id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12528v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12528v1
|
SirLLM: Streaming Infinite Retentive LLM
| 2024-05-21T06:37:03 | 2024-05-21T06:37:03 |
Yao Yao, Zuchao Li, Hai Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) become increasingly prevalent in various
domains, their ability to process inputs of any length and maintain a degree of
memory becomes essential. However, the one-off input of overly long texts is
limited, as studies have shown that when input lengths exceed the LLMs'
pre-trained text length, there is a dramatic decline in text generation
capabilities. Moreover, simply extending the length of pre-training texts is
impractical due to the difficulty in obtaining long text data and the
substantial memory consumption costs this would entail for LLMs. Recent efforts
have employed streaming inputs to alleviate the pressure of excessively long
text inputs, but this approach can significantly impair the model's long-term
memory capabilities.
Motivated by this challenge, we introduce Streaming Infinite Retentive LLM
(SirLLM), which allows LLMs to maintain longer memory during infinite-length
dialogues without the need for fine-tuning. SirLLM utilizes the Token Entropy
metric and a memory decay mechanism to filter key phrases, endowing LLMs with
both long-lasting and flexible memory. We designed three distinct tasks and
constructed three datasets to measure the effectiveness of SirLLM from various
angles: (1) DailyDialog; (2) Grocery Shopping; (3) Rock-Paper-Scissors. Our
experimental results robustly demonstrate that SirLLM can achieve stable and
significant improvements across different LLMs and tasks, compellingly proving
its effectiveness. When having a coversation, "A sir could forget himself," but
SirLLM never does! Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/Zoeyyao27/SirLLM
|
[
-0.06764006614685059,
-0.8261047005653381,
0.6181681156158447,
0.15146641433238983,
-0.5138628482818604,
0.31272852420806885,
-0.46504804491996765,
-0.26992741227149963,
0.3771352767944336,
0.5623770952224731,
-0.4915965795516968,
-0.29618579149246216,
-0.46223294734954834,
-0.032925523817539215,
-0.5049134492874146,
0.9497874975204468,
-0.3317304849624634,
-0.02022269181907177,
-0.6043895483016968,
-0.23361197113990784,
-0.5314542651176453,
-0.42356422543525696,
-0.7574774026870728,
-0.3764435648918152,
0.8223812580108643,
0.4153229892253876,
0.6295806765556335,
0.508195161819458,
0.5310390591621399,
0.21715384721755981,
0.02111472375690937,
0.40902242064476013,
-1.0476378202438354,
0.6797357201576233,
0.13465002179145813,
-0.4185788333415985,
-0.2589848041534424,
-0.15053534507751465,
1.0135035514831543,
0.15213268995285034,
-0.23080869019031525,
0.25078409910202026,
-0.010003346018493176,
0.7305362224578857,
-0.6592469215393066,
-0.08947195112705231,
-0.8862243890762329,
0.06072205677628517,
-0.2570509910583496,
-0.4093019366264343,
-0.2753564119338989,
-0.20485319197177887,
-0.017618434503674507,
-0.27626803517341614,
-0.1370936781167984,
0.09264283627271652,
0.6577759385108948,
0.49716994166374207,
0.21472002565860748,
-0.2313535362482071,
-0.86150723695755,
0.7290859222412109,
-0.8933786749839783,
0.41757869720458984,
0.616974413394928,
0.11910665780305862,
-0.06080228462815285,
-0.45664355158805847,
-0.5371758341789246,
-0.464853972196579,
0.28484606742858887,
0.37185877561569214,
0.19619698822498322,
-0.0943354070186615,
-0.017270255833864212,
0.24960877001285553,
-0.5105577707290649,
0.2270834594964981,
-0.41175028681755066,
0.07168697565793991,
0.576673686504364,
0.2951560318470001,
0.25449153780937195,
0.03264964371919632,
-0.3736668527126312,
0.35713693499565125,
-0.7402152419090271,
-0.1741679459810257,
0.2520516812801361,
0.0706813782453537,
-0.04044964164495468,
0.39463186264038086,
0.05976501479744911,
0.40564602613449097,
-0.3058971166610718,
-0.3602549731731415,
0.0643022358417511,
0.0030774406623095274,
-0.2047680765390396,
-0.03685646131634712,
0.7376108169555664,
0.15770620107650757,
0.13707014918327332,
-0.2605849802494049,
-0.1537788063287735,
-0.47909000515937805,
0.4023815095424652,
-0.8120884299278259,
-0.12964162230491638,
0.3292124569416046,
-0.13548196852207184,
-0.05326249450445175,
-0.2277766317129135,
-0.4162192642688751,
-0.13998648524284363,
-0.07400903850793839,
0.42246535420417786,
-0.47852393984794617,
-0.06363549828529358,
0.06524242460727692,
-0.01714927703142166,
0.2319696992635727,
0.22142568230628967,
-0.7773423790931702,
0.02787856012582779,
0.5252586007118225,
1.0401707887649536,
-0.5234375596046448,
-0.506566047668457,
-0.6163707375526428,
0.49847710132598877,
-0.2049064040184021,
0.6662769913673401,
-0.5743122100830078,
-0.44172123074531555,
-0.03258717432618141,
-0.20932267606258392,
-0.17876620590686798,
-0.6002755761146545,
0.49949362874031067,
-0.5203819274902344,
0.2111569344997406,
0.13211652636528015,
-0.8252775073051453,
-0.014797124080359936,
0.4345146417617798,
-0.41012316942214966,
0.8429027795791626,
-0.03865958750247955,
-0.5422868728637695,
0.05524715408682823,
-0.46860620379447937,
-0.37473049759864807,
0.28850510716438293,
-0.20935139060020447,
-0.7389434576034546,
0.32653313875198364,
-0.08727995306253433,
0.548071563243866,
-0.35136672854423523,
0.42175957560539246,
-0.4756845533847809,
-0.4609430432319641,
0.46004626154899597,
-0.7052078247070312,
0.18677125871181488,
0.13161815702915192,
-0.10081761330366135,
0.09589873999357224,
-0.4050036370754242,
-0.0028993263840675354,
0.2771507203578949,
-0.7179669737815857,
-0.017418431118130684,
0.2434467375278473,
0.0030326342675834894,
-0.11855614930391312,
0.16022580862045288,
-0.5167930126190186,
-0.08161702752113342,
-0.2991170585155487,
0.9133466482162476,
0.8104436993598938,
-0.26281729340553284,
0.15479613840579987,
-0.5820751786231995,
0.6788406372070312,
-0.21646052598953247,
0.06634948402643204,
-0.5306853652000427,
-0.10904721915721893,
-0.895179033279419,
-0.5401507019996643,
0.3064570128917694,
0.5440250039100647,
-0.506144106388092,
0.16628864407539368,
-0.45699623227119446,
-0.206032857298851,
-0.35190343856811523,
0.4945705533027649,
0.27538001537323,
0.30049121379852295,
0.29188111424446106,
-0.16409896314144135,
-0.4025878608226776,
-0.83331298828125,
-0.15159685909748077,
-0.21943753957748413,
0.09368665516376495,
0.44778016209602356,
0.33050546050071716,
-0.42137610912323,
0.9689956903457642,
-0.4350219964981079,
-0.2891366183757782,
-0.3843107223510742,
-0.08761768043041229,
-0.09427884221076965,
0.4620310068130493,
0.11171653121709824,
-0.47416365146636963,
-0.2570006549358368,
-0.3953571617603302,
-0.7003498673439026,
0.08484628051519394,
-0.5924459099769592,
0.013719271868467331,
0.16751259565353394,
0.5543786883354187,
-0.861921489238739,
0.3984752893447876,
0.34668734669685364,
0.14857186377048492,
0.6406926512718201,
-0.42302408814430237,
-0.24981392920017242,
-0.9059442281723022,
-0.18363691866397858,
-0.3375486135482788,
-0.5727767944335938,
-0.42308199405670166,
0.203976109623909,
0.11755750328302383,
-0.1967286914587021,
-0.5871115922927856,
0.6924526691436768,
-0.48573485016822815,
0.20170550048351288,
-0.4615754187107086,
0.22283869981765747,
0.013531810604035854,
0.4670443832874298,
-0.041497863829135895,
0.8017958998680115,
0.30528733134269714,
-0.40688371658325195,
0.3931148648262024,
0.08043107390403748,
-0.2623124122619629,
0.23907461762428284,
-0.6612170934677124,
0.2101900726556778,
-0.34881365299224854,
0.2782014310359955,
-1.1898597478866577,
-0.10660295188426971,
0.19623279571533203,
-0.48136088252067566,
0.7091313004493713,
0.2591242492198944,
-0.39072468876838684,
-0.404903382062912,
-0.4842927157878876,
0.2943124771118164,
0.5850359201431274,
-0.47495079040527344,
0.6466779708862305,
0.28837063908576965,
-0.3256579637527466,
-0.2566874921321869,
-0.6849694848060608,
0.4772341549396515,
-0.493135541677475,
-0.3425513505935669,
0.3042084574699402,
-0.3866826891899109,
0.08126546442508698,
-0.16116207838058472,
-0.26132380962371826,
-0.0018022141885012388,
0.007057179231196642,
0.41017141938209534,
0.19982077181339264,
-0.01429794356226921,
0.3817155957221985,
0.051978949457407,
-0.07004931569099426,
0.17117537558078766,
-0.3383767902851105,
0.5751183032989502,
0.08138354122638702,
-0.4155780076980591,
-0.4843975007534027,
0.5281053185462952,
0.7305970788002014,
-0.015453999862074852,
0.7297210097312927,
0.6050274968147278,
-0.14735646545886993,
-0.27937737107276917,
-0.9094302654266357,
-0.03747088834643364,
-0.4755280613899231,
0.4501604735851288,
-0.3119397461414337,
-1.3351386785507202,
0.5719785690307617,
-0.026530414819717407,
0.10191512107849121,
0.05650985240936279,
0.4667234718799591,
-0.6161043643951416,
0.6243776679039001,
0.2786758244037628,
-0.33360087871551514,
0.3369978368282318,
-0.21985912322998047,
0.22884486615657806,
-0.9599993228912354,
-0.13114559650421143,
-0.19880762696266174,
-0.40422219038009644,
0.038658902049064636,
-0.5908884406089783,
0.11526209861040115,
0.25284695625305176,
-0.31936025619506836,
0.04192233085632324,
-0.16027946770191193,
0.6243292093276978,
0.3637048900127411,
0.19633112847805023,
-0.04260355234146118,
-0.051888659596443176,
-0.1709124892950058,
-0.11875243484973907,
-0.7972729206085205,
-0.35921362042427063,
0.9277005791664124,
0.6249633431434631,
0.9961652755737305,
0.004038626328110695,
0.8381767272949219,
0.3950898051261902,
0.24650391936302185,
-0.809031069278717,
0.7546152472496033,
-0.11146194487810135,
-0.2487906962633133,
-0.5303205251693726,
-0.4784955084323883,
-0.8118247389793396,
0.010387441143393517,
0.07066874951124191,
-0.4142240285873413,
-0.3970435857772827,
0.206111341714859,
-0.4160175621509552,
0.5529548525810242,
-0.44053393602371216,
0.4054565727710724,
-0.7059176564216614,
-0.641415536403656,
-0.2620811462402344,
-0.4653799831867218,
0.3392146825790405,
-0.2978067696094513,
0.07298963516950607,
-0.40733402967453003,
-0.17084525525569916,
0.7193357944488525,
-0.3891143798828125,
0.9613234996795654,
0.0052557154558598995,
0.01781879924237728,
0.2099098265171051,
0.13283783197402954,
0.5932319760322571,
0.3336299955844879,
0.3400222957134247,
0.1688869148492813,
-0.2141195684671402,
-0.4233665466308594,
-0.530773401260376,
0.988284707069397,
-0.7754045724868774,
-0.8767037987709045,
-0.1882799118757248,
-0.6335158944129944,
-0.17839495837688446,
0.08012573421001434,
0.04456416144967079,
0.29292747378349304,
-0.1328209489583969,
0.3377845585346222,
0.8646446466445923,
-0.2845441401004791,
0.6161771416664124,
0.41577062010765076,
-0.3519742488861084,
-0.692164421081543,
1.0223664045333862,
0.06570398807525635,
0.40634334087371826,
0.45205071568489075,
0.23248209059238434,
-0.4901355504989624,
-0.8251386284828186,
-0.4557115435600281,
0.43081972002983093,
-0.42582112550735474,
-0.3943570852279663,
-0.7241162657737732,
-0.4500062167644501,
-0.15877337753772736,
-0.15689077973365784,
-0.3235704302787781,
-0.3388116657733917,
-0.6597237586975098,
-0.20507268607616425,
0.42600613832473755,
0.30491265654563904,
-0.03698461875319481,
0.27087661623954773,
-0.8162941336631775,
0.43356701731681824,
0.593000590801239,
0.36266466975212097,
0.05647575855255127,
-0.8220781683921814,
-0.31560981273651123,
-0.0517071932554245,
-0.2769164443016052,
-0.4988373816013336,
0.5068826079368591,
0.5769758820533752,
0.6203051209449768,
0.5218968391418457,
-0.11155691742897034,
0.9996063113212585,
-0.7444714903831482,
0.7362846732139587,
0.5319141149520874,
-0.7415605187416077,
0.2659527659416199,
-0.42268550395965576,
0.7731277346611023,
0.6208552718162537,
0.341483473777771,
-0.6063656210899353,
-0.645541250705719,
-0.265860915184021,
-0.986595094203949,
0.26801666617393494,
0.1328115016222,
0.6403450965881348,
-0.18454328179359436,
0.5495900511741638,
0.08951790630817413,
0.15594197809696198,
-0.5602925419807434,
-0.0887795016169548,
-0.27009180188179016,
-0.03630678728222847,
-0.14202724397182465,
-0.7847837805747986,
0.16988389194011688,
-0.2757416069507599,
0.6078022718429565,
0.008515593595802784,
0.25730186700820923,
0.14150086045265198,
-0.21915774047374725,
0.07535767555236816,
0.3033812642097473,
0.900149405002594,
0.7943012714385986,
-0.3854329288005829,
0.24473042786121368,
0.3240877389907837,
-0.4791671633720398,
0.015111581422388554,
-0.17779259383678436,
-0.2697652578353882,
-0.021289316937327385,
0.25064897537231445,
0.8921155333518982,
0.4572763442993164,
-1.1136244535446167,
0.08706075698137283,
-0.01570577174425125,
-0.4718855917453766,
-0.6915727257728577,
0.19144226610660553,
0.616378128528595,
0.044039901345968246,
0.3877807557582855,
-0.2618566155433655,
-0.27424880862236023,
-0.4964524209499359,
0.2954575717449188,
0.5604066252708435,
-0.49738749861717224,
-0.039396706968545914,
0.9153951406478882,
0.16724546253681183,
-0.4921467900276184,
0.8277202844619751,
-0.12209346145391464,
-0.5734841823577881,
0.2506808340549469,
0.7125150561332703,
1.0700827836990356,
-0.12223737686872482,
0.1663110852241516,
0.21801337599754333,
0.20258045196533203,
0.019432203844189644,
0.08561026304960251,
-0.27073201537132263,
-0.6866251230239868,
-0.5774499773979187,
-0.7363502383232117,
-0.2308223694562912,
0.3857453167438507,
-0.43805113434791565,
-0.21985968947410583,
-0.49903276562690735,
-0.2505769729614258,
-0.395309716463089,
-0.2512606382369995,
-0.36990025639533997,
-0.01998298615217209,
0.2636382281780243,
0.863239049911499,
-0.3590383231639862,
0.9419740438461304,
0.2791770100593567,
-0.05736427381634712,
-0.3896583318710327,
-0.13321040570735931,
-0.06952988356351852,
-1.0443731546401978,
0.5969521999359131,
0.31837961077690125,
-0.3073507249355316,
-0.07633712142705917,
-0.5670493245124817,
-0.7991888523101807,
1.056663155555725,
0.2530074715614319,
-0.7824695110321045,
0.004951097536832094,
0.32117021083831787,
0.27406632900238037,
-0.40658387541770935,
0.22233638167381287,
0.5353392958641052,
0.34833434224128723,
0.3170332610607147,
-0.7207947373390198,
-0.18215636909008026,
-0.1413542628288269,
0.19392968714237213,
0.2901255786418915,
-0.8426244258880615,
0.4695780575275421,
-0.3382605016231537,
-0.23261791467666626,
0.16944335401058197,
0.7379717230796814,
0.41190338134765625,
0.1715753972530365,
0.3570661246776581,
0.8628263473510742,
0.5686829090118408,
0.16978831589221954,
0.6958458423614502,
-0.11492788791656494,
0.15336979925632477,
1.448949933052063,
-0.4456121325492859,
1.0740584135055542,
0.561812162399292,
-0.12267603725194931,
0.1245904192328453,
0.5309115648269653,
0.17863820493221283,
0.32487180829048157,
0.6200824975967407,
-0.31265008449554443,
-0.4642620086669922,
-0.1357278674840927,
-0.27581456303596497,
0.3368110954761505,
0.39786556363105774,
-0.2082538604736328,
-0.11533030867576599,
0.26768758893013,
0.1773594468832016,
-0.0019014830468222499,
-0.26981738209724426,
0.6990537047386169,
0.29555585980415344,
-0.2976601719856262,
0.9117106795310974,
-0.1885939985513687,
0.8346286416053772,
-0.7779743671417236,
0.28929540514945984,
-0.4314306378364563,
0.10662892460823059,
0.026277434080839157,
-0.5517299771308899,
0.3427163362503052,
0.004760666284710169,
-0.33376580476760864,
-0.3753582239151001,
0.7271987795829773,
-0.6064774990081787,
-0.5421661734580994,
0.1892843246459961,
0.49967774748802185,
0.33783045411109924,
0.05062525346875191,
-0.8286142349243164,
0.3048059642314911,
0.128659188747406,
-0.23674112558364868,
0.5117239356040955,
0.002695349045097828,
0.2688315808773041,
1.1531462669372559,
0.6561133861541748,
0.36523789167404175,
0.13370400667190552,
0.03710790351033211,
0.7693254351615906,
-0.7947503924369812,
-0.2596391439437866,
-1.038620114326477,
0.19511710107326508,
0.06869183480739594,
-0.2037087082862854,
0.8778057098388672,
0.7282285690307617,
0.6589477062225342,
-0.009396979585289955,
0.6869466304779053,
0.38908621668815613,
0.49786511063575745,
-0.5323821306228638,
0.7791500091552734,
-0.5892828106880188,
0.28420332074165344,
0.13920556008815765,
-0.7164782285690308,
-0.2750784158706665,
0.3853725492954254,
-0.18416400253772736,
-0.12662525475025177,
0.5577782392501831,
0.5009984374046326,
0.12339279055595398,
-0.014682292938232422,
0.5006353855133057,
0.17149078845977783,
0.33901044726371765,
0.6732062697410583,
1.177444338798523,
-0.03241616487503052,
0.5066185593605042,
0.18185190856456757,
0.16331826150417328,
-0.19684377312660217,
-0.850621223449707,
-0.9924344420433044,
-0.37380456924438477,
-0.3879694640636444,
0.08660455793142319,
0.2227828949689865,
0.6454839706420898,
0.8727623224258423,
-0.5450456142425537,
-0.2989635765552521,
0.08001629263162613,
0.10810088366270065,
0.05261409282684326,
-0.1882123500108719,
0.2740676701068878,
-0.5953819751739502,
-0.4509464204311371,
0.5097562670707703,
0.8072419762611389,
0.14782382547855377,
-0.4996758699417114,
-0.2075681835412979,
-0.11611814796924591,
0.2271536886692047,
0.7214378118515015,
0.3887089788913727,
-0.779019296169281,
-0.20108294486999512,
-0.08982092887163162,
0.18894748389720917,
0.13984686136245728,
0.7962475419044495,
-0.7208092212677002,
0.4798140823841095,
0.35364285111427307,
0.991349995136261,
0.646175742149353,
-0.10637455433607101,
0.36518728733062744,
-0.4747122526168823,
-0.12327452003955841,
0.3113958537578583,
0.236562117934227,
0.21226488053798676,
-0.28348782658576965,
0.18275631964206696,
-0.02945610322058201,
-0.804050624370575,
-0.9391964077949524,
0.07709486037492752,
-0.9311596155166626,
-0.5177150368690491,
1.044416069984436,
-0.15645304322242737,
-0.13906973600387573,
-0.06033674627542496,
-0.018091237172484398,
-0.10138415545225143,
-0.4521658718585968,
0.7816023230552673,
0.6515352129936218,
-0.011432850733399391,
-0.5022781491279602,
-0.7000372409820557,
0.29350268840789795,
0.6284833550453186,
-0.6607290506362915,
0.12517140805721283,
0.42469510436058044,
0.3050644099712372,
-0.0961582139134407,
0.8153087496757507,
0.15502780675888062,
-0.03924518823623657,
-0.40291711688041687,
-0.3398650288581848,
-0.3760407269001007,
-0.4911253750324249,
-0.22663941979408264,
0.229678675532341,
0.06440772861242294,
-0.21065598726272583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12522v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12522v1
|
Sparse Autoencoders Enable Scalable and Reliable Circuit Identification in Language Models
| 2024-05-21T06:26:10 | 2024-05-21T06:26:10 |
Charles O'Neill, Thang Bui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces an efficient and robust method for discovering
interpretable circuits in large language models using discrete sparse
autoencoders. Our approach addresses key limitations of existing techniques,
namely computational complexity and sensitivity to hyperparameters. We propose
training sparse autoencoders on carefully designed positive and negative
examples, where the model can only correctly predict the next token for the
positive examples. We hypothesise that learned representations of attention
head outputs will signal when a head is engaged in specific computations. By
discretising the learned representations into integer codes and measuring the
overlap between codes unique to positive examples for each head, we enable
direct identification of attention heads involved in circuits without the need
for expensive ablations or architectural modifications. On three well-studied
tasks - indirect object identification, greater-than comparisons, and docstring
completion - the proposed method achieves higher precision and recall in
recovering ground-truth circuits compared to state-of-the-art baselines, while
reducing runtime from hours to seconds. Notably, we require only 5-10 text
examples for each task to learn robust representations. Our findings highlight
the promise of discrete sparse autoencoders for scalable and efficient
mechanistic interpretability, offering a new direction for analysing the inner
workings of large language models.
|
[
-0.37329068779945374,
-0.4995810091495514,
0.7476341128349304,
0.22612948715686798,
-0.11943241208791733,
-0.0940876379609108,
-0.274737685918808,
-0.09150172024965286,
0.16518697142601013,
0.15852807462215424,
-0.5942490100860596,
-0.17966999113559723,
-0.8098475933074951,
0.09013278782367706,
-0.6272130012512207,
0.6204257607460022,
0.048888444900512695,
-0.36109262704849243,
0.05618525668978691,
0.010164160281419754,
-0.3749161958694458,
-0.6039912104606628,
-0.33602088689804077,
-0.11812974512577057,
0.47201818227767944,
0.14448024332523346,
0.44856080412864685,
1.0473145246505737,
0.20045295357704163,
0.43068990111351013,
0.03824301064014435,
0.05950139835476875,
-0.3795450031757355,
-0.17147959768772125,
-0.17962202429771423,
0.09213506430387497,
-0.21921563148498535,
-0.21361161768436432,
0.4869260787963867,
0.9467225670814514,
-0.154604971408844,
0.18220208585262299,
0.1592107117176056,
0.25260335206985474,
-0.7421240210533142,
0.6221283674240112,
-0.9201641082763672,
-0.06094185635447502,
-0.004105779342353344,
-0.35969191789627075,
-0.5358941555023193,
-0.02078339271247387,
-0.2058117389678955,
-0.5444411039352417,
0.3127584457397461,
-0.05563092976808548,
0.930475652217865,
0.48849669098854065,
-0.27174675464630127,
-0.4075832962989807,
-0.632020115852356,
0.8686769008636475,
-0.37574437260627747,
0.5168346762657166,
0.321145623922348,
0.2513371407985687,
-0.0369291752576828,
-0.6870924830436707,
-0.4838467836380005,
0.10417155921459198,
-0.3970606029033661,
-0.15801410377025604,
-0.08978927135467529,
0.1358979195356369,
0.6229171752929688,
0.5343014001846313,
-0.6549343466758728,
-0.22711370885372162,
-0.1364297717809677,
-0.28568071126937866,
0.19989600777626038,
0.14469535648822784,
0.2857765555381775,
-0.16333426535129547,
0.07462641596794128,
0.09182015061378479,
-0.5267476439476013,
-0.34570032358169556,
0.10186395049095154,
0.09981200844049454,
-0.027511868625879288,
0.2523561716079712,
-0.10131926089525223,
0.8680997490882874,
0.6096069812774658,
-0.021050674840807915,
0.24771514534950256,
-0.2492303103208542,
-0.3530063331127167,
-0.09294192492961884,
0.8972901105880737,
-0.36570632457733154,
0.6317670345306396,
-0.24810472130775452,
-0.30973324179649353,
-0.16319680213928223,
0.3716100752353668,
-0.796186089515686,
-0.5638278722763062,
-0.08272995054721832,
-0.5323591232299805,
-0.08535926043987274,
-0.032190751284360886,
-0.7160869240760803,
-0.12374930083751678,
-0.505193293094635,
0.4606543779373169,
-0.1945509910583496,
-0.05281391739845276,
0.24834778904914856,
0.14555314183235168,
0.2689054310321808,
0.052759453654289246,
-1.4421741962432861,
0.5927703380584717,
0.43066325783729553,
0.6585912108421326,
0.10533397644758224,
-0.24088020622730255,
-0.5481181740760803,
0.08302485197782516,
-0.3549785315990448,
0.4573676884174347,
-0.33830296993255615,
0.10886009782552719,
-0.2681555151939392,
0.1778682917356491,
-0.1529882401227951,
-0.535642147064209,
0.27302539348602295,
-0.6879542469978333,
-0.3695051074028015,
-0.31109553575515747,
-0.14830134809017181,
0.09612631797790527,
-0.10720928758382797,
-0.6961871385574341,
0.7671749591827393,
0.36197078227996826,
-0.8543249368667603,
0.1351824551820755,
0.01762506552040577,
-0.626097559928894,
0.008952650241553783,
-0.5874161720275879,
-0.3783952295780182,
0.2655312418937683,
0.30175337195396423,
0.5132687091827393,
-0.2298317849636078,
0.2610902786254883,
-0.40594974160194397,
-0.4919740557670593,
0.2354619801044464,
-0.7058050632476807,
0.8747902512550354,
0.19277594983577728,
-0.6392013430595398,
-0.025542303919792175,
-0.9968938231468201,
-0.17861704528331757,
0.032565295696258545,
0.2176232933998108,
-0.4605396091938019,
0.0008874903433024883,
-0.03366706892848015,
0.40723857283592224,
0.18394015729427338,
-0.6145017147064209,
-0.18419671058654785,
-0.50069260597229,
0.7434777021408081,
0.8222367167472839,
0.17135195434093475,
0.1707170009613037,
0.08667270094156265,
0.12835808098316193,
-0.0566529706120491,
0.009536712430417538,
-0.40744900703430176,
-0.22410163283348083,
-0.9162831902503967,
-0.33271893858909607,
0.46269115805625916,
0.3025796413421631,
-0.5326897501945496,
0.852924108505249,
-0.27261587977409363,
-0.00630624545738101,
-0.23174221813678741,
0.1972285360097885,
0.15916603803634644,
0.494669109582901,
0.26816526055336,
-0.34223878383636475,
-0.4284152388572693,
-0.8517314195632935,
0.07410750538110733,
-0.08430390805006027,
-0.17654862999916077,
0.4251600503921509,
0.4744946360588074,
-0.26675790548324585,
0.6884406208992004,
-0.4805224537849426,
-0.022337347269058228,
-0.021336650475859642,
0.25347429513931274,
0.21543793380260468,
0.6278519034385681,
0.4556817412376404,
-0.6378831267356873,
-0.47413966059684753,
0.11564603447914124,
-0.750064492225647,
-0.0022087828256189823,
-0.5269495844841003,
0.06192523241043091,
-0.39676564931869507,
0.5658354759216309,
-0.47465139627456665,
0.271788626909256,
0.1409624218940735,
0.0208148006349802,
0.09380330890417099,
-0.29145389795303345,
0.013767557218670845,
-0.5161805152893066,
0.07359389215707779,
0.01927747018635273,
-0.3220570385456085,
-0.32175663113594055,
-0.12397339195013046,
0.43697184324264526,
-0.1930677741765976,
-0.005285186227411032,
0.3959974944591522,
-0.6822192072868347,
-0.26489001512527466,
-0.21440958976745605,
-0.05384340509772301,
-0.04203414171934128,
0.8777323961257935,
0.1919505000114441,
0.7816118001937866,
0.6356512308120728,
-0.5207434892654419,
0.22611132264137268,
0.11562832444906235,
-0.4141315221786499,
0.21531900763511658,
-0.7872152328491211,
0.13857732713222504,
-0.32542723417282104,
-0.26830512285232544,
-1.0245630741119385,
-0.41774579882621765,
0.2396102249622345,
-0.3975347876548767,
0.5477653741836548,
-0.15053874254226685,
-0.5528244972229004,
-0.519990086555481,
0.09435030072927475,
0.6846092343330383,
0.6022222638130188,
-0.7578415870666504,
0.5106543302536011,
0.5825838446617126,
-0.300802618265152,
-0.41519999504089355,
-0.6436835527420044,
-0.044243913143873215,
0.04434732347726822,
0.0016640274552628398,
0.009137731045484543,
-0.02914002165198326,
0.04612530395388603,
-0.13169236481189728,
-0.2524387538433075,
-0.546739399433136,
0.25161683559417725,
0.3165719509124756,
0.0739314928650856,
0.0016802734462544322,
0.13738980889320374,
0.03955027461051941,
-0.5069995522499084,
0.26374518871307373,
-0.6276679635047913,
0.3612901568412781,
-0.1495097577571869,
-0.37945953011512756,
-0.4614484906196594,
0.4043540954589844,
0.931652307510376,
-0.4330001473426819,
0.2415464073419571,
0.3671446442604065,
-0.8616272807121277,
-0.2591775357723236,
-0.35205864906311035,
-0.06644754111766815,
-0.5680455565452576,
0.3649913966655731,
-0.4322015345096588,
-0.6869111657142639,
0.1862800568342209,
-0.007460146676748991,
-0.3935215473175049,
0.5176544785499573,
0.7895420789718628,
0.2766530513763428,
1.1878613233566284,
0.7978566884994507,
-0.35043105483055115,
0.14047375321388245,
-0.11638595908880234,
0.3707829713821411,
-0.5681868195533752,
-0.1619173288345337,
-0.37825682759284973,
0.1060708537697792,
-0.15768469870090485,
-0.2753027677536011,
0.2128157913684845,
-0.2900148034095764,
-0.3009609282016754,
0.4883628189563751,
-0.817426323890686,
0.6017757654190063,
0.1384989321231842,
-0.03289477154612541,
0.10159443318843842,
0.14695215225219727,
-0.26132625341415405,
-0.20129741728305817,
-0.799399197101593,
-0.14500366151332855,
0.7925336956977844,
0.36651501059532166,
0.91627037525177,
-0.3911494314670563,
0.3991301357746124,
0.22895547747612,
0.27254077792167664,
-0.714368999004364,
0.2528946101665497,
-0.062303900718688965,
-0.35978174209594727,
-0.124759741127491,
-0.5626158118247986,
-0.7038827538490295,
-0.052218712866306305,
0.1628538817167282,
-0.7259868383407593,
0.6863094568252563,
0.10742518305778503,
-0.676856517791748,
0.03217054158449173,
-0.6035980582237244,
1.0656777620315552,
-0.3012697994709015,
-0.18225091695785522,
-0.08881963789463043,
-0.41203731298446655,
0.22785335779190063,
-0.20649950206279755,
0.24226097762584686,
0.3752738833427429,
0.14521630108356476,
0.42624878883361816,
-0.36316490173339844,
0.8722453713417053,
0.15549029409885406,
-0.09578106552362442,
0.30340707302093506,
0.0013532587327063084,
0.5369715690612793,
0.2131510227918625,
0.057653844356536865,
0.06415212154388428,
-0.16473405063152313,
-0.41438281536102295,
-0.6731364727020264,
1.0888047218322754,
-0.697422206401825,
-0.2024238109588623,
-0.42424604296684265,
-0.6167037487030029,
-0.21219690144062042,
0.34373173117637634,
0.2754635214805603,
0.9336711764335632,
0.1796203851699829,
0.03389395400881767,
1.1583582162857056,
-0.15571610629558563,
0.3846239149570465,
0.025671757757663727,
0.3679787218570709,
-0.5318466424942017,
1.3789753913879395,
0.15674163401126862,
-0.0638459101319313,
0.509792685508728,
-0.34098002314567566,
-0.06617231667041779,
-0.5395561456680298,
-0.636249303817749,
0.37108737230300903,
-0.7081213593482971,
-0.21139825880527496,
-0.9208470582962036,
-0.36503395438194275,
-0.1366879940032959,
-0.026068422943353653,
-0.4454754889011383,
-0.4342745542526245,
-0.419925332069397,
-0.07070515304803848,
0.0376790389418602,
0.7152831554412842,
-0.06676678359508514,
0.1412387192249298,
-0.38482749462127686,
0.5857357382774353,
0.7303207516670227,
0.6717640161514282,
0.4104742109775543,
-0.2786116898059845,
-0.49168720841407776,
-0.2431066334247589,
0.03821730986237526,
-0.7866284847259521,
0.3754905164241791,
0.11720725148916245,
0.5917854309082031,
0.5312677621841431,
0.02075578272342682,
0.6220762729644775,
-0.6048769354820251,
0.2074996680021286,
-0.05001110956072807,
-1.1175259351730347,
0.24868349730968475,
-0.19988955557346344,
0.24155880510807037,
0.5096379518508911,
0.5667084455490112,
-0.08308066427707672,
-0.19856144487857819,
-0.556995153427124,
-0.7347384095191956,
0.48192042112350464,
0.23075295984745026,
0.0019349897047504783,
-0.44924798607826233,
0.6878128051757812,
-0.03415485844016075,
0.2722289562225342,
-0.7454878091812134,
-0.3391819894313812,
-0.3358127176761627,
-0.5734216570854187,
0.016169890761375427,
-0.39873677492141724,
0.11442529410123825,
-0.27161476016044617,
0.4071292579174042,
-0.14579614996910095,
0.46609437465667725,
0.2251306176185608,
-0.41077902913093567,
-0.27220863103866577,
0.022401729598641396,
0.17521439492702484,
0.5984854102134705,
-0.1460597962141037,
0.5716411471366882,
0.1962844729423523,
-0.4159509241580963,
0.23655912280082703,
0.18471603095531464,
-0.20674122869968414,
0.1313171684741974,
0.33333274722099304,
0.5313929915428162,
0.27865931391716003,
-0.7529906034469604,
0.7260453701019287,
-0.224526047706604,
-0.12019232660531998,
-0.37561678886413574,
-0.1457872986793518,
-0.24454417824745178,
-0.08164171129465103,
0.21067741513252258,
-0.06345763802528381,
0.5650107860565186,
-0.29657313227653503,
0.5699299573898315,
0.48355725407600403,
-0.7698055505752563,
-0.40781569480895996,
0.6290684938430786,
-0.05606779083609581,
0.039790987968444824,
0.5277100801467896,
-0.4757356643676758,
-0.4530982971191406,
0.6880072951316833,
0.45769673585891724,
0.9996957182884216,
-0.01556943915784359,
-0.1464872509241104,
0.6271904706954956,
0.4570677578449249,
0.114562027156353,
-0.13731831312179565,
-0.503616213798523,
-0.31948593258857727,
-0.6967896819114685,
-0.6268312335014343,
0.02523772045969963,
0.3918342888355255,
-0.7890563011169434,
-0.016278013586997986,
-0.6977717876434326,
0.25338876247406006,
0.19823472201824188,
-0.2457910031080246,
-0.3540915250778198,
0.27777785062789917,
0.2799622714519501,
0.6802722215652466,
-0.8803255558013916,
1.075795292854309,
0.30172088742256165,
-0.13132652640342712,
-0.6556679010391235,
-0.00911645032465458,
-0.12170101702213287,
-0.4539532959461212,
0.6486082673072815,
0.1775493025779724,
-0.2079443782567978,
0.19466529786586761,
-0.2980909049510956,
-0.9277991652488708,
0.7489701509475708,
0.24148115515708923,
-0.6408465504646301,
0.04268275946378708,
-0.2679298520088196,
0.3711004853248596,
-0.22591619193553925,
0.5388988256454468,
0.5850156545639038,
0.1698814481496811,
-0.003991048317402601,
-0.7518674731254578,
0.24919936060905457,
-0.40139052271842957,
-0.03689923509955406,
0.4078534245491028,
-0.4625667631626129,
1.0227017402648926,
-0.06876848638057709,
-0.3596055209636688,
0.24496839940547943,
0.702792763710022,
-0.15486478805541992,
-0.08255351334810257,
0.48408833146095276,
0.35275888442993164,
0.7313441634178162,
0.09337083995342255,
0.8925339579582214,
-0.6069939136505127,
0.6928211450576782,
1.0056337118148804,
-0.11996546387672424,
0.3106210231781006,
0.33660832047462463,
-0.012240594252943993,
0.4744490087032318,
0.39951807260513306,
-0.08929834514856339,
0.8028866648674011,
0.3507949709892273,
-0.12293711304664612,
-0.6031606197357178,
0.20519116520881653,
-0.1426086276769638,
-0.084119513630867,
0.6262094974517822,
-0.348375141620636,
-0.4521816074848175,
0.05176260694861412,
-0.3994302451610565,
0.05991361290216446,
-0.37960994243621826,
0.6214565634727478,
0.039670247584581375,
-0.4552956819534302,
0.9015092253684998,
0.014202539809048176,
0.2889404892921448,
-0.4009411334991455,
-0.40570396184921265,
0.11872756481170654,
0.43945837020874023,
-0.0726204365491867,
-0.3106679320335388,
0.5299338102340698,
-0.23476029932498932,
-0.412535697221756,
-0.4111698567867279,
0.9384779930114746,
-0.4467306137084961,
-0.4549359977245331,
0.10780654102563858,
0.2009216547012329,
0.022177739068865776,
-0.15175174176692963,
-0.43274596333503723,
0.16718997061252594,
-0.13391706347465515,
0.08856337517499924,
0.4061185121536255,
0.8188029527664185,
0.018462469801306725,
0.5511050224304199,
0.19320890307426453,
-0.09779039770364761,
0.04395287483930588,
-0.1544565111398697,
0.952172577381134,
-0.6815237402915955,
-0.2881571650505066,
-0.805010974407196,
0.057716209441423416,
-0.028778495267033577,
0.03922491893172264,
0.7340613007545471,
0.48239681124687195,
0.688530445098877,
-0.1527700126171112,
0.8848296403884888,
-0.03318072482943535,
0.423208624124527,
-0.30773618817329407,
0.5223216414451599,
-0.21926364302635193,
0.4011150598526001,
-0.1249333992600441,
-0.46591562032699585,
-0.2324783056974411,
1.0590603351593018,
-0.19181743264198303,
0.047317229211330414,
0.7133322358131409,
0.7877988219261169,
-0.5724492073059082,
-0.21444100141525269,
0.2514607608318329,
0.5401581525802612,
-0.17215734720230103,
0.8726335167884827,
0.7492102980613708,
-0.559467077255249,
0.5390587449073792,
-0.45132794976234436,
-0.5326300859451294,
-0.02251455746591091,
-0.6590752601623535,
-0.9871078133583069,
-0.5541428923606873,
-0.42521336674690247,
-0.08792629837989807,
0.14162690937519073,
0.75934237241745,
0.7793698906898499,
-1.088441014289856,
-0.25985226035118103,
-0.5250752568244934,
0.38557595014572144,
-0.27731433510780334,
-0.17380253970623016,
0.3791528642177582,
-0.6536611318588257,
-0.5513302683830261,
0.11946526169776917,
0.7024634480476379,
-0.17665769159793854,
-0.3502240777015686,
-0.012619845569133759,
0.04760010167956352,
0.1219426617026329,
0.534749448299408,
0.5535679459571838,
-0.5633288025856018,
-0.30105751752853394,
0.1760198026895523,
-0.21711423993110657,
-0.02226851135492325,
0.9487229585647583,
-0.9840956926345825,
0.42378970980644226,
0.2732928395271301,
0.8587937355041504,
0.4741688072681427,
-0.1800813525915146,
0.47591668367385864,
-0.5340916514396667,
0.2288007289171219,
0.08242778480052948,
0.49606603384017944,
0.296626478433609,
-0.28715619444847107,
0.14408963918685913,
0.45430415868759155,
-0.5869398713111877,
-0.6594702005386353,
0.25001049041748047,
-1.0140528678894043,
-0.2030351608991623,
1.069105625152588,
-0.3048093914985657,
-0.3508955240249634,
-0.5658978223800659,
-0.02603972516953945,
-0.025405457243323326,
-0.0003283514524810016,
0.8122296929359436,
0.5300162434577942,
0.12475238740444183,
-0.35676172375679016,
-0.4972107410430908,
0.39925622940063477,
0.10026316344738007,
-0.4173509478569031,
0.40491747856140137,
0.40622609853744507,
0.21935589611530304,
0.1952241212129593,
0.5612781643867493,
-0.21560873091220856,
0.4244433641433716,
0.029484035447239876,
0.04999767243862152,
0.049646709114313126,
-0.6982408761978149,
-0.513839840888977,
0.1883193999528885,
0.19229476153850555,
0.03820990025997162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13077v1
|
GPT-4 Jailbreaks Itself with Near-Perfect Success Using Self-Explanation
| 2024-05-21T03:16:35 | 2024-05-21T03:16:35 |
Govind Ramesh, Yao Dou, Wei Xu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Research on jailbreaking has been valuable for testing and understanding the
safety and security issues of large language models (LLMs). In this paper, we
introduce Iterative Refinement Induced Self-Jailbreak (IRIS), a novel approach
that leverages the reflective capabilities of LLMs for jailbreaking with only
black-box access. Unlike previous methods, IRIS simplifies the jailbreaking
process by using a single model as both the attacker and target. This method
first iteratively refines adversarial prompts through self-explanation, which
is crucial for ensuring that even well-aligned LLMs obey adversarial
instructions. IRIS then rates and enhances the output given the refined prompt
to increase its harmfulness. We find IRIS achieves jailbreak success rates of
98% on GPT-4 and 92% on GPT-4 Turbo in under 7 queries. It significantly
outperforms prior approaches in automatic, black-box and interpretable
jailbreaking, while requiring substantially fewer queries, thereby establishing
a new standard for interpretable jailbreaking methods.
|
[
-0.09873270988464355,
-0.7948489785194397,
0.6974853873252869,
0.41626524925231934,
-0.23095816373825073,
0.27279403805732727,
-0.16514262557029724,
-0.3451681137084961,
0.20055051147937775,
0.4583464562892914,
-0.771519660949707,
-0.5125311017036438,
-0.44203293323516846,
0.2540692985057831,
-0.4273379445075989,
1.2633548974990845,
-0.2542015612125397,
-0.10465948283672333,
0.4777124524116516,
0.11926451325416565,
-0.6132045984268188,
-0.26476606726646423,
-0.268606573343277,
-0.06402052193880081,
0.43388864398002625,
0.5234205722808838,
0.4822571277618408,
0.6886757016181946,
0.49455633759498596,
0.41300368309020996,
0.26553454995155334,
-0.09469683468341827,
-0.47451871633529663,
0.05288006737828255,
-0.09791097044944763,
-0.463584303855896,
-0.21504299342632294,
0.1025814339518547,
0.42648839950561523,
-0.11866997182369232,
-0.24018190801143646,
0.12237419933080673,
0.04960481822490692,
0.6895269751548767,
-0.5217660665512085,
-0.09484510868787766,
-0.9213391542434692,
0.014125020243227482,
-0.5411176085472107,
-0.22297567129135132,
-0.3748818635940552,
-0.110943503677845,
-0.16975648701190948,
-0.533214807510376,
0.4307207465171814,
0.05503664165735245,
0.7903763055801392,
0.4180387258529663,
0.04140070453286171,
-0.12368083000183105,
-0.5809159874916077,
0.502778947353363,
-0.6077526211738586,
0.19899554550647736,
0.17849776148796082,
0.42519107460975647,
-0.1707460582256317,
-0.7899967432022095,
-0.41022977232933044,
-0.5215914249420166,
0.07505082339048386,
-0.22969195246696472,
-0.11278753727674484,
-0.010116104036569595,
0.20567788183689117,
0.4582705497741699,
-0.540757954120636,
-0.020522186532616615,
-0.7707658410072327,
-0.21827390789985657,
0.3547017574310303,
-0.04803360626101494,
0.31657761335372925,
-0.30907291173934937,
-0.6078982949256897,
0.3122454583644867,
-1.046936273574829,
-0.236509308218956,
0.365668386220932,
0.07680846750736237,
0.18753328919410706,
0.39796531200408936,
-0.04600885137915611,
0.4228958785533905,
0.34015849232673645,
0.2532263696193695,
0.36612218618392944,
-0.34822878241539,
-0.12351203709840775,
-0.029020527377724648,
0.8474264740943909,
0.3912920653820038,
0.17023800313472748,
-0.5812257528305054,
-0.06579597294330597,
-0.23480169475078583,
0.5477370619773865,
-0.9553319811820984,
-0.37194564938545227,
0.4068876802921295,
-0.285835862159729,
-0.2824532091617584,
-0.14877527952194214,
-0.8762232065200806,
-0.32065272331237793,
0.21396182477474213,
0.39802229404449463,
-0.47061997652053833,
-0.31778356432914734,
0.022973038256168365,
-0.1071508526802063,
0.3316513001918793,
0.05814795568585396,
-1.007645845413208,
0.06596149504184723,
0.7200056314468384,
1.0439833402633667,
0.04551509767770767,
-0.6241535544395447,
-0.49529552459716797,
0.19428399205207825,
-0.23062372207641602,
0.562385618686676,
-0.24984361231327057,
-0.1046728864312172,
-0.4257124662399292,
-0.06889010965824127,
0.10693058371543884,
-0.38650208711624146,
0.28945523500442505,
-0.6456617712974548,
-0.16094207763671875,
-0.2040410041809082,
-0.2733018696308136,
-0.14698034524917603,
0.28783804178237915,
-0.517930805683136,
0.5266196727752686,
-0.0552545003592968,
-0.6160058975219727,
0.39813244342803955,
-0.8485923409461975,
-0.4030769169330597,
0.1006878912448883,
-0.045288849622011185,
-0.6842638850212097,
0.0687507763504982,
0.3126298189163208,
0.3545122444629669,
0.021005744114518166,
0.3092573285102844,
-0.5417448282241821,
-0.503793478012085,
-0.001595566631294787,
-0.280338317155838,
0.707526683807373,
0.49298784136772156,
-1.0323152542114258,
0.06527373939752579,
-0.5424144268035889,
0.11281371861696243,
0.4440804421901703,
0.25977322459220886,
-0.12267515808343887,
-0.23344923555850983,
-0.5011312365531921,
-0.11557513475418091,
0.4251744747161865,
-0.8841411471366882,
0.38819774985313416,
-0.48868054151535034,
0.9107027649879456,
0.9433937668800354,
-0.09551297128200531,
0.29225242137908936,
0.28193041682243347,
0.3780069053173065,
-0.2583889663219452,
0.42017534375190735,
-0.4398277997970581,
-0.3657463788986206,
-0.23512285947799683,
-0.3143841326236725,
0.28088662028312683,
0.6875516176223755,
-0.694157063961029,
-0.02583625353872776,
0.17512613534927368,
-0.39682701230049133,
-0.7544333338737488,
0.5269684791564941,
0.6159675121307373,
0.5194578766822815,
0.528438150882721,
-0.1544446349143982,
-0.3404431939125061,
-0.9323957562446594,
-0.4654114246368408,
-0.17023877799510956,
0.18604254722595215,
0.004123502876609564,
0.5512610673904419,
-0.37489330768585205,
0.5843862295150757,
-0.3459267020225525,
-0.3041601777076721,
-0.22367079555988312,
0.2826363444328308,
0.1917206048965454,
0.535865068435669,
0.6077966094017029,
-0.5127244591712952,
-0.2582310736179352,
-0.4351820647716522,
-1.04682457447052,
-0.17352023720741272,
-0.13068801164627075,
0.024247057735919952,
-0.1334380805492401,
0.5645445585250854,
-0.31050214171409607,
0.5785848498344421,
0.2982592284679413,
-0.45849451422691345,
0.751325786113739,
-0.3719680905342102,
0.29487401247024536,
-0.6144735813140869,
-0.2695578634738922,
0.0940796360373497,
-0.19738371670246124,
-0.5380356311798096,
0.5727167129516602,
0.3490445017814636,
-0.02458789385855198,
-0.2636328637599945,
0.3318677246570587,
-0.7928780913352966,
-0.13302287459373474,
-0.437220960855484,
0.13425123691558838,
-0.17635241150856018,
0.4519345760345459,
-0.37572306394577026,
1.0976518392562866,
0.5438344478607178,
-0.09360427409410477,
0.4749176502227783,
0.07263663411140442,
-0.1069650948047638,
0.14395515620708466,
-0.820566713809967,
0.2567700445652008,
-0.005551584530621767,
-0.14903606474399567,
-1.0385935306549072,
0.018659507855772972,
0.3788561224937439,
-0.39213791489601135,
0.3248000144958496,
-0.27779707312583923,
-0.2730899751186371,
-0.5030359029769897,
-0.5987808704376221,
0.49075159430503845,
0.2694900333881378,
-0.9589502811431885,
0.41103866696357727,
0.006444546859711409,
-0.07859066128730774,
-0.6385520696640015,
-0.7544050812721252,
0.5711787939071655,
-0.5066413879394531,
-0.8420544862747192,
0.31702935695648193,
-0.12983915209770203,
-0.3157274127006531,
-0.1847337782382965,
-0.04257339611649513,
0.03634824976325035,
0.344775527715683,
0.15441782772541046,
0.429254412651062,
-0.04758380725979805,
-0.37731504440307617,
-0.2657049596309662,
-0.3177223801612854,
0.10502152889966965,
-0.25698304176330566,
0.24287356436252594,
-0.5790918469429016,
-0.35685738921165466,
-0.5810627341270447,
0.19894622266292572,
0.43711361289024353,
-0.4449043273925781,
0.6104339361190796,
0.2779635488986969,
0.1253718137741089,
-0.32652267813682556,
-0.6451927423477173,
-0.3880953788757324,
-0.5995427370071411,
0.19456776976585388,
-0.7971559762954712,
-1.0092930793762207,
0.6542537212371826,
-0.0724220722913742,
0.06688664108514786,
0.06518030911684036,
0.4377315044403076,
0.15979303419589996,
0.8922767043113708,
0.6848752498626709,
-0.39157819747924805,
0.5921205878257751,
-0.17497193813323975,
0.43672117590904236,
-0.8792130947113037,
0.0017527309246361256,
-0.28134098649024963,
-0.06544322520494461,
-0.5936220288276672,
0.0015375649090856314,
0.2735762298107147,
0.10087684541940689,
-0.33729249238967896,
0.5999656319618225,
-0.7923191785812378,
0.6874173879623413,
0.42142221331596375,
0.20268405973911285,
0.26657283306121826,
-0.09419821947813034,
-0.12260091304779053,
-0.015288418158888817,
-0.17175310850143433,
-0.2348623424768448,
1.3534700870513916,
0.5534065365791321,
0.880689263343811,
0.21337230503559113,
0.9851576685905457,
0.22282090783119202,
0.6151179075241089,
-0.1737675815820694,
0.34190621972084045,
0.024951566010713577,
-0.7371470332145691,
-0.22187264263629913,
-0.48097991943359375,
-0.694950520992279,
0.24670851230621338,
0.36803022027015686,
-1.1290864944458008,
-0.04722832515835762,
0.3303372263908386,
-0.5405125021934509,
0.2108391970396042,
-0.9597182869911194,
1.0091755390167236,
-0.47884249687194824,
-0.7015506625175476,
-0.18867729604244232,
-0.5502766966819763,
0.8757685422897339,
-0.18698199093341827,
0.27575212717056274,
-0.05106000602245331,
0.27624616026878357,
0.3895241916179657,
-0.8004441261291504,
0.6480614542961121,
-0.453203946352005,
-0.1096993088722229,
0.15364094078540802,
0.2320971041917801,
0.6518841981887817,
0.29995518922805786,
-0.09398692101240158,
0.25074976682662964,
-0.3379613161087036,
-0.38086774945259094,
-0.7713204026222229,
0.7745233178138733,
-0.5087787508964539,
-1.1657277345657349,
-0.35010313987731934,
-0.16905751824378967,
-0.009664981625974178,
0.13380299508571625,
0.32710617780685425,
0.3643506169319153,
0.16506162285804749,
-0.2706701457500458,
0.42186498641967773,
-0.14740677177906036,
0.32125723361968994,
0.8839718103408813,
-0.4132814109325409,
-0.4439564049243927,
0.8550809621810913,
0.01952681690454483,
0.27161526679992676,
-0.33731183409690857,
0.08370164036750793,
-0.2025260478258133,
-0.8999450206756592,
-0.7921711206436157,
0.3916020393371582,
-0.41992485523223877,
-0.22525353729724884,
-0.20958727598190308,
-0.22828054428100586,
-0.3872845768928528,
-0.16347061097621918,
-0.5664671063423157,
-0.22718657553195953,
0.14186912775039673,
-0.3957505524158478,
0.4028688371181488,
0.822333812713623,
-0.5546690821647644,
0.40758460760116577,
-0.5450766086578369,
0.7781241536140442,
0.2805156409740448,
0.5891168117523193,
-0.15003621578216553,
-0.6310431957244873,
-0.11733666807413101,
-0.18381430208683014,
-0.302282452583313,
-1.34048330783844,
0.2841414213180542,
0.13534128665924072,
0.35937976837158203,
0.4789053499698639,
-0.05013025924563408,
0.8778524398803711,
-0.8609616756439209,
0.6970751881599426,
0.14003296196460724,
-0.9991673231124878,
0.7836506962776184,
-0.3661213219165802,
0.041633039712905884,
0.8450299501419067,
-0.20360292494297028,
-0.20099785923957825,
-0.8537314534187317,
-0.4848603308200836,
-1.0658597946166992,
0.4792441427707672,
0.2484641969203949,
0.06158209964632988,
-0.09662356972694397,
0.854752779006958,
0.021137544885277748,
0.08051081001758575,
-1.0415796041488647,
-0.5302919745445251,
-0.5034409761428833,
0.027214480563998222,
-0.016505161300301552,
-0.3256118893623352,
-0.17226772010326385,
-0.21342617273330688,
0.7217828631401062,
0.059157345443964005,
0.3469778299331665,
0.38020265102386475,
-0.13902762532234192,
-0.06819520145654678,
0.3854947090148926,
0.4951331317424774,
0.6858312487602234,
-0.31211385130882263,
0.027385108172893524,
-0.03844331577420235,
-0.45982563495635986,
0.3675209879875183,
0.38186898827552795,
-0.38424187898635864,
-0.23176811635494232,
0.14692993462085724,
0.6236518025398254,
0.02261374332010746,
-0.3980887532234192,
0.6938753724098206,
-0.35179752111434937,
-0.07731468230485916,
-0.32570499181747437,
0.20818474888801575,
-0.38994869589805603,
0.3932321071624756,
0.5652256608009338,
-0.09924411028623581,
0.3886125683784485,
-0.6363665461540222,
0.5897830724716187,
0.6062719821929932,
-0.07278724014759064,
-0.36355721950531006,
1.0599446296691895,
0.15845654904842377,
-0.12156230211257935,
0.746088445186615,
-0.4498087167739868,
-0.7884442806243896,
0.5367183685302734,
0.74686598777771,
1.259917974472046,
-0.35545581579208374,
0.29986995458602905,
0.22375285625457764,
0.6936862468719482,
-0.1175583079457283,
0.19798031449317932,
-0.23442403972148895,
-0.7808343768119812,
-0.6335481405258179,
-0.3423653841018677,
-0.3053317666053772,
0.17251195013523102,
-0.4998571574687958,
-0.021279970183968544,
-0.6689316034317017,
0.1427130550146103,
0.007168555166572332,
-0.2799585163593292,
-0.18974673748016357,
0.0017926396103575826,
-0.057832784950733185,
0.9744647741317749,
-0.5703222751617432,
0.7040565013885498,
0.19390341639518738,
-0.34417417645454407,
-1.0047481060028076,
0.10190185904502869,
0.3200798034667969,
-1.091946005821228,
0.6251704692840576,
0.5836430191993713,
-0.18498928844928741,
0.017343146726489067,
-0.8237899541854858,
-0.7819682359695435,
0.845232367515564,
0.4845362901687622,
-0.7839156985282898,
0.08817893266677856,
-0.03128531202673912,
0.30975770950317383,
-0.12010432034730911,
0.22422514855861664,
1.035400390625,
0.6299098134040833,
-0.043446268886327744,
-0.9236961603164673,
0.16295519471168518,
-0.47481244802474976,
-0.4431542158126831,
0.33413398265838623,
-0.710005521774292,
0.5855252146720886,
-0.7530611753463745,
-0.0670306608080864,
0.2953411936759949,
0.7921720743179321,
0.30396127700805664,
0.3760334253311157,
0.45634251832962036,
0.8074568510055542,
0.6207330822944641,
-0.18992719054222107,
0.9614565968513489,
-0.5820450782775879,
0.20603124797344208,
1.1253573894500732,
-0.21348218619823456,
0.41311389207839966,
0.3858009874820709,
0.08900127559900284,
0.6514797210693359,
0.41857442259788513,
-0.3273758590221405,
0.7988104224205017,
0.31098827719688416,
-0.33142125606536865,
-0.03601672872900963,
0.6669439077377319,
-0.28601813316345215,
0.39185503125190735,
0.10209336876869202,
-0.2610776424407959,
-0.3991316854953766,
0.5212355852127075,
0.3394295573234558,
-0.030672339722514153,
-0.5222012996673584,
0.8281420469284058,
0.00921773910522461,
-0.7517587542533875,
0.7074209451675415,
0.24831531941890717,
0.6545782685279846,
-0.48662135004997253,
0.04477260634303093,
-0.15983353555202484,
0.3698519170284271,
-0.3241482675075531,
-0.8223271369934082,
0.32269585132598877,
0.4726810157299042,
0.08601543307304382,
-0.2811325788497925,
0.7138220071792603,
-0.20620176196098328,
-0.17808422446250916,
0.5379133224487305,
0.06547384709119797,
0.2802937626838684,
-0.31898149847984314,
-0.7709169983863831,
0.010799236595630646,
0.35828477144241333,
-0.3760296404361725,
0.1428898423910141,
0.41294971108436584,
0.29359689354896545,
0.8717227578163147,
0.38565051555633545,
0.15266825258731842,
0.34186768531799316,
-0.10814464837312698,
1.0477508306503296,
-0.9964923858642578,
-0.40904223918914795,
-1.2774947881698608,
0.5216885209083557,
-0.09565145522356033,
-0.19537712633609772,
1.0500370264053345,
0.4441564381122589,
0.516636848449707,
0.3249588906764984,
0.8410637974739075,
0.012067610397934914,
0.4454079866409302,
-0.4948866665363312,
0.4353940486907959,
-0.37658295035362244,
0.7591778635978699,
-0.2565600275993347,
-0.5278387665748596,
0.018962915986776352,
0.6394327282905579,
-0.6923351883888245,
0.006718118209391832,
0.5744904279708862,
0.8785707354545593,
0.17325064539909363,
0.19309021532535553,
0.08344657719135284,
0.4746670722961426,
0.5015199780464172,
0.39122632145881653,
0.7330747842788696,
-0.39141473174095154,
0.6134820580482483,
-0.29284024238586426,
-0.5131130814552307,
0.23148144781589508,
-0.7529575824737549,
-0.762018084526062,
-0.24029290676116943,
-0.1584445685148239,
-0.4242688715457916,
0.4336627721786499,
0.42380523681640625,
0.5600062012672424,
-0.5514264702796936,
0.10760775208473206,
-0.27532291412353516,
0.1684338003396988,
-0.003651281353086233,
-0.24947847425937653,
0.016370799392461777,
-0.6868078708648682,
-0.29147401452064514,
0.8613187670707703,
0.5161111354827881,
-0.376470685005188,
-0.5025023221969604,
0.00672669243067503,
0.25998884439468384,
-0.17270147800445557,
0.12023598700761795,
0.5978365540504456,
-0.5528576374053955,
-0.4220733940601349,
-0.19410046935081482,
0.10198500007390976,
0.286832332611084,
0.8023390173912048,
-0.7634697556495667,
0.5324568748474121,
-0.10234653949737549,
0.5329794883728027,
0.744756281375885,
0.19572308659553528,
0.7685271501541138,
-0.6235318779945374,
0.010252009145915508,
-0.1182706281542778,
0.4394459128379822,
0.2912183403968811,
-0.680736243724823,
0.4477084279060364,
0.13000470399856567,
-0.8185712099075317,
-0.7901136875152588,
0.32467857003211975,
-0.4218364357948303,
-0.5604144930839539,
0.8458110690116882,
-0.33488550782203674,
-0.5949354767799377,
-0.21208208799362183,
-0.11676766723394394,
-0.13178205490112305,
-0.4483118951320648,
1.1122980117797852,
0.452458918094635,
-0.10922298580408096,
-0.5558876991271973,
-0.42502501606941223,
0.5634350776672363,
0.3029888868331909,
-0.6360754370689392,
0.3271678686141968,
0.31543785333633423,
0.6363546848297119,
0.22584958374500275,
0.7144585847854614,
-0.399065762758255,
0.5051742792129517,
-0.3098934590816498,
0.0446961335837841,
-0.4210527837276459,
-0.5341311097145081,
-0.5857383608818054,
0.37017714977264404,
0.08902471512556076,
-0.15778137743473053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12468v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12468v2
|
Diverse and Effective Synthetic Data Generation for Adaptable Zero-Shot Dialogue State Tracking
| 2024-05-21T03:04:14 | 2024-06-13T17:32:00 |
James D. Finch, Jinho D. Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We demonstrate substantial performance gains in zero-shot dialogue state
tracking (DST) by enhancing training data diversity through synthetic data
generation. Existing DST datasets are severely limited in the number of
application domains and slot types they cover due to the high costs of data
collection, restricting their adaptability to new domains. This work addresses
this challenge with a novel, fully automatic data generation approach that
creates synthetic zero-shot DST datasets. Distinguished from previous methods,
our approach can generate dialogues across a massive range of application
domains, complete with silver-standard dialogue state annotations and slot
descriptions. This technique is used to create the D0T dataset for training
zero-shot DST models, encompassing an unprecedented 1,000+ domains. Experiments
on the MultiWOZ benchmark show that training models on diverse synthetic data
improves Joint Goal Accuracy by 6.7%, achieving results competitive with models
13.5 times larger than ours.
|
[
-0.39099133014678955,
-0.622972846031189,
0.7451778054237366,
-0.2364654392004013,
-0.2213834971189499,
0.5538743138313293,
0.014928565360605717,
-0.3317672908306122,
0.2816016972064972,
0.45241525769233704,
-1.116941213607788,
-0.5754657983779907,
-0.22609424591064453,
0.12150932848453522,
-0.23856952786445618,
1.287219524383545,
-0.087272047996521,
0.04626023769378662,
0.27872905135154724,
-0.2645350694656372,
-0.6204245686531067,
-0.6213122010231018,
-0.2732328176498413,
-0.04736886918544769,
0.4011297821998596,
0.26546674966812134,
0.3574654161930084,
0.44163984060287476,
0.019356492906808853,
0.1623217910528183,
0.2297443300485611,
0.2678833305835724,
-0.7016838788986206,
0.39658400416374207,
-0.20050932466983795,
-0.3111567795276642,
-0.5938503742218018,
-0.06534149497747421,
0.5987179279327393,
0.5348618626594543,
-0.14847171306610107,
0.2017587274312973,
-0.39372289180755615,
0.3602946102619171,
-0.6242008209228516,
0.11967457830905914,
-1.019268274307251,
0.17316724359989166,
-0.15918445587158203,
-0.3405759036540985,
-0.18788854777812958,
-0.22072850167751312,
0.2285536676645279,
-0.6955906748771667,
0.6251519322395325,
-0.4557097852230072,
0.35123223066329956,
0.19960927963256836,
-0.7061970829963684,
0.0031173613388091326,
-1.199766755104065,
0.7643861770629883,
-0.7642867565155029,
0.09641819447278976,
-0.11252415180206299,
0.6557280421257019,
-0.31699955463409424,
-0.42446210980415344,
-0.7793670296669006,
-0.047350525856018066,
0.4092767536640167,
0.47957372665405273,
-0.08464961498975754,
0.12583516538143158,
0.5177417397499084,
0.30766069889068604,
-0.4784049391746521,
-0.2978602647781372,
-0.4259578287601471,
-0.1252444088459015,
0.8904152512550354,
0.6916980147361755,
0.10088635981082916,
0.040578603744506836,
-0.16607043147087097,
-0.074600450694561,
-0.4959591031074524,
-0.15812835097312927,
0.39731165766716003,
0.7345255613327026,
-0.010167145170271397,
0.5624245405197144,
-0.8662392497062683,
0.9298350811004639,
0.1224595233798027,
-0.05245367810130119,
0.1382295787334442,
-0.6635527014732361,
-0.186163991689682,
0.29290297627449036,
0.547784686088562,
0.4923345744609833,
-0.1411910206079483,
-0.12006737291812897,
-0.25135719776153564,
0.37803521752357483,
0.5569009184837341,
-0.8300687074661255,
-0.15909990668296814,
0.15225400030612946,
0.2915668189525604,
-0.4732256233692169,
-0.12457438558340073,
-0.5574564337730408,
-0.20102539658546448,
-0.6019070744514465,
0.4981074631214142,
-0.4155932068824768,
-0.33997076749801636,
0.35154497623443604,
-0.18021634221076965,
0.25667980313301086,
0.6591211557388306,
-0.8649126291275024,
0.15330034494400024,
0.30798834562301636,
0.8464294672012329,
-0.20391695201396942,
0.01937868818640709,
-0.3179933726787567,
0.2884756922721863,
-0.5318555235862732,
0.7691275477409363,
-0.2821663022041321,
-0.37937548756599426,
-0.1665443778038025,
-0.12662066519260406,
-0.20764747262001038,
-0.272885799407959,
0.21547530591487885,
-0.17830227315425873,
0.18082258105278015,
-0.024131881073117256,
-0.5443112850189209,
-0.08185578882694244,
0.5079944133758545,
-0.344300240278244,
0.750633180141449,
0.37570273876190186,
-0.3821759521961212,
0.5155091881752014,
-0.8153265714645386,
-0.3026403784751892,
0.14199425280094147,
-0.4165496826171875,
-0.3682042360305786,
0.28272590041160583,
0.12406286597251892,
0.08058731257915497,
-0.0684923455119133,
0.28815963864326477,
-0.4909832775592804,
-0.3989729583263397,
0.1930960714817047,
-0.6026991605758667,
0.5499467253684998,
0.1854054182767868,
-0.3644624948501587,
-0.12793955206871033,
-1.075252652168274,
0.15856514871120453,
0.11507565528154373,
-0.04009139910340309,
-0.04692137986421585,
-0.24033036828041077,
-0.1775217056274414,
0.2797313928604126,
-0.17958569526672363,
-1.0953418016433716,
0.4235055148601532,
-0.29059359431266785,
0.1537853479385376,
0.6612702012062073,
0.41242551803588867,
0.1034163162112236,
-0.39812013506889343,
0.7772942781448364,
0.18346135318279266,
0.036784328520298004,
-0.406476765871048,
-0.36995717883110046,
-0.5124215483665466,
-0.37323400378227234,
0.04570366442203522,
0.5737128853797913,
-0.7698032855987549,
0.334860622882843,
-0.1880379021167755,
-0.6249781250953674,
-0.46646350622177124,
-0.28008538484573364,
0.0905119851231575,
0.6336514353752136,
0.287862628698349,
-0.4668236970901489,
-0.6004984378814697,
-0.6858348250389099,
-0.11635042726993561,
0.11310319602489471,
-0.03646402806043625,
0.40059468150138855,
0.45325058698654175,
0.019238770008087158,
1.275968313217163,
-0.7868928909301758,
-0.13647890090942383,
-0.34489619731903076,
0.13726632297039032,
0.17875829339027405,
0.4046226143836975,
0.70145183801651,
-0.4015776813030243,
-0.799981951713562,
-0.1984402984380722,
-0.7412928342819214,
0.04506106674671173,
-0.5510002374649048,
-0.23740361630916595,
0.1313382238149643,
-0.12070798873901367,
-0.7608795166015625,
0.7809011936187744,
0.3577113449573517,
-0.14152027666568756,
0.48336857557296753,
0.033160801976919174,
0.330508828163147,
-1.3613768815994263,
-0.043590087443590164,
-0.12135118991136551,
-0.316860556602478,
-1.062789797782898,
-0.5538754463195801,
-0.25977519154548645,
-0.5540000200271606,
-0.6306584477424622,
0.4544505774974823,
-0.1148681789636612,
-0.13847941160202026,
-0.2106846123933792,
-0.0046841916628181934,
-0.005453462712466717,
0.8050234317779541,
0.15381434559822083,
0.7399798035621643,
0.606254518032074,
-0.4444766342639923,
0.620300829410553,
0.5997030735015869,
-0.2998058497905731,
0.8299654722213745,
-0.5890131592750549,
0.2634584605693817,
-0.07112187892198563,
0.754759669303894,
-0.9441325068473816,
-0.33239272236824036,
0.24946466088294983,
-0.5275264382362366,
0.16027313470840454,
-0.45468732714653015,
-0.12003636360168457,
0.010075917467474937,
-0.24395212531089783,
0.3549449145793915,
0.5139182209968567,
-0.2484458088874817,
0.17347067594528198,
0.2647181749343872,
-0.19567281007766724,
-0.19351986050605774,
-0.3657977879047394,
0.29573649168014526,
-0.17099736630916595,
-0.3629063069820404,
0.31730809807777405,
-0.14463546872138977,
0.22021222114562988,
-0.302778422832489,
-0.5785497426986694,
-0.12289369106292725,
-0.013523271307349205,
0.05705367028713226,
0.4574967920780182,
-0.12340215593576431,
-0.13316482305526733,
0.07429002225399017,
-0.05749759450554848,
-0.3287672996520996,
-0.5317515730857849,
0.42403843998908997,
0.31452620029449463,
-0.4771205186843872,
-0.7170813679695129,
0.5137113332748413,
0.647488534450531,
0.07282666116952896,
0.5264772176742554,
0.5346303582191467,
-0.18631084263324738,
-0.4630626440048218,
-0.12569421529769897,
-0.29723992943763733,
-0.4484492540359497,
0.2152838557958603,
-0.48395049571990967,
-0.719861626625061,
0.26533833146095276,
0.033927999436855316,
0.40548133850097656,
0.2316722571849823,
0.5311465859413147,
-0.14938153326511383,
1.4685887098312378,
0.42267879843711853,
0.26292282342910767,
0.6571416854858398,
-0.26892873644828796,
0.18788744509220123,
-0.7599248290061951,
0.13661262392997742,
-0.16407908499240875,
-0.29382792115211487,
-0.707956075668335,
-0.3422034680843353,
0.597079336643219,
-0.11732805520296097,
-0.3278649151325226,
0.593131422996521,
-0.5965420007705688,
0.3457460105419159,
0.4613593816757202,
-0.0038256703410297632,
0.24551859498023987,
0.15461920201778412,
0.2181960791349411,
-0.16070018708705902,
-0.6063217520713806,
-0.2791827917098999,
1.4555879831314087,
-0.12252024561166763,
0.7737824320793152,
0.1228753998875618,
1.0098052024841309,
0.39307814836502075,
-0.08071884512901306,
-0.7678432464599609,
0.5143473148345947,
-0.17044703662395477,
-0.7594126462936401,
-0.2357327789068222,
-0.5107393264770508,
-0.6762902140617371,
0.04070059955120087,
-0.2100016176700592,
-0.6951037645339966,
-0.023031799122691154,
0.21402181684970856,
-0.6795018315315247,
0.3209175765514374,
-0.5154691338539124,
0.6851915121078491,
-0.10470414906740189,
-0.1398303061723709,
-0.09644771367311478,
-0.4715099334716797,
0.30889904499053955,
-0.370606392621994,
-0.5370743274688721,
-0.5443356037139893,
0.43230322003364563,
0.47574788331985474,
-0.3091447651386261,
1.012487530708313,
-0.5214508771896362,
-0.0889197289943695,
0.5114188194274902,
0.1992146372795105,
0.44389578700065613,
0.11382399499416351,
0.015469009056687355,
0.25684747099876404,
0.0779416412115097,
-0.5550210475921631,
-0.7049267888069153,
0.4691268801689148,
-0.6681510210037231,
-0.4305768311023712,
-0.5515910983085632,
-0.8450762033462524,
-0.5783560276031494,
0.15628677606582642,
0.0771455392241478,
0.6241823434829712,
-0.3713744580745697,
0.08036268502473831,
0.42069169878959656,
-0.3116053342819214,
0.10359521210193634,
1.0044689178466797,
0.28493043780326843,
-0.48416370153427124,
1.0333647727966309,
0.18207122385501862,
0.6169816255569458,
0.09050377458333969,
-0.24151484668254852,
-0.35886213183403015,
-0.5106486082077026,
-0.8547707200050354,
-0.13244149088859558,
-0.2420675903558731,
-0.3845783472061157,
-0.5957415103912354,
-0.44532549381256104,
-0.6501778960227966,
-0.1757158488035202,
-0.6058909893035889,
-0.9924784302711487,
0.07028419524431229,
-0.1950625777244568,
0.5413137078285217,
0.7673650979995728,
-0.07072485238313675,
0.3134705722332001,
-0.9084815382957458,
0.53915935754776,
0.29396793246269226,
0.4270133972167969,
-0.5453536510467529,
-0.494709312915802,
-0.1983480155467987,
0.5563569664955139,
-0.6190855503082275,
-0.6744412779808044,
0.3984264135360718,
0.3336995840072632,
0.5686184167861938,
-0.24044141173362732,
0.3454481363296509,
0.8123045563697815,
-0.5094301700592041,
1.0727981328964233,
0.2558150887489319,
-0.7443733811378479,
0.8360966444015503,
-0.8453912734985352,
0.5719166994094849,
0.4739832282066345,
0.16943685710430145,
-0.5041639804840088,
-0.4981294870376587,
-0.6798347234725952,
-0.6392599940299988,
1.269944667816162,
0.43974384665489197,
0.3014051020145416,
0.15127475559711456,
0.30399656295776367,
0.3091774582862854,
0.31289368867874146,
-0.25138136744499207,
0.03046884946525097,
-0.5029122829437256,
-0.3869256377220154,
0.022293346002697945,
0.30974775552749634,
-0.4368587136268616,
-0.1606854349374771,
0.7010582685470581,
-0.503418505191803,
0.334144651889801,
0.2148161679506302,
0.05846000462770462,
-0.09687043726444244,
0.21192778646945953,
0.8082228899002075,
0.5205644369125366,
-0.45130789279937744,
-0.42233389616012573,
0.3064608573913574,
-0.336811900138855,
0.4698198735713959,
-0.02430877462029457,
-0.613129198551178,
0.19810377061367035,
-0.06302858144044876,
1.2091072797775269,
-0.2335897535085678,
-0.535129964351654,
0.26294514536857605,
-0.19027665257453918,
-0.44893309473991394,
-0.46336841583251953,
0.48252519965171814,
-0.3649119734764099,
0.19709192216396332,
0.1409231424331665,
0.20755603909492493,
0.09140534698963165,
-0.515291154384613,
0.5129914879798889,
0.4379189610481262,
-0.40257546305656433,
-0.6544653177261353,
0.5697382688522339,
0.28695476055145264,
-0.09326940029859543,
0.5760268568992615,
-0.11888857930898666,
-0.20800043642520905,
0.5083745121955872,
0.5642654895782471,
1.0849963426589966,
-0.15788467228412628,
0.589113712310791,
0.5907533168792725,
-0.22949323058128357,
0.057673655450344086,
0.2727947235107422,
-0.4624643623828888,
-0.8363076448440552,
-0.31760406494140625,
-0.6686831712722778,
-0.7717335820198059,
0.2335115522146225,
-0.7951468825340271,
0.405549019575119,
-0.5839536786079407,
-0.31364327669143677,
0.1400177776813507,
-0.000295203470159322,
-0.5899243950843811,
0.30380967259407043,
0.3826017379760742,
0.6028901934623718,
-0.8016058206558228,
0.9248301386833191,
0.412309467792511,
-0.38690492510795593,
-0.3553485870361328,
0.09434531629085541,
0.38350290060043335,
-0.8090366125106812,
0.26875874400138855,
0.10375183075666428,
-0.17636063694953918,
0.10551758855581284,
-0.3826581835746765,
-0.7224213480949402,
1.2096102237701416,
0.42646223306655884,
-0.5779041647911072,
0.045775339007377625,
0.5301154851913452,
0.6549571752548218,
-0.5748298764228821,
0.23161077499389648,
0.7923358082771301,
0.04723391309380531,
0.5441453456878662,
-0.8462806940078735,
-0.2719075083732605,
-0.09111057966947556,
0.025951484218239784,
0.27255865931510925,
-0.5951942205429077,
0.553591251373291,
-0.06771063059568405,
-0.40744224190711975,
0.020965062081813812,
0.07638271152973175,
0.3999864459037781,
0.3483511805534363,
0.43936002254486084,
0.5533594489097595,
0.3609142303466797,
-0.10668376833200455,
0.5878587365150452,
-0.4244973063468933,
0.3030010759830475,
1.371626615524292,
-0.8119332194328308,
0.2303091585636139,
0.15818177163600922,
-0.06612861156463623,
0.30784735083580017,
0.5174216628074646,
-0.29055824875831604,
0.5705756545066833,
0.15216189622879028,
-0.8094517588615417,
-0.317932665348053,
-0.31224459409713745,
-0.15906521677970886,
0.6995049118995667,
0.2844286859035492,
0.09725261479616165,
-0.45743465423583984,
-0.13034039735794067,
-0.16746462881565094,
-0.22570708394050598,
0.1673002988100052,
1.1511343717575073,
-0.21766485273838043,
-0.6939569711685181,
0.7367293238639832,
-0.3264941871166229,
0.3737289309501648,
-0.9033433198928833,
-0.2631809413433075,
-0.4794572591781616,
0.286136269569397,
-0.06408737599849701,
-0.702323317527771,
0.4384906589984894,
0.34331730008125305,
-0.0025207800790667534,
-0.37150242924690247,
0.3707689046859741,
-0.6137011051177979,
-0.5298620462417603,
-0.11521057784557343,
0.4253391623497009,
0.07152681797742844,
0.039578262716531754,
-0.5490838289260864,
-0.10164975374937057,
0.4611589312553406,
-0.25075653195381165,
0.48957985639572144,
0.3224194347858429,
-0.1438106745481491,
0.2975426912307739,
0.8240684866905212,
0.3572506606578827,
0.07513024657964706,
0.029890166595578194,
0.8676691651344299,
-0.9829413890838623,
-0.40026724338531494,
-0.3623223602771759,
0.8070593476295471,
-0.33579716086387634,
-0.35896819829940796,
0.5347375273704529,
0.531819760799408,
0.9329532980918884,
-0.0717729851603508,
1.3183400630950928,
-0.1971820443868637,
0.8488714694976807,
-0.18755170702934265,
0.4178331792354584,
-0.34586694836616516,
0.06109633669257164,
-0.05596722662448883,
-1.0339958667755127,
-0.018593739718198776,
0.36057648062705994,
0.056208278983831406,
-0.12269532680511475,
0.13254667818546295,
0.9214496612548828,
-0.3388279378414154,
0.1978626847267151,
0.4859924018383026,
0.07548343390226364,
0.8357382416725159,
0.6797579526901245,
0.8564023375511169,
-0.662403404712677,
0.5361703038215637,
-0.31653261184692383,
-0.20253920555114746,
0.14768241345882416,
-0.6153261661529541,
-0.6327342987060547,
-0.48531439900398254,
-0.5056849122047424,
-0.05825028195977211,
-0.013592706061899662,
0.883570671081543,
0.9355581998825073,
-0.9449358582496643,
-0.12789815664291382,
-0.19862069189548492,
-0.5418703556060791,
0.011654244735836983,
-0.26285436749458313,
-0.16574104130268097,
-0.4201258420944214,
-0.8829740881919861,
0.8924920558929443,
0.36993488669395447,
0.47204118967056274,
-0.1550845205783844,
0.03495517745614052,
0.035636190325021744,
0.4398609697818756,
0.541617751121521,
0.45391640067100525,
-0.3455314040184021,
-0.38140517473220825,
0.01196378841996193,
0.15243281424045563,
-0.0005551846115849912,
0.945375382900238,
-0.9099061489105225,
0.7819424867630005,
0.2940555214881897,
0.5054329633712769,
0.942927360534668,
0.09972314536571503,
1.0598185062408447,
-1.059265375137329,
0.27245527505874634,
0.3920813798904419,
-0.048467181622982025,
0.3740903437137604,
-0.2136792093515396,
0.5976601243019104,
0.39872920513153076,
-0.352592796087265,
-1.0363703966140747,
0.5587188601493835,
-0.9724085330963135,
0.057110533118247986,
0.7855570316314697,
-0.15673574805259705,
0.2433777153491974,
-0.20420344173908234,
-0.2642691433429718,
0.39615771174430847,
-0.5194388628005981,
0.9626659750938416,
0.31162160634994507,
-0.6457992792129517,
0.14232654869556427,
-0.6249020099639893,
0.6601946949958801,
0.20767545700073242,
-0.7578974366188049,
0.2499176412820816,
0.7724975347518921,
0.4959569275379181,
-0.039814747869968414,
0.7889136075973511,
-0.01949741505086422,
0.14450079202651978,
0.1956930309534073,
-0.06259912252426147,
-0.04566656053066254,
-0.28119903802871704,
-0.2805294692516327,
-0.2718888223171234,
-0.5195233821868896,
-0.3900502026081085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12438v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12438v1
|
CoCo Matrix: Taxonomy of Cognitive Contributions in Co-writing with Intelligent Agents
| 2024-05-21T01:31:17 | 2024-05-21T01:31:17 |
Ruyuan Wan, Simret Gebreegziabhe, Toby Jia-Jun Li, Karla Badillo-Urquiola
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In recent years, there has been a growing interest in employing intelligent
agents in writing. Previous work emphasizes the evaluation of the quality of
end product-whether it was coherent and polished, overlooking the journey that
led to the product, which is an invaluable dimension of the creative process.
To understand how to recognize human efforts in co-writing with intelligent
writing systems, we adapt Flower and Hayes' cognitive process theory of writing
and propose CoCo Matrix, a two-dimensional taxonomy of entropy and information
gain, to depict the new human-agent co-writing model. We define four quadrants
and situate thirty-four published systems within the taxonomy. Our research
found that low entropy and high information gain systems are under-explored,
yet offer promising future directions in writing tasks that benefit from the
agent's divergent planning and the human's focused translation. CoCo Matrix,
not only categorizes different writing systems but also deepens our
understanding of the cognitive processes in human-agent co-writing. By
analyzing minimal changes in the writing process, CoCo Matrix serves as a proxy
for the writer's mental model, allowing writers to reflect on their
contributions. This reflection is facilitated through the measured metrics of
information gain and entropy, which provide insights irrespective of the
writing system used.
|
[
-0.2638653516769409,
-0.6997615694999695,
0.577836811542511,
0.28769296407699585,
0.24682486057281494,
0.5028613805770874,
-0.31624892354011536,
-0.6606685519218445,
0.6100872159004211,
0.5788201689720154,
-0.6643012762069702,
-0.600647509098053,
-0.6227959394454956,
0.14098887145519257,
-0.19900043308734894,
1.0940696001052856,
-0.09361285716295242,
-0.0926777645945549,
-1.0255119800567627,
0.24609313905239105,
-0.5157593488693237,
-0.4448212683200836,
-0.49786749482154846,
-0.12487812340259552,
0.9486401081085205,
0.6724216938018799,
0.48599398136138916,
0.3692156970500946,
0.934073805809021,
0.2695229947566986,
0.642765998840332,
0.00003590772394090891,
-0.4668850302696228,
0.15133416652679443,
-0.3428777754306793,
-0.733809232711792,
-0.6919379234313965,
0.21187326312065125,
0.3774850070476532,
0.6068664789199829,
0.00816449522972107,
0.3580859899520874,
0.21140362322330475,
0.5891692638397217,
-0.9660401940345764,
0.46759429574012756,
-0.3759036660194397,
0.17743271589279175,
-0.12713800370693207,
-0.38355377316474915,
-0.6327097415924072,
-0.39899852871894836,
-0.15406490862369537,
-0.9088148474693298,
0.19933198392391205,
0.19905446469783783,
0.2852921485900879,
0.22609475255012512,
-0.14111296832561493,
-0.7821546792984009,
-1.064219355583191,
0.716840922832489,
-0.0981287881731987,
-0.18437641859054565,
0.5446919798851013,
0.1282099336385727,
-0.11282223463058472,
-0.8438979983329773,
-0.8894042372703552,
-0.22666051983833313,
0.10994292795658112,
0.3785913586616516,
-0.2901451587677002,
-0.07203371822834015,
-0.04780090972781181,
0.08554436266422272,
-0.3764142692089081,
-0.13294358551502228,
-0.3688139021396637,
-0.3652055263519287,
0.8909604549407959,
0.4750852584838867,
0.6450142860412598,
0.4753877520561218,
-0.46928563714027405,
-0.34976282715797424,
-0.3599206805229187,
0.3833393156528473,
0.4328687787055969,
0.07057948410511017,
0.027763616293668747,
0.7268807888031006,
-0.02385239116847515,
0.46775785088539124,
-0.3524003028869629,
-0.059509504586458206,
-0.3869994878768921,
-0.346504807472229,
-0.015534675680100918,
0.23155544698238373,
0.8118844032287598,
0.3639715611934662,
0.14500229060649872,
-0.5335662961006165,
-0.04765099659562111,
0.5921506285667419,
0.5720211267471313,
-0.42730841040611267,
-0.3696262538433075,
-0.274286687374115,
-0.11511838436126709,
-0.4145241677761078,
0.32341644167900085,
-0.46946945786476135,
-0.7104358077049255,
-0.3129148781299591,
0.3182823657989502,
-0.28446802496910095,
-0.1463862955570221,
0.07310653477907181,
-0.5197712779045105,
0.1156424954533577,
0.4228646457195282,
-0.8760738372802734,
0.8932887315750122,
0.7791886329650879,
0.6584309935569763,
-0.288228303194046,
-0.5792181491851807,
0.04839639365673065,
0.25866618752479553,
-0.6263306140899658,
1.135825753211975,
-0.6515631079673767,
-0.04370648413896561,
-0.3122398853302002,
-0.5263275504112244,
-0.3431830108165741,
-0.2236701399087906,
0.4400845170021057,
-0.4945940673351288,
0.11698677390813828,
-0.6176596879959106,
-0.26370200514793396,
-0.24226894974708557,
0.1960754096508026,
-0.5715569257736206,
0.6755903959274292,
0.28989556431770325,
-0.5106644630432129,
0.46650925278663635,
-0.5889537334442139,
-0.40094849467277527,
-0.03426048904657364,
-0.09968111664056778,
-0.2424897700548172,
0.0975119099020958,
-0.26633715629577637,
0.33386144042015076,
-0.6205586791038513,
0.08190673589706421,
-0.36833053827285767,
-0.2754225730895996,
0.7897056341171265,
-0.1456887573003769,
0.7234654426574707,
0.11420463770627975,
-0.19386838376522064,
0.12874265015125275,
-0.7599542140960693,
0.030721383169293404,
0.06863514333963394,
-0.43907538056373596,
-0.2974325716495514,
-0.08840551972389221,
-0.1750400960445404,
0.2576954662799835,
0.3229001462459564,
-0.6939293742179871,
0.38236358761787415,
0.07946690917015076,
0.32665425539016724,
0.45640283823013306,
0.1175631657242775,
0.6148145794868469,
-0.5806957483291626,
0.6318891644477844,
-0.015285516157746315,
0.19750528037548065,
0.19083933532238007,
-0.4413784146308899,
-0.9376963973045349,
-0.322596937417984,
0.03958519548177719,
0.587104856967926,
-0.5936331152915955,
0.3009055554866791,
-0.19819505512714386,
-0.5884055495262146,
-0.44524896144866943,
0.258750855922699,
0.19096754491329193,
0.3973635733127594,
0.24637916684150696,
-0.7994242906570435,
-0.45905882120132446,
-0.6512061357498169,
-0.3289690613746643,
-0.3675887882709503,
0.27328091859817505,
0.05786221846938133,
0.54461669921875,
-0.05839892476797104,
1.1090413331985474,
-0.6389704942703247,
-0.5256255865097046,
-0.2230328470468521,
0.3067994713783264,
-0.11294568330049515,
0.5197264552116394,
0.41028717160224915,
-0.3298513889312744,
-0.4531383514404297,
-0.27575576305389404,
-0.8347800374031067,
0.05720515921711922,
-0.2912267744541168,
-0.6764641404151917,
-0.04715952277183533,
0.5449293851852417,
-0.7018267512321472,
0.565062403678894,
0.22922152280807495,
-0.516018271446228,
0.5014496445655823,
-0.2256840169429779,
-0.2163086086511612,
-0.8909583687782288,
0.1831294298171997,
-0.3613893687725067,
0.13494251668453217,
-0.5531522035598755,
-0.04912376403808594,
-0.09212043136358261,
0.1435367465019226,
0.03394864499568939,
0.12946681678295135,
-0.6029840111732483,
-0.14757822453975677,
-0.24222339689731598,
0.09647053480148315,
0.42492029070854187,
0.9886866211891174,
0.002380580874159932,
0.24043649435043335,
0.40463677048683167,
-0.5065288543701172,
0.5391461849212646,
-0.08818867057561874,
-0.3075609803199768,
0.6489041447639465,
-0.23729963600635529,
0.3730494976043701,
-0.14781929552555084,
0.33546361327171326,
-0.9948670268058777,
-0.039678726345300674,
0.5474404096603394,
-0.7323113083839417,
0.26059913635253906,
0.6116324663162231,
-0.4282572865486145,
-0.35791662335395813,
-0.43206679821014404,
0.38706639409065247,
-0.024642428383231163,
0.22155718505382538,
0.44122397899627686,
0.4450230300426483,
-0.29765447974205017,
-0.5006476044654846,
-0.8615469932556152,
0.6015335917472839,
-0.0024810379836708307,
-0.5302571654319763,
0.3003890812397003,
-0.30845779180526733,
-0.38171979784965515,
0.13653989136219025,
0.4046469032764435,
-0.08789841085672379,
0.19920465350151062,
0.2893766462802887,
0.29636716842651367,
-0.3630906343460083,
0.026697231456637383,
-0.033769283443689346,
-0.06745238602161407,
0.3767000734806061,
-0.6032965779304504,
0.4368237257003784,
-0.11636660993099213,
-0.1386585682630539,
-0.47395631670951843,
0.4521642327308655,
0.6721945405006409,
-0.4674259424209595,
0.9784864187240601,
0.7675599455833435,
-0.4309963583946228,
-0.1356530636548996,
-0.2099093496799469,
0.06477455049753189,
-0.33371058106422424,
0.16635257005691528,
-0.24787463247776031,
-0.4366104006767273,
0.5398285984992981,
0.25074502825737,
-0.29210585355758667,
0.691651463508606,
0.5890089869499207,
-0.21696168184280396,
0.7697301506996155,
1.1016782522201538,
0.1732310652732849,
0.3585004508495331,
-0.6556025147438049,
0.2862569987773895,
-1.0037013292312622,
-0.7267484664916992,
-0.4951479136943817,
-0.5494705438613892,
-0.21775025129318237,
-0.5260142683982849,
0.21289847791194916,
0.19399107992649078,
-0.16318249702453613,
0.2961699366569519,
-0.6802646517753601,
0.18017686903476715,
0.8933957815170288,
-0.028732433915138245,
0.451389878988266,
-0.0936579629778862,
-0.20994597673416138,
0.1972282975912094,
-0.8867279887199402,
-0.5661510229110718,
0.8389669060707092,
0.11382744461297989,
0.8576071262359619,
0.26076117157936096,
0.4376142919063568,
0.7124148607254028,
0.5291689038276672,
-0.8365727066993713,
0.5818631052970886,
0.3800189197063446,
-0.40979263186454773,
-0.4171266555786133,
0.044380854815244675,
-1.0060184001922607,
-0.1897384524345398,
-0.36615973711013794,
-0.7958899140357971,
0.714667797088623,
-0.06790303438901901,
-0.5045398473739624,
0.15338100492954254,
-0.7040615081787109,
0.7319859266281128,
-0.0888962522149086,
-0.6625698208808899,
-0.3682519793510437,
-0.5466459393501282,
0.14308512210845947,
0.23929966986179352,
-0.10884477198123932,
-0.0476003922522068,
-0.28277111053466797,
1.0400019884109497,
-0.5477429032325745,
0.9797005653381348,
0.2207355946302414,
-0.06784240901470184,
0.9604124426841736,
0.3627271056175232,
0.2405339777469635,
-0.01827654056251049,
0.12312771379947662,
0.11704466491937637,
-0.004972594324499369,
-0.4458259046077728,
-0.7849938273429871,
0.5132325887680054,
-1.0097123384475708,
-0.35880815982818604,
-0.5960118174552917,
-0.9179490208625793,
0.03216424584388733,
0.25114694237709045,
0.510599672794342,
0.38853833079338074,
-0.36764341592788696,
-0.01943594217300415,
0.11773008108139038,
0.011927838437259197,
0.4775565266609192,
0.34711799025535583,
-0.011294197291135788,
-0.4150000214576721,
1.1296169757843018,
0.2597997188568115,
0.11203929036855698,
0.7018393874168396,
-0.053335290402173996,
-0.05929943546652794,
-0.4675338566303253,
-0.2115405648946762,
-0.0021089045330882072,
-0.682685911655426,
-0.1880621463060379,
-0.8293323516845703,
-0.08071548491716385,
-0.7754265069961548,
-0.4215344786643982,
-0.2517639398574829,
-0.6081881523132324,
-0.4910106658935547,
0.15147092938423157,
0.05592070519924164,
1.1502740383148193,
-0.07560323923826218,
0.07298321276903152,
-0.3583357334136963,
-0.060882266610860825,
0.21156926453113556,
0.22146180272102356,
0.2949298322200775,
0.2686370611190796,
-0.73866206407547,
0.24037490785121918,
-0.6401376724243164,
-0.7198940515518188,
0.2882286608219147,
0.028422445058822632,
0.3507879972457886,
0.45626795291900635,
0.2643597722053528,
0.49367210268974304,
0.13452506065368652,
0.7826358079910278,
0.3983345329761505,
-0.8902233242988586,
0.3201894462108612,
-0.24775637686252594,
0.19600197672843933,
0.5881521701812744,
0.09374909102916718,
-0.7946122288703918,
-0.5105202198028564,
-0.410035103559494,
-0.7105624079704285,
0.739571213722229,
0.2729356586933136,
-0.020732644945383072,
0.01080264151096344,
0.18732720613479614,
0.14749690890312195,
0.2884359359741211,
-0.5799203515052795,
0.35867610573768616,
-0.19390782713890076,
-0.3506261110305786,
-0.28604990243911743,
-0.12698832154273987,
-0.01277867890894413,
-0.31956300139427185,
0.4515426456928253,
-0.19534657895565033,
0.7465628385543823,
0.49428585171699524,
-0.451716810464859,
-0.2885129153728485,
0.029265061020851135,
0.7850781083106995,
0.5221194624900818,
0.03803646191954613,
0.5168687701225281,
0.05039702728390694,
-0.8359790444374084,
-0.007448581513017416,
-0.3577541410923004,
0.034090638160705566,
-0.6244410872459412,
0.963461697101593,
0.6487996578216553,
-0.11591984331607819,
-0.3487608730792999,
0.34482619166374207,
-0.30769845843315125,
0.12150293588638306,
-0.48999589681625366,
0.6742022633552551,
-0.03664174675941467,
0.2940465807914734,
0.17487159371376038,
0.853001594543457,
0.14247626066207886,
-0.9948460459709167,
-0.19107580184936523,
0.31923311948776245,
-0.8547883033752441,
-0.5025419592857361,
0.5078914761543274,
-0.007995067164301872,
-0.4535146951675415,
0.7159128189086914,
-0.26325103640556335,
-0.31791773438453674,
0.8893147706985474,
0.6471455097198486,
0.920214056968689,
0.0900845006108284,
0.3999960124492645,
0.1710813194513321,
0.4022640585899353,
0.18185381591320038,
0.11985169351100922,
-0.520571768283844,
-0.7213535904884338,
0.12671354413032532,
-0.5064744353294373,
-0.28982120752334595,
-0.47560015320777893,
-0.8056469559669495,
0.22289374470710754,
-0.5501071214675903,
-0.3522581458091736,
-0.012412309646606445,
0.22523728013038635,
-0.8200722336769104,
0.03077685832977295,
0.10594538599252701,
0.6903248429298401,
-0.5559841394424438,
0.5348116159439087,
0.8222266435623169,
-0.6212597489356995,
-0.575734555721283,
-0.11828567832708359,
-0.20273371040821075,
-0.765339732170105,
0.404624879360199,
-0.0472620390355587,
-0.6201909780502319,
0.1070009395480156,
-0.619822084903717,
-1.0645846128463745,
1.4634441137313843,
0.4016367495059967,
-0.030580956488847733,
-0.10639160126447678,
0.486115425825119,
0.9275156855583191,
-0.859136700630188,
0.24921944737434387,
0.2836790084838867,
0.31423601508140564,
0.1356932371854782,
-0.32253512740135193,
0.026340192183852196,
-0.5787381529808044,
0.036620043218135834,
-0.20901474356651306,
-0.9405872225761414,
0.9015054702758789,
-0.6099913716316223,
-0.2608518600463867,
0.13868357241153717,
0.7859567403793335,
-0.24078552424907684,
0.716223418712616,
0.034123703837394714,
0.3018163740634918,
1.0453089475631714,
0.035041600465774536,
1.2150927782058716,
-0.29382964968681335,
0.1891806423664093,
0.910771369934082,
-0.1602354645729065,
0.6598337292671204,
0.23032264411449432,
0.002380917314440012,
1.080588936805725,
0.47225868701934814,
0.12357260286808014,
0.3210367262363434,
0.4311416447162628,
-0.26272618770599365,
-0.0808022990822792,
-0.4492497742176056,
0.05143184959888458,
0.5999194979667664,
0.46054336428642273,
-0.31925854086875916,
0.25312331318855286,
0.11502478271722794,
0.11097464710474014,
0.1070185974240303,
-0.2234538048505783,
0.9353354573249817,
0.2222946286201477,
-1.2263669967651367,
0.09498284012079239,
0.09376493841409683,
0.13222636282444,
-0.29386383295059204,
-0.0034038592129945755,
-0.011442432180047035,
0.35776641964912415,
-0.23743468523025513,
-0.8159317374229431,
0.3967777490615845,
-0.17254552245140076,
-0.4147762656211853,
-0.30670517683029175,
0.8770554065704346,
-0.46723154187202454,
-0.7822495698928833,
0.1968327760696411,
0.30373701453208923,
0.030323639512062073,
-0.026245370507240295,
-0.4217225909233093,
-0.0072989994660019875,
-0.5512502193450928,
-0.09808053076267242,
-0.04317788779735565,
0.3908887207508087,
-0.315516859292984,
0.43584978580474854,
0.5868721008300781,
0.11138308048248291,
-0.020181436091661453,
-0.16271646320819855,
0.5829745531082153,
-0.7985172271728516,
-0.6259511709213257,
-0.9585838913917542,
0.24648571014404297,
-0.06570939719676971,
-0.3232751488685608,
0.6672562956809998,
0.8308537006378174,
0.6421889662742615,
0.026406770572066307,
0.881278395652771,
-0.08244894444942474,
-0.13262081146240234,
-0.3631158471107483,
0.927444577217102,
-0.20826691389083862,
0.10052260756492615,
-0.5695307850837708,
-1.0079716444015503,
-0.35452955961227417,
0.31470027565956116,
-0.3261789381504059,
-0.12635070085525513,
0.9240136742591858,
0.7785113453865051,
0.2130553126335144,
0.14424656331539154,
0.17043261229991913,
0.24166329205036163,
0.1953359991312027,
0.8667147159576416,
1.0961917638778687,
-0.19190171360969543,
0.3557530641555786,
-0.21138861775398254,
-0.3187810778617859,
-0.25393080711364746,
-0.5590122938156128,
-0.8122199773788452,
-0.9648382663726807,
-0.4027182161808014,
-0.3388926684856415,
-0.2685169577598572,
0.7328643798828125,
0.4961645007133484,
-0.44902652502059937,
-0.35290852189064026,
-0.2642439007759094,
0.3596629500389099,
-0.4423399865627289,
-0.21230101585388184,
0.3094283938407898,
-0.15845201909542084,
-0.37044110894203186,
-0.09994659572839737,
0.7867022156715393,
-0.15838618576526642,
-0.5084501504898071,
-0.22320105135440826,
-0.06568305194377899,
0.5679662227630615,
0.6360509991645813,
0.04650425910949707,
-0.2873995006084442,
-0.009632116183638573,
0.17880205810070038,
-0.39337968826293945,
0.1295151710510254,
1.2928614616394043,
-0.668565571308136,
0.592074453830719,
0.6647199988365173,
0.07892760634422302,
0.4399380385875702,
-0.31402483582496643,
0.5432055592536926,
-0.2391672134399414,
-0.1641818732023239,
0.35231131315231323,
0.055181264877319336,
0.3101901113986969,
-0.7388342618942261,
0.15432512760162354,
0.5117011070251465,
-0.3313508927822113,
-0.4097524583339691,
0.03731325641274452,
-1.1117768287658691,
-0.1970888376235962,
0.7231616377830505,
-0.021998874843120575,
-0.7187665700912476,
-0.1693245768547058,
-0.36338284611701965,
0.7000458836555481,
-0.18750201165676117,
1.0600265264511108,
0.8993154168128967,
-0.5138846635818481,
0.11314581334590912,
-0.1438765525817871,
0.29565897583961487,
0.03953336924314499,
-0.9388098120689392,
-0.21933937072753906,
0.3276064097881317,
-0.03932600095868111,
0.5335631966590881,
1.1005849838256836,
0.07261501997709274,
0.26930636167526245,
0.5286579728126526,
0.4096912741661072,
-0.10709680616855621,
-0.7299304008483887,
0.2672986388206482,
0.287366658449173,
0.20741192996501923,
0.051124200224876404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12434v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12434v1
|
Resolving Word Vagueness with Scenario-guided Adapter for Natural Language Inference
| 2024-05-21T01:19:52 | 2024-05-21T01:19:52 |
Yonghao Liu, Mengyu Li, Di Liang, Ximing Li, Fausto Giunchiglia, Lan Huang, Xiaoyue Feng, Renchu Guan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural Language Inference (NLI) is a crucial task in natural language
processing that involves determining the relationship between two sentences,
typically referred to as the premise and the hypothesis. However, traditional
NLI models solely rely on the semantic information inherent in independent
sentences and lack relevant situational visual information, which can hinder a
complete understanding of the intended meaning of the sentences due to the
ambiguity and vagueness of language. To address this challenge, we propose an
innovative ScenaFuse adapter that simultaneously integrates large-scale
pre-trained linguistic knowledge and relevant visual information for NLI tasks.
Specifically, we first design an image-sentence interaction module to
incorporate visuals into the attention mechanism of the pre-trained model,
allowing the two modalities to interact comprehensively. Furthermore, we
introduce an image-sentence fusion module that can adaptively integrate visual
information from images and semantic information from sentences. By
incorporating relevant visual information and leveraging linguistic knowledge,
our approach bridges the gap between language and vision, leading to improved
understanding and inference capabilities in NLI tasks. Extensive benchmark
experiments demonstrate that our proposed ScenaFuse, a scenario-guided
approach, consistently boosts NLI performance.
|
[
-0.3954015374183655,
-0.962892472743988,
0.7633883357048035,
0.4927659332752228,
-0.5776321887969971,
-0.3125387728214264,
-0.2684057056903839,
-0.44712936878204346,
0.42413797974586487,
0.5096002221107483,
-0.7101032137870789,
-0.19439491629600525,
-0.5983192920684814,
0.1626579314470291,
-0.28078001737594604,
0.9263752102851868,
0.11621750146150589,
-0.26328960061073303,
-0.4322747588157654,
-0.051578011363744736,
-0.7659667134284973,
0.19904902577400208,
-0.6494526863098145,
-0.06355977803468704,
0.41861462593078613,
0.34699663519859314,
0.7714931964874268,
0.481018602848053,
0.38509994745254517,
0.3860014081001282,
0.14048202335834503,
0.10491377860307693,
-0.16331645846366882,
0.21724984049797058,
-0.39421793818473816,
-0.5004041194915771,
-0.06669722497463226,
-0.3749782145023346,
0.5769498348236084,
0.8376928567886353,
-0.1812146157026291,
0.07936733961105347,
0.17060701549053192,
0.4212276041507721,
-0.8227508068084717,
0.02559196949005127,
-0.7051746249198914,
0.06338746845722198,
-0.22360077500343323,
-0.191728875041008,
-0.31343260407447815,
0.10125790536403656,
0.48012879490852356,
-1.0145291090011597,
0.35155433416366577,
0.23200398683547974,
1.300382375717163,
0.6076396107673645,
-0.2610633969306946,
-0.32041135430336,
-0.6897352933883667,
0.7042699456214905,
-1.0055291652679443,
0.24863211810588837,
0.2590978145599365,
0.20027071237564087,
-0.3278188705444336,
-0.8306316137313843,
-0.9386245012283325,
0.002277553780004382,
-0.08948004990816116,
0.2817043662071228,
-0.46318066120147705,
0.1828944832086563,
0.16791319847106934,
0.3242684006690979,
-0.6035845279693604,
0.09536182880401611,
-0.20058673620224,
-0.13498660922050476,
0.27529028058052063,
-0.08526740968227386,
0.19882473349571228,
-0.5194794535636902,
-0.3601738512516022,
0.12689338624477386,
-0.09712233394384384,
-0.2068842351436615,
0.06559398025274277,
0.09982457756996155,
0.012481071054935455,
0.5218312740325928,
-0.32295849919319153,
1.1343200206756592,
0.04079090803861618,
0.12439727038145065,
0.27247679233551025,
-0.4115433096885681,
-0.32913750410079956,
-0.09019817411899567,
0.7620351910591125,
0.5385258197784424,
0.015952114015817642,
-0.28921934962272644,
-0.02309631183743477,
0.1711350679397583,
0.3838929533958435,
-0.6354119777679443,
0.005222788546234369,
0.4269688129425049,
-0.212889164686203,
-0.13266141712665558,
0.14980801939964294,
-1.189517617225647,
-0.46420785784721375,
-0.048846546560525894,
0.5447266697883606,
-0.6990360021591187,
-0.06564052402973175,
0.2603805661201477,
-0.532301664352417,
0.4098535478115082,
0.15829749405384064,
-0.7378513216972351,
0.3142721951007843,
0.43951722979545593,
0.9533593654632568,
-0.1507783830165863,
-0.35947269201278687,
-0.8203055262565613,
0.38751307129859924,
-0.10231080651283264,
1.1003775596618652,
-0.3305697441101074,
-0.24564515054225922,
0.0621320940554142,
-0.11691952496767044,
-0.19647952914237976,
-0.4005170464515686,
0.7685476541519165,
-0.28870922327041626,
0.40890929102897644,
0.2470686286687851,
-0.6958274245262146,
-0.14219188690185547,
0.14377814531326294,
-0.5519416928291321,
1.0182160139083862,
0.06574730575084686,
-1.0338330268859863,
0.49769124388694763,
-0.6890202760696411,
-0.504641056060791,
0.3409561514854431,
-0.11627618968486786,
-0.37970584630966187,
0.3671814799308777,
0.26792988181114197,
0.42684540152549744,
-0.10120236128568649,
0.534659206867218,
-0.39281222224235535,
-0.4668707251548767,
0.13236071169376373,
-0.45101648569107056,
0.25464513897895813,
0.17771704494953156,
-0.3024404048919678,
0.31862136721611023,
-0.7987565398216248,
0.04609678313136101,
0.19284315407276154,
0.07598377764225006,
-0.6253957152366638,
-0.028847910463809967,
0.1455802470445633,
0.23400326073169708,
0.054428234696388245,
-0.5373775362968445,
-0.1333494931459427,
-0.7744782567024231,
0.40878596901893616,
0.5744413733482361,
0.2227112352848053,
0.7197707295417786,
0.05603931471705437,
0.394191175699234,
0.028457053005695343,
0.20633263885974884,
-0.29056042432785034,
-0.5465648770332336,
-1.2469496726989746,
-0.23932094871997833,
0.35866206884384155,
0.7390296459197998,
-1.2194292545318604,
0.5837399959564209,
-0.5632326602935791,
-0.036393895745277405,
-0.8129341006278992,
0.11030450463294983,
0.17669394612312317,
0.5132560729980469,
0.26215052604675293,
-0.2535388469696045,
-0.6963711380958557,
-1.2417036294937134,
-0.593902051448822,
0.19918639957904816,
-0.4160209596157074,
0.23050422966480255,
0.5550254583358765,
-0.20965327322483063,
1.1441086530685425,
-0.6931143403053284,
-0.3690164089202881,
-0.4279564321041107,
0.19936344027519226,
0.26205766201019287,
0.3730665147304535,
0.4677973687648773,
-0.8769322633743286,
0.018298344686627388,
-0.09231125563383102,
-0.6846693754196167,
-0.014815235510468483,
-0.34491342306137085,
-0.30149465799331665,
-0.00512219313532114,
0.5107512474060059,
-0.46233779191970825,
0.9337983727455139,
0.4928648769855499,
-0.5544116497039795,
0.21322445571422577,
-0.31083834171295166,
0.11249030381441116,
-1.320363998413086,
-0.058624301105737686,
0.27566269040107727,
-0.10337109118700027,
-0.8809555172920227,
0.10822876542806625,
-0.09440760314464569,
-0.04548361152410507,
-0.3595496714115143,
0.7462702393531799,
-0.17409180104732513,
0.163626030087471,
-0.3344901204109192,
0.3743668794631958,
0.21807512640953064,
0.46851444244384766,
0.08216854184865952,
0.679044783115387,
0.6385300159454346,
-0.5714318752288818,
0.0050283693708479404,
0.2606680691242218,
-0.24729689955711365,
0.7311331629753113,
-0.6745961904525757,
-0.08145159482955933,
-0.15242919325828552,
0.043647486716508865,
-0.8811278343200684,
-0.5099351406097412,
0.45591193437576294,
-0.1612575352191925,
-0.00325382174924016,
0.06593118607997894,
-0.532390296459198,
-0.46840527653694153,
-0.12552271783351898,
0.4237215518951416,
0.2094935029745102,
-0.3259204030036926,
1.2062568664550781,
-0.017664965242147446,
-0.1823832392692566,
-0.32961785793304443,
-0.9420208930969238,
0.5099077820777893,
-0.28279563784599304,
-0.6359993815422058,
0.26906466484069824,
0.08158203214406967,
-0.17706707119941711,
0.16322144865989685,
-0.24927133321762085,
-0.42854997515678406,
-0.025812216103076935,
0.4045734107494354,
0.5292908549308777,
-0.1614963561296463,
0.18680065870285034,
0.10124718397855759,
-0.14781486988067627,
-0.24171900749206543,
-0.4806748032569885,
0.3624802529811859,
-0.28548479080200195,
-0.28584903478622437,
-0.4581536054611206,
0.6186726689338684,
0.1259041577577591,
-0.25089073181152344,
0.8286616802215576,
0.6458918452262878,
-0.5075346827507019,
-0.1391976922750473,
-0.7842360734939575,
0.04267163947224617,
-0.48376771807670593,
0.40333259105682373,
-0.36840376257896423,
-0.8195441365242004,
0.325947105884552,
-0.3221893310546875,
-0.1554352045059204,
0.20336203277111053,
-0.14866308867931366,
-0.25290271639823914,
0.5236579775810242,
0.7496175169944763,
0.25879955291748047,
0.6142190098762512,
-0.12293694913387299,
0.44867685437202454,
-0.7522405385971069,
0.02420438639819622,
-0.1690066009759903,
-0.026270978152751923,
-0.2688225507736206,
-0.582307755947113,
0.0636446475982666,
0.24261628091335297,
0.24363625049591064,
0.1424080729484558,
-0.17920663952827454,
0.5041120648384094,
0.7139525413513184,
0.28687500953674316,
0.21815413236618042,
-0.03186503425240517,
0.025182398036122322,
-0.2482866495847702,
-1.0201928615570068,
-0.3135896623134613,
0.6839019656181335,
-0.0991925597190857,
0.19824787974357605,
0.01019197329878807,
0.7294226288795471,
0.08246555179357529,
0.14125628769397736,
-0.757465660572052,
0.5457468628883362,
-0.14110444486141205,
-0.20556889474391937,
-0.14566244184970856,
-0.2629135251045227,
-0.9570780396461487,
0.3358052372932434,
-0.5820215344429016,
-0.8707742094993591,
0.3323875069618225,
0.27998438477516174,
-0.2917567193508148,
0.1458975374698639,
-0.9647914171218872,
1.0006754398345947,
0.016439687460660934,
-0.4739578068256378,
-0.1137249618768692,
-0.8731222748756409,
0.4616393446922302,
-0.05156959220767021,
0.6349053978919983,
0.17549028992652893,
-0.024828746914863586,
0.5249301791191101,
-0.3413309156894684,
0.8709754347801208,
-0.00020927353762090206,
0.08857918530702591,
0.09889744967222214,
-0.1204456239938736,
0.4015149772167206,
0.05562364310026169,
-0.18213967978954315,
0.21215052902698517,
-0.2922922968864441,
-0.7686182856559753,
-0.9424475431442261,
0.5917525291442871,
-0.08994431048631668,
-0.7092073559761047,
-0.5778229236602783,
-0.7268952131271362,
-0.2343173772096634,
0.3859238028526306,
0.4299958348274231,
0.2881450355052948,
-0.3152872622013092,
-0.2975687086582184,
0.6170492768287659,
-0.19454093277454376,
0.5738028883934021,
0.1809922456741333,
-0.1125226765871048,
-0.373540461063385,
0.9790945053100586,
-0.3318641185760498,
0.531088650226593,
0.18114638328552246,
0.031942225992679596,
-0.00501118553802371,
-0.6500310897827148,
-0.36167290806770325,
0.1684706211090088,
-0.6403728723526001,
-0.08719193935394287,
-0.49393633008003235,
-0.1549077183008194,
-0.09311936795711517,
-0.25531521439552307,
-0.023701023310422897,
-0.24237792193889618,
-0.31062552332878113,
0.1302274614572525,
0.4051503539085388,
0.5222102999687195,
0.1945255696773529,
0.5003525614738464,
-0.5860411524772644,
0.5830039381980896,
0.18161052465438843,
0.509751558303833,
-0.2061809003353119,
-0.5441084504127502,
-0.06302587687969208,
-0.06441240012645721,
0.05981217697262764,
-0.7519504427909851,
0.21505612134933472,
0.6827585697174072,
0.3209071457386017,
0.5526236891746521,
0.06370483338832855,
1.1619906425476074,
-0.745451807975769,
0.7115945219993591,
0.36180272698402405,
-1.0183285474777222,
1.024398922920227,
-0.10959355533123016,
0.6521629095077515,
0.6951718926429749,
-0.21410802006721497,
-0.5312380790710449,
-0.8834096789360046,
-0.5398030877113342,
-1.0977914333343506,
0.3149714469909668,
0.39851662516593933,
0.05057791247963905,
-0.24482350051403046,
0.5904903411865234,
0.08254113793373108,
0.17132620513439178,
-0.7017307877540588,
-0.15047363936901093,
-0.334170401096344,
-0.4586520195007324,
-0.026508178561925888,
-0.06480750441551208,
-0.04646456241607666,
-0.16982658207416534,
0.43414491415023804,
-0.2946212887763977,
0.08259312063455582,
0.4014587104320526,
-0.3952878415584564,
0.2758333384990692,
0.5053098201751709,
0.4117107391357422,
0.3690791428089142,
-0.008121863007545471,
0.14634084701538086,
0.4397214949131012,
-0.4620283544063568,
-0.27404946088790894,
0.4135974943637848,
-0.29680898785591125,
0.15682078897953033,
0.5969094634056091,
1.0951173305511475,
0.6535727977752686,
-0.8201031684875488,
0.7414120435714722,
-0.2334997057914734,
-0.21848444640636444,
-0.02074192278087139,
0.15320517122745514,
0.042930785566568375,
0.2599364221096039,
0.30165717005729675,
0.7792054414749146,
0.45860010385513306,
-0.23017919063568115,
0.2870156168937683,
0.3895050287246704,
-0.49635347723960876,
0.007347382605075836,
0.5718436241149902,
0.13230793178081512,
-0.3783351182937622,
0.43140628933906555,
-0.24555939435958862,
-0.22822748124599457,
0.33884307742118835,
0.5685969591140747,
0.5963700413703918,
-0.05271467939019203,
0.3581559658050537,
0.1339992731809616,
0.2906860113143921,
0.09338046610355377,
0.20794539153575897,
0.025199832394719124,
-0.6071739196777344,
-0.6284317374229431,
-0.6292819976806641,
0.0366901159286499,
-0.04744502156972885,
-0.8960148692131042,
0.1431727558374405,
-0.31028032302856445,
-0.0453198067843914,
-0.01697494089603424,
-0.524468719959259,
-0.9331122636795044,
0.18714205920696259,
0.02232496254146099,
0.8996917605400085,
-0.891609787940979,
0.5963205099105835,
0.37759992480278015,
-0.3697810471057892,
-0.4696509540081024,
0.3979406952857971,
-0.24966716766357422,
-0.6091378927230835,
0.20101483166217804,
0.2127351015806198,
-0.3058148920536041,
0.09462469071149826,
-0.4041433334350586,
-0.7435545325279236,
1.0223182439804077,
0.4203370213508606,
-0.5636041164398193,
0.1672075092792511,
-0.1061672568321228,
0.41680431365966797,
-0.28535348176956177,
-0.08393122255802155,
0.5929740071296692,
0.4594898521900177,
0.2547386586666107,
-0.608950674533844,
0.14712463319301605,
-0.4654582440853119,
0.43484994769096375,
0.24199454486370087,
-0.037988945841789246,
0.1066172644495964,
-0.45243963599205017,
-0.4621843099594116,
0.4368821084499359,
1.0942636728286743,
0.15604737401008606,
0.3982693552970886,
0.8824486136436462,
0.6664510369300842,
0.7171120643615723,
-0.13821744918823242,
1.157410979270935,
-0.019276320934295654,
-0.04516471549868584,
1.4762572050094604,
-0.30846214294433594,
1.1353464126586914,
1.0173447132110596,
0.2197478711605072,
0.70221346616745,
0.5309038162231445,
-0.15400643646717072,
0.5610677599906921,
0.11270661652088165,
-0.5826720595359802,
-0.2334398776292801,
-0.36365991830825806,
-0.08611257374286652,
0.3156990706920624,
0.5146430730819702,
-0.13608205318450928,
-0.13080449402332306,
0.41270676255226135,
-0.31731536984443665,
0.1762823462486267,
-0.16137216985225677,
0.9397493004798889,
-0.08438105136156082,
-0.6965445280075073,
0.19774411618709564,
-0.3567811846733093,
0.8656842112541199,
-0.6429528594017029,
-0.23423798382282257,
0.07953494042158127,
-0.036998968571424484,
-0.2112678736448288,
-0.7790973782539368,
0.3615409731864929,
-0.16133415699005127,
-0.14319108426570892,
0.20681864023208618,
0.7293811440467834,
-0.478643000125885,
-0.7631723880767822,
0.1634223312139511,
0.4242869019508362,
-0.1089189201593399,
0.032800834625959396,
-0.42919328808784485,
-0.02181924693286419,
-0.10511787235736847,
0.05327626317739487,
0.23382017016410828,
0.5421435236930847,
0.15593838691711426,
0.718752384185791,
0.582781970500946,
0.06096692010760307,
0.0425080880522728,
0.222995787858963,
0.8949434757232666,
-0.5469369888305664,
-0.5465684533119202,
-0.6864389777183533,
0.6644697785377502,
-0.618919312953949,
-0.5604706406593323,
0.5833926796913147,
0.4655255377292633,
0.4202432632446289,
-0.12485963106155396,
0.8176513910293579,
-0.08220193535089493,
-0.037018537521362305,
-0.6472495794296265,
0.30395016074180603,
-0.525937020778656,
0.22755785286426544,
-0.33623775839805603,
-0.7132890820503235,
-0.7245630621910095,
0.6784952282905579,
-0.3036649525165558,
-0.39576902985572815,
0.9666337966918945,
0.5696929693222046,
-0.2016744315624237,
0.08895138651132584,
0.09287982434034348,
0.26465800404548645,
-0.020459389314055443,
0.3438717722892761,
0.6015048027038574,
-0.5465754270553589,
0.6722100377082825,
-0.07383690774440765,
-0.3729041516780853,
0.10626813024282455,
-1.0421663522720337,
-0.8273307681083679,
-0.5782739520072937,
-0.3629249632358551,
-0.24648220837116241,
0.28217700123786926,
0.4981379806995392,
0.5577312111854553,
-0.6952002048492432,
0.13101236522197723,
-0.5271923542022705,
0.009762179106473923,
-0.28219372034072876,
-0.3106566071510315,
0.3039526641368866,
-0.3535447120666504,
-0.5336151123046875,
0.3649527132511139,
0.6559280157089233,
0.0020996215753257275,
0.16661563515663147,
0.1179865226149559,
-0.4673384130001068,
0.2335389405488968,
0.4709371030330658,
0.21355096995830536,
-1.207802653312683,
-0.4772500693798065,
-0.12283287942409515,
0.3581060469150543,
-0.03029419295489788,
0.6968904137611389,
-0.8943790197372437,
0.5894668102264404,
-0.08722977340221405,
0.6331980228424072,
0.5300178527832031,
-0.33958691358566284,
0.9015755653381348,
-0.9642066955566406,
0.6801813840866089,
0.1170918270945549,
0.5585013628005981,
0.36964282393455505,
-0.29669296741485596,
0.30078577995300293,
0.11194641888141632,
-0.15927398204803467,
-0.7208840847015381,
0.5333614945411682,
-1.196295142173767,
-0.3896811306476593,
0.8386696577072144,
-0.18625421822071075,
-0.47447359561920166,
-0.3312018811702728,
-0.3473450243473053,
0.20662225782871246,
-0.23190933465957642,
0.6167135238647461,
0.7815248370170593,
0.0932982861995697,
-0.26711973547935486,
-0.9138698577880859,
0.26823046803474426,
0.6241293549537659,
-1.0003292560577393,
-0.2958577871322632,
0.31117668747901917,
0.1578492820262909,
0.1332019567489624,
0.26684823632240295,
0.4968840479850769,
0.3782734274864197,
0.10081048309803009,
0.046592723578214645,
0.3173435926437378,
0.09794948995113373,
-0.45307645201683044,
-0.033377669751644135,
-0.1771918088197708,
-0.3674852252006531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12413v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12413v1
|
Targeted Multilingual Adaptation for Low-resource Language Families
| 2024-05-20T23:38:06 | 2024-05-20T23:38:06 |
C. M. Downey, Terra Blevins, Dhwani Serai, Dwija Parikh, Shane Steinert-Threlkeld
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The "massively-multilingual" training of multilingual models is known to
limit their utility in any one language, and they perform particularly poorly
on low-resource languages. However, there is evidence that low-resource
languages can benefit from targeted multilinguality, where the model is trained
on closely related languages. To test this approach more rigorously, we
systematically study best practices for adapting a pre-trained model to a
language family. Focusing on the Uralic family as a test case, we adapt XLM-R
under various configurations to model 15 languages; we then evaluate the
performance of each experimental setting on two downstream tasks and 11
evaluation languages. Our adapted models significantly outperform mono- and
multilingual baselines. Furthermore, a regression analysis of hyperparameter
effects reveals that adapted vocabulary size is relatively unimportant for
low-resource languages, and that low-resource languages can be aggressively
up-sampled during training at little detriment to performance in high-resource
languages. These results introduce new best practices for performing language
adaptation in a targeted setting.
|
[
-0.2733018100261688,
-0.167710080742836,
0.27028948068618774,
0.35160553455352783,
-0.1582878679037094,
0.21271470189094543,
-0.6899811625480652,
-0.31202664971351624,
-0.0417645238339901,
0.5091766715049744,
-0.4994613528251648,
-0.22136086225509644,
-0.5741270184516907,
0.3127513527870178,
0.10055311769247055,
1.2506439685821533,
-0.13623186945915222,
-0.06162061542272568,
0.30815431475639343,
-0.738007664680481,
-0.5324257016181946,
-0.6974613070487976,
-0.5736609697341919,
-0.2091415822505951,
0.8411715030670166,
0.6894081830978394,
0.7777312397956848,
0.6781051158905029,
0.4496470093727112,
0.21656760573387146,
0.1714026778936386,
-0.04189072921872139,
-0.902594804763794,
-0.031055467203259468,
-0.3343157470226288,
-0.3467923402786255,
-0.251704603433609,
-0.2141333520412445,
0.8822211623191833,
0.9721179604530334,
-0.04474940896034241,
0.53984534740448,
0.40822333097457886,
0.47870489954948425,
-0.953938364982605,
-0.1637798547744751,
-0.7415140867233276,
0.14835409820079803,
-0.13348433375358582,
-0.3580249547958374,
-0.6396116614341736,
0.01507248729467392,
-0.2058137059211731,
-0.5360623002052307,
-0.00907638669013977,
0.26575496792793274,
0.4900364577770233,
0.17242255806922913,
-0.1584029197692871,
0.10407388210296631,
-1.0463279485702515,
1.0136353969573975,
-0.4711255133152008,
0.6281418800354004,
0.20628467202186584,
0.06777298450469971,
-0.06335482746362686,
-0.218454971909523,
-0.07851307094097137,
-0.330099493265152,
-0.08636339753866196,
0.23943425714969635,
-0.4591579735279083,
-0.06827128678560257,
0.2899066209793091,
-0.10753567516803741,
-0.7619410753250122,
0.2574913799762726,
-0.2987513542175293,
-0.06632392108440399,
0.2878011167049408,
-0.010425552725791931,
0.23674289882183075,
-0.006814528256654739,
-0.30641379952430725,
-0.19639073312282562,
-0.5607766509056091,
-0.1075829491019249,
0.41404250264167786,
0.865192711353302,
-0.40025997161865234,
0.32717618346214294,
0.05749258026480675,
0.7103120684623718,
-0.16946975886821747,
-0.32329070568084717,
-0.030041832476854324,
-0.7348959445953369,
-0.014002152718603611,
-0.045835647732019424,
0.32438385486602783,
0.1652388870716095,
0.5773354768753052,
-0.2652989625930786,
-0.19391565024852753,
-0.2907165288925171,
0.004027836490422487,
-0.6363534927368164,
0.031201278790831566,
-0.264534056186676,
-0.4606582522392273,
0.12879741191864014,
-0.5963048338890076,
-0.7993965744972229,
-0.14913645386695862,
-0.25191566348075867,
0.3861863911151886,
-0.3380771279335022,
-0.30275803804397583,
0.07567744702100754,
-0.23035991191864014,
0.0967552438378334,
0.03019336611032486,
-1.1162935495376587,
0.5331617593765259,
0.2005832940340042,
0.7999873757362366,
-0.20759738981723785,
-0.7712328433990479,
-0.8461630344390869,
0.35497915744781494,
-0.14160509407520294,
0.8618661761283875,
-0.609021782875061,
-0.41340571641921997,
0.059274740517139435,
-0.07582978904247284,
-0.6322258114814758,
-0.6074897050857544,
0.45380353927612305,
-0.2951839864253998,
-0.16114972531795502,
-0.2790483832359314,
0.12097980082035065,
0.10355914384126663,
0.025235528126358986,
-0.5373400449752808,
0.967101514339447,
0.6385669112205505,
-0.5233586430549622,
0.5825830698013306,
-0.764107346534729,
-0.44214197993278503,
-0.027037665247917175,
0.23987247049808502,
0.032026972621679306,
0.3651125729084015,
0.05862145125865936,
0.16764141619205475,
-0.2517023980617523,
-0.4840410649776459,
-0.4427626430988312,
-0.2955869436264038,
0.06146040931344032,
-0.422778457403183,
0.6741135120391846,
0.20934291183948517,
-0.015633845701813698,
0.21169470250606537,
-0.6801186800003052,
0.09400633722543716,
0.1824401170015335,
-0.6662896275520325,
-0.6951340436935425,
-0.4056977927684784,
0.4383167028427124,
0.33700597286224365,
-0.12461459636688232,
-0.3308567702770233,
0.16839800775051117,
-0.11264048516750336,
0.15454618632793427,
0.5765650868415833,
-0.2152368277311325,
0.561289370059967,
-0.09468449652194977,
0.8295721411705017,
-0.22202160954475403,
0.29660284519195557,
0.07759593427181244,
-0.049500104039907455,
-0.8813617825508118,
-0.1693861037492752,
0.5702922344207764,
0.45633575320243835,
-0.7410349249839783,
0.016963651403784752,
-0.4619276821613312,
-0.1557311713695526,
-0.45309746265411377,
0.6224622130393982,
0.5607354044914246,
0.20090079307556152,
0.2646649479866028,
-0.5091593861579895,
-0.4486886262893677,
-0.7897982001304626,
-0.33101126551628113,
-0.16627924144268036,
0.24613012373447418,
0.23649051785469055,
0.6096760034561157,
-0.115065798163414,
0.3012416958808899,
-0.35447198152542114,
-0.12276826798915863,
-0.6939741373062134,
0.09673520177602768,
0.009938813745975494,
0.24212878942489624,
1.0137534141540527,
-0.5027964115142822,
-0.649978756904602,
0.2732068598270416,
-0.34014421701431274,
0.10334691405296326,
-0.10449269413948059,
-0.27556854486465454,
0.2578139901161194,
0.2506052851676941,
0.05736606940627098,
0.10833529382944107,
1.0838841199874878,
-0.19980284571647644,
0.5226671695709229,
-0.5469452142715454,
-0.07727852463722229,
-1.0773011445999146,
0.11885382235050201,
0.11654158681631088,
-0.19616107642650604,
-0.7020673751831055,
0.1364629715681076,
0.06638043373823166,
-0.16166938841342926,
-0.47580865025520325,
0.7592084407806396,
-0.5535702109336853,
-0.4688546359539032,
-0.4017210602760315,
-0.07707087695598602,
-0.25956785678863525,
0.6752631068229675,
0.17294606566429138,
1.0212773084640503,
0.35448455810546875,
-0.5955954194068909,
0.10869445651769638,
0.058223724365234375,
-0.2068510353565216,
0.637958824634552,
-0.23199525475502014,
0.14739887416362762,
-0.11093080043792725,
-0.08627382665872574,
-0.7609220743179321,
-0.13230034708976746,
0.15143616497516632,
-0.11507523059844971,
0.3869754374027252,
-0.5099548697471619,
-0.392599880695343,
-0.26378872990608215,
-0.13541367650032043,
0.6373788714408875,
0.338670015335083,
-0.577792763710022,
0.6754741072654724,
0.2022707760334015,
-0.5188438892364502,
-0.5280343294143677,
-0.6346254348754883,
0.12395220249891281,
-0.39922893047332764,
-0.33684206008911133,
0.20700134336948395,
-0.3006041944026947,
-0.23313778638839722,
-0.025412824004888535,
0.1245700865983963,
-0.3251672089099884,
0.17124025523662567,
-0.1826503425836563,
0.05260571464896202,
-0.5113090872764587,
-0.11667552590370178,
-0.008737768046557903,
-0.08084937185049057,
-0.2725808322429657,
-0.1929490566253662,
0.5919903516769409,
-0.015448740683495998,
-0.09586305916309357,
-0.011788720265030861,
0.4549158811569214,
0.5142632722854614,
-0.3208102881908417,
0.744408130645752,
0.6601389050483704,
-0.32479071617126465,
-0.3019793629646301,
-0.37345069646835327,
-0.16988474130630493,
-0.39213433861732483,
0.6697579622268677,
-0.4991653561592102,
-0.6624972820281982,
0.48579850792884827,
-0.17498824000358582,
0.10143984109163284,
0.23709441721439362,
0.654056966304779,
0.10059018433094025,
0.8380350470542908,
1.1441466808319092,
-0.25838160514831543,
0.5056968927383423,
-0.05564552918076515,
-0.019988376647233963,
-0.9472227692604065,
0.19609053432941437,
-0.7671806812286377,
-0.14447081089019775,
-0.598052978515625,
-0.2766932547092438,
0.2803709805011749,
-0.006056258454918861,
0.08658214658498764,
0.8076560497283936,
0.03430403769016266,
0.314287006855011,
0.4981590211391449,
-0.1399650126695633,
0.3408026397228241,
0.3967580497264862,
-0.21709328889846802,
-0.10344596952199936,
-1.060625672340393,
-0.2839618921279907,
1.0972237586975098,
0.15828393399715424,
0.7951189279556274,
0.287061482667923,
0.47078007459640503,
0.15812623500823975,
0.6911861896514893,
-0.7253614664077759,
0.0837840810418129,
-0.5115808248519897,
-0.6403900980949402,
-0.4291611313819885,
-0.38790467381477356,
-1.0613327026367188,
0.4834754467010498,
-0.18572473526000977,
-0.6015006899833679,
0.3260318636894226,
0.14110217988491058,
-0.661389946937561,
0.13755308091640472,
-0.8437474966049194,
0.8782365918159485,
-0.5850095152854919,
-0.386465460062027,
-0.40119609236717224,
-0.211944118142128,
0.08787261694669724,
-0.7025920152664185,
0.5872324109077454,
-0.10829706490039825,
0.06873742491006851,
0.7025467753410339,
0.28343695402145386,
0.6456608772277832,
0.010714965872466564,
0.0905681625008583,
-0.14984457194805145,
0.04522222653031349,
0.2202448695898056,
-0.1341475397348404,
-0.23442097008228302,
0.052836447954177856,
-0.0005114896921440959,
-0.7298012971878052,
-0.48986712098121643,
0.6867874264717102,
-0.8085065484046936,
-0.42672067880630493,
-0.3551211357116699,
-1.0623806715011597,
-0.4511483609676361,
0.32864660024642944,
0.014725436456501484,
0.3233736455440521,
-0.39302924275398254,
0.1062171459197998,
0.317546010017395,
-0.3541547954082489,
0.4754880368709564,
0.7922142744064331,
-0.16618646681308746,
-0.34795039892196655,
0.8330672979354858,
0.03825874626636505,
0.5763603448867798,
0.3497171998023987,
0.36890923976898193,
-0.24679437279701233,
-0.7354725003242493,
-0.7342662811279297,
0.3970058560371399,
-0.6463704109191895,
0.1713418811559677,
-0.2494947612285614,
0.10732080042362213,
-0.4060143530368805,
-0.08932282775640488,
-0.28319716453552246,
-0.16948524117469788,
0.0198114812374115,
0.16181325912475586,
0.11100891977548599,
0.5570002794265747,
-0.1791452020406723,
0.3532235324382782,
-0.9206282496452332,
0.14968371391296387,
0.26099395751953125,
0.16836996376514435,
-0.2610625922679901,
-1.1127861738204956,
-0.531577467918396,
-0.11609549075365067,
-0.08331546187400818,
-0.3203383982181549,
0.35614943504333496,
0.6576928496360779,
0.650278627872467,
0.07767394930124283,
-0.01722085103392601,
0.7843695878982544,
-0.7265081405639648,
0.06735797226428986,
0.2382967174053192,
-0.5335665941238403,
0.22138509154319763,
-0.35782232880592346,
0.4384046196937561,
0.7384474873542786,
0.6405391693115234,
-0.6106973886489868,
-0.05187873914837837,
-0.11774885654449463,
-0.4632088541984558,
0.7939550876617432,
0.15949483215808868,
0.5237936973571777,
0.374776154756546,
0.4164005517959595,
0.28044602274894714,
-0.053046632558107376,
-0.8207071423530579,
-0.2343067079782486,
0.012504774145781994,
-0.11774652451276779,
-0.2608064115047455,
-0.21965336799621582,
-0.3110068440437317,
-0.22929202020168304,
0.3582899272441864,
-0.4967731833457947,
0.080095574259758,
-0.31758394837379456,
-0.3971153199672699,
-0.45175182819366455,
0.42976194620132446,
0.6900243759155273,
0.8558062314987183,
-0.20048628747463226,
0.025300011038780212,
0.5253205895423889,
-0.41800862550735474,
0.23064926266670227,
0.30727657675743103,
0.10469633340835571,
-0.11577894538640976,
0.5681039094924927,
0.8392199277877808,
0.6730053424835205,
-0.5355571508407593,
0.16039492189884186,
-0.21544411778450012,
-0.021346036344766617,
-0.02647586353123188,
0.09287114441394806,
0.13918833434581757,
0.006248548161238432,
0.10535033047199249,
0.08297967165708542,
-0.17833128571510315,
-0.9008094668388367,
-0.05107206478714943,
0.2712250053882599,
-0.3641509413719177,
-0.4637460708618164,
0.24237120151519775,
0.26060950756073,
-0.22092027962207794,
0.40742623805999756,
0.048317503184080124,
-0.3105725049972534,
0.31910234689712524,
0.7778164744377136,
0.5394408106803894,
-0.4379901587963104,
0.1237579807639122,
0.3195939064025879,
0.5169469118118286,
0.15611931681632996,
0.3189584016799927,
0.1934846192598343,
-0.9025750756263733,
-0.613996684551239,
-0.6957929134368896,
-0.3796180486679077,
0.2244108021259308,
-0.8930686712265015,
0.1295756846666336,
-0.3588595390319824,
-0.12553247809410095,
0.2938440442085266,
-0.17786085605621338,
-0.8352701663970947,
-0.04436956346035004,
0.19640575349330902,
0.9862872362136841,
-1.065516471862793,
0.9173682332038879,
0.7978968620300293,
-0.4732084274291992,
-0.5649237632751465,
0.08187701553106308,
-0.11185751855373383,
-1.0982410907745361,
0.8231995105743408,
-0.26806187629699707,
-0.23823441565036774,
0.24931292235851288,
0.0032376956660300493,
-1.1225172281265259,
0.6370856165885925,
0.810203492641449,
-0.49411845207214355,
0.1568288952112198,
0.3631206452846527,
0.5105161666870117,
-0.3881707191467285,
0.05232047289609909,
0.6671619415283203,
0.5782569646835327,
-0.2434876412153244,
-1.0610991716384888,
-0.07336071133613586,
0.09835658222436905,
0.12406988441944122,
0.18072089552879333,
-0.6535438299179077,
0.46376875042915344,
-0.3447495698928833,
-0.020916499197483063,
0.21214497089385986,
0.5057891607284546,
0.15603338181972504,
-0.06787891685962677,
0.6152176260948181,
0.30148252844810486,
0.4517678916454315,
0.04533902183175087,
1.259157657623291,
-0.518744170665741,
0.22316521406173706,
1.0226739645004272,
-0.5176928043365479,
0.8552530407905579,
0.5975028872489929,
-0.15917038917541504,
0.2361774891614914,
0.4836481511592865,
0.11574321985244751,
0.5673649311065674,
0.12354037910699844,
-0.2211226224899292,
-0.4045656621456146,
-0.6892129182815552,
-0.16476768255233765,
0.5863946676254272,
0.3778911232948303,
-0.2296542525291443,
-0.41350510716438293,
0.31487759947776794,
0.16820693016052246,
0.08500595390796661,
-0.49982014298439026,
0.586457371711731,
0.0336306095123291,
-0.6637166142463684,
0.8738784193992615,
0.09532073140144348,
0.4953288733959198,
-0.5702793002128601,
0.1525517702102661,
-0.3794366717338562,
0.34763026237487793,
-0.06466543674468994,
-0.432198166847229,
0.10338548570871353,
0.13666951656341553,
-0.2678762376308441,
-0.2061341553926468,
0.7075397968292236,
-0.4443676471710205,
-0.7100803256034851,
0.7469887137413025,
0.7968077063560486,
0.04493306204676628,
0.01950969733297825,
-0.8246400952339172,
0.221329927444458,
-0.12661771476268768,
0.037332214415073395,
0.7729604840278625,
0.27869054675102234,
-0.09871415048837662,
0.4909723401069641,
0.7202378511428833,
0.38138309121131897,
0.10242240875959396,
0.4846383333206177,
0.8366904258728027,
-0.5316953659057617,
-0.1388590782880783,
-0.5103710293769836,
0.07155060768127441,
0.2280343472957611,
-0.6490579843521118,
0.8181844353675842,
0.5102601051330566,
1.1993708610534668,
-0.24218744039535522,
0.865606963634491,
0.33061590790748596,
0.18329986929893494,
-0.4756561815738678,
0.5010496973991394,
-0.7038648724555969,
-0.34018784761428833,
-0.2132522463798523,
-1.1705633401870728,
-0.343064546585083,
0.3254530131816864,
-0.27481743693351746,
0.23874518275260925,
0.9489409327507019,
0.5401977896690369,
-0.2621493935585022,
-0.3829580247402191,
0.7042314410209656,
0.023814905434846878,
-0.18529915809631348,
0.585874080657959,
0.7236690521240234,
-0.10349514335393906,
0.9510771036148071,
-0.5115681290626526,
-0.3949906527996063,
-0.3063613772392273,
-0.8963648676872253,
-0.8355407118797302,
-0.24278026819229126,
-0.259762167930603,
-0.11370012164115906,
0.3892734944820404,
0.9609963297843933,
0.982137143611908,
-0.8817079663276672,
-0.6209034323692322,
0.4515594244003296,
-0.1650533378124237,
-0.4767168164253235,
-0.07986294478178024,
0.19094659388065338,
-0.384507954120636,
-0.7288116216659546,
0.5240961909294128,
0.4967901110649109,
-0.09537447988986969,
-0.19379746913909912,
-0.21414923667907715,
-0.12529155611991882,
-0.08875047415494919,
0.7018823623657227,
0.6007193922996521,
-0.36348041892051697,
-0.3549872040748596,
0.02512178011238575,
-0.08646927028894424,
0.09315108507871628,
1.0237864255905151,
-0.17530998587608337,
0.16170716285705566,
0.08799328655004501,
0.6885472536087036,
0.2049720138311386,
-0.20003190636634827,
0.619266927242279,
-0.6828060746192932,
0.3563404679298401,
0.1284070461988449,
0.523595929145813,
0.2977968752384186,
-0.21797405183315277,
0.42241811752319336,
0.15946054458618164,
-0.24827350676059723,
-0.8104795813560486,
0.29611366987228394,
-0.7066077589988708,
-0.18414412438869476,
1.53121817111969,
-0.23896490037441254,
-0.16053541004657745,
-0.39566877484321594,
-0.14545665681362152,
0.21254098415374756,
-0.36626607179641724,
0.6439473628997803,
0.7484886050224304,
-0.07389695197343826,
-0.2172047197818756,
-0.6803475022315979,
0.2604767382144928,
0.6371902823448181,
-0.72337806224823,
0.3259616792201996,
0.004502041731029749,
0.4000239968299866,
0.14060448110103607,
0.35200726985931396,
0.01959575153887272,
0.4105387330055237,
-0.24513986706733704,
0.06879037618637085,
0.22698594629764557,
-0.45666760206222534,
-0.6803041100502014,
-0.06226630508899689,
0.7612564563751221,
0.20667539536952972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00013v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00013v1
|
Thesis: Document Summarization with applications to Keyword extraction and Image Retrieval
| 2024-05-20T21:27:18 | 2024-05-20T21:27:18 |
Jayaprakash Sundararaj
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Automatic summarization is the process of reducing a text document in order
to generate a summary that retains the most important points of the original
document. In this work, we study two problems - i) summarizing a text document
as set of keywords/caption, for image recommedation, ii) generating opinion
summary which good mix of relevancy and sentiment with the text document.
Intially, we present our work on an recommending images for enhancing a
substantial amount of existing plain text news articles. We use probabilistic
models and word similarity heuristics to generate captions and extract
Key-phrases which are re-ranked using a rank aggregation framework with
relevance feedback mechanism. We show that such rank aggregation and relevant
feedback which are typically used in Tagging Documents, Text Information
Retrieval also helps in improving image retrieval. These queries are fed to the
Yahoo Search Engine to obtain relevant images 1. Our proposed method is
observed to perform better than all existing baselines. Additonally, We propose
a set of submodular functions for opinion summarization. Opinion summarization
has built in it the tasks of summarization and sentiment detection. However, it
is not easy to detect sentiment and simultaneously extract summary. The two
tasks conflict in the sense that the demand of compression may drop sentiment
bearing sentences, and the demand of sentiment detection may bring in redundant
sentences. However, using submodularity we show how to strike a balance between
the two requirements. Our functions generate summaries such that there is good
correlation between document sentiment and summary sentiment along with good
ROUGE score. We also compare the performances of the proposed submodular
functions.
|
[
-0.6306944489479065,
-0.5873642563819885,
0.4643809497356415,
0.02090097777545452,
-0.7130779027938843,
0.03926168382167816,
-0.032308924943208694,
-0.2067941278219223,
0.5888431072235107,
0.3914746642112732,
-0.0053961859084665775,
-0.4730414152145386,
-0.6600871682167053,
0.04768352955579758,
-0.5496921539306641,
1.0302478075027466,
0.05033646523952484,
-0.10540656745433807,
-0.39928147196769714,
-0.3198162615299225,
-0.39020660519599915,
-0.21214205026626587,
-0.5904332399368286,
-0.31017982959747314,
0.2968261241912842,
0.3084598481655121,
0.7239590287208557,
0.40931862592697144,
0.9501806497573853,
0.4006333351135254,
0.11286500096321106,
-0.023300426080822945,
-0.2833611071109772,
0.33830955624580383,
-0.24752631783485413,
-0.410195916891098,
-0.46535471081733704,
0.11297065764665604,
0.5823734998703003,
0.28112804889678955,
0.1688312292098999,
-0.12736709415912628,
-0.08660247921943665,
1.0294584035873413,
-0.5366817712783813,
0.464923232793808,
-0.48271483182907104,
0.004622753243893385,
0.06334389746189117,
-0.44653210043907166,
-0.014687848277390003,
-0.5348055362701416,
0.18602505326271057,
-0.5183289647102356,
0.45191946625709534,
0.09822367876768112,
0.8450586199760437,
0.254800021648407,
-0.20178644359111786,
-0.6683022975921631,
-0.16256661713123322,
0.906707227230072,
-0.830411434173584,
-0.04935278370976448,
0.27876660227775574,
0.1623791605234146,
0.1293657273054123,
-0.6806167960166931,
-0.4294147193431854,
-0.08081453293561935,
-0.3570082485675812,
0.8060970902442932,
-0.10624188184738159,
0.0746375024318695,
0.013812814839184284,
0.9039371013641357,
-0.3068910837173462,
-0.18828918039798737,
-0.42811477184295654,
-0.1081974133849144,
0.6131538152694702,
0.014784703962504864,
0.2612192928791046,
-0.43690598011016846,
0.09354932606220245,
-0.1548887938261032,
-0.3367469012737274,
0.07532461732625961,
0.5836352705955505,
-0.034792810678482056,
0.11883901059627533,
0.624488890171051,
-0.39294078946113586,
0.4049946963787079,
-0.08020041882991791,
-0.34025174379348755,
0.263214647769928,
-0.20335695147514343,
-0.10355979204177856,
-0.18361499905586243,
0.6584805846214294,
0.9556580185890198,
0.31297385692596436,
0.05450494959950447,
-0.3312644362449646,
-0.12836909294128418,
0.29095059633255005,
-0.6483333110809326,
-0.2151515930891037,
0.36287444829940796,
-1.0902702808380127,
-0.7388670444488525,
0.24297592043876648,
-0.8543729782104492,
-0.2088550180196762,
-0.27246248722076416,
0.43565499782562256,
-0.5187579393386841,
-0.23245248198509216,
-0.20897236466407776,
-0.7083971500396729,
0.3003363013267517,
0.432659775018692,
-0.7118066549301147,
0.19057752192020416,
0.5716285109519958,
1.0536943674087524,
-0.2586401402950287,
0.010300219990313053,
-0.12445462495088577,
0.01581922173500061,
-0.3173697292804718,
1.076365351676941,
-0.370866060256958,
-0.7366423010826111,
0.1264963299036026,
0.1355418860912323,
0.16940507292747498,
-0.5908021926879883,
0.5772076845169067,
-0.5470084547996521,
0.2476314902305603,
-0.18571646511554718,
-0.6891207098960876,
-0.3224124014377594,
0.33541637659072876,
-0.7160909175872803,
0.6691258549690247,
0.13088738918304443,
-0.9723929762840271,
0.1419227123260498,
-0.5497883558273315,
-0.9582998752593994,
0.09649711102247238,
-0.04612283781170845,
-0.5052662491798401,
0.3625375032424927,
0.4527939260005951,
0.3906475007534027,
-0.04828978702425957,
-0.2867279052734375,
0.050106748938560486,
-0.23493637144565582,
0.05248750001192093,
0.25608980655670166,
0.35330861806869507,
0.27692779898643494,
-0.06790100783109665,
0.006432437803596258,
-0.17963428795337677,
-0.013921109959483147,
0.08162066340446472,
-0.3939646780490875,
-0.6171390414237976,
0.23147456347942352,
-0.012289696373045444,
-0.2650928199291229,
0.42668184638023376,
-0.3079407513141632,
0.18733365833759308,
-0.43292036652565,
0.31769514083862305,
0.43793147802352905,
0.3423531949520111,
0.6359269618988037,
-0.5565235614776611,
0.5688837766647339,
-0.02289075404405594,
-0.005127345211803913,
-0.8047850131988525,
-0.3409110903739929,
-0.6076875925064087,
-0.3813783526420593,
0.5142889618873596,
0.6435285210609436,
-1.0146186351776123,
0.3443080186843872,
-0.2215857207775116,
-0.44663286209106445,
-0.4248714745044708,
0.14863212406635284,
0.4246118366718292,
0.4490736126899719,
0.21684043109416962,
-0.531922459602356,
-0.367888867855072,
-1.0133293867111206,
-0.30317986011505127,
-0.2683974504470825,
0.07506614923477173,
0.14358556270599365,
0.40262964367866516,
0.17905853688716888,
0.9086578488349915,
-0.7641433477401733,
-0.693403959274292,
-0.4844869375228882,
0.6700226068496704,
0.39459550380706787,
0.4220983386039734,
0.7969157695770264,
-1.046619176864624,
-0.3353249132633209,
-0.1486835926771164,
-0.7660391926765442,
-0.21320855617523193,
0.05267077684402466,
0.1919839084148407,
0.36504417657852173,
0.40560343861579895,
-0.42009657621383667,
0.3122215270996094,
0.09636349976062775,
0.40453335642814636,
0.267110675573349,
-0.47678276896476746,
0.5158369541168213,
-1.280252456665039,
-0.09462245553731918,
0.11435875296592712,
-0.2770322263240814,
-0.09556886553764343,
0.22586728632450104,
-0.03374844789505005,
-0.023343229666352272,
-0.1748596578836441,
0.21022173762321472,
-0.6524409651756287,
-0.19533132016658783,
-0.8475255966186523,
0.3109129071235657,
-0.08393658697605133,
0.27982795238494873,
0.20554843544960022,
0.5251402258872986,
0.5751310586929321,
-0.2985703647136688,
0.4315847158432007,
0.019589310511946678,
-0.0701008290052414,
0.6416193246841431,
-0.8018630146980286,
-0.20847350358963013,
-0.5592105984687805,
0.03933790698647499,
-1.2503219842910767,
-0.19124732911586761,
-0.17181184887886047,
-0.5675056576728821,
0.413749098777771,
-0.18615438044071198,
-0.570895254611969,
-0.23995168507099152,
-0.9304807782173157,
-0.10357023775577545,
0.6329161524772644,
-0.12092708796262741,
0.6245813369750977,
0.8219085931777954,
-0.5737987756729126,
-0.5007008910179138,
-0.3404926061630249,
0.20370276272296906,
-0.08866795152425766,
-0.31326836347579956,
0.4088755249977112,
0.1772432029247284,
-0.3834785521030426,
0.36039435863494873,
-0.009795724414288998,
0.1833210438489914,
-0.1977647840976715,
0.3166784644126892,
0.26020342111587524,
0.20008863508701324,
0.15748558938503265,
0.39008602499961853,
-0.27524542808532715,
-0.1867849975824356,
-0.18190070986747742,
0.20962493121623993,
-0.30791541934013367,
0.14478839933872223,
0.05142824351787567,
0.7402871251106262,
0.5740827918052673,
-0.09681610763072968,
0.28253287076950073,
0.6634873747825623,
-0.2745898365974426,
0.17494463920593262,
-0.46750250458717346,
0.12047281116247177,
-0.39006364345550537,
0.1950489729642868,
-0.19783668220043182,
-0.5273623466491699,
0.45102614164352417,
-0.11638340353965759,
0.3991239368915558,
0.6260671615600586,
0.6934551000595093,
-0.5906928777694702,
0.7810317277908325,
0.5906820893287659,
-0.4048285186290741,
0.7060303688049316,
-0.5293366312980652,
0.26457226276397705,
-0.5756527781486511,
0.16712917387485504,
-0.42002809047698975,
-0.36787742376327515,
-0.7040782570838928,
0.020528409630060196,
0.48775580525398254,
-0.0741223692893982,
0.8324128985404968,
0.292595237493515,
-0.4960143268108368,
0.675463855266571,
0.6099876761436462,
0.030570361763238907,
0.2165975421667099,
0.04836968332529068,
-0.026474151760339737,
0.005810736212879419,
-0.23986998200416565,
-0.4811965227127075,
0.7793710231781006,
-0.0016063954681158066,
0.8709014654159546,
-0.014039691537618637,
0.8551517128944397,
0.9144221544265747,
0.3191242516040802,
-1.1369069814682007,
0.5980290174484253,
-0.48064830899238586,
-0.1874232143163681,
-0.20304352045059204,
-0.10454604029655457,
-0.8838320970535278,
0.4693734049797058,
-0.23461072146892548,
-0.23195910453796387,
0.03635047376155853,
0.017222950235009193,
-0.00971976388245821,
-0.10828471928834915,
-0.7222382426261902,
0.34767743945121765,
0.03689354285597801,
-0.13707518577575684,
-0.44477275013923645,
-0.7041445970535278,
0.20345988869667053,
0.05937286466360092,
0.2668256461620331,
0.08481726795434952,
-0.11348897218704224,
0.8531246781349182,
-0.3399654030799866,
0.3963804841041565,
-0.11559629440307617,
0.09374704211950302,
0.320428729057312,
-0.14428555965423584,
0.16040486097335815,
-0.0511753223836422,
-0.09166986495256424,
-0.07049398869276047,
0.12217060476541519,
-0.27344250679016113,
-0.576885461807251,
0.75993412733078,
-0.5306928157806396,
-0.7165391445159912,
-0.35725101828575134,
-0.6863769292831421,
0.1352522373199463,
0.5251215696334839,
0.4651394188404083,
0.6277089715003967,
0.06632229685783386,
0.21247999370098114,
0.6398530602455139,
-0.08818599581718445,
0.8470975160598755,
0.2507690191268921,
-0.1117476373910904,
-0.8468420505523682,
0.9208835959434509,
0.26307132840156555,
-0.17237068712711334,
0.7293044924736023,
0.2396721988916397,
-0.29164978861808777,
-0.6527903079986572,
-0.12756314873695374,
0.25256407260894775,
-0.8782141208648682,
-0.34106671810150146,
-0.7093981504440308,
-0.09074810147285461,
-0.8259693384170532,
-0.4636591672897339,
0.04677398502826691,
-0.8369734287261963,
-0.0035408311523497105,
-0.08000826090574265,
0.0452142171561718,
0.5698019862174988,
0.022680696099996567,
0.2640879154205322,
-0.831392765045166,
0.5697141289710999,
0.20099355280399323,
-0.14036279916763306,
-0.016397204250097275,
-0.248957097530365,
-0.38534536957740784,
-0.5544353723526001,
-0.47242918610572815,
-0.997128963470459,
0.6944437623023987,
0.18139231204986572,
0.7044777274131775,
0.4395427405834198,
0.17732596397399902,
0.2974015176296234,
-0.08229125291109085,
0.7940444350242615,
0.05457431823015213,
-0.7512310743331909,
0.8718265295028687,
-0.5225562453269958,
0.40503501892089844,
0.6771921515464783,
0.4385909140110016,
-0.043315961956977844,
-0.8699756264686584,
-0.707409679889679,
-1.0015074014663696,
0.35245516896247864,
0.3781905174255371,
0.055880770087242126,
0.07254244387149811,
0.47411325573921204,
-0.022188734263181686,
0.4243225157260895,
-0.3618890643119812,
-0.18580079078674316,
-0.4014102518558502,
-0.4202258586883545,
0.001754248165525496,
-0.24811764061450958,
0.03810622915625572,
-0.09850810468196869,
0.7863829731941223,
-0.2167411744594574,
0.19483867287635803,
0.3648309111595154,
-0.3215370178222656,
0.01943032816052437,
0.30390098690986633,
0.5022530555725098,
0.460175096988678,
-0.40859028697013855,
0.1906770020723343,
-0.1805773824453354,
-0.5643974542617798,
-0.22829724848270416,
-0.007435591891407967,
-0.23364347219467163,
0.3965800106525421,
0.5561920404434204,
0.05798191577196121,
0.007994132116436958,
-0.42890846729278564,
0.6446974277496338,
-0.2727638781070709,
-0.19762781262397766,
-0.25798290967941284,
-0.06364648789167404,
0.04071478173136711,
0.11114279180765152,
0.6101980209350586,
-0.07375159859657288,
0.5619127154350281,
-0.7446330785751343,
0.1436859369277954,
0.6370651125907898,
-0.12754324078559875,
-0.06560199707746506,
0.2587222158908844,
0.2783496081829071,
-0.07972042262554169,
0.25510597229003906,
-0.03511204943060875,
-0.538248598575592,
0.7433046102523804,
0.21570108830928802,
0.9697377681732178,
0.14503811299800873,
0.17574341595172882,
0.3682084083557129,
0.38222503662109375,
-0.04528862237930298,
0.2649199664592743,
-0.4373335540294647,
-0.45998695492744446,
0.0735919177532196,
-0.5490790605545044,
-0.5398703813552856,
-0.3025759756565094,
-0.575182318687439,
0.11654918640851974,
-0.27783018350601196,
-0.3754776120185852,
0.17319293320178986,
0.21773399412631989,
-0.006980705074965954,
0.30802592635154724,
-0.26719146966934204,
0.6381270289421082,
-0.624464750289917,
0.6283527612686157,
0.8802585005760193,
-0.7264639735221863,
-0.2765478789806366,
0.11573469638824463,
-0.08967749029397964,
-0.41817495226860046,
0.38050734996795654,
0.06800635904073715,
-0.16111865639686584,
-0.1094646006822586,
-0.44086506962776184,
-0.40962639451026917,
1.120678186416626,
-0.05273580551147461,
0.06267121434211731,
0.16904139518737793,
-0.31947532296180725,
0.6460997462272644,
-0.49455592036247253,
0.20496001839637756,
0.3403201699256897,
0.3618837893009186,
0.27916014194488525,
-0.4300830066204071,
0.03216193988919258,
-0.5356407761573792,
0.09010092169046402,
0.28587815165519714,
-0.6037518978118896,
0.7273007035255432,
-0.21236124634742737,
-0.17617201805114746,
0.17779803276062012,
0.586380660533905,
-0.10704629868268967,
0.3923207223415375,
0.5661774277687073,
0.5191786289215088,
0.2250199168920517,
-0.19885262846946716,
1.1578843593597412,
-0.4053811728954315,
0.4106065630912781,
0.8776517510414124,
0.061166997998952866,
0.6616528630256653,
0.3922470211982727,
0.06913574784994125,
0.25120285153388977,
0.5936612486839294,
-0.0577397458255291,
0.7236641049385071,
-0.09927716851234436,
-0.04034240543842316,
0.09463545680046082,
-0.0734572559595108,
-0.34220996499061584,
0.1239926889538765,
0.39710789918899536,
-0.6107931137084961,
-0.42805102467536926,
-0.04468366876244545,
-0.22646506130695343,
-0.016553407534956932,
-0.3772231936454773,
1.0471206903457642,
0.20132701098918915,
-0.879604160785675,
-0.026417480781674385,
0.10987623035907745,
0.6444326639175415,
-0.35200080275535583,
-0.06038716807961464,
-0.40365076065063477,
0.018168607726693153,
-0.44099366664886475,
-0.8976098895072937,
0.4272076189517975,
-0.2183704972267151,
-0.38569337129592896,
-0.3594970703125,
1.2206850051879883,
-0.2057400345802307,
-0.4660035967826843,
-0.12436959892511368,
0.43686243891716003,
0.24088938534259796,
0.23976877331733704,
-0.4790239930152893,
-0.3182251453399658,
-0.27812159061431885,
-0.14399349689483643,
0.23945477604866028,
0.16816067695617676,
0.07847726345062256,
0.29553133249282837,
0.572223424911499,
0.20027853548526764,
-0.24755944311618805,
0.1513676792383194,
0.7582056522369385,
-0.4996272921562195,
-0.6920301914215088,
-0.7022925615310669,
0.05311141535639763,
-0.3683903217315674,
0.0556071400642395,
0.6932841539382935,
0.5425984859466553,
0.3912746012210846,
-0.2987574338912964,
1.0380796194076538,
-0.32146772742271423,
0.24118873476982117,
-0.5787907242774963,
0.7142729163169861,
-0.6474980115890503,
-0.03065306879580021,
-0.5227833390235901,
-0.7991573810577393,
-0.2797733545303345,
0.5341103076934814,
-0.31127089262008667,
-0.18137796223163605,
0.7616066932678223,
0.7286033034324646,
0.32309097051620483,
-0.05006026104092598,
0.25003013014793396,
-0.2809610068798065,
0.29430699348449707,
-0.005216476507484913,
0.5737627744674683,
-0.4820774495601654,
0.3600841462612152,
-0.14495263993740082,
-0.39255133271217346,
-0.3046369254589081,
-0.8608927130699158,
-0.737664520740509,
-0.8239206671714783,
-0.5584744215011597,
-0.10207492113113403,
-0.11269700527191162,
0.4254981279373169,
0.5979636311531067,
-0.778415858745575,
-0.09522146731615067,
0.092885822057724,
0.5205209255218506,
-0.3176402747631073,
-0.3691706359386444,
0.4157378673553467,
-0.6246469020843506,
-0.931323766708374,
-0.2104083001613617,
0.6493436694145203,
0.14431236684322357,
-0.11167199909687042,
0.2711217999458313,
-0.14146217703819275,
0.17148642241954803,
0.6805967688560486,
0.1734868735074997,
-0.4131694436073303,
0.06175103783607483,
-0.3343307077884674,
-0.05012264847755432,
-0.02241416834294796,
1.1156448125839233,
-0.5991334915161133,
0.2973334789276123,
1.0785554647445679,
0.2861148416996002,
0.36232990026474,
0.38415560126304626,
0.42851006984710693,
-0.5612083673477173,
0.06043568626046181,
-0.08767194300889969,
0.6729288101196289,
0.33847740292549133,
-0.4211729168891907,
0.6047688126564026,
0.4448406994342804,
-0.4263327419757843,
-0.3959338665008545,
0.05053162947297096,
-1.2513819932937622,
-0.3494933843612671,
0.7697550654411316,
-0.2488119900226593,
-0.3687472939491272,
0.058071035891771317,
-0.47626468539237976,
0.24712927639484406,
-0.534203290939331,
0.9749714136123657,
0.6221818923950195,
-0.27958205342292786,
-0.3448205590248108,
-0.18329644203186035,
0.18690088391304016,
0.18726690113544464,
-0.8985416889190674,
-0.4109136760234833,
0.5593202710151672,
0.18386046588420868,
0.5904065370559692,
0.8158116936683655,
-0.42241591215133667,
0.2655685842037201,
-0.12136705219745636,
-0.06414641439914703,
-0.2547454833984375,
0.05031218007206917,
-0.22093357145786285,
0.6281363368034363,
-0.1860170215368271,
-0.48595157265663147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13071v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13071v1
|
A Novel Method for News Article Event-Based Embedding
| 2024-05-20T20:55:07 | 2024-05-20T20:55:07 |
Koren Ishlach, Itzhak Ben-David, Michael Fire, Lior Rokach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
Embedding news articles is a crucial tool for multiple fields, such as media
bias detection, identifying fake news, and news recommendations. However,
existing news embedding methods are not optimized for capturing the latent
context of news events. In many cases, news embedding methods rely on
full-textual information and neglect the importance of time-relevant embedding
generation. Here, we aim to address these shortcomings by presenting a novel
lightweight method that optimizes news embedding generation by focusing on the
entities and themes mentioned in the articles and their historical connections
to specific events. We suggest a method composed of three stages. First, we
process and extract the events, entities, and themes for the given news
articles. Second, we generate periodic time embeddings for themes and entities
by training timely separated GloVe models on current and historical data.
Lastly, we concatenate the news embeddings generated by two distinct
approaches: Smooth Inverse Frequency (SIF) for article-level vectors and
Siamese Neural Networks for embeddings with nuanced event-related information.
To test and evaluate our method, we leveraged over 850,000 news articles and
1,000,000 events from the GDELT project. For validation purposes, we conducted
a comparative analysis of different news embedding generation methods, applying
them twice to a shared event detection task - first on articles published
within the same day and subsequently on those published within the same month.
Our experiments show that our method significantly improves the
Precision-Recall (PR) AUC across all tasks and datasets. Specifically, we
observed an average PR AUC improvement of 2.15% and 2.57% compared to SIF, as
well as 2.57% and 2.43% compared to the semi-supervised approach for daily and
monthly shared event detection tasks, respectively.
|
[
-0.40682774782180786,
-0.8188447952270508,
0.5112285614013672,
0.08354537934064865,
-0.7320680618286133,
-0.08194440603256226,
-0.1598065346479416,
-0.22357399761676788,
0.5525091290473938,
-0.1207706406712532,
-0.42976120114326477,
-0.7096274495124817,
-0.21041783690452576,
-0.2798954248428345,
-0.24517491459846497,
0.9264715313911438,
-0.21212972700595856,
-0.08949165791273117,
-0.1332297921180725,
-0.40709999203681946,
-0.11847200244665146,
-0.4785290062427521,
-0.42515239119529724,
-0.06779158115386963,
0.3124340772628784,
0.11131003499031067,
0.301338255405426,
0.6093649864196777,
0.13630042970180511,
-0.0009503268520347774,
-0.05487451329827309,
0.41781553626060486,
-0.303800493478775,
-0.15891408920288086,
-0.003430783050134778,
-0.26492494344711304,
-0.13666117191314697,
0.23820172250270844,
0.4223672151565552,
0.4643034040927887,
-0.23313984274864197,
0.3709544539451599,
0.12151211500167847,
0.4327266216278076,
-0.8378666043281555,
0.022961558774113655,
-0.6892760396003723,
0.5222017168998718,
-0.17446216940879822,
-0.6877691149711609,
-0.3728226125240326,
-0.2394893914461136,
-0.18751013278961182,
-0.6772832870483398,
0.4239793121814728,
-0.10968539863824844,
0.8695634007453918,
-0.05248964577913284,
-0.563663125038147,
-0.24315957725048065,
-0.5233482718467712,
0.7618647813796997,
-0.5647246837615967,
0.604884147644043,
0.21007244288921356,
-0.20442672073841095,
0.16431817412376404,
-0.37371039390563965,
-0.46571385860443115,
-0.05026816204190254,
0.11985667049884796,
0.12405731528997421,
0.019742261618375778,
-0.46429747343063354,
0.15689611434936523,
0.0727420449256897,
-0.6031306385993958,
-0.2771000266075134,
-0.10439761728048325,
-0.032583609223365784,
0.4048433303833008,
-0.05981935188174248,
0.07508009672164917,
-0.2624133229255676,
-0.2891576290130615,
0.12701314687728882,
-0.802591860294342,
-0.1187862828373909,
0.5985654592514038,
0.14357143640518188,
-0.26499152183532715,
0.38063764572143555,
-0.07341892272233963,
0.41462618112564087,
0.2686745524406433,
-0.30442190170288086,
0.509863018989563,
-0.4885615408420563,
0.24359142780303955,
0.3404715061187744,
0.4931308329105377,
0.590021014213562,
-0.009831645525991917,
-0.3043513894081116,
0.019612103700637817,
-0.08354595303535461,
0.3495686948299408,
-0.7123590111732483,
0.03533419221639633,
-0.20823900401592255,
-0.6506221294403076,
-0.6189562678337097,
0.20380428433418274,
-0.6652616858482361,
-0.06665509939193726,
-0.26989319920539856,
0.5948362350463867,
-0.2157975435256958,
-0.06401744484901428,
-0.12687045335769653,
-0.1527310013771057,
0.1361929327249527,
0.27017778158187866,
-0.5403985977172852,
0.018848340958356857,
0.4562869668006897,
0.9822574257850647,
-0.06809991598129272,
0.199798583984375,
-0.7328388690948486,
0.3833982050418854,
-0.4712144434452057,
0.4432775378227234,
-0.41319170594215393,
-0.0006084706983529031,
0.04185561090707779,
-0.19383938610553741,
0.24823077023029327,
-0.15573029220104218,
0.4474964439868927,
-0.6795186996459961,
-0.041682954877614975,
-0.2063961923122406,
-0.5800865888595581,
-0.06935589760541916,
0.08913154155015945,
-0.7693321704864502,
0.9308332800865173,
-0.21090447902679443,
-0.9819381237030029,
0.6477078795433044,
-0.2994464039802551,
-0.6227818727493286,
-0.4933909475803375,
-0.38854551315307617,
-0.8525766730308533,
0.29730409383773804,
0.7962803840637207,
0.5980944633483887,
0.24241776764392853,
0.4340917468070984,
-0.5183644890785217,
-0.3726988136768341,
-0.17548547685146332,
-0.5285500288009644,
0.2876604199409485,
0.0536993183195591,
-0.562953770160675,
-0.5455467104911804,
-0.6764053702354431,
-0.45352181792259216,
0.21459798514842987,
-0.22481852769851685,
-0.620474100112915,
0.19597189128398895,
0.14162831008434296,
0.0303643848747015,
0.11043106764554977,
-0.7180767059326172,
0.22977451980113983,
-0.36418190598487854,
0.32032233476638794,
0.612007737159729,
0.6243453025817871,
0.7154451608657837,
-0.34087198972702026,
0.026378145441412926,
0.42344582080841064,
-0.14439068734645844,
-0.5320472717285156,
-0.312992125749588,
-0.3566988408565521,
0.11754410713911057,
0.2679688632488251,
0.5825967192649841,
-0.7106209397315979,
0.5664491057395935,
-0.13267038762569427,
-0.17767934501171112,
-0.1211223229765892,
0.1490987092256546,
0.02558041177690029,
0.36225366592407227,
0.33448779582977295,
-0.30055728554725647,
-0.6620018482208252,
-0.6930609941482544,
-0.4088972508907318,
0.035617999732494354,
0.2429002970457077,
0.22405442595481873,
0.23776087164878845,
0.3880799412727356,
0.8536208271980286,
-0.39184823632240295,
-0.16822722554206848,
0.09231449663639069,
0.4068491756916046,
0.2219480723142624,
0.5171164870262146,
0.7248099446296692,
-0.8892980813980103,
-0.15053214132785797,
-0.14722013473510742,
-0.8488795161247253,
0.2504631280899048,
-0.4775307774543762,
0.0065392074175179005,
0.5204086899757385,
0.6127954125404358,
-0.13054729998111725,
0.8653547763824463,
0.20835140347480774,
-0.23669861257076263,
0.17329400777816772,
0.004471480380743742,
0.28450915217399597,
-1.092880368232727,
-0.07171133905649185,
0.1642119139432907,
-0.3663273751735687,
-0.26651930809020996,
-0.41698339581489563,
0.26063114404678345,
-0.3215405344963074,
-0.5495153069496155,
0.5517500042915344,
-0.5586339235305786,
0.026204364374279976,
-0.16024236381053925,
0.11452905088663101,
0.15830521285533905,
0.5194886922836304,
-0.009641129523515701,
0.5165876150131226,
0.08571413159370422,
-0.5000520348548889,
-0.005214565899223089,
0.013233670964837074,
-0.47462400794029236,
0.581331193447113,
-0.29332977533340454,
0.1872435361146927,
-0.4212307333946228,
0.2728493809700012,
-0.7204893231391907,
0.2446490079164505,
0.12668438255786896,
-0.39966854453086853,
0.5415641665458679,
-0.20250624418258667,
-0.5547536015510559,
-0.1361377090215683,
-0.5195034742355347,
0.5290992259979248,
0.30611732602119446,
-0.6238530278205872,
0.645139753818512,
0.27395951747894287,
-0.17043131589889526,
-0.5666207671165466,
-0.6942389607429504,
0.012400475330650806,
-0.3311197757720947,
-0.4651147723197937,
0.5041025876998901,
0.21870262920856476,
0.04343153163790703,
0.5470600128173828,
-0.5742918252944946,
0.12428934127092361,
0.1358918398618698,
-0.004194553475826979,
-0.02320181392133236,
-0.46129316091537476,
0.3615456819534302,
0.4285355806350708,
-0.04392492026090622,
-0.35239681601524353,
-0.526733934879303,
0.2992539405822754,
0.11091834306716919,
-0.612983226776123,
-0.7848607897758484,
0.6740535497665405,
0.14915317296981812,
-0.43015867471694946,
0.862601101398468,
1.1221592426300049,
-0.5620659589767456,
-0.0755215734243393,
-0.8110001683235168,
-0.47743120789527893,
-0.3112594485282898,
0.47857534885406494,
-0.0925435721874237,
-0.828647792339325,
0.36037829518318176,
-0.024015024304389954,
0.17382727563381195,
0.39189857244491577,
0.3944411873817444,
-0.07808326929807663,
0.8975819945335388,
0.3244255781173706,
-0.4370100200176239,
0.7918536067008972,
-0.27276766300201416,
0.17310765385627747,
-0.62274169921875,
-0.1554475873708725,
-0.25931233167648315,
-0.5355896949768066,
-0.07617056369781494,
-0.5323951840400696,
0.3905496299266815,
0.3416871726512909,
-0.17809711396694183,
0.021037744358181953,
-0.23292480409145355,
0.31868577003479004,
0.4707053601741791,
0.3678201735019684,
0.42415091395378113,
0.351271390914917,
-0.10641613602638245,
-0.1350577026605606,
-0.7384551167488098,
-0.35177531838417053,
1.3413221836090088,
0.15569354593753815,
0.855205237865448,
-0.21461665630340576,
1.1167988777160645,
0.38048872351646423,
0.2646910846233368,
-0.3744005858898163,
-0.019113188609480858,
-0.1897135227918625,
-0.3336751163005829,
-0.008667252026498318,
-0.3149521052837372,
-0.7165703177452087,
-0.00900884810835123,
-0.3318721055984497,
-0.7090556621551514,
0.40880823135375977,
-0.04121706262230873,
-0.5335501432418823,
0.6556159257888794,
-0.5815407633781433,
0.5157707929611206,
0.03299739956855774,
-0.26991137862205505,
-0.3302561342716217,
-0.17669297754764557,
0.06169497221708298,
-0.04582730308175087,
0.33846744894981384,
-0.22756850719451904,
-0.314931184053421,
0.8776624202728271,
0.13142848014831543,
0.8237116932868958,
-0.2519160211086273,
0.13101692497730255,
0.45761415362358093,
-0.10564329475164413,
0.835625410079956,
0.6527830362319946,
-0.04907657578587532,
0.07154359668493271,
-0.3161209225654602,
-0.24301402270793915,
-0.6583782434463501,
0.7697019577026367,
-0.6958052515983582,
-0.438253253698349,
-0.11777306348085403,
-0.3977522552013397,
-0.07266955822706223,
-0.14999476075172424,
0.17282328009605408,
1.0057791471481323,
-0.32617199420928955,
0.5427201390266418,
0.7764235734939575,
-0.15921388566493988,
0.6225785613059998,
0.39544400572776794,
0.13536781072616577,
-0.5010541081428528,
0.8141011595726013,
0.2914044260978699,
-0.38833507895469666,
0.6870014667510986,
-0.07204964756965637,
-0.023130252957344055,
-0.38520288467407227,
-0.43256282806396484,
0.09702543169260025,
-0.28936269879341125,
-0.46770337224006653,
-0.93182373046875,
0.12975721061229706,
-0.3363701105117798,
-0.4297267496585846,
-0.4965929687023163,
-0.5537324547767639,
-0.5730226635932922,
-0.19114772975444794,
0.20111584663391113,
0.3405185639858246,
-0.25408148765563965,
0.1431419849395752,
-0.7553806304931641,
0.5256949067115784,
0.06839222460985184,
0.10031519830226898,
0.10842176526784897,
-0.07526468485593796,
-0.42513737082481384,
0.012564048171043396,
-0.5731452107429504,
-1.1845498085021973,
0.27687808871269226,
0.3808805048465729,
0.9221746325492859,
0.45542800426483154,
0.2391786277294159,
0.4117298424243927,
-0.5712628364562988,
0.695989727973938,
0.042527444660663605,
-0.9253419041633606,
0.8837817907333374,
-0.25132855772972107,
0.10167782753705978,
0.3271796405315399,
0.460849791765213,
-0.285280704498291,
-0.35251739621162415,
-0.7387069463729858,
-0.9895731806755066,
0.616845428943634,
0.2789473533630371,
0.21371576189994812,
-0.2964886426925659,
0.5228517055511475,
0.07393509894609451,
0.302127480506897,
-0.41171321272850037,
-0.3262185752391815,
-0.16406749188899994,
-0.24627619981765747,
-0.09024760872125626,
-0.2452811449766159,
-0.03972186893224716,
-0.16141916811466217,
0.6348232626914978,
-0.17483066022396088,
0.5732758045196533,
0.4718012511730194,
-0.36978453397750854,
-0.10703589767217636,
0.02826663665473461,
0.5164797902107239,
0.5536122918128967,
-0.14541880786418915,
0.17724667489528656,
0.3709734380245209,
-0.41048353910446167,
0.026927249506115913,
0.3348928987979889,
-0.22371116280555725,
0.3673901855945587,
0.3595329523086548,
0.7863567471504211,
0.4770825207233429,
-0.12117844074964523,
0.7776638269424438,
0.04982012137770653,
-0.08034314215183258,
-0.2358759492635727,
-0.20079395174980164,
0.1332283765077591,
0.49865153431892395,
0.8763546347618103,
0.0748700350522995,
0.14259780943393707,
-0.5579537153244019,
0.7500438690185547,
0.324092298746109,
-0.35897356271743774,
-0.21139252185821533,
0.6745566725730896,
0.2204146683216095,
0.24835525453090668,
0.3539491891860962,
-0.33082616329193115,
-0.32267072796821594,
0.7346174716949463,
0.475819855928421,
0.6532446146011353,
-0.04590897262096405,
0.2266952097415924,
0.4634464979171753,
0.2640761733055115,
0.08086938410997391,
0.26828867197036743,
-0.11167492717504501,
-0.6241649389266968,
-0.36472874879837036,
-0.5945194959640503,
0.12570323050022125,
0.0599655918776989,
-0.7634419202804565,
0.17745932936668396,
-0.0753333792090416,
-0.32672446966171265,
-0.12420342117547989,
0.4527488350868225,
-0.9209355711936951,
-0.17003469169139862,
0.2213412970304489,
1.0681965351104736,
-1.0664348602294922,
0.5778498649597168,
0.7407302260398865,
-0.13100703060626984,
-0.5774751305580139,
0.2733977437019348,
0.2739934027194977,
-0.5287227630615234,
0.11883820593357086,
0.20815469324588776,
0.543674886226654,
0.140388622879982,
-0.2903430163860321,
-0.6579294204711914,
1.3216410875320435,
0.3777824640274048,
-0.5176999568939209,
-0.06499296426773071,
-0.4084983170032501,
0.026445860043168068,
-0.6219673752784729,
-0.07913682609796524,
0.0671476274728775,
0.3577100932598114,
-0.17033791542053223,
-0.587551474571228,
0.025286318734288216,
-0.18503160774707794,
0.11059610545635223,
0.3540835380554199,
-0.47512951493263245,
0.44762852787971497,
-0.2081957310438156,
-0.13067425787448883,
0.013614818453788757,
1.0543986558914185,
0.17985501885414124,
0.7296626567840576,
0.3786376714706421,
0.851161777973175,
0.7381505966186523,
-0.02444619871675968,
0.9434192776679993,
-0.23906545341014862,
0.5499391555786133,
0.8307976126670837,
0.037363313138484955,
0.5383324027061462,
0.45591866970062256,
0.09710539877414703,
0.31428197026252747,
0.35070154070854187,
-0.08069393038749695,
0.9843805432319641,
-0.044275376945734024,
-0.33609938621520996,
-0.2579207420349121,
-0.20237824320793152,
-0.6616871953010559,
0.1326226443052292,
0.30814218521118164,
-0.425732284784317,
-0.677731454372406,
0.5203530192375183,
0.20552857220172882,
-0.07194255292415619,
-0.3366253077983856,
0.6262259483337402,
0.22053074836730957,
-0.18719594180583954,
-0.020500246435403824,
0.09889183938503265,
0.7550995349884033,
-0.32271289825439453,
-0.03195417299866676,
-0.3109285235404968,
0.11793025583028793,
0.014351806603372097,
-0.540500819683075,
0.43114396929740906,
-0.21918770670890808,
-0.1972113400697708,
-0.13250893354415894,
0.7555050849914551,
-0.5529733300209045,
-0.4194086492061615,
-0.036880847066640854,
0.6356543898582458,
-0.28662192821502686,
-0.19789724051952362,
-0.40993815660476685,
0.3254224359989166,
-0.16749705374240875,
-0.7208561897277832,
0.24407649040222168,
0.657754123210907,
-0.13099335134029388,
-0.051481910049915314,
0.5499043464660645,
-0.1009942814707756,
-0.0639197900891304,
0.017343193292617798,
0.7685898542404175,
-0.6613478064537048,
-0.7379436492919922,
-0.6889300346374512,
0.21272125840187073,
-0.08801926672458649,
-0.23134170472621918,
0.42047712206840515,
0.8742455244064331,
0.7341272234916687,
-0.0422210656106472,
0.6422579288482666,
0.17632907629013062,
0.17166873812675476,
-0.633033812046051,
0.6907123327255249,
-0.8538163900375366,
-0.09130973368883133,
-0.26484614610671997,
-0.727163553237915,
-0.2663860619068146,
0.5696168541908264,
-0.14360401034355164,
0.16043134033679962,
0.5568978190422058,
0.6442081928253174,
-0.20706164836883545,
0.25216710567474365,
0.11332361400127411,
-0.19408437609672546,
0.14566992223262787,
0.5699890851974487,
0.6085823178291321,
-0.4155796468257904,
0.4951658248901367,
-0.47470155358314514,
-0.1185772642493248,
-0.4582313299179077,
-0.9983072280883789,
-0.8503777980804443,
-0.7854474782943726,
-0.5360611081123352,
-0.05522384122014046,
0.5860680937767029,
0.9329823851585388,
0.8986876010894775,
-0.7286913990974426,
0.3754347264766693,
0.18696238100528717,
0.10922840237617493,
-0.3579806387424469,
-0.216905876994133,
0.6520707011222839,
-0.3745609223842621,
-0.53091961145401,
0.3472163677215576,
0.2597634196281433,
-0.12653693556785583,
0.09399690479040146,
0.1618598997592926,
-0.3511715531349182,
-0.08606453239917755,
0.4303399622440338,
0.027318598702549934,
-0.34208717942237854,
-0.6303481459617615,
-0.20024167001247406,
-0.14049148559570312,
-0.027323395013809204,
0.9679130911827087,
-0.9299600124359131,
0.0805296003818512,
0.41529399156570435,
0.7177639603614807,
0.8677815198898315,
-0.03166188672184944,
0.3865058124065399,
-1.1967453956604004,
0.43955254554748535,
0.19981668889522552,
0.3160250186920166,
0.09678089618682861,
-0.5862103700637817,
0.33083054423332214,
0.6107025742530823,
-0.048773109912872314,
-0.6275389790534973,
-0.07382011413574219,
-1.0433135032653809,
-0.23196016252040863,
0.9246353507041931,
0.02920537441968918,
-0.24835370481014252,
-0.10372507572174072,
0.022972680628299713,
0.5254762172698975,
-0.684752881526947,
0.5447536706924438,
0.4672369062900543,
0.012396612204611301,
-0.24159252643585205,
-0.5932990312576294,
0.16988605260849,
0.003588816151022911,
-0.3879469037055969,
-0.5171517133712769,
0.20523622632026672,
0.14338859915733337,
0.20739252865314484,
0.4770807921886444,
-0.3313654065132141,
0.4198778569698334,
0.04304073005914688,
-0.064888596534729,
-0.4590739607810974,
-0.40536245703697205,
-0.08541278541088104,
0.42947569489479065,
-0.5883975028991699,
-0.20630426704883575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12368v1
|
Layout Agnostic Human Activity Recognition in Smart Homes through Textual Descriptions Of Sensor Triggers (TDOST)
| 2024-05-20T20:37:44 | 2024-05-20T20:37:44 |
Megha Thukral, Sourish Gunesh Dhekane, Shruthi K. Hiremath, Harish Haresamudram, Thomas Ploetz
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Human activity recognition (HAR) using ambient sensors in smart homes has
numerous applications for human healthcare and wellness. However, building
general-purpose HAR models that can be deployed to new smart home environments
requires a significant amount of annotated sensor data and training overhead.
Most smart homes vary significantly in their layouts, i.e., floor plans and the
specifics of sensors embedded, resulting in low generalizability of HAR models
trained for specific homes. We address this limitation by introducing a novel,
layout-agnostic modeling approach for HAR systems in smart homes that utilizes
the transferrable representational capacity of natural language descriptions of
raw sensor data. To this end, we generate Textual Descriptions Of Sensor
Triggers (TDOST) that encapsulate the surrounding trigger conditions and
provide cues for underlying activities to the activity recognition models.
Leveraging textual embeddings, rather than raw sensor data, we create activity
recognition systems that predict standard activities across homes without
either (re-)training or adaptation on target homes. Through an extensive
evaluation, we demonstrate the effectiveness of TDOST-based models in unseen
smart homes through experiments on benchmarked CASAS datasets. Furthermore, we
conduct a detailed analysis of how the individual components of our approach
affect downstream activity recognition performance.
|
[
0.09205374866724014,
-0.39966538548469543,
0.633919358253479,
0.02193184196949005,
-0.018824033439159393,
0.040923167020082474,
0.136239156126976,
-0.5011099576950073,
0.44394174218177795,
0.5168221592903137,
-0.5062463879585266,
-0.6612138152122498,
-0.19421915709972382,
-0.12710459530353546,
-0.30824342370033264,
0.600836455821991,
-0.19229762256145477,
-0.4941229224205017,
0.015985744073987007,
-0.03826060891151428,
-0.44231030344963074,
-0.18291136622428894,
0.07085540145635605,
-0.38778918981552124,
0.17218288779258728,
0.2978043258190155,
0.5433089733123779,
0.7811560034751892,
0.34521862864494324,
0.1954861581325531,
0.13631410896778107,
0.257656067609787,
0.10244353115558624,
0.1103585883975029,
0.3033587634563446,
0.19228513538837433,
-0.5896099805831909,
-0.26448485255241394,
0.3316349685192108,
0.484069287776947,
-0.17235901951789856,
0.3821069896221161,
0.011916222982108593,
0.5658938884735107,
-0.7734395861625671,
0.32754793763160706,
-0.352405846118927,
0.3943345844745636,
0.042324498295784,
-0.1269838809967041,
-0.2808368504047394,
-0.18398994207382202,
0.09994222968816757,
-0.5555334091186523,
0.33940038084983826,
0.06360549479722977,
0.45290541648864746,
0.32984858751296997,
-0.4859999120235443,
-0.22079481184482574,
-1.0647211074829102,
0.5186952352523804,
-0.3060426712036133,
0.563753068447113,
0.44164925813674927,
0.2824026346206665,
-0.053535833954811096,
-0.43805351853370667,
-0.2952975630760193,
-0.24208158254623413,
-0.6550312042236328,
0.044450946152210236,
-0.13616245985031128,
-0.1615535318851471,
0.19433723390102386,
0.30031922459602356,
-0.5703747868537903,
-0.4762776792049408,
0.009905784390866756,
-0.45536625385284424,
0.6715307235717773,
0.4122764468193054,
0.13388916850090027,
-0.5858315825462341,
-0.6106568574905396,
0.2623980939388275,
-0.32429030537605286,
0.3500745892524719,
-0.005219177808612585,
0.5842093229293823,
-0.31324446201324463,
0.5363239645957947,
-0.3125612139701843,
0.6504891514778137,
0.11043523997068405,
-0.20111116766929626,
0.13041643798351288,
-0.49183887243270874,
0.04378877580165863,
0.40992599725723267,
0.468749076128006,
0.0946374163031578,
0.019547056406736374,
-0.6278204917907715,
-0.41647395491600037,
0.2762695550918579,
0.548507571220398,
-0.4995567202568054,
-0.1531117856502533,
0.33714205026626587,
-0.21004648506641388,
-0.2633357644081116,
0.1572219580411911,
-0.594159722328186,
-0.5951703190803528,
-0.20549076795578003,
0.5275053381919861,
-0.17350898683071136,
-0.04401585832238197,
0.5143327116966248,
-0.03032400645315647,
0.13551415503025055,
0.2238629162311554,
-0.8218111991882324,
0.6628310680389404,
0.5653719305992126,
0.746556282043457,
-0.08579368144273758,
-0.20211969316005707,
-0.5608708262443542,
0.6219607591629028,
0.027020983397960663,
0.8029515743255615,
-0.3183528184890747,
-0.574604868888855,
0.15926043689250946,
-0.2188558578491211,
-0.4056912064552307,
-0.42035943269729614,
0.5793036818504333,
-0.5401105284690857,
0.27925845980644226,
-0.18100447952747345,
-0.41093361377716064,
0.13433393836021423,
0.45870277285575867,
-0.9000943303108215,
0.9625386595726013,
0.16664080321788788,
-0.7116258144378662,
0.2291041761636734,
-1.2465101480484009,
-0.8670939207077026,
-0.06457601487636566,
0.09779815375804901,
-0.8392112255096436,
0.12367846071720123,
0.04825615882873535,
0.47989439964294434,
0.44452425837516785,
0.09144148230552673,
-0.08564778417348862,
-0.3004102110862732,
0.006936822552233934,
-0.07628175616264343,
0.553806483745575,
0.2447027862071991,
-0.459411084651947,
0.2408284693956375,
-0.9155490398406982,
-0.24717475473880768,
0.1413736194372177,
-0.4108145534992218,
-0.3493713140487671,
0.31204161047935486,
-0.11328962445259094,
0.08738008886575699,
0.5706201195716858,
-0.869218647480011,
-0.0531599186360836,
0.3195905387401581,
0.17427386343479156,
0.35405775904655457,
-0.1604340374469757,
0.5760329365730286,
-0.5937442183494568,
0.449290007352829,
-0.1676761656999588,
0.25425514578819275,
-0.44653189182281494,
-0.46998459100723267,
-0.14442482590675354,
-0.7277594804763794,
0.12263909727334976,
0.7855833172798157,
-0.13031379878520966,
0.8691068291664124,
-0.6725803017616272,
-0.15858589112758636,
0.04175765439867973,
-0.032458025962114334,
0.3464895784854889,
0.8106777667999268,
0.28574347496032715,
-0.13224464654922485,
-0.7156026363372803,
-0.32765519618988037,
-0.42073580622673035,
0.013860712759196758,
-0.06700880825519562,
0.25150710344314575,
0.33876827359199524,
-0.437493234872818,
1.1914517879486084,
-0.7344239354133606,
-0.6825633645057678,
-0.3713167607784271,
-0.005477362312376499,
-0.146603062748909,
0.0505950003862381,
0.4392108917236328,
-0.80548495054245,
-0.4854927361011505,
0.17985114455223083,
-0.7356274724006653,
-0.11198581010103226,
-0.0330321379005909,
-0.04147035628557205,
-0.20918183028697968,
0.3946629464626312,
-0.8800452351570129,
1.1411261558532715,
0.45892322063446045,
-0.6797785758972168,
0.6021243333816528,
-0.1169995367527008,
-0.30362942814826965,
-1.29925537109375,
0.0609234981238842,
0.06585649400949478,
-0.2724277973175049,
-0.8490781188011169,
-0.26902681589126587,
0.21431347727775574,
-0.1942129135131836,
-0.24059239029884338,
1.1150379180908203,
-0.4990353286266327,
-0.1906871199607849,
-0.03250763192772865,
-0.6937435865402222,
0.44224944710731506,
0.6219330430030823,
0.3620043396949768,
0.5124706625938416,
0.14781811833381653,
-0.5658408999443054,
-0.04997400939464569,
0.5105139017105103,
-0.29896795749664307,
-0.027303505688905716,
-0.34032073616981506,
-0.14717911183834076,
0.3575591444969177,
0.4326116740703583,
-1.1446651220321655,
-0.8966493010520935,
0.25723138451576233,
-0.27227693796157837,
0.01929757185280323,
0.3457984924316406,
-0.5756374597549438,
-0.3746190369129181,
-0.6210260987281799,
0.32195040583610535,
0.5488422513008118,
-0.7332777380943298,
1.069830060005188,
0.45643192529678345,
0.23995645344257355,
-0.1491280496120453,
-0.37365320324897766,
-0.29083696007728577,
-0.41675201058387756,
-0.3170568346977234,
0.7244120240211487,
0.29093214869499207,
-0.21202462911605835,
-0.16415302455425262,
-0.2580752670764923,
-0.3107786774635315,
0.1712081879377365,
0.5268874168395996,
0.2330305427312851,
0.18443945050239563,
0.2268364280462265,
-0.28879091143608093,
-0.11081892251968384,
0.22431737184524536,
-0.23596373200416565,
0.3890211880207062,
-0.019813256338238716,
-0.7172241806983948,
-0.5240442752838135,
0.450086385011673,
0.7166808843612671,
-0.2803179621696472,
0.3524729907512665,
0.41803985834121704,
-0.8406442403793335,
0.14446412026882172,
-0.27155688405036926,
-0.04176969453692436,
-0.5012435913085938,
-0.02987358346581459,
0.0691927969455719,
-0.7479721307754517,
0.9714927673339844,
-0.15142740309238434,
0.3180141746997833,
-0.11000645160675049,
0.3215530216693878,
-0.381361186504364,
1.0168920755386353,
0.6357091069221497,
0.10941091924905777,
0.9333456158638,
-0.10456075519323349,
0.5738392472267151,
-1.1754437685012817,
-0.36806243658065796,
-0.3587009310722351,
-0.5857203602790833,
-0.17313480377197266,
-0.26832669973373413,
0.5761018991470337,
-0.5228367447853088,
-0.4445154070854187,
0.5211567878723145,
-0.48440438508987427,
0.13728703558444977,
0.23928265273571014,
0.43770793080329895,
0.5144359469413757,
0.3078240156173706,
-0.03742916136980057,
-0.01917174831032753,
-0.5364649295806885,
-0.6421892642974854,
0.8770110607147217,
0.2904263436794281,
0.7429962754249573,
0.22388340532779694,
0.878502607345581,
0.6246243715286255,
0.24912427365779877,
-0.7989285588264465,
0.5302481651306152,
-0.04553312435746193,
-0.8290789127349854,
-0.3919638991355896,
0.02956838719546795,
-1.3251144886016846,
-0.17776058614253998,
0.08702396601438522,
-0.9102450609207153,
0.43625351786613464,
0.3149518370628357,
-0.8631407022476196,
0.46362006664276123,
-0.8496604561805725,
0.6392771601676941,
-0.3230765759944916,
-0.31594449281692505,
0.2611294984817505,
-0.45962780714035034,
0.18597577512264252,
-0.0697556659579277,
0.4426998794078827,
-0.050427086651325226,
0.12295439839363098,
0.34494078159332275,
-0.2627390921115875,
1.1242213249206543,
-0.2825830280780792,
-0.030455466359853745,
0.5292200446128845,
0.14146055281162262,
0.5657040476799011,
0.06806333363056183,
-0.13853178918361664,
-0.05459963157773018,
-0.5166391134262085,
-0.5147558450698853,
-0.22222495079040527,
0.4253590404987335,
-0.522269606590271,
-0.2952427566051483,
-0.3893153965473175,
-0.5384387373924255,
-0.3145970404148102,
0.16995659470558167,
0.25137045979499817,
0.49567416310310364,
-0.4013195037841797,
-0.12817172706127167,
0.6075128316879272,
0.37861308455467224,
0.47136250138282776,
0.22920143604278564,
-0.13629530370235443,
0.008164310827851295,
0.7838883399963379,
-0.04614066332578659,
-0.2867651581764221,
0.6606876254081726,
0.30795586109161377,
-0.5763629078865051,
-0.2681868374347687,
-0.21747061610221863,
-0.15586939454078674,
-0.3197973370552063,
-0.17375212907791138,
-0.7679207921028137,
-0.08113300800323486,
-0.400439977645874,
-0.42551708221435547,
-0.28077223896980286,
-0.477280855178833,
-0.35930299758911133,
-0.21429620683193207,
0.3543922007083893,
0.7116098403930664,
-0.15727736055850983,
0.351117879152298,
-0.9984951019287109,
0.7590042352676392,
0.8688209056854248,
0.5705636739730835,
-0.09820472449064255,
-0.42744579911231995,
-0.3748953640460968,
0.02945162169635296,
-0.3721386790275574,
-0.6632119417190552,
0.22013531625270844,
0.1605655699968338,
0.695144534111023,
0.299933522939682,
0.41423097252845764,
0.3368311822414398,
-0.5534436702728271,
0.6130549907684326,
0.08231253921985626,
-0.6980754137039185,
0.7085579037666321,
-0.7282949686050415,
0.43078288435935974,
0.5943408012390137,
0.037674810737371445,
0.07234714180231094,
0.4860774576663971,
-0.5798479914665222,
-0.800243079662323,
0.2314659208059311,
0.09730305522680283,
0.36268508434295654,
0.0707247257232666,
0.2953852117061615,
0.11935241520404816,
0.17912593483924866,
-0.7974532246589661,
0.44581615924835205,
-0.5045846700668335,
-0.15407125651836395,
0.5134526491165161,
0.12927421927452087,
-0.3255540728569031,
-0.501470685005188,
0.17013902962207794,
-0.25914835929870605,
0.5885162949562073,
0.05825996398925781,
-0.2541321814060211,
-0.3849468529224396,
0.20898184180259705,
0.5058960318565369,
0.3730827271938324,
-0.33987656235694885,
0.05465403571724892,
0.1608150154352188,
-0.773370623588562,
0.24422025680541992,
0.10885782539844513,
-0.11729637533426285,
0.29192793369293213,
0.6566448211669922,
0.5124108195304871,
0.48165827989578247,
-0.4330650269985199,
0.43855658173561096,
-0.13467827439308167,
-0.19256383180618286,
-0.5082206726074219,
0.38724634051322937,
-0.04515253007411957,
0.16496017575263977,
0.22503791749477386,
0.27872058749198914,
0.2038705199956894,
-0.6006985902786255,
0.21986988186836243,
0.21390153467655182,
-0.7032596468925476,
-0.817256510257721,
0.6663937568664551,
0.23364809155464172,
-0.7318219542503357,
0.3733183741569519,
-0.3756050169467926,
-0.5027375817298889,
0.5549207925796509,
0.12395212799310684,
1.2145655155181885,
-0.39489856362342834,
0.2602119743824005,
0.32537850737571716,
-0.023107443004846573,
0.1433962732553482,
0.5427859425544739,
-0.4867495000362396,
-0.8042851090431213,
-0.1819837987422943,
-0.6439688205718994,
-0.4354797303676605,
-0.22360487282276154,
-0.8409936428070068,
0.27966010570526123,
-0.44269075989723206,
-0.18453636765480042,
-0.19147072732448578,
-0.08997290581464767,
-0.6842561960220337,
0.2461848109960556,
0.5334111452102661,
0.8899534344673157,
-0.9275930523872375,
0.730341911315918,
1.223488211631775,
0.561362624168396,
-0.6466364860534668,
0.5648889541625977,
-0.07517196238040924,
-0.6246016025543213,
0.06902720779180527,
0.31736260652542114,
-0.39130502939224243,
-0.14777466654777527,
-0.30693647265434265,
-0.47145673632621765,
1.3757518529891968,
0.16060324013233185,
-0.11548109352588654,
-0.09710491448640823,
0.3692426383495331,
0.7142648696899414,
-0.5406196713447571,
-0.39414289593696594,
0.30765500664711,
0.7487637996673584,
-0.026861146092414856,
-0.6696310639381409,
0.036023303866386414,
-0.4048343002796173,
-0.2191171646118164,
-0.03557826206088066,
-0.49787673354148865,
0.5622978806495667,
-0.6160802245140076,
-0.17716500163078308,
0.05413777381181717,
0.44533291459083557,
0.6824935674667358,
0.7901376485824585,
0.5042792558670044,
0.50246661901474,
0.46682825684547424,
-0.1082468032836914,
1.0181976556777954,
-0.4867475926876068,
0.19301198422908783,
1.004248023033142,
-0.7064058780670166,
0.7540813684463501,
0.27053102850914,
-0.18205751478672028,
0.7229606509208679,
0.44228777289390564,
0.46487995982170105,
1.0631837844848633,
-0.15498685836791992,
-0.5331469178199768,
-0.23727218806743622,
-0.22582043707370758,
-0.2249259352684021,
0.661613941192627,
0.5834472179412842,
-0.17919938266277313,
-0.5041339993476868,
-0.10352209955453873,
-0.08842327445745468,
0.2284088432788849,
-0.08892863988876343,
0.7637010216712952,
-0.17165707051753998,
-0.5466408133506775,
0.15932302176952362,
-0.20325598120689392,
0.4842095375061035,
-0.7887000441551208,
-0.038422588258981705,
-0.032969582825899124,
0.10786332190036774,
-0.4429880678653717,
-0.5740079879760742,
0.7919708490371704,
0.03757089003920555,
-0.4469676911830902,
-0.6540920734405518,
1.1619954109191895,
0.17917396128177643,
-0.5214744806289673,
0.2691415846347809,
0.6074740886688232,
-0.37448546290397644,
-0.2532355785369873,
-0.22470469772815704,
-0.1646038293838501,
-0.11972169578075409,
-0.4071020483970642,
0.46767958998680115,
0.7041116952896118,
-0.4550352990627289,
0.3607847988605499,
0.5776399374008179,
-0.29237717390060425,
0.12415748089551926,
-0.22912947833538055,
0.8710952401161194,
-0.6864138841629028,
-0.8353546857833862,
-0.32897618412971497,
0.8675099611282349,
0.09523433446884155,
-0.42245230078697205,
0.3617601990699768,
0.5329456925392151,
0.3110826313495636,
-0.19800156354904175,
0.8901306986808777,
0.017301546409726143,
0.6946933269500732,
-0.0235277209430933,
0.4398202896118164,
-0.3814435601234436,
0.5804021954536438,
0.1000058650970459,
-0.8658897876739502,
-0.347745418548584,
0.8376014828681946,
-0.5213403105735779,
-0.10803920775651932,
0.34024569392204285,
0.37432754039764404,
-0.3939734399318695,
0.2672690153121948,
0.24423429369926453,
-0.08963048458099365,
0.2810865342617035,
0.2565996050834656,
0.8644101023674011,
-0.2877696752548218,
0.3043980300426483,
-0.44324398040771484,
0.03412327915430069,
-0.5368579626083374,
-1.0731720924377441,
-0.6572670340538025,
-0.39387351274490356,
-0.38224396109580994,
-0.024362020194530487,
-0.08067946135997772,
0.6952894330024719,
0.8938311338424683,
-0.9934075474739075,
-0.16167756915092468,
-0.24378131330013275,
0.05019092932343483,
-0.2968064248561859,
-0.20396564900875092,
0.3966889977455139,
0.28511762619018555,
-0.09083179384469986,
0.23920714855194092,
0.4234960377216339,
0.043163955211639404,
-0.1791997253894806,
-0.15691395103931427,
-0.019787047058343887,
-0.0024779371451586485,
0.5378937125205994,
0.6810628771781921,
-0.6418382525444031,
-0.5825909376144409,
0.366066038608551,
-0.20413899421691895,
0.1403329074382782,
0.6276244521141052,
-1.076519250869751,
0.1416400671005249,
0.599301278591156,
0.4636606276035309,
0.022526925429701805,
0.10811872035264969,
-0.009145587682723999,
-1.2272557020187378,
0.10177821666002274,
0.30875131487846375,
0.4225548803806305,
0.45937785506248474,
-0.7874281406402588,
0.5602216720581055,
-0.005208105314522982,
-0.2325109839439392,
-0.6462538242340088,
0.24887923896312714,
-1.2198944091796875,
-0.052579041570425034,
0.9835919737815857,
-0.11555884033441544,
-0.22249187529087067,
-0.6138798594474792,
-0.07204999029636383,
0.06768905371427536,
-0.442825049161911,
1.5011298656463623,
0.5556812882423401,
-0.6570110321044922,
0.2082773596048355,
-0.5081579685211182,
0.24783271551132202,
0.2782168388366699,
-0.8401132822036743,
0.2425292730331421,
0.36084336042404175,
-0.048737771809101105,
0.5550161600112915,
0.5872501730918884,
-0.04003768414258957,
0.5453688502311707,
-0.35207661986351013,
-0.00807175226509571,
-0.21652591228485107,
-0.34549063444137573,
-0.01154387928545475,
0.13650557398796082,
-0.43670913577079773,
-0.4189576506614685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12363v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12363v1
|
Question-Based Retrieval using Atomic Units for Enterprise RAG
| 2024-05-20T20:27:00 | 2024-05-20T20:27:00 |
Vatsal Raina, Mark Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Enterprise retrieval augmented generation (RAG) offers a highly flexible
framework for combining powerful large language models (LLMs) with internal,
possibly temporally changing, documents. In RAG, documents are first chunked.
Relevant chunks are then retrieved for a specific user query, which are passed
as context to a synthesizer LLM to generate the query response. However, the
retrieval step can limit performance, as incorrect chunks can lead the
synthesizer LLM to generate a false response. This work proposes a zero-shot
adaptation of standard dense retrieval steps for more accurate chunk recall.
Specifically, a chunk is first decomposed into atomic statements. A set of
synthetic questions are then generated on these atoms (with the chunk as the
context). Dense retrieval involves finding the closest set of synthetic
questions, and associated chunks, to the user query. It is found that retrieval
with the atoms leads to higher recall than retrieval with chunks. Further
performance gain is observed with retrieval using the synthetic questions
generated over the atoms. Higher recall at the retrieval step enables higher
performance of the enterprise LLM using the RAG pipeline.
|
[
-0.43014809489250183,
-1.0772203207015991,
0.9995861649513245,
-0.2636900246143341,
-0.17200295627117157,
0.144801527261734,
-0.09939578175544739,
-0.5351570248603821,
0.4134255349636078,
0.8964865803718567,
-0.20687870681285858,
-0.24683499336242676,
0.03174145519733429,
0.28368431329727173,
-0.3574095666408539,
0.9280644059181213,
0.1267155408859253,
-0.28908154368400574,
-0.12936784327030182,
-0.19412584602832794,
-0.5035122632980347,
-0.43607383966445923,
-0.7432782649993896,
-0.19411976635456085,
0.39620473980903625,
0.698440670967102,
0.4854445159435272,
0.4997822642326355,
0.45014283061027527,
0.30289480090141296,
-0.07188191264867783,
0.09156917035579681,
-0.4491889178752899,
0.4811069965362549,
-0.4186382293701172,
-0.496340811252594,
-0.5272082090377808,
-0.37825995683670044,
0.7835082411766052,
0.49065276980400085,
-0.362539678812027,
0.13472412526607513,
-0.4022151231765747,
0.5843008160591125,
-0.9409029483795166,
-0.5075979828834534,
-1.1324437856674194,
0.0126113910228014,
-0.091947041451931,
-0.38803163170814514,
-0.7936033010482788,
0.031844209879636765,
-0.23242893815040588,
-0.6484922170639038,
0.4512820839881897,
0.4436578154563904,
0.7833586931228638,
0.05469799414277077,
-0.5549938082695007,
-0.47076159715652466,
-0.9849766492843628,
0.8914852142333984,
-0.6225389242172241,
0.4349765479564667,
0.32900044322013855,
0.4539913535118103,
-0.011857282370328903,
-0.7394453883171082,
-0.5846337676048279,
-0.2415994107723236,
0.04035438969731331,
0.24910138547420502,
0.13154274225234985,
-0.04635733366012573,
0.24427969753742218,
0.5230924487113953,
-0.7490765452384949,
-0.12033337354660034,
-0.2561340630054474,
-0.03557918220758438,
0.7004757523536682,
0.47877568006515503,
0.029493296518921852,
-0.3572729527950287,
-0.5083443522453308,
-0.35708343982696533,
-0.4902895390987396,
-0.5440239310264587,
-0.14706675708293915,
0.3271748125553131,
0.3090721666812897,
0.6431567072868347,
-0.4701896607875824,
0.7588264346122742,
0.32750558853149414,
0.10163833945989609,
0.11409351229667664,
-0.14200736582279205,
-0.3140822947025299,
0.2985193133354187,
0.2755190134048462,
-0.044563908129930496,
-0.2902364134788513,
-0.2473297417163849,
-0.38818681240081787,
-0.32968971133232117,
0.7036786079406738,
-0.9787946939468384,
0.20544227957725525,
0.4030379354953766,
-0.05926596000790596,
0.10518685728311539,
0.10021736472845078,
-0.470081090927124,
-0.3072686195373535,
-0.1526586264371872,
0.7640902400016785,
-0.4719184339046478,
-0.04423009231686592,
-0.08230525255203247,
-0.41284802556037903,
0.3823654055595398,
0.46102139353752136,
-0.6545332074165344,
0.44550058245658875,
0.7841818928718567,
0.6283819079399109,
0.03922366350889206,
0.009244512766599655,
-0.5219444632530212,
0.5870282053947449,
-0.6740164756774902,
0.9623868465423584,
-0.3720465898513794,
-0.5311100482940674,
-0.3891805410385132,
-0.4126855134963989,
0.17848381400108337,
-0.9529135227203369,
0.23626671731472015,
-1.0749348402023315,
0.07648184895515442,
-0.36044037342071533,
-0.7444572448730469,
-0.1552700698375702,
0.5438248515129089,
-0.6493373513221741,
1.0126492977142334,
0.2844380736351013,
-0.4432978332042694,
0.2678607404232025,
-0.36430370807647705,
-0.22684498131275177,
0.46868595480918884,
-0.2974550127983093,
-0.24612028896808624,
0.22221684455871582,
-0.025512803345918655,
0.3105373680591583,
-0.2876974046230316,
-0.18677932024002075,
-0.202164426445961,
-0.38367098569869995,
0.1586601883172989,
-0.07971362769603729,
0.47455060482025146,
0.5387139916419983,
0.015263024717569351,
-0.07799652963876724,
-0.7291955947875977,
0.280014306306839,
0.03678407892584801,
-0.4305785596370697,
-0.5605306625366211,
-0.16534879803657532,
-0.10853161662817001,
-0.22015024721622467,
0.29459652304649353,
-0.6167711615562439,
0.02539050579071045,
-0.22220048308372498,
-0.22753742337226868,
0.589693546295166,
0.6793377995491028,
0.5675812363624573,
-0.533266544342041,
0.38963496685028076,
0.04284251481294632,
-0.14967875182628632,
-0.3375754952430725,
-0.09332465380430222,
-0.7660322785377502,
-0.16722819209098816,
0.05483740195631981,
0.6204159259796143,
-0.8060417175292969,
0.13252988457679749,
-0.04329625889658928,
-0.5757201910018921,
-0.3313714265823364,
0.023996861651539803,
0.30880430340766907,
0.68255615234375,
0.5698785781860352,
-0.5341521501541138,
-0.5325005650520325,
-0.8000769019126892,
-0.20297257602214813,
-0.4559268653392792,
-0.2707993984222412,
0.7872359156608582,
0.4398799240589142,
-0.008582058362662792,
0.8269950747489929,
-0.763732373714447,
-0.13788121938705444,
-0.2212432473897934,
0.35890236496925354,
0.30794569849967957,
0.19280582666397095,
0.038373108953237534,
-0.9729534387588501,
-0.6510865092277527,
0.27108654379844666,
-0.6321715712547302,
0.05054406076669693,
-0.5278943181037903,
-0.17324034869670868,
0.42170292139053345,
0.5866344571113586,
-0.6514148712158203,
0.1843581348657608,
0.03448772802948952,
-0.4242859184741974,
0.5851292610168457,
-0.3250599801540375,
0.26654526591300964,
-1.3982887268066406,
0.20047953724861145,
-0.4225581884384155,
-0.5035650134086609,
-0.599122941493988,
0.42063838243484497,
0.40221938490867615,
-0.17187176644802094,
-0.6745030283927917,
0.7497627139091492,
-0.7680668234825134,
-0.47805842757225037,
-0.3467971980571747,
0.16388516128063202,
0.17614305019378662,
0.1721729189157486,
-0.03436139225959778,
1.0605233907699585,
0.06418851017951965,
-0.9583027958869934,
0.0127326725050807,
0.2933538556098938,
-0.17189744114875793,
0.9678537249565125,
-0.49181148409843445,
0.5171586275100708,
-0.437924861907959,
0.15393675863742828,
-0.561869740486145,
-0.2820633351802826,
-0.3737315237522125,
-0.4581688940525055,
0.5019789338111877,
0.08747699111700058,
-0.23725754022598267,
0.00043654468026943505,
-0.28719013929367065,
0.3174549639225006,
0.5698918700218201,
-0.16802863776683807,
0.8295870423316956,
0.29898422956466675,
-0.15065798163414001,
-0.4514777958393097,
-0.518328845500946,
0.10553747415542603,
-0.11911167204380035,
-0.4048842191696167,
0.4017462730407715,
-0.1799808293581009,
-0.35088402032852173,
0.2006857544183731,
-0.31978827714920044,
-0.3291504681110382,
0.1099701002240181,
-0.11936862766742706,
0.28351306915283203,
-0.3474745750427246,
0.016033168882131577,
-0.07619361579418182,
0.20971791446208954,
-0.34217569231987,
0.17821890115737915,
0.4484456777572632,
-0.005533037707209587,
-0.21949778497219086,
0.08461818844079971,
0.5130849480628967,
0.49023979902267456,
-0.16578705608844757,
0.7323935627937317,
0.389930784702301,
-0.21655632555484772,
-0.6411595344543457,
-0.7956877946853638,
-0.5262330174446106,
-0.4953230023384094,
0.49998024106025696,
-0.48677390813827515,
-0.9555725455284119,
0.5121078491210938,
0.07078038156032562,
-0.18387585878372192,
0.34148257970809937,
0.5964574813842773,
-0.14075468480587006,
0.6551905274391174,
0.43598300218582153,
0.1061464175581932,
0.4089314043521881,
-0.3397905230522156,
-0.03367440775036812,
-1.3305565118789673,
-0.10213334858417511,
-0.6262694597244263,
-0.2362225502729416,
-0.13202287256717682,
-0.7959747910499573,
0.7160330414772034,
0.3637908399105072,
-0.38557830452919006,
0.4394295811653137,
-0.13621075451374054,
0.6117475032806396,
0.15776532888412476,
-0.018975242972373962,
0.39859315752983093,
-0.15301275253295898,
-0.10399997234344482,
0.2492585927248001,
-0.628944456577301,
-0.1597847193479538,
1.0088794231414795,
-0.08779658377170563,
0.7525243163108826,
0.3040226697921753,
1.064516544342041,
0.30326220393180847,
0.2534956932067871,
-0.6735285520553589,
0.8019589781761169,
0.07903644442558289,
-1.1436234712600708,
-0.43812084197998047,
-0.7673675417900085,
-0.9857298135757446,
0.42668062448501587,
-0.1978898048400879,
-0.5676997303962708,
-0.022223150357604027,
-0.021860716864466667,
-0.4750208258628845,
0.2128286212682724,
-0.6327052712440491,
0.5077828764915466,
-0.19660989940166473,
-0.257976770401001,
-0.34945419430732727,
-0.414471298456192,
0.16455021500587463,
-0.22313250601291656,
0.06121904402971268,
-0.09171999990940094,
-0.22945308685302734,
0.5032192468643188,
-0.28394457697868347,
0.31864339113235474,
-0.011172223836183548,
0.37194833159446716,
0.5662146806716919,
0.5298421382904053,
0.592619001865387,
-0.07636133581399918,
-0.42111736536026,
-0.2647790014743805,
-0.2127200961112976,
-0.2639380991458893,
-0.7015628218650818,
0.6700748205184937,
-0.43424829840660095,
-0.7070198059082031,
-0.5441015362739563,
-0.8084927797317505,
-0.17600630223751068,
0.5703994035720825,
-0.1171853318810463,
0.2106553316116333,
-0.26141995191574097,
0.44958123564720154,
0.7251346111297607,
-0.15058760344982147,
0.49511823058128357,
1.047467589378357,
-0.24154718220233917,
-0.3578103184700012,
0.7903084754943848,
0.2812264561653137,
0.4514086842536926,
0.6567155718803406,
0.03088236413896084,
-0.2804471254348755,
-0.46631574630737305,
-0.6471505165100098,
0.3058633804321289,
-0.46290305256843567,
-0.5664660334587097,
-0.5839357972145081,
-0.15155737102031708,
-0.37269219756126404,
-0.4183123707771301,
-0.41684895753860474,
-0.45761722326278687,
-0.3695155382156372,
-0.00664266012609005,
0.3900701105594635,
0.5698791742324829,
0.1246262788772583,
-0.12064871937036514,
-1.0119178295135498,
0.6255058646202087,
0.29088443517684937,
0.3588857650756836,
0.12170733511447906,
-0.5966478586196899,
-0.35556504130363464,
-0.25588032603263855,
-0.5610446333885193,
-1.0984658002853394,
0.3481124937534332,
0.3198985159397125,
0.3451196253299713,
-0.1357637643814087,
0.3345075845718384,
0.9583303332328796,
-0.6750782132148743,
0.6701712012290955,
-0.2856394648551941,
-0.811143696308136,
0.4409886598587036,
-0.3317079246044159,
0.4014425575733185,
0.6750645041465759,
0.4482323229312897,
-0.740264892578125,
-0.43338900804519653,
-0.653536856174469,
-1.2106090784072876,
0.7768265604972839,
-0.02747614122927189,
0.16210326552391052,
-0.29302242398262024,
0.6076592803001404,
-0.16754330694675446,
-0.03903533145785332,
-0.023685425519943237,
-0.059860412031412125,
0.3910749554634094,
0.04226648807525635,
0.08299404382705688,
-0.1742178201675415,
0.20904946327209473,
0.22693416476249695,
0.8562600612640381,
-0.13882210850715637,
0.20854316651821136,
0.6842356324195862,
-0.202267587184906,
-0.3528565764427185,
0.5276735424995422,
0.1100296899676323,
0.6369543075561523,
-0.582935094833374,
0.03530632704496384,
0.536467969417572,
-0.3812856674194336,
0.0437556728720665,
-0.38001373410224915,
-0.5602512359619141,
0.051821351051330566,
-0.0021013817749917507,
0.6832342147827148,
0.10628536343574524,
-0.8030258417129517,
0.15662340819835663,
0.18511199951171875,
0.05119995027780533,
-0.5178442597389221,
0.10405199229717255,
-0.03919880837202072,
0.31851303577423096,
0.7143332958221436,
-0.38343751430511475,
0.3886987268924713,
-0.8455965518951416,
0.5770137906074524,
0.5705366730690002,
-0.12506401538848877,
0.04403604567050934,
0.683258056640625,
-0.22881050407886505,
-0.30802521109580994,
0.8239235281944275,
-0.2587353587150574,
-0.18468740582466125,
0.5695986747741699,
0.9182279109954834,
0.939896821975708,
-0.3205915093421936,
0.2967599928379059,
0.4696980118751526,
0.1158260926604271,
0.037517428398132324,
0.4877770245075226,
-0.17230640351772308,
-0.6919147372245789,
-0.501872181892395,
-0.8178637027740479,
-0.7667173147201538,
0.055824361741542816,
-0.8135396242141724,
0.13789626955986023,
-0.632673442363739,
-0.06211027875542641,
-0.15783970057964325,
0.1274455189704895,
-0.29125556349754333,
0.47172480821609497,
0.12218176573514938,
1.0267812013626099,
-0.5396987199783325,
0.5981899499893188,
0.7325193285942078,
-0.587385356426239,
-1.1047552824020386,
-0.11545226722955704,
-0.11669116467237473,
-0.5731419920921326,
0.23870067298412323,
-0.22031903266906738,
0.1538839042186737,
0.06866146624088287,
-0.012524343095719814,
-0.9981439113616943,
1.3347734212875366,
0.19141173362731934,
-0.2981920540332794,
0.16217166185379028,
0.09731025248765945,
0.5913745760917664,
-0.13343402743339539,
0.5465799570083618,
0.3271797299385071,
0.19681432843208313,
0.44036009907722473,
-0.7872685790061951,
0.18790316581726074,
0.027081290259957314,
0.1692659705877304,
0.6558018922805786,
-0.6334555745124817,
1.1962230205535889,
0.020590320229530334,
-0.2739226222038269,
0.03252413496375084,
0.7670151591300964,
0.47561267018318176,
0.6126306056976318,
0.2749347686767578,
1.0565133094787598,
0.6297752261161804,
0.380312442779541,
1.2441341876983643,
-0.1541714370250702,
0.41203248500823975,
1.2085095643997192,
-0.6377518177032471,
1.4515987634658813,
0.4916781187057495,
0.027045179158449173,
0.6807424426078796,
0.00535019813105464,
0.2826167345046997,
0.20550107955932617,
-0.13246244192123413,
-0.4623178243637085,
0.05192261189222336,
-0.13020825386047363,
-0.20380772650241852,
0.25210291147232056,
0.27896180748939514,
-0.1110275387763977,
-0.35901951789855957,
-0.39635178446769714,
0.1793370544910431,
-0.032734718173742294,
-0.43329158425331116,
1.2004611492156982,
0.005738917272537947,
-0.7282817363739014,
0.7037303447723389,
0.150868758559227,
0.2425183653831482,
-0.6230437159538269,
-0.20063818991184235,
-0.5641463994979858,
0.16297556459903717,
-0.24197454750537872,
-0.6531568169593811,
0.6761336922645569,
0.09922534972429276,
-0.2507949471473694,
-0.17017757892608643,
0.8540312051773071,
-0.42998361587524414,
-0.4063081741333008,
-0.061112601310014725,
0.3540940284729004,
0.3757544159889221,
-0.25042957067489624,
-0.4965786933898926,
0.15497002005577087,
-0.08865880221128464,
-0.4880220592021942,
0.4599134027957916,
0.4371899962425232,
-0.243157297372818,
0.3868290185928345,
0.5946441292762756,
0.16492581367492676,
0.2193959653377533,
-0.27714645862579346,
0.6987645030021667,
-0.947265088558197,
-0.4147558808326721,
-0.47858095169067383,
0.4983012080192566,
-0.02922927215695381,
0.13928957283496857,
1.0460017919540405,
0.8940383195877075,
1.0708656311035156,
-0.05311959236860275,
0.4640025496482849,
-0.23930048942565918,
0.7544509768486023,
-0.5087536573410034,
0.6936052441596985,
-0.8299439549446106,
0.2299317866563797,
-0.11224343627691269,
-1.2501537799835205,
-0.11927267163991928,
0.36956316232681274,
-0.06879091262817383,
0.07669197022914886,
0.803992748260498,
1.053768515586853,
-0.14965224266052246,
-0.2135830521583557,
0.5571640133857727,
0.5229436755180359,
0.3195616900920868,
0.45266127586364746,
0.3910643756389618,
-0.5804048776626587,
0.32160112261772156,
-0.25588783621788025,
-0.02067307010293007,
-0.3595280349254608,
-0.7676244974136353,
-0.18860790133476257,
-0.4597166180610657,
-0.14895327389240265,
-0.2492881715297699,
-0.13267342746257782,
0.7365763187408447,
0.6244394183158875,
-0.7163206934928894,
-0.47515156865119934,
-0.01468300074338913,
-0.09532001614570618,
0.07120950520038605,
-0.31569337844848633,
0.11099965125322342,
-0.49946340918540955,
-0.47238439321517944,
0.7368026375770569,
0.4553712010383606,
-0.14761477708816528,
0.005157922860234976,
-0.10678919404745102,
-0.4172310531139374,
0.5470023155212402,
0.5952509045600891,
0.5232843160629272,
-0.30084481835365295,
-0.3511510491371155,
0.15012946724891663,
-0.05027640983462334,
-0.04583631828427315,
0.7407247424125671,
-0.8955480456352234,
0.47076836228370667,
0.6521808505058289,
0.908577024936676,
1.0705204010009766,
0.268057644367218,
0.07656670361757278,
-1.003466248512268,
0.08795500546693802,
0.8790530562400818,
-0.04846375435590744,
0.31432172656059265,
-0.5226561427116394,
0.4162207245826721,
0.023190677165985107,
-0.799380362033844,
-0.8329675793647766,
0.36883410811424255,
-1.1211140155792236,
-0.5421972870826721,
1.0190515518188477,
0.23403671383857727,
-0.5638156533241272,
-0.04889819398522377,
-0.19434550404548645,
0.08375657349824905,
-0.4204062223434448,
0.7928479313850403,
0.33043375611305237,
-0.39009952545166016,
-0.0020453748293220997,
-0.47911351919174194,
0.041284698992967606,
0.7894960641860962,
-0.7262759208679199,
-0.11308633536100388,
0.7993749976158142,
0.2987552285194397,
0.35107147693634033,
0.9994636178016663,
-0.23298871517181396,
0.2914429008960724,
0.13254253566265106,
0.10966741293668747,
-0.05650372430682182,
-0.5239342451095581,
-0.21160411834716797,
0.3354845941066742,
0.2826065123081207,
0.11237369477748871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12209v1
|
MathBench: Evaluating the Theory and Application Proficiency of LLMs with a Hierarchical Mathematics Benchmark
| 2024-05-20T17:52:29 | 2024-05-20T17:52:29 |
Hongwei Liu, Zilong Zheng, Yuxuan Qiao, Haodong Duan, Zhiwei Fei, Fengzhe Zhou, Wenwei Zhang, Songyang Zhang, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have showcased
significant improvements in mathematics. However, traditional math benchmarks
like GSM8k offer a unidimensional perspective, falling short in providing a
holistic assessment of the LLMs' math capabilities. To address this gap, we
introduce MathBench, a new benchmark that rigorously assesses the mathematical
capabilities of large language models. MathBench spans a wide range of
mathematical disciplines, offering a detailed evaluation of both theoretical
understanding and practical problem-solving skills. The benchmark progresses
through five distinct stages, from basic arithmetic to college mathematics, and
is structured to evaluate models at various depths of knowledge. Each stage
includes theoretical questions and application problems, allowing us to measure
a model's mathematical proficiency and its ability to apply concepts in
practical scenarios. MathBench aims to enhance the evaluation of LLMs'
mathematical abilities, providing a nuanced view of their knowledge
understanding levels and problem solving skills in a bilingual context. The
project is released at https://github.com/open-compass/MathBench .
|
[
-0.4981790781021118,
-0.640311062335968,
0.41517359018325806,
0.4730890095233917,
-0.07376063615083694,
0.4015142321586609,
-0.24910272657871246,
-0.21823234856128693,
-0.08593761175870895,
0.2177097052335739,
-0.5917402505874634,
-0.867929995059967,
-0.4192967414855957,
-0.049568720161914825,
-0.477847158908844,
0.6896689534187317,
-0.16450053453445435,
0.39062368869781494,
-0.6048720479011536,
-0.16130782663822174,
-0.42607882618904114,
-0.5071139931678772,
-0.5790081024169922,
-0.6660007238388062,
0.30754855275154114,
0.38375842571258545,
0.7917465567588806,
0.4652003347873688,
0.8371822834014893,
0.34850940108299255,
-0.04954138398170471,
-0.29437243938446045,
-0.5922679305076599,
0.024324864149093628,
-0.26445797085762024,
-0.6696421504020691,
-0.693383514881134,
-0.010380588471889496,
0.8677918314933777,
1.2425001859664917,
-0.5055637955665588,
0.30606523156166077,
-0.10756141692399979,
0.7098848819732666,
-0.6122071146965027,
0.4362417757511139,
-0.613288402557373,
0.10413254797458649,
-0.41151779890060425,
0.22810116410255432,
-0.21080166101455688,
-0.6766257882118225,
-0.12685291469097137,
-0.5442277789115906,
0.02887287735939026,
-0.10337124764919281,
0.3822524845600128,
-0.15589438378810883,
-0.35535570979118347,
-0.012247683480381966,
-0.2654389441013336,
0.8905481696128845,
-0.6440302729606628,
0.4928920865058899,
0.4227122366428375,
0.872958242893219,
-0.23328232765197754,
-0.6001613140106201,
-0.16312259435653687,
-0.3195337653160095,
0.32424601912498474,
0.17362850904464722,
-0.11523622274398804,
-0.1614966094493866,
0.5485407710075378,
0.6036858558654785,
-0.6673153042793274,
0.05035155266523361,
-0.32436126470565796,
-0.22914822399616241,
0.544806718826294,
0.6082251667976379,
0.16919879615306854,
-0.013787672854959965,
-0.08099444210529327,
-0.13879743218421936,
-0.781708836555481,
0.0318487174808979,
0.43290627002716064,
0.11740978807210922,
-0.23216696083545685,
0.6941161751747131,
-0.1889408677816391,
0.6398109197616577,
-0.5042209625244141,
-0.2026347666978836,
0.2812807857990265,
-0.21801616251468658,
-0.020235439762473106,
-0.12255329638719559,
0.5363937020301819,
0.33340710401535034,
0.2947041094303131,
-0.09335099905729294,
-0.2032100111246109,
0.3832758665084839,
0.12154607474803925,
-0.8075485825538635,
-0.14196930825710297,
-0.18250656127929688,
-0.18371236324310303,
-0.33388054370880127,
0.10270091891288757,
-0.8548291325569153,
-0.500697910785675,
-0.33788204193115234,
0.18317800760269165,
-0.22064310312271118,
-0.2883877754211426,
0.14683599770069122,
0.10482656210660934,
0.19832994043827057,
0.48109567165374756,
-0.7686611413955688,
0.8906970620155334,
1.0952450037002563,
0.8889649510383606,
-0.353788286447525,
-0.4242848753929138,
-0.4500442445278168,
-0.24643878638744354,
-0.6305181384086609,
0.6120492219924927,
-0.5029094219207764,
-0.6627820730209351,
0.011187844909727573,
-0.17602458596229553,
0.04442889243364334,
-0.8593066930770874,
0.6998805403709412,
-0.6500024795532227,
-0.14859680831432343,
-0.21808499097824097,
-0.48474401235580444,
-0.0822075605392456,
0.3719131350517273,
-0.7464643120765686,
1.4013986587524414,
0.509368360042572,
-0.41512084007263184,
0.021963579580187798,
-0.6174913644790649,
-0.21933847665786743,
-0.03132824972271919,
-0.1812250316143036,
-0.2447780817747116,
0.3932648003101349,
0.022717460989952087,
0.007124454248696566,
-0.8119523525238037,
0.33338621258735657,
-0.6140835881233215,
-0.4039728045463562,
0.42379987239837646,
-0.29290086030960083,
0.6500730514526367,
0.09965401887893677,
-0.05453742295503616,
0.15143461525440216,
-0.8746917247772217,
0.3596654236316681,
0.09596676379442215,
-0.2312929481267929,
-0.04572371393442154,
-0.17026694118976593,
-0.07155189663171768,
0.22129562497138977,
0.39825114607810974,
-0.3653663694858551,
0.09961856156587601,
-0.41703352332115173,
0.1888268142938614,
0.7855019569396973,
-0.30072325468063354,
0.3462138772010803,
-0.2294565588235855,
0.7676628828048706,
-0.3018713593482971,
-0.08661478757858276,
-0.0870242789387703,
-0.27314552664756775,
-0.6462773680686951,
-0.059027913957834244,
0.7527075409889221,
0.47034749388694763,
-0.419007807970047,
0.3580629229545593,
-0.42057690024375916,
-0.6881224513053894,
-0.12738573551177979,
0.4273817837238312,
0.516806423664093,
0.45889008045196533,
0.15006954967975616,
-0.7075467109680176,
-0.36007145047187805,
-0.7800388336181641,
-0.5486336946487427,
0.03803054988384247,
-0.2696802616119385,
0.15949444472789764,
0.6036174893379211,
0.03534300625324249,
0.6573075652122498,
-0.4593285918235779,
-0.17486092448234558,
-0.2564370036125183,
0.2025652825832367,
0.4835546612739563,
0.23781098425388336,
0.48815038800239563,
-0.4273178279399872,
-0.5939731001853943,
0.2038002610206604,
-0.7985497713088989,
-0.38158926367759705,
0.43668973445892334,
-0.3684805631637573,
-0.07738497853279114,
0.5346635580062866,
-0.34690824151039124,
0.49810850620269775,
0.6909604668617249,
-0.18645928800106049,
0.6663719415664673,
0.10987376421689987,
0.016118844971060753,
-0.7770578265190125,
0.18397623300552368,
-0.24661511182785034,
-0.06806357204914093,
-0.2399226278066635,
0.11125566065311432,
0.2259618490934372,
-0.3923095762729645,
-0.27743637561798096,
0.5534674525260925,
-0.3957308530807495,
-0.7599412202835083,
-0.09914702922105789,
0.37046724557876587,
-0.12922392785549164,
0.2016298472881317,
-0.46451181173324585,
0.8766133189201355,
0.6333048939704895,
-0.17333020269870758,
0.5344814658164978,
-0.10871902853250504,
-0.7136244773864746,
0.8719774484634399,
-0.6674198508262634,
-0.1132981926202774,
0.33426356315612793,
0.09332156926393509,
-0.912455677986145,
-0.2412044256925583,
-0.16380827128887177,
-0.3626878261566162,
-0.004023552406579256,
-0.06225050613284111,
-0.7356844544410706,
-0.39430516958236694,
-0.32739123702049255,
0.5425890684127808,
0.4108025133609772,
-0.25354424118995667,
0.7735632061958313,
0.36966967582702637,
-0.36580613255500793,
-0.3221449553966522,
-0.5916955471038818,
0.11536505818367004,
0.06211476773023605,
-0.743000864982605,
0.30626586079597473,
-0.0958133116364479,
-0.4556695520877838,
0.03668715059757233,
-0.4620026648044586,
-0.18640832602977753,
0.30205056071281433,
0.11165712028741837,
0.32764723896980286,
-0.42133525013923645,
-0.030313927680253983,
-0.06252599507570267,
-0.4799644649028778,
0.3978547155857086,
0.05416332185268402,
0.6224278211593628,
-0.46378353238105774,
-0.8971144556999207,
-0.122382253408432,
0.04177209362387657,
0.7643212676048279,
-0.40053269267082214,
0.6219348907470703,
0.16380079090595245,
-0.4701559841632843,
-0.08599667996168137,
-0.4768810272216797,
0.04552283138036728,
-0.4665037989616394,
0.48444080352783203,
-0.6690199971199036,
-0.6642276048660278,
0.8364541530609131,
-0.5252354741096497,
0.1294996440410614,
0.478787362575531,
0.66364985704422,
0.286326140165329,
0.9753458499908447,
0.47218191623687744,
-0.1669677048921585,
0.334725946187973,
-0.1445111632347107,
0.07699141651391983,
-0.8051921129226685,
-0.12955516576766968,
-0.5846087336540222,
-0.2614034116268158,
-0.21574494242668152,
-0.6754472851753235,
0.5026859045028687,
0.305731862783432,
-0.28829580545425415,
0.26918789744377136,
0.1209271028637886,
0.8433368802070618,
0.23365086317062378,
-0.22725512087345123,
0.5519649386405945,
0.20533084869384766,
-0.6111451983451843,
-0.4229230582714081,
-0.4998326599597931,
-0.36969056725502014,
1.2416865825653076,
0.30665498971939087,
0.8131102919578552,
0.37455061078071594,
0.4514879584312439,
0.0536583848297596,
0.5874107480049133,
-0.8247846961021423,
0.7738884091377258,
0.0016020609764382243,
-0.6849378347396851,
-0.10817290097475052,
-0.6460676789283752,
-0.8327598571777344,
0.4652140438556671,
0.087040975689888,
-0.807079553604126,
-0.2354801744222641,
-0.13001036643981934,
0.024296702817082405,
0.19221702218055725,
-0.4908171594142914,
1.068483829498291,
-0.5149678587913513,
-0.6785624027252197,
-0.5772757530212402,
-0.29973727464675903,
0.46096593141555786,
-0.29283419251441956,
0.4926477074623108,
-0.4811702072620392,
-0.16642004251480103,
0.5238884091377258,
-0.46359124779701233,
0.697224497795105,
-0.061446551233530045,
-0.2312474101781845,
0.056564949452877045,
0.6249015927314758,
0.16837948560714722,
-0.019479619339108467,
-0.5492207407951355,
0.29622557759284973,
0.04260298237204552,
-0.44612210988998413,
-0.7871939539909363,
0.8808627128601074,
-0.7324591875076294,
-0.37277573347091675,
-0.46773940324783325,
-0.621066153049469,
-0.6437032222747803,
0.31612589955329895,
-0.3391483724117279,
0.41304007172584534,
-0.598895788192749,
0.31049269437789917,
0.29244527220726013,
-0.113460473716259,
0.010110587812960148,
0.6391202807426453,
-0.6858847141265869,
-0.610492467880249,
0.840287446975708,
0.0928310677409172,
0.26148515939712524,
0.10000984370708466,
0.22272464632987976,
-0.45563700795173645,
-0.4139924645423889,
-0.37784767150878906,
0.25305432081222534,
-1.0572553873062134,
-0.23965486884117126,
-0.07743506878614426,
-0.27740782499313354,
-0.14953573048114777,
-0.11308147013187408,
-0.39194455742836,
-0.5225138664245605,
0.2247019112110138,
-0.024697167798876762,
0.20526954531669617,
0.7055861353874207,
0.048056356608867645,
0.27907103300094604,
-0.6474046111106873,
0.3563133180141449,
0.1177263930439949,
0.7503942251205444,
0.02940683811903,
-0.5730002522468567,
-0.3753928542137146,
-0.15733350813388824,
-0.5285894870758057,
-0.47185230255126953,
0.01419123262166977,
0.09291863441467285,
0.7286545634269714,
0.332996129989624,
-0.2721605598926544,
0.8556404113769531,
-0.5885313153266907,
0.4136507213115692,
0.3131882846355438,
-1.3165717124938965,
0.2599424123764038,
-0.47547829151153564,
0.4471960961818695,
0.6218916177749634,
0.1793575882911682,
-0.5669950246810913,
-0.06803248822689056,
-0.4450136423110962,
-0.5891740918159485,
0.6169845461845398,
0.1997007131576538,
0.10142035782337189,
0.4174140691757202,
0.1507585644721985,
-0.0053685931488871574,
0.4198925495147705,
-0.6359016299247742,
-0.03115478716790676,
0.04025638476014137,
-0.2864251136779785,
-0.22804397344589233,
-0.1743415743112564,
-0.39246249198913574,
-0.44281721115112305,
0.37181633710861206,
-0.16759821772575378,
0.001352585619315505,
-0.47097793221473694,
-0.23486821353435516,
-0.2923688292503357,
0.30498549342155457,
0.4757843017578125,
1.286681056022644,
0.08172843605279922,
0.19363746047019958,
0.5414087176322937,
-0.401203453540802,
0.044172488152980804,
0.25315240025520325,
0.2858434319496155,
-0.1676052361726761,
0.5225220322608948,
0.4061490297317505,
0.8494898080825806,
-0.7986154556274414,
0.3633924722671509,
0.0697522908449173,
-0.3678763210773468,
-0.24221794307231903,
0.09458956867456436,
0.4147582948207855,
0.01800835132598877,
0.23786114156246185,
-0.1585513800382614,
0.11225464940071106,
-0.5128855109214783,
0.13210678100585938,
0.40770500898361206,
-0.06648414582014084,
-0.26452717185020447,
0.28710371255874634,
0.08397120982408524,
-0.27143365144729614,
0.559110164642334,
0.10209725797176361,
-0.6090831160545349,
0.8805056214332581,
0.5844283699989319,
0.5524850487709045,
-0.33809638023376465,
0.02267639711499214,
0.4019485116004944,
0.31192275881767273,
-0.0781092718243599,
0.3074438273906708,
-0.03879842534661293,
-0.39950406551361084,
-0.22939033806324005,
-0.7047704458236694,
-0.8006522059440613,
-0.27358153462409973,
-0.7511329054832458,
0.42678213119506836,
-0.6072799563407898,
-0.1740931123495102,
-0.04461628571152687,
0.2461518943309784,
-0.4822121560573578,
-0.15923748910427094,
0.023971425369381905,
1.0731306076049805,
-0.6381035447120667,
0.6331614851951599,
0.6470521688461304,
0.08848144114017487,
-0.5662331581115723,
-0.32228195667266846,
0.3051924705505371,
-1.0097274780273438,
0.598149299621582,
0.2248452752828598,
-0.3638223111629486,
0.07105563580989838,
-0.19868098199367523,
-0.9174444675445557,
1.0521944761276245,
0.6352550983428955,
-0.5699260830879211,
0.20974412560462952,
0.5097238421440125,
0.6994035840034485,
-0.2551179528236389,
0.3756081461906433,
0.6055812835693359,
0.4839927554130554,
0.22201457619667053,
-1.1479204893112183,
-0.20778492093086243,
-0.46135228872299194,
0.1646508425474167,
0.3220193088054657,
-0.49207407236099243,
1.0717576742172241,
-0.002144646132364869,
-0.13753993809223175,
0.2809455990791321,
0.48944130539894104,
0.3503963351249695,
0.40199536085128784,
0.36583495140075684,
0.8675802946090698,
0.6778111457824707,
-0.3078809976577759,
0.9834938645362854,
-0.43553030490875244,
0.48614850640296936,
0.9772630333900452,
-0.5185256004333496,
0.975581705570221,
0.1603577584028244,
-0.6979010105133057,
0.8177587985992432,
0.5041128993034363,
-0.0325302816927433,
0.09832678735256195,
0.7904313206672668,
-0.3170555531978607,
-0.3481282889842987,
-0.1099110022187233,
-0.6189213991165161,
0.22126296162605286,
0.5510796308517456,
-0.05848298966884613,
-0.7642934918403625,
-0.3455595076084137,
-0.041451346129179,
0.23007211089134216,
-0.38098543882369995,
0.3804280161857605,
0.29808515310287476,
-0.5275189876556396,
0.6021748781204224,
0.27513232827186584,
0.0853433832526207,
-0.9046413898468018,
-0.08711402863264084,
-0.28495079278945923,
0.5268887281417847,
-0.1697797030210495,
-0.7771443128585815,
0.1430554986000061,
0.05365636572241783,
0.11275395005941391,
0.04123729094862938,
0.4554336667060852,
-0.2185521125793457,
-0.8665299415588379,
0.3552050292491913,
0.8233967423439026,
0.15206174552440643,
-0.003395454492419958,
-0.967133641242981,
0.5425819158554077,
-0.5508361458778381,
0.013421410694718361,
0.3938561677932739,
0.5468499660491943,
-0.3446319103240967,
0.6523078680038452,
0.7962073683738708,
-0.05389741063117981,
0.032175466418266296,
0.4334181845188141,
0.9623419642448425,
-0.6777758598327637,
-0.3786020278930664,
-0.8628208041191101,
0.22057940065860748,
-0.10830321162939072,
-0.3036697804927826,
1.0705043077468872,
0.856503963470459,
0.9207035899162292,
0.04758467897772789,
0.4843688905239105,
0.12567853927612305,
0.47694388031959534,
-0.34402918815612793,
0.4887941777706146,
-0.628709077835083,
0.40808936953544617,
-0.40643730759620667,
-1.0702484846115112,
-0.4895988702774048,
0.7762117981910706,
-0.7478277683258057,
0.29111969470977783,
0.9034490585327148,
0.6905218362808228,
-0.24856939911842346,
0.05038696527481079,
0.544874906539917,
0.04239512234926224,
0.09628704935312271,
0.6078208684921265,
1.0958629846572876,
-0.17795027792453766,
0.454236775636673,
-0.25988590717315674,
-0.32467374205589294,
-0.2095303237438202,
-0.8101356625556946,
-1.1838486194610596,
-0.06471870094537735,
-0.013509764336049557,
-0.19875268638134003,
-0.13683964312076569,
0.6819058656692505,
0.4547766149044037,
-0.7488844394683838,
-1.0410070419311523,
-0.23389804363250732,
0.15733079612255096,
-0.1447134166955948,
-0.25708794593811035,
0.13047125935554504,
-0.2986632287502289,
-0.5865726470947266,
0.2893229126930237,
0.29665905237197876,
-0.13826464116573334,
-0.5817755460739136,
0.043889377266168594,
0.26808348298072815,
-0.08055631816387177,
0.51526939868927,
0.17421051859855652,
-0.5037600994110107,
0.38033127784729004,
0.17270036041736603,
-0.17282450199127197,
0.06992311030626297,
1.179160237312317,
-0.5950708389282227,
0.4398556351661682,
0.3549076318740845,
0.765026330947876,
0.557706892490387,
-0.06385686993598938,
0.5976220965385437,
-0.2951156795024872,
0.11447044461965561,
0.13718181848526,
0.38148921728134155,
0.2539149224758148,
0.18001532554626465,
0.699400007724762,
0.3013315796852112,
-0.2070757895708084,
-0.9599641561508179,
0.18741624057292938,
-0.7912049293518066,
-0.023487553000450134,
0.6279675960540771,
-0.18625043332576752,
-0.2028568536043167,
-0.0035422134678810835,
-0.13911283016204834,
-0.27361148595809937,
-0.2469010353088379,
0.6970944404602051,
1.0868728160858154,
-0.035674117505550385,
-0.08371332287788391,
-0.8663423657417297,
0.007226615212857723,
0.7430769205093384,
-1.078294277191162,
0.1866990029811859,
0.47618699073791504,
0.23453612625598907,
0.08918020874261856,
0.48951396346092224,
-0.522074818611145,
0.5138252377510071,
0.04881482943892479,
0.052621401846408844,
0.09428127110004425,
-0.30695441365242004,
-0.31701022386550903,
0.20061485469341278,
0.3395085036754608,
0.35397881269454956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12206v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12206v1
|
Modeling citation worthiness by using attention-based bidirectional long short-term memory networks and interpretable models
| 2024-05-20T17:45:36 | 2024-05-20T17:45:36 |
Tong Zeng, Daniel E. Acuna
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Scientist learn early on how to cite scientific sources to support their
claims. Sometimes, however, scientists have challenges determining where a
citation should be situated -- or, even worse, fail to cite a source
altogether. Automatically detecting sentences that need a citation (i.e.,
citation worthiness) could solve both of these issues, leading to more robust
and well-constructed scientific arguments. Previous researchers have applied
machine learning to this task but have used small datasets and models that do
not take advantage of recent algorithmic developments such as attention
mechanisms in deep learning. We hypothesize that we can develop significantly
accurate deep learning architectures that learn from large supervised datasets
constructed from open access publications. In this work, we propose a
Bidirectional Long Short-Term Memory (BiLSTM) network with attention mechanism
and contextual information to detect sentences that need citations. We also
produce a new, large dataset (PMOA-CITE) based on PubMed Open Access Subset,
which is orders of magnitude larger than previous datasets. Our experiments
show that our architecture achieves state of the art performance on the
standard ACL-ARC dataset ($F_{1}=0.507$) and exhibits high performance
($F_{1}=0.856$) on the new PMOA-CITE. Moreover, we show that it can transfer
learning across these datasets. We further use interpretable models to
illuminate how specific language is used to promote and inhibit citations. We
discover that sections and surrounding sentences are crucial for our improved
predictions. We further examined purported mispredictions of the model, and
uncovered systematic human mistakes in citation behavior and source data. This
opens the door for our model to check documents during pre-submission and
pre-archival procedures. We make this new dataset, the code, and a web-based
tool available to the community.
|
[
-0.012870628386735916,
-0.326392263174057,
0.9440343976020813,
0.22322283685207367,
-0.3124898374080658,
-0.25143933296203613,
-0.1603183150291443,
-0.3961147964000702,
0.06243109330534935,
0.3353034257888794,
-0.11702346056699753,
-0.2318069487810135,
-0.4997994005680084,
0.35796666145324707,
-0.25312864780426025,
0.9177101254463196,
0.007951856590807438,
0.03962162137031555,
-0.5808996558189392,
-0.24726232886314392,
-0.2376260608434677,
-0.34709814190864563,
-0.16846902668476105,
-0.3156271278858185,
1.0557715892791748,
0.28802958130836487,
0.5979537963867188,
0.40332895517349243,
0.8215135931968689,
0.12295202910900116,
-0.22751502692699432,
0.2606600821018219,
-0.45358312129974365,
0.002598883816972375,
-0.6950722932815552,
-0.3358432352542877,
-0.4049142599105835,
-0.026532402262091637,
0.6993526220321655,
0.826714038848877,
0.16901953518390656,
0.2294626235961914,
0.1408064067363739,
0.8777249455451965,
-0.5961265563964844,
0.35384687781333923,
-0.5648406744003296,
-0.24543540179729462,
-0.48793497681617737,
-0.35228461027145386,
-0.6101884245872498,
-0.2941266894340515,
0.3622158467769623,
-0.3232826590538025,
0.05489327758550644,
0.273547887802124,
0.9172264337539673,
0.26027506589889526,
-0.2799517512321472,
-0.26154911518096924,
-0.42919793725013733,
0.6648028492927551,
-0.616296648979187,
0.3361493945121765,
0.4914734363555908,
0.03620603308081627,
-0.05354166403412819,
-0.9520593881607056,
-0.3975200951099396,
-0.36044934391975403,
-0.24646709859371185,
0.08166974037885666,
-0.44745495915412903,
-0.10513149201869965,
0.14651957154273987,
0.08374636620283127,
-0.7919617295265198,
-0.19495686888694763,
-0.5451626777648926,
0.008341402746737003,
0.35778018832206726,
-0.2073211669921875,
-0.11943317949771881,
-0.41628319025039673,
-0.3928803503513336,
0.07592198997735977,
-0.8466907143592834,
-0.1905694305896759,
0.27713990211486816,
0.5797289609909058,
0.2214345633983612,
0.6686831712722778,
0.06818543374538422,
0.37528929114341736,
-0.013757552020251751,
0.6310186386108398,
0.2728385031223297,
-0.5314872860908508,
-0.19252996146678925,
0.19066651165485382,
0.5972006916999817,
0.1442337930202484,
0.3563250005245209,
-0.4239555299282074,
0.0222853422164917,
-0.4752921164035797,
0.3369999825954437,
-0.9795973300933838,
-0.40855205059051514,
0.29073241353034973,
-0.6134132146835327,
-0.13218142092227936,
0.01180250383913517,
-0.5353603363037109,
-0.18875569105148315,
-0.545898973941803,
0.42373332381248474,
-0.4944263994693756,
0.019635170698165894,
0.040818944573402405,
0.03591431304812431,
-0.30248361825942993,
0.15832951664924622,
-0.3219142556190491,
-0.21699053049087524,
0.33350691199302673,
1.3122769594192505,
-0.1499536782503128,
-0.5576342344284058,
-0.6265932321548462,
0.3380867540836334,
-0.092837393283844,
0.9090181589126587,
-0.45848774909973145,
-0.09017393738031387,
-0.24281783401966095,
0.17849460244178772,
-0.2635383903980255,
-0.4364132881164551,
0.6260147094726562,
-0.9052709937095642,
0.09638646245002747,
-0.27808651328086853,
-0.33992066979408264,
-0.09612984955310822,
0.17600837349891663,
-0.8479940891265869,
0.5297362804412842,
0.07447659969329834,
-0.9408078789710999,
0.039771776646375656,
-0.9683223366737366,
-0.39898520708084106,
0.01910598948597908,
0.36023762822151184,
-0.5870841145515442,
0.14883749186992645,
0.02112078294157982,
0.385588675737381,
-0.32053107023239136,
0.6730470657348633,
-0.59480220079422,
-0.12045933306217194,
0.46785780787467957,
-0.2472214549779892,
0.8688158392906189,
0.41967955231666565,
-0.0903959572315216,
0.23082619905471802,
-0.8269684910774231,
-0.11881788820028305,
0.10815171897411346,
-0.32679688930511475,
-0.5678397417068481,
0.12392836064100266,
0.12714457511901855,
0.10180049389600754,
0.0889061763882637,
-0.4833931028842926,
-0.07936545461416245,
-0.4023652672767639,
0.7136370539665222,
0.733877956867218,
0.05157974734902382,
0.3224928677082062,
-0.2331450879573822,
0.15523487329483032,
0.239749014377594,
-0.09481766819953918,
-0.3632110059261322,
-0.2737468183040619,
-0.3927990198135376,
-0.10409852117300034,
0.3479556739330292,
0.2749188244342804,
-0.3923376500606537,
0.32154375314712524,
-0.6233877539634705,
-0.11751215904951096,
-0.45977798104286194,
0.2626936733722687,
0.26177507638931274,
0.840774655342102,
0.6819666028022766,
-0.1255825310945511,
-0.7307360172271729,
-0.9420403838157654,
-0.2769818603992462,
-0.2691684663295746,
-0.025609135627746582,
0.4773489534854889,
0.7081763744354248,
-0.3029455542564392,
1.0244075059890747,
-0.28252431750297546,
-0.14322596788406372,
0.12206947803497314,
0.4267631471157074,
0.22001713514328003,
0.3543533980846405,
0.2939043641090393,
-0.9562155604362488,
-0.23442348837852478,
-0.28494492173194885,
-0.8258859515190125,
-0.21834295988082886,
-0.06657690554857254,
-0.2040315568447113,
-0.10567208379507065,
0.5435745716094971,
-0.48385122418403625,
0.18216025829315186,
0.15248849987983704,
-0.4560011923313141,
0.48994749784469604,
-0.1351138949394226,
-0.17250888049602509,
-0.9364039897918701,
0.7398832440376282,
0.059649623930454254,
-0.1900031715631485,
-0.2780347168445587,
-0.11389350146055222,
0.390463262796402,
-0.26901301741600037,
-0.39489299058914185,
0.34466010332107544,
-0.5596612095832825,
-0.04900888353586197,
-0.41217711567878723,
-0.09208035469055176,
0.3220352530479431,
0.2867915630340576,
0.06429578363895416,
0.6918774247169495,
0.06555771082639694,
-0.3828008770942688,
0.06630394607782364,
0.22038023173809052,
-0.3644026517868042,
0.631484866142273,
-0.9606661200523376,
0.028929900377988815,
-0.3770102858543396,
0.234696164727211,
-0.7694644331932068,
-0.12953390181064606,
-0.029374947771430016,
-0.3038792908191681,
0.36790934205055237,
-0.3533410429954529,
-0.5098395347595215,
-0.342309832572937,
-0.021973880007863045,
0.5116406679153442,
-0.051944948732852936,
-0.5547673106193542,
0.2842550575733185,
0.08437151461839676,
-0.31902894377708435,
-0.4516015648841858,
-0.6361826062202454,
0.3762788772583008,
0.063987135887146,
-0.5487849712371826,
0.3944208025932312,
-0.234031543135643,
-0.17711438238620758,
0.3537914454936981,
0.29980263113975525,
0.03490067273378372,
0.09712427854537964,
0.41355398297309875,
0.45895498991012573,
-0.28356462717056274,
0.46425479650497437,
-0.07535932958126068,
-0.09574653208255768,
0.1601260006427765,
-0.5114194750785828,
0.2849818766117096,
-0.4299696981906891,
-0.25723904371261597,
-0.21687886118888855,
0.32097503542900085,
0.8468052744865417,
-0.4313463568687439,
0.617030143737793,
0.3909045159816742,
-0.23863965272903442,
0.2590485215187073,
-0.224511057138443,
-0.06712878495454788,
-0.3856467604637146,
0.30406653881073,
-0.048017341643571854,
-0.6175375580787659,
0.18202973902225494,
-0.06927181780338287,
-0.07406556606292725,
0.36659806966781616,
0.4970332682132721,
-0.2830613851547241,
0.6114179491996765,
0.24302925169467926,
-0.0246615968644619,
0.4017196297645569,
-0.07641373574733734,
0.30016911029815674,
-0.9065477252006531,
-0.2061656266450882,
-0.6143040060997009,
-0.3593520522117615,
-0.07580836117267609,
-0.597024142742157,
0.14928129315376282,
0.14433085918426514,
-0.41177499294281006,
0.21923546493053436,
-0.49914291501045227,
0.4744836390018463,
0.5581426620483398,
0.1733779013156891,
0.2663593888282776,
-0.0034646005369722843,
-0.03615415841341019,
0.21729318797588348,
-0.3195604681968689,
-0.6877586841583252,
1.2371811866760254,
0.3438485562801361,
0.6339104771614075,
0.07203421741724014,
0.4447971284389496,
0.48568060994148254,
0.3591817319393158,
-0.6036444902420044,
0.24003367125988007,
0.22871606051921844,
-0.6009456515312195,
-0.25150346755981445,
-0.4107174277305603,
-1.0922164916992188,
0.026501895859837532,
0.15498819947242737,
-0.2851657271385193,
0.6173271536827087,
0.16678300499916077,
-0.3120677173137665,
0.1456928700208664,
-0.7319006323814392,
0.7844765782356262,
-0.3706521689891815,
-0.8406291604042053,
-0.17619502544403076,
-0.8799704909324646,
0.06709671765565872,
0.0020675293635576963,
0.06003560498356819,
-0.08285138010978699,
0.15493562817573547,
0.7182681560516357,
-0.09818543493747711,
0.6748605966567993,
-0.2695913314819336,
0.3916138708591461,
0.23782026767730713,
-0.03836553916335106,
0.6148624420166016,
0.050563231110572815,
-0.35338810086250305,
0.17629022896289825,
-0.05015259236097336,
-0.6029717326164246,
-0.32362040877342224,
0.7870707511901855,
-0.5234732627868652,
-0.40875259041786194,
-0.5035836100578308,
-0.7323419451713562,
-0.09788494557142258,
0.5883519649505615,
-0.016264213249087334,
0.12165562808513641,
-0.1789218783378601,
0.467181533575058,
0.6882277131080627,
0.23492774367332458,
0.513638436794281,
0.5593010187149048,
0.15667112171649933,
-0.43432044982910156,
0.9098678827285767,
0.18228046596050262,
-0.06555164605379105,
0.42586782574653625,
0.24849654734134674,
-0.3297315239906311,
-0.887222170829773,
-0.3807860314846039,
0.3770373463630676,
-0.41344285011291504,
-0.42806318402290344,
-0.6640275120735168,
-0.055942241102457047,
-0.49149656295776367,
0.0755731388926506,
-0.19249145686626434,
-0.28541961312294006,
-0.6564434766769409,
-0.19320274889469147,
0.10523270815610886,
0.21879835426807404,
-0.16511064767837524,
-0.23551104962825775,
-0.7426252961158752,
-0.04063001275062561,
0.2722121775150299,
0.38516438007354736,
0.22233594954013824,
-0.4254694879055023,
-0.4789285361766815,
0.03333910554647446,
-0.1975872963666916,
-0.8027109503746033,
0.3989098370075226,
0.22891511023044586,
0.469842791557312,
0.5039731860160828,
0.1614382416009903,
0.459607869386673,
-0.5288606286048889,
0.3863118588924408,
-0.041090335696935654,
-0.6420263051986694,
0.7982710599899292,
-0.27722620964050293,
0.0844898372888565,
0.8058228492736816,
0.6058720350265503,
-0.052956629544496536,
0.1673218458890915,
-0.3014279305934906,
-0.7848418354988098,
0.5963718891143799,
0.23739849030971527,
-0.1538623869419098,
-0.21965178847312927,
0.31573837995529175,
-0.03601358085870743,
0.14517909288406372,
-0.7489346861839294,
0.14861826598644257,
-0.45497244596481323,
-0.3314196765422821,
-0.25382623076438904,
-0.3155841827392578,
-0.23700277507305145,
-0.0054139746353030205,
0.7003816366195679,
-0.4371449947357178,
0.2551220655441284,
0.5287166237831116,
-0.5087470412254333,
-0.16905876994132996,
0.35362547636032104,
0.5998238921165466,
0.8976348042488098,
-0.6950809955596924,
0.42231908440589905,
-0.4322655498981476,
-0.43920719623565674,
-0.11737886816263199,
0.5638314485549927,
-0.2991081476211548,
0.020008394494652748,
0.1779133528470993,
0.6248513460159302,
0.32040083408355713,
-0.8508725166320801,
0.5423792600631714,
0.20558993518352509,
-0.08770270645618439,
-0.20861248672008514,
-0.4566592574119568,
0.37065377831459045,
0.4042627811431885,
0.47213345766067505,
0.262347936630249,
0.2761939764022827,
-0.5958614349365234,
0.12744933366775513,
0.34230712056159973,
-0.6479703187942505,
-0.4991207718849182,
0.6641986966133118,
0.09013903141021729,
-0.12249678373336792,
0.5872239470481873,
0.08142745494842529,
-0.34904107451438904,
0.353433758020401,
0.5256658792495728,
0.791956901550293,
0.08161813020706177,
0.062459900975227356,
0.37957412004470825,
0.19710476696491241,
0.008455577306449413,
-0.03146974369883537,
-0.36269327998161316,
-0.3545214831829071,
-0.16681620478630066,
-0.7537789344787598,
-0.4107308089733124,
-0.0036154799163341522,
-0.761003315448761,
0.04402688145637512,
-0.15503434836864471,
-0.07183243334293365,
0.32951754331588745,
-0.03788117319345474,
-0.5523961186408997,
0.0016459228936582804,
0.1708420366048813,
0.8405868411064148,
-0.8364431858062744,
1.0179533958435059,
0.6130582094192505,
-0.6983957290649414,
-0.22701293230056763,
-0.1173335537314415,
-0.24948781728744507,
-0.5829600691795349,
0.8531079292297363,
0.182257741689682,
-0.07061063498258591,
-0.15920136868953705,
-0.6625360250473022,
-1.0453698635101318,
1.1888062953948975,
0.3118187189102173,
-0.6702010035514832,
-0.31045421957969666,
-0.22652839124202728,
0.4982312321662903,
-0.279969722032547,
0.11277631670236588,
0.19396351277828217,
0.5078718662261963,
0.1738283783197403,
-0.5206472277641296,
0.18441453576087952,
-0.44720005989074707,
-0.14733847975730896,
0.10251648724079132,
-0.5873271226882935,
0.8188412189483643,
-0.5251291394233704,
-0.10554588586091995,
0.01135356817394495,
0.8123146891593933,
0.3427291512489319,
0.9728263020515442,
0.331613153219223,
0.5658108592033386,
1.0982493162155151,
0.21537445485591888,
0.8050205707550049,
-0.18243521451950073,
0.31493914127349854,
1.3381003141403198,
-0.5465472340583801,
1.0171104669570923,
0.8037334084510803,
-0.12322478741407394,
0.7474710941314697,
0.40102043747901917,
-0.2804020345211029,
0.7756937742233276,
0.045607082545757294,
0.006559179630130529,
-0.31356164813041687,
-0.2198929786682129,
-0.3146503269672394,
0.017115499824285507,
0.3362875282764435,
-1.013532042503357,
-0.11554989963769913,
0.29700395464897156,
-0.05479838699102402,
-0.01451460737735033,
-0.23051436245441437,
0.4011789858341217,
0.08821222931146622,
-0.8029520511627197,
0.3243085443973541,
-0.21139414608478546,
0.3193689286708832,
-0.44496744871139526,
0.11704401671886444,
-0.06757945567369461,
0.24376678466796875,
-0.2570743262767792,
-0.8262113332748413,
0.33913519978523254,
-0.04219797998666763,
-0.8307425379753113,
-0.2067856341600418,
0.7830859422683716,
-0.2905801236629486,
-0.42375603318214417,
0.23181243240833282,
0.37642034888267517,
0.2387116551399231,
-0.21930283308029175,
-0.4862307906150818,
-0.29243582487106323,
-0.04297013208270073,
-0.3728228509426117,
0.547244668006897,
0.277628630399704,
-0.07754085958003998,
0.535468578338623,
1.0004546642303467,
0.12958717346191406,
-0.16149643063545227,
0.09654973447322845,
0.8981444835662842,
-0.5699530839920044,
-0.4002643823623657,
-0.7402538657188416,
0.18469592928886414,
-0.30108878016471863,
0.0016021316405385733,
0.6406869292259216,
0.8471802473068237,
0.48683008551597595,
0.1476924568414688,
0.6278316378593445,
0.18898767232894897,
0.702621340751648,
-0.2933015823364258,
0.7814351320266724,
-0.5227044820785522,
0.26085153222084045,
-0.11200951039791107,
-0.5540335774421692,
-0.44130146503448486,
0.47106999158859253,
-0.497981995344162,
-0.15925227105617523,
0.6370714902877808,
0.715850293636322,
-0.2394849807024002,
0.17200800776481628,
0.09250878542661667,
0.3661753833293915,
0.47015121579170227,
0.5638240575790405,
0.6355365514755249,
-0.2219190001487732,
0.7542255520820618,
-0.27681097388267517,
-0.05130869895219803,
-0.5608118772506714,
-1.0499327182769775,
-0.844532310962677,
-0.5899646282196045,
-0.2853189706802368,
-0.6339877843856812,
0.3195594549179077,
0.7189700603485107,
0.6443971991539001,
-0.7963366508483887,
0.2938203811645508,
-0.26350390911102295,
0.20666469633579254,
-0.06218449026346207,
-0.19674891233444214,
0.9225473999977112,
-0.39938879013061523,
-0.4893762469291687,
0.40359947085380554,
0.4950684607028961,
0.054387036710977554,
-0.1370299607515335,
-0.0507834255695343,
-0.583750307559967,
0.19369006156921387,
0.675076425075531,
0.5557029843330383,
-0.5133996605873108,
-0.14418165385723114,
0.13792113959789276,
-0.2764084041118622,
0.11451949924230576,
0.9298769235610962,
-0.8069868087768555,
0.6411809325218201,
0.4403055012226105,
0.5093326568603516,
0.5036244988441467,
-0.0029683273751288652,
0.28401637077331543,
-0.3471697270870209,
-0.2304743528366089,
0.6200069189071655,
0.5979642868041992,
0.46565887331962585,
-0.36011993885040283,
0.5397495031356812,
0.34813252091407776,
-0.9354816675186157,
-1.0256683826446533,
-0.2002914696931839,
-1.101424217224121,
-0.43209290504455566,
0.8409420251846313,
-0.3756383955478668,
-0.44414249062538147,
-0.31527337431907654,
0.08102645725011826,
0.10081831365823746,
-0.283358097076416,
0.9004414677619934,
0.6304357647895813,
-0.08849472552537918,
-0.15066242218017578,
-0.12262316048145294,
0.1069282665848732,
0.4816208779811859,
-0.5754499435424805,
0.399946391582489,
0.5899064540863037,
0.19268348813056946,
0.44219130277633667,
0.2556045949459076,
-0.2318504899740219,
0.5622993111610413,
-0.3012084662914276,
-0.19273073971271515,
-0.5928983688354492,
-0.45183196663856506,
-0.3378457725048065,
0.5013176202774048,
0.03578444942831993,
-0.06328577548265457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17787v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17787v1
|
Role of Dependency Distance in Text Simplification: A Human vs ChatGPT Simplification Comparison
| 2024-05-20T17:43:17 | 2024-05-20T17:43:17 |
Sumi Lee, Gondy Leroy, David Kauchak, Melissa Just
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study investigates human and ChatGPT text simplification and its
relationship to dependency distance. A set of 220 sentences, with increasing
grammatical difficulty as measured in a prior user study, were simplified by a
human expert and using ChatGPT. We found that the three sentence sets all
differed in mean dependency distances: the highest in the original sentence
set, followed by ChatGPT simplified sentences, and the human simplified
sentences showed the lowest mean dependency distance.
|
[
-0.2185174822807312,
-0.5449051260948181,
0.6629120111465454,
0.3574196398258209,
-0.11195997893810272,
-0.36585965752601624,
-0.19746996462345123,
-0.7933803200721741,
0.11012744903564453,
0.040885210037231445,
-0.6383532881736755,
0.006767623592168093,
-0.6255627274513245,
0.4919610321521759,
0.14953160285949707,
0.8680854439735413,
-0.18891343474388123,
-0.03794523701071739,
-0.36189892888069153,
0.03455475717782974,
-0.5945384502410889,
-0.6925243139266968,
-0.3507104516029358,
-0.4135584235191345,
0.6297848224639893,
0.5397784113883972,
1.0260303020477295,
0.6563800573348999,
0.9527102708816528,
0.3601458966732025,
-0.37433069944381714,
-0.12368394434452057,
-0.1372465342283249,
-0.0649874359369278,
0.10187892615795135,
-0.7675110697746277,
-0.18567852675914764,
0.03952163830399513,
0.28543007373809814,
1.0771254301071167,
-0.034971684217453,
-0.14130240678787231,
0.16397395730018616,
1.1087830066680908,
-0.5555257201194763,
0.4257263243198395,
-0.05574886500835419,
0.03604845330119133,
-0.3749692142009735,
-0.05407533049583435,
-0.09841534495353699,
-0.2960965633392334,
0.6856591105461121,
-0.699944257736206,
0.5363726615905762,
0.2125341296195984,
1.1769070625305176,
0.4677627682685852,
-0.5982756614685059,
-0.43488383293151855,
-0.7411161661148071,
0.7507060766220093,
-0.42954617738723755,
0.06599073857069016,
0.2572309672832489,
0.15325786173343658,
-0.30475613474845886,
-0.5414243340492249,
-0.34807896614074707,
-0.25419801473617554,
-0.642956018447876,
-0.036987919360399246,
-0.05144481733441353,
0.6436445116996765,
0.8629154562950134,
0.33736559748649597,
-0.3541899621486664,
-0.335107684135437,
-0.9981693625450134,
-0.11357264965772629,
0.43316131830215454,
-0.005381579976528883,
0.637355625629425,
-0.8477454781532288,
-0.3190813660621643,
0.06562555581331253,
-0.8921079635620117,
-0.10623214393854141,
0.2481273114681244,
0.28979894518852234,
0.1463572382926941,
0.6426663994789124,
-0.4929095506668091,
0.25248244404792786,
-0.21133717894554138,
-0.16151022911071777,
0.30363285541534424,
-0.41329294443130493,
-0.21145348250865936,
0.16571925580501556,
0.8888193368911743,
0.5911325216293335,
0.7187199592590332,
-0.03559884801506996,
0.15959756076335907,
0.06573738902807236,
0.17998410761356354,
-0.7723852396011353,
-0.31753259897232056,
-0.4187600314617157,
-0.5909371376037598,
0.11123402416706085,
0.2916814982891083,
-0.5078256130218506,
-0.3395462930202484,
-0.48273465037345886,
0.4267728328704834,
-0.43289056420326233,
0.03801669180393219,
0.14374107122421265,
-0.22682802379131317,
0.0798209011554718,
0.47726523876190186,
-1.0119576454162598,
0.6477532386779785,
0.528670072555542,
0.9375154972076416,
-0.09503675997257233,
-0.5278100967407227,
0.07297622412443161,
0.057963110506534576,
0.017407912760972977,
0.9177517294883728,
-0.07122163474559784,
-0.42786604166030884,
-0.5241923928260803,
-0.3670658767223358,
-0.212276428937912,
-0.6040287613868713,
0.851108193397522,
0.01819542981684208,
0.5501211285591125,
-0.5003429651260376,
-0.6943755149841309,
-0.6358311772346497,
-0.3119259774684906,
-0.7399365901947021,
0.9987393617630005,
0.2532801330089569,
-1.1519685983657837,
0.546094536781311,
-0.5659896731376648,
-0.7644869089126587,
0.23036086559295654,
-0.2080545872449875,
-0.35954633355140686,
-0.024758554995059967,
0.006956242024898529,
0.3642062246799469,
-0.1868087351322174,
-0.07661920040845871,
-0.030545620247721672,
-0.6199069023132324,
-0.06617681682109833,
-0.3767069876194,
0.9676389098167419,
-0.041144225746393204,
-0.5699831247329712,
-0.25464320182800293,
-0.7739840149879456,
-0.218056321144104,
-0.3222053349018097,
-0.7199686169624329,
-0.5452274084091187,
0.2800677716732025,
0.1115574985742569,
0.1884995847940445,
-0.031903818249702454,
-0.3504701852798462,
0.1911834478378296,
-0.3934940993785858,
0.35925477743148804,
0.41847532987594604,
0.308765709400177,
0.3548993766307831,
-0.4854622185230255,
0.5678309202194214,
-0.053288329392671585,
0.1616925150156021,
-0.048606593161821365,
-0.804846465587616,
-0.740294337272644,
-0.14212223887443542,
0.38018909096717834,
0.951676070690155,
-0.3869485557079315,
0.26548415422439575,
-0.4017227292060852,
-0.1854771226644516,
-0.3507303297519684,
0.2130271941423416,
0.3436596393585205,
0.3959819972515106,
0.37105992436408997,
-0.17338788509368896,
-0.599534809589386,
-1.2109477519989014,
-0.34784236550331116,
-0.5204895734786987,
-0.2968442738056183,
0.09623218327760696,
0.5300658941268921,
0.02454182133078575,
1.058809757232666,
-0.7260094881057739,
-0.5206356644630432,
-0.2517485022544861,
0.1044517382979393,
-0.10060691088438034,
0.44628357887268066,
0.5029392838478088,
-1.060266375541687,
-0.7736936211585999,
-0.13421635329723358,
-0.5079438090324402,
-0.34529054164886475,
-0.0028576229233294725,
0.0838632881641388,
0.011299435049295425,
0.8221769332885742,
-1.1171985864639282,
0.9959476590156555,
0.12218906730413437,
-0.4296061396598816,
0.7785025238990784,
-0.5044667720794678,
0.28582412004470825,
-1.113867998123169,
-0.20616880059242249,
-0.0009565571672283113,
-0.1979926973581314,
-0.730806291103363,
-0.28991419076919556,
0.03368625044822693,
0.1746162325143814,
-0.5475680232048035,
0.005121773108839989,
-0.4681483507156372,
-0.028133206069469452,
0.15026305615901947,
0.13382954895496368,
-0.0053778295405209064,
0.4776025116443634,
-0.2024981528520584,
0.8027054667472839,
0.20597051084041595,
-0.48486340045928955,
0.4448103904724121,
0.1498369425535202,
-0.20461909472942352,
0.4664514362812042,
-0.9697082042694092,
-0.39811617136001587,
0.09557688236236572,
0.2663118243217468,
-1.0810518264770508,
-0.5608273148536682,
0.26623061299324036,
-0.2692226767539978,
-0.35040247440338135,
0.13322217762470245,
-0.8188562393188477,
0.11356149613857269,
-0.2220878303050995,
0.5560184121131897,
0.7464529275894165,
-0.14679747819900513,
0.3815484642982483,
-0.24640922248363495,
-0.31423044204711914,
-0.17886818945407867,
-0.8279826045036316,
0.03072364255785942,
-0.4829673171043396,
-0.9255807995796204,
0.45092499256134033,
-0.02589699812233448,
-0.8008564710617065,
-0.15536850690841675,
0.07892859727144241,
-0.055497076362371445,
0.014333866536617279,
0.6254777312278748,
0.009145322255790234,
-0.10836608707904816,
0.5421656370162964,
-0.14537189900875092,
-0.07294673472642899,
0.14012715220451355,
0.597837507724762,
0.09244909137487411,
-0.21479523181915283,
-0.2663136124610901,
-0.5611344575881958,
0.5852801203727722,
0.3333704173564911,
0.2926933169364929,
0.6552539467811584,
0.05533163249492645,
-0.18870773911476135,
0.2795434892177582,
-0.6023358106613159,
0.024074211716651917,
-0.5069740414619446,
-0.02837313897907734,
-0.5503082871437073,
-0.7849008440971375,
0.4330645501613617,
0.0879778116941452,
-0.35676199197769165,
0.5539208054542542,
0.20617038011550903,
-0.1652987003326416,
0.6581867933273315,
0.5835824012756348,
0.14380982518196106,
0.46084943413734436,
0.555443525314331,
0.05339625105261803,
-0.35475268959999084,
-0.1852744072675705,
-0.6519594192504883,
-0.07448086142539978,
-1.043344259262085,
-0.24325822293758392,
0.21617449820041656,
0.3103136122226715,
-0.18775664269924164,
0.2443341314792633,
-0.15798801183700562,
0.8033242225646973,
0.6339356899261475,
0.46241649985313416,
0.45280876755714417,
-0.08191846311092377,
-0.03723499923944473,
-0.31384992599487305,
-0.45194143056869507,
-0.4335179328918457,
0.7395505905151367,
0.15404152870178223,
0.5391411781311035,
0.303083211183548,
0.7434742450714111,
0.2169368863105774,
-0.12291917949914932,
-0.7819954752922058,
0.6193616390228271,
-0.1295396238565445,
-0.40897250175476074,
-0.33887022733688354,
-0.6589253544807434,
-1.0967961549758911,
0.03711959347128868,
0.08947908133268356,
-0.6339941620826721,
-0.22301085293293,
-0.05815131217241287,
-0.18538470566272736,
-0.0961107388138771,
-1.4124329090118408,
0.5561872720718384,
0.37413161993026733,
0.033916175365448,
-0.014960499480366707,
-1.0629565715789795,
-0.06705578416585922,
0.22993749380111694,
0.02063082344830036,
-0.08097013086080551,
-0.04147639870643616,
0.8965637683868408,
-0.8391466736793518,
0.8913419842720032,
0.18302346765995026,
0.1574573814868927,
0.3094283640384674,
-0.022393500432372093,
0.14232848584651947,
-0.34267470240592957,
0.153020977973938,
-0.25847047567367554,
-0.3777505159378052,
-0.6231284141540527,
-0.465561181306839,
0.3501395583152771,
-0.6562396287918091,
-0.7824628949165344,
-0.28602561354637146,
-0.7190566658973694,
-0.020517216995358467,
0.35058102011680603,
0.3902920186519623,
0.32021522521972656,
-0.27651408314704895,
0.10780804604291916,
0.4470594525337219,
-0.1226145401597023,
0.7284734845161438,
-0.046854015439748764,
0.014010090380907059,
-0.10504373162984848,
0.2631993591785431,
0.18179455399513245,
0.7057298421859741,
0.5607470273971558,
0.32858744263648987,
-0.18376073241233826,
-0.12297554314136505,
-0.2668358385562897,
0.4281306266784668,
-0.9518716931343079,
0.2535722851753235,
-0.41148248314857483,
-0.09827636927366257,
-0.38894325494766235,
-0.33578115701675415,
-0.046324051916599274,
-0.7224373817443848,
-0.2972504794597626,
-0.21709208190441132,
0.6015293002128601,
1.1419649124145508,
-0.01999266818165779,
0.5281194448471069,
-0.5373167395591736,
0.14584361016750336,
0.6261565685272217,
0.1805262714624405,
-0.29860326647758484,
-0.1739174723625183,
-0.05654856190085411,
-0.2880376875400543,
-0.2582738399505615,
-0.9112217426300049,
0.08010606467723846,
0.16799801588058472,
0.233428493142128,
0.34090250730514526,
-0.18281866610050201,
1.0376771688461304,
-0.6937077641487122,
0.9346825480461121,
0.3566807210445404,
-1.023539662361145,
0.4631660282611847,
-0.5186562538146973,
0.5344126224517822,
0.6617277264595032,
0.32352131605148315,
-0.6282262206077576,
-0.2747165560722351,
-0.8970686793327332,
-0.7014021873474121,
0.5283285975456238,
0.6319299936294556,
-0.27209851145744324,
0.1703864187002182,
0.797699511051178,
-0.08078621327877045,
-0.23399148881435394,
-0.8537330627441406,
-0.48121917247772217,
0.38831689953804016,
-0.062063589692115784,
-0.10187825560569763,
-0.3205643594264984,
0.2417590469121933,
-0.29904046654701233,
0.3400951325893402,
0.2743038833141327,
0.2923833131790161,
0.33207884430885315,
-0.11888659745454788,
0.00033325309050269425,
0.4046410620212555,
0.7867307066917419,
0.6965371370315552,
-0.1514359563589096,
0.2710278034210205,
0.47637301683425903,
-0.7970070242881775,
0.2575778365135193,
0.14167986810207367,
-0.0926331877708435,
0.3526666760444641,
0.8408191204071045,
0.6088683009147644,
0.2111174315214157,
-0.4389754831790924,
0.6688053607940674,
-0.007714323233813047,
-0.5292708873748779,
-0.13672810792922974,
0.13496863842010498,
0.3461461365222931,
0.03133617714047432,
0.2155493050813675,
0.3302849233150482,
0.44546520709991455,
-0.23500964045524597,
0.2499997764825821,
-0.19638711214065552,
-0.6279078722000122,
-0.07467678934335709,
0.4343849718570709,
0.09452307224273682,
-0.5716553926467896,
0.7524413466453552,
-0.10682400315999985,
-0.7005782723426819,
0.8103174567222595,
0.13196773827075958,
0.705155611038208,
-0.4339638352394104,
0.1228465884923935,
0.24162915349006653,
0.27410852909088135,
-0.6123547554016113,
0.17194516956806183,
0.07278633862733841,
-0.21369022130966187,
-0.5270258188247681,
-0.18588733673095703,
-0.43977704644203186,
-0.4269297420978546,
-0.7809269428253174,
0.7028243541717529,
-0.18578585982322693,
0.18498995900154114,
0.24809637665748596,
0.10681231319904327,
-0.2663097679615021,
0.42064595222473145,
-0.24954737722873688,
0.5776745080947876,
-0.9062688946723938,
0.4450400173664093,
0.6250928044319153,
-0.4225690960884094,
-1.2012523412704468,
0.18577638268470764,
0.1307319849729538,
-0.1326863020658493,
0.9468134045600891,
0.5644286870956421,
-0.1304119974374771,
-0.3883996307849884,
-0.2226593941450119,
-0.3701474666595459,
1.183539628982544,
0.27876028418540955,
-0.4049292206764221,
-0.25238871574401855,
0.6067402362823486,
0.9249110817909241,
-0.16346363723278046,
0.46678388118743896,
0.5802379250526428,
0.22053954005241394,
-0.1036829873919487,
-1.3656400442123413,
0.29738298058509827,
-0.040308382362127304,
0.1149955615401268,
0.6615791916847229,
-0.7105876803398132,
1.1444640159606934,
-0.21627962589263916,
-0.3166316747665405,
-0.20549455285072327,
0.4802766442298889,
0.04520231485366821,
0.034904997795820236,
0.6869916319847107,
0.23967978358268738,
0.4634755849838257,
-0.013365495949983597,
0.9957482218742371,
0.3032779097557068,
0.6235830187797546,
1.0489004850387573,
0.14351670444011688,
0.8526966571807861,
0.684968113899231,
-0.5191939473152161,
0.6356734037399292,
0.5838300585746765,
0.24282892048358917,
0.29554033279418945,
0.5361671447753906,
-0.5198259949684143,
0.05173861235380173,
0.031212197616696358,
-0.29833659529685974,
0.14226150512695312,
0.23229165375232697,
-0.42495784163475037,
-0.2957009971141815,
0.011019637808203697,
0.4950292408466339,
0.08523879945278168,
-0.08563299477100372,
0.8310269117355347,
0.2324434071779251,
-0.641992449760437,
0.3555019199848175,
-0.13464827835559845,
0.5468022227287292,
-0.2804044783115387,
-0.04104486107826233,
-0.19264444708824158,
0.2576066255569458,
-0.2688600420951843,
-0.7074757218360901,
0.44692015647888184,
-0.19403332471847534,
-0.4072694480419159,
-0.09877049922943115,
0.9040897488594055,
-0.21645314991474152,
-0.29283061623573303,
0.3783266246318817,
0.5549103021621704,
0.30332690477371216,
-0.3805539309978485,
-0.5059360265731812,
-0.3202650547027588,
0.18865348398685455,
-0.48561859130859375,
0.17862673103809357,
0.8601272106170654,
-0.1499176174402237,
0.8547917604446411,
0.12502439320087433,
-0.0941457524895668,
0.2860567569732666,
0.04029211774468422,
0.7301442623138428,
-0.8782182931900024,
-0.6470752954483032,
-1.205828070640564,
0.0004896835307590663,
-0.004527106415480375,
-0.4549715220928192,
0.9103626608848572,
0.5970054864883423,
0.5656915903091431,
-0.13801781833171844,
0.8290843367576599,
-0.48248860239982605,
0.7308607697486877,
-0.3494345247745514,
0.49761173129081726,
-0.45600423216819763,
0.35449084639549255,
-0.5250005722045898,
-0.8903039693832397,
-0.7072423696517944,
0.4330504238605499,
-0.4708215892314911,
0.04250999912619591,
1.216586947441101,
1.031704068183899,
-0.13723978400230408,
-0.04600399732589722,
0.19783760607242584,
-0.07979241013526917,
0.19038476049900055,
0.7235710620880127,
0.7877405881881714,
-0.4460113048553467,
1.0823603868484497,
-0.5129749178886414,
-0.0957423597574234,
-0.14618909358978271,
-0.841057300567627,
-1.1232045888900757,
-0.5353963375091553,
-0.3886004388332367,
-0.2377483993768692,
-0.019841857254505157,
1.0730741024017334,
0.45266759395599365,
-0.47236382961273193,
-0.21958185732364655,
-0.461543470621109,
0.0631750300526619,
-0.2924111783504486,
-0.3212197422981262,
0.5668932795524597,
-0.22481174767017365,
-0.7769694328308105,
-0.18839745223522186,
0.08625692874193192,
0.3900090157985687,
-0.007057350128889084,
-0.0593828409910202,
-0.30989569425582886,
-0.09930708259344101,
0.5547932386398315,
-0.1741020530462265,
-0.7196042537689209,
-0.6402418613433838,
-0.26452863216400146,
-0.48687928915023804,
0.4921494722366333,
0.8217565417289734,
-0.4751077890396118,
0.2624392509460449,
0.8930250406265259,
0.003801122074946761,
0.17827145755290985,
0.22226345539093018,
0.6055013537406921,
-0.8752326369285583,
0.3715679347515106,
-0.22227929532527924,
0.06400201469659805,
0.42100977897644043,
-0.6402791142463684,
0.7098138928413391,
0.49503907561302185,
-0.8433477282524109,
-0.24492023885250092,
0.34126195311546326,
-1.2475733757019043,
-0.20185936987400055,
1.3558626174926758,
-0.4193245470523834,
-0.01595034822821617,
-0.6325199007987976,
-0.7964691519737244,
0.08589600771665573,
-0.41956958174705505,
0.6568799018859863,
1.1337207555770874,
-0.5191128849983215,
-0.4267098307609558,
-0.8320003747940063,
0.9463531374931335,
0.4270381033420563,
-1.102505087852478,
-0.11291999369859695,
0.5095174908638,
0.3151422441005707,
0.38815417885780334,
0.5553722977638245,
0.17577503621578217,
0.2406354695558548,
0.39563700556755066,
0.1805211901664734,
0.45812907814979553,
0.11570987105369568,
-0.028706591576337814,
0.21829423308372498,
-0.051112957298755646,
-0.024040816351771355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12174v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12174v1
|
CT-Eval: Benchmarking Chinese Text-to-Table Performance in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-20T16:58:02 | 2024-05-20T16:58:02 |
Haoxiang Shi, Jiaan Wang, Jiarong Xu, Cen Wang, Tetsuya Sakai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text-to-Table aims to generate structured tables to convey the key
information from unstructured documents. Existing text-to-table datasets are
typically oriented English, limiting the research in non-English languages.
Meanwhile, the emergence of large language models (LLMs) has shown great
success as general task solvers in multi-lingual settings (e.g., ChatGPT),
theoretically enabling text-to-table in other languages. In this paper, we
propose a Chinese text-to-table dataset, CT-Eval, to benchmark LLMs on this
task. Our preliminary analysis of English text-to-table datasets highlights two
key factors for dataset construction: data diversity and data hallucination.
Inspired by this, the CT-Eval dataset selects a popular Chinese
multidisciplinary online encyclopedia as the source and covers 28 domains to
ensure data diversity. To minimize data hallucination, we first train an LLM to
judge and filter out the task samples with hallucination, then employ human
annotators to clean the hallucinations in the validation and testing sets.
After this process, CT-Eval contains 88.6K task samples. Using CT-Eval, we
evaluate the performance of open-source and closed-source LLMs. Our results
reveal that zero-shot LLMs (including GPT-4) still have a significant
performance gap compared with human judgment. Furthermore, after fine-tuning,
open-source LLMs can significantly improve their text-to-table ability,
outperforming GPT-4 by a large margin. In short, CT-Eval not only helps
researchers evaluate and quickly understand the Chinese text-to-table ability
of existing LLMs but also serves as a valuable resource to significantly
improve the text-to-table performance of LLMs.
|
[
-0.1597239226102829,
-0.9596143364906311,
0.5746669173240662,
0.22774329781532288,
-0.37183263897895813,
-0.0034660024102777243,
-0.6522926092147827,
-0.5277304649353027,
-0.15281018614768982,
0.4891292154788971,
-0.14016273617744446,
-0.8807297348976135,
-0.3947561979293823,
0.34868133068084717,
-0.6212167143821716,
1.0595647096633911,
-0.057999227195978165,
0.08102967590093613,
-0.036263417452573776,
-0.06530077755451202,
-0.4732918441295624,
-0.4893377423286438,
-0.5328308939933777,
-0.21549169719219208,
0.470519483089447,
0.22032047808170319,
0.5476550459861755,
0.8093752264976501,
0.3497324287891388,
0.16262783110141754,
0.09691084921360016,
0.25420698523521423,
-0.5602731108665466,
-0.030962299555540085,
-0.08730163425207138,
-0.4501638114452362,
-0.39594295620918274,
-0.3154714107513428,
0.6520647406578064,
0.4487673342227936,
0.012488403357565403,
-0.12014958262443542,
0.34193989634513855,
0.5938876271247864,
-0.5183440446853638,
0.14574243128299713,
-0.7729931473731995,
0.21735571324825287,
-0.44723689556121826,
-0.1799977421760559,
-0.6726856827735901,
-0.4249153435230255,
0.006772284861654043,
-0.4292420744895935,
0.14316001534461975,
0.03404252976179123,
0.6420047283172607,
0.0961291491985321,
-0.47885340452194214,
-0.15347036719322205,
-0.7564461827278137,
0.6170868873596191,
-0.6404646635055542,
0.6351578831672668,
0.11147619783878326,
0.21527455747127533,
-0.10141528397798538,
-0.7439954876899719,
-0.5173032879829407,
-0.5709627866744995,
-0.13493281602859497,
0.1828337460756302,
0.11980202049016953,
-0.025492729619145393,
0.2763528823852539,
0.36928313970565796,
-1.0443192720413208,
0.2192099392414093,
-0.14963901042938232,
-0.04534601792693138,
0.6801522374153137,
0.18195542693138123,
0.30733466148376465,
0.0454878956079483,
-0.32187703251838684,
-0.22698462009429932,
-0.7158585786819458,
-0.228101909160614,
0.0033175991848111153,
0.5742011070251465,
-0.055390406399965286,
0.4768468737602234,
-0.17591935396194458,
0.5700359344482422,
-0.3147841691970825,
0.13650250434875488,
0.28622621297836304,
-0.39115169644355774,
-0.1840495616197586,
0.18170107901096344,
0.8224096894264221,
0.12069133669137955,
0.2103756219148636,
-0.36355575919151306,
-0.5106313228607178,
-0.06529483199119568,
0.17586348950862885,
-0.7093626856803894,
-0.19514109194278717,
0.10515180975198746,
-0.4067736268043518,
-0.06041176617145538,
0.09569744765758514,
-0.88922119140625,
-0.4036276042461395,
-0.2541027069091797,
0.5416959524154663,
-0.43385791778564453,
-0.1611749678850174,
-0.2383170872926712,
0.03638935834169388,
0.24907328188419342,
0.47759589552879333,
-0.5375915169715881,
0.4159718155860901,
0.7715885043144226,
1.0801634788513184,
-0.7749968767166138,
-0.40083786845207214,
-0.5214846730232239,
-0.08008170872926712,
-0.506276547908783,
0.8906117677688599,
-0.32286641001701355,
-0.3416465222835541,
0.22230218350887299,
-0.15004023909568787,
-0.09797380864620209,
-0.5771762728691101,
0.5023839473724365,
-0.10768778622150421,
0.15998320281505585,
-0.38010478019714355,
-0.4727838635444641,
-0.03210950270295143,
0.506058394908905,
-0.7775676846504211,
1.1729087829589844,
0.036896295845508575,
-0.5076459646224976,
0.32920101284980774,
-0.7108057141304016,
-0.5325625538825989,
0.24825383722782135,
-0.4731786549091339,
-0.44354817271232605,
0.13930188119411469,
0.17440636456012726,
0.4297305941581726,
-0.652056872844696,
0.3366440236568451,
-0.0847904309630394,
-0.6309118866920471,
0.079251229763031,
-0.6430641412734985,
0.5465071201324463,
0.25185635685920715,
-0.38664594292640686,
0.20216195285320282,
-0.7187355756759644,
0.052323825657367706,
0.16265638172626495,
-0.2637678384780884,
-0.32784503698349,
0.12488822638988495,
0.49428749084472656,
0.25520631670951843,
0.10656436532735825,
-0.2751370966434479,
0.07585218548774719,
-0.3386525511741638,
0.25878676772117615,
0.4632723927497864,
-0.3001021444797516,
-0.1570618599653244,
-0.3590976595878601,
0.268002450466156,
0.10597223043441772,
-0.18974041938781738,
-0.24995167553424835,
-0.24938984215259552,
-0.6686493754386902,
-0.10451566427946091,
0.2954978048801422,
0.5031489133834839,
-0.985924243927002,
0.45699694752693176,
-0.3664593994617462,
-0.581174910068512,
-0.33338385820388794,
-0.13156963884830475,
0.43309399485588074,
0.3289802372455597,
0.4324898421764374,
-0.18486864864826202,
-0.19609439373016357,
-0.8876187801361084,
-0.20540577173233032,
-0.01895248517394066,
-0.31025174260139465,
0.30714818835258484,
0.6155198216438293,
0.13793666660785675,
0.6646737456321716,
-0.40281814336776733,
-0.4822356700897217,
-0.4747113287448883,
0.1292201578617096,
0.023980537429451942,
0.20130471885204315,
0.3556911051273346,
-0.6185997128486633,
-0.6352862119674683,
0.3253991901874542,
-0.6667770743370056,
-0.2073047161102295,
-0.2836354076862335,
0.026903724297881126,
0.6079587936401367,
0.23953543603420258,
-0.2872006297111511,
0.3033921718597412,
0.5160280466079712,
-0.31979018449783325,
0.6228270530700684,
-0.20723707973957062,
0.2853367030620575,
-1.147499918937683,
0.29909569025039673,
0.17377032339572906,
0.014919193461537361,
-0.7738994359970093,
-0.00005808546848129481,
0.3679264187812805,
0.014975839294493198,
-0.5924217104911804,
0.5291792750358582,
-0.4084239602088928,
-0.18812313675880432,
-0.14126349985599518,
0.4757629632949829,
-0.2398657500743866,
0.6427038908004761,
0.28359994292259216,
0.8904297351837158,
0.3381640613079071,
-0.46875426173210144,
0.1290319859981537,
0.17908403277397156,
-0.35419926047325134,
0.45365193486213684,
-0.4726204574108124,
0.14379717409610748,
0.25867849588394165,
0.20677217841148376,
-0.9367794394493103,
0.058795128017663956,
0.04211247339844704,
-0.17513971030712128,
0.12992142140865326,
0.35707423090934753,
-0.6508437395095825,
-0.16526752710342407,
-0.6144970059394836,
0.47702276706695557,
0.22802616655826569,
-0.7255033254623413,
0.47670215368270874,
0.08577857911586761,
0.20813405513763428,
-0.5514472723007202,
-0.6424716711044312,
0.3755396008491516,
-0.11599228531122208,
-0.5039969086647034,
0.5702401399612427,
-0.043372444808483124,
-0.16209566593170166,
-0.14086434245109558,
-0.04283812642097473,
-0.228973388671875,
-0.041244782507419586,
0.012008731253445148,
0.33478784561157227,
-0.26862427592277527,
0.24962221086025238,
-0.09269239008426666,
0.04400689899921417,
0.03798886761069298,
-0.21297353506088257,
0.7229824662208557,
0.0009608909022063017,
-0.30624985694885254,
-0.26302263140678406,
0.09385541826486588,
0.23133619129657745,
-0.19715312123298645,
0.5048825740814209,
0.36146458983421326,
-0.5036738514900208,
-0.5269514322280884,
-0.6014809608459473,
-0.1440349817276001,
-0.4169522225856781,
0.7399808168411255,
-0.3165276050567627,
-0.6739732623100281,
0.4614582657814026,
0.19956530630588531,
0.3371722102165222,
0.5389978289604187,
0.8098253607749939,
0.4668717384338379,
0.6683601140975952,
0.4776051342487335,
-0.30281832814216614,
0.24685165286064148,
0.07570258527994156,
0.09122537076473236,
-0.5390427708625793,
-0.16178715229034424,
-0.798646092414856,
-0.1776822954416275,
-0.6769295930862427,
-0.3744336664676666,
0.32207921147346497,
-0.5216701626777649,
-0.14990341663360596,
0.3819737136363983,
-0.6148518919944763,
0.49166053533554077,
0.29951950907707214,
0.05585356056690216,
0.6315698027610779,
-0.1449226438999176,
0.0037345385644584894,
0.05031639710068703,
-0.4251527488231659,
-0.389373242855072,
1.0810126066207886,
0.1613663285970688,
0.5505433082580566,
-0.308960884809494,
0.6019256114959717,
0.30121156573295593,
0.29742226004600525,
-0.570866584777832,
0.6970531344413757,
-0.43719884753227234,
-0.2494276612997055,
-0.39340248703956604,
-0.4719807505607605,
-0.9001551270484924,
0.4218992292881012,
-0.08708687126636505,
-0.7465828657150269,
-0.3252212405204773,
-0.022652801126241684,
-0.017492227256298065,
0.3763256072998047,
-0.41916584968566895,
0.9523431062698364,
-0.5057027339935303,
-0.5438937544822693,
-0.11314044892787933,
-0.2630046308040619,
0.490075945854187,
-0.43709567189216614,
-0.05422118678689003,
0.117363840341568,
-0.01509539783000946,
0.7650734782218933,
-0.18260645866394043,
0.4828127324581146,
0.1429692506790161,
-0.3411186635494232,
0.1304173469543457,
0.061336107552051544,
0.5368944406509399,
-0.014720050618052483,
-0.29592806100845337,
0.6473594903945923,
-0.04389588162302971,
0.05767204612493515,
-0.3985091745853424,
0.8084132075309753,
-0.7388773560523987,
-0.45716387033462524,
-0.4275684356689453,
-0.5301418900489807,
-0.10334670543670654,
0.16592152416706085,
0.3654933273792267,
0.1992485076189041,
-0.35341912508010864,
0.46070873737335205,
0.4637044370174408,
-0.44258877635002136,
0.5646684765815735,
0.5028643012046814,
-0.15256863832473755,
-0.21895496547222137,
0.8864690661430359,
0.3798089027404785,
0.12563356757164001,
0.7056377530097961,
-0.00009374476212542504,
-0.3426044285297394,
-0.7108462452888489,
-0.4620497226715088,
-0.06318852305412292,
-0.3566797971725464,
-0.11638756096363068,
-0.6163021326065063,
-0.5627896189689636,
-0.13029949367046356,
-0.10826746374368668,
-0.4639211595058441,
-0.19915002584457397,
-0.04763171449303627,
0.09623167663812637,
0.12930718064308167,
0.49874117970466614,
0.2672962248325348,
-0.01624239794909954,
-0.6281924843788147,
0.2740294635295868,
-0.18298688530921936,
0.5436002612113953,
0.19060343503952026,
-0.45435550808906555,
-0.37666115164756775,
-0.10537431389093399,
-0.45304787158966064,
-0.8520630598068237,
0.5242009162902832,
0.021399084478616714,
0.43675342202186584,
0.3304827809333801,
0.13222406804561615,
0.6046148538589478,
-0.4482964277267456,
0.9833088517189026,
-0.11000023037195206,
-1.0171979665756226,
0.41653308272361755,
-0.28640827536582947,
0.2431686967611313,
0.4833088517189026,
0.0804223120212555,
-0.7938684225082397,
-0.49863147735595703,
-0.12490978837013245,
-0.9362442493438721,
0.7896368503570557,
0.44048839807510376,
-0.1395481377840042,
0.13274574279785156,
0.12325137853622437,
0.3978172540664673,
0.2263769507408142,
-1.1016556024551392,
-0.13094587624073029,
-0.11718335002660751,
-0.15248741209506989,
-0.16293087601661682,
0.02529505267739296,
0.2762856185436249,
-0.0036450617481023073,
0.5450778603553772,
-0.09939058870077133,
0.18441008031368256,
0.03285077214241028,
-0.0981772243976593,
-0.04785286262631416,
0.38821691274642944,
0.5644176006317139,
0.596397340297699,
-0.05752379447221756,
0.15448960661888123,
0.524894654750824,
-0.5405629277229309,
-0.18796345591545105,
0.11703914403915405,
-0.12310146540403366,
0.014059619978070259,
0.42880332469940186,
0.6139886379241943,
-0.11903193593025208,
-0.9297333359718323,
0.33534494042396545,
-0.09990781545639038,
-0.3893725574016571,
-0.28150317072868347,
0.13665369153022766,
-0.15886381268501282,
0.0032439776696264744,
0.3731161057949066,
-0.5927636623382568,
0.19833646714687347,
-0.433898001909256,
0.2997007668018341,
0.4785343110561371,
-0.19809575378894806,
-0.29108813405036926,
0.7631554007530212,
0.14935003221035004,
-0.46893197298049927,
0.7569480538368225,
0.017841311171650887,
-0.3439587950706482,
0.6973658204078674,
0.5545592308044434,
1.1547892093658447,
-0.1948004961013794,
0.0625491663813591,
0.3624614179134369,
0.34230807423591614,
-0.34410062432289124,
0.21793484687805176,
-0.007888835854828358,
-0.4645572602748871,
-0.22809475660324097,
-0.3336888551712036,
-0.47234347462654114,
0.6258520483970642,
-0.3634282946586609,
0.5817468166351318,
-0.08090807497501373,
0.3277876079082489,
-0.1458480954170227,
0.25679948925971985,
-0.6648135185241699,
0.13426221907138824,
0.08929727226495743,
0.8230174779891968,
-0.7484898567199707,
1.0532375574111938,
0.2874840199947357,
-0.17931942641735077,
-0.7029674649238586,
0.273532897233963,
-0.001948238001205027,
-0.708351194858551,
0.3348976671695709,
0.408130407333374,
0.31145888566970825,
-0.23050916194915771,
-0.2284044474363327,
-0.5663238763809204,
1.1383790969848633,
0.16462337970733643,
-0.8712854385375977,
0.02957244962453842,
0.7428008913993835,
0.8430405259132385,
-0.21889299154281616,
0.553435206413269,
0.7322263717651367,
0.6281151175498962,
-0.05658300593495369,
-0.9277625679969788,
0.25730112195014954,
-0.296499103307724,
0.13093280792236328,
0.3032987713813782,
-0.6344781517982483,
0.9697756171226501,
0.12472929805517197,
-0.17656207084655762,
-0.07849255949258804,
0.4480462670326233,
0.3187335431575775,
0.5765108466148376,
0.4373947083950043,
0.28755834698677063,
0.5049862861633301,
-0.2710156738758087,
0.7011560797691345,
-0.5955387949943542,
0.20245125889778137,
0.9734150171279907,
-0.7040694355964661,
0.9137157201766968,
0.22744591534137726,
-0.011388418264687061,
-0.01868114434182644,
0.5553428530693054,
-0.5340822339057922,
0.31083494424819946,
0.27521204948425293,
-0.048604872077703476,
0.06650592386722565,
-0.1044766902923584,
-0.44178953766822815,
0.42435675859451294,
0.18367761373519897,
-0.34476789832115173,
-0.5364364981651306,
-0.10081618279218674,
-0.16360023617744446,
0.09493853151798248,
-0.03250812739133835,
0.7585785984992981,
-0.08580588549375534,
-0.770416259765625,
0.5109031796455383,
0.07862479984760284,
0.6620632410049438,
-0.5803506374359131,
-0.16193529963493347,
-0.37105947732925415,
0.13140125572681427,
-0.14237236976623535,
-0.8297185301780701,
0.19686080515384674,
0.12549492716789246,
0.2333446890115738,
-0.04016590118408203,
0.5812443494796753,
-0.5812009572982788,
-0.356479674577713,
0.3839989900588989,
0.6975511908531189,
0.21595069766044617,
-0.2774945795536041,
-0.4070493280887604,
0.11478770524263382,
0.07965279370546341,
-0.48146429657936096,
0.5486699938774109,
0.5780731439590454,
-0.28104686737060547,
0.4306110441684723,
0.45900002121925354,
0.1623857468366623,
-0.4214828908443451,
-0.03547166287899017,
0.7484378218650818,
-0.8511269688606262,
-0.5352768301963806,
-1.194899320602417,
0.3042187988758087,
0.04099961742758751,
-0.4115525484085083,
0.6309120059013367,
1.033730149269104,
0.9534423351287842,
-0.005525653250515461,
0.869644820690155,
0.07652773708105087,
0.22358350455760956,
-0.4766133725643158,
1.0248180627822876,
-0.7076690196990967,
0.3497486710548401,
-0.34473493695259094,
-1.144392728805542,
-0.3721952438354492,
0.3010404109954834,
-0.09433599561452866,
0.2278793305158615,
0.887371301651001,
0.8854173421859741,
0.22083456814289093,
0.15877971053123474,
0.5957353711128235,
0.2885792851448059,
0.5621923208236694,
0.9429643154144287,
0.6443060636520386,
-0.2604767978191376,
0.7444334030151367,
-0.18925318121910095,
-0.06304968893527985,
-0.1725412756204605,
-0.8962467908859253,
-0.9908176064491272,
-0.7602153420448303,
-0.11676912754774094,
-0.18434807658195496,
0.2804395258426666,
1.0737360715866089,
0.31409555673599243,
-0.7550695538520813,
-0.5042733550071716,
-0.07639896124601364,
0.08013860881328583,
-0.4274987280368805,
-0.23544220626354218,
0.7470577359199524,
-0.34305816888809204,
-0.7634731531143188,
0.13320200145244598,
0.32855650782585144,
-0.18260163068771362,
-0.19463218748569489,
0.05338370427489281,
0.15878891944885254,
0.054771315306425095,
0.7344112992286682,
0.051502957940101624,
-0.6408082842826843,
-0.15233612060546875,
-0.023954963311553,
-0.23081211745738983,
0.3712784945964813,
0.7339366674423218,
-0.7312688231468201,
0.19184453785419464,
0.3443445563316345,
0.7339598536491394,
0.3560222387313843,
-0.12104824185371399,
0.3928544223308563,
-0.6349551677703857,
-0.18853998184204102,
0.2782652676105499,
0.19959363341331482,
0.07256103307008743,
-0.33066272735595703,
0.7112647891044617,
-0.007856565527617931,
-0.5873257517814636,
-0.9475821256637573,
-0.35244613885879517,
-1.0182827711105347,
-0.39478039741516113,
1.2260940074920654,
0.07123393565416336,
-0.0752677172422409,
-0.04957086965441704,
-0.33274298906326294,
0.3492242097854614,
-0.5135883688926697,
1.4393888711929321,
0.7216309309005737,
-0.05485925450921059,
-0.12610112130641937,
-0.6339382529258728,
0.509788453578949,
0.3323437571525574,
-1.3402994871139526,
0.5078461766242981,
0.3765770494937897,
-0.10429207980632782,
-0.1067495122551918,
0.4672856032848358,
-0.003183205844834447,
0.26427924633026123,
-0.09043567627668381,
0.07217022031545639,
-0.17502820491790771,
-0.30167198181152344,
-0.2028161585330963,
0.3770706355571747,
-0.14385250210762024,
-0.01679910160601139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12163v1
|
Fennec: Fine-grained Language Model Evaluation and Correction Extended through Branching and Bridging
| 2024-05-20T16:47:22 | 2024-05-20T16:47:22 |
Xiaobo Liang, Haoke Zhang, Helan hu, Juntao Li, Jun Xu, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of large language models has given rise to a plethora
of applications across a myriad of real-world tasks, mainly centered on
aligning with human intent. However, the complexities inherent in human intent
necessitate a dependence on labor-intensive and time-consuming human
evaluation. To alleviate this constraint, we delve into the paradigm of
employing open-source large language models as evaluators, aligning with the
prevailing trend of utilizing GPT-4. Particularly, we present a step-by-step
evaluation framework: \textbf{Fennec}, capable of \textbf{F}ine-grained
\textbf{E}valuatio\textbf{N} and correctio\textbf{N} \textbf{E}xtended through
bran\textbf{C}hing and bridging. Specifically, the branching operation dissects
the evaluation task into various dimensions and granularities, thereby
alleviating the challenges associated with evaluation. Concurrently, the
bridging operation amalgamates diverse training datasets, augmenting the
variety of evaluation tasks. In experimental trials, our 7B model consistently
outperforms open-source larger-scale evaluation models across various widely
adopted benchmarks in terms of both \textit{Agreement} and
\textit{Consistency}, closely approaching the capabilities of GPT-4. We employ
the fine-grained correction capabilities induced by the evaluation model to
refine multiple model responses, and the results show that the refinement
elevates the quality of responses, leading to an improvement of 1-2 points on
the MT-Bench. Our code is available at
Github\footnote{\url{https://github.com/dropreg/Fennec}}.
|
[
-0.2805744707584381,
-0.6890843510627747,
0.48638734221458435,
0.24251870810985565,
0.16233955323696136,
-0.1447281539440155,
-0.520578920841217,
-0.5486665964126587,
-0.3319149613380432,
0.38139548897743225,
-0.33818209171295166,
-0.4299177825450897,
-0.39115291833877563,
0.10377797484397888,
-0.41439947485923767,
1.1770786046981812,
-0.09642689675092697,
0.23101869225502014,
-0.08467558771371841,
-0.018839910626411438,
-0.14886976778507233,
-0.2755720317363739,
-0.734425961971283,
-0.521682858467102,
0.706517219543457,
0.3250906765460968,
0.5241038799285889,
0.46597862243652344,
0.708985447883606,
0.36408886313438416,
-0.26554009318351746,
-0.05755026265978813,
-0.7427312135696411,
-0.13335850834846497,
-0.579017162322998,
-0.24027816951274872,
-0.6293755173683167,
-0.19673411548137665,
0.8145814538002014,
0.47072967886924744,
-0.240120530128479,
-0.12873096764087677,
0.15812119841575623,
0.5874043703079224,
-0.58536297082901,
-0.016778966411948204,
-0.7541324496269226,
-0.2267424464225769,
-0.25770103931427,
0.10195571929216385,
-0.36268559098243713,
-0.29248854517936707,
0.22604715824127197,
-0.25300872325897217,
0.23053298890590668,
-0.1957806497812271,
1.06413733959198,
-0.10531550645828247,
-0.225697860121727,
-0.26731353998184204,
-1.0049399137496948,
0.7261248826980591,
-0.9601833820343018,
0.43171268701553345,
0.2581970989704132,
0.5463100075721741,
-0.0764249935746193,
-0.7685518860816956,
-0.31280022859573364,
-0.311604768037796,
-0.019714629277586937,
0.11294899880886078,
-0.06856116652488708,
0.45069390535354614,
0.2724005877971649,
0.9058762788772583,
-0.5237174034118652,
0.050006747245788574,
-0.5541970729827881,
-0.2528202533721924,
0.5180779099464417,
0.17616097629070282,
0.1650628000497818,
-0.15642563998699188,
-0.33819860219955444,
-0.1894567757844925,
-0.33290812373161316,
-0.14880411326885223,
0.5794054865837097,
0.505683422088623,
-0.05739310383796692,
0.5327107906341553,
-0.4290040135383606,
0.7144401669502258,
-0.005095845554023981,
0.2141876369714737,
0.2829427123069763,
-0.49988552927970886,
-0.34629231691360474,
-0.3150275945663452,
0.7635074853897095,
0.4322023391723633,
0.2399623543024063,
-0.20374204218387604,
-0.6362798810005188,
0.04413911700248718,
0.3633974492549896,
-0.9666382670402527,
-0.2143474966287613,
0.19367992877960205,
-0.339022159576416,
-0.27617621421813965,
0.07835818827152252,
-0.8991936445236206,
-0.19724561274051666,
-0.28578490018844604,
0.629033088684082,
-0.28108736872673035,
-0.133930042386055,
0.3990195095539093,
0.06852951645851135,
0.039385415613651276,
0.4307501018047333,
-1.0796360969543457,
0.6229569315910339,
0.7800798416137695,
1.0585182905197144,
0.08183944225311279,
-0.32643693685531616,
-0.7820343375205994,
-0.19651545584201813,
-0.11470182985067368,
0.7588828206062317,
-0.6680739521980286,
-0.1954333484172821,
-0.1642688512802124,
-0.057062458246946335,
-0.17381219565868378,
-0.4489791691303253,
0.7957268953323364,
-0.2067861258983612,
0.226793572306633,
-0.10869728028774261,
-0.38746342062950134,
-0.09459596872329712,
0.5746474266052246,
-0.7124248743057251,
0.9114798307418823,
0.4333086907863617,
-0.7404311895370483,
-0.12708130478858948,
-0.7231992483139038,
0.026047097519040108,
-0.135700061917305,
-0.15740257501602173,
-0.352809876203537,
0.1717253476381302,
0.22675012052059174,
0.22399918735027313,
-0.4457208812236786,
0.1714838296175003,
-0.3539930582046509,
-0.3233675956726074,
-0.10340643674135208,
-0.4989881217479706,
0.4995603859424591,
0.164703369140625,
-0.4229496717453003,
0.5708471536636353,
-0.5106603503227234,
0.06563630700111389,
-0.2003444880247116,
-0.39323246479034424,
-0.29358360171318054,
-0.2170645296573639,
0.15637484192848206,
0.3727260231971741,
0.07322878390550613,
-0.6510453224182129,
0.19699139893054962,
-0.7100411653518677,
0.48239848017692566,
0.8819426894187927,
-0.1627604365348816,
0.5512852072715759,
-0.22712673246860504,
0.4029417335987091,
-0.31477028131484985,
0.5095676779747009,
-0.08485856652259827,
-0.4467187821865082,
-0.6487977504730225,
-0.08566953986883163,
0.8020853400230408,
0.31603506207466125,
-0.44356897473335266,
0.1227845624089241,
-0.2824013829231262,
-0.5276142954826355,
-0.3260238468647003,
0.09532633423805237,
0.577315092086792,
0.2821439504623413,
0.28684160113334656,
-0.42794981598854065,
-0.459044873714447,
-0.9490435719490051,
-0.2216780185699463,
-0.19073165953159332,
-0.1307888627052307,
0.4442822337150574,
0.3917599320411682,
-0.46094900369644165,
0.7737721800804138,
-0.23332755267620087,
-0.10898073762655258,
-0.16740326583385468,
0.3988848328590393,
0.27365216612815857,
0.5679209232330322,
0.5011800527572632,
-0.5438798666000366,
-0.43575283885002136,
0.6323544979095459,
-0.1765693724155426,
-0.2628858685493469,
-0.05716273933649063,
-0.2932398021221161,
0.029522713273763657,
0.3540806472301483,
-0.4730563163757324,
0.39080125093460083,
1.0113592147827148,
-0.40249139070510864,
0.8569322228431702,
0.022798672318458557,
0.3692450523376465,
-0.9274756908416748,
0.19989468157291412,
-0.10310909152030945,
-0.23396629095077515,
-0.6040487885475159,
0.16013653576374054,
-0.019530288875102997,
0.11931287497282028,
-0.31985047459602356,
0.8959691524505615,
-0.2872629463672638,
-0.15743277966976166,
-0.1122264638543129,
0.17236119508743286,
0.10859660059213638,
0.32134413719177246,
-0.18175704777240753,
0.5575940012931824,
0.2665012776851654,
-0.2775958180427551,
0.4095103442668915,
-0.020531846210360527,
-0.25976505875587463,
0.39369145035743713,
-0.6580749154090881,
0.1019650250673294,
0.23295718431472778,
0.09462814778089523,
-0.5950948596000671,
-0.32468315958976746,
0.3621252477169037,
-0.3515416979789734,
0.05944839492440224,
-0.45798277854919434,
-0.3506667912006378,
-0.2762594521045685,
-0.2534632682800293,
0.47895753383636475,
0.20500792562961578,
-0.5780714750289917,
0.8481290936470032,
-0.11339224874973297,
-0.2034095823764801,
-0.38039258122444153,
-0.5722606182098389,
-0.13496027886867523,
0.08346928656101227,
-0.815240740776062,
0.401695191860199,
-0.19150549173355103,
-0.32198193669319153,
0.0756596103310585,
-0.3655162751674652,
-0.1957930624485016,
-0.16849656403064728,
0.03763899579644203,
0.16834089159965515,
-0.2691764831542969,
0.10077334940433502,
-0.2085076868534088,
-0.08468407392501831,
-0.10339631140232086,
-0.4568854868412018,
0.6404035091400146,
-0.570848286151886,
-0.622805655002594,
-0.09406183660030365,
0.08641178160905838,
0.575167715549469,
-0.3806613087654114,
0.2620907425880432,
0.6896297335624695,
-0.5972403883934021,
-0.08800952881574631,
-0.5608609318733215,
-0.45404791831970215,
-0.47193509340286255,
0.2962620258331299,
-0.38643184304237366,
-1.1196552515029907,
0.640746533870697,
0.05690765008330345,
0.16450388729572296,
0.5220474004745483,
0.6499162912368774,
0.284650057554245,
0.7862839698791504,
0.5766481161117554,
0.15326596796512604,
0.5531043410301208,
-0.21858224272727966,
0.4000314474105835,
-0.8998126983642578,
-0.18273450434207916,
-0.6625693440437317,
-0.3906252682209015,
-0.45347651839256287,
-0.7120949029922485,
0.044379256665706635,
0.4831037223339081,
0.07103993743658066,
0.3793637752532959,
-0.3166319727897644,
0.5846882462501526,
0.16848255693912506,
0.012816954404115677,
0.33390578627586365,
-0.09970041364431381,
-0.425857812166214,
0.15693935751914978,
-0.6865824460983276,
-0.41382747888565063,
1.0059072971343994,
0.7298630475997925,
0.9127461910247803,
0.013225852511823177,
0.6706474423408508,
-0.018926842138171196,
0.42335543036460876,
-0.8203583359718323,
0.23547081649303436,
-0.26832014322280884,
-0.6846508383750916,
-0.4207943379878998,
-0.7644034028053284,
-0.5854314565658569,
0.3365257680416107,
-0.11454693228006363,
-1.1307622194290161,
0.34861645102500916,
0.25691595673561096,
-0.554334819316864,
0.5391085147857666,
-0.8407096862792969,
1.3353227376937866,
-0.3910081386566162,
-0.6423571705818176,
-0.31656721234321594,
-0.1956706941127777,
0.6229129433631897,
-0.05687354877591133,
-0.04639419913291931,
-0.18010644614696503,
0.4599825143814087,
0.4229884445667267,
-0.47121918201446533,
0.6266153454780579,
-0.014420181512832642,
-0.19221743941307068,
0.07004959881305695,
0.017381584271788597,
0.7045512795448303,
0.21664190292358398,
-0.19554854929447174,
0.13598303496837616,
0.017697542905807495,
-0.36718735098838806,
-0.8985544443130493,
0.9676140546798706,
-0.33788639307022095,
-0.207272008061409,
-0.4622330069541931,
-0.5817275643348694,
-0.20969265699386597,
0.17070838809013367,
0.039537228643894196,
0.6613548994064331,
-0.3102499544620514,
0.29653650522232056,
0.4934583604335785,
0.0024136558640748262,
0.3051285147666931,
0.2674662470817566,
-0.754506528377533,
-0.47778937220573425,
0.8799073100090027,
-0.3025309443473816,
0.5172150135040283,
0.2810056805610657,
0.4775577783584595,
-0.37887582182884216,
-0.6842922568321228,
-0.3209823668003082,
0.23587045073509216,
-0.4803895354270935,
-0.1728527992963791,
-0.5633547306060791,
-0.47773057222366333,
-0.22590301930904388,
-0.01692207343876362,
-0.6330692768096924,
-0.2580229341983795,
0.11743786185979843,
0.06787587702274323,
0.318958044052124,
0.9110972881317139,
-0.04433739557862282,
0.4598526358604431,
-0.982365608215332,
0.1051119938492775,
0.4563696086406708,
0.8136966824531555,
-0.04103308916091919,
-0.47119826078414917,
-0.493832528591156,
0.1727842092514038,
-0.16731353104114532,
-0.4579451084136963,
-0.08697178959846497,
0.11680189520120621,
0.3971406817436218,
0.4884311854839325,
-0.2796095311641693,
0.8143563270568848,
-0.4901632070541382,
0.563256561756134,
0.21141576766967773,
-1.1366242170333862,
0.1963171809911728,
-0.5851530432701111,
0.3192615211009979,
0.6332209706306458,
0.019211724400520325,
-0.8367608785629272,
-0.15273094177246094,
-0.6143352389335632,
-0.9066327214241028,
0.6506693363189697,
0.47219330072402954,
-0.08954067528247833,
0.12902556359767914,
0.1682453155517578,
-0.11143384873867035,
0.0017779443878680468,
-0.5697916746139526,
0.49248114228248596,
-0.04836202785372734,
-0.06905246526002884,
-0.027722112834453583,
-0.300249844789505,
-0.2403090000152588,
-0.22924453020095825,
0.6300389170646667,
-0.21198536455631256,
0.16427437961101532,
0.10900110006332397,
0.08300986886024475,
-0.019716467708349228,
0.5032666921615601,
0.7615810632705688,
0.7372701168060303,
-0.4159702956676483,
-0.07323634624481201,
0.151236891746521,
-0.35630133748054504,
-0.2079133838415146,
0.19444499909877777,
-0.046588748693466187,
0.08230754733085632,
0.40992486476898193,
0.9617311358451843,
0.547652542591095,
-0.5819972157478333,
0.5834118723869324,
-0.24544423818588257,
-0.30173924565315247,
0.08177907019853592,
-0.0428597517311573,
0.08064227551221848,
0.3754018247127533,
-0.10452839732170105,
0.3128041923046112,
0.2400970607995987,
-0.40709587931632996,
0.42730090022087097,
0.29027852416038513,
-0.5065694451332092,
-0.41147541999816895,
0.2661997377872467,
0.49046948552131653,
-0.18080295622348785,
0.6097821593284607,
-0.2533881664276123,
-0.61794114112854,
0.31911641359329224,
0.37643706798553467,
1.1792930364608765,
-0.46328112483024597,
0.2735273838043213,
0.5347837805747986,
0.5065454244613647,
-0.25444579124450684,
0.12611018121242523,
0.15175321698188782,
-0.5495128035545349,
-0.7639283537864685,
-0.9638671875,
-0.4274941086769104,
0.30095359683036804,
-0.5606963634490967,
0.32402345538139343,
-0.5826915502548218,
-0.10927651822566986,
-0.267662912607193,
-0.141218364238739,
-0.5001311302185059,
0.19302092492580414,
0.0977395549416542,
1.1190999746322632,
-0.8509730100631714,
0.821106493473053,
0.522172749042511,
-0.2111784815788269,
-0.8719977736473083,
0.2346958965063095,
0.12691502273082733,
-0.09516160935163498,
0.3667159676551819,
0.19595438241958618,
-0.2840869724750519,
-0.0891566276550293,
-0.07753996551036835,
-0.7175018191337585,
0.798203706741333,
0.3236173093318939,
-1.0093750953674316,
-0.2348346710205078,
-0.1311936229467392,
0.6519296169281006,
-0.5054987072944641,
0.7407714128494263,
0.7593227028846741,
0.7404744029045105,
0.0868384838104248,
-1.2213000059127808,
-0.31106504797935486,
-0.3917619585990906,
0.13040360808372498,
0.27737361192703247,
-0.32605141401290894,
1.0247019529342651,
0.08452292531728745,
-0.2513902485370636,
0.2055826187133789,
0.4228534698486328,
0.07419858872890472,
0.06692391633987427,
0.5425605773925781,
0.7029346823692322,
0.5495942831039429,
-0.4306507706642151,
1.0090579986572266,
-0.08736979961395264,
0.6619353294372559,
1.3836256265640259,
-0.1336333304643631,
0.9328508377075195,
0.524400532245636,
-0.06805442273616791,
0.45145225524902344,
0.5440288186073303,
0.0910262018442154,
0.2286769598722458,
0.3691115081310272,
-0.23455727100372314,
-0.15671177208423615,
-0.05305568501353264,
-0.06613519787788391,
0.45015034079551697,
0.24263544380664825,
-0.20764502882957458,
-0.6898795366287231,
-0.2780109941959381,
-0.34679535031318665,
0.19744153320789337,
-0.40730899572372437,
0.45073193311691284,
-0.009204696863889694,
-0.3710792660713196,
0.623670756816864,
0.18195512890815735,
0.6128023266792297,
-0.8550066351890564,
-0.19491420686244965,
-0.20869842171669006,
0.4066937565803528,
-0.458413302898407,
-0.6729158163070679,
0.49898505210876465,
0.17620256543159485,
-0.304037868976593,
-0.024462305009365082,
0.5384329557418823,
-0.5778420567512512,
-0.3673986792564392,
0.7415342330932617,
0.06950131803750992,
0.0494229793548584,
-0.32162588834762573,
-0.8240088820457458,
0.460720032453537,
0.1179722398519516,
-0.12412728369235992,
0.09999973326921463,
0.24696624279022217,
-0.3277444839477539,
0.48710304498672485,
0.628140926361084,
0.21038956940174103,
0.1290670782327652,
0.5567457675933838,
1.0252900123596191,
-0.4557560682296753,
-0.21870708465576172,
-0.7062075734138489,
0.8030635118484497,
-0.21544910967350006,
-0.44532284140586853,
0.4924846887588501,
0.7407441139221191,
1.1870578527450562,
-0.1020529568195343,
0.7632259130477905,
-0.25474539399147034,
0.2993853986263275,
-0.7729579210281372,
0.5690866708755493,
-0.3715408146381378,
0.26816096901893616,
-0.4019923806190491,
-1.2827285528182983,
-0.19772487878799438,
0.6328886151313782,
-0.6227744817733765,
0.23061521351337433,
1.0002121925354004,
1.045495867729187,
-0.47849440574645996,
-0.08979601413011551,
0.4279961585998535,
0.35639819502830505,
0.3915729522705078,
0.6405618190765381,
0.8371810913085938,
-0.5028592348098755,
0.47830748558044434,
-0.315510630607605,
-0.35193243622779846,
-0.38409048318862915,
-0.8504152297973633,
-1.0203808546066284,
-0.49527737498283386,
-0.08492089062929153,
-0.3161728084087372,
0.3225168287754059,
0.9187566637992859,
0.6194879412651062,
-1.0021889209747314,
-0.4516763687133789,
-0.251575767993927,
-0.004745625890791416,
-0.255425363779068,
-0.24813321232795715,
0.005988425575196743,
-0.43947115540504456,
-0.978178083896637,
0.3991883397102356,
0.4674878716468811,
-0.0795525386929512,
-0.5089008212089539,
-0.4386894106864929,
-0.3366732597351074,
0.08128895610570908,
0.4568732678890228,
0.21473164856433868,
-0.923545777797699,
-0.4910470247268677,
-0.09366537630558014,
-0.22666479647159576,
0.03838198259472847,
0.9856757521629333,
-0.3595108389854431,
0.6941115856170654,
0.800307035446167,
0.8200103640556335,
0.4777604043483734,
0.25091755390167236,
0.8470629453659058,
-0.5554859638214111,
-0.18434986472129822,
0.39462995529174805,
0.25786226987838745,
0.4514220952987671,
-0.13197338581085205,
0.5249927043914795,
0.09172303229570389,
-0.6892951130867004,
-0.795049786567688,
0.3152279555797577,
-0.8317609429359436,
-0.00944330170750618,
1.0753014087677002,
-0.29057323932647705,
-0.3989768326282501,
0.15397047996520996,
-0.3802879750728607,
-0.0474235825240612,
-0.3348156213760376,
0.586272656917572,
0.9742261171340942,
0.08034440875053406,
-0.22937767207622528,
-0.5582330226898193,
0.4787147045135498,
0.3009157180786133,
-0.8922128081321716,
0.3311665952205658,
0.42947787046432495,
0.248691588640213,
0.17273037135601044,
0.4492088258266449,
-0.360283762216568,
0.28604429960250854,
-0.07610383629798889,
0.3535245358943939,
0.10083774477243423,
-0.6427557468414307,
-0.6813546419143677,
-0.26025283336639404,
0.1798836886882782,
0.03682935610413551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12147v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12147v2
|
Eliciting Problem Specifications via Large Language Models
| 2024-05-20T16:19:02 | 2024-06-10T19:05:57 |
Robert E. Wray, James R. Kirk, John E. Laird
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.11; I.2.7
|
Cognitive systems generally require a human to translate a problem definition
into some specification that the cognitive system can use to attempt to solve
the problem or perform the task. In this paper, we illustrate that large
language models (LLMs) can be utilized to map a problem class, defined in
natural language, into a semi-formal specification that can then be utilized by
an existing reasoning and learning system to solve instances from the problem
class. We present the design of LLM-enabled cognitive task analyst agent(s).
Implemented with LLM agents, this system produces a definition of problem
spaces for tasks specified in natural language. LLM prompts are derived from
the definition of problem spaces in the AI literature and general
problem-solving strategies (Polya's How to Solve It). A cognitive system can
then use the problem-space specification, applying domain-general problem
solving strategies ("weak methods" such as search), to solve multiple instances
of problems from the problem class. This result, while preliminary, suggests
the potential for speeding cognitive systems research via disintermediation of
problem formulation while also retaining core capabilities of cognitive
systems, such as robust inference and online learning.
|
[
-0.513817548751831,
-1.1487126350402832,
1.104608416557312,
0.11557766050100327,
0.029421022161841393,
0.27162301540374756,
-0.6885820031166077,
-0.8547540307044983,
0.04116808995604515,
0.6112024784088135,
-0.40017300844192505,
-0.16651464998722076,
-0.4486122131347656,
0.08885500580072403,
-0.39733341336250305,
0.5371546149253845,
-0.17287631332874298,
-0.2259598970413208,
-0.4825856685638428,
0.38710981607437134,
-0.7954506278038025,
-0.5610112547874451,
-0.8041956424713135,
-0.46097737550735474,
0.36922720074653625,
0.5383961200714111,
0.7795478701591492,
0.17085255682468414,
0.4218837320804596,
0.45459848642349243,
-0.0908326581120491,
0.31603187322616577,
-0.1403551697731018,
0.18625253438949585,
-0.23924538493156433,
-0.5894349217414856,
-0.5410791039466858,
0.021726012229919434,
0.492870956659317,
0.8878752589225769,
-0.2163899540901184,
0.16462399065494537,
0.21673431992530823,
0.23288917541503906,
-0.5631733536720276,
0.606939435005188,
-0.543851912021637,
-0.13539254665374756,
-0.055858027189970016,
-0.038441259413957596,
-0.622556746006012,
0.09523632377386093,
0.16751642525196075,
-0.96546471118927,
-0.11360268294811249,
0.0062278276309370995,
0.6205549836158752,
0.30556395649909973,
-0.2462943196296692,
-0.56879723072052,
-1.2211610078811646,
0.9467667937278748,
-0.6496628522872925,
-0.08156732469797134,
0.4902789294719696,
0.45231151580810547,
-0.39463573694229126,
-0.4053795635700226,
-0.5863326191902161,
-0.49971240758895874,
-0.175959050655365,
-0.1000891849398613,
-0.205947145819664,
0.043889664113521576,
0.4194211959838867,
0.05181492120027542,
-0.35192301869392395,
0.1816132515668869,
-0.38668292760849,
-0.2932173013687134,
0.8802633881568909,
0.4964814782142639,
0.30434438586235046,
0.08221723139286041,
0.07444573193788528,
0.22517059743404388,
-0.36178505420684814,
-0.2917121946811676,
-0.13724885880947113,
0.4021395146846771,
0.10539379715919495,
0.6900647282600403,
-0.2444334328174591,
0.8882893919944763,
-0.09516701847314835,
-0.031830910593271255,
0.01324998214840889,
0.00678633339703083,
-0.17841409146785736,
-0.10817538946866989,
0.5163276791572571,
-0.09980392456054688,
0.3132282495498657,
-0.1569885015487671,
-0.5420868992805481,
0.2905786335468292,
0.40838199853897095,
-0.3548417389392853,
0.07976119965314865,
0.3082633316516876,
-0.13020159304141998,
0.044326476752758026,
-0.469666451215744,
-0.633280873298645,
-0.29162371158599854,
-0.7491356730461121,
0.5920516848564148,
-0.3396081030368805,
-0.21002140641212463,
0.15643587708473206,
-0.17577432096004486,
0.370212197303772,
0.32137107849121094,
-0.6373133659362793,
0.41728881001472473,
0.5141850113868713,
0.4769093692302704,
-0.14079831540584564,
-0.0274575874209404,
-0.06590799987316132,
0.293429434299469,
-0.32484304904937744,
0.8637295961380005,
-0.7413586378097534,
-0.47796064615249634,
0.27776578068733215,
-0.19072076678276062,
0.1076403260231018,
-0.7956281304359436,
0.3306907117366791,
-0.6397134065628052,
-0.031803227961063385,
-0.11595936864614487,
-0.6006974577903748,
0.06483403593301773,
0.41051989793777466,
-0.5299010872840881,
1.0729408264160156,
-0.08463317900896072,
-0.18486179411411285,
-0.10942219942808151,
-0.8908089399337769,
-0.6184526681900024,
0.3922729194164276,
-0.22442716360092163,
-0.012314685620367527,
0.08236106485128403,
0.11972150951623917,
0.6321767568588257,
-0.5914011597633362,
0.2386283576488495,
-0.14261223375797272,
-0.34880179166793823,
0.36668577790260315,
-0.11474070698022842,
0.652694821357727,
0.4569534659385681,
-0.31319165229797363,
-0.03997137024998665,
-0.5838866233825684,
0.2755250334739685,
0.6185108423233032,
-0.4489689767360687,
-0.44595104455947876,
0.2718936502933502,
-0.22025543451309204,
0.015723485499620438,
0.7128138542175293,
-0.27738165855407715,
0.19867578148841858,
-0.1541270911693573,
0.5879592895507812,
0.543207049369812,
-0.0979672223329544,
0.3293969929218292,
-0.5008541941642761,
0.4576798975467682,
-0.3330478072166443,
0.23914062976837158,
0.14533254504203796,
-0.5026547312736511,
-0.8512578010559082,
-0.4720901846885681,
-0.20429423451423645,
0.6102973222732544,
-0.8808532953262329,
0.30154603719711304,
-0.012153341434895992,
-0.42975538969039917,
-0.06724028289318085,
0.12949685752391815,
0.29713931679725647,
0.04620799794793129,
0.3731086850166321,
0.08328760415315628,
-0.4003557562828064,
-0.9141881465911865,
-0.006497364491224289,
-0.2274015247821808,
-0.22760836780071259,
0.38621020317077637,
0.44005024433135986,
-0.09429523348808289,
0.9746648669242859,
-0.7206207513809204,
-0.3289143443107605,
-0.5087901949882507,
0.18105949461460114,
-0.004422854166477919,
0.21214602887630463,
0.25553593039512634,
-0.7552242875099182,
-0.2302599549293518,
-0.2776847779750824,
-0.9404576420783997,
-0.2314404994249344,
-0.09536287188529968,
-0.15052713453769684,
0.11758508533239365,
0.7281652688980103,
-0.7589200139045715,
0.3133157193660736,
0.18824556469917297,
-0.11141340434551239,
0.6236302256584167,
-0.4004271328449249,
-0.23192676901817322,
-0.8878413438796997,
0.05505376309156418,
0.10431568324565887,
-0.028835732489824295,
-0.5036227107048035,
0.4496656060218811,
-0.194841206073761,
-0.3799225389957428,
-0.3272113502025604,
0.40914130210876465,
-0.554023265838623,
0.02780330553650856,
-0.4055783450603485,
0.48716363310813904,
-0.11419056355953217,
0.5173260569572449,
0.16775143146514893,
0.44511935114860535,
0.417377233505249,
-0.9978526830673218,
0.46253931522369385,
0.18594922125339508,
-0.18684424459934235,
0.6614173054695129,
-0.627403974533081,
0.31572476029396057,
-0.12168557941913605,
0.27667543292045593,
-0.7848590016365051,
-0.20544560253620148,
0.05368055775761604,
-0.11574125289916992,
0.2044716328382492,
0.1399001181125641,
-0.7488604187965393,
-0.5395695567131042,
0.2311478704214096,
0.6195144057273865,
0.42724454402923584,
-0.14520321786403656,
0.7656012773513794,
0.570327639579773,
-0.161530539393425,
-0.11350898444652557,
-0.7159727215766907,
0.23027671873569489,
-0.010935235768556595,
-0.5497831702232361,
0.4130542278289795,
-0.22476527094841003,
-0.4206857681274414,
0.08144377917051315,
0.2716071605682373,
-0.10948533564805984,
0.3912009000778198,
0.24233020842075348,
0.6321027278900146,
-0.19230256974697113,
0.3770955801010132,
-0.1396704614162445,
-0.09143654257059097,
0.3213290870189667,
-0.39133721590042114,
0.45558223128318787,
-0.06554440408945084,
-0.49642810225486755,
-0.3110252916812897,
0.7291600704193115,
0.6965180039405823,
-0.536108136177063,
0.5669704079627991,
0.011340504512190819,
-0.6080731153488159,
-0.5493483543395996,
-0.5566314458847046,
-0.27215394377708435,
-0.4782085716724396,
0.36124515533447266,
-0.4294781982898712,
-0.8345035314559937,
0.4080815613269806,
-0.3752749264240265,
0.2164018452167511,
0.21275214850902557,
0.7142313718795776,
-0.08552707731723785,
1.0250414609909058,
0.6438183188438416,
0.07351037114858627,
0.5853922367095947,
-0.38968202471733093,
0.3738235533237457,
-0.6916698813438416,
-0.2481101006269455,
-0.6865264773368835,
-0.44927820563316345,
-0.18292096257209778,
-0.5704366564750671,
0.43974414467811584,
-0.23976199328899384,
-0.2477198988199234,
0.28848254680633545,
-0.48085325956344604,
0.4958474934101105,
0.48848360776901245,
0.012491007335484028,
0.27331310510635376,
-0.0706184059381485,
-0.3173897862434387,
0.27578356862068176,
-0.5419831275939941,
-0.6895606517791748,
0.8507991433143616,
0.0345936119556427,
0.669506311416626,
0.120106540620327,
0.5826948881149292,
0.3578731417655945,
0.3023506999015808,
-0.9355596303939819,
1.0688282251358032,
0.05411289259791374,
-0.9928063750267029,
-0.5375930666923523,
-0.3187587261199951,
-1.1088815927505493,
0.05352074280381203,
-0.28800055384635925,
-0.8329550623893738,
-0.05938299372792244,
-0.061827290803194046,
-0.2608657777309418,
0.04912379011511803,
-0.5659846663475037,
0.6294670701026917,
-0.15674105286598206,
-0.17979243397712708,
-0.7858315110206604,
-0.1254226714372635,
0.18909063935279846,
-0.05171572044491768,
0.4544212222099304,
-0.18954232335090637,
0.0702541396021843,
0.6197844743728638,
-0.2775537371635437,
1.1602709293365479,
-0.1987103372812271,
-0.23859119415283203,
0.6280983090400696,
0.23173600435256958,
0.664543092250824,
-0.22438818216323853,
-0.11664571613073349,
-0.23874472081661224,
-0.010887671262025833,
-0.6647158265113831,
-0.7390914559364319,
0.4682091176509857,
-0.8249937295913696,
-0.9236654043197632,
-0.25482991337776184,
-0.7315689325332642,
-0.431955486536026,
0.0056169116869568825,
-0.24950577318668365,
0.3986043930053711,
-0.33037206530570984,
-0.2806110680103302,
0.561007022857666,
-0.11437655240297318,
0.4169805347919464,
0.8808196187019348,
-0.19911299645900726,
0.29767441749572754,
0.9185070991516113,
0.1597951501607895,
0.4097457826137543,
0.28360041975975037,
-0.014790890738368034,
-0.08993954956531525,
-0.6786155700683594,
-0.08949995785951614,
0.23031000792980194,
-0.7874324321746826,
-0.06438446789979935,
-0.11316977441310883,
-0.38754549622535706,
-0.10555952787399292,
-0.24921874701976776,
-0.31747791171073914,
-0.20912446081638336,
-0.24737592041492462,
0.12624119222164154,
0.0628582015633583,
0.9161573648452759,
0.1725737452507019,
0.13110339641571045,
-0.6563519835472107,
0.3076811730861664,
0.38526761531829834,
0.07028675824403763,
0.13785165548324585,
-0.4450322389602661,
-0.4297974705696106,
0.014444442465901375,
-0.45914772152900696,
-0.7614362239837646,
0.22627770900726318,
-0.10596863180398941,
0.8638339638710022,
0.1372588574886322,
0.3290296792984009,
0.5277177691459656,
-0.32086944580078125,
0.6593484282493591,
-0.21963484585285187,
-0.9366067051887512,
0.6586485505104065,
-0.18393343687057495,
0.23284867405891418,
0.14407867193222046,
0.323647141456604,
-0.5238363742828369,
-0.8551400899887085,
-0.2149355113506317,
-0.837835967540741,
0.5621939301490784,
0.09275893867015839,
0.24477893114089966,
-0.27538663148880005,
0.606570839881897,
-0.2694038450717926,
-0.06676303595304489,
-0.28145459294319153,
-0.18536266684532166,
0.2690432667732239,
-0.2712441086769104,
-0.20237724483013153,
-0.1054234504699707,
-0.1904471069574356,
-0.016662169247865677,
0.6867762804031372,
-0.2749655842781067,
0.42883941531181335,
0.26390498876571655,
-0.2854164242744446,
-0.08522073924541473,
0.49663451313972473,
0.3741043210029602,
0.5475830435752869,
0.16668559610843658,
0.15860368311405182,
0.17296408116817474,
-0.17611266672611237,
0.24578489363193512,
0.04808049649000168,
-0.17427687346935272,
-0.5472725629806519,
0.3198925852775574,
0.2787671983242035,
0.2007797360420227,
-1.0004349946975708,
0.0641702339053154,
0.030308539047837257,
-0.2668527066707611,
-0.4698151648044586,
0.18640616536140442,
0.2728496491909027,
0.48968684673309326,
0.5302866101264954,
-0.3191571533679962,
-0.0020034192129969597,
-0.62087482213974,
-0.07657574862241745,
0.6049895286560059,
-0.1779104620218277,
-0.15472625195980072,
0.2644198536872864,
0.25744470953941345,
-0.49420520663261414,
0.8555232286453247,
-0.33358609676361084,
-0.3883439898490906,
0.7585009336471558,
0.7770474553108215,
0.5256491303443909,
-0.12717553973197937,
0.44679319858551025,
0.11618263274431229,
0.33133164048194885,
-0.07747753709554672,
0.37676721811294556,
0.10073120892047882,
-0.7867600917816162,
-0.6817395091056824,
-0.44004353880882263,
-0.4553000032901764,
0.2272108793258667,
-0.49875760078430176,
0.06852704286575317,
-0.5940310955047607,
-0.3177904486656189,
0.25615930557250977,
0.1535206288099289,
-0.6843512058258057,
-0.05821273848414421,
0.5804606676101685,
0.7633467316627502,
-0.7325469851493835,
0.5711382627487183,
1.0173368453979492,
-0.3424869179725647,
-1.0438547134399414,
-0.22279798984527588,
-0.01664564572274685,
-0.7569299340248108,
0.6237053871154785,
-0.21524330973625183,
-0.006941195577383041,
-0.18343430757522583,
-0.6918792724609375,
-0.8134912252426147,
1.1225358247756958,
0.6142975687980652,
-0.5354340076446533,
-0.06484586745500565,
0.3262936770915985,
0.614515483379364,
-0.576198399066925,
0.07554005086421967,
0.4655590057373047,
0.7124235033988953,
-0.009996427223086357,
-1.0801687240600586,
0.5149203538894653,
-0.12916074693202972,
-0.04630608111619949,
0.12966729700565338,
-0.5944703221321106,
0.6277795433998108,
-0.29617029428482056,
-0.2175329625606537,
0.11449818313121796,
0.5738115906715393,
0.21131879091262817,
0.3385697305202484,
0.6303962469100952,
0.2622274160385132,
0.974341630935669,
0.21908006072044373,
0.9594628214836121,
-0.16095274686813354,
0.03892485424876213,
1.000419020652771,
-0.44216975569725037,
1.0083435773849487,
0.5684432983398438,
-0.16290181875228882,
0.6091178059577942,
0.38823723793029785,
0.1617402583360672,
0.17565733194351196,
0.49742943048477173,
-0.2618327736854553,
-0.7555468082427979,
-0.2627162039279938,
0.0350494459271431,
0.44111955165863037,
0.837906002998352,
0.035727400332689285,
-0.18210338056087494,
0.09359965473413467,
-0.402364581823349,
0.21190184354782104,
-0.32679376006126404,
0.697403609752655,
0.2747472822666168,
-0.8533803224563599,
0.507144570350647,
0.2511923313140869,
0.2209392786026001,
-0.49788329005241394,
-0.029634064063429832,
0.03393622115254402,
0.17705492675304413,
-0.014064904302358627,
-0.6473758220672607,
0.2859947681427002,
-0.18427430093288422,
-0.22479180991649628,
-0.03414153680205345,
0.6015495657920837,
-0.18443073332309723,
-0.4986712336540222,
0.5181387662887573,
0.7472460865974426,
0.19814571738243103,
-0.2474130094051361,
-0.561471700668335,
-0.011823596432805061,
-0.4158523678779602,
-0.09620337933301926,
0.4619055688381195,
0.43778979778289795,
-0.4498620629310608,
0.9445748925209045,
0.5273868441581726,
-0.04317741468548775,
0.04531538113951683,
-0.10885006934404373,
0.9569831490516663,
-0.6138179302215576,
-0.3014957010746002,
-0.5214700102806091,
0.2450871616601944,
0.08730001002550125,
0.23550373315811157,
0.3335539400577545,
0.21947434544563293,
0.5415116548538208,
0.030826253816485405,
0.9422473311424255,
-0.08778232336044312,
0.14722701907157898,
-0.4660980999469757,
0.2583118677139282,
-0.6077331900596619,
0.631939709186554,
0.050929728895425797,
-0.8720393776893616,
-0.15246868133544922,
0.39776960015296936,
-0.5335767865180969,
0.08018327504396439,
0.8488301634788513,
0.7698544263839722,
-0.013245539739727974,
0.054382868111133575,
0.3701878488063812,
0.39258256554603577,
0.4894108474254608,
0.8768139481544495,
1.152479648590088,
0.24332275986671448,
0.7905031442642212,
0.12049376219511032,
-0.42111894488334656,
-0.41461750864982605,
-0.48388341069221497,
-0.9560044407844543,
-0.6227281093597412,
-0.3964613080024719,
-0.157983660697937,
0.07248079031705856,
0.8698365688323975,
0.7973466515541077,
-0.5329115390777588,
-0.32305678725242615,
0.10615523159503937,
0.23274369537830353,
-0.34074729681015015,
-0.20675039291381836,
0.05365728586912155,
-0.7191649079322815,
-0.6459457874298096,
0.5249030590057373,
0.1044619232416153,
-0.03616269305348396,
-0.5287089347839355,
-0.06213519349694252,
0.016514744609594345,
0.5601019263267517,
0.47708660364151,
0.33420059084892273,
-0.755100667476654,
-0.491476833820343,
0.08974786102771759,
-0.25964125990867615,
-0.2879689633846283,
1.132845163345337,
-0.767795741558075,
0.09035423398017883,
0.17132487893104553,
0.5724404454231262,
0.5550100803375244,
-0.5656391382217407,
0.5539303421974182,
-0.5590396523475647,
0.08814167231321335,
0.30238696932792664,
0.39057567715644836,
0.03474590927362442,
-0.4113108217716217,
0.16324976086616516,
0.020582864060997963,
-0.49884819984436035,
-0.569075345993042,
0.42763587832450867,
-1.0452871322631836,
-0.700564444065094,
1.0343403816223145,
-0.14864197373390198,
-0.2728770971298218,
-0.6311847567558289,
-0.3351849317550659,
0.16490182280540466,
-0.43892011046409607,
0.9606435298919678,
0.8452821373939514,
-0.18131904304027557,
0.2630535066127777,
-0.6867039203643799,
0.21618840098381042,
0.5700629949569702,
-0.8582258820533752,
0.22609710693359375,
0.4403960704803467,
0.13376516103744507,
0.5429354906082153,
0.5859306454658508,
-0.02338818646967411,
0.11600126326084137,
-0.1005077213048935,
0.15636269748210907,
-0.11750832200050354,
-0.2664617598056793,
0.11623359471559525,
0.2868041396141052,
0.3286378085613251,
-0.050436947494745255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12130v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12130v1
|
MoRA: High-Rank Updating for Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning
| 2024-05-20T15:48:32 | 2024-05-20T15:48:32 |
Ting Jiang, Shaohan Huang, Shengyue Luo, Zihan Zhang, Haizhen Huang, Furu Wei, Weiwei Deng, Feng Sun, Qi Zhang, Deqing Wang, Fuzhen Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Low-rank adaptation is a popular parameter-efficient fine-tuning method for
large language models. In this paper, we analyze the impact of low-rank
updating, as implemented in LoRA. Our findings suggest that the low-rank
updating mechanism may limit the ability of LLMs to effectively learn and
memorize new knowledge. Inspired by this observation, we propose a new method
called MoRA, which employs a square matrix to achieve high-rank updating while
maintaining the same number of trainable parameters. To achieve it, we
introduce the corresponding non-parameter operators to reduce the input
dimension and increase the output dimension for the square matrix. Furthermore,
these operators ensure that the weight can be merged back into LLMs, which
makes our method can be deployed like LoRA. We perform a comprehensive
evaluation of our method across five tasks: instruction tuning, mathematical
reasoning, continual pretraining, memory and pretraining. Our method
outperforms LoRA on memory-intensive tasks and achieves comparable performance
on other tasks.
|
[
-0.2754426598548889,
-0.6853548288345337,
0.5487937927246094,
0.11346156895160675,
-0.3837231695652008,
-0.03169574588537216,
-0.43014204502105713,
-0.2863974869251251,
0.15814881026744843,
0.7277885675430298,
-0.2239171862602234,
-0.7238700985908508,
-0.7545530200004578,
-0.22624792158603668,
-0.07120800763368607,
0.9938663244247437,
0.015337430872023106,
0.08548731356859207,
0.15112334489822388,
-0.1551547646522522,
-0.7744373083114624,
-0.2078496813774109,
-0.9290821552276611,
-0.11286730319261551,
0.7540908455848694,
0.672097384929657,
0.41581273078918457,
0.5300678610801697,
0.4142683148384094,
0.23721672594547272,
-0.22637537121772766,
0.1762743592262268,
-1.002313256263733,
0.23782281577587128,
-0.10586772859096527,
-0.9724833369255066,
-0.7685600519180298,
-0.16931003332138062,
1.0515336990356445,
0.753295361995697,
-0.33971524238586426,
0.25339680910110474,
0.3516947627067566,
0.9393941164016724,
-0.8018006682395935,
0.04725946485996246,
-1.0286096334457397,
-0.1695200651884079,
-0.28675463795661926,
-0.3589012622833252,
-0.47269558906555176,
-0.6600147485733032,
-0.3466794788837433,
-0.782550573348999,
-0.25747570395469666,
0.12034579366445541,
0.6362573504447937,
0.7356711030006409,
0.015798116102814674,
0.03317926451563835,
-0.7377792596817017,
0.9720236659049988,
-0.7286868095397949,
0.27240461111068726,
0.4044276475906372,
0.46917724609375,
-0.2768693268299103,
-0.1902652084827423,
-0.15076227486133575,
-0.15007159113883972,
0.3236861526966095,
-0.05600154399871826,
-0.08540806174278259,
0.00492237089201808,
0.3379514813423157,
0.11571343243122101,
0.08205530792474747,
0.5277658700942993,
-0.5687302947044373,
0.31899628043174744,
0.4993395507335663,
0.1787441223859787,
0.03481438010931015,
-0.013502610847353935,
-0.26781144738197327,
-0.0017692764522507787,
-1.273049235343933,
0.00870779249817133,
0.2407214641571045,
0.32368171215057373,
-0.06796208024024963,
0.4025724232196808,
-0.26535752415657043,
0.948447048664093,
0.2601800262928009,
-0.23843544721603394,
-0.14224132895469666,
0.03618306294083595,
-0.2824288010597229,
0.16030675172805786,
0.3511890769004822,
0.2183617502450943,
0.10004588216543198,
0.027990980073809624,
-0.0968608632683754,
-0.32370200753211975,
0.14508511126041412,
-0.6572751402854919,
-0.054430581629276276,
-0.3428208529949188,
-0.24406002461910248,
-0.314214825630188,
-0.3054591715335846,
-1.082545280456543,
-0.39813390374183655,
-0.12377575784921646,
0.9062312245368958,
-0.2551755905151367,
0.4721008539199829,
0.41847214102745056,
0.20230618119239807,
0.21358561515808105,
1.1207584142684937,
-1.0192396640777588,
0.3785608410835266,
0.5399779081344604,
0.5148435831069946,
-0.15290452539920807,
-0.4142976999282837,
-1.0645653009414673,
0.2617965638637543,
-0.4210909307003021,
0.7902733087539673,
-0.4176025092601776,
-0.09071371704339981,
-0.4876119792461395,
-0.12545721232891083,
-0.2875196933746338,
-0.6901171803474426,
0.12668751180171967,
-0.6242132782936096,
0.3699215054512024,
-0.22187454998493195,
-0.1721862107515335,
-0.1033603772521019,
0.02598184533417225,
-0.5775517225265503,
1.4487316608428955,
0.2912755310535431,
-0.27541226148605347,
0.3393091559410095,
-0.742536723613739,
-0.2731423079967499,
-0.14035767316818237,
0.017924509942531586,
-0.36939138174057007,
0.21979986131191254,
0.04698660597205162,
0.4707845151424408,
-0.5905430316925049,
-0.2401953786611557,
-0.3215404450893402,
-0.7734265327453613,
0.07773984223604202,
-0.1928541511297226,
0.5486948490142822,
-0.0004035095334984362,
-0.2853396236896515,
0.031701844185590744,
-0.751002848148346,
-0.026255158707499504,
-0.21419331431388855,
-0.8684608340263367,
-0.43895116448402405,
0.060860197991132736,
-0.5482421517372131,
0.004073427524417639,
0.4764593243598938,
-0.4644930362701416,
0.3846442699432373,
-0.36143016815185547,
0.31267204880714417,
1.0374764204025269,
0.16261684894561768,
0.38708722591400146,
-0.339067667722702,
0.3724372982978821,
-0.2102510929107666,
0.3563331067562103,
0.23635238409042358,
-0.5976400375366211,
-0.8508678674697876,
-0.4544839859008789,
0.7465477585792542,
0.4294406771659851,
-0.321271687746048,
0.5468527674674988,
-0.3519885838031769,
-0.40437182784080505,
-0.845249354839325,
0.5891855955123901,
0.2820981740951538,
0.32025840878486633,
0.6296522617340088,
-0.26819512248039246,
-0.29193922877311707,
-0.5861958265304565,
-0.05375390127301216,
-0.067470021545887,
0.06584025174379349,
0.17786350846290588,
0.32947129011154175,
-0.11469793319702148,
0.7432563900947571,
-0.7808447480201721,
-0.46691590547561646,
-0.08400389552116394,
0.1667601764202118,
0.28774330019950867,
0.5163834095001221,
0.6127902865409851,
-0.09996216744184494,
-0.6344014406204224,
0.08424375206232071,
-0.5493625402450562,
-0.015421397052705288,
0.20256194472312927,
-0.18877775967121124,
0.20882371068000793,
0.5550137758255005,
-0.4278377592563629,
0.27019786834716797,
0.6136616468429565,
-0.013841782696545124,
0.13097667694091797,
-0.6383726000785828,
0.1921878159046173,
-1.177961826324463,
-0.02381167747080326,
-0.19335216283798218,
-0.14112140238285065,
-0.4154691696166992,
0.0365680530667305,
-0.17466814815998077,
-0.3725011646747589,
-0.41397762298583984,
0.6213554739952087,
-0.4077240228652954,
-0.328725665807724,
-0.23558206856250763,
0.27470123767852783,
-0.020513111725449562,
0.6822153329849243,
-0.49949613213539124,
0.8241976499557495,
0.5338020920753479,
-0.7035532593727112,
0.23194800317287445,
0.21480455994606018,
-0.6587271094322205,
0.6064399480819702,
-0.37393614649772644,
0.0986289456486702,
-0.18350501358509064,
0.05348416045308113,
-0.7369236946105957,
0.044955119490623474,
0.1935272365808487,
-0.1793765425682068,
0.24691906571388245,
-0.424191415309906,
-0.3200020492076874,
0.15553976595401764,
-0.6293151378631592,
0.042673707008361816,
0.7595941424369812,
-0.5976826548576355,
0.466726154088974,
0.38548946380615234,
-0.21128161251544952,
-0.5553742051124573,
-0.4540843069553375,
0.02367016300559044,
-0.45326125621795654,
-0.3466057777404785,
0.22247661650180817,
-0.15452100336551666,
-0.2122439444065094,
-0.0458853542804718,
-0.23951587080955505,
0.002918566344305873,
0.48870596289634705,
-0.11913033574819565,
0.15840311348438263,
-0.3678772449493408,
-0.1547217220067978,
0.3699902892112732,
-0.18636657297611237,
-0.38616716861724854,
0.02027040533721447,
0.4599398672580719,
0.17569023370742798,
-0.267119824886322,
-0.5254624485969543,
0.11104739457368851,
0.805079460144043,
-0.030378049239516258,
0.7552312612533569,
0.3597376048564911,
-0.3436131477355957,
-0.5718964338302612,
-0.4669848382472992,
-0.1664741188287735,
-0.46147096157073975,
0.4444926381111145,
-0.47781795263290405,
-0.76371169090271,
0.6017090678215027,
-0.45000842213630676,
-0.06129103899002075,
0.34807249903678894,
0.47617337107658386,
-0.4630317986011505,
0.911449134349823,
0.7053653597831726,
-0.2125406265258789,
0.605581521987915,
-0.2332199066877365,
0.17254826426506042,
-1.2705485820770264,
-0.1417245715856552,
-0.8293231129646301,
-0.5237376093864441,
-0.3564617931842804,
-0.6747507452964783,
0.49062782526016235,
0.7117007374763489,
-0.15211452543735504,
0.4993448257446289,
-0.2709055542945862,
0.34622523188591003,
0.41681304574012756,
0.189068004488945,
0.4761700928211212,
-0.005233646836131811,
0.2082277089357376,
-0.06342744082212448,
-0.6704621315002441,
-0.20705938339233398,
1.0880659818649292,
0.21312804520130157,
1.3472809791564941,
0.3447158932685852,
0.7127860188484192,
0.5547549724578857,
0.02446773275732994,
-0.7575941681861877,
0.8032227754592896,
-0.4382791221141815,
-0.25600937008857727,
-0.8183006048202515,
-0.2854771912097931,
-1.102744460105896,
0.2592434287071228,
-0.34755784273147583,
-0.9105072617530823,
0.4461069703102112,
0.1228940337896347,
-0.5130634307861328,
0.2600591480731964,
-0.5758105516433716,
0.54776531457901,
-0.12298066169023514,
-0.33246368169784546,
-0.6869566440582275,
-0.2243516743183136,
0.04392535984516144,
-0.47161221504211426,
-0.06370950490236282,
-0.31325918436050415,
-0.14694111049175262,
0.7794438004493713,
-0.17942661046981812,
0.9421066641807556,
-0.3708050847053528,
-0.3956267833709717,
-0.3018825054168701,
-0.01128704659640789,
0.8334565162658691,
0.06668209284543991,
-0.5015787482261658,
0.02599666640162468,
-0.08826569467782974,
-0.4577082097530365,
-1.0127043724060059,
0.8836323618888855,
-0.9126625657081604,
-0.7871668338775635,
-0.16496795415878296,
-0.3646915853023529,
-0.3739564120769501,
0.1029997393488884,
0.011324728839099407,
0.24229030311107635,
-0.2177681028842926,
0.3676438629627228,
0.9244999289512634,
-0.17681677639484406,
0.038421399891376495,
0.6332696676254272,
-0.17205648124217987,
-0.3248615562915802,
0.9460182785987854,
0.32056164741516113,
0.3115864098072052,
0.5260799527168274,
0.057562172412872314,
0.056813374161720276,
-0.8969485759735107,
-0.7769688963890076,
0.2657741904258728,
-0.7206107974052429,
-0.14975807070732117,
-0.09174143522977829,
-0.05993114784359932,
0.07006357610225677,
-0.3203192949295044,
-0.3949373662471771,
-0.673215925693512,
-0.23858954012393951,
0.41650304198265076,
0.4917212128639221,
0.9118300080299377,
0.06223835051059723,
0.483489990234375,
-0.38891980051994324,
0.3697535991668701,
0.5290514826774597,
0.3942185044288635,
-0.1781054437160492,
-0.7338309288024902,
-0.6470451354980469,
-0.045156922191381454,
0.03913717344403267,
-0.6922348737716675,
-0.11614587157964706,
0.2932656407356262,
0.7020456790924072,
0.15575169026851654,
0.026494383811950684,
0.7326236367225647,
-0.38586682081222534,
0.5028727650642395,
0.06303499639034271,
-0.9847643375396729,
0.6528536677360535,
-0.4013814330101013,
0.1362169235944748,
0.7807123064994812,
0.08317705243825912,
-0.23775862157344818,
-0.21511457860469818,
-0.05255916342139244,
-0.49687036871910095,
0.896132230758667,
-0.3159249424934387,
0.12176896631717682,
0.4550057351589203,
0.5184438228607178,
0.10516253858804703,
0.08794072270393372,
-0.4501100778579712,
-0.001661962945945561,
0.1977718025445938,
-0.1556374728679657,
-0.14290884137153625,
-0.2046932727098465,
-0.27014604210853577,
-0.5194370746612549,
0.8024522066116333,
-0.2925381064414978,
0.4131920337677002,
-0.3928089439868927,
-0.43384116888046265,
-0.24724581837654114,
0.5206112861633301,
0.8012891411781311,
0.7262417674064636,
-0.4630945920944214,
-0.1618591845035553,
0.8754919767379761,
-0.2768298387527466,
0.10573998838663101,
-0.09647798538208008,
-0.4041655957698822,
-0.26393696665763855,
-0.02087727002799511,
1.207620620727539,
0.9881855249404907,
-0.24710646271705627,
0.1955520361661911,
0.28833121061325073,
-0.23229508101940155,
0.1275940090417862,
0.5535834431648254,
-0.12444694340229034,
0.09646090865135193,
0.38002970814704895,
0.34961870312690735,
-0.28444457054138184,
-0.7616717219352722,
-0.16899563372135162,
0.2506897449493408,
-0.46703246235847473,
-0.31638213992118835,
0.49414217472076416,
0.1446334421634674,
-0.2466641515493393,
0.04918074235320091,
0.07423898577690125,
-0.13652531802654266,
0.2243216633796692,
0.5062063336372375,
0.4136350452899933,
-0.3985995054244995,
0.1693231165409088,
0.17575187981128693,
0.27635127305984497,
-0.3212675154209137,
0.3066334128379822,
-0.002705055521801114,
-0.5279176235198975,
-0.6493216156959534,
-0.7091896533966064,
-0.5370574593544006,
0.16004645824432373,
-0.6849005818367004,
0.601192057132721,
-0.7266684770584106,
-0.00860166922211647,
-0.06556958705186844,
0.15938544273376465,
-0.2150435894727707,
-0.04606673866510391,
-0.17788958549499512,
0.8216737508773804,
-0.6155025362968445,
1.2795114517211914,
0.6533572673797607,
-0.10470423102378845,
-0.44420379400253296,
0.19242481887340546,
-0.25724413990974426,
-0.9668897986412048,
0.6985083222389221,
-0.4368601143360138,
-0.5999704599380493,
0.408316045999527,
-0.16730612516403198,
-1.182028889656067,
1.1353156566619873,
0.8720413446426392,
-0.4206770956516266,
-0.17866410315036774,
-0.023211047053337097,
0.5426519513130188,
-0.1880531758069992,
-0.23636585474014282,
0.3604390025138855,
0.713204026222229,
-0.16727516055107117,
-0.8495100736618042,
0.07795479148626328,
0.060828372836112976,
0.07740887999534607,
0.4481087923049927,
-0.7311088442802429,
0.9268884062767029,
-0.24100224673748016,
-0.0039133490063250065,
0.22621947526931763,
0.407588392496109,
0.1818310171365738,
-0.24661879241466522,
0.4152933955192566,
0.7112221717834473,
1.0574190616607666,
0.021933188661932945,
0.6630867719650269,
-0.29401955008506775,
0.34790897369384766,
1.02958083152771,
-0.6072137951850891,
1.152387261390686,
0.34645387530326843,
-0.08918974548578262,
0.8174290657043457,
0.30677956342697144,
-0.10163047164678574,
0.7602448463439941,
0.3714297115802765,
-0.2591344118118286,
-0.19963400065898895,
0.21657513082027435,
-0.4540095329284668,
0.6037806272506714,
0.36349913477897644,
0.04396292194724083,
-0.3762229382991791,
0.2068444788455963,
0.0927891954779625,
-0.024610675871372223,
-0.6190018653869629,
0.8184552192687988,
0.050509415566921234,
-0.5995156764984131,
0.9826908707618713,
0.30036720633506775,
0.6784202456474304,
-0.6234523057937622,
-0.15925656259059906,
-0.050281696021556854,
0.39584219455718994,
-0.06900763511657715,
-0.45752477645874023,
0.07260391116142273,
-0.05861252546310425,
-0.20570197701454163,
-0.004711274057626724,
0.5871478915214539,
-0.2648119032382965,
-0.19730183482170105,
0.5938044190406799,
0.5152791738510132,
0.060544513165950775,
0.18748515844345093,
-0.7819486260414124,
0.22065958380699158,
-0.11850825697183609,
-0.15523310005664825,
0.8040202856063843,
0.26108479499816895,
-0.2698843777179718,
0.69626784324646,
0.6659648418426514,
0.4088418185710907,
0.1590021401643753,
-0.007990122772753239,
0.9018813371658325,
-0.6403675675392151,
-0.43347135186195374,
-0.513066291809082,
0.10844070464372635,
0.14665165543556213,
-0.24396374821662903,
0.6939262747764587,
0.4435432255268097,
0.48463118076324463,
-0.008550189435482025,
0.5936728715896606,
0.16321466863155365,
0.5106335878372192,
-1.008874773979187,
0.7927080392837524,
-0.7293637990951538,
0.5968679785728455,
-0.050636064261198044,
-1.1134488582611084,
-0.24007874727249146,
0.5383995175361633,
-0.4484710693359375,
-0.07812362164258957,
0.8060123920440674,
0.7416192889213562,
-0.14775680005550385,
-0.374834269285202,
0.5715189576148987,
0.41483303904533386,
-0.24393436312675476,
0.5413006544113159,
0.7110044956207275,
-0.5582302212715149,
0.31265702843666077,
0.14375226199626923,
-0.09918250888586044,
-0.557889461517334,
-0.6431881785392761,
-0.8473113179206848,
-0.43890103697776794,
-0.23821207880973816,
-0.22076962888240814,
0.578554093837738,
0.6761110424995422,
0.8680023550987244,
-0.659186601638794,
-0.3232731521129608,
0.3375965654850006,
0.26677772402763367,
-0.3245317041873932,
-0.1374097317457199,
0.40491804480552673,
-0.364963561296463,
-0.8117641806602478,
0.8673285245895386,
0.48917698860168457,
-0.2842811048030853,
-0.3806317448616028,
-0.35676875710487366,
-0.19700802862644196,
0.23277747631072998,
0.6867366433143616,
0.3983790874481201,
-0.4442425072193146,
-0.4888170063495636,
-0.15648581087589264,
-0.16867253184318542,
0.4019729197025299,
0.5192835927009583,
-0.6760863065719604,
0.014568688347935677,
0.5041939616203308,
0.6478336453437805,
0.9621241092681885,
-0.12386031448841095,
0.5684242248535156,
-0.5478779673576355,
-0.04984079301357269,
-0.19288094341754913,
0.26457059383392334,
0.12375838309526443,
-0.3558793365955353,
0.38216468691825867,
0.0623289979994297,
-0.35342133045196533,
-0.9810138940811157,
0.1193404272198677,
-1.233844518661499,
-0.26083970069885254,
0.8221210837364197,
-0.03912238031625748,
-0.39417603611946106,
-0.31998497247695923,
-0.1611802726984024,
-0.0610237717628479,
-0.4258294999599457,
0.9732415080070496,
0.3908839225769043,
-0.042010385543107986,
-0.2709025740623474,
-0.606549084186554,
0.6409370303153992,
0.5647903084754944,
-1.0912036895751953,
0.15902301669120789,
0.16267433762550354,
0.46022719144821167,
-0.05568348988890648,
0.7201451659202576,
-0.2083813101053238,
0.44736936688423157,
-0.5233117341995239,
0.06922151893377304,
-0.008611018769443035,
-0.500390887260437,
-0.6728765368461609,
0.04585268348455429,
0.6329538822174072,
-0.1140250712633133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12119v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12119v1
|
Reindex-Then-Adapt: Improving Large Language Models for Conversational Recommendation
| 2024-05-20T15:37:55 | 2024-05-20T15:37:55 |
Zhankui He, Zhouhang Xie, Harald Steck, Dawen Liang, Rahul Jha, Nathan Kallus, Julian McAuley
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are revolutionizing conversational recommender
systems by adeptly indexing item content, understanding complex conversational
contexts, and generating relevant item titles. However, controlling the
distribution of recommended items remains a challenge. This leads to suboptimal
performance due to the failure to capture rapidly changing data distributions,
such as item popularity, on targeted conversational recommendation platforms.
In conversational recommendation, LLMs recommend items by generating the titles
(as multiple tokens) autoregressively, making it difficult to obtain and
control the recommendations over all items. Thus, we propose a
Reindex-Then-Adapt (RTA) framework, which converts multi-token item titles into
single tokens within LLMs, and then adjusts the probability distributions over
these single-token item titles accordingly. The RTA framework marries the
benefits of both LLMs and traditional recommender systems (RecSys):
understanding complex queries as LLMs do; while efficiently controlling the
recommended item distributions in conversational recommendations as traditional
RecSys do. Our framework demonstrates improved accuracy metrics across three
different conversational recommendation datasets and two adaptation settings
|
[
-0.2292218804359436,
-0.4859907627105713,
0.35573604702949524,
0.36162278056144714,
-0.2730434536933899,
0.17010624706745148,
-0.38722091913223267,
-0.2711438834667206,
0.3964305520057678,
0.5351405739784241,
-0.5232818722724915,
-0.5275176763534546,
-0.5259915590286255,
-0.021159039810299873,
-0.2870177924633026,
0.9696952104568481,
0.2295161932706833,
-0.11523344367742538,
-0.049442365765571594,
-0.2350929081439972,
-0.8016254305839539,
-0.18409523367881775,
-1.029848575592041,
-0.3510216176509857,
0.48301756381988525,
0.6043083071708679,
0.8715037703514099,
0.3614424169063568,
0.49118277430534363,
0.3424331247806549,
0.15540961921215057,
0.47228124737739563,
-0.7148956656455994,
0.36411890387535095,
-0.4932538568973541,
-0.48881518840789795,
-0.5875855684280396,
-0.47206881642341614,
0.5037218332290649,
0.6045933961868286,
-0.5711828470230103,
0.10786854475736618,
0.03385026752948761,
0.6946766972541809,
-0.47032803297042847,
0.2056368738412857,
-0.8070089221000671,
-0.35259512066841125,
-0.04111103340983391,
-0.34294623136520386,
-0.5922216176986694,
-0.3618725836277008,
0.5360446572303772,
-0.764183759689331,
-0.11661088466644287,
0.4872126281261444,
0.43214187026023865,
-0.0642344132065773,
-0.21463844180107117,
-0.22640876471996307,
-0.813079833984375,
0.8680123090744019,
-0.5730249881744385,
0.5972560048103333,
0.07981044799089432,
0.4025520086288452,
-0.48715874552726746,
-0.9701043963432312,
-0.22681663930416107,
-0.12288910150527954,
0.15750202536582947,
-0.2707199156284332,
-0.43659114837646484,
-0.23092304170131683,
-0.20531640946865082,
-0.06757020205259323,
-0.5210167765617371,
0.13726010918617249,
0.011301146820187569,
0.07093628495931625,
0.5622637867927551,
0.2579291760921478,
0.173454150557518,
0.21905560791492462,
-0.2355794459581375,
-0.22735069692134857,
-0.6992470622062683,
-0.1891029328107834,
-0.18702104687690735,
0.516174852848053,
0.06153644248843193,
0.5345981121063232,
-0.37963980436325073,
0.6009315252304077,
0.41533952951431274,
-0.14550599455833435,
0.2690048813819885,
-0.5699708461761475,
-0.10643267631530762,
-0.006834317464381456,
0.6665260195732117,
0.731224775314331,
0.3201219141483307,
-0.08982682973146439,
-0.015939656645059586,
-0.5099344253540039,
0.36672520637512207,
-0.7701146602630615,
-0.3689643442630768,
0.012413839809596539,
-0.5768081545829773,
-0.15970277786254883,
0.02436935342848301,
-0.8351230621337891,
-0.5763275623321533,
-0.11332553625106812,
0.33560967445373535,
-0.15869292616844177,
-0.21352307498455048,
0.5281223058700562,
0.0436057448387146,
-0.10955135524272919,
0.33123579621315,
-1.0057501792907715,
0.28310880064964294,
0.6497164368629456,
0.8236666917800903,
-0.25309085845947266,
-0.26984643936157227,
-0.46564188599586487,
0.19084106385707855,
-0.3468697965145111,
1.1403143405914307,
-0.7149480581283569,
-0.511094331741333,
0.13802145421504974,
0.44483432173728943,
-0.030553285032510757,
-0.5444647669792175,
0.3822409212589264,
-0.8031270503997803,
0.06862453371286392,
-0.22507868707180023,
-0.3431590497493744,
-0.08389190584421158,
0.25469598174095154,
-0.28113025426864624,
0.8722057938575745,
0.023449067026376724,
-0.5272650122642517,
0.41622763872146606,
-0.4608944058418274,
-0.4348408281803131,
-0.11084108799695969,
0.24551954865455627,
-0.23276755213737488,
-0.07557155936956406,
0.38012397289276123,
0.36248108744621277,
-0.3548901677131653,
0.37827882170677185,
-0.7515352964401245,
-0.12372176349163055,
0.33061590790748596,
-0.35238319635391235,
0.163058802485466,
0.25286126136779785,
0.11148523539304733,
0.48386314511299133,
-0.39652931690216064,
0.06952925771474838,
-0.10320310294628143,
-0.23759011924266815,
-0.3510987162590027,
0.2421495020389557,
0.16293132305145264,
-0.11943906545639038,
0.3480687141418457,
-0.2585795521736145,
0.37585946917533875,
-0.6698921322822571,
0.37738871574401855,
0.9240767955780029,
0.0038524754345417023,
0.7122758030891418,
-0.4870851933956146,
0.4422837495803833,
-0.03971659764647484,
-0.047654323279857635,
-0.2294592708349228,
-0.33920785784721375,
-0.7891910076141357,
-0.07049025595188141,
0.18864788115024567,
0.4906062185764313,
-0.8567255139350891,
0.6492986083030701,
-0.4963605999946594,
-0.6007376313209534,
-0.38896435499191284,
0.15158197283744812,
0.0598277784883976,
0.0419444814324379,
0.09780421108007431,
-0.5324001312255859,
-0.7366483807563782,
-0.7168510556221008,
-0.36781638860702515,
-0.3185761272907257,
-0.050847556442022324,
0.5245497822761536,
-0.015034103766083717,
-0.49138274788856506,
0.7834543585777283,
-0.7381313443183899,
-0.415383517742157,
-0.2568821609020233,
0.06902842223644257,
0.39603251218795776,
0.24031688272953033,
0.43739011883735657,
-0.36755919456481934,
-0.33393439650535583,
0.04779123514890671,
-0.19630973041057587,
-0.3257524371147156,
-0.06775347143411636,
-0.3489956855773926,
0.0712084248661995,
0.5266035795211792,
-0.34072190523147583,
0.06699711084365845,
0.3981778621673584,
-0.4874197542667389,
0.39834779500961304,
-0.5557435750961304,
0.06357327103614807,
-1.3772625923156738,
-0.21677125990390778,
0.043213509023189545,
-0.3779056668281555,
-0.23742260038852692,
-0.29922693967819214,
-0.09100684523582458,
0.13162794709205627,
-0.15058743953704834,
0.5337491631507874,
-0.13928736746311188,
-0.04817592725157738,
-0.46890079975128174,
0.32248780131340027,
0.09158790111541748,
0.09756141155958176,
-0.04659649729728699,
0.7269167304039001,
0.41529402136802673,
-0.7237450480461121,
0.4317047595977783,
0.37128138542175293,
-0.32809433341026306,
0.7467355728149414,
-0.6056378483772278,
-0.14992758631706238,
0.005790011025965214,
0.531457245349884,
-1.3470827341079712,
0.1684941202402115,
0.04718715324997902,
-0.14981931447982788,
0.18193402886390686,
-0.08901654928922653,
-0.1744893342256546,
-0.08102703094482422,
-0.35369375348091125,
0.45620355010032654,
0.2217707633972168,
-0.7107508778572083,
0.6562608480453491,
0.5199191570281982,
-0.3886721730232239,
-0.6729776859283447,
-0.298544317483902,
0.2725730836391449,
-0.1063956543803215,
-0.5044887065887451,
0.5007981061935425,
-0.5708000659942627,
-0.2845590114593506,
-0.10779216885566711,
0.22064845263957977,
0.27290138602256775,
0.03224926441907883,
0.18785010278224945,
0.11143127083778381,
-0.25793638825416565,
0.33918339014053345,
-0.05832092836499214,
-0.44604572653770447,
-0.27246543765068054,
-0.5322333574295044,
0.7031660079956055,
-0.12754833698272705,
-0.2236168384552002,
-0.4790692627429962,
0.006472754757851362,
0.8095443248748779,
0.016270430758595467,
0.6121438145637512,
0.6567110419273376,
-0.052159544080495834,
-0.1858353167772293,
-0.5944980382919312,
-0.38055628538131714,
-0.5036699771881104,
0.7227005362510681,
-0.3922504484653473,
-0.7868952751159668,
0.2622672915458679,
-0.17329992353916168,
0.30880534648895264,
0.19895969331264496,
0.7111485600471497,
-0.12205113470554352,
1.0380773544311523,
0.716252326965332,
-0.3596961200237274,
0.805819034576416,
0.03193186968564987,
0.5338515043258667,
-0.7494986057281494,
-0.11871523410081863,
-0.5049563646316528,
-0.25909802317619324,
-0.6994983553886414,
-0.3344253599643707,
0.10634711384773254,
-0.2534503638744354,
-0.06378433853387833,
0.28167837858200073,
-0.2107224464416504,
0.2626760005950928,
0.39060133695602417,
0.05168555676937103,
0.3262433409690857,
0.20207612216472626,
0.37844955921173096,
0.03986438363790512,
-0.6754575967788696,
-0.22113695740699768,
1.323535442352295,
0.29170602560043335,
1.0965203046798706,
0.3286145329475403,
0.30383265018463135,
0.5565100312232971,
0.5469195246696472,
-0.8788723349571228,
0.39936041831970215,
-0.5943001508712769,
-0.120163694024086,
-0.06130622699856758,
-0.0533430390059948,
-1.0706275701522827,
0.2736707329750061,
-0.31421801447868347,
-0.5115972757339478,
0.476151704788208,
-0.021033605560660362,
-0.5016850233078003,
0.20504549145698547,
-0.6260833144187927,
0.7007558941841125,
-0.08102194964885712,
-0.19957150518894196,
-0.36082202196121216,
-0.13298919796943665,
0.17231103777885437,
-0.237604558467865,
0.46157729625701904,
-0.14606817066669464,
-0.1591530591249466,
0.771023154258728,
-0.09031803905963898,
0.6858105063438416,
0.05001113936305046,
-0.04624173417687416,
0.06957444548606873,
0.4633713960647583,
0.701682984828949,
0.2856873571872711,
-0.22764569520950317,
-0.008900687098503113,
0.37988168001174927,
-0.04420800879597664,
-0.5965154767036438,
1.0310417413711548,
-0.7522369027137756,
-0.6665672659873962,
-0.1309109777212143,
-0.6546526551246643,
-0.1168927475810051,
0.3213089406490326,
-0.1666179746389389,
0.22707624733448029,
-0.34221047163009644,
0.5138155817985535,
0.49749141931533813,
-0.06117231398820877,
0.32223236560821533,
0.8251546621322632,
-0.5719318985939026,
-0.6056479215621948,
0.7614190578460693,
0.07581041753292084,
0.1128215417265892,
0.28950217366218567,
0.20009668171405792,
-0.6705318689346313,
-0.6425197720527649,
-0.4027304947376251,
0.22576592862606049,
-0.5394973158836365,
-0.18229496479034424,
-0.6804397106170654,
0.24029283225536346,
-0.5951969623565674,
-0.20606876909732819,
-0.3679027259349823,
-0.24078097939491272,
-0.5538889765739441,
-0.15977546572685242,
0.5564349293708801,
0.5467634797096252,
0.10712860524654388,
0.5113240480422974,
-0.6320235133171082,
0.33636367321014404,
0.23610997200012207,
0.5002490282058716,
-0.13159871101379395,
-1.1241873502731323,
-0.18923385441303253,
-0.052361875772476196,
-0.0876966044306755,
-0.5146339535713196,
0.4798562228679657,
0.36160388588905334,
0.2753838896751404,
0.7201945185661316,
0.12045015394687653,
0.7888155579566956,
-0.5727641582489014,
0.5454176068305969,
0.16116805374622345,
-0.4971141517162323,
0.18821203708648682,
-0.29160770773887634,
0.277506560087204,
0.5542861819267273,
-0.057300202548503876,
-0.8245038390159607,
-0.06092051416635513,
-0.4540407955646515,
-0.8369329571723938,
0.7370558381080627,
-0.2304832935333252,
0.36832526326179504,
-0.15162406861782074,
0.4188236892223358,
0.20521123707294464,
0.11395662277936935,
-0.4689091444015503,
-0.22634616494178772,
0.10262081772089005,
-0.4201560318470001,
-0.41030991077423096,
-0.7899497747421265,
-0.12831126153469086,
-0.029343266040086746,
0.8756350874900818,
-0.1362646073102951,
-0.03643124923110008,
-0.0080944262444973,
0.07003090530633926,
-0.1155032217502594,
0.344870924949646,
0.5734328627586365,
0.850078284740448,
-0.39254945516586304,
0.058770887553691864,
0.2258017361164093,
-0.2329673022031784,
0.16053612530231476,
-0.009250862523913383,
-0.012409964576363564,
-0.09347595274448395,
-0.031831949949264526,
0.6283937692642212,
0.5826031565666199,
-0.749801754951477,
0.2804099917411804,
-0.3204440772533417,
0.25189247727394104,
-0.39040079712867737,
-0.037465471774339676,
0.23393511772155762,
0.35494911670684814,
0.0652923509478569,
0.0957382470369339,
0.007041839882731438,
-0.5826058387756348,
0.4765435457229614,
0.5172780752182007,
-0.30453234910964966,
-0.16254059970378876,
0.21450847387313843,
0.262848436832428,
-0.6419128775596619,
0.3737488389015198,
0.23568765819072723,
-0.035070210695266724,
0.24410896003246307,
0.8551709651947021,
1.0309107303619385,
-0.30077654123306274,
0.22132204473018646,
0.3355814218521118,
0.27151989936828613,
-0.4521179795265198,
0.12358309328556061,
0.1739232987165451,
-1.155841588973999,
-0.07962505519390106,
-0.568516731262207,
-0.21319814026355743,
-0.2681427597999573,
-0.6186122894287109,
0.36175963282585144,
-0.505537748336792,
-0.4514034390449524,
-0.07549313455820084,
-0.4175577759742737,
-0.6077703833580017,
-0.08519106358289719,
-0.21334722638130188,
0.8331825733184814,
-0.6913067102432251,
0.6825507879257202,
0.48559847474098206,
0.03137043118476868,
-0.4180646538734436,
-0.3563341498374939,
-0.2735116183757782,
-1.0101226568222046,
0.33093181252479553,
-0.20876339077949524,
-0.3187161684036255,
0.17709758877754211,
-0.1257900446653366,
-1.07987380027771,
1.0801453590393066,
0.13481031358242035,
-0.8675022721290588,
0.2520516514778137,
-0.23616905510425568,
0.5722691416740417,
-0.8065664172172546,
0.5124801397323608,
0.7817885279655457,
0.39077526330947876,
0.1428399533033371,
-0.9403613209724426,
0.013963662087917328,
0.15957240760326385,
0.08733462542295456,
0.1782757192850113,
-0.5624822974205017,
0.3101293742656708,
-0.3720763921737671,
-0.08346680551767349,
0.35125723481178284,
0.5617108345031738,
0.510129451751709,
0.35903793573379517,
0.7151947617530823,
0.5352925062179565,
0.5872500538825989,
-0.11255548149347305,
0.9135568141937256,
-0.2724713385105133,
0.2067577987909317,
1.4237356185913086,
-0.44284719228744507,
1.1942170858383179,
0.43730613589286804,
-0.37010595202445984,
0.6901093125343323,
0.8766798973083496,
0.10372813045978546,
0.505766749382019,
0.07586433738470078,
-0.12748265266418457,
-0.41360723972320557,
-0.34480324387550354,
-0.46776509284973145,
0.32636645436286926,
0.4429313540458679,
-0.4739645719528198,
-0.15964657068252563,
0.05507047101855278,
-0.08842845261096954,
-0.10189831256866455,
-0.08872493356466293,
1.0905998945236206,
0.10877279192209244,
-0.6294559836387634,
0.5720704793930054,
0.17650549113750458,
0.6370400190353394,
-0.591115415096283,
0.0730767771601677,
-0.2433248907327652,
0.28672629594802856,
-0.027773398905992508,
-0.6682177782058716,
-0.06032181903719902,
-0.37519216537475586,
-0.45338618755340576,
-0.08732029050588608,
0.6239151358604431,
-0.5798082947731018,
-0.7222597002983093,
0.296272337436676,
0.27555742859840393,
0.1455400139093399,
0.05251006409525871,
-0.8544464707374573,
0.07387273758649826,
0.13105452060699463,
-0.22126871347427368,
0.34063833951950073,
0.3022545576095581,
-0.12605813145637512,
1.123175024986267,
0.9204135537147522,
0.1420152634382248,
-0.014290755614638329,
0.2755011320114136,
0.6030365228652954,
-0.5406857132911682,
-0.5357381105422974,
-0.6767080426216125,
0.222049742937088,
0.18531689047813416,
0.02057255059480667,
0.5674727559089661,
0.23436078429222107,
0.7020352482795715,
-0.024259110912680626,
0.44217801094055176,
0.1766098141670227,
0.3804897367954254,
-0.3030131161212921,
0.5532960891723633,
-0.5383159518241882,
0.7500373125076294,
-0.0671382024884224,
-1.085706114768982,
-0.3480028212070465,
0.22530347108840942,
-0.37325969338417053,
0.01037721335887909,
0.5981962084770203,
1.0957485437393188,
0.08205651491880417,
-0.21386118233203888,
0.27049142122268677,
0.4331057667732239,
0.6024738550186157,
0.4809732437133789,
0.541259765625,
-0.4197646677494049,
0.5531062483787537,
0.1437063366174698,
-0.12011555582284927,
-0.5597726106643677,
-0.8565134406089783,
-0.44538092613220215,
-0.29422491788864136,
-0.29138511419296265,
-0.5298299193382263,
0.14867383241653442,
1.079819679260254,
0.8801047205924988,
-0.9492844939231873,
-0.4534318447113037,
0.18509364128112793,
0.34994566440582275,
-0.3623413145542145,
-0.2497633695602417,
0.49978145956993103,
-0.221496120095253,
-0.6976526379585266,
0.6376216411590576,
0.4261365532875061,
-0.152816504240036,
-0.10518516600131989,
-0.16016888618469238,
-0.01760994642972946,
0.08919911086559296,
0.7603591680526733,
0.15011288225650787,
-0.843972384929657,
-0.4013812839984894,
-0.2323395162820816,
0.12465155124664307,
0.041230667382478714,
0.9923060536384583,
-0.5895894169807434,
0.9991020560264587,
0.5648493766784668,
0.6949266195297241,
0.14150795340538025,
0.014438225887715816,
0.8152288794517517,
-0.3951578736305237,
0.14324520528316498,
-0.20011574029922485,
0.4168027341365814,
0.10013668239116669,
-0.21957609057426453,
0.12132934480905533,
0.12919169664382935,
-0.621492326259613,
-0.8840554356575012,
0.20529350638389587,
-1.0894501209259033,
-0.1554233431816101,
1.100927472114563,
-0.050587840378284454,
-0.018097544088959694,
-0.3708634674549103,
-0.5562554597854614,
-0.02982143685221672,
-0.6127517819404602,
0.943483829498291,
0.5385277271270752,
0.124323271214962,
-0.14394216239452362,
-0.21838508546352386,
0.31689247488975525,
0.5458606481552124,
-0.5708727240562439,
0.35124269127845764,
0.32479727268218994,
0.6244452595710754,
-0.08023399114608765,
0.7240762114524841,
-0.05070601403713226,
0.0776108130812645,
-0.6602470278739929,
0.07331787794828415,
0.061480820178985596,
-0.3727535009384155,
-0.31805574893951416,
0.24564069509506226,
0.5172610282897949,
-0.20946243405342102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12109v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12109v1
|
Linguistic Structure from a Bottleneck on Sequential Information Processing
| 2024-05-20T15:25:18 | 2024-05-20T15:25:18 |
Richard Futrell, Michael Hahn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT
|
Human language is a unique form of communication in the natural world,
distinguished by its structured nature. Most fundamentally, it is systematic,
meaning that signals can be broken down into component parts that are
individually meaningful -- roughly, words -- which are combined in a regular
way to form sentences. Furthermore, the way in which these parts are combined
maintains a kind of locality: words are usually concatenated together, and they
form contiguous phrases, keeping related parts of sentences close to each
other. We address the challenge of understanding how these basic properties of
language arise from broader principles of efficient communication under
information processing constraints. Here we show that natural-language-like
systematicity arises from minimization of excess entropy, a measure of
statistical complexity that represents the minimum amount of information
necessary for predicting the future of a sequence based on its past. In
simulations, we show that codes that minimize excess entropy factorize their
source distributions into approximately independent components, and then
express those components systematically and locally. Next, in a series of
massively cross-linguistic corpus studies, we show that human languages are
structured to have low excess entropy at the level of phonology, morphology,
syntax, and semantics. Our result suggests that human language performs a
sequential generalization of Independent Components Analysis on the statistical
distribution over meanings that need to be expressed. It establishes a link
between the statistical and algebraic structure of human language, and
reinforces the idea that the structure of human language may have evolved to
minimize cognitive load while maximizing communicative expressiveness.
|
[
-0.3939301669597626,
-0.9687525033950806,
0.43652817606925964,
0.36187654733657837,
-0.22881408035755157,
0.07321783900260925,
-0.4719613194465637,
-0.6167690753936768,
0.21191023290157318,
0.2773323953151703,
-0.4138571619987488,
-0.2232457399368286,
-0.36389651894569397,
0.12182491272687912,
-0.3808196485042572,
0.8335973024368286,
0.21599777042865753,
-0.22081701457500458,
0.0204085074365139,
-0.20800967514514923,
-0.19494961202144623,
-0.5824378132820129,
-0.4399932622909546,
-0.47793301939964294,
0.27630674839019775,
0.3714585602283478,
0.923382043838501,
1.0155587196350098,
0.5213786363601685,
0.4364076256752014,
-0.09984356164932251,
-0.31395119428634644,
-0.44003304839134216,
0.3916447162628174,
-0.01679109036922455,
-0.7635858058929443,
0.04446236044168472,
-0.33959531784057617,
0.9037817120552063,
1.4000797271728516,
-0.27102330327033997,
0.13356545567512512,
0.2452268749475479,
0.9952727556228638,
-0.5361747145652771,
0.28315767645835876,
-0.4558371305465698,
-0.16246925294399261,
-0.6162309050559998,
-0.36530283093452454,
-0.029670443385839462,
-0.23688551783561707,
0.22457775473594666,
-0.33939826488494873,
0.3842207193374634,
0.004445360042154789,
0.6163274645805359,
0.38317471742630005,
-0.09319796413183212,
-0.42924603819847107,
-0.7498707175254822,
0.6292384266853333,
-0.09691745787858963,
0.4147323668003082,
0.4041844308376312,
-0.0764935091137886,
-0.3185499310493469,
-0.24090318381786346,
-0.4626048803329468,
-0.19559639692306519,
-0.09562691301107407,
-0.24305514991283417,
-0.1961599737405777,
0.1856604963541031,
0.15484891831874847,
0.2709727883338928,
-0.9278828501701355,
-0.04819301888346672,
-0.5184258818626404,
-0.19260044395923615,
0.5117489099502563,
0.23222002387046814,
0.5928726196289062,
-0.06844837218523026,
-0.25527918338775635,
-0.001285424456000328,
-0.5251744985580444,
0.00626136502251029,
0.3652781546115875,
0.20472931861877441,
-0.1359543800354004,
0.4222111105918884,
-0.5219444036483765,
0.5268720984458923,
-0.25021594762802124,
0.039010580629110336,
0.17361325025558472,
-0.48310765624046326,
-0.1387391835451126,
0.019930405542254448,
0.9004725217819214,
-0.03485677391290665,
0.38502037525177,
-0.30288466811180115,
0.17458702623844147,
0.28421908617019653,
0.19794735312461853,
-0.4068338871002197,
-0.4374638497829437,
0.2710006535053253,
-0.3796648383140564,
-0.17174619436264038,
-0.05887410789728165,
-0.5109729766845703,
-0.0842875987291336,
-0.35380932688713074,
-0.16013260185718536,
-0.4619028568267822,
-0.06359686702489853,
0.009700791910290718,
-0.2342556118965149,
-0.028371253982186317,
-0.027514908462762833,
-1.1176317930221558,
0.7282735109329224,
0.6924949288368225,
0.9530405402183533,
-0.11769523471593857,
-0.32948338985443115,
0.031065035611391068,
0.022690506651997566,
-0.5039715766906738,
0.753602921962738,
-0.5314334034919739,
-0.04891679435968399,
-0.38495907187461853,
-0.33633461594581604,
0.34258371591567993,
-0.5273561477661133,
0.4451485872268677,
-0.44593116641044617,
-0.0029413977172225714,
-0.12576018273830414,
-0.2839069068431854,
0.060667652636766434,
-0.3073576092720032,
-0.7070597410202026,
0.7678093910217285,
-0.22476284205913544,
-0.9223857522010803,
0.3965465724468231,
-0.41717174649238586,
-0.7133169174194336,
0.2895422577857971,
-0.3379356861114502,
0.0423806868493557,
0.39886337518692017,
-0.3365911841392517,
0.12983526289463043,
-0.4319663345813751,
0.11844801157712936,
-0.1671660840511322,
-0.3252553641796112,
0.29928383231163025,
-0.2730204463005066,
0.6010046005249023,
0.5510989427566528,
-0.2519899606704712,
-0.13788147270679474,
-0.9574494361877441,
0.1965947449207306,
0.005729404743760824,
-0.4853898286819458,
-0.7625342011451721,
0.1698722541332245,
-0.16105766594409943,
0.033521901816129684,
0.26936137676239014,
-0.22991473972797394,
0.331264853477478,
-0.5782497525215149,
0.5200440883636475,
0.6023542284965515,
-0.04741273075342178,
1.000050663948059,
-0.20980466902256012,
0.20833244919776917,
-0.05590815469622612,
-0.047973304986953735,
-0.16447830200195312,
-0.549519956111908,
-0.5742654800415039,
-0.22062085568904877,
-0.13245756924152374,
0.8173373937606812,
-0.4366660416126251,
0.6334866881370544,
-0.3210300803184509,
-0.2155831754207611,
-0.29436179995536804,
0.43211111426353455,
0.32615983486175537,
0.23569472134113312,
0.07630783319473267,
-0.7114384770393372,
-0.7634431719779968,
-1.0295178890228271,
-0.2961581349372864,
-0.38132572174072266,
-0.15849992632865906,
-0.3678168058395386,
0.2500123083591461,
-0.05923166498541832,
0.8333712220191956,
-0.6249810457229614,
0.19244179129600525,
-0.3287300765514374,
0.5532953143119812,
0.34040367603302,
0.4821447432041168,
0.009798417799174786,
-0.5927203893661499,
-0.23818759620189667,
0.02268647588789463,
-0.7744834423065186,
-0.2248542755842209,
-0.24816052615642548,
-0.23170886933803558,
0.06128794327378273,
0.2851606607437134,
-0.8017299771308899,
0.30055153369903564,
0.09208867698907852,
-0.16260887682437897,
0.23102782666683197,
-0.23798231780529022,
-0.23841917514801025,
-0.5827045440673828,
0.07977090775966644,
-0.11025848984718323,
-0.013143518939614296,
-0.9871862530708313,
0.10854724794626236,
-0.31672796607017517,
0.008406280539929867,
0.1139293983578682,
0.34375080466270447,
-0.5968192219734192,
0.011075406335294247,
-0.522293210029602,
-0.059976380318403244,
-0.3478758633136749,
0.651172935962677,
0.063448466360569,
0.2558853328227997,
0.6051437854766846,
-0.6830878853797913,
0.21019500494003296,
-0.22733935713768005,
-0.4444717764854431,
0.4642742872238159,
-0.5909550786018372,
0.03629613295197487,
-0.6553936004638672,
0.025780143216252327,
-0.8839911222457886,
-0.3861589729785919,
0.17574185132980347,
-0.4672674238681793,
0.37118664383888245,
0.22732879221439362,
-0.48770466446876526,
-0.13298940658569336,
-0.2055627703666687,
0.7014439702033997,
0.574494481086731,
0.12061532586812973,
-0.07086873799562454,
0.6389486193656921,
-0.3610948622226715,
-0.4673212170600891,
-0.8798468708992004,
0.06099972873926163,
-0.12820595502853394,
-0.9581484198570251,
0.1161780133843422,
-0.12392130494117737,
-0.7747142910957336,
-0.02178368903696537,
-0.18879514932632446,
-0.5325024127960205,
0.19022315740585327,
0.1558918058872223,
-0.005408068653196096,
-0.16242007911205292,
0.3493920564651489,
-0.23800960183143616,
0.030394604429602623,
-0.04001300781965256,
-0.5809624791145325,
0.6349401473999023,
-0.1925051212310791,
0.1576893925666809,
-0.46024641394615173,
0.6965456604957581,
0.37984713912010193,
0.3976204991340637,
0.6603940725326538,
0.24295549094676971,
-0.35877519845962524,
-0.21831689774990082,
-0.5001749992370605,
-0.15936027467250824,
-0.4176238775253296,
0.511512041091919,
-0.48224928975105286,
-0.8620733618736267,
0.5725588202476501,
0.3614708483219147,
-0.23929481208324432,
0.3735622763633728,
0.6118088960647583,
-0.21239136159420013,
0.6008867025375366,
0.708369791507721,
-0.2240970879793167,
0.4997204542160034,
0.0759342759847641,
0.06626222282648087,
-0.3759448826313019,
-0.038549937307834625,
-0.6244228482246399,
-0.2509598433971405,
-0.8097505569458008,
-0.3605649471282959,
0.16891823709011078,
0.48103854060173035,
-0.30792608857154846,
0.37219104170799255,
-0.5033262372016907,
0.6248311400413513,
0.6388624906539917,
-0.05341114476323128,
0.27362266182899475,
0.05811017006635666,
-0.074541836977005,
0.021273983642458916,
-0.8034192323684692,
-0.3302084505558014,
0.7004743218421936,
0.2740619480609894,
1.0152790546417236,
0.05818932130932808,
0.798629641532898,
0.1616000235080719,
-0.10385680943727493,
-0.6303397417068481,
0.37749984860420227,
-0.016608893871307373,
-0.39455342292785645,
-0.5508981347084045,
-0.7723842859268188,
-1.1311265230178833,
0.4004799723625183,
0.07138017565011978,
-1.0190393924713135,
0.3471492528915405,
0.15201689302921295,
-0.05917508900165558,
-0.1620028018951416,
-0.9832970499992371,
0.6122549176216125,
-0.274503618478775,
-0.34696364402770996,
-0.1617840677499771,
-1.0154755115509033,
0.5896397233009338,
0.013373473659157753,
0.6446148753166199,
-0.01823977380990982,
-0.17216922342777252,
0.5778476595878601,
-0.6630122661590576,
0.8697130084037781,
0.2842680811882019,
0.06032430753111839,
0.4518500566482544,
0.1119513064622879,
0.2585054636001587,
-0.12177535891532898,
0.4064929783344269,
0.14071998000144958,
-0.03996174409985542,
-0.6077357530593872,
-0.590846836566925,
0.3267131447792053,
-0.6129308938980103,
-0.2518821656703949,
-0.4158511161804199,
-0.36586442589759827,
0.043981168419122696,
0.2854251563549042,
0.4942720830440521,
0.4403371810913086,
-0.14528368413448334,
-0.02349052019417286,
0.5913078188896179,
-0.11157781630754471,
0.38894757628440857,
0.17461998760700226,
0.18983867764472961,
-0.1511337161064148,
0.8535235524177551,
0.15981407463550568,
0.40680280327796936,
0.716508150100708,
0.34643465280532837,
-0.05900924280285835,
-0.37541109323501587,
0.1710517853498459,
0.1403488963842392,
-0.8179259896278381,
0.09043332189321518,
-0.4976862072944641,
0.010657528415322304,
-0.3435656428337097,
0.03754929080605507,
-0.30699238181114197,
-0.5956996083259583,
0.12418711930513382,
0.07214850187301636,
-0.06333380192518234,
0.9447238445281982,
-0.4159063696861267,
0.2358272671699524,
-0.705406904220581,
0.4449491500854492,
0.1337173879146576,
0.3227385878562927,
0.1589202731847763,
-0.030219048261642456,
-0.2668890357017517,
-0.18698857724666595,
-0.16894161701202393,
-0.7845335602760315,
0.1870671659708023,
0.4315582513809204,
0.5543993711471558,
0.36256110668182373,
-0.12405060976743698,
0.7383291125297546,
-0.6633532047271729,
0.5639068484306335,
0.3872658312320709,
-0.9288866519927979,
0.4026724100112915,
-0.14075680077075958,
0.7557396292686462,
0.540868878364563,
0.2738165259361267,
-0.6922826766967773,
-0.8075661063194275,
-0.543269693851471,
-0.9985030293464661,
0.3983665108680725,
0.45051485300064087,
0.007470243144780397,
-0.2864738404750824,
0.28727102279663086,
-0.06557337939739227,
0.11779298633337021,
-0.6139795780181885,
-0.2664755582809448,
0.229599267244339,
-0.2487385869026184,
0.15266026556491852,
-0.28433337807655334,
-0.20505444705486298,
-0.16001416742801666,
0.028157571330666542,
0.10476170480251312,
0.4462341368198395,
0.2229861617088318,
-0.3441489338874817,
-0.06655984371900558,
0.5998633503913879,
0.9330750703811646,
0.6030589938163757,
-0.06894542276859283,
0.4176572263240814,
-0.1325497031211853,
-0.7079201936721802,
0.11552342027425766,
-0.2815578877925873,
-0.008928251452744007,
-0.06972234696149826,
0.8178744316101074,
0.6128321886062622,
0.3899402916431427,
-0.42572882771492004,
0.11455901712179184,
0.036134395748376846,
0.21919448673725128,
-0.27747654914855957,
-0.08556324243545532,
-0.08344630897045135,
0.26841750741004944,
0.6270220875740051,
0.4423673152923584,
0.3650084435939789,
-1.07955002784729,
0.34555158019065857,
0.4377536475658417,
0.03572211414575577,
-0.6273359656333923,
0.44516924023628235,
0.05120811238884926,
-0.05963576212525368,
0.5236414670944214,
-0.2433040738105774,
-0.48749998211860657,
0.3568447530269623,
0.2795253396034241,
0.9909752011299133,
-0.02144351415336132,
-0.08818290382623672,
0.21711134910583496,
0.6132384538650513,
-0.3730500340461731,
0.4399511516094208,
-0.5441040992736816,
-0.7867534160614014,
-0.4935451149940491,
-0.8043491244316101,
-0.022635485976934433,
-0.3815763294696808,
-0.3809256851673126,
0.023773198947310448,
-0.3378911316394806,
-0.09412588179111481,
0.045585259795188904,
-0.19224637746810913,
-0.642291784286499,
0.03886909410357475,
0.33384689688682556,
0.6526549458503723,
-0.6474862098693848,
0.8108289241790771,
0.15968045592308044,
-0.3607247471809387,
-0.5560492873191833,
-0.041917990893125534,
0.19312942028045654,
-0.7523627877235413,
0.9815925359725952,
0.02095446176826954,
-0.22160789370536804,
-0.43213531374931335,
-0.6605455279350281,
-1.0671772956848145,
0.5249208211898804,
0.30528488755226135,
-0.580001711845398,
-0.25945454835891724,
0.12101386487483978,
0.8075426816940308,
-0.11470481008291245,
0.000986930332146585,
0.6609786748886108,
0.2585470676422119,
0.2880052328109741,
-0.8901797533035278,
0.23638398945331573,
-0.29809290170669556,
0.09423843771219254,
0.5759829878807068,
-0.3098089396953583,
0.8499918580055237,
-0.19240936636924744,
-0.783380389213562,
0.13343288004398346,
0.5609674453735352,
-0.13273106515407562,
-0.01455592829734087,
0.25404658913612366,
0.528445839881897,
0.9735275506973267,
-0.09291157871484756,
1.1955832242965698,
-0.27723053097724915,
0.046633265912532806,
1.0969475507736206,
0.1062224805355072,
0.7720558643341064,
0.39380761981010437,
-0.30946478247642517,
0.438632071018219,
0.25624924898147583,
0.44261226058006287,
0.5972683429718018,
0.6498748064041138,
-0.14937034249305725,
0.10018837451934814,
0.09734828770160675,
-0.15040245652198792,
0.4589840769767761,
0.4377744793891907,
-0.2576594948768616,
-0.08434803038835526,
-0.15034569799900055,
-0.07586314529180527,
-0.14483623206615448,
-0.21739035844802856,
0.9262350797653198,
0.1857864409685135,
-0.6989181637763977,
0.7444291710853577,
-0.24168474972248077,
0.6825494170188904,
-0.6166152954101562,
0.22774817049503326,
-0.1727720946073532,
-0.07695960253477097,
-0.3228543996810913,
-0.7246952056884766,
0.69488924741745,
-0.2069690227508545,
-0.3249334394931793,
-0.11558371037244797,
0.5565192699432373,
-0.6932477355003357,
-0.16897204518318176,
-0.07187920808792114,
0.13131660223007202,
0.4084639251232147,
0.12804420292377472,
-0.2760211229324341,
0.29908499121665955,
-0.3868652880191803,
-0.04061723127961159,
0.24632272124290466,
0.6322129368782043,
-0.23372289538383484,
0.6540915966033936,
0.49214592576026917,
0.5369080305099487,
0.40078964829444885,
-0.03227509930729866,
0.6433405876159668,
-0.8779472708702087,
-0.6929843425750732,
-1.07487154006958,
0.3362388610839844,
-0.08009891211986542,
-0.326185017824173,
0.47752025723457336,
0.4052305221557617,
0.7916931509971619,
0.10081955790519714,
0.8207207322120667,
-0.0859980583190918,
0.06019582599401474,
-0.5417603254318237,
0.41211816668510437,
-0.17646148800849915,
0.19226597249507904,
-0.3042554259300232,
-0.8856886029243469,
-0.5144018530845642,
0.6567640900611877,
-0.04153914004564285,
-0.3460993766784668,
0.9065927863121033,
0.45712313055992126,
0.38709816336631775,
-0.02606218494474888,
0.2006729245185852,
0.2967403829097748,
-0.15499255061149597,
0.5918207168579102,
0.7135616540908813,
-0.018748249858617783,
0.5298359394073486,
-0.32785460352897644,
-0.5017359852790833,
0.0788607969880104,
-0.42587926983833313,
-0.6376866698265076,
-0.870945930480957,
-0.14048929512500763,
-0.03365889936685562,
-0.09905793517827988,
0.8252361416816711,
0.689435601234436,
-0.6620597243309021,
-0.6823408603668213,
-0.45008036494255066,
0.31198978424072266,
-0.15602974593639374,
-0.29810836911201477,
0.03810675069689751,
-0.7343318462371826,
-0.35584452748298645,
0.298697829246521,
0.667154848575592,
-0.11934642493724823,
-0.17065951228141785,
0.1575084626674652,
-0.046980854123830795,
0.13826514780521393,
0.6032894849777222,
0.7092373371124268,
-0.5706807374954224,
-0.21600662171840668,
-0.14718128740787506,
-0.35063424706459045,
0.1455751657485962,
1.1447519063949585,
-0.45615532994270325,
0.578076958656311,
1.0000077486038208,
0.4940376877784729,
0.16708067059516907,
0.0378742553293705,
0.9032154679298401,
-0.9701173305511475,
0.4661603569984436,
0.11848621815443039,
0.28157272934913635,
0.30191051959991455,
-0.3518308103084564,
0.3633671998977661,
0.3161547780036926,
-0.5860644578933716,
-0.6578739881515503,
0.5575200915336609,
-0.8848059773445129,
-0.5162500143051147,
0.6280823349952698,
0.3468092679977417,
-0.5158467888832092,
-0.4676440954208374,
0.18656641244888306,
0.1069459319114685,
-0.4810388684272766,
0.7287094593048096,
0.9403888583183289,
-0.5248542428016663,
-0.22431428730487823,
-0.3426317274570465,
0.6536968350410461,
0.17688141763210297,
-0.6284182667732239,
-0.008640450425446033,
0.3763168454170227,
0.19401921331882477,
0.6214741468429565,
0.9768550395965576,
0.19847255945205688,
0.10978516936302185,
0.15374213457107544,
-0.08754468709230423,
0.7125570178031921,
-0.30752333998680115,
-0.36468183994293213,
0.41362693905830383,
-0.008146570064127445,
-0.14294610917568207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12107v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12107v2
|
Imp: Highly Capable Large Multimodal Models for Mobile Devices
| 2024-05-20T15:23:19 | 2024-05-30T02:47:10 |
Zhenwei Shao, Zhou Yu, Jun Yu, Xuecheng Ouyang, Lihao Zheng, Zhenbiao Gai, Mingyang Wang, Jiajun Ding
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
By harnessing the capabilities of large language models (LLMs), recent large
multimodal models (LMMs) have shown remarkable versatility in open-world
multimodal understanding. Nevertheless, they are usually parameter-heavy and
computation-intensive, thus hindering their applicability in
resource-constrained scenarios. To this end, several lightweight LMMs have been
proposed successively to maximize the capabilities under constrained scale
(e.g., 3B). Despite the encouraging results achieved by these methods, most of
them only focus on one or two aspects of the design space, and the key design
choices that influence model capability have not yet been thoroughly
investigated. In this paper, we conduct a systematic study for lightweight LMMs
from the aspects of model architecture, training strategy, and training data.
Based on our findings, we obtain Imp -- a family of highly capable LMMs at the
2B-4B scales. Notably, our Imp-3B model steadily outperforms all the existing
lightweight LMMs of similar size, and even surpasses the state-of-the-art LMMs
at the 13B scale. With low-bit quantization and resolution reduction
techniques, our Imp model can be deployed on a Qualcomm Snapdragon 8Gen3 mobile
chip with a high inference speed of about 13 tokens/s.
|
[
-0.5435915589332581,
-0.28212863206863403,
0.5055790543556213,
0.36976924538612366,
-0.3392623960971832,
0.0023676424752920866,
-0.2918176054954529,
-0.7540673017501831,
-0.019625019282102585,
0.08502998948097229,
-0.3370480239391327,
0.06484208256006241,
-0.44941550493240356,
0.11491630971431732,
-0.15919744968414307,
0.5197131633758545,
-0.10305462777614594,
0.11803125590085983,
-0.039450958371162415,
-0.4677204191684723,
-0.585023820400238,
-0.15083573758602142,
-0.12054704874753952,
-0.18550117313861847,
0.7067118883132935,
0.7051432728767395,
0.8490670919418335,
0.5860445499420166,
0.6854912042617798,
0.18382656574249268,
-0.09766720235347748,
0.2017262578010559,
-0.42435696721076965,
0.08377673476934433,
-0.13671723008155823,
-0.3700382709503174,
-0.5304583311080933,
-0.12843288481235504,
0.6799582242965698,
0.6066451668739319,
0.17121639847755432,
0.30095118284225464,
0.18033689260482788,
0.2746010720729828,
-0.6137390732765198,
-0.06399485468864441,
-0.7177899479866028,
-0.25198352336883545,
-0.1589110940694809,
0.24755531549453735,
-0.6605584025382996,
0.011286744847893715,
-0.03466181457042694,
-0.30577078461647034,
-0.09584897756576538,
0.3607080578804016,
0.6474501490592957,
0.13649281859397888,
-0.7722753286361694,
-0.07752934098243713,
-1.0054121017456055,
0.8284949064254761,
-0.7858302593231201,
0.7053272128105164,
0.28247490525245667,
0.24211327731609344,
0.05418727546930313,
-0.6932097673416138,
-0.5627578496932983,
-0.3561418056488037,
0.21902427077293396,
-0.18370404839515686,
0.010520024225115776,
0.1385376900434494,
0.2120000720024109,
0.40917524695396423,
-0.5331379771232605,
0.3483015298843384,
-0.47989487648010254,
-0.2000933289527893,
0.4210977852344513,
0.2553658187389374,
0.26306119561195374,
-0.17313840985298157,
-0.5821414589881897,
0.2927342653274536,
-1.0208332538604736,
0.17099548876285553,
0.09509692341089249,
0.2898683249950409,
-0.4042471945285797,
0.6147855520248413,
-0.1813421994447708,
0.7920993566513062,
-0.22237811982631683,
-0.7242140173912048,
0.12350814044475555,
-0.6148551106452942,
0.11092013120651245,
-0.17863821983337402,
0.6616935133934021,
0.3935391306877136,
-0.22288650274276733,
0.009065210819244385,
-0.4615277945995331,
-0.2957225441932678,
0.08334487676620483,
-1.1501015424728394,
0.30811378359794617,
0.17175184190273285,
-0.9639648199081421,
0.1939665526151657,
-0.49773627519607544,
-0.404543399810791,
-0.5529630780220032,
-0.20668330788612366,
0.8267863392829895,
-0.5795992612838745,
-0.3443436324596405,
-0.041631173342466354,
0.005461967550218105,
0.07132816314697266,
0.3294942378997803,
-1.0696574449539185,
0.06652161478996277,
0.21322329342365265,
1.026589274406433,
-0.0802251324057579,
-0.1163887158036232,
-0.05113830789923668,
0.25575074553489685,
-0.19992214441299438,
0.5130284428596497,
-0.4614553153514862,
-0.4811305105686188,
-0.4262748062610626,
-0.23080889880657196,
-0.019506024196743965,
-0.24847054481506348,
0.7149483561515808,
-0.3919956386089325,
-0.46535778045654297,
-0.008315283805131912,
-0.16780473291873932,
-0.6062722206115723,
0.11975686997175217,
-0.7549904584884644,
0.6445661783218384,
0.265373170375824,
-0.6897458434104919,
0.4093959629535675,
-0.19018937647342682,
-0.4497219920158386,
0.12560796737670898,
0.08884046226739883,
-0.22888682782649994,
0.4851134717464447,
-0.017977146431803703,
0.6973878145217896,
-0.738277792930603,
0.003955173306167126,
-0.7169099450111389,
-0.5603376030921936,
0.22949567437171936,
-0.592806875705719,
0.43727385997772217,
0.5774944424629211,
-0.07082906365394592,
0.09373047202825546,
-0.8648214936256409,
-0.08342323452234268,
-0.05202837288379669,
-0.39426231384277344,
-0.3029737174510956,
0.06868795305490494,
0.017176052555441856,
0.4195176959037781,
0.3089357614517212,
-0.5787016749382019,
0.011544991284608841,
-0.15117688477039337,
0.8205394148826599,
0.41200217604637146,
-0.46284469962120056,
0.4990299642086029,
-0.24015924334526062,
0.415576308965683,
-0.18935412168502808,
0.36066949367523193,
-0.5856465697288513,
-0.36663687229156494,
-0.5867836475372314,
-0.8781563639640808,
0.40733134746551514,
0.2860262989997864,
-0.76987224817276,
-0.14184486865997314,
-0.3673049807548523,
-0.6586702466011047,
-0.27862977981567383,
0.34668511152267456,
0.2234012335538864,
0.28457456827163696,
0.16577188670635223,
0.04710220918059349,
-0.349936842918396,
-1.2665729522705078,
0.08558353781700134,
-0.03782885894179344,
0.02607959881424904,
0.5688186287879944,
0.5010392665863037,
-0.22550956904888153,
0.8204519748687744,
-0.0886751189827919,
0.05453656613826752,
-0.7638192176818848,
-0.03610789030790329,
0.05771157145500183,
0.4553646743297577,
0.6148378252983093,
-0.8467428088188171,
-0.2774202823638916,
0.16074663400650024,
-0.6103339791297913,
0.15337063372135162,
-0.11495079100131989,
0.45746102929115295,
-0.11018823832273483,
0.2537749409675598,
-0.9162458181381226,
0.3698558807373047,
0.5762653350830078,
0.007176756393164396,
0.38581427931785583,
-0.2872858941555023,
-0.15603764355182648,
-1.0330283641815186,
-0.03824969008564949,
0.16741779446601868,
-0.229353129863739,
-0.4741758108139038,
0.20289358496665955,
0.6652585864067078,
-0.256799578666687,
-0.6866767406463623,
0.7303034663200378,
-0.5969533324241638,
-0.1832776814699173,
-0.4381718635559082,
-0.1777256578207016,
0.02346584014594555,
0.4510033428668976,
-0.14763939380645752,
0.8390406370162964,
0.3716605603694916,
-0.804267942905426,
0.3216121792793274,
-0.1090565174818039,
-0.532794177532196,
0.5185508131980896,
-0.7527432441711426,
-0.26776063442230225,
-0.01139054261147976,
0.34165897965431213,
-1.118038296699524,
-0.5473484992980957,
-0.16492193937301636,
-0.18650978803634644,
0.34506645798683167,
-0.06052033230662346,
-0.6151015162467957,
-0.6234428882598877,
-0.416012167930603,
0.8755537867546082,
0.28554320335388184,
-0.4701225161552429,
1.1124787330627441,
0.29923003911972046,
-0.21700915694236755,
-0.435915470123291,
-0.5799647569656372,
-0.007893200032413006,
-0.3579332232475281,
-0.8029360771179199,
0.44446122646331787,
-0.01125762052834034,
-0.0007070040446706116,
-0.34075579047203064,
-0.05800722911953926,
-0.016739463433623314,
-0.013549472205340862,
0.48657262325286865,
0.4115847945213318,
-0.24598947167396545,
0.23707911372184753,
-0.03605734556913376,
0.08091026544570923,
-0.45947203040122986,
0.15369246900081635,
0.532501220703125,
-0.18523557484149933,
-0.29288429021835327,
-0.6151610016822815,
0.11734223365783691,
0.9558480978012085,
-0.47573986649513245,
0.6085997223854065,
0.6308646202087402,
-0.36449122428894043,
-0.2692156136035919,
-0.563134491443634,
-0.00970443431288004,
-0.49607279896736145,
0.4400794208049774,
-0.6532696485519409,
-0.8866886496543884,
0.5935691595077515,
-0.24864672124385834,
0.009276045486330986,
0.08487497270107269,
0.712921142578125,
0.12593159079551697,
1.2288731336593628,
0.6472314596176147,
0.17743638157844543,
0.35347217321395874,
0.06494417041540146,
0.26091164350509644,
-1.0530978441238403,
-0.3204404413700104,
-0.4898408055305481,
-0.5344719886779785,
-0.5944051146507263,
-0.40638789534568787,
0.556937575340271,
-0.11409490555524826,
-0.3827831447124481,
0.4513367712497711,
-0.028741242364048958,
0.16384167969226837,
0.5910645127296448,
0.31263723969459534,
0.11633694171905518,
-0.32506483793258667,
-0.23279961943626404,
0.1316390484571457,
-0.7652029991149902,
-0.31297823786735535,
1.2268667221069336,
0.6364274024963379,
1.2480847835540771,
0.2175307422876358,
-0.034653376787900925,
-0.05268651619553566,
0.0319826677441597,
-0.8975325226783752,
0.643618106842041,
-0.13276398181915283,
-0.7374120354652405,
0.003967892844229937,
-0.44686979055404663,
-0.4197257161140442,
0.4294847846031189,
-0.3022650480270386,
-0.6544027328491211,
0.3148408532142639,
0.04066639393568039,
-0.7313995957374573,
0.32242605090141296,
-1.0666528940200806,
0.6316052675247192,
-0.40937280654907227,
-0.7956010699272156,
-0.3926279842853546,
-0.624553382396698,
0.7651928663253784,
-0.23913486301898956,
0.3260180652141571,
-0.34075379371643066,
-0.2280498892068863,
0.3531038463115692,
-0.2521519660949707,
0.6540804505348206,
-0.046065814793109894,
-0.1900404393672943,
0.4574299454689026,
0.14856381714344025,
0.42305684089660645,
0.17671193182468414,
-0.09201472997665405,
-0.03948475420475006,
-0.1816449761390686,
-0.14326296746730804,
-0.4159821569919586,
0.8112413287162781,
-0.6975575685501099,
-0.37265610694885254,
0.06113351136445999,
-0.9313409328460693,
-0.40726596117019653,
0.34217190742492676,
0.05373980477452278,
0.9529551267623901,
0.16308914124965668,
0.7839164137840271,
0.6877027750015259,
-0.3922153413295746,
0.9078434109687805,
0.35923486948013306,
-0.2927379906177521,
-0.22646328806877136,
1.1787872314453125,
0.3517646789550781,
0.35580533742904663,
0.3598894476890564,
-0.026134174317121506,
-0.4582854211330414,
-0.7459193468093872,
-0.6624754667282104,
0.0449911393225193,
-0.3630874752998352,
-0.3540077209472656,
-0.5098084807395935,
-0.11620791256427765,
-0.1789351999759674,
0.08926055580377579,
-0.6201396584510803,
-0.630823016166687,
-0.1795405000448227,
0.05079437419772148,
0.07756547629833221,
0.5872769951820374,
-0.04823312535881996,
0.7790636420249939,
-0.690555214881897,
0.5807411074638367,
0.4423002600669861,
0.6292386651039124,
0.2588091492652893,
-0.6861207485198975,
-0.42236417531967163,
0.010918465442955494,
-0.3916323781013489,
-0.43402668833732605,
0.15082477033138275,
0.12613165378570557,
0.3432464897632599,
0.6727743148803711,
-0.11828824132680893,
0.4715818762779236,
-0.429411381483078,
0.6737351417541504,
0.2480861097574234,
-0.7604020237922668,
0.12290703505277634,
-0.6105258464813232,
0.4090174734592438,
0.32252800464630127,
0.41866543889045715,
-0.12407446652650833,
0.08324459195137024,
-0.23316970467567444,
-0.7538531422615051,
0.688822865486145,
0.039552055299282074,
0.38558343052864075,
0.4295264184474945,
0.2313854694366455,
0.33007171750068665,
0.19296768307685852,
-0.8051526546478271,
0.09827710688114166,
-0.1296251118183136,
-0.29014068841934204,
0.2591572105884552,
-0.6419534683227539,
0.3006936311721802,
-0.2303130030632019,
0.42376723885536194,
0.023410441353917122,
0.06607375293970108,
-0.16611023247241974,
-0.1505586802959442,
0.31502577662467957,
0.12258400022983551,
0.9174032211303711,
0.8328462243080139,
-0.3582737147808075,
0.45162519812583923,
0.18378375470638275,
-0.5282366871833801,
0.3020383417606354,
-0.08696460723876953,
0.05782172083854675,
-0.2422753870487213,
0.2121697962284088,
0.9309443831443787,
0.38732588291168213,
-0.8743104338645935,
0.5087682604789734,
-0.09251613914966583,
0.09946288168430328,
0.07348111271858215,
-0.01280236430466175,
0.07271793484687805,
0.26377642154693604,
0.4036782681941986,
0.20325839519500732,
0.04660638049244881,
-0.5179269313812256,
0.04057588428258896,
0.6558514833450317,
-0.21464373171329498,
-0.464569091796875,
0.8327524065971375,
0.5522419214248657,
0.05039246380329132,
0.3665774464607239,
-0.10423948615789413,
-0.13622267544269562,
0.31177079677581787,
0.6421002745628357,
0.3992096483707428,
-0.4318447709083557,
-0.028208507224917412,
0.3923400640487671,
0.4568960964679718,
-0.26241666078567505,
0.13106955587863922,
-0.06963132321834564,
-0.7326951622962952,
-0.6063392758369446,
-0.46908891201019287,
-0.35880059003829956,
0.14154966175556183,
-0.31075233221054077,
0.4583350718021393,
-0.5518537759780884,
-0.41017064452171326,
-0.12287794053554535,
-0.33912476897239685,
-0.4495033323764801,
0.3283001780509949,
0.3937196135520935,
0.9248765110969543,
-0.16727347671985626,
0.8441982865333557,
0.4218616485595703,
-0.25570541620254517,
-0.9763815402984619,
-0.4289834797382355,
-0.08458857983350754,
-0.8043080568313599,
0.6635960340499878,
0.36387160420417786,
-0.24719832837581635,
-0.10344058275222778,
-0.5094730854034424,
-0.9573017954826355,
1.0824402570724487,
0.4699278771877289,
-0.49011847376823425,
-0.12670020759105682,
0.07966411858797073,
0.0164675060659647,
-0.2828245460987091,
0.6386420130729675,
0.2379559576511383,
0.27681636810302734,
0.11741829663515091,
-1.3500175476074219,
-0.016298804432153702,
-0.14030899107456207,
0.22031985223293304,
0.0740918517112732,
-1.2244071960449219,
1.1565649509429932,
-0.38060232996940613,
0.01841956004500389,
0.2539955675601959,
0.6779643297195435,
0.2558610141277313,
0.18116021156311035,
0.37656861543655396,
0.4594997465610504,
0.45380741357803345,
0.13323171436786652,
0.8989971876144409,
-0.4639952480792999,
0.09656766802072525,
0.816238284111023,
-0.527924120426178,
0.8263188600540161,
0.26452958583831787,
0.1666443645954132,
0.19771283864974976,
0.6583450436592102,
0.240378737449646,
0.34784844517707825,
-0.005926754325628281,
-0.4550116956233978,
-0.3881240487098694,
-0.313570499420166,
-0.3309767246246338,
0.8215656280517578,
0.5922684073448181,
-0.31802457571029663,
-0.11921627074480057,
0.5173916220664978,
-0.09106545895338058,
-0.3888431489467621,
-0.8052342534065247,
0.23430046439170837,
0.17625990509986877,
-0.2662777006626129,
0.5843722224235535,
0.3743893504142761,
0.7682399153709412,
-0.6910851001739502,
0.13228757679462433,
-0.26000070571899414,
0.30996567010879517,
-0.10003092139959335,
-0.5160496234893799,
-0.1171814575791359,
-0.09131714701652527,
-0.15580272674560547,
-0.14271104335784912,
1.0279114246368408,
0.1006149873137474,
-0.469140887260437,
0.09705609083175659,
0.524540364742279,
-0.26587310433387756,
-0.057912446558475494,
-0.1531846672296524,
0.5413080453872681,
-0.2271055281162262,
-0.14673466980457306,
0.44284331798553467,
0.5285599231719971,
-0.14833006262779236,
1.2099379301071167,
0.2813171446323395,
0.030625294893980026,
0.05837586149573326,
-0.39899131655693054,
0.830987811088562,
-0.7002341151237488,
-0.32966530323028564,
-0.8208081722259521,
0.36803340911865234,
0.2003578394651413,
-0.27946150302886963,
0.8286047577857971,
0.7224456071853638,
0.5248100161552429,
0.02363283559679985,
0.7318422794342041,
-0.18965892493724823,
0.5586640238761902,
-0.40806764364242554,
0.5503831505775452,
-0.7984495759010315,
0.16848662495613098,
0.05646670609712601,
-0.8914011716842651,
-0.16347000002861023,
0.3100232183933258,
-0.11247054487466812,
0.20979712903499603,
0.4835914671421051,
0.6641925573348999,
-0.2758919298648834,
0.22586755454540253,
0.3775580823421478,
0.10981834679841995,
0.10595167428255081,
0.6446686387062073,
0.9177817106246948,
-0.18707479536533356,
0.6899240016937256,
-0.19667372107505798,
-0.2575470209121704,
-0.5815640091896057,
-0.6834843754768372,
-0.8933112621307373,
-0.4962466359138489,
0.2302570343017578,
0.018605012446641922,
-0.40093520283699036,
0.9292417168617249,
1.1108160018920898,
-0.31525811553001404,
-0.29558661580085754,
0.35476380586624146,
0.2817123532295227,
0.059819724410772324,
-0.045200761407613754,
0.10414740443229675,
-0.05870852619409561,
-0.631175696849823,
0.5379049777984619,
0.3573307991027832,
0.2274853140115738,
-0.34630486369132996,
0.027603482827544212,
0.028756335377693176,
0.10655679553747177,
1.0340168476104736,
0.18308894336223602,
-0.46861082315444946,
-0.3183945417404175,
-0.06909149140119553,
-0.1407206505537033,
-0.11189652979373932,
0.9445738792419434,
-0.7203205227851868,
0.3178924024105072,
0.5110821723937988,
0.5410244464874268,
0.2047409564256668,
-0.028377076610922813,
0.5136660933494568,
-0.4662710428237915,
0.57232666015625,
0.11438582837581635,
0.5037333369255066,
0.2136547714471817,
0.09973956644535065,
0.3895781934261322,
0.06382011622190475,
-0.5030568242073059,
-1.1114286184310913,
0.21236826479434967,
-1.1202584505081177,
-0.4300448000431061,
1.3256518840789795,
0.17483516037464142,
-0.2220863699913025,
0.014807549305260181,
-0.3597963750362396,
-0.055330533534288406,
-0.3117716312408447,
0.30801427364349365,
0.606055736541748,
-0.15522506833076477,
-0.4262734651565552,
-0.9664850831031799,
0.1075398400425911,
0.1429818868637085,
-0.4469138979911804,
-0.05421048402786255,
0.31769227981567383,
0.10163949429988861,
0.05736938863992691,
0.39580076932907104,
0.032455284148454666,
0.25649669766426086,
0.1985233724117279,
0.15896295011043549,
-0.19199326634407043,
-0.5835294723510742,
-0.03949405625462532,
0.38227763772010803,
0.35433071851730347,
-0.07472877204418182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12100v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12100v1
|
DOP: Diagnostic-Oriented Prompting for Large Language Models in Mathematical Correction
| 2024-05-20T15:13:22 | 2024-05-20T15:13:22 |
Hao Chen, Biaojie Zeng, Xin Lin, Liang He, Aimin Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Math world problems correction(MWPC) is a novel task dedicated to rectifying
reasoning errors in the process of solving mathematical problems. In this
paper, leveraging the advancements in large language models (LLMs), we address
two key objectives:(1) Distinguishing between mathematical reasoning and error
correction; (2) Exploring strategies to enhance the error correction
capabilities of LLMs in mathematics to solve MWPC task. We noticed that, in
real-time education,assisting students in recognizing their mistakes is more
crucial than simply providing correct answers. However, current research tends
to prioritize obtaining accurate solutions to math problems rather than
correcting potentially incorrect ones. Therefore, we modify the research
paradigm, demonstrating that improving mathematical reasoning abilities does
not equate to mastery in error correction. Meanwhile, we propose a novel method
called diagnostic-oriented promping(DOP) aimed at facilitating LLMs to excel in
error correction. In experiments, DOP has shown outstanding performance,
highlighting its significant impact. We argue that in mathematical education,
the demand for outstanding correctors surpasses that for proficient reasoners.
Codes and data are available on
https://github.com/ChenhaoEcnuCS/Reason-Correct.
|
[
-0.031050818040966988,
-0.9110857844352722,
0.7718055844306946,
0.5340207815170288,
0.06719304621219635,
0.061187371611595154,
-0.18080827593803406,
-0.20868776738643646,
-0.16837084293365479,
0.21599696576595306,
-0.5781843066215515,
-0.21908260881900787,
-0.5637013912200928,
0.10979457944631577,
-0.018536366522312164,
0.6246686577796936,
-0.1442977637052536,
0.3968132734298706,
-0.42995354533195496,
0.2542603611946106,
-0.6875731945037842,
-0.48665446043014526,
-1.1435682773590088,
-0.30677667260169983,
0.37830087542533875,
0.6138688325881958,
0.5962833762168884,
0.5106668472290039,
0.5708112716674805,
0.25090137124061584,
-0.12023358792066574,
0.5359324812889099,
-0.3306575119495392,
0.15324406325817108,
-0.19848985970020294,
-0.6141700744628906,
-0.8579091429710388,
-0.16647447645664215,
0.5040901303291321,
0.9352518916130066,
-0.29101407527923584,
-0.18711130321025848,
0.10558366030454636,
0.6834509372711182,
-0.5839356184005737,
0.2427804172039032,
-0.3132292330265045,
0.18763211369514465,
-0.09883531183004379,
-0.5317161679267883,
-0.6777321696281433,
-0.21562381088733673,
-0.03668565675616264,
-0.5944925546646118,
0.2835350036621094,
-0.1455899029970169,
0.1933046281337738,
0.17102597653865814,
-0.47121620178222656,
-0.1729419231414795,
-0.8311983942985535,
1.0935832262039185,
-0.7777338624000549,
0.2291826754808426,
0.32666441798210144,
0.2642446458339691,
-0.3499308228492737,
-0.510981559753418,
-0.49291595816612244,
0.08559025079011917,
0.36147642135620117,
0.24895192682743073,
-0.30867332220077515,
0.10915164649486542,
0.6625449657440186,
0.19012166559696198,
-0.329640656709671,
0.2487030029296875,
-0.12803342938423157,
-0.26673927903175354,
0.6642731428146362,
0.3744322955608368,
0.40955767035484314,
0.23217646777629852,
0.07405001670122147,
-0.03406009450554848,
-0.8747979998588562,
0.06971568614244461,
-0.06685759127140045,
0.2557402551174164,
-0.1949603110551834,
0.5544690489768982,
-0.08168401569128036,
1.080431580543518,
-0.015149994753301144,
-0.4509744942188263,
-0.062257882207632065,
0.036542680114507675,
-0.04603126272559166,
0.14111639559268951,
0.29766854643821716,
0.3827803134918213,
0.31632906198501587,
0.29110369086265564,
-0.3228166997432709,
0.21490341424942017,
0.17019732296466827,
-0.5376076102256775,
-0.1414911150932312,
0.158371701836586,
-0.3126412630081177,
-0.40221187472343445,
-0.17874769866466522,
-0.7408861517906189,
-0.3638134002685547,
-0.7090400457382202,
0.4423103928565979,
-0.3431650698184967,
-0.057161517441272736,
0.615086555480957,
0.05853249505162239,
-0.03250453248620033,
0.6540735960006714,
-0.8393092155456543,
0.03308034688234329,
0.9379215240478516,
0.9082964658737183,
0.05326588451862335,
-0.17987781763076782,
-0.7310531735420227,
0.10122155398130417,
-0.4581860601902008,
0.8980266451835632,
-0.6289662718772888,
-0.6056802868843079,
0.07259839028120041,
-0.29043734073638916,
0.017145691439509392,
-0.62429279088974,
0.7072988748550415,
-0.19363555312156677,
0.14207424223423004,
-0.5359402894973755,
-0.4180426299571991,
-0.003986000083386898,
0.5116569399833679,
-0.1131509467959404,
0.9946383237838745,
0.013451613485813141,
-0.7780135273933411,
-0.06418106704950333,
-0.7794867753982544,
-0.23512080311775208,
0.11677511036396027,
-0.06947004050016403,
-0.22930219769477844,
0.35484081506729126,
0.5378152132034302,
0.38285601139068604,
-0.3274606168270111,
0.45551443099975586,
-0.22026905417442322,
-0.3019987940788269,
0.2980193495750427,
-0.5121908187866211,
0.8384878039360046,
0.05721859633922577,
-0.3104307949542999,
0.20686398446559906,
-0.9768128395080566,
0.2062283456325531,
0.3683300018310547,
0.003091190941631794,
-0.2816120982170105,
0.22404277324676514,
-0.7204035520553589,
0.30725130438804626,
0.25555431842803955,
-0.5972011685371399,
0.5527178645133972,
-0.36130884289741516,
0.5046995878219604,
1.0331400632858276,
-0.11582647264003754,
-0.05391967296600342,
-0.6499684453010559,
0.8334396481513977,
0.17939245700836182,
0.17795830965042114,
-0.2538157105445862,
-0.6919589042663574,
-0.822504460811615,
-0.26222413778305054,
0.13124892115592957,
0.7873268127441406,
-0.7935342788696289,
0.08448667824268341,
0.1492467224597931,
-0.6493247151374817,
-0.27626699209213257,
-0.36271145939826965,
0.4378926455974579,
1.0996500253677368,
0.36974602937698364,
0.18794246017932892,
-0.8187957406044006,
-0.4360489249229431,
-0.2646643817424774,
-0.18269412219524384,
-0.015275455079972744,
0.34484151005744934,
0.0793549045920372,
-0.1523318588733673,
0.7101929187774658,
-0.858689546585083,
-0.3223973214626312,
-0.30349087715148926,
-0.23989953100681305,
0.4109525680541992,
0.32858040928840637,
0.39644718170166016,
-0.5006446838378906,
-0.5235376358032227,
-0.22668403387069702,
-0.6150614619255066,
-0.6176774501800537,
0.11640558391809464,
-0.03874094784259796,
0.17607581615447998,
0.4560268223285675,
-0.18300114572048187,
0.3186279833316803,
0.5289978981018066,
-0.4316008687019348,
0.9778692722320557,
-0.44744613766670227,
0.1162525862455368,
-0.6049330830574036,
-0.1528151035308838,
0.045908357948064804,
-0.15719884634017944,
-0.44330450892448425,
-0.052678048610687256,
-0.01440390944480896,
-0.3116108775138855,
-0.17515040934085846,
0.5087772607803345,
-0.13680540025234222,
0.0908450037240982,
-0.144888237118721,
0.3605461120605469,
-0.03590855374932289,
0.15583309531211853,
-0.02019546926021576,
0.7524658441543579,
0.9290753602981567,
-0.8335451483726501,
0.5726250410079956,
0.18869636952877045,
0.02506355196237564,
0.9023791551589966,
-0.7309141159057617,
0.01103968359529972,
-0.12355422973632812,
0.22765882313251495,
-1.0246440172195435,
0.0023725794162601233,
0.08191003650426865,
-0.4737437963485718,
0.0800878256559372,
-0.07554532587528229,
-0.563607931137085,
-0.5557424426078796,
-0.12329425662755966,
0.48441681265830994,
0.5663402080535889,
-0.9211215376853943,
0.24481350183486938,
0.09873165190219879,
-0.31082478165626526,
-0.7211291193962097,
-0.3896336853504181,
-0.20029810070991516,
0.08534542471170425,
-0.8209426403045654,
0.3222675323486328,
-0.22742660343647003,
-0.4730006158351898,
-0.4669911563396454,
-0.18384197354316711,
0.006610846146941185,
0.039591431617736816,
-0.015781685709953308,
0.5834507346153259,
-0.19692839682102203,
0.2585512101650238,
0.0815131887793541,
-0.5702842473983765,
0.23101462423801422,
-0.463485449552536,
0.6065784692764282,
-0.06192004308104515,
-0.468858003616333,
-0.3837062418460846,
0.19238369166851044,
0.28117647767066956,
-0.33660340309143066,
0.4994470179080963,
0.029545562341809273,
-0.34655940532684326,
-0.4024379849433899,
-0.5315253138542175,
-0.2742057740688324,
-0.4557308852672577,
0.16305510699748993,
-0.33993473649024963,
-0.7186412811279297,
0.38940542936325073,
-0.17241398990154266,
0.22096286714076996,
0.36835357546806335,
0.5395466685295105,
-0.14488570392131805,
1.6498160362243652,
0.5063331127166748,
0.4175436794757843,
0.2070581018924713,
-0.13704119622707367,
0.5154590606689453,
-0.8326323628425598,
-0.320887953042984,
-0.6903772354125977,
-0.27678394317626953,
-0.07872721552848816,
-0.5093806385993958,
0.4111967086791992,
0.07576270401477814,
-0.04889941215515137,
-0.23477284610271454,
-0.655278205871582,
0.49158409237861633,
0.2660785913467407,
0.031485993415117264,
0.48806941509246826,
-0.02636617049574852,
-0.4018520414829254,
-0.7051634788513184,
-0.7492120862007141,
-0.33965128660202026,
0.89473956823349,
0.1860613226890564,
0.5874564051628113,
0.09657923132181168,
0.558051347732544,
-0.08869724720716476,
0.20037837326526642,
-1.0169845819473267,
0.7446317076683044,
-0.19322313368320465,
-0.10457108914852142,
0.012699618004262447,
-0.5496501922607422,
-0.8404905200004578,
0.24717316031455994,
0.06530258804559708,
-0.5290579795837402,
0.04947524517774582,
0.6582328081130981,
-0.06569783389568329,
0.4338945150375366,
-0.4029831886291504,
0.947433590888977,
-0.23806653916835785,
-0.17532317340373993,
-0.3980095386505127,
-0.24024441838264465,
0.262215793132782,
0.015698451548814774,
0.3925201892852783,
0.03785502538084984,
-0.13746415078639984,
0.464632511138916,
-0.5792458057403564,
0.8148597478866577,
-0.4199724793434143,
-0.5067048668861389,
0.15271034836769104,
0.291267454624176,
0.5984310507774353,
0.02044084668159485,
-0.18155434727668762,
-0.05351768061518669,
0.057968560606241226,
-0.30078935623168945,
-0.6538119316101074,
0.6007831692695618,
-0.5272042751312256,
-0.7140606045722961,
-0.5430838465690613,
-0.6801822185516357,
-0.6079038977622986,
0.146315336227417,
0.11873988062143326,
0.8319312334060669,
0.176924929022789,
-0.16980533301830292,
0.8556494116783142,
-0.05189652740955353,
0.4001820683479309,
0.8007476925849915,
-0.5033758282661438,
-0.03578043356537819,
0.9458873271942139,
0.029705816879868507,
0.22738401591777802,
0.387166827917099,
0.6171637773513794,
-0.24748381972312927,
-0.6147855520248413,
-0.24554039537906647,
0.638608992099762,
-0.8119996786117554,
-0.3472638726234436,
-0.5844469666481018,
-0.06690963357686996,
-0.39560458064079285,
-0.5764276385307312,
-0.2144429087638855,
-0.4966316521167755,
-0.254469096660614,
0.24030768871307373,
0.36973026394844055,
0.3876781761646271,
-0.3965159058570862,
0.25456538796424866,
-0.852222204208374,
0.19728542864322662,
0.18674436211585999,
0.2987751364707947,
0.23642417788505554,
-0.7925989627838135,
0.19311779737472534,
0.1821613907814026,
-0.6429498195648193,
-0.6509339809417725,
0.45715662837028503,
0.045106396079063416,
0.4097590744495392,
0.3993169367313385,
0.09097503870725632,
1.023310661315918,
-0.37462660670280457,
0.5581794381141663,
0.21155418455600739,
-1.3313326835632324,
0.8761569261550903,
-0.37664756178855896,
0.36823683977127075,
-0.0667947307229042,
0.2957083284854889,
-1.0551239252090454,
-0.3450991213321686,
-0.773573637008667,
-0.2925262153148651,
0.8400442600250244,
-0.3397369384765625,
-0.06318794190883636,
-0.2840403914451599,
0.5196466445922852,
-0.15024949610233307,
-0.14217089116573334,
-0.4165087342262268,
-0.11496234685182571,
0.1049405038356781,
-0.20451129972934723,
0.08948544412851334,
-0.48889636993408203,
-0.30332422256469727,
-0.2913186252117157,
1.0098365545272827,
-0.3299931287765503,
0.1650758683681488,
0.43997132778167725,
0.16889114677906036,
-0.24714809656143188,
0.42641758918762207,
0.7810841798782349,
1.3281360864639282,
0.17308805882930756,
0.05244247987866402,
0.15346819162368774,
-0.47829005122184753,
0.09547109156847,
-0.0826997458934784,
0.017353925853967667,
-0.11478681117296219,
0.26984941959381104,
0.37140539288520813,
0.1397406905889511,
-1.0008807182312012,
0.624432384967804,
-0.0922810286283493,
-0.18167434632778168,
-0.2696281373500824,
0.007595876231789589,
-0.03920746594667435,
0.04386867955327034,
0.3119167387485504,
0.15237025916576385,
-0.0011563879670575261,
-0.3335316777229309,
-0.0793023332953453,
0.2827785611152649,
-0.2727976143360138,
-0.2210617959499359,
0.5074167847633362,
0.17751239240169525,
-0.49498581886291504,
0.9350984692573547,
-0.13710950314998627,
-0.6273730993270874,
0.7332958579063416,
1.28793203830719,
0.3613503575325012,
-0.39113524556159973,
0.2886900305747986,
0.49429216980934143,
-0.11506134271621704,
-0.3365974724292755,
0.6679427027702332,
0.24017201364040375,
-0.7106384634971619,
-0.9955362677574158,
-0.15460841357707977,
-0.589897632598877,
-0.14262378215789795,
-0.7143277525901794,
0.6252655386924744,
-0.854282796382904,
0.17865654826164246,
-0.006140034180134535,
-0.16859060525894165,
-0.11012422293424606,
0.31168338656425476,
-0.016671136021614075,
0.914237380027771,
-0.5199519991874695,
0.5805587768554688,
0.8406708836555481,
0.26677411794662476,
-0.9827374815940857,
-0.2532028257846832,
0.2934935688972473,
-1.007523775100708,
0.8020643591880798,
0.18151640892028809,
0.033958517014980316,
0.14867480099201202,
-0.533944308757782,
-0.46339741349220276,
0.6872314810752869,
0.4038805365562439,
-1.011927843093872,
0.057820651680231094,
-0.13515612483024597,
0.5657084584236145,
-0.22229452431201935,
0.021441707387566566,
0.27679571509361267,
0.3141806423664093,
0.3541630506515503,
-0.9649556279182434,
-0.022023363038897514,
0.059819191694259644,
-0.18251226842403412,
0.7141375541687012,
-0.3651563227176666,
0.7549830079078674,
-0.7229815125465393,
0.18212221562862396,
-0.1290004700422287,
0.27593812346458435,
0.8054489493370056,
0.46046993136405945,
0.3966066539287567,
0.7060578465461731,
0.7802245020866394,
-0.33475160598754883,
1.0874959230422974,
0.032157402485609055,
0.3045404255390167,
0.7693744897842407,
-0.09059146046638489,
0.7449621558189392,
0.40510720014572144,
-0.5618062019348145,
0.3124576508998871,
0.4303281605243683,
0.05145823210477829,
0.13631951808929443,
0.22104167938232422,
-0.3740353286266327,
-0.5249622464179993,
-0.059258222579956055,
-0.4604156017303467,
0.41850802302360535,
0.6219935417175293,
0.04031667858362198,
-0.2328321486711502,
-0.0012426405446603894,
0.2963150441646576,
0.25081905722618103,
-0.6995956301689148,
0.36101457476615906,
0.14443852007389069,
-0.7801008224487305,
0.4838692843914032,
0.15277500450611115,
0.5487889051437378,
-0.6875821352005005,
-0.3224093019962311,
-0.1787208914756775,
0.5613978505134583,
-0.415640652179718,
-0.6671454906463623,
0.5716588497161865,
-0.16097502410411835,
-0.35520312190055847,
-0.24589857459068298,
0.5854019522666931,
-0.20302481949329376,
-0.6242491006851196,
0.027633341029286385,
0.3637717664241791,
0.055311623960733414,
-0.042583566159009933,
-0.8409828543663025,
0.07706288993358612,
0.23247550427913666,
0.40687325596809387,
0.16789574921131134,
0.4757140576839447,
-0.1503288596868515,
0.8844295740127563,
0.7966142296791077,
0.34721946716308594,
-0.16272948682308197,
0.3784724771976471,
0.48147526383399963,
-0.6536571383476257,
-0.6130725741386414,
-1.0471948385238647,
0.5488294959068298,
0.07207353413105011,
-0.2691364288330078,
0.7915279865264893,
0.2549409568309784,
0.7265215516090393,
-0.09064776450395584,
0.5357098579406738,
-0.005568377207964659,
0.7928355932235718,
-0.48289310932159424,
-0.02661079354584217,
-0.5122460126876831,
0.5628509521484375,
-0.372371643781662,
-0.8849799633026123,
-0.7108773589134216,
0.7931352257728577,
-0.4440765976905823,
-0.08461560308933258,
0.7120089530944824,
0.5448250770568848,
0.07641824334859848,
0.08925840258598328,
0.37376219034194946,
0.38290107250213623,
0.6216538548469543,
0.6588993668556213,
0.9584539532661438,
-0.1280812919139862,
0.41622868180274963,
-0.3994676172733307,
-0.5573412775993347,
-0.3176773488521576,
-0.9993618726730347,
-0.7815658450126648,
-0.22198913991451263,
-0.7033296823501587,
-0.5441693663597107,
-0.10874100774526596,
0.784270703792572,
0.2923641800880432,
-0.5826793909072876,
-0.11358001828193665,
-0.32988083362579346,
0.21960531175136566,
-0.627905011177063,
-0.22200091183185577,
0.2790515124797821,
-0.5774314999580383,
-0.6901280879974365,
0.3862571120262146,
0.49292537569999695,
0.15861138701438904,
-0.16027437150478363,
0.09411116689443588,
0.26690661907196045,
0.02551106922328472,
0.6991541385650635,
0.25866907835006714,
-0.5646520256996155,
-0.13710498809814453,
0.10622859001159668,
0.12275192141532898,
0.18863213062286377,
1.2295496463775635,
-0.6712799072265625,
0.68377685546875,
0.45153579115867615,
0.529594361782074,
0.09503666311502457,
-0.3822660744190216,
0.7320270538330078,
-0.47804537415504456,
0.29745641350746155,
0.43418028950691223,
0.5718321800231934,
0.2824477553367615,
-0.475955992937088,
0.5311347842216492,
0.5041325092315674,
-0.7446523904800415,
-1.1347198486328125,
0.30831143260002136,
-0.9763134121894836,
-0.011487993411719799,
0.7647634744644165,
-0.3336963951587677,
0.052569784224033356,
-0.13005289435386658,
-0.6331079602241516,
-0.09171166270971298,
-0.16825874149799347,
0.9411150813102722,
0.6824098825454712,
-0.3546975553035736,
-0.21535789966583252,
-0.4982737600803375,
0.3477557897567749,
0.8390553593635559,
-0.9010276794433594,
0.24887116253376007,
0.5260247588157654,
0.1520017683506012,
0.06679879873991013,
0.6295737028121948,
-0.5469713807106018,
0.6116095185279846,
-0.11234200745820999,
-0.2962946593761444,
-0.14218337833881378,
-0.23942449688911438,
-0.42284882068634033,
-0.21785220503807068,
0.1939999908208847,
0.18136540055274963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12084v1
|
Distributional Semantics, Holism, and the Instability of Meaning
| 2024-05-20T14:53:25 | 2024-05-20T14:53:25 |
Jumbly Grindrod, J. D. Porter, Nat Hansen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current language models are built on the so-called distributional semantic
approach to linguistic meaning that has the distributional hypothesis at its
core. The distributional hypothesis involves a holistic conception of word
meaning: the meaning of a word depends upon its relations to other words in the
model. A standard objection to meaning holism is the charge of instability: any
change in the meaning properties of a linguistic system (a human speaker, for
example) would lead to many changes or possibly a complete change in the entire
system. When the systems in question are trying to communicate with each other,
it has been argued that instability of this kind makes communication impossible
(Fodor and Lepore 1992, 1996, 1999). In this article, we examine whether the
instability objection poses a problem for distributional models of meaning.
First, we distinguish between distinct forms of instability that these models
could exhibit, and we argue that only one such form is relevant for
understanding the relation between instability and communication: what we call
differential instability. Differential instability is variation in the relative
distances between points in a space, rather than variation in the absolute
position of those points. We distinguish differential and absolute instability
by constructing two of our own models, a toy model constructed from the text of
two novels, and a more sophisticated model constructed using the Word2vec
algorithm from a combination of Wikipedia and SEP articles. We demonstrate the
two forms of instability by showing how these models change as the corpora they
are constructed from increase in size.
|
[
-0.3418959677219391,
-1.203826665878296,
0.4691324830055237,
0.20117561519145966,
-0.3460490107536316,
-0.04026623070240021,
-0.0852702185511589,
-0.5646897554397583,
0.22536587715148926,
0.40066200494766235,
-0.3629915118217468,
-0.1339605301618576,
-1.1720563173294067,
0.07121194899082184,
-0.7176922559738159,
0.9717200398445129,
-0.16012661159038544,
-0.24939686059951782,
-0.21178019046783447,
-0.6352384686470032,
-0.6180725693702698,
-0.5181374549865723,
-0.03392787650227547,
-0.3105636537075043,
0.5148415565490723,
-0.28340065479278564,
1.4086790084838867,
0.6819744110107422,
0.6078823208808899,
0.4238010346889496,
-0.4502285122871399,
-0.25392261147499084,
-0.6894797086715698,
0.7538099884986877,
-0.09611719846725464,
-0.6646168828010559,
-0.23921935260295868,
0.04968022182583809,
0.5814539790153503,
1.0436381101608276,
-0.35434287786483765,
-0.10472555458545685,
-0.03607720509171486,
0.754165530204773,
-0.6086709499359131,
0.007113987114280462,
-0.6229380369186401,
-0.391353040933609,
-0.41486668586730957,
-0.04726843535900116,
-0.23477157950401306,
-0.22132723033428192,
0.512444257736206,
-0.6232005953788757,
0.006239560432732105,
-0.1352490484714508,
1.201100468635559,
0.21214865148067474,
-0.29768526554107666,
-0.8176762461662292,
-0.8149203062057495,
0.4738946557044983,
-0.19949883222579956,
0.30172091722488403,
0.4051985740661621,
0.10025395452976227,
-0.05890500918030739,
-0.16260622441768646,
-0.7594953775405884,
-0.3891538977622986,
0.05547141283750534,
0.2113223373889923,
-0.35055023431777954,
-0.0015382919227704406,
0.10240424424409866,
0.135478213429451,
-0.23376771807670593,
-0.1137193888425827,
-0.39810439944267273,
0.11885661631822586,
0.4911726117134094,
0.31117376685142517,
0.651239275932312,
-0.1735897958278656,
-0.3032412827014923,
-0.21848146617412567,
-0.7883886098861694,
-0.11788825690746307,
0.6689428687095642,
0.19034872949123383,
-0.35691189765930176,
0.6299949288368225,
0.4039739966392517,
0.1554708033800125,
0.17027391493320465,
0.0909307524561882,
-0.03991686552762985,
-0.000047205354348989204,
-0.0714304968714714,
0.05133878067135811,
0.45865964889526367,
0.397127628326416,
0.0915282666683197,
-0.11622151732444763,
-0.13694129884243011,
0.610611081123352,
0.2713416814804077,
-0.30873942375183105,
0.025175198912620544,
0.30024591088294983,
-0.2783583402633667,
-0.39662590622901917,
0.19802795350551605,
-0.6100147366523743,
-0.5405797362327576,
-0.039165545254945755,
0.44262513518333435,
-0.4617847800254822,
-0.642135500907898,
0.24849209189414978,
-0.2114047408103943,
-0.16846080124378204,
0.03245863318443298,
-1.2876949310302734,
0.2697965204715729,
0.6668161153793335,
0.8966245055198669,
0.13878180086612701,
-0.5162123441696167,
0.07011977583169937,
0.3419729173183441,
-0.7563955783843994,
0.8276281356811523,
-0.5993225574493408,
-0.6788157224655151,
0.3376348912715912,
0.032078806310892105,
0.1580476611852646,
-0.36503902077674866,
0.19032779335975647,
-0.599574863910675,
-0.08229419589042664,
-0.2952955365180969,
-0.3789120018482208,
0.1184350922703743,
-0.007515061181038618,
-0.7544131278991699,
0.8396721482276917,
0.23563909530639648,
-1.076093077659607,
0.3495291769504547,
-0.6257169842720032,
-0.3970981538295746,
0.1690756231546402,
0.05637577921152115,
-0.03214026987552643,
0.545125424861908,
-0.7519116401672363,
0.2246539145708084,
-0.09771790355443954,
0.42131978273391724,
-0.4832584261894226,
-0.2813686728477478,
0.4230062961578369,
-0.36301189661026,
0.7092393636703491,
0.07873272150754929,
-0.4256283640861511,
-0.19414083659648895,
-0.4691924452781677,
-0.42338868975639343,
0.19912473857402802,
-0.2540052831172943,
-0.9119260907173157,
0.47470682859420776,
-0.328590452671051,
0.1295330673456192,
-0.04251706972718239,
-0.2453441470861435,
0.17543408274650574,
-0.924644410610199,
0.46293753385543823,
0.8078973293304443,
-0.19220076501369476,
0.9080962538719177,
-0.30323824286460876,
0.36654168367385864,
0.4546385407447815,
0.0019376955460757017,
0.2269519865512848,
-0.41241392493247986,
-0.7884190678596497,
0.3737485706806183,
0.22066675126552582,
0.49105507135391235,
-0.451416015625,
0.011189501732587814,
-0.49009203910827637,
-0.4382137954235077,
-0.5447485446929932,
-0.06024312600493431,
0.04456629231572151,
0.08313509821891785,
-0.040983736515045166,
-0.09722050279378891,
-0.411430299282074,
-0.5729628205299377,
-0.11454293876886368,
-0.5890281796455383,
0.35650649666786194,
0.03712480515241623,
0.5053255558013916,
-0.6047361493110657,
0.6945989727973938,
-0.4229758679866791,
-0.07532446086406708,
-0.21250075101852417,
0.2578122615814209,
0.03364783152937889,
-0.13883045315742493,
0.7133895754814148,
-0.7131602168083191,
-0.3490654528141022,
0.11202450841665268,
-0.7314195036888123,
-0.0332857184112072,
0.16232608258724213,
-0.41729849576950073,
0.45960506796836853,
-0.06544464081525803,
-0.7636884450912476,
0.617017388343811,
0.7462940812110901,
-0.44775551557540894,
0.5519070625305176,
-0.3845977783203125,
-0.11910229176282883,
-1.091463327407837,
-0.38235804438591003,
0.08084235340356827,
0.33434006571769714,
-0.6353426575660706,
0.03627106174826622,
-0.1579962968826294,
0.3095383942127228,
-0.437658429145813,
0.45139554142951965,
-0.31231749057769775,
0.3196442723274231,
-0.4384777247905731,
0.6876307725906372,
-0.08498754352331161,
-0.48530977964401245,
-0.0252392515540123,
0.3610128164291382,
0.5791242122650146,
-0.8512551784515381,
0.6556555032730103,
0.36613163352012634,
-0.039242781698703766,
0.34358108043670654,
-0.6663362979888916,
-0.3655027449131012,
-0.6334441900253296,
0.08105804771184921,
-0.8126484155654907,
-0.245160311460495,
0.21854554116725922,
-0.12079384922981262,
-0.035659972578287125,
0.1356821209192276,
-0.3580935001373291,
-0.03199922665953636,
-0.2761761546134949,
0.28170958161354065,
0.4864305555820465,
-0.24243402481079102,
-0.026073291897773743,
0.7231177091598511,
0.07545182853937149,
-0.5629599094390869,
-0.8207100033760071,
-0.14496582746505737,
-0.523776113986969,
-0.7699669003486633,
0.34622815251350403,
-0.07049816846847534,
-1.1045957803726196,
0.2829453647136688,
0.011535007506608963,
-0.14685633778572083,
0.05601018667221069,
0.6131179332733154,
0.33912020921707153,
-0.09077660739421844,
0.5192376971244812,
0.4090099036693573,
-0.04889557510614395,
0.284891277551651,
-0.10003730654716492,
0.46030229330062866,
-0.14592278003692627,
0.12861573696136475,
-0.09201230108737946,
0.5467591881752014,
0.7183578610420227,
0.21499784290790558,
1.0967377424240112,
0.0916440337896347,
-0.28044724464416504,
-0.16699229180812836,
-0.04137806221842766,
0.006365022622048855,
-0.4815809428691864,
0.08988072723150253,
-0.5938491821289062,
-0.7338370680809021,
0.6486760377883911,
0.007264242973178625,
-0.21396413445472717,
0.740304172039032,
0.8124681115150452,
-0.2106945514678955,
0.7135198712348938,
0.8591219186782837,
0.29403525590896606,
0.2717215418815613,
-0.3968525826931,
0.31891492009162903,
-0.49017617106437683,
-0.0898209884762764,
-0.5888605117797852,
0.03447224572300911,
-0.9211646318435669,
-0.21746841073036194,
-0.01005034614354372,
0.18754447996616364,
-0.2709641754627228,
0.3759041726589203,
-0.4603031277656555,
0.38763314485549927,
-0.06762175261974335,
-0.3605172634124756,
0.021469097584486008,
-0.08926744759082794,
-0.10514779388904572,
-0.14256766438484192,
-0.39910539984703064,
-0.8564174175262451,
0.6989509463310242,
0.4191897511482239,
0.9013420343399048,
0.5057861804962158,
0.3409139811992645,
0.189816415309906,
0.22059714794158936,
-0.6772434115409851,
0.2485882192850113,
-0.18391647934913635,
-0.791835606098175,
-0.3505009710788727,
-0.0672992393374443,
-1.1642987728118896,
0.15262280404567719,
-0.06461797654628754,
-0.9737468957901001,
0.5593513250350952,
0.07070982456207275,
-0.0074277883395552635,
0.18726494908332825,
-0.37181147933006287,
0.5546530485153198,
-0.302524209022522,
-0.08442631363868713,
-0.14941151440143585,
-0.6363292932510376,
0.4025317430496216,
0.15506421029567719,
0.5602231621742249,
-0.4765101373195648,
-0.07989227771759033,
0.5042276382446289,
-0.4487045705318451,
0.8436943292617798,
0.1666083037853241,
-0.6386178731918335,
0.5582011342048645,
0.47579750418663025,
0.2177160084247589,
0.23943136632442474,
-0.1936688870191574,
0.2342478334903717,
0.7578209042549133,
-0.5047343373298645,
-0.604491114616394,
0.5450173616409302,
-1.1898914575576782,
-0.5580060482025146,
-0.649090051651001,
-0.617499828338623,
0.138958141207695,
0.007640826981514692,
0.647983729839325,
0.588646650314331,
-0.27153223752975464,
-0.09137367457151413,
0.5142208933830261,
-0.0898829847574234,
0.5306285619735718,
0.1888045072555542,
-0.36165377497673035,
-0.16321177780628204,
0.4849819839000702,
0.3837800920009613,
0.8469339609146118,
0.3935691714286804,
0.2605729401111603,
-0.5009428858757019,
-0.3328590393066406,
-0.2500973641872406,
0.2632349133491516,
-0.922954797744751,
0.09303773194551468,
-0.43667349219322205,
0.018887870013713837,
-0.31455960869789124,
-0.18411478400230408,
-0.3331713080406189,
-0.12073821574449539,
-0.2621057331562042,
0.046371445059776306,
0.2629331648349762,
1.0802217721939087,
0.027294743806123734,
0.2583802342414856,
-0.728837251663208,
0.11447319388389587,
-0.15932174026966095,
0.34092193841934204,
-0.1881440430879593,
-0.5554191470146179,
-0.2256443351507187,
0.4396854639053345,
-0.4362856447696686,
-1.3421465158462524,
0.4098227918148041,
0.2227855622768402,
0.37338027358055115,
0.7443685531616211,
0.30778923630714417,
0.7213142514228821,
-0.538964569568634,
0.8378430604934692,
0.30523595213890076,
-1.250380277633667,
0.6000692248344421,
-0.5125783085823059,
0.04319559037685394,
0.29616057872772217,
0.47084107995033264,
-0.8174883723258972,
-0.6475567817687988,
-0.7870489358901978,
-0.8048799633979797,
0.3707474172115326,
-0.21777765452861786,
1.0011513233184814,
-0.46614834666252136,
0.6465700268745422,
0.34425440430641174,
0.07121773809194565,
-0.7467746138572693,
-0.3223710358142853,
-0.4031308889389038,
0.034599218517541885,
0.1179516613483429,
-0.6400347352027893,
-0.315093070268631,
-0.11686810106039047,
0.39174625277519226,
-0.059602633118629456,
0.34760576486587524,
-0.018805086612701416,
-0.1747332215309143,
-0.4301297962665558,
0.28970175981521606,
0.8110270500183105,
1.0655583143234253,
0.065505251288414,
0.5479378700256348,
-0.016476454213261604,
-0.7634300589561462,
0.5040372014045715,
-0.3538404107093811,
-0.18681782484054565,
0.07847405970096588,
0.23665763437747955,
0.8264951705932617,
0.2680355906486511,
-0.5348435640335083,
0.45892900228500366,
0.04720819368958473,
-0.3410223424434662,
-0.1700206845998764,
-0.15427441895008087,
0.20482827723026276,
-0.05405943840742111,
0.03667350113391876,
0.03852585330605507,
-0.12369508296251297,
-0.9052311182022095,
0.027900153771042824,
0.4119882881641388,
-0.44982343912124634,
-0.7813247442245483,
0.6860984563827515,
0.03716806322336197,
-0.24226896464824677,
0.5581380128860474,
-0.5062021613121033,
-0.2818368971347809,
0.3121512830257416,
0.9563653469085693,
0.6640392541885376,
-0.17715196311473846,
0.7768791317939758,
-0.11187224835157394,
0.36295440793037415,
-0.2173963040113449,
0.10318606346845627,
0.3438304364681244,
-1.0851829051971436,
-0.25103065371513367,
-0.720827043056488,
-0.0993177518248558,
-0.07947643846273422,
-0.6180261373519897,
0.33444586396217346,
-0.36747413873672485,
-0.18845491111278534,
-0.05584040284156799,
-0.16352076828479767,
0.05256694182753563,
-0.09888127446174622,
-0.047575656324625015,
0.4023497998714447,
-1.0252447128295898,
0.851608395576477,
0.841343879699707,
-0.38991791009902954,
-0.7121460437774658,
0.31387001276016235,
-0.21763888001441956,
-0.25849199295043945,
0.8407064080238342,
-0.000909123569726944,
-0.16117337346076965,
-0.32651931047439575,
-0.13881398737430573,
-1.053941011428833,
0.884283185005188,
0.6495795845985413,
-0.3860304057598114,
-0.03837452456355095,
0.2651512324810028,
0.8174433708190918,
-0.36181360483169556,
-0.009698241949081421,
0.5753881335258484,
0.42554041743278503,
0.24589970707893372,
-0.8088937401771545,
0.08950477093458176,
-0.11528022587299347,
0.38289642333984375,
0.6472328901290894,
-0.5400588512420654,
0.7448505163192749,
-0.22752296924591064,
-0.6863036155700684,
0.06335943937301636,
0.4140581488609314,
-0.038572005927562714,
0.23298262059688568,
0.2899317443370819,
0.5565643310546875,
0.44366708397865295,
-0.31369492411613464,
1.2794610261917114,
-0.36824366450309753,
0.5953081250190735,
0.32431137561798096,
-0.25084787607192993,
0.8820065855979919,
0.3758712410926819,
-0.39768296480178833,
0.542397677898407,
0.5898444056510925,
0.32479798793792725,
0.553297221660614,
0.2750580906867981,
-0.22987809777259827,
0.03585268184542656,
0.13604295253753662,
-0.11913592368364334,
0.42705869674682617,
0.5077272653579712,
-0.10188968479633331,
-0.28659993410110474,
0.11572080105543137,
0.02134610339999199,
0.3337981402873993,
0.008133995346724987,
0.564461350440979,
0.16133958101272583,
-0.3591974973678589,
0.7950397729873657,
-0.1375647336244583,
0.43183866143226624,
-0.3376077711582184,
0.31310006976127625,
0.07804560661315918,
0.06954117864370346,
-0.14927543699741364,
-0.6346657872200012,
0.8932292461395264,
-0.32169482111930847,
-0.29419195652008057,
-0.021937353536486626,
0.5765148401260376,
-0.2157122641801834,
-0.43071484565734863,
0.6705220937728882,
0.4953925311565399,
0.1344628632068634,
0.4874798059463501,
-0.6412863731384277,
0.4456717371940613,
-0.49262961745262146,
-0.050991661846637726,
0.3520033359527588,
0.6157042384147644,
-0.03995160013437271,
0.61810302734375,
0.07843741029500961,
0.5011831521987915,
0.2801547944545746,
-0.10256902128458023,
0.5840914249420166,
-0.379536896944046,
-0.4498218894004822,
-1.035668134689331,
0.5946332216262817,
0.2759595513343811,
-0.5081790685653687,
0.3864627480506897,
-0.1139291301369667,
0.5028072595596313,
0.1850648671388626,
0.7019364237785339,
-0.3658801317214966,
0.0032300064340233803,
-0.30188968777656555,
0.8379016518592834,
-0.3906262516975403,
0.500222384929657,
-0.43486925959587097,
-1.0524417161941528,
-0.3007766008377075,
0.62620609998703,
-0.5709728002548218,
-0.16529574990272522,
0.9309245944023132,
0.40547940135002136,
0.28802981972694397,
0.053584206849336624,
0.5292870402336121,
0.4504258632659912,
0.12055739015340805,
-0.03277423977851868,
1.1535053253173828,
-0.32664650678634644,
0.43939048051834106,
-0.27115598320961,
-0.08964003622531891,
-0.11590997874736786,
-0.6457539200782776,
-0.6724495887756348,
-1.0723129510879517,
-0.4352200925350189,
-0.6706280708312988,
0.4094856083393097,
0.4305541217327118,
0.3610810935497284,
-0.3878694176673889,
-0.33028826117515564,
-0.3835047781467438,
0.1837756186723709,
-0.22658683359622955,
-0.1865045726299286,
0.37218940258026123,
-0.29085758328437805,
-0.7871034145355225,
-0.06674136966466904,
0.6471748352050781,
0.34400129318237305,
-0.5489446520805359,
-0.05018860846757889,
0.0619971789419651,
0.4920518696308136,
0.6998945474624634,
-0.057838793843984604,
-1.0162233114242554,
-0.5119454264640808,
-0.16180969774723053,
-0.08194457739591599,
0.036605458706617355,
0.3994578719139099,
-0.33641549944877625,
0.3410138487815857,
0.48020297288894653,
0.23616927862167358,
-0.2149842530488968,
0.060045577585697174,
0.4496276080608368,
-0.34801241755485535,
0.39048948884010315,
0.10745398700237274,
0.14585371315479279,
0.1438419222831726,
-0.4153287708759308,
-0.016779212281107903,
0.5118963718414307,
-0.5134034752845764,
-0.9885490536689758,
0.7339098453521729,
-0.6233134269714355,
-0.29468196630477905,
1.1867142915725708,
0.06777393817901611,
-0.4430714547634125,
-0.01276677567511797,
0.06268466264009476,
0.21674449741840363,
-0.23029235005378723,
1.0534236431121826,
1.009975552558899,
-0.2211262583732605,
0.00759111950173974,
-0.6751845479011536,
0.42578548192977905,
0.0731504037976265,
-0.40768319368362427,
0.2187146097421646,
0.29628804326057434,
0.2891201674938202,
0.6499123573303223,
0.340453177690506,
-0.27020102739334106,
0.017810266464948654,
0.3327094316482544,
-0.4092693030834198,
0.6195533275604248,
-0.0828651413321495,
-0.18384000658988953,
0.3373148441314697,
0.18706341087818146,
0.018964821472764015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12081v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12081v1
|
Selective Annotation via Data Allocation: These Data Should Be Triaged to Experts for Annotation Rather Than the Model
| 2024-05-20T14:52:05 | 2024-05-20T14:52:05 |
Chen Huang, Yang Deng, Wenqiang Lei, Jiancheng Lv, Ido Dagan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To obtain high-quality annotations under limited budget, semi-automatic
annotation methods are commonly used, where a portion of the data is annotated
by experts and a model is then trained to complete the annotations for the
remaining data. However, these methods mainly focus on selecting informative
data for expert annotations to improve the model predictive ability (i.e.,
triage-to-human data), while the rest of the data is indiscriminately assigned
to model annotation (i.e., triage-to-model data). This may lead to
inefficiencies in budget allocation for annotations, as easy data that the
model could accurately annotate may be unnecessarily assigned to the expert,
and hard data may be misclassified by the model. As a result, the overall
annotation quality may be compromised. To address this issue, we propose a
selective annotation framework called SANT. It effectively takes advantage of
both the triage-to-human and triage-to-model data through the proposed
error-aware triage and bi-weighting mechanisms. As such, informative or hard
data is assigned to the expert for annotation, while easy data is handled by
the model. Experimental results show that SANT consistently outperforms other
baselines, leading to higher-quality annotation through its proper allocation
of data to both expert and model workers. We provide pioneering work on data
annotation within budget constraints, establishing a landmark for future
triage-based annotation studies.
|
[
-0.47814589738845825,
-0.130060076713562,
0.44309917092323303,
0.20817749202251434,
-0.4643564820289612,
0.016964050009846687,
0.1251816600561142,
-0.9335020184516907,
0.3661253750324249,
0.7227296233177185,
-0.4074970781803131,
-0.23454073071479797,
-0.2810354232788086,
0.06487643718719482,
-0.3646427392959595,
1.3021456003189087,
0.061748046427965164,
0.2359662801027298,
-0.495120108127594,
-0.2986713945865631,
-0.6003285646438599,
-0.7529064416885376,
-0.5467464923858643,
-0.2459874302148819,
0.7339205741882324,
0.4966510236263275,
0.6851123571395874,
0.9457897543907166,
0.9214656352996826,
0.07122089713811874,
-0.020461957901716232,
0.28940048813819885,
-0.4224132001399994,
-0.22908486425876617,
-0.4048879146575928,
-0.5862200260162354,
-0.5056433081626892,
0.002982994308695197,
0.47234001755714417,
0.7825854420661926,
0.2774154543876648,
0.6087702512741089,
-0.38839560747146606,
0.7189809083938599,
-0.836351215839386,
0.15489019453525543,
-0.6588240265846252,
-0.19341136515140533,
-0.6398298144340515,
-0.07422353327274323,
-0.2365254908800125,
-0.540571928024292,
0.39715149998664856,
-0.731132447719574,
0.23747076094150543,
0.28645068407058716,
0.8598446249961853,
0.856864869594574,
0.05221918970346451,
-0.007855270057916641,
-0.7565433382987976,
0.5882738828659058,
-0.3643301725387573,
-0.16472125053405762,
0.6077214479446411,
0.5598113536834717,
0.3631446957588196,
-0.5156242847442627,
-0.061075061559677124,
0.06136107072234154,
-0.22819706797599792,
-0.03964502736926079,
0.0963444635272026,
-0.013914779759943485,
0.48867344856262207,
0.14617301523685455,
0.009939895942807198,
0.060791779309511185,
-0.521188497543335,
-0.2809159755706787,
1.1058382987976074,
0.07127014547586441,
0.21087424457073212,
-0.287992000579834,
-0.7807859778404236,
0.16570928692817688,
-0.6738665103912354,
-0.02109813503921032,
0.36939817667007446,
0.6110807061195374,
0.11139730364084244,
0.805465042591095,
-0.5954467058181763,
0.7647738456726074,
-0.060361962765455246,
0.18835341930389404,
0.38782232999801636,
-0.41673576831817627,
-0.09169500321149826,
0.28712382912635803,
0.41802978515625,
0.432773232460022,
0.774457573890686,
-0.17101047933101654,
-0.412710577249527,
-0.016552742570638657,
0.3114694654941559,
-0.4737987816333771,
-0.4815366864204407,
-0.001988552510738373,
0.027503542602062225,
-0.5829585790634155,
0.08627597987651825,
-0.7746525406837463,
-0.4767596125602722,
-0.2727145254611969,
0.5108538866043091,
0.017167478799819946,
-0.14307492971420288,
-0.1575433909893036,
-0.1705639809370041,
-0.27224698662757874,
0.3918329179286957,
-0.7614630460739136,
0.047556109726428986,
0.08053147047758102,
0.7293604016304016,
-0.13341619074344635,
0.029170256108045578,
-0.34575754404067993,
0.6295686364173889,
-0.4779733121395111,
1.2275092601776123,
-0.6057133674621582,
-0.16048885881900787,
-0.3460531234741211,
-0.14993472397327423,
-0.07695657759904861,
-0.45026224851608276,
0.7479395270347595,
-0.3500165045261383,
-0.32970717549324036,
-0.5617451071739197,
-0.2707831859588623,
-0.3614153265953064,
-0.16869616508483887,
-1.028519868850708,
1.1106131076812744,
0.4541500210762024,
-1.264727234840393,
0.7382665276527405,
-0.8166506290435791,
-0.15275464951992035,
0.20587624609470367,
-0.10341250896453857,
-0.5630977153778076,
0.0070973532274365425,
0.39925214648246765,
0.5062824487686157,
-0.37240374088287354,
0.4158821105957031,
-0.6031134128570557,
-0.31613779067993164,
0.2560423016548157,
0.02247537672519684,
0.6410030126571655,
0.12752461433410645,
-0.1625167429447174,
0.24088428914546967,
-0.6554328799247742,
-0.07489728927612305,
0.20044313371181488,
-0.022752707824110985,
-0.5405080914497375,
-0.03648941218852997,
0.1999720335006714,
0.06636804342269897,
0.10604674369096756,
-0.4955751299858093,
0.2433483898639679,
-0.20528444647789001,
0.21592795848846436,
0.7280446887016296,
0.32205840945243835,
0.5311657786369324,
-0.7464798092842102,
0.23812904953956604,
-0.12432676553726196,
0.30499446392059326,
0.1570279449224472,
-0.33871620893478394,
-0.6806816458702087,
-0.5996615886688232,
0.6695826649665833,
0.6053174734115601,
-0.4085313379764557,
-0.10659624636173248,
-0.23637445271015167,
-0.4729650020599365,
-0.8307725787162781,
-0.12859222292900085,
0.07890671491622925,
0.7057909965515137,
0.540415346622467,
-0.03945383429527283,
-0.6304925680160522,
-1.444627285003662,
0.10603202134370804,
-0.2511433959007263,
0.2794983386993408,
0.3371468484401703,
0.4792400896549225,
0.11664661765098572,
1.2785815000534058,
-0.49569621682167053,
-0.28501516580581665,
-0.10674288868904114,
0.22431735694408417,
-0.38968247175216675,
0.6709607839584351,
0.9105128645896912,
-0.8513195514678955,
-0.13113059103488922,
-0.2878648042678833,
-0.38921016454696655,
-0.39309659600257874,
-0.3674091696739197,
-0.54484623670578,
-0.06853633373975754,
0.015718981623649597,
-0.24989037215709686,
0.8716724514961243,
-0.04379519820213318,
0.013291943818330765,
0.5434568524360657,
0.1067291721701622,
-0.16262583434581757,
-0.6748097538948059,
0.3517531454563141,
-0.07046309858560562,
-0.37735527753829956,
-0.4956504702568054,
-0.4467102289199829,
0.10566820204257965,
0.0861702635884285,
-0.26961469650268555,
0.6325899958610535,
-0.3394129276275635,
-0.23392663896083832,
-0.06292426586151123,
-0.11325255036354065,
-0.04964490979909897,
0.4404437839984894,
0.5284013748168945,
0.7073023915290833,
0.3109881579875946,
-0.5014917850494385,
0.12916792929172516,
0.39040711522102356,
-0.2611311078071594,
0.7199834585189819,
-0.7238761186599731,
-0.049381762742996216,
-0.1922907531261444,
0.08437617868185043,
-0.9513999223709106,
-0.4358581602573395,
0.3573042154312134,
-0.32213640213012695,
0.18534551560878754,
-0.4060388505458832,
-0.37059396505355835,
-0.12146130949258804,
-0.006673086434602737,
0.5190368294715881,
-0.11290314793586731,
-0.41061538457870483,
0.15024028718471527,
0.6915231943130493,
-0.20117025077342987,
-0.277393102645874,
-0.931632936000824,
-0.12404446303844452,
-0.2898634076118469,
-0.4083620309829712,
0.17906714975833893,
-0.03381999582052231,
-0.19586865603923798,
0.17622996866703033,
0.0305109154433012,
-0.15954935550689697,
0.22571048140525818,
0.43086162209510803,
0.6879984140396118,
0.31611502170562744,
0.29062122106552124,
0.12091909348964691,
-0.48568785190582275,
-0.0520038977265358,
-0.12807007133960724,
0.05163188651204109,
0.22131386399269104,
-0.6293163299560547,
-0.4563809633255005,
0.3821972906589508,
0.48567190766334534,
-0.6298454999923706,
0.25866833329200745,
0.6136578321456909,
-0.7969446778297424,
-0.07976432889699936,
-0.8919245004653931,
-0.03663698211312294,
-0.3079445958137512,
0.26109376549720764,
-0.35116925835609436,
-0.3376224637031555,
0.6053200364112854,
-0.05731838569045067,
0.3777880072593689,
0.7293611168861389,
0.13852617144584656,
-0.18212643265724182,
1.092898964881897,
0.44637924432754517,
-0.07684725522994995,
0.4874415397644043,
-0.40521663427352905,
-0.06858716905117035,
-1.011448621749878,
-0.27502840757369995,
-0.7283449769020081,
-0.4565694332122803,
-0.21953247487545013,
-0.19925005733966827,
0.18338102102279663,
0.2082219421863556,
-0.320671409368515,
0.05358694866299629,
-0.9753065705299377,
0.19924992322921753,
0.6315714716911316,
0.17782200872898102,
0.04701473191380501,
0.06614601612091064,
0.06894831359386444,
-0.029878728091716766,
-0.7594151496887207,
-0.6209014654159546,
1.1851989030838013,
0.300708532333374,
0.5523635745048523,
-0.3699977695941925,
0.702588677406311,
0.2423851191997528,
0.5752180218696594,
-0.5016907453536987,
0.3240640163421631,
0.10298622399568558,
-1.042128324508667,
-0.4036860466003418,
-0.32845619320869446,
-0.3497799038887024,
-0.2151067852973938,
-0.37023600935935974,
-0.8858208060264587,
0.8012472987174988,
-0.007697924040257931,
-0.8658204674720764,
0.4666302800178528,
-0.8150528073310852,
0.6458665728569031,
-0.24527843296527863,
-0.2699146866798401,
0.0635540634393692,
-0.517866313457489,
-0.04856820032000542,
-0.26759159564971924,
0.11368946731090546,
-0.6084978580474854,
-0.05875594541430473,
0.9729304909706116,
-0.1979888379573822,
0.869968593120575,
-0.3491254448890686,
0.5207133293151855,
0.4747928977012634,
-0.003345015924423933,
0.6730242371559143,
0.32864508032798767,
-0.35238680243492126,
0.11127682775259018,
0.2465551644563675,
-0.5719169974327087,
-0.31818825006484985,
0.11840301007032394,
-0.7652509808540344,
-0.4420877695083618,
-0.41450145840644836,
-0.8327065706253052,
-0.2623949348926544,
0.12597762048244476,
0.2911417484283447,
0.33067625761032104,
0.35428163409233093,
-0.09419316798448563,
0.29123741388320923,
0.2916094660758972,
0.46388912200927734,
0.13259902596473694,
0.07719157636165619,
-0.687994122505188,
0.9727051258087158,
0.5927168130874634,
0.34330692887306213,
0.05293942987918854,
0.07726361602544785,
-0.31492772698402405,
-0.8340306878089905,
-0.7404438853263855,
0.21470016241073608,
-0.5072759389877319,
-0.5210350155830383,
-0.5635738968849182,
-0.19875551760196686,
0.020018257200717926,
-0.4485418498516083,
-0.5669426321983337,
-0.8045490384101868,
-0.5078880786895752,
-0.393322229385376,
0.6964297294616699,
0.5330542922019958,
-0.07755912840366364,
0.14290302991867065,
-0.353732168674469,
0.09311798959970474,
0.22510474920272827,
0.3361673355102539,
-0.15956377983093262,
-0.19936180114746094,
-0.354692667722702,
0.287121057510376,
0.29861894249916077,
-0.8321836590766907,
-0.04716857522726059,
-0.14321771264076233,
0.7005662322044373,
0.40449362993240356,
0.47191476821899414,
0.9581604599952698,
0.13191193342208862,
0.42205309867858887,
-0.0037649006117135286,
-0.7344379425048828,
0.6227757930755615,
-0.37877559661865234,
0.007401255425065756,
1.064765214920044,
0.08136323094367981,
-0.16112929582595825,
-0.30268236994743347,
-0.6613104939460754,
-0.9573448300361633,
1.0452419519424438,
0.011541959829628468,
-0.26921769976615906,
0.19915269315242767,
0.7368918061256409,
0.15654771029949188,
0.26883000135421753,
-0.577113151550293,
0.053090836852788925,
-0.2028157263994217,
-0.130559042096138,
0.30658820271492004,
-0.49021846055984497,
-0.3237302005290985,
-0.20594094693660736,
0.6702067255973816,
-0.23836904764175415,
0.14697858691215515,
0.4757337272167206,
0.08919789642095566,
-0.32050585746765137,
-0.15814660489559174,
0.36610400676727295,
0.9478669166564941,
-0.3986327052116394,
-0.1629583090543747,
0.45293983817100525,
-0.3695339262485504,
0.014666561037302017,
0.2620696723461151,
-0.7977072596549988,
0.06403784453868866,
0.40534520149230957,
0.9471321105957031,
0.18221896886825562,
-0.31716015934944153,
0.32851383090019226,
0.4267529547214508,
-0.11805201321840286,
-0.38666313886642456,
0.18047209084033966,
-0.07921236753463745,
0.39184728264808655,
0.44420650601387024,
0.36195799708366394,
0.0736069530248642,
-0.006938924081623554,
0.1393256038427353,
0.3372699022293091,
-0.5063247680664062,
-0.07303890585899353,
0.7434818148612976,
0.21942771971225739,
0.029746543616056442,
0.45772913098335266,
-0.09881854802370071,
-0.28845441341400146,
0.6671585440635681,
0.14135125279426575,
0.7126250863075256,
-0.12241942435503006,
0.3878912329673767,
0.5452836751937866,
0.3570365309715271,
-0.3289811909198761,
0.3815784752368927,
0.030014339834451675,
-0.3865247070789337,
-0.28075578808784485,
-0.5481047630310059,
-0.4229520857334137,
-0.2323480099439621,
-0.9422166347503662,
0.4169098734855652,
-0.5999017357826233,
-0.5892455577850342,
0.15345822274684906,
0.24371737241744995,
-0.8312200307846069,
0.5003418326377869,
0.06269701570272446,
0.8406999707221985,
-0.7547975182533264,
0.586270272731781,
0.9959689378738403,
-0.7997878193855286,
-0.8851397037506104,
-0.3893691301345825,
-0.27714425325393677,
-0.6876809597015381,
0.6897969245910645,
-0.00877046212553978,
0.2546043395996094,
0.03382278233766556,
-0.42038655281066895,
-1.1315618753433228,
1.2043695449829102,
0.6694910526275635,
-0.6372509002685547,
-0.2193637639284134,
0.22847050428390503,
0.267546147108078,
-0.6574353575706482,
0.38768792152404785,
0.3940427601337433,
0.8375279903411865,
0.3002679944038391,
-0.959347665309906,
0.14043362438678741,
-0.10942161828279495,
-0.029948487877845764,
0.08748937398195267,
-0.7361275553703308,
0.6539682149887085,
-0.5105905532836914,
-0.22644871473312378,
-0.26043179631233215,
0.49208390712738037,
0.017758147791028023,
0.6354506015777588,
0.6285855174064636,
0.5384862422943115,
1.041861653327942,
-0.2793945372104645,
0.8259903788566589,
0.004945983178913593,
0.2081863433122635,
1.0179650783538818,
-0.20477294921875,
0.7104204297065735,
0.4640568792819977,
-0.10921484977006912,
0.04511646181344986,
1.1462137699127197,
-0.25735771656036377,
0.5951236486434937,
0.2564278542995453,
-0.03917441517114639,
-0.4209914803504944,
-0.6067070364952087,
-0.33017775416374207,
0.28957709670066833,
0.15658898651599884,
-0.19564932584762573,
-0.26944130659103394,
-0.1594167947769165,
-0.13693855702877045,
-0.29800674319267273,
-0.5390941500663757,
0.8258218765258789,
-0.22844868898391724,
-0.25282609462738037,
0.36913445591926575,
-0.24211274087429047,
0.12882761657238007,
-0.3561885952949524,
0.07492038607597351,
-0.053363505750894547,
-0.35899755358695984,
-0.6745692491531372,
-0.5459899306297302,
0.5637574791908264,
0.06319241225719452,
-0.29731467366218567,
-0.0025504983495920897,
0.6881581544876099,
-0.26199275255203247,
-0.8557237386703491,
0.007671730127185583,
0.31425657868385315,
0.09994201362133026,
-0.19007228314876556,
-0.5037010312080383,
-0.06205516681075096,
0.028798304498195648,
-0.10637733340263367,
0.09920622408390045,
0.2946168780326843,
-0.5957580804824829,
0.6910881400108337,
0.7328273057937622,
0.47933870553970337,
-0.14988015592098236,
0.1433643400669098,
1.0480453968048096,
-0.40984800457954407,
-0.6018573045730591,
-0.5394797325134277,
0.7283064723014832,
-0.2843886613845825,
-0.27860355377197266,
0.3227407932281494,
0.4612124264240265,
0.8995314240455627,
0.2888078987598419,
1.0608279705047607,
0.20187553763389587,
0.7264343500137329,
-0.19240020215511322,
0.541248083114624,
-0.4804573059082031,
0.17499400675296783,
-0.5093890428543091,
-0.8501039147377014,
-0.5012528300285339,
0.7276002764701843,
-0.8858811259269714,
0.022472012788057327,
0.22491489350795746,
0.5182673931121826,
0.1131666824221611,
0.29483768343925476,
-0.08544020354747772,
-0.40810635685920715,
0.14152537286281586,
0.43511271476745605,
0.6355646848678589,
0.04617037996649742,
0.46849846839904785,
-0.7412349581718445,
-0.3549596071243286,
-0.40201711654663086,
-0.6288444399833679,
-1.0973001718521118,
-0.604211688041687,
-0.4932694733142853,
0.14751239120960236,
0.11562800407409668,
0.9475299119949341,
1.0016671419143677,
-0.8100497126579285,
0.07898814231157303,
0.054539453238248825,
0.1764386147260666,
-0.2305263727903366,
-0.1518825739622116,
0.5845373272895813,
-0.21072930097579956,
-0.6168414354324341,
-0.1715511828660965,
0.30938270688056946,
0.2764148414134979,
-0.33288753032684326,
0.39466649293899536,
-0.2803446352481842,
0.12269194424152374,
0.06357216835021973,
0.11737695336341858,
-0.3277178108692169,
-0.5201379060745239,
-0.2406727522611618,
-0.10448374599218369,
-0.005987140815705061,
0.6833779215812683,
-0.6474355459213257,
0.5055977702140808,
0.4004582464694977,
0.8629465103149414,
0.5309512615203857,
0.34964150190353394,
0.32335492968559265,
-0.4420105814933777,
0.1392812877893448,
0.5393804907798767,
0.20868800580501556,
0.40443411469459534,
-0.7715479731559753,
0.8300224542617798,
0.26339253783226013,
-0.42949622869491577,
-1.0877336263656616,
0.0040220897644758224,
-0.8965499997138977,
0.020005838945508003,
0.9005551934242249,
-0.06799305975437164,
-0.23464010655879974,
-0.1586814522743225,
-0.45724576711654663,
0.2635613977909088,
-0.49047142267227173,
0.8991384506225586,
0.8557865619659424,
-0.32911214232444763,
-0.07760818302631378,
-0.8817573189735413,
0.7641247510910034,
0.45270365476608276,
-0.8523901700973511,
0.18809650838375092,
0.5382148623466492,
0.15959429740905762,
0.24747347831726074,
0.5125783085823059,
-0.11612626910209656,
0.31418755650520325,
-0.2032758742570877,
0.23726584017276764,
-0.5984371304512024,
-0.542304277420044,
0.15401151776313782,
0.22493718564510345,
0.11565075069665909,
-0.4723634719848633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12063v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12063v2
|
CLAMBER: A Benchmark of Identifying and Clarifying Ambiguous Information Needs in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-20T14:34:01 | 2024-06-01T07:35:26 |
Tong Zhang, Peixin Qin, Yang Deng, Chen Huang, Wenqiang Lei, Junhong Liu, Dingnan Jin, Hongru Liang, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used to meet user information
needs, but their effectiveness in dealing with user queries that contain
various types of ambiguity remains unknown, ultimately risking user trust and
satisfaction. To this end, we introduce CLAMBER, a benchmark for evaluating
LLMs using a well-organized taxonomy. Building upon the taxonomy, we construct
~12K high-quality data to assess the strengths, weaknesses, and potential risks
of various off-the-shelf LLMs. Our findings indicate the limited practical
utility of current LLMs in identifying and clarifying ambiguous user queries,
even enhanced by chain-of-thought (CoT) and few-shot prompting. These
techniques may result in overconfidence in LLMs and yield only marginal
enhancements in identifying ambiguity. Furthermore, current LLMs fall short in
generating high-quality clarifying questions due to a lack of conflict
resolution and inaccurate utilization of inherent knowledge. In this paper,
CLAMBER presents a guidance and promotes further research on proactive and
trustworthy LLMs. Our dataset is available at
https://github.com/zt991211/CLAMBER
|
[
-0.44148382544517517,
-0.692976176738739,
0.7393352389335632,
-0.0005393950850702822,
-0.35775190591812134,
0.17135651409626007,
-0.3284713625907898,
-0.5728054046630859,
-0.21579164266586304,
0.33125558495521545,
-0.3490487039089203,
-0.5727674961090088,
-0.946432888507843,
-0.06005235016345978,
-0.6683936715126038,
0.6989933848381042,
-0.18873368203639984,
-0.2661609351634979,
-0.142193004488945,
-0.38312265276908875,
-0.6856274008750916,
-0.4788322150707245,
-0.36802852153778076,
-0.2772963345050812,
0.6520094871520996,
0.32557693123817444,
0.9138655662536621,
0.3927633464336395,
0.5836095809936523,
0.1941545605659485,
-0.14299820363521576,
0.32601529359817505,
-0.8207178115844727,
0.424948513507843,
-0.370321661233902,
-0.4298185408115387,
-0.24227629601955414,
-0.284775972366333,
0.5968604683876038,
0.7470681071281433,
-0.31997373700141907,
0.4814842939376831,
0.10874447971582413,
0.4487403631210327,
-1.1517330408096313,
-0.06499272584915161,
-0.8936182856559753,
-0.2505159378051758,
-0.673067033290863,
0.0755852460861206,
-0.29659610986709595,
-0.37265387177467346,
0.14477217197418213,
-0.4188097417354584,
-0.14577917754650116,
0.24803794920444489,
0.8784790635108948,
0.2722405195236206,
-0.5245282053947449,
-0.5775968432426453,
-0.5760344862937927,
0.7184062004089355,
-0.7980517148971558,
0.48197251558303833,
0.22566427290439606,
0.46123167872428894,
-0.40140092372894287,
-0.8249474763870239,
-0.4145876169204712,
0.05597202479839325,
-0.33201220631599426,
-0.049164287745952606,
-0.250227689743042,
-0.015057078562676907,
0.30253326892852783,
0.1964014172554016,
-0.7116385102272034,
0.27801409363746643,
-0.4006342589855194,
-0.26974257826805115,
0.7540053129196167,
0.24232953786849976,
0.048705898225307465,
0.1957971155643463,
-0.5531448721885681,
0.21190151572227478,
-0.7471104860305786,
0.09098722785711288,
0.3258109986782074,
-0.09062517434358597,
0.2106284201145172,
0.6637875437736511,
-0.03786591440439224,
0.8607677817344666,
-0.21797530353069305,
-0.0791802853345871,
0.1693134307861328,
0.04028764367103577,
-0.1356317400932312,
0.024530572816729546,
0.7929404973983765,
0.4801575541496277,
0.17303450405597687,
-0.07976129651069641,
-0.4897100329399109,
-0.06905245035886765,
0.06704042106866837,
-0.6588225364685059,
0.18495003879070282,
0.3516589105129242,
-0.28221601247787476,
0.3619130849838257,
0.2940097153186798,
-0.844274640083313,
-0.713873565196991,
-0.14874805510044098,
0.31237277388572693,
-0.3039843440055847,
-0.28590258955955505,
0.307747483253479,
-0.008598186075687408,
0.1251848340034485,
0.15681283175945282,
-0.4810295104980469,
0.2587231695652008,
0.8806456923484802,
0.8154919743537903,
-0.3376421630382538,
-0.1428801268339157,
-0.4670318067073822,
0.25099286437034607,
-0.25725337862968445,
0.47569283843040466,
-0.7690189480781555,
-0.4930044710636139,
0.20053905248641968,
-0.36504194140434265,
-0.03687882795929909,
-0.7885512709617615,
0.7460737824440002,
-0.6693358421325684,
-0.027984244748950005,
-0.3323267102241516,
-0.833471417427063,
-0.13137677311897278,
0.37371358275413513,
-0.6132296919822693,
1.162274956703186,
0.14422094821929932,
-0.6932596564292908,
0.1892089992761612,
-0.37462249398231506,
-0.12716111540794373,
0.3090420961380005,
-0.3769107460975647,
-0.20626848936080933,
0.19884273409843445,
-0.06551080197095871,
0.33656027913093567,
-0.7011770009994507,
0.6774000525474548,
-0.4103509485721588,
-0.39042195677757263,
0.4184853434562683,
-0.1325548142194748,
0.4360203146934509,
0.44543102383613586,
-0.1954657882452011,
0.0374017134308815,
-0.6525373458862305,
0.29103055596351624,
0.023341385647654533,
-0.1151951253414154,
-0.4300660490989685,
-0.12110504508018494,
-0.24976535141468048,
0.15980269014835358,
0.6186304688453674,
-0.21906128525733948,
0.058566223829984665,
-0.2521512806415558,
0.4495271146297455,
0.6171508431434631,
-0.04149579256772995,
0.08596089482307434,
-0.32170379161834717,
0.5658636689186096,
-0.014178398065268993,
0.03562794253230095,
-0.18224577605724335,
-0.35199788212776184,
-0.8384101986885071,
-0.22801129519939423,
0.27795925736427307,
0.3764239251613617,
-0.2806532084941864,
0.5409186482429504,
-0.1739528924226761,
-0.5981957316398621,
-0.73615962266922,
0.4457193613052368,
0.3576352298259735,
0.276653528213501,
0.25579455494880676,
-0.42707863450050354,
-0.6880037784576416,
-0.9216614961624146,
-0.5573516488075256,
-0.18926416337490082,
-0.04715903848409653,
0.16840492188930511,
0.4973663091659546,
-0.40736255049705505,
1.080823540687561,
-0.5068361163139343,
-0.08207408338785172,
-0.05275902897119522,
0.404578298330307,
0.151693195104599,
0.13962581753730774,
0.16684330999851227,
-0.7199912667274475,
-0.41347163915634155,
-0.15544696152210236,
-0.6048806309700012,
-0.21171188354492188,
-0.06657494604587555,
-0.038013484328985214,
-0.07459951937198639,
0.4581972658634186,
-0.8980835676193237,
0.3077780306339264,
0.5875665545463562,
0.04190577194094658,
0.4580043852329254,
0.04791960492730141,
-0.06063259392976761,
-0.7006511688232422,
0.3308928608894348,
-0.214951753616333,
-0.19258545339107513,
-0.5349742770195007,
0.14316542446613312,
0.0759265124797821,
0.05937165766954422,
-0.1819840669631958,
0.8807365298271179,
-0.5155193209648132,
-0.07023383677005768,
-0.17144858837127686,
0.627134382724762,
-0.13174821436405182,
-0.05960261449217796,
-0.30277833342552185,
0.6523408889770508,
0.5956519842147827,
-0.586544930934906,
0.3464960753917694,
0.040211137384176254,
-0.667368471622467,
0.6003564596176147,
-0.7165431976318359,
0.21400073170661926,
-0.16429217159748077,
0.19885268807411194,
-1.0442187786102295,
-0.2763215899467468,
0.16244596242904663,
-0.2659617066383362,
0.05998624488711357,
-0.09643396735191345,
-0.7380342483520508,
-0.443115770816803,
0.051914509385824203,
0.6349471807479858,
0.34465256333351135,
-0.5175577402114868,
0.6068534851074219,
0.36273375153541565,
-0.002360518788918853,
-0.6894617080688477,
-0.43723949790000916,
0.09002570062875748,
-0.36955538392066956,
-0.6625164151191711,
0.2955048084259033,
-0.1923072189092636,
-0.3826138973236084,
-0.09315350651741028,
-0.39883896708488464,
-0.2106340378522873,
0.20013217628002167,
0.40381401777267456,
0.05570714920759201,
-0.22665652632713318,
0.40630143880844116,
-0.49159640073776245,
-0.11916609853506088,
0.03887137398123741,
-0.10272195935249329,
0.5832293033599854,
-0.35178855061531067,
-0.6964744329452515,
-0.04180233180522919,
0.18449988961219788,
0.578080415725708,
-0.43721410632133484,
0.5853384137153625,
0.727008581161499,
-0.30413007736206055,
-0.21722421050071716,
-0.8564951419830322,
-0.16540712118148804,
-0.4698295593261719,
0.24473506212234497,
-0.3379983901977539,
-1.1280614137649536,
0.6614479422569275,
-0.30097565054893494,
0.11847393959760666,
0.33153292536735535,
0.3844321668148041,
0.021312525495886803,
0.8048517107963562,
0.3379483222961426,
-0.10100585967302322,
0.10579752922058105,
0.2608289420604706,
0.5335952043533325,
-0.5725519061088562,
-0.25863373279571533,
-0.4619746506214142,
-0.45068830251693726,
-0.5370596647262573,
-0.29387617111206055,
0.2715184688568115,
0.41575416922569275,
-0.16479218006134033,
0.1918109953403473,
-0.2343234419822693,
0.43233025074005127,
0.28264209628105164,
-0.23776832222938538,
0.4145204722881317,
-0.589179277420044,
0.0671960860490799,
-0.0733518898487091,
-0.44876307249069214,
-0.6063621044158936,
0.8975363373756409,
0.37466418743133545,
0.9006257057189941,
0.3069285452365875,
0.5698146820068359,
0.22696833312511444,
0.231561541557312,
-0.6722849011421204,
0.5947691798210144,
0.32729965448379517,
-0.9671105146408081,
-0.12990838289260864,
-0.4204970598220825,
-1.2213239669799805,
0.4743310213088989,
-0.2102123498916626,
-1.0176043510437012,
-0.002612240379676223,
0.2249191254377365,
-0.335510790348053,
0.18024741113185883,
-0.6242154836654663,
0.7810152173042297,
-0.6485834121704102,
-0.42305174469947815,
-0.0759492814540863,
-0.721153974533081,
0.6010642647743225,
-0.2751223146915436,
0.2858847677707672,
-0.4423716068267822,
-0.3479496240615845,
0.44989368319511414,
-0.17664243280887604,
0.7669117450714111,
0.035753440111875534,
-0.0601678304374218,
0.41466647386550903,
0.24192802608013153,
0.7054268717765808,
0.052604470402002335,
-0.3271044194698334,
0.1754952073097229,
0.06309515982866287,
-0.2510506808757782,
-0.7111728191375732,
0.673660159111023,
-0.40662989020347595,
-0.8315052390098572,
-0.42018425464630127,
-0.507473349571228,
-0.3224833905696869,
0.525305986404419,
0.1274089515209198,
0.03926301747560501,
-0.25457003712654114,
0.4097506105899811,
0.6608268022537231,
0.012895749881863594,
0.18392980098724365,
0.7147448658943176,
-0.3659147322177887,
-0.06380295753479004,
0.47130081057548523,
0.11962756514549255,
0.18756158649921417,
0.08770240843296051,
0.09445095807313919,
-0.22021575272083282,
-0.6783313751220703,
-0.05996546149253845,
0.13317614793777466,
-0.7444260716438293,
-0.35654106736183167,
-0.35255101323127747,
-0.2997121512889862,
-0.13984878361225128,
0.014044150710105896,
-0.45436474680900574,
0.08042135834693909,
-0.25579196214675903,
-0.00952292513102293,
0.19312724471092224,
0.6613458395004272,
0.38733038306236267,
0.49354681372642517,
-0.8637533783912659,
-0.06485846638679504,
-0.09856001287698746,
0.4824983477592468,
-0.0343991182744503,
-0.5371093153953552,
-0.10352391749620438,
-0.22737956047058105,
-0.25894731283187866,
-0.8008605241775513,
0.1606437861919403,
0.03666209802031517,
0.9524275064468384,
0.6524149179458618,
0.41831889748573303,
0.8095571994781494,
-0.1284671276807785,
0.602052628993988,
0.27440187335014343,
-0.9314190745353699,
0.3094496428966522,
-0.1117778867483139,
0.41960859298706055,
0.8267828822135925,
0.6612215042114258,
-0.6956411004066467,
-0.3264560401439667,
-0.5978734493255615,
-1.152294635772705,
0.19414637982845306,
0.14114265143871307,
-0.013597778044641018,
0.11276883631944656,
0.3490397334098816,
0.11601102352142334,
0.46186643838882446,
-0.6061709523200989,
-0.22673247754573822,
0.4223496615886688,
-0.24668152630329132,
0.04927540197968483,
-0.47247856855392456,
-0.3177565634250641,
0.1551467329263687,
0.37158194184303284,
0.08586835861206055,
-0.3431738317012787,
-0.08765608817338943,
-0.34376612305641174,
0.08423484116792679,
0.6459722518920898,
0.5113618969917297,
1.091936469078064,
-0.19737142324447632,
0.4951958954334259,
0.33965232968330383,
0.022870304062962532,
-0.09494117647409439,
0.07779161632061005,
0.019351566210389137,
0.09665755182504654,
0.33314570784568787,
0.6389874815940857,
0.34806159138679504,
-1.1477690935134888,
0.5577724575996399,
0.22538810968399048,
0.10956727713346481,
-0.2433880865573883,
0.34269610047340393,
0.21340003609657288,
0.1455422341823578,
0.2148236185312271,
-0.13992290198802948,
0.06147630140185356,
-0.43829795718193054,
0.1595320850610733,
0.5102259516716003,
-0.4060138761997223,
-0.005303497426211834,
0.2192421406507492,
0.21959707140922546,
-0.21386733651161194,
0.437266081571579,
-0.12514880299568176,
-0.25534141063690186,
0.0458780936896801,
0.4017038643360138,
0.4665336608886719,
-0.326457142829895,
-0.21284283697605133,
0.406069815158844,
0.4551966190338135,
-0.2722252607345581,
0.13435474038124084,
0.13715136051177979,
-0.5257802605628967,
0.0031155268661677837,
-0.2903522551059723,
-0.40942251682281494,
0.4029395580291748,
-0.7819091081619263,
0.4262319505214691,
-0.48210325837135315,
-0.5373005867004395,
-0.05298280715942383,
-0.15376266837120056,
-0.6148965954780579,
-0.1903088539838791,
0.04321814700961113,
1.075137734413147,
-0.559220552444458,
0.5803419947624207,
0.4156804382801056,
-0.18292270600795746,
-0.4228508174419403,
0.0014313667779788375,
0.36285698413848877,
-0.8122085332870483,
0.37221604585647583,
0.24842628836631775,
-0.37219366431236267,
-0.26625871658325195,
-0.5188098549842834,
-0.8944623470306396,
1.0964200496673584,
0.4116098880767822,
-0.9359515309333801,
0.12545281648635864,
0.274116575717926,
0.5245608687400818,
-0.465961754322052,
0.4246499836444855,
0.7633630037307739,
0.8400644659996033,
0.2252219021320343,
-0.8056585788726807,
0.054699014872312546,
0.00994366966187954,
0.07593058794736862,
0.34975844621658325,
-0.6013577580451965,
0.6638240814208984,
-0.15950968861579895,
-0.5883768200874329,
0.2126496583223343,
0.5838442444801331,
0.24563461542129517,
0.46942493319511414,
0.48494312167167664,
0.44087278842926025,
1.2832138538360596,
-0.10856086760759354,
0.7409840822219849,
-0.29263025522232056,
0.28623294830322266,
1.6313714981079102,
-0.5386053919792175,
1.1020311117172241,
0.5150200724601746,
0.04998322203755379,
0.3235112130641937,
0.6116726994514465,
-0.14553897082805634,
0.138737753033638,
0.5054811239242554,
-0.2478870451450348,
-0.4501970708370209,
-0.12184847146272659,
-0.4228106737136841,
0.2882431447505951,
0.7344773411750793,
-0.3516390323638916,
-0.47584274411201477,
-0.33631396293640137,
0.1327980011701584,
0.2824710011482239,
-0.036508966237306595,
0.5649768710136414,
0.256670206785202,
-0.7975996136665344,
0.6173217296600342,
0.004418284632265568,
0.5526745319366455,
-0.7930217385292053,
0.23303349316120148,
-0.02500368468463421,
0.1590839922428131,
-0.38811132311820984,
-1.1744331121444702,
0.1012667864561081,
-0.03594350814819336,
0.027315359562635422,
0.022461209446191788,
0.656726062297821,
-0.4239121377468109,
-0.18311484158039093,
0.4749525785446167,
0.4521525204181671,
0.16524052619934082,
0.014173195697367191,
-0.7458961009979248,
0.5183835029602051,
-0.15883585810661316,
-0.12310416996479034,
0.1320776790380478,
0.45466098189353943,
-0.018377386033535004,
0.9012596011161804,
0.3699178695678711,
-0.11778862029314041,
0.03372187167406082,
-0.05654844641685486,
0.7142057418823242,
-0.5263239145278931,
-0.06476012617349625,
-0.9912245869636536,
0.494306355714798,
-0.21445530652999878,
-0.5766323804855347,
0.9352895617485046,
0.7230934500694275,
0.831581711769104,
0.4051138162612915,
0.702094316482544,
0.042141105979681015,
0.45511195063591003,
-0.4324014186859131,
0.4138453006744385,
-0.5345680117607117,
0.6157185435295105,
0.16744683682918549,
-0.7467149496078491,
-0.35260769724845886,
0.3086528778076172,
-0.5459262728691101,
0.19305811822414398,
0.5300253033638,
0.9235557913780212,
-0.14572739601135254,
-0.04095727950334549,
0.3229050934314728,
0.29420241713523865,
0.20982715487480164,
0.4860004782676697,
1.0437206029891968,
-0.10190925002098083,
0.771319568157196,
0.3361280858516693,
-0.06368300318717957,
-0.6661577224731445,
-0.948149561882019,
-0.9139438271522522,
-0.5900446176528931,
-0.17464908957481384,
-0.31525999307632446,
0.2899281978607178,
0.9838275909423828,
0.8364498019218445,
-0.7009572982788086,
-0.32789602875709534,
0.10308985412120819,
0.3326626718044281,
0.014419827610254288,
-0.15042006969451904,
-0.007067019119858742,
-0.4464149475097656,
-0.3306368589401245,
0.17509056627750397,
0.1811879426240921,
-0.1041424497961998,
-0.31942692399024963,
-0.1433410346508026,
-0.023144003003835678,
0.10129797458648682,
0.3659571409225464,
0.41297292709350586,
-0.9333686232566833,
-0.17815445363521576,
-0.1754143089056015,
-0.27680304646492004,
0.0451527014374733,
0.9469617009162903,
-0.29175570607185364,
0.5818401575088501,
0.31843751668930054,
0.746832013130188,
0.5535634160041809,
0.12610483169555664,
0.5814170241355896,
-0.6961309313774109,
-0.13343365490436554,
0.3642761707305908,
0.3606604039669037,
0.24649889767169952,
-0.26412177085876465,
0.44085991382598877,
-0.23262329399585724,
-0.5358144044876099,
-0.847933828830719,
0.41242724657058716,
-0.9142038822174072,
-0.21328212320804596,
1.3217326402664185,
-0.34363558888435364,
-0.09520077705383301,
-0.1793082058429718,
-0.21921874582767487,
-0.18110042810440063,
-0.43343988060951233,
0.7202884554862976,
0.8824901580810547,
0.0768563374876976,
-0.2076498121023178,
-0.7257990837097168,
0.390658974647522,
0.35347747802734375,
-0.7120711803436279,
0.38821232318878174,
0.4844258725643158,
0.19543702900409698,
0.10935152322053909,
0.31379833817481995,
0.051325101405382156,
-0.021637778729200363,
-0.361287385225296,
-0.1380462497472763,
0.17753857374191284,
-0.2246861755847931,
-0.013937171548604965,
0.19643692672252655,
0.47254127264022827,
0.19145943224430084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12059v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12059v2
|
STYLE: Improving Domain Transferability of Asking Clarification Questions in Large Language Model Powered Conversational Agents
| 2024-05-20T14:28:25 | 2024-06-01T07:38:37 |
Yue Chen, Chen Huang, Yang Deng, Wenqiang Lei, Dingnan Jin, Jia Liu, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Equipping a conversational search engine with strategies regarding when to
ask clarification questions is becoming increasingly important across various
domains. Attributing to the context understanding capability of LLMs and their
access to domain-specific sources of knowledge, LLM-based clarification
strategies feature rapid transfer to various domains in a post-hoc manner.
However, they still struggle to deliver promising performance on unseen
domains, struggling to achieve effective domain transferability. We take the
first step to investigate this issue and existing methods tend to produce
one-size-fits-all strategies across diverse domains, limiting their search
effectiveness. In response, we introduce a novel method, called Style, to
achieve effective domain transferability. Our experimental results indicate
that Style bears strong domain transferability, resulting in an average search
performance improvement of ~10% on four unseen domains.
|
[
-0.5933629274368286,
-1.1263505220413208,
0.7118736505508423,
0.262018084526062,
-0.3548244833946228,
0.21855823695659637,
-0.5291785001754761,
-0.5199044346809387,
0.13623663783073425,
0.48863545060157776,
-0.7565324902534485,
-0.4187716841697693,
-0.6268868446350098,
0.1270800530910492,
-0.24729976058006287,
0.7420600652694702,
-0.04065881669521332,
-0.27403685450553894,
-0.45278045535087585,
-0.2015346735715866,
-0.4330185055732727,
-0.700452983379364,
-0.8062311410903931,
-0.3708309233188629,
0.26548194885253906,
0.5929014086723328,
0.8572814464569092,
0.5060575008392334,
0.6366440057754517,
0.2412242740392685,
-0.20975148677825928,
0.5431113839149475,
-0.7329103350639343,
0.45475077629089355,
-0.5603886842727661,
-0.3574216663837433,
-0.47271594405174255,
-0.3261028528213501,
0.4009174108505249,
0.8197280764579773,
0.07992587238550186,
-0.030451569706201553,
-0.11904770135879517,
0.6577103734016418,
-0.6029989123344421,
0.1726577877998352,
-0.8465551733970642,
-0.24438513815402985,
-0.09166575223207474,
-0.7948017716407776,
-0.5308256149291992,
-0.43982791900634766,
0.5709587335586548,
-0.9244012236595154,
0.19036240875720978,
-0.012576868757605553,
0.8897225260734558,
0.1292819231748581,
-0.5177525281906128,
-0.3553067147731781,
-0.7481149435043335,
0.7139002084732056,
-0.4193246364593506,
0.3006734848022461,
0.2644346058368683,
0.526180624961853,
-0.06187941133975983,
-1.2325793504714966,
-0.5499456524848938,
0.048876918852329254,
-0.24966003000736237,
-0.35527223348617554,
-0.17645469307899475,
-0.02045426145195961,
0.22144407033920288,
0.011140592396259308,
-0.46936455368995667,
-0.31945446133613586,
-0.3287731409072876,
-0.18189384043216705,
0.8466755151748657,
-0.13698086142539978,
0.28988906741142273,
0.4887882173061371,
-0.21227185428142548,
-0.009339812211692333,
-0.779008150100708,
0.024540169164538383,
-0.13714510202407837,
0.19629862904548645,
0.22193561494350433,
-0.03707580268383026,
-0.38235631585121155,
0.7117241024971008,
0.26930874586105347,
-0.2614649832248688,
-0.12712275981903076,
-0.5608314275741577,
0.08966027945280075,
-0.0954396054148674,
0.1765061765909195,
0.6346831917762756,
0.463577002286911,
-0.2061772346496582,
-0.14548179507255554,
-0.4801921546459198,
0.3968384563922882,
-1.0788249969482422,
-0.16872809827327728,
0.10679139196872711,
-0.3938644230365753,
0.0036052039358764887,
-0.16779527068138123,
-0.7941204309463501,
-0.44416454434394836,
-0.49238160252571106,
0.6494151949882507,
-0.3142572045326233,
-0.078154057264328,
0.18062584102153778,
-0.1383192539215088,
0.6257755756378174,
0.9117371439933777,
-0.8493189811706543,
0.30793502926826477,
0.7253860831260681,
0.7639607787132263,
-0.36883944272994995,
-0.06915374100208282,
-0.31993529200553894,
-0.005778566002845764,
-0.3155083656311035,
0.7705504894256592,
-0.49144312739372253,
-0.5751001834869385,
0.2707233428955078,
0.3149382770061493,
-0.34147313237190247,
-0.5241144299507141,
0.294620543718338,
-0.9045587778091431,
0.004539020359516144,
-0.3510196805000305,
-0.6138277053833008,
-0.4013998806476593,
0.23296719789505005,
-0.39517778158187866,
0.7309389114379883,
0.06331314146518707,
-0.1997540146112442,
0.1944526880979538,
-0.7354632019996643,
-0.7039561867713928,
0.31270959973335266,
0.16946156322956085,
-0.27608051896095276,
-0.24150316417217255,
0.30173423886299133,
0.41158124804496765,
-0.028288843110203743,
-0.01385530922561884,
-0.35306864976882935,
-0.5007413625717163,
0.36729392409324646,
-0.0645015761256218,
0.5419469475746155,
0.3828493058681488,
-0.4797472059726715,
0.11687120795249939,
-0.4978535771369934,
0.30386409163475037,
0.3979230523109436,
0.11337185651063919,
-0.4567434787750244,
-0.36041003465652466,
-0.07022398710250854,
0.11857613921165466,
0.5962517857551575,
0.03785610944032669,
0.5473185181617737,
-0.14165623486042023,
0.5767407417297363,
0.6703829765319824,
0.28585946559906006,
0.6933780908584595,
-0.4918937385082245,
0.6383511424064636,
-0.4584590196609497,
0.3254311680793762,
0.003972148522734642,
-0.4762429893016815,
-0.8297380805015564,
0.014207273721694946,
0.03326789662241936,
0.4502267837524414,
-0.904338538646698,
0.21753400564193726,
-0.212594673037529,
-0.58134925365448,
-0.4497341513633728,
0.1724303662776947,
0.31763380765914917,
0.3133622705936432,
0.3477000594139099,
-0.33064818382263184,
-0.44313427805900574,
-0.8208777904510498,
-0.2295948714017868,
0.08241186290979385,
0.3058573603630066,
0.46061787009239197,
0.5967965126037598,
-0.22899560630321503,
1.02646005153656,
-0.5031643509864807,
0.17494110763072968,
-0.5270437002182007,
0.07587384432554245,
-0.09975820779800415,
0.3012482523918152,
0.579910933971405,
-1.0889968872070312,
-0.6371945142745972,
0.1282048523426056,
-0.5164021253585815,
-0.2271481603384018,
0.005683937110006809,
-0.37358683347702026,
0.1903419941663742,
0.7553924918174744,
-0.631396472454071,
0.42493852972984314,
0.28121647238731384,
-0.20479045808315277,
0.43755921721458435,
-0.11361222714185715,
0.2445230782032013,
-0.9350303411483765,
0.23674042522907257,
-0.19041503965854645,
-0.5106992721557617,
-0.9390825629234314,
0.30772867798805237,
0.02397644706070423,
-0.008109577000141144,
-0.6497734189033508,
0.9566516280174255,
-0.4184274673461914,
0.1756339818239212,
-0.39083167910575867,
0.5543493032455444,
0.4615456461906433,
0.6437845826148987,
-0.021903742104768753,
1.2153445482254028,
0.5300608277320862,
-1.116040825843811,
0.22414332628250122,
0.32625332474708557,
0.024743730202317238,
0.8507618308067322,
-0.7560195326805115,
0.5960111618041992,
-0.04134945943951607,
0.38335829973220825,
-1.0330398082733154,
-0.13592076301574707,
-0.008126703090965748,
-0.2943136692047119,
0.43190181255340576,
-0.41866180300712585,
-0.3250464200973511,
-0.10320694744586945,
-0.26078587770462036,
0.6103852987289429,
0.5058286190032959,
-0.714800238609314,
0.4646056592464447,
0.24887095391750336,
-0.36754992604255676,
-0.521547257900238,
-0.21069404482841492,
0.04756278172135353,
-0.34704890847206116,
-1.0065810680389404,
0.5564577579498291,
-0.5171505808830261,
-0.538017988204956,
-0.4276733696460724,
-0.23256854712963104,
-0.3865048885345459,
0.38483598828315735,
-0.05760510265827179,
0.1968839168548584,
-0.21751780807971954,
0.026016078889369965,
-0.23243457078933716,
0.4245411455631256,
-0.012791742570698261,
-0.2607342600822449,
0.6885111331939697,
-0.2134188562631607,
-0.18694821000099182,
-0.5043774247169495,
0.16848687827587128,
0.8683928847312927,
-0.31474560499191284,
0.7352723479270935,
0.43855980038642883,
-0.029555484652519226,
-0.671891450881958,
-0.5676219463348389,
-0.5015050172805786,
-0.5282210111618042,
0.21188083291053772,
-0.5371950268745422,
-1.1241259574890137,
0.6230177879333496,
-0.44130533933639526,
-0.0009957635775208473,
0.2628364562988281,
0.3665735423564911,
0.2072533369064331,
1.0012346506118774,
0.8959904909133911,
0.179504856467247,
0.5471116304397583,
-0.11209360510110855,
0.33067718148231506,
-0.565852165222168,
-0.25900256633758545,
-0.5289633274078369,
-0.2605639696121216,
-0.634086012840271,
-0.39882978796958923,
0.2035965472459793,
0.11745095998048782,
0.14554917812347412,
0.4861021041870117,
-0.5110887289047241,
0.46678003668785095,
0.6163909435272217,
0.05984833464026451,
0.4815475046634674,
-0.06112132966518402,
0.17013387382030487,
0.08320333063602448,
-0.5352834463119507,
-0.4146154224872589,
0.9191555976867676,
0.19543513655662537,
0.7189631462097168,
0.39289024472236633,
0.2973036468029022,
0.42116615176200867,
0.15065136551856995,
-1.005658507347107,
0.6955493688583374,
0.0511128269135952,
-0.5226414203643799,
-0.3630167543888092,
-0.181583970785141,
-1.0043233633041382,
0.33583468198776245,
0.11421976238489151,
-0.6733202934265137,
0.21492446959018707,
0.023375436663627625,
-0.20057223737239838,
0.09015924483537674,
-0.6268162727355957,
0.6617128252983093,
-0.0757969319820404,
-0.5490191578865051,
-0.07506559044122696,
-0.8291276693344116,
0.05370476096868515,
-0.1188923716545105,
0.16101139783859253,
0.11669359356164932,
-0.053319573402404785,
0.6411075592041016,
-0.5722844004631042,
0.572642982006073,
0.0995732769370079,
-0.23754073679447174,
0.35780441761016846,
0.28048932552337646,
0.6362000107765198,
-0.11066500097513199,
0.1019110381603241,
0.06540347635746002,
0.027068166062235832,
-0.46379032731056213,
-1.2291350364685059,
0.5167505741119385,
-0.5785743594169617,
-0.8938347101211548,
-0.04114243760704994,
-0.5450698137283325,
-0.39943864941596985,
0.32516270875930786,
0.15814703702926636,
0.42073115706443787,
-0.1552472859621048,
0.36032381653785706,
1.0890443325042725,
0.09538623690605164,
0.22160764038562775,
0.9010109901428223,
-0.25021064281463623,
0.03207702562212944,
0.6341251134872437,
-0.02228599227964878,
0.48305198550224304,
0.39335358142852783,
-0.03753693401813507,
-0.500264048576355,
-0.5565296411514282,
-0.3620748221874237,
0.4574701488018036,
-1.0489078760147095,
0.09768296033143997,
-0.45687857270240784,
-0.3343268632888794,
-0.7566829323768616,
-0.5120623111724854,
-0.15281899273395538,
-0.5577235817909241,
-0.24173811078071594,
0.06041501462459564,
0.5831767916679382,
0.7708263993263245,
0.40321898460388184,
0.5013065338134766,
-0.5045146942138672,
-0.08860905468463898,
0.5332074165344238,
0.04210060089826584,
-0.27835574746131897,
-0.974062442779541,
-0.04023495689034462,
-0.2295190691947937,
-0.2910289168357849,
-0.8219963312149048,
0.40681421756744385,
0.22629202902317047,
0.5509699583053589,
0.31390097737312317,
0.2212967872619629,
0.6242905259132385,
-0.19108156859874725,
0.8363434672355652,
-0.2924090027809143,
-0.9185786843299866,
0.7291339039802551,
-0.24918285012245178,
0.22705993056297302,
0.7152560353279114,
0.5605297088623047,
-0.5865658521652222,
-0.05882291495800018,
-0.727514386177063,
-0.8703508377075195,
0.5854171514511108,
0.20383518934249878,
0.060391515493392944,
0.22460272908210754,
0.502819299697876,
0.009214479476213455,
0.42743486166000366,
-0.21210643649101257,
-0.5878880023956299,
0.09260977059602737,
0.28906846046447754,
0.19108133018016815,
-0.1399993747472763,
-0.3349336087703705,
-0.25179797410964966,
0.833116888999939,
-0.32614651322364807,
0.16501615941524506,
0.45171383023262024,
-0.30980461835861206,
0.07360810786485672,
0.5365177989006042,
0.8536686301231384,
1.1766425371170044,
-0.2099720984697342,
0.25605958700180054,
0.15997134149074554,
-0.34507906436920166,
-0.12161706387996674,
0.09245528280735016,
-0.1888112872838974,
0.17673037946224213,
0.13678348064422607,
0.7220913767814636,
-0.04491995647549629,
-0.6284348368644714,
0.6220683455467224,
-0.18714503943920135,
-0.2955585718154907,
-0.16555938124656677,
0.20776155591011047,
-0.23835919797420502,
0.09358629584312439,
0.29781222343444824,
-0.14942249655723572,
0.15836626291275024,
-0.7571631669998169,
0.3813830316066742,
0.5902812480926514,
-0.29441574215888977,
-0.15094541013240814,
0.33377495408058167,
0.2255043089389801,
-0.3884550631046295,
0.2742168605327606,
-0.13018356263637543,
-0.7487325072288513,
0.6797027587890625,
0.4593324661254883,
0.7127786874771118,
-0.22576123476028442,
0.10685312002897263,
0.10694549977779388,
0.0706484243273735,
-0.20696254074573517,
0.10187322646379471,
-0.34811803698539734,
-0.6154525279998779,
-0.39150649309158325,
-0.2802930772304535,
-0.8793441653251648,
0.20052127540111542,
-0.5340616703033447,
0.2557169795036316,
-0.5810837745666504,
-0.20478057861328125,
-0.07889551669359207,
0.1115206852555275,
-0.7185763716697693,
0.09512852132320404,
-0.14414718747138977,
1.0751149654388428,
-0.3928624987602234,
0.667718231678009,
0.819002091884613,
-0.47184282541275024,
-0.813320517539978,
0.018832314759492874,
-0.03131195530295372,
-1.0636075735092163,
0.5969724059104919,
0.08710002154111862,
-0.588205873966217,
0.0666298046708107,
-1.0205473899841309,
-0.9681432843208313,
1.2915741205215454,
0.13322366774082184,
-0.4426572620868683,
-0.08722879737615585,
-0.14582641422748566,
0.6371718645095825,
-0.33644744753837585,
0.39455923438072205,
0.8110718131065369,
0.6409636735916138,
0.40986573696136475,
-1.1775667667388916,
0.19703862071037292,
-0.3132416009902954,
-0.16281481087207794,
-0.036054518073797226,
-0.8155167102813721,
0.5512304902076721,
-0.15220198035240173,
-0.257343053817749,
0.24566179513931274,
0.4481513202190399,
-0.0023080301471054554,
0.7323374152183533,
0.2642790973186493,
0.16213220357894897,
1.0552030801773071,
-0.04482756182551384,
1.039292335510254,
-0.5166730284690857,
0.3444872796535492,
0.9214569330215454,
-0.29175904393196106,
0.6777183413505554,
0.3992244005203247,
0.02569614350795746,
0.5696443319320679,
0.41391465067863464,
0.3476184904575348,
0.4344794452190399,
0.25116291642189026,
-0.39224472641944885,
-0.28777629137039185,
-0.48665961623191833,
-0.43588730692863464,
0.35084667801856995,
0.4616227149963379,
-0.3836444914340973,
-0.04108965024352074,
-0.2408968061208725,
0.5730077624320984,
0.23925332725048065,
-0.335973858833313,
0.907234787940979,
0.050295814871788025,
-0.9092031121253967,
0.8089424967765808,
-0.08139026910066605,
0.7789199948310852,
-0.8000640273094177,
-0.23525720834732056,
-0.49771714210510254,
0.09225179255008698,
-0.1886972188949585,
-0.6323630213737488,
0.05869894102215767,
-0.4231199026107788,
-0.0764426663517952,
-0.4644221067428589,
1.002440094947815,
-0.40678346157073975,
0.13378825783729553,
0.21833394467830658,
0.7099335789680481,
0.27020952105522156,
-0.22100241482257843,
-0.6803430914878845,
0.05177152529358864,
-0.03518369048833847,
-0.04994133114814758,
0.3877907693386078,
0.7125612497329712,
-0.22753959894180298,
0.9456450939178467,
0.6079813838005066,
-0.03615715727210045,
-0.05228932946920395,
0.05718066543340683,
0.8489229083061218,
-0.3968628942966461,
-0.34196507930755615,
-0.7465852499008179,
0.015522045083343983,
-0.13488875329494476,
-0.1324140578508377,
0.9998501539230347,
0.10931656509637833,
0.7914971113204956,
0.033721040934324265,
0.7998020648956299,
0.10980534553527832,
0.3077948987483978,
-0.4691818058490753,
0.7344592213630676,
-0.7223567962646484,
0.2614094316959381,
-0.041439883410930634,
-0.8060396909713745,
-0.24152155220508575,
0.623501181602478,
-0.3325943350791931,
0.25428181886672974,
0.8905704617500305,
0.9909787178039551,
0.09770669788122177,
0.04847459867596626,
0.41548073291778564,
0.043182920664548874,
0.34039950370788574,
0.41666603088378906,
0.648809015750885,
-0.08298955857753754,
0.6630746722221375,
-0.39872899651527405,
-0.0942850261926651,
-0.6587697863578796,
-0.7533789277076721,
-0.7882121801376343,
-0.5459803938865662,
-0.48778510093688965,
-0.5854518413543701,
0.4161759912967682,
0.921566903591156,
1.1766598224639893,
-0.6208840012550354,
-0.141584113240242,
0.17879848182201385,
0.2735196352005005,
-0.22245407104492188,
-0.33468273282051086,
0.29338058829307556,
-0.4873860776424408,
-0.7591608762741089,
0.5725582838058472,
0.24104519188404083,
-0.0868980661034584,
-0.19101792573928833,
0.023851575329899788,
-0.047349534928798676,
0.4266084134578705,
0.7376552224159241,
0.43761250376701355,
-0.5311794877052307,
-0.31937283277511597,
0.21554794907569885,
-0.21084432303905487,
0.049817897379398346,
1.1523454189300537,
-0.3872828781604767,
0.5894825458526611,
0.46006807684898376,
0.8812957406044006,
0.3270666301250458,
0.3687165081501007,
0.6496003270149231,
-0.9764335751533508,
-0.13991506397724152,
0.08093686401844025,
0.23562683165073395,
0.377991646528244,
-0.616936981678009,
0.6151361465454102,
0.3871047794818878,
-0.8422639966011047,
-0.28891393542289734,
0.21094928681850433,
-1.2215206623077393,
-0.517304003238678,
1.4895954132080078,
-0.06472174823284149,
-0.27497291564941406,
-0.3842509686946869,
-0.3646913468837738,
-0.016308262944221497,
-0.6720485687255859,
0.6097811460494995,
0.7472931742668152,
-0.3021542429924011,
-0.08525484055280685,
-0.5108660459518433,
0.7854915261268616,
0.48612916469573975,
-0.7164921760559082,
0.030210129916667938,
0.3727481961250305,
0.4616129696369171,
0.21685686707496643,
0.8057916164398193,
0.016823215410113335,
0.3677796423435211,
-0.44608065485954285,
-0.14291492104530334,
0.056897491216659546,
-0.47018009424209595,
-0.27858731150627136,
0.3038102090358734,
0.36745306849479675,
0.02944101393222809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12055v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12055v1
|
Unveiling factors influencing judgment variation in Sentiment Analysis with Natural Language Processing and Statistics
| 2024-05-20T14:24:18 | 2024-05-20T14:24:18 |
Olga Kellert, Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez, Mahmud Uz Zaman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, 91F20, I.2.7
|
TripAdvisor reviews and comparable data sources play an important role in
many tasks in Natural Language Processing (NLP), providing a data basis for the
identification and classification of subjective judgments, such as hotel or
restaurant reviews, into positive or negative polarities. This study explores
three important factors influencing variation in crowdsourced polarity
judgments, focusing on TripAdvisor reviews in Spanish. Three hypotheses are
tested: the role of Part Of Speech (POS), the impact of sentiment words such as
"tasty", and the influence of neutral words like "ok" on judgment variation.
The study's methodology employs one-word titles, demonstrating their efficacy
in studying polarity variation of words. Statistical tests on mean equality are
performed on word groups of our interest. The results of this study reveal that
adjectives in one-word titles tend to result in lower judgment variation
compared to other word types or POS. Sentiment words contribute to lower
judgment variation as well, emphasizing the significance of sentiment words in
research on polarity judgments, and neutral words are associated with higher
judgment variation as expected. However, these effects cannot be always
reproduced in longer titles, which suggests that longer titles do not represent
the best data source for testing the ambiguity of single words due to the
influence on word polarity by other words like negation in longer titles. This
empirical investigation contributes valuable insights into the factors
influencing polarity variation of words, providing a foundation for NLP
practitioners that aim to capture and predict polarity judgments in Spanish and
for researchers that aim to understand factors influencing judgment variation.
|
[
-0.8305277824401855,
-0.5618941783905029,
0.31613653898239136,
0.629645824432373,
-0.4806272089481354,
0.09149200469255447,
-0.13524363934993744,
-0.6800554990768433,
0.6533941030502319,
0.5846309065818787,
-0.26771795749664307,
-0.5271393060684204,
-0.7659538388252258,
0.44061875343322754,
0.0857330784201622,
1.2486516237258911,
0.029207579791545868,
0.4309218227863312,
-0.13701002299785614,
-0.6073207259178162,
-0.3072109520435333,
-0.56406569480896,
-0.33007892966270447,
-0.5087983012199402,
0.7346704006195068,
0.46283450722694397,
1.0611518621444702,
-0.04765767976641655,
0.7818675637245178,
0.1912633180618286,
-0.2157069593667984,
-0.011492504738271236,
-0.12919826805591583,
0.01910240761935711,
-0.6036074757575989,
-0.6597530245780945,
-0.42636170983314514,
0.3554987609386444,
0.2782614529132843,
0.8708536624908447,
-0.18605713546276093,
0.13938221335411072,
0.02794216014444828,
1.227434754371643,
-0.5502057671546936,
0.08992095291614532,
-0.2671772539615631,
0.20882849395275116,
-0.112772136926651,
-0.20700407028198242,
-0.020672794431447983,
-0.5590499639511108,
0.4548945128917694,
-0.2686341404914856,
0.7009261250495911,
0.16103196144104004,
0.9473462700843811,
0.16014467179775238,
-0.44918009638786316,
-0.34412574768066406,
-0.7882426977157593,
1.092219352722168,
-0.8263160586357117,
0.46214646100997925,
0.49458232522010803,
-0.2187904268503189,
-0.057958025485277176,
-0.05147085338830948,
-0.6013583540916443,
-0.3751329183578491,
0.07869802415370941,
0.19630734622478485,
-0.12079863250255585,
0.24942004680633545,
0.1908351331949234,
0.6012756824493408,
-0.13174831867218018,
-0.11111627519130707,
-0.1303175687789917,
0.08239421248435974,
0.47046759724617004,
0.09476003795862198,
0.2889983355998993,
-0.7099366784095764,
-0.2082565426826477,
-0.15881997346878052,
-0.6214503049850464,
0.35886600613594055,
0.756946861743927,
0.24223564565181732,
0.062344495207071304,
0.7367850542068481,
-0.456545889377594,
0.5984974503517151,
-0.16373978555202484,
0.01994144544005394,
0.4910675287246704,
-0.32403069734573364,
-0.27447792887687683,
-0.14730361104011536,
0.6662005186080933,
0.9929446578025818,
-0.055193014442920685,
-0.0690879225730896,
-0.1696568727493286,
0.11155804246664047,
0.1320790797472,
-0.5519135594367981,
-0.011639081872999668,
0.1267433911561966,
-0.44269853830337524,
-0.45779645442962646,
0.767830491065979,
-1.0903455018997192,
-0.771407425403595,
-0.36227235198020935,
-0.19222518801689148,
-0.03532399982213974,
-0.20217008888721466,
0.46684327721595764,
-0.5969005227088928,
0.5066194534301758,
0.2844266891479492,
-0.30776840448379517,
0.47461509704589844,
0.5219597816467285,
0.6150695085525513,
-0.5502694249153137,
-0.25216490030288696,
-0.19543203711509705,
-0.5938540101051331,
-0.2660144567489624,
0.8205291032791138,
-0.2768280804157257,
-0.5010319352149963,
-0.10306531935930252,
0.08376774191856384,
-0.03857553377747536,
-0.5611065030097961,
0.6740593314170837,
-0.4874373972415924,
0.6420525312423706,
-0.47452643513679504,
-0.2443196177482605,
-0.6120092868804932,
0.1344659924507141,
-0.7165559530258179,
0.8160033822059631,
0.05294240638613701,
-1.097805380821228,
0.6045511364936829,
-0.21953408420085907,
-0.6607939600944519,
0.00033344601979479194,
-0.09885512292385101,
-0.4073076546192169,
0.5528304576873779,
0.12194836884737015,
0.03553501516580582,
-0.5486953854560852,
0.15483149886131287,
-0.0870521292090416,
0.1508823037147522,
0.5856252908706665,
-0.11455154418945312,
0.7379969954490662,
0.02727910317480564,
-0.46481120586395264,
-0.063185915350914,
-0.3680078983306885,
-0.34582293033599854,
0.08003870397806168,
-0.24357153475284576,
-0.5732841491699219,
0.46951591968536377,
0.08751286566257477,
0.03933455049991608,
0.13839690387248993,
-0.711260199546814,
-0.05466769263148308,
-0.6943305730819702,
-0.17169591784477234,
0.3558056354522705,
0.5454874634742737,
0.5542666912078857,
-0.26117029786109924,
1.0152783393859863,
-0.004205720499157906,
0.4980086386203766,
0.4991426169872284,
-0.8431409001350403,
-0.8275940418243408,
0.029679248109459877,
0.27593374252319336,
0.6135039925575256,
-0.6905932426452637,
0.13523022830486298,
0.011562572792172432,
-0.31558772921562195,
-0.5013710856437683,
0.20154544711112976,
0.36079707741737366,
0.418226420879364,
0.3419485092163086,
-0.5652235746383667,
-0.5902742147445679,
-0.9327899813652039,
-0.5752483010292053,
-0.1731606274843216,
0.1341717690229416,
0.38897430896759033,
0.30292290449142456,
0.04478581249713898,
0.9180231690406799,
-0.6691229343414307,
-0.5163602828979492,
-0.5069252252578735,
0.43348342180252075,
0.5762795209884644,
0.11199181526899338,
0.6941804885864258,
-0.8168922066688538,
-0.4790152907371521,
-0.1386900097131729,
-0.30308225750923157,
-0.11506257951259613,
0.15154018998146057,
0.15140502154827118,
0.20939794182777405,
0.16590027511119843,
-0.30278223752975464,
0.3806937336921692,
0.5318459272384644,
-0.49938955903053284,
0.3002448081970215,
-0.03849866986274719,
0.3478895127773285,
-0.6422668695449829,
-0.4867047667503357,
0.31129154562950134,
0.07567309588193893,
-0.5292102098464966,
0.15623587369918823,
-0.21968324482440948,
0.4322585463523865,
-0.47832393646240234,
0.13493767380714417,
-0.39369651675224304,
0.24377630650997162,
-0.2998097240924835,
-0.13696248829364777,
0.3566833436489105,
0.24274365603923798,
-0.003448525909334421,
0.49941080808639526,
0.6273269653320312,
-0.5022962093353271,
0.28128594160079956,
-0.1177850216627121,
-0.44125881791114807,
0.48669326305389404,
-0.6468968987464905,
0.0360565185546875,
-0.5734854340553284,
0.04983978718519211,
-1.0406746864318848,
-0.06965193152427673,
0.25240278244018555,
-0.3747227191925049,
-0.0802290290594101,
-0.029184356331825256,
-0.4261004328727722,
-0.3367599546909332,
-0.8494544625282288,
0.10856790840625763,
0.06015076860785484,
-0.26339447498321533,
0.5066947937011719,
0.5792286992073059,
-0.2524837851524353,
-0.6623610258102417,
-0.5818637013435364,
0.09646295756101608,
-0.296443372964859,
-0.14538061618804932,
0.25206729769706726,
0.06992708891630173,
-0.7191387414932251,
-0.24512028694152832,
-0.29269763827323914,
0.12958990037441254,
-0.04406193271279335,
0.3727536201477051,
0.3361344635486603,
-0.004249530378729105,
0.08805403858423233,
0.07635954022407532,
0.19270777702331543,
0.26478540897369385,
0.18102844059467316,
0.6642633080482483,
-0.4796617031097412,
0.10302359610795975,
-0.370421826839447,
0.22358231246471405,
0.6394912004470825,
-0.2506304383277893,
0.660897433757782,
0.10167108476161957,
0.054492488503456116,
-0.029303791001439095,
-0.6377309560775757,
0.0723397433757782,
-0.33020809292793274,
0.08502422273159027,
0.006865760777145624,
-0.42495763301849365,
0.6468114256858826,
0.5258742570877075,
-0.3757421672344208,
0.6286906003952026,
0.35870295763015747,
-0.23040074110031128,
1.0602437257766724,
0.49267348647117615,
-0.22331905364990234,
0.7377027273178101,
-0.15181976556777954,
0.2287987321615219,
-0.7012217044830322,
-0.2151242047548294,
-0.7031181454658508,
-0.20398274064064026,
-1.0329818725585938,
-0.46326908469200134,
0.0676693320274353,
-0.0986124649643898,
0.3255646824836731,
-0.055814675986766815,
-0.25870367884635925,
0.5574309825897217,
0.4744601249694824,
0.2180565893650055,
0.45743733644485474,
-0.15094591677188873,
0.023471493273973465,
-0.13202497363090515,
-0.31580850481987,
-0.45448437333106995,
0.9301053285598755,
0.40305519104003906,
0.7817788124084473,
0.10220693796873093,
0.4993584156036377,
0.5159175992012024,
0.2296433299779892,
-1.0508085489273071,
0.5758577585220337,
-0.13315612077713013,
-0.5341669321060181,
-0.04960229992866516,
-0.27788421511650085,
-0.7694123387336731,
0.3610824644565582,
-0.16901853680610657,
-0.24014203250408173,
0.6281641721725464,
-0.30416780710220337,
-0.1275370866060257,
0.07192239165306091,
-0.6870193481445312,
0.4616962969303131,
-0.25311627984046936,
-0.2729012668132782,
-0.16963495314121246,
-0.5769741535186768,
0.035135190933942795,
0.2616000771522522,
0.39271071553230286,
-0.36853641271591187,
-0.035369232296943665,
1.0445866584777832,
-0.25402015447616577,
0.8625205755233765,
-0.38063591718673706,
-0.11952991783618927,
0.3364272117614746,
0.14299288392066956,
0.20532451570034027,
0.2992022931575775,
-0.16589520871639252,
0.5060163736343384,
-0.25004127621650696,
-0.16814829409122467,
-0.2579202950000763,
0.6379550099372864,
-0.7937842607498169,
-0.5396121144294739,
-0.5706897974014282,
-0.29000532627105713,
-0.3479790687561035,
-0.09400497376918793,
0.5231336951255798,
0.05050469562411308,
-0.2882993817329407,
0.17169399559497833,
0.5119134187698364,
-0.2965661883354187,
0.43315526843070984,
0.5233303904533386,
-0.49212542176246643,
-0.5260128378868103,
0.7781698703765869,
0.13420253992080688,
0.025573614984750748,
0.3131773769855499,
0.4064292311668396,
-0.19440104067325592,
-0.45615193247795105,
-0.09921808540821075,
0.3106319010257721,
-0.43901169300079346,
-0.21128331124782562,
-0.4994576871395111,
0.36358723044395447,
-0.3645893931388855,
0.05122528597712517,
-0.4062093198299408,
-0.6331095695495605,
-0.3039035201072693,
-0.42322444915771484,
0.24002137780189514,
0.7649577856063843,
0.18039332330226898,
0.3613188564777374,
-0.194576233625412,
0.47033804655075073,
0.251713365316391,
0.49101588129997253,
-0.16201385855674744,
-0.4359818398952484,
-0.10352380573749542,
-0.27131348848342896,
-0.16140252351760864,
-1.2270736694335938,
0.3911729156970978,
-0.036715343594551086,
0.34702491760253906,
0.6810584664344788,
0.015902794897556305,
0.11933879554271698,
0.09403131902217865,
0.9705308675765991,
0.4461728632450104,
-0.6909486651420593,
0.6218470931053162,
-0.39565393328666687,
0.14964912831783295,
0.8732873797416687,
0.28939396142959595,
-0.33285415172576904,
-0.8453518748283386,
-0.6566160321235657,
-0.9753005504608154,
0.523919939994812,
0.103335902094841,
0.0513482391834259,
-0.1240399032831192,
0.02352217771112919,
0.37461718916893005,
0.5202623009681702,
-0.9024708867073059,
-0.4361327886581421,
-0.37735918164253235,
0.3669333755970001,
-0.2338542640209198,
-0.3726849853992462,
-0.2891205847263336,
-0.5740399956703186,
0.5072768330574036,
0.20374049246311188,
-0.00994555652141571,
0.3791244924068451,
0.09905602782964706,
-0.1315634846687317,
0.5372442007064819,
0.49432089924812317,
0.5808894038200378,
-0.5644048452377319,
0.2865737974643707,
0.08574935793876648,
-0.6215155124664307,
-0.25790151953697205,
-0.08108973503112793,
-0.2752126157283783,
0.33507224917411804,
0.13813847303390503,
0.6800576448440552,
-0.28949880599975586,
-0.37190040946006775,
0.711635410785675,
-0.19558684527873993,
0.04204714298248291,
-0.16331936419010162,
-0.12226259708404541,
-0.46512627601623535,
-0.03914804011583328,
0.2902049422264099,
0.253187358379364,
0.4703017473220825,
-0.5430117845535278,
-0.29856663942337036,
0.4918707311153412,
-0.42131516337394714,
-0.3617509603500366,
0.24586771428585052,
0.21635118126869202,
-0.2424214631319046,
0.3123456835746765,
-0.41842031478881836,
-0.6250311732292175,
0.7603267431259155,
0.162937730550766,
1.032669186592102,
-0.27274736762046814,
0.6061968207359314,
0.21285094320774078,
0.43129613995552063,
-0.06709033995866776,
0.5336007475852966,
-0.015097721479833126,
-0.8745359182357788,
-0.21452142298221588,
-0.6784074902534485,
-0.6897361874580383,
-0.16696122288703918,
-1.067272424697876,
0.1631833165884018,
-0.49731600284576416,
-0.7074621915817261,
-0.2368566244840622,
-0.21487587690353394,
-0.6751323342323303,
0.35753363370895386,
0.1395123451948166,
0.39176544547080994,
-1.0073344707489014,
0.32463574409484863,
0.9740701913833618,
-0.6535102128982544,
-0.45521700382232666,
0.2328261137008667,
-0.29554471373558044,
-0.24867257475852966,
0.40437614917755127,
0.01243234146386385,
-0.6803494691848755,
-0.4847094714641571,
-0.6763657331466675,
-0.45441532135009766,
0.26972150802612305,
-0.10035883635282516,
-0.13063445687294006,
0.015113833360373974,
0.33899009227752686,
0.9469074606895447,
-0.29705801606178284,
-0.010147358290851116,
0.5346671342849731,
0.3650539219379425,
-0.2537750005722046,
-0.6881536245346069,
-0.1354222148656845,
-0.07789295166730881,
-0.04732012376189232,
0.15014012157917023,
-0.4209831655025482,
0.8431973457336426,
-0.24769459664821625,
-0.10137705504894257,
-0.43133142590522766,
0.3924415707588196,
-0.01274820789694786,
0.5675103068351746,
0.4940795302391052,
0.4908747971057892,
0.5519998669624329,
-0.025105902925133705,
1.1821564435958862,
-0.28454872965812683,
0.6119840145111084,
1.0497103929519653,
-0.1187184602022171,
0.7021207809448242,
1.0427860021591187,
-0.38026851415634155,
1.0016053915023804,
0.33290591835975647,
-0.04696115851402283,
0.6318926215171814,
0.16575336456298828,
-0.2145383656024933,
0.0990653857588768,
-0.4744686186313629,
-0.2859863042831421,
0.7182707190513611,
0.1830851137638092,
-0.5282941460609436,
-0.0913114920258522,
0.25934407114982605,
0.10059668123722076,
-0.13036158680915833,
-0.4449010491371155,
0.6965777277946472,
0.003749049734324217,
-0.8027358055114746,
0.016749994829297066,
0.37781307101249695,
0.6474098563194275,
-0.22046011686325073,
0.18450795114040375,
-0.5573613047599792,
-0.12770478427410126,
-0.5392343401908875,
-0.8105486631393433,
0.13922211527824402,
0.0343477763235569,
-0.43686148524284363,
-0.4257287085056305,
0.481857031583786,
0.40855440497398376,
-0.4370327591896057,
0.3399618864059448,
0.7121830582618713,
-0.13177978992462158,
-0.35872796177864075,
-0.3390643894672394,
-0.2769429683685303,
0.17128726840019226,
-0.5135352611541748,
0.10831449180841446,
0.26835405826568604,
0.12392159551382065,
0.18468926846981049,
0.4350692331790924,
0.431255578994751,
0.2796061038970947,
0.49650949239730835,
0.6153996586799622,
-0.9549090266227722,
-0.46242690086364746,
-0.6826580166816711,
0.1493634730577469,
-0.09274370223283768,
-0.5622395873069763,
0.9216352105140686,
0.7074177265167236,
0.6725912690162659,
-0.30498167872428894,
0.4500640630722046,
-0.19339242577552795,
0.517561674118042,
-0.26269155740737915,
0.5516931414604187,
-0.2301281988620758,
0.37678301334381104,
-0.4261157214641571,
-0.9512096047401428,
-0.39156997203826904,
0.5703442096710205,
-0.7170500159263611,
-0.1085234209895134,
0.8403058648109436,
0.5905270576477051,
0.40212154388427734,
0.2188047617673874,
-0.05594893544912338,
0.0986817479133606,
0.11840590089559555,
-0.1626487374305725,
1.0105628967285156,
-0.26392048597335815,
0.024325566366314888,
-0.5275974273681641,
-0.30532246828079224,
-0.230683371424675,
-0.7882747054100037,
-0.6644364595413208,
-0.26777997612953186,
-0.486642062664032,
-0.5229719877243042,
-0.28298965096473694,
0.7301177978515625,
0.10540209710597992,
-1.0094269514083862,
-0.3894749879837036,
-0.4132879078388214,
0.5972076058387756,
-0.316200852394104,
-0.4119221270084381,
0.18429191410541534,
-0.2523605525493622,
-0.7250619530677795,
0.13578735291957855,
0.2647668421268463,
-0.03894168138504028,
-0.2609028220176697,
0.18262620270252228,
-0.014020053669810295,
0.30476710200309753,
0.6044638156890869,
0.24098528921604156,
-0.5787667632102966,
-0.06995010375976562,
0.16832712292671204,
-0.14668427407741547,
0.3493235409259796,
0.8878644108772278,
-0.5539166331291199,
0.6090043187141418,
0.7316792011260986,
-0.021298130974173546,
0.21186494827270508,
0.1489368975162506,
0.27146103978157043,
-0.6279274821281433,
0.09252304583787918,
0.46700936555862427,
0.3595805764198303,
0.43235886096954346,
-0.26175326108932495,
0.3509323000907898,
0.5204718112945557,
-0.3473953604698181,
-0.5876309871673584,
0.3156384229660034,
-1.2655388116836548,
-0.07204575091600418,
1.410078525543213,
0.37603381276130676,
0.021027779206633568,
-0.13104654848575592,
-0.30574244260787964,
-0.017058108001947403,
-0.5095235705375671,
1.0356019735336304,
0.9921875,
-0.7963467836380005,
0.21414588391780853,
-0.6231324672698975,
0.4394253194332123,
0.46881553530693054,
-0.5698332786560059,
-0.17208977043628693,
0.5387903451919556,
0.29603832960128784,
0.2763107419013977,
0.39652612805366516,
-0.22679243981838226,
0.061061035841703415,
-0.43435072898864746,
0.2677516043186188,
0.5088817477226257,
-0.2613179385662079,
-0.41280338168144226,
0.3141644299030304,
0.23417814075946808,
-0.2729607820510864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12035v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12035v1
|
KG-RAG: Bridging the Gap Between Knowledge and Creativity
| 2024-05-20T14:03:05 | 2024-05-20T14:03:05 |
Diego Sanmartin
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Ensuring factual accuracy while maintaining the creative capabilities of
Large Language Model Agents (LMAs) poses significant challenges in the
development of intelligent agent systems. LMAs face prevalent issues such as
information hallucinations, catastrophic forgetting, and limitations in
processing long contexts when dealing with knowledge-intensive tasks. This
paper introduces a KG-RAG (Knowledge Graph-Retrieval Augmented Generation)
pipeline, a novel framework designed to enhance the knowledge capabilities of
LMAs by integrating structured Knowledge Graphs (KGs) with the functionalities
of LLMs, thereby significantly reducing the reliance on the latent knowledge of
LLMs. The KG-RAG pipeline constructs a KG from unstructured text and then
performs information retrieval over the newly created graph to perform KGQA
(Knowledge Graph Question Answering). The retrieval methodology leverages a
novel algorithm called Chain of Explorations (CoE) which benefits from LLMs
reasoning to explore nodes and relationships within the KG sequentially.
Preliminary experiments on the ComplexWebQuestions dataset demonstrate notable
improvements in the reduction of hallucinated content and suggest a promising
path toward developing intelligent systems adept at handling
knowledge-intensive tasks.
|
[
-0.5329596996307373,
-0.5997313261032104,
0.7054674625396729,
-0.021621616557240486,
0.05724788457155228,
0.6909492611885071,
0.022760480642318726,
-0.3874818682670593,
0.32204243540763855,
0.7064612507820129,
-0.5132041573524475,
-0.4246451258659363,
-0.5883195996284485,
-0.05668429657816887,
-0.19081872701644897,
0.9386998414993286,
-0.055948276072740555,
-0.3155749440193176,
-0.45878344774246216,
0.02711392566561699,
-0.33490973711013794,
-0.17745408415794373,
-0.4733995199203491,
-0.5892019271850586,
1.01217520236969,
0.1934838443994522,
0.7971562743186951,
0.4705905616283417,
0.43967151641845703,
0.32451409101486206,
-0.045716576278209686,
0.8494386076927185,
-0.7576364278793335,
0.553717315196991,
-0.39050325751304626,
-0.4330672323703766,
-0.3961266875267029,
-0.10398980975151062,
0.42340782284736633,
0.6669471859931946,
-0.012541038915514946,
0.17169621586799622,
0.014231390319764614,
0.8415249586105347,
-0.8133834600448608,
0.31368452310562134,
-0.663690984249115,
0.17956462502479553,
-0.16213077306747437,
-0.4286704659461975,
-0.4080134332180023,
-0.2128644734621048,
-0.03718586638569832,
-0.8134123682975769,
-0.12318026274442673,
0.06915141642093658,
0.6627000570297241,
0.5550364851951599,
-0.4763075113296509,
-0.6730514764785767,
-0.6398975253105164,
0.4581162631511688,
-0.41253453493118286,
0.40210098028182983,
0.28541702032089233,
0.46642377972602844,
-0.400870144367218,
-1.1641050577163696,
-0.7054489850997925,
-0.07516961544752121,
-0.19514261186122894,
0.13689380884170532,
0.14811471104621887,
-0.03925098478794098,
0.1405031532049179,
0.04776535555720329,
-0.37284088134765625,
-0.04708156734704971,
-0.3399112820625305,
-0.28043749928474426,
0.6778011322021484,
0.2734147012233734,
0.2562091052532196,
-0.18776863813400269,
-0.17363645136356354,
-0.10882200300693512,
-0.5342674255371094,
0.08217427879571915,
0.4946374297142029,
0.20373162627220154,
0.3559153378009796,
0.8189243078231812,
-0.3149707019329071,
0.7027310729026794,
-0.32576578855514526,
-0.4221695363521576,
0.21263332664966583,
0.21097247302532196,
-0.06949202716350555,
-0.06705769896507263,
0.5494735240936279,
0.21470919251441956,
0.2280828207731247,
-0.5712547898292542,
-0.280294805765152,
0.0032625198364257812,
0.4284069836139679,
-0.7116575241088867,
-0.1438412368297577,
0.18431700766086578,
-0.10710597038269043,
-0.4528570771217346,
0.030347727239131927,
-0.5058174729347229,
-0.8216370940208435,
-0.25964823365211487,
0.4951551556587219,
-0.2712169289588928,
-0.18224646151065826,
-0.12026437371969223,
-0.5016991496086121,
0.01858500763773918,
0.22712256014347076,
-0.25024449825286865,
0.06085701659321785,
0.6696019768714905,
0.5478000640869141,
-0.10849961638450623,
-0.04447538033127785,
-0.4853033423423767,
0.45120760798454285,
-0.4497984051704407,
0.7741283774375916,
-0.5487180948257446,
-0.21785101294517517,
-0.30589258670806885,
-0.14942717552185059,
-0.024495882913470268,
-0.5774524807929993,
0.4388870894908905,
-1.0598779916763306,
0.09347187727689743,
-0.13086307048797607,
-0.5530105829238892,
-0.3400218188762665,
0.5475593209266663,
-0.5306178331375122,
0.9394820332527161,
0.3887248933315277,
-0.6604041457176208,
0.031164711341261864,
-0.5986182689666748,
-0.23777610063552856,
0.19977201521396637,
-0.20100140571594238,
-0.23076237738132477,
-0.3623189926147461,
0.1706310361623764,
0.3918978273868561,
-0.4498952329158783,
0.3671603798866272,
-0.16756696999073029,
-0.23079277575016022,
0.2160773128271103,
-0.03672186657786369,
0.515504002571106,
0.49720299243927,
0.01810971088707447,
-0.13989689946174622,
-0.8213009238243103,
0.4453378915786743,
0.18772491812705994,
-0.40979355573654175,
-0.3739064037799835,
0.11360623687505722,
-0.5093637704849243,
0.19111250340938568,
0.25350430607795715,
-0.33690544962882996,
0.3758017122745514,
-0.33291491866111755,
0.03499170392751694,
0.7917513251304626,
-0.025179056450724602,
0.4984836280345917,
-0.5126211047172546,
0.6574183106422424,
-0.07000803202390671,
-0.17273081839084625,
-0.08189720660448074,
-0.39910128712654114,
-0.7763786911964417,
-0.22662118077278137,
0.2398039847612381,
0.6620170474052429,
-1.2487568855285645,
0.19682568311691284,
-0.26628580689430237,
-0.7446788549423218,
-0.4148597717285156,
0.2552034258842468,
0.27960047125816345,
0.6551918387413025,
0.149224191904068,
-0.29562708735466003,
-0.486203134059906,
-0.49701493978500366,
-0.2814379930496216,
-0.008857467211782932,
-0.23047000169754028,
0.6149758696556091,
0.22419486939907074,
-0.5276534557342529,
1.158136248588562,
-0.6488229036331177,
-0.22729487717151642,
-0.26896265149116516,
0.07554001361131668,
0.4076080322265625,
0.2239322066307068,
0.2502841055393219,
-0.9847670793533325,
-0.6103444695472717,
0.25333458185195923,
-0.8756696581840515,
-0.3937472105026245,
0.12894102931022644,
-0.33394381403923035,
-0.04449630528688431,
0.4673846662044525,
-0.807399570941925,
0.24217264354228973,
0.4278774857521057,
-0.450334370136261,
0.45710518956184387,
0.08675729483366013,
-0.12437445670366287,
-0.9530993700027466,
0.22684067487716675,
-0.6216920614242554,
-0.18241021037101746,
-0.5457178354263306,
0.11166493594646454,
-0.20358099043369293,
-0.08024963736534119,
-0.16820944845676422,
0.7034398317337036,
-0.3931261897087097,
-0.2437373697757721,
-0.27963486313819885,
0.5630435943603516,
0.29112401604652405,
0.49920138716697693,
-0.483141154050827,
0.6452257633209229,
0.36261188983917236,
-0.7369718551635742,
0.5869012475013733,
0.1609065681695938,
-0.15831807255744934,
0.3370058238506317,
-0.20618849992752075,
0.4492301642894745,
-0.6135082840919495,
0.199506014585495,
-0.7420682311058044,
-0.228416308760643,
0.31000396609306335,
-0.6039871573448181,
0.34755662083625793,
0.008693561889231205,
-0.5081273317337036,
-0.4414716958999634,
-0.021727707237005234,
0.22876711189746857,
0.44993820786476135,
-0.4132930040359497,
0.9698513746261597,
0.4359560012817383,
-0.11598744243383408,
-0.9717666506767273,
-0.3160320818424225,
0.09459291398525238,
-0.015063338913023472,
-0.9088679552078247,
0.36487144231796265,
-0.025149373337626457,
-0.33738312125205994,
0.2829132676124573,
-0.17780491709709167,
0.028894301503896713,
0.1259143054485321,
-0.07693403214216232,
0.05825069174170494,
-0.02247566729784012,
0.23107123374938965,
0.006470261141657829,
-0.023884348571300507,
0.022534657269716263,
-0.45898184180259705,
0.7547721862792969,
0.17648530006408691,
-0.23502564430236816,
0.14364920556545258,
0.01024139765650034,
0.5482339859008789,
-0.2540471851825714,
0.6115007400512695,
0.6742029786109924,
-0.08952047675848007,
-0.6085695028305054,
-0.5248774886131287,
-0.0016203601844608784,
-0.5283465385437012,
0.3473465144634247,
-0.36490491032600403,
-0.9384270310401917,
0.5896376371383667,
-0.47652626037597656,
-0.22606274485588074,
0.41807106137275696,
0.37515610456466675,
-0.24553227424621582,
0.8531358242034912,
0.3497742712497711,
0.20310313999652863,
0.01673055626451969,
-0.5980939865112305,
0.4228426516056061,
-0.9039170742034912,
-0.4970068633556366,
-0.28324422240257263,
-0.5030885338783264,
-0.49014607071876526,
-0.6585152745246887,
0.7012893557548523,
0.32517150044441223,
-0.2530331611633301,
-0.056613799184560776,
-0.5398380160331726,
0.5833171606063843,
0.4605136215686798,
-0.004394759889692068,
0.2770139276981354,
-0.16879013180732727,
-0.43418118357658386,
0.245320126414299,
-0.9514654874801636,
-0.4023469388484955,
1.0044001340866089,
0.17512981593608856,
0.7521478533744812,
0.20775127410888672,
0.4474831521511078,
0.451670378446579,
0.3382381200790405,
-0.8623103499412537,
0.672397792339325,
0.01803041249513626,
-0.415063738822937,
-0.5014074444770813,
-0.4818579852581024,
-0.9776023030281067,
0.3004080653190613,
-0.15520252287387848,
-0.585118293762207,
-0.06675013154745102,
-0.1906469762325287,
-0.07807203382253647,
0.5357919931411743,
-0.4456939697265625,
0.4373003840446472,
-0.055818166583776474,
-0.3684833347797394,
0.020536454394459724,
-0.717685341835022,
0.2813050150871277,
-0.192464217543602,
0.22979618608951569,
-0.10231052339076996,
-0.0952223688364029,
0.5028371810913086,
-0.5332949161529541,
0.5330978035926819,
-0.2561885416507721,
-0.19438904523849487,
0.7330054640769958,
0.21435777842998505,
0.9613001346588135,
-0.22693021595478058,
-0.09181273728609085,
-0.33449211716651917,
-0.4394340217113495,
-0.1951553076505661,
-1.0168431997299194,
0.40305307507514954,
-0.6903076767921448,
-0.7124720811843872,
-0.19512775540351868,
-1.1375501155853271,
-0.4257078468799591,
0.30599504709243774,
-0.13649505376815796,
0.23760297894477844,
0.21929435431957245,
0.36404940485954285,
0.5414278507232666,
-0.26971113681793213,
0.23160357773303986,
0.3711478114128113,
-0.3360505998134613,
-0.3351440727710724,
1.0140907764434814,
0.39947834610939026,
0.28224843740463257,
0.4058937132358551,
0.24934369325637817,
-0.20974497497081757,
-0.3888780474662781,
-0.34881511330604553,
0.11993583291769028,
-0.8769797086715698,
-0.41060149669647217,
-0.9426526427268982,
-0.6158761382102966,
-0.49636581540107727,
-0.21844817698001862,
-0.21199648082256317,
-0.4879644215106964,
-0.07383311539888382,
-0.004602234344929457,
0.3104134500026703,
0.8265944719314575,
-0.051815543323755264,
0.11612308025360107,
-0.8249238133430481,
0.3944493532180786,
0.4991871416568756,
0.2779783308506012,
0.17120762169361115,
-0.21162225306034088,
-0.26896294951438904,
-0.08699364215135574,
-0.5132021307945251,
-0.6363252401351929,
0.5136315822601318,
-0.09107384085655212,
0.6925681233406067,
0.2502012550830841,
0.28141412138938904,
0.6322195529937744,
-0.26112720370292664,
0.5162240862846375,
-0.07886797934770584,
-0.5909268260002136,
0.21962837874889374,
-0.602625846862793,
0.17842908203601837,
0.07492359727621078,
0.4132269620895386,
-0.5841044187545776,
-0.5551788210868835,
-0.5095513463020325,
-0.9350413680076599,
0.5758683085441589,
0.3997613787651062,
-0.12154266238212585,
0.12151111662387848,
0.3023856580257416,
-0.04341985285282135,
0.3535548448562622,
-0.5656487941741943,
-0.13383525609970093,
0.018722254782915115,
-0.18864551186561584,
0.10395843535661697,
-0.1242574006319046,
-0.24118393659591675,
-0.13125507533550262,
0.8065988421440125,
-0.2594020962715149,
0.16180619597434998,
0.3037591576576233,
-0.06005344167351723,
-0.05956870689988136,
0.2096583992242813,
0.29222235083580017,
0.7881603240966797,
-0.01750045269727707,
0.2728632688522339,
0.23580116033554077,
-0.5119072794914246,
0.09565918147563934,
0.04912592098116875,
-0.21684926748275757,
-0.14627830684185028,
0.17985063791275024,
0.6640161275863647,
-0.35321441292762756,
-0.9470065832138062,
0.20794658362865448,
0.28637057542800903,
0.0037287473678588867,
-0.39116963744163513,
0.2844957709312439,
0.25327762961387634,
0.6501131057739258,
0.6061800122261047,
0.10231474041938782,
0.009565780870616436,
-0.5177782773971558,
0.26662400364875793,
0.4344879686832428,
-0.21293137967586517,
0.24581153690814972,
0.46429356932640076,
0.04142744466662407,
-0.4488407075405121,
0.5450528860092163,
-0.5952408909797668,
-0.6223352551460266,
0.8201591968536377,
0.43177691102027893,
0.5561861395835876,
0.0323791578412056,
0.340334415435791,
0.0338875837624073,
0.25621840357780457,
0.1770300269126892,
0.19227932393550873,
-0.07103654742240906,
-0.9734886884689331,
-0.5263796448707581,
-0.6044868230819702,
-0.20677299797534943,
-0.13023820519447327,
-0.23338398337364197,
0.28090280294418335,
-0.23630331456661224,
-0.10357214510440826,
-0.3857274353504181,
0.03882936015725136,
-0.46833711862564087,
0.26910972595214844,
0.022226953878998756,
0.720117449760437,
-0.20228976011276245,
0.7581090927124023,
0.3712093234062195,
-0.1809040904045105,
-1.0604327917099,
-0.18229618668556213,
-0.17792266607284546,
-0.8797067999839783,
0.9197786450386047,
0.05911868065595627,
-0.2820671796798706,
0.2929738163948059,
-0.46854284405708313,
-1.068174958229065,
1.6091605424880981,
0.21894659101963043,
-0.24003751575946808,
-0.22539883852005005,
0.3679780066013336,
0.4886336028575897,
-0.4930512309074402,
0.039198026061058044,
0.36960309743881226,
0.5319926142692566,
0.5085609555244446,
-0.7416704893112183,
-0.1286761313676834,
-0.36625051498413086,
-0.16187988221645355,
0.3680771589279175,
-0.6440812945365906,
0.9387359619140625,
-0.22834542393684387,
-0.21096405386924744,
-0.019836101680994034,
0.4273409843444824,
0.5323019623756409,
0.7069656252861023,
0.6007254719734192,
0.8234093189239502,
0.9997761845588684,
-0.014285113662481308,
1.0402090549468994,
-0.24423901736736298,
0.25764942169189453,
0.9559779763221741,
-0.23013266921043396,
0.36824604868888855,
0.3884788155555725,
0.0359782837331295,
0.7183989882469177,
0.17626744508743286,
0.10779641568660736,
0.4255985915660858,
0.5254441499710083,
-0.34039512276649475,
-0.07777435332536697,
-0.5159251689910889,
-0.23191024363040924,
0.43478137254714966,
0.47003835439682007,
-0.31539979577064514,
-0.10123384743928909,
-0.013971595093607903,
0.1154157817363739,
0.16415002942085266,
-0.43920502066612244,
0.7212282419204712,
-0.02142092026770115,
-0.8956352472305298,
0.4669765532016754,
-0.15668794512748718,
0.3862433433532715,
-0.7352851033210754,
-0.07550367712974548,
-0.02111825905740261,
0.042477045208215714,
-0.22626543045043945,
-0.8242752552032471,
0.323280930519104,
-0.02543346956372261,
-0.06003288924694061,
-0.1755724549293518,
1.1340936422348022,
-0.3719203770160675,
-0.4026520550251007,
0.4082317352294922,
0.6893366575241089,
0.043661005795001984,
0.025142038241028786,
-0.38131415843963623,
-0.07665000110864639,
-0.19400471448898315,
-0.36892035603523254,
0.08673257380723953,
0.7989257574081421,
0.04307713732123375,
0.9699782729148865,
0.7045711874961853,
0.08380503207445145,
-0.00047051458386704326,
0.05055201053619385,
1.207662582397461,
-0.5390090346336365,
-0.4743123948574066,
-0.45313024520874023,
0.7163189649581909,
-0.21032212674617767,
0.23419669270515442,
0.5570536255836487,
0.5081861019134521,
0.8538073301315308,
0.024045873433351517,
0.9144049882888794,
-0.39699020981788635,
0.6044270992279053,
-0.5464493632316589,
0.9792510867118835,
-0.641979455947876,
0.34669747948646545,
-0.3299260437488556,
-0.9205918908119202,
-0.18555662035942078,
0.2959398925304413,
-0.06882373243570328,
0.02930581010878086,
0.579220175743103,
0.9664113521575928,
0.12390373647212982,
-0.30863258242607117,
0.4164482355117798,
0.33728930354118347,
0.37788620591163635,
0.3441919982433319,
0.9836253523826599,
-0.27357587218284607,
0.708753228187561,
-0.18157275021076202,
0.11208663880825043,
0.11633609235286713,
-0.7571897506713867,
-0.81723952293396,
-0.495445191860199,
0.19880469143390656,
-0.5139917135238647,
0.05090809985995293,
0.785925567150116,
0.3299632668495178,
-0.2905731797218323,
-0.19444912672042847,
-0.053194332867860794,
0.4106253385543823,
0.08418199419975281,
-0.2934066653251648,
0.20521323382854462,
-0.6312276124954224,
-0.6247802376747131,
0.3609939515590668,
0.3060341477394104,
-0.10081052780151367,
-0.38849344849586487,
-0.36792880296707153,
-0.1425836682319641,
0.14036576449871063,
0.7620667219161987,
0.10933571308851242,
-0.5221882462501526,
-0.2630627751350403,
0.23768584430217743,
-0.0005887048901058733,
-0.13706670701503754,
0.774444580078125,
-0.9798323512077332,
0.6163005232810974,
0.6956817507743835,
0.947332501411438,
0.4928162395954132,
-0.119187131524086,
0.47255104780197144,
-0.7990805506706238,
0.27998122572898865,
0.5820234417915344,
-0.01645999774336815,
0.23194774985313416,
-0.5061055421829224,
0.7986857891082764,
0.42447909712791443,
-0.5418780446052551,
-0.7609665989875793,
0.29782721400260925,
-0.8902397155761719,
-0.34495165944099426,
1.0426307916641235,
0.03096328116953373,
-0.12600521743297577,
-0.1998790204524994,
-0.29489395022392273,
0.3911197781562805,
-0.049488283693790436,
0.821863055229187,
0.7191132307052612,
-0.13698172569274902,
-0.0017349958652630448,
-0.5355148911476135,
0.39248237013816833,
0.06889954954385757,
-0.6872854828834534,
-0.2682377099990845,
0.2856418192386627,
-0.07450052350759506,
0.4020712673664093,
0.6431642174720764,
-0.0076506067998707294,
-0.015768524259328842,
-0.0981631651520729,
0.03416712209582329,
-0.35384950041770935,
-0.5155689716339111,
0.5999769568443298,
0.4649413824081421,
-0.08212940394878387,
0.2722705006599426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12021v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12021v1
|
Can AI Relate: Testing Large Language Model Response for Mental Health Support
| 2024-05-20T13:42:27 | 2024-05-20T13:42:27 |
Saadia Gabriel, Isha Puri, Xuhai Xu, Matteo Malgaroli, Marzyeh Ghassemi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are already being piloted for clinical use in
hospital systems like NYU Langone, Dana-Farber and the NHS. A proposed
deployment use case is psychotherapy, where a LLM-powered chatbot can treat a
patient undergoing a mental health crisis. Deployment of LLMs for mental health
response could hypothetically broaden access to psychotherapy and provide new
possibilities for personalizing care. However, recent high-profile failures,
like damaging dieting advice offered by the Tessa chatbot to patients with
eating disorders, have led to doubt about their reliability in high-stakes and
safety-critical settings.
In this work, we develop an evaluation framework for determining whether LLM
response is a viable and ethical path forward for the automation of mental
health treatment. Using human evaluation with trained clinicians and automatic
quality-of-care metrics grounded in psychology research, we compare the
responses provided by peer-to-peer responders to those provided by a
state-of-the-art LLM.
We show that LLMs like GPT-4 use implicit and explicit cues to infer patient
demographics like race. We then show that there are statistically significant
discrepancies between patient subgroups: Responses to Black posters
consistently have lower empathy than for any other demographic group (2%-13%
lower than the control group). Promisingly, we do find that the manner in which
responses are generated significantly impacts the quality of the response. We
conclude by proposing safety guidelines for the potential deployment of LLMs
for mental health response.
|
[
-0.25537392497062683,
-0.8259265422821045,
1.0122382640838623,
0.25869104266166687,
0.12508133053779602,
-0.01417751144617796,
-0.18118856847286224,
-0.6062936782836914,
0.09216215461492538,
0.3871275782585144,
-0.5792399048805237,
-0.08509652316570282,
-0.8023199439048767,
0.25797322392463684,
-0.5085974931716919,
0.9226603507995605,
0.03889131918549538,
0.4515596628189087,
-0.1956820785999298,
0.029772961512207985,
-0.4757041335105896,
-0.6623794436454773,
-1.0701075792312622,
-0.38755837082862854,
0.7489745616912842,
0.08737378567457199,
0.8341659903526306,
0.17940481007099152,
0.8507310748100281,
0.32159218192100525,
0.04704994708299637,
-0.15547743439674377,
-0.5094389319419861,
-0.15364351868629456,
-0.16474372148513794,
-0.4831937849521637,
-0.809029757976532,
-0.04470502957701683,
0.2949443757534027,
0.5531761646270752,
-0.33101996779441833,
0.24098652601242065,
0.21209119260311127,
0.449974000453949,
-0.34474313259124756,
-0.12051784992218018,
-0.5223808288574219,
0.1941651999950409,
0.2615507245063782,
0.042759668081998825,
-0.47377461194992065,
-0.3730754554271698,
-0.008271259255707264,
-0.48990780115127563,
-0.06556562334299088,
0.2425118237733841,
0.6154083609580994,
0.487397164106369,
-0.6172577142715454,
-0.21313825249671936,
-0.9486812353134155,
0.44913342595100403,
-1.0684016942977905,
0.05863964185118675,
0.6350297331809998,
0.47500061988830566,
-0.3066985309123993,
-0.6084029674530029,
-0.7133169174194336,
-0.46337175369262695,
-0.31812286376953125,
0.12349924445152283,
-0.1399075835943222,
0.30951929092407227,
0.42629438638687134,
0.28625041246414185,
-0.6180720925331116,
0.21177220344543457,
-0.16213901340961456,
-0.24320006370544434,
0.8374775052070618,
0.5126699209213257,
0.5148958563804626,
0.015528686344623566,
-0.05311977490782738,
0.0901772752404213,
-0.314724326133728,
-0.15255315601825714,
0.07957544922828674,
0.1127079427242279,
-0.3710043430328369,
0.7364130020141602,
0.2875617444515228,
0.23985816538333893,
0.06411389261484146,
-0.3151545524597168,
-0.0006416866090148687,
-0.1445816308259964,
-0.3205144703388214,
-0.03313184529542923,
0.9804231524467468,
0.7615175843238831,
0.5564006567001343,
-0.010842434130609035,
-0.10271823406219482,
0.28482624888420105,
0.6568111181259155,
-0.6645579934120178,
0.04704758897423744,
0.4522325396537781,
-0.6117439270019531,
0.12132783979177475,
-0.3653956651687622,
-0.5344673991203308,
-0.6608833074569702,
-0.27971741557121277,
0.35338354110717773,
-0.3688647449016571,
-0.39301738142967224,
0.11058813333511353,
0.1053009182214737,
0.39288195967674255,
0.2958873212337494,
-0.6874019503593445,
0.45480912923812866,
0.729589581489563,
0.7802488803863525,
-0.1809336096048355,
-0.12191936373710632,
-0.43936431407928467,
0.05525459721684456,
-0.330373615026474,
0.6380845308303833,
-0.34940576553344727,
-0.4035918414592743,
0.12404802441596985,
0.03998925909399986,
0.07975105941295624,
-0.5613095164299011,
0.4730583727359772,
-0.18903711438179016,
0.16578622162342072,
-0.2905155420303345,
-0.5456225872039795,
0.22801083326339722,
0.38619235157966614,
-0.4098204970359802,
0.49332818388938904,
0.45726707577705383,
-0.8788160085678101,
0.09673631191253662,
-0.7606795430183411,
-0.4687727391719818,
0.054024115204811096,
-0.19332551956176758,
-0.3375592529773712,
0.2067711502313614,
0.11062848567962646,
0.4270021319389343,
-0.410697340965271,
0.3285570740699768,
-0.910256564617157,
-0.48057106137275696,
0.5211736559867859,
-0.4519016444683075,
0.7070268988609314,
0.18039003014564514,
-0.26040592789649963,
0.30707788467407227,
-0.5916827917098999,
-0.018117044121026993,
0.37774550914764404,
-0.21910493075847626,
-0.20122727751731873,
-0.017553146928548813,
0.22582286596298218,
0.13826891779899597,
-0.06080828607082367,
-0.5153805017471313,
-0.14653922617435455,
-0.25797536969184875,
0.4479621350765228,
0.8529603481292725,
0.08647891879081726,
0.02858942374587059,
-0.46507760882377625,
0.7218093276023865,
-0.4134923815727234,
0.4549637734889984,
0.07059034705162048,
-0.33640822768211365,
-0.468090295791626,
-0.5326608419418335,
-0.2667221426963806,
0.5588985085487366,
-0.4688158333301544,
0.5261135697364807,
-0.06264026463031769,
-0.1969071626663208,
-0.742894172668457,
-0.20287857949733734,
0.2596415877342224,
0.7081183195114136,
0.198273167014122,
-0.31112781167030334,
-0.4306822121143341,
-1.0318042039871216,
-0.17920905351638794,
-0.5454329252243042,
-0.27422305941581726,
0.5246793627738953,
0.34800440073013306,
-0.5420365333557129,
0.6968932151794434,
-0.2701337933540344,
-0.18372665345668793,
-0.16248439252376556,
-0.15903936326503754,
-0.1014220342040062,
0.026311036199331284,
0.48841965198516846,
-0.48153984546661377,
-0.41896718740463257,
-0.05608170107007027,
-1.0414612293243408,
-0.10466407984495163,
0.14026466012001038,
-0.08209669589996338,
-0.05231843888759613,
0.30210182070732117,
-0.5133930444717407,
0.39336198568344116,
0.6911972761154175,
-0.3334934413433075,
0.4432850778102875,
-0.2490299493074417,
0.1824447363615036,
-1.2260892391204834,
0.21395547688007355,
0.0849047377705574,
-0.19175754487514496,
-0.4263569116592407,
-0.1787230223417282,
-0.22495050728321075,
-0.1556985080242157,
-0.37100186944007874,
0.4857887625694275,
0.11842110008001328,
-0.15893729031085968,
-0.4684543013572693,
-0.05666116997599602,
-0.39509639143943787,
0.21530835330486298,
-0.18975520133972168,
0.7506630420684814,
0.29843825101852417,
-0.2512444853782654,
0.5700336694717407,
0.1451738178730011,
-0.24161379039287567,
1.0591692924499512,
-0.8584816455841064,
0.3374742269515991,
-0.2016671597957611,
0.5098552107810974,
-1.1604793071746826,
-0.5791349411010742,
0.2755254805088043,
-0.38536593317985535,
-0.22749312222003937,
0.3285956382751465,
-0.638388991355896,
-0.5472919940948486,
-0.04532470926642418,
0.42456352710723877,
0.42609304189682007,
-0.002983869519084692,
0.4720984697341919,
0.5415330529212952,
-0.4566761553287506,
-0.1651451587677002,
-0.5647072196006775,
0.19657006859779358,
-0.47523069381713867,
-0.45777395367622375,
-0.22415049374103546,
-0.3531121611595154,
-0.5501879453659058,
-0.07798594981431961,
0.2642979621887207,
0.042843956500291824,
0.46076318621635437,
0.3860648572444916,
0.25020402669906616,
-0.10029622167348862,
0.19577635824680328,
-0.025876065716147423,
-0.08687365800142288,
0.4660385847091675,
0.10049603879451752,
0.5580136179924011,
-0.1709907203912735,
-0.7241984009742737,
-0.6147695183753967,
0.6897748708724976,
0.6159921884536743,
-0.08099628984928131,
0.6493451595306396,
0.6582126021385193,
-0.6153534650802612,
0.2607699930667877,
-0.5350918769836426,
-0.5980481505393982,
-0.41391047835350037,
0.38327014446258545,
0.07031521946191788,
-0.9427938461303711,
0.32304996252059937,
0.11406055092811584,
0.11791373789310455,
0.10569106042385101,
0.8791942000389099,
-0.35653871297836304,
1.2529635429382324,
0.7077940106391907,
-0.32670101523399353,
0.21005240082740784,
0.10625364631414413,
0.47951191663742065,
-0.6935660243034363,
0.022267047315835953,
-0.40046972036361694,
-0.3871545195579529,
-0.6831436157226562,
0.024014422670006752,
0.7490518093109131,
-0.4970562756061554,
-0.6431026458740234,
-0.1260945200920105,
-0.3088902235031128,
0.041390106081962585,
0.19358152151107788,
0.34247562289237976,
0.33903250098228455,
-0.2158360332250595,
0.06110534444451332,
-0.06452836096286774,
-0.40919029712677,
-0.5751142501831055,
0.9662648439407349,
0.6165252923965454,
0.9026305079460144,
0.09942591935396194,
0.4334120750427246,
0.47150924801826477,
0.8989720940589905,
-0.8627617955207825,
0.5304682850837708,
0.18085812032222748,
-0.7804185748100281,
-0.39180508255958557,
-0.3387051224708557,
-0.9933043718338013,
0.06564100831747055,
-0.19052445888519287,
-0.9039871692657471,
-0.32816246151924133,
0.10716255754232407,
-0.5122632384300232,
0.0715566873550415,
-0.8012412190437317,
0.5120842456817627,
-0.4675460457801819,
0.056543298065662384,
-0.3429677188396454,
-0.7365190386772156,
0.2898465394973755,
-0.4023683965206146,
0.32514864206314087,
-0.40142542123794556,
0.19490154087543488,
0.6326532363891602,
-0.2834305763244629,
0.9031305313110352,
0.0689292699098587,
-0.3633721172809601,
-0.1453351378440857,
0.025348471477627754,
0.18559876084327698,
0.1519164741039276,
-0.14314408600330353,
-0.0779479518532753,
0.11368075013160706,
-0.40358641743659973,
-0.9231042861938477,
0.582341194152832,
-1.0754234790802002,
-0.8597702383995056,
-0.20837850868701935,
-0.7104793190956116,
-0.5113634467124939,
0.12598639726638794,
-0.08486467599868774,
0.021514182910323143,
-0.0781988576054573,
-0.029982073232531548,
0.3965102732181549,
-0.3963128924369812,
0.06722373515367508,
0.7294485569000244,
-0.3211466372013092,
-0.4259082078933716,
0.3646942675113678,
-0.3117092251777649,
0.22922632098197937,
0.10206469148397446,
0.40216371417045593,
-0.13833937048912048,
-0.3736518323421478,
-0.04423220083117485,
0.5949856042861938,
-0.5055358409881592,
-0.024820851162075996,
-0.3943002223968506,
-0.4923507869243622,
-0.5110020637512207,
-0.24752111732959747,
-0.29672613739967346,
0.27485358715057373,
-0.05875338613986969,
-0.26686450839042664,
0.27521562576293945,
0.8667697310447693,
0.18604931235313416,
0.27567675709724426,
-0.6665423512458801,
0.35795876383781433,
0.26460325717926025,
0.3738143742084503,
0.2829623520374298,
-0.4446239471435547,
-0.17824524641036987,
0.042830780148506165,
-0.3256511092185974,
-0.9169858694076538,
0.2731631100177765,
-0.12199034541845322,
0.47734275460243225,
0.4046887159347534,
0.2885359823703766,
0.5669122934341431,
-0.5974581837654114,
0.698021650314331,
0.249384805560112,
-0.6247397661209106,
0.607794463634491,
-0.45715537667274475,
0.056732408702373505,
0.47369951009750366,
0.7699365615844727,
-0.8033601641654968,
-0.6455012559890747,
-0.5780487060546875,
-0.7480173110961914,
0.4917660653591156,
-0.020336415618658066,
0.3785422742366791,
-0.07327992469072342,
0.595325767993927,
-0.08319605886936188,
0.15237164497375488,
-0.7210249304771423,
-0.23777443170547485,
0.2511577606201172,
-0.4407815635204315,
-0.24790482223033905,
-0.2471584677696228,
-0.641362726688385,
0.09415300190448761,
0.26071861386299133,
-0.28401628136634827,
0.5747037529945374,
0.284110426902771,
0.2455475926399231,
-0.4215961694717407,
0.3075028359889984,
0.28540465235710144,
0.6857736110687256,
-0.2171275019645691,
0.1083647832274437,
0.11982084065675735,
-0.21754857897758484,
0.42027175426483154,
0.0751900002360344,
0.22898544371128082,
-0.4430246949195862,
0.6276869177818298,
0.5005099773406982,
-0.15585659444332123,
-0.847297191619873,
0.45881903171539307,
-0.31637442111968994,
-0.03506503626704216,
-0.34935808181762695,
0.1413477659225464,
0.10866952687501907,
0.43035733699798584,
0.10721753537654877,
-0.5502619743347168,
0.2144537717103958,
-0.6649423241615295,
0.28472229838371277,
0.5807561278343201,
-0.39117613434791565,
-0.3284107446670532,
0.5083731412887573,
0.12442624568939209,
-0.8850851058959961,
0.789615273475647,
0.2265014946460724,
-0.2021520882844925,
0.5506559014320374,
0.6465674042701721,
0.7751089930534363,
-0.19421324133872986,
0.1732398122549057,
0.041853632777929306,
0.26371920108795166,
0.06564739346504211,
0.16456013917922974,
0.3217485547065735,
-0.7234657406806946,
-0.35333701968193054,
-0.2769949734210968,
-0.6715907454490662,
0.4738529920578003,
-0.9148685932159424,
0.030502894893288612,
-0.7189738750457764,
-0.5790908336639404,
-0.18790020048618317,
-0.0774441808462143,
-0.6726717948913574,
0.03963403403759003,
0.4210599660873413,
0.7235189080238342,
-1.016347885131836,
0.5486792325973511,
0.8718956708908081,
-0.23197630047798157,
-0.8912172913551331,
0.4518320858478546,
0.22341835498809814,
-1.0119024515151978,
0.3000398576259613,
0.08709453791379929,
0.021750558167696,
-0.2761521637439728,
-0.5412322282791138,
-0.7289730906486511,
1.0368958711624146,
0.7995592355728149,
-0.4246096611022949,
-0.21206313371658325,
0.23171545565128326,
0.9633817076683044,
-0.2593275308609009,
0.6520975828170776,
0.5917302370071411,
0.4303987920284271,
-0.052158549427986145,
-1.3327548503875732,
0.2197042852640152,
-0.05560572072863579,
0.23994523286819458,
-0.2860112190246582,
-0.8296350836753845,
0.39182859659194946,
-0.26804885268211365,
0.014297881163656712,
0.2116405963897705,
0.5026549100875854,
0.376737505197525,
0.4189833700656891,
0.47535157203674316,
0.36569103598594666,
0.929177463054657,
0.241571307182312,
1.3092360496520996,
-0.2503921091556549,
0.30333584547042847,
0.9675846695899963,
-0.6100255250930786,
0.764883279800415,
0.466520220041275,
-0.41807666420936584,
0.2333507239818573,
0.6547749042510986,
0.2293952852487564,
0.24037012457847595,
0.45521944761276245,
-0.2661823630332947,
-0.022246219217777252,
-0.44176092743873596,
-0.2082844227552414,
0.21218594908714294,
0.39845043420791626,
-0.3135256767272949,
-0.09215659648180008,
0.22743074595928192,
0.29330235719680786,
0.10955138504505157,
-0.1065521389245987,
0.7186000347137451,
0.5375856757164001,
-0.5609490275382996,
0.46494460105895996,
-0.05130664259195328,
0.3977341651916504,
-0.5280940532684326,
0.015946097671985626,
-0.3241257071495056,
0.268189936876297,
-0.16782502830028534,
-0.7611796259880066,
0.3866109549999237,
0.02567920833826065,
-0.06795661151409149,
-0.05856374278664589,
0.537321150302887,
-0.01788690686225891,
-0.6118777394294739,
0.6256862878799438,
0.4864039421081543,
0.13381905853748322,
0.08556574583053589,
-0.8156101703643799,
0.14953896403312683,
-0.3686051666736603,
-0.1441311091184616,
0.738006591796875,
0.2808365821838379,
0.008323545567691326,
0.9722562432289124,
0.5245516896247864,
0.2634468972682953,
-0.29482656717300415,
0.10377795249223709,
0.7647698521614075,
-0.4872172772884369,
-0.13243621587753296,
-0.8836941719055176,
0.2573181390762329,
0.13892211019992828,
-0.0003450432850513607,
0.6097936630249023,
0.05008326470851898,
0.5200212001800537,
0.1995379775762558,
0.898382306098938,
0.1530095338821411,
0.3383096754550934,
-0.3067091405391693,
0.6581859588623047,
-0.6844896674156189,
0.15247686207294464,
-0.2718792259693146,
-0.7056683301925659,
-0.3502804934978485,
0.7358957529067993,
-0.4656267762184143,
0.23180550336837769,
0.7046780586242676,
0.8275360465049744,
0.28331708908081055,
-0.11992805451154709,
0.45103901624679565,
0.3469913899898529,
0.7444055676460266,
0.6549959778785706,
0.9722604751586914,
-0.030597709119319916,
0.23398035764694214,
0.14555184543132782,
-0.33242499828338623,
-0.1629544347524643,
-0.7329927682876587,
-0.7500406503677368,
-0.29040244221687317,
-0.12158356606960297,
-0.5168017745018005,
0.21861371397972107,
1.1334072351455688,
0.5944888591766357,
-0.5318998694419861,
-0.3939078748226166,
0.36030113697052,
-0.005488088820129633,
-0.1274876892566681,
-0.2690320611000061,
0.2034766674041748,
-0.16975347697734833,
-0.49787768721580505,
-0.006975871976464987,
0.34670373797416687,
-0.01049706619232893,
-0.6109302043914795,
-0.1379801332950592,
0.22876493632793427,
0.1528782695531845,
0.5429056882858276,
0.004793250001966953,
-0.7883491516113281,
-0.44097650051116943,
-0.049695760011672974,
-0.40460553765296936,
0.12402436882257462,
0.8193703889846802,
-0.4789528250694275,
0.0368645042181015,
-0.004340491723269224,
0.9880883693695068,
-0.08066382259130478,
-0.09430486708879471,
0.6641508340835571,
-0.14805328845977783,
-0.12953095138072968,
0.423246294260025,
0.5128456354141235,
0.33722662925720215,
-0.5924227833747864,
0.3449699282646179,
0.03728273883461952,
-0.7049525380134583,
-0.7428449392318726,
0.23604807257652283,
-0.8621673583984375,
0.05134046450257301,
1.4878071546554565,
-0.4577636122703552,
-0.1875508576631546,
-0.07616254687309265,
-0.5172837972640991,
0.12929733097553253,
-0.45040223002433777,
1.1542339324951172,
0.6500547528266907,
-0.3376985788345337,
-0.27650636434555054,
-0.5829141736030579,
0.18795542418956757,
0.3629066050052643,
-1.0150847434997559,
-0.07556980848312378,
0.3857279419898987,
0.3740265369415283,
-0.04145737737417221,
1.0683702230453491,
-0.048005931079387665,
0.16132131218910217,
-0.3711225986480713,
-0.0008472378831356764,
0.30125749111175537,
0.030166497454047203,
-0.331623911857605,
-0.03768467158079147,
0.3799247145652771,
0.15736348927021027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11983v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11983v1
|
A review on the use of large language models as virtual tutors
| 2024-05-20T12:33:42 | 2024-05-20T12:33:42 |
Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, María del Carmen Somoza-López
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Transformer architectures contribute to managing long-term dependencies for
Natural Language Processing, representing one of the most recent changes in the
field. These architectures are the basis of the innovative, cutting-edge Large
Language Models (LLMs) that have produced a huge buzz in several fields and
industrial sectors, among the ones education stands out. Accordingly, these
generative Artificial Intelligence-based solutions have directed the change in
techniques and the evolution in educational methods and contents, along with
network infrastructure, towards high-quality learning. Given the popularity of
LLMs, this review seeks to provide a comprehensive overview of those solutions
designed specifically to generate and evaluate educational materials and which
involve students and teachers in their design or experimental plan. To the best
of our knowledge, this is the first review of educational applications (e.g.,
student assessment) of LLMs. As expected, the most common role of these systems
is as virtual tutors for automatic question generation. Moreover, the most
popular models are GTP-3 and BERT. However, due to the continuous launch of new
generative models, new works are expected to be published shortly.
|
[
-0.610352098941803,
-0.9539527893066406,
0.401383638381958,
0.20121848583221436,
0.09734724462032318,
0.12393395602703094,
-0.24856498837471008,
-0.44251060485839844,
-0.0763271376490593,
0.579807460308075,
-0.32606399059295654,
-0.15548227727413177,
-0.524470329284668,
0.32718878984451294,
-0.918738603591919,
0.631875216960907,
-0.02134748548269272,
0.33177393674850464,
-0.5943377614021301,
0.14258983731269836,
-0.4484691917896271,
-0.6720929145812988,
-0.8114595413208008,
-0.46959009766578674,
0.30570173263549805,
0.1714566946029663,
0.5943963527679443,
0.49789556860923767,
0.361361563205719,
0.4367429316043854,
-0.3632718324661255,
-0.12649552524089813,
-0.21543939411640167,
0.22789865732192993,
-0.26955923438072205,
-0.750625491142273,
-0.18489845097064972,
-0.1952958106994629,
0.6067587733268738,
0.7628977298736572,
-0.08270128071308136,
0.048788588494062424,
0.11630623787641525,
0.553401529788971,
-0.2839922308921814,
0.22082671523094177,
-0.30256688594818115,
0.24507388472557068,
0.004442363046109676,
0.20546486973762512,
-0.6356869339942932,
-0.4027973711490631,
0.508848249912262,
-0.1549495905637741,
0.2887214720249176,
-0.26933130621910095,
0.5140628814697266,
0.09161029011011124,
-0.3138878643512726,
-0.517907977104187,
-1.2007942199707031,
0.8750680685043335,
-0.5496648550033569,
0.3897668123245239,
0.12463600188493729,
0.816882848739624,
-0.21745595335960388,
-0.8528222441673279,
-0.6075735092163086,
-0.30697399377822876,
0.09114914387464523,
0.18062366545200348,
-0.12732897698879242,
0.02448672614991665,
0.03405451029539108,
0.5110095739364624,
-0.33447766304016113,
0.5460000038146973,
-0.4904661774635315,
-0.02749003656208515,
0.29799965023994446,
0.38508862257003784,
0.24133674800395966,
-0.14472047984600067,
-0.32568585872650146,
-0.12252896279096603,
-0.8862379789352417,
-0.20633064210414886,
0.41066792607307434,
0.268323689699173,
0.05682482197880745,
0.6431348323822021,
0.13251034915447235,
0.8526092171669006,
-0.32450783252716064,
-0.22889825701713562,
-0.08192839473485947,
-0.10137314349412918,
-0.25382328033447266,
-0.175812765955925,
0.8351467251777649,
-0.17830277979373932,
0.5921342372894287,
0.0861663818359375,
-0.1498090773820877,
0.03817768767476082,
0.32349348068237305,
-0.7364715337753296,
-0.04166436940431595,
0.21752683818340302,
-0.18901951611042023,
-0.3350137174129486,
-0.04350390285253525,
-0.8973889350891113,
-0.12898916006088257,
-0.7759212851524353,
0.2868768870830536,
-0.30607157945632935,
-0.22401908040046692,
0.3010263442993164,
0.23647953569889069,
0.5251639485359192,
0.48336338996887207,
-0.9677312970161438,
0.43022623658180237,
0.7899826169013977,
0.652375340461731,
-0.35515928268432617,
-0.2561686336994171,
0.011012750677764416,
0.029354825615882874,
-0.13472341001033783,
0.7703025341033936,
-0.4337213337421417,
-0.6704335808753967,
0.6039242744445801,
-0.11983972787857056,
0.19294612109661102,
-0.6582198143005371,
0.49799099564552307,
-0.516299843788147,
0.7310597896575928,
-0.007151711266487837,
-0.5088090896606445,
-0.1338188648223877,
0.4170447587966919,
-0.6147429347038269,
1.0065076351165771,
0.23350365459918976,
-0.4070450961589813,
-0.3176034688949585,
-0.5530769228935242,
-0.39796188473701477,
0.3275749683380127,
-0.110077865421772,
-0.30413493514060974,
0.01169890072196722,
0.26210471987724304,
0.4818374514579773,
-0.5875256657600403,
0.3505572974681854,
0.22720913589000702,
-0.31644925475120544,
0.10779315233230591,
-0.4978851079940796,
0.799597978591919,
-0.0006399150006473064,
-0.44462066888809204,
0.2524715065956116,
-0.6364566087722778,
-0.0584302581846714,
0.2560661733150482,
-0.3945533037185669,
-0.21928571164608002,
0.16331149637699127,
0.07495028525590897,
0.15693145990371704,
0.20344477891921997,
-0.2818238437175751,
0.19264258444309235,
-0.3665260076522827,
0.6197379231452942,
0.9325785040855408,
-0.32902202010154724,
0.12787801027297974,
-0.03999287262558937,
0.6887984275817871,
0.02584908902645111,
0.438651978969574,
-0.3703638017177582,
-0.39797309041023254,
-1.1397535800933838,
-0.036889612674713135,
0.28905224800109863,
0.36504626274108887,
-0.8025148510932922,
0.2492612600326538,
-0.20292077958583832,
-0.6488765478134155,
-0.5471760034561157,
0.1003343015909195,
0.1695125550031662,
0.18933196365833282,
0.38796404004096985,
0.0908353254199028,
-0.49410706758499146,
-0.7558530569076538,
0.1650533229112625,
-0.15665876865386963,
-0.0938173234462738,
0.2443651258945465,
0.47950226068496704,
-0.48576363921165466,
0.9578664302825928,
-0.4266349971294403,
-0.33265426754951477,
-0.519268810749054,
-0.20670121908187866,
0.12041507661342621,
0.3044690489768982,
0.7877280116081238,
-0.7926937341690063,
-0.4843660295009613,
-0.2252635508775711,
-0.6029741764068604,
0.06442828476428986,
-0.009322535246610641,
-0.01837122067809105,
0.22217464447021484,
0.49171513319015503,
-0.9552162885665894,
-0.13998906314373016,
0.47599849104881287,
-0.08522192388772964,
0.810102105140686,
-0.16671545803546906,
-0.23874066770076752,
-1.060611367225647,
-0.2952827513217926,
0.11932351440191269,
-0.14435485005378723,
-0.49313071370124817,
0.22459818422794342,
-0.23871669173240662,
-0.26667532324790955,
-0.5412894487380981,
0.659363865852356,
-0.3719295859336853,
-0.08271174132823944,
-0.4486743211746216,
0.3803481161594391,
-0.18666572868824005,
0.2832860052585602,
-0.18869289755821228,
0.8434303402900696,
0.5577844977378845,
-0.49393460154533386,
0.7701417207717896,
0.3352185785770416,
-0.3767772316932678,
0.6767244935035706,
-0.8665395379066467,
0.15458860993385315,
-0.25820299983024597,
0.09485776722431183,
-0.7075977921485901,
-0.16448013484477997,
0.12855106592178345,
-0.24658378958702087,
0.31724339723587036,
0.18757474422454834,
-0.7075562477111816,
-0.8745945692062378,
-0.2001744955778122,
0.03853593021631241,
0.621319055557251,
-0.8511102795600891,
0.7877082824707031,
0.22802212834358215,
-0.22718629240989685,
-0.3966035544872284,
-0.35795292258262634,
0.3108785152435303,
-0.03844438120722771,
-0.35700494050979614,
0.21973541378974915,
-0.30420488119125366,
-0.346849650144577,
0.10883393883705139,
0.13007347285747528,
-0.02012602426111698,
0.11802070587873459,
0.24047507345676422,
0.5336930155754089,
-0.5065073370933533,
0.05999854579567909,
-0.008527503348886967,
-0.12453597784042358,
0.3397650718688965,
-0.21160708367824554,
0.76191246509552,
-0.1989344209432602,
-0.41910016536712646,
-0.2745043635368347,
0.3235461413860321,
0.8567119836807251,
-0.2128044217824936,
0.9040181636810303,
0.4107014834880829,
-0.2339128851890564,
-0.4160371720790863,
-0.7364282608032227,
-0.13494771718978882,
-0.5287768840789795,
0.47019168734550476,
-0.18404702842235565,
-1.022823691368103,
0.2561213970184326,
-0.10849928855895996,
0.06603366881608963,
0.45249202847480774,
0.7883662581443787,
0.0012333716731518507,
0.9101794958114624,
0.8296907544136047,
-0.3345431089401245,
0.6282371282577515,
-0.2765475809574127,
0.4138880968093872,
-0.6362014412879944,
-0.35962873697280884,
-0.6668943166732788,
-0.021534668281674385,
-0.4839257299900055,
-0.2086876779794693,
0.30788543820381165,
-0.051961034536361694,
-0.22169797122478485,
0.25945013761520386,
-0.4533962607383728,
0.5117323398590088,
0.6073275804519653,
-0.3344196677207947,
0.14680594205856323,
-0.003140864195302129,
0.08259792625904083,
0.21184779703617096,
-0.45764949917793274,
-0.8617894649505615,
1.0368434190750122,
0.41715919971466064,
0.6086747646331787,
0.04274250194430351,
0.35043972730636597,
0.07093536853790283,
0.5352048873901367,
-0.9279636740684509,
0.7961499691009521,
-0.061121437698602676,
-0.5128650665283203,
-0.2556856870651245,
-0.22616159915924072,
-0.8301755785942078,
0.37459540367126465,
-0.022394424304366112,
-0.3903551995754242,
-0.34715816378593445,
-0.1919158548116684,
-0.13338574767112732,
0.4141232967376709,
-0.6306794285774231,
0.5096712112426758,
-0.35466283559799194,
-0.27295225858688354,
-0.2054077386856079,
-0.3611854016780853,
0.2852528691291809,
-0.22790434956550598,
-0.019258100539445877,
0.3609435558319092,
0.3046121895313263,
0.6785183548927307,
-0.08446285873651505,
0.8029106855392456,
-0.10251376777887344,
-0.2976377606391907,
0.6380133628845215,
-0.043904684484004974,
0.23968972265720367,
-0.3560872972011566,
-0.19685772061347961,
0.014894063584506512,
-0.021901549771428108,
-0.1585354208946228,
-0.5719833970069885,
0.7989239692687988,
-1.0048211812973022,
-1.0092378854751587,
-0.24381709098815918,
-0.4751531481742859,
-0.2040306031703949,
0.23645401000976562,
-0.19000975787639618,
0.409166544675827,
-0.1140209212899208,
0.3100126087665558,
0.7551001310348511,
-0.3712923526763916,
0.46139809489250183,
0.5064650774002075,
-0.3207342028617859,
-0.25895464420318604,
0.7625338435173035,
0.11603376269340515,
0.24150297045707703,
0.23218950629234314,
0.274310439825058,
-0.18724235892295837,
-0.5739725828170776,
-0.338002473115921,
0.3797890841960907,
-0.8422659039497375,
-0.19001595675945282,
-0.5025726556777954,
-0.653005063533783,
-0.377753347158432,
-0.2124331295490265,
-0.3304712474346161,
-0.08293198049068451,
-0.5232016444206238,
-0.3474610149860382,
0.025535067543387413,
1.0497546195983887,
0.3102332651615143,
0.5089173913002014,
-0.6949511766433716,
0.2622149884700775,
0.6959284543991089,
0.280061811208725,
0.17986281216144562,
-0.2630425989627838,
-0.2027178853750229,
-0.02008725143969059,
-0.5513697266578674,
-0.5102919340133667,
0.2996814250946045,
-0.030047651380300522,
0.6448667049407959,
0.3626628518104553,
-0.2854751646518707,
0.14044971764087677,
-0.4891293942928314,
1.1105444431304932,
0.04215927794575691,
-0.7814320921897888,
0.28256285190582275,
-0.19673503935337067,
0.13862551748752594,
0.017705999314785004,
0.5507179498672485,
-0.49255189299583435,
-0.3009471893310547,
-0.3182471990585327,
-0.8148906230926514,
0.5218998193740845,
-0.14010941982269287,
0.7835760712623596,
-0.030953524634242058,
0.4089755415916443,
0.20609208941459656,
0.25963565707206726,
-0.856094479560852,
-0.48199763894081116,
-0.1711076945066452,
-0.3218996822834015,
0.03583253175020218,
-0.801099419593811,
0.038935452699661255,
-0.2245347946882248,
0.7012960910797119,
-0.01626589708030224,
0.19686703383922577,
-0.27783793210983276,
0.13900414109230042,
-0.06271355599164963,
0.41410019993782043,
0.5468268394470215,
0.7271544337272644,
0.16755472123622894,
-0.02166784554719925,
0.026734748855233192,
-0.5219709277153015,
0.24611428380012512,
-0.20157212018966675,
-0.18717604875564575,
0.04188143089413643,
0.40483784675598145,
0.738577663898468,
0.2248101681470871,
-0.6725794076919556,
0.535660982131958,
0.07387722283601761,
-0.18866479396820068,
-0.7486066222190857,
0.2950808107852936,
0.16033026576042175,
0.315199613571167,
0.3348015546798706,
-0.2903287708759308,
-0.2927111089229584,
-0.5063594579696655,
-0.1465950757265091,
0.42526283860206604,
-0.34949928522109985,
-0.4502969980239868,
0.5961995720863342,
0.28639334440231323,
-0.7139832377433777,
0.8709096312522888,
0.31646960973739624,
-0.6336905360221863,
0.5339028239250183,
0.9261497259140015,
0.9248126745223999,
-0.5845450162887573,
0.48989275097846985,
0.14010997116565704,
0.177174374461174,
-0.26791760325431824,
0.06987370550632477,
0.04214724898338318,
-0.6718559265136719,
-0.40893295407295227,
-0.6968784928321838,
-0.6653077602386475,
0.39078304171562195,
-0.4850904941558838,
0.4358319640159607,
-0.33667755126953125,
-0.046194370836019516,
-0.10902289301156998,
-0.3043813705444336,
-0.6036126017570496,
0.15532314777374268,
0.1979818344116211,
0.8145012855529785,
-0.7813935279846191,
0.7254843711853027,
0.7798117399215698,
-0.15828055143356323,
-0.4538838863372803,
-0.2820638418197632,
-0.2997123599052429,
-0.5215966701507568,
0.8766826391220093,
0.05055219307541847,
0.018989209085702896,
0.204498752951622,
-0.44382601976394653,
-0.7410193085670471,
0.8366682529449463,
0.3419373035430908,
-0.5550317168235779,
-0.5948522686958313,
0.6721404790878296,
0.9574239253997803,
-0.07383885979652405,
0.3633906841278076,
0.5194294452667236,
0.30429646372795105,
0.11338921636343002,
-0.6036445498466492,
-0.533620297908783,
-0.049547500908374786,
0.15561962127685547,
0.16751115024089813,
-0.49786248803138733,
0.8194392323493958,
0.025731027126312256,
-0.1156875416636467,
0.2161065936088562,
0.7277779579162598,
0.012733961455523968,
-0.24652992188930511,
0.16775257885456085,
0.3314642608165741,
0.2529667019844055,
-0.2257668673992157,
1.0069737434387207,
-0.3014395534992218,
0.33116090297698975,
0.8594924211502075,
-0.024642033502459526,
0.8906403183937073,
0.5611266493797302,
-0.5087575912475586,
0.5825701951980591,
0.2727258503437042,
-0.3338342607021332,
0.17618019878864288,
0.497816264629364,
-0.28621146082878113,
-0.10586433857679367,
-0.1418423056602478,
-0.20975299179553986,
0.42287030816078186,
0.4046432673931122,
-0.24213431775569916,
-0.29697415232658386,
0.3081384003162384,
-0.1822521686553955,
0.20718587934970856,
-0.32840386033058167,
0.5766950845718384,
0.237809419631958,
-0.5974552631378174,
0.2465047836303711,
0.06829912215471268,
0.5413559675216675,
-0.5299749374389648,
0.0026423227973282337,
-0.29661834239959717,
0.24145373702049255,
0.016720985993742943,
-0.7984830141067505,
0.05625103786587715,
-0.026666995137929916,
-0.09367449581623077,
-0.40818339586257935,
0.4159819185733795,
-0.29777005314826965,
-0.5677990317344666,
0.3891260325908661,
0.6129940152168274,
-0.21079885959625244,
0.29420408606529236,
-0.5490149259567261,
0.12167353928089142,
-0.1965608149766922,
-0.4224323332309723,
0.2783796489238739,
0.1765640825033188,
0.016942691057920456,
0.976646900177002,
0.4379524290561676,
0.12856467068195343,
0.23642127215862274,
0.24424664676189423,
0.7738742828369141,
-0.5179030895233154,
-0.1969035118818283,
-0.8086026310920715,
0.3876570463180542,
0.27314844727516174,
-0.11342408508062363,
0.8258885741233826,
0.3493468165397644,
1.0361589193344116,
-0.23372000455856323,
0.6687010526657104,
0.23349681496620178,
0.43646955490112305,
-0.34002619981765747,
0.447532594203949,
-0.21021340787410736,
0.22103144228458405,
-0.25972825288772583,
-1.3506495952606201,
-0.2783874273300171,
0.3944365382194519,
-0.33005020022392273,
0.06343547999858856,
0.4673474133014679,
0.3874019980430603,
0.06456779688596725,
0.17927567660808563,
0.35231009125709534,
0.19833333790302277,
0.8116793632507324,
0.33197546005249023,
1.125486135482788,
-0.40658360719680786,
0.33925527334213257,
-0.22443297505378723,
0.18205192685127258,
-0.26219648122787476,
-0.45181018114089966,
-1.1890202760696411,
-0.7043731212615967,
-0.32349300384521484,
0.02709006890654564,
-0.2639555037021637,
0.7982666492462158,
0.2558871805667877,
-0.8121678233146667,
-0.3745723068714142,
-0.1295527070760727,
0.16485349833965302,
0.1271706074476242,
-0.286504328250885,
0.5186579823493958,
-0.30579692125320435,
-1.113478422164917,
0.307595819234848,
0.1497410386800766,
0.3873313069343567,
-0.9922935366630554,
0.21992816030979156,
0.14316824078559875,
0.1719619631767273,
0.9499028325080872,
0.13445527851581573,
-0.8259475827217102,
-0.3605424761772156,
0.012126910500228405,
-0.28024137020111084,
-0.0038505964912474155,
0.5811217427253723,
-0.9549887776374817,
0.44433045387268066,
0.3500043749809265,
0.8468006253242493,
0.291961669921875,
-0.26194870471954346,
0.4618751108646393,
-0.10576748847961426,
-0.014303978532552719,
0.3146910071372986,
0.3284916281700134,
0.4935052692890167,
-0.050557058304548264,
0.3157177269458771,
0.06512430310249329,
-0.47520893812179565,
-1.0362993478775024,
0.14789924025535583,
-0.5626723766326904,
-0.10835883021354675,
0.9425592422485352,
-0.07681955397129059,
-0.24657045304775238,
0.12913623452186584,
-0.4172799587249756,
0.14842647314071655,
0.33020779490470886,
1.034472942352295,
0.7203487157821655,
0.12017171084880829,
-0.23859764635562897,
-0.6751627326011658,
0.1934627890586853,
0.38043397665023804,
-1.0380451679229736,
-0.10516329854726791,
0.34299206733703613,
0.14130814373493195,
0.2979190945625305,
-0.001371335587464273,
-0.17853030562400818,
-0.1557811200618744,
-0.3559601306915283,
0.044305358082056046,
-0.20296065509319305,
-0.6127885580062866,
-0.24848034977912903,
0.4028013348579407,
0.13040262460708618,
0.0791068896651268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13059v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13059v1
|
RNG: Reducing Multi-level Noise and Multi-grained Semantic Gap for Joint Multimodal Aspect-Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-05-20T12:18:46 | 2024-05-20T12:18:46 |
Yaxin Liu, Yan Zhou, Ziming Li, Jinchuan Zhang, Yu Shang, Chenyang Zhang, Songlin Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As an important multimodal sentiment analysis task, Joint Multimodal
Aspect-Sentiment Analysis (JMASA), aiming to jointly extract aspect terms and
their associated sentiment polarities from the given text-image pairs, has
gained increasing concerns. Existing works encounter two limitations: (1)
multi-level modality noise, i.e., instance- and feature-level noise; and (2)
multi-grained semantic gap, i.e., coarse- and fine-grained gap. Both issues may
interfere with accurate identification of aspect-sentiment pairs. To address
these limitations, we propose a novel framework named RNG for JMASA.
Specifically, to simultaneously reduce multi-level modality noise and
multi-grained semantic gap, we design three constraints: (1) Global Relevance
Constraint (GR-Con) based on text-image similarity for instance-level noise
reduction, (2) Information Bottleneck Constraint (IB-Con) based on the
Information Bottleneck (IB) principle for feature-level noise reduction, and
(3) Semantic Consistency Constraint (SC-Con) based on mutual information
maximization in a contrastive learning way for multi-grained semantic gap
reduction. Extensive experiments on two datasets validate our new
state-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.716414749622345,
-0.9487447142601013,
0.3475126624107361,
0.22855998575687408,
-0.5385558605194092,
-0.029588159173727036,
-0.2350345402956009,
-0.38979372382164,
0.2801339626312256,
0.2573853135108948,
-0.899037778377533,
-0.7693161964416504,
-0.5291242003440857,
0.05236511677503586,
-0.1780967116355896,
1.0311317443847656,
-0.02521388791501522,
0.26976993680000305,
-0.5678268671035767,
-0.36371544003486633,
-0.29504647850990295,
-0.10003769397735596,
-0.6869766116142273,
-0.09616629779338837,
0.7503825426101685,
0.03145856782793999,
0.5836811661720276,
0.25901076197624207,
0.7688565850257874,
0.3155536651611328,
-0.21603503823280334,
0.32171767950057983,
-0.13737346231937408,
0.39398202300071716,
-0.07583393156528473,
-0.3814760148525238,
-0.237435981631279,
-0.03834055736660957,
0.46722081303596497,
0.45869383215904236,
0.05847141891717911,
0.345403254032135,
0.0935363620519638,
0.8853668570518494,
-0.526268482208252,
0.497173935174942,
-0.39990925788879395,
0.3414948582649231,
-0.3295113742351532,
-0.3563499450683594,
-0.03840111568570137,
-0.12745217978954315,
-0.05907858908176422,
-0.811947226524353,
0.334479957818985,
0.1453135460615158,
1.1925923824310303,
0.3466765284538269,
-0.14565585553646088,
-0.09949027001857758,
-0.4630853235721588,
0.8123279809951782,
-0.7404959201812744,
0.029290631413459778,
0.1681486815214157,
-0.03414827212691307,
-0.1998557448387146,
-0.44090381264686584,
-0.5852234363555908,
0.05327002704143524,
-0.004702776204794645,
0.21605488657951355,
0.02608388103544712,
0.2164561152458191,
0.005824068561196327,
0.6056705117225647,
-0.4209323227405548,
-0.17562030255794525,
-0.34446266293525696,
-0.16171465814113617,
0.34635141491889954,
-0.025591561570763588,
0.2256157249212265,
-0.28766319155693054,
-0.5114853978157043,
-0.14849410951137543,
-0.3488950729370117,
0.23181042075157166,
0.353107213973999,
0.3246610462665558,
-0.11063478142023087,
0.31251946091651917,
-0.45634302496910095,
0.6514536142349243,
-0.13157767057418823,
-0.43920668959617615,
0.7103692889213562,
-0.40600690245628357,
-0.05834583938121796,
-0.3578382432460785,
0.9165590405464172,
0.5341809988021851,
-0.09575475752353668,
-0.17253750562667847,
-0.14815635979175568,
0.23404082655906677,
0.2293403148651123,
-0.6091915369033813,
0.04650125280022621,
0.0807381346821785,
-0.8389663696289062,
-0.6319471001625061,
-0.0009172986610792577,
-1.1699771881103516,
-0.398169606924057,
-0.4103855490684509,
0.6926686763763428,
-0.14231091737747192,
-0.316619336605072,
-0.033651888370513916,
-0.1013357937335968,
0.08059494197368622,
0.19504591822624207,
-0.3430818021297455,
-0.05926847457885742,
0.5553977489471436,
0.8906939029693604,
-0.017626864835619926,
-0.22902131080627441,
-0.21282702684402466,
-0.10103050619363785,
-0.026394687592983246,
0.6418379545211792,
-0.7219600081443787,
-0.23360539972782135,
-0.19349901378154755,
-0.11462069302797318,
-0.0241575725376606,
-0.23333753645420074,
0.47071513533592224,
-0.34499406814575195,
0.5129315853118896,
-0.17895476520061493,
-0.24787551164627075,
-0.5131091475486755,
0.5632852911949158,
-0.5539802312850952,
0.8442222476005554,
0.0960228368639946,
-0.6738404631614685,
0.519472062587738,
-0.3307447135448456,
-0.2912375032901764,
-0.37811121344566345,
-0.41085174679756165,
-0.7880638241767883,
0.3312905430793762,
0.6066884994506836,
0.34942135214805603,
-0.5021607875823975,
0.23482775688171387,
-0.7014930248260498,
-0.04153621196746826,
0.17885181307792664,
-0.4465468227863312,
0.09427391737699509,
0.4165228307247162,
-0.10610885918140411,
0.1833653748035431,
-0.9543938636779785,
0.031837332993745804,
-0.014020703732967377,
0.04880591481924057,
-0.42561599612236023,
0.1529092788696289,
-0.11060015857219696,
0.6805459260940552,
0.28871792554855347,
-0.5511729121208191,
0.19327659904956818,
-0.05741551145911217,
0.2769792973995209,
0.675125777721405,
0.12216031551361084,
0.43241849541664124,
-0.3793809115886688,
0.6016277074813843,
0.64925217628479,
0.4432021677494049,
-0.28600865602493286,
-0.6738060116767883,
-0.7439931631088257,
-0.26758459210395813,
0.2213468849658966,
0.18401025235652924,
-0.8191562294960022,
0.3166038691997528,
-0.10763103514909744,
-0.022568056359887123,
-0.7898945212364197,
0.25004732608795166,
0.47123032808303833,
0.39528265595436096,
0.4600730538368225,
-0.8624168038368225,
-0.4645739197731018,
-0.9363535642623901,
-0.21231627464294434,
-0.08909966051578522,
0.17887352406978607,
0.12625481188297272,
-0.05764193832874298,
-0.020419495180249214,
0.9584600329399109,
-0.22609096765518188,
-0.5753530859947205,
-0.11375752091407776,
0.5511407256126404,
0.04030740633606911,
0.4042622148990631,
0.2802591621875763,
-0.855986475944519,
0.02975759468972683,
-0.03362119570374489,
-0.7994247674942017,
-0.19499869644641876,
-0.21566076576709747,
0.0017277465667575598,
0.06699486821889877,
0.47841495275497437,
-0.70206618309021,
0.6105175614356995,
0.6543821096420288,
-0.21462880074977875,
0.0242967177182436,
0.13362976908683777,
0.20477402210235596,
-1.3402023315429688,
-0.3551764190196991,
0.42554494738578796,
-0.02885379083454609,
-0.5148796439170837,
0.030057204887270927,
-0.31496134400367737,
-0.06038855016231537,
-0.08378838747739792,
0.28712522983551025,
-0.4365813136100769,
0.048428505659103394,
-0.38036927580833435,
0.005634473171085119,
0.26607275009155273,
0.7330725789070129,
-0.1341201215982437,
0.45922720432281494,
0.6964769959449768,
-0.4293508231639862,
-0.10328612476587296,
-0.16293983161449432,
-0.20325422286987305,
0.7160117626190186,
-0.25143247842788696,
-0.07781796902418137,
-0.41811251640319824,
0.4558180570602417,
-0.9160531759262085,
-0.16615739464759827,
0.4815773367881775,
-0.4464814364910126,
0.15775592625141144,
-0.06256848573684692,
-0.2199627012014389,
-0.24023102223873138,
-0.39939188957214355,
0.6804092526435852,
0.3723998963832855,
-0.4448254704475403,
0.8553370833396912,
0.2917511761188507,
-0.17731206119060516,
-0.6604875326156616,
-0.4304668605327606,
-0.016133535653352737,
-0.19955497980117798,
-0.8041689991950989,
0.30524709820747375,
0.24418416619300842,
-0.08672021329402924,
0.28395864367485046,
-0.32086360454559326,
-0.06233570724725723,
-0.3718835413455963,
0.4941839277744293,
0.05654121935367584,
-0.17987774312496185,
0.23934045433998108,
0.043533723801374435,
-0.03810598701238632,
0.04063449427485466,
-0.044783737510442734,
0.6421607136726379,
-0.28254058957099915,
-0.3247640132904053,
-0.5052629113197327,
0.32194986939430237,
0.47337961196899414,
-0.12037011235952377,
0.5188813209533691,
1.4022799730300903,
-0.12164132297039032,
-0.18452604115009308,
-0.7479727268218994,
-0.041463784873485565,
-0.44171273708343506,
0.5018826723098755,
-0.37495777010917664,
-1.062495231628418,
0.5372738838195801,
-0.03686584159731865,
-0.10657279193401337,
0.3175489008426666,
0.40929102897644043,
0.06175113841891289,
0.8985223174095154,
0.3872814476490021,
-0.2874569594860077,
0.5618695020675659,
-0.010378267616033554,
0.46398040652275085,
-0.8384743928909302,
-0.26861536502838135,
-0.2760908007621765,
-0.5495947003364563,
-0.6613394618034363,
-0.5779626369476318,
0.3880540132522583,
0.2473350614309311,
0.2307833582162857,
-0.2564714848995209,
-0.5252740383148193,
0.417596697807312,
0.5332515239715576,
0.2522992491722107,
0.31297796964645386,
0.2215251922607422,
0.25825873017311096,
-0.016977516934275627,
-0.6083618998527527,
-0.07768300920724869,
1.0159976482391357,
0.4032093286514282,
0.8175302147865295,
-0.24821455776691437,
0.809644877910614,
0.10982418805360794,
0.022381838411092758,
-0.5702734589576721,
0.6080819368362427,
-0.13098688423633575,
-0.34452569484710693,
-0.02210068516433239,
-0.7914508581161499,
-0.902692973613739,
0.5817959308624268,
-0.24065212905406952,
-0.4937737286090851,
0.1034877672791481,
0.11271596699953079,
-0.12086586654186249,
0.4821148216724396,
-0.5434006452560425,
0.45065921545028687,
0.3828998804092407,
-0.3098292946815491,
-0.3892512321472168,
-0.7907446622848511,
0.5787345170974731,
0.2721499800682068,
0.6178028583526611,
-0.40697652101516724,
-0.010762844234704971,
0.6673146486282349,
-0.18768905103206635,
0.8867834806442261,
-0.3206857442855835,
0.05355342850089073,
0.454166054725647,
-0.23876596987247467,
0.4062177538871765,
0.21492554247379303,
0.41956019401550293,
0.38339924812316895,
-0.19373436272144318,
-0.29339176416397095,
-0.5989909768104553,
0.8496716022491455,
-0.7185243964195251,
-0.5011817216873169,
-0.45952194929122925,
-0.8516165018081665,
-0.3099935054779053,
-0.06729485839605331,
0.085812047123909,
0.5686587691307068,
0.03984486684203148,
0.1622638702392578,
0.5327722430229187,
-0.22066906094551086,
0.5747103095054626,
0.20354411005973816,
-0.3519068658351898,
-0.5859570503234863,
1.2355064153671265,
-0.13815248012542725,
0.22019560635089874,
0.18044805526733398,
0.30860060453414917,
-0.1543162614107132,
-0.5832363367080688,
-0.31519192457199097,
-0.0477546826004982,
-0.46103256940841675,
-0.3059897720813751,
-0.5786417722702026,
-0.227699413895607,
-0.3312865197658539,
-0.03899518400430679,
-0.32312044501304626,
-0.43231308460235596,
-0.2489786297082901,
0.3923718333244324,
0.36969414353370667,
0.5159127116203308,
-0.028108494356274605,
0.14927034080028534,
-0.7751599550247192,
0.6520957350730896,
0.29866838455200195,
0.42891961336135864,
-0.0960683599114418,
-0.24019357562065125,
0.049338068813085556,
-0.08681593090295792,
-0.33405300974845886,
-0.379504531621933,
0.4113054573535919,
0.11521906405687332,
0.09964945167303085,
0.4174637794494629,
-0.23053476214408875,
0.863728404045105,
-0.08379197865724564,
0.9734953045845032,
0.5946378111839294,
-0.6677603125572205,
0.18059730529785156,
-0.3823520541191101,
0.4528064429759979,
0.6582256555557251,
-0.13532891869544983,
-0.398849219083786,
-0.6887481212615967,
-0.551738977432251,
-1.093943476676941,
0.5507723689079285,
0.328733891248703,
-0.16956710815429688,
-0.05320467799901962,
0.194055438041687,
0.17693550884723663,
0.33318254351615906,
-0.983883261680603,
-0.15812811255455017,
-0.12028888612985611,
-0.35619351267814636,
0.2966548502445221,
-0.03395850211381912,
-0.3163687586784363,
-0.2952122092247009,
0.6375774145126343,
0.01896653324365616,
0.22803470492362976,
0.17150872945785522,
0.0025876739528030157,
-0.16164885461330414,
0.5549855828285217,
0.5384038090705872,
0.3564581573009491,
-0.20458918809890747,
0.026031672954559326,
-0.0901651456952095,
-0.6024077534675598,
0.13634046912193298,
0.033238690346479416,
-0.2657800614833832,
0.1450207680463791,
0.05330144613981247,
0.7765176892280579,
0.07349980622529984,
-0.16508708894252777,
0.5690321326255798,
-0.22623074054718018,
-0.04811064153909683,
-0.1634470820426941,
-0.06598883867263794,
-0.301248162984848,
0.31733739376068115,
0.19344398379325867,
0.5100457072257996,
0.11432977020740509,
-0.25293153524398804,
0.08646424114704132,
0.5773229002952576,
-0.43464571237564087,
-0.1928204745054245,
0.25334686040878296,
0.3195590376853943,
-0.0008183263125829399,
0.042064983397722244,
-0.6572346687316895,
0.015289563685655594,
0.5718625783920288,
0.2181798368692398,
1.015772819519043,
0.1389346420764923,
0.2883135974407196,
0.34425315260887146,
0.3015274703502655,
-0.3165675103664398,
0.3870719075202942,
0.04444688931107521,
-0.6527053713798523,
-0.6321801543235779,
-0.8906214237213135,
-0.20265698432922363,
0.24964967370033264,
-0.9430594444274902,
0.02623453550040722,
-0.49040719866752625,
-0.30210521817207336,
-0.2655009925365448,
-0.37607893347740173,
-0.6182022094726562,
0.28310951590538025,
0.25150468945503235,
0.157607764005661,
-0.5214641094207764,
0.6574788689613342,
0.4370480179786682,
-0.5256206393241882,
-0.5334495306015015,
0.007267419248819351,
0.26112768054008484,
-0.7336839437484741,
0.17678679525852203,
0.4793974757194519,
-0.24630899727344513,
-0.3255826532840729,
-0.434396892786026,
-0.9416486024856567,
1.1316450834274292,
-0.21914197504520416,
-0.6723974347114563,
0.14939507842063904,
0.18244676291942596,
0.39018264412879944,
-0.5392323732376099,
0.10605407506227493,
0.27772316336631775,
0.48875489830970764,
0.0740555077791214,
-0.627422034740448,
-0.13133348524570465,
-0.45752277970314026,
0.3491136431694031,
0.5522149801254272,
-0.9029375314712524,
0.8910911679267883,
0.1944788545370102,
-0.05494137480854988,
0.07339627295732498,
0.8687503933906555,
0.14807246625423431,
0.680896520614624,
0.7020969986915588,
1.1314696073532104,
0.31913667917251587,
-0.26794618368148804,
0.7251309156417847,
-0.4029911458492279,
0.45587021112442017,
1.0042717456817627,
-0.13155239820480347,
0.4298630952835083,
0.7188291549682617,
-0.1425512582063675,
0.7199042439460754,
0.4055798053741455,
0.19434423744678497,
0.5249037146568298,
0.13361650705337524,
-0.6109257936477661,
-0.14390182495117188,
-0.29273009300231934,
-0.5607509016990662,
0.3893483579158783,
0.44358646869659424,
-0.4627802073955536,
-0.3703635334968567,
0.1536998599767685,
0.17738984525203705,
-0.21659345924854279,
-0.5966635346412659,
0.7102116942405701,
0.08471709489822388,
-0.5115270018577576,
0.027484633028507233,
-0.04485432431101799,
0.9938962459564209,
-0.6812986135482788,
0.15978841483592987,
-0.11110400408506393,
0.039741795510053635,
-0.22784948348999023,
-0.5552677512168884,
0.12707652151584625,
-0.22489821910858154,
-0.30364856123924255,
-0.046885840594768524,
0.7340314984321594,
-0.5993086695671082,
-0.6318972110748291,
0.08943042159080505,
0.30230286717414856,
-0.20309767127037048,
-0.0012415200471878052,
-0.7895112633705139,
0.20801176130771637,
-0.1153947114944458,
-0.5009964108467102,
0.6522341370582581,
0.6890323162078857,
0.12147457897663116,
0.46381181478500366,
0.5604499578475952,
0.11218008399009705,
0.13477320969104767,
0.5615899562835693,
0.9425001740455627,
-0.6793214678764343,
-0.40707844495773315,
-0.6589415669441223,
0.3116140067577362,
-0.25348594784736633,
-0.7216929793357849,
0.6405860781669617,
0.21991853415966034,
0.7710134387016296,
0.039047736674547195,
0.7160967588424683,
-0.3268543779850006,
0.1687772572040558,
-0.8639829158782959,
0.30281969904899597,
-0.6389617323875427,
0.16799506545066833,
-0.49381735920906067,
-0.9240579009056091,
-0.43252354860305786,
0.49417534470558167,
-0.041119467467069626,
0.12403281033039093,
0.9860013723373413,
1.250200629234314,
0.04705355316400528,
0.22159376740455627,
0.19885630905628204,
0.016284586861729622,
0.26510486006736755,
0.4714371860027313,
0.8440583944320679,
-0.32485732436180115,
0.6308132410049438,
-0.5995450615882874,
-0.19057270884513855,
0.20532377064228058,
-0.7288859486579895,
-0.8282095789909363,
-0.6196829676628113,
-0.481036514043808,
-0.5532121658325195,
-0.068796306848526,
0.921353816986084,
0.55119389295578,
-0.6238141059875488,
0.02076084539294243,
-0.2041051685810089,
-0.029315896332263947,
-0.37307021021842957,
-0.301482230424881,
0.1756608933210373,
-0.8773523569107056,
-0.49991825222969055,
0.2620094418525696,
0.6638887524604797,
-0.23616276681423187,
-0.499479740858078,
0.11314266175031662,
-0.11438599228858948,
0.07883098721504211,
0.5283295512199402,
0.242344468832016,
-0.9291917681694031,
-0.31864261627197266,
-0.5668770670890808,
0.03598564490675926,
0.21068120002746582,
0.9801867604255676,
-0.6149641275405884,
0.7278202176094055,
0.532832682132721,
0.5565975904464722,
0.3964588940143585,
0.16939324140548706,
0.2687076926231384,
-1.0204792022705078,
0.5840364098548889,
0.09151984006166458,
0.23882605135440826,
0.1609288901090622,
-0.16427172720432281,
0.3284232020378113,
0.46605145931243896,
-0.5007839798927307,
-0.4438188672065735,
0.24246743321418762,
-1.4044060707092285,
-0.2643103301525116,
1.363018274307251,
0.1202307865023613,
-0.37816593050956726,
-0.06446172297000885,
-0.04285762831568718,
0.1306740790605545,
-0.641754686832428,
1.1810939311981201,
0.9052204489707947,
-0.12414440512657166,
-0.22645972669124603,
-0.3119739294052124,
0.4796048104763031,
0.7276150584220886,
-0.9023049473762512,
-0.42783471941947937,
0.5606229901313782,
0.003004401922225952,
0.31272783875465393,
0.5800098776817322,
-0.4292241632938385,
0.1262357383966446,
0.007839290425181389,
0.36569178104400635,
-0.19359268248081207,
-0.39957723021507263,
-0.4577643573284149,
0.5662282109260559,
-0.24631886184215546,
-0.47143077850341797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11966v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11966v4
|
Multiple-Choice Questions are Efficient and Robust LLM Evaluators
| 2024-05-20T11:47:13 | 2024-06-26T07:16:42 |
Ziyin Zhang, Zhaokun Jiang, Lizhen Xu, Hongkun Hao, Rui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present GSM-MC, a multiple-choice (MC) dataset constructed by collecting
answers and incorrect predictions on GSM8K from 60 open-source models. Through
extensive experiments, we show that LLMs' performance on the MC version of this
popular benchmark is strongly correlated with their performance on the original
version and is quite robust to distractor choices and option orders, while the
evaluation time is reduced by a factor of up to 30. Following similar
procedures, we introduce MATH-MC, constructed from MATH, and PythonIO, a new
program reasoning MC dataset constructed from HumanEval and MBPP. Experimental
results indicate that LLMs' performance on these MC benchmarks leaves much room
for improvement. Our data and code are available at
https://github.com/Geralt-Targaryen/MC-Evaluation.
|
[
-0.5653477311134338,
-0.565861701965332,
0.826179027557373,
-0.034736573696136475,
-0.0909661054611206,
0.11338643729686737,
-0.23161651194095612,
-0.16213205456733704,
-0.19152207672595978,
0.4494202733039856,
-0.5226276516914368,
-0.3471234142780304,
-0.4849451780319214,
0.16293121874332428,
0.2521883249282837,
0.9754716753959656,
-0.14506895840168,
0.4950677156448364,
-0.4698873460292816,
-0.3903038799762726,
0.014445547945797443,
-0.4900321066379547,
-0.5313783288002014,
-0.45584744215011597,
0.6583312153816223,
0.4604966640472412,
0.7536563277244568,
0.5740228891372681,
0.6808437705039978,
0.20813237130641937,
0.1196369081735611,
0.33357182145118713,
-0.2708912789821625,
0.08126134425401688,
-0.015767332166433334,
-0.43501245975494385,
-0.24613173305988312,
0.334025114774704,
0.5092606544494629,
0.19680389761924744,
-0.254046231508255,
0.6567566394805908,
-0.18033891916275024,
0.6277951002120972,
-0.9398474097251892,
-0.2543450891971588,
-0.825876772403717,
-0.22734180092811584,
-0.031951986253261566,
-0.1856485903263092,
-0.38911089301109314,
-0.6080631017684937,
-0.2599177658557892,
-0.27271947264671326,
-0.18271882832050323,
-0.00217417161911726,
0.45288828015327454,
0.5381654500961304,
-0.450659841299057,
-0.5485902428627014,
-0.48039326071739197,
1.0518717765808105,
-0.1872938871383667,
0.36804839968681335,
0.6361156105995178,
0.8551562428474426,
-0.20080113410949707,
-0.46257486939430237,
0.0009513223194517195,
-0.517837643623352,
0.4105358123779297,
0.5310940146446228,
0.020652828738093376,
-0.169077068567276,
0.47180306911468506,
0.2356511652469635,
-0.5420774221420288,
-0.057058922946453094,
-0.4118673503398895,
-0.32017359137535095,
0.7068386673927307,
0.3156760334968567,
0.12752056121826172,
-0.18924768269062042,
-0.3770729899406433,
0.19327296316623688,
-0.6982703804969788,
0.12130726128816605,
0.7079046368598938,
-0.06110646203160286,
0.24618719518184662,
1.0328084230422974,
-0.1614610254764557,
0.8195042610168457,
-0.27476802468299866,
-0.492397665977478,
0.07352138310670853,
-0.2602290213108063,
-0.32695016264915466,
-0.18349787592887878,
0.715497612953186,
0.28354769945144653,
0.21220998466014862,
-0.002893408527597785,
-0.09680470824241638,
0.18605533242225647,
0.300260990858078,
-0.7177000045776367,
-0.2982311546802521,
0.5008996725082397,
-0.4397227168083191,
-0.31132838129997253,
-0.02348082698881626,
-0.383693128824234,
-0.18700800836086273,
-0.2629549205303192,
0.3527319133281708,
-0.28705936670303345,
-0.0003916468995157629,
0.1927243024110794,
-0.13898888230323792,
0.09980805218219757,
0.31024110317230225,
-0.46983975172042847,
0.3798898458480835,
0.5421302318572998,
0.8736258149147034,
-0.3207070827484131,
-0.3055989146232605,
-0.9061211943626404,
-0.11407103389501572,
-0.2861172556877136,
0.8811688423156738,
-0.717048168182373,
-0.41997507214546204,
-0.5539502501487732,
-0.34721577167510986,
-0.2668752074241638,
-0.7596597671508789,
0.8252249360084534,
-0.5077387690544128,
0.20098166167736053,
-0.39243027567863464,
-0.35725894570350647,
-0.15179575979709625,
0.4952073097229004,
-0.652973473072052,
1.257184386253357,
0.27580395340919495,
-0.7353322505950928,
0.31495389342308044,
-0.7335324287414551,
-0.01217062771320343,
-0.27083900570869446,
-0.17334838211536407,
-0.5533856153488159,
0.013740760274231434,
0.5091260671615601,
0.40281030535697937,
-0.18720728158950806,
-0.0073273563757538795,
-0.8596886992454529,
-0.5705470442771912,
0.6645150780677795,
-0.6193786859512329,
0.977059543132782,
0.5600978136062622,
0.17883995175361633,
-0.15082032978534698,
-1.0270681381225586,
0.3341851532459259,
0.02255714125931263,
-0.7851605415344238,
-0.0489388108253479,
0.07101855427026749,
-0.4381057322025299,
0.53145831823349,
-0.048793260008096695,
-0.33144935965538025,
0.21289561688899994,
0.2981633245944977,
0.23254984617233276,
0.7761052846908569,
-0.08820224553346634,
0.18737396597862244,
-0.8716883659362793,
0.8296133875846863,
-0.18980659544467926,
0.27312493324279785,
-0.08246209472417831,
-0.7028638124465942,
-0.45775359869003296,
-0.6732702255249023,
0.2731093466281891,
0.7134581208229065,
-0.7268128991127014,
0.010897106491029263,
0.021119358018040657,
-0.48012056946754456,
-0.5667232871055603,
0.1312239170074463,
0.043564751744270325,
0.44612404704093933,
0.24471129477024078,
0.37889179587364197,
-0.5059375166893005,
-0.7900887131690979,
-0.44917187094688416,
-0.1163719967007637,
-0.2664639353752136,
0.5660327076911926,
0.4976885914802551,
-0.07400307804346085,
0.8132110834121704,
-0.4358169138431549,
0.4879971444606781,
-0.04179960489273071,
-0.1432454138994217,
0.25799405574798584,
0.12641917169094086,
0.5111538767814636,
-0.4906359612941742,
-0.3192022442817688,
-0.1768614947795868,
-0.5515204668045044,
-0.3307650685310364,
-0.030011724680662155,
-0.336213082075119,
-0.31606218218803406,
0.007456131279468536,
-0.40994733572006226,
0.038971997797489166,
0.508019208908081,
0.06172316148877144,
1.0980143547058105,
0.0536879263818264,
0.2681025564670563,
-1.1364012956619263,
0.0889052003622055,
-0.07278242707252502,
-0.26516804099082947,
-0.49132663011550903,
-0.06667201220989227,
0.1738917976617813,
0.014282599091529846,
-0.8152984380722046,
0.5591667890548706,
-0.39504995942115784,
-0.30850154161453247,
0.06711067259311676,
0.1773611456155777,
-0.26698586344718933,
0.22743196785449982,
-0.378703773021698,
1.0866167545318604,
0.5896424055099487,
-0.6911144852638245,
0.3195863962173462,
0.07368802279233932,
-0.5186911821365356,
0.4625434875488281,
-0.41183722019195557,
0.3972882628440857,
-0.03465666249394417,
0.06787662208080292,
-1.1944550275802612,
-0.4172417223453522,
0.4866724908351898,
-0.41787201166152954,
-0.24995729327201843,
-0.5142280459403992,
-0.3950366973876953,
-0.6006841659545898,
-0.5634307265281677,
0.26272261142730713,
0.30863484740257263,
-0.7247433662414551,
0.5474793314933777,
0.19278673827648163,
-0.06944736838340759,
-0.9414753317832947,
-0.7239391207695007,
-0.12231136113405228,
-0.4205590784549713,
-0.5184983015060425,
-0.24703624844551086,
-0.5983762741088867,
-0.5093314051628113,
-0.33561816811561584,
-0.2871279716491699,
-0.08500557392835617,
0.4415283203125,
0.2239093780517578,
0.6189758777618408,
0.01762259379029274,
0.03926336392760277,
0.02137364260852337,
-0.19783459603786469,
0.2911053001880646,
-0.08041512966156006,
0.3144287168979645,
-0.2195214182138443,
-0.770112156867981,
0.13859499990940094,
0.15709188580513,
0.7282403111457825,
0.011509661562740803,
0.12561549246311188,
0.46452322602272034,
-0.21822498738765717,
-0.19223935902118683,
-0.6764561533927917,
0.382938414812088,
-0.4646681249141693,
-0.01584336906671524,
-0.7147961258888245,
-0.9164552092552185,
0.709632933139801,
-0.1590825617313385,
0.15661758184432983,
0.242684468626976,
0.8075693845748901,
0.08740545809268951,
1.3206350803375244,
-0.17854565382003784,
0.12089735269546509,
0.31238359212875366,
0.05521193891763687,
-0.2732810974121094,
-0.9243954420089722,
-0.0900774821639061,
-0.5218446850776672,
-0.22381579875946045,
-0.37230241298675537,
-0.4527013301849365,
0.3298795819282532,
0.25419628620147705,
-0.2585405111312866,
0.041381679475307465,
-0.4188125729560852,
0.7555180788040161,
0.38704144954681396,
0.2343698889017105,
0.26627835631370544,
0.03879136964678764,
-0.6399158239364624,
0.2552122473716736,
-0.7492533922195435,
-0.8799418210983276,
1.7262587547302246,
0.2008161097764969,
0.9456795454025269,
0.018907418474555016,
0.741764485836029,
-0.10297448933124542,
0.7814231514930725,
-0.8464072346687317,
0.5398760437965393,
0.1305452585220337,
-0.6253560781478882,
0.019864672794938087,
-0.697867214679718,
-0.6340324282646179,
0.6070414781570435,
0.007899452932178974,
-0.8171759247779846,
-0.30810612440109253,
-0.07097335904836655,
-0.6404740214347839,
0.2671962380409241,
-0.8200667500495911,
0.41627952456474304,
-0.48427674174308777,
-0.3617241680622101,
0.18343375623226166,
-0.3954772651195526,
0.7032528519630432,
-0.17566856741905212,
0.07363762706518173,
-0.478894978761673,
-0.18749815225601196,
0.5657345652580261,
-0.17178839445114136,
0.11458415538072586,
0.17866455018520355,
0.051070377230644226,
0.6240194439888,
-0.0013431912520900369,
0.31329700350761414,
0.4201098084449768,
-0.6525527238845825,
0.02270740643143654,
0.011532116681337357,
-0.3340912163257599,
-0.6815325021743774,
0.5994329452514648,
-0.6104243397712708,
-0.390813946723938,
-0.26357948780059814,
-0.5972512364387512,
-0.3163158893585205,
0.1267692893743515,
0.2255290001630783,
0.43725407123565674,
-0.036687228828668594,
0.07460466772317886,
0.4023648500442505,
-0.0013984147226437926,
0.5062459707260132,
0.2375059872865677,
-0.3942256569862366,
-1.0044310092926025,
0.5924720168113708,
0.30765700340270996,
0.34008434414863586,
0.09490153193473816,
0.4119793772697449,
-0.6628836989402771,
-0.6292763352394104,
-0.7239903211593628,
0.00862734206020832,
-0.8748834729194641,
-0.12967757880687714,
-0.7052798867225647,
-0.1828870326280594,
0.15550167858600616,
-0.07728316634893417,
-0.13408148288726807,
-0.5187286138534546,
-0.27056601643562317,
-0.187474325299263,
-0.11815890669822693,
0.6379241347312927,
0.01052062213420868,
0.09462207555770874,
-0.6565684676170349,
0.5415064096450806,
0.40490978956222534,
0.5340104103088379,
-0.42686155438423157,
-0.23242446780204773,
-0.10231775045394897,
0.1902165710926056,
-0.4515814185142517,
-0.8119461536407471,
-0.18692071735858917,
-0.22545605897903442,
0.9649713635444641,
0.4437727928161621,
0.04589259251952171,
0.6626945734024048,
-0.22093912959098816,
0.7722001671791077,
0.19525209069252014,
-0.660725474357605,
0.4418382942676544,
-0.3505556583404541,
0.35470011830329895,
0.7407612204551697,
0.5242526531219482,
-0.08557046949863434,
-0.2786414325237274,
-0.5431251525878906,
0.0007762223831377923,
0.6405163407325745,
0.3684174418449402,
-0.4453118145465851,
0.03458915278315544,
0.23735332489013672,
0.3513679802417755,
0.1975702941417694,
-0.5267053246498108,
-0.2638804018497467,
-0.10747205466032028,
-0.09113985300064087,
-0.19525091350078583,
-0.31596753001213074,
-0.25829553604125977,
-0.21554458141326904,
0.46487295627593994,
-0.34002697467803955,
0.25255268812179565,
-0.005840078927576542,
-0.19170576333999634,
-0.0003470157098490745,
0.4569590091705322,
0.9286257028579712,
0.9857415556907654,
-0.383090078830719,
0.5221176743507385,
0.5147587060928345,
-0.5229453444480896,
0.4414564073085785,
0.015597805380821228,
-0.05011257901787758,
-0.07374309003353119,
-0.04184184595942497,
0.4376741647720337,
-0.11528570204973221,
-0.6281810402870178,
0.2621533274650574,
-0.1476590633392334,
-0.5096505284309387,
-0.0025716288946568966,
0.2811550498008728,
0.040998026728630066,
0.09935931861400604,
0.15877434611320496,
0.4129160940647125,
0.20247505605220795,
-0.24788425862789154,
0.3827279210090637,
0.4181763529777527,
-0.10385981947183609,
-0.0345814973115921,
0.7192175984382629,
-0.27311450242996216,
-0.27509182691574097,
0.3946346044540405,
-0.301364928483963,
-0.5397449731826782,
0.7701687812805176,
0.4619699716567993,
0.8152144551277161,
-0.2510420083999634,
0.31125950813293457,
0.3445388674736023,
0.27159613370895386,
-0.36734601855278015,
0.7395896911621094,
-0.1792195737361908,
-0.619005024433136,
-0.4275020360946655,
-0.34362882375717163,
-0.6806106567382812,
0.21776820719242096,
-0.625272810459137,
0.3567166328430176,
-0.49949324131011963,
-0.44179567694664,
-0.18571309745311737,
0.2279001623392105,
-0.5506600737571716,
0.08734450489282608,
0.09720270335674286,
0.9718854427337646,
-0.524031937122345,
0.6759641766548157,
0.8211512565612793,
0.01849810965359211,
-0.6083568334579468,
-0.3134758770465851,
0.0942080095410347,
-0.8716362714767456,
0.22810114920139313,
0.3595612347126007,
-0.2898767590522766,
-0.24342361092567444,
-0.6321050524711609,
-0.8827498555183411,
1.1090691089630127,
0.6303464770317078,
-0.4172723591327667,
0.5834944844245911,
0.09316041320562363,
0.10488029569387436,
-0.2700943946838379,
0.9127470850944519,
0.6032766103744507,
0.548717200756073,
0.156368687748909,
-0.6138785481452942,
-0.1913914978504181,
-0.3384070098400116,
-0.27997979521751404,
0.18180467188358307,
-0.8299815654754639,
0.7264147996902466,
-0.45037841796875,
-0.14145083725452423,
0.041405413299798965,
0.14715974032878876,
0.7355260848999023,
0.5575066804885864,
0.3744758367538452,
0.5462141036987305,
1.047371745109558,
-0.20784370601177216,
1.07835054397583,
-0.30898964405059814,
0.43326693773269653,
1.1668013334274292,
-0.15564872324466705,
0.6998124718666077,
0.4482215344905853,
-0.4086974263191223,
0.056889940053224564,
1.0780847072601318,
-0.18137846887111664,
0.30622246861457825,
0.6058856248855591,
-0.2997824549674988,
-0.6571487784385681,
0.3883664011955261,
-0.22163081169128418,
0.4653851389884949,
0.1425406038761139,
-0.09570874273777008,
-0.3464382588863373,
-0.13930262625217438,
-0.10741284489631653,
-0.4246307611465454,
-0.3589627146720886,
0.33346953988075256,
0.06363826990127563,
-0.7233792543411255,
0.486415296792984,
-0.0852857157588005,
0.42791152000427246,
-0.6670150756835938,
0.21877770125865936,
-0.011942446231842041,
-0.04531828314065933,
-0.2756425440311432,
-0.7539681792259216,
0.16861678659915924,
-0.02729049138724804,
-0.06541763246059418,
-0.15238308906555176,
1.0018181800842285,
-0.18550990521907806,
-0.629209578037262,
-0.027871349826455116,
0.8014076948165894,
0.3989953100681305,
-0.14154647290706635,
-0.979099690914154,
0.020895354449748993,
-0.1604747474193573,
-0.41731834411621094,
0.3021455705165863,
-0.08275182545185089,
0.03118710406124592,
1.1855355501174927,
0.8981756567955017,
-0.03269629925489426,
0.40788984298706055,
0.010095621459186077,
0.7947018146514893,
-0.4095703661441803,
-0.32832929491996765,
-1.1466050148010254,
0.4175121486186981,
0.012050317600369453,
-0.5176304578781128,
0.9176745414733887,
0.9916003346443176,
0.7898070812225342,
-0.0183486919850111,
1.0034615993499756,
0.44148918986320496,
0.3005353808403015,
-0.6888930201530457,
0.4973573386669159,
-0.4239441454410553,
0.44000065326690674,
-0.07515674084424973,
-0.9389680624008179,
-0.3154330849647522,
0.39388197660446167,
-0.4491278827190399,
0.2757534384727478,
0.6290896534919739,
0.825522243976593,
-0.2695351541042328,
0.09967679530382156,
0.5332899689674377,
-0.5860850811004639,
0.22934424877166748,
0.6552848219871521,
1.6468905210494995,
-0.37293994426727295,
0.8059550523757935,
-0.22781506180763245,
-0.16596518456935883,
-0.16230085492134094,
-0.9641074538230896,
-1.0861092805862427,
-0.045146651566028595,
-0.3058854639530182,
-0.32245901226997375,
-0.11732667684555054,
1.0809719562530518,
0.6491155624389648,
-0.6827760934829712,
-0.19757595658302307,
0.21407094597816467,
0.5749095678329468,
-0.33034995198249817,
-0.13876309990882874,
0.1493968814611435,
-0.22566945850849152,
-0.4965742528438568,
0.5529682636260986,
0.36260321736335754,
0.12655602395534515,
0.010203319601714611,
-0.32157567143440247,
0.040099576115608215,
0.3477054238319397,
0.667823076248169,
-0.17467212677001953,
-0.6247370839118958,
-0.2912038564682007,
0.23549175262451172,
-0.21024373173713684,
0.3742038607597351,
1.0272477865219116,
-0.49974149465560913,
0.46741488575935364,
0.5310931205749512,
0.6972992420196533,
0.16892284154891968,
0.4566180408000946,
0.14130276441574097,
-0.20629547536373138,
-0.5481032729148865,
0.15527886152267456,
0.4457297921180725,
0.02175622247159481,
-0.2738885283470154,
0.6573362350463867,
0.19874611496925354,
-0.7436032295227051,
-0.7352601885795593,
0.21336375176906586,
-1.0976929664611816,
-0.13212180137634277,
1.5061718225479126,
-0.001916204346343875,
-0.1451474130153656,
-0.2746032178401947,
-0.35460853576660156,
-0.10643214732408524,
-0.2683934271335602,
0.5901436805725098,
1.1780529022216797,
-0.40097901225090027,
-0.2191445529460907,
-0.8038288950920105,
0.24107438325881958,
0.15188652276992798,
-0.9568701982498169,
-0.28313952684402466,
0.48407652974128723,
0.6600890159606934,
-0.0648968368768692,
0.7781956195831299,
-0.10435955226421356,
0.382516086101532,
0.22906944155693054,
-0.4045082628726959,
-0.5655748844146729,
-0.43196025490760803,
-0.42588481307029724,
0.3801819682121277,
-0.1299550086259842,
-0.5070705413818359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11950v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11950v1
|
WisPerMed at BioLaySumm: Adapting Autoregressive Large Language Models for Lay Summarization of Scientific Articles
| 2024-05-20T10:54:47 | 2024-05-20T10:54:47 |
Tabea M. G. Pakull, Hendrik Damm, Ahmad Idrissi-Yaghir, Henning Schäfer, Peter A. Horn, Christoph M. Friedrich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper details the efforts of the WisPerMed team in the BioLaySumm2024
Shared Task on automatic lay summarization in the biomedical domain, aimed at
making scientific publications accessible to non-specialists. Large language
models (LLMs), specifically the BioMistral and Llama3 models, were fine-tuned
and employed to create lay summaries from complex scientific texts. The
summarization performance was enhanced through various approaches, including
instruction tuning, few-shot learning, and prompt variations tailored to
incorporate specific context information. The experiments demonstrated that
fine-tuning generally led to the best performance across most evaluated
metrics. Few-shot learning notably improved the models' ability to generate
relevant and factually accurate texts, particularly when using a well-crafted
prompt. Additionally, a Dynamic Expert Selection (DES) mechanism to optimize
the selection of text outputs based on readability and factuality metrics was
developed. Out of 54 participants, the WisPerMed team reached the 4th place,
measured by readability, factuality, and relevance. Determined by the overall
score, our approach improved upon the baseline by approx. 5.5 percentage points
and was only approx 1.5 percentage points behind the first place.
|
[
-0.045983485877513885,
-0.4455934464931488,
0.6720041632652283,
0.4819675385951996,
-0.4011801481246948,
0.13593728840351105,
-0.22080320119857788,
-0.6768515706062317,
0.5234662890434265,
0.4238446056842804,
-0.13200287520885468,
-0.5881741046905518,
-0.8394033908843994,
0.7045116424560547,
-0.3477405905723572,
0.9808294177055359,
-0.07538039237260818,
0.04868341609835625,
-0.47173917293548584,
-0.19791381061077118,
-0.1548500657081604,
-0.14794503152370453,
-0.2987743616104126,
-0.29551804065704346,
0.5825074911117554,
0.31845831871032715,
0.44123998284339905,
0.7516924142837524,
0.6456548571586609,
0.2667231559753418,
-0.19318102300167084,
0.4224044382572174,
-0.6152763366699219,
0.17756593227386475,
-0.3134899437427521,
-0.4524954557418823,
-0.7603198885917664,
-0.0374588705599308,
0.5138441324234009,
1.04747474193573,
0.027105601504445076,
0.22653526067733765,
0.1224786788225174,
0.6345950365066528,
-0.5305467247962952,
0.11049117892980576,
-0.3770541846752167,
0.16508975625038147,
0.08921510726213455,
-0.5202378034591675,
-0.5271198153495789,
-0.31205108761787415,
0.09830860793590546,
-0.7617539167404175,
0.19950416684150696,
-0.048958297818899155,
0.31846433877944946,
0.4432917833328247,
-0.6232079267501831,
-0.2185370922088623,
-0.5058507323265076,
0.7575588822364807,
-1.077280879020691,
0.07728436589241028,
0.352216511964798,
-0.16159263253211975,
-0.4476175606250763,
-0.6426885724067688,
0.008822028525173664,
-0.3398853838443756,
-0.11793456971645355,
0.4063313901424408,
-0.2641206681728363,
-0.057390909641981125,
0.028938306495547295,
0.0021514573600143194,
-0.5674018263816833,
0.2298002392053604,
-0.6727194786071777,
-0.18914206326007843,
1.0566171407699585,
0.24769282341003418,
0.08055078983306885,
-0.06743243336677551,
-0.039306461811065674,
0.162408709526062,
-0.530770480632782,
-0.1999981850385666,
-0.128443643450737,
0.07819011807441711,
-0.10898753255605698,
0.8276690244674683,
-0.4753877818584442,
0.6681548953056335,
0.10359187424182892,
-0.313356876373291,
0.22532734274864197,
-0.39766445755958557,
-0.01953655481338501,
0.18593049049377441,
0.9204311370849609,
0.311107873916626,
0.007720786612480879,
-0.14745301008224487,
0.08800773322582245,
-0.43426576256752014,
0.08047656714916229,
-0.8703141808509827,
-0.30956435203552246,
0.33529600501060486,
-0.7685269713401794,
-0.5171164274215698,
-0.14922486245632172,
-0.6186507940292358,
-0.3930208086967468,
-0.22993406653404236,
0.5201577544212341,
-0.4179978370666504,
0.056515950709581375,
0.05734332278370857,
-0.254947304725647,
-0.33713817596435547,
0.6815202832221985,
-0.7236195206642151,
0.28393977880477905,
0.38128432631492615,
1.0342012643814087,
-0.6291860342025757,
-0.361724317073822,
-0.3429563045501709,
0.6327682137489319,
-0.25497886538505554,
0.9631680250167847,
-0.08764346688985825,
-0.6647197604179382,
-0.5525268912315369,
-0.15321531891822815,
-0.14100192487239838,
-0.22150976955890656,
0.22107528150081635,
-0.26518335938453674,
0.33194461464881897,
-0.26247718930244446,
-0.6653627753257751,
-0.09487618505954742,
-0.1211227998137474,
-0.4832710027694702,
0.5887012481689453,
-0.16629059612751007,
-0.8321857452392578,
0.22203826904296875,
-0.7508266568183899,
-0.6014362573623657,
0.12033829838037491,
0.1092139258980751,
-0.14991679787635803,
0.3882690370082855,
0.05520259588956833,
0.6441679000854492,
-0.0008314813603647053,
0.2388448268175125,
-0.2092415988445282,
-0.33037039637565613,
0.21595869958400726,
-0.19614990055561066,
0.6802347302436829,
0.18536710739135742,
-0.3844258487224579,
0.05748385190963745,
-0.7495205402374268,
-0.12079400569200516,
-0.10783383995294571,
-0.2739535868167877,
-0.4717762768268585,
0.22850088775157928,
-0.2011440247297287,
0.10934890061616898,
0.2280348688364029,
-0.42451614141464233,
0.17760448157787323,
-0.503387451171875,
0.3203897476196289,
0.4437408149242401,
0.12747012078762054,
0.2843385636806488,
-0.1759168654680252,
0.18942464888095856,
-0.2450190782546997,
0.008744523860514164,
-0.15235762298107147,
-0.4239015579223633,
-0.3918858766555786,
-0.6695569753646851,
0.37725141644477844,
0.5770550966262817,
-0.3695511221885681,
0.3043467700481415,
-0.17664708197116852,
-0.6129580736160278,
-0.24129897356033325,
0.047390665858983994,
0.20034754276275635,
0.7206557989120483,
0.4939044415950775,
-0.3064839839935303,
-0.3633917570114136,
-0.847450852394104,
-0.30633434653282166,
-0.15400812029838562,
0.026077240705490112,
0.06493361294269562,
0.7200424075126648,
-0.36360645294189453,
0.8809548020362854,
-0.7635490894317627,
-0.15705910325050354,
-0.1159951314330101,
0.4570786654949188,
0.3963516652584076,
0.27112001180648804,
0.5120427012443542,
-0.6359226703643799,
-0.6487829685211182,
0.058910299092531204,
-0.8894737958908081,
-0.5887203216552734,
0.30967089533805847,
0.038530752062797546,
0.14674074947834015,
0.5970655083656311,
-0.6650193333625793,
0.418937087059021,
0.4230392277240753,
-0.4464925527572632,
0.7751638293266296,
-0.48949024081230164,
0.29682397842407227,
-1.1071066856384277,
0.37173283100128174,
-0.0944458618760109,
-0.5082066655158997,
-0.38981831073760986,
-0.21572890877723694,
-0.04732871428132057,
0.06398003548383713,
-0.19316069781780243,
0.6021991968154907,
-0.5031082630157471,
-0.11166898906230927,
-0.5911138653755188,
0.0008956090314313769,
0.16297264397144318,
0.047811154276132584,
0.30261966586112976,
0.775874674320221,
-0.009817366488277912,
-0.7149799466133118,
0.12127795815467834,
0.529537558555603,
0.025630876421928406,
0.336855947971344,
-1.005515456199646,
-0.48856282234191895,
-0.28262266516685486,
0.6097744703292847,
-0.792087197303772,
-0.6341813206672668,
-0.13623666763305664,
-0.36556005477905273,
0.13448384404182434,
0.3296158015727997,
-0.1663266122341156,
-0.19263993203639984,
-0.43213868141174316,
0.187637597322464,
0.3994753062725067,
-0.05539089813828468,
0.5206475853919983,
0.43600520491600037,
-0.6937677264213562,
-0.3967820405960083,
-0.5629967451095581,
0.3190518319606781,
0.05779051408171654,
-0.4592781066894531,
0.6031848788261414,
-0.17895255982875824,
-0.37799549102783203,
0.06112987548112869,
0.021445246413350105,
0.009564036503434181,
0.09108614921569824,
-0.0034267206210643053,
0.17667163908481598,
-0.033697135746479034,
0.10564317554235458,
0.21049535274505615,
-0.09408025443553925,
0.14674873650074005,
-0.13822102546691895,
0.10364595055580139,
0.3134745657444,
-0.17680494487285614,
-0.26965266466140747,
0.4988135099411011,
0.5307368040084839,
-0.1337306946516037,
0.8198215961456299,
0.5378313064575195,
-0.24449953436851501,
-0.08654779940843582,
-0.44081953167915344,
-0.1723545789718628,
-0.3571069538593292,
0.6293911337852478,
0.1338430792093277,
-0.7811543941497803,
0.43417099118232727,
-0.1560003161430359,
0.36290299892425537,
0.8510791063308716,
0.7377866506576538,
-0.5783241391181946,
1.0548237562179565,
0.9832596778869629,
0.2636926770210266,
0.13340742886066437,
-0.005726746749132872,
0.017419181764125824,
-0.4953232407569885,
-0.4279767572879791,
-0.5888612270355225,
-0.1484583169221878,
-0.43909162282943726,
-0.33127447962760925,
0.779813826084137,
-0.06795373558998108,
0.2712680697441101,
0.1704249531030655,
-0.41364702582359314,
0.350329726934433,
0.27484551072120667,
0.13353243470191956,
0.4886763095855713,
0.06091148778796196,
-0.10489533096551895,
-0.07270535081624985,
-0.8062316179275513,
-0.43353912234306335,
0.9565269351005554,
0.3892422318458557,
0.6955148577690125,
0.10467639565467834,
0.7228055596351624,
0.6286288499832153,
0.3184812366962433,
-0.6760632991790771,
0.393970787525177,
-0.40042564272880554,
-0.2249554693698883,
-0.22338443994522095,
-0.5780617594718933,
-0.7575019001960754,
0.2312939316034317,
-0.287575900554657,
-0.5020524859428406,
0.3617514967918396,
0.294949471950531,
-0.452108234167099,
-0.06398596614599228,
-0.4319646656513214,
0.42880597710609436,
-0.24093550443649292,
-0.2775026261806488,
-0.38295692205429077,
-0.8117678761482239,
0.5088183283805847,
-0.4055193066596985,
0.5084740519523621,
-0.13685661554336548,
-0.32192113995552063,
0.8961800932884216,
-0.4512336254119873,
0.9605894088745117,
0.04514138773083687,
-0.17960552871227264,
-0.16030584275722504,
0.04910605400800705,
0.40116244554519653,
0.031135663390159607,
-0.13726745545864105,
0.11370128393173218,
0.24138613045215607,
-0.5889827609062195,
-0.16110411286354065,
0.5482492446899414,
-0.8074086904525757,
-0.37244492769241333,
-0.5348020792007446,
-0.7403085827827454,
-0.3677673041820526,
0.36560508608818054,
0.594545841217041,
0.4708266258239746,
-0.48280656337738037,
0.1479663997888565,
1.1334309577941895,
-0.316105455160141,
0.34811341762542725,
0.7614143490791321,
-0.012323164381086826,
-0.6087238788604736,
0.6792286038398743,
0.11138150095939636,
0.18054212629795074,
0.5412715673446655,
0.2496514469385147,
-0.12111630290746689,
-0.7290924787521362,
-0.14815065264701843,
0.39356517791748047,
-0.613917350769043,
-0.3310258686542511,
-1.2171648740768433,
-0.15712708234786987,
-0.5814372897148132,
-0.3182576596736908,
-0.1480967253446579,
-0.8820080757141113,
-0.46411022543907166,
-0.077755406498909,
0.37428659200668335,
0.9032609462738037,
-0.33209094405174255,
0.18982267379760742,
-0.8266118764877319,
0.3000616431236267,
-0.01934163272380829,
0.014656915329396725,
-0.27058422565460205,
-0.7581368684768677,
-0.49549826979637146,
-0.04651482030749321,
-0.02671072818338871,
-0.8638620376586914,
0.5324601531028748,
0.4784334599971771,
0.5655845999717712,
0.07567008584737778,
-0.0851980671286583,
0.35916420817375183,
-0.5427137017250061,
0.5977650880813599,
0.2746693193912506,
-0.6433275938034058,
0.4936467111110687,
-0.5344993472099304,
0.6120177507400513,
0.7865284085273743,
0.4671792984008789,
-0.333204060792923,
-0.45950084924697876,
-0.2683238685131073,
-1.0552597045898438,
0.32339975237846375,
0.10589190572500229,
-0.06299147754907608,
0.12386231869459152,
0.3699573874473572,
0.47064292430877686,
0.2795995771884918,
-0.42443323135375977,
-0.052467476576566696,
-0.1706964075565338,
-0.6939281225204468,
-0.30641937255859375,
-0.5071689486503601,
-0.35021665692329407,
-0.24071615934371948,
0.8820012807846069,
-0.2896275818347931,
0.25123003125190735,
0.4866277575492859,
-0.5632568597793579,
-0.13726988434791565,
0.08375333249568939,
1.0820175409317017,
1.156761646270752,
-0.23965385556221008,
0.08960159122943878,
0.26520806550979614,
-0.8687052726745605,
0.056909311562776566,
0.27582159638404846,
-0.29627206921577454,
0.18344315886497498,
0.9879829287528992,
0.5832091569900513,
0.3854142427444458,
-0.607657253742218,
0.4245836138725281,
0.014321672730147839,
-0.4245178699493408,
-0.08622094243764877,
0.09882085025310516,
-0.06266555935144424,
0.08967042714357376,
0.7613247036933899,
0.1686810553073883,
0.4571725130081177,
-0.11862538009881973,
0.21059440076351166,
0.34741365909576416,
-0.24454481899738312,
-0.4818956255912781,
0.7889671921730042,
0.3669094145298004,
0.09083697199821472,
-0.030389156192541122,
0.20812061429023743,
-0.3005565404891968,
0.6168584227561951,
0.7104506492614746,
0.6871144771575928,
-0.30271556973457336,
0.482980877161026,
0.38108453154563904,
0.24893276393413544,
-0.23508404195308685,
0.06286751478910446,
0.20191927254199982,
-0.2790673077106476,
-0.8614398837089539,
-0.5975558161735535,
-0.45789337158203125,
-0.28224238753318787,
-0.43890631198883057,
0.22051413357257843,
-0.23815397918224335,
-0.17210277915000916,
0.18233805894851685,
0.11480741947889328,
-0.2327466756105423,
0.22876326739788055,
-0.18911154568195343,
1.2842681407928467,
-0.9555734992027283,
0.2547531723976135,
0.7221709489822388,
-0.1309279352426529,
-0.45264357328414917,
-0.24855439364910126,
-0.023624083027243614,
-0.42771655321121216,
0.4923599362373352,
-0.21800824999809265,
-0.019361089915037155,
0.2005860060453415,
-0.6800447106361389,
-1.058929681777954,
1.2350945472717285,
0.21824613213539124,
-0.4869898855686188,
-0.056987885385751724,
-0.11930795758962631,
0.7571877241134644,
-0.30012598633766174,
0.40394362807273865,
0.16894486546516418,
0.4788511097431183,
0.10759363323450089,
-0.9933739304542542,
-0.14681582152843475,
-0.29925063252449036,
-0.39549732208251953,
0.06846922636032104,
-0.8243350386619568,
0.5466652512550354,
-0.21735796332359314,
0.3907995820045471,
-0.0027724788524210453,
0.8302860260009766,
0.351904034614563,
0.41543933749198914,
0.0793490931391716,
0.25132817029953003,
0.7536223530769348,
0.24868273735046387,
0.9233814477920532,
-0.12685374915599823,
0.011496094986796379,
0.8831886649131775,
-0.284604012966156,
0.5993807315826416,
0.5011543035507202,
-0.1866910755634308,
0.43865472078323364,
0.5002618432044983,
0.06925328820943832,
0.6297491192817688,
-0.22712959349155426,
-0.20156912505626678,
-0.0972270742058754,
-0.2584546208381653,
-0.39459896087646484,
0.46078622341156006,
0.3562295734882355,
-0.39443275332450867,
-0.06677118688821793,
0.15405717492103577,
0.21304702758789062,
0.028104456141591072,
-0.48568499088287354,
0.9042453765869141,
0.35859760642051697,
-0.5329486727714539,
0.1965487152338028,
0.32247641682624817,
0.5810903310775757,
-0.8141506314277649,
-0.03342211991548538,
-0.2621505856513977,
-0.10499032586812973,
-0.5237882137298584,
-0.4174652695655823,
0.35223931074142456,
0.16706903278827667,
-0.5508469939231873,
-0.0018817756790667772,
0.9205402731895447,
-0.4802373945713043,
-0.72758948802948,
-0.06490559130907059,
0.386422336101532,
0.1362207680940628,
0.43248283863067627,
-0.4206587076187134,
0.03407284989953041,
-0.02707544155418873,
-0.3358784019947052,
0.22659288346767426,
0.26933372020721436,
-0.33049026131629944,
0.5623385310173035,
0.6182557344436646,
0.3913162350654602,
-0.22784818708896637,
-0.2399914562702179,
0.5696249008178711,
-0.5802834033966064,
-0.4336703419685364,
-0.791117250919342,
0.4985063672065735,
-0.26959317922592163,
-0.07782254368066788,
0.8648321032524109,
0.5340682864189148,
0.06638292223215103,
-0.14647699892520905,
0.7766270041465759,
-0.02499152533710003,
0.6670768857002258,
-0.3801266551017761,
0.9468938708305359,
-0.4382745623588562,
0.042425088584423065,
-0.32803380489349365,
-0.8344188332557678,
-0.3961659371852875,
0.4572333097457886,
-0.14516690373420715,
-0.047902289777994156,
0.7168023586273193,
0.1693938970565796,
-0.15034785866737366,
-0.2269868403673172,
0.13787941634655,
0.6377747654914856,
0.19260574877262115,
0.07724753022193909,
0.3566751480102539,
-0.16045886278152466,
0.07879326492547989,
-0.10338474810123444,
-0.6185868382453918,
-0.5326541066169739,
-1.2816556692123413,
-0.7740004062652588,
-0.26069724559783936,
-0.46978268027305603,
-0.1821936070919037,
0.24681653082370758,
1.0197221040725708,
0.48718416690826416,
-0.9473512172698975,
-0.1606813371181488,
0.21329686045646667,
-0.12576301395893097,
-0.10084309428930283,
-0.16809551417827606,
0.5741100311279297,
-0.11763406544923782,
-0.33115559816360474,
0.5592520833015442,
0.6250884532928467,
-0.005887269973754883,
-0.1633080542087555,
0.027746403589844704,
-0.13183733820915222,
0.3380312919616699,
0.8099220395088196,
0.3449610471725464,
-0.24175715446472168,
0.15588662028312683,
0.1641826033592224,
-0.3348267674446106,
-0.3952336609363556,
0.5717976093292236,
-0.6834735870361328,
0.22266533970832825,
0.6121187210083008,
0.4551771283149719,
0.4354642331600189,
0.06310167163610458,
0.9622840285301208,
-0.5351331233978271,
0.21879367530345917,
0.37372905015945435,
0.21766504645347595,
0.30477088689804077,
-0.6042365431785583,
0.5394099950790405,
0.23622629046440125,
-0.6343490481376648,
-0.8742979764938354,
-0.1633823961019516,
-0.7941718101501465,
-0.38987603783607483,
1.021687388420105,
0.02630993165075779,
-0.3965671956539154,
-0.13310275971889496,
-0.14186538755893707,
0.19147911667823792,
-0.03557756543159485,
0.9783356189727783,
0.508175253868103,
-0.23877497017383575,
0.02565915510058403,
-0.5352280139923096,
0.5422611832618713,
0.43586814403533936,
-1.1084322929382324,
-0.27776584029197693,
0.6350097060203552,
0.522848904132843,
-0.038288358598947525,
0.8723880052566528,
-0.20079343020915985,
0.5220409631729126,
-0.5213095545768738,
0.03865063190460205,
-0.254900723695755,
-0.13474245369434357,
-0.2525697350502014,
-0.03539278358221054,
0.04167872294783592,
0.6008825302124023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11942v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11942v1
|
FAME-MT Dataset: Formality Awareness Made Easy for Machine Translation Purposes
| 2024-05-20T10:35:30 | 2024-05-20T10:35:30 |
Dawid Wiśniewski, Zofia Rostek, Artur Nowakowski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
People use language for various purposes. Apart from sharing information,
individuals may use it to express emotions or to show respect for another
person. In this paper, we focus on the formality level of machine-generated
translations and present FAME-MT -- a dataset consisting of 11.2 million
translations between 15 European source languages and 8 European target
languages classified to formal and informal classes according to target
sentence formality. This dataset can be used to fine-tune machine translation
models to ensure a given formality level for each European target language
considered. We describe the dataset creation procedure, the analysis of the
dataset's quality showing that FAME-MT is a reliable source of language
register information, and we present a publicly available proof-of-concept
machine translation model that uses the dataset to steer the formality level of
the translation. Currently, it is the largest dataset of formality annotations,
with examples expressed in 112 European language pairs. The dataset is
published online: https://github.com/laniqo-public/fame-mt/ .
|
[
-0.027206270024180412,
-0.43881890177726746,
0.2238072007894516,
0.27845966815948486,
-0.22233621776103973,
-0.21634818613529205,
-0.2122655212879181,
-0.47650080919265747,
0.10516151040792465,
0.5568665862083435,
-0.058381881564855576,
-0.7634815573692322,
-0.6674679517745972,
0.36171475052833557,
-0.6444424390792847,
0.9085689187049866,
-0.3687640428543091,
0.006034213118255138,
0.08726821839809418,
-0.18070246279239655,
-0.058380864560604095,
-0.6636376976966858,
-0.24959729611873627,
0.15372712910175323,
0.5105809569358826,
0.41806259751319885,
0.7174464464187622,
1.0200234651565552,
0.9625406265258789,
0.30822139978408813,
0.32661640644073486,
0.5286996364593506,
-0.7143167853355408,
0.09994316846132278,
0.013087316416203976,
-0.41136062145233154,
-0.7165651321411133,
0.10690542310476303,
0.9776893854141235,
0.6189755797386169,
0.2205335646867752,
0.5300196409225464,
-0.1462780088186264,
0.8609817028045654,
-0.32694104313850403,
0.35164937376976013,
-0.5573908090591431,
0.047807298600673676,
-0.5479220747947693,
-0.31720027327537537,
-0.33463335037231445,
-0.3706967234611511,
-0.19003614783287048,
-0.5551936030387878,
0.0112163620069623,
0.35705187916755676,
1.0381970405578613,
0.31026265025138855,
-0.357835590839386,
-0.14125792682170868,
-0.8800687193870544,
0.4943150281906128,
-0.3616887927055359,
0.5596500635147095,
0.5909287333488464,
0.497250497341156,
-0.026627836748957634,
-0.5246871113777161,
-0.5252802968025208,
-0.15681201219558716,
-0.20374499261379242,
-0.07457288354635239,
0.027662156149744987,
-0.2655912935733795,
0.307365357875824,
0.8228452801704407,
-0.5648220181465149,
-0.16653037071228027,
-0.3892068862915039,
-0.16107489168643951,
0.6542596220970154,
0.010145950131118298,
0.2538352608680725,
-0.11148384213447571,
-0.21639852225780487,
0.08423174172639847,
-0.7293103933334351,
-0.12989915907382965,
0.578156590461731,
0.23751889169216156,
-0.17174142599105835,
0.758495032787323,
-0.48780015110969543,
0.7296441793441772,
-0.481039434671402,
-0.09034007042646408,
0.4092773199081421,
-0.36815252900123596,
-0.19246679544448853,
-0.1415729969739914,
0.8315814733505249,
0.2510306239128113,
0.36580803990364075,
-0.27331167459487915,
-0.448005348443985,
0.07140912860631943,
-0.0946185365319252,
-0.5915275812149048,
-0.16849111020565033,
0.31582313776016235,
-0.23070763051509857,
-0.5135497450828552,
0.32764139771461487,
-0.30121275782585144,
-0.11075486242771149,
-0.4925990700721741,
0.5070100426673889,
-0.39072731137275696,
0.09112871438264847,
0.43727633357048035,
0.1924605667591095,
0.02526485174894333,
0.30957546830177307,
-0.431839257478714,
0.30173587799072266,
0.5552775263786316,
0.6258891224861145,
0.06167667731642723,
-0.09548778831958771,
-0.5881292819976807,
0.338623583316803,
-0.49625489115715027,
0.43789708614349365,
-0.3097170293331146,
0.09391561895608902,
-0.14179345965385437,
0.1297329217195511,
0.0034465768840163946,
-0.23116828501224518,
0.8247094750404358,
-0.6376734972000122,
0.40064316987991333,
-0.1639557182788849,
-0.629838764667511,
-0.26772889494895935,
0.42486461997032166,
-0.6727807521820068,
1.1719876527786255,
0.16116023063659668,
-0.6362628936767578,
0.47219136357307434,
-0.7645216584205627,
-0.5937864184379578,
0.28820690512657166,
0.09761390089988708,
-0.3027954399585724,
0.01801440119743347,
0.1229785606265068,
0.7636824250221252,
0.027992932125926018,
0.26876336336135864,
0.03484167903661728,
-0.20485298335552216,
0.4371107518672943,
-0.12607699632644653,
0.4218701422214508,
0.6333950161933899,
-0.2792317271232605,
0.02321031503379345,
-0.8426934480667114,
-0.4116857945919037,
0.09153548628091812,
-0.2999812960624695,
-0.44900456070899963,
-0.2021917998790741,
0.02956486865878105,
0.5644580721855164,
0.4965159296989441,
-0.4032873511314392,
0.025658901780843735,
-0.3966473340988159,
0.3587571084499359,
0.48767292499542236,
0.21386048197746277,
-0.02767835184931755,
-0.2876756489276886,
0.18410392105579376,
0.05443042516708374,
0.25519269704818726,
-0.1742798537015915,
-0.5869239568710327,
-0.6156354546546936,
-0.25877705216407776,
0.670518159866333,
0.6805953979492188,
-0.2875082194805145,
0.699693500995636,
-0.7241054773330688,
-0.27403417229652405,
-0.8251772522926331,
0.25301632285118103,
0.504967987537384,
0.4124874174594879,
0.11309771984815598,
-0.2824999988079071,
-0.6162478923797607,
-0.960344672203064,
-0.21347576379776,
-0.09690270572900772,
-0.10144589096307755,
0.39713117480278015,
0.48608922958374023,
-0.23883435130119324,
0.44090014696121216,
-0.13817158341407776,
-0.40503230690956116,
0.11407527327537537,
-0.05603789538145065,
-0.08085383474826813,
0.5925885438919067,
0.2980765402317047,
-0.7958953976631165,
-0.3286933898925781,
0.42056289315223694,
-0.9280840754508972,
0.132549449801445,
-0.049244727939367294,
-0.5080249905586243,
0.23619617521762848,
0.22128926217556,
0.0658716931939125,
0.07225970178842545,
0.775315523147583,
-0.18421821296215057,
0.0732400119304657,
-0.2386600375175476,
0.8071754574775696,
-1.5122637748718262,
0.6092632412910461,
-0.07641623914241791,
-0.6061760187149048,
-0.45916223526000977,
0.09831275790929794,
-0.03523160144686699,
-0.14494116604328156,
-0.3983059823513031,
0.5230923295021057,
-0.2304895520210266,
-0.18249481916427612,
0.44567638635635376,
0.4142611622810364,
-0.04723372682929039,
0.2760009467601776,
-0.12031733244657516,
0.5856366753578186,
0.55772864818573,
-0.613348126411438,
0.3045301139354706,
0.4089982211589813,
-0.4586566984653473,
0.4704740345478058,
-0.5297781825065613,
0.16872191429138184,
0.10536612570285797,
-0.2228124886751175,
-0.9871519804000854,
-0.7451324462890625,
0.42243605852127075,
-0.6469608545303345,
0.21506367623806,
-0.22074201703071594,
-1.0892397165298462,
-0.06114594265818596,
0.13316890597343445,
0.1768096536397934,
0.5550616383552551,
-0.15902641415596008,
0.08152608573436737,
0.7143825888633728,
-0.0410606823861599,
-0.28315970301628113,
-0.5517827272415161,
0.5342835187911987,
-0.1645408421754837,
-0.8598130941390991,
-0.1417977511882782,
0.037463899701833725,
-0.38530656695365906,
-0.26259204745292664,
0.22953763604164124,
0.0028133441228419542,
0.15113022923469543,
0.21654216945171356,
0.22552837431430817,
-0.009390609338879585,
0.025138182565569878,
-0.027648182585835457,
-0.09201280772686005,
0.015375812537968159,
-0.34678417444229126,
0.2908995747566223,
-0.17825089395046234,
-0.1244756355881691,
-0.737646222114563,
0.02160136215388775,
0.6335247159004211,
-0.30600669980049133,
0.8468310236930847,
0.40462324023246765,
-0.5479934811592102,
0.011687171645462513,
-0.5850563049316406,
-0.08786852657794952,
-0.36634936928749084,
-0.008862104266881943,
-0.6190243363380432,
-0.7798723578453064,
0.5761545896530151,
-0.07414743304252625,
0.3416689932346344,
0.6531835794448853,
0.5158815979957581,
-0.08626868575811386,
0.981736958026886,
0.3897753059864044,
-0.23710593581199646,
0.35809436440467834,
-0.27420300245285034,
-0.2112291008234024,
-0.44523605704307556,
-0.2270531952381134,
-0.5893048644065857,
-0.5072655081748962,
-0.43161430954933167,
-0.5130317211151123,
0.23344378173351288,
-0.09748227894306183,
0.20519475638866425,
0.6257807612419128,
-0.2856380343437195,
0.23743347823619843,
0.2771904766559601,
0.11955931037664413,
0.7420974969863892,
0.3263379633426666,
-0.046588946133852005,
-0.09449608623981476,
-0.43604952096939087,
-1.0092509984970093,
1.0442591905593872,
0.47802338004112244,
0.29475322365760803,
0.04867679253220558,
0.6276837587356567,
0.39213618636131287,
0.3266807496547699,
-0.6023991107940674,
0.49884161353111267,
-0.3193272352218628,
-0.7759673595428467,
-0.3986789882183075,
-0.877483069896698,
-0.7846145629882812,
-0.43564239144325256,
-0.16433240473270416,
-0.118773452937603,
0.05648510530591011,
0.3376408815383911,
0.07166769355535507,
0.19767525792121887,
-0.4392659366130829,
1.043707013130188,
-0.061734993010759354,
-0.16696575284004211,
-0.09880395233631134,
-1.0416103601455688,
0.59653639793396,
-0.32477185130119324,
0.5331452488899231,
-0.15532498061656952,
-0.048752639442682266,
0.7286889553070068,
-0.2031119018793106,
0.7086818218231201,
0.1399027556180954,
-0.46034562587738037,
0.2116284817457199,
0.42547473311424255,
0.736280083656311,
-0.07649919390678406,
-0.20102770626544952,
0.41021406650543213,
-0.21563832461833954,
-0.2788306772708893,
-0.25412458181381226,
0.4454325735569,
-0.6190091371536255,
0.11117663234472275,
0.010342960245907307,
-0.6570426821708679,
0.008634787984192371,
0.31556960940361023,
0.327390193939209,
0.48174622654914856,
-0.4053835868835449,
0.13971416652202606,
0.9015242457389832,
0.24343861639499664,
-0.25995156168937683,
0.6755157709121704,
-0.1360372006893158,
-0.4327830970287323,
1.2295374870300293,
0.19568857550621033,
0.3053356111049652,
0.7604602575302124,
0.003612730884924531,
-0.17265364527702332,
-0.39934518933296204,
-0.5309287309646606,
0.2537655830383301,
-0.5119239687919617,
0.08157365024089813,
-0.7156392335891724,
-0.01244898047298193,
-0.5168785452842712,
-0.06948796659708023,
-0.4252327084541321,
-0.9275301694869995,
0.1482219398021698,
0.020493222400546074,
0.42544302344322205,
0.6371216177940369,
-0.029438626021146774,
0.026013432070612907,
-0.829765260219574,
0.5272113680839539,
0.1256924867630005,
0.5362889170646667,
-0.8838071227073669,
-0.8622841238975525,
-0.3812694549560547,
-0.013722063973546028,
0.1399255245923996,
-0.4721890985965729,
0.24451099336147308,
0.28894054889678955,
0.28393375873565674,
0.6126447319984436,
-0.006633543875068426,
0.44390231370925903,
-0.5140795707702637,
0.5404161810874939,
-0.3657025098800659,
-0.8664373755455017,
0.7618958950042725,
-0.5736786127090454,
-0.2348945438861847,
0.4950995445251465,
0.4098255932331085,
-0.8584563136100769,
-0.7782875895500183,
-0.8336148858070374,
-0.43395838141441345,
0.3756919503211975,
0.6435441374778748,
-0.05535734444856644,
0.03446929529309273,
0.5229223370552063,
0.20731019973754883,
0.3004171550273895,
-0.3195784389972687,
-0.3855758309364319,
0.11694899201393127,
-0.28157851099967957,
-0.21796365082263947,
-0.06431226432323456,
-0.4843393862247467,
0.017712147906422615,
0.8915965557098389,
0.16697265207767487,
-0.03807337209582329,
0.07140698283910751,
-0.19891469180583954,
-0.3746606111526489,
0.2855672836303711,
0.6825243234634399,
0.41379842162132263,
-0.31242915987968445,
0.23034612834453583,
-0.10862286388874054,
-0.47959479689598083,
-0.10797669738531113,
0.08099336922168732,
-0.2778424620628357,
0.20221886038780212,
0.09655315428972244,
0.5384278893470764,
0.2914668023586273,
-0.45352765917778015,
0.3248153328895569,
0.07509378343820572,
-0.25269365310668945,
0.005537237506359816,
-0.013999855145812035,
-0.23409710824489594,
-0.2925211191177368,
-0.163657084107399,
0.31032660603523254,
0.25411155819892883,
-0.3407168686389923,
0.4409577250480652,
0.12639828026294708,
-0.4407559633255005,
-0.5147078037261963,
0.8761246800422668,
0.29983699321746826,
-0.08644571155309677,
0.3467288017272949,
-0.30032190680503845,
-0.1966836303472519,
0.13581381738185883,
0.07347702980041504,
0.8113105297088623,
-0.28519120812416077,
0.13890333473682404,
0.5486091375350952,
0.5695216655731201,
-0.4232436418533325,
0.546073853969574,
0.04208103194832802,
-0.5998009443283081,
-0.3252892792224884,
-0.7344716787338257,
-0.4561937749385834,
-0.033218901604413986,
-0.5181564688682556,
0.36252862215042114,
-0.1312849372625351,
-0.03700380399823189,
-0.23093682527542114,
-0.024366458877921104,
-0.5734490156173706,
0.21608372032642365,
-0.08182177692651749,
0.7530720829963684,
-1.0285981893539429,
0.7136939167976379,
0.6808531880378723,
-0.41352444887161255,
-0.7089241743087769,
-0.4316297471523285,
-0.19874243438243866,
-0.9490773677825928,
0.6053019165992737,
-0.11429324001073837,
-0.026410149410367012,
0.4187973737716675,
-0.7034551501274109,
-0.5957333445549011,
0.7415929436683655,
0.442301869392395,
-0.4887826144695282,
0.3998629152774811,
0.38076215982437134,
0.5178751349449158,
-0.47906237840652466,
-0.7494213581085205,
0.39589324593544006,
0.6346026062965393,
0.17974425852298737,
-0.7715601325035095,
0.09067703783512115,
-0.2590651214122772,
-0.04519771412014961,
0.25654926896095276,
-0.3391733467578888,
0.3668520748615265,
-0.10735758394002914,
-0.38128072023391724,
-0.03146303445100784,
0.48647239804267883,
0.14260165393352509,
0.05098927766084671,
0.2100737988948822,
0.566880464553833,
0.7182131409645081,
-0.2635516822338104,
0.9012593626976013,
-0.8045793771743774,
0.20895442366600037,
0.836085319519043,
0.034952398389577866,
0.8458912968635559,
0.1700676828622818,
-0.1010069027543068,
0.3188391625881195,
0.5436243414878845,
-0.10365856438875198,
-0.12010721862316132,
0.14477361738681793,
-0.15065275132656097,
-0.29613181948661804,
-0.1349002569913864,
-0.43501847982406616,
0.20395368337631226,
0.41305944323539734,
-0.7670626044273376,
0.05807983875274658,
-0.2558937072753906,
0.1772007793188095,
0.03232823684811592,
-0.21781259775161743,
0.8452850580215454,
-0.09052928537130356,
-0.2546599209308624,
0.46331506967544556,
0.049195367842912674,
0.025797780603170395,
-0.4690018892288208,
-0.06248358264565468,
-0.23333029448986053,
0.05214838311076164,
-0.32248032093048096,
-0.7360755801200867,
0.08840969204902649,
0.07601859420537949,
-0.1340721696615219,
-0.3042631149291992,
0.4132280945777893,
-0.6932327747344971,
-0.8003849387168884,
-0.5253824591636658,
0.5085147023200989,
1.027465581893921,
-0.09860649704933167,
-0.5211704969406128,
-0.06261956691741943,
-0.35332128405570984,
-0.08288649469614029,
0.049903448671102524,
1.1251847743988037,
-0.11979551613330841,
0.47172918915748596,
0.6506605744361877,
0.31399357318878174,
0.10612306743860245,
0.17720557749271393,
0.5582506060600281,
-0.3486543893814087,
-0.419087678194046,
-0.5536406636238098,
0.6909803152084351,
-0.03808591142296791,
-0.36307162046432495,
1.118445634841919,
0.9738320708274841,
0.7493431568145752,
-0.162624791264534,
0.6275621652603149,
0.02590198442339897,
0.39092788100242615,
-0.37287694215774536,
0.8250986933708191,
-0.3747766315937042,
0.21490487456321716,
-0.5302121043205261,
-0.7744693756103516,
-0.720044732093811,
0.5347012877464294,
-0.24758777022361755,
-0.1036449521780014,
0.4015948176383972,
0.7425687909126282,
0.009175637736916542,
-0.19830843806266785,
0.5895899534225464,
0.15372058749198914,
0.07725519686937332,
0.2201722115278244,
0.45306098461151123,
-0.8638268709182739,
0.5503620505332947,
-0.2204332798719406,
-0.38552334904670715,
-0.2924204468727112,
-0.8407488465309143,
-0.8278700709342957,
-0.6812752485275269,
-0.47367969155311584,
-0.3966619074344635,
-0.02516856975853443,
0.7048619389533997,
0.634661853313446,
-0.9917860627174377,
-0.21807807683944702,
0.00546659342944622,
-0.02889390103518963,
-0.3854629695415497,
-0.1979915201663971,
0.3864803910255432,
-0.6424424648284912,
-0.6987146139144897,
0.27895328402519226,
0.3922501504421234,
0.2538679242134094,
-0.375847190618515,
-0.17733195424079895,
0.04847719520330429,
0.01769142597913742,
0.6352608799934387,
0.2161705195903778,
-0.3927799463272095,
-0.19212566316127777,
0.10139778256416321,
-0.40533357858657837,
0.12093713879585266,
0.7309462428092957,
-0.37174123525619507,
0.580623984336853,
0.41746994853019714,
0.4389108419418335,
0.03230620548129082,
0.05305434763431549,
0.6075038313865662,
-1.0693119764328003,
-0.07132988423109055,
-0.07846345007419586,
0.32389000058174133,
0.4704352617263794,
-0.5835039019584656,
0.7503939270973206,
0.502421498298645,
-0.6677871942520142,
-0.8730994462966919,
0.13656863570213318,
-0.9410373568534851,
0.3046295940876007,
1.0149400234222412,
-0.10772068053483963,
-0.24684108793735504,
-0.2951919138431549,
-0.1745915561914444,
0.39026695489883423,
-0.4322926104068756,
1.0592255592346191,
0.7342500686645508,
0.23535697162151337,
0.10100606083869934,
-0.8070668578147888,
0.7537278532981873,
-0.07195737212896347,
-0.9113219976425171,
0.3853677213191986,
0.5749819874763489,
0.28449079394340515,
0.21782352030277252,
0.3226250410079956,
-0.6226033568382263,
0.0969107523560524,
-0.13923047482967377,
0.1841168999671936,
-0.2381289154291153,
-0.47907426953315735,
-0.11350970715284348,
0.10649074614048004,
-0.09761320054531097,
-0.12047591805458069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11941v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11941v1
|
Biomedical Entity Linking for Dutch: Fine-tuning a Self-alignment BERT Model on an Automatically Generated Wikipedia Corpus
| 2024-05-20T10:30:36 | 2024-05-20T10:30:36 |
Fons Hartendorp, Tom Seinen, Erik van Mulligen, Suzan Verberne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Biomedical entity linking, a main component in automatic information
extraction from health-related texts, plays a pivotal role in connecting
textual entities (such as diseases, drugs and body parts mentioned by patients)
to their corresponding concepts in a structured biomedical knowledge base. The
task remains challenging despite recent developments in natural language
processing. This paper presents the first evaluated biomedical entity linking
model for the Dutch language. We use MedRoBERTa.nl as base model and perform
second-phase pretraining through self-alignment on a Dutch biomedical ontology
extracted from the UMLS and Dutch SNOMED. We derive a corpus from Wikipedia of
ontology-linked Dutch biomedical entities in context and fine-tune our model on
this dataset. We evaluate our model on the Dutch portion of the Mantra
GSC-corpus and achieve 54.7% classification accuracy and 69.8% 1-distance
accuracy. We then perform a case study on a collection of unlabeled,
patient-support forum data and show that our model is hampered by the limited
quality of the preceding entity recognition step. Manual evaluation of small
sample indicates that of the correctly extracted entities, around 65% is linked
to the correct concept in the ontology. Our results indicate that biomedical
entity linking in a language other than English remains challenging, but our
Dutch model can be used to for high-level analysis of patient-generated text.
|
[
-0.27562215924263,
-0.6200546026229858,
0.5489757061004639,
-0.0632469654083252,
-0.38348808884620667,
-0.27662211656570435,
-0.17083211243152618,
-0.9668050408363342,
0.49349313974380493,
0.4999690353870392,
-0.4544079601764679,
-0.689667284488678,
-0.5161091685295105,
0.5237841606140137,
-0.2366165965795517,
1.2625000476837158,
0.019642530009150505,
0.2658790946006775,
-0.2591612637042999,
-0.2309337556362152,
-0.1064765453338623,
-0.21128082275390625,
-0.579909086227417,
-0.2700931429862976,
0.8175731301307678,
0.2156984508037567,
0.6126980185508728,
0.7476688623428345,
0.7328068614006042,
0.24403388798236847,
0.0247879009693861,
0.054381515830755234,
-0.3859451115131378,
0.24716730415821075,
-0.5491892695426941,
-0.09907398372888565,
-0.46141374111175537,
-0.3133684992790222,
0.4931912124156952,
0.9018692970275879,
0.05205303803086281,
0.305294394493103,
0.1008906289935112,
0.6648651361465454,
-0.2441670447587967,
0.21769391000270844,
-0.592218279838562,
-0.14767712354660034,
-0.413587361574173,
-0.041183505207300186,
-0.09305305033922195,
-0.23557443916797638,
0.44494688510894775,
-0.5635913014411926,
0.14395318925380707,
0.14810176193714142,
1.1761794090270996,
0.40798419713974,
-0.26091665029525757,
-0.5777639150619507,
-0.26108694076538086,
0.30681607127189636,
-0.4875015914440155,
0.4809396266937256,
0.2360723912715912,
0.09460952877998352,
-0.3254505395889282,
-0.6102784872055054,
-0.38425782322883606,
-0.3751647174358368,
-0.03621853515505791,
0.08510377258062363,
-0.26030513644218445,
0.14013099670410156,
0.0033387693110853434,
0.0055981287732720375,
-0.5755552053451538,
0.22544220089912415,
-0.7429201602935791,
-0.26088932156562805,
0.4078250229358673,
-0.04594170302152634,
0.32622450590133667,
-0.6641351580619812,
-0.4706544876098633,
0.2671010494232178,
-0.8996566534042358,
-0.3980814516544342,
0.21545547246932983,
0.30683618783950806,
0.24909624457359314,
0.82624751329422,
0.05855102464556694,
0.6304097175598145,
0.34254828095436096,
0.06566701829433441,
0.31590843200683594,
-0.25282031297683716,
-0.08744527399539948,
0.45765945315361023,
0.6951249837875366,
0.28462812304496765,
0.24086807668209076,
-0.31278789043426514,
0.029643669724464417,
-0.0637083351612091,
0.6020511984825134,
-0.6855655908584595,
-0.5844932198524475,
0.2170107513666153,
-0.6546650528907776,
-0.173121377825737,
-0.2968071699142456,
-0.3321267366409302,
-0.09378529340028763,
-0.3293333351612091,
0.47903355956077576,
-0.8444119691848755,
-0.024749746546149254,
0.08378425240516663,
0.3908299207687378,
-0.11211274564266205,
0.2812473773956299,
-0.7935425639152527,
0.04046943783760071,
0.4195554554462433,
0.5282166004180908,
-0.377120703458786,
-0.1245589479804039,
0.018185274675488472,
0.5185884237289429,
-0.06995978951454163,
0.9689379930496216,
-0.22686025500297546,
-0.28009507060050964,
-0.1346656084060669,
0.11118210852146149,
0.1526332050561905,
-0.4080390930175781,
0.42576777935028076,
-0.49916142225265503,
0.13169804215431213,
-0.2302592247724533,
-0.9992413520812988,
0.13280639052391052,
0.03182143718004227,
-0.6287463903427124,
0.886817216873169,
-0.01870199479162693,
-1.0138410329818726,
0.5072556734085083,
-0.6939750909805298,
-0.6195540428161621,
0.011322288773953915,
-0.23681259155273438,
-0.4246228039264679,
0.04946343973278999,
-0.022319048643112183,
0.41578030586242676,
-0.29570767283439636,
0.3022186756134033,
-0.5015763640403748,
0.08292633295059204,
-0.002331143943592906,
0.03269263729453087,
0.9683659076690674,
0.28196221590042114,
0.040692854672670364,
0.11963943392038345,
-0.9011594653129578,
-0.18586882948875427,
-0.01543748565018177,
-0.37950703501701355,
-0.8225776553153992,
-0.1487596333026886,
0.018717028200626373,
0.4069295823574066,
0.4393286108970642,
-0.6130465269088745,
0.38422009348869324,
-0.7027809023857117,
0.0997367575764656,
0.5088399648666382,
0.08273646980524063,
0.2104341685771942,
0.12264836579561234,
0.10581322014331818,
-0.01346021518111229,
0.2886291444301605,
0.17233796417713165,
-0.707504153251648,
-0.5705855488777161,
-0.32932671904563904,
0.9203634858131409,
0.3333876430988312,
-0.6850007176399231,
0.9096967577934265,
-0.2871607840061188,
-0.4337307810783386,
-0.9222610592842102,
0.10831748694181442,
0.36816084384918213,
1.0265164375305176,
0.7325056791305542,
-0.4472375512123108,
-0.4732457101345062,
-1.0393500328063965,
-0.07912936061620712,
-0.3200055956840515,
-0.2687581479549408,
0.31554073095321655,
0.5925253033638,
-0.5591776967048645,
0.8054155707359314,
-0.22442087531089783,
-0.4684647023677826,
0.17197339236736298,
0.3157738149166107,
-0.016272859647870064,
0.6060037016868591,
0.652260422706604,
-0.4014217257499695,
-0.4422597885131836,
-0.08299504965543747,
-0.8385140299797058,
-0.3740115463733673,
0.19579720497131348,
-0.31132248044013977,
0.11901889741420746,
0.3776676058769226,
-0.40679308772087097,
0.31829580664634705,
0.522706151008606,
-0.2667658030986786,
0.4638972878456116,
-0.6736888289451599,
-0.16776037216186523,
-1.1979241371154785,
0.3987687826156616,
0.09218855202198029,
-0.15684252977371216,
-0.3282613754272461,
-0.19811105728149414,
0.18725965917110443,
0.17199645936489105,
-0.18745426833629608,
0.4224282205104828,
-0.5382203459739685,
0.042496129870414734,
-0.4136500358581543,
0.041463907808065414,
-0.11482542753219604,
0.02443697862327099,
0.06121665984392166,
0.4707101583480835,
0.45749175548553467,
-0.5555603504180908,
0.2556345760822296,
0.5776510834693909,
-0.2965930700302124,
0.7048895359039307,
-0.6734265089035034,
0.03213328495621681,
-0.07190109044313431,
0.07175832986831665,
-0.7355131506919861,
-0.14618730545043945,
0.2963542640209198,
-0.3689727783203125,
0.5463675260543823,
-0.053271785378456116,
-0.5160587430000305,
-0.3315242826938629,
0.17357029020786285,
0.3168927729129791,
0.15905128419399261,
-0.37032920122146606,
0.42035558819770813,
0.7304889559745789,
-0.2822059690952301,
-0.5118138194084167,
-0.5182860493659973,
0.17565277218818665,
0.12597277760505676,
-0.6569626331329346,
0.6100912094116211,
0.10799366235733032,
0.23132741451263428,
0.29081594944000244,
-0.28947317600250244,
-0.20527450740337372,
-0.06732288002967834,
0.1976493000984192,
0.456111341714859,
-0.08221088349819183,
0.6015996336936951,
0.47995564341545105,
-0.2907796800136566,
0.20641648769378662,
-0.36463019251823425,
0.08407746255397797,
0.15093310177326202,
-0.3135417401790619,
-0.3402969241142273,
0.40709900856018066,
0.1800023466348648,
-0.06501007080078125,
0.776725172996521,
0.389286607503891,
-0.6266660690307617,
0.430019736289978,
-0.678374171257019,
-0.2680087983608246,
-0.36184924840927124,
0.3963034152984619,
-0.34244173765182495,
-0.6373863220214844,
0.4174421727657318,
-0.28046464920043945,
-0.20761242508888245,
0.9282946586608887,
0.6407788395881653,
-0.5187140703201294,
0.6939378380775452,
0.9211887717247009,
0.08651023358106613,
0.10770119726657867,
0.13637806475162506,
0.05050677806138992,
-0.6014110445976257,
-0.3175007700920105,
-0.6519825458526611,
-0.07466945797204971,
-0.740846574306488,
-0.18443356454372406,
0.5280017852783203,
0.07537128776311874,
-0.07733102142810822,
0.7328134775161743,
-0.3990224301815033,
0.08541957288980484,
0.4594801962375641,
0.46111685037612915,
0.3231871724128723,
-0.021054191514849663,
-0.5912196636199951,
-0.1800086498260498,
-0.7977055311203003,
-0.5557169914245605,
1.1253200769424438,
0.20020483434200287,
0.807750403881073,
-0.13638359308242798,
0.8916299343109131,
0.0994909331202507,
0.5911759734153748,
-0.41793644428253174,
0.17294202744960785,
-0.19480611383914948,
-0.8175870776176453,
-0.37588757276535034,
-0.286224365234375,
-1.2303338050842285,
-0.24658772349357605,
-0.6893489956855774,
-0.481187641620636,
0.25721508264541626,
0.30885452032089233,
-0.3772751986980438,
0.02478126809000969,
-0.436832994222641,
0.9352805614471436,
-0.343523770570755,
-0.240068718791008,
-0.31561097502708435,
-1.174282431602478,
0.026601260527968407,
-0.4575801491737366,
-0.11218051612377167,
-0.22824595868587494,
-0.007910292595624924,
0.70145583152771,
-0.40295568108558655,
0.6206093430519104,
0.0816766619682312,
-0.4238351583480835,
-0.04046148434281349,
-0.10709872096776962,
0.22411464154720306,
-0.029042517766356468,
-0.06550136208534241,
0.6120479702949524,
0.3108282685279846,
-0.43672505021095276,
-0.31819120049476624,
0.5984863638877869,
-0.588778018951416,
-0.2930225431919098,
-0.36059942841529846,
-0.21021686494350433,
-0.31878748536109924,
0.49438467621803284,
0.3724397122859955,
0.041433367878198624,
-0.3797209858894348,
0.05887720733880997,
0.7706040740013123,
-0.25809574127197266,
-0.25308674573898315,
0.8059801459312439,
-0.039110634475946426,
-0.18245474994182587,
0.5685262680053711,
0.16700774431228638,
-0.02099044807255268,
0.284805029630661,
-0.05956994369626045,
-0.5700428485870361,
-0.4523320496082306,
-0.45407429337501526,
0.41921356320381165,
-0.6234452128410339,
-0.4080982804298401,
-0.7742599248886108,
-0.1651288866996765,
-0.45138195157051086,
0.1468675285577774,
-0.4971708059310913,
-0.20824475586414337,
-0.37997499108314514,
0.09813409298658371,
0.20456118881702423,
0.5592460632324219,
-0.347542405128479,
-0.14863653481006622,
-0.8809188604354858,
0.48801666498184204,
0.02791510336101055,
0.45000365376472473,
-0.44277283549308777,
-0.24998469650745392,
-0.4168618619441986,
-0.21293488144874573,
0.12693554162979126,
-1.2504032850265503,
0.0946529358625412,
0.14347076416015625,
0.4976625442504883,
0.5281051397323608,
0.07373399287462234,
0.6386805176734924,
-1.020160436630249,
0.20993192493915558,
0.39515095949172974,
-0.5996027588844299,
0.780724048614502,
-0.07683879882097244,
-0.1005382090806961,
0.7172178030014038,
0.6953087449073792,
-0.27733689546585083,
-0.30321553349494934,
-0.6432725787162781,
-0.7634880542755127,
0.1319616585969925,
0.20664481818675995,
-0.15371406078338623,
-0.3657958507537842,
0.7288845777511597,
0.24575133621692657,
0.02868824638426304,
-0.42313504219055176,
-0.5024184584617615,
0.09480684995651245,
-0.46123310923576355,
0.26202940940856934,
-0.4358300268650055,
-0.21857818961143494,
-0.3731454610824585,
0.781582236289978,
-0.11494117975234985,
0.3146815896034241,
0.48557403683662415,
-0.4215325117111206,
-0.24690844118595123,
0.02376564033329487,
0.2196488380432129,
0.556382954120636,
-0.17554669082164764,
-0.15263766050338745,
0.21481424570083618,
-0.38475504517555237,
-0.05781836062669754,
0.433562308549881,
-0.15817123651504517,
0.2472860962152481,
0.11810214072465897,
0.3800613284111023,
0.5902510285377502,
-0.4596176743507385,
0.4313056468963623,
0.059547774493694305,
0.04563218355178833,
-0.08123326301574707,
-0.03571968525648117,
-0.003803777741268277,
0.26084449887275696,
0.06824259459972382,
-0.020522359758615494,
0.3276265561580658,
-0.1951703578233719,
0.44377005100250244,
0.4956083595752716,
-0.37355440855026245,
-0.2716066241264343,
0.9049293994903564,
0.4094933271408081,
0.12219379097223282,
0.4722524881362915,
0.015716899186372757,
-0.10921134799718857,
0.2157566100358963,
0.4787367880344391,
0.6706583499908447,
-0.2120329737663269,
-0.10431579500436783,
0.4101313352584839,
0.338611364364624,
0.11394481360912323,
0.24173106253147125,
0.11225662380456924,
-0.5969908237457275,
-0.7076414227485657,
-0.6327747702598572,
-0.38914093375205994,
-0.2903232276439667,
-0.804572343826294,
0.33712467551231384,
0.14065195620059967,
-0.369174599647522,
0.3496229946613312,
-0.014639991335570812,
-0.7542416453361511,
0.3495619595050812,
0.11981818825006485,
0.9170210957527161,
-0.7218548059463501,
1.3776432275772095,
0.7771762013435364,
-0.5927897095680237,
-0.4840046167373657,
-0.15270563960075378,
-0.2842816114425659,
-0.8087695240974426,
0.7972639203071594,
-0.18412116169929504,
-0.019294559955596924,
0.040030818432569504,
-0.5235240459442139,
-0.9429514408111572,
0.7837757468223572,
0.5380847454071045,
-0.6733336448669434,
-0.4188881814479828,
-0.050295792520046234,
0.8328539133071899,
-0.2386796623468399,
-0.014579122886061668,
0.34250208735466003,
0.4165545701980591,
-0.20887793600559235,
-1.0363143682479858,
0.13919584453105927,
-0.18081426620483398,
-0.09689541906118393,
0.021404506638646126,
-0.2781986594200134,
0.3635846674442291,
-0.19261771440505981,
0.02146528847515583,
0.24254518747329712,
0.9167752861976624,
0.005865170620381832,
-0.07680438458919525,
0.4586571156978607,
0.5666480660438538,
1.006120204925537,
0.023607227951288223,
0.8132266402244568,
-0.8082069158554077,
0.5970832109451294,
0.9555037617683411,
-0.37758442759513855,
0.7127498984336853,
0.4416731894016266,
-0.09999264776706696,
0.6472985744476318,
0.5408676266670227,
-0.13260871171951294,
0.5091149806976318,
0.1449916511774063,
-0.07929439842700958,
-0.1955195963382721,
0.028193913400173187,
-0.6301129460334778,
0.4629978835582733,
0.4436095654964447,
-0.5585147738456726,
-0.33098122477531433,
0.04231226444244385,
-0.08053485304117203,
-0.28151655197143555,
-0.20134703814983368,
0.8162046074867249,
-0.05134683847427368,
-0.37531906366348267,
0.3235374987125397,
-0.12871989607810974,
0.38746872544288635,
-0.5709310173988342,
0.022678717970848083,
0.16096605360507965,
-0.054166875779628754,
-0.06426507979631424,
-0.5018013715744019,
0.41940048336982727,
0.12401210516691208,
-0.42272934317588806,
0.08177600055932999,
1.0751278400421143,
-0.5710898041725159,
-0.4632698595523834,
0.35818856954574585,
0.46588143706321716,
0.48205745220184326,
0.15856429934501648,
-1.135277509689331,
-0.3019174039363861,
-0.22654210031032562,
0.010273882187902927,
0.38948556780815125,
0.6823766827583313,
0.12031558901071548,
0.4694136679172516,
0.6278736591339111,
0.26918360590934753,
-0.10641133785247803,
-0.027588017284870148,
0.7380872368812561,
-0.7427896857261658,
-0.35000771284103394,
-0.5817003846168518,
0.13558687269687653,
-0.18635182082653046,
-0.2998170554637909,
0.5137878656387329,
0.5273866653442383,
0.7569522857666016,
-0.11810596287250519,
0.5510787963867188,
0.056854285299777985,
0.7077836990356445,
-0.4498545229434967,
1.019539475440979,
-0.5315203666687012,
-0.11133337765932083,
-0.30141058564186096,
-0.6505250334739685,
-0.36886000633239746,
0.8859612941741943,
-0.08892374485731125,
-0.12687227129936218,
0.7220438718795776,
0.4213962256908417,
0.04528236761689186,
-0.1467181295156479,
0.16346247494220734,
0.5227946043014526,
-0.04615611210465431,
0.3294124901294708,
0.32772430777549744,
-0.39061278104782104,
0.4121967852115631,
-0.34167879819869995,
-0.11132220178842545,
-0.3596583306789398,
-1.0200215578079224,
-0.8516252636909485,
-0.42642706632614136,
-0.5823735594749451,
-0.709113359451294,
0.30696234107017517,
1.119482398033142,
0.5747238397598267,
-1.0404822826385498,
0.226134791970253,
0.14573617279529572,
-0.23343658447265625,
-0.012919791974127293,
-0.07619599252939224,
0.6972672939300537,
-0.4948107898235321,
-0.5929470062255859,
0.33858251571655273,
0.6388921141624451,
0.008123098872601986,
-0.3899381458759308,
0.1689475178718567,
-0.3937836289405823,
-0.07557263970375061,
0.40952885150909424,
0.4799959361553192,
-0.7773417830467224,
-0.30486658215522766,
-0.06396091729402542,
-0.6397627592086792,
0.2217513769865036,
0.4687119424343109,
-0.6724980473518372,
0.7469517588615417,
0.17419183254241943,
0.8065251111984253,
0.3682780861854553,
-0.14288540184497833,
0.4526856541633606,
-0.5603687763214111,
-0.2018124908208847,
0.14065559208393097,
0.5619726777076721,
0.17155852913856506,
-0.2649959325790405,
0.5295121669769287,
0.1637583076953888,
-0.578248918056488,
-0.4401005506515503,
0.009885654784739017,
-0.9086993336677551,
-0.2919365465641022,
0.8641724586486816,
-0.1110180914402008,
-0.46218758821487427,
-0.3210937976837158,
-0.34276485443115234,
0.801597535610199,
-0.06644255667924881,
1.2247726917266846,
0.5134080648422241,
-0.20037032663822174,
0.465519517660141,
-0.4585992991924286,
0.5611168146133423,
0.4002741575241089,
-0.7344490885734558,
-0.36262190341949463,
0.47685760259628296,
0.538185179233551,
0.14912384748458862,
0.612870454788208,
-0.1565733700990677,
0.3107292056083679,
-0.5094959735870361,
0.460976779460907,
0.27379390597343445,
-0.28081488609313965,
-0.15146276354789734,
-0.0731392651796341,
-0.2662647068500519,
-0.11268389225006104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11937v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11937v1
|
Chasing COMET: Leveraging Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding for Self-Improving Machine Translation
| 2024-05-20T10:25:03 | 2024-05-20T10:25:03 |
Kamil Guttmann, Mikołaj Pokrywka, Adrian Charkiewicz, Artur Nowakowski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper explores Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) decoding for self-improvement in
machine translation (MT), particularly for domain adaptation and low-resource
languages. We implement the self-improvement process by fine-tuning the model
on its MBR-decoded forward translations. By employing COMET as the MBR utility
metric, we aim to achieve the reranking of translations that better aligns with
human preferences. The paper explores the iterative application of this
approach and the potential need for language-specific MBR utility metrics. The
results demonstrate significant enhancements in translation quality for all
examined language pairs, including successful application to domain-adapted
models and generalisation to low-resource settings. This highlights the
potential of COMET-guided MBR for efficient MT self-improvement in various
scenarios.
|
[
0.1094578355550766,
-0.2361638993024826,
0.43205526471138,
0.11893907934427261,
-0.13176344335079193,
0.2828681170940399,
0.07712089270353317,
-0.013369604013860226,
0.2284437119960785,
0.6809013485908508,
-0.7646790146827698,
-0.40562787652015686,
-0.9312899112701416,
0.31612956523895264,
-0.1999424397945404,
1.038670539855957,
0.11087379604578018,
-0.0342690572142601,
0.14062044024467468,
0.1902988702058792,
-0.6458686590194702,
-0.4745995104312897,
-0.6410278677940369,
0.19225971400737762,
0.7046130299568176,
0.7145733833312988,
0.9300687313079834,
0.8971350789070129,
0.854682207107544,
0.3025000989437103,
0.24811340868473053,
0.05784456059336662,
-0.5436626672744751,
0.10632405430078506,
-0.4918394684791565,
-0.42275694012641907,
-0.36611208319664,
-0.2142713963985443,
0.8237866163253784,
0.8162019848823547,
-0.21450695395469666,
0.3167650103569031,
0.14979439973831177,
1.2454397678375244,
-0.9269530773162842,
0.08939855545759201,
-0.6659196615219116,
-0.10143590718507767,
-0.3136003911495209,
-0.5499232411384583,
-0.44124987721443176,
-0.13149558007717133,
-0.29571592807769775,
-0.36080697178840637,
0.2716006636619568,
0.22759266197681427,
0.4143431782722473,
0.5734774470329285,
-0.5034926533699036,
0.08497551083564758,
-0.48462972044944763,
0.9133989810943604,
-0.42638733983039856,
0.49235278367996216,
0.3665957748889923,
0.3864577114582062,
-0.6112169027328491,
-0.33593741059303284,
-0.15461088716983795,
0.23097234964370728,
0.06720668077468872,
0.2622416019439697,
-0.5342543125152588,
-0.19763527810573578,
-0.14564207196235657,
0.31665274500846863,
-0.3586384356021881,
0.1445680856704712,
-0.24330337345600128,
-0.47936663031578064,
0.6562851667404175,
0.32442158460617065,
0.16158045828342438,
-0.3916395902633667,
0.008381894789636135,
-0.40158647298812866,
-0.6356762051582336,
0.27936768531799316,
0.27932292222976685,
0.4717215299606323,
0.2228906750679016,
0.542906641960144,
-0.43274590373039246,
0.4546905755996704,
0.3124648630619049,
-0.05629808083176613,
0.26921579241752625,
-0.2096286416053772,
-0.12567642331123352,
0.05625656992197037,
0.6940397024154663,
0.4441661536693573,
-0.23534707725048065,
-0.3988606035709381,
-0.28867974877357483,
-0.3027763366699219,
0.5424769520759583,
-0.7437546849250793,
-0.37555986642837524,
0.210510715842247,
-0.7337108850479126,
-0.08321236073970795,
-0.41934213042259216,
-0.8128883242607117,
-0.3115909993648529,
0.072843998670578,
0.6169542074203491,
-0.7011301517486572,
-0.2369178831577301,
0.2077106386423111,
-0.17841318249702454,
0.02996704913675785,
0.08568007498979568,
-1.1212677955627441,
0.27447113394737244,
0.5623646974563599,
0.8423016667366028,
0.032384686172008514,
-0.31664249300956726,
-0.9703173637390137,
0.24751612544059753,
-0.7328739166259766,
0.789884626865387,
-0.2385844886302948,
-0.6585380434989929,
-0.054305385798215866,
0.12529458105564117,
-0.19722478091716766,
-0.5037416219711304,
0.6377502083778381,
-0.3952092230319977,
-0.2105131596326828,
-0.26480698585510254,
-0.5228548645973206,
-0.0709160640835762,
-0.10710076242685318,
-0.3326076865196228,
0.7570715546607971,
0.2759183943271637,
-0.7074385285377502,
0.4150353968143463,
-0.7238267064094543,
-0.7139418125152588,
0.02451830729842186,
0.17368635535240173,
-0.5126221776008606,
0.6027828454971313,
0.3511691689491272,
0.6744775772094727,
-0.08841174095869064,
0.20776444673538208,
-0.18189600110054016,
-0.033958956599235535,
0.2992311418056488,
-0.4641011655330658,
0.4341924786567688,
0.4915827214717865,
-0.23217347264289856,
0.05054210498929024,
-0.7900333404541016,
0.2982790768146515,
0.1375332772731781,
-0.3326290547847748,
-0.40703508257865906,
0.4049525260925293,
-0.20804153382778168,
-0.01724098064005375,
0.28408411145210266,
-0.4726381301879883,
0.16435275971889496,
-0.5147845149040222,
0.22276274859905243,
0.6707884669303894,
0.03778005763888359,
0.6138150691986084,
-0.35921475291252136,
0.3455767035484314,
0.1739833950996399,
0.34171074628829956,
-0.1127118393778801,
-0.46448296308517456,
-0.6860188245773315,
-0.1983141154050827,
0.5308980941772461,
0.4965773820877075,
-0.9798566102981567,
0.4818738102912903,
-0.6215694546699524,
-0.4947669804096222,
-1.1673094034194946,
0.22791260480880737,
0.5866432189941406,
0.3225279748439789,
0.7141575813293457,
-0.48207277059555054,
-0.18107634782791138,
-1.1046282052993774,
-0.675853967666626,
-0.12732817232608795,
0.09451255202293396,
-0.20933547616004944,
0.16048508882522583,
-0.5772759318351746,
0.762921154499054,
-0.2842008173465729,
-0.3165927529335022,
-0.28924688696861267,
0.09154408425092697,
0.47705426812171936,
0.9290789365768433,
0.39320507645606995,
-0.5949932336807251,
-0.6275502443313599,
-0.08098070323467255,
-0.29027649760246277,
-0.010307352989912033,
-0.20240208506584167,
-0.40078696608543396,
0.449496865272522,
-0.005929600913077593,
-0.03517239913344383,
0.4967339336872101,
0.762625515460968,
-0.15133357048034668,
0.16592200100421906,
-0.5989106893539429,
0.6559021472930908,
-0.9627705812454224,
0.013644253835082054,
0.10972302407026291,
-0.3253876566886902,
-0.7093588709831238,
0.17132358253002167,
0.4622432291507721,
0.08746480941772461,
-0.3744688928127289,
0.16956022381782532,
-0.5314686298370361,
-0.03760404512286186,
-0.5610774159431458,
-0.05538490414619446,
-0.4660993218421936,
0.08830344676971436,
0.11811597645282745,
0.8538616895675659,
0.600471019744873,
-0.8659245371818542,
-0.4154108762741089,
0.3599538207054138,
-0.3184502422809601,
0.4197518229484558,
-0.1290619969367981,
-0.0789065733551979,
-0.09891723841428757,
-0.2631358802318573,
-0.9059368968009949,
-0.007185843773186207,
0.4005652666091919,
-0.613584578037262,
0.5954245328903198,
-0.4824691414833069,
-0.5939663648605347,
-0.2937779426574707,
-0.07693389058113098,
0.09504992514848709,
0.9419258236885071,
-0.6410897374153137,
0.41775596141815186,
0.33961203694343567,
-0.3208943009376526,
-0.648583710193634,
-0.6209554076194763,
0.3927883803844452,
0.08015505969524384,
-0.5479484796524048,
0.39566272497177124,
-0.4221932291984558,
0.19525477290153503,
-0.1862688809633255,
-0.2628233730792999,
-0.03973907232284546,
0.1965857446193695,
0.24210701882839203,
-0.12822113931179047,
0.12029599398374557,
-0.1580008864402771,
0.636614203453064,
-0.6755714416503906,
0.08508839458227158,
-0.4570690989494324,
0.11235576122999191,
-0.10066014528274536,
0.001795951509848237,
-0.5789061784744263,
0.44348663091659546,
0.06934414803981781,
0.08092474192380905,
0.7765651941299438,
0.550775945186615,
-0.04499448463320732,
0.09083938598632812,
-0.6561596989631653,
-0.046702537685632706,
-0.5828229188919067,
0.12776978313922882,
-0.9462648630142212,
-0.8877604603767395,
0.27766647934913635,
-0.2727290093898773,
-0.14663907885551453,
0.8185556530952454,
0.4312424063682556,
-0.4403926432132721,
1.1244540214538574,
1.0972152948379517,
-0.4399354159832001,
0.2812972664833069,
-0.24507318437099457,
0.0735754743218422,
-0.8640003800392151,
-0.061898015439510345,
-0.6036071181297302,
-0.21828699111938477,
-0.9151937365531921,
-0.24786779284477234,
0.3192291557788849,
-0.05897070840001106,
-0.08817921578884125,
0.6698520183563232,
-0.5334690809249878,
0.45507100224494934,
0.899277925491333,
0.04953152686357498,
0.1962914615869522,
-0.03629865124821663,
-0.16592095792293549,
-0.4142196476459503,
-1.1542112827301025,
-0.36521267890930176,
0.9384812712669373,
0.24348166584968567,
0.6887602806091309,
0.33963146805763245,
1.111007809638977,
0.49004030227661133,
0.38107383251190186,
-0.5743136405944824,
0.3129635751247406,
-0.24020089209079742,
-0.7739754915237427,
-0.2375575751066208,
-0.9942824244499207,
-1.2564281225204468,
0.3303854465484619,
-0.17316053807735443,
-0.53950035572052,
0.19946806132793427,
0.39235919713974,
-0.24653182923793793,
0.2987772524356842,
-0.3457113802433014,
1.1813257932662964,
-0.3245580494403839,
-0.2050771564245224,
-0.5389581322669983,
-1.0068211555480957,
0.155600905418396,
-0.2804286479949951,
0.6288303136825562,
-0.08386935293674469,
-0.0907985121011734,
0.5750346183776855,
-0.2859034240245819,
0.8519030213356018,
-0.12609674036502838,
-0.11674397438764572,
0.15080317854881287,
0.8493056297302246,
0.39469078183174133,
-0.21212436258792877,
-0.08780931681394577,
0.2983814477920532,
0.3981187045574188,
-0.7242688536643982,
-0.367081880569458,
0.47643065452575684,
-0.7640639543533325,
-0.7774456143379211,
-0.593034029006958,
-0.30373290181159973,
-0.029058991000056267,
0.37193453311920166,
0.27485764026641846,
0.15533164143562317,
-0.14705191552639008,
0.03058081492781639,
0.43823885917663574,
-0.2622181177139282,
0.6109282970428467,
0.9593225717544556,
-0.04522465914487839,
-0.7783123254776001,
1.1234310865402222,
-0.03638181835412979,
0.3838171660900116,
0.8355221152305603,
0.2248072475194931,
-0.30679190158843994,
-0.9161882996559143,
-0.6754417419433594,
0.1376255601644516,
-0.6320834755897522,
-0.5593623518943787,
-0.6751878261566162,
0.08149940520524979,
-0.6004633903503418,
-0.21437779068946838,
-0.7308319211006165,
-0.39594489336013794,
-0.20086385309696198,
0.23979879915714264,
0.1266341209411621,
0.48987120389938354,
-0.5848320126533508,
0.7370739579200745,
-1.4178526401519775,
0.1366165280342102,
-0.24883516132831573,
0.3203599750995636,
-0.4434066414833069,
-0.932161271572113,
-0.6949656009674072,
0.10348816215991974,
-0.32552337646484375,
-0.7598978281021118,
0.8186429142951965,
0.14055174589157104,
0.6720917224884033,
0.036418940871953964,
0.23156112432479858,
0.8159028887748718,
-0.9901718497276306,
0.5326395034790039,
0.4582977294921875,
-1.2779542207717896,
0.8660703897476196,
-0.2279149740934372,
0.11022605746984482,
0.8874891996383667,
0.5087703466415405,
-0.6402700543403625,
-0.25050920248031616,
-0.6567521095275879,
-0.4327303171157837,
0.4165361523628235,
0.39061594009399414,
0.0854562446475029,
-0.271548867225647,
0.6804131269454956,
0.2247927337884903,
0.0367678664624691,
-0.5023894906044006,
-0.29280179738998413,
-0.22674597799777985,
-0.25374776124954224,
-0.4947396516799927,
-0.10022641718387604,
0.10409777611494064,
-0.0760563462972641,
0.9667307734489441,
-0.3183014690876007,
0.27955615520477295,
0.3025508522987366,
-0.3620835244655609,
-0.5834457874298096,
0.35391345620155334,
0.07544514536857605,
0.14689089357852936,
-0.24815939366817474,
0.12790890038013458,
0.1647607833147049,
-0.08882482349872589,
0.3003273606300354,
-0.10090799629688263,
0.016646502539515495,
-0.13901709020137787,
0.030887851491570473,
0.12815195322036743,
0.42942312359809875,
-0.4667128622531891,
0.5945943593978882,
-0.013482512906193733,
0.024816080927848816,
0.038290150463581085,
0.252925843000412,
-0.28520360589027405,
0.09517105668783188,
0.29261982440948486,
0.33655375242233276,
0.6016373038291931,
-0.5797117948532104,
0.24874934554100037,
0.3696936070919037,
-0.4404590129852295,
-0.2930634021759033,
0.7684431672096252,
0.22651228308677673,
-0.3902992606163025,
0.5131049156188965,
-0.3838571012020111,
-0.2679271101951599,
0.13233917951583862,
0.7040178775787354,
0.8854858875274658,
-0.47417524456977844,
0.10386304557323456,
0.35377037525177,
0.711314857006073,
-0.09846905618906021,
0.3239942193031311,
0.18552544713020325,
-0.5302131175994873,
-0.5954320430755615,
-0.527217447757721,
-0.6229568123817444,
-0.5853126645088196,
-0.5870059728622437,
-0.01051801722496748,
-0.2934611737728119,
-0.3695433437824249,
-0.19765564799308777,
-0.026686852797865868,
-0.6561468839645386,
0.29456764459609985,
-0.27752068638801575,
0.8712075352668762,
-0.33742111921310425,
0.9027367830276489,
0.27383172512054443,
-0.45097607374191284,
-0.2760566473007202,
-0.03450348973274231,
-0.01794072426855564,
-0.7212966084480286,
0.7120783925056458,
0.027666257694363594,
-0.3864220082759857,
0.3895002007484436,
-0.3634931743144989,
-1.2522828578948975,
0.9938718676567078,
0.2342105209827423,
-0.8041089177131653,
0.5829025506973267,
0.10665198415517807,
0.2583615779876709,
-0.2117317020893097,
-0.15352363884449005,
0.5720559358596802,
0.3181799650192261,
-0.20398351550102234,
-0.8156390190124512,
0.0743398517370224,
-0.10456575453281403,
0.16099467873573303,
0.6278660893440247,
-0.7147747874259949,
0.05733615532517433,
-0.5171799063682556,
-0.4044707417488098,
0.3982751667499542,
0.7797728776931763,
-0.33937734365463257,
0.3632560968399048,
0.21647495031356812,
0.3635481595993042,
0.47665345668792725,
0.0660967230796814,
1.3690887689590454,
-0.5180379748344421,
0.18793131411075592,
1.024322509765625,
0.013900683261454105,
1.0862069129943848,
0.29244762659072876,
-0.21565337479114532,
0.5409256219863892,
0.8124356865882874,
0.220001220703125,
0.9710109233856201,
0.20685113966464996,
0.03540448844432831,
-0.44856494665145874,
0.37928691506385803,
-0.2360905408859253,
0.022483037784695625,
0.366790235042572,
-0.35464170575141907,
0.03379736840724945,
-0.13740625977516174,
-0.0903581827878952,
0.1536746323108673,
-0.4305424690246582,
0.8706017732620239,
0.07549784332513809,
-0.5201843976974487,
0.5282720327377319,
0.4239415228366852,
0.5433427691459656,
-0.4001036286354065,
0.36410143971443176,
-0.1851392537355423,
0.30467694997787476,
-0.07098627090454102,
-0.6779676675796509,
0.4474218487739563,
-0.0769633799791336,
-0.30812087655067444,
-0.2226010262966156,
0.7754579186439514,
-0.1369265913963318,
-0.6727852821350098,
0.3738536834716797,
0.700711190700531,
0.46912476420402527,
-0.24313057959079742,
-0.8577231764793396,
-0.18131041526794434,
-0.073563352227211,
0.12909692525863647,
0.5729840993881226,
0.5820361375808716,
0.5835620760917664,
1.0096131563186646,
0.6952103972434998,
-0.07167825102806091,
0.20154428482055664,
-0.03700580820441246,
0.5245363712310791,
-1.1715351343154907,
-0.38986173272132874,
-0.8659131526947021,
0.6736394762992859,
0.14789007604122162,
-0.1206740289926529,
0.7886317372322083,
0.7729939818382263,
0.6614097356796265,
-0.3138384521007538,
0.7008559703826904,
0.2056402564048767,
0.5752942562103271,
-0.5477023720741272,
0.6416088342666626,
-0.5265102386474609,
-0.018031425774097443,
-0.2893935441970825,
-0.844816267490387,
-0.561553418636322,
0.640177845954895,
-0.1764756441116333,
-0.38221630454063416,
0.8099818229675293,
0.6873924136161804,
0.09129111468791962,
-0.2674730718135834,
0.7082043886184692,
0.01116926223039627,
0.1676698476076126,
0.47647786140441895,
0.6736131310462952,
-0.7833066582679749,
0.5760889053344727,
-0.2304655909538269,
-0.5034995079040527,
-0.2003687471151352,
-1.074752688407898,
-0.7495981454849243,
-0.40941426157951355,
-0.7686538100242615,
-0.39600586891174316,
0.2784615755081177,
0.992143988609314,
0.5984895825386047,
-0.647847056388855,
-0.2599417269229889,
0.11968167126178741,
0.04554787650704384,
-0.5613983869552612,
-0.07170983403921127,
0.056233543902635574,
-0.9672929048538208,
-0.583065390586853,
0.8149216771125793,
0.47018757462501526,
0.1738436371088028,
0.1678030639886856,
-0.2030327469110489,
0.25460654497146606,
0.08306995779275894,
0.586143970489502,
0.15876010060310364,
-0.5272049903869629,
-0.32189345359802246,
-0.14833682775497437,
-0.007915543392300606,
0.23325861990451813,
0.7260183095932007,
-0.550427258014679,
0.4225883185863495,
0.017070284113287926,
1.0464913845062256,
0.46432116627693176,
-0.23562796413898468,
0.5607350468635559,
-0.4565330743789673,
-0.5672892332077026,
-0.10273554921150208,
0.5409057140350342,
0.29059740900993347,
-0.5099824666976929,
0.8013739585876465,
0.24351440370082855,
-0.7770009636878967,
-0.33429059386253357,
0.21466517448425293,
-1.0058823823928833,
-0.2008923441171646,
0.8628490567207336,
-0.043149542063474655,
-0.37976357340812683,
0.09367940574884415,
-0.08539940416812897,
0.1442866325378418,
-0.5099039077758789,
0.9839516282081604,
0.3474574685096741,
-0.09285189211368561,
-0.09385938197374344,
-0.4299614429473877,
0.3280036747455597,
0.5059577822685242,
-0.6313982605934143,
0.19984020292758942,
0.5069776773452759,
0.7012290954589844,
0.09868410974740982,
0.7038219571113586,
-0.10012077540159225,
0.16473044455051422,
-0.009834781289100647,
0.21351924538612366,
0.37285149097442627,
-0.42710044980049133,
-0.4697098135948181,
-0.1367214471101761,
0.18562312424182892,
-0.18082356452941895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11919v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11919v2
|
On Efficient and Statistical Quality Estimation for Data Annotation
| 2024-05-20T09:57:29 | 2024-05-29T06:43:37 |
Jan-Christoph Klie, Juan Haladjian, Marc Kirchner, Rahul Nair
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Annotated datasets are an essential ingredient to train, evaluate, compare
and productionalize supervised machine learning models. It is therefore
imperative that annotations are of high quality. For their creation, good
quality management and thereby reliable quality estimates are needed. Then, if
quality is insufficient during the annotation process, rectifying measures can
be taken to improve it. Quality estimation is often performed by having experts
manually label instances as correct or incorrect. But checking all annotated
instances tends to be expensive. Therefore, in practice, usually only subsets
are inspected; sizes are chosen mostly without justification or regard to
statistical power and more often than not, are relatively small. Basing
estimates on small sample sizes, however, can lead to imprecise values for the
error rate. Using unnecessarily large sample sizes costs money that could be
better spent, for instance on more annotations. Therefore, we first describe in
detail how to use confidence intervals for finding the minimal sample size
needed to estimate the annotation error rate. Then, we propose applying
acceptance sampling as an alternative to error rate estimation We show that
acceptance sampling can reduce the required sample sizes up to 50% while
providing the same statistical guarantees.
|
[
-0.5342505574226379,
-0.5783382654190063,
0.5881751179695129,
0.22353757917881012,
-0.3281317353248596,
-0.44970110058784485,
-0.17303936183452606,
-0.6139079332351685,
0.2527182400226593,
0.3981236219406128,
-0.2368898242712021,
-0.3832753598690033,
-0.658044695854187,
0.06751446425914764,
-0.14922663569450378,
0.6434690356254578,
-0.11967030167579651,
0.25756582617759705,
-0.2658287584781647,
-0.443096399307251,
-0.43124905228614807,
-0.47409534454345703,
-0.48462697863578796,
0.004225187003612518,
0.43401870131492615,
0.47475486993789673,
0.75660240650177,
0.8172810673713684,
0.7147513628005981,
0.23584923148155212,
-0.044353727251291275,
0.4925290048122406,
-0.19852188229560852,
0.1757981777191162,
0.1336929202079773,
-0.5671727061271667,
-0.32186460494995117,
0.49377626180648804,
0.5392968058586121,
0.8821456432342529,
0.008236323483288288,
0.5554774403572083,
0.1831948161125183,
0.7387577295303345,
-0.8749173879623413,
0.27124106884002686,
-0.37995606660842896,
0.22402194142341614,
0.036808986216783524,
-0.27925458550453186,
-0.4456072151660919,
-0.557637631893158,
0.04209432378411293,
-0.8677918314933777,
0.137373149394989,
0.08136645704507828,
0.7279286980628967,
0.6976582407951355,
0.04982345551252365,
-0.33039113879203796,
-0.6162745952606201,
0.9477784037590027,
-0.48402994871139526,
0.12192422151565552,
0.9405383467674255,
0.5327946543693542,
-0.2826039493083954,
-0.4865061342716217,
-0.4185430109500885,
-0.23244702816009521,
-0.18422508239746094,
0.0740775614976883,
0.013418341055512428,
0.0890573263168335,
0.5431222319602966,
0.30557745695114136,
-0.32930928468704224,
0.16071754693984985,
-0.1967812329530716,
-0.17119641602039337,
0.9558855295181274,
0.005320627707988024,
-0.09369304031133652,
-0.09336844831705093,
-0.061613112688064575,
-0.1329793781042099,
-0.19231761991977692,
0.06932362169027328,
0.4883973300457001,
0.4392557740211487,
0.3357923924922943,
0.6073524951934814,
-0.42260703444480896,
0.8044314980506897,
-0.11874614655971527,
-0.15350931882858276,
0.36890408396720886,
-0.40710046887397766,
-0.41708904504776,
-0.11309751868247986,
0.5560227036476135,
0.4524261951446533,
0.5431796908378601,
0.06947693973779678,
-0.3400176763534546,
0.0016229574102908373,
0.44681835174560547,
-0.7237507104873657,
-0.4763478636741638,
0.5357088446617126,
-0.6469944715499878,
-0.36626195907592773,
0.23267625272274017,
-0.8674067258834839,
-0.31254181265830994,
-0.39601296186447144,
0.6665721535682678,
-0.28743523359298706,
-0.06421588361263275,
-0.29728105664253235,
-0.23482508957386017,
-0.38423973321914673,
0.5589184165000916,
-0.587790310382843,
0.014624043367803097,
0.3072982132434845,
0.801901638507843,
0.3085441589355469,
-0.014261691831052303,
-0.5273592472076416,
-0.32218652963638306,
-0.8824338912963867,
0.5763736367225647,
-0.30139607191085815,
-0.2937442362308502,
-0.18065373599529266,
-0.06162828207015991,
0.10868214815855026,
-0.4988099932670593,
0.6932598948478699,
-0.38505586981773376,
-0.11906546354293823,
-0.15747547149658203,
-0.9046411514282227,
-0.4336067736148834,
-0.003575148293748498,
-0.846430778503418,
0.8625873327255249,
0.41896331310272217,
-0.721257209777832,
1.1299693584442139,
-0.5829618573188782,
-0.28477609157562256,
-0.014223798178136349,
0.07865191996097565,
-0.8879237771034241,
0.2591269910335541,
0.5369621515274048,
0.6708543300628662,
0.14178809523582458,
-0.1025669202208519,
-0.6357192397117615,
-0.41697436571121216,
0.45924490690231323,
-0.3292126953601837,
0.8078917860984802,
0.562395453453064,
-0.13696043193340302,
0.001640382339246571,
-0.8215696811676025,
0.3191075921058655,
-0.25313618779182434,
-0.11551404744386673,
-0.4340019226074219,
0.012302719056606293,
0.12644341588020325,
-0.0785398781299591,
-0.15201596915721893,
-0.5197626352310181,
0.07243857532739639,
-0.09359406679868698,
0.15095573663711548,
0.5475653409957886,
0.3230043053627014,
0.3900109529495239,
-0.29164424538612366,
0.11761196702718735,
-0.16425339877605438,
0.6205825805664062,
0.058196060359478,
-0.49707871675491333,
-0.5347215533256531,
-0.6542945504188538,
0.9156408309936523,
0.2719280421733856,
-0.5694028735160828,
0.6678922176361084,
0.09936567395925522,
-0.749132513999939,
-0.8210508227348328,
0.1741887331008911,
-0.049707453697919846,
0.28625816106796265,
0.45447808504104614,
-0.282787561416626,
-0.5734590888023376,
-0.631054162979126,
-0.1808810979127884,
-0.37769442796707153,
-0.05364064499735832,
-0.0500568151473999,
0.617966890335083,
0.20603474974632263,
1.085133671760559,
-0.24226319789886475,
-0.3390538692474365,
-0.06316469609737396,
0.32789844274520874,
0.09758694469928741,
0.7507904767990112,
0.7062416672706604,
-0.8406254649162292,
-0.26594221591949463,
-0.4608898460865021,
-0.9895610213279724,
-0.04049084335565567,
-0.23018550872802734,
-0.21271561086177826,
0.37806397676467896,
-0.022475145757198334,
-0.14644485712051392,
0.8592562079429626,
0.5789281129837036,
0.11995667219161987,
0.22235068678855896,
-0.2904045581817627,
0.4829709231853485,
-0.6018707752227783,
0.07684321701526642,
0.4255806803703308,
-0.23308245837688446,
-0.47410425543785095,
-0.02517043985426426,
0.15176238119602203,
0.2934139668941498,
-0.10093049705028534,
0.2515680491924286,
-0.352285236120224,
-0.12940220534801483,
-0.4618126153945923,
0.007803719490766525,
0.018700389191508293,
0.12294403463602066,
0.12665367126464844,
0.7788886427879333,
0.15950889885425568,
-0.5243034958839417,
-0.004761391319334507,
0.15149366855621338,
-0.5624721646308899,
0.8854963183403015,
-0.5210258960723877,
-0.37192267179489136,
-0.12193255126476288,
0.39607056975364685,
-0.9972580671310425,
-0.44172415137290955,
0.4325934052467346,
-0.7301194667816162,
0.26453325152397156,
-0.3982734680175781,
-0.4750771224498749,
-0.31264135241508484,
-0.25805023312568665,
-0.039763253182172775,
0.688617467880249,
-0.7781200408935547,
0.2870946526527405,
0.6074854135513306,
0.16543079912662506,
-0.6183623671531677,
-0.814022958278656,
-0.16004088521003723,
-0.31463977694511414,
-0.4337635338306427,
-0.3962911069393158,
0.09979227930307388,
-0.21547989547252655,
0.049189530313014984,
-0.022573307156562805,
-0.5209342241287231,
0.33552491664886475,
0.5414468050003052,
0.1675952523946762,
0.03185257315635681,
0.23781441152095795,
0.03909183293581009,
-0.3898161053657532,
-0.09784170985221863,
-0.4319518804550171,
-0.08516895771026611,
0.5147523283958435,
-0.5762877464294434,
-0.8573900461196899,
0.09140348434448242,
0.15160644054412842,
0.021825216710567474,
0.8634894490242004,
0.7184407711029053,
-0.5884500741958618,
-0.030158599838614464,
-0.7887693047523499,
-0.15585829317569733,
-0.32548782229423523,
0.12272107601165771,
-0.2595268189907074,
-0.4144632816314697,
0.34144920110702515,
0.25330618023872375,
0.23918719589710236,
0.7132444381713867,
0.15265712141990662,
-0.43611428141593933,
0.9754213690757751,
0.49495166540145874,
0.06635280698537827,
0.4692726135253906,
-0.2056543231010437,
-0.02417067438364029,
-0.48487022519111633,
0.1478068232536316,
-0.8376244306564331,
-0.15516892075538635,
-0.7053178548812866,
-0.34561777114868164,
0.3819943368434906,
0.3280833661556244,
-0.08108098059892654,
0.09420513361692429,
-0.7198023200035095,
0.292549192905426,
0.9554163813591003,
0.32697346806526184,
0.2725934088230133,
0.21019236743450165,
0.5293377041816711,
-0.15221871435642242,
-0.7065858244895935,
-0.6839050054550171,
1.3884320259094238,
0.5359286665916443,
0.5563525557518005,
-0.35973188281059265,
0.7046509981155396,
0.30171674489974976,
0.7368476986885071,
-0.5694252848625183,
0.12485029548406601,
0.005558784119784832,
-0.6839088797569275,
-0.5875426530838013,
-0.7694101929664612,
-0.6506471037864685,
0.11230943351984024,
-0.3008796274662018,
-0.6055429577827454,
0.40517669916152954,
0.6382041573524475,
-0.41452163457870483,
0.3157738447189331,
-0.7106472253799438,
0.7421929240226746,
0.13168074190616608,
-0.06772114336490631,
0.04866764694452286,
-0.470185786485672,
0.25824445486068726,
-0.30614519119262695,
0.24782368540763855,
-0.3052077889442444,
0.017122751101851463,
1.1087125539779663,
-0.7048819065093994,
0.7014448046684265,
-0.6613616347312927,
0.4898512363433838,
0.802172064781189,
-0.14578525722026825,
0.5257752537727356,
0.07540340721607208,
-0.3565394878387451,
0.4765913486480713,
0.2047443389892578,
-0.6922799944877625,
-0.650299072265625,
0.08324039727449417,
-0.6802392601966858,
0.06370993703603745,
-0.45216238498687744,
-0.31520402431488037,
-0.10711809247732162,
-0.3684179484844208,
0.3914225101470947,
0.16279546916484833,
0.26923590898513794,
-0.01886202022433281,
0.35239702463150024,
0.03199755772948265,
0.3640851378440857,
0.004114266950637102,
0.2720630168914795,
-0.845862090587616,
0.897571325302124,
0.7593533992767334,
0.23380589485168457,
0.029281768947839737,
0.10024721175432205,
-0.42220816016197205,
-0.80516517162323,
-0.6527841687202454,
-0.10894181579351425,
-0.6778573989868164,
-0.3549359440803528,
-0.5708418488502502,
0.05121669918298721,
-0.21202851831912994,
-0.09999087452888489,
-0.23429924249649048,
-0.7087438702583313,
-0.17895232141017914,
-0.13616302609443665,
0.6869716048240662,
0.3837306499481201,
-0.5199710726737976,
0.5517653226852417,
-0.48178642988204956,
-0.011179151944816113,
0.04222816601395607,
0.36271730065345764,
-0.08246325701475143,
-0.5701357126235962,
-0.39442846179008484,
0.14021724462509155,
0.08226705342531204,
-0.5915886759757996,
0.3266332745552063,
-0.10416147112846375,
0.6946825981140137,
0.2831590175628662,
0.34770965576171875,
0.7526785731315613,
-0.04504775628447533,
0.8843398094177246,
0.0026073437184095383,
-0.6875227689743042,
0.5664103627204895,
0.20902298390865326,
-0.4705463945865631,
1.0359692573547363,
0.44420748949050903,
-0.2148912101984024,
-0.2309761792421341,
-0.7493125200271606,
-0.8670529127120972,
0.5098112225532532,
0.3372962772846222,
-0.35190415382385254,
0.1221122294664383,
0.4899393618106842,
0.19438336789608002,
0.34807899594306946,
-0.1914985030889511,
-0.3522377610206604,
-0.2160598635673523,
-0.4571138918399811,
-0.3164597153663635,
-0.35682013630867004,
-0.11450327187776566,
-0.05109291896224022,
0.9810078740119934,
-0.11114273965358734,
0.16887828707695007,
0.12244341522455215,
-0.1630619615316391,
-0.17967745661735535,
-0.010943871922791004,
0.20878182351589203,
0.8399799466133118,
-0.3826032876968384,
0.04194221645593643,
0.3527114689350128,
-0.5396585464477539,
0.3461885452270508,
0.15219053626060486,
-0.4587666392326355,
0.21697905659675598,
0.2831484377384186,
0.4509623348712921,
-0.35107168555259705,
-0.340390145778656,
0.4524969458580017,
0.0316004604101181,
-0.130131334066391,
-0.6081516742706299,
0.15276359021663666,
-0.4938625395298004,
0.18388861417770386,
0.2504103481769562,
0.09744671732187271,
0.28172099590301514,
0.015687981620430946,
0.33446401357650757,
0.2936898469924927,
-0.7264506816864014,
0.3201560080051422,
0.5836448669433594,
-0.003975462168455124,
-0.011347944848239422,
0.6809561848640442,
-0.23310916125774384,
-0.1079450398683548,
0.5350080728530884,
-0.2533695101737976,
0.6883190870285034,
-0.3588303029537201,
0.14165177941322327,
0.671187162399292,
0.41446393728256226,
-0.47653713822364807,
0.1608581691980362,
0.15207630395889282,
-0.4909476637840271,
-0.6663379669189453,
-0.6554406881332397,
-0.6729731559753418,
-0.1678648740053177,
-0.7011178731918335,
-0.0037470522802323103,
-0.2153445929288864,
-0.3704608976840973,
0.026551654562354088,
0.2524010241031647,
-0.6080564856529236,
0.6695523262023926,
-0.26718759536743164,
1.0400402545928955,
-1.0836288928985596,
0.29395848512649536,
0.3229493796825409,
-0.8718015551567078,
-0.8625196218490601,
-0.3234511613845825,
-0.04164658859372139,
-0.5587502121925354,
0.4820922911167145,
0.1042909100651741,
0.49262431263923645,
-0.22644510865211487,
-0.5763262510299683,
-0.6712273955345154,
0.7288028001785278,
0.0016814384143799543,
-0.33857402205467224,
0.6369236707687378,
0.0063338205218315125,
0.38832610845565796,
-0.23184028267860413,
0.5303817391395569,
0.6796514391899109,
0.7555065751075745,
-0.16808448731899261,
-0.6081147193908691,
-0.09313381463289261,
0.09032540023326874,
0.03751254081726074,
0.13661016523838043,
-0.1471344530582428,
0.48803380131721497,
-0.12014922499656677,
0.07328880578279495,
0.31815963983535767,
0.7824445366859436,
0.21568557620048523,
0.6230781674385071,
0.7174170613288879,
0.3230763077735901,
0.9041774272918701,
-0.38028207421302795,
1.045817255973816,
-0.13349023461341858,
0.48195698857307434,
0.8893041014671326,
0.14128892123699188,
0.8184527158737183,
0.5095840692520142,
-0.366428405046463,
-0.2991926670074463,
1.288413643836975,
-0.23556499183177948,
0.11793531477451324,
0.3104744255542755,
-0.11013305932283401,
-0.2094997763633728,
-0.11074398458003998,
-0.19714802503585815,
0.01427313219755888,
0.2170996367931366,
-0.6258708238601685,
0.2921578586101532,
-0.0030905751045793295,
-0.07758475840091705,
0.033349599689245224,
-0.27972787618637085,
0.7337958216667175,
-0.13928167521953583,
-0.34178709983825684,
0.22092603147029877,
-0.19249673187732697,
0.2953716218471527,
-0.2470785528421402,
-0.13704271614551544,
-0.16854578256607056,
-0.12051626294851303,
-0.4460560381412506,
-0.8146086931228638,
0.1386021375656128,
-0.08446962386369705,
-0.10834521055221558,
0.2070229947566986,
0.32756590843200684,
-0.2537386119365692,
-0.702241063117981,
-0.246171236038208,
0.42967596650123596,
0.6219152212142944,
-0.35649561882019043,
-0.2670970559120178,
-0.01212574914097786,
-0.15606428682804108,
-0.44408321380615234,
0.07093177735805511,
0.3505704700946808,
-0.07877161353826523,
0.3460638225078583,
0.6108033061027527,
0.37522679567337036,
-0.25619396567344666,
-0.028706954792141914,
0.3143497705459595,
-0.33360975980758667,
-0.5117290616035461,
-0.6351187825202942,
0.7296611666679382,
-0.5176549553871155,
-0.22758524119853973,
0.6605390310287476,
0.3703758716583252,
0.9003298878669739,
0.13274981081485748,
1.0741535425186157,
0.07924044877290726,
0.7077703475952148,
-0.5308582782745361,
0.5560488104820251,
-0.39699313044548035,
-0.1259382963180542,
-0.5473424792289734,
-0.9392227530479431,
-0.6827555894851685,
1.206225037574768,
-0.39781078696250916,
0.2553364038467407,
0.30574288964271545,
0.5181006789207458,
0.07475710660219193,
0.5602747797966003,
0.40809905529022217,
-0.21765796840190887,
0.29602858424186707,
-0.02613348327577114,
0.6458104848861694,
-0.5653014183044434,
0.3329002559185028,
-0.7862260937690735,
-0.5725846290588379,
-0.43591246008872986,
-0.8041078448295593,
-0.5591727495193481,
-0.4414546489715576,
-0.5677801370620728,
-0.5463574528694153,
0.10873479396104813,
1.2035752534866333,
1.0169801712036133,
-0.9075666666030884,
0.009073611348867416,
0.1955178827047348,
-0.050965163856744766,
-0.6943486332893372,
-0.17865926027297974,
0.6426395177841187,
-0.5355432033538818,
-0.7296721339225769,
-0.2579842805862427,
0.021823331713676453,
0.2305983603000641,
-0.18644224107265472,
0.15184740722179413,
0.1570272296667099,
-0.08255907148122787,
0.3531191945075989,
0.2267015129327774,
-0.32477867603302,
-0.6992122530937195,
-0.4731653928756714,
-0.08212332427501678,
0.08091755956411362,
0.3794845640659332,
-0.4190644323825836,
0.48312273621559143,
0.321351021528244,
0.9204341769218445,
0.31979650259017944,
0.22601252794265747,
0.12731727957725525,
-0.5489121675491333,
0.09701360762119293,
0.09661328047513962,
0.3798986077308655,
0.3677016496658325,
-0.3350107669830322,
1.1116832494735718,
0.19955375790596008,
-0.779607892036438,
-0.9541073441505432,
-0.15897369384765625,
-0.809475302696228,
-0.04380495846271515,
0.6864125728607178,
-0.4870936870574951,
-0.4230642020702362,
-0.1232871562242508,
-0.12462801486253738,
0.295161634683609,
-0.38324087858200073,
0.7874640226364136,
0.6470656394958496,
-0.6514737606048584,
0.16184797883033752,
-1.036061406135559,
0.5226994752883911,
0.05507642403244972,
-0.7644028067588806,
-0.006885271053761244,
0.627284049987793,
0.13494451344013214,
0.3398732841014862,
0.4204649031162262,
0.1867453008890152,
0.3278661370277405,
0.37238365411758423,
0.2830047905445099,
-0.1823902130126953,
-0.3390568792819977,
-0.2043941617012024,
0.37319421768188477,
0.23685187101364136,
-0.6332147121429443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11912v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11912v2
|
ARAIDA: Analogical Reasoning-Augmented Interactive Data Annotation
| 2024-05-20T09:48:15 | 2024-06-01T07:30:51 |
Chen Huang, Yiping Jin, Ilija Ilievski, Wenqiang Lei, Jiancheng Lv
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Human annotation is a time-consuming task that requires a significant amount
of effort. To address this issue, interactive data annotation utilizes an
annotation model to provide suggestions for humans to approve or correct.
However, annotation models trained with limited labeled data are prone to
generating incorrect suggestions, leading to extra human correction effort. To
tackle this challenge, we propose Araida, an analogical reasoning-based
approach that enhances automatic annotation accuracy in the interactive data
annotation setting and reduces the need for human corrections. Araida involves
an error-aware integration strategy that dynamically coordinates an annotation
model and a k-nearest neighbors (KNN) model, giving more importance to KNN's
predictions when predictions from the annotation model are deemed inaccurate.
Empirical studies demonstrate that Araida is adaptable to different annotation
tasks and models. On average, it reduces human correction labor by 11.02%
compared to vanilla interactive data annotation methods.
|
[
-0.674740731716156,
-0.8507382869720459,
0.4721693992614746,
-0.07528303563594818,
-0.3815193772315979,
0.0564173124730587,
0.01005146186798811,
-0.8661121129989624,
0.6238847970962524,
0.2916088402271271,
-0.2452605664730072,
-0.4562002420425415,
-0.3930923640727997,
0.19156686961650848,
-0.12813957035541534,
0.9903066754341125,
-0.3543083071708679,
0.02064758725464344,
-0.3081243634223938,
-0.7018056511878967,
-0.3402566611766815,
-0.4061219394207001,
-0.6261099576950073,
-0.2605948746204376,
0.5185839533805847,
0.5514428019523621,
0.966663658618927,
1.1056828498840332,
0.36996787786483765,
0.2958276867866516,
-0.2133239060640335,
0.7707536220550537,
0.250786155462265,
-0.01643972471356392,
-0.16535638272762299,
-0.6842682361602783,
-0.7474066615104675,
0.012033965438604355,
0.3387339115142822,
0.8669869899749756,
-0.272746205329895,
0.4063258767127991,
-0.33477574586868286,
0.9253537058830261,
-0.8324662446975708,
0.23031291365623474,
-0.34646350145339966,
-0.07734578102827072,
-0.24637649953365326,
-0.05653351917862892,
0.03323397412896156,
-0.4852766692638397,
-0.12111561745405197,
-1.3499046564102173,
-0.19720983505249023,
0.21246685087680817,
0.6247729659080505,
0.578249454498291,
-0.13436660170555115,
-0.537095844745636,
-0.9676558971405029,
0.35713592171669006,
-0.5342862606048584,
0.03294725716114044,
0.6841731071472168,
0.6945102214813232,
-0.09625177085399628,
-0.6633434295654297,
-1.0694557428359985,
-0.25039875507354736,
0.006076982244849205,
0.08147500455379486,
-0.02576787956058979,
-0.05263163894414902,
0.3039773106575012,
0.16609419882297516,
-0.0992058515548706,
0.04423394799232483,
-0.3237913250923157,
0.14607016742229462,
0.5198714137077332,
0.24467237293720245,
0.2808665931224823,
-0.001998503925278783,
-0.09090609848499298,
-0.10306181013584137,
-0.5196740031242371,
-0.03878604248166084,
0.663894772529602,
0.29445913434028625,
0.020376598462462425,
0.40248534083366394,
-0.5493117570877075,
0.9287593960762024,
0.08365926891565323,
0.15426865220069885,
0.30279964208602905,
0.10223482549190521,
-0.04343747720122337,
0.2898300290107727,
0.4667776823043823,
0.5866547226905823,
0.314628928899765,
-0.18973003327846527,
0.12958349287509918,
0.44442906975746155,
0.13621284067630768,
-0.45759132504463196,
-0.4806869924068451,
0.24381640553474426,
-0.39721453189849854,
-0.5859662294387817,
-0.01519634760916233,
-0.7662517428398132,
-0.5448657274246216,
-0.6147881746292114,
0.4219535291194916,
-0.3220161199569702,
-0.1187635213136673,
-0.128177672624588,
0.0021231097634881735,
-0.4843769967556,
0.8171700835227966,
-0.7981210947036743,
0.65488201379776,
0.5952621102333069,
0.9084950685501099,
0.0005826487904414535,
-0.20376363396644592,
-0.6170104146003723,
0.4325399696826935,
-0.5182056427001953,
1.2913880348205566,
-0.7459425330162048,
-0.1618747115135193,
-0.5140883922576904,
-0.36637353897094727,
0.24689440429210663,
-0.6082732081413269,
0.5548772811889648,
-0.5544346570968628,
-0.3065606355667114,
-0.18786843121051788,
-0.5513330698013306,
-0.622134804725647,
0.3606547713279724,
-1.1229158639907837,
1.0060290098190308,
-0.0021682321093976498,
-0.8651995062828064,
0.5272527933120728,
-1.1367409229278564,
-0.013943209312856197,
0.19982105493545532,
-0.2615787386894226,
-0.2782592475414276,
-0.38825786113739014,
0.5251923203468323,
-0.015295948833227158,
-0.2154935598373413,
-0.05368001013994217,
-0.4435155987739563,
-0.6241735816001892,
0.18155573308467865,
0.1262115091085434,
0.6109153032302856,
0.28009355068206787,
-0.4335486590862274,
0.3110249936580658,
-0.9152542352676392,
-0.16812828183174133,
-0.07927512377500534,
-0.048907775431871414,
-0.7220937609672546,
-0.07117072492837906,
-0.07634997367858887,
0.12346434593200684,
-0.022191399708390236,
-0.5084202885627747,
0.5780410170555115,
-0.41505664587020874,
0.35394737124443054,
0.7554746270179749,
-0.038845885545015335,
0.5709111094474792,
-0.6607108116149902,
0.6801572442054749,
0.18078474700450897,
0.01957889273762703,
0.013756074011325836,
-0.5575390458106995,
-0.6423568725585938,
-0.24982017278671265,
0.8992877006530762,
0.890153169631958,
-1.0439645051956177,
0.3582629859447479,
-0.30432385206222534,
-0.7528215646743774,
-0.8886629939079285,
0.11629527807235718,
-0.02923496998846531,
0.9189717173576355,
0.2819775640964508,
-0.22434626519680023,
-0.6684308052062988,
-0.7332168817520142,
-0.04680659621953964,
-0.4552392065525055,
0.1679605096578598,
0.29084914922714233,
0.6009401679039001,
-0.2256840318441391,
0.8967297673225403,
-0.16982729732990265,
-0.38061290979385376,
0.2793099582195282,
0.3817960321903229,
0.030796531587839127,
0.5109055042266846,
0.5276634097099304,
-0.8575258851051331,
-0.42531007528305054,
0.19828371703624725,
-0.8886036276817322,
-0.2474241405725479,
-0.1430872082710266,
-0.19645540416240692,
0.18827541172504425,
0.3876613676548004,
-0.44406282901763916,
0.8748415112495422,
0.20500193536281586,
0.07118891179561615,
0.5506072044372559,
-0.2750622034072876,
0.49819689989089966,
-0.8348265290260315,
0.3107612729072571,
-0.0615718699991703,
-0.21417103707790375,
-0.31527262926101685,
0.04076716676354408,
-0.15447014570236206,
-0.09903224557638168,
-0.11815457791090012,
0.7420542240142822,
-0.18442486226558685,
0.0948101133108139,
-0.31137800216674805,
0.05880250036716461,
-0.10521356016397476,
0.3614804446697235,
0.2096664309501648,
0.905436098575592,
0.5084472298622131,
-0.5112789273262024,
0.5507746338844299,
0.5272530913352966,
-0.20428934693336487,
0.8708302974700928,
-0.6088319420814514,
0.20425818860530853,
-0.1743292510509491,
0.5477929711341858,
-0.8825390934944153,
-0.31573259830474854,
0.5959333777427673,
-0.45359504222869873,
-0.2567390501499176,
-0.27231112122535706,
-0.9787052869796753,
0.04272979870438576,
-0.38284608721733093,
0.6660381555557251,
0.5436446666717529,
-0.9059129357337952,
0.906161367893219,
0.3347233533859253,
-0.010062950663268566,
-0.293805330991745,
-0.7035924792289734,
0.19496700167655945,
-0.5914534330368042,
-0.45180368423461914,
0.1836763471364975,
-0.009302057325839996,
-0.4367549419403076,
0.13290145993232727,
0.21840576827526093,
-0.16777755320072174,
-0.025986548513174057,
0.4291721284389496,
0.16591881215572357,
0.05860625207424164,
0.27344658970832825,
0.1924883872270584,
-0.49801552295684814,
-0.09860866516828537,
0.011456782929599285,
-0.0688723474740982,
-0.21022777259349823,
-0.3626933693885803,
-0.6408944129943848,
0.5281702280044556,
0.515598714351654,
-0.07964903861284256,
0.7366610765457153,
0.3255900740623474,
-0.5488986372947693,
0.06612648069858551,
-0.38436129689216614,
0.07698420435190201,
-0.4130129814147949,
-0.10972850769758224,
-0.5027992129325867,
-0.32000792026519775,
0.9957392811775208,
-0.5512877702713013,
0.04322949796915054,
0.3215794563293457,
0.2901237905025482,
-0.5392294526100159,
1.2046709060668945,
0.14018353819847107,
0.30274254083633423,
0.26573121547698975,
-0.1800268292427063,
0.0259088221937418,
-1.0693469047546387,
-0.025082631036639214,
-0.2925429940223694,
-0.46680301427841187,
-0.5023952722549438,
-0.17366553843021393,
0.529309868812561,
0.3309125602245331,
-0.24880242347717285,
0.11075610667467117,
-0.7313469648361206,
0.2724479138851166,
0.7027508020401001,
0.5220721960067749,
0.3718055486679077,
-0.13081875443458557,
0.14597022533416748,
-0.10963785648345947,
-0.6733300685882568,
-0.743324339389801,
1.083957314491272,
0.14025458693504333,
0.5225265026092529,
0.2011048048734665,
0.6174907088279724,
0.4525112211704254,
0.4657860994338989,
-0.5474461317062378,
0.48408105969429016,
0.14748439192771912,
-0.40131497383117676,
-0.20267479121685028,
-0.34981459379196167,
-0.7079806327819824,
-0.13446131348609924,
-0.4622049927711487,
-0.7717472910881042,
0.2809203863143921,
0.7962505221366882,
-0.5498453378677368,
0.6846551895141602,
-0.7429358959197998,
0.5877914428710938,
0.15419630706310272,
-0.1844175010919571,
-0.15072433650493622,
-0.7754316329956055,
0.11346115916967392,
-0.15739302337169647,
0.315536230802536,
-0.009088750928640366,
-0.3232737183570862,
0.811733067035675,
-0.8528923392295837,
0.7766777276992798,
-0.15457244217395782,
0.3487308621406555,
0.5766282677650452,
0.30763858556747437,
0.787289023399353,
-0.13977034389972687,
-0.42006349563598633,
0.22812895476818085,
-0.13165976107120514,
-0.4383017122745514,
-1.1390005350112915,
0.4631648659706116,
-0.3572983145713806,
-0.2361202985048294,
-0.5367122888565063,
-0.6464738845825195,
-0.07251748442649841,
-0.04723901301622391,
-0.006584477610886097,
0.2834869623184204,
0.369155615568161,
-0.3354078531265259,
0.23102997243404388,
0.30193623900413513,
0.05361407250165939,
0.10345621407032013,
-0.08333487808704376,
-0.6865476965904236,
0.7764275074005127,
0.3358650505542755,
0.0021447287872433662,
-0.04157586023211479,
0.14829117059707642,
-0.07889809459447861,
-0.3618641197681427,
-0.9793102741241455,
-0.05461161583662033,
-0.9357156753540039,
-0.27147626876831055,
-0.48671039938926697,
0.23924168944358826,
-0.0368083156645298,
-0.38952213525772095,
-0.2698480784893036,
-0.8546003103256226,
-0.1895875781774521,
-0.018310680985450745,
1.168280005455017,
0.4857049584388733,
-0.3801479935646057,
0.47335782647132874,
-0.6210415363311768,
0.42599615454673767,
0.23856563866138458,
0.48173797130584717,
0.32358014583587646,
-0.2717757821083069,
-0.029892850667238235,
0.2319289892911911,
0.10666925460100174,
-0.8180615901947021,
-0.029647402465343475,
0.17142334580421448,
0.3791669011116028,
0.14026238024234772,
0.16765406727790833,
1.0194060802459717,
-0.4999779164791107,
0.45991596579551697,
-0.024242378771305084,
-0.9043551087379456,
0.6668742299079895,
-0.2320186197757721,
0.1801157146692276,
0.8470644354820251,
0.3411919176578522,
-0.3172614276409149,
-0.09236838668584824,
-0.81453537940979,
-0.8138441443443298,
0.5976741909980774,
0.4014348089694977,
-0.3027019202709198,
-0.021788055077195168,
0.6914102435112,
0.2411833554506302,
0.15787003934383392,
-0.41625821590423584,
-0.4231181740760803,
-0.06268143653869629,
-0.30558881163597107,
0.43697282671928406,
0.08682769536972046,
-0.05250675231218338,
-0.5652719736099243,
0.696256160736084,
-0.11976881325244904,
0.09000516682863235,
0.26529285311698914,
-0.0034789552446454763,
-0.19189509749412537,
-0.25127920508384705,
0.5463510751724243,
0.6696435809135437,
-0.2827720642089844,
0.09302022308111191,
0.6277248859405518,
-0.3859917223453522,
0.07815838605165482,
0.2858561873435974,
-0.3212842643260956,
0.1024273931980133,
0.46487072110176086,
0.6255179643630981,
-0.21606329083442688,
-0.7022077441215515,
0.1540982723236084,
0.09365770220756531,
0.13884077966213226,
-0.6328349113464355,
0.1865147054195404,
-0.040565092116594315,
0.2149507850408554,
0.21524536609649658,
0.4675716757774353,
0.45358845591545105,
-0.48637738823890686,
0.18987327814102173,
-0.06672491133213043,
-0.22534658014774323,
-0.011429817415773869,
0.8897311091423035,
0.16662660241127014,
-0.602273166179657,
0.459439754486084,
-0.33741044998168945,
-0.40282443165779114,
0.7471863627433777,
0.27491676807403564,
0.5111476182937622,
-0.21541589498519897,
-0.05402692034840584,
0.4152141809463501,
-0.018682215362787247,
0.13524606823921204,
0.2721042335033417,
-0.2635696530342102,
-0.3837693929672241,
-0.498423308134079,
-0.14208118617534637,
-0.7415093183517456,
-0.21729913353919983,
-0.6980298757553101,
0.4654881954193115,
-0.593754768371582,
-0.04355541244149208,
0.4024072587490082,
-0.3345431387424469,
-0.27707529067993164,
0.35950425267219543,
-0.1272263526916504,
0.9101552963256836,
-1.190796136856079,
0.6058832406997681,
1.18135666847229,
-0.727168083190918,
-0.5668210983276367,
-0.3148438334465027,
-0.05839914083480835,
-0.6101438999176025,
0.8150057792663574,
0.01589558646082878,
-0.0918683335185051,
-0.16888579726219177,
-0.5741007328033447,
-0.44803357124328613,
0.8914405107498169,
0.26463422179222107,
-0.3482133150100708,
0.2397754192352295,
0.039549410343170166,
0.7922816872596741,
-0.47512924671173096,
0.5123196840286255,
0.575812578201294,
0.49112367630004883,
0.2320082038640976,
-1.020918607711792,
0.02272520214319229,
-0.6388048529624939,
-0.017796067520976067,
0.46649834513664246,
-0.33311641216278076,
0.5684857964515686,
-0.09447412937879562,
0.20028568804264069,
0.1839105486869812,
0.7352970838546753,
0.5478591322898865,
0.5384904146194458,
0.9518444538116455,
0.813779354095459,
0.7420847415924072,
0.2499588429927826,
0.9431267380714417,
0.03002486377954483,
-0.20378826558589935,
1.320939064025879,
-0.31779906153678894,
0.7452378869056702,
0.4949386715888977,
0.0533052533864975,
0.7299700379371643,
0.7394402027130127,
0.1349470615386963,
0.5058963894844055,
0.0763619989156723,
-0.38980430364608765,
-0.25376275181770325,
-0.20793303847312927,
-0.12118950486183167,
0.3368687331676483,
0.49802136421203613,
0.03489293158054352,
-0.29700320959091187,
0.14177760481834412,
-0.0011755205923691392,
0.5422676801681519,
-0.30266714096069336,
0.8236408233642578,
-0.25564488768577576,
-0.40508949756622314,
0.4606603682041168,
-0.12475316971540451,
0.32710373401641846,
-0.07123133540153503,
-0.9942913055419922,
0.028001924976706505,
-0.22291983664035797,
-0.4236809313297272,
-0.8061921000480652,
0.571129322052002,
-0.027256952598690987,
-0.17025303840637207,
0.4061751961708069,
0.4077523350715637,
-0.18142861127853394,
-0.558288037776947,
-0.17657725512981415,
0.039861805737018585,
0.400003582239151,
0.025309015065431595,
-0.7173029780387878,
0.04630342870950699,
-0.15592335164546967,
0.1749885231256485,
-0.06604520976543427,
0.4468629062175751,
-0.665160059928894,
0.8762872219085693,
0.8302942514419556,
0.417451947927475,
-0.28721553087234497,
-0.1870720237493515,
0.9431071281433105,
-0.4039907157421112,
-0.8936771154403687,
-0.597671627998352,
0.5565932989120483,
-0.33718255162239075,
-0.3742350935935974,
0.3145810067653656,
0.3406199812889099,
0.5116102695465088,
0.16510926187038422,
0.6738425493240356,
-0.06363018602132797,
0.9132051467895508,
-0.4405418038368225,
0.508144736289978,
-0.38218724727630615,
0.38207948207855225,
-0.2941912114620209,
-0.9382452964782715,
-0.4883710443973541,
0.9818357229232788,
-0.6152307987213135,
0.11157170683145523,
0.3813600540161133,
0.6075573563575745,
-0.39970821142196655,
0.09193295240402222,
-0.2397998720407486,
-0.23951055109500885,
0.16522735357284546,
0.3936636447906494,
0.7668476104736328,
-0.6314693093299866,
0.2526974380016327,
-0.6558228135108948,
-0.41709017753601074,
-0.25046005845069885,
-1.0864341259002686,
-0.8362839221954346,
-0.6782211065292358,
-0.7174679636955261,
-0.3583770990371704,
0.19679905474185944,
1.0225812196731567,
0.8223715424537659,
-0.6882530450820923,
0.1569557785987854,
-0.2837550640106201,
-0.24700848758220673,
-0.38958099484443665,
-0.2122260481119156,
0.7858753800392151,
0.26730459928512573,
-0.6232838034629822,
-0.1300651580095291,
-0.042066071182489395,
0.08709030598402023,
0.14175531268119812,
-0.07191213220357895,
-0.3382933437824249,
0.02047334611415863,
0.10415568202733994,
0.5221343636512756,
-0.686107337474823,
-0.3773016333580017,
-0.7557249665260315,
0.18598173558712006,
0.2864569127559662,
0.25416848063468933,
-1.0751360654830933,
0.9281359314918518,
0.3024679720401764,
0.7625793218612671,
0.4380785822868347,
0.4471278488636017,
0.4003094434738159,
-0.43163883686065674,
0.6833536624908447,
0.3963466286659241,
0.041835565119981766,
0.2911081612110138,
-0.6380525827407837,
0.8948548436164856,
-0.03835989534854889,
-0.4070016145706177,
-0.849590003490448,
0.047288928180933,
-1.0694007873535156,
-0.014174076728522778,
0.6940793991088867,
-0.2806319296360016,
-0.4818907678127289,
-0.14398221671581268,
-0.6011395454406738,
0.31596532464027405,
-0.34062421321868896,
1.1774587631225586,
0.6158470511436462,
-0.6226363778114319,
-0.21738435328006744,
-0.6709655523300171,
0.4790310561656952,
0.5070394277572632,
-1.149839162826538,
-0.2632363736629486,
0.3828922212123871,
-0.10407042503356934,
0.44361791014671326,
0.22429020702838898,
0.008359999395906925,
0.7910100221633911,
0.1265133172273636,
0.2521921694278717,
-0.5952996015548706,
-0.13141754269599915,
-0.17073608934879303,
-0.3035328984260559,
0.18927182257175446,
-0.48510316014289856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11904v1
|
A Constraint-Enforcing Reward for Adversarial Attacks on Text Classifiers
| 2024-05-20T09:33:43 | 2024-05-20T09:33:43 |
Tom Roth, Inigo Jauregi Unanue, Alsharif Abuadbba, Massimo Piccardi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text classifiers are vulnerable to adversarial examples --
correctly-classified examples that are deliberately transformed to be
misclassified while satisfying acceptability constraints. The conventional
approach to finding adversarial examples is to define and solve a combinatorial
optimisation problem over a space of allowable transformations. While
effective, this approach is slow and limited by the choice of transformations.
An alternate approach is to directly generate adversarial examples by
fine-tuning a pre-trained language model, as is commonly done for other
text-to-text tasks. This approach promises to be much quicker and more
expressive, but is relatively unexplored. For this reason, in this work we
train an encoder-decoder paraphrase model to generate a diverse range of
adversarial examples. For training, we adopt a reinforcement learning algorithm
and propose a constraint-enforcing reward that promotes the generation of valid
adversarial examples. Experimental results over two text classification
datasets show that our model has achieved a higher success rate than the
original paraphrase model, and overall has proved more effective than other
competitive attacks. Finally, we show how key design choices impact the
generated examples and discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the proposed
approach.
|
[
-0.2698264718055725,
-0.6574215888977051,
0.4048614203929901,
-0.003975061699748039,
-0.3298218250274658,
-0.2336597591638565,
-0.16732919216156006,
-0.008751893416047096,
-0.156497061252594,
0.8227701187133789,
-0.47375723719596863,
-0.3098076581954956,
-0.9639175534248352,
0.25465211272239685,
-0.43577584624290466,
1.4447687864303589,
-0.24288079142570496,
-0.29176294803619385,
-0.17736099660396576,
-0.15021932125091553,
-0.2179391235113144,
-0.8629227876663208,
-0.5287382006645203,
-0.17404279112815857,
0.4425393342971802,
0.15300299227237701,
0.8835698366165161,
0.6876357793807983,
0.4793906509876251,
0.32894831895828247,
-0.19561420381069183,
0.275454044342041,
-0.4358900785446167,
0.013470089994370937,
-0.18784072995185852,
-0.6472371816635132,
0.30365076661109924,
0.23962172865867615,
0.36793267726898193,
0.17646311223506927,
-0.14165060222148895,
-0.39707276225090027,
0.15175151824951172,
0.3802250921726227,
-0.9465979337692261,
-0.01609920710325241,
-0.8078587651252747,
0.09882640093564987,
-0.18168142437934875,
-0.4176581799983978,
-0.6707983016967773,
-0.4481353163719177,
-0.02504635602235794,
-0.6705813407897949,
0.05814436078071594,
-0.13336575031280518,
1.0673469305038452,
0.46020519733428955,
-0.41844019293785095,
-0.7689212560653687,
-0.4851844012737274,
0.6296654939651489,
-0.5067525506019592,
-0.09311719238758087,
0.1541820764541626,
0.3615770936012268,
-0.3857405483722687,
-0.7833673357963562,
-0.3807065486907959,
-0.14014199376106262,
-0.31638872623443604,
0.012633196078240871,
-0.23089982569217682,
0.16181164979934692,
0.16352678835391998,
0.11817722022533417,
-0.6223370432853699,
-0.16663901507854462,
-0.21974270045757294,
-0.15480375289916992,
0.45646005868911743,
0.12724490463733673,
0.41691532731056213,
-0.10141822695732117,
-0.3951585292816162,
-0.40412965416908264,
-0.6450018286705017,
0.15690335631370544,
0.6593629121780396,
0.2351061850786209,
0.3304474353790283,
0.5375723838806152,
-0.0037958482280373573,
0.7346312403678894,
-0.034458011388778687,
0.19485916197299957,
-0.1827680766582489,
-0.11928810924291611,
0.00015243362577166408,
0.18790705502033234,
0.8776119351387024,
0.07417429238557816,
0.13692043721675873,
-0.4196905791759491,
-0.35766056180000305,
0.47127819061279297,
0.6620495915412903,
-0.9519627690315247,
-0.397276908159256,
-0.13642320036888123,
-0.3545052111148834,
-0.8930608034133911,
0.011641748249530792,
-0.7830455899238586,
-0.590956449508667,
0.14170780777931213,
0.6966343522071838,
-0.494769811630249,
0.15706239640712738,
0.427369624376297,
-0.5280848145484924,
-0.04486899450421333,
0.06757230311632156,
-0.9073631167411804,
0.3551194369792938,
0.6564905643463135,
0.5653846859931946,
-0.13434097170829773,
-0.5377156734466553,
-0.5918072462081909,
0.13938477635383606,
-0.27597200870513916,
0.545731246471405,
-0.5194061994552612,
-0.33784276247024536,
0.04933721944689751,
-0.12702833116054535,
-0.16295784711837769,
-0.4592817723751068,
0.8605448603630066,
-0.7329817414283752,
0.4205109179019928,
-0.0008674658602103591,
-0.5826241970062256,
-0.024677837267518044,
0.50252765417099,
-0.6435007452964783,
0.391435444355011,
0.04422108456492424,
-0.8691465258598328,
0.14574062824249268,
-0.5677152872085571,
-0.5512791275978088,
-0.0454847551882267,
-0.17964671552181244,
-0.6910925507545471,
-0.10004841536283493,
0.43485650420188904,
0.22638686001300812,
-0.3089916408061981,
0.11292562633752823,
-0.1839413046836853,
-0.3380676209926605,
0.4727570712566376,
-0.6249394416809082,
0.805103063583374,
0.3823281526565552,
-0.4915826916694641,
0.07018498331308365,
-0.4505070149898529,
-0.05415918678045273,
0.45777562260627747,
-0.30711764097213745,
-0.5382135510444641,
0.12811215221881866,
-0.021814553067088127,
0.22615686058998108,
0.2960413992404938,
-0.4290101230144501,
0.2567000985145569,
-0.6535472273826599,
0.5810901522636414,
0.7027149796485901,
0.29169049859046936,
0.4093659520149231,
-0.44335007667541504,
0.5874012112617493,
-0.06076608598232269,
0.30336588621139526,
0.11406853795051575,
-0.08297191560268402,
-0.48351937532424927,
-0.02174331806600094,
0.3935263156890869,
0.5929206013679504,
-1.2523841857910156,
0.22135846316814423,
-0.14719761908054352,
-0.5428864359855652,
-0.3849647045135498,
0.1805873066186905,
0.7469518780708313,
0.15280459821224213,
0.4004018306732178,
0.13236528635025024,
-0.3764374852180481,
-0.7361152768135071,
-0.6574862599372864,
-0.1274678111076355,
-0.043661054223775864,
0.18454448878765106,
0.6394702792167664,
-0.0921514630317688,
0.5191650390625,
-0.6407448053359985,
-0.17024128139019012,
-0.2930934429168701,
0.28846973180770874,
-0.16321252286434174,
0.5182904601097107,
0.5608013272285461,
-1.3372209072113037,
-0.238730788230896,
-0.2669335603713989,
-0.7146356105804443,
0.16005875170230865,
-0.5369846224784851,
-0.1837148517370224,
-0.15849938988685608,
0.6212738752365112,
-0.4475868046283722,
0.3606065809726715,
0.34160634875297546,
-0.415086954832077,
0.2707664370536804,
-0.23303304612636566,
0.17900210618972778,
-0.9322355389595032,
-0.30743637681007385,
-0.17462007701396942,
-0.2123371958732605,
-0.6326897144317627,
0.5063716769218445,
0.1745801568031311,
-0.48468658328056335,
-0.529789924621582,
0.1537095457315445,
0.032595984637737274,
0.5948052406311035,
-0.4351692497730255,
-0.0792665034532547,
0.08448189496994019,
0.6192435026168823,
0.1455804407596588,
0.587612509727478,
0.18691198527812958,
-0.6903257966041565,
0.2336903065443039,
0.4169459044933319,
-0.19253621995449066,
0.5617433190345764,
-0.719178318977356,
0.024043932557106018,
0.012840618379414082,
0.29275354743003845,
-0.5221759676933289,
-0.08899670839309692,
0.43783679604530334,
-0.5366203188896179,
0.3193553686141968,
0.024126067757606506,
-0.30337366461753845,
-0.23186157643795013,
-0.41546744108200073,
0.26202353835105896,
0.44619810581207275,
-0.9963359832763672,
0.4883163571357727,
0.23693028092384338,
0.1445654183626175,
-0.6614590287208557,
-0.49611130356788635,
0.29931846261024475,
-0.5418981313705444,
-0.22330926358699799,
0.7436598539352417,
-0.04797337204217911,
0.15251435339450836,
0.25396400690078735,
0.10882343351840973,
-0.039196427911520004,
0.49861279129981995,
0.10156185179948807,
-0.06501516699790955,
0.15137754380702972,
-0.2594108581542969,
-0.1666537970304489,
-0.0111464848741889,
0.2603956162929535,
-0.410123348236084,
0.3638174533843994,
-0.01896696910262108,
-0.19017235934734344,
-0.3654038906097412,
0.2679753005504608,
0.6788020730018616,
-0.19100520014762878,
0.7532583475112915,
0.2192767858505249,
-0.47259432077407837,
-0.5256043076515198,
-0.039151523262262344,
-0.01128208264708519,
-0.5730407238006592,
0.46667250990867615,
-0.5375534296035767,
-0.5051348805427551,
0.043453581631183624,
-0.04380297660827637,
0.08153432607650757,
0.3074634373188019,
0.22015368938446045,
0.2291804701089859,
1.234208106994629,
0.37372416257858276,
-0.15101556479930878,
0.5303664803504944,
-0.08258610963821411,
-0.08153923600912094,
-0.47957757115364075,
-0.2335590124130249,
-0.5988903641700745,
-0.06730800122022629,
-0.6154381036758423,
-0.11232704669237137,
0.17055362462997437,
0.19784283638000488,
-0.26126593351364136,
0.7655301690101624,
-0.6784536838531494,
0.49259400367736816,
0.6743049621582031,
0.487600713968277,
-0.3900412321090698,
-0.23027561604976654,
-0.07150272279977798,
-0.024845287203788757,
-0.8339484333992004,
-0.4073896110057831,
1.0737632513046265,
0.006634014658629894,
0.8795081377029419,
0.271585613489151,
0.9619046449661255,
0.40405896306037903,
0.10604699701070786,
-0.4061407148838043,
0.4362238645553589,
-0.5075417160987854,
-0.4376477003097534,
-0.27144092321395874,
-0.5500550270080566,
-0.9895774722099304,
0.06979218125343323,
-0.16899457573890686,
-0.31074634194374084,
0.14209195971488953,
0.19793155789375305,
-0.08955645561218262,
0.4544858932495117,
-0.4563242197036743,
1.241337537765503,
-0.28792062401771545,
-0.29962238669395447,
-0.034055087715387344,
-0.4343413710594177,
0.24965861439704895,
0.051737040281295776,
-0.04706195369362831,
0.5662117600440979,
0.15440480411052704,
0.7211588621139526,
-0.5626314878463745,
0.6054937839508057,
-0.27355703711509705,
0.10582306981086731,
0.3105953633785248,
0.16180622577667236,
0.9757711887359619,
-0.15556700527668,
0.004769844934344292,
-0.418624609708786,
-0.08734174072742462,
-0.5976649522781372,
-0.9537863731384277,
0.45625439286231995,
-0.8126555681228638,
-0.7273568511009216,
-0.4836786985397339,
-0.4441988468170166,
-0.10293704271316528,
-0.16813983023166656,
0.6735057234764099,
0.3982405960559845,
-0.35356631875038147,
0.37614312767982483,
0.820044219493866,
-0.42777612805366516,
0.23251695930957794,
0.28468409180641174,
0.40471792221069336,
-0.5735162496566772,
1.3928742408752441,
-0.15379668772220612,
0.3654993772506714,
0.7082117199897766,
0.20233546197414398,
-0.3950347900390625,
-0.7652220726013184,
-0.5048274993896484,
-0.2956313490867615,
-0.7488397359848022,
-0.22357410192489624,
-0.5116909146308899,
-0.3369995355606079,
-0.5257583260536194,
-0.5421938300132751,
-0.18550920486450195,
-0.40812867879867554,
-0.3319474160671234,
0.23906730115413666,
0.14312726259231567,
0.6296175718307495,
0.16264984011650085,
0.4393405020236969,
-0.5157506465911865,
0.31785842776298523,
0.6360993385314941,
-0.08216066658496857,
-0.2989272177219391,
-0.5594640374183655,
-0.17929023504257202,
-0.07213468104600906,
-0.6082361936569214,
-0.9579611420631409,
0.5396237969398499,
0.04279717803001404,
0.5102848410606384,
0.22137367725372314,
0.4768126308917999,
0.29006150364875793,
-0.5268715023994446,
0.6572599411010742,
0.06473639607429504,
-0.8673779368400574,
0.6123791337013245,
-0.11793442070484161,
0.05058194324374199,
0.6329706311225891,
0.4080532491207123,
-0.35965994000434875,
-0.6307398676872253,
-0.8184903860092163,
-0.6608033180236816,
0.609843909740448,
0.47158515453338623,
-0.07320081442594528,
-0.006812617182731628,
0.48794275522232056,
-0.19530212879180908,
0.16817361116409302,
-0.9796591401100159,
-0.08323507010936737,
-0.5513790845870972,
-0.5351946949958801,
-0.33269280195236206,
-0.21397912502288818,
-0.26037201285362244,
0.28182607889175415,
0.7742812633514404,
0.0813886821269989,
0.011681713163852692,
0.04274722933769226,
-0.40977832674980164,
0.5162171721458435,
0.5268785953521729,
0.5587582588195801,
-0.12637746334075928,
-0.04144686087965965,
0.33737680315971375,
0.17508256435394287,
-0.3063415586948395,
0.4870757460594177,
0.47445404529571533,
-0.5460322499275208,
-0.11532291024923325,
0.17990845441818237,
0.8554778099060059,
0.1632194221019745,
-0.5819821357727051,
0.7427271604537964,
-0.34632250666618347,
-0.42412444949150085,
-0.14031687378883362,
0.16370144486427307,
-0.2769906222820282,
0.2128501534461975,
-0.019409645348787308,
0.1135709285736084,
0.31393858790397644,
-0.17713519930839539,
0.3030984401702881,
0.5633135437965393,
-0.5947967171669006,
-0.004396624863147736,
0.8869585394859314,
0.1501455157995224,
-0.4566570222377777,
0.24546273052692413,
-0.4967748522758484,
-1.0930784940719604,
0.723274827003479,
0.6850059628486633,
0.7832911014556885,
-0.14417295157909393,
0.329591304063797,
-0.03761504963040352,
0.5993815660476685,
-0.3009890019893646,
-0.09980639070272446,
-0.12597402930259705,
-0.5891953706741333,
0.2848736345767975,
-0.5383976697921753,
-0.5646831393241882,
0.2175111174583435,
-0.737185001373291,
0.2797783315181732,
-0.41179442405700684,
0.19026866555213928,
0.17291098833084106,
-0.1767822653055191,
-0.3647274672985077,
0.3595239520072937,
0.041038453578948975,
0.510643720626831,
-0.8282154202461243,
0.7071442604064941,
0.587385356426239,
-0.43379735946655273,
-0.41182827949523926,
0.1364143341779709,
-0.10369227081537247,
-0.5067739486694336,
0.5884673595428467,
0.17205478250980377,
-0.06475363671779633,
-0.16828066110610962,
-0.29159143567085266,
-0.32146379351615906,
0.624376654624939,
0.36386236548423767,
-0.27176856994628906,
-0.14909178018569946,
0.26855671405792236,
0.4090602993965149,
-0.11623644083738327,
-0.06925886869430542,
0.38387906551361084,
0.22346501052379608,
-0.2520136535167694,
-0.23615208268165588,
0.27107328176498413,
-0.3756600320339203,
0.04069574549794197,
0.4754948318004608,
-0.4721258878707886,
0.8794482350349426,
0.10104917734861374,
-0.2215595543384552,
0.09954974800348282,
0.5565412640571594,
0.058588143438100815,
0.23845231533050537,
0.7167962789535522,
0.6334036588668823,
0.4260261058807373,
0.043369684368371964,
1.2301840782165527,
-0.2564670741558075,
0.12143199890851974,
1.105674386024475,
-0.07963205873966217,
0.6925061345100403,
0.34615853428840637,
0.0860905572772026,
0.3883880376815796,
0.48683810234069824,
-0.11933250725269318,
0.9983529448509216,
0.4574257433414459,
-0.3459275960922241,
-0.29503703117370605,
-0.06701600551605225,
-0.1821422427892685,
0.34447434544563293,
0.3239228427410126,
-0.4801386594772339,
-0.2707546055316925,
0.35149917006492615,
-0.024667322635650635,
0.6115226745605469,
-0.24353517591953278,
0.7038125991821289,
-0.2027522623538971,
-0.8338720202445984,
0.7796966433525085,
0.25466442108154297,
0.8064354658126831,
-0.7647988200187683,
0.09819689393043518,
0.24489444494247437,
0.4928841292858124,
0.12882696092128754,
-0.4207344353199005,
0.1637864112854004,
0.10662965476512909,
-0.027411960065364838,
-0.39863088726997375,
0.5588957071304321,
-0.4075617790222168,
-0.3113841712474823,
0.13385498523712158,
-0.2083464115858078,
-0.1287769079208374,
-0.18486960232257843,
-0.7271393537521362,
-0.33074989914894104,
0.15323856472969055,
-0.2515610158443451,
0.45822572708129883,
0.5964951515197754,
0.143906369805336,
0.43120884895324707,
0.3723925054073334,
0.061401963233947754,
-0.14266373217105865,
-0.31574684381484985,
0.9199404716491699,
-0.5197798013687134,
-0.7415974140167236,
-1.0789589881896973,
-0.000573633355088532,
-0.2559982240200043,
-0.3969780206680298,
0.803289532661438,
0.6489670872688293,
0.8912211060523987,
0.054181650280952454,
0.930091381072998,
0.19846761226654053,
0.15154284238815308,
-0.6575324535369873,
0.7114265561103821,
-0.564635157585144,
0.23175598680973053,
-0.2121555060148239,
-0.1680833399295807,
-0.228541299700737,
0.43462634086608887,
-0.22440758347511292,
-0.3708931803703308,
0.781273603439331,
0.7755618095397949,
0.1632826179265976,
0.06280200928449631,
0.22742456197738647,
-0.2395416498184204,
0.5755577087402344,
1.1024353504180908,
0.9857130646705627,
-0.6090792417526245,
1.3628593683242798,
-0.3879835903644562,
-0.13518795371055603,
-0.036203641444444656,
-0.7156758904457092,
-1.1446527242660522,
-0.41859757900238037,
-0.34416478872299194,
-0.7785604000091553,
0.5272188186645508,
0.6298795342445374,
0.3727094233036041,
-0.7737584114074707,
0.08155011385679245,
-0.5736042261123657,
0.17511965334415436,
-0.30537915229797363,
-0.19059908390045166,
0.3857864439487457,
-0.5286241769790649,
-0.7212765216827393,
0.4337405264377594,
-0.10616133362054825,
0.28703585267066956,
0.07204681634902954,
-0.142446830868721,
-0.048825863748788834,
0.2895675599575043,
0.11731399595737457,
0.4971620440483093,
-0.28070759773254395,
-0.20310404896736145,
-0.17339614033699036,
-0.3398398458957672,
-0.3159160017967224,
1.011251449584961,
-0.5778492093086243,
0.30705100297927856,
0.2726943790912628,
1.3240231275558472,
0.3925703763961792,
0.0013488500844687223,
0.625471830368042,
-0.7015058398246765,
0.30556225776672363,
0.4220533072948456,
0.2590518891811371,
0.1251314878463745,
-0.496692031621933,
0.2480812668800354,
0.15529364347457886,
-0.4824073910713196,
-1.0346355438232422,
0.4114576280117035,
-0.33597540855407715,
-0.8465155959129333,
1.0279130935668945,
-0.5120859146118164,
-0.28536561131477356,
0.12160226702690125,
-0.10894676297903061,
0.2581470310688019,
-0.036965735256671906,
1.011983036994934,
0.6893171668052673,
0.3790997862815857,
0.2713867425918579,
-0.23959948122501373,
0.8712826371192932,
0.5894656181335449,
-0.9047139286994934,
0.20683947205543518,
0.12228180468082428,
0.05792340636253357,
0.03363810107111931,
0.11246486008167267,
-0.06544041633605957,
0.45169797539711,
0.278809130191803,
-0.13720226287841797,
-0.23637597262859344,
-0.44519031047821045,
-0.552920401096344,
0.4732484817504883,
-0.002131727756932378,
-0.49396464228630066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11897v1
|
CReMa: Crisis Response through Computational Identification and Matching of Cross-Lingual Requests and Offers Shared on Social Media
| 2024-05-20T09:30:03 | 2024-05-20T09:30:03 |
Rabindra Lamsal, Maria Rodriguez Read, Shanika Karunasekera, Muhammad Imran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
During times of crisis, social media platforms play a vital role in
facilitating communication and coordinating resources. Amidst chaos and
uncertainty, communities often rely on these platforms to share urgent pleas
for help, extend support, and organize relief efforts. However, the sheer
volume of conversations during such periods, which can escalate to
unprecedented levels, necessitates the automated identification and matching of
requests and offers to streamline relief operations. This study addresses the
challenge of efficiently identifying and matching assistance requests and
offers on social media platforms during emergencies. We propose CReMa (Crisis
Response Matcher), a systematic approach that integrates textual, temporal, and
spatial features for multi-lingual request-offer matching. By leveraging
CrisisTransformers, a set of pre-trained models specific to crises, and a
cross-lingual embedding space, our methodology enhances the identification and
matching tasks while outperforming strong baselines such as RoBERTa, MPNet, and
BERTweet, in classification tasks, and Universal Sentence Encoder, Sentence
Transformers in crisis embeddings generation tasks. We introduce a novel
multi-lingual dataset that simulates scenarios of help-seeking and offering
assistance on social media across the 16 most commonly used languages in
Australia. We conduct comprehensive cross-lingual experiments across these 16
languages, also while examining trade-offs between multiple vector search
strategies and accuracy. Additionally, we analyze a million-scale geotagged
global dataset to comprehend patterns in relation to seeking help and offering
assistance on social media. Overall, these contributions advance the field of
crisis informatics and provide benchmarks for future research in the area.
|
[
-0.14966146647930145,
-0.7354838848114014,
0.2563663721084595,
0.863159716129303,
-0.23306900262832642,
0.4816446602344513,
-0.28685086965560913,
-0.3426075875759125,
0.6348427534103394,
0.24359065294265747,
-0.6643354296684265,
-0.4263671934604645,
-0.7701566219329834,
0.31216877698898315,
-0.6478344202041626,
0.6836905479431152,
-0.36126548051834106,
0.006280259229242802,
0.14335128664970398,
-0.06885191053152084,
-0.4659382998943329,
-0.2878429591655731,
-0.9874124526977539,
0.2520189881324768,
0.8214184641838074,
0.7303112745285034,
0.6529915928840637,
0.38003236055374146,
0.6757134199142456,
0.44045108556747437,
0.41829612851142883,
0.15420383214950562,
-0.7699770927429199,
0.05115172266960144,
-0.17290709912776947,
0.011006888002157211,
0.05822509527206421,
-0.5625044107437134,
0.3130296468734741,
0.23393718898296356,
-0.5105950832366943,
0.327007532119751,
0.08962400257587433,
0.4231084883213043,
-0.7507341504096985,
0.12233186513185501,
-0.6626810431480408,
0.07074286043643951,
-0.004569258540868759,
-0.5592936277389526,
0.07362385839223862,
-0.5262554883956909,
0.1719963401556015,
-0.8126028180122375,
0.639156699180603,
0.07904702425003052,
0.6994279623031616,
0.2739940285682678,
-0.24753987789154053,
-0.7259724140167236,
-0.9065523743629456,
0.4044440984725952,
-0.230024516582489,
0.3183857500553131,
0.4132617115974426,
0.5310124158859253,
-0.1066555455327034,
-0.5850455164909363,
-0.4449945390224457,
0.6197335720062256,
-0.08705855160951614,
-0.0165532398968935,
-0.3269347846508026,
-0.2201455980539322,
-0.08554934710264206,
0.051141705363988876,
-0.7236433029174805,
-0.21928927302360535,
-0.4625665247440338,
-0.43391862511634827,
0.6359721422195435,
0.32784557342529297,
0.8666035532951355,
-0.27820929884910583,
-0.5009583830833435,
-0.14845110476016998,
-0.2504168748855591,
-0.030974894762039185,
0.15456941723823547,
0.6857441067695618,
-0.6723961234092712,
0.5768563151359558,
-0.23719654977321625,
0.22314231097698212,
-0.21044807136058807,
-0.06603634357452393,
0.044010113924741745,
-0.5235700607299805,
-0.3178698718547821,
0.3581514060497284,
1.0105211734771729,
0.6569998860359192,
0.4642166793346405,
0.33232009410858154,
0.04529009014368057,
0.13882192969322205,
0.4600929915904999,
-0.8189891576766968,
-0.09367315471172333,
0.13401615619659424,
-0.2785785496234894,
-0.05353511497378349,
-0.028951602056622505,
-1.060144305229187,
-0.6237193942070007,
0.02218237891793251,
0.0221023578196764,
-0.43995392322540283,
-0.39131608605384827,
0.3207695484161377,
-0.3006233870983124,
0.14255252480506897,
0.1831478625535965,
-0.5041902661323547,
0.1696510910987854,
0.48717001080513,
1.0253722667694092,
0.4090110659599304,
-0.05769439786672592,
-0.2649811804294586,
0.0859522596001625,
-0.1341693103313446,
1.0532833337783813,
-0.6732677221298218,
-0.3999936282634735,
0.7016646265983582,
0.3118516802787781,
-0.17584110796451569,
-0.43420547246932983,
0.8501752018928528,
-0.5303412675857544,
-0.09335866570472717,
-0.5856041312217712,
0.06911429017782211,
-0.24929334223270416,
0.13396814465522766,
-0.6890567541122437,
1.0838998556137085,
0.1763952076435089,
-0.8133086562156677,
0.38230547308921814,
-0.519379734992981,
-0.5964789390563965,
0.28117191791534424,
0.09343890100717545,
-0.3779992461204529,
0.01421028096228838,
0.4626840054988861,
0.5533103942871094,
-0.5973426103591919,
-0.1015094444155693,
-0.6180479526519775,
-0.17920942604541779,
0.1519380658864975,
-0.11833909153938293,
0.43469101190567017,
0.05244670808315277,
-0.17330490052700043,
0.11335352808237076,
-0.5202258229255676,
-0.03151876851916313,
0.6409091353416443,
-0.17625363171100616,
-0.5264981389045715,
0.05180783569812775,
0.6611121892929077,
0.28915640711784363,
0.11158207803964615,
-0.32898280024528503,
-0.07539267092943192,
-0.20383092761039734,
0.6253790855407715,
0.19902187585830688,
0.20440810918807983,
0.4004962146282196,
-0.40940847992897034,
0.6408843994140625,
-0.0051392908208072186,
0.0975673645734787,
-0.12729163467884064,
-0.35546350479125977,
-0.4993584454059601,
-0.38181206583976746,
0.04150208830833435,
1.0465049743652344,
-0.8377955555915833,
-0.05086783692240715,
-0.13847847282886505,
-0.4753642976284027,
-0.8999719619750977,
0.06252623349428177,
0.2573131322860718,
0.30986839532852173,
0.6299515962600708,
0.023228399455547333,
-0.9734379649162292,
-1.1565563678741455,
-0.2646321654319763,
-0.010489040054380894,
-0.1979735791683197,
0.4209717810153961,
-0.14986513555049896,
-0.19464175403118134,
0.5614516735076904,
-0.15704971551895142,
-0.29109489917755127,
-0.6016906499862671,
0.007310838904231787,
-0.3174194097518921,
-0.1270461529493332,
0.6810603737831116,
-1.133226990699768,
-0.6382641792297363,
0.13214647769927979,
-0.551213800907135,
-0.47697022557258606,
-0.1706816554069519,
-0.21765300631523132,
0.08727402240037918,
0.022205427289009094,
-0.22364479303359985,
0.40473878383636475,
0.5431898832321167,
-0.2008054256439209,
0.0021302499808371067,
-0.06415258347988129,
0.8040474057197571,
-1.4149317741394043,
-0.03464929014444351,
0.29186171293258667,
-0.12739132344722748,
-0.7416427731513977,
-0.32559090852737427,
0.2220628559589386,
-0.41885101795196533,
-0.5606842637062073,
0.6080660820007324,
-0.5276355743408203,
-0.022466009482741356,
-0.12556234002113342,
0.5342228412628174,
-0.2966122627258301,
-0.07207510620355606,
-0.022190535441040993,
0.5163302421569824,
0.6670143604278564,
-0.240430548787117,
0.24309545755386353,
0.48824620246887207,
-0.3139908015727997,
0.5880287289619446,
-0.6574682593345642,
-0.07709991186857224,
-0.21913960576057434,
0.34878358244895935,
-1.2745168209075928,
-0.530119776725769,
0.5919538140296936,
-0.2849901020526886,
-0.26923707127571106,
-0.350832998752594,
-0.30676358938217163,
-0.5364283323287964,
0.003526575630530715,
0.6580132842063904,
0.10153421014547348,
-0.046906955540180206,
0.8282312154769897,
0.530990481376648,
-0.738825798034668,
-0.6643038392066956,
-0.4832957684993744,
0.18177646398544312,
-0.4104204773902893,
-0.5358604192733765,
0.16391950845718384,
-0.007281716447323561,
-0.16681964695453644,
-0.10796411335468292,
0.08603546023368835,
-0.332012802362442,
0.07539863884449005,
0.5492914915084839,
0.22389641404151917,
0.007538775447756052,
-0.23294226825237274,
0.08665440231561661,
-0.06799951195716858,
-0.10314230620861053,
0.098747618496418,
0.9594341516494751,
0.21071481704711914,
-0.279435396194458,
-0.5007266998291016,
0.9222580194473267,
0.5902779698371887,
-0.1548669934272766,
0.5722124576568604,
0.6355987787246704,
-0.7028743028640747,
0.04909607023000717,
-0.58433598279953,
0.051116570830345154,
-0.5168735980987549,
0.17451496422290802,
0.061687812209129333,
-0.537251889705658,
0.7446392774581909,
0.06784825026988983,
0.07487785071134567,
0.08971850574016571,
0.8949060440063477,
0.14634864032268524,
0.6687570214271545,
0.5688570141792297,
-0.41145363450050354,
0.41093283891677856,
-0.023612864315509796,
0.61094731092453,
-0.028595978394150734,
-0.22835732996463776,
-0.6929423809051514,
-0.47621554136276245,
-0.20229752361774445,
-0.43009305000305176,
0.40146827697753906,
-0.11840897798538208,
0.17460988461971283,
0.5923123359680176,
-0.39178428053855896,
0.24237802624702454,
0.11137888580560684,
-0.02397121861577034,
-0.017904553562402725,
0.08807981759309769,
0.29964345693588257,
0.03576366603374481,
-0.9123213887214661,
-0.36872807145118713,
0.24365131556987762,
-0.04762265831232071,
0.5618486404418945,
0.014232976362109184,
0.49538281559944153,
0.4377557039260864,
0.42652627825737,
-0.7247217297554016,
0.4196072518825531,
0.34028488397598267,
-0.3923663794994354,
-0.06260635703802109,
-0.46074041724205017,
-1.133415699005127,
0.001206515240482986,
-0.6100567579269409,
-0.3166396915912628,
0.04907083883881569,
0.06026555225253105,
-0.6022002100944519,
0.024093208834528923,
-0.5776313543319702,
0.566758930683136,
-0.057455409318208694,
0.21113614737987518,
-0.3661078214645386,
-0.624675989151001,
0.03634444624185562,
-0.14235995709896088,
0.8118836879730225,
-0.2233254611492157,
-0.07424501329660416,
0.25278687477111816,
-0.13031025230884552,
0.9474750757217407,
0.1259593367576599,
-0.08253538608551025,
0.22397519648075104,
0.26646074652671814,
0.23369361460208893,
0.2495424896478653,
0.11720570921897888,
0.23642875254154205,
0.08896218985319138,
-0.5244868397712708,
-0.42543911933898926,
0.6696504354476929,
-0.5488186478614807,
-0.132357656955719,
0.02688957005739212,
-0.7589697241783142,
0.07749180495738983,
0.23500381410121918,
0.3438222110271454,
0.7369711995124817,
-0.34985780715942383,
-0.27349841594696045,
0.1450817883014679,
-0.2925526797771454,
0.6643186807632446,
0.5100899338722229,
0.11274005472660065,
-0.6253342628479004,
0.7989179491996765,
-0.047171998769044876,
-0.11283386498689651,
0.3819120228290558,
0.10209974646568298,
-0.20081786811351776,
-0.13977175951004028,
-0.512281060218811,
0.3137745261192322,
-0.5631394386291504,
-0.5781509876251221,
-0.9061816334724426,
-0.09877198189496994,
-0.441196084022522,
-0.5926527380943298,
-0.3184936046600342,
-0.06528792530298233,
0.04066787660121918,
0.047289736568927765,
0.43762755393981934,
0.6592491269111633,
-0.17416030168533325,
0.0589374341070652,
-1.1026633977890015,
0.3370808959007263,
-0.4131656885147095,
0.050987403839826584,
-0.16172555088996887,
-0.0245857872068882,
-0.2557404637336731,
0.1846054345369339,
0.15252244472503662,
-1.0835387706756592,
0.4429680109024048,
0.33791711926460266,
0.07734628766775131,
0.45704787969589233,
0.4514126777648926,
0.8590924143791199,
-0.8762161135673523,
0.5340122580528259,
0.12424300611019135,
-0.5480511784553528,
0.3884749710559845,
-0.402752161026001,
-0.15786339342594147,
0.5580902695655823,
1.0023233890533447,
-1.0263876914978027,
-0.38512977957725525,
-0.5128418207168579,
-1.1081353425979614,
0.21802480518817902,
0.11177131533622742,
0.383868008852005,
-0.34052783250808716,
0.1864684373140335,
-0.23325884342193604,
0.10312402993440628,
0.009091154672205448,
-0.12338925898075104,
-0.04281849414110184,
-0.3781035840511322,
0.19150571525096893,
-0.1503651738166809,
-0.473325252532959,
0.21202845871448517,
0.3995397686958313,
-0.08830714970827103,
0.22906766831874847,
0.31273704767227173,
-0.05943049490451813,
-0.42646360397338867,
0.1523684710264206,
0.617836058139801,
0.3758283257484436,
0.45575734972953796,
-0.1918756067752838,
0.22525310516357422,
-0.37539204955101013,
0.01381733175367117,
0.3234252631664276,
0.1863986849784851,
0.12702421844005585,
0.43714794516563416,
0.408982515335083,
0.7168129682540894,
-0.9511407017707825,
0.5121884346008301,
-0.5313157439231873,
-0.10621602833271027,
-0.4879474341869354,
-0.13276199996471405,
0.09147773683071136,
0.5015441179275513,
0.5010031461715698,
-0.2615382969379425,
0.2779030501842499,
-0.47918906807899475,
0.12761324644088745,
0.45379358530044556,
-0.2003473937511444,
-0.3904046416282654,
0.30238065123558044,
0.13646458089351654,
-1.0520886182785034,
0.2481725662946701,
0.1663583666086197,
-0.661264181137085,
0.48377832770347595,
0.5026717185974121,
0.7584416270256042,
-0.6953672170639038,
0.5208619236946106,
0.3569742441177368,
0.12474309653043747,
-0.11377350240945816,
0.5014074444770813,
0.17474500834941864,
-0.691827654838562,
-0.06493249535560608,
-0.4094310402870178,
-0.22028063237667084,
-0.03340582549571991,
-0.8805252313613892,
0.5802313089370728,
-0.5342910289764404,
0.015230320394039154,
-0.0034749815240502357,
-0.426149845123291,
-0.9621217250823975,
-0.05089518427848816,
0.12762942910194397,
0.9748685956001282,
-1.0211795568466187,
0.05454712361097336,
0.8103814721107483,
-0.03357191011309624,
-1.0159282684326172,
0.08161385357379913,
0.24384115636348724,
-0.8764686584472656,
-0.0532691590487957,
0.19508808851242065,
0.015348024666309357,
-0.21317999064922333,
-0.2647634446620941,
-0.8910098671913147,
0.7435669302940369,
0.2810024917125702,
-0.597027063369751,
-0.18384206295013428,
0.5018606185913086,
0.47105973958969116,
-0.3911161720752716,
0.3691072165966034,
0.4575105905532837,
0.4325001835823059,
0.001547962543554604,
-1.0387572050094604,
0.27745869755744934,
-0.30893823504447937,
-0.216513991355896,
0.5502983927726746,
-0.7433186173439026,
0.19809560477733612,
-0.24380172789096832,
-0.7666290998458862,
0.019896509125828743,
0.3148779273033142,
-0.03530379757285118,
0.4562999904155731,
0.6875672340393066,
0.2758019268512726,
0.6077128052711487,
-0.09858336299657822,
1.043026328086853,
-0.6340710520744324,
0.4451085031032562,
0.5496350526809692,
-0.32689806818962097,
0.7086076140403748,
0.15542660653591156,
0.3177121877670288,
0.4498860538005829,
0.827646017074585,
0.3553417921066284,
0.4922504425048828,
0.07866005599498749,
-0.2993702292442322,
-0.3224344551563263,
-0.256354957818985,
-0.2504954934120178,
0.19419968128204346,
0.6770114302635193,
-0.24576091766357422,
-0.7027063369750977,
0.20423147082328796,
-0.10633117705583572,
0.05697842687368393,
-0.10347945988178253,
0.7648533582687378,
-0.0455961599946022,
-0.18442927300930023,
0.6179935336112976,
-0.10372214019298553,
0.18177612125873566,
-0.4632802903652191,
-0.06129281222820282,
-0.14021460711956024,
-0.12548036873340607,
-0.23332922160625458,
-0.5174939632415771,
0.5709530711174011,
-0.18424685299396515,
-0.2632909119129181,
0.08868055790662766,
0.8461585640907288,
-0.6585246920585632,
-0.7017313241958618,
0.7133872509002686,
0.5426523089408875,
-0.11385742574930191,
0.005027390085160732,
-0.975580632686615,
0.37984010577201843,
-0.40279170870780945,
0.040045615285634995,
0.18130776286125183,
0.7926368117332458,
-0.10504738241434097,
0.7433554530143738,
0.5585632920265198,
0.08702372759580612,
-0.1600201427936554,
0.16712211072444916,
0.9071066975593567,
-0.43136972188949585,
-0.4314647316932678,
-0.7647368311882019,
0.3200218975543976,
-0.056460704654455185,
-0.2853258550167084,
0.552903950214386,
0.4626649022102356,
0.6611356735229492,
0.13615761697292328,
1.0054785013198853,
-0.3138931095600128,
0.5982315540313721,
-0.15911215543746948,
0.42628735303878784,
-0.6559567451477051,
-0.1169518232345581,
-0.4962072968482971,
-0.5692387819290161,
-0.22168640792369843,
0.4601004123687744,
-0.17222988605499268,
-0.38099583983421326,
0.36854425072669983,
0.9479826092720032,
-0.35241419076919556,
0.03522519767284393,
-0.09818830341100693,
-0.11486370861530304,
0.1489451676607132,
0.42146626114845276,
0.7898967862129211,
-0.29115384817123413,
0.7050868272781372,
-0.11426066607236862,
-0.3203132748603821,
-0.47487324476242065,
-0.6917879581451416,
-1.006614327430725,
-0.8642063140869141,
0.053689226508140564,
-0.5348566174507141,
0.06528552621603012,
1.2920722961425781,
0.3884319067001343,
-0.6372527480125427,
0.014278403483331203,
0.46357461810112,
0.03744708374142647,
-0.23299580812454224,
-0.20707663893699646,
0.07149451971054077,
-0.01614508591592312,
-0.5986500978469849,
0.521759033203125,
0.4114569425582886,
-0.20866632461547852,
-0.1933877170085907,
0.4924341142177582,
0.046371202915906906,
0.500432550907135,
0.42144569754600525,
0.3583422303199768,
-0.4445367753505707,
-0.3179631531238556,
0.22503527998924255,
-0.15419475734233856,
-0.0006005650502629578,
1.4239696264266968,
-0.33048009872436523,
-0.1254355013370514,
0.4037629961967468,
1.1682146787643433,
-0.03179960697889328,
0.1838269829750061,
0.64723140001297,
-0.651755154132843,
0.2614108920097351,
0.08959770202636719,
0.589093029499054,
0.8371196985244751,
-0.7148183584213257,
0.37776273488998413,
0.18886804580688477,
-0.4217173755168915,
-0.7705680131912231,
0.1315923035144806,
-0.85024094581604,
0.07955144345760345,
1.3249489068984985,
0.03637096285820007,
-0.2247532308101654,
-0.4521752893924713,
-0.43378445506095886,
0.41914305090904236,
-0.7087281346321106,
1.2304152250289917,
0.6051352620124817,
0.4088551998138428,
-0.21794632077217102,
-0.5065761804580688,
0.35278376936912537,
0.2407297044992447,
-0.6892961263656616,
0.24663113057613373,
0.21352802217006683,
0.5229343175888062,
0.3397983908653259,
0.7218658328056335,
0.23978686332702637,
0.20124663412570953,
-0.5501835942268372,
-0.0836932361125946,
0.3723278343677521,
-0.4572187066078186,
-0.05081029236316681,
0.3336346447467804,
-0.7402799725532532,
0.16251659393310547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11891v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11891v1
|
Unveiling and Manipulating Prompt Influence in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-20T09:15:36 | 2024-05-20T09:15:36 |
Zijian Feng, Hanzhang Zhou, Zixiao Zhu, Junlang Qian, Kezhi Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Prompts play a crucial role in guiding the responses of Large Language Models
(LLMs). However, the intricate role of individual tokens in prompts, known as
input saliency, in shaping the responses remains largely underexplored.
Existing saliency methods either misalign with LLM generation objectives or
rely heavily on linearity assumptions, leading to potential inaccuracies. To
address this, we propose Token Distribution Dynamics (TDD), a
\textcolor{black}{simple yet effective} approach to unveil and manipulate the
role of prompts in generating LLM outputs. TDD leverages the robust
interpreting capabilities of the language model head (LM head) to assess input
saliency. It projects input tokens into the embedding space and then estimates
their significance based on distribution dynamics over the vocabulary. We
introduce three TDD variants: forward, backward, and bidirectional, each
offering unique insights into token relevance. Extensive experiments reveal
that the TDD surpasses state-of-the-art baselines with a big margin in
elucidating the causal relationships between prompts and LLM outputs. Beyond
mere interpretation, we apply TDD to two prompt manipulation tasks for
controlled text generation: zero-shot toxic language suppression and sentiment
steering. Empirical results underscore TDD's proficiency in identifying both
toxic and sentimental cues in prompts, subsequently mitigating toxicity or
modulating sentiment in the generated content.
|
[
-0.25160250067710876,
-0.9273490905761719,
0.7142093181610107,
0.37695029377937317,
-0.5826582312583923,
-0.019318534061312675,
-0.3714403808116913,
-0.09680246561765671,
0.18031299114227295,
0.3166375160217285,
-0.534817099571228,
-0.5962367653846741,
-0.5786684155464172,
0.04248509183526039,
-0.24170514941215515,
1.2241569757461548,
0.1772545725107193,
-0.1226392611861229,
-0.038195136934518814,
-0.027002889662981033,
-0.6007379293441772,
-0.5714177489280701,
-0.7313632965087891,
-0.16346614062786102,
1.1622545719146729,
0.23900096118450165,
0.7427852749824524,
0.6097058057785034,
0.27631834149360657,
0.2259344607591629,
-0.542840838432312,
-0.2423112988471985,
-0.4294918179512024,
0.6295536160469055,
-0.3101867735385895,
-0.49571704864501953,
0.16855694353580475,
-0.061990153044462204,
0.6739141345024109,
0.6145881414413452,
0.2161196768283844,
-0.08926121890544891,
0.24022679030895233,
0.06856851279735565,
-0.6376339793205261,
0.36476340889930725,
-0.4516327381134033,
0.05435728654265404,
-0.5578383803367615,
-0.47321441769599915,
-0.6125226020812988,
-0.2008272111415863,
0.06387003511190414,
-0.18723809719085693,
-0.08397410064935684,
-0.09266966581344604,
0.42194491624832153,
0.32114091515541077,
-0.5087088942527771,
-0.21171046793460846,
-0.6212484836578369,
0.6538078188896179,
-0.540898859500885,
0.06162532791495323,
-0.14078690111637115,
0.10457834601402283,
-0.33678799867630005,
-0.5152273774147034,
-0.5828551054000854,
-0.19064834713935852,
-0.018714703619480133,
-0.06885838508605957,
-0.1896466612815857,
0.34751343727111816,
0.3500487804412842,
0.049726758152246475,
-0.08664527535438538,
0.3173680901527405,
-0.06788595765829086,
-0.018251005560159683,
0.29938551783561707,
0.18615074455738068,
0.5133812427520752,
-0.411257803440094,
-0.3626366853713989,
-0.24212592840194702,
-0.6650866270065308,
0.44899773597717285,
0.0951007828116417,
0.5568503737449646,
-0.1440729945898056,
0.7000980377197266,
0.19435815513134003,
0.3873234987258911,
0.21796467900276184,
0.042655717581510544,
0.018217841163277626,
-0.3972874879837036,
-0.06184927746653557,
0.16756364703178406,
0.8387486338615417,
0.36157530546188354,
0.1692761927843094,
0.016983618959784508,
-0.3066359758377075,
-0.14568157494068146,
0.05526350811123848,
-0.6643060445785522,
0.06075969710946083,
0.29896944761276245,
-0.246551513671875,
-0.6526771783828735,
0.13491050899028778,
-1.1286157369613647,
-0.7306673526763916,
-0.05761845037341118,
0.3252258896827698,
-0.2308822125196457,
-0.10845376551151276,
-0.07086775451898575,
-0.23477669060230255,
0.07803051173686981,
0.28092849254608154,
-0.9964041709899902,
-0.2103324979543686,
0.6052604913711548,
1.0009394884109497,
-0.5575867891311646,
-0.18273226916790009,
-1.0053119659423828,
0.16520991921424866,
-0.2867642343044281,
0.6272727847099304,
-0.7483555674552917,
-0.44382548332214355,
0.26902467012405396,
-0.01786503754556179,
0.03857550397515297,
-0.37555280327796936,
0.5024412870407104,
-0.6686801314353943,
0.19773374497890472,
-0.46888163685798645,
-0.1273881196975708,
0.10000238567590714,
0.05580565705895424,
-0.5699136853218079,
0.9002285003662109,
0.15540245175361633,
-1.0099880695343018,
0.41217395663261414,
-0.8815302848815918,
-0.45031359791755676,
0.12487810105085373,
-0.012924586422741413,
-0.0751069039106369,
0.44284552335739136,
0.1594977229833603,
0.5153914093971252,
0.05725346878170967,
0.3364883363246918,
-0.30273959040641785,
-0.3497774302959442,
0.43810364603996277,
-0.5692819952964783,
0.7009215950965881,
0.1268191784620285,
-0.4976562559604645,
0.5784650444984436,
-0.46670129895210266,
-0.43886804580688477,
-0.14617812633514404,
-0.26490622758865356,
-0.3700175881385803,
-0.2818537950515747,
0.10566742718219757,
0.21263904869556427,
-0.1404067575931549,
-0.33867576718330383,
0.2313220202922821,
-0.46627354621887207,
0.3095535933971405,
0.9479644894599915,
0.5470721125602722,
0.5732921957969666,
0.026674799621105194,
0.7625957131385803,
0.40420234203338623,
0.22461476922035217,
-0.6365420818328857,
-0.4828837215900421,
-0.488735169172287,
-0.3702986538410187,
0.356972336769104,
0.3263641595840454,
-0.9495336413383484,
0.2224789559841156,
0.07677849382162094,
-0.10771984606981277,
-0.45923173427581787,
-0.1484270691871643,
0.19814461469650269,
0.4619973599910736,
0.1417788714170456,
-0.08484216034412384,
-0.048936571925878525,
-0.6405020356178284,
-0.20264846086502075,
-0.30872446298599243,
-0.0003993232094217092,
0.08062390983104706,
0.11052597314119339,
-0.10696979612112045,
0.8824869990348816,
-0.3111758530139923,
-0.11492729187011719,
-0.21075335144996643,
0.36435404419898987,
0.11789242923259735,
0.3818308413028717,
0.6631516218185425,
-0.5456589460372925,
-0.3437224328517914,
-0.03076067753136158,
-0.3926008641719818,
-0.6316722631454468,
-0.35531625151634216,
-0.28627628087997437,
0.25849947333335876,
0.5824909806251526,
-0.8354945778846741,
0.6525861620903015,
0.2611360549926758,
-0.6299971342086792,
0.7652614712715149,
-0.015511786565184593,
0.11298874765634537,
-0.9505568742752075,
0.1442985236644745,
-0.0823969691991806,
-0.1344362199306488,
-0.6422951221466064,
0.19644419848918915,
-0.019901428371667862,
-0.08749648183584213,
-0.6787320971488953,
0.8431078791618347,
-0.48754388093948364,
-0.12916961312294006,
-0.19353169202804565,
0.2693169414997101,
-0.07831691205501556,
0.4189598858356476,
-0.37080541253089905,
0.8970253467559814,
0.5331345796585083,
-0.5526208281517029,
0.2826992869377136,
0.1386503279209137,
-0.1642710268497467,
0.4809945523738861,
-0.7633405327796936,
-0.24523097276687622,
-0.3225920498371124,
-0.02741415798664093,
-1.2337877750396729,
-0.10566965490579605,
0.3753344416618347,
-0.3405494689941406,
0.4231767952442169,
-0.13295747339725494,
-0.7660332322120667,
-0.09641320258378983,
-0.43999341130256653,
0.3960151970386505,
0.6677266955375671,
-0.5356991291046143,
0.4899051785469055,
0.1651814728975296,
-0.44777339696884155,
-0.6064186692237854,
-0.5793296098709106,
0.1173875629901886,
-0.3260244131088257,
-0.318744033575058,
0.08755195140838623,
-0.14182458817958832,
-0.544842541217804,
-0.14721600711345673,
0.23152053356170654,
0.4473515748977661,
0.19384391605854034,
0.3738376200199127,
0.08983217179775238,
0.04353209212422371,
0.37995895743370056,
0.42643415927886963,
-0.030454544350504875,
0.3805115222930908,
-0.016969559714198112,
0.7581520676612854,
0.49118784070014954,
-0.37637221813201904,
-0.519969642162323,
0.24084436893463135,
0.9683295488357544,
-0.3507075607776642,
0.8221965432167053,
0.5341624021530151,
0.12436006963253021,
-0.2615457773208618,
-0.23561342060565948,
-0.38163793087005615,
-0.5083833932876587,
0.2687402069568634,
-0.19745512306690216,
-0.7527769804000854,
0.7447267770767212,
0.012912468053400517,
0.014715486206114292,
0.24904301762580872,
0.7526448965072632,
0.11022438108921051,
1.1615376472473145,
0.6887955665588379,
0.086663618683815,
0.9908900856971741,
0.10235689580440521,
-0.06658298522233963,
-0.8443397283554077,
-0.33031877875328064,
-0.450107216835022,
-0.41788384318351746,
-0.355683296918869,
-0.6298086643218994,
0.50864577293396,
0.11517824977636337,
-0.13146071135997772,
-0.3194339871406555,
-0.2764667868614197,
0.49873778223991394,
0.6344826817512512,
-0.11345493793487549,
0.0826379656791687,
-0.0034369081258773804,
-0.6075551509857178,
-0.07593081146478653,
-0.5362187623977661,
-0.33029142022132874,
0.747876763343811,
0.38866305351257324,
0.5778481364250183,
0.09013372659683228,
0.4667070806026459,
0.337184339761734,
0.2737131416797638,
-0.6545643210411072,
0.6240657567977905,
0.10623578727245331,
-0.1522291600704193,
-0.24114608764648438,
-0.25492751598358154,
-1.0557284355163574,
0.09150317311286926,
-0.2712918221950531,
-0.7689512968063354,
0.2879709005355835,
0.12979000806808472,
-0.21762561798095703,
0.32148173451423645,
-0.6350437998771667,
0.7535525560379028,
-0.008521107025444508,
-0.5471872091293335,
-0.08661811798810959,
-0.6748621463775635,
0.3237141966819763,
-0.04258893057703972,
0.10591765493154526,
0.03944443166255951,
-0.1345037817955017,
0.4021461308002472,
-0.3027538061141968,
1.080428957939148,
-0.4536323845386505,
-0.2666749656200409,
0.06421307474374771,
0.3948006331920624,
0.7272440791130066,
0.21211881935596466,
-0.24048279225826263,
-0.0663716271519661,
-0.27143388986587524,
-0.3856792449951172,
-0.6720240116119385,
0.8442806601524353,
-0.5952110290527344,
-0.7539327144622803,
-0.19198374450206757,
-0.7641366124153137,
0.016072815284132957,
0.22895793616771698,
0.2825984060764313,
0.4408559501171112,
-0.06944430619478226,
0.0012247395934537053,
0.604779839515686,
-0.46042177081108093,
0.8884539604187012,
0.06630916148424149,
-0.41932159662246704,
-0.1994391828775406,
0.4587104320526123,
-0.13137736916542053,
0.47638648748397827,
0.2743452787399292,
0.3021334409713745,
-0.592108964920044,
-0.5011230111122131,
-0.7035886645317078,
0.37821143865585327,
-0.8360418677330017,
-0.08430864661931992,
-0.7076959609985352,
0.07603872567415237,
-0.2823079526424408,
-0.25289925932884216,
0.1125260591506958,
-0.2578164339065552,
-0.6895530819892883,
-0.3619900941848755,
0.5620450377464294,
0.7654871940612793,
-0.03733334690332413,
0.45381948351860046,
-0.5457643866539001,
-0.1435738056898117,
0.3164645731449127,
0.2261129468679428,
0.16484783589839935,
-0.5284537076950073,
-0.01686391420662403,
-0.023311426863074303,
-0.11330151557922363,
-1.2057348489761353,
0.4359133839607239,
-0.23313230276107788,
0.37564510107040405,
0.7838666439056396,
0.21279995143413544,
0.3765106797218323,
-0.3965887129306793,
1.2270318269729614,
0.2701869606971741,
-1.1174968481063843,
0.5486547350883484,
-0.5733909010887146,
0.5304282903671265,
0.2606661319732666,
0.11174631863832474,
-0.6966583132743835,
-0.7843191027641296,
-0.3589686453342438,
-0.7677821516990662,
0.7108091115951538,
-0.04449400305747986,
0.29192620515823364,
-0.25045058131217957,
0.3994286060333252,
0.14605368673801422,
0.3927517533302307,
-0.4693107306957245,
-0.26591238379478455,
-0.07773861289024353,
-0.3066193163394928,
-0.10313575714826584,
-0.5470388531684875,
-0.0367131382226944,
0.0239871833473444,
0.21690842509269714,
-0.07451605051755905,
0.04295053333044052,
0.04212106019258499,
0.1071629598736763,
-0.21468180418014526,
0.34669792652130127,
0.7930248975753784,
0.37714460492134094,
-0.008302336558699608,
0.48733559250831604,
-0.1518881618976593,
-0.3607260286808014,
0.11304572224617004,
-0.1346442848443985,
-0.5594165921211243,
0.26713499426841736,
0.2716132402420044,
1.0160030126571655,
0.38744914531707764,
-0.7236682176589966,
0.6912054419517517,
0.1369892954826355,
0.21060079336166382,
0.26835599541664124,
0.11390025168657303,
-0.1377970427274704,
0.390089750289917,
0.4158916175365448,
0.01023944653570652,
-0.04643538221716881,
-0.6776171922683716,
0.1984357237815857,
0.5755245685577393,
-0.5928261876106262,
-0.742425799369812,
0.8850467205047607,
0.30322179198265076,
-0.3949098587036133,
0.3894513249397278,
-0.29702720046043396,
-0.548061728477478,
0.4942299425601959,
0.4940767288208008,
0.8958786725997925,
-0.19850945472717285,
0.5634492039680481,
0.07011888176202774,
0.10190998762845993,
0.1636148989200592,
0.18313443660736084,
-0.04427549988031387,
-0.5083561539649963,
-0.527534544467926,
-0.4248002767562866,
-0.2805575132369995,
0.026718545705080032,
-0.5909408926963806,
0.44370871782302856,
-0.49196144938468933,
-0.2122942954301834,
-0.012731052935123444,
-0.35689446330070496,
-0.4530371427536011,
-0.2995433807373047,
0.13843704760074615,
0.650749683380127,
-0.7873693704605103,
0.4831976294517517,
0.6667835116386414,
-0.4575451910495758,
-0.6218231320381165,
0.34970465302467346,
0.0997237041592598,
-0.7482120394706726,
0.9064255952835083,
0.06311403214931488,
0.07016971707344055,
0.1594099998474121,
-0.5974164009094238,
-0.5825537443161011,
0.7691175937652588,
0.42466112971305847,
-0.29085034132003784,
0.1352531462907791,
0.17483334243297577,
0.6041745543479919,
-0.3197158873081207,
0.3565537929534912,
0.4501284956932068,
0.6111495494842529,
0.24748557806015015,
-0.690348744392395,
0.2644326090812683,
-0.11374916881322861,
0.15324820578098297,
0.22723133862018585,
-0.49669864773750305,
0.8494324088096619,
-0.5947433114051819,
-0.7529537081718445,
-0.13068591058254242,
0.37516865134239197,
0.4629357159137726,
0.22169464826583862,
0.5087605118751526,
0.10224547982215881,
0.5365257263183594,
-0.12539231777191162,
1.0742263793945312,
-0.46329861879348755,
-0.006229297257959843,
0.6187223196029663,
-0.3083396553993225,
0.6765831708908081,
0.851473867893219,
0.20901520550251007,
0.5481946468353271,
0.5583949685096741,
0.09060785174369812,
0.6598957777023315,
0.3190927803516388,
-0.44170209765434265,
0.028328552842140198,
-0.6605640649795532,
-0.0924156904220581,
0.08873921632766724,
0.17855340242385864,
-0.4689176380634308,
-0.27200138568878174,
0.3558400273323059,
0.07001082599163055,
-0.03625182807445526,
-0.4318987727165222,
0.6779390573501587,
-0.07532740384340286,
-0.5501769185066223,
0.30794018507003784,
-0.06779205799102783,
0.763009250164032,
-0.4711785912513733,
-0.06070127338171005,
-0.4200247526168823,
-0.06551878899335861,
0.13985617458820343,
-1.0184135437011719,
-0.00553129892796278,
0.10050193965435028,
-0.2525138258934021,
-0.3417724370956421,
0.5571299195289612,
-0.5556994080543518,
-0.183919295668602,
0.2586362957954407,
0.5346081852912903,
0.04152974486351013,
-0.10518050938844681,
-0.36758700013160706,
0.3572818338871002,
-0.014568252488970757,
-0.35618582367897034,
0.4023301303386688,
0.9225143194198608,
-0.23473647236824036,
0.6096442937850952,
0.7335798144340515,
0.3016026020050049,
0.03257284313440323,
0.24671967327594757,
1.0417449474334717,
-0.7073814272880554,
-0.6430333256721497,
-1.0002009868621826,
0.6237970590591431,
0.015132573433220387,
-0.29708606004714966,
0.73760986328125,
0.06850901246070862,
0.4406866431236267,
-0.19518719613552094,
0.565254271030426,
0.2734031081199646,
0.15102455019950867,
-0.45905834436416626,
0.7699954509735107,
-0.2956759035587311,
0.43190711736679077,
-0.3212679326534271,
-0.7810526490211487,
-0.4599449932575226,
0.05368100479245186,
-0.0928502231836319,
-0.03159930557012558,
0.6668878197669983,
0.753873348236084,
0.2823081910610199,
-0.2532222867012024,
0.39087122678756714,
0.4363926649093628,
0.4414164423942566,
0.20097972452640533,
1.0978354215621948,
0.22242239117622375,
0.415187269449234,
-0.05015095695853233,
-0.12496300786733627,
-0.3878888785839081,
-0.9606032371520996,
-1.0804429054260254,
-0.487939715385437,
-0.24357852339744568,
-0.18189328908920288,
0.03544752672314644,
0.9618821144104004,
0.5669293999671936,
-0.6972814202308655,
0.20299336314201355,
-0.024154992774128914,
0.35739582777023315,
-0.11504458636045456,
-0.3776109516620636,
0.47377315163612366,
-0.530414342880249,
-0.9152964353561401,
0.14097072184085846,
0.598686933517456,
0.3748604953289032,
-0.5631833672523499,
0.2705949544906616,
0.1968265026807785,
0.2680574655532837,
0.7950482368469238,
0.007140066009014845,
-0.8499652743339539,
-0.47223037481307983,
0.15302865207195282,
-0.10013692080974579,
-0.1424829661846161,
0.9948467016220093,
-0.8410769104957581,
0.4222363531589508,
0.5817632675170898,
0.4922332167625427,
0.016744179651141167,
0.12756502628326416,
0.6839300394058228,
-1.1992216110229492,
0.25376778841018677,
0.09758061170578003,
0.10719827562570572,
0.11883635073900223,
-0.6408496499061584,
0.16726583242416382,
0.23963889479637146,
-0.361054390668869,
-1.1655827760696411,
0.2770044505596161,
-0.995808482170105,
-0.33022117614746094,
1.4178327322006226,
0.08946513384580612,
-0.3481588065624237,
-0.08000129461288452,
-0.4292920231819153,
0.16793859004974365,
-0.7118383646011353,
0.8096569180488586,
0.6592676043510437,
-0.037852831184864044,
-0.6005058288574219,
-0.288813978433609,
0.61937016248703,
0.4544299244880676,
-0.718338668346405,
0.4969484508037567,
0.6263423562049866,
0.018719317391514778,
0.12528224289417267,
0.3050040006637573,
-0.13115669786930084,
0.05987365543842316,
-0.23106685280799866,
0.08663449436426163,
-0.20020197331905365,
-0.3183077573776245,
-0.7430832386016846,
0.272879421710968,
0.043211329728364944,
-0.13125775754451752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11880v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11880v1
|
Quantifying In-Context Reasoning Effects and Memorization Effects in LLMs
| 2024-05-20T08:51:03 | 2024-05-20T08:51:03 |
Siyu Lou, Yuntian Chen, Xiaodan Liang, Liang Lin, Quanshi Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In this study, we propose an axiomatic system to define and quantify the
precise memorization and in-context reasoning effects used by the large
language model (LLM) for language generation. These effects are formulated as
non-linear interactions between tokens/words encoded by the LLM. Specifically,
the axiomatic system enables us to categorize the memorization effects into
foundational memorization effects and chaotic memorization effects, and further
classify in-context reasoning effects into enhanced inference patterns,
eliminated inference patterns, and reversed inference patterns. Besides, the
decomposed effects satisfy the sparsity property and the universal matching
property, which mathematically guarantee that the LLM's confidence score can be
faithfully decomposed into the memorization effects and in-context reasoning
effects. Experiments show that the clear disentanglement of memorization
effects and in-context reasoning effects enables a straightforward examination
of detailed inference patterns encoded by LLMs.
|
[
-0.08977557718753815,
-0.8483065962791443,
0.5526406764984131,
0.2948930561542511,
-0.2991921603679657,
-0.26358991861343384,
-0.16170121729373932,
-0.07905535399913788,
0.02537553943693638,
0.31390395760536194,
-0.3014243543148041,
-0.40778183937072754,
-0.2960975170135498,
0.07513552904129028,
-0.5938400626182556,
0.8266704082489014,
-0.0077618821524083614,
0.17647898197174072,
-0.406070351600647,
-0.0026199272833764553,
-0.42217621207237244,
-0.7324519753456116,
-0.33910441398620605,
-0.6775964498519897,
0.3439122438430786,
0.18623502552509308,
0.5156140923500061,
0.6315853595733643,
0.30452078580856323,
0.30368003249168396,
-0.38982781767845154,
0.016501927748322487,
-0.5932038426399231,
0.11541774868965149,
-0.2823694944381714,
-0.5335946679115295,
-0.3946487009525299,
-0.15929241478443146,
0.9784190058708191,
0.7921987175941467,
-0.09431730210781097,
0.0009980122558772564,
0.17310763895511627,
0.28430551290512085,
-0.522594690322876,
0.1323326826095581,
-0.6577348709106445,
-0.019026653841137886,
0.08501876145601273,
-0.6584248542785645,
-0.527304470539093,
-0.22485609352588654,
-0.2174733430147171,
-0.428554892539978,
0.07359304279088974,
0.17042158544063568,
0.7191832661628723,
0.22986695170402527,
-0.5090007781982422,
-0.4116061329841614,
-0.6891120672225952,
1.045636773109436,
-0.9491396546363831,
0.3694186508655548,
0.24631762504577637,
0.07001693546772003,
-0.4400341510772705,
-0.6367244720458984,
-0.7470235824584961,
-0.014352576807141304,
-0.08266600966453552,
0.04907906800508499,
-0.007882405072450638,
0.3348756432533264,
0.3700888752937317,
0.42909449338912964,
-0.312777578830719,
-0.03672834485769272,
-0.13971759378910065,
-0.3909159004688263,
0.5739853382110596,
0.5496055483818054,
0.20426364243030548,
-0.07089810818433762,
-0.4730948805809021,
0.11633403599262238,
-0.8922001123428345,
-0.1184576228260994,
0.12020234018564224,
0.19377584755420685,
0.1375039517879486,
0.5118773579597473,
0.01962156407535076,
0.5774927735328674,
-0.1165570467710495,
-0.4776260554790497,
0.216904878616333,
-0.504365086555481,
-0.5774391889572144,
0.07546835392713547,
0.582384467124939,
0.327237069606781,
0.02678793855011463,
-0.22002896666526794,
-0.3992116153240204,
0.17308612167835236,
-0.2912311553955078,
-0.8375909328460693,
0.27548640966415405,
-0.08980859816074371,
-0.5481115579605103,
-0.16915927827358246,
0.00616460619494319,
-0.5815019011497498,
-0.18281511962413788,
-0.49136245250701904,
0.6435593366622925,
-0.48568984866142273,
-0.1520509421825409,
0.326986163854599,
-0.1655203253030777,
0.40525004267692566,
0.20952944457530975,
-0.7179328203201294,
0.52970951795578,
0.8381184339523315,
0.6034639477729797,
-0.04542186111211777,
-0.3170044422149658,
-0.18012315034866333,
0.32788774371147156,
-0.3124656081199646,
0.4871353209018707,
-0.6454132199287415,
-0.260946124792099,
0.047325219959020615,
-0.2187335342168808,
-0.22192811965942383,
-0.5901033282279968,
0.39959022402763367,
-0.5784136652946472,
-0.032856885343790054,
-0.25337645411491394,
-1.1021780967712402,
-0.24614234268665314,
0.20321537554264069,
-0.39309161901474,
0.8455775380134583,
-0.1062108650803566,
-0.600503146648407,
0.24139463901519775,
-0.13600178062915802,
-0.3495182991027832,
-0.10399212688207626,
-0.1916808933019638,
-0.23960082232952118,
0.34051036834716797,
-0.20770391821861267,
0.4469377398490906,
-0.21929216384887695,
0.5154504776000977,
-0.3446148633956909,
-0.6415140628814697,
0.5416322946548462,
-0.5550879240036011,
0.6694169044494629,
0.20573385059833527,
-0.3489024341106415,
0.023746566846966743,
-0.7686851024627686,
0.04420490190386772,
0.06554146856069565,
-0.6182023882865906,
-0.5101664662361145,
0.07836148142814636,
-0.2500450611114502,
0.3804212212562561,
0.20851321518421173,
-0.2976078987121582,
0.0728951245546341,
-0.3308528959751129,
0.5241917371749878,
0.6588813662528992,
0.45796293020248413,
0.5284371972084045,
-0.15693022310733795,
0.0689641460776329,
0.3252713978290558,
-0.09603516757488251,
-0.37482017278671265,
-0.2308349460363388,
-0.7388499975204468,
-0.24224643409252167,
0.1562901735305786,
0.45113620162010193,
-0.481021523475647,
0.46588724851608276,
-0.18047688901424408,
0.16948658227920532,
0.08864960819482803,
0.18735142052173615,
0.7478033304214478,
0.5920392870903015,
-0.02057347074151039,
-0.2893993854522705,
-0.4307449460029602,
-0.7780215740203857,
-0.1806623786687851,
-0.09440954774618149,
-0.09414921700954437,
0.1635432243347168,
0.7362808585166931,
-0.16534921526908875,
0.9063164591789246,
-0.3818618655204773,
0.04498220980167389,
-0.019120261073112488,
0.07264184951782227,
-0.009167217649519444,
0.3314369022846222,
0.25255775451660156,
-0.3603474795818329,
0.09339197725057602,
-0.29386794567108154,
-0.6727871298789978,
-0.23899774253368378,
-0.18877308070659637,
-0.21120093762874603,
0.2474226951599121,
0.843117356300354,
-0.7014869451522827,
0.392168790102005,
0.04294789209961891,
-0.4009658992290497,
0.379965215921402,
-0.2961847484111786,
-0.10404594987630844,
-0.9216657876968384,
-0.10361579060554504,
-0.3051551580429077,
0.031571950763463974,
-0.6743903160095215,
-0.08182290941476822,
0.04108401760458946,
0.16126462817192078,
-0.31740233302116394,
0.57350754737854,
-0.37581226229667664,
-0.30942243337631226,
-0.04019474238157272,
0.26273253560066223,
0.22564686834812164,
0.5531976819038391,
-0.08415045589208603,
0.7304174304008484,
0.33903250098228455,
-0.7526889443397522,
-0.01947670243680477,
-0.017253756523132324,
-0.38008490204811096,
0.5349987745285034,
-0.5150386691093445,
-0.05719221755862236,
-0.3320844769477844,
0.2486007809638977,
-1.2096130847930908,
-0.1356368511915207,
-0.008301246911287308,
-0.2976635694503784,
0.2339213788509369,
0.2928563058376312,
-0.8456155061721802,
-0.005558853503316641,
-0.12167626619338989,
0.4216032028198242,
0.42512956261634827,
-0.5203264355659485,
0.5138494968414307,
0.1476152241230011,
0.2171153575181961,
-0.5989471077919006,
-0.5927980542182922,
-0.20698679983615875,
-0.6404358744621277,
-0.4064323604106903,
0.11681022495031357,
-0.09334787726402283,
-0.6558296084403992,
-0.13892221450805664,
-0.03098100982606411,
-0.054677095264196396,
0.07969870418310165,
0.24671953916549683,
0.12011229991912842,
-0.22442619502544403,
0.5412145853042603,
0.3015204071998596,
0.02259024791419506,
0.3125382661819458,
-0.10326509922742844,
0.5872606635093689,
-0.3792055547237396,
-0.42428916692733765,
-0.15014545619487762,
0.20831915736198425,
0.7157717943191528,
-0.13045047223567963,
0.6898285746574402,
0.1038229763507843,
-0.4208480417728424,
-0.5007609724998474,
-0.33266839385032654,
-0.32611531019210815,
-0.45767709612846375,
0.3453421890735626,
-0.2774668037891388,
-0.715758204460144,
0.7788402438163757,
-0.35479700565338135,
-0.08324262499809265,
0.2941729426383972,
0.6404927968978882,
-0.02127796970307827,
1.0898380279541016,
0.28929057717323303,
-0.0007041738135740161,
0.3665902614593506,
-0.20781266689300537,
0.12689881026744843,
-0.9413884878158569,
-0.2952362596988678,
-0.0855584591627121,
-0.27606773376464844,
-0.09156690537929535,
-0.30245453119277954,
0.1388251632452011,
0.7917886972427368,
-0.5590178966522217,
-0.07188700139522552,
-0.2330431044101715,
0.454547256231308,
0.37911051511764526,
-0.03818582743406296,
0.4132712781429291,
0.008481116034090519,
-0.5734126567840576,
-0.04069983586668968,
-0.6140783429145813,
-0.6312255859375,
0.977028489112854,
0.3395516574382782,
0.7934814691543579,
0.21091294288635254,
0.7466155886650085,
0.032638970762491226,
0.3150121569633484,
-0.7861368656158447,
0.8519516587257385,
0.29169028997421265,
-0.6077840924263,
-0.19473722577095032,
-0.42006880044937134,
-0.8339544534683228,
0.3875505328178406,
-0.19395634531974792,
-0.7488260269165039,
0.07131600379943848,
0.25702136754989624,
-0.15000773966312408,
0.26427820324897766,
-0.6957625150680542,
0.5731379389762878,
-0.29680073261260986,
-0.4638887345790863,
-0.3233787715435028,
-0.5350906252861023,
0.6187460422515869,
0.012044239789247513,
0.2520671486854553,
-0.039583850651979446,
-0.16990917921066284,
0.4589911997318268,
-0.4543028175830841,
1.0041015148162842,
-0.05100345239043236,
-0.21746180951595306,
0.38101398944854736,
0.3111613094806671,
0.32066380977630615,
0.08736323565244675,
-0.02285267598927021,
0.12443986535072327,
-0.1998959630727768,
-0.10734935104846954,
-0.6011571288108826,
0.7463989853858948,
-0.6228399276733398,
-0.4482930302619934,
-0.30756574869155884,
-0.9489849209785461,
-0.05143296718597412,
0.3346792757511139,
0.20011459290981293,
0.4960019588470459,
-0.4029203951358795,
-0.07924693077802658,
0.9200294017791748,
-0.27425089478492737,
0.3538955748081207,
0.5312689542770386,
-0.5031039118766785,
-0.36307570338249207,
0.9902083873748779,
0.18022441864013672,
0.5140518546104431,
0.37818264961242676,
0.2997291386127472,
-0.1811971217393875,
-0.5785589814186096,
-0.06601671129465103,
0.4541252851486206,
-0.9301791787147522,
-0.016664879396557808,
-0.13079409301280975,
-0.1821552813053131,
-0.04400751739740372,
-0.11411988735198975,
0.06182827427983284,
-0.41204833984375,
-0.2977046072483063,
-0.07372359186410904,
0.19718417525291443,
0.7839221954345703,
-0.06443186104297638,
0.22239337861537933,
-0.43643075227737427,
0.051184818148612976,
0.3973756432533264,
0.5250106453895569,
0.18589675426483154,
-0.524570107460022,
-0.19714753329753876,
-0.10945417732000351,
-0.36623457074165344,
-0.7161781191825867,
0.2945021390914917,
0.2680104076862335,
0.5786769390106201,
0.7038845419883728,
-0.008117149583995342,
0.7162719368934631,
-0.5294672250747681,
0.629464328289032,
0.11896662414073944,
-1.2461997270584106,
0.2399192750453949,
-0.4686957895755768,
0.25648581981658936,
0.07285142689943314,
-0.21494737267494202,
-0.43247827887535095,
-0.45889148116111755,
-0.523934006690979,
-0.9850445985794067,
0.631127119064331,
0.2572396397590637,
0.1879522204399109,
-0.45648086071014404,
0.4546889662742615,
-0.1003028154373169,
0.2463078647851944,
-0.48687484860420227,
-0.28048643469810486,
-0.2895618677139282,
-0.15653692185878754,
-0.08469461649656296,
-0.49186787009239197,
-0.23640604317188263,
-0.30931732058525085,
0.4966132640838623,
0.14579008519649506,
0.3326016068458557,
0.012677866965532303,
-0.14447632431983948,
-0.034284383058547974,
0.3765350580215454,
1.0157115459442139,
0.6518967747688293,
-0.29634809494018555,
0.3540950119495392,
0.45004308223724365,
-0.15596042573451996,
0.13051080703735352,
-0.2075832039117813,
-0.24728639423847198,
0.026680737733840942,
0.5065667629241943,
0.7281919121742249,
0.3727739453315735,
-0.7000102996826172,
0.47599735856056213,
0.008495434187352657,
-0.39071011543273926,
-0.5257279276847839,
0.1832370012998581,
0.43253833055496216,
0.22897577285766602,
0.1511298269033432,
-0.14875435829162598,
0.05156276747584343,
-0.3689817786216736,
0.3371414542198181,
0.5820241570472717,
-0.15905553102493286,
-0.35231950879096985,
0.4906931221485138,
-0.028120171278715134,
-0.3026881515979767,
0.5050061345100403,
-0.06754611432552338,
-0.2139616161584854,
0.6945452094078064,
1.0153186321258545,
0.5642862319946289,
-0.3650054633617401,
-0.12789689004421234,
0.36469078063964844,
0.058880917727947235,
-0.24060969054698944,
0.16336475312709808,
-0.16221286356449127,
-0.8603416681289673,
-0.30468258261680603,
-0.4646895229816437,
-0.34544339776039124,
0.30311861634254456,
-0.79645174741745,
-0.07883002609014511,
-0.5310869812965393,
-0.048539526760578156,
-0.030685771256685257,
-0.31203123927116394,
-0.4145606458187103,
0.18077640235424042,
0.31950101256370544,
0.737224280834198,
-0.8636104464530945,
0.9023335576057434,
0.4714994728565216,
-0.36350616812705994,
-0.8295135498046875,
0.11288498342037201,
0.17704187333583832,
-0.7658223509788513,
0.922714352607727,
0.0879804790019989,
-0.419599711894989,
-0.10546674579381943,
-0.5586745142936707,
-0.9433627128601074,
1.2329163551330566,
0.4996093511581421,
-0.4775545001029968,
0.16680964827537537,
0.35033562779426575,
0.6459734439849854,
-0.4631870985031128,
0.14145249128341675,
0.7714688181877136,
0.29903367161750793,
0.2155272513628006,
-0.6870772242546082,
0.09733366221189499,
-0.1024695560336113,
0.2633780837059021,
0.2990039587020874,
-0.5234643220901489,
0.9856940507888794,
-0.08690371364355087,
-0.5607093572616577,
0.10478955507278442,
0.41262009739875793,
0.3232712149620056,
0.35107895731925964,
0.2544620633125305,
0.6318569779396057,
0.6056634783744812,
-0.08950699865818024,
0.9552699327468872,
-0.460693895816803,
0.44519710540771484,
0.9129594564437866,
-0.22755548357963562,
0.7781931161880493,
0.6751878261566162,
-0.01607629843056202,
0.41722992062568665,
0.14749941229820251,
0.43174245953559875,
0.4494350254535675,
0.6832234263420105,
-0.49354249238967896,
-0.21181397140026093,
-0.03020813874900341,
-0.27020931243896484,
0.303829163312912,
0.8462036848068237,
-0.5993847250938416,
-0.36833763122558594,
-0.06862189620733261,
0.2518518567085266,
0.12422038614749908,
-0.5006272792816162,
0.7413640022277832,
0.3129557967185974,
-0.5432707667350769,
0.9242762923240662,
-0.004764868877828121,
0.5390732288360596,
-0.5830625295639038,
-0.20785191655158997,
-0.2846246659755707,
0.6493197083473206,
-0.2482645958662033,
-0.8913057446479797,
0.4031406044960022,
-0.34283578395843506,
-0.19038423895835876,
-0.14764109253883362,
0.6235062479972839,
-0.5900108814239502,
-0.40367045998573303,
0.548983633518219,
0.23489844799041748,
0.21212609112262726,
0.44607803225517273,
-0.32598793506622314,
0.0738203376531601,
-0.2195955365896225,
-0.46375951170921326,
0.36845794320106506,
0.5867412090301514,
-0.27448251843452454,
0.6743367910385132,
0.46169447898864746,
-0.14636966586112976,
0.20805785059928894,
0.23115745186805725,
0.8112301826477051,
-0.8034610748291016,
-0.2183304727077484,
-0.994163990020752,
0.3012147545814514,
0.12099599838256836,
-0.2837083041667938,
0.8911845088005066,
0.4923354685306549,
0.7513108253479004,
-0.010102637112140656,
0.679483950138092,
0.2543705105781555,
0.2778591513633728,
-0.4847412407398224,
0.43287867307662964,
-0.45437684655189514,
0.5036132335662842,
-0.5059283375740051,
-0.7521185874938965,
-0.5653731226921082,
0.6763694882392883,
-0.37742680311203003,
-0.10128694027662277,
0.6806339025497437,
0.9777049422264099,
0.04768623039126396,
-0.21676771342754364,
0.4952966272830963,
0.37171512842178345,
0.11527802050113678,
0.6481462121009827,
0.7955501675605774,
-0.27841082215309143,
0.560641348361969,
0.007885264232754707,
-0.24785543978214264,
-0.10719573497772217,
-0.8262782692909241,
-1.096264123916626,
-0.5777317881584167,
0.05755195766687393,
-0.4259343445301056,
-0.11142079532146454,
0.8729669451713562,
0.2144186794757843,
-0.6592209339141846,
-0.44389721751213074,
-0.4426945745944977,
0.28096944093704224,
-0.40274712443351746,
-0.29151374101638794,
0.464372456073761,
-0.3464742600917816,
-0.5259708166122437,
0.13221010565757751,
0.4208155870437622,
-0.04052408039569855,
-0.2761721909046173,
-0.47009462118148804,
-0.02346613258123398,
0.6127526760101318,
0.9556090831756592,
0.22753582894802094,
-0.8912329077720642,
-0.2501414120197296,
-0.13027265667915344,
-0.21203629672527313,
0.043670933693647385,
0.8146783113479614,
-0.5961019992828369,
0.31802481412887573,
0.6851205825805664,
0.24530531466007233,
0.29832470417022705,
-0.02593786083161831,
0.5853644013404846,
-0.7019253373146057,
0.15378069877624512,
-0.009575503878295422,
0.6382184624671936,
0.08736157417297363,
-0.2098204791545868,
0.1816292107105255,
0.16555657982826233,
-0.49922335147857666,
-0.916341245174408,
0.5879398584365845,
-0.5330455303192139,
-0.3572840690612793,
1.2986791133880615,
-0.1984737515449524,
-0.16058824956417084,
-0.19386164844036102,
-0.059171758592128754,
0.2640259861946106,
-0.2506372034549713,
0.7507627010345459,
0.6636187434196472,
-0.31548455357551575,
-0.1668022871017456,
-0.3186444342136383,
0.34371742606163025,
0.5251253843307495,
-0.6313954591751099,
0.11586256325244904,
0.7217592597007751,
0.39685556292533875,
0.15142878890037537,
0.48800864815711975,
-0.32344916462898254,
0.038796354085206985,
0.1437968611717224,
0.1944998949766159,
-0.26555323600769043,
-0.09778425842523575,
-0.5375617742538452,
0.11238192021846771,
0.03203611820936203,
-0.016283806413412094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11877v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11877v3
|
A Novel Cartography-Based Curriculum Learning Method Applied on RoNLI: The First Romanian Natural Language Inference Corpus
| 2024-05-20T08:41:15 | 2024-05-22T19:14:51 |
Eduard Poesina, Cornelia Caragea, Radu Tudor Ionescu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Natural language inference (NLI), the task of recognizing the entailment
relationship in sentence pairs, is an actively studied topic serving as a proxy
for natural language understanding. Despite the relevance of the task in
building conversational agents and improving text classification, machine
translation and other NLP tasks, to the best of our knowledge, there is no
publicly available NLI corpus for the Romanian language. To this end, we
introduce the first Romanian NLI corpus (RoNLI) comprising 58K training
sentence pairs, which are obtained via distant supervision, and 6K validation
and test sentence pairs, which are manually annotated with the correct labels.
We conduct experiments with multiple machine learning methods based on distant
learning, ranging from shallow models based on word embeddings to
transformer-based neural networks, to establish a set of competitive baselines.
Furthermore, we improve on the best model by employing a new curriculum
learning strategy based on data cartography. Our dataset and code to reproduce
the baselines are available at https://github.com/Eduard6421/RONLI.
|
[
-0.3923536539077759,
-0.9936977624893188,
0.3002515137195587,
0.05956399813294411,
-0.28493234515190125,
-0.10255385935306549,
-0.39137357473373413,
-0.5112015604972839,
0.0707608312368393,
0.7253634333610535,
-0.45669934153556824,
-1.123566746711731,
-0.5349177718162537,
0.06246855854988098,
-0.27875763177871704,
1.0044304132461548,
-0.01369607076048851,
0.18760371208190918,
-0.1676858514547348,
-0.35369911789894104,
-0.6206896901130676,
-0.3156130313873291,
-0.6185164451599121,
-0.10951907932758331,
0.6054151058197021,
0.5202917456626892,
0.38209405541419983,
0.42837461829185486,
0.30849334597587585,
0.21826137602329254,
0.1977287083864212,
0.5448569655418396,
-0.38866883516311646,
-0.03755496069788933,
0.08280070871114731,
-0.7015884518623352,
-0.1221703365445137,
-0.0491701140999794,
0.5566238760948181,
0.8708643317222595,
0.09384086728096008,
0.18442797660827637,
0.250755250453949,
0.892892599105835,
-0.7250086665153503,
0.2746390104293823,
-0.6253067851066589,
0.05009642243385315,
-0.21671107411384583,
-0.10939788818359375,
-0.8533208966255188,
-0.6648582816123962,
0.43649476766586304,
-0.844635546207428,
0.22106371819972992,
0.21568086743354797,
1.2447469234466553,
0.06359313428401947,
-0.5696475505828857,
-0.7316570281982422,
-0.7103045582771301,
1.2431777715682983,
-0.3201397657394409,
0.24690355360507965,
0.8250245451927185,
0.5497962236404419,
-0.06229640170931816,
-0.42316651344299316,
-0.24725648760795593,
-0.13638156652450562,
-0.002523614326491952,
0.0676996260881424,
-0.2733883559703827,
-0.17903344333171844,
-0.24070075154304504,
0.24492087960243225,
-0.7916141152381897,
-0.10363562405109406,
-0.6091349720954895,
0.21428604423999786,
0.36516377329826355,
-0.009715717285871506,
0.1881498396396637,
0.0006026170449331403,
-0.37870049476623535,
-0.07195523381233215,
-0.9421470761299133,
-0.22389879822731018,
0.43074867129325867,
0.2586405575275421,
-0.30338573455810547,
0.4762119948863983,
-0.020378734916448593,
0.9839207530021667,
-0.22317412495613098,
0.19867978990077972,
0.00254559563472867,
-0.31082138419151306,
-0.543630838394165,
0.2085106521844864,
0.5261462926864624,
0.13550825417041779,
0.5001979470252991,
-0.49162963032722473,
0.20856061577796936,
0.26523861289024353,
0.35660767555236816,
-0.38147786259651184,
-0.2350960522890091,
-0.051920335739851,
-0.14361464977264404,
-0.3965505063533783,
0.19687820971012115,
-0.8892938494682312,
0.17677822709083557,
-0.525270938873291,
0.06055906042456627,
-0.8676756024360657,
0.25656554102897644,
0.2910454273223877,
0.45516330003738403,
0.5610032081604004,
0.30275362730026245,
-0.7733055949211121,
0.42338913679122925,
0.8940682411193848,
0.8536118268966675,
-0.022922908887267113,
-0.26837417483329773,
-0.6758522987365723,
0.2613885998725891,
-0.3304324746131897,
0.9428024888038635,
-0.5762754082679749,
-0.2780263423919678,
0.27611657977104187,
-0.08136091381311417,
-0.11520776897668839,
-0.6068205833435059,
0.8812478184700012,
-0.6853849291801453,
0.4755406081676483,
-0.06922708451747894,
-0.6004744172096252,
-0.5378650426864624,
0.3888111412525177,
-0.8060614466667175,
1.2378935813903809,
-0.013158146291971207,
-0.765831470489502,
0.43274879455566406,
-0.3135893642902374,
-0.328560471534729,
-0.11336634308099747,
-0.14347031712532043,
-0.624588131904602,
-0.37038490176200867,
0.27911853790283203,
0.42146554589271545,
-0.2508302927017212,
0.7448437213897705,
-0.18881362676620483,
-0.38495123386383057,
0.030452456325292587,
-0.5046592950820923,
1.1529203653335571,
0.16768860816955566,
-0.2587313950061798,
-0.06806397438049316,
-0.8818148374557495,
-0.1726149618625641,
-0.08344059437513351,
-0.3053528070449829,
-0.4472630023956299,
-0.0386747382581234,
0.07075235992670059,
-0.16621613502502441,
-0.021450068801641464,
-0.5378450751304626,
0.15595902502536774,
-0.657709002494812,
0.07754947990179062,
0.4833422601222992,
-0.03547884151339531,
0.638785719871521,
-0.49930423498153687,
0.3301467299461365,
-0.09790769219398499,
-0.049440957605838776,
0.00377727416343987,
-0.8664588332176208,
-1.0783675909042358,
-0.3769140839576721,
0.329772025346756,
0.8166883587837219,
-0.6132750511169434,
0.7916778922080994,
-0.3768162727355957,
-0.4448595941066742,
-0.676428496837616,
0.2796710133552551,
0.21988527476787567,
0.29988837242126465,
0.4445330500602722,
-0.02430596947669983,
-0.9532720446586609,
-0.7686696648597717,
0.10642015933990479,
-0.23429235816001892,
-0.06063813343644142,
0.14486423134803772,
0.4759579300880432,
-0.05454257130622864,
1.0980371236801147,
-0.35216036438941956,
-0.5726829171180725,
-0.4741753041744232,
0.4437190890312195,
0.11134302616119385,
0.38033410906791687,
0.6361814141273499,
-0.4966330826282501,
-0.20908671617507935,
0.08680355548858643,
-0.9852415919303894,
0.09384742379188538,
-0.16679486632347107,
-0.7808535695075989,
0.24248193204402924,
0.14330416917800903,
-0.23643483221530914,
0.5887904167175293,
0.4783456027507782,
-0.21344703435897827,
0.27145493030548096,
-0.3709821105003357,
0.029169943183660507,
-1.139806866645813,
-0.04510324448347092,
0.3112928867340088,
-0.120404914021492,
-0.6219854354858398,
0.050870444625616074,
-0.27872955799102783,
0.1654718518257141,
-0.29631179571151733,
0.4319438338279724,
-0.5425674915313721,
0.16626286506652832,
-0.1565479040145874,
0.33720776438713074,
0.25171661376953125,
0.3199557065963745,
0.26577988266944885,
0.5681716799736023,
0.6002002954483032,
-0.5707694292068481,
0.050708137452602386,
0.41261497139930725,
-0.4665970802307129,
0.5118895173072815,
-0.26746928691864014,
0.16877949237823486,
-0.187029168009758,
0.26919758319854736,
-0.8601670265197754,
0.16662733256816864,
0.41851335763931274,
-0.33594250679016113,
0.1305486261844635,
-0.34142258763313293,
-0.31285154819488525,
0.06333256512880325,
-0.08214081823825836,
0.2627246379852295,
0.40315380692481995,
-0.60550457239151,
0.5533968210220337,
0.34639880061149597,
0.40114498138427734,
-0.5223148465156555,
-0.9424352049827576,
0.12928999960422516,
-0.5556060671806335,
-0.490932822227478,
-0.04110201448202133,
0.13971862196922302,
-0.49885863065719604,
-0.23719710111618042,
0.36283808946609497,
-0.6347270607948303,
0.019375044852495193,
0.4077394902706146,
0.763413667678833,
-0.5335761904716492,
0.04539848119020462,
-0.025813531130552292,
-0.15817593038082123,
0.130095437169075,
-0.4506881833076477,
0.20080086588859558,
-0.23643262684345245,
-0.40790441632270813,
-0.4614570736885071,
0.2561112344264984,
0.08294876664876938,
-0.3307032287120819,
0.8194347620010376,
0.6708254814147949,
-0.5043140053749084,
-0.2573803961277008,
-0.5989896059036255,
-0.011785726062953472,
-0.3941366672515869,
-0.09870494157075882,
-0.34506770968437195,
-0.6479188203811646,
0.06978173553943634,
-0.09049233049154282,
0.19347533583641052,
0.12560170888900757,
0.21338753402233124,
0.14751286804676056,
0.1356866955757141,
0.480078786611557,
-0.4201784133911133,
0.2378968745470047,
-0.5482208132743835,
0.35992762446403503,
-0.4838143587112427,
-0.23061539232730865,
-0.6733459234237671,
-0.03971772640943527,
-0.492846816778183,
-0.8692099452018738,
-0.10130015760660172,
0.14851658046245575,
-0.0814623087644577,
0.39993733167648315,
-0.4856727421283722,
0.44049301743507385,
0.6639233827590942,
0.2599445879459381,
0.5151204466819763,
0.27627652883529663,
0.020754123106598854,
-0.14688797295093536,
-0.6375912427902222,
-1.1136221885681152,
1.1822259426116943,
-0.04233275353908539,
0.47035685181617737,
0.09185255318880081,
0.9842507839202881,
0.12119238823652267,
0.33202722668647766,
-0.5110577344894409,
0.6075301766395569,
-0.12879648804664612,
-0.36854445934295654,
-0.1266430765390396,
-0.12923564016819,
-1.209145188331604,
0.012177381664514542,
-0.3474101126194,
-0.6492502689361572,
0.10386139899492264,
-0.15992985665798187,
-0.33672887086868286,
0.47648531198501587,
-0.6568545699119568,
0.6893684267997742,
-0.014077145606279373,
-0.5614057183265686,
-0.16023612022399902,
-0.6864361763000488,
0.2676437795162201,
0.2028953731060028,
0.36483234167099,
-0.09482981264591217,
0.22594785690307617,
0.47225505113601685,
0.09802879393100739,
1.088282823562622,
0.029186353087425232,
0.01233585737645626,
0.6067864298820496,
0.3113219141960144,
0.22733661532402039,
0.2524242103099823,
-0.35379356145858765,
0.2648545503616333,
-0.15731993317604065,
-0.6008177995681763,
-0.6166013479232788,
0.744012176990509,
-0.6581863760948181,
-0.2262498438358307,
-0.2737240791320801,
-0.3289559483528137,
0.14495894312858582,
-0.09629876166582108,
0.01832355558872223,
0.4646488130092621,
-0.7172476053237915,
-0.05680212751030922,
0.784384548664093,
-0.3623580038547516,
0.11530914902687073,
0.367440402507782,
-0.10136660188436508,
-0.27163830399513245,
1.1718555688858032,
-0.2407272458076477,
0.010248709470033646,
0.7898330092430115,
-0.011674834415316582,
0.13683681190013885,
-0.4554733335971832,
-0.6085612773895264,
0.20057693123817444,
-0.6320919394493103,
0.018029725179076195,
-0.634305477142334,
-0.2211645096540451,
-0.21450915932655334,
-0.5647832751274109,
-0.2846623361110687,
-0.07007373869419098,
-0.5396879315376282,
-0.07416246086359024,
0.31025421619415283,
0.9773470163345337,
0.18053759634494781,
-0.1595253199338913,
-0.46372750401496887,
0.046077847480773926,
0.07357461750507355,
-0.24396838247776031,
-0.1755070835351944,
-0.3532196283340454,
-0.12465230375528336,
0.14889109134674072,
-0.28572866320610046,
-0.7668255567550659,
0.500924825668335,
0.3226001560688019,
0.35220035910606384,
0.6063759326934814,
0.15845274925231934,
0.7536182999610901,
-0.4818958640098572,
0.5652792453765869,
-0.2239970713853836,
-0.7107552886009216,
0.7681291103363037,
-0.14393991231918335,
0.08914744853973389,
0.6650815010070801,
0.38631653785705566,
-0.3197183609008789,
-0.7026958465576172,
-0.37436413764953613,
-0.7687668800354004,
0.29498082399368286,
0.425393283367157,
0.033552538603544235,
-0.3196110129356384,
0.3154068887233734,
0.34683093428611755,
-0.16967514157295227,
-0.7329567670822144,
-0.4132729172706604,
0.05800813436508179,
-0.47807225584983826,
0.036001820117235184,
-0.08269069343805313,
-0.01781865581870079,
-0.3991938829421997,
0.906949520111084,
-0.2052554190158844,
0.42268797755241394,
0.21573173999786377,
-0.4156048595905304,
0.23494015634059906,
0.4093542695045471,
0.6480902433395386,
0.6769352555274963,
-0.35106968879699707,
0.12576818466186523,
0.5376111268997192,
-0.27545997500419617,
-0.09884907305240631,
-0.062236182391643524,
-0.2204754650592804,
0.36024758219718933,
0.5258631706237793,
0.9737577438354492,
0.599849283695221,
-0.6035114526748657,
0.4175977110862732,
0.02392716519534588,
-0.23346003890037537,
-0.6560463905334473,
-0.2955699563026428,
0.05342278629541397,
0.17753222584724426,
0.23687660694122314,
-0.13436448574066162,
0.12214620411396027,
-0.32677045464515686,
0.5155735015869141,
0.41256386041641235,
-0.6558855772018433,
-0.18468444049358368,
0.6721926331520081,
-0.14423300325870514,
-0.15408939123153687,
0.6617568135261536,
-0.18365702033042908,
-0.10659680515527725,
0.6277174949645996,
0.41909265518188477,
0.6977366209030151,
0.03210441768169403,
0.6242352724075317,
0.733633279800415,
0.4348425269126892,
0.10451752692461014,
-0.04878927767276764,
-0.17439399659633636,
-0.6790782809257507,
-0.28760161995887756,
-0.5863918662071228,
-0.37966281175613403,
-0.02991405688226223,
-0.9968160390853882,
0.6026976108551025,
-0.1637180596590042,
0.24587233364582062,
-0.05326564237475395,
0.0169103741645813,
-0.7029539942741394,
0.16190151870250702,
0.29300591349601746,
0.7316505312919617,
-0.8507030606269836,
1.279774785041809,
0.6017631888389587,
-0.31093287467956543,
-0.33169957995414734,
-0.08644852042198181,
-0.07040971517562866,
-0.7930233478546143,
0.9730740785598755,
0.3512239158153534,
-0.30643558502197266,
-0.045402634888887405,
-0.3171870708465576,
-0.3745196461677551,
1.008510708808899,
0.5458039045333862,
-0.502494752407074,
-0.2484072893857956,
0.31657955050468445,
0.501050591468811,
-0.5630633234977722,
0.439831018447876,
0.407356858253479,
0.35724174976348877,
-0.12919875979423523,
-0.1957726925611496,
-0.2419421672821045,
0.05212799087166786,
-0.14074376225471497,
0.07092238962650299,
-0.22201505303382874,
0.30194321274757385,
-0.1842913031578064,
-0.3107990622520447,
0.37457042932510376,
1.1042256355285645,
0.30034568905830383,
0.5994037985801697,
0.35276156663894653,
0.6022754907608032,
0.7354477047920227,
-0.19051635265350342,
0.7497445940971375,
-0.450310081243515,
0.36421480774879456,
1.4514546394348145,
-0.283832311630249,
1.1399623155593872,
0.5372205972671509,
-0.05840826779603958,
0.8662564158439636,
0.594117283821106,
-0.10100585967302322,
0.4432617127895355,
0.2732485830783844,
-0.772099494934082,
-0.1800955832004547,
-0.056006964296102524,
-0.010909409262239933,
0.48065945506095886,
0.30964532494544983,
-0.4013928771018982,
-0.4610348641872406,
0.26173022389411926,
-0.04404960572719574,
0.37913137674331665,
0.305593878030777,
0.6561835408210754,
-0.03577228635549545,
-0.5241243839263916,
0.5225018262863159,
-0.14782759547233582,
0.5019720196723938,
-0.4625202715396881,
-0.25202417373657227,
-0.13258928060531616,
0.0258187185972929,
0.057724181562662125,
-0.5433084964752197,
0.5666770935058594,
0.030707689002156258,
0.1450858861207962,
-0.1524754911661148,
0.3403962254524231,
-0.6222137212753296,
-0.7883496284484863,
0.5102279782295227,
0.41716036200523376,
0.23814518749713898,
0.2804185152053833,
-0.4522669017314911,
-0.10468213260173798,
-0.043873999267816544,
0.06630150973796844,
0.23075096309185028,
0.6275514364242554,
-0.045683227479457855,
0.5804996490478516,
0.41998279094696045,
-0.08349677920341492,
0.2068900614976883,
0.00894829723984003,
0.7239647507667542,
-0.36219945549964905,
-0.16872812807559967,
-0.8765357732772827,
0.16848483681678772,
0.023357942700386047,
-0.33181917667388916,
0.7223988175392151,
1.0176596641540527,
1.0745781660079956,
0.028661254793405533,
0.6062291860580444,
0.2606928050518036,
0.22686436772346497,
-0.7524503469467163,
0.5259552597999573,
-0.20277592539787292,
0.20473119616508484,
-0.07016558945178986,
-0.7322093844413757,
-0.5701874494552612,
0.8595625162124634,
-0.6615059971809387,
-0.3950619399547577,
0.9525399208068848,
0.9825358390808105,
-0.1359604150056839,
0.37053072452545166,
0.4332663118839264,
-0.2791033387184143,
-0.1649940013885498,
0.8347309231758118,
0.5712790489196777,
-0.6686123013496399,
0.5907558798789978,
-0.552542507648468,
-0.03461240977048874,
0.13166819512844086,
-0.6116941571235657,
-1.2476590871810913,
-0.8489101529121399,
-0.397239625453949,
-0.40730929374694824,
0.6191067695617676,
0.9494045376777649,
0.809818685054779,
-1.1174532175064087,
-0.443929523229599,
-0.47961220145225525,
0.11524680256843567,
-0.1167219877243042,
-0.2175114005804062,
0.46448394656181335,
-0.25945210456848145,
-1.0365941524505615,
0.5548064112663269,
0.21556612849235535,
-0.2406514286994934,
-0.19140110909938812,
-0.13796669244766235,
-0.8148773312568665,
-0.09506843984127045,
0.4049122929573059,
0.1368722766637802,
-0.8943746089935303,
-0.18343664705753326,
-0.31349122524261475,
-0.21652619540691376,
0.516432523727417,
0.9469577670097351,
-0.8092980980873108,
0.47368699312210083,
0.08766783773899078,
0.9246816635131836,
0.38864681124687195,
-0.2503963112831116,
0.5482962131500244,
-0.6661826968193054,
0.44253966212272644,
-0.034367483109235764,
0.17240524291992188,
0.3269830644130707,
-0.37933751940727234,
0.5892705917358398,
0.17215357720851898,
-0.44524863362312317,
-0.504319429397583,
0.18833689391613007,
-1.059779167175293,
-0.11156619340181351,
0.9431402087211609,
-0.5239303708076477,
-0.49969497323036194,
-0.5474373698234558,
-0.40584486722946167,
0.6580594182014465,
-0.20431023836135864,
0.8461360335350037,
0.6199241876602173,
0.4706262946128845,
-0.04533316195011139,
-1.1302821636199951,
0.13526879251003265,
0.548194944858551,
-0.9900122880935669,
-0.14262263476848602,
0.37935683131217957,
0.058386482298374176,
-0.04924914240837097,
0.22520408034324646,
0.06422054767608643,
-0.10011208802461624,
-0.14227798581123352,
0.148432195186615,
0.21633106470108032,
-0.2652263343334198,
-0.26069995760917664,
0.17446918785572052,
-0.01430680975317955,
-0.4083535969257355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11874v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11874v2
|
xFinder: Robust and Pinpoint Answer Extraction for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-20T08:30:13 | 2024-05-23T07:00:45 |
Qingchen Yu, Zifan Zheng, Shichao Song, Zhiyu Li, Feiyu Xiong, Bo Tang, Ding Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The continuous advancement of large language models (LLMs) has brought
increasing attention to the critical issue of developing fair and reliable
methods for evaluating their performance. Particularly, the emergence of
subjective or non-subjective cheating phenomena, such as test set leakage and
prompt format overfitting, poses significant challenges to the reliable
evaluation of LLMs. Since evaluation frameworks often utilize Regular
Expression (RegEx) for answer extraction, some models may adjust their
responses to comply with specific formats that are easily extractable by RegEx.
Nevertheless, the key answer extraction module based on RegEx frequently
suffers from extraction errors. This paper conducts a comprehensive analysis of
the entire LLM evaluation chain, demonstrating that optimizing the key answer
extraction module can improve extraction accuracy, reduce LLMs' reliance on
specific answer formats, and enhance the reliability of LLM evaluation. To
address these issues, we propose xFinder, a model specifically designed for key
answer extraction. As part of this process, we create a specialized dataset,
the Key Answer Finder (KAF) dataset, to ensure effective model training and
evaluation. Through generalization testing and evaluation in real-world
scenarios, the results demonstrate that the smallest xFinder model with only
500 million parameters achieves an average answer extraction accuracy of
93.42%. In contrast, RegEx accuracy in the best evaluation framework is 74.38%.
xFinder exhibits stronger robustness and higher accuracy compared to existing
evaluation frameworks.
|
[
-0.1911979764699936,
-0.6455796360969543,
0.9206396341323853,
0.026547178626060486,
-0.3083670139312744,
0.18140453100204468,
-0.19840234518051147,
-0.3165452778339386,
-0.30665460228919983,
0.32590538263320923,
-0.5673289895057678,
-0.652479887008667,
-0.7692805528640747,
0.013753599487245083,
-0.4388555586338043,
0.7244405746459961,
0.054156772792339325,
0.05407651141285896,
-0.13425219058990479,
-0.27392545342445374,
-0.5424547791481018,
-0.541251540184021,
-0.6471986174583435,
-0.11002308875322342,
0.4068424701690674,
0.4845004379749298,
0.7171744704246521,
1.0636353492736816,
0.6562028527259827,
0.2742016613483429,
-0.14323769509792328,
0.022493835538625717,
-0.3285217881202698,
0.25572100281715393,
-0.347037136554718,
-0.711089015007019,
-0.6392950415611267,
0.21601584553718567,
0.6970289945602417,
0.31775665283203125,
-0.22002346813678741,
0.7267586588859558,
-0.18213486671447754,
0.3515975773334503,
-0.5283518433570862,
0.3970426619052887,
-0.803802490234375,
-0.19980815052986145,
-0.21657755970954895,
-0.09554537385702133,
-0.3058794140815735,
-0.4789307415485382,
0.09241608530282974,
-0.48794233798980713,
0.19465510547161102,
0.043970901519060135,
0.9141395092010498,
0.18375341594219208,
-0.13510142266750336,
-0.32013025879859924,
-0.5628793835639954,
1.0514503717422485,
-0.9111977219581604,
0.43654200434684753,
0.39967048168182373,
0.6758756041526794,
-0.18406374752521515,
-0.5356879234313965,
-0.6226142644882202,
-0.11008905619382858,
0.0864899531006813,
-0.04251363128423691,
-0.07724393159151077,
-0.006648028269410133,
0.17205750942230225,
0.41627025604248047,
-0.774628758430481,
0.1704755574464798,
0.014050750061869621,
-0.043575040996074677,
0.8164650201797485,
0.44811052083969116,
0.20484629273414612,
-0.3167845904827118,
-0.07710874825716019,
-0.2984207272529602,
-0.663643479347229,
0.3267585039138794,
0.13608480989933014,
0.4331626892089844,
0.22879080474376678,
0.3744460940361023,
-0.21244464814662933,
0.7878228425979614,
-0.027100779116153717,
-0.5880606770515442,
0.07347624003887177,
-0.41114622354507446,
-0.2583921551704407,
-0.3943824768066406,
0.7855581045150757,
0.3170064091682434,
0.33268800377845764,
-0.3072744905948639,
-0.34943097829818726,
-0.03624461963772774,
-0.056448694318532944,
-0.7809937000274658,
-0.08224793523550034,
0.40862470865249634,
-0.6085264682769775,
-0.7151910066604614,
0.09822963178157806,
-0.9567126035690308,
-0.26030370593070984,
0.1441807895898819,
0.26015275716781616,
-0.0360698327422142,
-0.062414899468421936,
0.17779222130775452,
-0.12558557093143463,
0.6014059782028198,
0.2801816463470459,
-0.5848332643508911,
0.43392038345336914,
0.791233241558075,
0.739107608795166,
-0.3289526402950287,
0.22998742759227753,
-0.8768439292907715,
-0.13332845270633698,
-0.190596342086792,
0.688411295413971,
-0.7118477821350098,
-0.42200493812561035,
-0.27430057525634766,
0.08699031174182892,
-0.01714738830924034,
-0.7031652927398682,
0.5826437473297119,
-0.8300652503967285,
0.22178015112876892,
-0.3018942177295685,
-0.5556482076644897,
-0.056107137352228165,
0.6257154941558838,
-0.8143793344497681,
1.0116612911224365,
0.04313061013817787,
-0.3437504172325134,
0.37533149123191833,
-0.6205549836158752,
-0.07097326964139938,
0.04025188088417053,
-0.43285655975341797,
-0.451028048992157,
0.14617182314395905,
0.3274785578250885,
0.2384033203125,
-0.7512478232383728,
0.3150074779987335,
-0.42917490005493164,
-0.4481566846370697,
0.5382797718048096,
-0.5408074259757996,
0.725753903388977,
0.04512305557727814,
-0.4604700207710266,
0.06901941448450089,
-1.0199016332626343,
0.4789649248123169,
0.28075194358825684,
-0.5429527163505554,
-0.010552994906902313,
0.04313685745000839,
-0.002027180278673768,
0.5149634480476379,
0.07168151438236237,
-0.8979817032814026,
0.059525199234485626,
-0.22704121470451355,
0.08328131586313248,
1.0378327369689941,
-0.008537954650819302,
0.25109347701072693,
-0.39152488112449646,
1.1048951148986816,
-0.3076540529727936,
0.08650293946266174,
-0.25413960218429565,
-0.5411065220832825,
-0.4043036699295044,
-0.47713035345077515,
0.4159926474094391,
0.6639571189880371,
-0.10975499451160431,
0.47465670108795166,
-0.4187812805175781,
-0.554309606552124,
-0.6829886436462402,
0.5503113269805908,
0.6222679018974304,
0.5858995318412781,
0.10171357542276382,
-0.02343817427754402,
-0.37844958901405334,
-0.6748086214065552,
-0.2541298568248749,
-0.2620415687561035,
-0.0032263544853776693,
0.3512948453426361,
0.16068914532661438,
0.09776150435209274,
1.1437413692474365,
-0.686674952507019,
-0.19637085497379303,
-0.3603050112724304,
-0.24737104773521423,
0.6020556092262268,
0.21813762187957764,
0.24595414102077484,
-0.8756377100944519,
-0.5990690588951111,
0.07850717753171921,
-0.6162433624267578,
-0.23937542736530304,
0.005809457041323185,
0.0035437934566289186,
-0.0824066773056984,
0.3399985730648041,
-0.6599630117416382,
0.36371898651123047,
0.477810800075531,
-0.26482030749320984,
0.5815171003341675,
0.27153459191322327,
-0.07566545903682709,
-0.8112733364105225,
0.5950269103050232,
-0.14580826461315155,
-0.651949405670166,
-0.27606987953186035,
0.48539307713508606,
0.07367398589849472,
0.08959092944860458,
-0.23172682523727417,
0.8367844820022583,
-0.36373060941696167,
0.006968510802835226,
-0.24596580862998962,
0.4989214241504669,
0.19559000432491302,
0.3239060044288635,
-0.15376338362693787,
0.7869819402694702,
0.11474226415157318,
-0.07177668809890747,
0.5122600197792053,
0.4796011745929718,
-0.4308865964412689,
0.14982189238071442,
-0.7510131001472473,
0.3857162892818451,
-0.05454742908477783,
-0.12988072633743286,
-1.2163439989089966,
-0.05691290646791458,
0.1525801122188568,
-0.48605877161026,
0.3513604700565338,
-0.25498440861701965,
-0.5870746970176697,
-0.06246037781238556,
-0.43735721707344055,
0.11453961580991745,
0.7013334035873413,
-0.5010562539100647,
0.3821651339530945,
0.2932935059070587,
-0.42886465787887573,
-0.6301093697547913,
-0.13083302974700928,
-0.07840836048126221,
-0.20515577495098114,
-0.6554818153381348,
-0.16528694331645966,
-0.2071669101715088,
-0.2878209054470062,
-0.193008691072464,
-0.3992026746273041,
-0.1713615208864212,
0.45277732610702515,
0.170497328042984,
0.46122869849205017,
-0.2600031793117523,
0.149586483836174,
-0.17407862842082977,
-0.3744170665740967,
0.1334945559501648,
0.10453319549560547,
0.5461039543151855,
-0.03705335035920143,
-0.2670849561691284,
-0.16117392480373383,
0.535312831401825,
0.7071290016174316,
-0.5862456560134888,
0.5225341320037842,
0.1281946897506714,
-0.24304494261741638,
-0.13476090133190155,
-0.4009971618652344,
-0.0447634719312191,
-0.4733140766620636,
0.7168228626251221,
-0.5361841320991516,
-0.7267807722091675,
0.7919152975082397,
0.12577173113822937,
0.30222389101982117,
0.2316141426563263,
0.335472971200943,
0.14220117032527924,
1.523506999015808,
0.8911759853363037,
0.03346297889947891,
0.13558457791805267,
0.03363155573606491,
0.2870832681655884,
-0.6215763688087463,
-0.2626993656158447,
-0.697488009929657,
-0.1086948961019516,
-0.30915433168411255,
-0.20562376081943512,
0.2887350022792816,
0.1590925008058548,
0.20710928738117218,
0.033370740711688995,
-0.14162105321884155,
0.5611473321914673,
0.27118268609046936,
-0.08011404424905777,
0.6370182633399963,
-0.1353953778743744,
-0.03789335861802101,
-0.13950373232364655,
-0.4391079545021057,
-0.889301061630249,
1.2352046966552734,
0.5553635358810425,
0.7761598825454712,
0.27781209349632263,
0.5062029361724854,
-0.0009903566678985953,
0.5798569917678833,
-0.9612141251564026,
0.5057867169380188,
-0.12199731171131134,
-0.8763903379440308,
-0.37000277638435364,
-0.411194771528244,
-0.49503716826438904,
0.22272533178329468,
0.038029856979846954,
-0.8955093026161194,
0.160364031791687,
0.03662959486246109,
-0.5837721824645996,
0.09124636650085449,
-0.4341573417186737,
1.0332443714141846,
-0.1899346113204956,
-0.16487908363342285,
0.23972900211811066,
-0.7202877402305603,
0.40382444858551025,
-0.7199336290359497,
0.08737342059612274,
-0.23082295060157776,
-0.04238850250840187,
0.7921003103256226,
-0.31467223167419434,
0.4646145701408386,
-0.13351593911647797,
-0.26816532015800476,
-0.02084215357899666,
0.042931780219078064,
0.550154983997345,
0.07168249040842056,
-0.35735517740249634,
-0.21906568109989166,
0.40747031569480896,
-0.31108376383781433,
-0.947547435760498,
0.48193517327308655,
-0.6307514309883118,
-0.7899033427238464,
-0.2282443791627884,
-0.5989890694618225,
-0.4739789664745331,
0.29752665758132935,
0.16091518104076385,
0.43744122982025146,
-0.10283026844263077,
-0.02338843233883381,
0.7904359698295593,
-0.1943356841802597,
0.3377387821674347,
0.6772680878639221,
-0.6182783246040344,
-0.2753562331199646,
0.7732896208763123,
0.03188638389110565,
0.3432646095752716,
0.22643406689167023,
0.2615201771259308,
-0.38219431042671204,
-0.6305350065231323,
-0.44923025369644165,
0.24136216938495636,
-0.9034311771392822,
-0.5433269143104553,
-0.5237219333648682,
-0.16347651183605194,
-0.3936516046524048,
0.1682278960943222,
-0.24539165198802948,
-0.44967570900917053,
0.07532663643360138,
-0.3354550004005432,
0.12684138119220734,
0.6721231937408447,
0.10209456086158752,
0.7177243232727051,
-1.1598197221755981,
0.2185521125793457,
0.1969701647758484,
0.29017823934555054,
-0.024352600798010826,
-0.5503139495849609,
-0.19057999551296234,
-0.09350790828466415,
-0.07623735815286636,
-1.0603492259979248,
0.19874246418476105,
0.35808390378952026,
0.6562310457229614,
0.550064206123352,
-0.15994280576705933,
0.7057110071182251,
-0.2956656515598297,
0.42741432785987854,
-0.21454104781150818,
-0.8728278875350952,
0.3240481913089752,
-0.12223183363676071,
0.3721579313278198,
0.8273592591285706,
0.2837405204772949,
-0.5651978850364685,
-0.3752254545688629,
-0.36636173725128174,
-0.6871321797370911,
0.6150072813034058,
-0.05057564377784729,
-0.012344107031822205,
-0.04335949942469597,
0.6594272255897522,
0.2491217702627182,
0.19697187840938568,
-0.6758373379707336,
-0.14798758924007416,
0.36151212453842163,
-0.4091343879699707,
-0.15622994303703308,
-0.3003687560558319,
-0.00007266696047736332,
0.02713763900101185,
0.5676561594009399,
-0.215336412191391,
-0.054197125136852264,
0.09579477459192276,
-0.28806746006011963,
-0.21601280570030212,
0.21489976346492767,
0.13171888887882233,
0.8067594170570374,
-0.6137017011642456,
0.07351532578468323,
-0.10363920778036118,
-0.6501892805099487,
0.3845161497592926,
0.1325293779373169,
-0.14025922119617462,
0.1234087124466896,
0.5699617862701416,
0.09305058419704437,
-0.2496906816959381,
-1.080629587173462,
0.9297406077384949,
-0.32406842708587646,
0.3080436587333679,
-0.19020462036132812,
0.16242846846580505,
-0.13300631940364838,
0.0477299764752388,
0.4676644504070282,
-0.1766781061887741,
0.17633900046348572,
-0.4022057056427002,
0.33814743161201477,
0.6223207712173462,
-0.49245139956474304,
-0.3761906921863556,
0.5170073509216309,
-0.1074119433760643,
-0.22528430819511414,
0.6460260152816772,
-0.15030355751514435,
-0.6632013916969299,
0.515648365020752,
0.5377735495567322,
0.9615030884742737,
-0.34534934163093567,
0.13741053640842438,
0.1419222503900528,
0.3426083028316498,
0.19295184314250946,
0.5209853649139404,
-0.2066253125667572,
-0.5897511839866638,
-0.7217853665351868,
-0.7223591804504395,
-0.21929340064525604,
0.09604815393686295,
-0.9941693544387817,
0.2586984932422638,
-0.5910725593566895,
-0.06811543554067612,
-0.10879036039113998,
0.21279996633529663,
-0.6661373972892761,
0.3596610426902771,
0.007830112241208553,
1.3001006841659546,
-0.958504319190979,
0.8271052837371826,
0.5645946264266968,
-0.22277820110321045,
-0.926223874092102,
-0.23156921565532684,
-0.0018667292315512896,
-0.9380870461463928,
0.6185110807418823,
0.36385294795036316,
-0.08900068700313568,
-0.14348238706588745,
-0.7612152695655823,
-0.9441227912902832,
0.9843978881835938,
0.38612475991249084,
-0.758512020111084,
-0.12032067775726318,
0.23800237476825714,
0.37328436970710754,
-0.30602335929870605,
0.26145291328430176,
0.927416205406189,
0.5447580218315125,
0.03578563407063484,
-0.8428242802619934,
0.3803022801876068,
-0.38165774941444397,
-0.1816399097442627,
0.2200392186641693,
-0.43597495555877686,
0.3988291025161743,
-0.07674943655729294,
-0.34073230624198914,
0.6032488942146301,
0.15363432466983795,
0.46337395906448364,
-0.02468038536608219,
0.4448299705982208,
0.46871834993362427,
0.7597368955612183,
-0.021863404661417007,
1.0230892896652222,
-0.08381892740726471,
0.29706117510795593,
1.358396291732788,
-0.5035943388938904,
1.0097558498382568,
0.46492379903793335,
-0.049036119133234024,
0.3317702114582062,
0.5249984264373779,
-0.015313833020627499,
0.5984992980957031,
0.24395650625228882,
-0.2199728786945343,
-0.4712027609348297,
0.2036752849817276,
0.07327210158109665,
0.7188355326652527,
0.14343170821666718,
-0.5261704921722412,
-0.40688735246658325,
-0.286154568195343,
0.2849943935871124,
-0.04388406500220299,
-0.013099411502480507,
0.6480117440223694,
0.04017901048064232,
-0.5271178483963013,
0.10387250036001205,
0.2600315511226654,
0.2167433649301529,
-0.6594562530517578,
-0.3153790533542633,
-0.44406652450561523,
0.35215991735458374,
-0.14736133813858032,
-0.630729079246521,
0.1279512196779251,
0.1227717250585556,
-0.36427193880081177,
0.06337288022041321,
0.5875426530838013,
-0.2149704098701477,
-0.5103224515914917,
0.3012586832046509,
0.6550101041793823,
0.09594917297363281,
-0.2624094784259796,
-0.6259110569953918,
0.2858859598636627,
0.10365235060453415,
-0.2672642469406128,
0.13246583938598633,
0.04965943098068237,
-0.22034117579460144,
0.773582398891449,
0.756252646446228,
0.16956974565982819,
0.3249287009239197,
-0.4121706187725067,
0.8486540913581848,
-0.7398737072944641,
-0.33821961283683777,
-0.9885381460189819,
0.5250709652900696,
-0.2022540420293808,
-0.35099393129348755,
0.9872532486915588,
0.521591067314148,
0.4007236063480377,
0.242903470993042,
0.8031489253044128,
0.10253365337848663,
0.7255962491035461,
-0.2352963238954544,
0.6547800898551941,
-0.2698054611682892,
0.44819357991218567,
-0.3353309631347656,
-1.1835911273956299,
-0.4844823479652405,
0.4754940867424011,
-0.26692190766334534,
0.016628937795758247,
0.3979438245296478,
0.8499082922935486,
-0.0896027535200119,
-0.1761864274740219,
0.4578392803668976,
0.18393900990486145,
0.8173524141311646,
0.50331050157547,
0.8905586004257202,
-0.5488824844360352,
0.746220588684082,
0.007677567657083273,
-0.6172492504119873,
0.11654844880104065,
-0.8348531126976013,
-0.697868824005127,
-0.2342984825372696,
-0.24582159519195557,
-0.27916285395622253,
-0.06159968301653862,
0.6990028619766235,
0.750407338142395,
-0.7933245301246643,
-0.32886019349098206,
0.25613805651664734,
0.20507772266864777,
0.012440891936421394,
-0.2615317106246948,
0.46530407667160034,
-0.2937023639678955,
-0.5561122894287109,
0.4138045907020569,
0.325762003660202,
-0.1099209114909172,
-0.39141035079956055,
-0.01525275781750679,
-0.02233441174030304,
0.12238255143165588,
0.2144474983215332,
0.1684158891439438,
-0.4774489402770996,
-0.31861019134521484,
0.6195618510246277,
0.043775565922260284,
0.12634721398353577,
0.49465951323509216,
-0.7209514379501343,
0.6085729002952576,
0.3784506022930145,
0.6860958933830261,
0.1310984194278717,
0.20546524226665497,
0.8753989934921265,
-0.45448267459869385,
-0.28102558851242065,
0.07763069123029709,
0.26055261492729187,
0.30900582671165466,
-0.24423061311244965,
0.36986634135246277,
-0.041101500391960144,
-0.48909327387809753,
-1.0626845359802246,
0.17991803586483002,
-0.8277155160903931,
0.016720261424779892,
1.0554150342941284,
-0.611531138420105,
-0.44187986850738525,
-0.23555240035057068,
-0.20787683129310608,
-0.12383470684289932,
-0.1462516486644745,
0.6674665808677673,
0.8197280764579773,
0.04871848225593567,
-0.2452239990234375,
-0.40496399998664856,
0.33994096517562866,
0.32197797298431396,
-0.6981031894683838,
0.1215677261352539,
0.24222411215305328,
0.6862524151802063,
0.3138771057128906,
0.43399572372436523,
-0.5680901408195496,
0.48154735565185547,
-0.30948150157928467,
-0.14203208684921265,
0.045321546494960785,
-0.1936100870370865,
-0.7821248769760132,
0.30025261640548706,
0.5979949831962585,
-0.3074968457221985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11870v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11870v2
|
Intuitive Fine-Tuning: Towards Simplifying Alignment into a Single Process
| 2024-05-20T08:23:28 | 2024-05-28T16:14:58 |
Ermo Hua, Biqing Qi, Kaiyan Zhang, Yue Yu, Ning Ding, Xingtai Lv, Kai Tian, Bowen Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Preference Optimization (PO) are two
fundamental processes for enhancing the capabilities of Language Models (LMs)
post pre-training, aligning them better with human preferences. Although SFT
advances in training efficiency, PO delivers better alignment, thus they are
often combined. However, common practices simply apply them sequentially
without integrating their optimization objectives, ignoring the opportunities
to bridge their paradigm gap and take the strengths from both. To obtain a
unified understanding, we interpret SFT and PO with two sub-processes --
Preference Estimation and Transition Optimization -- defined at token level
within the Markov Decision Process (MDP) framework. This modeling shows that
SFT is only a specialized case of PO with inferior estimation and optimization.
PO evaluates the quality of model's entire generated answer, whereas SFT only
scores predicted tokens based on preceding tokens from target answers.
Therefore, SFT overestimates the ability of model, leading to inferior
optimization. Building on this view, we introduce Intuitive Fine-Tuning (IFT)
to integrate SFT and Preference Optimization into a single process. IFT
captures LMs' intuitive sense of the entire answers through a temporal residual
connection, but it solely relies on a single policy and the same volume of
non-preference-labeled data as SFT. Our experiments show that IFT performs
comparably or even superiorly to sequential recipes of SFT and some typical
Preference Optimization methods across several tasks, particularly those
requires generation, reasoning, and fact-following abilities. An explainable
Frozen Lake game further validates the effectiveness of IFT for getting
competitive policy.
|
[
-0.6525387763977051,
-0.939771294593811,
0.783294677734375,
-0.14765037596225739,
-0.3497953414916992,
-0.07479879260063171,
-0.4618530571460724,
-0.056414831429719925,
0.01599705219268799,
0.5534909963607788,
-0.9502781629562378,
-0.29299336671829224,
-0.48943963646888733,
-0.14897899329662323,
0.046768222004175186,
1.241121530532837,
-0.0797903761267662,
-0.030439699068665504,
-0.02169634960591793,
-0.11310899257659912,
-0.4978054165840149,
-0.10569435358047485,
-0.9210705757141113,
-0.3958226144313812,
0.31466206908226013,
0.5344414710998535,
1.0876479148864746,
1.0434244871139526,
0.43271657824516296,
0.2756085693836212,
0.1362336128950119,
0.2740870714187622,
-0.5409190654754639,
-0.12157625705003738,
-0.39664220809936523,
-0.47750169038772583,
-0.38366368412971497,
0.08951244503259659,
0.24275951087474823,
0.7670463919639587,
-0.11036169528961182,
0.22812116146087646,
0.3170127868652344,
1.0121512413024902,
-0.5743913054466248,
0.14790432155132294,
-0.7711610794067383,
0.034623049199581146,
-0.052872754633426666,
-0.5092735886573792,
-0.10135123133659363,
-0.3203258812427521,
0.38137078285217285,
-0.7672897577285767,
0.0017503744456917048,
0.08389261364936829,
0.8916318416595459,
0.7644506692886353,
-0.31544381380081177,
-0.06643850356340408,
-0.4662666320800781,
0.7330817580223083,
-0.6662687063217163,
0.22054633498191833,
0.26286038756370544,
0.1413058042526245,
-0.26478147506713867,
-0.2960430085659027,
-0.47616949677467346,
-0.1422516256570816,
0.038052864372730255,
0.05094091594219208,
-0.03965461999177933,
0.4887904226779938,
0.19703859090805054,
0.12499526143074036,
-0.37826526165008545,
0.327240526676178,
-0.06724376231431961,
0.053018804639577866,
0.6161975860595703,
0.1317051351070404,
0.05140060931444168,
0.22965915501117706,
-0.2405073642730713,
0.12184001505374908,
-0.40019649267196655,
0.352687805891037,
0.49943211674690247,
0.5266944169998169,
0.08234971016645432,
0.526669442653656,
-0.3825368881225586,
0.6729976534843445,
0.6436553597450256,
-0.22572743892669678,
0.08170697093009949,
-0.11343158781528473,
-0.12440092861652374,
0.26199302077293396,
0.7451743483543396,
0.6676990985870361,
0.4763632118701935,
-0.13031885027885437,
-0.1866672784090042,
0.12622953951358795,
0.22032932937145233,
-0.62180095911026,
-0.23077167570590973,
0.3375805616378784,
-0.4376303255558014,
-0.26957690715789795,
-0.01297846157103777,
-0.16499967873096466,
-0.05253027752041817,
-1.0163229703903198,
0.4264504909515381,
-0.4187329113483429,
-0.30574795603752136,
0.5006099343299866,
-0.1187773197889328,
-0.04748791828751564,
0.22974765300750732,
-1.1529189348220825,
0.30369067192077637,
1.0160690546035767,
0.6218987703323364,
-0.3640260100364685,
-0.34869128465652466,
-0.510755717754364,
-0.06810010969638824,
-0.4260023832321167,
0.7663328647613525,
-0.5227658748626709,
-0.15414083003997803,
-0.2950177490711212,
-0.22958272695541382,
-0.10008656233549118,
-0.40038001537323,
0.6719536185264587,
-0.3863637447357178,
0.1336333155632019,
-0.22216075658798218,
-0.5880007743835449,
-0.09491369128227234,
0.05163169652223587,
-0.3196316957473755,
0.9883367419242859,
-0.1426836997270584,
-0.7884035110473633,
0.9373424649238586,
-0.8406862020492554,
-0.355491042137146,
-0.24036365747451782,
0.022039510309696198,
-0.20061112940311432,
0.23480257391929626,
0.3207065165042877,
0.496802419424057,
-0.3272760808467865,
0.4051227271556854,
-0.6446937322616577,
-0.1559159755706787,
-0.056347932666540146,
-0.199443057179451,
0.42400115728378296,
0.4117111563682556,
-0.19433026015758514,
0.41787293553352356,
-0.7335867881774902,
0.3009486198425293,
-0.1473560333251953,
-0.3009704351425171,
-0.462188720703125,
0.22886574268341064,
-0.23996618390083313,
0.24551068246364594,
0.4371716380119324,
-0.27468281984329224,
0.4236288070678711,
-0.4373314082622528,
0.507313072681427,
0.9615532755851746,
-0.0437089242041111,
0.8830732703208923,
-0.1862812340259552,
0.33683034777641296,
0.016947520896792412,
0.35631272196769714,
0.000024045235477387905,
-0.2080390304327011,
-0.7067520618438721,
-0.12535589933395386,
0.0999310314655304,
0.5212078094482422,
-0.4928445518016815,
0.6498314738273621,
-0.240401953458786,
-0.3417236804962158,
-0.8199250102043152,
0.04758281260728836,
0.12828423082828522,
0.7731532454490662,
0.29987290501594543,
-0.3277641236782074,
-0.326984703540802,
-1.1240755319595337,
-0.5324899554252625,
0.023141298443078995,
0.13249020278453827,
0.06308489292860031,
0.05965975299477577,
0.09289159625768661,
1.1427215337753296,
-0.5482834577560425,
-0.1661590039730072,
-0.04028773307800293,
0.15170004963874817,
0.5660654902458191,
0.6167834997177124,
0.4376603364944458,
-0.8583368062973022,
-0.6171364188194275,
0.33036699891090393,
-0.38665255904197693,
-0.1579880714416504,
-0.2406703233718872,
-0.14922770857810974,
0.17821115255355835,
0.3653985261917114,
-0.3293980658054352,
0.22124241292476654,
0.14557570219039917,
-0.10571449249982834,
0.3928345739841461,
-0.27037134766578674,
0.30630725622177124,
-0.7064898610115051,
-0.2239178717136383,
-0.04604122415184975,
-0.0012190836714580655,
-0.5919690132141113,
0.09760395437479019,
-0.052521366626024246,
0.2429226189851761,
-0.17192532122135162,
0.29353100061416626,
-0.31241273880004883,
0.21618300676345825,
-0.2368566244840622,
-0.0898100808262825,
-0.22883029282093048,
0.6298564672470093,
0.20240840315818787,
0.6200176477432251,
0.7325441241264343,
-0.6510723829269409,
0.04272312670946121,
-0.11640074849128723,
-0.24111180007457733,
0.6253463625907898,
-0.46566644310951233,
-0.025345321744680405,
-0.25772368907928467,
-0.2374926060438156,
-0.92531418800354,
0.0015865814639255404,
0.03653847053647041,
-0.1505136787891388,
0.2847380042076111,
-0.4258968234062195,
-0.600942075252533,
-0.06114515662193298,
-0.2531602382659912,
0.10575305670499802,
0.5019524097442627,
-0.3456753194332123,
0.4535203278064728,
0.2540420889854431,
-0.13896432518959045,
-0.5657106041908264,
-0.3954595625400543,
-0.25796547532081604,
-0.5250793099403381,
-0.6847147345542908,
0.04452981799840927,
-0.12260353565216064,
-0.09206078946590424,
-0.11893273890018463,
-0.4904763102531433,
-0.04356107488274574,
0.3202194571495056,
-0.01672700047492981,
0.07294391095638275,
-0.4941836893558502,
-0.06275641918182373,
0.48895180225372314,
-0.4043697714805603,
-0.19214342534542084,
-0.7015394568443298,
0.3473544120788574,
-0.1981259286403656,
-0.3728092312812805,
-0.5131128430366516,
0.25209906697273254,
0.5997608304023743,
-0.17596757411956787,
0.600970983505249,
0.47430381178855896,
0.06212397292256355,
0.015639323741197586,
-0.5062949061393738,
-0.2425493746995926,
-0.4739874005317688,
0.15477724373340607,
-0.7013154625892639,
-0.7628627419471741,
0.3804391324520111,
-0.3634650707244873,
0.3120470643043518,
0.38156673312187195,
0.3220699727535248,
-0.08802062273025513,
1.4741078615188599,
0.5940572023391724,
0.16287705302238464,
0.7245544791221619,
-0.03274213895201683,
0.2884189784526825,
-0.49059855937957764,
0.016801653429865837,
-0.4285030663013458,
-0.4587148129940033,
-0.6710687875747681,
0.14656837284564972,
0.4152906835079193,
0.5053659677505493,
-0.5405036211013794,
0.32733026146888733,
-0.691286563873291,
0.8078592419624329,
0.6533871293067932,
0.14850746095180511,
0.3579120337963104,
-0.0764775350689888,
-0.2975301742553711,
-0.34821224212646484,
-0.7944443225860596,
-0.5370159149169922,
0.9475933909416199,
0.15428020060062408,
0.8198255300521851,
-0.1454296112060547,
0.8327117562294006,
-0.026085108518600464,
0.02654990740120411,
-0.8769631385803223,
0.2842356264591217,
-0.3186407685279846,
-0.3876664638519287,
-0.5018582940101624,
-0.17096638679504395,
-0.7491171956062317,
0.2959718406200409,
-0.387826144695282,
-0.8379017114639282,
0.1461004763841629,
0.47935014963150024,
-0.47949957847595215,
0.1050584688782692,
-1.1198664903640747,
1.0974458456039429,
-0.43112748861312866,
-0.5645400881767273,
-0.3103538155555725,
-0.8278643488883972,
0.26817241311073303,
-0.21434256434440613,
0.21387052536010742,
-0.3265371024608612,
-0.012723506428301334,
0.34988972544670105,
-0.49913766980171204,
0.4506114423274994,
-0.0694500207901001,
-0.002578053856268525,
-0.10893860459327698,
0.20597006380558014,
0.3594974875450134,
-0.07044260203838348,
-0.26595067977905273,
-0.07969307899475098,
0.30253544449806213,
-0.305378794670105,
-0.8368811011314392,
0.6042039394378662,
-0.6813936829566956,
-0.786664605140686,
-0.11948700249195099,
-0.4840258061885834,
-0.30714139342308044,
0.4826773703098297,
0.18779094517230988,
0.13755623996257782,
-0.08676020056009293,
-0.06061023101210594,
0.6814735531806946,
0.17277702689170837,
0.06288699805736542,
0.33937081694602966,
-0.18167570233345032,
0.0007484419620595872,
0.7101584076881409,
0.004488757345825434,
0.5687156319618225,
0.6787593364715576,
0.5315113067626953,
-0.3026203215122223,
-0.7485476732254028,
-0.12573085725307465,
-0.03419342264533043,
-0.5405696630477905,
0.044082190841436386,
-0.5309033393859863,
0.2832435667514801,
-0.3688103258609772,
-0.4767637252807617,
-0.5140747427940369,
-0.5174092650413513,
-0.32964950799942017,
-0.11194203794002533,
0.3851322829723358,
0.36597940325737,
-0.33867111802101135,
0.46262770891189575,
-0.4591808617115021,
0.42675846815109253,
0.11560696363449097,
0.32755300402641296,
-0.12811987102031708,
-0.3617270588874817,
-0.09052874892950058,
0.2693999111652374,
-0.2986108958721161,
-0.3632657825946808,
0.12699662148952484,
0.26227867603302,
0.39774444699287415,
0.81329345703125,
0.06326024234294891,
1.1029201745986938,
-0.6462798714637756,
0.5160283446311951,
0.18760083615779877,
-0.9262800812721252,
0.6660798192024231,
-0.4779894948005676,
0.2796105742454529,
0.9796874523162842,
0.3166162073612213,
-0.318654328584671,
-0.26510247588157654,
-0.5918952226638794,
-0.7929611206054688,
0.9888725876808167,
-0.12756937742233276,
-0.041661716997623444,
0.08875607699155807,
0.27768319845199585,
0.4664593040943146,
0.39002159237861633,
-0.2965788245201111,
-0.3580375015735626,
-0.19948001205921173,
-0.0766497254371643,
-0.17592500150203705,
0.16727280616760254,
-0.1936633139848709,
-0.45729222893714905,
0.59316086769104,
-0.2999676764011383,
-0.2543303072452545,
-0.08463112264871597,
0.09304139018058777,
-0.14412745833396912,
0.2812759280204773,
0.44212663173675537,
0.49351629614830017,
-0.31671470403671265,
-0.05929425358772278,
-0.012026197277009487,
0.004259735345840454,
-0.10418424010276794,
-0.03574831038713455,
-0.11295424401760101,
-0.36215099692344666,
0.1000220999121666,
0.982831597328186,
0.3863372504711151,
-0.30949798226356506,
0.2735189199447632,
0.14181549847126007,
-0.18303218483924866,
0.11779366433620453,
0.3513786792755127,
0.01669204607605934,
0.22545166313648224,
0.20099902153015137,
0.5010318756103516,
0.31992703676223755,
-0.6331680417060852,
0.14400504529476166,
0.6344092488288879,
-0.2779037058353424,
-0.09823881834745407,
0.7508981823921204,
0.06786049902439117,
-0.2153942584991455,
0.3109610676765442,
0.1649741530418396,
-0.3356338143348694,
0.4267965853214264,
0.16941168904304504,
0.8767228126525879,
0.11922901123762131,
0.059295766055583954,
0.24336132407188416,
0.2372000515460968,
-0.3421763777732849,
0.14728443324565887,
-0.3935304880142212,
-0.8844289779663086,
-0.26405563950538635,
-0.5670228600502014,
-0.14485953748226166,
-0.2139221578836441,
-0.9152700901031494,
0.4007444679737091,
-0.5188510417938232,
-0.1546916961669922,
0.25962281227111816,
-0.06019149720668793,
-0.7933676838874817,
-0.004422586411237717,
-0.24800775945186615,
0.9010597467422485,
-0.7331359386444092,
0.7366448044776917,
0.6188106536865234,
-0.3887315094470978,
-0.8443973064422607,
0.004548317287117243,
0.1566133350133896,
-1.0284075736999512,
0.5080386996269226,
-0.15062610805034637,
-0.22423145174980164,
0.1482117623090744,
-0.5912190079689026,
-0.7634910345077515,
0.7033755779266357,
0.5589281916618347,
-0.5340164303779602,
-0.10025142133235931,
-0.01751757599413395,
0.603687584400177,
-0.4496701955795288,
0.06894493103027344,
1.0257328748703003,
0.6920955181121826,
0.03788203373551369,
-1.2248775959014893,
-0.1391674429178238,
0.1287495642900467,
-0.12128212302923203,
0.4915502369403839,
-0.4560704231262207,
0.43233513832092285,
-0.5244606137275696,
-0.2806936800479889,
0.08594992011785507,
0.3429584503173828,
0.05988064408302307,
0.16972802579402924,
0.5132138729095459,
0.5288241505622864,
0.5142256021499634,
-0.24258647859096527,
0.9229066967964172,
-0.2789820432662964,
0.39445289969444275,
1.069893717765808,
-0.06908658146858215,
0.6582618951797485,
0.873519778251648,
-0.14658983051776886,
0.02955859899520874,
0.8527544736862183,
0.31339317560195923,
0.8811229467391968,
0.05620506778359413,
0.13668036460876465,
-0.6169868111610413,
-0.011888457462191582,
-0.21272198855876923,
0.24468275904655457,
0.310377299785614,
-0.11319857835769653,
-0.2721630930900574,
-0.10661010444164276,
0.060853760689496994,
0.26447793841362,
-0.3788548409938812,
1.0347789525985718,
0.024840593338012695,
-1.0735441446304321,
0.5275968909263611,
-0.16072893142700195,
0.7812777757644653,
-0.7571574449539185,
0.16729101538658142,
-0.1030946746468544,
0.20370835065841675,
-0.3211892545223236,
-1.0307210683822632,
-0.02076002210378647,
-0.33824142813682556,
-0.32618919014930725,
-0.5099541544914246,
0.2051786631345749,
-0.5983268618583679,
-0.12093295156955719,
0.008594782091677189,
0.33139222860336304,
0.11337287724018097,
0.012323341332376003,
-1.0081255435943604,
-0.08370102941989899,
0.16565710306167603,
-0.191768616437912,
0.2587149143218994,
0.718265175819397,
-0.06802217662334442,
0.6987807750701904,
0.7803916335105896,
0.12192130833864212,
-0.10822129249572754,
-0.001079042674973607,
0.5955502986907959,
-0.2402631789445877,
-0.6436704397201538,
-0.9579665660858154,
0.4861215054988861,
0.08769254386425018,
-0.45728257298469543,
0.4495600759983063,
0.5043331384658813,
0.9327401518821716,
-0.08795519173145294,
0.6944966316223145,
0.11722263693809509,
0.2858629822731018,
-0.8350547552108765,
0.4931768476963043,
-0.7105056643486023,
0.21860142052173615,
-0.4643705189228058,
-0.8997421860694885,
-0.3006340265274048,
0.656903088092804,
-0.42200616002082825,
-0.15716752409934998,
0.7500758767127991,
0.6958361268043518,
-0.3879808783531189,
-0.030320484191179276,
0.3258357346057892,
-0.02367427758872509,
0.13278700411319733,
0.5047794580459595,
0.5925323367118835,
-0.07274880260229111,
0.0878189355134964,
-0.18056021630764008,
-0.32884684205055237,
-0.13975927233695984,
-0.9991042613983154,
-0.6796948909759521,
-0.7724169492721558,
-0.3104957044124603,
0.019577421247959137,
0.0026972685009241104,
1.2307219505310059,
0.7496236562728882,
-0.6707546710968018,
-0.17854391038417816,
-0.11139648407697678,
0.227447509765625,
-0.47880128026008606,
-0.2667621374130249,
0.36656537652015686,
-0.5642344951629639,
-0.6726759076118469,
0.12614519894123077,
0.45095095038414,
-0.01070538442581892,
0.09924688190221786,
-0.09961867332458496,
0.020537545904517174,
-0.015558320097625256,
0.5403903126716614,
0.36376380920410156,
-0.9278140664100647,
-0.2448561191558838,
-0.10687055438756943,
0.2225072681903839,
0.23259137570858002,
0.904629111289978,
-0.5646322965621948,
0.5933361053466797,
0.4276631474494934,
0.5037522315979004,
0.445902019739151,
0.04314951226115227,
0.797858715057373,
-0.41879504919052124,
0.059865571558475494,
-0.0859222337603569,
0.27460891008377075,
-0.008940611965954304,
-0.33120524883270264,
0.42316174507141113,
-0.1524360030889511,
-0.46266254782676697,
-0.7309278845787048,
0.4258153736591339,
-1.062027931213379,
-0.3158436417579651,
0.9390436410903931,
0.20610547065734863,
0.15134377777576447,
-0.12290467321872711,
-0.5185492038726807,
0.15755775570869446,
-0.7489124536514282,
0.7622096538543701,
0.7748013734817505,
-0.4797898828983307,
0.001148706185631454,
-0.3707559406757355,
0.7506212592124939,
0.467182993888855,
-0.4651382863521576,
0.06864221394062042,
0.3122462034225464,
0.3961942493915558,
0.05703620985150337,
0.5182504057884216,
0.16453847289085388,
0.24736317992210388,
-0.3605855107307434,
-0.24333587288856506,
-0.0890526995062828,
-0.11006712913513184,
-0.27151086926460266,
0.04905229061841965,
0.25997427105903625,
-0.16583192348480225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11865v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11865v1
|
CoNLL#: Fine-grained Error Analysis and a Corrected Test Set for CoNLL-03 English
| 2024-05-20T08:16:34 | 2024-05-20T08:16:34 |
Andrew Rueda, Elena Álvarez Mellado, Constantine Lignos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Modern named entity recognition systems have steadily improved performance in
the age of larger and more powerful neural models. However, over the past
several years, the state-of-the-art has seemingly hit another plateau on the
benchmark CoNLL-03 English dataset. In this paper, we perform a deep dive into
the test outputs of the highest-performing NER models, conducting a
fine-grained evaluation of their performance by introducing new document-level
annotations on the test set. We go beyond F1 scores by categorizing errors in
order to interpret the true state of the art for NER and guide future work. We
review previous attempts at correcting the various flaws of the test set and
introduce CoNLL#, a new corrected version of the test set that addresses its
systematic and most prevalent errors, allowing for low-noise, interpretable
error analysis.
|
[
-0.46156951785087585,
-0.7865824699401855,
0.052654288709163666,
0.05278466269373894,
0.09312956780195236,
-0.09551675617694855,
-0.32961317896842957,
-0.7850492000579834,
-0.24433249235153198,
0.372344046831131,
-0.32016822695732117,
-0.24390801787376404,
-0.8085343837738037,
0.5163776874542236,
-0.5850136876106262,
0.9573471546173096,
0.09457410871982574,
0.42918670177459717,
-0.0824742242693901,
-0.21942420303821564,
-0.6520982980728149,
-0.3299568295478821,
-1.1703228950500488,
-0.478976845741272,
0.5577439665794373,
0.4767228662967682,
0.5527403354644775,
0.11687818169593811,
1.0053642988204956,
0.17666253447532654,
-0.20066145062446594,
0.29812154173851013,
-0.4792517423629761,
0.03431485593318939,
-0.11793370544910431,
-0.12570501863956451,
-0.7106985449790955,
-0.08854303508996964,
0.6394830942153931,
0.7740747332572937,
0.12200845777988434,
0.04182056337594986,
0.2905055284500122,
0.4545696973800659,
-0.5451420545578003,
0.18015840649604797,
-0.7634689211845398,
-0.10376928001642227,
-0.43152710795402527,
0.08739301562309265,
-0.8336992859840393,
-0.3492152690887451,
0.20835840702056885,
-0.6674963235855103,
0.47356945276260376,
0.11720462888479233,
1.1436412334442139,
0.4654959440231323,
-0.17134305834770203,
-0.14089429378509521,
-0.8762226700782776,
0.8083547949790955,
-0.8087735176086426,
0.4464886784553528,
0.10195126384496689,
0.6209245920181274,
-0.3871292769908905,
-0.7198758721351624,
-0.6255246996879578,
-0.07828979194164276,
-0.25093844532966614,
-0.17433695495128632,
-0.2579576373100281,
0.15286695957183838,
0.4405369162559509,
0.499561607837677,
-0.3473638594150543,
0.33056193590164185,
-0.36864879727363586,
-0.17730024456977844,
0.8162634372711182,
-0.06849418580532074,
0.06322722882032394,
0.25573083758354187,
-0.07903695851564407,
-0.07279886305332184,
-0.7504789233207703,
-0.059078365564346313,
-0.029647497460246086,
0.4599743187427521,
0.1130717545747757,
0.42356163263320923,
-0.2830144464969635,
0.7324867248535156,
0.2550044655799866,
0.13785915076732635,
0.17734989523887634,
0.006174636073410511,
-0.5910259485244751,
0.2567651867866516,
0.6129589676856995,
0.5670552253723145,
0.7248342037200928,
-0.08142093569040298,
-0.5690313577651978,
-0.12213404476642609,
-0.09734589606523514,
-0.8912549018859863,
-0.35348471999168396,
-0.009804246947169304,
-0.164903461933136,
-0.06977753341197968,
-0.015597570687532425,
-0.7234686017036438,
-0.7613025903701782,
-0.40110480785369873,
0.543247401714325,
-0.4184844493865967,
-0.07149984687566757,
0.3478153347969055,
-0.010828893631696701,
0.11098406463861465,
0.6343915462493896,
-0.7306382656097412,
0.6791414022445679,
0.8222957849502563,
0.43709948658943176,
0.04301571846008301,
-0.16755785048007965,
-0.6307116746902466,
-0.29984545707702637,
-0.4738953411579132,
1.0160222053527832,
-0.5585358738899231,
-0.18124701082706451,
-0.2318795621395111,
0.09752393513917923,
-0.14936183393001556,
-0.7374256253242493,
0.2596290409564972,
-0.5250546932220459,
0.06629796326160431,
-0.32757240533828735,
-0.7702661752700806,
-0.24655485153198242,
0.5892698764801025,
-0.7641276717185974,
1.0021734237670898,
0.21991653740406036,
-0.6851658821105957,
0.3433799743652344,
-0.7274399399757385,
-0.1566198766231537,
0.06817255914211273,
-0.09036126732826233,
-0.08694750815629959,
0.09482104331254959,
-0.11487554758787155,
0.426097571849823,
-0.6016990542411804,
0.37645193934440613,
-0.208140566945076,
-0.5120105147361755,
0.32951924204826355,
-0.4653610289096832,
0.4673346281051636,
-0.17309781908988953,
-0.4646461606025696,
-0.24012210965156555,
-1.2260164022445679,
0.06471709907054901,
-0.2002522051334381,
-0.0790594071149826,
-0.4177436828613281,
0.027864232659339905,
0.02745729498565197,
-0.1606719195842743,
0.1317550092935562,
-0.6131200194358826,
-0.02879415825009346,
-0.2661231756210327,
0.2382088452577591,
0.5278348326683044,
-0.00006584599759662524,
0.4233603775501251,
-0.09263511747121811,
0.15089431405067444,
-0.06422559916973114,
0.2229425311088562,
0.025560012087225914,
-0.37958040833473206,
-1.0292643308639526,
0.09935451298952103,
0.8449037671089172,
0.5717315077781677,
-0.1349485069513321,
0.008626928552985191,
-0.1640440970659256,
-0.7513427138328552,
-0.4140896499156952,
-0.32750266790390015,
0.5352470278739929,
0.6782245635986328,
0.6567696928977966,
-0.04257027804851532,
-0.6919793486595154,
-0.8964644074440002,
-0.1882423460483551,
0.029626060277223587,
0.32227736711502075,
0.24511179327964783,
0.4780080020427704,
-0.32791441679000854,
0.5352787971496582,
-0.3443673849105835,
-0.18871159851551056,
-0.05110762268304825,
0.07996015250682831,
0.10072579234838486,
0.8748964071273804,
0.07608181983232498,
-0.6442821025848389,
-0.2806786298751831,
0.25108611583709717,
-0.5510044693946838,
0.04039989411830902,
0.04359393194317818,
0.20620092749595642,
0.20549555122852325,
0.774878740310669,
-0.2701229751110077,
0.39981669187545776,
0.39241522550582886,
-0.2895519435405731,
0.6359124183654785,
-0.002264241920784116,
-0.02634294517338276,
-0.6589035987854004,
-0.05101950466632843,
0.06011355295777321,
-0.046275340020656586,
-0.37225618958473206,
-0.07278887927532196,
0.11671559512615204,
0.21953396499156952,
-0.27656617760658264,
0.9274865984916687,
-0.5720922350883484,
-0.08255596458911896,
-0.02533244900405407,
-0.05364255979657173,
0.16884151101112366,
-0.11294863373041153,
-0.4197154939174652,
0.8203825354576111,
0.5007657408714294,
-0.7081420421600342,
0.2472611665725708,
0.1337900459766388,
-0.2583308815956116,
0.700023889541626,
-0.5961498618125916,
0.0718037337064743,
-0.1676793098449707,
-0.002634243108332157,
-0.7761306166648865,
-0.5668505430221558,
-0.18802906572818756,
-0.3321576416492462,
0.69642174243927,
0.026923781260848045,
-0.3852418065071106,
-0.06879329681396484,
0.05740664154291153,
0.2889963388442993,
0.21051345765590668,
-0.34551846981048584,
0.32289087772369385,
0.38511329889297485,
0.2956685423851013,
-0.6817751526832581,
-0.880991518497467,
-0.10115543007850647,
0.08578971773386002,
-0.4601289629936218,
0.4019698202610016,
0.09687739610671997,
-0.5306385159492493,
-0.04055756703019142,
-0.24465389549732208,
-0.35394546389579773,
0.39116427302360535,
0.18496675789356232,
0.020019540563225746,
-0.6001718044281006,
0.19920001924037933,
-0.21150371432304382,
-0.3229665756225586,
-0.16908395290374756,
0.14873339235782623,
0.3927980661392212,
-0.33058029413223267,
0.060734063386917114,
-0.33525750041007996,
-0.005498829297721386,
0.35152989625930786,
-0.28319087624549866,
0.3993200957775116,
0.27984818816185,
-1.090633749961853,
-0.27091163396835327,
-0.5867278575897217,
-0.09434697777032852,
-0.41774821281433105,
0.2751859128475189,
-0.4202077090740204,
-0.8269283175468445,
0.4126894772052765,
0.04896146431565285,
0.004970809910446405,
0.7145996689796448,
-0.2245456725358963,
-0.1450706273317337,
0.5973204970359802,
0.5611339807510376,
0.4252925217151642,
0.09423306584358215,
-0.4693394601345062,
0.4171539545059204,
-1.017500400543213,
-0.5038124322891235,
-0.6935153007507324,
-0.5410698652267456,
-0.7220094203948975,
-0.18487270176410675,
-0.1563185751438141,
0.36202603578567505,
-0.48144519329071045,
0.5341702699661255,
-0.5876390933990479,
0.7797855138778687,
0.3289079964160919,
-0.21125173568725586,
0.2419545203447342,
-0.38187119364738464,
0.012321126647293568,
-0.2776348888874054,
-0.0654878243803978,
-0.7386295795440674,
0.7735982537269592,
0.09504829347133636,
0.77248215675354,
-0.0612524040043354,
0.633627712726593,
0.17999255657196045,
0.6156852841377258,
-0.7564427852630615,
0.6962954998016357,
-0.7742428779602051,
-0.6664279699325562,
-0.2852807343006134,
-0.03516751900315285,
-0.9008593559265137,
-0.08240041881799698,
-0.18762144446372986,
-0.8649306297302246,
0.4715850353240967,
0.20215831696987152,
-0.7994508147239685,
0.38283678889274597,
-0.7336891293525696,
1.1737639904022217,
-0.0288490429520607,
-0.024522690102458,
0.21123355627059937,
-0.2694878876209259,
0.3645261824131012,
-0.20509572327136993,
-0.061305902898311615,
-0.31616246700286865,
0.021929901093244553,
0.6313536763191223,
-0.08513572067022324,
0.3799660801887512,
-0.3096054494380951,
0.0678660124540329,
0.07674387097358704,
0.29229676723480225,
0.5655918121337891,
0.06428158283233643,
-0.5739719271659851,
0.10296773910522461,
0.06880651414394379,
-0.050476036965847015,
-0.5966435074806213,
0.8546358346939087,
-0.398759126663208,
-0.3699203431606293,
-0.5494147539138794,
-0.39468252658843994,
-0.17265796661376953,
0.38647499680519104,
0.28619682788848877,
0.8680195808410645,
-0.40547552704811096,
0.33053138852119446,
0.8167610764503479,
-0.0835285633802414,
0.5243948698043823,
0.40124404430389404,
-0.25482213497161865,
-0.2943163216114044,
0.6103646159172058,
0.6422679424285889,
-0.001633613952435553,
0.3864923119544983,
-0.11686389148235321,
-0.1584392637014389,
-0.9825562834739685,
-0.3340000808238983,
0.033933863043785095,
-0.5374250411987305,
-0.4821213483810425,
-0.861950695514679,
-0.38622352480888367,
-0.26291847229003906,
-0.15005876123905182,
-0.4730793237686157,
-0.3308162987232208,
-0.45257216691970825,
-0.11729387193918228,
0.2629850506782532,
0.8601317405700684,
0.12269729375839233,
0.5584492683410645,
-0.6561592221260071,
-0.056099873036146164,
0.03356064483523369,
0.4547184109687805,
-0.17387670278549194,
-0.3361271917819977,
-0.062167003750801086,
-0.09957845509052277,
-0.18653665482997894,
-0.728030800819397,
0.007991758175194263,
0.33108726143836975,
0.16044560074806213,
0.12692436575889587,
-0.023357495665550232,
1.032765507698059,
-0.6670142412185669,
0.6102152466773987,
-0.22152414917945862,
-0.8383730053901672,
0.32003307342529297,
-0.018805276602506638,
-0.06775480508804321,
0.964856743812561,
0.033555012196302414,
-0.6232109069824219,
-0.1451471447944641,
-1.0056332349777222,
-0.5670415759086609,
0.4394682049751282,
-0.15347367525100708,
0.08723228424787521,
-0.2357230931520462,
0.42824557423591614,
0.2308337241411209,
-0.14199824631214142,
-0.4643315076828003,
-0.10688260942697525,
0.34808021783828735,
-0.3206569254398346,
-0.08206824958324432,
-0.25296834111213684,
0.3812797963619232,
-0.13285867869853973,
0.97528076171875,
-0.1354769766330719,
-0.035578325390815735,
0.40195396542549133,
-0.15021255612373352,
0.06285979598760605,
0.2989910840988159,
0.4448176920413971,
0.6122792959213257,
-0.5460217595100403,
0.30144956707954407,
0.36882027983665466,
-0.4059152901172638,
0.07644923776388168,
0.528300940990448,
-0.40897896885871887,
0.35498008131980896,
0.12451919913291931,
0.5950223207473755,
0.5822625160217285,
-0.4448337256908417,
0.4153895080089569,
-0.12227383255958557,
0.2314816266298294,
-0.5905194282531738,
0.27651122212409973,
-0.20498298108577728,
0.14704184234142303,
0.3474416732788086,
0.6175216436386108,
0.46515190601348877,
-0.22192354500293732,
0.45166558027267456,
0.3424750566482544,
-0.7274417877197266,
-0.358769029378891,
0.5240120887756348,
0.18967048823833466,
-0.4700968265533447,
0.36810749769210815,
-0.671071469783783,
-0.22462891042232513,
0.7907428741455078,
0.5089836716651917,
0.789384126663208,
-0.19318610429763794,
0.04061167314648628,
0.7325798869132996,
0.4850136935710907,
-0.5243213176727295,
0.46893301606178284,
0.5637229681015015,
-0.7210137248039246,
-0.4993375837802887,
-0.5683084726333618,
-0.3970079720020294,
0.44732144474983215,
-0.7074178457260132,
0.4717105031013489,
-0.6899278163909912,
-0.2410552203655243,
0.5091652274131775,
0.07677720487117767,
-0.7389734387397766,
0.7873685359954834,
0.12402641028165817,
1.2731853723526,
-0.401854544878006,
0.598930299282074,
0.7545775771141052,
-0.1957709938287735,
-0.8825139403343201,
-0.011238367296755314,
-0.05043724551796913,
-0.3923097550868988,
0.6851602792739868,
0.6964696645736694,
0.18311965465545654,
0.37603771686553955,
-0.5369621515274048,
-1.0211929082870483,
1.0184576511383057,
0.2853337228298187,
-0.9081027507781982,
0.024342844262719154,
-0.06888836622238159,
0.5715892910957336,
-0.381681352853775,
0.516298234462738,
0.8335829973220825,
0.5469662547111511,
-0.34809672832489014,
-0.9827039241790771,
0.06541045010089874,
-0.14638644456863403,
-0.11938370019197464,
0.5579711198806763,
-0.5338634848594666,
0.9163941740989685,
-0.1951688975095749,
-0.3736656904220581,
0.0991731807589531,
0.5323124527931213,
0.07441672682762146,
0.6700772643089294,
0.38873517513275146,
0.7165169715881348,
1.1453896760940552,
-0.6379920840263367,
1.0699995756149292,
0.07229927182197571,
0.4248530864715576,
1.644609808921814,
-0.530737042427063,
1.0917359590530396,
0.3294907510280609,
-0.11909616738557816,
0.3604862093925476,
0.7431931495666504,
-0.2492438107728958,
0.3585965037345886,
0.4453040361404419,
-0.02544407919049263,
-0.09785261005163193,
-0.29746904969215393,
-0.16370487213134766,
0.3765837550163269,
0.23902446031570435,
-0.10969671607017517,
-0.43784981966018677,
-0.14704526960849762,
0.2462509274482727,
0.01777738146483898,
-0.33454325795173645,
0.6814529895782471,
0.030277056619524956,
-0.6730356812477112,
0.49780890345573425,
-0.014207670465111732,
0.8235313892364502,
-0.035959094762802124,
-0.2048444151878357,
-0.514579176902771,
0.5860456228256226,
-0.2801428735256195,
-0.7268096804618835,
0.49825912714004517,
0.2815482020378113,
-0.2295345664024353,
0.17461495101451874,
0.7417832016944885,
-0.1967199146747589,
-0.5868867039680481,
0.5148648023605347,
0.09025975316762924,
0.3791622519493103,
-0.25978711247444153,
-0.5194858908653259,
-0.07301092892885208,
-0.22694647312164307,
0.12130498886108398,
-0.23425525426864624,
0.6665518879890442,
-0.22356566786766052,
0.40478524565696716,
0.40991050004959106,
-0.08437009900808334,
0.2858022451400757,
0.2800615429878235,
0.361514687538147,
-0.7458754181861877,
0.3191564977169037,
-0.8736511468887329,
0.7823282480239868,
-0.23580491542816162,
-0.702146053314209,
0.41969025135040283,
0.9011833071708679,
1.2307323217391968,
0.147459015250206,
0.449013352394104,
-0.09966086596250534,
0.4038936495780945,
-0.32561299204826355,
0.5402380228042603,
-0.46990063786506653,
0.1626625657081604,
-0.14677754044532776,
-0.7757344245910645,
-0.6725020408630371,
0.354112446308136,
-0.18162384629249573,
-0.26280349493026733,
0.909271776676178,
1.0315539836883545,
-0.12678967416286469,
0.20208685100078583,
0.3569242060184479,
0.4970545172691345,
0.17553426325321198,
0.5816149711608887,
0.9365549683570862,
-1.2838133573532104,
0.255210816860199,
-0.37498021125793457,
0.04086630046367645,
-0.3445720672607422,
-0.8634967803955078,
-0.5295578241348267,
-0.3681091070175171,
-0.6883010864257812,
-0.6161584258079529,
0.1754065901041031,
0.7272428870201111,
0.4301745891571045,
-1.2572541236877441,
0.1977752447128296,
-0.2740459740161896,
-0.03324124962091446,
-0.20390601456165314,
-0.2180316299200058,
0.2735210955142975,
-0.48675286769866943,
-0.835197389125824,
0.31170666217803955,
0.13067622482776642,
0.3150515854358673,
0.006893685553222895,
-0.16339991986751556,
-0.09914419800043106,
0.0667685717344284,
0.32463356852531433,
0.05379496514797211,
-0.6897555589675903,
-0.4009220600128174,
0.22772899270057678,
-0.3296268582344055,
0.10408954322338104,
0.4274247884750366,
-0.4505898952484131,
0.35136717557907104,
0.4437514841556549,
0.8052321076393127,
0.08689102530479431,
-0.35467472672462463,
0.32619085907936096,
-0.4682047665119171,
-0.16816909611225128,
0.23741942644119263,
0.6474252939224243,
0.8010412454605103,
-0.3600378930568695,
0.9368723034858704,
0.09529315680265427,
-0.5378158688545227,
-1.141963243484497,
-0.29719746112823486,
-1.0422950983047485,
0.10979317873716354,
1.146436095237732,
-0.12182269245386124,
-0.255336731672287,
-0.06154107674956322,
-0.2138587385416031,
0.31533074378967285,
-0.26716530323028564,
0.4884510040283203,
0.9078981876373291,
0.18160642683506012,
-0.09088397771120071,
-0.7400186061859131,
0.7451292276382446,
0.3565051555633545,
-0.9094006419181824,
-0.012785237282514572,
0.566842257976532,
0.31081992387771606,
0.38166388869285583,
0.4515219032764435,
-0.3183589577674866,
0.3936655819416046,
-0.16660697758197784,
0.151931494474411,
0.17934072017669678,
-0.41950881481170654,
-0.4107651114463806,
-0.03329920023679733,
0.1331763118505478,
-0.22244608402252197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13056v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13056v1
|
Large language models for sentiment analysis of newspaper articles during COVID-19: The Guardian
| 2024-05-20T07:10:52 | 2024-05-20T07:10:52 |
Rohitash Chandra, Baicheng Zhu, Qingying Fang, Eka Shinjikashvili
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
During the COVID-19 pandemic, the news media coverage encompassed a wide
range of topics that includes viral transmission, allocation of medical
resources, and government response measures. There have been studies on
sentiment analysis of social media platforms during COVID-19 to understand the
public response given the rise of cases and government strategies implemented
to control the spread of the virus. Sentiment analysis can provide a better
understanding of changes in societal opinions and emotional trends during the
pandemic. Apart from social media, newspapers have played a vital role in the
dissemination of information, including information from the government,
experts, and also the public about various topics. A study of sentiment
analysis of newspaper sources during COVID-19 for selected countries can give
an overview of how the media covered the pandemic. In this study, we select The
Guardian newspaper and provide a sentiment analysis during various stages of
COVID-19 that includes initial transmission, lockdowns and vaccination. We
employ novel large language models (LLMs) and refine them with expert-labelled
sentiment analysis data. We also provide an analysis of sentiments experienced
pre-pandemic for comparison. The results indicate that during the early
pandemic stages, public sentiment prioritised urgent crisis response, later
shifting focus to addressing the impact on health and the economy. In
comparison with related studies about social media sentiment analyses, we found
a discrepancy between The Guardian with dominance of negative sentiments (sad,
annoyed, anxious and denial), suggesting that social media offers a more
diversified emotional reflection. We found a grim narrative in The Guardian
with overall dominance of negative sentiments, pre and during COVID-19 across
news sections including Australia, UK, World News, and Opinion
|
[
-0.3297666907310486,
-0.7643499970436096,
0.37602996826171875,
0.5824900269508362,
-0.4117720127105713,
0.10475859045982361,
-0.3448653519153595,
-0.44088444113731384,
0.6097723841667175,
0.1745842546224594,
-0.38172754645347595,
-0.3791884183883667,
-0.6613043546676636,
0.2232239544391632,
-0.5319637656211853,
1.264980435371399,
0.24015672504901886,
0.26785922050476074,
-0.0799742117524147,
0.16375480592250824,
0.4157419204711914,
-0.8395602703094482,
-0.905693531036377,
-0.1638403981924057,
0.6373600959777832,
0.1274261474609375,
0.5953291058540344,
-0.47413384914398193,
0.8051532506942749,
0.12286777049303055,
-0.4502412676811218,
-0.05891399830579758,
-0.6183003783226013,
-0.1840619593858719,
-0.3052407205104828,
-0.1991952508687973,
-0.6347858309745789,
0.29535728693008423,
-0.005868765991181135,
0.03165249153971672,
-0.0678342878818512,
0.3534312844276428,
0.21496403217315674,
0.40642058849334717,
-0.20430974662303925,
-0.033349256962537766,
-0.338113009929657,
0.2633382976055145,
-0.24749456346035004,
-0.2798949182033539,
-0.3034155070781708,
-0.071958526968956,
0.16345913708209991,
-0.32993084192276,
0.0887066051363945,
-0.38733622431755066,
0.7476398944854736,
-0.0020260184537619352,
-0.6992161870002747,
-0.3922581970691681,
-0.8214132785797119,
0.8040143847465515,
-0.6391465067863464,
0.14298200607299805,
-0.00459327781572938,
-0.013002927415072918,
-0.0988849401473999,
-0.4106801748275757,
-0.5254945158958435,
-0.11721686273813248,
0.3429131507873535,
0.49763721227645874,
-0.265209436416626,
-0.040396299213171005,
-0.009051328524947166,
0.4366500973701477,
-0.41709190607070923,
-0.18813009560108185,
-0.679050862789154,
-0.13314154744148254,
0.799873411655426,
0.06567737460136414,
0.4196525812149048,
-0.5467368960380554,
-0.37336939573287964,
0.05071944743394852,
-0.5885418057441711,
0.3618253171443939,
0.24990083277225494,
0.2815682590007782,
-0.5669757723808289,
0.5245489478111267,
0.03833049163222313,
0.3064790666103363,
0.4273298978805542,
-0.4477112293243408,
0.28440579771995544,
-0.3998219966888428,
-0.1757688820362091,
0.046984318643808365,
0.8199177980422974,
0.6564731001853943,
-0.018273500725626945,
0.07786642014980316,
-0.0058604939840734005,
0.25912055373191833,
0.468994140625,
-0.7923464775085449,
-0.057021450251340866,
0.17402340471744537,
-0.5107725262641907,
-0.45656993985176086,
-0.08151420950889587,
-1.2419779300689697,
-0.718629777431488,
0.013292988762259483,
0.026913249865174294,
0.2762361466884613,
-0.31872546672821045,
0.31124478578567505,
-0.1920526623725891,
0.37365585565567017,
0.48780256509780884,
-0.3224051296710968,
0.2961755096912384,
0.6214392781257629,
0.7013608813285828,
-0.01792234182357788,
0.4488821029663086,
-0.5073392987251282,
-0.26010945439338684,
-0.30468395352363586,
0.5121349096298218,
-0.541061520576477,
-0.30381321907043457,
0.05073901638388634,
-0.2016919106245041,
0.021818310022354126,
-0.15491244196891785,
0.865760087966919,
-0.5949231386184692,
0.35319390892982483,
-0.4246307909488678,
-0.0077031818218529224,
-0.2497321516275406,
0.3195016086101532,
-0.5893285870552063,
0.6626183390617371,
-0.055391956120729446,
-1.0783445835113525,
0.19907839596271515,
-0.43790456652641296,
-0.5946101546287537,
-0.35881122946739197,
-0.2176172286272049,
-0.5771039724349976,
0.17989897727966309,
0.5675663352012634,
0.5901857018470764,
-0.42697563767433167,
0.11340782046318054,
-0.6570185422897339,
0.02176935225725174,
0.023561326786875725,
-0.04185424745082855,
0.82884281873703,
0.1226339191198349,
-0.3028494417667389,
-0.04818447306752205,
-0.29785826802253723,
-0.6447446942329407,
-0.030092835426330566,
-0.0667480006814003,
-0.398938924074173,
-0.016772441565990448,
0.35173994302749634,
0.6404602527618408,
0.20322935283184052,
-0.7050385475158691,
0.2832818031311035,
-0.3533356487751007,
0.616383969783783,
0.17887282371520996,
0.5945344567298889,
0.44701117277145386,
0.09058897197246552,
0.9199047088623047,
0.4669085144996643,
0.5894672274589539,
0.29355159401893616,
-0.4318636655807495,
-0.25579461455345154,
-0.1784822791814804,
-0.3503902554512024,
0.8064533472061157,
-0.41371822357177734,
0.03210529685020447,
-0.03267559036612511,
-0.5426803231239319,
-0.23642271757125854,
-0.031872622668743134,
0.0652608573436737,
0.5185900926589966,
0.10273834317922592,
-0.14119458198547363,
-0.7086763381958008,
-0.6314353942871094,
-0.2509182393550873,
-0.14925144612789154,
0.60731440782547,
0.15500961244106293,
0.2816128432750702,
-0.23180845379829407,
0.5526675581932068,
-0.4613306522369385,
-0.2723296880722046,
-0.4586900472640991,
0.2423606663942337,
0.28923338651657104,
-0.20508189499378204,
0.5524449348449707,
-1.0690454244613647,
-0.26946207880973816,
0.039387889206409454,
-0.669393002986908,
-0.044043198227882385,
-0.32788583636283875,
0.30519405007362366,
0.15793859958648682,
0.6715905666351318,
-0.4762408137321472,
0.2592303454875946,
0.6862443089485168,
-0.26446425914764404,
0.5333674550056458,
0.18129363656044006,
0.12843428552150726,
-1.4085897207260132,
0.1275135576725006,
0.5563778281211853,
-0.1583261787891388,
-0.5783235430717468,
0.10966811329126358,
-0.2247876673936844,
-0.39987707138061523,
-0.4102054834365845,
0.4811595678329468,
-0.14083229005336761,
0.188588947057724,
-0.2272433489561081,
0.08253622055053711,
0.3945210874080658,
-0.2489597350358963,
0.07823817431926727,
0.7335608005523682,
0.5127328634262085,
-0.15152229368686676,
0.3921288251876831,
0.2661711573600769,
-0.31658485531806946,
0.23851655423641205,
-0.569916307926178,
-0.14192409813404083,
-0.25211861729621887,
0.561034083366394,
-0.8986544609069824,
-0.2561740577220917,
0.3789159655570984,
-0.43182989954948425,
-0.24634918570518494,
0.22432571649551392,
-0.1397351324558258,
-0.6309909224510193,
-0.32324132323265076,
-0.07319489121437073,
0.1350172758102417,
-0.1106826588511467,
0.4793010652065277,
0.6455309987068176,
-0.5146522521972656,
-0.6033509373664856,
-0.6734866499900818,
0.5569087862968445,
-0.565953254699707,
-0.5450734496116638,
0.2126249372959137,
-0.0020002485252916813,
-0.637425422668457,
-0.04335495084524155,
-0.10089580714702606,
-0.22857576608657837,
0.16071397066116333,
0.2736876308917999,
0.08967386186122894,
-0.2570860683917999,
0.17725501954555511,
-0.11399629712104797,
0.18472619354724884,
0.2590191066265106,
0.3935321867465973,
0.6323909163475037,
-0.14446458220481873,
0.11343742161989212,
-0.5938237905502319,
0.40953677892684937,
0.9365098476409912,
-0.35110870003700256,
0.792121410369873,
0.6795223951339722,
-0.2688210904598236,
0.10674680024385452,
-0.387904554605484,
-0.07789815962314606,
-0.3213471472263336,
0.2927287518978119,
0.0629052072763443,
-0.6759381890296936,
0.5591485500335693,
0.15403355658054352,
-0.3389332592487335,
0.6793175935745239,
0.5350509285926819,
0.10627184063196182,
0.7041099071502686,
0.5664578080177307,
-0.7391042113304138,
0.5356847047805786,
-0.061646733433008194,
0.4901418089866638,
-0.48608046770095825,
-0.21884453296661377,
-0.42711102962493896,
0.08437290787696838,
-0.33982670307159424,
-0.10401565581560135,
0.7061922550201416,
0.07516738027334213,
-0.03613414615392685,
-0.02612735703587532,
-0.2180332988500595,
-0.08070310205221176,
0.1290903240442276,
0.33913081884384155,
0.07848826050758362,
0.12004904448986053,
0.15092360973358154,
0.1555747091770172,
-0.5232965350151062,
-0.43567153811454773,
0.6406224370002747,
0.3252870440483093,
0.8337949514389038,
-0.1681593805551529,
0.8775626420974731,
0.5705769062042236,
0.22734282910823822,
-0.7281786203384399,
0.4891226887702942,
-0.4894639849662781,
-0.4283052980899811,
-0.10783180594444275,
-0.09592704474925995,
-0.7410012483596802,
-0.25448668003082275,
-0.2968924939632416,
-0.4339887797832489,
0.3558207154273987,
-0.20451976358890533,
-0.789460301399231,
0.034733064472675323,
-0.41157856583595276,
0.4075128138065338,
0.0529898963868618,
-0.23090697824954987,
-0.6822217702865601,
-0.2941989600658417,
0.4969451427459717,
-0.17005227506160736,
0.34560322761535645,
0.09889979660511017,
0.10725431144237518,
0.6520956158638,
-0.3561770021915436,
1.0722301006317139,
0.029381966218352318,
-0.31325364112854004,
0.3881330192089081,
-0.5688933730125427,
0.3428881764411926,
0.289819598197937,
-0.44743484258651733,
-0.17770379781723022,
-0.1401406228542328,
-0.3837665617465973,
-0.20536139607429504,
0.7589077353477478,
-1.173866868019104,
-0.7580174803733826,
-0.6108197569847107,
-0.29315122961997986,
0.06965508311986923,
-0.18605753779411316,
0.22308465838432312,
0.718653678894043,
-0.40686944127082825,
0.20253033936023712,
0.5003597736358643,
-0.4163474142551422,
0.4688505232334137,
0.09892837703227997,
-0.5180816650390625,
-0.5516800880432129,
0.23554034531116486,
0.33715736865997314,
-0.17448753118515015,
0.3727777302265167,
0.5739072561264038,
-0.06364918500185013,
-0.21509210765361786,
-0.15472978353500366,
0.15166312456130981,
-0.4666331112384796,
-0.12699274718761444,
-0.6253142952919006,
-0.35025590658187866,
-0.43115106225013733,
-0.2015731930732727,
0.004935684148222208,
-0.05410481616854668,
-0.3723892569541931,
-0.15205635130405426,
0.6856422424316406,
0.6999329924583435,
-0.008883806876838207,
0.4163672924041748,
-0.8483986854553223,
0.49547889828681946,
0.1926143616437912,
-0.0173358004540205,
-0.02948581427335739,
-0.2595756947994232,
-0.396320641040802,
-0.11888483166694641,
-0.38935357332229614,
-0.9658840298652649,
0.6229455471038818,
0.13197609782218933,
0.15136678516864777,
0.685498833656311,
0.26805293560028076,
0.5599820613861084,
-0.09065429866313934,
1.1634043455123901,
0.3044085204601288,
-0.8798065781593323,
0.29107391834259033,
-0.8316150903701782,
0.11130468547344208,
0.3446272909641266,
0.37285560369491577,
-0.6900191307067871,
-0.36406031250953674,
-0.5571491122245789,
-0.8529683351516724,
0.2585734724998474,
-0.2621961832046509,
0.2622945308685303,
-0.29063570499420166,
0.3914336860179901,
0.031132103875279427,
0.1487058699131012,
-0.699038565158844,
0.0755377784371376,
-0.1446009874343872,
0.024298345670104027,
-0.4186859130859375,
-0.2720053791999817,
-0.2689657509326935,
-0.24146310985088348,
0.5385251045227051,
0.34811487793922424,
0.30691957473754883,
0.41372472047805786,
-0.025305936112999916,
-0.509796679019928,
0.38602983951568604,
0.5083670020103455,
0.7701014876365662,
-0.22636821866035461,
0.07259444147348404,
-0.06247603893280029,
-0.671693742275238,
0.10443133860826492,
0.056639786809682846,
-0.17916958034038544,
-0.13358455896377563,
0.2654018998146057,
0.6508023738861084,
0.02748940698802471,
-0.41857922077178955,
0.8622506856918335,
0.1320546418428421,
-0.039604559540748596,
-0.5729696750640869,
-0.23823584616184235,
0.2078719288110733,
0.6417980790138245,
0.5811429619789124,
0.20026297867298126,
0.21540473401546478,
-0.8097187280654907,
0.16798783838748932,
0.5554688572883606,
-0.16305407881736755,
-0.6914460062980652,
0.5318199396133423,
0.37233150005340576,
0.07812691479921341,
0.3387221693992615,
-0.05353491008281708,
-0.5828678607940674,
0.6681067943572998,
0.5017426013946533,
0.8218845725059509,
-0.30561548471450806,
0.6760802268981934,
0.192048117518425,
0.23463496565818787,
-0.45517754554748535,
0.7212079763412476,
0.5657728314399719,
-0.5491403341293335,
-0.6857686042785645,
-0.523148775100708,
-0.2056572139263153,
0.5910969972610474,
-1.0584490299224854,
0.14402863383293152,
-0.4190637469291687,
-0.5758266448974609,
-0.00010502664372324944,
0.38989725708961487,
-0.738744854927063,
0.6710667610168457,
0.6548647284507751,
1.1476008892059326,
-1.2925472259521484,
0.556572437286377,
0.9120688438415527,
-0.4515519142150879,
-0.5637763142585754,
0.5691990852355957,
-0.019358156248927116,
-0.36502233147621155,
0.4868829548358917,
0.1911505162715912,
-0.15096482634544373,
-0.37981343269348145,
-0.6028386354446411,
-0.708448052406311,
0.669819712638855,
0.06225696578621864,
-0.5836020112037659,
0.053645242005586624,
0.2086896151304245,
0.9040333032608032,
-0.4404958486557007,
0.03180824592709541,
0.05748319253325462,
0.48254460096359253,
-0.24539966881275177,
-0.8364804983139038,
-0.17477430403232574,
-0.438018798828125,
-0.5252273082733154,
0.0805676057934761,
-1.1937973499298096,
0.8136964440345764,
0.10663799941539764,
0.04882289096713066,
-0.2961758077144623,
0.5566037893295288,
-0.2402706891298294,
0.8007775545120239,
0.35633355379104614,
0.5609495639801025,
0.6855425238609314,
0.2549288868904114,
1.1978869438171387,
-0.4704749584197998,
0.17938624322414398,
0.642829418182373,
-0.212342768907547,
1.1873642206192017,
0.5347694158554077,
-0.10447512567043304,
0.3589676022529602,
0.4918080270290375,
0.2245248258113861,
0.5008664727210999,
0.008763819001615047,
-0.41597530245780945,
-0.3621522784233093,
-0.2786311209201813,
-0.3990858793258667,
0.4586380124092102,
0.494623601436615,
-0.48650118708610535,
-0.3888094425201416,
0.46924299001693726,
0.1265830546617508,
0.06713627278804779,
-0.8532084226608276,
0.47949543595314026,
0.37768155336380005,
-0.3023555874824524,
0.22771789133548737,
0.05680932104587555,
0.5268142223358154,
-0.2906636595726013,
0.5526531338691711,
-0.2455369532108307,
0.20588776469230652,
-0.36456498503685,
-0.703472375869751,
0.5973260402679443,
0.04030226543545723,
-0.509589672088623,
-0.0737246498465538,
0.7723470330238342,
-0.23788802325725555,
-0.6140991449356079,
0.4716731309890747,
0.7649040222167969,
-0.052365224808454514,
-0.3002091348171234,
-0.6955457925796509,
0.21773555874824524,
-0.18871578574180603,
-0.6380136013031006,
0.4944424629211426,
0.2697207033634186,
-0.2030959576368332,
0.34929272532463074,
0.18020635843276978,
0.22493939101696014,
-0.032539065927267075,
-0.04507387802004814,
0.9070693254470825,
-0.7139928340911865,
-0.5686036944389343,
-0.8196371793746948,
0.07862463593482971,
-0.2235790491104126,
-0.36085250973701477,
0.91462641954422,
0.5319187045097351,
0.2923118770122528,
-0.24579310417175293,
1.065086007118225,
-0.039926063269376755,
0.4159775972366333,
-0.14240536093711853,
0.7395836710929871,
-0.4692665934562683,
-0.22839492559432983,
-0.3460254371166229,
-0.5828598737716675,
-0.41695550084114075,
0.3577071726322174,
-1.112149715423584,
-0.39021000266075134,
0.28499794006347656,
0.8399879336357117,
0.04842829704284668,
-0.03516656532883644,
-0.11828577518463135,
0.33016324043273926,
0.1309979259967804,
0.02437629923224449,
0.7565092444419861,
-0.07018639892339706,
0.3858405351638794,
0.026074422523379326,
-0.031499650329351425,
-0.5057991743087769,
-0.8937078714370728,
-0.8954741954803467,
-0.4918580651283264,
-0.2613092362880707,
-0.685951828956604,
0.3656514585018158,
1.2790998220443726,
0.360507994890213,
-0.7135182619094849,
-0.14095571637153625,
0.2222924530506134,
-0.19509302079677582,
-0.2532026767730713,
-0.26122725009918213,
0.6517484784126282,
-0.09515317529439926,
-0.3778316378593445,
0.13086077570915222,
0.3305319547653198,
-0.35671430826187134,
-0.3866402804851532,
0.33541277050971985,
-0.1475691795349121,
0.528968870639801,
0.9580868482589722,
0.24652229249477386,
-0.6264119148254395,
-0.1904447227716446,
0.09995125979185104,
-0.4957112669944763,
0.19256818294525146,
0.6766287088394165,
-0.5268443822860718,
0.1328648328781128,
0.7402406334877014,
0.4783337414264679,
0.3569398522377014,
0.1780707836151123,
0.4592033624649048,
-0.3639535903930664,
0.12632562220096588,
0.06910844892263412,
0.26394012570381165,
0.548130989074707,
-0.6537331938743591,
0.010381117463111877,
0.14231917262077332,
-0.4157373309135437,
-0.5991116762161255,
0.0697350725531578,
-1.3120965957641602,
-0.13283394277095795,
1.4461205005645752,
-0.049784593284130096,
-0.19958458840847015,
-0.02257101610302925,
-0.34319087862968445,
0.3826168179512024,
-0.7600294351577759,
1.3617737293243408,
0.8022060990333557,
0.2583344280719757,
-0.36952635645866394,
-0.41539525985717773,
0.43861454725265503,
0.09535279870033264,
-0.8024129271507263,
-0.3082962930202484,
0.06912903487682343,
0.11979758739471436,
-0.02886531874537468,
0.541686475276947,
-0.03736693784594536,
0.0583021454513073,
-0.23876690864562988,
-0.18572278320789337,
0.23584991693496704,
-0.3751155138015747,
-0.45754536986351013,
0.5817745327949524,
-0.23763124644756317,
0.20435556769371033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11819v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11819v1
|
Beyond MLE: Investigating SEARNN for Low-Resourced Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-05-20T06:28:43 | 2024-05-20T06:28:43 |
Chris Emezue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Structured prediction tasks, like machine translation, involve learning
functions that map structured inputs to structured outputs. Recurrent Neural
Networks (RNNs) have historically been a popular choice for such tasks,
including in natural language processing (NLP) applications. However, training
RNNs using Maximum Likelihood Estimation (MLE) has its limitations, including
exposure bias and a mismatch between training and testing metrics. SEARNN,
based on the learning to search (L2S) framework, has been proposed as an
alternative to MLE for RNN training. This project explored the potential of
SEARNN to improve machine translation for low-resourced African languages -- a
challenging task characterized by limited training data availability and the
morphological complexity of the languages. Through experiments conducted on
translation for English to Igbo, French to \ewe, and French to \ghomala
directions, this project evaluated the efficacy of SEARNN over MLE in
addressing the unique challenges posed by these languages. With an average BLEU
score improvement of $5.4$\% over the MLE objective, we proved that SEARNN is
indeed a viable algorithm to effectively train RNNs on machine translation for
low-resourced languages.
|
[
-0.3820115625858307,
-0.46114951372146606,
0.43658876419067383,
0.2564109265804291,
-0.22519835829734802,
-0.17720496654510498,
-0.5113598108291626,
-0.31438469886779785,
0.20025531947612762,
0.5037391185760498,
-0.6082959175109863,
-0.4363316595554352,
-0.838720440864563,
0.3431691825389862,
-0.22101862728595734,
0.7245643734931946,
0.014239611104130745,
0.04280818626284599,
0.2186713069677353,
-0.3910301625728607,
-0.4561244249343872,
-0.5585727691650391,
-0.9970425367355347,
-0.3599362373352051,
1.0873256921768188,
0.33511173725128174,
0.6003715395927429,
0.5010859966278076,
0.5400580167770386,
0.31947436928749084,
-0.27778226137161255,
0.3958836793899536,
-0.5924313068389893,
0.2506837844848633,
-0.16759315133094788,
-0.32145383954048157,
-0.22690580785274506,
0.043712154030799866,
0.33862438797950745,
0.9249346852302551,
-0.19104669988155365,
0.09134145081043243,
0.19817402958869934,
1.0074338912963867,
-0.6138541102409363,
0.14806345105171204,
-0.5774747133255005,
0.2646300494670868,
-0.23741638660430908,
0.10920902341604233,
-0.24548116326332092,
0.021329062059521675,
0.3164210319519043,
-0.3414044678211212,
0.2656520903110504,
-0.1268528401851654,
0.45147162675857544,
0.3812444508075714,
-0.44507449865341187,
-0.2609384059906006,
-0.5184842348098755,
0.9190878868103027,
-0.754282534122467,
0.43011993169784546,
0.4175472855567932,
0.2285468876361847,
-0.45859697461128235,
-0.927430272102356,
-0.30956125259399414,
-0.162564218044281,
-0.15276089310646057,
0.3040812611579895,
-0.06841883063316345,
0.16854755580425262,
0.33211469650268555,
0.45338431000709534,
-0.6679939031600952,
0.2074371576309204,
-0.33217954635620117,
-0.039541978389024734,
0.8064575791358948,
-0.16771702468395233,
-0.10515324026346207,
-0.18345700204372406,
-0.18117985129356384,
-0.09099756181240082,
-0.3551079332828522,
0.026662908494472504,
0.012280996888875961,
0.4240499436855316,
-0.06256042420864105,
0.6351761817932129,
-0.14668865501880646,
0.5783746242523193,
-0.22302986681461334,
0.23678739368915558,
0.14844650030136108,
-0.12471316754817963,
-0.293575644493103,
0.30918002128601074,
0.7341107726097107,
0.20770086348056793,
0.21085335314273834,
-0.2541700601577759,
-0.45185568928718567,
-0.19735978543758392,
0.23738476634025574,
-0.8533592820167542,
-0.08078186959028244,
0.2170427143573761,
-0.659345805644989,
-0.33211004734039307,
-0.1829610913991928,
-0.505609393119812,
-0.4714469015598297,
-0.14472492039203644,
0.16614708304405212,
-0.26535528898239136,
-0.03716425597667694,
-0.12789027392864227,
0.049826886504888535,
-0.0807681530714035,
-0.021006302908062935,
-0.7693113088607788,
0.057064495980739594,
0.4644028842449188,
1.1939011812210083,
-0.27936145663261414,
-0.09839478135108948,
-0.4837941825389862,
-0.23675031960010529,
-0.3948219418525696,
0.25981733202934265,
-0.2868609130382538,
-0.48250138759613037,
0.07478643208742142,
0.11182429641485214,
-0.08387315273284912,
-0.3924720287322998,
0.7407916784286499,
-0.6307617425918579,
0.0018852769862860441,
-0.119186170399189,
-0.545333206653595,
-0.458366721868515,
0.06810738891363144,
-0.9402579665184021,
1.0676809549331665,
0.3502458930015564,
-0.39222612977027893,
0.08015456795692444,
-0.7476270198822021,
-0.6683861017227173,
-0.05971641093492508,
0.053929030895233154,
-0.336282879114151,
0.44737130403518677,
0.2143266201019287,
0.4163483679294586,
-0.3560298979282379,
0.10908770561218262,
-0.14853939414024353,
-0.3483271896839142,
0.43921926617622375,
-0.7923603057861328,
0.5721544623374939,
0.34307026863098145,
-0.503014326095581,
-0.016893431544303894,
-0.8468207716941833,
0.37526288628578186,
0.013617883436381817,
-0.5975674390792847,
-0.2455543577671051,
-0.15420980751514435,
0.1097433939576149,
0.26333087682724,
0.13927318155765533,
-0.4470232427120209,
0.07769079506397247,
-0.7984777688980103,
0.6724230647087097,
0.5039576292037964,
-0.10811428725719452,
0.6573175191879272,
-0.010669884271919727,
0.3926900327205658,
-0.25087350606918335,
-0.1000969260931015,
-0.061952706426382065,
-0.5532766580581665,
-0.7455092668533325,
0.20487812161445618,
0.7020665407180786,
0.7405745387077332,
-0.8381267786026001,
0.15750788152217865,
-0.12707479298114777,
-0.10501021146774292,
-0.8931297659873962,
0.3632809817790985,
0.34317171573638916,
0.39291879534721375,
0.5206130146980286,
-0.2675570547580719,
-0.9095656871795654,
-0.9116789102554321,
-0.24312448501586914,
0.1884201616048813,
-0.2353489249944687,
0.2635122835636139,
0.3640895485877991,
-0.5444801449775696,
0.3408273160457611,
0.04136184975504875,
-0.37231406569480896,
-0.36347317695617676,
0.19448520243167877,
0.686779260635376,
0.5727002620697021,
0.09582221508026123,
-0.8910051584243774,
-0.46105632185935974,
0.32881948351860046,
-0.6224384307861328,
-0.06927887350320816,
-0.1313764601945877,
0.1472638100385666,
0.4287387728691101,
0.5638363361358643,
-0.38069453835487366,
0.5584266781806946,
0.8869770169258118,
0.08855743706226349,
0.0719916895031929,
-0.44355201721191406,
-0.08425290137529373,
-1.1407760381698608,
0.1048661470413208,
0.019884688779711723,
-0.26321402192115784,
-0.6657467484474182,
-0.048330310732126236,
-0.1755341738462448,
-0.24340498447418213,
-0.27933454513549805,
0.3701612651348114,
-0.3950852155685425,
-0.28210365772247314,
-0.42915090918540955,
0.26492905616760254,
-0.11590702086687088,
0.32332324981689453,
0.35991936922073364,
0.9584435820579529,
-0.001606630627065897,
-0.4310789406299591,
0.2115362137556076,
0.142931267619133,
-0.4378766417503357,
0.06097926199436188,
-0.8565759658813477,
0.24821171164512634,
-0.014726804569363594,
-0.020492088049650192,
-0.6596521139144897,
0.07172035425901413,
-0.005153001751750708,
-0.35903987288475037,
0.38733938336372375,
-0.3996993601322174,
-0.05674806609749794,
-0.30205345153808594,
0.16929326951503754,
0.3783019781112671,
0.3805355131626129,
-0.46814069151878357,
0.4531773328781128,
0.09498772770166397,
-0.33083584904670715,
-0.725974440574646,
-0.952457070350647,
0.4146885275840759,
0.13097253441810608,
-0.4828431010246277,
0.37085777521133423,
0.20645956695079803,
-0.07142207026481628,
-0.19986465573310852,
-0.14518558979034424,
-0.1353190541267395,
0.14118018746376038,
0.23990103602409363,
0.01272045262157917,
-0.5563669800758362,
-0.047011978924274445,
-0.07014629989862442,
-0.2949266731739044,
-0.05803418532013893,
-0.6061622500419617,
0.4915618300437927,
-0.31155094504356384,
-0.05247466638684273,
-0.04904738813638687,
0.27617159485816956,
0.15241965651512146,
-0.23642340302467346,
0.8403563499450684,
0.8229790329933167,
-0.28527793288230896,
-0.38399580121040344,
-0.42758631706237793,
-0.17025135457515717,
-0.4570676386356354,
0.659910261631012,
-0.44721031188964844,
-0.7486173510551453,
0.2363455444574356,
-0.33887821435928345,
-0.038237057626247406,
0.37736499309539795,
0.331990510225296,
-0.7149850130081177,
0.8163225054740906,
0.5819386839866638,
-0.037691254168748856,
0.2848794162273407,
-0.7426717877388,
0.13077174127101898,
-0.9711712002754211,
-0.24019460380077362,
-0.16135935485363007,
-0.8954647183418274,
-1.0244030952453613,
-0.5458879470825195,
0.417167067527771,
0.2564587891101837,
-0.08108168095350266,
0.30545586347579956,
-0.22824682295322418,
0.4263739585876465,
0.7177318334579468,
0.19964979588985443,
-0.026645369827747345,
0.20642195641994476,
-0.13086345791816711,
-0.1872960925102234,
-1.1546516418457031,
-0.36957553029060364,
1.0214228630065918,
0.1496122181415558,
0.2871144413948059,
-0.17535057663917542,
0.6730129718780518,
0.43018996715545654,
0.33422860503196716,
-0.9220400452613831,
0.30773472785949707,
-0.5877445936203003,
-0.32720327377319336,
-0.6259100437164307,
-0.5139623880386353,
-1.2163480520248413,
0.45996856689453125,
-0.29186660051345825,
-0.19396477937698364,
0.39487990736961365,
0.030506836250424385,
-0.1296650469303131,
0.2794080674648285,
-0.1571846604347229,
0.9392125606536865,
-0.5593042373657227,
-0.359982430934906,
-0.2919974625110626,
-0.774298369884491,
0.06305473297834396,
0.011980940587818623,
0.22799625992774963,
0.26578277349472046,
-0.08620176464319229,
0.5148753523826599,
-0.6182629466056824,
0.7235960364341736,
0.026323454454541206,
-0.011031248606741428,
0.2273108810186386,
0.3115849196910858,
0.5873140096664429,
0.06850986182689667,
-0.39572325348854065,
0.47890356183052063,
-0.39134833216667175,
-0.6570532321929932,
-0.5997794270515442,
0.6413511633872986,
-0.5503327250480652,
-0.33103400468826294,
-0.5304270386695862,
-0.7862650752067566,
-0.1735462099313736,
0.25142645835876465,
0.4292908012866974,
0.18618637323379517,
-0.2773759961128235,
0.4014686644077301,
0.7278047800064087,
-0.06771987676620483,
0.7240782380104065,
0.3184300661087036,
0.11278736591339111,
-0.7724393010139465,
0.6558628678321838,
-0.004377851728349924,
0.19219504296779633,
0.35930511355400085,
0.21726086735725403,
-0.2510403096675873,
-0.6408666968345642,
-0.6156625151634216,
0.0122177479788661,
-0.48550042510032654,
-0.12570293247699738,
-0.17228035628795624,
-0.5083096623420715,
0.07036707550287247,
-0.24273845553398132,
-0.4779183566570282,
-0.693862795829773,
-0.14982964098453522,
-0.11222467571496964,
0.08281026035547256,
0.643848717212677,
-0.220920592546463,
0.6258273720741272,
-0.8692165613174438,
0.085140161216259,
0.048108913004398346,
0.10644254833459854,
-0.10989135503768921,
-0.8029153943061829,
-0.4566137492656708,
0.4430526793003082,
-0.11844724416732788,
-0.5617713332176208,
0.4076938331127167,
0.32385677099227905,
0.3740275800228119,
0.27505597472190857,
-0.2824001610279083,
0.559181809425354,
-0.610028862953186,
0.5654563307762146,
0.32409238815307617,
-0.6623481512069702,
0.5052765607833862,
0.03810400888323784,
0.22125890851020813,
0.5746234059333801,
0.5244846940040588,
-0.7786778807640076,
0.18565739691257477,
-0.3984316289424896,
-0.757998526096344,
0.39484739303588867,
0.5701289772987366,
0.0068092369474470615,
0.19890274107456207,
0.693789005279541,
0.041959960013628006,
0.3900619149208069,
-0.5635136961936951,
-0.34069153666496277,
-0.24337825179100037,
-0.18252958357334137,
-0.44737160205841064,
-0.2668863832950592,
0.1760094314813614,
-0.020158488303422928,
0.7454901337623596,
-0.03396908938884735,
-0.03531530499458313,
0.43483808636665344,
-0.31356942653656006,
-0.08250455558300018,
0.18697014451026917,
0.5626192092895508,
0.3689141273498535,
-0.11451558023691177,
0.04997456818819046,
0.46096712350845337,
-0.4663322865962982,
0.08359266072511673,
0.11545469611883163,
-0.39799240231513977,
0.26925796270370483,
0.6382718086242676,
0.9703757166862488,
0.26585468649864197,
-0.3925534784793854,
0.32034072279930115,
0.20107848942279816,
-0.20442557334899902,
-0.3177819848060608,
-0.1985219269990921,
0.1927759349346161,
0.3549730181694031,
0.023955047130584717,
0.3432479798793793,
0.1460873782634735,
-0.4642241895198822,
0.17441730201244354,
0.18081676959991455,
-0.7099480628967285,
-0.18910688161849976,
0.5803771615028381,
0.251640647649765,
-0.4092969298362732,
0.8604459762573242,
0.10899830609560013,
-0.572136640548706,
0.5619936585426331,
0.5623344779014587,
0.813091516494751,
-0.46652039885520935,
0.22966302931308746,
0.39099934697151184,
0.6370860934257507,
-0.20221787691116333,
0.5305702686309814,
0.1255069375038147,
-0.6638140082359314,
-0.5527448058128357,
-0.6587866544723511,
-0.03033977933228016,
0.3568395674228668,
-0.49257028102874756,
0.054452504962682724,
-0.2241697460412979,
-0.45548227429389954,
-0.29524123668670654,
0.07512931525707245,
-0.7422793507575989,
0.3191658854484558,
0.30609622597694397,
1.0249433517456055,
-0.49103763699531555,
0.7887961864471436,
0.5701999664306641,
-0.5581521391868591,
-0.390796035528183,
-0.5461702942848206,
-0.2921944260597229,
-0.6763259768486023,
0.8956202864646912,
0.05845024809241295,
-0.0049859401769936085,
-0.08818704634904861,
-0.26085129380226135,
-0.9817843437194824,
1.0783170461654663,
0.10309342294931412,
-1.0301657915115356,
-0.07730762660503387,
0.5314568877220154,
0.6375794410705566,
-0.4913285970687866,
0.050645921379327774,
0.6100944876670837,
0.6628836393356323,
-0.05818188562989235,
-0.7307954430580139,
-0.16403332352638245,
-0.08008569478988647,
0.528643012046814,
0.12562939524650574,
-0.5004772543907166,
0.5827941298484802,
-0.36875656247138977,
0.014814993366599083,
0.273002564907074,
0.8003498911857605,
0.0744767114520073,
0.5999317765235901,
0.35229796171188354,
0.4967688024044037,
0.7929577231407166,
-0.05433795228600502,
1.1264246702194214,
-0.13092923164367676,
-0.03651518374681473,
1.3066635131835938,
-0.16118654608726501,
0.9644361138343811,
0.536573588848114,
-0.19734086096286774,
0.5176072716712952,
0.6623947620391846,
-0.018819453194737434,
0.5864818096160889,
0.2940150797367096,
-0.22221505641937256,
-0.21453151106834412,
-0.05022197216749191,
-0.18500545620918274,
0.24337249994277954,
0.5516377687454224,
-0.6018552184104919,
0.1444534808397293,
0.05229564756155014,
-0.31474965810775757,
0.3346721827983856,
-0.49351006746292114,
0.8109548091888428,
0.6524698734283447,
-0.2557362914085388,
0.7472855448722839,
0.09381678700447083,
0.4580785632133484,
-0.5211002230644226,
-0.12249073386192322,
-0.41800442337989807,
0.2082790732383728,
-0.3383857011795044,
-0.5205420851707458,
0.13988544046878815,
-0.23602299392223358,
-0.2964755594730377,
-0.1529092788696289,
0.8616741299629211,
-0.7197949886322021,
-0.6805419921875,
0.40361639857292175,
0.5871155858039856,
0.271235853433609,
-0.16127511858940125,
-0.8704667687416077,
-0.1230645552277565,
-0.034861233085393906,
-0.2769308090209961,
0.1402043104171753,
0.5679210424423218,
-0.09439697861671448,
0.790969729423523,
0.7135951519012451,
0.46460315585136414,
0.12444335222244263,
0.13597437739372253,
0.34532439708709717,
-0.6148645877838135,
-0.24262870848178864,
-0.7112667560577393,
0.33669376373291016,
-0.13663651049137115,
-0.16414380073547363,
0.5228095054626465,
0.7791887521743774,
0.8535179495811462,
-0.1807171106338501,
0.8873056769371033,
0.18817487359046936,
0.34035640954971313,
-0.5989214181900024,
0.7442612648010254,
-0.4482058584690094,
0.17714670300483704,
0.17524801194667816,
-1.1667066812515259,
-0.16952785849571228,
0.7596892714500427,
-0.14185425639152527,
-0.10734478384256363,
0.7944177389144897,
0.702588677406311,
-0.20430681109428406,
0.10570401698350906,
0.4437311291694641,
0.23008504509925842,
-0.05871010199189186,
0.49110516905784607,
0.6548641324043274,
-0.8582925200462341,
0.6901389360427856,
-0.5151578187942505,
0.05120106413960457,
-0.18230420351028442,
-0.8766145706176758,
-0.903622031211853,
-0.4181850552558899,
0.008892016485333443,
-0.4913420081138611,
0.2568148672580719,
0.950697124004364,
0.4764195680618286,
-1.268040418624878,
-0.5116553902626038,
-0.25541749596595764,
0.052611369639635086,
-0.41273143887519836,
-0.1093759685754776,
0.3543265759944916,
-0.5132715702056885,
-0.5469358563423157,
0.8806115388870239,
0.13035398721694946,
0.08942154794931412,
0.07637529820203781,
-0.345771461725235,
-0.17470155656337738,
-0.09658148139715195,
0.9444034695625305,
0.3182666301727295,
-0.6059895157814026,
0.1455545574426651,
0.053182560950517654,
-0.16970278322696686,
-0.0651303082704544,
0.8767924904823303,
-0.5943458080291748,
0.25898659229278564,
0.3187793791294098,
1.0933010578155518,
0.7951924800872803,
-0.16411133110523224,
0.8331730365753174,
-0.7105225324630737,
0.2954518795013428,
0.2587625980377197,
0.5039191246032715,
0.2763286530971527,
-0.30442970991134644,
0.9529484510421753,
0.08151105791330338,
-0.5299638509750366,
-0.5352935194969177,
0.18457773327827454,
-0.6198123097419739,
-0.21090641617774963,
0.9940112233161926,
-0.1590917706489563,
-0.2404542863368988,
0.12719295918941498,
-0.16214299201965332,
0.33153805136680603,
-0.2636280357837677,
0.6997050642967224,
0.4721968472003937,
0.20606429874897003,
-0.07046836614608765,
-1.054335355758667,
0.5521209239959717,
0.6572427153587341,
-0.3302827775478363,
-0.23604513704776764,
0.2759198546409607,
-0.003235533833503723,
0.03788705915212631,
0.14148259162902832,
0.15755657851696014,
0.2609925866127014,
-0.2990647256374359,
0.09494837373495102,
-0.10592983663082123,
-0.19864973425865173,
-0.4485918879508972,
-0.10442837327718735,
-0.1564588099718094,
-0.14539119601249695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11817v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11817v1
|
Systematic Review on Healthcare Systems Engineering utilizing ChatGPT
| 2024-05-20T06:25:39 | 2024-05-20T06:25:39 |
Jungwoo Kim, Ji-Su Lee, Huijae Kim, Taesik Lee
|
cs.ET
|
cs.ET, cs.CL
|
This paper presents an analytical framework for conducting academic reviews
in the field of Healthcare Systems Engineering, employing ChatGPT, a
state-of-the-art tool among recent language models. We utilized 9,809 abstract
paragraphs from conference presentations to systematically review the field.
The framework comprises distinct analytical processes, each employing tailored
prompts and the systematic use of the ChatGPT API. Through this framework, we
organized the target field into 11 topic categories and conducted a
comprehensive analysis covering quantitative yearly trends and detailed
sub-categories. This effort explores the potential for leveraging ChatGPT to
alleviate the burden of academic reviews. Furthermore, it provides valuable
insights into the dynamic landscape of Healthcare Systems Engineering research.
|
[
-0.30672192573547363,
-0.6196892857551575,
0.34234362840652466,
0.3105621039867401,
-0.31706348061561584,
0.20240840315818787,
0.3537975251674652,
-0.47843223810195923,
0.13764415681362152,
0.1459503173828125,
-0.5653677582740784,
-0.10165858268737793,
-0.3890213370323181,
0.02408785931766033,
-0.5845250487327576,
1.2930123805999756,
-0.33237728476524353,
0.37542805075645447,
0.3505638539791107,
0.13225588202476501,
-0.210241436958313,
-0.5802110433578491,
-0.6637101769447327,
-0.3613809645175934,
0.3139863908290863,
0.07504982501268387,
0.42408716678619385,
-0.18873828649520874,
1.151634931564331,
0.2522503137588501,
-0.22353878617286682,
-0.15163885056972504,
-0.4423256516456604,
0.34727931022644043,
0.24717943370342255,
0.15178868174552917,
-0.609212338924408,
-0.25529634952545166,
0.599209189414978,
0.750946581363678,
-0.4035049378871918,
0.3711477220058441,
0.2769046127796173,
0.5988015532493591,
-0.4593227505683899,
0.48285505175590515,
-0.12107227742671967,
0.38411030173301697,
-0.05220046639442444,
-0.43785321712493896,
-0.3211086690425873,
-0.5461470484733582,
0.5889583826065063,
-0.3231508731842041,
-0.08518818765878677,
0.046216461807489395,
0.7286030054092407,
0.1346464902162552,
-0.3966291844844818,
-0.2795153558254242,
-0.7248073816299438,
0.504608690738678,
-0.7432959675788879,
0.48088717460632324,
-0.1296144276857376,
0.6023249626159668,
-0.1475902646780014,
-0.7629410624504089,
-0.07047954201698303,
-0.37317630648612976,
-0.059866584837436676,
0.40157175064086914,
-0.22130218148231506,
0.3444405794143677,
-0.029707379639148712,
0.5278165936470032,
-0.660603404045105,
-0.2248414307832718,
-0.6985078454017639,
-0.17564524710178375,
0.702383279800415,
0.1731061488389969,
0.6501068472862244,
-0.1408824622631073,
-0.607628583908081,
0.18997235596179962,
-0.5786502957344055,
-0.08855606615543365,
-0.21256357431411743,
-0.09514206647872925,
-0.012596271000802517,
0.4610084295272827,
-0.5472005009651184,
0.17989186942577362,
-0.42807790637016296,
-0.09495667368173599,
0.3106386065483093,
-0.4394923150539398,
-0.5898343324661255,
-0.1385383903980255,
0.8565775156021118,
0.7022263407707214,
-0.2791094481945038,
-0.24052953720092773,
-0.4638100266456604,
0.3433900773525238,
0.5815657377243042,
-0.689213216304779,
-0.05381494387984276,
0.43897801637649536,
-0.8416646718978882,
-0.5507775545120239,
-0.07163528352975845,
-0.7182216048240662,
-0.31129273772239685,
-0.20981036126613617,
-0.21416307985782623,
-0.4316096603870392,
-0.47288766503334045,
0.3411773145198822,
-0.3499200642108917,
0.2305794209241867,
0.10508067905902863,
-0.48949000239372253,
0.4678787589073181,
0.8607420325279236,
0.8357011079788208,
-0.2970183491706848,
0.06304282695055008,
0.07333654910326004,
-0.277381956577301,
-0.2833556532859802,
1.1736477613449097,
-0.2572161853313446,
-0.7756465673446655,
0.29154643416404724,
-0.09886369109153748,
-0.043294891715049744,
-0.3353424370288849,
0.7759553790092468,
-0.5530487895011902,
0.13067446649074554,
0.03632393106818199,
-0.4474286735057831,
0.029768051579594612,
0.5137336254119873,
-0.23844867944717407,
0.8581874966621399,
0.18435822427272797,
-0.8312394618988037,
0.4794814884662628,
-0.978783130645752,
-0.19948723912239075,
0.3538079559803009,
-0.28136706352233887,
-0.5604679584503174,
0.08393656462430954,
-0.054712194949388504,
0.18402418494224548,
-0.29043349623680115,
0.3466871380805969,
-0.20010289549827576,
-0.21006853878498077,
0.14365331828594208,
-0.014467753469944,
0.6805750727653503,
0.6863940954208374,
-0.4013228416442871,
0.4605393409729004,
-0.6067805290222168,
0.15319746732711792,
-0.24649743735790253,
-0.11722854524850845,
-0.11662423610687256,
0.3478243052959442,
0.4660091698169708,
0.01421433873474598,
-0.20690305531024933,
-0.47780412435531616,
0.1619286984205246,
-0.29890114068984985,
0.6479367017745972,
0.4417342245578766,
0.4930017292499542,
0.44489362835884094,
-0.47342732548713684,
0.8060953617095947,
-0.4043937027454376,
0.6264550685882568,
-0.11098646372556686,
-0.41523128747940063,
-0.4904731512069702,
-0.23583994805812836,
0.1821085661649704,
0.5095171332359314,
-0.5484476685523987,
0.1336861103773117,
-0.048189885914325714,
-0.6664741039276123,
-0.5159918665885925,
-0.7655491828918457,
0.13942275941371918,
0.3859695792198181,
0.12047238647937775,
-0.7305929660797119,
-0.458662748336792,
-1.1371220350265503,
-0.10333312302827835,
-0.5339809060096741,
-0.27869635820388794,
0.13966108858585358,
0.41880401968955994,
-0.6434348821640015,
0.7062145471572876,
-0.2929876446723938,
-0.0012881604488939047,
-0.13396695256233215,
0.18482276797294617,
-0.09905627369880676,
0.4126305878162384,
0.21011793613433838,
-0.39829695224761963,
-0.34509265422821045,
0.353588730096817,
-0.7281040549278259,
-0.10406997054815292,
0.13619893789291382,
-0.16200795769691467,
-0.4586038887500763,
0.3583165407180786,
-0.4008910357952118,
0.5362527966499329,
0.3185899555683136,
-0.2665517330169678,
0.8128076791763306,
0.21080633997917175,
0.5756973028182983,
-0.6493431925773621,
0.30773138999938965,
0.025636844336986542,
0.2761858105659485,
-0.6193773150444031,
0.42192542552948,
-0.07945084571838379,
-0.4589250385761261,
0.037728626281023026,
0.3555038869380951,
-0.3527703881263733,
0.21150746941566467,
-0.2263827919960022,
-0.15185976028442383,
-0.20417273044586182,
0.07711785286664963,
-0.06855030357837677,
0.393496036529541,
0.4538930058479309,
-0.2961123585700989,
0.38254114985466003,
0.408000111579895,
-0.5296356678009033,
0.559566855430603,
-0.953211784362793,
-0.18596038222312927,
0.18542064726352692,
0.3942030966281891,
-1.0932509899139404,
-0.26637399196624756,
0.20724740624427795,
-0.3466346263885498,
-0.006696246098726988,
-0.0977911502122879,
-0.3197859227657318,
-0.4733775854110718,
-0.23544105887413025,
-0.06487578898668289,
0.5252590775489807,
0.2949986159801483,
0.22496278584003448,
0.9252715706825256,
-0.8498396277427673,
-0.16535978019237518,
-0.42186933755874634,
0.0034011059906333685,
0.07875767350196838,
-0.6434949636459351,
0.20820897817611694,
0.26625528931617737,
-0.7091912031173706,
-0.2212216556072235,
-0.4345768392086029,
-0.22743844985961914,
0.11480043083429337,
0.14161352813243866,
0.502888023853302,
-0.32963836193084717,
0.19553537666797638,
-0.0027138094883412123,
-0.2549699544906616,
0.3338976204395294,
-0.2517573833465576,
0.3221426010131836,
-0.19964124262332916,
-0.6489631533622742,
-0.617027997970581,
0.6492094993591309,
0.6236289739608765,
-0.152219757437706,
-0.02393130585551262,
0.3559471666812897,
-0.16774700582027435,
0.02744721993803978,
-0.37013840675354004,
-0.5889796018600464,
-0.3886359930038452,
0.6002271175384521,
0.02486787922680378,
-0.8599840402603149,
0.4862784445285797,
-0.06195780634880066,
0.8964481353759766,
0.2281537801027298,
0.5259298086166382,
-0.21048268675804138,
0.8880842924118042,
0.5973863005638123,
-0.04599869251251221,
0.4289689362049103,
0.0775037482380867,
0.5440921783447266,
-0.6610164046287537,
-0.15161363780498505,
-0.7735741138458252,
-0.24725690484046936,
-0.8720636963844299,
-0.10795939713716507,
0.6500114798545837,
-0.3692212402820587,
-0.23561851680278778,
0.0393085703253746,
-0.8911515474319458,
-0.10491842031478882,
0.1686696708202362,
0.3343160152435303,
0.2602354884147644,
-0.1421554982662201,
-0.28378647565841675,
0.2958429753780365,
-0.7163730263710022,
-0.6835752129554749,
0.8929715752601624,
0.7306485772132874,
0.7918005585670471,
-0.2784160077571869,
0.6803490519523621,
0.14589053392410278,
0.8795937895774841,
-0.8761451840400696,
0.40948012471199036,
0.4601391851902008,
-0.7546750903129578,
-0.5729075074195862,
-0.24745036661624908,
-0.9288380742073059,
0.37614935636520386,
0.021488046273589134,
-0.551263689994812,
-0.02353794500231743,
-0.05949339270591736,
-0.523520827293396,
0.04959570989012718,
-0.7681353092193604,
0.6307397484779358,
-0.015043448656797409,
-0.08001168072223663,
-0.1163468211889267,
-0.5255008339881897,
0.29938486218452454,
0.16085445880889893,
0.2738040089607239,
-0.09092682600021362,
0.12579099833965302,
0.7192980647087097,
-0.6778093576431274,
0.5714311003684998,
0.19389428198337555,
-0.1400708258152008,
0.3123347759246826,
0.0144491633400321,
0.2009810358285904,
0.1573677808046341,
0.08219295740127563,
0.08542092144489288,
0.6913683414459229,
-0.4716922342777252,
-0.4348466694355011,
0.4903835952281952,
-0.5478789210319519,
-0.35235118865966797,
-0.6942380666732788,
-0.1422479748725891,
-0.800583004951477,
0.2104305922985077,
0.11662288755178452,
0.49701473116874695,
-0.3880651891231537,
-0.04579319432377815,
0.433408260345459,
-0.16720591485500336,
0.07771434634923935,
0.3197823464870453,
-0.21579985320568085,
-0.30948659777641296,
0.4219784438610077,
0.13538777828216553,
0.12098068743944168,
0.12006434053182602,
0.030050786212086678,
0.033005960285663605,
-0.8662099242210388,
-0.4673426151275635,
0.014993269927799702,
-0.3306145668029785,
0.16263091564178467,
-0.6599611639976501,
-0.4995655119419098,
-0.5238838195800781,
-0.036940038204193115,
-0.18159951269626617,
-0.21414925158023834,
0.37557631731033325,
-0.10612519830465317,
-0.19078558683395386,
0.9867663979530334,
0.5252712368965149,
0.5731272101402283,
-0.7945805788040161,
0.10152111947536469,
0.1165141835808754,
0.6567197442054749,
-0.04103677719831467,
-0.2046351432800293,
-0.07703247666358948,
-0.13918684422969818,
-0.6525769829750061,
-0.9949828386306763,
0.19737525284290314,
-0.4597446024417877,
0.7793401479721069,
0.48390790820121765,
-0.05244608223438263,
0.4715903699398041,
-0.7997090220451355,
1.0950543880462646,
0.4898168444633484,
-0.4336874783039093,
0.409274160861969,
-0.592158854007721,
0.39722156524658203,
0.5481303930282593,
0.30114683508872986,
-0.8983405232429504,
-0.39338213205337524,
-0.8197313547134399,
-0.9961116909980774,
0.307756245136261,
0.32320278882980347,
-0.049755681306123734,
0.15566320717334747,
-0.10278619825839996,
-0.08062061667442322,
0.10989683121442795,
-0.4046722650527954,
-0.12183454632759094,
0.136930450797081,
-0.05734454095363617,
0.4556652903556824,
-0.3436128497123718,
-0.5068863034248352,
0.194235697388649,
0.9139420390129089,
0.055137261748313904,
0.5308998227119446,
0.27081307768821716,
0.160379558801651,
0.04573584720492363,
0.5824629664421082,
0.3664497435092926,
0.8977952599525452,
-0.08767712116241455,
-0.1299416869878769,
-0.08359825611114502,
-0.6874570250511169,
-0.11973177641630173,
0.34671688079833984,
-0.35526934266090393,
0.3426375389099121,
0.29293984174728394,
0.3133183717727661,
0.4331466257572174,
-0.5579599142074585,
0.1924281120300293,
-0.15010693669319153,
-0.34045425057411194,
0.040493112057447433,
-0.14279134571552277,
-0.026560764759778976,
-0.035203613340854645,
0.2661619484424591,
0.161812424659729,
0.7632603049278259,
-0.2773452401161194,
0.5719844102859497,
0.37936198711395264,
-1.0383949279785156,
-0.23140676319599152,
0.3211619257926941,
0.5198602080345154,
-0.1893841028213501,
0.31555673480033875,
0.38576382398605347,
-0.09619350731372833,
0.4855676591396332,
0.024524280801415443,
0.9146255850791931,
-0.25460895895957947,
0.3694194257259369,
0.27129632234573364,
0.3151600956916809,
-0.07614166289567947,
0.2769923508167267,
-0.029874559491872787,
-0.11305852234363556,
-0.5724543929100037,
-0.6280081868171692,
-0.8608715534210205,
0.07738639414310455,
-0.5570970773696899,
0.4580913782119751,
-0.39297130703926086,
-0.5113844275474548,
0.19080735743045807,
-0.29186558723449707,
-0.2986869812011719,
0.057669807225465775,
0.08680684119462967,
0.9819777011871338,
-0.4267727732658386,
0.14333420991897583,
0.7350409626960754,
-0.47715893387794495,
-0.8144596219062805,
-0.12121423333883286,
0.5176921486854553,
-0.690239667892456,
0.2076902836561203,
-0.26586782932281494,
-0.11632773280143738,
-0.4873049855232239,
-0.4086669683456421,
-0.6479760408401489,
0.7422392964363098,
-0.1917976588010788,
-0.6370029449462891,
-0.28575819730758667,
-0.043476805090904236,
0.8039761781692505,
0.04257345572113991,
0.8203359246253967,
0.4755198061466217,
0.11850259453058243,
-0.024024520069360733,
-1.4586542844772339,
-0.15973761677742004,
-0.5533273816108704,
-0.1953849345445633,
-0.0025672486517578363,
-0.6915373802185059,
0.3888815939426422,
0.2429002821445465,
-0.4025798738002777,
0.020679514855146408,
0.29195183515548706,
0.5523509979248047,
0.46572795510292053,
0.17865850031375885,
0.03914234787225723,
0.5650650858879089,
-0.18573565781116486,
0.9551417231559753,
-0.42604678869247437,
0.6019986271858215,
0.7384946942329407,
-0.5669069886207581,
0.5061118006706238,
0.6472808718681335,
-0.6449579000473022,
0.3447670340538025,
0.9146428108215332,
0.3615601062774658,
0.26179182529449463,
0.5438739657402039,
-0.49355509877204895,
0.22880277037620544,
0.07902153581380844,
-0.8638259172439575,
0.12430854886770248,
0.19231031835079193,
-0.3816632330417633,
-0.4949568212032318,
0.04656493291258812,
0.12930257618427277,
-0.42976558208465576,
-0.2146661877632141,
1.094853401184082,
0.24408990144729614,
-0.8116311430931091,
0.29604122042655945,
-0.26828569173812866,
0.2914860248565674,
-0.8543589115142822,
-0.049252934753894806,
-0.2321465164422989,
0.002919346559792757,
-0.36887258291244507,
-0.6041722297668457,
0.33625009655952454,
-0.028024926781654358,
0.15208490192890167,
-0.6728951334953308,
0.6782243251800537,
0.2014312446117401,
-0.32582366466522217,
-0.1484304517507553,
0.5745242834091187,
0.05413996800780296,
0.2979506254196167,
-0.8031210899353027,
0.09612645953893661,
-0.1704740822315216,
-0.3857821226119995,
0.3506266176700592,
0.5611962080001831,
-0.07309963554143906,
0.6377741098403931,
0.6221046447753906,
0.35297393798828125,
-0.23779572546482086,
0.09730160981416702,
1.0185819864273071,
-0.5042690634727478,
-0.8712265491485596,
-0.6572445034980774,
0.634364128112793,
-0.23000125586986542,
-0.36760181188583374,
0.4864162504673004,
0.5229488015174866,
0.43252548575401306,
-0.0497453436255455,
1.467292308807373,
-0.13211101293563843,
0.7655277252197266,
-0.12076272815465927,
0.7846858501434326,
-0.15533429384231567,
0.22767111659049988,
-0.5487170815467834,
-0.42827630043029785,
-0.456207811832428,
0.5528099536895752,
-0.5390214323997498,
-0.33710411190986633,
0.8245131373405457,
0.671039342880249,
0.050524696707725525,
0.6465022563934326,
0.18798625469207764,
-0.10327661037445068,
0.6181136965751648,
0.011918336153030396,
1.1713591814041138,
-0.49641066789627075,
0.2592361867427826,
0.1568128913640976,
-0.682898759841919,
-0.30408015847206116,
-0.4815804064273834,
-0.39234480261802673,
-0.46529141068458557,
-0.3881092071533203,
-0.6283738613128662,
0.22994916141033173,
0.7895870208740234,
1.0426298379898071,
-1.111006736755371,
-0.35126516222953796,
0.13261762261390686,
0.006908340845257044,
-0.47764384746551514,
-0.19547437131404877,
0.3121458888053894,
-0.6748567819595337,
-0.2561034560203552,
-0.06505326181650162,
0.7167072296142578,
-0.26722440123558044,
-0.3799915909767151,
0.26402848958969116,
0.10716646164655685,
0.03883450850844383,
0.7282477617263794,
0.09025295823812485,
-0.46483612060546875,
-0.018212994560599327,
0.4851900637149811,
-0.34537845849990845,
0.02309185452759266,
1.1161223649978638,
-0.06098145246505737,
0.2690742313861847,
0.7815790772438049,
0.6853270530700684,
0.2643333971500397,
-0.18601053953170776,
0.522884726524353,
-0.0009403522708453238,
-0.19167718291282654,
0.5942882895469666,
0.6499130129814148,
-0.08628655970096588,
-0.09759753942489624,
0.6045857071876526,
0.3128093183040619,
-0.9600638151168823,
-0.8802947998046875,
0.056769341230392456,
-1.0423188209533691,
-0.01576983742415905,
1.301322102546692,
0.028143227100372314,
0.05367898941040039,
-0.43793585896492004,
-0.5604389905929565,
-0.14190907776355743,
-0.3114203214645386,
1.0942168235778809,
0.8497955799102783,
-0.7032045722007751,
0.026123790070414543,
-0.9105607867240906,
0.5768301486968994,
0.22311000525951385,
-0.9951390027999878,
-0.12074513733386993,
0.36309483647346497,
0.31341028213500977,
0.05627468600869179,
1.2134853601455688,
-0.6605626344680786,
0.40829336643218994,
0.037612129002809525,
0.19787532091140747,
0.7238141298294067,
0.2586609721183777,
0.0036352500319480896,
0.3899994194507599,
-0.06990927457809448,
-0.12400814145803452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11804v1
|
(Perhaps) Beyond Human Translation: Harnessing Multi-Agent Collaboration for Translating Ultra-Long Literary Texts
| 2024-05-20T05:55:08 | 2024-05-20T05:55:08 |
Minghao Wu, Yulin Yuan, Gholamreza Haffari, Longyue Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in machine translation (MT) have significantly enhanced
translation quality across various domains. However, the translation of
literary texts remains a formidable challenge due to their complex language,
figurative expressions, and cultural nuances. In this work, we introduce a
novel multi-agent framework based on large language models (LLMs) for literary
translation, implemented as a company called TransAgents, which mirrors
traditional translation publication process by leveraging the collective
capabilities of multiple agents, to address the intricate demands of
translating literary works. To evaluate the effectiveness of our system, we
propose two innovative evaluation strategies: Monolingual Human Preference
(MHP) and Bilingual LLM Preference (BLP). MHP assesses translations from the
perspective of monolingual readers of the target language, while BLP uses
advanced LLMs to compare translations directly with the original texts.
Empirical findings indicate that despite lower d-BLEU scores, translations from
TransAgents are preferred by both human evaluators and LLMs over human-written
references, particularly in genres requiring domain-specific knowledge. We also
highlight the strengths and limitations of TransAgents through case studies and
suggests directions for future research.
|
[
-0.05319866165518761,
-0.16550453007221222,
0.6652207970619202,
0.22168733179569244,
-0.39859843254089355,
0.6812199950218201,
-0.3406237065792084,
-0.7515211701393127,
0.17577365040779114,
0.7814996242523193,
-0.3885636627674103,
-0.4685571491718292,
-0.518631637096405,
0.513530433177948,
-0.44084176421165466,
1.021742582321167,
-0.07512298226356506,
-0.014304590411484241,
0.01823674887418747,
-0.2607450485229492,
-0.24705770611763,
-0.4644987881183624,
-0.26805052161216736,
-0.6138411164283752,
0.8899869322776794,
-0.013511748984456062,
1.1757125854492188,
0.3043002188205719,
0.47382810711860657,
0.34296080470085144,
0.11578705906867981,
0.5392795205116272,
-0.3274988830089569,
0.11138049513101578,
-0.38065680861473083,
-0.4443238079547882,
-0.48981091380119324,
0.09792210906744003,
0.6323778033256531,
0.620923638343811,
0.16015735268592834,
0.13209518790245056,
0.06619330495595932,
0.6619600057601929,
-0.3787001073360443,
-0.0859813466668129,
-0.3341754078865051,
0.2574317753314972,
-0.24479785561561584,
-0.28643834590911865,
-0.8739399909973145,
-0.2944369614124298,
0.03273604065179825,
-0.42730382084846497,
0.027898333966732025,
0.22271466255187988,
0.517975926399231,
0.06449367851018906,
-0.9368210434913635,
-0.0027495031245052814,
-0.8682025671005249,
0.8587545156478882,
-0.21776613593101501,
0.31802836060523987,
0.06651626527309418,
0.1798548847436905,
-0.16984789073467255,
-0.5622525215148926,
-0.5104588866233826,
-0.37167593836784363,
-0.19652341306209564,
0.22100336849689484,
-0.22910195589065552,
-0.08598638325929642,
-0.3637854754924774,
-0.041263822466135025,
-0.6964020133018494,
-0.003815258387476206,
-0.12334296852350235,
-0.09515175968408585,
0.7723201513290405,
0.3073437213897705,
0.48963358998298645,
-0.02953401207923889,
-0.5377178192138672,
-0.024776585400104523,
-0.32831162214279175,
-0.18404902517795563,
0.1445981115102768,
0.37025508284568787,
0.08546764403581619,
0.5731180906295776,
0.27797093987464905,
0.2271886020898819,
-0.33361709117889404,
0.12879852950572968,
0.4520407021045685,
-0.37703415751457214,
0.0066207339987158775,
-0.0008670731331221759,
0.9119131565093994,
0.43863219022750854,
0.20502734184265137,
-0.5899620652198792,
-0.26534608006477356,
-0.025376172736287117,
0.2243562489748001,
-0.4514191746711731,
0.43192335963249207,
0.20855030417442322,
-0.4385528862476349,
-0.24552981555461884,
-0.1803668737411499,
-0.645135223865509,
-0.5432998538017273,
-0.29870790243148804,
0.42114609479904175,
-0.15863673388957977,
-0.2611916661262512,
0.2795065939426422,
-0.2041277438402176,
0.14727503061294556,
0.2746421992778778,
-0.5032423138618469,
0.007181140594184399,
0.33241817355155945,
0.9164097905158997,
-0.4920733869075775,
-0.890693724155426,
-0.507565975189209,
0.5589845776557922,
-0.5919901132583618,
0.693287193775177,
-0.26615023612976074,
-0.3820483684539795,
0.011193590238690376,
-0.005767046008259058,
-0.03447228670120239,
-0.14681905508041382,
0.7335957884788513,
-0.730903685092926,
-0.06851024180650711,
-0.12442576140165329,
-0.12886391580104828,
-0.08537285029888153,
0.09979216754436493,
-0.7507078051567078,
0.6818098425865173,
0.02249210700392723,
-0.3080836236476898,
0.13925626873970032,
-0.5916581153869629,
-0.3608056902885437,
0.25327977538108826,
0.12004905194044113,
-0.1043224185705185,
0.10863544791936874,
0.026865800842642784,
0.3402642607688904,
-0.6985460519790649,
0.12088136374950409,
-0.16760987043380737,
-0.41315531730651855,
0.589048445224762,
-0.41169556975364685,
0.5466973185539246,
0.30651021003723145,
-0.18093803524971008,
0.39728260040283203,
-0.22565223276615143,
-0.0937543734908104,
0.06614436954259872,
-0.3673996329307556,
-0.36134910583496094,
-0.307041734457016,
0.5612221360206604,
0.31380701065063477,
0.3737809658050537,
-0.5480396151542664,
0.15105237066745758,
-0.1964889019727707,
0.39051318168640137,
0.7335525155067444,
-0.4237377941608429,
0.505721390247345,
-0.3321800231933594,
0.6997596025466919,
-0.2711780369281769,
0.048420101404190063,
0.052276141941547394,
-0.20682848989963531,
-0.06071007624268532,
-0.4044952392578125,
0.3702699542045593,
0.37382224202156067,
-1.0833193063735962,
0.5595553517341614,
-0.47889798879623413,
-0.5604429841041565,
-0.6677972674369812,
0.1899155080318451,
0.4343387186527252,
-0.13247275352478027,
0.2688451111316681,
-0.15137839317321777,
0.0871300920844078,
-0.5549209713935852,
-0.4914259612560272,
-0.21639429032802582,
0.21568705141544342,
-0.30531203746795654,
0.3852553069591522,
-0.5417957305908203,
0.602900505065918,
-0.18637128174304962,
-0.4186702072620392,
-0.7841134071350098,
0.13442857563495636,
0.16625414788722992,
0.13267578184604645,
0.6806477904319763,
-0.9082990884780884,
-0.6556380391120911,
0.5631550550460815,
-0.6818822026252747,
-0.00595910893753171,
-0.17898878455162048,
-0.4990272521972656,
0.2055477648973465,
0.24192871153354645,
-0.8108373284339905,
0.3675418496131897,
0.6341452598571777,
-0.44652876257896423,
0.7108293771743774,
-0.35669347643852234,
0.33909082412719727,
-1.11356520652771,
0.15814784169197083,
-0.11060898751020432,
-0.5013604760169983,
-0.41861116886138916,
0.29062896966934204,
0.11269718408584595,
-0.10837715864181519,
-0.49580371379852295,
0.7840319275856018,
-0.6415380239486694,
0.05386701971292496,
-0.3204270303249359,
0.23234428465366364,
0.3686496317386627,
0.32809633016586304,
0.026405133306980133,
0.616407573223114,
0.04090641438961029,
-0.2846677899360657,
0.7074602842330933,
0.45213472843170166,
0.08332818001508713,
0.6489858627319336,
-0.3208952248096466,
0.3837071359157562,
-0.2467150092124939,
0.5451108813285828,
-1.0361049175262451,
0.010078883729875088,
0.06647803634405136,
-0.36448389291763306,
0.26850268244743347,
-0.0009388417238369584,
-0.8021602034568787,
-0.22472377121448517,
-0.36132246255874634,
0.5216652750968933,
0.24839965999126434,
-0.3317677080631256,
0.8279868960380554,
0.041163522750139236,
-0.1168380156159401,
-0.7046322226524353,
-1.116934061050415,
0.5988655686378479,
-0.012146452441811562,
-0.554792046546936,
0.2398640662431717,
-0.21852128207683563,
-0.04330058395862579,
0.16127978265285492,
0.1882593035697937,
-0.05465051531791687,
-0.2779422104358673,
-0.18616440892219543,
0.28919270634651184,
0.062428560107946396,
0.25728246569633484,
0.3124300539493561,
-0.24814853072166443,
-0.2555224299430847,
-0.4292580187320709,
0.22991737723350525,
-0.14519856870174408,
-0.3261258006095886,
-0.10249156504869461,
0.6944122910499573,
0.9527215361595154,
-0.686842679977417,
0.7983853816986084,
0.6508863568305969,
-0.06207169219851494,
-0.21375298500061035,
-0.4179355800151825,
0.14954301714897156,
-0.3712103068828583,
0.4615636169910431,
-0.6023808121681213,
-0.5496153831481934,
0.4192278981208801,
-0.1701565831899643,
0.027132339775562286,
0.40924230217933655,
0.6925280094146729,
0.10645873844623566,
0.8413721919059753,
0.5125511884689331,
-0.19520577788352966,
0.28806665539741516,
-0.24421675503253937,
0.018459901213645935,
-0.6618503332138062,
-0.03608391433954239,
-0.5632786750793457,
-0.3883112072944641,
-0.4279196858406067,
-0.4008951485157013,
0.7090562582015991,
-0.3399566411972046,
0.3732072114944458,
0.3812606930732727,
-0.21217188239097595,
0.5220529437065125,
0.08875894546508789,
-0.030724484473466873,
0.8726128339767456,
0.18079745769500732,
-0.3681698739528656,
-0.002440640004351735,
-0.2936643660068512,
-0.8517003655433655,
1.116979956626892,
0.26370012760162354,
0.6203925013542175,
0.502228856086731,
0.5068948864936829,
0.6162499189376831,
0.38139134645462036,
-0.8296529054641724,
0.5475766658782959,
-0.2903546094894409,
-1.012429118156433,
-0.5772275924682617,
-0.35744014382362366,
-1.2880890369415283,
0.9552944302558899,
-0.15192550420761108,
-0.3364377021789551,
0.1917961686849594,
-0.5246884226799011,
-0.06107008829712868,
0.37542280554771423,
-0.468767911195755,
0.8711715936660767,
-0.4750422537326813,
-0.6635739207267761,
-0.4071039855480194,
-0.7969249486923218,
-0.1290159374475479,
-0.3317534327507019,
0.2971290349960327,
-0.02841603197157383,
-0.5277348756790161,
0.2319348156452179,
-0.025219745934009552,
0.5235921144485474,
0.3910517394542694,
-0.29369884729385376,
0.2114078849554062,
0.32309436798095703,
0.2890065312385559,
-0.2744330167770386,
-0.6277127265930176,
0.12148448079824448,
0.14863541722297668,
-0.6717615127563477,
-0.4805925786495209,
0.4644804298877716,
-0.8947308659553528,
-0.04753100499510765,
-0.583293080329895,
-0.7922635078430176,
-0.14603528380393982,
0.4851856231689453,
0.18802635371685028,
0.3043186366558075,
-0.42086148262023926,
0.010097258724272251,
0.07102394849061966,
0.05798572301864624,
0.4591119587421417,
0.7494267821311951,
-0.30023816227912903,
-0.5295255780220032,
0.7429383993148804,
0.10046989470720291,
0.34916171431541443,
0.5586047768592834,
0.11123528331518173,
-0.6596819758415222,
-0.5933219790458679,
-0.9246348738670349,
0.5061626434326172,
-0.5710514783859253,
0.05756513029336929,
-0.5069968700408936,
0.04679597169160843,
-0.2764594554901123,
-0.20833878219127655,
-0.35828521847724915,
0.028946958482265472,
-0.15029388666152954,
-0.03747688978910446,
-0.07046734541654587,
0.807571291923523,
0.1008005142211914,
0.057395920157432556,
-1.1538997888565063,
0.26921793818473816,
-0.0096075888723135,
0.19751465320587158,
-0.20895162224769592,
-0.5311748385429382,
-0.5415292382240295,
-0.20347513258457184,
-0.43453922867774963,
-1.002084732055664,
0.5589898228645325,
-0.22637248039245605,
0.45814430713653564,
-0.13868314027786255,
0.2133207768201828,
0.23336105048656464,
-0.45627155900001526,
0.49002787470817566,
0.18817536532878876,
-0.9529772400856018,
-0.007989905774593353,
-0.5715903639793396,
0.17140978574752808,
0.752189576625824,
0.4357486367225647,
-0.6668255925178528,
-0.35612544417381287,
-0.18797434866428375,
-0.5882911086082458,
0.619090735912323,
0.46959376335144043,
0.3642692267894745,
0.3454909920692444,
0.11942658573389053,
0.12573270499706268,
0.4866204559803009,
-0.9435666799545288,
-0.050180476158857346,
0.3656918406486511,
-0.2495427131652832,
-0.7680830955505371,
0.08945813775062561,
-0.08341003209352493,
-0.07505830377340317,
0.4610639810562134,
-0.19967244565486908,
-0.11736351996660233,
0.36173659563064575,
-0.39153966307640076,
-0.3607507348060608,
0.6066190600395203,
0.30154064297676086,
0.8602175116539001,
-0.0514574833214283,
0.06185626611113548,
-0.11720702052116394,
-0.18284480273723602,
0.5782538652420044,
0.14379002153873444,
-0.07213134318590164,
-0.01476296316832304,
0.5656356811523438,
0.33616313338279724,
-0.5514911413192749,
-0.49461376667022705,
0.45001843571662903,
-0.006588736083358526,
-0.01759166829288006,
-0.1433265656232834,
-0.44732120633125305,
0.10993532836437225,
0.45271846652030945,
0.38001173734664917,
0.07428348064422607,
0.35891225934028625,
-0.7255852818489075,
-0.13207431137561798,
0.2912476062774658,
-0.5313917994499207,
-0.4163491725921631,
0.4124244749546051,
0.6595993041992188,
-0.2952309250831604,
-0.034180596470832825,
-0.4438689947128296,
-0.4100625514984131,
0.32526183128356934,
0.3322097063064575,
1.150142788887024,
-0.2366221696138382,
0.4778888523578644,
-0.41050049662590027,
0.731807291507721,
-0.19892871379852295,
-0.08381630480289459,
0.27803874015808105,
-0.6529463529586792,
-0.6200352311134338,
-0.39268556237220764,
-0.496234267950058,
-0.16413334012031555,
-0.14424388110637665,
0.2707216739654541,
0.02629420906305313,
-0.34934452176094055,
-0.1388503462076187,
0.13031016290187836,
-0.452816367149353,
-0.20567336678504944,
0.012310736812651157,
0.5667486786842346,
-0.8576758503913879,
0.7638475298881531,
1.1746034622192383,
-0.6924951672554016,
-0.36948397755622864,
0.20810578763484955,
0.023613668978214264,
-0.11319015920162201,
0.2065221518278122,
-0.08930841833353043,
-0.6932059526443481,
0.18028327822685242,
-0.2444995790719986,
-0.3435928523540497,
0.9653821587562561,
0.8836438655853271,
-0.447492778301239,
-0.1261732429265976,
0.3496227264404297,
1.0231014490127563,
-0.3290473222732544,
0.3736600875854492,
0.3490070700645447,
0.5401137471199036,
0.09482879936695099,
-1.1426349878311157,
0.026101335883140564,
-0.19286692142486572,
0.049454282969236374,
0.26081931591033936,
-1.156792402267456,
0.5229294300079346,
-0.1976826786994934,
-0.008878215216100216,
0.32213735580444336,
0.6088910698890686,
0.07732491940259933,
0.7044442892074585,
0.3810536861419678,
0.055258989334106445,
0.5296963453292847,
0.43995505571365356,
1.1934752464294434,
-0.04010697081685066,
0.24981480836868286,
0.7576819658279419,
-0.5761508345603943,
0.6449345350265503,
0.49383965134620667,
-0.2819707691669464,
0.42479684948921204,
0.29200008511543274,
0.3065539002418518,
0.1097002774477005,
0.26968157291412354,
-0.3429855704307556,
-0.48355966806411743,
-0.5107018947601318,
-0.3113076686859131,
0.43228113651275635,
-0.11045641452074051,
-0.326313853263855,
0.005242432467639446,
0.14428389072418213,
-0.04705103859305382,
0.5837949514389038,
0.06976642459630966,
0.5337994694709778,
0.26756083965301514,
-0.6203124523162842,
0.4154202342033386,
0.3905167579650879,
0.5224933624267578,
-0.6638409495353699,
0.1001872718334198,
-0.13477292656898499,
0.24818381667137146,
-0.20480366051197052,
-0.8188735246658325,
0.04612468555569649,
-0.09496942907571793,
-0.2227790802717209,
-0.3461187481880188,
0.5844923853874207,
-0.5599551796913147,
-0.7961323857307434,
0.8372749090194702,
0.9373504519462585,
0.27102866768836975,
-0.2652347981929779,
-0.636786937713623,
-0.06269757449626923,
-0.19692164659500122,
-0.2581646740436554,
0.12181773036718369,
0.8178933262825012,
-0.17444655299186707,
0.6829259991645813,
0.6182229518890381,
0.29677048325538635,
-0.2048027068376541,
0.17141401767730713,
0.5800653696060181,
-0.7492876052856445,
-0.6051515340805054,
-0.7580307722091675,
0.5003131628036499,
0.15385688841342926,
-0.1849534958600998,
0.5463230013847351,
0.3925877809524536,
0.39305830001831055,
-0.14765936136245728,
0.8501548171043396,
0.3268599808216095,
0.33806151151657104,
-0.16885292530059814,
0.8563370108604431,
-0.7647280693054199,
0.22273536026477814,
-0.44347065687179565,
-1.0286260843276978,
-0.20156949758529663,
0.04937465488910675,
-0.15506213903427124,
0.003717029932886362,
0.8773025274276733,
0.5750280022621155,
-0.00944720208644867,
-0.14570428431034088,
0.6546746492385864,
-0.09965432435274124,
0.40137234330177307,
0.6410165429115295,
1.0674933195114136,
-0.3327043056488037,
0.8514650464057922,
0.4187851548194885,
-0.22761648893356323,
-0.11988868564367294,
-0.8275418281555176,
-0.9713628888130188,
-0.4867863357067108,
-0.15868186950683594,
-0.25704747438430786,
0.07388290762901306,
1.190014362335205,
0.4763396680355072,
-0.25246474146842957,
-0.6379187703132629,
0.49540939927101135,
0.17042125761508942,
-0.18612362444400787,
-0.0865289494395256,
0.17995254695415497,
-0.11218186467885971,
-0.8659313917160034,
0.31868505477905273,
0.25609108805656433,
-0.0951458215713501,
-0.6009112000465393,
-0.2985205352306366,
-0.3377702236175537,
0.3401139974594116,
0.8408536911010742,
-0.25900986790657043,
-0.6250729560852051,
0.11729482561349869,
-0.1622421145439148,
-0.4958450198173523,
-0.1224905252456665,
0.6960667967796326,
-0.3133104145526886,
0.5727002024650574,
0.5429940223693848,
0.7850148677825928,
0.5759764313697815,
-0.21272365748882294,
0.6150507926940918,
-0.40416133403778076,
0.14585362374782562,
0.20930904150009155,
0.07036050409078598,
0.26745977997779846,
-0.41073012351989746,
0.6220516562461853,
0.28767573833465576,
-0.5260285139083862,
-0.7351220846176147,
0.20172013342380524,
-0.8051818013191223,
-0.33675211668014526,
1.1644539833068848,
-0.08846975117921829,
-0.15816503763198853,
-0.2478736937046051,
-0.41552895307540894,
0.30086249113082886,
-0.6177123188972473,
0.31763729453086853,
0.7768417000770569,
-0.013006340712308884,
0.04631633684039116,
-0.5762669444084167,
0.04233318194746971,
0.544242799282074,
-0.7924936413764954,
-0.08212736248970032,
0.5314164757728577,
-0.043404240161180496,
0.4453445374965668,
0.6727246642112732,
-0.29687002301216125,
0.15321950614452362,
-0.45171675086021423,
0.423271119594574,
-0.006642964668571949,
-0.5243138670921326,
-0.3631935119628906,
0.2134627401828766,
0.3045509457588196,
-0.051019519567489624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11783v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11783v1
|
Inverse Design of Metal-Organic Frameworks Using Quantum Natural Language Processing
| 2024-05-20T05:02:12 | 2024-05-20T05:02:12 |
Shinyoung Kang, Jihan Kim
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, quant-ph
|
In this study, we explore the potential of using quantum natural language
processing (QNLP) to inverse design metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) with
targeted properties. Specifically, by analyzing 150 hypothetical MOF structures
consisting of 10 metal nodes and 15 organic ligands, we categorize these
structures into four distinct classes for pore volume and $H_{2}$ uptake
values. We then compare various QNLP models (i.e. the bag-of-words, DisCoCat
(Distributional Compositional Categorical), and sequence-based models) to
identify the most effective approach to process the MOF dataset. Using a
classical simulator provided by the IBM Qiskit, the bag-of-words model is
identified to be the optimum model, achieving validation accuracies of 85.7%
and 86.7% for binary classification tasks on pore volume and $H_{2}$ uptake,
respectively. Further, we developed multi-class classification models tailored
to the probabilistic nature of quantum circuits, with average test accuracies
of 88.4% and 80.7% across different classes for pore volume and $H_{2}$ uptake
datasets. Finally, the performance of generating MOF with target properties
showed accuracies of 93.5% for pore volume and 89% for $H_{2}$ uptake,
respectively. Although our investigation covers only a fraction of the vast MOF
search space, it marks a promising first step towards using quantum computing
for materials design, offering a new perspective through which to explore the
complex landscape of MOFs.
|
[
-0.2138141542673111,
-0.9297230243682861,
0.8211516737937927,
-0.48038557171821594,
-0.23169861733913422,
0.2419852763414383,
0.2379315197467804,
-0.23108185827732086,
0.13155485689640045,
0.4949907064437866,
-0.46689102053642273,
-0.3916158676147461,
-0.0554363876581192,
0.0610751137137413,
-0.1994280219078064,
0.21035264432430267,
-0.09102516621351242,
0.10675454139709473,
-0.17190437018871307,
0.1253412812948227,
-0.1669212281703949,
-0.3460000157356262,
-0.3228317201137543,
-0.3101782202720642,
-0.046020347625017166,
0.04829999431967735,
0.9015141725540161,
0.8262543678283691,
0.5563982129096985,
0.29688748717308044,
-0.20423917472362518,
-0.11528731882572174,
-0.01491007674485445,
-0.4229643940925598,
-0.3103429675102234,
-0.572370707988739,
-0.3049207925796509,
-0.04594583064317703,
0.8023781776428223,
0.792517900466919,
-0.2707566022872925,
0.2873287498950958,
0.037028439342975616,
1.0669224262237549,
-0.6510162353515625,
-0.1976669281721115,
-0.5635568499565125,
0.7113872170448303,
-0.21560274064540863,
-0.5581226348876953,
-0.29543986916542053,
-0.12967132031917572,
0.19478857517242432,
-0.7374878525733948,
0.2612980604171753,
0.4719611704349518,
0.7351274490356445,
-0.13932424783706665,
-0.6728264093399048,
-0.22791826725006104,
-0.7656641602516174,
0.8105136156082153,
-0.977942168712616,
0.765180766582489,
0.4416043162345886,
0.3144811987876892,
-0.5802515745162964,
-0.5647876262664795,
-0.7035499215126038,
-0.03463256359100342,
-0.12445415556430817,
0.15472429990768433,
0.0397467166185379,
0.42634743452072144,
0.0895790308713913,
0.9591116309165955,
-1.1529432535171509,
-0.34690865874290466,
-0.21749918162822723,
-0.40562722086906433,
0.3382527828216553,
0.033665332943201065,
0.3968695104122162,
-0.3095671236515045,
-0.6188838481903076,
-0.3030105531215668,
-0.642338752746582,
0.19396118819713593,
0.3291606903076172,
0.4028071165084839,
0.20737560093402863,
0.8050938844680786,
-0.473733514547348,
0.7442435622215271,
-0.08005472272634506,
-0.0023009483702480793,
0.017150336876511574,
-0.7391571402549744,
-0.8173812627792358,
0.051332440227270126,
0.6751174330711365,
-0.01802004687488079,
-0.15176403522491455,
-0.21905536949634552,
-0.2489929348230362,
-0.23985031247138977,
0.2095816731452942,
-1.1108847856521606,
-0.2741963565349579,
0.5561431050300598,
-0.7677417397499084,
-0.30474188923835754,
0.19139327108860016,
-0.612905740737915,
-0.49856770038604736,
-0.40479329228401184,
0.7445329427719116,
-0.022612515836954117,
-0.41955623030662537,
0.6578542590141296,
-0.426809161901474,
-0.12524598836898804,
-0.14977864921092987,
-0.7621901631355286,
0.5579641461372375,
0.37175220251083374,
0.8951263427734375,
0.1076563373208046,
0.3139203190803528,
-0.44504791498184204,
0.21181362867355347,
-0.33392152190208435,
0.6731300354003906,
-0.5581656098365784,
-0.45354896783828735,
-0.12676844000816345,
-0.1934906244277954,
0.012228020466864109,
-0.8217732310295105,
0.7987366318702698,
-0.6790958642959595,
0.2390211671590805,
-0.34110698103904724,
-0.2945742905139923,
-0.5117510557174683,
0.3205416798591614,
-0.98627108335495,
0.5139267444610596,
0.5646857619285583,
-0.5453925132751465,
0.14289404451847076,
-0.701209306716919,
-0.3152592182159424,
-0.1578364223241806,
-0.09952637553215027,
-0.3619423508644104,
0.2407260239124298,
-0.04774040728807449,
0.06804046779870987,
-0.5378723740577698,
0.19094818830490112,
-0.619630753993988,
-0.4260783791542053,
0.4473261535167694,
-0.3751557469367981,
0.8508991599082947,
0.19986151158809662,
-0.29185590147972107,
0.2371784746646881,
-1.1061233282089233,
0.3235471546649933,
-0.01770510897040367,
-0.45692867040634155,
-0.24028749763965607,
-0.07135787606239319,
0.14721806347370148,
0.4956947863101959,
-0.20215944945812225,
-0.7963496446609497,
-0.09668345749378204,
-0.7286540865898132,
0.6959512829780579,
0.8129398226737976,
0.21637855470180511,
0.6639173030853271,
-0.3072514832019806,
0.6296929717063904,
0.011198487132787704,
0.16733725368976593,
0.26687267422676086,
-0.05667278543114662,
-0.4901626408100128,
0.04955470189452171,
0.4412343502044678,
0.39316636323928833,
-0.6911226511001587,
0.27233272790908813,
0.0005481795524246991,
-0.22600820660591125,
-0.13234718143939972,
0.3432930111885071,
0.3730493187904358,
0.5884428024291992,
0.2643655836582184,
-0.3179533779621124,
-0.3330309987068176,
-1.2670836448669434,
-0.3994763493537903,
-0.5048850774765015,
0.022562170401215553,
0.3075564503669739,
0.3327338993549347,
-0.09405146539211273,
0.973707914352417,
-0.6662362217903137,
-0.5946548581123352,
0.3708922863006592,
0.04212161526083946,
0.2859521508216858,
0.6630378365516663,
0.35764291882514954,
-1.2605262994766235,
-0.2008984237909317,
0.09761329740285873,
-0.4199392795562744,
0.2475210428237915,
-0.2762210965156555,
-0.8466631174087524,
0.023555634543299675,
0.2109365314245224,
-0.9268744587898254,
0.33914345502853394,
0.405120849609375,
-0.4796253740787506,
0.6417102813720703,
0.25637826323509216,
0.25775399804115295,
-1.0107471942901611,
0.36685970425605774,
0.08734898269176483,
-0.12168150395154953,
-0.48571789264678955,
0.4568328857421875,
0.03170730173587799,
-0.17323823273181915,
-0.6558538675308228,
0.631916344165802,
-0.5714361071586609,
-0.08511590957641602,
-0.12168992310762405,
-0.2553720474243164,
0.242903932929039,
0.9054938554763794,
-0.007251618430018425,
0.6922400593757629,
0.07631909847259521,
-0.7111571431159973,
0.12645700573921204,
-0.03221653401851654,
-0.23916298151016235,
0.44617995619773865,
-0.5733094811439514,
-0.007693701423704624,
0.2186795324087143,
0.05965197831392288,
-1.187143087387085,
-0.05494284629821777,
0.6368759274482727,
-0.2749421298503876,
0.18947991728782654,
-0.044724076986312866,
-0.964929461479187,
-0.44015705585479736,
-0.3791663348674774,
0.39418020844459534,
0.17276166379451752,
-0.35485392808914185,
1.0359638929367065,
0.2249096781015396,
0.13608701527118683,
0.15280655026435852,
-0.5982786417007446,
-0.2926160395145416,
-0.46896621584892273,
-0.4953452944755554,
0.5797854661941528,
-0.5543645620346069,
-0.11378201097249985,
0.10542990267276764,
-0.5303940176963806,
-0.28921690583229065,
0.41019129753112793,
0.3591724634170532,
-0.10264658182859421,
-0.3053603172302246,
0.47513347864151,
0.2873864471912384,
0.0810636430978775,
0.34170621633529663,
-0.6837928295135498,
0.6458414196968079,
-0.3493250608444214,
-0.3758588433265686,
-0.6175808906555176,
0.2502216696739197,
0.4098697304725647,
-0.3331080973148346,
0.3934452533721924,
0.4332334101200104,
-0.7285013198852539,
0.0550190731883049,
-0.02550298534333706,
-0.2107403427362442,
-0.6026840806007385,
0.12150093168020248,
-0.6965499520301819,
-0.5611211061477661,
0.3505917489528656,
0.00811554305255413,
0.24448902904987335,
0.4768998622894287,
0.2543029487133026,
-0.18441510200500488,
1.2314800024032593,
0.49583446979522705,
0.27271944284439087,
0.5636373162269592,
-0.3393069803714752,
0.1751851886510849,
-0.8795859217643738,
0.1837361454963684,
-0.26314765214920044,
-0.45842233300209045,
-0.3581778407096863,
-0.14435556530952454,
0.3631477952003479,
0.46077102422714233,
-0.21925517916679382,
0.47421690821647644,
-0.5120697021484375,
0.23747815191745758,
0.454305499792099,
0.3110942542552948,
0.4964972138404846,
0.4582270383834839,
-0.39073094725608826,
0.24243563413619995,
-0.6397575736045837,
-0.47041723132133484,
1.0246477127075195,
0.19728243350982666,
0.3100878596305847,
0.4058080017566681,
0.651167631149292,
0.2843363583087921,
0.03362827003002167,
-0.7821560502052307,
0.5687851309776306,
0.2759586572647095,
-0.9384433031082153,
-0.411012202501297,
-0.3997116982936859,
-0.7230779528617859,
0.5323323607444763,
-0.24514655768871307,
-0.4005314111709595,
0.4611811339855194,
0.32087764143943787,
-0.6690298914909363,
0.5295886993408203,
-0.78729647397995,
0.729313313961029,
-0.17284995317459106,
-0.3947769105434418,
-0.23934556543827057,
-0.3861699104309082,
0.5155583620071411,
-0.11267814040184021,
0.4268702566623688,
0.07363470643758774,
0.20203115046024323,
0.5123027563095093,
-0.39950165152549744,
0.40182217955589294,
-0.07511641085147858,
-0.4848261773586273,
0.6219025254249573,
0.5947288274765015,
0.21867264807224274,
0.21102522313594818,
-0.33179372549057007,
-0.2347109019756317,
0.3607572019100189,
-0.3315308690071106,
-0.7588638663291931,
0.39839276671409607,
-0.2497308999300003,
-0.7446082234382629,
-0.2958039939403534,
-0.4353273808956146,
-0.22711360454559326,
0.6955195069313049,
-0.022097419947385788,
0.618960440158844,
0.014215958304703236,
0.32382479310035706,
0.5841377377510071,
0.1376670002937317,
0.3047995865345001,
0.6175795793533325,
-0.32152536511421204,
-0.3254765570163727,
1.3836979866027832,
0.18435987830162048,
0.47241082787513733,
0.962467610836029,
0.5943582057952881,
-0.5280773043632507,
-0.6238937973976135,
-0.850755512714386,
0.04640878736972809,
-0.5548622608184814,
-0.23750469088554382,
-0.5743370056152344,
-0.10794485360383987,
-0.3112201690673828,
0.007787254638969898,
-0.18308918178081512,
-0.5692758560180664,
-0.515208899974823,
-0.09411229193210602,
0.0019799626898020506,
-0.0005559598212130368,
0.0738338828086853,
0.31971651315689087,
-0.9043390154838562,
0.6410568952560425,
0.26173093914985657,
0.7912994027137756,
0.13779105246067047,
-0.3622775673866272,
-0.14024144411087036,
0.5802880525588989,
-0.5314086675643921,
-0.7603614926338196,
0.0484360046684742,
0.3017835021018982,
0.5708619356155396,
0.3420560657978058,
0.39287787675857544,
0.724947988986969,
-0.25998175144195557,
0.3972158133983612,
0.1163468211889267,
-0.7599208950996399,
0.6592573523521423,
-0.37526294589042664,
0.4081093370914459,
0.44179290533065796,
0.19078779220581055,
-0.14853915572166443,
-0.04520048946142197,
-0.6599766612052917,
-0.4942067861557007,
0.45152631402015686,
0.5012355446815491,
-0.2621408700942993,
0.25813043117523193,
0.09058121591806412,
0.03649386763572693,
0.3490214943885803,
-0.7330965995788574,
-0.08282312005758286,
0.04012000933289528,
-0.25658267736434937,
0.30359917879104614,
-0.05381667613983154,
-0.36501410603523254,
0.10171303153038025,
0.737802267074585,
-0.2449270486831665,
0.27883997559547424,
0.3145305812358856,
-0.2946692109107971,
-0.4552120864391327,
0.4284740686416626,
0.7174668312072754,
0.636968195438385,
-0.6923564076423645,
0.17121468484401703,
-0.3980330228805542,
-0.449381560087204,
0.2503877580165863,
0.0637054443359375,
-0.1696990430355072,
-0.11178659647703171,
-0.03541507199406624,
0.38770556449890137,
-0.04544137045741081,
-0.936352550983429,
0.038005102425813675,
-0.03043700009584427,
-0.34979701042175293,
-0.35568177700042725,
0.17890380322933197,
0.023938927799463272,
0.3880133628845215,
0.33879685401916504,
0.09973736107349396,
0.9341015219688416,
-0.8143317699432373,
0.18142378330230713,
0.5957366824150085,
-0.4140872061252594,
-0.45388320088386536,
0.5871906280517578,
0.1580028384923935,
-0.3716588020324707,
0.3468639552593231,
-0.3877873718738556,
-0.4166768789291382,
0.6205484867095947,
0.6668647527694702,
0.8998810648918152,
0.3035248816013336,
0.2204923927783966,
0.5306380987167358,
0.1473345309495926,
0.03661827743053436,
0.35652250051498413,
-0.4663195013999939,
-0.48215940594673157,
0.24476884305477142,
-0.9115302562713623,
-0.09226636588573456,
-0.049286287277936935,
-0.5853621959686279,
-0.1082599014043808,
-0.8713707327842712,
-0.40870723128318787,
0.040932778269052505,
0.42074379324913025,
-0.6209815740585327,
0.41559329628944397,
-0.10508625954389572,
0.655817449092865,
-0.6636466979980469,
0.5138056874275208,
0.7962586879730225,
-0.27334412932395935,
-0.5242626667022705,
-0.1411905437707901,
0.46049943566322327,
-0.3310566842556,
0.4541964828968048,
0.09098584949970245,
-0.35196009278297424,
0.45757392048835754,
-0.2710266709327698,
-1.1736220121383667,
1.2108327150344849,
0.05836013704538345,
-0.4076409637928009,
0.05022788792848587,
0.2746581733226776,
0.3383535146713257,
0.007426361553370953,
0.10697988420724869,
0.5474869012832642,
0.32487934827804565,
-0.10216832906007767,
-0.704963743686676,
0.26401013135910034,
-0.568867564201355,
0.22518987953662872,
0.3401702642440796,
-0.611236035823822,
0.644670307636261,
-0.09705527126789093,
-0.8997758626937866,
0.39184248447418213,
0.5268997550010681,
0.7700551152229309,
0.12300173193216324,
0.6639322638511658,
0.589853048324585,
0.5717843174934387,
0.09989668428897858,
0.8789229989051819,
-0.06125115975737572,
0.10439833998680115,
0.743963360786438,
-0.18073002994060516,
0.807153582572937,
0.7592816352844238,
-0.44161462783813477,
0.47051846981048584,
0.6674127578735352,
0.22472047805786133,
0.47314906120300293,
0.4589158296585083,
0.012096917256712914,
-0.2198452204465866,
-0.3630889654159546,
-0.36684495210647583,
0.022324927151203156,
0.3109690845012665,
-0.18536034226417542,
-0.02847140282392502,
-0.043902140110731125,
-0.6968315839767456,
0.09250761568546295,
-0.08245988935232162,
0.22464925050735474,
0.14432117342948914,
-0.24043093621730804,
0.3725970983505249,
0.2657788395881653,
0.4833703339099884,
-0.2850353419780731,
-0.3921450078487396,
-0.09131504595279694,
0.06143687292933464,
-0.2075706571340561,
-0.7748362421989441,
-0.014702282845973969,
-0.6963537931442261,
-0.5158805847167969,
-0.30455711483955383,
0.66387939453125,
-0.30912333726882935,
-0.6238745450973511,
-0.08282654732465744,
0.18960894644260406,
-0.1513434797525406,
-0.29809126257896423,
-0.5366727113723755,
-0.04750673100352287,
-0.05243299901485443,
-0.2957799434661865,
0.3238702416419983,
0.3070680499076843,
-0.047525759786367416,
0.7445753812789917,
1.116413950920105,
0.03740078583359718,
0.0025490056723356247,
-0.3486907482147217,
0.7185537815093994,
-0.9301377534866333,
-0.6528264880180359,
-0.5790559649467468,
0.5639570355415344,
0.12581783533096313,
-0.2324208766222,
0.37518784403800964,
0.8044463992118835,
0.967065155506134,
-0.18579530715942383,
0.35490164160728455,
0.09200446307659149,
0.4424504041671753,
-1.051486611366272,
0.5579801201820374,
-0.943416953086853,
0.38722720742225647,
-0.3647387623786926,
-0.8256930708885193,
-0.020308349281549454,
0.7042450904846191,
0.3707081377506256,
-0.06653561443090439,
0.6389347314834595,
0.8858729004859924,
-0.12293648719787598,
0.16920247673988342,
0.013151183724403381,
-0.11895859986543655,
0.7951546311378479,
0.653379499912262,
0.6980750560760498,
-0.6900187134742737,
0.5207299590110779,
-0.542995274066925,
0.19406017661094666,
-0.39541107416152954,
-0.5464465618133545,
-0.5846750736236572,
-0.5336301326751709,
-0.33840662240982056,
-0.1482739895582199,
-0.4204663932323456,
0.8355096578598022,
0.8293360471725464,
-0.7554545998573303,
-0.39789336919784546,
-0.5650045871734619,
0.310146301984787,
-0.37671852111816406,
-0.3031251132488251,
0.6408324837684631,
0.2514633536338806,
-0.5673884153366089,
0.14498479664325714,
0.2355474978685379,
0.44675570726394653,
-0.3478977084159851,
0.02928725816309452,
-0.28453612327575684,
-0.1543363630771637,
0.8883830904960632,
0.41006147861480713,
-0.9483221769332886,
-0.1933102160692215,
0.4111960530281067,
-0.2397948056459427,
0.008970599621534348,
0.8403103351593018,
-0.9498993754386902,
0.6160072088241577,
0.7362605333328247,
0.7021991014480591,
-0.013394970446825027,
0.09885604679584503,
0.6282581686973572,
-0.3878733217716217,
-0.12738272547721863,
0.3736530542373657,
0.17289415001869202,
-0.06164335086941719,
-0.4418262243270874,
0.5298355221748352,
0.3743993043899536,
-0.08031829446554184,
-1.0965839624404907,
0.1661287099123001,
-1.229784607887268,
-0.6276606321334839,
0.993054986000061,
0.540316641330719,
-0.30264273285865784,
0.12567168474197388,
-0.4569365084171295,
0.26740631461143494,
-0.1765414923429489,
0.5781735777854919,
0.8462426066398621,
-0.2695268988609314,
-0.17146575450897217,
-0.8309750556945801,
0.3055274486541748,
0.5955918431282043,
-0.6359301209449768,
-0.08448106050491333,
0.4597347676753998,
0.09311068058013916,
0.3658543825149536,
0.6286251544952393,
-0.3523871600627899,
0.352003276348114,
-0.1584782749414444,
-0.29804638028144836,
-0.23769532144069672,
-0.35941171646118164,
-0.11599844694137573,
0.20862527191638947,
-0.05543453246355057,
-0.15987685322761536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11775v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11775v1
|
Exploring Ordinality in Text Classification: A Comparative Study of Explicit and Implicit Techniques
| 2024-05-20T04:31:04 | 2024-05-20T04:31:04 |
Siva Rajesh Kasa, Aniket Goel, Karan Gupta, Sumegh Roychowdhury, Anish Bhanushali, Nikhil Pattisapu, Prasanna Srinivasa Murthy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Ordinal Classification (OC) is a widely encountered challenge in Natural
Language Processing (NLP), with applications in various domains such as
sentiment analysis, rating prediction, and more. Previous approaches to tackle
OC have primarily focused on modifying existing or creating novel loss
functions that \textbf{explicitly} account for the ordinal nature of labels.
However, with the advent of Pretrained Language Models (PLMs), it became
possible to tackle ordinality through the \textbf{implicit} semantics of the
labels as well. This paper provides a comprehensive theoretical and empirical
examination of both these approaches. Furthermore, we also offer strategic
recommendations regarding the most effective approach to adopt based on
specific settings.
|
[
-0.2736227512359619,
-0.8121272325515747,
0.6005552411079407,
-0.10541149228811264,
-0.045544516295194626,
-0.26978588104248047,
-0.03980183228850365,
-0.586527943611145,
-0.5396131873130798,
0.4429008662700653,
-0.3347507417201996,
-0.9010818600654602,
-0.5939693450927734,
0.03193777799606323,
-0.3159624934196472,
1.292063593864441,
-0.2255052626132965,
0.15700899064540863,
-0.3640170097351074,
-0.5538380742073059,
-0.28852495551109314,
-1.1979345083236694,
-1.1927112340927124,
-0.22324921190738678,
0.6863974928855896,
0.34578219056129456,
0.7072710990905762,
0.49194130301475525,
0.5351072549819946,
0.3703369200229645,
-0.14469923079013824,
0.031818754971027374,
-0.3877769708633423,
0.35991379618644714,
-0.06639611721038818,
-0.500026285648346,
-0.6357147693634033,
0.3852420747280121,
0.6475718021392822,
1.1181963682174683,
-0.14581280946731567,
0.05458226799964905,
0.07773452252149582,
0.5770245790481567,
-0.7826300263404846,
0.22632557153701782,
-0.09824027121067047,
0.1369544267654419,
-0.23003756999969482,
-0.3504810929298401,
-0.43995681405067444,
-0.7192894816398621,
0.5473721027374268,
-0.3587733805179596,
0.12488061189651489,
0.32052335143089294,
0.41974157094955444,
0.35705578327178955,
-0.6340516209602356,
-0.6754485964775085,
-0.7804058194160461,
0.742676854133606,
-0.45064103603363037,
0.5270541310310364,
0.27013736963272095,
-0.09677407145500183,
0.04684336483478546,
-0.7711046934127808,
-0.2989247441291809,
-0.14144323766231537,
-0.09429431706666946,
0.2129891961812973,
0.40209290385246277,
0.06850364804267883,
0.2930520176887512,
0.4551514685153961,
-0.3493211567401886,
0.19643348455429077,
0.0017471115570515394,
0.3285157084465027,
0.7574132084846497,
0.07826440036296844,
0.4080364406108856,
-0.13144700229167938,
-0.5134299397468567,
-0.2212108075618744,
-0.4986952245235443,
0.47584590315818787,
0.507374107837677,
0.0946311429142952,
0.1237269788980484,
0.7231015563011169,
0.027214523404836655,
0.5443325638771057,
0.04288491606712341,
-0.33718401193618774,
0.12124910950660706,
-0.26611629128456116,
-0.1981230229139328,
0.6007316708564758,
0.5721805095672607,
0.13874171674251556,
0.33341333270072937,
0.12562471628189087,
-0.16183242201805115,
-0.03446846082806587,
0.37345755100250244,
-0.5669288635253906,
-0.10302294045686722,
0.030895531177520752,
-0.5538145899772644,
-0.4055243730545044,
0.309053510427475,
-0.2279522866010666,
-0.6308163404464722,
-0.47483548521995544,
0.13140684366226196,
-0.552322268486023,
0.005286653526127338,
0.21194137632846832,
-0.05477558448910713,
0.27733051776885986,
0.36542102694511414,
-0.872313916683197,
0.28342095017433167,
0.7159618735313416,
0.5745242834091187,
-0.24765104055404663,
-0.22049574553966522,
-0.09895646572113037,
-0.24835523962974548,
-0.4153234660625458,
0.8408316373825073,
-0.4730519950389862,
-0.538710355758667,
0.20422646403312683,
-0.3596157431602478,
-0.08567965775728226,
-0.07878977060317993,
1.0682578086853027,
-0.5613923072814941,
0.5002284049987793,
-0.15012487769126892,
-0.3570669889450073,
-0.20102235674858093,
0.0699143335223198,
-0.49593105912208557,
1.4293816089630127,
-0.20408350229263306,
-1.0511001348495483,
0.708175539970398,
-0.7559723854064941,
-0.5474552512168884,
-0.2386731058359146,
0.0950956717133522,
-0.406083881855011,
0.2793633043766022,
-0.16713503003120422,
0.5808088183403015,
0.011699453927576542,
-0.07068649679422379,
-0.4269964396953583,
-0.09198664128780365,
0.19188103079795837,
-0.3323259651660919,
0.7140482068061829,
0.10169956088066101,
-0.2384680062532425,
0.011129322461783886,
-0.8713019490242004,
0.037351056933403015,
-0.2328508049249649,
-0.2586500346660614,
-1.0074437856674194,
0.5151450037956238,
-0.23388664424419403,
0.04430970922112465,
0.24078406393527985,
-0.38644465804100037,
0.28971248865127563,
-0.5694196820259094,
0.639780580997467,
0.4979291558265686,
-0.23064948618412018,
1.0331084728240967,
0.04144247621297836,
0.21060363948345184,
-0.5755245089530945,
0.34208500385284424,
0.1746595799922943,
-0.5228342413902283,
-0.8999871611595154,
-0.09925214946269989,
0.37403246760368347,
0.5758486986160278,
-0.7106435298919678,
0.5207810997962952,
-0.1916903704404831,
-0.22470150887966156,
-0.3912830352783203,
-0.25744175910949707,
0.3581085205078125,
0.5048662424087524,
0.4284103810787201,
-0.2798803448677063,
-0.2780780792236328,
-0.30602508783340454,
-0.23394663631916046,
-0.5364567637443542,
0.032814934849739075,
0.2553294897079468,
0.2613341808319092,
0.11482062935829163,
0.97845458984375,
-0.6908848881721497,
-0.5137799978256226,
-0.058508001267910004,
0.8759677410125732,
-0.0698070302605629,
0.31048470735549927,
0.4630453288555145,
-0.9378345012664795,
-0.536011815071106,
-0.034643325954675674,
-0.8161852359771729,
-0.37119272351264954,
0.3891701400279999,
-0.0711464062333107,
0.9757480025291443,
0.9342380166053772,
-0.0964168980717659,
0.8122269511222839,
0.23982372879981995,
-0.3762286901473999,
0.28469833731651306,
-0.3018924593925476,
0.26269978284835815,
-0.40614622831344604,
0.0590854249894619,
-0.13213080167770386,
-0.24611203372478485,
-0.714224100112915,
-0.09886913746595383,
-0.15115848183631897,
0.13463148474693298,
-0.4235478937625885,
0.4909449815750122,
-0.3435799181461334,
0.07810395210981369,
-0.0982946828007698,
-0.08232409507036209,
-0.03304583206772804,
0.35717931389808655,
0.6489614844322205,
0.31893184781074524,
0.2763771712779999,
-0.5902987122535706,
0.10542882233858109,
0.042010724544525146,
-0.1825137734413147,
1.062160611152649,
-0.4144875407218933,
0.17719624936580658,
-0.5554947853088379,
0.196552574634552,
-1.2352756261825562,
0.12733662128448486,
0.35219261050224304,
-0.5215356945991516,
0.5388503670692444,
0.044848956167697906,
-0.5940127968788147,
-0.06267250329256058,
-0.5098982453346252,
0.5834338068962097,
0.5214455127716064,
-0.5022030472755432,
0.6980903744697571,
0.23811060190200806,
-0.4510490894317627,
-0.4490368664264679,
-0.6052849292755127,
-0.4424300789833069,
-0.37639254331588745,
-0.367310106754303,
0.4538460075855255,
-0.09122582525014877,
-0.2780899703502655,
-0.060534119606018066,
-0.2826186716556549,
-0.14204762876033783,
-0.051121361553668976,
0.47108474373817444,
0.22337009012699127,
-0.24377399682998657,
0.2626429498195648,
-0.1365491896867752,
-0.19582484662532806,
0.2456206977367401,
-0.3215382993221283,
0.218643918633461,
-0.2601971924304962,
-0.15723749995231628,
-0.03206227719783783,
0.3718464970588684,
0.21358899772167206,
-0.06855485588312149,
0.9379072189331055,
0.5057574510574341,
0.07254704087972641,
-0.39401957392692566,
-0.7020559906959534,
0.1723453253507614,
-0.38949909806251526,
0.10457795113325119,
-0.21164432168006897,
-0.600946843624115,
0.15607862174510956,
0.0776313841342926,
0.04351375252008438,
0.4033677279949188,
0.147671639919281,
-0.40634384751319885,
1.5159839391708374,
0.9358323812484741,
-0.06399920582771301,
0.5338349342346191,
-0.12467488646507263,
0.2599218189716339,
-0.5004984140396118,
-0.5583980083465576,
-0.9632735848426819,
-0.07207441329956055,
-0.6589686870574951,
-0.06162114068865776,
0.5081247687339783,
0.22313344478607178,
-0.42439013719558716,
0.016372404992580414,
-0.4880038797855377,
0.2866087257862091,
0.4903547167778015,
-0.09812948107719421,
0.4941334128379822,
0.004230865277349949,
-0.07267241925001144,
0.090782530605793,
-0.9071281552314758,
-0.6235696077346802,
0.7621057033538818,
0.46074485778808594,
0.5965083837509155,
-0.02667425572872162,
0.4695422351360321,
0.10918907076120377,
0.6283997297286987,
-0.835395097732544,
0.39837750792503357,
-0.5250519514083862,
-0.4784311056137085,
-0.6061964631080627,
-0.36272305250167847,
-1.0152676105499268,
0.009505582973361015,
-0.3681887686252594,
-0.5651171803474426,
0.347237765789032,
0.05749141424894333,
-0.2765417695045471,
0.009394804015755653,
-0.7796400785446167,
0.7893097400665283,
-0.45595884323120117,
-0.013044992461800575,
0.4459817707538605,
-0.7643927931785583,
0.15005196630954742,
0.05975780636072159,
0.27821820974349976,
0.16369442641735077,
-0.49933868646621704,
0.6913799047470093,
-0.543913722038269,
0.7645058035850525,
0.10375326126813889,
-0.46292054653167725,
0.2695101201534271,
-0.39678823947906494,
0.2697499096393585,
-0.01623808592557907,
-0.1698712706565857,
0.2980670928955078,
0.036221254616975784,
-0.17644937336444855,
-0.6886537075042725,
0.7734336853027344,
-0.8952504992485046,
-0.05476350709795952,
-0.8328383564949036,
-0.09178056567907333,
-0.20907601714134216,
0.13583312928676605,
0.5333956480026245,
0.6059950590133667,
-0.343580037355423,
0.005938415881246328,
1.0366069078445435,
-0.2854670584201813,
0.4136689007282257,
0.7404363751411438,
0.012470714747905731,
-0.3412207067012787,
0.7233956456184387,
0.41909751296043396,
0.011796663515269756,
0.6175675392150879,
0.16076788306236267,
-0.7685419321060181,
-0.6331004500389099,
0.11812936514616013,
0.037117850035429,
-0.800060510635376,
-0.08577436953783035,
-0.5174157619476318,
-0.34131497144699097,
-0.5344337821006775,
-0.3096488416194916,
-0.030975593253970146,
-0.17430587112903595,
-0.3715234398841858,
-0.11153582483530045,
0.33379754424095154,
0.8847900629043579,
0.27835536003112793,
0.19636401534080505,
-0.2942350208759308,
0.2873096466064453,
0.3819335103034973,
0.6165892481803894,
-0.14482392370700836,
-0.3545665144920349,
0.2055526226758957,
-0.20863781869411469,
-0.1262626051902771,
-0.8262796401977539,
0.3090267479419708,
0.25059646368026733,
0.5151559710502625,
0.5270986557006836,
0.5634303092956543,
0.4691605865955353,
-0.5651691555976868,
0.694303035736084,
0.1297312080860138,
-1.0187100172042847,
0.3175542950630188,
-0.14663179218769073,
0.2924618721008301,
0.8256358504295349,
1.0019043684005737,
-0.31847548484802246,
-0.28049784898757935,
-0.7444673776626587,
-1.1599476337432861,
1.027768611907959,
0.3251359760761261,
-0.3027227818965912,
0.16031979024410248,
0.48805147409439087,
0.24779793620109558,
0.4589211344718933,
-0.7178792953491211,
-0.6378669142723083,
-0.3523106276988983,
-0.22647282481193542,
-0.47121259570121765,
-0.4108447730541229,
0.39459139108657837,
-0.06285731494426727,
0.6448627710342407,
0.20084960758686066,
-0.00322746392339468,
0.4250166118144989,
-0.2122802436351776,
0.2573337256908417,
0.24090629816055298,
0.41460904479026794,
0.10696717351675034,
-0.4033711850643158,
0.5715345740318298,
0.3676646053791046,
-0.429149329662323,
0.117987722158432,
-0.023949047550559044,
-0.2589840590953827,
-0.16298171877861023,
0.47573238611221313,
0.610897958278656,
0.3547685742378235,
-0.1816231906414032,
0.3456198275089264,
-0.010991365648806095,
-0.14381514489650726,
-0.27897346019744873,
-0.10432378202676773,
-0.3655860424041748,
-0.188690647482872,
0.19036470353603363,
0.15673761069774628,
0.46971169114112854,
-0.8872607350349426,
-0.3834657371044159,
0.21546976268291473,
-0.7346128225326538,
-0.047992583364248276,
0.2778831720352173,
0.2976621389389038,
-0.26389193534851074,
0.5685651302337646,
-0.013392430730164051,
-0.6225633025169373,
0.31329479813575745,
-0.17341993749141693,
0.7991944551467896,
-0.36610713601112366,
0.2062707394361496,
0.03186892718076706,
0.2386026680469513,
-0.30572474002838135,
-0.02662087418138981,
-0.22689269483089447,
-0.6204352378845215,
-0.3284922242164612,
-0.5230496525764465,
-0.2205318808555603,
0.0002558041305746883,
-0.7735667824745178,
0.3241051435470581,
-0.4571346342563629,
-0.4338337182998657,
0.32688337564468384,
0.026204047724604607,
-0.4283575415611267,
0.2755427956581116,
0.5140615105628967,
0.7583996653556824,
-0.7250707149505615,
0.6131965517997742,
1.098990559577942,
-0.3087601959705353,
-0.5822186470031738,
-0.24441084265708923,
-0.12306539714336395,
-0.35236993432044983,
0.8351941108703613,
0.008425922133028507,
-0.45921677350997925,
0.0710601955652237,
-0.6678666472434998,
-0.6070349216461182,
0.6141746640205383,
-0.06832154840230942,
0.16855591535568237,
0.06766372174024582,
0.41628995537757874,
0.9758676290512085,
-0.28261616826057434,
0.5548248291015625,
0.7132852673530579,
0.7568318247795105,
0.017169028520584106,
-0.7404501438140869,
-0.23950043320655823,
-0.24407744407653809,
0.22183580696582794,
0.32143354415893555,
-0.19453148543834686,
0.7606400847434998,
0.19888104498386383,
-0.4442306160926819,
0.3279480040073395,
0.598252534866333,
-0.1960538923740387,
0.5617016553878784,
0.6033027768135071,
0.24744951725006104,
0.5302073955535889,
-0.31635671854019165,
1.3106342554092407,
0.1398749053478241,
0.19661486148834229,
0.8534650802612305,
-0.42327767610549927,
1.1083130836486816,
0.08560077846050262,
-0.12363120168447495,
0.6412920951843262,
0.5886774659156799,
0.3551160395145416,
0.41358858346939087,
0.16838438808918,
-0.05278518795967102,
-0.21623767912387848,
-0.38678044080734253,
-0.4494658410549164,
0.19819055497646332,
0.315389484167099,
-0.1908460557460785,
-0.08716420829296112,
0.18796193599700928,
0.12218084186315536,
0.2255115807056427,
-0.6907806992530823,
1.1562979221343994,
0.23832356929779053,
-0.8493824601173401,
0.5177972912788391,
0.25292539596557617,
0.6802269220352173,
-0.7257389426231384,
-0.08226458728313446,
-0.15857170522212982,
0.17673242092132568,
-0.36288219690322876,
-0.8016186356544495,
0.23376205563545227,
-0.13079720735549927,
-0.38139957189559937,
-0.8921820521354675,
0.8618119359016418,
-0.5408340692520142,
-0.278066486120224,
0.251268595457077,
-0.006300441455096006,
0.0888182669878006,
-0.11688974499702454,
-0.6386815905570984,
-0.13113820552825928,
-0.5207917094230652,
-0.1650705486536026,
0.31215378642082214,
0.7552345395088196,
-0.15506552159786224,
0.4955693483352661,
0.44751426577568054,
-0.12396904826164246,
0.017208563163876534,
-0.12439380586147308,
0.48981720209121704,
-0.4867703914642334,
-0.4911724030971527,
-0.6013015508651733,
0.23716813325881958,
-0.04667462036013603,
-0.325703889131546,
1.1326783895492554,
0.1477775275707245,
0.8052482604980469,
-0.18122461438179016,
0.4167279601097107,
0.022738613188266754,
0.41039398312568665,
-0.7126991748809814,
0.5880919098854065,
-0.4944821298122406,
0.28083860874176025,
-0.3352474272251129,
-1.0570592880249023,
-0.3865998685359955,
0.7624446153640747,
-0.7552741765975952,
0.13839119672775269,
1.1692100763320923,
0.28989094495773315,
0.35921546816825867,
0.20105086266994476,
0.047743044793605804,
0.22444775700569153,
-0.41080722212791443,
0.3896823525428772,
1.284006953239441,
-0.25326618552207947,
0.5824646949768066,
-0.16476468741893768,
-0.3783341944217682,
-0.2098403424024582,
-1.1606791019439697,
-1.2235631942749023,
-0.46134111285209656,
-0.591081976890564,
-0.12838214635849,
0.36500805616378784,
0.6215775609016418,
0.7042227387428284,
-0.7460024356842041,
-0.07709408551454544,
-0.1404760181903839,
0.37985995411872864,
-0.1772083044052124,
-0.18576790392398834,
0.4931027591228485,
-0.37038424611091614,
-0.9245173931121826,
0.03708735853433609,
0.1326751857995987,
0.18146401643753052,
-0.20064786076545715,
0.17106522619724274,
-0.11070647835731506,
0.18588842451572418,
0.9475340843200684,
0.38719621300697327,
-0.4407987892627716,
-0.2944422662258148,
-0.19523051381111145,
-0.3937995731830597,
-0.19808290898799896,
0.9775514006614685,
-0.701838493347168,
0.16041120886802673,
1.1040382385253906,
-0.04650792479515076,
-0.03804643452167511,
0.3728727102279663,
0.6010614633560181,
-0.9305856823921204,
0.0053953430615365505,
0.1969670057296753,
-0.057566579431295395,
0.08221475034952164,
-0.25016483664512634,
0.5553641319274902,
0.03539591655135155,
-0.38232848048210144,
-0.8445473909378052,
0.015949279069900513,
-1.0288854837417603,
-0.5675398111343384,
1.319146752357483,
-0.18693573772907257,
-0.1933397501707077,
-0.5510724782943726,
-0.5097286701202393,
-0.08407975733280182,
-0.4670196771621704,
0.49760040640830994,
0.5799360871315002,
0.07067574560642242,
0.294649600982666,
-0.28241485357284546,
0.900050699710846,
0.4104428291320801,
-0.7136010527610779,
-0.42347997426986694,
0.2610655426979065,
-0.10347762703895569,
0.47825828194618225,
0.41321638226509094,
-0.006306045688688755,
-0.19211150705814362,
-0.22484628856182098,
0.14512303471565247,
-0.0954723209142685,
-0.602060079574585,
-0.40426620841026306,
0.5928485989570618,
0.07665079087018967,
0.0949857160449028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13055v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13055v1
|
Large Language Models for Medicine: A Survey
| 2024-05-20T02:32:26 | 2024-05-20T02:32:26 |
Yanxin Zheng, Wensheng Gan, Zefeng Chen, Zhenlian Qi, Qian Liang, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
To address challenges in the digital economy's landscape of digital
intelligence, large language models (LLMs) have been developed. Improvements in
computational power and available resources have significantly advanced LLMs,
allowing their integration into diverse domains for human life. Medical LLMs
are essential application tools with potential across various medical
scenarios. In this paper, we review LLM developments, focusing on the
requirements and applications of medical LLMs. We provide a concise overview of
existing models, aiming to explore advanced research directions and benefit
researchers for future medical applications. We emphasize the advantages of
medical LLMs in applications, as well as the challenges encountered during
their development. Finally, we suggest directions for technical integration to
mitigate challenges and potential research directions for the future of medical
LLMs, aiming to meet the demands of the medical field better.
|
[
-0.2560598850250244,
-0.7889819145202637,
1.108136773109436,
-0.14485129714012146,
-0.10972097516059875,
0.08534492552280426,
-0.3832646608352661,
-0.8153231143951416,
0.2780348062515259,
0.7794796228408813,
-0.5400134325027466,
-0.47139081358909607,
-0.9322096109390259,
0.16798092424869537,
-0.5344566702842712,
0.5869578123092651,
-0.0516103059053421,
0.6621414422988892,
-0.4581473469734192,
0.055176593363285065,
-0.2094900906085968,
-0.9380435943603516,
-0.7531831860542297,
-0.49839794635772705,
0.612591564655304,
0.14347469806671143,
0.6177034974098206,
0.5431303977966309,
0.942211389541626,
0.3973800539970398,
-0.16413889825344086,
0.11410477757453918,
0.011315707117319107,
0.3647269904613495,
-0.09946773946285248,
-0.37851741909980774,
-0.8061975240707397,
0.14301414787769318,
0.5872763991355896,
1.1449055671691895,
-0.21288670599460602,
-0.07578237354755402,
-0.40526628494262695,
0.652462899684906,
-0.18503601849079132,
0.10045459121465683,
-0.15762339532375336,
0.02969764918088913,
-0.2047092467546463,
-0.06422700732946396,
-0.15036603808403015,
-0.4563904106616974,
0.290601909160614,
-0.228677436709404,
-0.3373958468437195,
-0.022538388147950172,
0.4793356657028198,
0.17074652016162872,
-0.6902711391448975,
-0.5689065456390381,
-0.9240521192550659,
0.7337515354156494,
-1.004003643989563,
0.490477979183197,
0.2546430230140686,
0.3586331605911255,
-0.5651164054870605,
-0.9634073376655579,
-0.33950093388557434,
-0.3179034888744354,
0.2823060154914856,
-0.15839749574661255,
-0.11328946799039841,
0.16424670815467834,
-0.05862858146429062,
0.515417754650116,
-0.29313382506370544,
0.6463654041290283,
-0.5602865815162659,
0.21877911686897278,
0.6712443232536316,
0.7994805574417114,
0.6507620215415955,
0.22143560647964478,
0.10153339803218842,
0.38181549310684204,
-0.8549590706825256,
-0.47901731729507446,
-0.07870553433895111,
0.17322935163974762,
-0.3346402943134308,
0.8370837569236755,
0.12601962685585022,
0.8882697820663452,
-0.26016634702682495,
-0.5322587490081787,
0.05855153128504753,
-0.3730064332485199,
-0.3147467076778412,
-0.32557374238967896,
0.7833357453346252,
0.30606701970100403,
0.19333863258361816,
0.06358685344457626,
-0.1491686999797821,
-0.12839457392692566,
0.14995841681957245,
-0.8468175530433655,
0.049448464065790176,
0.7059308886528015,
-0.610551655292511,
-0.1861608624458313,
-0.5935043096542358,
-0.6596746444702148,
-0.9513649940490723,
-0.4594314694404602,
-0.14256225526332855,
-0.3124200999736786,
-0.36526742577552795,
0.4385063052177429,
0.05347630754113197,
0.2533804774284363,
0.3305325508117676,
-1.0027697086334229,
0.5203524231910706,
0.8779916763305664,
0.7689945697784424,
-0.257562518119812,
0.1826411932706833,
0.00693171052262187,
-0.013976113870739937,
-0.4934641420841217,
0.737861692905426,
-0.632610559463501,
-0.5662931203842163,
0.2895556092262268,
-0.0855407640337944,
-0.014860173687338829,
-0.908342719078064,
0.3006778061389923,
-0.4244556725025177,
0.05581772327423096,
-0.1411115974187851,
-0.651161789894104,
-0.06316052377223969,
0.4027664065361023,
-0.6433623433113098,
0.30962899327278137,
0.13051855564117432,
-0.44799667596817017,
0.0371304452419281,
-0.9664838314056396,
-0.5496702194213867,
0.3542437255382538,
-0.357792466878891,
-0.32576805353164673,
0.33650118112564087,
0.04852103069424629,
0.6278499960899353,
-0.9642586708068848,
0.5096063017845154,
-0.36992913484573364,
-0.11743345111608505,
0.5333775281906128,
-0.2107148915529251,
0.8887835741043091,
0.32594922184944153,
0.13960406184196472,
0.19544652104377747,
-0.5280884504318237,
-0.19680240750312805,
0.34191980957984924,
-0.44445177912712097,
-0.20253638923168182,
0.37878724932670593,
0.22387853264808655,
0.20700053870677948,
0.3498707115650177,
-0.31860119104385376,
0.4783461093902588,
-0.44030624628067017,
0.8865951895713806,
0.39569389820098877,
0.0755784809589386,
0.2605307996273041,
-0.457484632730484,
0.6611342430114746,
-0.03349822014570236,
0.3104410767555237,
-0.0493127666413784,
-0.5197190046310425,
-0.35631152987480164,
-0.6132357120513916,
0.4350025951862335,
0.5013755559921265,
-0.3934619426727295,
0.2680240571498871,
-0.17405669391155243,
-0.5688877701759338,
-0.47150903940200806,
0.07983087003231049,
-0.28952646255493164,
0.11539153754711151,
-0.007103465031832457,
0.0434468649327755,
-0.44007250666618347,
-0.8130638599395752,
0.032804980874061584,
-0.08092432469129562,
-0.1503559798002243,
0.5173811912536621,
0.428913950920105,
-0.8985792398452759,
0.5959511399269104,
-0.3129478394985199,
-0.19628916680812836,
-0.5557547211647034,
-0.3660838305950165,
0.2551622986793518,
0.20670858025550842,
0.501105010509491,
-0.906951367855072,
-0.16106955707073212,
0.12713153660297394,
-0.7167190313339233,
-0.17068684101104736,
0.0818171426653862,
0.3982183635234833,
0.06779173761606216,
0.48710158467292786,
-0.7683698534965515,
-0.1377585530281067,
0.9785893559455872,
-0.16241607069969177,
0.38862767815589905,
-0.40345337986946106,
0.09104697406291962,
-1.1105782985687256,
0.047441668808460236,
0.21705172955989838,
-0.26118457317352295,
-0.7673012614250183,
0.17208246886730194,
-0.020840534940361977,
-0.12665903568267822,
-0.4402163624763489,
0.8556674718856812,
-0.6042634844779968,
0.03232818841934204,
-0.4649377465248108,
0.20153453946113586,
-0.3340378403663635,
-0.4089089334011078,
0.021713627502322197,
0.5091162323951721,
0.6652847528457642,
-0.6874171495437622,
0.7194916605949402,
0.03710155561566353,
-0.41074901819229126,
0.5623614192008972,
-0.6502634286880493,
-0.18666166067123413,
-0.022547312080860138,
0.2141309678554535,
-0.6708147525787354,
-0.5629884004592896,
0.1778963953256607,
-0.2606518566608429,
0.4913833737373352,
0.32535797357559204,
-0.7875589728355408,
-0.7471463680267334,
-0.12970897555351257,
0.492697149515152,
0.731315553188324,
-0.25451794266700745,
0.5825316309928894,
0.8854239583015442,
-0.5438357591629028,
-0.0006585600785911083,
-0.7096455693244934,
0.5192833542823792,
-0.2204924374818802,
-0.5377664566040039,
0.14096811413764954,
-0.2729596793651581,
-0.6468656063079834,
-0.15693268179893494,
0.24820205569267273,
-0.21564233303070068,
0.16381904482841492,
0.2235809564590454,
0.5667481422424316,
-0.247914656996727,
0.25546637177467346,
-0.1427444964647293,
-0.014792517758905888,
0.2915242910385132,
-0.31619325280189514,
0.5391307473182678,
0.24235227704048157,
-0.4094446003437042,
-0.31956231594085693,
0.5686280131340027,
1.0066221952438354,
-0.1112702488899231,
0.6194470524787903,
0.046842608600854874,
-0.6106371283531189,
0.16535526514053345,
-0.7546541094779968,
-0.07291139662265778,
-0.460995078086853,
0.7352549433708191,
0.17604850232601166,
-1.0587589740753174,
0.365270733833313,
-0.5605421662330627,
0.1562136709690094,
0.3771332800388336,
1.0859599113464355,
-0.18853522837162018,
1.1386393308639526,
0.6184912323951721,
-0.046619169414043427,
0.2329849749803543,
-0.005696528125554323,
0.3017491400241852,
-0.7800832390785217,
-0.3439359962940216,
-0.5198594927787781,
-0.11769211292266846,
-0.5960531234741211,
-0.3999147415161133,
0.5372589230537415,
-0.3540329039096832,
-0.1893831044435501,
-0.29346418380737305,
-0.2558891177177429,
0.16291022300720215,
0.19008079171180725,
-0.13214386999607086,
0.24206003546714783,
-0.22445446252822876,
-0.055989716202020645,
-0.06069507822394371,
-0.5623992085456848,
-0.5023089647293091,
1.0065734386444092,
0.7076201438903809,
1.0916615724563599,
0.06729137152433395,
0.4262412190437317,
0.10676351189613342,
0.4078787565231323,
-0.9977035522460938,
0.5424238443374634,
-0.5860998630523682,
-0.7755511999130249,
-0.2148294746875763,
-0.2891576588153839,
-0.9634450078010559,
-0.107328861951828,
-0.22041335701942444,
-0.6983420848846436,
-0.18899446725845337,
-0.057626642286777496,
-0.3370615541934967,
0.43318304419517517,
-0.3989619016647339,
0.48308229446411133,
-0.6032392382621765,
0.0062288157641887665,
-0.2711494565010071,
-0.4493556320667267,
0.4231444299221039,
-0.4320122301578522,
0.4366784691810608,
-0.18438050150871277,
-0.2688925862312317,
0.5729042291641235,
-0.307477205991745,
0.9133511185646057,
0.12681138515472412,
-0.36105331778526306,
0.15473514795303345,
-0.3040478229522705,
0.2867761254310608,
-0.2276819795370102,
-0.08727972954511642,
0.3224453628063202,
0.2036868780851364,
-0.2604925334453583,
-0.126495361328125,
0.8471208810806274,
-0.5151602625846863,
-0.8008130788803101,
-0.5258891582489014,
-0.8721518516540527,
-0.515873372554779,
0.18422028422355652,
-0.038977496325969696,
0.35321417450904846,
-0.16644057631492615,
0.23090045154094696,
0.6004659533500671,
-0.549383282661438,
0.328115850687027,
0.5395734310150146,
-0.547712504863739,
-0.3045904338359833,
0.5268895030021667,
0.16857169568538666,
0.3094073235988617,
0.13870418071746826,
0.2883144021034241,
-0.44597697257995605,
-1.133038878440857,
-0.358659565448761,
0.6284425854682922,
-0.49769166111946106,
0.08037114888429642,
-0.5699083209037781,
-0.41066670417785645,
-0.46882331371307373,
-0.20634736120700836,
-0.39325934648513794,
0.003252536291256547,
-0.39183753728866577,
0.2332957535982132,
0.4479857385158539,
1.2553308010101318,
0.22743821144104004,
0.20036716759204865,
-1.0879693031311035,
0.4840031862258911,
0.08410525321960449,
0.629148542881012,
-0.13481618463993073,
-0.13199986517429352,
-0.18795078992843628,
-0.015943503007292747,
-0.03737848252058029,
-0.7530461549758911,
0.44704318046569824,
-0.1794128566980362,
0.6677044630050659,
0.41419729590415955,
-0.3147886395454407,
0.387378990650177,
-0.7125921249389648,
0.8432083129882812,
0.3996181786060333,
-0.5431213974952698,
0.17716513574123383,
-0.495140939950943,
0.33370164036750793,
0.0879272073507309,
0.5324901342391968,
-0.8332005739212036,
-0.2612972855567932,
-0.026222573593258858,
-0.7663847804069519,
0.20759610831737518,
-0.3575418293476105,
0.26035404205322266,
-0.09959257394075394,
0.5157226324081421,
-0.11963152885437012,
0.05990290269255638,
-0.4306009113788605,
-0.14934653043746948,
0.6826432943344116,
-0.44827839732170105,
-0.032817721366882324,
-0.2735781967639923,
-0.019698964431881905,
-0.24014151096343994,
0.43288955092430115,
0.07306166738271713,
0.10551278293132782,
-0.04241737723350525,
0.21877717971801758,
-0.1600755900144577,
0.36706122756004333,
0.6592528820037842,
0.6492640376091003,
0.10296617448329926,
-0.15508736670017242,
0.18020465970039368,
-0.6813123822212219,
0.29032835364341736,
0.027515430003404617,
-0.017766691744327545,
-0.16913571953773499,
0.27886804938316345,
0.32714006304740906,
0.030139023438096046,
-1.1361262798309326,
0.4852738082408905,
-0.04630345478653908,
-0.2855251431465149,
-0.38059455156326294,
-0.055807217955589294,
0.7101436257362366,
0.5679406523704529,
0.16950489580631256,
-0.4097471237182617,
0.0636618509888649,
-0.6023891568183899,
-0.16547535359859467,
0.7185488939285278,
-0.2576729655265808,
-0.08470827341079712,
0.5960808992385864,
0.18474332988262177,
-0.3894570469856262,
0.5808446407318115,
0.2496214210987091,
-0.20501230657100677,
0.5888823866844177,
0.6647100448608398,
0.590703547000885,
-0.3539756238460541,
-0.25404104590415955,
-0.044529303908348083,
0.18110285699367523,
-0.28466349840164185,
0.38410523533821106,
0.6271696090698242,
-0.3968392312526703,
-0.5495529770851135,
-0.6155468821525574,
-0.6712963581085205,
0.4392363429069519,
-0.020128760486841202,
0.48823609948158264,
-0.520201563835144,
-0.5035759806632996,
0.21161866188049316,
-0.10144490003585815,
-0.6220936179161072,
0.28188830614089966,
0.46167701482772827,
0.9190924763679504,
-0.31098857522010803,
0.9224680066108704,
0.8451218008995056,
-0.1099759042263031,
-0.3229690194129944,
-0.3313902020454407,
0.2139294296503067,
-0.8230251669883728,
0.5191326141357422,
-0.2251371145248413,
0.05185260996222496,
-0.30405065417289734,
-0.48043572902679443,
-0.7231875061988831,
0.8194693326950073,
0.3169921040534973,
-0.8464769124984741,
-0.47372230887413025,
0.3892230689525604,
0.6425583958625793,
-0.641984760761261,
0.011422941461205482,
0.6086987853050232,
0.4731844365596771,
-0.0012986751971766353,
-0.9441083669662476,
-0.0780944898724556,
-0.1686326116323471,
0.021641355007886887,
0.3199104964733124,
-0.40156683325767517,
0.9059515595436096,
-0.3770696818828583,
-0.06993137300014496,
0.4221266806125641,
0.09791718423366547,
0.22758236527442932,
0.1871265470981598,
0.08285228908061981,
0.13823223114013672,
0.6216928362846375,
-0.02157088741660118,
1.297622799873352,
-0.4602627754211426,
0.12986181676387787,
0.7185178995132446,
-0.5580022931098938,
0.7391381859779358,
0.48174697160720825,
-0.4165854752063751,
0.17150641977787018,
0.6936318874359131,
-0.10820593684911728,
-0.05443735793232918,
0.498640775680542,
-0.5302138328552246,
-0.1587614119052887,
-0.2654522955417633,
-0.4750432074069977,
0.2002657800912857,
0.9525657892227173,
-0.6288562417030334,
-0.00441388227045536,
0.08057593554258347,
-0.01435585506260395,
0.055633943527936935,
-0.5462086796760559,
0.718227744102478,
0.4493166506290436,
-0.24490821361541748,
0.2672341763973236,
0.17681236565113068,
0.6600083708763123,
-0.8103981614112854,
-0.04148329794406891,
0.024719391018152237,
0.17713584005832672,
-0.14318059384822845,
-0.5559340119361877,
0.2660636603832245,
0.05630519613623619,
-0.10916607081890106,
0.10228744894266129,
0.7587617635726929,
-0.30595123767852783,
-0.678810179233551,
0.41426578164100647,
0.6418857574462891,
0.19992581009864807,
0.15619124472141266,
-0.43776935338974,
0.25212812423706055,
-0.3571391701698303,
-0.14912354946136475,
0.42600303888320923,
0.28002476692199707,
-0.045414332300424576,
0.9506828784942627,
0.4879121482372284,
0.6712735295295715,
-0.006334302015602589,
0.06780482828617096,
0.7379531264305115,
-1.0104659795761108,
-0.20672543346881866,
-1.0388344526290894,
0.2140921652317047,
0.10708779096603394,
0.07510409504175186,
0.3966812491416931,
0.3617958128452301,
0.2160014659166336,
-0.06328482180833817,
0.9667450189590454,
0.26969826221466064,
0.6224358081817627,
-0.36109334230422974,
0.9386812448501587,
-0.6814988851547241,
0.24387922883033752,
-0.023329362273216248,
-0.5773264765739441,
-0.7563403844833374,
0.19466744363307953,
-0.31277361512184143,
0.1705486923456192,
0.6731641888618469,
0.45158955454826355,
0.12245436757802963,
-0.07142960280179977,
0.4895147979259491,
0.3028499484062195,
0.36240822076797485,
0.6514143347740173,
0.8605262637138367,
0.0372188463807106,
0.09521484375,
0.15110339224338531,
-0.12581737339496613,
-0.4874551594257355,
-0.808399498462677,
-0.8586459159851074,
-0.3703763782978058,
-0.33616384863853455,
-0.14078009128570557,
-0.1144435927271843,
1.2284424304962158,
0.756980836391449,
-0.7710822224617004,
-0.36785992980003357,
0.2723948061466217,
-0.047699857503175735,
0.10857892036437988,
-0.05746491625905037,
0.08039527386426926,
0.0031282634008675814,
-0.8812412619590759,
0.32575568556785583,
0.6634800434112549,
0.3986537456512451,
-0.6549270749092102,
-0.08255414664745331,
-0.13121329247951508,
0.4329850971698761,
0.7056859135627747,
0.30890020728111267,
-0.9063417911529541,
-0.010490995831787586,
0.12599071860313416,
-0.4980143904685974,
0.11788087338209152,
1.072067141532898,
-0.337539404630661,
0.23060868680477142,
0.28792691230773926,
0.9554742574691772,
0.25346314907073975,
-0.4860055446624756,
0.6347122192382812,
0.10182379931211472,
-0.0792427510023117,
0.4912782907485962,
0.6504884362220764,
0.44780460000038147,
-0.28243109583854675,
0.33845189213752747,
-0.0003588144900277257,
-0.5149055123329163,
-0.8133389949798584,
0.26517191529273987,
-0.8809800148010254,
-0.5054545998573303,
1.1729648113250732,
0.21239443123340607,
-0.1515604704618454,
-0.2758491337299347,
-0.13415297865867615,
0.13937295973300934,
0.167573943734169,
0.6395072340965271,
0.8121419548988342,
-0.15007284283638,
-0.09582757204771042,
-1.021897554397583,
0.2008070945739746,
0.11192440986633301,
-1.176906943321228,
-0.009275546297430992,
0.6330129504203796,
0.2754853665828705,
-0.15807734429836273,
0.8892035484313965,
-0.6855583786964417,
0.11848052591085434,
-0.23448628187179565,
0.07920731604099274,
0.09171472489833832,
-0.21858686208724976,
-0.5902960300445557,
0.15761804580688477,
0.5354716181755066,
0.2535092234611511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11724v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11724v1
|
Token-wise Influential Training Data Retrieval for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-20T01:57:34 | 2024-05-20T01:57:34 |
Huawei Lin, Jikai Long, Zhaozhuo Xu, Weijie Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.IR
|
Given a Large Language Model (LLM) generation, how can we identify which
training data led to this generation? In this paper, we proposed RapidIn, a
scalable framework adapting to LLMs for estimating the influence of each
training data. The proposed framework consists of two stages: caching and
retrieval. First, we compress the gradient vectors by over 200,000x, allowing
them to be cached on disk or in GPU/CPU memory. Then, given a generation,
RapidIn efficiently traverses the cached gradients to estimate the influence
within minutes, achieving over a 6,326x speedup. Moreover, RapidIn supports
multi-GPU parallelization to substantially accelerate caching and retrieval.
Our empirical result confirms the efficiency and effectiveness of RapidIn.
|
[
-0.1749729961156845,
-0.7310084700584412,
0.3984543979167938,
0.5097388625144958,
-0.20007452368736267,
-0.07983198016881943,
-0.41745296120643616,
-0.28602176904678345,
0.5426772236824036,
0.1627519577741623,
-0.1442491114139557,
-0.2957954704761505,
-0.8004326820373535,
-0.020506611093878746,
-0.6488679647445679,
0.6617290377616882,
0.18993322551250458,
0.2921656668186188,
0.2955528497695923,
-0.34804296493530273,
-0.34517359733581543,
-0.2263876050710678,
-1.0357615947723389,
-0.11991896480321884,
1.0005749464035034,
0.42198771238327026,
0.8322113156318665,
1.121883511543274,
0.2609955072402954,
0.3403851389884949,
-0.14929252862930298,
-0.21335628628730774,
-0.9481133818626404,
0.1525164693593979,
0.019633252173662186,
-0.666713535785675,
-0.24612222611904144,
-0.2094775289297104,
1.0369868278503418,
0.4964756667613983,
-0.007929526269435883,
0.19814558327198029,
-0.07991856336593628,
0.33001136779785156,
-0.7136030197143555,
0.1707180291414261,
-0.8416095972061157,
-0.12234045565128326,
-0.5899456739425659,
-0.298338919878006,
-0.6656649708747864,
-0.34112393856048584,
-0.1395363211631775,
-0.535368800163269,
0.3279183506965637,
-0.005836895667016506,
0.3318770229816437,
0.00341139012016356,
-0.40335094928741455,
-0.11734960228204727,
-0.4910835027694702,
1.0640811920166016,
-0.6951406002044678,
0.5382747054100037,
0.1819833517074585,
0.1330825239419937,
-0.38088518381118774,
-1.0270702838897705,
-0.4278648793697357,
-0.03639521822333336,
0.007839915342628956,
-0.29319533705711365,
0.21868179738521576,
-0.1135857030749321,
0.4326142966747284,
0.23225899040699005,
-0.28957536816596985,
0.3751375377178192,
-0.03198409080505371,
-0.1759745329618454,
0.4478273093700409,
0.12773002684116364,
0.4120090901851654,
-0.1159696877002716,
-0.1217893660068512,
-0.2583721876144409,
-0.8998245596885681,
-0.10981425642967224,
0.19707417488098145,
0.628539502620697,
0.11410397291183472,
0.37584665417671204,
-0.19633539021015167,
0.4896988570690155,
0.17896434664726257,
-0.13506539165973663,
0.3192935287952423,
-0.6452214121818542,
-0.01120524201542139,
0.057266030460596085,
0.7139111757278442,
-0.06946389377117157,
0.15832102298736572,
-0.22003304958343506,
-0.44667065143585205,
-0.32262083888053894,
0.012189855799078941,
-1.4191563129425049,
0.062458336353302,
-0.0587061382830143,
-0.4212869107723236,
-0.07753843814134598,
0.15700823068618774,
-0.9802059531211853,
-0.6595357060432434,
-0.10897568613290787,
0.22731131315231323,
-0.013532186858355999,
-0.2517637610435486,
-0.18477647006511688,
0.029641278088092804,
0.38121286034584045,
0.18146996200084686,
-1.120584487915039,
0.026865726336836815,
0.854649007320404,
1.1827976703643799,
-0.21247701346874237,
-0.32624244689941406,
-1.085056185722351,
-0.15898826718330383,
-0.3938058316707611,
0.5012589693069458,
-0.8352886438369751,
-0.487646222114563,
0.21448597311973572,
0.10361510515213013,
-0.07879212498664856,
-0.49169206619262695,
0.2890656292438507,
-0.8130248188972473,
-0.2675297260284424,
-0.455507755279541,
-0.5388332605361938,
0.17447863519191742,
-0.17130537331104279,
-1.02202308177948,
1.1558946371078491,
-0.17210935056209564,
-1.0934536457061768,
0.4713577926158905,
-0.22145529091358185,
-0.5538454055786133,
0.2089090347290039,
-0.2092665731906891,
-0.2802679240703583,
0.22393976151943207,
0.34642675518989563,
0.7710124850273132,
-0.39939627051353455,
0.4293115735054016,
-0.501110315322876,
-0.5925096869468689,
-0.02561398409307003,
-0.19257356226444244,
0.8861556053161621,
0.03203582763671875,
-0.38024720549583435,
0.44345664978027344,
-0.8141908645629883,
-0.09696614742279053,
-0.02756822109222412,
-0.4450456500053406,
-0.5583571195602417,
-0.04116569086909294,
0.1069207489490509,
0.13259071111679077,
0.09065838158130646,
-0.344632625579834,
0.29616862535476685,
-0.1568651646375656,
0.29843568801879883,
0.9406790733337402,
0.2761722207069397,
0.6031496524810791,
-0.03962690755724907,
0.38775280117988586,
-0.2755206227302551,
0.18455524742603302,
-0.3098137676715851,
-0.49575403332710266,
-0.8338028788566589,
-0.48720234632492065,
0.4653591215610504,
0.2651887536048889,
-0.6924149990081787,
-0.01792743243277073,
-0.49224570393562317,
-0.4442782700061798,
-0.5531882643699646,
0.4640166759490967,
0.13604140281677246,
0.2025034874677658,
0.21533289551734924,
-0.3974083662033081,
-0.505132257938385,
-0.7254218459129333,
-0.5053817629814148,
-0.12177418917417526,
-0.10544450581073761,
0.34613198041915894,
0.5354677438735962,
-0.2802543342113495,
0.5733697414398193,
-0.13862581551074982,
0.11593455821275711,
-0.23728428781032562,
0.26515036821365356,
0.16335301101207733,
0.4497339427471161,
0.6337515711784363,
-0.4713170826435089,
-0.7979499697685242,
-0.13618585467338562,
-0.41796156764030457,
-0.05793440714478493,
-0.31239837408065796,
-0.33445948362350464,
-0.33721524477005005,
0.6637932062149048,
-0.5344433188438416,
0.22199338674545288,
0.3520320951938629,
-0.20461614429950714,
0.3736775517463684,
-0.07179737836122513,
0.17856526374816895,
-1.1341907978057861,
0.27453306317329407,
0.08091253787279129,
-0.23936615884304047,
-0.8109871745109558,
-0.1422015130519867,
0.3520973026752472,
0.0665149912238121,
-0.3721676170825958,
0.8695215582847595,
-0.24653875827789307,
0.017461400479078293,
-0.05503785237669945,
0.3130546808242798,
-0.3245179355144501,
0.2534536123275757,
-0.18693804740905762,
1.0939795970916748,
0.7956804037094116,
-0.4987587630748749,
-0.02039923146367073,
0.029957743361592293,
-0.6487088799476624,
0.04767536744475365,
-0.7585827112197876,
0.20868229866027832,
-0.22917988896369934,
0.3211786448955536,
-0.8535932302474976,
-0.1565229445695877,
-0.1321103274822235,
-0.20711064338684082,
0.20696090161800385,
-0.4482016861438751,
-0.863197922706604,
0.10848640650510788,
-0.3936452567577362,
0.44288742542266846,
0.2225928157567978,
-0.9118167161941528,
0.7158368825912476,
0.4012809693813324,
-0.29955798387527466,
-0.8591115474700928,
-0.2930941879749298,
0.009757006540894508,
-0.14484360814094543,
-0.3259226381778717,
-0.010424737818539143,
-0.10037951171398163,
-0.35825809836387634,
-0.4002164304256439,
0.1318792700767517,
-0.14609074592590332,
0.028492314741015434,
0.3600838780403137,
0.09374997019767761,
-0.21637263894081116,
0.2818497121334076,
-0.1237853541970253,
0.16238950192928314,
-0.009768471121788025,
-0.151414155960083,
0.4458892345428467,
0.14569628238677979,
0.09192829579114914,
-0.37507903575897217,
0.2020236849784851,
0.9033025503158569,
-0.2324804663658142,
0.9611071348190308,
0.6932188272476196,
-0.06411609053611755,
-0.5395023822784424,
-0.7044851779937744,
-0.4507058560848236,
-0.45232918858528137,
0.6180137991905212,
-0.16702765226364136,
-0.721835196018219,
0.8628947138786316,
-0.2737128436565399,
0.12468433380126953,
0.39818617701530457,
0.8047901391983032,
0.6616848707199097,
1.1255759000778198,
0.7865500450134277,
-0.7008594274520874,
1.2026753425598145,
-0.34308549761772156,
-0.17205238342285156,
-0.4936966896057129,
-0.20406877994537354,
-0.5138185620307922,
-0.29676395654678345,
-0.45227906107902527,
-0.615581750869751,
-0.02260037139058113,
0.2323419600725174,
-0.259161114692688,
0.1501394361257553,
0.23942679166793823,
0.46926242113113403,
0.3309800624847412,
-0.0017743166536092758,
0.11390383541584015,
0.06910471618175507,
-0.2644924223423004,
0.24175915122032166,
-0.893822431564331,
0.11099302023649216,
1.4098563194274902,
0.343524694442749,
0.6232549548149109,
0.07585632055997849,
0.3388572931289673,
0.1907976120710373,
0.8158428072929382,
-0.7232096791267395,
0.6089803576469421,
0.07981029897928238,
-0.7030820846557617,
-0.2854120433330536,
-0.6746540665626526,
-0.9504083395004272,
0.28009214997291565,
-0.2868759334087372,
-0.47465723752975464,
0.2293805181980133,
-0.08931219577789307,
-0.04405517503619194,
0.34403374791145325,
-0.5784856081008911,
0.6243907809257507,
-0.23271207511425018,
-0.717275083065033,
-0.6496352553367615,
-0.4408038854598999,
0.24190515279769897,
-0.38085484504699707,
0.08893270790576935,
0.05188734456896782,
-0.08367101848125458,
1.140173316001892,
-0.478674054145813,
0.9196937680244446,
-0.3945518732070923,
0.13081319630146027,
0.3553600013256073,
0.013442340306937695,
0.9353224039077759,
0.3180878460407257,
-0.42447414994239807,
0.16425403952598572,
-0.5728975534439087,
-0.6290770769119263,
-0.9388101100921631,
1.1052863597869873,
-0.5957364439964294,
-0.39017704129219055,
0.0733243077993393,
-0.36869874596595764,
-0.2131354957818985,
0.549543559551239,
-0.05701858550310135,
0.45128747820854187,
-0.1537269800901413,
0.43769654631614685,
0.5979927182197571,
0.03150421753525734,
0.5911149978637695,
0.5169302225112915,
-0.36429935693740845,
-0.3088880479335785,
0.8177265524864197,
0.151692733168602,
0.13292908668518066,
0.23520468175411224,
0.3000118136405945,
-0.15842631459236145,
-0.4399307072162628,
-0.5712398290634155,
0.6013904809951782,
-0.8423452377319336,
-0.0857706218957901,
-0.44236671924591064,
0.15311327576637268,
-0.11780082434415817,
0.0404156930744648,
-0.6529756188392639,
-0.28268134593963623,
-0.2914789021015167,
-0.1565692126750946,
0.5010993480682373,
0.8648051619529724,
0.20230692625045776,
0.5318461060523987,
-0.5430434942245483,
-0.02492288127541542,
0.23564042150974274,
0.6890667080879211,
0.504008412361145,
-0.6113758087158203,
-0.7001743912696838,
-0.30927228927612305,
0.30577361583709717,
-0.553928792476654,
0.26131266355514526,
0.2342061549425125,
0.5554206967353821,
0.7379012703895569,
-0.2451535165309906,
0.7523335218429565,
-0.5726469159126282,
0.6255437731742859,
0.16330142319202423,
-0.7609706521034241,
0.2765287756919861,
-0.043973155319690704,
0.3143397569656372,
0.6972294449806213,
0.666007399559021,
-0.37977516651153564,
-0.16213753819465637,
-0.22710277140140533,
-0.9780277609825134,
0.4236919581890106,
-0.08002724498510361,
0.17591236531734467,
-0.19796252250671387,
0.7882552146911621,
0.12499693781137466,
-0.0020826265681535006,
-0.3881789743900299,
-0.3844548165798187,
-0.03611112758517265,
0.062202613800764084,
-0.22067859768867493,
-0.3640284538269043,
0.12763474881649017,
-0.3516261875629425,
0.63515704870224,
-0.20218180119991302,
-0.025838835164904594,
-0.13840699195861816,
-0.15616418421268463,
0.0165590588003397,
0.02431376837193966,
0.27520883083343506,
0.7372146248817444,
-0.027104604989290237,
0.0020433650352060795,
0.19509537518024445,
-0.6307644248008728,
-0.1329808533191681,
-0.06895197927951813,
-0.27465829253196716,
0.16948841512203217,
0.5461008548736572,
0.9871370792388916,
0.309161514043808,
-0.6631032228469849,
0.5611152052879333,
-0.3155457377433777,
0.19788116216659546,
0.12216036766767502,
-0.005653532221913338,
-0.20899049937725067,
0.31047460436820984,
0.3002810478210449,
-0.19991475343704224,
-0.1555299460887909,
-0.38540932536125183,
0.5168505311012268,
0.38296228647232056,
-0.42656105756759644,
-0.5397684574127197,
0.5836421847343445,
0.220008984208107,
0.010211181826889515,
0.8208365440368652,
0.20976130664348602,
-0.27268195152282715,
0.41446352005004883,
0.47050175070762634,
0.852267324924469,
-0.3216346204280853,
-0.04684736579656601,
0.7037631273269653,
-0.12424961477518082,
-0.6646230816841125,
0.15080752968788147,
-0.10603208094835281,
-0.5904066562652588,
-0.6431653499603271,
-0.38936614990234375,
-0.022906560450792313,
0.05988333001732826,
-0.4904087483882904,
0.25163766741752625,
-0.6199683547019958,
-0.48440805077552795,
0.0024898627307265997,
0.10210385173559189,
-0.82784503698349,
-0.11323395371437073,
-0.14199155569076538,
0.9420565366744995,
-0.8448871374130249,
1.2544997930526733,
0.27536851167678833,
-0.2931506931781769,
-0.9505312442779541,
0.14155420660972595,
0.03711705282330513,
-0.8523528575897217,
1.0678027868270874,
0.018818311393260956,
-0.2568151652812958,
0.08429016917943954,
-0.4795997440814972,
-0.916599690914154,
1.0974370241165161,
0.2392277866601944,
-0.7408573031425476,
0.22171248495578766,
-0.051811590790748596,
0.46205395460128784,
-0.48480796813964844,
0.42111334204673767,
0.5341507196426392,
0.5266364812850952,
0.08105455338954926,
-0.6237888932228088,
0.1779247522354126,
-0.3261493742465973,
0.12222907692193985,
0.18675637245178223,
-0.7468564510345459,
0.7638158798217773,
-0.30456486344337463,
-0.345170259475708,
0.001161424908787012,
0.7667932510375977,
-0.06756460666656494,
-0.1709137111902237,
0.5395169854164124,
0.31378257274627686,
0.8952723741531372,
0.3433772921562195,
1.2460321187973022,
-0.6854708194732666,
0.26466503739356995,
1.0489709377288818,
0.02671821229159832,
1.010480523109436,
0.5948275327682495,
0.19176511466503143,
0.1754588931798935,
0.4492419362068176,
0.1429113745689392,
0.37888166308403015,
0.42520320415496826,
-0.4304209053516388,
-0.035410962998867035,
-0.22044813632965088,
-0.18153466284275055,
0.07521391659975052,
0.2342645227909088,
-0.5501577258110046,
0.08235493302345276,
-0.0954991951584816,
0.27291804552078247,
-0.5288991928100586,
-0.5518240928649902,
0.4876857101917267,
-0.05297392979264259,
-0.5010137557983398,
0.5794430375099182,
0.11853063851594925,
0.537439227104187,
-0.816137433052063,
0.06489666551351547,
-0.5855775475502014,
0.20050771534442902,
-0.13043642044067383,
-0.31495150923728943,
-0.3540441393852234,
-0.004712570458650589,
-0.15039987862110138,
-0.15006594359874725,
0.5546171069145203,
-0.4737622141838074,
-0.4804173707962036,
0.5640770196914673,
0.6068455576896667,
-0.03575397655367851,
0.14835381507873535,
-0.5338364243507385,
0.4116010069847107,
-0.04127084091305733,
-0.682363748550415,
0.6276353597640991,
0.4266708791255951,
-0.16187787055969238,
0.8312939405441284,
0.5616368651390076,
0.3974451422691345,
0.43429192900657654,
0.44321805238723755,
1.0336706638336182,
-0.5265807509422302,
-0.22965876758098602,
-0.7446889877319336,
0.18967518210411072,
0.017625361680984497,
-0.27766019105911255,
1.1349575519561768,
0.671682596206665,
0.5950266122817993,
0.1290559321641922,
0.5845856666564941,
0.12122010439634323,
0.10428490489721298,
-0.3298885226249695,
0.7204753756523132,
-0.4440748989582062,
0.4355953633785248,
-0.0728304460644722,
-1.04887855052948,
-0.6742585897445679,
0.3200252056121826,
-0.28337106108665466,
0.01593647338449955,
0.5186312794685364,
1.18085777759552,
0.00642389478161931,
-0.09642553329467773,
0.1176537498831749,
0.5274694561958313,
0.3619925081729889,
-0.049780961126089096,
0.362331748008728,
-0.23969514667987823,
0.3817470073699951,
-0.0736907497048378,
-0.3146463632583618,
-0.2737623155117035,
-0.7588444948196411,
-1.0442793369293213,
-0.37526240944862366,
-0.16127946972846985,
-0.35121721029281616,
0.07412414997816086,
0.9046602249145508,
0.860772967338562,
-0.9627458453178406,
-0.3375132381916046,
-0.016577696427702904,
0.15631598234176636,
-0.07303363084793091,
-0.20710891485214233,
0.698248028755188,
-0.3684006929397583,
-0.7483243942260742,
0.6597179770469666,
0.1754249781370163,
-0.20660008490085602,
-0.4693123996257782,
-0.2594868540763855,
-0.2533155083656311,
0.26947221159935,
0.5471178293228149,
0.31686222553253174,
-0.4454174339771271,
-0.3674282133579254,
-0.07624253630638123,
-0.1389789581298828,
-0.02046097442507744,
1.5650501251220703,
-0.7741408348083496,
0.7348744869232178,
0.7263253927230835,
0.965336263179779,
0.5287211537361145,
-0.11772384494543076,
0.389096200466156,
-0.7678056955337524,
0.39949363470077515,
-0.011458968743681908,
0.41929253935813904,
0.16715143620967865,
-0.2148236632347107,
0.29375237226486206,
0.29939132928848267,
-0.5850697159767151,
-0.608647346496582,
-0.00909670814871788,
-0.6800766587257385,
-0.10675778239965439,
1.2193074226379395,
-0.19234462082386017,
-0.20318813621997833,
0.05035821348428726,
0.1737067997455597,
0.09356953203678131,
-0.7105604410171509,
0.7526323795318604,
0.4550916850566864,
0.0392509289085865,
-0.1278006136417389,
-0.8597008585929871,
0.5068146586418152,
0.4404182434082031,
-0.315780371427536,
0.29289790987968445,
0.2051481008529663,
0.2504158020019531,
-0.17323601245880127,
0.6310858726501465,
-0.12149874866008759,
-0.2674066722393036,
0.2150881141424179,
-0.18461745977401733,
0.17090623080730438,
-0.4776146411895752,
-0.30668750405311584,
0.18527556955814362,
0.12643881142139435,
0.24886290729045868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11143v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11143v2
|
OpenRLHF: An Easy-to-use, Scalable and High-performance RLHF Framework
| 2024-05-20T01:04:40 | 2024-06-03T12:19:18 |
Jian Hu, Xibin Wu, Weixun Wang, Xianyu, Dehao Zhang, Yu Cao
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
As large language models (LLMs) continue to grow by scaling laws,
reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has gained significant
attention due to its outstanding performance. However, unlike pretraining or
fine-tuning a single model, scaling reinforcement learning from human feedback
(RLHF) for training large language models poses coordination challenges across
four models. We present OpenRLHF, an open-source framework enabling efficient
RLHF scaling. Unlike existing RLHF frameworks that co-locate four models on the
same GPUs, OpenRLHF re-designs scheduling for the models beyond 70B parameters
using Ray, vLLM, and DeepSpeed, leveraging improved resource utilization and
diverse training approaches. Integrating seamlessly with Hugging Face, OpenRLHF
provides an out-of-the-box solution with optimized algorithms and launch
scripts, which ensures user-friendliness. OpenRLHF implements RLHF, DPO,
rejection sampling, and other alignment techniques. Empowering state-of-the-art
LLM development, OpenRLHF's code is available at
https://github.com/OpenLLMAI/OpenRLHF.
|
[
-0.1793908178806305,
-0.7628359794616699,
0.22099795937538147,
0.6610201001167297,
0.022148719057440758,
-0.09278813004493713,
-0.6171153783798218,
-0.3378444314002991,
-0.0901479721069336,
0.5680941343307495,
-0.819710910320282,
-0.3154072165489197,
-0.17238925397396088,
-0.1570865511894226,
0.016790026798844337,
1.0044753551483154,
-0.1588488668203354,
0.21580299735069275,
-0.2506399154663086,
-0.5391060709953308,
0.13320080935955048,
-0.44412654638290405,
-0.7318239808082581,
-0.7948682308197021,
0.7543911933898926,
0.6416673064231873,
0.9345545172691345,
0.9010624885559082,
0.5438541173934937,
0.24015973508358002,
0.049024567008018494,
0.11865074187517166,
-0.6372925043106079,
0.2916982173919678,
-0.050151973962783813,
-0.05516987666487694,
-0.47182777523994446,
-0.3642027974128723,
0.8453876376152039,
0.5255639553070068,
-0.9394553303718567,
0.282033234834671,
-0.1972588449716568,
0.9746059775352478,
-0.6543245911598206,
0.39598697423934937,
-0.09762979298830032,
0.2558206617832184,
-0.13467691838741302,
-0.013701877556741238,
-0.4706692695617676,
-0.4597126543521881,
0.11101093888282776,
-0.8017565608024597,
-0.19295340776443481,
0.3294987380504608,
0.6959143280982971,
0.28241878747940063,
-0.106414295732975,
-0.05836979299783707,
-0.7105671763420105,
0.6563900709152222,
-0.6951080560684204,
0.519494354724884,
0.13933983445167542,
0.5376653075218201,
-0.2983563244342804,
-0.6063419580459595,
-0.454623281955719,
-0.30428892374038696,
0.12268863618373871,
-0.12085618078708649,
0.11326014250516891,
0.2584115266799927,
0.2950742840766907,
0.4256714880466461,
-0.6833999156951904,
0.5949079394340515,
-0.05837089940905571,
-0.09045921266078949,
0.2886334955692291,
0.20510035753250122,
0.18870621919631958,
0.33990925550460815,
-0.3515266478061676,
-0.4726544916629791,
-0.8585578799247742,
0.09040843695402145,
0.4135180115699768,
0.5412520170211792,
-0.35169127583503723,
0.27204427123069763,
-0.244686096906662,
0.6988161206245422,
0.04139212146401405,
-0.09452790766954422,
0.17711873352527618,
0.12640434503555298,
-0.33926787972450256,
-0.05898822844028473,
0.8959757089614868,
0.02929542027413845,
0.18274672329425812,
-0.00894846860319376,
-0.3006516396999359,
-0.47419166564941406,
0.19426840543746948,
-1.1336253881454468,
0.04550890997052193,
0.09046686440706253,
-0.42639562487602234,
-0.4556918144226074,
-0.01976892165839672,
-0.8160907626152039,
-0.37644195556640625,
-0.0961519181728363,
0.1741008758544922,
0.08379089087247849,
-0.5530939698219299,
0.07414674013853073,
0.33472442626953125,
0.35169270634651184,
0.2915036082267761,
-1.0330415964126587,
0.44521135091781616,
0.7297054529190063,
0.6029673218727112,
-0.29003021121025085,
-0.5536261796951294,
-1.1485728025436401,
-0.1606568992137909,
-0.3891463279724121,
0.27110838890075684,
-0.2883608043193817,
-0.22184883058071136,
0.3159273564815521,
-0.06971312314271927,
0.11243056505918503,
-0.8147057294845581,
0.5148810744285583,
-0.7678529620170593,
0.20380038022994995,
-0.06864821165800095,
-0.22842055559158325,
0.06677723675966263,
0.20772890746593475,
-0.8946496844291687,
1.2088432312011719,
0.23210978507995605,
-0.731493353843689,
0.06865884363651276,
-0.6928179860115051,
-0.44827741384506226,
0.1471465528011322,
-0.15569764375686646,
-0.6879145503044128,
-0.08743725717067719,
0.2677716612815857,
0.24963140487670898,
-0.36310723423957825,
0.23706217110157013,
-0.5464443564414978,
-0.0863971933722496,
-0.025729870423674583,
-0.05491321161389351,
0.49975547194480896,
0.28590038418769836,
-0.22173821926116943,
0.8880314230918884,
-0.6725463271141052,
0.23976057767868042,
0.1374320387840271,
-0.8588476181030273,
0.12815581262111664,
-0.056707948446273804,
0.5010474920272827,
0.20139098167419434,
0.08546202629804611,
-0.3988165557384491,
0.12456479668617249,
-0.3481917977333069,
0.579708456993103,
0.718405544757843,
-0.3317686915397644,
0.5279121994972229,
-0.2797330617904663,
0.8085880875587463,
-0.18192830681800842,
0.14699095487594604,
-0.01172584854066372,
-0.07899905741214752,
-0.3339293301105499,
-0.33244410157203674,
0.24333858489990234,
0.4061420261859894,
-0.6162304282188416,
0.26393377780914307,
-0.18865932524204254,
-0.3154374957084656,
-0.6658879518508911,
0.33866190910339355,
0.6819334626197815,
0.4353604018688202,
0.24037565290927887,
-0.18463726341724396,
-0.5862768888473511,
-0.7033004760742188,
-0.1056615486741066,
-0.2045115977525711,
0.12029561400413513,
0.433078795671463,
0.33800628781318665,
-0.12284008413553238,
0.8510503172874451,
-0.3542080521583557,
-0.41590577363967896,
-0.35522085428237915,
0.1783146858215332,
0.07528561353683472,
0.3027428984642029,
0.2669532299041748,
-0.5749521851539612,
-0.45581093430519104,
0.36473286151885986,
-0.5482829809188843,
-0.015847112983465195,
0.23794852197170258,
-0.18287241458892822,
0.4982683062553406,
0.6180862188339233,
-0.6694661378860474,
0.004019287880510092,
0.9050709009170532,
-0.27126169204711914,
0.7207151055335999,
-0.5850174427032471,
-0.12647466361522675,
-0.5998049378395081,
0.10533308237791061,
-0.24990065395832062,
-0.6357852220535278,
-0.30801302194595337,
0.4421521723270416,
0.15230989456176758,
-0.17906254529953003,
-0.5441883206367493,
0.7354452610015869,
-0.2853383719921112,
-0.21081233024597168,
-0.20438338816165924,
0.1285391002893448,
-0.5695338845252991,
0.790598452091217,
0.13733597099781036,
0.6752671599388123,
0.3283158838748932,
-0.5346328020095825,
0.3757777810096741,
-0.06423010677099228,
-0.26371148228645325,
0.45475462079048157,
-0.6954482793807983,
0.0972769483923912,
0.008775929920375347,
0.44473493099212646,
-0.41022157669067383,
-0.5157222747802734,
0.2693140506744385,
-0.22652819752693176,
0.1468866914510727,
0.05481291189789772,
-0.48621153831481934,
-0.3932250738143921,
-0.24807703495025635,
0.3850727081298828,
0.47803306579589844,
-0.983190655708313,
0.7619447112083435,
0.38384750485420227,
0.1745424121618271,
-0.6983146667480469,
-0.2762010097503662,
-0.3594186007976532,
-0.02137388288974762,
-0.37178847193717957,
0.15693996846675873,
-0.01614951342344284,
-0.22223231196403503,
0.10821718722581863,
-0.06402206420898438,
-0.16239480674266815,
0.022064287215471268,
0.4727482497692108,
0.119572713971138,
-0.14815914630889893,
0.19206054508686066,
-0.4205804467201233,
0.09709130972623825,
-0.060366190969944,
-0.4954906404018402,
0.5022422671318054,
-0.31661754846572876,
-0.2754817605018616,
-0.21928828954696655,
-0.010629046708345413,
0.7467092871665955,
-0.3051210939884186,
0.5493479371070862,
0.8701907396316528,
-0.1986401528120041,
-0.686182975769043,
-0.22360816597938538,
-0.20666001737117767,
-0.4166545569896698,
0.6200502514839172,
-0.0666123703122139,
-1.3331208229064941,
0.2143598049879074,
-0.010248740203678608,
0.3205776512622833,
0.10290814191102982,
0.9940532445907593,
0.09322087466716766,
0.9167848229408264,
0.8380900621414185,
-0.3053135573863983,
0.7187507152557373,
0.3426516652107239,
-0.15833507478237152,
-0.48402079939842224,
-0.059540871530771255,
-0.45147594809532166,
-0.22615110874176025,
-0.5356458425521851,
-0.6721104383468628,
0.2561222016811371,
0.17445188760757446,
-0.6821804642677307,
0.10979998111724854,
-0.17447346448898315,
0.5721753835678101,
0.5120735764503479,
0.10953722149133682,
0.3500535488128662,
0.05624755844473839,
-0.2025730013847351,
0.14805591106414795,
-0.7705170512199402,
-0.09583913534879684,
0.9326980113983154,
0.6912342309951782,
1.0768896341323853,
0.23927238583564758,
0.523876428604126,
0.10635242611169815,
0.3858667016029358,
-0.8269805312156677,
0.4871441423892975,
0.11743411421775818,
-0.38627031445503235,
-0.8086195588111877,
-0.7658915519714355,
-0.811851978302002,
0.41724270582199097,
-0.18298067152500153,
-0.47093233466148376,
-0.40973347425460815,
0.48951956629753113,
-0.39010709524154663,
0.5237265825271606,
-0.4120614528656006,
0.7374902367591858,
-0.22425346076488495,
-0.47777578234672546,
-0.6050773859024048,
-0.5336756110191345,
0.40170684456825256,
0.2947455644607544,
0.3908941447734833,
-0.007597021292895079,
0.07156319916248322,
0.763265073299408,
-0.5881819128990173,
0.8137112259864807,
-0.26503193378448486,
-0.26585233211517334,
0.17542876303195953,
0.15453004837036133,
0.6447452306747437,
0.05867918208241463,
0.21258209645748138,
-0.20857924222946167,
-0.10046318173408508,
-0.20734119415283203,
-0.527336597442627,
0.8095391988754272,
-0.9845777750015259,
-0.21748046576976776,
-0.3149370551109314,
-0.47987836599349976,
-0.25014716386795044,
0.2637326121330261,
-0.2062395215034485,
0.309583842754364,
-0.45644986629486084,
0.28147026896476746,
0.9051433801651001,
-0.2514320909976959,
0.5779670476913452,
0.49257582426071167,
-0.901847779750824,
-0.7075150609016418,
0.880580484867096,
-0.4490807056427002,
0.322979599237442,
0.554944634437561,
0.2971592843532562,
-0.2955642342567444,
-0.038391321897506714,
-0.6918431520462036,
0.4037158787250519,
-0.4686177670955658,
-0.031597308814525604,
-0.28690817952156067,
-0.10389027744531631,
-0.292331725358963,
0.20002983510494232,
-0.5641152262687683,
-0.3403826355934143,
-0.1541658639907837,
0.02035178802907467,
0.3000659942626953,
0.8243335485458374,
-0.1213226169347763,
0.1841839849948883,
-0.5907061100006104,
0.23091931641101837,
0.39830732345581055,
0.8509445190429688,
0.31197601556777954,
-0.3992196023464203,
-0.43898433446884155,
-0.3603343963623047,
-0.2951405942440033,
-0.3288746774196625,
0.24176008999347687,
0.22554899752140045,
0.341327965259552,
0.2538926303386688,
-0.0044699436984956264,
0.3839477300643921,
-0.587381899356842,
0.3208502233028412,
0.5254740118980408,
-0.6208328008651733,
0.05721505358815193,
-0.46772995591163635,
0.5109575986862183,
0.2705492675304413,
0.41486242413520813,
-0.6904947757720947,
0.013172665610909462,
-0.2911805510520935,
-0.6454694271087646,
1.0158272981643677,
-0.25145596265792847,
-0.28419220447540283,
0.4348601996898651,
0.22522665560245514,
-0.016254281625151634,
0.15645699203014374,
-0.8046548962593079,
-0.1345014125108719,
-0.03671874478459358,
-0.16870737075805664,
-0.05845077335834503,
-0.08904290944337845,
-0.1596970111131668,
-0.11720693111419678,
0.7093657851219177,
-0.445880651473999,
0.0730438232421875,
-0.006308733019977808,
-0.19931736588478088,
-0.6497438549995422,
0.3553714156150818,
0.6761995553970337,
0.49533316493034363,
-0.274371862411499,
-0.06202643737196922,
-0.018176110461354256,
-0.475257933139801,
0.022285502403974533,
-0.11917903274297714,
0.04049032926559448,
-0.47231820225715637,
0.46809858083724976,
0.9655872583389282,
0.5427437424659729,
-1.0878729820251465,
0.3665677309036255,
-0.2018217295408249,
-0.49250075221061707,
-0.1855628490447998,
-0.005692826583981514,
0.3883221745491028,
0.3701031804084778,
0.02668970823287964,
-0.3425463140010834,
-0.4507197141647339,
-0.4003206193447113,
0.24195575714111328,
0.15927760303020477,
-0.7075402140617371,
-0.30680519342422485,
0.5686355233192444,
0.2396629899740219,
-0.4838438034057617,
0.8434285521507263,
-0.04937906190752983,
-0.48274004459381104,
0.35266417264938354,
0.44096723198890686,
0.8831996917724609,
-0.05894599109888077,
0.3420398533344269,
0.5735476016998291,
0.04753310605883598,
-0.4747838079929352,
0.17202593386173248,
-0.21743620932102203,
-0.6130178570747375,
-0.5707505345344543,
-0.8476477265357971,
-0.7658112645149231,
-0.05118671432137489,
-0.7429115176200867,
0.09559635072946548,
-0.883179247379303,
-0.016516869887709618,
-0.4159737825393677,
-0.2103244960308075,
-0.5053197145462036,
-0.21408335864543915,
0.0034118015319108963,
0.8198904395103455,
-0.3819267749786377,
0.9704416394233704,
0.8898861408233643,
-0.29550546407699585,
-0.8418474197387695,
-0.1609567552804947,
0.13698163628578186,
-0.8009658455848694,
0.808630645275116,
-0.10621801018714905,
-0.2605961263179779,
0.09692943096160889,
-0.5072465538978577,
-0.7139126062393188,
1.031729817390442,
0.3289608359336853,
-0.8424696326255798,
-0.3331809937953949,
-0.17274963855743408,
0.5213417410850525,
-0.42898204922676086,
0.35062721371650696,
0.49902036786079407,
0.34340089559555054,
0.23282453417778015,
-1.1645787954330444,
0.13823994994163513,
0.15796877443790436,
0.07938311249017715,
0.30547887086868286,
-0.67587810754776,
0.7743866443634033,
-0.5991016626358032,
-0.09762214869260788,
-0.04029076173901558,
0.8685277104377747,
0.36887699365615845,
-0.2580048441886902,
0.6039167642593384,
0.8875924348831177,
0.6265153288841248,
0.08259765058755875,
0.7294555902481079,
-0.049248963594436646,
0.5985594987869263,
1.403846025466919,
-0.370087593793869,
1.1954853534698486,
0.36910495162010193,
-0.26729243993759155,
0.5286383628845215,
0.46772289276123047,
0.2990032732486725,
0.43420374393463135,
0.6320251822471619,
-0.1944512575864792,
-0.2455941140651703,
0.030646327883005142,
-0.18044587969779968,
0.06104431673884392,
0.17270049452781677,
0.08062847703695297,
-0.6752812266349792,
0.18125414848327637,
0.04333331808447838,
0.2286415994167328,
-0.3800983428955078,
0.7763586044311523,
0.1262473165988922,
-0.7997838258743286,
0.5260436534881592,
0.14205336570739746,
0.7741060853004456,
-0.640167772769928,
-0.1012052595615387,
-0.06851209700107574,
0.5970180034637451,
-0.24722352623939514,
-0.5626267194747925,
0.08147681504487991,
-0.28105875849723816,
-0.243425652384758,
-0.5304857492446899,
0.4365505278110504,
-0.655156672000885,
0.09760210663080215,
0.6551949381828308,
0.3212774991989136,
-0.2901540994644165,
0.05538562685251236,
-0.6308626532554626,
0.35675060749053955,
-0.13396325707435608,
-0.4133756756782532,
0.6566988825798035,
0.2281300574541092,
-0.14478309452533722,
0.9023887515068054,
0.5489487648010254,
0.286664754152298,
0.019080258905887604,
0.30011868476867676,
0.5850276947021484,
-0.5365786552429199,
-0.4368668496608734,
-0.6449945569038391,
-0.0025503619108349085,
0.24840430915355682,
-0.39484870433807373,
0.3801318109035492,
0.08737407624721527,
1.0145641565322876,
-0.1333039402961731,
0.4364055395126343,
0.021015020087361336,
0.6311577558517456,
-0.35680991411209106,
0.7554861903190613,
-0.4839995801448822,
-0.11635351181030273,
0.10493534058332443,
-0.6567164063453674,
-0.3436473608016968,
0.444146066904068,
-0.0011104070581495762,
0.11761799454689026,
0.5441442131996155,
0.9330659508705139,
0.1877683848142624,
0.06874269247055054,
0.3159511089324951,
0.2296362668275833,
0.5012696385383606,
0.47476306557655334,
0.5385384559631348,
0.12940792739391327,
0.637536346912384,
-0.16397692263126373,
-0.35276374220848083,
-0.43845707178115845,
-0.9137482643127441,
-0.9103432893753052,
-0.46622905135154724,
-0.27848339080810547,
-0.2946423888206482,
-0.06080038100481033,
1.434674859046936,
0.9759429097175598,
-0.825604259967804,
-0.7395773530006409,
-0.244873508810997,
0.25831538438796997,
-0.49703407287597656,
-0.23980605602264404,
0.2393713742494583,
-0.6273223161697388,
-0.5066975951194763,
0.22324690222740173,
0.21883799135684967,
-0.19858545064926147,
-0.606905460357666,
-0.6530500054359436,
-0.11305060982704163,
-0.2731379270553589,
0.5955653786659241,
0.840786337852478,
-0.7373199462890625,
-0.020905165001749992,
-0.22712726891040802,
-0.3865921199321747,
-0.05984559655189514,
1.0829702615737915,
-0.5651785135269165,
0.298071950674057,
0.4893212616443634,
1.0532753467559814,
0.513081431388855,
-0.15901707112789154,
0.5369954109191895,
-0.6220031380653381,
0.01696755364537239,
0.16218839585781097,
0.08574768155813217,
0.0713474377989769,
-0.24536387622356415,
0.38760846853256226,
0.08281401544809341,
-0.7642346024513245,
-0.8894742727279663,
0.30508920550346375,
-0.8517675399780273,
-0.13649249076843262,
0.9601240754127502,
-0.06774928420782089,
-0.42910921573638916,
0.35862913727760315,
-0.05821451172232628,
-0.024169128388166428,
-0.6234967708587646,
0.40537673234939575,
0.7471175193786621,
-0.09152962267398834,
-0.39806699752807617,
-0.5709582567214966,
0.6971154808998108,
0.34015196561813354,
-0.8459053635597229,
0.5867215991020203,
0.42925333976745605,
0.1997942477464676,
-0.21463258564472198,
0.8625755906105042,
-0.2738725244998932,
0.35306480526924133,
-0.3986188769340515,
0.3713456988334656,
-0.3294494152069092,
-0.46758297085762024,
-0.559222400188446,
0.26037296652793884,
0.4416345953941345,
0.08622036874294281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12250v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12250v1
|
Your Transformer is Secretly Linear
| 2024-05-19T22:44:00 | 2024-05-19T22:44:00 |
Anton Razzhigaev, Matvey Mikhalchuk, Elizaveta Goncharova, Nikolai Gerasimenko, Ivan Oseledets, Denis Dimitrov, Andrey Kuznetsov
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper reveals a novel linear characteristic exclusive to transformer
decoders, including models such as GPT, LLaMA, OPT, BLOOM and others. We
analyze embedding transformations between sequential layers, uncovering a
near-perfect linear relationship (Procrustes similarity score of 0.99).
However, linearity decreases when the residual component is removed due to a
consistently low output norm of the transformer layer. Our experiments show
that removing or linearly approximating some of the most linear blocks of
transformers does not affect significantly the loss or model performance.
Moreover, in our pretraining experiments on smaller models we introduce a
cosine-similarity-based regularization, aimed at reducing layer linearity. This
regularization improves performance metrics on benchmarks like Tiny Stories and
SuperGLUE and as well successfully decreases the linearity of the models. This
study challenges the existing understanding of transformer architectures,
suggesting that their operation may be more linear than previously assumed.
|
[
-0.5622316598892212,
-0.5673274993896484,
0.32529157400131226,
0.05480287969112396,
-0.01954704336822033,
-0.047279972583055496,
0.07066613435745239,
-0.4539943039417267,
0.39704060554504395,
0.3131575286388397,
-0.7580614686012268,
-0.0927131325006485,
-0.49015843868255615,
-0.3486339747905731,
-0.6932849287986755,
1.108002781867981,
0.041645292192697525,
0.032200902700424194,
-0.11579922586679459,
-0.10811319947242737,
-0.2228451371192932,
-0.37994351983070374,
-0.3408059775829315,
-0.5856927037239075,
0.6424919962882996,
-0.057647835463285446,
1.2096706628799438,
0.7649933099746704,
0.5968347191810608,
0.2139090895652771,
-0.10731503367424011,
-0.16375061869621277,
-0.8943196535110474,
-0.06420066207647324,
0.042202867567539215,
-0.5942655801773071,
-0.3601170778274536,
0.18498021364212036,
0.4687221944332123,
0.8346050977706909,
0.3099830448627472,
0.41238510608673096,
0.31317660212516785,
0.5160884857177734,
-0.24401549994945526,
0.0055766636505723,
-0.5347797274589539,
0.430932879447937,
0.023844387382268906,
-0.08248622715473175,
-0.40501919388771057,
-0.40321242809295654,
0.06805992871522903,
-0.5772844552993774,
0.803623378276825,
0.1756076216697693,
1.4046521186828613,
0.6116021871566772,
-0.27632373571395874,
-0.2144155651330948,
-1.4934788942337036,
0.737249493598938,
-0.47571277618408203,
0.4647068977355957,
0.11435813456773758,
0.39253872632980347,
0.37127622961997986,
-1.0448219776153564,
-0.3795037865638733,
-0.17116650938987732,
-0.5167311429977417,
0.08196801692247391,
-0.390861839056015,
0.08093097060918808,
0.4519761800765991,
0.5426679253578186,
-0.44206833839416504,
-0.041634902358055115,
-0.5268849730491638,
-0.41107189655303955,
0.28004181385040283,
0.1267893761396408,
-0.0952281504869461,
0.17597463726997375,
-0.7041463851928711,
-0.04545639082789421,
-0.6411638259887695,
0.3995661735534668,
0.4779464602470398,
-0.31640347838401794,
0.11544986814260483,
0.2774182856082916,
0.45147037506103516,
-0.15995271503925323,
0.38423389196395874,
0.054653849452733994,
0.11247853189706802,
-0.32342788577079773,
-0.06792203336954117,
-0.3791763484477997,
0.5629382729530334,
0.22927358746528625,
0.2709648609161377,
-0.530047595500946,
-0.3904796838760376,
0.28250232338905334,
0.4710257053375244,
-0.6601809859275818,
-0.5395640134811401,
-0.1416492611169815,
-0.8661583662033081,
-0.4777351915836334,
0.13450917601585388,
-0.4915246367454529,
-0.17599153518676758,
-0.17268723249435425,
0.7445301413536072,
-0.1324003040790558,
0.15250825881958008,
0.0797324851155281,
-0.016878178343176842,
0.6426801681518555,
0.05578424409031868,
-0.7736032009124756,
0.9193817377090454,
0.72608882188797,
0.6002233028411865,
0.03135586529970169,
-0.06130138039588928,
-0.249961718916893,
-0.23648808896541595,
-0.4272027611732483,
0.46758708357810974,
-0.5002827644348145,
-0.11042574793100357,
-0.2041834443807602,
0.08562169224023819,
-0.002508549951016903,
-0.611876904964447,
0.923186719417572,
-0.6772574186325073,
0.4097999334335327,
-0.22421874105930328,
-0.2872326672077179,
0.02706637978553772,
-0.19497084617614746,
-0.8916808366775513,
1.016650915145874,
-0.10014808923006058,
-0.6253530979156494,
0.22609475255012512,
-0.2612738311290741,
-0.014882687479257584,
-0.1718522608280182,
-0.10594262182712555,
-0.9024013876914978,
0.4391624331474304,
0.2409374862909317,
0.2505786716938019,
-0.10749021917581558,
0.18465325236320496,
-0.18756471574306488,
-0.765437662601471,
0.09801974147558212,
-0.4890282154083252,
0.24196602404117584,
0.12503625452518463,
-0.42970383167266846,
0.12678468227386475,
-0.8177511692047119,
-0.2154342085123062,
0.16024468839168549,
0.11249053478240967,
-0.2142566740512848,
0.07488030195236206,
0.044382549822330475,
0.375948041677475,
0.23284627497196198,
-0.6691794395446777,
0.318550705909729,
-0.24564674496650696,
0.16498254239559174,
0.7992111444473267,
-0.02663334645330906,
0.8027467727661133,
-0.47463715076446533,
0.4881034791469574,
-0.06328930705785751,
0.3991008996963501,
-0.1537466049194336,
-0.5331605672836304,
-1.2471199035644531,
-0.10140807181596756,
0.3528529107570648,
0.35905975103378296,
-0.45980313420295715,
0.5023902058601379,
-0.41875213384628296,
-0.3347854018211365,
-0.6307639479637146,
0.10113564133644104,
0.3245972692966461,
0.349568635225296,
0.46847304701805115,
-0.2235705703496933,
-0.4066949188709259,
-1.154629111289978,
-0.290761262178421,
0.5340822339057922,
-0.4271852672100067,
0.12907911837100983,
0.403816819190979,
-0.28438252210617065,
0.9341645240783691,
-0.5875289440155029,
-0.5101003050804138,
-0.0521446168422699,
-0.06113235652446747,
0.6287883520126343,
0.4976634383201599,
0.5762726664543152,
-0.5124467015266418,
-0.40638473629951477,
-0.19839119911193848,
-0.5973634719848633,
0.11349005997180939,
-0.44676488637924194,
0.22150947153568268,
-0.4990868866443634,
0.5808870196342468,
-0.46967941522598267,
0.6986778974533081,
0.46164676547050476,
-0.3334408402442932,
0.2352808564901352,
-0.3196216821670532,
-0.525248646736145,
-0.6156195998191833,
0.05996321141719818,
-0.10678761452436447,
-0.43192413449287415,
-0.8649993538856506,
0.0066398996859788895,
0.17681433260440826,
-0.34273022413253784,
-0.04424991458654404,
-0.08010368049144745,
-0.3652274012565613,
-0.10421798378229141,
-0.04019193351268768,
-0.1508750021457672,
0.23214896023273468,
0.6844961047172546,
-0.4032626152038574,
0.6220898628234863,
0.35711804032325745,
-0.3546440601348877,
0.21250185370445251,
0.2829088270664215,
-0.14489547908306122,
0.004427437204867601,
-1.0318737030029297,
0.4641585946083069,
-0.28766050934791565,
0.2474260926246643,
-0.7867395281791687,
0.3272199034690857,
0.12044400721788406,
-0.07923111319541931,
0.16420838236808777,
-0.018673628568649292,
-0.16018028557300568,
-0.42586153745651245,
-0.5203763246536255,
0.27999159693717957,
0.9198794960975647,
-0.6093000173568726,
0.6105362176895142,
-0.21172577142715454,
0.07898792624473572,
-0.6733182668685913,
-0.7790517210960388,
-0.2355191707611084,
-0.06947056204080582,
-0.839329719543457,
0.5482243895530701,
-0.14702416956424713,
-0.04149797931313515,
0.24527230858802795,
-0.46378451585769653,
-0.03372514620423317,
-0.09898554533720016,
0.3399662375450134,
0.059469159692525864,
-0.6849642395973206,
-0.13826961815357208,
0.05153185501694679,
-0.4372045695781708,
0.36199328303337097,
-0.28795740008354187,
0.7092883586883545,
-0.2665557861328125,
-0.24383017420768738,
-0.7240819931030273,
0.12128480523824692,
0.5949419736862183,
-0.13504648208618164,
0.7455335259437561,
0.9664528965950012,
-0.23840691149234772,
-0.3276698589324951,
-0.44096633791923523,
-0.2649548351764679,
-0.6029287576675415,
0.056129418313503265,
-0.6258915066719055,
-0.5181002616882324,
0.930135190486908,
-0.18372580409049988,
-0.18649613857269287,
0.5107973217964172,
0.04320201650261879,
-0.224791020154953,
0.7196493148803711,
0.8862783312797546,
-0.08120666444301605,
0.23428452014923096,
-0.6588942408561707,
0.6889441609382629,
-0.48706239461898804,
-0.42693591117858887,
-0.26929110288619995,
-0.9478849172592163,
-0.4260539412498474,
-0.3087746798992157,
0.33405086398124695,
0.20852170884609222,
0.030719349160790443,
0.40789514780044556,
-0.42582011222839355,
0.6801493167877197,
0.2365141212940216,
0.2665393650531769,
0.12491478025913239,
-0.01261829026043415,
-0.06930159777402878,
-0.40015140175819397,
-0.4418576657772064,
-0.3421650826931,
0.7901220321655273,
0.964396595954895,
0.9414017796516418,
-0.022618023678660393,
0.7344733476638794,
0.35590603947639465,
-0.2827928364276886,
-0.795979380607605,
0.19577516615390778,
-0.18510344624519348,
-0.14095187187194824,
-0.19250473380088806,
-0.4294723868370056,
-0.8853512406349182,
0.09020684659481049,
-0.26244816184043884,
-0.28646424412727356,
0.5979384779930115,
0.1216142550110817,
-0.3029743432998657,
0.5650311708450317,
-0.5615280270576477,
0.5033929944038391,
-0.09436316788196564,
-0.2657601535320282,
-0.042173292487859726,
-0.4791696071624756,
0.20307742059230804,
-0.10483414679765701,
0.13456055521965027,
0.20757688581943512,
-0.13215158879756927,
0.3832903802394867,
-0.5330410003662109,
0.6150004267692566,
-0.2119201421737671,
-0.14143171906471252,
-0.06619945913553238,
0.38213029503822327,
0.6601086258888245,
-0.10904795676469803,
0.21739530563354492,
0.2421441525220871,
-0.23132628202438354,
-0.6553149819374084,
-0.9098938703536987,
0.7029695510864258,
-0.9882134199142456,
-0.4530244767665863,
-0.12351493537425995,
-0.6595844030380249,
0.09032776206731796,
0.11107680201530457,
0.4313502609729767,
0.6864415407180786,
-0.06667140126228333,
0.42267274856567383,
0.8964956402778625,
-0.13962335884571075,
0.5752109289169312,
-0.05073319748044014,
-0.19517767429351807,
0.00567009299993515,
0.8170046210289001,
0.11417979001998901,
0.3887910544872284,
0.43200168013572693,
0.43297091126441956,
-0.11533886194229126,
-0.5741409659385681,
0.05936126783490181,
0.31646764278411865,
-0.7076128721237183,
0.14368121325969696,
-0.5058505535125732,
-0.533159077167511,
-0.05688180401921272,
-0.2219437211751938,
-0.6019749641418457,
-0.7175845503807068,
-0.06623305380344391,
-0.11807961016893387,
-0.18677712976932526,
1.449856162071228,
0.24769064784049988,
0.36480459570884705,
-0.5254364013671875,
0.603767454624176,
0.5578151345252991,
0.4707946181297302,
0.01216326653957367,
-0.9140011072158813,
-0.19301806390285492,
-0.23279081284999847,
-0.4558972120285034,
-0.3098679780960083,
0.5300401449203491,
0.41451314091682434,
0.5375491976737976,
0.6626807451248169,
-0.016713039949536324,
0.7423818707466125,
-0.879392683506012,
0.8329713940620422,
0.1352488249540329,
-1.0797761678695679,
0.050622500479221344,
-0.16487714648246765,
-0.021599315106868744,
0.022383088245987892,
0.42903658747673035,
-0.15155088901519775,
-0.05558254197239876,
-0.7996466159820557,
-0.6720833778381348,
0.49039870500564575,
0.5824421048164368,
0.33564436435699463,
0.7717450857162476,
0.3486981689929962,
0.21873535215854645,
-0.023259639739990234,
-0.9613849520683289,
-0.7655839920043945,
-0.4471636712551117,
-0.1371341198682785,
-0.12937772274017334,
-0.5737508535385132,
-0.04807296395301819,
-0.344384104013443,
0.1669912189245224,
0.26935088634490967,
0.6496041417121887,
0.028821609914302826,
-0.13828550279140472,
-0.11345004290342331,
0.09862187504768372,
0.7739248871803284,
0.5252671837806702,
-0.39695194363594055,
0.4374150037765503,
0.20631356537342072,
-0.5569645166397095,
-0.00548724876716733,
-0.3691249489784241,
-0.23003433644771576,
0.3798069655895233,
0.43344515562057495,
0.7071774005889893,
0.35646361112594604,
0.1896166056394577,
0.6913339495658875,
-0.39432546496391296,
-0.20664072036743164,
-0.4703584611415863,
-0.16959963738918304,
-0.21796180307865143,
0.16481322050094604,
0.5740696787834167,
0.9188233613967896,
0.07010604441165924,
-0.2397783100605011,
0.395697683095932,
0.24978797137737274,
-0.5180968642234802,
-0.7510613203048706,
0.7862393260002136,
0.13197821378707886,
-0.4374485909938812,
0.2054920345544815,
-0.11253975331783295,
-0.5520692467689514,
0.4596189558506012,
0.5023697018623352,
0.8538500666618347,
-0.20093870162963867,
-0.026407720521092415,
0.19037854671478271,
0.7426205277442932,
0.06892327219247818,
-0.2889515459537506,
-0.05879123881459236,
-0.6050715446472168,
-0.15791471302509308,
-0.5816044211387634,
-0.11350435763597488,
0.3163177967071533,
-0.9884833693504333,
0.4050094783306122,
-0.6945171356201172,
0.21133646368980408,
0.005383066367357969,
-0.08360661566257477,
-0.7671114802360535,
-0.06831203401088715,
0.25098928809165955,
0.6382011771202087,
-1.0092183351516724,
1.1341675519943237,
-0.17056863009929657,
-0.334396094083786,
-0.8193569779396057,
0.18430569767951965,
-0.26800334453582764,
-0.60285484790802,
0.7294235825538635,
0.1835145503282547,
-0.33875584602355957,
-0.11429218202829361,
-0.36465296149253845,
-0.9967641234397888,
1.1442674398422241,
0.4643671214580536,
-0.6131570935249329,
-0.40220901370048523,
0.4922226369380951,
0.7327615022659302,
-0.3782415986061096,
0.46151256561279297,
0.44459158182144165,
0.21820253133773804,
-0.107879638671875,
-0.8427334427833557,
-0.027590719982981682,
-0.4079410135746002,
0.3290664553642273,
-0.0661558285355568,
-0.5647125244140625,
1.1014035940170288,
0.06153911352157593,
-0.40709683299064636,
0.24534696340560913,
0.4685666263103485,
-0.6635115742683411,
0.2809894382953644,
0.46358194947242737,
0.4478217661380768,
0.5587974190711975,
-0.22580823302268982,
1.033826470375061,
-0.4729806184768677,
0.6699296236038208,
0.8009130954742432,
-0.05009967461228371,
0.4036102592945099,
0.3055664300918579,
-0.08015114814043045,
0.6356267333030701,
-0.06845065206289291,
-0.3636343479156494,
0.5167226791381836,
-0.014851740561425686,
0.1723453551530838,
-0.1056026965379715,
0.11761660128831863,
-0.553676187992096,
0.3655549883842468,
0.35390669107437134,
-0.6437877416610718,
-0.11890944093465805,
-0.11876780539751053,
-0.009967237710952759,
0.29145750403404236,
-0.2936907410621643,
0.39121606945991516,
0.029674289748072624,
-0.012427872978150845,
0.8738359808921814,
-0.2820476293563843,
0.8213677406311035,
-0.5654283761978149,
0.11368298530578613,
-0.3024831712245941,
0.6520819067955017,
-0.4993574619293213,
-0.30122819542884827,
0.5487309694290161,
-0.40227019786834717,
-0.48474788665771484,
-0.6945351958274841,
0.7389666438102722,
-0.35427382588386536,
-0.44091281294822693,
0.5258767008781433,
0.2050144076347351,
0.002349751302972436,
0.14162451028823853,
-0.5228064656257629,
0.15703435242176056,
0.18027906119823456,
-0.23725347220897675,
0.11929329484701157,
0.2126452922821045,
0.2204948514699936,
0.6536086797714233,
0.6908448338508606,
0.12468525022268295,
0.5819068551063538,
0.19254562258720398,
1.1363584995269775,
-0.5976975560188293,
-0.26645857095718384,
-0.46037915349006653,
0.39862391352653503,
-0.049672119319438934,
-0.05472080409526825,
0.8711944818496704,
0.7658287882804871,
0.7981751561164856,
-0.5247277021408081,
0.2882058918476105,
0.47507211565971375,
0.40447571873664856,
-0.40016603469848633,
0.7939174771308899,
-0.12124302983283997,
0.7307718992233276,
-0.15231071412563324,
-1.1736057996749878,
-0.10680772364139557,
0.4636184871196747,
-0.21494995057582855,
-0.1861265003681183,
0.9319145679473877,
0.9108144640922546,
-0.4095495045185089,
-0.03208547085523605,
0.8585346341133118,
0.4593200981616974,
0.413362979888916,
0.43071186542510986,
0.9362182021141052,
-1.127812385559082,
0.8223769664764404,
-0.6718712449073792,
-0.050213973969221115,
0.12269396334886551,
-0.48061496019363403,
-1.0694218873977661,
-0.40403416752815247,
-0.09424850344657898,
-0.10762635618448257,
-0.28776997327804565,
0.4066016972064972,
0.6937156319618225,
-1.0280348062515259,
-0.08358319103717804,
-0.018837014213204384,
-0.1695612519979477,
-0.3071962893009186,
-0.2355603277683258,
0.22760161757469177,
-0.2841372489929199,
-0.5204005837440491,
0.35278376936912537,
0.011110207065939903,
-0.1815720647573471,
-0.3662584125995636,
-0.03949369490146637,
0.22140894830226898,
0.20780329406261444,
0.432606965303421,
0.023272639140486717,
-0.8133902549743652,
-0.6236663460731506,
0.2634676396846771,
-0.016675813123583794,
0.2891768217086792,
1.1438167095184326,
-0.8937764763832092,
0.22946104407310486,
0.46533283591270447,
0.4208933413028717,
0.8068854212760925,
0.01900547742843628,
0.35590365529060364,
-1.0169349908828735,
0.5291792154312134,
0.4092252552509308,
0.3907286524772644,
-0.07109847664833069,
-0.5846291780471802,
0.18366482853889465,
0.3588727116584778,
-0.5842761993408203,
-0.5476179122924805,
0.25719282031059265,
-1.021872878074646,
0.11034511774778366,
0.7684868574142456,
-0.23900078237056732,
-0.12973739206790924,
-0.23207984864711761,
-0.10562089085578918,
-0.00046349497279152274,
-0.11277450621128082,
0.5470230579376221,
0.06613175570964813,
-0.1138562336564064,
-0.293104350566864,
-0.3653743267059326,
0.5076767802238464,
0.4291459321975708,
-0.1697482466697693,
-0.33765843510627747,
-0.18107853829860687,
0.38931092619895935,
0.7485786080360413,
-0.2015298753976822,
-0.130506694316864,
-0.01575886271893978,
0.2714483141899109,
0.031859882175922394,
-0.3358381688594818,
-0.49985867738723755,
-0.7101645469665527,
0.4871213734149933,
-0.20150457322597504,
-0.2768811285495758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11685v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11685v1
|
ColorFoil: Investigating Color Blindness in Large Vision and Language Models
| 2024-05-19T22:04:57 | 2024-05-19T22:04:57 |
Ahnaf Mozib Samin, M. Firoz Ahmed, Md. Mushtaq Shahriyar Rafee
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
With the utilization of Transformer architecture, large Vision and Language
(V&L) models have shown promising performance in even zero-shot settings.
Several studies, however, indicate a lack of robustness of the models when
dealing with complex linguistics and visual attributes. In this work, we
introduce a novel V&L benchmark - ColorFoil, by creating color-related foils to
assess the models' perception ability to detect colors like red, white, green,
etc. We evaluate seven state-of-the-art V&L models including CLIP, ViLT,
GroupViT, and BridgeTower, etc. in a zero-shot setting and present intriguing
findings from the V&L models. The experimental evaluation indicates that ViLT
and BridgeTower demonstrate much better color perception capabilities compared
to CLIP and its variants and GroupViT. Moreover, CLIP-based models and GroupViT
struggle to distinguish colors that are visually distinct to humans with normal
color perception ability.
|
[
-0.4630856513977051,
-0.11452353000640869,
0.3436697721481323,
0.29465699195861816,
-0.004063654690980911,
0.1912304311990738,
0.12371385097503662,
-0.6822001934051514,
0.22867617011070251,
0.3646668791770935,
-0.47342267632484436,
-0.4533008635044098,
-0.454834520816803,
0.033170830458402634,
-0.4411984980106354,
0.5137332677841187,
0.012313686311244965,
0.24097301065921783,
0.36074167490005493,
-0.6172375679016113,
-0.7502982020378113,
-0.1895342916250229,
-0.2315264344215393,
-0.02886173687875271,
0.6053531765937805,
0.41933807730674744,
0.6146148443222046,
0.450920045375824,
0.6086680293083191,
0.3203834891319275,
-0.12405186891555786,
-0.3163735568523407,
-0.4470580816268921,
0.07286534458398819,
-0.5555054545402527,
-0.6350816488265991,
-0.11241982132196426,
-0.23740045726299286,
0.3122759759426117,
0.42266127467155457,
0.06259305775165558,
0.2590271532535553,
-0.13669870793819427,
0.4964064359664917,
-1.264732837677002,
0.22348040342330933,
-0.7336408495903015,
0.3098256289958954,
-0.449974924325943,
0.21848958730697632,
-0.3934905230998993,
0.21352683007717133,
-0.004790628328919411,
-0.5070595741271973,
0.3051202595233917,
0.407310426235199,
0.7698506712913513,
0.07028981298208237,
-0.4561532139778137,
0.225460946559906,
-0.9868559837341309,
0.7853848934173584,
-0.3721652925014496,
0.9098539352416992,
-0.12447603046894073,
0.8400533199310303,
0.3665909469127655,
-0.8243273496627808,
-1.1349420547485352,
-0.05656708776950836,
0.09409373253583908,
0.5715989470481873,
-0.538110613822937,
-0.1847977638244629,
0.4041348695755005,
0.11616643518209457,
-0.6489778757095337,
0.027981005609035492,
-0.7553473114967346,
-0.25751614570617676,
0.3812093138694763,
0.28997132182121277,
0.3342488706111908,
-0.25273963809013367,
-0.35177791118621826,
-0.42446669936180115,
-0.41394078731536865,
-0.1364145427942276,
0.2546817362308502,
0.2326357662677765,
-0.33729472756385803,
0.5442569255828857,
-0.36260750889778137,
0.637681245803833,
-0.35363173484802246,
0.02260865457355976,
0.4093717932701111,
-0.28498050570487976,
-0.4112524390220642,
-0.34246376156806946,
0.5462281107902527,
0.623244047164917,
0.7487056255340576,
-0.03574514389038086,
-0.19304753839969635,
0.0868847593665123,
0.25147750973701477,
-0.7308174967765808,
-0.4805285632610321,
0.061255455017089844,
-0.39717501401901245,
-0.05727025866508484,
0.14668823778629303,
-0.9529594779014587,
-0.4972028434276581,
-0.14774230122566223,
0.8125616312026978,
-0.44033384323120117,
-0.463847815990448,
0.21334579586982727,
-0.5880091190338135,
0.5501899123191833,
0.16581617295742035,
-1.024278998374939,
0.21457797288894653,
0.6445485949516296,
0.7597358226776123,
-0.6870949864387512,
-0.28366389870643616,
-0.3252021074295044,
-0.0982857495546341,
-0.2596866488456726,
0.7098810076713562,
-0.4459899961948395,
-0.20498307049274445,
0.06379444897174835,
0.1676214188337326,
-0.028372934088110924,
-0.5036200881004333,
0.5314629077911377,
-0.5707893371582031,
-0.18928711116313934,
-0.41502735018730164,
0.0831877663731575,
-0.16181224584579468,
0.22817929089069366,
-0.7429361939430237,
0.2042703926563263,
0.2324063926935196,
-0.7776366472244263,
0.569826602935791,
-0.47702428698539734,
-0.016734126955270767,
0.5358673334121704,
-0.3699055016040802,
-0.4982641637325287,
0.23421317338943481,
0.13062316179275513,
0.11512421071529388,
-0.02239271253347397,
-0.1906467229127884,
-0.6548531651496887,
-0.5490723848342896,
0.17039218544960022,
-0.3513769209384918,
0.8470056653022766,
0.2474154382944107,
-0.3369113504886627,
0.29423514008522034,
-0.6143633723258972,
-0.07333894819021225,
0.07002127170562744,
0.261271595954895,
-0.3168792426586151,
-0.19376295804977417,
0.3347610831260681,
0.00891149416565895,
-0.29792889952659607,
-0.9569250345230103,
-0.15814125537872314,
-0.25655901432037354,
0.45481207966804504,
0.6652420163154602,
-0.3006003499031067,
0.2088208645582199,
-0.10746297240257263,
0.6389179229736328,
0.152530699968338,
0.5295438766479492,
-0.37189942598342896,
-0.35970771312713623,
-1.0692225694656372,
-0.42504701018333435,
0.33465275168418884,
0.5438882112503052,
-0.9423078298568726,
-0.33371224999427795,
-0.18029733002185822,
-0.6094858646392822,
-0.21978236734867096,
-0.3228128254413605,
0.19439399242401123,
0.3578987121582031,
0.3362703323364258,
-0.2610986530780792,
-0.27544090151786804,
-1.0377129316329956,
-0.17900237441062927,
0.03925124555826187,
-0.02458985149860382,
0.4208337068557739,
0.9385758638381958,
-0.12097403407096863,
0.8274980783462524,
-0.7957225441932678,
-0.3195142447948456,
-0.19669684767723083,
-0.03329265117645264,
0.32048943638801575,
0.09544410556554794,
0.63655686378479,
-1.116215705871582,
-0.6812458038330078,
0.1406000256538391,
-0.534631073474884,
0.05067557096481323,
0.5045942068099976,
0.1635596752166748,
0.2135695070028305,
0.6574670076370239,
0.052522290498018265,
0.7040696740150452,
0.812845766544342,
-0.4910055696964264,
0.6584784388542175,
-0.06636934727430344,
0.17952074110507965,
-0.4660223424434662,
0.34487593173980713,
0.13157466053962708,
0.014670290052890778,
-0.8747208118438721,
0.1109389141201973,
0.5208924412727356,
-0.24261032044887543,
-0.8229736089706421,
0.766994297504425,
-0.42053934931755066,
-0.33263063430786133,
0.0007806373760104179,
-0.3358410894870758,
-0.13965825736522675,
0.6831053495407104,
0.001961969304829836,
0.7069078683853149,
0.4085649251937866,
-0.1890304535627365,
0.4446021318435669,
0.11057721823453903,
-0.5504090189933777,
0.9162218570709229,
-0.9480558633804321,
-0.4803963005542755,
-0.4203229248523712,
-0.41143715381622314,
-1.1339977979660034,
-0.22420614957809448,
0.2522421181201935,
-0.23635903000831604,
0.15549056231975555,
0.033767469227313995,
-0.15168198943138123,
-0.6410098075866699,
-0.6252803206443787,
0.8060674071311951,
0.7268421053886414,
-0.4480918049812317,
0.6167362928390503,
0.04869668558239937,
-0.14936880767345428,
-0.5343676805496216,
-0.7296173572540283,
0.004393707029521465,
-0.2131786048412323,
-0.37022534012794495,
0.2911219894886017,
-0.14467984437942505,
-0.23692891001701355,
-0.13834047317504883,
-0.06994936615228653,
-0.2016679346561432,
-0.056930914521217346,
0.38741952180862427,
0.3122870624065399,
-0.3352321684360504,
0.00854488741606474,
-0.5496001839637756,
0.001822161371819675,
-0.39216116070747375,
0.025187309831380844,
0.39686018228530884,
-0.15021401643753052,
-0.8180286288261414,
0.020660877227783203,
0.1750166267156601,
0.953994870185852,
-0.7874060273170471,
0.5772833228111267,
0.24788227677345276,
-0.10790510475635529,
-0.5174387693405151,
-0.7161182165145874,
0.040470242500305176,
-0.5223973393440247,
0.5576611757278442,
-0.16793608665466309,
-0.8458839058876038,
0.6366671323776245,
0.448830783367157,
-0.33224722743034363,
0.453675776720047,
0.3943033218383789,
0.026646876707673073,
0.5961692929267883,
0.9633393287658691,
0.22682037949562073,
0.7024019956588745,
-0.06410646438598633,
0.19442881643772125,
-0.9043317437171936,
-0.26067957282066345,
-0.40600255131721497,
-0.4016108214855194,
-0.6025817394256592,
-0.3569576144218445,
0.7341263294219971,
-0.001168308313935995,
-0.624284565448761,
0.2734413743019104,
-0.5557832717895508,
0.6166881918907166,
0.6437947750091553,
-0.06308623403310776,
0.2460702508687973,
0.046732861548662186,
-0.3134065270423889,
-0.32262521982192993,
-0.6099953055381775,
0.24367362260818481,
1.1269885301589966,
0.5209656357765198,
0.5603771209716797,
0.0328001007437706,
0.06773494184017181,
0.24418038129806519,
0.3918861150741577,
-0.4641609787940979,
0.3461607098579407,
-0.4131929576396942,
-0.5955377221107483,
-0.18169263005256653,
-0.07000810652971268,
-0.6853859424591064,
0.5262631177902222,
-0.5217912793159485,
-0.8864624500274658,
0.5138488411903381,
0.23261475563049316,
-0.10608665645122528,
0.2709188163280487,
-0.650163471698761,
1.1954915523529053,
-0.4616883099079132,
-0.44608041644096375,
0.3354085385799408,
-0.2229631543159485,
0.7295279502868652,
-0.20295235514640808,
0.02102590911090374,
0.11495474725961685,
0.08013743162155151,
0.5489134788513184,
-0.229084312915802,
0.6178329586982727,
0.10527292639017105,
0.20903320610523224,
-0.034747883677482605,
0.0029325447976589203,
0.1931489109992981,
-0.545499324798584,
-0.0016195995267480612,
0.4690658450126648,
-0.2222667932510376,
-0.19737933576107025,
-0.6116138100624084,
0.36911270022392273,
-0.4278642535209656,
-0.39326515793800354,
-0.7034868001937866,
-0.5056289434432983,
-0.265666127204895,
0.42650240659713745,
0.22576503455638885,
0.35287854075431824,
-0.029150113463401794,
0.07098909467458725,
0.3266449570655823,
-0.5351582765579224,
0.6227539777755737,
0.8367741703987122,
-0.2806812524795532,
-0.5985316038131714,
1.103098750114441,
0.2214425802230835,
0.41166359186172485,
0.10086075961589813,
0.028178108856081963,
-0.029709849506616592,
-1.0301249027252197,
-0.21729803085327148,
0.5031227469444275,
-0.6646055579185486,
-0.099785216152668,
-0.4115538001060486,
-0.4581127464771271,
-0.009451606310904026,
0.019946003332734108,
-0.15543003380298615,
-0.17194391787052155,
0.17907609045505524,
0.09895877540111542,
0.13153237104415894,
0.7700517177581787,
0.12429016828536987,
0.19375403225421906,
-0.39214229583740234,
0.3894311785697937,
0.6644212007522583,
0.7009091377258301,
0.04619792848825455,
-0.37289708852767944,
0.10283499211072922,
-0.18434318900108337,
-0.36072590947151184,
-0.8388475775718689,
0.4096011817455292,
-0.2781292200088501,
0.4683570861816406,
0.38687101006507874,
-0.06970738619565964,
0.5005621314048767,
-0.768528938293457,
0.691425085067749,
0.5209421515464783,
-1.0167381763458252,
0.11518201977014542,
-0.3787335455417633,
0.5326951146125793,
0.4220517873764038,
0.3109363317489624,
-0.6598597168922424,
-0.6206714510917664,
-0.34123098850250244,
-0.7835156917572021,
0.6852075457572937,
0.3064880967140198,
-0.14242605865001678,
0.14546209573745728,
-0.05632353201508522,
-0.19671688973903656,
0.24370115995407104,
-0.9643933773040771,
-0.23634976148605347,
-0.5320639610290527,
-0.18850724399089813,
-0.14648708701133728,
-0.46670326590538025,
0.1471748650074005,
-0.12126707285642624,
0.03959963843226433,
-0.19718366861343384,
0.1587361842393875,
0.09215028584003448,
0.13685302436351776,
-0.017349643632769585,
0.25542163848876953,
1.0510491132736206,
0.6667510271072388,
-0.19023673236370087,
0.1611875593662262,
0.3794598877429962,
-0.5463242530822754,
-0.17224986851215363,
-0.23260065913200378,
-0.39999401569366455,
-0.07030599564313889,
0.9943516850471497,
0.7068564295768738,
-0.031543221324682236,
-0.7021922469139099,
1.0161328315734863,
-0.10525569319725037,
-0.23708367347717285,
-0.17175549268722534,
0.3423954248428345,
0.1393328458070755,
0.5037520527839661,
0.2110063135623932,
0.16105911135673523,
0.06831967830657959,
-0.6806996464729309,
0.1758601814508438,
0.9002485871315002,
-0.5744017362594604,
-0.3464992344379425,
0.8095332384109497,
0.3671899735927582,
-0.45603612065315247,
0.32722732424736023,
0.02786293998360634,
-0.9492596387863159,
0.7654168009757996,
0.31376582384109497,
0.8265782594680786,
-0.23459431529045105,
0.15735384821891785,
0.46466684341430664,
0.4905669093132019,
0.06295253336429596,
0.3284771740436554,
-0.19686707854270935,
-0.8501962423324585,
-0.07275344431400299,
-0.757224977016449,
-0.5167865753173828,
0.23869678378105164,
-0.4510307013988495,
0.3737752139568329,
-0.31856653094291687,
0.14714284241199493,
0.14305227994918823,
-0.5469029545783997,
-0.5942951440811157,
0.13225752115249634,
0.41439199447631836,
1.1516621112823486,
-1.1314713954925537,
0.5268168449401855,
0.08931291848421097,
-0.23694704473018646,
-0.7118126153945923,
0.0451904758810997,
-0.06793128699064255,
-0.8589757084846497,
1.33719801902771,
0.10437945276498795,
-0.10195573419332504,
-0.5000990033149719,
-0.24710847437381744,
-0.7162946462631226,
1.1527597904205322,
0.42225292325019836,
-0.7799709439277649,
0.20985837280750275,
0.41767334938049316,
0.608429491519928,
-0.1336975246667862,
0.5700616240501404,
0.35206517577171326,
0.6013195514678955,
0.5641703009605408,
-1.224886417388916,
-0.362371027469635,
-0.017687205225229263,
0.13647893071174622,
0.21710661053657532,
-0.8812546730041504,
1.2998425960540771,
-0.12001878768205643,
-0.4568060636520386,
-0.18228356540203094,
0.7057161331176758,
0.09114614129066467,
0.3237326145172119,
0.6725559830665588,
0.26533132791519165,
0.346956342458725,
-0.05625098571181297,
0.865431547164917,
-0.05140154808759689,
0.340495765209198,
0.8105261921882629,
-0.5297857522964478,
0.9439192414283752,
0.24817344546318054,
0.020963303744792938,
0.07012888789176941,
-0.35476917028427124,
-0.5414401888847351,
0.6651949286460876,
0.47559744119644165,
-0.09153294563293457,
-0.16951890289783478,
-0.13112469017505646,
-0.15231966972351074,
0.6790584921836853,
-0.11998043209314346,
-0.1778847575187683,
-0.2512233257293701,
0.1987471878528595,
-0.18560616672039032,
0.1284445971250534,
-0.5176163911819458,
0.3022385537624359,
-0.04522206261754036,
-0.7465001344680786,
0.5760533213615417,
-0.011800847947597504,
0.8752202987670898,
-0.680525004863739,
-0.29956233501434326,
-0.27194297313690186,
0.42830342054367065,
-0.15616433322429657,
-0.9537067413330078,
0.361392080783844,
0.017468955367803574,
0.053990695625543594,
-0.03212343156337738,
0.5059359073638916,
-0.21774037182331085,
-0.8399887084960938,
0.4641629755496979,
0.05366316810250282,
-0.2247774749994278,
0.08645983040332794,
-0.23171916604042053,
0.5950117111206055,
0.17093200981616974,
0.08379417657852173,
-0.12594738602638245,
0.28697359561920166,
-0.23331259191036224,
0.8466470837593079,
0.3321439325809479,
0.35060200095176697,
0.037341080605983734,
-0.17589730024337769,
0.5311108827590942,
-0.8975266814231873,
-0.382835328578949,
-0.9965866804122925,
0.4627181589603424,
-0.18745742738246918,
-0.26807478070259094,
0.8956272602081299,
0.4052818715572357,
0.8051097989082336,
-0.3265056312084198,
0.4969996213912964,
0.3617887496948242,
0.3847973644733429,
-0.4834040701389313,
0.9348135590553284,
-0.6931692361831665,
-0.10741844028234482,
-0.39593982696533203,
-0.9701616764068604,
-0.5878705978393555,
0.4325106739997864,
-0.21188999712467194,
0.10037558525800705,
0.8429702520370483,
0.8370507955551147,
-0.4505610764026642,
-0.07565397024154663,
0.695332407951355,
0.48826318979263306,
0.4777301549911499,
0.8097677230834961,
0.7601560950279236,
-0.22630268335342407,
0.5390340685844421,
0.00014475754869636148,
-0.15312020480632782,
-0.26050904393196106,
-1.0514813661575317,
-1.0855422019958496,
-0.4767567813396454,
-0.13878363370895386,
0.12896858155727386,
0.04570281133055687,
0.004748960491269827,
0.7328890562057495,
-0.891214907169342,
-0.0604415088891983,
-0.0034171058796346188,
0.17789386212825775,
0.0611635223031044,
-0.1450997292995453,
0.18123942613601685,
0.3772279918193817,
-0.508653998374939,
0.010219099000096321,
0.6354791522026062,
0.23998823761940002,
-0.4507776200771332,
0.15070229768753052,
0.2710372805595398,
0.21194840967655182,
0.45659202337265015,
0.640617311000824,
-0.6701543927192688,
-0.5820772051811218,
-0.044723816215991974,
0.06425675004720688,
-0.10065957903862,
0.5712849497795105,
-0.8355566263198853,
0.4538895785808563,
0.5220189690589905,
0.2684580683708191,
0.6743109822273254,
-0.20132644474506378,
0.4076862037181854,
-0.18104828894138336,
0.13548488914966583,
0.12060919404029846,
0.5517367124557495,
0.30236881971359253,
0.29816117882728577,
0.43103569746017456,
0.24956852197647095,
-0.19786688685417175,
-0.8942236304283142,
0.5834435820579529,
-1.1330509185791016,
-0.14962387084960938,
0.9712750315666199,
0.07544466853141785,
-0.48668304085731506,
0.050450630486011505,
-0.19042448699474335,
-0.3710854649543762,
0.09156306087970734,
0.2951202690601349,
0.5178860425949097,
0.08203300088644028,
-0.270186185836792,
-0.6199290752410889,
0.3160982131958008,
0.3933057188987732,
-0.534954309463501,
0.028060603886842728,
0.19332808256149292,
0.5917460322380066,
0.4830615520477295,
0.4513918161392212,
0.1843876987695694,
0.44952327013015747,
0.18555572628974915,
0.08574196696281433,
-0.6288011074066162,
-0.576788604259491,
-0.5243057012557983,
0.6006271243095398,
-0.011088982224464417,
-0.2736453711986542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13053v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13053v2
|
MeteoRA: Multiple-tasks Embedded LoRA for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-19T20:46:07 | 2024-05-24T13:38:54 |
Jingwei Xu, Junyu Lai, Yunpeng Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
The pretrain+fine-tune paradigm is foundational in deploying large language
models (LLMs) across a diverse range of downstream applications. Among these,
Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) stands out for its parameter-efficient fine-tuning
(PEFT), producing numerous off-the-shelf task-specific LoRA adapters. However,
this approach requires explicit task intention selection, posing challenges for
automatic task sensing and switching during inference with multiple existing
LoRA adapters embedded in a single LLM. In this work, we introduce MeteoRA
(Multiple-Tasks embedded LoRA), a scalable multi-knowledge LoRA fusion
framework designed for LLMs. MeteoRA integrates various LoRA adapters in a
Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) style into the base LLM, enabling the model to
automatically select the most pertinent adapter based on the task input. This
advancement significantly enhances the LLM's capability to handle composite
tasks that require different adapters to solve various components of the
problem. Our evaluations, featuring the LlaMA2-13B and LlaMA3-8B base models
equipped with off-the-shelf 28 LoRA adapters through MeteoRA, demonstrate
equivalent performance with the individual adapters. Furthermore, both base
models equipped with MeteoRA achieve superior performance in sequentially
solving composite tasks with ten problems in only a single inference process,
highlighting the ability of timely intention switching in MeteoRA embedded
LLMs.
|
[
-0.4007619023323059,
-0.6919744610786438,
0.7754096984863281,
0.4995270371437073,
-0.37279003858566284,
-0.21916650235652924,
-0.34983429312705994,
-0.38846370577812195,
0.21799466013908386,
0.4949728846549988,
-0.5613835453987122,
-0.4077555537223816,
-0.7060126066207886,
-0.11161042749881744,
-0.310204416513443,
0.677809476852417,
-0.07817315310239792,
-0.298107385635376,
-0.11003619432449341,
-0.12960103154182434,
-0.7458615303039551,
-0.08863981813192368,
-0.6443666219711304,
-0.26351606845855713,
0.8209923505783081,
0.5763599872589111,
0.3955567181110382,
0.21666686236858368,
0.283698171377182,
0.32212498784065247,
0.22732146084308624,
0.4049707353115082,
-0.4387603998184204,
0.05885297432541847,
-0.6532344222068787,
-0.494197279214859,
-0.6349553465843201,
-0.20235995948314667,
0.45866963267326355,
0.47822311520576477,
-0.14069800078868866,
0.40830177068710327,
0.1553635150194168,
0.3400665521621704,
-0.9563637375831604,
0.06790905445814133,
-0.8952373266220093,
-0.34984132647514343,
-0.3354748785495758,
-0.16728883981704712,
-0.428798645734787,
0.1728142946958542,
-0.20362542569637299,
-0.6632145643234253,
-0.3167225420475006,
0.05030591040849686,
0.33415520191192627,
0.8449135422706604,
-0.49017125368118286,
0.03480139747262001,
-0.7885233163833618,
0.8893824815750122,
-0.719148576259613,
0.37353038787841797,
0.09539307653903961,
0.3090306520462036,
-0.1693309247493744,
-0.3420258164405823,
-0.652541995048523,
0.31609269976615906,
0.269904762506485,
0.21921803057193756,
-0.12202651053667068,
-0.26530271768569946,
-0.11360122263431549,
-0.09281206876039505,
-0.3547218143939972,
0.6371496915817261,
0.014997518621385098,
0.1574411243200302,
0.3067322373390198,
0.12699759006500244,
0.03197372704744339,
-0.16310861706733704,
-0.0018176643643528223,
0.0942867174744606,
-0.8590742945671082,
-0.2707161009311676,
0.24723348021507263,
0.5763316750526428,
-0.1345459669828415,
0.4553064703941345,
-0.3620202839374542,
0.8199270963668823,
0.20585624873638153,
-0.1606704592704773,
0.19701983034610748,
-0.2820972800254822,
-0.24548086524009705,
0.05188922956585884,
0.8227745890617371,
-0.09919286519289017,
-0.2800838053226471,
0.026171818375587463,
-0.11660531163215637,
0.09943056851625443,
0.13358242809772491,
-0.6293399333953857,
0.10555221885442734,
0.36486154794692993,
-0.24654453992843628,
-0.0025426754727959633,
-0.5108818411827087,
-0.6290602087974548,
-0.4389653205871582,
-0.33232009410858154,
0.6766336560249329,
-0.1794099062681198,
-0.02413231134414673,
0.3487263023853302,
0.11798550188541412,
0.036339450627565384,
0.6412273049354553,
-0.869902491569519,
0.16126324236392975,
0.6915315389633179,
0.5492475032806396,
-0.25824883580207825,
-0.5762158036231995,
-0.7903016209602356,
0.20751304924488068,
0.026170983910560608,
1.0859920978546143,
-0.437503457069397,
-0.251827210187912,
-0.1797514408826828,
-0.07880135625600815,
-0.6694459319114685,
-0.3784541189670563,
0.4725756049156189,
-0.5467463731765747,
0.17175684869289398,
-0.07452715188264847,
-0.05544116348028183,
-0.2237885445356369,
0.2125772088766098,
-0.5061144232749939,
0.9934273958206177,
0.11536432802677155,
-0.5015169978141785,
0.27896663546562195,
-0.7421365976333618,
-0.4112832546234131,
-0.16238775849342346,
-0.05681045725941658,
-0.23391814529895782,
0.25494253635406494,
0.32899466156959534,
0.48699912428855896,
-0.5377469062805176,
0.07378328591585159,
-0.2916348874568939,
-0.2831653356552124,
-0.11897475272417068,
-0.20301440358161926,
0.3989968001842499,
0.03378000482916832,
-0.4707203209400177,
0.4160774052143097,
-0.6312900185585022,
-0.19993500411510468,
0.0018436413956806064,
-0.5143713355064392,
-0.3061365485191345,
0.4279903471469879,
0.14616112411022186,
0.46553170680999756,
0.6218908429145813,
-0.4833584725856781,
0.13073359429836273,
-0.1443096101284027,
0.14379337430000305,
0.8048584461212158,
-0.15871256589889526,
0.17330239713191986,
-0.2784363329410553,
0.30570462346076965,
0.17523322999477386,
0.18729881942272186,
0.2843919098377228,
-0.5441232323646545,
-1.0233409404754639,
-0.303840696811676,
0.0743069127202034,
0.6113295555114746,
-0.6876706480979919,
0.66526859998703,
-0.4996422827243805,
-0.6015851497650146,
-0.48226919770240784,
0.47325071692466736,
0.26430147886276245,
0.3185233175754547,
0.31075337529182434,
-0.19368676841259003,
-0.38532260060310364,
-0.8675956130027771,
-0.31116998195648193,
0.10607020556926727,
0.18605268001556396,
0.4138557016849518,
0.4526739716529846,
-0.3799424171447754,
0.9355890154838562,
-0.3369346559047699,
-0.4820595979690552,
-0.35924679040908813,
-0.12710939347743988,
0.638279139995575,
0.5035287737846375,
0.6815398335456848,
-0.5314770340919495,
-0.55204838514328,
0.3180399537086487,
-0.5605211853981018,
0.08524749428033829,
-0.13086017966270447,
-0.2744581699371338,
-0.07773952931165695,
0.16970278322696686,
-0.6620056629180908,
0.009591907262802124,
0.9484421610832214,
-0.45772871375083923,
0.31926441192626953,
-0.22224479913711548,
0.14911098778247833,
-1.244361400604248,
0.2764970660209656,
-0.1458149403333664,
-0.3129775822162628,
-0.5547012686729431,
-0.02007920667529106,
-0.0966728925704956,
0.17411218583583832,
-0.6218734979629517,
0.8403464555740356,
-0.11592204123735428,
-0.16317512094974518,
-0.45591020584106445,
0.18787415325641632,
-0.09654560685157776,
0.5098970532417297,
0.010213145054876804,
0.7251217365264893,
0.603469729423523,
-0.7244032621383667,
0.011690285988152027,
0.47281011939048767,
-0.46319711208343506,
0.5828664302825928,
-0.3862519860267639,
0.3808458149433136,
-0.03145755082368851,
0.14988449215888977,
-0.5363684892654419,
-0.1947002410888672,
0.24125467240810394,
0.16548097133636475,
-0.17355632781982422,
-0.19133570790290833,
-0.6624391078948975,
-0.1458871066570282,
-0.027796568349003792,
0.4496399164199829,
0.5766233801841736,
-0.5764324069023132,
1.0403356552124023,
0.25117549300193787,
-0.3209898769855499,
-0.47620248794555664,
-0.32764601707458496,
-0.07583837956190109,
-0.2850611209869385,
-0.3080027401447296,
0.3079729974269867,
-0.18526501953601837,
-0.07113798707723618,
-0.1110319048166275,
-0.09159819036722183,
0.008589938282966614,
0.3330956697463989,
0.4534042775630951,
0.14871300756931305,
-0.28586119413375854,
-0.22065454721450806,
0.46360164880752563,
-0.07053639739751816,
-0.2893046736717224,
-0.19406916201114655,
0.7560653686523438,
0.15000078082084656,
-0.7105556726455688,
-0.46626901626586914,
0.066011443734169,
0.7684258818626404,
-0.2953859269618988,
0.9197900295257568,
0.5433472394943237,
-0.2857382893562317,
-0.25028517842292786,
-0.7000605463981628,
0.0035307034850120544,
-0.4691896140575409,
0.4559372067451477,
-0.618940532207489,
-0.6399537324905396,
0.5670287013053894,
-0.21707643568515778,
0.2628594934940338,
0.5803419351577759,
0.6296021342277527,
0.005789987742900848,
0.6694128513336182,
0.4250330328941345,
-0.3577345311641693,
0.6484777331352234,
-0.009179752320051193,
0.11777868121862411,
-1.0855491161346436,
-0.02834155596792698,
-0.610484778881073,
-0.523553729057312,
-0.10062555968761444,
-0.7380234003067017,
0.4900006651878357,
-0.006538404617458582,
-0.08099687844514847,
0.48305246233940125,
-0.20611940324306488,
0.3788944184780121,
0.4995518922805786,
0.2672307789325714,
0.4346795082092285,
-0.26670965552330017,
0.5214955806732178,
0.37124788761138916,
-0.8906276226043701,
-0.17966538667678833,
1.1053177118301392,
0.10370933264493942,
0.6942126154899597,
0.26726457476615906,
0.7541000843048096,
-0.032589320093393326,
0.24864821135997772,
-0.6182603240013123,
0.5933964848518372,
-0.5934194326400757,
-0.5899810791015625,
-0.34513887763023376,
-0.13415144383907318,
-0.9009336829185486,
0.5728698372840881,
-0.2925434708595276,
-0.827241063117981,
0.3847043216228485,
0.3527618944644928,
-0.49021029472351074,
0.164078027009964,
-0.46615463495254517,
0.8539697527885437,
-0.2234724909067154,
-0.24105891585350037,
-0.8144827485084534,
-0.12722890079021454,
0.4202481508255005,
-0.6618618965148926,
0.47633999586105347,
-0.4189213812351227,
0.04243702068924904,
0.9319758415222168,
0.13044524192810059,
1.1278774738311768,
-0.22755949199199677,
-0.25669512152671814,
0.02449079602956772,
-0.04198729991912842,
0.7757020592689514,
-0.06828711926937103,
-0.31586071848869324,
-0.0022292183712124825,
-0.13412517309188843,
-0.30600038170814514,
-0.48860350251197815,
1.096130132675171,
-0.7620649933815002,
-0.6822314858436584,
-0.1368679702281952,
-0.8319957852363586,
-0.5183115601539612,
0.4399780035018921,
-0.075857974588871,
0.3247062861919403,
-0.2652246057987213,
0.15743014216423035,
0.4573541581630707,
-0.13177774846553802,
0.34242135286331177,
0.661627471446991,
-0.19731292128562927,
-0.07496564090251923,
1.0089472532272339,
-0.1878238171339035,
0.17512758076190948,
0.5080263018608093,
0.09730039536952972,
0.04121265932917595,
-0.9605823159217834,
-0.4033163785934448,
0.20832760632038116,
-0.6974338293075562,
0.05535747855901718,
-0.5964962840080261,
0.209119975566864,
-0.23772147297859192,
-0.1383611410856247,
-0.7059541940689087,
-0.25673186779022217,
-0.5866498351097107,
0.4378359913825989,
0.21603082120418549,
0.7252671122550964,
0.3134540021419525,
0.4995293617248535,
-0.8144457936286926,
0.5421012043952942,
0.33158862590789795,
0.1526455134153366,
-0.24227958917617798,
-0.5447709560394287,
-0.25541144609451294,
-0.16407597064971924,
-0.0637333020567894,
-0.43828824162483215,
0.11155194789171219,
0.3365533947944641,
0.6362565755844116,
0.3731929063796997,
-0.09304187446832657,
0.6408895254135132,
-0.6648011803627014,
0.4274391531944275,
0.09389694780111313,
-0.849289059638977,
0.3731805384159088,
-0.5758826732635498,
0.5806892514228821,
0.7689993381500244,
0.15863703191280365,
-0.32617315649986267,
-0.15392625331878662,
-0.2318040430545807,
-0.5903337597846985,
0.6982449889183044,
-0.07043082267045975,
0.051512762904167175,
0.09027548134326935,
0.08963379263877869,
0.44623371958732605,
0.12560215592384338,
-0.42951852083206177,
-0.09184447675943375,
-0.07182374596595764,
-0.3628317713737488,
-0.5239853262901306,
-0.0013739978894591331,
-0.3471603989601135,
-0.0679873377084732,
0.698316216468811,
-0.5860902070999146,
0.1240914836525917,
-0.27527812123298645,
-0.45372697710990906,
0.0309281088411808,
0.4797559380531311,
0.5557934641838074,
0.8544492721557617,
-0.11268845200538635,
0.08374632149934769,
0.44105324149131775,
-0.14937825500965118,
-0.15217699110507965,
0.32128453254699707,
0.03054647520184517,
-0.21872550249099731,
0.30006182193756104,
0.9779849052429199,
0.9436686635017395,
-0.7416549324989319,
0.14626337587833405,
0.23075111210346222,
0.006814789026975632,
-0.04397996515035629,
0.35961589217185974,
0.24924641847610474,
0.3388333022594452,
0.19016431272029877,
0.3398101329803467,
-0.10724759101867676,
-0.6528868079185486,
-0.19860106706619263,
0.4877855181694031,
-0.11276337504386902,
-0.5220831632614136,
0.4823543131351471,
0.4590100049972534,
-0.08297505229711533,
0.20676112174987793,
0.12359035015106201,
-0.3056800067424774,
0.3291306793689728,
0.5573282241821289,
0.5496528148651123,
-0.3180451989173889,
-0.009266166016459465,
0.06889037042856216,
0.1260358840227127,
-0.13700367510318756,
0.4250295162200928,
0.0683961883187294,
-0.8815575838088989,
-0.496881902217865,
-0.7201959490776062,
-0.30705976486206055,
-0.14340631663799286,
-0.41964200139045715,
0.15711116790771484,
-0.34516504406929016,
-0.02258361130952835,
-0.019816085696220398,
-0.37062668800354004,
-0.8764970302581787,
0.021551040932536125,
0.049412962049245834,
0.8829299807548523,
-0.8193304538726807,
1.0401849746704102,
0.5837365984916687,
0.03711312264204025,
-0.447213351726532,
-0.2665270268917084,
-0.10723940283060074,
-0.8205187916755676,
0.6799188256263733,
-0.23266786336898804,
-0.20811913907527924,
0.3255275785923004,
0.06939142942428589,
-1.0812976360321045,
1.2359402179718018,
0.4729328453540802,
-0.6260330080986023,
-0.18862560391426086,
-0.016126008704304695,
0.014472897164523602,
-0.3321365714073181,
0.10666832327842712,
0.6897357702255249,
0.5797918438911438,
-0.04242679476737976,
-1.395987629890442,
0.11592690646648407,
0.0998864695429802,
-0.4366075396537781,
0.2657041847705841,
-0.7573460340499878,
0.823936402797699,
0.048676200211048126,
0.10905440896749496,
0.11471185833215714,
0.48103952407836914,
0.6020773649215698,
0.010012641549110413,
0.8372204899787903,
0.44764500856399536,
0.5221246480941772,
0.11082132905721664,
0.9484849572181702,
-0.36685121059417725,
0.1673738956451416,
1.2337323427200317,
-0.559161901473999,
1.251995325088501,
0.7477795481681824,
-0.08376374840736389,
0.7036790251731873,
0.38014841079711914,
0.4150165915489197,
0.6292035579681396,
-0.32542771100997925,
-0.31923922896385193,
-0.6480202674865723,
-0.12071844935417175,
-0.23807349801063538,
0.5928184986114502,
0.4743986427783966,
-0.039227697998285294,
-0.3617827594280243,
0.08683212101459503,
-0.17141513526439667,
-0.31513315439224243,
-0.3661530613899231,
0.6870743036270142,
0.14881809055805206,
-0.8333994746208191,
0.2668013870716095,
-0.010092183016240597,
0.7880685329437256,
-0.7787037491798401,
0.19175274670124054,
0.10055294632911682,
0.37241262197494507,
-0.30673670768737793,
-0.4424031972885132,
-0.01050895918160677,
-0.29072532057762146,
-0.20569393038749695,
-0.11609837412834167,
0.6808850169181824,
-0.209977924823761,
-0.36854609847068787,
0.23426735401153564,
0.6589422225952148,
-0.04645650088787079,
-0.3680093586444855,
-0.4049459397792816,
0.3276377320289612,
-0.18182705342769623,
-0.3127084970474243,
0.7039362788200378,
0.012607455253601074,
-0.15000376105308533,
0.7622098326683044,
0.7662960290908813,
0.052251268178224564,
0.2459760457277298,
0.09045133739709854,
1.0042611360549927,
-0.403464138507843,
-0.5458947420120239,
-0.3849448561668396,
0.5334399938583374,
0.13264396786689758,
-0.2909855842590332,
0.8094491958618164,
0.4911002814769745,
0.3059237599372864,
-0.3170856535434723,
0.7141140699386597,
-0.16746030747890472,
0.3331620693206787,
-0.8282238841056824,
0.5833974480628967,
-0.5314710140228271,
0.12422385811805725,
-0.10675863921642303,
-1.211082100868225,
-0.04143117368221283,
0.21351365745067596,
-0.5533976554870605,
-0.0969136655330658,
0.7970485687255859,
0.41927263140678406,
-0.5460914969444275,
-0.37616050243377686,
0.30874642729759216,
0.1997765749692917,
0.3336738348007202,
0.7989968061447144,
0.4925525486469269,
-0.3675646483898163,
0.1937951296567917,
0.01660650409758091,
-0.12450195848941803,
-0.431278258562088,
-0.834866464138031,
-0.9146139621734619,
-0.5276917219161987,
-0.3572346866130829,
0.15048043429851532,
0.10192742943763733,
0.8767679929733276,
0.9801459312438965,
-0.859052300453186,
-0.18359920382499695,
0.0532897487282753,
0.08457066863775253,
-0.2739678621292114,
-0.09135504066944122,
0.3335886001586914,
-0.2306402027606964,
-0.9736430644989014,
1.1486996412277222,
0.24379415810108185,
-0.35329753160476685,
-0.20198890566825867,
-0.1436888426542282,
-0.26451975107192993,
0.14837485551834106,
0.6182587742805481,
0.361601322889328,
-0.7425445318222046,
-0.46157506108283997,
-0.4803231358528137,
0.15161378681659698,
-0.1820051223039627,
0.6641745567321777,
-0.9150927662849426,
0.04637690633535385,
0.46439504623413086,
0.7408593893051147,
0.5370321869850159,
-0.058561813086271286,
0.4800471067428589,
-0.49335819482803345,
0.31946423649787903,
-0.0049940296448767185,
0.6134039163589478,
-0.0387883186340332,
-0.21144703030586243,
0.11208605766296387,
-0.00392313115298748,
-0.4448317289352417,
-0.7778539657592773,
0.18917246162891388,
-1.2256815433502197,
-0.2848800718784332,
1.14076566696167,
0.08618544042110443,
-0.1892763376235962,
-0.18747706711292267,
-0.06654670834541321,
-0.08406837284564972,
-0.2845694124698639,
0.5908705592155457,
0.34861913323402405,
-0.18230308592319489,
-0.1614433377981186,
-0.5252178907394409,
0.18265126645565033,
0.6491639018058777,
-1.317075252532959,
-0.13584880530834198,
0.25480642914772034,
0.4095083475112915,
0.27121487259864807,
0.5533226728439331,
0.35460177063941956,
0.33983638882637024,
-0.18664418160915375,
0.07501350343227386,
-0.13887901604175568,
-0.396311491727829,
-0.13111931085586548,
0.19518017768859863,
0.3453679084777832,
-0.18877458572387695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13052v1
|
Large Language Models Can Infer Personality from Free-Form User Interactions
| 2024-05-19T20:33:36 | 2024-05-19T20:33:36 |
Heinrich Peters, Moran Cerf, Sandra C. Matz
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
This study investigates the capacity of Large Language Models (LLMs) to infer
the Big Five personality traits from free-form user interactions. The results
demonstrate that a chatbot powered by GPT-4 can infer personality with moderate
accuracy, outperforming previous approaches drawing inferences from static text
content. The accuracy of inferences varied across different conversational
settings. Performance was highest when the chatbot was prompted to elicit
personality-relevant information from users (mean r=.443, range=[.245, .640]),
followed by a condition placing greater emphasis on naturalistic interaction
(mean r=.218, range=[.066, .373]). Notably, the direct focus on personality
assessment did not result in a less positive user experience, with participants
reporting the interactions to be equally natural, pleasant, engaging, and
humanlike across both conditions. A chatbot mimicking ChatGPT's default
behavior of acting as a helpful assistant led to markedly inferior personality
inferences and lower user experience ratings but still captured psychologically
meaningful information for some of the personality traits (mean r=.117,
range=[-.004, .209]). Preliminary analyses suggest that the accuracy of
personality inferences varies only marginally across different
socio-demographic subgroups. Our results highlight the potential of LLMs for
psychological profiling based on conversational interactions. We discuss
practical implications and ethical challenges associated with these findings.
|
[
-0.372322142124176,
-0.5304984450340271,
0.9806782007217407,
0.49403512477874756,
0.06977140158414841,
-0.010091659612953663,
-0.5381960272789001,
-0.655747652053833,
0.05465658754110336,
0.44148537516593933,
-0.566713273525238,
-0.16258995234966278,
-0.5200173258781433,
0.034953560680150986,
-0.3090305030345917,
0.9936997294425964,
0.5596447587013245,
0.09380639344453812,
-0.4099506139755249,
0.07082080841064453,
-0.40820834040641785,
-1.1121244430541992,
-0.7294672727584839,
-0.5842458009719849,
0.8399084210395813,
0.2293938398361206,
0.8026642799377441,
-0.06182166188955307,
0.25640469789505005,
0.3249116539955139,
-0.02026590146124363,
-0.009120840579271317,
-0.5484328866004944,
0.13013723492622375,
-0.2485184520483017,
-0.43388137221336365,
-0.5455806851387024,
0.26357486844062805,
0.4075250029563904,
0.5413900017738342,
-0.06494594365358353,
-0.040962111204862595,
0.03839348629117012,
0.5276155471801758,
-0.4124400019645691,
0.29864442348480225,
-0.5415099859237671,
-0.32379403710365295,
-0.18953172862529755,
0.1376149207353592,
-0.6352394819259644,
-0.3244718611240387,
0.25575071573257446,
-0.2875044643878937,
0.03076872043311596,
-0.08988982439041138,
0.8651148676872253,
0.08649315685033798,
-0.6545302271842957,
-0.3558955192565918,
-1.0735785961151123,
0.8175367712974548,
-0.7537736892700195,
0.3212772011756897,
0.8255219459533691,
0.42937204241752625,
-0.22429299354553223,
-0.19002844393253326,
-0.881746232509613,
-0.4316697418689728,
-0.28434309363365173,
-0.041959114372730255,
-0.2794390916824341,
0.08722809702157974,
0.5107800364494324,
0.33913764357566833,
-0.362247496843338,
0.2976444363594055,
-0.21562516689300537,
-0.10863076895475388,
0.8596689701080322,
0.0980258584022522,
0.28839510679244995,
-0.19029021263122559,
0.29533177614212036,
-0.15708042681217194,
-0.6392044425010681,
0.18336857855319977,
0.6792280673980713,
0.04744812473654747,
-0.2723354995250702,
0.5554035902023315,
0.06106853112578392,
0.20960262417793274,
0.2663583755493164,
-0.2529546022415161,
0.1923113763332367,
-0.09695585072040558,
-0.08906754851341248,
-0.37664806842803955,
1.0875771045684814,
0.461541086435318,
1.0898545980453491,
-0.12992779910564423,
0.09378013014793396,
-0.07311739027500153,
0.25788548588752747,
-0.9471964240074158,
-0.48106297850608826,
0.3577946722507477,
-0.2628440856933594,
-0.04644621163606644,
0.1987503618001938,
-0.8689131736755371,
-0.7534780502319336,
-0.09526930004358292,
0.05717790126800537,
-0.6089257001876831,
-0.2618998885154724,
-0.24691197276115417,
-0.0462881401181221,
0.41034117341041565,
0.28818124532699585,
-1.2821155786514282,
0.28191450238227844,
0.4732830226421356,
0.8426024913787842,
-0.12387159466743469,
-0.10083404928445816,
-0.49049314856529236,
-0.003482760628685355,
-0.19653639197349548,
0.7003540992736816,
-0.7013765573501587,
-0.5753833651542664,
-0.18902069330215454,
-0.11221528053283691,
0.10938496887683868,
-0.3769114017486572,
0.37132230401039124,
-0.37108007073402405,
0.3803965449333191,
-0.32319727540016174,
-0.5227199196815491,
-0.05349138006567955,
-0.12858450412750244,
-0.5009805560112,
0.7882480025291443,
0.28642651438713074,
-0.5832053422927856,
0.3336418867111206,
-0.5951681137084961,
-0.2691636383533478,
0.1275782436132431,
-0.3488211929798126,
-0.2298460602760315,
0.16023722290992737,
0.053599219769239426,
0.8244817852973938,
0.02854311279952526,
0.23883631825447083,
-0.7400955557823181,
-0.16370905935764313,
0.7908403873443604,
-0.30674195289611816,
0.6163903474807739,
-0.18276450037956238,
-0.18076175451278687,
0.21942824125289917,
-0.7303853631019592,
-0.04802468791604042,
0.12489243596792221,
-0.23231011629104614,
-0.27756842970848083,
0.16256201267242432,
-0.08859880268573761,
0.3814195394515991,
0.1696605086326599,
-0.8576876521110535,
0.10633359849452972,
-0.265747606754303,
0.3448294699192047,
0.7953130602836609,
-0.23055191338062286,
0.3349718451499939,
-0.20830433070659637,
0.3334421217441559,
-0.20784905552864075,
-0.06156190112233162,
0.1077471449971199,
-0.6251046061515808,
-0.4617471992969513,
-0.6925956606864929,
-0.13332206010818481,
0.5343595743179321,
-0.2367718666791916,
0.655078649520874,
-0.3567264676094055,
-0.7412761449813843,
-0.21615105867385864,
0.19788409769535065,
0.45223310589790344,
0.1520642191171646,
0.12735627591609955,
-0.25768840312957764,
-0.3813698887825012,
-0.879510760307312,
-0.2514648139476776,
-0.2233598381280899,
-0.6763879656791687,
0.8006582260131836,
0.41936182975769043,
-0.1715688407421112,
1.0964478254318237,
-0.3095270097255707,
0.09569460153579712,
-0.4660792648792267,
-0.1370345950126648,
0.18679526448249817,
0.12515462934970856,
0.791762113571167,
-0.5194547176361084,
-0.49474599957466125,
-0.0631539598107338,
-0.6593084335327148,
-0.24439577758312225,
0.04643648862838745,
0.08286775648593903,
0.19696107506752014,
0.10404864698648453,
-0.8447428345680237,
0.29380178451538086,
0.7914950847625732,
-0.5793683528900146,
0.6781917214393616,
-0.20343653857707977,
-0.15428578853607178,
-0.8631788492202759,
0.24836528301239014,
0.23678942024707794,
-0.1424885243177414,
-0.6887698769569397,
-0.36525145173072815,
0.028049416840076447,
0.07242587953805923,
-0.04202260822057724,
0.9356046915054321,
-0.18878445029258728,
-0.21598444879055023,
-0.17173407971858978,
0.04765184968709946,
-0.2373398095369339,
0.4338519871234894,
0.019155355170369148,
0.9542984962463379,
0.16085191071033478,
-0.45125868916511536,
0.27042481303215027,
0.32506340742111206,
-0.2928788661956787,
0.8586137890815735,
-0.8041565418243408,
0.49531885981559753,
-0.1251390427350998,
0.5672805309295654,
-1.2680070400238037,
-0.7247797250747681,
-0.08104810863733292,
-0.6085861325263977,
-0.07648071646690369,
-0.07929930835962296,
-0.587387204170227,
-0.284505158662796,
-0.13705118000507355,
-0.31025436520576477,
0.5870208144187927,
-0.22293812036514282,
0.7006401419639587,
0.18872962892055511,
-0.43277183175086975,
-0.05085154250264168,
-0.6494543552398682,
0.08197161555290222,
-0.28712108731269836,
-0.6321830153465271,
0.0019845895003527403,
-0.3620437681674957,
-0.36555200815200806,
-0.6248205900192261,
0.3190052807331085,
-0.013470631092786789,
0.0185843612998724,
0.603472113609314,
0.41205501556396484,
0.07351075112819672,
0.11644770205020905,
-0.4301595091819763,
0.07666493207216263,
0.1265057921409607,
0.32611969113349915,
0.870539665222168,
-0.33050256967544556,
-0.2469271868467331,
-0.7077560424804688,
0.2583470344543457,
0.8758992552757263,
-0.10650010406970978,
1.021371603012085,
0.5757054090499878,
-0.0037945604417473078,
0.15559162199497223,
-0.6824334263801575,
-0.47333958745002747,
-0.4958363473415375,
0.24916434288024902,
-0.45146968960762024,
-1.0661135911941528,
0.7700372934341431,
0.37783586978912354,
0.14354433119297028,
0.09133411198854446,
0.7397778630256653,
-0.24628202617168427,
1.2167859077453613,
0.5856258869171143,
-0.05482352524995804,
0.6997200846672058,
0.3687150478363037,
0.47118502855300903,
-0.8587974309921265,
-0.25058627128601074,
-0.39286717772483826,
-0.3842739760875702,
-0.864987313747406,
0.037103693932294846,
0.0635257288813591,
-0.346340149641037,
-0.5846119523048401,
0.01774861104786396,
-0.11141826212406158,
0.33339107036590576,
0.45971378684043884,
0.22106841206550598,
0.2723707854747772,
-0.10975300520658493,
0.08891274034976959,
-0.21281766891479492,
0.015684625133872032,
-0.7404465675354004,
1.1346122026443481,
0.5221284627914429,
0.7299318909645081,
0.47794392704963684,
0.32109448313713074,
0.15119700133800507,
0.6864128708839417,
-0.806027889251709,
0.7043680548667908,
-0.16850809752941132,
-0.7536073327064514,
-0.40531352162361145,
-0.5195146203041077,
-0.8071848154067993,
0.0529659129679203,
-0.19577986001968384,
-1.5241280794143677,
-0.05304662138223648,
0.3002472519874573,
-0.42217135429382324,
0.05590301752090454,
-0.9700289964675903,
0.5569396615028381,
-0.2549050450325012,
-0.29393550753593445,
-0.14657603204250336,
-0.7368856072425842,
0.43961673974990845,
-0.13426552712917328,
0.028708726167678833,
-0.3707486391067505,
0.27245664596557617,
0.5613616108894348,
-0.14940711855888367,
1.2090778350830078,
-0.20308531820774078,
-0.28796735405921936,
-0.15622182190418243,
0.27233052253723145,
0.42302384972572327,
-0.13137774169445038,
-0.25413358211517334,
0.2241409420967102,
0.24380770325660706,
-0.37555044889450073,
-0.8695241212844849,
0.6565085649490356,
-1.2133997678756714,
-0.4518130421638489,
-0.19907113909721375,
-0.4493475556373596,
-0.6342996954917908,
0.1306101679801941,
-0.13791003823280334,
0.11639389395713806,
-0.28222575783729553,
0.581989049911499,
0.42919284105300903,
-0.3351055383682251,
0.2952456474304199,
0.5982354879379272,
-0.3824511468410492,
-0.28231027722358704,
0.7474818825721741,
-0.19696161150932312,
0.47946611046791077,
0.140173077583313,
0.528070330619812,
-0.2920036315917969,
-0.16653867065906525,
-0.18541395664215088,
0.6613383293151855,
-0.5365683436393738,
0.4002811014652252,
-0.6765065789222717,
-0.08302684873342514,
-0.36189010739326477,
-0.08120978623628616,
-0.31344160437583923,
-0.0029018085915595293,
-0.023214805871248245,
0.01926426962018013,
0.4150901436805725,
0.748827338218689,
0.34366267919540405,
0.7693332433700562,
-0.5712324380874634,
-0.01686953566968441,
0.424166738986969,
0.3695203959941864,
0.13289083540439606,
-0.5229791402816772,
0.24917027354240417,
0.08190330117940903,
-0.4529936611652374,
-0.9296347498893738,
0.33910542726516724,
0.2658311426639557,
0.47811850905418396,
0.7775642275810242,
-0.40427687764167786,
0.34824904799461365,
-0.16053836047649384,
0.9038269519805908,
0.03544450178742409,
-0.7593384981155396,
0.30385106801986694,
-0.7206497192382812,
0.1708219200372696,
0.35473892092704773,
0.5624532699584961,
-0.8307415246963501,
-0.28893202543258667,
-0.7665492296218872,
-0.34213772416114807,
0.5022174715995789,
0.2588875889778137,
0.473514586687088,
-0.2046888768672943,
0.4157102406024933,
0.03235546499490738,
0.2274303436279297,
-0.8684744834899902,
0.025740571320056915,
-0.2011413425207138,
-0.262458473443985,
-0.27022919058799744,
-0.2853538393974304,
0.08839240670204163,
-0.1572592556476593,
0.35719895362854004,
-0.39440757036209106,
0.5973061323165894,
-0.07342129200696945,
0.34559598565101624,
0.1355276107788086,
0.29153403639793396,
0.645989179611206,
0.6682871580123901,
-0.31334787607192993,
0.10915938764810562,
0.07808186858892441,
-0.4615055322647095,
-0.06752569228410721,
-0.14652754366397858,
0.34872686862945557,
-0.3662278950214386,
0.3113234043121338,
0.6043775081634521,
0.14977635443210602,
-0.8765136003494263,
0.6760000586509705,
-0.23678959906101227,
-0.2027798742055893,
-0.4244960844516754,
0.23880667984485626,
0.43518510460853577,
0.3187454640865326,
0.18421603739261627,
-0.430932879447937,
-0.34706634283065796,
-0.708661675453186,
-0.06561718881130219,
0.6735997796058655,
-0.3068479895591736,
-0.6790708899497986,
0.38055112957954407,
0.2828039526939392,
-0.3679695129394531,
0.8839616179466248,
-0.08493680506944656,
-0.23920570313930511,
0.2787661850452423,
0.47146883606910706,
0.8444658517837524,
-0.403168648481369,
0.1252017319202423,
0.19110029935836792,
-0.26075270771980286,
0.20815147459506989,
0.2987147867679596,
-0.032300468534231186,
-1.050256609916687,
-0.47642457485198975,
-0.6733764410018921,
-0.7893663048744202,
0.4847060739994049,
-0.17790143191814423,
0.01744718849658966,
-0.6862872838973999,
-0.20139285922050476,
0.1476193070411682,
0.06584503501653671,
-0.8607811331748962,
-0.06440559774637222,
0.33731988072395325,
0.33681100606918335,
-0.7850496768951416,
0.707874596118927,
0.6524174213409424,
-0.3751656413078308,
-0.7167069315910339,
-0.09168586879968643,
0.29155367612838745,
-0.9007965922355652,
0.6993610858917236,
0.2263297736644745,
-0.0975998193025589,
-0.1205548644065857,
-0.6307149529457092,
-0.7101012468338013,
0.9172365069389343,
0.40858036279678345,
-0.38576841354370117,
-0.3024899959564209,
0.12488149106502533,
0.7688761353492737,
-0.1666342169046402,
0.7356449365615845,
0.5085028409957886,
0.4198959767818451,
0.28158092498779297,
-1.3035688400268555,
0.08958785980939865,
-0.18175633251667023,
-0.07195360958576202,
-0.027741191908717155,
-0.8483443260192871,
0.5868099927902222,
-0.19292554259300232,
-0.012401009909808636,
0.13954994082450867,
0.5958362221717834,
0.35229793190956116,
-0.04253826290369034,
0.4455617666244507,
0.16136085987091064,
0.9758983254432678,
0.1517607569694519,
1.1348860263824463,
-0.3375314772129059,
0.09230461716651917,
1.0741044282913208,
-0.45506080985069275,
0.8557092547416687,
0.47879356145858765,
-0.2859880328178406,
0.8532404899597168,
0.395217627286911,
0.006206808146089315,
0.17193017899990082,
0.03641510009765625,
-0.40304332971572876,
-0.19523495435714722,
0.1099143922328949,
0.29222649335861206,
0.8045058846473694,
0.6190844178199768,
-0.4800615906715393,
0.05826113373041153,
-0.028073405846953392,
0.5272114276885986,
-0.2004036158323288,
0.24980638921260834,
0.7663701176643372,
0.0009690549923107028,
-0.7638429403305054,
0.09784351289272308,
-0.1453986018896103,
0.8535462617874146,
-0.7264530062675476,
0.18844778835773468,
-0.28849124908447266,
0.4198175072669983,
-0.26116126775741577,
-1.0197625160217285,
0.18173857033252716,
0.039411645382642746,
-0.07707418501377106,
-0.2814667820930481,
0.7191503643989563,
0.007438642904162407,
-0.1715477705001831,
0.16023176908493042,
0.7286505103111267,
0.5025268197059631,
-0.5040134787559509,
-0.06708388030529022,
-0.3014058470726013,
-0.12099861353635788,
-0.4710366725921631,
0.6479792594909668,
0.30958718061447144,
-0.32638710737228394,
0.9407109022140503,
0.8609375357627869,
0.011981461197137833,
-0.24834492802619934,
0.12375278770923615,
0.548312246799469,
-0.7147598266601562,
-0.40947622060775757,
-1.2376629114151,
0.22759400308132172,
-0.3365726172924042,
-0.4363391697406769,
0.7246196866035461,
0.15090900659561157,
0.5157524347305298,
-0.07619446516036987,
0.9284986853599548,
-0.13123172521591187,
0.5218477845191956,
-0.15204337239265442,
0.6480746865272522,
-0.13782767951488495,
-0.10724624246358871,
-0.40619632601737976,
-0.7230967283248901,
0.002186160534620285,
0.6029217839241028,
-0.832499623298645,
0.50188148021698,
0.4187835454940796,
0.780604898929596,
0.04678685963153839,
0.04786107316613197,
0.5631172060966492,
0.2402694970369339,
0.8645522594451904,
0.5341022610664368,
0.5151944160461426,
0.3892381191253662,
0.3526846766471863,
-0.03822169452905655,
-0.4522639214992523,
-0.29717808961868286,
-0.8190023899078369,
-1.4706252813339233,
-0.3752415180206299,
0.17239701747894287,
-0.33070194721221924,
-0.27428412437438965,
0.9447861909866333,
0.7318539619445801,
-0.4246232807636261,
-0.11535201221704483,
0.11899169534444809,
-0.20786844193935394,
0.11884842813014984,
-0.2828753888607025,
0.05469706282019615,
0.05334360525012016,
-0.7210209965705872,
0.04441564902663231,
0.132350355386734,
0.1306278556585312,
-0.6573114395141602,
0.015558939427137375,
0.0679807960987091,
0.3231591582298279,
0.932891845703125,
0.38954436779022217,
-0.8555325269699097,
-0.8896905779838562,
0.2293870896100998,
-0.12711229920387268,
0.06776895374059677,
0.7473952174186707,
-0.54695063829422,
0.08398479223251343,
0.2164182811975479,
0.4483560621738434,
0.3325027525424957,
0.1142909899353981,
0.6691710948944092,
-0.8932642340660095,
-0.18173865973949432,
0.0946703627705574,
0.25112593173980713,
0.5126194953918457,
-0.4810052514076233,
0.17845742404460907,
0.18647100031375885,
-0.8380028605461121,
-0.2820378541946411,
0.335845410823822,
-1.1194730997085571,
0.1375570446252823,
1.5506123304367065,
-0.052041951566934586,
0.010782831348478794,
-0.10882271081209183,
-0.41997218132019043,
-0.14279292523860931,
-0.73033207654953,
0.8933329582214355,
1.1820931434631348,
-0.6831681728363037,
-0.4878259599208832,
-0.9178443551063538,
0.5157958269119263,
0.2440531700849533,
-0.951022207736969,
0.29913148283958435,
0.5888474583625793,
0.4674157500267029,
0.23871400952339172,
0.7758440375328064,
0.03900664672255516,
0.028119919821619987,
-0.3345624804496765,
0.13082383573055267,
0.24921347200870514,
0.05024164915084839,
0.03262714296579361,
0.05860766023397446,
0.2251628339290619,
0.20892614126205444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11668v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11668v1
|
Cyber Risks of Machine Translation Critical Errors : Arabic Mental Health Tweets as a Case Study
| 2024-05-19T20:24:51 | 2024-05-19T20:24:51 |
Hadeel Saadany, Ashraf Tantawy, Constantin Orasan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the advent of Neural Machine Translation (NMT) systems, the MT output
has reached unprecedented accuracy levels which resulted in the ubiquity of MT
tools on almost all online platforms with multilingual content. However, NMT
systems, like other state-of-the-art AI generative systems, are prone to errors
that are deemed machine hallucinations. The problem with NMT hallucinations is
that they are remarkably \textit{fluent} hallucinations. Since they are trained
to produce grammatically correct utterances, NMT systems are capable of
producing mistranslations that are too fluent to be recognised by both users of
the MT tool, as well as by automatic quality metrics that are used to gauge
their performance. In this paper, we introduce an authentic dataset of machine
translation critical errors to point to the ethical and safety issues involved
in the common use of MT. The dataset comprises mistranslations of Arabic mental
health postings manually annotated with critical error types. We also show how
the commonly used quality metrics do not penalise critical errors and highlight
this as a critical issue that merits further attention from researchers.
|
[
-0.07246016710996628,
-0.7328242063522339,
0.46288979053497314,
0.1951398402452469,
-0.24437600374221802,
0.2756100594997406,
0.15902206301689148,
-0.45376017689704895,
-0.025415807962417603,
0.5457971096038818,
-0.4280443489551544,
-0.46153736114501953,
-0.9955213665962219,
0.25405946373939514,
-0.7538591027259827,
1.1252614259719849,
-0.4134042263031006,
0.17441673576831818,
0.23705759644508362,
-0.30122044682502747,
-0.5564870238304138,
-0.8229084610939026,
-0.7024977803230286,
0.127511128783226,
0.3383302390575409,
0.14499245584011078,
1.1965867280960083,
0.3604837656021118,
0.8158151507377625,
0.24366991221904755,
0.378818541765213,
0.40103402733802795,
-0.3622133433818817,
0.23375189304351807,
-0.20398379862308502,
-0.3397587239742279,
-0.5516708493232727,
-0.19016395509243011,
0.17216834425926208,
0.5287871956825256,
-0.26156091690063477,
0.24584729969501495,
-0.040670640766620636,
0.90028977394104,
-0.39283111691474915,
-0.137257918715477,
-0.6223253607749939,
0.3179839253425598,
-0.3453812897205353,
-0.29502591490745544,
-0.32595527172088623,
-0.7068940997123718,
-0.02267494425177574,
-0.48005253076553345,
0.07247576862573624,
-0.0037655134219676256,
0.901002824306488,
0.817323625087738,
-0.3850940763950348,
-0.3643311858177185,
-0.8807719945907593,
0.48693352937698364,
-0.775575578212738,
0.16482025384902954,
0.5722863078117371,
0.5764999985694885,
-0.09141899645328522,
-0.5684987306594849,
-0.5087050795555115,
0.15699781477451324,
0.0030131672974675894,
0.03656772896647453,
-0.3052622079849243,
0.09448306262493134,
0.2931481897830963,
0.14677268266677856,
-0.6388199925422668,
-0.1392262578010559,
-0.3915378749370575,
-0.31868499517440796,
0.4996735155582428,
0.40389901399612427,
0.6329253911972046,
-0.022985203191637993,
0.030409259721636772,
-0.023391565307974815,
-0.636217474937439,
-0.304492712020874,
0.33638995885849,
-0.012855296023190022,
-0.11593183130025864,
0.8334977626800537,
0.2302841693162918,
0.4851687252521515,
-0.2073303759098053,
-0.1278671771287918,
0.24488352239131927,
-0.20913487672805786,
-0.2413308173418045,
0.07997170090675354,
0.9666980504989624,
0.6916247010231018,
0.8428974747657776,
-0.3680211901664734,
-0.3683278560638428,
0.025319023057818413,
0.891507625579834,
-0.5874309539794922,
-0.038297515362501144,
0.48162272572517395,
-0.28862226009368896,
-0.219089075922966,
0.2463725507259369,
-0.6594544053077698,
-0.49447324872016907,
-0.1060146689414978,
0.5288872122764587,
-0.4725290834903717,
-0.17390263080596924,
0.18396112322807312,
0.13570697605609894,
-0.24455510079860687,
0.33420097827911377,
-0.24737930297851562,
0.07462866604328156,
0.2976129949092865,
0.841181218624115,
0.09507331997156143,
-0.26300445199012756,
-0.12305770814418793,
0.029284225776791573,
-0.735480546951294,
0.4191958010196686,
0.03715939074754715,
-0.20590074360370636,
0.3418603837490082,
-0.1634082794189453,
-0.17509853839874268,
-0.5555989742279053,
0.5184347629547119,
-0.5685375332832336,
0.005316324532032013,
-0.11672476679086685,
0.16698963940143585,
-0.43967458605766296,
0.0988885685801506,
-0.4438245892524719,
0.7587940096855164,
0.2146231085062027,
-0.913346529006958,
0.0511690117418766,
-0.5396134257316589,
-0.6730475425720215,
-0.16074000298976898,
-0.05305997282266617,
-0.4313812553882599,
0.1226959079504013,
-0.0021981624886393547,
0.5430201888084412,
-0.2514078915119171,
0.44963645935058594,
-0.0777144655585289,
-0.44437479972839355,
0.8125365376472473,
-0.5807938575744629,
0.933233916759491,
0.24746732413768768,
-0.8844144940376282,
-0.04689911752939224,
-0.5557453036308289,
0.14774224162101746,
-0.0827929824590683,
0.03709830716252327,
-0.12166640162467957,
0.053926799446344376,
0.3000240921974182,
0.5361593961715698,
0.021796638146042824,
-0.07806262373924255,
-0.3044392764568329,
-0.24530461430549622,
0.38896942138671875,
0.7679348587989807,
0.1720053106546402,
-0.08235456049442291,
-0.4864855706691742,
0.637657105922699,
0.19221536815166473,
0.34701788425445557,
0.341110497713089,
-0.5060643553733826,
-0.5882139205932617,
0.06174837425351143,
0.23227979242801666,
1.0665940046310425,
-1.0303237438201904,
0.5617315769195557,
-0.3193611800670624,
-0.4040781557559967,
-0.9586871862411499,
-0.014822607859969139,
0.26679226756095886,
0.2901575565338135,
0.41532713174819946,
0.03004678338766098,
-0.3806314170360565,
-0.9793127775192261,
-0.3747689127922058,
-0.21715500950813293,
-0.03400345891714096,
0.1779434084892273,
0.37552374601364136,
-0.7401851415634155,
0.6680055260658264,
-0.1813966929912567,
-0.38030698895454407,
0.13707402348518372,
0.28880155086517334,
-0.1198812797665596,
0.5554044842720032,
0.4292888045310974,
-0.7281883955001831,
-0.6211967468261719,
0.11829254776239395,
-1.1964261531829834,
-0.10809506475925446,
-0.5431813597679138,
-0.0825452208518982,
0.2595776915550232,
0.3774056136608124,
-0.4917008876800537,
0.5048536062240601,
0.6126076579093933,
-0.09682249277830124,
0.48690035939216614,
-0.10095638781785965,
0.40225404500961304,
-1.3277119398117065,
0.14308594167232513,
-0.3043539524078369,
-0.2383352816104889,
-0.5781452059745789,
0.0016675570514053106,
-0.09663575887680054,
0.22110873460769653,
-0.43295028805732727,
-0.16212822496891022,
-0.04669959098100662,
0.23837143182754517,
-0.22017072141170502,
-0.11514852195978165,
-0.2125089168548584,
0.010100085288286209,
-0.5078593492507935,
1.0409053564071655,
0.37785404920578003,
-0.2702683210372925,
0.19133490324020386,
0.02535688504576683,
-0.1011238768696785,
0.6976926326751709,
-0.4965698719024658,
0.2696065604686737,
-0.002211387502029538,
-0.09217849373817444,
-0.7806627750396729,
-0.4615904688835144,
0.632846474647522,
-0.7944412231445312,
0.17947794497013092,
0.43760451674461365,
-0.9454476833343506,
-0.14184316992759705,
-0.03896489366889,
0.4155135452747345,
0.3486176133155823,
0.05458492413163185,
0.30366018414497375,
0.626808762550354,
0.05601786449551582,
-0.9229211807250977,
-1.0790808200836182,
0.439608097076416,
-0.22772495448589325,
-0.4959859848022461,
-0.18868032097816467,
0.20067711174488068,
-0.3957861065864563,
0.09150516986846924,
-0.03453525900840759,
-0.33229967951774597,
0.6336489319801331,
0.6080123782157898,
-0.009099585935473442,
-0.10401564836502075,
-0.039142463356256485,
0.2556181848049164,
-0.14105328917503357,
0.4219229817390442,
-0.2963705062866211,
0.4226821959018707,
-0.32082897424697876,
-0.3064351975917816,
-0.8705592155456543,
0.7135981321334839,
0.9773303866386414,
0.1261415332555771,
1.0469367504119873,
0.7904936671257019,
-0.9075323343276978,
0.2015431523323059,
-0.6357287764549255,
-0.2583472430706024,
-0.41616785526275635,
0.251880019903183,
-0.09450317919254303,
-0.6453272104263306,
0.5149134397506714,
0.13531768321990967,
-0.05104104056954384,
0.8363094329833984,
0.3247948884963989,
-0.4441387951374054,
1.1218433380126953,
0.44228482246398926,
-0.044767171144485474,
-0.02649008482694626,
-0.00409781513735652,
0.49276676774024963,
-0.39719879627227783,
-0.09800300747156143,
-0.6576034426689148,
-0.1538955271244049,
-0.9942749738693237,
-0.2997385859489441,
0.5517147779464722,
-0.0796038806438446,
-0.3577231764793396,
0.3346438705921173,
-0.4537903666496277,
0.2391979843378067,
0.3948395252227783,
0.12243509292602539,
0.24793364107608795,
0.23628225922584534,
-0.2446228414773941,
-0.5044345259666443,
-0.575442373752594,
-0.9533283710479736,
0.9402881264686584,
0.20856726169586182,
0.5661816596984863,
0.23378032445907593,
0.4900134205818176,
0.6925195455551147,
0.4727742671966553,
-0.5765786170959473,
0.20603494346141815,
0.03208290413022041,
-0.8628089427947998,
-0.2726736068725586,
-0.5895636081695557,
-0.7948974370956421,
-0.11766611039638519,
-0.19884565472602844,
-0.5789004564285278,
-0.011007655411958694,
0.0033797926735132933,
-0.414218932390213,
0.4823470711708069,
-0.43078577518463135,
0.748014509677887,
-0.2630704939365387,
-0.06562910974025726,
-0.2562074065208435,
-1.0334666967391968,
0.3149970471858978,
-0.48262307047843933,
0.42070841789245605,
-0.000967833329923451,
0.06581152975559235,
0.6819052696228027,
-0.15553832054138184,
1.0551081895828247,
0.1968865990638733,
0.26256033778190613,
0.3262718915939331,
0.40674978494644165,
0.31505444645881653,
-0.08673174679279327,
0.059144627302885056,
0.5891885757446289,
0.08768145740032196,
-0.49231618642807007,
-0.2026880532503128,
0.36669430136680603,
-1.1907052993774414,
-0.5687114596366882,
-0.7854561805725098,
-0.4945180118083954,
-0.2168695479631424,
0.33010542392730713,
0.5371919870376587,
0.08050867170095444,
-0.069814033806324,
-0.011864625848829746,
0.5938863754272461,
-0.19879572093486786,
-0.05632879212498665,
0.1293659508228302,
-0.01068886462599039,
-0.8246438503265381,
1.1343708038330078,
0.462862104177475,
0.3105575442314148,
0.0511321946978569,
-0.11368602514266968,
-0.002340438310056925,
-0.7493849992752075,
-0.7855890393257141,
0.25322091579437256,
-0.6941272616386414,
-0.3604831397533417,
-0.9590438604354858,
-0.5788789987564087,
-0.3131655156612396,
-0.3695617616176605,
-0.42482268810272217,
-0.36097365617752075,
-0.4142875671386719,
-0.12455598264932632,
0.274806410074234,
0.961260199546814,
-0.15484336018562317,
0.4780188202857971,
-1.1199547052383423,
0.22180227935314178,
-0.2212793380022049,
0.10100919753313065,
-0.18461665511131287,
-0.3527173399925232,
-0.43846362829208374,
0.30293574929237366,
-0.3694334626197815,
-1.1214874982833862,
0.42134955525398254,
-0.2606169581413269,
0.39103183150291443,
0.5444549918174744,
0.21015766263008118,
0.7786756157875061,
-0.564057469367981,
0.7056620121002197,
0.16390444338321686,
-0.9779934883117676,
0.29266616702079773,
-0.49663448333740234,
0.009124540723860264,
0.9643164873123169,
0.9399572014808655,
-1.2251449823379517,
-0.7090232968330383,
-0.7166928648948669,
-0.8820565938949585,
0.3487699031829834,
0.37608617544174194,
0.15889687836170197,
-0.20212386548519135,
0.33431145548820496,
0.21010220050811768,
0.3623526394367218,
-0.6081228256225586,
-0.3096058666706085,
-0.304851770401001,
-0.19873274862766266,
0.011716367676854134,
-0.18605907261371613,
-0.3463393449783325,
0.07941169291734695,
0.7237461805343628,
-0.008694828487932682,
0.1753714233636856,
0.2038593888282776,
-0.32368776202201843,
-0.4514700472354889,
-0.006625565234571695,
0.8692393898963928,
0.747507631778717,
-0.20455166697502136,
0.2619456350803375,
0.027782917022705078,
-0.5912268161773682,
0.33242592215538025,
-0.20184287428855896,
-0.20055213570594788,
0.23826226592063904,
0.06938178092241287,
0.14385823905467987,
-0.25478389859199524,
-0.5778501033782959,
0.3475017249584198,
0.006996574345976114,
0.0659317821264267,
-0.5191943645477295,
-0.3729037642478943,
-0.007692157756537199,
-0.0185089148581028,
0.29930752515792847,
0.7267780900001526,
0.22423017024993896,
-0.23689739406108856,
0.26469293236732483,
0.1741655468940735,
-0.5503180623054504,
-0.35488301515579224,
0.6142328381538391,
0.09914496541023254,
-0.52547687292099,
0.7051163911819458,
-0.061866749078035355,
-0.6819884181022644,
0.3314042091369629,
0.3070325553417206,
1.2149289846420288,
-0.4056769907474518,
0.35645508766174316,
0.1688222587108612,
1.006588339805603,
-0.24877765774726868,
0.21759168803691864,
0.48034539818763733,
-0.5240423679351807,
-0.2682027816772461,
-0.11539307236671448,
-0.5429647564888,
0.021336296573281288,
-0.6659025549888611,
-0.04822322353720665,
-0.6970808506011963,
-0.6242896914482117,
-0.4724034368991852,
-0.5401822924613953,
-0.5405673384666443,
0.23047545552253723,
0.07230817526578903,
0.40089964866638184,
-0.956105649471283,
0.5449302792549133,
0.5290457606315613,
-0.2998683750629425,
-0.3728524446487427,
0.28014466166496277,
0.196739062666893,
-0.706957995891571,
0.40599972009658813,
0.20214325189590454,
-0.3570397198200226,
-0.21921762824058533,
-0.18688103556632996,
-0.6910854578018188,
0.7079680562019348,
0.3994144797325134,
-0.2974105477333069,
0.11442963033914566,
0.9658072590827942,
0.6243945956230164,
-0.09368841350078583,
0.09740158170461655,
0.2830258309841156,
0.4653940498828888,
-0.44927316904067993,
-0.9798862338066101,
0.29308590292930603,
0.0780503898859024,
-0.028827490285038948,
0.20306475460529327,
-0.4294276833534241,
0.522857666015625,
-0.09528625011444092,
-0.4185067117214203,
-0.28751063346862793,
0.2608759105205536,
-0.25547319650650024,
0.37545207142829895,
0.0993867814540863,
0.5488841533660889,
0.8837173581123352,
-0.059546198695898056,
1.0170882940292358,
-0.16171418130397797,
-0.014926227740943432,
0.8682605624198914,
-0.0934990793466568,
0.660865306854248,
0.5129809975624084,
0.038234222680330276,
0.12823057174682617,
0.7627982497215271,
0.2080187052488327,
0.16726286709308624,
0.18472591042518616,
-0.13454321026802063,
-0.15218062698841095,
-0.08745186030864716,
-0.5590090751647949,
0.006872050929814577,
0.7264193892478943,
-0.49145692586898804,
-0.16783197224140167,
0.03237885236740112,
0.37846988439559937,
0.19794310629367828,
0.1254429668188095,
0.5323466062545776,
0.40116259455680847,
-0.2937772572040558,
0.6558024287223816,
0.1986972838640213,
0.45423293113708496,
-0.03736075013875961,
0.0878591313958168,
-0.09806432574987411,
0.15183350443840027,
-0.3798469305038452,
-0.5755102038383484,
0.9478898048400879,
0.08745744079351425,
-0.014467987231910229,
-0.284431517124176,
0.3449971079826355,
0.08069995045661926,
-0.6405198574066162,
0.1871313899755478,
0.7586976289749146,
0.3669428527355194,
-0.44776853919029236,
-0.9144021272659302,
0.018326131626963615,
-0.07507043331861496,
0.1663457155227661,
0.15360546112060547,
0.6126950979232788,
-0.2592754065990448,
0.630123496055603,
0.6037131547927856,
0.1325027197599411,
0.12827196717262268,
-0.2710055112838745,
0.5801634788513184,
-0.6971807479858398,
-0.0057990895584225655,
-1.0475643873214722,
0.5907566547393799,
-0.02030724287033081,
-0.47667378187179565,
0.6286938786506653,
0.3072493076324463,
0.7703256607055664,
-0.18838459253311157,
0.8382065892219543,
0.2345857173204422,
0.25960811972618103,
-0.26487061381340027,
1.2477481365203857,
-0.5034834146499634,
0.06651086360216141,
-0.07670045644044876,
-0.7664433121681213,
-0.6321000456809998,
0.6254897713661194,
-0.1823360174894333,
-0.2572488784790039,
0.9907835721969604,
0.675220787525177,
0.3076030910015106,
-0.16308043897151947,
0.5786658525466919,
0.41179946064949036,
0.23044200241565704,
0.24777480959892273,
0.7150810360908508,
-0.792992115020752,
0.46021655201911926,
-0.28759658336639404,
-0.011194204911589622,
-0.4310697019100189,
-0.6279941201210022,
-0.9231279492378235,
-0.5665592551231384,
-0.47635209560394287,
-0.9956863522529602,
0.42634716629981995,
1.0998049974441528,
0.4158756136894226,
-0.9646278023719788,
-0.24195554852485657,
0.12297516316175461,
0.2304242104291916,
-0.411957710981369,
-0.23646590113639832,
0.25054502487182617,
-0.18700210750102997,
-0.5020151734352112,
-0.1446886509656906,
0.2760860323905945,
0.30791741609573364,
-0.18048852682113647,
0.21651795506477356,
0.06132164224982262,
0.06943126022815704,
0.4260255694389343,
0.05253639817237854,
-0.7730565071105957,
-0.25636225938796997,
0.0923047736287117,
-0.7192385792732239,
0.16113954782485962,
0.4492110311985016,
-0.18026483058929443,
0.3293266296386719,
0.2418990135192871,
1.0988495349884033,
-0.02637644298374653,
-0.30524930357933044,
0.6150079369544983,
-0.07531996071338654,
-0.222903311252594,
0.5791810154914856,
0.13409560918807983,
0.4996951222419739,
-0.6321605443954468,
0.4905860722064972,
0.37819918990135193,
-0.48571130633354187,
-0.9805880188941956,
-0.013125329278409481,
-0.9557192921638489,
0.034869153052568436,
0.9675396680831909,
-0.19814008474349976,
-0.18433301150798798,
-0.4575394093990326,
-0.30313581228256226,
0.4556870758533478,
-0.17093536257743835,
1.4685239791870117,
0.8945617079734802,
0.2797855734825134,
0.20167288184165955,
-1.3493149280548096,
0.5905710458755493,
0.4700714349746704,
-0.7427272796630859,
-0.07042282074689865,
0.17868216335773468,
0.16567502915859222,
0.3060641884803772,
0.2770208716392517,
-0.33001452684402466,
0.6109590530395508,
0.07727938145399094,
0.07229141145944595,
0.16971412301063538,
-0.278823584318161,
-0.036315277218818665,
0.12914980947971344,
0.2024538516998291,
-0.15338991582393646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11640v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11640v1
|
Inquire, Interact, and Integrate: A Proactive Agent Collaborative Framework for Zero-Shot Multimodal Medical Reasoning
| 2024-05-19T18:26:11 | 2024-05-19T18:26:11 |
Zishan Gu, Fenglin Liu, Changchang Yin, Ping Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The adoption of large language models (LLMs) in healthcare has attracted
significant research interest. However, their performance in healthcare remains
under-investigated and potentially limited, due to i) they lack rich
domain-specific knowledge and medical reasoning skills; and ii) most
state-of-the-art LLMs are unimodal, text-only models that cannot directly
process multimodal inputs. To this end, we propose a multimodal medical
collaborative reasoning framework \textbf{MultiMedRes}, which incorporates a
learner agent to proactively gain essential information from domain-specific
expert models, to solve medical multimodal reasoning problems. Our method
includes three steps: i) \textbf{Inquire}: The learner agent first decomposes
given complex medical reasoning problems into multiple domain-specific
sub-problems; ii) \textbf{Interact}: The agent then interacts with
domain-specific expert models by repeating the ``ask-answer'' process to
progressively obtain different domain-specific knowledge; iii)
\textbf{Integrate}: The agent finally integrates all the acquired
domain-specific knowledge to accurately address the medical reasoning problem.
We validate the effectiveness of our method on the task of difference visual
question answering for X-ray images. The experiments demonstrate that our
zero-shot prediction achieves state-of-the-art performance, and even
outperforms the fully supervised methods. Besides, our approach can be
incorporated into various LLMs and multimodal LLMs to significantly boost their
performance.
|
[
-0.24475423991680145,
-0.723875105381012,
1.2299232482910156,
-0.3043809235095978,
-0.09469442069530487,
0.22679191827774048,
-0.015548370778560638,
-0.5640345811843872,
0.2557294964790344,
0.6659941077232361,
-0.5575551986694336,
-0.4472999572753906,
-0.5410623550415039,
-0.10597896575927734,
0.16866335272789001,
0.45216625928878784,
-0.27349379658699036,
0.39609336853027344,
-0.6676817536354065,
-0.3273129165172577,
-0.33650752902030945,
-0.2750779092311859,
-0.4003717303276062,
-0.4847366511821747,
0.5383573174476624,
0.6922644972801208,
0.7134180665016174,
0.09958025813102722,
0.6469421982765198,
0.4087701737880707,
0.2578965723514557,
0.5761924982070923,
-0.014835379086434841,
0.4740569293498993,
-0.3475697934627533,
-0.39982107281684875,
-0.42522192001342773,
-0.1517878770828247,
0.3141596019268036,
0.6462902426719666,
0.06012224033474922,
-0.2134081870317459,
-0.4710686504840851,
0.1971619427204132,
-0.6189736127853394,
0.26988330483436584,
-0.2132093608379364,
-0.05530921742320061,
0.19386325776576996,
-0.35573458671569824,
-0.48423242568969727,
-0.12148042023181915,
0.189461812376976,
-0.7321875095367432,
-0.1189468502998352,
-0.23134085536003113,
0.43863609433174133,
0.3281932473182678,
-0.6899080276489258,
-0.06142417713999748,
-0.6282180547714233,
0.6590769290924072,
-0.5850949287414551,
0.40221595764160156,
0.39093732833862305,
0.5011000037193298,
-0.31948718428611755,
-0.8913076519966125,
-0.6977142691612244,
-0.36436259746551514,
0.0924326553940773,
0.37700289487838745,
-0.2533617615699768,
0.4119397699832916,
-0.01010617334395647,
0.14254678785800934,
-0.7835161685943604,
-0.17423979938030243,
0.03978313133120537,
-0.055876459926366806,
0.5575906038284302,
0.22746026515960693,
0.3794320225715637,
0.18111154437065125,
-0.43263086676597595,
0.1797161102294922,
-0.33101946115493774,
-0.0060942810960114,
-0.4768708050251007,
0.0339432992041111,
-0.10117398202419281,
0.6600995063781738,
-0.2470664381980896,
0.5712002515792847,
0.13306234776973724,
-0.4630790650844574,
0.2996536195278168,
-0.450603187084198,
-0.42097607254981995,
-0.14070233702659607,
0.6632510423660278,
0.34407058358192444,
0.0653655007481575,
-0.18226221203804016,
0.032642465084791183,
0.22456198930740356,
0.16758862137794495,
-0.5966535806655884,
-0.07862875610589981,
0.5554950833320618,
-0.36772865056991577,
-0.013217615894973278,
-0.3426418900489807,
-0.39843106269836426,
-0.3552384376525879,
-0.3112378418445587,
0.7974376678466797,
-0.5313028693199158,
-0.34175071120262146,
0.384868860244751,
0.04669424891471863,
-0.1415150761604309,
0.6707624793052673,
-0.38130778074264526,
0.10990682244300842,
0.24656321108341217,
0.48598459362983704,
0.25834041833877563,
-0.2930094301700592,
-0.6539705991744995,
0.29214006662368774,
-0.1976100653409958,
1.0332801342010498,
-0.7249886393547058,
-0.3780677020549774,
0.03309696540236473,
0.125468447804451,
-0.39191022515296936,
-0.5066210031509399,
0.2832375466823578,
-0.5202141404151917,
0.24829252064228058,
0.003252785187214613,
-0.6377356052398682,
-0.40722525119781494,
0.5691607594490051,
-0.4170064926147461,
0.36540308594703674,
0.2611069679260254,
-0.3351580798625946,
0.20858027040958405,
-0.736761748790741,
-0.1670794039964676,
0.5315501689910889,
-0.4626845717430115,
-0.173577681183815,
-0.1736420840024948,
0.23593983054161072,
0.4416026771068573,
-0.3971715569496155,
0.2824822664260864,
-0.49061110615730286,
-0.27462366223335266,
0.42091140151023865,
-0.12144897878170013,
0.5413020849227905,
0.09193216264247894,
-0.18053986132144928,
0.37064775824546814,
-0.6255543231964111,
0.17274817824363708,
0.1717468649148941,
-0.07247833907604218,
-0.15998701751232147,
-0.19714556634426117,
-0.2895561158657074,
0.36394888162612915,
0.05080709233880043,
-0.5732420086860657,
0.24478648602962494,
-0.20856334269046783,
0.13481059670448303,
0.2208728939294815,
0.42089101672172546,
0.5834848284721375,
-0.5831267237663269,
0.6177423000335693,
0.13249768316745758,
0.46132224798202515,
-0.38527828454971313,
-0.6292425990104675,
-0.4983730912208557,
-0.7072953581809998,
-0.1069980040192604,
0.5378503799438477,
-1.4047915935516357,
-0.08491332083940506,
0.23238195478916168,
-0.4549008309841156,
-0.5158634185791016,
0.00034249492455273867,
0.47317445278167725,
0.6668951511383057,
0.5366050004959106,
-0.34779462218284607,
-0.2957000136375427,
-0.5725518465042114,
0.19101443886756897,
-0.2558384835720062,
0.20479635894298553,
0.43140915036201477,
0.46316903829574585,
-0.5658658146858215,
0.7048681974411011,
-0.4061901271343231,
-0.42181968688964844,
-0.4484715163707733,
0.17175069451332092,
0.12367545068264008,
0.41190385818481445,
0.43922168016433716,
-0.6596032381057739,
-0.5086998343467712,
0.0910995602607727,
-1.110080361366272,
0.2412116378545761,
-0.2373165488243103,
-0.20489037036895752,
0.018793335184454918,
0.3862266540527344,
-0.7739393711090088,
0.34167981147766113,
0.49909651279449463,
-0.35260048508644104,
0.39650657773017883,
-0.5069063901901245,
0.4039973318576813,
-1.1065939664840698,
-0.18141400814056396,
0.13061049580574036,
-0.3223429024219513,
-0.7980275750160217,
0.2315359264612198,
0.016409900039434433,
-0.02304050698876381,
-0.5943640470504761,
0.697210431098938,
-0.5344377160072327,
0.2742694318294525,
-0.2142958641052246,
0.01321408897638321,
0.1886109858751297,
0.48148226737976074,
0.18433400988578796,
0.4687563478946686,
0.8285845518112183,
-0.3806304335594177,
0.45933419466018677,
0.3535906970500946,
-0.22213561832904816,
0.9363633394241333,
-0.559289276599884,
0.1152702271938324,
-0.1646125614643097,
0.2138628512620926,
-0.9671837687492371,
-0.45857736468315125,
0.4130668342113495,
-0.5757441520690918,
0.30899345874786377,
-0.08244703710079193,
-0.514997661113739,
-0.12911267578601837,
-0.05187489837408066,
0.5556032657623291,
0.03227769583463669,
-0.26063084602355957,
0.878144383430481,
0.3442794978618622,
-0.17854756116867065,
-0.5587048530578613,
-0.5929157137870789,
0.04201487824320793,
0.37562575936317444,
-0.7968795895576477,
0.35167840123176575,
-0.24545256793498993,
-0.3073706328868866,
0.20552758872509003,
0.16360214352607727,
-0.427176296710968,
-0.2802003026008606,
0.24244238436222076,
0.4691043198108673,
-0.23119337856769562,
0.19332675635814667,
0.11625602841377258,
-0.22131489217281342,
-0.17107366025447845,
-0.12022149562835693,
0.22213280200958252,
-0.12331251800060272,
-0.942169189453125,
-0.6165440082550049,
0.5520872473716736,
1.0074958801269531,
-0.3550761044025421,
0.533903956413269,
0.3737390637397766,
-0.43146833777427673,
0.18043053150177002,
-0.7029123306274414,
-0.31496456265449524,
-0.3930894136428833,
0.29514244198799133,
-0.20402473211288452,
-0.9094070792198181,
0.36431655287742615,
-0.20820340514183044,
-0.1426929086446762,
0.05111793801188469,
0.8074681758880615,
-0.35835790634155273,
1.215164303779602,
0.590867817401886,
0.5276479125022888,
0.2328435480594635,
-0.42870140075683594,
0.05090942978858948,
-0.5321875214576721,
-0.7484854459762573,
-0.07496310025453568,
-0.13878068327903748,
-0.1808367669582367,
-0.8513292670249939,
0.7384467124938965,
-0.25142836570739746,
-0.24580781161785126,
0.03084718808531761,
-0.2817445993423462,
0.2747189700603485,
0.4260263741016388,
0.34793296456336975,
0.3531215190887451,
-0.21482540667057037,
-0.3958199620246887,
0.0912834107875824,
-0.6579371094703674,
-0.10907462239265442,
0.8828439116477966,
0.1827501505613327,
0.6879085302352905,
0.1961263120174408,
0.5693261623382568,
0.05176868662238121,
0.2099791020154953,
-0.797616183757782,
0.5238001346588135,
-0.02213279716670513,
-0.6661099195480347,
-0.009259391576051712,
-0.13783738017082214,
-0.8295791149139404,
0.354021281003952,
-0.45812299847602844,
-0.44660618901252747,
0.5063040256500244,
-0.15708114206790924,
-0.5946508049964905,
0.23867405951023102,
-0.7233356833457947,
0.7744058966636658,
-0.36028891801834106,
-0.5243606567382812,
-0.26117241382598877,
-0.7816949486732483,
0.15046963095664978,
0.038464341312646866,
0.2625299394130707,
-0.1396070271730423,
-0.10635524988174438,
0.04857796058058739,
-0.27273109555244446,
0.8804728388786316,
-0.24939048290252686,
0.16961117088794708,
0.3935469388961792,
0.35139745473861694,
0.19778954982757568,
0.15304195880889893,
0.07655656337738037,
0.0697728842496872,
0.04642003774642944,
-0.3835292458534241,
-0.6706457734107971,
0.5053955912590027,
-0.7074715495109558,
-0.3336273729801178,
-0.4081677198410034,
-0.7940824031829834,
-0.5252142548561096,
0.17728692293167114,
-0.03532562777400017,
0.6657107472419739,
-0.009651469066739082,
0.16112925112247467,
0.6011542081832886,
0.003168914234265685,
0.3418430984020233,
0.9138169288635254,
-0.1317388117313385,
-0.6603924036026001,
0.7219546437263489,
0.06829646974802017,
0.287385493516922,
0.5855759382247925,
-0.022298013791441917,
-0.4017742872238159,
-0.4123135507106781,
-0.4494931399822235,
0.46520254015922546,
-0.708387017250061,
-0.29069963097572327,
-0.680919349193573,
-0.24792437255382538,
-0.2207130789756775,
-0.4293695390224457,
-0.18974478542804718,
-0.07377037405967712,
-0.19335508346557617,
0.21238651871681213,
0.20830699801445007,
0.5876846313476562,
-0.11253093183040619,
0.17362792789936066,
-1.196263074874878,
0.24703748524188995,
0.403224915266037,
0.23865906894207,
-0.2352890521287918,
-0.4242308437824249,
-0.20244848728179932,
-0.11867634952068329,
-0.21466241776943207,
-0.9839974045753479,
0.2932319641113281,
-0.06202149763703346,
1.0669353008270264,
0.5040493607521057,
0.07042047381401062,
0.4848268926143646,
-0.23885853588581085,
0.630497395992279,
0.4751424491405487,
-0.5406157374382019,
0.37170642614364624,
-0.1806056797504425,
0.28883299231529236,
0.6120256781578064,
0.5916445851325989,
-0.3660014569759369,
-0.35521039366722107,
-0.5534250736236572,
-0.511905312538147,
0.49393120408058167,
-0.18025073409080505,
-0.08996973931789398,
-0.14418339729309082,
0.1591954380273819,
-0.011493079364299774,
0.12530885636806488,
-0.3091249465942383,
-0.10486850887537003,
0.17025935649871826,
-0.10542628169059753,
0.07022757083177567,
-0.2855992615222931,
-0.3401812016963959,
-0.3935747444629669,
0.31388941407203674,
-0.42454832792282104,
0.29125460982322693,
0.42921632528305054,
-0.21636341512203217,
-0.323596328496933,
0.21349017322063446,
0.5663860440254211,
0.6295135617256165,
-0.2308167964220047,
0.17905820906162262,
0.10648350417613983,
-0.3133856952190399,
0.2150854915380478,
-0.0053012617863714695,
0.27114138007164,
0.047077346593141556,
0.4605582356452942,
0.5555428862571716,
0.26863500475883484,
-0.8692528605461121,
0.787214457988739,
-0.19438403844833374,
-0.5769151449203491,
-0.24604377150535583,
-0.1329655945301056,
0.11198239773511887,
0.8447778224945068,
0.05329718813300133,
0.4344250559806824,
0.025845656171441078,
-0.5270421504974365,
0.4360347390174866,
0.41976580023765564,
-0.6214142441749573,
-0.21206732094287872,
0.6514636874198914,
0.2593938708305359,
-0.04059479013085365,
0.38105741143226624,
-0.15244166553020477,
-0.1747421771287918,
0.47681859135627747,
0.3161451518535614,
0.6993511319160461,
-0.20283375680446625,
0.5396938323974609,
0.24067322909832,
-0.07893860340118408,
0.058181773871183395,
0.6001186966896057,
-0.10102733224630356,
-0.9231790900230408,
-0.8559691309928894,
0.06002747267484665,
-0.8088734149932861,
-0.12292469292879105,
-0.2649497091770172,
0.08844152092933655,
-0.3346399962902069,
-0.2805801331996918,
0.056479569524526596,
-0.03976251929998398,
-0.4792632460594177,
0.2507055401802063,
0.18034544587135315,
0.74971604347229,
-0.6023050546646118,
0.8951742053031921,
0.9455634355545044,
-0.9597805142402649,
-0.6195650696754456,
-0.05656258016824722,
0.2471168488264084,
-0.9414405226707458,
0.5801135897636414,
-0.02913922443985939,
-0.2109256386756897,
-0.26416200399398804,
-0.5105026364326477,
-0.6214115619659424,
1.0595195293426514,
0.5287277102470398,
-0.2590605914592743,
0.07631321996450424,
-0.0689704492688179,
0.49260491132736206,
-0.5395939350128174,
0.6763593554496765,
0.3191838562488556,
0.2924189269542694,
0.7553055882453918,
-0.9645875096321106,
-0.03322775661945343,
-0.25211969017982483,
-0.3863544166088104,
-0.10707399994134903,
-0.517191469669342,
0.828264057636261,
-0.7458789348602295,
0.1167815625667572,
-0.008306904695928097,
0.23220674693584442,
0.19165655970573425,
0.6265633702278137,
0.3588304817676544,
0.4680841565132141,
0.7368224263191223,
0.22018924355506897,
0.958338737487793,
-0.46106573939323425,
0.18389616906642914,
0.944670557975769,
-0.6973245739936829,
0.7571318745613098,
0.39398863911628723,
0.043907441198825836,
0.6094382405281067,
0.2549018859863281,
0.1962430626153946,
0.5258784294128418,
-0.4981895387172699,
-0.8749285936355591,
-0.6783760190010071,
-0.45838555693626404,
-0.40837639570236206,
0.5543381571769714,
0.3054933249950409,
-0.1671665459871292,
-0.37300562858581543,
0.12881691753864288,
0.058028414845466614,
0.058136578649282455,
-0.2031135857105255,
0.9762902855873108,
0.034487586468458176,
-0.6229488253593445,
0.4498923420906067,
-0.195962592959404,
0.4698931872844696,
-0.5877403020858765,
-0.25350478291511536,
-0.17988009750843048,
0.46439698338508606,
-0.3137564957141876,
-0.9377655982971191,
0.18291977047920227,
-0.42469555139541626,
-0.15341252088546753,
-0.07715726643800735,
0.7998555302619934,
-0.6206753849983215,
-0.24280241131782532,
0.46768563985824585,
1.0165598392486572,
0.12580318748950958,
-0.19580189883708954,
-0.6239408254623413,
-0.23866857588291168,
-0.030331501737236977,
0.1294710487127304,
0.5407044887542725,
0.4057914614677429,
-0.004169703461229801,
0.8276732563972473,
0.7155612111091614,
-0.05470164120197296,
-0.4133186638355255,
0.2253652960062027,
1.0330268144607544,
-0.21892200410366058,
0.019708821550011635,
-0.6181621551513672,
0.7573720216751099,
0.04897208884358406,
-0.028716353699564934,
0.27353793382644653,
0.29159075021743774,
0.7350513339042664,
-0.02581058070063591,
0.7214124798774719,
0.30792251229286194,
0.520331084728241,
-0.17577692866325378,
0.677222728729248,
-1.0069836378097534,
-0.08164698630571365,
-0.05077270418405533,
-0.42099741101264954,
-0.6380836963653564,
0.6071277856826782,
-0.20213232934474945,
-0.035500988364219666,
0.7378259301185608,
0.9248272180557251,
0.1679997742176056,
-0.17579154670238495,
0.7906073331832886,
0.035176459699869156,
0.3000985085964203,
0.7302417755126953,
0.868989109992981,
-0.11586020141839981,
0.47795388102531433,
-0.42509573698043823,
-0.5088093876838684,
-0.40967199206352234,
-0.6305922269821167,
-0.7479372620582581,
-0.47198379039764404,
-0.46647003293037415,
-0.2113451510667801,
-0.004253635182976723,
1.3069300651550293,
0.757642388343811,
-0.5608600378036499,
0.03956673666834831,
0.2498980462551117,
0.13083988428115845,
-0.24864692986011505,
-0.13780564069747925,
0.049857985228300095,
-0.33244192600250244,
-0.6115585565567017,
0.7405908107757568,
0.6949620246887207,
-0.0948454886674881,
-0.21010354161262512,
-0.26021069288253784,
-0.3943914473056793,
0.30564650893211365,
0.7511014938354492,
0.38564160466194153,
-0.584428071975708,
-0.04951343312859535,
0.3266715109348297,
-0.2545403838157654,
0.11508924514055252,
0.7159160375595093,
-0.8122755289077759,
1.0254712104797363,
0.4388889670372009,
0.5428832173347473,
0.32088226079940796,
-0.25866377353668213,
0.3185564875602722,
-0.4545956254005432,
0.1379033625125885,
0.5130205154418945,
0.5375418663024902,
0.033212315291166306,
-0.25303763151168823,
0.3287712633609772,
0.4852341115474701,
-0.6623296141624451,
-0.5538590550422668,
0.18680015206336975,
-1.0842883586883545,
-0.40704748034477234,
1.0159152746200562,
-0.26013779640197754,
-0.0004949261783622205,
-0.4300544857978821,
-0.44517701864242554,
0.1878318190574646,
-0.2883358597755432,
0.2591971158981323,
0.16980305314064026,
-0.6817403435707092,
-0.6215623617172241,
-0.4071122407913208,
0.062217868864536285,
0.3567967712879181,
-0.7565091252326965,
-0.5481037497520447,
0.5842558741569519,
0.21634232997894287,
0.1624516397714615,
1.0821465253829956,
-0.20638398826122284,
0.6338284611701965,
0.11654767394065857,
0.45380735397338867,
-0.46175289154052734,
-0.5583103895187378,
-0.06358659267425537,
0.2875216603279114,
0.17186282575130463,
-0.4293919801712036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11637v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11637v1
|
Zero-Shot Stance Detection using Contextual Data Generation with LLMs
| 2024-05-19T17:58:26 | 2024-05-19T17:58:26 |
Ghazaleh Mahmoudi, Babak Behkamkia, Sauleh Eetemadi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Stance detection, the classification of attitudes expressed in a text towards
a specific topic, is vital for applications like fake news detection and
opinion mining. However, the scarcity of labeled data remains a challenge for
this task. To address this problem, we propose Dynamic Model Adaptation with
Contextual Data Generation (DyMoAdapt) that combines Few-Shot Learning and
Large Language Models. In this approach, we aim to fine-tune an existing model
at test time. We achieve this by generating new topic-specific data using
GPT-3. This method could enhance performance by allowing the adaptation of the
model to new topics. However, the results did not increase as we expected.
Furthermore, we introduce the Multi Generated Topic VAST (MGT-VAST) dataset,
which extends VAST using GPT-3. In this dataset, each context is associated
with multiple topics, allowing the model to understand the relationship between
contexts and various potential topics
|
[
-0.29499557614326477,
-0.9797976016998291,
0.7917421460151672,
-0.12328679114580154,
-0.5332105755805969,
-0.06127800792455673,
0.059820473194122314,
-0.09085004776716232,
0.32309335470199585,
0.2417488396167755,
-0.7813543081283569,
-0.7724717259407043,
-0.5862137675285339,
-0.17302975058555603,
-0.1697148233652115,
1.3261449337005615,
-0.24416829645633698,
-0.08262548595666885,
0.04761752486228943,
-0.4970543086528778,
-0.6493933200836182,
-0.33584609627723694,
-0.4757211208343506,
-0.25241419672966003,
0.2551910877227783,
0.5309935808181763,
0.49712637066841125,
0.5156025290489197,
0.14111046493053436,
0.13626347482204437,
0.10807429999113083,
-0.12410289794206619,
-0.525179922580719,
0.4844307601451874,
-0.2139311134815216,
-0.38658207654953003,
-0.7597534656524658,
0.11093755811452866,
0.7951220273971558,
0.25546690821647644,
0.051044438034296036,
0.04767010733485222,
-0.02521492727100849,
0.3705199062824249,
-0.4064696133136749,
-0.01033263560384512,
-0.9046627283096313,
0.14382925629615784,
-0.1608336865901947,
-0.24580545723438263,
-0.11171522736549377,
-0.007992331869900227,
-0.06085977330803871,
-0.41228488087654114,
0.30114489793777466,
-0.3208900988101959,
0.7344772815704346,
0.2671777009963989,
-0.665556013584137,
-0.19499103724956512,
-0.4656086564064026,
0.6864468455314636,
-0.7921358942985535,
0.16464903950691223,
0.1426352560520172,
0.0763973817229271,
-0.20768138766288757,
-0.1584750860929489,
-0.8892920017242432,
-0.03681257367134094,
0.4028264582157135,
0.3789232075214386,
-0.2643369138240814,
-0.11258211731910706,
0.13479122519493103,
0.19808393716812134,
-0.6142967939376831,
0.20991739630699158,
0.12104873359203339,
0.014384465292096138,
0.5896873474121094,
0.2927890121936798,
0.17667488753795624,
-0.5693708658218384,
-0.44362711906433105,
-0.06567306816577911,
-0.7079654335975647,
-0.2787736654281616,
0.3777957856655121,
0.3995889127254486,
-0.31649866700172424,
0.6688334345817566,
-0.40441974997520447,
0.7441556453704834,
0.42849475145339966,
-0.32142117619514465,
0.3018052875995636,
-0.07572722434997559,
-0.27764102816581726,
0.14447341859340668,
0.6513875722885132,
0.4198055863380432,
-0.30754855275154114,
0.3796292841434479,
-0.18855029344558716,
0.059376366436481476,
-0.03220682963728905,
-0.9156939387321472,
0.10125841200351715,
0.43610861897468567,
-0.23552022874355316,
-0.5320743322372437,
-0.1446821093559265,
-0.6694586277008057,
-0.7875173687934875,
-0.4295073449611664,
0.3564673066139221,
-0.4728029668331146,
-0.44808149337768555,
0.14892524480819702,
0.10145726799964905,
0.5756930112838745,
0.5437880754470825,
-0.7765165567398071,
-0.1307642161846161,
0.8032307028770447,
1.2277977466583252,
-0.480486124753952,
-0.25612181425094604,
-0.44454309344291687,
0.23617973923683167,
-0.34202781319618225,
0.8772986531257629,
-0.27936646342277527,
-0.2897392511367798,
-0.13334618508815765,
-0.1368550956249237,
0.07699673622846603,
-0.1829962134361267,
0.36536288261413574,
-0.3078838586807251,
0.3946329951286316,
-0.10737266391515732,
-0.7283051013946533,
0.06585386395454407,
0.9763776659965515,
-0.5443898439407349,
0.8957837820053101,
0.0135300662368536,
-0.9274345636367798,
0.7669162154197693,
-0.7848187685012817,
-0.3478395640850067,
0.0764305591583252,
-0.4601259231567383,
-0.48748779296875,
0.12570513784885406,
0.1775297224521637,
0.7765418291091919,
0.08659464865922928,
0.39582300186157227,
-0.6298179030418396,
-0.1339237093925476,
0.08708476275205612,
-0.5075829029083252,
0.5943776965141296,
0.08677203208208084,
-0.5049678087234497,
0.2402128130197525,
-0.6733062267303467,
-0.4312931299209595,
0.15821968019008636,
-0.3306833803653717,
-0.2747935950756073,
0.06392598152160645,
-0.22139529883861542,
0.376322478055954,
0.05202779173851013,
-0.4981614351272583,
0.6021967530250549,
-0.3000742197036743,
0.008206420578062534,
0.8328756093978882,
0.3709339499473572,
0.357161283493042,
-0.10557626932859421,
0.6086035370826721,
0.15080086886882782,
-0.1532168984413147,
-0.16647067666053772,
-0.4459311366081238,
-0.6686681509017944,
-0.3429878354072571,
-0.029061300680041313,
0.4908975064754486,
-0.815577507019043,
0.3391246497631073,
-0.33071866631507874,
-0.3016349673271179,
-0.05342741310596466,
0.12254282087087631,
-0.038093503564596176,
0.5646095275878906,
0.13812115788459778,
-0.18565542995929718,
-0.3298332393169403,
-0.5180473327636719,
-0.26712465286254883,
-0.33451053500175476,
0.010928372852504253,
0.21834179759025574,
0.5921381711959839,
-0.10216687619686127,
0.9848827719688416,
-0.7160266637802124,
-0.3655439019203186,
-0.2646276652812958,
0.37596747279167175,
0.3691605031490326,
0.15565338730812073,
0.8866062164306641,
-0.7245239019393921,
-0.6240413784980774,
-0.13615773618221283,
-0.8471084237098694,
0.049471307545900345,
-0.27758166193962097,
-0.14524856209754944,
0.3775143027305603,
0.3548222482204437,
-0.6593945622444153,
0.3191450834274292,
0.5769175291061401,
-0.4766860604286194,
0.3717446029186249,
0.20653864741325378,
0.10596682131290436,
-1.5493324995040894,
-0.17108258605003357,
0.17542782425880432,
-0.4137742221355438,
-0.8154733777046204,
-0.16372525691986084,
-0.07820019870996475,
-0.3315888047218323,
-0.78602534532547,
0.844419538974762,
-0.2308332324028015,
0.08287163078784943,
-0.6070153117179871,
0.2248190939426422,
-0.06910833716392517,
0.22105519473552704,
0.402106910943985,
0.42030569911003113,
0.7307432889938354,
-0.4176451861858368,
0.42442482709884644,
0.24499401450157166,
-0.08009890466928482,
1.0400338172912598,
-0.2266775667667389,
0.30675289034843445,
-0.29376786947250366,
0.4730132222175598,
-1.1062346696853638,
-0.6063095927238464,
0.424129843711853,
-0.4827810227870941,
0.33930155634880066,
-0.5852251648902893,
-0.25718405842781067,
-0.11646135151386261,
-0.673750102519989,
0.11137985438108444,
0.012341797351837158,
-0.47004279494285583,
0.3401131331920624,
0.4138639271259308,
-0.2910352349281311,
-0.683609127998352,
-0.475082665681839,
0.047967616468667984,
-0.5143116116523743,
-0.16308413445949554,
0.2707130014896393,
0.05815934017300606,
-0.1572846919298172,
-0.06924691051244736,
-0.1768139749765396,
0.07736823707818985,
-0.1774923950433731,
0.32655471563339233,
0.2753083109855652,
-0.2222405970096588,
0.29732075333595276,
0.16622616350650787,
0.12411686778068542,
-0.2520974576473236,
-0.316995233297348,
0.6032091975212097,
-0.1356581151485443,
-0.3520812392234802,
-0.4908159673213959,
0.15982308983802795,
0.7704857587814331,
0.214737668633461,
0.5685920715332031,
0.8010696768760681,
-0.31334447860717773,
-0.1937328279018402,
-0.18070587515830994,
-0.09853827953338623,
-0.4249272644519806,
0.48312443494796753,
-0.39201754331588745,
-0.8215216398239136,
0.31672632694244385,
-0.007506746333092451,
-0.09370570629835129,
0.27635839581489563,
1.0310862064361572,
-0.03257239609956741,
0.9261627793312073,
0.598404586315155,
-0.5722596049308777,
0.7413462400436401,
-0.192125141620636,
0.03436056151986122,
-0.4722210466861725,
0.1104155108332634,
-0.02932346612215042,
-0.3949087858200073,
-0.6364040374755859,
-0.3478424549102783,
0.34389057755470276,
-0.0846177190542221,
-0.18405920267105103,
0.11389178037643433,
-0.3153766095638275,
0.3227026164531708,
0.003889004699885845,
0.19294635951519012,
0.19420267641544342,
0.1425657719373703,
0.19284962117671967,
-0.10503050684928894,
-0.443782240152359,
-0.4453110992908478,
1.1395280361175537,
0.4136139154434204,
0.5306656956672668,
0.34209170937538147,
0.8186621069908142,
0.3480919897556305,
0.6291376352310181,
-1.2292211055755615,
0.5402328968048096,
-0.03995521739125252,
-0.7275102734565735,
-0.2419794797897339,
-0.2948575019836426,
-0.862147331237793,
0.33323514461517334,
-0.34412500262260437,
-0.5690986514091492,
0.08023371547460556,
0.23533374071121216,
-0.3783615827560425,
0.3796136677265167,
-0.32356202602386475,
0.674746572971344,
-0.35360491275787354,
-0.6851723790168762,
-0.041162941604852676,
-0.25341686606407166,
0.5357629060745239,
-0.16155599057674408,
-0.04498281329870224,
-0.5768983960151672,
-0.10798342525959015,
0.8035269379615784,
-0.050774671137332916,
1.0666863918304443,
-0.7316281199455261,
-0.4458658695220947,
0.34031274914741516,
0.16681626439094543,
0.35741862654685974,
0.38063114881515503,
-0.3085024654865265,
0.03743424266576767,
-0.22967633605003357,
-0.34492385387420654,
-0.3536819517612457,
0.9418283104896545,
-0.6628285646438599,
-0.669853925704956,
-0.6285762786865234,
-0.6787388324737549,
-0.38710203766822815,
0.40682682394981384,
0.09664265066385269,
0.18302017450332642,
-0.5061631798744202,
0.08648117631673813,
0.42055022716522217,
-0.26314011216163635,
0.49655061960220337,
0.5973817706108093,
-0.21257169544696808,
-0.1786242425441742,
0.7535014748573303,
-0.02612999454140663,
-0.020507652312517166,
0.20023053884506226,
0.22652119398117065,
-0.47707682847976685,
-0.6237334609031677,
-0.5774393081665039,
0.12948112189769745,
-0.586286723613739,
-0.48484399914741516,
-0.4273313879966736,
0.2505189776420593,
-0.4851427674293518,
-0.18081431090831757,
-0.4152020215988159,
-0.4144773483276367,
-0.3838135898113251,
-0.2368735373020172,
0.6084608435630798,
0.5811228156089783,
-0.017523761838674545,
0.5304836630821228,
-0.44161930680274963,
0.6512447595596313,
0.26310792565345764,
0.2504357397556305,
-0.4967077076435089,
-0.7404477596282959,
0.18308521807193756,
-0.01512937992811203,
-0.7244519591331482,
-1.1274584531784058,
0.5642241835594177,
0.19670319557189941,
0.33430859446525574,
0.5287501811981201,
-0.0026129870675504208,
0.407321959733963,
-0.3474286198616028,
0.7754842638969421,
0.1939546763896942,
-0.9054630398750305,
0.8679875135421753,
-0.9131537675857544,
0.3833649456501007,
0.4745215177536011,
0.7073989510536194,
-0.2532084882259369,
-0.08040360361337662,
-0.5679898858070374,
-0.82415372133255,
0.7701146602630615,
-0.04642157256603241,
0.49420300126075745,
0.07799842208623886,
0.630719006061554,
0.17601126432418823,
0.1809406876564026,
-0.9321534633636475,
0.09314709901809692,
-0.514651894569397,
-0.34491628408432007,
0.05427810922265053,
0.07804971933364868,
-0.15715423226356506,
-0.3473152220249176,
0.5424745678901672,
-0.6361247897148132,
0.19050779938697815,
-0.033943723887205124,
-0.17414309084415436,
-0.01267548743635416,
0.405633807182312,
0.5986838936805725,
0.5157784819602966,
-0.4806725084781647,
0.007239449769258499,
0.3849404752254486,
-0.4661473035812378,
0.4691130518913269,
-0.003422204405069351,
-0.33448249101638794,
0.11863970756530762,
0.1434672772884369,
0.9911895990371704,
-0.0446794368326664,
-0.2522566318511963,
0.7226269841194153,
0.1175321415066719,
-0.29887041449546814,
-0.0717373937368393,
0.023279301822185516,
-0.1879567950963974,
0.20378975570201874,
0.3104698359966278,
-0.27287760376930237,
-0.11161018162965775,
-0.8794308304786682,
0.4735921323299408,
0.532673180103302,
-0.5630152225494385,
-0.4574696719646454,
0.6023147702217102,
0.12972964346408844,
0.2021535038948059,
0.16577380895614624,
-0.19601114094257355,
-0.4197068512439728,
0.39297741651535034,
0.6129478812217712,
0.716358482837677,
-0.22064286470413208,
0.5821652412414551,
0.3447417616844177,
-0.1714610755443573,
-0.029236258938908577,
0.35074755549430847,
0.01153749693185091,
-1.0243281126022339,
-0.40705883502960205,
-0.5666967034339905,
-0.5105156302452087,
0.6363276243209839,
-0.6830788850784302,
0.5757039785385132,
-0.6009089946746826,
-0.28038325905799866,
0.1222071424126625,
0.19677430391311646,
-0.4713393747806549,
0.2009647786617279,
0.31536537408828735,
0.49945005774497986,
-1.0876972675323486,
1.1254788637161255,
0.8377676606178284,
-0.15333516895771027,
-0.27100518345832825,
0.5387165546417236,
0.6542433500289917,
-0.7452608942985535,
0.4204341173171997,
0.08418439328670502,
-0.17680847644805908,
0.04851103946566582,
-0.5329743027687073,
-0.4880443215370178,
1.204105019569397,
0.5675109028816223,
-0.4640878140926361,
0.443372517824173,
0.044227227568626404,
0.45758479833602905,
-0.4422180652618408,
-0.13514213263988495,
0.4251915514469147,
0.39316800236701965,
0.16186697781085968,
-0.43996933102607727,
0.05717047303915024,
0.15904481709003448,
-0.3799234628677368,
0.09109170734882355,
-0.6867791414260864,
0.8854822516441345,
0.04708635434508324,
-0.07853036373853683,
-0.25520822405815125,
0.5533087849617004,
0.6273581981658936,
0.4535670578479767,
0.45209673047065735,
0.3920463025569916,
0.7472428679466248,
0.06252814829349518,
1.0054289102554321,
-0.13727419078350067,
0.5554583668708801,
1.1415120363235474,
-0.7991724610328674,
0.9311115741729736,
0.44997677206993103,
0.1447223424911499,
0.38840726017951965,
0.6381954550743103,
-0.03239870443940163,
0.4458828568458557,
-0.10627779364585876,
-0.5055156946182251,
-0.04129697382450104,
-0.022164642810821533,
-0.2787652313709259,
0.7511722445487976,
0.4574193060398102,
-0.12193211168050766,
-0.3622024655342102,
0.0309006180614233,
0.4308463931083679,
-0.26135921478271484,
-0.3782668709754944,
0.7356938123703003,
-0.090781569480896,
-0.4821150004863739,
0.5934067368507385,
0.07366248220205307,
0.8716990351676941,
-0.4151102304458618,
0.059050302952528,
-0.43694519996643066,
0.19626125693321228,
-0.11996212601661682,
-0.9845743775367737,
0.2328115552663803,
0.2274211049079895,
-0.06856770813465118,
-0.2223910391330719,
1.0721080303192139,
-0.2525213360786438,
-0.47190359234809875,
0.08029282093048096,
0.7592893242835999,
0.10382886976003647,
-0.1434181183576584,
-0.8175721168518066,
0.03672966733574867,
0.014376211911439896,
-0.6420040130615234,
0.5852985382080078,
0.5356694459915161,
-0.16771644353866577,
0.2469847947359085,
0.5454826951026917,
0.12567144632339478,
-0.24828261137008667,
0.04761117324233055,
0.9623053073883057,
-0.7640112042427063,
-0.33412787318229675,
-1.1003284454345703,
0.28606823086738586,
-0.08896774798631668,
-0.3545095920562744,
0.8655380606651306,
0.44773590564727783,
0.6089487671852112,
-0.043879877775907516,
0.9046239852905273,
-0.2208537459373474,
0.3554198443889618,
-0.5918534398078918,
0.6818332672119141,
-0.6540150046348572,
0.12352558970451355,
-0.3946243226528168,
-0.8318652510643005,
-0.6210072636604309,
0.50239497423172,
-0.4566779136657715,
-0.19863954186439514,
0.3626422882080078,
0.7435957789421082,
-0.4629433751106262,
-0.41319915652275085,
0.38805049657821655,
0.25719672441482544,
0.4025079905986786,
0.4253041744232178,
0.7950623035430908,
-0.22985461354255676,
0.2982947826385498,
0.06846705824136734,
-0.29265978932380676,
-0.26774293184280396,
-1.2861918210983276,
-0.7327877879142761,
-0.4488341510295868,
-0.5216453075408936,
-0.2155436873435974,
-0.08392906188964844,
0.6588771343231201,
0.8984792828559875,
-0.8317347764968872,
-0.0161103717982769,
-0.1285223662853241,
0.07117640972137451,
0.12464413791894913,
-0.2698405683040619,
0.4700022339820862,
-0.050314199179410934,
-0.6799922585487366,
0.6281269192695618,
0.29538601636886597,
0.19149643182754517,
-0.07379113882780075,
-0.12479749321937561,
-0.2903168797492981,
0.13357359170913696,
0.8723061084747314,
0.4200892150402069,
-0.43461814522743225,
-0.457949161529541,
-0.19163668155670166,
0.24790465831756592,
0.2530415654182434,
0.837392270565033,
-0.6736336350440979,
0.2479894757270813,
0.47615212202072144,
0.40196776390075684,
0.7962154746055603,
0.21059033274650574,
0.3488541841506958,
-1.2214386463165283,
0.5853108167648315,
0.2181897759437561,
0.2923896312713623,
0.45273005962371826,
-0.4078525900840759,
0.3597443997859955,
0.30193227529525757,
-0.22082820534706116,
-0.921539843082428,
0.3850157856941223,
-1.0783720016479492,
-0.39105984568595886,
1.3727197647094727,
0.005338551476597786,
-0.012301639653742313,
-0.0917697474360466,
-0.2683097720146179,
0.27576929330825806,
-0.4572342336177826,
0.6894019842147827,
0.5608831644058228,
-0.625169575214386,
-0.2725187838077545,
-0.7492073774337769,
0.3688695430755615,
0.3273272216320038,
-0.899256706237793,
0.07089557498693466,
0.6884106993675232,
0.5126244425773621,
-0.09603847563266754,
0.8708559274673462,
0.05273338779807091,
-0.09399059414863586,
-0.13476331532001495,
-0.045727189630270004,
0.20448966324329376,
-0.23370519280433655,
-0.5730522871017456,
0.23205280303955078,
0.14663220942020416,
-0.2920730412006378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11622v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11622v1
|
Continuous Predictive Modeling of Clinical Notes and ICD Codes in Patient Health Records
| 2024-05-19T17:23:04 | 2024-05-19T17:23:04 |
Mireia Hernandez Caralt, Clarence Boon Liang Ng, Marek Rei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7; J.3
|
Electronic Health Records (EHR) serve as a valuable source of patient
information, offering insights into medical histories, treatments, and
outcomes. Previous research has developed systems for detecting applicable ICD
codes that should be assigned while writing a given EHR document, mainly
focusing on discharge summaries written at the end of a hospital stay. In this
work, we investigate the potential of predicting these codes for the whole
patient stay at different time points during their stay, even before they are
officially assigned by clinicians. The development of methods to predict
diagnoses and treatments earlier in advance could open opportunities for
predictive medicine, such as identifying disease risks sooner, suggesting
treatments, and optimizing resource allocation. Our experiments show that
predictions regarding final ICD codes can be made already two days after
admission and we propose a custom model that improves performance on this early
prediction task.
|
[
-0.15654920041561127,
-0.34421902894973755,
1.141689419746399,
-0.08727008104324341,
-0.4323013424873352,
0.08703742921352386,
-0.08421625196933746,
-0.6330298781394958,
0.2476045936346054,
0.6835430860519409,
-0.41532641649246216,
-0.5783646702766418,
-0.38612252473831177,
-0.12064414471387863,
-0.18012920022010803,
1.087440013885498,
-0.3190304636955261,
0.14359906315803528,
-0.2877960205078125,
0.07269172370433807,
-0.6008065938949585,
-0.928883969783783,
-0.43054232001304626,
-0.4706418514251709,
0.41732850670814514,
0.22097806632518768,
0.24093633890151978,
0.6736994981765747,
1.0276716947555542,
0.1400391310453415,
0.05208076536655426,
-0.20643146336078644,
0.16127483546733856,
0.11440969258546829,
0.30733275413513184,
-0.48818379640579224,
-0.5886557102203369,
-0.4721187651157379,
0.3038136661052704,
0.3842231333255768,
-0.7352333068847656,
0.19257612526416779,
-0.1661609560251236,
0.22158250212669373,
-0.09068012982606888,
0.0788796991109848,
-0.3140142261981964,
0.2263491153717041,
-0.2828153371810913,
-0.5485855937004089,
-0.6080216765403748,
-0.436509907245636,
0.1995912343263626,
-0.4656021296977997,
0.38563135266304016,
-0.044436629861593246,
0.8219714760780334,
0.021814212203025818,
-0.09565714001655579,
-0.2861326336860657,
-0.9172055125236511,
0.4590469300746918,
-0.6634597182273865,
0.340996116399765,
0.2991252541542053,
0.6610612869262695,
-0.15242229402065277,
-0.9061890244483948,
-0.37726089358329773,
-0.31845995783805847,
-0.3766772747039795,
0.1704445332288742,
0.02043372206389904,
0.39501598477363586,
0.3679656982421875,
0.11449331790208817,
-0.4299435317516327,
0.0065066576935350895,
-0.5354442596435547,
0.14520196616649628,
0.507311224937439,
0.5327827334403992,
0.40560153126716614,
-0.11144953966140747,
-0.23540446162223816,
0.4487747251987457,
-0.3780210018157959,
0.13079321384429932,
-0.4877738654613495,
-0.02243945747613907,
-0.5757061839103699,
0.4529138207435608,
0.0740118995308876,
0.26720130443573,
0.37945449352264404,
-0.37751051783561707,
0.19432193040847778,
-0.04912450164556503,
-0.1163208857178688,
0.3345741331577301,
0.40232744812965393,
0.4350517690181732,
0.022806191816926003,
-0.019090767949819565,
-0.3971867263317108,
0.4588932991027832,
0.41689276695251465,
-0.711222231388092,
-0.6797232627868652,
0.44603201746940613,
-0.9326026439666748,
-0.3096112906932831,
-0.29766297340393066,
-0.6151642203330994,
-0.15897734463214874,
-0.588154137134552,
-0.01168162189424038,
-0.4113733470439911,
0.184956893324852,
0.05509904772043228,
0.3347049653530121,
-0.4600745439529419,
0.5811506509780884,
-0.7062236666679382,
0.6134995222091675,
0.4946787655353546,
0.9361087083816528,
-0.34149983525276184,
0.008602983318269253,
-0.45280104875564575,
0.25631996989250183,
-0.5303122401237488,
0.780034065246582,
-0.42579686641693115,
-0.7340656518936157,
0.0844610407948494,
0.04624634236097336,
-0.006337789818644524,
-0.37268924713134766,
0.5928494930267334,
-0.6365044713020325,
-0.21002592146396637,
0.2306705117225647,
-0.595719575881958,
0.22521884739398956,
0.03158525004982948,
-0.8481438159942627,
0.2096145749092102,
0.4157332479953766,
-0.6823321580886841,
0.41014403104782104,
-0.5957616567611694,
-0.45782071352005005,
0.4122947156429291,
-0.19862860441207886,
-0.9741768836975098,
0.23524746298789978,
-0.020177079364657402,
0.45705077052116394,
0.040974657982587814,
0.4752081036567688,
-0.029563918709754944,
-0.14396971464157104,
0.39747586846351624,
0.2848253846168518,
0.2273443192243576,
0.4454972445964813,
0.14525343477725983,
-0.10483385622501373,
-0.6135201454162598,
0.10942388325929642,
-0.15922874212265015,
-0.5727769732475281,
-0.265270859003067,
0.29290270805358887,
0.06405651569366455,
0.24881619215011597,
-0.0071451375260949135,
-0.45706164836883545,
0.1415083259344101,
0.13876020908355713,
0.06463401764631271,
0.6313546895980835,
0.5591722726821899,
0.08853413164615631,
-0.8938586711883545,
1.0979491472244263,
0.22050727903842926,
0.31976187229156494,
-0.7970321178436279,
-0.5207433104515076,
-0.26586201786994934,
-0.17608746886253357,
0.38855794072151184,
0.38124510645866394,
-0.040751487016677856,
0.21658127009868622,
-0.4608311951160431,
-0.4207053482532501,
-0.29027900099754333,
-0.30330127477645874,
0.5760113000869751,
0.48359084129333496,
0.519444465637207,
-0.3867053985595703,
-0.7818268537521362,
-0.39378395676612854,
0.10343459993600845,
-0.42784321308135986,
-0.11182738840579987,
0.2751316726207733,
0.3840559422969818,
-0.3995426893234253,
0.5683445334434509,
-0.7163404822349548,
-0.3535354435443878,
-0.37674668431282043,
0.07047095149755478,
0.33348798751831055,
0.5403999090194702,
0.31198424100875854,
-0.553292453289032,
-0.7606807351112366,
0.29384762048721313,
-0.5850257277488708,
0.032357681542634964,
-0.5157723426818848,
0.09694243967533112,
-0.10347318649291992,
0.5155117511749268,
-0.30919545888900757,
0.6199101209640503,
0.3097086548805237,
-0.23007579147815704,
0.375858873128891,
-0.6863487362861633,
0.28172892332077026,
-0.7027928829193115,
-0.12903796136379242,
0.09352777898311615,
-0.17787757515907288,
-0.7339909672737122,
-0.45318683981895447,
0.19598862528800964,
-0.22653725743293762,
-0.0032816282473504543,
0.3571091592311859,
-0.40215176343917847,
0.2242128849029541,
0.14650502800941467,
-0.3807356357574463,
0.07905062288045883,
0.08744272589683533,
0.3157484531402588,
0.19874244928359985,
0.04732149839401245,
-0.5679990649223328,
-0.3332884907722473,
0.39073067903518677,
-0.6394612789154053,
0.14092566072940826,
-0.726607084274292,
0.06478095799684525,
-0.23809704184532166,
0.5073498487472534,
-0.5914306044578552,
-0.3509877920150757,
-0.15342138707637787,
-0.5314292311668396,
0.3795747458934784,
-0.26321789622306824,
-0.2140933722257614,
-0.5743979811668396,
0.09440714865922928,
0.47455787658691406,
0.7927910685539246,
-0.24032293260097504,
0.6352694630622864,
0.39350858330726624,
-0.5071007013320923,
0.09102208912372589,
-0.5097851157188416,
-0.18296624720096588,
-0.16487471759319305,
-0.16525021195411682,
0.835602343082428,
-0.21823695302009583,
-0.4830981492996216,
0.09608356654644012,
0.40877100825309753,
-0.09180354326963425,
0.1197744607925415,
0.5961537957191467,
0.8722299933433533,
-0.22876180708408356,
0.2826731204986572,
0.17850038409233093,
-0.22847825288772583,
0.08089795708656311,
-0.35355648398399353,
0.42319244146347046,
0.38689011335372925,
-0.516852080821991,
-0.7210643291473389,
0.6186454892158508,
0.6804864406585693,
-0.4486728012561798,
0.538859486579895,
0.0856395959854126,
-0.9507426023483276,
0.028544388711452484,
-0.5748767256736755,
-0.036219723522663116,
-0.3233864903450012,
0.18720674514770508,
-0.22189906239509583,
-0.1553376019001007,
0.8683730363845825,
0.14337316155433655,
0.0413951613008976,
0.2685500979423523,
0.5186814069747925,
-0.16827012598514557,
1.293829083442688,
0.8808647990226746,
0.2344028651714325,
0.42127344012260437,
-0.05058033764362335,
0.3691078722476959,
-0.9906869530677795,
-0.7537693381309509,
-0.5165851712226868,
0.1308554857969284,
-0.5743907690048218,
-0.32498911023139954,
0.5807256102561951,
0.32817909121513367,
-0.0805918276309967,
-0.05083358660340309,
-0.6146482825279236,
0.32060104608535767,
0.003037029644474387,
0.4580417573451996,
0.10292118787765503,
-0.17161890864372253,
-0.09772133827209473,
-0.19829846918582916,
-0.3434842526912689,
-0.5043808817863464,
1.2907840013504028,
0.43541228771209717,
0.43623918294906616,
-0.19901393353939056,
0.9337510466575623,
0.5843786597251892,
0.7565010190010071,
-0.31712615489959717,
-0.031941041350364685,
-0.2994391620159149,
-0.2843177914619446,
0.09225276112556458,
0.14049531519412994,
-0.639157772064209,
-0.408265084028244,
0.03234636411070824,
-0.8315376043319702,
0.25258925557136536,
0.3272147476673126,
-0.9987652897834778,
0.2140125036239624,
-0.6758483648300171,
0.5537695288658142,
-0.4176581799983978,
0.12980744242668152,
-0.21186694502830505,
-0.6671417951583862,
-0.030106473714113235,
-0.5029420852661133,
0.4944666922092438,
-0.054772160947322845,
0.08399123698472977,
0.8787686824798584,
-0.5620344877243042,
0.3662963807582855,
-0.02575901709496975,
0.23013564944267273,
0.29067230224609375,
-0.007533029653131962,
0.3372317850589752,
0.26476937532424927,
0.019018400460481644,
0.03613552451133728,
0.2795654833316803,
-0.14887359738349915,
-0.39898768067359924,
0.4915343225002289,
-0.6002963185310364,
-0.12688662111759186,
-0.421878844499588,
-0.025591980665922165,
0.19598716497421265,
0.18923145532608032,
0.4004814922809601,
0.9057081341743469,
-0.05437178537249565,
-0.34887683391571045,
0.7132568955421448,
-0.25442588329315186,
0.35802873969078064,
0.5691115856170654,
-0.15468554198741913,
-0.25903451442718506,
0.5475830435752869,
0.16502727568149567,
-0.02357284165918827,
0.5638681650161743,
0.33998262882232666,
-0.06700611859560013,
-0.894364058971405,
-0.12493570894002914,
0.1856377273797989,
-0.6846729516983032,
-0.2677609920501709,
-0.9852167367935181,
-0.07329276949167252,
-0.34750398993492126,
-0.7272520065307617,
0.1787831038236618,
0.08655677735805511,
-0.5186181664466858,
-0.1998719871044159,
0.3027510643005371,
0.8393882513046265,
-0.05669642239809036,
0.3833060562610626,
-1.1255642175674438,
0.3258635103702545,
-0.39130380749702454,
0.4355749487876892,
-0.22317767143249512,
-0.3286471664905548,
-0.608835756778717,
-0.1896154135465622,
-0.08601215481758118,
-0.7742868661880493,
0.6088343262672424,
0.07748613506555557,
0.6396713852882385,
0.6779653429985046,
-0.11710891127586365,
0.4041326344013214,
-0.8115792870521545,
0.7663258910179138,
0.620826780796051,
-0.5327445864677429,
0.898213803768158,
-0.4700789451599121,
0.13889102637767792,
0.40027469396591187,
0.3276396095752716,
-0.5967557430267334,
0.011353434063494205,
-0.7252875566482544,
-0.5946115851402283,
0.5571650862693787,
-0.3999161720275879,
-0.2694868743419647,
-0.2132682353258133,
0.569909930229187,
0.07548488676548004,
0.09705883264541626,
-0.2793452739715576,
-0.13291288912296295,
-0.0083364462479949,
-0.337959885597229,
-0.23889271914958954,
-0.4112096130847931,
0.045944757759571075,
-0.17654918134212494,
0.11947402358055115,
0.21070308983325958,
0.5886396169662476,
0.21497809886932373,
0.27991294860839844,
-0.6175710558891296,
0.1753237098455429,
0.5920712351799011,
0.9594792127609253,
-0.5588439702987671,
-0.24118982255458832,
0.06449877470731735,
-0.7161524295806885,
0.1589173972606659,
0.19657185673713684,
-0.007525946479290724,
0.39445894956588745,
0.42364051938056946,
0.5692748427391052,
0.11640185117721558,
-0.7589479684829712,
0.35415661334991455,
-0.14927558600902557,
0.06352399289608002,
-1.0084736347198486,
-0.07990910857915878,
-0.27175191044807434,
0.0867401733994484,
0.09118951857089996,
0.16512493789196014,
-0.02296684868633747,
-0.3795243501663208,
0.6728432774543762,
-0.19495610892772675,
-0.623283326625824,
-0.5411719679832458,
1.060278296470642,
-0.15884925425052643,
-0.6355682015419006,
0.4884682595729828,
0.04757310822606087,
-0.6469376683235168,
1.0161025524139404,
0.6569640636444092,
0.7677444815635681,
-0.7324550151824951,
0.057225871831178665,
0.41859543323516846,
-0.3011796474456787,
-0.01966145820915699,
0.3009800612926483,
0.10843408852815628,
-0.3414440155029297,
-0.24772219359874725,
-0.6354329586029053,
-0.18030209839344025,
0.008040438406169415,
-1.0288352966308594,
0.7963008284568787,
-0.6865569353103638,
-0.39431679248809814,
0.1579500138759613,
0.08082682639360428,
-0.6894658207893372,
0.5839832425117493,
0.46240249276161194,
0.6631543636322021,
-0.735130250453949,
0.7140477895736694,
0.5912541747093201,
-0.223989799618721,
-0.8069658279418945,
-0.04295163229107857,
0.06066172569990158,
-0.18276658654212952,
0.5032913684844971,
0.029519597068428993,
0.2717720568180084,
-0.19865994155406952,
0.016680032014846802,
-0.6187587380409241,
1.0983902215957642,
-0.39002296328544617,
-0.8855735659599304,
-0.44780662655830383,
-0.3648977279663086,
0.738476574420929,
-0.7232464551925659,
0.41119521856307983,
0.7087019681930542,
-0.10124658048152924,
-0.03178069368004799,
-0.8824883699417114,
-0.014518693089485168,
-0.4090370833873749,
-0.12078269571065903,
0.4622449278831482,
-0.17129522562026978,
1.3039350509643555,
-0.8619974255561829,
-0.11071305721998215,
0.028502464294433594,
0.2839713394641876,
0.34897154569625854,
0.713169515132904,
0.16374832391738892,
0.4350140690803528,
0.8482212424278259,
-0.07314193248748779,
1.4815186262130737,
-0.47699689865112305,
-0.044887956231832504,
0.9813458323478699,
-0.37479105591773987,
0.9125819206237793,
-0.0018753006588667631,
-0.27053937315940857,
0.7960513234138489,
0.727803647518158,
-0.15242929756641388,
0.9765211343765259,
0.34597858786582947,
-0.5932031869888306,
-0.03599061444401741,
-0.24649597704410553,
-0.7633454203605652,
-0.12945538759231567,
0.6656562685966492,
-0.48283034563064575,
0.3721892237663269,
0.15031792223453522,
0.10959786176681519,
-0.0070740520022809505,
-0.36216819286346436,
0.7992793321609497,
0.17861948907375336,
-1.0345966815948486,
0.23174729943275452,
0.0324796624481678,
0.16390754282474518,
-0.42682504653930664,
-0.31495851278305054,
-0.000368983339285478,
0.5490201115608215,
-0.34227317571640015,
-0.349875807762146,
-0.07243660092353821,
-0.11433076858520508,
-0.3885924518108368,
-0.32475927472114563,
0.4504307806491852,
-0.38214918971061707,
-0.5026681423187256,
0.19519758224487305,
-0.03809431940317154,
-0.1307951658964157,
0.4601830542087555,
-0.4050825834274292,
-0.06953206658363342,
0.05028808116912842,
0.1041809618473053,
0.39037778973579407,
0.4150097370147705,
-0.12069020420312881,
0.6738619804382324,
0.6095333695411682,
0.6095108985900879,
-0.02882278338074684,
0.10082169622182846,
0.9285088777542114,
-0.3112266957759857,
-1.022676706314087,
-0.6487956643104553,
0.672049343585968,
0.27573397755622864,
-0.28538891673088074,
-0.0006622881046496332,
0.4606890380382538,
0.6061229705810547,
-0.024614788591861725,
1.1739848852157593,
0.19090406596660614,
1.0997589826583862,
-0.6269472241401672,
0.6650254130363464,
-0.2858964502811432,
0.44492584466934204,
-0.3069690465927124,
-0.12533476948738098,
-0.24179524183273315,
0.19149164855480194,
-0.2108910232782364,
-0.17711974680423737,
0.9660577178001404,
0.26041296124458313,
0.19120994210243225,
-0.1412152498960495,
0.022815974429249763,
-0.18799453973770142,
0.7889392971992493,
0.5938010215759277,
0.6020458936691284,
-0.0950004830956459,
0.058678608387708664,
-0.6178710460662842,
-0.10467397421598434,
-0.653532862663269,
-0.5470479726791382,
-0.6592379808425903,
-0.5956491231918335,
-0.42328116297721863,
-0.5241208076477051,
0.21233725547790527,
0.8490443825721741,
0.5100879073143005,
-1.0092567205429077,
0.049972109496593475,
-0.018155917525291443,
-0.2381773740053177,
-0.07063129544258118,
-0.05952524393796921,
0.6934426426887512,
0.16933052241802216,
-0.09657669067382812,
-0.14390389621257782,
0.09950390458106995,
0.5660699605941772,
0.29715490341186523,
-0.17639358341693878,
0.17592483758926392,
-0.14553870260715485,
0.21402794122695923,
0.10880839079618454,
-0.6154600977897644,
-0.04879876226186752,
0.2340964674949646,
-0.27080145478248596,
0.114164799451828,
1.2507333755493164,
-0.6586543917655945,
0.5280311107635498,
0.28570643067359924,
0.10644599795341492,
0.4014887809753418,
0.515536904335022,
0.46759217977523804,
0.09770490229129791,
-0.16425539553165436,
0.7202104330062866,
0.43044164776802063,
0.06058622896671295,
-0.7454899549484253,
-0.013682063668966293,
-0.1312238872051239,
-0.6444150805473328,
-0.8631404638290405,
-0.17008520662784576,
-0.6017385125160217,
0.13540683686733246,
0.5703650116920471,
-0.5707544088363647,
0.12996406853199005,
-0.4762810170650482,
0.10273173451423645,
0.19372496008872986,
-0.31895601749420166,
0.9470303654670715,
0.23649053275585175,
-0.5174364447593689,
-0.07878310978412628,
-0.8072144389152527,
0.9452642202377319,
-0.08824151009321213,
-0.960712194442749,
-0.24641519784927368,
0.43065568804740906,
0.11440473049879074,
0.29167598485946655,
1.1664023399353027,
-0.27596744894981384,
0.6285606622695923,
-0.10624358057975769,
-0.08890005201101303,
0.36114057898521423,
-0.6922205686569214,
-0.19606055319309235,
-0.06583861261606216,
0.06571019440889359,
-0.42387938499450684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11613v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11613v2
|
Decoding by Contrasting Knowledge: Enhancing LLMs' Confidence on Edited Facts
| 2024-05-19T17:08:31 | 2024-05-21T04:52:32 |
Baolong Bi, Shenghua Liu, Lingrui Mei, Yiwei Wang, Pengliang Ji, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The knowledge within large language models (LLMs) may become outdated
quickly. While in-context editing (ICE) is currently the most effective method
for knowledge editing (KE), it is constrained by the black-box modeling of LLMs
and thus lacks interpretability. Our work aims to elucidate the superior
performance of ICE on the KE by analyzing the impacts of in-context new
knowledge on token-wise distributions. We observe that despite a significant
boost in logits of the new knowledge, the performance of is still hindered by
stubborn knowledge. Stubborn knowledge refers to as facts that have gained
excessive confidence during pretraining, making it hard to edit effectively. To
address this issue and further enhance the performance of ICE, we propose a
novel approach termed $\textbf{De}$coding by $\textbf{C}$ontrasting
$\textbf{K}$nowledge (DeCK). DeCK derives the distribution of the next token by
contrasting the logits obtained from the newly edited knowledge guided by ICE
with those from the unedited parametric knowledge. Our experiments consistently
demonstrate that DeCK enhances the confidence of LLMs in edited facts. For
instance, it improves the performance of LLaMA3-8B-instruct on MQuAKE by up to
219%, demonstrating its capability to strengthen ICE in the editing of stubborn
knowledge. Our work paves the way to develop the both effective and accountable
KE methods for LLMs. (The source code is available at:
https://deck-llm.meirtz.com)
|
[
-0.13028673827648163,
-0.6822599172592163,
0.5486209988594055,
-0.0038157831877470016,
-0.6270075440406799,
0.32953548431396484,
-0.3437480330467224,
-0.4231513738632202,
0.24507488310337067,
0.38328471779823303,
-0.19131650030612946,
-0.8612129092216492,
-0.789391815662384,
0.10068152099847794,
-0.27596646547317505,
0.8857841491699219,
-0.08276194334030151,
0.012687101028859615,
-0.3346754014492035,
-0.1337665468454361,
-0.5446041226387024,
-0.7243998050689697,
-0.4656589925289154,
-0.49858394265174866,
0.26807913184165955,
0.4661942720413208,
0.6438487768173218,
0.7746123671531677,
0.34938448667526245,
0.2744905948638916,
-0.5377707481384277,
0.16330620646476746,
-0.5919490456581116,
0.026352105662226677,
-0.19790054857730865,
-0.7459039092063904,
-0.5249171257019043,
-0.15823955833911896,
0.7145726680755615,
0.3804681897163391,
-0.15616384148597717,
-0.12181048840284348,
0.24596227705478668,
0.50437992811203,
-0.7781381011009216,
0.318832129240036,
-0.943777859210968,
-0.16685514152050018,
-0.22328054904937744,
-0.4442727863788605,
-0.5162044763565063,
-0.10786494612693787,
-0.08004273474216461,
-0.5965362787246704,
-0.05931468307971954,
-0.04458419233560562,
0.600213885307312,
0.415545791387558,
-0.37416595220565796,
-0.3853428065776825,
-0.39443662762641907,
0.6636666059494019,
-0.826302707195282,
0.4863940179347992,
0.3102998435497284,
-0.049228183925151825,
-0.23491686582565308,
-0.7115699648857117,
-0.6776247620582581,
-0.055547427386045456,
-0.17041118443012238,
-0.032499104738235474,
-0.21791085600852966,
0.08211787045001984,
0.16183234751224518,
0.22646397352218628,
0.11595378816127777,
0.386997789144516,
-0.133896604180336,
-0.23893985152244568,
0.5235608220100403,
0.21752387285232544,
0.09926488250494003,
-0.3407388925552368,
-0.12129674106836319,
-0.23116372525691986,
-0.9038695096969604,
0.10083910077810287,
0.2740013301372528,
-0.03412899002432823,
-0.2122437208890915,
0.6213132739067078,
-0.2881268262863159,
0.5315192341804504,
0.3907946050167084,
-0.5144729614257812,
0.3711172938346863,
0.096230149269104,
-0.29749956727027893,
0.21150463819503784,
0.3296108543872833,
0.7346315979957581,
-0.3120947778224945,
-0.20137900114059448,
-0.198528453707695,
-0.12529268860816956,
-0.1149078756570816,
-0.78363037109375,
-0.4440893530845642,
-0.10427404195070267,
-0.5481085181236267,
-0.3326687812805176,
-0.13881289958953857,
-0.7627121210098267,
-0.7099524736404419,
-0.4106329083442688,
0.49435797333717346,
-0.45518484711647034,
-0.1631539762020111,
0.29509201645851135,
-0.4272505044937134,
0.06575999408960342,
0.4585120677947998,
-0.7047743201255798,
0.15130074322223663,
0.8174699544906616,
0.688775897026062,
-0.07761512696743011,
-0.09804429113864899,
-0.5886971354484558,
0.3130916655063629,
-0.2595459520816803,
0.7764647006988525,
-0.7295540571212769,
-0.2457445114850998,
-0.09423082321882248,
-0.4074985980987549,
0.1511814296245575,
-0.5529725551605225,
0.4915215075016022,
-0.7516599893569946,
-0.16250796616077423,
-0.4345301687717438,
-0.8336554169654846,
-0.1193532794713974,
0.2445889413356781,
-0.5297747850418091,
0.8412463665008545,
-0.09241288900375366,
-1.1220120191574097,
0.5688366889953613,
-0.58204185962677,
-0.414249986410141,
-0.1086781844496727,
-0.16446872055530548,
-0.1313454657793045,
0.2844979763031006,
0.2519262135028839,
0.5376426577568054,
-0.1728379726409912,
0.1702946424484253,
-0.32608094811439514,
-0.395227313041687,
0.34225454926490784,
-0.3568311929702759,
0.6770920753479004,
0.23392124474048615,
-0.3547840416431427,
-0.11144524067640305,
-0.942851722240448,
-0.15604650974273682,
-0.3081451654434204,
-0.632317066192627,
-0.548989474773407,
0.04151337966322899,
-0.48458951711654663,
-0.03366135433316231,
0.030402692034840584,
-0.5271005034446716,
0.278140664100647,
-0.40618276596069336,
0.24361471831798553,
0.9754843711853027,
0.2176368236541748,
0.5267296433448792,
-0.1995975226163864,
0.430971622467041,
0.1510290801525116,
0.005718990694731474,
0.09612017869949341,
-0.20690079033374786,
-0.6705933809280396,
-0.3808647692203522,
0.5026233792304993,
0.6354045867919922,
-1.098063349723816,
0.22810164093971252,
-0.4846417307853699,
-0.47401514649391174,
-0.5860521793365479,
0.33682575821876526,
0.34756895899772644,
0.7264018058776855,
0.5148584842681885,
-0.2574136257171631,
-0.5758035778999329,
-0.7601660490036011,
-0.5240305066108704,
-0.1406949758529663,
-0.02078060433268547,
0.21972079575061798,
0.293771356344223,
-0.17761921882629395,
0.7713742852210999,
-0.6031032204627991,
-0.01248319074511528,
-0.2021309733390808,
0.18661653995513916,
0.18413063883781433,
0.5917873382568359,
0.38300374150276184,
-0.5258712768554688,
-0.5748612284660339,
-0.15928177535533905,
-0.7051396369934082,
-0.21835950016975403,
-0.0501457042992115,
-0.295350044965744,
0.3524901866912842,
0.8034692406654358,
-0.680722177028656,
0.5358657836914062,
0.3612084686756134,
-0.4092444181442261,
0.5008540153503418,
-0.23440539836883545,
0.2766454815864563,
-0.9081138372421265,
-0.08184219896793365,
-0.5097323060035706,
-0.0012348718009889126,
-0.643343985080719,
0.0932113528251648,
0.14589214324951172,
0.43799296021461487,
-0.5852444171905518,
0.4758547842502594,
-0.578846275806427,
0.3242964446544647,
-0.16525781154632568,
0.07028781622648239,
-0.056597474962472916,
0.5025460124015808,
0.010874290019273758,
0.3820180892944336,
0.46547049283981323,
-0.6798697113990784,
0.25245824456214905,
0.4137139320373535,
-0.7845574021339417,
0.7460150718688965,
-0.2958858013153076,
0.3814176917076111,
-0.3842218518257141,
0.1855747103691101,
-0.6300238966941833,
-0.05630219727754593,
0.3659595251083374,
-0.24120458960533142,
0.768057107925415,
-0.29176703095436096,
-0.6047781705856323,
0.08767490833997726,
-0.42306599020957947,
0.49211034178733826,
0.6657935976982117,
-0.703140139579773,
0.687678337097168,
0.4590923488140106,
-0.026624243706464767,
-0.926405131816864,
-0.8878662586212158,
0.27108609676361084,
-0.5169219374656677,
-0.48350492119789124,
0.4787209630012512,
-0.23834110796451569,
-0.7211688160896301,
0.1622343212366104,
-0.3493601381778717,
-0.00701651256531477,
0.18169353902339935,
0.016293112188577652,
0.09326225519180298,
0.06715675443410873,
0.14736078679561615,
0.2723265290260315,
-0.12220525741577148,
0.09965268522500992,
-0.18026529252529144,
0.24196550250053406,
0.17707373201847076,
-0.2697676122188568,
-0.35462483763694763,
0.07911127805709839,
0.34606096148490906,
0.029535405337810516,
1.132826566696167,
0.3068080544471741,
-0.246223583817482,
-0.13457977771759033,
-0.698523759841919,
-0.021459177136421204,
-0.508560299873352,
0.24287168681621552,
-0.5747614502906799,
-0.9651286005973816,
0.5397523641586304,
-0.12350530177354813,
0.05071420967578888,
0.4629749655723572,
0.39522668719291687,
-0.15689514577388763,
0.5546042919158936,
0.6304669380187988,
-0.0654865950345993,
0.3930855691432953,
-0.08880789577960968,
0.18490900099277496,
-0.7500306367874146,
-0.5628098845481873,
-0.4833025634288788,
-0.4123952090740204,
-0.4789106547832489,
-0.5018718242645264,
0.4403027594089508,
0.41984274983406067,
0.09877334535121918,
0.02814832143485546,
-0.09125114977359772,
0.6794490814208984,
0.41180580854415894,
0.32386067509651184,
0.4125654399394989,
0.01186742726713419,
-0.2675633728504181,
-0.1813802421092987,
-1.0397969484329224,
-0.24166853725910187,
1.334242820739746,
0.26036009192466736,
0.9770894646644592,
0.09807999432086945,
0.8816013336181641,
0.44132888317108154,
0.5131465792655945,
-0.47530460357666016,
0.4493350684642792,
-0.033330418169498444,
-0.32177409529685974,
-0.16610701382160187,
-0.4771668612957001,
-0.665181040763855,
0.11672641336917877,
-0.3614831566810608,
-0.6856619715690613,
0.2542751431465149,
0.43738701939582825,
-0.15298351645469666,
0.7163755893707275,
-0.7984809279441833,
0.6747186183929443,
-0.00736777251586318,
-0.2951214611530304,
-0.5791738629341125,
-0.7262668609619141,
0.3189623951911926,
-0.12325800210237503,
0.49871325492858887,
0.12685906887054443,
0.04593774303793907,
0.7754318714141846,
-0.3123225271701813,
0.9824294447898865,
-0.4209863841533661,
-0.20270416140556335,
0.4151589274406433,
0.2820705771446228,
0.8582306504249573,
0.15810729563236237,
-0.2476038783788681,
0.2115960419178009,
0.04096224904060364,
-0.26931753754615784,
-0.8544268608093262,
0.6092634201049805,
-0.6436652541160583,
-0.8139461278915405,
-0.10071941465139389,
-0.6492868661880493,
-0.1178952232003212,
-0.03102579154074192,
0.26763075590133667,
0.5332362651824951,
-0.09216134250164032,
0.4573430120944977,
0.6946126818656921,
-0.3210296034812927,
0.29590484499931335,
0.4689585864543915,
0.1268255114555359,
-0.4633439779281616,
0.5929788947105408,
0.2641470432281494,
0.3205093741416931,
0.9564961791038513,
0.09873854368925095,
-0.37686657905578613,
-0.8953235149383545,
-0.0130679402500391,
0.06082506477832794,
-1.239479899406433,
-0.4680386483669281,
-0.7203851342201233,
-0.005877531599253416,
-0.3106975555419922,
-0.26681458950042725,
-0.18136456608772278,
-0.6595153212547302,
-0.22123202681541443,
-0.4533637464046478,
0.468508780002594,
0.7526384592056274,
-0.5543514490127563,
0.4433002173900604,
-0.74934983253479,
0.1923510581254959,
0.1481255143880844,
0.47465813159942627,
-0.1394326090812683,
-0.7973330616950989,
-0.5327714681625366,
0.04256775975227356,
-0.010323300957679749,
-1.0319976806640625,
0.11216863989830017,
0.03211386501789093,
0.7628654837608337,
0.38585957884788513,
0.25155049562454224,
0.9282626509666443,
-0.18693894147872925,
0.5593056678771973,
0.005826437845826149,
-1.3039530515670776,
0.21943312883377075,
0.02417483925819397,
0.2537531554698944,
0.5853342413902283,
0.05992355942726135,
-0.6022464632987976,
-0.6723136305809021,
-0.8588672876358032,
-0.7517496943473816,
0.8099416494369507,
0.09877018630504608,
0.20296278595924377,
-0.05363590270280838,
0.5928727388381958,
0.3296186327934265,
0.4263398349285126,
-0.6905015707015991,
-0.3592595160007477,
-0.1816861480474472,
-0.2083287239074707,
-0.21437641978263855,
-0.833204448223114,
-0.1005953699350357,
-0.4440716803073883,
0.7690094709396362,
0.16563086211681366,
0.14510375261306763,
0.1412905901670456,
-0.3794516921043396,
0.04449107497930527,
0.4509553611278534,
0.4968079924583435,
0.646744966506958,
-0.2683143615722656,
0.7046133875846863,
0.7599095702171326,
-0.24879808723926544,
0.01033802144229412,
-0.1951274871826172,
-0.39058810472488403,
-0.019798940047621727,
0.6159437894821167,
0.8133605122566223,
0.44625380635261536,
-0.595831573009491,
0.30823415517807007,
0.09212003648281097,
-0.22162072360515594,
0.1352996528148651,
0.17046581208705902,
0.015617654658854008,
0.3020528256893158,
0.07380308210849762,
0.26817989349365234,
-0.02861665189266205,
-0.3930397629737854,
0.2354700267314911,
0.3235473334789276,
0.13723918795585632,
-0.2995213568210602,
0.4329187273979187,
0.14461496472358704,
-0.12901510298252106,
0.6454407572746277,
-0.3432372510433197,
-0.5671618580818176,
0.28288519382476807,
0.49345847964286804,
0.7059497833251953,
-0.13651522994041443,
-0.004114721901714802,
0.38436564803123474,
0.28699585795402527,
0.09635795652866364,
0.06649866700172424,
-0.1926274448633194,
-0.8922420740127563,
-0.4957876205444336,
-0.4185487627983093,
-0.14733387529850006,
0.2198658287525177,
-0.6283640265464783,
0.34433770179748535,
-0.47510212659835815,
0.06960473209619522,
-0.4454881250858307,
-0.17550808191299438,
-0.8401164412498474,
0.08688744157552719,
-0.08578675985336304,
1.1327581405639648,
-0.7405666708946228,
0.7280460596084595,
0.4653129577636719,
0.10149877518415451,
-0.854228138923645,
0.08406170457601547,
-0.012796272523701191,
-0.7495004534721375,
0.5479255318641663,
-0.07886761426925659,
-0.043269846588373184,
0.00011635952250799164,
-0.6185272336006165,
-0.9114665985107422,
1.0861127376556396,
0.6137505769729614,
-0.47017717361450195,
0.27784329652786255,
-0.07294175028800964,
0.4921075999736786,
-0.19972114264965057,
0.07339483499526978,
0.7289372682571411,
0.5862236618995667,
0.19921137392520905,
-0.8015171885490417,
0.08849821984767914,
-0.14862671494483948,
-0.3429761230945587,
0.10722489655017853,
-0.5335192680358887,
0.5320601463317871,
-0.14311730861663818,
-0.24661612510681152,
-0.25072750449180603,
0.6394248008728027,
0.043405771255493164,
0.26465335488319397,
0.5655394792556763,
0.6901479363441467,
0.9536686539649963,
0.26026612520217896,
0.897652804851532,
-0.3090885579586029,
0.04369455203413963,
1.2854530811309814,
0.06324081867933273,
0.8674206733703613,
0.7047834992408752,
-0.028560036793351173,
0.7718084454536438,
0.3748219311237335,
0.14190106093883514,
0.8181133270263672,
0.1725650280714035,
-0.35316070914268494,
-0.25020453333854675,
0.03058915212750435,
-0.29926246404647827,
0.4925205707550049,
0.17321117222309113,
-0.21344901621341705,
-0.18961161375045776,
-0.10427181422710419,
0.4730711281299591,
0.1337982714176178,
-0.42040276527404785,
0.8509653210639954,
0.03918612003326416,
-0.7455167770385742,
0.7134203910827637,
0.4120253920555115,
0.6050882935523987,
-0.459297776222229,
-0.01815345697104931,
-0.23885022103786469,
0.09104885905981064,
-0.2559208571910858,
-0.819736897945404,
0.47922906279563904,
0.141502246260643,
0.02427702583372593,
-0.3109121024608612,
0.738939642906189,
-0.45440876483917236,
-0.31067705154418945,
0.16268017888069153,
0.38001370429992676,
0.22998443245887756,
-0.036472566425800323,
-0.38295042514801025,
0.18615885078907013,
0.22845539450645447,
-0.13147328794002533,
0.2935948669910431,
0.6896909475326538,
0.10656895488500595,
0.7059286236763,
0.48992159962654114,
-0.0472419410943985,
0.0787351131439209,
-0.09295722097158432,
0.9460049271583557,
-0.5653483867645264,
-0.6644089818000793,
-1.2043548822402954,
0.704468309879303,
0.038866639137268066,
-0.035298239439725876,
0.7835813760757446,
0.5752351880073547,
0.9265784025192261,
-0.08517952263355255,
0.6362897753715515,
-0.21271444857120514,
0.18165192008018494,
-0.986977756023407,
0.5936609506607056,
-0.3892005681991577,
0.5670542120933533,
-0.3074260354042053,
-0.6402245759963989,
-0.34118255972862244,
0.264256089925766,
-0.31417226791381836,
-0.37317168712615967,
0.7901256680488586,
0.9026646614074707,
0.13571810722351074,
-0.18860767781734467,
0.2682788074016571,
0.5261030197143555,
0.2394416332244873,
0.5175930857658386,
0.9852936863899231,
-0.13368119299411774,
0.646491527557373,
-0.4028572738170624,
-0.278883159160614,
-0.04092807322740555,
-1.150633454322815,
-1.1247988939285278,
-0.48876115679740906,
-0.32597675919532776,
-0.33240243792533875,
0.10032962262630463,
0.9755920767784119,
0.4508349299430847,
-0.5581502318382263,
0.013713506050407887,
-0.006836578715592623,
0.44394174218177795,
-0.18266427516937256,
-0.11111747473478317,
0.5785374641418457,
-0.1677001416683197,
-0.46707674860954285,
0.5101291537284851,
0.049764566123485565,
0.136089488863945,
0.3708422780036926,
-0.4578664004802704,
0.054663509130477905,
-0.009313574992120266,
0.5604835748672485,
-0.05814105644822121,
-0.5087557435035706,
-0.4021097421646118,
-0.24997133016586304,
0.1629714071750641,
0.1335957795381546,
0.8822915554046631,
-0.6604912877082825,
0.4704705476760864,
0.5975727438926697,
0.6930635571479797,
0.5894899368286133,
0.056459371000528336,
0.5260680913925171,
-0.8367992639541626,
0.2301550954580307,
0.02006451226770878,
0.3377316892147064,
0.33462581038475037,
-0.5953372120857239,
0.29281026124954224,
0.3827672302722931,
-0.2868976891040802,
-0.8507364392280579,
-0.02825661562383175,
-0.7616558074951172,
-0.4202496409416199,
1.2658039331436157,
-0.17509356141090393,
-0.07885003089904785,
-0.1033952534198761,
-0.26763713359832764,
0.4340280294418335,
-0.38954275846481323,
1.12161123752594,
1.0656120777130127,
-0.1415373831987381,
-0.21746249496936798,
-0.09959204494953156,
0.8371502757072449,
0.4508444666862488,
-0.6844343543052673,
0.12869973480701447,
0.6057838797569275,
0.47902995347976685,
-0.20633001625537872,
0.6693926453590393,
-0.027518384158611298,
0.11106854677200317,
0.1561291664838791,
0.013971160165965557,
-0.309083491563797,
-0.3319907784461975,
-0.4693179428577423,
0.21797974407672882,
0.38140663504600525,
0.019448980689048767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11597v1
|
Language Reconstruction with Brain Predictive Coding from fMRI Data
| 2024-05-19T16:06:02 | 2024-05-19T16:06:02 |
Congchi Yin, Ziyi Ye, Piji Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Many recent studies have shown that the perception of speech can be decoded
from brain signals and subsequently reconstructed as continuous language.
However, there is a lack of neurological basis for how the semantic information
embedded within brain signals can be used more effectively to guide language
reconstruction. The theory of predictive coding suggests that human brain
naturally engages in continuously predicting future word representations that
span multiple timescales. This implies that the decoding of brain signals could
potentially be associated with a predictable future. To explore the predictive
coding theory within the context of language reconstruction, this paper
proposes a novel model \textsc{PredFT} for jointly modeling neural decoding and
brain prediction. It consists of a main decoding network for language
reconstruction and a side network for predictive coding. The side network
obtains brain predictive coding representation from related brain regions of
interest with a multi-head self-attention module. This representation is fused
into the main decoding network with cross-attention to facilitate the language
models' generation process. Experiments are conducted on the largest
naturalistic language comprehension fMRI dataset Narratives. \textsc{PredFT}
achieves current state-of-the-art decoding performance with a maximum BLEU-1
score of $27.8\%$.
|
[
-0.43851548433303833,
-0.6831530332565308,
0.38231849670410156,
0.298711359500885,
-0.2521333396434784,
-0.1750543862581253,
-0.343779981136322,
-0.4205095171928406,
0.5272404551506042,
0.5827598571777344,
-0.7817239165306091,
-0.13669736683368683,
-0.39715418219566345,
0.11363301426172256,
-0.5209291577339172,
0.9166166186332703,
0.23161233961582184,
0.06674609333276749,
-0.2062722146511078,
0.21206679940223694,
-0.5466247797012329,
-0.7544416785240173,
-0.6583067774772644,
-0.39396587014198303,
0.33213967084884644,
-0.2014012634754181,
0.5167238712310791,
0.6469026803970337,
0.19187459349632263,
0.2859552502632141,
0.3719714283943176,
-0.4201498031616211,
-0.38350772857666016,
-0.158638134598732,
-0.1544838696718216,
-0.24900349974632263,
-0.6525080800056458,
-0.16168415546417236,
0.570501446723938,
0.7492935061454773,
-0.220023974776268,
-0.2262611985206604,
0.199357271194458,
0.48109379410743713,
-0.24236945807933807,
0.2593836188316345,
-0.5394933223724365,
-0.03354015201330185,
0.047807954251766205,
-0.5485950112342834,
-0.3725222945213318,
-0.07042612880468369,
0.09194760769605637,
-0.3645901381969452,
0.2941628396511078,
0.021872971206903458,
0.5782757997512817,
0.19125725328922272,
-0.28600332140922546,
-0.1854427307844162,
-0.6190611124038696,
0.46907728910446167,
-0.6208755373954773,
0.583646833896637,
0.7989414930343628,
0.13902951776981354,
-0.28588154911994934,
-0.8357059955596924,
-0.6399421095848083,
-0.10087307542562485,
-0.2545338273048401,
0.26758456230163574,
-0.27450427412986755,
0.08059746026992798,
-0.08309197425842285,
0.198036327958107,
-0.7859318852424622,
-0.20941537618637085,
-0.37406641244888306,
-0.43724191188812256,
0.47267478704452515,
0.16963185369968414,
0.30552938580513,
-0.25376155972480774,
-0.41040974855422974,
-0.12190813571214676,
-0.38146883249282837,
-0.26147714257240295,
0.18169468641281128,
0.1501755565404892,
-0.104233518242836,
0.19941815733909607,
-0.16788774728775024,
0.7153498530387878,
0.06202152371406555,
0.03790118917822838,
0.28772759437561035,
-0.5102847814559937,
-0.2503037750720978,
0.11820419132709503,
0.8381054997444153,
0.2961515188217163,
0.4130033850669861,
-0.2892519533634186,
-0.1934286206960678,
0.40009424090385437,
0.24641947448253632,
-0.516480028629303,
-0.47656485438346863,
0.15922531485557556,
-0.6011356711387634,
-0.1123475581407547,
-0.42973312735557556,
-0.7325804233551025,
-0.144015371799469,
-0.3288760185241699,
0.3220939040184021,
-0.760737955570221,
-0.6637653708457947,
0.4964950382709503,
0.4135443866252899,
0.03249659761786461,
-0.15660804510116577,
-0.8587464690208435,
0.27280256152153015,
0.31679269671440125,
0.49539920687675476,
-0.0644826740026474,
-0.5519974231719971,
-0.14673523604869843,
0.1602754443883896,
-0.14274947345256805,
0.8198013305664062,
-0.16969019174575806,
-0.1494876891374588,
-0.0558653324842453,
-0.07140777260065079,
-0.09555349498987198,
-0.052928078919649124,
0.3799695074558258,
-0.7765105962753296,
0.08513181656599045,
-0.07567831128835678,
-0.41170039772987366,
-0.19127623736858368,
0.25533661246299744,
-0.931547224521637,
0.06111495569348335,
-0.023418908938765526,
-0.927778422832489,
0.011720240116119385,
-0.4221987724304199,
-0.6159003376960754,
0.09477400034666061,
-0.21236200630664825,
-0.34036609530448914,
0.042613063007593155,
0.3774166703224182,
0.4861622452735901,
-0.25886330008506775,
0.5812951326370239,
-0.22912052273750305,
-0.19185182452201843,
0.3769744634628296,
-0.4399634599685669,
0.6013648509979248,
0.2770846486091614,
-0.03648398816585541,
0.04642978310585022,
-0.7273297905921936,
0.00009205596143146977,
0.08311610668897629,
-0.18395212292671204,
-0.12734781205654144,
0.006188858766108751,
0.13285624980926514,
0.30372995138168335,
0.15516594052314758,
-0.45887717604637146,
-0.227806955575943,
-0.37999770045280457,
0.42504361271858215,
0.5311796069145203,
-0.010145321488380432,
0.4262225329875946,
-0.2742455005645752,
0.7132046818733215,
0.01968858577311039,
-0.2871467173099518,
-0.378903865814209,
-0.04598524048924446,
-0.5566227436065674,
-0.07427022606134415,
0.37764182686805725,
0.42061057686805725,
-0.7642145156860352,
0.36087286472320557,
-0.6618757843971252,
-0.06880538910627365,
-0.3820323348045349,
-0.43753087520599365,
0.3782716691493988,
0.41520360112190247,
0.5259302854537964,
-0.17907382547855377,
-0.9825198650360107,
-0.9153985977172852,
-0.12833788990974426,
-0.09610482305288315,
-0.0991017296910286,
-0.09534952789545059,
0.21924267709255219,
-0.37999093532562256,
1.0078858137130737,
-0.40614038705825806,
-0.6071999669075012,
-0.3942372798919678,
0.09463246166706085,
0.24143342673778534,
0.7450230121612549,
0.40619057416915894,
-0.681061327457428,
-0.20304623246192932,
-0.03070046193897724,
-0.7488114237785339,
0.23627911508083344,
-0.12743070721626282,
0.003438574029132724,
0.23102445900440216,
0.5794477462768555,
-0.4079509377479553,
0.41736868023872375,
0.7637341618537903,
-0.4048084020614624,
0.43787989020347595,
-0.4041154682636261,
0.22437112033367157,
-1.165196418762207,
0.05291697755455971,
-0.24718861281871796,
-0.06391897052526474,
-0.5852972865104675,
-0.3924464285373688,
0.02865244634449482,
-0.11257834732532501,
0.14390350878238678,
0.3107450306415558,
-0.7362406253814697,
-0.10466843843460083,
-0.4058683216571808,
-0.36512264609336853,
-0.18897785246372223,
0.691157341003418,
0.418042927980423,
0.5287522077560425,
0.6704968214035034,
-0.35163548588752747,
0.1002146527171135,
0.19455353915691376,
-0.39156532287597656,
0.2107156366109848,
-0.6020504832267761,
0.30674418807029724,
-0.4303456246852875,
0.5577333569526672,
-0.8306675553321838,
-0.16416402161121368,
-0.08469406515359879,
-0.6979092955589294,
0.4298669099807739,
0.15373530983924866,
-0.1955835223197937,
-0.3037964999675751,
0.2191895842552185,
0.7851232290267944,
0.512765645980835,
-0.2488390952348709,
0.8367528915405273,
0.5434512495994568,
-0.1311796009540558,
-0.6275110244750977,
-0.9431153535842896,
0.04008914530277252,
0.09120092540979385,
-0.44447457790374756,
0.4126860797405243,
-0.15806332230567932,
0.24831266701221466,
0.21975672245025635,
0.09584372490644455,
-0.02382199652493,
-0.29420217871665955,
0.273678719997406,
0.10345541685819626,
-0.3018280863761902,
-0.09292315691709518,
-0.0007773233228363097,
-0.25804582238197327,
0.2915706932544708,
-0.5413383841514587,
0.7832223773002625,
-0.014451845549046993,
-0.019708096981048584,
-0.2122655212879181,
0.5514907836914062,
0.38880714774131775,
-0.6228854656219482,
0.5149247050285339,
0.6190887093544006,
-0.8157798051834106,
0.024819599464535713,
-0.5484762191772461,
-0.38702020049095154,
-0.43275994062423706,
0.7005525231361389,
-0.7711654901504517,
-0.6925159096717834,
0.46368536353111267,
0.2629888653755188,
-0.6143841743469238,
0.25687211751937866,
0.38950836658477783,
-0.0361197367310524,
0.8787088990211487,
0.7857204079627991,
-0.05781497806310654,
0.4136143624782562,
-0.322768896818161,
0.051373228430747986,
-0.6931964159011841,
-0.2169230878353119,
-0.11605657637119293,
-0.013214151374995708,
-0.2545890212059021,
-0.2270818054676056,
0.05932874605059624,
0.07504772394895554,
0.2525964379310608,
0.5515266060829163,
-0.13792197406291962,
0.47209063172340393,
0.383046418428421,
0.2997782826423645,
0.21942584216594696,
0.29474782943725586,
-0.11753392964601517,
-0.005966881290078163,
-0.7484083771705627,
-0.22076213359832764,
1.1395736932754517,
0.19489380717277527,
0.5271347165107727,
-0.43982237577438354,
0.7369095683097839,
0.03463635593652725,
0.3351551592350006,
-0.4513340890407562,
0.5547523498535156,
-0.21496738493442535,
-0.5939838290214539,
-0.21469245851039886,
-0.33609408140182495,
-1.0026519298553467,
0.05562683567404747,
-0.33323678374290466,
-0.6092206239700317,
0.24877169728279114,
0.19631975889205933,
-0.5467721819877625,
0.12155863642692566,
-0.5997770428657532,
0.7814511060714722,
-0.03594261780381203,
-0.30511048436164856,
-0.522308886051178,
-0.7950443625450134,
0.3059295117855072,
-0.35484743118286133,
0.25309017300605774,
0.019639205187559128,
0.3754160702228546,
0.6721935868263245,
0.1317674070596695,
0.7850742936134338,
-0.08292030543088913,
0.04304775223135948,
0.05555042624473572,
0.10141679644584656,
0.10615991055965424,
0.1632741242647171,
-0.200928196310997,
0.2572736442089081,
0.2817334830760956,
-0.3357177674770355,
-0.4336441159248352,
0.7820261120796204,
-0.6197657585144043,
-0.32838132977485657,
-0.5268846154212952,
-0.7008578777313232,
-0.26858747005462646,
0.3926672041416168,
0.6103001832962036,
0.5889716744422913,
-0.6080186367034912,
-0.22048810124397278,
0.38436633348464966,
-0.14630305767059326,
0.5540885329246521,
0.22544847428798676,
-0.28321290016174316,
-0.6544836759567261,
0.9241207838058472,
0.01384222973138094,
-0.11945969611406326,
0.686755895614624,
-0.1372898817062378,
-0.37761011719703674,
-0.8939229846000671,
0.02137826383113861,
0.28863295912742615,
-0.4955880641937256,
-0.39567214250564575,
-0.8075351119041443,
-0.16197431087493896,
-0.559921383857727,
0.016214609146118164,
-0.3306434154510498,
-0.02350614406168461,
-0.19001957774162292,
-0.05379535257816315,
-0.09708253294229507,
0.6341216564178467,
-0.308661550283432,
0.27048754692077637,
-0.7904407978057861,
0.36980247497558594,
0.06523897498846054,
0.4370127022266388,
-0.06386739760637283,
-0.10408101230859756,
-0.4270862936973572,
0.2616276443004608,
0.3352455496788025,
-0.8171393275260925,
0.8728681802749634,
0.05251840502023697,
0.42026206851005554,
-0.002881978638470173,
0.17272509634494781,
0.5636314749717712,
-0.6852439045906067,
0.2752818465232849,
0.4205082356929779,
-0.7398795485496521,
0.4755787253379822,
-0.2308797836303711,
0.6502888202667236,
0.3725984990596771,
0.3382285535335541,
-0.3259198069572449,
-0.20479324460029602,
-0.4435640275478363,
-0.5063726305961609,
0.7541055679321289,
0.12281650304794312,
0.07737316191196442,
-0.23820242285728455,
0.247174933552742,
0.26878029108047485,
-0.12505170702934265,
-0.6062137484550476,
0.11685457080602646,
-0.4322679340839386,
-0.371562123298645,
-0.46554434299468994,
-0.3126194179058075,
-0.009540985338389874,
-0.21500180661678314,
0.27755481004714966,
-0.18624642491340637,
0.9051925539970398,
0.15301349759101868,
-0.06932370364665985,
-0.0054468438029289246,
0.03635454550385475,
0.5691823959350586,
0.5946159958839417,
-0.3684162199497223,
0.16429854929447174,
0.04249490797519684,
-0.5013254284858704,
-0.04102836549282074,
0.39598843455314636,
0.3048308193683624,
-0.19007188081741333,
0.4550819396972656,
0.9114107489585876,
-0.08651380985975266,
-0.2721084654331207,
0.5405541062355042,
-0.4543708860874176,
-0.05669550970196724,
-0.7900477051734924,
-0.4301092028617859,
0.31577175855636597,
0.37870344519615173,
0.4990657866001129,
0.4762042760848999,
0.22314883768558502,
-0.33918190002441406,
0.45308175683021545,
0.17791615426540375,
-0.08870124816894531,
-0.7733343243598938,
0.7260393500328064,
0.12382922321557999,
-0.325016587972641,
0.6355969309806824,
0.09463503211736679,
-0.47697725892066956,
0.5086086392402649,
0.920638918876648,
0.8653699159622192,
-0.3417273461818695,
-0.16024327278137207,
0.6035647392272949,
0.03333408012986183,
-0.05114753171801567,
0.40957948565483093,
-0.032601453363895416,
-1.0787837505340576,
-0.6658459305763245,
-0.9149055480957031,
0.4002740979194641,
0.1313703954219818,
-0.562789797782898,
0.10135012120008469,
-0.28771743178367615,
-0.26940998435020447,
-0.19862303137779236,
-0.2785794734954834,
-0.6829792261123657,
0.6399211883544922,
0.3812231123447418,
0.635141134262085,
-0.6783261299133301,
1.5798664093017578,
0.40792667865753174,
-0.40928322076797485,
-0.7868128418922424,
0.26475706696510315,
-0.5559737086296082,
-0.6058548092842102,
0.4636276066303253,
0.2850269079208374,
-0.4392073452472687,
0.504909098148346,
-0.18852980434894562,
-1.0005494356155396,
0.8887730836868286,
0.7192397117614746,
-0.4041854441165924,
-0.5480077862739563,
-0.06264840811491013,
0.5426033735275269,
-0.5873878002166748,
0.049069251865148544,
0.5529873371124268,
0.1334104835987091,
-0.09451021999120712,
-0.9140047430992126,
0.20195165276527405,
-0.25588634610176086,
0.09548104554414749,
0.0071227955631911755,
-0.12312328070402145,
0.6878297924995422,
-0.21607714891433716,
-0.44235965609550476,
0.007505074609071016,
0.9227383732795715,
0.0563507005572319,
0.15085004270076752,
0.4080122411251068,
0.2368593066930771,
0.26326993107795715,
0.06581028550863266,
1.157810926437378,
-0.5341247320175171,
0.35337039828300476,
1.0011682510375977,
0.18663692474365234,
0.8864384293556213,
0.48218223452568054,
-0.08038660138845444,
0.4354843199253082,
0.3821702301502228,
0.44890907406806946,
0.9383484125137329,
-0.03554606810212135,
-0.005716062616556883,
-0.2962014377117157,
0.06954911351203918,
-0.5613622069358826,
0.7323887944221497,
0.37552523612976074,
-0.3984659016132355,
0.10450248420238495,
0.41771766543388367,
-0.23257701098918915,
0.19377411901950836,
-0.20493240654468536,
0.5576351881027222,
0.10688960552215576,
-0.9513670206069946,
0.8410961031913757,
-0.037413615733385086,
0.7670213580131531,
-0.6751400828361511,
-0.0024953335523605347,
-0.25204017758369446,
0.47415032982826233,
-0.01434155460447073,
-0.513881504535675,
0.5439300537109375,
-0.7350887656211853,
-0.19849567115306854,
-0.4157959818840027,
0.8510368466377258,
-0.8628383278846741,
-0.23011985421180725,
0.5205464959144592,
0.35448890924453735,
-0.009413368068635464,
-0.13694190979003906,
-0.38769593834877014,
0.19377531111240387,
0.13915275037288666,
-0.1247066780924797,
0.35957539081573486,
0.12210354954004288,
0.23171161115169525,
0.5201264023780823,
0.5446417331695557,
-0.04370751231908798,
0.09818600118160248,
-0.14856018126010895,
0.8387836813926697,
-0.7283743023872375,
-0.9651730060577393,
-0.649722695350647,
0.49490222334861755,
0.23990757763385773,
0.022760696709156036,
0.2331238090991974,
0.32601597905158997,
0.8357182741165161,
-0.44527336955070496,
0.6809987425804138,
-0.08785737305879593,
0.3451337218284607,
-0.6512287855148315,
0.8967980742454529,
-0.3026462197303772,
-0.1637372076511383,
-0.18429073691368103,
-0.6829472780227661,
-0.27851614356040955,
0.7074201107025146,
-0.3018418252468109,
0.10796982795000076,
1.0775146484375,
0.7719621062278748,
-0.042420823127031326,
0.2954137623310089,
0.4740216135978699,
0.15205645561218262,
-0.04002305492758751,
0.905832827091217,
0.6411424279212952,
-0.26258108019828796,
0.654556393623352,
-0.24073870480060577,
-0.2192586064338684,
-0.04384792596101761,
-0.7489580512046814,
-0.6463142037391663,
-1.062608003616333,
-0.18092668056488037,
-0.45624879002571106,
0.06615584343671799,
0.7569180130958557,
0.7518718838691711,
-0.8479539155960083,
-0.37386924028396606,
-0.28168344497680664,
-0.46326783299446106,
-0.24799588322639465,
-0.12518727779388428,
0.4485809803009033,
-0.09355268627405167,
-0.6702291369438171,
0.6157126426696777,
0.1256895363330841,
0.04085160419344902,
-0.3060767948627472,
-0.27780187129974365,
-0.32538431882858276,
-0.12946444749832153,
0.5372186303138733,
0.24607506394386292,
-0.4828595519065857,
-0.1552247852087021,
0.03571484982967377,
-0.15139709413051605,
-0.019467147067189217,
0.8971976637840271,
-1.1882206201553345,
0.4067786633968353,
0.5761062502861023,
0.7695984244346619,
0.9400657415390015,
-0.22357697784900665,
1.090049386024475,
-0.48424357175827026,
0.20294570922851562,
0.4247891306877136,
0.5071516036987305,
0.4788018763065338,
-0.4213705360889435,
0.23470261693000793,
0.03763483837246895,
-0.3525112271308899,
-0.5789018869400024,
0.4704987108707428,
-0.9919438362121582,
-0.29932284355163574,
0.974173903465271,
-0.26033374667167664,
-0.4599394202232361,
-0.0203144159168005,
-0.03833852335810661,
0.5580227971076965,
-0.12275335192680359,
0.5319496989250183,
0.6589617729187012,
-0.13145554065704346,
-0.40399765968322754,
-0.22198161482810974,
0.41563984751701355,
0.48791858553886414,
-0.49610039591789246,
0.09395354241132736,
0.6150076389312744,
0.38255226612091064,
0.19146107137203217,
1.0525052547454834,
-0.12940272688865662,
0.29366055130958557,
0.2646847367286682,
0.09879176318645477,
-0.1501290202140808,
-0.36537736654281616,
-0.479272723197937,
0.4066249430179596,
-0.25133800506591797,
-0.25574302673339844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11582v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11582v2
|
SLAB: Efficient Transformers with Simplified Linear Attention and Progressive Re-parameterized Batch Normalization
| 2024-05-19T15:22:25 | 2024-06-17T05:59:24 |
Jialong Guo, Xinghao Chen, Yehui Tang, Yunhe Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Transformers have become foundational architectures for both natural language
and computer vision tasks. However, the high computational cost makes it quite
challenging to deploy on resource-constraint devices. This paper investigates
the computational bottleneck modules of efficient transformer, i.e.,
normalization layers and attention modules. LayerNorm is commonly used in
transformer architectures but is not computational friendly due to statistic
calculation during inference. However, replacing LayerNorm with more efficient
BatchNorm in transformer often leads to inferior performance and collapse in
training. To address this problem, we propose a novel method named PRepBN to
progressively replace LayerNorm with re-parameterized BatchNorm in training.
Moreover, we propose a simplified linear attention (SLA) module that is simple
yet effective to achieve strong performance. Extensive experiments on image
classification as well as object detection demonstrate the effectiveness of our
proposed method. For example, our SLAB-Swin obtains $83.6\%$ top-1 accuracy on
ImageNet-1K with $16.2$ms latency, which is $2.4$ms less than that of
Flatten-Swin with $0.1\%$ higher accuracy. We also evaluated our method for
language modeling task and obtain comparable performance and lower
latency.Codes are publicly available at https://github.com/xinghaochen/SLAB and
https://github.com/mindspore-lab/models/tree/master/research/huawei-noah/SLAB.
|
[
-0.5473992824554443,
-0.5730025768280029,
0.20120662450790405,
0.4132750630378723,
-0.3088069260120392,
-0.34620019793510437,
-0.2937679588794708,
-0.28910231590270996,
0.07630019634962082,
0.7284120321273804,
-0.41316401958465576,
-0.12885914742946625,
-0.4811614453792572,
-0.23290744423866272,
-0.2601868510246277,
0.7333387732505798,
0.0011542163556441665,
-0.1886288821697235,
-0.07484107464551926,
-0.2761136591434479,
-0.3934037387371063,
0.019764764234423637,
-0.9086531400680542,
-0.30601024627685547,
0.4821655750274658,
0.1042146384716034,
0.7145156860351562,
0.8330309391021729,
0.857277512550354,
0.4102182984352112,
0.23984172940254211,
0.14607450366020203,
-0.47157105803489685,
-0.09721678495407104,
-0.23561900854110718,
-0.4429510831832886,
-0.4933326244354248,
-0.11991804093122482,
0.5267303586006165,
0.6490918397903442,
-0.016421610489487648,
0.4146290719509125,
-0.08269025385379791,
0.7515331506729126,
-0.7997872233390808,
0.17297321557998657,
-0.7404609322547913,
0.12511160969734192,
-0.30026882886886597,
-0.25143247842788696,
-0.6098236441612244,
0.05863035470247269,
0.0473465695977211,
-0.5359019637107849,
0.7477770447731018,
0.07444653660058975,
0.9161605834960938,
0.7541520595550537,
-0.0712897777557373,
0.021471217274665833,
-0.9289177060127258,
1.0480272769927979,
-0.6010052561759949,
0.7506241202354431,
0.04929273948073387,
0.49914172291755676,
0.0386662557721138,
-1.298791766166687,
-0.47719606757164,
-0.13665473461151123,
-0.22617670893669128,
0.28589120507240295,
-0.027193518355488777,
0.20034514367580414,
0.3381582796573639,
0.4818321168422699,
-0.32219257950782776,
0.014805325306952,
-0.4677693843841553,
-0.1684214174747467,
0.23667898774147034,
0.15861789882183075,
0.2931421995162964,
-0.056436602026224136,
-0.6127857565879822,
-0.238933727145195,
-0.49647849798202515,
0.2794399857521057,
0.08045634627342224,
0.25837644934654236,
-0.06646879017353058,
0.19085641205310822,
-0.05649888888001442,
0.9054095149040222,
-0.09113579243421555,
-0.3445303738117218,
0.21570459008216858,
-0.19294483959674835,
-0.310676246881485,
-0.26282915472984314,
0.6005224585533142,
0.12671740353107452,
0.14816822111606598,
-0.32572081685066223,
-0.3776121139526367,
0.3643544316291809,
0.9643855094909668,
-0.8813009858131409,
-0.4173198640346527,
0.2759636640548706,
-0.28609520196914673,
-0.1895822286605835,
-0.4426858425140381,
-0.6409316062927246,
0.030360691249370575,
-0.3777164816856384,
0.3845715820789337,
-0.21452051401138306,
0.07990357279777527,
0.16784517467021942,
0.14098520576953888,
0.4660421907901764,
0.35798969864845276,
-0.8344069719314575,
0.451119989156723,
0.44644302129745483,
0.6511932611465454,
-0.19796432554721832,
0.05208979919552803,
-0.30378419160842896,
0.10201672464609146,
-0.2995438575744629,
0.7920806407928467,
-0.08956510573625565,
0.0941290408372879,
-0.3533770442008972,
-0.09037931263446808,
-0.15907640755176544,
-0.6006414890289307,
0.8006729483604431,
-0.6155590415000916,
0.039774179458618164,
0.3547906279563904,
-0.05885354056954384,
0.09191250056028366,
0.29444074630737305,
-0.9285961389541626,
1.060335397720337,
0.25141680240631104,
-0.6920678615570068,
0.015612639486789703,
-0.5177837610244751,
-0.46450984477996826,
0.42393967509269714,
-0.30794233083724976,
-0.6287416219711304,
-0.07286223769187927,
0.4660164415836334,
0.547942042350769,
-0.6554170846939087,
0.3198900818824768,
0.15893930196762085,
-0.5086168050765991,
0.05502745881676674,
-0.26341110467910767,
0.6311875581741333,
0.17935629189014435,
-0.6048575639724731,
-0.009783080779016018,
-0.6869522333145142,
0.21670278906822205,
-0.07419103384017944,
-0.2613326907157898,
0.07049081474542618,
-0.2339925765991211,
0.3126557767391205,
0.11789383739233017,
-0.0032203758601099253,
-0.5393221378326416,
-0.15252210199832916,
-0.44476035237312317,
0.47772300243377686,
0.6861754059791565,
-0.3548859655857086,
0.5886223912239075,
-0.15991400182247162,
0.36502978205680847,
-0.213693767786026,
0.3217291235923767,
-0.04366767406463623,
-0.38636520504951477,
-0.8899934887886047,
-0.5664256811141968,
0.31761085987091064,
0.5168121457099915,
-0.7986864447593689,
0.11593475192785263,
-0.47870105504989624,
-0.42895540595054626,
-0.6692700982093811,
0.3342452645301819,
0.6541200876235962,
0.6645004749298096,
0.5178918838500977,
-0.4270625710487366,
-0.6883872151374817,
-1.1877659559249878,
-0.27031487226486206,
0.17304512858390808,
-0.3128225803375244,
0.39175450801849365,
-0.041784461587667465,
-0.42798617482185364,
0.966362714767456,
-0.6083800196647644,
-0.603736162185669,
-0.4127599000930786,
-0.023839253932237625,
0.3584286570549011,
0.655912458896637,
0.4265563189983368,
-1.0468554496765137,
-0.4231624901294708,
-0.06424591690301895,
-0.3901541233062744,
-0.08961128443479538,
-0.19894763827323914,
-0.05768657475709915,
-0.04234191030263901,
0.5212634801864624,
-0.6494007706642151,
0.5769080519676208,
0.22311852872371674,
0.42739102244377136,
0.33322542905807495,
0.05295873060822487,
-0.23742614686489105,
-0.9353799819946289,
0.13326425850391388,
0.2015366554260254,
-0.3046165406703949,
-1.0579078197479248,
0.23746629059314728,
0.3435406982898712,
-0.2643725574016571,
-0.7695838809013367,
0.4211607873439789,
-0.3249633014202118,
0.04276709631085396,
-0.20530614256858826,
0.16408671438694,
0.14470772445201874,
1.1160427331924438,
-0.0858951136469841,
0.6198580265045166,
0.376848042011261,
-0.7839986681938171,
0.3928724527359009,
-0.029917053878307343,
-0.3494158387184143,
0.3336324393749237,
-0.8799186944961548,
0.1958557814359665,
-0.30402520298957825,
0.2985588312149048,
-1.0408601760864258,
-0.12849430739879608,
0.1595882773399353,
-0.15599985420703888,
0.4356210231781006,
0.03604637086391449,
-0.05431707575917244,
-0.40527576208114624,
-0.3341105580329895,
0.8411546349525452,
0.5756287574768066,
-0.5523950457572937,
1.0422804355621338,
0.3183526396751404,
0.2628924548625946,
-0.8196604251861572,
-0.8630737066268921,
-0.047545209527015686,
0.04484700411558151,
-0.6030436754226685,
0.8266811370849609,
0.04884684458374977,
0.04628148302435875,
-0.09849020093679428,
-0.3676636517047882,
-0.1906556487083435,
-0.2317473441362381,
0.18812093138694763,
0.1884651482105255,
-0.17253108322620392,
-0.10670385509729385,
-0.35410213470458984,
-0.37557873129844666,
-0.13303206861019135,
-0.2128864824771881,
0.7065859436988831,
-0.2983177900314331,
0.010049139149487019,
-0.6773964762687683,
-0.03967642784118652,
0.4675813615322113,
-0.2231585532426834,
0.47739145159721375,
1.0449706315994263,
-0.39956673979759216,
-0.5042535066604614,
-0.9339216947555542,
-0.25201526284217834,
-0.573427140712738,
0.497774213552475,
-0.5354358553886414,
-0.620830774307251,
0.45463064312934875,
-0.14409904181957245,
0.019141361117362976,
0.2581108808517456,
0.3673744797706604,
-0.18482211232185364,
0.5476241111755371,
0.5029392242431641,
0.08306750655174255,
0.3838244676589966,
-0.61449134349823,
0.5828468203544617,
-1.1886695623397827,
-0.16613221168518066,
-0.3603958487510681,
-0.6451524496078491,
-0.3817394971847534,
-0.6327008008956909,
0.3316671848297119,
0.021350214257836342,
-0.02934892661869526,
0.6692445874214172,
-0.5362246632575989,
0.31170058250427246,
0.3530197739601135,
0.4719810485839844,
-0.10413089394569397,
-0.034834593534469604,
0.06040525436401367,
-0.1835799664258957,
-0.7664206624031067,
-0.16844870150089264,
0.9462138414382935,
0.41314154863357544,
0.8116662502288818,
-0.013806491158902645,
0.28294843435287476,
0.1423507034778595,
0.35986992716789246,
-0.7538758516311646,
0.7442634105682373,
-0.3651238679885864,
-0.2796061038970947,
-0.36412012577056885,
-0.43152081966400146,
-0.888369083404541,
0.2557036280632019,
0.06259653717279434,
-0.5379452109336853,
0.26135674118995667,
0.28157177567481995,
-0.27372118830680847,
0.4017919600009918,
-0.6906909346580505,
0.8091530799865723,
0.00030945450998842716,
-0.43581730127334595,
-0.08471386879682541,
-0.6562079787254333,
0.34261125326156616,
-0.05716085806488991,
0.04012206196784973,
-0.006583319045603275,
-0.051976125687360764,
0.5781636238098145,
-0.3306694030761719,
0.8811087012290955,
-0.17873677611351013,
0.09670985490083694,
0.17811371386051178,
-0.25628066062927246,
0.5036857724189758,
0.19062085449695587,
0.14812414348125458,
0.029920190572738647,
-0.5485045313835144,
-0.6611112952232361,
-0.9974639415740967,
0.6226849555969238,
-0.7746795415878296,
-0.691896378993988,
0.19437918066978455,
-0.7821272611618042,
-0.16770051419734955,
0.23672088980674744,
0.27016761898994446,
0.9832027554512024,
0.22353090345859528,
0.5749155282974243,
0.9022307991981506,
-0.031199418008327484,
0.4769568145275116,
0.1068900004029274,
0.1439673900604248,
-0.29847875237464905,
0.8621384501457214,
0.015274913050234318,
0.24591009318828583,
0.6177970170974731,
0.06695584207773209,
-0.19583626091480255,
-0.6052185893058777,
-0.4541056156158447,
-0.014853054657578468,
-0.6242654323577881,
-0.4450647532939911,
-0.830920934677124,
-0.37924498319625854,
-0.3754463195800781,
-0.2437480390071869,
-0.7777875065803528,
-0.3859718441963196,
0.11775617301464081,
0.18874762952327728,
-0.06693271547555923,
0.16359198093414307,
0.5259746313095093,
0.5425004363059998,
-0.2855207622051239,
0.8558821678161621,
0.5359643697738647,
0.5677515268325806,
0.03082612156867981,
-0.5153855681419373,
-0.19302015006542206,
-0.11225483566522598,
-0.13566656410694122,
-0.32937750220298767,
0.3044324815273285,
0.2407928705215454,
0.584398090839386,
0.3295069932937622,
0.1851292848587036,
0.794381320476532,
-0.39910829067230225,
0.4445762634277344,
0.11370856314897537,
-0.7995436787605286,
0.25964784622192383,
0.0161892157047987,
0.5000013709068298,
0.48894089460372925,
0.18802055716514587,
-0.23691391944885254,
-0.37581098079681396,
-0.4172176420688629,
-1.0647249221801758,
0.7797445058822632,
0.3452434837818146,
0.19399090111255646,
0.38645365834236145,
0.43184614181518555,
-0.2673511505126953,
-0.014738040044903755,
-0.817238450050354,
-0.3204183876514435,
-0.33709582686424255,
-0.1532241404056549,
0.06975255161523819,
-0.3037026524543762,
-0.0418151393532753,
-0.4184645116329193,
0.576360821723938,
-0.049496352672576904,
0.24981534481048584,
0.31514668464660645,
-0.47815027832984924,
0.20544391870498657,
0.11023248732089996,
0.5834246277809143,
0.5804561376571655,
-0.3337433338165283,
0.4025348722934723,
0.4420432150363922,
-0.9380630850791931,
0.11269143968820572,
-0.2932678759098053,
-0.19799961149692535,
-0.09047494828701019,
0.4166397452354431,
0.944510817527771,
0.5544464588165283,
-0.4656606614589691,
0.40469276905059814,
-0.20734721422195435,
-0.0013699346454814076,
-0.41931235790252686,
-0.011125029064714909,
0.04826798662543297,
0.06215697154402733,
0.40683406591415405,
0.5794633030891418,
0.030947932973504066,
-0.20893017947673798,
0.22916361689567566,
0.16627638041973114,
-0.3805595338344574,
-0.10080978274345398,
0.48024705052375793,
0.1390678435564041,
-0.5877735018730164,
0.641390323638916,
-0.028824644163250923,
-0.44170495867729187,
0.701418399810791,
0.6944172978401184,
0.7305660843849182,
-0.34519508481025696,
-0.03362327814102173,
0.2387687861919403,
0.5319256782531738,
0.13554207980632782,
-0.08563919365406036,
-0.09387773275375366,
-1.0078853368759155,
-0.5625987648963928,
-0.6883581280708313,
-0.14616332948207855,
0.28227663040161133,
-0.47158172726631165,
0.2702529728412628,
-0.7064089775085449,
-0.2020324319601059,
0.136326402425766,
-0.1767009049654007,
-0.9912874698638916,
0.5589517951011658,
-0.17266398668289185,
0.6905425786972046,
-0.45048072934150696,
1.0157724618911743,
0.7075319886207581,
-0.0009540586615912616,
-0.9404862523078918,
-0.2713332772254944,
-0.5687877535820007,
-0.5564841628074646,
0.7493306994438171,
0.36916583776474,
-0.3844603896141052,
0.11556924879550934,
-0.19192513823509216,
-0.5912072658538818,
1.1330724954605103,
0.4112302362918854,
-0.3644045293331146,
0.18330462276935577,
0.47811615467071533,
0.5769968628883362,
-0.3994689881801605,
0.5734701752662659,
0.4575560986995697,
0.3221815228462219,
0.125629261136055,
-0.5833727717399597,
0.00988779217004776,
-0.4785206913948059,
0.5487689971923828,
0.24322685599327087,
-0.6410220265388489,
0.8934741616249084,
0.11371321231126785,
-0.35497134923934937,
-0.40543168783187866,
0.6041441559791565,
-0.08532970398664474,
0.09710574895143509,
0.7838934659957886,
0.8749808073043823,
0.17339690029621124,
-0.17917180061340332,
0.8970368504524231,
-0.26420289278030396,
0.20571887493133545,
0.9245521426200867,
-0.03663458302617073,
0.6364635825157166,
0.5967409014701843,
-0.27801790833473206,
0.4086587131023407,
0.1162947341799736,
0.14071619510650635,
0.5287458300590515,
0.2936532199382782,
-0.19406236708164215,
-0.13129962980747223,
-0.03216303512454033,
-0.1544872224330902,
0.4495985805988312,
0.33105266094207764,
-0.08327744901180267,
-0.21593077480793,
0.12472085654735565,
-0.3353222906589508,
0.039672404527664185,
-0.43661078810691833,
0.4602721631526947,
0.08562885969877243,
-0.5374603271484375,
0.859338641166687,
0.1239008679986,
0.8247187733650208,
-0.5050159692764282,
0.07900340855121613,
-0.2693398892879486,
0.5994011163711548,
-0.3297927975654602,
-0.25988176465034485,
0.520973801612854,
-0.40089672803878784,
-0.23452754318714142,
-0.4082621932029724,
0.979797899723053,
-0.2039554864168167,
-0.46689561009407043,
0.19436632096767426,
-0.10936211794614792,
-0.02194444090127945,
-0.009421849623322487,
-0.5662782788276672,
0.2828029692173004,
0.00004830395846511237,
-0.22681663930416107,
0.10072766244411469,
-0.036482442170381546,
-0.24319617450237274,
0.9592543244361877,
0.6797205805778503,
-0.14004124701023102,
0.2736707925796509,
0.23998454213142395,
0.9962945580482483,
-0.4902476370334625,
-0.35816094279289246,
-0.6059627532958984,
0.5652416944503784,
-0.1068708598613739,
-0.17115901410579681,
0.44380983710289,
0.46333935856819153,
0.8220856785774231,
-0.44271615147590637,
0.2055448591709137,
0.03806192800402641,
0.21859313547611237,
-0.3890392780303955,
0.5363197326660156,
-0.23868577182292938,
0.44295215606689453,
-0.1942790448665619,
-1.2475371360778809,
-0.4750269055366516,
0.4556471109390259,
-0.23613354563713074,
-0.09763501584529877,
0.7464166879653931,
1.0275084972381592,
-0.4049306809902191,
-0.15243062376976013,
0.2867062985897064,
-0.003043403849005699,
0.29914602637290955,
0.5386750102043152,
0.33154812455177307,
-0.7611029148101807,
0.6306661367416382,
-0.6264069676399231,
-0.2339419722557068,
-0.08827982097864151,
-0.7493284940719604,
-0.8961323499679565,
-0.4888313412666321,
-0.3703257739543915,
-0.06210915744304657,
-0.10250132530927658,
0.4856012463569641,
0.8731720447540283,
-0.8801735043525696,
-0.2117057740688324,
-0.2944387197494507,
-0.07240143418312073,
-0.2849532961845398,
-0.2779112756252289,
0.521345317363739,
-0.7894336581230164,
-0.7446371912956238,
0.1765037178993225,
0.39598020911216736,
-0.3171337842941284,
-0.3027293384075165,
-0.003402476431801915,
-0.1634577214717865,
0.08597232401371002,
0.44881898164749146,
0.1343967467546463,
-0.785757839679718,
-0.13940395414829254,
-0.17670558393001556,
-0.30891847610473633,
0.06186572462320328,
1.0052025318145752,
-0.9245942234992981,
0.477431982755661,
0.4885866045951843,
0.9317024946212769,
1.015555739402771,
0.013909143395721912,
0.537575900554657,
-1.012237310409546,
0.7671769261360168,
0.41255369782447815,
0.31115567684173584,
0.35011833906173706,
-0.3827393352985382,
0.5705564618110657,
0.15652121603488922,
-0.35230371356010437,
-0.8469860553741455,
0.42470672726631165,
-1.1279916763305664,
0.07884233444929123,
0.5740665197372437,
-0.20643775165081024,
-0.6383165717124939,
-0.20923170447349548,
-0.16327978670597076,
0.21025323867797852,
0.007620202377438545,
0.7096604704856873,
0.1067802906036377,
0.08835670351982117,
-0.6398054361343384,
-0.5974341630935669,
0.6205405592918396,
0.7576563358306885,
-0.6148095726966858,
-0.3047569692134857,
-0.23464888334274292,
0.02868473343551159,
0.5943832993507385,
0.5247086882591248,
-0.17327480018138885,
0.21467968821525574,
-0.1365472823381424,
0.3691669702529907,
-0.16865913569927216,
-0.36895719170570374,
0.0886431485414505,
0.28022778034210205,
-0.3744887709617615,
-0.19328151643276215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11579v1
|
Exploring the Capabilities of Prompted Large Language Models in Educational and Assessment Applications
| 2024-05-19T15:13:51 | 2024-05-19T15:13:51 |
Subhankar Maity, Aniket Deroy, Sudeshna Sarkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the era of generative artificial intelligence (AI), the fusion of large
language models (LLMs) offers unprecedented opportunities for innovation in the
field of modern education. We embark on an exploration of prompted LLMs within
the context of educational and assessment applications to uncover their
potential. Through a series of carefully crafted research questions, we
investigate the effectiveness of prompt-based techniques in generating
open-ended questions from school-level textbooks, assess their efficiency in
generating open-ended questions from undergraduate-level technical textbooks,
and explore the feasibility of employing a chain-of-thought inspired
multi-stage prompting approach for language-agnostic multiple-choice question
(MCQ) generation. Additionally, we evaluate the ability of prompted LLMs for
language learning, exemplified through a case study in the low-resource Indian
language Bengali, to explain Bengali grammatical errors. We also evaluate the
potential of prompted LLMs to assess human resource (HR) spoken interview
transcripts. By juxtaposing the capabilities of LLMs with those of human
experts across various educational tasks and domains, our aim is to shed light
on the potential and limitations of LLMs in reshaping educational practices.
|
[
-0.28994861245155334,
-1.2698218822479248,
0.527358889579773,
0.12074963003396988,
0.23013533651828766,
0.3025726079940796,
-0.42988088726997375,
-0.09234071522951126,
-0.05775655806064606,
0.31853172183036804,
-0.7080335021018982,
-0.1323554813861847,
-0.19108343124389648,
0.410367488861084,
-0.6160178184509277,
0.4941023886203766,
-0.030105698853731155,
0.2099015861749649,
-0.5263065695762634,
0.01078507024794817,
-0.6762914657592773,
-0.40861058235168457,
-0.7681689262390137,
-0.35221001505851746,
0.5511500835418701,
0.47589123249053955,
0.4099513292312622,
0.20810380578041077,
0.13933613896369934,
0.3299291133880615,
-0.1670628935098648,
0.12527552247047424,
-0.17016014456748962,
0.38565805554389954,
-0.18385553359985352,
-0.41422656178474426,
-0.010013818740844727,
0.1790844202041626,
0.7464923858642578,
0.8793904185295105,
-0.25008106231689453,
0.39228373765945435,
0.24920757114887238,
0.6033692359924316,
-0.6416090130805969,
-0.15503089129924774,
-0.5277931690216064,
-0.06974150985479355,
-0.13151420652866364,
-0.1257026195526123,
-0.44846972823143005,
-0.4473285377025604,
0.010747467167675495,
-0.20242084562778473,
0.015618794597685337,
-0.03248858079314232,
0.3144167363643646,
0.27469268441200256,
-0.36772358417510986,
-0.5036740303039551,
-0.6989128589630127,
0.8358574509620667,
-0.40801548957824707,
0.393231600522995,
0.2804587185382843,
0.38959118723869324,
-0.2604276239871979,
-0.5972504019737244,
-0.8445319533348083,
-0.35807108879089355,
0.15206122398376465,
0.050458524376153946,
0.08257325738668442,
-0.052421730011701584,
0.33211711049079895,
0.33285391330718994,
-0.6555373072624207,
0.47258296608924866,
-0.2932291328907013,
-0.18029822409152985,
0.4329195022583008,
0.3337472081184387,
0.520482063293457,
-0.2701015770435333,
-0.36609238386154175,
-0.1445891559123993,
-0.7790076732635498,
0.22860564291477203,
0.3283989727497101,
0.5260656476020813,
0.09224221855401993,
0.7188873887062073,
-0.19656787812709808,
1.009164571762085,
-0.20449897646903992,
-0.06740421056747437,
-0.045505307614803314,
-0.26837441325187683,
-0.07232294231653214,
0.05082756653428078,
0.8368401527404785,
0.031094297766685486,
0.3233477473258972,
0.2953195869922638,
-0.18564827740192413,
0.09408926218748093,
0.045679084956645966,
-0.46061933040618896,
0.30189579725265503,
0.5144336819648743,
0.012065479531884193,
-0.12953516840934753,
-0.31486859917640686,
-0.9515603184700012,
-0.49538570642471313,
-0.4631582796573639,
0.5181313157081604,
-0.28464797139167786,
-0.2292892187833786,
0.09338649362325668,
0.042964860796928406,
0.4654327630996704,
0.3808007538318634,
-1.0672608613967896,
-0.26225709915161133,
0.6795649528503418,
0.4865850508213043,
0.04896288737654686,
-0.34243786334991455,
-0.28232792019844055,
-0.15159951150417328,
-0.4582784175872803,
0.6101754903793335,
-0.7546345591545105,
-0.6127769351005554,
0.48454222083091736,
-0.39886438846588135,
-0.10725220292806625,
-0.6087753772735596,
0.39444687962532043,
-0.5345306992530823,
0.3133653998374939,
-0.1708201915025711,
-0.42751839756965637,
-0.23111218214035034,
0.8064634799957275,
-0.40712782740592957,
1.2409048080444336,
0.21369345486164093,
-0.28597044944763184,
0.11691359430551529,
-0.6044682860374451,
-0.22422608733177185,
0.4446258544921875,
-0.5579445958137512,
0.08833015710115433,
-0.15384694933891296,
0.2211146056652069,
0.5046917796134949,
-0.6708016991615295,
0.5419719219207764,
0.13927094638347626,
-0.285798579454422,
0.37764015793800354,
-0.7111541032791138,
1.095181941986084,
-0.0006324182031676173,
-0.23315666615962982,
0.19454972445964813,
-0.6092928051948547,
0.24005207419395447,
0.3091932535171509,
-0.5393422842025757,
-0.28580281138420105,
-0.13502171635627747,
-0.2953595817089081,
0.06831332296133041,
0.35826021432876587,
-0.22505134344100952,
0.4139350354671478,
-0.0911417081952095,
0.4471372663974762,
0.7786825299263,
0.031134650111198425,
0.20926795899868011,
-0.2147623598575592,
0.860848069190979,
-0.39035433530807495,
0.15682785212993622,
-0.3697790503501892,
-0.3847958743572235,
-0.7043719291687012,
-0.09170651435852051,
0.2863486111164093,
0.6922354698181152,
-0.8279862999916077,
0.3966134786605835,
-0.03258649259805679,
-0.5951768159866333,
-0.6306601166725159,
0.22234082221984863,
0.2379300594329834,
0.68880695104599,
0.14950639009475708,
0.1160033643245697,
-0.4844529628753662,
-0.5679551959037781,
-0.23467110097408295,
-0.39958080649375916,
0.059519123286008835,
0.3867138624191284,
0.5109483003616333,
-0.3226332366466522,
1.0561076402664185,
-0.18219012022018433,
0.13631406426429749,
-0.38354119658470154,
-0.028293583542108536,
0.2391452044248581,
0.3187006711959839,
0.321911096572876,
-0.8947365880012512,
-0.3996052145957947,
-0.3308999538421631,
-0.8557579517364502,
-0.283687561750412,
-0.19619601964950562,
0.005022882018238306,
-0.0807439535856247,
0.6438091993331909,
-0.7537513971328735,
0.09887812286615372,
0.4182150661945343,
-0.15817095339298248,
0.9487807750701904,
-0.013547656126320362,
0.2528234124183655,
-1.011871099472046,
-0.028753461316227913,
-0.08965318650007248,
0.22740377485752106,
-0.6274964213371277,
0.1393592804670334,
0.05286632850766182,
-0.29507336020469666,
-0.5337949991226196,
0.9718844890594482,
-0.4192618429660797,
0.050439685583114624,
-0.20987989008426666,
0.4705512523651123,
-0.2792016565799713,
0.11504378169775009,
-0.22079013288021088,
1.1332191228866577,
0.6904517412185669,
-0.7788994312286377,
0.4196246266365051,
0.46078675985336304,
-0.47303518652915955,
0.5023257732391357,
-0.47578951716423035,
0.11093524098396301,
-0.10447149723768234,
0.1047990471124649,
-0.9361951947212219,
-0.4714714586734772,
0.17001713812351227,
-0.39562156796455383,
0.22355537116527557,
0.24630817770957947,
-0.47352415323257446,
-0.6148930788040161,
-0.2669432759284973,
0.521159827709198,
0.6605861783027649,
-0.799457311630249,
0.6162524819374084,
0.026256486773490906,
-0.5437429547309875,
-0.7214550375938416,
-0.32942673563957214,
0.20051640272140503,
-0.11818187683820724,
-0.34355390071868896,
-0.161156564950943,
-0.30951040983200073,
-0.6759533882141113,
-0.21959269046783447,
0.15838465094566345,
0.15818579494953156,
0.2972695231437683,
0.16887912154197693,
0.60936039686203,
-0.23623186349868774,
0.07680545747280121,
0.17184168100357056,
0.18166859447956085,
0.2715219259262085,
-0.09202530980110168,
0.7002224922180176,
-0.025949757546186447,
-0.5472761392593384,
-0.2867060601711273,
0.289171427488327,
0.5200493335723877,
-0.1986696571111679,
0.6374736428260803,
0.3047744631767273,
-0.31283456087112427,
-0.31528234481811523,
-0.6414051651954651,
-0.29983314871788025,
-0.4905717670917511,
0.222103551030159,
-0.08666672557592392,
-1.0895932912826538,
0.30325746536254883,
-0.25174906849861145,
-0.0037153030280023813,
0.37767571210861206,
0.7062311172485352,
0.010445822961628437,
0.8519510626792908,
0.3633699119091034,
-0.09146299213171005,
0.48680758476257324,
-0.23598121106624603,
0.23250317573547363,
-0.8947076201438904,
-0.4625824987888336,
-0.6131675839424133,
-0.10092959553003311,
-0.443319708108902,
-0.2829812467098236,
0.49890613555908203,
0.24113650619983673,
-0.22751151025295258,
-0.2601398527622223,
-0.3391214609146118,
0.5492321252822876,
0.7020513415336609,
-0.11074456572532654,
0.051353685557842255,
-0.1464361995458603,
-0.14521078765392303,
0.3597841262817383,
-0.7040672302246094,
-0.7207208871841431,
0.9432593584060669,
0.004347977228462696,
0.548893392086029,
0.03198001906275749,
0.5539935231208801,
0.3055800497531891,
0.44907552003860474,
-0.9182822108268738,
0.9858513474464417,
0.3086915910243988,
-0.8141307830810547,
-0.49019360542297363,
-0.2891162037849426,
-0.845005452632904,
0.15235385298728943,
-0.33730125427246094,
-0.6653141379356384,
-0.17998267710208893,
-0.062437597662210464,
-0.5441077947616577,
0.09332825243473053,
-0.614588737487793,
0.4164702594280243,
-0.389044851064682,
-0.335290789604187,
-0.06848563998937607,
-0.4197498559951782,
0.40166589617729187,
-0.3905695378780365,
0.24433590471744537,
0.06384223699569702,
0.015892790630459785,
0.8915583491325378,
-0.0025689860340207815,
0.9987097382545471,
0.020974883809685707,
-0.2206353098154068,
0.8230220079421997,
0.08320591598749161,
0.2564726769924164,
-0.15694303810596466,
-0.25543826818466187,
0.03665062412619591,
-0.38837382197380066,
-0.2869131565093994,
-0.6474353075027466,
0.5790281295776367,
-0.6300360560417175,
-1.096888542175293,
-0.3852338492870331,
-0.7041693925857544,
-0.3623690605163574,
0.29854822158813477,
-0.07682180404663086,
0.4242669343948364,
-0.07051043212413788,
-0.03693991154432297,
0.45318296551704407,
-0.344188392162323,
0.5816788673400879,
0.5053436756134033,
-0.21066617965698242,
-0.37366122007369995,
0.7811034917831421,
0.06510278582572937,
0.2255955934524536,
0.052736472338438034,
0.35976243019104004,
-0.5276991128921509,
-0.5779961347579956,
-0.4451891779899597,
0.3185032904148102,
-0.7543246746063232,
-0.12474681437015533,
-0.3326942026615143,
-0.2801528573036194,
-0.582170307636261,
-0.37832528352737427,
0.1463039070367813,
-0.08829797059297562,
-0.3771952688694,
-0.14747580885887146,
0.18650828301906586,
0.9429271817207336,
0.0787840187549591,
0.21466849744319916,
-0.9335508942604065,
-0.12516295909881592,
0.6424968838691711,
-0.07904767990112305,
0.11959003657102585,
-0.46324270963668823,
0.028052767738699913,
0.035918187350034714,
-0.2951611280441284,
-0.771120011806488,
0.20133131742477417,
0.09898774325847626,
0.6577713489532471,
0.37912341952323914,
0.030243169516324997,
0.37485966086387634,
-0.5138752460479736,
1.276328206062317,
0.12452733516693115,
-0.7491049766540527,
0.6077051162719727,
-0.40137729048728943,
0.21233174204826355,
0.3162591755390167,
0.6816285252571106,
-0.4743235111236572,
-0.3200831711292267,
-0.4266701340675354,
-0.8164286613464355,
0.45973268151283264,
-0.19479329884052277,
0.2891371250152588,
-0.20346690714359283,
0.5191429257392883,
0.23515212535858154,
0.3021389842033386,
-0.3735661506652832,
-0.12885791063308716,
0.2234097123146057,
-0.3771314024925232,
-0.14503340423107147,
-0.4888070523738861,
-0.03597066178917885,
-0.09916975349187851,
0.6679441928863525,
-0.12708818912506104,
-0.2254008799791336,
0.023532593622803688,
0.028515756130218506,
0.11185804754495621,
0.6828892230987549,
0.64066481590271,
0.6063386797904968,
0.267155259847641,
-0.09974351525306702,
0.2063761204481125,
-0.3081561326980591,
0.3040967583656311,
-0.10569872707128525,
-0.30934104323387146,
-0.3351023495197296,
0.3524450659751892,
0.5096254348754883,
-0.036354418843984604,
-1.1090433597564697,
0.24745674431324005,
0.049146708101034164,
-0.16191168129444122,
-0.41714832186698914,
0.3210015296936035,
-0.05374278873205185,
0.4088117778301239,
0.5533843636512756,
-0.3616498112678528,
-0.10190559178590775,
-0.6816027760505676,
-0.03781743347644806,
0.5134440064430237,
-0.14753055572509766,
-0.08888649940490723,
0.5316907167434692,
0.29651758074760437,
-0.7382501363754272,
0.8786280155181885,
0.07126366347074509,
-0.6117625832557678,
0.4277953505516052,
0.6248960494995117,
0.721818208694458,
-0.6170364022254944,
0.2598247528076172,
0.4230078458786011,
0.23510520160198212,
-0.2368728518486023,
0.442595511674881,
-0.1687067598104477,
-0.901090145111084,
-0.471655935049057,
-0.6023686528205872,
-0.6418040990829468,
0.23619067668914795,
-0.5267508029937744,
0.25738176703453064,
-0.4099927544593811,
-0.17286893725395203,
-0.24542321264743805,
-0.2514905631542206,
-0.44768020510673523,
0.24675215780735016,
0.11246313899755478,
1.0581791400909424,
-0.8876339197158813,
0.39130496978759766,
0.8466038703918457,
-0.40482133626937866,
-1.0457489490509033,
-0.07427958399057388,
0.021352654322981834,
-0.9337140321731567,
0.7295174598693848,
0.2732661962509155,
0.1417664885520935,
0.366350919008255,
-0.5497792959213257,
-0.5740094780921936,
0.9022721648216248,
0.2498573660850525,
-0.48079773783683777,
-0.19114571809768677,
0.20911523699760437,
0.34819409251213074,
-0.19581718742847443,
0.3940649926662445,
0.6677606105804443,
0.5012091398239136,
0.026938151568174362,
-0.7971642017364502,
-0.13761882483959198,
-0.1307365745306015,
-0.17342159152030945,
0.2653682827949524,
-0.5194975137710571,
0.7452557682991028,
-0.3792111277580261,
-0.10412133485078812,
0.17923834919929504,
0.6051250100135803,
0.4812019467353821,
0.41888925433158875,
0.4205547273159027,
0.2639515995979309,
0.9041524529457092,
-0.11703745275735855,
0.9703083038330078,
-0.13134394586086273,
0.15285155177116394,
0.7065907120704651,
-0.4383281469345093,
0.9577791690826416,
0.5359781980514526,
-0.2382848858833313,
0.5570918321609497,
0.7867011427879333,
0.010367964394390583,
-0.10675238817930222,
0.1950891613960266,
-0.5767476558685303,
-0.26176056265830994,
-0.4921703338623047,
-0.1982376128435135,
0.5227638483047485,
0.5646243095397949,
-0.013401669450104237,
-0.1593501716852188,
0.3122695982456207,
-0.34161972999572754,
0.2860654294490814,
-0.5670775771141052,
0.573262631893158,
0.047491420060396194,
-0.9030418395996094,
0.44892430305480957,
-0.4051112234592438,
0.4975150227546692,
-0.5276414155960083,
-0.05628801882266998,
-0.04630240425467491,
-0.2590509057044983,
0.05311749875545502,
-0.9906520843505859,
-0.16656284034252167,
0.15534542500972748,
-0.02129954844713211,
-0.3660134971141815,
0.5923684239387512,
-0.6531464457511902,
-0.3242223560810089,
0.012169887311756611,
0.7211555242538452,
0.1166267842054367,
0.2729940712451935,
-0.562288761138916,
0.13956356048583984,
-0.08974814414978027,
-0.3273817002773285,
0.2695266902446747,
0.32278215885162354,
-0.0810278132557869,
0.9498823881149292,
0.6226400136947632,
0.11578987538814545,
0.09725269675254822,
0.15857596695423126,
0.5145093202590942,
-0.6478711366653442,
-0.3616948425769806,
-0.8277605772018433,
0.6007466912269592,
0.23566630482673645,
-0.24878770112991333,
0.8105528354644775,
0.3273998498916626,
0.8096538782119751,
-0.03281892091035843,
0.9612231850624084,
0.009458307176828384,
0.44148287177085876,
-0.7186362147331238,
0.5250600576400757,
-0.46991097927093506,
0.1648414582014084,
-0.017409436404705048,
-0.9059755206108093,
-0.13055771589279175,
0.18088306486606598,
-0.4028940796852112,
0.33541935682296753,
0.533557653427124,
0.6871589422225952,
0.541753888130188,
0.1791849434375763,
0.46717163920402527,
0.04134940728545189,
0.3020073473453522,
0.2064748853445053,
1.2812072038650513,
-0.09223362803459167,
0.3140050768852234,
0.1623687744140625,
-0.2962873876094818,
-0.19647911190986633,
-0.5464795827865601,
-1.037516713142395,
-0.7568626999855042,
-0.2500346004962921,
-0.22250717878341675,
-0.20928430557250977,
1.1782652139663696,
0.05342869460582733,
-0.3892607092857361,
-0.26336270570755005,
-0.0070276823826134205,
0.11477767676115036,
0.12481619417667389,
-0.2655278444290161,
0.22800295054912567,
-0.41214460134506226,
-0.9277774095535278,
0.7517989873886108,
0.05078507587313652,
0.3376973569393158,
-0.6302029490470886,
0.17139291763305664,
-0.2500195801258087,
0.23217712342739105,
0.7216310501098633,
0.38818490505218506,
-0.8133348822593689,
-0.3047790825366974,
0.018585510551929474,
-0.051648762077093124,
-0.44174277782440186,
0.8867571353912354,
-0.8815613389015198,
0.4584885835647583,
0.4918259382247925,
0.9776864647865295,
-0.39853501319885254,
0.007901463657617569,
0.40621834993362427,
-0.5989531874656677,
0.04636508971452713,
0.4631250500679016,
0.2321481704711914,
0.43817076086997986,
-0.275420218706131,
0.467379629611969,
0.07967483252286911,
-0.5681790113449097,
-1.0936732292175293,
0.19851826131343842,
-0.673487663269043,
-0.1542184054851532,
1.2981469631195068,
0.22544576227664948,
-0.28115811944007874,
0.08377856761217117,
-0.27629217505455017,
0.10992630571126938,
-0.14383457601070404,
0.7134058475494385,
0.7750938534736633,
-0.12337389588356018,
-0.0932156890630722,
-0.5703377723693848,
0.23228153586387634,
0.5272941589355469,
-0.6952200531959534,
0.07902957499027252,
0.43167924880981445,
-0.008591198362410069,
0.3574773073196411,
0.4690716564655304,
0.1529283970594406,
0.21938791871070862,
-0.10058201104402542,
0.06268880516290665,
-0.034149955958127975,
-0.361619770526886,
-0.571622908115387,
0.2483554184436798,
0.20798997581005096,
0.02440749481320381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11577v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11577v4
|
A Multi-Perspective Analysis of Memorization in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-19T15:00:50 | 2024-06-04T15:28:20 |
Bowen Chen, Namgi Han, Yusuke Miyao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), trained on massive corpora with billions of
parameters, show unprecedented performance in various fields. Though surprised
by their excellent performances, researchers also noticed some special
behaviors of those LLMs. One of those behaviors is memorization, in which LLMs
can generate the same content used to train them. Though previous research has
discussed memorization, the memorization of LLMs still lacks explanation,
especially the cause of memorization and the dynamics of generating them. In
this research, we comprehensively discussed memorization from various
perspectives and extended the discussion scope to not only just the memorized
content but also less and unmemorized content. Through various studies, we
found that: (1) Through experiments, we revealed the relation of memorization
between model size, continuation size, and context size. Further, we showed how
unmemorized sentences transition to memorized sentences. (2) Through embedding
analysis, we showed the distribution and decoding dynamics across model size in
embedding space for sentences with different memorization scores. The n-gram
statistics analysis presents d (3) An analysis over n-gram and entropy decoding
dynamics discovered a boundary effect when the model starts to generate
memorized sentences or unmemorized sentences. (4)We trained a Transformer model
to predict the memorization of different models, showing that it is possible to
predict memorizations by context.
|
[
-0.1384187936782837,
-0.9211700558662415,
0.7115583419799805,
-0.07734352350234985,
-0.308225154876709,
-0.11372661590576172,
-0.33845654129981995,
-0.08820167183876038,
-0.0736934095621109,
0.5676538944244385,
-0.2681064009666443,
-0.40834563970565796,
-0.5429213643074036,
-0.12229568511247635,
-0.45567214488983154,
1.102363109588623,
-0.10408549010753632,
0.16546159982681274,
-0.4527346193790436,
-0.09304890036582947,
-0.38674917817115784,
-0.8319216370582581,
-0.4336148798465729,
-0.5191096067428589,
0.48525184392929077,
0.059389740228652954,
0.17063944041728973,
0.8521041870117188,
0.3619263172149658,
0.35733935236930847,
-0.45587706565856934,
-0.13062436878681183,
-0.7182590961456299,
0.18987885117530823,
0.02666366659104824,
-0.6792926788330078,
-0.22856773436069489,
-0.15079911053180695,
1.06461501121521,
0.833466112613678,
-0.12455626577138901,
0.026001574471592903,
0.2273455113172531,
0.7537763118743896,
-0.5133699178695679,
0.1885543018579483,
-0.750931978225708,
0.06761838495731354,
0.0564555786550045,
-0.5430052280426025,
-0.4904768466949463,
-0.047057535499334335,
0.13394413888454437,
-0.35609716176986694,
0.2887836992740631,
-0.06204945221543312,
0.4164952337741852,
0.10121021419763565,
-0.617259681224823,
-0.3676143288612366,
-0.9310067296028137,
0.8590869307518005,
-0.5273184180259705,
0.425851970911026,
0.16109433770179749,
0.029776664450764656,
-0.16457003355026245,
-0.5038819909095764,
-0.43554848432540894,
-0.0970560610294342,
0.05171988904476166,
0.007692356128245592,
0.003368748351931572,
0.013227693736553192,
0.4742191433906555,
0.4518786072731018,
-0.24627132713794708,
0.08846506476402283,
-0.4838968515396118,
-0.24884633719921112,
0.30964139103889465,
0.39567315578460693,
0.21011103689670563,
0.018864907324314117,
-0.5733649134635925,
-0.08206713944673538,
-0.782044529914856,
0.04837731644511223,
-0.006224508862942457,
0.22172576189041138,
-0.10138051211833954,
0.4513013958930969,
0.19046616554260254,
0.28862079977989197,
-0.10162317007780075,
-0.7413891553878784,
0.3019523620605469,
-0.10651621967554092,
-0.36972683668136597,
-0.05237680301070213,
0.6527622938156128,
0.28542593121528625,
0.30308401584625244,
-0.449418842792511,
-0.05674567446112633,
-0.259965181350708,
0.257590651512146,
-0.9250633120536804,
0.04170737415552139,
-0.035460229963064194,
-0.5759004354476929,
0.33352717757225037,
-0.0472409650683403,
-0.5945300459861755,
-0.2991051971912384,
-0.4410001337528229,
0.36693984270095825,
-0.7690862417221069,
-0.11999884247779846,
0.03769591078162193,
-0.06520391255617142,
0.1371602863073349,
0.3995403051376343,
-0.7673167586326599,
0.2435755729675293,
0.7306845784187317,
0.871937096118927,
-0.14297625422477722,
-0.7969031929969788,
-0.29528364539146423,
0.4139319658279419,
-0.12456320971250534,
0.5582168698310852,
-0.5386448502540588,
-0.22626908123493195,
0.14366085827350616,
0.05723962187767029,
-0.5639551877975464,
-0.5020922422409058,
0.18129728734493256,
-0.6060857176780701,
-0.037056680768728256,
-0.31201350688934326,
-1.0536168813705444,
-0.5750389695167542,
0.39042967557907104,
-0.739818811416626,
0.5737146735191345,
-0.32811668515205383,
-0.808054506778717,
0.1601662039756775,
-0.09312770515680313,
-0.2838466167449951,
-0.3700282573699951,
-0.0341593436896801,
-0.32487037777900696,
0.5821206569671631,
-0.33801114559173584,
0.6104894280433655,
-0.15999850630760193,
0.43530455231666565,
-0.16487130522727966,
-0.3043648898601532,
0.518129825592041,
-0.45712611079216003,
0.3549484312534332,
0.08107629418373108,
0.08454548567533493,
-0.032196685671806335,
-0.7984164357185364,
-0.19451957941055298,
0.07800956070423126,
-0.7849246263504028,
-0.3498326241970062,
-0.013677883893251419,
-0.17905649542808533,
0.2785298228263855,
0.15871766209602356,
-0.3544771373271942,
0.13788999617099762,
-0.16558563709259033,
0.4665977358818054,
0.4455280601978302,
0.2785014808177948,
0.6869369745254517,
-0.2912707030773163,
0.2788236737251282,
0.4327598512172699,
-0.31177136301994324,
-0.6231793761253357,
-0.1427788883447647,
-0.655212938785553,
-0.09109830111265182,
-0.0017390711000189185,
0.35403621196746826,
-0.2217491865158081,
0.01508175116032362,
-0.32956281304359436,
-0.11168262362480164,
-0.03574462980031967,
0.399172306060791,
0.5042166709899902,
0.2840358316898346,
0.1820945292711258,
-0.3572646379470825,
-0.3513314425945282,
-0.944302499294281,
-0.22075767815113068,
-0.04562417417764664,
0.13435252010822296,
0.07191909849643707,
0.7529394030570984,
-0.1975332647562027,
0.6591605544090271,
-0.2868911921977997,
-0.281668484210968,
-0.2275814414024353,
0.07851118594408035,
-0.22707410156726837,
0.31232765316963196,
0.2646382451057434,
-0.6194978356361389,
-0.12404840439558029,
-0.10323546081781387,
-0.5463356971740723,
0.3002091646194458,
-0.17724153399467468,
0.09341882914304733,
0.42240914702415466,
1.0179967880249023,
-0.6592345237731934,
0.22593750059604645,
0.3567325472831726,
-0.008637241087853909,
0.22292877733707428,
-0.5970015525817871,
-0.20809678733348846,
-1.028747320175171,
0.08524363487958908,
-0.1617661863565445,
0.12571179866790771,
-0.7035574913024902,
0.10319382697343826,
0.06779582798480988,
0.19609005749225616,
-0.3455151617527008,
0.2670314311981201,
-0.7360365390777588,
-0.128146231174469,
-0.418925940990448,
0.148560032248497,
-0.07116737961769104,
0.7282940745353699,
0.10698904097080231,
0.49633559584617615,
0.3520737588405609,
-0.8565994501113892,
-0.009879834949970245,
0.04669318348169327,
-0.3993057310581207,
0.14272163808345795,
-0.35291656851768494,
0.06222397834062576,
-0.4962896704673767,
0.2274916172027588,
-1.0461926460266113,
-0.04150751233100891,
-0.26253238320350647,
-0.11108465492725372,
0.4579594135284424,
-0.14760860800743103,
-0.664081335067749,
-0.05253422260284424,
-0.24060297012329102,
0.3879556357860565,
0.4281110167503357,
-0.30551716685295105,
0.6029626727104187,
0.41958677768707275,
0.11731404066085815,
-0.4042827785015106,
-0.5455183386802673,
-0.16579051315784454,
-0.5775887966156006,
-0.33347412943840027,
0.13897903263568878,
-0.24793052673339844,
-0.37008047103881836,
-0.20495757460594177,
-0.02603035978972912,
-0.1320849061012268,
0.1272391825914383,
0.46267709136009216,
0.020093796774744987,
-0.2228066623210907,
0.37971341609954834,
-0.11628587543964386,
0.10877729952335358,
0.3277061879634857,
-0.18110917508602142,
0.8158777356147766,
-0.17080846428871155,
-0.16759000718593597,
-0.10491343587636948,
0.22833526134490967,
0.7942348718643188,
-0.14138247072696686,
1.1452257633209229,
0.5337773561477661,
-0.291916161775589,
-0.10152344405651093,
-0.5752995610237122,
0.03451184928417206,
-0.3662993013858795,
0.5849711894989014,
-0.33154311776161194,
-0.9388472437858582,
0.9243550300598145,
-0.22238579392433167,
-0.11516918241977692,
0.3240886628627777,
0.795490026473999,
0.15231157839298248,
0.6465440988540649,
0.8570674061775208,
-0.09143301099538803,
0.3455911874771118,
-0.28715187311172485,
0.19040454924106598,
-1.145954966545105,
-0.6638431549072266,
-0.2789306044578552,
-0.2626820504665375,
-0.5897940993309021,
-0.28616729378700256,
0.23579901456832886,
0.4292869567871094,
-0.367991179227829,
0.06965500861406326,
-0.005464001093059778,
0.506445586681366,
0.47290363907814026,
-0.1765807718038559,
0.4139915704727173,
0.01118670403957367,
-0.2908764183521271,
0.09806495159864426,
-0.5016798377037048,
-0.5860554575920105,
1.0566341876983643,
0.534061849117279,
0.7928398847579956,
0.031433138996362686,
0.7346787452697754,
-0.3697931468486786,
-0.02081187628209591,
-0.8619295358657837,
0.5285866260528564,
-0.0029202569276094437,
-0.6314353346824646,
-0.25087442994117737,
-0.4295497238636017,
-0.9635547399520874,
0.43254464864730835,
-0.0805405005812645,
-0.8537036180496216,
-0.13236422836780548,
0.14754018187522888,
-0.2613059878349304,
0.5064346194267273,
-0.7601813673973083,
0.7966414093971252,
-0.150964617729187,
-0.34472325444221497,
-0.19204063713550568,
-0.7085007429122925,
0.48134276270866394,
-0.13240674138069153,
0.194302037358284,
0.04754122719168663,
0.04324428737163544,
0.6998137831687927,
0.030484303832054138,
0.8946987390518188,
-0.06522055715322495,
-0.3553786277770996,
0.16674453020095825,
0.1876092255115509,
0.202063649892807,
-0.002151382388547063,
0.18094801902770996,
-0.05236313119530678,
-0.07112331688404083,
-0.023883210495114326,
-0.3997122347354889,
0.8317047953605652,
-0.7510173916816711,
-0.7047611474990845,
-0.16431604325771332,
-0.7979371547698975,
-0.06860489398241043,
0.15063421428203583,
0.3798510432243347,
0.319536417722702,
-0.5121166110038757,
0.3265831470489502,
1.0346912145614624,
-0.29582107067108154,
0.6029629111289978,
0.522184431552887,
-0.2923642694950104,
-0.07220912724733353,
0.6155099272727966,
0.35672441124916077,
0.4023890793323517,
0.7587152123451233,
0.10255535691976547,
-0.03921716660261154,
-0.748456597328186,
-0.01992066204547882,
0.3597358465194702,
-0.7563242316246033,
0.1205616220831871,
-0.8738601207733154,
-0.2852770984172821,
-0.2388637661933899,
0.15820395946502686,
-0.32605963945388794,
-0.24172648787498474,
-0.2758795917034149,
-0.07481968402862549,
0.15091443061828613,
0.7467830181121826,
0.1369050294160843,
0.3665693700313568,
-0.8116077184677124,
0.11460182070732117,
0.10886117070913315,
0.26305899024009705,
0.49305784702301025,
-0.6558376550674438,
-0.5344283580780029,
-0.17525313794612885,
-0.5148178339004517,
-0.614486575126648,
0.5315094590187073,
0.1533672958612442,
0.4670664072036743,
0.5670927166938782,
-0.3823081851005554,
0.5043038129806519,
-0.878811776638031,
0.5796555280685425,
0.007179835345596075,
-0.8839167952537537,
0.13048575818538666,
-0.35336825251579285,
0.4196263253688812,
0.29540467262268066,
0.19681067764759064,
-0.544965386390686,
-0.44155600666999817,
-0.5663465261459351,
-0.98130863904953,
0.7401700019836426,
-0.1909158080816269,
0.40179184079170227,
-0.020305149257183075,
0.42499569058418274,
0.2949194312095642,
0.3645933270454407,
-0.7126501202583313,
-0.13094070553779602,
-0.16854974627494812,
0.09552495181560516,
-0.3877795338630676,
-0.5511306524276733,
-0.05175109580159187,
-0.22180107235908508,
0.3496691882610321,
0.08167031407356262,
0.4006063640117645,
-0.14724133908748627,
-0.45351991057395935,
-0.06560885161161423,
0.49256110191345215,
0.9099144339561462,
0.7589604258537292,
-0.1925937682390213,
0.25833702087402344,
0.2813088595867157,
-0.4631046652793884,
0.018809150904417038,
-0.29622843861579895,
-0.1312955915927887,
-0.17654572427272797,
0.636285662651062,
1.1450705528259277,
0.3710997998714447,
-0.5224170088768005,
0.42135483026504517,
0.09983663260936737,
-0.15492044389247894,
-0.6666796803474426,
0.0812651515007019,
0.48073747754096985,
0.29103145003318787,
0.27752017974853516,
-0.06765326112508774,
-0.0812411829829216,
-0.8952991366386414,
-0.014336281456053257,
0.4178676903247833,
-0.1612805873155594,
-0.5216032266616821,
0.5565583109855652,
-0.21721526980400085,
-0.10862480849027634,
0.671603262424469,
0.04477452114224434,
-0.6368405818939209,
0.6853089332580566,
0.7760516405105591,
0.7185704112052917,
-0.26144957542419434,
0.04874594882130623,
0.4911031126976013,
0.22586901485919952,
-0.3836491107940674,
-0.20662420988082886,
-0.08552469313144684,
-0.7785913944244385,
-0.3305187523365021,
-0.6776609420776367,
-0.09137231856584549,
0.534591019153595,
-0.8326255083084106,
-0.11173664033412933,
-0.5339953899383545,
0.07082819193601608,
0.042540960013866425,
-0.13536791503429413,
-0.6196348071098328,
0.16623952984809875,
0.3553996682167053,
0.6617695093154907,
-0.8494418859481812,
0.8067374229431152,
0.5117450952529907,
-0.2855739891529083,
-0.7199828624725342,
0.3314635157585144,
0.09753350168466568,
-0.8066514730453491,
0.8073576092720032,
0.3940791189670563,
-0.04312801733613014,
-0.2552880644798279,
-0.3483915328979492,
-0.8382768630981445,
1.1394996643066406,
0.31948915123939514,
-0.4962250888347626,
-0.0810677632689476,
0.0383262112736702,
0.8633064031600952,
-0.5106660723686218,
0.20391835272312164,
0.5610736012458801,
0.19728033244609833,
0.1878940612077713,
-0.7816047072410583,
-0.019789669662714005,
-0.14628198742866516,
0.30706965923309326,
0.2906855046749115,
-0.8456969857215881,
1.2628556489944458,
-0.3315088450908661,
-0.37946227192878723,
0.11764009296894073,
0.4335179030895233,
0.12101013213396072,
0.3722390830516815,
0.10696739703416824,
0.48468127846717834,
0.6498998403549194,
0.14655376970767975,
1.108762264251709,
-0.22954291105270386,
0.4153479337692261,
0.9027420282363892,
-0.3242093026638031,
0.9089280366897583,
0.6496054530143738,
0.07833404839038849,
0.4922820031642914,
0.19402115046977997,
0.0414043627679348,
0.5188772678375244,
0.3254356384277344,
0.02539069391787052,
-0.2433445006608963,
0.13881325721740723,
-0.2610543966293335,
0.5067128539085388,
0.27343451976776123,
-0.6686919331550598,
-0.19042040407657623,
0.25514334440231323,
0.19114786386489868,
0.06277688592672348,
-0.3971380889415741,
0.993797242641449,
0.31919243931770325,
-0.6158720254898071,
0.6399216055870056,
0.13136409223079681,
0.35979825258255005,
-0.44927477836608887,
0.2748667597770691,
-0.2266325056552887,
0.5626649856567383,
0.04821069911122322,
-0.6108783483505249,
0.2928352653980255,
-0.1442372053861618,
-0.5067125558853149,
-0.22864152491092682,
0.3293367922306061,
-0.6903072595596313,
-0.30932146310806274,
0.5523639917373657,
0.6406786441802979,
0.2532971203327179,
-0.006690304260700941,
-0.20548015832901,
0.17274782061576843,
-0.10231105983257294,
-0.5295546054840088,
0.6309002637863159,
0.8156118392944336,
-0.12253863364458084,
0.7818138003349304,
0.2492986023426056,
-0.09184347838163376,
0.31957218050956726,
0.1261090785264969,
0.7034265398979187,
-0.8418385982513428,
-0.3766377568244934,
-1.1708558797836304,
0.29297614097595215,
0.2027430683374405,
-0.23447677493095398,
1.0513432025909424,
0.7631536722183228,
0.9829710125923157,
-0.2926271855831146,
0.4900716543197632,
0.31190839409828186,
0.5411175489425659,
-0.8794583082199097,
0.4640967845916748,
-0.5231969952583313,
0.3290661573410034,
-0.27360570430755615,
-0.9974470734596252,
-0.3041655123233795,
0.4356060326099396,
-0.30578142404556274,
0.1239449605345726,
1.0551313161849976,
0.5343995094299316,
-0.0897052064538002,
-0.059331078082323074,
0.3243347704410553,
0.4239618480205536,
0.052676379680633545,
0.8486472964286804,
0.9012053608894348,
-0.223628431558609,
0.6295222043991089,
-0.02271701954305172,
0.09194439649581909,
-0.2139434814453125,
-0.5808111429214478,
-1.2649444341659546,
-0.8148682117462158,
-0.13302892446517944,
-0.18119841814041138,
-0.25441867113113403,
0.6660788655281067,
0.2232515960931778,
-0.6173380613327026,
-0.3786921203136444,
-0.03995641693472862,
0.020901208743453026,
-0.04480929300189018,
-0.14926032721996307,
0.3475271463394165,
-0.2319783866405487,
-0.6774870753288269,
0.1469540297985077,
0.25634288787841797,
0.15273870527744293,
-0.21445313096046448,
-0.07601078599691391,
-0.03240714967250824,
0.11323943734169006,
0.7562364935874939,
0.2196531593799591,
-0.7902706861495972,
-0.06444072723388672,
-0.07814229279756546,
-0.2010926455259323,
0.22189189493656158,
1.1988939046859741,
-0.5322015881538391,
0.025697138160467148,
0.5517653822898865,
0.44991326332092285,
0.7125359773635864,
-0.1148456558585167,
0.3710310459136963,
-0.7029105424880981,
0.0820104330778122,
-0.15060342848300934,
0.4960136413574219,
0.3802756667137146,
-0.1540011465549469,
-0.022615374997258186,
0.08308346569538116,
-0.5197786092758179,
-0.7367928624153137,
0.33480653166770935,
-0.6975834369659424,
-0.5099804401397705,
1.2861762046813965,
-0.18300467729568481,
-0.3893094062805176,
0.13944658637046814,
-0.11636939644813538,
0.34448519349098206,
-0.12104663252830505,
0.8728707432746887,
1.0545254945755005,
-0.03301678225398064,
-0.29661014676094055,
-0.5605365037918091,
0.2902745306491852,
0.37032389640808105,
-0.5246990919113159,
0.4146479666233063,
0.6191440224647522,
0.47564977407455444,
0.3740041255950928,
0.4802345335483551,
-0.11917012929916382,
-0.10361753404140472,
-0.0553639754652977,
-0.14262379705905914,
-0.08666088432073593,
-0.6408371925354004,
-0.576885998249054,
0.33538171648979187,
-0.01434094924479723,
0.06261491030454636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11575v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11575v1
|
SEEP: Training Dynamics Grounds Latent Representation Search for Mitigating Backdoor Poisoning Attacks
| 2024-05-19T14:50:09 | 2024-05-19T14:50:09 |
Xuanli He, Qiongkai Xu, Jun Wang, Benjamin I. P. Rubinstein, Trevor Cohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Modern NLP models are often trained on public datasets drawn from diverse
sources, rendering them vulnerable to data poisoning attacks. These attacks can
manipulate the model's behavior in ways engineered by the attacker. One such
tactic involves the implantation of backdoors, achieved by poisoning specific
training instances with a textual trigger and a target class label. Several
strategies have been proposed to mitigate the risks associated with backdoor
attacks by identifying and removing suspected poisoned examples. However, we
observe that these strategies fail to offer effective protection against
several advanced backdoor attacks. To remedy this deficiency, we propose a
novel defensive mechanism that first exploits training dynamics to identify
poisoned samples with high precision, followed by a label propagation step to
improve recall and thus remove the majority of poisoned instances. Compared
with recent advanced defense methods, our method considerably reduces the
success rates of several backdoor attacks while maintaining high classification
accuracy on clean test sets.
|
[
-0.04017512500286102,
-0.5454237461090088,
0.22450906038284302,
0.13784709572792053,
0.12669596076011658,
0.07197152078151703,
0.13501782715320587,
-0.1111961305141449,
0.1453935205936432,
0.5056635141372681,
-0.5105146765708923,
-0.5503026247024536,
-0.6323224902153015,
-0.2769041061401367,
-0.28976744413375854,
1.0596739053726196,
0.12006986886262894,
-0.09954438358545303,
0.03559158742427826,
0.1206597164273262,
-0.28761884570121765,
-0.7823670506477356,
-0.7888580560684204,
-0.42058631777763367,
0.7625074982643127,
0.040134280920028687,
0.543921172618866,
0.14738944172859192,
0.30508333444595337,
0.19178886711597443,
-0.3619668781757355,
-0.1524803191423416,
-0.6170148253440857,
0.4307486116886139,
-0.15389862656593323,
-0.6787825226783752,
-0.3629685342311859,
0.15351635217666626,
0.4073265790939331,
0.45448529720306396,
-0.24272920191287994,
-0.4387213885784149,
0.02722383290529251,
0.5276589393615723,
-1.0171395540237427,
-0.17113745212554932,
-0.8034465312957764,
0.668643057346344,
-0.26534441113471985,
-0.732371985912323,
-0.6996283531188965,
0.05215929448604584,
0.1196870356798172,
-0.42602628469467163,
0.07133595645427704,
-0.22622299194335938,
0.6173973083496094,
0.3522726595401764,
-0.2991194427013397,
0.2627581059932709,
-0.4742264449596405,
0.5489587783813477,
-0.7604411244392395,
0.4060004949569702,
0.40046408772468567,
0.19237518310546875,
-0.6452795267105103,
-0.713042140007019,
-0.27968630194664,
-0.19495923817157745,
0.13728974759578705,
0.26471325755119324,
-0.09459251910448074,
0.12991227209568024,
0.4945988655090332,
0.033861760050058365,
-0.8504643440246582,
0.28554871678352356,
-0.04712027311325073,
-0.31303438544273376,
0.40224337577819824,
0.1720566600561142,
0.4058360457420349,
-0.015443550422787666,
-0.32551634311676025,
-0.31004610657691956,
-1.133165717124939,
-0.15040665864944458,
0.4993080794811249,
0.442392498254776,
0.045774906873703,
0.4171368181705475,
-0.06235741823911667,
0.41971123218536377,
-0.2640880048274994,
0.26845699548721313,
0.22079189121723175,
0.10112246870994568,
-0.12716983258724213,
0.3198404908180237,
0.695550799369812,
0.24868232011795044,
-0.006399139296263456,
-0.28255242109298706,
-0.4034000635147095,
0.05034426227211952,
0.6547492742538452,
-0.9208327531814575,
-0.4509894847869873,
0.3292023539543152,
-0.5076513886451721,
-0.8306704163551331,
-0.1578124612569809,
-1.1015074253082275,
-0.4766481816768646,
0.44208240509033203,
0.5304265022277832,
-0.4399189352989197,
-0.27427616715431213,
0.058421965688467026,
-0.37886959314346313,
0.4070042073726654,
0.13943813741207123,
-1.0147027969360352,
0.3278549909591675,
0.7116569876670837,
0.9802002310752869,
-0.06280899792909622,
-0.333547443151474,
-0.8833186626434326,
0.31421932578086853,
-0.549304187297821,
0.555008590221405,
-0.8172861337661743,
-0.4797777831554413,
0.08309821784496307,
-0.12161273509263992,
0.18497806787490845,
-0.6442064046859741,
0.023804862052202225,
-0.8656385540962219,
0.19838066399097443,
-0.16272900998592377,
-0.20489494502544403,
-0.19245615601539612,
0.5831998586654663,
-0.5526551008224487,
0.8948116898536682,
-0.3732703924179077,
-1.1087990999221802,
0.24085870385169983,
-0.5230335593223572,
-0.32708868384361267,
0.06491827964782715,
-0.23986154794692993,
-0.5558409094810486,
0.17294251918792725,
0.15431822836399078,
0.5890024304389954,
0.3349195718765259,
-0.12779542803764343,
-0.3138579726219177,
-0.32287150621414185,
-0.03250773996114731,
-0.49298617243766785,
0.8617773056030273,
0.018945693969726562,
-0.42749467492103577,
0.2739688754081726,
-0.76666259765625,
-0.04611175134778023,
0.2581389248371124,
-0.24853256344795227,
-0.6386131048202515,
0.21798649430274963,
-0.2893121540546417,
0.13392274081707,
-0.22841864824295044,
-0.3795473873615265,
0.34742221236228943,
-0.9218907356262207,
0.23013655841350555,
0.727748692035675,
0.5440268516540527,
0.23350442945957184,
-0.3084864616394043,
0.5044826865196228,
0.2670496702194214,
-0.010547015815973282,
-0.3126108944416046,
-0.6524724364280701,
-0.37200817465782166,
0.04554472118616104,
0.09776771068572998,
0.7066474556922913,
-0.840070366859436,
0.3693622052669525,
-0.08842982351779938,
-0.7965182662010193,
0.17786847054958344,
-0.3727109134197235,
0.5129154324531555,
0.556789219379425,
0.5661966800689697,
-0.1868245154619217,
-0.23201999068260193,
-0.5136793851852417,
-0.36461490392684937,
0.006159696727991104,
-0.20808154344558716,
-0.11605193465948105,
0.7527914643287659,
-0.20309416949748993,
0.6409310102462769,
-0.41811439394950867,
-0.11879725754261017,
0.441864013671875,
0.2530221939086914,
0.13019774854183197,
0.8309268951416016,
0.5983180999755859,
-0.8778021335601807,
-0.15546253323554993,
-0.27369874715805054,
-0.8410007953643799,
0.07449926435947418,
-0.14922450482845306,
0.07264016568660736,
-0.03798561170697212,
0.601607084274292,
-0.380111426115036,
0.8400312066078186,
0.4329347312450409,
-0.08465848863124847,
0.5992405414581299,
0.02045842632651329,
-0.08324389159679413,
-0.835675835609436,
0.039896976202726364,
-0.12670648097991943,
-0.15676884353160858,
-0.694339394569397,
0.430691659450531,
0.01523660123348236,
-0.730556309223175,
-0.6660626530647278,
0.42632248997688293,
-0.11391013115644455,
0.2003549039363861,
-0.02559264935553074,
-0.02875060774385929,
-0.10639744997024536,
0.5195320248603821,
0.12635716795921326,
0.8280700445175171,
0.8120344877243042,
-0.6999174952507019,
0.4346129596233368,
0.24496594071388245,
0.10606230050325394,
0.3577430844306946,
-0.5448296070098877,
0.3065207302570343,
0.09433753788471222,
0.4286794066429138,
-0.9008323550224304,
-0.1113487184047699,
0.6248719692230225,
-0.5268389582633972,
0.772233784198761,
-0.4650391936302185,
-0.42179495096206665,
-0.0242916252464056,
-0.5604190826416016,
0.23263897001743317,
0.27453306317329407,
-0.9676875472068787,
0.6085959672927856,
0.09721825271844864,
-0.08707074075937271,
-0.9397015571594238,
-0.8305959701538086,
0.21513594686985016,
-0.35028424859046936,
-0.580174446105957,
0.56775963306427,
0.11620111018419266,
0.02665131725370884,
-0.3352868854999542,
-0.506963849067688,
-0.059274766594171524,
0.5532012581825256,
0.1823575794696808,
-0.07787707448005676,
-0.1267262101173401,
0.23457060754299164,
0.18164457380771637,
-0.38406845927238464,
0.3619741201400757,
-0.3504171073436737,
0.6714650988578796,
0.26015743613243103,
-0.5792031288146973,
-0.5172492265701294,
0.6497411131858826,
0.4347338080406189,
-0.2998616397380829,
1.045560598373413,
0.1718565672636032,
-0.6388570070266724,
-0.4502832293510437,
-0.03169797733426094,
-0.6695184111595154,
-0.5547478795051575,
0.4519340395927429,
-0.3482844829559326,
-0.18733792006969452,
0.49455535411834717,
-0.093767449259758,
0.18579773604869843,
0.17479807138442993,
0.31927716732025146,
0.18902187049388885,
0.8744786381721497,
0.296159952878952,
-0.001895879046060145,
0.3957078158855438,
-0.2841700613498688,
0.30318519473075867,
-0.6837278604507446,
-0.5440928936004639,
-0.492374062538147,
-0.20846113562583923,
-0.46019619703292847,
-0.17796635627746582,
0.2950453758239746,
0.023374279960989952,
-0.27936848998069763,
0.13722124695777893,
-0.6335728764533997,
0.388947069644928,
0.5193727016448975,
0.3419759273529053,
0.00407247431576252,
0.07549690455198288,
-0.4160352051258087,
-0.2560358941555023,
-0.6557741165161133,
-0.4286940395832062,
1.183567762374878,
0.46112892031669617,
0.9913511872291565,
0.25323814153671265,
1.0789494514465332,
0.10157816857099533,
0.10264144837856293,
-0.6544230580329895,
0.6126659512519836,
0.11166051030158997,
-0.5202693939208984,
-0.1070183739066124,
-0.4684733748435974,
-0.9517090916633606,
0.17278894782066345,
-0.32132384181022644,
-0.9559487700462341,
0.12467341870069504,
0.25449469685554504,
-0.2295326441526413,
0.5644012093544006,
-0.5392202734947205,
0.8432369828224182,
-0.30446454882621765,
-0.573675274848938,
0.02771860919892788,
-0.5934175848960876,
0.1262385994195938,
-0.22346524894237518,
-0.4018155634403229,
0.2316673845052719,
-0.11597834527492523,
0.9547169208526611,
-0.6121395230293274,
0.8910168409347534,
-0.41528815031051636,
-0.14789506793022156,
-0.2096259891986847,
0.20334084331989288,
0.7187455892562866,
0.06100359186530113,
0.09908952564001083,
0.2823405861854553,
-0.1858217418193817,
-0.49066677689552307,
-0.6467181444168091,
0.44994786381721497,
-0.33482059836387634,
-0.8578254580497742,
-0.6800747513771057,
0.001874305889941752,
-0.3214344084262848,
0.14483273029327393,
0.6258131265640259,
0.3412728011608124,
0.09997057169675827,
0.22848057746887207,
1.0735595226287842,
-0.6453902721405029,
0.5794939398765564,
0.25091829895973206,
-0.15766029059886932,
-0.14885438978672028,
0.9286218881607056,
0.013073367066681385,
0.18166358768939972,
0.4090809226036072,
0.27179962396621704,
-0.045959990471601486,
-0.822794497013092,
0.13742394745349884,
0.002085196552798152,
-0.5714346766471863,
-0.4215031862258911,
-0.7077717781066895,
-0.5128850340843201,
-0.6097720265388489,
0.03551771119236946,
-0.4398450553417206,
0.09696250408887863,
-0.35845816135406494,
-0.161890909075737,
0.37131643295288086,
0.3629651367664337,
-0.14480510354042053,
0.6264246702194214,
-0.6794223189353943,
0.05239633098244667,
0.5110061764717102,
0.4143005907535553,
0.18747036159038544,
-0.4420352876186371,
0.047413505613803864,
-0.14053192734718323,
-0.6461229920387268,
-1.463539719581604,
0.750724732875824,
-0.050743818283081055,
0.673363983631134,
0.4579117000102997,
0.20858794450759888,
0.38008958101272583,
-0.663116455078125,
0.784667432308197,
0.18797531723976135,
-0.8175437450408936,
0.9942322373390198,
-0.4679146111011505,
-0.18058645725250244,
0.20648133754730225,
0.6481708288192749,
-0.5625143051147461,
-0.3411347568035126,
-0.6636191606521606,
-1.087247610092163,
0.36562463641166687,
0.3104267716407776,
0.13563336431980133,
0.08275358378887177,
0.4037472605705261,
-0.17586839199066162,
0.21930938959121704,
-0.7796385884284973,
-0.2405589073896408,
-0.23944208025932312,
0.037982165813446045,
0.3435949385166168,
-0.30235570669174194,
-0.3649623990058899,
0.2800772488117218,
0.8130547404289246,
0.07927674800157547,
0.3159080147743225,
0.25026312470436096,
0.03604204207658768,
0.19475021958351135,
0.05584140866994858,
0.40233516693115234,
0.13073492050170898,
-0.30260324478149414,
0.1986076533794403,
0.01000975165516138,
-0.6760766506195068,
0.1927478015422821,
0.16736234724521637,
-0.15525910258293152,
-0.2831294536590576,
0.45875459909439087,
0.39434781670570374,
0.2601015567779541,
-0.5706078410148621,
0.7152149081230164,
-0.041447192430496216,
-0.05182590335607529,
-0.3068319857120514,
0.33357325196266174,
-0.23256036639213562,
0.23158831894397736,
0.5186351537704468,
0.19881002604961395,
0.1486218273639679,
-0.45079660415649414,
0.44630247354507446,
0.42877423763275146,
-0.5628600120544434,
-0.22901971638202667,
0.5556559562683105,
0.2181980162858963,
-0.5660697221755981,
0.6257306337356567,
0.08831977099180222,
-0.9344830513000488,
0.49284061789512634,
0.4964495003223419,
0.8210566639900208,
-0.6925569176673889,
-0.1604054570198059,
0.0751405656337738,
0.4247525930404663,
-0.047245047986507416,
0.24088802933692932,
0.1307435780763626,
-0.7597058415412903,
-0.18790708482265472,
-0.2847391366958618,
-0.374565452337265,
0.4965023696422577,
-0.6702668070793152,
0.06782018393278122,
-0.8063856363296509,
0.0424356572329998,
-0.14954525232315063,
-0.16473984718322754,
-0.0388757586479187,
0.10437573492527008,
0.2431221902370453,
0.9783711433410645,
-1.1252983808517456,
0.5796107649803162,
0.4533688426017761,
-0.44711121916770935,
-0.5506275296211243,
0.48353394865989685,
0.3039977550506592,
-0.3661196529865265,
0.8188961148262024,
0.5192498564720154,
-0.1159142255783081,
-0.2249009758234024,
-0.7838191986083984,
-0.5144809484481812,
0.4380594491958618,
0.1917910873889923,
-0.38541266322135925,
-0.0951090082526207,
-0.5872713327407837,
0.3754214644432068,
0.026780113577842712,
-0.11767714470624924,
0.22120775282382965,
0.22274257242679596,
-0.09514610469341278,
-0.4164137542247772,
0.025916997343301773,
-0.4489666521549225,
-0.2099885493516922,
0.1404404640197754,
-0.21938008069992065,
0.6090598106384277,
0.016099296510219574,
-0.14449046552181244,
-0.17959509789943695,
0.5554016828536987,
0.7706578373908997,
0.6099982857704163,
0.24724867939949036,
0.7301100492477417,
0.7434673309326172,
-0.1864926517009735,
0.8502986431121826,
0.07828917354345322,
0.11054379492998123,
1.2481802701950073,
-0.30758729577064514,
0.9584035873413086,
0.528148889541626,
-0.09377320110797882,
0.3829943537712097,
0.8007305860519409,
-0.27296727895736694,
0.8574662804603577,
0.5773509740829468,
-0.2197805643081665,
0.006380986887961626,
0.2718685567378998,
-0.6996932625770569,
0.39642927050590515,
0.5841163396835327,
-0.20829139649868011,
-0.14787063002586365,
0.25560563802719116,
0.26438987255096436,
0.18941035866737366,
-0.19639308750629425,
0.6520870327949524,
-0.09720015525817871,
-0.3677692413330078,
0.5255455374717712,
-0.20098385214805603,
0.6561049818992615,
-0.7296251654624939,
-0.2237984538078308,
-0.23056603968143463,
-0.03803619369864464,
-0.3238046169281006,
-0.5056610107421875,
0.3957192599773407,
-0.16601382195949554,
0.05725623667240143,
-0.12196236103773117,
0.6689180135726929,
-0.15980926156044006,
0.2534790635108948,
0.6467969417572021,
0.02661231905221939,
0.20136308670043945,
-0.4286797344684601,
-0.5933271646499634,
-0.08203139901161194,
-0.15282250940799713,
-0.507590115070343,
0.3178281784057617,
0.29217153787612915,
0.2309124618768692,
0.777387261390686,
0.7072381973266602,
0.39709988236427307,
0.390616774559021,
-0.10022033005952835,
1.1064555644989014,
-0.6782426238059998,
-0.7010851502418518,
-0.7248028516769409,
0.3187195360660553,
-0.29520389437675476,
0.010784750804305077,
0.6092886328697205,
0.6376659274101257,
0.6705048680305481,
0.18577098846435547,
0.5233243107795715,
0.4422414302825928,
0.20594367384910583,
-0.7347432374954224,
1.1778180599212646,
-0.6449804306030273,
0.5132822394371033,
-0.3022851347923279,
-0.8042432069778442,
-0.5270718932151794,
0.7600569725036621,
-0.23272304236888885,
0.15770001709461212,
0.7103908061981201,
1.0669595003128052,
0.01050524041056633,
0.08372144401073456,
0.29032057523727417,
0.40346309542655945,
0.688282310962677,
0.5247706770896912,
0.9555969834327698,
-0.5862699151039124,
0.5070947408676147,
-0.19976958632469177,
-0.39768537878990173,
-0.2090212106704712,
-1.0792839527130127,
-1.1870023012161255,
-0.2805921733379364,
-0.38094469904899597,
-0.9178979992866516,
0.26737546920776367,
0.5201548933982849,
0.9690721035003662,
-0.8051691055297852,
0.3419665992259979,
-0.14178510010242462,
0.029931580647826195,
-0.24155984818935394,
-0.20896057784557343,
0.2882130444049835,
-0.4923589527606964,
-0.2766197621822357,
0.7282699346542358,
0.47555381059646606,
0.1576353758573532,
-0.24346260726451874,
0.04028777405619621,
-0.3111405074596405,
-0.1722942739725113,
0.13429756462574005,
0.4785235524177551,
-0.44368359446525574,
-0.25882527232170105,
-0.4992184340953827,
-0.10509362816810608,
0.05752288177609444,
0.7470241785049438,
-1.0229640007019043,
0.5337644815444946,
0.5756530165672302,
0.8900898098945618,
0.45444872975349426,
-0.5198628902435303,
0.5651084780693054,
-1.2162208557128906,
0.5105229616165161,
0.6480957865715027,
0.2133558839559555,
0.17651411890983582,
-0.6661272644996643,
0.5881856679916382,
0.5280303359031677,
-0.3180525004863739,
-1.092429757118225,
0.3970877230167389,
-0.7988678812980652,
-0.40771493315696716,
0.8812835216522217,
-0.40065523982048035,
-0.38219767808914185,
-0.08616696298122406,
0.31994542479515076,
0.16111886501312256,
-0.4005054533481598,
0.8689684271812439,
0.3347610831260681,
0.3200790584087372,
-0.0529097244143486,
-0.4033251106739044,
0.4887092411518097,
0.3347981572151184,
-0.872261106967926,
0.10280836373567581,
0.17207366228103638,
0.2546559274196625,
0.43006694316864014,
0.11678779125213623,
-0.2240574061870575,
0.1765097677707672,
0.2621118426322937,
-0.2230454683303833,
0.03286256268620491,
-0.6002418398857117,
-0.5786650776863098,
0.3259805738925934,
-0.4786253273487091,
-0.3962000608444214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11559v1
|
DaVinci at SemEval-2024 Task 9: Few-shot prompting GPT-3.5 for Unconventional Reasoning
| 2024-05-19T14:21:53 | 2024-05-19T14:21:53 |
Suyash Vardhan Mathur, Akshett Rai Jindal, Manish Shrivastava
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While significant work has been done in the field of NLP on vertical
thinking, which involves primarily logical thinking, little work has been done
towards lateral thinking, which involves looking at problems from an
unconventional perspective and defying existing conceptions and notions.
Towards this direction, SemEval 2024 introduces the task of BRAINTEASER, which
involves two types of questions -- Sentence Puzzles and Word Puzzles that defy
conventional common-sense reasoning and constraints. In this paper, we tackle
both types of questions using few-shot prompting on GPT-3.5 and gain insights
regarding the difference in the nature of the two types. Our prompting strategy
placed us 26th on the leaderboard for the Sentence Puzzle and 15th on the Word
Puzzle task.
|
[
-0.653860330581665,
-1.3159252405166626,
0.9289863705635071,
-0.06877104192972183,
-0.34956756234169006,
-0.1523522436618805,
0.24003517627716064,
-0.24548520147800446,
0.11699772626161575,
0.2498963177204132,
-1.2301836013793945,
-0.1670861542224884,
-0.6823127269744873,
0.3847680687904358,
0.05183137580752373,
0.9965731501579285,
-0.07704085856676102,
-0.04805377498269081,
0.17008596658706665,
-0.1350882202386856,
-0.9287181496620178,
-0.27192118763923645,
-0.6768308281898499,
-0.2017584592103958,
0.6537607312202454,
0.3299494683742523,
0.47090044617652893,
0.143654003739357,
0.5372979044914246,
0.2538975775241852,
-0.16434116661548615,
0.29256728291511536,
-0.20648814737796783,
0.20270085334777832,
-0.2935235798358917,
-0.4170383810997009,
-0.12879428267478943,
-0.04374539852142334,
0.3007408082485199,
0.48412373661994934,
0.022354410961270332,
0.07930354028940201,
0.01788174919784069,
0.8675246834754944,
-0.6162660121917725,
-0.14930641651153564,
-0.7203372716903687,
0.26036256551742554,
-0.3336728513240814,
-0.2126966416835785,
-0.10493092238903046,
-0.1454852968454361,
-0.021409479901194572,
-0.46840593218803406,
-0.013482088223099709,
-0.16038066148757935,
0.6052635908126831,
0.7061828970909119,
-0.5874037146568298,
-0.14753767848014832,
-0.4184907376766205,
0.5260011553764343,
-0.19739393889904022,
-0.0385589636862278,
0.42524397373199463,
0.369840145111084,
-0.2982392907142639,
-0.5480607748031616,
-0.6698086261749268,
0.007550189271569252,
0.4253367483615875,
0.27610573172569275,
-0.29703840613365173,
-0.23723550140857697,
0.5095586180686951,
0.025867408141493797,
-0.7546197772026062,
-0.019817089661955833,
-0.26325884461402893,
0.08122970163822174,
0.47078877687454224,
0.47022873163223267,
0.2981364130973816,
-0.08339688926935196,
-0.43754518032073975,
0.21020366251468658,
-0.7148509621620178,
0.21484659612178802,
0.19049642980098724,
-0.06490027159452438,
0.2192297726869583,
0.5632444024085999,
-0.23347213864326477,
0.9558919072151184,
0.1652212142944336,
0.31775179505348206,
-0.050388265401124954,
-0.30660945177078247,
-0.05067650228738785,
0.028365453705191612,
0.426517128944397,
0.5154131650924683,
0.24759192764759064,
0.2641364634037018,
-0.0007988036959432065,
0.30799925327301025,
0.26588907837867737,
-0.48316290974617004,
-0.30875641107559204,
0.3153988718986511,
-0.11242061853408813,
0.0032698495779186487,
-0.09237796813249588,
-0.5922468304634094,
-0.4984505772590637,
0.03135324642062187,
0.7491011023521423,
-0.6174673438072205,
0.23297977447509766,
0.16102971136569977,
-0.5251659750938416,
0.26233938336372375,
0.6470597386360168,
-1.0268008708953857,
0.08969280868768692,
0.7424668073654175,
0.6756430268287659,
-0.3228362202644348,
-0.2932864725589752,
-0.8262259364128113,
0.154684916138649,
-0.2595662474632263,
1.091653823852539,
-0.36686137318611145,
-0.2588862478733063,
-0.2594680190086365,
-0.015323766507208347,
0.013454784639179707,
-0.1417914181947708,
0.5270348787307739,
-0.44725334644317627,
0.32101258635520935,
-1.0338846445083618,
-0.5287391543388367,
-0.49365630745887756,
0.6330934166908264,
-0.3752666413784027,
0.9159971475601196,
-0.00434920797124505,
-0.9051865339279175,
0.7243186831474304,
-0.8593026995658875,
-0.19075554609298706,
0.5843233466148376,
-0.6614055037498474,
0.03931044787168503,
-0.10967635363340378,
0.6210204362869263,
0.294232577085495,
-0.07834924012422562,
-0.059944089502096176,
-0.16731175780296326,
-0.5570244193077087,
-0.01172114722430706,
-0.3746505081653595,
0.9954677224159241,
0.14600065350532532,
-0.7011829018592834,
-0.32332736253738403,
-0.6140244007110596,
0.1665591448545456,
0.29728034138679504,
0.06438947468996048,
-0.28885120153427124,
-0.12730515003204346,
-0.3846142292022705,
0.35092243552207947,
0.10528945922851562,
-0.5341103076934814,
0.7435401678085327,
-0.40187719464302063,
0.48575738072395325,
0.6037278771400452,
0.6516843438148499,
0.12575241923332214,
-0.3183462619781494,
0.7558502554893494,
0.3023567497730255,
0.028112564235925674,
-0.15584324300289154,
-1.2185964584350586,
-0.5369983315467834,
-0.1335039883852005,
-0.10946493595838547,
0.9531702399253845,
-1.025467872619629,
0.039726026356220245,
0.18973666429519653,
-0.3724246323108673,
-0.3307006359100342,
0.03572632372379303,
0.15408141911029816,
0.5650416612625122,
0.48868289589881897,
-0.006575203966349363,
-0.40105968713760376,
-0.8673329949378967,
-0.6461624503135681,
-0.08666104078292847,
0.220518559217453,
-0.011789077892899513,
1.017439365386963,
-0.06876744329929352,
0.7350617051124573,
-0.8987585306167603,
-0.41943052411079407,
-0.32474857568740845,
0.3361130654811859,
0.4363451898097992,
0.373005747795105,
0.4022831320762634,
-0.6851011514663696,
-0.3884735405445099,
-0.33746692538261414,
-0.6198675632476807,
-0.09807825088500977,
-0.19412100315093994,
0.26496070623397827,
0.18514810502529144,
0.30044546723365784,
-0.5428270101547241,
0.772748589515686,
0.1276906430721283,
-0.4801138639450073,
0.19542816281318665,
0.03953290730714798,
0.5050649046897888,
-0.8872358202934265,
-0.34306567907333374,
-0.20612016320228577,
0.008655753917992115,
-0.5804262161254883,
-0.09065122902393341,
-0.12658941745758057,
0.1169334128499031,
-0.6452489495277405,
0.328708678483963,
-0.4995236098766327,
0.20848369598388672,
-0.16887375712394714,
0.11578072607517242,
0.10895726829767227,
0.3421626687049866,
-0.0006671566516160965,
0.8604666590690613,
0.4822905659675598,
-0.5594457983970642,
0.44844990968704224,
0.5058952569961548,
-0.21921972930431366,
0.5014969110488892,
-0.5880066156387329,
0.5202139019966125,
-0.14648129045963287,
0.2767649292945862,
-1.065630555152893,
-0.05172122269868851,
0.28401321172714233,
-0.3272613286972046,
-0.08315126597881317,
-0.08859541267156601,
-0.37558022141456604,
-0.8224489092826843,
-0.27327045798301697,
0.26521462202072144,
0.46947741508483887,
-0.3532351553440094,
0.12158157676458359,
0.2631870210170746,
-0.2812211513519287,
-0.411056786775589,
-1.1946293115615845,
0.07885812968015671,
-0.3341306149959564,
-0.7635051608085632,
0.23706358671188354,
-0.1487332433462143,
-0.3844214379787445,
-0.24652813374996185,
-0.0019140889635309577,
-0.17401941120624542,
-0.03549439087510109,
0.1622387170791626,
0.24275042116641998,
-0.131026029586792,
-0.11213495582342148,
0.141473650932312,
-0.1156969740986824,
0.02539137378334999,
-0.1417667716741562,
0.29694169759750366,
-0.5359351634979248,
-0.7038385272026062,
-0.47733667492866516,
0.6500232815742493,
-0.20311011373996735,
0.09629759192466736,
0.3654938042163849,
0.6339587569236755,
-0.29177936911582947,
-0.15062931180000305,
-0.7616937756538391,
-0.2979958951473236,
-0.4860203266143799,
0.025176983326673508,
-0.6869420409202576,
-1.2080694437026978,
0.48630398511886597,
0.21554388105869293,
-0.19219347834587097,
0.5238457918167114,
0.9157417416572571,
-0.1563449203968048,
1.1140120029449463,
0.3320007920265198,
0.2776739299297333,
-0.00654784357175231,
-0.26707154512405396,
0.20287442207336426,
-0.5695609450340271,
-0.07181297242641449,
-0.1996113359928131,
-0.39155542850494385,
-0.5518483519554138,
-0.27017858624458313,
0.6096816658973694,
-0.019679633900523186,
-0.05003804713487625,
0.5343645215034485,
-0.929807186126709,
0.7207397818565369,
0.6126226782798767,
-0.11112341284751892,
0.23228725790977478,
-0.3985711336135864,
-0.3477713167667389,
-0.36170169711112976,
-0.6805906295776367,
-0.4578407406806946,
0.6735488772392273,
0.04818297177553177,
0.3826984763145447,
0.30427390336990356,
1.0297129154205322,
-0.00425825547426939,
-0.47464096546173096,
-0.7702590227127075,
0.7519818544387817,
0.3266327977180481,
-1.1336417198181152,
-0.36294832825660706,
0.0307520292699337,
-1.0777097940444946,
0.3271004557609558,
-0.0044345674104988575,
-1.1539500951766968,
0.2985168993473053,
-0.167001411318779,
-0.8865702152252197,
0.05508656054735184,
-0.6359289288520813,
0.798213005065918,
0.02045857161283493,
-0.4056522846221924,
-0.035210926085710526,
-0.7547771334648132,
0.42501771450042725,
-0.014598110690712929,
-0.06346356868743896,
-0.052179936319589615,
-0.2915063500404358,
0.45001935958862305,
-0.2937801480293274,
0.46149125695228577,
-0.2158544510602951,
0.10327540338039398,
0.6919338703155518,
0.32623326778411865,
0.397501140832901,
0.3613739013671875,
0.16378925740718842,
-0.17083489894866943,
0.35635456442832947,
-0.35030311346054077,
-0.6240518689155579,
0.4805511236190796,
-0.42851176857948303,
-1.193876028060913,
-0.9176961779594421,
-0.6395534873008728,
-0.41516974568367004,
0.25992855429649353,
0.5976544618606567,
0.19972281157970428,
-0.2845825254917145,
0.019709544256329536,
0.6155456900596619,
-0.023108912631869316,
0.887089192867279,
0.3679826259613037,
0.2199748456478119,
-0.28624317049980164,
0.21590682864189148,
0.4111570417881012,
-0.04452623054385185,
0.21096262335777283,
0.14283117651939392,
-0.1267329752445221,
-0.5644098520278931,
-0.478652685880661,
-0.1516590714454651,
-0.7519307136535645,
-0.03249943256378174,
-0.8052403330802917,
-0.13956153392791748,
-0.4004161059856415,
-0.3170557916164398,
-0.18645818531513214,
-0.6554681658744812,
-0.12080135196447372,
-0.12617386877536774,
0.37564077973365784,
0.7739860415458679,
-0.036504559218883514,
-0.04387006163597107,
-0.9276872277259827,
0.39810100197792053,
0.7283134460449219,
-0.2802049517631531,
-0.4999297261238098,
-0.47801682353019714,
0.17060990631580353,
-0.15347535908222198,
-0.5991037487983704,
-1.1181640625,
0.19894428551197052,
-0.14956721663475037,
0.326553612947464,
0.36687028408050537,
-0.07460340112447739,
0.9544594287872314,
-0.8053303360939026,
1.332014560699463,
0.14886067807674408,
-0.744343101978302,
1.1495565176010132,
-0.7065949440002441,
0.8401194214820862,
0.9822015166282654,
0.5406709909439087,
-0.31834378838539124,
-0.28865543007850647,
-0.6997738480567932,
-0.2954348623752594,
0.7070488333702087,
0.3528693616390228,
-0.01059328205883503,
-0.3159716725349426,
0.21245791018009186,
0.28655222058296204,
0.09130417555570602,
-0.6650041341781616,
-0.06470450758934021,
-0.04858210310339928,
0.3775401711463928,
0.13962259888648987,
-0.026612576097249985,
-0.395361989736557,
-0.567501962184906,
0.417012482881546,
-0.06548837572336197,
0.24696464836597443,
0.4265434145927429,
-0.06635894626379013,
0.02043304406106472,
0.4739592671394348,
0.7488505244255066,
0.6803902983665466,
-0.08806644380092621,
0.010673441924154758,
0.5327267646789551,
-0.5260505676269531,
0.33942291140556335,
0.024769287556409836,
-0.300432026386261,
-0.19315457344055176,
0.3947456479072571,
0.8003678917884827,
-0.18931908905506134,
-0.25819018483161926,
0.8091540336608887,
0.13606314361095428,
-0.5341461300849915,
-0.41141819953918457,
0.2791919708251953,
0.0647367313504219,
0.520025372505188,
0.34872883558273315,
-0.024545064195990562,
0.5298120379447937,
-0.5561445355415344,
0.1644521802663803,
0.36821603775024414,
-0.3981143534183502,
-0.23710612952709198,
0.7861011028289795,
0.10704568773508072,
-0.16941024363040924,
0.4279736876487732,
-0.5228936672210693,
-0.5576716065406799,
0.42705467343330383,
0.36344069242477417,
0.9996592998504639,
0.04893233999609947,
0.21859508752822876,
0.19026300311088562,
0.38151630759239197,
0.0173864234238863,
0.8600305318832397,
-0.15303944051265717,
-0.6925863027572632,
-0.5237749218940735,
-0.028403155505657196,
-0.37952667474746704,
0.17711395025253296,
-0.4269115924835205,
0.4884212613105774,
-0.3670884966850281,
-0.35357579588890076,
0.20935069024562836,
0.2943936884403229,
-0.6677352786064148,
0.1640741527080536,
0.42138779163360596,
0.8551892638206482,
-0.7378010153770447,
0.8269476890563965,
0.8609062433242798,
-0.690265417098999,
-0.7165382504463196,
0.04253818094730377,
0.6379593014717102,
-0.7651260495185852,
0.9739866852760315,
0.2712779939174652,
-0.2219022512435913,
0.1672372817993164,
-0.5474976301193237,
-0.5330216288566589,
1.0870198011398315,
0.003959475085139275,
-0.40287232398986816,
-0.15176129341125488,
-0.08922349661588669,
0.276978999376297,
-0.19169409573078156,
0.23843957483768463,
0.5268535614013672,
0.7716970443725586,
0.18107889592647552,
-0.5588347911834717,
0.016691988334059715,
-0.24362003803253174,
0.08393888175487518,
0.1901659071445465,
-0.6097199320793152,
0.6910062432289124,
-0.3479483425617218,
-0.08391666412353516,
-0.09282570332288742,
0.5441290736198425,
0.5223241448402405,
0.4093737006187439,
0.5201312899589539,
0.6412206888198853,
0.48989781737327576,
-0.2143450230360031,
0.98497474193573,
0.17852279543876648,
-0.19166068732738495,
1.031099557876587,
-0.4759863317012787,
0.7445852756500244,
0.8774223327636719,
-0.3463411033153534,
0.61420077085495,
0.6849883198738098,
-0.23617146909236908,
0.686371386051178,
-0.02591966837644577,
-0.17186518013477325,
-0.29037243127822876,
0.24255453050136566,
-0.44593703746795654,
0.7412806749343872,
0.2577986717224121,
0.3251861333847046,
-0.22491084039211273,
0.2502169609069824,
-0.10346300899982452,
0.04738949239253998,
-0.22777648270130157,
0.7945411801338196,
0.28022730350494385,
-1.1984244585037231,
0.547873854637146,
-0.2519558072090149,
0.44862642884254456,
-0.4327075481414795,
-0.08179593086242676,
0.045460015535354614,
0.09168294817209244,
0.018261676654219627,
-0.9517375826835632,
0.39261338114738464,
-0.07187507301568985,
0.11130929738283157,
-0.3487003445625305,
0.8163706660270691,
-0.06306904554367065,
-0.16557712852954865,
-0.12268194556236267,
0.7268672585487366,
0.16108207404613495,
-0.2346726804971695,
-1.1248369216918945,
-0.07903452217578888,
-0.024959692731499672,
-0.5376957058906555,
0.1302451193332672,
0.8199161887168884,
-0.022206522524356842,
0.538623571395874,
0.2768886387348175,
-0.044288042932748795,
0.0247803945094347,
0.15053369104862213,
0.7208313345909119,
-0.8879683613777161,
-0.7655825614929199,
-1.1549822092056274,
0.5140962600708008,
0.006507122423499823,
-0.7117511630058289,
0.9053734540939331,
0.2599111497402191,
0.3627780079841614,
-0.26791083812713623,
0.34863367676734924,
-0.058623895049095154,
0.376115083694458,
-0.5920858979225159,
0.4249354302883148,
-0.5026276707649231,
-0.002566190669313073,
-0.5149838328361511,
-0.9189540147781372,
-0.2776113748550415,
0.6141399145126343,
-0.6427657604217529,
0.04928283393383026,
1.3527238368988037,
0.6675817370414734,
0.2448139488697052,
0.5944515466690063,
0.33709943294525146,
-0.08340812474489212,
-0.05439666286110878,
0.9461376070976257,
1.225827693939209,
-0.3495476543903351,
0.37585151195526123,
0.05406065657734871,
-0.22231653332710266,
-0.0934809222817421,
-1.0235154628753662,
-1.147311806678772,
-0.788280189037323,
-0.42892882227897644,
-0.07431264966726303,
0.10476798564195633,
0.9069454669952393,
0.27963465452194214,
-0.6514093279838562,
0.21790802478790283,
-0.5336629748344421,
-0.1707378476858139,
-0.2645028829574585,
-0.1723518967628479,
0.08184144645929337,
-0.2823452651500702,
-0.6762361526489258,
0.5476481318473816,
0.6712823510169983,
0.032041992992162704,
-0.13361114263534546,
0.4165104925632477,
-0.7788740396499634,
0.004734760150313377,
0.4174883961677551,
0.05277090519666672,
-0.8297783136367798,
-0.5208412408828735,
-0.04541086032986641,
0.011484484188258648,
-0.02409503422677517,
0.6350303888320923,
-0.963555097579956,
0.20849604904651642,
0.7689558267593384,
0.6903468370437622,
0.8097639083862305,
-0.10072720050811768,
0.47932714223861694,
-0.28301194310188293,
0.3576926589012146,
0.7446501851081848,
0.2189309298992157,
0.11428690701723099,
-0.4911723732948303,
0.7338336110115051,
0.4323430359363556,
-0.7741960287094116,
-0.6255292892456055,
0.5544456243515015,
-0.9253012537956238,
-0.368973046541214,
1.0415171384811401,
0.08347046375274658,
-0.284280925989151,
-0.31070899963378906,
-0.39682531356811523,
-0.00945864524692297,
-0.10231359302997589,
0.46167612075805664,
1.3294461965560913,
-0.5853554010391235,
-0.2436787188053131,
-0.8107558488845825,
0.6550158262252808,
0.8609625101089478,
-0.6506748795509338,
-0.6306240558624268,
0.3726067543029785,
-0.056907493621110916,
0.09507109969854355,
0.9209083318710327,
-0.05655260756611824,
0.559098482131958,
0.22136247158050537,
-0.4838290810585022,
-0.04046026989817619,
-0.11185553669929504,
-0.3392716646194458,
0.08030969649553299,
-0.1850811094045639,
-0.14301402866840363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11524v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11524v1
|
Simple-Sampling and Hard-Mixup with Prototypes to Rebalance Contrastive Learning for Text Classification
| 2024-05-19T11:33:49 | 2024-05-19T11:33:49 |
Mengyu Li, Yonghao Liu, Fausto Giunchiglia, Xiaoyue Feng, Renchu Guan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text classification is a crucial and fundamental task in natural language
processing. Compared with the previous learning paradigm of pre-training and
fine-tuning by cross entropy loss, the recently proposed supervised contrastive
learning approach has received tremendous attention due to its powerful feature
learning capability and robustness. Although several studies have incorporated
this technique for text classification, some limitations remain. First, many
text datasets are imbalanced, and the learning mechanism of supervised
contrastive learning is sensitive to data imbalance, which may harm the model
performance. Moreover, these models leverage separate classification branch
with cross entropy and supervised contrastive learning branch without explicit
mutual guidance. To this end, we propose a novel model named SharpReCL for
imbalanced text classification tasks. First, we obtain the prototype vector of
each class in the balanced classification branch to act as a representation of
each class. Then, by further explicitly leveraging the prototype vectors, we
construct a proper and sufficient target sample set with the same size for each
class to perform the supervised contrastive learning procedure. The empirical
results show the effectiveness of our model, which even outperforms popular
large language models across several datasets.
|
[
-0.2881716787815094,
-0.4650420844554901,
0.21888110041618347,
0.060184456408023834,
-0.4700232744216919,
0.1099163293838501,
-0.264664888381958,
-0.5869603157043457,
-0.019289813935756683,
0.4932072162628174,
-0.473432719707489,
-0.5189021229743958,
-0.5682612657546997,
0.14053688943386078,
-0.5014723539352417,
1.4286288022994995,
-0.07400540262460709,
-0.11761600524187088,
-0.13358841836452484,
-0.42855319380760193,
-0.3294118046760559,
-0.4163181781768799,
-0.43187224864959717,
-0.5774502754211426,
0.4604737460613251,
0.6740708947181702,
0.3748290240764618,
0.4778398275375366,
0.5014501810073853,
0.34517839550971985,
-0.054939016699790955,
-0.014118285849690437,
-0.36862611770629883,
0.15917305648326874,
-0.26281845569610596,
-0.632611870765686,
-0.16876600682735443,
0.2091810703277588,
0.5198000073432922,
0.8701267838478088,
-0.07450071722269058,
-0.1355886459350586,
0.5403692126274109,
0.39223092794418335,
-0.8135846853256226,
-0.10742240399122238,
-0.8069193363189697,
0.029173683375120163,
-0.23747406899929047,
-0.06487373262643814,
-0.5200422406196594,
-0.08454735577106476,
0.3935793936252594,
-0.48306381702423096,
0.7905758619308472,
0.02618013694882393,
0.8637984991073608,
0.15432047843933105,
-0.4120125472545624,
-0.27939900755882263,
-0.648165762424469,
1.113527774810791,
-0.5014048218727112,
0.26646292209625244,
0.2910762131214142,
0.1669737547636032,
0.32334110140800476,
-0.8656582832336426,
-0.5469105839729309,
-0.01902954839169979,
-0.06295131891965866,
0.056702662259340286,
-0.11933117359876633,
0.053641535341739655,
-0.10064174979925156,
0.5953382849693298,
-0.509090781211853,
0.41305506229400635,
-0.45252424478530884,
-0.11373965442180634,
0.3126504421234131,
0.15349754691123962,
0.16694054007530212,
-0.08086932450532913,
-0.714223325252533,
-0.36649033427238464,
-0.22584082186222076,
-0.0711434856057167,
0.2451779693365097,
0.663898766040802,
-0.3323979377746582,
0.39226216077804565,
-0.26828664541244507,
0.7286078333854675,
0.2552257776260376,
0.0761929601430893,
0.5533450841903687,
-0.25553005933761597,
-0.42116788029670715,
-0.07042611390352249,
0.6808595657348633,
0.4087335765361786,
0.11920306086540222,
0.00334480800665915,
-0.2990645468235016,
-0.05209291726350784,
0.4565817713737488,
-0.981186032295227,
-0.5549885034561157,
0.04431569576263428,
-0.40969064831733704,
-0.6396268606185913,
-0.04991583153605461,
-0.6886415481567383,
-0.18067993223667145,
-0.2615565359592438,
0.26054465770721436,
-0.2939554750919342,
0.1360195428133011,
0.07023076713085175,
-0.20211057364940643,
-0.08530241996049881,
0.4128815829753876,
-1.120643138885498,
0.5487541556358337,
0.4675411581993103,
0.6962023377418518,
-0.4296901226043701,
-0.3487860858440399,
-0.3487106263637543,
-0.09573166072368622,
0.20728109776973724,
0.9540782570838928,
-0.519679069519043,
-0.1210363507270813,
0.15394611656665802,
-0.13037651777267456,
0.015466263517737389,
-0.5699892044067383,
0.8017402291297913,
-0.2525981068611145,
0.5740794539451599,
0.2893097698688507,
-0.3911924362182617,
-0.2159697562456131,
0.5931893587112427,
-0.8457448482513428,
0.7957644462585449,
-0.013752598315477371,
-1.328373908996582,
0.6004242300987244,
0.1535886973142624,
-0.5689151287078857,
0.058767903596162796,
-0.21726655960083008,
-0.8355094194412231,
0.029231814667582512,
0.14948128163814545,
0.585112988948822,
-0.34019234776496887,
0.14462415874004364,
-0.3668577969074249,
-0.35239237546920776,
0.20457769930362701,
-0.40584853291511536,
0.7060768604278564,
0.24830280244350433,
-0.0974307507276535,
0.18410341441631317,
-0.7970377206802368,
0.11654480546712875,
-0.10448601096868515,
-0.5956051349639893,
-0.8775473237037659,
-0.07017777860164642,
0.5581972599029541,
0.16125144064426422,
0.04316383972764015,
-0.43408817052841187,
-0.06310006231069565,
-0.565714418888092,
0.197936549782753,
0.5600128173828125,
-0.0939912274479866,
0.6676549911499023,
-0.6209371089935303,
0.2335532158613205,
0.000056695236708037555,
-0.04204905033111572,
-0.20825980603694916,
-0.22602540254592896,
-0.883625864982605,
-0.5835490822792053,
0.6500843167304993,
0.7831238508224487,
-0.7217022776603699,
0.4462122917175293,
-0.09988844394683838,
-0.3366084098815918,
-0.6103713512420654,
0.3536717891693115,
0.6043936610221863,
0.3481523394584656,
0.42959922552108765,
-0.213080495595932,
-0.6437594890594482,
-0.9608823657035828,
-0.264324814081192,
-0.049729958176612854,
-0.20196957886219025,
0.07261577993631363,
0.3515738844871521,
-0.38295549154281616,
0.7850925326347351,
-0.58067786693573,
-0.42399653792381287,
-0.4219115376472473,
0.5720317363739014,
0.08310176432132721,
0.7226566672325134,
0.24638055264949799,
-1.1025495529174805,
-0.28097185492515564,
-0.021412108093500137,
-0.5228066444396973,
-0.23394502699375153,
-0.10997191071510315,
0.0658685564994812,
0.017738979309797287,
0.7494905591011047,
-0.09688110649585724,
0.15835298597812653,
0.4455169439315796,
-0.025178199633955956,
0.25665444135665894,
-0.12901900708675385,
0.03372751921415329,
-1.1627517938613892,
0.06578520685434341,
0.3011726438999176,
-0.14474177360534668,
-0.7648126482963562,
0.06180369853973389,
0.20392891764640808,
-0.0027282238006591797,
-0.5446522235870361,
0.5805443525314331,
-0.12417030334472656,
0.6465431451797485,
-0.48323994874954224,
0.008980792947113514,
0.09232252836227417,
0.5036888718605042,
0.005336647387593985,
0.27627652883529663,
0.0869993045926094,
-0.7734426259994507,
-0.18122991919517517,
0.07123591005802155,
-0.11255889385938644,
0.7768114805221558,
-0.6053349375724792,
-0.17083144187927246,
-0.15241111814975739,
0.029355423524975777,
-1.0321259498596191,
-0.03009420447051525,
0.18521788716316223,
-0.29023081064224243,
0.43966078758239746,
0.06908467411994934,
-0.21773852407932281,
-0.23203250765800476,
-0.44973766803741455,
0.7553789615631104,
0.4688074588775635,
-0.5646036863327026,
0.5525359511375427,
0.3088938593864441,
-0.23021875321865082,
-0.4495207965373993,
-0.6293755173683167,
-0.31176331639289856,
-0.23648938536643982,
-0.31902381777763367,
0.7963801026344299,
0.037031810730695724,
-0.3106061816215515,
-0.0539110004901886,
-0.20576074719429016,
-0.4483046531677246,
0.11506462097167969,
0.2801705300807953,
0.13936051726341248,
0.25332653522491455,
0.32114869356155396,
0.1558723747730255,
-0.178428053855896,
-0.34745070338249207,
-0.10963520407676697,
0.412338525056839,
0.049155332148075104,
-0.0829087644815445,
-0.4046468138694763,
0.3580297827720642,
0.4558494985103607,
-0.007649129256606102,
0.3559347093105316,
0.45802658796310425,
-0.4905334711074829,
-0.5703002214431763,
-0.4421149790287018,
-0.2549750506877899,
-0.4446318745613098,
0.43289631605148315,
-0.25396016240119934,
-0.8751241564750671,
0.525597333908081,
-0.12392640858888626,
0.29069003462791443,
0.50270015001297,
0.38020065426826477,
-0.10900614410638809,
0.7344721555709839,
1.0398319959640503,
-0.007086845580488443,
0.6144973039627075,
0.007825272157788277,
-0.058344516903162,
-0.4397323727607727,
-0.32805126905441284,
-0.9186161756515503,
-0.28328707814216614,
-0.6793006062507629,
-0.28780993819236755,
-0.13419675827026367,
0.011126205325126648,
-0.112015500664711,
0.02592146210372448,
-0.4985593259334564,
0.3908132314682007,
0.7168509364128113,
0.3696533143520355,
0.4008709788322449,
0.22788961231708527,
-0.4301435947418213,
-0.34766221046447754,
-0.6928590536117554,
-0.3402666449546814,
0.9404740333557129,
0.20162485539913177,
1.0173139572143555,
-0.3616885542869568,
0.9282697439193726,
0.40887290239334106,
0.47301965951919556,
-0.745672881603241,
0.2781086564064026,
-0.6542484164237976,
-0.41442111134529114,
-0.041158922016620636,
-0.28726470470428467,
-0.8232322335243225,
0.5282461643218994,
-0.4858001172542572,
-0.09593512117862701,
0.26443129777908325,
0.22948406636714935,
-0.08827302604913712,
0.30010855197906494,
-0.6387320756912231,
0.7624602913856506,
-0.07349760830402374,
-0.3696189820766449,
0.0020599430426955223,
-0.5649558305740356,
0.5314075350761414,
-0.287704199552536,
0.2287629097700119,
0.19422249495983124,
0.17604969441890717,
0.9638140201568604,
-0.4114631116390228,
1.2528263330459595,
0.10569097101688385,
-0.016250308603048325,
0.07716221362352371,
-0.09195676445960999,
0.38128578662872314,
-0.17324122786521912,
-0.03707607090473175,
-0.10466636717319489,
-0.3233022093772888,
-0.4668513536453247,
-0.5024299025535583,
0.5377905964851379,
-0.6621851921081543,
-0.3247549831867218,
-0.5441443920135498,
-0.4099547564983368,
0.027069907635450363,
0.19838370382785797,
0.5163881182670593,
0.1338341236114502,
-0.4787226617336273,
0.19407230615615845,
0.5929137468338013,
0.09962204843759537,
0.3772018253803253,
0.41971442103385925,
0.02188352681696415,
-0.5841085910797119,
0.8540695905685425,
-0.21857935190200806,
0.3557910919189453,
0.5358128547668457,
-0.02882886491715908,
0.04523001238703728,
-0.6750462651252747,
0.01680924743413925,
-0.025912612676620483,
-0.637822151184082,
-0.2256481796503067,
-0.7281377911567688,
-0.16169491410255432,
0.0411592498421669,
-0.5438610315322876,
-0.23877966403961182,
-0.25095078349113464,
-0.5362260937690735,
0.025126738473773003,
-0.11300532519817352,
0.38263195753097534,
0.12707901000976562,
0.5167785882949829,
-0.5623331069946289,
0.32951581478118896,
0.5566723942756653,
0.15235400199890137,
-0.10053941607475281,
-0.5123816132545471,
-0.10830870270729065,
-0.05548926070332527,
-0.3424947261810303,
-0.4922691285610199,
0.46540331840515137,
0.18818047642707825,
0.5873225331306458,
0.41647985577583313,
0.3515473008155823,
0.3861027956008911,
-0.5399559140205383,
0.2293500155210495,
0.5030398964881897,
-0.8528167009353638,
0.44087305665016174,
-0.03684549406170845,
0.4493507742881775,
1.1849807500839233,
0.2704153060913086,
-0.45407161116600037,
-0.7492384314537048,
-0.6056236624717712,
-1.001672387123108,
0.527046263217926,
0.11147084087133408,
0.15983356535434723,
0.04318615421652794,
0.12385838478803635,
0.42228955030441284,
0.16985411942005157,
-0.9455274343490601,
0.03247915208339691,
-0.25076916813850403,
-0.5767709016799927,
-0.14020578563213348,
-0.27005070447921753,
0.03133120387792587,
-0.22249151766300201,
0.45917031168937683,
-0.1260422021150589,
-0.014199086464941502,
0.08046533912420273,
-0.31281551718711853,
0.17825855314731598,
0.4928916096687317,
0.4654829204082489,
0.08391590416431427,
-0.40265706181526184,
0.6723418831825256,
0.3023834824562073,
-0.7290796041488647,
0.18574285507202148,
0.22531655430793762,
-0.3578919470310211,
-0.020086202770471573,
0.4573477804660797,
0.5407895445823669,
0.6286293864250183,
-0.6373440623283386,
0.4638199210166931,
-0.10121811181306839,
-0.5109089016914368,
0.19653472304344177,
0.02103259228169918,
-0.3775816857814789,
0.2734346389770508,
0.4787116050720215,
0.3742881119251251,
0.1648941934108734,
-0.3846305310726166,
0.49736809730529785,
0.34953609108924866,
-0.7205072641372681,
-0.0888822078704834,
0.4514666199684143,
0.4439047574996948,
-0.25106000900268555,
0.6817939281463623,
-0.14965303242206573,
-0.6419803500175476,
0.5158529877662659,
0.7247213125228882,
0.8566919565200806,
-0.20065182447433472,
0.24187834560871124,
0.10898298770189285,
0.4475580155849457,
-0.23808054625988007,
0.017242081463336945,
-0.10381389409303665,
-0.6929000020027161,
-0.21324118971824646,
-0.5661495327949524,
-0.5511917471885681,
-0.023508794605731964,
-0.735220193862915,
0.28811681270599365,
-0.612557053565979,
-0.11772722750902176,
0.043335720896720886,
0.09169667214155197,
-0.6653119325637817,
0.33505675196647644,
-0.0415329746901989,
0.7718297839164734,
-1.2785531282424927,
0.7968564033508301,
0.5964357852935791,
-0.2659691572189331,
-0.22588250041007996,
0.285418301820755,
-0.18692518770694733,
-0.38535889983177185,
0.810763955116272,
0.3859896957874298,
-0.12469597905874252,
-0.1262095421552658,
-0.7005906105041504,
-0.2439827173948288,
0.6257189512252808,
-0.04217856377363205,
-0.6389514803886414,
0.07428736984729767,
-0.2542542517185211,
0.5248939394950867,
-0.41535893082618713,
-0.10448838770389557,
0.07819168269634247,
0.1875452697277069,
0.3566461503505707,
-0.6881466507911682,
0.1246601939201355,
-0.4901936948299408,
-0.13328245282173157,
0.2276163250207901,
-0.31889307498931885,
1.2265751361846924,
-0.16104742884635925,
-0.24170301854610443,
-0.011845169588923454,
0.6943241357803345,
0.40287044644355774,
0.5134091377258301,
0.47907039523124695,
0.6446678042411804,
0.8916844725608826,
0.10672882199287415,
0.8167566657066345,
0.07857883721590042,
0.36724820733070374,
1.2409756183624268,
-0.45305633544921875,
0.9766836762428284,
0.5039072036743164,
0.021752487868070602,
0.42930829524993896,
0.4469257891178131,
-0.14919587969779968,
0.7657548785209656,
0.20249663293361664,
-0.42907482385635376,
-0.4147341251373291,
0.028286004438996315,
-0.1807144731283188,
0.38617584109306335,
0.257425457239151,
-0.4144015610218048,
-0.4791918694972992,
0.3438805043697357,
-0.0417349636554718,
0.29139217734336853,
-0.33079952001571655,
0.5975155234336853,
0.025812283158302307,
-0.424374520778656,
0.5111657381057739,
0.3420669734477997,
1.2307521104812622,
-0.15482807159423828,
-0.04910432547330856,
-0.13098478317260742,
0.5712946057319641,
-0.15626370906829834,
-0.5870832204818726,
0.09109178930521011,
-0.15232621133327484,
-0.6070133447647095,
-0.104673832654953,
0.7097945213317871,
-0.5529218912124634,
-0.6189311146736145,
0.132377490401268,
0.34161844849586487,
-0.2263277769088745,
0.0535704679787159,
-0.5524311065673828,
-0.07046546787023544,
0.12530077993869781,
0.28308266401290894,
0.3475232422351837,
0.4038742482662201,
-0.22816981375217438,
0.625935971736908,
0.4724685549736023,
-0.2457856833934784,
-0.17260387539863586,
-0.06585962325334549,
0.9002026319503784,
-0.7652685642242432,
-0.6619005799293518,
-0.937849760055542,
0.49047160148620605,
-0.15818218886852264,
-0.3773021399974823,
0.7122509479522705,
0.5839884281158447,
0.8811269998550415,
0.006107989698648453,
0.821357011795044,
0.31179335713386536,
0.5948280692100525,
-0.5550053715705872,
0.5541960597038269,
-0.47207772731781006,
0.1099359318614006,
-0.2965366244316101,
-0.7698959708213806,
-0.8744356036186218,
0.6014302968978882,
-0.030025841668248177,
0.09693851321935654,
0.8516077399253845,
0.374784380197525,
-0.32652682065963745,
0.003972951322793961,
0.07089827209711075,
0.007613232359290123,
0.21116933226585388,
0.5315749049186707,
0.5866749286651611,
-0.45323416590690613,
0.6242075562477112,
-0.17535045742988586,
-0.21720021963119507,
-0.5917072892189026,
-0.7839760184288025,
-1.2915416955947876,
-0.610876202583313,
-0.4423478841781616,
-0.15842527151107788,
0.13880030810832977,
0.6887166500091553,
0.6954836845397949,
-0.9074587225914001,
-0.01371346041560173,
-0.11933725327253342,
0.31434115767478943,
-0.07426286488771439,
-0.1662137657403946,
0.25278642773628235,
-0.5518520474433899,
-0.8549794554710388,
-0.07297120988368988,
0.05329761281609535,
0.5290071368217468,
0.10595156997442245,
0.12911997735500336,
-0.3636223077774048,
-0.15712690353393555,
0.4698425829410553,
0.4852460026741028,
-0.3313847482204437,
0.024257279932498932,
-0.1807604283094406,
-0.4704863131046295,
-0.10720579326152802,
0.9541027545928955,
-0.938156247138977,
0.3199172019958496,
0.6523865461349487,
0.6075735688209534,
0.6103506684303284,
0.024234479293227196,
0.5089989900588989,
-0.9205369353294373,
0.4823496341705322,
0.2403065413236618,
0.11640771478414536,
0.25085577368736267,
0.007967785932123661,
0.03534277528524399,
0.14220422506332397,
-0.23261815309524536,
-0.8023956418037415,
0.01069296058267355,
-1.180902361869812,
-0.5650967955589294,
0.7115764021873474,
0.14948239922523499,
-0.15087220072746277,
-0.311233788728714,
-0.3098500072956085,
0.19521106779575348,
-0.23764145374298096,
0.7960516214370728,
0.4511607587337494,
0.31422194838523865,
-0.22281259298324585,
-0.33879852294921875,
0.48425278067588806,
0.48946741223335266,
-0.7651563882827759,
-0.04201687499880791,
0.36815664172172546,
0.16650594770908356,
0.13621897995471954,
0.3735138177871704,
0.0955151692032814,
0.09964250028133392,
-0.09146487712860107,
0.3655162453651428,
0.10992807149887085,
-0.4627969264984131,
-0.4752015769481659,
0.6194912791252136,
0.034259483218193054,
-0.3560551404953003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11519v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11519v1
|
MSNER: A Multilingual Speech Dataset for Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-05-19T11:17:00 | 2024-05-19T11:17:00 |
Quentin Meeus, Marie-Francine Moens, Hugo Van hamme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While extensively explored in text-based tasks, Named Entity Recognition
(NER) remains largely neglected in spoken language understanding. Existing
resources are limited to a single, English-only dataset. This paper addresses
this gap by introducing MSNER, a freely available, multilingual speech corpus
annotated with named entities. It provides annotations to the VoxPopuli dataset
in four languages (Dutch, French, German, and Spanish). We have also releasing
an efficient annotation tool that leverages automatic pre-annotations for
faster manual refinement. This results in 590 and 15 hours of silver-annotated
speech for training and validation, alongside a 17-hour, manually-annotated
evaluation set. We further provide an analysis comparing silver and gold
annotations. Finally, we present baseline NER models to stimulate further
research on this newly available dataset.
|
[
-0.3744919002056122,
-0.2793513834476471,
0.1790272295475006,
0.04880276694893837,
-0.12121526151895523,
0.12929537892341614,
-0.4313880205154419,
-0.5100805759429932,
0.14087733626365662,
0.5198848843574524,
-0.3467986285686493,
-0.32104429602622986,
-0.5927380919456482,
0.6120598316192627,
-0.2287498116493225,
1.1144051551818848,
0.25905922055244446,
0.2426677793264389,
-0.10163932293653488,
-0.14976218342781067,
-0.10049021244049072,
-0.6993445754051208,
-0.7580665946006775,
-0.2253701537847519,
0.8196303844451904,
0.5987367033958435,
0.22920246422290802,
0.42566242814064026,
0.39135441184043884,
0.3073563277721405,
-0.23627418279647827,
0.11456722021102905,
-0.40242382884025574,
0.06496120244264603,
0.08592705428600311,
-0.101292185485363,
-0.13472416996955872,
-0.2559206187725067,
0.8723300099372864,
0.5809063911437988,
-0.2182556837797165,
0.12323793768882751,
-0.0955425500869751,
0.2877231240272522,
-0.5912231206893921,
0.18459630012512207,
-0.7188146710395813,
0.16321656107902527,
-0.4137915372848511,
-0.012601752765476704,
-0.4945414066314697,
0.018661482259631157,
0.3130945861339569,
-0.5379056334495544,
0.3136741816997528,
-0.24062640964984894,
0.9925578832626343,
0.27320775389671326,
-0.41874709725379944,
-0.43580543994903564,
-0.8079808354377747,
0.7131668925285339,
-0.2764695882797241,
0.7863965034484863,
0.18016056716442108,
0.45815789699554443,
0.06280365586280823,
-0.7604924440383911,
-0.5428367257118225,
-0.20172357559204102,
-0.13089774549007416,
0.00793516356498003,
-0.38038551807403564,
-0.2226085215806961,
0.3329460322856903,
-0.04135843738913536,
-0.4223951995372772,
0.07930260896682739,
-0.8473610877990723,
-0.4168463945388794,
0.5319987535476685,
-0.29740822315216064,
0.14728088676929474,
-0.5676941871643066,
-0.4650786519050598,
0.11912237852811813,
-0.4812679588794708,
-0.05487588420510292,
0.3947943150997162,
0.9119643568992615,
-0.14534136652946472,
0.597406268119812,
0.20448200404644012,
0.6947332620620728,
-0.2045319825410843,
-0.2275383472442627,
0.7219935655593872,
-0.032521676272153854,
-0.1699565351009369,
0.5383523106575012,
0.8052091002464294,
0.03214961662888527,
0.5311260223388672,
-0.3037691116333008,
0.03312176838517189,
-0.15666566789150238,
-0.04475945234298706,
-0.9481186270713806,
-0.4908677041530609,
0.1337709128856659,
-0.08887478709220886,
0.041495323181152344,
0.18039140105247498,
-0.6131678819656372,
-0.4268827736377716,
-0.534723162651062,
-0.08931012451648712,
-0.4752888083457947,
-0.6591094732284546,
-0.1787680834531784,
-0.22203002870082855,
-0.07211778312921524,
0.16208748519420624,
-0.4428230822086334,
0.08042839169502258,
0.5994549989700317,
0.812932550907135,
-0.06293293088674545,
-0.36651256680488586,
-0.7629384994506836,
0.25974971055984497,
-0.21882317960262299,
1.051819920539856,
-0.8082588315010071,
-0.44219592213630676,
-0.31740280985832214,
0.1655307561159134,
-0.21252308785915375,
-0.3534255623817444,
0.37856626510620117,
-0.2527049779891968,
0.2685800790786743,
-0.1103922426700592,
-0.539868950843811,
-0.32883915305137634,
0.07223907858133316,
-0.7167155742645264,
0.9173744320869446,
-0.07137306034564972,
-0.896079421043396,
0.551784336566925,
-0.875673770904541,
-0.3662811815738678,
0.4021899998188019,
-0.4347356855869293,
-0.12202854454517365,
-0.009816537611186504,
0.22845956683158875,
0.45105570554733276,
0.1891077607870102,
0.21805065870285034,
0.1614970862865448,
-0.06792699545621872,
0.1628490388393402,
-0.27244335412979126,
0.7122399806976318,
0.29766109585762024,
-0.02037147805094719,
0.09822896867990494,
-1.0872459411621094,
0.025366446003317833,
0.05176946893334389,
-0.32699623703956604,
-0.43567222356796265,
-0.016439683735370636,
0.5185146331787109,
0.23485927283763885,
-0.05597605183720589,
-0.605466902256012,
-0.050759024918079376,
-0.2604855000972748,
0.5954052805900574,
0.5239949226379395,
-0.004178258124738932,
0.29124799370765686,
0.42481714487075806,
0.516866147518158,
0.28616848587989807,
-0.3149670660495758,
-0.2816222310066223,
-0.2828235626220703,
-0.8476747274398804,
-0.5146476626396179,
0.86403888463974,
0.7024363279342651,
-0.737907886505127,
-0.05047237128019333,
-0.5851900577545166,
-0.5588802099227905,
-0.8093887567520142,
0.001969616860151291,
0.3901262879371643,
0.5074669122695923,
0.4492608904838562,
0.19527877867221832,
-0.9270185828208923,
-1.317590594291687,
-0.056467581540346146,
0.10030081123113632,
-0.08858560025691986,
0.5020718574523926,
0.6105560660362244,
-0.3227393329143524,
0.7505254149436951,
-0.018524397164583206,
-0.4594513773918152,
-0.223542258143425,
0.2820078432559967,
0.15799100697040558,
0.33069121837615967,
0.343805730342865,
-1.0344452857971191,
-0.5316450595855713,
0.21568112075328827,
-0.560588538646698,
0.19096830487251282,
-0.010866961441934109,
0.2641933262348175,
0.10608580708503723,
0.6686304807662964,
-0.21016283333301544,
0.03341887146234512,
0.7840746641159058,
-0.08515383303165436,
0.2588323652744293,
-0.028340373188257217,
0.10317078232765198,
-1.2681835889816284,
-0.008675985969603062,
0.008600612170994282,
-0.36300352215766907,
-0.8064401745796204,
-0.5469471216201782,
0.2126341164112091,
-0.3474244475364685,
-0.6913299560546875,
0.5394220352172852,
-0.9082956314086914,
0.009354331530630589,
-0.12416870146989822,
0.44435808062553406,
-0.3322821259498596,
0.055818695574998856,
0.31233423948287964,
1.0979681015014648,
0.6805596947669983,
-0.7625445127487183,
0.041124507784843445,
0.32952001690864563,
-0.2495489865541458,
0.8250037431716919,
-0.6955260634422302,
0.33542197942733765,
-0.5180661082267761,
-0.1401112675666809,
-0.4189921021461487,
-0.14329075813293457,
0.2643534243106842,
-0.5886015892028809,
0.37664467096328735,
-0.7186346054077148,
-0.38528427481651306,
-0.15513888001441956,
0.4634448289871216,
-0.017035676166415215,
-0.11129152029752731,
-0.35850459337234497,
0.9269018173217773,
0.7976742386817932,
-0.4051913917064667,
-0.7364027500152588,
-0.7723814249038696,
0.4677368998527527,
-0.15423904359340668,
-0.2308809757232666,
0.23377740383148193,
0.09114374965429306,
-0.14646203815937042,
0.013925696723163128,
0.08150932937860489,
-0.16745850443840027,
-0.2701151371002197,
0.4362121820449829,
0.047829773277044296,
-0.18522639572620392,
0.5379623770713806,
-0.29189127683639526,
-0.6489963531494141,
-0.4320140480995178,
0.030883485451340675,
0.4176064729690552,
-0.36417511105537415,
-0.012031612917780876,
-0.3784977197647095,
0.4995816946029663,
0.21045351028442383,
-0.5782915949821472,
0.5645958781242371,
0.7243102192878723,
-0.6860774159431458,
0.045245494693517685,
-0.5205857753753662,
0.10892751812934875,
-0.3583827614784241,
0.43150630593299866,
-0.9195398688316345,
-0.9914311766624451,
0.30835771560668945,
0.20189931988716125,
0.19142574071884155,
0.5529636144638062,
0.26865389943122864,
-0.044159114360809326,
0.8122084140777588,
0.5987926125526428,
-0.03060479275882244,
0.39171838760375977,
-0.13127349317073822,
0.2424289584159851,
-0.6740813851356506,
-0.1919710636138916,
-0.7433345317840576,
-0.20863278210163116,
-0.6388670206069946,
-0.38910579681396484,
0.027717040851712227,
-0.11897429823875427,
-0.024197975173592567,
0.6743635535240173,
-0.5976313352584839,
0.6011008620262146,
0.38312068581581116,
-0.5144952535629272,
0.09144243597984314,
0.0567411333322525,
-0.07210810482501984,
-0.37996160984039307,
-0.5483093857765198,
-0.8275725245475769,
0.6539203524589539,
0.2594996392726898,
0.14566120505332947,
0.013254806399345398,
0.7095394134521484,
0.12405915558338165,
0.38184210658073425,
-0.6549450755119324,
0.4049726128578186,
-0.07158556580543518,
-0.7679787874221802,
-0.184141144156456,
-0.7107888460159302,
-1.0727075338363647,
0.44293028116226196,
-0.3347492516040802,
-0.8863966464996338,
0.19514024257659912,
0.08511140942573547,
-0.3333190381526947,
0.266605406999588,
-0.8430657982826233,
0.7751584053039551,
-0.32198500633239746,
0.1929469257593155,
0.15890882909297943,
-0.34718307852745056,
-0.07782057672739029,
0.10252267867326736,
0.475235253572464,
-0.3850118815898895,
-0.06927523761987686,
0.9807279706001282,
0.054543014615774155,
0.40309199690818787,
-0.4294787347316742,
0.18697746098041534,
0.11295910179615021,
-0.11042315512895584,
0.3408775329589844,
0.1209811195731163,
-0.12860916554927826,
0.6103593111038208,
0.13781626522541046,
-0.17506475746631622,
-0.0689694806933403,
0.7103606462478638,
-0.4274854063987732,
-0.03513650223612785,
-0.8137573599815369,
-0.33632078766822815,
-0.049726054072380066,
0.5669991970062256,
0.24631112813949585,
0.23087778687477112,
-0.20731155574321747,
0.40253308415412903,
0.3692055940628052,
0.04829100891947746,
0.38103222846984863,
0.6282106041908264,
-0.26360780000686646,
-0.6966768503189087,
0.8837648034095764,
0.5386109948158264,
-0.37169694900512695,
0.25559157133102417,
-0.10231722891330719,
-0.16566872596740723,
-0.4766673743724823,
-0.6208214163780212,
0.35260048508644104,
-0.6161584854125977,
-0.15482744574546814,
-1.1599230766296387,
-0.30099666118621826,
-0.2588096559047699,
0.13382090628147125,
-0.6043996810913086,
-0.3662054240703583,
-0.41285440325737,
-0.49726951122283936,
0.4187004864215851,
0.7159556150436401,
-0.13699252903461456,
0.2466098964214325,
-0.7260557413101196,
0.35888946056365967,
0.038260120898485184,
0.24278026819229126,
-0.4012250006198883,
-0.21907401084899902,
-0.09297731518745422,
0.11654185503721237,
0.2140907645225525,
-1.0511575937271118,
0.1332678496837616,
0.6047725677490234,
0.6203780174255371,
0.5358964800834656,
-0.1972394436597824,
0.9674340486526489,
-0.8805492520332336,
0.5213249921798706,
0.24833783507347107,
-0.7466990947723389,
0.6328514814376831,
-0.11330781877040863,
-0.019480880349874496,
0.7129241228103638,
0.5674698352813721,
-0.9214630126953125,
-0.053014934062957764,
-0.6797780990600586,
-0.9322619438171387,
0.5320252776145935,
0.20740501582622528,
0.294185072183609,
-0.2729824185371399,
-0.045866768807172775,
0.2828149199485779,
0.326510488986969,
-0.7138320207595825,
-0.41224077343940735,
-0.014685009606182575,
0.04364987090229988,
-0.5152028799057007,
-0.36917704343795776,
-0.0052077979780733585,
-0.15670093894004822,
0.8481600880622864,
0.06175040081143379,
0.186752587556839,
0.17941737174987793,
-0.48858410120010376,
0.1536446064710617,
0.5670506954193115,
0.536217451095581,
0.6634879112243652,
-0.03173370659351349,
0.12868955731391907,
0.28906917572021484,
-0.3548985421657562,
-0.08772510290145874,
0.6326025128364563,
-0.332988977432251,
0.5960750579833984,
0.11144709587097168,
0.93610680103302,
0.45929667353630066,
-0.6569371223449707,
0.2708202004432678,
-0.1840471476316452,
-0.18404030799865723,
-0.8926023244857788,
-0.14562904834747314,
0.4007929265499115,
0.20389294624328613,
0.40074825286865234,
0.08205253630876541,
0.1355815976858139,
-0.013984776102006435,
0.2892926335334778,
0.22809502482414246,
-0.8087189793586731,
-0.14662179350852966,
0.4202028214931488,
0.10639648884534836,
-0.6354963779449463,
0.7713265419006348,
-0.44131678342819214,
-0.3893895447254181,
0.22486692667007446,
0.3230407238006592,
0.5441441535949707,
-0.3841332197189331,
0.2532467544078827,
0.6790088415145874,
0.3143378794193268,
0.20342782139778137,
0.5385602116584778,
0.04455704241991043,
-0.6394230127334595,
-0.22339077293872833,
-0.5270753502845764,
-0.3154112696647644,
0.12615244090557098,
-0.6783955097198486,
0.41466549038887024,
-0.11357231438159943,
-0.40126708149909973,
0.6191421747207642,
-0.2915622591972351,
-0.9482380747795105,
0.10028150677680969,
0.45660772919654846,
0.7288728952407837,
-0.6482694745063782,
0.447841614484787,
0.9090997576713562,
-0.5380456447601318,
-0.4919304847717285,
-0.5521867871284485,
0.10797740519046783,
-0.39138948917388916,
0.568364679813385,
0.4942265450954437,
-0.09563691914081573,
0.2524881958961487,
-0.20091785490512848,
-1.011218786239624,
0.7508602142333984,
0.3331194519996643,
-0.8013721704483032,
-0.05408944934606552,
-0.11763177067041397,
0.42757338285446167,
-0.5010153651237488,
0.3875427544116974,
0.38553473353385925,
0.6238277554512024,
-0.19576099514961243,
-0.9215291142463684,
-0.7169197201728821,
-0.48418477177619934,
-0.015314183197915554,
0.37124359607696533,
-0.25025397539138794,
0.6855411529541016,
-0.47301363945007324,
-0.6027597188949585,
-0.3907797336578369,
0.9133702516555786,
0.10531803220510483,
0.2174532115459442,
0.6297703981399536,
0.5095235109329224,
1.227770209312439,
-0.2706362307071686,
0.7188155651092529,
-0.17903932929039001,
0.2418612688779831,
1.509437918663025,
-0.3109019994735718,
1.158366322517395,
0.6104995608329773,
-0.13382385671138763,
0.5617098212242126,
0.5983412265777588,
-0.32264843583106995,
0.3039616644382477,
0.3014194071292877,
-0.11610046774148941,
-0.20312784612178802,
-0.3954049050807953,
-0.43273496627807617,
0.7322395443916321,
0.3536657392978668,
-0.31503766775131226,
-0.19777725636959076,
0.4591035842895508,
0.3034289479255676,
-0.110075943171978,
-0.2487611025571823,
0.9746708869934082,
0.041447918862104416,
-0.09823091328144073,
0.2690490484237671,
-0.24300932884216309,
0.678188145160675,
-0.49761030077934265,
0.024893933907151222,
0.42391058802604675,
0.08730853348970413,
-0.3068619668483734,
-0.47059062123298645,
0.031215978786349297,
0.42765533924102783,
-0.31368252635002136,
-0.13042373955249786,
0.5485873222351074,
-0.5841070413589478,
-0.9998076558113098,
0.47800302505493164,
0.6562883257865906,
0.6262078881263733,
-0.09855575859546661,
-0.6856585144996643,
-0.16995304822921753,
-0.10790785402059555,
-0.2693341374397278,
-0.17126519978046417,
0.34115564823150635,
0.2152828574180603,
0.7763040661811829,
0.7075672149658203,
0.37540820240974426,
0.18076172471046448,
0.4443596303462982,
0.522989809513092,
-0.6500771045684814,
-0.5467802286148071,
-0.5631433129310608,
0.8231346011161804,
-0.3067551255226135,
-0.3209034502506256,
0.7372968792915344,
0.9335532188415527,
1.1088392734527588,
-0.030587023124098778,
1.0470553636550903,
-0.14197176694869995,
1.0901888608932495,
-0.2717489004135132,
0.754156231880188,
-0.4987317621707916,
-0.1470380574464798,
-0.19015765190124512,
-0.8514885902404785,
-0.2446926385164261,
0.8061813116073608,
-0.32786792516708374,
0.12840667366981506,
0.42243483662605286,
0.6915783882141113,
-0.23034831881523132,
-0.0718851163983345,
0.29502660036087036,
0.08448749780654907,
0.24160626530647278,
0.23779988288879395,
0.7243204116821289,
-0.4545952379703522,
0.7401448488235474,
-0.35877665877342224,
0.20558679103851318,
-0.13568176329135895,
-1.0734949111938477,
-0.9273980855941772,
-0.7932391166687012,
-0.4980742633342743,
-0.12543785572052002,
0.12117134779691696,
1.2226614952087402,
0.9089273810386658,
-1.1642390489578247,
-0.06129330396652222,
0.3052383065223694,
-0.1542941778898239,
-0.17272745072841644,
-0.19473661482334137,
0.27331146597862244,
-0.09168598055839539,
-0.8896263241767883,
0.6384998559951782,
0.20100171864032745,
0.11690935492515564,
0.08868010342121124,
-0.079520083963871,
-0.2919773757457733,
-0.290417343378067,
0.38990217447280884,
0.3308548629283905,
-0.7160029411315918,
-0.2901228666305542,
-0.09470299631357193,
-0.023240096867084503,
0.30367720127105713,
0.6812909245491028,
-0.5503352284431458,
0.7431157231330872,
0.10653255879878998,
0.5268914699554443,
0.4089490473270416,
-0.16598455607891083,
0.22258234024047852,
-0.7132748961448669,
0.2793917953968048,
0.4998131990432739,
0.6081307530403137,
0.802399218082428,
-0.14824946224689484,
0.43623900413513184,
-0.10930633544921875,
-0.33088043332099915,
-1.0085594654083252,
0.1386493593454361,
-0.7546815872192383,
0.07823515683412552,
1.1181275844573975,
0.011614935472607613,
-0.00597425177693367,
-0.33149051666259766,
-0.3096548020839691,
0.25356730818748474,
-0.6390771865844727,
0.21869370341300964,
0.7983577847480774,
-0.006271255202591419,
-0.7268216609954834,
-0.9027059674263,
0.48429927229881287,
-0.2500324547290802,
-0.618113100528717,
0.04846010357141495,
0.5703366994857788,
0.3039933443069458,
0.4539526104927063,
0.6602937579154968,
-0.0005145027535036206,
0.06150776520371437,
0.07130473852157593,
0.3919315040111542,
-0.5105993151664734,
-0.7170038819313049,
-0.3097155690193176,
0.197417214512825,
-0.16554738581180573,
-0.1931956261396408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13049v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13049v2
|
SemEval-2024 Task 3: Multimodal Emotion Cause Analysis in Conversations
| 2024-05-19T09:59:00 | 2024-06-11T03:12:01 |
Fanfan Wang, Heqing Ma, Jianfei Yu, Rui Xia, Erik Cambria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM
|
The ability to understand emotions is an essential component of human-like
artificial intelligence, as emotions greatly influence human cognition,
decision making, and social interactions. In addition to emotion recognition in
conversations, the task of identifying the potential causes behind an
individual's emotional state in conversations, is of great importance in many
application scenarios. We organize SemEval-2024 Task 3, named Multimodal
Emotion Cause Analysis in Conversations, which aims at extracting all pairs of
emotions and their corresponding causes from conversations. Under different
modality settings, it consists of two subtasks: Textual Emotion-Cause Pair
Extraction in Conversations (TECPE) and Multimodal Emotion-Cause Pair
Extraction in Conversations (MECPE). The shared task has attracted 143
registrations and 216 successful submissions. In this paper, we introduce the
task, dataset and evaluation settings, summarize the systems of the top teams,
and discuss the findings of the participants.
|
[
-0.6137295365333557,
-0.6872771382331848,
0.5521366000175476,
0.47030404210090637,
-0.19116201996803284,
-0.11024709790945053,
0.04058511182665825,
-0.5480778813362122,
0.4384267330169678,
0.2492663413286209,
-0.9254924654960632,
-0.15855413675308228,
-0.6758372783660889,
0.18058468401432037,
-0.13042296469211578,
0.8689841032028198,
-0.23387761414051056,
-0.01016402617096901,
-0.16614790260791779,
-0.3888706862926483,
-0.7644420266151428,
-0.5833470821380615,
-0.6313239932060242,
0.03582217916846275,
0.6952880620956421,
0.7674688100814819,
-0.09537442028522491,
-0.3585142195224762,
0.36000752449035645,
0.3743669390678406,
0.3724534809589386,
0.1056416854262352,
-0.535271942615509,
0.35473740100860596,
-0.07695481181144714,
-0.17147457599639893,
-0.6830549836158752,
-0.0047901831567287445,
0.183705672621727,
0.08424809575080872,
-0.09316524118185043,
-0.048100363463163376,
0.2715318500995636,
0.6721984148025513,
-0.6727766394615173,
0.23872166872024536,
-0.353017121553421,
0.21391750872135162,
-0.4241732060909271,
-0.6626360416412354,
-0.06041092053055763,
0.040246278047561646,
0.21469329297542572,
-0.3349628150463104,
0.11118551343679428,
0.054769936949014664,
0.5677546262741089,
0.07664310932159424,
-0.9698277115821838,
-0.5168618559837341,
-0.36574262380599976,
0.7706303000450134,
-0.4512266218662262,
0.35149016976356506,
0.14812274277210236,
-0.07559323310852051,
-0.005843300372362137,
-0.4303400218486786,
-0.661224365234375,
0.4036499559879303,
0.04931597784161568,
0.5638713240623474,
-0.4062890112400055,
0.14137516915798187,
0.10194896906614304,
0.1747817099094391,
-0.5537350177764893,
-0.13461941480636597,
-0.5239043831825256,
-0.2972570061683655,
0.5460513234138489,
0.4118821620941162,
0.5978570580482483,
-0.27316907048225403,
-0.39032694697380066,
0.06668297946453094,
-0.4062771201133728,
-0.0352332778275013,
0.2531996965408325,
-0.17230919003486633,
-0.22971013188362122,
0.38671550154685974,
-0.20024599134922028,
0.284799724817276,
-0.2925165891647339,
0.14702603220939636,
0.49133384227752686,
-0.899832546710968,
-0.08305042237043381,
0.030315307900309563,
0.9101002812385559,
0.5439203381538391,
0.07500188052654266,
0.22261734306812286,
0.07993408292531967,
-0.010026642121374607,
0.23889409005641937,
-0.6871288418769836,
0.08406292647123337,
0.49427610635757446,
-0.5547008514404297,
-0.3234122097492218,
-0.22811409831047058,
-1.3396750688552856,
-0.5152808427810669,
-0.397593230009079,
0.5655874013900757,
-0.2588754892349243,
-0.6181832551956177,
-0.08572950959205627,
-0.15147142112255096,
0.16414420306682587,
0.4739517569541931,
-0.7546870708465576,
0.29491472244262695,
0.5096622109413147,
0.5637277364730835,
-0.21016384661197662,
-0.4539601802825928,
-0.448845773935318,
-0.2862381935119629,
0.017128929495811462,
0.8981651663780212,
-0.43534111976623535,
-0.3331272304058075,
-0.23543047904968262,
0.21788500249385834,
-0.38813120126724243,
-0.1625756323337555,
0.8491644859313965,
-0.09023328125476837,
0.4507518708705902,
-0.5787448883056641,
-0.1948377788066864,
-0.3212321996688843,
0.47122424840927124,
-0.5378810167312622,
0.8075374960899353,
-0.2654198706150055,
-0.6093745231628418,
0.019507743418216705,
-1.0175341367721558,
-0.31685179471969604,
0.03348471224308014,
-0.13349373638629913,
-0.11952502280473709,
0.2525448799133301,
0.14103420078754425,
0.6533780097961426,
-0.691240668296814,
0.4191899597644806,
-0.1327146738767624,
-0.026960084214806557,
0.13998623192310333,
-0.4291588366031647,
0.5337409973144531,
0.3543365001678467,
-0.6066054105758667,
0.35255351662635803,
-0.45383891463279724,
-0.2935355007648468,
0.06790270656347275,
0.06633208692073822,
-0.3078285753726959,
0.13318663835525513,
0.00529097393155098,
0.49770253896713257,
0.11006645113229752,
-0.6391158699989319,
-0.24643053114414215,
-0.016404764726758003,
0.37385275959968567,
0.8837767839431763,
0.6269967555999756,
0.24138307571411133,
-0.06266243010759354,
0.6271951794624329,
0.4334537088871002,
0.2803479731082916,
-0.35752779245376587,
-0.4916461110115051,
-0.6599403619766235,
-0.09012768417596817,
-0.105803944170475,
0.48040834069252014,
-0.7835336923599243,
-0.26383116841316223,
0.12447525560855865,
-0.48992857336997986,
-0.18111145496368408,
-0.05136576667428017,
0.37062549591064453,
0.507393479347229,
0.10573256760835648,
-0.07784797251224518,
-0.6326161623001099,
-0.876044750213623,
-0.2726183831691742,
0.037622369825839996,
0.30009889602661133,
0.5571221113204956,
0.5718255639076233,
-0.3224480450153351,
0.4641057252883911,
-0.2280803918838501,
-0.11296539753675461,
-0.15445254743099213,
0.5491963624954224,
-0.24103030562400818,
0.46528586745262146,
0.6003099679946899,
-0.7811330556869507,
-0.22163130342960358,
-0.3050514757633209,
-0.8183061480522156,
-0.5675838589668274,
-0.13344241678714752,
-0.3023925721645355,
0.3797616958618164,
0.43981659412384033,
-0.08688650280237198,
0.33271536231040955,
0.92235267162323,
-0.5075345635414124,
0.32417455315589905,
0.14110352098941803,
0.9750285148620605,
-1.2628425359725952,
-0.2458939552307129,
0.23178179562091827,
0.21095140278339386,
-0.7042182087898254,
-0.5463772416114807,
-0.08133266866207123,
-0.4406915605068207,
-0.5276197195053101,
0.4796117842197418,
-0.33918341994285583,
0.013403387740254402,
0.2202465981245041,
0.2925412654876709,
0.16868770122528076,
0.7505125999450684,
-0.13639011979103088,
0.48479193449020386,
0.44340282678604126,
-0.3622659146785736,
0.6303752064704895,
0.1588105410337448,
-0.08440683782100677,
0.762738823890686,
-0.5617085099220276,
0.1915184110403061,
0.05971245840191841,
-0.12517927587032318,
-1.2098350524902344,
-0.4009949862957001,
0.44513076543807983,
-0.3628152310848236,
0.006689518690109253,
0.49229663610458374,
-0.29653650522232056,
-0.22685927152633667,
-0.33920183777809143,
0.5826611518859863,
-0.062108490616083145,
-0.3702661097049713,
0.8554871678352356,
0.6828339099884033,
-0.5920140147209167,
-0.23480066657066345,
-0.26591527462005615,
0.22465753555297852,
-0.32813015580177307,
-0.8669922351837158,
0.15247881412506104,
-0.22061854600906372,
-0.2629816234111786,
-0.20095399022102356,
0.07048898935317993,
-0.11998533457517624,
0.13772770762443542,
0.4617835581302643,
-0.0013240386033430696,
-0.011071915738284588,
0.305866539478302,
0.02984895557165146,
-0.2453007698059082,
0.25023624300956726,
0.48332497477531433,
0.5380926728248596,
-0.5529259443283081,
-0.42768076062202454,
-0.3800671100616455,
0.7602049708366394,
0.7957322001457214,
-0.4004928469657898,
0.40451353788375854,
0.6788062453269958,
-0.3773713707923889,
0.2339835911989212,
-0.7431345582008362,
-0.20241649448871613,
-0.38485464453697205,
0.5470348000526428,
-0.352325975894928,
-1.0170127153396606,
0.4826456904411316,
-0.23120521008968353,
-0.2267821580171585,
0.5151069760322571,
0.7962155342102051,
-0.3091661334037781,
1.0757017135620117,
0.295036256313324,
-0.00983516313135624,
0.4822017550468445,
0.2676169276237488,
0.27418121695518494,
-0.6376084685325623,
-0.6436180472373962,
-0.5290547013282776,
-0.35444676876068115,
-0.39522382616996765,
-0.3063417077064514,
0.6866489052772522,
-0.3659118413925171,
0.18592140078544617,
0.13412423431873322,
-0.22321127355098724,
0.12820538878440857,
0.47287410497665405,
-0.03580520674586296,
-0.04676203802227974,
-0.1319926530122757,
0.17823240160942078,
-0.2735413908958435,
-0.45527586340904236,
-0.20783406496047974,
0.556106686592102,
0.32784461975097656,
0.26118946075439453,
0.2790799140930176,
0.7074921727180481,
0.3563670516014099,
-0.11094909906387329,
-0.7826941609382629,
0.7244970798492432,
0.28416919708251953,
-0.6336498260498047,
-0.056824564933776855,
-0.3241365849971771,
-0.8933602571487427,
0.22095829248428345,
-0.36553317308425903,
-0.9258377552032471,
0.32892856001853943,
-0.1137390211224556,
0.000446146703325212,
-0.2491184026002884,
-0.847112774848938,
1.2316924333572388,
-0.4825729429721832,
-0.28245434165000916,
-0.5196264982223511,
-0.6621795296669006,
0.6430497169494629,
-0.32874414324760437,
0.3110584020614624,
-0.33350226283073425,
0.3306768834590912,
1.108044981956482,
-0.3031380772590637,
0.803477942943573,
-0.2916688621044159,
0.11796558648347855,
0.491476833820343,
0.007672078441828489,
0.3427150845527649,
-0.08295095711946487,
0.0061722067184746265,
0.22386513650417328,
0.21130768954753876,
-0.16046495735645294,
-0.5039153695106506,
0.6024215817451477,
-0.6049063205718994,
-0.24306495487689972,
-0.4916329085826874,
-0.3761587142944336,
-0.1669396311044693,
-0.07765145599842072,
0.24412019550800323,
0.8247402906417847,
-0.24165427684783936,
0.38629889488220215,
0.4466237723827362,
-0.4209992587566376,
0.6856561899185181,
0.4545024037361145,
0.2391301989555359,
-0.46204009652137756,
1.0711023807525635,
-0.06977009773254395,
-0.06531670689582825,
0.02394186705350876,
0.2868739664554596,
-0.10644467175006866,
-0.04997146874666214,
-0.056289397180080414,
0.004220420494675636,
-0.5252162218093872,
-0.22086606919765472,
-0.7972290515899658,
0.23383991420269012,
-0.35411614179611206,
-0.010045441798865795,
-0.32034575939178467,
-0.29035910964012146,
-0.3774113357067108,
0.08449551463127136,
0.17403452098369598,
0.5985823273658752,
-0.16814176738262177,
0.10285763442516327,
-1.1605231761932373,
0.14879292249679565,
0.43662548065185547,
-0.10992112755775452,
-0.22929514944553375,
0.10800648480653763,
-0.019564751535654068,
-0.016800597310066223,
-0.6177880764007568,
-1.2321068048477173,
0.48924317955970764,
0.20180457830429077,
0.4895840585231781,
0.37583449482917786,
0.06600097566843033,
0.8049285411834717,
-0.0907362774014473,
0.9637709259986877,
0.43273910880088806,
-1.2097889184951782,
0.6715779304504395,
-0.5089702010154724,
-0.0304670799523592,
0.33505693078041077,
0.2688174247741699,
-0.8404542207717896,
-0.04110308364033699,
-0.6926860809326172,
-0.6777273416519165,
0.9042202234268188,
0.45774778723716736,
-0.05003690347075462,
-0.2021939903497696,
0.02917502075433731,
-0.2059384137392044,
0.08760609477758408,
-0.4827715754508972,
0.06984084844589233,
-0.09496115148067474,
-0.3401927351951599,
0.14344997704029083,
-0.7869745492935181,
-0.10097092390060425,
0.06599625945091248,
0.7317320704460144,
-0.06657292693853378,
0.6495065093040466,
0.052347347140312195,
0.004529847297817469,
-0.27207323908805847,
0.5853140354156494,
0.9152752757072449,
0.3105762004852295,
-0.06362096965312958,
0.06647792458534241,
0.4364889860153198,
-0.05330036208033562,
-0.10987753421068192,
-0.010894027538597584,
0.7068041563034058,
-0.30406731367111206,
0.4558667838573456,
0.784178614616394,
0.3937032222747803,
-0.6486009955406189,
0.9141860008239746,
-0.30613476037979126,
-0.271216481924057,
-0.151335671544075,
-0.19845040142536163,
0.004441071301698685,
0.5620004534721375,
0.16296470165252686,
0.15271912515163422,
0.6636701822280884,
-0.6729463934898376,
0.1664716750383377,
0.17367099225521088,
-0.5706855654716492,
-0.6706776022911072,
0.35885488986968994,
0.6448703408241272,
0.0019931939896196127,
0.4234751760959625,
-0.1789054572582245,
-0.9498236179351807,
0.7269575595855713,
0.4017411768436432,
0.866895854473114,
-0.3675645887851715,
0.1261492669582367,
0.3837543725967407,
0.041981831192970276,
0.30137598514556885,
0.667170524597168,
-0.13005830347537994,
-0.9098596572875977,
-0.33582013845443726,
-0.2782238721847534,
-0.5297673940658569,
-0.05672641843557358,
-0.6317195296287537,
0.3672308027744293,
0.1404309868812561,
0.0530598945915699,
-0.26119711995124817,
-0.11899104714393616,
-0.6575618386268616,
0.13080039620399475,
0.331785649061203,
0.3429989814758301,
-1.1388579607009888,
0.3424800634384155,
0.6041004061698914,
-0.26797938346862793,
-0.7741810083389282,
-0.3613821864128113,
0.6425594091415405,
-0.6168107986450195,
0.7639809846878052,
0.10755152255296707,
-0.18815243244171143,
-0.1205458715558052,
-0.4974309206008911,
-0.4257654845714569,
1.06043541431427,
0.013143990188837051,
-0.367715984582901,
0.23856517672538757,
-0.1429479867219925,
0.3672098219394684,
-0.3620871603488922,
0.44755470752716064,
0.37610238790512085,
0.4340447783470154,
0.3138014078140259,
-0.8648279309272766,
-0.08256201446056366,
-0.6656164526939392,
-0.3327867388725281,
0.40619558095932007,
-0.7943382263183594,
0.6387327909469604,
0.23636499047279358,
-0.052104294300079346,
-0.47815123200416565,
0.2673379182815552,
0.2274101972579956,
0.6772565841674805,
0.546352207660675,
0.22936734557151794,
0.6223055124282837,
-0.2594386041164398,
0.7607514262199402,
-0.24758893251419067,
0.30950042605400085,
1.0461554527282715,
-0.3779295086860657,
0.5015976428985596,
0.5155711770057678,
0.10954716801643372,
0.27441883087158203,
0.6301594972610474,
0.37908247113227844,
0.316672146320343,
-0.38229987025260925,
-0.3903951644897461,
-0.27445366978645325,
-0.31814977526664734,
-0.26220518350601196,
0.8914697170257568,
0.640900731086731,
-0.1976577490568161,
-0.08493559807538986,
0.36003750562667847,
0.140094593167305,
-0.570182204246521,
-0.12323113530874252,
0.8420073390007019,
-0.044903792440891266,
-0.6384785175323486,
-0.018176523968577385,
-0.2857258915901184,
0.3072402775287628,
-0.40382739901542664,
-0.1480945497751236,
-0.17642255127429962,
0.07256925851106644,
-0.34074047207832336,
-0.6366233825683594,
0.4912688136100769,
-0.10695745795965195,
0.04463927820324898,
-0.4560815095901489,
0.9789118766784668,
-0.3086920976638794,
-0.1030600294470787,
0.28776735067367554,
0.642662525177002,
0.2787540555000305,
-0.410124272108078,
-0.7155169248580933,
0.37992507219314575,
0.03809081017971039,
-0.513085663318634,
0.22569680213928223,
0.946097731590271,
-0.17286764085292816,
0.1438673883676529,
0.350025475025177,
-0.485679566860199,
-0.08633609861135483,
0.13710837066173553,
0.8377143144607544,
-0.7109301686286926,
-0.14362294971942902,
-0.9376829862594604,
0.7883639931678772,
-0.18349191546440125,
-0.4146200120449066,
0.590270459651947,
0.25150877237319946,
0.07133438438177109,
-0.0005492795608006418,
0.5969171524047852,
-0.4149816334247589,
0.3142058253288269,
-0.358722448348999,
0.32777631282806396,
-0.9129775166511536,
0.04862837493419647,
-0.7732363939285278,
-0.8890911936759949,
-0.07404845207929611,
0.34802377223968506,
-0.2552103102207184,
-0.28963321447372437,
0.9219412207603455,
0.739748477935791,
0.29441991448402405,
0.6137734651565552,
0.3596697151660919,
0.14380227029323578,
0.46955639123916626,
0.8695458173751831,
1.1093811988830566,
-0.4716242849826813,
0.5347615480422974,
-0.19468164443969727,
-0.3618879020214081,
-0.2873087525367737,
-1.0309842824935913,
-0.7036604881286621,
-1.169137716293335,
-0.4340873956680298,
-0.12443047761917114,
-0.23665666580200195,
1.0098758935928345,
0.43071115016937256,
-0.761384129524231,
0.07519026100635529,
-0.1389068365097046,
0.009855644777417183,
0.2393464744091034,
-0.26094385981559753,
-0.05128868669271469,
-0.2937071621417999,
-0.6899597644805908,
0.4713042676448822,
0.6310794949531555,
-0.24592691659927368,
0.2898501455783844,
-0.15021200478076935,
-0.2519627511501312,
-0.0545523576438427,
0.729205310344696,
0.23457320034503937,
-0.5165697932243347,
-0.4966876208782196,
-0.048080626875162125,
0.056912753731012344,
-0.10219422727823257,
0.9383189678192139,
-0.37402960658073425,
0.8305795192718506,
0.8249884843826294,
0.43701934814453125,
0.5971164703369141,
-0.1588265597820282,
0.7104328274726868,
-0.6415008306503296,
-0.008852826431393623,
0.1541234850883484,
0.6433708667755127,
-0.020477568730711937,
-0.2951677739620209,
0.8390951752662659,
0.5081189870834351,
-0.9120144248008728,
-0.5545786023139954,
0.16819924116134644,
-1.1970945596694946,
0.12831376492977142,
1.0467501878738403,
-0.05422217398881912,
-0.08992509543895721,
-0.1366402804851532,
-0.5973471999168396,
0.4168437719345093,
-0.44775623083114624,
0.3927009403705597,
0.9408262968063354,
-0.5604504942893982,
-0.5521676540374756,
-0.6436049342155457,
0.0856681764125824,
0.6229640245437622,
-1.1965848207473755,
-0.2760511040687561,
0.7479346394538879,
-0.036636095494031906,
0.13841068744659424,
0.800375759601593,
-0.10714209824800491,
0.17492243647575378,
-0.19533173739910126,
0.3027413785457611,
0.145461767911911,
-0.4435909390449524,
-0.17247523367404938,
0.2494925707578659,
-0.4505206346511841,
-0.17387154698371887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11465v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11465v1
|
Effective In-Context Example Selection through Data Compression
| 2024-05-19T06:46:28 | 2024-05-19T06:46:28 |
Zhongxiang Sun, Kepu Zhang, Haoyu Wang, Xiao Zhang, Jun Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning has been extensively validated in large language models.
However, the mechanism and selection strategy for in-context example selection,
which is a crucial ingredient in this approach, lacks systematic and in-depth
research. In this paper, we propose a data compression approach to the
selection of in-context examples. We introduce a two-stage method that can
effectively choose relevant examples and retain sufficient information about
the training dataset within the in-context examples. Our method shows a
significant improvement of an average of 5.90% across five different real-world
datasets using four language models.
|
[
-0.46631819009780884,
-0.6511870622634888,
0.4599222242832184,
0.05961775779724121,
-0.5953980088233948,
-0.3252791464328766,
-0.3369707763195038,
-0.2496717870235443,
-0.23217087984085083,
0.09619500488042831,
-0.3364142179489136,
-0.2662126421928406,
-0.2632434070110321,
0.14604052901268005,
-0.6019739508628845,
0.6947407126426697,
0.02026498131453991,
0.2411009669303894,
-0.46720898151397705,
-0.031024226918816566,
-0.8467604517936707,
-0.48674631118774414,
-0.8090115785598755,
-0.31978100538253784,
-0.08959420770406723,
0.8626130223274231,
0.14594779908657074,
0.6173010468482971,
0.10888637602329254,
0.13967306911945343,
-0.15983033180236816,
0.3444612920284271,
-0.5578657984733582,
0.5438802242279053,
0.047857534140348434,
-0.3652840852737427,
0.2989027202129364,
0.07769503444433212,
0.7522640228271484,
0.500828742980957,
-0.2123713195323944,
0.19512920081615448,
0.17867717146873474,
0.4423971474170685,
-0.6312170028686523,
0.04117449373006821,
-0.46568575501441956,
0.11726154386997223,
0.09830424934625626,
-0.2402922809123993,
-0.6772530674934387,
-0.3510393798351288,
0.10096456110477448,
-0.4537432789802551,
0.14702504873275757,
0.16935977339744568,
0.43269655108451843,
0.05840573459863663,
-0.31601688265800476,
-0.33932560682296753,
-0.6029773354530334,
0.8177487850189209,
-0.7432308197021484,
0.3582378327846527,
0.5951245427131653,
0.525506317615509,
-0.24863365292549133,
-0.6972542405128479,
-0.4129514694213867,
0.11788681149482727,
0.036243196576833725,
-0.014818268828094006,
0.13826698064804077,
-0.2556684911251068,
0.46433520317077637,
0.22786760330200195,
-0.40192392468452454,
0.17025752365589142,
-0.23499557375907898,
-0.04978914186358452,
0.2988090217113495,
-0.09686966985464096,
0.09053501486778259,
-0.2030656337738037,
-0.2645612359046936,
-0.5644614696502686,
-1.1502883434295654,
-0.017679626122117043,
0.4944993853569031,
0.44974589347839355,
0.07195593416690826,
0.2128511369228363,
-0.24706879258155823,
1.025541067123413,
0.02079944685101509,
-0.3161594569683075,
0.12333306670188904,
-0.23762843012809753,
-0.08342666923999786,
0.04112086817622185,
0.29520729184150696,
0.35390254855155945,
-0.010340551845729351,
-0.2894645929336548,
-0.24921609461307526,
-0.036636121571063995,
0.20851650834083557,
-1.1782097816467285,
0.004592475946992636,
0.36625275015830994,
-0.5924808382987976,
-0.2870250642299652,
0.19363217055797577,
-1.174149751663208,
-0.0909862071275711,
-0.15763340890407562,
0.450339138507843,
-0.377411812543869,
0.05347813293337822,
0.18608605861663818,
-0.3555057942867279,
0.03836563974618912,
0.17828300595283508,
-0.8855706453323364,
0.4116601049900055,
0.5339701771736145,
0.8265637159347534,
0.01691906712949276,
-0.05439871549606323,
-0.831084668636322,
0.1421276181936264,
-0.22103366255760193,
0.9161930680274963,
-0.9127762913703918,
-0.38799408078193665,
0.27327480912208557,
-0.23260237276554108,
0.35319891571998596,
-0.566843569278717,
0.8848357796669006,
-0.2988223731517792,
0.6158550977706909,
-0.19335998594760895,
-0.8983187079429626,
-0.3605565130710602,
0.1305258572101593,
-0.5623096227645874,
1.2262438535690308,
0.42726361751556396,
-0.6450681090354919,
0.6649367809295654,
-0.4051315188407898,
-0.4470413327217102,
0.01549470517784357,
-0.35786718130111694,
-0.6083720922470093,
0.2226060926914215,
0.48302391171455383,
0.8682058453559875,
-0.23106805980205536,
0.017589261755347252,
-0.35739028453826904,
-0.6975309252738953,
0.06552446633577347,
-0.10042271763086319,
0.6943895220756531,
0.3166339695453644,
-0.16835413873195648,
-0.36384621262550354,
-0.5556145906448364,
-0.006045407149940729,
0.11500905454158783,
-0.5048536062240601,
-0.6526355147361755,
0.025921093299984932,
0.220799520611763,
0.6152341365814209,
-0.3185790777206421,
-0.5166603326797485,
0.5789985060691833,
-0.3458440601825714,
0.5935808420181274,
0.40715792775154114,
0.23238804936408997,
0.5647389888763428,
-0.3342913091182709,
0.5109067559242249,
-0.06791967153549194,
0.18632300198078156,
-0.21946106851100922,
-0.24175721406936646,
-0.5170663595199585,
-0.04960862547159195,
0.6465597748756409,
0.27925699949264526,
-1.0169137716293335,
0.4821224808692932,
-0.298284649848938,
-0.22820599377155304,
-0.22990696132183075,
0.1681177318096161,
0.35479119420051575,
0.653494119644165,
0.399301141500473,
-0.36282843351364136,
-0.5719906687736511,
-0.7084298133850098,
-0.03708409145474434,
-0.09983378648757935,
-0.18983152508735657,
0.4321630597114563,
0.35063254833221436,
0.04344901442527771,
1.1485528945922852,
-0.3658258616924286,
0.07786872237920761,
-0.4174373745918274,
0.07393442094326019,
0.06972360610961914,
0.6169944405555725,
0.7913914322853088,
-1.0404402017593384,
-0.3616577386856079,
-0.5048162341117859,
-0.5396929979324341,
-0.001007898012176156,
-0.27058517932891846,
-0.12809263169765472,
-0.2189740687608719,
0.5780566334724426,
-0.3113476037979126,
0.38349229097366333,
0.4371594786643982,
-0.2347421795129776,
0.03672512248158455,
-0.20139537751674652,
0.14055150747299194,
-1.3467042446136475,
-0.3049669861793518,
0.12362463027238846,
-0.532420814037323,
-0.8360968232154846,
0.0413627102971077,
0.5293843746185303,
-0.06472162157297134,
-0.6470171809196472,
0.5592501759529114,
-0.4456236958503723,
-0.010485061444342136,
-0.1912733018398285,
-0.07078461349010468,
-0.22251516580581665,
0.386109322309494,
0.12488317489624023,
0.6993378400802612,
0.7547972202301025,
-0.7492077946662903,
0.03018343448638916,
0.44510406255722046,
-0.8910176157951355,
0.42050889134407043,
-0.32644709944725037,
0.516494631767273,
-0.28650397062301636,
0.6457921266555786,
-0.7734937071800232,
-0.40483057498931885,
-0.0018414295045658946,
0.000049654703616397455,
0.595613420009613,
-0.4297190308570862,
-0.8925597667694092,
-0.27513548731803894,
-0.35250598192214966,
0.5385384559631348,
0.7815542221069336,
-1.0014718770980835,
0.275849848985672,
0.42338159680366516,
-0.06342214345932007,
-0.34623822569847107,
-0.6306779980659485,
0.07775753736495972,
-0.8229724764823914,
-0.10043324530124664,
0.4266982972621918,
-0.334028959274292,
0.013657694682478905,
-0.3454906940460205,
-0.2839898467063904,
-0.04232114925980568,
0.09822911769151688,
0.10889104753732681,
-0.0486307218670845,
0.30087125301361084,
0.172524556517601,
0.32947930693626404,
0.15939269959926605,
-0.3516146242618561,
-0.3469277322292328,
0.5205510258674622,
0.2305312156677246,
-0.13778220117092133,
-0.2623365819454193,
0.5683413743972778,
0.042486827820539474,
0.23516619205474854,
0.48115140199661255,
0.2963215410709381,
-0.4571898579597473,
-0.7696964144706726,
-0.5241562724113464,
-0.4547809660434723,
-0.4379503130912781,
0.1646639108657837,
-0.133958637714386,
-0.8248130083084106,
0.14976562559604645,
-0.3540935218334198,
-0.008989270776510239,
-0.21950313448905945,
0.32613104581832886,
0.11353081464767456,
1.0028290748596191,
0.5675387978553772,
-0.16575035452842712,
0.9809063076972961,
-0.4427296221256256,
0.2497682273387909,
-0.8444272875785828,
-0.019901154562830925,
-0.5870027542114258,
-0.16986271739006042,
-0.07889506965875626,
-0.34574973583221436,
0.38573530316352844,
0.3663378059864044,
-0.0063354019075632095,
0.6098934412002563,
-0.48205170035362244,
0.8354887962341309,
0.3693757951259613,
0.5086050033569336,
-0.12269672751426697,
0.3084667921066284,
0.05303562432527542,
0.23584899306297302,
-1.1352492570877075,
-0.565631091594696,
1.062312364578247,
0.2802441120147705,
0.44480735063552856,
0.3479514718055725,
0.5984041690826416,
0.18703924119472504,
0.1529034525156021,
-0.7057655453681946,
0.4743120074272156,
-0.04215621203184128,
-0.44795969128608704,
-0.2422071397304535,
-0.4317927956581116,
-1.0156886577606201,
0.17923809587955475,
-0.31917911767959595,
-0.7651405334472656,
0.25918659567832947,
0.12464960664510727,
-0.48748889565467834,
-0.07300302386283875,
-0.7232034206390381,
0.5356114506721497,
0.20117735862731934,
-0.2607678771018982,
-0.17824889719486237,
-0.6762753129005432,
0.18240752816200256,
-0.20715907216072083,
0.3516518473625183,
0.32346367835998535,
0.05257727578282356,
0.7861974835395813,
-0.325305312871933,
0.6761599779129028,
-0.3177209794521332,
0.18628095090389252,
0.2720949649810791,
0.07658766210079193,
0.6002515554428101,
0.18158985674381256,
-0.3511323928833008,
-0.011212928220629692,
-0.2010943442583084,
-0.4050077497959137,
-1.024618148803711,
0.3277372717857361,
-0.2763345539569855,
-0.1475522369146347,
-0.11274182051420212,
-0.4800308048725128,
-0.5223516225814819,
-0.16086609661579132,
0.4125550389289856,
1.0438272953033447,
0.058148548007011414,
0.5539823174476624,
0.5667518973350525,
-0.1331859976053238,
0.7812283635139465,
0.3238438069820404,
0.21980220079421997,
-0.33220717310905457,
0.5887786149978638,
0.03206505626440048,
0.2521560490131378,
0.42029905319213867,
0.40528467297554016,
-0.29574647545814514,
-0.8125969767570496,
-0.5835480093955994,
-0.1704850047826767,
-0.9965445399284363,
-0.5730423927307129,
-0.3961299955844879,
0.24834808707237244,
-0.3726169466972351,
-0.1529093235731125,
0.09961044043302536,
-0.5888462066650391,
-0.07701606303453445,
-0.08427056670188904,
0.2141713798046112,
0.6288827657699585,
0.27053630352020264,
0.3616015315055847,
-0.5428187251091003,
0.1905503273010254,
0.42586275935173035,
0.18355746567249298,
0.06929826736450195,
-0.5884820222854614,
-0.49478957056999207,
-0.09132235497236252,
-0.18387018144130707,
-0.9607170224189758,
0.34830281138420105,
0.5578086972236633,
0.7878723740577698,
0.6348271369934082,
0.04255466163158417,
0.7283807396888733,
-0.5035963654518127,
0.969868004322052,
-0.04771433398127556,
-0.7681728601455688,
0.8183573484420776,
0.032160501927137375,
0.22391586005687714,
0.7845847606658936,
0.39279478788375854,
-0.47086694836616516,
-0.2542106509208679,
-0.6954668164253235,
-0.8304558992385864,
0.6478713750839233,
0.3876838982105255,
0.06555431336164474,
-0.1491326242685318,
0.5988030433654785,
0.41988399624824524,
0.13813059031963348,
-0.5440430045127869,
-0.061713460832834244,
-0.04052703082561493,
-0.26525720953941345,
-0.10856417566537857,
-0.2862890064716339,
-0.09730253368616104,
-0.311387300491333,
0.6117678880691528,
-0.30030351877212524,
0.12798792123794556,
0.1581132858991623,
-0.299950510263443,
0.14073269069194794,
0.2213088870048523,
0.43274253606796265,
0.4949420094490051,
-0.1996515393257141,
0.18306797742843628,
0.30811336636543274,
-0.5027655363082886,
0.26645126938819885,
-0.10985417664051056,
-0.33473360538482666,
-0.07323171943426132,
0.31958484649658203,
0.5942026376724243,
0.5724647641181946,
-0.7397011518478394,
0.7480735182762146,
-0.31590765714645386,
0.0050307996571063995,
-0.12000226974487305,
0.13847866654396057,
-0.4838852882385254,
0.22046685218811035,
0.2780928909778595,
-0.1351129710674286,
0.43454456329345703,
-0.7791389226913452,
0.2655799686908722,
0.18215647339820862,
-0.09208787977695465,
0.08391977101564407,
0.18519148230552673,
-0.006671841721981764,
-0.2162202000617981,
0.632469892501831,
-0.3827173411846161,
-0.507282018661499,
0.4551123082637787,
0.8520960211753845,
0.7371581196784973,
-0.08547906577587128,
-0.033804576843976974,
0.5736909508705139,
-0.2160002589225769,
-0.9563311338424683,
0.19597776234149933,
-0.39925655722618103,
-0.7119138836860657,
-0.39103400707244873,
-0.39603015780448914,
-0.4112853407859802,
0.089613176882267,
-0.8210421204566956,
0.4498429596424103,
-0.09321504086256027,
0.0441913977265358,
-0.3601076304912567,
0.2016664445400238,
-0.6911326050758362,
0.22616879642009735,
0.14617280662059784,
1.1718990802764893,
-1.0662072896957397,
1.2406190633773804,
0.4296605587005615,
-0.31308627128601074,
-0.7840037941932678,
0.04071750119328499,
-0.1679007112979889,
-0.18310311436653137,
0.4169686436653137,
0.2876179814338684,
0.32297277450561523,
-0.2722664475440979,
-0.817491888999939,
-0.7391149401664734,
1.1025067567825317,
0.4114129841327667,
-0.35770758986473083,
0.297314316034317,
-0.4731976091861725,
0.31075751781463623,
-0.7904573678970337,
0.3088870942592621,
0.58183753490448,
0.20670148730278015,
0.2038041651248932,
-0.5271111726760864,
0.12951834499835968,
-0.22057493031024933,
0.2991039454936981,
0.13850192725658417,
-0.5497511625289917,
0.6154394149780273,
0.19498834013938904,
-0.34798917174339294,
-0.005927440710365772,
0.6845383048057556,
0.21770243346691132,
0.15489420294761658,
0.9459397196769714,
0.4187883734703064,
0.7376333475112915,
0.25990402698516846,
1.1871975660324097,
-0.21341611444950104,
0.39734917879104614,
1.1414587497711182,
-0.10495534539222717,
0.9760305285453796,
0.49737343192100525,
0.03957637771964073,
0.6196981072425842,
0.9862903952598572,
-0.11883019655942917,
0.9523290395736694,
0.16974160075187683,
-0.26725849509239197,
-0.36658376455307007,
-0.06977422535419464,
-0.17461876571178436,
0.5193123817443848,
0.282938152551651,
-0.12309745699167252,
-0.1801331639289856,
0.05243382602930069,
0.16593307256698608,
-0.09453540295362473,
-0.20109371840953827,
0.7054846882820129,
-0.1347121298313141,
-0.8063158988952637,
0.47057029604911804,
-0.19174593687057495,
0.5924229621887207,
-0.579512894153595,
-0.4936964511871338,
-0.20677991211414337,
-0.37250298261642456,
-0.22977617383003235,
-0.5603880882263184,
-0.02312898077070713,
0.1140039786696434,
-0.03521404415369034,
-0.5198528170585632,
0.7568026781082153,
-0.6079738140106201,
-0.368022084236145,
-0.05392797291278839,
0.2278892546892166,
0.49623286724090576,
0.0597282350063324,
-0.24666807055473328,
-0.06764473766088486,
-0.13343445956707,
-0.17166218161582947,
0.5343351364135742,
0.21940162777900696,
-0.0974300280213356,
0.5317632555961609,
0.5066288113594055,
0.15875451266765594,
-0.45059651136398315,
0.16817152500152588,
0.9302509427070618,
-0.40925219655036926,
-0.6959385871887207,
-0.7438388466835022,
0.3398601710796356,
-0.5602180361747742,
-0.2566766142845154,
0.8604896664619446,
0.7573233246803284,
1.0989941358566284,
0.04534243792295456,
0.8228296041488647,
-0.2089238464832306,
0.39511096477508545,
-0.8599867820739746,
0.23674118518829346,
-0.4708787500858307,
0.29555484652519226,
-0.43314146995544434,
-0.8724328875541687,
-0.28229132294654846,
0.9223443269729614,
-0.04318062961101532,
0.0800006166100502,
0.7690445780754089,
0.7544717192649841,
-0.351278692483902,
0.15394948422908783,
0.2542552947998047,
-0.1604803204536438,
0.2074035108089447,
0.6407291889190674,
0.5892255902290344,
-0.5212035775184631,
0.28435859084129333,
-0.5351232886314392,
-0.33463725447654724,
-0.22898194193840027,
-1.2272151708602905,
-0.9967780113220215,
-0.8860561847686768,
-0.24219255149364471,
-0.2996181845664978,
-0.20532254874706268,
1.2720463275909424,
1.3733551502227783,
-0.5824317932128906,
-0.15746746957302094,
0.06653354316949844,
0.033527884632349014,
-0.5848616361618042,
-0.08909990638494492,
0.29127705097198486,
-0.3051609396934509,
-0.6990645527839661,
0.9054105281829834,
0.0396319180727005,
0.06678762286901474,
-0.026626180857419968,
0.07340768724679947,
0.06671374291181564,
-0.007241776213049889,
0.71479731798172,
0.08533410727977753,
-0.26603758335113525,
-0.4776030480861664,
-0.6398087739944458,
0.28947073221206665,
-0.018062599003314972,
1.1152842044830322,
-1.0716054439544678,
0.4165406823158264,
0.5278617739677429,
0.6549789905548096,
0.6934309601783752,
0.2279026359319687,
0.5888193249702454,
-1.0460357666015625,
0.5536647439002991,
0.3081378936767578,
0.5272713303565979,
0.4672513008117676,
-0.4650341868400574,
0.8168579936027527,
-0.07845034450292587,
-0.5947524905204773,
-0.9349357485771179,
0.2664974331855774,
-0.8977019786834717,
-0.7124654054641724,
1.5500119924545288,
-0.14596042037010193,
0.02275799587368965,
-0.19025340676307678,
-0.21401767432689667,
0.24205602705478668,
-0.5321245789527893,
0.9947556853294373,
0.7892418503761292,
-0.06919116526842117,
-0.08955267816781998,
-0.8716716766357422,
0.6266059875488281,
0.19158166646957397,
-0.7748680114746094,
-0.007728096097707748,
0.5262655019760132,
0.12812913954257965,
-0.26054802536964417,
0.21431304514408112,
0.20261849462985992,
0.007189932744950056,
0.03788076713681221,
-0.1644892394542694,
-0.04917791858315468,
-0.4923073947429657,
-0.8114598989486694,
0.36337998509407043,
-0.08924135565757751,
-0.0672585517168045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11464v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11464v2
|
Efficient Prompt Tuning by Multi-Space Projection and Prompt Fusion
| 2024-05-19T06:43:12 | 2024-07-01T14:27:51 |
Pengxiang Lan, Enneng Yang, Yuting Liu, Guibing Guo, Linying Jiang, Jianzhe Zhao, Xingwei Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Prompt tuning is a promising method to fine-tune a pre-trained language model
without retraining its large-scale parameters. Instead, it attaches a soft
prompt to the input text, whereby downstream tasks can be well adapted by
merely learning the embeddings of prompt tokens. Nevertheless, existing methods
still suffer from two challenges: (i) they are hard to balance accuracy and
efficiency. A longer (shorter) soft prompt generally leads to a better(worse)
accuracy but at the cost of more (less) training time. (ii)The performance may
not be consistent when adapting to different downstream tasks. We attribute it
to the same embedding space but responsible for different requirements of
downstream tasks. To address these issues, we propose an Efficient Prompt
Tuning method (EPT) by multi-space projection and prompt fusion. Specifically,
it decomposes a given soft prompt into a shorter prompt and two low-rank
matrices, significantly reducing the training time. Accuracy is also enhanced
by leveraging low-rank matrices and the short prompt as additional knowledge
sources to enrich the semantics of the original short prompt. In addition, we
project the soft prompt into multiple subspaces to improve the performance
consistency, and then adaptively learn the combination weights of different
spaces through a gating network. Experiments on 13 natural language processing
downstream tasks show that our method significantly and consistently
outperforms 11 comparison methods with the relative percentage of improvements
up to 12.9%, and training time decreased by 14%.
|
[
-0.41923224925994873,
-0.7053938508033752,
0.7763423323631287,
0.2705114483833313,
-0.31427881121635437,
0.08924971520900726,
-0.61965012550354,
0.11292611062526703,
0.1520158052444458,
0.06868594139814377,
-0.8729673027992249,
-0.4790628254413605,
-0.3935808837413788,
0.33737441897392273,
0.35840660333633423,
1.0291452407836914,
0.14029765129089355,
-0.19658097624778748,
0.12068217247724533,
-0.11278972774744034,
-0.9981697797775269,
-0.14896680414676666,
-0.7378727197647095,
0.21118420362472534,
0.7239494919776917,
0.6577942371368408,
0.5914711356163025,
0.7049962282180786,
0.18675534427165985,
0.33645182847976685,
-0.17231102287769318,
0.6547329425811768,
-0.3343271017074585,
0.218059703707695,
-0.08324078470468521,
-0.14850987493991852,
-0.15715616941452026,
-0.038966480642557144,
0.7764676213264465,
0.6542324423789978,
-0.06263439357280731,
-0.08220267295837402,
0.48097550868988037,
0.5537257790565491,
-0.6057132482528687,
0.1663789600133896,
-0.43078064918518066,
-0.18105630576610565,
-0.24664832651615143,
-0.4545781910419464,
-0.4561567008495331,
-0.5608583092689514,
0.010018064640462399,
-0.9023374319076538,
0.34513604640960693,
0.2760513424873352,
0.8765255808830261,
0.47260749340057373,
-0.3735712170600891,
-0.2373785823583603,
-0.47665223479270935,
0.7416766285896301,
-0.4177984893321991,
0.30257171392440796,
0.18650101125240326,
0.3648938834667206,
-0.2192005217075348,
-0.527617335319519,
-0.4034254848957062,
-0.307024210691452,
-0.15940116345882416,
0.14447174966335297,
-0.16516198217868805,
0.3123815655708313,
0.35170459747314453,
-0.024491921067237854,
-0.673911452293396,
0.155337393283844,
-0.15759490430355072,
-0.5188981294631958,
0.10269966721534729,
0.0694686621427536,
0.24691283702850342,
-0.2549003064632416,
-0.3901134431362152,
-0.36661696434020996,
-0.6450647115707397,
0.1737351268529892,
0.490557461977005,
0.818758487701416,
0.058220766484737396,
0.2982502579689026,
-0.20271120965480804,
0.8933154344558716,
0.305890291929245,
0.027507517486810684,
0.23137329518795013,
-0.6364731788635254,
0.13689403235912323,
0.0028145345859229565,
0.5829028487205505,
0.29906997084617615,
0.03685634583234787,
-0.02758469432592392,
-0.14688993990421295,
0.13087743520736694,
0.2597734034061432,
-0.536531388759613,
-0.1640564352273941,
-0.13002029061317444,
-0.2509033977985382,
0.21672700345516205,
-0.1266094148159027,
-0.808247983455658,
-0.49100565910339355,
-0.42699894309043884,
0.490062415599823,
-0.6862745881080627,
0.09398666769266129,
-0.10819877684116364,
-0.16312888264656067,
0.13588915765285492,
0.46918100118637085,
-0.8462532162666321,
-0.009025843814015388,
0.7369968891143799,
1.1715381145477295,
0.14876945316791534,
-0.3220994770526886,
-1.1486037969589233,
-0.2261715531349182,
-0.167765274643898,
1.1098538637161255,
-0.5549938082695007,
-0.2315140664577484,
0.06800170242786407,
-0.04342477768659592,
-0.3874814510345459,
-0.3234310746192932,
0.8890818357467651,
-0.15345723927021027,
0.41839703917503357,
-0.39882999658584595,
-0.43001291155815125,
0.059220414608716965,
0.0066328528337180614,
-0.6186235547065735,
0.7802947163581848,
0.24246472120285034,
-0.3023717701435089,
0.5589998960494995,
-0.7032471895217896,
-0.5321040153503418,
0.10106709599494934,
0.07881254702806473,
-0.26636314392089844,
0.22260114550590515,
0.7010464072227478,
0.4706377685070038,
-0.14194850623607635,
0.20300419628620148,
-0.02104419656097889,
-0.5231650471687317,
-0.2192389965057373,
-0.3325650990009308,
0.36931735277175903,
0.29522737860679626,
-0.15336287021636963,
0.3841032087802887,
-0.8433122038841248,
-0.054610725492239,
-0.2581295371055603,
-0.37477487325668335,
-0.43647751212120056,
-0.10931564122438431,
-0.0760485827922821,
0.07584688067436218,
0.1736847311258316,
-0.45652174949645996,
0.450516939163208,
-0.6804788708686829,
0.3233092129230499,
0.8834599852561951,
-0.10993572324514389,
0.8055265545845032,
-0.2524487376213074,
0.4925134479999542,
0.00792363565415144,
0.12085002660751343,
-0.6172050833702087,
-0.5432580709457397,
-0.6676449775695801,
-0.3684425354003906,
0.28817951679229736,
0.5361937284469604,
-1.0599677562713623,
0.6184267997741699,
-0.23723770678043365,
-0.3294781744480133,
-0.7128790020942688,
0.16679584980010986,
0.31518563628196716,
0.7887922525405884,
0.4776299297809601,
0.11616511642932892,
-0.44438233971595764,
-0.8091970086097717,
-0.6148651242256165,
-0.006748938001692295,
-0.09007968753576279,
0.36188119649887085,
0.024702372029423714,
0.251274049282074,
0.8895065784454346,
-0.6509240865707397,
-0.4459000527858734,
-0.2329218089580536,
0.2693958878517151,
0.6506073474884033,
0.4961143732070923,
0.4285695254802704,
-0.5139342546463013,
-0.6124267578125,
-0.1803503930568695,
-0.2559421956539154,
-0.4357035458087921,
-0.38175198435783386,
-0.12049829959869385,
0.06244944408535957,
0.40278854966163635,
-0.6817554831504822,
-0.059016160666942596,
0.3357061743736267,
-0.7645286917686462,
0.36053797602653503,
-0.42345380783081055,
0.2849752902984619,
-1.0953612327575684,
-0.004666887689381838,
0.18810027837753296,
-0.19912400841712952,
-0.7611435055732727,
-0.09910392761230469,
0.3277803659439087,
-0.22343699634075165,
-0.4662694036960602,
0.4735340178012848,
-0.5443752408027649,
0.5429161787033081,
-0.3590678572654724,
0.25323259830474854,
0.13073430955410004,
0.7203740477561951,
-0.18739494681358337,
0.9591770768165588,
0.5178624987602234,
-0.7004677057266235,
0.22964055836200714,
0.2666832208633423,
-0.34382307529449463,
0.6661606431007385,
-0.5345017910003662,
0.3372388780117035,
-0.43293267488479614,
0.34545016288757324,
-1.283531665802002,
0.04645036160945892,
0.3984251022338867,
-0.3441501557826996,
0.3686753213405609,
-0.19578561186790466,
-0.432672381401062,
-0.06823844462633133,
-0.40766867995262146,
0.19934558868408203,
0.6371293663978577,
-0.6948819160461426,
0.6453573703765869,
-0.12404941022396088,
-0.3890814483165741,
-0.4201755225658417,
-0.1713966578245163,
-0.015111317858099937,
-0.3636523187160492,
-0.7171550989151001,
0.49520769715309143,
0.17307588458061218,
0.18712086975574493,
-0.20298966765403748,
0.106438547372818,
0.2961774170398712,
0.1475249081850052,
0.030729882419109344,
0.0989300087094307,
-0.28553494811058044,
0.2529345452785492,
0.41928809881210327,
-0.4613410532474518,
-0.46854346990585327,
-0.5350240468978882,
0.44750064611434937,
-0.08812707662582397,
-0.16241280734539032,
-0.4021475911140442,
0.48768216371536255,
0.3787672519683838,
0.04203018546104431,
0.8866073489189148,
0.7176735997200012,
-0.24303525686264038,
-0.29049351811408997,
-0.482835590839386,
-0.2595231533050537,
-0.529593288898468,
0.23009920120239258,
-0.4324846565723419,
-0.9337754845619202,
0.4399620294570923,
-0.3786347508430481,
0.23218421638011932,
0.36642250418663025,
0.3867729604244232,
-0.010707375593483448,
1.2350525856018066,
0.7941195964813232,
0.1645924150943756,
0.7116095423698425,
0.2210851013660431,
0.2227455973625183,
-0.7726944088935852,
-0.14772573113441467,
-0.8709858059883118,
-0.4152841567993164,
-0.377240926027298,
-0.38236647844314575,
0.5831698775291443,
0.07494931668043137,
-0.22675855457782745,
0.5188848376274109,
-0.50131756067276,
0.4073328971862793,
0.6990423798561096,
0.07137776166200638,
0.12139695882797241,
-0.0302105825394392,
-0.23265387117862701,
-0.2069157361984253,
-0.8689497709274292,
-0.4368508756160736,
0.5369231700897217,
0.21912400424480438,
0.5948411226272583,
0.11960419267416,
0.425024151802063,
0.1574147343635559,
-0.12809304893016815,
-0.6368529200553894,
0.367782860994339,
-0.25946617126464844,
-0.08083741366863251,
-0.31895554065704346,
-0.560117781162262,
-0.9455998539924622,
0.35780927538871765,
-0.16430558264255524,
-0.6251598596572876,
0.23261083662509918,
0.41713210940361023,
-0.8817281723022461,
-0.061909716576337814,
-1.2408323287963867,
0.7720623016357422,
0.0952342301607132,
-0.3134016692638397,
-0.10929444432258606,
-0.7058120965957642,
-0.054922156035900116,
0.06576545536518097,
-0.011864379979670048,
-0.16745957732200623,
-0.0745687410235405,
0.6990857124328613,
-0.48576176166534424,
0.7495629191398621,
-0.5978714823722839,
0.024575060233473778,
0.054678771644830704,
-0.19431939721107483,
0.7491422891616821,
0.10352785140275955,
0.01927054673433304,
-0.20775823295116425,
-0.20330901443958282,
-0.43032607436180115,
-0.8298131823539734,
0.6745525002479553,
-0.6889573931694031,
-0.4690536856651306,
-0.3473496735095978,
-0.4753068685531616,
-0.45228829979896545,
0.020551661029458046,
0.38797658681869507,
0.636623203754425,
0.00184095767326653,
-0.023208515718579292,
0.5350847244262695,
-0.5888016223907471,
0.533562183380127,
0.3104041814804077,
0.2505226731300354,
-0.32147017121315,
1.0107094049453735,
-0.08383669704198837,
-0.04971321299672127,
0.5580445528030396,
0.36634430289268494,
-0.7094213366508484,
-0.3239658772945404,
-0.7095192670822144,
0.04020785167813301,
-0.592303991317749,
-0.4474700391292572,
-0.6321641206741333,
0.18714219331741333,
-0.5345962047576904,
-0.2722927927970886,
-0.3141627907752991,
-0.35988375544548035,
-0.4751516282558441,
0.1135488897562027,
0.5250201225280762,
0.2646072208881378,
-0.07759391516447067,
0.6099550724029541,
-0.9284682273864746,
0.34564000368118286,
0.12012094259262085,
0.3854012191295624,
-0.28380510210990906,
-0.5714107751846313,
-0.1959356963634491,
-0.11525435745716095,
-0.22876675426959991,
-0.7531010508537292,
0.3048299551010132,
0.6172705292701721,
0.5378970503807068,
0.2507809102535248,
0.037544045597314835,
0.8518399596214294,
-0.7051276564598083,
0.837629497051239,
0.23765210807323456,
-1.0097575187683105,
0.7787641882896423,
-0.36090755462646484,
0.6880854964256287,
0.8352825045585632,
0.11070656776428223,
-0.571648120880127,
-0.2425573766231537,
-0.1913951188325882,
-1.0109047889709473,
0.8502938151359558,
0.06892876327037811,
0.10329850018024445,
0.05403415486216545,
0.3070843815803528,
0.3959018290042877,
0.10617420822381973,
-0.20349864661693573,
-0.18188410997390747,
-0.2186252623796463,
-0.3554176390171051,
-0.341564804315567,
-0.05653180554509163,
0.09767099469900131,
-0.2701476216316223,
0.5888773202896118,
-0.5663276314735413,
0.31005021929740906,
0.059764694422483444,
-0.3045731782913208,
-0.004765051882714033,
0.4430229067802429,
0.6980882287025452,
0.51904296875,
0.04866332560777664,
0.1410519778728485,
0.27496910095214844,
-0.4473575949668884,
0.2771812975406647,
0.21147164702415466,
-0.08360046148300171,
0.08614245057106018,
0.23451760411262512,
1.1848385334014893,
0.38163337111473083,
-0.3630515933036804,
0.5308987498283386,
-0.26265835762023926,
-0.05688072368502617,
0.15469703078269958,
0.03725830838084221,
-0.26567959785461426,
0.1981900930404663,
0.42833200097084045,
0.4409758746623993,
0.025257248431444168,
-0.2553546726703644,
0.1270758956670761,
0.2249148190021515,
-0.2730245590209961,
-0.31550806760787964,
0.48186564445495605,
0.4209856688976288,
-0.4098809063434601,
0.8124927878379822,
-0.21393710374832153,
-0.424103319644928,
0.31268733739852905,
0.45213624835014343,
0.937315046787262,
-0.12402607500553131,
0.44768399000167847,
0.3681320250034332,
0.2776821255683899,
0.006409342400729656,
0.33092519640922546,
-0.1718253195285797,
-0.5293048620223999,
-0.8372682929039001,
-0.6627498865127563,
-0.2598929703235626,
-0.07001003623008728,
-0.38303086161613464,
0.3743246793746948,
-0.4624670147895813,
-0.190943643450737,
-0.2038213312625885,
0.043013542890548706,
-0.730194091796875,
-0.20324954390525818,
0.19275447726249695,
1.0351895093917847,
-0.8974076509475708,
0.4426659047603607,
0.8409802913665771,
-0.06512600928544998,
-0.9435148239135742,
-0.031491562724113464,
-0.06952723860740662,
-0.5854724645614624,
0.17339564859867096,
0.3397074043750763,
-0.04803493618965149,
0.17814786732196808,
-0.3108446002006531,
-0.8471602201461792,
0.7441887259483337,
0.5965941548347473,
-0.7341920733451843,
-0.02810409851372242,
-0.28484559059143066,
0.420372873544693,
-0.10472742468118668,
0.37756726145744324,
0.5380398035049438,
0.6804036498069763,
-0.04734194278717041,
-0.932044267654419,
0.3058857023715973,
-0.27450644969940186,
0.08355008810758591,
0.3858688175678253,
-0.7162531018257141,
0.7043406963348389,
-0.14860810339450836,
-0.6389127373695374,
0.1251971423625946,
0.8726806640625,
0.30455324053764343,
0.12087055295705795,
0.7687394022941589,
0.2509969472885132,
0.8909986019134521,
-0.4182424545288086,
0.8823327422142029,
-0.37284085154533386,
0.20894663035869598,
0.6402584314346313,
-0.3065767288208008,
0.28942641615867615,
0.6409274339675903,
0.1561710387468338,
0.43417108058929443,
0.5844625234603882,
0.10806213319301605,
0.9016212821006775,
0.04397770017385483,
-0.12458575516939163,
-0.3015199303627014,
-0.16514547169208527,
-0.28145456314086914,
0.2985166907310486,
0.33849772810935974,
-0.023460736498236656,
-0.513359010219574,
0.38437318801879883,
-0.17931045591831207,
0.19986560940742493,
-0.2481580525636673,
0.8219910860061646,
0.07535326480865479,
-1.1553152799606323,
0.3885839581489563,
0.1358250081539154,
0.8375362157821655,
-0.748208224773407,
-0.21714845299720764,
-0.12000434100627899,
0.2493460327386856,
0.025587987154722214,
-0.4689711928367615,
0.06201045215129852,
-0.03074873611330986,
-0.00007170701428549364,
-0.6207810640335083,
0.7962180972099304,
-0.2818509042263031,
-0.24885284900665283,
0.004324367269873619,
0.7279649376869202,
-0.17033708095550537,
-0.1491648405790329,
-0.516829788684845,
-0.055505428463220596,
-0.1358516365289688,
-0.30949631333351135,
0.30674099922180176,
0.39852777123451233,
0.12183091044425964,
0.37028616666793823,
0.7766661047935486,
0.18825341761112213,
0.03908323496580124,
0.2478405386209488,
0.8823509812355042,
-0.7448118925094604,
-1.0671515464782715,
-0.8993280529975891,
0.557794988155365,
-0.041690658777952194,
-0.7624114751815796,
0.7394078373908997,
0.23152707517147064,
0.4580489695072174,
-0.06516440957784653,
0.6622557044029236,
-0.0413796603679657,
0.5313000082969666,
-0.8515658378601074,
0.5073347687721252,
-0.4123620092868805,
0.15784548223018646,
-0.29343506693840027,
-1.173838496208191,
-0.3566431701183319,
0.6407511234283447,
-0.1641579419374466,
0.14430534839630127,
0.8781338334083557,
0.8542467951774597,
-0.025031445547938347,
0.05856199562549591,
0.25371965765953064,
-0.053619686514139175,
0.31681421399116516,
0.7442463040351868,
1.0519386529922485,
-0.15766336023807526,
0.46973592042922974,
-0.11296508461236954,
-0.3783011734485626,
-0.23290389776229858,
-0.9372783899307251,
-0.6146271824836731,
-0.7610937356948853,
-0.21706005930900574,
-0.22553639113903046,
0.19240358471870422,
1.201785922050476,
0.7720226645469666,
-0.7695579528808594,
0.26482224464416504,
0.05952056124806404,
0.10885791480541229,
-0.5177061557769775,
-0.23509660363197327,
0.5184057354927063,
-0.6645511388778687,
-0.7040749788284302,
0.8127735257148743,
0.3503248691558838,
-0.2570202052593231,
0.007535385433584452,
0.004903294611722231,
-0.06489066779613495,
-0.11279594153165817,
0.6105912327766418,
0.1733761876821518,
-0.36762723326683044,
-0.5732151865959167,
0.20573803782463074,
-0.05835296958684921,
0.06112828105688095,
0.9992223978042603,
-1.0075925588607788,
0.27976858615875244,
0.6478936672210693,
0.557279109954834,
0.03753984346985817,
0.22881434857845306,
0.7252296209335327,
-1.2212399244308472,
0.022465432062745094,
0.2255488485097885,
0.40155404806137085,
0.3923516571521759,
-0.6102347373962402,
0.06959879398345947,
0.1379547417163849,
-0.5089444518089294,
-0.6737086772918701,
0.12093673646450043,
-1.0349397659301758,
-0.2423674613237381,
1.1159703731536865,
0.006163732148706913,
-0.17901018261909485,
-0.31756970286369324,
-0.5143830180168152,
0.43276724219322205,
-0.7588896155357361,
0.5930688381195068,
0.46817269921302795,
-0.1569633185863495,
-0.09046142548322678,
-0.12881995737552643,
0.5746666789054871,
0.5864043831825256,
-0.5532742142677307,
-0.09050146490335464,
0.5482745170593262,
-0.01840965636074543,
0.26544395089149475,
0.5379711389541626,
0.34707799553871155,
0.3898325562477112,
-0.039987172931432724,
-0.4108531177043915,
-0.25481998920440674,
-0.6584176421165466,
-0.7562259435653687,
0.43004310131073,
-0.09539911150932312,
-0.2907329201698303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11461v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11461v1
|
DocReLM: Mastering Document Retrieval with Language Model
| 2024-05-19T06:30:22 | 2024-05-19T06:30:22 |
Gengchen Wei, Xinle Pang, Tianning Zhang, Yu Sun, Xun Qian, Chen Lin, Han-Sen Zhong, Wanli Ouyang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With over 200 million published academic documents and millions of new
documents being written each year, academic researchers face the challenge of
searching for information within this vast corpus. However, existing retrieval
systems struggle to understand the semantics and domain knowledge present in
academic papers. In this work, we demonstrate that by utilizing large language
models, a document retrieval system can achieve advanced semantic understanding
capabilities, significantly outperforming existing systems. Our approach
involves training the retriever and reranker using domain-specific data
generated by large language models. Additionally, we utilize large language
models to identify candidates from the references of retrieved papers to
further enhance the performance. We use a test set annotated by academic
researchers in the fields of quantum physics and computer vision to evaluate
our system's performance. The results show that DocReLM achieves a Top 10
accuracy of 44.12% in computer vision, compared to Google Scholar's 15.69%, and
an increase to 36.21% in quantum physics, while that of Google Scholar is
12.96%.
|
[
-0.15248940885066986,
-0.7034851908683777,
0.9432754516601562,
-0.1225944235920906,
-0.1962258666753769,
0.49525707960128784,
-0.24743561446666718,
-0.5308843851089478,
-0.22690951824188232,
0.34276026487350464,
0.017013082280755043,
-0.5523549914360046,
-1.0721124410629272,
0.18890760838985443,
-0.790367603302002,
0.5860779881477356,
-0.22122149169445038,
0.4744458496570587,
-0.38532474637031555,
0.028564447537064552,
-0.054188307374715805,
-0.29094383120536804,
-0.7104602456092834,
-0.5908675193786621,
0.2853962182998657,
0.19129785895347595,
0.6405584812164307,
0.3466607630252838,
1.1888498067855835,
0.3604578375816345,
-0.24215556681156158,
0.2124066948890686,
-0.6687250733375549,
0.0755276009440422,
-0.5735458731651306,
-0.6082485914230347,
-0.24383030831813812,
0.027004197239875793,
1.0093435049057007,
0.6153614521026611,
-0.13732020556926727,
-0.2655687630176544,
-0.255100280046463,
0.6648309230804443,
-0.47661134600639343,
0.2750626802444458,
-0.6655927896499634,
0.0276847705245018,
-0.14374575018882751,
-0.32607755064964294,
-0.6209542751312256,
-0.19193361699581146,
0.08489625155925751,
-1.102587342262268,
0.5198325514793396,
0.18833836913108826,
1.1084233522415161,
-0.07198138535022736,
-0.6278825402259827,
-0.17675051093101501,
-0.7307864427566528,
0.7367761135101318,
-0.24141281843185425,
0.8499516248703003,
0.4224795997142792,
0.4144376218318939,
-0.14943592250347137,
-1.0017110109329224,
-0.5297554731369019,
-0.12382789701223373,
-0.10650098323822021,
0.24866104125976562,
0.05214659869670868,
-0.13610804080963135,
0.25892123579978943,
0.3912537097930908,
-0.8037776947021484,
-0.04395236447453499,
-0.5157836079597473,
0.039537858217954636,
0.491516649723053,
0.05331456661224365,
0.18178197741508484,
0.020235799252986908,
-0.2796548008918762,
-0.572138786315918,
-0.3585870563983917,
-0.5598737001419067,
0.060678884387016296,
-0.1008579432964325,
0.4731718599796295,
0.4605056047439575,
-0.18047617375850677,
0.769615888595581,
-0.06953280419111252,
0.028372984379529953,
0.19598866999149323,
-0.3712010681629181,
-0.16307950019836426,
-0.2307175248861313,
0.581775963306427,
0.16289512813091278,
0.23559355735778809,
-0.43053048849105835,
-0.23380737006664276,
0.08815514296293259,
0.5592693090438843,
-0.744697093963623,
-0.17708443105220795,
0.02206290327012539,
-0.37270551919937134,
-0.10079015046358109,
0.20155955851078033,
-0.5325829386711121,
-0.31056296825408936,
-0.490343302488327,
0.33214718103408813,
-0.9372285604476929,
-0.3129018545150757,
0.2508091628551483,
-0.5446805357933044,
0.5592591166496277,
0.7489241361618042,
-0.7230377197265625,
0.5046042203903198,
1.0569360256195068,
0.8873088955879211,
-0.18028323352336884,
-0.26176688075065613,
-0.47849324345588684,
0.22202862799167633,
-0.57831209897995,
0.7838529944419861,
-0.7590282559394836,
-0.6771202683448792,
-0.1393352597951889,
0.041719622910022736,
-0.13575240969657898,
-0.5848501324653625,
0.7624396085739136,
-1.0712883472442627,
0.09130717813968658,
0.1212390810251236,
-0.9111470580101013,
-0.18171754479408264,
0.41116756200790405,
-0.3901059329509735,
0.7140318751335144,
0.2942935824394226,
-0.6283614039421082,
0.1442575305700302,
-0.39272451400756836,
-0.21296076476573944,
0.2964002788066864,
-0.11477245390415192,
-0.07862111181020737,
0.2894687354564667,
-0.16504128277301788,
0.18138092756271362,
-0.4724084734916687,
0.4014275372028351,
0.0021208019461482763,
-0.3242143988609314,
0.10614999383687973,
0.025261996313929558,
0.4796590507030487,
0.4349634647369385,
0.14254507422447205,
-0.177101269364357,
-0.7159056663513184,
0.006364716216921806,
0.21644902229309082,
-0.3976677358150482,
-0.653887152671814,
-0.1187514066696167,
0.26116296648979187,
0.06204838678240776,
0.33264902234077454,
-0.7128798365592957,
0.0959397554397583,
-0.2986508011817932,
0.316911518573761,
0.4311933219432831,
-0.3471207022666931,
0.524143397808075,
-0.19436049461364746,
0.4933580160140991,
-0.07056844234466553,
-0.019490502774715424,
-0.06912964582443237,
-0.19641205668449402,
-0.5258098840713501,
-0.0816575288772583,
0.5073611736297607,
0.39704182744026184,
-0.5509511828422546,
0.025246476754546165,
-0.5282227993011475,
-0.6288756132125854,
-0.5685479640960693,
0.3393489718437195,
0.44447535276412964,
0.7233582139015198,
0.3722752034664154,
-0.5630064010620117,
-0.2031719833612442,
-0.8425189852714539,
-0.3032130300998688,
-0.1598435491323471,
-0.06592883914709091,
0.2469351887702942,
0.5873647928237915,
-0.3821514844894409,
0.7665129899978638,
-0.7307506799697876,
-0.34153592586517334,
0.284271240234375,
0.3728097677230835,
0.11932806670665741,
0.4522707462310791,
0.1028180867433548,
-1.3248841762542725,
-0.4017028510570526,
0.21687813103199005,
-1.0632621049880981,
0.19604350626468658,
0.3575561046600342,
-0.2527826130390167,
0.1511874496936798,
0.7270609736442566,
-0.6657750010490417,
0.09268452227115631,
0.149126797914505,
-0.45184555649757385,
0.588194727897644,
-0.6116108298301697,
0.23599621653556824,
-0.8566163778305054,
0.43439850211143494,
0.2887360155582428,
-0.40315428376197815,
-0.39741164445877075,
0.6756525635719299,
0.6035036444664001,
-0.31509992480278015,
-0.3218736946582794,
0.6008818745613098,
-0.7072228789329529,
-0.029566626995801926,
-0.28725630044937134,
0.6813799738883972,
0.2916662096977234,
-0.22577479481697083,
0.28857603669166565,
0.6619057655334473,
0.4484867751598358,
-0.43970391154289246,
0.2787219285964966,
0.6138299703598022,
-0.459200382232666,
0.8883288502693176,
-0.6533395051956177,
0.07377371937036514,
-0.2736336290836334,
0.2407958060503006,
-0.8033827543258667,
-0.16040892899036407,
-0.4134202003479004,
-0.5056806802749634,
0.8067992329597473,
-0.07012176513671875,
-0.858831524848938,
-0.4133552610874176,
-0.044265877455472946,
0.13505670428276062,
0.45772072672843933,
-0.48090657591819763,
0.802263081073761,
0.3374018371105194,
-0.14521174132823944,
-0.570942223072052,
-0.24451151490211487,
0.26211467385292053,
0.22897520661354065,
-0.6773157715797424,
0.49513712525367737,
-0.09434749186038971,
-0.4203212857246399,
0.10769923776388168,
0.018849331885576248,
-0.00500025600194931,
0.2513168156147003,
0.16145382821559906,
0.3555813729763031,
0.10836290568113327,
0.33475810289382935,
-0.2844013273715973,
-0.4104635417461395,
0.04528670385479927,
-0.39222562313079834,
0.4880615174770355,
-0.11888134479522705,
-0.2234904170036316,
-0.029089143499732018,
0.2651270925998688,
0.4825343191623688,
-0.6202682852745056,
0.574587345123291,
0.6419073343276978,
-0.19004862010478973,
0.023460160940885544,
-0.549323558807373,
-0.35122814774513245,
-0.46071621775627136,
0.48769789934158325,
-0.5002740621566772,
-0.7711310386657715,
0.2881118357181549,
-0.3159619867801666,
-0.08914918452501297,
0.4808133542537689,
0.14766466617584229,
-0.03452213853597641,
1.1242913007736206,
0.6879116296768188,
-0.04508804902434349,
0.5077158212661743,
-0.4560549259185791,
0.049516621977090836,
-1.0770297050476074,
-0.4390586316585541,
-0.8419023752212524,
-0.003147787880152464,
-0.3545684218406677,
-0.6166012287139893,
0.26586058735847473,
0.21714118123054504,
-0.22302433848381042,
0.18577687442302704,
-0.6417747735977173,
0.3286218047142029,
0.6993755102157593,
0.0719355046749115,
0.7077677845954895,
0.1890588402748108,
-0.4298284947872162,
0.09876547753810883,
-0.3777516484260559,
-0.5902358293533325,
1.161955714225769,
0.2456813007593155,
1.058859944343567,
0.1412421464920044,
0.6008347272872925,
0.004714201670140028,
0.22037801146507263,
-0.716029167175293,
0.5541582703590393,
-0.35391300916671753,
-0.6749081015586853,
-0.14801113307476044,
-0.5407593846321106,
-1.012336254119873,
0.4951639175415039,
-0.23932184278964996,
-0.49358299374580383,
0.1262144148349762,
-0.47918063402175903,
0.2694019079208374,
0.07142350822687149,
-0.5168052315711975,
0.5015177130699158,
-0.10946591943502426,
-0.3999634087085724,
-0.7521584033966064,
-0.5801790356636047,
0.1506974846124649,
-0.4567814767360687,
0.3209506571292877,
0.09622538089752197,
-0.03249078616499901,
0.8754271864891052,
-0.15700630843639374,
0.21737875044345856,
0.030565816909074783,
-0.10375391691923141,
-0.0739777535200119,
0.32999715209007263,
0.4682403802871704,
0.05223564803600311,
-0.498319149017334,
0.0033616621512919664,
0.152109295129776,
-0.40961968898773193,
-0.5619706511497498,
1.0236936807632446,
-0.8564390540122986,
-0.8045021891593933,
-0.6482986807823181,
-0.6513392925262451,
-0.11158078908920288,
0.5895194411277771,
-0.07147497683763504,
0.42007991671562195,
-0.37734198570251465,
0.33688923716545105,
0.9264127612113953,
-0.04691550135612488,
0.16336485743522644,
1.2095043659210205,
-0.37891629338264465,
-0.193750262260437,
0.8180864453315735,
0.13559046387672424,
0.1933811604976654,
0.6217594146728516,
-0.09341861307621002,
-0.34369370341300964,
-0.6463730335235596,
-0.23232214152812958,
0.6141221523284912,
-0.8257866501808167,
-0.12459782510995865,
-1.01729416847229,
-0.23396451771259308,
-0.6263692378997803,
-0.23443178832530975,
-0.17278258502483368,
-0.33884236216545105,
-0.2822720408439636,
-0.14000757038593292,
0.30839911103248596,
0.6450598239898682,
0.034889549016952515,
0.06702622771263123,
-0.7994897365570068,
0.33545631170272827,
0.13196346163749695,
0.5439035296440125,
-0.1522008180618286,
-0.733948290348053,
-0.31612133979797363,
-0.34980905055999756,
-0.46952059864997864,
-0.5802783966064453,
0.5313127040863037,
0.22450746595859528,
0.6476466655731201,
0.2313050776720047,
-0.10568404197692871,
0.3468571901321411,
-0.5383740067481995,
0.46003660559654236,
0.03468916565179825,
-0.7495728135108948,
0.8097041845321655,
-0.40106824040412903,
0.37203213572502136,
0.6290009021759033,
0.6881698966026306,
-0.4788566529750824,
-0.6369116306304932,
-0.8584254384040833,
-0.764213502407074,
0.626862645149231,
-0.1516716033220291,
-0.09554765373468399,
0.011097944341599941,
0.4822779595851898,
-0.09825282543897629,
0.08619722723960876,
-0.021732859313488007,
0.019750220701098442,
0.06444427371025085,
-0.35514378547668457,
-0.5913439393043518,
-0.17804595828056335,
-0.30122512578964233,
-0.13124853372573853,
0.8517197370529175,
-0.22955940663814545,
0.14930346608161926,
0.4431832730770111,
-0.34051641821861267,
-0.1509590595960617,
0.12387383729219437,
0.3638785481452942,
1.1207358837127686,
-0.49530911445617676,
0.28856638073921204,
-0.19342198967933655,
-0.6777734160423279,
0.11957337707281113,
0.4866582453250885,
-0.2434050291776657,
0.15131108462810516,
0.2645094692707062,
0.3588438630104065,
0.2563278079032898,
-0.7997660636901855,
0.3859168589115143,
-0.2785654067993164,
-0.4081072509288788,
-0.3923718333244324,
0.10695143789052963,
0.2267197221517563,
0.1550585776567459,
0.6951310634613037,
-0.16736117005348206,
0.2054416537284851,
-0.5829991102218628,
0.2506788372993469,
0.592126190662384,
-0.4354955852031708,
-0.09549267590045929,
0.7968090772628784,
-0.08386159688234329,
-0.2994846999645233,
0.7913767099380493,
0.13503548502922058,
-0.44375503063201904,
0.6179717183113098,
0.7118388414382935,
0.391206830739975,
-0.07008879631757736,
0.3259466588497162,
0.34379303455352783,
0.13514180481433868,
-0.46638086438179016,
0.20937418937683105,
0.17162153124809265,
-0.6618378162384033,
-0.0974946841597557,
-0.8767239451408386,
-0.6798620223999023,
-0.30333948135375977,
-0.5396156907081604,
0.21053379774093628,
-0.48438942432403564,
-0.19788213074207306,
0.30142778158187866,
0.5281786322593689,
-0.8052122592926025,
0.34300392866134644,
-0.22946858406066895,
1.2768906354904175,
-0.5740309953689575,
0.9092326164245605,
0.904737114906311,
-0.5042898058891296,
-0.5353756546974182,
-0.6583855152130127,
-0.09926143288612366,
-0.6899450421333313,
1.154263973236084,
-0.21114595234394073,
-0.09957308322191238,
0.42680031061172485,
-0.39609846472740173,
-0.8367582559585571,
1.2061837911605835,
0.24906182289123535,
-0.7483009099960327,
0.02374197170138359,
-0.326681911945343,
0.8042933940887451,
-0.18161380290985107,
0.6412412524223328,
0.3397297263145447,
0.5785340070724487,
0.06300626695156097,
-0.8411370515823364,
-0.06799789518117905,
-0.2875935435295105,
0.03481758013367653,
0.35867375135421753,
-0.6874879598617554,
0.7711799740791321,
0.045308567583560944,
-0.2355859875679016,
-0.17220787703990936,
0.4473288357257843,
0.2515547573566437,
0.41773006319999695,
0.21710920333862305,
0.8023744225502014,
1.0021775960922241,
-0.09191612899303436,
1.309747338294983,
-0.580314576625824,
0.41904452443122864,
0.9241165518760681,
-0.41542676091194153,
1.0143229961395264,
0.45502567291259766,
-0.0648069977760315,
0.5056539177894592,
0.39105913043022156,
-0.10039716958999634,
0.40869250893592834,
0.022815871983766556,
-0.3714568018913269,
-0.35963374376296997,
-0.25266072154045105,
-0.2976720333099365,
0.3449621796607971,
0.5525643825531006,
-0.6481969356536865,
-0.2618229389190674,
0.1463792771100998,
-0.17911547422409058,
0.34961339831352234,
-0.207924947142601,
0.8501689434051514,
0.38344883918762207,
-0.591938316822052,
0.5390563011169434,
0.10655172169208527,
0.4649401605129242,
-0.6397387385368347,
0.1459839642047882,
-0.18551094830036163,
0.4097698926925659,
-0.06298413872718811,
-0.7741011381149292,
0.030394066125154495,
-0.25758761167526245,
-0.2951761484146118,
-0.25963476300239563,
0.9622588157653809,
-0.28334081172943115,
-0.5964592695236206,
0.5992193818092346,
0.48252758383750916,
0.2533983588218689,
-0.00602831831201911,
-0.4510660171508789,
-0.005746912676841021,
-0.48270484805107117,
-0.0461723729968071,
0.5457331538200378,
0.3781161308288574,
-0.0032438926864415407,
0.9566255807876587,
0.6534420847892761,
0.19819293916225433,
-0.2151631861925125,
0.010831980966031551,
0.8043699264526367,
-0.6385142803192139,
-0.19130288064479828,
-0.4781348705291748,
-0.18020273745059967,
-0.3477826714515686,
0.04376204311847687,
0.8752790689468384,
0.7529915571212769,
0.9881404638290405,
-0.08035321533679962,
0.6313637495040894,
0.16665036976337433,
0.5179884433746338,
-0.25357139110565186,
0.7665883898735046,
-0.6275862455368042,
-0.06040550023317337,
-0.1513291895389557,
-0.9127057194709778,
-0.3894188106060028,
0.64408278465271,
-0.5236260294914246,
-0.16702230274677277,
0.7881354689598083,
0.8787997961044312,
-0.20932196080684662,
-0.13627654314041138,
0.3814254403114319,
0.22778786718845367,
0.5478546619415283,
0.43343228101730347,
0.5866504907608032,
-0.6172703504562378,
0.43339425325393677,
0.1380838006734848,
-0.20394057035446167,
-0.4136558771133423,
-0.5478941798210144,
-0.5527114272117615,
-0.5982962250709534,
-0.435590535402298,
-0.396610289812088,
0.248683899641037,
0.33711618185043335,
0.8046053051948547,
-0.5546854138374329,
-0.02011871337890625,
0.0019026994705200195,
0.12474381178617477,
-0.012682631611824036,
-0.23432162404060364,
0.45652642846107483,
-0.6170021295547485,
-0.9228820204734802,
0.4605259597301483,
0.2010086625814438,
-0.10475572198629379,
-0.18939296901226044,
-0.1550484001636505,
-0.47877609729766846,
-0.04419650509953499,
0.6030075550079346,
0.12957622110843658,
-0.3439841866493225,
-0.10393232852220535,
0.0522320382297039,
-0.5500901937484741,
-0.01700362004339695,
0.7336349487304688,
-0.7899792790412903,
0.7435302734375,
0.6263362169265747,
0.5906524658203125,
0.9993225932121277,
0.1015286073088646,
0.6539044976234436,
-0.21918703615665436,
-0.10601198673248291,
0.11247772723436356,
0.372236430644989,
0.5886319875717163,
-0.3074129819869995,
0.9062760472297668,
0.30489906668663025,
-0.7583680748939514,
-0.6485519409179688,
-0.09662438184022903,
-0.8951426148414612,
-0.5401987433433533,
0.8857336044311523,
-0.17769935727119446,
-0.4101197421550751,
-0.07728331536054611,
-0.1475612223148346,
0.38390880823135376,
-0.31926780939102173,
0.8209871053695679,
0.6844482421875,
0.35988545417785645,
-0.23002752661705017,
-0.7211599946022034,
0.2004697173833847,
0.5705972909927368,
-0.48755982518196106,
-0.27198299765586853,
0.49703341722488403,
0.4631917178630829,
0.5227119326591492,
0.6580321192741394,
-0.4991368055343628,
0.23795172572135925,
-0.019341429695487022,
-0.017724547535181046,
-0.1190050020813942,
-0.22690775990486145,
-0.44048506021499634,
0.38962554931640625,
0.409414142370224,
0.33331218361854553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11459v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11459v1
|
Du-IN: Discrete units-guided mask modeling for decoding speech from Intracranial Neural signals
| 2024-05-19T06:00:36 | 2024-05-19T06:00:36 |
Hui Zheng, Hai-Teng Wang, Wei-Bang Jiang, Zhong-Tao Chen, Li He, Pei-Yang Lin, Peng-Hu Wei, Guo-Guang Zhao, Yun-Zhe Liu
|
eess.SP
|
eess.SP, cs.CL, q-bio.NC
|
Invasive brain-computer interfaces have garnered significant attention due to
their high performance. The current intracranial stereoElectroEncephaloGraphy
(sEEG) foundation models typically build univariate representations based on a
single channel. Some of them further use Transformer to model the relationship
among channels. However, due to the locality and specificity of brain
computation, their performance on more difficult tasks, e.g., speech decoding,
which demands intricate processing in specific brain regions, is yet to be
fully investigated. We hypothesize that building multi-variate representations
within certain brain regions can better capture the specific neural processing.
To explore this hypothesis, we collect a well-annotated Chinese word-reading
sEEG dataset, targeting language-related brain networks, over 12 subjects.
Leveraging this benchmark dataset, we developed the Du-IN model that can
extract contextual embeddings from specific brain regions through discrete
codebook-guided mask modeling. Our model achieves SOTA performance on the
downstream 61-word classification task, surpassing all baseline models. Model
comparison and ablation analysis reveal that our design choices, including (i)
multi-variate representation by fusing channels in vSMC and STG regions and
(ii) self-supervision by discrete codebook-guided mask modeling, significantly
contribute to these performances. Collectively, our approach, inspired by
neuroscience findings, capitalizing on multi-variate neural representation from
specific brain regions, is suitable for invasive brain modeling. It marks a
promising neuro-inspired AI approach in BCI.
|
[
-0.380197137594223,
-0.7564887404441833,
0.42673128843307495,
0.320760577917099,
-0.3754383623600006,
-0.07005032151937485,
-0.2014349400997162,
-0.42393386363983154,
0.14194227755069733,
0.5112318992614746,
-0.577093780040741,
-0.5726840496063232,
-0.39993202686309814,
-0.00836434680968523,
-0.31317004561424255,
0.40876299142837524,
0.0964408665895462,
0.31781524419784546,
-0.35753291845321655,
0.05725923925638199,
-0.9010383486747742,
-0.7119385004043579,
-0.4296247661113739,
-0.4854198098182678,
0.45363059639930725,
0.23000679910182953,
0.27980002760887146,
0.45448973774909973,
0.4420115649700165,
0.21451066434383392,
-0.15199242532253265,
0.19026519358158112,
-0.10159134119749069,
-0.35837864875793457,
0.23701661825180054,
-0.40029600262641907,
-0.391591340303421,
-0.2176910638809204,
0.7529297471046448,
1.020163893699646,
-0.22153079509735107,
-0.32054370641708374,
0.09382159262895584,
0.3377611041069031,
-0.4761650562286377,
0.07772228866815567,
-0.20904558897018433,
-0.042675942182540894,
-0.2158908247947693,
0.03410768136382103,
-0.6509210467338562,
-0.19846464693546295,
0.2810942828655243,
-0.33686453104019165,
-0.11281098425388336,
-0.3567506670951843,
0.5299216508865356,
0.30595654249191284,
-0.2504505515098572,
-0.02410796284675598,
-0.460398405790329,
0.631327211856842,
-0.9280538558959961,
0.5237266421318054,
0.6934305429458618,
0.020856237038969994,
-0.10738682001829147,
-0.9376014471054077,
-0.5420562624931335,
-0.06424341350793839,
-0.3557165265083313,
0.25072774291038513,
-0.37482762336730957,
0.3268212080001831,
0.22842465341091156,
0.06821389496326447,
-0.6423755288124084,
0.22384127974510193,
-0.3587331771850586,
-0.15813979506492615,
0.6378548741340637,
0.04272240772843361,
0.45815879106521606,
-0.14530624449253082,
-0.41497892141342163,
0.014240005053579807,
-0.665798544883728,
0.07768592983484268,
0.188277930021286,
0.22461645305156708,
-0.2780388593673706,
0.2601239085197449,
-0.014937212690711021,
0.7590245008468628,
-0.20936819911003113,
0.1834746152162552,
0.22352971136569977,
-0.3476586639881134,
-0.255460649728775,
0.4011901319026947,
0.656080961227417,
-0.17553910613059998,
0.16654640436172485,
-0.2253115177154541,
0.03944891691207886,
0.0700632631778717,
0.3484463393688202,
-0.8234074711799622,
-0.527336835861206,
0.20557841658592224,
-0.49875155091285706,
-0.007951900362968445,
-0.15358306467533112,
-0.5086502432823181,
-0.34161704778671265,
-0.47713780403137207,
0.5354146957397461,
-0.7785991430282593,
-0.2077830284833908,
0.3815879225730896,
0.0876617431640625,
-0.0018014268716797233,
-0.009108718484640121,
-0.8260209560394287,
0.25276121497154236,
0.2291112095117569,
0.8162655234336853,
-0.30242279171943665,
-0.29217761754989624,
-0.4008024334907532,
0.03655388206243515,
-0.3760163187980652,
0.8445013761520386,
-0.7176474332809448,
-0.3850475251674652,
-0.07677623629570007,
-0.1680685132741928,
-0.0548098087310791,
-0.4405003786087036,
0.19354969263076782,
-0.6251029968261719,
-0.11048624664545059,
-0.5030115842819214,
-0.3526401221752167,
-0.3847256898880005,
-0.2680763304233551,
-0.66010582447052,
0.36362224817276,
0.04279474541544914,
-0.4875262677669525,
0.05214960128068924,
-0.9004337787628174,
-0.43499311804771423,
0.37962958216667175,
-0.49965900182724,
-0.2463352233171463,
0.20228013396263123,
0.18422192335128784,
0.2837517559528351,
-0.16826702654361725,
0.19840745627880096,
-0.05298010632395744,
-0.6635203957557678,
0.3690589666366577,
-0.6457962989807129,
1.0830211639404297,
0.1360589563846588,
-0.2938689887523651,
0.0433395653963089,
-0.6853466629981995,
0.14895512163639069,
-0.22982102632522583,
-0.27327021956443787,
-0.6328527331352234,
0.12925522029399872,
-0.19348736107349396,
-0.000989093678072095,
0.04767390713095665,
-0.6517246961593628,
0.09627539664506912,
-0.20440860092639923,
0.4985739588737488,
0.4511629641056061,
-0.1108899787068367,
0.3943651020526886,
-0.0024917793925851583,
0.2664049565792084,
0.31577029824256897,
-0.09193487465381622,
-0.3390403687953949,
-0.3534097969532013,
-0.4220464825630188,
-0.8035025000572205,
0.6877228021621704,
0.335328072309494,
-0.560739278793335,
0.3166825473308563,
-0.30985888838768005,
-0.36933428049087524,
-0.5867645144462585,
-0.5089892745018005,
0.284720778465271,
0.4512779712677002,
0.4196368455886841,
-0.5653527975082397,
-0.4455202519893646,
-1.030612587928772,
0.05622510612010956,
0.07943885028362274,
-0.2256527841091156,
0.32003167271614075,
0.06279868632555008,
-0.5844842791557312,
0.9097039103507996,
-0.44110435247421265,
-0.3889191746711731,
-0.02580607682466507,
0.31628191471099854,
0.1973772794008255,
0.4037182033061981,
0.20377665758132935,
-0.6597010493278503,
-0.309793084859848,
0.1840677112340927,
-0.9342911243438721,
-0.3309592306613922,
-0.28153514862060547,
-0.12914809584617615,
0.12930212914943695,
0.634684681892395,
-0.2853265702724457,
0.7618759870529175,
0.5229149460792542,
-0.21811115741729736,
0.34064406156539917,
-0.20843474566936493,
0.12052401155233383,
-0.5550511479377747,
-0.030262747779488564,
-0.08822477608919144,
0.11907302588224411,
-0.9996466636657715,
-0.1353098303079605,
0.4127607047557831,
0.1446455419063568,
-0.18776708841323853,
-0.03472258150577545,
-0.39161789417266846,
0.12141149491071701,
-0.41088026762008667,
0.09041056036949158,
0.05368230119347572,
0.7799744009971619,
0.4260479509830475,
0.6207541227340698,
0.673190176486969,
-0.6400612592697144,
-0.12681235373020172,
0.32212990522384644,
-0.3616694509983063,
0.43144750595092773,
-0.7186658978462219,
0.3915366232395172,
-0.12501810491085052,
0.12926237285137177,
-1.028760552406311,
0.07198838144540787,
-0.11315459758043289,
-0.32490411400794983,
0.32360950112342834,
0.0998120978474617,
-0.3713381886482239,
0.16057264804840088,
0.08849885314702988,
0.9371568560600281,
0.4207806885242462,
-0.8021243810653687,
0.9206482172012329,
0.5374816656112671,
-0.11563446372747421,
-0.4796043932437897,
-1.228386640548706,
0.03609256073832512,
-0.047140855342149734,
-0.7044145464897156,
0.8073155879974365,
-0.23967422544956207,
-0.1543443500995636,
-0.1724168360233307,
-0.12751394510269165,
-0.12896092236042023,
-0.3389253616333008,
0.2720763683319092,
0.3058510422706604,
-0.11705721914768219,
0.039469603449106216,
0.036599986255168915,
0.04648992046713829,
0.24780674278736115,
-0.14458362758159637,
0.6970154047012329,
-0.09986130893230438,
-0.3980545699596405,
-0.40618959069252014,
0.6443805694580078,
0.2931312918663025,
-0.3073415160179138,
0.40485063195228577,
0.42358309030532837,
-0.7561179399490356,
-0.27739018201828003,
-0.2888890504837036,
-0.17026148736476898,
-0.5061744451522827,
0.5674800872802734,
-0.7228586077690125,
-0.6298087239265442,
0.46086186170578003,
-0.15539680421352386,
-0.05580098181962967,
-0.017487643286585808,
0.3789389133453369,
-0.2406644970178604,
0.8283600807189941,
0.7527424097061157,
0.07025353610515594,
0.47329357266426086,
-0.4542112648487091,
0.4103117883205414,
-0.987005889415741,
-0.4351072609424591,
-0.0650913268327713,
-0.3154201805591583,
-0.2646833658218384,
-0.30883166193962097,
0.48701244592666626,
0.07555124163627625,
-0.01564696989953518,
0.4875508248806,
-0.6461434364318848,
0.4599042534828186,
0.5913324356079102,
0.2907674312591553,
0.2072231024503708,
0.21026715636253357,
-0.18589839339256287,
-0.18286935985088348,
-0.9334233403205872,
-0.11777769029140472,
0.8208255171775818,
0.27474504709243774,
0.7085257172584534,
0.018380673602223396,
0.5031814575195312,
0.2428705394268036,
0.18671134114265442,
-0.616597592830658,
0.5274673700332642,
-0.46123605966567993,
-0.06820019334554672,
-0.2917487919330597,
-0.38286805152893066,
-0.9477389454841614,
0.3252318501472473,
0.2055530995130539,
-0.8606354594230652,
0.9438052177429199,
-0.20681193470954895,
-0.6197959780693054,
0.3064085841178894,
-0.8261626362800598,
0.6804186105728149,
-0.1313401162624359,
-0.16505901515483856,
-0.3872372508049011,
-0.47044676542282104,
0.47446131706237793,
-0.28999823331832886,
0.10054050385951996,
0.414580762386322,
0.11217142641544342,
0.6523604989051819,
-0.08549007028341293,
0.9157150983810425,
0.05260792374610901,
-0.1595580279827118,
0.3446454107761383,
0.17558357119560242,
0.19078673422336578,
-0.11617597937583923,
-0.04324761778116226,
1.0932989120483398,
0.06698048114776611,
-0.07082363963127136,
-0.2974270284175873,
0.7641343474388123,
-0.8202545642852783,
-0.19868749380111694,
-0.41836270689964294,
-0.7496761679649353,
-0.14167185127735138,
0.014854039065539837,
0.42453429102897644,
0.5915775299072266,
-0.04515421390533447,
0.1844845712184906,
0.8905551433563232,
-0.29329290986061096,
0.7858362793922424,
0.32110756635665894,
0.04957250878214836,
-0.5008956789970398,
0.9219909310340881,
0.4120566248893738,
0.22005634009838104,
0.45257291197776794,
-0.07200849801301956,
-0.16199517250061035,
-0.594332218170166,
-0.1912309229373932,
0.3301831781864166,
-0.6495586633682251,
-0.24723464250564575,
-0.5715079307556152,
-0.6516562104225159,
-0.23236675560474396,
-0.07745222747325897,
-0.2856506407260895,
0.2224021703004837,
-0.3060634434223175,
0.1576019674539566,
0.04898177459836006,
0.6915017366409302,
-0.3360607624053955,
0.6227486729621887,
-0.41669848561286926,
0.4608510732650757,
0.4828701615333557,
0.6173725724220276,
-0.1778348982334137,
-0.6149632930755615,
-0.46333736181259155,
0.1980922520160675,
0.013362286612391472,
-0.9959229230880737,
0.5678329467773438,
-0.1666574776172638,
0.4765637516975403,
0.29354649782180786,
-0.027713380753993988,
0.9858293533325195,
-0.4392969012260437,
0.612742006778717,
0.12109257280826569,
-0.9702771306037903,
0.263400673866272,
-0.09082507342100143,
0.5782132744789124,
0.2938251197338104,
0.27377021312713623,
-0.553622305393219,
0.19046752154827118,
-0.37968334555625916,
-0.8169901967048645,
1.0718331336975098,
0.23800139129161835,
-0.07737976312637329,
-0.05190252512693405,
0.22458648681640625,
0.10504599660634995,
0.04647444561123848,
-0.685348391532898,
-0.38807496428489685,
-0.09033800661563873,
-0.09831967204809189,
0.20424890518188477,
-0.36557865142822266,
-0.05967338755726814,
-0.18129076063632965,
0.348326176404953,
-0.06480459868907928,
0.7019022703170776,
0.4562329947948456,
-0.007181267719715834,
0.1357015073299408,
-0.1000414714217186,
0.49531835317611694,
0.49063804745674133,
-0.13584397733211517,
0.20396018028259277,
0.34028634428977966,
-0.743186354637146,
-0.29780474305152893,
0.2748526930809021,
-0.03776803985238075,
0.2549567222595215,
0.13876298069953918,
0.6386739015579224,
-0.07651200890541077,
-0.5158034563064575,
0.3873502314090729,
-0.3920082449913025,
-0.20440877974033356,
-0.4768180251121521,
-0.19477622210979462,
0.07846730202436447,
0.316415935754776,
0.20096519589424133,
0.21229057013988495,
0.22915151715278625,
-0.3200105130672455,
0.1683976948261261,
0.4375683665275574,
-0.3306582570075989,
-0.1997433304786682,
0.5316086411476135,
-0.07556534558534622,
-0.6033847332000732,
0.7268723249435425,
0.21106797456741333,
-0.1345098465681076,
0.5625273585319519,
0.6978157162666321,
0.9519093036651611,
-0.18762415647506714,
-0.11713086068630219,
0.3761194944381714,
0.29211291670799255,
0.07304179668426514,
0.28589925169944763,
-0.25719285011291504,
-0.5624114871025085,
-0.5403769016265869,
-0.4298763573169708,
-0.16728416085243225,
0.4667941629886627,
-0.33754006028175354,
0.26245927810668945,
-0.20918120443820953,
-0.055029019713401794,
-0.0607139989733696,
-0.3553451597690582,
-0.5555075407028198,
0.3178084194660187,
0.47404053807258606,
0.7070847749710083,
-0.4985548257827759,
1.089849829673767,
0.18729031085968018,
-0.291227251291275,
-0.6280790567398071,
0.07417546957731247,
-0.37672939896583557,
-0.47192054986953735,
0.36374151706695557,
0.08534805476665497,
-0.30378487706184387,
0.028519077226519585,
-0.5395776629447937,
-0.9693043231964111,
1.0210044384002686,
0.47166162729263306,
-0.7358304858207703,
0.16146399080753326,
0.3617119789123535,
0.34382960200309753,
-0.5029562711715698,
0.3414633274078369,
0.7558963894844055,
0.21774347126483917,
-0.25780409574508667,
-0.7386671900749207,
-0.04913423955440521,
-0.3226117789745331,
0.1385924518108368,
-0.13135212659835815,
-0.48743635416030884,
0.8332199454307556,
0.0597788542509079,
-0.3609059154987335,
-0.13641703128814697,
0.6719492077827454,
0.4832878112792969,
0.24312393367290497,
0.4057055711746216,
0.20471864938735962,
0.6172602772712708,
-0.13574205338954926,
0.891704261302948,
-0.14767159521579742,
-0.33555692434310913,
1.0572175979614258,
0.22665992379188538,
0.7968500852584839,
0.45245224237442017,
-0.009448240511119366,
0.7913892865180969,
0.43670645356178284,
0.23559905588626862,
0.8630973696708679,
0.28216880559921265,
-0.44752970337867737,
-0.22164158523082733,
-0.08799070864915848,
-0.31518828868865967,
0.5253321528434753,
0.5224331021308899,
-0.3465079367160797,
0.16346803307533264,
0.11887168139219284,
-0.307375431060791,
0.028570353984832764,
-0.25867483019828796,
0.6512306332588196,
0.2472100704908371,
-0.6403204202651978,
0.6005702018737793,
0.02012542076408863,
0.8137190341949463,
-0.9539538621902466,
-0.2892058193683624,
-0.37853237986564636,
0.05914553999900818,
-0.14301171898841858,
-0.4387529492378235,
0.1673220992088318,
-0.1727919578552246,
-0.18599402904510498,
-0.18169806897640228,
0.5150576829910278,
-0.6602907776832581,
-0.21555347740650177,
0.3523097336292267,
0.16643257439136505,
0.3993884027004242,
-0.24358220398426056,
-0.1862819939851761,
0.22449561953544617,
0.06972986459732056,
-0.0701291412115097,
0.3215499818325043,
0.34025850892066956,
-0.21188795566558838,
0.3217822313308716,
0.5633206367492676,
0.052361346781253815,
0.10075460374355316,
0.402964323759079,
0.6953713893890381,
-0.6374163031578064,
-0.5681828260421753,
-0.971767246723175,
0.7145395874977112,
-0.040366146713495255,
-0.07675047218799591,
0.4790601432323456,
0.4173198640346527,
0.7993568181991577,
0.06172402575612068,
0.879698634147644,
0.0388835147023201,
-0.05526689440011978,
-0.18715469539165497,
0.7782559990882874,
-0.36504849791526794,
0.3630855083465576,
-0.15971919894218445,
-0.6123603582382202,
-0.46773919463157654,
0.776275098323822,
-0.2886923849582672,
0.07962857186794281,
0.7904110550880432,
0.9083760976791382,
-0.03337281197309494,
0.33118128776550293,
0.6110477447509766,
0.20123380422592163,
0.1847318410873413,
0.6981903314590454,
0.6078982949256897,
-0.4691237807273865,
0.6183525323867798,
-0.3122837543487549,
-0.4289291799068451,
0.15839527547359467,
-0.6408922076225281,
-0.7579174637794495,
-0.657954216003418,
-0.4810985028743744,
-0.11738651990890503,
-0.19009087979793549,
0.48800912499427795,
0.8569868206977844,
-0.6311127543449402,
-0.3568812608718872,
-0.26551902294158936,
-0.1169322058558464,
-0.4606080651283264,
-0.14262966811656952,
0.697515606880188,
-0.21899254620075226,
-0.7020512223243713,
0.7177208662033081,
0.377821683883667,
-0.14145226776599884,
-0.3299271762371063,
-0.007929647341370583,
-0.20966479182243347,
0.2798852324485779,
0.7077081799507141,
0.12732936441898346,
-0.5840756893157959,
-0.043376315385103226,
0.11833731085062027,
-0.1749822050333023,
0.048994988203048706,
0.5653114914894104,
-1.1229219436645508,
0.6682031750679016,
0.5293653011322021,
0.7451213002204895,
0.6074298620223999,
-0.17322473227977753,
0.5880699753761292,
-0.7376647591590881,
-0.19537575542926788,
0.20600932836532593,
0.4575287401676178,
0.17075291275978088,
-0.5345842242240906,
0.42750322818756104,
0.030768664553761482,
-0.5818125605583191,
-0.8550059199333191,
0.21922676265239716,
-1.1125707626342773,
-0.5446222424507141,
1.1301380395889282,
-0.05542449280619621,
-0.31212514638900757,
-0.18910790979862213,
-0.36251020431518555,
0.21153376996517181,
-0.03394535183906555,
0.998616099357605,
0.5738177299499512,
-0.3893383741378784,
-0.146900936961174,
-0.25883248448371887,
0.2971322536468506,
0.47670939564704895,
-0.6582077741622925,
0.21301011741161346,
0.4772365987300873,
0.0676557868719101,
0.3407929837703705,
0.7467944025993347,
-0.3239316940307617,
0.5486301779747009,
0.2860959470272064,
0.26769503951072693,
-0.1407514065504074,
-0.427909255027771,
-0.6680028438568115,
0.28199154138565063,
-0.4597935676574707,
-0.6336639523506165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11446v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11446v1
|
MAML-en-LLM: Model Agnostic Meta-Training of LLMs for Improved In-Context Learning
| 2024-05-19T04:49:42 | 2024-05-19T04:49:42 |
Sanchit Sinha, Yuguang Yue, Victor Soto, Mayank Kulkarni, Jianhua Lu, Aidong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Adapting large language models (LLMs) to unseen tasks with in-context
training samples without fine-tuning remains an important research problem. To
learn a robust LLM that adapts well to unseen tasks, multiple meta-training
approaches have been proposed such as MetaICL and MetaICT, which involve
meta-training pre-trained LLMs on a wide variety of diverse tasks. These
meta-training approaches essentially perform in-context multi-task fine-tuning
and evaluate on a disjointed test set of tasks. Even though they achieve
impressive performance, their goal is never to compute a truly general set of
parameters. In this paper, we propose MAML-en-LLM, a novel method for
meta-training LLMs, which can learn truly generalizable parameters that not
only perform well on disjointed tasks but also adapts to unseen tasks. We see
an average increase of 2% on unseen domains in the performance while a massive
4% improvement on adaptation performance. Furthermore, we demonstrate that
MAML-en-LLM outperforms baselines in settings with limited amount of training
data on both seen and unseen domains by an average of 2%. Finally, we discuss
the effects of type of tasks, optimizers and task complexity, an avenue barely
explored in meta-training literature. Exhaustive experiments across 7 task
settings along with two data settings demonstrate that models trained with
MAML-en-LLM outperform SOTA meta-training approaches.
|
[
-0.44051891565322876,
-0.8003369569778442,
0.5419780611991882,
0.07591757923364639,
-0.4181496798992157,
-0.026354389265179634,
-0.39986541867256165,
-0.2151937335729599,
-0.0061506833881139755,
0.37566861510276794,
-0.8814488649368286,
-0.6081027388572693,
-0.7470791935920715,
0.272341251373291,
-0.018063507974147797,
0.758242130279541,
-0.1444316804409027,
0.16662292182445526,
-0.35043802857398987,
-0.36514583230018616,
-0.4526377320289612,
-0.3873864412307739,
-0.46336203813552856,
-0.1126028373837471,
0.2598630487918854,
0.46093305945396423,
0.20960190892219543,
0.4469011425971985,
0.2038271427154541,
0.2036888152360916,
0.292123019695282,
0.8415895700454712,
-0.42285415530204773,
0.011601670645177364,
-0.2797686457633972,
-0.4041800796985626,
-0.6319790482521057,
0.07968238741159439,
0.777243435382843,
0.6372456550598145,
-0.11124622076749802,
0.4313099980354309,
0.5955468416213989,
0.5925809144973755,
-0.9453635215759277,
0.07772739976644516,
-1.0356913805007935,
0.07636042684316635,
-0.032367780804634094,
-0.451736181974411,
-0.48284196853637695,
0.18163293600082397,
-0.08092387765645981,
-0.8149959444999695,
0.040633395314216614,
-0.03942197933793068,
0.5454109907150269,
0.4946913421154022,
-0.44968584179878235,
-0.34691452980041504,
-0.8445264101028442,
0.8462623953819275,
-0.7256006002426147,
0.39163267612457275,
0.23211871087551117,
0.3976210057735443,
-0.2563990354537964,
-0.4242461025714874,
-0.3942524194717407,
-0.11417952179908752,
0.062802754342556,
0.23640474677085876,
0.10232381522655487,
0.07783883064985275,
0.20345473289489746,
0.2084047496318817,
-0.43586573004722595,
0.041079651564359665,
0.19519469141960144,
0.04242979735136032,
0.37222909927368164,
0.2902832627296448,
0.24934837222099304,
0.4422599673271179,
-0.42594701051712036,
0.25299862027168274,
-0.8915069699287415,
-0.00777435302734375,
0.1172635406255722,
0.3817729949951172,
-0.20481306314468384,
0.37713533639907837,
-0.17197540402412415,
1.0107769966125488,
0.15461888909339905,
-0.4475960433483124,
0.09566473960876465,
-0.2116984724998474,
-0.30671489238739014,
-0.3546951413154602,
0.5302047729492188,
0.12184153497219086,
0.2147393524646759,
-0.2818552851676941,
-0.24901840090751648,
-0.15931445360183716,
0.1432623416185379,
-0.7882248163223267,
0.05118769034743309,
-0.10916633903980255,
-0.2311962991952896,
0.026838475838303566,
-0.08908955752849579,
-0.419711172580719,
-0.17719019949436188,
-0.4167570471763611,
0.9353821277618408,
-0.22137005627155304,
-0.09810624271631241,
0.16299396753311157,
0.25257450342178345,
0.21377839148044586,
0.5312453508377075,
-0.9078292846679688,
0.44643181562423706,
0.5288400053977966,
0.8588131666183472,
-0.25240054726600647,
-0.5187819004058838,
-0.7904282808303833,
0.35017257928848267,
-0.17116492986679077,
0.477313369512558,
-0.7993091940879822,
-0.3048330247402191,
-0.23876141011714935,
0.07017957419157028,
-0.5149202942848206,
-0.537738025188446,
0.3249049186706543,
-0.33007481694221497,
0.18740102648735046,
-0.15253207087516785,
-0.5146085619926453,
-0.16794945299625397,
0.5331550240516663,
-0.3346032202243805,
0.832892119884491,
0.049130164086818695,
-0.5809386968612671,
0.47872817516326904,
-0.9524275660514832,
-0.37185075879096985,
-0.2512013614177704,
-0.058659330010414124,
-0.2569652497768402,
0.1965862661600113,
0.3486410677433014,
0.6880708932876587,
-0.31451180577278137,
0.12118351459503174,
-0.3446710705757141,
-0.38842591643333435,
0.06407777965068817,
-0.5742560625076294,
0.4272303283214569,
-0.02524370141327381,
-0.4421672821044922,
0.06264668703079224,
-0.8496203422546387,
0.015936171635985374,
0.09227167814970016,
-0.7449236512184143,
-0.3164653480052948,
-0.0036276322789490223,
-0.2900312542915344,
0.26096057891845703,
0.22509078681468964,
-0.4774019718170166,
0.3209933340549469,
-0.6782433390617371,
0.36202046275138855,
0.629845917224884,
-0.11215117573738098,
0.5697762370109558,
-0.1944362074136734,
0.38018256425857544,
-0.1429680436849594,
0.12809190154075623,
-0.08910922706127167,
-0.2896774113178253,
-1.088377594947815,
-0.43916547298431396,
0.30768266320228577,
0.49398568272590637,
-0.7475189566612244,
0.2995970845222473,
-0.2678047716617584,
-0.364120215177536,
-0.6496878862380981,
0.2614225745201111,
0.42528435587882996,
0.5884616374969482,
0.565036416053772,
-0.2554665803909302,
-0.353497713804245,
-0.7031449675559998,
-0.5803313851356506,
0.3608695864677429,
-0.1213662400841713,
0.5364603996276855,
0.5311075448989868,
-0.4617573916912079,
0.6574880480766296,
-0.2682288885116577,
-0.3038524091243744,
-0.05839996412396431,
0.013577562756836414,
0.28195613622665405,
0.2998383045196533,
0.39450758695602417,
-0.49246999621391296,
-0.8259236812591553,
0.03394254297018051,
-0.5732950568199158,
-0.04140092432498932,
-0.02345217391848564,
0.004935197997838259,
0.16885927319526672,
0.4585760533809662,
-0.5036118626594543,
0.06265045702457428,
0.6491970419883728,
-0.14619843661785126,
0.31609296798706055,
-0.4478968381881714,
-0.08361533284187317,
-1.0765284299850464,
0.16961343586444855,
-0.37692683935165405,
-0.44883430004119873,
-0.8036409020423889,
0.2655092775821686,
0.26810508966445923,
0.023612091317772865,
-0.5486593842506409,
0.8355227112770081,
-0.7904381155967712,
-0.0688665360212326,
-0.5974257588386536,
-0.16973599791526794,
-0.04971291497349739,
0.6771628260612488,
0.024423694238066673,
0.8033075332641602,
1.012085199356079,
-0.8547885417938232,
-0.03351328521966934,
0.10033398121595383,
-0.09697850048542023,
0.4291626811027527,
-0.18339429795742035,
0.39252835512161255,
-0.038924627006053925,
0.14403897523880005,
-0.824108362197876,
-0.07903364300727844,
0.4342665374279022,
-0.2775862216949463,
0.4974628686904907,
-0.18969468772411346,
-0.3239210844039917,
-0.012674706056714058,
-0.1400163322687149,
0.4326817989349365,
0.25243300199508667,
-0.6260679364204407,
1.1018140316009521,
0.15413498878479004,
0.24526342749595642,
-0.9462223052978516,
-0.48674386739730835,
-0.009894691407680511,
-0.2651110589504242,
-0.14569640159606934,
0.3025108277797699,
-0.20728784799575806,
0.0761316791176796,
-0.1759815812110901,
-0.37587833404541016,
0.01013216096907854,
0.4841439723968506,
0.374894380569458,
-0.08721580356359482,
-0.18455110490322113,
0.05818812921643257,
0.027657920494675636,
-0.14961566030979156,
0.027911372482776642,
-0.4925781190395355,
0.5338026285171509,
-0.2501465976238251,
-0.6739320755004883,
-0.0001923269737744704,
0.07025384902954102,
0.6017166376113892,
-0.34610143303871155,
0.8318833708763123,
0.6468492150306702,
-0.3888818025588989,
-0.6585075259208679,
-0.3945808708667755,
-0.06357384473085403,
-0.5120686292648315,
0.426114022731781,
-0.47216713428497314,
-1.0070009231567383,
0.30473771691322327,
-0.4094458520412445,
0.3134358823299408,
0.362070232629776,
0.6204986572265625,
-0.11955525726079941,
0.7746623754501343,
0.7444582581520081,
-0.09379998594522476,
0.0833907201886177,
-0.10760974884033203,
-0.1314307004213333,
-0.9081999063491821,
-0.08485811203718185,
-0.17050082981586456,
-0.461127370595932,
-0.21073000133037567,
-0.6487693190574646,
0.48050686717033386,
-0.047410547733306885,
-0.14727574586868286,
0.1181555986404419,
-0.20714780688285828,
0.6306683421134949,
0.3358566164970398,
0.33925333619117737,
0.3274064362049103,
-0.23325113952159882,
-0.18656013906002045,
0.21886718273162842,
-0.7606291770935059,
-0.291482150554657,
1.4726676940917969,
0.12879401445388794,
0.5683049559593201,
-0.014007782563567162,
0.5557376146316528,
0.10866544395685196,
0.45076683163642883,
-0.633339524269104,
0.5142987370491028,
-0.24257472157478333,
-0.5092239379882812,
-0.45066773891448975,
-0.21223141252994537,
-0.8025924563407898,
0.5782897472381592,
-0.46215593814849854,
-0.3038029968738556,
-0.09051323682069778,
0.2808721363544464,
-0.1948600858449936,
0.45945149660110474,
-0.4044688642024994,
0.6655421257019043,
-0.3749356269836426,
-0.19906766712665558,
-0.1867649406194687,
-0.6291606426239014,
0.30462363362312317,
-0.49246376752853394,
0.5100364089012146,
-0.36715370416641235,
-0.4362054467201233,
0.3813815414905548,
-0.20720942318439484,
1.031994342803955,
-0.40712785720825195,
-0.13815024495124817,
0.1261846423149109,
0.17471154034137726,
0.7073104977607727,
0.08073094487190247,
0.03943554311990738,
0.06462196260690689,
-0.37513554096221924,
-0.3977012634277344,
-0.6644530892372131,
0.5585256218910217,
-0.6340159773826599,
-0.8422735333442688,
-0.07680114358663559,
-0.7893393635749817,
-0.6315053701400757,
0.3131009042263031,
0.28017961978912354,
0.4218883514404297,
-0.3092174828052521,
0.02978670410811901,
0.6944170594215393,
-0.21835605800151825,
0.37231284379959106,
0.9784160256385803,
0.08901120722293854,
-0.27140945196151733,
0.7497056126594543,
-0.07186867296695709,
0.5274795889854431,
0.7682612538337708,
0.12975823879241943,
-0.10144520550966263,
-0.8220129609107971,
-0.49068862199783325,
0.1127525046467781,
-0.7670225501060486,
-0.13984334468841553,
-0.7565550208091736,
-0.14100514352321625,
0.045195065438747406,
-0.0990380272269249,
-0.4072574973106384,
-0.14626795053482056,
-0.5255842208862305,
0.0871315449476242,
-0.031204141676425934,
0.3205533027648926,
0.08826465159654617,
0.22279636561870575,
-0.6743545532226562,
0.3736599385738373,
0.5159956812858582,
0.3236686587333679,
-0.04479023441672325,
-0.9550350904464722,
-0.3585403561592102,
0.21030904352664948,
-0.11111391335725784,
-0.47890424728393555,
0.21451635658740997,
0.9156235456466675,
0.6779287457466125,
0.3200361728668213,
-0.0730065181851387,
0.6899868845939636,
-0.8687272667884827,
0.3726050853729248,
-0.0007541447994299233,
-0.9629034399986267,
0.4333488643169403,
-0.3651778995990753,
0.44124850630760193,
0.6822801232337952,
0.5540393590927124,
-0.20430809259414673,
-0.34563031792640686,
-0.23401495814323425,
-0.5244306325912476,
0.5223087668418884,
-0.01923958770930767,
0.39476120471954346,
0.2896499037742615,
0.537501871585846,
0.4841771125793457,
0.1551729142665863,
-0.8273885250091553,
-0.3426918387413025,
-0.03767720237374306,
-0.11976832151412964,
-0.3523409068584442,
-0.18688277900218964,
-0.15350046753883362,
-0.48445212841033936,
0.4933334290981293,
-0.4890037477016449,
0.11175060272216797,
-0.0030186849180608988,
-0.5760077834129333,
-0.07372547686100006,
0.29112520813941956,
0.7470388412475586,
0.8256122469902039,
-0.11257471144199371,
0.39044153690338135,
0.9113395810127258,
-0.4514688551425934,
0.29513847827911377,
-0.2674815356731415,
0.08420295268297195,
-0.032081153243780136,
0.42963144183158875,
0.8366725444793701,
0.3867872357368469,
-0.5930437445640564,
0.6254187226295471,
0.05598590523004532,
-0.5130970478057861,
-0.09070637822151184,
0.5098700523376465,
0.2695118486881256,
0.3692767024040222,
0.27750107645988464,
0.2917827069759369,
0.09758604317903519,
-0.5213950872421265,
0.16205555200576782,
0.7496232390403748,
-0.3306320309638977,
-0.4668912887573242,
0.6940674781799316,
0.24530747532844543,
-0.17502351105213165,
-0.05496542155742645,
-0.009298576042056084,
-0.21651841700077057,
0.28440606594085693,
0.7218608260154724,
0.8994212746620178,
-0.43446993827819824,
-0.055559512227773666,
0.251415878534317,
0.3949134647846222,
-0.13993848860263824,
0.15121661126613617,
-0.20542357861995697,
-0.7977792024612427,
-0.43519169092178345,
-0.7816685438156128,
-0.48713019490242004,
0.30053427815437317,
-0.40096136927604675,
0.34846004843711853,
-0.5168640613555908,
0.09489073604345322,
-0.3333222568035126,
-0.25052377581596375,
-0.8016620874404907,
0.31367090344429016,
0.010267985984683037,
0.9620224237442017,
-0.8171598315238953,
0.8831307291984558,
0.7221475839614868,
0.27614232897758484,
-0.4303046762943268,
0.15045712888240814,
-0.14601178467273712,
-1.1114422082901,
0.16607555747032166,
0.22070033848285675,
-0.3151555061340332,
0.3238600194454193,
-0.3709992468357086,
-1.0281976461410522,
1.2548024654388428,
0.6612723469734192,
-0.5145940780639648,
0.16110123693943024,
0.4085591435432434,
0.44666001200675964,
-0.6145403385162354,
0.14140324294567108,
0.3761843144893646,
0.4716406464576721,
-0.19167183339595795,
-1.0257929563522339,
0.11015044897794724,
-0.17301590740680695,
-0.2944529056549072,
0.15620467066764832,
-0.6585471630096436,
0.6993507742881775,
-0.08986269682645798,
-0.3439689576625824,
-0.16662578284740448,
0.39386963844299316,
0.11829405277967453,
0.22737835347652435,
0.5878925919532776,
0.4526546597480774,
0.7534918189048767,
0.10451208055019379,
0.6952461004257202,
-0.24835985898971558,
0.2715969979763031,
1.2138837575912476,
-0.24872468411922455,
0.7569791674613953,
0.38250109553337097,
-0.014889487996697426,
0.22423623502254486,
0.5280230641365051,
-0.028119588270783424,
0.7327612042427063,
0.05160383880138397,
-0.31383758783340454,
-0.5149565935134888,
0.20524534583091736,
-0.3251032829284668,
0.42902180552482605,
0.4109979271888733,
-0.22405947744846344,
-0.3771442770957947,
0.35037028789520264,
-0.2621181607246399,
-0.019772114232182503,
-0.5315796732902527,
0.8453094363212585,
0.26937687397003174,
-0.260816752910614,
0.839798092842102,
0.10174718499183655,
0.9638093113899231,
-0.5887143611907959,
0.10195352137088776,
-0.03271559253334999,
0.014565368182957172,
-0.12102451920509338,
-0.35283997654914856,
0.37232688069343567,
-0.027872513979673386,
-0.16574856638908386,
-0.17823752760887146,
1.0173994302749634,
-0.46333882212638855,
-0.4117419719696045,
0.30740949511528015,
0.7740470767021179,
-0.019520023837685585,
-0.34983375668525696,
-0.6697424054145813,
-0.42445072531700134,
-0.10477351397275925,
-0.21865202486515045,
0.6136348247528076,
0.5182978510856628,
0.2499500960111618,
0.847399890422821,
0.5246781706809998,
-0.1485133171081543,
-0.08904850482940674,
-0.3102303147315979,
0.8717462420463562,
-0.49154654145240784,
-0.3094960153102875,
-1.2146567106246948,
0.48588860034942627,
0.4451447129249573,
-0.2300914078950882,
0.8215780258178711,
0.5398775935173035,
0.9514155387878418,
-0.3962148129940033,
0.703316867351532,
0.41909605264663696,
0.5066964030265808,
-0.7826586365699768,
0.6874488592147827,
-0.8831456899642944,
0.23347055912017822,
-0.04866644740104675,
-1.1435507535934448,
-0.2767607271671295,
0.16394995152950287,
-0.165017232298851,
0.07404254376888275,
0.4945182800292969,
0.6014474034309387,
-0.4084392786026001,
-0.3745584785938263,
0.5272507071495056,
0.017131023108959198,
-0.0010905396193265915,
0.7192926406860352,
0.8306326270103455,
-0.19073258340358734,
0.3802541196346283,
0.13530179858207703,
-0.10273607820272446,
-0.34287965297698975,
-0.8642449975013733,
-1.196599006652832,
-0.4800143241882324,
-0.00021416945673990995,
0.15015269815921783,
0.18334776163101196,
0.7785316109657288,
0.720679759979248,
-0.7990449070930481,
-0.0727938637137413,
-0.09288781136274338,
-0.08203715085983276,
-0.2648301422595978,
-0.07107602059841156,
0.2629590630531311,
-0.32416319847106934,
-0.632645845413208,
0.7471432089805603,
0.45422881841659546,
-0.07624304294586182,
-0.04472004994750023,
-0.31174546480178833,
0.012868701480329037,
0.13098794221878052,
0.6023557782173157,
0.08794673532247543,
-0.7282209396362305,
-0.19388717412948608,
-0.014509148895740509,
0.04599251225590706,
0.15948604047298431,
0.5252471566200256,
-0.46847882866859436,
0.33724159002304077,
0.12384362518787384,
0.8642951250076294,
0.5388610363006592,
-0.03688479959964752,
0.5542481541633606,
-0.9747040867805481,
0.11783377081155777,
0.06892814487218857,
0.2633587121963501,
0.12738583981990814,
-0.27574780583381653,
0.5224939584732056,
0.14156684279441833,
-0.32351675629615784,
-0.802950382232666,
0.19674056768417358,
-0.6914552450180054,
-0.4393276274204254,
1.203680396080017,
-0.12928299605846405,
-0.06004877761006355,
-0.04092986509203911,
-0.010687935166060925,
0.20290371775627136,
0.06486133486032486,
0.6754045486450195,
0.6084635257720947,
0.010650231502950191,
-0.07400339096784592,
-0.6805623769760132,
0.5368978381156921,
0.4494447708129883,
-0.8907694220542908,
0.04568237066268921,
-0.004433768335729837,
0.5751887559890747,
-0.2736698389053345,
0.5522943139076233,
0.16825896501541138,
0.13485319912433624,
-0.30574676394462585,
-0.05631900206208229,
-0.4701592028141022,
-0.532017171382904,
-0.42466461658477783,
0.07232015579938889,
0.2831760048866272,
-0.270193487405777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11441v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11441v1
|
EmbSum: Leveraging the Summarization Capabilities of Large Language Models for Content-Based Recommendations
| 2024-05-19T04:31:54 | 2024-05-19T04:31:54 |
Chiyu Zhang, Yifei Sun, Minghao Wu, Jun Chen, Jie Lei, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed, Rong Jin, Angli Liu, Ji Zhu, Sem Park, Ning Yao, Bo Long
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Content-based recommendation systems play a crucial role in delivering
personalized content to users in the digital world. In this work, we introduce
EmbSum, a novel framework that enables offline pre-computations of users and
candidate items while capturing the interactions within the user engagement
history. By utilizing the pretrained encoder-decoder model and poly-attention
layers, EmbSum derives User Poly-Embedding (UPE) and Content Poly-Embedding
(CPE) to calculate relevance scores between users and candidate items. EmbSum
actively learns the long user engagement histories by generating user-interest
summary with supervision from large language model (LLM). The effectiveness of
EmbSum is validated on two datasets from different domains, surpassing
state-of-the-art (SoTA) methods with higher accuracy and fewer parameters.
Additionally, the model's ability to generate summaries of user interests
serves as a valuable by-product, enhancing its usefulness for personalized
content recommendations.
|
[
-0.6150370836257935,
-0.6910571455955505,
0.7291579246520996,
-0.09781200438737869,
-0.125154510140419,
-0.026236433535814285,
-0.39096421003341675,
0.1388224959373474,
0.8052670955657959,
0.6115874648094177,
-0.46842482686042786,
-0.6898137331008911,
-0.3792778253555298,
-0.22836090624332428,
-0.29963263869285583,
1.2552214860916138,
0.0708950012922287,
-0.3539092540740967,
-0.5497511029243469,
0.04298848658800125,
-0.49748507142066956,
-0.397106796503067,
-0.21827207505702972,
-0.0876271203160286,
0.6590685248374939,
0.6334839463233948,
0.44167596101760864,
0.2832221984863281,
0.3531506657600403,
0.19524477422237396,
-0.06992127746343613,
0.4365335702896118,
-0.8157520294189453,
0.2803577184677124,
-0.27839937806129456,
-0.29007813334465027,
-0.697688639163971,
-0.4667379558086395,
0.3353652358055115,
0.5259091854095459,
-0.4526715576648712,
0.32528018951416016,
0.09276080131530762,
0.519995391368866,
-0.790533721446991,
0.04549398645758629,
-0.13579565286636353,
-0.19204431772232056,
-0.24291281402111053,
-0.4188773036003113,
-0.6036628484725952,
-0.42790716886520386,
0.40745216608047485,
-0.584419310092926,
-0.13190315663814545,
0.2036922723054886,
0.5658270120620728,
-0.0762915387749672,
-0.4046310782432556,
-0.5229923129081726,
-0.6926345825195312,
0.6975270509719849,
-0.6169086694717407,
0.42302918434143066,
0.8236823081970215,
0.31422489881515503,
-0.02555844560265541,
-0.8074228167533875,
-0.13591548800468445,
0.01944425143301487,
-0.0587971955537796,
0.22451232373714447,
0.07278570532798767,
-0.10053539276123047,
0.04091864451766014,
0.48454684019088745,
-0.5192887783050537,
-0.2505643963813782,
-0.13569851219654083,
0.1727726310491562,
0.436781644821167,
0.24000205099582672,
0.16853316128253937,
0.1242208182811737,
0.033973485231399536,
0.05135359615087509,
-0.6963688135147095,
0.18227560818195343,
0.2675039768218994,
0.13402971625328064,
-0.4173409640789032,
0.6846338510513306,
-0.28440552949905396,
0.7883974313735962,
0.23651716113090515,
0.01860068365931511,
-0.04047452658414841,
-0.4530722200870514,
-0.04299004748463631,
-0.033466488122940063,
0.5161740779876709,
0.34482309222221375,
0.23507733643054962,
-0.27283453941345215,
0.13880141079425812,
-0.2847302556037903,
0.1608245074748993,
-1.0822514295578003,
-0.31609681248664856,
0.2594180703163147,
-0.5865721702575684,
-0.021013835445046425,
0.4535563886165619,
-0.8153920769691467,
-0.41983044147491455,
-0.13732151687145233,
0.27909088134765625,
-0.08966385573148727,
-0.03195897117257118,
0.15824533998966217,
0.14955919981002808,
-0.44833090901374817,
0.19243644177913666,
-0.9301608800888062,
0.404351145029068,
0.43275323510169983,
0.8374069929122925,
-0.09069051593542099,
-0.14312335848808289,
-0.5718463659286499,
0.4812878668308258,
0.10564494132995605,
0.931219220161438,
-0.8781722784042358,
-0.3294878900051117,
0.2645851969718933,
-0.02073833905160427,
0.28866082429885864,
-0.24065935611724854,
0.14517460763454437,
-0.6372082233428955,
0.06736975908279419,
-0.44601333141326904,
-0.7785891890525818,
-0.40335991978645325,
0.18213053047657013,
-0.5253286361694336,
0.803290605545044,
0.12289786338806152,
-0.610037088394165,
0.35108208656311035,
-0.6235816478729248,
-0.4874016344547272,
-0.03076455183327198,
-0.07973439246416092,
-0.46889209747314453,
0.26092612743377686,
0.33491984009742737,
0.745445728302002,
-0.35741540789604187,
0.3677143454551697,
-0.695431113243103,
-0.5226340293884277,
-0.06197184696793556,
0.18403853476047516,
0.24066784977912903,
0.14197638630867004,
0.12925197184085846,
0.08340489119291306,
-0.4679712951183319,
-0.39135193824768066,
0.07780557125806808,
-0.12075485289096832,
-0.45129159092903137,
0.2976734936237335,
0.07524193078279495,
0.1405852884054184,
0.5415838360786438,
-0.6341707706451416,
0.027274928987026215,
-0.26571762561798096,
0.1718229353427887,
0.3677312731742859,
0.24777008593082428,
0.40836185216903687,
-0.49646759033203125,
0.4886593520641327,
-0.1311982423067093,
-0.1917368471622467,
-0.9683367013931274,
-0.3010771572589874,
-0.41897931694984436,
-0.30061888694763184,
0.3547377288341522,
0.15901266038417816,
-0.3820030689239502,
0.7480669617652893,
-0.426140695810318,
-0.6594833135604858,
-0.057953573763370514,
0.3310307264328003,
0.06489095091819763,
-0.09486761689186096,
0.3221149444580078,
-0.4093272387981415,
-0.591952383518219,
-0.3105657696723938,
0.006437363103032112,
-0.14717522263526917,
-0.1673056036233902,
0.7600449323654175,
0.036749955266714096,
-0.5901718735694885,
1.1963765621185303,
-0.8758296370506287,
-0.7425792217254639,
-0.5736265778541565,
0.11970417201519012,
0.3725247085094452,
0.04605779051780701,
0.4341316521167755,
-0.543056309223175,
-0.6267328858375549,
0.0713663101196289,
-0.6183993816375732,
-0.282180517911911,
-0.23777221143245697,
-0.16559474170207977,
-0.09301294386386871,
0.30121925473213196,
-0.10618463158607483,
0.3237871825695038,
0.7072593569755554,
-0.5140022039413452,
-0.020527655258774757,
-0.5438662767410278,
0.3866167664527893,
-1.3221901655197144,
0.09527567028999329,
0.09966662526130676,
-0.4613300561904907,
-0.19214600324630737,
-0.45259103178977966,
0.0391535609960556,
-0.20070284605026245,
-0.23599183559417725,
0.5066407918930054,
-0.26700475811958313,
-0.11244402825832367,
-0.27261772751808167,
0.3626154065132141,
0.1606193631887436,
0.5694248676300049,
0.13937580585479736,
0.13537196815013885,
0.2748551070690155,
-0.7737919092178345,
0.29335010051727295,
0.5598829984664917,
-0.2321188896894455,
0.3183615207672119,
-0.5165541768074036,
0.06709747761487961,
0.059347279369831085,
0.2684085965156555,
-1.039969563484192,
-0.11505813151597977,
-0.205215722322464,
-0.21128574013710022,
0.15919438004493713,
-0.16514207422733307,
-0.4315747320652008,
0.17617593705654144,
-0.6120553612709045,
0.6424081325531006,
0.3431206941604614,
-0.4852420687675476,
1.0752180814743042,
0.7091445326805115,
-0.5296918749809265,
-0.09129475802183151,
-0.4139814078807831,
-0.03784358873963356,
0.05432666838169098,
-0.5532864928245544,
0.7280340790748596,
-0.3340182900428772,
0.026359718292951584,
0.1498076170682907,
0.2744410037994385,
0.07272745668888092,
-0.009130480699241161,
0.4644516110420227,
0.02518373541533947,
0.0764179453253746,
0.08337544649839401,
0.2708733379840851,
0.04045142978429794,
-0.2405398190021515,
-0.01621268130838871,
0.791467010974884,
0.10360358655452728,
-0.4939289689064026,
-0.11218582838773727,
0.3840840756893158,
0.40231454372406006,
-0.3730964660644531,
0.5792168974876404,
0.5721423029899597,
-0.28946325182914734,
-0.059763550758361816,
-0.6785659790039062,
-0.24285146594047546,
-0.45553335547447205,
0.6333811283111572,
-0.18269160389900208,
-1.0382027626037598,
0.5741285681724548,
0.06954648345708847,
0.25069722533226013,
0.136831596493721,
1.0105074644088745,
-0.14508381485939026,
1.0727474689483643,
0.6389607191085815,
-0.0630531907081604,
0.8240061402320862,
-0.17344215512275696,
0.1688472032546997,
-0.745850682258606,
-0.38938218355178833,
-0.03192698583006859,
-0.1287008672952652,
-0.4435948431491852,
0.03864253684878349,
0.07347844541072845,
-0.1751735657453537,
0.0015961327590048313,
0.35692843794822693,
-0.018002362921833992,
0.3754355013370514,
0.3201742172241211,
0.268624871969223,
0.29533764719963074,
-0.08928894251585007,
0.08252382278442383,
-0.10627873986959457,
-0.5074630379676819,
-0.33871906995773315,
1.1979963779449463,
0.3370867967605591,
1.1607588529586792,
0.3469501733779907,
0.6241576075553894,
0.9274723529815674,
0.22436869144439697,
-0.8188176155090332,
0.40343502163887024,
-0.27862972021102905,
-0.5168237090110779,
-0.0948823094367981,
-0.2609938383102417,
-0.8857460021972656,
-0.005861659534275532,
-0.3704676032066345,
-0.5840250849723816,
-0.10494399070739746,
0.2534686028957367,
-0.654484212398529,
0.2360735386610031,
-0.4888732135295868,
0.7564272284507751,
-0.4564973711967468,
-0.5517475008964539,
-0.5585836172103882,
-0.19692164659500122,
-0.01967010460793972,
-0.23367533087730408,
0.2420024424791336,
0.03363993763923645,
0.08131793141365051,
0.8055564761161804,
-0.013092584908008575,
0.6817749738693237,
0.003987941890954971,
0.034972816705703735,
0.25134360790252686,
0.45832526683807373,
0.3846718370914459,
0.2590748965740204,
0.176815003156662,
0.1537948101758957,
0.04451283812522888,
-0.09640137106180191,
-0.5144931077957153,
0.8108444809913635,
-0.5057645440101624,
-0.32832756638526917,
-0.3707495629787445,
-0.4298884868621826,
-0.01463087648153305,
0.3257698714733124,
-0.09792167693376541,
0.7541507482528687,
-0.4388008415699005,
0.5704700946807861,
0.414705365896225,
-0.3229091167449951,
0.29222366213798523,
0.6949362754821777,
-0.5453757047653198,
-0.6161757111549377,
1.174491047859192,
0.11402418464422226,
-0.21331696212291718,
0.6028470396995544,
0.0863073542714119,
-0.3484610915184021,
-0.43078696727752686,
-0.2871888279914856,
0.4060105085372925,
-0.6087994575500488,
-0.018239717930555344,
-0.862325131893158,
0.41107481718063354,
-0.38389188051223755,
-0.4572198987007141,
-0.22248448431491852,
0.11346856504678726,
-0.3320791721343994,
0.00461202347651124,
0.046069979667663574,
1.0398060083389282,
0.27875226736068726,
0.41561639308929443,
-1.008250117301941,
0.2615559697151184,
0.11581314355134964,
0.4624824821949005,
-0.11385773122310638,
-0.6240224242210388,
-0.9324924349784851,
-0.10466758161783218,
-0.40863871574401855,
-0.8554342985153198,
0.439914733171463,
0.3251730501651764,
0.6143529415130615,
0.9818766117095947,
0.2388625293970108,
0.3765338063240051,
-0.40034016966819763,
0.6281305551528931,
-0.05891498178243637,
-0.9543468356132507,
0.5032176375389099,
-0.4799010455608368,
0.33489322662353516,
0.6437145471572876,
0.39791983366012573,
-0.5651423335075378,
-0.05627906322479248,
-0.3556956648826599,
-0.8487622737884521,
0.7806427478790283,
-0.07563041150569916,
-0.03509601205587387,
0.021995022892951965,
0.1781347244977951,
0.24279578030109406,
0.1609569936990738,
-0.3518896698951721,
-0.09490466862916946,
0.05302473530173302,
-0.5463829040527344,
-0.24689152836799622,
-0.6367453336715698,
0.20768941938877106,
0.09824813902378082,
0.8222136497497559,
-0.0606280118227005,
0.025882380083203316,
-0.01681610196828842,
-0.6276431679725647,
-0.0048128715716302395,
-0.035095781087875366,
0.3598484694957733,
0.9955102801322937,
-0.6710396409034729,
-0.15516297519207,
0.27093371748924255,
-0.2887842655181885,
-0.0454501211643219,
-0.09135659784078598,
0.07812211662530899,
-0.0863160490989685,
0.02596745640039444,
0.4373730719089508,
0.4996036887168884,
-0.9492982625961304,
0.6631575226783752,
-0.5189787745475769,
0.3216816782951355,
-0.5775440335273743,
-0.4062156081199646,
0.10915503650903702,
0.0010704490123316646,
-0.006813033949583769,
-0.24022796750068665,
0.3279123902320862,
-0.4736053943634033,
0.34252867102622986,
0.06330887973308563,
-0.5569936633110046,
-0.5736070871353149,
0.304031640291214,
0.47768834233283997,
-0.0630386546254158,
0.16745929419994354,
0.23339393734931946,
-0.2354842573404312,
0.12448178976774216,
0.5383296012878418,
0.7387601733207703,
-0.06878038495779037,
0.18559537827968597,
0.26275619864463806,
-0.1623256951570511,
-0.04006076604127884,
0.0715751200914383,
-0.516252875328064,
-0.6239776611328125,
-0.3634621500968933,
-0.5872386693954468,
-0.7386666536331177,
-0.4124765992164612,
-1.0031455755233765,
0.7169667482376099,
-0.4465705156326294,
-0.30466848611831665,
-0.1875259429216385,
-0.13442036509513855,
-0.5291295051574707,
0.1491234451532364,
0.37120482325553894,
0.49733349680900574,
-0.9042897820472717,
0.4957568049430847,
1.0004693269729614,
-0.421586811542511,
-0.232161745429039,
-0.0738135278224945,
-0.26962509751319885,
-0.16788415610790253,
0.18759785592556,
0.17231382429599762,
-0.2624785006046295,
0.08935871720314026,
0.20018605887889862,
-0.7558268308639526,
1.071593999862671,
0.47137051820755005,
-0.38160407543182373,
0.05881050229072571,
-0.23539608716964722,
0.37299346923828125,
-0.5803824067115784,
1.0139195919036865,
0.35177916288375854,
0.16484186053276062,
-0.08124423772096634,
-0.5642831325531006,
0.04231296852231026,
-0.2440796196460724,
-0.23411785066127777,
0.26899710297584534,
-0.5995239019393921,
0.6574633121490479,
-0.32290521264076233,
-0.12168188393115997,
-0.17427240312099457,
0.6714080572128296,
0.37143418192863464,
0.40423905849456787,
0.3114582598209381,
0.5047767162322998,
0.2705734372138977,
0.08326104283332825,
1.1638728380203247,
-0.43786144256591797,
0.3956691026687622,
1.0700095891952515,
-0.3477838337421417,
0.8994201421737671,
0.14640794694423676,
-0.026665085926651955,
0.9203658103942871,
0.8380274772644043,
-0.00925355777144432,
0.7326115965843201,
-0.2755175828933716,
0.013342389836907387,
-0.3904085159301758,
-0.33652642369270325,
-0.3102222979068756,
0.27243858575820923,
0.4133125841617584,
-0.5421159267425537,
-0.1200232282280922,
-0.1759064644575119,
-0.03951973095536232,
0.15859390795230865,
-0.31111404299736023,
1.1608643531799316,
0.11889886856079102,
-0.6703066825866699,
0.0186125710606575,
0.10461211204528809,
0.7315506339073181,
-0.8668944239616394,
-0.11162228137254715,
-0.08891797810792923,
0.38400304317474365,
-0.3749926686286926,
-0.6402750611305237,
0.01824083738029003,
0.01609385758638382,
-0.4408070743083954,
-0.06889703124761581,
0.5516756772994995,
-0.5590415596961975,
-0.3338330388069153,
0.5299928188323975,
0.4679289758205414,
-0.03182794153690338,
-0.11532354354858398,
-0.00273779290728271,
-0.17956551909446716,
-0.03082834929227829,
-0.36973538994789124,
0.3927939236164093,
0.0971137061715126,
0.08783218264579773,
0.6348507404327393,
0.6606842279434204,
0.2505042552947998,
-0.23697367310523987,
0.21511772274971008,
0.6914254426956177,
-0.6949973702430725,
-1.1898537874221802,
-0.9816617369651794,
0.3160339891910553,
0.12415183335542679,
-0.11263393610715866,
0.8287481665611267,
0.6853126883506775,
0.9701269865036011,
-0.016416123136878014,
0.8758093118667603,
-0.12113071978092194,
0.4308660328388214,
-0.3103347420692444,
0.6853607296943665,
-0.7706462740898132,
0.4395183324813843,
-0.16450418531894684,
-1.1439566612243652,
-0.0885762870311737,
0.1998169720172882,
-0.3832036256790161,
0.40035656094551086,
0.5643871426582336,
0.6373282074928284,
-0.24031956493854523,
-0.10549209266901016,
0.5020677447319031,
-0.0974588394165039,
0.34501126408576965,
0.4930032789707184,
0.5819215178489685,
-0.07016108930110931,
0.5685590505599976,
-0.02167993225157261,
-0.23944668471813202,
-0.5761681795120239,
-0.80776447057724,
-1.2318789958953857,
-0.5356780290603638,
-0.17842648923397064,
-0.2573612928390503,
0.04850265011191368,
1.439581274986267,
0.8785287737846375,
-1.1615231037139893,
-0.5238475203514099,
0.33470994234085083,
-0.09047622233629227,
0.006507083773612976,
-0.11841011792421341,
0.5136085748672485,
0.17200307548046112,
-0.6649551391601562,
0.24861690402030945,
0.47976449131965637,
-0.16004715859889984,
-0.32513704895973206,
-0.35171061754226685,
-0.07312299311161041,
0.0729072093963623,
0.556210994720459,
0.17642857134342194,
-0.45075589418411255,
0.21797147393226624,
-0.06618349254131317,
0.127559095621109,
-0.2361987978219986,
0.976833701133728,
-0.6044164299964905,
0.7613139152526855,
0.9426077604293823,
0.7978453040122986,
0.906262993812561,
0.3481629192829132,
0.8556027412414551,
-0.7471847534179688,
-0.16181176900863647,
0.1363377869129181,
0.7947598695755005,
0.3344740569591522,
-0.40447086095809937,
0.16422750055789948,
-0.12778785824775696,
-0.5034999847412109,
-0.78974449634552,
0.0666927918791771,
-0.9997325539588928,
0.03936288505792618,
1.2177565097808838,
-0.6280015707015991,
0.07126600295305252,
-0.27892136573791504,
-0.3101629316806793,
0.2897584140300751,
-0.65343177318573,
0.8239483833312988,
0.4214819669723511,
0.08252400159835815,
-0.058087125420570374,
-0.17708337306976318,
0.06253734230995178,
0.5461893677711487,
-0.8095914721488953,
-0.013574212789535522,
0.26432761549949646,
0.12016957998275757,
0.03422360122203827,
0.45592692494392395,
-0.028956981375813484,
0.3158324360847473,
-0.39443543553352356,
0.17998410761356354,
-0.6329435110092163,
-0.5224399566650391,
-0.09617612510919571,
0.3497859835624695,
0.018086759373545647,
0.0899302139878273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11430v1
|
MHPP: Exploring the Capabilities and Limitations of Language Models Beyond Basic Code Generation
| 2024-05-19T03:08:02 | 2024-05-19T03:08:02 |
Jianbo Dai, Jianqiao Lu, Yunlong Feng, Rongju Ruan, Ming Cheng, Haochen Tan, Zhijiang Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have greatly improved
code generation, specifically at the function level. For instance, GPT-4 has
achieved an 88.4% pass rate on HumanEval. However, this draws into question the
adequacy of existing benchmarks in thoroughly assessing function-level code
generation capabilities. Our study analyzed two common benchmarks, HumanEval
and MBPP, and found that these might not thoroughly evaluate LLMs' code
generation capacities due to limitations in quality, difficulty, and
granularity. To resolve this, we introduce the Mostly Hard Python Problems
(MHPP) dataset, consisting of 140 unique human-curated problems. By focusing on
the combination of natural language and code reasoning, MHPP gauges LLMs'
abilities to comprehend specifications and restrictions, engage in multi-step
reasoning, and apply coding knowledge effectively. Initial evaluations of 22
LLMs using MHPP showed many high-performing models on HumanEval failed to
achieve similar success on MHPP. Moreover, MHPP highlighted various previously
undiscovered limitations within various LLMs, leading us to believe that it
could pave the way for a better understanding of LLMs' capabilities and
limitations. Dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/SparksofAGI/MHPP.
|
[
-0.357993483543396,
-0.5061455368995667,
0.5756500959396362,
0.2638927698135376,
0.16174906492233276,
-0.05795814469456673,
-0.2813988924026489,
-0.40305039286613464,
-0.35959160327911377,
0.5228942036628723,
-0.4245002865791321,
-0.23902778327465057,
-0.48809072375297546,
0.4730975925922394,
-0.0026315043214708567,
0.9010789394378662,
0.09039855003356934,
-0.1376895308494568,
-0.36447620391845703,
0.13047660887241364,
-0.19362801313400269,
-0.8664302229881287,
-0.18585534393787384,
-0.5149842500686646,
0.43498432636260986,
0.382869154214859,
0.7794755697250366,
0.728648841381073,
0.746877908706665,
0.2250606119632721,
0.03645847365260124,
0.14001576602458954,
-0.22486308217048645,
0.11574280261993408,
0.03394704312086105,
-0.21661829948425293,
-0.33070945739746094,
-0.10624561458826065,
0.686031699180603,
0.7401553392410278,
-0.15962035953998566,
0.0864708423614502,
0.12932996451854706,
0.6327413320541382,
-0.6474591493606567,
0.33026909828186035,
-0.7087336778640747,
0.033651966601610184,
-0.21598926186561584,
-0.15783315896987915,
-0.26616597175598145,
-0.10928032547235489,
-0.1981748789548874,
-0.23240360617637634,
0.06990405917167664,
-0.09465832263231277,
0.5915936827659607,
0.3350912034511566,
-0.4538637399673462,
-0.2847173511981964,
-0.49236997961997986,
0.9337893128395081,
-0.8546953797340393,
0.2144235223531723,
0.4123867452144623,
0.19304950535297394,
-0.509154200553894,
-0.6762478351593018,
-0.5929715633392334,
-0.49073001742362976,
0.39976435899734497,
-0.5394651293754578,
-0.3734414875507355,
0.10566733777523041,
0.7492418885231018,
0.4753255844116211,
-0.6537936925888062,
0.10479214787483215,
-0.27819758653640747,
-0.38692110776901245,
0.6851485967636108,
0.3868502974510193,
0.24597546458244324,
-0.5704547762870789,
-0.12191835045814514,
-0.1299341768026352,
-0.7646571397781372,
0.29288437962532043,
0.39989128708839417,
0.29701393842697144,
-0.03068584017455578,
0.7199021577835083,
-0.3526085317134857,
0.7934482097625732,
-0.5786189436912537,
-0.15721775591373444,
0.22891585528850555,
-0.29943710565567017,
-0.20195609331130981,
-0.542063295841217,
0.6930067539215088,
0.21689069271087646,
0.3866601288318634,
0.139450803399086,
-0.3419862389564514,
-0.03171680122613907,
0.2639487683773041,
-0.856050431728363,
-0.172295942902565,
0.4279719591140747,
-0.5151693820953369,
-0.3390296697616577,
-0.3229602575302124,
-0.5334949493408203,
-0.49607181549072266,
-0.20316316187381744,
0.13506141304969788,
-0.3287791311740875,
-0.48195570707321167,
0.17569902539253235,
-0.18665370345115662,
0.3435010015964508,
0.06751422584056854,
-1.047561764717102,
0.10624805837869644,
1.024400234222412,
0.8533965945243835,
-0.03249233588576317,
-0.5296037197113037,
-0.5196151733398438,
-0.1369711309671402,
-0.16812413930892944,
0.7427717447280884,
-0.5797246694564819,
-0.28313589096069336,
0.11125370860099792,
-0.23349273204803467,
0.10835950821638107,
-0.7042238116264343,
0.6333722472190857,
-0.1539996713399887,
-0.2813325524330139,
-0.3878660798072815,
-0.5054728984832764,
0.09465062618255615,
0.2776441276073456,
-0.4533289968967438,
0.7690997123718262,
0.4429444670677185,
-0.8954415321350098,
0.2983400523662567,
-0.3764861822128296,
-0.45312777161598206,
0.07579133659601212,
-0.41516366600990295,
-0.25888487696647644,
0.2207152247428894,
0.08612728863954544,
0.5502889752388,
-0.35455140471458435,
0.33437952399253845,
-0.5406135320663452,
-0.3164249062538147,
0.21137012541294098,
-0.32672759890556335,
0.7859482169151306,
0.43831050395965576,
-0.06906485557556152,
0.10092859715223312,
-0.7709924578666687,
0.25766438245773315,
0.23503826558589935,
-0.8145133256912231,
-0.05231992527842522,
0.1793752759695053,
0.16812215745449066,
0.3554891347885132,
0.16457976400852203,
-0.3422306776046753,
0.626071035861969,
-0.31886938214302063,
0.8192928433418274,
0.7283086180686951,
-0.14924700558185577,
0.1356274038553238,
-0.6985272169113159,
0.574255645275116,
-0.3747841715812683,
0.08644840866327286,
-0.2821856439113617,
-0.8903599381446838,
-0.3202913999557495,
-0.006545926444232464,
0.09780967235565186,
0.4965541362762451,
-0.681156575679779,
0.33191657066345215,
-0.04484499990940094,
-0.406272292137146,
-0.39502206444740295,
0.37149912118911743,
0.3889933228492737,
0.5207587480545044,
0.3225117325782776,
-0.2415023148059845,
-0.4531202018260956,
-1.014321208000183,
-0.2517116367816925,
-0.3354710042476654,
-0.32956644892692566,
0.38830167055130005,
0.6119349002838135,
-0.47159096598625183,
0.6766533255577087,
-0.3370852470397949,
0.10003525763750076,
-0.369797945022583,
0.16657297313213348,
0.46069878339767456,
0.6499013304710388,
0.23034259676933289,
-0.5776436924934387,
-0.045696649700403214,
-0.17728440463542938,
-0.5985445380210876,
-0.4245253801345825,
-0.008358759805560112,
0.1303277611732483,
0.23540621995925903,
0.2113177329301834,
-0.6331061720848083,
0.11446791142225266,
0.6606032252311707,
-0.11266657710075378,
1.0753132104873657,
-0.42650073766708374,
0.06839212030172348,
-0.7067321538925171,
0.061736490577459335,
0.06570340692996979,
0.08350347727537155,
-0.6323193907737732,
0.37526798248291016,
0.19879916310310364,
-0.38399142026901245,
-0.43608441948890686,
0.3937189280986786,
-0.30002352595329285,
-0.21667823195457458,
-0.3638618588447571,
-0.43512099981307983,
-0.097227543592453,
0.5526138544082642,
0.10655135661363602,
0.7187163233757019,
0.4978232681751251,
-0.5870038270950317,
0.45096081495285034,
0.03035304695367813,
-0.26662659645080566,
0.1304224133491516,
-0.7206189036369324,
0.2376372516155243,
0.22858789563179016,
0.049074698239564896,
-0.7645682692527771,
-0.47005364298820496,
-0.003696595085784793,
-0.22479258477687836,
0.23844334483146667,
-0.3953394293785095,
-0.8078104853630066,
-0.5153026580810547,
-0.4069421887397766,
0.3733867406845093,
0.700167715549469,
-0.27958980202674866,
0.050462089478969574,
0.34155702590942383,
-0.2663423717021942,
-0.5478397011756897,
-0.5075838565826416,
0.2526129186153412,
-0.09326430410146713,
-0.8724062442779541,
0.1757984757423401,
-0.09207281470298767,
-0.3065352141857147,
-0.47116637229919434,
-0.10599420964717865,
-0.1357124298810959,
0.011569575406610966,
0.1972532719373703,
-0.20020608603954315,
-0.228040412068367,
0.059969738125801086,
0.02269599214196205,
-0.2697482407093048,
0.2037479132413864,
-0.06037821248173714,
0.6456815004348755,
-0.51552414894104,
-0.5021656155586243,
-0.243757426738739,
0.3293260335922241,
0.44398581981658936,
-0.2250681072473526,
0.2773776650428772,
0.3303748667240143,
-0.4021948575973511,
-0.24713066220283508,
-0.4838245213031769,
0.023094110190868378,
-0.48411235213279724,
0.3297809064388275,
-0.504353404045105,
-0.7810710668563843,
0.3108455538749695,
-0.07558584958314896,
0.1009802594780922,
0.2068171501159668,
0.6994441747665405,
0.013296900317072868,
1.039535403251648,
0.6118398904800415,
-0.09445425868034363,
0.1446375846862793,
-0.14518480002880096,
-0.09246053546667099,
-0.7605840563774109,
-0.06461352854967117,
-0.7236360311508179,
-0.07112671434879303,
-0.9333910942077637,
-0.6281209588050842,
0.224856436252594,
0.10364162176847458,
-0.322870135307312,
0.2687748074531555,
-0.6160157322883606,
0.3975510597229004,
0.6803776025772095,
-0.056528240442276,
0.41324567794799805,
-0.0010630033211782575,
-0.06541114300489426,
-0.17766737937927246,
-0.7242404818534851,
-0.6570106148719788,
1.4206278324127197,
0.5042405724525452,
0.8555867671966553,
-0.06826519221067429,
0.7120149731636047,
0.417410671710968,
0.12919950485229492,
-0.6628193259239197,
0.4869290590286255,
0.08442048728466034,
-0.533750593662262,
-0.23297947645187378,
-0.7256886959075928,
-0.9536092877388,
0.28685247898101807,
-0.19871211051940918,
-0.5521844029426575,
-0.06942713260650635,
0.08439922332763672,
-0.18645162880420685,
0.23104910552501678,
-0.5619065761566162,
0.8743190765380859,
-0.23476000130176544,
-0.5024763941764832,
-0.1069180816411972,
-0.5548931956291199,
0.46755337715148926,
-0.1314212530851364,
0.30518361926078796,
-0.31386998295783997,
-0.026464371010661125,
0.4935528337955475,
-0.5284141898155212,
0.5460706353187561,
-0.10298348218202591,
-0.23474249243736267,
0.27457043528556824,
0.06296642869710922,
0.2726038098335266,
0.009204487316310406,
-0.35184404253959656,
0.18020321428775787,
0.18570372462272644,
-0.5782260894775391,
-0.2852988839149475,
0.6597592830657959,
-0.5111724138259888,
-0.574133574962616,
-0.35755330324172974,
-0.717765212059021,
-0.2676299214363098,
0.37954193353652954,
0.16910403966903687,
0.5091681480407715,
0.12041332572698593,
0.08950965106487274,
0.3142537474632263,
-0.5222902894020081,
0.38644152879714966,
0.2870209515094757,
-0.2778230905532837,
-0.21628087759017944,
1.0097532272338867,
-0.033352043479681015,
0.12522557377815247,
0.1360279768705368,
0.46384021639823914,
-0.32411399483680725,
-0.818798303604126,
-0.37289881706237793,
0.16891193389892578,
-0.6628284454345703,
-0.19087354838848114,
-0.4027153551578522,
-0.0879550650715828,
-0.3934928774833679,
-0.03330952301621437,
-0.11416870355606079,
-0.43107402324676514,
-0.003544732229784131,
0.297049880027771,
-0.04816459119319916,
0.8905359506607056,
-0.2486809492111206,
0.047203510999679565,
-0.8610485196113586,
0.3820519745349884,
0.3260355293750763,
0.31597089767456055,
-0.194069966673851,
-0.3275916874408722,
-0.030024521052837372,
0.00924934446811676,
-0.6475401520729065,
-0.9507573843002319,
0.3072536885738373,
0.06718605756759644,
0.5836678147315979,
0.32856690883636475,
0.17733332514762878,
0.3645901679992676,
-0.427444189786911,
0.6437960863113403,
-0.020869038999080658,
-0.9651920795440674,
0.6494834423065186,
-0.6822079420089722,
0.20974290370941162,
0.34966856241226196,
0.26500919461250305,
-0.38178709149360657,
-0.5266548991203308,
-0.656319797039032,
-0.46147072315216064,
0.3793368339538574,
0.3729734420776367,
0.1539282649755478,
0.07944020628929138,
0.5640261173248291,
-0.02993503399193287,
0.3719335198402405,
-0.8930163383483887,
0.1088109239935875,
-0.022214829921722412,
0.08515922725200653,
-0.042852867394685745,
-0.2116149514913559,
0.10696830600500107,
-0.34909918904304504,
0.2648426294326782,
-0.16159126162528992,
0.2062562257051468,
0.09631180763244629,
-0.08532081544399261,
-0.16036957502365112,
0.49405723810195923,
0.679065465927124,
0.8455003499984741,
-0.3487319350242615,
0.16061003506183624,
-0.012861199676990509,
-0.31107091903686523,
0.19266164302825928,
0.12350146472454071,
0.09931106120347977,
-0.34381750226020813,
0.7752071022987366,
0.16837626695632935,
-0.05760781466960907,
-0.8926728367805481,
0.56401526927948,
0.10698947310447693,
-0.28935909271240234,
0.0855066254734993,
0.3768267035484314,
0.03986727073788643,
0.24902908504009247,
0.3864303529262543,
-0.10845665633678436,
0.18635745346546173,
-0.45867711305618286,
0.43530064821243286,
0.4796489179134369,
0.03184662014245987,
-0.16652032732963562,
0.5917916893959045,
0.3073360025882721,
-0.4178634285926819,
0.8927236199378967,
-0.228934645652771,
-0.3653814196586609,
0.8963497877120972,
0.6187458038330078,
0.5514980554580688,
-0.05966704338788986,
-0.011436098255217075,
0.3058743178844452,
0.5540668368339539,
-0.06508665531873703,
0.49655967950820923,
-0.2254425436258316,
-0.5907905101776123,
-0.8028017282485962,
-0.6808982491493225,
-0.6923484206199646,
0.3798905909061432,
-0.5754572153091431,
0.19138744473457336,
-0.6008981466293335,
-0.24504102766513824,
-0.06684819608926773,
0.30481475591659546,
-0.47525128722190857,
-0.13301537930965424,
0.34994012117385864,
1.0119802951812744,
-0.883926272392273,
0.8738707304000854,
0.6289129257202148,
-0.48495012521743774,
-0.6591989398002625,
0.010670281015336514,
-0.05383523926138878,
-0.8826664090156555,
0.4617083966732025,
0.4186963737010956,
0.11399123072624207,
-0.10699403285980225,
-0.6876245737075806,
-0.3396361470222473,
0.6935809254646301,
0.4690427780151367,
-0.46394869685173035,
-0.15146823227405548,
0.36068016290664673,
0.5514302253723145,
-0.2949385643005371,
0.03993888571858406,
0.7070231437683105,
0.5157391428947449,
-0.2077283263206482,
-1.0733416080474854,
0.05158863961696625,
-0.3943423330783844,
0.0557132288813591,
0.04638241231441498,
-0.3930652141571045,
1.033323049545288,
-0.6409333348274231,
0.14416807889938354,
0.06693632900714874,
0.35581061244010925,
0.7384382486343384,
0.44885018467903137,
0.1840425580739975,
0.46784189343452454,
0.6077918410301208,
-0.09022583067417145,
1.279428243637085,
-0.14909765124320984,
0.3896632194519043,
0.7399349212646484,
-0.32911360263824463,
0.9968243837356567,
0.5388075709342957,
-0.5557407736778259,
0.2341659814119339,
0.5520200133323669,
-0.1605396270751953,
0.2390625774860382,
0.8280909061431885,
-0.1391507089138031,
-0.5079811215400696,
-0.009494287893176079,
-0.7432573437690735,
0.42874443531036377,
0.2085426300764084,
-0.07608684152364731,
-0.205623596906662,
-0.034917883574962616,
-0.09027346968650818,
-0.10602378845214844,
-0.16293276846408844,
0.4826289117336273,
0.17039161920547485,
-0.5039238333702087,
0.8599087595939636,
0.1144535094499588,
0.680672824382782,
-0.48518356680870056,
-0.34017446637153625,
-0.18512652814388275,
0.031974028795957565,
-0.31420421600341797,
-0.9448468089103699,
0.3234696388244629,
0.15321366488933563,
-0.09083939343690872,
-0.34307003021240234,
0.8484306335449219,
0.03192763403058052,
-0.4022192656993866,
0.0735517218708992,
0.7150824666023254,
0.26457351446151733,
-0.32141730189323425,
-0.7687346339225769,
0.2552158236503601,
0.021991560235619545,
-0.25860199332237244,
0.4637978971004486,
0.3734379708766937,
0.2363944947719574,
1.021605134010315,
0.8170719146728516,
0.2067308872938156,
-0.006531279534101486,
-0.06243525445461273,
0.8185660243034363,
-0.796797513961792,
-0.3931618928909302,
-0.929560124874115,
0.241571843624115,
0.22531935572624207,
-0.34087586402893066,
0.5150542259216309,
0.46659594774246216,
0.6822546124458313,
-0.1750195026397705,
0.8841537833213806,
-0.026005206629633904,
0.40325796604156494,
-0.5258892774581909,
0.6080014705657959,
-0.6347945928573608,
0.41292136907577515,
-0.4425302743911743,
-0.7760246992111206,
-0.3634342551231384,
0.6972787380218506,
-0.2284952700138092,
0.10137275606393814,
0.4834975600242615,
0.6280186772346497,
0.04385245963931084,
-0.23216691613197327,
0.41670891642570496,
-0.1135353222489357,
0.6448684930801392,
0.979038417339325,
1.341397762298584,
-0.09618427604436874,
0.7074214220046997,
-0.4076402187347412,
-0.3242311179637909,
-0.2102103978395462,
-1.1753171682357788,
-0.7986021637916565,
-0.5271617770195007,
-0.1381276398897171,
-0.33215954899787903,
-0.24892176687717438,
0.9135785102844238,
0.695930540561676,
-0.6345275640487671,
-0.4730585813522339,
-0.24960541725158691,
0.34297454357147217,
-0.12569639086723328,
-0.17853932082653046,
0.07334854453802109,
-0.5771342515945435,
-0.513029932975769,
0.3910321593284607,
0.22619247436523438,
0.04584682732820511,
-0.28260475397109985,
-0.25989457964897156,
0.18212001025676727,
-0.07613078504800797,
0.5129984617233276,
0.5589348077774048,
-0.6032801866531372,
-0.15674994885921478,
-0.12606169283390045,
-0.18861833214759827,
0.058896396309137344,
1.142643928527832,
-0.4720419645309448,
0.34768176078796387,
0.6524685621261597,
0.6525174379348755,
0.20124611258506775,
-0.04311986267566681,
0.6388716697692871,
-0.5899044871330261,
0.09767093509435654,
0.36264294385910034,
0.45564281940460205,
0.2477850764989853,
-0.024846931919455528,
0.39837825298309326,
0.2557290494441986,
-0.8693310022354126,
-1.127145767211914,
0.40982353687286377,
-0.7414461970329285,
-0.33842942118644714,
1.3021390438079834,
0.11326293647289276,
0.10781837999820709,
-0.3697914779186249,
-0.15288779139518738,
-0.008361747488379478,
-0.25059959292411804,
0.6280243992805481,
0.7453781366348267,
-0.6526221632957458,
-0.07068729400634766,
-0.9473796486854553,
0.7360490560531616,
0.3438522517681122,
-0.9075998663902283,
0.3229503631591797,
0.6388532519340515,
0.25392571091651917,
0.11248954385519028,
0.8978612422943115,
0.07502251118421555,
0.33220627903938293,
0.1888463944196701,
0.0160354133695364,
-0.38486340641975403,
-0.3886694312095642,
-0.5250115990638733,
0.3168855607509613,
0.4804818034172058,
0.1921164095401764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11424v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11424v2
|
Metric Dimension and Resolvability of Jaccard Spaces
| 2024-05-19T02:09:50 | 2024-06-27T04:41:07 |
Manuel E. Lladser, Alexander J. Paradise
|
cs.DM
|
cs.DM, cs.CL, math.CO, math.PR, 05C12, 60C05, 68R05, 68R12, 46B85, 33D90, 68T50, G.2; G.3; E.4; G.2.1; G.2.2
|
A subset of points in a metric space is said to resolve it if each point in
the space is uniquely characterized by its distance to each point in the
subset. In particular, resolving sets can be used to represent points in
abstract metric spaces as Euclidean vectors. Importantly, due to the triangle
inequality, points close by in the space are represented as vectors with
similar coordinates, which may find applications in classification problems of
symbolic objects under suitably chosen metrics. In this manuscript, we address
the resolvability of Jaccard spaces, i.e., metric spaces of the form
$(2^X,\text{Jac})$, where $2^X$ is the power set of a finite set $X$, and
$\text{Jac}$ is the Jaccard distance between subsets of $X$. Specifically, for
different $a,b\in 2^X$, $\text{Jac}(a,b)=|a\Delta b|/|a\cup b|$, where
$|\cdot|$ denotes size (i.e., cardinality) and $\Delta$ denotes the symmetric
difference of sets. We combine probabilistic and linear algebra arguments to
construct highly likely but nearly optimal (i.e., of minimal size) resolving
sets of $(2^X,\text{Jac})$. In particular, we show that the metric dimension of
$(2^X,\text{Jac})$, i.e., the minimum size of a resolving set of this space, is
$\Theta(|X|/\ln|X|)$. In addition, we show that a much smaller subset of $2^X$
suffices to resolve, with high probability, all different pairs of subsets of
$X$ of cardinality at most $\sqrt{|X|}/\ln|X|$, up to a factor.
|
[
-0.45087626576423645,
-0.3097332715988159,
0.7627273797988892,
-0.08371049165725708,
-0.1546994298696518,
0.20302583277225494,
-0.4084266126155853,
-0.48882028460502625,
0.48584073781967163,
0.20885677635669708,
-0.12752921879291534,
-0.4222107529640198,
-0.5342585444450378,
-0.13251306116580963,
-0.3253656327724457,
0.46247410774230957,
0.016014311462640762,
-0.04691595956683159,
-0.4378441274166107,
-0.7515357732772827,
-0.7417498230934143,
-0.5478326678276062,
-0.41860291361808777,
0.23891577124595642,
0.3797990083694458,
0.48372235894203186,
1.0399949550628662,
0.584471583366394,
0.9025498628616333,
0.5227652192115784,
-0.21092770993709564,
0.16288381814956665,
-0.36229780316352844,
0.46967247128486633,
-0.23083429038524628,
-0.7600002288818359,
-0.01007241103798151,
0.011438683606684208,
1.0463225841522217,
1.0234439373016357,
-0.05072614923119545,
0.2608047127723694,
-0.08662018924951553,
0.9229198098182678,
-0.6057921051979065,
0.1830483376979828,
-0.319217711687088,
0.22137907147407532,
-0.5389025807380676,
0.06856562942266464,
-0.17088046669960022,
-0.5449140667915344,
0.08442728221416473,
-1.0214606523513794,
0.5324603319168091,
0.22150814533233643,
1.063256025314331,
0.32635244727134705,
0.01303926482796669,
0.059892088174819946,
-0.944830060005188,
0.9147151708602905,
-0.17189498245716095,
0.39658322930336,
0.41925305128097534,
0.9402122497558594,
-0.4359816014766693,
-0.6504821181297302,
-0.35894861817359924,
0.0008648096118122339,
-0.223661869764328,
0.2437436282634735,
-0.406792551279068,
-0.11036890000104904,
0.8696001172065735,
0.40838053822517395,
-0.7956757545471191,
-0.014709639362990856,
-0.6053668856620789,
0.009870114736258984,
0.599864661693573,
0.28987032175064087,
-0.056424230337142944,
-0.184968039393425,
0.048031002283096313,
-0.19258232414722443,
-0.32415294647216797,
0.364571750164032,
0.1897767335176468,
0.39225929975509644,
0.08471093326807022,
0.28148314356803894,
-0.03654525429010391,
0.5828549265861511,
0.07458007335662842,
-0.36963096261024475,
-0.039757005870342255,
-0.11293082684278488,
0.08465565741062164,
-0.40558338165283203,
0.40930843353271484,
-0.022372351959347725,
0.23309363424777985,
0.18915310502052307,
0.048569757491350174,
-0.11134101450443268,
0.3379412293434143,
-0.3726671040058136,
-0.38828837871551514,
0.06751665472984314,
-0.7454328536987305,
0.13869403302669525,
0.23754708468914032,
-0.3057699203491211,
-0.3035629689693451,
-0.35155147314071655,
0.3889716565608978,
-0.3302720785140991,
-0.2384755164384842,
0.0567549429833889,
-0.17887434363365173,
-0.06889340281486511,
0.2482934296131134,
-0.4546532928943634,
0.4511772692203522,
0.5583778023719788,
0.9013623595237732,
0.3786291778087616,
0.2877262830734253,
-0.14159376919269562,
-0.20197749137878418,
-0.6676878333091736,
0.7333950996398926,
-0.5261706709861755,
-0.635469913482666,
-0.1084708571434021,
-0.13995987176895142,
0.4475434720516205,
-0.6088072061538696,
0.5353941917419434,
-0.4049229919910431,
-0.06924490630626678,
-0.6267035007476807,
-0.278577595949173,
-0.22210532426834106,
-0.011888728477060795,
-0.7312397956848145,
0.6890501379966736,
0.47068843245506287,
-0.34395140409469604,
0.286377489566803,
-0.4661217927932739,
-0.304027795791626,
0.3035021424293518,
-0.18960370123386383,
-0.49332481622695923,
0.5873002409934998,
-0.09782755374908447,
0.32572346925735474,
-0.46697601675987244,
-0.04620404914021492,
-0.34300461411476135,
-0.09478004276752472,
0.20156750082969666,
0.06683071702718735,
0.7479150295257568,
0.39662879705429077,
0.12792357802391052,
-0.43287089467048645,
-0.8779321908950806,
0.2862343490123749,
0.2771759629249573,
-0.09005200862884521,
-0.7991214394569397,
0.1395139843225479,
-0.5100352168083191,
0.05742138624191284,
0.261125773191452,
-0.6387167572975159,
0.23730607330799103,
-0.17694495618343353,
-0.2574065923690796,
0.7300352454185486,
-0.03819914534687996,
0.3852683901786804,
-0.3307144045829773,
0.50946444272995,
0.17742067575454712,
0.2393951117992401,
0.28979557752609253,
-0.5851368308067322,
-0.8573071360588074,
-0.2115098536014557,
0.4721831679344177,
0.12627118825912476,
-0.5997893810272217,
0.30272117257118225,
-0.32915884256362915,
-0.8804646134376526,
-0.17299175262451172,
-0.32709091901779175,
0.6014054417610168,
0.09914299100637436,
0.3611404299736023,
-0.41324058175086975,
-0.5970690846443176,
-1.0219991207122803,
-0.16796261072158813,
-0.4146130084991455,
0.10158917307853699,
0.3073330521583557,
0.31510186195373535,
0.41569817066192627,
0.9931604266166687,
-0.6443270444869995,
-0.48830467462539673,
0.1533132791519165,
-0.1189182922244072,
0.4076346755027771,
0.5548797845840454,
0.7288649678230286,
-0.6830596327781677,
-0.5391108393669128,
0.2060358077287674,
-0.7256305813789368,
-0.06045885384082794,
-0.11438950151205063,
-0.15016202628612518,
-0.04496053233742714,
0.20309050381183624,
-0.18424905836582184,
0.9521358609199524,
0.37985363602638245,
-0.3038802742958069,
0.7220180630683899,
-0.36729300022125244,
0.1171831339597702,
-0.9806482195854187,
-0.008229967206716537,
0.20130383968353271,
-0.5055539608001709,
-0.4487401247024536,
0.14231549203395844,
-0.19325895607471466,
-0.22003985941410065,
-0.04628024250268936,
0.38149547576904297,
-0.5792105793952942,
-0.5983514785766602,
-0.004743198864161968,
0.3684364855289459,
-0.03695658594369888,
0.24460984766483307,
0.05610194057226181,
0.1525312066078186,
0.49376150965690613,
-0.7165817022323608,
0.5656278729438782,
0.32561561465263367,
-0.18576151132583618,
0.9566394090652466,
-0.5948997735977173,
-0.2883903980255127,
-0.16414548456668854,
0.32729533314704895,
-1.0453126430511475,
0.2264910638332367,
-0.11611076444387436,
-0.7820040583610535,
0.1881594955921173,
-0.13112497329711914,
-0.3859362304210663,
-0.4907037019729614,
-0.06818490475416183,
0.747166097164154,
0.691554605960846,
-0.7850257754325867,
0.3488212525844574,
0.27512937784194946,
0.10439585894346237,
-0.5607422590255737,
-0.6117960214614868,
-0.2100333869457245,
0.037036437541246414,
-0.5972400307655334,
0.09377600252628326,
0.04476800188422203,
-0.6829305291175842,
0.31010735034942627,
-0.06489831954240799,
0.048112060874700546,
-0.21807272732257843,
0.6360784769058228,
0.08411118388175964,
-0.32334113121032715,
0.2612018585205078,
0.20743000507354736,
-0.6507393717765808,
-0.027421530336141586,
-0.5191366672515869,
0.14476683735847473,
-0.21884700655937195,
-0.6568071246147156,
-0.163760244846344,
0.5806616544723511,
0.3623884618282318,
-0.01756715029478073,
0.6963008642196655,
0.3329661786556244,
-0.7541964650154114,
0.10141646862030029,
-0.6008567810058594,
0.06784085929393768,
-0.4894983470439911,
0.338518351316452,
-0.82184237241745,
-0.9124172329902649,
0.9477713704109192,
0.11459197849035263,
0.45001357793807983,
0.6240946650505066,
0.4770607054233551,
-0.23820972442626953,
0.7902801036834717,
0.524424135684967,
0.2580379843711853,
0.16729716956615448,
-0.5552923083305359,
0.6970863342285156,
-0.643922746181488,
-0.26242178678512573,
-1.0654845237731934,
-0.7557809948921204,
-0.9074695110321045,
-0.696915328502655,
0.45409780740737915,
0.3010742664337158,
-0.19541308283805847,
0.47369253635406494,
-0.5679962038993835,
1.0178537368774414,
0.49006128311157227,
-0.310954749584198,
0.13954709470272064,
0.042154062539339066,
-0.4136756956577301,
-0.4571804106235504,
-0.7878602743148804,
-0.14932510256767273,
0.648592472076416,
0.38104063272476196,
0.4638754427433014,
0.6087207794189453,
0.7179803848266602,
-0.011106619611382484,
-0.12438801676034927,
-0.850575864315033,
0.5435281991958618,
-0.47171536087989807,
-0.6538373827934265,
-0.35140445828437805,
-0.38185998797416687,
-1.1245681047439575,
0.21276451647281647,
0.08582384139299393,
-0.9370388388633728,
0.8520692586898804,
-0.10648863762617111,
-0.27942195534706116,
0.7536842226982117,
-0.15092973411083221,
0.28719818592071533,
0.1512576937675476,
-0.019381606951355934,
-0.718105673789978,
-0.7622990012168884,
0.2812260687351227,
0.0816102996468544,
0.06693079322576523,
-0.18223004043102264,
0.08452188223600388,
0.9150579571723938,
-0.7834005951881409,
0.384890615940094,
-0.31999310851097107,
0.36827853322029114,
0.45649534463882446,
0.7784185409545898,
0.1959526538848877,
0.2910102605819702,
0.22500579059123993,
0.36776643991470337,
0.35454675555229187,
-0.7406657338142395,
-0.8542673587799072,
0.7511104345321655,
-0.926119327545166,
-0.6438605785369873,
-0.7380877733230591,
-0.3716440200805664,
-0.1588008999824524,
-0.09560781717300415,
0.19359251856803894,
0.7411004900932312,
0.03979327157139778,
0.31625398993492126,
0.5079750418663025,
-0.10095454007387161,
0.48144853115081787,
0.3628579080104828,
-0.2298981249332428,
-0.00607364671304822,
0.7501865029335022,
0.5634359121322632,
0.1852024495601654,
0.2257823348045349,
0.22458961606025696,
-0.3900626599788666,
-0.3993324935436249,
0.13210391998291016,
0.3515624403953552,
-0.782293438911438,
-0.6849272847175598,
0.12487393617630005,
-0.5836624503135681,
0.07707604765892029,
-0.6926606893539429,
-0.5621379613876343,
-0.972733736038208,
-0.07587308436632156,
0.15796929597854614,
0.37646710872650146,
0.6849980354309082,
-0.8260188102722168,
0.18484967947006226,
-0.7640843391418457,
0.18214720487594604,
0.07295504957437515,
0.3575575649738312,
-0.07061750441789627,
-0.8330138325691223,
-0.4766210615634918,
-0.3531690239906311,
-0.1545334756374359,
-0.25892773270606995,
0.2225334644317627,
-0.08274152129888535,
0.5930494666099548,
0.7678049206733704,
0.34529945254325867,
1.122766137123108,
-0.22421956062316895,
0.9279180765151978,
0.6155128479003906,
-0.763134777545929,
0.41923147439956665,
-0.10857967287302017,
0.04766353964805603,
0.4597553312778473,
0.6310611963272095,
-0.8637829422950745,
-0.6591312885284424,
-1.1252074241638184,
-0.487896591424942,
0.14336872100830078,
0.2557867765426636,
-0.2221183180809021,
0.024231141433119774,
0.6427427530288696,
-0.06619565933942795,
-0.5576731562614441,
-0.201277956366539,
-0.41641610860824585,
0.0930834412574768,
0.23023252189159393,
0.01735549606382847,
-0.3856562077999115,
-0.20483407378196716,
-0.2663259208202362,
0.5239728093147278,
0.10234306007623672,
0.7282203435897827,
0.011768348515033722,
0.04784899950027466,
-0.06161916255950928,
-0.06976933032274246,
0.43129783868789673,
0.8739937543869019,
0.08812858909368515,
0.048851121217012405,
0.20007090270519257,
-0.44036346673965454,
0.5405521988868713,
-0.060312334448099136,
0.3972860276699066,
0.22278651595115662,
0.5292471051216125,
0.3552405834197998,
-0.19587799906730652,
0.012062995694577694,
0.22332923114299774,
-0.4184741973876953,
-0.265720397233963,
-0.6866080164909363,
0.056465260684490204,
-0.26689714193344116,
0.4373954236507416,
0.17560571432113647,
0.31470271944999695,
-0.02220894768834114,
0.08933042734861374,
-0.1406640112400055,
0.3824540376663208,
-0.30846014618873596,
-0.24638523161411285,
0.3772622048854828,
0.007953648455440998,
-0.411393404006958,
0.7840307354927063,
-0.3144446313381195,
-0.36184370517730713,
0.5460383296012878,
0.3219756782054901,
0.6464977264404297,
-0.03248032554984093,
0.01812671311199665,
0.9264318346977234,
-0.02337596006691456,
0.2652386426925659,
-0.019511578604578972,
-0.32168564200401306,
-0.7813946604728699,
-0.10515539348125458,
-0.6579791307449341,
-0.2755076587200165,
-0.34908995032310486,
-0.7986610531806946,
0.09900670498609543,
-1.1219316720962524,
-0.3714525103569031,
0.00713329529389739,
0.4455885887145996,
-0.5060033202171326,
-0.05045345053076744,
-0.1263345181941986,
0.678885817527771,
-0.7592262625694275,
0.46949177980422974,
0.424376517534256,
-0.2287410944700241,
-1.1302123069763184,
-0.3732472360134125,
0.37057963013648987,
-0.7347077131271362,
0.6997889280319214,
-0.3477499186992645,
-0.0869106724858284,
-0.4193616509437561,
-0.35716596245765686,
-1.1822880506515503,
1.0189322233200073,
0.013664674013853073,
-0.7515340447425842,
0.4182431101799011,
0.26101911067962646,
0.6852246522903442,
0.07305506616830826,
0.15094703435897827,
0.5964395999908447,
0.6133167147636414,
0.1964653730392456,
-0.9791132807731628,
0.0043452950194478035,
-0.014186197891831398,
0.7537893056869507,
0.4644549787044525,
-0.832603394985199,
0.41406598687171936,
-0.41861778497695923,
-0.2593725919723511,
0.5198726058006287,
0.92349773645401,
0.32048821449279785,
-0.33253908157348633,
0.5847671031951904,
0.8457179665565491,
0.8653084635734558,
-0.6936963200569153,
0.8993247747421265,
-0.04892783612012863,
0.6078580021858215,
0.5748175382614136,
0.167429581284523,
0.6676323413848877,
0.1891723871231079,
-0.7209033966064453,
0.6289525032043457,
0.5418682098388672,
0.1738109439611435,
0.11416896432638168,
0.526311993598938,
-0.37927481532096863,
-0.23087406158447266,
-0.08443845808506012,
-0.3628704249858856,
0.4177725613117218,
0.4854217767715454,
-0.04079374298453331,
-0.14483332633972168,
-0.26370468735694885,
-0.03391428291797638,
0.4009263813495636,
-0.2834145724773407,
0.40722838044166565,
0.07349034398794174,
-0.19338840246200562,
0.5122413635253906,
0.07340165972709656,
0.1099623292684555,
-0.5732412934303284,
0.05379925295710564,
-0.42671266198158264,
0.31659048795700073,
-0.45121246576309204,
-0.9734514355659485,
0.5341538786888123,
-0.28939348459243774,
-0.4927992820739746,
0.0879942923784256,
0.6310286521911621,
0.1289983093738556,
-0.608555018901825,
0.07706773281097412,
0.19948993623256683,
0.4563073217868805,
0.49882224202156067,
-0.41049233078956604,
-0.20322111248970032,
-0.19317518174648285,
-0.14875099062919617,
0.33912551403045654,
0.598265528678894,
-0.19536806643009186,
0.6114943623542786,
0.7064797878265381,
0.2784186601638794,
0.022810377180576324,
-0.10707151144742966,
0.5785281658172607,
-0.5274880528450012,
-0.522125244140625,
-0.3402227461338043,
0.7036190032958984,
-0.07904693484306335,
-0.3062903881072998,
0.5169022679328918,
0.38018718361854553,
0.4890560507774353,
0.013938839547336102,
0.4451849162578583,
-0.2989708483219147,
0.7596549391746521,
-0.24975493550300598,
0.3958302438259125,
-0.689780592918396,
0.023628678172826767,
-0.23649267852306366,
-0.9392273426055908,
-0.8671001195907593,
0.9712075591087341,
-0.2644397020339966,
0.04544186592102051,
0.9329767227172852,
0.7504658699035645,
0.025815894827246666,
-0.2878866195678711,
0.8916502594947815,
0.02177049033343792,
0.7514117360115051,
0.8097969889640808,
0.8530638217926025,
-0.24885672330856323,
0.3090094327926636,
-0.3137683570384979,
-0.2027108520269394,
-0.1374608874320984,
-0.459210067987442,
-0.5132808089256287,
-1.17401123046875,
-0.39276397228240967,
-0.7695997953414917,
-0.0036845384165644646,
0.6699903607368469,
0.8746664524078369,
-0.7355709075927734,
-0.007204745896160603,
0.3753325045108795,
0.23493972420692444,
-0.3634982109069824,
-0.23453979194164276,
0.4784947633743286,
-0.29023271799087524,
-0.5280229449272156,
-0.2614733874797821,
0.47539022564888,
0.050898246467113495,
-0.4530056118965149,
-0.0939214900135994,
0.20031635463237762,
-0.13370484113693237,
0.2848871052265167,
0.7752496600151062,
-0.6823332905769348,
-0.7561273574829102,
-0.47493037581443787,
0.029398208484053612,
0.15359178185462952,
0.8509905934333801,
-0.9788064360618591,
0.46938496828079224,
0.6269903182983398,
0.5086821913719177,
0.47197720408439636,
-0.13640573620796204,
0.16870926320552826,
-1.0680458545684814,
0.5066050887107849,
0.3371114730834961,
0.6939368844032288,
-0.06035822629928589,
-0.34294331073760986,
0.5797747373580933,
0.34882068634033203,
-0.7622703313827515,
-0.39987269043922424,
0.32891005277633667,
-1.216208815574646,
-0.12914302945137024,
0.8551636934280396,
-0.4506301283836365,
-0.06211187317967415,
-0.047365207225084305,
0.043662283569574356,
-0.12690141797065735,
-0.12899945676326752,
0.5109062790870667,
0.6690770387649536,
-0.45552828907966614,
-0.08050356805324554,
-0.22854439914226532,
0.17555992305278778,
0.25359979271888733,
-0.4903086721897125,
-0.0786953791975975,
0.5167379379272461,
0.1408892124891281,
0.9032076597213745,
0.28884679079055786,
-0.41113656759262085,
0.5003316402435303,
0.14246737957000732,
-0.12520518898963928,
-0.08806169033050537,
-0.6077199578285217,
-0.414055198431015,
0.13016296923160553,
0.2632678151130676,
-0.34817200899124146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11422v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11422v1
|
Large Language Models are Biased Reinforcement Learners
| 2024-05-19T01:43:52 | 2024-05-19T01:43:52 |
William M. Hayes, Nicolas Yax, Stefano Palminteri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In-context learning enables large language models (LLMs) to perform a variety
of tasks, including learning to make reward-maximizing choices in simple bandit
tasks. Given their potential use as (autonomous) decision-making agents, it is
important to understand how these models perform such reinforcement learning
(RL) tasks and the extent to which they are susceptible to biases. Motivated by
the fact that, in humans, it has been widely documented that the value of an
outcome depends on how it compares to other local outcomes, the present study
focuses on whether similar value encoding biases apply to how LLMs encode
rewarding outcomes. Results from experiments with multiple bandit tasks and
models show that LLMs exhibit behavioral signatures of a relative value bias.
Adding explicit outcome comparisons to the prompt produces opposing effects on
performance, enhancing maximization in trained choice sets but impairing
generalization to new choice sets. Computational cognitive modeling reveals
that LLM behavior is well-described by a simple RL algorithm that incorporates
relative values at the outcome encoding stage. Lastly, we present preliminary
evidence that the observed biases are not limited to fine-tuned LLMs, and that
relative value processing is detectable in the final hidden layer activations
of a raw, pretrained model. These findings have important implications for the
use of LLMs in decision-making applications.
|
[
-0.2043919861316681,
-0.5205413699150085,
0.7077630162239075,
-0.1085258275270462,
0.04196017608046532,
-0.03747492656111717,
-0.5514493584632874,
-0.4163656234741211,
0.13586585223674774,
0.6166572570800781,
-0.6418089866638184,
-0.24146723747253418,
-0.7603014707565308,
-0.06285101920366287,
-0.032721977680921555,
1.1586384773254395,
0.02587130106985569,
0.25189581513404846,
-0.2156979888677597,
-0.08848164975643158,
-0.4580499827861786,
-1.0773104429244995,
-0.7540909051895142,
-0.6678605675697327,
0.6284618377685547,
0.1188514456152916,
0.567013144493103,
0.43847787380218506,
0.02563568949699402,
0.3225615322589874,
-0.11505776643753052,
-0.07910904288291931,
-0.7178277969360352,
0.11748246103525162,
-0.3965534567832947,
-0.8024100065231323,
-0.05622856691479683,
0.39967575669288635,
0.6771787405014038,
0.4739760160446167,
-0.04240991547703743,
0.05930006876587868,
0.023376723751425743,
0.7043979167938232,
-0.7307466268539429,
0.3868793249130249,
-0.7625427842140198,
0.05561584606766701,
-0.007787900511175394,
-0.3069271445274353,
-0.6960085034370422,
-0.40680232644081116,
0.09239693731069565,
-0.4243035316467285,
-0.09155888110399246,
-0.04728251323103905,
0.7664688229560852,
0.44241219758987427,
-0.47006404399871826,
-0.5707679986953735,
-0.47507497668266296,
1.0857760906219482,
-0.5113089680671692,
0.17405492067337036,
0.5724533200263977,
0.19268234074115753,
-0.2584496736526489,
-0.18071681261062622,
-0.34065452218055725,
-0.3274294137954712,
-0.28895336389541626,
-0.07725591957569122,
0.127627894282341,
0.14717347919940948,
0.5221940279006958,
0.1441616266965866,
-0.12886402010917664,
0.2550031244754791,
-0.2852185368537903,
-0.11991811543703079,
0.4412527084350586,
0.1521269679069519,
-0.01614554040133953,
-0.16837115585803986,
-0.20283132791519165,
-0.4234500527381897,
-0.8631312251091003,
0.570246696472168,
0.5339148044586182,
0.42761820554733276,
-0.09302610903978348,
0.4317043423652649,
-0.20842893421649933,
0.7531645894050598,
0.3095831871032715,
-0.2608586251735687,
0.28442567586898804,
0.023654043674468994,
-0.2661115825176239,
0.09545885026454926,
0.47839388251304626,
0.04967023804783821,
0.544032096862793,
0.007985289208590984,
-0.6108567118644714,
0.03470718488097191,
0.4210343360900879,
-0.4813767969608307,
0.0721333846449852,
-0.03287787362933159,
-0.6346974968910217,
-0.4712955355644226,
-0.14753705263137817,
-0.25487083196640015,
-0.41175419092178345,
-0.48850512504577637,
0.5534717440605164,
-0.22415082156658173,
0.026894422248005867,
0.1721697598695755,
-0.29818424582481384,
0.4188307225704193,
0.13685153424739838,
-1.0372469425201416,
0.2793416678905487,
0.5598605275154114,
0.42923465371131897,
-0.16268177330493927,
-0.3416022062301636,
-0.9585567116737366,
-0.04085404425859451,
-0.2979504466056824,
0.562139630317688,
-0.7379274964332581,
-0.2583163380622864,
0.24618077278137207,
-0.06897309422492981,
0.086558997631073,
-0.7559185028076172,
0.5824458003044128,
-1.0372463464736938,
0.04001660272479057,
-0.6038329601287842,
-0.43626126646995544,
-0.0982377752661705,
0.21690510213375092,
-0.7250655889511108,
0.6300583481788635,
0.18976786732673645,
-0.6827973127365112,
0.8107922077178955,
-0.36952900886535645,
-0.4325190484523773,
-0.22869965434074402,
-0.35705962777137756,
-0.3063953220844269,
0.3692263960838318,
0.06556351482868195,
0.5235692858695984,
-0.17996558547019958,
0.2131585329771042,
-0.2503407597541809,
-0.5313637256622314,
0.7923033833503723,
-0.5081289410591125,
0.6125800609588623,
-0.04962815344333649,
-0.21035172045230865,
0.2246139645576477,
-0.18199419975280762,
-0.016861913725733757,
0.2449510544538498,
-0.7495461106300354,
-0.5273378491401672,
0.21664953231811523,
-0.39948228001594543,
0.47416892647743225,
0.20612739026546478,
-0.3717010021209717,
0.22978411614894867,
-0.13411110639572144,
0.26264697313308716,
1.174208402633667,
-0.15739919245243073,
0.4526703953742981,
-0.3799399137496948,
0.3982680141925812,
0.01432389859110117,
0.05445805937051773,
0.06209231913089752,
-0.10017719119787216,
-0.7642281651496887,
-0.19116894900798798,
0.30676037073135376,
0.35575181245803833,
-0.916865885257721,
0.09703164547681808,
-0.24145770072937012,
0.16808494925498962,
-0.3309740126132965,
-0.12047389149665833,
0.6175333857536316,
0.3782287836074829,
0.20991773903369904,
-0.27501019835472107,
-0.31858909130096436,
-1.0719373226165771,
-0.37494590878486633,
-0.03098190762102604,
-0.169844388961792,
0.5122273564338684,
0.389059454202652,
-0.0002808966673910618,
0.8046641945838928,
-0.41734740138053894,
-0.1797071248292923,
-0.3241006135940552,
0.039259351789951324,
0.4286787509918213,
0.20278103649616241,
0.4161478281021118,
-0.704924464225769,
-0.32140907645225525,
-0.14550873637199402,
-0.7861963510513306,
-0.06933549791574478,
-0.28148317337036133,
-0.048353951424360275,
0.21269366145133972,
0.3552672863006592,
-0.34351426362991333,
0.15503434836864471,
0.45787179470062256,
-0.37505069375038147,
0.6109879612922668,
-0.39005571603775024,
0.15026789903640747,
-0.3103686273097992,
-0.2881624102592468,
0.08981859683990479,
-0.25195467472076416,
-0.4412560760974884,
-0.10229317843914032,
0.13600172102451324,
0.5229260921478271,
-0.4129089117050171,
0.47206154465675354,
-0.3190844655036926,
-0.4530079662799835,
-0.423861563205719,
-0.043593768030405045,
-0.2115669697523117,
0.7483169436454773,
0.5983794331550598,
0.7999314665794373,
0.2875640392303467,
-0.7732359766960144,
0.177812859416008,
-0.15616223216056824,
-0.5179319381713867,
0.5561047196388245,
-0.45176586508750916,
0.04502685368061066,
-0.3351658284664154,
0.5450479388237,
-0.286603718996048,
-0.14126914739608765,
0.06521197408437729,
-0.4181644022464752,
0.36831915378570557,
-0.20269164443016052,
-0.21018566191196442,
-0.1066916286945343,
-0.3620372414588928,
0.517443060874939,
0.6702479124069214,
-0.709801435470581,
0.4321604073047638,
0.5288731455802917,
0.07843475043773651,
-0.8457140922546387,
-0.6536415815353394,
-0.3204547166824341,
-0.43219470977783203,
-0.006745299324393272,
0.23862625658512115,
0.07658909261226654,
-0.33525213599205017,
-0.16344888508319855,
0.11308523267507553,
0.08904612064361572,
-0.13045459985733032,
0.34520211815834045,
0.3546542227268219,
0.11294356733560562,
0.1170521154999733,
-0.07502144575119019,
-0.0735081136226654,
0.39718812704086304,
-0.5739193558692932,
0.45126792788505554,
0.05269784480333328,
-0.3535243570804596,
0.08362880349159241,
0.142351895570755,
0.32429757714271545,
-0.1229080781340599,
0.9324814081192017,
0.287071168422699,
-0.20827801525592804,
-0.5825278162956238,
-0.46979621052742004,
-0.3081584870815277,
-0.4898129105567932,
0.39243173599243164,
-0.5723080039024353,
-1.139377474784851,
0.4072514772415161,
0.04741640016436577,
-0.07001230865716934,
0.26889851689338684,
0.7596743106842041,
-0.0527089461684227,
0.9257729649543762,
0.3609130084514618,
-0.37603986263275146,
0.7028780579566956,
-0.17448456585407257,
-0.021548904478549957,
-0.934237539768219,
-0.2838227152824402,
-0.3843488395214081,
-0.2657322883605957,
-0.6132341623306274,
-0.5438568592071533,
0.468688040971756,
-0.18672366440296173,
-0.4113227427005768,
-0.06148344278335571,
-0.3840845227241516,
0.7743051648139954,
0.7175903916358948,
0.2305893748998642,
-0.034213632345199585,
-0.029678678140044212,
-0.2695053517818451,
-0.08312620967626572,
-0.7650265097618103,
-0.44169285893440247,
1.319179654121399,
0.3094173073768616,
0.8386539816856384,
-0.10209501534700394,
0.515771210193634,
0.5228075385093689,
0.41070857644081116,
-0.6705709099769592,
0.2766394317150116,
0.07038933783769608,
-0.5108900666236877,
-0.42011499404907227,
-0.46139052510261536,
-0.9491157531738281,
0.46634772419929504,
-0.31683555245399475,
-0.7434179782867432,
0.16517673432826996,
0.12777698040008545,
-0.3593868017196655,
0.23095449805259705,
-0.5181745290756226,
0.6937748789787292,
-0.49504733085632324,
-0.6422114372253418,
-0.4838656783103943,
-0.509202241897583,
0.46253249049186707,
0.022261206060647964,
0.3428433835506439,
0.20571285486221313,
0.10612458735704422,
0.6230034232139587,
0.12007550150156021,
0.8544102311134338,
-0.21427972614765167,
-0.11450961977243423,
0.16001112759113312,
0.071273073554039,
0.7234724164009094,
0.08593793958425522,
-0.20003125071525574,
0.1261759102344513,
-0.23613686859607697,
-0.5026682019233704,
-0.5520002841949463,
0.8056445717811584,
-0.9070075154304504,
-0.5914418697357178,
-0.613793134689331,
-0.45216473937034607,
-0.21623578667640686,
-0.2249857783317566,
0.04461078718304634,
0.4065338671207428,
-0.1922769546508789,
-0.07977546006441116,
1.1099601984024048,
-0.6282397508621216,
0.21435625851154327,
0.50176602602005,
-0.12673524022102356,
-0.0383526049554348,
0.8501259684562683,
-0.0434558168053627,
0.5333526730537415,
0.6248670220375061,
0.04937916621565819,
-0.3494929075241089,
-0.4212097227573395,
-0.3096029460430145,
0.26912230253219604,
-0.9999464750289917,
-0.00193623302038759,
-0.2661176919937134,
-0.15512479841709137,
0.06299758702516556,
-0.46869969367980957,
-0.28902751207351685,
0.05415778607130051,
0.052822478115558624,
-0.26093244552612305,
-0.00469964649528265,
1.0284465551376343,
-0.08676883578300476,
-0.0017577605322003365,
-0.3802216947078705,
0.1843244880437851,
0.6877952218055725,
0.27345624566078186,
0.10156910121440887,
-0.6289719939231873,
-0.5358738303184509,
0.17927175760269165,
0.018742036074399948,
-0.637907862663269,
0.3526492118835449,
-0.2972935140132904,
0.7979244589805603,
0.2590378224849701,
0.009369157254695892,
0.18284718692302704,
-0.4166281223297119,
0.7538091540336609,
-0.14062242209911346,
-0.8497006893157959,
0.28112083673477173,
-0.3386298716068268,
0.4015047550201416,
0.3378598392009735,
0.27534008026123047,
-0.5553289651870728,
-0.08042041957378387,
-0.4657045602798462,
-0.42490407824516296,
1.1022393703460693,
-0.14626748859882355,
0.15019440650939941,
-0.1398332417011261,
0.3788403272628784,
0.17427359521389008,
0.2012452632188797,
-1.1487749814987183,
-0.1466187983751297,
-0.07165924459695816,
0.19609121978282928,
-0.20814941823482513,
-0.4807943105697632,
-0.11773677915334702,
0.0005619866424240172,
0.5861581563949585,
-0.13791559636592865,
0.36071038246154785,
-0.053435392677783966,
-0.25531768798828125,
0.010305616073310375,
0.3338410556316376,
0.6155438423156738,
0.3066738545894623,
-0.29679569602012634,
0.21538473665714264,
0.45436039566993713,
0.05990181118249893,
0.17077451944351196,
-0.48581090569496155,
-0.12449228763580322,
-0.36747291684150696,
0.5702479481697083,
1.0032135248184204,
0.28953441977500916,
-0.8649289011955261,
0.5263302326202393,
-0.14017315208911896,
0.027129793539643288,
-0.33340418338775635,
0.23956893384456635,
-0.10395082831382751,
0.3094746768474579,
0.29691460728645325,
-0.15805771946907043,
0.15579615533351898,
-0.7831651568412781,
-0.04785735160112381,
0.7391011714935303,
-0.4794448912143707,
-0.23642213642597198,
0.36035555601119995,
0.06195614114403725,
-0.15987743437290192,
0.7065866589546204,
-0.3246231973171234,
-0.8262863755226135,
0.679409921169281,
0.4515601396560669,
0.7233416438102722,
0.03457193449139595,
0.020941749215126038,
0.34146586060523987,
0.2627134323120117,
-0.0434238575398922,
-0.024265745654702187,
-0.25440552830696106,
-0.8566730618476868,
-0.591143786907196,
-0.6916800141334534,
-0.23651766777038574,
0.17043563723564148,
-0.680871307849884,
0.0567777045071125,
-0.2281421422958374,
-0.07123278081417084,
-0.1985837072134018,
-0.2642875015735626,
-0.8228206038475037,
0.42324748635292053,
0.5110711455345154,
0.4585109055042267,
-0.9134595394134521,
1.0259039402008057,
0.5514664053916931,
-0.29100582003593445,
-0.803141713142395,
0.07059981673955917,
-0.029991906136274338,
-0.7314464449882507,
1.0730632543563843,
0.05444713309407234,
-0.31364020705223083,
-0.5748139023780823,
-0.4646415114402771,
-0.9829245209693909,
0.8500239849090576,
0.32820752263069153,
-0.17616380751132965,
-0.0961887463927269,
0.07645770162343979,
0.47292694449424744,
-0.5986844301223755,
0.6653760075569153,
0.6977137923240662,
0.3698897361755371,
-0.04461665824055672,
-1.0042978525161743,
0.021083889529109,
0.12605531513690948,
0.06284777075052261,
0.21473176777362823,
-0.7013769745826721,
1.0252282619476318,
-0.11817172169685364,
0.12298642843961716,
-0.512059211730957,
0.366468608379364,
0.45618584752082825,
-0.06746239215135574,
0.40065285563468933,
0.23259833455085754,
0.5952456593513489,
-0.03893270343542099,
1.3577170372009277,
-0.025004185736179352,
0.1716964989900589,
1.0380672216415405,
-0.22634202241897583,
0.7364821434020996,
0.3964685797691345,
-0.2669769823551178,
0.6950619220733643,
0.7034904956817627,
0.5742686986923218,
0.8364636301994324,
0.5009886622428894,
-0.1918056160211563,
-0.42115724086761475,
-0.12992261350154877,
-0.08725385367870331,
0.37538546323776245,
0.5498430728912354,
-0.6090342402458191,
0.17369133234024048,
-0.04199860990047455,
0.011640540324151516,
0.23677313327789307,
-0.5769808888435364,
0.7688330411911011,
0.012648828327655792,
-0.9950811266899109,
0.588115930557251,
0.17763304710388184,
0.9718071222305298,
-0.7917094230651855,
0.03173890709877014,
-0.03304829075932503,
0.2915661633014679,
-0.09082119911909103,
-0.7270917892456055,
0.06930021196603775,
-0.1826389729976654,
-0.5132507085800171,
-0.48720163106918335,
0.4937501549720764,
-0.256626695394516,
-0.08014123141765594,
0.4923500120639801,
0.23770637810230255,
-0.05053498595952988,
-0.04112912341952324,
-0.5005682706832886,
0.2500499188899994,
0.18499638140201569,
-0.48414474725723267,
0.7928268313407898,
0.3028120696544647,
-0.4024975597858429,
0.8356671929359436,
0.4878339469432831,
0.2263684719800949,
0.028893334791064262,
0.024228500202298164,
0.8376688957214355,
-0.6543365120887756,
-0.5965253114700317,
-0.8706744909286499,
0.25168243050575256,
-0.11087562143802643,
-0.06024733930826187,
0.6039807200431824,
0.4364146590232849,
1.3483291864395142,
-0.2980354130268097,
0.9115288257598877,
0.26006361842155457,
0.279441773891449,
-0.9022881984710693,
0.33954447507858276,
-0.28838396072387695,
0.3029070794582367,
-0.031204812228679657,
-0.6541801691055298,
0.17870639264583588,
0.7949596047401428,
-0.8377029895782471,
0.2336941361427307,
0.657697856426239,
0.5726260542869568,
0.11180439591407776,
-0.3063420355319977,
0.37242645025253296,
-0.08177617937326431,
0.07948581874370575,
1.0139081478118896,
0.9366062879562378,
0.06884805113077164,
0.0866093561053276,
0.06306855380535126,
-0.3147522509098053,
-0.14825136959552765,
-0.712140679359436,
-1.0894945859909058,
-0.5894284248352051,
0.06646505743265152,
-0.33783581852912903,
0.24298404157161713,
1.158866286277771,
0.7852077484130859,
-0.7088017463684082,
-0.5406906604766846,
0.262131005525589,
0.3710753917694092,
-0.3104090690612793,
-0.15201646089553833,
0.18800851702690125,
-0.38926130533218384,
-0.7454047799110413,
0.38369932770729065,
0.18575088679790497,
-0.32762205600738525,
-0.36101797223091125,
-0.5566623210906982,
-0.01197043526917696,
0.3333740830421448,
0.6179177165031433,
0.26280587911605835,
-0.8043444752693176,
-0.32327577471733093,
-0.36326974630355835,
-0.26205524802207947,
0.07298652082681656,
0.9932515025138855,
-1.2727712392807007,
0.2976556420326233,
0.331469863653183,
0.5412356853485107,
0.7057936787605286,
-0.06382516026496887,
0.6135236620903015,
-0.6792789697647095,
0.28272944688796997,
0.09308627992868423,
0.3564803898334503,
0.25414833426475525,
-0.4222134053707123,
0.292375773191452,
-0.13251268863677979,
-0.6854228973388672,
-0.5364541411399841,
0.41142767667770386,
-0.4119885563850403,
-0.40763774514198303,
1.305408000946045,
-0.06691843271255493,
-0.21613278985023499,
0.15598498284816742,
-0.16860756278038025,
0.08039063215255737,
-0.5305330157279968,
0.7504557371139526,
0.8499771952629089,
-0.17529256641864777,
0.04282866790890694,
-0.6527456641197205,
0.814319908618927,
0.46830183267593384,
-0.4928321838378906,
0.04230677708983421,
0.7952374815940857,
0.2949540913105011,
-0.23731793463230133,
0.5895102620124817,
0.1523340791463852,
0.268679141998291,
-0.0794537216424942,
0.13412193953990936,
0.05543295666575432,
-0.1229037418961525,
-0.7046099901199341,
0.2202661633491516,
0.4895070195198059,
-0.0553804449737072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11407v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11407v2
|
Can Public LLMs be used for Self-Diagnosis of Medical Conditions ?
| 2024-05-18T22:43:44 | 2024-06-26T01:12:11 |
Nikil Sharan Prabahar Balasubramanian, Sagnik Dakshit
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Advancements in deep learning have generated a large-scale interest in the
development of foundational deep learning models. The development of Large
Language Models (LLM) has evolved as a transformative paradigm in
conversational tasks, which has led to its integration and extension even in
the critical domain of healthcare. With LLMs becoming widely popular and their
public access through open-source models and integration with other
applications, there is a need to investigate their potential and limitations.
One such crucial task where LLMs are applied but require a deeper understanding
is that of self-diagnosis of medical conditions based on bias-validating
symptoms in the interest of public health. The widespread integration of Gemini
with Google search and GPT-4.0 with Bing search has led to a shift in the trend
of self-diagnosis using search engines to conversational LLM models. Owing to
the critical nature of the task, it is prudent to investigate and understand
the potential and limitations of public LLMs in the task of self-diagnosis. In
this study, we prepare a prompt engineered dataset of 10000 samples and test
the performance on the general task of self-diagnosis. We compared the
performance of both the state-of-the-art GPT-4.0 and the fee Gemini model on
the task of self-diagnosis and recorded contrasting accuracies of 63.07% and
6.01%, respectively. We also discuss the challenges, limitations, and potential
of both Gemini and GPT-4.0 for the task of self-diagnosis to facilitate future
research and towards the broader impact of general public knowledge.
Furthermore, we demonstrate the potential and improvement in performance for
the task of self-diagnosis using Retrieval Augmented Generation.
|
[
-0.2788531184196472,
-0.4609520137310028,
1.0392307043075562,
0.34702810645103455,
-0.2243081033229828,
-0.18783855438232422,
-0.23300006985664368,
-0.7262438535690308,
0.3340628445148468,
0.5689327120780945,
-0.4462459981441498,
-0.7329831719398499,
-0.7018706798553467,
0.4254605770111084,
-0.5802099108695984,
0.997325599193573,
-0.0631226971745491,
0.2982540726661682,
-0.2549915611743927,
0.0042529236525297165,
-0.4028165340423584,
-0.8428735733032227,
-0.6729228496551514,
-0.16676534712314606,
0.39548301696777344,
0.054267607629299164,
0.5620132088661194,
0.4596596360206604,
0.658410370349884,
0.2799986004829407,
-0.05505334213376045,
0.16343079507350922,
-0.24922068417072296,
0.21824172139167786,
-0.28215745091438293,
-0.05564189702272415,
-0.37143898010253906,
0.2613312005996704,
0.6454229950904846,
0.613700807094574,
-0.13079260289669037,
0.11816273629665375,
0.010727345943450928,
0.8576680421829224,
-0.37297824025154114,
0.10793245583772659,
-0.2971639633178711,
0.3030233085155487,
-0.18665958940982819,
0.11188691854476929,
0.07804158329963684,
-0.2971435785293579,
0.3104747235774994,
-0.3906252384185791,
0.3910732865333557,
-0.33381447196006775,
0.7319372296333313,
0.5637421607971191,
-0.34475991129875183,
-0.5279760360717773,
-0.7467396855354309,
0.3721644878387451,
-0.5887614488601685,
0.282083660364151,
0.10153964161872864,
0.3619101643562317,
-0.06393246352672577,
-0.722135603427887,
-0.31683582067489624,
-0.45412832498550415,
-0.0626775398850441,
0.21813228726387024,
-0.1484384536743164,
-0.0016509788110852242,
0.18317128717899323,
0.6029161810874939,
-0.6108613014221191,
0.36125048995018005,
-0.46058735251426697,
-0.25218719244003296,
0.45743775367736816,
0.41711869835853577,
0.23732224106788635,
-0.610390305519104,
-0.4775513708591461,
0.557428240776062,
-0.7103536128997803,
-0.3888983130455017,
-0.03058810345828533,
0.3686141073703766,
-0.11159392446279526,
0.316167950630188,
-0.3965652287006378,
0.4535036087036133,
0.14873147010803223,
-0.022479064762592316,
0.23425088822841644,
-0.2555578947067261,
-0.3680993318557739,
-0.08760935068130493,
0.8846265077590942,
0.23363839089870453,
0.08554893732070923,
-0.03710654005408287,
-0.23506499826908112,
0.005047979764640331,
0.195770725607872,
-0.6475356221199036,
-0.20238769054412842,
0.19760309159755707,
-0.6563553214073181,
-0.3536244034767151,
-0.42942872643470764,
-0.46120455861091614,
-0.7264832258224487,
-0.3862047493457794,
0.41187939047813416,
-0.01583101972937584,
-0.3612646162509918,
0.15854540467262268,
0.2910090386867523,
-0.24207589030265808,
0.348269522190094,
-0.7188696265220642,
0.30227968096733093,
0.5653077960014343,
0.8322089314460754,
-0.3708032965660095,
-0.07392197102308273,
-0.18667049705982208,
-0.09844128042459488,
-0.302706778049469,
0.5448142290115356,
-0.1461891084909439,
-0.6532018780708313,
-0.13067926466464996,
0.003093026578426361,
-0.13971030712127686,
-0.9996852874755859,
0.4131249785423279,
-0.24342624843120575,
0.2419070601463318,
-0.44821450114250183,
-0.32794812321662903,
0.25627225637435913,
0.404402494430542,
-0.3653576970100403,
0.7736698389053345,
0.10507436096668243,
-0.42582252621650696,
0.22198455035686493,
-0.7105359435081482,
-0.46278271079063416,
0.13478219509124756,
-0.33908191323280334,
-0.47553539276123047,
0.08437211811542511,
0.35275977849960327,
0.9095445275306702,
-0.4252687394618988,
0.6397991180419922,
-0.44351378083229065,
-0.25079840421676636,
0.23025862872600555,
-0.5708605647087097,
0.4151391386985779,
0.31344327330589294,
-0.28774604201316833,
-0.17539101839065552,
-0.49716174602508545,
-0.3104391396045685,
0.017727745696902275,
-0.4758564531803131,
-0.024857379496097565,
0.06840582937002182,
-0.44324368238449097,
0.22172565758228302,
0.43947064876556396,
-0.4065106511116028,
0.2816789746284485,
-0.643485963344574,
0.2959693670272827,
0.8424238562583923,
0.013571023009717464,
-0.0952237918972969,
-0.27575168013572693,
0.4377516508102417,
0.37053751945495605,
0.4456641972064972,
-0.05037223920226097,
-0.8601640462875366,
-0.5295002460479736,
-0.41825124621391296,
0.3317524790763855,
0.36130490899086,
-0.2344842106103897,
0.28032127022743225,
-0.011058123782277107,
-0.2241506278514862,
-0.7901573181152344,
0.01263397466391325,
0.3613637089729309,
0.8955284953117371,
0.5343360900878906,
-0.08985043317079544,
-0.23520979285240173,
-1.0826483964920044,
-0.33391696214675903,
0.14313241839408875,
-0.05320976674556732,
0.6378704309463501,
0.2769888937473297,
-0.5871087908744812,
0.6894809603691101,
-0.4469448924064636,
-0.4953136146068573,
0.2080765813589096,
0.13072605431079865,
0.4599272310733795,
0.26211923360824585,
0.4754461348056793,
-0.4774561822414398,
-0.3532407879829407,
-0.07053784281015396,
-0.8664973378181458,
-0.3636489808559418,
0.27195608615875244,
0.40633198618888855,
0.11653884500265121,
0.21598263084888458,
-0.47176095843315125,
0.4677374064922333,
0.9285292029380798,
-0.2416929453611374,
0.5968462824821472,
-0.5283733606338501,
0.04843878000974655,
-0.9810831546783447,
-0.05625690519809723,
0.269041508436203,
-0.3988161087036133,
-0.4063691198825836,
-0.06125127524137497,
0.10771375149488449,
-0.4005125164985657,
-0.4173596501350403,
0.4144710302352905,
-0.34632208943367004,
-0.2023995965719223,
-0.47035226225852966,
0.06524337083101273,
-0.16143585741519928,
-0.11214590072631836,
-0.06370086222887039,
0.5972024202346802,
0.9596359729766846,
-0.8999463319778442,
0.2411588877439499,
-0.24400898814201355,
-0.2480042576789856,
0.23171530663967133,
-0.7294296622276306,
0.08015909790992737,
-0.1175796240568161,
0.06675374507904053,
-0.8573945760726929,
-0.2604425251483917,
0.6500850915908813,
-0.3903469145298004,
0.33287933468818665,
-0.14363078773021698,
-0.32250475883483887,
-0.513495683670044,
0.20208217203617096,
0.4305604100227356,
0.5735064148902893,
-0.9203318357467651,
0.4790690243244171,
0.15770894289016724,
0.012475045397877693,
-0.5453975200653076,
-0.5779976844787598,
-0.004285912960767746,
-0.10228551179170609,
-0.7922841906547546,
0.3328401744365692,
-0.00964940432459116,
-0.06127050891518593,
-0.023349782451987267,
-0.1028682217001915,
0.0024593048729002476,
0.28958573937416077,
0.38307952880859375,
0.31122440099716187,
-0.25082656741142273,
0.4445621967315674,
-0.007419336121529341,
-0.3896629512310028,
0.33431968092918396,
-0.18949845433235168,
0.2593443989753723,
-0.2658659517765045,
-0.8366338610649109,
-0.602203905582428,
0.24318981170654297,
0.575458824634552,
-0.09176591783761978,
0.3240838944911957,
0.34442198276519775,
-0.45507046580314636,
0.1108730286359787,
-0.7497027516365051,
-0.10936910659074783,
-0.514794111251831,
0.13445289433002472,
-0.1742211878299713,
-0.9543268084526062,
0.46695995330810547,
-0.37907981872558594,
-0.4977518916130066,
0.7795473337173462,
0.806439220905304,
-0.229913592338562,
1.094772458076477,
0.13520391285419464,
-0.3522190451622009,
-0.14249791204929352,
-0.14525073766708374,
0.2571587860584259,
-0.8868249654769897,
-0.22143347561359406,
-0.4218050241470337,
-0.07201224565505981,
-0.8323758840560913,
-0.3614826500415802,
0.6947476863861084,
-0.27588751912117004,
-0.022365335375070572,
-0.37392881512641907,
-0.8769478797912598,
0.34379369020462036,
0.30430346727371216,
0.5111281871795654,
0.37311413884162903,
-0.36930498480796814,
-0.13523216545581818,
-0.017836784943938255,
-0.29986336827278137,
-0.3634992241859436,
1.301622986793518,
0.5701630711555481,
0.6184273362159729,
-0.022777080535888672,
0.9011839032173157,
0.49586713314056396,
0.6449986100196838,
-0.7325530648231506,
0.3854947090148926,
-0.48210421204566956,
-0.9831689596176147,
-0.2189309298992157,
-0.51582932472229,
-1.1578223705291748,
0.20433638989925385,
-0.019353533163666725,
-0.6180446147918701,
0.15315058827400208,
0.3862660527229309,
-0.4317984879016876,
0.07034243643283844,
-0.6839233040809631,
0.9397568106651306,
-0.7083578109741211,
0.002541631693020463,
-0.28189176321029663,
-0.40726494789123535,
0.4628719389438629,
-0.19731497764587402,
0.23222492635250092,
-0.585951030254364,
0.10573474317789078,
0.7352790832519531,
-0.07714556902647018,
1.0353730916976929,
-0.37159645557403564,
0.019850237295031548,
0.0016434502322226763,
-0.19602972269058228,
0.30760657787323,
0.2048599123954773,
0.06107310950756073,
0.3609047532081604,
-0.10689470916986465,
-0.1691121757030487,
-0.5816773176193237,
0.918213963508606,
-1.0043416023254395,
-1.041572093963623,
-0.608106255531311,
-0.0022866397630423307,
-0.33866453170776367,
0.13930077850818634,
-0.00535992905497551,
0.38844767212867737,
-0.06578394770622253,
-0.1561862677335739,
0.5697643756866455,
-0.26765531301498413,
0.1159198060631752,
0.906183123588562,
-0.31727856397628784,
-0.1465686559677124,
0.9419213533401489,
0.12239489704370499,
-0.024506893008947372,
-0.0020819990895688534,
0.7498558163642883,
-0.3904775083065033,
-0.9265503287315369,
-0.042740851640701294,
0.5765954256057739,
-0.627223789691925,
-0.08359194546937943,
-0.49533405900001526,
-0.2276638150215149,
-0.5886207818984985,
0.21176041662693024,
-0.5230847597122192,
-0.04887247458100319,
-0.8031888604164124,
0.05525572597980499,
0.1094285100698471,
1.157889723777771,
-0.39223724603652954,
-0.13015571236610413,
-0.5161089301109314,
0.6261329650878906,
0.3799828886985779,
0.5394546985626221,
-0.07047818601131439,
-0.4238373935222626,
-0.14204005897045135,
0.05655254051089287,
-0.30920034646987915,
-0.9526288509368896,
0.3254115581512451,
-0.24129943549633026,
0.6274313926696777,
0.6912872791290283,
0.0881052315235138,
0.6326362490653992,
-0.05108632147312164,
0.7437121272087097,
0.38597941398620605,
-0.7598814368247986,
0.6075578331947327,
-0.38795286417007446,
-0.025799091905355453,
0.3052166998386383,
0.8349869251251221,
-0.7116772532463074,
-0.2638865113258362,
-0.4652285873889923,
-0.595066487789154,
0.5541273355484009,
-0.022975247353315353,
-0.029082724824547768,
-0.318890243768692,
0.6887617111206055,
-0.026341287419199944,
-0.1818789839744568,
-0.6502408385276794,
-0.3339660167694092,
-0.26843395829200745,
-0.13734543323516846,
-0.2413407266139984,
-0.25262460112571716,
-0.22407889366149902,
-0.4331286549568176,
0.3697386682033539,
-0.14540527760982513,
0.35118743777275085,
0.6541695594787598,
0.20698796212673187,
0.10187014192342758,
0.2318771332502365,
0.4315502941608429,
0.5509120225906372,
0.05430234223604202,
-0.13170018792152405,
0.2114953249692917,
-0.2596171796321869,
-0.005097505170851946,
0.2986030578613281,
-0.013905677013099194,
-0.08438064157962799,
-0.05894813686609268,
0.5080696940422058,
0.16703037917613983,
-0.39321258664131165,
0.8336102366447449,
0.02528957836329937,
-0.3797333538532257,
-0.4288269281387329,
0.0016227011801674962,
0.2557205855846405,
0.3979167938232422,
0.3076322078704834,
-0.0434451699256897,
0.2833525836467743,
-0.4501349925994873,
-0.12579815089702606,
0.6203811764717102,
-0.27777865529060364,
-0.23102106153964996,
0.664824366569519,
0.6052964925765991,
-0.35129082202911377,
0.9385040998458862,
-0.24137166142463684,
-0.33292320370674133,
0.5303856134414673,
0.5290665030479431,
0.7397645711898804,
-0.09933250397443771,
0.06948676705360413,
0.1003308892250061,
0.1681913584470749,
-0.18230998516082764,
0.2252439260482788,
0.07611367106437683,
-0.7757361531257629,
-0.5456319451332092,
-0.44990572333335876,
-0.4618196487426758,
0.643616795539856,
-0.5499621033668518,
0.1798357516527176,
-0.5534255504608154,
-0.5084284543991089,
-0.10574010759592056,
-0.08681833744049072,
-0.6981809139251709,
0.4837181270122528,
0.5336557626724243,
0.7615818381309509,
-0.6712038516998291,
0.5395979881286621,
0.3698548376560211,
-0.13786183297634125,
-0.7395033240318298,
0.059375520795583725,
0.011135736480355263,
-1.1440215110778809,
0.6844732165336609,
0.2715170085430145,
0.04671226441860199,
-0.2941397428512573,
-0.45387229323387146,
-1.0490013360977173,
0.9497007727622986,
0.38583406805992126,
-0.532602071762085,
-0.3356201946735382,
0.15377959609031677,
0.6584100127220154,
-0.2695856988430023,
0.25193238258361816,
0.37869754433631897,
0.6023927330970764,
-0.05266709253191948,
-1.2654083967208862,
0.22432510554790497,
0.1958632469177246,
-0.12247298657894135,
0.14071355760097504,
-0.6327164173126221,
0.8836706280708313,
-0.18497420847415924,
-0.3371140956878662,
0.0011432684259489179,
0.4347821772098541,
0.24430876970291138,
0.5075104236602783,
0.1261836141347885,
0.6674927473068237,
1.0188976526260376,
-0.14106068015098572,
1.3225080966949463,
-0.5339640974998474,
0.4521271884441376,
0.6623490452766418,
-0.24366292357444763,
0.47391369938850403,
0.06181349232792854,
-0.22507737576961517,
0.302238792181015,
0.6502745151519775,
-0.16351398825645447,
0.2204631119966507,
0.15140701830387115,
-0.45452880859375,
-0.3171460032463074,
0.14749619364738464,
-0.7635357975959778,
0.3057979345321655,
0.6618486642837524,
-0.7877703905105591,
-0.1433596909046173,
-0.1428045779466629,
-0.1458207666873932,
-0.13717927038669586,
-0.4353947043418884,
0.5893153548240662,
-0.01788264513015747,
-0.5447772145271301,
0.4797230064868927,
-0.005348570644855499,
0.7533792853355408,
-0.49808675050735474,
0.2371765822172165,
-0.003401799825951457,
0.052654583007097244,
-0.35843971371650696,
-0.7078161835670471,
0.347747802734375,
-0.11206810176372528,
-0.06975860893726349,
-0.3654285967350006,
1.0277210474014282,
0.10981536656618118,
-0.48964789509773254,
0.40377601981163025,
0.6281742453575134,
0.5331431031227112,
-0.4232557415962219,
-0.7419865131378174,
-0.13072088360786438,
-0.2294936180114746,
-0.11439280956983566,
0.5080583095550537,
0.2510635256767273,
0.4492473304271698,
0.863285481929779,
0.6278557777404785,
0.2160130888223648,
0.007643404416739941,
0.10717704892158508,
0.9378533959388733,
-0.7457959651947021,
-0.24849824607372284,
-0.7927563190460205,
0.21147766709327698,
0.16743482649326324,
-0.42494815587997437,
0.4976929724216461,
0.423262357711792,
0.5745338797569275,
-0.08073404431343079,
1.0221045017242432,
0.39259734749794006,
0.8468577265739441,
-0.5325711965560913,
0.6851834654808044,
-0.5419630408287048,
0.17229396104812622,
0.05818396061658859,
-0.19654378294944763,
-0.15935979783535004,
0.405254602432251,
-0.6959646940231323,
0.2303464263677597,
0.7301703095436096,
0.7088238596916199,
0.05250251665711403,
-0.06586983054876328,
0.46307116746902466,
0.3272777199745178,
0.21312148869037628,
0.3973425030708313,
1.1577188968658447,
0.1884188950061798,
0.5657546520233154,
-0.21785232424736023,
-0.24003228545188904,
-0.3959580659866333,
-0.783506453037262,
-0.9729445576667786,
-0.3181222975254059,
-0.3245803713798523,
-0.24962927401065826,
0.2523757815361023,
0.7780166268348694,
0.9137536287307739,
-0.4895741641521454,
0.12410186976194382,
-0.014723090454936028,
0.11804095655679703,
0.11180675029754639,
-0.2222655564546585,
0.16687200963497162,
-0.1878722757101059,
-0.37895599007606506,
0.6320694088935852,
0.2840377688407898,
0.2581506669521332,
-0.6714595556259155,
-0.017611153423786163,
0.4154696464538574,
-0.4219236373901367,
0.43877360224723816,
0.36710846424102783,
-0.9405296444892883,
-0.09820600599050522,
-0.04390401393175125,
-0.09692097455263138,
0.25914812088012695,
0.8593134880065918,
-1.0004348754882812,
0.3495923578739166,
-0.015536476857960224,
0.6145107746124268,
0.6159217953681946,
0.018716981634497643,
0.32246100902557373,
-0.2764478325843811,
-0.4897997975349426,
0.5003603100776672,
0.45066243410110474,
0.3260171115398407,
-0.8047849535942078,
0.21349649131298065,
0.4579002559185028,
-0.8242017030715942,
-0.4045259952545166,
0.21106350421905518,
-0.7386537194252014,
-0.2073335200548172,
1.078762173652649,
-0.033409006893634796,
-0.06082442030310631,
-0.21128429472446442,
0.00901854783296585,
0.08675092458724976,
-0.49510517716407776,
1.1226533651351929,
0.3354785740375519,
-0.7169533371925354,
0.19304312765598297,
-0.3482663631439209,
0.32019418478012085,
0.2811291217803955,
-0.6573010087013245,
-0.13432887196540833,
0.26787424087524414,
0.6485180258750916,
0.13237841427326202,
1.0190367698669434,
-0.1773696392774582,
0.461992084980011,
-0.5840762853622437,
-0.14752715826034546,
-0.21701519191265106,
-0.12395238876342773,
-0.5110023617744446,
0.2642446756362915,
0.049810297787189484,
-0.21354760229587555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13046v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13046v1
|
LeaPformer: Enabling Linear Transformers for Autoregressive and Simultaneous Tasks via Learned Proportions
| 2024-05-18T22:23:07 | 2024-05-18T22:23:07 |
Victor Agostinelli, Sanghyun Hong, Lizhong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
A promising approach to preserving model performance in linearized
transformers is to employ position-based re-weighting functions. However,
state-of-the-art re-weighting functions rely heavily on target sequence
lengths, making it difficult or impossible to apply them to autoregressive and
simultaneous tasks, where the target and sometimes even the input sequence
length are unknown. To address this issue, we propose Learned Proportions
(LeaP) and LeaPformers. Our contribution is built on two major components.
First, we generalize the dependence on explicit positional representations and
sequence lengths into dependence on sequence proportions for re-weighting.
Second, we replace static positional representations with dynamic proportions
derived via a compact module, enabling more flexible attention concentration
patterns. We evaluate LeaPformer against eight representative efficient
transformers on the Long-Range Arena benchmark, showing that LeaPformer
achieves the best quality-throughput trade-off, as well as LeaPformer to
Wikitext-103 autoregressive language modeling and simultaneous speech-to-text
translation for two language pairs, achieving competitive results.
|
[
-0.1931447833776474,
-0.0422523096203804,
0.26926207542419434,
0.5868269801139832,
0.16424812376499176,
0.10162200778722763,
0.0689062625169754,
-0.15724359452724457,
0.3573862910270691,
0.0567643940448761,
-0.42406150698661804,
0.31063103675842285,
-0.8309537172317505,
-0.13055068254470825,
-0.6184303760528564,
0.8366534113883972,
-0.26925382018089294,
-0.12679080665111542,
-0.42305439710617065,
-0.15708015859127045,
-0.5957944393157959,
-0.4765695631504059,
-0.5214674472808838,
-0.5029125809669495,
0.7051429152488708,
0.39272981882095337,
0.7413471937179565,
0.5603818893432617,
0.5505521893501282,
0.36517250537872314,
0.2805248498916626,
-0.25098952651023865,
-0.48607346415519714,
0.44295188784599304,
0.08639466017484665,
-0.7864847183227539,
-0.520561933517456,
0.04514656960964203,
0.7826778292655945,
0.6193434000015259,
-0.4287627041339874,
0.13173449039459229,
-0.05922108516097069,
0.9483476281166077,
-0.7139170169830322,
0.21010971069335938,
-0.24422885477542877,
0.4221273362636566,
0.2801256775856018,
0.013093075715005398,
-0.518267035484314,
-0.13238753378391266,
-0.10094302147626877,
-0.7045347690582275,
0.44738277792930603,
-0.1675409972667694,
0.4723908007144928,
0.7703015804290771,
-0.5105841159820557,
0.09878458082675934,
-1.0492066144943237,
1.0445553064346313,
-0.5492802858352661,
0.8852959871292114,
-0.07066994160413742,
0.48334240913391113,
0.004329859744757414,
-1.0367968082427979,
-0.25572094321250916,
0.09364744275808334,
-0.18148082494735718,
0.3890645205974579,
-0.497997909784317,
-0.05103284865617752,
0.37161627411842346,
0.5300530195236206,
-0.526039719581604,
0.02438930794596672,
-0.3341749608516693,
-0.08605584502220154,
0.6480016708374023,
0.11761025339365005,
0.2179885357618332,
0.1619463711977005,
-0.3086552619934082,
-0.6229776740074158,
-0.23692888021469116,
0.298107773065567,
0.11647351086139679,
0.04687947407364845,
0.07674414664506912,
0.5294394493103027,
0.17603379487991333,
0.6332143545150757,
0.7060543298721313,
-0.10676693916320801,
0.2476632446050644,
-0.17799994349479675,
-0.3624191880226135,
-0.10528324544429779,
0.6710529923439026,
0.09593304246664047,
0.03587076812982559,
-0.25213780999183655,
-0.30926990509033203,
0.03574994578957558,
0.7736145257949829,
-0.7836447358131409,
-0.4982410669326782,
0.030400138348340988,
-0.4004739224910736,
-0.0037750399205833673,
0.17092324793338776,
-0.5644416213035583,
0.06446703523397446,
-0.4936050474643707,
0.7106072902679443,
-0.3230348229408264,
0.034494414925575256,
0.2504410147666931,
-0.18588976562023163,
0.21923793852329254,
0.4588509500026703,
-1.172353744506836,
0.3647520840167999,
0.6580814123153687,
0.7649796009063721,
-0.5869594812393188,
-0.027013590559363365,
-0.5156340003013611,
-0.050773318856954575,
-0.10359610617160797,
0.41962966322898865,
-0.20093047618865967,
-0.3837856948375702,
-0.2524654269218445,
-0.055796388536691666,
-0.5166342258453369,
-0.4595053493976593,
0.6233089566230774,
-0.5506716966629028,
0.5051436424255371,
0.15686677396297455,
-0.6661946177482605,
0.00036284764064475894,
-0.045938968658447266,
-1.04787015914917,
1.1455457210540771,
0.03482012078166008,
-0.6077796220779419,
0.414387971162796,
-0.2746813893318176,
-0.6565472483634949,
-0.0858415886759758,
-0.10727173089981079,
-0.6733900904655457,
0.37739992141723633,
0.311201274394989,
0.20979593694210052,
0.1920001357793808,
0.030542032793164253,
0.14137165248394012,
-0.0954427421092987,
0.009077673777937889,
-0.7820979952812195,
0.3567936420440674,
0.0025434650015085936,
-0.25113680958747864,
0.2640928030014038,
-0.5886858105659485,
-0.19265161454677582,
-0.02173769660294056,
-0.3698868751525879,
-0.12227368354797363,
0.2718186378479004,
-0.009211985394358635,
0.33825626969337463,
0.305605947971344,
-0.511410653591156,
0.18064621090888977,
-0.43388378620147705,
0.15680992603302002,
0.29468610882759094,
-0.22479526698589325,
0.7428264021873474,
-0.5647609829902649,
0.818901002407074,
-0.14777183532714844,
0.31619492173194885,
-0.2719734013080597,
-0.4363684058189392,
-0.9134541749954224,
-0.28673800826072693,
0.13638935983181,
0.5449758172035217,
-0.5302366614341736,
0.5180670619010925,
-0.43860962986946106,
-0.5922957062721252,
-0.369155615568161,
-0.07983172684907913,
0.04269539937376976,
0.3927351236343384,
0.5164272785186768,
-0.5230506062507629,
-0.6449951529502869,
-0.8748014569282532,
-0.20400592684745789,
-0.36722904443740845,
-0.4842248857021332,
-0.1815943568944931,
0.02594403736293316,
0.14721086621284485,
0.8990508317947388,
-0.6587682962417603,
-0.37369656562805176,
-0.0004485448298510164,
0.19698014855384827,
0.42366695404052734,
0.5227684378623962,
0.5337496995925903,
-1.0952227115631104,
-0.4273172616958618,
-0.37589696049690247,
-0.19492052495479584,
0.06403396278619766,
-0.16914360225200653,
0.12948836386203766,
-0.13015107810497284,
0.5681483149528503,
-0.7332401275634766,
0.4256703853607178,
0.6663040518760681,
-0.08028186857700348,
0.3116128742694855,
-0.15018761157989502,
0.13592997193336487,
-1.0171712636947632,
0.018637971952557564,
-0.14695972204208374,
-0.5467071533203125,
-0.7068660259246826,
-0.15809902548789978,
0.253207266330719,
0.06891874969005585,
-0.34991157054901123,
0.08743953704833984,
-0.25682348012924194,
-0.01885044015944004,
-0.20438039302825928,
-0.08580130338668823,
0.11381019651889801,
0.2634686529636383,
0.016645260155200958,
0.85213303565979,
0.21193742752075195,
-0.4218142032623291,
0.22183163464069366,
0.22880379855632782,
0.007009034976363182,
0.49408677220344543,
-0.8247029185295105,
-0.18845151364803314,
-0.10563736408948898,
0.2704063951969147,
-1.2737661600112915,
-0.1275787651538849,
-0.11192014813423157,
-0.7061002850532532,
0.5308405160903931,
-0.11708113551139832,
-0.07031072676181793,
-0.5907724499702454,
-0.2924575209617615,
0.6409639120101929,
0.5937615633010864,
-0.25739777088165283,
0.7998002767562866,
0.37586238980293274,
-0.2053578495979309,
-0.8789265155792236,
-0.6635892391204834,
-0.2579408884048462,
-0.17334938049316406,
-0.5180873274803162,
0.5070181488990784,
-0.10511119663715363,
0.19276337325572968,
-0.3125089704990387,
-0.570097029209137,
0.24665366113185883,
-0.14437489211559296,
0.3169761002063751,
0.20459428429603577,
-0.28264328837394714,
0.1862322986125946,
-0.16323526203632355,
-0.1564410924911499,
0.19787995517253876,
-0.6319581270217896,
0.38566118478775024,
0.09572969377040863,
-0.6458904147148132,
-0.07966800034046173,
0.12526802718639374,
0.8997857570648193,
-0.06107988953590393,
0.4847862720489502,
0.605422854423523,
-0.28249385952949524,
-0.22813370823860168,
-0.4738398790359497,
-0.10267225652933121,
-0.45499300956726074,
0.47489961981773376,
0.018820010125637054,
-0.98624187707901,
0.2619677484035492,
0.1322018951177597,
0.47286128997802734,
0.6518162488937378,
0.5946125984191895,
0.0024280333891510963,
0.9274885058403015,
0.9531731605529785,
-0.20385605096817017,
0.817333459854126,
-0.10188882797956467,
0.29089269042015076,
-0.5296636819839478,
-0.2601736783981323,
-0.22131067514419556,
-0.7499470710754395,
-0.2371133267879486,
-0.782705545425415,
0.4498864412307739,
-0.1548997461795807,
-0.13982218503952026,
0.69303959608078,
-0.5473370552062988,
0.11506317555904388,
0.5363575220108032,
-0.23699091374874115,
0.13981235027313232,
0.1513710767030716,
0.006521420553326607,
-0.32163432240486145,
-0.83139568567276,
-0.055634789168834686,
0.880969226360321,
0.3372114598751068,
1.0993832349777222,
0.12126171588897705,
0.6239163875579834,
0.32527101039886475,
0.20585709810256958,
-1.2624520063400269,
0.20613901317119598,
-0.4251905381679535,
-0.36924272775650024,
-0.5352591872215271,
-0.359586238861084,
-1.0771859884262085,
0.3541058897972107,
-0.0649166852235794,
-0.45771658420562744,
0.5810227394104004,
0.36174866557121277,
-0.48395010828971863,
0.25729817152023315,
-0.48686718940734863,
0.6418917775154114,
-0.22518199682235718,
-0.06297893822193146,
-0.2159501314163208,
-0.5676272511482239,
0.2313336282968521,
-0.22043302655220032,
-0.11470816284418106,
0.1841612607240677,
-0.1344435065984726,
0.849810779094696,
-0.28405433893203735,
0.722846508026123,
-0.07780292630195618,
-0.2667537033557892,
-0.09914471954107285,
0.03146258741617203,
0.19280341267585754,
0.023890700191259384,
0.09996511042118073,
-0.1308698207139969,
-0.2185128778219223,
-0.2324165254831314,
-0.8422675728797913,
0.4844468832015991,
-0.7723495960235596,
-0.5530765056610107,
-0.37867891788482666,
-0.7977651357650757,
-0.3105970323085785,
0.23184162378311157,
0.21346651017665863,
0.24447692930698395,
-0.34973227977752686,
0.38952329754829407,
0.7237488627433777,
0.24540278315544128,
0.7771332263946533,
0.35309794545173645,
-0.2013668715953827,
-0.7351207137107849,
0.6339024901390076,
-0.05876148119568825,
0.4737692177295685,
0.9111776351928711,
-0.1712673455476761,
-0.43855127692222595,
-0.11888778954744339,
-0.2492370456457138,
0.10872665792703629,
-0.4223952293395996,
-0.3325221538543701,
-0.5935279130935669,
-0.48807987570762634,
-0.29628774523735046,
-0.2757975459098816,
-0.6504543423652649,
-0.9864622354507446,
-0.11146487295627594,
-0.0931888073682785,
-0.017728859558701515,
0.6645622849464417,
-0.19391480088233948,
0.35663241147994995,
-0.6374254822731018,
0.56052166223526,
0.6991433501243591,
0.126235693693161,
0.08658410608768463,
-0.7211728096008301,
-0.31656259298324585,
0.04510261118412018,
-0.573606014251709,
-0.4900817275047302,
0.5851439237594604,
0.3265096843242645,
0.7474668622016907,
0.24092084169387817,
-0.061946649104356766,
0.5535240769386292,
-0.6731936931610107,
0.5971253514289856,
0.6422241926193237,
-0.7473812699317932,
0.23101219534873962,
0.24720452725887299,
0.34895795583724976,
0.26759594678878784,
0.49402177333831787,
-0.6503633856773376,
-0.20261551439762115,
-0.5199533104896545,
-1.050817847251892,
0.826267421245575,
0.6230084896087646,
0.0021510999649763107,
0.3994825482368469,
0.07724902033805847,
-0.07186226546764374,
0.06069467216730118,
-0.5506546497344971,
-0.42291945219039917,
-0.5546498894691467,
-0.4763281047344208,
-0.45964515209198,
0.052720919251441956,
0.03712299093604088,
-0.31498104333877563,
0.522975504398346,
0.04959560185670853,
0.27360406517982483,
0.39809438586235046,
-0.2966157793998718,
-0.3271479308605194,
0.1440807580947876,
0.3622419238090515,
0.28761640191078186,
-0.03422306105494499,
0.14616258442401886,
0.014970128424465656,
-0.8310186266899109,
0.685103714466095,
0.555122971534729,
-0.2230139970779419,
0.09688898921012878,
0.4192090332508087,
0.839979887008667,
0.622020959854126,
-0.24594475328922272,
0.4645484685897827,
-0.2603239417076111,
-0.12727044522762299,
-0.44546830654144287,
0.1654801368713379,
0.25882992148399353,
0.07680144906044006,
0.5900346040725708,
0.39168766140937805,
0.11215943843126297,
0.05107706040143967,
0.6805323958396912,
0.12858211994171143,
-0.7282681465148926,
-0.3842296004295349,
0.9881339073181152,
0.02022925764322281,
-0.39987242221832275,
0.5037532448768616,
0.36355525255203247,
-0.2590811848640442,
0.73692387342453,
0.527371883392334,
0.8852587938308716,
-0.8617415428161621,
0.10261286050081253,
0.3881663382053375,
0.1678728610277176,
-0.3361092805862427,
-0.1271183341741562,
-0.2650812864303589,
-0.6594997048377991,
-0.6124001145362854,
-0.6840031743049622,
-0.3078988194465637,
-0.30254805088043213,
-0.9112094640731812,
0.20936308801174164,
-0.06693132221698761,
-0.36638545989990234,
0.3400398790836334,
-0.27312853932380676,
-0.43174999952316284,
0.1359325796365738,
0.41400134563446045,
0.8600581884384155,
-0.8786144852638245,
0.5696467757225037,
0.9197824001312256,
-0.3100782036781311,
-0.7643462419509888,
0.07187927514314651,
-0.09170112758874893,
-0.5861077904701233,
0.6811999082565308,
0.0984259843826294,
-0.22720061242580414,
0.03579258173704147,
-0.17260120809078217,
-1.1741396188735962,
1.094963788986206,
0.4595232605934143,
-0.6435900330543518,
-0.3973955810070038,
0.30629608035087585,
0.41960254311561584,
-0.15229389071464539,
0.3566947281360626,
0.28076571226119995,
0.13605056703090668,
0.45923230051994324,
-1.0691012144088745,
-0.22033452987670898,
-0.219321608543396,
-0.1053324043750763,
0.4033932387828827,
-0.6878445148468018,
0.907623827457428,
0.029005439952015877,
-0.14728736877441406,
-0.05394464358687401,
0.9451134204864502,
0.19195730984210968,
0.10631801933050156,
0.8089141249656677,
0.6449334621429443,
0.3581002950668335,
-0.03674190118908882,
0.6229428648948669,
-0.309234082698822,
0.5169250965118408,
0.962016761302948,
-0.13075898587703705,
0.8565199375152588,
0.35255080461502075,
-0.6329054236412048,
0.5653873682022095,
0.15030400454998016,
0.13547413051128387,
0.21833167970180511,
0.09091784060001373,
-0.23382341861724854,
-0.35100114345550537,
0.41295984387397766,
-0.11127573996782303,
0.43527668714523315,
0.5367169976234436,
-0.37534210085868835,
-0.2871430814266205,
0.010108075104653835,
-0.24647608399391174,
0.03267490863800049,
-0.21162430942058563,
0.5615045428276062,
0.40792346000671387,
-0.8563529253005981,
0.4271937608718872,
-0.2094893753528595,
0.740895688533783,
-0.7635597586631775,
-0.04063424468040466,
-0.25156527757644653,
0.5201227068901062,
-0.028583679348230362,
-0.7335016131401062,
0.34172895550727844,
-0.45640841126441956,
-0.5459791421890259,
-0.6272839903831482,
0.723227858543396,
-0.6188415288925171,
-0.5941800475120544,
0.23620998859405518,
0.21486864984035492,
-0.22166754305362701,
-0.026060041040182114,
-0.5152404308319092,
-0.28863757848739624,
0.012356913648545742,
-0.19210007786750793,
0.05265280231833458,
0.26951006054878235,
-0.15238837897777557,
0.7741585373878479,
0.2978544235229492,
-0.13550153374671936,
0.3333604633808136,
0.13935095071792603,
0.6725639700889587,
-0.5351630449295044,
-0.5736765265464783,
-0.574118435382843,
0.44990941882133484,
-0.018624037504196167,
0.06233708932995796,
0.8577425479888916,
0.8069707751274109,
0.6795440316200256,
-0.3494340181350708,
0.4187208116054535,
-0.07854606211185455,
0.2273980975151062,
-0.1373937427997589,
0.6469528079032898,
-0.5876426100730896,
-0.2451067715883255,
-0.18792621791362762,
-0.9740053415298462,
-0.4061812460422516,
0.48905301094055176,
-0.11144525557756424,
0.0019019180908799171,
0.39943772554397583,
0.36013954877853394,
-0.3745664358139038,
-0.23553134500980377,
0.5514419674873352,
0.02990652061998844,
0.40662702918052673,
0.9096950888633728,
0.6559988260269165,
-0.7819522619247437,
0.7004866600036621,
-0.17214350402355194,
-0.19248831272125244,
-0.1939590871334076,
-0.6217884421348572,
-0.44362837076187134,
-0.6192711591720581,
-0.32843002676963806,
0.09186483919620514,
-0.22403444349765778,
0.6007053852081299,
0.9940416216850281,
-1.0607020854949951,
-0.3146723806858063,
-0.08626683801412582,
-0.030936412513256073,
-0.3405018746852875,
-0.24587620794773102,
0.2525220811367035,
-0.5030549168586731,
-0.8762863874435425,
0.46482405066490173,
0.2532899081707001,
0.10807302594184875,
-0.20684243738651276,
-0.08947975933551788,
-0.015521613880991936,
0.07824312895536423,
0.7345853447914124,
0.5885292887687683,
-0.6305413842201233,
-0.14729775488376617,
0.2606258988380432,
-0.013728012330830097,
0.2547370195388794,
1.0479309558868408,
-1.128048062324524,
0.37351560592651367,
0.6559723615646362,
0.4092469811439514,
0.5747409462928772,
0.3953924775123596,
0.9097658395767212,
-0.8177028298377991,
0.22496750950813293,
0.4631321430206299,
0.5243716835975647,
0.35763049125671387,
-0.35010093450546265,
0.37946492433547974,
0.19930410385131836,
-0.6999385356903076,
-0.33705732226371765,
0.23846536874771118,
-1.110485315322876,
0.1559855043888092,
0.7380104660987854,
-0.1624961793422699,
0.061757009476423264,
0.05995810776948929,
-0.0632515400648117,
0.5454868078231812,
-0.27372339367866516,
0.621870756149292,
0.38922399282455444,
-0.20223698019981384,
-0.22227364778518677,
-0.21971207857131958,
0.4755295515060425,
0.6905574798583984,
-0.38051295280456543,
0.0007036136812530458,
0.4538983106613159,
0.16026338934898376,
0.5537482500076294,
0.2712502181529999,
-0.2804895341396332,
0.10122839361429214,
-0.06241568922996521,
0.3415127694606781,
0.2183249294757843,
-0.2611372172832489,
-0.3568399250507355,
0.22779129445552826,
-0.08498653769493103,
-0.3783874213695526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11403v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11403v1
|
MapCoder: Multi-Agent Code Generation for Competitive Problem Solving
| 2024-05-18T22:10:15 | 2024-05-18T22:10:15 |
Md. Ashraful Islam, Mohammed Eunus Ali, Md Rizwan Parvez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Code synthesis, which requires a deep understanding of complex natural
language problem descriptions, generation of code instructions for complex
algorithms and data structures, and the successful execution of comprehensive
unit tests, presents a significant challenge. While large language models
(LLMs) demonstrate impressive proficiency in natural language processing, their
performance in code generation tasks remains limited. In this paper, we
introduce a new approach to code generation tasks leveraging multi-agent
prompting that uniquely replicates the full cycle of program synthesis as
observed in human developers. Our framework, MapCoder, consists of four LLM
agents specifically designed to emulate the stages of this cycle: recalling
relevant examples, planning, code generation, and debugging. After conducting
thorough experiments, with multiple LLM ablations and analyses across eight
challenging competitive problem-solving and program synthesis benchmarks,
MapCoder showcases remarkable code generation capabilities, achieving new
state-of-the-art results (pass@1) on HumanEval (93.9%), MBPP (83.1%), APPS
(22.0%), CodeContests (28.5%), and xCodeEval (45.3%). Moreover, our method
consistently delivers superior performance across various programming languages
and varying problem difficulties. We open-source our framework at
https://github.com/Md-Ashraful-Pramanik/MapCoder.
|
[
-0.6446887254714966,
-0.5898053646087646,
0.31845512986183167,
0.39189615845680237,
0.04223806783556938,
0.5492095351219177,
-0.3788151144981384,
-0.09730125963687897,
-0.03244940936565399,
0.5655307173728943,
-0.5780507326126099,
-0.6327404379844666,
-0.28350362181663513,
0.34571847319602966,
-0.2570681869983673,
0.9025242328643799,
-0.1353948414325714,
-0.24977637827396393,
-0.15088577568531036,
0.09603769332170486,
-0.5028702020645142,
-0.667862057685852,
-0.5212166905403137,
-0.2732023298740387,
0.2406115084886551,
0.7037757635116577,
0.643648087978363,
0.4951176941394806,
0.4971439242362976,
0.3366846740245819,
0.34169647097587585,
0.47904857993125916,
-0.5244654417037964,
0.5015915632247925,
0.3533702492713928,
-0.12122485786676407,
-0.3074398338794708,
-0.3568328619003296,
0.31034547090530396,
0.03092753142118454,
-0.2366497665643692,
0.2958832383155823,
-0.055347103625535965,
0.6187326312065125,
-0.5479496121406555,
0.333013653755188,
-0.6775192618370056,
-0.09335799515247345,
0.15787601470947266,
-0.3728497624397278,
-0.4792584776878357,
-0.5297601819038391,
-0.4213167726993561,
-0.5633351802825928,
0.47350776195526123,
-0.04985155165195465,
0.46900591254234314,
0.3020534813404083,
-0.37144383788108826,
-0.47392505407333374,
-0.7209703326225281,
0.4259207844734192,
-0.5861659646034241,
0.0014935169601812959,
-0.026154421269893646,
0.5430207252502441,
-0.42613285779953003,
-0.6869290471076965,
-0.796477198600769,
-0.15694114565849304,
0.348832368850708,
-0.05604129657149315,
-0.1357630044221878,
-0.15930673480033875,
0.21575474739074707,
0.14362919330596924,
-0.6531319618225098,
-0.32070988416671753,
-0.46887120604515076,
-0.09032000601291656,
0.7145625948905945,
0.33689457178115845,
0.32517632842063904,
0.16329695284366608,
-0.2741703987121582,
-0.24397847056388855,
-0.7829513549804688,
0.019721703603863716,
0.1529429405927658,
0.371872216463089,
0.011274372227489948,
0.3516866862773895,
-0.05211494490504265,
0.6326678395271301,
-0.009570148773491383,
0.026147328317165375,
0.3799736201763153,
-0.4485681653022766,
0.10987772047519684,
0.0688360184431076,
0.6901489496231079,
0.5068424344062805,
0.2147679626941681,
-0.01565132848918438,
-0.41986244916915894,
0.34575897455215454,
0.4625561535358429,
-1.0028055906295776,
-0.2415938675403595,
0.2030247151851654,
-0.12999096512794495,
-0.33913591504096985,
-0.025960298255085945,
-0.9762162566184998,
-0.5139684677124023,
-0.03800496831536293,
0.040513694286346436,
-0.14222483336925507,
-0.36758434772491455,
0.17501696944236755,
-0.0338217094540596,
0.5078474283218384,
-0.10018228739500046,
-0.507178783416748,
0.14604434370994568,
0.6186497211456299,
0.7104832530021667,
-0.07978975772857666,
-0.672210156917572,
-0.6536982655525208,
0.09500358998775482,
-0.4746803939342499,
0.7569146752357483,
-0.5726264119148254,
-0.5742337703704834,
0.1267773061990738,
-0.34699612855911255,
0.0936867967247963,
-0.6843881011009216,
0.16688311100006104,
-0.48717284202575684,
-0.44013240933418274,
-0.14898791909217834,
-0.24318987131118774,
0.05289286747574806,
0.37216827273368835,
-0.7248585224151611,
1.133061408996582,
0.09564551711082458,
-0.3132403790950775,
0.19081313908100128,
-0.9223637580871582,
-0.46819257736206055,
0.1480189710855484,
-0.4299711585044861,
-0.5633396506309509,
-0.0848195031285286,
0.43097785115242004,
0.29477301239967346,
-0.5745899081230164,
0.33255940675735474,
0.09952446073293686,
-0.4752430021762848,
0.4089786410331726,
0.04908343032002449,
0.3910447061061859,
0.36544516682624817,
-0.6614657640457153,
0.44118043780326843,
-0.7229440212249756,
0.3213936686515808,
0.4992845058441162,
-0.41020822525024414,
0.30268973112106323,
-0.08325854688882828,
0.10436802357435226,
0.43511420488357544,
0.018907342106103897,
-0.41300082206726074,
0.5024790167808533,
-0.09604462236166,
0.4621249735355377,
0.6011756658554077,
0.26789090037345886,
0.3445397913455963,
-0.6729186773300171,
0.9941205978393555,
-0.14238134026527405,
0.08345402032136917,
-0.36828848719596863,
-0.7279917001724243,
-0.5455152988433838,
-0.40412604808807373,
-0.0006769616156816483,
0.42379331588745117,
-0.8269333839416504,
0.32473641633987427,
-0.39109233021736145,
-0.47852399945259094,
-0.6992238163948059,
0.33224621415138245,
0.5142912268638611,
0.05683319643139839,
0.2843021750450134,
-0.21002018451690674,
-0.7013363242149353,
-0.4218905568122864,
0.049618590623140335,
0.06643662601709366,
0.05334996432065964,
0.0498293973505497,
0.559131383895874,
-0.5705066323280334,
0.9562170505523682,
-0.6731424331665039,
-0.18054425716400146,
-0.6301074028015137,
0.13567519187927246,
0.1030876636505127,
0.3933078944683075,
0.48588261008262634,
-0.6319323182106018,
-0.3768244981765747,
-0.15323369204998016,
-0.24304687976837158,
-0.2684674859046936,
-0.33330652117729187,
-0.3170944154262543,
0.24166680872440338,
0.47560110688209534,
-0.5093176364898682,
0.09650091826915741,
0.6767870187759399,
-0.4101024270057678,
0.5865064859390259,
-0.36258262395858765,
0.152445450425148,
-1.147998332977295,
0.24688158929347992,
-0.4340748190879822,
-0.09327404946088791,
-0.5391432046890259,
0.685448169708252,
-0.22608473896980286,
-0.4301694333553314,
-0.2591601014137268,
0.4225527346134186,
-0.6458237767219543,
0.0014710378600284457,
-0.3785187304019928,
-0.024525752291083336,
0.09529774636030197,
0.579625129699707,
-0.37205302715301514,
1.128282070159912,
0.43875354528427124,
-0.530271589756012,
0.5406204462051392,
0.3305915594100952,
-0.22200092673301697,
0.015528518706560135,
-0.49806153774261475,
0.5643110871315002,
-0.11142878234386444,
0.23202255368232727,
-0.963849663734436,
-0.158730611205101,
0.15354079008102417,
-0.4480551481246948,
-0.016502900049090385,
-0.06846015900373459,
-0.6566656827926636,
-0.5710424780845642,
-0.3205384612083435,
0.5232101678848267,
0.8490976095199585,
-0.5357223749160767,
0.4967707395553589,
0.2884503901004791,
-0.11907725781202316,
-0.06540913134813309,
-0.6740490794181824,
0.19834746420383453,
0.17481406033039093,
-0.5622552037239075,
-0.03216187655925751,
-0.520278811454773,
-0.03389764577150345,
-0.19663986563682556,
-0.04719772934913635,
-0.32933762669563293,
0.01656973548233509,
0.4986160695552826,
0.23345819115638733,
-0.10850303620100021,
-0.11933805793523788,
-0.1655009239912033,
-0.3019119203090668,
0.06414834409952164,
-0.2703894078731537,
0.5960269570350647,
-0.14354507625102997,
-0.4257752597332001,
0.05487681180238724,
0.598892331123352,
0.7886087894439697,
-0.8907703161239624,
0.27803999185562134,
0.43531543016433716,
-0.12973645329475403,
-0.6256405711174011,
-0.34129801392555237,
-0.006961854174733162,
-0.4711453318595886,
0.17855773866176605,
-0.6315805315971375,
-0.6758680939674377,
0.4775930941104889,
-0.16184067726135254,
0.1094854399561882,
-0.009454785846173763,
0.9215518832206726,
0.5996923446655273,
1.0384790897369385,
0.3039625287055969,
-0.01587624102830887,
0.17321427166461945,
-0.47116410732269287,
0.36399567127227783,
-0.4887325167655945,
-0.11125148087739944,
-0.5934468507766724,
-0.15984518826007843,
-0.47899651527404785,
-0.8874006867408752,
0.41498786211013794,
-0.1849081814289093,
-0.2925463020801544,
0.14312773942947388,
-0.8754945397377014,
0.7860488295555115,
0.6631377935409546,
0.006118801888078451,
0.19755612313747406,
-0.041947897523641586,
-0.13834357261657715,
0.2322816252708435,
-0.7670150399208069,
-0.4118531048297882,
1.1764540672302246,
-0.15922586619853973,
0.6854512095451355,
0.13107360899448395,
1.068266749382019,
0.41637787222862244,
0.2986776530742645,
-0.49801936745643616,
0.6213909387588501,
0.3086501359939575,
-0.6350417733192444,
-0.13639146089553833,
-0.4749120771884918,
-1.1213922500610352,
0.25524017214775085,
-0.22811195254325867,
-0.08676010370254517,
-0.16877122223377228,
0.1446654498577118,
-0.4245527982711792,
0.04352366179227829,
-0.6712469458580017,
1.0137665271759033,
-0.15808382630348206,
-0.13994838297367096,
-0.04320409148931503,
-0.45246651768684387,
0.07115492224693298,
-0.10279014706611633,
0.4434162378311157,
-0.004434324335306883,
0.0328097939491272,
0.20180265605449677,
-0.22081293165683746,
0.5792093276977539,
-0.22369953989982605,
-0.09598829597234726,
0.6169112324714661,
0.37976405024528503,
0.5211501717567444,
-0.09319137781858444,
-0.20275214314460754,
-0.26743489503860474,
-0.2749697268009186,
-0.43587031960487366,
-0.44081342220306396,
0.701834499835968,
-0.5146173238754272,
-0.33457085490226746,
-0.16176386177539825,
-0.6597365736961365,
0.07209179550409317,
0.3372659683227539,
0.17896993458271027,
0.6897566914558411,
-0.256473183631897,
-0.15785294771194458,
0.2664226293563843,
-0.3283206820487976,
0.28283190727233887,
0.4321853220462799,
-0.4742357134819031,
-0.47352755069732666,
1.1890524625778198,
-0.3808865249156952,
0.12448198348283768,
0.12148826569318771,
-0.07140195369720459,
0.08023402094841003,
-0.5640909671783447,
-0.5344713926315308,
-0.12888208031654358,
-0.5150327682495117,
-0.5694246292114258,
-0.28538089990615845,
-0.12022480368614197,
-0.34439921379089355,
-0.5774043202400208,
-0.44432637095451355,
0.07161223888397217,
0.1549167037010193,
-0.035305436700582504,
0.16483749449253082,
0.9386789202690125,
0.03854835778474808,
0.04958301782608032,
-1.0236682891845703,
0.6147028803825378,
0.17090699076652527,
0.2290651500225067,
-0.044546179473400116,
0.22394466400146484,
-0.24206119775772095,
0.0906028151512146,
-0.5096140503883362,
-0.9564825296401978,
0.4059722423553467,
0.13468369841575623,
0.4208488464355469,
0.004970666952431202,
0.37865960597991943,
0.5170152187347412,
-0.568905770778656,
0.7542197108268738,
0.11104995757341385,
-0.8975535035133362,
0.4387582242488861,
-0.12433324754238129,
0.6929245591163635,
0.4941193759441376,
-0.2002066820859909,
-0.311349481344223,
-0.8902596831321716,
-0.2203216850757599,
-0.895340621471405,
0.4744444489479065,
0.4879843294620514,
-0.039917606860399246,
-0.3006298243999481,
0.2048431634902954,
0.004033387638628483,
0.1781632900238037,
-0.3468518555164337,
-0.24217797815799713,
-0.19245971739292145,
-0.3271510601043701,
-0.23652969300746918,
-0.2165374457836151,
-0.14816422760486603,
-0.02460012398660183,
0.3487795293331146,
-0.32322728633880615,
0.4541795551776886,
0.342373788356781,
-0.2916563153266907,
-0.1486111581325531,
0.587827742099762,
0.8315459489822388,
0.6780505180358887,
0.015978891402482986,
0.07339531183242798,
-0.2080073356628418,
-0.3243892192840576,
0.4558830261230469,
0.2749468982219696,
-0.14513030648231506,
-0.1399414986371994,
0.3677540719509125,
0.5433661937713623,
0.07272019982337952,
-0.9049862623214722,
0.6079759001731873,
-0.17626360058784485,
-0.33285796642303467,
-0.1359299272298813,
0.13458947837352753,
0.11875440925359726,
0.4951285719871521,
0.4147186279296875,
0.17237579822540283,
0.19244761765003204,
-0.31783953309059143,
0.2365027219057083,
0.08295728266239166,
0.12591184675693512,
-0.23750819265842438,
0.7180266380310059,
0.5571611523628235,
-0.3570250868797302,
0.624337911605835,
-0.7752813696861267,
-0.8727665543556213,
1.063463568687439,
0.8402434587478638,
0.9706403017044067,
-0.20011401176452637,
0.28050675988197327,
0.38325732946395874,
0.34503868222236633,
0.03338709846138954,
0.6451244950294495,
-0.042397528886795044,
-0.5808770656585693,
-0.4633343517780304,
-0.41132020950317383,
-0.2530807554721832,
-0.40069830417633057,
-0.5171968340873718,
-0.09080445021390915,
-0.33512404561042786,
-0.2360784262418747,
-0.3999720513820648,
-0.09208619594573975,
-0.663222074508667,
-0.27533161640167236,
0.36419031023979187,
0.8067826628684998,
-0.38360998034477234,
0.679542601108551,
0.9178835153579712,
-0.3884771168231964,
-0.7573276162147522,
0.07054168730974197,
0.037807680666446686,
-0.6188938617706299,
0.33220285177230835,
0.40965911746025085,
-0.27957817912101746,
0.1871444284915924,
-0.4229227304458618,
-0.3613242506980896,
1.0864509344100952,
0.5379030108451843,
-0.531459629535675,
-0.058888912200927734,
0.17360027134418488,
0.5346882343292236,
-0.7081904411315918,
0.06905823200941086,
0.4250907301902771,
0.3861193358898163,
0.08571647852659225,
-0.7483158707618713,
0.3468713164329529,
-0.4165821969509125,
0.1576996147632599,
0.3473776876926422,
-0.4563981294631958,
0.6172474026679993,
-0.7350096702575684,
-0.21630358695983887,
0.1582682728767395,
0.1152438297867775,
0.6379340887069702,
0.2742071747779846,
0.2518128454685211,
0.19007541239261627,
0.5970285534858704,
0.04047245904803276,
1.0492165088653564,
-0.8850122690200806,
0.2823636531829834,
1.027429461479187,
-0.4886075258255005,
0.6658309102058411,
0.3028980791568756,
0.09729594737291336,
0.44198155403137207,
0.16695675253868103,
-0.09930163621902466,
0.43978649377822876,
0.5996136665344238,
-0.22055447101593018,
-0.27005472779273987,
-0.012236421927809715,
-0.5633707046508789,
0.3987026512622833,
-0.09935362637042999,
0.013059746474027634,
-0.1994016468524933,
0.00597436772659421,
-0.024822508916258812,
0.18519355356693268,
-0.037444520741701126,
0.706251323223114,
-0.20132344961166382,
-0.7579421997070312,
0.8157471418380737,
-0.0895644798874855,
0.32531917095184326,
-0.6644671559333801,
-0.4551679790019989,
-0.41460341215133667,
0.3928918242454529,
0.11039938777685165,
-0.5985696315765381,
0.1544315665960312,
0.10346325486898422,
-0.20777514576911926,
-0.4325171709060669,
0.4216553270816803,
-0.5451745986938477,
-0.2771633267402649,
0.3969210386276245,
0.4706069827079773,
-0.20508721470832825,
-0.22054359316825867,
-0.5244567394256592,
0.4281735122203827,
0.14061108231544495,
-0.09983330219984055,
-0.010455721989274025,
0.4337003231048584,
0.3311910331249237,
0.792344868183136,
0.7932230830192566,
0.06096315011382103,
0.4881601929664612,
0.03372812271118164,
1.0293235778808594,
-0.7921881079673767,
-0.592578649520874,
-0.6152667999267578,
0.4509808123111725,
0.07255492359399796,
-0.29766780138015747,
0.3840591013431549,
0.7466909885406494,
0.7129790782928467,
-0.3978476822376251,
0.8709744811058044,
-0.04247632995247841,
0.062361814081668854,
-0.346476674079895,
0.6413742303848267,
-0.30688947439193726,
0.28036707639694214,
-0.11293110251426697,
-0.8754906058311462,
-0.42531904578208923,
0.3182818591594696,
0.26886308193206787,
-0.13212153315544128,
0.586781919002533,
1.1656230688095093,
0.23299601674079895,
-0.33599725365638733,
0.17432820796966553,
0.06000051274895668,
0.6892927885055542,
1.0200084447860718,
0.8829487562179565,
-0.2348794788122177,
1.0824499130249023,
0.15741027891635895,
-0.2799789011478424,
-0.2058487832546234,
-0.5653606057167053,
-0.8960873484611511,
-0.5570151209831238,
-0.08416421711444855,
-0.3496541976928711,
0.17241986095905304,
1.2701685428619385,
0.6164918541908264,
-0.7249005436897278,
-0.4729060232639313,
-0.15893696248531342,
0.15550000965595245,
-0.35834234952926636,
-0.19505038857460022,
-0.06627658009529114,
-0.5146797299385071,
-0.43255555629730225,
0.43112751841545105,
0.14637653529644012,
-0.19175447523593903,
-0.15290433168411255,
-0.6140286922454834,
0.008203627541661263,
0.15521155297756195,
0.42850878834724426,
0.23607978224754333,
-0.4299190938472748,
0.17133809626102448,
-0.04426015168428421,
-0.4875180721282959,
0.2592359483242035,
1.2180402278900146,
-0.5330196022987366,
0.7231611013412476,
0.32547780871391296,
0.939384937286377,
0.3749920725822449,
-0.06059982627630234,
0.678607165813446,
-0.728489875793457,
0.10523182153701782,
0.13284435868263245,
0.08659854531288147,
0.2970781624317169,
-0.11592558026313782,
0.46856266260147095,
-0.053914766758680344,
-0.7074924111366272,
-0.7259697318077087,
0.3948518633842468,
-0.7395564317703247,
-0.2026502639055252,
1.157015323638916,
0.020551757887005806,
-0.10973816365003586,
0.05477670580148697,
-0.5712005496025085,
0.22355903685092926,
-0.8009242415428162,
0.7522964477539062,
0.37106573581695557,
-0.05816355720162392,
-0.09638740122318268,
-0.4347364902496338,
0.41091015934944153,
-0.08002997189760208,
-0.8372840881347656,
0.07108531147241592,
0.7712180614471436,
0.0741097703576088,
0.13682202994823456,
0.9808287024497986,
0.06538961082696915,
0.4452684223651886,
0.36819127202033997,
0.6474882364273071,
-0.5384506583213806,
-0.4211087226867676,
-0.1548035889863968,
0.26017746329307556,
0.3869955241680145,
-0.384281188249588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11357v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11357v2
|
Large Language Models Lack Understanding of Character Composition of Words
| 2024-05-18T18:08:58 | 2024-06-19T16:58:14 |
Andrew Shin, Kunitake Kaneko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performances on a
wide range of natural language tasks. Yet, LLMs' successes have been largely
restricted to tasks concerning words, sentences, or documents, and it remains
questionable how much they understand the minimal units of text, namely
characters. In this paper, we examine contemporary LLMs regarding their ability
to understand character composition of words, and show that most of them fail
to reliably carry out even the simple tasks that can be handled by humans with
perfection. We analyze their behaviors with comparison to token level
performances, and discuss the potential directions for future research.
|
[
-0.068122997879982,
-0.6747099161148071,
1.0215790271759033,
0.07510647922754288,
-0.19060911238193512,
0.516734778881073,
-0.23891957104206085,
-0.5437914729118347,
0.09476169943809509,
0.7071855068206787,
-0.7911950349807739,
-0.4497033655643463,
-0.7158242464065552,
0.49255624413490295,
-0.37159743905067444,
0.6901552677154541,
-0.07759547978639603,
-0.04736951366066933,
-0.4238561987876892,
0.0001742623426252976,
-0.6457928419113159,
-0.6896399855613708,
-0.6720811128616333,
-0.7186110615730286,
0.6192773580551147,
0.4787600338459015,
0.6853860020637512,
0.6078260540962219,
0.4209229052066803,
0.36016881465911865,
-0.40529075264930725,
0.4402468502521515,
-0.8401406407356262,
0.14725439250469208,
-0.1358707845211029,
-0.8464637994766235,
-0.1952924281358719,
-0.08416421711444855,
1.062940001487732,
1.0502140522003174,
0.2648874521255493,
-0.3404417634010315,
0.14726179838180542,
0.7040504217147827,
-0.3358544707298279,
0.3709484040737152,
-0.5628851652145386,
0.11164391785860062,
-0.06497036665678024,
0.10291649401187897,
-0.4915316104888916,
0.039476316422224045,
-0.057284191250801086,
-0.7357184290885925,
0.18769264221191406,
0.43642520904541016,
0.7235556840896606,
-0.07702654600143433,
-0.6482048630714417,
-0.6584024429321289,
-0.6006140112876892,
1.005548357963562,
-0.6785035729408264,
0.09984847903251648,
0.6134950518608093,
-0.13190406560897827,
-0.4142161011695862,
-0.4187198281288147,
-0.7335458993911743,
-0.5371622443199158,
-0.19305534660816193,
-0.32454773783683777,
-0.09996882826089859,
0.2750302255153656,
0.3929866552352905,
0.48995575308799744,
-0.4072929620742798,
0.5746171474456787,
-0.15695029497146606,
-0.13190491497516632,
0.44740399718284607,
0.7277795672416687,
0.5763583779335022,
-0.47567567229270935,
-0.29849937558174133,
-0.07164061814546585,
-0.572740912437439,
0.10644753277301788,
0.1388922780752182,
0.2155468612909317,
-0.16085383296012878,
0.8227729797363281,
0.18618610501289368,
0.5397171378135681,
-0.22545580565929413,
-0.37187689542770386,
-0.2749691605567932,
-0.3584766685962677,
-0.5414213538169861,
-0.37879303097724915,
0.7681546807289124,
0.11111363023519516,
0.38461393117904663,
-0.27025726437568665,
-0.39698487520217896,
-0.13599999248981476,
0.19565925002098083,
-0.705916702747345,
-0.03249558433890343,
0.10871455818414688,
-0.3558134436607361,
0.010860882699489594,
-0.12271040678024292,
-0.21040606498718262,
-0.8065053820610046,
-0.46137523651123047,
0.5260360836982727,
-0.6478572487831116,
-0.05834413319826126,
0.07567841559648514,
-0.2166835218667984,
0.21424998342990875,
0.3970198631286621,
-1.0830018520355225,
0.2878054976463318,
1.0204198360443115,
0.9067025780677795,
-0.45418089628219604,
-0.39180994033813477,
-0.19344978034496307,
0.07641283422708511,
-0.5961651802062988,
0.5975911617279053,
-0.582773745059967,
-0.6366092562675476,
-0.13408909738063812,
0.2703832983970642,
-0.531912088394165,
-0.503372848033905,
0.6826490163803101,
-0.2929506301879883,
-0.2097044140100479,
-0.854841947555542,
-0.9584025144577026,
-0.2762785851955414,
0.15866029262542725,
-0.6825031638145447,
0.32115888595581055,
0.09167233109474182,
-0.6519186496734619,
0.1300431340932846,
-0.26736465096473694,
-0.5209915637969971,
0.054744452238082886,
-0.08586680144071579,
0.13992705941200256,
0.686561644077301,
-0.05910865217447281,
0.7898740768432617,
-0.22344815731048584,
-0.07442950457334518,
-0.21846504509449005,
-0.843813955783844,
0.78435879945755,
-0.36548149585723877,
0.6185421943664551,
0.18800342082977295,
0.1285875290632248,
-0.03193964064121246,
-0.6084962487220764,
-0.27662864327430725,
0.1914314329624176,
-0.2950643002986908,
-0.31845730543136597,
0.3001852035522461,
0.08808443695306778,
0.012458101846277714,
0.29628393054008484,
-0.44247695803642273,
0.35509735345840454,
-0.29799720644950867,
0.7701574563980103,
0.8816021680831909,
-0.40910449624061584,
0.5645759105682373,
-0.5329816341400146,
0.7467926144599915,
-0.3007834255695343,
-0.38320252299308777,
-0.33508554100990295,
-0.08093719184398651,
-0.9597997665405273,
-0.3839036524295807,
0.10915452241897583,
0.23934981226921082,
-0.7437050938606262,
0.42732810974121094,
-0.5543543100357056,
-0.41222676634788513,
-0.1378004103899002,
0.322730153799057,
0.38919976353645325,
0.18495842814445496,
-0.060859933495521545,
-0.34932801127433777,
-0.16959170997142792,
-0.9371890425682068,
-0.37395113706588745,
-0.31583109498023987,
-0.09544659405946732,
0.19636893272399902,
0.5379378795623779,
-0.3260203003883362,
0.5664464235305786,
-0.32098841667175293,
-0.2946643531322479,
-0.7853564023971558,
0.025767866522073746,
-0.010876269079744816,
0.22528566420078278,
0.3296448290348053,
-0.49472934007644653,
-0.23277762532234192,
0.032470062375068665,
-0.6852483749389648,
0.16017965972423553,
-0.12083517014980316,
0.238576278090477,
0.1666795164346695,
0.6073049306869507,
-0.6115126013755798,
0.011208219453692436,
0.7755663990974426,
-0.5738059878349304,
0.5499105453491211,
-0.2673541009426117,
-0.0040274388156831264,
-0.905974805355072,
0.10778951644897461,
0.05624709278345108,
-0.39045894145965576,
-0.8083223700523376,
0.23599019646644592,
0.0007098771748133004,
0.016660176217556,
-0.240407332777977,
0.6870015859603882,
-0.6183804273605347,
-0.34149685502052307,
-0.4552544057369232,
0.2621755599975586,
0.19793862104415894,
0.36859795451164246,
-0.0564417690038681,
0.6642720103263855,
0.19750165939331055,
-0.5989318490028381,
0.1966206580400467,
0.1353217214345932,
-0.5882031917572021,
0.6152716875076294,
-0.7336298227310181,
0.11385747790336609,
-0.33569133281707764,
0.12084279954433441,
-1.3018521070480347,
-0.691510796546936,
-0.13774923980236053,
-0.2680843770503998,
0.664376974105835,
0.02102874405682087,
-0.735050618648529,
-0.3646461069583893,
-0.18164248764514923,
0.16883163154125214,
0.4282347559928894,
-0.018422385677695274,
0.5164713263511658,
0.25398847460746765,
-0.18647508323192596,
-0.3282627761363983,
-1.0345121622085571,
0.23279787600040436,
-0.03844142332673073,
-0.5930808186531067,
-0.009584606625139713,
-0.073091059923172,
-0.4282330274581909,
-0.2063097059726715,
-0.10683543235063553,
-0.07782416045665741,
0.2380993664264679,
0.3263155221939087,
0.12534518539905548,
-0.12804153561592102,
0.24602092802524567,
-0.20048251748085022,
0.2385576069355011,
-0.03830544650554657,
0.261199414730072,
0.657179057598114,
0.05653815716505051,
-0.5475971102714539,
-0.7352328896522522,
0.3805045783519745,
1.0399458408355713,
0.05292664095759392,
0.9821258783340454,
0.36326462030410767,
-0.26177898049354553,
-0.07194768637418747,
-0.533875048160553,
0.00048528765910305083,
-0.44281673431396484,
0.71891850233078,
-0.3400489389896393,
-1.2667250633239746,
0.723883330821991,
0.3660441040992737,
0.018712110817432404,
0.6673124432563782,
0.2669117748737335,
-0.34936627745628357,
0.922670841217041,
0.6732845306396484,
-0.08203669637441635,
0.413242369890213,
0.05469952151179314,
0.16029475629329681,
-0.974568784236908,
-0.18251270055770874,
-0.7010239362716675,
-0.4515294134616852,
-0.7473127841949463,
-0.4165501296520233,
0.10423543304204941,
0.20308122038841248,
-0.30687251687049866,
0.23376600444316864,
-0.17246313393115997,
0.4144434928894043,
0.13553915917873383,
-0.06232761964201927,
0.43136146664619446,
0.08327321708202362,
0.07277898490428925,
-0.15928910672664642,
-0.47685524821281433,
-0.8085648417472839,
0.7646956443786621,
0.5698741674423218,
1.024978756904602,
-0.023383423686027527,
0.36116185784339905,
0.28512629866600037,
-0.025771770626306534,
-0.9875455498695374,
0.6644498109817505,
-0.5650640726089478,
-0.4244440793991089,
-0.3639346659183502,
-0.640624463558197,
-1.0806622505187988,
0.27994924783706665,
-0.04692502319812775,
-0.771327555179596,
0.005683824885636568,
-0.045607294887304306,
-0.15581484138965607,
0.3367415964603424,
-0.6693100929260254,
0.7593504190444946,
-0.12388185411691666,
-0.02544051595032215,
-0.1276874542236328,
-0.35884666442871094,
0.5946086049079895,
-0.20585481822490692,
0.4168957769870758,
-0.3002716600894928,
-0.1412719041109085,
0.8178042769432068,
-0.4281509518623352,
0.9186668395996094,
0.19111573696136475,
-0.31652703881263733,
0.11711560189723969,
0.17305061221122742,
0.6729959845542908,
-0.2572415769100189,
-0.21936139464378357,
-0.10312189161777496,
0.12855997681617737,
-0.549567461013794,
-0.3080504834651947,
0.7574931979179382,
-0.7865169644355774,
-0.45687055587768555,
-0.29793834686279297,
-0.48588210344314575,
-0.2608548402786255,
-0.04266257956624031,
0.31636860966682434,
0.3256306052207947,
-0.3288933038711548,
0.3529428243637085,
0.672640323638916,
-0.17223875224590302,
0.5635653138160706,
0.2931211292743683,
-0.1983935683965683,
-0.16302400827407837,
0.7574789524078369,
0.2010105848312378,
0.5167352557182312,
0.37444591522216797,
0.021162234246730804,
-0.28424152731895447,
-0.6543052196502686,
-0.2721521258354187,
0.4642883241176605,
-0.7329450845718384,
0.215423583984375,
-0.7024985551834106,
-0.16995961964130402,
-0.13859377801418304,
-0.13671185076236725,
-0.14320506155490875,
-0.11055786907672882,
-0.7095917463302612,
0.0029993578791618347,
0.08574773371219635,
1.3245588541030884,
0.4569011926651001,
0.5358166098594666,
-0.8836683630943298,
0.15816795825958252,
0.41067641973495483,
0.09015762805938721,
0.2708955407142639,
-0.9617351293563843,
-0.30979204177856445,
0.02190774492919445,
-0.28513282537460327,
-0.6513776779174805,
0.31089046597480774,
0.20686666667461395,
0.4747774004936218,
0.5483894348144531,
-0.24723055958747864,
0.609710156917572,
-0.3591015636920929,
1.0908925533294678,
0.11747029423713684,
-1.2706382274627686,
0.054958753287792206,
-0.27758777141571045,
0.39641064405441284,
0.40939128398895264,
0.3210241496562958,
-0.9118273854255676,
-0.3004007637500763,
-0.15735068917274475,
-0.4532430171966553,
0.8595590591430664,
0.17998892068862915,
0.6134976148605347,
-0.027539465576410294,
0.4267043471336365,
0.1408519446849823,
0.17835336923599243,
-0.70099276304245,
-0.01599016599357128,
0.2750646471977234,
-0.23252369463443756,
-0.4751795530319214,
-0.6162262558937073,
0.38469570875167847,
-0.08568930625915527,
0.3684500455856323,
-0.17688076198101044,
0.2743963599205017,
0.102724090218544,
-0.2065705806016922,
-0.14195729792118073,
0.2897971272468567,
1.0189297199249268,
0.7801045775413513,
0.11446274071931839,
0.16863463819026947,
0.06957706063985825,
-0.4751039147377014,
0.18184658885002136,
-0.3272329568862915,
0.06264594942331314,
-0.21791110932826996,
1.0429372787475586,
1.0967448949813843,
0.44390520453453064,
-0.8223381638526917,
0.4499013423919678,
-0.12760885059833527,
-0.2126147747039795,
-0.14762456715106964,
0.25734958052635193,
0.49052050709724426,
0.14922450482845306,
0.32906466722488403,
-0.30947166681289673,
-0.3344762623310089,
-1.0891728401184082,
-0.3041362762451172,
0.5205034613609314,
-0.44895341992378235,
-0.5037461519241333,
0.351162850856781,
0.04392775893211365,
-0.3071373701095581,
0.7210338711738586,
-0.20597168803215027,
-0.6222171187400818,
0.7070509195327759,
0.5287510752677917,
0.8033499717712402,
0.05011635273694992,
0.09025033563375473,
0.05722352862358093,
0.4611344039440155,
-0.36608392000198364,
0.15533266961574554,
0.32084113359451294,
-0.7931110262870789,
-0.7321368455886841,
-0.9240401983261108,
-0.43640443682670593,
0.21491993963718414,
-0.24987538158893585,
0.002905308734625578,
-0.5335082411766052,
-0.04015645757317543,
-0.20101052522659302,
0.18440045416355133,
-0.8878971934318542,
0.1250024288892746,
0.051891714334487915,
0.6669874787330627,
-0.8332414627075195,
0.47560763359069824,
0.578066885471344,
-0.359144926071167,
-0.9191460013389587,
0.06128939986228943,
-0.21612121164798737,
-0.7601562142372131,
0.7207558155059814,
0.2711941599845886,
0.2083323746919632,
-0.08235717564821243,
-0.4527961313724518,
-0.5947712659835815,
0.7922447323799133,
0.5099213719367981,
-0.7177968621253967,
-0.5669426321983337,
0.34238752722740173,
0.7324249148368835,
-0.23269473016262054,
0.15353521704673767,
0.4206674098968506,
0.6496790647506714,
0.1468973606824875,
-1.0125024318695068,
0.007731130346655846,
0.22061830759048462,
0.15404775738716125,
-0.1551857590675354,
-0.8259719014167786,
1.126731038093567,
-0.0722413882613182,
-0.25664007663726807,
0.3963446021080017,
0.6580020785331726,
0.015054070390760899,
0.19844314455986023,
0.286419540643692,
0.39204105734825134,
0.8597239851951599,
-0.1317569762468338,
1.325287938117981,
0.1821388304233551,
0.24910405278205872,
0.7389672994613647,
-0.31091952323913574,
0.8726472854614258,
0.12001310288906097,
-0.33659398555755615,
0.36076819896698,
0.5526946187019348,
0.09766612946987152,
0.037532031536102295,
0.4186108708381653,
-0.28829988837242126,
-0.7236421704292297,
-0.09678814560174942,
0.12064022570848465,
0.7618575692176819,
0.4340839385986328,
-0.6305209398269653,
0.28893208503723145,
0.0990467220544815,
-0.07517024874687195,
0.13585048913955688,
-0.5748220086097717,
0.8719291090965271,
0.4137573540210724,
-0.5872580409049988,
0.5027939677238464,
0.17674706876277924,
0.6233835220336914,
-0.5338125824928284,
0.21811507642269135,
-0.28432804346084595,
-0.05301886051893234,
-0.11189451813697815,
-0.859254777431488,
0.2120932638645172,
-0.02942732721567154,
-0.1708253026008606,
0.06845743954181671,
0.7126709818840027,
-0.09142012894153595,
-0.5632553696632385,
0.060968510806560516,
0.4605468213558197,
0.37323540449142456,
-0.2131624072790146,
-0.167992502450943,
0.4304450452327728,
-0.016785774379968643,
-0.07867664098739624,
0.3089412450790405,
0.7619500160217285,
0.01338799949735403,
0.8284761309623718,
0.35598477721214294,
0.052677810192108154,
-0.07909002900123596,
-0.3360835015773773,
0.4980962574481964,
-0.8423708081245422,
-0.19330964982509613,
-1.1339746713638306,
0.1524290293455124,
-0.02358320541679859,
-0.19465287029743195,
0.7548718452453613,
0.2854626774787903,
0.618268609046936,
-0.193055659532547,
0.640557587146759,
0.24421042203903198,
0.2755630612373352,
-0.6862961053848267,
0.8522840142250061,
-0.6844891309738159,
0.1696852296590805,
-0.22774454951286316,
-1.0308514833450317,
0.005690994206815958,
0.48351791501045227,
-0.012087931856513023,
0.21974453330039978,
0.6801773905754089,
0.4522501826286316,
0.09088481962680817,
-0.004954657517373562,
0.9397468566894531,
0.37026113271713257,
0.3472748100757599,
0.7101312279701233,
0.8921720385551453,
-0.0418822206556797,
0.1948886215686798,
0.3231790065765381,
0.08639580011367798,
-0.428189754486084,
-0.745972216129303,
-1.3434135913848877,
-0.46895691752433777,
0.08042686432600021,
-0.017854956910014153,
-0.07218597084283829,
0.9113048911094666,
0.5229954719543457,
-0.585420548915863,
-0.02929285354912281,
-0.2364843785762787,
0.3922612965106964,
0.21761749684810638,
-0.14955857396125793,
0.26316872239112854,
-0.4536621868610382,
-0.9963332414627075,
0.5040340423583984,
0.2764520049095154,
0.11368699371814728,
-0.487941712141037,
-0.04804015904664993,
0.20553138852119446,
0.4689094126224518,
0.6732104420661926,
0.22650359570980072,
-1.0063248872756958,
-0.4290166199207306,
0.05219199135899544,
-0.48986369371414185,
-0.041746675968170166,
0.8890941739082336,
-0.2698870897293091,
0.24881158769130707,
0.6924717426300049,
0.6920605897903442,
0.09581996500492096,
-0.12968574464321136,
0.486764132976532,
-0.5890080332756042,
-0.3671773076057434,
0.2499091774225235,
0.47743168473243713,
0.5915241241455078,
-0.11965770274400711,
0.11596126854419708,
0.38916370272636414,
-0.7938648462295532,
-0.5389076471328735,
0.30926206707954407,
-0.9513335227966309,
-0.4129876494407654,
1.2155565023422241,
-0.26884210109710693,
-0.41271811723709106,
0.004826728720217943,
-0.33419737219810486,
0.15525688230991364,
-0.16959644854068756,
0.37977904081344604,
1.2611089944839478,
-0.013999073766171932,
-0.11755505949258804,
-0.5475838780403137,
0.3588733375072479,
0.49125513434410095,
-0.566740870475769,
0.43907347321510315,
0.6248161792755127,
0.37592563033103943,
-0.0017339158803224564,
0.6303837299346924,
0.11709829419851303,
-0.1888241171836853,
-0.21404653787612915,
-0.2238680124282837,
0.07829057425260544,
-0.04750905930995941,
-0.4474998116493225,
0.24627824127674103,
0.6614079475402832,
0.2987905740737915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11301v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11301v1
|
Enhancing Fine-Grained Image Classifications via Cascaded Vision Language Models
| 2024-05-18T14:12:04 | 2024-05-18T14:12:04 |
Canshi Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Fine-grained image classification, particularly in zero/few-shot scenarios,
presents a significant challenge for vision-language models (VLMs), such as
CLIP. These models often struggle with the nuanced task of distinguishing
between semantically similar classes due to limitations in their pre-trained
recipe, which lacks supervision signals for fine-grained categorization. This
paper introduces CascadeVLM, an innovative framework that overcomes the
constraints of previous CLIP-based methods by effectively leveraging the
granular knowledge encapsulated within large vision-language models (LVLMs).
Experiments across various fine-grained image datasets demonstrate that
CascadeVLM significantly outperforms existing models, specifically on the
Stanford Cars dataset, achieving an impressive 85.6% zero-shot accuracy.
Performance gain analysis validates that LVLMs produce more accurate
predictions for challenging images that CLIPs are uncertain about, bringing the
overall accuracy boost. Our framework sheds light on a holistic integration of
VLMs and LVLMs for effective and efficient fine-grained image classification.
|
[
-0.5360932350158691,
-0.5277139544487,
0.3039284944534302,
-0.08404118567705154,
-0.1509961485862732,
0.22090639173984528,
0.035687707364559174,
-0.7318260073661804,
-0.435626745223999,
0.5043359994888306,
-0.18543562293052673,
-0.6838189959526062,
-0.42371076345443726,
-0.3927416503429413,
-0.7035678029060364,
0.7902405261993408,
0.03534218668937683,
0.28013619780540466,
-0.20698575675487518,
-0.23207765817642212,
-0.3732839524745941,
-0.3676587641239166,
-0.37308135628700256,
-0.3336392939090729,
0.46457815170288086,
0.12054400146007538,
0.7181810140609741,
0.6756395101547241,
0.6811527013778687,
0.14142175018787384,
-0.24933499097824097,
0.26115667819976807,
-0.2341860830783844,
-0.35029706358909607,
-0.31797274947166443,
-0.25812992453575134,
-0.19264669716358185,
-0.3630613088607788,
0.23579581081867218,
0.5237869620323181,
-0.19121070206165314,
0.3113514482975006,
0.28799423575401306,
0.43326014280319214,
-1.2507487535476685,
0.18127845227718353,
-0.7830724120140076,
0.22991278767585754,
-0.5398216843605042,
-0.2819484770298004,
-0.30571380257606506,
-0.036394212394952774,
0.04379134997725487,
-0.36352235078811646,
0.22727879881858826,
-0.10062441229820251,
1.1084232330322266,
0.33993402123451233,
-0.014546419493854046,
0.03892496973276138,
-0.7514832019805908,
0.7770224809646606,
-0.5538694262504578,
0.3181174099445343,
0.12965704500675201,
0.5912575721740723,
-0.042840152978897095,
-0.7933337688446045,
-0.4975862205028534,
0.15417852997779846,
0.0706082209944725,
-0.13661731779575348,
-0.11000582575798035,
0.1457286775112152,
0.04353359714150429,
0.426574170589447,
-0.047678347676992416,
0.3124638795852661,
-0.18615469336509705,
-0.14665430784225464,
0.22808754444122314,
0.5024092793464661,
0.2893657386302948,
-0.011761891655623913,
-0.4983982741832733,
-0.11913011223077774,
-0.39284443855285645,
0.41857096552848816,
-0.4431253671646118,
0.49488115310668945,
0.08115224540233612,
0.38419973850250244,
-0.4865882396697998,
0.9164497256278992,
0.16671015322208405,
-0.4131454527378082,
0.028484901413321495,
-0.07661080360412598,
-0.5066677927970886,
-0.029125157743692398,
0.5776917338371277,
0.7760352492332458,
0.08328486233949661,
0.0011094458168372512,
-0.20364703238010406,
0.1712527573108673,
0.04834868386387825,
-1.0575660467147827,
-0.11024820059537888,
-0.051442354917526245,
-0.3285309374332428,
-0.5584648251533508,
-0.003854075912386179,
-0.6124116778373718,
-0.274572491645813,
-0.2885171175003052,
0.7247093915939331,
-0.2791675925254822,
0.4151943027973175,
0.2611466348171234,
-0.17848531901836395,
0.7244753837585449,
0.8236347436904907,
-0.6434431076049805,
0.2601569890975952,
0.8468478918075562,
0.9299174547195435,
-0.04101938009262085,
-0.38941270112991333,
-0.7767712473869324,
0.2917371690273285,
-0.4225459098815918,
0.9246647357940674,
-0.669181764125824,
-0.11033204942941666,
0.22205506265163422,
-0.03597366437315941,
0.3576059937477112,
-0.5446228981018066,
0.2971515357494354,
-0.34048226475715637,
-0.14807212352752686,
-0.017640698701143265,
-0.2979064881801605,
-0.05080144852399826,
0.5617527961730957,
-0.12841039896011353,
1.1731038093566895,
0.04369641840457916,
-0.7698739171028137,
0.5549548864364624,
-0.012213156558573246,
-0.4340631365776062,
0.39068588614463806,
-0.3917997479438782,
-0.29213663935661316,
0.20800833404064178,
0.38350537419319153,
0.7421770691871643,
-0.2203945815563202,
0.2524065375328064,
-0.7494421601295471,
-0.2947874665260315,
-0.06867419928312302,
-0.5160773992538452,
0.5293253064155579,
0.0007271887152455747,
0.12236716598272324,
-0.028256289660930634,
-0.6939124464988708,
0.1735604852437973,
-0.11829765886068344,
-0.07906395196914673,
-0.7266425490379333,
-0.10653000324964523,
0.05816198140382767,
0.34901851415634155,
0.17688411474227905,
-0.5698480010032654,
0.35616782307624817,
-0.1373865306377411,
0.09021612256765366,
0.5402034521102905,
-0.17387522757053375,
0.5851821899414062,
-0.07026607543230057,
0.08396093547344208,
0.20954087376594543,
0.5155733227729797,
-0.4272030293941498,
-0.36761194467544556,
-0.7761639356613159,
-0.30565550923347473,
0.10451744496822357,
0.6109366416931152,
-0.982796847820282,
0.09405463933944702,
-0.12197276204824448,
-0.4338657557964325,
-0.37655773758888245,
0.13920524716377258,
0.4121500253677368,
0.7655998468399048,
0.49885380268096924,
-0.676552951335907,
-0.2978379726409912,
-0.7399479150772095,
-0.06518865376710892,
0.16790597140789032,
-0.23648731410503387,
0.4666263163089752,
0.2842485010623932,
-0.22352135181427002,
1.120680809020996,
-0.8378716707229614,
-0.6277260184288025,
-0.12965428829193115,
0.20379552245140076,
-0.08453886955976486,
0.3818109333515167,
0.6810963749885559,
-0.39964428544044495,
-0.5356274843215942,
0.3482871949672699,
-0.74496990442276,
-0.07096748799085617,
0.054079681634902954,
-0.04101402685046196,
-0.08960705250501633,
0.5267609357833862,
-0.337597131729126,
0.7919456958770752,
0.06628493219614029,
-0.0694216936826706,
0.6383273601531982,
-0.19552260637283325,
0.020360896363854408,
-0.5526111125946045,
-0.3602048456668854,
0.09008410573005676,
-0.5132471919059753,
-0.6227393746376038,
0.21149994432926178,
0.14541393518447876,
0.05363171175122261,
-1.0214009284973145,
0.5903136134147644,
-0.1261177361011505,
-0.24733173847198486,
-0.44367715716362,
-0.16581809520721436,
0.08220916241407394,
0.3131847679615021,
0.3272315561771393,
0.5126780867576599,
1.2254332304000854,
-0.7222198843955994,
0.0941094383597374,
0.25505343079566956,
-0.5823276042938232,
0.7774286270141602,
-0.3727320730686188,
-0.23238801956176758,
-0.2414228916168213,
0.40035873651504517,
-0.4235902726650238,
-0.45830535888671875,
-0.0758303552865982,
0.08899179100990295,
0.3316357731819153,
-0.2416764199733734,
-0.26999104022979736,
-0.4793320298194885,
-0.44889163970947266,
0.5908899903297424,
0.743308961391449,
-0.7043510675430298,
0.438299298286438,
0.3104079067707062,
0.2662646174430847,
-0.6810932159423828,
-0.7910280823707581,
0.06755287945270538,
-0.02790837734937668,
-0.26301106810569763,
0.36504024267196655,
0.2699858844280243,
0.06912855058908463,
0.009523771703243256,
-0.003973963670432568,
-0.37353259325027466,
-0.09137842804193497,
0.27149686217308044,
0.3880859315395355,
-0.24149373173713684,
-0.04888978973031044,
-0.18087272346019745,
0.09581281989812851,
-0.49379608035087585,
-0.4338817894458771,
0.6001749038696289,
-0.34742775559425354,
-0.17568422853946686,
-0.5591374635696411,
0.045378852635622025,
0.7753320336341858,
-0.2717888355255127,
0.5468512773513794,
0.9967424869537354,
-0.2555924355983734,
-0.41734519600868225,
-0.30624619126319885,
0.14968813955783844,
-0.4678725302219391,
0.3023155927658081,
-0.20846131443977356,
-0.9588587284088135,
0.39383813738822937,
-0.14309071004390717,
-0.1250481754541397,
0.19791977107524872,
0.5186019539833069,
-0.4213670492172241,
0.8702781200408936,
0.6484369039535522,
-0.056483760476112366,
0.8503323793411255,
-0.26221853494644165,
-0.009584992192685604,
-0.9662682414054871,
-0.4845980405807495,
-0.1914500743150711,
-0.24479851126670837,
-0.3890640437602997,
-1.0031323432922363,
0.23663783073425293,
0.35986143350601196,
-0.17539212107658386,
0.2003430277109146,
-0.4020208716392517,
0.8936960697174072,
0.4240778386592865,
0.2620244026184082,
0.2320627123117447,
0.053003259003162384,
0.13797608017921448,
0.17870542407035828,
-0.6251500248908997,
-0.21874967217445374,
0.6953040361404419,
0.40777239203453064,
1.152733325958252,
-0.40620365738868713,
0.5976108312606812,
0.3670593798160553,
0.19574865698814392,
-1.2345306873321533,
0.6358893513679504,
-0.6952393054962158,
-0.3244364857673645,
-0.04937940835952759,
-0.13617107272148132,
-0.3578674793243408,
0.20755839347839355,
-0.08919637650251389,
-0.7481555938720703,
0.42320194840431213,
0.2847880721092224,
-0.6172584295272827,
0.5494334697723389,
-0.2399371713399887,
0.7762411236763,
-0.29846271872520447,
-0.5502643585205078,
0.14245983958244324,
-0.6057822108268738,
0.6052277088165283,
-0.04147116467356682,
0.23328211903572083,
-0.26214396953582764,
0.1605045199394226,
0.27253249287605286,
-0.7815207242965698,
0.9192605018615723,
-0.12846165895462036,
-0.1445644348859787,
0.4939954876899719,
0.14711149036884308,
0.3358001112937927,
-0.3338521420955658,
0.34760579466819763,
0.5511617660522461,
0.11700183898210526,
-0.37833306193351746,
-0.518879771232605,
0.5281159281730652,
-0.3229193091392517,
-0.2157224863767624,
-0.2426784634590149,
-0.5400208830833435,
-0.1563694030046463,
0.18256866931915283,
0.2861647605895996,
0.76814866065979,
-0.029620587825775146,
0.1807788610458374,
0.39196866750717163,
-0.33678489923477173,
0.5500409603118896,
0.3609192669391632,
-0.6993892192840576,
-0.29266518354415894,
0.9812873601913452,
0.020175188779830933,
0.36991792917251587,
0.4097449481487274,
0.17113204300403595,
0.012629788368940353,
-0.6363615989685059,
-0.36447155475616455,
-0.4244285523891449,
-0.8105814456939697,
-0.6105025410652161,
-0.4381210207939148,
-0.421430766582489,
-0.19344386458396912,
-0.4411470890045166,
-0.624733030796051,
-0.27496689558029175,
-0.31288453936576843,
0.3005283772945404,
-0.019751887768507004,
0.6115342974662781,
0.10463155061006546,
0.4534643292427063,
-0.9632954597473145,
0.23899424076080322,
0.6107890009880066,
0.4551820456981659,
0.18622712790966034,
-0.5561628341674805,
-0.16492417454719543,
-0.15284618735313416,
-0.44417673349380493,
-0.28667744994163513,
0.38100048899650574,
0.49543288350105286,
0.18435707688331604,
0.6086245179176331,
-0.0310682225972414,
1.3778043985366821,
-0.8733000159263611,
0.8901721835136414,
0.5071203112602234,
-1.031276822090149,
0.5599178075790405,
-0.08399638533592224,
0.41295796632766724,
0.6060814261436462,
-0.04699285328388214,
-0.3319062888622284,
-0.46932217478752136,
-0.3147408962249756,
-0.8470469117164612,
0.6769953370094299,
0.03579024598002434,
0.17561569809913635,
0.07765830308198929,
0.10210588574409485,
0.10599162429571152,
0.14640963077545166,
-0.5544273853302002,
0.09199625253677368,
-0.17116311192512512,
-0.23899687826633453,
0.2663794457912445,
-0.050763215869665146,
0.09081960469484329,
-0.641732394695282,
0.3220260739326477,
-0.19116057455539703,
-0.2845751941204071,
0.1736328899860382,
-0.20035777986049652,
0.07372677326202393,
0.1838972568511963,
0.5006116032600403,
0.0985151007771492,
-0.3274987041950226,
0.5099220871925354,
0.33984628319740295,
-0.44387561082839966,
0.1197841465473175,
-0.3970262110233307,
-0.5528344511985779,
-0.15106011927127838,
0.5528824925422668,
0.7901039719581604,
0.26380807161331177,
-0.6319729685783386,
0.6975664496421814,
0.02579808048903942,
0.0036198932211846113,
0.18146413564682007,
0.18290892243385315,
-0.5841553807258606,
0.2659054100513458,
0.32570233941078186,
0.5888102650642395,
0.3062736392021179,
-0.6178056597709656,
0.5344139933586121,
0.7001882791519165,
-0.7460832595825195,
-0.3447319567203522,
0.3313163220882416,
0.18947546184062958,
-0.22071045637130737,
0.09775558114051819,
-0.3434546887874603,
-0.7109502553939819,
0.37665751576423645,
0.4721440374851227,
0.9453251361846924,
-0.06352443248033524,
0.37797626852989197,
0.20712366700172424,
0.07519461959600449,
-0.4859900176525116,
-0.12139104306697845,
-0.2585947513580322,
-0.8113303184509277,
-0.23512685298919678,
-1.1842601299285889,
-0.34678372740745544,
0.16437514126300812,
-0.7591123580932617,
0.5079877972602844,
-0.6855630874633789,
-0.07842326164245605,
0.03505271300673485,
-0.7193231582641602,
-0.7106236815452576,
0.13476532697677612,
0.6646031737327576,
1.0769134759902954,
-0.7830692529678345,
0.8736717104911804,
0.4818134009838104,
-0.16229520738124847,
-0.627426028251648,
0.2700680196285248,
-0.2293432354927063,
-0.8225866556167603,
0.864244818687439,
0.3612598776817322,
-0.39385131001472473,
-0.10780491679906845,
-0.818340003490448,
-0.5798543095588684,
0.9566283822059631,
0.1510365605354309,
-0.6408094167709351,
0.0030070513021200895,
0.16341009736061096,
0.5285291075706482,
-0.5307217836380005,
-0.07903053611516953,
0.5902626514434814,
-0.008745049126446247,
0.8249717950820923,
-0.9329361915588379,
-0.503534734249115,
0.25879937410354614,
0.23527906835079193,
0.2639926075935364,
-0.5082260370254517,
0.8319433927536011,
-0.2375897318124771,
-0.1788383275270462,
0.026362339034676552,
0.5105626583099365,
-0.1977032572031021,
0.8076401352882385,
0.33059993386268616,
0.7332995533943176,
0.5293884873390198,
-0.04169769585132599,
1.081671953201294,
-0.10937226563692093,
0.7715694904327393,
1.4707374572753906,
-0.5223231911659241,
1.2005231380462646,
0.3886103332042694,
-0.26567965745925903,
0.4670528173446655,
0.44382381439208984,
-0.1548362523317337,
0.9254082441329956,
-0.19419069588184357,
-0.2469950169324875,
-0.7551308274269104,
-0.6174063086509705,
-0.07366158813238144,
0.7031484842300415,
0.24857838451862335,
-0.21344898641109467,
-0.769493818283081,
0.5022773146629333,
-0.3400343656539917,
-0.27430805563926697,
-0.9249972701072693,
0.7369938492774963,
0.12334942817687988,
-0.09908749163150787,
0.6221730709075928,
-0.28895270824432373,
0.8079430460929871,
-0.22868920862674713,
0.08892250061035156,
-0.07079321891069412,
0.5752608776092529,
-0.3250707685947418,
-1.2397258281707764,
0.33714377880096436,
0.2789120674133301,
-0.019323008134961128,
0.02296990342438221,
0.9884932637214661,
-0.46551790833473206,
-0.7447318434715271,
0.08083689957857132,
0.12523865699768066,
-0.03683723136782646,
-0.17219099402427673,
-0.516158938407898,
0.12786532938480377,
-0.25910213589668274,
0.4021346867084503,
0.26751649379730225,
0.37516021728515625,
-0.18380093574523926,
0.648124635219574,
0.44495925307273865,
0.017049001529812813,
0.09079685807228088,
0.08654586225748062,
0.8687829971313477,
-0.5551918745040894,
-0.2382545918226242,
-1.047550082206726,
0.5061770081520081,
-0.090884268283844,
0.06750944256782532,
0.6550765633583069,
0.5874283313751221,
0.9373329877853394,
-0.3743439018726349,
0.639718770980835,
-0.09274592250585556,
-0.048367176204919815,
-0.47473111748695374,
0.2529088854789734,
-0.7714961767196655,
0.19075961410999298,
-0.526738166809082,
-0.6352843642234802,
-0.6316734552383423,
0.5005195736885071,
-0.36483198404312134,
-0.3675829768180847,
0.41655707359313965,
0.6512349247932434,
-0.4519987404346466,
-0.38895514607429504,
0.6783689260482788,
0.15004949271678925,
0.20713873207569122,
0.6561275720596313,
1.1783875226974487,
-0.5092628598213196,
0.44625648856163025,
-0.40817999839782715,
-0.20063303411006927,
-0.4337003231048584,
-0.9579660296440125,
-0.9419411420822144,
-0.1727413535118103,
-0.4301256239414215,
0.06770486384630203,
-0.3379180133342743,
0.5734236240386963,
0.8172963261604309,
-0.7636855244636536,
0.017438283190131187,
-0.2551323473453522,
-0.014433815144002438,
0.029699748381972313,
-0.2317342311143875,
0.0077020167373120785,
-0.284969687461853,
-0.6463643908500671,
-0.041502028703689575,
0.8334784507751465,
0.3390355408191681,
-0.17394807934761047,
-0.06743337959051132,
0.24555109441280365,
0.16002555191516876,
1.0246496200561523,
0.36883628368377686,
-0.859205424785614,
-0.3742092251777649,
-0.3168782591819763,
-0.32924792170524597,
0.21458712220191956,
0.6688143014907837,
-0.882112979888916,
0.32080698013305664,
0.44103679060935974,
0.48018038272857666,
0.430275022983551,
0.24621891975402832,
-0.020807316526770592,
-0.7987903356552124,
0.4170674681663513,
0.05102068558335304,
0.21835710108280182,
0.35587093234062195,
-0.03930158540606499,
0.1931755095720291,
0.16535000503063202,
-0.20900388062000275,
-1.071006417274475,
0.3552350103855133,
-1.2586171627044678,
-0.38076671957969666,
1.0235565900802612,
-0.0679321438074112,
-0.5536810159683228,
0.11761040985584259,
-0.3719423711299896,
-0.003222123486921191,
-0.14881545305252075,
0.542679488658905,
0.3592418432235718,
-0.09269945323467255,
-0.3127298653125763,
-0.40264832973480225,
0.47646379470825195,
0.047382209450006485,
-0.8402145504951477,
0.2064846307039261,
0.44305214285850525,
0.28248313069343567,
0.26757344603538513,
0.3699840307235718,
0.029740378260612488,
0.23873823881149292,
-0.13047932088375092,
0.03621816262602806,
-0.0940217599272728,
-0.5678543448448181,
-0.32446491718292236,
0.48328468203544617,
-0.05574357137084007,
-0.3796493709087372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00010v1
|
EnterpriseEM: Fine-tuned Embeddings for Enterprise Semantic Search
| 2024-05-18T14:06:53 | 2024-05-18T14:06:53 |
Kamalkumar Rathinasamy, Jayarama Nettar, Amit Kumar, Vishal Manchanda, Arun Vijayakumar, Ayush Kataria, Venkateshprasanna Manjunath, Chidambaram GS, Jaskirat Singh Sodhi, Shoeb Shaikh, Wasim Akhtar Khan, Prashant Singh, Tanishq Dattatray Ige, Vipin Tiwari, Rajab Ali Mondal, Harshini K, S Reka, Chetana Amancharla, Faiz ur Rahman, Harikrishnan P A, Indraneel Saha, Bhavya Tiwary, Navin Shankar Patel, Pradeep T S, Balaji A J, Priyapravas, Mohammed Rafee Tarafdar
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Enterprises grapple with the significant challenge of managing proprietary
unstructured data, hindering efficient information retrieval. This has led to
the emergence of AI-driven information retrieval solutions, designed to adeptly
extract relevant insights to address employee inquiries. These solutions often
leverage pre-trained embedding models and generative models as foundational
components. While pre-trained embeddings may exhibit proximity or disparity
based on their original training objectives, they might not fully align with
the unique characteristics of enterprise-specific data, leading to suboptimal
alignment with the retrieval goals of enterprise environments. In this paper,
we propose a methodology to fine-tune pre-trained embedding models specifically
for enterprise environments. By adapting the embeddings to better suit the
retrieval tasks prevalent in enterprises, we aim to enhance the performance of
information retrieval solutions. We discuss the process of fine-tuning, its
effect on retrieval accuracy, and the potential benefits for enterprise
information management. Our findings demonstrate the efficacy of fine-tuned
embedding models in improving the precision and relevance of search results in
enterprise settings.
|
[
-0.6484901905059814,
-0.8035342693328857,
0.8358728289604187,
-0.07898176461458206,
-0.0765218585729599,
0.0008990887436084449,
-0.11152719706296921,
-0.45833656191825867,
0.41893309354782104,
0.6671423316001892,
-0.5751155614852905,
-0.7537346482276917,
-0.41014719009399414,
0.03788629174232483,
-0.15112942457199097,
0.5272156596183777,
0.17996199429035187,
-0.25560885667800903,
-0.2717459201812744,
-0.2653917968273163,
-0.6997119188308716,
-0.36012646555900574,
-0.20460951328277588,
-0.03198908269405365,
0.09917962551116943,
0.704479992389679,
0.7195008397102356,
0.8529477715492249,
0.7256344556808472,
0.2317655384540558,
0.1847841739654541,
0.4839274287223816,
-0.4070061147212982,
0.3119449317455292,
-0.4774995744228363,
-0.4959501326084137,
-0.5118289589881897,
-0.15878134965896606,
0.3795590102672577,
0.7811275720596313,
-0.5852978229522705,
0.26804855465888977,
0.11256030946969986,
0.502039909362793,
-0.8144250512123108,
0.05054967477917671,
-0.9966591596603394,
0.0729202926158905,
-0.2234586626291275,
-0.3447592854499817,
-0.4669030010700226,
0.010041615925729275,
0.11009287089109421,
-0.8472800254821777,
0.4002609848976135,
0.730303168296814,
1.1524626016616821,
0.4012046158313751,
-0.2816872298717499,
-0.2698955833911896,
-0.7846194505691528,
0.8286675810813904,
-0.4078473746776581,
0.4943971037864685,
0.2609916925430298,
0.0475112609565258,
-0.08072157204151154,
-0.8038345575332642,
-0.03990979865193367,
0.30643364787101746,
0.031998760998249054,
0.23711423575878143,
-0.20741961896419525,
0.18886639177799225,
0.150657057762146,
0.136704221367836,
-0.4976653754711151,
0.6034193634986877,
-0.20744571089744568,
0.31953296065330505,
0.38863226771354675,
0.5656570196151733,
0.12872588634490967,
0.4605166018009186,
-0.1291162222623825,
-0.16444824635982513,
-0.5651212334632874,
-0.36763182282447815,
0.15212775766849518,
0.4329812824726105,
0.779772937297821,
0.8915497064590454,
-0.3462577164173126,
0.5570391416549683,
0.29328426718711853,
0.5076394081115723,
0.08289526402950287,
-0.13503892719745636,
-0.4342968761920929,
0.31156691908836365,
0.04408042132854462,
0.4515129029750824,
-0.06364613026380539,
-0.5005203485488892,
-0.5070000290870667,
-0.05061377212405205,
0.8188517689704895,
-0.8646391034126282,
-0.1474483758211136,
0.39821863174438477,
-0.6547815203666687,
0.02811489813029766,
0.42020970582962036,
-0.4374554753303528,
-0.06900492310523987,
-0.625602126121521,
0.6801893711090088,
-0.5428409576416016,
0.09427693486213684,
0.3927822411060333,
-0.19707553088665009,
0.30862581729888916,
0.47884753346443176,
-0.6813452839851379,
0.2797005772590637,
0.8471860885620117,
0.4773721396923065,
0.16578593850135803,
-0.14972780644893646,
-0.5725776553153992,
0.6289336085319519,
-0.3912854790687561,
0.5938931107521057,
-0.9738840460777283,
-0.1218833327293396,
0.03880327567458153,
-0.002976934192702174,
-0.08403301984071732,
-1.0205663442611694,
0.5399369597434998,
-0.8533622026443481,
-0.1385057270526886,
-0.1274498701095581,
-1.103675365447998,
-0.27424201369285583,
0.14506623148918152,
-0.6718428730964661,
0.8129842877388,
-0.17732900381088257,
-0.3814356327056885,
0.7366349697113037,
-0.6279906630516052,
-0.15061508119106293,
0.151277557015419,
0.02581425942480564,
-0.6084668040275574,
0.454700231552124,
0.41191092133522034,
0.68492192029953,
-0.0571923702955246,
-0.24649770557880402,
-0.4695219099521637,
-0.4005314111709595,
-0.6239150762557983,
0.5172056555747986,
0.31313493847846985,
0.32354283332824707,
-0.23426315188407898,
-0.3527342975139618,
-0.4644041955471039,
0.5450035333633423,
0.07594520598649979,
0.16294406354427338,
-0.9718707799911499,
0.24752633273601532,
-0.24307657778263092,
-0.20387329161167145,
0.487832635641098,
-0.33992907404899597,
0.11982697248458862,
-0.252427339553833,
0.11972218751907349,
0.5357407927513123,
0.0624501034617424,
0.6372936367988586,
-0.1663324385881424,
0.14933525025844574,
0.23016372323036194,
0.1895371377468109,
-0.15269601345062256,
-0.08539052307605743,
-0.4343973994255066,
-0.2642093002796173,
0.03478339686989784,
0.6045681238174438,
-0.015770532190799713,
0.8594755530357361,
-0.31273698806762695,
-0.6099969148635864,
-0.6980953812599182,
0.23352913558483124,
-0.13936367630958557,
0.28677231073379517,
0.7386210560798645,
-0.5103318691253662,
-0.6418373584747314,
-1.0528414249420166,
-0.3457198441028595,
0.22703447937965393,
-0.2797570526599884,
0.5505498647689819,
0.3624483644962311,
-0.5257781147956848,
0.8695950508117676,
-0.5429718494415283,
-0.7523906826972961,
0.09979933500289917,
0.21702879667282104,
0.19349107146263123,
0.4078128933906555,
0.21383827924728394,
-0.9689265489578247,
-0.2626562714576721,
0.0782872661948204,
-0.7230261564254761,
0.13772358000278473,
-0.03871746361255646,
-0.2275417000055313,
-0.36097201704978943,
0.594316303730011,
-0.34753188490867615,
0.3439602255821228,
-0.008823340758681297,
-0.23792317509651184,
0.1319335699081421,
-0.542226254940033,
0.16347821056842804,
-1.0510070323944092,
0.10153259336948395,
0.00794671755284071,
-0.3476382791996002,
-0.2216881811618805,
0.26804178953170776,
0.22040052711963654,
-0.1350456029176712,
-0.21277981996536255,
0.18328922986984253,
-0.8350891470909119,
-0.29642021656036377,
-0.043613024055957794,
0.4482870399951935,
0.3017919063568115,
-0.12876379489898682,
0.09398780763149261,
0.6348629593849182,
0.23911647498607635,
-1.0728291273117065,
0.09268274903297424,
0.723753035068512,
-0.4950544238090515,
0.9480169415473938,
-0.6692756414413452,
0.18892352283000946,
-0.39165201783180237,
-0.18796572089195251,
-0.21622763574123383,
-0.042487919330596924,
-0.7709091305732727,
-0.03954104706645012,
0.4633128046989441,
-0.10206689685583115,
-0.5944669246673584,
-0.13475170731544495,
-0.12804724276065826,
0.01768416538834572,
0.45021623373031616,
-0.6081946492195129,
0.6559208035469055,
0.44880586862564087,
-0.15730255842208862,
-0.385307639837265,
-0.524021327495575,
0.07995225489139557,
-0.40631622076034546,
-0.8884360790252686,
1.0190973281860352,
0.4042634963989258,
-0.11942742019891739,
0.2743481695652008,
-0.22525250911712646,
-0.005436701234430075,
0.38850536942481995,
0.006065609864890575,
0.13634447753429413,
-0.44055765867233276,
0.017860250547528267,
0.047040604054927826,
0.02732144296169281,
-0.307594358921051,
-0.5077218413352966,
0.17886081337928772,
-0.2516934871673584,
-0.636866569519043,
-0.07601537555456161,
0.48813173174858093,
0.24419544637203217,
-0.6309728622436523,
1.043824553489685,
0.5488054752349854,
-0.6255267262458801,
-0.19558697938919067,
-0.7673599123954773,
-0.5868586897850037,
-0.4483271539211273,
0.8001343011856079,
-0.3901011049747467,
-0.8000156879425049,
0.4597651958465576,
-0.6266265511512756,
-0.031150849536061287,
0.32401448488235474,
0.3752969801425934,
-0.5285091400146484,
1.3449050188064575,
1.0889310836791992,
0.09447994083166122,
0.5957911014556885,
-0.1859339475631714,
0.3065028190612793,
-0.9978068470954895,
-0.45641040802001953,
-0.7239315509796143,
-0.4955975413322449,
-0.5578354001045227,
0.008350302465260029,
0.2356991171836853,
0.44921180605888367,
-0.5754400491714478,
0.44188234210014343,
-0.4576551616191864,
0.530461847782135,
0.485688179731369,
0.28981226682662964,
-0.023515699431300163,
0.00901876576244831,
-0.12210355699062347,
-0.37338805198669434,
-0.583381175994873,
-0.7558150291442871,
0.692637026309967,
0.23992325365543365,
1.1346207857131958,
0.25197869539260864,
0.8244478106498718,
0.34200045466423035,
-0.25109192728996277,
-0.2784865200519562,
0.09042048454284668,
-0.5042049884796143,
-0.6274268627166748,
-0.39688006043434143,
-0.1309732049703598,
-1.0677272081375122,
-0.16330821812152863,
-0.2176782786846161,
-1.0024113655090332,
0.39356309175491333,
0.02765212208032608,
-0.3067318797111511,
0.2589334547519684,
-0.8027867078781128,
0.902431070804596,
-0.19936583936214447,
-0.2883581817150116,
-0.4659481346607208,
-0.46208304166793823,
-0.4006306827068329,
0.007336406037211418,
-0.2628180682659149,
-0.0040749358013272285,
-0.1896585077047348,
0.3968011140823364,
-0.36023998260498047,
0.3854125440120697,
-0.18524464964866638,
0.4645877778530121,
-0.04791424795985222,
0.20413170754909515,
0.9632137417793274,
-0.06920547783374786,
-0.16380329430103302,
-0.16326642036437988,
-0.06823631376028061,
-0.6112334728240967,
-0.5751767754554749,
0.4592711627483368,
-0.506401002407074,
-0.6506094336509705,
0.1881001889705658,
0.1448754072189331,
-0.3028901219367981,
0.40172678232192993,
0.33234238624572754,
0.06971266120672226,
-0.4712078869342804,
0.8145777583122253,
1.2406673431396484,
-0.3176670968532562,
-0.014273306354880333,
0.5352575778961182,
0.2486409991979599,
0.16642846167087555,
0.5639463067054749,
0.11767549067735672,
-0.16968198120594025,
0.7123610377311707,
-0.42329561710357666,
-0.48002007603645325,
-0.26346540451049805,
-0.14959779381752014,
-0.0077901496551930904,
-0.5104527473449707,
-0.3627828359603882,
-0.6141093373298645,
0.08840267360210419,
-0.23742173612117767,
-0.3984808921813965,
-0.7636597752571106,
-0.06520561128854752,
-0.6472153663635254,
-0.160383403301239,
0.04325539246201515,
0.6506065726280212,
0.25837409496307373,
0.021706337109208107,
-0.9284588098526001,
-0.20309296250343323,
0.025632048025727272,
0.4297369718551636,
-0.22067272663116455,
-0.3115708827972412,
-0.7035422325134277,
0.06332118809223175,
-0.2911061644554138,
-0.6208624839782715,
0.3671490550041199,
0.5777355432510376,
0.6946792006492615,
0.06975945830345154,
0.22336170077323914,
0.9038992524147034,
-0.5306886434555054,
0.4180172085762024,
-0.4505777955055237,
-0.7494881749153137,
0.941522479057312,
-0.07620005309581757,
-0.26949912309646606,
0.8002133369445801,
0.42342615127563477,
-0.12969228625297546,
-0.23358292877674103,
-0.6323836445808411,
-1.2717386484146118,
0.5907914042472839,
0.10183203965425491,
0.21988973021507263,
0.13132034242153168,
0.4665066599845886,
-0.011688340455293655,
0.17683154344558716,
0.20124021172523499,
-0.2066785991191864,
-0.05715718865394592,
-0.25765088200569153,
0.1505928784608841,
-0.14323025941848755,
0.2381952702999115,
0.028824934735894203,
0.7911657094955444,
0.03258713334798813,
0.4750877320766449,
0.11430355161428452,
-0.4579140543937683,
-0.000851750373840332,
0.07146149128675461,
0.12024561315774918,
0.6049705743789673,
-0.5007722973823547,
-0.13520854711532593,
0.21227949857711792,
-0.3761942684650421,
-0.08728457987308502,
0.006936584133654833,
-0.021691959351301193,
0.09659621864557266,
-0.15438060462474823,
0.7369053959846497,
-0.18721529841423035,
-0.3087381422519684,
0.4465363621711731,
0.011080347001552582,
0.15540838241577148,
-0.4051886796951294,
0.21459068357944489,
0.0012815720401704311,
0.46601733565330505,
0.4880615770816803,
-0.14351312816143036,
0.46049875020980835,
-0.3137892782688141,
0.4953427314758301,
0.5890529155731201,
-0.2015112042427063,
0.06411474943161011,
0.8531369566917419,
-0.019423801451921463,
-0.14208492636680603,
1.236983060836792,
0.19933991134166718,
-0.27108463644981384,
0.6416640877723694,
0.6055197715759277,
0.8200348019599915,
-0.28585758805274963,
-0.16936419904232025,
0.19242483377456665,
0.5846596360206604,
-0.10619065165519714,
0.11572213470935822,
0.20501300692558289,
-0.7197523713111877,
-0.15839065611362457,
-0.44777196645736694,
-0.5490936040878296,
-0.0392855629324913,
-1.0378159284591675,
0.5612061619758606,
-0.2530185282230377,
-0.2909669876098633,
-0.09823474287986755,
0.18035350739955902,
-1.2905534505844116,
0.3981490135192871,
-0.07614870369434357,
1.2254995107650757,
-0.6125761866569519,
0.35881179571151733,
1.0178784132003784,
-0.4279555380344391,
-0.7388200163841248,
-0.16497890651226044,
-0.5368324518203735,
-0.6853805184364319,
0.4780476689338684,
0.19673985242843628,
0.11812888830900192,
0.35130739212036133,
-0.39096587896347046,
-0.7537558674812317,
1.4209513664245605,
0.3399556279182434,
-0.7679853439331055,
-0.10011902451515198,
0.09052707999944687,
0.4350874125957489,
-0.5289104580879211,
0.3565206825733185,
0.29582399129867554,
0.3918025493621826,
-0.585848867893219,
-0.5124348402023315,
-0.1639188975095749,
0.009179510176181793,
0.32714980840682983,
0.21183113753795624,
-0.4716159999370575,
0.5031379461288452,
-0.09812559932470322,
-0.05357219651341438,
-0.15094392001628876,
0.5333978533744812,
-0.036110132932662964,
0.3911726474761963,
0.1324005424976349,
0.8691000938415527,
1.033151626586914,
-0.11386432498693466,
0.8691186904907227,
-0.4606119394302368,
0.45474672317504883,
1.0500445365905762,
-0.43176621198654175,
0.930531919002533,
0.2738734781742096,
0.11349836736917496,
0.42821004986763,
0.7197811603546143,
-0.23582687973976135,
0.786356508731842,
-0.22733163833618164,
-0.05432150512933731,
-0.5479295253753662,
-0.10417861491441727,
-0.2989852726459503,
0.329168438911438,
0.7093678712844849,
-0.552223801612854,
-0.04928683489561081,
-0.10332629829645157,
-0.42144298553466797,
0.08082609623670578,
-0.3446182906627655,
0.9521142840385437,
0.06329793483018875,
-0.1915093958377838,
-0.033469025045633316,
0.33176013827323914,
0.47739478945732117,
-0.1826840341091156,
0.02105053700506687,
-0.25624969601631165,
0.3374263346195221,
-0.3785470724105835,
-0.7714380025863647,
0.43076664209365845,
-0.33716699481010437,
-0.22573202848434448,
-0.13226597011089325,
0.7224076986312866,
-0.13054965436458588,
0.17552243173122406,
0.3749092221260071,
0.4869125485420227,
-0.030971787869930267,
-0.4062301814556122,
-0.6427373290061951,
-0.26451221108436584,
-0.20724602043628693,
-0.3659418523311615,
0.11933595687150955,
0.9847539663314819,
0.0046265809796750546,
0.4890514016151428,
0.24298498034477234,
-0.15063121914863586,
0.08951509743928909,
-0.12135632336139679,
0.4867210388183594,
-0.7402844429016113,
-0.47393175959587097,
-0.6621116399765015,
0.2800387144088745,
-0.1636844277381897,
0.08440600335597992,
0.42641112208366394,
0.8582856059074402,
1.011651635169983,
-0.155756875872612,
0.46791374683380127,
0.023046361282467842,
0.41263100504875183,
-0.6656237840652466,
0.4966837167739868,
-0.8845654726028442,
0.36416885256767273,
-0.29659444093704224,
-1.3438043594360352,
-0.06904356926679611,
0.7270980477333069,
-0.19086511433124542,
0.3225944936275482,
0.32138490676879883,
1.0496388673782349,
-0.5117414593696594,
-0.05795444920659065,
0.511701226234436,
0.1750062257051468,
0.07921542972326279,
0.2066192775964737,
0.5530142188072205,
-0.33979371190071106,
0.14797258377075195,
-0.06161494925618172,
0.07620590180158615,
-0.734138548374176,
-0.9013349413871765,
-0.25524479150772095,
-0.5909050107002258,
-0.33871421217918396,
-0.08626112341880798,
0.31642386317253113,
0.8548536896705627,
0.8994487524032593,
-0.7106888890266418,
0.3697633743286133,
-0.14618949592113495,
-0.19599992036819458,
-0.12763135135173798,
-0.254538357257843,
0.1642586886882782,
-0.5428348183631897,
-0.5879989862442017,
0.16481447219848633,
0.46858376264572144,
0.05934417247772217,
0.1759650856256485,
-0.0017862259410321712,
0.050796814262866974,
0.0531005859375,
0.3378002643585205,
0.02776753157377243,
-0.25959423184394836,
-0.4015730917453766,
0.4358973503112793,
-0.31112611293792725,
-0.0009588935063220561,
0.41243189573287964,
-0.5578060746192932,
0.28133442997932434,
0.1039634495973587,
1.070685625076294,
0.691336452960968,
0.28374090790748596,
0.5672870874404907,
-1.096861481666565,
-0.15878933668136597,
0.4350265562534332,
0.413985937833786,
0.23109601438045502,
-0.692495584487915,
0.5797799229621887,
-0.21407084167003632,
-0.6700066924095154,
-0.5854930877685547,
-0.003083514515310526,
-0.5841108560562134,
-0.14878302812576294,
0.537814199924469,
-0.014982406981289387,
-0.15124085545539856,
-0.09116622060537338,
0.06854692101478577,
0.17189455032348633,
-0.26204007863998413,
0.7341001629829407,
0.5728294849395752,
-0.24390172958374023,
0.1616002768278122,
-0.34524115920066833,
0.10721512883901596,
0.8377548456192017,
-0.5619907975196838,
-0.21021349728107452,
0.30999404191970825,
0.2580606937408447,
0.0799669474363327,
0.08833468705415726,
-0.004101262427866459,
0.18420827388763428,
0.018332481384277344,
0.09487828612327576,
-0.07087036967277527,
-0.32698795199394226,
0.05367515608668327,
-0.10854538530111313,
0.2776186466217041,
-0.3354593813419342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11297v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11297v1
|
Unveiling Key Aspects of Fine-Tuning in Sentence Embeddings: A Representation Rank Analysis
| 2024-05-18T13:51:27 | 2024-05-18T13:51:27 |
Euna Jung, Jaeill Kim, Jungmin Ko, Jinwoo Park, Wonjong Rhee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The latest advancements in unsupervised learning of sentence embeddings
predominantly involve employing contrastive learning-based (CL-based)
fine-tuning over pre-trained language models. In this study, we analyze the
latest sentence embedding methods by adopting representation rank as the
primary tool of analysis. We first define Phase 1 and Phase 2 of fine-tuning
based on when representation rank peaks. Utilizing these phases, we conduct a
thorough analysis and obtain essential findings across key aspects, including
alignment and uniformity, linguistic abilities, and correlation between
performance and rank. For instance, we find that the dynamics of the key
aspects can undergo significant changes as fine-tuning transitions from Phase 1
to Phase 2. Based on these findings, we experiment with a rank reduction (RR)
strategy that facilitates rapid and stable fine-tuning of the latest CL-based
methods. Through empirical investigations, we showcase the efficacy of RR in
enhancing the performance and stability of five state-of-the-art sentence
embedding methods.
|
[
-0.4552403688430786,
-0.8250681757926941,
0.4701348841190338,
0.07268644124269485,
-0.5430974960327148,
0.09966758638620377,
-0.5009410977363586,
-0.07947570830583572,
0.056456103920936584,
0.4097418189048767,
-0.2933689057826996,
-0.6873922944068909,
-0.9908426403999329,
0.06596002727746964,
-0.1638995110988617,
0.912457287311554,
0.10342162847518921,
0.21294640004634857,
-0.28529444336891174,
-0.41720592975616455,
-0.6495549082756042,
-0.43187427520751953,
-0.46527978777885437,
-0.17476651072502136,
0.3951714336872101,
0.4704679548740387,
0.6745414733886719,
0.7146605253219604,
0.539944589138031,
0.26688694953918457,
-0.3498666286468506,
0.2069350630044937,
-0.8494730591773987,
0.37040647864341736,
-0.1717546135187149,
-0.5339046120643616,
-0.013612879440188408,
0.19010505080223083,
0.7848702073097229,
0.8352190256118774,
0.1018940880894661,
0.06153981387615204,
0.2689118981361389,
0.6214962005615234,
-0.8710876107215881,
0.30167901515960693,
-0.7323665618896484,
0.06079570949077606,
-0.18309883773326874,
-0.3804028630256653,
-0.6540722846984863,
-0.277336448431015,
0.07709117233753204,
-0.38444381952285767,
0.059750866144895554,
0.10220247507095337,
0.8540903329849243,
0.42940250039100647,
-0.44849446415901184,
-0.19850775599479675,
-0.3060356676578522,
0.7503488063812256,
-0.540030300617218,
0.303099125623703,
0.12827135622501373,
0.10847573727369308,
-0.04403980076313019,
-0.6676528453826904,
-0.04431619122624397,
-0.23263058066368103,
-0.24682244658470154,
-0.017556166276335716,
-0.05115772783756256,
0.23686806857585907,
0.2044413536787033,
0.4412371814250946,
-0.29650619626045227,
0.3592444360256195,
-0.047483474016189575,
-0.13292796909809113,
0.3840518593788147,
-0.09625295549631119,
0.18721315264701843,
-0.1858973503112793,
-0.008110344409942627,
-0.3660503625869751,
-0.6427936553955078,
0.0989391952753067,
0.14939740300178528,
0.45381155610084534,
0.1556023359298706,
0.6588180661201477,
-0.1788482666015625,
0.45627808570861816,
0.15480738878250122,
0.4252014458179474,
0.10387642681598663,
-0.2877332866191864,
-0.23358821868896484,
0.0759289339184761,
0.6081725358963013,
0.5358904600143433,
0.3728829324245453,
-0.10707563906908035,
-0.20201632380485535,
0.13405147194862366,
0.21228468418121338,
-0.8859397768974304,
-0.4708288013935089,
-0.027621300891041756,
-0.6067035794258118,
-0.4544121026992798,
0.1894860714673996,
-0.5522714257240295,
-0.5080561637878418,
-0.2855899930000305,
0.39780551195144653,
-0.43894365429878235,
0.08593292534351349,
-0.03659704700112343,
-0.09593293815851212,
0.172010600566864,
0.3289045989513397,
-0.7772217392921448,
0.2990623712539673,
0.7913520932197571,
0.7970478534698486,
-0.10671127587556839,
-0.029075823724269867,
-0.8107085227966309,
-0.03351283445954323,
-0.4917573630809784,
0.7070348262786865,
-0.8780657052993774,
-0.26009616255760193,
0.431900292634964,
-0.07549692690372467,
-0.14492467045783997,
-0.6788091659545898,
0.5997712016105652,
-0.4281887114048004,
0.059499941766262054,
-0.34579139947891235,
-0.8368546366691589,
-0.024548929184675217,
0.029790280386805534,
-0.5954136252403259,
0.7629317045211792,
-0.10380057245492935,
-0.6594698429107666,
0.509882926940918,
-0.5540413856506348,
-0.37164509296417236,
-0.12778179347515106,
-0.12808819115161896,
-0.5294061899185181,
0.5576556921005249,
0.47203803062438965,
0.8176192045211792,
0.11464449763298035,
-0.09632974117994308,
-0.07350705564022064,
-0.6088302135467529,
0.1033928245306015,
-0.08744842559099197,
0.33801931142807007,
0.1294545978307724,
-0.11877001821994781,
0.11851661652326584,
-0.5027300715446472,
0.06429441273212433,
-0.07624359428882599,
0.02577841654419899,
-0.32571423053741455,
0.0933244600892067,
0.10951150953769684,
-0.06833469122648239,
0.34570392966270447,
-0.493291974067688,
0.37768593430519104,
-0.4843594431877136,
0.8301511406898499,
0.6008988618850708,
0.2747282087802887,
0.6200942397117615,
-0.046874724328517914,
0.3678969144821167,
0.2861478626728058,
-0.10450028628110886,
-0.32626309990882874,
-0.3683733344078064,
-0.9422630071640015,
0.02393038384616375,
0.7425560355186462,
0.3497191071510315,
-0.3395785391330719,
0.5152301788330078,
-0.3277732729911804,
-0.180889293551445,
-0.8378605842590332,
0.08171834796667099,
0.5661102533340454,
-0.30706244707107544,
0.5611048936843872,
-0.14557316899299622,
-0.4776087999343872,
-0.9682080149650574,
-0.5419343113899231,
0.1494838148355484,
0.3761526048183441,
-0.09184879064559937,
0.4036836624145508,
-0.11609304696321487,
0.6926662921905518,
-0.5713697075843811,
-0.2669946849346161,
-0.3463275730609894,
0.4871315658092499,
-0.2946237325668335,
0.75131756067276,
0.3930898904800415,
-0.7266697883605957,
-0.4122353494167328,
-0.022238921374082565,
-0.42331141233444214,
0.09949174523353577,
-0.1717522293329239,
0.023055460304021835,
0.14556337893009186,
1.0067377090454102,
-0.09244318306446075,
0.3476937711238861,
0.5061972737312317,
-0.32993197441101074,
-0.007848720997571945,
-0.4476102590560913,
0.20939522981643677,
-0.7631048560142517,
-0.17699164152145386,
0.012958829291164875,
-0.36493387818336487,
-0.3211866021156311,
0.28714391589164734,
0.14764603972434998,
-0.2361440807580948,
-0.08249066025018692,
0.00920995231717825,
-0.6391111016273499,
-0.03355120122432709,
-0.12171737849712372,
0.26914873719215393,
-0.13449998199939728,
0.37253665924072266,
-0.43187108635902405,
0.748175323009491,
0.315095990896225,
-0.3970459997653961,
-0.4377850294113159,
0.2935672402381897,
-0.41624292731285095,
0.2761956453323364,
-0.7663002014160156,
0.14674292504787445,
-0.2693161368370056,
-0.17820945382118225,
-1.1653265953063965,
0.23498773574829102,
0.03953574225306511,
-0.3351503312587738,
0.44905197620391846,
-0.31915998458862305,
-0.5799627304077148,
0.1426546573638916,
-0.44130682945251465,
0.16729982197284698,
0.44992029666900635,
-0.21128222346305847,
0.13444331288337708,
0.2850725054740906,
-0.2029237598180771,
-0.27752068638801575,
-0.6733611822128296,
-0.05943167954683304,
-0.003598919603973627,
-0.3682999908924103,
0.7827668786048889,
0.032003890722990036,
-0.1737380474805832,
-0.09555622935295105,
-0.12382812798023224,
0.1572171151638031,
0.18833670020103455,
0.1928289383649826,
-0.17158307135105133,
-0.011534438468515873,
0.02535819262266159,
0.5651063323020935,
-0.4175514578819275,
-0.15102748572826385,
0.04073210805654526,
0.5055212378501892,
-0.1812727153301239,
-0.18905946612358093,
-0.5504214763641357,
0.2650001645088196,
0.6081873178482056,
-0.4734514355659485,
0.8259401917457581,
0.5356177091598511,
-0.19626012444496155,
-0.26598450541496277,
-0.4072365164756775,
-0.13788782060146332,
-0.44704121351242065,
0.38046324253082275,
-0.3531385660171509,
-1.0403919219970703,
0.45236697793006897,
-0.4343027174472809,
0.01375312078744173,
0.3719100058078766,
0.3285846710205078,
-0.11078337579965591,
1.0413610935211182,
0.8042137622833252,
0.06427555531263351,
0.784887433052063,
-0.33438172936439514,
0.2571409046649933,
-0.8562875390052795,
-0.16232290863990784,
-0.48389101028442383,
-0.589098334312439,
-0.8988969922065735,
-0.5016995668411255,
0.28056177496910095,
0.4453619420528412,
-0.2598920464515686,
0.2154146432876587,
-0.5449677109718323,
0.5364412069320679,
0.37737107276916504,
0.13596369326114655,
0.2477775514125824,
-0.1308262199163437,
-0.36878859996795654,
-0.3249036371707916,
-0.3825455904006958,
-0.5546495318412781,
0.9875233769416809,
0.26848307251930237,
0.39642953872680664,
-0.09718235582113266,
0.7281803488731384,
0.45938771963119507,
-0.25858718156814575,
-0.6465662717819214,
0.5100695490837097,
-0.6632897853851318,
0.20571376383304596,
-0.20967668294906616,
-0.17883217334747314,
-0.9375048875808716,
0.5708975195884705,
-0.5614117383956909,
-0.5434326529502869,
0.17761141061782837,
-0.06097705662250519,
-0.21600395441055298,
-0.09058584272861481,
-0.8316248655319214,
1.0222692489624023,
0.11417712271213531,
-0.1467849463224411,
-0.4988313615322113,
-0.5138564705848694,
-0.12623244524002075,
0.6204118728637695,
-0.11317805200815201,
0.028112178668379784,
-0.04155391454696655,
0.7555812001228333,
-0.1484803557395935,
0.617110013961792,
-0.2939499020576477,
0.002828903030604124,
-0.2477492243051529,
0.04736802726984024,
0.5911988019943237,
0.268079936504364,
-0.0999377891421318,
-0.05443951487541199,
0.016080377623438835,
-0.493224173784256,
-0.8368799686431885,
1.0259592533111572,
-0.6765413880348206,
-0.4069840610027313,
-0.2666213810443878,
-0.2672961950302124,
-0.37742167711257935,
0.0971021056175232,
0.24784709513187408,
0.5401573181152344,
-0.4113992750644684,
0.5669036507606506,
0.8041602373123169,
-0.158250093460083,
0.41594552993774414,
0.11391761898994446,
-0.07154767215251923,
-0.45406216382980347,
0.7674969434738159,
0.33448028564453125,
0.055847954005002975,
0.6589552760124207,
0.07609933614730835,
-0.18396499752998352,
-0.988150954246521,
-0.062700055539608,
0.18545641005039215,
-0.6742346882820129,
0.0005407494609244168,
-0.6308330297470093,
-0.08682139217853546,
-0.4881048798561096,
-0.3159390985965729,
-0.3893921971321106,
-0.3435337543487549,
-0.36538001894950867,
-0.20604859292507172,
0.2833293080329895,
0.8611015677452087,
0.23529961705207825,
0.3364616930484772,
-0.42676854133605957,
0.23252081871032715,
-0.008324187248945236,
0.28312623500823975,
-0.2886947691440582,
-0.3671436309814453,
-0.4108530580997467,
-0.0314243845641613,
-0.293753057718277,
-0.6284927129745483,
0.13847199082374573,
0.2616173326969147,
0.6775173544883728,
0.4147133529186249,
0.020111825317144394,
0.6997789740562439,
-0.3428957462310791,
0.9077121615409851,
-0.18554696440696716,
-1.0596818923950195,
0.7873313426971436,
-0.20016199350357056,
0.22955557703971863,
0.9460179805755615,
0.09150472283363342,
-0.3194243907928467,
-0.5170148611068726,
-0.49210575222969055,
-0.8690937757492065,
0.40178897976875305,
0.3623095154762268,
0.13731396198272705,
0.04029097035527229,
0.5800666213035583,
0.020794622600078583,
0.3919018507003784,
-0.4821077287197113,
-0.46380722522735596,
-0.17499341070652008,
-0.2131868153810501,
-0.35527604818344116,
-0.4302501678466797,
0.053008757531642914,
-0.515575110912323,
0.296244353055954,
-0.08707433193922043,
0.321914941072464,
-0.034288644790649414,
-0.6266363263130188,
0.21230262517929077,
0.3822104036808014,
0.571735680103302,
0.5128348469734192,
-0.29910212755203247,
0.03425690904259682,
-0.035333890467882156,
-0.2900790274143219,
-0.20701304078102112,
0.017696117982268333,
-0.23047128319740295,
-0.08177270740270615,
0.412198930978775,
0.8879133462905884,
0.7425070405006409,
-0.3380739390850067,
0.6743589639663696,
0.13813713192939758,
0.0066734254360198975,
0.06437372416257858,
0.14388275146484375,
-0.19843070209026337,
0.14764992892742157,
0.1531350016593933,
0.11828512698411942,
0.1298132687807083,
-0.6410309672355652,
0.2703375816345215,
0.4019555449485779,
-0.6058802008628845,
-0.09618420898914337,
0.39116257429122925,
0.2525794208049774,
-0.027768993750214577,
0.5885371565818787,
-0.28303617238998413,
-0.468583345413208,
0.3154909312725067,
0.3600812256336212,
0.6734634637832642,
-0.027649153023958206,
0.5909885168075562,
0.2600676715373993,
0.2998036742210388,
-0.1296960413455963,
0.14337915182113647,
0.08891958743333817,
-0.5793684720993042,
-0.3197075128555298,
-0.46255314350128174,
-0.33987957239151,
-0.19278240203857422,
-0.9968327283859253,
0.19089026749134064,
-0.42565783858299255,
0.07798236608505249,
-0.0360197052359581,
0.319927453994751,
-0.5557580590248108,
0.03303348273038864,
0.036504533141851425,
0.590882420539856,
-0.824385941028595,
0.619827151298523,
0.9300035834312439,
-0.5700148940086365,
-0.3012200891971588,
0.28792494535446167,
-0.2766488194465637,
-0.6121610403060913,
0.538099467754364,
0.35959869623184204,
-0.026084566488862038,
0.32783687114715576,
-0.5181142687797546,
-0.626534104347229,
1.2280986309051514,
0.6233193278312683,
-0.5818586349487305,
0.034179434180259705,
0.012808958999812603,
0.7054846882820129,
-0.5470784306526184,
0.2926238477230072,
0.6078785061836243,
0.4994964599609375,
-0.38767319917678833,
-0.6564005613327026,
0.08738498389720917,
-0.2429186850786209,
0.5421901345252991,
0.19811080396175385,
-0.6057214140892029,
0.7811619639396667,
-0.08836353570222855,
-0.41711264848709106,
0.1345677673816681,
0.8214234709739685,
-0.09554246068000793,
-0.022171910852193832,
0.351485013961792,
0.6649920344352722,
0.9119947552680969,
-0.33895060420036316,
0.8801635503768921,
-0.4255702793598175,
0.42913544178009033,
0.8263461589813232,
0.08914744853973389,
1.2011033296585083,
0.43530920147895813,
0.1517377644777298,
0.9550986886024475,
0.32693228125572205,
-0.11998357623815536,
0.9087682962417603,
0.3593030571937561,
0.27167996764183044,
-0.3876001834869385,
0.0012283700052648783,
-0.39547982811927795,
0.4576367139816284,
0.35928410291671753,
-0.5529488921165466,
-0.23395171761512756,
0.3921358287334442,
-0.05774129554629326,
0.5027167201042175,
-0.3132201135158539,
0.892615556716919,
-0.10758903622627258,
-0.5307113528251648,
0.5767531991004944,
0.10081065446138382,
0.7679675817489624,
-0.33126822113990784,
-0.2366010844707489,
-0.008214482106268406,
0.1425195336341858,
-0.06881561875343323,
-0.75206458568573,
0.0004553637409117073,
-0.3055996894836426,
-0.18403001129627228,
-0.47052571177482605,
0.45424985885620117,
-0.4759393632411957,
-0.1714521199464798,
0.32886186242103577,
0.4656519591808319,
-0.16896140575408936,
-0.1921950876712799,
-0.6463263630867004,
0.4273674786090851,
-0.09922517836093903,
-0.05563809722661972,
0.5769952535629272,
0.5223134756088257,
0.2439481019973755,
0.5563463568687439,
0.31696224212646484,
-0.012694154866039753,
-0.12852105498313904,
0.27146780490875244,
0.8767062425613403,
-0.7802667021751404,
-0.5543294548988342,
-0.5563924312591553,
0.570328414440155,
-0.26291224360466003,
-0.6056497097015381,
0.5417566895484924,
0.41553959250450134,
0.8189159631729126,
0.05397432669997215,
0.5069241523742676,
0.21548084914684296,
0.24825330078601837,
-0.9095593094825745,
0.8092688918113708,
-0.5029242038726807,
0.2793913185596466,
-0.22455202043056488,
-0.7492050528526306,
-0.3782402276992798,
0.7922905683517456,
-0.3308824896812439,
0.01759256049990654,
1.0868395566940308,
0.7438626289367676,
0.16840782761573792,
-0.007969153113663197,
0.38467586040496826,
0.3379322588443756,
0.21201153099536896,
0.20609691739082336,
0.4939902126789093,
-0.7294920682907104,
0.3840569257736206,
-0.30964937806129456,
0.06711851060390472,
-0.43859291076660156,
-0.8128024339675903,
-0.9358752369880676,
-0.6916438341140747,
-0.523455023765564,
-0.03410779684782028,
0.4993899464607239,
0.761228084564209,
0.5700119733810425,
-0.9554489850997925,
0.17471621930599213,
-0.328439325094223,
-0.10437313467264175,
-0.4533759653568268,
-0.20821402966976166,
0.4878250062465668,
-0.8218005299568176,
-0.7495173215866089,
0.3929141163825989,
0.19927124679088593,
-0.2694951891899109,
-0.30268460512161255,
0.08508582413196564,
-0.19097477197647095,
-0.13433952629566193,
0.7600582838058472,
-0.21295569837093353,
-0.7810068130493164,
-0.5089558959007263,
-0.260123610496521,
-0.1701875776052475,
0.1180160790681839,
1.1254829168319702,
-0.7431509494781494,
0.40350979566574097,
0.4899137020111084,
0.6330606341362,
0.2828579246997833,
0.2625434398651123,
0.6885747313499451,
-0.8014242649078369,
-0.053237732499837875,
0.10656163096427917,
0.5067968368530273,
0.32401546835899353,
-0.2921285629272461,
0.24555519223213196,
-0.06530744582414627,
-0.601315438747406,
-0.6870178580284119,
0.115705706179142,
-1.2715930938720703,
-0.36771056056022644,
0.9831607341766357,
-0.1321774125099182,
0.2847805321216583,
-0.043273285031318665,
-0.3252948820590973,
0.2593013048171997,
-0.5589235424995422,
0.5512930750846863,
0.7957945466041565,
-0.038929685950279236,
-0.47900477051734924,
-0.2434663027524948,
0.7003157138824463,
0.6323255300521851,
-0.5486500859260559,
0.1322706639766693,
0.3777190148830414,
0.1174725890159607,
0.21905389428138733,
0.09730339795351028,
-0.26602908968925476,
0.06627832353115082,
-0.17929306626319885,
-0.40247321128845215,
-0.21029700338840485,
-0.39196887612342834,
-0.5966145992279053,
0.49017563462257385,
0.2808092534542084,
-0.2525271773338318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11290v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11290v3
|
MBIAS: Mitigating Bias in Large Language Models While Retaining Context
| 2024-05-18T13:31:12 | 2024-06-28T16:35:15 |
Shaina Raza, Ananya Raval, Veronica Chatrath
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The deployment of Large Language Models (LLMs) in diverse applications
necessitates an assurance of safety without compromising the contextual
integrity of the generated content. Traditional approaches, including
safety-specific fine-tuning or adversarial testing, often yield safe outputs at
the expense of contextual meaning. This can result in a diminished capacity to
handle nuanced aspects of bias and toxicity, such as underrepresentation or
negative portrayals across various demographics. To address these challenges,
we introduce MBIAS, an LLM framework carefully instruction fine-tuned on a
custom dataset designed specifically for safety interventions. MBIAS is
designed to significantly reduce biases and toxic elements in LLM outputs while
preserving the main information. This work also details our further use of
LLMs: as annotator under human supervision and as evaluator of generated
content. Empirical analysis reveals that MBIAS achieves a reduction in bias and
toxicity by over 30\% in standard evaluations, and by more than 90\% in diverse
demographic tests, highlighting the robustness of our approach. We make the
dataset and the fine-tuned model available to the research community for
further investigation and ensure reproducibility. The code for this project can
be accessed here https://github.com/shainarazavi/MBIAS/tree/main.
Warning: This paper contains examples that may be offensive or upsetting.
|
[
-0.25519293546676636,
-0.647982656955719,
0.4652148187160492,
0.3615190088748932,
-0.18275415897369385,
-0.08528769016265869,
-0.25441116094589233,
-0.23250897228717804,
0.10065983980894089,
0.6693646311759949,
-0.3396899998188019,
-0.7317714095115662,
-0.5555452704429626,
-0.0017738874303177,
-0.27478858828544617,
1.1919727325439453,
-0.03566889092326164,
0.06062907353043556,
-0.18646812438964844,
-0.10653089731931686,
-0.32626646757125854,
-0.5628742575645447,
-0.8664096593856812,
-0.2929005026817322,
0.8686426281929016,
0.3285956084728241,
0.6774154901504517,
0.9103953838348389,
0.23101806640625,
0.22780351340770721,
-0.4814126789569855,
0.19270636141300201,
-0.5737583041191101,
0.28998538851737976,
-0.4628327786922455,
-0.26997119188308716,
-0.42032819986343384,
-0.2002880871295929,
0.6439439058303833,
0.7622112035751343,
-0.22857290506362915,
0.16367608308792114,
0.22325336933135986,
0.5827308893203735,
-1.058295726776123,
-0.020348744466900826,
-0.7020851969718933,
-0.025006666779518127,
-0.2232959121465683,
-0.48045170307159424,
-0.6250419020652771,
-0.41126537322998047,
-0.05355609208345413,
-0.46170324087142944,
-0.28535330295562744,
0.06579719483852386,
0.6000174880027771,
0.38916683197021484,
-0.7696579098701477,
-0.1790657341480255,
-0.7254791259765625,
0.9657504558563232,
-0.7266781330108643,
0.18166251480579376,
0.3711586892604828,
0.255723237991333,
-0.3692142963409424,
-0.08866281807422638,
-0.31767475605010986,
-0.14230699837207794,
0.11309855431318283,
-0.2696312367916107,
0.059929218143224716,
0.06986428052186966,
0.3336999714374542,
-0.15231025218963623,
-0.2603510022163391,
0.32576799392700195,
-0.3672447204589844,
-0.5214256644248962,
0.7654369473457336,
0.3293130695819855,
0.46906086802482605,
-0.026360267773270607,
-0.17447681725025177,
-0.08166436105966568,
-1.4401779174804688,
-0.0636114850640297,
0.6005047559738159,
0.3957918584346771,
-0.14908930659294128,
0.30125322937965393,
-0.18750877678394318,
0.36392852663993835,
-0.2740020155906677,
-0.2240644097328186,
0.5833329558372498,
-0.10405707359313965,
-0.24928809702396393,
-0.052823733538389206,
0.8922539353370667,
0.48575514554977417,
0.5048098564147949,
-0.16682392358779907,
-0.1356954425573349,
0.1932479292154312,
0.38654738664627075,
-0.945569634437561,
0.039674945175647736,
0.12030534446239471,
-0.27751806378364563,
-0.5681211352348328,
-0.30677923560142517,
-0.9522073864936829,
-0.6706700921058655,
-0.3332926034927368,
0.22882622480392456,
-0.22706161439418793,
-0.26918524503707886,
-0.07165245711803436,
0.21909402310848236,
-0.20827294886112213,
0.14917400479316711,
-1.15243399143219,
0.1592663675546646,
0.610542893409729,
0.636870801448822,
-0.14377164840698242,
-0.1169067770242691,
-0.583997368812561,
0.5333817005157471,
-0.6554659605026245,
0.25891104340553284,
-0.6333246231079102,
-0.4045378267765045,
0.22158055007457733,
-0.0038622012361884117,
0.2704501450061798,
-0.5467048287391663,
0.76325523853302,
-0.4433523118495941,
-0.0662379190325737,
-0.680472195148468,
-0.08376632630825043,
-0.11853987723588943,
0.30582594871520996,
-0.35143107175827026,
0.8220642805099487,
-0.19226966798305511,
-0.8860487937927246,
0.4871041178703308,
-0.581744909286499,
-0.6861399412155151,
-0.4790377616882324,
-0.30568835139274597,
-0.4062153100967407,
-0.06200044974684715,
0.27042514085769653,
0.33455947041511536,
-0.007018417585641146,
0.48347604274749756,
-0.5492762923240662,
-0.5075002908706665,
0.12903092801570892,
-0.5074377655982971,
0.6947873830795288,
0.3550654947757721,
-0.3553869426250458,
0.5447834730148315,
-0.5853224396705627,
-0.2712712287902832,
-0.03191891685128212,
-0.627363383769989,
-0.6630738973617554,
0.3202221691608429,
0.18154242634773254,
0.37586891651153564,
-0.0216609425842762,
-0.6203846335411072,
-0.14213000237941742,
-0.41328904032707214,
0.3937261998653412,
1.0311537981033325,
0.007687818259000778,
0.5688658952713013,
-0.3041159212589264,
0.4655659794807434,
0.254170298576355,
0.34958937764167786,
-0.22018299996852875,
-0.17744076251983643,
-0.6537016034126282,
-0.18007682263851166,
0.16007228195667267,
0.48209938406944275,
-0.8132811784744263,
0.577048659324646,
-0.3334352672100067,
-0.37627464532852173,
-0.2893528640270233,
0.4032210111618042,
0.5840744376182556,
0.5351977348327637,
0.12467838078737259,
-0.30161142349243164,
-0.6584023237228394,
-1.1244999170303345,
-0.04632403329014778,
-0.007985818199813366,
-0.2470233291387558,
0.2615853548049927,
0.4655817747116089,
-0.5793907642364502,
0.8434891700744629,
-0.2557564973831177,
-0.14105524122714996,
-0.07159270346164703,
-0.07578137516975403,
-0.029160765931010246,
0.7190279364585876,
0.8206929564476013,
-0.5713900923728943,
-0.3225523829460144,
-0.07550960779190063,
-0.8298340439796448,
-0.5189516544342041,
0.001467471825890243,
-0.4366830885410309,
0.263428270816803,
0.4773871898651123,
-0.41424328088760376,
0.08608873933553696,
0.7052912712097168,
-0.22750206291675568,
0.30805692076683044,
-0.005961341317743063,
0.004664813634008169,
-1.2179981470108032,
0.33605650067329407,
0.20536543428897858,
-0.21365050971508026,
-0.5767126083374023,
0.053353019058704376,
0.037768859416246414,
0.19323328137397766,
-0.6237810254096985,
0.46051260828971863,
-0.3326585292816162,
0.060041770339012146,
-0.3354351222515106,
-0.06631529331207275,
0.05392170324921608,
0.3363085687160492,
-0.1823483109474182,
0.8531551361083984,
0.6053124666213989,
-0.6755789518356323,
-0.21081797778606415,
0.14576010406017303,
-0.11498990654945374,
0.5097578167915344,
-0.4602409601211548,
0.15933717787265778,
-0.44643259048461914,
0.3041011691093445,
-0.46335628628730774,
-0.23982039093971252,
0.4691152572631836,
-0.12481086701154709,
0.2550211548805237,
-0.30585941672325134,
-0.6582360863685608,
-0.003451521974056959,
-0.5296806693077087,
0.173135906457901,
0.5320674777030945,
-0.45558592677116394,
0.4519895911216736,
0.8639435172080994,
-0.2709139585494995,
-0.8151264190673828,
-0.7355741262435913,
0.10466261953115463,
-0.5662704110145569,
-0.4547918736934662,
0.005128619726747274,
-0.3206782341003418,
-0.3553105592727661,
-0.3329644501209259,
-0.08689671754837036,
0.07260207086801529,
0.41624996066093445,
0.526874303817749,
0.202935591340065,
-0.00006878336716908962,
0.24315086007118225,
0.6360092163085938,
-0.08085726946592331,
0.41370847821235657,
0.15863661468029022,
0.47789862751960754,
0.11080748587846756,
-0.2510826885700226,
-0.26765209436416626,
0.38797634840011597,
0.7290710210800171,
-0.08058429509401321,
0.9675770998001099,
0.4027259647846222,
-0.5332443118095398,
-0.24236823618412018,
-0.37346193194389343,
-0.11434239894151688,
-0.5640409588813782,
0.2510867714881897,
-0.0698331743478775,
-0.9688847064971924,
0.4927021563053131,
-0.05832089111208916,
0.23532716929912567,
0.15604393184185028,
0.7318618297576904,
-0.05266154557466507,
1.0858631134033203,
0.5702813863754272,
-0.5291737914085388,
0.5654357671737671,
0.17494964599609375,
0.047633230686187744,
-0.9976362586021423,
-0.15024562180042267,
-0.3658387064933777,
-0.18381290137767792,
-0.42845413088798523,
-0.1397816389799118,
0.5009390711784363,
-0.2783174216747284,
-0.46203118562698364,
-0.10734061896800995,
-0.2118130773305893,
0.6666397452354431,
0.41332828998565674,
0.21440231800079346,
0.20665106177330017,
-0.03901265189051628,
-0.06607864052057266,
-0.11309146881103516,
-0.43206140398979187,
-0.9511115550994873,
1.2962965965270996,
0.7199733257293701,
0.7885655760765076,
0.2534863352775574,
0.6042696833610535,
0.24833013117313385,
0.9411653280258179,
-0.4368680417537689,
0.5579437613487244,
0.029349137097597122,
-1.0763992071151733,
-0.15794380009174347,
-0.7289664149284363,
-0.88312166929245,
0.5513153076171875,
-0.4171942174434662,
-0.8976574540138245,
-0.03883272781968117,
0.5150963664054871,
-0.4798906743526459,
0.27343568205833435,
-0.6585935354232788,
0.7738569378852844,
-0.20123381912708282,
-0.6386523842811584,
-0.21364666521549225,
-0.6213400959968567,
0.5336676836013794,
-0.2623926103115082,
0.49061959981918335,
-0.290693998336792,
0.07445371150970459,
0.5879548192024231,
-0.11060965806245804,
1.1671961545944214,
-0.1734119951725006,
-0.27867135405540466,
0.16273608803749084,
0.2216036170721054,
0.3639066219329834,
-0.03856053575873375,
-0.19058072566986084,
0.147197425365448,
-0.0009392206557095051,
-0.3104150593280792,
-0.19513095915317535,
0.9974608421325684,
-0.5086506605148315,
-0.47636038064956665,
-0.29102128744125366,
-0.7820897698402405,
-0.34428179264068604,
0.35913699865341187,
-0.01157812774181366,
0.16481786966323853,
-0.1752931922674179,
0.2765904664993286,
0.9094197154045105,
-0.6140556931495667,
0.23758532106876373,
0.5014538168907166,
-0.33004966378211975,
-0.28870275616645813,
0.7311545610427856,
-0.03315640985965729,
0.22849814593791962,
0.035425443202257156,
0.21563094854354858,
-0.04968877509236336,
-0.838058590888977,
-0.5019515156745911,
0.10943398624658585,
-0.8512848615646362,
-0.11423815041780472,
-0.5022223591804504,
0.08357195556163788,
-0.35640478134155273,
-0.040101535618305206,
-0.22391122579574585,
0.16855405271053314,
-0.1708269715309143,
-0.37618282437324524,
-0.03168677166104317,
0.7114877700805664,
-0.03319406509399414,
0.5048322677612305,
-0.7247745394706726,
-0.017643079161643982,
-0.058564990758895874,
0.5477473735809326,
-0.027443792670965195,
-0.2404046207666397,
-0.2418777197599411,
0.08581303805112839,
-0.2959364950656891,
-0.8697659969329834,
0.5417002439498901,
-0.18539048731327057,
0.6032286882400513,
0.5441789031028748,
-0.0019348603673279285,
0.21502983570098877,
-0.5419586896896362,
0.46314388513565063,
-0.010893006809055805,
-0.9155082106590271,
0.5177155137062073,
-0.8957867622375488,
-0.04013212397694588,
0.8400887846946716,
0.3469259440898895,
-0.5742203593254089,
-0.24205397069454193,
-0.1839248687028885,
-0.9756466746330261,
0.4087364673614502,
0.2563513219356537,
0.3995385766029358,
-0.08288080990314484,
0.31485438346862793,
0.00117040378972888,
0.41406288743019104,
-0.8157944679260254,
-0.024427339434623718,
0.2528793215751648,
-0.5406470894813538,
-0.10092702507972717,
-0.5540705323219299,
-0.5187546610832214,
-0.03164725378155708,
0.871523916721344,
-0.11524126678705215,
-0.4827481508255005,
-0.13969211280345917,
-0.2776063084602356,
-0.408348947763443,
0.41790372133255005,
0.6268830895423889,
0.6006105542182922,
-0.17123885452747345,
0.34988000988960266,
0.28202393651008606,
-0.37850937247276306,
0.10914120078086853,
-0.21978619694709778,
-0.6490978002548218,
-0.30414843559265137,
0.1189960390329361,
0.49880552291870117,
0.29469749331474304,
-0.879551112651825,
0.38329651951789856,
0.1797368973493576,
0.1552821546792984,
-0.27997443079948425,
0.13877858221530914,
0.0727345421910286,
0.013973855413496494,
0.06981705874204636,
0.08038628846406937,
0.2673881947994232,
-0.555576741695404,
0.11283475160598755,
0.45709332823753357,
-0.10222284495830536,
-0.2881719470024109,
0.7106127142906189,
0.722735583782196,
-0.009078217670321465,
0.23028786480426788,
-0.06816757470369339,
-0.327806681394577,
0.4898967444896698,
0.3468885123729706,
0.6451478600502014,
-0.35860034823417664,
-0.07350970804691315,
0.27644917368888855,
0.7473838925361633,
-0.06999584287405014,
0.11284954845905304,
0.29007619619369507,
-0.8115995526313782,
-0.41934025287628174,
-0.5878340601921082,
-0.44586285948753357,
0.27883291244506836,
-0.4584776759147644,
-0.011016647331416607,
-0.8045504093170166,
-0.22746700048446655,
-0.20514796674251556,
-0.4520309269428253,
-0.20072144269943237,
0.2289765179157257,
0.48477882146835327,
0.8330236077308655,
-1.4396920204162598,
0.8411650061607361,
0.4268169403076172,
-0.4189314842224121,
-0.5519551634788513,
0.0999668538570404,
0.28565919399261475,
-0.39757660031318665,
0.3985942006111145,
0.3855988681316376,
-0.08371120691299438,
-0.37202802300453186,
-0.5489631295204163,
-0.9112415909767151,
0.8610517382621765,
0.748782217502594,
-0.6561703681945801,
0.18923121690750122,
0.20208950340747833,
0.6175107955932617,
-0.2617225646972656,
-0.018546579405665398,
0.7213992476463318,
0.44823479652404785,
-0.0371001735329628,
-0.84770667552948,
0.3091786503791809,
-0.29132080078125,
0.10910350829362869,
0.14636795222759247,
-0.38402026891708374,
0.48322078585624695,
0.007782581262290478,
-0.13568460941314697,
-0.09892396628856659,
0.3948923945426941,
0.48993825912475586,
0.4477322995662689,
0.5919003486633301,
0.41869261860847473,
0.6766406297683716,
-0.03662592172622681,
1.152348279953003,
-0.15116843581199646,
0.0840587168931961,
1.0634104013442993,
-0.40825220942497253,
0.7121968865394592,
0.7625642418861389,
0.08859309554100037,
0.4098110496997833,
0.6847121119499207,
0.36824744939804077,
0.48917821049690247,
0.40859276056289673,
-0.214468315243721,
-0.24099093675613403,
-0.3516451120376587,
-0.1252031922340393,
0.11154847592115402,
0.4271681606769562,
-0.8349981307983398,
0.04748513549566269,
-0.18348056077957153,
0.5655876398086548,
0.17585983872413635,
-0.25072580575942993,
0.4011980891227722,
0.19976374506950378,
-0.6559968590736389,
0.22293983399868011,
-0.04874824732542038,
0.8692181706428528,
-0.5709578394889832,
0.09110632538795471,
-0.22722022235393524,
0.24574917554855347,
-0.31279265880584717,
-0.6789220571517944,
0.6218299865722656,
0.06968886405229568,
-0.13207443058490753,
-0.2812824547290802,
0.6276862025260925,
-0.5031081438064575,
-0.39685413241386414,
0.3835144340991974,
0.18698157370090485,
0.016933484002947807,
-0.04161602258682251,
-0.28486311435699463,
0.431019127368927,
-0.16735488176345825,
-0.32178550958633423,
0.4578137993812561,
0.1865520030260086,
-0.28936445713043213,
0.8707688450813293,
0.7492700219154358,
0.10271576046943665,
0.00995629746466875,
0.315828800201416,
0.9932202696800232,
-0.3618152439594269,
-0.4999464750289917,
-1.0039066076278687,
0.5864334106445312,
-0.15089958906173706,
-0.22591263055801392,
0.7350159883499146,
0.4920307993888855,
0.6376820802688599,
-0.06425821781158447,
0.8857083916664124,
0.25033465027809143,
0.2976919710636139,
-0.5658844709396362,
1.0524790287017822,
-0.30112242698669434,
0.35829564929008484,
-0.42966359853744507,
-0.7629842162132263,
-0.40375855565071106,
0.4797661006450653,
-0.36653831601142883,
0.13492326438426971,
0.2591373324394226,
0.8920074105262756,
-0.02648800052702427,
-0.39948010444641113,
0.27255895733833313,
0.22069358825683594,
0.4918554127216339,
0.5547466278076172,
0.7968820333480835,
-0.05619940906763077,
0.48201432824134827,
-0.201546311378479,
-0.3400532007217407,
-0.13717900216579437,
-1.1265037059783936,
-1.092170238494873,
-0.13882356882095337,
-0.2406395822763443,
-0.276532381772995,
0.25796201825141907,
0.9561228156089783,
0.913414716720581,
-0.837303638458252,
-0.08881875872612,
0.1427805870771408,
0.09731291234493256,
0.11023277044296265,
-0.15786059200763702,
0.002645442495122552,
-0.05706673115491867,
-0.7648313045501709,
0.41692984104156494,
0.17326052486896515,
-0.07224765419960022,
-0.47717005014419556,
-0.2249462753534317,
0.12280719727277756,
0.238326296210289,
0.6540008783340454,
0.12484521418809891,
-0.5151364207267761,
-0.5251303315162659,
-0.39254677295684814,
-0.22582462430000305,
-0.029141360893845558,
0.4723324179649353,
-0.4895470142364502,
0.27179330587387085,
0.5224639177322388,
0.7285054326057434,
0.05787571147084236,
-0.044110991060733795,
0.7621652483940125,
-0.9411616921424866,
0.17138153314590454,
0.1337296962738037,
0.7758589386940002,
0.6204448938369751,
-0.5355338454246521,
0.5400986075401306,
-0.11515140533447266,
-0.37007787823677063,
-0.9704211354255676,
0.3793174922466278,
-0.9671236872673035,
-0.10649900883436203,
1.5165331363677979,
-0.07239638268947601,
-0.2057754546403885,
-0.005482737440615892,
-0.3613060712814331,
0.31467100977897644,
-0.43235278129577637,
1.108345627784729,
0.516160786151886,
0.42842742800712585,
-0.011441044509410858,
-0.6852770447731018,
0.4500197470188141,
0.571343719959259,
-1.139096975326538,
0.20382414758205414,
0.7167808413505554,
0.8203216195106506,
0.18982021510601044,
0.4872361123561859,
-0.1684054285287857,
-0.0009379519615322351,
-0.42467811703681946,
0.26063573360443115,
-0.018191803246736526,
-0.45874813199043274,
-0.520354151725769,
0.0486333891749382,
0.0646350234746933,
-0.15981969237327576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11282v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11282v3
|
Estimating the Level of Dialectness Predicts Interannotator Agreement in Multi-dialect Arabic Datasets
| 2024-05-18T12:58:02 | 2024-06-06T20:32:45 |
Amr Keleg, Walid Magdy, Sharon Goldwater
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
On annotating multi-dialect Arabic datasets, it is common to randomly assign
the samples across a pool of native Arabic speakers. Recent analyses
recommended routing dialectal samples to native speakers of their respective
dialects to build higher-quality datasets. However, automatically identifying
the dialect of samples is hard. Moreover, the pool of annotators who are native
speakers of specific Arabic dialects might be scarce. Arabic Level of
Dialectness (ALDi) was recently introduced as a quantitative variable that
measures how sentences diverge from Standard Arabic. On randomly assigning
samples to annotators, we hypothesize that samples of higher ALDi scores are
harder to label especially if they are written in dialects that the annotators
do not speak. We test this by analyzing the relation between ALDi scores and
the annotators' agreement, on 15 public datasets having raw individual sample
annotations for various sentence-classification tasks. We find strong evidence
supporting our hypothesis for 11 of them. Consequently, we recommend
prioritizing routing samples of high ALDi scores to native speakers of each
sample's dialect, for which the dialect could be automatically identified at
higher accuracies.
|
[
-1.0568015575408936,
-0.34033000469207764,
0.4312339127063751,
0.2323927879333496,
-0.21062444150447845,
0.03534989431500435,
-0.35529080033302307,
-0.7284027934074402,
0.4396555721759796,
0.34491193294525146,
-0.2738732695579529,
-0.5943759679794312,
-0.953464686870575,
0.30756044387817383,
-0.3446875214576721,
1.0094287395477295,
0.1413702666759491,
-0.25650644302368164,
-0.06902047991752625,
-0.6536828279495239,
-0.10215668380260468,
-0.6996267437934875,
-0.45419958233833313,
-0.0013448272366076708,
0.5530079007148743,
0.4970951974391937,
0.9990654587745667,
0.5704939961433411,
0.3190741539001465,
0.3534659743309021,
-0.02313448116183281,
-0.011409533210098743,
0.1354924738407135,
0.26839014887809753,
-0.013638993725180626,
-0.28021731972694397,
-0.334400475025177,
-0.1804753988981247,
0.19607846438884735,
0.9980625510215759,
0.033503707498311996,
0.028213514015078545,
-0.12770166993141174,
0.736344039440155,
-0.7188897728919983,
0.12673720717430115,
-0.45412763953208923,
-0.19889448583126068,
-0.4450168311595917,
0.16560214757919312,
-0.13243718445301056,
-0.4194363057613373,
0.19007229804992676,
-0.3950146436691284,
0.45966050028800964,
0.10949743539094925,
0.9917719960212708,
0.14833301305770874,
-0.6738103032112122,
-0.4227650463581085,
-0.49598371982574463,
0.5098411440849304,
-0.8358272314071655,
0.24451181292533875,
0.7978729009628296,
0.2375970333814621,
0.06086607277393341,
-0.1134692132472992,
-0.6666905879974365,
-0.20687034726142883,
-0.22268205881118774,
-0.09072629362344742,
-0.2406379133462906,
0.12842784821987152,
0.20431454479694366,
0.10946321487426758,
-0.3790692687034607,
0.22996987402439117,
-0.4449704587459564,
-0.12135918438434601,
0.6922991871833801,
-0.19790127873420715,
0.018298398703336716,
-0.2380196750164032,
-0.25639787316322327,
0.05589217692613602,
-0.5301000475883484,
0.11167363077402115,
0.5919463634490967,
0.4932810068130493,
0.014682134613394737,
0.5279256701469421,
-0.7127818465232849,
0.4035717844963074,
0.12367139011621475,
0.13273248076438904,
0.5686631202697754,
-0.39155998826026917,
0.20527954399585724,
0.49946698546409607,
0.8287050724029541,
0.30513113737106323,
0.7087278366088867,
0.017086004838347435,
-0.41378775238990784,
-0.2341376394033432,
-0.017273632809519768,
-0.5989232659339905,
-0.47537553310394287,
0.383268266916275,
-0.2705913484096527,
0.15198424458503723,
0.3324475884437561,
-0.7563679218292236,
-0.40930089354515076,
-0.05535165220499039,
0.3468659818172455,
-0.34774887561798096,
-0.3162443935871124,
-0.16844838857650757,
0.16642582416534424,
-0.21921980381011963,
0.26521751284599304,
-0.9663856625556946,
0.31190192699432373,
0.507275402545929,
0.9091676473617554,
0.13695025444030762,
-0.5284612774848938,
-0.4141518175601959,
0.04792741686105728,
-0.6770354509353638,
0.8793897032737732,
-0.38623425364494324,
-0.26738816499710083,
0.19489943981170654,
-0.15466278791427612,
-0.03459816053509712,
-0.7983749508857727,
0.6372200846672058,
-0.50323486328125,
0.07902257889509201,
-0.33176901936531067,
-0.43424901366233826,
-0.3871370851993561,
-0.027298500761389732,
-0.9075995087623596,
0.8148836493492126,
0.3123723268508911,
-0.4761415123939514,
0.6782485842704773,
-0.3771283030509949,
-0.500189483165741,
-0.07408171892166138,
0.022587930783629417,
-0.39708080887794495,
0.19778761267662048,
0.49506664276123047,
0.41571974754333496,
-0.01628822088241577,
0.08902782946825027,
-0.42759719491004944,
-0.3688037097454071,
0.5613425970077515,
-0.40951916575431824,
0.7904230356216431,
0.28576284646987915,
-0.4358571469783783,
-0.0417931005358696,
-0.7199840545654297,
0.005952673032879829,
-0.5502750277519226,
-0.23298336565494537,
-0.45708879828453064,
0.11193911731243134,
0.058194372802972794,
0.31589898467063904,
-0.01710362359881401,
-0.5763795375823975,
0.2522840201854706,
-0.41882583498954773,
0.16039924323558807,
0.9293634295463562,
0.0077096326276659966,
0.4079552888870239,
-0.5888762474060059,
0.4563329517841339,
0.2102653682231903,
-0.22566010057926178,
0.068332739174366,
-0.49577781558036804,
-1.180507779121399,
-0.4312467575073242,
0.6587673425674438,
0.2758929133415222,
-0.2328978180885315,
0.5849530696868896,
-0.4893125593662262,
-0.5806244611740112,
-0.6665936708450317,
0.21256333589553833,
0.19107301533222198,
-0.04393554851412773,
0.4927288591861725,
-0.4689594507217407,
-0.10623794794082642,
-1.0206835269927979,
-0.04165239259600639,
-0.4795725643634796,
0.22172418236732483,
0.04281504079699516,
0.3911466598510742,
-0.025330903008580208,
1.0269432067871094,
-0.08672235906124115,
-0.3829972445964813,
-0.16688860952854156,
0.45594504475593567,
0.2547999918460846,
0.3528720438480377,
0.7147873640060425,
-0.51929771900177,
-0.6498252749443054,
0.12267176806926727,
-0.17796911299228668,
-0.3375973403453827,
0.0802089050412178,
-0.009356174618005753,
0.4454116225242615,
0.36210429668426514,
-0.5581702589988708,
0.4944513738155365,
0.49232539534568787,
-0.24855999648571014,
0.2962963581085205,
0.008342825807631016,
0.40242651104927063,
-0.7622876763343811,
-0.4724048972129822,
-0.001200757920742035,
0.005712880287319422,
-0.5150102376937866,
-0.2547304034233093,
-0.10305401682853699,
0.2312735617160797,
-0.0035132840275764465,
0.3961507976055145,
-0.1737094521522522,
-0.01699122041463852,
0.137667715549469,
-0.2813713252544403,
0.00876669306308031,
0.42657989263534546,
0.05187623202800751,
1.0158379077911377,
0.2679234445095062,
-0.44412994384765625,
0.13853485882282257,
0.06206032261252403,
-0.8561777472496033,
0.566673994064331,
-0.5500165820121765,
0.03099050745368004,
-0.12096553295850754,
0.04390300065279007,
-1.4186252355575562,
-0.23996016383171082,
0.091472327709198,
-0.3828791677951813,
-0.2551685869693756,
-0.12170950323343277,
-0.36286023259162903,
0.11947634816169739,
-0.03315373882651329,
0.42601191997528076,
0.12056586146354675,
-0.4915046989917755,
0.47511816024780273,
-0.04342316463589668,
-0.6371597051620483,
-0.4495294690132141,
-0.43205782771110535,
-0.004077734891325235,
-0.5178797841072083,
-0.5488577485084534,
-0.03272099792957306,
0.08128926157951355,
-0.7234537601470947,
0.014992103911936283,
0.11648432910442352,
-0.3491322994232178,
0.04646902531385422,
0.5862728357315063,
-0.10753500461578369,
-0.36264848709106445,
0.3872770667076111,
0.09355804324150085,
-0.04582890123128891,
0.19630509614944458,
0.11635885387659073,
0.39633631706237793,
0.03523539751768112,
-0.6204530000686646,
-0.2547735273838043,
0.5754513740539551,
0.5396086573600769,
-0.39621126651763916,
0.8209711909294128,
0.4292289614677429,
-0.06462472677230835,
-0.13385999202728271,
-0.7705481052398682,
0.13471223413944244,
-0.44984692335128784,
0.45685112476348877,
-0.7317700982093811,
-0.3861571252346039,
0.5074931979179382,
0.0498315803706646,
-0.21729443967342377,
0.48112753033638,
0.3057675063610077,
-0.2613185942173004,
0.9073376655578613,
0.35017532110214233,
-0.3422739505767822,
0.23205335438251495,
0.011452991515398026,
0.3353006839752197,
-0.19229654967784882,
0.033301934599876404,
-0.759587824344635,
-0.4502814710140228,
-0.7876175045967102,
-0.1317831575870514,
0.48861706256866455,
0.15805144608020782,
-0.5830218195915222,
0.0164711344987154,
-0.0070371259935200214,
0.4834572970867157,
0.9558269381523132,
-0.13291051983833313,
0.336135596036911,
0.2687855660915375,
0.22172817587852478,
0.06130826100707054,
-0.45653125643730164,
-0.4775809347629547,
0.9229224324226379,
0.08384910225868225,
0.1996726244688034,
0.7188108563423157,
0.9523155093193054,
0.7143327593803406,
0.051913101226091385,
-0.560409426689148,
0.2747393548488617,
-0.034791652113199234,
-0.5261942744255066,
-0.11063402146100998,
-0.22527167201042175,
-0.7770679593086243,
-0.008175963535904884,
-0.2058572620153427,
-0.6450233459472656,
0.7387427091598511,
-0.20419932901859283,
-0.47557786107063293,
-0.04168524593114853,
-0.7396672368049622,
0.7489565014839172,
-0.13550502061843872,
-0.15427342057228088,
-0.01074275467544794,
-0.7188876867294312,
0.08975920081138611,
-0.2714279890060425,
0.48992258310317993,
-0.5063238143920898,
-0.02452031522989273,
0.8860061764717102,
-0.7539517283439636,
0.5877225399017334,
-0.1861746907234192,
-0.06208771839737892,
0.3612559735774994,
0.18734830617904663,
0.23210382461547852,
-0.0980641171336174,
-0.4959228038787842,
0.6069369316101074,
0.26742973923683167,
-0.6348204612731934,
-0.4497538208961487,
0.49278661608695984,
-1.241768717765808,
-0.5687698125839233,
-0.778106153011322,
-0.3373243808746338,
-0.3319723308086395,
-0.08205348998308182,
0.41012755036354065,
0.3589869439601898,
0.14246676862239838,
-0.050666969269514084,
0.1533508449792862,
0.07208990305662155,
0.5209532976150513,
0.248168483376503,
0.06606226414442062,
-0.5190421342849731,
0.9820696115493774,
0.4721955955028534,
0.5104774236679077,
0.13096772134304047,
-0.08854036778211594,
-0.18004120886325836,
-0.7039932608604431,
-0.6511924266815186,
-0.06894949078559875,
-0.7971792817115784,
-0.18357521295547485,
-0.16159886121749878,
-0.3542206287384033,
-0.34222450852394104,
-0.34233859181404114,
-0.10840512812137604,
-0.7495600581169128,
0.10914893448352814,
-0.3075140714645386,
0.586093544960022,
0.8998154997825623,
-0.27185526490211487,
0.460605263710022,
-0.5042006969451904,
-0.0699729323387146,
0.26290902495384216,
-0.10308073461055756,
-0.07597910612821579,
-0.49421408772468567,
-0.42497265338897705,
0.07959792017936707,
0.07671932876110077,
-0.8439674973487854,
0.32602792978286743,
0.45498448610305786,
0.06918307393789291,
0.7980721592903137,
0.34138065576553345,
0.8620703220367432,
-0.2842901051044464,
0.6549800038337708,
-0.09239207208156586,
-0.9987794160842896,
0.19246451556682587,
-0.19052067399024963,
0.03390239551663399,
0.9989686012268066,
0.6209557056427002,
-0.5213181376457214,
-0.47690483927726746,
-0.3800325393676758,
-1.0940109491348267,
0.4116324484348297,
-0.08619888126850128,
0.2737533748149872,
-0.21010567247867584,
0.15987619757652283,
0.3641297221183777,
0.2589257061481476,
-0.47862571477890015,
-0.30515915155410767,
-0.2750329077243805,
-0.44774898886680603,
-0.40831515192985535,
-0.3256036937236786,
-0.14610372483730316,
-0.18125495314598083,
0.4497990608215332,
-0.016819942742586136,
0.12684082984924316,
-0.058757249265909195,
0.023926623165607452,
-0.12442535907030106,
0.564444899559021,
0.3682428300380707,
0.9330780506134033,
-0.38113918900489807,
0.46108901500701904,
-0.15054647624492645,
-0.3380166292190552,
0.6418343186378479,
0.3913092315196991,
-0.22791573405265808,
0.2222750186920166,
0.8963850140571594,
0.5472661256790161,
-0.563426673412323,
-0.6789661645889282,
0.6167638897895813,
0.23460839688777924,
-0.08330038189888,
-0.43935704231262207,
0.15060091018676758,
-0.17367033660411835,
0.27541083097457886,
0.3837239444255829,
0.2082984447479248,
0.14068402349948883,
-0.45998138189315796,
0.1274554431438446,
0.28167179226875305,
-0.48612093925476074,
-0.14957237243652344,
0.2955132722854614,
0.21807068586349487,
-0.2703648507595062,
0.8327460289001465,
-0.40735724568367004,
-0.48627007007598877,
0.7621549963951111,
0.04784369841217995,
0.4647127389907837,
-0.21097587049007416,
0.1740635186433792,
0.32848846912384033,
0.28958290815353394,
0.2151990830898285,
-0.024913590401411057,
-0.14293134212493896,
-0.8424595594406128,
-0.21923711895942688,
-0.5940307378768921,
-0.42815208435058594,
-0.33618971705436707,
-0.8549469113349915,
0.047379571944475174,
-0.3040827810764313,
-0.25183698534965515,
-0.013229608535766602,
0.085576131939888,
-0.6529780626296997,
0.24035333096981049,
0.027110597118735313,
0.6347887516021729,
-1.1639572381973267,
0.8646880984306335,
0.3630135953426361,
-0.6079094409942627,
-0.6136608719825745,
0.3229963183403015,
-0.0876869186758995,
-0.5858052968978882,
1.025164008140564,
0.14477814733982086,
0.04612639546394348,
-0.2273433357477188,
-0.06715521216392517,
-0.8655160069465637,
0.6048936247825623,
0.0884486734867096,
-0.6482486724853516,
0.2695390284061432,
0.637065052986145,
0.3007766604423523,
-0.19881974160671234,
0.6299708485603333,
0.5057457089424133,
0.3772384822368622,
-0.1937788873910904,
-1.0024263858795166,
-0.08366493135690689,
-0.2959776818752289,
-0.21549050509929657,
0.3299960792064667,
-0.6598826050758362,
1.2408274412155151,
-0.23847638070583344,
-0.014957570470869541,
0.3183886706829071,
0.8758861422538757,
0.05110098421573639,
0.4668132960796356,
0.7174504399299622,
0.5893124938011169,
0.8311709761619568,
-0.2026486098766327,
0.6340658068656921,
-0.40766316652297974,
-0.01620008610188961,
1.2145121097564697,
-0.36321502923965454,
1.0962755680084229,
0.3897918164730072,
-0.42309847474098206,
0.8868927955627441,
0.7374887466430664,
0.27246400713920593,
0.7206583023071289,
0.21259117126464844,
-0.7634276747703552,
-0.166580468416214,
-0.3295659124851227,
-0.405815988779068,
0.6220110654830933,
0.20575609803199768,
-0.3165167570114136,
0.0719887986779213,
-0.09341602772474289,
0.11407668888568878,
0.09797447919845581,
-0.1280355304479599,
0.8728315234184265,
-0.38613468408584595,
-0.5823371410369873,
0.7149469256401062,
0.0053493850864470005,
0.4071640372276306,
-0.5085024237632751,
0.0612262524664402,
-0.5478938221931458,
0.04468867927789688,
-0.2636469602584839,
-0.7073703408241272,
0.13661634922027588,
-0.10307253152132034,
-0.32645872235298157,
0.19454501569271088,
0.0022165533155202866,
-0.5507473349571228,
-0.650497555732727,
0.2511468827724457,
0.8192844986915588,
0.2273057997226715,
-0.03543576970696449,
-0.2527516782283783,
0.08034238964319229,
-0.13808292150497437,
-0.15641435980796814,
0.3252899646759033,
0.7471113801002502,
-0.11847617477178574,
0.27175647020339966,
0.420879602432251,
0.43392670154571533,
0.18761126697063446,
0.023121953010559082,
0.6365019679069519,
-0.4603849947452545,
-0.20752669870853424,
-0.788171112537384,
0.17987585067749023,
-0.03770286217331886,
-0.6199122071266174,
0.9396956562995911,
0.5400587320327759,
1.0838584899902344,
0.3081439435482025,
1.0178842544555664,
-0.07782629132270813,
0.6505634784698486,
-0.5080534815788269,
0.5071015357971191,
-0.3624960780143738,
0.3400087058544159,
-0.2007100135087967,
-1.0723190307617188,
0.03402969613671303,
0.9029020667076111,
-0.547290563583374,
0.27515673637390137,
0.538897693157196,
0.942363440990448,
-0.24972234666347504,
0.08867601305246353,
-0.07177910208702087,
0.20506705343723297,
0.14825040102005005,
0.49816060066223145,
0.8469212055206299,
-0.15488877892494202,
0.20635710656642914,
-0.9148421287536621,
0.12572985887527466,
0.05983409658074379,
-0.6139468550682068,
-0.801166296005249,
-0.7206315398216248,
-0.21762517094612122,
-0.5640154480934143,
0.2854344844818115,
1.3459230661392212,
0.6797410249710083,
-1.002320408821106,
-0.6768428087234497,
0.16058120131492615,
0.019780198112130165,
-0.36307576298713684,
-0.2502302825450897,
0.6437506675720215,
-0.11458171904087067,
-0.8344831466674805,
0.04438770189881325,
-0.013795450329780579,
-0.13274675607681274,
-0.14105314016342163,
-0.03814064711332321,
-0.24903984367847443,
0.07122141867876053,
0.2450658529996872,
0.11310157179832458,
-0.751971423625946,
-0.45359930396080017,
-0.48132503032684326,
-0.16516876220703125,
0.31413960456848145,
0.3526201844215393,
-0.808176577091217,
0.43527278304100037,
0.16938278079032898,
0.40470248460769653,
0.14579907059669495,
0.3426954448223114,
0.2548542022705078,
-0.6781671047210693,
0.18166489899158478,
0.0084822503849864,
0.35966604948043823,
0.4238794147968292,
-0.07777826488018036,
0.518848717212677,
-0.0014742513885721564,
-0.5982084274291992,
-0.4556124210357666,
0.058648377656936646,
-0.6863765716552734,
-0.18275804817676544,
1.1202595233917236,
-0.28827789425849915,
0.09105321764945984,
-0.4295296370983124,
-0.15550464391708374,
-0.20062962174415588,
-0.7137776613235474,
0.827592670917511,
1.0661643743515015,
-0.3255019187927246,
-0.09938854724168777,
-0.6878240704536438,
0.5328488945960999,
0.5009836554527283,
-0.5432407259941101,
0.07296104729175568,
0.4914741814136505,
0.0709424763917923,
0.3909761607646942,
0.6975898146629333,
0.7246295213699341,
0.08690090477466583,
-0.07221604883670807,
-0.14651383459568024,
0.16395142674446106,
-0.3687518239021301,
-0.1957409679889679,
0.3750365078449249,
0.5185877680778503,
-0.1275162249803543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11277v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11277v2
|
Action Controlled Paraphrasing
| 2024-05-18T12:26:31 | 2024-07-01T23:23:41 |
Ning Shi, Zijun Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent studies have demonstrated the potential to control paraphrase
generation, such as through syntax, which has broad applications in various
downstream tasks. However, these methods often require detailed parse trees or
syntactic exemplars, countering human-like paraphrasing behavior in language
use. Furthermore, an inference gap exists, as control specifications are only
available during training but not during inference. In this work, we propose a
new setup for controlled paraphrase generation. Specifically, we represent user
intent as action tokens, embedding and concatenating them with text embeddings,
thus flowing together into a self-attention encoder for representation fusion.
To address the inference gap, we introduce an optional action token as a
placeholder that encourages the model to determine the appropriate action
independently when users' intended actions are not provided. Experimental
results show that our method successfully enables precise action-controlled
paraphrasing and preserves or even enhances performance compared to
conventional uncontrolled methods when actions are not given. Our findings
promote the concept of action-controlled paraphrasing for a more user-centered
design.
|
[
0.13622410595417023,
-0.7084664702415466,
0.5566743612289429,
0.4560149610042572,
-0.46453234553337097,
-0.2956981360912323,
0.23963645100593567,
0.36040300130844116,
0.5451170802116394,
0.9035941362380981,
-0.2424284666776657,
-0.4094189703464508,
-0.4272165298461914,
0.0660821944475174,
-0.4828241467475891,
0.7355278730392456,
-0.535007894039154,
-0.3018955886363983,
-0.2908191680908203,
-0.3485342860221863,
-0.4550612270832062,
-0.44457101821899414,
-0.4421594738960266,
-0.08070917427539825,
0.682407021522522,
0.31003111600875854,
0.7963897585868835,
0.7528008222579956,
0.4135397970676422,
0.2721797823905945,
0.0953417643904686,
0.1741313338279724,
0.02021269127726555,
0.28247949481010437,
-0.463970810174942,
-0.30604788661003113,
-0.33827856183052063,
-0.18297472596168518,
0.7279799580574036,
0.5031116604804993,
-0.3685078024864197,
-0.20775993168354034,
0.285243958234787,
0.08459673076868057,
-0.8379516005516052,
0.03369688242673874,
-0.40005677938461304,
0.2145262360572815,
-0.1562352031469345,
-0.15897849202156067,
-0.3814033567905426,
-0.20661094784736633,
-0.18675944209098816,
-0.42456215620040894,
0.08131327480077744,
0.08402132242918015,
0.5719600319862366,
0.40384188294410706,
-0.1557379513978958,
-0.32382720708847046,
-0.24561424553394318,
0.5440849661827087,
-0.8582781553268433,
0.06710132211446762,
0.336304634809494,
0.023279674351215363,
-0.11648416519165039,
-1.227482557296753,
-0.6469465494155884,
0.08878564834594727,
-0.5738104581832886,
0.12923158705234528,
-0.21701115369796753,
0.23905049264431,
0.15170475840568542,
-0.032453179359436035,
-0.33647963404655457,
-0.22100979089736938,
-0.23513875901699066,
-0.2544627785682678,
0.3030747175216675,
0.2246175855398178,
0.24960048496723175,
-0.7646007537841797,
-0.5357564091682434,
-0.02840098924934864,
-0.5802314877510071,
0.04392974451184273,
0.03775395452976227,
0.07389426231384277,
0.25977498292922974,
0.9538128972053528,
-0.23858459293842316,
0.4145689010620117,
0.04657343775033951,
0.4238077402114868,
-0.0876837894320488,
-0.20296773314476013,
-0.6356154084205627,
-0.142130509018898,
1.0391167402267456,
0.2677614092826843,
0.06917039304971695,
-0.3698806166648865,
-0.0700182095170021,
-0.014344350434839725,
0.496527761220932,
-0.35455551743507385,
-0.16871948540210724,
0.24959689378738403,
-0.3131592869758606,
-0.10405346751213074,
0.17272384464740753,
-0.8464470505714417,
-0.16402676701545715,
-0.2728157341480255,
0.44450998306274414,
-0.37981823086738586,
0.07792332023382187,
-0.12362336367368698,
-0.3952201306819916,
0.29337894916534424,
-0.10723104327917099,
-0.8217400312423706,
0.5002987384796143,
0.36101680994033813,
0.7953867316246033,
-0.5435692667961121,
-0.7278184294700623,
-0.5587508678436279,
0.905795156955719,
-0.4016745984554291,
0.5039156079292297,
-0.8182138204574585,
-0.3518458604812622,
-0.03658844530582428,
-0.14017988741397858,
-0.4108084440231323,
-0.3486577868461609,
0.37623563408851624,
-0.40655213594436646,
0.24911503493785858,
-0.07836277782917023,
-0.6509398221969604,
-0.09578606486320496,
-0.03704094514250755,
-0.4121803343296051,
0.7045263051986694,
0.02478126250207424,
-0.5394511818885803,
0.19366762042045593,
-0.568716824054718,
-0.7195113897323608,
0.1265081912279129,
-0.8260694742202759,
-0.358527272939682,
0.20351465046405792,
0.24963873624801636,
0.5591060519218445,
0.23749956488609314,
0.44162803888320923,
-0.07471591979265213,
-0.2303493618965149,
0.09041042625904083,
-0.3980477452278137,
0.4642264246940613,
0.14146502315998077,
-0.7112318277359009,
0.3266485929489136,
-0.20450398325920105,
0.2844974398612976,
-0.13472849130630493,
-0.2220572829246521,
-0.26173385977745056,
-0.09583830088376999,
-0.382042795419693,
0.4184686243534088,
0.2736741900444031,
-0.23250125348567963,
-0.18302133679389954,
-0.12141702324151993,
0.5989816784858704,
0.6078311800956726,
0.4775286018848419,
0.6188142895698547,
-0.01429040264338255,
0.6490039825439453,
-0.0908217579126358,
0.2272382229566574,
-0.14124588668346405,
-0.16417047381401062,
-0.6466790437698364,
-0.08592244237661362,
0.026256738230586052,
0.2965701222419739,
-0.8691508769989014,
0.6850565075874329,
-0.14524801075458527,
-0.06229628995060921,
-0.44287407398223877,
0.4665089547634125,
0.5797709226608276,
0.48390769958496094,
0.7410967350006104,
-0.07579915970563889,
-0.11093081533908844,
-0.8977591395378113,
-0.49552059173583984,
0.16211529076099396,
-0.21243947744369507,
0.3498345613479614,
0.1293448954820633,
0.2942858040332794,
0.8810407519340515,
-0.3520977795124054,
-0.15868745744228363,
-0.8507325649261475,
0.15142351388931274,
-0.31926241517066956,
0.6444795727729797,
0.24376827478408813,
-1.0137375593185425,
-0.34487658739089966,
-0.48676353693008423,
-0.9603474736213684,
-0.22129759192466736,
-0.44956034421920776,
-0.7053126692771912,
-0.2207425981760025,
0.9661821722984314,
-1.0242607593536377,
0.6598851084709167,
0.39980730414390564,
-0.5804690718650818,
-0.13220256567001343,
-0.3511682152748108,
0.11422888189554214,
-1.2076241970062256,
0.33014440536499023,
-0.42311346530914307,
0.02638309635221958,
-0.30336806178092957,
0.16762109100818634,
0.44774186611175537,
-0.18214236199855804,
-0.6370764970779419,
0.5301260352134705,
-0.31021901965141296,
0.07937224954366684,
-0.40500253438949585,
-0.06960920989513397,
0.2689019441604614,
0.8418372869491577,
0.2444622665643692,
0.5150317549705505,
0.35366058349609375,
-0.7524464726448059,
-0.03308524563908577,
0.6560671329498291,
-0.00845872238278389,
0.32965531945228577,
-0.87348872423172,
0.019268732517957687,
0.06904187053442001,
0.40098851919174194,
-0.8803199529647827,
-0.5964072942733765,
0.46181297302246094,
-0.19619017839431763,
0.11657872051000595,
0.3212776184082031,
-0.44656404852867126,
-0.28658363223075867,
-0.200361430644989,
-0.05200262740254402,
0.5429319143295288,
-0.3213485777378082,
0.6344231367111206,
0.049617283046245575,
-0.23378710448741913,
-0.10349316895008087,
-0.9237263202667236,
0.3252367675304413,
-0.48907628655433655,
-0.006042824126780033,
0.3210325837135315,
0.1571042537689209,
0.02357442118227482,
-0.196849063038826,
-0.14152921736240387,
-0.057807374745607376,
-0.05141861364245415,
0.23612794280052185,
-0.24272432923316956,
0.2473476082086563,
0.2113099992275238,
0.7600338459014893,
-0.0069300890900194645,
-0.01365617848932743,
0.06963241100311279,
0.49554169178009033,
0.6961513757705688,
-0.5873411893844604,
-0.6095606684684753,
0.9503840804100037,
0.6915705800056458,
-0.5341033339500427,
0.2982918322086334,
0.13056816160678864,
-0.17799432575702667,
-0.050202593207359314,
-0.1484726220369339,
-0.33851566910743713,
-0.5415287613868713,
-0.054996393620967865,
-0.1933954358100891,
-0.5113495588302612,
0.15124823153018951,
-0.0729406550526619,
0.3423094153404236,
0.22911906242370605,
0.3756508529186249,
-0.22820790112018585,
0.9132997393608093,
0.19312137365341187,
0.3589465320110321,
0.5028924942016602,
-0.017951907590031624,
0.06674864143133163,
-0.8341148495674133,
-0.2060353010892868,
-0.12253288179636002,
-0.9296436309814453,
-0.05404173210263252,
-0.4673653244972229,
-0.09000501781702042,
0.41724252700805664,
-0.21642161905765533,
0.45543909072875977,
-0.2577963173389435,
0.3663897216320038,
0.7739250659942627,
0.15830115973949432,
-0.034677084535360336,
0.08046571165323257,
-0.2949275076389313,
-0.20704437792301178,
-0.7868499159812927,
-0.47296765446662903,
0.7302709221839905,
-0.0704340711236,
0.7407857179641724,
0.05876968055963516,
0.9507221579551697,
0.3930300176143646,
-0.01770823635160923,
-0.2901037335395813,
0.7292137145996094,
0.029330162331461906,
-0.43831533193588257,
-0.44072553515434265,
-0.13858848810195923,
-0.8517308831214905,
0.2326584756374359,
0.4172056317329407,
-0.6187824010848999,
0.1445879340171814,
0.5796310305595398,
-0.6730427145957947,
0.012352827936410904,
-0.8798395991325378,
1.0198626518249512,
-0.03185352310538292,
-0.45857560634613037,
-0.11195989698171616,
-0.9398672580718994,
-0.20428353548049927,
0.17003928124904633,
-0.2868747115135193,
0.026292549446225166,
-0.22992049157619476,
0.8040829300880432,
-0.43238434195518494,
1.0537012815475464,
-0.4197823703289032,
0.442211776971817,
0.6677183508872986,
0.28973525762557983,
0.7152016162872314,
-0.060105107724666595,
0.03527006134390831,
-0.3941602408885956,
-0.6371767520904541,
-0.6673209071159363,
-0.6383899450302124,
0.8163748979568481,
-0.09838921576738358,
-0.655575156211853,
-0.01569635234773159,
-0.38934871554374695,
-0.32748547196388245,
0.35370904207229614,
0.531118631362915,
0.3110775351524353,
0.1465173363685608,
0.5250862240791321,
0.3981722295284271,
0.0363706573843956,
0.8405124545097351,
0.14203384518623352,
0.22124876081943512,
-0.5865636467933655,
0.7293995022773743,
-0.03114618919789791,
0.422782838344574,
0.5031608939170837,
0.2888256907463074,
-0.3294118046760559,
-0.5445060133934021,
-0.3960675299167633,
0.23363161087036133,
-0.6606380343437195,
-0.21980862319469452,
-1.0463396310806274,
-0.032727163285017014,
-0.6740275025367737,
-0.5528005361557007,
-0.011887578293681145,
-0.330186665058136,
-0.44268131256103516,
-0.3275390565395355,
0.2085048109292984,
0.44318005442619324,
0.22960665822029114,
0.7238659262657166,
-0.49018916487693787,
0.49148091673851013,
0.4632883369922638,
-0.016535446047782898,
-0.042910341173410416,
-0.32806506752967834,
0.0614810474216938,
-0.26030492782592773,
-0.5449378490447998,
-0.6611471772193909,
0.5134591460227966,
0.3602226674556732,
0.6704444289207458,
0.2575763463973999,
0.29529017210006714,
0.7672243714332581,
-0.6435430645942688,
1.050757646560669,
0.14332403242588043,
-0.932453989982605,
0.736911416053772,
-0.1481648087501526,
0.6641775965690613,
0.5482619404792786,
0.30924084782600403,
-0.196763277053833,
-0.9684714078903198,
-1.0626055002212524,
-0.884057343006134,
0.4975106418132782,
0.47929561138153076,
0.6474806666374207,
-0.4740528166294098,
0.41513335704803467,
0.0338362380862236,
0.47236812114715576,
-0.6743768453598022,
-0.0023130758199840784,
-0.3098639249801636,
-0.5017602443695068,
-0.004861593246459961,
-0.1635698676109314,
-0.24125829339027405,
-0.2043129801750183,
0.05272896960377693,
-0.10675117373466492,
0.1897631138563156,
0.25592318177223206,
-0.09921310842037201,
-0.02893405221402645,
0.21458514034748077,
0.34819772839546204,
0.6627981066703796,
0.39326155185699463,
0.4110127091407776,
0.14574238657951355,
-0.20527134835720062,
-0.05814167112112045,
-0.0005328513798303902,
-0.16819889843463898,
0.1930125653743744,
0.38337069749832153,
0.7564243078231812,
0.6583995819091797,
-0.4751041829586029,
0.4876609742641449,
0.14351055026054382,
-0.3201501965522766,
0.12829573452472687,
0.3606853187084198,
0.1172843873500824,
0.33040106296539307,
0.06669335812330246,
-0.0861448124051094,
0.15442140400409698,
0.09089799970388412,
0.35742253065109253,
-0.032263316214084625,
-0.40839242935180664,
-0.25632938742637634,
0.8952853083610535,
0.33360356092453003,
-0.19295601546764374,
0.4082249104976654,
0.11401309818029404,
-0.23646949231624603,
0.3074604272842407,
0.6536756157875061,
1.0571264028549194,
-0.3646470606327057,
0.2914420962333679,
0.07810508459806442,
-0.10404857248067856,
0.011395808309316635,
0.48220816254615784,
-0.5748873353004456,
-0.29496893286705017,
-0.09607359021902084,
-0.6138595938682556,
-0.40873563289642334,
0.08845949918031693,
-0.7735678553581238,
0.25372472405433655,
-0.5401871204376221,
0.29835230112075806,
-0.22888034582138062,
-0.7293798327445984,
-0.17357391119003296,
0.2636620104312897,
-0.09236813336610794,
0.8418325185775757,
-0.7485876083374023,
0.7757129073143005,
0.4414912760257721,
-0.26981836557388306,
-0.8165704607963562,
0.36397838592529297,
-0.5588783621788025,
-0.560497522354126,
0.07859362661838531,
0.08762707561254501,
0.07831808924674988,
0.29033488035202026,
-0.49695727229118347,
-0.6295978426933289,
1.3326706886291504,
0.23263446986675262,
-0.29825010895729065,
-0.392221063375473,
-0.13007239997386932,
0.41324755549430847,
-0.17827683687210083,
-0.44489771127700806,
0.5678758025169373,
0.34850093722343445,
0.29935741424560547,
-0.4170266091823578,
0.1511879712343216,
0.11894288659095764,
-0.07893817871809006,
0.3357422649860382,
-0.464654803276062,
0.7840900421142578,
0.11055416613817215,
-0.11442337185144424,
-0.046759407967329025,
0.9465885758399963,
0.21679948270320892,
0.05249880254268646,
0.30111584067344666,
0.4410856366157532,
0.3323597013950348,
0.3586488366127014,
1.1487767696380615,
-0.180694118142128,
0.015162178315222263,
1.3477319478988647,
-0.1316203474998474,
0.9514253735542297,
0.9166222810745239,
0.14719198644161224,
0.2435203343629837,
0.2569236159324646,
0.38286522030830383,
1.0199863910675049,
-0.19556258618831635,
-0.32973775267601013,
-0.5114228129386902,
0.01516012940555811,
0.11460993438959122,
0.45433029532432556,
0.5665351152420044,
-1.012359857559204,
-0.5571491718292236,
0.03962711989879608,
0.18006181716918945,
0.2387794703245163,
-0.3299865126609802,
1.0243383646011353,
0.0724104717373848,
-1.0366548299789429,
0.3935021162033081,
-0.32997438311576843,
0.2586599588394165,
-0.8905311822891235,
-0.11302944272756577,
-0.36879968643188477,
0.06843224167823792,
-0.03158336505293846,
-0.790492594242096,
0.4791063070297241,
0.06115557253360748,
0.33594873547554016,
-0.6671945452690125,
0.42549818754196167,
-0.6593539118766785,
-0.18793080747127533,
0.0695871040225029,
0.30490821599960327,
0.11300459504127502,
0.0006363322609104216,
-0.6573621034622192,
-0.32695648074150085,
0.28275054693222046,
-0.5344903469085693,
0.12263645231723785,
0.5073353052139282,
-0.3312338590621948,
0.23766237497329712,
0.17123845219612122,
-0.1412486881017685,
0.25376269221305847,
-0.06734564155340195,
0.8602980375289917,
-0.7625605463981628,
-0.8505099415779114,
-0.9796158671379089,
0.3938310742378235,
-0.32388007640838623,
-0.5459492206573486,
0.8679006695747375,
0.31463882327079773,
0.30636295676231384,
-0.0041770110838115215,
0.9611596465110779,
-0.3498705327510834,
0.3719365894794464,
-0.48705971240997314,
0.6736037135124207,
-0.3161557614803314,
-0.533886730670929,
-0.20007920265197754,
-0.49921396374702454,
-0.3775501847267151,
0.459026962518692,
-0.20326335728168488,
-0.14504162967205048,
0.7232910394668579,
0.5592859387397766,
-0.21473188698291779,
-0.2818588316440582,
0.4491114616394043,
-0.25096800923347473,
0.5308739542961121,
0.14709614217281342,
0.32373324036598206,
-0.03791685774922371,
0.7358944416046143,
-0.09015050530433655,
-0.07688586413860321,
-0.21184910833835602,
-0.7999247312545776,
-0.6918042302131653,
-0.24794769287109375,
-0.16483424603939056,
-0.050066594034433365,
-0.18551509082317352,
0.7100399136543274,
0.16778649389743805,
-0.7806724309921265,
0.09613730013370514,
-0.8526828289031982,
-0.08221467584371567,
-0.3397531509399414,
-0.136875182390213,
0.5432379841804504,
-0.5447143316268921,
-0.8107300400733948,
0.3984324336051941,
0.310962051153183,
0.2542445659637451,
-0.14948128163814545,
-0.08484029769897461,
-0.3167038559913635,
0.26828110218048096,
0.23888161778450012,
0.4599732756614685,
-0.9740899801254272,
-0.26243317127227783,
-0.01318723987787962,
-0.3075352907180786,
-0.15056511759757996,
1.1144684553146362,
-0.540130615234375,
0.4398345947265625,
0.4609667956829071,
0.6016315221786499,
0.10876698791980743,
0.3198123276233673,
0.9366686344146729,
-1.1249427795410156,
0.1211518943309784,
0.5696489810943604,
0.3325536549091339,
0.2833516001701355,
-0.15626820921897888,
-0.015219165943562984,
-0.004631543066352606,
-0.3006555736064911,
-0.3397878408432007,
0.052550408989191055,
-0.7481958866119385,
-0.38456547260284424,
1.360113263130188,
-0.43273189663887024,
-0.34683844447135925,
0.010256947949528694,
-0.5291792750358582,
0.42768731713294983,
-0.3572428822517395,
0.5095019936561584,
0.6292816996574402,
-0.4266442358493805,
0.03974048048257828,
-0.15879923105239868,
0.609501838684082,
0.5946797728538513,
-0.6793481111526489,
0.4978889524936676,
0.28475090861320496,
0.02797810360789299,
-0.03265363350510597,
0.435505211353302,
-0.14511635899543762,
0.49116435647010803,
0.027015499770641327,
0.06845880299806595,
-0.07172975689172745,
-0.37683597207069397,
-0.22847968339920044,
0.3317209780216217,
-0.2622765302658081,
-0.6003481149673462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11273v1
|
Uni-MoE: Scaling Unified Multimodal LLMs with Mixture of Experts
| 2024-05-18T12:16:01 | 2024-05-18T12:16:01 |
Yunxin Li, Shenyuan Jiang, Baotian Hu, Longyue Wang, Wanqi Zhong, Wenhan Luo, Lin Ma, Min Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM
|
Recent advancements in Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) underscore
the significance of scalable models and data to boost performance, yet this
often incurs substantial computational costs. Although the Mixture of Experts
(MoE) architecture has been employed to efficiently scale large language and
image-text models, these efforts typically involve fewer experts and limited
modalities. To address this, our work presents the pioneering attempt to
develop a unified MLLM with the MoE architecture, named Uni-MoE that can handle
a wide array of modalities. Specifically, it features modality-specific
encoders with connectors for a unified multimodal representation. We also
implement a sparse MoE architecture within the LLMs to enable efficient
training and inference through modality-level data parallelism and expert-level
model parallelism. To enhance the multi-expert collaboration and
generalization, we present a progressive training strategy: 1) Cross-modality
alignment using various connectors with different cross-modality data, 2)
Training modality-specific experts with cross-modality instruction data to
activate experts' preferences, and 3) Tuning the Uni-MoE framework utilizing
Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) on mixed multimodal instruction data. We evaluate
the instruction-tuned Uni-MoE on a comprehensive set of multimodal datasets.
The extensive experimental results demonstrate Uni-MoE's principal advantage of
significantly reducing performance bias in handling mixed multimodal datasets,
alongside improved multi-expert collaboration and generalization. Our findings
highlight the substantial potential of MoE frameworks in advancing MLLMs and
the code is available at
https://github.com/HITsz-TMG/UMOE-Scaling-Unified-Multimodal-LLMs.
|
[
-0.4896346628665924,
-0.5906125903129578,
0.2530815601348877,
0.26465627551078796,
-0.14139200747013092,
0.10203802585601807,
-0.5678855776786804,
-0.1134433001279831,
0.2061728686094284,
0.3522060811519623,
-0.26968804001808167,
-0.33850282430648804,
-0.518293559551239,
-0.06276460736989975,
0.028661176562309265,
0.6453838348388672,
0.1908317357301712,
0.4632951319217682,
-0.3145228326320648,
-0.32459184527397156,
-0.6409562826156616,
-0.2086946964263916,
-0.26688888669013977,
-0.30946671962738037,
0.543103814125061,
0.5887159109115601,
0.7092052102088928,
0.6189834475517273,
0.3522973358631134,
0.3881223201751709,
0.19281956553459167,
0.5165330171585083,
-0.4221482276916504,
0.19313016533851624,
-0.21960017085075378,
-0.3616064786911011,
-0.6745787262916565,
-0.26197054982185364,
0.6073262095451355,
0.796287477016449,
-0.1515406221151352,
0.04922172799706459,
0.07844042032957077,
0.525104284286499,
-0.6172323822975159,
0.05058208480477333,
-0.6271666884422302,
-0.03782360628247261,
-0.23440098762512207,
-0.2573380768299103,
-0.496439129114151,
0.4491334855556488,
-0.039998859167099,
-0.5826571583747864,
-0.029188789427280426,
0.08690562099218369,
0.1993672400712967,
0.3006930947303772,
-0.7878530025482178,
0.11482344567775726,
-0.5885335803031921,
1.044936180114746,
-0.5444409847259521,
0.5447422862052917,
0.04465915262699127,
0.06973040848970413,
-0.27003979682922363,
-0.5070658326148987,
-0.18267814815044403,
-0.05214366689324379,
0.1408248096704483,
0.15216651558876038,
-0.003736470825970173,
0.20622597634792328,
-0.2425062507390976,
0.2760698199272156,
-0.4998151361942291,
0.4094633460044861,
-0.17491020262241364,
-0.20937609672546387,
0.6656467318534851,
0.26651424169540405,
0.23798015713691711,
0.08533783257007599,
-0.7232370972633362,
0.09422139078378677,
-0.4275263845920563,
0.04961566627025604,
0.050975579768419266,
0.06251015514135361,
-0.10187886655330658,
0.497921884059906,
-0.1569748967885971,
0.5564376711845398,
0.07960228621959686,
-0.33263349533081055,
0.10226047784090042,
-0.24858906865119934,
-0.15602153539657593,
-0.20540708303451538,
0.9966706037521362,
0.6364386677742004,
0.18474560976028442,
-0.36284926533699036,
-0.27809664607048035,
-0.05140338093042374,
0.22689127922058105,
-0.6688700318336487,
-0.30060115456581116,
-0.1246424987912178,
-0.33878397941589355,
-0.14613838493824005,
-0.1473992019891739,
-0.9683612585067749,
-0.20231160521507263,
-0.5894625782966614,
0.6920366287231445,
-0.3058541417121887,
-0.38871869444847107,
0.012791684828698635,
0.15394359827041626,
-0.18108424544334412,
0.4559831917285919,
-0.9714991450309753,
-0.05407001078128815,
0.3293176591396332,
0.43360063433647156,
-0.2377261221408844,
-0.3206091821193695,
-0.41279342770576477,
0.43832290172576904,
-0.25692105293273926,
0.7318231463432312,
-0.9583998918533325,
-0.42970138788223267,
-0.14211253821849823,
-0.27230826020240784,
-0.3242202401161194,
-0.3955690860748291,
0.3680056929588318,
-0.431989461183548,
0.3142262101173401,
0.04235785827040672,
-0.5616029500961304,
-0.24462412297725677,
0.1491493284702301,
-0.35570627450942993,
1.1018630266189575,
0.06100068241357803,
-0.6384627223014832,
0.218881756067276,
-0.8098013401031494,
-0.4085709750652313,
-0.06283342093229294,
-0.5192375183105469,
-0.09778230637311935,
0.38657546043395996,
0.6123654842376709,
0.743320882320404,
-0.3837810158729553,
0.38416746258735657,
-0.45237696170806885,
-0.26777172088623047,
0.3684629201889038,
-0.8526353240013123,
0.5147930383682251,
0.0946366935968399,
-0.18429122865200043,
0.3766769468784332,
-0.8268519043922424,
-0.007520858198404312,
-0.2027571052312851,
-0.6820699572563171,
-0.2575230002403259,
-0.18799148499965668,
0.3353753387928009,
-0.08419781923294067,
0.37426280975341797,
-0.41535964608192444,
0.3921610414981842,
0.33406275510787964,
0.29643282294273376,
1.0157017707824707,
-0.3087153434753418,
0.7069928050041199,
-0.15426179766654968,
0.23591701686382294,
0.10515876859426498,
0.2835862934589386,
-0.39747247099876404,
-0.6275591850280762,
-0.789072573184967,
-0.7594990730285645,
0.35579630732536316,
0.269562304019928,
-0.8904011249542236,
0.3514088988304138,
-0.4400700330734253,
-0.1218750849366188,
-0.707175612449646,
0.5604633092880249,
0.4444003403186798,
0.4284202456474304,
0.434848427772522,
-0.5588989853858948,
-0.30717527866363525,
-0.881643533706665,
0.01948540098965168,
0.1332976371049881,
-0.35936498641967773,
0.19185540080070496,
0.10201528668403625,
-0.5807320475578308,
0.952606737613678,
-0.06188695505261421,
-0.3802889883518219,
-0.019893545657396317,
0.5210199952125549,
-0.07201638072729111,
0.6361966133117676,
0.3001638352870941,
-0.9022291302680969,
-0.44975510239601135,
0.00378010724671185,
-0.7994066476821899,
0.010867665521800518,
-0.1017642468214035,
-0.10573706030845642,
0.0665995255112648,
0.31526267528533936,
-0.38262659311294556,
0.07209540158510208,
0.5352615118026733,
-0.16899797320365906,
0.132942795753479,
-0.44080105423927307,
0.18828636407852173,
-1.3756611347198486,
-0.21099406480789185,
0.014088055118918419,
-0.22471803426742554,
-0.557685911655426,
0.2101869285106659,
0.07898389548063278,
0.054775286465883255,
-0.30599021911621094,
0.24546897411346436,
-0.6785250902175903,
-0.02675909548997879,
-0.12893536686897278,
-0.2514316737651825,
-0.08654244244098663,
0.8525550961494446,
-0.07534431666135788,
0.6160767674446106,
0.8865683078765869,
-0.46835142374038696,
0.3984215259552002,
-0.15418539941310883,
-0.05166666954755783,
0.7852454781532288,
-0.3318493962287903,
0.27342942357063293,
0.0666036456823349,
0.04242919385433197,
-0.9252261519432068,
-0.48736488819122314,
-0.1158587634563446,
-0.2734249234199524,
0.5769472122192383,
-0.03543159365653992,
-0.5082992315292358,
-0.004199260845780373,
-0.35640260577201843,
0.4843798875808716,
0.4437137246131897,
-0.40022146701812744,
1.1869711875915527,
0.2533469498157501,
-0.03721122443675995,
-0.5340656042098999,
-0.6757867932319641,
0.13727369904518127,
-0.0704730749130249,
-0.7114765048027039,
0.18138694763183594,
-0.3558010756969452,
-0.03756057471036911,
0.07590857893228531,
-0.012852616608142853,
-0.18884159624576569,
0.033167000859975815,
0.24141423404216766,
0.17535267770290375,
-0.48893478512763977,
0.0876733809709549,
0.3114737868309021,
-0.08005870878696442,
-0.17111706733703613,
-0.04970375820994377,
0.39728713035583496,
-0.14805172383785248,
-0.5333408117294312,
-0.46217837929725647,
0.5555056929588318,
0.9315959215164185,
-0.2163551151752472,
0.44874095916748047,
1.1256598234176636,
-0.022413313388824463,
0.13993015885353088,
-0.7182832360267639,
-0.015085686929523945,
-0.4437895715236664,
0.432411253452301,
-0.3054485023021698,
-0.8763806819915771,
0.197670117020607,
-0.34966224431991577,
0.2801634967327118,
0.15630501508712769,
0.8022778034210205,
-0.22124014794826508,
1.1580746173858643,
0.7831279635429382,
-0.3525775074958801,
0.4512063264846802,
-0.12722180783748627,
-0.27220872044563293,
-1.062062382698059,
-0.3768891990184784,
0.09971374273300171,
-0.719687819480896,
-0.2522802948951721,
-0.8532913327217102,
0.6589550971984863,
0.25061464309692383,
-0.12778906524181366,
-0.13060511648654938,
-0.3667122721672058,
0.4570956826210022,
0.6530055403709412,
0.28518643975257874,
0.5261011719703674,
0.298787385225296,
-0.2609943151473999,
0.06611718982458115,
-0.8050643801689148,
-0.2907121181488037,
1.5093741416931152,
0.38579532504081726,
1.2587945461273193,
0.12275675684213638,
0.4156070947647095,
0.361174613237381,
0.4067699909210205,
-0.5102522969245911,
0.644938051700592,
-0.20367246866226196,
-0.46596378087997437,
-0.3242703378200531,
-0.4317915439605713,
-0.7209596037864685,
0.6262624859809875,
-0.3873230814933777,
-0.38018399477005005,
0.3406994938850403,
0.02488173171877861,
-0.201083704829216,
0.45641157031059265,
-0.7043207287788391,
0.6053406596183777,
-0.44183096289634705,
-0.28616762161254883,
-0.3812422454357147,
-0.7755087018013,
0.2634439170360565,
-0.08476478606462479,
0.3032662272453308,
-0.08405483514070511,
-0.45177382230758667,
0.5066723823547363,
0.09203403443098068,
1.0667771100997925,
0.09820661693811417,
-0.1482524871826172,
-0.0160590261220932,
0.043757639825344086,
0.06640657037496567,
0.214637890458107,
0.21273203194141388,
0.2845451831817627,
-0.4983573257923126,
-0.5767114758491516,
-0.5308085680007935,
0.7022097706794739,
-1.006026268005371,
-0.3261900544166565,
0.18303155899047852,
-1.1724309921264648,
-0.4454176425933838,
0.1601209193468094,
0.19442281126976013,
0.829380452632904,
-0.0017259527230635285,
0.6120957732200623,
0.8176693916320801,
0.37078508734703064,
0.5182464122772217,
0.7157886028289795,
-0.16052474081516266,
-0.6392527222633362,
0.9215525388717651,
0.031054139137268066,
0.15248963236808777,
0.6823942065238953,
0.0471305288374424,
-0.07274816185235977,
-0.43904706835746765,
-0.8928324580192566,
-0.21628564596176147,
-0.4920768141746521,
-0.21717636287212372,
-0.5537324547767639,
0.2920907437801361,
-0.37906116247177124,
-0.25065407156944275,
-0.5462669134140015,
-0.1926855444908142,
-0.5505180358886719,
0.36649343371391296,
0.26941779255867004,
0.7237422466278076,
-0.17637589573860168,
0.24587184190750122,
-0.7992873191833496,
0.2679724097251892,
0.6484941244125366,
0.28433436155319214,
-0.0501113198697567,
-0.5524470806121826,
-0.3086702823638916,
0.2571360170841217,
-0.36844801902770996,
-0.5199601650238037,
0.07287652045488358,
0.3841415345668793,
0.6652272343635559,
0.8357625007629395,
-0.05165618658065796,
0.7356980443000793,
-0.41686490178108215,
0.5651581883430481,
0.565679669380188,
-0.6349803805351257,
0.09690732508897781,
-0.45954665541648865,
0.22543823719024658,
0.4301535189151764,
0.45092180371284485,
-0.11930558830499649,
-0.32461047172546387,
-0.161559596657753,
-0.7013967037200928,
0.34701982140541077,
0.004679719917476177,
0.3291555643081665,
0.3278445303440094,
0.030207524076104164,
0.28037840127944946,
0.1969960480928421,
-0.5895972847938538,
-0.22751180827617645,
-0.1694975346326828,
-0.48900943994522095,
-0.05479007214307785,
-0.27639925479888916,
-0.4624467194080353,
-0.4793328642845154,
0.32078075408935547,
-0.3583793640136719,
0.2337808758020401,
-0.06675311923027039,
-0.389293372631073,
-0.137923464179039,
0.4977177381515503,
0.5593292117118835,
0.6768999099731445,
-0.15815529227256775,
0.12858784198760986,
0.015774061903357506,
-0.3164307475090027,
0.09901018440723419,
0.042692407965660095,
-0.022082772105932236,
-0.09549349546432495,
0.4921550452709198,
0.834721028804779,
0.8459367156028748,
-0.6943179368972778,
0.3871353566646576,
0.052873335778713226,
-0.09833234548568726,
0.1874544620513916,
0.07929530739784241,
0.14039346575737,
0.6009230613708496,
0.5724259614944458,
0.3469958007335663,
0.026614878326654434,
-0.6251625418663025,
0.13929416239261627,
0.3809308111667633,
-0.11042511463165283,
-0.39170485734939575,
0.6412367224693298,
0.5907495617866516,
-0.09125470370054245,
0.46240556240081787,
0.0971650630235672,
-0.16994862258434296,
0.14407813549041748,
0.3694593906402588,
0.6194356083869934,
-0.2942970395088196,
0.15505316853523254,
-0.2707446217536926,
0.1544003188610077,
0.04050479456782341,
0.11405618488788605,
-0.2388094961643219,
-0.753889262676239,
-0.39526405930519104,
-0.4801206886768341,
-0.37969598174095154,
-0.13923294842243195,
-0.8394423127174377,
-0.06599941849708557,
-0.25014185905456543,
-0.1468176245689392,
-0.37232550978660583,
-0.3859849274158478,
-0.6295230388641357,
-0.05638888105750084,
0.23443809151649475,
0.6213279366493225,
-0.6709771156311035,
0.837498128414154,
1.15147066116333,
-0.3502761125564575,
-0.5715271830558777,
-0.16592289507389069,
-0.028576435521245003,
-0.8917995691299438,
0.5710945725440979,
0.0874716192483902,
0.07954136282205582,
0.019669070839881897,
-0.4128558933734894,
-0.6541342735290527,
1.249577283859253,
0.5351533889770508,
-0.7619099617004395,
-0.1030796468257904,
0.20025111734867096,
0.3354845345020294,
-0.6029946804046631,
0.36686208844184875,
0.13236548006534576,
0.30768755078315735,
0.058645252138376236,
-0.9887695908546448,
-0.2493632733821869,
-0.1035655066370964,
0.21760715544223785,
0.12474290281534195,
-0.5782660841941833,
1.0552167892456055,
-0.13232427835464478,
0.1443401575088501,
0.10953906178474426,
0.9383513927459717,
-0.13026566803455353,
0.29998812079429626,
0.5335323214530945,
0.8241450786590576,
0.5688132047653198,
0.17507018148899078,
0.5746955871582031,
-0.3348958492279053,
0.3640183210372925,
0.9487035274505615,
-0.041017353534698486,
0.8445213437080383,
0.4718800187110901,
0.00843717996031046,
0.5822330713272095,
0.48932814598083496,
0.1171308383345604,
0.40780264139175415,
-0.3781420588493347,
-0.4152899384498596,
-0.7126246690750122,
-0.30273714661598206,
-0.401930570602417,
0.46668726205825806,
0.2634192109107971,
-0.34012937545776367,
-0.410269558429718,
0.36190927028656006,
-0.1158481016755104,
0.03376811370253563,
-0.6286588907241821,
0.7774713635444641,
-0.057930201292037964,
-0.1485731303691864,
0.42125415802001953,
-0.02431286871433258,
1.1506869792938232,
-0.5263952016830444,
0.11599848419427872,
-0.3613319396972656,
0.1470659375190735,
-0.001485228887759149,
-0.7392788529396057,
-0.41795602440834045,
-0.13311628997325897,
-0.3078712522983551,
-0.18844789266586304,
0.5217432975769043,
-0.8276488184928894,
-0.6922265291213989,
0.21655040979385376,
0.5410320162773132,
0.019919781014323235,
-0.023274945095181465,
-0.6663753390312195,
0.06876078248023987,
-0.13849647343158722,
-0.3455769717693329,
0.7930293679237366,
0.6002016663551331,
-0.09239599108695984,
0.7492808699607849,
0.5531837344169617,
-0.26085495948791504,
0.3393448293209076,
0.13414257764816284,
1.09717857837677,
-0.2925174832344055,
-0.022185077890753746,
-0.6738080382347107,
0.6892403960227966,
0.13804732263088226,
-0.3035591244697571,
0.6908543109893799,
0.39575615525245667,
0.7880738973617554,
-0.10653232038021088,
0.32667064666748047,
0.06812351197004318,
0.10746094584465027,
-0.6241537928581238,
0.46398529410362244,
-0.8625879883766174,
0.03095075488090515,
0.013187292963266373,
-0.7463893294334412,
-0.2010532021522522,
0.26815706491470337,
0.12954306602478027,
0.12997034192085266,
0.20352934300899506,
0.7772215008735657,
-0.24453702569007874,
-0.22583864629268646,
0.6331504583358765,
0.193293958902359,
0.0908040925860405,
0.5062453150749207,
0.5781209468841553,
-0.038233835250139236,
0.5214954018592834,
-0.3590824007987976,
-0.341332346200943,
-0.37993648648262024,
-0.6258857846260071,
-1.0872254371643066,
-0.3410359025001526,
-0.19341780245304108,
0.3876727521419525,
-0.2208435982465744,
1.098480463027954,
0.8546134829521179,
-0.4548850953578949,
-0.22110767662525177,
0.24532048404216766,
-0.08887144178152084,
-0.10048689693212509,
-0.21015101671218872,
0.11642217636108398,
-0.4084196984767914,
-0.8022311925888062,
0.629021167755127,
0.5112130641937256,
-0.18961882591247559,
-0.707818865776062,
-0.17332953214645386,
-0.11830195039510727,
0.03929063677787781,
0.7546989321708679,
-0.016634123399853706,
-0.8473289608955383,
-0.03599989786744118,
-0.11024199426174164,
-0.005236260127276182,
-0.00785570964217186,
0.8741776943206787,
-0.4815753102302551,
0.7626597285270691,
0.24745941162109375,
0.8702343106269836,
-0.06219879537820816,
-0.13896241784095764,
0.6283652782440186,
-0.8644422292709351,
0.08611056953668594,
0.0311370100826025,
0.5837599039077759,
0.31423380970954895,
-0.24876999855041504,
0.427591472864151,
0.34741103649139404,
-0.5636188387870789,
-0.7462798953056335,
0.022954152897000313,
-1.1531013250350952,
-0.3430633246898651,
1.029067039489746,
-0.08561760932207108,
0.10868975520133972,
-0.08145667612552643,
-0.302259236574173,
0.030447499826550484,
-0.6519653797149658,
0.5065314173698425,
0.40425169467926025,
-0.23432579636573792,
-0.30047354102134705,
-0.3449748754501343,
-0.2903447449207306,
0.5730910301208496,
-0.49384805560112,
-0.23077769577503204,
0.4792174994945526,
0.3511458933353424,
0.2105158418416977,
0.5040733814239502,
0.04270821064710617,
0.13347241282463074,
-0.19961674511432648,
0.3091569244861603,
-0.42107051610946655,
-0.48869431018829346,
-0.2825079560279846,
0.1453293263912201,
-0.13226638734340668,
-0.37447407841682434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11265v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11265v1
|
EnviroExam: Benchmarking Environmental Science Knowledge of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-18T11:31:03 | 2024-05-18T11:31:03 |
Yu Huang, Liang Guo, Wanqian Guo, Zhe Tao, Yang Lv, Zhihao Sun, Dongfang Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the field of environmental science, it is crucial to have robust
evaluation metrics for large language models to ensure their efficacy and
accuracy. We propose EnviroExam, a comprehensive evaluation method designed to
assess the knowledge of large language models in the field of environmental
science. EnviroExam is based on the curricula of top international
universities, covering undergraduate, master's, and doctoral courses, and
includes 936 questions across 42 core courses. By conducting 0-shot and 5-shot
tests on 31 open-source large language models, EnviroExam reveals the
performance differences among these models in the domain of environmental
science and provides detailed evaluation standards. The results show that 61.3%
of the models passed the 5-shot tests, while 48.39% passed the 0-shot tests. By
introducing the coefficient of variation as an indicator, we evaluate the
performance of mainstream open-source large language models in environmental
science from multiple perspectives, providing effective criteria for selecting
and fine-tuning language models in this field. Future research will involve
constructing more domain-specific test sets using specialized environmental
science textbooks to further enhance the accuracy and specificity of the
evaluation.
|
[
-0.42755183577537537,
-0.8194360733032227,
0.8020975589752197,
0.2232789695262909,
0.14763027429580688,
0.1392529159784317,
-0.40236520767211914,
-0.5890172123908997,
-0.231634721159935,
0.5483822226524353,
-0.08902696520090103,
-0.8959915041923523,
-0.5876168012619019,
0.33840692043304443,
-0.30183616280555725,
0.46592432260513306,
-0.13693654537200928,
0.03644318878650665,
-0.645622193813324,
-0.4021705389022827,
-0.25426793098449707,
-0.06367223709821701,
-0.28638002276420593,
-0.3491199314594269,
0.39667272567749023,
0.2655220329761505,
0.5596123337745667,
0.4197729825973511,
0.48144960403442383,
0.29451918601989746,
-0.7023147344589233,
-0.19611310958862305,
-0.28410273790359497,
0.16655036807060242,
-0.5818113684654236,
-0.2953157424926758,
-0.04109373316168785,
0.031287334859371185,
0.9404184222221375,
0.6178096532821655,
-0.1766192615032196,
0.38739335536956787,
0.03506077826023102,
0.2892896234989166,
-1.1640281677246094,
-0.028823062777519226,
-0.441699355840683,
-0.04113413766026497,
0.2606048583984375,
0.07707778364419937,
-0.19160310924053192,
-0.24352245032787323,
0.09501037001609802,
-0.30610477924346924,
-0.19054295122623444,
0.09628421813249588,
0.44460564851760864,
0.05335300788283348,
-0.5796952843666077,
-0.002803167561069131,
-0.7171791791915894,
1.0987653732299805,
-0.8512548804283142,
0.6084897518157959,
0.047665197402238846,
0.2620903253555298,
0.0326746366918087,
-0.4187224507331848,
-0.628771185874939,
-0.660102128982544,
0.23269438743591309,
0.5316279530525208,
-0.1907646656036377,
-0.12547160685062408,
0.23589740693569183,
0.3299062252044678,
-0.5558106899261475,
0.19091354310512543,
-0.26135337352752686,
-0.13772812485694885,
0.4883892238140106,
0.16187217831611633,
0.2827415466308594,
0.04981078580021858,
-0.6076164245605469,
-0.26417118310928345,
-0.6180563569068909,
0.06882268935441971,
0.4406631588935852,
0.2534243166446686,
0.1397651582956314,
0.48335540294647217,
-0.40497514605522156,
0.5929543375968933,
-0.55058354139328,
-0.04787181317806244,
0.09648824483156204,
-0.44636526703834534,
-0.3121583163738251,
-0.04202382266521454,
0.48701566457748413,
0.15792204439640045,
-0.2957823872566223,
0.03574654459953308,
-0.35081490874290466,
0.21538551151752472,
0.050073325634002686,
-0.8852460384368896,
0.07464668899774551,
0.32607385516166687,
-0.1724768429994583,
-0.15602603554725647,
-0.08395165950059891,
-1.1077874898910522,
-0.21914568543434143,
-0.6200955510139465,
0.6421133279800415,
-0.2564435601234436,
-0.3971918523311615,
0.20773981511592865,
-0.40002045035362244,
0.09692131727933884,
0.28795066475868225,
-0.02345860004425049,
0.556694746017456,
0.7761212587356567,
0.823046863079071,
-0.4212248921394348,
-0.5052177906036377,
-0.3830411434173584,
-0.0940394327044487,
-0.2405930757522583,
0.993367612361908,
-1.1997363567352295,
-0.4220106601715088,
0.03548173978924751,
-0.11358670890331268,
0.10836834460496902,
-0.7847890257835388,
0.2725203037261963,
-0.46705514192581177,
0.08458761125802994,
0.018209464848041534,
-0.767691433429718,
-0.29485470056533813,
0.468403697013855,
-0.4225860834121704,
1.2592294216156006,
0.18315190076828003,
-0.5826885104179382,
0.2550429701805115,
-0.6617758870124817,
0.06206914409995079,
0.1915295571088791,
0.2532793879508972,
-0.32938826084136963,
-0.13199035823345184,
-0.06625214219093323,
-0.1098652258515358,
-0.47532257437705994,
-0.06289628893136978,
-0.6362729072570801,
-0.1416628211736679,
0.08884022384881973,
-0.030870912596583366,
0.7854915857315063,
0.3117888271808624,
-0.2620246410369873,
0.23746910691261292,
-0.8125450611114502,
0.3342297077178955,
-0.3545242249965668,
-0.4556712806224823,
-0.6019590497016907,
-0.15135158598423004,
0.40362730622291565,
0.1426917016506195,
0.21082697808742523,
-0.8046742677688599,
-0.28468507528305054,
-0.11279318481683731,
0.17589768767356873,
0.5501355528831482,
0.1329333633184433,
0.17862018942832947,
-0.19911208748817444,
0.7078366279602051,
-0.11778997629880905,
0.14525771141052246,
-0.4142856001853943,
-0.3733777701854706,
-0.48768529295921326,
-0.19143860042095184,
0.23780104517936707,
0.5169663429260254,
-0.20394448935985565,
0.5000407099723816,
-0.10503527522087097,
-1.1259453296661377,
-0.05226382613182068,
0.18358345329761505,
0.4733169674873352,
0.19414079189300537,
0.4486893117427826,
-0.5281049013137817,
-0.2468411922454834,
-0.6710333824157715,
-0.6922749876976013,
-0.028639430180191994,
0.012285376898944378,
0.39569559693336487,
1.0838743448257446,
-0.5670250058174133,
0.9405556321144104,
-0.5691613554954529,
0.2112838625907898,
0.22543109953403473,
0.13048523664474487,
-0.01210774015635252,
0.29138869047164917,
0.5808741450309753,
-0.4465453624725342,
-0.47115612030029297,
0.24324250221252441,
-0.3970114290714264,
-0.2366192489862442,
0.6219926476478577,
-0.2693151831626892,
-0.18454620242118835,
0.41840916872024536,
-0.40117907524108887,
0.16162754595279694,
0.4641435146331787,
-0.5785902738571167,
0.7110227346420288,
-0.2666819393634796,
0.34084075689315796,
-0.5530316829681396,
0.3605143129825592,
0.32982388138771057,
-0.27276769280433655,
-0.20220348238945007,
0.619533121585846,
0.07811522483825684,
-0.3057810068130493,
-0.6066830158233643,
0.8442569971084595,
-0.3786903917789459,
0.16896727681159973,
-0.2555333375930786,
0.1392698436975479,
0.049352385103702545,
0.01699496991932392,
0.121379055082798,
0.2938905358314514,
0.7669299840927124,
-0.7409032583236694,
0.5492354035377502,
0.1109737977385521,
-0.4937171936035156,
0.6757780909538269,
-0.5722952485084534,
0.2988094687461853,
-0.1637994945049286,
0.24571001529693604,
-0.584187924861908,
0.059851642698049545,
-0.4412008225917816,
0.06604260206222534,
-0.010125907137989998,
0.11829070746898651,
-0.36856502294540405,
-0.3203412890434265,
-0.18011242151260376,
0.20420968532562256,
0.5009480118751526,
-0.42985689640045166,
0.5643976330757141,
0.483557790517807,
-0.22811374068260193,
-0.23679521679878235,
0.0591726079583168,
-0.08716922998428345,
-0.378130704164505,
-0.3856678605079651,
-0.006655476987361908,
-0.2657027542591095,
-0.588293731212616,
0.03154616430401802,
-0.43761053681373596,
-0.20164203643798828,
0.12331003695726395,
0.1458326131105423,
-0.10281205177307129,
-0.31944742798805237,
0.09320783615112305,
-0.3365311026573181,
0.17183572053909302,
0.27933111786842346,
-0.4418494403362274,
0.16396735608577728,
-0.14353838562965393,
-0.1868956983089447,
0.3006252646446228,
0.3938359022140503,
0.7397791743278503,
-0.3574289381504059,
0.4964848458766937,
0.2642112970352173,
-0.6452860832214355,
-0.33352547883987427,
-0.27356788516044617,
-0.035648517310619354,
-0.3596859276294708,
0.6463958024978638,
0.007142688147723675,
-0.8954984545707703,
0.375653475522995,
-0.47675803303718567,
-0.06127985939383507,
0.6077460646629333,
0.5466089844703674,
0.2869901657104492,
0.7424501180648804,
0.8621438145637512,
0.028330013155937195,
0.3965558707714081,
0.024947045370936394,
0.09187255054712296,
-0.7087650895118713,
-0.3455609977245331,
-0.8970040678977966,
0.06930454075336456,
-0.4168476462364197,
-0.5181732773780823,
0.3335728049278259,
-0.08853483200073242,
-0.8851345181465149,
0.39257460832595825,
-0.2230001986026764,
0.5826870203018188,
0.4285603165626526,
0.15097014605998993,
0.3773188292980194,
-0.025032084435224533,
-0.23572967946529388,
0.1404181271791458,
-0.29889824986457825,
-0.7826756834983826,
0.9130135178565979,
0.4124884307384491,
0.7882828116416931,
0.21829339861869812,
0.39140260219573975,
0.25855034589767456,
0.46296578645706177,
-0.7026448249816895,
0.4842350482940674,
0.28303202986717224,
-0.5827953815460205,
-0.5721095204353333,
-0.5915848016738892,
-0.8515055775642395,
0.3227899372577667,
-0.02434030920267105,
-0.6468557715415955,
0.029209475964307785,
-0.016058458015322685,
-0.2919837236404419,
0.09441793709993362,
-0.40496134757995605,
0.8435550332069397,
-0.25581735372543335,
-0.5498984456062317,
-0.5137001872062683,
-0.2229345738887787,
0.22796978056430817,
-0.3767947554588318,
0.42908143997192383,
-0.36771681904792786,
-0.22738690674304962,
0.5713254809379578,
-0.2920575737953186,
0.4710017144680023,
-0.08619599044322968,
-0.45026203989982605,
0.5197967290878296,
0.1654224395751953,
0.2796209752559662,
0.2085408866405487,
-0.21692058444023132,
0.3485479950904846,
0.1987890899181366,
-0.322711318731308,
-0.3400805592536926,
0.9091795682907104,
-0.7325667142868042,
-0.47968780994415283,
-0.6086609363555908,
-0.3091289699077606,
-0.3794260025024414,
0.32260605692863464,
0.052640657871961594,
0.1583588719367981,
-0.6086363792419434,
0.14032481610774994,
0.6603206992149353,
-0.7600280046463013,
0.11760285496711731,
0.9383120536804199,
-0.47722673416137695,
-0.3523685932159424,
0.810560941696167,
0.06798800081014633,
0.3653912842273712,
0.475861519575119,
0.5101733803749084,
-0.3034229576587677,
-0.19974328577518463,
0.030406242236495018,
-0.08672455698251724,
-0.8988791704177856,
-0.36878570914268494,
-0.8865713477134705,
-0.1560724824666977,
-0.38028067350387573,
0.27631181478500366,
-0.4123198390007019,
0.13420066237449646,
0.3693600594997406,
-0.08102767914533615,
0.39574089646339417,
0.8051681518554688,
0.109367735683918,
-0.09052243828773499,
-0.7862503528594971,
0.02619960345327854,
0.34276795387268066,
0.5852108001708984,
-0.19477805495262146,
-0.5444614887237549,
-0.28586095571517944,
0.05515908822417259,
-0.5811201930046082,
-0.8131876587867737,
0.47054025530815125,
0.3932911455631256,
0.7182088494300842,
0.2684990465641022,
-0.18308506906032562,
0.27254414558410645,
-0.5343520641326904,
0.7995816469192505,
0.0599190890789032,
-1.2499606609344482,
0.7731496691703796,
-0.23054656386375427,
0.4393990635871887,
0.24929040670394897,
0.3821733593940735,
-0.5075101256370544,
-0.6221635341644287,
-0.5678136348724365,
-0.9246078133583069,
0.21932625770568848,
0.14652268588542938,
0.10973332077264786,
0.03653983771800995,
-0.08116377890110016,
0.2565864026546478,
0.02923535369336605,
-0.44374653697013855,
0.02055041864514351,
-0.012762842699885368,
0.09714987874031067,
-0.18953607976436615,
-0.07101700454950333,
-0.23125629127025604,
-0.3956686556339264,
0.7816997170448303,
-0.10527703166007996,
0.02278965711593628,
0.10369987040758133,
-0.152439683675766,
-0.026531388983130455,
0.5293435454368591,
0.5956472158432007,
0.9052683711051941,
-0.19316527247428894,
0.544739305973053,
0.518502950668335,
-0.6136302351951599,
0.3039323687553406,
-0.20958811044692993,
-0.037519898265600204,
0.1180102750658989,
0.2474716156721115,
0.5029851198196411,
0.32415279746055603,
-1.0347659587860107,
0.2929319739341736,
0.2517438232898712,
0.02827809564769268,
-0.1994657814502716,
0.25858649611473083,
0.08852855116128922,
-0.005467411130666733,
0.1465202420949936,
0.09371864795684814,
0.4368589222431183,
-0.7942851781845093,
0.10097386687994003,
0.23527948558330536,
-0.5447161793708801,
-0.2708252966403961,
0.5662885904312134,
0.07536547631025314,
0.0004416468145791441,
0.37548911571502686,
0.14258423447608948,
-0.5297845005989075,
1.1581783294677734,
0.53843754529953,
0.7286545038223267,
-0.3992708623409271,
0.029876139014959335,
0.812582790851593,
0.370950311422348,
-0.26792800426483154,
0.35069310665130615,
0.1999693661928177,
-0.5971687436103821,
-0.16120818257331848,
-0.9703710675239563,
-0.7880797386169434,
0.17231881618499756,
-0.5214840173721313,
0.40784430503845215,
-0.24024879932403564,
-0.03456936031579971,
0.06004337593913078,
-0.1276606023311615,
-0.896534264087677,
0.33436742424964905,
0.11720938235521317,
1.3056696653366089,
-0.9906589388847351,
0.1490396410226822,
1.1130434274673462,
-0.0654507651925087,
-0.3768717646598816,
0.0157550647854805,
-0.06744468957185745,
-0.29374709725379944,
0.513549268245697,
0.2823934257030487,
-0.16257821023464203,
0.0008055524667724967,
-0.8955610394477844,
-1.0937944650650024,
0.845655083656311,
0.38854503631591797,
-0.6800588965415955,
0.9068849682807922,
-0.06638835370540619,
0.5415562987327576,
-0.3609656095504761,
0.8084997534751892,
0.6015393137931824,
0.9031673669815063,
-0.37250903248786926,
-0.9213722348213196,
0.04359755665063858,
-0.4689808487892151,
0.36322134733200073,
0.02661391720175743,
-0.7234882712364197,
0.5711464881896973,
-0.022066408768296242,
-0.2944689393043518,
-0.24812228977680206,
0.49496152997016907,
0.33929353952407837,
0.3986506164073944,
0.45080482959747314,
0.5600517392158508,
0.7256327867507935,
-0.06946808844804764,
1.1154955625534058,
-0.4214448034763336,
0.6716892123222351,
0.8790085911750793,
-0.6807410717010498,
1.085898995399475,
0.27208688855171204,
-0.48990029096603394,
0.5035886168479919,
0.737791895866394,
-0.05976410210132599,
0.4682671129703522,
0.4381955862045288,
-0.5416695475578308,
-0.4100913107395172,
-0.36556974053382874,
-0.34172672033309937,
0.4752237796783447,
0.31170928478240967,
-0.034376949071884155,
-0.3182532489299774,
0.11061457544565201,
-0.1836521327495575,
0.24833166599273682,
-0.43716514110565186,
0.6715825796127319,
0.2081938236951828,
-0.8387827277183533,
0.15914125740528107,
0.17547614872455597,
0.5222663879394531,
-0.4728674590587616,
-0.12999357283115387,
-0.19814994931221008,
0.2404499053955078,
-0.11886104941368103,
-0.8237980008125305,
0.2502170205116272,
0.12234882265329361,
0.05130236595869064,
0.07877473533153534,
0.5455228686332703,
-0.554180920124054,
-0.5740809440612793,
0.47963500022888184,
0.4196246862411499,
0.17421485483646393,
-0.27741187810897827,
-0.27430951595306396,
-0.10485826432704926,
-0.4289248287677765,
-0.18310941755771637,
0.07411666959524155,
0.33358198404312134,
-0.05717131868004799,
0.47666415572166443,
0.5400654077529907,
-0.0043320669792592525,
-0.03568287566304207,
0.0630623921751976,
0.5168325901031494,
-0.6653519868850708,
-0.3487119972705841,
-0.8808757662773132,
0.30449342727661133,
-0.19939865171909332,
-0.4280501902103424,
0.9154356718063354,
1.0077606439590454,
0.791832685470581,
-0.22500379383563995,
1.0491002798080444,
0.12869508564472198,
0.2348984032869339,
-0.3083014190196991,
0.4940110146999359,
-0.19743454456329346,
0.16601958870887756,
-0.17859943211078644,
-1.4148032665252686,
-0.05978676676750183,
0.4052673280239105,
-0.06223374977707863,
0.34334442019462585,
0.9034029245376587,
0.6316277384757996,
-0.030631935223937035,
-0.08983220160007477,
0.445563405752182,
0.2671832740306854,
0.1832515150308609,
0.45208150148391724,
1.0756378173828125,
-0.020862799137830734,
0.13863903284072876,
-0.12818311154842377,
-0.3167158365249634,
0.06222398579120636,
-1.0851272344589233,
-0.6435919404029846,
-0.11691129207611084,
-0.8137484192848206,
-0.3921945095062256,
-0.050541866570711136,
0.7183299660682678,
0.456636905670166,
-0.7808544635772705,
-0.2811260521411896,
-0.1437777876853943,
0.12785860896110535,
-0.6215795278549194,
-0.254997581243515,
0.132443368434906,
-0.17841003835201263,
-0.8448662757873535,
0.3583117425441742,
0.5799214243888855,
-0.10409685224294662,
-0.5857999324798584,
-0.1286533921957016,
0.14652618765830994,
0.5653330683708191,
0.6226425170898438,
0.10243012756109238,
-0.4836791455745697,
-0.45318132638931274,
0.13693423569202423,
-0.20491211116313934,
-0.06915248185396194,
0.6296557784080505,
-0.6958941221237183,
0.551249623298645,
0.5746177434921265,
0.31436631083488464,
0.3805793523788452,
-0.3927578628063202,
0.5104403495788574,
-0.481609970331192,
-0.12173597514629364,
0.26774612069129944,
0.47377070784568787,
0.4246461093425751,
-0.2336129993200302,
0.5717793107032776,
0.10479072481393814,
-0.6008964776992798,
-0.8239288330078125,
0.030405480414628983,
-0.7578635811805725,
-0.3438376784324646,
1.5130282640457153,
-0.29331380128860474,
-0.2559780478477478,
-0.024052666500210762,
-0.10824844986200333,
-0.08978625386953354,
-0.12169583141803741,
0.745442271232605,
0.9268736839294434,
0.24082206189632416,
-0.14368736743927002,
-0.5795053243637085,
0.0950019508600235,
0.2606218457221985,
-1.1705427169799805,
-0.043394993990659714,
0.3623693883419037,
0.7491897344589233,
0.35167568922042847,
0.07284392416477203,
-0.093431256711483,
0.18228204548358917,
0.08076176047325134,
0.38879331946372986,
0.2534588873386383,
-0.11763793975114822,
-0.31764745712280273,
0.11333271861076355,
-0.0009810024639591575,
0.3363613486289978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11264v1
|
Cross-Language Assessment of Mathematical Capability of ChatGPT
| 2024-05-18T11:29:19 | 2024-05-18T11:29:19 |
Gargi Sathe, Aneesh Shamraj, Aditya Surve, Nahush Patil, Kumkum Saxena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper presents an evaluation of the mathematical capability of ChatGPT
across diverse languages like Hindi, Gujarati, and Marathi. ChatGPT, based on
GPT-3.5 by OpenAI, has garnered significant attention for its natural language
understanding and generation abilities. However, its performance in solving
mathematical problems across multiple natural languages remains a comparatively
unexplored area, especially in regional Indian languages. In this paper, we
explore those capabilities as well as using chain-of-thought prompting to
figure out if it increases the accuracy of responses as much as it does in the
English language and provide insights into the current limitations.
|
[
-0.6602296829223633,
-1.0457684993743896,
0.2527283728122711,
0.7305704355239868,
-0.2605641782283783,
0.2930920422077179,
-0.34889736771583557,
-0.5544491410255432,
0.05986928567290306,
-0.11672962456941605,
-0.46354538202285767,
0.020325709134340286,
-0.643546998500824,
0.06352630257606506,
0.03177870437502861,
0.9835132360458374,
-0.3572600185871124,
0.2516297698020935,
-0.045200299471616745,
-0.1531442254781723,
-0.7891518473625183,
-0.4207744598388672,
-0.8600597381591797,
-0.23880331218242645,
0.037388186901807785,
0.24001449346542358,
0.7571212649345398,
-0.4006970226764679,
0.8593704104423523,
0.27421873807907104,
0.27066367864608765,
-0.0220975112169981,
-0.26440760493278503,
-0.06578347086906433,
-0.1447088122367859,
-0.41801223158836365,
-0.3330182433128357,
-0.2373879998922348,
0.8340481519699097,
0.38760995864868164,
-0.34756946563720703,
0.14846578240394592,
0.0843711718916893,
0.7623674273490906,
-0.6658124327659607,
0.5939115881919861,
-0.5459059476852417,
0.058466650545597076,
-0.3478291928768158,
0.05523661896586418,
-0.1294843703508377,
-0.7505531311035156,
0.34318992495536804,
-0.4143727123737335,
0.047533463686704636,
-0.2322208434343338,
0.647631824016571,
0.078165702521801,
-0.11651608347892761,
-0.6303448677062988,
-0.907279908657074,
0.7582941651344299,
-0.41531437635421753,
0.41559037566185,
0.4594353437423706,
0.8489498496055603,
0.19432830810546875,
-0.420989990234375,
-0.5448484420776367,
-0.12461020052433014,
0.002024088753387332,
0.5987684726715088,
-0.3376021981239319,
-0.36822837591171265,
0.3295814096927643,
0.7194775342941284,
-0.7031341195106506,
-0.3434094786643982,
-0.6191460490226746,
-0.08903741836547852,
0.5993800759315491,
0.0885910913348198,
0.7486856579780579,
-0.16478651762008667,
-0.004003582056611776,
-0.1803060621023178,
-0.4857121706008911,
0.09775800257921219,
0.32461532950401306,
0.3302640914916992,
-0.26138538122177124,
0.8043146133422852,
-0.0593317486345768,
0.7385519742965698,
-0.4463026821613312,
0.1402135044336319,
0.04705371335148811,
-0.470572829246521,
-0.35836130380630493,
0.02088049240410328,
0.8670758605003357,
-0.07005482912063599,
0.5409756898880005,
0.23144012689590454,
0.135674387216568,
0.24025240540504456,
0.007915176451206207,
-0.5306143760681152,
-0.04725104197859764,
-0.09439213573932648,
0.02069183625280857,
-0.006988487672060728,
-0.0005471552140079439,
-1.0229567289352417,
-0.12004348635673523,
0.10081581771373749,
0.3721775412559509,
-0.7287262082099915,
-0.3753538131713867,
0.15145868062973022,
0.03299091011285782,
0.7512107491493225,
0.19254617393016815,
-1.0947129726409912,
0.4329613447189331,
0.7481249570846558,
0.9580220580101013,
0.1716713309288025,
-0.1968374252319336,
-0.2414732724428177,
-0.23012065887451172,
-0.17116636037826538,
0.8820905089378357,
-0.8361172080039978,
-0.5240121483802795,
-0.19445540010929108,
-0.5683647394180298,
-0.44356054067611694,
-0.13746538758277893,
0.4945036470890045,
-0.3524867594242096,
0.5359305143356323,
-0.28443336486816406,
-0.19580087065696716,
-0.4068799912929535,
0.39223363995552063,
-0.5823774933815002,
1.0627034902572632,
0.33808213472366333,
-0.8920137286186218,
0.3843134045600891,
-0.9778242707252502,
-0.3185899257659912,
0.2882913053035736,
-0.3834403157234192,
-0.4215313792228699,
0.05781847611069679,
0.797883152961731,
-0.020232757553458214,
-0.5494772791862488,
0.06607042998075485,
-0.04952385276556015,
-0.18261398375034332,
0.30493488907814026,
-0.742296040058136,
0.811316192150116,
0.32623547315597534,
-0.29704755544662476,
-0.0507378950715065,
-0.6527910828590393,
0.524096667766571,
0.1771785467863083,
0.06986749917268753,
-0.2714174687862396,
-0.10931006819009781,
-0.207366481423378,
0.20038598775863647,
0.1274041086435318,
-0.6983364224433899,
0.15145570039749146,
-0.49911239743232727,
0.36835435032844543,
0.5475272536277771,
0.18079940974712372,
0.01629733480513096,
-0.19588758051395416,
0.9903272390365601,
-0.3006478250026703,
0.04284047707915306,
0.1237129345536232,
-1.1836001873016357,
-0.597389817237854,
-0.14635394513607025,
0.4312581419944763,
1.0000206232070923,
-0.8504579663276672,
-0.03597692772746086,
-0.2643033266067505,
-0.6759214997291565,
-0.5916680097579956,
0.009853670373558998,
0.6006877422332764,
0.1908145248889923,
0.12934552133083344,
-0.379393994808197,
-0.43221089243888855,
-0.8194114565849304,
-0.45072615146636963,
-0.1806512475013733,
-0.032674383372068405,
0.3291984498500824,
0.4035572111606598,
0.07367196679115295,
0.822370707988739,
-0.4812116026878357,
-0.10738906264305115,
-0.2778760492801666,
0.21025051176548004,
0.189923956990242,
0.2517017424106598,
0.3580777645111084,
-0.6808702945709229,
-0.9790371656417847,
0.49031347036361694,
-0.6787654757499695,
-0.21707436442375183,
0.06384149193763733,
-0.13737016916275024,
0.04888610169291496,
-0.12272811681032181,
-0.4823082685470581,
0.7446431517601013,
0.836711049079895,
-0.16442915797233582,
0.38057708740234375,
-0.15395702421665192,
0.39028623700141907,
-1.2038558721542358,
0.06167685613036156,
0.07084321230649948,
0.03287884593009949,
-0.4597495198249817,
0.10585924983024597,
0.012950705364346504,
-0.5858269333839417,
-0.4175626039505005,
0.5069640874862671,
-0.36802586913108826,
-0.231918066740036,
0.1357821673154831,
0.4409950077533722,
-0.6678712368011475,
0.5012403726577759,
0.03020356595516205,
1.202931523323059,
0.7329754829406738,
-0.3916790783405304,
0.39798587560653687,
0.23466025292873383,
-0.3450756072998047,
0.6715720891952515,
-0.7842846512794495,
0.19235564768314362,
0.09077315032482147,
-0.13604241609573364,
-1.0578694343566895,
-0.09185075759887695,
0.41686972975730896,
-0.729597806930542,
-0.14977087080478668,
-0.08285307139158249,
-0.23908096551895142,
-0.38512471318244934,
-0.08670186996459961,
0.5626546740531921,
0.6340013742446899,
-0.19668897986412048,
0.6253058314323425,
0.19105792045593262,
-0.361904114484787,
-0.42109185457229614,
-0.6990891695022583,
-0.21388721466064453,
-0.06787820160388947,
-0.885567307472229,
-0.2807525098323822,
-0.0006147837266325951,
-0.4551909267902374,
-0.202104389667511,
-0.033147115260362625,
-0.1353512704372406,
-0.38925808668136597,
0.06932804733514786,
0.14888203144073486,
-0.12452904880046844,
-0.041095711290836334,
-0.17493943870067596,
-0.20351217687129974,
0.08316406607627869,
-0.25459399819374084,
0.7692777514457703,
-0.6366294026374817,
-0.7781863808631897,
-0.0008082389831542969,
0.238982692360878,
0.24475273489952087,
-0.5413109064102173,
0.3561275601387024,
0.6269626617431641,
-0.41106265783309937,
0.13526731729507446,
-0.18735171854496002,
0.2914942502975464,
-0.4717106521129608,
0.2134777456521988,
-0.7675015926361084,
-0.7658393979072571,
0.8262637257575989,
0.2427728772163391,
-0.06930956244468689,
0.6520876288414001,
0.9229477047920227,
0.5733720660209656,
1.0113753080368042,
0.28855422139167786,
0.007913661189377308,
0.23201657831668854,
0.010637341067194939,
0.7481127381324768,
-0.6859481930732727,
-0.19513702392578125,
-0.6622055172920227,
0.1293627768754959,
-1.0062071084976196,
-0.34064218401908875,
0.4453727900981903,
-0.0824943259358406,
0.02077116258442402,
0.24070824682712555,
-0.49437451362609863,
0.6934637427330017,
0.35281887650489807,
0.1204787865281105,
0.30229881405830383,
0.04849987104535103,
-0.2868008315563202,
-0.26175180077552795,
-0.5793920159339905,
-0.23679886758327484,
0.9218932390213013,
0.2468554824590683,
0.7388997673988342,
0.4439655840396881,
0.3978402316570282,
0.09610223770141602,
0.2961881160736084,
-0.7921453714370728,
0.36307844519615173,
0.00033977627754211426,
-0.6658596396446228,
-0.42906659841537476,
-0.6274606585502625,
-0.8869336247444153,
0.227815642952919,
0.2000897228717804,
-0.9258471131324768,
-0.3339616656303406,
-0.2146880328655243,
-0.28783226013183594,
0.3092000484466553,
-1.0735269784927368,
0.5877248644828796,
-0.3021325469017029,
-0.09278050065040588,
-0.18875865638256073,
-0.08676648139953613,
0.5226538777351379,
-0.30400553345680237,
0.14703044295310974,
0.07266723364591599,
0.15557685494422913,
0.7388191223144531,
-0.5317394137382507,
0.558793842792511,
0.021250711753964424,
-0.3290284276008606,
0.6258288025856018,
0.27660447359085083,
0.13004925847053528,
0.3892795443534851,
0.03819694370031357,
0.1440303474664688,
0.008070630021393299,
-0.7695527076721191,
-0.9318779706954956,
0.6327815651893616,
-0.7601585984230042,
-0.5493043661117554,
-0.5869213938713074,
-0.4451231062412262,
-0.6661629676818848,
0.2368236780166626,
0.13288915157318115,
0.365721732378006,
-0.1800851821899414,
-0.19850265979766846,
0.22131513059139252,
-0.2944228947162628,
0.5626145005226135,
0.25767263770103455,
-0.4900987446308136,
-0.5670371055603027,
1.0959303379058838,
0.05759503319859505,
0.36482417583465576,
0.22853867709636688,
0.4107268154621124,
-0.40083247423171997,
-0.19249263405799866,
-0.6645258069038391,
0.11544854938983917,
-0.695178747177124,
0.15655043721199036,
-0.26897498965263367,
-0.4057222604751587,
-0.3386792540550232,
-0.1336507797241211,
-0.26294657588005066,
-0.4722413420677185,
0.6197082996368408,
0.19241666793823242,
0.45432958006858826,
1.0440822839736938,
0.07450377196073532,
0.25765493512153625,
-0.8159724473953247,
-0.07702864706516266,
0.5891880393028259,
0.769790768623352,
0.02832845225930214,
-0.05914074555039406,
-0.05952538549900055,
0.2900128662586212,
-0.38637208938598633,
-0.7076053619384766,
0.3057292699813843,
0.04948417469859123,
0.5988993644714355,
0.05563506856560707,
-0.30790483951568604,
0.8090510964393616,
-0.20472149550914764,
0.9909811615943909,
0.2409202754497528,
-1.2856299877166748,
0.7202163934707642,
-0.4981239438056946,
0.5726100206375122,
0.2892589271068573,
0.5731667280197144,
-0.5417165756225586,
-0.3204053044319153,
-0.5500526428222656,
-0.3867936432361603,
0.4031393826007843,
0.7869871854782104,
-0.021924255415797234,
0.044237736612558365,
0.0353347584605217,
-0.046520788222551346,
-0.10959387570619583,
-0.5444363355636597,
0.11758443713188171,
-0.11425849050283432,
-0.030537238344550133,
0.04532083496451378,
0.07703035324811935,
0.136814147233963,
-0.31119129061698914,
0.4434508681297302,
-0.06779391318559647,
0.6291186809539795,
0.28090545535087585,
0.12587419152259827,
-0.08738923072814941,
0.49689945578575134,
0.858913242816925,
1.181320071220398,
-0.06834691017866135,
-0.2369571328163147,
0.5579007863998413,
-1.0697693824768066,
-0.08138496428728104,
0.10623107850551605,
0.1281030774116516,
-0.24494963884353638,
0.3588297963142395,
0.7217353582382202,
-0.08100161701440811,
-0.5119568705558777,
0.1662987619638443,
-0.5138339996337891,
-0.06307925283908844,
-0.2559792995452881,
0.026514828205108643,
-0.2970126271247864,
-0.06820350885391235,
0.25989800691604614,
0.07635068893432617,
-0.11480015516281128,
-0.5307197570800781,
0.09254971146583557,
0.4254979193210602,
-0.5536962151527405,
-0.25699758529663086,
0.3833020329475403,
0.14337344467639923,
-0.5608779191970825,
0.7787063121795654,
-0.18305009603500366,
-0.9689954519271851,
0.48654958605766296,
0.702278196811676,
1.061590313911438,
-0.26112261414527893,
0.10289235413074493,
0.3682304918766022,
0.41919267177581787,
0.2677648961544037,
0.6590623259544373,
-0.12507066130638123,
-0.5380899310112,
-0.7521036267280579,
-0.4158637821674347,
-0.7191680669784546,
-0.15691280364990234,
-0.5343941450119019,
0.27725520730018616,
-0.4688720703125,
-0.06601974368095398,
-0.003270916873589158,
0.21990907192230225,
-0.5690054297447205,
0.18334414064884186,
-0.06235366314649582,
0.6586858034133911,
-0.620339572429657,
0.7410056591033936,
0.7068031430244446,
-0.5901512503623962,
-0.961412250995636,
0.06422194093465805,
-0.18737512826919556,
-1.1578181982040405,
0.6073658466339111,
-0.1097215861082077,
-0.31571707129478455,
-0.02689172886312008,
-0.25345364212989807,
-0.7652646899223328,
0.6968110203742981,
0.0429808646440506,
-0.23589184880256653,
0.29120615124702454,
0.5551040172576904,
0.7647639513015747,
-0.08855698257684708,
0.8913172483444214,
0.40843552350997925,
0.4540177583694458,
0.10262270271778107,
-1.5620766878128052,
-0.11941559612751007,
-0.6239721775054932,
0.09380963444709778,
0.6370630264282227,
-0.6741121411323547,
0.8925480246543884,
0.007585772313177586,
-0.2688385844230652,
-0.26939165592193604,
0.5030478239059448,
0.20086805522441864,
0.22884111106395721,
0.2277141809463501,
0.6277254819869995,
0.62007075548172,
-0.30572041869163513,
1.2120610475540161,
-0.20583069324493408,
0.5229307413101196,
0.9022753834724426,
-0.18729910254478455,
0.7750248312950134,
0.2803962826728821,
-0.634398877620697,
0.393498957157135,
0.37422677874565125,
0.15926510095596313,
0.1643405705690384,
0.2622919976711273,
-0.4084075093269348,
0.04148702323436737,
0.19808827340602875,
-0.6193268895149231,
0.5893607139587402,
0.4991303086280823,
0.185920849442482,
-0.5355538129806519,
0.01931624487042427,
-0.03525406867265701,
-0.09515831619501114,
-0.2381320595741272,
0.4834562838077545,
0.037955231964588165,
-0.9672930836677551,
0.5833626985549927,
-0.15149903297424316,
0.3965036869049072,
-0.7531099319458008,
-0.21771404147148132,
-0.14773012697696686,
0.2177814245223999,
-0.05118308961391449,
-1.2530555725097656,
0.7284001708030701,
0.21165220439434052,
0.3224599361419678,
0.14923258125782013,
0.7890828847885132,
-0.21110044419765472,
-0.7013653516769409,
0.11484551429748535,
0.6647514700889587,
0.17666572332382202,
-0.014702336862683296,
-0.7223560810089111,
0.016049103811383247,
0.028656059876084328,
0.08263125270605087,
0.11048377305269241,
0.4878905713558197,
-0.37800008058547974,
0.7740633487701416,
0.7365134954452515,
0.06815317273139954,
0.3036951720714569,
0.10598872601985931,
0.533747136592865,
-0.5793653726577759,
-0.6183009743690491,
-0.920991837978363,
0.17163114249706268,
-0.07967059314250946,
-0.6478126049041748,
1.2028257846832275,
0.5493190288543701,
0.9715219140052795,
-0.12706905603408813,
1.0180531740188599,
-0.555631160736084,
0.24990811944007874,
-0.5192473530769348,
0.560621440410614,
-0.08740633726119995,
0.1741379052400589,
-0.5533428192138672,
-1.0248006582260132,
-0.396389901638031,
0.7130523920059204,
-0.8330140709877014,
0.35643431544303894,
0.9624344110488892,
0.4775907099246979,
-0.1559280902147293,
0.5820896029472351,
0.3409704267978668,
-0.32550984621047974,
0.4262092709541321,
0.928123950958252,
0.8866976499557495,
-0.584417998790741,
0.6595510840415955,
-0.2786804437637329,
-0.47247326374053955,
0.4734098017215729,
-0.6578980684280396,
-1.1194298267364502,
-0.5593727827072144,
-0.11954095214605331,
-0.39955079555511475,
-0.16080409288406372,
0.6411968469619751,
0.3654106855392456,
-0.8579732775688171,
-0.3876565098762512,
-0.314220130443573,
0.01317779440432787,
-0.1809110790491104,
-0.2856784462928772,
0.4683243930339813,
-0.36524078249931335,
-0.7964453101158142,
-0.053539443761110306,
0.3127537667751312,
-0.04784265160560608,
-0.4625355005264282,
-0.09629179537296295,
-0.3030429184436798,
0.2531088888645172,
0.6054489612579346,
0.41014236211776733,
-0.3623943626880646,
-0.14230753481388092,
0.02540358155965805,
0.04595093056559563,
0.046443112194538116,
1.098893404006958,
-0.5733193159103394,
0.7590680718421936,
0.8707176446914673,
0.7527902126312256,
0.49556705355644226,
0.02204820327460766,
0.8262074589729309,
-0.5333302021026611,
0.17591772973537445,
0.06082838773727417,
0.22668340802192688,
0.19228865206241608,
-0.26507502794265747,
0.7511416673660278,
0.1902744174003601,
-0.5478591918945312,
-0.34496456384658813,
0.24385152757167816,
-0.8780437707901001,
0.26087403297424316,
0.8675140142440796,
-0.11122914403676987,
-0.27783098816871643,
-0.08606264740228653,
-0.5254068970680237,
0.08913014084100723,
-0.25259286165237427,
0.6313475966453552,
1.1035913228988647,
-0.29380032420158386,
-0.2855111062526703,
-0.7908432483673096,
0.3427576422691345,
0.6639655828475952,
-0.8675388693809509,
-0.16935306787490845,
-0.031225277110934258,
-0.08634308725595474,
0.3854091167449951,
0.7032507658004761,
-0.45926639437675476,
0.3617408871650696,
0.2600700259208679,
-0.26562023162841797,
0.34971773624420166,
0.1251629889011383,
-0.35006359219551086,
-0.04703303426504135,
0.08125973492860794,
-0.13908858597278595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11255v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11255v1
|
WisPerMed at "Discharge Me!": Advancing Text Generation in Healthcare with Large Language Models, Dynamic Expert Selection, and Priming Techniques on MIMIC-IV
| 2024-05-18T10:56:45 | 2024-05-18T10:56:45 |
Hendrik Damm, Tabea M. G. Pakull, Bahadır Eryılmaz, Helmut Becker, Ahmad Idrissi-Yaghir, Henning Schäfer, Sergej Schultenkämper, Christoph M. Friedrich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This study aims to leverage state of the art language models to automate
generating the "Brief Hospital Course" and "Discharge Instructions" sections of
Discharge Summaries from the MIMIC-IV dataset, reducing clinicians'
administrative workload. We investigate how automation can improve
documentation accuracy, alleviate clinician burnout, and enhance operational
efficacy in healthcare facilities. This research was conducted within our
participation in the Shared Task Discharge Me! at BioNLP @ ACL 2024. Various
strategies were employed, including few-shot learning, instruction tuning, and
Dynamic Expert Selection (DES), to develop models capable of generating the
required text sections. Notably, utilizing an additional clinical
domain-specific dataset demonstrated substantial potential to enhance clinical
language processing. The DES method, which optimizes the selection of text
outputs from multiple predictions, proved to be especially effective. It
achieved the highest overall score of 0.332 in the competition, surpassing
single-model outputs. This finding suggests that advanced deep learning methods
in combination with DES can effectively automate parts of electronic health
record documentation. These advancements could enhance patient care by freeing
clinician time for patient interactions. The integration of text selection
strategies represents a promising avenue for further research.
|
[
-0.20280693471431732,
-0.565210223197937,
1.0089061260223389,
-0.060201775282621384,
-0.10172652453184128,
0.08081471174955368,
-0.0577537901699543,
-0.3367936611175537,
0.10423647612333298,
0.6642902493476868,
-0.6121572256088257,
-0.6019676327705383,
-0.630911648273468,
0.3323346972465515,
-0.5043567419052124,
1.0301157236099243,
-0.29895710945129395,
0.07443039119243622,
-0.25511839985847473,
0.17004796862602234,
-0.26174429059028625,
-0.4099072515964508,
-0.5716754794120789,
-0.5283223390579224,
0.511121392250061,
0.41450172662734985,
0.30072280764579773,
0.6990894079208374,
0.5929858088493347,
0.28572535514831543,
0.30532389879226685,
0.4016617238521576,
-0.2746623158454895,
0.41715696454048157,
0.07505977153778076,
-0.2755570411682129,
-0.5449315905570984,
-0.19195234775543213,
0.3315493166446686,
0.597606360912323,
-0.15353214740753174,
0.04276612401008606,
-0.09884282946586609,
0.7330970764160156,
-0.7583653330802917,
-0.06910168379545212,
-0.3515353500843048,
0.13052107393741608,
-0.12635096907615662,
-0.3301078677177429,
-0.47656118869781494,
-0.13558687269687653,
0.3308994770050049,
-0.5882055163383484,
0.37223392724990845,
-0.25792840123176575,
0.6347742676734924,
0.20052431523799896,
-0.3380732238292694,
-0.4211188554763794,
-0.8042954206466675,
0.7626284956932068,
-0.7098509669303894,
0.1354689747095108,
0.47935834527015686,
0.3278740644454956,
0.08770289272069931,
-1.089680552482605,
-0.08796379715204239,
-0.24323518574237823,
-0.25668224692344666,
0.48269137740135193,
-0.10421279817819595,
0.49012914299964905,
0.3071950674057007,
0.30837535858154297,
-0.43258315324783325,
0.28184810280799866,
-0.399394154548645,
-0.04267728701233864,
0.645331859588623,
0.4877358078956604,
0.3660733997821808,
-0.1859617680311203,
0.11689481884241104,
-0.04380381479859352,
-0.27843177318573,
-0.27950331568717957,
0.08724162727594376,
-0.003876033239066601,
-0.20154516398906708,
0.38315463066101074,
-0.49451595544815063,
0.3724551796913147,
0.10456947982311249,
-0.30236905813217163,
0.27853408455848694,
-0.20467516779899597,
-0.39069250226020813,
0.05246259272098541,
0.9482063055038452,
0.2254193276166916,
-0.026899660006165504,
-0.0880875289440155,
-0.231092169880867,
-0.3231560289859772,
0.5960080623626709,
-0.796972393989563,
-0.40467119216918945,
0.42546552419662476,
-0.8490977883338928,
-0.6008947491645813,
0.030202222988009453,
-0.7854502201080322,
-0.2582152187824249,
-0.39339739084243774,
0.14885646104812622,
-0.5826162695884705,
-0.05910579487681389,
-0.029615607112646103,
-0.06378831714391708,
-0.4559410810470581,
0.46105045080184937,
-0.9548357129096985,
0.46071234345436096,
0.41573214530944824,
0.6051982641220093,
-0.30453425645828247,
-0.06690181791782379,
-0.6238826513290405,
0.22475358843803406,
-0.19841685891151428,
0.46243324875831604,
-0.293570876121521,
-0.5318782925605774,
0.40333089232444763,
-0.3676186203956604,
-0.04739433154463768,
-0.6497087478637695,
0.4874124825000763,
-0.0681501030921936,
0.36682841181755066,
0.1787765920162201,
-0.5737279653549194,
0.01675974205136299,
0.015584982931613922,
-0.6508473753929138,
0.5015641450881958,
0.35493943095207214,
-0.6226128935813904,
0.2174140214920044,
-0.5616615414619446,
-0.4092654883861542,
0.16043919324874878,
-0.5249013900756836,
-0.5605258345603943,
0.2441921979188919,
0.11385989934206009,
0.5853216648101807,
-0.26569828391075134,
0.07820484787225723,
0.10262096673250198,
-0.16318388283252716,
-0.0706104263663292,
-0.2615375220775604,
0.4272434711456299,
0.39062806963920593,
-0.3817654848098755,
-0.09131987392902374,
-0.8235142230987549,
-0.08409486711025238,
-0.0708170160651207,
-0.33636772632598877,
-0.32168418169021606,
0.045101720839738846,
-0.059988200664520264,
0.024838190525770187,
0.07113683968782425,
-0.07624822854995728,
0.1420888900756836,
-0.5436081886291504,
-0.14851759374141693,
0.4715687334537506,
0.385066419839859,
0.4666740894317627,
-0.5328322052955627,
0.7762726545333862,
-0.051472071558237076,
0.2800738215446472,
-0.6533084511756897,
-0.34842371940612793,
-0.40169116854667664,
-0.49981021881103516,
0.07992886751890182,
0.5367178320884705,
-0.5309153199195862,
0.3339489698410034,
0.03718481957912445,
-0.5358080863952637,
-0.41437408328056335,
-0.12250116467475891,
0.6596340537071228,
0.8833720088005066,
0.5294672846794128,
-0.0301683247089386,
-0.4875430166721344,
-0.9002002477645874,
0.05400920286774635,
-0.05545666441321373,
-0.04903065413236618,
0.2753770351409912,
0.12363632023334503,
-0.633409857749939,
0.6254624724388123,
-0.6703711152076721,
-0.5138410329818726,
-0.360809326171875,
0.5319366455078125,
0.17302130162715912,
0.33120763301849365,
0.5072794556617737,
-0.5673995614051819,
-0.4730514883995056,
0.05906360223889351,
-0.8826581239700317,
-0.4145137369632721,
-0.35611259937286377,
0.08748943358659744,
0.06391329318284988,
0.4325787425041199,
-0.4774663746356964,
0.40584370493888855,
0.19934146106243134,
0.06142556667327881,
0.7300258874893188,
-0.7450529932975769,
0.4272974133491516,
-1.2550392150878906,
0.102812759578228,
-0.08727255463600159,
-0.17825953662395477,
-0.6442370414733887,
-0.10368264466524124,
0.11320207267999649,
-0.011654997244477272,
-0.2445051670074463,
0.4810461699962616,
-0.45492297410964966,
0.37694305181503296,
-0.26849326491355896,
-0.17779923975467682,
0.14640280604362488,
0.04118071869015694,
-0.050243109464645386,
0.35882091522216797,
0.42768970131874084,
-0.760145366191864,
0.3649351894855499,
0.422290563583374,
0.048994529992341995,
0.16500823199748993,
-0.42526891827583313,
-0.31414204835891724,
-0.13153083622455597,
0.24001602828502655,
-0.661040186882019,
-0.5074616074562073,
-0.05971430614590645,
-0.15694600343704224,
0.5522727966308594,
0.25225481390953064,
-0.3383426368236542,
-0.4681365191936493,
-0.28741204738616943,
0.15756545960903168,
0.8329833745956421,
0.10586492717266083,
0.5471726059913635,
0.2155405431985855,
-0.2644929885864258,
-0.525680661201477,
-0.6263623833656311,
-0.0017825968097895384,
0.07916615158319473,
-0.1647336333990097,
0.5632845759391785,
0.16862964630126953,
-0.47562241554260254,
-0.2584264278411865,
0.039332423359155655,
-0.09735806286334991,
0.1118706539273262,
0.18945832550525665,
0.2114994376897812,
-0.039269544184207916,
0.29157382249832153,
0.5952573418617249,
-0.20692259073257446,
0.1667845994234085,
-0.2137570083141327,
0.5296878814697266,
0.5071297287940979,
-0.5852951407432556,
-0.8380936980247498,
0.7263192534446716,
0.7016481757164001,
-0.12475124001502991,
0.525457501411438,
0.4702087640762329,
-0.5226714015007019,
-0.1969243288040161,
-0.7139824032783508,
-0.5138593912124634,
-0.4315694272518158,
0.4583149254322052,
-0.08290564268827438,
-0.3017362058162689,
0.3777175545692444,
-0.3850368857383728,
0.4914741516113281,
0.40483373403549194,
0.6261301636695862,
-0.4030543267726898,
1.0465984344482422,
0.6449009776115417,
0.24104011058807373,
0.39565128087997437,
-0.44414323568344116,
0.12521961331367493,
-0.4129737615585327,
-0.34994611144065857,
-0.44271546602249146,
-0.10902584344148636,
-0.5694863200187683,
-0.2719574570655823,
0.6006811261177063,
-0.11780010908842087,
0.1902931183576584,
-0.0232557263225317,
-0.6568817496299744,
-0.16979116201400757,
0.4554780125617981,
0.2246013730764389,
0.23307357728481293,
-0.004729229956865311,
-0.32789677381515503,
-0.1366744190454483,
-0.40791478753089905,
-0.6020969152450562,
1.1145280599594116,
0.2955038547515869,
0.8364987373352051,
-0.4368510842323303,
1.2495249509811401,
0.5023296475410461,
0.02143954113125801,
-0.2949870526790619,
0.31026604771614075,
-0.5363925099372864,
0.06538943946361542,
-0.06508809328079224,
-0.19951468706130981,
-0.8033490180969238,
-0.2532077729701996,
-0.3531644940376282,
-0.4322410821914673,
-0.11226721107959747,
0.40199100971221924,
-0.5767527222633362,
0.010578222572803497,
-0.6488858461380005,
0.6341634392738342,
-0.16087570786476135,
-0.027209892868995667,
-0.4109710156917572,
-0.5629639625549316,
0.3884967565536499,
-0.49276459217071533,
0.2386951446533203,
0.06236034631729126,
-0.1861075460910797,
0.4865120053291321,
-0.6409777998924255,
0.5907790064811707,
0.03669693320989609,
-0.16279785335063934,
0.058234915137290955,
0.07140804082155228,
0.386862576007843,
-0.025466104969382286,
-0.23399680852890015,
-0.18482747673988342,
0.003732516663148999,
0.009625250473618507,
-0.5336935520172119,
0.5204670429229736,
-0.6526049375534058,
-0.2710835337638855,
0.034467387944459915,
-0.3868589699268341,
-0.2122398018836975,
0.3308604657649994,
0.7525597214698792,
0.8048756122589111,
-0.20378881692886353,
-0.17086894810199738,
0.9571548700332642,
-0.5879409313201904,
0.3348124623298645,
0.4044111371040344,
-0.03815208002924919,
-0.42578643560409546,
0.7172562479972839,
0.2417462319135666,
0.23692017793655396,
0.7207232713699341,
0.22286704182624817,
-0.2580808997154236,
-0.5769568681716919,
-0.42742475867271423,
0.31869086623191833,
-0.631843626499176,
-0.31242549419403076,
-1.2235019207000732,
-0.38719049096107483,
-0.588767409324646,
-0.5599724650382996,
-0.1435994952917099,
-0.2719351351261139,
-0.6604498028755188,
-0.2225911021232605,
0.1288953423500061,
0.9459600448608398,
0.10279402136802673,
0.274655282497406,
-1.0287162065505981,
0.6099964380264282,
0.10335610806941986,
-0.013063269667327404,
-0.15126590430736542,
-0.2060498148202896,
-0.33304476737976074,
-0.04648878052830696,
-0.49119195342063904,
-1.040307879447937,
0.34006673097610474,
0.15318821370601654,
0.7392794489860535,
0.5988693833351135,
0.15571145713329315,
0.4148325026035309,
-0.7036345601081848,
0.7696920037269592,
0.5604602694511414,
-0.5879845023155212,
0.833977222442627,
-0.4977744519710541,
0.35400646924972534,
0.5655762553215027,
0.38190144300460815,
-0.3477122187614441,
-0.9659314155578613,
-0.7738726139068604,
-1.0233858823776245,
0.6763442754745483,
0.12515367567539215,
0.16200025379657745,
-0.1340731829404831,
0.4077233672142029,
0.3117252290248871,
0.13871905207633972,
0.011129853315651417,
-0.44501158595085144,
0.12994380295276642,
-0.7662188410758972,
0.21843290328979492,
-0.392768532037735,
-0.06473066657781601,
0.04464857652783394,
0.5090116858482361,
-0.07653458416461945,
0.24680669605731964,
0.23280151188373566,
0.042210955172777176,
-0.23112091422080994,
0.010179605334997177,
0.7893060445785522,
0.9628708362579346,
0.17123547196388245,
-0.1070927157998085,
0.17740684747695923,
-0.6582179069519043,
0.025841370224952698,
0.1653275340795517,
-0.25633707642555237,
0.5232129096984863,
0.4321960210800171,
0.5076776146888733,
0.13125020265579224,
-0.8549312949180603,
0.4548698663711548,
-0.03843213990330696,
-0.43575218319892883,
-0.2954409122467041,
0.2947174608707428,
-0.14495693147182465,
-0.10920253396034241,
0.5744315981864929,
0.02369430847465992,
0.5125269293785095,
-0.10700158029794693,
0.6435669660568237,
0.12924782931804657,
-0.23922523856163025,
-0.03513725847005844,
0.783690869808197,
0.25435128808021545,
-0.2039407640695572,
0.34655100107192993,
0.24607636034488678,
-0.026807785034179688,
0.7582871913909912,
0.4167824685573578,
0.9618028402328491,
-0.23379245400428772,
0.2693207859992981,
0.4599496126174927,
-0.13047201931476593,
-0.08662597090005875,
0.17278560996055603,
-0.0605795681476593,
-0.03700317069888115,
-0.40132373571395874,
-0.6077529191970825,
-0.38420116901397705,
0.23184433579444885,
-0.6777377128601074,
0.5395082235336304,
-0.4116799533367157,
-0.10693591833114624,
-0.18684746325016022,
-0.1368587613105774,
-0.5088182687759399,
0.4483560025691986,
0.3511849641799927,
0.9076111912727356,
-0.7204192280769348,
0.41490620374679565,
0.6635950803756714,
-0.44475263357162476,
-0.9106281399726868,
0.19650809466838837,
-0.007730972953140736,
-0.40362799167633057,
0.37076079845428467,
0.08722975850105286,
-0.07630898803472519,
-0.012199198827147484,
-0.12532193958759308,
-0.21672490239143372,
1.0836313962936401,
0.19877347350120544,
-0.5049919486045837,
-0.3914812505245209,
-0.031435079872608185,
0.7114095091819763,
-0.32027071714401245,
0.6925637722015381,
0.4172270894050598,
0.22144873440265656,
-0.2501816749572754,
-0.9857499599456787,
-0.151386097073555,
-0.11491672694683075,
-0.11144916713237762,
0.09402292221784592,
-0.4021575152873993,
0.5681815147399902,
-0.22626952826976776,
-0.011223416775465012,
0.10821320116519928,
0.6258593797683716,
0.13261830806732178,
0.3104540705680847,
0.1256621927022934,
0.3186451494693756,
0.828665018081665,
0.08790593594312668,
1.1449568271636963,
-0.2831132709980011,
-0.018524156883358955,
0.852501630783081,
-0.19090807437896729,
0.31230485439300537,
0.2566724419593811,
0.06908860057592392,
0.6333961486816406,
0.4843212962150574,
0.16527491807937622,
0.6109247803688049,
-0.10458586364984512,
-0.615263044834137,
-0.03089623898267746,
-0.1716141402721405,
-0.37837547063827515,
0.2842259705066681,
0.2532462179660797,
-0.964478611946106,
-0.18061865866184235,
0.38485023379325867,
0.05829726904630661,
0.29957687854766846,
-0.18417592346668243,
1.2400411367416382,
0.2372523546218872,
-0.9098672866821289,
0.4255823791027069,
0.007835682481527328,
0.34488505125045776,
-0.8122453093528748,
-0.21079136431217194,
-0.08499998599290848,
0.12115538865327835,
-0.4263504147529602,
-0.43211284279823303,
0.22090865671634674,
0.08424878120422363,
-0.4632660746574402,
-0.7169826626777649,
0.6607791185379028,
-0.33791467547416687,
-0.34671181440353394,
0.07625918835401535,
0.6209016442298889,
0.047369107604026794,
0.24016496539115906,
-0.670840322971344,
-0.15551620721817017,
0.012359795160591602,
-0.1013595312833786,
0.24178272485733032,
0.5028294920921326,
-0.02579079009592533,
0.5503742694854736,
0.43756189942359924,
0.38633716106414795,
0.1467396765947342,
0.41977596282958984,
0.7208215594291687,
-0.21615217626094818,
-0.4760301411151886,
-0.9294824004173279,
0.6907382607460022,
-0.22185325622558594,
-0.1852845698595047,
0.20555773377418518,
0.691577672958374,
0.2522508203983307,
-0.3307858407497406,
1.0680876970291138,
0.031111905351281166,
0.9162847995758057,
-0.3164738118648529,
0.9414389729499817,
-0.5965960621833801,
-0.16406117379665375,
-0.4012193977832794,
-0.267435759305954,
-0.21025386452674866,
0.20740017294883728,
-0.054540324956178665,
-0.08171497285366058,
0.8121336102485657,
0.29544684290885925,
-0.06030856445431709,
-0.5110552310943604,
0.4607985317707062,
-0.054189495742321014,
0.6319358944892883,
0.3661899268627167,
0.3796483874320984,
-0.3658137023448944,
0.35919618606567383,
-0.5059881210327148,
-0.3722028136253357,
-0.4821811318397522,
-0.6340638995170593,
-0.7232927680015564,
-0.5849483609199524,
-0.3764593005180359,
-0.20034915208816528,
-0.0006860635476186872,
0.8231045603752136,
0.6162469387054443,
-0.7072180509567261,
0.09433378279209137,
-0.20082904398441315,
-0.12535971403121948,
-0.23568055033683777,
-0.20362094044685364,
0.2832832336425781,
-0.7437564730644226,
-0.7708534002304077,
0.25007644295692444,
0.515870213508606,
0.12738431990146637,
-0.09221889078617096,
-0.021603558212518692,
0.12462860345840454,
-0.1316588968038559,
0.3110615909099579,
0.03766769915819168,
-0.572839081287384,
0.4041113555431366,
0.09098479151725769,
-0.728482723236084,
-0.20409533381462097,
0.9694600105285645,
-0.7093393802642822,
0.5752012133598328,
0.6803876757621765,
0.6690536141395569,
0.2829962968826294,
0.2001200020313263,
0.9226095080375671,
-0.5736604928970337,
-0.040017735213041306,
0.5651094317436218,
0.3471565544605255,
0.07230573147535324,
-0.7216251492500305,
0.24868369102478027,
0.13518762588500977,
-0.4751986265182495,
-0.6358083486557007,
0.15807823836803436,
-0.64494389295578,
-0.11857523024082184,
0.9920052886009216,
-0.043263789266347885,
-0.038538459688425064,
-0.36953336000442505,
-0.437151700258255,
0.47573617100715637,
-0.17609675228595734,
0.8361541628837585,
0.26986369490623474,
-0.48146069049835205,
-0.16452839970588684,
-0.6473050713539124,
0.8797879815101624,
0.3290439248085022,
-1.1084609031677246,
-0.0693875178694725,
0.5263614058494568,
0.10087960958480835,
0.1117614284157753,
0.9913032650947571,
-0.0871337279677391,
0.679104745388031,
-0.23668284714221954,
0.007342847064137459,
-0.1331956535577774,
-0.11895748972892761,
-0.0205827783793211,
0.13773569464683533,
-0.2157229483127594,
-0.1863749623298645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13044v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13044v1
|
Case-Based Reasoning Approach for Solving Financial Question Answering
| 2024-05-18T10:06:55 | 2024-05-18T10:06:55 |
Yikyung Kim, Jay-Yoon Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Measuring a machine's understanding of human language often involves
assessing its reasoning skills, i.e. logical process of deriving answers to
questions. While recent language models have shown remarkable proficiency in
text based tasks, their efficacy in complex reasoning problems involving
heterogeneous information such as text, tables, and numbers remain uncertain.
Addressing this gap, FinQA introduced a numerical reasoning dataset for
financial documents and simultaneously proposed a program generation approach .
Our investigation reveals that half of the errors (48%) stem from incorrect
operations being generated. To address this issue, we propose a novel approach
to tackle numerical reasoning problems using case based reasoning (CBR), an
artificial intelligence paradigm that provides problem solving guidance by
offering similar cases (i.e. similar questions and corresponding logical
programs). Our model retrieves relevant cases to address a given question, and
then generates an answer based on the retrieved cases and contextual
information. Through experiments on the FinQA dataset, we demonstrate
competitive performance of our approach and additionally show that by expanding
case repository, we can help solving complex multi step programs which FinQA
showed weakness of.
|
[
-0.35596129298210144,
-1.1525367498397827,
0.562785267829895,
0.27984583377838135,
-0.006992774549871683,
0.4841633439064026,
0.15080557763576508,
-0.22737200558185577,
-0.2246706634759903,
0.9062116146087646,
-0.6303139328956604,
-0.3376748263835907,
-0.2585727572441101,
0.03688666597008705,
-0.13953259587287903,
0.9906750321388245,
-0.018333885818719864,
0.1981291025876999,
-0.5003294348716736,
0.03558329865336418,
-0.6878612637519836,
-0.8215498328208923,
-1.0892767906188965,
-0.3025380074977875,
0.13654379546642303,
0.6823065280914307,
0.6069089770317078,
0.35043764114379883,
0.908107578754425,
0.2984490990638733,
0.16303309798240662,
-0.01675279065966606,
0.06545613706111908,
-0.15317274630069733,
-0.19977563619613647,
-0.5499851703643799,
-0.10986362397670746,
-0.4274428188800812,
0.16038808226585388,
0.7956046462059021,
-0.5313515663146973,
0.13063572347164154,
-0.4388224184513092,
0.9744507074356079,
-0.3646022081375122,
0.3882361352443695,
-0.647442102432251,
0.03170343488454819,
-0.20882171392440796,
-0.31334298849105835,
-0.4094156324863434,
-0.48392683267593384,
0.2545197010040283,
-0.6436045169830322,
0.36711084842681885,
0.15918602049350739,
0.5664304494857788,
0.4386139512062073,
-0.36588114500045776,
-0.6872620582580566,
-0.8118702173233032,
0.6576080918312073,
-0.7989771366119385,
0.07517223060131073,
0.3393317759037018,
0.7109206318855286,
-0.2118404507637024,
-0.5543209910392761,
-0.5243729948997498,
0.1876300573348999,
0.14624129235744476,
0.09480967372655869,
-0.1442718505859375,
-0.06283490359783173,
0.4576716125011444,
0.014063801616430283,
-0.5479956269264221,
-0.5301014184951782,
-0.6108518838882446,
-0.34354186058044434,
0.6723564863204956,
0.061028458178043365,
0.1626448929309845,
-0.05325912684202194,
-0.3419618010520935,
-0.4423716366291046,
-0.47016721963882446,
0.41937366127967834,
0.37967437505722046,
0.5103645920753479,
0.1995820701122284,
0.6514230966567993,
-0.26055046916007996,
0.6985740065574646,
0.08260448276996613,
-0.09214738011360168,
0.01992291584610939,
-0.2554078996181488,
-0.2875136435031891,
0.5736507773399353,
0.10277128219604492,
0.07434660196304321,
0.42900410294532776,
0.18417419493198395,
-0.3135167062282562,
-0.20579767227172852,
0.3666286766529083,
-0.4258978068828583,
-0.0381135568022728,
0.5799941420555115,
-0.3349103331565857,
-0.20224438607692719,
0.21435685455799103,
-0.6446934342384338,
-0.22383125126361847,
-0.2905550003051758,
0.5126001834869385,
-0.4130459129810333,
-0.06794764846563339,
0.45181113481521606,
-0.3486758768558502,
0.5078669190406799,
0.24727478623390198,
-0.6544642448425293,
0.43384626507759094,
0.9175099730491638,
0.21673999726772308,
0.4138118028640747,
0.28686174750328064,
-1.0053894519805908,
0.23752427101135254,
-0.3114137649536133,
1.0901216268539429,
-0.4184742271900177,
-0.33856841921806335,
-0.06897062808275223,
-0.49026042222976685,
-0.0983794629573822,
-0.6677812933921814,
0.4710977077484131,
-0.6876605749130249,
0.13035300374031067,
-0.4889986515045166,
-0.49886655807495117,
-0.2525568902492523,
0.17426039278507233,
-0.6039694547653198,
0.7977664470672607,
0.1534366011619568,
-0.8746873140335083,
0.30984893441200256,
-1.0324355363845825,
-0.4602516293525696,
0.1890486776828766,
-0.14640651643276215,
-0.5433356165885925,
-0.10508942604064941,
0.3241095542907715,
0.17497004568576813,
-0.3978733718395233,
0.6714656352996826,
-0.319160521030426,
-0.41371235251426697,
0.4829255938529968,
-0.37476110458374023,
0.5907672047615051,
0.22332163155078888,
-0.4137261211872101,
-0.055669717490673065,
-0.6309335231781006,
0.06278949975967407,
0.18150043487548828,
-0.13951930403709412,
-0.5774744749069214,
0.08001615107059479,
-0.1481543630361557,
0.12046851962804794,
0.2691623270511627,
-0.646594762802124,
0.06622860580682755,
-0.37962958216667175,
0.46552973985671997,
0.6118046641349792,
0.25217604637145996,
0.1158992350101471,
-0.49628257751464844,
0.44486233592033386,
0.012964511290192604,
0.07024114578962326,
-0.055394288152456284,
-0.4519892632961273,
-0.5268616676330566,
0.028171494603157043,
0.43022751808166504,
0.9091103672981262,
-0.8922868967056274,
-0.1955999881029129,
0.17876888811588287,
-0.1403883695602417,
-0.10969711095094681,
-0.1079239770770073,
0.36447352170944214,
0.7740752696990967,
0.39686712622642517,
-0.07225688546895981,
-0.38812240958213806,
-1.1648701429367065,
-0.25668349862098694,
-0.4408905804157257,
0.26653769612312317,
0.47804781794548035,
0.39593902230262756,
-0.028636757284402847,
1.1316275596618652,
-0.8932548761367798,
0.1964331567287445,
-0.12378983944654465,
0.5236273407936096,
0.3033270239830017,
0.5119727849960327,
0.4919024407863617,
-1.218288779258728,
-0.06156867742538452,
0.08925007283687592,
-0.6170666813850403,
-0.08814743906259537,
-0.6710729598999023,
-0.26412153244018555,
0.3575187027454376,
0.5826619267463684,
-0.261508047580719,
0.5797305107116699,
-0.011260485276579857,
-0.5003064870834351,
0.5337492823600769,
-0.21107515692710876,
0.09710079431533813,
-0.9710233807563782,
0.22917410731315613,
0.2166500836610794,
-0.06025170534849167,
-0.503017008304596,
-0.22839033603668213,
-0.12768003344535828,
-0.24031008780002594,
-0.0990820825099945,
0.5948023200035095,
-0.06428840756416321,
-0.4668383300304413,
-0.1831435263156891,
-0.06087249889969826,
0.1357436180114746,
0.6074376106262207,
0.14156675338745117,
0.7969353795051575,
0.09766501188278198,
-0.2412959188222885,
0.411966472864151,
0.3469623923301697,
-0.2390892058610916,
0.7252863049507141,
-0.6731738448143005,
-0.010791322216391563,
-0.20865629613399506,
0.07093282043933868,
-1.0552984476089478,
-0.06403330713510513,
0.2935757339000702,
-0.3554604947566986,
0.1860773116350174,
-0.028658924624323845,
-0.18271668255329132,
-0.6306518316268921,
0.17549653351306915,
0.42226022481918335,
-0.04826674610376358,
-0.21809121966362,
0.7884162068367004,
0.022102709859609604,
-0.895813524723053,
-0.9220646023750305,
-0.6117090582847595,
-0.012104514986276627,
-0.24539850652217865,
-0.6411813497543335,
0.3066714107990265,
-0.3100939095020294,
-0.7730753421783447,
0.12800242006778717,
-0.34577512741088867,
-0.5884005427360535,
0.20246082544326782,
-0.08520220965147018,
0.5617619156837463,
-0.36792275309562683,
0.16766873002052307,
0.4425300061702728,
-0.2214663028717041,
0.4349510073661804,
-0.28243258595466614,
0.14710856974124908,
-0.4299617111682892,
-0.4936285614967346,
0.011246091686189175,
0.6003522872924805,
0.5236431360244751,
-0.41450291872024536,
0.5429778099060059,
0.12464113533496857,
-0.501319408416748,
-0.06059614568948746,
-0.7332012057304382,
0.06248645484447479,
-0.47497060894966125,
-0.008908091112971306,
-0.5989069938659668,
-0.7095263004302979,
0.7847769260406494,
-0.1189044937491417,
0.13936495780944824,
0.5558801889419556,
0.5295004844665527,
-0.01963333785533905,
0.8003525137901306,
0.5534356236457825,
0.11324139684438705,
0.2614484429359436,
-0.1394275426864624,
0.2830064296722412,
-0.1821204125881195,
-0.5709459185600281,
-0.6753697395324707,
0.24749206006526947,
0.019270293414592743,
-0.34808534383773804,
0.33512550592422485,
0.2038951963186264,
-0.39193296432495117,
0.2767884135246277,
-0.4048076272010803,
0.31216469407081604,
0.6564732193946838,
-0.005225193686783314,
0.4204130470752716,
-0.1156901940703392,
-0.5574280023574829,
0.32266584038734436,
-0.8557926416397095,
-0.3757231831550598,
1.0228245258331299,
0.13111752271652222,
0.2582053542137146,
0.11162903904914856,
0.6746689081192017,
0.5774087309837341,
0.4409979283809662,
-0.5437663197517395,
0.2559744417667389,
0.14190174639225006,
-0.6840627789497375,
-0.5517299771308899,
-0.8917726278305054,
-0.4662126898765564,
-0.2076258510351181,
-0.21831710636615753,
-0.3469422161579132,
0.2451021671295166,
-0.005127914249897003,
-0.7460009455680847,
0.031051836907863617,
-0.6979683041572571,
1.0140239000320435,
-0.4588702619075775,
-0.25557219982147217,
-0.013804147951304913,
-0.6652565002441406,
0.37412330508232117,
-0.6303912997245789,
0.6449196338653564,
0.24944430589675903,
0.373729944229126,
0.6118680834770203,
-0.9779804348945618,
0.5350232720375061,
-0.35317203402519226,
-0.24828115105628967,
0.7666003108024597,
-0.15578897297382355,
0.34765398502349854,
0.15231631696224213,
-0.34599733352661133,
-0.01740674115717411,
0.46931836009025574,
-0.6687580943107605,
-0.8891058564186096,
0.30844846367836,
-0.391086608171463,
-0.6864098906517029,
-0.5371161103248596,
-0.6230655908584595,
-0.4347892999649048,
0.01072121225297451,
-0.21584975719451904,
0.5989198088645935,
-0.030512668192386627,
0.046677589416503906,
0.4975058436393738,
-0.36257922649383545,
0.41773414611816406,
0.5142180919647217,
-0.022128038108348846,
-0.5393688082695007,
0.8414755463600159,
-0.0851307213306427,
-0.003448953153565526,
0.5381726026535034,
0.2746257483959198,
-0.5136885046958923,
-0.391544908285141,
-0.6537092924118042,
0.15200884640216827,
-0.5712741017341614,
-0.3948776423931122,
-0.29089072346687317,
-0.23489227890968323,
-0.25908854603767395,
-0.3839719891548157,
-0.16211161017417908,
-0.515069305896759,
0.2234589159488678,
-0.01741238310933113,
0.4598517417907715,
0.4065065085887909,
-0.2004513293504715,
-0.11860696226358414,
-0.961147665977478,
0.33906978368759155,
0.5497848987579346,
0.3052598834037781,
-0.021462831646203995,
-0.10418953001499176,
-0.3675217032432556,
0.16804276406764984,
0.05610622093081474,
-0.6754069328308105,
0.2477676272392273,
-0.14767861366271973,
0.6206470727920532,
0.25325706601142883,
0.240877166390419,
0.5750400424003601,
-0.13809409737586975,
0.2505562901496887,
0.02843954972922802,
-1.0277632474899292,
0.5640316009521484,
-0.4235859215259552,
0.20690487325191498,
0.7404879927635193,
0.21493510901927948,
-0.4327658712863922,
-0.20372234284877777,
-0.7126315832138062,
-0.7316164970397949,
0.5151860117912292,
0.2653036415576935,
-0.27209192514419556,
0.07782553881406784,
0.8799184560775757,
0.054465506225824356,
0.42937755584716797,
-0.18385888636112213,
-0.11045114696025848,
-0.4197536110877991,
-0.31519052386283875,
0.25068145990371704,
0.09957130253314972,
0.06729622185230255,
-0.16402900218963623,
0.7111579179763794,
-0.4806826710700989,
0.07430768758058548,
0.3352299928665161,
0.3484402894973755,
-0.16081096231937408,
0.23408624529838562,
0.5970845818519592,
0.630607545375824,
-0.34193339943885803,
-0.3799130320549011,
0.04299383610486984,
-0.3041040003299713,
-0.12595336139202118,
0.4837595820426941,
-0.019938698038458824,
-0.3059227764606476,
0.20783279836177826,
0.2154425084590912,
0.1614874303340912,
-1.2986339330673218,
0.4637632369995117,
-0.3656669557094574,
-0.6056379079818726,
-0.5322811007499695,
-0.1786612570285797,
0.1830960214138031,
0.5662565231323242,
0.9246387481689453,
0.26746633648872375,
0.29903972148895264,
-0.704953134059906,
0.6020121574401855,
0.39033830165863037,
-0.3029867112636566,
0.3533917963504791,
0.5826480984687805,
0.07927865535020828,
-0.16471447050571442,
0.9405777454376221,
0.1668374240398407,
-0.6206578612327576,
1.2798482179641724,
0.5785568952560425,
0.5741968154907227,
0.199576273560524,
0.4804740250110626,
0.1737990528345108,
0.06067963317036629,
-0.2149708867073059,
0.6955533027648926,
-0.09785051643848419,
-0.9583922624588013,
-0.7504079937934875,
-0.6138685345649719,
-0.9239882826805115,
-0.1698468029499054,
-0.8711713552474976,
-0.07808409631252289,
-0.7082573771476746,
-0.033857885748147964,
0.23726418614387512,
0.08414753526449203,
-0.375480592250824,
0.4334280490875244,
0.16416119039058685,
0.9129617214202881,
-0.5599277019500732,
0.3927719295024872,
0.7199761271476746,
-0.5277160406112671,
-0.9322721362113953,
-0.11656541377305984,
-0.11441483348608017,
-0.47471556067466736,
0.6353731155395508,
-0.008454600349068642,
-0.05374414473772049,
-0.15075358748435974,
-0.43862926959991455,
-0.7608044743537903,
0.8070842623710632,
0.20334060490131378,
-0.48677101731300354,
0.11076914519071579,
0.3083786964416504,
0.345660001039505,
-0.31588298082351685,
-0.11065765470266342,
0.3918152451515198,
0.696841299533844,
0.7264560461044312,
-0.5329364538192749,
-0.1818511039018631,
-0.5286964774131775,
-0.2522750794887543,
0.3652615249156952,
-0.5412684082984924,
0.7267458438873291,
-0.4654525816440582,
0.06154512241482735,
-0.027033435180783272,
0.616165816783905,
0.522246778011322,
0.9974592328071594,
0.45489299297332764,
0.3135928511619568,
1.0131464004516602,
-0.1545373797416687,
0.9898727536201477,
-0.3557768166065216,
0.21001838147640228,
0.8808325529098511,
-0.47349002957344055,
0.8146371245384216,
0.32476118206977844,
0.06499035656452179,
0.7980301976203918,
0.6836935877799988,
-0.08616844564676285,
0.24788305163383484,
0.5570860505104065,
-0.31441977620124817,
-0.568328320980072,
0.06393809616565704,
-0.1106618270277977,
0.5158078074455261,
0.3527315855026245,
0.011628557927906513,
0.03164049610495567,
0.008260673843324184,
-0.28946590423583984,
0.3554205894470215,
-0.3488933742046356,
0.5421392917633057,
0.16111156344413757,
-0.6770059466362,
-0.03861584886908531,
0.39413899183273315,
0.12288419157266617,
-0.468758761882782,
-0.42047274112701416,
-0.2833203077316284,
0.024099422618746758,
-0.02312256582081318,
-0.5714322924613953,
0.815008282661438,
0.19454701244831085,
-0.3646751344203949,
-0.16336487233638763,
0.7816099524497986,
-0.04662013798952103,
-0.8968119025230408,
-0.1310507208108902,
0.7958629727363586,
-0.07054808735847473,
-0.20387600362300873,
-0.7389389872550964,
-0.49785247445106506,
0.006872132886201143,
0.06343148648738861,
0.1512208729982376,
0.7011849880218506,
-0.4209466874599457,
0.8814054131507874,
1.0661908388137817,
-0.3813530504703522,
-0.3482140600681305,
0.013386625796556473,
0.7374541759490967,
-0.9899903535842896,
-0.43942517042160034,
-0.5953063368797302,
0.1535811424255371,
-0.02654523402452469,
-0.20942401885986328,
0.25672778487205505,
0.8234187960624695,
0.7369265556335449,
0.12752903997898102,
0.8241158723831177,
0.28723227977752686,
0.50636887550354,
-0.549667477607727,
0.3853180408477783,
-0.39384564757347107,
0.5317841172218323,
-0.5190423130989075,
-0.6595766544342041,
-0.43662092089653015,
0.7054978609085083,
-0.6063845157623291,
-0.16762717068195343,
0.46942466497421265,
0.5487509965896606,
0.2062494158744812,
0.4851997494697571,
0.0349273718893528,
-0.1012096107006073,
-0.062009282410144806,
0.5934666991233826,
0.6231088638305664,
-0.29976269602775574,
0.8619887232780457,
-0.10734288394451141,
-0.15895545482635498,
-0.2010074257850647,
-0.7679432034492493,
-0.44490689039230347,
-0.2734331488609314,
-0.519417941570282,
-0.294677197933197,
0.14690320193767548,
0.6818432211875916,
0.0197969451546669,
-0.8274325132369995,
-0.30514371395111084,
-0.1639455258846283,
0.3035072386264801,
-0.47234824299812317,
-0.30554333329200745,
0.3356846570968628,
-0.08068745583295822,
-0.3031417727470398,
0.26904499530792236,
0.3756754398345947,
-0.019768066704273224,
-0.08457525074481964,
0.16918358206748962,
-0.06892241537570953,
0.7038849592208862,
0.41910380125045776,
0.5693030953407288,
-0.23629289865493774,
-0.3397151827812195,
0.20106372237205505,
-0.0025368814822286367,
0.013802196830511093,
0.9832642674446106,
-0.7801785469055176,
0.1816554218530655,
0.37472668290138245,
0.977423906326294,
0.7251265048980713,
0.4965425729751587,
0.8360095024108887,
-0.19001011550426483,
-0.22721415758132935,
0.09691756963729858,
0.28055769205093384,
0.15410295128822327,
-0.53228360414505,
0.46463024616241455,
0.2771952450275421,
-0.27262812852859497,
-0.4995128810405731,
0.03701787441968918,
-1.033596158027649,
-0.7115063071250916,
0.5909863710403442,
0.04526229947805405,
-0.36798030138015747,
-0.42099907994270325,
-0.273316353559494,
0.18055912852287292,
-0.5517521500587463,
0.7820824980735779,
0.6997271180152893,
-0.33983901143074036,
0.02202541194856167,
-0.5432844758033752,
0.158373162150383,
0.47337397933006287,
-0.9100460410118103,
-0.028700102120637894,
0.5643354058265686,
0.19969607889652252,
0.2617257833480835,
0.7021328806877136,
-0.10783880949020386,
0.4428260922431946,
0.2820546329021454,
0.0002736310998443514,
-0.19449232518672943,
-0.2532910108566284,
0.028835486620664597,
0.48162537813186646,
-0.22059278190135956,
0.24806688725948334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11227v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11227v1
|
BadActs: A Universal Backdoor Defense in the Activation Space
| 2024-05-18T08:32:37 | 2024-05-18T08:32:37 |
Biao Yi, Sishuo Chen, Yiming Li, Tong Li, Baolei Zhang, Zheli Liu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Backdoor attacks pose an increasingly severe security threat to Deep Neural
Networks (DNNs) during their development stage. In response, backdoor sample
purification has emerged as a promising defense mechanism, aiming to eliminate
backdoor triggers while preserving the integrity of the clean content in the
samples. However, existing approaches have been predominantly focused on the
word space, which are ineffective against feature-space triggers and
significantly impair performance on clean data. To address this, we introduce a
universal backdoor defense that purifies backdoor samples in the activation
space by drawing abnormal activations towards optimized minimum clean
activation distribution intervals. The advantages of our approach are twofold:
(1) By operating in the activation space, our method captures from
surface-level information like words to higher-level semantic concepts such as
syntax, thus counteracting diverse triggers; (2) the fine-grained continuous
nature of the activation space allows for more precise preservation of clean
content while removing triggers. Furthermore, we propose a detection module
based on statistical information of abnormal activations, to achieve a better
trade-off between clean accuracy and defending performance.
|
[
-0.07829178124666214,
-0.7014299035072327,
0.2525215744972229,
-0.13972215354442596,
-0.3244679570198059,
-0.032044362276792526,
0.16108065843582153,
-0.19936351478099823,
0.0934954509139061,
0.5586955547332764,
-0.42176294326782227,
-0.8580838441848755,
-0.3412919342517853,
-0.3262593448162079,
-0.526508092880249,
0.8779064416885376,
0.49701210856437683,
-0.2713870704174042,
0.21054969727993011,
-0.1418398767709732,
-0.40867888927459717,
-0.5519588589668274,
-0.7224589586257935,
-0.16866272687911987,
0.48832443356513977,
0.14562086760997772,
0.7319186329841614,
0.3435958921909332,
0.23381976783275604,
0.3651290237903595,
-0.1815914660692215,
0.04748227447271347,
-0.5212762951850891,
0.3780387043952942,
-0.28572461009025574,
-0.3123324513435364,
-0.46766921877861023,
0.10407014936208725,
0.39124736189842224,
0.5224765539169312,
-0.23945418000221252,
-0.053680505603551865,
-0.10177244246006012,
0.5649026036262512,
-0.9027817249298096,
-0.5065932869911194,
-0.6059420704841614,
0.1672239452600479,
-0.2792864739894867,
-0.0506419762969017,
-0.2639620006084442,
-0.29060471057891846,
-0.38560888171195984,
-0.7427707314491272,
0.2927679419517517,
-0.2638757526874542,
0.8124691247940063,
0.19683058559894562,
-0.045326102524995804,
0.2804187834262848,
-0.5787211656570435,
0.47453102469444275,
-0.6311990022659302,
0.47919145226478577,
0.40256476402282715,
0.19962528347969055,
-0.5187804102897644,
-0.6818341016769409,
-0.5566722750663757,
-0.21698863804340363,
0.06667240709066391,
-0.012375162914395332,
-0.6528207063674927,
0.21480201184749603,
0.20113028585910797,
0.26228460669517517,
-0.6033474206924438,
0.2836264967918396,
-0.61312335729599,
-0.6446386575698853,
0.5969534516334534,
0.20208334922790527,
0.598775327205658,
0.024596288800239563,
-0.5669132471084595,
-0.13123026490211487,
-1.0373804569244385,
0.1421358436346054,
0.5008510947227478,
0.27904582023620605,
0.2626368999481201,
0.36503246426582336,
-0.25299879908561707,
0.4574524760246277,
0.012886560522019863,
0.15801310539245605,
0.08737720549106598,
-0.1654205322265625,
-0.3872244358062744,
-0.18521811068058014,
0.6477441191673279,
0.10981318354606628,
-0.04250551760196686,
-0.5463605523109436,
-0.47983697056770325,
0.04690542444586754,
0.6954762935638428,
-1.0078133344650269,
-0.16517607867717743,
0.5002245306968689,
-0.35056766867637634,
-0.6594546437263489,
0.03079770877957344,
-0.8098719716072083,
-0.4280296862125397,
-0.08639369159936905,
0.5222373008728027,
-0.5311203598976135,
-0.17950397729873657,
0.10669942945241928,
-0.32442140579223633,
0.07076122611761093,
0.26295045018196106,
-0.48342806100845337,
0.43363630771636963,
0.7747209072113037,
0.47205182909965515,
-0.01706549897789955,
-0.19794419407844543,
-0.7737447619438171,
0.06291564553976059,
-0.6410854458808899,
0.5168704390525818,
-0.2385958731174469,
-0.21181368827819824,
0.03892508149147034,
-0.14489179849624634,
0.2802909314632416,
-0.7578216195106506,
0.25464969873428345,
-0.9021976590156555,
-0.1906682550907135,
0.15209399163722992,
-0.2774021327495575,
-0.32409417629241943,
0.43951377272605896,
-0.7033360004425049,
0.7860237956047058,
-0.0655764490365982,
-0.05356626957654953,
0.4110528230667114,
-0.4244219958782196,
-0.5334364175796509,
0.37053969502449036,
-0.012636261060833931,
-0.4841576814651489,
0.3283190131187439,
-0.01540179643779993,
0.5057739019393921,
0.3262271583080292,
0.1628398299217224,
-0.484428733587265,
-0.5972354412078857,
0.2953423857688904,
-0.5273829698562622,
1.025062084197998,
0.5353817343711853,
-0.4253704845905304,
0.10669708251953125,
-0.9217264652252197,
0.09242182970046997,
-0.133749857544899,
-0.1379537731409073,
-0.5093312859535217,
-0.1371939480304718,
-0.38551878929138184,
0.2618292570114136,
-0.2821325957775116,
-0.8783785104751587,
0.18354567885398865,
-0.5694782733917236,
0.18148037791252136,
0.8100160360336304,
0.26575544476509094,
0.42664751410484314,
0.06213273108005524,
0.3613247871398926,
0.2679411768913269,
0.2703894376754761,
-0.004689257126301527,
-0.5629121661186218,
-0.2959548830986023,
-0.7120317816734314,
-0.002792112063616514,
0.4205361604690552,
-0.6342977285385132,
0.7603124976158142,
-0.09109105914831161,
-0.36594119668006897,
-0.2499506026506424,
0.41166701912879944,
0.6802272796630859,
0.216593936085701,
0.44976744055747986,
-0.20703566074371338,
-0.09624806046485901,
-0.8755387663841248,
-0.2528351843357086,
0.18867889046669006,
-0.11934517323970795,
-0.028766056522727013,
0.5227943062782288,
-0.16021162271499634,
0.5964072942733765,
-0.4878346025943756,
-0.5061815977096558,
0.07081617414951324,
-0.15906764566898346,
0.19383473694324493,
0.4923907518386841,
0.4199812710285187,
-0.8221085667610168,
0.0548410564661026,
-0.38826626539230347,
-0.5582807660102844,
-0.04369831085205078,
0.08071720600128174,
-0.22474023699760437,
-0.1740599423646927,
0.8869871497154236,
-0.8543863296508789,
0.9966951608657837,
0.3492078483104706,
-0.6563077569007874,
0.2530612349510193,
0.12781356275081635,
0.02863098494708538,
-0.9369499087333679,
0.20753471553325653,
-0.10184455662965775,
-0.02500469796359539,
-0.8827419877052307,
0.5846725106239319,
0.002327371621504426,
-0.6817510724067688,
-0.7972514629364014,
0.85422682762146,
-0.01197571586817503,
0.3524400293827057,
-0.07258784025907516,
-0.06064087897539139,
0.26749080419540405,
0.7309740781784058,
-0.46387335658073425,
0.7449721097946167,
0.24735264480113983,
-0.7692551612854004,
0.39835402369499207,
0.30102550983428955,
-0.1370571404695511,
0.4327063262462616,
-0.5727460384368896,
0.20994704961776733,
0.3358555734157562,
0.562982976436615,
-1.3759204149246216,
-0.08822692185640335,
0.7096280455589294,
-0.4329478442668915,
0.5581762194633484,
-0.22977128624916077,
-0.4343436062335968,
-0.23192740976810455,
-0.3995237648487091,
0.5095609426498413,
0.6399086117744446,
-0.7670023441314697,
0.5076169967651367,
0.06919599324464798,
0.4002154469490051,
-0.8485932350158691,
-0.7714810371398926,
0.19001735746860504,
0.015822870656847954,
-0.7488563656806946,
0.3239023685455322,
0.1716269850730896,
-0.2632022202014923,
-0.015406742691993713,
-0.3852304518222809,
-0.19319769740104675,
0.5327807068824768,
0.4750029444694519,
0.0043460652232170105,
-0.2842234969139099,
0.024134257808327675,
0.051986582577228546,
-0.19115591049194336,
0.008068829774856567,
-0.626841127872467,
0.38274455070495605,
0.22675098478794098,
-0.6168860793113708,
-0.6449785232543945,
0.35843929648399353,
0.5990973711013794,
-0.16985024511814117,
0.4018040895462036,
0.41289761662483215,
-0.5671291947364807,
-0.45595261454582214,
-0.4393852949142456,
-0.34375911951065063,
-0.5739820599555969,
0.39341801404953003,
-0.39176222681999207,
-0.4612400531768799,
0.5296981334686279,
0.23444291949272156,
0.18572328984737396,
0.27319708466529846,
0.30944371223449707,
-0.06022307276725769,
0.6694390773773193,
0.14869102835655212,
-0.10000011324882507,
0.30255740880966187,
-0.5832732915878296,
0.3997820317745209,
-0.8641842603683472,
-0.1969609260559082,
-0.263423889875412,
-0.6158874034881592,
0.011112922802567482,
-0.15847773849964142,
-0.0757577046751976,
0.24101552367210388,
-0.3181644082069397,
0.2973869740962982,
-0.616418182849884,
0.3536413311958313,
0.5439035296440125,
0.517514705657959,
-0.08382601290941238,
0.061209630221128464,
-0.22434017062187195,
0.27339112758636475,
-0.37062668800354004,
-0.3117901086807251,
1.0295393466949463,
0.4207514226436615,
0.7958904504776001,
0.24935871362686157,
1.0724886655807495,
0.34855103492736816,
0.5613572001457214,
-0.45991334319114685,
0.7698153257369995,
-0.39825326204299927,
-0.9959737658500671,
-0.34359022974967957,
-0.09879715740680695,
-1.1637994050979614,
0.3424590528011322,
0.0961449071764946,
-0.994818925857544,
0.5141193270683289,
0.3070487380027771,
-0.7166563868522644,
0.6403940320014954,
-0.6187639236450195,
0.8136687278747559,
-0.018000608310103416,
-0.5778405666351318,
-0.21876007318496704,
-0.4516719579696655,
0.3564462661743164,
0.18554620444774628,
-0.04772627353668213,
-0.05099177733063698,
-0.05301978811621666,
0.5470361113548279,
-0.45282310247421265,
1.1226691007614136,
-0.5241223573684692,
-0.34067222476005554,
0.4579102396965027,
0.4106418192386627,
0.22170265018939972,
0.1330961138010025,
0.1775725781917572,
0.42135530710220337,
-0.5094994306564331,
-0.449577659368515,
-0.6324362754821777,
0.38214370608329773,
-0.4495297372341156,
-0.8446745872497559,
-0.12258685380220413,
-0.22393539547920227,
0.022326959297060966,
0.2716469466686249,
0.41934457421302795,
0.6119625568389893,
-0.3370204269886017,
0.1899370551109314,
0.7605469226837158,
-0.28287866711616516,
0.4657706320285797,
0.30493059754371643,
0.11963480710983276,
-0.45469599962234497,
1.084919810295105,
-0.1564531922340393,
0.1931670606136322,
0.2303970605134964,
0.2264794260263443,
-0.1986984759569168,
-0.8920031785964966,
-0.3220432996749878,
-0.24518467485904694,
-0.6635906100273132,
-0.5550922155380249,
-0.4383432865142822,
-0.30577585101127625,
-0.47005215287208557,
-0.01649102382361889,
-0.3153446614742279,
-0.2888071537017822,
-0.036598559468984604,
-0.07103642076253891,
0.048825815320014954,
0.3306671380996704,
-0.38648372888565063,
0.27928873896598816,
-0.8809415698051453,
0.7347126603126526,
0.4468636214733124,
0.39017611742019653,
-0.013193227350711823,
-0.4930550754070282,
-0.10805245488882065,
0.18222501873970032,
-0.6447730660438538,
-0.7213643193244934,
0.3734833002090454,
0.000992471817880869,
0.6271675825119019,
0.6264070868492126,
-0.12194350361824036,
0.28367888927459717,
-0.4583888053894043,
0.9952220320701599,
0.2288040667772293,
-0.5581318736076355,
0.35519519448280334,
-0.37093546986579895,
0.003957765642553568,
0.6233194470405579,
-0.039680276066064835,
-0.422610878944397,
-0.6479885578155518,
-0.7721858024597168,
-1.0136123895645142,
0.3970717191696167,
0.3340780436992645,
0.3773130178451538,
0.08929964900016785,
0.3368983864784241,
-0.03967413306236267,
0.285082072019577,
-0.4377361238002777,
-0.011829121969640255,
-0.37142547965049744,
-0.15914414823055267,
0.15169353783130646,
0.015383608639240265,
-0.7030078172683716,
-0.07175425440073013,
0.5947979688644409,
0.24491220712661743,
0.2556871175765991,
0.13834336400032043,
-0.35807204246520996,
-0.021373631432652473,
0.23588381707668304,
0.5381141304969788,
0.3402325510978699,
-0.03249497711658478,
-0.01069098711013794,
0.04378683492541313,
-0.8825770616531372,
0.6463674306869507,
0.14967629313468933,
-0.3571867346763611,
-0.2281612604856491,
0.3763596713542938,
0.35053399205207825,
0.15496473014354706,
-0.2417757362127304,
0.8437486290931702,
0.0885893926024437,
-0.2346261888742447,
-0.1453288197517395,
0.5400393605232239,
-0.43071338534355164,
0.27064716815948486,
0.48452144861221313,
0.41994181275367737,
0.316386342048645,
-0.5224959850311279,
0.5033851265907288,
0.3976408541202545,
-0.5305914878845215,
-0.38293230533599854,
0.34957125782966614,
0.44346004724502563,
-0.5716868042945862,
0.9072417616844177,
-0.3968314230442047,
-0.8301928639411926,
0.7494066953659058,
0.4105885326862335,
1.2757292985916138,
-0.3036458492279053,
-0.11664983630180359,
0.10538235306739807,
0.14409081637859344,
0.35295602679252625,
0.3013492822647095,
-0.12754541635513306,
-0.8820374608039856,
-0.2222701460123062,
-0.514462947845459,
0.08536970615386963,
0.6574751734733582,
-0.312978059053421,
-0.0187416709959507,
-0.7827767729759216,
0.17134931683540344,
-0.09059111773967743,
-0.16635021567344666,
-0.5747366547584534,
0.48240020871162415,
0.43263381719589233,
0.9899493455886841,
-0.7453896999359131,
0.42850109934806824,
0.35817912220954895,
-0.46421605348587036,
-0.7402316331863403,
0.1075572744011879,
0.31181594729423523,
-0.7538532614707947,
0.9626113176345825,
0.11156269162893295,
-0.1569872498512268,
-0.30332842469215393,
-0.8490098118782043,
-0.7363216280937195,
0.6274986267089844,
-0.04370923712849617,
-0.23466894030570984,
0.06583850085735321,
-0.27090176939964294,
0.5081692934036255,
0.03610169515013695,
-0.35850581526756287,
0.24366475641727448,
0.4865606129169464,
-0.21790093183517456,
-0.026033584028482437,
0.49677133560180664,
-0.5789620876312256,
-0.25771602988243103,
0.3850921392440796,
-0.3482104539871216,
0.5039311051368713,
-0.05249286815524101,
-0.2511904835700989,
0.40748241543769836,
0.573071300983429,
0.44257602095603943,
0.4543635845184326,
0.5092419981956482,
1.1104451417922974,
0.3565822243690491,
-0.24877294898033142,
0.996558427810669,
-0.19248247146606445,
-0.24884624779224396,
0.7389892339706421,
-0.12747526168823242,
0.6010149717330933,
0.2868252396583557,
0.06307673454284668,
0.43383824825286865,
0.3805707097053528,
-0.4180264174938202,
0.7048780918121338,
0.6433567404747009,
-0.20778805017471313,
0.032028499990701675,
0.37223851680755615,
-0.283745676279068,
0.5164429545402527,
0.5294678807258606,
0.01129182893782854,
-0.24100632965564728,
0.06357251107692719,
-0.040924906730651855,
-0.018769165500998497,
-0.2705007493495941,
0.7704958319664001,
0.058441005647182465,
-0.7020633220672607,
0.46330100297927856,
-0.28953713178634644,
0.3584563434123993,
-0.646104097366333,
-0.17349515855312347,
-0.4136159121990204,
0.48147231340408325,
-0.3379858434200287,
-0.855131208896637,
0.16337703168392181,
-0.34406644105911255,
0.14533305168151855,
0.004167920909821987,
0.8894006013870239,
-0.24444721639156342,
0.19250550866127014,
0.3272232711315155,
0.11276724189519882,
0.046879708766937256,
-0.30529993772506714,
-0.4973430335521698,
-0.24496760964393616,
-0.2000444531440735,
-0.4932498633861542,
0.20882165431976318,
0.5846017003059387,
0.004498034715652466,
0.4811193645000458,
1.1350573301315308,
0.3295512795448303,
0.11317086964845657,
0.342057466506958,
1.0835179090499878,
-0.6932507753372192,
-0.6973039507865906,
-0.7656692862510681,
0.8212792277336121,
-0.3592875003814697,
-0.6570469737052917,
0.5247476696968079,
0.47761380672454834,
0.4826472997665405,
0.19801458716392517,
0.5119532942771912,
0.22373460233211517,
0.17440220713615417,
-0.4648711383342743,
0.9640483260154724,
-0.6511500477790833,
0.26104024052619934,
-0.2651198208332062,
-0.864144504070282,
-0.35831427574157715,
0.15962214767932892,
0.12920653820037842,
-0.15111754834651947,
0.4792054295539856,
0.9539991021156311,
-0.41307100653648376,
-0.035145264118909836,
0.47867676615715027,
0.20360440015792847,
0.7421898245811462,
0.3575463891029358,
1.0321664810180664,
-0.5234407782554626,
0.7324324250221252,
-0.2784304916858673,
-0.2991621196269989,
-0.2508876621723175,
-0.5468985438346863,
-0.9101573824882507,
-0.1986069679260254,
-0.013638055883347988,
-1.0295789241790771,
0.3564835786819458,
0.5003867745399475,
0.9054524302482605,
-0.9151668548583984,
0.13939672708511353,
-0.013053239323198795,
0.10628777742385864,
-0.3620941936969757,
-0.18799333274364471,
0.4154795706272125,
-0.5031102895736694,
-0.11307547986507416,
0.5980179905891418,
0.3100430369377136,
-0.0856650248169899,
-0.27623996138572693,
0.06339728087186813,
-0.03119220957159996,
0.15582460165023804,
0.3223859369754791,
0.6419851183891296,
-0.6947997212409973,
-0.3863341808319092,
-0.032231274992227554,
-0.5811014175415039,
-0.1923161745071411,
0.848120927810669,
-0.5780844688415527,
0.22491873800754547,
0.5685309767723083,
0.8423178195953369,
0.2043331265449524,
-0.16941677033901215,
0.7029762864112854,
-1.0393450260162354,
0.5054121613502502,
0.6769950985908508,
0.33964642882347107,
-0.02008775621652603,
-0.6799440383911133,
0.4720209836959839,
0.26404961943626404,
-0.18875397741794586,
-0.8150997757911682,
0.4122738838195801,
-0.5730418562889099,
-0.7397782802581787,
1.1928186416625977,
-0.22072431445121765,
-0.44631990790367126,
-0.32214832305908203,
0.06420248746871948,
0.2529356777667999,
-0.4736481010913849,
0.8630509376525879,
0.402890682220459,
0.08368083089590073,
0.5059396028518677,
-0.11805648356676102,
0.5743603706359863,
0.28327539563179016,
-0.562808632850647,
0.02920587733387947,
0.4636106789112091,
0.3154188096523285,
0.5845829248428345,
0.37671083211898804,
-0.3400583565235138,
0.7333025932312012,
0.14004018902778625,
0.0028236922807991505,
-0.2610939145088196,
-0.5865745544433594,
-0.5285520553588867,
0.38824406266212463,
-0.6795434951782227,
-0.6745873689651489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11222v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11222v1
|
Transformer based neural networks for emotion recognition in conversations
| 2024-05-18T08:05:05 | 2024-05-18T08:05:05 |
Claudiu Creanga, Liviu P. Dinu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper outlines the approach of the ISDS-NLP team in the SemEval 2024
Task 10: Emotion Discovery and Reasoning its Flip in Conversation (EDiReF). For
Subtask 1 we obtained a weighted F1 score of 0.43 and placed 12 in the
leaderboard. We investigate two distinct approaches: Masked Language Modeling
(MLM) and Causal Language Modeling (CLM). For MLM, we employ pre-trained
BERT-like models in a multilingual setting, fine-tuning them with a classifier
to predict emotions. Experiments with varying input lengths, classifier
architectures, and fine-tuning strategies demonstrate the effectiveness of this
approach. Additionally, we utilize Mistral 7B Instruct V0.2, a state-of-the-art
model, applying zero-shot and few-shot prompting techniques. Our findings
indicate that while Mistral shows promise, MLMs currently outperform them in
sentence-level emotion classification.
|
[
-0.5347132086753845,
-0.6485603451728821,
0.2731850743293762,
0.5785561203956604,
-0.18653512001037598,
-0.09751486778259277,
-0.19043700397014618,
-0.5438791513442993,
0.37624022364616394,
0.43171608448028564,
-0.7923810482025146,
-0.39827579259872437,
-0.7172248959541321,
0.17869701981544495,
-0.49161216616630554,
0.9021928906440735,
0.03076780028641224,
0.24398155510425568,
-0.22373487055301666,
-0.34976696968078613,
-0.10739471018314362,
-0.7758755683898926,
-0.8050424456596375,
-0.7423557043075562,
0.5190281271934509,
0.3507596254348755,
0.2217225283384323,
-0.08105314522981644,
0.3616925776004791,
0.3541364073753357,
-0.28162044286727905,
-0.1469356268644333,
-0.39122506976127625,
0.33969682455062866,
0.13235050439834595,
-0.35616534948349,
-0.26024797558784485,
0.005676897708326578,
0.06810427457094193,
0.31748220324516296,
-0.12894649803638458,
-0.0691886767745018,
0.013940875418484211,
0.7796531915664673,
-0.3816610872745514,
0.4249296188354492,
-0.6001137495040894,
0.4597628712654114,
-0.009756410494446754,
-0.25752654671669006,
-0.48421281576156616,
-0.14604105055332184,
0.44194522500038147,
0.03996698558330536,
0.08201707154512405,
0.06702098995447159,
0.7128697633743286,
0.44385826587677,
-0.6692147850990295,
-0.41333988308906555,
-0.5503208041191101,
0.4885507822036743,
-0.8786242008209229,
0.3309617042541504,
0.17730961740016937,
0.08493530005216599,
0.12344221025705338,
-0.7173023223876953,
-0.5898545384407043,
0.10025286674499512,
-0.06974086165428162,
0.43599313497543335,
-0.6467828154563904,
0.3004706799983978,
0.4124634265899658,
0.23503881692886353,
-0.5309793949127197,
0.15215587615966797,
-0.196262389421463,
0.030210237950086594,
0.7113215923309326,
0.28112560510635376,
0.002935446100309491,
-0.13982389867305756,
-0.48134851455688477,
-0.004088247194886208,
-0.6422962546348572,
0.3047854006290436,
0.4806133210659027,
0.17485815286636353,
-0.011467356234788895,
0.2291647344827652,
-0.19660913944244385,
0.22052475810050964,
0.23929859697818756,
0.34595566987991333,
0.24593065679073334,
0.2504989206790924,
-0.5066166520118713,
0.14944694936275482,
0.9212443232536316,
0.3678087592124939,
0.34160879254341125,
0.1690780222415924,
-0.06418251991271973,
-0.017683139070868492,
0.39461615681648254,
-0.86337810754776,
-0.21115946769714355,
0.32883670926094055,
-0.5072453618049622,
-0.4816356599330902,
-0.0996650978922844,
-1.0718458890914917,
-0.6511144638061523,
-0.2519336938858032,
0.446279913187027,
-0.2080097794532776,
-0.30621033906936646,
0.0363471545279026,
0.08148936182260513,
0.3778143525123596,
0.3726781904697418,
-0.8002053499221802,
0.45303207635879517,
0.4613947868347168,
0.49040311574935913,
-0.27978840470314026,
-0.004232275299727917,
-0.12005838751792908,
-0.6447182297706604,
-0.10093576461076736,
0.6316239237785339,
-0.3792650103569031,
-0.3424476683139801,
0.2913718521595001,
0.17551469802856445,
-0.1911235749721527,
-0.5677907466888428,
0.817886471748352,
-0.4550389349460602,
0.4210329055786133,
-0.09955505281686783,
-0.4918331801891327,
-0.6315849423408508,
0.37597334384918213,
-0.5972921252250671,
1.262885570526123,
-0.05585579201579094,
-0.7716463804244995,
-0.22972795367240906,
-0.6944414377212524,
-0.5538431406021118,
0.05701463297009468,
0.004394060000777245,
-0.5976016521453857,
0.23311734199523926,
0.11893093585968018,
0.6513014435768127,
-0.24448072910308838,
0.4023574888706207,
-0.15046176314353943,
-0.15689446032047272,
0.29115214943885803,
-0.6000246405601501,
0.5090412497520447,
0.1811470240354538,
-0.7994818091392517,
0.240070179104805,
-0.7128855586051941,
-0.1547517478466034,
-0.020930161699652672,
-0.03265226259827614,
-0.03518635034561157,
-0.04732838273048401,
0.1692626029253006,
0.553507387638092,
-0.07953010499477386,
-0.5091019868850708,
-0.199392631649971,
-0.39434918761253357,
0.3294893801212311,
0.8065195679664612,
-0.08791918307542801,
0.3292709290981293,
0.31432387232780457,
0.666961669921875,
0.5076884031295776,
0.14080946147441864,
-0.2524459660053253,
-0.5183728337287903,
-1.452383041381836,
0.24618034064769745,
0.07547427713871002,
0.5710745453834534,
-0.6845874786376953,
0.446842223405838,
0.14158445596694946,
-0.560100793838501,
-0.5515016317367554,
-0.44546231627464294,
0.29649266600608826,
0.7319197654724121,
0.38538888096809387,
-0.008589282631874084,
-0.5834856629371643,
-0.9725003242492676,
-0.22209079563617706,
-0.1821628212928772,
0.30991774797439575,
0.6382244825363159,
0.33138006925582886,
-0.3618393540382385,
0.48334240913391113,
-0.22916506230831146,
-0.040676943957805634,
-0.30861279368400574,
0.5944225788116455,
0.0939776673913002,
0.24652422964572906,
0.28473567962646484,
-0.8411253690719604,
-0.560527503490448,
-0.05606552213430405,
-0.7891795039176941,
-0.4545566737651825,
-0.04410580173134804,
0.16916044056415558,
0.39201387763023376,
0.6609881520271301,
-0.4297585189342499,
0.7797696590423584,
0.5841756463050842,
-0.3801218271255493,
0.15809620916843414,
0.11673267185688019,
0.27765214443206787,
-0.9060620069503784,
-0.18665236234664917,
0.211399108171463,
-0.30032309889793396,
-1.0946568250656128,
-0.5281051397323608,
0.11790677905082703,
-0.19843700528144836,
-0.6588019728660583,
0.43469375371932983,
-0.19009098410606384,
0.03474780172109604,
-0.4069034457206726,
-0.17888982594013214,
-0.10034500062465668,
0.9303202033042908,
0.4049042761325836,
0.168111652135849,
0.4052380919456482,
-0.4018203616142273,
0.6372583508491516,
0.05584295466542244,
-0.24969905614852905,
0.657634437084198,
-0.7423951029777527,
0.20679646730422974,
-0.24779164791107178,
0.2355063259601593,
-0.9242374300956726,
-0.014033865183591843,
0.16726922988891602,
-0.3467997610569,
0.38364177942276,
0.11620617657899857,
0.016216188669204712,
-0.5069288015365601,
-0.06051768735051155,
0.2006649523973465,
0.5103906989097595,
-0.6323907971382141,
1.0004621744155884,
0.20106621086597443,
-0.4630201458930969,
-0.4711012840270996,
-0.5484694242477417,
0.25271981954574585,
-0.41672152280807495,
-0.5819366574287415,
0.20262151956558228,
-0.05455341190099716,
-0.1436755657196045,
-0.26608332991600037,
0.013819392770528793,
0.0932871624827385,
0.14898455142974854,
0.7257792949676514,
0.09804551303386688,
0.017193060368299484,
0.25086867809295654,
0.04615338146686554,
-0.2585049867630005,
0.31801390647888184,
0.1800953596830368,
0.47221288084983826,
-0.4424651861190796,
-0.3023965358734131,
-0.3917691111564636,
0.44152140617370605,
0.5683398842811584,
-0.10573653876781464,
0.6169288158416748,
0.7718240022659302,
-0.585053026676178,
-0.37449201941490173,
-0.5169727802276611,
-0.27714860439300537,
-0.43553879857063293,
0.4902084767818451,
-0.35033726692199707,
-1.113283395767212,
0.6603533625602722,
-0.40817028284072876,
-0.31666630506515503,
0.4704049527645111,
0.9080468416213989,
-0.3062814176082611,
1.091790795326233,
0.6511428952217102,
-0.06438247859477997,
0.4878539741039276,
-0.026753701269626617,
0.6463673114776611,
-0.6449407935142517,
-0.4633084535598755,
-0.5144277215003967,
-0.6364713311195374,
-0.5308042168617249,
-0.10708683729171753,
0.5038024187088013,
0.024287264794111252,
-0.14086848497390747,
0.24860796332359314,
-0.2874366343021393,
0.38758403062820435,
0.4876822829246521,
-0.034748733043670654,
-0.16314758360385895,
-0.33859017491340637,
0.14547663927078247,
-0.2211213856935501,
-0.6298742890357971,
-0.3101655840873718,
0.5751717686653137,
0.6825754642486572,
0.7913055419921875,
-0.1569077968597412,
0.5702987313270569,
0.24629327654838562,
0.4452524781227112,
-1.096948266029358,
0.5449216365814209,
0.05087435618042946,
-0.3906349539756775,
-0.20701052248477936,
-0.23299607634544373,
-0.6567981243133545,
0.272344708442688,
-0.1481539011001587,
-0.8054234981536865,
0.30328795313835144,
-0.09981126338243484,
-0.1785455197095871,
0.11110255867242813,
-0.6619886159896851,
0.9154616594314575,
-0.21497918665409088,
0.016805345192551613,
-0.01004899013787508,
-0.8925889730453491,
0.2563501000404358,
0.07253990322351456,
0.033998534083366394,
-0.07173634320497513,
0.5644364356994629,
0.7566640377044678,
-0.4283219873905182,
0.9102004170417786,
-0.22462905943393707,
0.023672576993703842,
0.19035831093788147,
-0.0013433981221169233,
0.5736084580421448,
-0.17266897857189178,
-0.08750153332948685,
0.24523033201694489,
-0.16165171563625336,
0.04699923098087311,
-0.8328523635864258,
0.5440356135368347,
-0.645015299320221,
-0.5179303884506226,
-0.5593218207359314,
-0.3222667872905731,
-0.2142767608165741,
-0.15738674998283386,
0.4424617290496826,
0.28121569752693176,
-0.3190317153930664,
0.24596557021141052,
0.8802230358123779,
-0.4262634515762329,
0.6730678081512451,
0.6765154600143433,
-0.05405830964446068,
-0.30258846282958984,
0.5831453204154968,
-0.08878660947084427,
0.05542856454849243,
0.3400917053222656,
0.20880281925201416,
-0.3392821252346039,
-0.07014752179384232,
-0.23410820960998535,
-0.17686727643013,
-0.8168368935585022,
-0.5705204606056213,
-0.9405107498168945,
-0.44837093353271484,
-0.46648189425468445,
-0.02300204336643219,
-0.4167972803115845,
-0.32124507427215576,
-0.40893059968948364,
-0.37234756350517273,
0.41255664825439453,
0.7770079374313354,
0.04812910407781601,
0.14368537068367004,
-0.6211082339286804,
-0.01673070900142193,
0.4493646025657654,
0.2691078186035156,
0.04910745099186897,
-0.7126085758209229,
-0.2147420197725296,
-0.08120860159397125,
-0.3368809223175049,
-0.9123243689537048,
0.8221843838691711,
0.2743185758590698,
0.24268671870231628,
0.5741849541664124,
0.20215767621994019,
0.4021410346031189,
-0.48254895210266113,
0.9412593841552734,
0.21012167632579803,
-1.2235461473464966,
0.54166179895401,
-0.012678088620305061,
0.15316720306873322,
0.2711929380893707,
0.5696216225624084,
-0.8707218170166016,
-0.2026110291481018,
-0.7860432863235474,
-0.6960771083831787,
0.9069926738739014,
0.2136235386133194,
0.27768397331237793,
0.010847645811736584,
0.07001753896474838,
-0.054217442870140076,
0.3083809018135071,
-0.842083752155304,
-0.4670097231864929,
-0.2639431953430176,
-0.7698993682861328,
0.07453165203332901,
-0.4059657156467438,
0.016428746283054352,
-0.040362074971199036,
0.6907824277877808,
-0.10853080451488495,
0.506668210029602,
0.15094563364982605,
-0.06744507700204849,
-0.2514961063861847,
0.2684623599052429,
0.8022117018699646,
-0.20991641283035278,
-0.21690411865711212,
0.3996312916278839,
0.28367459774017334,
-0.3032427728176117,
0.006330842152237892,
0.12674403190612793,
0.1754591464996338,
0.15633369982242584,
0.22871166467666626,
1.3891719579696655,
0.2130773514509201,
-0.5539615750312805,
0.8366584181785583,
-0.19466429948806763,
-0.29881471395492554,
-0.2826581597328186,
-0.3217434585094452,
0.1787039190530777,
0.7858679890632629,
0.18476170301437378,
0.06065572053194046,
0.28894445300102234,
-0.4256879985332489,
0.068239226937294,
0.2680599093437195,
-0.9947974681854248,
-0.6003161668777466,
0.483400821685791,
0.40574410557746887,
-0.6087796688079834,
0.5376860499382019,
-0.12653830647468567,
-1.2562792301177979,
0.7091891765594482,
0.49007365107536316,
1.2671434879302979,
-0.49086299538612366,
0.30619943141937256,
0.1434955894947052,
0.13704682886600494,
-0.00545202661305666,
0.3858071565628052,
-0.002354753902181983,
-0.9812473654747009,
0.06813716143369675,
-0.47841739654541016,
-0.6222077012062073,
0.08747359365224838,
-0.7271589636802673,
0.3134269416332245,
-0.16282223165035248,
-0.05631626397371292,
-0.10109557211399078,
-0.2894112765789032,
-0.7883926630020142,
0.44351592659950256,
0.5458554625511169,
0.744665801525116,
-1.0097317695617676,
0.6798350811004639,
0.5207814574241638,
-0.2356255054473877,
-0.7001429200172424,
-0.35995709896087646,
0.157265305519104,
-0.6146306395530701,
0.8628782033920288,
0.34303829073905945,
0.13198542594909668,
0.10201026499271393,
-0.6145614385604858,
-0.2935696244239807,
1.0342884063720703,
0.051202114671468735,
-0.34286409616470337,
0.2558938264846802,
0.2845267057418823,
0.8387885093688965,
-0.46781980991363525,
0.6878354549407959,
0.3696451187133789,
0.22533376514911652,
0.23286250233650208,
-0.7566202878952026,
-0.39874932169914246,
-0.5161306262016296,
-0.10198521614074707,
0.20332317054271698,
-0.6601515412330627,
0.7162438631057739,
0.14255256950855255,
-0.21444322168827057,
-0.325551837682724,
0.7267695069313049,
-0.028007151558995247,
0.5909897089004517,
0.4806334972381592,
0.7455977201461792,
0.5961995124816895,
-0.3684334456920624,
0.733680009841919,
-0.24764879047870636,
0.38788577914237976,
0.9058777689933777,
-0.44536513090133667,
0.8425787687301636,
0.4356459975242615,
-0.2417677789926529,
0.5500145554542542,
0.7724192142486572,
0.26031383872032166,
0.42815741896629333,
0.34542718529701233,
-0.43712449073791504,
-0.12798938155174255,
-0.2932654321193695,
-0.009724125266075134,
0.46643930673599243,
0.4503736197948456,
-0.452210009098053,
-0.031059784814715385,
0.42240646481513977,
0.03034379333257675,
-0.23126663267612457,
-0.28659945726394653,
0.992389976978302,
0.41139090061187744,
-0.5082528591156006,
0.2614254951477051,
-0.06252717971801758,
0.7991393208503723,
-0.2836877405643463,
-0.016013195738196373,
-0.47428661584854126,
-0.005446985829621553,
-0.27764055132865906,
-0.6827717423439026,
0.20791156589984894,
0.14861170947551727,
-0.06335265934467316,
-0.5741809010505676,
0.9606356024742126,
-0.8558918833732605,
-0.3597494959831238,
0.3357335329055786,
0.4218897223472595,
0.2062484174966812,
-0.3088739216327667,
-0.743198573589325,
0.07493892312049866,
-0.03190404921770096,
-0.6442802548408508,
0.10386674851179123,
0.7844400405883789,
0.035790469497442245,
0.631463885307312,
0.05638289079070091,
-0.3424568772315979,
0.053066644817590714,
0.547462522983551,
0.6669321656227112,
-0.7160802483558655,
-0.29876023530960083,
-0.8522253036499023,
0.5603736042976379,
0.047472015023231506,
-0.2172103375196457,
0.38881057500839233,
0.10511165112257004,
0.5155979990959167,
-0.1892625391483307,
0.5753039717674255,
0.17278820276260376,
0.422453373670578,
-0.29723110795021057,
0.44180428981781006,
-0.34430548548698425,
0.0021963603794574738,
-0.48328593373298645,
-0.7531783580780029,
-0.25837260484695435,
0.6162521243095398,
-0.17691835761070251,
-0.10754269361495972,
0.7441111207008362,
0.7242912650108337,
0.24698644876480103,
0.4920477271080017,
0.5085825324058533,
0.15435203909873962,
0.37909412384033203,
0.7652114629745483,
0.9032320976257324,
-0.6914839744567871,
0.27371451258659363,
-0.24781769514083862,
-0.005056567024439573,
-0.32775312662124634,
-0.9384403824806213,
-0.8531634211540222,
-0.7613630890846252,
-0.4705997705459595,
-0.34233391284942627,
-0.36803287267684937,
0.9580918550491333,
0.39156097173690796,
-0.9985507726669312,
-0.0514201782643795,
-0.2074529230594635,
0.02764146961271763,
0.137161985039711,
-0.2671627998352051,
0.10110627114772797,
-0.28541868925094604,
-0.8346388936042786,
0.2380436360836029,
0.7016763091087341,
0.11456208676099777,
-0.21546345949172974,
-0.26429495215415955,
-0.23829533159732819,
0.22062449157238007,
0.764543354511261,
0.06455748528242111,
-0.665178656578064,
-0.32147252559661865,
0.20304903388023376,
-0.16059774160385132,
0.052023813128471375,
0.7936782240867615,
-0.6764048337936401,
0.535732090473175,
0.5424055457115173,
0.8398603796958923,
0.659241795539856,
-0.014563010074198246,
0.5539399981498718,
-0.6654191613197327,
0.1514827460050583,
0.46879842877388,
0.5386192202568054,
0.31337258219718933,
-0.3469941020011902,
0.6307735443115234,
0.21147651970386505,
-0.6785758137702942,
-0.6345019340515137,
0.2567862868309021,
-0.9207355976104736,
0.10805641114711761,
1.0633041858673096,
-0.36524346470832825,
-0.09385014325380325,
0.14896073937416077,
-0.3076741397380829,
0.2734585702419281,
-0.26755914092063904,
0.7582666873931885,
0.980559766292572,
-0.42991626262664795,
-0.6917586326599121,
-0.1595057100057602,
0.7060815095901489,
0.6169640421867371,
-0.9910022020339966,
-0.1224360316991806,
0.22005337476730347,
-0.26635804772377014,
0.08730965852737427,
0.5040820240974426,
-0.11193576455116272,
-0.12064764648675919,
-0.27582094073295593,
0.2634076178073883,
0.2304563671350479,
-0.16569361090660095,
-0.8153991103172302,
-0.07918494194746017,
-0.3641650676727295,
0.15277715027332306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11219v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11219v1
|
Identifying and Aligning Medical Claims Made on Social Media with Medical Evidence
| 2024-05-18T07:50:43 | 2024-05-18T07:50:43 |
Anthony Hughes, Xingyi Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Evidence-based medicine is the practice of making medical decisions that
adhere to the latest, and best known evidence at that time. Currently, the best
evidence is often found in the form of documents, such as randomized control
trials, meta-analyses and systematic reviews. This research focuses on aligning
medical claims made on social media platforms with this medical evidence. By
doing so, individuals without medical expertise can more effectively assess the
veracity of such medical claims. We study three core tasks: identifying medical
claims, extracting medical vocabulary from these claims, and retrieving
evidence relevant to those identified medical claims. We propose a novel system
that can generate synthetic medical claims to aid each of these core tasks. We
additionally introduce a novel dataset produced by our synthetic generator
that, when applied to these tasks, demonstrates not only a more flexible and
holistic approach, but also an improvement in all comparable metrics. We make
our dataset, the Expansive Medical Claim Corpus (EMCC), available at
https://zenodo.org/records/8321460
|
[
0.12135373055934906,
-0.7532102465629578,
0.7680662274360657,
0.1024809256196022,
-0.26475974917411804,
0.3052997291088104,
-0.2686941921710968,
-0.7040411233901978,
1.0635707378387451,
0.13087497651576996,
-0.3017076551914215,
-0.587650716304779,
-0.7428420186042786,
0.1894427090883255,
-0.16355139017105103,
0.8608649969100952,
-0.14389847218990326,
0.5249001979827881,
-0.17666466534137726,
-0.3148076832294464,
-0.38353395462036133,
-0.06955152750015259,
-0.5286765694618225,
-0.18794509768486023,
0.755287230014801,
0.3087063431739807,
0.49146151542663574,
0.6154519319534302,
0.5528658032417297,
0.19939114153385162,
0.48342621326446533,
0.6671673655509949,
-0.11109298467636108,
0.08323460817337036,
-0.5146315097808838,
-0.1362658441066742,
-0.4339361786842346,
-0.1645839959383011,
0.2720363438129425,
0.43708536028862,
-0.1746167242527008,
0.3980657458305359,
-0.08337066322565079,
0.37308749556541443,
-0.5934845805168152,
-0.2609775960445404,
-0.6814764142036438,
0.12151745706796646,
-0.13257093727588654,
-0.5100149512290955,
-0.08796468377113342,
-0.5492508411407471,
0.029097096994519234,
-0.7060630917549133,
0.4693130552768707,
-0.08464152365922928,
1.0658206939697266,
0.1955808699131012,
-0.4466131031513214,
-0.44185394048690796,
-0.6715430617332458,
0.3421526551246643,
-0.8482088446617126,
0.03688471391797066,
0.2579064667224884,
0.6868245005607605,
-0.030360519886016846,
-0.7227658629417419,
-0.5946604609489441,
0.17662440240383148,
-0.14176923036575317,
0.1612522453069687,
0.011718234978616238,
-0.10265418142080307,
0.0638907179236412,
0.4400263726711273,
-0.5259551405906677,
-0.014211601577699184,
-0.41690120100975037,
-0.3920290470123291,
0.866488516330719,
-0.04659286513924599,
0.6915470957756042,
-0.2503121793270111,
-0.05796133726835251,
0.21813157200813293,
-0.7297325134277344,
-0.3181057572364807,
-0.06779947131872177,
0.2705315351486206,
-0.1698334962129593,
1.1331862211227417,
-0.25154805183410645,
0.4214855432510376,
0.19058653712272644,
-0.29629793763160706,
0.32102781534194946,
-0.3009563982486725,
-0.14531858265399933,
0.5214199423789978,
0.9264792799949646,
0.8133899569511414,
-0.10800076276063919,
0.13961434364318848,
-0.05965424329042435,
0.4238939583301544,
0.5610774159431458,
-0.5950573682785034,
-0.04335198923945427,
0.4718332886695862,
-0.8766657114028931,
-0.5101117491722107,
0.14287006855010986,
-0.49247458577156067,
-0.8492316603660583,
-0.20360535383224487,
0.4692555069923401,
-0.49838316440582275,
-0.37031522393226624,
-0.035348307341337204,
-0.33275356888771057,
-0.14440400898456573,
0.23601044714450836,
-0.6232935190200806,
0.27769914269447327,
0.6616237163543701,
0.9330512881278992,
0.04744509235024452,
0.48198890686035156,
-0.22084152698516846,
0.35724544525146484,
-0.6109161376953125,
1.09103524684906,
-0.31623414158821106,
-0.11825533956289291,
0.4256870150566101,
0.22221221029758453,
0.04656772315502167,
-0.6848427653312683,
0.8359853029251099,
-0.20860712230205536,
0.10892320424318314,
-0.5361430644989014,
-0.7629167437553406,
0.05776258930563927,
0.36209505796432495,
-0.7107306122779846,
0.6268166303634644,
-0.11182679980993271,
-0.7024727463722229,
0.543129563331604,
-0.4398965835571289,
-0.5038239359855652,
0.24021409451961517,
-0.7096123099327087,
-0.4090574085712433,
0.37877553701400757,
0.2039203941822052,
0.38559937477111816,
-0.35380998253822327,
0.44781070947647095,
-0.4805954694747925,
0.07211285084486008,
0.3577418923377991,
0.03625725209712982,
0.6554522514343262,
0.3696495294570923,
-0.21637915074825287,
-0.007638382725417614,
-0.7797483205795288,
-0.13329188525676727,
0.29874101281166077,
-0.21330182254314423,
-0.7191950678825378,
0.3259246349334717,
-0.024054894223809242,
0.20011582970619202,
0.16863039135932922,
-1.1435606479644775,
0.23499849438667297,
-0.30583006143569946,
0.3829702138900757,
0.46638593077659607,
0.20671220123767853,
0.07455938309431076,
-0.838630735874176,
0.2341744601726532,
-0.29828667640686035,
0.05014858394861221,
0.13772641122341156,
-0.45545661449432373,
-0.09667322784662247,
-0.3753141462802887,
0.5373115539550781,
0.2626572847366333,
-0.7472482919692993,
0.49810659885406494,
-0.5891007781028748,
-0.5159162282943726,
-0.8490256071090698,
-0.032254528254270554,
0.1179576888680458,
0.6594826579093933,
0.4796871840953827,
-0.08056244254112244,
-0.7156984210014343,
-1.1015516519546509,
-0.6006232500076294,
-0.10911386460065842,
-0.2513670325279236,
0.27519482374191284,
0.20978590846061707,
-0.31581708788871765,
0.8629946112632751,
-0.4286927282810211,
-0.4597594738006592,
-0.004293080884963274,
0.044452864676713943,
0.11097705364227295,
0.42208224534988403,
0.4027019441127777,
-0.8407146334648132,
-0.6550748944282532,
0.295670747756958,
-0.8846185803413391,
-0.48018428683280945,
-0.22894278168678284,
-0.11162963509559631,
0.11020974814891815,
0.1658674031496048,
-0.7324320673942566,
0.309333473443985,
0.41008439660072327,
-0.24463710188865662,
0.20158857107162476,
-0.04250733554363251,
0.22891589999198914,
-1.3218777179718018,
0.08826733380556107,
0.3085725009441376,
-0.3122209906578064,
-0.3229193091392517,
-0.4227551221847534,
0.16055238246917725,
0.1756337434053421,
-0.141905277967453,
0.6024602651596069,
-0.31401824951171875,
0.30763041973114014,
-0.36191102862358093,
-0.15428954362869263,
-0.009852753952145576,
-0.34233394265174866,
-0.13504965603351593,
-0.05061694607138634,
0.34263765811920166,
-0.3313383162021637,
0.12127815186977386,
0.2831955552101135,
-0.2948724329471588,
0.8712270259857178,
-0.5416653752326965,
-0.1642303764820099,
-0.06871367990970612,
0.3046182096004486,
-0.8069263100624084,
-0.8444706797599792,
0.37060293555259705,
-0.8374262452125549,
0.1830926090478897,
-0.03721196576952934,
-0.3739388585090637,
-0.4539313018321991,
-0.17346462607383728,
0.20209452509880066,
0.27117592096328735,
-0.4569714069366455,
0.851656973361969,
0.8475250601768494,
-0.4173715114593506,
-0.42139074206352234,
-0.3818013668060303,
0.2025851458311081,
-0.1640465259552002,
-0.4011699855327606,
0.9607916474342346,
0.499343603849411,
-0.42760151624679565,
0.29401805996894836,
-0.30799469351768494,
-0.018209414556622505,
-0.5593164563179016,
0.2958802282810211,
0.24271517992019653,
-0.18675817549228668,
0.4980897307395935,
0.4129651188850403,
0.3241333067417145,
0.25683870911598206,
0.037647049874067307,
0.277530699968338,
0.21568632125854492,
-0.5276824831962585,
-0.40224626660346985,
0.5770061016082764,
0.4001430869102478,
0.15563467144966125,
0.4808904528617859,
0.30706098675727844,
-1.0297200679779053,
-0.1181277483701706,
-0.9186988472938538,
-0.0941481739282608,
-0.4205404222011566,
-0.044151999056339264,
0.18014729022979736,
-0.4750145375728607,
0.4657290577888489,
-0.028240716084837914,
0.4880267381668091,
0.837092936038971,
0.7342444062232971,
-0.30723199248313904,
1.2121738195419312,
0.08097846060991287,
0.4989420473575592,
0.13486990332603455,
0.06557867676019669,
0.08046926558017731,
-0.39274081587791443,
-0.4296795725822449,
-0.09802085161209106,
-0.3817688226699829,
-0.5428322553634644,
-0.44575709104537964,
0.3433912396430969,
-0.5149037837982178,
-0.07452338933944702,
0.2619172930717468,
-0.7718159556388855,
0.19423402845859528,
0.3195926249027252,
0.7561110258102417,
0.3827093243598938,
0.1410515010356903,
-0.17538860440254211,
-0.007472679018974304,
-0.7585658431053162,
-0.58092200756073,
1.226563572883606,
0.34396567940711975,
0.5163581371307373,
0.10066420584917068,
0.7763062119483948,
0.5962716341018677,
0.9267924427986145,
-0.7873637676239014,
0.3899261951446533,
-0.08921347558498383,
-1.0035457611083984,
0.28214123845100403,
-0.49408137798309326,
-0.9224870800971985,
0.03629250079393387,
-0.8812965750694275,
-0.17146915197372437,
0.03497125953435898,
0.23160849511623383,
-0.7035470008850098,
0.25789135694503784,
-0.66199791431427,
0.3606693148612976,
-0.606111466884613,
-0.34285998344421387,
-0.4108313024044037,
-0.7725160717964172,
0.3248538076877594,
-0.23688216507434845,
0.30303096771240234,
-0.25298571586608887,
0.07848723977804184,
0.7678692936897278,
-0.7202562093734741,
0.7734671831130981,
-0.37855568528175354,
0.15099075436592102,
0.3105800449848175,
-0.3277842402458191,
-0.051270779222249985,
0.14971143007278442,
0.23716320097446442,
0.07572752237319946,
0.4864313006401062,
-0.4103524088859558,
-0.5223656296730042,
0.7132022976875305,
-0.30261483788490295,
-0.35587745904922485,
-0.5759875774383545,
-0.2978137731552124,
-0.13499708473682404,
0.3428744375705719,
0.1570192575454712,
0.27255526185035706,
-0.7562114000320435,
0.12571720778942108,
0.3232665956020355,
-0.453424870967865,
0.025261828675866127,
0.5894704461097717,
-0.07644418627023697,
-0.7972818613052368,
0.7367275357246399,
0.3807280659675598,
-0.14671269059181213,
0.19877409934997559,
0.5191437602043152,
-0.4406004548072815,
-0.4237859547138214,
-0.3067559003829956,
0.4436139762401581,
-0.46320703625679016,
-0.3949340581893921,
-0.745284914970398,
-0.1283041536808014,
-0.6481190323829651,
-0.11660773307085037,
-0.3477850556373596,
-0.41703665256500244,
0.32308584451675415,
-0.10600297152996063,
0.29689517617225647,
0.6748654842376709,
-0.19865529239177704,
0.19863413274288177,
-1.034238576889038,
0.6406868696212769,
-0.05730217695236206,
0.33195000886917114,
-0.386271595954895,
0.11402730643749237,
-0.26537400484085083,
0.3522287607192993,
-0.4119459092617035,
-1.031175971031189,
0.22455206513404846,
0.15562979876995087,
0.560836911201477,
0.7573649287223816,
0.31607240438461304,
0.7449870109558105,
-0.7044006586074829,
0.43841007351875305,
0.5275813937187195,
-0.4650605022907257,
0.5870862603187561,
-0.481349915266037,
-0.35356640815734863,
0.7829393148422241,
0.6501006484031677,
-0.4514569640159607,
-0.1127849742770195,
-0.886608362197876,
-0.5974997878074646,
-0.13476018607616425,
0.1405126005411148,
-0.018408717587590218,
-0.364729106426239,
0.285374253988266,
0.08926872909069061,
0.003842256497591734,
-0.29541832208633423,
0.16807936131954193,
-0.03617708757519722,
-0.8329728841781616,
0.4478415250778198,
0.1863720864057541,
-0.7645937204360962,
-0.3366530239582062,
0.5928894281387329,
-0.2543250322341919,
0.29845377802848816,
0.6653842926025391,
-0.09543081372976303,
-0.26678624749183655,
0.05090835690498352,
0.3204124867916107,
0.6515616178512573,
-0.09123395383358002,
0.3215976655483246,
-0.032467857003211975,
-0.38693445920944214,
-0.07145132124423981,
0.27373433113098145,
-0.06670481711626053,
0.5762526392936707,
0.3565094769001007,
0.11190348863601685,
0.03566882759332657,
-0.9987797141075134,
0.5215557813644409,
-0.09760481864213943,
-0.37458565831184387,
-0.6013445258140564,
-0.19414427876472473,
0.10566256195306778,
0.17662014067173004,
0.4126836657524109,
0.1899193823337555,
0.18937580287456512,
-0.5442894101142883,
0.38504430651664734,
0.5820222496986389,
-0.2687631845474243,
-0.26095855236053467,
0.6272183656692505,
0.24707409739494324,
-0.3745931386947632,
0.172332301735878,
0.382055401802063,
-0.09181150048971176,
0.4683094620704651,
0.37269917130470276,
0.5355377793312073,
-0.22505512833595276,
0.4144306778907776,
0.5683150291442871,
-0.031583525240421295,
-0.31947723031044006,
0.2669917047023773,
0.13159482181072235,
-0.7183826565742493,
-0.579606294631958,
-0.3774355351924896,
-0.2973271906375885,
-0.043227069079875946,
-0.5518330931663513,
0.4382455348968506,
-0.45267245173454285,
-0.6754077076911926,
0.6074534058570862,
-0.121586374938488,
-0.30888909101486206,
0.22645430266857147,
0.14291730523109436,
0.6728041768074036,
-1.0307259559631348,
0.571600615978241,
0.8872816562652588,
-0.27896881103515625,
-0.7261693477630615,
-0.0329444594681263,
0.4992313086986542,
-0.8192506432533264,
0.10181532800197601,
0.28988316655158997,
0.02813851460814476,
-0.45019814372062683,
-0.722649097442627,
-0.3938812017440796,
1.0740495920181274,
0.3627305030822754,
-0.34027838706970215,
-0.19585798680782318,
0.15322065353393555,
0.7174580097198486,
-0.8274897933006287,
-0.09452405571937561,
0.05439857393503189,
0.13977710902690887,
0.2647619843482971,
-0.747368574142456,
0.4059503674507141,
-0.5569888949394226,
-0.24276483058929443,
-0.030296647921204567,
-0.3582400977611542,
0.1520373672246933,
-0.40123528242111206,
-0.5301399230957031,
-0.06497492641210556,
0.2886207103729248,
0.5407164692878723,
0.757219672203064,
0.4718027710914612,
0.5406830310821533,
0.8137180805206299,
0.02858649380505085,
0.9710525870323181,
-0.3364454209804535,
0.18810880184173584,
0.9744665026664734,
-0.4009113013744354,
0.692796528339386,
0.5345954895019531,
0.15364588797092438,
0.6882668733596802,
1.005331039428711,
-0.1831241250038147,
0.38740503787994385,
-0.03795788809657097,
-0.45504650473594666,
-0.17038679122924805,
-0.49489519000053406,
-0.3873189687728882,
0.04509243741631508,
0.5850874185562134,
-1.012581706047058,
-0.09814489632844925,
-0.24597761034965515,
0.17888988554477692,
0.05063796415925026,
-0.17280209064483643,
0.9797600507736206,
0.1730661690235138,
-0.9056844115257263,
0.4298989772796631,
-0.24669355154037476,
0.33400455117225647,
-0.4517157971858978,
-0.4275887906551361,
0.3490484058856964,
0.13570630550384521,
-0.7464972734451294,
-0.5697855353355408,
0.6409273743629456,
0.015693556517362595,
0.03306831791996956,
-0.09384585171937943,
1.1422624588012695,
-0.5738793015480042,
-0.6377500891685486,
-0.04340513423085213,
0.5544688701629639,
-0.12636299431324005,
0.1427401900291443,
-0.7244422435760498,
-0.2449040710926056,
-0.2443499118089676,
0.1762591302394867,
0.09250083565711975,
0.4799838662147522,
-0.10141019523143768,
0.32473185658454895,
0.8384332656860352,
0.671707808971405,
-0.25971749424934387,
0.0005255048745311797,
0.8259785175323486,
-0.39118069410324097,
-0.16649968922138214,
-0.9121755361557007,
0.2506099045276642,
-0.6708871126174927,
-0.04823444038629532,
0.7109037637710571,
0.7367327213287354,
0.4279479682445526,
-0.03859939053654671,
1.0041911602020264,
-0.554203987121582,
0.92702317237854,
-0.4488154947757721,
0.9769132137298584,
-0.7708068490028381,
0.01808258704841137,
-0.16890345513820648,
-0.3532927334308624,
-0.3179275095462799,
0.5227283239364624,
-0.16386198997497559,
-0.3254294991493225,
0.7562571167945862,
0.7577918171882629,
-0.028590871021151543,
0.10112671554088593,
-0.2205233871936798,
0.13890598714351654,
0.29093635082244873,
0.23073816299438477,
0.6767533421516418,
-0.29243141412734985,
0.12575937807559967,
-0.08665873855352402,
-0.41099199652671814,
-0.2744211256504059,
-0.608396589756012,
-0.6247156262397766,
-0.40146610140800476,
-0.4200480282306671,
-0.9368203282356262,
-0.07245689630508423,
1.4073636531829834,
0.5210703015327454,
-0.7137385606765747,
0.3170483708381653,
0.006820262875407934,
-0.19547638297080994,
-0.5314138531684875,
-0.19505521655082703,
0.48196256160736084,
0.021525369957089424,
-0.36619502305984497,
0.18982182443141937,
0.1044376865029335,
-0.1855452060699463,
0.17589949071407318,
-0.03269103169441223,
-0.34567034244537354,
0.13529804348945618,
0.5165883302688599,
0.5003183484077454,
-0.566403329372406,
-0.1848028600215912,
0.2560805678367615,
-0.19183650612831116,
0.2626533806324005,
1.08291494846344,
-0.37836754322052,
0.6623769402503967,
0.4543556571006775,
0.967815101146698,
0.383998304605484,
0.3312182128429413,
0.6664931774139404,
-0.36345434188842773,
-0.6894465684890747,
0.4072898328304291,
0.5029709935188293,
0.45316627621650696,
-0.2739761471748352,
0.4555472731590271,
0.3607337772846222,
-0.2629426121711731,
-0.7495322823524475,
-0.11935220658779144,
-1.3029606342315674,
-0.3282681405544281,
1.2304394245147705,
0.0944158285856247,
-0.2848789095878601,
-0.3316802680492401,
-0.29137152433395386,
0.5848164558410645,
-0.25703510642051697,
1.2767484188079834,
0.6189079880714417,
-0.15991392731666565,
0.32098883390426636,
-0.6533473134040833,
0.49619078636169434,
0.27264708280563354,
-0.679623544216156,
-0.18892042338848114,
0.6268572211265564,
0.6707047820091248,
0.39133521914482117,
0.8961396813392639,
-0.5432811379432678,
0.19404688477516174,
-0.201424703001976,
0.030835995450615883,
0.28530851006507874,
0.11518798023462296,
-0.015928801149129868,
0.06684070825576782,
-0.5329755544662476,
-0.17106950283050537
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.