516532838344574,
-0.05463814735412598,
0.65948086977005,
-0.9179618954658508,
1.2552334070205688,
0.4671460688114166,
-0.765639066696167,
0.6217958927154541,
-0.5791165828704834,
0.3374069631099701,
0.751180112361908,
-0.35292088985443115,
-0.42488032579421997,
-0.06725050508975983,
-0.9295352697372437,
-1.0046031475067139,
0.17361314594745636,
0.018657095730304718,
0.2965068221092224,
0.08651906251907349,
0.07173123210668564,
0.3138161897659302,
0.1543988734483719,
-0.49530327320098877,
-0.14623834192752838,
0.007550008129328489,
-0.12679244577884674,
0.3079769015312195,
-0.6473890542984009,
0.13378100097179413,
0.04079059511423111,
0.7655053734779358,
-0.03779618814587593,
0.8556104898452759,
0.08852063119411469,
0.07531630247831345,
0.09326506406068802,
0.22900880873203278,
1.1661773920059204,
0.4074056148529053,
-0.2947239577770233,
-0.2772909998893738,
0.4182814657688141,
-0.6638731956481934,
0.21006834506988525,
0.03379274159669876,
-0.3528579771518707,
0.14194129407405853,
0.23686733841896057,
1.0116022825241089,
0.2366524487733841,
-0.6833620667457581,
0.40875381231307983,
-0.18650054931640625,
-0.18687616288661957,
-1.3849507570266724,
-0.2647440433502197,
-0.06274178624153137,
0.5980646014213562,
1.0129235982894897,
0.22642648220062256,
0.4458406865596771,
-0.48630401492118835,
0.39121177792549133,
0.5122069716453552,
-0.5464333295822144,
-0.0038289225194603205,
0.759940505027771,
0.6028960943222046,
-0.9247241020202637,
0.4383145868778229,
-0.7170085906982422,
-0.9600228667259216,
0.4347452223300934,
0.798008143901825,
0.8800599575042725,
-0.02375410869717598,
0.06334235519170761,
0.15302059054374695,
-0.24059368669986725,
-0.0318572036921978,
0.6696483492851257,
-0.10236294567584991,
-0.44911888241767883,
-0.41163283586502075,
-0.30344250798225403,
-0.795371413230896,
0.006701867561787367,
-0.5858193039894104,
0.1627359390258789,
-0.09489262849092484,
-0.5384342670440674,
-0.4543013274669647,
0.4888180196285248,
-0.2592836618423462,
0.27011212706565857,
0.02707824669778347,
0.9174535870552063,
-0.19689695537090302,
0.6270045638084412,
0.43223363161087036,
0.17205503582954407,
-0.3831957280635834,
-0.26196858286857605,
0.46882468461990356,
-0.8371372222900391,
0.8930802941322327,
0.175728440284729,
-0.4629862308502197,
0.16439206898212433,
-0.5101407170295715,
-1.0897431373596191,
1.2745462656021118,
-0.16028839349746704,
-0.30785977840423584,
-0.3312452733516693,
-0.2568088173866272,
0.2044840306043625,
-0.0970383733510971,
0.44921454787254333,
0.43986621499061584,
0.467783123254776,
0.32166048884391785,
-1.6557388305664062,
-0.4808245599269867,
-0.4801613986492157,
-0.08318259567022324,
0.43621188402175903,
-1.1187927722930908,
0.5910106301307678,
-0.3803795874118805,
-0.20996618270874023,
0.830792248249054,
1.0795384645462036,
0.7018247246742249,
0.6057097315788269,
0.5272353887557983,
0.6165958642959595,
0.47453251481056213,
-0.13325656950473785,
0.66668301820755,
0.030003182590007782,
0.4662041962146759,
1.4799154996871948,
-0.3344089984893799,
0.6448588371276855,
0.5146352052688599,
-0.17185863852500916,
0.4946616291999817,
0.785817563533783,
0.1708677113056183,
0.797626256942749,
-0.14395006000995636,
-0.7663612961769104,
0.08638403564691544,
-0.6406535506248474,
-0.7720028162002563,
0.4920040965080261,
0.7919403910636902,
0.18553760647773743,
0.07066261023283005,
0.18903762102127075,
-0.22895656526088715,
0.1058969795703888,
-0.17459751665592194,
1.0349950790405273,
-0.03831341490149498,
-0.645036518573761,
0.48231080174446106,
-0.5180227756500244,
0.812000572681427,
-0.30933678150177,
-0.2320040911436081,
-0.04686889797449112,
0.34439125657081604,
-0.05355506017804146,
-0.626112163066864,
0.13641825318336487,
-0.2500123679637909,
-0.08549077808856964,
-0.6135252118110657,
1.027766466140747,
-0.2669827342033386,
-0.4283768832683563,
0.07666859030723572,
0.3922330439090729,
0.25538209080696106,
0.4512430429458618,
-0.9590402245521545,
0.19369302690029144,
0.30356067419052124,
-0.22105954587459564,
0.3088948726654053,
0.23987609148025513,
-0.20451103150844574,
0.9441823363304138,
0.38426628708839417,
-0.07424059510231018,
0.26617154479026794,
0.26998457312583923,
0.6988798379898071,
-0.5439807772636414,
-0.34506386518478394,
-0.22168178856372833,
-0.025321561843156815,
-0.31931066513061523,
-0.21014821529388428,
0.5330795049667358,
0.9491904973983765,
0.5618036389350891,
-0.013617314398288727,
0.8702149391174316,
-0.3498198688030243,
1.1444683074951172,
-0.32751426100730896,
0.20865492522716522,
-0.696958601474762,
-0.0967654436826706,
-0.2821257710456848,
-0.7596688270568848,
0.14585882425308228,
0.0901813730597496,
-0.008482435718178749,
0.20161177217960358,
0.5854076147079468,
0.6101117134094238,
0.509325385093689,
0.4321781098842621,
0.2008245438337326,
-0.21186064183712006,
0.6611221432685852,
0.7010286450386047,
0.8550257086753845,
-0.6665380597114563,
0.36755919456481934,
-0.006091542076319456,
-0.3686479926109314,
-0.42664477229118347,
-0.5563251376152039,
-0.43236973881721497,
-1.0371209383010864,
0.17625436186790466,
-0.5447066426277161,
0.1634233444929123,
1.0324751138687134,
0.7165014147758484,
-0.9203898906707764,
-0.06549017876386642,
-0.03410791978240013,
-0.1056053638458252,
0.2716176509857178,
-0.23059597611427307,
0.2281421273946762,
-0.11918210238218307,
-0.8092041611671448,
0.4738777279853821,
0.5791220664978027,
0.5042035579681396,
-0.2919534742832184,
-0.10231729596853256,
-0.11656574159860611,
-0.12755508720874786,
0.9401929378509521,
0.4021594226360321,
-0.8132335543632507,
-0.552226185798645,
0.01387016847729683,
0.006807204335927963,
-0.28724193572998047,
0.8373304605484009,
-0.8386025428771973,
0.3559597134590149,
0.36879441142082214,
0.554782509803772,
0.40809905529022217,
0.23150090873241425,
0.7190074920654297,
-0.3168998062610626,
0.5067441463470459,
0.6438118815422058,
-0.07229499518871307,
0.10722275078296661,
-0.4975299835205078,
0.5722925066947937,
0.5747004151344299,
-0.9335770606994629,
-0.9838000535964966,
0.7140132188796997,
-1.0468636751174927,
0.23569971323013306,
0.8417702317237854,
0.39355239272117615,
0.29050153493881226,
-0.718465268611908,
-0.5115571022033691,
0.05352756381034851,
-0.6506384015083313,
0.1254117488861084,
0.5091884136199951,
-0.602377712726593,
-0.5268943905830383,
-1.0777169466018677,
0.551638662815094,
0.5859380960464478,
-0.9445674419403076,
-0.11538966000080109,
0.4907427728176117,
-0.17077098786830902,
0.3731697201728821,
1.0397719144821167,
-0.5499920845031738,
0.4664202928543091,
0.19241830706596375,
-0.557503879070282,
0.03745719790458679,
-0.3936695158481598,
0.29753193259239197,
-0.06029457971453667,
-0.19378940761089325,
0.08743385225534439
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12532v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12532v2
|
PyramidInfer: Pyramid KV Cache Compression for High-throughput LLM Inference
| 2024-05-21T06:46:37 | 2024-06-05T09:01:24 |
Dongjie Yang, XiaoDong Han, Yan Gao, Yao Hu, Shilin Zhang, Hai Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable comprehension abilities
but face challenges in GPU memory usage during inference, hindering their
scalability for real-time applications like chatbots. To accelerate inference,
we store computed keys and values (KV cache) in the GPU memory. Existing
methods study the KV cache compression to reduce memory by pruning the
pre-computed KV cache. However, they neglect the inter-layer dependency between
layers and huge memory consumption in pre-computation. To explore these
deficiencies, we find that the number of crucial keys and values that influence
future generations decreases layer by layer and we can extract them by the
consistency in attention weights. Based on the findings, we propose
PyramidInfer, a method that compresses the KV cache by layer-wise retaining
crucial context. PyramidInfer saves significant memory by computing fewer keys
and values without sacrificing performance. Experimental results show
PyramidInfer improves 2.2x throughput compared to Accelerate with over 54% GPU
memory reduction in KV cache.
|
[
-0.4262123703956604,
-0.7761014699935913,
0.23079721629619598,
0.2364271730184555,
-0.09394057840108871,
-0.19095063209533691,
-0.30831974744796753,
-0.2928599417209625,
0.04372866824269295,
0.5514707565307617,
-0.2555094361305237,
-0.45452120900154114,
-0.5942764282226562,
-0.35095933079719543,
-0.35100772976875305,
0.8026793003082275,
0.29214829206466675,
0.2032339721918106,
-0.6194080114364624,
0.2842642068862915,
-0.19247668981552124,
-0.45431920886039734,
-0.7446761727333069,
-0.47738009691238403,
0.4763701558113098,
0.6935216784477234,
0.8300230503082275,
0.8140920400619507,
0.49103960394859314,
0.25780725479125977,
-0.19075147807598114,
-0.1862953156232834,
-0.6411747336387634,
0.5607092380523682,
0.20944134891033173,
-0.49881604313850403,
-0.5084617733955383,
-0.10941725969314575,
0.5957830548286438,
0.41552305221557617,
-0.1998017579317093,
0.18821574747562408,
-0.06815139949321747,
0.7176245450973511,
-1.2669554948806763,
0.15077921748161316,
-0.48864004015922546,
0.19021761417388916,
-0.16092398762702942,
-0.22496725618839264,
-0.5203961133956909,
-0.2941074073314667,
-0.04609347879886627,
-0.46849095821380615,
0.2890753149986267,
-0.14865992963314056,
0.7701303958892822,
0.6155193448066711,
-0.09469889104366302,
0.12065766006708145,
-0.6764628291130066,
0.5591791868209839,
-0.6903472542762756,
0.33429425954818726,
0.5611313581466675,
0.27875861525535583,
-0.3854925334453583,
-1.1611095666885376,
-0.6728762984275818,
-0.17865875363349915,
0.12723040580749512,
0.2169245481491089,
0.011856438592076302,
0.45815736055374146,
0.4140521287918091,
0.5800072550773621,
-0.37542152404785156,
-0.05611924082040787,
-0.31579363346099854,
-0.3280656039714813,
0.20605874061584473,
0.1197570264339447,
0.2854919135570526,
-0.34145548939704895,
-0.02702213078737259,
-0.3831027150154114,
-1.0309832096099854,
0.15068134665489197,
0.22056330740451813,
-0.12117033451795578,
0.1796976923942566,
0.44364407658576965,
-0.3888147175312042,
0.4716053009033203,
-0.03103940561413765,
-0.1852940171957016,
-0.11017566174268723,
-0.022155210375785828,
-0.6450113654136658,
0.22614724934101105,
0.6011483073234558,
0.2319755256175995,
0.38881930708885193,
-0.30651751160621643,
0.26161089539527893,
0.2777038514614105,
0.410461962223053,
-1.4261808395385742,
-0.5651665925979614,
0.512163519859314,
-0.5395440459251404,
-0.21499045193195343,
-0.24909546971321106,
-0.9742322564125061,
-0.363906592130661,
0.2377883493900299,
0.18845492601394653,
-0.14473189413547516,
0.168512761592865,
0.2858816385269165,
-0.3476243019104004,
0.2074863761663437,
0.40036100149154663,
-0.9917160868644714,
0.47547242045402527,
0.5731322765350342,
0.7828388810157776,
-0.07290299236774445,
0.0005825470434501767,
-0.8691775798797607,
0.21707075834274292,
-0.04004896432161331,
0.7617564797401428,
-0.8029336929321289,
-0.36166325211524963,
-0.1081790030002594,
-0.19631227850914001,
0.23309452831745148,
-0.7008383870124817,
0.6342516541481018,
-0.605681836605072,
-0.1633693128824234,
-0.16860488057136536,
-0.49909961223602295,
-0.1656210720539093,
0.08355385810136795,
-0.8240444660186768,
1.2061495780944824,
-0.1296493262052536,
-0.7104452252388,
0.13112466037273407,
-0.19845157861709595,
-0.5530663728713989,
0.18458940088748932,
-0.18157032132148743,
-0.4301188588142395,
0.20523624122142792,
0.5876764059066772,
0.7274678349494934,
-0.6052957773208618,
-0.04820362851023674,
-0.3134077191352844,
-0.524345874786377,
0.09494884312152863,
-0.21890529990196228,
0.5205966234207153,
0.04180773347616196,
-0.24685315787792206,
-0.016681315377354622,
-0.5746563673019409,
0.18383926153182983,
-0.12145644426345825,
-0.3427965044975281,
-0.10477200150489807,
0.17447304725646973,
-0.08045697957277298,
0.26647835969924927,
0.05999235436320305,
-0.3795948624610901,
0.4659799635410309,
-0.15319879353046417,
0.7377536296844482,
0.7016825675964355,
-0.15205632150173187,
0.5780791640281677,
-0.12640869617462158,
0.4987472593784332,
0.0054442803375422955,
0.25801995396614075,
-0.04638924077153206,
-0.48669862747192383,
-1.0909219980239868,
-0.3519667685031891,
0.37371712923049927,
0.5069334506988525,
-0.5285733342170715,
0.028817813843488693,
-0.6307804584503174,
-0.4104200601577759,
-0.5692334175109863,
0.02409568428993225,
0.3007253408432007,
0.6175890564918518,
0.31545811891555786,
-0.3905293047428131,
-0.4094623029232025,
-0.9225905537605286,
-0.01851712353527546,
-0.31327277421951294,
-0.12272593379020691,
0.6052032113075256,
0.4990813732147217,
-0.058012329041957855,
0.5736847519874573,
-0.39765170216560364,
0.036759790033102036,
0.004301955923438072,
-0.003868924919515848,
0.057531360536813736,
0.6059743165969849,
0.09281183779239655,
-0.5802614688873291,
-0.4584956169128418,
-0.18731200695037842,
-0.44977208971977234,
-0.050871990621089935,
-0.09139158576726913,
-0.08677467703819275,
-0.11640285700559616,
0.5007951855659485,
-1.026050329208374,
0.6021401882171631,
0.668297290802002,
-0.021846700459718704,
0.5588085055351257,
-0.2164405882358551,
0.24508443474769592,
-0.7027730941772461,
-0.09590514004230499,
-0.24224363267421722,
-0.30312392115592957,
-0.5475373268127441,
-0.15887856483459473,
0.32659822702407837,
0.13375622034072876,
-0.3481391370296478,
0.6273493766784668,
-0.3946230113506317,
-0.1693548858165741,
-0.3379451036453247,
-0.019909972324967384,
-0.04071276634931564,
0.6073079705238342,
-0.016169562935829163,
1.1996663808822632,
0.6646357774734497,
-0.841569721698761,
0.38056984543800354,
0.2090943306684494,
-0.5398154854774475,
0.2199733853340149,
-0.7460513710975647,
0.2766362726688385,
-0.07298137247562408,
0.5064480900764465,
-1.0303722620010376,
-0.2122403383255005,
0.4204118847846985,
-0.5612707138061523,
0.26946473121643066,
-0.36386963725090027,
-0.6517252326011658,
-0.23311203718185425,
-0.36721834540367126,
0.46875736117362976,
0.7595423460006714,
-0.5226795673370361,
0.7207352519035339,
0.40253931283950806,
-0.07422889024019241,
-0.9302850961685181,
-0.7080835103988647,
0.2313418984413147,
-0.053753942251205444,
-0.810310423374176,
0.6834260821342468,
-0.06238513067364693,
-0.13717566430568695,
-0.0035324387717992067,
-0.33462926745414734,
0.005870372988283634,
-0.0594438835978508,
0.5916046500205994,
-0.010974823497235775,
-0.2521910071372986,
0.22607356309890747,
0.11301777511835098,
-0.2106529176235199,
-0.044946037232875824,
-0.5162177681922913,
0.6342813372612,
-0.06636868417263031,
-0.07873570173978806,
-0.4591088891029358,
0.1764930784702301,
0.6494158506393433,
0.04367808997631073,
0.8305906057357788,
0.4378957450389862,
-0.4011036455631256,
-0.3098262548446655,
-0.7104074358940125,
-0.4110768735408783,
-0.4811922609806061,
0.2717989981174469,
-0.3915417790412903,
-0.9196329116821289,
0.6649762988090515,
-0.35676172375679016,
-0.19122309982776642,
0.24836552143096924,
0.7055240869522095,
-0.12199681997299194,
0.6954358816146851,
0.28909653425216675,
-0.3887523412704468,
0.5023466348648071,
-0.26855313777923584,
0.045468639582395554,
-0.9587016701698303,
-0.1067650094628334,
-0.6880752444267273,
-0.5150681734085083,
-0.30111175775527954,
-0.5949073433876038,
0.23403599858283997,
0.43971922993659973,
-0.2702961266040802,
0.07365383207798004,
-0.35938945412635803,
0.6576167345046997,
0.5726439952850342,
0.27986904978752136,
0.21691522002220154,
0.12278357148170471,
0.004960570950061083,
-0.009075045585632324,
-0.7909436225891113,
-0.23799142241477966,
1.121774435043335,
-0.008761133998632431,
0.9616666436195374,
-0.14568358659744263,
0.20665444433689117,
0.34398630261421204,
0.34201109409332275,
-0.7846154570579529,
0.6223925352096558,
0.18028655648231506,
-0.5500038266181946,
-0.29971668124198914,
-0.4426107108592987,
-0.8282099962234497,
0.3165033459663391,
-0.17091454565525055,
-0.98381108045578,
-0.16229291260242462,
0.31995654106140137,
-0.41501083970069885,
0.22574187815189362,
-0.4289109706878662,
0.7432106137275696,
0.18537385761737823,
-0.6705276966094971,
-0.5411801338195801,
-0.6884137988090515,
0.2908417880535126,
0.4024839699268341,
-0.31560567021369934,
0.1268138885498047,
-0.05682925507426262,
0.5724440217018127,
-0.5872219204902649,
0.7272197008132935,
0.12267778068780899,
0.10178779065608978,
0.1481124311685562,
0.06051604449748993,
0.960965096950531,
0.37759122252464294,
0.00673403637483716,
0.20323270559310913,
-0.2824041247367859,
-0.6849565505981445,
-0.9001621007919312,
0.7985258102416992,
-0.8030346632003784,
-0.7487409710884094,
-0.23967112600803375,
-0.5018005967140198,
-0.05884302780032158,
-0.07953691482543945,
0.29392656683921814,
0.24294158816337585,
0.05249908193945885,
0.2818067669868469,
0.9629839658737183,
-0.22923164069652557,
0.45909982919692993,
-0.1319916844367981,
0.16803854703903198,
-0.5590037107467651,
0.4376365542411804,
0.004295495338737965,
0.3005601167678833,
0.5677735805511475,
0.164301335811615,
0.01140584610402584,
-0.7951787710189819,
-0.43247097730636597,
0.10279292613267899,
-0.8320583701133728,
-0.2845817804336548,
-0.746231198310852,
-0.3170614540576935,
-0.4064267575740814,
-0.19972661137580872,
-0.6015729904174805,
-0.607440710067749,
-0.050552405416965485,
0.1524888426065445,
0.4482041001319885,
0.26507723331451416,
0.07925306260585785,
0.8468095064163208,
-0.748446524143219,
0.3522709906101227,
0.25853291153907776,
0.19223237037658691,
0.2653086483478546,
-0.47545140981674194,
-0.35888996720314026,
-0.07487408071756363,
-0.1867484599351883,
-0.6037189960479736,
0.39493879675865173,
0.25835511088371277,
0.393267422914505,
0.5854688286781311,
-0.02749728038907051,
1.1051692962646484,
-0.38392505049705505,
0.7146146297454834,
0.06968314945697784,
-0.9848219752311707,
0.19937485456466675,
0.01945168524980545,
0.47029680013656616,
0.35781869292259216,
0.2731384336948395,
-0.7790859937667847,
-0.2012813836336136,
-0.5104641318321228,
-0.7579986453056335,
0.41768157482147217,
0.34240201115608215,
0.13318723440170288,
0.014355568215250969,
0.7460352182388306,
-0.04438268020749092,
0.11942433565855026,
-0.576686441898346,
-0.49147829413414,
-0.07293901592493057,
0.005829330068081617,
0.11779424548149109,
-0.4440081715583801,
0.11285450309515,
-0.5084724426269531,
0.5801921486854553,
0.06719952076673508,
0.4473245441913605,
0.1831342577934265,
-0.3041245937347412,
0.013685906305909157,
0.09010680764913559,
0.5536710619926453,
0.4060564339160919,
-0.145895853638649,
0.4846607446670532,
0.1199178621172905,
-1.0146671533584595,
-0.0024843267165124416,
-0.10747365653514862,
-0.24602654576301575,
-0.3293828070163727,
0.1274326741695404,
0.5891751646995544,
0.15661807358264923,
-0.5858878493309021,
0.3726702332496643,
-0.45416560769081116,
-0.0002694143040571362,
-0.2913517653942108,
0.35001567006111145,
0.4077596068382263,
0.4328596591949463,
0.20419993996620178,
-0.02040936052799225,
0.03397171199321747,
-0.11508408188819885,
0.0951930359005928,
0.5110921859741211,
-0.3034534752368927,
-0.0911761224269867,
0.6010046601295471,
0.16603298485279083,
-0.11480315029621124,
1.095691204071045,
0.19356150925159454,
-0.38064855337142944,
0.6446164846420288,
0.4424615502357483,
0.764794647693634,
-0.20639660954475403,
-0.10932695865631104,
0.44331586360931396,
0.11902159452438354,
-0.3036763072013855,
0.07713793963193893,
-0.5084553956985474,
-0.8321099281311035,
-0.7955267429351807,
-0.5454415678977966,
-0.2007165104150772,
0.4096710681915283,
-0.4253028631210327,
0.0293424092233181,
-0.5069632530212402,
-0.15216223895549774,
-0.007450048811733723,
0.08128400146961212,
-0.38181278109550476,
0.10335827618837357,
0.036479245871305466,
0.8212236762046814,
-0.36951929330825806,
1.2856619358062744,
0.2003001868724823,
-0.22672413289546967,
-0.1900479793548584,
-0.14226798713207245,
-0.21418936550617218,
-0.694031298160553,
0.9135526418685913,
0.1050635576248169,
-0.15098866820335388,
0.08139269798994064,
-0.7848644852638245,
-0.8220646977424622,
0.9915325045585632,
0.5022845268249512,
-0.47040754556655884,
0.014132901094853878,
-0.010178115218877792,
0.14985090494155884,
-0.09776380658149719,
0.4729214906692505,
0.48325014114379883,
0.5601497888565063,
0.2940256893634796,
-0.5840245485305786,
0.04258003458380699,
-0.49775269627571106,
-0.013569041155278683,
0.3664603531360626,
-0.4152674973011017,
0.8740675449371338,
-0.232133686542511,
-0.3699459731578827,
0.07253243774175644,
0.9508999586105347,
0.0815265104174614,
-0.1639164537191391,
0.16473811864852905,
0.7974279522895813,
0.8094781041145325,
0.03362857922911644,
1.1318479776382446,
-0.4312151074409485,
0.16856999695301056,
1.0273849964141846,
0.044598568230867386,
0.8487191200256348,
0.7112405300140381,
-0.025290220975875854,
0.4352649450302124,
0.7774744629859924,
0.1537608653306961,
0.568153977394104,
0.48970186710357666,
-0.5625470280647278,
-0.521797776222229,
0.14420415461063385,
-0.32732197642326355,
0.2415069043636322,
0.5338606238365173,
-0.2234073281288147,
-0.011558287777006626,
-0.22584888339042664,
0.30463138222694397,
-0.5256637334823608,
-0.36609047651290894,
0.4913163185119629,
0.13838914036750793,
-0.8642899394035339,
0.7099815011024475,
-0.09269952028989792,
0.49629083275794983,
-0.39306333661079407,
-0.17682039737701416,
-0.20497924089431763,
0.42687124013900757,
-0.13205865025520325,
-0.3187394142150879,
-0.1737636923789978,
-0.3265543282032013,
-0.3156644105911255,
-0.11985812336206436,
0.9202957153320312,
-0.35696467757225037,
-0.21638742089271545,
0.1943627893924713,
0.2900347411632538,
0.19051200151443481,
-0.4025062620639801,
-0.4141407907009125,
-0.012881633825600147,
-0.3151378333568573,
-0.5269991159439087,
0.4717787504196167,
0.16161955893039703,
0.07926180958747864,
1.023149847984314,
0.7148704528808594,
0.3696499168872833,
0.3189166486263275,
-0.04902717471122742,
0.9830138683319092,
-0.6971226334571838,
-0.31459981203079224,
-1.0737392902374268,
0.3553178608417511,
-0.14887402951717377,
-0.2064729928970337,
0.7244049310684204,
0.458569198846817,
0.7504926323890686,
-0.06480219960212708,
0.8621195554733276,
0.10711611062288284,
-0.39901334047317505,
-0.6010681986808777,
0.729561984539032,
-0.3444652557373047,
0.028034314513206482,
-0.06016405671834946,
-0.7754244208335876,
-0.48601770401000977,
0.7431976795196533,
-0.17056868970394135,
-0.043753866106271744,
0.7819703817367554,
0.981568455696106,
-0.1404958814382553,
0.05383982136845589,
0.324020653963089,
0.2500867545604706,
0.28887122869491577,
0.8585571646690369,
0.6756596565246582,
-0.5989789366722107,
0.662731945514679,
-0.14655348658561707,
-0.03540987893939018,
-0.36861175298690796,
-0.9142810106277466,
-1.0952208042144775,
-0.4402572810649872,
-0.27189698815345764,
-0.6263992190361023,
0.16237761080265045,
0.49679577350616455,
0.9733787178993225,
-0.6346353888511658,
-0.3186294436454773,
-0.36156874895095825,
0.17497988045215607,
-0.29084575176239014,
-0.1538095325231552,
0.4627968966960907,
-0.28309279680252075,
-0.7244135141372681,
0.12710212171077728,
0.5058526992797852,
-0.1526135355234146,
-0.33762139081954956,
-0.3334923982620239,
-0.012021692469716072,
0.03616628050804138,
0.4651835858821869,
0.2916031777858734,
-0.6810299158096313,
-0.21804313361644745,
-0.02457192912697792,
-0.3039591610431671,
0.4636465907096863,
1.1890490055084229,
-1.1178416013717651,
0.3191046118736267,
0.9027453064918518,
0.8895734548568726,
1.2082719802856445,
-0.23551544547080994,
0.6187298893928528,
-0.3858240246772766,
0.3104638457298279,
0.1538999080657959,
0.4683009386062622,
0.03983800858259201,
-0.452792763710022,
0.26663118600845337,
0.1169501319527626,
-0.6843172311782837,
-0.49420279264450073,
0.26079875230789185,
-0.9866290092468262,
-0.3645387291908264,
1.1437246799468994,
-0.05478622019290924,
-0.4647018015384674,
-0.14222565293312073,
0.04878038540482521,
0.28181737661361694,
-0.4687660336494446,
1.021481990814209,
0.933215320110321,
-0.029363607987761497,
-0.6098875999450684,
-0.7801447510719299,
0.7972201704978943,
0.4620210826396942,
-0.7399270534515381,
0.23492884635925293,
0.3640773594379425,
-0.12835419178009033,
-0.08419155329465866,
0.689812421798706,
0.010818452574312687,
0.3407190144062042,
0.23176120221614838,
0.27330854535102844,
0.09302181750535965,
-0.4322420656681061,
-0.06750664114952087,
0.4262916147708893,
-0.2707679271697998,
-0.025962240993976593
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.