id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09983v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09983v2
|
Zero-Shot Hierarchical Classification on the Common Procurement Vocabulary Taxonomy
| 2024-05-16T11:01:09 | 2024-05-30T15:34:10 |
Federico Moiraghi, Matteo Palmonari, Davide Allavena, Federico Morando
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Classifying public tenders is a useful task for both companies that are
invited to participate and for inspecting fraudulent activities. To facilitate
the task for both participants and public administrations, the European Union
presented a common taxonomy (Common Procurement Vocabulary, CPV) which is
mandatory for tenders of certain importance; however, the contracts in which a
CPV label is mandatory are the minority compared to all the Public
Administrations activities. Classifying over a real-world taxonomy introduces
some difficulties that can not be ignored. First of all, some fine-grained
classes have an insufficient (if any) number of observations in the training
set, while other classes are far more frequent (even thousands of times) than
the average. To overcome those difficulties, we present a zero-shot approach,
based on a pre-trained language model that relies only on label description and
respects the label taxonomy. To train our proposed model, we used industrial
data, which comes from contrattipubblici.org, a service by SpazioDati s.r.l.
that collects public contracts stipulated in Italy in the last 25 years.
Results show that the proposed model achieves better performance in classifying
low-frequent classes compared to three different baselines, and is also able to
predict never-seen classes.
|
[
-0.2698265612125397,
-0.1981823891401291,
0.36856064200401306,
-0.008811735548079014,
-0.42277762293815613,
-0.13498307764530182,
0.30020225048065186,
-0.708243727684021,
-0.05865224078297615,
0.4467843472957611,
0.003967419732362032,
-0.6641674041748047,
-0.5290065407752991,
0.05437817797064781,
-0.3831402063369751,
1.166403889656067,
0.2125425934791565,
-0.0002387065178481862,
0.028791217133402824,
-0.07434660196304321,
-0.13569065928459167,
-0.6471224427223206,
-0.2982334494590759,
-0.26199162006378174,
0.6928970217704773,
0.3587786555290222,
0.3416978418827057,
0.522739827632904,
0.24344682693481445,
0.3289029598236084,
-0.26389288902282715,
-0.030366813763976097,
-0.06329236924648285,
-0.4379909038543701,
-0.4939729571342468,
-0.5152453780174255,
-0.6350803971290588,
0.4539276957511902,
0.14946946501731873,
0.5483693480491638,
-0.35571131110191345,
0.31699663400650024,
0.03670384734869003,
0.2541164457798004,
-1.0238988399505615,
0.3955470025539398,
-0.9626710414886475,
-0.14242830872535706,
-0.2756979465484619,
-0.37157702445983887,
-0.4807702898979187,
-0.04289546608924866,
0.46998870372772217,
-0.6034385561943054,
0.276118665933609,
-0.23892876505851746,
1.3327895402908325,
-0.2714097499847412,
-0.4406878650188446,
-0.05060878396034241,
-0.6082490086555481,
0.8761739730834961,
-0.15822046995162964,
0.07737482339143753,
0.1337215006351471,
0.4375513195991516,
0.04108981788158417,
-0.6462631225585938,
-0.12982754409313202,
-0.20862916111946106,
0.026638377457857132,
0.48124179244041443,
-0.25896763801574707,
0.2801394462585449,
-0.20500448346138,
0.17024308443069458,
-0.4959527254104614,
0.2822072505950928,
-0.703133761882782,
-0.20071634650230408,
0.4229399263858795,
0.1387469470500946,
0.03599574789404869,
-0.31431227922439575,
-0.7169380784034729,
0.3536224365234375,
-0.7352283000946045,
0.04598904028534889,
0.359407901763916,
0.4865165054798126,
-0.2680800259113312,
0.2832678258419037,
-0.4464077055454254,
0.9245073795318604,
-0.04086466506123543,
-0.05488613620400429,
0.3494863212108612,
-0.03219086304306984,
-0.5588435530662537,
0.025708235800266266,
0.452772319316864,
0.14320187270641327,
0.2560277283191681,
-0.2041885107755661,
-0.28266841173171997,
0.19670020043849945,
0.4036291837692261,
-0.2777869701385498,
-0.14134986698627472,
0.21751849353313446,
-0.09830467402935028,
-0.6783016920089722,
0.24745655059814453,
-0.26592814922332764,
0.33906319737434387,
-0.4196823239326477,
0.4543948471546173,
0.050332553684711456,
-0.0552113875746727,
0.21695995330810547,
-0.2683137059211731,
0.42724910378456116,
0.6569520235061646,
-0.4492090046405792,
0.2975156307220459,
0.8440782427787781,
0.8907418251037598,
0.26711344718933105,
-0.3756231963634491,
-0.6395256519317627,
0.3654613792896271,
-0.2039562165737152,
1.2788370847702026,
-0.3543529510498047,
-0.23950989544391632,
0.12709550559520721,
0.08305194228887558,
-0.07804859429597855,
-0.5321340560913086,
0.21347284317016602,
-0.44608286023139954,
0.27858904004096985,
0.352058470249176,
-0.40400612354278564,
0.23566068708896637,
0.8317269086837769,
-0.18064288794994354,
0.3474577069282532,
0.3437964916229248,
-0.833375096321106,
0.7204207181930542,
-0.46223825216293335,
-0.04083217307925224,
0.7309269309043884,
-0.3913964331150055,
-0.4642118215560913,
0.10856884717941284,
-0.4556484818458557,
0.6367073655128479,
-0.20483072102069855,
0.36442115902900696,
-0.343005508184433,
-0.38757628202438354,
0.02217673510313034,
-0.25610944628715515,
0.7598456144332886,
0.25998201966285706,
-0.024300115182995796,
-0.1750965714454651,
-0.8673636317253113,
-0.2971881628036499,
-0.43428465723991394,
-0.5445061922073364,
-0.4496641159057617,
-0.25307682156562805,
0.14075340330600739,
0.31719425320625305,
0.15063521265983582,
-0.836007833480835,
0.33307576179504395,
-0.7528446316719055,
0.2625836431980133,
0.7666239738464355,
0.04288909211754799,
0.3968021869659424,
-0.6255647540092468,
0.45432019233703613,
0.2949616312980652,
0.5241851210594177,
0.31278181076049805,
-0.5262711048126221,
-0.5256471037864685,
-0.39846622943878174,
0.6771575808525085,
0.7063248753547668,
-0.6548183560371399,
0.2778313159942627,
-0.24967403709888458,
-0.7791144251823425,
-0.2161475569009781,
-0.3607103228569031,
0.4202445447444916,
0.2357863038778305,
0.09770187735557556,
-0.37909993529319763,
-0.3600956201553345,
-0.866996169090271,
-0.015057230368256569,
-0.4508587419986725,
-0.2517879605293274,
0.31160786747932434,
0.5075147747993469,
0.008310710079967976,
0.6945468187332153,
-0.5275091528892517,
-0.837112307548523,
-0.15175233781337738,
0.7294386625289917,
0.46282243728637695,
0.3930600583553314,
0.5887119174003601,
-0.7119696140289307,
-0.4433678984642029,
0.19096866250038147,
-0.19114160537719727,
0.1205919086933136,
-0.2467590570449829,
-0.027514981105923653,
0.35770514607429504,
0.2530613839626312,
-0.33500924706459045,
0.43818020820617676,
0.18924476206302643,
-0.1310749650001526,
0.4488333761692047,
-0.29252374172210693,
-0.16553355753421783,
-0.6858766674995422,
0.1550845503807068,
0.16692447662353516,
-0.05625549703836441,
-0.7787343263626099,
0.08477457612752914,
0.025087427347898483,
-0.06597275286912918,
-1.3059661388397217,
0.412581205368042,
-0.3719992935657501,
0.11711545288562775,
-0.01261283177882433,
-0.06414896249771118,
-0.09740228205919266,
0.4807366132736206,
0.49413612484931946,
0.4990744888782501,
0.9802696108818054,
-0.939495325088501,
0.288470059633255,
0.06830402463674545,
-0.4307854175567627,
0.6522576212882996,
-0.37934762239456177,
-0.13341224193572998,
-0.17973458766937256,
0.15199913084506989,
-0.5415328741073608,
0.06802142411470413,
0.2622511684894562,
-0.4898042678833008,
0.4301275312900543,
-0.672731876373291,
-0.30972522497177124,
-0.2657347619533539,
-0.13363564014434814,
0.16887053847312927,
0.2523190677165985,
-0.33821430802345276,
0.33009546995162964,
0.2472997009754181,
0.3173734247684479,
-0.6566473841667175,
-0.7149479985237122,
-0.24140097200870514,
-0.1041029840707779,
-0.1846197098493576,
0.1835029572248459,
0.20650064945220947,
0.09422055631875992,
-0.06175684928894043,
-0.2692525088787079,
-0.7118828296661377,
0.4389675557613373,
0.05587387457489967,
0.37221887707710266,
-0.006644802168011665,
-0.02419556863605976,
-0.22151358425617218,
-0.3741413950920105,
-0.10253431648015976,
-0.29925304651260376,
0.260656476020813,
0.2555888891220093,
-0.11056338250637054,
-0.5413585901260376,
0.10072413086891174,
0.8059085607528687,
-0.062179166823625565,
0.748939037322998,
-0.07658734172582626,
-0.051680129021406174,
-0.1818971484899521,
-0.318027138710022,
0.5523182153701782,
-0.4575888514518738,
-0.00201869267039001,
-0.41595667600631714,
-0.5115565657615662,
0.18278545141220093,
-0.2556370496749878,
0.19713589549064636,
0.3943256735801697,
0.3809727132320404,
-0.0198733638972044,
0.6412840485572815,
0.6417944431304932,
-0.19765427708625793,
0.13966675102710724,
-0.4949084520339966,
-0.024130944162607193,
-0.4228956699371338,
-0.5503044724464417,
-0.9158530831336975,
0.15406298637390137,
-0.7449426651000977,
-0.22664935886859894,
0.4485386610031128,
-0.07706892490386963,
-0.16547247767448425,
0.5137407779693604,
-0.697886049747467,
0.49498113989830017,
0.35474979877471924,
0.07939069718122482,
0.3282184898853302,
-0.03411580249667168,
-0.0397675484418869,
0.3949810564517975,
-0.804699718952179,
-0.5343153476715088,
0.8421623110771179,
0.2485322654247284,
0.47125664353370667,
-0.05185578018426895,
1.1707468032836914,
-0.010291647166013718,
0.7016816139221191,
-1.0747411251068115,
0.3656550943851471,
-0.4229092597961426,
-0.9746302366256714,
-0.2975882589817047,
-0.41026413440704346,
-1.3631436824798584,
0.21450386941432953,
-0.06436222791671753,
-0.49541059136390686,
0.561030387878418,
0.22666461765766144,
-0.512266993522644,
0.2587450444698334,
-0.32612356543540955,
0.7535262107849121,
-0.14606115221977234,
0.04797108843922615,
-0.028372129425406456,
-0.2571084499359131,
0.31905460357666016,
-0.17151382565498352,
0.5151752829551697,
-0.16953641176223755,
-0.11246412992477417,
0.4459516406059265,
-0.513641357421875,
0.7112928032875061,
-0.2868412733078003,
-0.15199922025203705,
0.2834673225879669,
-0.06979484856128693,
0.3149910867214203,
-0.07343535870313644,
0.01375647448003292,
0.18354426324367523,
0.337240070104599,
-0.778422474861145,
-0.316771000623703,
0.39372503757476807,
-0.9160478115081787,
-0.4163372218608856,
-1.024114966392517,
0.06061976030468941,
-0.09052548557519913,
-0.11087073385715485,
0.7717633843421936,
0.5469930171966553,
-0.3558083474636078,
-0.027314577251672745,
0.3617984354496002,
-0.15761186182498932,
0.2230008840560913,
0.8865114450454712,
0.42313358187675476,
-0.12505555152893066,
0.8879231214523315,
0.6626293063163757,
0.1313542276620865,
0.6468716263771057,
0.05121034011244774,
-0.05411939322948456,
-0.8385601043701172,
-0.24275055527687073,
0.07157513499259949,
-0.2177933305501938,
-0.704837441444397,
-0.47943851351737976,
-0.3163049817085266,
-0.5569971799850464,
-0.22357361018657684,
-0.41734176874160767,
-0.4456382691860199,
-0.49174678325653076,
0.07332811504602432,
0.005103904288262129,
0.6021197438240051,
-0.22187848389148712,
0.21038424968719482,
-1.0955861806869507,
0.280276894569397,
0.4609619975090027,
0.7666480541229248,
-0.15642862021923065,
-0.47944191098213196,
-0.38614949584007263,
-0.3345256745815277,
-0.39179450273513794,
-0.744855523109436,
0.46742528676986694,
0.1030096486210823,
0.6500587463378906,
0.6164230704307556,
0.3861159384250641,
0.6315322518348694,
-0.4380199909210205,
0.7845206260681152,
0.4901626706123352,
-1.0006499290466309,
0.6148801445960999,
-0.47402140498161316,
0.2633956968784332,
0.5325362086296082,
0.712211549282074,
-0.3140765130519867,
-0.7263253927230835,
-0.953326404094696,
-1.1499544382095337,
1.0268244743347168,
0.25760576128959656,
0.09224483370780945,
-0.36072981357574463,
0.17121943831443787,
-0.12412670254707336,
0.11839789152145386,
-0.8112838268280029,
-0.1822502315044403,
-0.06965896487236023,
0.30606216192245483,
0.10369528084993362,
-0.2702082395553589,
-0.024537254124879837,
-0.12365339696407318,
0.7625136971473694,
0.3420225977897644,
-0.08685657382011414,
0.17187057435512543,
-0.005467500537633896,
-0.09117070585489273,
0.8554732799530029,
0.46496209502220154,
0.7815117835998535,
-0.45575594902038574,
0.19327475130558014,
0.06130106374621391,
-0.3054922819137573,
0.34697577357292175,
-0.15056413412094116,
-0.1461108922958374,
0.2591482698917389,
0.27086570858955383,
0.21424482762813568,
0.2940256595611572,
-0.4292925000190735,
0.8083345293998718,
0.0715453177690506,
-0.7995536923408508,
-0.5341973900794983,
-0.1237969845533371,
-0.5974336862564087,
0.10540693998336792,
0.13724125921726227,
0.05886295810341835,
0.4230137765407562,
-0.8775744438171387,
0.2316766232252121,
0.17757444083690643,
-0.4163476824760437,
-0.21380802989006042,
0.11334996670484543,
0.5345650315284729,
-0.1509917825460434,
0.29398077726364136,
-0.45071977376937866,
-0.4598829448223114,
0.5180529356002808,
0.1780521720647812,
0.8436006307601929,
-0.2350110560655594,
0.6116440296173096,
0.15762579441070557,
0.20982331037521362,
-0.3355078399181366,
0.22429953515529633,
-0.12315602600574493,
-0.6298491954803467,
-0.4440581798553467,
-0.6730008125305176,
-0.47791945934295654,
0.672544538974762,
-0.891570508480072,
0.49260151386260986,
-0.5928614139556885,
-0.014206613413989544,
0.14746657013893127,
0.0707511380314827,
-0.743567943572998,
0.15057463943958282,
0.292175829410553,
1.1997860670089722,
-1.120231032371521,
0.9568986296653748,
0.8752435445785522,
-0.29805922508239746,
-0.736566424369812,
-0.34208589792251587,
-0.07330840080976486,
-0.32652390003204346,
1.0090291500091553,
-0.08275401592254639,
-0.0413551926612854,
-0.23678362369537354,
-0.7227345705032349,
-0.7097043395042419,
0.8453947901725769,
0.014738140627741814,
-0.826275646686554,
-0.05456022545695305,
0.1024094894528389,
0.6096382737159729,
-0.18034642934799194,
0.011697746813297272,
0.33287596702575684,
0.39224526286125183,
0.34773269295692444,
-1.2232205867767334,
-0.6331195831298828,
-0.12453415989875793,
-0.16695167124271393,
0.37616613507270813,
-0.5555883646011353,
0.7966547608375549,
0.5264999866485596,
-0.46722981333732605,
0.323288232088089,
0.21875716745853424,
0.36644577980041504,
0.7364185452461243,
0.4365594685077667,
0.5329998731613159,
0.3529531955718994,
-0.06811506301164627,
0.8816533088684082,
-0.015185769647359848,
0.5578800439834595,
0.9936423301696777,
-0.3170643150806427,
0.7542729377746582,
0.15046493709087372,
-0.11486146599054337,
0.3098938763141632,
0.420815646648407,
-0.3629249930381775,
0.4629162847995758,
0.5415834784507751,
-0.12782561779022217,
-0.638701319694519,
-0.21473287045955658,
-0.2785283327102661,
0.8044477105140686,
0.08660215884447098,
-0.002080057980492711,
-0.6799913048744202,
-0.009575886651873589,
-0.3735586702823639,
0.08775825053453445,
-0.7024846076965332,
0.8980368971824646,
-0.002486245706677437,
-0.2665804326534271,
0.6000574827194214,
-0.0025336910039186478,
0.7365288734436035,
-0.3409784138202667,
0.029409274458885193,
-0.04299488663673401,
0.21217581629753113,
-0.19463028013706207,
-0.5917705297470093,
0.39623549580574036,
0.17651444673538208,
-0.06706637144088745,
-0.3062865734100342,
0.22267787158489227,
-0.20220734179019928,
-0.42808130383491516,
0.33438652753829956,
0.36347877979278564,
0.5681838989257812,
-0.10549420118331909,
-0.728900134563446,
-0.299371600151062,
-0.41919195652008057,
0.22331812977790833,
0.6285735964775085,
0.8780274987220764,
-0.02206120267510414,
0.31009143590927124,
0.25028470158576965,
0.5571654438972473,
-0.1483110636472702,
0.15642210841178894,
0.8018302917480469,
-0.6228706240653992,
-0.6349349021911621,
-0.37254461646080017,
0.5560522079467773,
0.02605106681585312,
-0.29648280143737793,
0.4412863850593567,
0.7881264090538025,
1.2392810583114624,
-0.19730141758918762,
0.5345638990402222,
0.35200247168540955,
0.625285804271698,
-0.272401362657547,
0.5402268767356873,
-0.5698687434196472,
0.4007359445095062,
-0.3112654387950897,
-0.6907257437705994,
-0.5817806720733643,
0.38002249598503113,
-0.18851326406002045,
-0.5381169319152832,
0.3711428642272949,
0.461978554725647,
-0.23715555667877197,
-0.48899197578430176,
0.7274884581565857,
0.11195987462997437,
-0.03227364644408226,
0.5800737738609314,
1.1213890314102173,
-0.2754267156124115,
0.9803452491760254,
-0.33607158064842224,
-0.1726035177707672,
-0.09264003485441208,
-0.7075973749160767,
-0.7411918640136719,
-0.29750993847846985,
-0.7284941673278809,
-0.14167162775993347,
0.032214537262916565,
0.8726039528846741,
0.8736197352409363,
-0.8801252245903015,
-0.5817803740501404,
-0.174998477101326,
-0.01795344054698944,
0.06873637437820435,
-0.18327322602272034,
0.08064624667167664,
-0.41784393787384033,
-0.6720765233039856,
0.014829810708761215,
0.5106367468833923,
0.37270015478134155,
0.14398618042469025,
0.2262108325958252,
-0.2967049181461334,
0.23807960748672485,
0.5098521113395691,
0.3472623825073242,
-0.49740689992904663,
-0.22139261662960052,
-0.35753557085990906,
0.029013870283961296,
0.0192953459918499,
0.9521064758300781,
-0.8136065602302551,
0.14363470673561096,
0.4866940975189209,
-0.12628592550754547,
0.4129386246204376,
-0.10936622321605682,
0.2428901642560959,
-0.9092820882797241,
0.4994526505470276,
0.45485714077949524,
0.13862988352775574,
-0.27436986565589905,
-0.49475979804992676,
0.28506597876548767,
0.17204296588897705,
-0.38239848613739014,
-0.7467229962348938,
0.449657678604126,
-1.11728835105896,
-0.7410908341407776,
0.6822257041931152,
-0.42282548546791077,
-0.304948091506958,
-0.8274511098861694,
0.2682420611381531,
0.3195716142654419,
-0.35581567883491516,
0.9191970825195312,
0.47144103050231934,
0.06851009279489517,
-0.050569891929626465,
-0.015813875943422318,
0.3834167420864105,
-0.1545983850955963,
-0.6001324653625488,
-0.05611388012766838,
0.49138563871383667,
0.21230487525463104,
0.5029807090759277,
0.7872903347015381,
-0.24504858255386353,
0.5935534834861755,
-0.34193575382232666,
-0.14993816614151,
0.05153470113873482,
-0.7243704795837402,
-0.5286404490470886,
0.6096158623695374,
0.19655628502368927,
-0.32313966751098633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09980v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09980v1
|
FinTextQA: A Dataset for Long-form Financial Question Answering
| 2024-05-16T10:53:31 | 2024-05-16T10:53:31 |
Jian Chen, Peilin Zhou, Yining Hua, Yingxin Loh, Kehui Chen, Ziyuan Li, Bing Zhu, Junwei Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Accurate evaluation of financial question answering (QA) systems necessitates
a comprehensive dataset encompassing diverse question types and contexts.
However, current financial QA datasets lack scope diversity and question
complexity. This work introduces FinTextQA, a novel dataset for long-form
question answering (LFQA) in finance. FinTextQA comprises 1,262 high-quality,
source-attributed QA pairs extracted and selected from finance textbooks and
government agency websites.Moreover, we developed a Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG)-based LFQA system, comprising an embedder, retriever,
reranker, and generator. A multi-faceted evaluation approach, including human
ranking, automatic metrics, and GPT-4 scoring, was employed to benchmark the
performance of different LFQA system configurations under heightened noisy
conditions. The results indicate that: (1) Among all compared generators,
Baichuan2-7B competes closely with GPT-3.5-turbo in accuracy score; (2) The
most effective system configuration on our dataset involved setting the
embedder, retriever, reranker, and generator as Ada2, Automated Merged
Retrieval, Bge-Reranker-Base, and Baichuan2-7B, respectively; (3) models are
less susceptible to noise after the length of contexts reaching a specific
threshold.
|
[
-0.23761549592018127,
-0.7377922534942627,
0.32584860920906067,
0.5041629672050476,
-0.21599195897579193,
0.4076562225818634,
-0.12038188427686691,
-0.5890178084373474,
0.024673793464899063,
0.40021851658821106,
-0.42780250310897827,
-0.18596673011779785,
-0.1816980540752411,
0.09858731180429459,
-0.4940001964569092,
1.0421124696731567,
0.014934957958757877,
0.07426554709672928,
-0.18295937776565552,
-0.05003438517451286,
-0.40691593289375305,
-0.30248674750328064,
-0.9609923362731934,
-0.03271080553531647,
0.4668567478656769,
0.011846248060464859,
0.7251441478729248,
0.08069651573896408,
0.6693301200866699,
0.3104276955127716,
-0.021768664941191673,
0.1723189651966095,
-0.5077212452888489,
0.11512688547372818,
-0.05871771648526192,
-0.1641405075788498,
-0.4332124888896942,
-0.18705357611179352,
0.41336530447006226,
0.4464121162891388,
-0.21183781325817108,
0.41484513878822327,
0.03785525634884834,
0.6256301403045654,
-0.667021632194519,
0.3146791458129883,
-0.31483057141304016,
-0.2575061023235321,
-0.28236839175224304,
0.12560512125492096,
-0.20677335560321808,
-0.47476211190223694,
0.3308148980140686,
-0.7561159729957581,
0.010501239448785782,
0.06407700479030609,
0.9582054018974304,
0.4397158920764923,
-0.5325596928596497,
-0.4935864508152008,
-0.5551409125328064,
0.6126237511634827,
-0.5087062120437622,
0.531139612197876,
0.3081439435482025,
0.5759115815162659,
0.11751148104667664,
-0.8269626498222351,
-0.32347965240478516,
0.1731591671705246,
-0.08268220722675323,
0.3398544490337372,
-0.25149837136268616,
-0.05368686094880104,
-0.005881421267986298,
0.4318464398384094,
-0.4707900285720825,
-0.20545849204063416,
-0.5926302075386047,
-0.23479607701301575,
0.5427272915840149,
-0.13295431435108185,
-0.26789596676826477,
-0.3887532353401184,
-0.5190133452415466,
-0.22572287917137146,
-0.23790544271469116,
0.46245622634887695,
0.3419002294540405,
0.30586865544319153,
0.1784479320049286,
0.22956311702728271,
-0.20543625950813293,
0.6515167355537415,
0.3134461045265198,
-0.33732324838638306,
0.31110459566116333,
-0.332139253616333,
-0.33621230721473694,
-0.07914001494646072,
0.5999853610992432,
0.17673099040985107,
0.07181708514690399,
-0.17102409899234772,
-0.6518741250038147,
-0.7571994066238403,
0.28773850202560425,
-0.5120964050292969,
-0.05427674204111099,
0.43571212887763977,
-0.2453203946352005,
-0.33854490518569946,
0.24145902693271637,
-0.7740091681480408,
-0.14423596858978271,
-0.1620672196149826,
0.8067886829376221,
-0.2812774181365967,
0.006561910733580589,
0.21874591708183289,
-0.32972317934036255,
0.6047912240028381,
0.10504408180713654,
-0.679567277431488,
0.53761225938797,
0.8484781980514526,
0.5878186821937561,
-0.10951430350542068,
0.10854232311248779,
-0.696543276309967,
0.004509720019996166,
-0.33855563402175903,
0.7454740405082703,
-0.13992322981357574,
-0.15809598565101624,
-0.17104974389076233,
-0.1977989226579666,
-0.09873057156801224,
-0.7048022747039795,
0.5212015509605408,
-0.831433117389679,
0.3094632923603058,
-0.15806786715984344,
-0.4470656216144562,
-0.15399564802646637,
0.0029707862995564938,
-0.8449917435646057,
1.1288901567459106,
0.5800046920776367,
-0.6500049829483032,
0.5413320064544678,
-0.6001718640327454,
-0.29524168372154236,
0.1047816351056099,
-0.1856302171945572,
-0.5557318329811096,
-0.37264537811279297,
0.3638381063938141,
0.2852500379085541,
-0.5300301909446716,
0.49600842595100403,
-0.0006923803011886775,
-0.6308243274688721,
0.40827253460884094,
-0.6137956380844116,
0.5334914326667786,
0.17728310823440552,
-0.6135401129722595,
-0.19942684471607208,
-0.7069892287254333,
0.10701529681682587,
-0.04199877753853798,
-0.2157650887966156,
-0.48788610100746155,
-0.38640686869621277,
0.13575127720832825,
0.05818849802017212,
0.4869937002658844,
-0.5568909645080566,
-0.09939407557249069,
-0.38352903723716736,
0.4652872383594513,
0.8355889320373535,
0.07825823128223419,
0.04965424910187721,
-0.5764089226722717,
0.5345513820648193,
-0.14205095171928406,
0.14278075098991394,
0.15871591866016388,
-0.3772313594818115,
-0.4354810416698456,
-0.37286365032196045,
0.4723729193210602,
0.6385788917541504,
-0.645118236541748,
0.03099222667515278,
-0.1693510264158249,
-0.3935723304748535,
-0.2436688244342804,
0.1793231964111328,
0.3817542791366577,
0.4122146666049957,
0.31256428360939026,
0.22545504570007324,
-0.17999696731567383,
-1.1848301887512207,
-0.21209841966629028,
-0.15241718292236328,
-0.2193531095981598,
0.6268749237060547,
0.41951173543930054,
0.20496462285518646,
0.8154441714286804,
-0.6261440515518188,
0.130340114235878,
0.13666749000549316,
0.06757667660713196,
0.5707666873931885,
0.218200221657753,
0.7105791568756104,
-1.1321561336517334,
-0.17121820151805878,
-0.20707480609416962,
-0.2749244272708893,
-0.012537353672087193,
-0.3142099678516388,
-0.3644506633281708,
-0.054921649396419525,
0.23754052817821503,
-0.3632971942424774,
0.24029669165611267,
0.3982599973678589,
-0.5432183742523193,
0.40805014967918396,
0.1543770283460617,
0.32027700543403625,
-1.1595661640167236,
0.4009033739566803,
-0.2675560712814331,
-0.1975812315940857,
-0.351337194442749,
0.011348976753652096,
0.19451464712619781,
-0.06828639656305313,
-0.08546918630599976,
0.6415543556213379,
-0.03226964920759201,
-0.2662684917449951,
0.051521867513656616,
0.16802769899368286,
0.18928109109401703,
0.6309807896614075,
-0.21021440625190735,
1.2419830560684204,
0.09208016097545624,
-0.33012884855270386,
0.435879111289978,
0.3439652621746063,
-0.3769628703594208,
0.5192404389381409,
-0.8149136304855347,
-0.07060731202363968,
-0.16107167303562164,
0.26995354890823364,
-1.159035086631775,
-0.2727566063404083,
0.1745201051235199,
-0.21238568425178528,
0.021354015916585922,
0.22221739590168,
-0.07304587960243225,
-0.33546528220176697,
-0.18941561877727509,
0.7986178994178772,
0.18691830337047577,
-0.48804032802581787,
0.3662344813346863,
0.12370551377534866,
-0.6629900932312012,
-0.9249900579452515,
-0.37460336089134216,
-0.015077964402735233,
-0.2287299633026123,
-0.6271342635154724,
0.33562007546424866,
-0.05066518113017082,
-0.3076672852039337,
-0.312303751707077,
-0.3659476041793823,
-0.22157159447669983,
0.2067009061574936,
0.21805092692375183,
0.4311831593513489,
-0.48118847608566284,
0.46151503920555115,
0.1342930942773819,
0.11697246134281158,
0.13595430552959442,
-0.3628924787044525,
0.1858276128768921,
-0.2294382005929947,
-0.01740392856299877,
0.10908515006303787,
0.33076590299606323,
0.42776545882225037,
-0.3232797384262085,
0.39636337757110596,
0.39112141728401184,
-0.3422449827194214,
-0.12623727321624756,
-0.5264787077903748,
0.18637676537036896,
-0.5237346887588501,
0.201346293091774,
-0.4233405590057373,
-1.1020511388778687,
0.5726532936096191,
0.1909836083650589,
0.3433310091495514,
0.8121682405471802,
0.3535245358943939,
0.004429715219885111,
0.31866392493247986,
0.3685489594936371,
0.013119802810251713,
0.15299999713897705,
-0.024938231334090233,
-0.031012972816824913,
-0.2853652238845825,
-0.3117259442806244,
-0.5907805562019348,
-0.22134511172771454,
-0.4126761555671692,
-0.384866327047348,
0.472543865442276,
0.1066175252199173,
-0.6511436104774475,
0.1717081367969513,
-0.18659503757953644,
0.4136303663253784,
0.4138816297054291,
0.14399483799934387,
0.21005117893218994,
-0.15824376046657562,
-0.08763262629508972,
0.29910945892333984,
-0.40561461448669434,
-0.17444197833538055,
1.0638046264648438,
0.43733134865760803,
0.6396059989929199,
0.38065293431282043,
0.6678510308265686,
0.36541247367858887,
0.2861049771308899,
-0.5927333235740662,
0.022058425471186638,
-0.3298158347606659,
-0.7020044326782227,
-0.7990418672561646,
-0.8080339431762695,
-0.7312877774238586,
-0.12421321868896484,
-0.0353250615298748,
-0.42522740364074707,
0.3281914293766022,
-0.31484487652778625,
-1.0368342399597168,
0.014116202481091022,
-0.32281768321990967,
0.7239183783531189,
-0.2568780779838562,
-0.28825610876083374,
0.3840239942073822,
-0.4736151099205017,
0.6148919463157654,
-0.6724013090133667,
0.3803548216819763,
0.05108509957790375,
-0.16422314941883087,
0.9562703371047974,
-0.30914559960365295,
0.3830675780773163,
-0.053679801523685455,
-0.7786506414413452,
0.32869574427604675,
-0.19402214884757996,
0.3511706590652466,
0.4906180500984192,
-0.26607421040534973,
-0.16720570623874664,
0.441879004240036,
-0.5344659686088562,
-0.8235971331596375,
0.4962529242038727,
-0.7732532024383545,
-0.30701184272766113,
-0.23827099800109863,
-0.3787604868412018,
-0.5630877017974854,
0.18258515000343323,
0.07059004157781601,
0.5093324780464172,
-0.2584972679615021,
0.4107036888599396,
0.49767544865608215,
-0.21101254224777222,
0.18746228516101837,
0.16201552748680115,
-0.329377144575119,
-0.7517433762550354,
0.8333028554916382,
0.01815984584391117,
0.208711177110672,
0.4019230902194977,
0.02072400227189064,
-0.49745672941207886,
-0.00595043646171689,
-0.43402180075645447,
0.09892460703849792,
-0.5963876247406006,
-0.5448222756385803,
-0.33633875846862793,
-0.5093687176704407,
-0.4844004511833191,
-0.031359732151031494,
-0.2339254468679428,
-0.5784473419189453,
0.03539711982011795,
-0.10376430302858353,
0.4858984351158142,
0.7361415028572083,
-0.052883442491292953,
0.06704346835613251,
-0.7208901643753052,
0.7081006765365601,
0.7574439644813538,
0.7620805501937866,
-0.1279541254043579,
-0.3498747646808624,
-0.3325969874858856,
0.08372842520475388,
0.04539445787668228,
-0.6126985549926758,
-0.07544340193271637,
0.32831501960754395,
0.4387061595916748,
0.28693851828575134,
0.17326043546199799,
0.6161208748817444,
0.08567368984222412,
0.5913076996803284,
-0.17517894506454468,
-0.8037955164909363,
0.09747789800167084,
-0.5015403032302856,
0.32880130410194397,
0.7283382415771484,
0.23435188829898834,
-0.4594370424747467,
-0.48509761691093445,
-0.4588634669780731,
-0.9934374094009399,
0.4030773937702179,
0.4399958550930023,
-0.08719929307699203,
0.07808829843997955,
0.831557035446167,
0.34022122621536255,
0.3066011369228363,
-0.3736453950405121,
-0.20498837530612946,
-0.4837230145931244,
-0.23379291594028473,
-0.13347071409225464,
-0.1185697615146637,
-0.019613584503531456,
-0.01002882607281208,
0.5855944752693176,
-0.2568610608577728,
0.14571453630924225,
0.2364669293165207,
0.2770511507987976,
-0.05942484363913536,
0.17664451897144318,
0.4888552129268646,
0.6995590329170227,
-0.4682190418243408,
-0.27366960048675537,
0.1260635405778885,
-0.601496696472168,
0.20044052600860596,
0.41495198011398315,
-0.13537539541721344,
-0.013119316659867764,
0.31183692812919617,
0.4832542836666107,
0.5260124802589417,
-0.8559944033622742,
0.5957273244857788,
-0.3358236253261566,
-0.48172134160995483,
-0.5669476985931396,
-0.012430211529135704,
0.011360353790223598,
0.5020735859870911,
0.942547619342804,
-0.16259273886680603,
0.374423086643219,
-0.2682974934577942,
0.5883489847183228,
0.1985764056444168,
-0.3002028167247772,
0.2747393846511841,
0.721588671207428,
0.13494433462619781,
0.19902268052101135,
0.6004875302314758,
0.19107504189014435,
-0.26151835918426514,
0.7406352758407593,
0.22210822999477386,
0.8111174702644348,
0.19084177911281586,
0.4180651605129242,
0.4415656626224518,
0.11059311032295227,
0.005415147636085749,
0.6244261264801025,
-0.23990590870380402,
-0.3574763834476471,
-0.4416440725326538,
-0.9936711192131042,
-0.46065425872802734,
0.17509245872497559,
-0.9259587526321411,
-0.02584831975400448,
-0.524063766002655,
-0.3728583753108978,
0.16726039350032806,
0.18539300560951233,
-0.4879244267940521,
0.3847685754299164,
0.08307226747274399,
1.0006370544433594,
-0.2504170536994934,
0.0877353698015213,
0.3837830722332001,
-0.1619594842195511,
-0.8623085618019104,
-0.011398857459425926,
-0.16627027094364166,
-0.4865526258945465,
0.5664178133010864,
0.0001664990995777771,
-0.22645629942417145,
-0.1897421032190323,
-0.47722041606903076,
-1.0974527597427368,
1.3410346508026123,
0.19483047723770142,
-0.4475409984588623,
-0.25656482577323914,
0.21451573073863983,
0.2624783515930176,
-0.08389157056808472,
0.061584435403347015,
0.5835077166557312,
0.6591877937316895,
0.23971685767173767,
-1.0605779886245728,
-0.07089731097221375,
-0.4067138433456421,
-0.41398581862449646,
0.3133147358894348,
-1.1073696613311768,
0.9058214426040649,
0.05944466218352318,
-0.12515296041965485,
0.36518165469169617,
0.8429826498031616,
0.29972967505455017,
0.36823877692222595,
0.554192841053009,
0.026273243129253387,
0.8926815390586853,
-0.14712661504745483,
0.5605233907699585,
-0.3526524603366852,
0.3366236388683319,
1.0378671884536743,
-0.015936587005853653,
0.8708795309066772,
0.3235202729701996,
-0.16933836042881012,
0.3778259754180908,
0.7141811847686768,
0.012528544291853905,
0.18604730069637299,
0.4571231007575989,
-0.0798838809132576,
-0.5319549441337585,
0.1927294135093689,
-0.33404070138931274,
0.6867896318435669,
0.1373109519481659,
-0.20455089211463928,
-0.2208414524793625,
-0.104632668197155,
-0.3749232292175293,
-0.024368222802877426,
-0.09223634004592896,
0.7463387846946716,
0.1360313445329666,
-0.5130759477615356,
0.4517630338668823,
0.1631922572851181,
0.5138396620750427,
-0.6287220120429993,
0.0493045449256897,
-0.5120365023612976,
-0.22102420032024384,
0.033394619822502136,
-0.6963427662849426,
0.11400432139635086,
0.043630748987197876,
-0.10966205596923828,
0.03510913997888565,
0.42388924956321716,
-0.3298667371273041,
-0.6068572402000427,
0.02486341819167137,
0.5416569709777832,
-0.08738040924072266,
-0.03408080339431763,
-0.48640871047973633,
-0.426033079624176,
-0.19902725517749786,
-0.35572752356529236,
0.11957215517759323,
0.5300589799880981,
-0.1575319916009903,
0.6578406691551208,
0.6924257278442383,
-0.36562204360961914,
-0.2454010248184204,
-0.06855747103691101,
0.7942220568656921,
-0.8324922919273376,
-0.6002715229988098,
-0.28248879313468933,
0.07965414226055145,
-0.04236050322651863,
-0.7021193504333496,
0.42933812737464905,
0.8207213282585144,
0.5510244965553284,
0.08793602883815765,
0.5458410382270813,
0.2079082876443863,
0.6380175948143005,
-0.6226087212562561,
0.8133933544158936,
-0.6573516726493835,
0.27386337518692017,
-0.5102606415748596,
-0.7964587807655334,
-0.16867642104625702,
0.33779478073120117,
-0.06715676933526993,
0.10926990956068039,
0.23195357620716095,
0.5700643658638,
-0.10574786365032196,
0.2730790078639984,
0.24461109936237335,
-0.005241953767836094,
0.12898077070713043,
0.6141195297241211,
0.642040491104126,
-0.6865352988243103,
0.79424649477005,
-0.23273038864135742,
-0.027885321527719498,
-0.09835744649171829,
-0.3789401948451996,
-0.43627771735191345,
-0.6469215154647827,
0.009993036277592182,
-0.3177068531513214,
0.2172551453113556,
0.7239821553230286,
0.16874194145202637,
-0.7806850671768188,
-0.3100307285785675,
0.7105090022087097,
-0.038811519742012024,
-0.268441379070282,
-0.24220652878284454,
0.6119534969329834,
-0.23036380112171173,
-0.5005637407302856,
0.28243696689605713,
0.25643786787986755,
0.11286043375730515,
-0.24993368983268738,
-0.03097289241850376,
-0.06151688098907471,
0.38762232661247253,
0.4419313371181488,
0.1659017950296402,
-0.3587244749069214,
-0.3694082796573639,
0.46314364671707153,
-0.28339865803718567,
-0.2109087109565735,
0.6559222936630249,
-0.6083365678787231,
-0.023931965231895447,
0.3505723774433136,
0.8337096571922302,
0.278853178024292,
0.4133843779563904,
0.7003524303436279,
-0.4090314507484436,
-0.20683981478214264,
0.20382599532604218,
0.04975353926420212,
-0.16069449484348297,
-0.5006334185600281,
0.4748076796531677,
-0.07414510101079941,
-0.5283066034317017,
-0.4789287745952606,
-0.2517644166946411,
-0.8923460245132446,
-0.4186605215072632,
0.9649761319160461,
-0.03979362174868584,
-0.46134811639785767,
-0.238328218460083,
-0.22863027453422546,
-0.024028338491916656,
-0.5578991770744324,
0.7043588757514954,
0.7066149115562439,
0.049181148409843445,
0.06330733001232147,
-0.5527636408805847,
0.7339809536933899,
0.2986174523830414,
-0.5793284773826599,
0.14787904918193817,
0.506657600402832,
0.2611877918243408,
0.1671074777841568,
0.5808154940605164,
-0.05755912512540817,
0.7635309100151062,
0.026997292414307594,
-0.3412502110004425,
-0.07622171938419342,
-0.14762918651103973,
-0.090905100107193,
0.4465864896774292,
-0.21137148141860962,
0.197891965508461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13031v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13031v1
|
A Robust Autoencoder Ensemble-Based Approach for Anomaly Detection in Text
| 2024-05-16T10:45:43 | 2024-05-16T10:45:43 |
Jeremie Pantin, Christophe Marsala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this work, a robust autoencoder ensemble-based approach designed to
address anomaly detection in text corpora is introduced. Each autoencoder
within the ensemble incorporates a local robust subspace recovery projection of
the original data in its encoding embedding, leveraging the geometric
properties of the k-nearest neighbors to optimize subspace recovery and
identify anomalous patterns in textual data. The evaluation of such an approach
needs an experimental setting dedicated to the context of textual anomaly
detection. Thus, beforehand, a comprehensive real-world taxonomy is introduced
to distinguish between independent anomalies and contextual anomalies. Such a
study to identify clearly the kinds of anomalies appearing in a textual context
aims at addressing a critical gap in the existing literature. Then, extensive
experiments on classical text corpora have been conducted and their results are
presented that highlights the efficiency, both in robustness and in
performance, of the robust autoencoder ensemble-based approach when detecting
both independent and contextual anomalies. Diverse range of tasks, including
classification, sentiment analysis, and spam detection, across eight different
corpora, have been studied in these experiments.
|
[
-0.23592343926429749,
-0.979501485824585,
0.28697818517684937,
0.12222100794315338,
0.09637539088726044,
0.11010071635246277,
-0.21064640581607819,
-0.32273998856544495,
0.30847984552383423,
0.2482655942440033,
-0.35741645097732544,
-0.7163944244384766,
-0.773185670375824,
0.3893071413040161,
-0.9505683779716492,
0.7449803352355957,
0.002591382944956422,
-0.4021416902542114,
-0.2868727147579193,
-0.07797183841466904,
-0.33746883273124695,
-0.7248786091804504,
-0.3197733163833618,
0.3885360360145569,
-0.0803874284029007,
0.2578478157520294,
0.4990520477294922,
0.9832958579063416,
0.777481734752655,
0.367277592420578,
0.15581157803535461,
0.459524542093277,
-0.23626577854156494,
0.3621133863925934,
-0.047334685921669006,
-0.3427908718585968,
-0.2930282652378082,
-0.5031676888465881,
0.7374717593193054,
0.3714351952075958,
-0.16855385899543762,
-0.31731751561164856,
0.1914660632610321,
0.3005349636077881,
-0.6622976064682007,
-0.09690617769956589,
-0.5081983208656311,
0.2501332759857178,
-0.2543407678604126,
-0.29585471749305725,
-0.21798749268054962,
-0.28400567173957825,
-0.14125211536884308,
-0.591799259185791,
0.5626024603843689,
0.23215922713279724,
0.6764270663261414,
0.44005221128463745,
-0.15063676238059998,
-0.7436291575431824,
-0.5538780093193054,
0.8773754835128784,
-0.6266298890113831,
0.19378399848937988,
0.3539559543132782,
-0.04116912931203842,
-0.2910729944705963,
-0.6122587323188782,
-0.5770810842514038,
0.3089658319950104,
-0.37778183817863464,
0.09827998280525208,
-0.5822513699531555,
-0.38219019770622253,
-0.2356208711862564,
0.6321660876274109,
-0.9684461355209351,
0.3251073360443115,
-0.02788335271179676,
-0.3988294005393982,
0.49813899397850037,
0.3184570074081421,
0.4710257649421692,
-0.6277762651443481,
-0.5203278660774231,
-0.40311887860298157,
-0.08719508349895477,
-0.08838975429534912,
0.594548225402832,
-0.08893004804849625,
-0.3787701427936554,
0.09025409072637558,
0.07874515652656555,
0.43863990902900696,
0.15557609498500824,
0.14800673723220825,
0.2833251953125,
-0.449753999710083,
-0.13005799055099487,
0.19574971497058868,
1.068152904510498,
-0.03584987297654152,
-0.048382826149463654,
-0.1270708292722702,
-0.407140851020813,
0.31571221351623535,
0.3053118884563446,
-0.3207967281341553,
-0.5095876455307007,
0.16158901154994965,
-0.7545714974403381,
-0.6836997270584106,
0.08025769889354706,
-1.2528935670852661,
-0.1921081840991974,
-0.1542188972234726,
0.42802366614341736,
-0.6421237587928772,
-0.4857799708843231,
-0.18449541926383972,
-0.2805279493331909,
0.011171870864927769,
0.036962248384952545,
-0.9214770793914795,
0.5007460713386536,
0.5245656371116638,
0.5386255979537964,
-0.6946230530738831,
-0.37490203976631165,
-0.3069392740726471,
0.029094893485307693,
-0.26209837198257446,
0.8741346001625061,
-0.6531738042831421,
-0.4295658767223358,
0.15313862264156342,
0.31716951727867126,
-0.25942671298980713,
-0.45811864733695984,
0.661423921585083,
-0.2515980005264282,
0.5097873210906982,
-0.0558011569082737,
-0.7465774416923523,
-0.02924131602048874,
0.5789989233016968,
-0.44410282373428345,
1.143274188041687,
0.1395389586687088,
-1.0522797107696533,
0.24776814877986908,
-0.6168270111083984,
-0.2673702836036682,
-0.06489116698503494,
-0.3698243796825409,
-0.4322896897792816,
-0.031537823379039764,
0.4238419830799103,
0.3210911154747009,
0.043151214718818665,
0.05006522685289383,
-0.19695502519607544,
-0.29184260964393616,
0.44166451692581177,
-0.7927725315093994,
0.5274696350097656,
0.26833146810531616,
-0.5135818719863892,
-0.06136484071612358,
-0.858095109462738,
-0.12343785166740417,
-0.11903640627861023,
0.018061285838484764,
-0.9085158705711365,
-0.1348511278629303,
0.28997549414634705,
-0.15918679535388947,
0.292593389749527,
-0.42916905879974365,
0.18510505557060242,
-0.3765849471092224,
0.146286740899086,
0.4858229160308838,
0.3405722379684448,
0.6254363656044006,
-0.15365132689476013,
0.3853006362915039,
0.3563426434993744,
-0.05124056711792946,
-0.42234209179878235,
-0.20039474964141846,
-0.48572778701782227,
-0.6701756715774536,
0.37963545322418213,
0.8280365467071533,
-0.7493865489959717,
1.0359711647033691,
-0.10450492799282074,
-0.10879542678594589,
-0.32084012031555176,
0.30187883973121643,
0.26696330308914185,
0.6240106225013733,
0.17293252050876617,
-0.34892162680625916,
-0.6076127886772156,
-0.8022440671920776,
-0.3936547636985779,
-0.020281672477722168,
-0.09866780787706375,
-0.1300986409187317,
0.5551096796989441,
-0.5910424590110779,
1.151349425315857,
-0.26319488883018494,
-0.35172751545906067,
0.21510790288448334,
0.4827181100845337,
-0.15657411515712738,
0.7861083149909973,
0.7888455986976624,
-0.9338674545288086,
-0.24359387159347534,
-0.08018768578767776,
-1.201459288597107,
-0.07611288875341415,
-0.026782842352986336,
-0.08618626743555069,
0.30446138978004456,
0.6270694136619568,
-0.03819912672042847,
0.3683795630931854,
0.5370939373970032,
-0.38204294443130493,
0.17790283262729645,
-0.5299391150474548,
0.38345494866371155,
-1.0565346479415894,
-0.14814390242099762,
-0.051913850009441376,
-0.14661379158496857,
-0.628645122051239,
-0.2721055746078491,
0.26908329129219055,
0.20034511387348175,
0.2480945736169815,
0.19289720058441162,
-0.3962155878543854,
0.10114288330078125,
-0.45439958572387695,
0.13842204213142395,
0.12664149701595306,
0.30310216546058655,
0.12470366060733795,
0.4620389938354492,
0.7119552493095398,
-0.6893666386604309,
0.012823120690882206,
0.23428404331207275,
0.05029038339853287,
0.6528844237327576,
-0.17343151569366455,
0.03293542563915253,
-0.49695754051208496,
-0.16374962031841278,
-1.1109423637390137,
-0.6356189250946045,
0.3122921586036682,
-0.6617169976234436,
0.41517093777656555,
0.18426117300987244,
-0.43955591320991516,
-0.09797512739896774,
-0.3180176615715027,
0.3959006667137146,
0.26828497648239136,
-0.6629785895347595,
0.4720434546470642,
0.549714207649231,
-0.11109539866447449,
-0.5457285046577454,
-0.9036102890968323,
0.13485535979270935,
-0.4757341742515564,
-0.5084108114242554,
0.13877835869789124,
0.1039426326751709,
-0.2310193032026291,
0.276526540517807,
0.25490033626556396,
-0.43784499168395996,
0.30421504378318787,
-0.08444803208112717,
0.1939401477575302,
-0.17457397282123566,
0.05032198503613472,
0.3119172751903534,
0.08148317039012909,
0.22675783932209015,
-0.3418179750442505,
0.2021576315164566,
-0.33640408515930176,
-0.2725043296813965,
-0.38397085666656494,
0.6133564114570618,
0.4613247513771057,
0.040649015456438065,
0.3578941822052002,
0.8875465989112854,
-0.6609548926353455,
-0.29713913798332214,
-0.4040919840335846,
-0.14370524883270264,
-0.45726659893989563,
0.31413766741752625,
0.08654090017080307,
-0.675193727016449,
0.5112746953964233,
0.16336704790592194,
-0.20397649705410004,
0.4694170355796814,
0.4164331257343292,
-0.1463259905576706,
0.7683408856391907,
0.8419690728187561,
-0.2647370398044586,
0.3137303590774536,
-0.12402642518281937,
0.30339792370796204,
-0.5643975734710693,
-0.1122872456908226,
-0.5129401087760925,
0.02318946085870266,
-0.8325470089912415,
-0.32187941670417786,
0.48059821128845215,
-0.1768992841243744,
0.14574986696243286,
0.429391473531723,
-0.8275381326675415,
0.045082759112119675,
0.44976404309272766,
-0.29993128776550293,
0.2909049391746521,
0.267892450094223,
0.01857038587331772,
-0.3538312315940857,
-0.8340427279472351,
-0.5196000933647156,
0.6977864503860474,
0.21665425598621368,
0.44000422954559326,
0.2642698585987091,
0.7770239114761353,
0.8176894187927246,
0.1522238403558731,
-0.49726539850234985,
-0.16827625036239624,
-0.12678579986095428,
-0.44622114300727844,
-0.38772913813591003,
-0.48655614256858826,
-1.11027193069458,
0.16855904459953308,
-0.3570190668106079,
-0.7884386777877808,
0.868618369102478,
0.36869046092033386,
-0.1056663915514946,
0.2883661687374115,
-0.7248269319534302,
0.9133279919624329,
-0.08118602633476257,
-0.2280794084072113,
0.2286878228187561,
-0.5569182634353638,
0.3771563470363617,
-0.05364931747317314,
0.8195221424102783,
0.4817548096179962,
-0.10922115296125412,
0.430198609828949,
-0.11885407567024231,
0.7862039804458618,
0.07864715158939362,
-0.18720589578151703,
0.4611850380897522,
0.2207658290863037,
0.49348217248916626,
0.17185312509536743,
-0.010883248411118984,
-0.02403920143842697,
0.11897911876440048,
-0.41241785883903503,
-0.5551050305366516,
0.8053522706031799,
-0.6221221685409546,
-0.09095102548599243,
-0.544684886932373,
-0.5400350093841553,
-0.09584999084472656,
0.09437519311904907,
0.7008211612701416,
0.6812748312950134,
-0.4348166882991791,
0.1559816598892212,
0.9085328578948975,
-0.3117881715297699,
1.0260640382766724,
0.3188614249229431,
0.17990908026695251,
-0.5514134764671326,
0.978394091129303,
-0.172279492020607,
-0.20126524567604065,
0.5686208605766296,
0.10822825878858566,
-0.1636401116847992,
-0.37074583768844604,
-0.6920526623725891,
-0.3566597104072571,
-0.5776849985122681,
-0.22449763119220734,
-0.9732502698898315,
0.008574170991778374,
-0.5893607139587402,
-0.11829472333192825,
-0.34478530287742615,
-0.28028908371925354,
-0.2918078899383545,
0.3424219489097595,
0.20998035371303558,
0.6403026580810547,
-0.24567683041095734,
0.08496915549039841,
-1.0174850225448608,
-0.0938904881477356,
-0.060684334486722946,
-0.08420998603105545,
-0.007872093468904495,
-0.4242733120918274,
-0.1381029337644577,
-0.33342206478118896,
-0.13919876515865326,
-0.8148835301399231,
0.8096683025360107,
0.13843071460723877,
0.5479665398597717,
0.647565484046936,
0.28951072692871094,
0.10662495344877243,
-0.1752835512161255,
0.7196468710899353,
-0.0676349401473999,
-0.7355471849441528,
0.544072687625885,
-0.779086172580719,
0.3500376343727112,
0.4955868422985077,
0.3841067850589752,
-0.2054765820503235,
-0.6124470829963684,
-0.8689406514167786,
-0.8286569118499756,
0.21915288269519806,
0.5964598655700684,
-0.008706115186214447,
-0.23988063633441925,
0.3387548327445984,
0.17423510551452637,
0.3242407739162445,
-0.6348462104797363,
-0.4024929404258728,
-0.43113306164741516,
-0.6544650197029114,
0.13165226578712463,
-0.07535064965486526,
-0.11828231066465378,
0.10369744151830673,
0.34619295597076416,
-0.10253703594207764,
0.4895167052745819,
0.7288340330123901,
-0.3417544364929199,
0.08884011954069138,
0.2722664177417755,
0.5753220915794373,
0.22361110150814056,
-0.023126624524593353,
0.32820114493370056,
0.2775251567363739,
-0.6804547309875488,
-0.08777604252099991,
0.2207322120666504,
-0.04735936224460602,
0.3124992549419403,
0.5363922119140625,
0.307900071144104,
0.3238447606563568,
-0.546189546585083,
0.7355736494064331,
-0.26203209161758423,
-0.19882705807685852,
-0.5450149774551392,
-0.019076362252235413,
-0.48173779249191284,
-0.11105678230524063,
0.5442232489585876,
0.36019328236579895,
0.7039366364479065,
-0.6031509637832642,
0.3443220555782318,
0.23360329866409302,
-0.3985143303871155,
-0.22916755080223083,
0.42673802375793457,
-0.10650461912155151,
-0.3153674304485321,
0.10275529325008392,
-0.5313080549240112,
-0.6123981475830078,
0.8389744162559509,
0.5072327256202698,
0.6128495335578918,
-0.2041979432106018,
-0.14781291782855988,
0.1933346539735794,
0.5916323065757751,
-0.04420791193842888,
-0.13514123857021332,
0.008186336606740952,
-0.7639976739883423,
0.09022750705480576,
-0.3868630528450012,
-0.1984160989522934,
0.009147589094936848,
-0.7421260476112366,
0.014525343663990498,
-0.12693636119365692,
0.2042357325553894,
-0.3261948823928833,
-0.28825971484184265,
-0.3079293966293335,
0.2540859282016754,
-0.037455130368471146,
0.6451472043991089,
-0.8230617046356201,
0.6324778199195862,
0.7541417479515076,
0.12830545008182526,
-0.34823232889175415,
0.22020061314105988,
0.33077821135520935,
-0.24469491839408875,
0.0743260309100151,
-0.07945909351110458,
-0.010901639237999916,
-0.22879484295845032,
-0.2619607448577881,
-1.0927566289901733,
0.8610870838165283,
-0.05744721740484238,
-0.5705764889717102,
0.28843623399734497,
-0.1633249968290329,
0.694496750831604,
-0.4601130783557892,
0.05151282250881195,
0.5752984285354614,
0.33477142453193665,
-0.49351972341537476,
-0.4633009433746338,
-0.025211771950125694,
-0.4111422300338745,
-0.1277473419904709,
0.46622756123542786,
-0.48651057481765747,
0.5351488590240479,
0.6000736951828003,
0.09255491942167282,
0.16770361363887787,
0.8058920502662659,
-0.06583624333143234,
0.5466940402984619,
0.6654583811759949,
0.34935957193374634,
1.190923810005188,
0.012761491350829601,
1.0747147798538208,
-0.5136303901672363,
0.2826943099498749,
0.7545782923698425,
0.07151556760072708,
0.4677223861217499,
0.06198611482977867,
0.41517356038093567,
0.7300416231155396,
0.4388943016529083,
-0.185073584318161,
0.6255983710289001,
-0.10136110335588455,
-0.28645166754722595,
-0.17657588422298431,
0.2757489085197449,
-0.42734193801879883,
0.5921658277511597,
0.7468151450157166,
-0.41766852140426636,
-0.10835473984479904,
0.2626539468765259,
0.1663132756948471,
0.5351274013519287,
-0.17515750229358673,
0.5614141225814819,
-0.056868698447942734,
-0.6348385810852051,
0.14266686141490936,
0.14214710891246796,
0.9509077072143555,
-0.23586644232273102,
0.021713558584451675,
-0.08499778807163239,
0.474688321352005,
-0.15157298743724823,
-0.2154628187417984,
0.44934022426605225,
0.1301780343055725,
-0.38570740818977356,
-0.10053212195634842,
1.2939481735229492,
-0.3356274366378784,
-0.4529893100261688,
0.120012566447258,
0.4897625148296356,
0.1885852962732315,
0.4764815866947174,
-0.24860642850399017,
0.0173097625374794,
-0.26336872577667236,
0.1306239366531372,
0.3253098726272583,
0.9762319326400757,
-0.12186023592948914,
0.028492094948887825,
0.3937307298183441,
-0.28558266162872314,
-0.029428962618112564,
-0.17133763432502747,
0.6849029660224915,
-0.4702817499637604,
-0.7119348049163818,
-0.7827828526496887,
0.15177829563617706,
-0.5442251563072205,
-0.5483147501945496,
0.9085363149642944,
0.6823925375938416,
0.5439774990081787,
-0.11512274295091629,
1.0007202625274658,
-0.08163917064666748,
0.5821908116340637,
-0.4100348651409149,
0.6932072043418884,
-0.3230748176574707,
0.4375811219215393,
-0.49503293633461,
-0.588086724281311,
-0.30563050508499146,
0.695704996585846,
-0.1572965532541275,
-0.13821041584014893,
0.8270840644836426,
0.80298912525177,
-0.26408669352531433,
0.359487384557724,
0.17547790706157684,
0.24243053793907166,
-0.04510853812098503,
0.10427245497703552,
0.8353255987167358,
-0.6219637989997864,
0.591072142124176,
-0.16058017313480377,
-0.4162008464336395,
-0.015758750960230827,
-0.9854973554611206,
-0.7965769171714783,
-0.4138299524784088,
-0.3680186867713928,
-0.24051128327846527,
0.2581389248371124,
0.7701039910316467,
0.37205612659454346,
-1.0300202369689941,
-0.053120918571949005,
-0.44724467396736145,
0.06708114594221115,
-0.26139840483665466,
-0.37830814719200134,
0.44844821095466614,
-0.7788854837417603,
-0.9067572355270386,
0.5505111813545227,
0.2681131064891815,
-0.007490274030715227,
-0.34419485926628113,
0.34569352865219116,
-0.025012094527482986,
0.026826541870832443,
0.2597951591014862,
0.3134991228580475,
-0.035323575139045715,
-0.2754458487033844,
0.3052193820476532,
-0.20691323280334473,
0.08834421634674072,
0.7894106507301331,
-0.596449077129364,
0.31288376450538635,
0.4475361406803131,
0.8611357808113098,
0.2370220571756363,
0.022819526493549347,
0.7343334555625916,
-0.9223945140838623,
0.2690512537956238,
0.14832471311092377,
0.33061450719833374,
0.4473135769367218,
-0.7352783679962158,
0.3167929947376251,
0.41008755564689636,
-0.6761507987976074,
-0.9673653244972229,
-0.17846177518367767,
-0.7993428111076355,
-0.30189770460128784,
0.9470248222351074,
-0.23171396553516388,
-0.2862725555896759,
-0.4551701545715332,
0.14704211056232452,
0.027289554476737976,
-0.2810911536216736,
1.0812710523605347,
0.6904192566871643,
-0.1723327934741974,
0.1638963371515274,
-0.4428863227367401,
0.6163068413734436,
0.4875383675098419,
-0.795433759689331,
-0.3358781337738037,
0.3282461166381836,
0.24798613786697388,
0.43289878964424133,
0.19971321523189545,
-0.14039598405361176,
0.3798072636127472,
0.11868017166852951,
-0.1664077192544937,
0.3445295989513397,
-0.1741250455379486,
-0.5671115517616272,
0.421924352645874,
-0.2632904350757599,
-0.26871994137763977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19343v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19343v1
|
Luganda Speech Intent Recognition for IoT Applications
| 2024-05-16T10:14:00 | 2024-05-16T10:14:00 |
Andrew Katumba, Sudi Murindanyi, John Trevor Kasule, Elvis Mugume
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
The advent of Internet of Things (IoT) technology has generated massive
interest in voice-controlled smart homes. While many voice-controlled smart
home systems are designed to understand and support widely spoken languages
like English, speakers of low-resource languages like Luganda may need more
support. This research project aimed to develop a Luganda speech intent
classification system for IoT applications to integrate local languages into
smart home environments. The project uses hardware components such as Raspberry
Pi, Wio Terminal, and ESP32 nodes as microcontrollers. The Raspberry Pi
processes Luganda voice commands, the Wio Terminal is a display device, and the
ESP32 nodes control the IoT devices. The ultimate objective of this work was to
enable voice control using Luganda, which was accomplished through a natural
language processing (NLP) model deployed on the Raspberry Pi. The NLP model
utilized Mel Frequency Cepstral Coefficients (MFCCs) as acoustic features and a
Convolutional Neural Network (Conv2D) architecture for speech intent
classification. A dataset of Luganda voice commands was curated for this
purpose and this has been made open-source. This work addresses the
localization challenges and linguistic diversity in IoT applications by
incorporating Luganda voice commands, enabling users to interact with smart
home devices without English proficiency, especially in regions where local
languages are predominant.
|
[
-0.1171988695859909,
-0.791322648525238,
0.3702262043952942,
0.1117536723613739,
-0.06367242336273193,
-0.11585060507059097,
-0.38601574301719666,
-0.684512734413147,
0.4645846486091614,
0.4480729103088379,
-0.48827236890792847,
-0.657100260257721,
-0.44275444746017456,
-0.11402010917663574,
-0.301256000995636,
0.8648383617401123,
0.17726653814315796,
-0.011072082445025444,
0.30195948481559753,
-0.00874336902052164,
-0.6434847116470337,
0.04403921216726303,
-0.6559334397315979,
-0.26278156042099,
0.5922773480415344,
0.563990592956543,
0.3288625478744507,
-0.08876726776361465,
0.21522139012813568,
0.18912261724472046,
0.03586659952998161,
0.2820048928260803,
-0.04304437339305878,
0.08894363790750504,
0.3127093017101288,
-0.5883610844612122,
-0.6852128505706787,
-0.12072040140628815,
0.030853455886244774,
0.2218814492225647,
-0.520280122756958,
0.14240241050720215,
-0.2684188187122345,
0.4955855906009674,
-0.47905221581459045,
0.3279882073402405,
-0.7465798258781433,
0.2417273223400116,
-0.33891311287879944,
-0.18885929882526398,
-0.3526131212711334,
-0.3913865387439728,
0.30620497465133667,
-0.5135380625724792,
-0.047387272119522095,
-0.2600787580013275,
0.5117436647415161,
0.21567922830581665,
-0.038226328790187836,
-0.49198243021965027,
-1.1302543878555298,
0.6552228331565857,
-0.86767578125,
0.37391769886016846,
0.6751980185508728,
0.36407342553138733,
0.17097985744476318,
-0.5661938190460205,
-0.5886483192443848,
-0.14781554043293,
0.03427999094128609,
0.023206153884530067,
-0.31269747018814087,
-0.13023480772972107,
0.17971251904964447,
0.04982338100671768,
-0.742838442325592,
0.08322492986917496,
-0.6114455461502075,
-0.1649971604347229,
0.6582175493240356,
-0.17364488542079926,
0.17192906141281128,
-0.3527027666568756,
-0.26186007261276245,
0.408695787191391,
-0.5077511072158813,
0.4287697970867157,
0.3715934753417969,
0.5839136838912964,
0.06978365778923035,
0.4852977693080902,
-0.46971890330314636,
0.7527012825012207,
-0.04815324768424034,
-0.40793541073799133,
0.16622062027454376,
-0.0017497293883934617,
-0.20122689008712769,
0.9733480215072632,
0.5720385909080505,
0.0216722022742033,
0.07661537826061249,
-0.1075458973646164,
-0.1311008334159851,
-0.07685188949108124,
0.20263011753559113,
-0.39191949367523193,
0.33775919675827026,
0.431316077709198,
-0.3153001666069031,
-0.06326936930418015,
0.02060106210410595,
-0.357880562543869,
-0.2773115038871765,
-0.22360505163669586,
0.3905192017555237,
-0.19702094793319702,
-0.3620826005935669,
0.47458651661872864,
0.31421029567718506,
0.5113988518714905,
0.30647507309913635,
-1.251915454864502,
0.2440398931503296,
0.7489303350448608,
0.6976833343505859,
-0.07202854752540588,
-0.014287403784692287,
-0.41560494899749756,
0.33635374903678894,
0.22725684940814972,
0.4252755343914032,
-0.17858219146728516,
-0.6557478904724121,
-0.22691594064235687,
-0.17092455923557281,
-0.16252002120018005,
-0.36760008335113525,
0.9315301179885864,
-0.5238744020462036,
0.23509129881858826,
0.3993646800518036,
-0.29119813442230225,
-0.3926287293434143,
0.08611493557691574,
-0.46016448736190796,
0.33136478066444397,
-0.10811030864715576,
-0.5695757865905762,
0.2126712203025818,
-1.1238504648208618,
-0.7378726601600647,
0.3711059093475342,
-0.1700800508260727,
-0.46623823046684265,
-0.0786525085568428,
0.0945749506354332,
0.7892798781394958,
-0.01783687435090542,
0.3798169791698456,
0.10271457582712173,
-0.38688552379608154,
0.09267991781234741,
-0.7640511393547058,
0.8327107429504395,
0.42859095335006714,
-0.7141948938369751,
0.28065600991249084,
-0.6572282910346985,
0.1784101277589798,
-0.06736017763614655,
-0.22541043162345886,
-0.2896892726421356,
0.32562026381492615,
0.1532251089811325,
-0.2384626865386963,
0.5184760689735413,
-0.7938583493232727,
-0.02645588479936123,
-0.1757403463125229,
0.6212421655654907,
0.4079831838607788,
-0.42170968651771545,
0.24682216346263885,
0.24015747010707855,
0.40392711758613586,
-0.26989585161209106,
0.5723445415496826,
0.20974543690681458,
-1.170998454093933,
-0.6523795127868652,
0.017178088426589966,
0.2953519821166992,
1.0387604236602783,
-0.3946674168109894,
0.823154866695404,
-0.7248703241348267,
-0.5791505575180054,
-0.7314935922622681,
0.18361367285251617,
0.09859459102153778,
0.4773326814174652,
0.21269702911376953,
0.3369077444076538,
-0.41751205921173096,
-0.7751858830451965,
0.08898899704217911,
0.08246653527021408,
0.026634754613041878,
0.36986950039863586,
-0.06926652789115906,
-0.5796553492546082,
1.2425404787063599,
-0.49057477712631226,
-0.6163097620010376,
-0.21397648751735687,
0.15651167929172516,
0.5435715913772583,
0.22379957139492035,
0.3978806734085083,
-1.0975476503372192,
-0.679166853427887,
0.805963933467865,
-0.4792649745941162,
-0.11170037090778351,
0.44329965114593506,
0.312776118516922,
0.045385900884866714,
0.4785553216934204,
-0.6777745485305786,
0.8086603879928589,
0.7971497774124146,
-0.11867515742778778,
0.13650712370872498,
0.18546749651432037,
-0.04873954877257347,
-1.210608720779419,
0.07217620313167572,
-0.41029566526412964,
-0.32555684447288513,
-0.6455798745155334,
-0.6629996299743652,
-0.30074355006217957,
-0.26534003019332886,
-0.7007830739021301,
0.2865310609340668,
0.12847205996513367,
-0.10923116654157639,
-0.2204882651567459,
0.08684112876653671,
-0.1618187129497528,
0.2953229248523712,
0.22569119930267334,
0.7480437159538269,
0.39931073784828186,
-0.5526562333106995,
0.7297138571739197,
-0.028386743739247322,
-0.3233358561992645,
0.4687669277191162,
-0.604375422000885,
0.011881869286298752,
0.3504221439361572,
-0.1495399922132492,
-0.7398625612258911,
-0.1654849648475647,
0.15711182355880737,
-0.6409645676612854,
0.029368581250309944,
0.09810562431812286,
-0.2035984843969345,
-0.10558783262968063,
-0.3077859580516815,
-0.019938789308071136,
0.47730910778045654,
-0.565222442150116,
0.8006138205528259,
0.27185821533203125,
-0.2574182450771332,
-0.4526357650756836,
-0.7041794657707214,
-0.24294732511043549,
-0.33983638882637024,
-0.4265598952770233,
0.2676185667514801,
-0.06631969660520554,
-0.07283598929643631,
-0.04932878911495209,
0.334517240524292,
-0.14852112531661987,
-0.029774688184261322,
0.39688003063201904,
-0.027630992233753204,
-0.3068685829639435,
-0.09025591611862183,
0.1480422168970108,
-0.1821892410516739,
0.03343164548277855,
-0.3205068111419678,
0.6502776145935059,
-0.25645673274993896,
-0.3018088936805725,
-0.7014868855476379,
0.36513522267341614,
0.7660080790519714,
-0.24515843391418457,
0.39109572768211365,
1.0048737525939941,
-0.39812716841697693,
-0.2562950849533081,
-0.3280298113822937,
-0.08373779058456421,
-0.5029352307319641,
0.11535199731588364,
-0.19763092696666718,
-1.0123519897460938,
0.47139814496040344,
0.20806185901165009,
0.06105485558509827,
0.25976061820983887,
0.1807151436805725,
-0.38655978441238403,
0.906519889831543,
0.32415008544921875,
-0.3885639011859894,
0.7308626770973206,
-0.25753700733184814,
0.5885066390037537,
-1.037426471710205,
-0.11677693575620651,
-0.37200072407722473,
-0.5625805258750916,
-0.5983600616455078,
-0.26428261399269104,
0.5144394636154175,
-0.10009081661701202,
0.22619380056858063,
0.48451587557792664,
-0.5963782072067261,
0.23622117936611176,
0.580529510974884,
0.26346758008003235,
0.36630359292030334,
0.2505761981010437,
0.4123391807079315,
-0.1459517627954483,
-0.5822404623031616,
-0.4951563775539398,
0.9608971476554871,
0.3395606577396393,
0.8175821900367737,
0.38619333505630493,
0.4923988878726959,
0.3554225265979767,
0.1427546888589859,
-0.9603034257888794,
0.5205284953117371,
-0.3773059546947479,
-0.4871620237827301,
-0.3684612214565277,
-0.16931401193141937,
-1.3298165798187256,
-0.31994110345840454,
0.3113650679588318,
-0.9049150347709656,
0.27705058455467224,
-0.14621774852275848,
-0.6610105633735657,
0.3172154128551483,
-1.036647081375122,
0.4924880564212799,
-0.4716906249523163,
0.052210189402103424,
-0.19125431776046753,
-0.48054903745651245,
0.4175526797771454,
0.3103143572807312,
0.015379129908978939,
-0.11632959544658661,
0.23253707587718964,
0.7092458009719849,
-0.03905824199318886,
0.9807810187339783,
-0.34469103813171387,
-0.5082159042358398,
0.4915197193622589,
-0.33384644985198975,
0.27488115429878235,
0.4348808526992798,
-0.02457728236913681,
0.30303266644477844,
-0.3799763321876526,
-0.1309194713830948,
-0.3531213402748108,
0.9553050398826599,
-0.584932804107666,
-0.07417351752519608,
-0.20093631744384766,
-0.08104152232408524,
-0.19407658278942108,
0.24891959130764008,
0.32283836603164673,
0.21674704551696777,
-0.1652793139219284,
0.5205018520355225,
1.0243172645568848,
0.08543918281793594,
0.7191139459609985,
0.5740625858306885,
-0.5579380989074707,
-0.23833265900611877,
1.0837047100067139,
0.2405075579881668,
0.07023207098245621,
0.5725212097167969,
0.23670868575572968,
-0.13539837300777435,
-0.39354172348976135,
-0.270391583442688,
-0.22780272364616394,
-0.5605775713920593,
-0.28024062514305115,
-0.4543505609035492,
-0.518022894859314,
-0.20137926936149597,
-0.22745123505592346,
-0.32461079955101013,
-0.116834357380867,
-0.5280758142471313,
-0.0858544260263443,
0.7312203049659729,
0.7571470737457275,
0.3467530608177185,
0.5932649374008179,
-0.6636119484901428,
0.4039277732372284,
0.9997085928916931,
0.42050448060035706,
-0.45463576912879944,
-0.21729673445224762,
-0.2756165862083435,
0.09079841524362564,
-0.022475816309452057,
-0.690278947353363,
0.05426124110817909,
0.31263309717178345,
0.4897628128528595,
0.6444926261901855,
-0.21245840191841125,
0.1854906529188156,
-0.29666221141815186,
0.7515378594398499,
-0.018389888107776642,
-0.9074650406837463,
1.069422960281372,
-0.6162819862365723,
0.2193061113357544,
0.518858790397644,
0.06134747341275215,
-0.4341447353363037,
0.30723822116851807,
-0.528870165348053,
-0.6207609176635742,
0.6687226891517639,
-0.0016683645080775023,
0.16576439142227173,
0.23643498122692108,
0.21684926748275757,
-0.011751106940209866,
0.3483128249645233,
-0.8072305917739868,
-0.0005845738342031837,
-0.07539591938257217,
-0.4004501402378082,
0.16017231345176697,
0.17156000435352325,
-0.01878877356648445,
-0.4604247808456421,
0.4105871319770813,
-0.24746473133563995,
0.4842650890350342,
0.2119152843952179,
-0.09940372407436371,
0.24862293899059296,
0.41562288999557495,
1.1176326274871826,
0.13156826794147491,
-0.37605786323547363,
-0.17592431604862213,
0.09781826287508011,
-0.824288547039032,
-0.18664546310901642,
0.12059420347213745,
-0.43089374899864197,
0.3759215176105499,
0.14525407552719116,
0.9167540073394775,
0.14380592107772827,
-0.5643744468688965,
0.4217540919780731,
-0.47437840700149536,
0.10610433667898178,
-0.4415218234062195,
0.33750006556510925,
0.28386926651000977,
0.013863506726920605,
0.19257068634033203,
0.2871033549308777,
0.30649083852767944,
-0.24028943479061127,
-0.24310900270938873,
0.42526116967201233,
-0.5188962817192078,
-0.2779451310634613,
0.3607986271381378,
0.571096658706665,
-0.7307656407356262,
0.34180593490600586,
-0.4914521276950836,
-0.5665038824081421,
0.40974023938179016,
0.2063397318124771,
1.252090573310852,
-0.6621392965316772,
0.2036273032426834,
0.20318523049354553,
0.35419410467147827,
0.4412100613117218,
0.9333937168121338,
-0.26479262113571167,
-0.6895272135734558,
-0.25136977434158325,
-0.4520954191684723,
-0.3290591239929199,
0.16217894852161407,
-0.35025307536125183,
0.4486504793167114,
-0.5877707600593567,
-0.263488233089447,
-0.346568763256073,
-0.2055865079164505,
-0.4606025218963623,
0.20373286306858063,
0.4821544289588928,
0.34027406573295593,
-0.5337115526199341,
0.9516915678977966,
0.6005610823631287,
0.16498103737831116,
-0.8127941489219666,
-0.061750926077365875,
-0.46265819668769836,
-0.5476028323173523,
0.6017732620239258,
0.14521124958992004,
-0.7478747963905334,
0.2886296212673187,
-0.48207199573516846,
-0.4980069398880005,
1.2919176816940308,
0.07452330738306046,
-0.6521109938621521,
0.5898913741111755,
0.11260849237442017,
0.42181381583213806,
-0.2948305308818817,
-0.06895937025547028,
0.3551362454891205,
0.7776238918304443,
-0.5079923272132874,
-1.2721168994903564,
-0.6179555058479309,
-0.2522296905517578,
-0.26987093687057495,
-0.011258147656917572,
-0.37773194909095764,
0.5696289539337158,
-0.030028628185391426,
0.1324337124824524,
-0.20672525465488434,
0.5868402123451233,
-0.0652131587266922,
0.49372878670692444,
0.424760639667511,
0.3106381595134735,
0.4963603913784027,
-0.2807030975818634,
0.5756964683532715,
0.012932302430272102,
0.20328734815120697,
0.8909603953361511,
-0.4483204483985901,
1.3134467601776123,
0.47328484058380127,
-0.44345077872276306,
0.49710580706596375,
0.26883214712142944,
0.4990725517272949,
0.7300218343734741,
-0.1767454594373703,
-0.7374922633171082,
0.5586857199668884,
-0.43336784839630127,
-0.3108063042163849,
0.7939590811729431,
0.9764142632484436,
-0.0005875711212866008,
0.08887487649917603,
0.45676642656326294,
-0.022229593247175217,
-0.10437384992837906,
-0.3213290274143219,
0.7849193811416626,
-0.0663432851433754,
-0.2660558223724365,
0.33589690923690796,
0.015744775533676147,
1.3913078308105469,
-1.0825400352478027,
0.06985713541507721,
0.16087067127227783,
0.2065654844045639,
-0.5921710729598999,
-0.5544069409370422,
0.5471640825271606,
0.1001533716917038,
-0.3645678162574768,
-0.3331260085105896,
0.6798437237739563,
-0.45961621403694153,
-0.3792600929737091,
0.4289584755897522,
0.0919705480337143,
0.0631379708647728,
-0.0536234974861145,
-0.5909645557403564,
0.12047157436609268,
0.14639848470687866,
-0.1388101875782013,
-0.08911231905221939,
0.17764130234718323,
-0.035799577832221985,
0.3895220160484314,
0.8343690633773804,
0.19831861555576324,
0.3520330786705017,
0.1594969481229782,
0.2771885395050049,
-0.3340240716934204,
-0.6703084111213684,
-0.4147331118583679,
0.4099177420139313,
-0.0029898718930780888,
-0.49166980385780334,
0.5849214792251587,
0.4351471960544586,
0.7842079997062683,
-0.24865864217281342,
0.693436861038208,
-0.5569365620613098,
0.5600169897079468,
-0.5143537521362305,
0.7675505876541138,
-0.2650608718395233,
0.32365918159484863,
0.05529572069644928,
-0.8388979434967041,
-0.0663466602563858,
0.8722484707832336,
-0.3829132318496704,
0.06955277174711227,
0.3282417356967926,
0.48338428139686584,
-0.2644920349121094,
0.22490355372428894,
0.4426597058773041,
-0.17318271100521088,
0.39765211939811707,
0.44649538397789,
0.5095440149307251,
-0.587939977645874,
0.2062709778547287,
-0.19865837693214417,
0.13726116716861725,
-0.4871900677680969,
-0.6754431128501892,
-0.41304919123649597,
-0.6682693362236023,
-0.21071089804172516,
0.17306403815746307,
-0.20825417339801788,
0.8450599908828735,
0.9951252937316895,
-0.861117959022522,
-0.3351423144340515,
-0.2225908786058426,
0.22467423975467682,
-0.21057096123695374,
-0.36128589510917664,
0.044085316359996796,
0.1488477885723114,
-0.874254584312439,
0.830456018447876,
0.4504607021808624,
-0.019094346091151237,
-0.5295169949531555,
-0.3519038259983063,
-0.32466062903404236,
-0.2771412432193756,
0.6714013814926147,
0.4715458154678345,
-0.8897922039031982,
0.012881320901215076,
0.062217459082603455,
-0.16014692187309265,
0.020280921831727028,
0.6317560076713562,
-0.6896809339523315,
0.5362681746482849,
0.5940793752670288,
0.42197123169898987,
0.22620731592178345,
-0.16322441399097443,
0.2478511780500412,
-0.9937533140182495,
0.2704916298389435,
0.5236794948577881,
0.24153661727905273,
0.3850385844707489,
-0.6269265413284302,
0.3101121783256531,
-0.0270619448274374,
-0.42553529143333435,
-0.5324875116348267,
0.12263677269220352,
-1.1719796657562256,
0.05305318161845207,
0.8277376294136047,
-0.005001992452889681,
-0.28695106506347656,
-0.286765992641449,
-0.5947976112365723,
-0.02294577844440937,
-0.39575639367103577,
0.31724032759666443,
0.4922142028808594,
-0.3963623344898224,
-0.14270024001598358,
-1.1997301578521729,
0.3845512270927429,
0.4886157810688019,
-1.0400289297103882,
-0.05856144055724144,
-0.16416499018669128,
-0.09064824879169464,
0.6267083883285522,
0.6379357576370239,
0.028347624465823174,
0.3936726152896881,
-0.614084780216217,
0.10992451012134552,
0.2896340489387512,
-0.2125670462846756,
-0.4057886302471161,
-0.1807967722415924,
-0.1208154708147049,
-0.4676963686943054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09948v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09948v1
|
Mitigating Text Toxicity with Counterfactual Generation
| 2024-05-16T09:52:21 | 2024-05-16T09:52:21 |
Milan Bhan, Jean-Noel Vittaut, Nina Achache, Victor Legrand, Nicolas Chesneau, Annabelle Blangero, Juliette Murris, Marie-Jeanne Lesot
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Toxicity mitigation consists in rephrasing text in order to remove offensive
or harmful meaning. Neural natural language processing (NLP) models have been
widely used to target and mitigate textual toxicity. However, existing methods
fail to detoxify text while preserving the initial non-toxic meaning at the
same time. In this work, we propose to apply counterfactual generation methods
from the eXplainable AI (XAI) field to target and mitigate textual toxicity. In
particular, we perform text detoxification by applying local feature importance
and counterfactual generation methods to a toxicity classifier distinguishing
between toxic and non-toxic texts. We carry out text detoxification through
counterfactual generation on three datasets and compare our approach to three
competitors. Automatic and human evaluations show that recently developed NLP
counterfactual generators can mitigate toxicity accurately while better
preserving the meaning of the initial text as compared to classical
detoxification methods. Finally, we take a step back from using automated
detoxification tools, and discuss how to manage the polysemous nature of
toxicity and the risk of malicious use of detoxification tools. This work is
the first to bridge the gap between counterfactual generation and text
detoxification and paves the way towards more practical application of XAI
methods.
|
[
-0.27703338861465454,
-0.8693974614143372,
0.5455176830291748,
-0.09417816996574402,
-0.3941952884197235,
-0.2522996962070465,
0.2515689432621002,
-0.5007808804512024,
-0.026758862659335136,
0.5915948152542114,
-0.6236560344696045,
-0.19688177108764648,
-0.3613468408584595,
0.14955388009548187,
-0.48662593960762024,
1.4623891115188599,
0.1634889841079712,
-0.23494146764278412,
-0.39819449186325073,
-0.39480045437812805,
-0.4626826345920563,
-0.5042685866355896,
-1.0920653343200684,
-0.5931897163391113,
0.8690389394760132,
0.3426347076892853,
0.752288281917572,
0.4694817066192627,
0.24412128329277039,
0.30706146359443665,
-0.04668230190873146,
-0.05094016715884209,
-0.43985551595687866,
0.31352293491363525,
-0.6364983916282654,
-0.6852710843086243,
0.023725716397166252,
0.15389251708984375,
0.1361454725265503,
0.11599282175302505,
-0.10391228646039963,
-0.1302117258310318,
-0.2204591929912567,
0.6759300231933594,
-0.5779631733894348,
-0.048645734786987305,
-0.7974185943603516,
0.332079142332077,
-0.0333905853331089,
-0.5021499991416931,
-0.4945380985736847,
-0.248587504029274,
0.31035351753234863,
-0.6383967399597168,
-0.10296790301799774,
0.01570587232708931,
0.7271896004676819,
0.5719785094261169,
-0.48372048139572144,
-0.3224574327468872,
-0.7219640016555786,
0.953433632850647,
-0.8583542108535767,
-0.05020792782306671,
0.3513179123401642,
-0.020955704152584076,
0.10755100846290588,
-0.5804650783538818,
-0.716590166091919,
-0.28972652554512024,
-0.2803407609462738,
0.2984851002693176,
-0.45470568537712097,
-0.0905940905213356,
0.17421790957450867,
0.10580352693796158,
-0.8144365549087524,
0.10197433084249496,
-0.06772713363170624,
-0.11888329684734344,
0.796931266784668,
0.22955289483070374,
0.922050416469574,
-0.34835225343704224,
-0.5359180569648743,
0.006361878477036953,
-0.8493012189865112,
-0.18253730237483978,
0.25417765974998474,
-0.0011513748904690146,
0.20668785274028778,
0.3135492205619812,
0.1673728972673416,
-0.03637644276022911,
-0.2556433379650116,
0.26270875334739685,
0.3011302053928375,
-0.48197585344314575,
-0.37096068263053894,
0.4167102873325348,
0.9394658803939819,
0.5232051610946655,
0.28330451250076294,
-0.1713612824678421,
0.2141600400209427,
0.17998921871185303,
0.7792505621910095,
-1.0393257141113281,
-0.193013533949852,
0.5304723381996155,
-0.6718594431877136,
-0.8680042028427124,
-0.5835769176483154,
-0.916662335395813,
-0.3898041248321533,
0.062438324093818665,
0.5461461544036865,
-0.5160898566246033,
-0.39339929819107056,
-0.2709212303161621,
-0.34277427196502686,
-0.041354160755872726,
-0.04956234619021416,
-0.7828916311264038,
-0.01536173652857542,
0.2533431351184845,
0.8144514560699463,
-0.08316902816295624,
0.07497565448284149,
-0.36177322268486023,
0.10985058546066284,
-0.3136439323425293,
0.7335377931594849,
-0.542640209197998,
-0.2748000919818878,
-0.15446922183036804,
-0.36856505274772644,
-0.006824319250881672,
-0.6366952061653137,
0.7862617373466492,
-0.2719167470932007,
0.4612913131713867,
-0.22673070430755615,
-0.2031954526901245,
-0.3905828893184662,
0.35459819436073303,
-0.7095133662223816,
0.9358159303665161,
-0.20589691400527954,
-1.0786936283111572,
0.2709788382053375,
-0.8504831194877625,
-0.566167414188385,
0.03536219522356987,
0.09722103923559189,
-0.8274147510528564,
0.10100848972797394,
-0.07780154794454575,
0.03734550252556801,
-0.1298523098230362,
0.33039405941963196,
-0.12213218957185745,
-0.1853911280632019,
0.13736914098262787,
-0.724856972694397,
0.9438173770904541,
0.34068506956100464,
-0.7021141648292542,
0.44832125306129456,
-0.5592960715293884,
0.11378981918096542,
0.14787544310092926,
-0.0882975310087204,
-0.7843968868255615,
0.14261913299560547,
0.20433753728866577,
0.6519367694854736,
-0.26109614968299866,
-0.5586404204368591,
-0.46764346957206726,
-0.6808380484580994,
0.5666358470916748,
0.4395408630371094,
0.31254491209983826,
0.21182067692279816,
-0.6627592444419861,
0.41873812675476074,
0.22450733184814453,
0.10738860815763474,
-0.39459753036499023,
-0.5401819944381714,
-0.5789356827735901,
0.010465702973306179,
-0.2373906970024109,
0.8537178039550781,
-1.2629181146621704,
0.42324379086494446,
0.025380814447999,
-0.7428632378578186,
-0.18397262692451477,
-0.07071619480848312,
0.7999454736709595,
0.9078712463378906,
0.6862391233444214,
0.033442091196775436,
-0.4994826018810272,
-0.7749119997024536,
-0.4024921655654907,
-0.4686862528324127,
-0.06775596737861633,
0.3573407828807831,
0.47579148411750793,
-0.40562403202056885,
0.7572052478790283,
-0.39073145389556885,
-0.3020387887954712,
-0.17555630207061768,
0.6394705772399902,
-0.2868139445781708,
0.4559580087661743,
0.7969967722892761,
-1.067625880241394,
-0.36846664547920227,
-0.003290516324341297,
-0.91903156042099,
-0.4303120970726013,
-0.6629489660263062,
-0.11021626740694046,
0.31109482049942017,
0.6710882782936096,
-0.609963059425354,
0.5569924712181091,
0.1829931139945984,
-0.2129872441291809,
0.6152125597000122,
-0.28927505016326904,
0.12435956299304962,
-0.7363074421882629,
0.3886411190032959,
0.20356522500514984,
-0.19968925416469574,
-0.9205654263496399,
0.23593762516975403,
-0.2921997606754303,
-0.03274909779429436,
-0.728079617023468,
0.7234278917312622,
0.005208933725953102,
0.6728412508964539,
-0.32353490591049194,
0.2510828971862793,
0.3064252734184265,
0.40872353315353394,
0.29373279213905334,
0.44180864095687866,
0.11251547187566757,
-0.3479543924331665,
0.07976718246936798,
0.2652286887168884,
0.10220970958471298,
0.664067804813385,
-0.6442427039146423,
-0.24717384576797485,
-0.4485814869403839,
0.2730540633201599,
-0.947036862373352,
0.36953747272491455,
0.501990795135498,
-0.22990454733371735,
-0.013786322437226772,
0.26205575466156006,
-0.38202905654907227,
-0.058989983052015305,
-0.47012728452682495,
0.2871212363243103,
0.38889792561531067,
-0.4249015152454376,
0.45577695965766907,
0.10785995423793793,
-0.4041370153427124,
-0.3333071172237396,
-0.8637788891792297,
0.37150198221206665,
-0.7571218013763428,
-0.34753939509391785,
0.3025651276111603,
-0.3048511743545532,
-0.2579311728477478,
-0.048853907734155655,
-0.13645270466804504,
0.03210779279470444,
0.2180023342370987,
0.2790011763572693,
0.13777099549770355,
0.05619385093450546,
0.3963600695133209,
0.457882821559906,
-0.47165414690971375,
0.5433933734893799,
0.18850915133953094,
0.14361557364463806,
0.24234512448310852,
0.16941004991531372,
-0.37216997146606445,
0.7220093607902527,
0.3481743037700653,
-0.2673836648464203,
0.8959848284721375,
0.6453738212585449,
-0.2178834080696106,
-0.21186795830726624,
-0.03186750039458275,
-0.07512371242046356,
-0.4598730206489563,
0.477517694234848,
0.010386059060692787,
-0.29919326305389404,
0.40846654772758484,
-0.06932202726602554,
0.16488227248191833,
0.5402711629867554,
0.5572001338005066,
-0.13823536038398743,
1.0313560962677002,
0.27242618799209595,
0.15508334338665009,
0.658841073513031,
-0.004594988655298948,
0.35049882531166077,
-0.4457542598247528,
-0.01835023984313011,
-0.4941422939300537,
-0.13924749195575714,
-0.5551682710647583,
-0.08930467069149017,
0.2880147695541382,
-0.34245020151138306,
-0.4913344085216522,
0.14200948178768158,
-0.5271837115287781,
0.4968397617340088,
0.6032430529594421,
0.30446258187294006,
0.2361087054014206,
-0.06578689068555832,
-0.21902033686637878,
-0.2074800580739975,
-0.5284708738327026,
-0.6431025862693787,
0.6991555690765381,
0.31083017587661743,
0.3258216679096222,
0.05740999057888985,
0.7258802652359009,
0.24595999717712402,
0.8452615141868591,
-0.3747376799583435,
0.40391162037849426,
-0.46156617999076843,
-1.0234076976776123,
-0.35963863134384155,
-0.6935179829597473,
-0.5551915168762207,
0.24578270316123962,
-0.5361481308937073,
-0.6567538380622864,
0.018327420577406883,
0.17525385320186615,
-0.21774011850357056,
0.36951181292533875,
-0.9015215039253235,
0.9890947341918945,
-0.24285666644573212,
-0.42279180884361267,
-0.23494434356689453,
-0.7569223046302795,
0.35954582691192627,
-0.3779028058052063,
0.3068922460079193,
0.2133411467075348,
0.13571330904960632,
0.5649522542953491,
-0.3936992883682251,
0.8359196782112122,
-0.14753808081150055,
-0.2805889844894409,
0.32201510667800903,
0.11654112488031387,
0.2802741825580597,
0.1685187965631485,
-0.4394620954990387,
0.23876306414604187,
0.03383287042379379,
-0.10966562479734421,
-0.4685497283935547,
0.6992073059082031,
-0.5950703024864197,
-0.47418904304504395,
-0.33033937215805054,
-0.5220926403999329,
0.11225496977567673,
0.6542966961860657,
0.6228443384170532,
0.12295883893966675,
-0.33444586396217346,
-0.0715838223695755,
0.8501909375190735,
-0.8062649965286255,
0.6674495339393616,
0.10633602738380432,
0.01640610583126545,
-0.2675553262233734,
1.1854583024978638,
0.029209550470113754,
0.3337886929512024,
0.46140527725219727,
0.5828090310096741,
-0.3353044390678406,
-0.6277147531509399,
-0.3401702046394348,
-0.19162406027317047,
-0.6310691237449646,
-0.28275373578071594,
-0.6461480259895325,
-0.3000122904777527,
-0.04291730746626854,
-0.11279071122407913,
-0.03638346493244171,
-0.10964911431074142,
-0.5456978678703308,
-0.22887022793293,
0.20064693689346313,
0.5346506834030151,
-0.08036962151527405,
0.360396146774292,
-0.98919677734375,
0.6074798107147217,
0.10241633653640747,
0.2460273802280426,
0.0685008242726326,
-0.10945434868335724,
-0.02139180712401867,
0.248263418674469,
-0.3599730432033539,
-0.9407709240913391,
0.5803992748260498,
0.2500018775463104,
0.7276434302330017,
0.5490239262580872,
0.562289297580719,
0.2493090033531189,
-0.49108248949050903,
0.676228404045105,
0.1685437709093094,
-0.9907781481742859,
0.6535797119140625,
-0.3738771677017212,
0.32808852195739746,
0.5803951025009155,
0.607806921005249,
-0.7755783200263977,
-0.6639713048934937,
-0.3767719268798828,
-1.1023168563842773,
0.514413058757782,
0.5922326445579529,
0.35713067650794983,
-0.3510245382785797,
0.4164634048938751,
0.3070548474788666,
0.1114402562379837,
-0.8945165872573853,
-0.471072256565094,
-0.5975057482719421,
-0.4441336691379547,
-0.014237080700695515,
-0.32029831409454346,
-0.20527267456054688,
0.19965867698192596,
0.9522063136100769,
0.12726226449012756,
-0.08058992773294449,
0.36523282527923584,
-0.416957288980484,
-0.2596694529056549,
0.36759287118911743,
0.5201321840286255,
0.1389797031879425,
-0.18145930767059326,
0.1203944981098175,
0.00026599946431815624,
-0.550263524055481,
0.21733808517456055,
0.10258590430021286,
-0.5085324645042419,
-0.2474624216556549,
0.468610554933548,
0.5734333992004395,
0.11804123222827911,
-0.6726557016372681,
0.18378295004367828,
-0.28299131989479065,
-0.24080392718315125,
-0.018480852246284485,
0.4087972342967987,
0.05198737233877182,
-0.053721070289611816,
0.29067468643188477,
0.20280393958091736,
0.28241223096847534,
-0.5890566110610962,
0.38755178451538086,
0.29681816697120667,
-0.5129499435424805,
-0.005320501048117876,
0.9513981342315674,
0.563671350479126,
-0.11933325231075287,
0.6499972343444824,
-0.10248126089572906,
-0.43623632192611694,
0.7526229619979858,
0.5470074415206909,
0.9815678000450134,
-0.1677691787481308,
0.5455752015113831,
0.41908013820648193,
0.42594313621520996,
0.5003223419189453,
0.05885974317789078,
0.13329344987869263,
-0.6033312082290649,
-0.3154680132865906,
-0.2952268421649933,
-0.16507039964199066,
0.26450127363204956,
-0.39089804887771606,
-0.11107952147722244,
-0.5522972941398621,
0.09549929946660995,
0.3573061227798462,
-0.02455136552453041,
-0.08055111020803452,
0.5742967128753662,
0.2131396383047104,
0.8268693685531616,
-1.3423187732696533,
0.49639374017715454,
0.554792046546936,
-0.6877456903457642,
-0.29267701506614685,
0.20264452695846558,
0.3203263580799103,
-0.2507425844669342,
0.5881264209747314,
0.5358582139015198,
-0.08087050169706345,
-0.15629030764102936,
-0.419307678937912,
-0.36950668692588806,
0.7482757568359375,
0.29087021946907043,
-0.40499716997146606,
-0.020946774631738663,
0.24967272579669952,
0.9300105571746826,
-0.008120766840875149,
0.6998955607414246,
0.481553316116333,
0.5617802739143372,
0.13871482014656067,
-0.39665836095809937,
0.53141850233078,
-0.7090842723846436,
-0.044001463800668716,
-0.013427733443677425,
-0.35965070128440857,
0.2786294221878052,
-0.1537657231092453,
-0.187441885471344,
0.14957009255886078,
0.33908143639564514,
0.08189519494771957,
0.6168608069419861,
0.6702060699462891,
0.7183327674865723,
0.4369986355304718,
0.1745615303516388,
0.8302276134490967,
0.2112317979335785,
-0.039046771824359894,
1.0992125272750854,
-0.3142082393169403,
0.5669481158256531,
0.44055676460266113,
0.23868833482265472,
0.8094406723976135,
0.4152461290359497,
0.056774869561195374,
0.4706277549266815,
0.26521989703178406,
-0.4305615723133087,
-0.16705361008644104,
-0.2214750051498413,
-0.04689915105700493,
0.444637268781662,
0.36560243368148804,
-0.5977986454963684,
-0.5716065168380737,
0.334200382232666,
0.3079163730144501,
0.30894699692726135,
-0.19178389012813568,
0.9160165786743164,
-0.026499439030885696,
-0.6313314437866211,
0.2300427258014679,
-0.1902473419904709,
0.5594155192375183,
-0.3873273432254791,
-0.2883225679397583,
-0.24696201086044312,
0.10422857850790024,
-0.31771615147590637,
-0.7307054996490479,
0.7638269066810608,
-0.1420954316854477,
-0.2829210162162781,
-0.4489390254020691,
0.8339828848838806,
-0.40344876050949097,
-0.2925283908843994,
0.4155934154987335,
0.11873966455459595,
-0.02038445882499218,
-0.24548950791358948,
-0.879310667514801,
-0.3510705232620239,
-0.059497591108083725,
-0.25523462891578674,
0.20737753808498383,
0.40267306566238403,
-0.45209604501724243,
0.7034804224967957,
0.7436372637748718,
-0.05277196317911148,
-0.2582361400127411,
0.029884006828069687,
0.8288844227790833,
-0.7376226782798767,
-0.5786493420600891,
-0.8821700811386108,
0.6843511462211609,
-0.024982374161481857,
-0.3065759241580963,
0.5031846165657043,
0.12411326169967651,
0.46017467975616455,
0.22321367263793945,
0.7879694104194641,
0.058340057730674744,
0.2082873433828354,
-0.2774712145328522,
1.374544382095337,
-0.5112472176551819,
0.1987057775259018,
-0.453118234872818,
-0.6074879765510559,
-0.5831093788146973,
0.3806565999984741,
-0.2867782711982727,
0.1846536099910736,
0.6675926446914673,
0.595303475856781,
0.2979687750339508,
0.09676790237426758,
0.2592785060405731,
0.5276239514350891,
0.6056368947029114,
0.47638675570487976,
0.5138078331947327,
-0.44416800141334534,
0.8843704462051392,
-0.2577441930770874,
-0.3699391186237335,
-0.0719023048877716,
-1.3089866638183594,
-0.9244102239608765,
-0.455762654542923,
-0.5257112979888916,
-0.23988372087478638,
0.10534750670194626,
0.42318543791770935,
0.48916247487068176,
-0.6484628915786743,
0.6339260935783386,
-0.34621164202690125,
0.5456193685531616,
-0.2922567129135132,
-0.320300430059433,
0.11789003014564514,
-0.27304092049598694,
-0.5553605556488037,
0.04533571004867554,
0.32923734188079834,
-0.17690494656562805,
-0.17808713018894196,
0.15980803966522217,
-0.528663694858551,
0.4688319265842438,
0.7080479860305786,
0.37967410683631897,
-0.2970309853553772,
-0.48990398645401,
-0.4179016947746277,
-0.13946698606014252,
-0.04197967052459717,
0.5522328019142151,
-0.9801064133644104,
0.487636923789978,
0.7255544662475586,
0.3684069812297821,
0.0908038541674614,
-0.13643871247768402,
0.5669437050819397,
-0.7985002398490906,
-0.12843511998653412,
0.09606199711561203,
0.02836490608751774,
0.25839003920555115,
-0.7708407640457153,
0.40059179067611694,
-0.07447647303342819,
-0.38438573479652405,
-0.7404357194900513,
0.2530902028083801,
-0.6040811538696289,
-0.6074274778366089,
0.8299433588981628,
-0.3617797791957855,
-0.20732372999191284,
-0.44873473048210144,
-0.38858363032341003,
0.41451674699783325,
-0.12100901454687119,
1.0087441205978394,
0.3962160050868988,
-0.12314477562904358,
-0.2924060821533203,
-0.4235418736934662,
0.5828573703765869,
0.5927294492721558,
-1.4751510620117188,
0.20831826329231262,
0.17896996438503265,
0.2511768341064453,
0.4207105040550232,
0.3448634445667267,
-0.29018959403038025,
0.37838080525398254,
0.10788779705762863,
-0.03545548766851425,
0.05436702072620392,
-0.2159615308046341,
-0.15756335854530334,
-0.13681140542030334,
-0.5709106922149658,
0.08792081475257874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09939v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09939v1
|
SciQAG: A Framework for Auto-Generated Scientific Question Answering Dataset with Fine-grained Evaluation
| 2024-05-16T09:42:37 | 2024-05-16T09:42:37 |
Yuwei Wan, Aswathy Ajith, Yixuan Liu, Ke Lu, Clara Grazian, Bram Hoex, Wenjie Zhang, Chunyu Kit, Tong Xie, Ian Foster
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The use of question-answer (QA) pairs for training and evaluating large
language models (LLMs) has attracted considerable attention. Yet few available
QA datasets are based on knowledge from the scientific literature. Here we
bridge this gap by presenting Automatic Generation of Scientific Question
Answers (SciQAG), a framework for automatic generation and evaluation of
scientific QA pairs sourced from published scientific literature. We fine-tune
an open-source LLM to generate \num{960000} scientific QA pairs from full-text
scientific papers and propose a five-dimensional metric to evaluate the quality
of the generated QA pairs. We show via LLM-based evaluation that the generated
QA pairs consistently achieve an average score of 2.5 out of 3 across five
dimensions, indicating that our framework can distill key knowledge from papers
into high-quality QA pairs at scale. We make the dataset, models, and
evaluation codes publicly available.
|
[
-0.24695515632629395,
-0.46358218789100647,
0.7052562832832336,
0.23560674488544464,
-0.29781845211982727,
0.03041575290262699,
0.1029774621129036,
-0.3632579445838928,
0.2176210582256317,
0.2139018326997757,
-0.37034475803375244,
-0.5686290860176086,
-0.31713801622390747,
0.439960241317749,
-0.4670506715774536,
1.032472014427185,
0.17066305875778198,
0.4133836328983307,
-0.817973256111145,
0.015530428849160671,
0.13109621405601501,
0.016081148758530617,
-0.3201179802417755,
-0.13387712836265564,
0.47079548239707947,
0.28706666827201843,
0.7740039825439453,
0.8425694704055786,
0.6417903900146484,
0.22132377326488495,
0.07181917130947113,
0.2790915369987488,
-0.42700132727622986,
0.08194447308778763,
-0.2518827021121979,
-0.25762587785720825,
-0.3120494782924652,
0.21685846149921417,
0.7705579996109009,
0.7404899597167969,
-0.009928283281624317,
0.7743967771530151,
-0.10524309426546097,
0.5678589940071106,
-0.18199458718299866,
0.09383703768253326,
-0.4752289950847626,
0.0041351523250341415,
0.07905323058366776,
-0.2983855903148651,
-0.2321794182062149,
-0.7298439145088196,
0.053273752331733704,
-0.8389933109283447,
0.29027584195137024,
0.2357345074415207,
0.8095049858093262,
0.310956209897995,
-0.28921443223953247,
-0.4703543782234192,
-0.43127667903900146,
0.5964192152023315,
-0.7389017939567566,
0.02967938594520092,
0.17232976853847504,
0.14747382700443268,
-0.37086221575737,
-0.9260093569755554,
-0.5779438614845276,
-0.2236260175704956,
-0.10512343794107437,
0.21279655396938324,
-0.13115954399108887,
0.03518921881914139,
0.22546416521072388,
0.4916771948337555,
-1.0493427515029907,
-0.15624140202999115,
-0.7703956365585327,
0.13665783405303955,
0.9996799826622009,
0.14351339638233185,
0.35907289385795593,
-0.5377159118652344,
-0.20310571789741516,
-0.046193577349185944,
-0.630062997341156,
-0.012845419347286224,
0.09040947258472443,
-0.012180997058749199,
0.22007019817829132,
0.7276158928871155,
-0.25404369831085205,
0.588546872138977,
0.36646828055381775,
0.17589394748210907,
0.1792992502450943,
-0.5905771255493164,
-0.20292147994041443,
0.03581404685974121,
1.1715893745422363,
0.40885472297668457,
-0.05124618113040924,
-0.3444782495498657,
0.14322488009929657,
-0.27017971873283386,
0.1850973218679428,
-0.9870025515556335,
-0.37009871006011963,
0.377309650182724,
-0.38502612709999084,
-0.3186049163341522,
0.00027008578763343394,
-0.7109878063201904,
-0.2690509557723999,
-0.1958458572626114,
0.47983551025390625,
-0.20147883892059326,
0.268865168094635,
0.20990745723247528,
-0.06750427931547165,
0.30209365487098694,
0.1660565584897995,
-0.5150978565216064,
0.07184011489152908,
0.3750300407409668,
0.7119842171669006,
-0.20788268744945526,
-0.0976782739162445,
-0.6005784869194031,
0.13260924816131592,
-0.4360045790672302,
0.8939785361289978,
-0.3542582094669342,
-0.44005507230758667,
-0.5274813771247864,
-0.10331118106842041,
0.0850144475698471,
-0.36890044808387756,
0.4161017835140228,
-0.7347994446754456,
0.6605133414268494,
-0.275138258934021,
-0.5212673544883728,
0.007183218840509653,
0.04516412690281868,
-0.5493631958961487,
1.1196541786193848,
0.17015986144542694,
-0.7756732106208801,
0.33677157759666443,
-0.7945197224617004,
-0.01005465816706419,
0.4893404245376587,
-0.11142580956220627,
-0.2340582013130188,
-0.09268029034137726,
0.43757811188697815,
0.3637060225009918,
-0.717880368232727,
0.49585458636283875,
-0.4875253736972809,
-0.17305906116962433,
0.2437024861574173,
-0.12654665112495422,
0.7569562196731567,
0.41128620505332947,
0.02014346793293953,
0.07618872821331024,
-0.9034605622291565,
0.5811088681221008,
-0.05132749676704407,
-0.26457494497299194,
-0.3507644534111023,
-0.15460078418254852,
-0.29124271869659424,
0.3519248068332672,
0.3657829463481903,
-0.8270813822746277,
0.06649711728096008,
-0.5309057235717773,
0.6000024080276489,
0.37619781494140625,
0.23286305367946625,
0.3083937168121338,
-0.32522836327552795,
0.64626544713974,
-0.30446726083755493,
0.06880983710289001,
-0.02793164923787117,
-0.3698909282684326,
-0.5500974059104919,
-0.16017770767211914,
0.5201362371444702,
0.30867213010787964,
-0.5626190900802612,
0.5266181826591492,
-0.14340649545192719,
-0.8531023263931274,
-0.8973670601844788,
0.22161802649497986,
0.4870702624320984,
0.45831215381622314,
0.43375205993652344,
-0.1377953588962555,
-0.3198580741882324,
-0.9535617232322693,
-0.15477807819843292,
-0.24266715347766876,
-0.3570353090763092,
0.41446453332901,
0.58912593126297,
0.07384319603443146,
1.1055439710617065,
-0.6312705278396606,
0.2953847646713257,
0.38072100281715393,
0.29184967279434204,
-0.01913250982761383,
0.40275993943214417,
0.6044111847877502,
-0.5551403164863586,
-0.35519644618034363,
-0.28470033407211304,
-0.8996356129646301,
-0.34883254766464233,
0.07087404280900955,
-0.27115195989608765,
-0.1255200356245041,
0.5413321852684021,
-0.4502306282520294,
-0.14981801807880402,
0.5919345021247864,
-0.4972468912601471,
0.8617087602615356,
-0.1449684053659439,
0.4205287992954254,
-1.3024091720581055,
0.3268032968044281,
0.027470383793115616,
-0.10441012680530548,
-0.3953757882118225,
0.19045807421207428,
-0.08796428143978119,
-0.22745294868946075,
-0.482166588306427,
0.7771918177604675,
-0.31060153245925903,
-0.17299212515354156,
0.011559324339032173,
0.42172688245773315,
0.42832058668136597,
0.10251374542713165,
-0.030074844136834145,
0.7359589338302612,
0.21701283752918243,
-0.33598437905311584,
0.5216469168663025,
0.4309109151363373,
-0.32396063208580017,
0.42248284816741943,
-1.0978965759277344,
0.17017702758312225,
-0.05888967588543892,
0.24368658661842346,
-0.8854716420173645,
-0.4692676067352295,
-0.030081946402788162,
-0.5594514608383179,
-0.2311410754919052,
0.12467528134584427,
-0.49515870213508606,
-0.5678535103797913,
-0.3077687919139862,
0.5179709792137146,
0.3721390962600708,
-0.6202934384346008,
0.1794668585062027,
0.20013345777988434,
-0.6470871567726135,
-0.3575092852115631,
-0.46344876289367676,
-0.003850736189633608,
-0.04328891634941101,
-0.7973499298095703,
0.12805981934070587,
-0.2648214101791382,
-0.15872830152511597,
0.12166614830493927,
-0.13573436439037323,
0.03660554066300392,
-0.1966344714164734,
0.29953813552856445,
0.08962219208478928,
-0.3071044385433197,
0.2575418949127197,
0.3474910259246826,
0.13867563009262085,
0.5099595189094543,
-0.2625143229961395,
0.2482127696275711,
-0.44425898790359497,
-0.3121474087238312,
-0.028701094910502434,
0.33430877327919006,
0.5240514874458313,
-0.287738174200058,
0.25908946990966797,
0.4634268283843994,
-0.25177353620529175,
-0.1612023413181305,
-0.18195073306560516,
-0.20204699039459229,
-0.485973060131073,
0.3389962613582611,
-0.20555299520492554,
-0.8521109819412231,
0.3754420280456543,
0.08631395548582077,
0.12389905005693436,
0.6413822174072266,
0.5466493368148804,
-0.3993898630142212,
1.119486927986145,
0.34077754616737366,
0.4176665246486664,
-0.12963803112506866,
-0.05703303962945938,
0.23827147483825684,
-0.5775713324546814,
-0.5114949345588684,
-0.7571024894714355,
-0.0879603698849678,
-0.47041964530944824,
-0.5429525375366211,
0.7250766158103943,
0.4609741270542145,
-0.3124699294567108,
-0.025711573660373688,
-0.9018387198448181,
0.731819748878479,
0.6414503455162048,
-0.10697658360004425,
0.43448907136917114,
-0.1305692046880722,
-0.14136728644371033,
0.19415828585624695,
-0.9985194206237793,
-0.8219005465507507,
1.0770103931427002,
0.2795870900154114,
0.589447557926178,
-0.3553846776485443,
0.7464902400970459,
0.14913788437843323,
0.2552874684333801,
-0.7092172503471375,
0.5403191447257996,
-0.047332387417554855,
-0.44860485196113586,
-0.4237237274646759,
-0.5881794095039368,
-0.7666547298431396,
0.11439312994480133,
-0.1893804520368576,
-0.21462216973304749,
0.09839386492967606,
0.05456264689564705,
-0.7295264005661011,
-0.1414940506219864,
-0.6490749716758728,
0.7038451433181763,
-0.3305991590023041,
-0.29703888297080994,
-0.06979363411664963,
-0.6942574977874756,
0.6417755484580994,
-0.17838698625564575,
0.05316627025604248,
0.010917768813669682,
0.28545647859573364,
1.1991124153137207,
-0.19061312079429626,
0.46868595480918884,
-0.028221450746059418,
-0.18023772537708282,
0.5199874639511108,
0.13821661472320557,
0.005392108112573624,
0.5333056449890137,
-0.21005241572856903,
-0.010992428287863731,
0.7724104523658752,
-0.5327421426773071,
-0.5721533298492432,
0.8237977623939514,
-0.8422138690948486,
-0.47951048612594604,
-0.6286267638206482,
-0.8843868970870972,
-0.27200576663017273,
0.12330974638462067,
0.05258457735180855,
0.1381482183933258,
-0.20438829064369202,
0.23257139325141907,
0.6218807697296143,
-0.5001922249794006,
0.17136360704898834,
0.6209234595298767,
-0.1644451916217804,
-0.5764335989952087,
0.7623352408409119,
-0.2619558870792389,
0.25407126545906067,
-0.058153968304395676,
0.26958003640174866,
-0.5015398263931274,
-0.4830107092857361,
-0.552625834941864,
0.3901529610157013,
-0.4888435900211334,
-0.477241188287735,
-0.6032316088676453,
-0.5135626196861267,
-0.42416322231292725,
-0.23112209141254425,
-0.03913336619734764,
-0.6237729787826538,
-0.3744194209575653,
0.0911792740225792,
0.44942307472229004,
0.804908812046051,
-0.1227470114827156,
0.04084232449531555,
-1.1229256391525269,
0.4645220935344696,
0.4233596622943878,
0.20224827527999878,
-0.3653920888900757,
-0.4576147198677063,
-0.25442543625831604,
0.27292686700820923,
-0.3088977038860321,
-0.6763144135475159,
0.392621248960495,
0.32565876841545105,
0.22016361355781555,
0.3100949227809906,
0.016455909237265587,
0.5288849472999573,
-0.4263603389263153,
1.2291569709777832,
0.20719566941261292,
-0.790569543838501,
0.5856568217277527,
-0.4258025586605072,
0.3173658847808838,
0.5145649909973145,
0.6815066337585449,
-0.382789671421051,
-0.4823774993419647,
-0.670226514339447,
-0.7023829221725464,
0.5965077877044678,
-0.07467343658208847,
-0.18828436732292175,
-0.06641587615013123,
0.6843488216400146,
0.20568206906318665,
0.2313348948955536,
-0.5655696988105774,
0.19026309251785278,
-0.43492934107780457,
-0.44048362970352173,
0.03350658714771271,
-0.05466528609395027,
-0.4202823042869568,
-0.2600509822368622,
0.6908102631568909,
-0.4841352105140686,
0.14017616212368011,
0.22758132219314575,
0.01088639721274376,
-0.2671962082386017,
0.26601293683052063,
0.3799940049648285,
0.6712431311607361,
-0.2078401744365692,
0.010581893846392632,
-0.09537415206432343,
-0.44268104434013367,
0.1356581747531891,
0.20720866322517395,
-0.37378984689712524,
-0.1929638683795929,
0.14356526732444763,
0.3644677698612213,
-0.31773337721824646,
-0.8197377324104309,
0.2886243462562561,
-0.01870713196694851,
-0.6292576193809509,
0.012133438140153885,
0.27713775634765625,
0.1993006467819214,
0.24823927879333496,
0.4964047074317932,
-0.24175509810447693,
0.2650907039642334,
-0.2701013684272766,
0.37332233786582947,
0.575829803943634,
-0.023376017808914185,
-0.2886731028556824,
0.7193443775177002,
0.13191930949687958,
-0.033201664686203,
0.2811881899833679,
-0.4025389850139618,
-0.32140880823135376,
0.7445146441459656,
0.49316349625587463,
0.5068725943565369,
-0.02879062108695507,
0.6666504144668579,
0.5871114730834961,
0.16165007650852203,
0.07859506458044052,
0.456146776676178,
0.02376553788781166,
-0.3147388696670532,
-0.5756561160087585,
-1.1565977334976196,
-0.46394598484039307,
0.32591894268989563,
-0.5921766757965088,
0.05773792415857315,
-0.37418609857559204,
0.1924787312746048,
0.12088756263256073,
0.36115792393684387,
-0.4627837538719177,
0.45572102069854736,
-0.13021011650562286,
0.7973814010620117,
-0.9232093691825867,
0.5883175730705261,
0.7911961078643799,
-0.48194149136543274,
-0.8632155060768127,
-0.311329185962677,
-0.3770723342895508,
-0.5384880900382996,
0.8922571539878845,
-0.3163863718509674,
-0.14713504910469055,
0.08029399812221527,
-0.7705676555633545,
-1.0923142433166504,
1.2077053785324097,
0.34443017840385437,
-0.5801077485084534,
-0.2053043693304062,
0.329549640417099,
0.944572389125824,
-0.3425450026988983,
0.47395193576812744,
0.4951651096343994,
0.5593152046203613,
0.21688684821128845,
-0.8147782683372498,
0.1082998663187027,
-0.5393377542495728,
-0.22133566439151764,
-0.12081209570169449,
-0.7623423933982849,
0.2774052321910858,
-0.23660261929035187,
-0.16512297093868256,
0.21122504770755768,
0.8245589733123779,
0.534817099571228,
0.40177127718925476,
0.17964179813861847,
0.4796043336391449,
0.8258922100067139,
-0.09969670325517654,
0.6052512526512146,
-0.4781031906604767,
0.1859879046678543,
1.01432466506958,
-0.22618064284324646,
0.5904438495635986,
0.5024259686470032,
-0.07667504996061325,
0.34325650334358215,
0.830994725227356,
-0.3764153718948364,
0.35294467210769653,
0.44132310152053833,
-0.049825556576251984,
-0.30874136090278625,
-0.05687227472662926,
-0.25937119126319885,
0.4585171639919281,
0.3656693994998932,
-0.4251275360584259,
-0.4375787377357483,
-0.06941448897123337,
-0.18242502212524414,
0.24494241178035736,
-0.33010563254356384,
0.5771454572677612,
0.14919643104076385,
-0.6930140256881714,
0.7326470017433167,
0.036729175597429276,
0.36854174733161926,
-0.4880940318107605,
-0.03423205763101578,
-0.18246477842330933,
-0.38029831647872925,
-0.4680688977241516,
-0.9152584075927734,
0.28707635402679443,
0.3263009786605835,
-0.28299593925476074,
-0.05128808319568634,
0.42448878288269043,
-0.7194139957427979,
-0.44572755694389343,
-0.16491782665252686,
0.4887130558490753,
0.38058632612228394,
0.39275771379470825,
-0.7756046652793884,
-0.5412057042121887,
-0.19623829424381256,
-0.31790462136268616,
0.28049737215042114,
0.4244703948497772,
-0.06170755624771118,
0.6731789112091064,
0.7918151617050171,
0.24169722199440002,
0.20690160989761353,
-0.2458188533782959,
0.8322699666023254,
-0.44662776589393616,
-0.15400023758411407,
-0.3111228048801422,
0.20385213196277618,
0.01640799269080162,
-0.3396684527397156,
0.7885206341743469,
0.7035494446754456,
0.479966938495636,
-0.05537496879696846,
0.8970386385917664,
-0.11562693119049072,
0.5075095295906067,
-0.44311824440956116,
0.9895069599151611,
-0.391993910074234,
0.09031448513269424,
-0.015115894377231598,
-0.852149486541748,
-0.4044543504714966,
0.5417563319206238,
-0.2823774516582489,
-0.02500060945749283,
0.7482691407203674,
0.8785861134529114,
-0.003925400320440531,
0.15091243386268616,
0.03274420648813248,
0.2999393343925476,
0.4485085904598236,
0.5432652831077576,
0.6303393244743347,
-0.512559175491333,
0.4187833070755005,
0.027996119111776352,
-0.2581567168235779,
0.04034718498587608,
-1.0025712251663208,
-0.8636043071746826,
-0.6587924957275391,
-0.41507580876350403,
-0.48382657766342163,
0.11062879860401154,
0.9310897588729858,
0.4319489300251007,
-0.765262246131897,
0.05773841589689255,
-0.04364730045199394,
-0.24599649012088776,
0.07854428887367249,
-0.33832475543022156,
0.7807504534721375,
-0.382679283618927,
-0.5534757971763611,
0.5354520082473755,
0.16294357180595398,
-0.12162160128355026,
-0.6497119069099426,
-0.11549234390258789,
-0.09933354705572128,
0.4621947407722473,
0.49906837940216064,
0.3812200129032135,
-0.3637569844722748,
-0.24294662475585938,
0.23628734052181244,
-0.2910427153110504,
-0.1283392608165741,
0.48680320382118225,
-0.8735786080360413,
0.32734817266464233,
0.7391797304153442,
0.6130392551422119,
0.33644503355026245,
0.18698029220104218,
0.6965367794036865,
-0.5770217180252075,
-0.45676589012145996,
0.5483273863792419,
-0.09291533380746841,
0.21243916451931,
-0.31569018959999084,
0.38479915261268616,
-0.06312214583158493,
-0.9804872274398804,
-0.990648090839386,
-0.05940181389451027,
-0.954338014125824,
-0.1787664145231247,
1.3048386573791504,
-0.23530998826026917,
-0.39835092425346375,
0.09870708733797073,
-0.01837940700352192,
0.1836962103843689,
-0.23934386670589447,
1.1580922603607178,
0.5687710046768188,
-0.24933770298957825,
0.12807166576385498,
-0.2270769476890564,
0.8087390661239624,
0.4296349287033081,
-1.1947987079620361,
0.015756700187921524,
0.6916525363922119,
0.4887354373931885,
0.2710649073123932,
0.24873049557209015,
-0.4329879879951477,
0.5843805074691772,
-0.17143917083740234,
0.3363337814807892,
-0.3595530092716217,
-0.19613246619701385,
-0.38195347785949707,
0.33251258730888367,
0.0855664610862732,
0.14022128283977509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09935v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09935v2
|
DEBATE: Devil's Advocate-Based Assessment and Text Evaluation
| 2024-05-16T09:41:12 | 2024-05-24T01:06:41 |
Alex Kim, Keonwoo Kim, Sangwon Yoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As natural language generation (NLG) models have become prevalent,
systematically assessing the quality of machine-generated texts has become
increasingly important. Recent studies introduce LLM-based evaluators that
operate as reference-free metrics, demonstrating their capability to adeptly
handle novel tasks. However, these models generally rely on a single-agent
approach, which, we argue, introduces an inherent limit to their performance.
This is because there exist biases in LLM agent's responses, including
preferences for certain text structure or content. In this work, we propose
DEBATE, an NLG evaluation framework based on multi-agent scoring system
augmented with a concept of Devil's Advocate. Within the framework, one agent
is instructed to criticize other agents' arguments, potentially resolving the
bias in LLM agent's answers. DEBATE substantially outperforms the previous
state-of-the-art methods in two meta-evaluation benchmarks in NLG evaluation,
SummEval and TopicalChat. We also show that the extensiveness of debates among
agents and the persona of an agent can influence the performance of evaluators.
|
[
-0.5924776196479797,
-0.7646073698997498,
0.4504357576370239,
0.05899941548705101,
-0.3073523938655853,
0.038794148713350296,
-0.2466340810060501,
-0.266618549823761,
0.27751249074935913,
0.7482466101646423,
-0.4149438440799713,
-0.5077070593833923,
-0.4201752245426178,
0.48734503984451294,
-0.13350754976272583,
1.3537782430648804,
0.19827458262443542,
-0.01937144622206688,
-0.44566014409065247,
-0.27920782566070557,
-0.509616494178772,
-0.3235852122306824,
-0.6182267665863037,
-0.525635302066803,
0.576131284236908,
-0.04392261430621147,
0.9395005106925964,
0.37089529633522034,
0.4015970826148987,
0.4077950119972229,
-0.05673470348119736,
0.33975639939308167,
-0.2686786949634552,
0.4748006761074066,
-0.5449255108833313,
-0.14602741599082947,
-0.42884665727615356,
0.2850218415260315,
0.4814058244228363,
0.2860087454319,
-0.08622792363166809,
-0.09518786519765854,
-0.08988007158041,
0.5346410870552063,
-0.6206837892532349,
-0.3283824920654297,
-0.9787653088569641,
-0.010928348638117313,
-0.03746970370411873,
-0.28932270407676697,
-0.5839926600456238,
-0.5922143459320068,
0.5506883859634399,
-0.31030017137527466,
0.20497983694076538,
-0.24815650284290314,
0.8033730983734131,
0.5156956315040588,
-0.37114080786705017,
-0.5830479264259338,
-0.4158068299293518,
0.671913743019104,
-0.7420039772987366,
-0.12494227290153503,
-0.002991227200254798,
0.32810670137405396,
-0.03435010462999344,
-0.6148177981376648,
-0.4138418138027191,
-0.42984122037887573,
0.04051579535007477,
0.4907281994819641,
-0.31081727147102356,
0.06420960277318954,
-0.05079108104109764,
0.14614687860012054,
-0.28012827038764954,
0.05274078994989395,
-0.07443880289793015,
-0.021211083978414536,
0.8860458135604858,
0.28749266266822815,
-0.00914342887699604,
-0.682989239692688,
-0.7167743444442749,
0.005172458011657,
-0.20170144736766815,
-0.23604275286197662,
0.630109965801239,
0.3767296373844147,
0.3070869743824005,
0.3088017404079437,
0.1685079038143158,
0.48145994544029236,
0.10022301971912384,
0.09504713118076324,
0.1409146934747696,
-0.29223203659057617,
-0.332549512386322,
0.10048621147871017,
1.122592568397522,
0.5706487894058228,
0.014858273789286613,
-0.2400568574666977,
-0.1397152990102768,
0.2544090151786804,
0.9800212979316711,
-0.8366493582725525,
0.30369648337364197,
0.282010018825531,
-0.3135274350643158,
-0.34149858355522156,
0.09404633939266205,
-1.0524051189422607,
-0.7521460056304932,
-0.13703633844852448,
0.3791567385196686,
-0.06720642745494843,
-0.3175141215324402,
0.15981782972812653,
-0.339663565158844,
0.003802062012255192,
0.4056907594203949,
-0.2350597232580185,
0.5083129405975342,
0.7788179516792297,
0.5462183356285095,
-0.5083478689193726,
-0.09653071314096451,
-0.4304763972759247,
-0.11179491877555847,
-0.5053151845932007,
1.219921350479126,
-0.6816743016242981,
-0.41861164569854736,
0.10558813065290451,
-0.3144804835319519,
-0.0928574874997139,
-0.6724061965942383,
1.1833879947662354,
-0.36166146397590637,
0.31467437744140625,
-0.26206034421920776,
-0.6554973125457764,
-0.046626877039670944,
0.4800596535205841,
-0.731766939163208,
1.2325692176818848,
-0.09040342271327972,
-0.9344224333763123,
0.4507642984390259,
-0.9032135605812073,
-0.11323162168264389,
0.2583363354206085,
-0.28418225049972534,
-0.36753708124160767,
0.20248380303382874,
0.1751185804605484,
0.25398507714271545,
-0.5204246640205383,
0.43649452924728394,
-0.23680278658866882,
-0.36691245436668396,
0.4894116222858429,
-0.7329894304275513,
0.46255889534950256,
0.18670248985290527,
-0.482726514339447,
0.22347494959831238,
-0.6988977789878845,
0.19416746497154236,
-0.1370188295841217,
-0.1545262336730957,
-0.5257430076599121,
0.1802261769771576,
-0.018833257257938385,
0.07972566038370132,
-0.12120959907770157,
-0.39144131541252136,
0.1001010611653328,
-0.7437488436698914,
0.10979993641376495,
0.8657029271125793,
0.07530916482210159,
0.20285609364509583,
-0.3696964681148529,
0.6018125414848328,
-0.2725578844547272,
-0.0914386510848999,
-0.025094153359532356,
-0.33171623945236206,
-0.7299424409866333,
0.09284606575965881,
0.38998720049858093,
0.3466690480709076,
-0.9709635376930237,
0.20141881704330444,
-0.2962534725666046,
-0.6392815709114075,
-0.7691824436187744,
-0.09869705140590668,
0.4905686676502228,
0.0991293266415596,
0.19380395114421844,
-0.4875100553035736,
-0.24020662903785706,
-1.0788540840148926,
-0.5801960825920105,
-0.2795357406139374,
0.1365271657705307,
0.6267740726470947,
0.40642249584198,
-0.13563871383666992,
1.1175458431243896,
-0.32036253809928894,
0.009389298968017101,
-0.35325855016708374,
0.3370002806186676,
0.08698875457048416,
0.13333415985107422,
0.5824946165084839,
-0.6437634825706482,
-0.598892331123352,
0.03166845068335533,
-0.5259324312210083,
-0.42007723450660706,
-0.33242061734199524,
-0.2310735583305359,
0.26513752341270447,
0.03883255273103714,
-0.4903649389743805,
0.5118264555931091,
0.3326475918292999,
-0.5056137442588806,
0.672182023525238,
-0.05189068242907524,
0.2704344093799591,
-0.9938670992851257,
-0.15502910315990448,
0.015262358821928501,
-0.173226460814476,
-0.695393443107605,
0.24965648353099823,
-0.38419559597969055,
0.2072896957397461,
-0.4244980216026306,
0.8067789673805237,
-0.001216540695168078,
0.16565510630607605,
-0.8488232493400574,
0.6735901236534119,
0.16019392013549805,
0.23963382840156555,
0.0572267509996891,
0.7386958003044128,
0.19278539717197418,
-0.5487815737724304,
0.11030884832143784,
0.07156316190958023,
-0.05067596957087517,
1.0850238800048828,
-0.6866869330406189,
0.6683386564254761,
-0.014339173212647438,
0.22384384274482727,
-0.982977032661438,
0.29055532813072205,
0.2808971107006073,
-0.4864517152309418,
-0.049284037202596664,
-0.0061223432421684265,
-0.35163411498069763,
-0.1629146933555603,
-0.435120552778244,
0.13400842249393463,
-0.1290833055973053,
-0.3928307592868805,
0.7869786024093628,
0.39019766449928284,
0.022665398195385933,
-0.9338057041168213,
-0.2578170597553253,
0.5524316430091858,
-0.3489660918712616,
-0.4778262972831726,
0.3553635776042938,
-0.37434622645378113,
-0.5326274037361145,
0.18555031716823578,
-0.1488441824913025,
-0.14044243097305298,
-0.015758562833070755,
0.14089350402355194,
-0.06905453652143478,
-0.11772899329662323,
0.3540163040161133,
0.12670625746250153,
-0.23817268013954163,
0.23203739523887634,
-0.12156408280134201,
0.25214576721191406,
-0.23955371975898743,
-0.13403619825839996,
0.13847319781780243,
0.3374759256839752,
0.2654650807380676,
-0.13765627145767212,
0.395224392414093,
0.3802233934402466,
-0.22572572529315948,
-0.5961641669273376,
-0.6936179399490356,
0.017012059688568115,
-0.46185141801834106,
0.3802025020122528,
-0.349477082490921,
-0.6199185252189636,
0.1329430788755417,
-0.0933983325958252,
0.4522598683834076,
0.6970207095146179,
0.638806164264679,
0.2006606161594391,
0.5227603316307068,
0.3258802592754364,
0.2994101345539093,
-0.06111210212111473,
0.044176507741212845,
-0.15241049230098724,
-0.6985169053077698,
0.060327548533678055,
-0.7745263576507568,
-0.21204836666584015,
-0.5106606483459473,
-0.5132954716682434,
0.2275896519422531,
-0.3874993920326233,
0.170091912150383,
0.3085539638996124,
-0.8099784851074219,
0.652741551399231,
0.029764829203486443,
-0.05631200224161148,
0.3005525767803192,
-0.13842494785785675,
-0.4698830246925354,
-0.3321707844734192,
-0.4196673035621643,
-1.0457674264907837,
1.093010425567627,
0.320170521736145,
0.4218343198299408,
0.09389788657426834,
0.5677548050880432,
0.6713281273841858,
0.9048484563827515,
-0.8318952322006226,
0.6858759522438049,
-0.12706820666790009,
-0.8901075720787048,
-0.12344316393136978,
-0.4932073652744293,
-1.0404770374298096,
0.9158351421356201,
-0.20956586301326752,
-0.5007721781730652,
-0.11869210749864578,
-0.4501006305217743,
-0.15699443221092224,
0.3322615921497345,
-0.380778431892395,
0.8076431751251221,
-0.2663942873477936,
-0.5464651584625244,
-0.21209436655044556,
-0.22828200459480286,
0.2893792986869812,
-0.011790766380727291,
0.17161083221435547,
0.06907975673675537,
-0.20380398631095886,
0.8031479716300964,
-0.31296810507774353,
0.6520766615867615,
-0.11346697062253952,
-0.3778420686721802,
0.6316309571266174,
0.011062161065638065,
0.28823336958885193,
0.23306487500667572,
-0.3961363434791565,
-0.06310541182756424,
-0.11818380653858185,
0.01498480699956417,
-0.8563181161880493,
0.5213162899017334,
-0.7025318741798401,
-0.8166965246200562,
-0.6333428621292114,
-0.3698301315307617,
-0.1922437846660614,
-0.03393905982375145,
-0.12600941956043243,
0.23502540588378906,
-0.6474353075027466,
0.19556035101413727,
0.3471793830394745,
-0.3916352689266205,
0.45272889733314514,
0.6350402235984802,
-0.15368524193763733,
-0.8810951709747314,
0.7034408450126648,
-0.03689325600862503,
0.2856636345386505,
0.11204908788204193,
0.5716296434402466,
-0.3842668831348419,
-0.40726354718208313,
-0.5373833179473877,
-0.01873590610921383,
-0.7686697244644165,
-0.21715180575847626,
-0.8688936829566956,
-0.28180161118507385,
0.1228959858417511,
0.003810895374044776,
-0.5477650165557861,
-0.21144472062587738,
0.015930308029055595,
-0.18859407305717468,
0.07273814082145691,
0.794876754283905,
0.27214041352272034,
0.3531958758831024,
-0.2794317901134491,
0.013688416220247746,
0.32813510298728943,
0.27779659628868103,
-0.15129263699054718,
-0.3435703217983246,
-0.14534442126750946,
-0.3431662321090698,
-0.8019260168075562,
-1.1949647665023804,
0.10645923018455505,
-0.13597841560840607,
0.5680142641067505,
0.39793166518211365,
0.2317933291196823,
0.510527491569519,
-0.48644202947616577,
0.867462694644928,
0.09415213763713837,
-0.9952383637428284,
0.2556076645851135,
-0.27197492122650146,
0.032408107072114944,
0.794236958026886,
0.03889064863324165,
-0.4484853148460388,
-0.6981219053268433,
-0.8121992945671082,
-0.5909560918807983,
0.6449413895606995,
0.4852762520313263,
0.2761344313621521,
-0.22979506850242615,
0.36199408769607544,
0.36576730012893677,
0.40487754344940186,
-0.8695110082626343,
-0.3099246919155121,
-0.3134816586971283,
0.09689394384622574,
0.1374235451221466,
-0.09994056075811386,
-0.16065002977848053,
0.06354157626628876,
0.3904983699321747,
-0.26595768332481384,
0.05590950325131416,
0.2467835694551468,
0.18193474411964417,
0.012993899174034595,
0.6919807195663452,
0.7172583341598511,
0.6662798523902893,
-0.08714096248149872,
0.24113163352012634,
0.34577271342277527,
-0.415207177400589,
0.25520625710487366,
0.17100191116333008,
-0.4383288025856018,
0.42732059955596924,
0.1636469066143036,
0.75905442237854,
0.11537855118513107,
-0.6026683449745178,
0.4519087076187134,
-0.3183479905128479,
-0.5098072290420532,
-0.056995611637830734,
0.07793130725622177,
0.10202851891517639,
0.16477294266223907,
0.3198689818382263,
0.23322421312332153,
0.22032995522022247,
-0.3273129165172577,
0.3667203485965729,
0.5706603527069092,
-0.7015506029129028,
-0.050854843109846115,
0.4933934211730957,
0.39448362588882446,
-0.5361126661300659,
-0.050664272159338,
-0.3897605240345001,
-0.5718495845794678,
0.8381323218345642,
0.40862008929252625,
1.2636650800704956,
-0.18269112706184387,
0.5741675496101379,
0.24448612332344055,
0.645409882068634,
0.25417450070381165,
0.06330516934394836,
0.21061040461063385,
-0.6318127512931824,
-0.3796533942222595,
-0.5107578039169312,
-0.6831386685371399,
0.3075322210788727,
-0.2885048985481262,
0.12261728197336197,
-0.41499847173690796,
-0.5820104479789734,
-0.05243078991770744,
0.5446892976760864,
-0.5707007050514221,
0.16961200535297394,
-0.12716802954673767,
0.8145133256912231,
-0.4463854134082794,
0.3341210186481476,
0.7026411294937134,
-0.19933174550533295,
-0.30374717712402344,
0.21760281920433044,
-0.11454291641712189,
-0.08610572665929794,
0.3900555372238159,
0.2739379107952118,
-0.33061546087265015,
-0.579599916934967,
-0.28549522161483765,
-0.36262911558151245,
0.5342221856117249,
0.4771623909473419,
-0.12886899709701538,
0.2492956817150116,
0.11054150760173798,
0.8493260741233826,
-0.6038109064102173,
0.9938459396362305,
0.3064039647579193,
0.6998584270477295,
-0.04015348106622696,
-0.8772110342979431,
0.014452474191784859,
-0.4377322196960449,
-0.11262195557355881,
-0.04963499307632446,
-0.8061555027961731,
0.5307565331459045,
-0.017542710527777672,
-0.4057466685771942,
0.031152578070759773,
0.6368350386619568,
0.21076519787311554,
0.6392257213592529,
0.6636149287223816,
0.40696659684181213,
0.5806395411491394,
-0.09471140056848526,
0.9952617287635803,
-0.08284009248018265,
0.2447962462902069,
1.1686501502990723,
-0.42443862557411194,
0.6923421621322632,
0.1499474048614502,
-0.1167999655008316,
0.5618857145309448,
0.43763449788093567,
-0.005427113268524408,
0.14953187108039856,
0.6278007626533508,
-0.06219448894262314,
-0.26962292194366455,
-0.4481913149356842,
-0.18395307660102844,
0.5152219533920288,
0.1751837432384491,
-0.19609025120735168,
-0.41350749135017395,
-0.3677787780761719,
0.08654709160327911,
0.6432451009750366,
0.07430146634578705,
0.8350419402122498,
-0.025052737444639206,
-0.8756229877471924,
0.3639591634273529,
0.3923182785511017,
0.6002616882324219,
-0.5272601842880249,
-0.043103139847517014,
-0.10157695412635803,
-0.050993386656045914,
-0.06598100066184998,
-0.5475561618804932,
0.2451343536376953,
0.28608253598213196,
0.09482653439044952,
-0.07924263924360275,
0.7626617550849915,
-0.26451247930526733,
-0.441545307636261,
0.39198461174964905,
0.7056087255477905,
0.2906557321548462,
0.10209885239601135,
-0.9989322423934937,
-0.04285527765750885,
-0.34947994351387024,
-0.35921695828437805,
0.021634995937347412,
0.5876411199569702,
0.08569678664207458,
0.477173388004303,
0.4573747515678406,
0.02552652172744274,
-0.25427624583244324,
0.30232903361320496,
0.7545315623283386,
-0.5566891431808472,
-0.40564244985580444,
-1.0780097246170044,
0.4648095667362213,
-0.3296070396900177,
-0.5175859928131104,
0.7936955690383911,
0.6290280818939209,
0.4712983965873718,
0.2867736220359802,
0.8303612470626831,
0.24232418835163116,
0.4623938500881195,
-0.2763653099536896,
0.7706393599510193,
-0.5472050309181213,
0.24308361113071442,
-0.8998386859893799,
-0.9564018249511719,
0.09834178537130356,
0.5842432379722595,
-0.15950606763362885,
0.27582237124443054,
0.9364020228385925,
0.4412911832332611,
0.2586168348789215,
0.2986532151699066,
0.24979828298091888,
0.000518543878570199,
0.5189762115478516,
0.6099561452865601,
1.2047525644302368,
-0.5033307671546936,
0.6459552645683289,
0.30324992537498474,
-0.11416111141443253,
0.18512113392353058,
-1.0969587564468384,
-1.3874108791351318,
-0.32967156171798706,
-0.33623918890953064,
-0.3967002332210541,
0.007457308936864138,
1.0421334505081177,
0.3607713580131531,
-0.3466309607028961,
-0.3546086251735687,
0.21776019036769867,
0.44878432154655457,
-0.3409826159477234,
-0.2769145965576172,
0.4800674021244049,
-0.38628485798835754,
-0.9436609745025635,
0.45378127694129944,
0.32020875811576843,
-0.433620810508728,
-0.5836760401725769,
-0.27117598056793213,
0.010083061642944813,
0.8326003551483154,
0.4964527487754822,
-0.3033120036125183,
-0.9377158284187317,
-0.1904776394367218,
-0.21672384440898895,
-0.20687292516231537,
0.22555020451545715,
0.8724967241287231,
-0.8811200857162476,
0.653182327747345,
0.08216888457536697,
1.0091476440429688,
0.05981312692165375,
0.20345252752304077,
0.44104114174842834,
-0.5464736819267273,
-0.2534009516239166,
0.32200944423675537,
-0.16157391667366028,
0.27223020792007446,
-0.16306571662425995,
0.6336324214935303,
0.1730291247367859,
-0.49681249260902405,
-0.954017698764801,
0.09494057297706604,
-0.8040371537208557,
-0.32893598079681396,
1.1281944513320923,
0.08530718833208084,
0.031121669337153435,
-0.16143560409545898,
-0.44301357865333557,
-0.028428606688976288,
-0.5712836980819702,
0.8742074370384216,
0.9102442264556885,
0.1404157280921936,
-0.16105516254901886,
-0.700843870639801,
0.5363703966140747,
0.4765538275241852,
-1.166706919670105,
0.1589692384004593,
0.30398136377334595,
0.05573562532663345,
0.46250680088996887,
0.79853355884552,
-0.0664491280913353,
0.12611347436904907,
0.030068719759583473,
-0.11752578616142273,
0.026503272354602814,
-0.4595428705215454,
-0.14997492730617523,
0.5197490453720093,
-0.23527409136295319,
0.26675090193748474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09913v1
|
TransMI: A Framework to Create Strong Baselines from Multilingual Pretrained Language Models for Transliterated Data
| 2024-05-16T09:08:09 | 2024-05-16T09:08:09 |
Yihong Liu, Chunlan Ma, Haotian Ye, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Transliterating related languages that use different scripts into a common
script shows effectiveness in improving crosslingual transfer in downstream
tasks. However, this methodology often makes pretraining a model from scratch
unavoidable, as transliteration brings about new subwords not covered in
existing multilingual pretrained language models (mPLMs). This is not desired
because it takes a lot of computation budget for pretraining. A more promising
way is to make full use of available mPLMs. To this end, this paper proposes a
simple but effective framework: Transliterate-Merge-Initialize (TransMI), which
can create a strong baseline well-suited for data that is transliterated into a
common script by exploiting an mPLM and its accompanied tokenizer. TransMI has
three stages: (a) transliterate the vocabulary of an mPLM into a common script;
(b) merge the new vocabulary with the original vocabulary; and (c) initialize
the embeddings of the new subwords. We applied TransMI to three recent strong
mPLMs, and our experiments demonstrate that TransMI not only preserves their
ability to handle non-transliterated data, but also enables the models to
effectively process transliterated data: the results show a consistent
improvement of 3% to 34%, varying across different models and tasks. We make
our code and models publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/cisnlp/TransMI}.
|
[
-0.11279173940420151,
0.029687238857150078,
0.13350947201251984,
0.19282689690589905,
-0.450122594833374,
0.2422766387462616,
-0.19445361196994781,
-0.12387289851903915,
0.010872690007090569,
0.2977476716041565,
-0.44467970728874207,
-0.4326777160167694,
-0.6935533881187439,
0.08047779649496078,
-0.4862630069255829,
0.8387245535850525,
-0.25331705808639526,
0.45747509598731995,
0.10329948365688324,
-0.2225160151720047,
-0.22238266468048096,
-0.47279906272888184,
0.07044720649719238,
-0.24938251078128815,
0.49475541710853577,
0.6039069890975952,
0.6002779006958008,
0.619911253452301,
0.7335341572761536,
0.21652017533779144,
0.4272540211677551,
-0.05719222500920296,
-0.6015908122062683,
0.13041533529758453,
-0.10609563440084457,
-0.29002708196640015,
-0.24603049457073212,
0.00695748021826148,
1.0494939088821411,
1.1278280019760132,
-0.28697672486305237,
0.4780159294605255,
0.1353609263896942,
0.30515655875205994,
-0.9019433856010437,
-0.22707562148571014,
-0.7383860349655151,
-0.012479506433010101,
-0.4411199986934662,
-0.23893378674983978,
-0.4065466821193695,
-0.21412774920463562,
-0.00927867740392685,
-0.48382368683815,
0.16357176005840302,
-0.09260687977075577,
0.8559857606887817,
0.02077595703303814,
-0.33694708347320557,
0.0648956149816513,
-0.9468292593955994,
1.0647063255310059,
-0.6005889773368835,
0.72864830493927,
0.29950079321861267,
0.3771366477012634,
0.15637828409671783,
-0.8147464394569397,
-0.27727967500686646,
-0.16116386651992798,
-0.24421246349811554,
-0.14212962985038757,
-0.16823098063468933,
-0.16419708728790283,
0.24570629000663757,
0.29826512932777405,
-0.6165364980697632,
-0.09359755367040634,
-0.38561683893203735,
-0.4156343936920166,
0.05464610829949379,
-0.013834419660270214,
0.5542515516281128,
0.12775030732154846,
-0.4143821597099304,
0.07809066772460938,
-1.0031468868255615,
-0.3650626242160797,
0.3724959194660187,
0.7554487586021423,
-0.179142564535141,
0.611059844493866,
-0.16932609677314758,
0.5558492541313171,
0.015914052724838257,
-0.2703951895236969,
0.5375014543533325,
-0.7154809832572937,
-0.12371307611465454,
-0.019341524690389633,
0.5491260886192322,
0.024135975167155266,
0.2906513810157776,
-0.36271825432777405,
-0.14688627421855927,
-0.13271865248680115,
0.2908332645893097,
-0.9361811876296997,
0.10615574568510056,
0.09887189418077469,
-0.5041878819465637,
0.1365460455417633,
0.0817088708281517,
-0.41083163022994995,
-0.015358260832726955,
-0.5171985030174255,
0.4544640779495239,
-0.6325920820236206,
-0.3236999213695526,
-0.06496018171310425,
0.2613559365272522,
0.3702424466609955,
-0.014024841599166393,
-0.8135477304458618,
0.024515651166439056,
0.6323820948600769,
0.9779292941093445,
-0.15137743949890137,
-0.6404305100440979,
-0.811720073223114,
0.47479039430618286,
-0.21266545355319977,
0.5173435807228088,
-0.5568455457687378,
-0.39668992161750793,
0.3007478415966034,
-0.04731369763612747,
-0.09203752875328064,
-0.41834238171577454,
0.3727131187915802,
-0.2858065068721771,
0.24402523040771484,
-0.17981906235218048,
-0.37672048807144165,
0.33907490968704224,
0.34560471773147583,
-0.7147313356399536,
0.9433256387710571,
0.24791724979877472,
-0.8759507536888123,
0.391808420419693,
-0.33195528388023376,
-0.7445611357688904,
0.15739275515079498,
0.25081154704093933,
-0.27365949749946594,
0.16122940182685852,
0.0751861035823822,
0.20328649878501892,
-0.33465003967285156,
0.35907530784606934,
-0.2296486496925354,
-0.44232335686683655,
-0.21036884188652039,
-0.041939008980989456,
0.7790790796279907,
0.37831634283065796,
-0.13692927360534668,
0.06046005338430405,
-0.8158215284347534,
0.14495567977428436,
-0.3282063603401184,
-0.4186616539955139,
-0.3345176577568054,
-0.2618195712566376,
0.019216448068618774,
0.21523533761501312,
0.2756548821926117,
-0.4841326177120209,
0.13934051990509033,
-0.28471797704696655,
0.1528421938419342,
0.4253385066986084,
-0.39632362127304077,
0.7010033130645752,
-0.20209500193595886,
0.6330154538154602,
0.27386674284935,
0.1546095609664917,
-0.29804298281669617,
0.14647647738456726,
-0.9128966331481934,
-0.3645423948764801,
0.6528436541557312,
0.38973480463027954,
-1.0174840688705444,
0.13438285887241364,
-0.6831212639808655,
-0.6071385145187378,
-0.7726588845252991,
0.28070268034935,
0.3915765583515167,
0.5448138117790222,
0.4453582763671875,
-0.15028323233127594,
-0.8780887722969055,
-1.0367096662521362,
-0.3219001591205597,
-0.19497233629226685,
-0.1950036585330963,
-0.40137675404548645,
0.33770260214805603,
-0.19208605587482452,
0.800302267074585,
0.0023572163190692663,
-0.171574205160141,
-0.6458587646484375,
0.4075669050216675,
0.08159001916646957,
0.8606382608413696,
0.33110538125038147,
-0.6767565011978149,
-0.6778884530067444,
-0.09793394804000854,
-0.36861351132392883,
-0.19747932255268097,
-0.010042763315141201,
-0.5604996681213379,
-0.3750452399253845,
0.3271777331829071,
-0.5157381892204285,
0.08827609568834305,
0.6094102263450623,
0.09388791769742966,
0.3180356025695801,
0.06569810956716537,
0.205998957157135,
-1.3781951665878296,
0.6365751028060913,
-0.24841749668121338,
-0.43457305431365967,
-1.1104165315628052,
0.0424923337996006,
0.2664108872413635,
-0.24939289689064026,
-0.8247572779655457,
0.5767096281051636,
-0.5974159836769104,
-0.11874723434448242,
-0.05798880755901337,
-0.3442328870296478,
-0.27568331360816956,
0.35267215967178345,
0.21700020134449005,
0.7570056319236755,
0.7153213620185852,
-0.5191549062728882,
0.10963726043701172,
0.07875187695026398,
-0.47268936038017273,
0.5415677428245544,
-0.4950360357761383,
0.07999660074710846,
-0.1296219676733017,
0.10796090960502625,
-0.7462957501411438,
-0.05336381867527962,
0.31285879015922546,
-0.3376718759536743,
0.40774819254875183,
-0.37534743547439575,
-0.41944950819015503,
-0.04522458091378212,
-0.133475661277771,
0.705984354019165,
0.5362974405288696,
-0.3971359133720398,
0.908765435218811,
0.25326329469680786,
-0.12383351475000381,
-0.8352283835411072,
-0.6391254663467407,
0.14208412170410156,
-0.1872740089893341,
-0.24879522621631622,
0.3519909977912903,
-0.16878831386566162,
-0.032434508204460144,
-0.17166195809841156,
0.035108532756567,
-0.11636460572481155,
-0.023375168442726135,
-0.020205345004796982,
0.3649752140045166,
-0.12394557893276215,
-0.03909226134419441,
-0.21633394062519073,
-0.24827580153942108,
-0.34355780482292175,
-0.47377705574035645,
0.756902813911438,
0.20289449393749237,
-0.4411551058292389,
-0.4722932279109955,
0.3400989770889282,
0.7023696899414062,
-0.4887145161628723,
0.8826847076416016,
0.698733925819397,
-0.5752286314964294,
-0.060945238918066025,
-0.43814918398857117,
0.13875603675842285,
-0.35561010241508484,
0.17428278923034668,
-0.5217512249946594,
-0.5621486902236938,
0.48285046219825745,
-0.2231641262769699,
0.2721274197101593,
0.14433541893959045,
0.6506711840629578,
0.02843577414751053,
0.922641396522522,
0.7182664275169373,
-0.07925432175397873,
0.7051665186882019,
-0.08884367346763611,
0.09786393493413925,
-0.6669214963912964,
-0.17551970481872559,
-0.7174528241157532,
-0.34616178274154663,
-0.4106893837451935,
-0.4895005524158478,
-0.006490006111562252,
-0.0172592680901289,
-0.16298441588878632,
0.5655315518379211,
0.21592766046524048,
0.3917701840400696,
0.5502967238426208,
-0.21235661208629608,
0.2054130584001541,
0.2114851474761963,
-0.3266604244709015,
-0.0508246086537838,
-0.6901658773422241,
-0.369754821062088,
1.1892573833465576,
0.2150329351425171,
0.9483708143234253,
0.035341084003448486,
0.68917316198349,
0.006349511444568634,
0.7286813855171204,
-0.5983012914657593,
0.3426712155342102,
-0.10802522301673889,
-0.6417965888977051,
-0.049600791186094284,
-0.6209940314292908,
-0.7891727089881897,
0.36501115560531616,
-0.15796497464179993,
-0.401007741689682,
0.27759817242622375,
0.18205003440380096,
-0.1705649048089981,
0.23828667402267456,
-0.4633372128009796,
0.6924662590026855,
-0.15705104172229767,
-0.3506309688091278,
-0.02543806843459606,
-0.8665789365768433,
0.4072839021682739,
-0.342111736536026,
0.051964256912469864,
-0.19024667143821716,
0.030730215832591057,
0.5924892425537109,
-0.5304908752441406,
0.5818324685096741,
-0.160112202167511,
-0.14740055799484253,
0.002187557751312852,
0.11712773889303207,
0.3108341693878174,
-0.33832305669784546,
-0.07137726247310638,
0.26342055201530457,
0.016833113506436348,
-0.5861265063285828,
-0.4998502731323242,
0.2736243009567261,
-0.435525119304657,
-0.2379278838634491,
-0.34776750206947327,
-0.4836384057998657,
-0.5578166842460632,
0.5030494928359985,
0.34476715326309204,
0.5575664043426514,
-0.30927979946136475,
0.3293919563293457,
0.31309619545936584,
-0.018948670476675034,
0.16830606758594513,
0.8441182374954224,
-0.17191773653030396,
-0.4160372018814087,
0.8447502255439758,
0.00885759387165308,
0.4208601415157318,
0.5308461785316467,
-0.07314378768205643,
-0.30948305130004883,
-0.6009467840194702,
-0.3438895344734192,
0.26779377460479736,
-0.6322171092033386,
-0.4160398840904236,
-0.35643553733825684,
-0.10900121927261353,
-0.636449933052063,
0.15909764170646667,
-0.5450195074081421,
-0.19048388302326202,
-0.006149112246930599,
0.05735545605421066,
-0.4485737979412079,
0.23732289671897888,
-0.3399788439273834,
0.4572050869464874,
-1.127224326133728,
0.47831642627716064,
-0.03725253790616989,
0.3210323452949524,
-0.12139880657196045,
-0.6620252132415771,
-0.6028509140014648,
0.24150465428829193,
0.1530401110649109,
-0.6615656018257141,
0.4975759983062744,
0.2550124526023865,
0.6199994087219238,
0.29936808347702026,
-0.10345075279474258,
1.0182262659072876,
-0.7300357818603516,
0.48510685563087463,
0.38910022377967834,
-1.1383233070373535,
0.4644913673400879,
-0.11600294709205627,
0.5866867899894714,
1.0162841081619263,
0.7085607051849365,
-0.8720405101776123,
-0.31980982422828674,
-0.21379919350147247,
-0.5344028472900391,
0.8322108387947083,
0.29462552070617676,
0.24983912706375122,
0.20566779375076294,
0.05185452476143837,
0.3608810603618622,
0.3860520124435425,
-0.6384075880050659,
-0.17550289630889893,
-0.14684826135635376,
-0.4680868685245514,
-0.3173784911632538,
-0.19946525990962982,
-0.06917896866798401,
-0.352792352437973,
0.7929614186286926,
-0.05100323259830475,
-0.09546080231666565,
-0.13035589456558228,
-0.7359421849250793,
-0.1975233554840088,
0.18327538669109344,
0.25353360176086426,
0.9386051893234253,
-0.15333470702171326,
0.45729848742485046,
0.05919056385755539,
-0.5890550017356873,
0.3410656452178955,
0.0315336175262928,
-0.36081787943840027,
0.22862614691257477,
0.6363468766212463,
0.678943932056427,
0.3721959590911865,
-0.5768235921859741,
0.4041672945022583,
-0.08617536723613739,
0.08770641684532166,
0.16529518365859985,
-0.399825781583786,
-0.018056847155094147,
-0.24798621237277985,
0.39367300271987915,
-0.08119494467973709,
-0.08292930573225021,
-0.7869501113891602,
0.2971421778202057,
0.4574795067310333,
-0.09640917181968689,
-0.5839700698852539,
0.3310745060443878,
0.300789475440979,
-0.0051003750413656235,
0.7372878789901733,
0.14652013778686523,
-0.7035372853279114,
0.10387449711561203,
0.6188137531280518,
0.8060969710350037,
-0.7575818300247192,
0.3731340765953064,
0.48960575461387634,
0.4128111004829407,
-0.2061980962753296,
0.1741170436143875,
-0.13408377766609192,
-0.9052562117576599,
-0.47582465410232544,
-0.8376405239105225,
-0.24275119602680206,
0.15664330124855042,
-0.6531804203987122,
0.5312501192092896,
-0.18468984961509705,
-0.059720639139413834,
-0.2627691924571991,
-0.1172802597284317,
-0.8436949253082275,
0.1877071112394333,
0.27677038311958313,
0.7935672402381897,
-0.9486979246139526,
1.0092837810516357,
0.5288050174713135,
-0.3570689260959625,
-0.6717383861541748,
0.11714047938585281,
-0.3381328284740448,
-0.9914901256561279,
0.7291563749313354,
0.11618858575820923,
-0.07130224257707596,
0.03346768394112587,
-0.3273848593235016,
-1.1575846672058105,
0.821540355682373,
0.7924486398696899,
-0.6508548855781555,
-0.20659732818603516,
0.5668087601661682,
0.4354286193847656,
-0.44483891129493713,
0.19193020462989807,
0.6409654021263123,
0.5624271631240845,
0.48098593950271606,
-0.8537957668304443,
-0.0818847194314003,
-0.2537590265274048,
-0.1055816113948822,
0.20337869226932526,
-0.26018428802490234,
0.8144543170928955,
-0.032297998666763306,
-0.6845750212669373,
0.20616203546524048,
0.7044685482978821,
-0.11060643196105957,
-0.028738215565681458,
0.5176131129264832,
0.5087324380874634,
0.6377003192901611,
-0.027326317504048347,
0.8776820302009583,
-0.7081276774406433,
0.3143034875392914,
1.2201895713806152,
-0.4697456657886505,
0.7837786078453064,
0.6077215075492859,
-0.05098356679081917,
0.3557388186454773,
0.47157543897628784,
0.1880919635295868,
0.5561486482620239,
0.08790566772222519,
-0.17846687138080597,
-0.574064314365387,
-0.3352416157722473,
-0.43928495049476624,
0.44251397252082825,
-0.20179159939289093,
-0.2910822629928589,
-0.5581303238868713,
0.2640244960784912,
-0.10114506632089615,
-0.3374841511249542,
-0.20509164035320282,
0.5212091207504272,
-0.029896564781665802,
-0.6792651414871216,
0.5026721954345703,
0.018466437235474586,
0.5357919931411743,
-1.0441560745239258,
0.12333419173955917,
-0.49217692017555237,
0.08565530180931091,
-0.054993584752082825,
-0.2853894829750061,
0.2140309065580368,
0.28708314895629883,
0.05743038281798363,
-0.60561203956604,
0.6695005893707275,
-1.0360784530639648,
-0.840514600276947,
0.1083436831831932,
0.7848654389381409,
0.17152996361255646,
0.2670527398586273,
-0.5541741251945496,
0.10409348458051682,
-0.09404609352350235,
0.024745799601078033,
0.37201136350631714,
0.11783730983734131,
0.11661124974489212,
0.5660095810890198,
0.6950846314430237,
0.3245707154273987,
0.07954853028059006,
0.41328340768814087,
0.8043990135192871,
-0.34478577971458435,
-0.38953903317451477,
-0.8462512493133545,
0.5337544083595276,
0.17573267221450806,
-0.035094574093818665,
0.9411659836769104,
0.855087161064148,
0.7111309170722961,
0.0036559640429913998,
0.7057104706764221,
-0.009217132814228535,
0.6578643321990967,
-0.531438946723938,
0.654293417930603,
-0.6702446937561035,
-0.0014048651792109013,
-0.09813570976257324,
-1.2990034818649292,
-0.40312492847442627,
0.20792125165462494,
-0.016388144344091415,
0.08385138213634491,
0.612853467464447,
0.6753888130187988,
-0.4182538390159607,
-0.5115549564361572,
0.3411484360694885,
-0.10718846321105957,
0.06885812431573868,
0.6048890352249146,
0.9819942712783813,
-0.2773863971233368,
0.5916834473609924,
-0.2515837550163269,
0.063218854367733,
0.05684401094913483,
-0.8976835608482361,
-0.7156892418861389,
-0.6190149188041687,
-0.17752905189990997,
-0.22114720940589905,
-0.03523652255535126,
0.8699745535850525,
0.8516079783439636,
-0.8415724039077759,
-0.38449692726135254,
0.21347971260547638,
-0.004114214796572924,
0.035329390317201614,
-0.0502527691423893,
0.09046715497970581,
-0.446878582239151,
-1.0533641576766968,
0.39359554648399353,
0.004842166323214769,
0.2732871472835541,
-0.3572468161582947,
-0.14350275695323944,
-0.46199071407318115,
0.1709892302751541,
0.22798848152160645,
0.2822231650352478,
-0.28261736035346985,
-0.1342117190361023,
-0.1197991669178009,
-0.29485252499580383,
0.21223971247673035,
1.3078646659851074,
-0.7188276052474976,
0.38270142674446106,
0.708583414554596,
0.5306835770606995,
0.2802771329879761,
0.3338790833950043,
0.8878602385520935,
-0.9897547364234924,
0.14946343004703522,
0.11524400115013123,
0.5437328219413757,
0.6181090474128723,
0.03847716376185417,
0.5220664143562317,
0.2669106721878052,
0.18826724588871002,
-1.1814405918121338,
0.154139444231987,
-0.547496497631073,
-0.15758882462978363,
1.0550415515899658,
-0.24821151793003082,
-0.09679003804922104,
0.2118867188692093,
0.13347037136554718,
0.5674520134925842,
0.07035642117261887,
0.28557056188583374,
0.8535753488540649,
0.4565623998641968,
0.14671307802200317,
-0.006752379238605499,
0.5551238656044006,
0.506223201751709,
-0.9000896215438843,
0.27194395661354065,
0.33246752619743347,
0.4404592216014862,
0.19941222667694092,
0.6492727994918823,
-0.1219141036272049,
0.031187620013952255,
-0.10263019800186157,
0.1021735817193985,
0.0011198680149391294,
-0.7100532054901123,
-0.48804929852485657,
0.168693408370018,
-0.16858340799808502,
-0.21006552875041962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13030v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13030v1
|
Crowdsourcing with Enhanced Data Quality Assurance: An Efficient Approach to Mitigate Resource Scarcity Challenges in Training Large Language Models for Healthcare
| 2024-05-16T08:29:00 | 2024-05-16T08:29:00 |
P. Barai, G. Leroy, P. Bisht, J. M. Rothman, S. Lee, J. Andrews, S. A. Rice, A. Ahmed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated immense potential in
artificial intelligence across various domains, including healthcare. However,
their efficacy is hindered by the need for high-quality labeled data, which is
often expensive and time-consuming to create, particularly in low-resource
domains like healthcare. To address these challenges, we propose a
crowdsourcing (CS) framework enriched with quality control measures at the
pre-, real-time-, and post-data gathering stages. Our study evaluated the
effectiveness of enhancing data quality through its impact on LLMs (Bio-BERT)
for predicting autism-related symptoms. The results show that real-time quality
control improves data quality by 19 percent compared to pre-quality control.
Fine-tuning Bio-BERT using crowdsourced data generally increased recall
compared to the Bio-BERT baseline but lowered precision. Our findings
highlighted the potential of crowdsourcing and quality control in
resource-constrained environments and offered insights into optimizing
healthcare LLMs for informed decision-making and improved patient care.
|
[
-0.18662196397781372,
-0.5175840258598328,
0.42138317227363586,
0.039425525814294815,
0.014790697023272514,
0.4409136474132538,
-0.03951169550418854,
-0.8274377584457397,
0.2655874788761139,
0.49617430567741394,
-0.6136124730110168,
-0.3704003393650055,
-0.6828203797340393,
0.2583114802837372,
-0.350351482629776,
0.8473423719406128,
-0.05744904279708862,
0.22144529223442078,
-0.30434855818748474,
0.008620242588222027,
0.2666163742542267,
-0.7962169051170349,
-0.979529082775116,
-0.15801385045051575,
0.6891132593154907,
0.6226089596748352,
1.0442804098129272,
0.6763304471969604,
0.6305508613586426,
0.2692519724369049,
-0.05945369228720665,
0.36628076434135437,
-0.4495120942592621,
0.09851646423339844,
-0.12802429497241974,
-0.16632364690303802,
-0.55329829454422,
0.1918489634990692,
0.37818849086761475,
0.8029031157493591,
-0.38433557748794556,
0.3132023513317108,
0.12898646295070648,
0.8303690552711487,
-0.4616919457912445,
0.1089143455028534,
-0.15720234811306,
0.1298976093530655,
-0.2195584625005722,
0.22608019411563873,
0.19860215485095978,
-0.46465590596199036,
-0.09456481784582138,
-0.7515358328819275,
0.08817683160305023,
0.0463021844625473,
1.0679972171783447,
0.5562893748283386,
-0.000583838380407542,
-0.0802164152264595,
-0.4793318212032318,
0.6767154335975647,
-0.9209301471710205,
0.6019263863563538,
1.159527063369751,
0.09137199819087982,
-0.0626043975353241,
-0.611207902431488,
-0.7315616607666016,
-0.29409024119377136,
-0.04032008349895477,
0.08336811512708664,
-0.1589629054069519,
0.10801076889038086,
0.13193395733833313,
0.08436930179595947,
-0.4376246929168701,
0.4517197012901306,
-0.5889221429824829,
-0.6058858036994934,
0.7690234780311584,
0.058876972645521164,
0.40370288491249084,
-0.23560746014118195,
0.12285887449979782,
0.07187007367610931,
-0.504124641418457,
0.17427751421928406,
0.15903447568416595,
0.20639941096305847,
-0.02630683220922947,
0.5163309574127197,
-0.49022090435028076,
0.43625256419181824,
-0.011025742627680302,
-0.21115995943546295,
0.2356485277414322,
-0.3805266320705414,
0.04186554253101349,
-0.301300972700119,
0.4286874234676361,
-0.04742933064699173,
0.12372303754091263,
-0.108072929084301,
-0.17809471487998962,
-0.31282076239585876,
0.24874792993068695,
-0.7085411548614502,
-0.21276120841503143,
0.6572507619857788,
-0.6920400857925415,
-0.10956805944442749,
-0.017397882416844368,
-0.5185238718986511,
-0.38719019293785095,
-0.5792875289916992,
-0.08156885951757431,
-0.512806236743927,
-0.3317863941192627,
-0.08752162754535675,
0.412744402885437,
-0.31510722637176514,
0.2833463251590729,
-0.7709007263183594,
0.140092134475708,
0.8787791728973389,
0.8482752442359924,
0.052464019507169724,
-0.18199774622917175,
-0.9426547288894653,
0.1449260413646698,
-0.316929429769516,
0.635612964630127,
-0.5885001420974731,
-0.26417529582977295,
-0.1279411017894745,
-0.1049140989780426,
0.2907218337059021,
-0.6077426075935364,
0.349841445684433,
-0.5394442081451416,
0.0413547158241272,
-0.35075268149375916,
-0.42438793182373047,
0.06502645462751389,
0.11748586595058441,
-0.7669985294342041,
0.8439823389053345,
0.559570848941803,
-0.30924656987190247,
0.4745050370693207,
-0.46033740043640137,
-0.5917177796363831,
0.34485742449760437,
-0.06391081213951111,
-0.722571849822998,
0.060583606362342834,
0.5814334154129028,
0.5563850998878479,
-0.050796885043382645,
0.4127105176448822,
-0.458271324634552,
-0.23344101011753082,
0.5730206370353699,
-0.2482384741306305,
0.6537038087844849,
0.35965707898139954,
-0.08188801258802414,
-0.009004157036542892,
-0.791597306728363,
0.14716193079948425,
-0.17872218787670135,
-0.4601955711841583,
-0.1320262998342514,
0.16987192630767822,
0.12422087788581848,
0.2621791660785675,
0.03619986027479172,
-0.38971132040023804,
-0.07197905331850052,
-0.5202670097351074,
0.4666084349155426,
0.6668902635574341,
0.08322836458683014,
0.16110900044441223,
-0.5805387496948242,
0.5903706550598145,
-0.18261770904064178,
0.5883127450942993,
0.22171087563037872,
-0.4683266282081604,
-0.2749423384666443,
-0.4538259506225586,
0.48236119747161865,
0.4493200182914734,
-0.8340205550193787,
0.634770929813385,
-0.10108967125415802,
-0.25992199778556824,
-1.082582950592041,
0.21691441535949707,
0.2893037796020508,
0.5016920566558838,
0.35089102387428284,
-0.4638831913471222,
-0.175321564078331,
-0.5627210736274719,
0.18074123561382294,
-0.22153304517269135,
-0.16871319711208344,
0.43795788288116455,
0.20590850710868835,
-0.3553149104118347,
0.6686621904373169,
0.042243361473083496,
-0.18962492048740387,
-0.023167693987488747,
0.017516249790787697,
-0.030176598578691483,
0.6459847688674927,
0.4059787690639496,
-0.7008901238441467,
-0.07562107592821121,
-0.2854490280151367,
-0.41230130195617676,
-0.1821136474609375,
0.06028302013874054,
-0.10873828083276749,
0.2905234694480896,
0.3513176739215851,
-0.31652653217315674,
0.41443368792533875,
0.8767917156219482,
-0.2113179862499237,
0.3363003432750702,
-0.1678493469953537,
0.40392041206359863,
-0.9243912696838379,
0.1476908028125763,
-0.0832846611738205,
-0.16068105399608612,
-0.36637577414512634,
-0.17621158063411713,
-0.05046128109097481,
-0.506781280040741,
-0.2536148726940155,
0.4512222409248352,
-0.3078697621822357,
-0.017941512167453766,
-0.1976040154695511,
-0.14143341779708862,
0.06974443793296814,
0.08077726513147354,
0.025435129180550575,
0.8354907035827637,
0.5087077617645264,
-0.39933332800865173,
0.5159319639205933,
0.2148907482624054,
-0.5473074913024902,
0.7365772128105164,
-0.6191865801811218,
0.013819847255945206,
0.0005183628527447581,
0.2989383041858673,
-0.6284153461456299,
-0.6400656700134277,
0.33985435962677,
-0.5031725764274597,
0.22386279702186584,
0.33987927436828613,
-0.7579447627067566,
-0.6416594982147217,
-0.10558795183897018,
0.40682926774024963,
0.3789363205432892,
-0.5753783583641052,
0.11781877279281616,
0.5309963822364807,
-0.6898437738418579,
-0.4677216410636902,
-0.7834802269935608,
0.18410547077655792,
0.17520494759082794,
-0.31637805700302124,
0.04078121855854988,
0.12037718296051025,
-0.22436340153217316,
0.18037785589694977,
0.02372627519071102,
-0.3315051198005676,
0.27305498719215393,
0.10838116705417633,
0.16165848076343536,
0.01647990755736828,
0.5337481498718262,
0.3262598514556885,
-0.29484423995018005,
0.02764708921313286,
-0.20032279193401337,
0.21959251165390015,
0.46424809098243713,
-0.9367415904998779,
-0.9837285876274109,
0.5561712384223938,
0.5174299478530884,
-0.5180258750915527,
0.6784447431564331,
0.5001285672187805,
-0.5825306177139282,
0.012483828701078892,
-0.6996681094169617,
-0.653228223323822,
-0.47063857316970825,
0.5503767132759094,
0.22042341530323029,
-0.9292103052139282,
0.48461219668388367,
-0.21882867813110352,
-0.09483794867992401,
0.089053675532341,
0.30806267261505127,
-0.43294450640678406,
0.9137545824050903,
0.4038722515106201,
-0.5907368063926697,
0.32696476578712463,
0.02329862304031849,
0.18464699387550354,
-0.4503704607486725,
-0.24182981252670288,
-0.5675032734870911,
-0.3959805369377136,
-0.3682035207748413,
-0.5735641121864319,
0.6339666843414307,
-0.05481405183672905,
-0.44628241658210754,
-0.30728572607040405,
-0.6656385660171509,
0.26062682271003723,
0.7226572036743164,
0.5052698254585266,
0.2989695966243744,
0.0043685040436685085,
0.4988524317741394,
-0.01455382164567709,
-0.7811614274978638,
-0.41166049242019653,
1.2078677415847778,
0.357766330242157,
0.45962315797805786,
-0.04992716759443283,
0.7044399976730347,
0.40337544679641724,
0.5128000378608704,
-0.4365524351596832,
0.10126301646232605,
-0.0705152079463005,
-0.7593367695808411,
-0.6520867347717285,
-0.5916560888290405,
-0.8860782980918884,
-0.3147752285003662,
-0.422895222902298,
-0.6054047346115112,
0.38948854804039,
0.24529342353343964,
-0.9246612787246704,
0.38937774300575256,
-0.35554295778274536,
0.39923521876335144,
-0.6260188817977905,
-0.40625903010368347,
-0.5008043646812439,
-0.5919240117073059,
0.02606241963803768,
-0.4252733588218689,
0.5292646288871765,
-0.45840731263160706,
-0.27671703696250916,
0.6985824704170227,
-0.7392764687538147,
0.8655356764793396,
-0.00040983950020745397,
-0.05199865624308586,
0.3322506248950958,
-0.14540092647075653,
0.6752287149429321,
0.263286292552948,
-0.48018547892570496,
0.6085987091064453,
-0.1201116293668747,
-0.9106206893920898,
-0.36417675018310547,
0.5526511073112488,
-0.8814413547515869,
-0.37881186604499817,
-0.27488353848457336,
-0.41976457834243774,
-0.7170462012290955,
-0.03143475204706192,
0.06547248363494873,
0.3052060902118683,
-0.015012824907898903,
-0.08175989985466003,
0.47252097725868225,
-0.47237613797187805,
0.21017633378505707,
0.5892118811607361,
0.27598345279693604,
-0.46855586767196655,
0.9418048858642578,
0.28914162516593933,
0.21545469760894775,
0.0718674585223198,
-0.0064621577039361,
-0.009159313514828682,
-0.6608667969703674,
-0.3007063567638397,
0.18643739819526672,
-0.19202366471290588,
-0.46341878175735474,
-0.38088640570640564,
-0.3342624604701996,
-0.6306576132774353,
-0.15404793620109558,
-0.22262446582317352,
-0.21401219069957733,
-0.5908117890357971,
-0.27157214283943176,
0.681063175201416,
0.6035206317901611,
-0.4747527837753296,
0.1622629165649414,
-1.1264009475708008,
0.3967249095439911,
0.3447705805301666,
0.8243404030799866,
0.013863453641533852,
-0.3660804331302643,
-0.5604814887046814,
0.19069693982601166,
0.09897711873054504,
-0.6914446949958801,
0.5204260349273682,
0.15826059877872467,
0.5354917049407959,
0.4680193066596985,
-0.020566172897815704,
0.508012592792511,
-0.2438325732946396,
0.7880581021308899,
0.1409803181886673,
-0.8811648488044739,
0.43117982149124146,
-0.07929389178752899,
0.020679902285337448,
0.7122960090637207,
0.3533937633037567,
-0.5372201800346375,
-0.5781570076942444,
-0.6250781416893005,
-0.944311261177063,
0.7270234823226929,
0.09924831241369247,
0.18538816273212433,
0.10887444764375687,
0.5051742196083069,
0.10347358137369156,
0.202859565615654,
-0.23121792078018188,
-0.022818971425294876,
-0.29354310035705566,
-0.254748672246933,
-0.09680329263210297,
-0.4567435383796692,
-0.2287176102399826,
-0.5040974020957947,
0.6531276106834412,
0.1612633466720581,
-0.16154004633426666,
0.2444036602973938,
0.31761667132377625,
-0.46445149183273315,
0.23454071581363678,
0.2659003734588623,
0.7871409058570862,
0.13339030742645264,
-0.20816247165203094,
0.11526095122098923,
-0.48254695534706116,
-0.027006108313798904,
0.47861459851264954,
0.044916730374097824,
-0.03157541900873184,
0.5467506647109985,
0.32097360491752625,
0.009932764805853367,
-0.9365372657775879,
0.2534615099430084,
0.4979903995990753,
-0.08706358820199966,
0.05509934201836586,
-0.003102347021922469,
0.13305442035198212,
0.38424232602119446,
0.4717620611190796,
-0.329531192779541,
0.13101409375667572,
-0.0006659894715994596,
0.41883406043052673,
0.24061249196529388,
-0.16936127841472626,
-0.10017331689596176,
0.5450900197029114,
0.449156790971756,
-0.2648203372955322,
1.0134069919586182,
-0.025845803320407867,
-0.0021381343249231577,
0.823497474193573,
0.028984710574150085,
0.343421071767807,
-0.5521148443222046,
0.37611356377601624,
0.24956415593624115,
0.3145976662635803,
-0.15088729560375214,
0.3614663779735565,
0.08434882760047913,
-0.5687031745910645,
-0.8210070729255676,
-0.39336419105529785,
-0.7561367154121399,
0.3261786997318268,
-0.7023165822029114,
-0.23791994154453278,
-0.5157535672187805,
-0.26919618248939514,
-0.21105805039405823,
0.043132856488227844,
-0.5934058427810669,
0.3996421694755554,
0.3632947504520416,
0.6191999912261963,
-0.6612980365753174,
0.6018677949905396,
0.4381884038448334,
-0.46008843183517456,
-1.1361151933670044,
0.02288285456597805,
0.037941690534353256,
-1.0588417053222656,
0.46549853682518005,
-0.2589738667011261,
0.2086995393037796,
-0.13682705163955688,
-0.8907150626182556,
-1.2517813444137573,
0.8382411003112793,
0.4631434977054596,
-0.8578211069107056,
0.17827880382537842,
0.19380038976669312,
0.6442528367042542,
0.13448050618171692,
-0.12539726495742798,
0.4892956018447876,
0.6830620169639587,
-0.10506374388933182,
-1.0869262218475342,
-0.008294230327010155,
-0.1757553368806839,
-0.20399242639541626,
-0.0924118384718895,
-0.5673946738243103,
0.5559200644493103,
-0.4046197235584259,
-0.17748673260211945,
-0.08729943633079529,
0.8238083124160767,
0.3713451027870178,
0.5033642649650574,
0.17242595553398132,
0.4709974527359009,
1.4147510528564453,
0.00657436391338706,
1.0365524291992188,
-0.5785952210426331,
0.05902213975787163,
0.7625552415847778,
-0.36938977241516113,
0.6662750840187073,
0.28958821296691895,
-0.4308275580406189,
0.3220581114292145,
0.9665255546569824,
-0.017858218401670456,
0.21966522932052612,
0.35053765773773193,
-0.37063419818878174,
-0.33507418632507324,
-0.37816184759140015,
-0.5096886157989502,
0.18790310621261597,
0.5299888849258423,
-0.23358073830604553,
0.04247719794511795,
0.4401160180568695,
0.09156117588281631,
0.31125789880752563,
-0.47724002599716187,
0.8515658974647522,
-0.07105689495801926,
-0.2512289583683014,
0.4545932114124298,
-0.24911834299564362,
0.5788823366165161,
-0.36962220072746277,
-0.062122736126184464,
-0.3249783217906952,
-0.3391937017440796,
-0.28904736042022705,
-0.5214463472366333,
0.2810715436935425,
0.09474658221006393,
-0.2197284996509552,
-0.2731122076511383,
0.4157998561859131,
-0.3401685655117035,
-0.9298016428947449,
-0.017061365768313408,
0.7679458260536194,
0.280339777469635,
-0.18596786260604858,
-0.8792170286178589,
-0.02283555269241333,
-0.2875690460205078,
-0.33357515931129456,
0.321236252784729,
0.5181337594985962,
-0.08291056007146835,
0.743129312992096,
0.8340322971343994,
0.6804255247116089,
-0.42442786693573,
0.11442377418279648,
0.8828155398368835,
-0.3264835476875305,
-0.3240567743778229,
-0.5688233971595764,
0.2468368262052536,
-0.18704621493816376,
-0.07815922051668167,
0.14911103248596191,
0.43039095401763916,
0.673406720161438,
0.2731952965259552,
1.042240023612976,
0.1882835328578949,
0.9598968625068665,
-0.23463588953018188,
1.174107551574707,
-0.5372582077980042,
0.0558035783469677,
0.06282603740692139,
-0.21409057080745697,
-0.3949287235736847,
0.39676541090011597,
-0.26894229650497437,
-0.019370660185813904,
0.2671149671077728,
0.7786227464675903,
0.04858502000570297,
-0.19068962335586548,
0.21036729216575623,
0.04472559690475464,
0.3426803946495056,
0.35961368680000305,
0.5581737756729126,
0.23126788437366486,
0.34310251474380493,
-0.4255200922489166,
-0.4493415355682373,
-0.14602310955524445,
-0.5799962878227234,
-0.3822174668312073,
-0.5608903169631958,
-0.34610360860824585,
-0.5745752453804016,
0.3441011607646942,
1.139374852180481,
0.9509451389312744,
-1.118230938911438,
0.15999338030815125,
0.2249721884727478,
0.1551075577735901,
-0.5487599968910217,
-0.18313221633434296,
0.6355505585670471,
-0.3472532331943512,
-0.6087629199028015,
0.20543228089809418,
0.19738192856311798,
0.0031221075914800167,
-0.2072279453277588,
-0.016116317361593246,
0.11874184757471085,
0.14489449560642242,
0.3796096444129944,
0.5646681785583496,
-0.6484161019325256,
-0.3649943768978119,
-0.06735807657241821,
-0.4809039235115051,
-0.049008291214704514,
0.6986256241798401,
-0.7272502779960632,
0.2654920220375061,
0.05407048389315605,
0.8599634170532227,
-0.05284217745065689,
0.44239696860313416,
0.5337276458740234,
-0.3525375723838806,
0.037686787545681,
0.7222568392753601,
0.22481440007686615,
0.47298094630241394,
-0.7535207271575928,
0.4047415256500244,
0.1406082659959793,
-0.5810837149620056,
-0.6142793297767639,
0.050398193299770355,
-0.7423605918884277,
-0.37912631034851074,
1.2323678731918335,
0.004827284254133701,
0.013013338670134544,
-0.4351557493209839,
-0.15970063209533691,
0.3852938115596771,
-0.6003429293632507,
1.4477955102920532,
0.5323455333709717,
-0.3053303360939026,
0.010194259695708752,
-0.4185718595981598,
0.657366931438446,
0.39648234844207764,
-1.1351550817489624,
0.08452659845352173,
0.7057830095291138,
0.020215127617120743,
-0.07932012528181076,
0.7211418151855469,
-0.03954606503248215,
0.3646847605705261,
-0.5119258761405945,
0.2972820997238159,
-0.37982675433158875,
0.04177919030189514,
-0.22675597667694092,
0.1061265766620636,
-0.13343442976474762,
-0.16497676074504852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09893v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09893v1
|
"Hunt Takes Hare": Theming Games Through Game-Word Vector Translation
| 2024-05-16T08:19:11 | 2024-05-16T08:19:11 |
Rabii Younès, Cook Michael
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
A game's theme is an important part of its design -- it conveys narrative
information, rhetorical messages, helps the player intuit strategies, aids in
tutorialisation and more. Thematic elements of games are notoriously difficult
for AI systems to understand and manipulate, however, and often rely on large
amounts of hand-written interpretations and knowledge. In this paper we present
a technique which connects game embeddings, a recent method for modelling game
dynamics from log data, and word embeddings, which models semantic information
about language. We explain two different approaches for using game embeddings
in this way, and show evidence that game embeddings enhance the linguistic
translations of game concepts from one theme to another, opening up exciting
new possibilities for reasoning about the thematic elements of games in the
future.
|
[
-0.21040679514408112,
-0.4711874723434448,
0.7208593487739563,
0.0824071392416954,
-0.5239938497543335,
0.2997691035270691,
-0.013062494806945324,
-0.371967077255249,
0.46869364380836487,
0.5284347534179688,
-0.7816199660301208,
-0.5510814785957336,
-0.6304060220718384,
-0.09710239619016647,
-0.03216702118515968,
0.7709110379219055,
-0.22608783841133118,
0.11422798782587051,
-0.25069132447242737,
-0.39696717262268066,
-0.9489311575889587,
-0.5724068284034729,
-0.3798181414604187,
-0.6676380038261414,
0.2852765917778015,
0.007781211286783218,
0.7959685325622559,
1.2421842813491821,
0.7254920601844788,
0.25663384795188904,
-0.03756324201822281,
-0.1128661036491394,
-0.6242170929908752,
0.6645552515983582,
-0.4268640875816345,
-1.2125000953674316,
0.40580251812934875,
0.13564322888851166,
0.02275393344461918,
0.2416549175977707,
-0.010479114949703217,
0.12356657534837723,
-0.13772468268871307,
0.3168569505214691,
-0.48496681451797485,
0.7388252019882202,
-0.6328884363174438,
0.4762763977050781,
-0.12007047981023788,
-0.4366159439086914,
-0.20165063440799713,
-0.18465499579906464,
0.20335522294044495,
-1.2274930477142334,
-0.15487273037433624,
0.24647457897663116,
0.8692389726638794,
0.23345310986042023,
0.19859346747398376,
-0.8738880753517151,
-0.7113315463066101,
1.0471552610397339,
-0.5047727227210999,
0.01976153254508972,
0.7208550572395325,
0.09864874184131622,
-0.057322170585393906,
-0.34931236505508423,
-0.1773137003183365,
0.17589017748832703,
-0.031801749020814896,
0.26554304361343384,
-0.23692983388900757,
-0.14928068220615387,
0.20679326355457306,
0.07738286256790161,
0.0792192593216896,
-0.2428387999534607,
-0.23983874917030334,
0.1550021916627884,
0.937447190284729,
0.6272929906845093,
0.7219236493110657,
0.09150084108114243,
-0.11836209148168564,
-0.26628169417381287,
-0.7292571067810059,
0.11433267593383789,
0.025781918317079544,
0.3557492196559906,
0.14052507281303406,
1.1203126907348633,
0.549460768699646,
0.3627097010612488,
-0.002065962180495262,
-0.09527437388896942,
-0.09633530676364899,
-0.1944197118282318,
0.18058107793331146,
0.36107900738716125,
0.2309822142124176,
0.7551739811897278,
0.24036656320095062,
-0.44864293932914734,
-0.1901645064353943,
0.7101166844367981,
0.34558001160621643,
-0.3438524305820465,
-0.35189658403396606,
0.28991690278053284,
-0.5357699990272522,
-0.41584524512290955,
-0.33233222365379333,
-0.8814782500267029,
-0.4238034188747406,
-0.11072526127099991,
0.4745517671108246,
-0.819261372089386,
-0.12377113848924637,
0.37495771050453186,
-0.6865760684013367,
1.0771795511245728,
0.34110376238822937,
-0.9013651013374329,
0.06205349415540695,
1.096269130706787,
0.8105183243751526,
0.04029030352830887,
-0.2765595018863678,
-0.3190035820007324,
0.7730197906494141,
-0.6842860579490662,
0.72451251745224,
-1.086748480796814,
-0.7930914163589478,
0.2881113886833191,
-0.08673670887947083,
0.20982246100902557,
-0.24603725969791412,
0.21286515891551971,
-0.5594469308853149,
-0.002300663385540247,
-0.49855589866638184,
-1.075563669204712,
-0.3171595335006714,
0.24366024136543274,
-0.528955340385437,
0.5395695567131042,
-0.4161824882030487,
-0.648256242275238,
0.43942973017692566,
-0.5613223910331726,
-0.7241392731666565,
0.3257933557033539,
-0.3380553424358368,
-0.0395374558866024,
0.8281955122947693,
0.29230955243110657,
0.15880036354064941,
-0.06707175076007843,
-0.19978471100330353,
-0.5065603852272034,
-0.2942376434803009,
0.2506594955921173,
0.5089117884635925,
0.45698970556259155,
0.2943120300769806,
-0.21597285568714142,
-0.447515070438385,
-0.013040353544056416,
-0.007345701102167368,
0.48358386754989624,
0.01386269647628069,
-0.7377778887748718,
0.9363285303115845,
-0.4092426598072052,
0.11153692752122879,
-0.11521933227777481,
-0.4181714653968811,
0.46821680665016174,
-0.463777095079422,
0.3670496344566345,
0.46138930320739746,
-0.1673271358013153,
0.721220850944519,
-0.6225987672805786,
0.5822988748550415,
-0.08016370236873627,
-0.10738904774188995,
-0.5121137499809265,
-0.8600031137466431,
-0.4878261089324951,
-0.1903948187828064,
0.25778424739837646,
0.8744877576828003,
-0.9741935133934021,
0.29593202471733093,
-0.10074445605278015,
-0.37313365936279297,
-0.7303466200828552,
-0.1836249679327011,
-0.09946541488170624,
-0.41835156083106995,
0.09975860267877579,
-0.25864747166633606,
-0.3502020537853241,
-0.25939440727233887,
-0.44677969813346863,
-0.3484671711921692,
0.033604301512241364,
0.5440337061882019,
0.3815869987010956,
0.011408338323235512,
0.8052569031715393,
-0.6923497319221497,
-0.5762823224067688,
-0.33931756019592285,
0.2470901757478714,
-0.20293216407299042,
0.5314344167709351,
0.5843802690505981,
-0.4822632670402527,
-0.04807199537754059,
-0.05172580108046532,
-1.2460029125213623,
0.10329511761665344,
-0.2537456750869751,
-0.30107736587524414,
-0.5908730030059814,
0.4006812870502472,
-0.5207118391990662,
0.8550335168838501,
0.22951194643974304,
-0.45824190974235535,
-0.11471202224493027,
-0.19894301891326904,
0.14012213051319122,
-0.9604607224464417,
-0.4119522273540497,
-0.3427436351776123,
-0.051195237785577774,
-0.3689119517803192,
0.8494457006454468,
-0.5827223062515259,
-0.25894272327423096,
-0.3101927936077118,
0.2509479820728302,
-0.5975084900856018,
-0.03507154807448387,
-0.24657751619815826,
0.5727601051330566,
0.22151495516300201,
0.05608715862035751,
0.011655240319669247,
0.6363088488578796,
0.6212003827095032,
-0.5703575611114502,
0.8185338377952576,
0.6334617137908936,
-0.38109904527664185,
0.6741544008255005,
-0.4769536852836609,
0.13738197088241577,
-0.2670014500617981,
-0.03508603945374489,
-1.0320708751678467,
0.28682518005371094,
0.2541309893131256,
-0.38564765453338623,
0.2688368856906891,
-0.25994688272476196,
-0.44843780994415283,
-0.23929113149642944,
-0.43617966771125793,
0.2926524877548218,
0.571464478969574,
-0.26175084710121155,
0.7011191248893738,
0.8056337237358093,
0.18189670145511627,
-0.10636232048273087,
-0.907859742641449,
0.1402396708726883,
-0.6033060550689697,
-0.2643487751483917,
0.21365933120250702,
0.06011996045708656,
-0.4053940176963806,
0.464325875043869,
0.026284893974661827,
-0.06097373738884926,
0.28643760085105896,
0.0355779230594635,
-0.10610331594944,
-0.4733295440673828,
0.3531780242919922,
-0.18733656406402588,
-0.04613160714507103,
0.20231078565120697,
-0.6108804941177368,
0.285177081823349,
0.2688353657722473,
-0.32277587056159973,
-0.18903754651546478,
0.8532509207725525,
0.415564626455307,
-0.48553478717803955,
0.6858041882514954,
0.24921919405460358,
-0.3920711874961853,
-0.1661214828491211,
-0.1446083039045334,
-0.0817968025803566,
-0.4194432497024536,
0.4150596261024475,
-0.6516057252883911,
-0.6925861239433289,
0.6580304503440857,
-0.6018249988555908,
0.13054674863815308,
0.5843230485916138,
0.07213489711284637,
-0.5963284969329834,
1.3457798957824707,
0.7229775786399841,
-0.2781279385089874,
0.31966328620910645,
-0.4170883893966675,
-0.019750766456127167,
-0.7176924347877502,
-0.5170409679412842,
-0.6476893424987793,
-0.5394697785377502,
-0.6649084687232971,
-0.7754109501838684,
-0.3248596489429474,
0.1328154057264328,
-0.04503257945179939,
0.32190218567848206,
-0.34140267968177795,
0.7200427651405334,
0.16010059416294098,
-0.0315057747066021,
-0.09685540944337845,
0.13263629376888275,
-0.27458348870277405,
-0.5832734107971191,
-0.693992555141449,
-0.2903570830821991,
0.84380042552948,
0.21633534133434296,
1.1455093622207642,
0.41148072481155396,
0.8613865971565247,
0.3175271451473236,
0.07862059026956558,
-1.0349596738815308,
0.28696733713150024,
-0.25279751420021057,
-0.7596483826637268,
-0.290444940328598,
0.14242321252822876,
-0.8889883160591125,
-0.011245181784033775,
-0.5789341926574707,
-0.9950554966926575,
-0.005792251322418451,
-0.3027205765247345,
-0.20254452526569366,
0.713918924331665,
-0.26719197630882263,
0.2713238596916199,
-0.32375264167785645,
-0.40548068284988403,
-0.433512806892395,
-0.08965694159269333,
0.14178375899791718,
0.023967426270246506,
0.2876061499118805,
-0.19178418815135956,
-0.28021034598350525,
0.6674171686172485,
-0.2423834651708603,
0.5491153597831726,
0.0035401142667979,
-0.2754368185997009,
0.5046681761741638,
0.6181416511535645,
0.6262315511703491,
-0.03005099482834339,
0.04367654398083687,
-0.04151223599910736,
0.36985546350479126,
-0.4021640717983246,
-0.7880477905273438,
0.5137065649032593,
-0.83834308385849,
-0.8463951349258423,
-0.7177587747573853,
-0.4586649239063263,
0.0006164801307022572,
-0.14863477647304535,
0.1650191992521286,
0.41720208525657654,
-0.35193368792533875,
0.1599993258714676,
0.5080062747001648,
-0.5492600202560425,
0.0642775371670723,
0.0793602392077446,
-0.647229015827179,
-0.08179134130477905,
1.1682723760604858,
0.004409674555063248,
-0.35053837299346924,
0.5038815140724182,
0.27898529171943665,
-0.551794707775116,
-0.191350519657135,
-0.3641104996204376,
0.22290582954883575,
-0.7149365544319153,
-0.27439138293266296,
-0.3370727598667145,
-0.13775809109210968,
0.42065972089767456,
-0.4455856382846832,
-0.3428134620189667,
-0.04129602760076523,
-0.45582443475723267,
-0.0702989473938942,
0.6237088441848755,
1.3811845779418945,
-0.08694060146808624,
0.6829124689102173,
-0.7320117354393005,
-0.03816945478320122,
0.2914992570877075,
0.4450126588344574,
-0.14388784766197205,
-0.1809678077697754,
-0.16097146272659302,
0.266756147146225,
-0.13864082098007202,
-1.3159149885177612,
0.38764405250549316,
0.3330499529838562,
0.6145936846733093,
0.38109609484672546,
-0.2648642957210541,
0.8667894601821899,
-0.9300100803375244,
1.0604946613311768,
0.12963464856147766,
-1.0184986591339111,
0.652190089225769,
-0.33408108353614807,
0.14440013468265533,
0.4847540259361267,
0.3479841351509094,
-0.47845786809921265,
-0.3554839789867401,
-0.5099449157714844,
-0.5485084652900696,
0.9345882534980774,
0.15256451070308685,
0.3924858272075653,
-0.13442173600196838,
0.49400997161865234,
-0.12676672637462616,
0.2760343551635742,
-0.03264663740992546,
-0.41955894231796265,
-0.19563664495944977,
-0.2625010013580322,
-0.5381028652191162,
-0.14996206760406494,
-0.1675778329372406,
-0.26261547207832336,
0.2566116452217102,
0.31654292345046997,
0.7871845960617065,
-0.1765262633562088,
-0.31154710054397583,
-0.03832164406776428,
-0.35318809747695923,
0.41862621903419495,
0.5000150799751282,
-0.1127595454454422,
0.07563609629869461,
0.12235283106565475,
-0.416047602891922,
0.3582752048969269,
-0.4141307473182678,
-0.2034681737422943,
0.195562943816185,
0.4843979775905609,
0.7948993444442749,
0.31308290362358093,
-0.22201862931251526,
0.3851286470890045,
-0.14580048620700836,
-0.14846472442150116,
0.11992181837558746,
-0.11987052857875824,
0.13397647440433502,
0.5317403078079224,
0.18171930313110352,
-0.34734973311424255,
0.007972506806254387,
-0.6070894598960876,
0.46811944246292114,
0.5135179758071899,
-0.6217244863510132,
-0.5551432967185974,
0.6791966557502747,
0.09419222176074982,
-0.6445100903511047,
0.5060602426528931,
-0.11148100346326828,
-0.6020402312278748,
0.5043688416481018,
1.0459246635437012,
0.9715226888656616,
-0.18245135247707367,
0.5485165119171143,
0.2204105108976364,
0.3835240304470062,
0.03976397216320038,
0.35726693272590637,
0.2556069493293762,
-0.6067284941673279,
-0.4902147650718689,
-0.4166194796562195,
-0.24827240407466888,
0.11807876825332642,
-0.5390664935112,
0.028108416125178337,
-0.31125178933143616,
-0.4650016129016876,
-0.06886009871959686,
0.02655763551592827,
-0.9601806402206421,
-0.2140905112028122,
0.4503708779811859,
0.7687859535217285,
-0.9657672643661499,
0.37506645917892456,
0.9980431199073792,
-0.5942167639732361,
-0.6893888115882874,
0.23699629306793213,
-0.05525907129049301,
-0.86104416847229,
0.685636043548584,
-0.2601233720779419,
0.1626465767621994,
0.16934923827648163,
-0.826836884021759,
-0.9221588373184204,
0.7861595749855042,
-0.004198069684207439,
-0.01923956908285618,
0.03293493390083313,
0.0455356165766716,
0.3937205374240875,
-0.7328039407730103,
0.0939839631319046,
0.3447690010070801,
0.4019327163696289,
0.2513132691383362,
0.05221805348992348,
-0.3388615548610687,
0.08555745333433151,
0.05783875659108162,
0.06108298525214195,
-0.26141253113746643,
0.5085610151290894,
-0.0866781622171402,
-0.4433231055736542,
-0.01962808147072792,
0.8020568490028381,
0.09079825133085251,
0.03875647857785225,
0.14789707958698273,
0.6359331607818604,
0.5481575131416321,
-0.3157624304294586,
0.8392166495323181,
-0.36888453364372253,
0.4600215256214142,
0.6593865752220154,
-0.5128775835037231,
0.7860323786735535,
0.3294430673122406,
-0.37731045484542847,
0.3670009672641754,
0.5146688222885132,
-0.1333516538143158,
1.1908985376358032,
0.7111294865608215,
-0.11132397502660751,
-0.26479899883270264,
-0.2745523154735565,
-0.36317241191864014,
0.9378257393836975,
0.8940505385398865,
0.0882543995976448,
-0.5232887864112854,
0.1297568827867508,
-0.2622242271900177,
0.12330712378025055,
-0.25528115034103394,
1.0358256101608276,
0.2126156985759735,
-0.4421010911464691,
0.007394005544483662,
0.012747052125632763,
0.6399115324020386,
-0.5990778207778931,
-0.3040297329425812,
-0.4753273129463196,
0.34445950388908386,
0.37522029876708984,
-0.9893835186958313,
0.4309575855731964,
-0.08169754594564438,
0.25441408157348633,
-0.050679564476013184,
0.5749760270118713,
-0.2795311510562897,
-0.5490449070930481,
0.5900537371635437,
0.8683352470397949,
0.2803313136100769,
0.3276612460613251,
-0.9467678070068359,
0.45739462971687317,
-0.14551450312137604,
0.15014846622943878,
0.0888344943523407,
0.9793784022331238,
0.12002301216125488,
0.48142722249031067,
0.2487511783838272,
0.3853060305118561,
0.06220850348472595,
-0.613318681716919,
0.6001814603805542,
-0.7801085710525513,
-0.5756831765174866,
-1.0167583227157593,
-0.14257116615772247,
0.09221763163805008,
0.004604940768331289,
0.7299569845199585,
0.46192988753318787,
0.6152855157852173,
-0.14834047853946686,
0.7708383798599243,
0.028140928596258163,
-0.22677236795425415,
-0.34156540036201477,
0.8545268774032593,
-0.5852300524711609,
-0.05650489777326584,
-0.4326742887496948,
-0.6629147529602051,
-0.19517813622951508,
0.903840959072113,
-0.11523578315973282,
-0.34868115186691284,
0.45798346400260925,
0.24321597814559937,
-0.14646832644939423,
0.24587459862232208,
0.3984815776348114,
-0.2282363623380661,
0.27536505460739136,
0.6550024747848511,
1.2877100706100464,
-0.4228340983390808,
0.006632321979850531,
-0.010813569650053978,
-0.04901516065001488,
-0.09214920550584793,
-0.6794337630271912,
-0.9791878461837769,
-0.7825222015380859,
-0.29818934202194214,
-0.3893161416053772,
0.3589434027671814,
0.8616209626197815,
0.3477862775325775,
-0.8224431872367859,
-0.450085312128067,
0.2224843055009842,
0.2930293083190918,
-0.3279936611652374,
-0.12148772180080414,
0.4638989567756653,
-0.48886385560035706,
-0.4833131730556488,
0.09193213284015656,
0.28133928775787354,
-0.014188077300786972,
-0.23138444125652313,
0.026913994923233986,
-0.615312933921814,
0.6158735156059265,
0.7714881896972656,
0.18452538549900055,
-0.7520496249198914,
-0.5735799670219421,
0.24163314700126648,
0.0009499788284301758,
-0.02723836340010166,
0.9466590881347656,
-0.7291719913482666,
0.7576391696929932,
0.3753262460231781,
1.0074084997177124,
0.46930813789367676,
-0.23354679346084595,
0.9904153347015381,
-0.5497515201568604,
0.26223495602607727,
-0.022576820105314255,
0.11314143985509872,
0.1994515061378479,
-0.17760732769966125,
0.4699731469154358,
0.3717150092124939,
0.09089372307062149,
-0.6482688784599304,
0.19702747464179993,
-0.18149922788143158,
-0.15659627318382263,
1.0943982601165771,
-0.4238901436328888,
-0.5695539712905884,
-0.10105743259191513,
-0.1530791074037552,
0.5734529495239258,
0.01410600170493126,
0.45802173018455505,
1.1779429912567139,
0.13459905982017517,
0.05255402624607086,
-0.6189684867858887,
0.8084629774093628,
0.16182532906532288,
-0.3499329686164856,
-0.004717434756457806,
0.2747100591659546,
-0.16610169410705566,
0.39943942427635193,
0.11280374228954315,
-0.05042322725057602,
-0.03496342897415161,
0.36440572142601013,
-0.11731415241956711,
0.24733491241931915,
-0.0329531654715538,
-0.3178527057170868,
-0.21880818903446198,
-0.012355505488812923,
-0.7055488228797913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10989v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10989v1
|
Learnable Privacy Neurons Localization in Language Models
| 2024-05-16T08:11:08 | 2024-05-16T08:11:08 |
Ruizhe Chen, Tianxiang Hu, Yang Feng, Zuozhu Liu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Concerns regarding Large Language Models (LLMs) to memorize and disclose
private information, particularly Personally Identifiable Information (PII),
become prominent within the community. Many efforts have been made to mitigate
the privacy risks. However, the mechanism through which LLMs memorize PII
remains poorly understood. To bridge this gap, we introduce a pioneering method
for pinpointing PII-sensitive neurons (privacy neurons) within LLMs. Our method
employs learnable binary weight masks to localize specific neurons that account
for the memorization of PII in LLMs through adversarial training. Our
investigations discover that PII is memorized by a small subset of neurons
across all layers, which shows the property of PII specificity. Furthermore, we
propose to validate the potential in PII risk mitigation by deactivating the
localized privacy neurons. Both quantitative and qualitative experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of our neuron localization algorithm.
|
[
-0.06808016449213028,
-0.5531822443008423,
0.34073764085769653,
-0.008528810925781727,
0.20354017615318298,
0.1514444798231125,
-0.3299936056137085,
-0.17196328938007355,
0.2491285651922226,
0.306520938873291,
-0.26386508345603943,
-0.757570743560791,
-0.3862999975681305,
-0.46106451749801636,
-0.16709814965724945,
0.9566610455513,
0.4508838355541229,
-0.03898301348090172,
0.13948892056941986,
0.05851360782980919,
0.005793277639895678,
-0.9954514503479004,
-0.7410617470741272,
-0.3273031711578369,
0.9955952167510986,
0.10204602032899857,
0.3378213942050934,
0.46026381850242615,
0.38801589608192444,
0.3122081458568573,
-0.7140411734580994,
-0.2595696449279785,
-0.4743502140045166,
-0.11574385315179825,
-0.25967293977737427,
-0.9886130094528198,
-0.47413942217826843,
-0.20169752836227417,
0.948887050151825,
0.8960728645324707,
-0.2007034868001938,
0.023189587518572807,
-0.13751783967018127,
0.5950163006782532,
-0.9002347588539124,
-0.07910490036010742,
-0.8480056524276733,
0.3498746454715729,
-0.1802431344985962,
-0.07466349005699158,
-0.5550571084022522,
-0.2398095726966858,
0.0028770193457603455,
-0.17427784204483032,
0.6995100378990173,
-0.2386232167482376,
0.6471289396286011,
-0.12307029962539673,
-0.23263852298259735,
0.13311997056007385,
-0.709391176700592,
0.5436257719993591,
-0.7157357335090637,
0.1069972962141037,
0.7257487773895264,
0.03927074000239372,
-0.13690954446792603,
-0.38029322028160095,
-0.129416823387146,
-0.13372817635536194,
-0.2893217206001282,
-0.24062655866146088,
-0.25174957513809204,
-0.02857874147593975,
0.4714404344558716,
0.16927479207515717,
-0.4306584894657135,
0.17633424699306488,
-0.4753529727458954,
-0.5008643269538879,
0.5530076026916504,
-0.17386023700237274,
0.24067939817905426,
0.1991550326347351,
-0.2519151568412781,
0.147855743765831,
-0.9016692042350769,
0.12236711382865906,
0.6865602731704712,
0.16050051152706146,
-0.1467369645833969,
0.3404640257358551,
-0.07245176285505295,
0.33213937282562256,
0.05359723046422005,
0.027117235586047173,
0.39369139075279236,
0.05343285948038101,
0.0017906703287735581,
0.40087050199508667,
0.8105204105377197,
-0.10812357068061829,
0.3496682345867157,
-0.4620461165904999,
-0.25571170449256897,
-0.43888628482818604,
0.31430160999298096,
-0.6549196243286133,
-0.5576074719429016,
0.09189698100090027,
-0.4055526852607727,
-0.4190596044063568,
-0.12582817673683167,
-0.25730013847351074,
-0.5222354531288147,
0.16408193111419678,
0.2409498542547226,
-0.345701664686203,
-0.392890602350235,
-0.15546728670597076,
-0.03956616669893265,
0.20602649450302124,
-0.1355377435684204,
-1.4919625520706177,
0.2708461880683899,
0.8325086236000061,
0.9705140590667725,
-0.08291531354188919,
-0.41390174627304077,
-0.14800576865673065,
0.5283347964286804,
-0.42354291677474976,
0.30891650915145874,
-0.3111436665058136,
-0.28156206011772156,
-0.07653477042913437,
0.18221578001976013,
-0.2810593843460083,
-0.6506679654121399,
0.05842611938714981,
-0.6046356558799744,
-0.09512073546648026,
-0.18744954466819763,
-0.3721945285797119,
-0.3216642141342163,
0.14222104847431183,
-0.5661526322364807,
0.41482657194137573,
-0.11810868978500366,
-1.0343623161315918,
-0.11259603500366211,
-0.44184547662734985,
-0.5129045248031616,
-0.05399034544825554,
-0.08939016610383987,
-0.7494909763336182,
0.5476284623146057,
0.017838511615991592,
0.7962033152580261,
0.4501894414424896,
0.43269842863082886,
-0.31429794430732727,
-0.3868055045604706,
0.623599112033844,
-0.5789932012557983,
0.8282598257064819,
0.01854829676449299,
-0.4529343545436859,
0.37624865770339966,
-0.7576713562011719,
-0.06299394369125366,
0.2626764178276062,
-0.0723334550857544,
-0.4252435863018036,
-0.18413087725639343,
-0.40741732716560364,
-0.2830030918121338,
0.46105894446372986,
-0.5337915420532227,
-0.18671023845672607,
-0.4595770537853241,
0.7747355699539185,
0.9182186722755432,
0.011750445701181889,
0.7761728167533875,
-0.09644494205713272,
0.14126916229724884,
0.17272260785102844,
0.349959135055542,
-0.047493670135736465,
-0.7103594541549683,
-0.43243321776390076,
-0.38459479808807373,
0.24200290441513062,
0.3264712393283844,
-0.06793463230133057,
0.5097410678863525,
-0.1511666625738144,
-0.4429285228252411,
-0.12412966787815094,
0.006476256530731916,
0.538003146648407,
0.4086495041847229,
-0.19397325813770294,
-0.3807986378669739,
0.09282334893941879,
-1.1467900276184082,
-0.2211165428161621,
0.037437908351421356,
-0.20333638787269592,
0.41747599840164185,
0.5087740421295166,
0.048090338706970215,
0.7651141881942749,
-0.2795419991016388,
-0.17371824383735657,
0.009210626594722271,
0.1129910796880722,
0.1822434663772583,
0.6613815426826477,
0.411170095205307,
-0.935390055179596,
-0.1869562715291977,
0.10567363351583481,
-0.6490328311920166,
0.21488843858242035,
-0.11726221442222595,
-0.13830332458019257,
-0.12220600992441177,
0.4027077555656433,
-0.43364518880844116,
0.655666172504425,
0.5379579067230225,
-0.2824229896068573,
-0.012983160093426704,
-0.6987404823303223,
-0.29346930980682373,
-0.7143546342849731,
0.36430296301841736,
-0.27887967228889465,
-0.30918797850608826,
-0.8781931400299072,
-0.14747588336467743,
0.4066392183303833,
-0.35278335213661194,
-0.5237197279930115,
0.42357301712036133,
-0.5980334877967834,
-0.27062714099884033,
-0.21207717061042786,
0.028297631070017815,
-0.22799134254455566,
0.9390959143638611,
0.19331249594688416,
0.8332328796386719,
0.8384103178977966,
-0.6645009517669678,
0.000970799068454653,
-0.026082199066877365,
-0.2956109344959259,
0.031642936170101166,
-0.5038233995437622,
0.32299569249153137,
-0.12775038182735443,
-0.0849345326423645,
-0.7532365918159485,
-0.15919137001037598,
0.4307910203933716,
-0.49162641167640686,
0.5401161909103394,
-0.17094695568084717,
-0.1565331667661667,
0.21561281383037567,
-0.20888081192970276,
0.7531444430351257,
0.32250455021858215,
-0.6933294534683228,
0.646206796169281,
0.7318553328514099,
-0.17547392845153809,
-0.5708606243133545,
-0.6890917420387268,
-0.03718500956892967,
-0.05615530163049698,
-0.2527604401111603,
0.4369391202926636,
0.05585990846157074,
-0.020304905250668526,
-0.16922667622566223,
-0.11497284471988678,
-0.36259493231773376,
0.5705613493919373,
0.6459514498710632,
-0.045959070324897766,
-0.05869181454181671,
0.16104307770729065,
-0.1645759642124176,
-0.3790800869464874,
0.16674284636974335,
-0.1011386290192604,
0.6588321328163147,
-0.3732548952102661,
-0.4235507845878601,
-0.5924955010414124,
0.48324552178382874,
0.1287972331047058,
-0.6914383172988892,
0.9145247936248779,
0.5699048638343811,
-0.8207734227180481,
-0.23186099529266357,
-0.598169207572937,
-0.22748513519763947,
-0.5277919173240662,
0.4426450729370117,
-0.26492658257484436,
-0.8186996579170227,
0.7438823580741882,
-0.1314896047115326,
-0.33368927240371704,
-0.057900622487068176,
0.4302869141101837,
0.19924575090408325,
0.8005970120429993,
0.7199955582618713,
-0.37126392126083374,
0.5656601786613464,
-0.31379905343055725,
0.5858135223388672,
-1.0386768579483032,
-0.4892316162586212,
-0.37026292085647583,
-0.4831085503101349,
-0.4931104779243469,
-0.21825093030929565,
0.233586385846138,
0.34330058097839355,
-0.19143065810203552,
0.1672203242778778,
-0.6651133894920349,
0.8763790130615234,
0.9135892987251282,
0.3780483305454254,
0.1312115341424942,
0.15473057329654694,
-0.040153149515390396,
0.050268761813640594,
-0.6487472653388977,
-0.40993207693099976,
1.0326409339904785,
0.7133564949035645,
0.5299306511878967,
0.06239017844200134,
0.8497127890586853,
-0.04189642518758774,
0.36088839173316956,
-0.5019087195396423,
0.6849489212036133,
-0.05171654000878334,
-0.7303599715232849,
-0.25728046894073486,
-0.5701872110366821,
-0.8310466408729553,
0.0014512949855998158,
0.004290466662496328,
-1.2698734998703003,
0.557628870010376,
0.0058501726016402245,
-0.6095609664916992,
0.7591831088066101,
-0.8959882855415344,
0.7818606495857239,
-0.3490271270275116,
-0.4226952791213989,
-0.12545357644557953,
-0.6063451170921326,
0.09028802812099457,
-0.09333178400993347,
0.0733909159898758,
-0.21288830041885376,
-0.1142943724989891,
0.7304244041442871,
0.06508419662714005,
1.356270432472229,
-0.2175537496805191,
-0.23112769424915314,
0.05714724585413933,
0.11298150569200516,
0.47374221682548523,
0.11035478860139847,
-0.04668622463941574,
0.7319169640541077,
-0.38342317938804626,
-0.3995150625705719,
-0.43515074253082275,
1.0928239822387695,
-0.5790545344352722,
-0.525767982006073,
-0.3756558895111084,
-0.4987097680568695,
-0.02127617783844471,
0.26702696084976196,
0.23049679398536682,
0.05651126801967621,
-0.11066224426031113,
0.0830242857336998,
1.1275992393493652,
-0.48860207200050354,
0.7280963659286499,
0.5455091595649719,
0.1393733024597168,
-0.336607426404953,
1.1911078691482544,
0.0799906775355339,
0.03387276828289032,
0.5267565846443176,
0.3536178767681122,
0.07780514657497406,
-0.8402507305145264,
0.21876956522464752,
0.5357474088668823,
-0.6156614422798157,
-0.014500496909022331,
-0.45262840390205383,
-0.5075521469116211,
-0.26984328031539917,
-0.16400669515132904,
-0.581746518611908,
-0.35957980155944824,
-0.3159632682800293,
-0.25316423177719116,
0.10622456669807434,
0.6816934943199158,
-0.27089184522628784,
0.4869477152824402,
-0.4943576157093048,
0.2211495190858841,
0.321505606174469,
0.8097962737083435,
-0.07122401893138885,
-0.3626704216003418,
-0.07009359449148178,
0.003130692522972822,
-0.024414874613285065,
-0.7727132439613342,
0.4612264037132263,
0.16245627403259277,
0.5678752064704895,
0.48842737078666687,
-0.12902653217315674,
0.2418207973241806,
-0.5636174082756042,
0.4959368109703064,
0.34619101881980896,
-0.9855871200561523,
0.7106012105941772,
-0.24861739575862885,
0.07605758309364319,
0.3128964900970459,
0.4257567226886749,
-0.33372315764427185,
-0.30098864436149597,
-0.5862182378768921,
-0.9633141160011292,
0.6507008075714111,
0.1178036481142044,
0.48455706238746643,
-0.16786950826644897,
0.7555692791938782,
-0.15953393280506134,
0.3699221611022949,
-0.9402690529823303,
-0.38262826204299927,
0.21569788455963135,
-0.12716896831989288,
-0.1140274852514267,
-0.58982253074646,
-0.3701344430446625,
-0.022709069773554802,
0.5804870128631592,
0.014244929887354374,
0.4704771637916565,
0.19129110872745514,
0.10900644958019257,
0.17044951021671295,
0.12636293470859528,
0.59685879945755,
0.7559452652931213,
-0.3623129427433014,
0.17943859100341797,
0.14763572812080383,
-0.5831503868103027,
-0.07099856436252594,
-0.25459781289100647,
-0.6812140345573425,
0.11844794452190399,
0.20870497822761536,
0.7677890658378601,
0.10125149041414261,
-0.29681387543678284,
1.0252211093902588,
-0.1523561179637909,
-0.10062884539365768,
-0.6428478360176086,
0.26533493399620056,
0.1632898598909378,
0.3483083248138428,
-0.04726395010948181,
0.22075778245925903,
-0.08139130473136902,
-0.4122178852558136,
0.17115303874015808,
0.5792773962020874,
-0.6062666177749634,
-0.42194312810897827,
0.7045472860336304,
0.045178916305303574,
-0.821527361869812,
0.5535784959793091,
-0.01107066497206688,
-0.43880677223205566,
0.5596134662628174,
0.6055694222450256,
1.0073984861373901,
-0.5265234112739563,
0.26264095306396484,
0.3492719233036041,
0.3512836992740631,
0.13103577494621277,
0.021039314568042755,
-0.29993295669555664,
-0.6799463033676147,
0.019957875832915306,
-0.20416729152202606,
-0.19232043623924255,
0.0559026300907135,
-0.7685549855232239,
-0.22670388221740723,
-1.0942490100860596,
-0.28461894392967224,
-0.026477739214897156,
-0.41723981499671936,
-0.3663727343082428,
0.14515630900859833,
0.5649394989013672,
0.5220897197723389,
-0.6706225275993347,
0.9831184148788452,
0.21389050781726837,
-0.02949157916009426,
-0.6320555210113525,
0.03052150085568428,
-0.25388091802597046,
-0.8275109529495239,
0.6892009973526001,
0.2686907649040222,
-0.1482691615819931,
-0.2554892599582672,
-0.7899123430252075,
-0.6482501029968262,
1.026511549949646,
0.45059171319007874,
-0.8611035943031311,
-0.000622526160441339,
0.15639561414718628,
0.41586193442344666,
-0.1933198869228363,
0.27817991375923157,
0.26281121373176575,
-0.00852711871266365,
-0.3234317898750305,
-0.5975151062011719,
-0.01644897647202015,
-0.34270381927490234,
0.06298743188381195,
0.11493819952011108,
-0.7156395316123962,
0.8993541598320007,
-0.39729586243629456,
-0.1317199468612671,
-0.17168311774730682,
0.522425651550293,
-0.04349334165453911,
0.39139553904533386,
0.24627785384655,
0.3681644797325134,
1.1750138998031616,
-0.06684102863073349,
0.9099705815315247,
-0.39893239736557007,
0.21179337799549103,
1.2558541297912598,
-0.1213698461651802,
1.0446900129318237,
0.48035305738449097,
0.2177266776561737,
0.062339793890714645,
0.32737505435943604,
-0.12242363393306732,
0.6544211506843567,
0.6035120487213135,
-0.6514267921447754,
-0.2050849348306656,
-0.07551946491003036,
-0.2457425743341446,
0.18061600625514984,
0.32940295338630676,
-0.57857346534729,
0.16116340458393097,
0.11879270523786545,
0.04477284848690033,
0.0445747934281826,
-0.3869442641735077,
0.8698235750198364,
-0.012574165128171444,
-0.23065365850925446,
0.534789502620697,
0.20815131068229675,
0.5852535963058472,
-0.8984355330467224,
0.169730544090271,
-0.31710878014564514,
0.34816429018974304,
-0.22783227264881134,
-0.531825602054596,
0.376788854598999,
-0.06584765762090683,
-0.2562916576862335,
-0.27506762742996216,
0.6117764711380005,
-0.44130611419677734,
-0.38811159133911133,
0.5268417596817017,
-0.09352968633174896,
0.22608917951583862,
-0.4525173604488373,
-0.4311826229095459,
-0.280659943819046,
0.05648408085107803,
-0.34620681405067444,
0.6888429522514343,
0.3972610831260681,
0.024394916370511055,
0.9613307118415833,
0.6588270664215088,
0.3290068507194519,
0.30887067317962646,
0.3527621626853943,
0.8234138488769531,
-0.7926921248435974,
-0.3605240285396576,
-0.7127645611763,
0.26581913232803345,
-0.16391825675964355,
-0.2690662443637848,
0.5450746417045593,
0.626724362373352,
1.0601369142532349,
-0.060206089168787,
0.5842199325561523,
0.3302566409111023,
0.42355477809906006,
-0.3286081552505493,
1.2617837190628052,
-0.16336067020893097,
0.632158637046814,
0.19863727688789368,
-0.6902225017547607,
-0.6200178265571594,
0.7871033549308777,
-0.5150742530822754,
-0.21948619186878204,
0.5733086466789246,
1.329176425933838,
-0.08092920482158661,
-0.10718923807144165,
0.45334598422050476,
0.2369992434978485,
0.18006284534931183,
0.7413234710693359,
0.7070861458778381,
-0.5108421444892883,
0.46480444073677063,
-0.8676111102104187,
-0.24398890137672424,
0.3624936044216156,
-0.7781336903572083,
-1.2299631834030151,
-0.34490445256233215,
-0.6810318231582642,
-0.03889577463269234,
0.13649268448352814,
0.2915891110897064,
0.8606001138687134,
-1.1093333959579468,
-0.11126293987035751,
-0.24352067708969116,
0.3571048080921173,
-0.029168184846639633,
-0.12634041905403137,
0.5624793767929077,
-0.11490941047668457,
-0.4558947682380676,
0.49033689498901367,
0.41985034942626953,
0.16287672519683838,
-0.1913626343011856,
0.1419440656900406,
-0.16811427474021912,
-0.1860360950231552,
0.03886955603957176,
0.3838493824005127,
-0.6221902966499329,
-0.11818753182888031,
-0.30725306272506714,
-0.145355224609375,
0.13084302842617035,
1.0341222286224365,
-0.3662847876548767,
0.34656620025634766,
0.4343850314617157,
0.5963326692581177,
0.30593758821487427,
-0.11176095902919769,
0.45234352350234985,
-1.0630717277526855,
0.43792954087257385,
0.3535156548023224,
0.3200452923774719,
0.3896635174751282,
-0.577706515789032,
0.21881335973739624,
0.05384119600057602,
-0.5121292471885681,
-0.581095278263092,
0.2041490525007248,
-0.751991331577301,
-0.27158182859420776,
0.8885170817375183,
-0.7354617714881897,
-0.8662753701210022,
0.04041698947548866,
-0.052814144641160965,
-0.02578752674162388,
-0.1138031855225563,
0.8240880370140076,
0.3935396671295166,
0.42875516414642334,
-0.1788334846496582,
-0.26077717542648315,
0.4320451021194458,
0.506809413433075,
-0.3309912383556366,
0.13855408132076263,
0.005300590768456459,
0.37710630893707275,
0.28078433871269226,
0.6219111084938049,
-0.3538011908531189,
-0.011179465800523758,
-0.03908633068203926,
0.09772197157144547,
-0.03907052055001259,
-0.6528903841972351,
-0.8244263529777527,
0.3465976119041443,
-0.12557151913642883,
-0.5513890981674194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09857v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09857v1
|
IGOT: Information Gain Optimized Tokenizer on Domain Adaptive Pretraining
| 2024-05-16T07:25:10 | 2024-05-16T07:25:10 |
Dawei Feng, Yihai Zhang, Zhixuan Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Pretrained Large Language Models (LLM) such as ChatGPT, Claude, etc. have
demonstrated strong capabilities in various fields of natural language
generation. However, there are still many problems when using LLM in
specialized domain-specific fields. When using generative AI to process
downstream tasks, a common approach is to add new knowledge (e.g., private
domain knowledge, cutting-edge information) to a pretrained model through
continued training or fine-tuning. However, whether there is a universal
paradigm for domain adaptation training is still an open question. In this
article, we proposed Information Gain Optimized Tokenizer (IGOT), which
analyzes the special token set of downstream tasks, constructs a new subset
using heuristic function $\phi$ with the special token and its information
gain, to build new domain-specific tokenizer, and continues pretraining on the
downstream task data. We explored the many positive effects of this method's
customized tokenizer on domain-adaptive pretraining and verified this method
can perform better than the ordinary method of just collecting data and
fine-tuning. Based on our experiment, the continued pretraining process of IGOT
with LLaMA-7B achieved 11.9\% token saving, 12.2\% training time saving, and
5.8\% maximum GPU VRAM usage saving, combined with the T5 model, we can even
reach a 31.5\% of training time saving, making porting general generative AI to
specific domains more effective than before. In domain-specific tasks,
supervised $IGOT_\tau$ shows great performance on reducing both the convergence
radius and convergence point during keep pretraining.
|
[
-0.40981507301330566,
-0.7802427411079407,
0.18263883888721466,
0.2346106469631195,
-0.4518613815307617,
0.2971402704715729,
-0.4129904508590698,
-0.16810515522956848,
0.0532052181661129,
0.2434924989938736,
-0.48615628480911255,
-0.3630228638648987,
-0.9933939576148987,
-0.09394367039203644,
-0.03680068626999855,
1.2225228548049927,
-0.067022405564785,
0.017360344529151917,
-0.028020720928907394,
0.1586003452539444,
-0.7050451636314392,
-0.8581799864768982,
-0.8658629655838013,
-0.036265432834625244,
0.2063041627407074,
0.08187178522348404,
0.04601665213704109,
0.39792099595069885,
0.5899651050567627,
0.23462241888046265,
0.15208213031291962,
0.2649533152580261,
-0.6754652261734009,
-0.08684844523668289,
-0.14822682738304138,
-0.492099791765213,
-0.5770761370658875,
-0.20471757650375366,
0.5508900880813599,
0.41629886627197266,
-0.06943131983280182,
0.16941891610622406,
0.2706232964992523,
0.4607933759689331,
-0.6645686030387878,
0.3252696394920349,
-1.0243887901306152,
-0.15133070945739746,
-0.376986563205719,
-0.6483399868011475,
-0.35802608728408813,
-0.14611168205738068,
-0.010335824452340603,
-1.006070852279663,
0.3425164520740509,
0.11582992225885391,
0.9176440238952637,
0.46145859360694885,
-0.14543965458869934,
-0.08761909604072571,
-0.6838188767433167,
0.6119962930679321,
-0.9296804666519165,
0.2949102222919464,
0.30570289492607117,
0.15019410848617554,
-0.22311143577098846,
-0.9503183960914612,
-0.6035960912704468,
-0.23149991035461426,
0.1493740975856781,
0.2885756194591522,
-0.23851917684078217,
0.20695684850215912,
0.23004862666130066,
0.11064270883798599,
-0.35658928751945496,
0.09916891157627106,
-0.4024394452571869,
-0.1337837129831314,
0.3084825873374939,
-0.07388578355312347,
0.15482781827449799,
0.3362674117088318,
-0.6515651345252991,
-0.032996341586112976,
-0.7993948459625244,
0.0007428122917190194,
0.22913476824760437,
0.27912288904190063,
0.15660794079303741,
0.10699674487113953,
-0.1622692048549652,
0.7617534399032593,
0.19280722737312317,
-0.08036691695451736,
0.15573769807815552,
-0.4515610635280609,
-0.06727554649114609,
-0.09436065703630447,
0.5020236372947693,
0.1142519861459732,
0.4631637930870056,
-0.2774799168109894,
-0.2880796492099762,
-0.17361655831336975,
0.5580414533615112,
-1.1069252490997314,
-0.14468736946582794,
-0.05365806445479393,
-0.31687313318252563,
-0.07500419020652771,
0.0932609811425209,
-0.24257569015026093,
-0.05977426469326019,
-0.45662257075309753,
0.5876939296722412,
-0.59178227186203,
-0.3532746136188507,
0.14404448866844177,
0.076652392745018,
0.17587025463581085,
0.43053391575813293,
-0.9934006333351135,
0.3057793378829956,
0.7513594031333923,
0.7304105758666992,
-0.6268699765205383,
-0.3303067684173584,
-0.8794230818748474,
0.08774916082620621,
-0.18262067437171936,
0.7105329036712646,
-0.23942624032497406,
-0.299577534198761,
0.021734734997153282,
-0.15108107030391693,
-0.4182046353816986,
-0.5450834035873413,
0.4546089172363281,
-0.8943912982940674,
-0.013089505955576897,
-0.14871953427791595,
-0.7701937556266785,
-0.17072466015815735,
0.571871280670166,
-0.3446037173271179,
0.7185856699943542,
0.10429669171571732,
-0.6781904697418213,
0.7191086411476135,
-0.8445224761962891,
-0.36629951000213623,
0.293753057718277,
0.028224032372236252,
-0.2856542468070984,
0.13572777807712555,
0.24457550048828125,
0.46364307403564453,
-0.15368260443210602,
0.3751479983329773,
0.0379827544093132,
-0.3198431134223938,
0.07497480511665344,
-0.28019532561302185,
0.39546942710876465,
0.04201921448111534,
-0.5626881718635559,
0.28672707080841064,
-0.583682656288147,
0.06055731326341629,
0.048088300973176956,
-0.6252302527427673,
-0.2383367270231247,
-0.10199018567800522,
-0.0011003119871020317,
-0.10643598437309265,
0.24303220212459564,
-0.3599558472633362,
0.3468555212020874,
-0.12367662042379379,
0.19671370089054108,
1.0837039947509766,
0.11716742068529129,
0.14444684982299805,
-0.1809423267841339,
0.6966769099235535,
0.19854184985160828,
0.1439538300037384,
-0.010210016742348671,
-0.3336573839187622,
-1.0137758255004883,
-0.3186938166618347,
0.7176083922386169,
0.4707861542701721,
-0.876214325428009,
0.5474530458450317,
-0.46721434593200684,
-0.03948400169610977,
-0.3228881061077118,
0.021003348752856255,
0.31485047936439514,
0.5239559412002563,
0.3796383738517761,
-0.48750039935112,
-0.3651323616504669,
-0.4881782829761505,
-0.3879221975803375,
0.04180625081062317,
0.18042489886283875,
0.11889195442199707,
0.3834238350391388,
-0.3601228594779968,
0.8793023824691772,
-0.5239586234092712,
-0.41461825370788574,
-0.195143461227417,
0.0788646787405014,
0.19933411478996277,
0.519208550453186,
0.752266526222229,
-0.6439146399497986,
-0.6226438283920288,
0.05426522716879845,
-0.5033406615257263,
0.016068801283836365,
-0.06561148911714554,
-0.43060702085494995,
-0.08170425146818161,
0.32135871052742004,
-0.5659741759300232,
0.3629956543445587,
0.3730529844760895,
-0.28681957721710205,
0.4833787977695465,
-0.24828802049160004,
0.1868027299642563,
-1.0716758966445923,
0.16367094218730927,
-0.38771870732307434,
-0.34506431221961975,
-0.7468850016593933,
0.012680175714194775,
-0.08861100673675537,
0.13008961081504822,
-0.1919061839580536,
0.7451454997062683,
-0.3850126266479492,
0.2108408659696579,
-0.560943603515625,
0.21000130474567413,
-0.2560989260673523,
0.6416910886764526,
-0.08585569262504578,
1.0432813167572021,
0.5951098203659058,
-0.8969621658325195,
0.07311207056045532,
0.2701246738433838,
-0.2591051161289215,
0.3391072154045105,
-0.3751392960548401,
0.4776752293109894,
-0.16248451173305511,
0.0006464911857619882,
-0.7296044230461121,
-0.1098947823047638,
0.2818894386291504,
-0.47446614503860474,
0.481790691614151,
0.05353131890296936,
-0.25316697359085083,
-0.1944962739944458,
-0.07043937593698502,
0.40422114729881287,
0.47181078791618347,
-0.8360022306442261,
0.5755434036254883,
0.20737995207309723,
-0.1842648833990097,
-0.6638508439064026,
-0.27114182710647583,
0.04666878655552864,
-0.1591619849205017,
-0.46549904346466064,
0.48761510848999023,
-0.33490708470344543,
0.10667331516742706,
0.02130028046667576,
-0.20150905847549438,
-0.05540599673986435,
0.21711410582065582,
-0.06972938030958176,
0.2875540852546692,
-0.34912949800491333,
0.17955535650253296,
0.02716176211833954,
-0.222905695438385,
-0.17635875940322876,
-0.7892990112304688,
0.7738742828369141,
-0.08560007065534592,
-0.25695401430130005,
-0.35521936416625977,
0.06970631331205368,
0.15100930631160736,
-0.36622291803359985,
0.7746081352233887,
0.7619181871414185,
-0.21729040145874023,
-0.2595386803150177,
-0.5265633463859558,
-0.07252736389636993,
-0.49335581064224243,
0.5707570314407349,
-0.5800188779830933,
-1.0363729000091553,
0.10835187137126923,
-0.4988030791282654,
0.17594924569129944,
0.35542821884155273,
0.5694104433059692,
0.22728101909160614,
0.6557544469833374,
0.7463849782943726,
-0.3085276186466217,
0.8108448386192322,
-0.456240713596344,
0.4243009090423584,
-0.8299185633659363,
-0.039639368653297424,
-0.2461702525615692,
-0.17090533673763275,
-0.14852407574653625,
-0.4124499559402466,
0.2632492482662201,
0.34775230288505554,
-0.1465710550546646,
0.14529754221439362,
-0.45058390498161316,
0.191072478890419,
0.7212731838226318,
0.0037018791772425175,
0.24375124275684357,
0.1726459115743637,
0.26602354645729065,
0.05580877512693405,
-0.7383080124855042,
-0.24910268187522888,
1.1053168773651123,
-0.030574137344956398,
0.7338048219680786,
-0.08899765461683273,
0.6861259937286377,
0.5618355870246887,
0.5979893803596497,
-0.7946755290031433,
0.29667961597442627,
-0.2243730127811432,
-0.321444034576416,
-0.07533733546733856,
-0.3241691589355469,
-0.9376015663146973,
0.15194495022296906,
-0.061199039220809937,
-0.5128989815711975,
0.025344233959913254,
0.45439255237579346,
-0.17636899650096893,
0.301928848028183,
-0.6896087527275085,
0.7118331789970398,
-0.3540950417518616,
-0.0788273885846138,
-0.15677380561828613,
-0.38339972496032715,
0.07053212076425552,
-0.3860953450202942,
0.07090496271848679,
0.02478286810219288,
-0.02410251274704933,
0.872658371925354,
-0.40836769342422485,
0.5878319144248962,
-0.5899571776390076,
0.16539475321769714,
0.312634140253067,
-0.29399263858795166,
0.7581416368484497,
-0.1588478982448578,
-0.007540641352534294,
0.2159644067287445,
-0.2303813248872757,
-0.5629534721374512,
-0.6304216384887695,
0.3893420696258545,
-0.787778377532959,
-0.8729448318481445,
-0.04274653643369675,
-0.28523072600364685,
-0.5310189723968506,
0.4360213875770569,
0.6041135787963867,
0.20018981397151947,
-0.2636715769767761,
0.2495207041501999,
0.537895143032074,
0.04302568733692169,
0.28601160645484924,
0.3201681673526764,
-0.025366373360157013,
-0.4307030737400055,
0.935737133026123,
-0.12890760600566864,
0.44736480712890625,
0.4655304253101349,
0.12269848585128784,
-0.008773290552198887,
-0.9279729127883911,
-0.3917067348957062,
0.05618726462125778,
-0.6649227738380432,
-0.5291008353233337,
-0.6143620014190674,
-0.4041764438152313,
-0.30801162123680115,
-0.02757173776626587,
-0.1722732037305832,
-0.3133205771446228,
-0.3333051800727844,
-0.22713012993335724,
0.35277533531188965,
0.5310375690460205,
0.18650338053703308,
0.9481744170188904,
-0.6669197678565979,
0.16813820600509644,
0.2260986715555191,
0.16148284077644348,
-0.08260076493024826,
-0.5115596652030945,
-0.4485933184623718,
-0.012443140149116516,
-0.24334269762039185,
-0.2465141862630844,
0.2177511602640152,
0.5599797964096069,
0.6143463253974915,
0.2912997305393219,
-0.03810236230492592,
0.7420549988746643,
-0.4121416509151459,
0.6957746744155884,
0.27428382635116577,
-0.9122321605682373,
0.3086020052433014,
-0.16977925598621368,
0.16155323386192322,
0.5119186043739319,
0.24483215808868408,
-0.2862962782382965,
-0.07231650501489639,
-0.403087854385376,
-0.759070873260498,
0.7275850176811218,
0.14542874693870544,
0.4083087146282196,
0.12367785722017288,
0.5805710554122925,
0.4265437424182892,
0.38511142134666443,
-0.5941668152809143,
-0.04062171280384064,
-0.32602211833000183,
-0.28558453917503357,
0.04842078313231468,
-0.1401788294315338,
-0.03310839459300041,
-0.22006253898143768,
0.9033375978469849,
-0.424136221408844,
0.4417622983455658,
-0.06739628314971924,
-0.3048262298107147,
0.09314784407615662,
0.02832970581948757,
0.32218024134635925,
0.6166680455207825,
0.027211355045437813,
-0.15409855544567108,
0.24794000387191772,
-0.7602262496948242,
0.1317720264196396,
0.17981211841106415,
-0.19208133220672607,
-0.24715963006019592,
0.4067104756832123,
1.3728384971618652,
-0.22451841831207275,
-0.4833816885948181,
0.7867198586463928,
-0.27281811833381653,
-0.3069930672645569,
0.011090312153100967,
0.38225284218788147,
-0.2020597904920578,
0.25918614864349365,
0.46601060032844543,
0.3613987863063812,
-0.09238962084054947,
-0.15069831907749176,
0.14181029796600342,
0.47398510575294495,
-0.21618367731571198,
-0.47666481137275696,
0.8843939304351807,
0.15801045298576355,
-0.2910599708557129,
0.49136966466903687,
-0.18911345303058624,
-0.6505874395370483,
0.32231423258781433,
0.8414068818092346,
1.0275521278381348,
-0.292405903339386,
-0.10716481506824493,
0.32413753867149353,
0.07482505589723587,
0.12986214458942413,
0.11644117534160614,
-0.3522891402244568,
-0.796699047088623,
-0.4746963679790497,
-0.8175451755523682,
-0.053993962705135345,
0.11498484760522842,
-0.36567598581314087,
0.08118792623281479,
-0.523613452911377,
-0.4584138095378876,
-0.3354111611843109,
-0.10652697831392288,
-0.8828874826431274,
0.4562832713127136,
-0.2751716673374176,
0.776423454284668,
-0.24797788262367249,
0.9532824158668518,
0.5511834621429443,
-0.15164333581924438,
-0.6942483186721802,
0.47194692492485046,
-0.6450244188308716,
-0.9764695763587952,
0.8599080443382263,
-0.07731851935386658,
-0.23887203633785248,
0.34507596492767334,
-0.5021364688873291,
-1.0882052183151245,
0.969508171081543,
0.4814046323299408,
-0.5117678642272949,
-0.19594928622245789,
-0.047770529985427856,
0.29161563515663147,
-0.4168667495250702,
-0.34183067083358765,
0.45829784870147705,
0.43862417340278625,
0.11542654782533646,
-0.6680448055267334,
0.1280509978532791,
-0.527628481388092,
0.20013532042503357,
0.16445936262607574,
-0.696540355682373,
0.7392292618751526,
-0.13108286261558533,
-0.15102262794971466,
0.11908984184265137,
0.6104570627212524,
0.07591934502124786,
-0.06523296236991882,
0.6933057904243469,
0.2574704587459564,
0.8494616150856018,
-0.10833906382322311,
0.955375075340271,
-0.4596816897392273,
0.2770366966724396,
0.8937426209449768,
0.06796970963478088,
0.543512761592865,
0.38227277994155884,
-0.12217523902654648,
0.16230922937393188,
0.6278200745582581,
0.12151025235652924,
0.8178253173828125,
0.35019388794898987,
-0.5073444843292236,
-0.16027399897575378,
0.02488049678504467,
-0.4366881251335144,
0.310874342918396,
0.261718213558197,
-0.14001530408859253,
0.11868343502283096,
0.31602269411087036,
0.040515027940273285,
-0.4399493336677551,
-0.15322566032409668,
0.8975609540939331,
-0.01035523321479559,
-0.7840266227722168,
0.7734987139701843,
-0.05750766769051552,
0.8530569672584534,
-0.8736411333084106,
0.196517676115036,
-0.18115554749965668,
0.4357282519340515,
-0.0653098002076149,
-0.06163788214325905,
-0.05000918358564377,
0.06882468611001968,
0.08122377842664719,
-0.18243183195590973,
0.8653679490089417,
-0.21606706082820892,
-0.2043996900320053,
0.263149619102478,
0.35751068592071533,
-0.056305304169654846,
-0.25801587104797363,
-0.44276702404022217,
-0.04953621327877045,
0.17342481017112732,
-0.49304142594337463,
0.35666579008102417,
0.2850552499294281,
-0.11036379635334015,
0.31003308296203613,
0.7441886067390442,
0.31976863741874695,
0.41618314385414124,
0.13682734966278076,
1.0273590087890625,
-0.5522350668907166,
-0.5638281106948853,
-0.6238313317298889,
0.45942163467407227,
-0.08691215515136719,
-0.45738959312438965,
0.5114391446113586,
0.51573646068573,
0.9770217537879944,
-0.2827403247356415,
1.095990538597107,
-0.12406433373689651,
0.1682472676038742,
-0.7634366750717163,
0.5661734342575073,
-0.580358624458313,
0.031892262399196625,
-0.061196889728307724,
-1.0330973863601685,
-0.23932842910289764,
0.41231077909469604,
-0.2499006986618042,
0.1884652078151703,
0.5465794801712036,
0.47316110134124756,
-0.17570829391479492,
-0.2779843211174011,
0.3095608651638031,
0.20839539170265198,
0.5832692384719849,
0.3124235272407532,
0.7933395504951477,
-0.3886675536632538,
0.37490221858024597,
0.11564812809228897,
-0.37368056178092957,
-0.2772397994995117,
-0.7229743003845215,
-0.8832244873046875,
-0.6472302675247192,
-0.23867914080619812,
-0.07401873171329498,
0.25582703948020935,
0.8487970232963562,
0.9370668530464172,
-0.7859638929367065,
-0.02117769978940487,
-0.21662095189094543,
-0.29958564043045044,
-0.08049648255109787,
-0.1692177653312683,
0.5212817192077637,
-0.8465828895568848,
-0.678992509841919,
0.32018712162971497,
0.27634480595588684,
-0.07865868508815765,
0.2246970534324646,
-0.24905499815940857,
0.08879329264163971,
-0.0026363094802945852,
0.6999315023422241,
0.0330173522233963,
-0.4285857379436493,
-0.32273268699645996,
0.07081998139619827,
0.21305161714553833,
0.3306014835834503,
1.0277235507965088,
-0.6680311560630798,
0.5471721887588501,
0.2559174597263336,
1.0692451000213623,
1.033755898475647,
0.2866247892379761,
0.6444321274757385,
-0.6870435476303101,
0.2033102810382843,
0.0730355903506279,
0.3075999319553375,
0.3423796594142914,
-0.490369975566864,
0.515724778175354,
0.3647688627243042,
-0.42843127250671387,
-0.5351099967956543,
-0.041469674557447433,
-0.8103510737419128,
-0.05865125358104706,
0.9163764119148254,
-0.3429887890815735,
-0.17329417169094086,
0.15112338960170746,
-0.42612117528915405,
0.47621816396713257,
-0.24151508510112762,
0.8416057229042053,
0.48499393463134766,
-0.20180946588516235,
0.2457786202430725,
-0.37348684668540955,
0.6670243740081787,
0.3243093192577362,
-1.2397081851959229,
-0.11741258949041367,
0.05099570378661156,
0.4213908612728119,
-0.03125360980629921,
1.0255860090255737,
0.12156063318252563,
0.09767291694879532,
-0.08283482491970062,
-0.05893148481845856,
-0.0899730771780014,
-0.2152145951986313,
0.0918537899851799,
-0.11244171112775803,
0.35474175214767456,
-0.5012081265449524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09854v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09854v1
|
On the relevance of pre-neural approaches in natural language processing pedagogy
| 2024-05-16T07:14:13 | 2024-05-16T07:14:13 |
Aditya Joshi, Jake Renzella, Pushpak Bhattacharyya, Saurav Jha, Xiangyu Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While neural approaches using deep learning are the state-of-the-art for
natural language processing (NLP) today, pre-neural algorithms and approaches
still find a place in NLP textbooks and courses of recent years. In this paper,
we compare two introductory NLP courses taught in Australia and India, and
examine how Transformer and pre-neural approaches are balanced within the
lecture plan and assessments of the courses. We also draw parallels with the
objects-first and objects-later debate in CS1 education. We observe that
pre-neural approaches add value to student learning by building an intuitive
understanding of NLP problems, potential solutions and even Transformer-based
models themselves. Despite pre-neural approaches not being state-of-the-art,
the paper makes a case for their inclusion in NLP courses today.
|
[
-0.45018014311790466,
-0.7126125693321228,
0.2522564232349396,
0.08728490024805069,
-0.04149605706334114,
0.3180241286754608,
-0.4505949914455414,
-0.3266240060329437,
0.02545860968530178,
0.14017610251903534,
-0.5706679224967957,
-0.2145567536354065,
-0.45077696442604065,
0.12360577285289764,
-0.4862919747829437,
0.7935153841972351,
0.3281787633895874,
0.037544555962085724,
-0.23218248784542084,
0.016570275649428368,
-0.4963836371898651,
-0.7434455752372742,
-0.8229120373725891,
-0.5009604096412659,
0.4005413055419922,
0.12271902710199356,
0.9729353785514832,
0.05044601112604141,
0.42702174186706543,
0.3813384473323822,
-0.2067573219537735,
-0.3097429573535919,
0.05362999811768532,
-0.039978574961423874,
-0.3850416839122772,
-0.5054598450660706,
-0.14037109911441803,
0.017125237733125687,
0.5339760184288025,
1.0697308778762817,
-0.11817006766796112,
0.03476092591881752,
0.2597688138484955,
0.9069181680679321,
-0.6821976900100708,
-0.29467329382896423,
-0.17908108234405518,
0.33376115560531616,
-0.21461491286754608,
-0.07449359446763992,
-0.5076565146446228,
-0.2311343103647232,
0.7210369110107422,
-0.4885408580303192,
0.14114490151405334,
-0.4868677854537964,
0.7799028158187866,
0.23149865865707397,
-0.1087028756737709,
-0.39956390857696533,
-0.8275684714317322,
0.8764071464538574,
-0.7881109714508057,
0.23584657907485962,
0.16949082911014557,
0.3990333378314972,
0.1863606721162796,
-0.9839242696762085,
-0.5911691784858704,
0.04195614904165268,
-0.36075159907341003,
-0.0844632163643837,
-0.09561758488416672,
0.01743706874549389,
0.11150636523962021,
0.48034507036209106,
-0.47861355543136597,
0.6311754584312439,
-0.5414358377456665,
-0.11133074760437012,
0.449977308511734,
-0.009295216761529446,
0.18772035837173462,
-0.20269402861595154,
-0.278057336807251,
-0.16806447505950928,
-0.5795974135398865,
0.31136631965637207,
0.4360402524471283,
0.4583738446235657,
0.06576677411794662,
0.2507708966732025,
-0.06600432097911835,
0.989306628704071,
0.03687068819999695,
0.2042795866727829,
-0.07316917926073074,
-0.4715360999107361,
-0.29667171835899353,
0.23270580172538757,
0.8600547909736633,
-0.12636664509773254,
0.6003146171569824,
-0.1754675805568695,
0.2662475109100342,
0.1765580177307129,
0.5783824324607849,
-0.6521314382553101,
-0.4188215434551239,
0.14596204459667206,
-0.425176203250885,
-0.13106028735637665,
-0.2722451984882355,
-0.6687290072441101,
-0.2310129851102829,
-0.7902764678001404,
0.22407838702201843,
-0.10096266865730286,
-0.4052460193634033,
0.2588030993938446,
0.215721994638443,
0.7339011430740356,
0.18687477707862854,
-1.1504263877868652,
0.6579667925834656,
0.8205055594444275,
0.5405007004737854,
-0.04843199625611305,
-0.30979037284851074,
0.14752931892871857,
-0.4708181321620941,
-0.40752509236335754,
0.948122501373291,
-0.7210369110107422,
-0.00803737249225378,
0.1229531317949295,
-0.3708933889865875,
0.016949795186519623,
-0.38677266240119934,
0.5367603302001953,
-0.3790484666824341,
0.6236244440078735,
-0.18478383123874664,
-0.2793501317501068,
-0.29309672117233276,
0.21751827001571655,
-0.37427645921707153,
0.9986678957939148,
-0.014161897823214531,
-0.70849609375,
0.36730140447616577,
-0.88176429271698,
-0.7544759511947632,
-0.09189631789922714,
-0.18928669393062592,
-0.04245072230696678,
0.05514729022979736,
0.4068174660205841,
0.4856555759906769,
-0.1739274114370346,
0.3864976763725281,
0.31710514426231384,
-0.36116209626197815,
-0.03633075952529907,
-0.5831685066223145,
0.9431895613670349,
0.11529657989740372,
-0.3640681505203247,
0.19343745708465576,
-0.6715529561042786,
0.19716867804527283,
0.1675499826669693,
-0.06181564927101135,
-0.28234541416168213,
0.365578830242157,
-0.06855720281600952,
0.3710629343986511,
0.008962903171777725,
-0.12947164475917816,
0.14145569503307343,
-0.9074211120605469,
0.7174968719482422,
0.6467257142066956,
-0.5706882476806641,
1.0193417072296143,
0.19477777183055878,
0.33837929368019104,
-0.1424848735332489,
0.2153274267911911,
-0.44863492250442505,
-0.263439416885376,
-0.8346642851829529,
0.4352330267429352,
0.3070753216743469,
0.511290431022644,
-0.5048829317092896,
0.09872771054506302,
-0.13394370675086975,
-0.6628426909446716,
-0.4423648715019226,
0.05915727838873863,
0.3912960886955261,
0.5224705338478088,
0.6628351807594299,
-0.0855298861861229,
-0.7538623809814453,
-0.6844583749771118,
-0.6647936105728149,
-0.03419000655412674,
-0.06619840115308762,
-0.03623324632644653,
0.08784416317939758,
0.0924268364906311,
1.1209042072296143,
-0.4209393560886383,
-0.18851058185100555,
-0.16201429069042206,
0.045649200677871704,
0.3864498436450958,
0.5664607882499695,
0.6712836623191833,
-0.9648053646087646,
-0.4786929190158844,
-0.16527590155601501,
-0.8938139081001282,
0.26490458846092224,
-0.0631687268614769,
0.0011246134527027607,
0.35110408067703247,
0.48591896891593933,
-0.613362193107605,
0.6685119867324829,
0.20267631113529205,
-0.16221044957637787,
0.3016277849674225,
-0.20628389716148376,
-0.044285181909799576,
-0.9267783761024475,
-0.284913569688797,
-0.17543162405490875,
0.014494805596768856,
-0.941216766834259,
-0.11794353276491165,
-0.16867609322071075,
-0.20012082159519196,
-0.7047709822654724,
0.4030391573905945,
-0.2942745089530945,
-0.0997154638171196,
-0.5571413636207581,
0.13151249289512634,
0.11322583258152008,
0.2509956955909729,
0.3971942365169525,
0.5877456068992615,
0.6271594166755676,
-0.7160813808441162,
-0.0369039811193943,
0.16460742056369781,
-0.18017521500587463,
0.47370803356170654,
-0.6126421093940735,
0.3497507572174072,
-0.07167193293571472,
0.11022299528121948,
-0.7004290223121643,
0.3550854027271271,
0.09209412336349487,
-0.6385936141014099,
0.6065862774848938,
0.13787713646888733,
-0.15000994503498077,
-0.5125479698181152,
-0.14309746026992798,
0.35513535141944885,
0.46434104442596436,
-0.5252524614334106,
0.8399584293365479,
0.06962127238512039,
-0.25670191645622253,
-1.120299220085144,
-0.8926755785942078,
0.26578032970428467,
-0.020210914313793182,
-0.33104613423347473,
0.33118754625320435,
0.15136726200580597,
-0.2479100227355957,
0.014755203388631344,
-0.27411308884620667,
-0.3036572337150574,
0.34302932024002075,
0.1286219358444214,
0.08453324437141418,
-0.6816827654838562,
-0.00366220367141068,
-0.21600230038166046,
-0.4473247528076172,
0.3376486301422119,
-0.5484946370124817,
0.7284261584281921,
-0.3851916790008545,
-0.26308003067970276,
-0.5206761360168457,
0.22377680242061615,
0.19573624432086945,
-0.27068379521369934,
0.6970782279968262,
0.504405677318573,
-0.37950652837753296,
-0.0191388837993145,
-0.5064370036125183,
-0.3790762424468994,
-0.5228223204612732,
0.4475330412387848,
-0.13327407836914062,
-0.6485900282859802,
0.0901508554816246,
-0.03896351903676987,
0.20696385204792023,
0.3418894112110138,
0.3216114044189453,
-0.32982879877090454,
0.4944821298122406,
0.9220914244651794,
-0.004409773275256157,
0.4359720051288605,
-0.3309377431869507,
1.0037769079208374,
-0.5705322623252869,
-0.10917200893163681,
-0.7161502242088318,
-0.3543736934661865,
-0.439291775226593,
-0.07543953508138657,
-0.5822736024856567,
0.17777502536773682,
-0.4766436517238617,
0.39982953667640686,
-0.8199195861816406,
0.7043569684028625,
0.43506813049316406,
-0.08661806583404541,
0.09552574902772903,
-0.09038884937763214,
0.32566899061203003,
-0.11871926486492157,
-0.9541674256324768,
-0.6509103178977966,
1.129704236984253,
0.026492571458220482,
0.41554737091064453,
-0.18108920753002167,
0.5550430417060852,
0.016612349078059196,
0.6034348607063293,
-0.9081185460090637,
0.3768875300884247,
-0.20332489907741547,
-0.5585802793502808,
-0.46134015917778015,
0.03621166571974754,
-1.0603448152542114,
0.25955843925476074,
-0.4690401256084442,
-0.33189401030540466,
0.009252247400581837,
-0.0012790128821507096,
-0.5459282398223877,
0.5781633257865906,
-0.8998270630836487,
0.9764001965522766,
-0.22997987270355225,
-0.3691743016242981,
0.04478961601853371,
-0.8309909105300903,
-0.008504255674779415,
-0.018719665706157684,
0.3343900144100189,
0.329524964094162,
0.2508243918418884,
0.833392322063446,
-0.2374342978000641,
0.6166248917579651,
-0.2580333650112152,
-0.009975665248930454,
0.5354824066162109,
-0.05486008897423744,
-0.26515549421310425,
0.03130633011460304,
0.051145222038030624,
0.20214907824993134,
-0.21263468265533447,
-0.5378103256225586,
-0.6106099486351013,
0.48613885045051575,
-0.6963098049163818,
-0.9055909514427185,
-0.6049356460571289,
-0.3049728274345398,
0.14715562760829926,
0.35912856459617615,
0.16679531335830688,
0.32563063502311707,
-0.04422547668218613,
0.21267497539520264,
0.5072340369224548,
-0.3364359438419342,
0.9558722376823425,
0.41268426179885864,
-0.18266215920448303,
-0.14227871596813202,
0.6128638386726379,
0.21841387450695038,
0.379143089056015,
0.45163559913635254,
0.38586798310279846,
-0.31205588579177856,
-0.6586812734603882,
-0.004409497138112783,
-0.28169968724250793,
-1.0615290403366089,
-0.07236868888139725,
-0.6946476101875305,
-0.36706504225730896,
-0.5310333371162415,
-0.6899706125259399,
-0.5506460666656494,
-0.005985848139971495,
-0.2121330201625824,
-0.19635286927223206,
-0.00871462281793356,
0.6264377236366272,
0.015995513647794724,
0.48868951201438904,
-0.625399649143219,
0.3293091654777527,
0.58722323179245,
0.14696016907691956,
0.10492239892482758,
-0.24871085584163666,
0.003951402381062508,
0.1427726447582245,
-0.33990439772605896,
-0.4873628318309784,
0.24017645418643951,
0.3167460262775421,
0.4777250289916992,
0.2158171385526657,
-0.14604349434375763,
0.5411004424095154,
-0.6353662610054016,
1.0923655033111572,
0.3417593538761139,
-0.9886271357536316,
0.8147385716438293,
0.23537693917751312,
0.31030845642089844,
0.7599502801895142,
0.7563378810882568,
-0.25108128786087036,
0.1626812070608139,
-0.6231858730316162,
-0.965894341468811,
0.6673798561096191,
0.16930778324604034,
0.6037660241127014,
-0.025740528479218483,
0.269275963306427,
0.1319098174571991,
0.1382964551448822,
-0.9303984642028809,
-0.5172043442726135,
-0.47401219606399536,
-0.06698072701692581,
-0.49715158343315125,
-0.10313697159290314,
0.36688902974128723,
-0.48968079686164856,
0.24143445491790771,
-0.17997334897518158,
-0.004583782982081175,
0.29099154472351074,
-0.35977497696876526,
0.33497849106788635,
0.45242223143577576,
0.505678117275238,
1.0022698640823364,
-0.08215317875146866,
0.11331913620233536,
0.3019077181816101,
-0.6578247547149658,
0.19724248349666595,
-0.2379625141620636,
0.011461174115538597,
-0.0666634812951088,
0.4156675636768341,
0.6257768273353577,
0.6263960599899292,
-0.4199363887310028,
0.7093716263771057,
-0.19049327075481415,
-0.20141321420669556,
-0.48858147859573364,
-0.1505766063928604,
0.03550281748175621,
-0.005480833817273378,
0.46927717328071594,
0.5938255786895752,
-0.0026043630205094814,
-0.5723884701728821,
0.008882632479071617,
0.1293734312057495,
-0.5102851390838623,
-0.34656187891960144,
0.5086185336112976,
0.006987323518842459,
-0.762622594833374,
0.6510947346687317,
0.16677899658679962,
-0.6405586004257202,
0.6116777658462524,
0.5429672598838806,
0.8959225416183472,
-0.26330623030662537,
0.0738174319267273,
0.40229910612106323,
0.5354601144790649,
-0.07440750300884247,
0.07399459183216095,
-0.5579555630683899,
-0.5860212445259094,
-0.9150763154029846,
-0.5942237973213196,
-0.34714579582214355,
-0.1603536158800125,
-0.6156324744224548,
0.5311614871025085,
-0.5134391188621521,
-0.06165730580687523,
0.16179168224334717,
-0.06554413586854935,
-0.9187483787536621,
0.2995055317878723,
0.3942863345146179,
0.8312735557556152,
-0.8805526494979858,
0.6701464653015137,
0.7871780395507812,
-0.3182670474052429,
-0.6672638058662415,
-0.19415803253650665,
-0.4042667746543884,
-0.21029207110404968,
0.9561424255371094,
0.33419230580329895,
0.03067345730960369,
0.030382288619875908,
-0.37553539872169495,
-0.906737208366394,
0.6625248193740845,
0.32205262780189514,
-0.3036481440067291,
-0.3989987075328827,
0.2423076033592224,
0.5628891587257385,
0.1032317504286766,
0.5435855984687805,
0.5710527300834656,
0.4313131272792816,
-0.31485551595687866,
-0.7804656028747559,
-0.3616192936897278,
-0.14340725541114807,
-0.23304224014282227,
0.13153411448001862,
-0.14056101441383362,
0.9659174084663391,
-0.09070078283548355,
-0.3396100401878357,
-0.3254898190498352,
0.9728534817695618,
-0.11770778149366379,
0.43154335021972656,
0.32148340344429016,
0.6672683358192444,
0.369329035282135,
-0.2552895247936249,
1.00307035446167,
0.11405560374259949,
0.1947140097618103,
1.127132773399353,
-0.1515820026397705,
0.9143248200416565,
0.5176684260368347,
-0.7183484435081482,
0.6751295328140259,
0.5578727126121521,
0.3454330563545227,
0.3020923435688019,
0.35671108961105347,
0.12800739705562592,
-0.10329484939575195,
0.2448047548532486,
-0.5145888924598694,
0.5766997933387756,
0.37655821442604065,
0.062168680131435394,
-0.39880266785621643,
0.38503628969192505,
-0.027510127052664757,
0.6397578120231628,
-0.6259964108467102,
0.831272304058075,
0.31709396839141846,
-0.7471887469291687,
0.5736807584762573,
-0.5142015814781189,
1.0292129516601562,
-0.5881406664848328,
0.11891315132379532,
-0.0018158791353926063,
0.043826885521411896,
-0.46310368180274963,
-0.8774610757827759,
0.6898655891418457,
-0.03536968678236008,
-0.26697278022766113,
-0.46701526641845703,
0.9193580746650696,
0.02401820383965969,
-0.3121396005153656,
0.4161534607410431,
0.3175491392612457,
-0.058123983442783356,
-0.18102554976940155,
-0.42116135358810425,
-0.3535274565219879,
-0.4625907242298126,
-0.39508765935897827,
0.2911384105682373,
0.1192430928349495,
0.08221033215522766,
0.36697712540626526,
0.6675208210945129,
-0.21474646031856537,
0.4053668677806854,
0.19548861682415009,
0.697130024433136,
-0.6793272495269775,
-0.3175998032093048,
-1.0674210786819458,
0.5579424500465393,
0.0015340546378865838,
-0.3893102705478668,
0.5891906023025513,
0.3247222900390625,
1.260329008102417,
0.06077641621232033,
0.3491264879703522,
0.0021114281844347715,
0.12580738961696625,
-0.5284025073051453,
0.5568227171897888,
-0.1977526694536209,
0.09361688047647476,
-0.31414368748664856,
-1.1801261901855469,
-0.5276769399642944,
0.7910841107368469,
-0.6176202893257141,
0.11454847455024719,
0.8848502039909363,
0.21505001187324524,
0.12228111922740936,
0.29039475321769714,
0.03454204648733139,
-0.18598392605781555,
0.22776572406291962,
0.5912320017814636,
1.1361567974090576,
-0.6591172218322754,
0.15013864636421204,
-0.5642700791358948,
0.09898768365383148,
0.24745512008666992,
-1.0471620559692383,
-0.8904683589935303,
-0.3781026005744934,
-0.22150234878063202,
-0.0936904028058052,
-0.2193383127450943,
0.8965011835098267,
0.8310146331787109,
-0.6994770765304565,
-0.08814030140638351,
-0.4092290699481964,
0.10833556950092316,
-0.2575830817222595,
-0.23547272384166718,
0.4963139593601227,
-0.7513141632080078,
-0.5462305545806885,
0.4435063302516937,
0.33730214834213257,
-0.20791901648044586,
-0.2143126130104065,
0.043031178414821625,
-0.5775924324989319,
-0.03899887576699257,
0.7716781497001648,
0.3828573226928711,
-0.7273053526878357,
-0.007184043060988188,
0.21958895027637482,
0.1158486157655716,
0.48572033643722534,
0.842587947845459,
-1.2304474115371704,
0.34753328561782837,
0.5515395402908325,
1.0267540216445923,
0.35739970207214355,
-0.2079184502363205,
0.2894194722175598,
-0.457624614238739,
0.5318850874900818,
0.6189092397689819,
0.09209457784891129,
0.44280678033828735,
-0.23876400291919708,
0.41586825251579285,
-0.0381699837744236,
-0.3667583167552948,
-0.8680869936943054,
0.06678502261638641,
-0.7573719620704651,
-0.5447825789451599,
0.3636121451854706,
-0.03971249610185623,
-0.33133965730667114,
-0.04992165416479111,
-0.11329787969589233,
0.36001574993133545,
0.4999076724052429,
0.40416857600212097,
0.7044825553894043,
0.12785150110721588,
-0.13318727910518646,
-0.5784410238265991,
0.5599451065063477,
0.7295721173286438,
-0.782932460308075,
-0.2950059771537781,
-0.28165778517723083,
-0.11827118694782257,
0.51988685131073,
0.5215252637863159,
-0.2210862785577774,
0.07467900216579437,
-0.10388029366731644,
0.15723533928394318,
-0.028294969350099564,
-0.5394144654273987,
-0.4194585084915161,
0.23420938849449158,
-0.12846970558166504,
0.13781212270259857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09848v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09848v1
|
Enhancing Semantics in Multimodal Chain of Thought via Soft Negative Sampling
| 2024-05-16T06:55:11 | 2024-05-16T06:55:11 |
Guangmin Zheng, Jin Wang, Xiaobing Zhou, Xuejie Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Chain of thought (CoT) has proven useful for problems requiring complex
reasoning. Many of these problems are both textual and multimodal. Given the
inputs in different modalities, a model generates a rationale and then uses it
to answer a question. Because of the hallucination issue, the generated soft
negative rationales with high textual quality but illogical semantics do not
always help improve answer accuracy. This study proposes a rationale generation
method using soft negative sampling (SNSE-CoT) to mitigate hallucinations in
multimodal CoT. Five methods were applied to generate soft negative samples
that shared highly similar text but had different semantics from the original.
Bidirectional margin loss (BML) was applied to introduce them into the
traditional contrastive learning framework that involves only positive and
negative samples. Extensive experiments on the ScienceQA dataset demonstrated
the effectiveness of the proposed method. Code and data are released at
https://github.com/zgMin/SNSE-CoT.
|
[
-0.7977983355522156,
-0.8691749572753906,
0.7501500844955444,
0.12329744547605515,
-0.43474358320236206,
-0.15672968327999115,
-0.41091156005859375,
-0.17960835993289948,
0.4822618365287781,
0.6423006057739258,
-0.8997235298156738,
-0.6139165163040161,
-0.18746468424797058,
0.1717212051153183,
-0.2538048326969147,
1.2416497468948364,
-0.04411999136209488,
0.11018607765436172,
-0.09486807882785797,
-0.302023708820343,
-0.5212542414665222,
-0.7391281127929688,
-0.2732401192188263,
-0.12938083708286285,
0.7392027378082275,
0.43233180046081543,
0.5767263174057007,
-0.09845846891403198,
0.13988371193408966,
0.25995561480522156,
0.06547228246927261,
0.520304799079895,
-0.48736220598220825,
0.6373807787895203,
-0.601388692855835,
-0.35780540108680725,
-0.3197990655899048,
-0.07216791808605194,
0.21024399995803833,
0.5178764462471008,
-0.09074953943490982,
0.004265888128429651,
-0.08258617669343948,
0.4137539863586426,
-1.0479154586791992,
-0.22517095506191254,
-0.683784008026123,
0.0807075947523117,
0.04181540384888649,
-0.6583914756774902,
-0.49472296237945557,
-0.2542380690574646,
0.04344097897410393,
-0.6200323700904846,
0.40769535303115845,
-0.2930434048175812,
0.6865652203559875,
0.1812981516122818,
-0.6419529914855957,
-0.5237482190132141,
-0.4944226145744324,
0.9989404678344727,
-0.6709029674530029,
0.3012900650501251,
0.26131701469421387,
0.0792132318019867,
-0.23014989495277405,
-0.472447007894516,
-0.9902504086494446,
-0.349308043718338,
0.07142776250839233,
0.21749041974544525,
0.531590461730957,
0.1189284399151802,
0.3428588807582855,
0.004071829374879599,
-0.14582332968711853,
-0.432664692401886,
-0.4894919693470001,
-0.3777817189693451,
0.5542986989021301,
0.10588140785694122,
0.2623167634010315,
-0.4555928409099579,
-0.6710650324821472,
-0.30714407563209534,
-0.5519009828567505,
-0.43771636486053467,
0.3515475392341614,
0.38007688522338867,
0.1883702129125595,
0.7847000360488892,
-0.03679763898253441,
0.30677536129951477,
-0.12091229110956192,
-0.3420317769050598,
0.557776689529419,
-0.6136896014213562,
-0.04758326709270477,
0.2085181474685669,
0.38515666127204895,
0.5696402192115784,
0.15610098838806152,
-0.20779769122600555,
-0.23675629496574402,
0.6072349548339844,
0.4646342396736145,
-0.8853139877319336,
0.07968165725469589,
0.20773251354694366,
-0.24618974328041077,
-0.3397282063961029,
-0.15152747929096222,
-1.0338515043258667,
-0.5426383018493652,
-0.8120685815811157,
0.5684919953346252,
-0.6353691220283508,
-0.4184575080871582,
0.06398262828588486,
-0.4816228449344635,
0.21425320208072662,
0.3945017158985138,
-0.39012470841407776,
0.35556334257125854,
0.2476625144481659,
0.6777848601341248,
-0.07320239394903183,
-0.2587890326976776,
-0.43867674469947815,
0.28155770897865295,
-0.34849104285240173,
0.8823790550231934,
-0.32604357600212097,
-0.2742488384246826,
-0.19073083996772766,
-0.011559771373867989,
-0.11879121512174606,
-0.3945119082927704,
0.5300000309944153,
-0.23155947029590607,
0.29109272360801697,
-0.21283785998821259,
-0.29995012283325195,
-0.3460513651371002,
0.5265739560127258,
-0.637542188167572,
0.7903968095779419,
-0.05456429347395897,
-0.7120301127433777,
0.35127517580986023,
-0.24836647510528564,
-0.45703572034835815,
-0.13566114008426666,
-0.5613153576850891,
-0.32160332798957825,
0.20833340287208557,
0.0953894630074501,
0.22416378557682037,
-0.14658090472221375,
0.37096384167671204,
-0.49990445375442505,
-0.3420324921607971,
0.5308185815811157,
-0.5837669372558594,
0.5480539202690125,
0.3138224184513092,
-0.7047701478004456,
0.3170049488544464,
-0.8466384410858154,
0.22444269061088562,
-0.18405146896839142,
0.09745172411203384,
-0.49930834770202637,
-0.11580874025821686,
0.28327444195747375,
0.6416108012199402,
-0.18199510872364044,
-0.43235865235328674,
-0.031600892543792725,
-0.31818893551826477,
0.3070906698703766,
0.8963106274604797,
0.23977921903133392,
0.3739928603172302,
-0.5081953406333923,
0.5012355446815491,
0.36048424243927,
-0.07830817252397537,
-0.03657557815313339,
-0.28487834334373474,
-0.8164048194885254,
-0.2373267561197281,
-0.0023109063040465117,
0.30263814330101013,
-1.322237491607666,
0.0033616574946790934,
0.19608379900455475,
-0.23463290929794312,
-0.3780446946620941,
0.3072492480278015,
0.3162129819393158,
0.5569236874580383,
0.717889130115509,
-0.35067689418792725,
-0.5863288044929504,
-0.88971346616745,
0.19356201589107513,
0.2145182490348816,
0.04927121475338936,
0.5288973450660706,
0.4394282400608063,
-0.4669477343559265,
0.549024224281311,
-0.5571343898773193,
-0.4054778814315796,
-0.3109035789966583,
0.3187197744846344,
-0.015309320762753487,
0.5589228868484497,
0.280224084854126,
-0.9568682312965393,
0.03408973291516304,
-0.4626100957393646,
-0.5590738654136658,
-0.065920390188694,
-0.42569974064826965,
-0.662895917892456,
0.4858681857585907,
0.4111742675304413,
-0.7408560514450073,
0.5362961888313293,
0.32134929299354553,
-0.409227579832077,
0.731221079826355,
-0.15409649908542633,
0.2596859931945801,
-1.3095608949661255,
-0.04518153890967369,
-0.04895880073308945,
0.24712829291820526,
-0.4950098693370819,
0.20201101899147034,
-0.08529375493526459,
-0.038014624267816544,
-0.5430874228477478,
0.2754637598991394,
-0.23425444960594177,
0.3002506196498871,
-0.35273194313049316,
0.4874778985977173,
0.3530329167842865,
0.7592240571975708,
0.20481090247631073,
0.6631326079368591,
0.27837103605270386,
-0.7661018967628479,
0.153572678565979,
0.05742115527391434,
0.0008304097573272884,
0.6458417773246765,
-0.30154961347579956,
0.26585638523101807,
-0.4555003046989441,
0.4481901228427887,
-0.9382184147834778,
-0.07572895288467407,
0.2669605314731598,
-0.18931853771209717,
0.05080541968345642,
0.3053645193576813,
-0.20587588846683502,
0.015309451147913933,
-0.8343102335929871,
0.7843624353408813,
0.12006623297929764,
-0.35476046800613403,
0.6489930152893066,
0.21055923402309418,
0.0018815927905961871,
-0.5483313798904419,
-0.7264036536216736,
0.09745493531227112,
-0.18019916117191315,
-0.4825975298881531,
0.4375571608543396,
-0.1980154663324356,
-0.16606305539608002,
-0.04930584505200386,
-0.11952625960111618,
0.007518191821873188,
-0.24561011791229248,
0.1041850596666336,
0.43146371841430664,
-0.3153645396232605,
0.5769568085670471,
0.21279215812683105,
-0.2091708779335022,
0.06024816632270813,
-0.2118394821882248,
0.7607289552688599,
-0.12980057299137115,
-0.08408918976783752,
-0.30751708149909973,
0.47043755650520325,
0.6361483931541443,
0.08708956092596054,
0.7077004313468933,
0.7091508507728577,
-0.3728891909122467,
-0.5196931958198547,
-0.6541193723678589,
-0.5082198977470398,
-0.4330028295516968,
0.0006064673070795834,
-0.4724639654159546,
-0.35745835304260254,
0.30376046895980835,
-0.02075856178998947,
-0.3926542103290558,
0.29572194814682007,
0.6949390172958374,
0.007945891469717026,
0.9082579016685486,
0.15222111344337463,
0.6236851215362549,
0.27273955941200256,
-0.5139038562774658,
0.2966840863227844,
-0.8498438000679016,
-0.3581662178039551,
-0.23886829614639282,
-0.31253767013549805,
-0.8560418486595154,
-0.6588495969772339,
0.2315632700920105,
-0.005240975879132748,
-0.11771812289953232,
0.18247808516025543,
-0.5479523539543152,
0.19415317475795746,
0.6552198529243469,
0.43132054805755615,
0.14403381943702698,
-0.0843806117773056,
-0.31950441002845764,
-0.0698857232928276,
-0.44925016164779663,
-0.5290840268135071,
0.9769730567932129,
-0.1577364206314087,
0.873967170715332,
0.1367020457983017,
0.7521583437919617,
0.034116603434085846,
0.3100877106189728,
-0.7045078873634338,
0.7028253674507141,
0.021930120885372162,
-0.717265784740448,
-0.1765020489692688,
-0.5908377170562744,
-0.5623464584350586,
0.5107202529907227,
-0.491243451833725,
-0.4727412760257721,
0.44083383679389954,
0.026754435151815414,
-0.2435160130262375,
0.1030743271112442,
-0.8967938423156738,
0.5316742658615112,
-0.13560229539871216,
-0.746950626373291,
-0.4021478593349457,
-0.5682711601257324,
0.443996399641037,
0.07917102426290512,
0.12983863055706024,
-0.008806089870631695,
-0.04322413355112076,
0.6290966272354126,
-0.45664477348327637,
0.8026123642921448,
-0.24936728179454803,
-0.21372586488723755,
0.6931278705596924,
0.12731143832206726,
0.2204125076532364,
0.2817767262458801,
-0.08983966708183289,
-0.12025807052850723,
0.08000703901052475,
-0.4852384328842163,
-0.8051825761795044,
0.7954001426696777,
-0.5981745719909668,
-0.560577929019928,
-0.4247487783432007,
-0.5977229475975037,
-0.2052299678325653,
0.0894247367978096,
0.25396883487701416,
0.7525583505630493,
0.32505759596824646,
0.2083587348461151,
0.5382246971130371,
-0.4437635540962219,
0.11932136118412018,
0.0830504521727562,
-0.027348579838871956,
-0.7068510055541992,
1.0173932313919067,
0.3022425174713135,
0.3141751289367676,
0.07548899948596954,
0.25517621636390686,
-0.43190377950668335,
-0.1752777099609375,
-0.35467779636383057,
0.1471189558506012,
-0.8348481059074402,
-0.46245265007019043,
-0.6496178507804871,
-0.3164348602294922,
-0.366255521774292,
-0.3729231059551239,
-0.16813255846500397,
-0.6345260143280029,
-0.0014750052941963077,
-0.3264589011669159,
0.3477594256401062,
0.33921748399734497,
-0.07861416786909103,
-0.2007097601890564,
-0.43689635396003723,
0.719429075717926,
0.17247532308101654,
0.2229016274213791,
0.15961773693561554,
0.09558353573083878,
0.196162611246109,
0.314281165599823,
-0.550772488117218,
-0.9605512022972107,
0.27006250619888306,
-0.0635865330696106,
0.3695317804813385,
0.230190709233284,
0.3820461928844452,
0.8973239064216614,
-0.20335155725479126,
0.7033988833427429,
0.432540625333786,
-1.0221357345581055,
0.6594043970108032,
-0.050762616097927094,
0.2321162074804306,
0.9064701199531555,
0.26684269309043884,
-0.33821314573287964,
-0.642325222492218,
-0.6457744836807251,
-1.1617367267608643,
0.3458954989910126,
0.364116907119751,
0.2812981903553009,
-0.3178827464580536,
0.25162482261657715,
0.4672192931175232,
0.3303165137767792,
-0.8564072847366333,
-0.0015377001836895943,
-0.5402088165283203,
-0.2956523001194,
0.022312454879283905,
-0.22748859226703644,
-0.09778466820716858,
-0.21887779235839844,
0.7680336833000183,
-0.20134638249874115,
0.14217016100883484,
0.534034788608551,
-0.17602550983428955,
-0.005263225641101599,
0.5401319861412048,
0.9386200904846191,
0.6146863102912903,
-0.22251302003860474,
0.6921631693840027,
0.41344666481018066,
-0.5715556740760803,
0.18434764444828033,
-0.2577413320541382,
-0.2487514168024063,
-0.012533905915915966,
0.26133283972740173,
0.45057788491249084,
0.1137152761220932,
-0.8668810129165649,
0.49107441306114197,
-0.10304512828588486,
-0.37442341446876526,
-0.29471826553344727,
0.13751593232154846,
-0.1697276085615158,
0.1298408955335617,
0.14286895096302032,
0.37480899691581726,
0.343622624874115,
-0.6219905614852905,
0.3246292769908905,
0.15293334424495697,
-0.44817858934402466,
-0.18997973203659058,
0.37371423840522766,
0.18693968653678894,
-0.11753661185503006,
0.6382929682731628,
-0.28553837537765503,
-0.4801557958126068,
0.6196632981300354,
0.8283834457397461,
0.8049390912055969,
0.11806859821081161,
0.38858547806739807,
0.3894735276699066,
0.07410649955272675,
0.22614789009094238,
0.565920889377594,
-0.4131286144256592,
-0.7871010303497314,
-0.5489185452461243,
-0.47117796540260315,
-0.3476470708847046,
0.2869361639022827,
-0.6307714581489563,
0.5086045265197754,
-0.38445326685905457,
-0.2961936295032501,
-0.23355737328529358,
-0.0447395034134388,
-0.5193275809288025,
0.35256245732307434,
0.29957816004753113,
0.6098788380622864,
-0.6251158118247986,
0.5932410359382629,
0.41457492113113403,
-0.7338792085647583,
-0.7920477986335754,
0.14138028025627136,
-0.1553926020860672,
-0.3537181615829468,
0.5434806942939758,
0.44153574109077454,
-0.7254087328910828,
-0.4219779670238495,
-0.5832783579826355,
-0.507941722869873,
0.9983333945274353,
0.1208549216389656,
-0.2802446782588959,
0.11504510790109634,
-0.04621407017111778,
0.5731132626533508,
-0.31236332654953003,
0.3342971205711365,
0.11961225420236588,
0.35520780086517334,
0.2884148061275482,
-0.35869473218917847,
0.5232261419296265,
-0.37756669521331787,
0.09500068426132202,
0.23457454144954681,
-0.35291019082069397,
0.8998146653175354,
-0.3752167224884033,
-0.33038270473480225,
0.0286712683737278,
0.3932162821292877,
0.7107193470001221,
0.7996949553489685,
0.6930060386657715,
0.4859483242034912,
0.6820034980773926,
0.3735257685184479,
0.685146152973175,
-0.3063181936740875,
0.20426350831985474,
1.1994197368621826,
-0.5044834613800049,
0.7194032073020935,
0.9556148052215576,
0.46389877796173096,
0.8803179860115051,
0.15221726894378662,
0.22768473625183105,
0.6690973043441772,
0.5037947297096252,
-0.37455683946609497,
-0.21182042360305786,
-0.2697891891002655,
-0.5064918398857117,
0.288115918636322,
0.5966717600822449,
-0.2354472577571869,
-0.3221605122089386,
0.2605202794075012,
-0.09233713895082474,
0.25884121656417847,
-0.1550740897655487,
0.7616393566131592,
0.22528238594532013,
-0.8050028681755066,
0.625099241733551,
-0.16123563051223755,
0.7020356059074402,
-0.3931066393852234,
-0.3294362425804138,
-0.11774814873933792,
0.37181225419044495,
-0.24084937572479248,
-0.4636591970920563,
0.26012903451919556,
-0.2056208699941635,
-0.030111493542790413,
-0.2205791026353836,
0.7511985898017883,
-0.4768960177898407,
-0.6121716499328613,
0.4691285789012909,
0.4580456018447876,
-0.009652861393988132,
0.21856500208377838,
-0.3406486511230469,
-0.13763472437858582,
-0.2709973156452179,
-0.21819832921028137,
0.05551525577902794,
0.746778666973114,
-0.15782800316810608,
0.4680650532245636,
0.7342007756233215,
0.0022946270182728767,
-0.013142133131623268,
0.4333144426345825,
1.1466223001480103,
-0.9531500935554504,
-0.4375324249267578,
-0.8530722856521606,
0.3475232422351837,
-0.25427138805389404,
-0.4899758994579315,
0.6394922137260437,
0.4039680063724518,
0.7730164527893066,
-0.10676123201847076,
0.5822916626930237,
-0.052785761654376984,
0.18804991245269775,
-0.6563038229942322,
0.43816205859184265,
-0.5535730123519897,
0.19838207960128784,
-0.5675839781761169,
-0.9372435212135315,
-0.2270553559064865,
0.7337515950202942,
-0.3284229636192322,
0.02783835493028164,
1.0634526014328003,
1.1105928421020508,
0.011743439361453056,
0.2213515341281891,
0.17942418158054352,
0.15379072725772858,
0.1523897647857666,
0.6036671996116638,
1.1750270128250122,
-0.40161168575286865,
0.5552647113800049,
-0.4519723653793335,
-0.16293345391750336,
-0.08388084173202515,
-0.7386677265167236,
-0.8570693135261536,
-0.6462029218673706,
-0.19988475739955902,
-0.8456811308860779,
0.04227989912033081,
1.142638087272644,
0.6065717935562134,
-0.7953565716743469,
-0.05366196110844612,
-0.4008462131023407,
0.3106757700443268,
-0.178019717335701,
-0.3538152873516083,
0.378818541765213,
-0.7303089499473572,
-0.3767804503440857,
0.015120855532586575,
0.23065617680549622,
-0.05975610017776489,
-0.3167303502559662,
-0.12179733067750931,
-0.39335766434669495,
0.4427747130393982,
0.889329195022583,
-0.3312549889087677,
-0.5736663937568665,
-0.42141836881637573,
0.04456527158617973,
-0.18972542881965637,
-0.12599216401576996,
1.063596487045288,
-0.9658465385437012,
0.36886104941368103,
0.5954933762550354,
0.20693376660346985,
0.5955003499984741,
0.051645468920469284,
0.5892091989517212,
-0.5903599262237549,
0.3770819306373596,
0.552019476890564,
0.16174574196338654,
0.18617351353168488,
-0.38184988498687744,
0.36695021390914917,
0.30817946791648865,
-0.18761971592903137,
-0.7909073829650879,
0.38831549882888794,
-1.1226967573165894,
-0.6873860955238342,
1.340731143951416,
0.36421993374824524,
-0.41378331184387207,
-0.23906387388706207,
-0.6945982575416565,
0.21521861851215363,
-0.2749289870262146,
1.036245584487915,
0.6947795748710632,
-0.14945167303085327,
0.13372434675693512,
-0.30061763525009155,
0.3686662018299103,
0.5135748386383057,
-0.7652999758720398,
-0.2774805426597595,
0.4844799041748047,
0.09343612194061279,
0.508663535118103,
0.6824092268943787,
-0.05833732336759567,
0.36123982071876526,
0.23385252058506012,
0.20037682354450226,
0.1533915251493454,
-0.5315526723861694,
0.08779118210077286,
0.42356371879577637,
-0.37269318103790283,
-0.06988131254911423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13028v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13028v1
|
DuetSim: Building User Simulator with Dual Large Language Models for Task-Oriented Dialogues
| 2024-05-16T06:24:31 | 2024-05-16T06:24:31 |
Xiang Luo, Zhiwen Tang, Jin Wang, Xuejie Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
User Simulators play a pivotal role in training and evaluating task-oriented
dialogue systems. Traditional user simulators typically rely on
human-engineered agendas, resulting in generated responses that often lack
diversity and spontaneity. Although large language models (LLMs) exhibit a
remarkable capacity for generating coherent and contextually appropriate
utterances, they may fall short when tasked with generating responses that
effectively guide users towards their goals, particularly in dialogues with
intricate constraints and requirements. This paper introduces DuetSim, a novel
framework designed to address the intricate demands of task-oriented dialogues
by leveraging LLMs. DuetSim stands apart from conventional approaches by
employing two LLMs in tandem: one dedicated to response generation and the
other focused on verification. This dual LLM approach empowers DuetSim to
produce responses that not only exhibit diversity but also demonstrate accuracy
and are preferred by human users. We validate the efficacy of our method
through extensive experiments conducted on the MultiWOZ dataset, highlighting
improvements in response quality and correctness, largely attributed to the
incorporation of the second LLM. Our code is accessible at:
https://github.com/suntea233/DuetSim.
|
[
-0.2830382287502289,
-0.7511721253395081,
0.31073448061943054,
0.6059792041778564,
-0.0020361938513815403,
0.3494999408721924,
-0.4303964078426361,
-0.27779337763786316,
-0.02585669979453087,
0.6207156181335449,
-0.5028896927833557,
-0.28302231431007385,
-0.3728564977645874,
-0.012963013723492622,
-0.22341203689575195,
0.7895704507827759,
0.060514844954013824,
0.35578370094299316,
-0.8128126263618469,
-0.29527249932289124,
-0.7075724005699158,
-0.6583331823348999,
-0.4055395722389221,
-0.4493962228298187,
0.5864381790161133,
0.6912174224853516,
0.48407164216041565,
-0.034629691392183304,
0.25024154782295227,
0.35074618458747864,
0.1773541420698166,
0.4414742887020111,
-0.47595834732055664,
0.3899184465408325,
0.1323653757572174,
-0.3837094306945801,
-0.3293737769126892,
-0.15932224690914154,
0.6567975878715515,
0.678703784942627,
-0.2788325250148773,
0.2744115889072418,
0.20514118671417236,
0.32290932536125183,
-0.3356415331363678,
0.16864915192127228,
-0.4526973366737366,
-0.13803191483020782,
-0.028590289875864983,
0.034765880554914474,
-0.40292760729789734,
0.15174375474452972,
0.12930670380592346,
-0.27445557713508606,
-0.17057012021541595,
0.06659456342458725,
0.5201652646064758,
0.10453490912914276,
-0.9394687414169312,
-0.10974307358264923,
-0.9543545842170715,
1.028262734413147,
-0.6037598848342896,
0.31594783067703247,
-0.08324882388114929,
0.3540733754634857,
-0.4797199070453644,
-0.5725602507591248,
-0.6091559529304504,
-0.5279780626296997,
-0.08263090997934341,
0.32432669401168823,
0.10637271404266357,
0.0889422819018364,
0.4577328860759735,
0.14069198071956635,
-0.6355432271957397,
0.2381982058286667,
-0.28453657031059265,
-0.14457030594348907,
0.7293129563331604,
0.6367194056510925,
0.5063456296920776,
-0.1503371149301529,
-0.7782444357872009,
0.06598421186208725,
-0.5202509164810181,
0.1098550409078598,
0.6808765530586243,
0.4688950479030609,
-0.3425960838794708,
0.6142809391021729,
0.07198070734739304,
0.6697909832000732,
-0.17401835322380066,
-0.3687416613101959,
0.16678690910339355,
-0.36192435026168823,
-0.13205751776695251,
-0.20011547207832336,
1.0459461212158203,
0.37541013956069946,
-0.07535000145435333,
-0.06968865543603897,
-0.1927081197500229,
0.1408110111951828,
0.2462058663368225,
-0.9129422307014465,
-0.01689787209033966,
0.5076064467430115,
-0.2515290677547455,
-0.01639436185359955,
-0.17143890261650085,
-0.5762456655502319,
-0.2802605628967285,
-0.5233270525932312,
0.3864838480949402,
-0.24027952551841736,
-0.4255028963088989,
0.11876830458641052,
-0.16356831789016724,
0.025634346529841423,
0.4926620125770569,
-0.642785906791687,
0.6850675940513611,
0.86745685338974,
0.5660600662231445,
-0.24790997803211212,
-0.5532234311103821,
-0.8337883949279785,
0.2684551775455475,
0.03334050998091698,
0.5734117031097412,
-0.35745927691459656,
-0.6566628813743591,
-0.171739861369133,
-0.6139606833457947,
-0.22510306537151337,
-0.571988582611084,
0.48430195450782776,
-0.41007086634635925,
0.16430841386318207,
-0.1947445273399353,
-0.3392474055290222,
-0.011284494772553444,
0.35382652282714844,
-0.48206937313079834,
1.143813967704773,
0.13386940956115723,
-0.8880355358123779,
0.0085834339261055,
-0.7508869171142578,
-0.5609354376792908,
0.16688823699951172,
-0.43424490094184875,
-0.3465327024459839,
0.1429271101951599,
-0.17934343218803406,
0.1346672624349594,
-0.7117311358451843,
0.524975597858429,
-0.39797157049179077,
-0.32277992367744446,
0.4071958661079407,
-0.21128810942173004,
0.7623539566993713,
0.193937286734581,
0.07572942227125168,
0.35459837317466736,
-0.3733994662761688,
0.18685346841812134,
0.14766810834407806,
-0.18451133370399475,
-0.2560228407382965,
0.03322823345661163,
0.269807904958725,
0.4894039034843445,
0.21837550401687622,
-0.6996652483940125,
0.09055342525243759,
-0.24378855526447296,
0.36956852674484253,
0.3969290852546692,
-0.25112658739089966,
0.17320995032787323,
-0.4580186903476715,
0.49950137734413147,
0.3921791613101959,
-0.00035409542033448815,
-0.050512999296188354,
-0.39379358291625977,
-0.7085144519805908,
-0.3768914043903351,
0.08480580151081085,
0.7775460481643677,
-0.5301312804222107,
0.25824686884880066,
-0.19357618689537048,
-0.36804571747779846,
-0.3322359025478363,
0.5130907893180847,
0.39716437458992004,
0.3385336697101593,
0.03805452585220337,
-0.5257948040962219,
-0.9697011113166809,
-1.0345221757888794,
-0.30506911873817444,
-0.5285439491271973,
-0.015653442591428757,
0.7320834994316101,
0.49582064151763916,
-0.30641621351242065,
1.0759445428848267,
-0.3228713572025299,
-0.12234988808631897,
-0.8339710831642151,
0.39716285467147827,
-0.10812212526798248,
0.46276357769966125,
0.42568033933639526,
-1.055689811706543,
-0.5191696286201477,
-0.3334973454475403,
-0.7090694904327393,
-0.12282110005617142,
-0.2664295732975006,
-0.14908190071582794,
0.019052140414714813,
0.04226503521203995,
-0.7458845376968384,
0.004567684140056372,
0.7553794980049133,
0.00037577273906208575,
0.7290636301040649,
-0.10940275341272354,
0.2515161633491516,
-1.4644566774368286,
0.16247504949569702,
0.022721700370311737,
-0.41176319122314453,
-0.5696743130683899,
0.030439311638474464,
-0.13295680284500122,
-0.18014515936374664,
-0.2859117388725281,
0.5494565963745117,
-0.5377396941184998,
-0.28937119245529175,
-0.318570613861084,
0.14803336560726166,
-0.09095548838376999,
0.47928354144096375,
-0.15284469723701477,
0.9430654048919678,
0.4576056897640228,
-0.2504446506500244,
0.6690874695777893,
0.4060955047607422,
-0.36072471737861633,
0.6990441679954529,
-0.9215238094329834,
0.3096723258495331,
0.08542344719171524,
0.584743082523346,
-0.9922002553939819,
-0.6704589128494263,
0.09098587930202484,
-0.2558307945728302,
0.28934386372566223,
-0.2500818073749542,
-0.8168781995773315,
-0.700722336769104,
-0.18064536154270172,
0.5744543671607971,
0.6794258952140808,
-0.38073796033859253,
0.8659422993659973,
0.6184720396995544,
-0.2889077663421631,
-0.5469739437103271,
-0.4622596502304077,
0.3019021451473236,
-0.1914440244436264,
-0.8390470743179321,
0.015425126999616623,
-0.4526158273220062,
-0.3046398460865021,
-0.44931885600090027,
-0.14170634746551514,
-0.11028365790843964,
0.2594470679759979,
0.7915182709693909,
0.3969001770019531,
-0.15185636281967163,
-0.14473575353622437,
0.10969765484333038,
-0.004050907213240862,
0.17792394757270813,
-0.29723072052001953,
0.5824613571166992,
-0.10705852508544922,
-0.5760018825531006,
-0.6197076439857483,
0.7661687135696411,
0.6386874914169312,
-0.28282564878463745,
0.47044211626052856,
0.6989894509315491,
-0.07106168568134308,
-0.18993505835533142,
-0.712750256061554,
-0.12459728866815567,
-0.4594176709651947,
0.543880045413971,
-0.5595393180847168,
-1.183984637260437,
0.4106942415237427,
-0.2957088351249695,
0.14384357631206512,
-0.17629314959049225,
0.785718560218811,
-0.06650203466415405,
1.3037269115447998,
0.44037652015686035,
0.005347173195332289,
0.2666111886501312,
0.19581522047519684,
0.18795059621334076,
-0.9846161007881165,
-0.3545827865600586,
-0.6661548018455505,
-0.2569420337677002,
-0.226746067404747,
-0.6785162687301636,
0.519126832485199,
0.0015758780064061284,
-0.11959939450025558,
0.2824449837207794,
0.13473448157310486,
0.39720630645751953,
0.6997778415679932,
0.0048649911768734455,
0.12113644927740097,
-0.0026362957432866096,
-0.08794131875038147,
-0.0947769433259964,
-0.670933723449707,
-0.5574929714202881,
0.8239824175834656,
0.17524738609790802,
0.731155276298523,
0.12167680263519287,
0.8139449954032898,
0.16103069484233856,
0.2451176941394806,
-0.6997573971748352,
0.8787643313407898,
0.01636098325252533,
-0.5122476816177368,
-0.024700405076146126,
-0.7702614665031433,
-0.596228837966919,
0.4165516793727875,
-0.09381692856550217,
-0.8970413208007812,
-0.4800755977630615,
0.3440929353237152,
-0.33803319931030273,
0.1537693291902542,
-0.7550610303878784,
1.0078097581863403,
-0.37834376096725464,
-0.5008453130722046,
-0.3504507541656494,
-0.9272032976150513,
0.46431344747543335,
0.08396907895803452,
-0.04992815479636192,
-0.3502284586429596,
0.12093430012464523,
0.4867885708808899,
-0.33848559856414795,
1.0145699977874756,
-0.17405372858047485,
-0.08368892967700958,
0.3957293927669525,
0.092695452272892,
0.36404168605804443,
0.31039202213287354,
-0.03604721650481224,
0.06617946922779083,
-0.08078838139772415,
-0.3991517722606659,
-0.59312903881073,
1.0081628561019897,
-0.7642002701759338,
-1.0522643327713013,
-0.17146210372447968,
-1.0116726160049438,
-0.43608471751213074,
0.0652194544672966,
-0.23577670753002167,
0.5598579049110413,
-0.5295132994651794,
-0.1531890630722046,
0.3544957935810089,
-0.24850386381149292,
-0.05483831837773323,
0.46157240867614746,
-0.27242034673690796,
-0.34102463722229004,
0.6569843888282776,
-0.3285636901855469,
0.32940030097961426,
0.1602008044719696,
-0.014507783576846123,
-0.17773643136024475,
-0.4430021047592163,
-0.7672939896583557,
0.14104513823986053,
-0.25632867217063904,
-0.13649164140224457,
-0.9287027716636658,
-0.14745986461639404,
-0.3757210075855255,
0.29271399974823,
-0.3024698793888092,
-0.38277408480644226,
0.09684368968009949,
0.17869441211223602,
-0.026383837684988976,
0.6501820683479309,
-0.10452956706285477,
0.021523725241422653,
-1.072560429573059,
0.41834619641304016,
0.5503385066986084,
0.007094901986420155,
-0.18848395347595215,
-0.21062377095222473,
-0.19224081933498383,
0.3826538026332855,
-0.24588041007518768,
-0.7303388714790344,
0.13932879269123077,
0.060661379247903824,
0.510437548160553,
-0.012822975404560566,
0.16572226583957672,
0.8268474340438843,
-0.3926245868206024,
0.9310377240180969,
0.3566974103450775,
-0.9602040648460388,
0.4496537744998932,
-0.3140805959701538,
0.20183242857456207,
0.41364914178848267,
-0.00831562653183937,
-0.7917584776878357,
-0.6274493932723999,
-0.13219137489795685,
-0.7464598417282104,
1.0963220596313477,
0.2759813964366913,
0.5574584007263184,
0.17118020355701447,
0.014852079562842846,
0.1905263066291809,
0.27192363142967224,
-0.35686737298965454,
-0.2330307513475418,
0.11452975869178772,
-0.35637038946151733,
-0.02459486573934555,
-0.5413631796836853,
-0.45071443915367126,
0.11933578550815582,
0.5522449016571045,
-0.06356126070022583,
0.139798104763031,
-0.15056408941745758,
-0.20096999406814575,
-0.20389960706233978,
0.4870782494544983,
0.4764178991317749,
0.35091909766197205,
-0.039153315126895905,
0.03418934345245361,
0.17488005757331848,
-0.17821428179740906,
0.11525668948888779,
0.23702701926231384,
-0.0018432694487273693,
-0.15422417223453522,
0.05580960959196091,
0.8941240906715393,
0.3353463411331177,
-0.960299551486969,
0.7436610460281372,
-0.3199702501296997,
0.0817561224102974,
-0.36729544401168823,
0.3243517577648163,
0.32360637187957764,
0.4514159560203552,
0.08398622274398804,
0.2806890308856964,
0.30639904737472534,
-0.3557526171207428,
-0.04102659970521927,
0.5862653255462646,
-0.1817132532596588,
-0.5134835839271545,
0.7328555583953857,
0.5893906354904175,
-0.38481608033180237,
0.7194823026657104,
-0.12300891429185867,
-0.627359926700592,
0.7143349647521973,
0.759141743183136,
0.9254000782966614,
-0.08304616808891296,
0.26072171330451965,
0.41046634316444397,
-0.11230191588401794,
-0.10957928001880646,
0.3195188343524933,
-0.39085060358047485,
-0.5744994878768921,
-0.29914167523384094,
-0.5342864394187927,
-0.5282834768295288,
-0.1905083805322647,
-0.8889931440353394,
0.17242467403411865,
-0.013300134800374508,
-0.25758299231529236,
-0.13939201831817627,
-0.07583525031805038,
-0.5417140126228333,
-0.1586327850818634,
0.3972032070159912,
0.8718600869178772,
-0.6963545083999634,
0.8721708655357361,
1.0265082120895386,
-0.17264671623706818,
-0.6687058806419373,
0.0776592269539833,
0.18107303977012634,
-0.5507529377937317,
0.7203019857406616,
0.4388299286365509,
-0.3925999701023102,
-0.20798635482788086,
-0.5569562315940857,
-0.2853732407093048,
0.9760960340499878,
0.4253271520137787,
-0.5976362824440002,
-0.026454610750079155,
0.37974804639816284,
0.5310670733451843,
-0.45647644996643066,
0.31021323800086975,
0.22485531866550446,
0.16698479652404785,
0.33755314350128174,
-1.1545425653457642,
-0.07893510162830353,
-0.32086899876594543,
0.3723507523536682,
0.3129837214946747,
-0.921332061290741,
0.6214131116867065,
-0.6281348466873169,
-0.2539204955101013,
0.5548778772354126,
0.752465546131134,
0.49683886766433716,
0.5055160522460938,
0.7626492381095886,
0.3764771521091461,
0.38050633668899536,
-0.040897417813539505,
0.841802179813385,
-0.40684446692466736,
0.2653384506702423,
1.5326039791107178,
-0.9643338918685913,
0.7699790596961975,
0.6572954058647156,
-0.02636071853339672,
0.5757209658622742,
0.2030719369649887,
0.03034330904483795,
0.08763720840215683,
0.22623957693576813,
-0.5093866586685181,
-0.7831070423126221,
-0.2632896602153778,
-0.13699926435947418,
0.5320654511451721,
0.35554566979408264,
0.05460798740386963,
-0.012091749347746372,
0.03424529731273651,
-0.06421670317649841,
0.15544560551643372,
0.15392985939979553,
0.7642391324043274,
0.22368793189525604,
-0.8768641352653503,
0.12585946917533875,
0.15307344496250153,
0.42989593744277954,
-0.7254175543785095,
0.005810892675071955,
-0.2060997188091278,
0.1435701549053192,
-0.015026045963168144,
-0.5695825219154358,
0.02807997539639473,
0.16803866624832153,
-0.12722337245941162,
-0.26273515820503235,
0.6467612981796265,
-0.8311818242073059,
-0.2473384588956833,
0.43725186586380005,
0.6255438327789307,
-0.05810806527733803,
0.2920328378677368,
-0.8308607935905457,
0.24885690212249756,
0.016036149114370346,
-0.1017674058675766,
0.34885239601135254,
0.22756201028823853,
0.03844582289457321,
0.6911250948905945,
0.5193049311637878,
-0.240622878074646,
-0.2508746087551117,
0.32691049575805664,
0.9263694286346436,
-0.3225453197956085,
-0.4192757308483124,
-0.6411687135696411,
0.6279858946800232,
-0.36085161566734314,
-0.08826091885566711,
0.9903013706207275,
1.0211914777755737,
0.6423391103744507,
-0.10543930530548096,
0.9376360774040222,
-0.08552008867263794,
0.4946713149547577,
-0.17765302956104279,
0.3280712366104126,
-0.6639168858528137,
0.3600720763206482,
-0.11716289818286896,
-0.6125050783157349,
-0.30815595388412476,
0.1640542596578598,
-0.08328443020582199,
0.24389702081680298,
0.3320232629776001,
0.9205090999603271,
-0.30762115120887756,
0.037994738668203354,
0.3291527330875397,
0.3678395748138428,
0.17531222105026245,
0.9701770544052124,
1.3440937995910645,
-0.262688010931015,
0.5728539228439331,
-0.0712205097079277,
-0.1143202930688858,
-0.4091840982437134,
-0.4925716519355774,
-1.2441433668136597,
-0.4548051953315735,
-0.3973436653614044,
-0.4545249938964844,
0.114237479865551,
1.3307852745056152,
0.8996227979660034,
-0.6760098934173584,
-0.802683413028717,
0.18376976251602173,
-0.00022725547023583204,
-0.1356828212738037,
-0.12586422264575958,
-0.20240557193756104,
-0.36674410104751587,
-0.9280840754508972,
0.42335543036460876,
0.5607122778892517,
0.14726345241069794,
-0.3984653353691101,
-0.43205076456069946,
0.20231743156909943,
0.3029076159000397,
0.4374367594718933,
0.20601852238178253,
-0.750671923160553,
-0.06692355871200562,
-0.18658648431301117,
-0.542424738407135,
0.07465089112520218,
1.1679883003234863,
-0.6127530932426453,
0.4692469835281372,
0.41427990794181824,
0.2765999734401703,
0.365212082862854,
0.018686039373278618,
0.8347830176353455,
-0.8070823550224304,
0.3262315094470978,
0.19554775953292847,
0.2894445061683655,
0.3746604919433594,
-0.07638943940401077,
0.11188679188489914,
0.08807756006717682,
-0.46760597825050354,
-1.171320915222168,
0.7393698692321777,
-1.343993902206421,
0.016369318589568138,
1.2233200073242188,
-0.4657667279243469,
-0.11087160557508469,
-0.04658763110637665,
-0.5622066855430603,
0.1316850334405899,
-0.4908643364906311,
0.6321868896484375,
0.4889103174209595,
-0.07252604514360428,
0.06495009362697601,
-0.24485935270786285,
0.08458513021469116,
0.6058058738708496,
-0.992344081401825,
0.1877257376909256,
0.8072351217269897,
0.3569798767566681,
-0.12545856833457947,
0.5076271295547485,
0.1530810445547104,
0.29237210750579834,
0.13073012232780457,
-0.08802024275064468,
-0.26863861083984375,
-0.3545286953449249,
0.08148230612277985,
0.2632717788219452,
0.1972232311964035,
-0.08897650241851807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09818v1
|
Chameleon: Mixed-Modal Early-Fusion Foundation Models
| 2024-05-16T05:23:41 | 2024-05-16T05:23:41 |
Chameleon Team
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present Chameleon, a family of early-fusion token-based mixed-modal models
capable of understanding and generating images and text in any arbitrary
sequence. We outline a stable training approach from inception, an alignment
recipe, and an architectural parameterization tailored for the early-fusion,
token-based, mixed-modal setting. The models are evaluated on a comprehensive
range of tasks, including visual question answering, image captioning, text
generation, image generation, and long-form mixed modal generation. Chameleon
demonstrates broad and general capabilities, including state-of-the-art
performance in image captioning tasks, outperforms Llama-2 in text-only tasks
while being competitive with models such as Mixtral 8x7B and Gemini-Pro, and
performs non-trivial image generation, all in a single model. It also matches
or exceeds the performance of much larger models, including Gemini Pro and
GPT-4V, according to human judgments on a new long-form mixed-modal generation
evaluation, where either the prompt or outputs contain mixed sequences of both
images and text. Chameleon marks a significant step forward in a unified
modeling of full multimodal documents.
|
[
-0.29187607765197754,
-0.43637481331825256,
0.11147034913301468,
0.32377171516418457,
-0.5139231085777283,
-0.05220691114664078,
0.1266888529062271,
-0.7144144177436829,
0.013828452676534653,
0.5691829323768616,
-0.6247052550315857,
-0.12593087553977966,
-0.42765334248542786,
0.14862386882305145,
-0.4362294375896454,
0.8827345371246338,
0.2133859246969223,
-0.03467952832579613,
-0.4200666844844818,
-0.04982168227434158,
-0.6267150640487671,
-0.06503209471702576,
-0.42821013927459717,
-0.6675811409950256,
0.6243911385536194,
0.233255073428154,
0.8474846482276917,
0.8585442304611206,
0.39860355854034424,
0.28313297033309937,
0.13229677081108093,
0.21936461329460144,
-0.30964502692222595,
0.2438623607158661,
-0.09164237231016159,
-0.2939491868019104,
-0.2602871358394623,
0.022769251838326454,
0.2753165066242218,
0.7089990973472595,
0.07071194797754288,
-0.011311039328575134,
-0.3704785108566284,
0.3786014914512634,
-0.7763935327529907,
0.11150339245796204,
-0.6735857725143433,
0.041866179555654526,
-0.15530230104923248,
-0.12876372039318085,
-0.4169924855232239,
0.2070300430059433,
0.15647941827774048,
-0.6989473700523376,
0.13454318046569824,
0.24670282006263733,
0.7777503132820129,
0.20492775738239288,
-0.7893113493919373,
-0.1484830677509308,
-0.49549224972724915,
0.6802459955215454,
-0.4207554757595062,
0.4185177683830261,
0.12690363824367523,
0.5048144459724426,
0.04656073451042175,
-1.21490478515625,
-0.8506662249565125,
-0.2845087945461273,
-0.1802341639995575,
0.33678844571113586,
-0.15264585614204407,
0.3037227988243103,
-0.11531422287225723,
0.4547244906425476,
-0.7550272941589355,
-0.06295385956764221,
-0.4075952470302582,
-0.3852752447128296,
0.626342236995697,
0.17786023020744324,
0.3662318289279938,
-0.4169251024723053,
-0.6513217687606812,
-0.13682295382022858,
-0.5204254388809204,
-0.10817091166973114,
-0.07062939554452896,
0.08177289366722107,
-0.3628840744495392,
0.8512033820152283,
-0.16487890481948853,
1.1019288301467896,
-0.025463223457336426,
-0.0718737542629242,
-0.13178089261054993,
-0.5600758194923401,
-0.5471447110176086,
0.008381632156670094,
0.6941227316856384,
0.37470078468322754,
-0.28333187103271484,
-0.06728506088256836,
-0.5462512969970703,
0.5074126124382019,
0.17088116705417633,
-0.5666806697845459,
-0.3506068289279938,
0.053363583981990814,
-0.717000424861908,
-0.529661238193512,
0.04707058519124985,
-0.8988047242164612,
-0.781152606010437,
-0.38251590728759766,
0.48298925161361694,
-0.36755600571632385,
-0.017078349366784096,
0.20881815254688263,
-0.10238386690616608,
0.454266220331192,
0.4884318709373474,
-0.7679160237312317,
0.32167115807533264,
0.47150519490242004,
0.783365786075592,
-0.1279853731393814,
-0.5087074637413025,
-0.3674384355545044,
0.32608234882354736,
0.08356567472219467,
0.7479754090309143,
-0.7603909373283386,
-0.5332987308502197,
-0.06676627695560455,
-0.20685282349586487,
-0.19614234566688538,
-0.2542612850666046,
0.2880832552909851,
-0.6537500023841858,
0.37635183334350586,
0.15911464393138885,
-0.283920556306839,
-0.24442870914936066,
0.3222461938858032,
-0.9453762769699097,
0.7114940881729126,
0.1993705779314041,
-0.7416395545005798,
0.07870112359523773,
-0.76683109998703,
-0.5746822953224182,
0.1365150362253189,
-0.2754932641983032,
-0.20049206912517548,
0.05246034637093544,
0.17042797803878784,
0.49089258909225464,
-0.8068516254425049,
0.041347991675138474,
0.11086525022983551,
-0.3988836109638214,
0.22734308242797852,
-0.23414340615272522,
0.6195842623710632,
0.2811874747276306,
-0.40334707498550415,
0.2556571662425995,
-0.9939676523208618,
-0.3030167520046234,
0.32855886220932007,
-0.025276847183704376,
-0.15687569975852966,
-0.09734185039997101,
0.26015111804008484,
0.4232911467552185,
0.2256462574005127,
-0.40951138734817505,
0.1985064148902893,
0.02789144776761532,
0.5824877619743347,
0.6616514325141907,
0.25033828616142273,
0.37511715292930603,
-0.4882892072200775,
0.45695361495018005,
0.4412324130535126,
0.24607738852500916,
-0.9848639965057373,
-0.6502640247344971,
-0.9741622805595398,
-0.38654792308807373,
0.19904129207134247,
0.4263605773448944,
-1.0751041173934937,
0.11908554285764694,
-0.30129456520080566,
-0.7196118235588074,
-0.25489541888237,
0.0702943280339241,
0.4805925190448761,
0.6008410453796387,
0.22520379722118378,
-0.6127294301986694,
-0.4760527014732361,
-1.2709298133850098,
0.04936880245804787,
-0.17048990726470947,
0.24169395864009857,
0.4812993109226227,
0.7036259770393372,
-0.4870244562625885,
0.6810939311981201,
-0.3249850869178772,
0.16978119313716888,
-0.2431289255619049,
0.4656805396080017,
-0.05988791584968567,
0.5353884100914001,
0.48647233843803406,
-1.2378321886062622,
-0.06302562355995178,
0.10092441737651825,
-0.5320919752120972,
0.10614632815122604,
-0.43759962916374207,
-0.10256314277648926,
-0.2036835104227066,
0.034210775047540665,
-0.9989839792251587,
0.13659219443798065,
0.5408758521080017,
-0.31584474444389343,
0.2916887700557709,
0.19246678054332733,
0.2841852307319641,
-1.1371303796768188,
0.25846418738365173,
0.33401918411254883,
-0.17157360911369324,
-0.7226740121841431,
0.1335299164056778,
0.21313786506652832,
-0.5680442452430725,
-0.7731418013572693,
0.5274162292480469,
-0.38025936484336853,
-0.1449960619211197,
-0.08148308843374252,
0.08606582880020142,
0.20607472956180573,
0.40677106380462646,
-0.0195701252669096,
0.7154311537742615,
0.5479785203933716,
-0.5562019348144531,
0.5633423328399658,
0.18338152766227722,
-0.2864725887775421,
0.573906660079956,
-0.9149838089942932,
0.24034130573272705,
-0.26709043979644775,
0.349128782749176,
-0.9234912991523743,
-0.7014390826225281,
0.20155881345272064,
-0.2340986430644989,
0.42658334970474243,
0.11795315891504288,
-0.2139521986246109,
-0.5079906582832336,
-0.1730213612318039,
0.8454859852790833,
0.32664451003074646,
-0.3703979551792145,
0.7590487599372864,
0.08462489396333694,
0.008874425664544106,
-0.3829643428325653,
-0.6416793465614319,
0.06894630193710327,
0.22613072395324707,
-0.8293583989143372,
0.6290518045425415,
0.0320693664252758,
-0.11315073072910309,
-0.06612115353345871,
-0.050411418080329895,
-0.2974184453487396,
-0.1520373672246933,
0.33277392387390137,
0.5164571404457092,
-0.1916574090719223,
-0.20835177600383759,
-0.12764188647270203,
-0.13784122467041016,
-0.5081724524497986,
-0.40756890177726746,
0.5509204864501953,
-0.24430401623249054,
-0.35333192348480225,
-0.27109295129776,
0.26078081130981445,
0.9669857025146484,
-0.6382418870925903,
0.44789060950279236,
0.38629451394081116,
-0.6640353202819824,
0.033593133091926575,
-0.3899536728858948,
-0.07823473960161209,
-0.4098866581916809,
0.25948530435562134,
-0.1744024008512497,
-0.7143604159355164,
0.47209933400154114,
-0.038737136870622635,
0.11932683736085892,
0.4634917378425598,
0.6115084886550903,
0.001471961266361177,
0.9338024854660034,
0.6645714044570923,
0.11867915093898773,
0.3816670775413513,
-0.10008594393730164,
-0.07346820831298828,
-0.5455885529518127,
-0.6529595255851746,
-0.3856326639652252,
-0.4836629331111908,
-0.16271387040615082,
-0.5331386923789978,
0.27084779739379883,
-0.11620834469795227,
-0.25131529569625854,
0.38302090764045715,
-0.4887273609638214,
0.5053521990776062,
0.5191506147384644,
0.2379298061132431,
0.18189595639705658,
-0.1792197972536087,
-0.015043615363538265,
0.12255491316318512,
-0.6943446397781372,
-0.4215065538883209,
0.9968960881233215,
0.12626367807388306,
0.8445238471031189,
-0.12942752242088318,
0.47419214248657227,
0.6170821189880371,
0.28400087356567383,
-0.584672749042511,
0.6412689685821533,
0.21261107921600342,
-0.5684033036231995,
0.10398808121681213,
-0.24849450588226318,
-0.865016520023346,
0.4265861511230469,
-0.41178542375564575,
-0.36770543456077576,
0.07387367635965347,
0.15537890791893005,
-0.28988611698150635,
0.0033623974304646254,
-0.3628341853618622,
1.0891979932785034,
-0.4445110857486725,
-0.29721423983573914,
-0.14595989882946014,
-0.9991229176521301,
0.9582067728042603,
-0.022248990833759308,
-0.00404002983123064,
0.20539654791355133,
-0.44067665934562683,
0.4172512888908386,
-0.1231413260102272,
0.9554700255393982,
0.10896062850952148,
0.2795303761959076,
0.4480005204677582,
0.24091078341007233,
0.2877846658229828,
-0.045544255524873734,
-0.011000732891261578,
-0.07777312397956848,
-0.12358793616294861,
-0.5474128723144531,
-0.7106136679649353,
0.6726778745651245,
-1.000532627105713,
-0.21612708270549774,
-0.3376888334751129,
-0.5203533172607422,
0.023895621299743652,
0.3868553638458252,
0.30086714029312134,
0.4815501868724823,
-0.10709252208471298,
0.3615965247154236,
0.56333327293396,
0.0321323424577713,
0.5739835500717163,
0.17098163068294525,
0.00027395455981604755,
-0.9392697811126709,
0.8530897498130798,
-0.4336211383342743,
0.09913357347249985,
0.4400244951248169,
-0.13298086822032928,
-0.15240518748760223,
-0.39066311717033386,
-0.7111549377441406,
0.18361622095108032,
-0.8480284214019775,
-0.312931627035141,
-0.37504372000694275,
-0.16149429976940155,
-0.05084138363599777,
-0.39245548844337463,
-0.35910314321517944,
-0.5892525911331177,
-0.3671938180923462,
0.24463073909282684,
-0.33925575017929077,
0.7534566521644592,
0.45984262228012085,
0.4707953631877899,
-1.0602524280548096,
0.40752437710762024,
0.6180180907249451,
0.20657938718795776,
-0.023993583396077156,
-0.13336682319641113,
-0.21460594236850739,
0.010437062941491604,
-0.5343501567840576,
-1.2277854681015015,
-0.05646343156695366,
0.2718878388404846,
0.6922951936721802,
0.28347334265708923,
-0.32629525661468506,
0.41117796301841736,
-0.20047137141227722,
1.4451909065246582,
0.7359200119972229,
-0.9332083463668823,
0.6173500418663025,
-0.5909916758537292,
0.3456096053123474,
0.4590400457382202,
0.15994620323181152,
-0.6441901326179504,
0.2635359466075897,
-0.500537097454071,
-0.562598466873169,
0.4986873269081116,
0.5241813659667969,
0.022917132824659348,
-0.04176465421915054,
0.37417879700660706,
0.3305068910121918,
0.7070856094360352,
-1.2052351236343384,
-0.16966453194618225,
-0.8002229928970337,
-0.3958035111427307,
0.0419539213180542,
-0.041979722678661346,
-0.31456825137138367,
-0.25290611386299133,
0.6542508602142334,
-0.27691325545310974,
0.28573372960090637,
0.09422057121992111,
-0.5315500497817993,
-0.26573556661605835,
0.0795130580663681,
1.1156816482543945,
0.5056936740875244,
0.29594358801841736,
0.3605230152606964,
-0.3600784242153168,
-0.3196471035480499,
0.3565804362297058,
0.1573662906885147,
-0.3292189836502075,
-0.1604057252407074,
0.5732983350753784,
1.0311813354492188,
0.641228973865509,
-0.7344769835472107,
0.7051275968551636,
0.07890291512012482,
0.007417974527925253,
0.18047338724136353,
0.07740885019302368,
-0.250683456659317,
0.22584429383277893,
0.20466874539852142,
0.4152504801750183,
-0.06211058050394058,
-0.5446973443031311,
0.28738850355148315,
0.24683615565299988,
-0.2439267784357071,
-0.48280224204063416,
0.9428904056549072,
0.5440148711204529,
-0.15663473308086395,
0.5330164432525635,
0.0022430482786148787,
-0.42394202947616577,
0.6120215058326721,
0.9290428161621094,
1.0221247673034668,
0.08872167021036148,
0.2771798074245453,
-0.06705393642187119,
0.39386048913002014,
0.06365479528903961,
0.20037347078323364,
-0.3221513330936432,
-0.5663362145423889,
0.022631216794252396,
-0.6240708827972412,
-0.24097833037376404,
0.04695466533303261,
-0.4088057577610016,
0.3603922724723816,
-0.4212450087070465,
-0.0611455999314785,
0.022567851468920708,
-0.19947773218154907,
-0.7706535458564758,
0.3939323127269745,
0.46668216586112976,
1.2447476387023926,
-0.9222018718719482,
0.45206117630004883,
1.293729305267334,
-0.723382294178009,
-0.333482950925827,
-0.2757079005241394,
0.10457272827625275,
-0.7485712170600891,
0.2888171076774597,
0.25034770369529724,
0.10572623461484909,
0.2388768196105957,
-0.6594990491867065,
-0.5932466387748718,
1.6942975521087646,
0.3122931122779846,
-0.399107962846756,
-0.16467824578285217,
0.09305886924266815,
0.10591147840023041,
-0.7047268152236938,
0.26093411445617676,
0.32902583479881287,
0.4704740047454834,
0.3662429451942444,
-0.623852550983429,
-0.11109470576047897,
-0.5112369060516357,
0.35163819789886475,
0.11437437683343887,
-0.9308022260665894,
0.958130419254303,
-0.042706266045570374,
-0.07436711341142654,
0.25667378306388855,
0.8513122200965881,
0.27829626202583313,
0.4127778112888336,
0.6129084229469299,
0.4924485385417938,
0.6266252994537354,
-0.10528405755758286,
1.286357045173645,
-0.5241286754608154,
-0.019007259979844093,
0.8368830680847168,
-0.34157758951187134,
0.4617888033390045,
0.5336307287216187,
0.24493011832237244,
0.44143790006637573,
0.9499792456626892,
-0.13617998361587524,
0.7662311792373657,
-0.2531944215297699,
-0.42823490500450134,
-0.4965507686138153,
-0.22790351510047913,
-0.3232918679714203,
0.5126973986625671,
-0.01866866648197174,
-0.5418209433555603,
-0.2482868880033493,
0.017528343945741653,
-0.5191627144813538,
-0.0830780416727066,
-0.641811728477478,
0.5141162276268005,
0.13804903626441956,
-0.6922860741615295,
0.29301515221595764,
0.1339968740940094,
0.4082225263118744,
-0.6826218366622925,
0.034167882055044174,
-0.12692829966545105,
-0.23367001116275787,
-0.16133563220500946,
-0.5919163823127747,
-0.2677628695964813,
-0.33976733684539795,
-0.2903117835521698,
0.06046345457434654,
1.28781259059906,
-0.4890287518501282,
-0.32363462448120117,
-0.16319558024406433,
0.5481778979301453,
-0.4359830915927887,
0.23093751072883606,
-0.7444756031036377,
0.3508222699165344,
-0.15451286733150482,
-0.37961307168006897,
0.07567878067493439,
0.026399150490760803,
-0.06366616487503052,
0.5590074062347412,
0.532488226890564,
-0.296847403049469,
0.35943010449409485,
0.08160841464996338,
1.0159834623336792,
-0.6248870491981506,
-0.5870013236999512,
-0.7345024943351746,
0.9444752931594849,
-0.16037659347057343,
-0.3604590594768524,
0.3783460557460785,
0.6125351786613464,
0.5628768801689148,
-0.30829644203186035,
0.8670510053634644,
0.0035386476665735245,
-0.4682164490222931,
-0.44844552874565125,
0.5071153044700623,
-0.7263383269309998,
-0.06956730037927628,
-0.18902452290058136,
-1.224061369895935,
-0.38645365834236145,
0.3526376187801361,
0.21789418160915375,
0.06227761134505272,
0.5624039769172668,
0.5691073536872864,
-0.4078591763973236,
0.6166305541992188,
0.27071428298950195,
-0.1284639686346054,
0.3137694001197815,
0.6283534169197083,
0.9189373254776001,
-0.49955102801322937,
0.3890560269355774,
-0.3628544211387634,
-0.21351349353790283,
-0.18798474967479706,
-0.9504416584968567,
-0.9056147933006287,
-0.6205669641494751,
-0.10711073875427246,
-0.1637297421693802,
-0.1936756819486618,
0.9303836822509766,
0.8079901933670044,
-0.4712570905685425,
-0.0810941606760025,
-0.19689111411571503,
-0.08701253682374954,
-0.03008454106748104,
-0.1368715763092041,
-0.14144887030124664,
0.007973780855536461,
-0.34592464566230774,
0.5859673023223877,
0.7062522172927856,
0.4927842319011688,
-0.39203041791915894,
-0.23701690137386322,
-0.07469199597835541,
0.3829631507396698,
0.7487696409225464,
0.37769320607185364,
-0.7689597010612488,
-0.3417859673500061,
0.1584513634443283,
-0.37982994318008423,
-0.060524601489305496,
1.229998230934143,
-0.5859915614128113,
0.6495165228843689,
0.5152735710144043,
0.8088264465332031,
0.6072379946708679,
-0.05609212443232536,
0.7110734581947327,
-0.7711782455444336,
0.4806317687034607,
0.4209154546260834,
0.583416759967804,
0.39057812094688416,
-0.008696118369698524,
0.37768012285232544,
0.6109805107116699,
-0.3196444809436798,
-0.8057055473327637,
0.40574634075164795,
-1.3069510459899902,
-0.023847809061408043,
0.772462010383606,
0.2694692313671112,
-0.3631935715675354,
0.25161540508270264,
-0.23216776549816132,
0.3972604274749756,
-0.020198127254843712,
0.5645366311073303,
0.5507009625434875,
-0.18337957561016083,
-0.5312633514404297,
-0.18385189771652222,
0.10048621147871017,
0.18021923303604126,
-0.9188241958618164,
-0.2726568579673767,
0.9099839329719543,
-0.17375430464744568,
0.27603188157081604,
0.5721094608306885,
-0.11013804376125336,
0.8560532331466675,
0.2653254270553589,
0.07183881103992462,
-0.5489376187324524,
-0.5944734811782837,
-0.21287576854228973,
0.36219146847724915,
-0.21308104693889618,
-0.08386792242527008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09806v1
|
MediSyn: Text-Guided Diffusion Models for Broad Medical 2D and 3D Image Synthesis
| 2024-05-16T04:28:44 | 2024-05-16T04:28:44 |
Joseph Cho, Cyril Zakka, Rohan Shad, Ross Wightman, Akshay Chaudhari, William Hiesinger
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Diffusion models have recently gained significant traction due to their
ability to generate high-fidelity and diverse images and videos conditioned on
text prompts. In medicine, this application promises to address the critical
challenge of data scarcity, a consequence of barriers in data sharing,
stringent patient privacy regulations, and disparities in patient population
and demographics. By generating realistic and varying medical 2D and 3D images,
these models offer a rich, privacy-respecting resource for algorithmic training
and research. To this end, we introduce MediSyn, a pair of instruction-tuned
text-guided latent diffusion models with the ability to generate high-fidelity
and diverse medical 2D and 3D images across specialties and modalities. Through
established metrics, we show significant improvement in broad medical image and
video synthesis guided by text prompts.
|
[
-0.09536223858594894,
-0.6471553444862366,
0.9666724801063538,
-0.058743737637996674,
-0.1277676522731781,
-0.11446273326873779,
0.22341789305210114,
-0.08041111379861832,
0.19682954251766205,
0.5678504705429077,
-0.628376841545105,
-0.7010382413864136,
-0.607284426689148,
-0.10874705761671066,
-0.2388743907213211,
1.2317888736724854,
-0.2269146591424942,
0.6563400626182556,
-0.24250338971614838,
-0.07327429950237274,
-0.04868030548095703,
-0.009888426400721073,
-0.6121243238449097,
0.16202124953269958,
0.6956661939620972,
0.1478261947631836,
0.8742274045944214,
0.7526276707649231,
0.5809565186500549,
0.24554172158241272,
-0.29307305812835693,
0.3690289258956909,
-0.21660301089286804,
0.5654195547103882,
-0.11403702944517136,
-0.214787557721138,
-0.4168831706047058,
0.20512332022190094,
0.8127094507217407,
1.0551340579986572,
-0.14815828204154968,
0.020939389243721962,
-0.1665368378162384,
1.0286756753921509,
-0.523330807685852,
-0.5858164429664612,
-0.2698085308074951,
0.3214692771434784,
-0.04263117536902428,
-0.10170939564704895,
-0.08390367776155472,
-0.655894935131073,
0.491036593914032,
-0.8452297449111938,
0.6166172027587891,
-0.2678222954273224,
0.452970415353775,
0.4526486396789551,
-0.3814004361629486,
-0.31522098183631897,
-0.560677170753479,
0.40665867924690247,
-0.4650654196739197,
0.3599596619606018,
0.22454190254211426,
0.29942572116851807,
-0.19312740862369537,
-1.1141548156738281,
-0.0933261439204216,
0.022323139011859894,
0.14279109239578247,
0.13713350892066956,
-0.0053260354325175285,
0.18248899281024933,
0.11803564429283142,
0.3006650507450104,
-0.6957393884658813,
-0.1649845987558365,
-0.5439925193786621,
0.0008761661010794342,
0.4864097833633423,
0.4012454152107239,
0.4280034899711609,
0.16726066172122955,
-0.2328249216079712,
0.09045962244272232,
-0.5427113175392151,
-0.4610333740711212,
0.2765499949455261,
-0.2719942033290863,
-0.39009469747543335,
0.5357297658920288,
0.12797266244888306,
1.0042006969451904,
-0.09293000400066376,
-0.18906474113464355,
0.3046453893184662,
-0.13754913210868835,
-0.3099333345890045,
-0.36178097128868103,
0.6777734756469727,
0.6166856288909912,
-0.02166023664176464,
0.1706242859363556,
-0.13956677913665771,
0.06757894903421402,
-0.003350266721099615,
-1.1587953567504883,
-0.6617676615715027,
0.39918285608291626,
-0.9374266862869263,
-0.7455708384513855,
-0.39839714765548706,
-1.0999675989151,
-0.6978767514228821,
-0.13789993524551392,
0.18351531028747559,
-0.24600261449813843,
-0.3494129180908203,
0.28822699189186096,
-0.2662384510040283,
-0.6299545764923096,
0.3729041814804077,
-1.0097402334213257,
0.40433406829833984,
0.07873237133026123,
1.1535001993179321,
-0.35806402564048767,
-0.07535850256681442,
-0.5682409405708313,
0.13097220659255981,
-0.798938512802124,
0.6121326088905334,
-0.5802698135375977,
-0.44684916734695435,
0.0264772716909647,
-0.050207097083330154,
-0.06404729187488556,
-0.5888374447822571,
0.14203676581382751,
-0.17501579225063324,
0.6543126106262207,
0.016329459846019745,
-0.6396216154098511,
-0.012456302531063557,
-0.030662119388580322,
-0.6890954971313477,
0.479268342256546,
0.38831159472465515,
-0.7769710421562195,
0.11252622306346893,
-0.9163985252380371,
-0.3453435003757477,
-0.04774336516857147,
-0.5112990736961365,
-0.5297173261642456,
0.26179346442222595,
-0.01105373166501522,
0.566230833530426,
-0.28840410709381104,
0.29462388157844543,
-0.21032443642616272,
0.020576519891619682,
0.3147985637187958,
-0.7326871156692505,
0.29699385166168213,
0.4171886742115021,
0.043725427240133286,
0.3265856206417084,
-0.9291934370994568,
-0.16017943620681763,
0.0060972957871854305,
-0.17415842413902283,
-0.4060223400592804,
0.09004862606525421,
0.5035470128059387,
0.10880514234304428,
-0.07544271647930145,
-0.536716639995575,
0.16441024839878082,
-0.5859255790710449,
0.5089250802993774,
0.5739923119544983,
0.26372531056404114,
0.6599637866020203,
-0.3491511940956116,
0.7289522290229797,
0.18255139887332916,
0.43061986565589905,
-0.2704927623271942,
-0.8379508852958679,
-0.15933890640735626,
-0.6332484483718872,
0.32105642557144165,
0.37668439745903015,
-0.5985263586044312,
-0.20014309883117676,
0.15890973806381226,
-0.36186957359313965,
-0.6906105279922485,
-0.24355216324329376,
0.06990119814872742,
0.719156801700592,
0.19712010025978088,
-0.11314308643341064,
-0.3472427427768707,
-0.9420570135116577,
0.019264455884695053,
0.3008739948272705,
-0.19759051501750946,
0.504719614982605,
0.28725409507751465,
-0.42930781841278076,
0.4709550142288208,
-0.8050146102905273,
-0.2852611541748047,
0.10207975655794144,
-0.002819451503455639,
0.2450348287820816,
0.6695488095283508,
0.6759792566299438,
-1.1214783191680908,
-0.544540286064148,
-0.03759472072124481,
-0.5347639322280884,
-0.07365258783102036,
-0.31507959961891174,
-0.20844444632530212,
0.1254826784133911,
0.5538981556892395,
-0.5990821719169617,
0.6364148259162903,
0.8780628442764282,
-0.6506442427635193,
0.24418316781520844,
-0.6068823337554932,
0.37697452306747437,
-1.494884729385376,
0.1718672811985016,
0.019811449572443962,
-0.5012079477310181,
-0.6676017642021179,
-0.08877748250961304,
-0.007776340935379267,
-0.4519527852535248,
-0.5282188653945923,
0.58045893907547,
-0.3415433466434479,
0.08209211379289627,
-0.03558432683348656,
-0.14208076894283295,
0.1356508433818817,
0.030858229845762253,
0.13097518682479858,
0.796815037727356,
0.946892499923706,
-0.7095897197723389,
0.06337055563926697,
0.21409127116203308,
-0.3033928871154785,
0.7266029119491577,
-0.72825688123703,
-0.24521079659461975,
-0.3456874191761017,
0.208623006939888,
-1.0786677598953247,
-0.6087555289268494,
0.2856861352920532,
-0.19408251345157623,
0.16141828894615173,
-0.3627637028694153,
-0.2270982414484024,
-0.2367342710494995,
-0.11789807677268982,
0.8735218048095703,
0.7983965277671814,
-0.47003498673439026,
0.5642460584640503,
0.31239479780197144,
-0.15999022126197815,
-0.2320490926504135,
-0.7976334095001221,
-0.2483855038881302,
-0.06890928745269775,
-0.5508530139923096,
0.6869742274284363,
-0.5477638244628906,
-0.1432460993528366,
0.1329660415649414,
0.1363873928785324,
-0.3794018626213074,
-0.13122615218162537,
0.6006523966789246,
0.47677332162857056,
0.04138709977269173,
0.08159640431404114,
0.48025578260421753,
-0.25402194261550903,
-0.13816635310649872,
-0.5057377219200134,
0.06676451861858368,
0.4077696204185486,
-0.46423405408859253,
-0.5999764800071716,
0.7294825315475464,
0.8671358227729797,
0.01832508109509945,
0.6041502952575684,
0.5421322584152222,
-0.5611292719841003,
0.02817259170114994,
-0.2856447696685791,
-0.07599145174026489,
-0.4731157720088959,
0.5071986317634583,
-0.0976598784327507,
-0.699851393699646,
0.4011125862598419,
-0.41506969928741455,
0.17234447598457336,
0.23867303133010864,
0.6552647352218628,
-0.251653254032135,
1.5588560104370117,
0.4503002166748047,
0.5454789996147156,
0.3738369941711426,
-0.3673180043697357,
-0.33669447898864746,
-0.6557050347328186,
-0.36228054761886597,
-0.13252367079257965,
-0.424306184053421,
-0.387595534324646,
-0.6486310958862305,
0.8569623827934265,
-0.43318697810173035,
-0.10124809294939041,
-0.5983776450157166,
-0.9552080035209656,
0.7099372744560242,
0.22821944952011108,
0.4026971757411957,
-0.023011285811662674,
0.3127831518650055,
-0.28077563643455505,
-0.44955453276634216,
-0.6886196732521057,
-0.21672454476356506,
1.134519100189209,
0.4174526333808899,
0.9010093808174133,
0.1117299497127533,
0.576960027217865,
0.5044417381286621,
0.19575750827789307,
-0.5588475465774536,
0.2883392572402954,
-0.6725286245346069,
-0.3540635108947754,
0.19093306362628937,
-0.436252623796463,
-0.891893744468689,
0.13136087357997894,
-0.4226640462875366,
-0.1226421520113945,
0.12706807255744934,
0.40891340374946594,
-0.69395911693573,
0.6456602215766907,
-0.6613587141036987,
0.7501425743103027,
0.1669488549232483,
-0.47818225622177124,
-0.2507595419883728,
-0.6219567656517029,
0.3154674768447876,
-0.05308947712182999,
0.34937629103660583,
0.032886337488889694,
-0.4182451069355011,
0.7565171122550964,
-0.5266121029853821,
0.661251962184906,
-0.3898429572582245,
0.0463453084230423,
-0.08231154084205627,
0.370150089263916,
0.14532648026943207,
0.08614584058523178,
0.3322398364543915,
-0.056688182055950165,
0.22031642496585846,
-0.30123791098594666,
-0.3991616666316986,
0.905875563621521,
-0.5347592830657959,
-0.1819971203804016,
-0.20438292622566223,
-0.8445317149162292,
0.08681885153055191,
0.18074855208396912,
0.5719959735870361,
0.7652515172958374,
-0.22231872379779816,
-0.1289014220237732,
1.1114070415496826,
-0.42275935411453247,
0.2708912193775177,
0.3002059757709503,
-0.29027360677719116,
-0.7736139297485352,
0.6125752329826355,
-0.1423385888338089,
0.4223344326019287,
0.1417854130268097,
0.1406845897436142,
-0.11117088794708252,
-0.6388222575187683,
-0.7242465019226074,
0.2196158766746521,
-0.5755221247673035,
-0.27863240242004395,
-0.5356879234313965,
-0.2209729254245758,
-0.1698174923658371,
-0.390315979719162,
-0.6251348257064819,
-0.5726005434989929,
-0.634742259979248,
0.3642161190509796,
0.4386717677116394,
1.0488033294677734,
-0.16236063838005066,
0.20354482531547546,
-0.7321515679359436,
0.6959462761878967,
0.24301190674304962,
0.6800795197486877,
-0.414774626493454,
-0.4310086667537689,
-0.15737025439739227,
-0.09839799255132675,
-0.12086010724306107,
-1.1033331155776978,
0.24738483130931854,
-0.048364754766225815,
0.1707821935415268,
0.3624263405799866,
-0.44377315044403076,
0.48137375712394714,
-1.0227595567703247,
0.9045270085334778,
0.5773049592971802,
-0.5228852033615112,
0.7650489211082458,
-0.25368064641952515,
0.03201797232031822,
0.24705572426319122,
0.312157541513443,
-0.3313644528388977,
-0.032715871930122375,
-0.6603609323501587,
-0.5869676470756531,
0.37207645177841187,
0.209263876080513,
0.07535933703184128,
0.09976954758167267,
0.5872699618339539,
0.24274344742298126,
-0.028515443205833435,
-0.20987670123577118,
-0.3190201222896576,
0.0049018701538443565,
-0.7263501882553101,
0.3697390854358673,
-0.4650631546974182,
-0.4679219126701355,
-0.15867741405963898,
0.46237310767173767,
0.034878961741924286,
0.14344725012779236,
0.5843908786773682,
0.29464632272720337,
-0.18834064900875092,
-0.12835648655891418,
0.7575806379318237,
0.34653496742248535,
0.007979359477758408,
0.029532987624406815,
-0.2747218906879425,
-0.8954710960388184,
0.3184320032596588,
0.28686320781707764,
-0.3269318640232086,
0.3640175461769104,
-0.1413474828004837,
0.6627954244613647,
-0.08738300204277039,
-0.5517758131027222,
0.7466854453086853,
-0.34155118465423584,
-0.7270237803459167,
-0.21155481040477753,
0.040349867194890976,
-0.13821135461330414,
0.43659502267837524,
0.06688055396080017,
0.8441552519798279,
0.5303301215171814,
0.22775225341320038,
0.26381054520606995,
0.2281927764415741,
-0.3137006163597107,
-0.14703652262687683,
1.1624670028686523,
0.3101717531681061,
-0.24920162558555603,
0.4495928883552551,
0.10588632524013519,
0.10593084990978241,
0.42158007621765137,
0.41190820932388306,
0.7731003761291504,
-0.38597503304481506,
0.44779396057128906,
0.32522207498550415,
-0.14479278028011322,
-0.21120165288448334,
0.5523932576179504,
0.054590124636888504,
-0.31656312942504883,
-0.18847540020942688,
-0.17458871006965637,
-0.18946513533592224,
0.1250712275505066,
-0.47761020064353943,
0.13596826791763306,
-0.6396409869194031,
-0.47458258271217346,
0.28396421670913696,
-0.3866185247898102,
-0.4360692501068115,
0.3386678993701935,
0.18390780687332153,
0.9335815906524658,
-0.8597227931022644,
0.5340448021888733,
0.7978234887123108,
-0.13122698664665222,
-0.26989057660102844,
-0.10396722704172134,
-0.04000801965594292,
-0.3380388021469116,
0.22497709095478058,
-0.10673169791698456,
0.026948243379592896,
0.05842379853129387,
-0.6491304636001587,
-0.5596044659614563,
0.8725082874298096,
0.24676276743412018,
-0.6280247569084167,
0.09415234625339508,
-0.10829071700572968,
0.518589973449707,
-0.6580730080604553,
0.02012716792523861,
0.28742456436157227,
-0.009113791398704052,
0.2589995563030243,
-0.41640281677246094,
-0.09706003963947296,
-0.4032716155052185,
0.3153155446052551,
-0.005455605685710907,
-0.13133986294269562,
0.9194228649139404,
-0.6275812983512878,
0.0648670420050621,
0.5522733926773071,
0.3514777421951294,
0.4214268624782562,
0.5003262758255005,
0.5235230326652527,
0.3696625828742981,
0.8405399918556213,
0.07882092893123627,
0.9780195355415344,
-0.3953825831413269,
-0.11848969757556915,
0.7387254238128662,
-0.10468931496143341,
0.47277024388313293,
0.5467888712882996,
-0.0003797972167376429,
0.6342929601669312,
0.7503329515457153,
0.008152014575898647,
0.8247772455215454,
-0.034078262746334076,
-0.5462254881858826,
-0.11916296929121017,
-0.11798986047506332,
-0.5822790861129761,
-0.132228285074234,
0.7471760511398315,
-0.9687789082527161,
0.002467947546392679,
0.25722506642341614,
-0.08219310641288757,
0.22106657922267914,
-0.16891832649707794,
0.6514886021614075,
-0.17381444573402405,
-0.46715524792671204,
0.5661603808403015,
-0.047497112303972244,
0.5228885412216187,
-0.620254635810852,
-0.4187390208244324,
-0.3254816234111786,
0.07380715012550354,
-0.33339449763298035,
-0.9680604934692383,
0.20531782507896423,
0.007110035512596369,
-0.47374841570854187,
-0.21522405743598938,
0.501978874206543,
-0.6617454290390015,
-0.5197662711143494,
-0.26781266927719116,
0.21468254923820496,
0.41070637106895447,
0.3005768954753876,
-0.8804991841316223,
0.06888450682163239,
0.2345910221338272,
-0.15549255907535553,
0.07567320019006729,
0.39898934960365295,
0.21801313757896423,
0.5540792942047119,
0.6341089010238647,
0.4250783324241638,
-0.3289363980293274,
0.3043655753135681,
0.8544986248016357,
-0.26506346464157104,
-0.47686079144477844,
-0.6752460598945618,
0.6611220240592957,
-0.11329527199268341,
-0.4033506512641907,
0.18423224985599518,
0.7094594240188599,
0.14861924946308136,
-0.33370599150657654,
0.8269484043121338,
0.15637575089931488,
0.5807790160179138,
-0.7170119881629944,
0.8781439065933228,
-0.8421948552131653,
0.19094178080558777,
-0.05911025404930115,
-0.5514101386070251,
-0.5842781662940979,
0.6495464444160461,
0.18327659368515015,
-0.05474051460623741,
0.4619768559932709,
0.9658924341201782,
-0.42465460300445557,
-0.06639999151229858,
0.3381918966770172,
0.05035252496600151,
0.33701878786087036,
0.6776072978973389,
0.6543682217597961,
-0.45319730043411255,
0.27415212988853455,
-0.027070051059126854,
-0.5375771522521973,
0.11297445744276047,
-0.5441164970397949,
-0.9930007457733154,
-0.7713637351989746,
-0.5659924745559692,
-0.5972909331321716,
-0.06385637074708939,
0.7878344655036926,
1.1754239797592163,
-0.40147367119789124,
0.24232472479343414,
-0.33037835359573364,
0.0353529118001461,
0.058405552059412,
-0.11695174127817154,
0.5810189843177795,
-0.04896339401602745,
-0.7452836036682129,
0.25394612550735474,
0.37926870584487915,
0.7455479502677917,
-0.4921386241912842,
-0.2292969673871994,
0.13815857470035553,
-0.021800080314278603,
0.2391493171453476,
0.08282967656850815,
-0.4477809965610504,
0.5021211504936218,
-0.06374344229698181,
-0.259755402803421,
-0.1382245123386383,
0.8976898193359375,
-0.7313848733901978,
0.7157726883888245,
0.6628535389900208,
0.49082401394844055,
0.3139328360557556,
-0.3298499882221222,
0.5828158855438232,
-0.5995291471481323,
0.46030205488204956,
0.21515220403671265,
0.21911481022834778,
0.5575010180473328,
-0.42599382996559143,
0.4291332960128784,
0.3810303509235382,
-0.6285912990570068,
-0.8515089154243469,
0.3795345425605774,
-0.5432271361351013,
-0.5626158714294434,
1.0926059484481812,
-0.015640607103705406,
-0.09578726440668106,
0.10014021396636963,
-0.43414220213890076,
0.10491590946912766,
-0.0859915241599083,
0.6062385439872742,
0.07384596019983292,
-0.07109922170639038,
-0.06837904453277588,
-0.6385999321937561,
1.0359998941421509,
0.4172181189060211,
-0.7817922234535217,
-0.09570044279098511,
0.8739327192306519,
0.4997496008872986,
-0.15626604855060577,
0.7809377312660217,
-0.3170246183872223,
0.5802043080329895,
0.00891590490937233,
-0.22404193878173828,
0.055829621851444244,
-0.5467886924743652,
-0.3319965600967407,
-0.009903828613460064,
-0.2415148764848709,
-0.6121855974197388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09805v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09805v2
|
SecureLLM: Using Compositionality to Build Provably Secure Language Models for Private, Sensitive, and Secret Data
| 2024-05-16T04:25:53 | 2024-06-13T16:54:51 |
Abdulrahman Alabdulkareem, Christian M Arnold, Yerim Lee, Pieter M Feenstra, Boris Katz, Andrei Barbu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Traditional security mechanisms isolate resources from users who should not
access them. We reflect the compositional nature of such security mechanisms
back into the structure of LLMs to build a provably secure LLM; that we term
SecureLLM. Other approaches to LLM safety attempt to protect against bad actors
or bad outcomes, but can only do so to an extent making them inappropriate for
sensitive data. SecureLLM blends access security with fine-tuning methods. Each
data silo has associated with it a separate fine-tuning and a user has access
only to the collection of fine-tunings that they have permission for. The model
must then perform on compositional tasks at the intersection of those data
silos with the combination of those individual fine-tunings. While applicable
to any task like document QA or making API calls, in this work we concern
ourselves with models that learn the layouts of new SQL databases to provide
natural-language-to-SQL translation capabilities. Existing fine-tuning
composition methods fail in this challenging environment, as they are not
well-equipped for handling compositional tasks. Compositionality remains a
challenge for LLMs. We contribute both a difficult new compositional
natural-language-to-SQL translation task and a new perspective on LLM security
that allows models to be deployed to secure environments today.
|
[
-0.08895065635442734,
-0.9702646732330322,
0.49473321437835693,
0.1225133165717125,
-0.24731560051441193,
0.44078463315963745,
-0.06394006311893463,
-0.4557768404483795,
-0.3667384386062622,
0.951470673084259,
-0.5259717702865601,
-0.8247567415237427,
-0.34222161769866943,
0.05371672660112381,
-0.3543980121612549,
1.082728624343872,
-0.143013596534729,
0.11499786376953125,
-0.34049519896507263,
-0.08249662816524506,
-0.5366784334182739,
-0.7348831295967102,
-0.2295328974723816,
-0.13980992138385773,
0.27359727025032043,
0.1004871055483818,
0.8853576183319092,
0.7316136956214905,
0.678020715713501,
0.2878710925579071,
-0.14275671541690826,
0.4149630665779114,
-0.49979230761528015,
0.3676076829433441,
-0.43236273527145386,
-0.7971977591514587,
-0.5299150347709656,
-0.07469561696052551,
0.5340226292610168,
0.644515335559845,
-0.3038751482963562,
-0.036872994154691696,
0.002452534157782793,
0.8001642823219299,
-0.7128855586051941,
0.11378397792577744,
-1.0186073780059814,
0.029437769204378128,
-0.2719147801399231,
-0.04417720064520836,
-0.41250941157341003,
-0.43700772523880005,
-0.16212154924869537,
-0.41456282138824463,
-0.1355147361755371,
0.43481674790382385,
0.49619317054748535,
0.12952274084091187,
-0.4542064368724823,
-0.23465383052825928,
-0.7095751762390137,
1.0928229093551636,
-0.5373307466506958,
0.49470797181129456,
0.5065205097198486,
0.1725032925605774,
-0.307572603225708,
-0.4659002721309662,
-0.20710906386375427,
-0.1581607460975647,
-0.12087474018335342,
-0.24928376078605652,
0.04367675259709358,
0.10457266867160797,
-0.03307545185089111,
0.5533735752105713,
-0.5415672659873962,
0.15103977918624878,
-0.26369988918304443,
-0.20195890963077545,
0.7785852551460266,
0.44223159551620483,
0.5006881952285767,
0.15763337910175323,
-0.5853737592697144,
0.28852179646492004,
-1.0097334384918213,
-0.19288860261440277,
0.4900844097137451,
0.5764384865760803,
-0.1785738468170166,
0.5137540102005005,
-0.039061207324266434,
0.6634427309036255,
-0.2792761027812958,
-0.19761236011981964,
-0.26000964641571045,
-0.5172649621963501,
-0.4399539530277252,
-0.05920373275876045,
0.6336672902107239,
0.12891586124897003,
0.1468411535024643,
-0.5340306758880615,
-0.2933705747127533,
0.010044803842902184,
0.34707871079444885,
-0.6331533193588257,
-0.26382336020469666,
0.39335954189300537,
-0.4177844524383545,
-0.5318682193756104,
0.04830604046583176,
-0.38628852367401123,
-0.5564703345298767,
-0.5389426946640015,
0.4490608274936676,
-0.4004524350166321,
-0.28789472579956055,
0.18117155134677887,
0.4924948215484619,
0.21149973571300507,
0.18689891695976257,
-0.9916179180145264,
0.7028335332870483,
1.0472298860549927,
0.7606931924819946,
-0.5493513345718384,
-0.08520196378231049,
-0.28832772374153137,
0.5015444755554199,
-0.22638039290905,
0.4077516198158264,
-0.3771215081214905,
-0.6084610819816589,
0.10721209645271301,
0.17372986674308777,
-0.3334372341632843,
-0.6496396660804749,
0.4701329469680786,
-0.6280553340911865,
0.11635686457157135,
-0.17571775615215302,
-0.7844513058662415,
0.10022275149822235,
0.2930959463119507,
-0.5740569829940796,
0.589297354221344,
0.10622845590114594,
-0.5900582075119019,
0.1649874448776245,
-0.5271098613739014,
-0.5565814971923828,
0.019604457542300224,
-0.15603643655776978,
-0.4875450134277344,
0.20998872816562653,
-0.10432031005620956,
0.3061167895793915,
-0.07520201802253723,
0.1652783304452896,
-0.23510849475860596,
-0.14940278232097626,
0.7091087698936462,
-0.03630218654870987,
0.7000975012779236,
0.4867546856403351,
0.047811951488256454,
0.04772304743528366,
-0.5540865063667297,
0.0727764293551445,
0.13129110634326935,
-0.45308467745780945,
-0.33031830191612244,
0.1577959954738617,
0.10679583251476288,
-0.2022029161453247,
0.6629248857498169,
-0.30981990694999695,
-0.15748953819274902,
-0.7169525027275085,
0.42681586742401123,
0.8169125318527222,
-0.02825838513672352,
1.010378122329712,
-0.38263896107673645,
0.4235978424549103,
0.07309012115001678,
0.5797946453094482,
-0.05694207921624184,
-0.06819620728492737,
-0.3395546078681946,
-0.3648056387901306,
0.11744153499603271,
0.7524381279945374,
-0.0671985000371933,
0.4182995855808258,
0.15126392245292664,
-0.3245866596698761,
-0.25087371468544006,
0.6249211430549622,
0.37236520648002625,
0.29779842495918274,
0.1987590193748474,
-0.32508134841918945,
-0.46219402551651,
-0.8516189455986023,
-0.2839048206806183,
-0.11344747245311737,
0.00877606961876154,
0.21001259982585907,
0.2456454038619995,
-0.12891998887062073,
0.6452770233154297,
-0.5601567029953003,
-0.5497393012046814,
-0.15147648751735687,
-0.384138822555542,
0.17558157444000244,
0.7688347697257996,
0.24668695032596588,
-0.7487420439720154,
-0.26717159152030945,
0.12337972223758698,
-0.8798772692680359,
0.07268375903367996,
0.12741731107234955,
-0.4659369885921478,
0.14836180210113525,
0.578781247138977,
-0.660038411617279,
-0.12584176659584045,
0.3055117130279541,
-0.28010913729667664,
0.4512903392314911,
-0.07855004072189331,
-0.31861838698387146,
-1.2719810009002686,
-0.07863453775644302,
-0.4788004159927368,
-0.26349642872810364,
-0.7298369407653809,
0.7407154440879822,
0.022206397727131844,
-0.3274303376674652,
-0.6110706329345703,
0.400748610496521,
-0.6319983601570129,
0.23705829679965973,
-0.18278628587722778,
-0.18884874880313873,
0.05478892847895622,
0.1511860191822052,
-0.1961427628993988,
0.6090707182884216,
0.7064377069473267,
-0.5354546308517456,
0.08035875111818314,
0.33664295077323914,
-0.10138440132141113,
0.9492180943489075,
-0.5257609486579895,
0.2778589427471161,
0.09209351241588593,
-0.21491579711437225,
-0.6039971709251404,
-0.41403138637542725,
0.10414880514144897,
-0.011816579848527908,
0.46868863701820374,
-0.2181692272424698,
-0.5809572339057922,
0.15484455227851868,
-0.3375421166419983,
0.23581863939762115,
0.2534518837928772,
-0.10528257489204407,
0.7207061648368835,
0.6767473816871643,
-0.07898380607366562,
-0.2597693204879761,
-0.9108258485794067,
0.1372532844543457,
-0.33855175971984863,
-0.8143831491470337,
0.4244726598262787,
-0.21630188822746277,
-0.5358262062072754,
-0.24997876584529877,
-0.4032041132450104,
-0.3760957717895508,
0.5980554223060608,
0.36243078112602234,
0.3576101064682007,
-0.1785680204629898,
-0.15990786254405975,
0.07808716595172882,
0.03799126669764519,
0.2813713848590851,
-0.22894887626171112,
0.2573132812976837,
-0.17079372704029083,
-0.5010015368461609,
-0.15720593929290771,
0.7414202094078064,
0.5022313594818115,
-0.4102545976638794,
1.092963457107544,
0.36597004532814026,
-0.63426274061203,
-0.45808666944503784,
-0.481111615896225,
-0.44470781087875366,
-0.5162194967269897,
0.16126541793346405,
-0.24626708030700684,
-1.1039944887161255,
0.6597367525100708,
0.045108210295438766,
0.27865850925445557,
-0.2329888641834259,
0.4606889486312866,
-0.25882601737976074,
0.7777981162071228,
0.6002695560455322,
0.05043580010533333,
0.47435423731803894,
0.03909476846456528,
0.389813095331192,
-0.5782389640808105,
-0.4037153422832489,
-0.4543963074684143,
-0.18603253364562988,
-0.48419755697250366,
-0.09148650616407394,
0.18063561618328094,
0.203917995095253,
-0.13434599339962006,
0.4238188564777374,
-0.42058268189430237,
0.7476482391357422,
0.25304511189460754,
0.3270053267478943,
0.5222213864326477,
0.03164110332727432,
-0.07613015174865723,
-0.17619164288043976,
-0.18020522594451904,
-0.702861487865448,
0.9790957570075989,
0.3175888955593109,
1.2740936279296875,
0.6405553221702576,
0.9036179184913635,
0.2158028781414032,
0.0042468952015042305,
-0.4797300398349762,
0.6893208026885986,
-0.2519214153289795,
-0.7205380201339722,
-0.09349919855594635,
-0.30649179220199585,
-0.8795549273490906,
0.051881927996873856,
-0.13454508781433105,
-0.844214141368866,
0.07314111292362213,
-0.012775490060448647,
-0.23127426207065582,
0.2529255449771881,
-0.8243072628974915,
0.7798793315887451,
-0.25041303038597107,
-0.7080765962600708,
0.018842419609427452,
-0.7315768003463745,
0.560992956161499,
-0.22532659769058228,
0.24780409038066864,
-0.4314689636230469,
-0.13967595994472504,
0.23538097739219666,
-0.50815749168396,
1.0963351726531982,
-0.06025644764304161,
-0.30889445543289185,
0.09929227083921432,
0.6779499650001526,
0.5841213464736938,
0.27503564953804016,
-0.10539925843477249,
0.027681468054652214,
0.2119380086660385,
-0.2826997935771942,
-0.34677618741989136,
0.8859410285949707,
-0.5505526065826416,
-0.7426438331604004,
-0.16354842483997345,
-0.6566289663314819,
-0.219395712018013,
0.10192428529262543,
-0.08802768588066101,
0.004422005731612444,
-0.16976425051689148,
0.39427897334098816,
1.0050760507583618,
0.08853301405906677,
0.2888320982456207,
0.660611093044281,
-0.03304752707481384,
-0.1698462814092636,
0.808246374130249,
0.06194733455777168,
0.36139976978302,
0.5079597234725952,
-0.051018714904785156,
-0.6534692645072937,
-0.8455283045768738,
-0.17167694866657257,
0.08523539453744888,
-0.5743680596351624,
-0.4976181983947754,
-0.46496471762657166,
-0.4208070635795593,
-0.1922379732131958,
-0.21183593571186066,
-0.22324344515800476,
-0.2902592420578003,
-0.5361993908882141,
-0.3555787205696106,
0.27401629090309143,
0.4460843503475189,
0.2026720643043518,
0.1143198311328888,
-0.725283145904541,
0.028067294508218765,
0.3117678165435791,
0.274291455745697,
-0.3526507318019867,
-0.28663119673728943,
-0.2597458064556122,
-0.33043375611305237,
-0.4189642369747162,
-0.9483222961425781,
0.17577704787254333,
0.40465885400772095,
0.7030930519104004,
0.0012274541659280658,
0.1479026973247528,
0.2033730149269104,
-0.3406583070755005,
0.5847108960151672,
-0.1319032460451126,
-0.9034654498100281,
0.7667726874351501,
-0.48072394728660583,
0.00722725223749876,
0.8194276690483093,
0.07238762825727463,
-0.17568641901016235,
-0.6431161165237427,
-0.1987554281949997,
-0.9303309917449951,
0.3370107114315033,
0.35793501138687134,
0.3980945646762848,
0.11047044396400452,
0.33086028695106506,
0.20262591540813446,
0.41550180315971375,
-0.9591890573501587,
-0.038937199860811234,
0.06248725950717926,
-0.29430967569351196,
0.41404464840888977,
-0.2622492015361786,
-0.4741806983947754,
0.08560476452112198,
0.3017102777957916,
-0.2585802674293518,
-0.017377741634845734,
-0.11329422891139984,
-0.28733745217323303,
0.08663872629404068,
0.5784933567047119,
0.3999796211719513,
0.6809743642807007,
-0.058032307773828506,
0.49128103256225586,
0.24786408245563507,
-0.33995720744132996,
0.14710456132888794,
0.09153708070516586,
-0.4472882151603699,
-0.36149194836616516,
0.10625776648521423,
0.5765406489372253,
0.4137132167816162,
-0.4717213809490204,
0.2894896864891052,
0.08561287075281143,
-0.16633392870426178,
-0.22473931312561035,
0.5030802488327026,
0.2526439428329468,
0.13162098824977875,
0.2217661738395691,
0.07622756063938141,
0.019582683220505714,
-0.515086829662323,
0.19081388413906097,
0.5323440432548523,
-0.2245972603559494,
-0.41433581709861755,
0.9143117666244507,
0.07584883272647858,
-0.2990221083164215,
0.1265931874513626,
0.006519651971757412,
-0.1258939504623413,
0.3398445248603821,
0.6770793795585632,
0.9236729145050049,
-0.4735679626464844,
0.05651213228702545,
-0.01565316505730152,
0.5088292360305786,
-0.1545693278312683,
0.6879842877388,
-0.08354541659355164,
-0.701360821723938,
-0.13677290081977844,
-0.9269797205924988,
-0.5113280415534973,
-0.07301084697246552,
-0.4956369400024414,
0.042199451476335526,
-0.8036483526229858,
-0.05108480155467987,
-0.5133839249610901,
-0.07517031580209732,
-0.40366047620773315,
-0.015584881417453289,
0.012100051157176495,
0.8917429447174072,
-0.8078027963638306,
0.6057102084159851,
0.608153760433197,
-0.3218287527561188,
-0.500562846660614,
-0.41837969422340393,
0.027965713292360306,
-0.6221503615379333,
0.11835376173257828,
-0.07893920689821243,
0.03507302701473236,
-0.17076966166496277,
-0.525847852230072,
-0.5241177678108215,
0.9902690052986145,
0.7728180289268494,
-0.47405144572257996,
-0.0014126856112852693,
0.6103044152259827,
0.46444591879844666,
-0.25500720739364624,
-0.5223382115364075,
0.5329107046127319,
0.4868637025356293,
-0.3877406418323517,
-0.5355108976364136,
0.3137245178222656,
0.05903993919491768,
0.026297111064195633,
0.09552587568759918,
-0.5484208464622498,
0.7841941118240356,
-0.07071268558502197,
-0.40630853176116943,
0.22941148281097412,
0.5692851543426514,
0.5527576804161072,
0.21878357231616974,
0.33317598700523376,
0.3641132116317749,
0.929171621799469,
-0.2137867957353592,
0.9122276902198792,
-0.37952688336372375,
0.023580357432365417,
1.1930586099624634,
-0.5586077570915222,
0.8394085168838501,
0.6723496317863464,
-0.3388647139072418,
0.2508530914783478,
0.5324985384941101,
0.21779823303222656,
0.6074765920639038,
0.2362128496170044,
-0.7800966501235962,
-0.408752977848053,
-0.3450488746166229,
-0.2628231644630432,
0.25737082958221436,
0.43114137649536133,
-0.40374088287353516,
-0.060233112424612045,
-0.3004642724990845,
0.049962710589170456,
0.5031667351722717,
-0.13101163506507874,
0.9290368556976318,
0.6080830693244934,
-0.13166266679763794,
0.14729024469852448,
0.17854377627372742,
0.4144423305988312,
-0.7042763233184814,
0.5064703822135925,
-0.40812960267066956,
0.09764145314693451,
-0.449669748544693,
-0.7514449954032898,
0.7633634209632874,
-0.06605123728513718,
-0.12865234911441803,
-0.34453755617141724,
0.8534215688705444,
-0.4672381281852722,
-0.4014187455177307,
0.20457251369953156,
0.649899423122406,
-0.10603468865156174,
-0.10834638774394989,
-0.7239348292350769,
0.1356763392686844,
-0.25628307461738586,
-0.0025812366511672735,
0.41045740246772766,
0.32725852727890015,
-0.17275749146938324,
0.5731779932975769,
0.8096686005592346,
0.0752507895231247,
0.22620685398578644,
0.16084666550159454,
0.6195454001426697,
-0.4574221670627594,
-0.6145352721214294,
-1.2232378721237183,
0.3087203800678253,
0.024424107745289803,
0.0944068655371666,
0.7510907649993896,
0.7409932017326355,
0.6007919311523438,
-0.15710708498954773,
0.5061604380607605,
0.37357857823371887,
0.1336090862751007,
-0.904798150062561,
0.9801319241523743,
-0.340311199426651,
0.43073976039886475,
-0.05134478583931923,
-0.8913567066192627,
-0.5288652181625366,
0.3262253999710083,
0.04820800572633743,
-0.1813637912273407,
0.453094482421875,
1.2887814044952393,
-0.1622386872768402,
0.05759471282362938,
0.42599591612815857,
0.22631673514842987,
0.27822744846343994,
0.4915718138217926,
0.7958216667175293,
-0.2909378111362457,
0.4819539487361908,
0.03386199101805687,
0.1943424493074417,
0.000756884750444442,
-0.9273438453674316,
-0.8727274537086487,
-0.349500447511673,
-0.39954936504364014,
-0.17005610466003418,
0.2040976583957672,
0.6687425374984741,
0.997917652130127,
-1.0666747093200684,
-0.17980140447616577,
-0.3887077271938324,
0.47377222776412964,
-0.004054846242070198,
-0.21649916470050812,
-0.019992182031273842,
-0.2662099301815033,
-0.5695580840110779,
0.7832468152046204,
0.4934437572956085,
0.36892008781433105,
-0.5984498262405396,
-0.04933467507362366,
0.20622539520263672,
0.19482046365737915,
0.41950348019599915,
0.15939979255199432,
-0.5632608532905579,
-0.030805721879005432,
0.07516749203205109,
-0.3825874328613281,
-0.011095363646745682,
0.6483566164970398,
-0.13664819300174713,
0.32412856817245483,
0.582443356513977,
0.8402522206306458,
0.2451058030128479,
-0.21038097143173218,
0.6931778788566589,
-1.133387565612793,
-0.018876198679208755,
0.08524928241968155,
0.4579521119594574,
0.5377627611160278,
-0.5978192090988159,
0.4765719771385193,
0.2094324827194214,
-0.5413331985473633,
-1.0002228021621704,
0.539191722869873,
-1.1443066596984863,
-0.1478908807039261,
0.8323965072631836,
-0.1285886913537979,
-0.4698142409324646,
-0.3785398304462433,
-0.17857740819454193,
-0.20737653970718384,
-0.18652425706386566,
0.6922688484191895,
0.5774401426315308,
0.1668890416622162,
-0.054793767631053925,
-0.3064175844192505,
0.5509788990020752,
0.29607024788856506,
-1.0735719203948975,
0.103815458714962,
0.23534461855888367,
0.3956305980682373,
-0.10867223143577576,
0.5150100588798523,
-0.5428377389907837,
-0.04338429495692253,
-0.3728410005569458,
-0.3406834900379181,
-0.10567065328359604,
-0.2247677892446518,
-0.19486141204833984,
0.4100998044013977,
0.27537623047828674,
-0.16038121283054352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09798v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09798v1
|
Many-Shot In-Context Learning in Multimodal Foundation Models
| 2024-05-16T04:02:43 | 2024-05-16T04:02:43 |
Yixing Jiang, Jeremy Irvin, Ji Hun Wang, Muhammad Ahmed Chaudhry, Jonathan H. Chen, Andrew Y. Ng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large language models are well-known to be effective at few-shot in-context
learning (ICL). Recent advancements in multimodal foundation models have
enabled unprecedentedly long context windows, presenting an opportunity to
explore their capability to perform ICL with many more demonstrating examples.
In this work, we evaluate the performance of multimodal foundation models
scaling from few-shot to many-shot ICL. We benchmark GPT-4o and Gemini 1.5 Pro
across 10 datasets spanning multiple domains (natural imagery, medical imagery,
remote sensing, and molecular imagery) and tasks (multi-class, multi-label, and
fine-grained classification). We observe that many-shot ICL, including up to
almost 2,000 multimodal demonstrating examples, leads to substantial
improvements compared to few-shot (<100 examples) ICL across all of the
datasets. Further, Gemini 1.5 Pro performance continues to improve log-linearly
up to the maximum number of tested examples on many datasets. Given the high
inference costs associated with the long prompts required for many-shot ICL, we
also explore the impact of batching multiple queries in a single API call. We
show that batching up to 50 queries can lead to performance improvements under
zero-shot and many-shot ICL, with substantial gains in the zero-shot setting on
multiple datasets, while drastically reducing per-query cost and latency.
Finally, we measure ICL data efficiency of the models, or the rate at which the
models learn from more demonstrating examples. We find that while GPT-4o and
Gemini 1.5 Pro achieve similar zero-shot performance across the datasets,
Gemini 1.5 Pro exhibits higher ICL data efficiency than GPT-4o on most
datasets. Our results suggest that many-shot ICL could enable users to
efficiently adapt multimodal foundation models to new applications and domains.
Our codebase is publicly available at
https://github.com/stanfordmlgroup/ManyICL .
|
[
-0.4407917559146881,
-0.720243513584137,
0.39364299178123474,
0.3826342225074768,
-0.05196519196033478,
-0.2675568461418152,
-0.30879008769989014,
-0.6319320797920227,
-0.3397093415260315,
0.36969077587127686,
-0.5337165594100952,
-0.6908569931983948,
-0.6152087450027466,
0.06248054653406143,
-0.358384370803833,
0.9631208777427673,
0.07681555300951004,
0.0749596357345581,
-0.13816222548484802,
-0.4293285012245178,
-0.303643137216568,
-0.2606271505355835,
-0.4422575831413269,
-0.14410366117954254,
0.470501571893692,
0.4745459258556366,
0.3910694122314453,
0.2517489492893219,
0.7520542740821838,
0.21894389390945435,
0.2744496762752533,
0.055131696164608,
-0.6814306378364563,
0.145839124917984,
-0.018590040504932404,
-0.3165990710258484,
-0.2289566546678543,
-0.12496654689311981,
0.8574108481407166,
0.5411216616630554,
0.0003380861598998308,
0.07958203554153442,
-0.06310374289751053,
0.6009690761566162,
-1.1179298162460327,
0.2956089377403259,
-0.6288505792617798,
-0.03374924138188362,
-0.32763469219207764,
0.0917351022362709,
-0.6249185800552368,
0.22612157464027405,
0.37217849493026733,
-0.6829045414924622,
0.06345544010400772,
0.026390157639980316,
0.36110541224479675,
0.12135300040245056,
-0.7976951003074646,
-0.2047528326511383,
-0.5711586475372314,
0.8767852187156677,
-0.541151225566864,
0.49251222610473633,
0.1508055329322815,
0.6971696615219116,
-0.12502168118953705,
-0.8717398047447205,
-0.4394094944000244,
-0.30998000502586365,
0.033860888332128525,
0.17383402585983276,
-0.10479957610368729,
0.18063467741012573,
0.38384199142456055,
-0.04649246856570244,
-0.6807879209518433,
-0.026718538254499435,
-0.15782681107521057,
-0.06128707528114319,
0.40279966592788696,
0.20157989859580994,
-0.2862068712711334,
-0.07303551584482193,
-0.5058355331420898,
-0.2885540723800659,
-0.8312284350395203,
0.3238363265991211,
-0.10812095552682877,
0.5814838409423828,
-0.2571909725666046,
0.4111945927143097,
-0.45645058155059814,
0.9916243553161621,
-0.05387734994292259,
-0.5939933657646179,
0.22444497048854828,
-0.41959652304649353,
-0.29419592022895813,
-0.09209869801998138,
0.6115531325340271,
0.3207973837852478,
0.08098120242357254,
0.004633806645870209,
-0.15207117795944214,
-0.02657056786119938,
-0.09803814440965652,
-1.1754488945007324,
-0.022875206544995308,
0.12583737075328827,
-0.364063024520874,
0.1548241525888443,
0.17349457740783691,
-0.3688203692436218,
-0.16749274730682373,
-0.28647100925445557,
0.6129592657089233,
-0.499980092048645,
-0.07447730749845505,
0.05912696197628975,
-0.11423563212156296,
0.28167086839675903,
0.4711668789386749,
-0.7511328458786011,
0.3470883071422577,
0.5550456047058105,
0.9628168940544128,
-0.11591293662786484,
-0.5124872326850891,
-0.6689350008964539,
0.2498226761817932,
-0.38052287697792053,
0.7043564319610596,
-0.6288637518882751,
-0.28916749358177185,
-0.2032821625471115,
-0.14131678640842438,
-0.1735077053308487,
-0.4916892945766449,
-0.021197952330112457,
-0.38196027278900146,
-0.18341554701328278,
-0.17719821631908417,
-0.3118594288825989,
-0.0054483553394675255,
0.7180831432342529,
-0.5270636081695557,
0.7495197057723999,
0.13860531151294708,
-0.45386072993278503,
0.6440050601959229,
-0.7898465394973755,
-0.5970717072486877,
-0.1863216906785965,
-0.23170660436153412,
-0.3740755617618561,
0.03294116258621216,
0.2531079053878784,
0.7411883473396301,
-0.2914658784866333,
0.17451883852481842,
-0.505601167678833,
-0.49004632234573364,
0.10681185126304626,
-0.56136155128479,
0.5463372468948364,
0.14536134898662567,
-0.4136657416820526,
0.03940253332257271,
-0.7546923160552979,
-0.12312933802604675,
-0.3244988024234772,
-0.4096513092517853,
0.010064811445772648,
-0.35169875621795654,
0.3662765920162201,
0.6496636867523193,
-0.48705145716667175,
-0.5741609930992126,
0.2990623414516449,
-0.24579380452632904,
0.26075008511543274,
0.504656970500946,
-0.10534977167844772,
0.42815959453582764,
-0.16475830972194672,
0.4088020324707031,
0.4795251190662384,
0.35068032145500183,
-0.7235246300697327,
-0.5130022168159485,
-0.36640092730522156,
-0.7730749845504761,
0.05274688079953194,
0.06412651389837265,
-0.8446977734565735,
-0.44757720828056335,
-0.2480429857969284,
-0.24395698308944702,
-0.3487066626548767,
0.17944815754890442,
0.65440833568573,
0.6577200293540955,
0.5643854141235352,
-0.3125171661376953,
-0.07077533006668091,
-0.8971474766731262,
0.06866838037967682,
0.07927034050226212,
0.08094888925552368,
0.9079251885414124,
0.857713520526886,
-0.03447619080543518,
1.1028285026550293,
-0.44092974066734314,
-0.3625204563140869,
0.07808266580104828,
0.30731528997421265,
0.086790531873703,
0.3497902750968933,
0.8716356158256531,
-0.9274333119392395,
-0.7752708196640015,
-0.07417849451303482,
-0.7282053232192993,
0.3602331876754761,
-0.09045182913541794,
-0.030884865671396255,
0.23418158292770386,
0.19612640142440796,
-0.8195903301239014,
0.34675848484039307,
0.5518559217453003,
-0.19189821183681488,
0.6510505080223083,
0.119261734187603,
0.3722362518310547,
-1.0404590368270874,
0.09293684363365173,
0.23607712984085083,
-0.1931411772966385,
-0.49268507957458496,
0.1111128106713295,
0.3161941170692444,
-0.20648156106472015,
-1.130113959312439,
0.6500033140182495,
-0.5356994867324829,
-0.46957045793533325,
-0.12736865878105164,
-0.10943815857172012,
0.08589643239974976,
0.38196587562561035,
-0.11606000363826752,
0.7787702679634094,
1.0147857666015625,
-0.6245309114456177,
0.40654611587524414,
0.10282806307077408,
-0.35243290662765503,
0.7333143353462219,
-0.3084784746170044,
0.014265297912061214,
-0.46405696868896484,
0.877368688583374,
-1.1402374505996704,
-0.5063565373420715,
0.018420882523059845,
-0.11414401978254318,
0.40450966358184814,
-0.42255568504333496,
-0.418064683675766,
-0.2218855917453766,
-0.5295897126197815,
0.5535047054290771,
-0.08622047305107117,
-0.7104580402374268,
0.6842561960220337,
-0.17664456367492676,
0.3452373445034027,
-1.086113452911377,
-0.8677071332931519,
0.17091476917266846,
-0.04698534309864044,
-0.7673202157020569,
0.6279860138893127,
-0.07848803699016571,
-0.17240077257156372,
-0.06551972776651382,
0.035956114530563354,
-0.07423609495162964,
-0.027732864022254944,
0.35310134291648865,
0.1302517205476761,
-0.5130112171173096,
0.40275833010673523,
-0.0823320746421814,
-0.08443228155374527,
-0.4350557327270508,
-0.43740057945251465,
0.4103780686855316,
-0.297258585691452,
-0.5208744406700134,
-0.47127649188041687,
0.3227067291736603,
0.8871365785598755,
-0.2611601650714874,
1.004459023475647,
0.581609308719635,
-0.43220770359039307,
-0.09699016809463501,
-0.5820713639259338,
-0.346948504447937,
-0.3740859925746918,
0.31983456015586853,
-0.7733578681945801,
-0.7853825688362122,
0.44917577505111694,
-0.06246088072657585,
0.1529802680015564,
0.41699591279029846,
0.611402690410614,
-0.08171503245830536,
0.7571641206741333,
0.5982555747032166,
-0.18646474182605743,
0.5303900241851807,
-0.6512449383735657,
-0.1477752923965454,
-0.685538113117218,
-0.20203948020935059,
-0.1526576280593872,
-0.48579782247543335,
-0.3208743929862976,
-0.410910964012146,
0.6255078911781311,
0.053360018879175186,
-0.2005765438079834,
0.1538638323545456,
0.008142717182636261,
0.6252644062042236,
0.472034752368927,
0.27793025970458984,
0.37246519327163696,
-0.08527491986751556,
0.07592931389808655,
0.2945477366447449,
-0.6481885313987732,
-0.04582446813583374,
1.4946407079696655,
-0.006496700923889875,
0.9486257433891296,
0.3605417013168335,
0.443432480096817,
-0.1997814178466797,
0.566061794757843,
-0.8127661943435669,
0.17701618373394012,
-0.323350191116333,
-1.0271835327148438,
-0.21173088252544403,
-0.3457846939563751,
-0.6373383402824402,
0.6117000579833984,
-0.5179968476295471,
-0.4262516498565674,
0.18289409577846527,
0.28020450472831726,
-0.6300734877586365,
0.11597656458616257,
-0.8257946968078613,
1.0040069818496704,
-0.35059013962745667,
-0.7154614925384521,
-0.31285056471824646,
-1.0062355995178223,
0.5609484910964966,
-0.017693379893898964,
-0.12293773889541626,
-0.12096045911312103,
0.06633279472589493,
0.19791626930236816,
0.002721342956647277,
0.9001986980438232,
-0.26195597648620605,
0.3571604788303375,
0.30296531319618225,
-0.23356439173221588,
0.30115875601768494,
0.09347043931484222,
-0.15214648842811584,
0.12902362644672394,
0.011043003760278225,
-0.40005961060523987,
-0.4838487505912781,
0.954919695854187,
-0.6320887804031372,
-0.15167388319969177,
-0.2861325442790985,
-0.7159090638160706,
-0.28418970108032227,
0.05831054225564003,
0.26241326332092285,
0.99140465259552,
-0.05996176600456238,
0.763586699962616,
0.3880841135978699,
-0.054457634687423706,
0.7325661182403564,
0.5607357025146484,
-0.010829774662852287,
-0.10146372765302658,
0.5052259564399719,
0.40270838141441345,
0.4970422685146332,
0.4732239842414856,
-0.03395354002714157,
-0.391490638256073,
-0.5018424987792969,
-0.6965779066085815,
0.06192765384912491,
-0.7287320494651794,
-0.44941696524620056,
-0.7136709690093994,
0.17619726061820984,
-0.630774199962616,
-0.23565442860126495,
-0.4709221124649048,
-0.3322916626930237,
-0.22428153455257416,
0.09750830382108688,
0.17930968105793,
0.34475013613700867,
0.2607816457748413,
0.6075316667556763,
-0.6804668307304382,
0.24191318452358246,
0.25072428584098816,
0.39464235305786133,
0.06555606424808502,
-0.25903794169425964,
-0.24935640394687653,
-0.09322389960289001,
-0.509428083896637,
-0.6024868488311768,
0.096725694835186,
0.6219990849494934,
0.4474421739578247,
0.6660938858985901,
-0.1427256464958191,
1.073305368423462,
-0.3946326673030853,
0.646720826625824,
0.3357532322406769,
-0.643333911895752,
0.4071827232837677,
-0.32159265875816345,
0.5467709898948669,
0.6628444790840149,
0.6441322565078735,
-0.42842477560043335,
0.09304642677307129,
-0.29323095083236694,
-0.5820261240005493,
0.8611153960227966,
-0.012564037926495075,
0.11034096777439117,
-0.09238062798976898,
0.5146101713180542,
0.09347296506166458,
0.25999805331230164,
-0.7729651927947998,
-0.12936729192733765,
-0.14757712185382843,
-0.16705788671970367,
-0.11434555798768997,
-0.055868979543447495,
-0.1706131547689438,
-0.07194999605417252,
0.4251016080379486,
-0.6427236199378967,
-0.00026987906312569976,
0.02319834940135479,
-0.49613267183303833,
0.033378928899765015,
0.30798211693763733,
0.6963543891906738,
0.9772999286651611,
-0.20697420835494995,
0.2103685885667801,
0.11020629107952118,
-0.1633155643939972,
-0.003018663264811039,
0.16458439826965332,
0.2068880945444107,
-0.3807094097137451,
0.6559632420539856,
0.873633086681366,
0.5633286833763123,
-0.791411280632019,
0.7497525811195374,
0.10113745927810669,
-0.1678893268108368,
0.05617788806557655,
-0.06173395738005638,
-0.141353040933609,
0.5310682654380798,
0.4424668252468109,
0.18730592727661133,
0.3295687735080719,
-0.9467024803161621,
0.3269694745540619,
0.5980824828147888,
-0.15832430124282837,
-0.2921063303947449,
0.4807818531990051,
0.08760691434144974,
0.26376232504844666,
0.9843612909317017,
-0.01863378845155239,
-0.14396914839744568,
0.6020574569702148,
0.9142982363700867,
0.4762342572212219,
-0.05799736827611923,
0.1307118535041809,
0.3070710599422455,
0.0095093147829175,
-0.17218339443206787,
-0.12863405048847198,
-0.26740333437919617,
-0.7914073467254639,
-0.5024985671043396,
-0.4607698917388916,
-0.3139297664165497,
-0.11307304352521896,
-0.357604444026947,
0.28804662823677063,
-0.5126123428344727,
-0.3457581698894501,
0.07945673167705536,
-0.16566556692123413,
-0.8088212013244629,
0.13336600363254547,
0.2056238353252411,
0.8409273624420166,
-0.8534573316574097,
0.8981040120124817,
0.5534849762916565,
-0.3393746316432953,
-0.45437386631965637,
-0.1466246247291565,
0.43333524465560913,
-0.539268434047699,
0.8474883437156677,
0.5798038244247437,
-0.3125185966491699,
0.0916910395026207,
-0.4955540895462036,
-0.8058874607086182,
1.5471750497817993,
0.4761431813240051,
-0.6486049890518188,
0.11369126290082932,
0.011632862500846386,
0.4096963107585907,
-0.6891882419586182,
0.47035646438598633,
0.431382417678833,
0.22551557421684265,
0.46113213896751404,
-0.9138373732566833,
-0.4167026877403259,
0.16960151493549347,
-0.02852064184844494,
0.177716463804245,
-0.699006199836731,
1.0303901433944702,
-0.39754921197891235,
0.040531549602746964,
-0.14688722789287567,
0.28206783533096313,
0.44619229435920715,
0.6007105708122253,
0.36659133434295654,
0.5625941753387451,
0.5031653046607971,
-0.07688063383102417,
1.320986270904541,
-0.3327699303627014,
0.3995993137359619,
0.9677188992500305,
-0.483227401971817,
1.0586190223693848,
0.47817766666412354,
0.0038070334121584892,
0.15894420444965363,
0.4336209297180176,
0.17376752197742462,
0.6040746569633484,
-0.1839430183172226,
-0.5018776059150696,
-0.23692147433757782,
-0.1336529701948166,
-0.14255239069461823,
0.6891196370124817,
0.27935054898262024,
-0.22062194347381592,
-0.37770840525627136,
0.6339682936668396,
-0.1967787891626358,
-0.4664112329483032,
-0.19848188757896423,
0.640614926815033,
0.041669562458992004,
-0.5500509738922119,
0.29438209533691406,
0.10455906391143799,
0.8090130090713501,
-0.6952473521232605,
-0.1222345232963562,
-0.18020588159561157,
0.42788392305374146,
-0.24356207251548767,
-0.6526910662651062,
0.06181955337524414,
-0.15850111842155457,
-0.27293500304222107,
-0.03467832878232002,
0.6908340454101562,
-0.3240449130535126,
-0.46044474840164185,
0.2978525161743164,
0.31616342067718506,
0.05928509682416916,
-0.433322548866272,
-0.8190122246742249,
0.029822878539562225,
-0.44235554337501526,
-0.3475644886493683,
0.4506629407405853,
0.10617198050022125,
-0.3033367097377777,
0.7954452633857727,
0.7994415163993835,
-0.3598211109638214,
0.27877745032310486,
0.21615205705165863,
0.9375132322311401,
-0.4614717364311218,
-0.1791626363992691,
-0.980568528175354,
0.5837119221687317,
0.13327115774154663,
-0.5843022465705872,
0.5382694005966187,
0.7502015829086304,
0.9195314645767212,
-0.09334786981344223,
0.3875390589237213,
-0.10283274948596954,
-0.0704725980758667,
-0.6633313298225403,
0.35946452617645264,
-0.602715253829956,
0.013145485892891884,
-0.2758893668651581,
-0.9393595457077026,
-0.7687475681304932,
0.545222818851471,
-0.323947936296463,
0.2312827855348587,
0.5483899116516113,
1.0205512046813965,
-0.32451045513153076,
-0.2036561518907547,
0.5051365494728088,
0.16377337276935577,
0.508474588394165,
0.6115227341651917,
0.7343086004257202,
-0.5141372084617615,
0.5196025967597961,
-0.36538535356521606,
-0.3276016414165497,
-0.37841522693634033,
-0.748489499092102,
-0.7636076807975769,
-0.4001365005970001,
-0.14774596691131592,
-0.024048570543527603,
0.24048127233982086,
1.1666922569274902,
1.37964928150177,
-0.766993522644043,
-0.20117101073265076,
0.2745811641216278,
-0.23743385076522827,
-0.30467498302459717,
-0.2060960829257965,
0.22824051976203918,
-0.22764010727405548,
-0.6389738917350769,
0.4487151801586151,
0.6541832685470581,
-0.09685628116130829,
-0.18465839326381683,
-0.17890217900276184,
-0.4259358048439026,
-0.410674124956131,
1.2584396600723267,
0.11036374419927597,
-0.8056317567825317,
-0.09191489219665527,
0.0747101902961731,
-0.14914870262145996,
0.1442323923110962,
0.8609623312950134,
-0.8894944190979004,
0.7038121223449707,
0.2702890634536743,
0.6647294759750366,
1.107804298400879,
0.09621497988700867,
0.09691272675991058,
-1.054653525352478,
0.3224949836730957,
0.19397683441638947,
0.2946728467941284,
0.2991907298564911,
-0.12928074598312378,
0.4491271376609802,
0.22072459757328033,
-0.2646796405315399,
-0.5432223677635193,
0.11641324311494827,
-0.8741774559020996,
-0.4049684703350067,
0.9604663252830505,
-0.22354212403297424,
-0.0011768072145059705,
0.09863264113664627,
-0.06479663401842117,
-0.1524236649274826,
-0.4202292263507843,
0.42941978573799133,
0.7724062204360962,
-0.5871087312698364,
-0.4387816786766052,
-0.6629367470741272,
0.16811905801296234,
0.10018826276063919,
-0.8214796185493469,
-0.1740494966506958,
0.862419843673706,
0.3347800076007843,
-0.004816778469830751,
0.7583206295967102,
-0.22734177112579346,
0.395809531211853,
-0.05873937904834747,
-0.14199116826057434,
-0.1428653448820114,
-0.94760662317276,
-0.3312796652317047,
0.3984547555446625,
-0.05268389359116554,
-0.08787833154201508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09770v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09770v1
|
Optimization Techniques for Sentiment Analysis Based on LLM (GPT-3)
| 2024-05-16T02:21:13 | 2024-05-16T02:21:13 |
Tong Zhan, Chenxi Shi, Yadong Shi, Huixiang Li, Yiyu Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the rapid development of natural language processing (NLP) technology,
large-scale pre-trained language models such as GPT-3 have become a popular
research object in NLP field. This paper aims to explore sentiment analysis
optimization techniques based on large pre-trained language models such as
GPT-3 to improve model performance and effect and further promote the
development of natural language processing (NLP). By introducing the importance
of sentiment analysis and the limitations of traditional methods, GPT-3 and
Fine-tuning techniques are introduced in this paper, and their applications in
sentiment analysis are explained in detail. The experimental results show that
the Fine-tuning technique can optimize GPT-3 model and obtain good performance
in sentiment analysis task. This study provides an important reference for
future sentiment analysis using large-scale language models.
|
[
-0.7131069898605347,
-0.9267988204956055,
0.6333929896354675,
0.3130221366882324,
-0.5854273438453674,
-0.05907703563570976,
-0.28870582580566406,
-0.26490259170532227,
-0.212870791554451,
0.416177898645401,
-0.7319542169570923,
-0.6179365515708923,
-0.5878118276596069,
0.19487392902374268,
0.011317686177790165,
1.2081005573272705,
-0.051230352371931076,
0.4767981767654419,
0.25302913784980774,
-0.041283462196588516,
-0.24720899760723114,
-0.6545100212097168,
-1.090658187866211,
-0.12294221669435501,
0.3660125434398651,
0.045120928436517715,
0.6787175536155701,
0.22782661020755768,
0.9358874559402466,
0.29443615674972534,
-0.202795147895813,
0.07799775153398514,
-0.5273733139038086,
-0.06878544390201569,
-0.027489231899380684,
-0.4727470576763153,
-0.7016317844390869,
0.23464486002922058,
0.6469821929931641,
0.3142288327217102,
-0.009908891282975674,
0.16467005014419556,
0.34672072529792786,
0.8260096311569214,
-0.4673481583595276,
0.24021907150745392,
-0.5789365768432617,
0.18717724084854126,
-0.28550922870635986,
-0.4934085011482239,
-0.06847736984491348,
-0.7718591690063477,
0.06472726911306381,
-0.21246008574962616,
0.23734907805919647,
-0.023719223216176033,
0.8601782917976379,
0.34450432658195496,
0.044639941304922104,
-0.21710719168186188,
-0.5084285736083984,
1.1688650846481323,
-1.218819499015808,
0.05146190896630287,
-0.11469116061925888,
0.08336798846721649,
-0.050359394401311874,
-0.2996956706047058,
-0.5539529323577881,
-0.2076764851808548,
0.19338354468345642,
0.16912837326526642,
0.009707208722829819,
0.30101630091667175,
0.1584835946559906,
0.6324661374092102,
-0.4402543902397156,
0.20809677243232727,
0.10392827540636063,
0.1616075187921524,
0.4385194480419159,
0.19093914330005646,
0.25920307636260986,
-0.34118562936782837,
-0.1996646374464035,
0.08878035843372345,
-0.6372302770614624,
-0.22551795840263367,
0.3854563236236572,
0.4768609404563904,
0.07524003088474274,
0.4853382408618927,
-0.2005593329668045,
0.8447456359863281,
-0.17676222324371338,
-0.2927636504173279,
0.28567472100257874,
-0.20033226907253265,
-0.43750911951065063,
-0.5040369033813477,
0.7982571125030518,
0.6362136006355286,
0.6325628757476807,
0.07434921711683273,
-0.32726046442985535,
0.2383015751838684,
0.0862346664071083,
-0.7099562287330627,
0.25327104330062866,
0.054856766015291214,
-0.6138651371002197,
-0.5790892243385315,
-0.26602455973625183,
-0.8751412034034729,
-0.15701650083065033,
-0.48739922046661377,
0.32053452730178833,
-0.25297603011131287,
-0.319852739572525,
0.42295384407043457,
0.10192771255970001,
0.5431133508682251,
0.3153980076313019,
-0.9176305532455444,
0.4432950019836426,
1.0268335342407227,
0.9587918519973755,
-0.2235528528690338,
-0.07968394458293915,
-0.33968618512153625,
-0.25138428807258606,
-0.1982170045375824,
0.6666602492332458,
-0.36080026626586914,
-0.2727634608745575,
-0.03178747370839119,
-0.35674765706062317,
-0.0674298033118248,
-0.44429680705070496,
0.6657626032829285,
-0.7201372385025024,
0.12214676290750504,
-0.12641501426696777,
-0.43283766508102417,
-0.3929545283317566,
0.6892836689949036,
-0.547292947769165,
0.8803515434265137,
0.15829885005950928,
-0.9761593341827393,
0.28194165229797363,
-0.9854151010513306,
-0.311815470457077,
-0.1902739405632019,
0.3059008717536926,
-0.4959934949874878,
0.5310324430465698,
0.6755172610282898,
0.92409348487854,
-0.5097684264183044,
0.040395356714725494,
-0.295938104391098,
-0.41936859488487244,
-0.09428994357585907,
-0.2389315366744995,
0.5362098217010498,
0.30875566601753235,
-0.2647963762283325,
0.017353586852550507,
-0.3009422719478607,
0.13153548538684845,
-0.0002011614851653576,
-0.3049544095993042,
-0.13527750968933105,
0.14501430094242096,
-0.12819091975688934,
0.04298233240842819,
0.30868932604789734,
-0.4422139823436737,
0.22510041296482086,
-0.7804901003837585,
0.31662899255752563,
0.647097110748291,
0.24366576969623566,
0.3330817222595215,
0.06038331240415573,
0.7961670756340027,
-0.1840086579322815,
0.507811427116394,
0.2805173397064209,
-0.25661882758140564,
-0.7753905653953552,
-0.03989638388156891,
0.09913724660873413,
0.5845924019813538,
-0.4928882420063019,
0.38800889253616333,
-0.21785655617713928,
-0.35297900438308716,
-0.6333523392677307,
0.30568164587020874,
-0.006800629664212465,
0.23950974643230438,
0.41992753744125366,
0.05159325897693634,
-0.5791342854499817,
-0.9110884666442871,
-0.671174943447113,
0.1540798544883728,
0.19695350527763367,
-0.10688690841197968,
0.1234540194272995,
-0.2769078016281128,
0.8283392190933228,
-0.8042146563529968,
-0.2533251643180847,
-0.6475410461425781,
0.29174983501434326,
0.5762786865234375,
0.22779475152492523,
0.51846843957901,
-0.5051683783531189,
-0.6322806477546692,
0.062378160655498505,
-0.5394428372383118,
-0.12798631191253662,
0.21342647075653076,
-0.05736091360449791,
0.36703330278396606,
0.3337565064430237,
-0.5368857979774475,
0.03147507831454277,
0.651249885559082,
0.20056474208831787,
0.3452678918838501,
0.15080170333385468,
-0.05069489777088165,
-1.0502572059631348,
-0.2789655327796936,
0.41691869497299194,
-0.3554235100746155,
-0.40289413928985596,
0.26179948449134827,
-0.1139921024441719,
-0.08699292689561844,
-0.43520960211753845,
0.30544787645339966,
-0.46410638093948364,
0.21460695564746857,
-0.4081266224384308,
0.21227338910102844,
-0.20298239588737488,
0.47490736842155457,
0.07306040078401566,
0.6734519600868225,
0.5939776301383972,
-0.3353767991065979,
0.3705289661884308,
-0.2522343695163727,
-0.25471577048301697,
0.3779630959033966,
-0.44523996114730835,
0.24490682780742645,
-0.05720894783735275,
-0.24267110228538513,
-0.83278888463974,
0.17933422327041626,
0.16526825726032257,
-0.1880991905927658,
0.3405490815639496,
-0.058229342103004456,
-0.739998459815979,
-0.5902733206748962,
-0.8303804397583008,
-0.03519764915108681,
0.530879557132721,
-0.42996323108673096,
0.46133312582969666,
0.1682165414094925,
-0.3622443675994873,
-0.4037625789642334,
-0.32319411635398865,
-0.16476339101791382,
-0.6252712607383728,
-0.51576167345047,
-0.03781389445066452,
0.035263679921627045,
-0.16877417266368866,
-0.46240994334220886,
0.03376314789056778,
0.21109963953495026,
-0.11535346508026123,
-0.03188486024737358,
0.3437710404396057,
-0.30354759097099304,
-0.029932398349046707,
-0.12682099640369415,
-0.25376009941101074,
0.09974046796560287,
-0.05413583666086197,
0.7178675532341003,
-0.7470131516456604,
0.03240774944424629,
-0.5259795784950256,
0.11288226395845413,
0.3275032639503479,
-0.06092807650566101,
0.3355195224285126,
0.852372944355011,
-0.05424384027719498,
-0.10977884382009506,
-0.9229094386100769,
0.05200086906552315,
-0.5113224983215332,
0.6061946749687195,
-0.1138639822602272,
-1.0812238454818726,
0.09060752391815186,
-0.3536718487739563,
-0.3346197307109833,
0.44111403822898865,
0.6819046139717102,
0.09176959842443466,
1.3362959623336792,
0.5828214287757874,
-0.8070612549781799,
0.5222532749176025,
-0.1348821073770523,
0.48802098631858826,
-1.006817102432251,
0.3410715162754059,
-0.5172622203826904,
-0.16933345794677734,
-0.7364558577537537,
-0.34063804149627686,
0.3192857503890991,
0.24175935983657837,
-0.350891649723053,
-0.2102939933538437,
-0.5296381115913391,
0.49620765447616577,
0.44756796956062317,
-0.05881728604435921,
0.22884230315685272,
0.13305775821208954,
-0.023284373804926872,
-0.13046209514141083,
-0.2038528025150299,
-0.7082200050354004,
0.9610841274261475,
0.6779336929321289,
0.7479752898216248,
-0.18960098922252655,
0.6792428493499756,
0.054625753313302994,
0.3638615310192108,
-1.0404819250106812,
0.7574447989463806,
-0.347504198551178,
-0.29236936569213867,
-0.2983110249042511,
-0.3152349591255188,
-0.4376908242702484,
0.13168081641197205,
-0.015682024881243706,
-0.6918444037437439,
-0.4985666275024414,
-0.05589353293180466,
-0.31348973512649536,
0.2182960957288742,
-0.6829583048820496,
0.6890690326690674,
-0.19111746549606323,
-0.09349506348371506,
-0.20565225183963776,
-0.39578384160995483,
0.38295048475265503,
-0.20266330242156982,
0.12384472042322159,
-0.21032606065273285,
-0.00978974811732769,
0.6815255880355835,
-0.37681472301483154,
0.6703960299491882,
-0.548270046710968,
-0.3743336796760559,
0.27657777070999146,
-0.13328330218791962,
0.787164032459259,
0.2980503737926483,
-0.317108690738678,
0.06935632973909378,
-0.3582365810871124,
-0.026675425469875336,
-0.6653794646263123,
0.9131410121917725,
-0.9042676687240601,
-0.7221477031707764,
-0.07128054648637772,
-0.2686144709587097,
-0.6427684426307678,
0.15260003507137299,
0.1057032123208046,
-0.0028261817060410976,
-0.020720237866044044,
0.0816216915845871,
0.4189688563346863,
-0.15859095752239227,
0.7743380069732666,
0.21822120249271393,
-0.264437198638916,
-0.4722059965133667,
0.7566354870796204,
-0.022350231185555458,
0.10536988824605942,
0.4965616464614868,
0.46628111600875854,
-0.2792534828186035,
-0.9397525191307068,
-0.051267076283693314,
0.36735695600509644,
-0.5646973848342896,
-0.5211362242698669,
-0.5390917658805847,
0.08709297329187393,
-0.2582443952560425,
-0.2512238919734955,
-0.3451479971408844,
-0.23357906937599182,
-0.3031432032585144,
-0.18948756158351898,
0.4690034091472626,
0.5190579295158386,
0.07210883498191833,
0.8145827054977417,
-0.6699915528297424,
0.6687963008880615,
0.37550798058509827,
0.5433782935142517,
-0.06489682197570801,
-0.07181066274642944,
-0.18535010516643524,
-0.09384839981794357,
-0.4547017812728882,
-0.607373058795929,
0.6621635556221008,
-0.08747522532939911,
0.20971831679344177,
0.4368164837360382,
-0.411685973405838,
0.5596927404403687,
-0.27264833450317383,
0.7843073606491089,
0.10817940533161163,
-1.1541025638580322,
0.7353936433792114,
-0.7664158940315247,
0.2130657285451889,
0.6011154055595398,
0.3330010771751404,
-0.18158653378486633,
-0.34395718574523926,
-0.267171174287796,
-0.8103943467140198,
0.679180920124054,
0.010578205808997154,
0.18179383873939514,
-0.03879612684249878,
0.627841055393219,
-0.07713007926940918,
0.22755759954452515,
-1.102394461631775,
0.09124463051557541,
-0.14397598803043365,
-0.2069961130619049,
-0.2381042242050171,
-0.39884430170059204,
0.0664675161242485,
-0.42449530959129333,
0.8014169931411743,
-0.22998084127902985,
0.22725988924503326,
-0.2284325212240219,
0.10923745483160019,
0.02165813371539116,
0.3817005157470703,
0.45327112078666687,
0.34189972281455994,
-0.489769846200943,
-0.39773255586624146,
0.4655033051967621,
-0.5290369987487793,
-0.02163059636950493,
-0.04153789207339287,
0.012273218482732773,
-0.34118837118148804,
0.18626657128334045,
0.6789012551307678,
-0.19591698050498962,
-0.08893359452486038,
0.6233714818954468,
0.1136331707239151,
-0.040122464299201965,
-0.15888001024723053,
0.18625624477863312,
0.3154744803905487,
0.24996761977672577,
0.1992228478193283,
-0.002741909120231867,
0.292285680770874,
-0.29907122254371643,
-0.38168132305145264,
0.8457104563713074,
-0.43363654613494873,
-0.11826058477163315,
0.2532711625099182,
-0.028323782607913017,
-0.09156662970781326,
0.4840332567691803,
-0.0857873186469078,
-0.5433688759803772,
0.35304754972457886,
0.5313572287559509,
0.9810882806777954,
-0.16930131614208221,
0.19796767830848694,
0.18262380361557007,
0.2181260734796524,
-0.4099639356136322,
0.4941512942314148,
0.2347654402256012,
-0.8543572425842285,
-0.9356130361557007,
-0.9946909546852112,
-0.2722559869289398,
0.26267021894454956,
-0.6356381177902222,
0.5174972414970398,
-0.5960399508476257,
-0.40540817379951477,
-0.25887295603752136,
0.474825918674469,
-0.746944785118103,
0.7440207600593567,
0.09945152699947357,
0.6011418700218201,
-0.6272619962692261,
0.7368327379226685,
0.4459935426712036,
-0.12113307416439056,
-0.9780896902084351,
0.062277067452669144,
-0.12644290924072266,
-0.875609278678894,
0.7717064023017883,
0.17411890625953674,
-0.47884616255760193,
0.27096083760261536,
-0.8156499266624451,
-0.62251216173172,
0.643502414226532,
0.19166527688503265,
-0.6133449077606201,
0.12058556824922562,
0.1945641040802002,
0.8230863809585571,
-0.4379895329475403,
0.025311067700386047,
0.876273512840271,
0.6362191438674927,
-0.22808578610420227,
-0.5843064188957214,
0.06304031610488892,
-0.20908582210540771,
0.31999605894088745,
0.37168705463409424,
-0.6714964509010315,
0.8483381271362305,
0.11244586110115051,
0.16428305208683014,
0.05272521451115608,
0.49972641468048096,
0.16112110018730164,
-0.1534224897623062,
0.43321338295936584,
0.6326302886009216,
0.41351068019866943,
-0.13678768277168274,
1.092862844467163,
-0.04749162867665291,
0.6807113885879517,
0.7988438606262207,
-0.2934132218360901,
0.9697138071060181,
0.5296521782875061,
-0.37651026248931885,
0.24935822188854218,
0.5056392550468445,
-0.20339897274971008,
0.48979389667510986,
0.5717289447784424,
-0.36496099829673767,
-0.04984686151146889,
0.35540255904197693,
-0.42154255509376526,
0.49975478649139404,
0.45886820554733276,
-0.31464168429374695,
-0.22319434583187103,
0.1388641595840454,
0.3989344835281372,
-0.2433539777994156,
-0.6366075873374939,
0.8776434063911438,
0.09312992542982101,
-0.45951777696609497,
0.572048008441925,
0.21750612556934357,
1.0388180017471313,
-0.44356536865234375,
0.3887062966823578,
-0.2359502613544464,
0.2325240522623062,
-0.13440752029418945,
-0.4544275104999542,
0.1716894507408142,
-0.035623449832201004,
0.009731370955705643,
-0.11385289579629898,
0.7406865358352661,
0.25619199872016907,
-0.723809540271759,
0.4259185492992401,
0.47717228531837463,
-0.13286684453487396,
-0.5650943517684937,
-0.7108436226844788,
0.012745335698127747,
0.11866191029548645,
-0.8619387149810791,
0.21535079181194305,
0.6183422207832336,
0.23865251243114471,
0.495015949010849,
0.59440016746521,
0.5732370615005493,
-0.28638309240341187,
0.42719539999961853,
1.0126827955245972,
-1.035345196723938,
-0.2304767668247223,
-1.3977750539779663,
0.09777772426605225,
-0.026811856776475906,
-0.1047043651342392,
0.7723307609558105,
0.4343545138835907,
0.49391499161720276,
-0.3140358030796051,
1.0214470624923706,
0.30605587363243103,
0.9218920469284058,
-0.8371272683143616,
0.47325631976127625,
-0.34798938035964966,
0.1878034472465515,
-0.8627562522888184,
-1.3641725778579712,
-0.8890066742897034,
0.6954147815704346,
-0.6557865738868713,
0.38893458247184753,
0.7676939964294434,
0.7746425867080688,
0.20688499510288239,
0.30507364869117737,
0.15728339552879333,
0.22560963034629822,
0.21430519223213196,
0.28855785727500916,
0.9593445658683777,
-0.1170072928071022,
0.24251163005828857,
-0.12025238573551178,
-0.10097435861825943,
-0.15208427608013153,
-1.1731873750686646,
-0.9994242787361145,
-0.015493406914174557,
-0.1880403459072113,
-0.05018402636051178,
-0.05280807986855507,
0.6504743099212646,
0.5570046305656433,
-0.5211261510848999,
-0.13577499985694885,
-0.29650676250457764,
-0.15805065631866455,
-0.05604124441742897,
-0.31753402948379517,
0.5090877413749695,
-0.8909342288970947,
-0.8022929430007935,
0.173105388879776,
0.3601556718349457,
0.13326767086982727,
-0.3271563649177551,
0.16008271276950836,
-0.019195014610886574,
0.0390525758266449,
0.9044062495231628,
-0.2321767807006836,
-0.4744444191455841,
-0.3014586567878723,
-0.26056694984436035,
0.20622532069683075,
0.20537276566028595,
0.919079601764679,
-0.4906608760356903,
0.1474195271730423,
0.4314876198768616,
0.32168880105018616,
0.4308862090110779,
0.35725468397140503,
0.6991357207298279,
-0.6704216003417969,
-0.06295185536146164,
0.2727415859699249,
0.2710111141204834,
0.5029956698417664,
-0.5301913619041443,
0.6595198512077332,
-0.21701037883758545,
-0.6574497222900391,
-0.4507645070552826,
-0.031941380351781845,
-0.9899771809577942,
-0.13690537214279175,
1.2546801567077637,
0.10511988401412964,
0.0070424871519207954,
0.061991624534130096,
-0.5451685786247253,
0.22515465319156647,
-0.3014747202396393,
0.6787207722663879,
0.8289504051208496,
-0.35913708806037903,
-0.19580630958080292,
-0.8213261961936951,
0.8125815987586975,
0.5057007074356079,
-0.9247922301292419,
-0.10522063076496124,
0.14845256507396698,
0.07960554957389832,
-0.02570595033466816,
0.6612767577171326,
-0.39270374178886414,
-0.30798986554145813,
-0.511848509311676,
-0.06332314014434814,
0.24488821625709534,
0.0033643387723714113,
-0.40723827481269836,
0.5446200966835022,
0.44554761052131653,
-0.03972109034657478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09765v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09765v1
|
Unsupervised Extractive Dialogue Summarization in Hyperdimensional Space
| 2024-05-16T02:11:03 | 2024-05-16T02:11:03 |
Seongmin Park, Kyungho Kim, Jaejin Seo, Jihwa Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present HyperSum, an extractive summarization framework that captures both
the efficiency of traditional lexical summarization and the accuracy of
contemporary neural approaches. HyperSum exploits the pseudo-orthogonality that
emerges when randomly initializing vectors at extremely high dimensions
("blessing of dimensionality") to construct representative and efficient
sentence embeddings. Simply clustering the obtained embeddings and extracting
their medoids yields competitive summaries. HyperSum often outperforms
state-of-the-art summarizers -- in terms of both summary accuracy and
faithfulness -- while being 10 to 100 times faster. We open-source HyperSum as
a strong baseline for unsupervised extractive summarization.
|
[
-0.30202436447143555,
-0.6645112633705139,
0.5172322392463684,
0.33820709586143494,
-0.3786355257034302,
0.15016689896583557,
-0.22515064477920532,
-0.04341381788253784,
0.8956077694892883,
0.3769673705101013,
-0.22600147128105164,
-0.5259798169136047,
-0.666407585144043,
-0.1668052077293396,
-0.32126426696777344,
1.2128019332885742,
0.5152326226234436,
-0.10942146927118301,
-0.6013909578323364,
-0.2108738273382187,
-0.06086960807442665,
-0.683868408203125,
0.1058584526181221,
0.10635692626237869,
0.42007115483283997,
0.5792217254638672,
0.9501891732215881,
0.7693037986755371,
0.486553430557251,
0.3791332244873047,
-0.2405136227607727,
0.3035368323326111,
-0.5565239191055298,
0.15507331490516663,
0.05107353627681732,
-0.3511109948158264,
-0.510283350944519,
0.08192158490419388,
0.7505757212638855,
0.9463317394256592,
-0.3868267238140106,
0.21913030743598938,
0.1333547979593277,
0.5261638164520264,
-0.7754071950912476,
0.39909207820892334,
-0.41492289304733276,
-0.030250009149312973,
-0.035030193626880646,
-0.37947866320610046,
0.03299165144562721,
-0.8068118691444397,
0.36197346448898315,
-0.8664482831954956,
0.12466873228549957,
0.13927040994167328,
0.702455997467041,
0.26504039764404297,
-0.1412113606929779,
-0.28589585423469543,
-0.8240455389022827,
0.9220142960548401,
-0.7511625289916992,
0.14967526495456696,
0.3587493896484375,
0.31014344096183777,
0.09190218150615692,
-1.1282836198806763,
-0.5961917042732239,
0.2429080605506897,
-0.19216769933700562,
0.4727994203567505,
-0.4597441554069519,
0.03668637201189995,
0.17150114476680756,
0.6761319637298584,
-0.38555559515953064,
-0.018781449645757675,
-0.33904412388801575,
-0.17709027230739594,
0.3253551423549652,
0.3063788414001465,
0.3142588436603546,
-0.45128631591796875,
-0.2597746253013611,
-0.01745135523378849,
-0.5857737064361572,
-0.1840413510799408,
0.2070593386888504,
0.06918732821941376,
-0.21272039413452148,
0.5546345710754395,
-0.18673065304756165,
0.2831573188304901,
-0.3348046541213989,
-0.24608303606510162,
0.3102489709854126,
-0.5017541646957397,
-0.13529358804225922,
0.1694777011871338,
0.7853136658668518,
0.816131055355072,
0.11180237680673599,
-0.04044830799102783,
0.033714354038238525,
-0.3461693823337555,
0.21247950196266174,
-0.9709627032279968,
-0.2828553318977356,
0.28446316719055176,
-0.9146507978439331,
-0.5279108881950378,
0.21847887337207794,
-1.1968082189559937,
-0.32886943221092224,
-0.26239681243896484,
0.06608715653419495,
-0.13923965394496918,
-0.13087984919548035,
-0.02497563138604164,
-0.44130921363830566,
-0.10201270878314972,
0.2776232659816742,
-0.8980564475059509,
0.3654654324054718,
0.6377773284912109,
1.0673145055770874,
-0.2891775071620941,
-0.0847775936126709,
-0.4770442247390747,
0.07917127758264542,
-0.34656962752342224,
0.857483446598053,
-0.35477638244628906,
-0.44952887296676636,
0.18640342354774475,
-0.33446282148361206,
0.16930359601974487,
-0.8738988637924194,
0.41012322902679443,
-0.21707332134246826,
0.44312670826911926,
-0.31429123878479004,
-0.43677520751953125,
-0.18099848926067352,
-0.037481456995010376,
-0.4232364594936371,
0.9351243376731873,
0.18832042813301086,
-0.7604967951774597,
0.2186402678489685,
-0.6232441663742065,
-0.2029099315404892,
0.12940573692321777,
-0.24093987047672272,
-0.3121859133243561,
0.33652037382125854,
0.38765642046928406,
0.5057427287101746,
-0.3758135735988617,
0.07410705089569092,
-0.04875662177801132,
-0.33379676938056946,
0.17184408009052277,
-0.3744522035121918,
0.7382403612136841,
0.3389088809490204,
-0.08074650913476944,
0.046916477382183075,
-0.8940410017967224,
-0.06739053130149841,
0.16289247572422028,
-0.022501947358250618,
-0.738533616065979,
0.033296629786491394,
0.01986716501414776,
0.12399976700544357,
0.3404400646686554,
-0.7380407452583313,
-0.10392779111862183,
-0.4904853105545044,
0.22247575223445892,
0.6764516830444336,
0.278001606464386,
0.38328248262405396,
-0.30521857738494873,
0.4170464277267456,
0.26556241512298584,
-0.07063349336385727,
-0.42061397433280945,
-0.37901702523231506,
-0.3850930333137512,
-0.9359756112098694,
0.35823798179626465,
0.5036431550979614,
-0.6570795178413391,
0.8490713238716125,
-0.3477310538291931,
-0.531848669052124,
-0.3313262462615967,
0.19496867060661316,
0.5217065215110779,
0.3358694911003113,
0.29566603899002075,
-0.29916512966156006,
-0.5391223430633545,
-0.9539559483528137,
-0.001035584369674325,
-0.27616086602211,
-0.1626395434141159,
0.16773509979248047,
0.30380621552467346,
0.015538658015429974,
1.0340772867202759,
-1.069985032081604,
-0.4013108015060425,
-0.6437134146690369,
0.5421581864356995,
0.34169062972068787,
0.3582298159599304,
0.6616126894950867,
-0.6301315426826477,
-0.20385025441646576,
-0.19602929055690765,
-1.0664052963256836,
-0.2156979739665985,
-0.14279314875602722,
-0.17204047739505768,
-0.23833981156349182,
0.6748917102813721,
-0.7243297696113586,
0.5605127215385437,
0.2885972261428833,
-0.0659002736210823,
0.43097731471061707,
-0.49303895235061646,
-0.05555935949087143,
-1.6255009174346924,
0.0457984134554863,
-0.12260670959949493,
-0.3442329168319702,
-0.3391392230987549,
-0.3145270347595215,
-0.10528867691755295,
-0.1409260630607605,
-0.21038642525672913,
-0.04565158858895302,
-0.3456916809082031,
-0.337879478931427,
-0.33053067326545715,
0.3622494637966156,
-0.12812238931655884,
0.6821973323822021,
-0.07117101550102234,
0.8093035221099854,
0.2394755333662033,
-0.46580731868743896,
0.27103444933891296,
0.7800165414810181,
-0.4681028425693512,
0.5410669445991516,
-1.010327935218811,
-0.12477028369903564,
-0.3714708089828491,
0.4392968714237213,
-1.0982054471969604,
-0.13889865577220917,
-0.2666361927986145,
-0.5456820130348206,
-0.059707868844270706,
0.03154386952519417,
-0.4592812657356262,
0.02533464878797531,
-0.5810551047325134,
0.4054693877696991,
0.6403505802154541,
-0.5144553184509277,
0.6439834237098694,
0.7817655205726624,
-0.6618961691856384,
-0.44321611523628235,
-0.30500131845474243,
0.17548169195652008,
-0.06748910993337631,
-0.0984806939959526,
0.21062959730625153,
0.025155464187264442,
-0.40562257170677185,
-0.0013310699723660946,
0.01776527613401413,
0.08953657001256943,
-0.03777989000082016,
0.41576600074768066,
0.30494484305381775,
-0.24797220528125763,
-0.19115206599235535,
0.19315029680728912,
-0.24498403072357178,
0.18531779944896698,
-0.3925270438194275,
0.4889181852340698,
0.15414243936538696,
-0.13969118893146515,
-0.6602157950401306,
0.8173877000808716,
0.9487461447715759,
-0.27457982301712036,
0.5695860385894775,
0.28751644492149353,
-0.48676836490631104,
0.03630886226892471,
-0.3037251830101013,
-0.001640278729610145,
-0.4174569249153137,
0.5877050161361694,
0.07258322834968567,
-0.6512210965156555,
0.6910638809204102,
-0.16642802953720093,
0.39852458238601685,
0.5276923775672913,
0.7611541152000427,
-0.21227094531059265,
1.1892653703689575,
0.7048235535621643,
-0.24863466620445251,
0.42368900775909424,
-0.33144399523735046,
0.41925111413002014,
-0.6962226033210754,
-0.32626286149024963,
-0.5678984522819519,
-0.18545423448085785,
-0.4492211639881134,
-0.15862897038459778,
0.8249123692512512,
-0.24001739919185638,
0.23558947443962097,
0.34696346521377563,
-0.12921859323978424,
0.612737774848938,
0.6372551918029785,
-0.2691211402416229,
0.308191180229187,
0.013697557151317596,
-0.18679524958133698,
-0.3588729798793793,
-0.5867565274238586,
-0.37066173553466797,
0.8879541754722595,
0.2790939509868622,
0.5097836256027222,
0.3658556640148163,
0.722740650177002,
0.3818587064743042,
-0.15584242343902588,
-0.7938300967216492,
0.46671152114868164,
-0.12689165771007538,
-0.12956759333610535,
-0.2908874750137329,
-0.6571231484413147,
-1.0061529874801636,
0.3221004903316498,
-0.32638898491859436,
-0.8024406433105469,
0.4071689248085022,
-0.12185275554656982,
-0.8213909864425659,
0.3018285632133484,
-0.6590116024017334,
0.5292205810546875,
0.2961907684803009,
0.10054029524326324,
-0.4240940511226654,
-0.6722075939178467,
0.12355867773294449,
0.05308504402637482,
0.21421095728874207,
0.07404670119285583,
0.08947896957397461,
1.0797103643417358,
-0.5300341248512268,
0.6781951189041138,
-0.2936498522758484,
0.091768279671669,
0.145677849650383,
0.2225198745727539,
0.16708514094352722,
0.21491192281246185,
0.5021722316741943,
0.13624027371406555,
0.030289150774478912,
-0.545779287815094,
-1.0371944904327393,
0.6035389304161072,
-0.7522963881492615,
-0.34966525435447693,
-0.584172248840332,
-0.8775783181190491,
-0.2939271926879883,
0.20874758064746857,
0.17584069073200226,
0.9754698276519775,
-0.5493241548538208,
0.3310476541519165,
0.7034346461296082,
-0.3799649477005005,
0.5260735154151917,
0.12136298418045044,
-0.256961852312088,
-0.7486392855644226,
1.1372638940811157,
0.07715590298175812,
0.1787193864583969,
0.4326150417327881,
0.32459381222724915,
-0.35622239112854004,
-0.5384656190872192,
-0.23177650570869446,
0.2765457034111023,
-0.5191612839698792,
-0.18080249428749084,
-1.0769927501678467,
-0.3156641125679016,
-0.617831826210022,
-0.1288253664970398,
-0.5339518189430237,
-0.9515233635902405,
-0.031531527638435364,
-0.3361857831478119,
0.07678268104791641,
1.043023705482483,
-0.2899652421474457,
0.3633381128311157,
-1.0526973009109497,
0.48534274101257324,
0.32688871026039124,
-0.047254953533411026,
-0.11391033232212067,
-0.43277230858802795,
-0.4605737030506134,
-0.05725725740194321,
-0.3036833107471466,
-0.43982994556427,
0.5345396399497986,
0.12705130875110626,
0.551240861415863,
0.7345924973487854,
0.054749276489019394,
0.5480347275733948,
-0.296590656042099,
1.1182940006256104,
0.4960983097553253,
-0.6086406111717224,
0.2852749228477478,
-0.433241069316864,
0.5097503066062927,
0.6158453226089478,
0.49115365743637085,
-0.3681979775428772,
-0.41960006952285767,
-0.7469035387039185,
-0.9506025910377502,
0.3846863806247711,
0.3921385109424591,
0.26314079761505127,
-0.15975891053676605,
-0.03895624727010727,
0.10574940592050552,
0.24741171300411224,
0.10569556802511215,
-0.2891746461391449,
-0.3403260409832001,
-0.3261408507823944,
-0.2550449073314667,
-0.6539836525917053,
-0.2612728774547577,
-0.3765161633491516,
0.3253261148929596,
-0.02464069426059723,
0.5462707877159119,
0.3163442015647888,
-0.29534682631492615,
0.14697715640068054,
-0.050581883639097214,
0.7607780694961548,
0.8307051658630371,
-0.4480345547199249,
0.32141023874282837,
0.016918739303946495,
-0.6691456437110901,
-0.19783921539783478,
-0.005414697341620922,
0.13864168524742126,
0.173395037651062,
0.6609272360801697,
0.35685229301452637,
0.3717929720878601,
-0.50801682472229,
0.8924221396446228,
-0.4559668004512787,
-0.3186679780483246,
-0.3725636303424835,
-0.33491936326026917,
-0.1197323352098465,
0.16471177339553833,
0.4487067759037018,
0.040610264986753464,
0.41396358609199524,
-0.705355703830719,
0.3342883884906769,
0.08696280419826508,
-0.3563459515571594,
-0.4296277165412903,
0.6008697152137756,
0.26362380385398865,
0.013478871434926987,
0.6426249742507935,
-0.0031901479233056307,
-0.5123893618583679,
0.2494066059589386,
0.5709240436553955,
1.0033729076385498,
0.15007643401622772,
0.3788451850414276,
0.3244449496269226,
-0.11403950303792953,
0.18649227917194366,
0.17545205354690552,
-0.3233887255191803,
-0.577553927898407,
-0.4755626618862152,
-0.5135868191719055,
-0.5204168558120728,
-0.20553413033485413,
-0.8492369055747986,
-0.2966254949569702,
-0.5575899481773376,
0.15652787685394287,
0.43360909819602966,
-0.2381737232208252,
0.07375691831111908,
-0.1701253205537796,
0.007469917647540569,
0.7738909125328064,
-0.7199617624282837,
0.39988797903060913,
0.3918555974960327,
-0.36609727144241333,
-0.3368765413761139,
0.14492636919021606,
0.27558308839797974,
-0.6430782079696655,
0.23632393777370453,
-0.12922075390815735,
-0.1497926563024521,
-0.01855223812162876,
-0.5240936279296875,
-0.7298297882080078,
1.031970500946045,
0.27764150500297546,
-0.0829455703496933,
-0.14179067313671112,
0.0393814891576767,
0.46901631355285645,
-0.39636120200157166,
0.43153607845306396,
0.7145904302597046,
0.09707693755626678,
0.07205802947282791,
-0.7010178565979004,
-0.21951518952846527,
-0.5126808881759644,
0.08809088915586472,
0.131620392203331,
-0.4421398639678955,
0.43886739015579224,
-0.1895805299282074,
-0.021749932318925858,
0.07246575504541397,
1.105645775794983,
-0.07134993374347687,
0.10727061331272125,
0.40553122758865356,
0.6730706095695496,
0.7747287154197693,
-0.035758860409259796,
1.1944429874420166,
-0.20797531306743622,
0.03088863007724285,
0.9076446890830994,
-0.12745167315006256,
0.48928555846214294,
0.2785612642765045,
0.05838378146290779,
0.5668531060218811,
0.11545665562152863,
0.4049384593963623,
0.5499255657196045,
0.014145326800644398,
-0.18412575125694275,
-0.019029000774025917,
-0.39188387989997864,
-0.06791677325963974,
0.7703111171722412,
0.35824573040008545,
-0.18801003694534302,
-0.5118381381034851,
-0.14154888689517975,
0.2950531840324402,
0.36185529828071594,
-0.20176587998867035,
1.2599741220474243,
0.1843964159488678,
-0.6515980958938599,
0.5082376003265381,
-0.2778802514076233,
0.4119405448436737,
-0.5632309317588806,
-0.31355562806129456,
-0.30297529697418213,
0.2332037091255188,
-0.2566503584384918,
-0.692996084690094,
0.3165317177772522,
0.05685467645525932,
-0.20882228016853333,
-0.3413674235343933,
0.31036055088043213,
-0.43080365657806396,
-0.29533299803733826,
0.04641951620578766,
0.724669873714447,
0.24989356100559235,
0.026061050593852997,
-0.288112610578537,
-0.4219944477081299,
-0.18958896398544312,
0.018501589074730873,
0.5016505122184753,
0.5535107254981995,
-0.09778249263763428,
0.2688405513763428,
0.8689281344413757,
0.3427163362503052,
-0.19300879538059235,
0.2896222472190857,
0.9915726780891418,
-0.6112865209579468,
-0.8194085955619812,
-0.7861040830612183,
0.2849040627479553,
-0.5402013063430786,
-0.6926360130310059,
0.8720753788948059,
0.8881440758705139,
0.36694157123565674,
0.17707914113998413,
0.6944982409477234,
0.02497517503798008,
0.5997065305709839,
-0.4053598940372467,
0.6967577338218689,
-0.3451637625694275,
-0.0456339493393898,
-0.410480260848999,
-1.134163498878479,
-0.32043278217315674,
0.3634653389453888,
-0.035453591495752335,
-0.35409772396087646,
0.9549139142036438,
0.8200439214706421,
-0.20728282630443573,
0.30488520860671997,
0.47620949149131775,
0.17037127912044525,
0.275432825088501,
0.08703776448965073,
0.8927209973335266,
-0.05606893450021744,
0.3360747992992401,
-0.17547853291034698,
-0.7145147323608398,
-0.06431032717227936,
-0.664555013179779,
-0.879916787147522,
-0.799470841884613,
-0.2847910523414612,
-0.2870467007160187,
-0.216105654835701,
1.1699281930923462,
0.5889896750450134,
-0.7685632705688477,
-0.357706755399704,
0.2481483519077301,
0.05012250691652298,
-0.3682072162628174,
-0.20673491060733795,
0.6184797286987305,
-0.23396745324134827,
-0.7002903819084167,
0.36152246594429016,
0.5380570292472839,
-0.043532729148864746,
-0.10276056081056595,
0.17521359026432037,
-0.1439124345779419,
0.329167902469635,
0.6013224720954895,
0.15397927165031433,
-0.001130241435021162,
-0.088467076420784,
-0.19623753428459167,
-0.1486036330461502,
0.06048516929149628,
1.2322907447814941,
-0.386737585067749,
0.32778483629226685,
0.7864660024642944,
0.7383941411972046,
0.5157192349433899,
0.2648725211620331,
0.878031849861145,
-0.7583129405975342,
0.30862006545066833,
0.13480032980442047,
0.5355697274208069,
0.00966993160545826,
-0.3071569800376892,
0.128487229347229,
0.27950069308280945,
-0.45972129702568054,
-0.7437429428100586,
-0.02286938950419426,
-1.1266744136810303,
-0.10863427072763443,
1.129376769065857,
-0.2824024558067322,
-0.3568713963031769,
-0.31122809648513794,
-0.37474822998046875,
0.12162643671035767,
-0.4279879331588745,
0.7019280195236206,
0.46867406368255615,
0.0579296313226223,
0.21023544669151306,
-0.35957100987434387,
0.5884310007095337,
0.530587375164032,
-0.8697770237922668,
0.3565989136695862,
0.4877467453479767,
-0.12349123507738113,
0.5325063467025757,
0.6120383739471436,
-0.6713813543319702,
0.38819068670272827,
-0.12672816216945648,
0.016103658825159073,
-0.2319481372833252,
-0.553423285484314,
-0.34129729866981506,
0.3118099868297577,
-0.26627469062805176,
-0.2988204061985016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13026v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13026v1
|
Leveraging Human Revisions for Improving Text-to-Layout Models
| 2024-05-16T01:33:09 | 2024-05-16T01:33:09 |
Amber Xie, Chin-Yi Cheng, Forrest Huang, Yang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Learning from human feedback has shown success in aligning large, pretrained
models with human values. Prior works have mostly focused on learning from
high-level labels, such as preferences between pairs of model outputs. On the
other hand, many domains could benefit from more involved, detailed feedback,
such as revisions, explanations, and reasoning of human users. Our work
proposes using nuanced feedback through the form of human revisions for
stronger alignment. In this paper, we ask expert designers to fix layouts
generated from a generative layout model that is pretrained on a large-scale
dataset of mobile screens. Then, we train a reward model based on how human
designers revise these generated layouts. With the learned reward model, we
optimize our model with reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF). Our
method, Revision-Aware Reward Models ($\method$), allows a generative
text-to-layout model to produce more modern, designer-aligned layouts, showing
the potential for utilizing human revisions and stronger forms of feedback in
improving generative models.
|
[
-0.2363526076078415,
-0.17003630101680756,
0.4684510827064514,
0.08761642128229141,
-0.1949089914560318,
0.08993390947580338,
-0.13886180520057678,
-0.2739350199699402,
0.3092603385448456,
0.6913859248161316,
-0.7185528874397278,
-0.29299458861351013,
-0.028731903061270714,
0.06763336807489395,
0.15539921820163727,
1.025368571281433,
-0.25078362226486206,
-0.23897281289100647,
-0.27438512444496155,
-0.015732746571302414,
-0.7120332717895508,
-0.42069876194000244,
-0.36301374435424805,
-0.41698676347732544,
0.8048327565193176,
0.5593443512916565,
0.7144082188606262,
0.7279898524284363,
0.34436264634132385,
0.2511318624019623,
-0.11782079190015793,
0.4440663456916809,
-0.3710785508155823,
0.11209627240896225,
-0.4617483913898468,
-0.2613781690597534,
-0.6913310289382935,
0.053476713597774506,
0.20152893662452698,
0.5168300867080688,
-0.22727036476135254,
-0.0884147509932518,
0.2451304942369461,
1.0757123231887817,
-0.708439826965332,
-0.16004548966884613,
-0.1573323905467987,
0.18968504667282104,
0.07725110650062561,
-0.42675045132637024,
-0.8743706345558167,
-0.6439881920814514,
-0.08480893075466156,
-1.0289289951324463,
0.2378128618001938,
-0.17145024240016937,
0.7682494521141052,
0.46269315481185913,
-0.5466519594192505,
-0.11416458338499069,
-0.8008882999420166,
0.6415010690689087,
-0.5308446288108826,
0.45115774869918823,
0.28519201278686523,
0.14771179854869843,
-0.3661298155784607,
-0.5985247492790222,
-0.21679626405239105,
-0.17849351465702057,
-0.01782050170004368,
0.17983508110046387,
0.37765228748321533,
-0.08975937217473984,
0.17315706610679626,
0.24287885427474976,
-0.3615022897720337,
0.11394719779491425,
-0.1649916023015976,
-0.19301283359527588,
1.1491230726242065,
0.09035145491361618,
0.46944212913513184,
-0.17147840559482574,
-0.5266203284263611,
-0.6109858751296997,
-0.8201804161071777,
0.0658632144331932,
0.3537212312221527,
0.151854008436203,
0.06919284909963608,
0.47395583987236023,
-0.20663192868232727,
0.9746155142784119,
0.3622150719165802,
-0.21104903519153595,
0.13630370795726776,
-0.3687262237071991,
-0.06316275149583817,
-0.09673133492469788,
0.45619502663612366,
0.6351839900016785,
-0.042806949466466904,
-0.3265206217765808,
-0.5564391613006592,
-0.11244554072618484,
0.7814083695411682,
-0.7659589052200317,
-0.5237485766410828,
-0.01850729249417782,
-0.6543055772781372,
-0.6148368120193481,
0.06585006415843964,
-0.7658466696739197,
-0.8987427353858948,
-0.6567333936691284,
0.5174530744552612,
-0.18424102663993835,
-0.22108016908168793,
0.1732541173696518,
-0.36616644263267517,
-0.1266280710697174,
0.8871268033981323,
-1.1439913511276245,
-0.22824643552303314,
0.5476387143135071,
0.4168950319290161,
0.05801453813910484,
-0.20887912809848785,
-0.3371463119983673,
0.28519514203071594,
-0.5409817099571228,
1.0804678201675415,
-0.15231101214885712,
-0.6309843063354492,
-0.15093538165092468,
-0.27177274227142334,
0.04965508356690407,
-0.6685579419136047,
0.713855504989624,
-0.7233651280403137,
0.4805535674095154,
-0.49153774976730347,
-0.4579932391643524,
0.1763904094696045,
0.3830958902835846,
-0.7704205513000488,
0.6601935625076294,
0.14210392534732819,
-0.984338641166687,
0.49663951992988586,
-0.5212716460227966,
-0.4584716260433197,
-0.062092021107673645,
-0.022156456485390663,
-0.7469743490219116,
0.1673014909029007,
0.4542674422264099,
0.07316149771213531,
0.25866085290908813,
0.15529920160770416,
-0.1814265102148056,
-0.2605990171432495,
0.19547522068023682,
-0.2133033722639084,
0.4412747323513031,
0.35811951756477356,
-0.19538219273090363,
0.5889625549316406,
-0.6473970413208008,
0.1706305742263794,
-0.09621111303567886,
-0.8633733987808228,
-0.27600300312042236,
0.13819678127765656,
0.293359637260437,
0.25166940689086914,
0.0366920605301857,
-0.26161712408065796,
0.7301549315452576,
-0.20001375675201416,
0.3979504406452179,
0.9450391530990601,
0.06524398922920227,
0.8804720640182495,
-0.6735914945602417,
0.5756951570510864,
-0.27985450625419617,
-0.05551154911518097,
-0.4077508747577667,
-0.10343912988901138,
-0.3593270480632782,
-0.15887567400932312,
0.6892213225364685,
0.17695406079292297,
-0.8825343251228333,
0.29213374853134155,
-0.3647196292877197,
-0.45472797751426697,
-0.24710389971733093,
0.16464218497276306,
0.4067407250404358,
0.3606255352497101,
0.2068783938884735,
-0.6819657683372498,
-0.4598153531551361,
-0.5498331189155579,
-0.4757474362850189,
-0.1293095052242279,
-0.4334857165813446,
0.18436333537101746,
0.3247223496437073,
-0.23265980184078217,
0.9515511393547058,
-0.6276201009750366,
-0.35357484221458435,
-0.10307718813419342,
0.4743199646472931,
-0.3760121166706085,
0.5504719614982605,
0.30669286847114563,
-0.8768792152404785,
-0.35295405983924866,
-0.03301010653376579,
-0.46588510274887085,
-0.08450907468795776,
-0.528772234916687,
-0.27152058482170105,
0.1528519093990326,
0.7047440409660339,
-0.520939826965332,
0.4847037196159363,
0.2602403163909912,
-0.5977072715759277,
0.5098336338996887,
-0.37992730736732483,
0.2270224392414093,
-1.3485263586044312,
-0.10780075937509537,
0.10533630847930908,
-0.3963390290737152,
-0.3610455393791199,
0.06639596819877625,
0.36547768115997314,
-0.14657536149024963,
-0.06373464316129684,
0.7103210687637329,
-0.4317900240421295,
-0.04035426303744316,
-0.40021640062332153,
0.012690362520515919,
0.40190544724464417,
0.5386426448822021,
0.23834674060344696,
0.7527449727058411,
-0.5610059499740601,
-0.5276136994361877,
0.10375344753265381,
0.44407325983047485,
-0.495778352022171,
0.823260486125946,
-0.518363893032074,
0.270714670419693,
-0.3074767589569092,
0.842365562915802,
-0.9715487360954285,
-0.67903071641922,
0.11640983074903488,
-0.5871726870536804,
0.2290261834859848,
-0.09918100386857986,
-0.43887582421302795,
-0.15410350263118744,
-0.5247594118118286,
0.2671162486076355,
0.11581328511238098,
-0.7752357125282288,
0.5857464671134949,
0.3722907304763794,
-0.18677116930484772,
-0.3534392714500427,
-0.3153178095817566,
-0.012759183533489704,
-0.1935802847146988,
-0.7284884452819824,
0.9946442246437073,
0.0272859875112772,
-0.07434943318367004,
-0.27509528398513794,
-0.12179309129714966,
0.11815907806158066,
0.19263127446174622,
0.3089480698108673,
0.3269828259944916,
0.16431882977485657,
0.3779750168323517,
-0.09867369383573532,
-0.15858210623264313,
-0.11754176020622253,
-0.3908112645149231,
0.4141671359539032,
0.36601948738098145,
-0.3106440007686615,
-0.674011766910553,
0.0178070031106472,
0.5008386969566345,
-0.4023866057395935,
0.25671979784965515,
0.39798057079315186,
-0.26855024695396423,
0.05541745573282242,
-0.4328746497631073,
-0.25616535544395447,
-0.46149030327796936,
0.38018280267715454,
-0.24791233241558075,
-0.733131468296051,
0.21649354696273804,
-0.3006957173347473,
0.45587602257728577,
0.30480945110321045,
0.5034102201461792,
-0.3947032392024994,
1.3709592819213867,
0.8063337802886963,
0.10586531460285187,
0.8018625974655151,
0.02247472293674946,
-0.14359262585639954,
-0.8937286138534546,
-0.5514118671417236,
-0.5944170355796814,
-0.6273695826530457,
-0.39383140206336975,
-0.37943947315216064,
0.12272656708955765,
0.21644827723503113,
-0.4695456326007843,
0.2686406672000885,
-0.690062940120697,
0.4459032714366913,
0.7026469111442566,
0.6453163027763367,
0.33239254355430603,
0.18903544545173645,
-0.08659037947654724,
-0.18917590379714966,
-0.4291665256023407,
-0.5486351847648621,
0.9581367373466492,
0.3455483913421631,
1.1939622163772583,
0.267963171005249,
0.8165551424026489,
0.2902204096317291,
0.7514921426773071,
-0.4629449248313904,
0.16384100914001465,
0.06274951994419098,
-0.4388591945171356,
-0.3781737685203552,
-0.5432106256484985,
-0.8639739751815796,
0.183155357837677,
-0.21659605205059052,
-0.5645583271980286,
0.31453102827072144,
0.5188992619514465,
-0.5230157375335693,
0.27198272943496704,
-0.8273758292198181,
0.9411265254020691,
-0.29750120639801025,
-0.5663620233535767,
-0.18303272128105164,
-0.5507889986038208,
0.22126780450344086,
0.154884934425354,
0.15153756737709045,
0.3799297511577606,
0.295173704624176,
0.7345798015594482,
-0.8090440034866333,
0.870860755443573,
-0.1937214583158493,
-0.5029751658439636,
0.03470645844936371,
0.12782377004623413,
0.5671113729476929,
0.17563481628894806,
0.03973616287112236,
-0.886493444442749,
-0.32085517048835754,
-0.5157194137573242,
-0.7389938831329346,
0.3963056802749634,
-0.9745913743972778,
-0.45469120144844055,
-0.08004961907863617,
-0.5356413125991821,
-0.3415195047855377,
-0.022364208474755287,
0.5826131105422974,
0.42422932386398315,
-0.2234964817762375,
0.018758559599518776,
0.8419618606567383,
-0.33943605422973633,
0.22418677806854248,
-0.045828308910131454,
-0.5607020258903503,
-0.7166827321052551,
0.6924464702606201,
-0.413504421710968,
0.17669124901294708,
0.7630100846290588,
0.012314347550272942,
-0.470841646194458,
-0.09138333052396774,
-0.8579696416854858,
-0.09626560658216476,
-0.47073182463645935,
-0.2377355396747589,
-0.31137701869010925,
-0.0006897951825521886,
-0.36009907722473145,
-0.4907791018486023,
-0.3342725932598114,
-0.6128179430961609,
-0.2220137119293213,
-0.018893029540777206,
0.08368732780218124,
0.8925847411155701,
-0.09176148474216461,
0.42201948165893555,
-0.7368260025978088,
0.30290380120277405,
0.7075895667076111,
0.400932639837265,
0.32087740302085876,
-0.6957330703735352,
-0.19378043711185455,
0.3028859496116638,
-0.9050322771072388,
-0.7983130216598511,
0.3392426371574402,
-0.3206034004688263,
0.2390345335006714,
0.19908422231674194,
0.06696250289678574,
0.5942577719688416,
-0.30926257371902466,
0.48224523663520813,
0.43564507365226746,
-0.7035710215568542,
0.5901198983192444,
-0.479591429233551,
0.5371337532997131,
0.5419524312019348,
-0.052360180765390396,
-0.8479871153831482,
0.3324950933456421,
-0.48176074028015137,
-0.6470273733139038,
0.5354810357093811,
-0.04574819281697273,
0.18224826455116272,
0.5116149187088013,
0.5930424332618713,
-0.14287208020687103,
0.12242577970027924,
-0.8021912574768066,
0.3780737817287445,
-0.47578752040863037,
-0.25282812118530273,
0.07056227326393127,
-0.14155426621437073,
-0.11559341847896576,
-0.2391699254512787,
0.6057888865470886,
-0.09859298169612885,
0.06131679564714432,
0.17753224074840546,
-0.3464125990867615,
-0.2325126826763153,
0.41832366585731506,
0.9579623341560364,
0.7521821856498718,
-0.15722011029720306,
-0.0612691231071949,
-0.2050095796585083,
-0.3036670982837677,
0.5165278315544128,
-0.0585317425429821,
-0.33196061849594116,
-0.15300625562667847,
0.2578526437282562,
0.8827693462371826,
0.20697087049484253,
-0.3906811773777008,
0.41630110144615173,
-0.23931318521499634,
-0.3385646939277649,
-0.06442591547966003,
-0.046273667365312576,
0.18088223040103912,
0.11601610481739044,
0.1715536266565323,
0.4111740291118622,
-0.19048863649368286,
-0.35563504695892334,
0.3209581673145294,
0.19413508474826813,
-0.7993146777153015,
-0.36484548449516296,
0.9775892496109009,
0.5119213461875916,
-0.6702939867973328,
0.8676825761795044,
-0.056120868772268295,
-0.5768311023712158,
0.6001351475715637,
0.4356074035167694,
0.5819437503814697,
-0.32698938250541687,
0.6483712196350098,
0.46339675784111023,
-0.1282462626695633,
-0.4085864722728729,
-0.016064681112766266,
-0.2618720531463623,
-0.5561918616294861,
-0.6398725509643555,
-0.24899256229400635,
-0.5623154640197754,
-0.15685881674289703,
-0.660674512386322,
0.40517550706863403,
-0.4344981610774994,
-0.32910147309303284,
0.049335602670907974,
-0.06617540121078491,
-0.27122610807418823,
0.31852012872695923,
0.00758725730702281,
0.8863487243652344,
-0.6222237944602966,
0.5435449481010437,
1.150750994682312,
-0.6129087209701538,
-0.9927815198898315,
0.2751012146472931,
0.04018484801054001,
-0.26562851667404175,
0.6363852620124817,
0.19663521647453308,
0.12962940335273743,
-0.11379392445087433,
-0.5264958143234253,
-0.5308890342712402,
0.9459708333015442,
0.0884670540690422,
-0.47958651185035706,
-0.3016689717769623,
-0.15662060678005219,
0.6353188753128052,
-0.0354074165225029,
0.10251552611589432,
-0.07494444400072098,
0.2742612659931183,
0.051306962966918945,
-0.614502489566803,
-0.08637648075819016,
-0.2718067467212677,
0.2497839331626892,
0.5171852707862854,
-0.49859732389450073,
0.526780903339386,
-0.44031330943107605,
-0.00744543457403779,
0.3058972954750061,
0.7774567604064941,
0.6269827485084534,
0.23783478140830994,
0.646397054195404,
0.8368067741394043,
0.7813686728477478,
0.047553014010190964,
0.9839949607849121,
0.13993258774280548,
0.32401397824287415,
1.2756145000457764,
-0.08482591807842255,
0.9044808149337769,
0.43256428837776184,
-0.01676337979733944,
0.8117802143096924,
0.8809421062469482,
0.34743189811706543,
0.8312529921531677,
0.34035637974739075,
-0.20374701917171478,
-0.34593465924263,
0.01252457220107317,
-0.4386708438396454,
-0.04020277410745621,
-0.06696714460849762,
-0.400481253862381,
-0.16953861713409424,
-0.04274459555745125,
0.07299300283193588,
0.39634770154953003,
-0.2762328088283539,
1.016499638557434,
-0.10972145199775696,
-1.076034665107727,
0.35128647089004517,
0.3156840205192566,
0.668244481086731,
-0.10102598369121552,
-0.0163995660841465,
-0.4969181418418884,
0.5209059119224548,
-0.3926418721675873,
-0.6021935343742371,
0.10551168769598007,
-0.13676516711711884,
-0.5383694767951965,
-0.5856260657310486,
0.637430727481842,
-0.36183905601501465,
-0.2562263607978821,
-0.2579020857810974,
-0.010736468248069286,
-0.5868712067604065,
-0.40633532404899597,
-0.30008918046951294,
-0.07940533012151718,
0.3423522114753723,
-0.08657823503017426,
0.6603421568870544,
0.24254727363586426,
-0.38490691781044006,
0.5061290264129639,
0.5280054807662964,
-0.23076999187469482,
-0.14404816925525665,
0.056450966745615005,
0.8008345365524292,
-0.7314833402633667,
-0.6407882571220398,
-0.6689074039459229,
0.7441357374191284,
-0.39188143610954285,
-0.3626047968864441,
0.30767086148262024,
0.6077462434768677,
1.0132372379302979,
-0.1961844116449356,
0.7936705350875854,
0.23954547941684723,
0.5830259323120117,
-0.41355636715888977,
0.6062115430831909,
-0.641735315322876,
0.33205926418304443,
-0.3899509608745575,
-0.872527539730072,
-0.1518990844488144,
0.7447307109832764,
-0.15291303396224976,
-0.022265393286943436,
0.19818420708179474,
0.7287859320640564,
-0.04795003682374954,
0.16496294736862183,
-0.17995211482048035,
-0.33446797728538513,
0.4205440878868103,
0.469828724861145,
1.0927133560180664,
-0.41749662160873413,
0.4247244894504547,
-0.4504016935825348,
-0.28713545203208923,
-0.38801124691963196,
-0.8155829310417175,
-0.5901260375976562,
-0.672797679901123,
-0.35141119360923767,
-0.6242902874946594,
0.05507470667362213,
0.8779789805412292,
0.7413680553436279,
-0.5409865379333496,
-0.23668593168258667,
-0.053104352205991745,
0.29918238520622253,
-0.2491067796945572,
-0.19687673449516296,
0.5606257319450378,
-0.18912909924983978,
-0.3601183593273163,
-0.010250739753246307,
0.06360622495412827,
0.220708429813385,
-0.03815283998847008,
-0.2457711547613144,
0.23031847178936005,
-0.16004453599452972,
0.6589165925979614,
0.3680766224861145,
-0.4519062340259552,
-0.32329660654067993,
0.03573454171419144,
-0.428008109331131,
0.20688875019550323,
1.1908247470855713,
-0.8832278847694397,
0.40332379937171936,
0.7203664183616638,
0.7876193523406982,
0.41387149691581726,
0.5657437443733215,
0.9213951230049133,
-0.8416511416435242,
-0.09570080041885376,
-0.043964870274066925,
0.19892394542694092,
0.6556496024131775,
-0.2686178684234619,
0.5423231720924377,
-0.06267368793487549,
-0.6736388206481934,
-0.7184358835220337,
0.4719599187374115,
-0.6589270234107971,
-0.3731749355792999,
0.8613644242286682,
0.00706927664577961,
0.09553400427103043,
0.09265104681253433,
-0.564507246017456,
0.23636266589164734,
-0.16984425485134125,
1.3947564363479614,
0.5719576478004456,
-0.046054381877183914,
-0.19900596141815186,
-0.06732328236103058,
0.7036230564117432,
0.6116005778312683,
-1.1506785154342651,
0.13113157451152802,
0.5553654432296753,
0.12830418348312378,
0.22106823325157166,
0.8522202968597412,
-0.26870834827423096,
0.5293671488761902,
-0.42081958055496216,
0.3287014365196228,
0.22178591787815094,
-0.2983051538467407,
-0.20780256390571594,
-0.05553818121552467,
0.40508005023002625,
-0.003373593557626009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09744v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09744v1
|
Many Hands Make Light Work: Task-Oriented Dialogue System with Module-Based Mixture-of-Experts
| 2024-05-16T01:02:09 | 2024-05-16T01:02:09 |
Ruolin Su, Biing-Hwang Juang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Task-oriented dialogue systems are broadly used in virtual assistants and
other automated services, providing interfaces between users and machines to
facilitate specific tasks. Nowadays, task-oriented dialogue systems have
greatly benefited from pre-trained language models (PLMs). However, their
task-solving performance is constrained by the inherent capacities of PLMs, and
scaling these models is expensive and complex as the model size becomes larger.
To address these challenges, we propose Soft Mixture-of-Expert Task-Oriented
Dialogue system (SMETOD) which leverages an ensemble of Mixture-of-Experts
(MoEs) to excel at subproblems and generate specialized outputs for
task-oriented dialogues. SMETOD also scales up a task-oriented dialogue system
with simplicity and flexibility while maintaining inference efficiency. We
extensively evaluate our model on three benchmark functionalities: intent
prediction, dialogue state tracking, and dialogue response generation.
Experimental results demonstrate that SMETOD achieves state-of-the-art
performance on most evaluated metrics. Moreover, comparisons against existing
strong baselines show that SMETOD has a great advantage in the cost of
inference and correctness in problem-solving.
|
[
-0.4751165807247162,
-0.6530792117118835,
0.5710062384605408,
0.07651656121015549,
-0.2896967828273773,
0.1317259520292282,
-0.2885409891605377,
-0.11124042421579361,
0.2616119384765625,
0.8689815998077393,
-0.5553136467933655,
-0.09349577873945236,
-0.6805609464645386,
0.05750203877687454,
-0.08817527443170547,
0.9728032946586609,
0.41211801767349243,
0.08912418782711029,
-0.21767009794712067,
-0.4321604371070862,
-0.3075602650642395,
-0.2856667935848236,
-0.4562497138977051,
-0.10021317005157471,
0.3053170442581177,
0.5948529243469238,
0.6773845553398132,
0.28070127964019775,
0.19022513926029205,
0.49668484926223755,
0.14278799295425415,
0.47802531719207764,
-0.14928126335144043,
0.20894795656204224,
-0.20863625407218933,
-0.5402964949607849,
-0.6876329779624939,
-0.2003125250339508,
0.05538500100374222,
0.7725131511688232,
-0.5050395727157593,
-0.14321811497211456,
0.24434028565883636,
0.22118274867534637,
-0.4250371754169464,
0.22222954034805298,
-0.6229587197303772,
-0.16501837968826294,
-0.12229850888252258,
0.009936736896634102,
-0.18120813369750977,
0.26838353276252747,
0.5243515968322754,
-0.5542168617248535,
-0.10066322982311249,
-0.005296846851706505,
0.07823334634304047,
0.48466813564300537,
-0.3605351150035858,
-0.09110638499259949,
-0.6132603883743286,
1.0633710622787476,
-1.1639816761016846,
0.04724029451608658,
-0.046224966645240784,
0.27009040117263794,
-0.20048096776008606,
-0.2961216866970062,
-0.5916478633880615,
-0.10812678188085556,
0.17337347567081451,
0.06427384167909622,
0.11474873870611191,
0.3395715057849884,
0.056538552045822144,
0.2290537804365158,
-0.24494650959968567,
-0.04595793038606644,
-0.11069772392511368,
0.12284959852695465,
0.4704760015010834,
0.23772473633289337,
0.0557895302772522,
-0.12460564076900482,
-0.25304704904556274,
0.21146023273468018,
-0.2592901587486267,
-0.17898568511009216,
0.14760877192020416,
0.44831544160842896,
0.07125014066696167,
0.3377242684364319,
-0.4090018570423126,
0.8037058115005493,
0.25460460782051086,
-0.5908998250961304,
0.17125393450260162,
-0.07070502638816833,
-0.4942890405654907,
-0.4094480276107788,
0.9827004671096802,
0.29570233821868896,
0.1618356853723526,
-0.22649361193180084,
-0.21498169004917145,
-0.24794146418571472,
0.2907669246196747,
-0.4651787579059601,
-0.13531531393527985,
0.15205135941505432,
-0.34361109137535095,
-0.15925945341587067,
-0.24152903258800507,
-0.4740930497646332,
-0.3458648920059204,
-0.45756995677948,
0.7560300230979919,
-0.45186662673950195,
-0.5213240385055542,
0.08698713779449463,
-0.020498504862189293,
-0.42121437191963196,
0.7121718525886536,
-0.7967910170555115,
0.7144990563392639,
0.6645358800888062,
0.6344244480133057,
-0.4647065997123718,
-0.17839442193508148,
-0.5934830904006958,
0.05258806794881821,
-0.0884685292840004,
0.7192323207855225,
-0.4091702997684479,
-0.5325016379356384,
-0.291598916053772,
-0.2472246289253235,
-0.17250221967697144,
-0.9068608283996582,
0.3517695963382721,
0.04221794009208679,
0.008391737937927246,
0.10790130496025085,
-0.3593169152736664,
0.10629672557115555,
0.13724403083324432,
-0.3375545144081116,
1.0528825521469116,
0.3226081132888794,
-0.6295953392982483,
0.33889299631118774,
-0.4467695653438568,
-0.39109155535697937,
0.3399888575077057,
-0.4377326965332031,
-0.02731555700302124,
0.22050157189369202,
0.09911777824163437,
0.6680501699447632,
-0.4151777923107147,
0.4391023516654968,
-0.24410967528820038,
-0.15808376669883728,
0.13984543085098267,
-0.27048027515411377,
0.6135028600692749,
0.43185561895370483,
-0.5014058947563171,
0.23600873351097107,
-0.6268404722213745,
-0.11123505979776382,
-0.29867076873779297,
-0.1730223447084427,
-0.3862518072128296,
0.13524845242500305,
-0.1359669268131256,
0.23023079335689545,
0.3517787754535675,
-0.5304473042488098,
0.20283378660678864,
-0.23339639604091644,
0.2635924816131592,
0.7657090425491333,
-0.365136057138443,
0.579064130783081,
-0.16308802366256714,
0.472095787525177,
0.358119398355484,
0.18949280679225922,
-0.09064719825983047,
-0.6541879773139954,
-1.0014511346817017,
-0.45609021186828613,
0.1374557465314865,
0.7436637282371521,
-1.3420449495315552,
0.6263858675956726,
0.04578728228807449,
-0.582584798336029,
-0.5293071866035461,
0.5251721739768982,
0.4243422746658325,
0.4548431634902954,
0.1611059010028839,
-0.6086488366127014,
-0.02410813793540001,
-1.00517737865448,
-0.28377681970596313,
-0.017992429435253143,
-0.23631654679775238,
0.7116983532905579,
0.1623554825782776,
-0.13829194009304047,
1.1019582748413086,
-0.37326380610466003,
-0.24935626983642578,
-0.496770977973938,
0.42781198024749756,
0.1661635935306549,
0.6518600583076477,
0.4306201934814453,
-0.7075055837631226,
-0.5483002066612244,
0.19943636655807495,
-0.38316160440444946,
-0.41885581612586975,
0.04579678550362587,
-0.12043682485818863,
-0.020893488079309464,
0.08586202561855316,
-0.8973438143730164,
0.07481642067432404,
0.40282300114631653,
0.03765403479337692,
0.5481792688369751,
-0.3936595916748047,
0.20220573246479034,
-1.0067487955093384,
-0.1548306792974472,
0.1133124977350235,
-0.3647458851337433,
-0.6873424649238586,
-0.19014163315296173,
-0.2050493359565735,
-0.11720036715269089,
-0.42936015129089355,
0.3060773015022278,
-0.24309378862380981,
-0.2039833962917328,
-0.4159157872200012,
-0.036659546196460724,
-0.27493444085121155,
0.9628063440322876,
0.15698321163654327,
0.6597604155540466,
0.6143406629562378,
-0.5333961248397827,
0.35237035155296326,
-0.07982639223337173,
-0.38299116492271423,
0.8604161739349365,
-0.4714001417160034,
0.19983486831188202,
0.18095803260803223,
0.09586822986602783,
-0.8560937643051147,
-0.14519087970256805,
-0.02037166990339756,
-0.15944921970367432,
0.09383450448513031,
-0.207183837890625,
-0.45499086380004883,
-0.23698869347572327,
0.04638838768005371,
0.376516193151474,
0.5055879950523376,
0.1057969480752945,
1.096366047859192,
0.4995891749858856,
-0.8807376027107239,
-0.5018563270568848,
-0.3741251528263092,
0.052848562598228455,
0.08190711587667465,
-0.668623149394989,
0.03636115416884422,
-0.12262073159217834,
-0.2839992046356201,
-0.1786004900932312,
-0.35271620750427246,
-0.302694171667099,
-0.00031239271629601717,
0.24457323551177979,
-0.04619831591844559,
-0.21048429608345032,
-0.22525082528591156,
0.32628920674324036,
-0.14149367809295654,
-0.2619463801383972,
-0.4175697863101959,
0.3324534296989441,
-0.01705954596400261,
-0.48548316955566406,
-0.3883206844329834,
0.6573371887207031,
0.9470519423484802,
-0.14844182133674622,
0.6143077611923218,
0.46734854578971863,
-0.05066802352666855,
-0.31850069761276245,
-0.9096830487251282,
-0.1353135108947754,
-0.5313288569450378,
0.3295068144798279,
-0.35330575704574585,
-0.9178164005279541,
0.29858875274658203,
-0.3353446424007416,
0.37909257411956787,
0.25195837020874023,
0.6158779263496399,
-0.0869814082980156,
1.2641947269439697,
0.6456928849220276,
0.2038680613040924,
0.5086852312088013,
-0.03535902500152588,
0.11241693049669266,
-0.6695674061775208,
-0.19670160114765167,
-0.4998561143875122,
-0.11035844683647156,
-0.36029016971588135,
-0.808921217918396,
0.606731116771698,
-0.27502965927124023,
0.15936996042728424,
0.4883616268634796,
-0.4375469386577606,
0.13856899738311768,
0.7955790758132935,
0.10184803605079651,
0.2585597634315491,
-0.33679836988449097,
-0.09446562081575394,
0.05714848265051842,
-0.9517480731010437,
-0.5906980037689209,
0.9347316026687622,
0.10403107106685638,
0.8065771460533142,
-0.04376794397830963,
0.6205462217330933,
0.3110056519508362,
0.2981792390346527,
-0.682893693447113,
0.8958508968353271,
-0.45137688517570496,
-0.3972882628440857,
-0.26349589228630066,
-0.5189954042434692,
-0.5251531004905701,
0.6443886756896973,
-0.16471734642982483,
-0.6940544247627258,
0.15890103578567505,
0.19373606145381927,
-0.6388149857521057,
0.05162585899233818,
-1.0555516481399536,
0.7805984020233154,
-0.1777999848127365,
-0.3084981143474579,
-0.4308599531650543,
-0.8162133097648621,
0.23475101590156555,
0.011057572439312935,
0.3294316530227661,
-0.17929711937904358,
0.11547856032848358,
0.9501755237579346,
-0.7718650102615356,
0.7924438714981079,
-0.357830673456192,
-0.03031124733388424,
0.345183402299881,
0.009258896112442017,
0.32392334938049316,
-0.17915844917297363,
-0.06116137653589249,
-0.3067688047885895,
-0.03507005050778389,
-0.5303856134414673,
-0.7250612378120422,
0.7410884499549866,
-0.6861953735351562,
-0.8050774931907654,
0.011075608432292938,
-0.8358314633369446,
-0.5321162343025208,
0.1729830950498581,
-0.15926232933998108,
0.7593274116516113,
0.00022962968796491623,
0.20105144381523132,
0.9110453128814697,
-0.045850783586502075,
0.14271947741508484,
0.5053877830505371,
0.1484840214252472,
-0.3109499514102936,
0.9472293257713318,
0.31247398257255554,
0.464720755815506,
0.17562702298164368,
-0.056322190910577774,
0.09092076867818832,
-0.40709835290908813,
-0.6382507085800171,
-0.09289726614952087,
-0.3003321886062622,
-0.14277948439121246,
-0.9556391835212708,
0.1921176016330719,
-0.5688840746879578,
-0.09970326721668243,
-0.4771611988544464,
-0.4939781725406647,
-0.1623658686876297,
0.017920957878232002,
-0.0290028415620327,
0.6049537658691406,
0.29040291905403137,
0.6363521814346313,
-0.8085203766822815,
0.5287847518920898,
0.7816036939620972,
0.04768848791718483,
-0.08910378068685532,
-0.1867045909166336,
-0.44873809814453125,
-0.06976798921823502,
-0.4201551079750061,
-0.7915061712265015,
0.4666122496128082,
0.05154579505324364,
0.7480498552322388,
0.6778262853622437,
0.07878273725509644,
0.4046649932861328,
-0.5270512700080872,
0.8233960866928101,
0.26427796483039856,
-0.7860879898071289,
0.15041042864322662,
-0.5003605484962463,
0.31699439883232117,
0.5745301842689514,
0.029737845063209534,
-0.10584606230258942,
-0.893600583076477,
-0.7351114749908447,
-0.6348015069961548,
0.9388146996498108,
0.216197207570076,
-0.005636797286570072,
0.1961791068315506,
-0.10121957212686539,
0.520977258682251,
0.689681887626648,
-0.21371698379516602,
-0.11575831472873688,
-0.1093459278345108,
-0.5661536455154419,
0.01304598804563284,
-0.04941008612513542,
-0.1475263237953186,
-0.10151276737451553,
0.506611168384552,
-0.318589985370636,
0.2648051679134369,
0.01938779652118683,
-0.19678963720798492,
0.0785975456237793,
0.5090452432632446,
0.5488982796669006,
0.5216825008392334,
-0.1537449061870575,
0.15583190321922302,
0.2247118353843689,
-0.1455463469028473,
0.014925245195627213,
0.04086320847272873,
0.3216893672943115,
-0.019738800823688507,
-0.009499511681497097,
0.8242066502571106,
0.4194192588329315,
-1.0212661027908325,
0.5710586309432983,
0.2174357920885086,
-0.07412274181842804,
0.22820135951042175,
0.6293143033981323,
0.041064001619815826,
0.3084731101989746,
0.813948929309845,
0.5306590795516968,
0.39115405082702637,
-0.6096312999725342,
0.08295600861310959,
0.41300421953201294,
-0.039109572768211365,
-0.18213921785354614,
0.33678266406059265,
0.8743538856506348,
-0.5699828267097473,
0.009145563468337059,
-0.1437259465456009,
-0.6151261925697327,
0.5790894031524658,
0.09877830743789673,
0.6309913992881775,
-0.35608264803886414,
0.15188392996788025,
-0.36849361658096313,
0.06019601970911026,
-0.0519789382815361,
0.2354847639799118,
-0.5959076285362244,
-0.6208162307739258,
-0.6875231862068176,
-0.3716305196285248,
-0.7568792700767517,
-0.1131773293018341,
-0.43741005659103394,
-0.07054279744625092,
-0.45403873920440674,
-0.4278290271759033,
-0.13092871010303497,
-0.021612878888845444,
-0.5018073916435242,
0.33592700958251953,
0.006136070936918259,
0.7101280689239502,
-0.8040207028388977,
0.6470701098442078,
0.6478775143623352,
0.2539825141429901,
-0.47127532958984375,
-0.30047211050987244,
-0.12355999648571014,
-0.4232233762741089,
0.35319116711616516,
0.027621757239103317,
-0.38145142793655396,
-0.0676901638507843,
-0.49366459250450134,
-0.2942931652069092,
0.7905125021934509,
0.3769488036632538,
-0.5955042839050293,
0.02989007905125618,
-0.03330545499920845,
0.47317761182785034,
-0.5126803517341614,
0.5069757103919983,
0.49454575777053833,
0.2672063708305359,
-0.06373560428619385,
-1.4817476272583008,
-0.3011326789855957,
-0.34760624170303345,
-0.16941721737384796,
0.16011476516723633,
-0.7691062688827515,
0.8803666830062866,
0.006294522434473038,
0.27067822217941284,
0.3090474307537079,
0.6888015270233154,
0.24814587831497192,
0.2936185300350189,
0.8878992199897766,
0.4538303017616272,
0.4010370969772339,
0.025549450889229774,
0.6684060096740723,
-0.19457124173641205,
0.05152632296085358,
0.9971895813941956,
-0.4403189420700073,
0.6599358320236206,
0.49890196323394775,
-0.11253435909748077,
0.5731688141822815,
0.07943863421678543,
0.4813569486141205,
0.6161664128303528,
-0.2390558421611786,
-0.5561186671257019,
-0.6839063167572021,
-0.06416597217321396,
0.0873216837644577,
0.11767856031656265,
0.6205382347106934,
-0.02262183651328087,
-0.06718400120735168,
0.32631173729896545,
-0.39856192469596863,
-0.060600023716688156,
-0.2487119883298874,
1.0542608499526978,
0.16094756126403809,
-0.9130710959434509,
0.013731954619288445,
-0.012331975623965263,
1.0487010478973389,
-0.5129092335700989,
0.0973055511713028,
0.03958793729543686,
0.10893402993679047,
-0.09839192032814026,
-0.510606586933136,
-0.11538729071617126,
0.012199909426271915,
0.045450977981090546,
-0.43011474609375,
0.7876163721084595,
-0.7643274664878845,
-0.34633776545524597,
-0.09928832948207855,
0.8250110745429993,
0.13384006917476654,
-0.04318824037909508,
-0.707237958908081,
-0.22152237594127655,
-0.06632373481988907,
-0.11890546977519989,
0.5074054598808289,
0.740127444267273,
0.05371198058128357,
0.8376433253288269,
0.34339475631713867,
0.05278847739100456,
0.1275082230567932,
-0.04153957590460777,
0.845147430896759,
-0.2057572603225708,
-0.6020496487617493,
-0.3324122428894043,
0.5812562704086304,
-0.19608017802238464,
-0.2754513621330261,
0.6258991956710815,
0.32116061449050903,
0.34929394721984863,
-0.19156572222709656,
0.7345328330993652,
-0.1559644639492035,
0.7562350630760193,
-0.23536300659179688,
0.33539900183677673,
-0.5298587083816528,
-0.06562122702598572,
-0.5902912616729736,
-0.7321770787239075,
0.18302835524082184,
0.5696831941604614,
-0.2489573210477829,
0.2129041999578476,
0.3705015778541565,
0.6728730797767639,
-0.32338231801986694,
-0.08940909802913666,
0.47208672761917114,
0.22165150940418243,
0.22290143370628357,
0.382437527179718,
0.6398207545280457,
0.07148468494415283,
0.4527938663959503,
-0.22388356924057007,
-0.37638357281684875,
-0.5578227639198303,
-0.4954058527946472,
-0.7795513868331909,
-0.5396614670753479,
-0.3824770450592041,
0.25038304924964905,
-0.08759883791208267,
1.0132181644439697,
1.0635048151016235,
-0.6130986213684082,
-0.40384766459465027,
0.0004334785044193268,
-0.030074400827288628,
-0.32683688402175903,
-0.25924333930015564,
-0.16427619755268097,
-0.2995627522468567,
-0.9978711605072021,
0.4892774820327759,
0.5614173412322998,
-0.21866409480571747,
-0.33412957191467285,
-0.1656493842601776,
0.13700518012046814,
0.40572378039360046,
0.5734035968780518,
-0.00012551620602607727,
-0.798712968826294,
0.045611266046762466,
-0.09391652047634125,
-0.18109014630317688,
-0.16152243316173553,
0.9719510078430176,
-0.8203045725822449,
0.4286338686943054,
0.45476391911506653,
0.6064538955688477,
0.3624100089073181,
0.09843515604734421,
0.8586613535881042,
-0.6650669574737549,
0.3344431221485138,
0.31443890929222107,
0.4379183351993561,
0.274203360080719,
-0.1620461642742157,
0.13649305701255798,
0.18100905418395996,
-0.5109143853187561,
-0.6567851305007935,
0.08636658638715744,
-1.287002444267273,
-0.2597395181655884,
0.8557512760162354,
-0.33200308680534363,
-0.09317537397146225,
-0.5005955696105957,
-0.7307223677635193,
0.02152041159570217,
-0.7205544710159302,
0.428657203912735,
0.5962427854537964,
-0.4172736704349518,
-0.27811452746391296,
-0.4351387023925781,
0.25613412261009216,
1.0346970558166504,
-0.798905611038208,
-0.11128484457731247,
0.4272417724132538,
0.33010295033454895,
0.34146422147750854,
0.9314702749252319,
0.4030601978302002,
0.2736809253692627,
-0.18618470430374146,
-0.1866796463727951,
0.003983112517744303,
-0.32880517840385437,
0.32672643661499023,
0.189208984375,
0.07642753422260284,
0.01736270636320114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09735v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09735v2
|
An Analysis of Sentential Neighbors in Implicit Discourse Relation Prediction
| 2024-05-16T00:06:36 | 2024-05-17T02:24:49 |
Evi Judge, Reece Suchocki, Konner Syed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Discourse relation classification is an especially difficult task without
explicit context markers (Prasad et al., 2008). Current approaches to implicit
relation prediction solely rely on two neighboring sentences being targeted,
ignoring the broader context of their surrounding environments (Atwell et al.,
2021). In this research, we propose three new methods in which to incorporate
context in the task of sentence relation prediction: (1) Direct Neighbors
(DNs), (2) Expanded Window Neighbors (EWNs), and (3) Part-Smart Random
Neighbors (PSRNs). Our findings indicate that the inclusion of context beyond
one discourse unit is harmful in the task of discourse relation classification.
|
[
-0.41170990467071533,
-0.743744432926178,
1.1232644319534302,
0.1369973123073578,
-0.07162383198738098,
-0.2947820723056793,
0.10539263486862183,
-0.7664542198181152,
-0.026656316593289375,
0.49870797991752625,
-0.6335029006004333,
-0.2786845862865448,
-0.5796374678611755,
0.0031794116366654634,
-0.0172415804117918,
0.9927620887756348,
0.30300378799438477,
0.029123110696673393,
-0.39778226613998413,
-0.13830307126045227,
-0.3681015968322754,
-0.8074425458908081,
-0.37885648012161255,
-0.05592901259660721,
0.5409348011016846,
0.2795100808143616,
0.6208062171936035,
0.3806726932525635,
0.32129374146461487,
0.4647975564002991,
-0.35967373847961426,
-0.031862664967775345,
-0.2733587324619293,
0.6019650101661682,
-0.06929735839366913,
-0.32174861431121826,
-0.47220683097839355,
0.1804758608341217,
0.529723584651947,
0.9831660985946655,
0.42598533630371094,
0.07367590069770813,
-0.02967708371579647,
0.536176323890686,
-0.6163510084152222,
0.3063504993915558,
-0.6482229232788086,
0.46417880058288574,
-0.32902050018310547,
-0.19405187666416168,
-0.47177237272262573,
-0.5748661756515503,
0.6713995337486267,
-0.314450204372406,
0.18540476262569427,
0.47118332982063293,
0.6350710988044739,
0.27261871099472046,
-0.8705222010612488,
0.0011819041101261973,
-0.6563912034034729,
0.5530606508255005,
-0.278430312871933,
0.1947772353887558,
0.33938121795654297,
0.239742711186409,
-0.4272238314151764,
-0.6222183704376221,
-0.3568167984485626,
-0.10064090043306351,
-0.7340172529220581,
0.2309250831604004,
-0.2131035029888153,
0.4064384698867798,
0.543499767780304,
0.2443585991859436,
-0.11186059564352036,
-0.3065448999404907,
-0.45073822140693665,
-0.09179171919822693,
0.323271781206131,
0.2684890329837799,
0.14346256852149963,
-0.5240189433097839,
-0.49390894174575806,
0.5765975117683411,
-0.6190056800842285,
0.0021965820342302322,
0.21489408612251282,
0.34196236729621887,
0.11938437819480896,
0.28945809602737427,
0.04353172332048416,
0.723412036895752,
0.20923122763633728,
-0.0600724071264267,
0.17303632199764252,
-0.3267853558063507,
0.041185248643159866,
0.3234075903892517,
0.8230119943618774,
0.3840959966182709,
0.47729963064193726,
-0.0964609831571579,
0.3002185821533203,
-0.26257359981536865,
-0.0358852781355381,
-0.7613814473152161,
0.034787196666002274,
-0.0688067153096199,
-0.4732760190963745,
-0.24231845140457153,
0.14439065754413605,
-0.7006494402885437,
-0.18464531004428864,
-0.2554114758968353,
-0.2555459439754486,
-0.3204895257949829,
-0.23041775822639465,
-0.7040801644325256,
-0.11057641357183456,
-0.08637725561857224,
0.26966726779937744,
-0.5228079557418823,
0.7271236181259155,
0.8263201117515564,
0.8381087779998779,
-0.11642944067716599,
-0.6160095930099487,
-0.6203233599662781,
0.36990445852279663,
-0.013290436007082462,
0.810998797416687,
-0.8281862139701843,
-0.3778567910194397,
0.048238370567560196,
0.06681929528713226,
-0.08667009323835373,
-0.01908598653972149,
0.4561370313167572,
-0.444016695022583,
0.6538439989089966,
-0.48800408840179443,
-0.4859103560447693,
-0.3356809914112091,
0.025487730279564857,
-0.6332244873046875,
0.9921925067901611,
0.2576395273208618,
-1.360163688659668,
0.18110963702201843,
-0.25104019045829773,
-0.6454430818557739,
-0.09648017585277557,
-0.10281440615653992,
-0.32156944274902344,
0.15795639157295227,
0.12094977498054504,
0.878650426864624,
0.15173906087875366,
0.4054415225982666,
-0.3920174241065979,
-0.573546290397644,
0.35166239738464355,
-0.15289965271949768,
0.7628153562545776,
0.08087088167667389,
-0.21817369759082794,
0.19187629222869873,
-0.7163366675376892,
-0.17485199868679047,
-0.4036298394203186,
0.2635015547275543,
-0.8440214395523071,
0.012658122926950455,
-0.35433489084243774,
0.25570446252822876,
-0.0069925482384860516,
-0.6476215124130249,
-0.11750844866037369,
-0.6069583296775818,
0.17016112804412842,
0.9481158256530762,
0.3337828814983368,
0.8129090666770935,
-0.05474799871444702,
0.5853422284126282,
0.11395630985498428,
-0.17833125591278076,
-0.12038270384073257,
-0.7033576965332031,
-0.40032875537872314,
0.04930190369486809,
0.2625297009944916,
0.29938939213752747,
-0.7511525750160217,
0.14293627440929413,
-0.535301923751831,
-0.3167033791542053,
0.0337371751666069,
-0.5467625260353088,
0.665195643901825,
0.6069051027297974,
0.24115540087223053,
0.34523922204971313,
-0.8563979268074036,
-0.8841409087181091,
-0.13621735572814941,
-0.4566359519958496,
0.09080774337053299,
0.5322038531303406,
0.4861735999584198,
0.15870711207389832,
1.1229921579360962,
-1.0621157884597778,
-0.2834416329860687,
0.11557812988758087,
-0.063156858086586,
-0.0663507953286171,
0.24732649326324463,
0.7509462833404541,
-0.6420671939849854,
-0.6574354767799377,
-0.17138320207595825,
-0.5883191823959351,
0.10073494911193848,
0.3271353840827942,
-0.11263080686330795,
0.020403016358613968,
0.65129554271698,
-0.2972366213798523,
0.5542998313903809,
0.6107498407363892,
-0.5514513850212097,
0.6241914629936218,
0.0938103124499321,
-0.0731639489531517,
-1.120031714439392,
-0.3745802044868469,
0.13309648633003235,
-0.4413098394870758,
-0.7702315449714661,
-0.04918951168656349,
-0.23931856453418732,
-0.0455864854156971,
-0.47059375047683716,
0.4864877760410309,
-0.4833153188228607,
-0.2748066186904907,
-0.05228617787361145,
0.0005286867963150144,
-0.25124216079711914,
0.6323493719100952,
0.3813399374485016,
0.8839603662490845,
0.32073256373405457,
-0.645993173122406,
0.2438633292913437,
0.1316346526145935,
-0.01891474425792694,
0.6529887914657593,
-0.5387386083602905,
0.21120058000087738,
-0.29573360085487366,
0.6389671564102173,
-0.8357923626899719,
-0.0024596748407930136,
0.33241426944732666,
-0.5662246346473694,
0.09342776983976364,
-0.09061330556869507,
-0.2582865357398987,
-0.323518842458725,
-0.38540568947792053,
0.6108376383781433,
0.17862877249717712,
-0.5107361674308777,
0.5399723649024963,
0.41727450489997864,
-0.3082978129386902,
-0.549270749092102,
-0.7241449356079102,
-0.12127712368965149,
-0.3943346440792084,
-0.5026490688323975,
0.5790265798568726,
0.31734710931777954,
-0.6040440201759338,
0.3500513732433319,
0.18333137035369873,
-0.37118497490882874,
-0.08533045649528503,
0.8475441336631775,
0.009492377750575542,
0.02162991836667061,
0.20813675224781036,
0.09284073114395142,
-0.23048518598079681,
0.2795711159706116,
0.21014708280563354,
-0.08636584132909775,
-0.25331854820251465,
0.16727669537067413,
-0.06634168326854706,
0.5348721742630005,
0.6012681126594543,
0.05785168334841728,
0.7605201005935669,
0.26148122549057007,
-0.4161205291748047,
-0.01735716313123703,
-0.45867669582366943,
-0.11135739833116531,
-0.4700313210487366,
0.45290103554725647,
-0.6824471950531006,
-1.0282827615737915,
0.5428228974342346,
-0.12828588485717773,
-0.39017006754875183,
0.049447860568761826,
-0.06803005933761597,
0.08284679800271988,
0.7488391399383545,
0.7852715849876404,
-0.21964481472969055,
0.20977932214736938,
0.26248279213905334,
0.28833216428756714,
-1.3226341009140015,
-0.26980626583099365,
-0.5302123427391052,
-0.08734182268381119,
-0.9676526188850403,
-0.2580467462539673,
0.3848499357700348,
-0.3742014169692993,
-0.27773401141166687,
0.6757529377937317,
-0.5466529130935669,
0.34337007999420166,
0.48106247186660767,
0.17985394597053528,
0.41069838404655457,
0.021699244156479836,
-0.3085494339466095,
-0.7387852072715759,
-0.5562446713447571,
-0.20651766657829285,
0.7181243896484375,
0.5041772723197937,
0.004063964355736971,
0.10267914086580276,
0.6122394800186157,
-0.0873754546046257,
0.4510689675807953,
-0.848564624786377,
0.790350079536438,
0.04570106044411659,
-0.6128829121589661,
-0.3798365890979767,
-0.49045035243034363,
-1.0635390281677246,
0.49728015065193176,
0.11972896009683609,
-0.9923816919326782,
0.19662033021450043,
-0.4551698863506317,
-0.3894253969192505,
0.22031688690185547,
-0.25758597254753113,
0.24850399792194366,
0.07382761687040329,
-0.4380413293838501,
0.23614898324012756,
-0.7788072228431702,
0.4228142499923706,
0.21955086290836334,
0.35103845596313477,
-0.12499953806400299,
0.007508821319788694,
0.7879295349121094,
-0.5655573010444641,
0.6347745060920715,
-0.27334800362586975,
0.09263099730014801,
0.3060063123703003,
0.10159517079591751,
0.46654781699180603,
-0.0727665051817894,
-0.4177347719669342,
-0.05389827862381935,
-0.24030989408493042,
-0.0790926143527031,
-0.5660009384155273,
0.8801096677780151,
-0.4501541554927826,
-0.5783466100692749,
-0.985132098197937,
-0.4692670702934265,
-0.3633938133716583,
0.1250188648700714,
0.33312058448791504,
0.2324785590171814,
-0.3915475308895111,
-0.07640612125396729,
0.5123527646064758,
0.07954562455415726,
0.49257466197013855,
0.5418593883514404,
-0.11357080936431885,
-0.38591310381889343,
0.616547167301178,
0.24583181738853455,
-0.2647613286972046,
0.20098833739757538,
0.2896730601787567,
-0.21007971465587616,
-0.4141443073749542,
0.05686962231993675,
0.11899174004793167,
-0.6173973679542542,
-0.224374458193779,
-0.8312468528747559,
-0.3274214565753937,
-0.4451119899749756,
-0.1857423335313797,
-0.09594147652387619,
-0.24308915436267853,
-0.23752461373806,
-0.5057792663574219,
0.37167203426361084,
0.8537521958351135,
0.23171475529670715,
0.17669367790222168,
-0.6450133323669434,
-0.10588832199573517,
0.4431709051132202,
0.25421443581581116,
0.07978568971157074,
-0.2900627553462982,
0.2955435812473297,
-0.2506377398967743,
-0.03154053911566734,
-1.1940562725067139,
0.20832982659339905,
-0.0006096659344621003,
0.3715434670448303,
0.4975558817386627,
0.2510271668434143,
0.901513934135437,
-0.9820382595062256,
0.7850294709205627,
0.1497081220149994,
-0.7861101031303406,
0.7391220331192017,
-0.46629083156585693,
0.20592276751995087,
0.8019571304321289,
0.6166945695877075,
-0.24516257643699646,
-0.42341184616088867,
-0.7627604603767395,
-0.7268911004066467,
0.6496744155883789,
0.3955253064632416,
0.23975515365600586,
-0.17847229540348053,
0.48206692934036255,
0.007906491868197918,
0.2443956732749939,
-1.0518286228179932,
-0.5938550233840942,
0.2617809772491455,
0.1267840564250946,
0.18646639585494995,
-0.5484591722488403,
0.23621614277362823,
-0.774759829044342,
0.45026275515556335,
0.0794576108455658,
0.34382688999176025,
0.3247818946838379,
0.20743021368980408,
-0.26821282505989075,
0.010465233586728573,
0.4100729525089264,
0.6113854646682739,
-0.37136515974998474,
0.2590808868408203,
0.40634503960609436,
-0.2728935778141022,
0.3373469412326813,
0.14980627596378326,
-0.4719747304916382,
0.3902782201766968,
0.46042895317077637,
0.6797414422035217,
0.4793831706047058,
0.1910983771085739,
0.7567081451416016,
-0.1495368331670761,
-0.1775921732187271,
-0.7195420265197754,
-0.35124096274375916,
0.08995573222637177,
-0.022143643349409103,
0.28933489322662354,
0.1162867546081543,
0.5223459601402283,
-0.8037300109863281,
0.2630050480365753,
0.28712883591651917,
-0.9567201137542725,
-0.3901243805885315,
0.4256088435649872,
0.4363095462322235,
-0.1472153216600418,
0.4279192388057709,
-0.5676690340042114,
-1.2978460788726807,
0.4753585457801819,
0.4991409480571747,
0.8807817697525024,
-0.44374561309814453,
0.11898445338010788,
0.7326479554176331,
0.06404674798250198,
0.12197083234786987,
-0.13676278293132782,
-0.010783598758280277,
-0.6089142560958862,
-0.5920286774635315,
-0.37287312746047974,
-0.35284048318862915,
0.054953478276729584,
-0.683240532875061,
0.0878196656703949,
-0.4020678997039795,
-0.16269451379776,
-0.07567457854747772,
0.20529057085514069,
-0.3288505971431732,
0.14032162725925446,
0.2094969004392624,
0.36990880966186523,
-0.7197850942611694,
0.6946684122085571,
0.7591015100479126,
0.21525287628173828,
-0.6161583065986633,
0.2928362786769867,
0.10697904229164124,
-0.09707649052143097,
0.8925790190696716,
0.4469054937362671,
-0.44460901618003845,
-0.283001184463501,
-0.27542558312416077,
-1.0028868913650513,
0.7779751420021057,
-0.016202855855226517,
-0.534184992313385,
-0.03349741920828819,
-0.0834914818406105,
0.5665948987007141,
-0.41361838579177856,
0.4201451241970062,
0.5375363230705261,
0.5693248510360718,
0.08450450748205185,
-0.7906171083450317,
0.7387118339538574,
-0.11572082340717316,
0.23847469687461853,
0.3508065342903137,
-0.6986690163612366,
0.8234487175941467,
-0.12802305817604065,
-0.1572403758764267,
0.06510607153177261,
1.0900373458862305,
0.11631209403276443,
0.5643481612205505,
0.5199605226516724,
0.2918274998664856,
0.7195053100585938,
-0.24244707822799683,
0.8322648406028748,
-0.05373520776629448,
0.08270283043384552,
1.728305459022522,
-0.4532739520072937,
0.7444363236427307,
0.43263888359069824,
-0.48976272344589233,
0.991697371006012,
0.4566195607185364,
-0.035462506115436554,
0.6946142315864563,
0.33420559763908386,
-0.2901727259159088,
0.36564481258392334,
-0.29744821786880493,
-0.6606407761573792,
0.5204471349716187,
0.5053868889808655,
-0.37234625220298767,
0.06645043939352036,
-0.11288101226091385,
0.30391794443130493,
0.45099958777427673,
-0.21117480099201202,
0.8244504928588867,
0.190589040517807,
-1.0132085084915161,
-0.22798217833042145,
-0.14148452877998352,
0.8075255155563354,
-0.12252342700958252,
-0.051947515457868576,
0.049871452152729034,
-0.011254888027906418,
-0.35165518522262573,
-0.7922975420951843,
0.5664188265800476,
-0.36372312903404236,
-0.17900346219539642,
0.024110151454806328,
1.1634759902954102,
-0.38083893060684204,
-0.41138574481010437,
0.5109592080116272,
0.5855206251144409,
-0.03082830272614956,
-0.1908787041902542,
-0.42097029089927673,
-0.4192409813404083,
-0.06099109351634979,
-0.3880818486213684,
0.3470405638217926,
0.7235651612281799,
0.05713224038481712,
0.43819278478622437,
0.38433265686035156,
0.07477539032697678,
-0.2693728506565094,
-0.25274649262428284,
0.9282993674278259,
-0.6390969753265381,
-0.5144832730293274,
-0.8581039309501648,
0.1387455314397812,
-0.4364633858203888,
-0.33468690514564514,
1.2048875093460083,
0.369000107049942,
0.43350398540496826,
0.19513098895549774,
0.623241662979126,
0.13404294848442078,
0.6296557784080505,
-0.22322991490364075,
0.1922043412923813,
0.04014228656888008,
0.07381944358348846,
-0.6562339663505554,
-1.3182071447372437,
-0.2136547863483429,
0.6393390893936157,
-0.7246200442314148,
0.0841793566942215,
1.227763056755066,
0.30788788199424744,
0.07176154851913452,
0.15818621218204498,
0.12165667116641998,
0.12900786101818085,
-0.18257229030132294,
0.5983739495277405,
1.0461620092391968,
-0.3729068338871002,
0.4724281430244446,
-0.7976033091545105,
-0.028305508196353912,
-0.04112226516008377,
-1.0118255615234375,
-1.120110273361206,
-0.5867892503738403,
-0.502024233341217,
-0.514631986618042,
0.16737712919712067,
0.560591995716095,
0.7631970047950745,
-0.749175488948822,
0.11588454991579056,
-0.29409322142601013,
0.2726640999317169,
-0.03576575964689255,
-0.3193396329879761,
0.41704168915748596,
0.08893953263759613,
-0.9001405239105225,
0.2816314399242401,
0.11441744118928909,
0.19762878119945526,
-0.19354650378227234,
-0.008212495595216751,
-0.2635806202888489,
-0.223537415266037,
0.7398869395256042,
-0.08035449683666229,
-0.5575752854347229,
-0.4764944911003113,
-0.2587558627128601,
-0.051317885518074036,
-0.19101770222187042,
0.829685389995575,
-0.8998743891716003,
0.13970306515693665,
0.5773248076438904,
-0.05018588900566101,
0.35662662982940674,
0.4203798472881317,
0.8103180527687073,
-1.255990982055664,
0.6123687624931335,
0.4446507394313812,
0.4072277545928955,
0.16652843356132507,
-0.7810457348823547,
0.7672578692436218,
-0.0443308986723423,
-0.533296525478363,
-0.7991153597831726,
0.4228138029575348,
-0.4899086654186249,
-0.6834275722503662,
1.272229790687561,
-0.48905181884765625,
-0.3451620042324066,
-0.42614027857780457,
-0.2223508656024933,
-0.013645471073687077,
-0.5383501648902893,
0.23767781257629395,
0.6292470693588257,
-0.16749416291713715,
0.015796009451150894,
-0.5677989721298218,
0.6754124164581299,
0.4936857223510742,
-0.4327830374240875,
-0.2243257761001587,
0.6015000939369202,
-0.0033248283434659243,
0.344529926776886,
0.7265350222587585,
0.1711399257183075,
0.09311515092849731,
-0.05852961540222168,
-0.5388387441635132,
-0.2628437280654907,
-0.41107404232025146,
0.04615406692028046,
0.4144444167613983,
-0.21085429191589355,
-0.09401631355285645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09733v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09733v2
|
SCI 3.0: A Web-based Schema Curation Interface for Graphical Event Representations
| 2024-05-15T23:52:19 | 2024-05-17T02:29:06 |
Reece Suchocki, Mary Martin, Martha Palmer, Susan Brown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To understand the complexity of global events, one must navigate a web of
interwoven sub-events, identifying those most impactful elements within the
larger, abstract macro-event framework at play. This concept can be extended to
the field of natural language processing (NLP) through the creation of
structured event schemas which can serve as representations of these abstract
events. Central to our approach is the Schema Curation Interface 3.0 (SCI 3.0),
a web application that facilitates real-time editing of event schema properties
within a generated graph e.g., adding, removing, or editing sub-events,
entities, and relations directly through an interface.
|
[
-0.3908376097679138,
-0.6889599561691284,
0.7084232568740845,
0.3700312077999115,
0.002472597872838378,
0.21023115515708923,
0.04512032866477966,
-0.9960687160491943,
0.5003258585929871,
0.16279001533985138,
-0.7487183213233948,
-0.6144105792045593,
-0.23757946491241455,
0.19145746529102325,
-0.38226956129074097,
0.969889760017395,
-0.15148292481899261,
0.054995592683553696,
-0.5206694006919861,
0.19068345427513123,
0.14845290780067444,
-0.3524114191532135,
-0.9073728919029236,
-0.5117051601409912,
0.696399986743927,
0.48725634813308716,
0.7412729263305664,
0.5911707878112793,
0.9294747710227966,
0.15215304493904114,
-0.09430410712957382,
0.04243035987019539,
-0.4202631115913391,
0.12643742561340332,
-0.5412799715995789,
-0.3926692008972168,
-0.7556713223457336,
0.292024165391922,
0.42581480741500854,
1.1285510063171387,
-0.07284528762102127,
0.14431220293045044,
-0.11952489614486694,
0.3697221577167511,
-0.8903394341468811,
0.534697949886322,
-0.2530384659767151,
0.4583890438079834,
-0.45180949568748474,
-0.35340726375579834,
-0.3619678020477295,
-0.5010637640953064,
0.12968586385250092,
-1.079017162322998,
0.5067951679229736,
-0.023663297295570374,
0.7527536749839783,
-0.21263347566127777,
-0.21700410544872284,
-0.17118924856185913,
-0.8038082122802734,
0.5981988906860352,
-0.34656035900115967,
0.26786771416664124,
0.4281034767627716,
0.30767372250556946,
-0.4426123797893524,
-1.071256399154663,
-0.7774595618247986,
0.2536497712135315,
-0.15740670263767242,
-0.04015683755278587,
-0.3775791823863983,
0.17143838107585907,
0.42210444808006287,
0.23274795711040497,
-0.5302709341049194,
0.29932430386543274,
-0.602712094783783,
-0.2407515048980713,
0.6363195776939392,
0.4869392514228821,
0.4213966727256775,
-0.2980167269706726,
0.17639221251010895,
0.3543477952480316,
-0.9677917957305908,
-0.43024492263793945,
0.32334932684898376,
0.13533444702625275,
0.02468053437769413,
0.6446793675422668,
-0.44509273767471313,
0.6491716504096985,
-0.3731587827205658,
-0.08953721076250076,
0.13083530962467194,
-0.4150013029575348,
0.09053515642881393,
0.042969826608896255,
0.970022976398468,
0.6026726365089417,
-0.15901227295398712,
0.027522841468453407,
0.4254963994026184,
0.19092512130737305,
-0.10745469480752945,
-0.6393017768859863,
-0.1608368456363678,
0.480671763420105,
-0.5874108672142029,
-0.4483673870563507,
-0.06500288099050522,
-0.6620576977729797,
-0.5196088552474976,
-0.1756003051996231,
-0.015355783514678478,
-0.46607884764671326,
-0.03782310336828232,
-0.0675005316734314,
-0.4884396195411682,
0.19627918303012848,
0.6284279227256775,
-0.9920511245727539,
0.4896642565727234,
0.7195906639099121,
1.1437352895736694,
-0.3204408586025238,
-0.2152145653963089,
-0.35911303758621216,
0.7525531053543091,
-0.12568502128124237,
0.9393805265426636,
-0.38778865337371826,
-0.6499594449996948,
-0.2579893171787262,
-0.1507376730442047,
0.42904913425445557,
-0.009832825511693954,
0.29675254225730896,
-0.5696906447410583,
0.2465878427028656,
0.022633548825979233,
-0.6209475994110107,
0.05115434154868126,
-0.16446882486343384,
-0.9576159119606018,
1.0999244451522827,
0.30830252170562744,
-0.8545348048210144,
0.4196082055568695,
-1.2292159795761108,
-0.4833908677101135,
0.5076214671134949,
-0.10619741678237915,
0.030355410650372505,
-0.18754832446575165,
0.05641693249344826,
0.43408405780792236,
-0.11764178425073624,
0.05974697694182396,
-0.671725332736969,
-0.5675555467605591,
-0.2568593919277191,
0.2864421010017395,
0.8395975828170776,
0.33530762791633606,
-0.1173466295003891,
0.21119511127471924,
-1.1177895069122314,
-0.24590125679969788,
0.038196366280317307,
-0.0802939385175705,
-0.2017456591129303,
0.4883671998977661,
-0.10941005498170853,
0.17570291459560394,
0.38503074645996094,
-0.7175763249397278,
0.6884303689002991,
-0.5902804732322693,
0.7140243053436279,
0.47865262627601624,
0.002047928050160408,
0.8213695883750916,
0.13460774719715118,
0.332316130399704,
-0.13749006390571594,
0.3605690598487854,
-0.07562969624996185,
-0.7898738980293274,
-0.6594445705413818,
0.00040822126902639866,
0.06903033703565598,
0.6654358506202698,
-0.6685642004013062,
0.12534604966640472,
-0.4563170373439789,
-0.8251604437828064,
-0.1385352611541748,
-0.022285187616944313,
-0.1342673897743225,
0.3032631576061249,
0.4950043857097626,
0.14403268694877625,
-1.1319315433502197,
-1.0057467222213745,
-0.15211254358291626,
-0.18098288774490356,
-0.5054084658622742,
-0.13159024715423584,
0.7208648324012756,
-0.4436275064945221,
1.1197985410690308,
-0.7898243069648743,
-0.20739057660102844,
-0.3406231105327606,
0.7194939851760864,
0.12446326017379761,
0.31391915678977966,
0.394599974155426,
-0.42788976430892944,
-0.32074862718582153,
0.20750613510608673,
-0.9997767210006714,
-0.2994891405105591,
0.23646222054958344,
0.10420001298189163,
0.39028847217559814,
0.7489956021308899,
-0.6287714242935181,
0.7568759918212891,
0.2806214392185211,
-0.3457992672920227,
0.5679362416267395,
0.08945847302675247,
-0.06698998808860779,
-0.8086098432540894,
0.11698389798402786,
-0.21836774051189423,
-0.07848417013883591,
-0.7378613352775574,
0.17870642244815826,
0.13142594695091248,
-0.10159418731927872,
-0.7311913967132568,
0.6876851320266724,
-0.3887771964073181,
-0.37635910511016846,
0.023507513105869293,
0.5122201442718506,
0.36219170689582825,
0.19415400922298431,
0.26327967643737793,
0.4780119061470032,
0.3761061728000641,
-0.7696803212165833,
0.7072818279266357,
0.26630479097366333,
-0.3575051426887512,
0.8319876194000244,
-0.4697367548942566,
-0.07386107742786407,
0.06767594069242477,
0.589247465133667,
-0.19339965283870697,
-0.7003474235534668,
0.315733939409256,
-0.21592828631401062,
-0.18895076215267181,
0.06734371930360794,
-0.43097686767578125,
-0.7055894732475281,
-0.32484912872314453,
0.14173291623592377,
-0.17437343299388885,
-0.31025537848472595,
0.9715568423271179,
0.3739798963069916,
-0.3958655595779419,
-0.3367113173007965,
-0.6936635971069336,
0.2687663435935974,
0.2685612440109253,
-0.6881200671195984,
0.5362244844436646,
0.20847757160663605,
-0.5231414437294006,
0.18219320476055145,
0.18534070253372192,
0.08024465292692184,
0.02508438006043434,
0.5505498051643372,
0.41104257106781006,
-0.0868111401796341,
-0.1688929945230484,
0.009981785900890827,
-0.16081446409225464,
0.1465512067079544,
-0.07314101606607437,
0.41179198026657104,
-0.25195759534835815,
-0.5131788849830627,
-0.9051825404167175,
0.7597070336341858,
0.4994719326496124,
0.2074853628873825,
0.6001361012458801,
0.536895751953125,
-0.6574782729148865,
0.2709597647190094,
-0.3141421377658844,
0.07160326838493347,
-0.4444506764411926,
0.30504804849624634,
-0.43271487951278687,
-1.029325008392334,
0.7887718677520752,
0.20355857908725739,
-0.11102337390184402,
0.867577075958252,
0.24322599172592163,
-0.35695764422416687,
1.5401883125305176,
0.5020723342895508,
0.3273026943206787,
0.2830018401145935,
-0.258574903011322,
0.5007666945457458,
-0.9782688617706299,
-0.6236760020256042,
-0.6482783555984497,
-0.15764877200126648,
-0.34168732166290283,
-0.5181778073310852,
0.21455064415931702,
0.12165530771017075,
-0.3936587870121002,
0.23060569167137146,
-0.4366114139556885,
0.5398210883140564,
0.8135196566581726,
-0.1132584810256958,
0.5148810148239136,
-0.3443397581577301,
0.3563089966773987,
-0.057701509445905685,
-0.6641078591346741,
-0.6082861423492432,
0.8526066541671753,
0.1875237226486206,
0.6992682218551636,
0.03247659280896187,
0.4676690995693207,
0.30966752767562866,
0.44736987352371216,
-0.5915197134017944,
0.7730481028556824,
0.3542882204055786,
-0.5532557964324951,
-0.33144474029541016,
-0.2540266513824463,
-0.7487626075744629,
-0.17756684124469757,
-0.524489164352417,
-1.0698246955871582,
0.44690558314323425,
0.033333055675029755,
-0.305673748254776,
0.5767180919647217,
-0.5310860872268677,
0.6741986274719238,
0.11323580890893936,
-0.4484942853450775,
-0.32961222529411316,
-0.5734450221061707,
0.2614636719226837,
0.23040467500686646,
0.6353583931922913,
-0.16595442593097687,
0.1216815635561943,
0.8793191909790039,
-0.2800111770629883,
0.628644585609436,
0.03417627885937691,
0.023550184443593025,
0.21757733821868896,
0.5923082232475281,
0.6776829957962036,
0.24392220377922058,
-0.15212620794773102,
0.39734694361686707,
0.27670636773109436,
-0.32009023427963257,
-0.6801623702049255,
0.8910272121429443,
-0.6831439733505249,
-0.5057845115661621,
-0.6043206453323364,
-0.45792055130004883,
-0.1820814311504364,
0.3620213270187378,
0.1633993536233902,
0.1495053917169571,
-0.4588196277618408,
0.09051276743412018,
0.3452288508415222,
-0.1281353235244751,
0.47514551877975464,
0.5793752670288086,
-0.512730598449707,
-0.19660621881484985,
0.9589266180992126,
0.045453108847141266,
0.08834066241979599,
0.4277189373970032,
-0.09101559966802597,
-0.06228656321763992,
-0.4631250500679016,
-0.08957996219396591,
-0.09040684998035431,
-0.9221809506416321,
-0.40532630681991577,
-1.02449369430542,
-0.2922324538230896,
-0.749082088470459,
-0.7339353561401367,
0.03615109995007515,
-0.9994959831237793,
-0.7432892918586731,
-0.33981817960739136,
0.42155921459198,
1.1716455221176147,
-0.6392837166786194,
0.5577337741851807,
-0.6582322716712952,
0.45923200249671936,
0.23650826513767242,
0.8418862223625183,
-0.41487497091293335,
0.17176850140094757,
-0.32713401317596436,
-0.0455620251595974,
-0.3084644079208374,
-1.00040602684021,
0.1778479367494583,
0.3473440110683441,
0.31333816051483154,
0.5375077724456787,
-0.6141502261161804,
0.6245648860931396,
-0.37149661779403687,
1.304858922958374,
0.21609410643577576,
-1.1411014795303345,
1.1708202362060547,
-0.7639464139938354,
0.21376752853393555,
0.11142247915267944,
0.5466833710670471,
-0.6280247569084167,
-0.5397282838821411,
-0.9578980803489685,
-1.0153065919876099,
1.0831375122070312,
0.08541975915431976,
-0.35668155550956726,
-0.2560323476791382,
0.37650156021118164,
0.009755668230354786,
-0.07781364023685455,
-0.7328657507896423,
-0.30766761302948,
-0.5694741606712341,
0.08149228990077972,
0.2338477075099945,
-0.49160993099212646,
-0.2405739724636078,
-0.24294887483119965,
0.7653103470802307,
-0.21274523437023163,
0.013525456190109253,
0.08027360588312149,
0.017631249502301216,
-0.05670919269323349,
0.121221624314785,
0.3754830062389374,
0.8189581632614136,
-0.512685239315033,
0.18897072970867157,
0.2703719735145569,
-0.646530032157898,
-0.24837751686573029,
0.1395971179008484,
-0.2539921998977661,
-0.16831263899803162,
0.591481626033783,
0.6812446713447571,
0.3804333508014679,
-0.5244213342666626,
0.39061248302459717,
-0.04975001513957977,
-0.42823782563209534,
0.021483834832906723,
0.15078109502792358,
-0.0043108160607516766,
-0.18178707361221313,
0.6873255372047424,
-0.19216090440750122,
0.602200984954834,
-0.5646743178367615,
0.11221098899841309,
0.1311013251543045,
-0.3745710551738739,
-0.10005731880664825,
0.9907436966896057,
0.3162133991718292,
-0.2710462510585785,
0.5999127626419067,
-0.33408498764038086,
-0.26834046840667725,
0.4045715034008026,
0.6186822652816772,
0.30334603786468506,
-0.08284954726696014,
0.6088021397590637,
0.625171422958374,
0.09612903743982315,
0.14100231230258942,
0.4291948676109314,
0.28275084495544434,
-0.42705246806144714,
-0.5414579510688782,
-0.8207203149795532,
-0.9060453772544861,
0.11331935226917267,
-0.6440619230270386,
0.5114859938621521,
-0.37545618414878845,
-0.08226335793733597,
0.39355525374412537,
-0.11521648615598679,
-0.5007188320159912,
0.19486254453659058,
0.19445158541202545,
1.0211553573608398,
-0.8623899817466736,
0.22541379928588867,
0.6172869801521301,
-0.423811137676239,
-0.4622928202152252,
-0.9684476256370544,
0.19765529036521912,
-0.2660605013370514,
0.7442925572395325,
-0.25516706705093384,
-0.16163842380046844,
-0.05119810253381729,
-0.7699122428894043,
-1.3332865238189697,
0.9272764325141907,
0.17222744226455688,
-0.3705542981624603,
-0.11520267277956009,
0.3216165602207184,
0.6845667362213135,
-0.1862441748380661,
0.38649967312812805,
0.7160230278968811,
0.5790297389030457,
0.060015082359313965,
-0.6810286045074463,
0.0804293155670166,
-0.530083417892456,
0.02054540626704693,
0.1431669145822525,
-0.12788458168506622,
0.6884609460830688,
-0.06923672556877136,
-0.43558642268180847,
-0.33330532908439636,
1.1532304286956787,
0.28874877095222473,
0.2659221887588501,
0.09248028695583344,
0.3497166931629181,
0.8318440914154053,
-0.603746771812439,
0.9989063739776611,
-0.31247884035110474,
0.1605614274740219,
1.3081423044204712,
-0.4949733018875122,
0.4869506359100342,
0.6087375283241272,
-0.37279945611953735,
1.0521223545074463,
0.838131308555603,
-0.002787209814414382,
0.12881898880004883,
0.019212260842323303,
-0.3430618643760681,
-0.013773512095212936,
-0.10697537660598755,
-0.3741799294948578,
0.41998958587646484,
1.0262141227722168,
0.195723757147789,
-0.4514601528644562,
0.12704309821128845,
0.02828250080347061,
-0.1458107978105545,
-0.4226367175579071,
0.6307572722434998,
-0.2907474935054779,
-0.4845868945121765,
-0.2537405788898468,
0.04682724550366402,
0.14819365739822388,
-0.5996066927909851,
-0.41768476366996765,
-0.12403523176908493,
-0.32590600848197937,
-0.6257801055908203,
-1.29157292842865,
0.5846595764160156,
-0.3160499930381775,
-0.32573947310447693,
-0.18448622524738312,
0.7122211456298828,
0.14229148626327515,
-0.3359634280204773,
0.19413048028945923,
0.23570936918258667,
-0.005680561996996403,
0.22888635098934174,
-0.24600756168365479,
0.30764612555503845,
-0.4307083785533905,
-0.4601391553878784,
0.04944159835577011,
0.36687231063842773,
-0.5576155185699463,
0.9406167268753052,
0.8610427379608154,
0.2786516547203064,
-0.20368880033493042,
0.37556397914886475,
0.7327826023101807,
-0.8024977445602417,
-0.6046687960624695,
-0.6398672461509705,
0.018050694838166237,
-0.5346480011940002,
-0.06807893514633179,
0.7217454314231873,
0.9078342914581299,
0.6707162261009216,
-0.0027334720361977816,
1.0886032581329346,
-0.49682101607322693,
0.504955530166626,
-0.1277744621038437,
0.44469934701919556,
-0.2041081339120865,
0.2126040905714035,
-0.3333749771118164,
-0.5557202696800232,
-0.8901134729385376,
0.6165814995765686,
-0.2576199471950531,
-0.49607041478157043,
0.7066150903701782,
0.595401406288147,
0.15068209171295166,
0.6768146753311157,
-0.30308231711387634,
0.23428402841091156,
0.43391621112823486,
0.1415477991104126,
0.8651493787765503,
-0.15780335664749146,
0.32798799872398376,
-0.3648530840873718,
-0.3241993486881256,
-0.5116913914680481,
-1.0500560998916626,
-0.5997350215911865,
-0.6952513456344604,
-0.07282310724258423,
-0.4613342881202698,
-0.01412915624678135,
0.7558109760284424,
0.2862137258052826,
-0.9041208028793335,
0.024981537833809853,
-0.1892842948436737,
0.4402724504470825,
-0.19030879437923431,
-0.3488208055496216,
0.48880481719970703,
-0.12663599848747253,
-0.6181520819664001,
0.3369975686073303,
0.8412540555000305,
0.0011699169408529997,
-0.36096084117889404,
0.2849282920360565,
-0.3393997251987457,
0.013523274101316929,
0.9833324551582336,
0.5605458617210388,
-0.5233058929443359,
-0.5513866543769836,
-0.08193846791982651,
-0.2421213686466217,
-0.18562336266040802,
0.6505867838859558,
-0.8291670680046082,
0.2205664962530136,
0.6411792635917664,
-0.23666903376579285,
0.7107742428779602,
-0.5901898145675659,
0.8407061696052551,
-0.5704689621925354,
0.11340246349573135,
0.2650073766708374,
0.4383987784385681,
0.2848335802555084,
-0.5547521114349365,
0.9644777178764343,
0.4369998276233673,
-0.42584213614463806,
-1.0289256572723389,
0.35365644097328186,
-0.9998111128807068,
-0.31547197699546814,
0.9710680842399597,
0.45111358165740967,
-0.43660426139831543,
-0.5596107244491577,
-0.1617933064699173,
0.3253621757030487,
0.04633268713951111,
0.7408894300460815,
0.7312628626823425,
-0.8480592370033264,
0.23753392696380615,
-0.5000540018081665,
0.8870242834091187,
-0.37520071864128113,
-0.91523677110672,
-0.01939617656171322,
0.7085509300231934,
-0.05029037222266197,
0.5281502604484558,
0.89067542552948,
-0.11478017270565033,
0.5084728598594666,
-0.017389288172125816,
0.561816930770874,
-0.006529612001031637,
-0.4193476438522339,
0.30924516916275024,
0.3369348645210266,
-0.5743834376335144,
0.6319674253463745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13025v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13025v2
|
A survey on fairness of large language models in e-commerce: progress, application, and challenge
| 2024-05-15T23:25:19 | 2024-06-21T21:26:03 |
Qingyang Ren, Zilin Jiang, Jinghan Cao, Sijia Li, Chiqu Li, Yiyang Liu, Shuning Huo, Tiange He, Yuan Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
This survey explores the fairness of large language models (LLMs) in
e-commerce, examining their progress, applications, and the challenges they
face. LLMs have become pivotal in the e-commerce domain, offering innovative
solutions and enhancing customer experiences. This work presents a
comprehensive survey on the applications and challenges of LLMs in e-commerce.
The paper begins by introducing the key principles underlying the use of LLMs
in e-commerce, detailing the processes of pretraining, fine-tuning, and
prompting that tailor these models to specific needs. It then explores the
varied applications of LLMs in e-commerce, including product reviews, where
they synthesize and analyze customer feedback; product recommendations, where
they leverage consumer data to suggest relevant items; product information
translation, enhancing global accessibility; and product question and answer
sections, where they automate customer support. The paper critically addresses
the fairness challenges in e-commerce, highlighting how biases in training data
and algorithms can lead to unfair outcomes, such as reinforcing stereotypes or
discriminating against certain groups. These issues not only undermine consumer
trust, but also raise ethical and legal concerns. Finally, the work outlines
future research directions, emphasizing the need for more equitable and
transparent LLMs in e-commerce. It advocates for ongoing efforts to mitigate
biases and improve the fairness of these systems, ensuring they serve diverse
global markets effectively and ethically. Through this comprehensive analysis,
the survey provides a holistic view of the current landscape of LLMs in
e-commerce, offering insights into their potential and limitations, and guiding
future endeavors in creating fairer and more inclusive e-commerce environments.
|
[
-0.2859979271888733,
-0.6459531188011169,
0.494974285364151,
0.2608470320701599,
-0.05193014815449715,
0.09683538228273392,
-0.4159739911556244,
-0.8392081260681152,
-0.02075722999870777,
0.4939334988594055,
-0.6227731704711914,
-0.44961029291152954,
-0.5318692326545715,
0.12068622559309006,
-0.5596835017204285,
0.9508928060531616,
0.08220896869897842,
0.4096873998641968,
-0.26462310552597046,
-0.0387713722884655,
-0.30753377079963684,
-0.8421555757522583,
-0.8408806324005127,
-0.09416679292917252,
0.48137086629867554,
0.25394195318222046,
0.3484686315059662,
0.06543648988008499,
0.5333016514778137,
0.4020044803619385,
-0.09950767457485199,
-0.12399645149707794,
-0.5945731401443481,
0.2921048104763031,
-0.23505903780460358,
-0.8978180289268494,
-0.7098720073699951,
0.017720868811011314,
0.49741432070732117,
0.8737097978591919,
-0.5795696973800659,
0.46677833795547485,
0.2183118760585785,
0.7227570414543152,
-0.6586195230484009,
-0.11659370362758636,
-0.5958107709884644,
0.315599650144577,
-0.2932303547859192,
0.17716281116008759,
-0.4156903624534607,
-0.5838422179222107,
-0.058563489466905594,
-0.5686132311820984,
0.12254514545202255,
0.4653429388999939,
0.6021887063980103,
-0.08360954374074936,
-0.5976908206939697,
-0.6412566304206848,
-0.737854540348053,
1.2826365232467651,
-0.7235376238822937,
0.6223308444023132,
0.20683014392852783,
0.49533504247665405,
-0.22471772134304047,
-0.7622759938240051,
-0.5669156312942505,
0.04507878050208092,
0.09553991258144379,
0.19852085411548615,
-0.26883333921432495,
-0.06802672147750854,
0.4152126908302307,
0.5001136064529419,
-0.48299774527549744,
0.5174363851547241,
-0.15452784299850464,
-0.10907454043626785,
0.7708823680877686,
0.32489049434661865,
0.13569362461566925,
0.21129685640335083,
-0.03180628642439842,
0.29284438490867615,
-0.7572108507156372,
0.24276065826416016,
0.7434949278831482,
0.017820218577980995,
-0.1994817703962326,
0.4143395721912384,
-0.372712641954422,
0.7220391035079956,
0.0011356133036315441,
-0.3226318061351776,
0.4496244788169861,
0.08356738090515137,
-0.23745563626289368,
-0.05469924956560135,
0.5334053039550781,
0.6113780736923218,
0.30940911173820496,
0.17244282364845276,
-0.5047094225883484,
-0.3165791928768158,
-0.08993114531040192,
-0.635463535785675,
0.5559166073799133,
0.3179202675819397,
-0.9285797476768494,
-0.0882003977894783,
-0.028425706550478935,
-0.815988302230835,
-0.3696519732475281,
-0.43482914566993713,
-0.022997867316007614,
0.6526514887809753,
-0.1699112057685852,
0.3526371717453003,
0.15751436352729797,
0.36555179953575134,
0.46177586913108826,
-0.8103338479995728,
0.6279051899909973,
0.8680916428565979,
0.5793747305870056,
0.07509006559848785,
-0.06893260031938553,
-0.32449784874916077,
0.1495964229106903,
-0.1046978235244751,
0.402849018573761,
-0.44520846009254456,
-0.06354039162397385,
0.3679434657096863,
0.24386471509933472,
0.27027952671051025,
-0.6786648035049438,
0.6198153495788574,
-0.7583438754081726,
-0.02851736545562744,
-0.24931111931800842,
-0.6704397797584534,
-0.08638670295476913,
0.585129976272583,
-0.7072770595550537,
0.33919069170951843,
-0.32486796379089355,
-0.594998836517334,
0.3231894373893738,
-0.41718512773513794,
-0.4633176922798157,
-0.017447488382458687,
-0.1861952692270279,
-0.5199873447418213,
0.4561927914619446,
0.12447015941143036,
0.559937059879303,
-0.540813684463501,
0.12123972922563553,
-0.6919320225715637,
-0.38428905606269836,
0.4752659797668457,
-0.6041556596755981,
0.9362967014312744,
0.5163411498069763,
-0.5156266093254089,
-0.3361705541610718,
-0.34839311242103577,
-0.13798512518405914,
0.4553004503250122,
-0.1261315494775772,
0.039177119731903076,
0.20049846172332764,
0.17665816843509674,
0.290463924407959,
0.3827490508556366,
-0.6035677194595337,
-0.050879888236522675,
-0.35660579800605774,
0.39770668745040894,
1.1263762712478638,
-0.4711111783981323,
0.36187461018562317,
-0.32907041907310486,
0.7440585494041443,
-0.14524732530117035,
0.6595646739006042,
-0.008116642013192177,
-0.5680357217788696,
-0.7867031693458557,
0.13042643666267395,
0.42186129093170166,
0.5046837329864502,
-0.254777193069458,
0.1784207820892334,
-0.2502225637435913,
-0.1559714525938034,
-0.5174846053123474,
0.15744468569755554,
0.0717008039355278,
0.029407372698187828,
-0.1695767045021057,
-0.3643916845321655,
-0.25684869289398193,
-1.1557612419128418,
-0.48872894048690796,
-0.010609368793666363,
-0.09421160072088242,
0.5875064730644226,
0.2593235373497009,
-0.0053949435241520405,
0.6303965449333191,
-0.3552760183811188,
-0.39876630902290344,
-0.16381239891052246,
-0.38260990381240845,
0.31278499960899353,
0.13863247632980347,
0.3624624013900757,
-0.9718371033668518,
-0.5637149810791016,
0.02753749117255211,
-0.6409204602241516,
-0.3269137442111969,
0.10073553025722504,
0.12984517216682434,
0.3093303143978119,
0.3004816770553589,
-0.2488751858472824,
0.2056080847978592,
0.7397617697715759,
-0.21179190278053284,
0.25345578789711,
-0.06699728220701218,
0.4598163366317749,
-0.7818779945373535,
-0.11900588124990463,
0.13802126049995422,
-0.4095756411552429,
-0.3263181746006012,
0.13062778115272522,
-0.17786246538162231,
0.1853588968515396,
-0.660556972026825,
0.48631420731544495,
-0.35939162969589233,
-0.3932732939720154,
-0.2724977433681488,
0.30173802375793457,
0.016422923654317856,
0.0788654237985611,
-0.20084825158119202,
0.33520716428756714,
0.3575422167778015,
-0.5365769863128662,
0.22839809954166412,
-0.010373705066740513,
-0.3019408881664276,
0.9917411208152771,
-0.5265756249427795,
0.06475169211626053,
-0.24277733266353607,
0.29728177189826965,
-0.5128140449523926,
0.15690365433692932,
0.4124809205532074,
-0.4296812117099762,
0.03707535192370415,
-0.11992493271827698,
-0.7729108333587646,
-0.33668696880340576,
-0.20741644501686096,
0.6418503522872925,
0.751738965511322,
-0.4895719885826111,
0.6265665292739868,
0.6686229705810547,
-0.354682058095932,
-0.7321779131889343,
-0.8029438853263855,
0.257137268781662,
-0.23416109383106232,
-0.6741088032722473,
0.274759978055954,
-0.3553928732872009,
-0.5827467441558838,
-0.18889355659484863,
0.06976643949747086,
0.1463320404291153,
0.340641051530838,
-0.0598917156457901,
-0.04778803884983063,
0.038713280111551285,
-0.09198836237192154,
-0.052426520735025406,
-0.03095083124935627,
0.2789405882358551,
-0.28926947712898254,
0.3984927237033844,
-0.08751831203699112,
-0.7320290207862854,
-0.2617665231227875,
0.5067940950393677,
0.13612519204616547,
0.013788675889372826,
0.4901885986328125,
0.39318588376045227,
-0.5472676753997803,
-0.41367101669311523,
-0.8148930668830872,
0.030855583027005196,
-0.5067746639251709,
0.3404136598110199,
-0.19796042144298553,
-1.3079280853271484,
0.5999922156333923,
-0.06397615373134613,
0.28104090690612793,
0.19381572306156158,
0.8750167489051819,
-0.018857872113585472,
1.2384306192398071,
0.785436749458313,
-0.09866292029619217,
0.30316174030303955,
0.3072461187839508,
0.6796373724937439,
-0.5217244029045105,
-0.5616336464881897,
-0.840678870677948,
-0.507033109664917,
-0.7934730648994446,
-0.1958511918783188,
0.00945322960615158,
0.049844890832901,
-0.4374598562717438,
-0.5151900053024292,
-0.2727290391921997,
0.48973211646080017,
0.3584662675857544,
0.11984968185424805,
0.6921859383583069,
0.1745176464319229,
0.146455317735672,
-0.2698674201965332,
-0.43012022972106934,
-0.6674151420593262,
1.1854232549667358,
0.5391390323638916,
0.8181790113449097,
0.4975736737251282,
0.39918914437294006,
0.3791610896587372,
0.36470580101013184,
-0.8660438656806946,
0.5857977867126465,
-0.3869487941265106,
-0.6552608609199524,
0.07767647504806519,
-0.5012969374656677,
-0.8001890778541565,
0.05093961954116821,
-0.014485304243862629,
-0.5894530415534973,
0.11063940823078156,
0.11985044926404953,
-0.002418057294562459,
0.516735851764679,
-0.5504415035247803,
0.656749427318573,
-0.6982563138008118,
-0.6503814458847046,
-0.1806810200214386,
-0.44490981101989746,
0.2004992663860321,
-0.23267093300819397,
0.7156299948692322,
-0.00619813147932291,
-0.23791155219078064,
0.8011830449104309,
-0.24137452244758606,
0.8152280449867249,
-0.19819563627243042,
-0.4412212073802948,
0.2167901247739792,
-0.05933606997132301,
0.5783763527870178,
-0.039187345653772354,
-0.03111407160758972,
0.4444368779659271,
-0.4357347786426544,
-0.46654048562049866,
-0.48693057894706726,
0.8057414889335632,
-0.5226643085479736,
-0.7650513648986816,
-0.517979085445404,
-0.26227691769599915,
-0.2784988582134247,
0.22030720114707947,
-0.26483410596847534,
-0.16343671083450317,
-0.15845884382724762,
0.17675432562828064,
0.8180485963821411,
-0.5231679081916809,
0.4265195429325104,
0.7343963980674744,
-0.5881801247596741,
-0.08507346361875534,
0.7757126688957214,
0.020085405558347702,
0.2764613926410675,
0.24372126162052155,
-0.016220318153500557,
-0.4759400486946106,
-0.8180100321769714,
-0.23462149500846863,
0.012747996486723423,
-0.8861420154571533,
-0.10384653508663177,
-0.5738402009010315,
0.05441503971815109,
-0.36288246512413025,
-0.2065333127975464,
-0.26615604758262634,
-0.2503418028354645,
-0.042351484298706055,
0.020017800852656364,
0.10936953872442245,
0.9108527898788452,
-0.018015660345554352,
0.18577483296394348,
-0.5862960815429688,
0.17746593058109283,
0.3311624825000763,
0.6353180408477783,
0.24262923002243042,
-0.5009739995002747,
-0.23787811398506165,
0.07070185989141464,
-0.1868250072002411,
-0.40009209513664246,
0.1191105917096138,
-0.1153976321220398,
0.788337230682373,
0.3136747181415558,
-0.2150995135307312,
0.3935964107513428,
-0.6163086891174316,
0.8723902106285095,
0.33602985739707947,
-0.9291895031929016,
0.10207825899124146,
-0.3036932349205017,
-0.2070946842432022,
0.30359184741973877,
0.4462589621543884,
-0.6088272929191589,
-0.2867508828639984,
-0.15070150792598724,
-0.9325787425041199,
0.5852115154266357,
0.09814732521772385,
0.349551260471344,
0.17302240431308746,
0.20761620998382568,
0.17318622767925262,
0.6251179575920105,
-1.0936871767044067,
-0.49574485421180725,
0.2063945233821869,
-0.27710914611816406,
-0.047241728752851486,
-0.1327219307422638,
0.07320600003004074,
-0.01301512774080038,
0.6415113806724548,
0.15550392866134644,
-0.007532033603638411,
-0.27087321877479553,
-0.3085551857948303,
-0.0023203003220260143,
0.5923182368278503,
0.3901338279247284,
0.6936922073364258,
0.08088883012533188,
-0.30158790946006775,
0.10267496854066849,
-0.38395336270332336,
0.2285577952861786,
-0.039668165147304535,
-0.2950322926044464,
-0.29925230145454407,
-0.10089842975139618,
0.31961533427238464,
-0.057866111397743225,
-0.8767362236976624,
0.8230098485946655,
-0.2987251877784729,
-0.19278542697429657,
-0.41666874289512634,
-0.3268929421901703,
0.06638290733098984,
0.4215322434902191,
0.2302272766828537,
-0.21764783561229706,
0.5072916150093079,
-0.3921245038509369,
-0.09295337647199631,
0.547743022441864,
-0.22280679643154144,
0.03722286596894264,
0.6610652208328247,
0.2277437150478363,
-0.40426313877105713,
0.5044336915016174,
-0.27169257402420044,
-0.40749213099479675,
0.6059256792068481,
0.6441407799720764,
0.8259136080741882,
-0.06227828934788704,
-0.004185323137789965,
-0.06313881278038025,
0.5952909588813782,
-0.21890147030353546,
0.20238469541072845,
0.2449219673871994,
-0.5705207586288452,
-0.2919153571128845,
-0.8594236373901367,
-0.43152916431427,
-0.09225237369537354,
-0.5073556900024414,
0.3503270149230957,
-0.4802402853965759,
-0.23053185641765594,
-0.44892045855522156,
-0.004645924083888531,
-0.9861252903938293,
0.09790942817926407,
0.4719911217689514,
0.5585646629333496,
-0.6164900064468384,
0.24656371772289276,
0.49460676312446594,
-0.16760344803333282,
-0.48375722765922546,
-0.24258901178836823,
0.20175234973430634,
-0.7415189743041992,
0.5533350110054016,
0.1067860946059227,
-0.1744077503681183,
-0.24595633149147034,
-0.4197380244731903,
-0.3544064164161682,
0.9326479434967041,
0.43640679121017456,
-1.353518009185791,
0.26341575384140015,
0.6199644207954407,
0.3688284754753113,
-0.3712838292121887,
0.5267977118492126,
0.4577149748802185,
0.44912418723106384,
-0.2500937879085541,
-0.8739050626754761,
0.04798978567123413,
-0.20245449244976044,
0.06593142449855804,
-0.07651287317276001,
-0.8994142413139343,
0.9237825274467468,
0.1557280272245407,
-0.006111341528594494,
0.08816049993038177,
0.21376337110996246,
0.41293424367904663,
0.5397076606750488,
0.6029850840568542,
0.7924787402153015,
0.8031652569770813,
0.04672842472791672,
0.9323844313621521,
-0.0709095448255539,
0.5652292370796204,
0.9450253248214722,
-0.6826379895210266,
0.6780909895896912,
0.4005514085292816,
-0.4949008524417877,
0.2875131666660309,
0.7413029074668884,
0.03567344695329666,
0.10030525922775269,
0.7037175893783569,
-0.4026343524456024,
-0.17167417705059052,
-0.3362540900707245,
-0.4934040606021881,
0.006083508487790823,
0.18659313023090363,
-0.3189592659473419,
-0.025421669706702232,
-0.010324031114578247,
-0.058602165430784225,
0.15943603217601776,
-0.8795832395553589,
0.4909663200378418,
0.4900481104850769,
-0.08917754888534546,
-0.020948760211467743,
0.4027726352214813,
0.9772980213165283,
-0.4426441192626953,
-0.10133535414934158,
-0.18640077114105225,
0.22223925590515137,
-0.38573357462882996,
-0.6286754012107849,
0.05573854595422745,
0.23326347768306732,
-0.13273602724075317,
-0.38513118028640747,
0.645399808883667,
-0.02799016423523426,
-0.7505350112915039,
0.5355995297431946,
0.587876558303833,
0.06807810813188553,
0.06806448101997375,
-1.0188950300216675,
0.3910525143146515,
-0.16998280584812164,
-0.35217446088790894,
0.4374088644981384,
0.447933554649353,
0.0006476283888332546,
0.6080342531204224,
0.515357255935669,
0.1484595537185669,
0.3440004885196686,
0.3797306418418884,
0.35457369685173035,
-0.8000592589378357,
-0.5913704037666321,
-0.8258749842643738,
0.5596376061439514,
-0.19709035754203796,
-0.021634723991155624,
0.8379112482070923,
0.6737892627716064,
1.3218278884887695,
0.20111528038978577,
0.8661547899246216,
0.1421244740486145,
0.46328097581863403,
-0.5239576697349548,
0.857045590877533,
-0.8055790662765503,
0.6796011328697205,
-0.21280419826507568,
-1.183521032333374,
-0.37340065836906433,
0.45116281509399414,
-0.3154129981994629,
0.4970960021018982,
0.515928328037262,
0.6987791061401367,
0.01751594990491867,
0.1792251169681549,
0.36508721113204956,
0.2763572633266449,
0.3089270293712616,
0.6249428987503052,
1.0774122476577759,
-0.46048811078071594,
0.45780444145202637,
0.0687970444560051,
-0.19438694417476654,
-0.2340986579656601,
-0.8620757460594177,
-0.6569932699203491,
-0.09471055865287781,
-0.17200620472431183,
-0.40970295667648315,
0.12212634831666946,
1.0867598056793213,
0.47102993726730347,
-0.7732648849487305,
-0.6104366779327393,
0.2971876859664917,
0.30964505672454834,
0.09535007178783417,
-0.13193665444850922,
-0.14965134859085083,
-0.23473002016544342,
-1.1037582159042358,
-0.20032332837581635,
0.20338991284370422,
-0.0502435602247715,
-0.2455601841211319,
-0.14570339024066925,
0.2512093484401703,
0.013254118151962757,
0.8850474953651428,
0.0296018086373806,
-0.7645748257637024,
0.005526157561689615,
0.01149772945791483,
0.04611285775899887,
-0.08639145642518997,
1.0535731315612793,
-0.38700971007347107,
0.2691860795021057,
0.2303585708141327,
0.7987474203109741,
0.3446565568447113,
-0.5645033121109009,
0.430642306804657,
-0.14770278334617615,
0.1244601234793663,
0.4225887656211853,
0.503418505191803,
0.2922085225582123,
-0.09162089228630066,
0.08249641954898834,
0.00608622282743454,
-0.6747762560844421,
-0.839855968952179,
0.461736261844635,
-0.8596944808959961,
-0.3120676577091217,
0.9178833365440369,
-0.0522427037358284,
-0.2612873315811157,
-0.3897383213043213,
0.10292427986860275,
-0.22486786544322968,
-0.36651793122291565,
0.6153683662414551,
0.71295166015625,
0.29991063475608826,
0.027421914041042328,
-0.7953113913536072,
0.1213110163807869,
0.4479445517063141,
-0.803958535194397,
-0.11020353436470032,
0.6981942653656006,
0.3639293611049652,
-0.5932840704917908,
0.8919822573661804,
-0.31582990288734436,
0.10569386929273605,
-0.5468346476554871,
0.05534084886312485,
0.23047900199890137,
-0.1913066804409027,
-0.707048237323761,
0.24637526273727417,
0.4693286418914795,
0.3749734163284302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09719v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09719v2
|
Spectral Editing of Activations for Large Language Model Alignment
| 2024-05-15T22:28:23 | 2024-05-25T16:08:23 |
Yifu Qiu, Zheng Zhao, Yftah Ziser, Anna Korhonen, Edoardo M. Ponti, Shay B. Cohen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) often exhibit undesirable behaviours, such as
generating untruthful or biased content. Editing their internal representations
has been shown to be effective in mitigating such behaviours on top of the
existing alignment methods. We propose a novel inference-time editing method,
namely spectral editing of activations (SEA), to project the input
representations into directions with maximal covariance with the positive
demonstrations (e.g., truthful) while minimising covariance with the negative
demonstrations (e.g., hallucinated). We also extend our method to non-linear
editing using feature functions. We run extensive experiments on benchmarks
concerning truthfulness and bias with six open-source LLMs of different sizes
and model families. The results demonstrate the superiority of SEA in
effectiveness, generalisation to similar tasks, as well as computation and data
efficiency. We also show that SEA editing only has a limited negative impact on
other model capabilities.
|
[
-0.21887905895709991,
-0.6110603213310242,
0.5378234386444092,
0.21214231848716736,
-0.1737147569656372,
0.06747139990329742,
-0.5319551229476929,
-0.4330817461013794,
0.2923695147037506,
0.551616907119751,
-0.3895931839942932,
-0.6857585906982422,
-0.4311828315258026,
-0.07923334836959839,
-0.5400093793869019,
0.6704311966896057,
-0.053328461945056915,
0.10799697041511536,
-0.09489240497350693,
-0.4480360150337219,
-0.27015119791030884,
-0.3844400644302368,
-0.4724712073802948,
-0.1976996660232544,
0.600593626499176,
0.16469129920005798,
0.969353973865509,
0.5794929265975952,
0.2397705763578415,
0.3670629560947418,
-0.19784526526927948,
0.2586926817893982,
-0.5076606273651123,
0.1793300360441208,
-0.5011612176895142,
-0.5311041474342346,
-0.6670464277267456,
0.044187456369400024,
0.6948725581169128,
0.849697470664978,
0.09204958379268646,
0.15820851922035217,
0.1688365787267685,
0.5795466899871826,
-0.7369965314865112,
0.07779455184936523,
-0.823818564414978,
-0.07642706483602524,
-0.06146828457713127,
0.02215215377509594,
-0.714492917060852,
-0.3126432001590729,
-0.12925481796264648,
-0.657479465007782,
0.19540943205356598,
-0.3004859387874603,
0.6897847056388855,
0.5293951034545898,
-0.42888179421424866,
-0.3089514374732971,
-0.8471210598945618,
0.9017122387886047,
-0.9229183197021484,
0.6098908185958862,
0.11107493191957474,
0.0423523485660553,
-0.38044309616088867,
-0.3539664149284363,
-0.6270368099212646,
-0.0657249391078949,
-0.02892148494720459,
0.03830523043870926,
-0.24151435494422913,
0.3332209289073944,
0.3010775148868561,
-0.1201837956905365,
-0.31275057792663574,
0.45397934317588806,
-0.00912383571267128,
-0.4193791449069977,
0.7734621167182922,
-0.16275252401828766,
0.21471935510635376,
-0.05692235380411148,
-0.10535892844200134,
-0.0811043530702591,
-0.891653835773468,
-0.17610757052898407,
0.5437604784965515,
0.31516337394714355,
-0.045755431056022644,
0.9926087260246277,
0.027749620378017426,
0.5785336494445801,
0.499798059463501,
0.012043222784996033,
0.21172207593917847,
-0.0008185077458620071,
-0.31278082728385925,
0.24791744351387024,
0.4777233898639679,
0.4666076898574829,
-0.17949828505516052,
-0.3210963308811188,
-0.18014751374721527,
0.2902851998806,
0.1343073546886444,
-0.5196083784103394,
0.08184940367937088,
0.5472763180732727,
-0.24674604833126068,
-0.3513086438179016,
-0.2650509476661682,
-0.8765775561332703,
-0.5753715634346008,
-0.47284287214279175,
0.4861677587032318,
-0.3712490499019623,
-0.04255862534046173,
0.15181493759155273,
0.06259223818778992,
0.08549347519874573,
0.31668272614479065,
-0.5579076409339905,
-0.01865353249013424,
0.5387898683547974,
0.5140798687934875,
0.02939113788306713,
-0.11170447617769241,
-0.7475770115852356,
0.28816699981689453,
-0.5633013248443604,
0.3316698968410492,
-0.795245885848999,
-0.05864746868610382,
-0.07661394774913788,
-0.20495136082172394,
0.06488703191280365,
-0.35415929555892944,
0.6599857807159424,
-1.0320417881011963,
0.16470594704151154,
-0.38117825984954834,
-0.7739203572273254,
-0.13276170194149017,
-0.26554614305496216,
-0.740375816822052,
1.0246529579162598,
-0.0492544025182724,
-0.40867555141448975,
0.2653141915798187,
-0.7525606751441956,
-0.26826074719429016,
-0.4044082462787628,
0.22801946103572845,
-0.6123558282852173,
0.33985865116119385,
0.4738331139087677,
0.31977009773254395,
0.1521005928516388,
0.47506093978881836,
-0.5098311901092529,
-0.28626787662506104,
0.5135931372642517,
-0.1671166867017746,
0.8172141909599304,
0.2150609940290451,
-0.507876455783844,
0.3328261971473694,
-1.0181165933609009,
-0.07447519898414612,
-0.14823567867279053,
-0.11222856491804123,
-0.5026751160621643,
0.04338613525032997,
-0.22377021610736847,
0.23253895342350006,
0.21937894821166992,
-0.7198384404182434,
0.45110297203063965,
-0.2933969795703888,
0.3959914445877075,
0.9494115710258484,
0.1671372950077057,
0.5245494246482849,
-0.10409550368785858,
0.48329612612724304,
-0.01523248665034771,
0.1270768642425537,
0.19679124653339386,
-0.15766756236553192,
-0.8990243673324585,
-0.5760690569877625,
0.6193754076957703,
0.2359214574098587,
-1.0848417282104492,
0.5350105166435242,
-0.35458478331565857,
-0.5035730600357056,
-0.7705457806587219,
0.31488218903541565,
0.3726634383201599,
0.4252469539642334,
0.45904383063316345,
-0.13923990726470947,
-0.5922415852546692,
-0.8731604218482971,
-0.3960474133491516,
-0.05931074917316437,
0.23005525767803192,
0.08158395439386368,
0.35411882400512695,
-0.3121131658554077,
0.9071987867355347,
-0.20834998786449432,
-0.0046732802875339985,
0.03384141996502876,
0.34431079030036926,
0.03461663797497749,
0.35816454887390137,
0.6536659598350525,
-0.5779204964637756,
-0.34348371624946594,
-0.3585069179534912,
-0.557502031326294,
-0.7959885597229004,
-0.4486764073371887,
-0.28130853176116943,
0.4429108202457428,
0.5487475395202637,
-0.6264030933380127,
0.3568618893623352,
0.7607321739196777,
-0.2737683355808258,
0.2671433091163635,
-0.17212669551372528,
0.14613302052021027,
-0.765205979347229,
-0.0493643619120121,
-0.02928803488612175,
-0.23995670676231384,
-0.8452193140983582,
0.1657189428806305,
0.25325682759284973,
0.028120990842580795,
-0.4583989679813385,
0.38070428371429443,
-0.5819781422615051,
-0.1766168177127838,
-0.16582728922367096,
0.21717000007629395,
-0.11052720993757248,
0.7152906060218811,
-0.10954660922288895,
0.5719686150550842,
0.2552392780780792,
-0.5935440063476562,
0.08945797383785248,
0.3124127686023712,
-0.37977656722068787,
0.397247314453125,
-0.49807560443878174,
0.40708059072494507,
-0.40684378147125244,
0.19570587575435638,
-1.0927650928497314,
-0.004255284089595079,
0.09787089377641678,
-0.18636243045330048,
0.35835811495780945,
-0.23395168781280518,
-0.4509766399860382,
0.1043306291103363,
-0.35178694128990173,
0.3196309506893158,
0.4333576261997223,
-0.7802628874778748,
0.5881447792053223,
0.2660719156265259,
-0.054118845611810684,
-0.7120699882507324,
-0.7437280416488647,
0.31815338134765625,
-0.17937229573726654,
-0.597654402256012,
0.5258927345275879,
0.07929287105798721,
-0.3348098397254944,
-0.027814339846372604,
0.009732740931212902,
0.21883563697338104,
0.05178172141313553,
0.20810844004154205,
0.4150412380695343,
-0.08982588350772858,
0.0641569122672081,
0.33567121624946594,
-0.1522180140018463,
-0.2726898789405823,
-0.0975661501288414,
0.5507068634033203,
0.3253431022167206,
-0.731214165687561,
-0.5032919049263,
0.15649186074733734,
0.7884994149208069,
-0.5564526915550232,
0.597388505935669,
0.3667277693748474,
-0.15231013298034668,
-0.31748178601264954,
-0.6458832621574402,
0.0018146082293242216,
-0.47681042551994324,
0.4455220103263855,
-0.18030254542827606,
-0.8835806250572205,
0.6198081374168396,
-0.12260187417268753,
0.06710466742515564,
0.42663702368736267,
0.5372946858406067,
-0.044124189764261246,
1.1138249635696411,
0.4139876961708069,
0.0037575296591967344,
0.4871070981025696,
-0.1735386699438095,
0.2225009799003601,
-1.0087518692016602,
0.19687020778656006,
-0.42023465037345886,
-0.6358471512794495,
-0.5959423780441284,
-0.6126317381858826,
0.5728117823600769,
0.17424815893173218,
-0.14063626527786255,
0.17212040722370148,
-0.34140995144844055,
0.3692946135997772,
0.11161474883556366,
0.2600303292274475,
0.24513787031173706,
-0.017620069906115532,
-0.06837616860866547,
-0.39470887184143066,
-0.6299282908439636,
-0.3268360495567322,
1.1757147312164307,
0.3252743184566498,
0.8487110137939453,
0.40203163027763367,
0.6091140508651733,
0.22129438817501068,
0.4219615161418915,
-0.5197454690933228,
0.5697798132896423,
-0.25520533323287964,
-0.48874232172966003,
-0.4333111345767975,
-0.14411883056163788,
-0.6722152829170227,
0.2007313072681427,
-0.33936551213264465,
-0.579721987247467,
0.6924989819526672,
0.2487611025571823,
-0.18157604336738586,
0.44401609897613525,
-0.5953402519226074,
0.4595628082752228,
-0.1561610847711563,
-0.7531372308731079,
-0.3302812874317169,
-0.37844425439834595,
0.2732243239879608,
-0.21909134089946747,
0.4457065761089325,
0.21524500846862793,
-0.2756795883178711,
0.39948615431785583,
-0.4915117025375366,
1.187230110168457,
-0.5446177124977112,
-0.4620125889778137,
0.2632127106189728,
0.30834341049194336,
0.9609484076499939,
-0.4373328685760498,
-0.38179364800453186,
0.12868352234363556,
-0.3818660378456116,
-0.3290325701236725,
-0.8058985471725464,
0.5177987813949585,
-0.6057390570640564,
-0.4594327211380005,
-0.09861069172620773,
-0.6415711641311646,
-0.4461991488933563,
0.027625679969787598,
0.11172085255384445,
0.4936649799346924,
-0.13206884264945984,
0.16692496836185455,
0.6114165186882019,
-0.45270872116088867,
0.5287057757377625,
0.49202635884284973,
-0.49606233835220337,
-0.42233601212501526,
0.8295904397964478,
0.3207883834838867,
0.7115070223808289,
0.27465593814849854,
0.0693565309047699,
-0.25436195731163025,
-0.8483887314796448,
-0.2913825809955597,
0.24762080609798431,
-0.8177710175514221,
0.0811600387096405,
-0.5159756541252136,
-0.018345655873417854,
-0.4514143764972687,
-0.292931467294693,
-0.5043253898620605,
-0.7673779129981995,
0.037056516855955124,
-0.017949752509593964,
0.20133404433727264,
0.5627220869064331,
-0.4152408540248871,
0.29575636982917786,
-0.5990016460418701,
0.413744181394577,
0.30196571350097656,
0.38562867045402527,
-0.08181958645582199,
-0.5963201522827148,
-0.2631426751613617,
0.13112697005271912,
-0.06838514655828476,
-0.9128159880638123,
0.2882639169692993,
0.20480240881443024,
0.4683556854724884,
0.16032736003398895,
-0.020339401438832283,
0.8459739685058594,
-0.34263625741004944,
0.9523659944534302,
-0.0134592829272151,
-1.3824517726898193,
0.14535647630691528,
-0.3371669352054596,
0.2684391438961029,
0.33591777086257935,
0.13945108652114868,
-0.5687167048454285,
-0.7189174294471741,
-0.3806290626525879,
-0.5802074074745178,
0.4888068437576294,
0.11798957735300064,
0.05381189286708832,
0.2721804976463318,
0.5136408805847168,
0.16349762678146362,
0.26597610116004944,
-0.5863526463508606,
-0.31647130846977234,
-0.2613118886947632,
-0.2496940791606903,
-0.07324288785457611,
-0.542142927646637,
-0.020080341026186943,
-0.43046998977661133,
1.1079750061035156,
-0.19125615060329437,
0.20048129558563232,
0.3103708028793335,
-0.44206732511520386,
-0.4220784604549408,
0.5056420564651489,
0.8020679354667664,
0.7193813323974609,
-0.0002962001890409738,
0.1687069982290268,
0.3302761912345886,
-0.30734750628471375,
0.25313714146614075,
-0.2921297252178192,
-0.40669044852256775,
0.08627717941999435,
0.6213088631629944,
0.820504367351532,
0.33191224932670593,
-0.33682510256767273,
0.39940908551216125,
0.23447315394878387,
-0.1056956872344017,
0.101664237678051,
0.08270426839590073,
0.05710085853934288,
0.3022688329219818,
-0.028141191229224205,
0.08686861395835876,
-0.1550145149230957,
-0.34537366032600403,
-0.008781819604337215,
0.5536876320838928,
-0.37267008423805237,
-0.34649035334587097,
0.7262513637542725,
-0.05532452464103699,
-0.12398018687963486,
0.3258025348186493,
-0.15298765897750854,
-0.6129699945449829,
0.3293779790401459,
0.41336989402770996,
1.0228618383407593,
-0.490516722202301,
0.20310963690280914,
0.328682541847229,
0.35405433177948,
0.31830742955207825,
0.32364341616630554,
0.2984493672847748,
-0.9885203838348389,
-0.820210337638855,
-0.3568064272403717,
-0.42126914858818054,
0.29912739992141724,
-0.5615898966789246,
0.4006498157978058,
-0.2517951726913452,
-0.13059654831886292,
0.2433236837387085,
-0.35494711995124817,
-0.3139936327934265,
0.012924814596772194,
0.1551596075296402,
0.6811147928237915,
-0.8009894490242004,
1.0353749990463257,
0.47848746180534363,
-0.1782282590866089,
-0.520715057849884,
-0.12381178140640259,
0.19402004778385162,
-0.7491322755813599,
0.6341622471809387,
-0.41431692242622375,
-0.268232136964798,
-0.1181686595082283,
-0.9699019193649292,
-0.9025171399116516,
0.8095307946205139,
0.9479440450668335,
-0.8653295040130615,
0.004739470314234495,
0.419960618019104,
0.7303572297096252,
-0.21006378531455994,
-0.07747985422611237,
0.43780800700187683,
0.732796311378479,
0.16821564733982086,
-0.7306292653083801,
0.06853149831295013,
-0.06990129500627518,
0.019984744489192963,
0.1689225286245346,
-0.7462717890739441,
0.7118260264396667,
-0.018319247290492058,
-0.12079163640737534,
0.1547970473766327,
0.6333501935005188,
-0.10077330470085144,
-0.14441978931427002,
0.7494234442710876,
0.6703420877456665,
0.9138126969337463,
-0.033665865659713745,
0.83060222864151,
-0.5672472715377808,
0.24943499267101288,
1.359581470489502,
-0.44710949063301086,
0.5853528380393982,
0.6767050623893738,
-0.06942006200551987,
0.5080243945121765,
0.2420303225517273,
-0.035877298563718796,
0.5390726327896118,
0.10138449817895889,
-0.2633747458457947,
-0.33427637815475464,
0.02242390625178814,
-0.07532146573066711,
0.5251253843307495,
0.20402374863624573,
-0.35678407549858093,
-0.23785953223705292,
0.062443673610687256,
0.23074883222579956,
0.15190637111663818,
-0.2771818935871124,
0.6930005550384521,
-0.1949426829814911,
-0.6515343189239502,
0.6961713433265686,
0.1736770123243332,
0.47758591175079346,
-0.47562146186828613,
-0.17760565876960754,
0.09322839230298996,
0.15104831755161285,
-0.4305940270423889,
-0.6451692581176758,
0.26524677872657776,
0.15763674676418304,
-0.10894612967967987,
-0.25797152519226074,
0.6101990938186646,
-0.6780537962913513,
-0.3829125761985779,
0.4380817711353302,
0.20620223879814148,
-0.20088666677474976,
0.01603863202035427,
-0.5536600947380066,
0.337981253862381,
0.2379690706729889,
-0.19200438261032104,
0.11774617433547974,
0.23424698412418365,
-0.195838063955307,
0.4125247895717621,
0.7381649613380432,
0.33893394470214844,
0.2646637260913849,
0.06793470680713654,
0.7003594636917114,
-0.5726349949836731,
-0.2645765542984009,
-0.8815562129020691,
0.6214719414710999,
-0.049107033759355545,
0.02207760140299797,
0.7934028506278992,
0.6168045997619629,
0.5776456594467163,
0.01990324817597866,
0.8049706220626831,
0.2628631293773651,
0.41907963156700134,
-0.793260931968689,
0.5891942381858826,
-0.30201777815818787,
0.47756797075271606,
-0.3981240391731262,
-1.0770947933197021,
-0.3819168210029602,
0.192692369222641,
-0.4936279058456421,
-0.32983651757240295,
0.5938389301300049,
1.103607177734375,
-0.059730589389801025,
0.1694638431072235,
0.23611047863960266,
0.8390588164329529,
0.5342057347297668,
0.3703615367412567,
0.7173221707344055,
-0.29956749081611633,
0.05532193183898926,
-0.5990012288093567,
-0.1435326635837555,
-0.007761204149574041,
-1.1130154132843018,
-0.8482256531715393,
-0.5467800498008728,
-0.5141789317131042,
-0.42510664463043213,
-0.03922688588500023,
1.0761070251464844,
0.3896638751029968,
-0.9009570479393005,
-0.11245755851268768,
0.1697624772787094,
0.11942623555660248,
-0.29985055327415466,
-0.13975581526756287,
0.7304672002792358,
-0.2838251292705536,
-0.7506147027015686,
0.5391435027122498,
0.19070610404014587,
-0.058371782302856445,
-0.32379642128944397,
-0.045901115983724594,
-0.3385195732116699,
0.29843631386756897,
0.6700427532196045,
0.08217242360115051,
-0.5769543647766113,
-0.7704601883888245,
-0.23649735748767853,
-0.04963557422161102,
0.15671545267105103,
0.5420900583267212,
-0.5392915606498718,
0.6893334984779358,
0.4093339145183563,
0.6979807019233704,
0.4425935745239258,
-0.215730682015419,
0.5037732720375061,
-0.741813063621521,
0.1745568960905075,
0.10240913927555084,
0.4475906789302826,
0.34566429257392883,
-0.3375858664512634,
0.38513779640197754,
0.17337709665298462,
-0.3577842116355896,
-0.9230932593345642,
0.04254189878702164,
-0.9424738883972168,
-0.20218026638031006,
1.174409031867981,
0.1568821668624878,
-0.3465200364589691,
0.08826487511396408,
-0.27282077074050903,
0.5461214184761047,
-0.14987340569496155,
0.8171283006668091,
0.9012564420700073,
-0.18441657721996307,
0.2214050143957138,
-0.329598605632782,
0.38587474822998047,
0.5613601207733154,
-0.625518798828125,
0.3156396150588989,
0.7547836899757385,
0.19872353971004486,
0.17368446290493011,
0.06022297963500023,
-0.38315311074256897,
0.10801364481449127,
-0.2871423661708832,
0.4597552716732025,
-0.18059536814689636,
-0.17416484653949738,
-0.7822553515434265,
0.1276792585849762,
0.03615486994385719,
0.12022151798009872
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09713v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09713v2
|
SOK-Bench: A Situated Video Reasoning Benchmark with Aligned Open-World Knowledge
| 2024-05-15T21:55:31 | 2024-05-17T02:18:16 |
Andong Wang, Bo Wu, Sunli Chen, Zhenfang Chen, Haotian Guan, Wei-Ning Lee, Li Erran Li, Chuang Gan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Learning commonsense reasoning from visual contexts and scenes in real-world
is a crucial step toward advanced artificial intelligence. However, existing
video reasoning benchmarks are still inadequate since they were mainly designed
for factual or situated reasoning and rarely involve broader knowledge in the
real world. Our work aims to delve deeper into reasoning evaluations,
specifically within dynamic, open-world, and structured context knowledge. We
propose a new benchmark (SOK-Bench), consisting of 44K questions and 10K
situations with instance-level annotations depicted in the videos. The
reasoning process is required to understand and apply situated knowledge and
general knowledge for problem-solving. To create such a dataset, we propose an
automatic and scalable generation method to generate question-answer pairs,
knowledge graphs, and rationales by instructing the combinations of LLMs and
MLLMs. Concretely, we first extract observable situated entities, relations,
and processes from videos for situated knowledge and then extend to open-world
knowledge beyond the visible content. The task generation is facilitated
through multiple dialogues as iterations and subsequently corrected and refined
by our designed self-promptings and demonstrations. With a corpus of both
explicit situated facts and implicit commonsense, we generate associated
question-answer pairs and reasoning processes, finally followed by manual
reviews for quality assurance. We evaluated recent mainstream large
vision-language models on the benchmark and found several insightful
conclusions. For more information, please refer to our benchmark at
www.bobbywu.com/SOKBench.
|
[
-0.5178425908088684,
-0.9365391731262207,
0.6149563789367676,
-0.05496840178966522,
-0.15982158482074738,
-0.5358138680458069,
-0.1482015997171402,
-0.18080992996692657,
-0.38514894247055054,
0.46943679451942444,
-0.8508562445640564,
-0.5085842609405518,
-0.16626830399036407,
-0.025142494589090347,
-0.16161009669303894,
0.4869195818901062,
-0.23314107954502106,
0.029954753816127777,
-0.6818265318870544,
-0.4076353907585144,
-0.2762601971626282,
-0.027628246694803238,
-0.055703744292259216,
0.07390455156564713,
0.1419912725687027,
0.6993496417999268,
0.44781726598739624,
0.6149909496307373,
0.3426624834537506,
0.3887033760547638,
0.2574521005153656,
0.4317566454410553,
-0.4924883544445038,
0.2770732343196869,
-0.34133750200271606,
0.0270457211881876,
-0.0771421417593956,
-0.05523345619440079,
0.6469563841819763,
0.5562808513641357,
0.16537371277809143,
0.6232770085334778,
-0.20605115592479706,
0.3627788722515106,
-0.9223964214324951,
0.0016293496591970325,
-0.47907158732414246,
0.2735104560852051,
0.03473054990172386,
0.11743549257516861,
-0.017596477642655373,
-0.40263423323631287,
0.03269146755337715,
-0.8192389607429504,
0.025585541501641273,
-0.0011604377068579197,
0.7362898588180542,
0.8330237865447998,
-0.2655976116657257,
0.08973712474107742,
-0.4459145665168762,
0.7228273749351501,
-0.4262518584728241,
0.5652734637260437,
0.33898642659187317,
0.8422371745109558,
-0.04518720135092735,
-0.7480388283729553,
-0.65420001745224,
-0.2074245661497116,
0.22554881870746613,
0.34906005859375,
0.2766196131706238,
-0.41042470932006836,
0.5568022131919861,
0.002563927322626114,
-0.5953384041786194,
-0.1311013549566269,
-0.2457934319972992,
0.038969554007053375,
0.8655886650085449,
0.13056011497974396,
0.0625307634472847,
-0.5311525464057922,
-0.4193362295627594,
-0.15938352048397064,
-0.6013767719268799,
0.2005680799484253,
0.11044713854789734,
-0.0841151773929596,
0.06182454153895378,
0.5157891511917114,
-0.5316174030303955,
0.7292994856834412,
-0.1808956414461136,
-0.19197013974189758,
0.011135946959257126,
-0.2262783944606781,
-0.41755831241607666,
-0.00682805385440588,
0.48737791180610657,
0.6281024813652039,
0.116461843252182,
0.15706083178520203,
0.10620192438364029,
-0.051678821444511414,
0.36448290944099426,
-0.4903305470943451,
-0.033364005386829376,
0.19798913598060608,
-0.34342026710510254,
-0.13926385343074799,
-0.05941709503531456,
-0.5641370415687561,
-0.3176404535770416,
-0.4633355140686035,
0.49194419384002686,
-0.33454185724258423,
-0.26915308833122253,
-0.3207087814807892,
0.08139868825674057,
0.21914084255695343,
0.5220539569854736,
-0.5448881983757019,
0.1489516645669937,
0.5896695256233215,
0.30620715022087097,
0.03979947417974472,
-0.4039865732192993,
-0.6488405466079712,
0.36177852749824524,
-0.35665687918663025,
0.936439037322998,
-0.3502770960330963,
0.059737008064985275,
0.2306928187608719,
-0.1072443276643753,
0.23300610482692719,
-0.7024232149124146,
0.31859710812568665,
-0.3757232427597046,
-0.0993121787905693,
-0.5187351107597351,
-0.2988853454589844,
0.01358774770051241,
0.8091364502906799,
-0.47609859704971313,
1.4908418655395508,
-0.04191692918539047,
-0.4285041093826294,
0.6135278344154358,
-0.5605593323707581,
-0.21931010484695435,
0.1252916306257248,
-0.628148078918457,
-0.09082307666540146,
-0.2686050832271576,
0.29027989506721497,
0.5700136423110962,
-0.22911366820335388,
0.5585318803787231,
-0.3062366247177124,
-0.25875145196914673,
0.3567273020744324,
-0.17664283514022827,
0.27288660407066345,
0.25651469826698303,
-0.5263360142707825,
0.05510752275586128,
-0.9118837714195251,
0.20307564735412598,
-0.12450788915157318,
-0.10213281959295273,
-0.06569681316614151,
0.00814373791217804,
-0.2548862397670746,
0.2621155381202698,
-0.024890955537557602,
-0.5031153559684753,
-0.1466657817363739,
-0.043462663888931274,
0.27205726504325867,
0.6387811899185181,
0.04580332338809967,
0.16895745694637299,
0.17669934034347534,
0.12130571901798248,
-0.11606535315513611,
0.27357837557792664,
0.08673654496669769,
-0.2642129957675934,
-0.4065006971359253,
-0.09537866711616516,
-0.10737624764442444,
0.27420270442962646,
-0.7136738896369934,
0.15755030512809753,
-0.30605611205101013,
-0.3602270185947418,
-0.187997505068779,
0.10859375447034836,
0.5149527788162231,
0.8074657917022705,
0.4001944065093994,
-0.036306653171777725,
-0.42841479182243347,
-0.8511684536933899,
-0.24852469563484192,
0.13128259778022766,
-0.17705996334552765,
0.7783448100090027,
0.5396572947502136,
0.14822141826152802,
0.9579693675041199,
-0.6170048713684082,
-0.036483850330114365,
0.11752709746360779,
0.20806171000003815,
-0.10111688822507858,
0.3417707085609436,
0.11571864038705826,
-0.9761544466018677,
-0.45695793628692627,
-0.1373693197965622,
-1.3022286891937256,
-0.14318233728408813,
0.10028455406427383,
-0.2914659082889557,
-0.027333632111549377,
0.968639075756073,
-0.5169763565063477,
0.5149497389793396,
0.23627272248268127,
0.007006191648542881,
0.7485854625701904,
-0.11967609822750092,
0.37677425146102905,
-0.8455066084861755,
0.25994300842285156,
-0.08253529667854309,
-0.04359329864382744,
-0.23097801208496094,
0.19186735153198242,
-0.2775673270225525,
-0.4497568607330322,
-0.7102941870689392,
0.7270120978355408,
-0.22756946086883545,
-0.6347846984863281,
0.23529452085494995,
0.6999037265777588,
-0.1617129147052765,
0.551575779914856,
0.21662642061710358,
0.553192138671875,
0.3683793246746063,
-0.6450103521347046,
0.6937544941902161,
0.37954017519950867,
-0.6944952011108398,
0.8622725605964661,
-0.33373457193374634,
-0.1640273779630661,
0.10836049914360046,
0.190779447555542,
-0.9540700316429138,
-0.5382465720176697,
-0.01890849694609642,
-0.3413383662700653,
-0.14345774054527283,
-0.15486231446266174,
-0.47157901525497437,
-0.3046855330467224,
0.03658859059214592,
0.48576173186302185,
0.3357403874397278,
-0.7081032395362854,
0.4262368679046631,
0.36324891448020935,
-0.04079563915729523,
-0.7059267163276672,
-0.5712329745292664,
-0.13783355057239532,
-0.04260876029729843,
-0.9370391368865967,
0.1297314167022705,
0.1311863511800766,
-0.391920268535614,
0.2740827798843384,
-0.5221318006515503,
-0.22468720376491547,
-0.062215812504291534,
0.34886521100997925,
0.009882177226245403,
-0.2861446142196655,
0.1768060326576233,
-0.013323146849870682,
-0.26417315006256104,
0.11306697875261307,
-0.2980845272541046,
-0.006250766571611166,
-0.33854565024375916,
-0.6853636503219604,
-0.028106823563575745,
0.3368852138519287,
0.3183446228504181,
-0.2132287323474884,
0.3227057456970215,
0.5793085694313049,
-0.4758286476135254,
-0.18684135377407074,
-0.6665279865264893,
-0.15037040412425995,
-0.4400314688682556,
0.36802202463150024,
-0.5890779495239258,
-0.8845070600509644,
0.3432304561138153,
-0.5916098952293396,
0.03650069236755371,
0.24163292348384857,
0.6250375509262085,
-0.47073954343795776,
0.8909508585929871,
-0.05096786841750145,
0.6267744898796082,
0.19279858469963074,
-0.47508248686790466,
0.2418464571237564,
-0.6137514114379883,
-0.3380003571510315,
-0.11115796118974686,
-0.4122067987918854,
-0.31285369396209717,
-0.7576383352279663,
0.7184290289878845,
0.22695793211460114,
-0.6607276201248169,
0.14589010179042816,
-0.32396289706230164,
0.5725127458572388,
0.6562002897262573,
0.08167880028486252,
0.08207651227712631,
-0.13841791450977325,
-0.451975554227829,
-0.0521271750330925,
-0.7426581382751465,
-0.6723197102546692,
0.8854856491088867,
-0.07167308777570724,
0.36528241634368896,
0.26063236594200134,
0.4434660077095032,
0.32330092787742615,
0.2676544785499573,
-0.3097708225250244,
0.9904214143753052,
-0.14077942073345184,
-0.6493613719940186,
-0.5992876887321472,
-0.2252224236726761,
-0.7461366653442383,
0.01599729061126709,
-0.20879609882831573,
-0.8576570749282837,
-0.1893526315689087,
0.2364688217639923,
-0.4656568467617035,
0.05810686945915222,
-0.4805334210395813,
1.3636949062347412,
-0.2117156982421875,
-1.0737087726593018,
-0.34661582112312317,
-0.8718529939651489,
0.6025528311729431,
0.42194944620132446,
0.2828389108181,
-0.20205770432949066,
0.28218892216682434,
0.3586593270301819,
-0.7125284075737,
0.5989627242088318,
-0.44583386182785034,
0.1984093338251114,
0.7017266154289246,
0.12512819468975067,
0.23662327229976654,
0.3110780119895935,
0.16074824333190918,
-0.06796780228614807,
0.09219948947429657,
-0.33733680844306946,
-0.8115308880805969,
0.7469766139984131,
-0.6887326240539551,
-0.5425154566764832,
-0.12407860904932022,
-0.5140673518180847,
-0.48258525133132935,
0.19339050352573395,
-0.08294299989938736,
0.6487776041030884,
-0.34150776267051697,
0.3038403391838074,
0.7836000323295593,
-0.3716278672218323,
0.09101519733667374,
0.38973113894462585,
0.06417853385210037,
-0.44860997796058655,
0.7328312397003174,
0.11032593995332718,
0.19881141185760498,
0.3767707347869873,
0.19025418162345886,
-0.49862852692604065,
-0.15425433218479156,
-0.7991905212402344,
-0.17793434858322144,
-0.9883192181587219,
-0.22376418113708496,
-0.3777760863304138,
-0.28034260869026184,
-0.474049836397171,
-0.36079251766204834,
-0.4499334990978241,
-0.35406455397605896,
0.19708870351314545,
-0.14585678279399872,
0.210569828748703,
0.33928781747817993,
-0.22252364456653595,
-0.17746689915657043,
-0.799754798412323,
0.6750406622886658,
0.9165952801704407,
0.47258442640304565,
-0.10165438055992126,
-0.15084703266620636,
-0.24270986020565033,
-0.13411381840705872,
-0.21782977879047394,
-0.5867655873298645,
-0.17058312892913818,
-0.026452727615833282,
0.909835159778595,
0.4830961525440216,
0.3385501205921173,
0.803878128528595,
-0.4889299273490906,
0.9310530424118042,
0.0076923551969230175,
-0.6251054406166077,
0.7724565863609314,
-0.47852036356925964,
0.33262211084365845,
0.7044739127159119,
0.34300464391708374,
-0.26656466722488403,
-0.05194967985153198,
-0.7111431360244751,
-0.5745515823364258,
0.7054186463356018,
0.08920354396104813,
-0.15236036479473114,
0.02104872465133667,
0.14146728813648224,
0.16314932703971863,
0.08835269510746002,
-0.5179522037506104,
0.19746805727481842,
-0.6080821752548218,
-0.2176012396812439,
0.24104076623916626,
-0.0896645188331604,
-0.5196976065635681,
-0.26278966665267944,
0.6305792331695557,
-0.45230790972709656,
-0.03673383966088295,
0.3317898213863373,
-0.33087435364723206,
-0.14825071394443512,
0.205732062458992,
0.5457968711853027,
0.5635330677032471,
-0.28104251623153687,
0.28139299154281616,
0.44240719079971313,
-0.1501573920249939,
0.08980252593755722,
0.1408015787601471,
-0.23966673016548157,
-0.3901906907558441,
0.2186649888753891,
0.5659785866737366,
0.656017541885376,
-1.1858534812927246,
0.5238544940948486,
0.12067358940839767,
-0.4524577856063843,
-0.25271496176719666,
0.08152377605438232,
0.13584712147712708,
0.5857645273208618,
0.07743251323699951,
-0.039663705974817276,
0.029484203085303307,
-0.5920829772949219,
0.35635480284690857,
0.25928711891174316,
-0.1387668401002884,
0.06021951884031296,
0.6718274354934692,
0.300715833902359,
-0.1394532173871994,
0.6887314319610596,
-0.22395701706409454,
-0.40033748745918274,
0.49074429273605347,
0.12494833767414093,
0.6561660170555115,
0.09485739469528198,
0.33890601992607117,
0.7345777750015259,
-0.12427733838558197,
-0.008398703299462795,
0.3578821122646332,
-0.7188494205474854,
-0.7900024056434631,
-0.34666183590888977,
-0.5078339576721191,
-0.575246274471283,
0.058940812945365906,
-0.529517650604248,
0.1905311793088913,
-0.5634521245956421,
0.15400873124599457,
-0.21184800565242767,
0.09699956327676773,
-0.6282213926315308,
0.5644975304603577,
0.2598915994167328,
0.9902967214584351,
-0.8699038624763489,
0.5361083745956421,
0.8265421986579895,
-0.38950949907302856,
-0.8488636612892151,
-0.14051073789596558,
0.013977641239762306,
-0.7910635471343994,
0.8536121249198914,
0.25095149874687195,
-0.12696099281311035,
-0.1800064593553543,
-0.7778036594390869,
-0.9430432915687561,
1.2288898229599,
0.20379020273685455,
-0.12859784066677094,
0.4406239092350006,
0.2290748953819275,
0.4805229604244232,
-0.21237494051456451,
0.1636175662279129,
0.47251927852630615,
0.5335190296173096,
0.5578292012214661,
-0.5972719788551331,
0.11241892725229263,
-0.4671343266963959,
-0.2899959981441498,
-0.040550347417593,
-0.6173304319381714,
0.43700650334358215,
-0.10698767751455307,
0.08234383165836334,
-0.03540710732340813,
0.5744648575782776,
0.8648706078529358,
0.702345073223114,
0.5652928352355957,
0.8226731419563293,
0.37374818325042725,
-0.040503110736608505,
0.666245698928833,
0.02680210955440998,
-0.1646857112646103,
1.3316339254379272,
-0.44276103377342224,
1.0600858926773071,
0.44617760181427,
-0.14540688693523407,
0.6317659616470337,
0.617482602596283,
-0.10726628452539444,
0.5770383477210999,
0.2849704325199127,
-0.1748984307050705,
-0.6832893490791321,
-0.2537505328655243,
-0.35837697982788086,
0.6261941194534302,
0.16443926095962524,
0.03754906356334686,
-0.28145259618759155,
-0.16087929904460907,
-0.5286813378334045,
0.46750882267951965,
-0.30372780561447144,
0.7393473982810974,
-0.10298065096139908,
-1.1553457975387573,
0.4623083770275116,
-0.2370370328426361,
-0.1742948591709137,
-0.5642552375793457,
-0.1434931457042694,
-0.10462120175361633,
0.18296149373054504,
-0.17939162254333496,
-0.8796408772468567,
0.2573806345462799,
0.28865110874176025,
0.02186882682144642,
-0.4759959578514099,
0.8102189898490906,
-0.17885136604309082,
-0.2931246757507324,
-0.1585179716348648,
0.46829622983932495,
0.5054706335067749,
0.01668168604373932,
-0.5445689558982849,
-0.1369016021490097,
-0.3319418430328369,
-0.13223814964294434,
0.40430381894111633,
0.6854134798049927,
-0.3635343015193939,
0.6240007877349854,
0.6178148984909058,
-0.4150376617908478,
0.03755372390151024,
0.2532026469707489,
0.9254289865493774,
-0.5301830172538757,
-0.5871977210044861,
-0.31244879961013794,
0.7396534085273743,
-0.418466717004776,
-0.27466338872909546,
0.7021514177322388,
0.6472413539886475,
0.9355159997940063,
-0.07465080916881561,
0.7066218256950378,
-0.24044489860534668,
0.3627517819404602,
-0.5775162577629089,
0.3953014612197876,
-0.7197737693786621,
0.04558268189430237,
-0.35318711400032043,
-0.8282279968261719,
-0.1861785352230072,
0.7772754430770874,
-0.6188786029815674,
-0.1200670599937439,
0.5622152090072632,
0.7511477470397949,
-0.1658756136894226,
0.1618577390909195,
0.36382532119750977,
0.22030387818813324,
-0.00963418185710907,
0.35029056668281555,
1.0636167526245117,
-0.3740572929382324,
0.7698308229446411,
-0.11878133565187454,
-0.28928035497665405,
-0.28812170028686523,
-1.1444377899169922,
-0.6989778876304626,
-0.4199603497982025,
-0.3645876348018646,
-0.1482703536748886,
0.07652445882558823,
0.6404210329055786,
0.8687422275543213,
-0.6543381214141846,
-0.12840214371681213,
-0.3125099539756775,
0.054746609181165695,
-0.5756209492683411,
-0.2033253163099289,
0.36175206303596497,
-0.10155878961086273,
-0.3187192380428314,
0.47091609239578247,
0.37446874380111694,
-0.4322376847267151,
-0.4194490313529968,
-0.32920846343040466,
-0.4343678653240204,
-0.17578397691249847,
0.5054078698158264,
0.4402393102645874,
-0.8124532699584961,
-0.5167299509048462,
0.1694202870130539,
0.14118769764900208,
-0.13866664469242096,
0.7692287564277649,
-0.9022122621536255,
0.5541151165962219,
0.5450491309165955,
0.525647759437561,
0.81477952003479,
0.209906667470932,
0.541492760181427,
-1.014051079750061,
0.007569923531264067,
0.2539345920085907,
0.08880694210529327,
0.3368864953517914,
0.00314419437199831,
0.709051251411438,
0.39939507842063904,
-0.46936947107315063,
-0.9104863405227661,
0.30436089634895325,
-0.7739293575286865,
-0.27422869205474854,
0.9406779408454895,
-0.315456748008728,
-0.23537760972976685,
-0.05532118305563927,
-0.05828672647476196,
0.3479068875312805,
0.1073489636182785,
0.8205850124359131,
0.48732152581214905,
-0.313370019197464,
-0.28250616788864136,
-0.6041198372840881,
0.5261531472206116,
0.46131399273872375,
-0.9206533432006836,
0.17717140913009644,
0.6521285176277161,
0.09903576225042343,
0.02714095450937748,
0.49413102865219116,
0.08290001004934311,
0.535379946231842,
0.5277193784713745,
-0.14075839519500732,
-0.28546562790870667,
-0.3176860809326172,
0.34293943643569946,
0.3358129560947418,
-0.3336588144302368,
-0.12300719320774078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09711v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09711v1
|
STAR: A Benchmark for Situated Reasoning in Real-World Videos
| 2024-05-15T21:53:54 | 2024-05-15T21:53:54 |
Bo Wu, Shoubin Yu, Zhenfang Chen, Joshua B Tenenbaum, Chuang Gan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Reasoning in the real world is not divorced from situations. How to capture
the present knowledge from surrounding situations and perform reasoning
accordingly is crucial and challenging for machine intelligence. This paper
introduces a new benchmark that evaluates the situated reasoning ability via
situation abstraction and logic-grounded question answering for real-world
videos, called Situated Reasoning in Real-World Videos (STAR Benchmark). This
benchmark is built upon the real-world videos associated with human actions or
interactions, which are naturally dynamic, compositional, and logical. The
dataset includes four types of questions, including interaction, sequence,
prediction, and feasibility. We represent the situations in real-world videos
by hyper-graphs connecting extracted atomic entities and relations (e.g.,
actions, persons, objects, and relationships). Besides visual perception,
situated reasoning also requires structured situation comprehension and logical
reasoning. Questions and answers are procedurally generated. The answering
logic of each question is represented by a functional program based on a
situation hyper-graph. We compare various existing video reasoning models and
find that they all struggle on this challenging situated reasoning task. We
further propose a diagnostic neuro-symbolic model that can disentangle visual
perception, situation abstraction, language understanding, and functional
reasoning to understand the challenges of this benchmark.
|
[
-0.5965449213981628,
-1.271514654159546,
0.7289004325866699,
-0.16916993260383606,
0.0007882596109993756,
0.036547787487506866,
-0.02521984651684761,
-0.4265519976615906,
-0.1261581927537918,
0.3327315151691437,
-0.8486966490745544,
-0.34490689635276794,
-0.46393561363220215,
0.02373829483985901,
-0.20223170518875122,
0.32051923871040344,
-0.09340740740299225,
-0.1991257518529892,
-0.5488423109054565,
-0.38245314359664917,
-0.7910869121551514,
-0.39580008387565613,
-0.15603993833065033,
0.01270386017858982,
0.3046456575393677,
0.4755510687828064,
0.9653685688972473,
0.6896184086799622,
0.8275922536849976,
0.4807787239551544,
0.08454860001802444,
0.27674755454063416,
0.01630394347012043,
0.28113991022109985,
-0.21534201502799988,
-0.12133905291557312,
-0.1785355806350708,
0.15912260115146637,
0.5701294541358948,
0.8423475623130798,
0.31495973467826843,
0.540177583694458,
-0.3700593411922455,
0.2490929663181305,
-0.9195275902748108,
0.034906890243291855,
-0.2728990912437439,
0.3572706878185272,
0.36960113048553467,
0.09311392903327942,
-0.07975572347640991,
-0.39307981729507446,
-0.14624004065990448,
-0.7109914422035217,
0.06447360664606094,
0.05448569729924202,
0.9957363605499268,
0.79931640625,
-0.4083672761917114,
0.23872509598731995,
-0.9069487452507019,
0.3133881390094757,
-0.2207055538892746,
0.6297426819801331,
0.3895779550075531,
0.9839164614677429,
0.05503392592072487,
-0.7506040334701538,
-0.7519445419311523,
-0.18953979015350342,
0.07881137728691101,
0.04236938804388046,
-0.09526468813419342,
-0.23050610721111298,
0.6887420415878296,
-0.1289997100830078,
-0.5825201869010925,
-0.30636686086654663,
-0.12813496589660645,
-0.21856512129306793,
0.46980151534080505,
0.24569115042686462,
0.29280033707618713,
-0.6427921056747437,
-0.22672879695892334,
-0.17329858243465424,
-0.4358395040035248,
0.2501170337200165,
-0.10789556801319122,
-0.13467149436473846,
-0.08873368054628372,
0.4201974868774414,
-0.3473479747772217,
0.826493501663208,
-0.18329666554927826,
-0.12780411541461945,
0.024676965549588203,
-0.09195876121520996,
-0.31126391887664795,
-0.017513031139969826,
0.20572015643119812,
0.5926806330680847,
0.34369292855262756,
0.22461561858654022,
0.024271883070468903,
0.2614377439022064,
0.3441010117530823,
-0.6182984709739685,
-0.29777684807777405,
0.2491835206747055,
-0.469648540019989,
-0.05366005748510361,
0.012043346650898457,
-0.3903273344039917,
-0.19122542440891266,
-0.5388184189796448,
0.6089128255844116,
-0.30073535442352295,
-0.2617205083370209,
-0.27794045209884644,
0.0043014222756028175,
0.082829549908638,
0.40552833676338196,
-0.46775999665260315,
0.2871304452419281,
0.9555671811103821,
0.5717175006866455,
0.4231315553188324,
-0.48069852590560913,
-0.961906373500824,
0.06218305975198746,
-0.2564050853252411,
0.9292183518409729,
-0.43587636947631836,
0.17623628675937653,
0.08555047959089279,
0.11705079674720764,
0.013621745631098747,
-0.6876503825187683,
0.36125534772872925,
-0.5104859471321106,
-0.13923071324825287,
-0.5394721627235413,
-0.33962613344192505,
-0.4114081561565399,
0.9248425364494324,
-0.5781348347663879,
1.0705336332321167,
-0.06591836363077164,
-0.4138612151145935,
0.5857282280921936,
-0.42433178424835205,
-0.19016119837760925,
0.1080860123038292,
-0.3890450894832611,
-0.035336919128894806,
-0.34036505222320557,
0.165760800242424,
0.4446749985218048,
-0.15096184611320496,
0.6223307847976685,
-0.5149546265602112,
-0.6136630177497864,
0.4721601903438568,
-0.3786478042602539,
0.19060617685317993,
0.287136971950531,
-0.31349071860313416,
0.07422928512096405,
-0.6332966089248657,
0.21550492942333221,
-0.17601925134658813,
0.2669800817966461,
-0.13954193890094757,
0.24105572700500488,
-0.2188427597284317,
0.7118114829063416,
0.11263490468263626,
-0.3270593285560608,
-0.10370431840419769,
0.07302391529083252,
0.335480272769928,
0.36837053298950195,
0.2459781914949417,
0.022268125787377357,
0.022695034742355347,
0.21193967759609222,
0.1333451122045517,
0.5045671463012695,
0.0910973995923996,
-0.4016788899898529,
-0.5090661644935608,
-0.20991666615009308,
-0.02208312600851059,
0.6231792569160461,
-0.6017469167709351,
0.4002719819545746,
-0.21918834745883942,
-0.363211065530777,
-0.2738284170627594,
-0.20816847681999207,
0.4274279773235321,
0.8603472113609314,
0.3538401424884796,
0.13008692860603333,
-0.35277655720710754,
-0.9416421055793762,
-0.18073876202106476,
-0.1568349152803421,
0.03662288933992386,
0.5054996609687805,
0.7205609679222107,
-0.075642891228199,
0.8227829933166504,
-0.7040378451347351,
0.15628601610660553,
0.07221240550279617,
0.13357146084308624,
0.23825204372406006,
0.29090067744255066,
0.08239127695560455,
-1.1119258403778076,
-0.11351896077394485,
-0.11884284019470215,
-1.4729689359664917,
0.12496089190244675,
-0.06495951861143112,
-0.06669152528047562,
-0.2809537947177887,
0.7836998701095581,
-0.6753550171852112,
0.4506836533546448,
0.24572673439979553,
-0.519239068031311,
0.5096514225006104,
-0.3016214072704315,
0.6736103296279907,
-0.6453657150268555,
0.17971009016036987,
0.07577569782733917,
-0.16502220928668976,
-0.18642759323120117,
0.10480191558599472,
-0.0872335433959961,
-0.6837010383605957,
-0.5741199851036072,
0.5433297157287598,
-0.21567346155643463,
-0.5914087891578674,
-0.05270208418369293,
0.6512945294380188,
-0.1932273805141449,
0.5596002340316772,
0.3174901008605957,
0.4497416615486145,
0.6494362354278564,
-0.6915407180786133,
0.558465301990509,
0.4186668395996094,
-0.4317026734352112,
0.8970431089401245,
-0.5358814597129822,
-0.40002456307411194,
-0.1043483167886734,
0.1402086466550827,
-0.9324874877929688,
-0.4187992811203003,
0.05841991677880287,
-0.43217191100120544,
-0.3814021944999695,
-0.2792447805404663,
-0.4053908586502075,
-0.2809164226055145,
0.3210446834564209,
0.5012619495391846,
0.5945380330085754,
-0.5395775437355042,
0.3668668270111084,
0.2904660403728485,
0.025204962119460106,
-0.4995766580104828,
-0.29473334550857544,
0.040387071669101715,
-0.3114100992679596,
-0.7932879328727722,
0.1854783296585083,
0.10788796097040176,
-0.5791131258010864,
0.33126360177993774,
-0.27508658170700073,
-0.3232431411743164,
0.12780144810676575,
0.47494664788246155,
0.16899389028549194,
-0.15453068912029266,
0.1278342306613922,
-0.14801214635372162,
-0.46141818165779114,
0.29354867339134216,
0.04719904437661171,
-0.15968072414398193,
-0.31954216957092285,
-0.7158078551292419,
-0.4410080909729004,
0.4343687891960144,
0.626336932182312,
-0.229670450091362,
0.2474743127822876,
0.5916665196418762,
-0.7910720705986023,
-0.03917594999074936,
-0.46518078446388245,
-0.34460169076919556,
-0.4396938979625702,
0.37316954135894775,
-0.551901638507843,
-0.6531861424446106,
0.5021950006484985,
-0.47150442004203796,
-0.15506763756275177,
0.12270286679267883,
0.3614661395549774,
-0.3179718255996704,
1.1163334846496582,
0.10868430882692337,
0.3989085853099823,
0.1386401206254959,
-0.3543497323989868,
0.44643595814704895,
-0.5740428566932678,
-0.3984435200691223,
-0.23889294266700745,
-0.5040555000305176,
-0.40279170870780945,
-0.5555992126464844,
0.7777867317199707,
0.21943823993206024,
-0.8120771646499634,
0.4396210312843323,
-0.45157021284103394,
0.5818805694580078,
0.3428962528705597,
0.02066984213888645,
0.15514148771762848,
-0.33170199394226074,
-0.1976223587989807,
-0.27414819598197937,
-0.7438670992851257,
-0.71405029296875,
0.32132506370544434,
0.14076538383960724,
0.13918428122997284,
0.2912585437297821,
0.26390889286994934,
0.47679266333580017,
0.1472690999507904,
-0.5920602679252625,
0.9187926650047302,
0.04845082759857178,
-0.6286906599998474,
-0.20655451714992523,
-0.2083379626274109,
-0.6861141920089722,
0.3280232846736908,
-0.3432583808898926,
-0.7939493656158447,
-0.0960473120212555,
0.1908443570137024,
-0.44236329197883606,
0.2185760885477066,
-0.5217595100402832,
1.350872278213501,
-0.26407933235168457,
-0.8352312445640564,
-0.2786279618740082,
-0.8092408776283264,
0.4056594967842102,
0.4548609256744385,
0.4087132215499878,
-0.2372463047504425,
0.33127734065055847,
0.33314990997314453,
-0.5594962239265442,
0.6082248687744141,
-0.3353204131126404,
0.4238676428794861,
0.6337157487869263,
0.575786828994751,
0.34376558661460876,
0.3773929178714752,
0.22660201787948608,
-0.09037221223115921,
0.06857950240373611,
-0.27303600311279297,
-0.942710816860199,
0.8365710973739624,
-0.6558334827423096,
-0.4317343533039093,
-0.46672487258911133,
-0.3492211103439331,
-0.45998361706733704,
-0.024528570473194122,
-0.06421670317649841,
0.6846932768821716,
-0.2613038122653961,
0.13830605149269104,
0.5843830108642578,
-0.011104782111942768,
0.4829103946685791,
0.23787185549736023,
0.10412629693746567,
-0.3566219210624695,
0.7211969494819641,
-0.07007380574941635,
-0.052439168095588684,
0.38721078634262085,
-0.03406769782304764,
-0.45564302802085876,
-0.10093824565410614,
-0.5374727845191956,
-0.003384356154128909,
-1.0830433368682861,
-0.09344890713691711,
-0.44886913895606995,
-0.2128448337316513,
0.10949639976024628,
-0.4405202865600586,
-0.5206323862075806,
-0.26974135637283325,
0.20624640583992004,
-0.17856036126613617,
0.18362200260162354,
0.3485651910305023,
0.01111725065857172,
-0.24799922108650208,
-0.9588385224342346,
0.6149885058403015,
0.6134186387062073,
0.40979716181755066,
-0.14957641065120697,
-0.24701805412769318,
-0.16227014362812042,
-0.13828174769878387,
-0.2654235064983368,
-0.6337113976478577,
-0.05844729766249657,
-0.20615388453006744,
0.7745968103408813,
0.3330383896827698,
0.039551716297864914,
0.8989465236663818,
-0.3514687120914459,
0.8254272937774658,
-0.05274330824613571,
-0.7081563472747803,
0.6271408200263977,
-0.41711708903312683,
0.2266348898410797,
0.6362214684486389,
0.4700183868408203,
-0.5328911542892456,
0.13030323386192322,
-0.8232457637786865,
-0.42586180567741394,
0.2697567641735077,
0.29086005687713623,
-0.25357288122177124,
-0.26122328639030457,
0.2561589777469635,
-0.26210924983024597,
-0.0391182042658329,
-0.43052124977111816,
0.03497482091188431,
-0.3755771517753601,
0.1193912923336029,
0.016550010070204735,
0.2805737555027008,
-0.2898373305797577,
-0.5115720629692078,
0.24364209175109863,
-0.16554352641105652,
0.24947024881839752,
0.4387110769748688,
-0.27712884545326233,
0.05747134983539581,
-0.06895799934864044,
0.3598191440105438,
0.5537634491920471,
-0.361994206905365,
0.38308659195899963,
0.25560739636421204,
-0.08367469906806946,
0.25176575779914856,
-0.13051237165927887,
0.041713401675224304,
-0.18208478391170502,
0.5762147307395935,
0.5445077419281006,
0.6822718977928162,
-0.9307234287261963,
0.4431537687778473,
0.1627035140991211,
-0.32177188992500305,
-0.44379210472106934,
0.20947447419166565,
0.044647302478551865,
0.4514983892440796,
-0.04565400630235672,
0.2696622312068939,
0.15523071587085724,
-0.7111653685569763,
0.519722580909729,
0.10190743207931519,
-0.5775471925735474,
-0.23646444082260132,
0.859279990196228,
0.3200211524963379,
-0.5672789216041565,
1.0378799438476562,
-0.22732174396514893,
-0.4117063879966736,
0.8287872672080994,
0.30988776683807373,
0.7825400829315186,
0.397748202085495,
0.4664387106895447,
0.8470795154571533,
-0.058568891137838364,
-0.010701787658035755,
0.3274197280406952,
-0.36168140172958374,
-0.7044645547866821,
-0.3246653378009796,
-0.17809933423995972,
-0.6737311482429504,
-0.13873723149299622,
-0.41887733340263367,
0.13844899833202362,
-0.590762734413147,
-0.12132830172777176,
0.04025103151798248,
-0.0074968161061406136,
-0.499855637550354,
0.6512542366981506,
0.17623071372509003,
0.8177365064620972,
-1.0060232877731323,
0.4400801956653595,
0.8073232769966125,
-0.4029817581176758,
-0.6694009304046631,
-0.09762568771839142,
0.1011582762002945,
-0.30104804039001465,
0.7497611045837402,
0.22260123491287231,
-0.2597930431365967,
-0.3228779137134552,
-0.42665359377861023,
-0.7166769504547119,
1.0846043825149536,
0.09637951105833054,
-0.06862381845712662,
0.49389854073524475,
-0.10993394255638123,
0.6130574941635132,
-0.34859704971313477,
0.3230713903903961,
0.4020496904850006,
0.5870221853256226,
0.3437756896018982,
-0.5202057957649231,
0.10501979291439056,
-0.6269967555999756,
-0.33892592787742615,
0.29403483867645264,
-0.5315265655517578,
0.7728967070579529,
-0.24086233973503113,
0.1431226283311844,
-0.3152851164340973,
0.5261527895927429,
0.7105187773704529,
0.668694019317627,
0.6043355464935303,
0.42703747749328613,
0.5440925359725952,
-0.1724953055381775,
0.8316872119903564,
-0.23784193396568298,
0.09189295768737793,
0.8636026382446289,
-0.5267816781997681,
0.9289630651473999,
0.47569867968559265,
-0.007025763392448425,
0.7749289870262146,
0.6837101578712463,
-0.09104543924331665,
0.32535839080810547,
0.12433716654777527,
-0.3123958110809326,
-1.0086472034454346,
-0.04006650671362877,
-0.26103127002716064,
0.7261358499526978,
0.18189901113510132,
0.15848270058631897,
-0.2710458040237427,
-0.21559134125709534,
-0.31466132402420044,
0.5653436779975891,
-0.0956205502152443,
0.46467795968055725,
-0.14594711363315582,
-1.2862738370895386,
0.6131055355072021,
-0.05027049407362938,
-0.1809866726398468,
-0.41761064529418945,
-0.42925673723220825,
-0.11959856003522873,
0.2622668445110321,
-0.16936731338500977,
-0.8545103669166565,
0.4251677095890045,
0.2088857740163803,
-0.035492412745952606,
-0.09412866085767746,
0.6209837198257446,
0.13311901688575745,
-0.3003968298435211,
0.03133175149559975,
0.558918833732605,
0.40249553322792053,
-0.14818035066127777,
-0.68515545129776,
-0.10245294868946075,
-0.46334388852119446,
-0.07892125099897385,
0.3330969512462616,
0.46944352984428406,
-0.5656836628913879,
0.9891307353973389,
0.6215879321098328,
-0.43417176604270935,
-0.3061087429523468,
0.11116576194763184,
0.6045211553573608,
-1.0183244943618774,
-0.6134397983551025,
-0.5197120904922485,
0.6507943868637085,
-0.26030170917510986,
-0.41395583748817444,
0.5707005262374878,
0.4870195686817169,
0.5196099877357483,
-0.1246001124382019,
0.4650423228740692,
-0.38863134384155273,
0.09648852050304413,
-0.4122505187988281,
0.28887468576431274,
-0.5279931426048279,
0.06391984224319458,
-0.35386618971824646,
-0.8372389078140259,
-0.359353631734848,
0.7940848469734192,
-0.38118812441825867,
0.0013657460222020745,
0.8782488107681274,
0.702100396156311,
-0.3948653042316437,
0.01841374859213829,
0.45698076486587524,
-0.04948021471500397,
0.07745935022830963,
0.5992039442062378,
1.013495683670044,
-0.48294228315353394,
0.46896496415138245,
-0.2598174512386322,
-0.22720284759998322,
-0.21736198663711548,
-1.1123950481414795,
-0.6246587634086609,
-0.6530888080596924,
-0.6366734504699707,
-0.16329219937324524,
0.0635966807603836,
0.7385518550872803,
1.0169093608856201,
-0.41009965538978577,
-0.08244827389717102,
-0.18478231132030487,
0.3450949490070343,
-0.9145937561988831,
-0.1683664470911026,
0.2974182665348053,
0.1004214808344841,
-0.4076097309589386,
0.49438783526420593,
0.36433926224708557,
-0.3562069833278656,
-0.21013961732387543,
-0.13854429125785828,
-0.4037071466445923,
-0.1339673399925232,
0.6674142479896545,
0.5026838779449463,
-0.6169617772102356,
-0.7927934527397156,
0.16324178874492645,
0.12884306907653809,
-0.10708387941122055,
0.7563880681991577,
-0.9496351480484009,
0.2586512863636017,
0.623484194278717,
0.2908703684806824,
0.470525324344635,
0.3515414595603943,
0.27654632925987244,
-0.5518305897712708,
0.2761540710926056,
0.18633899092674255,
0.2315538078546524,
0.23809635639190674,
-0.23458246886730194,
0.4700623154640198,
0.603644073009491,
-0.5110160112380981,
-0.7621421813964844,
0.4455099403858185,
-1.0519638061523438,
-0.3707897663116455,
0.8057417869567871,
-0.08191563934087753,
-0.1183103621006012,
-0.19357185065746307,
0.0341760516166687,
0.2697964906692505,
0.23152309656143188,
0.8093743324279785,
0.575462281703949,
-0.4367050230503082,
-0.32661759853363037,
-0.8526756763458252,
0.3765609860420227,
0.42734602093696594,
-0.9558183550834656,
0.054178014397621155,
0.763192892074585,
0.1937248408794403,
-0.00015806737064849585,
0.32958194613456726,
0.017307840287685394,
0.6634641885757446,
0.468959778547287,
-0.2435612678527832,
-0.3661731481552124,
-0.7316754460334778,
0.16728617250919342,
0.5142953991889954,
-0.27527734637260437,
-0.28132930397987366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09679v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09679v1
|
Simulating Policy Impacts: Developing a Generative Scenario Writing Method to Evaluate the Perceived Effects of Regulation
| 2024-05-15T19:44:54 | 2024-05-15T19:44:54 |
Julia Barnett, Kimon Kieslich, Nicholas Diakopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of AI technologies yields numerous future impacts on
individuals and society. Policy-makers are therefore tasked to react quickly
and establish policies that mitigate those impacts. However, anticipating the
effectiveness of policies is a difficult task, as some impacts might only be
observable in the future and respective policies might not be applicable to the
future development of AI. In this work we develop a method for using large
language models (LLMs) to evaluate the efficacy of a given piece of policy at
mitigating specified negative impacts. We do so by using GPT-4 to generate
scenarios both pre- and post-introduction of policy and translating these vivid
stories into metrics based on human perceptions of impacts. We leverage an
already established taxonomy of impacts of generative AI in the media
environment to generate a set of scenario pairs both mitigated and
non-mitigated by the transparency legislation of Article 50 of the EU AI Act.
We then run a user study (n=234) to evaluate these scenarios across four
risk-assessment dimensions: severity, plausibility, magnitude, and specificity
to vulnerable populations. We find that this transparency legislation is
perceived to be effective at mitigating harms in areas such as labor and
well-being, but largely ineffective in areas such as social cohesion and
security. Through this case study on generative AI harms we demonstrate the
efficacy of our method as a tool to iterate on the effectiveness of policy on
mitigating various negative impacts. We expect this method to be useful to
researchers or other stakeholders who want to brainstorm the potential utility
of different pieces of policy or other mitigation strategies.
|
[
-0.30700814723968506,
-0.8998691439628601,
0.5724587440490723,
0.3053952157497406,
0.0743226483464241,
-0.008378182537853718,
-0.11376234143972397,
-0.29897403717041016,
0.07759236544370651,
0.562910795211792,
-0.43561476469039917,
-0.40635427832603455,
-0.3227529525756836,
0.04339291900396347,
-0.39887741208076477,
1.040502905845642,
-0.005639779381453991,
-0.20169629156589508,
-0.1251407116651535,
0.6595833897590637,
-0.7360849976539612,
-0.571857750415802,
-0.5330947637557983,
-0.22028547525405884,
0.39098116755485535,
0.2037920355796814,
0.5131107568740845,
0.08655446022748947,
0.4500659108161926,
0.36383962631225586,
-0.21958579123020172,
-0.2764759957790375,
-0.6440523266792297,
-0.38751161098480225,
-0.07725675404071808,
-0.5680370330810547,
-0.04094249755144119,
0.40981560945510864,
0.7637537121772766,
0.18580469489097595,
-0.37798407673835754,
-0.1094125434756279,
0.4298451840877533,
0.02488517202436924,
-0.6184859871864319,
0.24321408569812775,
-0.593798816204071,
0.19094757735729218,
0.07091660052537918,
-0.46566808223724365,
-0.3922748565673828,
-0.20839081704616547,
0.15072762966156006,
-0.3934347629547119,
-0.17508640885353088,
0.1052095890045166,
0.8822008371353149,
0.20477932691574097,
-0.5088412761688232,
-0.4212293028831482,
-1.1501762866973877,
0.6874322295188904,
-0.7304854989051819,
-0.02223336137831211,
0.42713409662246704,
0.15825702250003815,
-0.3364134430885315,
-0.7956029176712036,
-0.8262489438056946,
-0.561447262763977,
-0.07240750640630722,
0.3485787510871887,
-0.19844123721122742,
0.4106212854385376,
0.4534788727760315,
0.3761635422706604,
-0.27606549859046936,
0.16980214416980743,
-0.5840262770652771,
-0.5108873248100281,
0.5730782747268677,
0.3228755593299866,
0.32393643260002136,
-0.25863876938819885,
-0.33423641324043274,
-0.16520822048187256,
-0.7908703684806824,
-0.05862689018249512,
0.8973338603973389,
0.10225290805101395,
-0.39811763167381287,
0.6517292857170105,
0.03690404072403908,
0.31262141466140747,
-0.39831677079200745,
-0.31147459149360657,
0.17734242975711823,
-0.49921879172325134,
-0.0962892547249794,
-0.2318379431962967,
0.5876240730285645,
0.4272165298461914,
-0.023567931726574898,
0.019028857350349426,
-0.18943381309509277,
0.2986356317996979,
0.3685511648654938,
-0.6684496998786926,
0.16247953474521637,
0.15400013327598572,
-0.3784530460834503,
-0.5434542298316956,
-0.04032272472977638,
-0.9387701153755188,
-0.4870903789997101,
-0.4738861322402954,
0.6294515132904053,
-0.188612163066864,
-0.1930880844593048,
0.1493016481399536,
-0.18983308970928192,
0.5691978335380554,
0.2044593095779419,
-0.6458807587623596,
0.16281600296497345,
0.781484842300415,
0.8188075423240662,
0.1131383404135704,
-0.08583969622850418,
-0.10998623818159103,
0.2503635585308075,
-0.2506195902824402,
0.5661195516586304,
-0.43988701701164246,
-0.8020934462547302,
0.22992132604122162,
-0.30888453125953674,
0.06928334385156631,
-0.3865489959716797,
0.5805568695068359,
-0.19487622380256653,
0.1423286497592926,
-0.031336504966020584,
-0.6999397277832031,
-0.012090254575014114,
0.4887627065181732,
-0.801266610622406,
0.23080892860889435,
-0.098598413169384,
-0.559923529624939,
0.47227537631988525,
-1.0010522603988647,
-0.5698082447052002,
0.035112522542476654,
-0.5088514685630798,
-0.5268254280090332,
-0.12528347969055176,
-0.11396048963069916,
0.26240044832229614,
-0.15808062255382538,
0.34400492906570435,
-0.09143160283565521,
-0.3495345413684845,
-0.0130241634324193,
-0.9097954630851746,
0.8583264350891113,
0.1261124461889267,
-0.47034069895744324,
0.45816969871520996,
-0.3270340859889984,
-0.16172245144844055,
-0.2375113070011139,
-0.40531525015830994,
0.022791296243667603,
-0.043320924043655396,
0.08377784490585327,
0.20377804338932037,
-0.0204775370657444,
-0.47449731826782227,
0.16208325326442719,
-0.18876755237579346,
0.640740692615509,
1.0157536268234253,
0.45304128527641296,
0.3343340754508972,
-0.38828837871551514,
0.992273211479187,
-0.1798875629901886,
0.5134701728820801,
-0.0783805325627327,
-0.46073970198631287,
-0.33857813477516174,
-0.3265936076641083,
0.3459019064903259,
0.4698837995529175,
-0.9935973286628723,
0.16164307296276093,
-0.08922336250543594,
-0.2360893338918686,
-0.4120637774467468,
-0.16409428417682648,
0.34512415528297424,
0.5155133605003357,
-0.06878677010536194,
-0.16044454276561737,
-0.4991084039211273,
-0.8681183457374573,
-0.20141838490962982,
-0.4491525888442993,
0.12485332041978836,
0.2802619934082031,
0.9005494117736816,
-0.14080502092838287,
0.8870687484741211,
-0.3977802097797394,
-0.4518145024776459,
-0.24772639572620392,
0.4132784307003021,
-0.0771300196647644,
0.5399710536003113,
0.17697972059249878,
-0.938226580619812,
-0.10434943437576294,
-0.3476962447166443,
-0.6465256810188293,
0.3351629972457886,
-0.5946106910705566,
0.008957073092460632,
0.15977874398231506,
0.4797557592391968,
-0.5603342652320862,
0.609828531742096,
0.4762301743030548,
-0.39408788084983826,
0.830783486366272,
-0.38057640194892883,
0.3380456566810608,
-0.9324373006820679,
0.13376770913600922,
0.1450149267911911,
0.1326049268245697,
-0.6112160086631775,
0.09465248882770538,
-0.2394820749759674,
-0.22472317516803741,
-0.6983789205551147,
0.45188260078430176,
-0.25378772616386414,
-0.011312547139823437,
0.10384970158338547,
-0.45994386076927185,
-0.11539802700281143,
0.09256613254547119,
-0.09792567044496536,
1.1157912015914917,
0.16017670929431915,
-0.34559062123298645,
-0.06106235459446907,
0.11161497980356216,
-0.7370734810829163,
0.4753856658935547,
-0.4658754765987396,
-0.020000802353024483,
-0.17828468978405,
0.47881555557250977,
-0.3088150918483734,
-0.21835626661777496,
0.30078625679016113,
-0.12981559336185455,
0.12745167315006256,
0.14881406724452972,
-0.7598749399185181,
-0.6097502708435059,
-0.4167625308036804,
0.11369463056325912,
0.6174185872077942,
-0.15433363616466522,
0.7820428609848022,
0.5222326517105103,
0.08586503565311432,
-0.35430842638015747,
-0.5932247638702393,
0.5805063247680664,
-0.8083974719047546,
-0.4127912223339081,
0.40681377053260803,
-0.19610655307769775,
-0.39217060804367065,
0.05421484261751175,
0.336934894323349,
0.1548704206943512,
0.4080754816532135,
0.3536001443862915,
0.17996492981910706,
0.1840362548828125,
-0.15028612315654755,
-0.06587453186511993,
-0.09965020418167114,
0.2167537659406662,
0.08370813727378845,
0.47409340739250183,
-0.2975510060787201,
-0.22546111047267914,
-0.7102495431900024,
0.4726015031337738,
0.3370595872402191,
-0.219114750623703,
0.6294921040534973,
0.3022858500480652,
-0.3170726001262665,
-0.15737102925777435,
-0.40826863050460815,
-0.22730755805969238,
-0.5208032727241516,
0.4383155405521393,
-0.43813517689704895,
-0.7118175029754639,
0.45765721797943115,
-0.36245158314704895,
0.037599291652441025,
0.30525311827659607,
0.6305644512176514,
-0.12393246591091156,
0.736730694770813,
0.7874151468276978,
-0.18799908459186554,
0.5983638167381287,
-0.5605902075767517,
0.2399275004863739,
-0.6225553750991821,
-0.3824111521244049,
-0.26395100355148315,
0.001406508032232523,
-0.6716216206550598,
-0.31514623761177063,
0.5916445255279541,
0.05750022456049919,
-0.007583370432257652,
0.14129287004470825,
-0.18552720546722412,
0.5515731573104858,
0.7552140355110168,
0.15338274836540222,
0.3857506215572357,
-0.0067136287689208984,
0.15674664080142975,
0.148920938372612,
-0.5683441758155823,
-0.7116793394088745,
1.1978589296340942,
0.41986092925071716,
0.8515569567680359,
0.1079733818769455,
0.7982289791107178,
0.7929946184158325,
0.8328836560249329,
-0.5457730889320374,
0.4892676770687103,
0.15009863674640656,
-0.5922823548316956,
-0.4710099399089813,
-0.5066360831260681,
-0.8376657366752625,
-0.0282983910292387,
-0.5374070405960083,
-0.653001070022583,
0.03292136639356613,
0.346822589635849,
-0.3723958730697632,
0.22992141544818878,
-0.7072144150733948,
0.7053898572921753,
-0.2824633717536926,
-0.29313376545906067,
-0.5428681373596191,
-0.400199294090271,
0.3972950875759125,
-0.03248719125986099,
0.3461979627609253,
0.09258977323770523,
0.12532705068588257,
0.4908577501773834,
-0.3014468252658844,
1.1493947505950928,
-0.21307381987571716,
-0.36648961901664734,
0.5345513820648193,
-0.38395604491233826,
0.3594132661819458,
-0.1280609667301178,
-0.2025720626115799,
0.35915666818618774,
-0.128450408577919,
-0.0450337715446949,
-0.4326416254043579,
0.4938647747039795,
-0.6815732717514038,
-0.7933970093727112,
-0.3181321620941162,
-0.6848401427268982,
-0.06557086855173111,
0.12370157986879349,
0.33807507157325745,
0.25313836336135864,
-0.5136392712593079,
-0.2550174593925476,
0.10398036986589432,
-0.3608430325984955,
0.3487265408039093,
0.43872445821762085,
-0.15190090239048004,
-0.3099214732646942,
0.9185159802436829,
0.2956608831882477,
0.11652132868766785,
0.12968169152736664,
0.2811538875102997,
-0.2491888850927353,
-0.38755500316619873,
-0.17219656705856323,
0.039686720818281174,
-0.5572417974472046,
-0.14863935112953186,
-0.18752072751522064,
-0.2136455476284027,
-0.2313244342803955,
-0.04523640498518944,
0.20503011345863342,
0.1165274903178215,
-0.14614805579185486,
-0.2305571287870407,
0.04190846160054207,
0.7675479650497437,
-0.3700017035007477,
0.3455086052417755,
-0.11634304374456406,
0.16784335672855377,
0.10035000741481781,
0.4769107401371002,
-0.11957837641239166,
-0.059449195861816406,
-0.0980740636587143,
-0.04042036086320877,
-0.48797479271888733,
-0.6124331951141357,
0.40100252628326416,
0.013025498948991299,
0.6327533721923828,
0.3473576605319977,
0.05560090392827988,
0.554595947265625,
-0.7486163377761841,
0.6504977345466614,
0.24667030572891235,
-0.9238976836204529,
0.4704706370830536,
-0.21938322484493256,
-0.13045722246170044,
0.4838857352733612,
0.23184774816036224,
-0.31412145495414734,
-0.45522716641426086,
-0.4859573543071747,
-0.8671706914901733,
0.21457459032535553,
0.5005688071250916,
0.6216601133346558,
-0.12381529062986374,
0.36276084184646606,
0.017402885481715202,
0.2238311916589737,
-0.5267534255981445,
-0.06982900947332382,
0.11726495623588562,
-0.10225863754749298,
-0.26505187153816223,
-0.42857977747917175,
-0.16882425546646118,
-0.13119788467884064,
0.7016173005104065,
0.2936675548553467,
0.3455973267555237,
0.014862177893519402,
0.2987097203731537,
0.2123425155878067,
0.43960052728652954,
0.821499228477478,
0.4156211316585541,
-0.0985209047794342,
-0.0009693439351394773,
-0.1531432569026947,
-0.3962738513946533,
0.17448458075523376,
0.19483031332492828,
-0.5918592810630798,
-0.24774855375289917,
0.403273344039917,
0.5791019797325134,
-0.11139939725399017,
-0.7082116603851318,
0.5717301368713379,
-0.015602577477693558,
-0.4464726746082306,
-0.6978008151054382,
-0.08236700296401978,
0.06226864457130432,
0.1839730143547058,
0.08639953285455704,
-0.13259701430797577,
0.5020152926445007,
-0.8354438543319702,
0.3343961536884308,
0.5535551309585571,
-0.2571074366569519,
-0.13153685629367828,
0.6493676900863647,
0.506162166595459,
-0.4343821108341217,
0.5732637643814087,
-0.20627829432487488,
-0.4769771695137024,
0.9867227077484131,
0.6437729597091675,
0.7718439698219299,
-0.08368159085512161,
0.3185446560382843,
0.09913886338472366,
0.5610430836677551,
-0.19007955491542816,
0.3432745337486267,
0.30487293004989624,
-0.7532682418823242,
-0.5335754752159119,
-0.4420139193534851,
-0.41173022985458374,
0.41564080119132996,
-0.6121453046798706,
0.11427570879459381,
-0.3723890781402588,
-0.46810153126716614,
-0.04560471698641777,
-0.09456923604011536,
-0.7672797441482544,
-0.15577904880046844,
0.19301261007785797,
0.767598569393158,
-1.1496126651763916,
0.47989124059677124,
0.3186451494693756,
-0.6364348530769348,
-0.8871958255767822,
0.5909597873687744,
0.26166650652885437,
-0.6683517694473267,
0.27713391184806824,
0.34667253494262695,
-0.01814383640885353,
0.04166620597243309,
-0.6532942056655884,
-0.5356955528259277,
1.1162776947021484,
0.4668866991996765,
-0.731096625328064,
0.038787033408880234,
0.38536232709884644,
0.7028266191482544,
-0.15261754393577576,
0.08453763276338577,
0.7450719475746155,
0.6554991602897644,
-0.12918397784233093,
-0.8548016548156738,
-0.03614331781864166,
-0.18991826474666595,
0.10756590962409973,
-0.05802864581346512,
-0.48510897159576416,
0.5891844630241394,
-0.4045555293560028,
-0.43850642442703247,
0.16121482849121094,
0.6003016829490662,
-0.025682497769594193,
0.2774738073348999,
0.5552387237548828,
0.4722960591316223,
0.58375084400177,
0.24279583990573883,
1.627569317817688,
-0.39585036039352417,
0.37222573161125183,
1.0717335939407349,
-0.2687861919403076,
0.7203179001808167,
0.6013820767402649,
-0.26827165484428406,
0.4436551630496979,
0.3280455470085144,
-0.2703014612197876,
0.5934380888938904,
0.7992636561393738,
-0.45783400535583496,
0.2104150652885437,
-0.5081650018692017,
-0.05024147033691406,
0.432662695646286,
0.39133715629577637,
-0.27234402298927307,
-0.047012683004140854,
0.4637150168418884,
-0.006551183760166168,
0.17234119772911072,
-0.41134631633758545,
0.6538636684417725,
0.10319427400827408,
-0.5184288024902344,
-0.07642147690057755,
0.18670141696929932,
0.7960220575332642,
-0.3229947090148926,
-0.5280703902244568,
-0.08098170161247253,
-0.004364673513919115,
-0.019868554547429085,
-0.9065833687782288,
0.42060503363609314,
0.07919635623693466,
0.03352301940321922,
-0.19141416251659393,
0.3670036196708679,
-0.428573340177536,
-0.755641520023346,
0.21099939942359924,
0.3614818751811981,
0.11741387844085693,
0.16236895322799683,
-0.6240361332893372,
0.2433542013168335,
-0.0819472223520279,
-0.1807885617017746,
0.0704457014799118,
0.06353843957185745,
-0.25626450777053833,
0.6249980330467224,
0.4519871771335602,
0.2668786644935608,
-0.2683761715888977,
0.230777308344841,
0.7748394012451172,
-0.36658769845962524,
-0.7151675224304199,
-0.8515016436576843,
0.4240553677082062,
-0.1516188234090805,
-0.2691749930381775,
0.6260576248168945,
0.5186991095542908,
0.7255762815475464,
0.008431878872215748,
1.0750651359558105,
-0.30117395520210266,
-0.0707273855805397,
-0.5398285984992981,
0.7348957061767578,
-0.37849438190460205,
0.6922157406806946,
-0.18050436675548553,
-0.6154091358184814,
-0.33197030425071716,
0.3728058338165283,
-0.7018296718597412,
0.12999272346496582,
0.20796750485897064,
0.8799536824226379,
0.2879568934440613,
-0.15501894056797028,
0.3820459544658661,
0.3916289210319519,
0.5557814836502075,
0.1499994993209839,
1.0030053853988647,
-0.01349097304046154,
0.6581119894981384,
-0.3582570254802704,
-0.29208651185035706,
0.12682640552520752,
-0.8733375072479248,
-0.7489579319953918,
-0.5087062120437622,
-0.10094454139471054,
-0.41624778509140015,
0.4361116290092468,
0.5879718065261841,
0.43206968903541565,
-0.5405819416046143,
-0.12046261876821518,
-0.3006492257118225,
0.005794449709355831,
0.02593773417174816,
-0.3537270724773407,
0.49142715334892273,
-0.005324742291122675,
-0.4391259253025055,
-0.0439014695584774,
0.1408042311668396,
0.12397988140583038,
-0.5675023794174194,
-0.14063681662082672,
0.12079490721225739,
0.1261824369430542,
0.65651935338974,
0.2200244516134262,
-0.8437934517860413,
-0.4852246940135956,
-0.5890307426452637,
-0.0853089690208435,
-0.16790178418159485,
0.8189696669578552,
-0.7650460004806519,
0.3665747046470642,
0.010292920283973217,
0.38812455534935,
0.2984012961387634,
0.04643514007329941,
0.8017361164093018,
-0.4295656085014343,
0.04853636026382446,
0.3030672073364258,
0.1956324428319931,
0.14059627056121826,
-0.6195116639137268,
0.5894591808319092,
-0.1414899379014969,
-0.28892943263053894,
-0.6907333135604858,
0.3332589864730835,
-0.4952734708786011,
-0.29978856444358826,
1.1516659259796143,
-0.3263065814971924,
0.05019718036055565,
-0.09507910162210464,
-0.2411700338125229,
0.005930705461651087,
-0.49592986702919006,
1.2967007160186768,
0.4600885808467865,
-0.09801369160413742,
-0.0965840294957161,
-0.5959219932556152,
0.387544184923172,
0.13077858090400696,
-1.155723214149475,
-0.18532846868038177,
0.4904632866382599,
0.19003134965896606,
-0.17691084742546082,
0.8763391375541687,
-0.14016760885715485,
-0.04105789214372635,
0.28467270731925964,
0.1453627645969391,
-0.007817648351192474,
-0.29470983147621155,
-0.6166552305221558,
-0.019136717543005943,
-0.11744911968708038,
0.18169261515140533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09673v1
|
LoRA Learns Less and Forgets Less
| 2024-05-15T19:27:45 | 2024-05-15T19:27:45 |
Dan Biderman, Jose Gonzalez Ortiz, Jacob Portes, Mansheej Paul, Philip Greengard, Connor Jennings, Daniel King, Sam Havens, Vitaliy Chiley, Jonathan Frankle, Cody Blakeney, John P. Cunningham
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) is a widely-used parameter-efficient finetuning
method for large language models. LoRA saves memory by training only low rank
perturbations to selected weight matrices. In this work, we compare the
performance of LoRA and full finetuning on two target domains, programming and
mathematics. We consider both the instruction finetuning ($\approx$100K
prompt-response pairs) and continued pretraining ($\approx$10B unstructured
tokens) data regimes. Our results show that, in most settings, LoRA
substantially underperforms full finetuning. Nevertheless, LoRA exhibits a
desirable form of regularization: it better maintains the base model's
performance on tasks outside the target domain. We show that LoRA provides
stronger regularization compared to common techniques such as weight decay and
dropout; it also helps maintain more diverse generations. We show that full
finetuning learns perturbations with a rank that is 10-100X greater than
typical LoRA configurations, possibly explaining some of the reported gaps. We
conclude by proposing best practices for finetuning with LoRA.
|
[
-0.40311339497566223,
-0.8500109314918518,
0.2764407694339752,
0.03306601941585541,
-0.20184876024723053,
-0.1785878688097,
-0.5260950326919556,
-0.24112822115421295,
0.2121943235397339,
0.39726752042770386,
-0.23096872866153717,
-0.33377566933631897,
-0.7739163041114807,
-0.12956373393535614,
-0.3036281168460846,
1.2082676887512207,
-0.015556265600025654,
-0.1680493950843811,
-0.023228637874126434,
-0.19794969260692596,
-0.7153199315071106,
-0.5531535148620605,
-1.0081393718719482,
-0.537670910358429,
1.0244759321212769,
0.6793493628501892,
0.5512791872024536,
0.38614267110824585,
0.4409045875072479,
0.22531938552856445,
-0.02217486873269081,
0.025278976187109947,
-1.153522253036499,
-0.08402562141418457,
-0.04252555966377258,
-0.72742760181427,
-0.34932658076286316,
0.059461697936058044,
0.5035144090652466,
1.0467355251312256,
-0.2858685553073883,
0.29270774126052856,
0.3907535672187805,
1.0492851734161377,
-0.854910671710968,
-0.03377262502908707,
-0.6500000953674316,
0.11815236508846283,
-0.14188699424266815,
-0.07427814602851868,
-0.32636117935180664,
-0.4225342273712158,
0.018739068880677223,
-0.803295373916626,
-0.250398725271225,
-0.33805471658706665,
0.8498430252075195,
0.7688862085342407,
-0.10689188539981842,
0.04108862206339836,
-0.9206824898719788,
1.0113836526870728,
-0.44623327255249023,
0.2927192747592926,
0.5757444500923157,
0.4638410806655884,
0.11886945366859436,
-0.33078086376190186,
-0.11611317098140717,
0.12146836519241333,
0.31449058651924133,
0.18438072502613068,
-0.359162300825119,
-0.13237443566322327,
0.39185261726379395,
0.32308730483055115,
-0.08013010770082474,
0.5659303069114685,
-0.6699080467224121,
0.01840464398264885,
0.2614605128765106,
-0.2079877108335495,
-0.17033468186855316,
0.07851185649633408,
-0.1920958012342453,
-0.23433560132980347,
-1.047100305557251,
0.2145051658153534,
0.16798537969589233,
0.6015456318855286,
-0.24357280135154724,
0.3230871260166168,
-0.1602015644311905,
0.5944332480430603,
0.29999276995658875,
-0.2702339291572571,
-0.08935470134019852,
0.00617421418428421,
-0.44367358088493347,
-0.05196947231888771,
0.4127989709377289,
0.032644618302583694,
0.5531027317047119,
-0.18775750696659088,
-0.11366859078407288,
0.3139530420303345,
-0.08146072924137115,
-0.7725587487220764,
-0.21421754360198975,
-0.1660199612379074,
-0.3796626925468445,
0.09180854260921478,
-0.06287868320941925,
-0.4704124629497528,
-0.37277552485466003,
-0.6425690054893494,
0.7423067092895508,
-0.477634996175766,
0.36151665449142456,
0.2736210823059082,
0.20447713136672974,
0.4792105555534363,
0.7137283086776733,
-1.057400107383728,
0.7250154614448547,
0.6364647150039673,
0.7468340992927551,
-0.41382676362991333,
-0.2601358890533447,
-1.1363773345947266,
-0.13859322667121887,
-0.2677682936191559,
0.9118731021881104,
-0.26501086354255676,
-0.04357272759079933,
-0.3156207501888275,
-0.29486319422721863,
-0.21661649644374847,
-0.6823583841323853,
0.291051983833313,
-0.4777805209159851,
0.11863992363214493,
-0.308258056640625,
-0.11826951056718826,
-0.06654801964759827,
-0.08961375057697296,
-0.7035180926322937,
0.7508662939071655,
0.2933812141418457,
-0.3542788326740265,
0.4396359324455261,
-0.7688103914260864,
-0.36706897616386414,
-0.4433799982070923,
0.02204023115336895,
-0.35162827372550964,
0.1937832534313202,
0.02816002070903778,
0.3425782322883606,
-0.26353803277015686,
-0.44525468349456787,
0.020672578364610672,
-0.8682194948196411,
0.050399307161569595,
-0.2870352268218994,
0.43672803044319153,
0.14372141659259796,
-0.18707554042339325,
-0.12937171757221222,
-0.6676487922668457,
0.017639033496379852,
0.13980694115161896,
-0.7958077788352966,
-0.5087689161300659,
-0.08756586909294128,
-0.17737098038196564,
0.048176318407058716,
0.11232590675354004,
-0.4757123589515686,
0.31557565927505493,
-0.6021875143051147,
0.6322635412216187,
0.8294953107833862,
-0.06794121116399765,
0.437637597322464,
-0.5076220035552979,
0.3323260247707367,
0.15712358057498932,
0.08504010736942291,
0.29026785492897034,
-0.24419644474983215,
-1.1943591833114624,
-0.0620732344686985,
0.7964057922363281,
0.4686385989189148,
-0.5792213082313538,
0.20605862140655518,
-0.29715174436569214,
-0.1203664168715477,
-0.5539899468421936,
0.5048962831497192,
0.4739474356174469,
0.1433454304933548,
0.5806487202644348,
-0.24735093116760254,
-0.4767712950706482,
-0.5777184367179871,
-0.1290990561246872,
0.4265904128551483,
0.15091565251350403,
0.017983339726924896,
0.4477313756942749,
-0.25198715925216675,
0.7231779098510742,
-0.4857558310031891,
-0.6619691252708435,
-0.1596740484237671,
-0.17296075820922852,
0.31521281599998474,
0.6204301714897156,
0.7908173203468323,
-0.46901312470436096,
-0.6764881610870361,
0.15155623853206635,
-0.4388735890388489,
0.36371755599975586,
0.13969308137893677,
-0.16374795138835907,
0.21025055646896362,
0.2532625198364258,
-0.3237978219985962,
0.4446098804473877,
0.7488902807235718,
-0.0924980416893959,
-0.11309970170259476,
-0.16733086109161377,
-0.07193824648857117,
-0.8944000601768494,
0.07683476060628891,
-0.3144800662994385,
-0.3212232291698456,
-0.5116881132125854,
-0.1252690702676773,
-0.3711075782775879,
-0.3394869267940521,
-0.3767569363117218,
0.45226821303367615,
-0.26127195358276367,
-0.3963968753814697,
-0.13021759688854218,
0.38597941398620605,
0.01248851791024208,
0.6834068298339844,
-0.31270307302474976,
0.9084149599075317,
0.36996838450431824,
-0.7726325988769531,
-0.047538839280605316,
0.3495557904243469,
-0.43968677520751953,
0.35433468222618103,
-0.6499423980712891,
0.375740647315979,
-0.08973491936922073,
-0.1053905263543129,
-0.7598192691802979,
-0.07553302496671677,
-0.054558005183935165,
-0.1878928244113922,
0.16218914091587067,
-0.28042319416999817,
-0.22092066705226898,
-0.08014212548732758,
-0.5276381969451904,
0.26311758160591125,
0.9272414445877075,
-0.5514930486679077,
0.34900936484336853,
0.12408360093832016,
-0.08375918120145798,
-0.6909680366516113,
-0.8285359740257263,
-0.3531496226787567,
-0.3689221739768982,
-0.06976713240146637,
0.09916099160909653,
-0.17085084319114685,
-0.22210809588432312,
-0.1724773347377777,
-0.23940995335578918,
-0.024575000628829002,
0.4182153344154358,
0.3584047257900238,
0.02223127894103527,
-0.571266233921051,
-0.17186836898326874,
0.1280192732810974,
-0.2598668932914734,
-0.4067070186138153,
-0.09315702319145203,
0.744243860244751,
-0.05294579267501831,
-0.3190303146839142,
-0.6337999105453491,
0.08954867720603943,
0.4562958776950836,
-0.038483768701553345,
0.9132171273231506,
0.2681903839111328,
-0.40884000062942505,
-0.28353360295295715,
-0.374782532453537,
-0.09117650985717773,
-0.43874260783195496,
0.10333860665559769,
-0.4490358233451843,
-0.5796781778335571,
0.4854029417037964,
-0.04264538735151291,
0.1682998538017273,
0.5287722945213318,
0.1586994081735611,
-0.281877338886261,
0.5996572375297546,
1.1192002296447754,
-0.22520960867404938,
0.8239227533340454,
-0.7104372978210449,
0.06026717647910118,
-0.8899067640304565,
0.20197780430316925,
-0.5265472531318665,
-0.6738348007202148,
-0.23163628578186035,
-0.36414942145347595,
0.22698639333248138,
0.5274781584739685,
-0.510743260383606,
0.2810663878917694,
-0.39047476649284363,
0.7614762783050537,
0.5051943063735962,
0.21188725531101227,
0.5469670295715332,
0.5754334330558777,
0.275851309299469,
-0.13850045204162598,
-0.7908936142921448,
-0.2744465470314026,
1.122441291809082,
0.1296541839838028,
1.2154260873794556,
0.2943974435329437,
0.9348820447921753,
0.1875370740890503,
0.24953924119472504,
-1.13832688331604,
0.229275181889534,
-0.8465778827667236,
0.057191599160432816,
-0.5862826704978943,
-0.4538567364215851,
-1.3460294008255005,
0.10541421920061111,
-0.25253620743751526,
-0.602133572101593,
0.3126104176044464,
0.27365076541900635,
-0.9922329783439636,
0.18816033005714417,
-0.8535804152488708,
0.6180983185768127,
-0.039939045906066895,
-0.15674026310443878,
-0.3548845648765564,
-0.23549149930477142,
0.07747458666563034,
-0.32545387744903564,
0.10418284684419632,
-0.00210938579402864,
0.1079227551817894,
1.1732321977615356,
-0.26406246423721313,
0.9444659352302551,
-0.2685754895210266,
-0.27552226185798645,
0.09245019406080246,
-0.0051049115136265755,
0.3056100308895111,
-0.22435997426509857,
-0.2544649541378021,
-0.08229870349168777,
0.20227979123592377,
-0.5873101949691772,
-0.6191188097000122,
1.0397080183029175,
-1.3279613256454468,
-0.46806788444519043,
-0.1730998307466507,
-0.4595397412776947,
-0.5678533315658569,
0.35355404019355774,
0.24093219637870789,
0.43971797823905945,
-0.13158608973026276,
0.562783420085907,
0.9998446106910706,
-0.18510222434997559,
0.2750541865825653,
0.2017120122909546,
-0.10326122492551804,
-0.2604316771030426,
0.9948126673698425,
0.5348008275032043,
0.4923870861530304,
0.40330955386161804,
0.30071160197257996,
0.3408062756061554,
-0.5168877243995667,
-0.28655722737312317,
0.30363020300865173,
-0.8332857489585876,
-0.41757673025131226,
-0.2793439030647278,
-0.3044971525669098,
-0.0836101695895195,
-0.3997911214828491,
-0.538301408290863,
-0.6907418370246887,
-0.10772980004549026,
0.26082995533943176,
0.5483411550521851,
0.7724214792251587,
0.035217247903347015,
0.5837686657905579,
-0.31558239459991455,
0.5136728286743164,
0.6006183624267578,
0.34383562207221985,
-0.02584964409470558,
-0.7133459448814392,
-0.3318098187446594,
0.10909418761730194,
-0.2063083052635193,
-0.18473294377326965,
-0.24012556672096252,
0.6753862500190735,
0.384414941072464,
0.46727296710014343,
-0.010750631801784039,
0.9755679965019226,
-0.3701959252357483,
0.5103546380996704,
0.2018011063337326,
-0.7644796371459961,
0.4642362594604492,
-0.22464539110660553,
0.5016880035400391,
0.7700037956237793,
0.20642805099487305,
-0.4140944182872772,
0.21145720779895782,
-0.2750735878944397,
-0.4355822503566742,
0.7754538059234619,
-0.026100557297468185,
0.299112468957901,
0.4946728050708771,
0.5021206736564636,
0.3852616250514984,
0.020961467176675797,
-0.7759596705436707,
-0.2041979730129242,
-0.22492919862270355,
-0.03298519551753998,
-0.2035525143146515,
-0.06657937169075012,
-0.39009377360343933,
-0.2797040641307831,
0.2924370765686035,
-0.2578953504562378,
0.4600988030433655,
-0.29979971051216125,
-0.378055602312088,
-0.28099584579467773,
0.3035958409309387,
0.5145524144172668,
0.6817098259925842,
-0.004593299236148596,
-0.0033935406245291233,
0.4802103340625763,
-0.5009819269180298,
-0.03723061829805374,
-0.07183991372585297,
-0.21160200238227844,
-0.35750508308410645,
0.45412859320640564,
0.8422814607620239,
0.6147673726081848,
-0.5188655853271484,
0.35676974058151245,
0.1650061160326004,
-0.24790744483470917,
0.07637743651866913,
0.48454055190086365,
-0.053749289363622665,
0.02222549542784691,
0.2364940047264099,
0.19707521796226501,
-0.21200743317604065,
-0.8451627492904663,
-0.28727295994758606,
0.20808151364326477,
-0.16413047909736633,
-0.2872823476791382,
0.464590847492218,
0.014869158156216145,
-0.007959205657243729,
0.2230052798986435,
0.2261877954006195,
-0.14715975522994995,
0.5232031345367432,
0.6746764779090881,
0.3067648410797119,
-0.02335957996547222,
-0.007858356460928917,
0.23669733107089996,
-0.0547126904129982,
-0.106124646961689,
0.3051368296146393,
-0.18659403920173645,
-0.5147291421890259,
-0.47334763407707214,
-0.7913125157356262,
-0.38834524154663086,
0.11048313230276108,
-0.7277617454528809,
0.2480757087469101,
-0.9618359804153442,
-0.13860319554805756,
0.010419857688248158,
0.2589672803878784,
-0.7553021907806396,
-0.013824458234012127,
0.15277411043643951,
0.7165928483009338,
-0.6916009187698364,
0.8336288928985596,
0.6971015930175781,
-0.5235162973403931,
-0.7273631691932678,
-0.08449100703001022,
-0.35701942443847656,
-0.798592746257782,
0.7949728965759277,
-0.0820242390036583,
-0.5652140974998474,
0.2669897675514221,
-0.4691494107246399,
-1.2131602764129639,
1.1410279273986816,
0.6966643333435059,
-0.4707029163837433,
-0.18564827740192413,
-0.04123656824231148,
0.48335716128349304,
-0.09589475393295288,
-0.5143058896064758,
0.7440360188484192,
0.24273546040058136,
0.0046634073369205,
-0.999136745929718,
-0.2712455987930298,
0.22786715626716614,
-0.060965608805418015,
0.23055709898471832,
-0.9358048439025879,
1.1213527917861938,
-0.2233579009771347,
-0.25416284799575806,
0.398281067609787,
0.5064883828163147,
0.05376129969954491,
-0.028438081964850426,
0.3558215796947479,
0.4595124125480652,
0.743062436580658,
-0.19767123460769653,
0.763975977897644,
0.0015497999265789986,
0.3084597587585449,
1.0854454040527344,
-0.13052774965763092,
1.118248701095581,
0.4636211395263672,
-0.4133002758026123,
0.7437435984611511,
0.38098084926605225,
0.31734466552734375,
0.613664448261261,
0.12057708203792572,
0.3321100175380707,
-0.16231299936771393,
0.09596999734640121,
-0.525764524936676,
0.5007268786430359,
0.3352590501308441,
0.21610835194587708,
-0.2554788291454315,
0.4078260064125061,
0.22598384320735931,
0.24989107251167297,
-0.6768107414245605,
0.8064543008804321,
0.3131398558616638,
-0.6062167286872864,
1.2623999118804932,
-0.12404339015483856,
0.7575535774230957,
-0.694006085395813,
-0.015934204682707787,
-0.6381189823150635,
0.6173640489578247,
-0.3235633373260498,
-0.25803279876708984,
0.014551656320691109,
0.10726426541805267,
-0.36377501487731934,
-0.06592349708080292,
0.49073371291160583,
-0.17764444649219513,
-0.06381937116384506,
0.20633022487163544,
0.5412336587905884,
0.15074005722999573,
0.2534045875072479,
-0.6200435757637024,
0.25876837968826294,
-0.2881075143814087,
-0.13451650738716125,
0.679366946220398,
0.2206578552722931,
-0.21650679409503937,
0.6580564379692078,
0.593826413154602,
0.1830858588218689,
0.0892891213297844,
0.20125925540924072,
1.0086724758148193,
-0.47416001558303833,
-0.4322909712791443,
-0.46648386120796204,
-0.05372311547398567,
0.21120865643024445,
-0.3655424118041992,
0.8234367370605469,
0.38354212045669556,
0.6919829249382019,
-0.13448166847229004,
0.37767598032951355,
0.06972172111272812,
0.3651446998119354,
-0.9232997298240662,
0.6017309427261353,
-0.4577796459197998,
0.04188663512468338,
-0.21858792006969452,
-1.2336342334747314,
-0.2824537456035614,
0.8280691504478455,
-0.6072432398796082,
0.15854668617248535,
0.7385588884353638,
0.22406214475631714,
-0.4987987279891968,
-0.6695958971977234,
0.5142501592636108,
0.2503613233566284,
-0.12028099596500397,
0.9132609963417053,
0.7757192850112915,
-0.7362468242645264,
0.46444079279899597,
-0.07506460696458817,
-0.07716980576515198,
-0.36045464873313904,
-0.4390290081501007,
-1.0227348804473877,
-0.19988402724266052,
-0.20974363386631012,
-0.1449519693851471,
0.28265947103500366,
0.8384160399436951,
0.9455833435058594,
-1.0316296815872192,
-0.1842113435268402,
0.3774724006652832,
0.08950752019882202,
-0.4926980435848236,
-0.10991451144218445,
0.5105759501457214,
-0.2444520890712738,
-0.7251408100128174,
0.45412057638168335,
0.08944515138864517,
0.04500586912035942,
-0.2450631856918335,
-0.2619525194168091,
-0.10204002261161804,
0.13364623486995697,
0.8667536973953247,
0.6817994713783264,
-0.5632771849632263,
-0.3804924786090851,
-0.23741626739501953,
-0.13244691491127014,
0.28561022877693176,
0.5896336436271667,
-0.955946683883667,
-0.11613282561302185,
0.17045356333255768,
0.8462015986442566,
0.5197219252586365,
0.22106289863586426,
0.14275391399860382,
-0.5133281350135803,
0.41296979784965515,
-0.08310912549495697,
0.24004609882831573,
0.22544452548027039,
-0.23687471449375153,
0.6625233292579651,
-0.018923791125416756,
-0.3964933454990387,
-0.7223721742630005,
0.09170892834663391,
-1.096908688545227,
-0.18543373048305511,
1.0858670473098755,
-0.029345422983169556,
-0.17404286563396454,
0.020116982981562614,
-0.3514273166656494,
-0.03812340274453163,
-0.38670259714126587,
0.5924844741821289,
0.3887951374053955,
-0.22288690507411957,
-0.013774879276752472,
-0.7146832942962646,
0.6226956844329834,
0.6366532444953918,
-0.799933910369873,
-0.05776651203632355,
0.30329814553260803,
0.42806750535964966,
0.24404285848140717,
0.47970595955848694,
0.17903603613376617,
0.41077446937561035,
-0.254306435585022,
-0.3179028332233429,
0.007724320515990257,
-0.4571338891983032,
-0.5012680292129517,
0.10775827616453171,
0.5488114356994629,
-0.041488151997327805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09605v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09605v1
|
Elements of World Knowledge (EWOK): A cognition-inspired framework for evaluating basic world knowledge in language models
| 2024-05-15T17:19:42 | 2024-05-15T17:19:42 |
Anna A. Ivanova, Aalok Sathe, Benjamin Lipkin, Unnathi Kumar, Setayesh Radkani, Thomas H. Clark, Carina Kauf, Jennifer Hu, R. T. Pramod, Gabriel Grand, Vivian Paulun, Maria Ryskina, Ekin Akyürek, Ethan Wilcox, Nafisa Rashid, Leshem Choshen, Roger Levy, Evelina Fedorenko, Joshua Tenenbaum, Jacob Andreas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The ability to build and leverage world models is essential for a
general-purpose AI agent. Testing such capabilities is hard, in part because
the building blocks of world models are ill-defined. We present Elements of
World Knowledge (EWOK), a framework for evaluating world modeling in language
models by testing their ability to use knowledge of a concept to match a target
text with a plausible/implausible context. EWOK targets specific concepts from
multiple knowledge domains known to be vital for world modeling in humans.
Domains range from social interactions (help/hinder) to spatial relations
(left/right). Both, contexts and targets are minimal pairs. Objects, agents,
and locations in the items can be flexibly filled in enabling easy generation
of multiple controlled datasets. We then introduce EWOK-CORE-1.0, a dataset of
4,374 items covering 11 world knowledge domains. We evaluate 20 openweights
large language models (1.3B--70B parameters) across a battery of evaluation
paradigms along with a human norming study comprising 12,480 measurements. The
overall performance of all tested models is worse than human performance, with
results varying drastically across domains. These data highlight simple cases
where even large models fail and present rich avenues for targeted research on
LLM world modeling capabilities.
|
[
-0.379808247089386,
-1.0215191841125488,
0.5039405822753906,
-0.10275442898273468,
0.004606483969837427,
-0.07292421907186508,
-0.06463276594877243,
-0.6718743443489075,
-0.23324845731258392,
0.21430262923240662,
-0.548128604888916,
-0.4238101840019226,
-0.36855751276016235,
0.03893418610095978,
-0.30655503273010254,
0.6944660544395447,
0.1168275848031044,
-0.3492092192173004,
-0.6168161630630493,
-0.12419810146093369,
-0.07989706099033356,
-0.2909437417984009,
-0.1870618313550949,
-0.7480186223983765,
0.26838764548301697,
0.3590651750564575,
0.6876994371414185,
0.3853997588157654,
0.29032453894615173,
0.2879718542098999,
0.06978242844343185,
0.3509264886379242,
-0.5079807043075562,
0.13596796989440918,
-0.2817877233028412,
-0.2360129952430725,
-0.6522296071052551,
0.2895752489566803,
0.026080088689923286,
0.8301950097084045,
-0.06330641359090805,
0.17484132945537567,
0.10807783901691437,
0.2639111876487732,
-0.5757481455802917,
0.26826056838035583,
-0.7139591574668884,
0.004239018075168133,
0.3632350564002991,
0.1259581297636032,
-0.3014630675315857,
0.03841405361890793,
0.5913813710212708,
-1.0286180973052979,
0.07004645466804504,
0.6714079976081848,
0.8153536319732666,
0.21824601292610168,
-0.610572338104248,
-0.29285895824432373,
-0.6373273134231567,
0.9362748265266418,
-0.46053656935691833,
0.6454199552536011,
0.7042077779769897,
0.11838681250810623,
-0.24853114783763885,
-0.3828597366809845,
-0.759595513343811,
-0.5847609043121338,
0.07948163151741028,
0.28755706548690796,
-0.25318190455436707,
0.26501670479774475,
0.32538339495658875,
0.24051102995872498,
-0.5006766319274902,
-0.05092843994498253,
-0.08091901242733002,
-0.37445592880249023,
0.6490562558174133,
0.17192675173282623,
0.6796179413795471,
-0.11036307364702225,
-0.25644636154174805,
-0.13094694912433624,
-0.7003927230834961,
0.018509026616811752,
0.31915685534477234,
0.05282130464911461,
-0.2821893095970154,
0.6152585744857788,
-0.4242454469203949,
1.0198549032211304,
-0.20913782715797424,
-0.5985023975372314,
-0.08809380978345871,
-0.21271240711212158,
-0.23436026275157928,
-0.40305984020233154,
0.29165247082710266,
0.5354256629943848,
0.03607699275016785,
-0.4623878002166748,
-0.08979075402021408,
0.06242702901363373,
0.2575250566005707,
-0.4676913619041443,
-0.0159458015114069,
0.19152027368545532,
-0.2766517102718353,
-0.34409087896347046,
0.12820008397102356,
-0.3958326578140259,
-0.3687877058982849,
-0.3890764117240906,
0.3512466251850128,
-0.5180510878562927,
-0.11849331855773926,
-0.07623644173145294,
-0.30387386679649353,
0.5508201718330383,
0.24470186233520508,
-0.6598774790763855,
0.35319051146507263,
0.7937415838241577,
0.5164076685905457,
-0.053436145186424255,
-0.6973103880882263,
0.017726661637425423,
0.07726117968559265,
-0.29379546642303467,
0.7947074174880981,
-0.45084911584854126,
-0.3011469542980194,
-0.09942058473825455,
-0.09583403915166855,
0.33694300055503845,
-0.36446040868759155,
0.3841780722141266,
-0.394347608089447,
-0.2393268197774887,
-0.24313059449195862,
-0.6736595034599304,
-0.1559048593044281,
0.5975316166877747,
-0.6742116808891296,
1.135224461555481,
0.3777112066745758,
-0.4522631764411926,
0.45121145248413086,
-0.5540050864219666,
-0.4779992997646332,
-0.01781773380935192,
-0.07351535558700562,
-0.020159678533673286,
0.12527622282505035,
0.0376238189637661,
0.4843108654022217,
-0.7316562533378601,
0.16630183160305023,
-0.4988647401332855,
-0.31840622425079346,
0.28312379121780396,
-0.14712822437286377,
0.5415421724319458,
0.18398348987102509,
-0.2279510796070099,
-0.14608044922351837,
-0.9330657720565796,
0.13777653872966766,
0.3131667971611023,
-0.2872945964336395,
-0.8510487675666809,
0.07092181593179703,
0.015672607347369194,
0.2852587103843689,
-0.016723060980439186,
-0.7788645625114441,
0.2047821432352066,
-0.5226043462753296,
0.412575900554657,
0.7639612555503845,
-0.06180906295776367,
0.47944843769073486,
-0.5086520314216614,
0.3562033474445343,
-0.2734149098396301,
0.08831579238176346,
0.010183125734329224,
-0.7788125276565552,
-0.783362627029419,
0.028894295915961266,
0.059542324393987656,
0.3792852759361267,
-0.7457515001296997,
0.6714409589767456,
-0.38325566053390503,
-0.7528442740440369,
-0.3739572763442993,
0.010973025113344193,
0.3073740601539612,
0.36948272585868835,
0.02292490564286709,
0.00003176866812282242,
-0.5943570137023926,
-1.1144027709960938,
-0.33170145750045776,
-0.4094686210155487,
-0.25153449177742004,
0.4629869759082794,
0.9391515851020813,
-0.1516900360584259,
1.1732861995697021,
-0.599017858505249,
0.13214229047298431,
-0.27184462547302246,
-0.19229142367839813,
-0.2954220473766327,
0.18928086757659912,
0.20384670794010162,
-0.748629093170166,
-0.3537251651287079,
0.19420190155506134,
-0.7763690948486328,
-0.0011347430991008878,
0.1728183478116989,
-0.3347221612930298,
-0.30500125885009766,
0.24509197473526,
-0.4865979850292206,
0.41703033447265625,
0.5319768190383911,
-0.5454620718955994,
0.47613856196403503,
-0.16773219406604767,
0.10182467848062515,
-0.8644703030586243,
0.19076327979564667,
0.020740728825330734,
-0.20715464651584625,
-0.6398916244506836,
0.4705277681350708,
0.017270712181925774,
-0.25238001346588135,
-0.477413535118103,
0.9156980514526367,
-0.2309611737728119,
-0.0743584856390953,
-0.14620721340179443,
0.4008692800998688,
0.24107316136360168,
0.48561736941337585,
-0.2715217173099518,
0.5000775456428528,
0.16828447580337524,
-0.8715664148330688,
0.6618737578392029,
0.23315180838108063,
-0.7196565270423889,
0.8236743211746216,
-0.6565448045730591,
0.6055259108543396,
0.07383303344249725,
0.05222683399915695,
-0.7027079463005066,
-0.3070015013217926,
-0.05995158106088638,
-0.3125714957714081,
-0.2854272723197937,
-0.05321838706731796,
-0.29495829343795776,
-0.30524057149887085,
-0.07086828351020813,
0.03046504221856594,
0.4617353081703186,
-0.5256198644638062,
0.8574191927909851,
0.6493960618972778,
0.0190001018345356,
-0.5272741913795471,
-0.5190123319625854,
-0.1584795117378235,
-0.06738333404064178,
-0.8430915474891663,
0.5467650890350342,
-0.23204679787158966,
-0.6324562430381775,
0.12815739214420319,
-0.2111877202987671,
-0.10317826271057129,
0.5759991407394409,
0.4634285569190979,
0.12365765124559402,
0.07906411588191986,
0.10456737875938416,
-0.10651295632123947,
-0.05750780180096626,
-0.13630707561969757,
-0.41227567195892334,
0.33036017417907715,
-0.09604573994874954,
-0.6868156790733337,
0.15171636641025543,
0.24092376232147217,
0.6405549645423889,
-0.07206140458583832,
0.6533374786376953,
0.1477491408586502,
-0.8262273073196411,
-0.605049192905426,
-0.4752292335033417,
-0.029117461293935776,
-0.38177427649497986,
0.8954391479492188,
-0.6227241158485413,
-0.7180700302124023,
0.5693044662475586,
-0.1907413750886917,
0.27419885993003845,
0.2917899787425995,
0.5287929773330688,
-0.1558474749326706,
0.9258114695549011,
0.9058908224105835,
-0.23008066415786743,
0.004753374960273504,
-0.26320502161979675,
0.5144723653793335,
-0.8752987384796143,
-0.28204116225242615,
-0.3843073546886444,
-0.2724419832229614,
-0.05727382004261017,
-0.5066075921058655,
0.25788062810897827,
0.0258424524217844,
-0.1343865543603897,
0.02827354334294796,
-0.0068044355139136314,
0.6498932242393494,
0.33081144094467163,
0.05365385115146637,
0.4901403486728668,
0.10711222141981125,
-0.44966864585876465,
0.15773455798625946,
-0.59378582239151,
-0.5808967351913452,
1.1915665864944458,
0.21030819416046143,
0.9384228587150574,
0.11522871255874634,
0.18301929533481598,
0.48972034454345703,
0.3068508505821228,
-1.0571154356002808,
0.4995048940181732,
0.25836431980133057,
-0.7184551954269409,
-0.4301195442676544,
-0.11951620876789093,
-0.7398503422737122,
0.4542948007583618,
-0.1583131104707718,
-0.4370057284832001,
-0.19788610935211182,
0.08395638316869736,
-0.40915822982788086,
0.3288963735103607,
-0.4860077500343323,
0.5985657572746277,
-0.09129999577999115,
-0.1623065322637558,
-0.24096736311912537,
-0.20058207213878632,
0.16648171842098236,
0.14947889745235443,
0.3552474081516266,
-0.3380594849586487,
-0.16865642368793488,
0.7086008191108704,
-0.15057818591594696,
0.8309144973754883,
0.0026921709068119526,
-0.1827014684677124,
0.39419546723365784,
0.1349179893732071,
0.49549204111099243,
-0.0790705680847168,
-0.06472134590148926,
0.03266512602567673,
-0.16219428181648254,
-0.38558533787727356,
-0.7891584038734436,
0.4902792274951935,
-1.0555191040039062,
-0.38701963424682617,
-0.17116321623325348,
-0.6543053388595581,
-0.4541274309158325,
-0.007954797707498074,
0.09619276225566864,
0.4141840934753418,
-0.9340671300888062,
0.12673641741275787,
0.43516111373901367,
-0.1761162132024765,
-0.07586133480072021,
0.7944490313529968,
-0.261425256729126,
0.013411005958914757,
1.0500342845916748,
0.032369501888751984,
0.297800749540329,
0.14532378315925598,
0.31295353174209595,
-0.08574780076742172,
-0.3304656744003296,
-0.3667564392089844,
-0.23867832124233246,
-0.995591402053833,
-0.0764906257390976,
-0.47326844930648804,
-0.12498246878385544,
-0.19122406840324402,
-0.10532254725694656,
-0.3031061291694641,
-0.27078303694725037,
0.38342589139938354,
-0.4166533946990967,
0.21815712749958038,
1.146398663520813,
0.037854015827178955,
-0.024651510640978813,
-0.5898555517196655,
0.2187175452709198,
0.5828988552093506,
0.27958494424819946,
0.29566749930381775,
-0.3911187946796417,
-0.501911461353302,
0.17974089086055756,
-0.3454211354255676,
-0.8381015658378601,
0.10259915888309479,
0.4772987365722656,
0.9076757431030273,
0.28091561794281006,
0.08486921340227127,
0.5439133048057556,
-0.40950751304626465,
0.8248770236968994,
-0.1731773316860199,
-1.0140421390533447,
0.5446417331695557,
-0.2605743408203125,
0.05340874195098877,
0.18029063940048218,
0.26363492012023926,
-0.9515895247459412,
-0.42369094491004944,
-0.6626591086387634,
-0.7322121262550354,
0.47538426518440247,
0.05043976008892059,
0.035107746720314026,
0.1377304047346115,
0.43267518281936646,
0.30560746788978577,
-0.06852719932794571,
-0.5949596166610718,
-0.3306480944156647,
-0.06844512373209,
-0.3213564455509186,
0.07236669212579727,
-0.10186732560396194,
-0.24811148643493652,
-0.23683781921863556,
0.7783931493759155,
-0.43680885434150696,
0.2058672159910202,
0.37406882643699646,
-0.7591302394866943,
-0.0017320988699793816,
0.36436256766319275,
0.303869366645813,
0.8917111158370972,
0.02039548195898533,
0.11377749592065811,
0.3330284059047699,
-0.5144506096839905,
0.5108398199081421,
-0.25000572204589844,
-0.3623848557472229,
-0.6032499670982361,
0.6791638731956482,
0.5859538316726685,
0.3504207730293274,
-0.7694990634918213,
0.2841874361038208,
-0.07920223474502563,
-0.18329301476478577,
-0.15525327622890472,
-0.0014769869158044457,
0.17830586433410645,
-0.028486674651503563,
0.3365508019924164,
-0.07916823774576187,
-0.03685753047466278,
-0.6971119046211243,
0.29263368248939514,
0.13201141357421875,
-0.3350807726383209,
-0.6798312067985535,
0.05942165479063988,
0.5139925479888916,
-0.08548229932785034,
0.7500097155570984,
-0.4691918194293976,
-0.7750428915023804,
0.8338640928268433,
0.7371172308921814,
0.4339279532432556,
-0.1323489248752594,
0.08278575539588928,
0.2927807569503784,
0.5679863095283508,
0.18289382755756378,
0.26013895869255066,
0.15358062088489532,
-1.297416090965271,
-0.21525317430496216,
-0.508945882320404,
-0.5030667781829834,
0.1397220939397812,
-0.4456770122051239,
-0.027291864156723022,
-0.5147348642349243,
-0.0681598111987114,
-0.37062859535217285,
0.1583799421787262,
-1.1396993398666382,
0.14930641651153564,
0.26516857743263245,
0.7811203002929688,
-1.1445950269699097,
0.7808005213737488,
0.902677059173584,
-0.21162547171115875,
-0.6732146739959717,
0.0410657674074173,
0.3166613280773163,
-0.9748907685279846,
0.6670789122581482,
-0.04335089772939682,
-0.09965898841619492,
0.014055542647838593,
-0.6335923671722412,
-0.9482908844947815,
1.2100173234939575,
0.13285116851329803,
-0.319547176361084,
-0.006942094303667545,
0.03212393820285797,
0.2996533513069153,
-0.617179274559021,
0.3095766603946686,
0.8527993559837341,
0.48967528343200684,
-0.3253747522830963,
-0.865165114402771,
0.04595927149057388,
-0.3663935661315918,
-0.02409425936639309,
-0.20489399135112762,
-0.7181139588356018,
0.6855865120887756,
-0.346468448638916,
-0.17636729776859283,
-0.05901028960943222,
0.6701057553291321,
0.31681886315345764,
0.09443598240613937,
0.7769798636436462,
0.8386406302452087,
0.9827268719673157,
-0.062126029282808304,
1.1230926513671875,
-0.28577306866645813,
0.3542628884315491,
0.822894811630249,
-0.48563140630722046,
0.7372353076934814,
0.3327144384384155,
-0.4850951135158539,
0.4316956400871277,
0.5515774488449097,
0.19801323115825653,
0.5364596247673035,
0.3331134021282196,
0.039128415286540985,
-0.3721078038215637,
-0.24242404103279114,
-0.12606889009475708,
0.7019205093383789,
0.38448143005371094,
0.3156009614467621,
-0.04338301718235016,
0.16549217700958252,
-0.25259748101234436,
-0.04487137123942375,
-0.05417953059077263,
0.6633886098861694,
0.2009134590625763,
-0.5524616837501526,
0.09604925662279129,
0.3023512363433838,
0.6827238202095032,
-0.6787348389625549,
-0.1666913777589798,
-0.06206166371703148,
0.016921550035476685,
0.004172528628259897,
-0.29155489802360535,
0.21849386394023895,
-0.10630118101835251,
-0.20158085227012634,
0.17387408018112183,
1.0307599306106567,
-0.1564624011516571,
-0.34959468245506287,
0.4540219008922577,
0.7986871004104614,
-0.012267466634511948,
-0.1319332867860794,
-0.7036495804786682,
0.015373430214822292,
0.00935151893645525,
-0.38452744483947754,
0.3795681595802307,
0.2562754154205322,
0.12016261368989944,
0.9208630323410034,
0.7576809525489807,
-0.05192345753312111,
-0.03910621255636215,
-0.06422721594572067,
0.6295579671859741,
-0.7169205546379089,
-0.594032883644104,
-0.7587630152702332,
0.46185949444770813,
-0.08159972727298737,
-0.3175544738769531,
0.827164888381958,
0.4217345416545868,
0.8963808417320251,
0.10914286971092224,
1.22893488407135,
-0.44740399718284607,
0.2920985817909241,
-0.41026127338409424,
0.8969616889953613,
-0.5976783633232117,
0.02250347100198269,
-0.05228804424405098,
-0.9197827577590942,
0.08944350481033325,
0.8082731366157532,
-0.10236508399248123,
-0.011294408701360226,
0.7343592643737793,
0.5050660371780396,
-0.03646194189786911,
0.19799213111400604,
0.7433940172195435,
0.3592112362384796,
0.44019249081611633,
0.5507053732872009,
1.1741523742675781,
-0.4550955593585968,
0.29607927799224854,
-0.5164734125137329,
-0.3146599531173706,
0.011300478130578995,
-0.7372547388076782,
-0.9758220314979553,
-0.7035573124885559,
-0.0072641936130821705,
-0.2066180408000946,
-0.1345115602016449,
1.1531982421875,
0.9131127595901489,
-0.5192950367927551,
-0.10682525485754013,
0.3726598620414734,
0.26585665345191956,
-0.24379143118858337,
-0.11662427335977554,
0.21773113310337067,
0.059172123670578,
-0.5384259819984436,
0.6567944288253784,
0.2063557505607605,
-0.0019193802727386355,
-0.5188146829605103,
-0.3771854043006897,
0.021079815924167633,
0.04663524404168129,
0.8618398308753967,
-0.059994131326675415,
-0.9392282366752625,
-0.5313871502876282,
0.24789980053901672,
-0.0964592769742012,
-0.34250426292419434,
0.982799232006073,
-0.6650670766830444,
0.41515910625457764,
0.4262228012084961,
0.5209779143333435,
0.024849331006407738,
-0.3164965510368347,
0.7770652174949646,
-0.8027052283287048,
0.39256295561790466,
0.19736894965171814,
0.4913478493690491,
0.31352466344833374,
-0.23717013001441956,
0.5278865694999695,
0.35473349690437317,
-0.39369121193885803,
-0.5949474573135376,
0.24945972859859467,
-0.43837693333625793,
-0.2629808783531189,
0.8968860507011414,
-0.399956613779068,
-0.4441452920436859,
-0.5725215077400208,
0.0578681044280529,
0.06216689199209213,
-0.17304185032844543,
0.6193597316741943,
1.1701043844223022,
-0.012941369786858559,
0.28305235505104065,
-0.6751958131790161,
0.3354233503341675,
0.14730660617351532,
-0.8545114994049072,
0.10980188101530075,
0.3032190501689911,
0.5122739672660828,
0.11182686686515808,
0.5550690293312073,
0.17923256754875183,
0.13083718717098236,
0.33197951316833496,
0.2984822988510132,
-0.23918162286281586,
-0.35430195927619934,
-0.036026183515787125,
-0.010195374488830566,
0.21041841804981232,
0.4403073191642761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09508v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09508v1
|
Modeling Bilingual Sentence Processing: Evaluating RNN and Transformer Architectures for Cross-Language Structural Priming
| 2024-05-15T17:01:02 | 2024-05-15T17:01:02 |
Bushi Xiao, Chao Gao, Demi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This study evaluates the performance of Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) and
Transformer in replicating cross-language structural priming: a key indicator
of abstract grammatical representations in human language processing. Focusing
on Chinese-English priming, which involves two typologically distinct
languages, we examine how these models handle the robust phenomenon of
structural priming, where exposure to a particular sentence structure increases
the likelihood of selecting a similar structure subsequently. Additionally, we
utilize large language models (LLM) to measure the cross-lingual structural
priming effect. Our findings indicate that Transformer outperform RNN in
generating primed sentence structures, challenging the conventional belief that
human sentence processing primarily involves recurrent and immediate processing
and suggesting a role for cue-based retrieval mechanisms. Overall, this work
contributes to our understanding of how computational models may reflect human
cognitive processes in multilingual contexts.
|
[
0.13700705766677856,
-0.7385954260826111,
0.3567272126674652,
0.747960090637207,
-0.010559779591858387,
-0.053043659776449203,
-0.1659051477909088,
-0.4383872449398041,
0.029686979949474335,
0.32396405935287476,
-0.15246282517910004,
-0.3060162663459778,
-0.4321947991847992,
0.4977346360683441,
-0.3434828817844391,
0.7134251594543457,
0.100594662129879,
0.27802959084510803,
0.004442831035703421,
0.1621144860982895,
-0.6007120609283447,
-0.6615910530090332,
-0.5248764157295227,
-0.5371905565261841,
0.3744741380214691,
0.20100277662277222,
0.7449572682380676,
0.6526890993118286,
0.25356531143188477,
0.29022860527038574,
-0.26799678802490234,
-0.31137195229530334,
-0.31599968671798706,
0.2064284384250641,
-0.29695627093315125,
-0.7567415237426758,
-0.5230830907821655,
-0.3030567169189453,
1.009145975112915,
0.9916531443595886,
0.22198650240898132,
-0.012685911729931831,
0.19846151769161224,
0.675800085067749,
-0.46270036697387695,
0.38737669587135315,
-0.6670700907707214,
0.27265849709510803,
-0.16113491356372833,
-0.28719013929367065,
-0.6460509896278381,
-0.03785005584359169,
0.3295968770980835,
-0.2402399331331253,
0.2915245592594147,
0.043330345302820206,
0.6555585265159607,
-0.13954436779022217,
-0.5871796011924744,
0.1496969312429428,
-0.6359512805938721,
0.6915456652641296,
-0.5825456976890564,
0.4901981055736542,
0.2566244304180145,
-0.18906128406524658,
0.0803617537021637,
-0.8355851769447327,
-0.15600062906742096,
-0.48034608364105225,
-0.39256468415260315,
0.1759549379348755,
0.03867775946855545,
0.24716004729270935,
0.27877041697502136,
0.6200456023216248,
-0.9854673147201538,
0.010356071405112743,
-0.6005572080612183,
-0.28475216031074524,
0.42774248123168945,
0.17359064519405365,
0.6252486109733582,
-0.6137372851371765,
-0.4362141191959381,
-0.03410041704773903,
-0.6129931211471558,
0.36057010293006897,
0.41348764300346375,
0.3943870961666107,
-0.033662259578704834,
0.7588537335395813,
-0.1212005615234375,
0.8552666902542114,
-0.18897324800491333,
0.09773408621549606,
0.3348686993122101,
-0.723664402961731,
-0.3184976875782013,
0.10424873977899551,
0.8481581211090088,
0.20096100866794586,
0.6007255911827087,
-0.423674076795578,
-0.08619605004787445,
0.07976667582988739,
0.31558874249458313,
-0.5657199621200562,
-0.013125792145729065,
-0.07346251606941223,
-0.6131574511528015,
-0.18860061466693878,
0.29264190793037415,
-0.551957368850708,
0.1812237650156021,
-0.2602786123752594,
-0.03743329271674156,
-0.38585299253463745,
-0.09316505491733551,
0.4171700179576874,
-0.2664254903793335,
0.3207496404647827,
-0.44577834010124207,
-0.8962076902389526,
0.4653690755367279,
0.7489686608314514,
0.9039033055305481,
-0.43843773007392883,
-0.5332506895065308,
-0.20138321816921234,
0.12438737601041794,
-0.08792069554328918,
0.5865660309791565,
-0.37693488597869873,
-0.3003450632095337,
0.06129299849271774,
0.2498580664396286,
-0.525892436504364,
-0.5087072253227234,
0.7075557112693787,
-0.6616706252098083,
0.15828844904899597,
0.02637585997581482,
-0.2550520896911621,
-0.3339695334434509,
0.46543604135513306,
-1.1220725774765015,
0.7077060341835022,
-0.06424020975828171,
-0.6275596022605896,
0.07070169597864151,
-0.48385369777679443,
-0.8579482436180115,
-0.01627344638109207,
-0.1414102166891098,
-0.39128947257995605,
0.09461882710456848,
0.256736159324646,
0.2898178696632385,
-0.242639422416687,
0.47188130021095276,
0.11392823606729507,
-0.18406185507774353,
0.21190616488456726,
-0.5762581825256348,
0.9282949566841125,
-0.1162671223282814,
-0.3099924325942993,
0.26000577211380005,
-0.5051608085632324,
0.04548826441168785,
0.1330885887145996,
-0.5550788044929504,
-0.19602246582508087,
-0.19499003887176514,
0.43386173248291016,
0.3245290517807007,
0.2562585175037384,
-0.5548749566078186,
0.10034878551959991,
-0.7902670502662659,
0.5746891498565674,
0.33579638600349426,
0.19145579636096954,
0.5828889608383179,
-0.3778557777404785,
0.48972517251968384,
0.051655419170856476,
-0.14425790309906006,
-0.673275887966156,
-0.6384061574935913,
-0.5635238289833069,
0.2074246108531952,
0.3681645393371582,
0.9736669063568115,
-0.4519613981246948,
0.26411497592926025,
-0.6550745368003845,
0.05852698162198067,
-0.2302689552307129,
0.20978207886219025,
0.6338559985160828,
0.0949578732252121,
0.2651691734790802,
-0.3561024069786072,
-0.8636366128921509,
-1.337878704071045,
-0.5867773294448853,
-0.16526354849338531,
0.06966067105531693,
0.05821625515818596,
0.3987211585044861,
-0.009680853225290775,
1.0279533863067627,
-0.14976151287555695,
-0.2548832893371582,
-0.8019332885742188,
0.4480040967464447,
0.017264174297451973,
0.2898167669773102,
0.5040585398674011,
-1.146338701248169,
-0.48863887786865234,
-0.030442766845226288,
-0.5343489050865173,
-0.07471814751625061,
-0.2230089157819748,
0.2704903483390808,
0.3171234130859375,
0.5576276183128357,
-0.4849238395690918,
0.49454572796821594,
0.49912041425704956,
-0.2135428935289383,
0.5272449254989624,
-0.16404882073402405,
0.12089669704437256,
-1.1010249853134155,
0.15493860840797424,
-0.013246885500848293,
-0.28556814789772034,
-0.5376952886581421,
-0.06821300834417343,
0.05818071588873863,
-0.1669618934392929,
-0.4761523902416229,
0.2563888430595398,
-0.7229682207107544,
-0.3186677098274231,
-0.18102224171161652,
-0.16247177124023438,
0.09659254550933838,
0.650600016117096,
0.3320970833301544,
0.6331005096435547,
0.41155463457107544,
-0.3213253319263458,
0.14464518427848816,
-0.032172683626413345,
-0.6005982756614685,
-0.08070550858974457,
-1.0403709411621094,
-0.2555903494358063,
-0.31760311126708984,
0.24441570043563843,
-1.1890027523040771,
0.018369002267718315,
0.1268846094608307,
-0.4087314009666443,
0.13472889363765717,
-0.2609962821006775,
-0.5603772401809692,
-0.24405528604984283,
-0.15517549216747284,
0.824820339679718,
0.15442189574241638,
0.03684508427977562,
0.6729546785354614,
0.15286122262477875,
-0.4519970118999481,
-0.5151023268699646,
-1.0253976583480835,
0.31067606806755066,
0.1745837777853012,
-0.8567686676979065,
0.8030137419700623,
0.2978670001029968,
-0.20696300268173218,
0.036824118345975876,
0.046771492809057236,
-0.048243023455142975,
-0.0034451503306627274,
0.31341055035591125,
0.3176846504211426,
-0.480597585439682,
-0.09488753229379654,
-0.18160375952720642,
-0.29399195313453674,
0.26215019822120667,
-0.3417952060699463,
0.6186890006065369,
-0.3481405973434448,
-0.2920840382575989,
-0.44913092255592346,
0.388828843832016,
0.7762399315834045,
-0.4335345923900604,
0.8168988227844238,
0.09856605529785156,
-0.35108482837677,
-0.14157222211360931,
-0.3522159159183502,
-0.17031225562095642,
-0.32905930280685425,
0.6278932094573975,
-0.5258007049560547,
-0.6856056451797485,
0.44043439626693726,
0.28738126158714294,
0.05736469477415085,
0.22931033372879028,
0.7143644094467163,
0.3159344792366028,
0.8598059415817261,
0.6519812941551208,
-0.3449409306049347,
0.5455862879753113,
-0.3203579783439636,
0.32936275005340576,
-0.6634348630905151,
-0.06802262365818024,
-0.25641733407974243,
-0.4322679340839386,
-0.3699709475040436,
-0.4748726189136505,
0.29938602447509766,
-0.15236061811447144,
0.10408294945955276,
0.558156430721283,
-0.09109358489513397,
0.4898771047592163,
0.3497019112110138,
-0.11654911190271378,
0.6074061989784241,
0.09468471258878708,
-0.44205188751220703,
-0.1084652692079544,
-0.8031417727470398,
-0.41731321811676025,
0.9642285108566284,
0.2542850375175476,
0.581895112991333,
-0.3029457628726959,
0.037358131259679794,
0.10076446086168289,
0.21164289116859436,
-0.7669915556907654,
0.4793274998664856,
-0.1896796077489853,
-0.6768909096717834,
-0.31690290570259094,
-0.41842350363731384,
-1.1388505697250366,
0.5881733894348145,
0.04188878834247589,
-0.6035639047622681,
-0.03023495152592659,
-0.3328343331813812,
-0.37528887391090393,
0.44961288571357727,
-0.4348447918891907,
1.0912857055664062,
-0.3794254660606384,
-0.1492891162633896,
-0.2383982539176941,
-0.7564631700515747,
0.5277172923088074,
0.3278307020664215,
-0.05544375255703926,
0.2948361337184906,
0.07785438746213913,
0.5607695579528809,
0.2300853282213211,
0.9494912028312683,
0.3841743469238281,
-0.05986702814698219,
0.1169251799583435,
0.18388353288173676,
0.07508260756731033,
0.1902424842119217,
-0.18852093815803528,
0.1953733116388321,
-0.21153759956359863,
-0.17937560379505157,
-0.6563873887062073,
0.5285583138465881,
-0.5661652684211731,
-0.6039382219314575,
-0.3917960822582245,
-0.9350268840789795,
0.023371679708361626,
0.18233869969844818,
0.43692952394485474,
0.3250493109226227,
-0.41491514444351196,
0.44983649253845215,
0.31225672364234924,
-0.03459951654076576,
0.507881224155426,
0.44773706793785095,
-0.2981802821159363,
-0.4767637252807617,
0.5039019584655762,
0.21019895374774933,
0.37269970774650574,
0.9373475909233093,
-0.08360861986875534,
-0.12828606367111206,
-0.34341076016426086,
-0.26121237874031067,
0.4208090901374817,
-0.4057226777076721,
0.1763267070055008,
-0.820527195930481,
-0.5500481724739075,
-0.6614439487457275,
0.059649012982845306,
-0.32532304525375366,
-0.5059204697608948,
0.12727296352386475,
-0.41881728172302246,
-0.3050059974193573,
0.47683191299438477,
0.17175230383872986,
-0.029863007366657257,
-0.8315903544425964,
0.5609394311904907,
0.10188214480876923,
0.15639755129814148,
0.0789317861199379,
-0.42990052700042725,
-0.20344918966293335,
0.2141607701778412,
-0.24434585869312286,
-0.8606005311012268,
0.3546435534954071,
0.11421527713537216,
0.6815688610076904,
0.07934315502643585,
-0.23788593709468842,
0.33389103412628174,
-0.6583803296089172,
0.8154131174087524,
-0.1848311871290207,
-0.8883422017097473,
0.4152846336364746,
-0.1245523989200592,
0.5049107074737549,
0.2249477654695511,
0.4029708206653595,
-0.7469361424446106,
-0.2923644185066223,
-0.3056228756904602,
-0.9122923016548157,
0.6262137293815613,
0.3718438446521759,
0.02721380442380905,
-0.03972279280424118,
0.2607784569263458,
-0.12420890480279922,
-0.0987846851348877,
-1.4001455307006836,
-0.40680423378944397,
0.022952785715460777,
0.15760044753551483,
-0.21894054114818573,
-0.49095040559768677,
0.13348068296909332,
-0.15302450954914093,
0.42945343255996704,
0.02173377014696598,
-0.046760283410549164,
0.3733152747154236,
-0.47956767678260803,
-0.02659248560667038,
0.520969033241272,
0.5749107003211975,
0.4832376539707184,
-0.0676916167140007,
-0.015829790383577347,
-0.018175939098000526,
-0.3196733593940735,
0.13057926297187805,
0.04294556751847267,
-0.3538307845592499,
0.21827645599842072,
0.6127929091453552,
0.7563545107841492,
0.7841030955314636,
-0.6271825432777405,
0.5045472979545593,
-0.014018426649272442,
-0.14738747477531433,
-0.2389110028743744,
-0.3014540672302246,
0.0634516105055809,
0.007111833896487951,
0.3070802390575409,
0.15023688971996307,
0.07173779606819153,
-0.707605242729187,
0.26784518361091614,
0.20796677470207214,
-0.11255070567131042,
-0.6354644298553467,
0.612700343132019,
-0.019971651956439018,
-0.41097643971443176,
0.8447290658950806,
0.17772673070430756,
-0.8995296955108643,
0.6592000722885132,
0.898032546043396,
1.037154197692871,
-0.15642912685871124,
0.1518069952726364,
0.48010319471359253,
0.5393925905227661,
-0.1720895618200302,
0.2647336721420288,
-0.27322080731391907,
-0.9005715250968933,
-0.6878923177719116,
-0.38544291257858276,
0.03843861445784569,
0.0012721000239253044,
-0.8410546183586121,
0.07710542529821396,
0.0741012766957283,
-0.20687617361545563,
-0.12127651274204254,
-0.32334446907043457,
-0.37282291054725647,
-0.1750670075416565,
0.4769155979156494,
0.8993166089057922,
-0.9443104863166809,
0.8068561553955078,
0.8151047825813293,
-0.348524272441864,
-0.5573196411132812,
0.026805028319358826,
-0.15417788922786713,
-0.3831726312637329,
1.1896798610687256,
0.3473609685897827,
-0.1430150717496872,
-0.17380593717098236,
0.04822271689772606,
-0.7471098899841309,
0.9613965749740601,
0.3043355345726013,
-0.22829154133796692,
-0.6188538074493408,
0.8026588559150696,
0.6653869152069092,
-0.33197125792503357,
-0.06518888473510742,
0.5590991973876953,
0.5120917558670044,
-0.2380741983652115,
-1.1731173992156982,
-0.1817152053117752,
-0.529371440410614,
0.37590184807777405,
0.013266890309751034,
-0.3521663248538971,
1.0312288999557495,
-0.05583072453737259,
-0.5222078561782837,
0.2148895412683487,
0.6289833188056946,
0.25918328762054443,
-0.05368545651435852,
0.5177758932113647,
0.7352173328399658,
0.19747839868068695,
0.09570711106061935,
1.1000562906265259,
-0.7468759417533875,
0.06301181763410568,
1.052310585975647,
-0.3301199972629547,
0.8150949478149414,
0.4334937632083893,
0.0665026605129242,
0.7912877202033997,
0.005684113595634699,
0.2289559245109558,
0.3124545216560364,
0.1373184621334076,
0.004528998862951994,
-0.11860743910074234,
0.08220818638801575,
-0.24987877905368805,
0.48513513803482056,
0.2563668191432953,
-0.7221766710281372,
-0.48162391781806946,
0.20197077095508575,
-0.38003894686698914,
0.196658194065094,
-0.27907881140708923,
0.6060993671417236,
0.2920173704624176,
-1.1036807298660278,
0.3272671103477478,
0.46747279167175293,
0.596107006072998,
-0.5422008037567139,
0.10391642153263092,
-0.03281165659427643,
0.2461261749267578,
-0.15228606760501862,
-0.8302558064460754,
0.572539210319519,
-0.08728672564029694,
-0.6780409216880798,
-0.868100106716156,
0.6400140523910522,
-0.6154024600982666,
-0.5406864881515503,
0.5508006811141968,
0.7140910625457764,
-0.12645435333251953,
-0.0676209032535553,
-0.6190873980522156,
-0.08917083591222763,
-0.09430363774299622,
-0.3964579403400421,
0.1784779578447342,
0.25568726658821106,
-0.24138033390045166,
0.5828034281730652,
0.6404887437820435,
0.18247279524803162,
0.3970060348510742,
0.4058530330657959,
0.37119966745376587,
-0.7366474866867065,
-0.7602428793907166,
-1.0002446174621582,
0.4831116795539856,
0.24914014339447021,
-0.23089668154716492,
0.8781271576881409,
0.9193661212921143,
1.0036675930023193,
-0.34703007340431213,
0.5763818621635437,
0.1523556411266327,
0.2272968292236328,
-0.40342977643013,
0.564026951789856,
-0.13490958511829376,
0.13939471542835236,
0.06234472990036011,
-1.0034366846084595,
-0.5201250314712524,
0.5155656337738037,
-0.56135493516922,
-0.13217738270759583,
0.7624894976615906,
0.8396046161651611,
-0.09092748910188675,
0.23306134343147278,
0.2684621810913086,
0.3447458744049072,
0.2155686914920807,
0.8591998219490051,
0.7950571179389954,
-0.6159443259239197,
0.6568882465362549,
-0.3382077217102051,
0.2070332020521164,
0.020754026249051094,
-0.6834038496017456,
-0.8274394273757935,
-0.6748930811882019,
0.09811986982822418,
-0.12929944694042206,
-0.03270917385816574,
0.689872682094574,
0.6363682746887207,
-0.7324532866477966,
-0.6556914448738098,
-0.301516592502594,
0.21308432519435883,
-0.36145827174186707,
-0.3553612232208252,
0.1711222231388092,
-0.5773447155952454,
-0.7434056401252747,
0.5170240998268127,
0.4772772490978241,
-0.1274919956922531,
-0.3179001808166504,
0.22510762512683868,
-0.39195510745048523,
-0.222976952791214,
0.6514845490455627,
0.3633795380592346,
-0.8642072081565857,
0.16152323782444,
0.41305020451545715,
-0.49481460452079773,
0.24273906648159027,
1.3721967935562134,
-0.9882179498672485,
0.09916578233242035,
0.8539423942565918,
0.718021810054779,
0.3067438006401062,
0.08107063919305801,
1.045390248298645,
-0.6481063961982727,
0.22847077250480652,
0.34948310256004333,
0.6981452107429504,
0.23746709525585175,
-0.18469242751598358,
0.35717305541038513,
0.21150445938110352,
-0.4188905954360962,
-0.7104697823524475,
0.26679521799087524,
-0.9013635516166687,
-0.30991578102111816,
1.0657017230987549,
0.006436761002987623,
-0.3493131101131439,
-0.27308347821235657,
-0.2393629103899002,
0.17770211398601532,
0.07443492114543915,
0.705402135848999,
0.8116930723190308,
0.10041748732328415,
-0.23044876754283905,
-0.29190874099731445,
0.0954979732632637,
0.708989143371582,
-0.4893023371696472,
-0.04717499017715454,
0.1845131814479828,
0.30423504114151,
0.40061652660369873,
0.2929469645023346,
-0.34406110644340515,
0.48051348328590393,
-0.17909997701644897,
-0.1797427386045456,
-0.11599332094192505,
-0.5223304033279419,
-0.4555032551288605,
0.5329577922821045,
-0.45876914262771606,
0.07895282655954361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09507v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09507v1
|
QueryNER: Segmentation of E-commerce Queries
| 2024-05-15T16:58:35 | 2024-05-15T16:58:35 |
Chester Palen-Michel, Lizzie Liang, Zhe Wu, Constantine Lignos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present QueryNER, a manually-annotated dataset and accompanying model for
e-commerce query segmentation. Prior work in sequence labeling for e-commerce
has largely addressed aspect-value extraction which focuses on extracting
portions of a product title or query for narrowly defined aspects. Our work
instead focuses on the goal of dividing a query into meaningful chunks with
broadly applicable types. We report baseline tagging results and conduct
experiments comparing token and entity dropping for null and low recall query
recovery. Challenging test sets are created using automatic transformations and
show how simple data augmentation techniques can make the models more robust to
noise. We make the QueryNER dataset publicly available.
|
[
-0.5326428413391113,
-0.8593243360519409,
0.05614534020423889,
-0.1256197988986969,
-0.20724758505821228,
0.07700853794813156,
0.4427107274532318,
-0.8008066415786743,
0.39151430130004883,
0.6695778369903564,
-0.7276887893676758,
-0.48480790853500366,
-0.06248225271701813,
0.21524599194526672,
-0.6770716905593872,
1.028940200805664,
0.527396559715271,
-0.10921566933393478,
-0.26209861040115356,
-0.16130121052265167,
-0.17195335030555725,
-0.8238211870193481,
-0.6824668645858765,
0.2651749551296234,
0.6153706312179565,
0.5075869560241699,
0.14169859886169434,
0.5878850817680359,
0.6260796189308167,
0.3276589810848236,
-0.07552213221788406,
0.1711677461862564,
-0.4997670352458954,
0.581455647945404,
-0.13922829926013947,
-0.6664505004882812,
-0.30965086817741394,
-0.0042190770618617535,
0.09351656585931778,
0.9062673449516296,
-0.24025213718414307,
0.4124513566493988,
-0.5440121293067932,
0.5823813080787659,
-0.7018214464187622,
-0.03322726860642433,
-0.6852075457572937,
-0.07452459633350372,
-0.02937649004161358,
0.12536944448947906,
-0.5369516611099243,
-0.31522348523139954,
0.0868261456489563,
-0.5652939081192017,
0.6632480621337891,
0.8287087678909302,
1.2858917713165283,
0.1903446614742279,
-0.502741813659668,
-0.1935155689716339,
-0.7150800824165344,
0.5487514138221741,
-0.15388093888759613,
0.7025396227836609,
0.6557415723800659,
0.42323926091194153,
0.21015585958957672,
-1.0435893535614014,
-0.20898166298866272,
0.31133076548576355,
-0.2868443429470062,
-0.0330924466252327,
-0.207550510764122,
-0.03050617314875126,
0.33083218336105347,
0.5492650270462036,
-0.37600985169410706,
-0.09897353500127792,
-0.8165188431739807,
-0.05279742553830147,
0.8833437561988831,
0.3762027621269226,
0.23963551223278046,
-0.3422614336013794,
-0.13713425397872925,
0.1574750691652298,
-0.4968074560165405,
0.12916649878025055,
0.31325462460517883,
0.24142105877399445,
0.4192267954349518,
0.5329975485801697,
-0.5209043025970459,
1.0020489692687988,
0.45029109716415405,
-0.12466423213481903,
0.026169542223215103,
-0.25562670826911926,
-0.36187440156936646,
0.23946663737297058,
0.5444787740707397,
0.44992703199386597,
-0.2081483006477356,
-0.2779605984687805,
-0.27200525999069214,
-0.6383493542671204,
0.33431634306907654,
-1.0061603784561157,
-0.6225706338882446,
0.4547812044620514,
-0.5961660146713257,
-0.051570095121860504,
0.4858357608318329,
-0.6605038642883301,
-0.2934354841709137,
-0.08353351801633835,
-0.048326026648283005,
-0.07043829560279846,
0.09440939128398895,
0.07038701325654984,
-0.34672707319259644,
0.5105859637260437,
0.11727536469697952,
-0.7890312671661377,
0.5293524265289307,
1.0198636054992676,
0.7139101028442383,
-0.09072936326265335,
0.3292962610721588,
-0.43118709325790405,
0.28001394867897034,
-0.09979307651519775,
0.9214330315589905,
-0.7892042398452759,
-0.5972753167152405,
-0.09344077855348587,
0.6686620116233826,
0.01893361657857895,
-0.6058171987533569,
0.5237517356872559,
-1.333398699760437,
0.1418256312608719,
-0.2903078496456146,
-0.9654587507247925,
-0.34974226355552673,
0.6087650060653687,
-0.9884328246116638,
0.7705087065696716,
0.024915186688303947,
-0.4369671940803528,
0.6548869013786316,
-0.31405529379844666,
-0.6883448362350464,
0.39767691493034363,
0.06802166253328323,
-0.3931584060192108,
0.25538620352745056,
0.12452965974807739,
0.045503031462430954,
-0.41295403242111206,
-0.34103482961654663,
-0.326696515083313,
-0.10777934640645981,
0.31850963830947876,
0.12702657282352448,
0.4098406136035919,
0.3331186771392822,
0.10770528018474579,
-0.01068232674151659,
-0.9948490262031555,
0.20624756813049316,
0.3349950313568115,
-0.07932321727275848,
-0.5391179323196411,
0.12757572531700134,
0.3726215362548828,
-0.04673784226179123,
0.023137005046010017,
-0.6285479664802551,
0.30820798873901367,
-0.4324619174003601,
0.44183623790740967,
0.29222553968429565,
0.48177996277809143,
0.30742067098617554,
-0.052306946367025375,
0.7266674041748047,
-0.12071363627910614,
0.3880980610847473,
-0.4337054193019867,
-0.4690287709236145,
-1.0919544696807861,
-0.12749218940734863,
0.5411773324012756,
0.370021790266037,
-0.4539123773574829,
0.5311228632926941,
-0.27400076389312744,
-0.29365020990371704,
-0.29872921109199524,
-0.4062225818634033,
0.01932583376765251,
0.5365225076675415,
0.33687451481819153,
-0.231100931763649,
-0.39685049653053284,
-1.182091236114502,
-0.3238524794578552,
-0.14713901281356812,
-0.21969589591026306,
0.30197620391845703,
0.24212822318077087,
0.12876489758491516,
1.0213830471038818,
-1.1097804307937622,
-0.32625702023506165,
-0.06347277015447617,
0.08885012567043304,
0.19417043030261993,
0.5075918436050415,
0.08042289316654205,
-1.3563361167907715,
-0.3733265995979309,
-0.10174623131752014,
-0.17680807411670685,
0.11265892535448074,
0.11424686759710312,
-0.25797611474990845,
0.107719786465168,
0.3424660861492157,
-0.28184249997138977,
0.6731830835342407,
-0.2099522054195404,
-0.18976618349552155,
0.25314176082611084,
0.07902968674898148,
0.47193583846092224,
-1.0284779071807861,
-0.03214577957987785,
0.30790576338768005,
-0.3637135326862335,
-0.6540655493736267,
0.016015421599149704,
0.17725688219070435,
-0.14816397428512573,
-0.39866843819618225,
0.12249589711427689,
-0.36235296726226807,
-0.1985650211572647,
-0.3420991897583008,
-0.1998825967311859,
0.47649532556533813,
0.04379936307668686,
0.03622468560934067,
0.5936918258666992,
0.035737816244363785,
-0.7288612723350525,
0.2397231012582779,
0.42923009395599365,
-0.3231804370880127,
0.7919948697090149,
-0.8559398055076599,
0.46826785802841187,
-0.010978301987051964,
0.01548517681658268,
-0.9697258472442627,
-0.6019061207771301,
0.5114668011665344,
-0.15780425071716309,
0.15983639657497406,
-0.9472324252128601,
-0.5457972884178162,
-0.44993555545806885,
0.10491295903921127,
0.4887731969356537,
0.409675270318985,
-0.42854151129722595,
0.44613638520240784,
0.6600317358970642,
-0.12911513447761536,
0.030025679618120193,
-0.6401818990707397,
-0.103176549077034,
-0.2374112457036972,
-0.6264462471008301,
0.5270563364028931,
0.19654138386249542,
-0.15229925513267517,
-0.025643080472946167,
-0.16963250935077667,
-0.6109743118286133,
-0.02041447162628174,
0.21852970123291016,
0.1891787350177765,
-0.12396079301834106,
0.27588212490081787,
0.11356929689645767,
-0.13859187066555023,
0.15489532053470612,
-0.49781423807144165,
0.2533370554447174,
0.1544385701417923,
-0.6780494451522827,
-0.17460599541664124,
0.3765985667705536,
-0.09895245730876923,
-0.48241543769836426,
0.5347702503204346,
0.21961116790771484,
-0.5168099999427795,
-0.1668568253517151,
-0.5253629088401794,
-0.09806136041879654,
-0.4657568633556366,
0.2934635281562805,
-0.6126689910888672,
-0.8127974271774292,
0.35279402136802673,
0.07583771646022797,
-0.10152707993984222,
0.4415000081062317,
-0.07648248970508575,
0.013398056849837303,
1.2053319215774536,
0.654850959777832,
0.2575564384460449,
0.272603303194046,
-0.19605594873428345,
0.5270553827285767,
-0.6607273817062378,
-0.6174378991127014,
-0.6698214411735535,
-0.3794686198234558,
-0.4889727830886841,
-0.30747729539871216,
0.05210867524147034,
0.4044150412082672,
-0.1803337186574936,
0.12172817438840866,
-0.8130695223808289,
0.8447545766830444,
0.49582532048225403,
0.23703274130821228,
0.17477166652679443,
0.11205535382032394,
0.5693572163581848,
0.02375154383480549,
-0.2751828134059906,
-0.24897237122058868,
0.8547481298446655,
-0.17851170897483826,
0.7300940155982971,
0.09873806685209274,
0.45265284180641174,
0.2663801908493042,
0.1746477484703064,
-1.2014505863189697,
0.2492063343524933,
0.11553194373846054,
-1.0673450231552124,
-0.060131292790174484,
-0.22936207056045532,
-0.9544973373413086,
0.2772023379802704,
0.3107018768787384,
-0.9422937631607056,
0.5249228477478027,
0.040001749992370605,
-0.4794931709766388,
0.07620634883642197,
-0.6112847328186035,
0.8189666867256165,
-0.48582351207733154,
-0.5098699331283569,
0.3900797963142395,
-0.6884027719497681,
0.23497691750526428,
-0.004928162787109613,
0.20284858345985413,
-0.31568479537963867,
-0.2346039116382599,
0.8273065686225891,
-0.6325362920761108,
0.422917902469635,
-0.12088344991207123,
0.29204297065734863,
0.3580619692802429,
0.21730314195156097,
0.3976786136627197,
-0.010523423552513123,
0.19818831980228424,
-0.2564604878425598,
0.2776618003845215,
-0.5211805105209351,
-0.45667174458503723,
0.19382396340370178,
-0.09954597055912018,
-0.7553973197937012,
-0.446929931640625,
-0.061339545994997025,
-0.24530446529388428,
0.2832548916339874,
0.06087867170572281,
0.23884208500385284,
-0.3144274652004242,
0.24220190942287445,
0.5352562665939331,
0.08785175532102585,
0.29405513405799866,
0.5233692526817322,
-0.4351758658885956,
-0.702171802520752,
0.8310121893882751,
-0.0907190591096878,
-0.1585768759250641,
0.3256312310695648,
-0.07462716102600098,
-0.6240986585617065,
-0.576130211353302,
-0.2831331491470337,
-0.11285033077001572,
-0.9332273602485657,
-0.2373943030834198,
-0.6308034658432007,
0.01368020847439766,
-0.4048566520214081,
0.04810680076479912,
-0.22564838826656342,
-0.5214553475379944,
-0.14663159847259521,
-0.4207890033721924,
0.4626142084598541,
0.9135679006576538,
0.18748582899570465,
0.4557400345802307,
-1.0968343019485474,
0.1108444482088089,
0.16123099625110626,
0.14196617901325226,
-0.150999516248703,
-0.25481274724006653,
-0.4226023256778717,
-0.16742609441280365,
-0.2235102504491806,
-0.7987074255943298,
0.5461214780807495,
0.2443419247865677,
0.30310583114624023,
0.6621456742286682,
0.27470600605010986,
0.8458049297332764,
-0.27842873334884644,
0.9939522743225098,
0.19594696164131165,
-0.6344728469848633,
0.766386091709137,
-0.12647338211536407,
0.000948603090364486,
0.7744657397270203,
0.7936820983886719,
-0.6790326237678528,
0.30839723348617554,
-0.5140935182571411,
-1.3354368209838867,
0.9563767910003662,
-0.049831587821245193,
-0.1238086149096489,
-0.2504609227180481,
0.4169139564037323,
0.2904803156852722,
0.21294493973255157,
-0.18952621519565582,
-0.6425960063934326,
-0.003953418228775263,
-0.14462079107761383,
0.14425089955329895,
-0.43713393807411194,
-0.13093483448028564,
-0.376112699508667,
0.4060900807380676,
0.03382682055234909,
-0.009307494387030602,
0.2251698076725006,
-0.6275404095649719,
0.196689173579216,
0.17033305764198303,
0.13844677805900574,
0.8417832255363464,
-0.22513258457183838,
-0.1695362776517868,
-0.36863788962364197,
-0.3976462483406067,
0.22411096096038818,
0.4686024785041809,
-0.43241482973098755,
-0.25410783290863037,
0.015924405306577682,
0.5564717054367065,
0.30968937277793884,
-0.3920242488384247,
0.2936486005783081,
-0.30914419889450073,
-0.0020071743056178093,
-0.14006999135017395,
-0.10829643160104752,
-0.07926560938358307,
0.07884978502988815,
0.5999470949172974,
-0.21577513217926025,
0.774425208568573,
0.015273126773536205,
0.5239897966384888,
-0.08176364004611969,
-0.6756224632263184,
-0.40748023986816406,
0.9351125359535217,
0.31057676672935486,
-0.6040118932723999,
0.9996614456176758,
-0.4322587251663208,
-0.5842155814170837,
0.6917330622673035,
0.39240702986717224,
0.9841130375862122,
0.15434570610523224,
0.18778112530708313,
0.3858402669429779,
0.11812598258256912,
0.2069302350282669,
0.14499881863594055,
-0.3046881854534149,
-0.3328932225704193,
-0.07701095193624496,
-0.7121067047119141,
-0.3341219425201416,
-0.20801329612731934,
-1.11299729347229,
0.12739236652851105,
-0.3096650540828705,
-0.3203142583370209,
0.2700386643409729,
-0.12371818721294403,
-0.6907094120979309,
0.30756038427352905,
-0.029910732060670853,
0.5210524201393127,
-0.3069112300872803,
0.491873562335968,
0.7732253074645996,
-0.9240067005157471,
-0.5870330929756165,
-0.04667631536722183,
0.0651584267616272,
-0.5063327550888062,
0.8892343044281006,
0.5271649360656738,
0.12093448638916016,
-0.025288302451372147,
-0.5054548382759094,
-0.8293095827102661,
0.9143008589744568,
-0.34824204444885254,
-0.6665529012680054,
0.10165303945541382,
0.33073344826698303,
0.08862398564815521,
-0.41409432888031006,
0.44261881709098816,
0.7117300629615784,
0.24660149216651917,
0.5068353414535522,
-0.45899325609207153,
0.03766033798456192,
-0.2304743230342865,
-0.08529183268547058,
0.5341918468475342,
-0.6059026122093201,
0.540713369846344,
0.15133872628211975,
-0.3915197551250458,
0.11969713121652603,
0.5112550258636475,
-0.11237943172454834,
0.5148453712463379,
0.5632565021514893,
0.5900341272354126,
1.0312182903289795,
-0.24512962996959686,
0.9318025708198547,
-0.3022362291812897,
0.48890629410743713,
1.2403218746185303,
-0.3764943778514862,
0.7489919662475586,
0.20481649041175842,
-0.49495914578437805,
0.31724387407302856,
1.130686640739441,
-0.20917829871177673,
0.4198572039604187,
0.18488764762878418,
-0.006450485438108444,
-0.47701653838157654,
-0.17822608351707458,
-0.34489527344703674,
0.3616820275783539,
0.364942729473114,
-0.4934832453727722,
0.12379687279462814,
-0.2693280577659607,
-0.09803031384944916,
-0.45605865120887756,
-0.2981926202774048,
1.0469937324523926,
-0.049975406378507614,
-0.3095559775829315,
0.28430214524269104,
0.0830780640244484,
0.22090734541416168,
-0.15256810188293457,
0.051089975982904434,
-0.26052579283714294,
0.018450012430548668,
-0.31826820969581604,
-0.29959049820899963,
0.27270975708961487,
-0.17906633019447327,
-0.2299029678106308,
0.21950958669185638,
1.0039290189743042,
-0.16468532383441925,
-0.8150455951690674,
-0.1635032594203949,
0.44152480363845825,
0.24969714879989624,
-0.3050178289413452,
-0.7484745383262634,
-0.016942987218499184,
-0.005612288601696491,
-0.3848194181919098,
0.02193235419690609,
0.44801944494247437,
0.17773838341236115,
0.5128848552703857,
0.5791347026824951,
-0.4557333290576935,
0.5118643045425415,
0.2329600602388382,
0.8238602876663208,
-1.115098237991333,
-0.565240204334259,
-0.4996965229511261,
0.612818717956543,
-0.6286375522613525,
-0.1860889494419098,
0.8919256329536438,
1.155632495880127,
0.8650641441345215,
0.08382424712181091,
0.6540228128433228,
-0.11230602860450745,
0.25261208415031433,
-0.17685340344905853,
0.6600491404533386,
-0.6617547273635864,
0.15533499419689178,
0.1708875149488449,
-0.8419002890586853,
-0.31769809126853943,
0.15139606595039368,
-0.3631616532802582,
0.013695069588720798,
0.5144001245498657,
0.6365833878517151,
-0.12212751805782318,
0.4899655282497406,
0.2753540873527527,
-0.12650491297245026,
0.41258057951927185,
-0.02062937058508396,
1.059573769569397,
-0.6165679693222046,
0.5834190845489502,
-0.6063300371170044,
0.000911443610675633,
-0.4168902337551117,
-0.3322566747665405,
-0.7227098345756531,
-0.42508208751678467,
-0.5560662746429443,
-0.1640784591436386,
0.054695986211299896,
0.8658021688461304,
1.1848317384719849,
-0.9672315716743469,
-0.1593637317419052,
0.1678326278924942,
0.11434105038642883,
0.003617608919739723,
-0.25095653533935547,
0.2489769458770752,
-0.5399272441864014,
-0.7710500955581665,
0.2927669584751129,
0.27402856945991516,
0.012908133678138256,
0.15869654715061188,
0.3726847767829895,
-0.24850201606750488,
-0.11063559353351593,
0.5664756894111633,
0.2921152710914612,
-0.6303799152374268,
-0.0756782665848732,
0.2521551251411438,
0.4985794425010681,
0.3768916130065918,
0.94829922914505,
-0.4769710302352905,
0.5979124307632446,
0.5083067417144775,
0.5839419960975647,
0.8331199884414673,
0.5960979461669922,
0.36078861355781555,
-0.6985483169555664,
0.02632746286690235,
0.35728827118873596,
0.21779155731201172,
0.16274602711200714,
-0.35542502999305725,
0.5047704577445984,
0.28819093108177185,
-0.653709352016449,
-0.6947057247161865,
0.24357551336288452,
-0.7862990498542786,
-0.3253801763057709,
0.9513413906097412,
-0.08061533421278,
-0.774432361125946,
-0.4406241476535797,
-0.021824844181537628,
-0.13869374990463257,
-0.41424497961997986,
0.38279008865356445,
0.467379093170166,
-0.4359287619590759,
-0.25952470302581787,
-0.0008367493283003569,
0.17259825766086578,
-0.1732688546180725,
-0.8461335301399231,
-0.21180424094200134,
1.0214766263961792,
0.32230550050735474,
0.0241131242364645,
0.27334147691726685,
0.07931018620729446,
-0.12482574582099915,
0.17180761694908142,
-0.015038512647151947,
-0.09772371500730515,
-0.14024746417999268,
-0.11044231802225113,
0.6482320427894592,
0.12404277920722961,
-0.64034104347229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09496v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09496v1
|
ParaNames 1.0: Creating an Entity Name Corpus for 400+ Languages using Wikidata
| 2024-05-15T16:44:54 | 2024-05-15T16:44:54 |
Jonne Sälevä, Constantine Lignos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce ParaNames, a massively multilingual parallel name resource
consisting of 140 million names spanning over 400 languages. Names are provided
for 16.8 million entities, and each entity is mapped from a complex type
hierarchy to a standard type (PER/LOC/ORG). Using Wikidata as a source, we
create the largest resource of this type to date. We describe our approach to
filtering and standardizing the data to provide the best quality possible.
ParaNames is useful for multilingual language processing, both in defining
tasks for name translation/transliteration and as supplementary data for tasks
such as named entity recognition and linking. We demonstrate the usefulness of
ParaNames on two tasks. First, we perform canonical name translation between
English and 17 other languages. Second, we use it as a gazetteer for
multilingual named entity recognition, obtaining performance improvements on
all 10 languages evaluated.
|
[
-0.7502319812774658,
-0.1689808964729309,
0.28449103236198425,
0.5442802906036377,
-0.15087144076824188,
0.13232310116291046,
-0.5501141548156738,
-0.7760322093963623,
0.5986226797103882,
0.6063433885574341,
-0.3560255765914917,
-0.5662927031517029,
-0.5575408339500427,
0.6003109216690063,
-0.5700836777687073,
1.201926350593567,
-0.06337983161211014,
0.1723635047674179,
-0.04907176271080971,
-0.15794596076011658,
0.13957849144935608,
-0.09492496401071548,
-1.0052598714828491,
0.1972946971654892,
1.0251965522766113,
0.6833694577217102,
0.4959285855293274,
0.6265396475791931,
0.7705020308494568,
0.3298557698726654,
0.04592050611972809,
0.32995399832725525,
-0.4658988416194916,
0.13873346149921417,
-0.6115497946739197,
-0.28622201085090637,
-0.4204448163509369,
-0.2086876630783081,
0.8270819187164307,
0.9069018959999084,
-0.15074600279331207,
0.39319226145744324,
-0.04431953281164169,
0.5029590129852295,
-0.700191080570221,
0.11901624500751495,
-0.44252294301986694,
0.008625260554254055,
-0.8097146153450012,
-0.3253350853919983,
-0.34970933198928833,
-0.45701539516448975,
0.07539239525794983,
-0.7879765033721924,
0.08814045786857605,
0.037834372371435165,
0.9750028848648071,
0.09573705494403839,
-0.3279993534088135,
-0.40232837200164795,
-0.8149824738502502,
0.8451968431472778,
0.05242099240422249,
0.7476597428321838,
0.3802025318145752,
0.42485567927360535,
-0.22018685936927795,
-0.98958820104599,
-0.27276960015296936,
-0.1428532898426056,
-0.11794673651456833,
-0.07304102182388306,
-0.4225316345691681,
-0.1141558513045311,
0.27844366431236267,
0.30939817428588867,
-0.4686642289161682,
0.1871177852153778,
-0.6889586448669434,
-0.42371177673339844,
0.456216424703598,
0.13723744451999664,
0.22132912278175354,
-0.2994919419288635,
-0.46623873710632324,
0.21554581820964813,
-0.7035550475120544,
-0.046634089201688766,
0.6145961284637451,
0.3014785647392273,
0.29320621490478516,
0.26225927472114563,
-0.45559224486351013,
0.824901819229126,
-0.1784629076719284,
-0.6320683360099792,
0.219147726893425,
-0.05265308916568756,
-0.2603280544281006,
-0.1647987961769104,
0.8945928812026978,
0.05788679048418999,
0.20828010141849518,
-0.7129696607589722,
0.1612682193517685,
-0.31517234444618225,
0.23813457787036896,
-0.847572386264801,
-0.06297130882740021,
0.19250166416168213,
-0.11361343413591385,
-0.3356538712978363,
0.1619780957698822,
-0.965844452381134,
-0.35591378808021545,
-0.29813891649246216,
-0.1104496568441391,
-0.6121087670326233,
-0.4020980894565582,
-0.033459361642599106,
-0.14672358334064484,
-0.046741969883441925,
0.4045659005641937,
-0.735645592212677,
0.5144190788269043,
0.5473892688751221,
0.5206732749938965,
-0.32338225841522217,
-0.6730827689170837,
-0.4802095293998718,
0.2526991069316864,
-0.5247498154640198,
1.186120867729187,
-0.3934782147407532,
-0.35592377185821533,
-0.23009730875492096,
0.28790363669395447,
0.33239221572875977,
-0.6263933181762695,
0.680945098400116,
-0.31674668192863464,
-0.19862015545368195,
-0.3513789772987366,
-0.41763320565223694,
-0.22983422875404358,
0.15690487623214722,
-0.9359608888626099,
1.1961935758590698,
0.097491055727005,
-0.6414927244186401,
0.16849839687347412,
-0.43423956632614136,
-0.527748703956604,
0.4403976500034332,
-0.1632463037967682,
0.11758928000926971,
0.11518971621990204,
-0.08330214023590088,
0.39371925592422485,
-0.7333322763442993,
0.3188403248786926,
0.03904617950320244,
0.10047964006662369,
-0.042097803205251694,
-0.04104942828416824,
0.9988617897033691,
0.5210952162742615,
-0.10594086349010468,
-0.16904403269290924,
-0.7165144681930542,
-0.22461022436618805,
-0.18093468248844147,
-0.2670547068119049,
-0.32901889085769653,
0.10499905049800873,
0.29678311944007874,
0.05830792337656021,
0.16659556329250336,
-0.6803690791130066,
0.0655733123421669,
0.033580660820007324,
0.1631166934967041,
0.23834364116191864,
-0.35116323828697205,
0.4618658721446991,
-0.06868641823530197,
0.6188046932220459,
0.32112956047058105,
0.12564678490161896,
-0.153220072388649,
-0.7481306195259094,
-0.979703426361084,
-0.3516393005847931,
0.7364822626113892,
0.5008312463760376,
-0.8243117332458496,
0.08797084540128708,
-0.6384345889091492,
-0.927621066570282,
-0.4158727526664734,
0.046319082379341125,
0.040281377732753754,
0.7017316818237305,
0.33740609884262085,
-0.11215221881866455,
-1.0027014017105103,
-1.2389479875564575,
0.07691866904497147,
0.05540494620800018,
-0.08588194847106934,
0.1554492712020874,
0.37631064653396606,
-0.2992945611476898,
0.8859372735023499,
-0.4661520719528198,
-0.3568284511566162,
0.1932288557291031,
-0.09845546633005142,
-0.13199995458126068,
0.26288142800331116,
0.788633406162262,
-0.8582713603973389,
-0.5812243223190308,
0.27296414971351624,
-0.5680031180381775,
0.057070400565862656,
0.2086486518383026,
-0.3991253077983856,
0.14850732684135437,
0.6165320873260498,
-0.3944966793060303,
-0.16927188634872437,
0.6182748079299927,
-0.03806261345744133,
0.5091339349746704,
0.08633539825677872,
0.1762617528438568,
-1.3358945846557617,
0.3044208288192749,
-0.07152745127677917,
-0.5552199482917786,
-0.41190215945243835,
0.15505068004131317,
0.24875317513942719,
-0.17891693115234375,
-0.7575345039367676,
0.7417877316474915,
-0.638731062412262,
0.0908302292227745,
0.016343357041478157,
0.24449865520000458,
-0.18921466171741486,
0.2306499183177948,
0.1320081502199173,
0.674180269241333,
1.0395904779434204,
-0.6720420122146606,
0.966923713684082,
-0.11441489309072495,
-0.43371012806892395,
0.7278572916984558,
-0.06725409626960754,
-0.23631002008914948,
-0.21168838441371918,
0.27683225274086,
-0.7270291447639465,
-0.3295535445213318,
0.16256925463676453,
-0.444692462682724,
0.0604088194668293,
-0.019498366862535477,
-0.3810420036315918,
-0.5082545876502991,
-0.20210236310958862,
0.20461168885231018,
0.07432588189840317,
-0.7619746327400208,
0.5187056660652161,
1.038540005683899,
-0.30072155594825745,
-0.7713411450386047,
-0.796760618686676,
0.5589960217475891,
-0.20385675132274628,
-0.4637567400932312,
0.5256783962249756,
-0.12759239971637726,
-0.029609380289912224,
0.43235182762145996,
0.22992435097694397,
-0.48558923602104187,
0.017612040042877197,
0.053460199385881424,
0.08805947005748749,
-0.18719832599163055,
0.31175655126571655,
0.024334553629159927,
-0.3095756471157074,
-0.29498955607414246,
-0.49023890495300293,
0.32441920042037964,
-0.19677165150642395,
0.3384789526462555,
-0.20277099311351776,
0.5985979437828064,
0.425338476896286,
-0.3788406252861023,
0.7314180731773376,
0.6317433714866638,
-0.9630261063575745,
-0.25576359033584595,
-0.6010940074920654,
0.376834899187088,
-0.414290189743042,
0.2851574420928955,
-0.6497146487236023,
-0.8255704641342163,
0.7397435903549194,
-0.16582368314266205,
-0.011336485855281353,
0.6591918468475342,
0.6623700857162476,
-0.022784186527132988,
0.17720405757427216,
0.6370190382003784,
-0.20874005556106567,
0.182936429977417,
-0.23309645056724548,
0.30386102199554443,
-0.6011087894439697,
-0.3258035480976105,
-0.8584933280944824,
-0.2792600691318512,
-0.909214973449707,
-0.5962755084037781,
-0.12242428958415985,
0.14075270295143127,
0.4003903269767761,
0.9851884841918945,
-0.5823215842247009,
0.7276257872581482,
0.5274763107299805,
-0.24335087835788727,
0.5215369462966919,
0.034100670367479324,
-0.015326066873967648,
-0.10920394212007523,
-0.3669295012950897,
-0.5726105570793152,
0.9817609786987305,
-0.02413780242204666,
0.6323977112770081,
0.30689695477485657,
0.7710003852844238,
-0.05230922996997833,
0.5937865972518921,
-0.93679279088974,
0.5735898613929749,
-0.33195021748542786,
-0.6810874342918396,
-0.4450533092021942,
-0.5148199796676636,
-1.189906120300293,
0.19917377829551697,
-0.17843760550022125,
-0.6591942310333252,
0.10901563614606857,
-0.15063749253749847,
-0.3295506536960602,
0.3860703110694885,
-0.48343825340270996,
0.7821128964424133,
-0.02556927315890789,
0.06959809362888336,
-0.3817184567451477,
-0.03504675626754761,
0.197043314576149,
-0.17225877940654755,
0.19837206602096558,
-0.424606055021286,
-0.450987845659256,
0.7702652215957642,
-0.12591125071048737,
0.20101314783096313,
0.24797777831554413,
-0.0014090100303292274,
0.35462358593940735,
-0.040982428938150406,
0.11213957518339157,
0.4639485776424408,
-0.15512850880622864,
0.6526070237159729,
0.026648567989468575,
-0.36936601996421814,
-0.14855539798736572,
1.2378920316696167,
-0.42772042751312256,
-0.31790435314178467,
-0.28235578536987305,
-0.4382787048816681,
-0.23453344404697418,
0.4808492064476013,
0.4913126230239868,
0.2929610013961792,
-0.5590264797210693,
0.28284141421318054,
0.6162309050559998,
-0.15657392144203186,
0.35946130752563477,
0.8060048222541809,
-0.3273150622844696,
-0.33152467012405396,
1.2276418209075928,
0.5351419448852539,
-0.4157147705554962,
0.5543083548545837,
-0.1185140460729599,
0.07820277661085129,
-0.4201739728450775,
-0.7074917554855347,
0.2621159553527832,
-0.3815058171749115,
-0.5649468302726746,
-0.6675038933753967,
-0.09786812216043472,
-0.4814468026161194,
0.08526752144098282,
-0.5213775038719177,
-0.5855138301849365,
0.027092743664979935,
-0.11721277981996536,
0.243124321103096,
0.635116457939148,
-0.13458377122879028,
0.0036687548272311687,
-0.7583142518997192,
0.47481492161750793,
0.17304693162441254,
0.7247300148010254,
-0.30141744017601013,
0.034095700830221176,
-0.42857590317726135,
-0.2607612907886505,
-0.11088337004184723,
-1.1887574195861816,
0.16418027877807617,
0.1796484738588333,
0.6129910945892334,
0.3760615289211273,
-0.23462557792663574,
0.7760889530181885,
-0.8399046659469604,
0.36410805583000183,
0.11377213895320892,
-0.7194543480873108,
0.4633497893810272,
-0.2878769040107727,
0.02996736764907837,
0.4566519260406494,
0.8293957710266113,
-0.9861347675323486,
-0.5819383263587952,
-0.6112983226776123,
-0.6187577247619629,
0.9272804856300354,
0.21652096509933472,
0.14971190690994263,
-0.29206544160842896,
0.2048110067844391,
0.23732513189315796,
0.027978185564279556,
-0.2655787467956543,
-0.4017248749732971,
0.4297208786010742,
-0.027150940150022507,
-0.11384253203868866,
-0.20881497859954834,
-0.10446541011333466,
-0.25357258319854736,
0.8392260074615479,
0.11666028946638107,
0.08644463121891022,
0.00056042819051072,
-0.29094991087913513,
-0.06228598207235336,
0.1323728859424591,
0.4783819019794464,
0.4736213982105255,
0.30200234055519104,
0.10204998403787613,
0.37434661388397217,
-0.5619237422943115,
-0.24940825998783112,
0.41660821437835693,
-0.018755804747343063,
0.5362871289253235,
-0.02765294350683689,
0.7749232053756714,
0.42776021361351013,
-0.7732950448989868,
0.1104777529835701,
-0.13394032418727875,
0.19129735231399536,
-0.5417230129241943,
-0.13420458137989044,
0.5100563764572144,
-0.13231608271598816,
0.26628023386001587,
0.03333281725645065,
0.30782416462898254,
-0.2922205924987793,
0.20223526656627655,
0.0938059538602829,
-0.04008646309375763,
-0.22518208622932434,
0.44968917965888977,
0.4483485817909241,
-0.30454695224761963,
0.443843275308609,
-0.35176771879196167,
-0.0845530554652214,
0.72566157579422,
0.05324504151940346,
0.6558966040611267,
-0.7837011814117432,
0.41170188784599304,
0.8487040400505066,
0.38197240233421326,
-0.19561085104942322,
-0.03956817835569382,
-0.21582293510437012,
-0.6976127028465271,
-0.21575643122196198,
-0.9653929471969604,
-0.6442620158195496,
0.1688767522573471,
-0.6356201171875,
0.7853268980979919,
-0.1937846839427948,
-0.31359684467315674,
0.6957950592041016,
-0.16780664026737213,
-0.7959840893745422,
0.08452654629945755,
0.5213490724563599,
1.119734287261963,
-0.5613031387329102,
1.0312731266021729,
1.0537296533584595,
-0.3311212360858917,
-0.7077388167381287,
-0.41083377599716187,
-0.06533759087324142,
-0.34448331594467163,
0.5277803540229797,
-0.0018285192782059312,
-0.13943523168563843,
0.0569743774831295,
-0.010170073248445988,
-1.4123270511627197,
0.8117005228996277,
0.7879152894020081,
-0.5451132655143738,
-0.23799987137317657,
0.44466203451156616,
0.6234273910522461,
-0.1477566510438919,
0.16588318347930908,
0.5546112656593323,
0.678763210773468,
-0.21300844848155975,
-1.1310486793518066,
-0.3648774325847626,
-0.19289347529411316,
-0.04928336292505264,
0.5058636665344238,
-0.4606257975101471,
0.635593831539154,
-0.0623418428003788,
-0.4328634738922119,
-0.06752526760101318,
0.7541325092315674,
-0.22742854058742523,
-0.3345445990562439,
0.4291445016860962,
0.7061945199966431,
1.0876575708389282,
-0.43438640236854553,
0.9514642953872681,
-0.48507970571517944,
0.610612690448761,
1.0602998733520508,
0.114859938621521,
0.7659374475479126,
0.5093594193458557,
-0.22375527024269104,
0.4756445586681366,
0.6398605108261108,
-0.003823245642706752,
0.18404200673103333,
0.03209362179040909,
-0.2389683723449707,
-0.06649678945541382,
-0.3311102092266083,
-0.08445115387439728,
0.6126575469970703,
0.5361999869346619,
-0.11601100862026215,
-0.7966018915176392,
0.37283819913864136,
0.3222632110118866,
-0.1431536078453064,
-0.19318810105323792,
0.3666970133781433,
-0.05940894037485123,
-0.977250874042511,
0.2861071825027466,
0.37462925910949707,
0.6098936796188354,
-0.5822873115539551,
0.31570887565612793,
-0.3260369896888733,
0.21194981038570404,
-0.5015263557434082,
-0.9699180126190186,
0.6688612699508667,
0.3355916440486908,
-0.18059255182743073,
-0.2534344494342804,
0.45155471563339233,
-0.6942822933197021,
-0.6597825884819031,
0.6261683702468872,
0.3100145161151886,
0.40558066964149475,
0.0025264963041990995,
-0.3811420202255249,
-0.1659536212682724,
-0.19666582345962524,
-0.45934391021728516,
0.13491541147232056,
0.42194145917892456,
-0.28622350096702576,
0.5342897176742554,
0.33102524280548096,
0.20709869265556335,
0.3525906801223755,
-0.012913268059492111,
0.5493362545967102,
-0.5739988088607788,
-0.5045242309570312,
-0.4780708849430084,
0.3211532533168793,
-0.09726320952177048,
-0.491992324590683,
0.726706326007843,
0.9276155233383179,
1.2708758115768433,
-0.1269298791885376,
0.5607688426971436,
-0.37029650807380676,
0.48478084802627563,
0.013560797087848186,
0.7202478647232056,
-0.6077815890312195,
-0.3200823962688446,
-0.03647293150424957,
-0.9979338645935059,
-0.3744039535522461,
0.2835715413093567,
0.16322992742061615,
-0.5136404037475586,
0.765395998954773,
0.6801599860191345,
-0.0255929883569479,
0.02531491219997406,
0.44746309518814087,
0.04647137597203255,
0.17285074293613434,
0.5184142589569092,
0.41644155979156494,
-0.5340482592582703,
0.9795102477073669,
-0.6504328846931458,
-0.2461288869380951,
0.04276515543460846,
-0.5815032720565796,
-0.5051038861274719,
-1.0143858194351196,
-0.20058447122573853,
-0.0586451031267643,
-0.23192721605300903,
0.6304793953895569,
0.8090441226959229,
-0.9919394850730896,
-0.4264395833015442,
0.1753215193748474,
0.12924769520759583,
-0.019068272784352303,
-0.11610939353704453,
0.0009173729340545833,
-0.5499085783958435,
-1.4246541261672974,
0.3834819197654724,
0.4173000454902649,
-0.42838945984840393,
-0.31560400128364563,
-0.0305464044213295,
-0.1174357533454895,
-0.1057361587882042,
0.556645929813385,
0.34818822145462036,
-0.5894482135772705,
0.030968692153692245,
0.12410735338926315,
-0.6102263927459717,
-0.0062250918708741665,
0.8861876130104065,
-0.745880663394928,
0.38740864396095276,
0.6166720986366272,
0.5039849877357483,
0.4194367825984955,
-0.4975194036960602,
0.09832211583852768,
-0.44573208689689636,
0.4888887107372284,
0.20588155090808868,
0.7300970554351807,
0.4157916307449341,
-0.3390006124973297,
0.6785115599632263,
0.21302998065948486,
-0.19464494287967682,
-0.6746856570243835,
0.12331342697143555,
-1.0187891721725464,
-0.17599435150623322,
1.0088385343551636,
-0.08170947432518005,
-0.13945536315441132,
-0.00698136119171977,
-0.0494290366768837,
0.19222372770309448,
-0.27029362320899963,
0.5906562805175781,
1.108581781387329,
-0.020610623061656952,
0.1698756217956543,
-0.6172882914543152,
0.6229989528656006,
0.12904375791549683,
-1.0391685962677002,
-0.2614799439907074,
0.36065804958343506,
0.5208907723426819,
0.6028136610984802,
0.8347868919372559,
-0.29425185918807983,
0.42929738759994507,
-0.059427712112665176,
0.2636764943599701,
0.04938641935586929,
-0.6448920965194702,
0.02670128270983696,
0.18051429092884064,
-0.23699058592319489,
-0.07295151799917221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09482v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09482v2
|
Beyond Flesch-Kincaid: Prompt-based Metrics Improve Difficulty Classification of Educational Texts
| 2024-05-15T16:22:16 | 2024-06-06T07:40:58 |
Donya Rooein, Paul Rottger, Anastassia Shaitarova, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Using large language models (LLMs) for educational applications like
dialogue-based teaching is a hot topic. Effective teaching, however, requires
teachers to adapt the difficulty of content and explanations to the education
level of their students. Even the best LLMs today struggle to do this well. If
we want to improve LLMs on this adaptation task, we need to be able to measure
adaptation success reliably. However, current Static metrics for text
difficulty, like the Flesch-Kincaid Reading Ease score, are known to be crude
and brittle. We, therefore, introduce and evaluate a new set of Prompt-based
metrics for text difficulty. Based on a user study, we create Prompt-based
metrics as inputs for LLMs. They leverage LLM's general language understanding
capabilities to capture more abstract and complex features than Static metrics.
Regression experiments show that adding our Prompt-based metrics significantly
improves text difficulty classification over Static metrics alone. Our results
demonstrate the promise of using LLMs to evaluate text adaptation to different
education levels.
|
[
-0.2707759141921997,
-0.7153564095497131,
0.9782862067222595,
0.19638298451900482,
-0.073346346616745,
0.3381485342979431,
-0.5250944495201111,
-0.09263543784618378,
-0.2721899449825287,
0.23324091732501984,
-0.4253874719142914,
-0.8369216918945312,
-0.7227131128311157,
0.4545471966266632,
-0.19746191799640656,
1.2086941003799438,
-0.26200032234191895,
0.13161441683769226,
-0.3951953053474426,
-0.06960595399141312,
-0.7244123220443726,
-0.3480892777442932,
-0.6586063504219055,
0.028397558256983757,
0.7067885994911194,
0.6563239693641663,
0.6033827662467957,
0.3014875650405884,
0.6003900766372681,
0.3235470950603485,
-0.18311455845832825,
0.09277249872684479,
-0.31355035305023193,
0.2313232421875,
-0.40590977668762207,
-0.6202801465988159,
-0.35853311419487,
-0.2572703957557678,
0.6861183643341064,
1.0142309665679932,
-0.06644599884748459,
-0.19754205644130707,
0.4480920433998108,
0.5117645263671875,
-0.4463726580142975,
0.20117567479610443,
-0.24054625630378723,
0.18511956930160522,
0.0066079734824597836,
-0.4150663912296295,
-0.5539573431015015,
-0.6164877414703369,
0.3462299108505249,
-0.7345582246780396,
0.2551686763763428,
0.16239489614963531,
0.3151606321334839,
0.13371098041534424,
-0.6147417426109314,
-0.7371101975440979,
-0.40193989872932434,
0.9877091646194458,
-0.44539129734039307,
0.46231338381767273,
0.1285894364118576,
0.276968389749527,
-0.39150694012641907,
-0.514832079410553,
-0.2706884443759918,
-0.4778640568256378,
0.15498510003089905,
0.062042608857154846,
0.06771722435951233,
0.2366718351840973,
0.22331218421459198,
0.33762842416763306,
-0.3344923257827759,
0.21417640149593353,
-0.13159231841564178,
-0.24549934267997742,
0.3770746886730194,
0.6197078227996826,
0.4759255051612854,
-0.22376316785812378,
-0.3421783149242401,
-0.021363908424973488,
-0.30114877223968506,
0.49503859877586365,
0.1220206469297409,
0.5363105535507202,
-0.14906524121761322,
0.1531517654657364,
0.019836481660604477,
0.6631200313568115,
-0.14912939071655273,
-0.5929656028747559,
0.15522707998752594,
-0.2789406478404999,
0.29904454946517944,
-0.13358207046985626,
0.4314810335636139,
0.32279151678085327,
0.294285386800766,
0.0012437541736289859,
-0.3183756470680237,
-0.2300405353307724,
-0.10135416686534882,
-0.841059148311615,
-0.21805314719676971,
-0.12414167821407318,
-0.4186018109321594,
-0.20346984267234802,
-0.07361949980258942,
-0.8830776214599609,
-0.9143761992454529,
-0.2838648557662964,
0.5573036670684814,
-0.5704265832901001,
0.06980514526367188,
0.22032487392425537,
-0.01847168058156967,
-0.0691043883562088,
0.8917762041091919,
-0.8787490725517273,
0.6200742125511169,
0.7386616468429565,
1.30862557888031,
-0.35088568925857544,
-0.2506169378757477,
-0.6006989479064941,
-0.46393850445747375,
-0.33450865745544434,
0.7751901149749756,
-0.6712004542350769,
-0.57630854845047,
0.16959290206432343,
-0.049435410648584366,
-0.14713843166828156,
-0.21529759466648102,
0.7753766775131226,
0.05777808651328087,
0.39945438504219055,
-0.38947102427482605,
-0.645611584186554,
-0.20726267993450165,
0.3437914550304413,
-0.34726807475090027,
0.9848878383636475,
0.3018384277820587,
-0.5279839038848877,
0.09856721758842468,
-0.46551990509033203,
-0.38594603538513184,
-0.055953461676836014,
0.16823793947696686,
0.12324962764978409,
0.36280930042266846,
0.24542763829231262,
0.5405135750770569,
-0.5227791666984558,
0.2258148044347763,
-0.08757243305444717,
-0.48042094707489014,
0.4022820293903351,
-0.5159264802932739,
0.4193640947341919,
0.19430585205554962,
-0.0784839540719986,
0.1074938252568245,
-0.7366329431533813,
-0.1378299444913864,
-0.24606581032276154,
-0.5324259400367737,
-0.40673550963401794,
0.24398092925548553,
-0.24743029475212097,
-0.13217990100383759,
0.15085838735103607,
-0.26324301958084106,
0.2031829059123993,
-0.3754594624042511,
0.07521627098321915,
0.8528974056243896,
0.07510893046855927,
0.5105335116386414,
-0.39364296197891235,
0.8556324243545532,
-0.1500183641910553,
-0.03223813325166702,
-0.4730772376060486,
-0.4764588177204132,
-0.8833363652229309,
-0.27974164485931396,
0.2729600667953491,
0.74235600233078,
-0.7068106532096863,
0.36462903022766113,
-0.2008037269115448,
-0.6064342856407166,
-0.2335006296634674,
0.2698400616645813,
0.32466813921928406,
0.7635491490364075,
0.2691216766834259,
-0.379708856344223,
0.14265504479408264,
-0.2029361128807068,
-0.379214346408844,
-0.2800860106945038,
-0.26135164499282837,
0.45368725061416626,
0.19328103959560394,
0.11561180651187897,
0.6932154893875122,
-0.4560610055923462,
-0.11375647783279419,
-0.2694554924964905,
0.20152437686920166,
0.381717711687088,
0.23492202162742615,
0.5155138969421387,
-0.26671406626701355,
-0.5253341794013977,
-0.20819534361362457,
-0.5406261682510376,
-0.48907697200775146,
-0.2967286705970764,
0.07845091074705124,
0.09086384624242783,
0.3917079269886017,
-0.30429938435554504,
0.0519530363380909,
0.08121449500322342,
-0.7604914307594299,
0.7335145473480225,
-0.17417563498020172,
0.5202919244766235,
-0.713409960269928,
-0.3096258342266083,
0.25319355726242065,
-0.2353305220603943,
-0.6082481741905212,
-0.12119095772504807,
0.0016879645409062505,
-0.2970266342163086,
-0.49720895290374756,
0.6308200359344482,
-0.298138827085495,
0.04747845232486725,
-0.031921178102493286,
0.45078131556510925,
0.18633678555488586,
0.30185994505882263,
-0.1221415102481842,
1.0201170444488525,
0.5504928231239319,
-0.6739414930343628,
0.41935548186302185,
0.2213311642408371,
-0.39141082763671875,
0.9757741689682007,
-0.4140418469905853,
-0.02987580932676792,
-0.1780124008655548,
0.38225191831588745,
-1.0894320011138916,
-0.06997714191675186,
0.24907748401165009,
-0.29079267382621765,
0.17748050391674042,
0.04937563091516495,
-0.10252748429775238,
-0.1892254799604416,
-0.5757837891578674,
0.17617841064929962,
0.6523977518081665,
-0.7324825525283813,
0.556670069694519,
-0.263831228017807,
-0.7272962927818298,
-0.4198050796985626,
-0.32690781354904175,
0.31708604097366333,
-0.23869234323501587,
-0.4031746983528137,
0.18680550158023834,
-0.4626956880092621,
-0.27751824259757996,
-0.27316349744796753,
-0.07576047629117966,
-0.2258433848619461,
0.33641090989112854,
0.07914814352989197,
0.21177208423614502,
-0.41243231296539307,
0.5246380567550659,
0.21684904396533966,
-0.08610847592353821,
0.142300546169281,
-0.05239340662956238,
0.20239116251468658,
-0.22453686594963074,
-0.12393712997436523,
-0.5073537230491638,
0.10854127258062363,
0.5872224569320679,
0.043421778827905655,
0.602108359336853,
0.4747479259967804,
-0.18720251321792603,
-0.46714773774147034,
-0.15776289999485016,
-0.2544002830982208,
-0.5243008136749268,
0.5579102039337158,
-0.41466355323791504,
-0.9065170884132385,
0.39349111914634705,
-0.27897894382476807,
0.14668141305446625,
0.13251270353794098,
0.1683131754398346,
-0.09477847069501877,
0.9375731945037842,
0.4076214134693146,
0.12871325016021729,
0.49798715114593506,
0.26088768243789673,
0.11866749078035355,
-0.522454023361206,
-0.2842881679534912,
-0.770067036151886,
-0.3006599247455597,
-0.33606278896331787,
-0.43209174275398254,
0.2096966654062271,
0.2351042479276657,
-0.2570531666278839,
-0.17848415672779083,
-0.35080209374427795,
0.4083564877510071,
0.17846240103244781,
0.1926787793636322,
0.301928848028183,
0.04642680659890175,
0.10276032984256744,
-0.4113130271434784,
-0.5674489140510559,
-0.6753590703010559,
0.924437940120697,
0.6684149503707886,
0.88541579246521,
0.23590126633644104,
0.507478654384613,
0.4684666395187378,
0.4231297969818115,
-1.1333986520767212,
0.766255259513855,
-0.3375396430492401,
-0.23229840397834778,
-0.29775404930114746,
-0.6087188720703125,
-0.703740656375885,
0.1749081015586853,
-0.2710036039352417,
-0.6618565917015076,
-0.000056216427765320987,
0.0554514154791832,
-0.3734843134880066,
0.24114763736724854,
-0.7698202729225159,
0.6790147423744202,
-0.4286952316761017,
-0.2622661292552948,
0.08702193200588226,
-0.29324793815612793,
0.07635336369276047,
-0.23263639211654663,
0.5877473950386047,
-0.2954540252685547,
-0.6028250455856323,
1.006790041923523,
-0.5453807711601257,
0.9013877511024475,
-0.38402998447418213,
-0.2581770122051239,
0.5113459229469299,
0.2184804528951645,
0.41506698727607727,
-0.023848725482821465,
-0.19316253066062927,
-0.11151695251464844,
-0.11526487022638321,
-0.28378021717071533,
-0.9560871720314026,
0.768738329410553,
-0.6437579393386841,
-0.7363573908805847,
-0.44184014201164246,
-0.6594344973564148,
-0.4315733015537262,
-0.09692279994487762,
0.014455819502472878,
0.7539353966712952,
-0.12626677751541138,
0.19973132014274597,
0.6741127967834473,
-0.45676735043525696,
0.42082634568214417,
0.6497754454612732,
-0.22916311025619507,
-0.3733833432197571,
1.1962331533432007,
0.1811555027961731,
0.22456572949886322,
0.21736615896224976,
0.43769314885139465,
-0.5275253653526306,
-0.7870997190475464,
-0.4047837555408478,
-0.09570474177598953,
-0.9232661724090576,
-0.27380287647247314,
-0.5013124346733093,
0.03294815123081207,
-0.10047891736030579,
-0.609812319278717,
0.09186159074306488,
-0.4161163568496704,
-0.8044216632843018,
-0.1660267561674118,
0.71596759557724,
0.7006216645240784,
0.11855710297822952,
0.6353015899658203,
-0.8421676754951477,
-0.009996711276471615,
0.33040809631347656,
0.4537547528743744,
-0.07444892823696136,
-1.165558934211731,
0.08406917005777359,
-0.40871647000312805,
-0.1587716042995453,
-0.9367047548294067,
0.13557858765125275,
0.5573899745941162,
0.15452437102794647,
0.17792858183383942,
0.17566385865211487,
0.3440845310688019,
-0.4543284475803375,
0.9949367046356201,
0.3476722240447998,
-1.2438586950302124,
0.35669010877609253,
-0.25779613852500916,
0.06732406467199326,
0.6317673921585083,
0.405404269695282,
-0.6745710968971252,
-0.27242058515548706,
-0.11381851136684418,
-0.521885097026825,
0.7905309796333313,
-0.22817453742027283,
0.578991174697876,
0.14929403364658356,
0.44646817445755005,
0.41078853607177734,
0.05466671288013458,
-0.5148528218269348,
0.06760561466217041,
-0.15606281161308289,
-0.916461169719696,
-0.347194641828537,
-0.3924383223056793,
0.35332995653152466,
-0.3261946439743042,
0.3664499521255493,
-0.17475934326648712,
-0.18063464760780334,
0.1434052288532257,
-0.38965174555778503,
0.11902967095375061,
0.6809820532798767,
0.3292728066444397,
0.46188676357269287,
-0.0321323461830616,
0.34144413471221924,
0.6697475910186768,
-0.6112408638000488,
0.5074796080589294,
-0.0363219752907753,
-0.022913796827197075,
0.07963361591100693,
0.7633647322654724,
0.8457508683204651,
0.6438777446746826,
-0.756040632724762,
0.668594241142273,
-0.08899171650409698,
-0.14214706420898438,
0.07320459187030792,
0.6161527037620544,
-0.2770567238330841,
0.12175700813531876,
0.32990482449531555,
-0.2183525264263153,
0.17807766795158386,
-0.35390356183052063,
0.0874369889497757,
-0.014670155942440033,
-0.6097539663314819,
-0.3432392477989197,
0.21580840647220612,
0.704533040523529,
-0.7658910155296326,
0.19921454787254333,
-0.10154914110898972,
-0.480046808719635,
0.5665267705917358,
0.7283477783203125,
0.6916070580482483,
-0.5169511437416077,
0.49237728118896484,
0.40168216824531555,
0.23139894008636475,
-0.20135222375392914,
0.3018600642681122,
-0.11981035768985748,
-0.4005899429321289,
-0.13248638808727264,
-0.7137648463249207,
-0.7607226371765137,
-0.17502401769161224,
-0.4157509207725525,
0.38666942715644836,
-0.9058920741081238,
-0.052222512662410736,
-0.11064258962869644,
0.13041093945503235,
-0.5931986570358276,
0.3037007749080658,
-0.025656940415501595,
1.069143533706665,
-1.043093204498291,
0.08364862948656082,
0.7662844657897949,
-0.13455228507518768,
-0.5691812634468079,
-0.06203504279255867,
0.032495077699422836,
-0.4594042897224426,
0.1212415024638176,
0.35829460620880127,
-0.12410387396812439,
0.30512505769729614,
-0.4144475758075714,
-0.5465945601463318,
0.8656710982322693,
0.3170638680458069,
-0.91750168800354,
0.07922815531492233,
-0.04255049303174019,
0.5943297743797302,
-0.40393784642219543,
0.5586292147636414,
0.567798376083374,
0.5270593166351318,
-0.18700720369815826,
-0.6213621497154236,
0.06655410677194595,
0.027322394773364067,
-0.15055686235427856,
0.2339421659708023,
-0.3127433657646179,
0.7703079581260681,
-0.26329243183135986,
-0.22583037614822388,
0.128262460231781,
0.6992612481117249,
0.025152917951345444,
0.6781138181686401,
0.7363577485084534,
0.13526858389377594,
1.0746623277664185,
-0.19802901148796082,
0.8642451167106628,
0.08747665584087372,
0.2643243670463562,
0.8471953272819519,
-0.06168154254555702,
0.7749823927879333,
0.2410399168729782,
-0.48331791162490845,
0.8626717925071716,
0.5762628316879272,
0.16622373461723328,
0.14620915055274963,
0.3154233694076538,
-0.5682036876678467,
-0.24501189589500427,
-0.448987752199173,
-0.3097259998321533,
0.1746450811624527,
0.5296175479888916,
-0.14196434617042542,
-0.27582332491874695,
0.3441726863384247,
0.1732618510723114,
0.510650634765625,
-0.4710797965526581,
0.6715837717056274,
0.2201034277677536,
-0.5103998780250549,
0.6207084655761719,
0.015012627467513084,
0.7574428915977478,
-0.5426358580589294,
0.09558723866939545,
-0.3464262783527374,
-0.18342368304729462,
-0.1765137016773224,
-1.108665108680725,
-0.1919095665216446,
0.45341065526008606,
-0.14119163155555725,
0.017519865185022354,
0.6619055271148682,
-0.4372149109840393,
-0.6162840127944946,
0.1942550390958786,
0.4676109254360199,
0.3594593405723572,
0.19611571729183197,
-0.595645546913147,
0.272805780172348,
-0.09425466507673264,
-0.3256704807281494,
0.07373582571744919,
0.7076594233512878,
0.04165351763367653,
0.5717910528182983,
0.5486764907836914,
-0.10059108585119247,
-0.1867256760597229,
0.21838395297527313,
0.5475754737854004,
-0.9742410182952881,
-0.5678785443305969,
-0.7039833068847656,
0.46532535552978516,
0.1064026951789856,
-0.5966759920120239,
0.5543396472930908,
0.020229507237672806,
0.25967517495155334,
0.04878069460391998,
0.7339934706687927,
0.25269821286201477,
0.5967368483543396,
-0.5917289853096008,
0.4829008877277374,
-0.6743587851524353,
0.3058837652206421,
-0.39426353573799133,
-1.0259172916412354,
-0.31956958770751953,
0.4097680449485779,
-0.3200474679470062,
0.09332232922315598,
0.8887175917625427,
0.5936048626899719,
0.09894945472478867,
-0.016936862841248512,
0.26216062903404236,
0.10813888907432556,
0.3508543372154236,
0.8061344027519226,
1.0120794773101807,
-0.11587151885032654,
0.684751033782959,
0.017400499433279037,
-0.5491010546684265,
-0.31075918674468994,
-0.7608228325843811,
-1.1030821800231934,
-0.4215562641620636,
-0.3253319263458252,
-0.23321424424648285,
0.1841484159231186,
0.8661624789237976,
0.11094570904970169,
-0.7351906299591064,
0.04054655879735947,
-0.18110638856887817,
0.3456859290599823,
0.22258812189102173,
-0.22054751217365265,
0.31885606050491333,
-0.7885732054710388,
-0.7369750738143921,
0.4166003167629242,
0.12666544318199158,
0.2077653557062149,
-0.07455041259527206,
-0.3154776990413666,
0.3875623047351837,
0.4246346652507782,
0.6019155383110046,
0.138689786195755,
-0.6056749224662781,
-0.663314163684845,
0.026569314301013947,
-0.269056499004364,
-0.10818816721439362,
0.7135857343673706,
-0.6026749014854431,
0.6248924136161804,
0.5543879866600037,
0.823367178440094,
-0.27895575761795044,
0.1214546486735344,
0.3161393404006958,
-0.6051278710365295,
0.089479461312294,
0.21718350052833557,
0.1870705634355545,
0.6024920344352722,
-0.20497557520866394,
0.228265643119812,
0.35602036118507385,
-0.40335771441459656,
-0.9898418188095093,
0.007258931174874306,
-0.6724692583084106,
-0.2386198192834854,
1.1132696866989136,
-0.321917325258255,
-0.21714402735233307,
-0.2813107967376709,
-0.557797372341156,
-0.020511003211140633,
-0.4917163848876953,
0.6541723012924194,
0.9384569525718689,
0.17127984762191772,
-0.23406152427196503,
-0.41920939087867737,
0.41563454270362854,
0.7907621264457703,
-0.9000789523124695,
0.08508037030696869,
0.6762181520462036,
0.27947771549224854,
-0.08666259795427322,
0.5195859670639038,
0.22903214395046234,
0.2788713276386261,
-0.07193733751773834,
-0.2137017846107483,
0.012947394512593746,
-0.6546180844306946,
-0.5683404803276062,
0.18573391437530518,
0.41924580931663513,
0.11796269565820694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09454v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09454v1
|
Tell Me Why: Explainable Public Health Fact-Checking with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-15T15:49:06 | 2024-05-15T15:49:06 |
Majid Zarharan, Pascal Wullschleger, Babak Behkam Kia, Mohammad Taher Pilehvar, Jennifer Foster
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of explainable fact-checking
through a series of experiments, focusing on the ability of large language
models to verify public health claims and provide explanations or
justifications for their veracity assessments. We examine the effectiveness of
zero/few-shot prompting and parameter-efficient fine-tuning across various open
and closed-source models, examining their performance in both isolated and
joint tasks of veracity prediction and explanation generation. Importantly, we
employ a dual evaluation approach comprising previously established automatic
metrics and a novel set of criteria through human evaluation. Our automatic
evaluation indicates that, within the zero-shot scenario, GPT-4 emerges as the
standout performer, but in few-shot and parameter-efficient fine-tuning
contexts, open-source models demonstrate their capacity to not only bridge the
performance gap but, in some instances, surpass GPT-4. Human evaluation reveals
yet more nuance as well as indicating potential problems with the gold
explanations.
|
[
-0.11854419857263565,
-0.8088374733924866,
1.1000871658325195,
-0.28370824456214905,
-0.10582291334867477,
-0.3793199062347412,
-0.247118279337883,
-0.39750295877456665,
-0.2926996350288391,
0.2153911590576172,
-0.44067153334617615,
-0.5682691931724548,
-0.6012561917304993,
0.2550252377986908,
-0.45927807688713074,
1.3130643367767334,
-0.015502969734370708,
-0.06404615193605423,
0.03179939463734627,
-0.0807112604379654,
-0.3444019854068756,
-0.18062736093997955,
-0.4820252060890198,
-0.6270220875740051,
0.8084912300109863,
0.7950032949447632,
1.051148772239685,
0.7042860984802246,
0.24558594822883606,
0.21611109375953674,
0.08581092953681946,
0.005508755799382925,
-0.35434550046920776,
-0.42448553442955017,
-0.5954976081848145,
-0.3929716646671295,
-0.25308355689048767,
0.1790289282798767,
0.3836636543273926,
0.5856937766075134,
-0.03850376233458519,
0.4584773778915405,
-0.16433732211589813,
0.6351037621498108,
-0.5936876535415649,
0.040680814534425735,
-0.4434733986854553,
-0.296234130859375,
0.009237328544259071,
-0.11907266825437546,
-0.14631226658821106,
-0.4854002296924591,
0.39510655403137207,
-0.3973997235298157,
0.44768622517585754,
-0.28491172194480896,
0.968447208404541,
0.26238247752189636,
-0.6190366148948669,
-0.25013720989227295,
-0.8590281009674072,
0.5485466718673706,
-0.8607929348945618,
0.34675487875938416,
0.5481135249137878,
0.3120386004447937,
0.0172492153942585,
-0.5926764011383057,
-0.7205272316932678,
-0.3043229877948761,
-0.15436646342277527,
0.11060062795877457,
-0.5008165836334229,
0.14787018299102783,
0.25321662425994873,
0.3515489101409912,
-1.0312466621398926,
0.011723405681550503,
-0.3544006943702698,
-0.3262045085430145,
0.5125025510787964,
-0.04991500452160835,
0.39392009377479553,
-0.1956782191991806,
-0.12375081330537796,
0.27971404790878296,
-0.7761193513870239,
-0.0004806251381523907,
0.20484398305416107,
0.18175506591796875,
-0.32763755321502686,
0.4844540059566498,
-0.4986376166343689,
0.7221839427947998,
-0.20899856090545654,
-0.2628323435783386,
-0.15597476065158844,
-0.5295760035514832,
-0.38225093483924866,
0.09864621609449387,
0.5306782722473145,
0.5056243538856506,
-0.10452555865049362,
-0.17674620449543,
0.10598821192979813,
0.1504177749156952,
-0.03861822187900543,
-1.0805680751800537,
-0.3803355097770691,
0.5865176320075989,
-0.5684999227523804,
-0.3207148015499115,
0.03359009325504303,
-0.7194700241088867,
-0.37999632954597473,
-0.26699167490005493,
0.7686091661453247,
-0.27796417474746704,
-0.3213423490524292,
0.570747971534729,
-0.1156686469912529,
-0.10441932827234268,
0.34168002009391785,
-0.9328969120979309,
0.075667604804039,
0.7618415355682373,
0.9986803531646729,
0.1778261661529541,
-0.1822482943534851,
-0.5664408802986145,
-0.03644033893942833,
-0.5063988566398621,
0.8863390684127808,
-0.22095917165279388,
0.05172676593065262,
-0.1611558198928833,
0.1004713624715805,
0.1076384037733078,
-0.456866055727005,
0.6385664939880371,
-0.09570521861314774,
0.22539374232292175,
-0.7660708427429199,
-0.16751433908939362,
-0.3653187155723572,
0.24405549466609955,
-0.45751848816871643,
0.5467251539230347,
0.04060523584485054,
-1.002722144126892,
0.6174770593643188,
-0.9139887094497681,
-0.2486090362071991,
0.051656100898981094,
0.07460794597864151,
-0.608344316482544,
0.057914603501558304,
0.2750595808029175,
0.3433028757572174,
-0.4340498149394989,
0.5075578689575195,
-0.388790488243103,
-0.4117535650730133,
0.30381226539611816,
-0.8307074308395386,
0.87494957447052,
0.3600766062736511,
-0.4947613477706909,
0.4262341856956482,
-0.6279472708702087,
-0.20750339329242706,
0.11797535419464111,
-0.34209591150283813,
-0.16202667355537415,
0.04722900316119194,
-0.3726988732814789,
0.0029761712066829205,
0.1332324743270874,
-0.49415212869644165,
-0.21193507313728333,
-0.671073317527771,
0.5532763600349426,
0.37282976508140564,
0.3003298342227936,
-0.09129785746335983,
-0.7500752210617065,
0.3913056254386902,
-0.19381633400917053,
0.4818144142627716,
-0.38010740280151367,
-0.6089332103729248,
-0.30690574645996094,
-0.3503091335296631,
0.3618665337562561,
0.48215365409851074,
-0.518511950969696,
0.210426926612854,
-0.22636732459068298,
-0.46352487802505493,
-0.5307182669639587,
-0.0638195052742958,
0.37524279952049255,
0.7955883145332336,
0.313493937253952,
-0.11854512989521027,
-0.29871904850006104,
-0.9595749378204346,
-0.5101317167282104,
-0.5360097885131836,
-0.08118248730897903,
0.13407959043979645,
0.7429097294807434,
-0.12012367695569992,
0.8549333810806274,
-0.49788469076156616,
0.5105629563331604,
-0.13379138708114624,
0.46359074115753174,
0.24018216133117676,
0.09241416305303574,
0.5245130062103271,
-0.7113421559333801,
-0.16774487495422363,
0.11058387905359268,
-0.6455684900283813,
-0.31884390115737915,
0.02115965262055397,
0.11866175383329391,
-0.24821241199970245,
0.040812574326992035,
-0.6178995370864868,
0.5889345407485962,
0.5787134170532227,
-0.5467419624328613,
1.071725606918335,
-0.5689830183982849,
0.3409119248390198,
-0.6427978873252869,
0.17142200469970703,
0.014632407575845718,
-0.32509392499923706,
-0.7292616963386536,
0.1385161429643631,
0.0397743284702301,
-0.38122183084487915,
-0.3503110706806183,
0.4316581189632416,
-0.2278757095336914,
0.10264254361391068,
-0.2683732509613037,
-0.04818323999643326,
0.2178608626127243,
-0.09016565978527069,
-0.37533921003341675,
0.5206900835037231,
0.6304526925086975,
-0.5446181297302246,
0.36893510818481445,
-0.09772305190563202,
-0.36490902304649353,
0.403940349817276,
-0.8348491787910461,
-0.22806471586227417,
-0.1809939742088318,
0.26616957783699036,
-0.8894322514533997,
-0.706994891166687,
0.25797560811042786,
-0.4250255823135376,
-0.06733013689517975,
-0.3173435926437378,
-0.6508471369743347,
-0.6401635408401489,
-0.21595875918865204,
0.0577167347073555,
0.45269739627838135,
-0.7323684096336365,
0.014376712962985039,
0.21559789776802063,
-0.0371406152844429,
-0.31448879837989807,
-0.6204058527946472,
0.0816904753446579,
-0.35217320919036865,
-0.7132267951965332,
-0.11198035627603531,
-0.2067532241344452,
-0.5063140988349915,
0.0830942913889885,
-0.44805747270584106,
-0.20250408351421356,
0.4440997838973999,
0.2791668474674225,
0.12807109951972961,
-0.32646018266677856,
0.4154300093650818,
0.03602486848831177,
-0.31282612681388855,
0.14726082980632782,
-0.19871284067630768,
-0.031535498797893524,
-0.3684553802013397,
-0.6050849556922913,
-0.7272613048553467,
0.36168181896209717,
0.8000814318656921,
-0.19443191587924957,
0.7134853601455688,
0.47773584723472595,
-0.33658483624458313,
0.13580471277236938,
-0.3170429766178131,
-0.35124513506889343,
-0.34787338972091675,
0.3231574594974518,
-0.09874044358730316,
-0.8261944651603699,
0.2234266698360443,
-0.0953867956995964,
0.09537012875080109,
0.3757806122303009,
0.8241240382194519,
0.26257216930389404,
0.927631139755249,
0.37937459349632263,
0.14047673344612122,
-0.12988734245300293,
0.22589163482189178,
0.4390423595905304,
0.05768508464097977,
0.07821143418550491,
-0.5907241702079773,
0.2802896499633789,
-0.6505080461502075,
-0.5250343680381775,
0.7077277302742004,
0.023915840312838554,
-0.19121357798576355,
-0.024285439401865005,
-0.4480637013912201,
0.6301029920578003,
0.21364223957061768,
0.30728796124458313,
0.5333178639411926,
-0.5270771384239197,
0.005047522485256195,
0.3809832036495209,
-0.6089352965354919,
-0.7326968312263489,
0.9186205863952637,
0.7349281311035156,
0.6385478377342224,
0.3083305358886719,
0.5242176055908203,
0.05853096768260002,
0.40428242087364197,
-0.7896520495414734,
0.1984151303768158,
-0.11597290635108948,
-1.1278728246688843,
-0.5854758024215698,
-0.3365243375301361,
-0.9700421094894409,
0.3244131803512573,
-0.3020487129688263,
-0.6923601627349854,
-0.10619320720434189,
0.5966458320617676,
-0.8220983743667603,
0.1774144470691681,
-0.9827023148536682,
0.8831194043159485,
-0.4007667601108551,
-0.249932199716568,
-0.42146340012550354,
-0.5661596655845642,
0.6532172560691833,
-0.12729962170124054,
0.5144848227500916,
-0.4294590950012207,
0.1709975302219391,
0.365016371011734,
-0.5846422910690308,
0.7417151927947998,
-0.09273837506771088,
-0.14424829185009003,
0.1611897498369217,
-0.07574749737977982,
0.23853345215320587,
0.3354202210903168,
-0.26075515151023865,
0.2664736211299896,
0.15674610435962677,
-0.39678725600242615,
-0.6613485217094421,
0.6188164353370667,
-0.5420553088188171,
-0.7014775276184082,
-0.22184845805168152,
-0.3287275433540344,
-0.15108177065849304,
0.2962081730365753,
0.24956202507019043,
0.6335580348968506,
-0.2230386734008789,
0.04913526028394699,
0.686663806438446,
-0.5701943039894104,
0.06456965953111649,
0.9823293089866638,
-0.1736931949853897,
-0.003453507088124752,
0.9163438081741333,
0.122493214905262,
0.1295188069343567,
0.397250235080719,
0.978766918182373,
-0.16264429688453674,
-0.5687166452407837,
-0.4070812463760376,
0.38976308703422546,
-0.5396429300308228,
0.05247354879975319,
-0.5399870872497559,
0.006209916435182095,
-0.44056689739227295,
0.07565928250551224,
-0.2787497937679291,
-0.17504607141017914,
-0.07926617562770844,
-0.2654057741165161,
0.3752357065677643,
1.122147560119629,
-0.5376677513122559,
0.10378550738096237,
-0.659299373626709,
0.7395744919776917,
0.7335569858551025,
0.5979040265083313,
-0.07469594478607178,
-0.35229697823524475,
-0.3787158131599426,
0.09438557177782059,
-0.2242014855146408,
-1.3505403995513916,
0.09425614029169083,
-0.15330426394939423,
0.5394607782363892,
0.608130931854248,
0.24236364662647247,
0.5446427464485168,
-0.3290415406227112,
0.8385981321334839,
0.07677419483661652,
-0.9577513933181763,
0.6788346171379089,
-0.5004500150680542,
0.34808245301246643,
0.3917900025844574,
0.5220984220504761,
-0.449612557888031,
-0.32202577590942383,
-0.4857282340526581,
-0.6771686673164368,
0.5509001612663269,
0.2519893944263458,
-0.41305011510849,
-0.007149534299969673,
0.32218414545059204,
0.4067229628562927,
-0.21774202585220337,
-0.4631088078022003,
-0.31332677602767944,
-0.29737016558647156,
0.06447220593690872,
0.026424773037433624,
-0.4993268847465515,
-0.44904565811157227,
-0.24246925115585327,
0.7336621284484863,
-0.17188572883605957,
0.053079839795827866,
0.47523218393325806,
0.057931527495384216,
-0.4239082932472229,
0.8067486882209778,
0.8343435525894165,
1.1032131910324097,
-0.2215312272310257,
0.5625981092453003,
0.14727245271205902,
-0.20482946932315826,
0.16102957725524902,
0.16291946172714233,
-0.24056142568588257,
0.26743564009666443,
0.5754150748252869,
0.8370506167411804,
0.2715660631656647,
-0.5030309557914734,
0.6231003999710083,
-0.024263033643364906,
-0.33716824650764465,
0.23627497255802155,
0.006151183508336544,
0.08171143382787704,
0.10687373578548431,
0.21719905734062195,
-0.20464670658111572,
0.25709769129753113,
-0.6736193895339966,
0.2424454391002655,
0.42851418256759644,
-0.18435315787792206,
-0.6263625025749207,
0.7185611128807068,
0.01274088490754366,
0.09700512140989304,
0.13185837864875793,
-0.22489549219608307,
-0.32680755853652954,
0.5009940266609192,
0.38708725571632385,
0.557884931564331,
-0.2985071539878845,
0.6399639844894409,
0.6973467469215393,
0.6203805208206177,
-0.14383722841739655,
0.2945348918437958,
0.07120072841644287,
-0.40034976601600647,
-0.8106328845024109,
-0.34616318345069885,
-0.5366387963294983,
0.7151042819023132,
-0.6067237257957458,
0.15284834802150726,
-0.23804324865341187,
0.001396683044731617,
0.480764776468277,
-0.1489638388156891,
-0.5393312573432922,
0.3088982105255127,
0.07693584263324738,
0.7870614528656006,
-1.4912744760513306,
0.5577025413513184,
0.321749746799469,
-0.40215009450912476,
-1.0041943788528442,
0.54749596118927,
0.471429705619812,
-0.7635100483894348,
0.24431195855140686,
0.2048887014389038,
-0.012884519062936306,
-0.395386666059494,
-0.7936819791793823,
-0.8054782152175903,
0.8166068196296692,
0.8356650471687317,
-0.4753265678882599,
0.09772461652755737,
-0.18039046227931976,
0.4336208403110504,
0.13736730813980103,
0.4029027819633484,
0.8029900193214417,
0.9249422550201416,
-0.02151058055460453,
-1.1502667665481567,
0.14853942394256592,
0.27781620621681213,
-0.2107073813676834,
-0.1393440067768097,
-0.4286567270755768,
0.565769612789154,
-0.7147965431213379,
-0.3221711814403534,
-0.02242552861571312,
0.4056313931941986,
0.22829391062259674,
0.6592933535575867,
0.4074096977710724,
0.38016074895858765,
0.9886065721511841,
0.0682745948433876,
1.3040701150894165,
-0.05772925913333893,
0.42661601305007935,
1.2211990356445312,
-0.06522402167320251,
0.5064218044281006,
0.038611818104982376,
-0.2814446687698364,
0.55550217628479,
0.6319707632064819,
0.21958765387535095,
0.4179977774620056,
0.054092515259981155,
-0.3055669069290161,
-0.18462583422660828,
-0.14884144067764282,
-0.18341179192066193,
0.6121867895126343,
0.24192240834236145,
-0.2514296770095825,
-0.6828617453575134,
-0.08939095586538315,
0.08667664229869843,
-0.19065165519714355,
-0.21345144510269165,
0.6841435432434082,
-0.16845658421516418,
-0.7481171488761902,
0.6408994197845459,
0.06636033952236176,
0.0703471302986145,
-0.5291090607643127,
-0.23712091147899628,
0.1193365752696991,
-0.19134758412837982,
-0.4854927062988281,
-0.8689694404602051,
0.43176397681236267,
0.14117352664470673,
-0.47799450159072876,
-0.015066425316035748,
0.7225911617279053,
-0.44664543867111206,
-0.03104349598288536,
-0.018448885530233383,
0.42267313599586487,
0.5340368747711182,
-0.2803839147090912,
-0.783548891544342,
-0.02352309040725231,
-0.04851924628019333,
-0.06712550669908524,
0.15597476065158844,
0.7023383975028992,
-0.15576119720935822,
0.46432825922966003,
0.8453987836837769,
0.35153254866600037,
-0.4040766954421997,
0.14841949939727783,
0.3935445249080658,
-0.44049257040023804,
-0.4532999098300934,
-1.2002184391021729,
0.4714856445789337,
0.30334511399269104,
-0.051801878958940506,
0.8323395848274231,
0.49040254950523376,
0.2056453973054886,
0.0008054415229707956,
1.086364984512329,
0.150277778506279,
0.7985403537750244,
-0.4056938886642456,
0.9591701626777649,
-0.33226531744003296,
0.06735719740390778,
-0.043191827833652496,
-0.21628601849079132,
-0.24381810426712036,
0.4192489981651306,
-0.48467114567756653,
-0.18864457309246063,
0.822939395904541,
0.7968903183937073,
0.02155262976884842,
-0.056149207055568695,
0.7110615372657776,
0.6541547775268555,
0.4062921702861786,
0.2671305239200592,
0.697655439376831,
0.04036574438214302,
0.4209025502204895,
-0.16746218502521515,
-0.6875113248825073,
-0.380673348903656,
-1.2058157920837402,
-0.6915459036827087,
-0.4905276298522949,
-0.536534309387207,
-0.5182453989982605,
0.12596045434474945,
0.6335089206695557,
1.011863112449646,
-0.8698563575744629,
0.35775265097618103,
0.028616582974791527,
0.5326065421104431,
-0.2158203125,
-0.20156915485858917,
0.3472599387168884,
0.08678122609853745,
-0.2546154856681824,
0.47694867849349976,
0.5895729660987854,
-0.029947808012366295,
-0.26998651027679443,
0.0716564729809761,
0.07539620250463486,
0.3196781575679779,
0.439967542886734,
0.7031130790710449,
-1.034355878829956,
-0.3210591673851013,
-0.6321881413459778,
0.055943164974451065,
-0.12895464897155762,
0.8235591650009155,
-0.6006566286087036,
0.8142848610877991,
0.45161327719688416,
0.3469904661178589,
0.170773446559906,
0.09436575323343277,
0.5250687599182129,
-0.38237276673316956,
-0.11958234012126923,
-0.08680138736963272,
0.28183215856552124,
0.5013346672058105,
-0.4910258948802948,
0.39182883501052856,
0.14332756400108337,
-0.7576522827148438,
-0.8115110397338867,
0.2248680144548416,
-0.6494430899620056,
-0.4066651463508606,
1.1229519844055176,
-0.20980732142925262,
-0.34308427572250366,
-0.7062419652938843,
-0.09380348771810532,
0.4352404475212097,
-0.33538001775741577,
0.8837913870811462,
0.6552480459213257,
-0.32293158769607544,
0.022864606231451035,
-0.9682590365409851,
0.5605427622795105,
0.07621581852436066,
-1.0217376947402954,
0.4203828275203705,
0.4856770634651184,
0.7530577182769775,
-0.032746821641922,
0.836563229560852,
-0.23071317374706268,
0.6917799711227417,
-0.1273118257522583,
-0.09668786823749542,
-0.021251801401376724,
-0.3001880645751953,
-0.6083595156669617,
0.001632647356018424,
0.3128947615623474,
0.007724166847765446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09439v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09439v1
|
Facilitating Opinion Diversity through Hybrid NLP Approaches
| 2024-05-15T15:30:17 | 2024-05-15T15:30:17 |
Michiel van der Meer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Modern democracies face a critical issue of declining citizen participation
in decision-making. Online discussion forums are an important avenue for
enhancing citizen participation. This thesis proposal 1) identifies the
challenges involved in facilitating large-scale online discussions with Natural
Language Processing (NLP), 2) suggests solutions to these challenges by
incorporating hybrid human-AI technologies, and 3) investigates what these
technologies can reveal about individual perspectives in online discussions. We
propose a three-layered hierarchy for representing perspectives that can be
obtained by a mixture of human intelligence and large language models. We
illustrate how these representations can draw insights into the diversity of
perspectives and allow us to investigate interactions in online discussions.
|
[
-1.068565845489502,
-0.6361845135688782,
0.5428288578987122,
0.16894125938415527,
0.019473254680633545,
0.6770989894866943,
-0.20627839863300323,
-0.837664008140564,
0.507792592048645,
0.24989277124404907,
-0.2961486279964447,
-0.27273306250572205,
-0.4014894366264343,
0.19496586918830872,
-0.12960804998874664,
0.9030057191848755,
0.10346857458353043,
0.19724318385124207,
-0.14057810604572296,
-0.20984381437301636,
-0.19000211358070374,
-0.8224294185638428,
-0.6965016722679138,
-0.34207379817962646,
0.3944886326789856,
0.30524110794067383,
0.7350127100944519,
-0.11333656311035156,
0.2370552271604538,
0.4002514183521271,
-0.17955897748470306,
0.3093659579753876,
-0.1757276952266693,
0.06072515249252319,
-0.3118520975112915,
-0.5907878279685974,
-0.20837444067001343,
0.09257712215185165,
0.5953367948532104,
0.8760777711868286,
-0.2566380500793457,
-0.01474226824939251,
0.15761740505695343,
0.651472806930542,
-0.6302850246429443,
-0.13016588985919952,
-0.36626097559928894,
0.30022522807121277,
-0.021564938127994537,
0.05058500915765762,
-0.11095605790615082,
-0.3481089174747467,
0.40294918417930603,
-0.37701499462127686,
-0.026352984830737114,
-0.16844694316387177,
0.238302543759346,
-0.12361881136894226,
-0.6483874917030334,
-0.15679515898227692,
-1.2894847393035889,
0.8106054663658142,
-0.7544034123420715,
0.07931118458509445,
0.49734604358673096,
0.2456037700176239,
0.03857996314764023,
-0.4851287603378296,
-0.9006813764572144,
0.1434127390384674,
0.005915942136198282,
0.34054771065711975,
-0.13410870730876923,
0.10860820859670639,
0.0009959936141967773,
0.4923864006996155,
-0.17306381464004517,
0.1796417385339737,
-0.3855622708797455,
-0.051765911281108856,
0.5942764282226562,
0.16712838411331177,
0.1455221176147461,
-0.49598175287246704,
-0.007675203029066324,
0.10701796412467957,
-0.06703111529350281,
0.05756894871592522,
0.8226873278617859,
0.20258204638957977,
-0.04584065452218056,
0.38714495301246643,
-0.28568387031555176,
0.7494802474975586,
0.09427335113286972,
-0.01606648415327072,
0.3000853657722473,
-0.4276581108570099,
-0.15660899877548218,
-0.389935165643692,
0.5260132551193237,
0.6300049424171448,
-0.2868906259536743,
0.2257070541381836,
0.22774404287338257,
0.1961681842803955,
0.236406147480011,
-0.3382072448730469,
0.07029760628938675,
0.5388200283050537,
-0.7725788950920105,
-0.20018093287944794,
0.5431504845619202,
-1.163157343864441,
-0.7609846591949463,
-0.4314243495464325,
0.025651369243860245,
0.1113680973649025,
-0.655580997467041,
0.16727417707443237,
-0.5154178738594055,
0.2530140280723572,
0.6793097853660583,
-0.7950174808502197,
0.6347086429595947,
0.6519958972930908,
0.6967762112617493,
-0.26978540420532227,
0.13353963196277618,
0.1911057084798813,
0.16174675524234772,
0.013669918291270733,
0.7110869288444519,
-0.6542085409164429,
-0.6174243688583374,
0.17548488080501556,
-0.494977205991745,
0.04575292393565178,
-0.7512028813362122,
0.4887142777442932,
-0.289836049079895,
0.796172559261322,
-0.2443099021911621,
-0.5112302899360657,
-0.20810776948928833,
0.7393614649772644,
-0.7318702340126038,
0.9351401925086975,
-0.09824459999799728,
-1.0085989236831665,
0.1617763638496399,
-0.9681693315505981,
-0.32079216837882996,
0.2193310707807541,
-0.4018172025680542,
-0.07031174749135971,
0.014954058453440666,
0.4477577805519104,
0.10850098729133606,
-0.07518766075372696,
0.13643699884414673,
-0.17287488281726837,
0.019220057874917984,
0.32802045345306396,
-0.18054956197738647,
0.8912551403045654,
0.1813201755285263,
-0.4468686282634735,
0.3106299638748169,
-0.5446460247039795,
-0.1816982626914978,
-0.10933884978294373,
-0.418033242225647,
-0.36542370915412903,
0.3594604730606079,
0.23984050750732422,
0.31854504346847534,
0.12188784033060074,
-0.5727776288986206,
0.09427889436483383,
-0.6067068576812744,
0.675227165222168,
0.6314076781272888,
0.10996793210506439,
0.5285999178886414,
-0.552026629447937,
0.4552566111087799,
0.10348539054393768,
0.3860718905925751,
0.06705447286367416,
-1.0961494445800781,
-0.8933489322662354,
0.1954645812511444,
0.04308607801795006,
0.6302047967910767,
-0.9030534029006958,
0.3985140919685364,
0.19933541119098663,
-0.2719043791294098,
-0.7391548156738281,
0.042347971349954605,
-0.20237979292869568,
0.09125557541847229,
0.2675132751464844,
-0.3499242961406708,
-0.6851060390472412,
-1.0249106884002686,
-0.3309144675731659,
-0.5488421320915222,
-0.2762073278427124,
0.3956587016582489,
0.40537771582603455,
-0.2632642090320587,
1.0974289178848267,
-0.06931769102811813,
-0.19103796780109406,
-0.6308848857879639,
0.5942158699035645,
-0.11740243434906006,
0.2977726459503174,
0.353085994720459,
-1.111230731010437,
-0.3772813081741333,
0.032942190766334534,
-0.4781331419944763,
0.3795813322067261,
-0.22252702713012695,
0.09493345767259598,
0.10621101409196854,
0.13668079674243927,
-0.5025360584259033,
0.260955274105072,
0.5724103450775146,
0.13483469188213348,
0.030914535745978355,
-0.019629331305623055,
0.4621727168560028,
-1.3900760412216187,
-0.12229888886213303,
0.1660415083169937,
-0.28086718916893005,
-0.6755825877189636,
0.2264804095029831,
-0.6591017246246338,
-0.14529672265052795,
-0.4330640137195587,
0.1783180981874466,
-0.23187820613384247,
0.016506996005773544,
-0.28403058648109436,
0.3820272982120514,
-0.2009388655424118,
0.24003246426582336,
0.28867846727371216,
0.2281491756439209,
-0.015119929797947407,
-0.172385573387146,
0.4082750082015991,
0.20834173262119293,
-0.31442081928253174,
0.5266139507293701,
-0.2911571264266968,
0.35295581817626953,
-0.18732966482639313,
0.7175214290618896,
-0.7209166288375854,
-0.4916558265686035,
0.1487731784582138,
-0.43780189752578735,
-0.3056778609752655,
0.0893600583076477,
-0.5006109476089478,
-0.45377063751220703,
-0.7987339496612549,
0.4736832082271576,
0.1856725662946701,
-0.09342322498559952,
0.974638819694519,
1.1449799537658691,
-0.47294092178344727,
-0.33430153131484985,
-0.6256420612335205,
0.45232540369033813,
0.03461160883307457,
-0.6179460287094116,
0.4100683927536011,
-0.07064054906368256,
-0.7657625079154968,
-0.02750546485185623,
0.3550876975059509,
-0.05373271554708481,
-0.040496665984392166,
0.22677813470363617,
0.20048029720783234,
-0.012797106988728046,
-0.15505829453468323,
-0.10589390248060226,
0.013093855232000351,
0.09940274804830551,
-0.30422767996788025,
0.6275970935821533,
-0.29287979006767273,
-0.41441085934638977,
-0.5200933218002319,
1.1095396280288696,
0.4601232707500458,
0.02134857326745987,
0.8403164148330688,
0.30065813660621643,
-0.5235480070114136,
-0.2733198404312134,
-0.6226188540458679,
0.08791565150022507,
-0.4737301468849182,
0.1717238426208496,
0.480344295501709,
-1.3785005807876587,
0.4587143361568451,
-0.11521016061306,
0.5161001682281494,
0.351411908864975,
0.9813156127929688,
-0.3692714273929596,
1.1019597053527832,
0.8146461844444275,
-0.09709364920854568,
0.41643762588500977,
0.048036761581897736,
0.46803367137908936,
-0.3835223913192749,
-0.30007070302963257,
-0.5335428714752197,
-0.621006965637207,
-0.6312313079833984,
-0.6448902487754822,
0.45972979068756104,
-0.26335060596466064,
0.1100226491689682,
-0.11102756857872009,
-0.4491868019104004,
0.44383472204208374,
0.6515853404998779,
0.12679916620254517,
0.348584920167923,
-0.19006280601024628,
0.12894503772258759,
-0.2666448950767517,
-0.47694042325019836,
-0.5616303086280823,
0.613735556602478,
0.2670328617095947,
0.29163941740989685,
0.21991337835788727,
0.5429784059524536,
0.4404415786266327,
0.22415918111801147,
-0.736050546169281,
0.730086088180542,
0.2265598475933075,
-0.9619235992431641,
-0.123359814286232,
-0.4329974353313446,
-0.5945497751235962,
0.44095927476882935,
-0.664355456829071,
-0.7158670425415039,
0.035808999091386795,
0.032122258096933365,
-0.5909512042999268,
0.7527885437011719,
-0.39597463607788086,
0.5689772367477417,
-0.038611702620983124,
0.021062007173895836,
-0.7029966711997986,
-0.9072140455245972,
0.4053562581539154,
0.21596048772335052,
0.4569723904132843,
0.2883125841617584,
0.197719544172287,
0.8073973059654236,
-0.14044147729873657,
1.0087748765945435,
-0.003412133315578103,
0.07185553759336472,
0.39398765563964844,
-0.24381041526794434,
-0.0775335282087326,
0.03892486169934273,
0.012604579329490662,
0.09122662991285324,
-0.2795935869216919,
-0.11983953416347504,
-0.41506636142730713,
0.5902055501937866,
-1.1369858980178833,
-0.8656597137451172,
-0.2735868990421295,
-0.4227242171764374,
-0.5319271087646484,
-0.2370365411043167,
0.019934412091970444,
0.019790224730968475,
-0.25059017539024353,
0.293173611164093,
0.4282277226448059,
-0.34768155217170715,
0.3976708948612213,
-0.1762550324201584,
-0.42957910895347595,
-0.4849846065044403,
0.6105598211288452,
0.08531568199396133,
0.3359093964099884,
0.29136765003204346,
0.2361103743314743,
-0.06687958538532257,
-0.42652276158332825,
-0.21773426234722137,
-0.006949231028556824,
-1.027885913848877,
0.037511736154556274,
-0.6901140809059143,
-0.13145305216312408,
-0.3348865211009979,
-0.23469331860542297,
-0.07053264230489731,
-0.8738420009613037,
-0.19032934308052063,
-0.3230135142803192,
-0.01868344098329544,
1.0534571409225464,
-0.025691397488117218,
0.15345746278762817,
-0.8265615701675415,
0.5151793956756592,
0.7021329998970032,
0.14304596185684204,
0.2793482542037964,
0.02873382717370987,
-0.06839360296726227,
0.02348419278860092,
-0.4884134531021118,
-0.8234673738479614,
0.04466128349304199,
-0.08972065895795822,
0.7198848724365234,
0.3191293776035309,
0.11812509596347809,
0.4570038616657257,
-0.023396102711558342,
1.3813661336898804,
0.13791416585445404,
-0.7801141738891602,
0.7232868671417236,
-0.5435714721679688,
0.07512181997299194,
0.6702820062637329,
0.4596487283706665,
-0.6932094097137451,
-0.8693398833274841,
-0.575885534286499,
-0.9838383197784424,
0.453043133020401,
0.15859216451644897,
0.11246693134307861,
0.09624737501144409,
-0.12028785794973373,
0.16404999792575836,
0.2905223071575165,
-0.9099589586257935,
-0.20983871817588806,
-0.3424675166606903,
-0.025174079462885857,
0.32633888721466064,
0.011288691312074661,
-0.4337402582168579,
-0.33163172006607056,
0.2932959198951721,
0.03676631674170494,
0.0964607521891594,
0.08254070580005646,
0.2427428513765335,
-0.21100324392318726,
0.49494022130966187,
0.5631930828094482,
0.7922784090042114,
0.09258335828781128,
0.2091146558523178,
0.166792094707489,
-0.2391384392976761,
-0.06709561496973038,
-0.15859302878379822,
-0.34474509954452515,
-0.14033913612365723,
0.2470979392528534,
0.43388327956199646,
-0.019759651273489,
-0.312278151512146,
0.3950521647930145,
-0.3783515691757202,
-0.35349491238594055,
-0.26658642292022705,
-0.1610434651374817,
0.46724796295166016,
0.16970093548297882,
0.5209290385246277,
0.3951478898525238,
0.17160561680793762,
-1.0668247938156128,
-0.03639233112335205,
0.44962936639785767,
-0.13259829580783844,
-0.2397724986076355,
0.5692899823188782,
0.8042352795600891,
-0.5139535069465637,
0.3664923310279846,
0.07639245688915253,
-0.684675395488739,
0.42045992612838745,
0.13308005034923553,
0.9038885831832886,
0.013486328534781933,
0.4480043053627014,
0.1791030615568161,
0.31252923607826233,
0.040788862854242325,
0.1394645869731903,
-0.17109067738056183,
-0.8206907510757446,
-0.37707817554473877,
-0.49575674533843994,
-0.8901932835578918,
-0.07714897394180298,
-0.5655573010444641,
-0.06363342702388763,
-0.943200945854187,
-0.612975537776947,
0.12343752384185791,
0.014499654062092304,
-0.3526746332645416,
-0.0786287933588028,
0.5972916483879089,
0.4688626527786255,
-0.8435493111610413,
0.4719013571739197,
0.6451661586761475,
-0.24130140244960785,
-0.3036215603351593,
0.30403006076812744,
0.24538320302963257,
-0.10615246742963791,
0.3522491157054901,
0.1539856344461441,
-0.3912440538406372,
-0.3445374667644501,
-0.7150881290435791,
-0.2913438081741333,
0.5025051236152649,
0.2061704397201538,
-0.20294518768787384,
0.12468406558036804,
0.39590808749198914,
0.5930150151252747,
-0.24425117671489716,
0.19096575677394867,
0.26707449555397034,
0.6374356746673584,
-0.10301653295755386,
-1.0566850900650024,
-0.34986555576324463,
-0.4855337142944336,
-0.11571984738111496,
0.06309405714273453,
-0.5865654349327087,
0.9543290734291077,
0.2100151777267456,
-0.31646060943603516,
-0.21096105873584747,
0.746178925037384,
0.1263689398765564,
0.14722749590873718,
0.7385978102684021,
0.3255971670150757,
0.48952022194862366,
0.10318911820650101,
0.9234799146652222,
-0.09752582013607025,
0.2661224901676178,
0.7345121502876282,
-0.4939926862716675,
1.0155738592147827,
0.5780429244041443,
-0.34546536207199097,
0.7907042503356934,
0.5235385894775391,
0.3250146508216858,
0.024488264694809914,
0.01017533615231514,
-0.5711513757705688,
-0.3915189206600189,
-0.275493323802948,
-0.20070557296276093,
0.2707529664039612,
0.35476893186569214,
0.11069720983505249,
-0.09667951613664627,
0.08736602216959,
-0.3282032608985901,
0.4598381221294403,
-0.42406365275382996,
0.9713588356971741,
0.05785296857357025,
-0.8020060658454895,
-0.21149128675460815,
0.3702719807624817,
0.8494986295700073,
-0.3794011175632477,
-0.2899823486804962,
0.03708929941058159,
0.019995413720607758,
-0.38422703742980957,
-1.004508376121521,
0.31576085090637207,
-0.02802547812461853,
-0.30922427773475647,
-0.48595571517944336,
0.5482997894287109,
-0.17236153781414032,
-0.4935339689254761,
0.36695143580436707,
0.6925438642501831,
-0.30889737606048584,
0.268944650888443,
-0.6410700678825378,
-0.003636479377746582,
-0.05215020477771759,
-0.10935977101325989,
0.5114268660545349,
0.04968157038092613,
-0.32381510734558105,
0.5054247379302979,
0.5919519066810608,
0.14057208597660065,
-0.007572478614747524,
0.3351422846317291,
1.0059033632278442,
-0.5260837078094482,
-0.8126696348190308,
-0.7162787914276123,
0.5231204628944397,
-0.6057003140449524,
-0.39628279209136963,
0.6499917507171631,
0.38708066940307617,
0.96342533826828,
0.16754214465618134,
1.1906746625900269,
-0.22631151974201202,
0.77097487449646,
-0.19928865134716034,
0.558689296245575,
-0.27588221430778503,
0.11270948499441147,
-0.2620519995689392,
-0.6240122318267822,
-0.46240103244781494,
0.8492403030395508,
-0.11889784783124924,
0.014880090951919556,
0.34742268919944763,
0.31139621138572693,
0.14081092178821564,
0.5950472354888916,
-0.014850497245788574,
-0.025850975885987282,
0.4023071229457855,
0.3441857695579529,
1.337899923324585,
0.04410325363278389,
0.2399579882621765,
-0.15071305632591248,
-0.21993961930274963,
-0.06750934571027756,
-0.6176344156265259,
-1.0256352424621582,
-0.5381330847740173,
-0.05610156059265137,
-0.17076009511947632,
-0.5331031084060669,
1.4018778800964355,
0.5548059940338135,
-0.8832017183303833,
-0.5632898807525635,
0.21129123866558075,
0.10448524355888367,
-0.022905796766281128,
-0.2128637135028839,
-0.15419861674308777,
0.28563588857650757,
-0.6706149578094482,
0.2622337341308594,
0.47664445638656616,
-0.24679867923259735,
-0.9081576466560364,
0.2218310534954071,
-0.4216024875640869,
0.12620611488819122,
0.6629594564437866,
0.2885175347328186,
-0.9338001608848572,
-0.2492792308330536,
-0.24423940479755402,
-0.031216105446219444,
0.29638153314590454,
1.201232671737671,
-0.6925206780433655,
0.5597557425498962,
0.5967915058135986,
0.8549191951751709,
0.5128331780433655,
0.24238954484462738,
0.7187508940696716,
-0.5922730565071106,
0.33309081196784973,
0.7774544358253479,
0.1434188187122345,
0.6082510948181152,
-0.03031252510845661,
0.07410633563995361,
0.34140723943710327,
-0.42164281010627747,
-0.46728551387786865,
0.3452536463737488,
-0.9332273006439209,
-0.4790867269039154,
0.7757886052131653,
0.16763156652450562,
0.11444927752017975,
-0.60794597864151,
-0.4008374810218811,
-0.07479164004325867,
-0.3486953377723694,
0.9340040683746338,
0.7845814228057861,
-0.3929736614227295,
-0.2879597842693329,
-0.7068008780479431,
0.3793265223503113,
0.08975417912006378,
-1.2186195850372314,
-0.07945071160793304,
0.4830932021141052,
-0.32779842615127563,
0.5160061120986938,
0.8750147223472595,
-0.05119483545422554,
0.00008740193152334541,
-0.1754658967256546,
-0.34205296635627747,
0.40596792101860046,
-0.17612788081169128,
-0.16614657640457153,
0.6025502681732178,
-0.054880037903785706,
0.32451972365379333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13024v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13024v1
|
Intelligent Tutor: Leveraging ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot Studio to Deliver a Generative AI Student Support and Feedback System within Teams
| 2024-05-15T15:09:41 | 2024-05-15T15:09:41 |
Wei-Yu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
This study explores the integration of the ChatGPT API with GPT-4 model and
Microsoft Copilot Studio on the Microsoft Teams platform to develop an
intelligent tutoring system. Designed to provide instant support to students,
the system dynamically adjusts educational content in response to the learners'
progress and feedback. Utilizing advancements in natural language processing
and machine learning, it interprets student inquiries, offers tailored
feedback, and facilitates the educational journey. Initial implementation
highlights the system's potential in boosting students' motivation and
engagement, while equipping educators with critical insights into the learning
process, thus promoting tailored educational experiences and enhancing
instructional effectiveness.
|
[
-0.3116607367992401,
-0.807109534740448,
0.36595824360847473,
0.19474200904369354,
0.024562161415815353,
1.0928362607955933,
-0.010863660834729671,
-0.26103153824806213,
0.016730722039937973,
-0.018100189045071602,
-0.9252418279647827,
-0.2515786588191986,
-0.2155781388282776,
-0.01673382893204689,
-0.30144771933555603,
1.3433599472045898,
0.10893496870994568,
0.4589744806289673,
-0.313510924577713,
0.13435113430023193,
-0.9155141115188599,
-0.7088858485221863,
-1.1165682077407837,
-0.12888425588607788,
0.24660633504390717,
0.810356855392456,
0.5494167804718018,
-0.025824174284934998,
0.7211263179779053,
0.3452901840209961,
0.2532404065132141,
0.0711115375161171,
-0.14841343462467194,
0.13522131741046906,
-0.176484614610672,
-0.6768691539764404,
-0.6204301118850708,
0.16478700935840607,
0.413839191198349,
0.40491539239883423,
-0.1276683658361435,
-0.015101884491741657,
0.5384746789932251,
0.5625584721565247,
-0.05357843637466431,
0.4664228856563568,
-0.25105994939804077,
0.31954166293144226,
0.0515449196100235,
-0.2704486846923828,
-0.2601749897003174,
-0.5571455955505371,
0.6555083990097046,
-0.8800603747367859,
0.3484492003917694,
-0.07660757750272751,
0.4723089337348938,
0.5853261947631836,
-0.02920350804924965,
-0.5686340928077698,
-0.5897038578987122,
0.6902881860733032,
-0.44522997736930847,
0.0231850016862154,
0.09216759353876114,
0.7308471202850342,
-0.15665118396282196,
-0.5788022875785828,
-0.24765938520431519,
-0.08198894560337067,
0.01880771480500698,
0.7347776293754578,
0.20736674964427948,
0.2931823134422302,
-0.24887339770793915,
0.2645111680030823,
-0.5943597555160522,
0.015226773917675018,
-0.46108686923980713,
-0.17126579582691193,
0.6805405616760254,
0.13625624775886536,
0.5471224784851074,
0.21363888680934906,
-0.3808595538139343,
0.0562722310423851,
-0.40319114923477173,
0.1694929450750351,
0.6365585923194885,
0.31974220275878906,
-0.12643513083457947,
0.44109195470809937,
0.08703695982694626,
0.673653781414032,
-0.005830029491335154,
0.03877094388008118,
0.08331228792667389,
-0.19656245410442352,
-0.033653635531663895,
0.24706386029720306,
0.6480624675750732,
0.24292071163654327,
0.18385107815265656,
-0.2983819842338562,
-0.11284847557544708,
0.12169619649648666,
0.08130519092082977,
-0.5702532529830933,
-0.6254528760910034,
0.20657089352607727,
-0.07159601897001266,
-0.4397585988044739,
0.21488119661808014,
-0.9801945686340332,
-0.5462854504585266,
-0.7881540060043335,
0.22841672599315643,
-0.7212458252906799,
-0.2741170823574066,
-0.19292142987251282,
-0.4056011140346527,
0.26174360513687134,
0.7937403321266174,
-0.8118426203727722,
0.4332338869571686,
0.7049998044967651,
1.0386017560958862,
-0.4458463788032532,
-0.3017844259738922,
-0.5847100019454956,
0.039715010672807693,
-0.09334785491228104,
1.114745855331421,
-0.574782133102417,
-0.5792493224143982,
-0.12797784805297852,
-0.1503494381904602,
-0.38327017426490784,
-0.4142708480358124,
0.33272823691368103,
-0.23954269289970398,
0.6755658388137817,
0.1757008582353592,
-0.8318427801132202,
-0.33252301812171936,
0.3407754600048065,
-0.21396128833293915,
0.9408912062644958,
0.3307928442955017,
-0.348784476518631,
0.0017562407301738858,
-1.3955156803131104,
-0.13785907626152039,
0.5558914542198181,
-0.317789226770401,
-0.3571605086326599,
-0.3583151400089264,
0.12264448404312134,
0.2689095139503479,
0.13240930438041687,
0.49479833245277405,
0.03493316099047661,
-0.4145101010799408,
-0.07396146655082703,
-0.3408051133155823,
0.9879993796348572,
0.024933692067861557,
-0.45981910824775696,
0.6726618409156799,
-0.5727715492248535,
0.08785227686166763,
0.22445325553417206,
-0.44703322649002075,
0.10813591629266739,
0.007823430001735687,
0.10836081951856613,
-0.09768299758434296,
0.22936248779296875,
-0.29801538586616516,
0.7380891442298889,
0.01599738374352455,
0.6750155091285706,
0.740667998790741,
0.018923267722129822,
0.3986903727054596,
-0.21484839916229248,
0.9653806686401367,
-0.20157387852668762,
0.16233347356319427,
-0.1401655524969101,
-0.8838267922401428,
-0.483782559633255,
-0.17418238520622253,
0.260116845369339,
1.0559643507003784,
-0.9416464567184448,
0.1396867334842682,
0.05369717255234718,
-0.3650858700275421,
-0.5864549875259399,
0.30157551169395447,
0.17119547724723816,
0.5022342801094055,
0.2412104606628418,
-0.11580091714859009,
-0.6147381067276001,
-0.5430845618247986,
0.05657490715384483,
-0.1405058652162552,
-0.24831190705299377,
0.10187738388776779,
0.34366127848625183,
-0.05370723828673363,
1.1191085577011108,
-0.3625332713127136,
-0.6161071062088013,
-0.34876197576522827,
-0.004179965239018202,
-0.03615209832787514,
0.7387006282806396,
0.8556117415428162,
-0.8542936444282532,
-0.8786841630935669,
-0.2675114870071411,
-0.5169287919998169,
-0.039328157901763916,
-0.08150474727153778,
-0.20823563635349274,
0.1156785860657692,
0.5792312026023865,
-0.36390674114227295,
0.4617900848388672,
0.5901023149490356,
-0.5172404050827026,
0.7762305736541748,
-0.053487010300159454,
-0.005131931975483894,
-1.0153535604476929,
-0.12524838745594025,
-0.42620134353637695,
-0.276807576417923,
-0.3627425730228424,
-0.3641831874847412,
-0.2692468762397766,
-0.3008171617984772,
-0.21680572628974915,
0.2587868273258209,
-0.27800387144088745,
0.025000624358654022,
-0.22095060348510742,
0.5817777514457703,
0.02136092446744442,
0.811852216720581,
-0.12077976018190384,
1.150816559791565,
0.5549152493476868,
-0.19060124456882477,
0.9271522164344788,
0.3148372769355774,
-0.053518421947956085,
0.9463505744934082,
-0.7746363878250122,
0.28782275319099426,
0.3408926725387573,
0.2980108857154846,
-1.1069965362548828,
-0.26944032311439514,
0.5381156206130981,
-0.7094700932502747,
0.0935029461979866,
-0.39700016379356384,
-0.578781008720398,
-0.5672582387924194,
-0.16504168510437012,
-0.06396716833114624,
0.31044676899909973,
-0.5130627155303955,
0.5320911407470703,
0.26067161560058594,
-0.48089542984962463,
-0.11220546066761017,
-0.27221009135246277,
0.1961839199066162,
-0.012059735134243965,
-0.5364018678665161,
0.24246865510940552,
-0.6494165658950806,
-0.17252522706985474,
0.18547400832176208,
0.2876492738723755,
-0.2160499095916748,
0.26040875911712646,
0.29190537333488464,
0.6845299601554871,
-0.23496459424495697,
0.3551892340183258,
-0.04601729288697243,
-0.0754811242222786,
0.015186592005193233,
-0.45416733622550964,
0.6140751838684082,
-0.5631576776504517,
-0.30054551362991333,
-0.5725531578063965,
0.3804844915866852,
0.572491466999054,
-0.24349290132522583,
0.6074331402778625,
0.6495384573936462,
-0.05605679750442505,
-0.06559759378433228,
-0.1632748544216156,
-0.3245009481906891,
-0.5302897095680237,
0.29260215163230896,
-0.01229653600603342,
-0.8009494543075562,
0.5902534127235413,
-0.06456480175256729,
0.24483394622802734,
0.15891841053962708,
0.4478468596935272,
-0.22445793449878693,
1.3194342851638794,
0.5660607814788818,
-0.1646306812763214,
0.9217314124107361,
-0.5531484484672546,
0.14185455441474915,
-0.7627700567245483,
-0.44278770685195923,
-0.29338952898979187,
-0.4201180338859558,
-0.19856415688991547,
0.13404414057731628,
0.06861895322799683,
0.03507286682724953,
-0.38894888758659363,
-0.008437462151050568,
-1.1463614702224731,
0.628767192363739,
1.1300873756408691,
0.09846864640712738,
0.028129080310463905,
-0.3546713590621948,
-0.3039354979991913,
0.11064121872186661,
-0.9269490838050842,
-0.4869749844074249,
0.8120030760765076,
0.07752709090709686,
0.2006305754184723,
0.3406105935573578,
0.3873934745788574,
0.35633420944213867,
0.647055983543396,
-1.0112735033035278,
0.5568646788597107,
0.19971849024295807,
-0.6356529593467712,
-0.3019287884235382,
-0.024144766852259636,
-0.8123877048492432,
-0.17371320724487305,
-0.1635805368423462,
-0.776330292224884,
-0.3122771680355072,
0.19153395295143127,
-0.7880823612213135,
0.36729857325553894,
-1.3756122589111328,
0.8781912922859192,
-0.4219191372394562,
-0.4980444312095642,
0.05075942352414131,
-0.5699329376220703,
-0.06157340109348297,
0.060416329652071,
-0.0739244893193245,
-0.06597483158111572,
0.12264185398817062,
0.9719789028167725,
-0.7686562538146973,
1.049210786819458,
-0.3894844651222229,
0.17854034900665283,
0.6328339576721191,
-0.0245272945612669,
0.11839957535266876,
0.1043476015329361,
0.00396136287599802,
-0.285550981760025,
0.09951949864625931,
-0.6136233806610107,
-0.765322744846344,
0.5385680794715881,
-0.9365918636322021,
-0.8514384031295776,
-0.30553629994392395,
-0.9300071597099304,
-0.37533697485923767,
0.15860678255558014,
0.03699849173426628,
0.3510276973247528,
0.19032928347587585,
0.07738929241895676,
0.38470208644866943,
0.0015807372983545065,
0.7123826742172241,
0.5566705465316772,
-0.3822545111179352,
-0.3436875641345978,
1.1746255159378052,
0.2523811161518097,
0.023028459399938583,
0.00935964472591877,
0.2686730623245239,
-0.13307230174541473,
-0.5844287276268005,
-0.7793547511100769,
-0.13066719472408295,
-0.5086079835891724,
-0.17889942228794098,
-0.2267506718635559,
-0.32411593198776245,
-0.4928499162197113,
-0.5175256133079529,
-0.33955666422843933,
-0.4577624201774597,
-0.25596269965171814,
-0.17717570066452026,
0.5423052310943604,
1.014475703239441,
0.18230879306793213,
0.652790904045105,
-0.8801982402801514,
-0.3594729006290436,
0.5620765686035156,
0.520582377910614,
-0.0861479863524437,
-0.1121455505490303,
-0.2871456742286682,
-0.032644033432006836,
-0.7805491089820862,
-0.7889155149459839,
0.3180992007255554,
0.27842608094215393,
0.6496192812919617,
0.38868358731269836,
0.06995325535535812,
0.2613477408885956,
-0.39633145928382874,
1.1395601034164429,
0.054865553975105286,
-0.8131663203239441,
0.8866455554962158,
-0.5771284699440002,
0.3214641511440277,
0.3817327320575714,
0.17709365487098694,
-0.20689958333969116,
-0.4861358404159546,
-0.6831808090209961,
-0.5841915011405945,
0.7659137845039368,
-0.033352747559547424,
-0.1550552248954773,
0.4456433355808258,
0.21413829922676086,
0.02615649811923504,
0.21175935864448547,
-0.26369407773017883,
-0.10888153314590454,
-0.46290236711502075,
-0.6185685992240906,
0.03849797323346138,
0.17558501660823822,
-0.1923241913318634,
-0.4274710416793823,
0.7299872636795044,
-0.3988790214061737,
0.4154369831085205,
0.0788123607635498,
0.218224436044693,
0.18081389367580414,
-0.00935734249651432,
0.7656778693199158,
0.5700810551643372,
-0.19429424405097961,
-0.2803274393081665,
0.09103721380233765,
-0.8966582417488098,
-0.10859054327011108,
0.2990293800830841,
0.11407453566789627,
0.0695604681968689,
0.1201743334531784,
0.4682411849498749,
0.22869715094566345,
-0.6562070250511169,
0.4875149428844452,
-0.29358533024787903,
-0.14663824439048767,
-0.5501614809036255,
0.44560375809669495,
0.091038279235363,
0.335976243019104,
0.587875485420227,
0.3214225769042969,
0.06468981504440308,
-0.43715158104896545,
0.08802007883787155,
0.37375348806381226,
-0.5686045289039612,
-0.51479172706604,
0.698865532875061,
0.5254679918289185,
-0.9885790348052979,
0.7210277318954468,
0.03929070383310318,
-1.077458143234253,
0.9898069500923157,
0.3960791826248169,
0.8597550988197327,
-0.42300650477409363,
0.47168755531311035,
0.11393114924430847,
-0.11344750225543976,
0.27008056640625,
0.21877968311309814,
-0.1672445386648178,
-0.37853309512138367,
-0.21834592521190643,
0.05826621502637863,
-1.1876763105392456,
-0.2877655625343323,
-0.44728922843933105,
0.29486608505249023,
-0.5670964121818542,
-0.01995484158396721,
-0.011977779679000378,
0.1272788643836975,
-0.7282891869544983,
0.07164864242076874,
0.05307622253894806,
0.5342192053794861,
-0.32841259241104126,
0.8615290522575378,
1.2258256673812866,
-0.6408078670501709,
-1.0722980499267578,
-0.17836764454841614,
0.43237510323524475,
-0.855617880821228,
0.6297212243080139,
0.19428502023220062,
-0.0673089548945427,
0.38090476393699646,
-0.7041692733764648,
-0.42400291562080383,
1.1092212200164795,
0.22060909867286682,
-0.390483021736145,
-0.09118058532476425,
0.2123298943042755,
0.7680271863937378,
-0.26514360308647156,
0.4115031063556671,
0.1292872577905655,
0.22203795611858368,
0.11901465803384781,
-0.7753979563713074,
-0.5259541869163513,
-0.4894523024559021,
-0.5260303020477295,
-0.16574998199939728,
-0.8735732436180115,
0.5724350810050964,
-0.17894484102725983,
-0.007818834856152534,
0.002484511351212859,
0.41614970564842224,
0.03612986579537392,
0.41357603669166565,
0.3367774188518524,
0.1661738157272339,
1.1232858896255493,
-0.3668922185897827,
0.9019946455955505,
-0.6845916509628296,
0.24857401847839355,
1.3278504610061646,
0.278768926858902,
0.6372716426849365,
0.5871639847755432,
-0.3161638379096985,
0.7090805172920227,
0.7356125116348267,
-0.043075352907180786,
0.2980733811855316,
0.11535751074552536,
-0.5669674873352051,
0.07810460776090622,
-0.10627223551273346,
-0.250057578086853,
0.13872846961021423,
0.49336832761764526,
0.02925613708794117,
0.12250994145870209,
0.2583538591861725,
-0.05398004874587059,
-0.17108342051506042,
-0.42045268416404724,
0.837818443775177,
-0.06237676739692688,
-0.9491884112358093,
0.021485252305865288,
-0.54483962059021,
0.5992869138717651,
-0.4744813144207001,
-0.30508169531822205,
-0.23166219890117645,
0.4036194384098053,
-0.4444924592971802,
-0.906518816947937,
0.1994827389717102,
0.006284760311245918,
-0.0307969618588686,
-0.2674947679042816,
0.45596083998680115,
-0.4760361611843109,
-0.3665379583835602,
0.1115400567650795,
0.5144891738891602,
0.020026883110404015,
0.07438968867063522,
-0.9327881932258606,
-0.299980491399765,
0.15717540681362152,
-0.15304945409297943,
0.14620599150657654,
0.494782418012619,
0.18099436163902283,
0.8969078660011292,
0.6817587614059448,
-0.15254153311252594,
0.15041974186897278,
0.10763787478208542,
0.7452353239059448,
-0.2663639187812805,
-0.5140677094459534,
-0.6969144940376282,
0.6247626543045044,
-0.20450277626514435,
-0.3835219740867615,
0.908517062664032,
0.5909134745597839,
0.6903571486473083,
-0.05809255689382553,
1.0698933601379395,
0.07558310776948929,
0.7475497722625732,
-0.03935471177101135,
0.68324875831604,
-0.21692043542861938,
0.45538124442100525,
-0.3202176094055176,
-0.8084598779678345,
-0.4276885986328125,
0.5179710388183594,
-0.45798367261886597,
-0.17277772724628448,
0.4421960115432739,
0.42037877440452576,
0.17164862155914307,
0.5012661814689636,
0.1011120155453682,
-0.1691478043794632,
0.8352199792861938,
0.40221652388572693,
0.9675164222717285,
-0.19472530484199524,
0.7765937447547913,
-0.3105964660644531,
-0.3126116693019867,
-0.37120577692985535,
-0.48476505279541016,
-0.9284082651138306,
-0.4981614053249359,
-0.6034384965896606,
-0.22287851572036743,
0.3541475832462311,
0.9669122099876404,
0.6287305951118469,
-1.040812611579895,
-0.02521209605038166,
-0.4803455173969269,
0.2017040103673935,
-0.13265816867351532,
-0.47690722346305847,
0.6230457425117493,
-0.6721529960632324,
-1.0651625394821167,
0.2940517067909241,
0.09255389124155045,
0.32920628786087036,
-0.5211957693099976,
-0.2298189252614975,
-0.03510012850165367,
-0.143752321600914,
0.5039743185043335,
0.25727298855781555,
-0.3338414430618286,
-0.3987117409706116,
0.23326504230499268,
-0.075916588306427,
0.21111412346363068,
0.5972079634666443,
-0.9216964840888977,
0.46168047189712524,
0.29789939522743225,
0.8429256677627563,
-0.13522526621818542,
-0.0876445323228836,
0.7834812998771667,
-0.33726099133491516,
0.13819928467273712,
0.49275803565979004,
0.32679465413093567,
0.3540770709514618,
-0.5280863046646118,
0.7956613302230835,
0.5702270865440369,
-0.8884725570678711,
-0.5346824526786804,
-0.3462677597999573,
-0.9385156035423279,
-0.08917117863893509,
0.6056743860244751,
-0.5019367933273315,
0.15365485846996307,
-0.4964243471622467,
-1.0058566331863403,
0.2608226239681244,
-0.547404944896698,
0.8837389945983887,
0.823151707649231,
-0.6636989116668701,
-0.25706884264945984,
-0.829355776309967,
0.46327123045921326,
0.4967053532600403,
-0.8317286372184753,
-0.5140496492385864,
0.3152005672454834,
0.21734283864498138,
0.2561269700527191,
0.3253078758716583,
0.2863042950630188,
0.314753919839859,
-0.0006918772123754025,
-0.045163024216890335,
-0.18224474787712097,
-0.08684325963258743,
0.14668677747249603,
0.17117273807525635,
-0.3469156324863434,
-0.5228703618049622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09395v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09395v2
|
Matching domain experts by training from scratch on domain knowledge
| 2024-05-15T14:50:51 | 2024-07-02T16:42:48 |
Xiaoliang Luo, Guangzhi Sun, Bradley C. Love
|
q-bio.NC
|
q-bio.NC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have outperformed human experts in
predicting the results of neuroscience experiments (Luo et al., 2024). What is
the basis for this performance? One possibility is that statistical patterns in
that specific scientific literature, as opposed to emergent reasoning abilities
arising from broader training, underlie LLMs' performance. To evaluate this
possibility, we trained (next word prediction) a relatively small
124M-parameter GPT-2 model on 1.3 billion tokens of domain-specific knowledge.
Despite being orders of magnitude smaller than larger LLMs trained on trillions
of tokens, small models achieved expert-level performance in predicting
neuroscience results. Small models trained on the neuroscience literature
succeeded when they were trained from scratch using a tokenizer specifically
trained on neuroscience text or when the neuroscience literature was used to
finetune a pretrained GPT-2. Our results indicate that expert-level performance
may be attained by even small LLMs through domain-specific, auto-regressive
training approaches.
|
[
-0.3132076561450958,
-0.43357211351394653,
0.832778811454773,
-0.08676086366176605,
-0.19825737178325653,
0.1166333332657814,
-0.2451208382844925,
-0.6126261949539185,
0.2716558277606964,
0.3375007212162018,
-0.3420424163341522,
-0.16651585698127747,
-0.9244338870048523,
0.12248934060335159,
-0.25228431820869446,
0.7978472709655762,
0.28374210000038147,
0.4279811680316925,
-0.5273147225379944,
0.1452638953924179,
-0.44106021523475647,
-0.5965328216552734,
-0.9235641360282898,
-0.725044846534729,
0.693789541721344,
0.24097681045532227,
0.592622697353363,
0.8409894108772278,
0.346530944108963,
0.20202258229255676,
0.04894671216607094,
0.2618216872215271,
-0.44100451469421387,
-0.25145667791366577,
-0.4007154405117035,
-0.5231460332870483,
-0.4094375967979431,
0.2696686387062073,
0.17852620780467987,
0.8207931518554688,
-0.07073087245225906,
-0.10446324199438095,
0.0530451238155365,
0.43655139207839966,
-0.07283324003219604,
0.05794737860560417,
-1.0770001411437988,
0.04196903854608536,
-0.021237850189208984,
-0.54228276014328,
-0.6013949513435364,
-0.14513608813285828,
0.2901920974254608,
-0.6884036064147949,
0.5366422533988953,
0.43552684783935547,
0.7963065505027771,
0.37936562299728394,
-0.40082523226737976,
-0.09247852861881256,
-0.4577767252922058,
0.6090701222419739,
-0.8306519389152527,
0.1806950569152832,
0.6063989996910095,
0.06743635982275009,
-0.5135475993156433,
-0.7182583808898926,
-0.4472671449184418,
-0.2947516143321991,
-0.12191198766231537,
-0.2400636225938797,
0.05760805681347847,
-0.1025635376572609,
0.4102926552295685,
-0.04903625696897507,
-0.6030123829841614,
0.42194250226020813,
-0.45588111877441406,
-0.18571726977825165,
0.5128230452537537,
0.1359291970729828,
0.20292828977108002,
0.1372334063053131,
-0.44609591364860535,
0.17861349880695343,
-0.8259429931640625,
-0.38648495078086853,
0.06723114103078842,
0.33890193700790405,
0.4922538697719574,
0.5800284147262573,
0.09367262572050095,
0.7152995467185974,
0.24983297288417816,
0.12430431693792343,
0.010727575980126858,
-0.0006941343890503049,
-0.013677303679287434,
-0.042529650032520294,
0.6562896966934204,
0.2292291671037674,
0.7430632710456848,
-0.5617343187332153,
-0.28453728556632996,
-0.22844192385673523,
0.40415719151496887,
-0.5936852693557739,
-0.7221558690071106,
-0.30315956473350525,
-0.35518741607666016,
-0.12540145218372345,
-0.34374552965164185,
-0.45632243156433105,
-0.6328579783439636,
-0.5563411116600037,
0.7474245429039001,
-0.42740529775619507,
-0.19957901537418365,
0.05260443687438965,
-0.1933126002550125,
0.26398414373397827,
0.4513203203678131,
-1.108974575996399,
0.4924652576446533,
0.7532992362976074,
0.8761762976646423,
-0.5473307967185974,
-0.522832453250885,
-0.2604062855243683,
0.08106948435306549,
-0.5722375512123108,
1.0255155563354492,
-0.3235721290111542,
-0.15896563231945038,
-0.2492811679840088,
-0.2867794334888458,
-0.26559001207351685,
-0.550132691860199,
0.20011775195598602,
-0.9969209432601929,
0.05513529106974602,
-0.4093483090400696,
-0.9166849255561829,
0.07565341889858246,
-0.06803159415721893,
-0.4254821836948395,
0.8004958033561707,
0.16332899034023285,
-0.8465601801872253,
0.8739601373672485,
-0.34101009368896484,
-0.45731520652770996,
0.09931480139493942,
-0.341473251581192,
-0.16292405128479004,
0.2547418773174286,
0.07358368486166,
0.5034497380256653,
-0.33597803115844727,
0.11203578859567642,
-0.4751215875148773,
-0.34010761976242065,
0.3300926089286804,
-0.08973228931427002,
0.47438478469848633,
-0.0788295641541481,
-0.2744005024433136,
-0.1390201449394226,
-0.5715517997741699,
0.23012886941432953,
0.10680878162384033,
-0.19806991517543793,
-0.5873702764511108,
0.06795885413885117,
-0.1607033908367157,
0.4315415918827057,
0.06638963520526886,
-0.4178798198699951,
0.3402025103569031,
-0.4650821089744568,
0.6164326071739197,
0.8969932794570923,
-0.023417238146066666,
0.4115591049194336,
-0.22767604887485504,
0.21402883529663086,
0.028834452852606773,
-0.38284415006637573,
0.24937157332897186,
-0.7087201476097107,
-0.6450541615486145,
-0.30914610624313354,
0.6727010607719421,
0.2826376259326935,
-0.6037728190422058,
0.3673158586025238,
-0.39785054326057434,
-0.4859701097011566,
-0.46815404295921326,
0.07284151017665863,
0.2338865101337433,
0.5334385633468628,
0.5255757570266724,
-0.5177252888679504,
-0.5170425176620483,
-1.0102121829986572,
-0.6778687238693237,
0.04483572021126747,
-0.16427123546600342,
0.2538240849971771,
0.7266082763671875,
-0.015245542861521244,
1.1984004974365234,
-0.5731654763221741,
-0.36269456148147583,
0.0631873831152916,
0.3880872130393982,
0.005750876385718584,
0.626121997833252,
0.4606132209300995,
-0.36245059967041016,
-0.4941445291042328,
0.008219791576266289,
-0.6749793291091919,
0.25262734293937683,
0.13880513608455658,
0.004736324306577444,
0.11831057816743851,
0.724826991558075,
-0.7700662016868591,
0.24799856543540955,
0.12905043363571167,
-0.4499446749687195,
0.48610401153564453,
-0.3585578501224518,
-0.05817365646362305,
-1.0464318990707397,
-0.12361408025026321,
0.10013165324926376,
-0.20953603088855743,
-0.6995711326599121,
-0.36941543221473694,
-0.1361408531665802,
0.04139289632439613,
-0.029274675995111465,
0.7677196264266968,
-0.5189231634140015,
-0.33813023567199707,
-0.44388431310653687,
0.23320379853248596,
-0.32854071259498596,
0.43730443716049194,
0.29805198311805725,
0.9589020013809204,
0.5612109899520874,
-0.43425267934799194,
-0.0860736221075058,
0.39584675431251526,
-0.5698428750038147,
0.19513310492038727,
-0.8886846899986267,
0.4661296308040619,
0.23231084644794464,
-0.030142322182655334,
-1.0184623003005981,
-0.4441778361797333,
-0.31586143374443054,
-0.7058581113815308,
0.463766485452652,
-0.06878862529993057,
-0.5099398493766785,
-0.3823401927947998,
0.17551054060459137,
0.38793304562568665,
0.7063735723495483,
-0.5561400651931763,
0.5445526838302612,
0.3315095603466034,
-0.4136503338813782,
-0.5612400770187378,
-0.759568989276886,
0.28461021184921265,
-0.03960101678967476,
-0.4361058175563812,
0.21903172135353088,
-0.026909414678812027,
-0.046475138515233994,
-0.03221574425697327,
-0.018264876678586006,
-0.1460375338792801,
0.04002152755856514,
0.03954816982150078,
0.10814221203327179,
-0.24066999554634094,
0.09219542890787125,
-0.06289473176002502,
-0.23733749985694885,
0.33320561051368713,
-0.5789361000061035,
0.2963452637195587,
0.11446823179721832,
-0.3461472988128662,
-0.06683774292469025,
0.14472107589244843,
0.4289591908454895,
0.05884038284420967,
0.8236265182495117,
0.3791002333164215,
-0.42660781741142273,
-0.5518329739570618,
-0.6418184041976929,
-0.6293391585350037,
-0.42443880438804626,
0.5073896050453186,
-0.3875208795070648,
-0.876083254814148,
0.344248503446579,
-0.06951162964105606,
-0.29061436653137207,
0.5287046432495117,
0.5824488401412964,
0.02660146914422512,
1.2189146280288696,
0.790371835231781,
-0.021852176636457443,
0.1487089842557907,
-0.09739937633275986,
0.13509687781333923,
-0.6474007368087769,
-0.36406856775283813,
-0.31246209144592285,
-0.25625455379486084,
-0.3437071740627289,
-0.4071516990661621,
0.10663489252328873,
-0.005926833488047123,
-0.26042497158050537,
0.29487743973731995,
-0.5894909501075745,
0.6171389818191528,
0.7715302109718323,
0.140894815325737,
0.21499332785606384,
0.2548043727874756,
-0.24798139929771423,
-0.1707068681716919,
-1.0138534307479858,
-0.3964141011238098,
1.261113166809082,
0.31463098526000977,
0.6971048712730408,
-0.34533557295799255,
0.4760498106479645,
0.4908953309059143,
0.5566905736923218,
-0.8494907021522522,
0.6706975698471069,
-0.05405254289507866,
-0.5525047183036804,
-0.20212088525295258,
-0.4413703382015228,
-0.8350244760513306,
0.25527915358543396,
-0.16558708250522614,
-0.552172064781189,
0.38203567266464233,
0.015138186514377594,
-0.33020809292793274,
0.25578293204307556,
-0.5600876212120056,
0.730539858341217,
-0.0871071144938469,
-0.03292699530720711,
-0.3387758135795593,
-0.6269893646240234,
0.2862648367881775,
-0.4294373095035553,
-0.021792519837617874,
-0.07726693898439407,
-0.31833770871162415,
1.0545637607574463,
-0.1953042894601822,
0.7861961126327515,
-0.1952335387468338,
0.029477210715413094,
0.03908232972025871,
0.1731754094362259,
0.33221036195755005,
0.03065025806427002,
-0.06033991649746895,
0.1846267729997635,
-0.25730273127555847,
-0.5856344103813171,
-0.5690292119979858,
0.8334174156188965,
-1.1601864099502563,
-0.7740426659584045,
-0.592831015586853,
-0.5498879551887512,
-0.6301116943359375,
0.2729322016239166,
0.48779550194740295,
0.34012410044670105,
-0.09414530545473099,
-0.016163425520062447,
0.8768991231918335,
0.30674782395362854,
0.26381534337997437,
0.8046261072158813,
0.1518072932958603,
-0.6228200793266296,
0.7940866351127625,
0.15579888224601746,
0.10957300662994385,
0.15534727275371552,
-0.013982432894408703,
-0.12525983154773712,
-0.9648909568786621,
-0.18046841025352478,
0.2887443006038666,
-0.758094310760498,
-0.40261587500572205,
-0.6711339950561523,
-0.08905641734600067,
-0.22249630093574524,
-0.15186330676078796,
-0.15231657028198242,
-0.41466671228408813,
-0.4645681083202362,
-0.15748319029808044,
0.33588120341300964,
1.0128824710845947,
-0.16235743463039398,
0.08111725747585297,
-0.48905712366104126,
0.07585077732801437,
0.4956994950771332,
0.4151580035686493,
0.0977104976773262,
-1.0440105199813843,
-0.531901478767395,
-0.006504016928374767,
0.09655709564685822,
-0.6244901418685913,
0.4035346508026123,
0.3247155249118805,
0.6610408425331116,
0.1108594760298729,
-0.3129536509513855,
0.5610106587409973,
-0.7946233749389648,
0.7162356972694397,
0.17277084290981293,
-0.6011530160903931,
0.3288087844848633,
-0.4442710280418396,
-0.19452537596225739,
0.5812839865684509,
0.7284415364265442,
-0.08721233159303665,
-0.3609517514705658,
-0.6953971982002258,
-0.6776189208030701,
0.7737888693809509,
-0.11197303235530853,
-0.0077197072096168995,
-0.20735129714012146,
0.7839813232421875,
0.30465683341026306,
0.17527806758880615,
-0.47086673974990845,
-0.026864053681492805,
0.037763018161058426,
-0.05190608650445938,
-0.2868795394897461,
-0.09260249137878418,
-0.2989063262939453,
-0.48292967677116394,
0.665439784526825,
-0.4031033217906952,
0.6298230886459351,
0.12722359597682953,
-0.1444709151983261,
-0.23813407123088837,
-0.29311805963516235,
0.6425983309745789,
0.9083914756774902,
-0.008577108383178711,
0.06758686900138855,
0.2453446090221405,
-0.3857215940952301,
0.1288534253835678,
0.080431267619133,
-0.03532365709543228,
-0.06868711858987808,
0.5344814658164978,
0.6892951726913452,
0.10991569608449936,
-0.45800432562828064,
0.5618828535079956,
-0.018525268882513046,
-0.5584366321563721,
-0.26004335284233093,
0.08146320283412933,
0.15558473765850067,
0.25301018357276917,
0.6970173120498657,
0.6676002740859985,
-0.1336228996515274,
-0.4144037067890167,
0.5139390826225281,
0.45720943808555603,
-0.3109605014324188,
-0.45760342478752136,
0.9038810729980469,
0.005458333995193243,
-0.38868221640586853,
0.5916154980659485,
-0.09351812303066254,
-0.46887558698654175,
0.6670270562171936,
0.6204982995986938,
0.8806253671646118,
-0.08200251311063766,
-0.10379534959793091,
0.2653857469558716,
0.11115908622741699,
-0.5035256147384644,
0.05325142294168472,
0.3860968053340912,
-0.7475640177726746,
-0.685379147529602,
-0.5038504600524902,
-0.3017532229423523,
0.08330093324184418,
-0.6323394179344177,
0.1199454590678215,
-0.445364385843277,
-0.34071436524391174,
0.23803256452083588,
0.1056806668639183,
-0.8504976034164429,
0.3607722222805023,
-0.048019494861364365,
1.2840402126312256,
-0.9839324951171875,
1.0939710140228271,
0.8155760765075684,
-0.5326363444328308,
-0.8082066178321838,
0.006720051169395447,
-0.3576187193393707,
-0.9175531268119812,
1.0591117143630981,
-0.11401010304689407,
0.06258688122034073,
0.23232778906822205,
-0.6536684632301331,
-0.9818932414054871,
0.9859351515769958,
0.3611809313297272,
-0.34078723192214966,
-0.24321530759334564,
-0.04695677012205124,
0.8534153699874878,
-0.6491208076477051,
0.1782137006521225,
0.6908907890319824,
0.13320961594581604,
0.01592954620718956,
-0.9201563596725464,
0.11083901673555374,
-0.12723228335380554,
-0.035560693591833115,
-0.0438203401863575,
-0.40800419449806213,
0.8821758031845093,
-0.5946418642997742,
0.25742605328559875,
0.1934545785188675,
0.9944106340408325,
0.1679016649723053,
0.20026151835918427,
0.3413376808166504,
0.5321821570396423,
0.803059458732605,
-0.12887318432331085,
0.8048928380012512,
-0.48803719878196716,
0.3454878032207489,
1.0150911808013916,
-0.16865041851997375,
1.0867136716842651,
0.4033801257610321,
-0.2489653080701828,
0.5249123573303223,
0.9150801301002502,
-0.21489736437797546,
0.830564022064209,
0.18786291778087616,
0.006964744068682194,
-0.5633687376976013,
0.26510220766067505,
-0.3654543459415436,
0.15248535573482513,
0.39363422989845276,
-0.4097382128238678,
0.1886013001203537,
0.15633448958396912,
-0.13986994326114655,
0.06922829896211624,
-0.41165515780448914,
1.0131922960281372,
0.340999037027359,
-0.7005170583724976,
0.6405195593833923,
-0.16137340664863586,
0.6131325364112854,
-0.42431944608688354,
0.11059366911649704,
-0.22102105617523193,
0.19464410841464996,
-0.08354748785495758,
-0.7179528474807739,
0.03425273299217224,
-0.29834437370300293,
-0.38021209836006165,
-0.08586813509464264,
0.9688006043434143,
-0.41154322028160095,
-0.2127373367547989,
0.2773607671260834,
0.7330949902534485,
0.23615728318691254,
-0.053351543843746185,
-0.6096648573875427,
-0.5985519289970398,
-0.3127620816230774,
-0.3557305932044983,
0.8044906854629517,
0.6747605204582214,
0.10778460651636124,
0.8273752927780151,
0.41224735975265503,
0.30452635884284973,
-0.027737528085708618,
-0.0897289365530014,
1.0099512338638306,
-0.6311348080635071,
-0.23276136815547943,
-0.7702740430831909,
0.015953507274389267,
-0.05337382107973099,
-0.3905775249004364,
0.6647106409072876,
0.5576796531677246,
0.7142553329467773,
-0.41621580719947815,
0.8366054892539978,
0.09793498367071152,
0.6488298177719116,
-0.26461097598075867,
0.6554697155952454,
-0.5695937871932983,
0.047617554664611816,
0.031149832531809807,
-0.832890510559082,
-0.148357555270195,
0.49884143471717834,
-0.4900985360145569,
0.40065979957580566,
0.789901077747345,
0.7105894684791565,
-0.015317903831601143,
-0.07767026126384735,
0.4431457221508026,
0.3569755554199219,
0.05683659762144089,
0.4278295338153839,
0.6988690495491028,
-0.13753487169742584,
0.36812499165534973,
0.15968604385852814,
-0.23789243400096893,
-0.27075913548469543,
-0.8651967644691467,
-1.1928025484085083,
-0.47139784693717957,
-0.2262544482946396,
-0.3010585904121399,
0.24374118447303772,
1.0325307846069336,
0.7045511603355408,
-0.862930178642273,
0.06289220601320267,
-0.24848659336566925,
-0.1826479732990265,
-0.3357086181640625,
-0.1504882425069809,
0.4778409004211426,
-0.48727306723594666,
-0.43156352639198303,
0.5492368340492249,
0.0001004593723337166,
-0.048575691878795624,
-0.32786422967910767,
0.030337264761328697,
-0.06849401444196701,
0.3947988450527191,
0.6070481538772583,
0.15278993546962738,
-0.7424821257591248,
-0.46539607644081116,
0.1500099003314972,
-0.36846524477005005,
-0.06588966399431229,
0.9952256083488464,
-0.9471823573112488,
0.09255947172641754,
0.40686020255088806,
0.685961127281189,
0.3621201813220978,
0.07639626413583755,
0.7963014245033264,
-0.6555024981498718,
-0.18244600296020508,
0.3998200297355652,
0.3738844096660614,
0.38379737734794617,
-0.3012531101703644,
0.5883757472038269,
0.4193217158317566,
-1.0302881002426147,
-0.7866827249526978,
-0.05578434094786644,
-0.794125497341156,
-0.3383011519908905,
1.2050695419311523,
-0.16905207931995392,
-0.02383987233042717,
-0.3484450876712799,
-0.03408750146627426,
0.05065448209643364,
-0.25333815813064575,
1.0648902654647827,
0.7121656537055969,
-0.2176937311887741,
0.02625560201704502,
-0.7277892827987671,
0.9783536195755005,
0.5645905137062073,
-0.5246909260749817,
0.04234866052865982,
0.11167993396520615,
0.5912254452705383,
0.12713266909122467,
0.7243920564651489,
0.2535565495491028,
0.33321693539619446,
0.2753039300441742,
-0.0120795127004385,
-0.19190146028995514,
-0.34652799367904663,
-0.20008087158203125,
0.041334930807352066,
0.5565575957298279,
0.3418845534324646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09373v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09373v2
|
PolygloToxicityPrompts: Multilingual Evaluation of Neural Toxic Degeneration in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-15T14:22:33 | 2024-05-20T15:07:47 |
Devansh Jain, Priyanshu Kumar, Samuel Gehman, Xuhui Zhou, Thomas Hartvigsen, Maarten Sap
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have led to their extensive
global deployment, and ensuring their safety calls for comprehensive and
multilingual toxicity evaluations. However, existing toxicity benchmarks are
overwhelmingly focused on English, posing serious risks to deploying LLMs in
other languages. We address this by introducing PolygloToxicityPrompts (PTP),
the first large-scale multilingual toxicity evaluation benchmark of 425K
naturally occurring prompts spanning 17 languages. We overcome the scarcity of
naturally occurring toxicity in web-text and ensure coverage across languages
with varying resources by automatically scraping over 100M web-text documents.
Using PTP, we investigate research questions to study the impact of model size,
prompt language, and instruction and preference-tuning methods on toxicity by
benchmarking over 60 LLMs. Notably, we find that toxicity increases as language
resources decrease or model size increases. Although instruction- and
preference-tuning reduce toxicity, the choice of preference-tuning method does
not have any significant impact. Our findings shed light on crucial
shortcomings of LLM safeguarding and highlight areas for future research.
|
[
-0.20688189566135406,
-0.5637111067771912,
0.523652970790863,
0.5054803490638733,
-0.18999184668064117,
-0.3794860243797302,
-0.18407544493675232,
-0.648775577545166,
-0.05253422260284424,
0.3461019992828369,
-0.2556758224964142,
-0.460834801197052,
-0.6852750778198242,
0.3320595920085907,
-0.030073435977101326,
0.9772217869758606,
0.2530805170536041,
0.32743123173713684,
-0.27435341477394104,
-0.12403830885887146,
-0.23001332581043243,
-0.6997531056404114,
-0.8840647339820862,
-0.30072617530822754,
1.1043001413345337,
0.2322770059108734,
0.6851439476013184,
-0.02363971434533596,
0.585030734539032,
0.22703470289707184,
-0.5469039678573608,
-0.09842563420534134,
-0.295923113822937,
0.055275168269872665,
-0.29681915044784546,
-0.33112481236457825,
-0.3495035469532013,
0.04335617274045944,
0.4769972264766693,
0.7449224591255188,
-0.06406886875629425,
0.03973321244120598,
0.23253598809242249,
0.5760064125061035,
-0.8485051989555359,
0.10852984338998795,
-0.44031915068626404,
0.3667338788509369,
-0.018427565693855286,
-0.1668170541524887,
-0.8298301100730896,
-0.30182793736457825,
0.18953588604927063,
-0.3967966139316559,
-0.5323886275291443,
-0.26300710439682007,
0.3851257562637329,
0.1630486100912094,
-0.8126830458641052,
-0.25593653321266174,
-0.3033687472343445,
0.7988712191581726,
-0.6818740963935852,
0.14845731854438782,
0.2424945831298828,
0.29142168164253235,
0.057670000940561295,
-0.6045069098472595,
-0.26252031326293945,
-0.5834890604019165,
0.03703535720705986,
0.036272160708904266,
-0.24240854382514954,
0.10186194628477097,
0.3070869445800781,
0.011273987591266632,
-0.6701486706733704,
0.2739378809928894,
-0.25818368792533875,
-0.3794260621070862,
0.5145518779754639,
0.2083539515733719,
0.5562490224838257,
-0.1447083204984665,
-0.41263413429260254,
-0.03402502089738846,
-0.9406617283821106,
-0.2933350205421448,
0.5805162787437439,
0.2523224353790283,
-0.06613527238368988,
0.27322617173194885,
0.19281522929668427,
0.5174713730812073,
-0.5615870952606201,
-0.09963807463645935,
0.21593905985355377,
-0.2541041374206543,
0.06358643621206284,
0.07557044178247452,
1.022256851196289,
0.7200822830200195,
0.4184531569480896,
-0.2694239914417267,
0.3572542667388916,
-0.12355989962816238,
0.18523408472537994,
-0.7964306473731995,
-0.1776208132505417,
0.2744958996772766,
-0.32923346757888794,
-0.2585063576698303,
-0.3541609048843384,
-1.0831085443496704,
-0.6797439455986023,
0.0272801723331213,
0.35382279753685,
-0.4780239164829254,
-0.47114694118499756,
0.2610366642475128,
-0.03159208595752716,
0.06890373677015305,
-0.04536668211221695,
-0.7449933886528015,
-0.009260935708880424,
0.4233829975128174,
0.9669603705406189,
-0.504114031791687,
-0.508331835269928,
-0.439098596572876,
0.023715250194072723,
-0.27693861722946167,
0.8302938938140869,
-0.42803889513015747,
-0.450377881526947,
0.03605341538786888,
-0.06456413120031357,
-0.004962102975696325,
-0.9061431288719177,
0.6060531139373779,
-0.06150234490633011,
0.05442485585808754,
-0.44078248739242554,
0.07681656628847122,
-0.008170170709490776,
0.21059106290340424,
-0.5816943049430847,
0.6990770101547241,
-0.1517929583787918,
-0.9213951826095581,
0.18038907647132874,
-0.30161693692207336,
-0.5595752596855164,
-0.041802968829870224,
0.22637753188610077,
-0.11161591857671738,
0.0759899839758873,
-0.1650265008211136,
0.20975369215011597,
-0.2890470027923584,
0.2989145517349243,
-0.5314666032791138,
-0.08747488260269165,
0.04642702266573906,
-0.5894768238067627,
1.0665991306304932,
0.20045636594295502,
-0.059118688106536865,
0.3077223300933838,
-0.542492687702179,
0.08117211610078812,
0.06359472125768661,
-0.477949857711792,
-0.39560097455978394,
0.042529501020908356,
0.08103637397289276,
0.6016957759857178,
0.11870875954627991,
-0.4498157203197479,
-0.08714235574007034,
-0.2737751305103302,
0.4181239902973175,
0.682158887386322,
0.07170622795820236,
0.07280561327934265,
-0.36429300904273987,
0.54612797498703,
0.1630488932132721,
0.6591552495956421,
0.06462842226028442,
-0.3406437337398529,
-0.4004661738872528,
0.06627728044986725,
-0.13278385996818542,
0.5606551170349121,
-0.7186928391456604,
0.3110101819038391,
-0.11588949710130692,
-0.637067437171936,
-0.043501511216163635,
-0.18791864812374115,
0.5701673626899719,
0.42891064286231995,
0.3045530915260315,
-0.09849834442138672,
-0.17099401354789734,
-0.9937848448753357,
-0.19733130931854248,
-0.14560504257678986,
0.029340794309973717,
0.443379670381546,
0.3598525822162628,
-0.22392742335796356,
0.13357596099376678,
-0.49840250611305237,
-0.4349345564842224,
-0.1130676344037056,
0.08335600048303604,
-0.03545430302619934,
0.22019483149051666,
0.8120548129081726,
-0.3082572817802429,
-0.7831186056137085,
-0.10823038220405579,
-0.6676058173179626,
-0.39811477065086365,
0.12048044055700302,
-0.10116618871688843,
0.17514897882938385,
0.5290096998214722,
-0.6051762104034424,
-0.20762823522090912,
0.8785989880561829,
-0.18017137050628662,
0.9890598058700562,
-0.3573477566242218,
-0.12151886522769928,
-0.7576695084571838,
0.2495267391204834,
0.2407807558774948,
0.03834979981184006,
-0.48229292035102844,
0.31265100836753845,
-0.10423452407121658,
-0.32377520203590393,
-0.8960058689117432,
0.5538173913955688,
-0.30464208126068115,
0.24021844565868378,
-0.1573837548494339,
0.040644701570272446,
0.1530836969614029,
0.06486687064170837,
-0.0730186402797699,
0.7559942007064819,
0.7402533888816833,
-0.5250499844551086,
0.506805419921875,
-0.020334187895059586,
-0.1571410447359085,
0.3609238862991333,
-0.5554577708244324,
-0.04182276502251625,
0.020348183810710907,
0.23322223126888275,
-0.6379172205924988,
-0.0031819925643503666,
-0.01151969376951456,
-0.09730622917413712,
0.22122405469417572,
-0.009309248067438602,
-0.7446273565292358,
-0.34998396039009094,
-0.48015642166137695,
0.28570547699928284,
0.40099114179611206,
-0.5026620626449585,
0.26516154408454895,
0.5908942222595215,
-0.4778250455856323,
-0.5232998132705688,
-0.7204494476318359,
0.30276918411254883,
-0.4258784353733063,
-0.6596435904502869,
0.23103033006191254,
-0.37552717328071594,
-0.2881355583667755,
-0.30561017990112305,
-0.08204876631498337,
-0.04325795918703079,
0.12029842287302017,
0.01853393018245697,
-0.04563338682055473,
0.03219784051179886,
0.22170615196228027,
0.051464296877384186,
-0.2871527671813965,
0.5556866526603699,
0.19477543234825134,
0.685178279876709,
-0.10539762675762177,
-0.14843444526195526,
-0.16426192224025726,
0.5559127926826477,
0.7486770153045654,
-0.3625936806201935,
0.674727737903595,
0.2551407814025879,
-0.13669364154338837,
-0.25930649042129517,
-0.15037748217582703,
-0.12635503709316254,
-0.4391285479068756,
0.37360382080078125,
-0.0891018956899643,
-0.46281155943870544,
0.613601565361023,
-0.3184777498245239,
-0.25651052594184875,
0.3169662654399872,
0.6158269643783569,
0.2676326632499695,
1.1700406074523926,
0.45134443044662476,
-0.20868659019470215,
0.41370007395744324,
0.03264521434903145,
0.02585200034081936,
-0.5635901689529419,
-0.17676818370819092,
-0.33863675594329834,
-0.0387471504509449,
-0.4436452090740204,
-0.33370062708854675,
0.8486361503601074,
-0.2189209908246994,
-0.36476802825927734,
-0.09123580157756805,
-0.28172269463539124,
0.7890979051589966,
0.41371455788612366,
0.1956547200679779,
0.30956485867500305,
-0.09851137548685074,
-0.47785449028015137,
-0.12649133801460266,
-0.5907291173934937,
-0.45689529180526733,
0.9724072217941284,
0.35599011182785034,
0.752963125705719,
0.1748226284980774,
0.3586910665035248,
-0.07023388147354126,
0.1856749951839447,
-0.7612122297286987,
0.5603605508804321,
-0.5929451584815979,
-0.8348301649093628,
0.031911902129650116,
-0.5810897350311279,
-0.7500093579292297,
0.19294653832912445,
-0.04762748256325722,
-0.7810667753219604,
-0.018455546349287033,
0.07574374973773956,
-0.5509725213050842,
0.2471476048231125,
-1.0365740060806274,
1.0645073652267456,
-0.7045159935951233,
-0.6649894118309021,
-0.34277063608169556,
-0.6677680611610413,
0.4988487660884857,
-0.19995826482772827,
0.19652584195137024,
-0.2458769977092743,
-0.0027064860332757235,
0.34574979543685913,
-0.12237387150526047,
0.8044689893722534,
-0.09899405390024185,
-0.35776063799858093,
0.0007549608708359301,
0.14593830704689026,
0.17770078778266907,
0.2083224356174469,
-0.3950072228908539,
0.32090047001838684,
-0.026680752635002136,
-0.25629130005836487,
-0.17979376018047333,
1.0486794710159302,
-0.5834230184555054,
-0.4959834814071655,
-0.6726135611534119,
-0.5881475806236267,
-0.47324398159980774,
0.32518795132637024,
0.33626723289489746,
0.1324150115251541,
-0.029766252264380455,
-0.050049301236867905,
0.6790534257888794,
-1.1705464124679565,
0.4732823967933655,
0.7259188890457153,
-0.3078758716583252,
-0.3028552234172821,
1.0628973245620728,
-0.030167635530233383,
0.6065906882286072,
-0.06132868677377701,
0.5249682068824768,
-0.3790414035320282,
-0.7415381669998169,
-0.19140680134296417,
0.2927689254283905,
-0.8035193681716919,
-0.14755688607692719,
-0.27747032046318054,
-0.3034709692001343,
-0.2342829704284668,
0.13766787946224213,
-0.352682501077652,
0.19285909831523895,
-0.297434538602829,
-0.16013017296791077,
0.19957302510738373,
0.5817704200744629,
-0.19206106662750244,
0.1492772400379181,
-1.045528531074524,
0.11128171533346176,
0.2676572799682617,
0.7174025774002075,
-0.12176822870969772,
-0.26580607891082764,
-0.03914502263069153,
-0.026658549904823303,
-0.42354798316955566,
-1.0912774801254272,
0.5072911977767944,
0.3831213414669037,
0.6361873149871826,
0.34085574746131897,
0.2039579451084137,
0.3270255923271179,
-0.49511465430259705,
0.8044378757476807,
0.24934661388397217,
-0.722968578338623,
0.45675382018089294,
-0.5933871269226074,
0.31748107075691223,
0.4065345525741577,
0.9621487855911255,
-0.7264353036880493,
-0.32434922456741333,
-0.20095893740653992,
-1.1511989831924438,
0.7014573812484741,
-0.24021968245506287,
0.41586586833000183,
-0.44024038314819336,
0.16353780031204224,
0.21211738884449005,
-0.35076192021369934,
-1.014286756515503,
-0.3016698360443115,
0.24794912338256836,
0.09880761057138443,
-0.20648425817489624,
-0.6075815558433533,
-0.28670206665992737,
-0.2931888997554779,
0.6318628191947937,
-0.0711672455072403,
-0.039270371198654175,
0.009119680151343346,
-0.32705235481262207,
-0.31124284863471985,
0.3941695988178253,
0.48886409401893616,
0.7415414452552795,
-0.28912970423698425,
0.3311953842639923,
0.2204514592885971,
-0.42258474230766296,
0.2559705674648285,
0.2679475247859955,
-0.13096308708190918,
-0.2285032719373703,
0.42269375920295715,
0.537259042263031,
0.23030562698841095,
-1.0023069381713867,
0.41702577471733093,
-0.04295744746923447,
0.03794151172041893,
-0.2449868619441986,
-0.055009037256240845,
0.24570192396640778,
0.0027536351699382067,
0.19495746493339539,
-0.2605709731578827,
0.12164374440908432,
-0.7154411673545837,
0.32955488562583923,
0.4106268584728241,
-0.33469754457473755,
-0.15114013850688934,
0.49992406368255615,
0.44098961353302,
0.1385916918516159,
0.4973187744617462,
-0.22987155616283417,
-0.35139504075050354,
0.4560326039791107,
0.5181517004966736,
0.6013509631156921,
-0.3379751443862915,
0.35053446888923645,
0.4617290198802948,
0.3432615101337433,
0.09037268906831741,
0.4175380766391754,
0.8325011730194092,
-0.5155133605003357,
-0.621002197265625,
-0.6865297555923462,
-0.26118004322052,
0.40622374415397644,
-0.5921783447265625,
0.1964268833398819,
-0.5028055310249329,
-0.15352939069271088,
0.343560129404068,
-0.21992893517017365,
0.1703658103942871,
-0.11411099880933762,
0.5194385647773743,
0.8535598516464233,
-1.1626031398773193,
0.7172726392745972,
0.7144951820373535,
-0.4404672384262085,
-0.4244365096092224,
0.012411613017320633,
0.26277753710746765,
-0.5031192898750305,
0.6755746603012085,
0.3683379888534546,
0.14140385389328003,
0.21617744863033295,
-0.15189683437347412,
-0.5249567031860352,
0.7114683389663696,
1.0268508195877075,
-0.615928590297699,
-0.12011817842721939,
0.48217329382896423,
0.6194897294044495,
0.2140066921710968,
0.3356949985027313,
0.6397085189819336,
0.5278595089912415,
-0.07033094018697739,
-1.1569515466690063,
0.0110243521630764,
-0.2667861878871918,
-0.36570605635643005,
0.13967885076999664,
-0.6505662798881531,
0.7525606155395508,
-0.29110872745513916,
-0.2383011132478714,
-0.2949649393558502,
-0.14912277460098267,
0.044617775827646255,
0.04827914014458656,
0.42421025037765503,
0.8728117346763611,
0.3633219003677368,
0.005904794670641422,
1.2604455947875977,
-0.31559595465660095,
0.2314428836107254,
1.0082625150680542,
-0.4437101185321808,
0.7954019904136658,
0.3426973819732666,
-0.37797412276268005,
0.14182209968566895,
0.5512188076972961,
0.20171813666820526,
0.4473663866519928,
0.4499069154262543,
-0.6028934717178345,
-0.2851810157299042,
-0.5391494631767273,
-0.33512383699417114,
0.371858686208725,
0.2524331212043762,
-0.4150518774986267,
-0.6398797035217285,
0.3590477705001831,
0.12247208505868912,
-0.06742864847183228,
-0.23495423793792725,
0.807691752910614,
0.27523961663246155,
-0.7586896419525146,
0.5711126923561096,
-0.28704386949539185,
0.6881449222564697,
-0.6795498132705688,
0.09960751980543137,
-0.3158567547798157,
0.3854304552078247,
-0.1178906261920929,
-0.9212726354598999,
0.5733676552772522,
-0.021177565678954124,
0.014515286311507225,
-0.21497254073619843,
0.4344164729118347,
-0.286760538816452,
-0.40659579634666443,
0.9913773536682129,
0.47709277272224426,
0.1677328646183014,
-0.542094886302948,
-0.8218348026275635,
0.07877396047115326,
-0.27072206139564514,
-0.16974882781505585,
0.8082568049430847,
0.2526529133319855,
-0.033247124403715134,
0.8930535912513733,
0.47302407026290894,
0.2628929316997528,
0.16731196641921997,
0.36743372678756714,
0.8921726942062378,
-0.45537129044532776,
0.12208818644285202,
-0.9245022535324097,
0.481626033782959,
0.244345560669899,
-0.30800583958625793,
0.579450249671936,
0.5004112124443054,
0.6059331893920898,
-0.0819675400853157,
0.5985713005065918,
-0.01179113145917654,
0.03132366016507149,
-0.44629716873168945,
0.9527379274368286,
-0.5503694415092468,
0.18586979806423187,
-0.13241387903690338,
-0.6682642698287964,
-0.5830970406532288,
0.21549169719219208,
-0.3878241181373596,
0.13091617822647095,
1.063143253326416,
0.8208005428314209,
0.22593282163143158,
-0.5033735036849976,
0.315213143825531,
0.4228206276893616,
0.20819678902626038,
0.8851783871650696,
0.9191393852233887,
0.017015116289258003,
0.8613870739936829,
-0.5850417613983154,
-0.10448761284351349,
-0.14334440231323242,
-1.1549952030181885,
-0.603361964225769,
-0.39970290660858154,
-0.33613166213035583,
-0.3946339190006256,
0.2858945429325104,
0.7074577808380127,
0.4771897494792938,
-0.729412317276001,
-0.057173144072294235,
-0.01349788997322321,
0.1631903052330017,
-0.12265171110630035,
-0.20677119493484497,
0.23312659561634064,
-0.33314675092697144,
-0.5584529042243958,
0.1382184624671936,
0.28838732838630676,
0.13960786163806915,
-0.3162204623222351,
0.02355886623263359,
-0.30278363823890686,
-0.2847557067871094,
1.0474956035614014,
0.19172073900699615,
-0.6191917061805725,
-0.40789929032325745,
-0.04126066714525223,
-0.28138217329978943,
-0.07298938930034637,
0.48930230736732483,
-0.2752284109592438,
0.47253668308258057,
0.6655467748641968,
0.15259335935115814,
0.03300526365637779,
-0.3963356614112854,
0.7420408129692078,
-0.6483720541000366,
0.12436353415250778,
0.5597570538520813,
0.3980116546154022,
0.23968622088432312,
-0.29983681440353394,
0.363893061876297,
0.07833778113126755,
-0.49588170647621155,
-0.7899951338768005,
0.2979191541671753,
-1.0151009559631348,
-0.5603352189064026,
1.5990962982177734,
-0.4720226526260376,
-0.049016304314136505,
-0.036585379391908646,
-0.29795128107070923,
0.14650976657867432,
-0.010346497409045696,
0.8941404819488525,
0.765364408493042,
-0.09171982854604721,
-0.310782790184021,
-0.911776065826416,
0.542136549949646,
0.41749680042266846,
-1.0887277126312256,
0.4885285496711731,
0.6120421886444092,
0.27350088953971863,
0.16740845143795013,
0.319691002368927,
-0.4804295301437378,
0.35399001836776733,
0.06506955623626709,
0.1983889937400818,
0.01708664372563362,
-0.4250902235507965,
-0.4368826746940613,
-0.020056499168276787,
0.3695639669895172,
0.4535001814365387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09341v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09341v2
|
Large Language Model Bias Mitigation from the Perspective of Knowledge Editing
| 2024-05-15T13:44:13 | 2024-06-29T05:50:28 |
Ruizhe Chen, Yichen Li, Zikai Xiao, Zuozhu Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing debiasing methods inevitably make unreasonable or undesired
predictions as they are designated and evaluated to achieve parity across
different social groups but leave aside individual facts, resulting in modified
existing knowledge. In this paper, we first establish a new bias mitigation
benchmark BiasKE leveraging existing and additional constructed datasets, which
systematically assesses debiasing performance by complementary metrics on
fairness, specificity, and generalization. Meanwhile, we propose a novel
debiasing method, Fairness Stamp (FAST), which enables editable fairness
through fine-grained calibration on individual biased knowledge. Comprehensive
experiments demonstrate that FAST surpasses state-of-the-art baselines with
remarkable debiasing performance while not hampering overall model capability
for knowledge preservation, highlighting the prospect of fine-grained debiasing
strategies for editable fairness in LLMs.
|
[
-0.47722506523132324,
-0.9714292287826538,
0.4897424876689911,
0.01951530948281288,
-0.10509730875492096,
-0.07552896440029144,
-0.29918673634529114,
-0.3252561092376709,
0.06203634291887283,
0.6780149340629578,
-0.31254687905311584,
-0.4083276689052582,
-0.8023307919502258,
-0.12345190346240997,
-0.13213907182216644,
0.9467024803161621,
0.1306215524673462,
0.3207308053970337,
-0.15008915960788727,
-0.2646983563899994,
-0.5603234767913818,
-0.5292069911956787,
-0.7604784369468689,
-0.4305543303489685,
0.336074560880661,
0.41063207387924194,
1.0345741510391235,
0.7942260503768921,
0.46669289469718933,
0.2822931110858917,
-0.5004709362983704,
0.0013135718181729317,
-0.48525580763816833,
-0.0489860400557518,
-0.4974327087402344,
-0.6627984642982483,
-0.8820311427116394,
0.08335992693901062,
0.7850390672683716,
0.7647940516471863,
0.10205186158418655,
0.32841432094573975,
0.11155968904495239,
0.8801095485687256,
-0.9098094701766968,
0.13493502140045166,
-0.8729260563850403,
0.21260420978069305,
-0.49624931812286377,
0.03598672151565552,
-0.24245645105838776,
-0.5889323949813843,
-0.18544453382492065,
-0.5354264378547668,
0.11016717553138733,
-0.005315506365150213,
0.42780205607414246,
0.5136393904685974,
-0.2320156693458557,
0.0976891964673996,
-0.5622825026512146,
0.8917014598846436,
-1.0316132307052612,
0.3339580297470093,
0.4442168176174164,
0.37906211614608765,
-0.12248436361551285,
-0.41687849164009094,
-0.7078714370727539,
0.23869577050209045,
0.1290508210659027,
-0.2223266363143921,
0.014112702570855618,
0.1464971899986267,
0.688355565071106,
0.27673694491386414,
-0.04476139321923256,
0.2912712097167969,
-0.02001381665468216,
-0.42034128308296204,
0.47611546516418457,
0.13837496936321259,
0.03697827830910683,
-0.1458740085363388,
-0.33539384603500366,
0.005793857388198376,
-0.8437620401382446,
0.1368398815393448,
0.5586121678352356,
0.15031160414218903,
-0.037006549537181854,
0.5267989039421082,
-0.5311951637268066,
0.40192878246307373,
0.08508031070232391,
-0.22785267233848572,
0.49100762605667114,
-0.008992153219878674,
-0.35471081733703613,
0.10593297332525253,
0.5185697078704834,
0.7914179563522339,
0.5532723069190979,
-0.050465214997529984,
-0.3292272388935089,
0.22860698401927948,
-0.3180698752403259,
-0.7635015249252319,
0.22595523297786713,
0.04628164321184158,
-0.4909568428993225,
-0.2810157835483551,
-0.2588772177696228,
-1.0746291875839233,
-1.0123358964920044,
-0.4483669400215149,
0.15164244174957275,
-0.0013158186338841915,
-0.11971674114465714,
0.3199619948863983,
-0.04832473769783974,
-0.0882231593132019,
0.4677606225013733,
-0.8140509128570557,
0.16162128746509552,
0.8664368987083435,
0.4663565456867218,
0.1306617707014084,
-0.2762986123561859,
-0.8630024194717407,
0.4046690762042999,
-0.09754569083452225,
0.7310401797294617,
-0.835509181022644,
-0.1935550719499588,
0.03833429515361786,
-0.07329586148262024,
0.3127042055130005,
-0.510393500328064,
0.7217714190483093,
-0.5889753103256226,
-0.0657530352473259,
-0.7033404111862183,
-0.6196787357330322,
-0.014406919479370117,
0.3268861472606659,
-0.8005400896072388,
0.8447413444519043,
-0.0008966848254203796,
-1.1128950119018555,
0.6581590175628662,
-0.32666999101638794,
-0.3433065414428711,
-0.3375576436519623,
0.02928857132792473,
-0.40317457914352417,
0.1210513785481453,
0.565690279006958,
0.412182480096817,
-0.37363123893737793,
0.6276295185089111,
-0.7508573532104492,
-0.37372905015945435,
0.09947284311056137,
-0.6337973475456238,
0.5581091642379761,
0.12484829872846603,
-0.4795830249786377,
0.0013139189686626196,
-0.7858860492706299,
-0.13053147494792938,
-0.1821974515914917,
-0.39430344104766846,
-0.5941858887672424,
0.05388528108596802,
-0.2421911358833313,
0.3235813081264496,
0.16586726903915405,
-0.632840633392334,
0.26784229278564453,
-0.4030301570892334,
0.2242804616689682,
1.2398868799209595,
-0.07476246356964111,
0.5970293879508972,
-0.4774281084537506,
0.31899115443229675,
0.0670529305934906,
0.34634748101234436,
0.20156754553318024,
-0.25715985894203186,
-0.8158098459243774,
-0.2516813278198242,
0.6034955978393555,
0.5027428865432739,
-0.7225913405418396,
0.2641478180885315,
-0.427084356546402,
-0.13854575157165527,
-0.7753574848175049,
0.3362794816493988,
0.5287804007530212,
0.5591490864753723,
0.28390923142433167,
-0.35572680830955505,
-0.4365527629852295,
-1.0401301383972168,
-0.8250464200973511,
0.38411736488342285,
0.11732400953769684,
0.051908355206251144,
0.278549462556839,
-0.33359503746032715,
0.9401171207427979,
-0.3049069941043854,
-0.32769089937210083,
-0.010004275478422642,
0.038460761308670044,
0.02274671010673046,
0.5607064366340637,
0.41932013630867004,
-0.5541009306907654,
-0.33057886362075806,
-0.39848512411117554,
-0.5478078722953796,
-0.53001868724823,
0.1323985606431961,
-0.2868362367153168,
0.37674304842948914,
0.6158050894737244,
-0.42699575424194336,
0.5357956886291504,
0.2651861906051636,
-0.44743067026138306,
0.31828489899635315,
0.08263904601335526,
0.3924146890640259,
-0.7822790741920471,
-0.081057108938694,
-0.1457139402627945,
-0.30584657192230225,
-0.39255988597869873,
-0.13552790880203247,
0.24102623760700226,
0.24963292479515076,
-0.5892527103424072,
1.0544254779815674,
-0.24344873428344727,
-0.08882799744606018,
-0.2990139424800873,
0.31944116950035095,
0.09929259121417999,
0.30901986360549927,
-0.2885753810405731,
0.47171035408973694,
0.21958905458450317,
-0.39026889204978943,
-0.10713781416416168,
0.22642573714256287,
-0.569611668586731,
0.5958336591720581,
-0.39220449328422546,
0.19329962134361267,
-0.4899272322654724,
0.3724640905857086,
-0.5923805832862854,
0.20008105039596558,
0.07957734912633896,
-0.1570403277873993,
0.1118602529168129,
-0.1970033198595047,
-0.6518192291259766,
-0.24855312705039978,
-0.6207371354103088,
0.45996883511543274,
0.4383300840854645,
-0.4856549799442291,
0.4055904150009155,
0.5122118592262268,
-0.18937374651432037,
-0.9768097996711731,
-0.8391706943511963,
-0.10798746347427368,
-0.16725312173366547,
-0.5560961961746216,
0.22714850306510925,
-0.2525649666786194,
-0.6566492319107056,
-0.10561330616474152,
-0.10207533836364746,
0.09972386807203293,
0.1167382076382637,
0.029735174030065536,
0.010819301940500736,
0.18274401128292084,
0.19996801018714905,
0.3177831172943115,
-0.21157103776931763,
-0.0586848221719265,
0.20331551134586334,
0.6601148247718811,
0.2692667841911316,
-0.3657751679420471,
-0.30670297145843506,
0.22549006342887878,
0.5827727913856506,
-0.3578101396560669,
0.6714134812355042,
0.4956291913986206,
-0.5294784307479858,
-0.31475162506103516,
-1.1176623106002808,
-0.1071348562836647,
-0.47925806045532227,
0.2665208876132965,
-0.38552743196487427,
-0.9520821571350098,
0.7689568400382996,
-0.002958400407806039,
0.04772697389125824,
0.4122484028339386,
0.5257652401924133,
0.518799364566803,
0.8469289541244507,
0.5380116701126099,
-0.52717524766922,
0.37926211953163147,
0.09714953601360321,
0.2851652503013611,
-0.8605599999427795,
0.10913771390914917,
-0.6220960021018982,
-0.49685055017471313,
-0.44416823983192444,
-0.7487475275993347,
0.021573899313807487,
0.30575889348983765,
-0.5100185871124268,
-0.36099687218666077,
-0.29504841566085815,
0.7351372241973877,
0.6990818977355957,
0.21963678300380707,
0.6044313907623291,
-0.21752546727657318,
-0.11834745109081268,
-0.18856048583984375,
-0.39943477511405945,
-0.6332887411117554,
1.2701539993286133,
0.4525333344936371,
0.8265707492828369,
-0.11665794253349304,
0.5512524247169495,
0.5507756471633911,
0.3313871920108795,
-0.3586340546607971,
0.6451621055603027,
-0.275447815656662,
-0.6816288828849792,
-0.32456710934638977,
-0.5203651189804077,
-0.28971847891807556,
0.2965026795864105,
-0.3117346465587616,
-0.5849347114562988,
0.25508108735084534,
0.3659232556819916,
-0.2696433663368225,
0.7745930552482605,
-0.6332007646560669,
0.7068566679954529,
0.03125347942113876,
-0.6836521029472351,
-0.27186933159828186,
-0.38189730048179626,
0.46592527627944946,
-0.17913579940795898,
0.7281959056854248,
-0.4489237666130066,
0.05501739680767059,
0.7777202725410461,
-0.2431100606918335,
0.8651460409164429,
-0.6875251531600952,
-0.13369715213775635,
0.09318192303180695,
0.24710066616535187,
0.7763135433197021,
0.2001727968454361,
-0.5047245621681213,
0.256026029586792,
-0.20947174727916718,
-0.34277260303497314,
-0.4776410758495331,
0.8216230273246765,
-0.46612685918807983,
-0.6615462899208069,
-0.19493670761585236,
-0.7126100659370422,
-0.45558592677116394,
0.23443540930747986,
-0.10673291981220245,
0.18222089111804962,
-0.15946900844573975,
-0.08321304619312286,
0.6627306342124939,
-0.5397695899009705,
0.47291332483291626,
0.7536913156509399,
-0.09767800569534302,
-0.49351245164871216,
0.38705432415008545,
0.12626636028289795,
0.31882283091545105,
0.37790924310684204,
0.39370912313461304,
-0.1221562996506691,
-0.49157458543777466,
-0.1589595228433609,
0.05252542346715927,
-0.93108731508255,
-0.36571475863456726,
-0.75447678565979,
0.12286276370286942,
-0.6743439435958862,
-0.25967302918434143,
-0.5044889450073242,
-0.5907972455024719,
0.2245691865682602,
-0.02812482975423336,
0.1865607351064682,
0.5055180191993713,
-0.1482844352722168,
0.37989509105682373,
-0.6063109636306763,
0.46264663338661194,
0.20988167822360992,
0.6999493837356567,
0.12962916493415833,
-0.5263698101043701,
-0.0942673459649086,
0.2326660305261612,
-0.158124178647995,
-0.42143508791923523,
0.09867914021015167,
-0.1952371895313263,
0.5986311435699463,
0.29108142852783203,
0.21957039833068848,
0.6007694005966187,
-0.7651308178901672,
0.6137276887893677,
0.10247232764959335,
-1.316587209701538,
0.48072370886802673,
-0.2295721173286438,
0.3216051459312439,
0.7189627289772034,
-0.05847172439098358,
-0.5286063551902771,
-0.4181634485721588,
-0.35531312227249146,
-0.7908896207809448,
0.4834194779396057,
-0.33957892656326294,
-0.002656323369592428,
-0.014794006943702698,
0.3800100088119507,
0.26214683055877686,
0.43153107166290283,
-0.9062585234642029,
-0.13274818658828735,
0.07581525295972824,
-0.14560216665267944,
-0.057641904801130295,
-0.6870741844177246,
-0.08796998858451843,
-0.49265432357788086,
0.7923581600189209,
-0.05641769990324974,
-0.10324178636074066,
0.06260882318019867,
-0.17279408872127533,
-0.2574901580810547,
0.6482148170471191,
0.45452880859375,
0.6147022247314453,
-0.19543346762657166,
0.07493387907743454,
0.21950621902942657,
-0.29136067628860474,
0.02949986793100834,
0.12914299964904785,
-0.48389002680778503,
-0.2949986457824707,
0.14033648371696472,
0.720439076423645,
0.2626359760761261,
-0.4226192533969879,
0.6086038947105408,
0.11458886414766312,
-0.002276187064126134,
0.167022705078125,
0.03792646899819374,
-0.029606979340314865,
0.43656426668167114,
-0.06514588743448257,
0.05126022920012474,
0.08721781522035599,
-0.2576953172683716,
0.06771489977836609,
0.5917352437973022,
-0.1488805115222931,
-0.019143909215927124,
0.8676804900169373,
0.29425686597824097,
-0.0525926910340786,
0.21065595746040344,
-0.17622558772563934,
-0.6047287583351135,
0.4308136999607086,
0.33698171377182007,
0.7823774814605713,
-0.3576120138168335,
-0.07374147325754166,
0.3318307101726532,
0.5324394106864929,
-0.272420734167099,
0.19222815334796906,
0.22837360203266144,
-0.8453234434127808,
-0.47131118178367615,
-0.7461617588996887,
-0.43157100677490234,
0.18762879073619843,
-0.43653205037117004,
0.3065463602542877,
-0.4814049303531647,
-0.1937541514635086,
0.01605103351175785,
0.06393653154373169,
-1.02395761013031,
0.25762665271759033,
0.16405697166919708,
1.0276044607162476,
-0.8050551414489746,
0.9126051068305969,
0.29982495307922363,
-0.1771794706583023,
-0.4746743440628052,
-0.02971103973686695,
0.14637641608715057,
-0.8434566855430603,
0.5125175714492798,
0.10208025574684143,
0.06158120930194855,
-0.2601030468940735,
-0.3208489716053009,
-0.7973738312721252,
0.8980534076690674,
0.6309117078781128,
-0.9109781980514526,
0.15115444362163544,
0.3682601749897003,
0.15262743830680847,
-0.03504768759012222,
0.26477688550949097,
0.795707643032074,
0.7950717806816101,
-0.4297197461128235,
-1.0197484493255615,
0.2525171637535095,
-0.08363927155733109,
-0.0006353177595883608,
0.183064803481102,
-0.7538439631462097,
0.9123249053955078,
0.1058027595281601,
0.1496725082397461,
-0.1721615195274353,
0.14211638271808624,
-0.06917919218540192,
0.3669355809688568,
0.6058756709098816,
0.9171720743179321,
0.8651858568191528,
-0.0500091016292572,
0.8977190852165222,
-0.19425269961357117,
0.23981846868991852,
1.4107016324996948,
-0.6340793967247009,
0.4406900405883789,
0.5850414633750916,
-0.10461252927780151,
0.11223772168159485,
0.20832309126853943,
0.09976714104413986,
0.4578360617160797,
0.47294652462005615,
-0.25804823637008667,
-0.09148259460926056,
-0.12042754143476486,
-0.36836275458335876,
0.38804367184638977,
-0.003938194829970598,
-0.3707396388053894,
-0.20001102983951569,
0.17243507504463196,
0.5014517307281494,
0.3211844265460968,
-0.7218071818351746,
0.5851558446884155,
-0.15831170976161957,
-0.6926126480102539,
0.35025784373283386,
0.2308410406112671,
0.9940841794013977,
-0.3535652160644531,
0.04075675457715988,
-0.43609803915023804,
0.5241761803627014,
-0.10961736738681793,
-0.6876060366630554,
0.216202974319458,
-0.035568155348300934,
-0.5827376246452332,
-0.17474950850009918,
0.8227241039276123,
-0.39307206869125366,
-0.41570255160331726,
0.4380216598510742,
0.46930867433547974,
-0.2791996896266937,
-0.1869267076253891,
-0.5321104526519775,
0.38011109828948975,
0.08576967567205429,
-0.4206843078136444,
0.4057098925113678,
0.6054696440696716,
-0.26295050978660583,
0.5984396934509277,
0.40486639738082886,
0.22531116008758545,
0.08199475705623627,
0.3948250114917755,
0.9093243479728699,
-0.772264838218689,
-0.401869535446167,
-1.0460790395736694,
0.5146610736846924,
-0.2776789665222168,
-0.17298069596290588,
0.7677416205406189,
0.5777180194854736,
0.918799102306366,
-0.04842210188508034,
0.9196246266365051,
0.24080204963684082,
0.7307640314102173,
-0.6773711442947388,
0.9148277044296265,
-0.20247149467468262,
0.41976532340049744,
-0.7340829372406006,
-1.0366853475570679,
-0.3681240379810333,
0.3459365963935852,
-0.49939048290252686,
0.0031003844924271107,
0.5437925457954407,
0.9089853167533875,
-0.06131242960691452,
-0.0031151387374848127,
0.394357830286026,
0.29257598519325256,
0.31574830412864685,
0.5294852256774902,
0.5932812690734863,
-0.29053205251693726,
0.04572447016835213,
-0.45434892177581787,
-0.3445468842983246,
0.0871356725692749,
-1.2348791360855103,
-1.14795982837677,
-0.08030892163515091,
-0.2783122658729553,
-0.28440091013908386,
0.2755754292011261,
0.7970040440559387,
0.46730178594589233,
-0.7461823225021362,
0.15614227950572968,
0.20727385580539703,
0.4348672330379486,
0.12763264775276184,
-0.2488022893667221,
0.4282691776752472,
-0.2523757517337799,
-0.7805908918380737,
-0.004502405878156424,
-0.020960556343197823,
-0.11187811940908432,
-0.07669030129909515,
0.0032171946950256824,
0.00040839012945070863,
0.24583035707473755,
0.6242972016334534,
-0.05820945277810097,
-0.6085607409477234,
-0.39992088079452515,
-0.5789773464202881,
0.03589897230267525,
-0.015365846455097198,
0.8434842824935913,
-0.879079282283783,
0.5385717153549194,
0.37355953454971313,
0.8166514039039612,
0.24028900265693665,
-0.11474478244781494,
0.34548419713974,
-0.6644993424415588,
0.4940703213214874,
0.0844547227025032,
0.5659056305885315,
0.46628841757774353,
-0.3571905493736267,
0.48843005299568176,
0.13706156611442566,
-0.6356814503669739,
-0.8856037855148315,
0.05383497104048729,
-0.7286019921302795,
-0.18697570264339447,
1.2299342155456543,
0.0620369128882885,
-0.08541030436754227,
0.12081631273031235,
-0.322914719581604,
0.33320751786231995,
-0.4295598566532135,
0.906766414642334,
0.8779375553131104,
0.41713038086891174,
0.16033907234668732,
-0.7447004914283752,
0.6065207719802856,
0.5202851295471191,
-0.8344643115997314,
0.44967636466026306,
0.7028388381004333,
0.3787594735622406,
-0.3253174424171448,
0.8221293091773987,
-0.2960518002510071,
0.13862474262714386,
-0.2869509160518646,
0.35387322306632996,
-0.12511320412158966,
-0.025290990248322487,
-0.34403279423713684,
0.009922557510435581,
0.11958406120538712,
0.1622050702571869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09335v1
|
Prompting-based Synthetic Data Generation for Few-Shot Question Answering
| 2024-05-15T13:36:43 | 2024-05-15T13:36:43 |
Maximilian Schmidt, Andrea Bartezzaghi, Ngoc Thang Vu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Although language models (LMs) have boosted the performance of Question
Answering, they still need plenty of data. Data annotation, in contrast, is a
time-consuming process. This especially applies to Question Answering, where
possibly large documents have to be parsed and annotated with questions and
their corresponding answers. Furthermore, Question Answering models often only
work well for the domain they were trained on. Since annotation is costly, we
argue that domain-agnostic knowledge from LMs, such as linguistic
understanding, is sufficient to create a well-curated dataset. With this
motivation, we show that using large language models can improve Question
Answering performance on various datasets in the few-shot setting compared to
state-of-the-art approaches. For this, we perform data generation leveraging
the Prompting framework, suggesting that language models contain valuable
task-agnostic knowledge that can be used beyond the common
pre-training/fine-tuning scheme. As a result, we consistently outperform
previous approaches on few-shot Question Answering.
|
[
-0.49954819679260254,
-1.175983190536499,
0.8611498475074768,
-0.21367347240447998,
-0.09965283423662186,
-0.11567264795303345,
-0.0256999172270298,
-0.3971625566482544,
-0.13251349329948425,
0.48853278160095215,
-1.150824785232544,
-0.36673879623413086,
-0.12697353959083557,
0.44058361649513245,
-0.1785973757505417,
0.8681156635284424,
0.22713690996170044,
0.0912579596042633,
-0.43698784708976746,
-0.06500226259231567,
-0.5533692240715027,
-0.293587327003479,
-0.675640344619751,
-0.44181278347969055,
0.7105676531791687,
0.49848535656929016,
0.5926939249038696,
0.6153022050857544,
0.04548925533890724,
0.1560700535774231,
0.13324005901813507,
0.6119363903999329,
-0.46132704615592957,
0.23289133608341217,
-0.09512614458799362,
-0.6595983505249023,
-0.0978773757815361,
-0.0627208799123764,
0.41706132888793945,
0.8925298452377319,
0.2118978500366211,
0.3542601466178894,
-0.07394737750291824,
0.46949502825737,
-0.4976576864719391,
-0.0574338436126709,
-1.018004059791565,
-0.1350160390138626,
-0.17058908939361572,
-0.3361586034297943,
-0.3630084693431854,
-0.45499059557914734,
0.21654866635799408,
-0.9075208306312561,
0.4863678216934204,
0.10615764558315277,
0.6438071131706238,
0.2542392611503601,
-0.025570714846253395,
-0.31839802861213684,
-0.7110048532485962,
0.767517626285553,
-0.6296986937522888,
0.04729447513818741,
0.6777207255363464,
0.569931149482727,
-0.12377405911684036,
-0.4948134124279022,
-0.9575965404510498,
-0.0005180977750569582,
0.004519444890320301,
0.0037135048769414425,
-0.06064614653587341,
-0.05806591361761093,
0.5746923089027405,
0.05708484724164009,
-0.6761564612388611,
0.012390690855681896,
-0.39930570125579834,
-0.1199922040104866,
0.6057453751564026,
0.4067056477069855,
0.19924797117710114,
-0.3043028712272644,
-0.05718930810689926,
-0.03381724655628204,
-1.1874810457229614,
0.15925240516662598,
0.40905097126960754,
0.6800441145896912,
0.1374354511499405,
0.6191980242729187,
-0.4790070652961731,
1.181459665298462,
0.089976467192173,
0.158173605799675,
-0.11404874920845032,
-0.36316555738449097,
-0.15528790652751923,
-0.11440146714448929,
0.5378095507621765,
0.31714391708374023,
0.6979729533195496,
-0.012794099748134613,
0.011083346791565418,
0.14626683294773102,
0.12310701608657837,
-0.7797704339027405,
-0.28728440403938293,
0.5262669920921326,
0.0025175437331199646,
-0.15040342509746552,
-0.15051567554473877,
-0.6754348278045654,
-0.4610256254673004,
-0.3513166308403015,
0.49005845189094543,
-0.4057794213294983,
0.04773298278450966,
0.11435163021087646,
-0.15801487863063812,
0.36121609807014465,
0.5256427526473999,
-0.9664203524589539,
0.08390536904335022,
0.69366055727005,
0.6833860278129578,
0.0797775387763977,
-0.26779282093048096,
-0.9381662011146545,
0.08764965087175369,
-0.5780899524688721,
1.0051205158233643,
-0.6593159437179565,
-0.444150447845459,
0.1575714349746704,
-0.03154617175459862,
0.07229090481996536,
-0.620765745639801,
0.039199426770210266,
-0.6095568537712097,
0.35353171825408936,
-0.510914146900177,
-0.827994167804718,
-0.06788038462400436,
0.4821026027202606,
-0.5318173170089722,
1.11891508102417,
0.13059282302856445,
-0.4178602695465088,
0.4210980534553528,
-0.678672194480896,
-0.24236953258514404,
0.35865116119384766,
-0.18766413629055023,
-0.11787895113229752,
0.06973101198673248,
0.6663666367530823,
0.5332022309303284,
-0.34435340762138367,
0.10513626039028168,
-0.18262746930122375,
-0.30778607726097107,
0.37867364287376404,
-0.2650315761566162,
0.5077420473098755,
0.21649514138698578,
0.12717393040657043,
-0.2500113248825073,
-0.6514389514923096,
0.2578868269920349,
0.2165985405445099,
-0.19095826148986816,
-0.1893039345741272,
-0.279930055141449,
-0.3193603754043579,
0.17617429792881012,
-0.033187318593263626,
-0.6643261313438416,
0.3928587734699249,
-0.6937022805213928,
0.2329167276620865,
0.5697169303894043,
0.46648383140563965,
0.4303276538848877,
-0.6281518936157227,
0.8128503561019897,
-0.05290580913424492,
-0.11414410173892975,
-0.7278426289558411,
-0.6171622276306152,
-0.4805578589439392,
0.011283472180366516,
0.1933739334344864,
0.5757946968078613,
-1.1265555620193481,
-0.08659664541482925,
-0.21007871627807617,
-0.37100356817245483,
-0.7723003625869751,
0.4794877767562866,
0.1885451078414917,
0.8397424221038818,
0.5012419819831848,
0.19788384437561035,
-0.48414355516433716,
-0.6907103061676025,
-0.3258703052997589,
-0.2851519286632538,
-0.06779872626066208,
0.569131076335907,
0.34773483872413635,
0.1808197796344757,
1.309322714805603,
-0.8231683373451233,
0.1009439006447792,
-0.5028772354125977,
0.18188543617725372,
0.30575552582740784,
0.2682080566883087,
0.49595585465431213,
-0.3851470351219177,
-0.42671459913253784,
-0.16045355796813965,
-0.6715368032455444,
-0.26299068331718445,
-0.24100729823112488,
-0.17964483797550201,
0.13580048084259033,
0.30982935428619385,
-0.7630489468574524,
0.06510316580533981,
0.2767147421836853,
0.2277309000492096,
0.4540858864784241,
0.07905071973800659,
0.10508084297180176,
-1.0381234884262085,
0.13515512645244598,
-0.05555965006351471,
-0.3121717572212219,
-0.9720907807350159,
-0.2151937335729599,
-0.06540791690349579,
-0.38471779227256775,
-0.7316264510154724,
1.0596466064453125,
-0.30225062370300293,
0.31523630023002625,
-0.3848358690738678,
0.21882525086402893,
0.29110193252563477,
0.3238166570663452,
0.3155209422111511,
0.8462740182876587,
0.6985538005828857,
-0.7955271005630493,
0.2712569534778595,
0.5468984842300415,
-0.24758903682231903,
0.4283060133457184,
-0.8715023994445801,
0.5443944931030273,
-0.4357917010784149,
0.11409162729978561,
-1.0143040418624878,
-0.5745442509651184,
0.1448092758655548,
-0.5968070030212402,
0.11555502563714981,
-0.5066717267036438,
-0.5258110761642456,
-0.4526454508304596,
-0.2704704701900482,
0.2738247811794281,
0.6228852272033691,
-0.6483808755874634,
0.1031707227230072,
0.0351201668381691,
-0.4340595006942749,
-0.4229313135147095,
-0.8283219337463379,
-0.14460816979408264,
-0.141517773270607,
-0.5715188384056091,
-0.06030596047639847,
-0.1049843356013298,
-0.14411397278308868,
-0.2605689764022827,
0.057790011167526245,
-0.11367751657962799,
-0.04350296035408974,
0.017097925767302513,
0.3301490843296051,
-0.29914340376853943,
0.5562756657600403,
0.07177937775850296,
-0.12466693669557571,
-0.06066398695111275,
-0.3442865312099457,
0.520793080329895,
0.3138619363307953,
-0.3740396797657013,
-0.3872166574001312,
0.5836514830589294,
0.20874030888080597,
-0.13607938587665558,
0.6684622764587402,
0.28800851106643677,
-0.41196107864379883,
-0.5278751254081726,
-0.5455454587936401,
-0.6322329640388489,
-0.4685046970844269,
-0.023371241986751556,
-0.4233570396900177,
-0.9430155754089355,
0.3917425870895386,
-0.06510746479034424,
0.23223671317100525,
0.29755574464797974,
0.5808810591697693,
-0.2546396553516388,
1.0175484418869019,
0.3584689497947693,
0.043282508850097656,
0.24496816098690033,
-0.12972809374332428,
0.026306085288524628,
-0.3084152042865753,
0.07168556749820709,
-0.5573632717132568,
-0.09303098171949387,
-0.42425262928009033,
-0.4120241105556488,
0.4560050666332245,
-0.008021524176001549,
-0.09977071732282639,
0.059605371206998825,
-0.46782758831977844,
0.6685826778411865,
0.59160977602005,
0.045080844312906265,
0.2227494865655899,
0.0038478951901197433,
0.21849991381168365,
0.1895727962255478,
-1.034718632698059,
-0.6273449659347534,
1.2738733291625977,
-0.030142787843942642,
0.8327530026435852,
-0.25005871057510376,
0.7821934223175049,
-0.006019176449626684,
-0.02631179429590702,
-0.6961797475814819,
0.45389124751091003,
0.15275004506111145,
-0.8205561637878418,
-0.40341416001319885,
-0.2563386559486389,
-0.9923539161682129,
-0.16258183121681213,
-0.2604190707206726,
-0.6046038269996643,
0.1097182109951973,
0.5674378275871277,
-0.8909375071525574,
-0.10270433127880096,
-0.759268045425415,
0.6798877716064453,
0.0992964506149292,
-0.4589748978614807,
0.19993984699249268,
-0.5487375855445862,
0.29591768980026245,
-0.06785397231578827,
-0.183047354221344,
-0.1302572637796402,
0.1281716674566269,
0.5922168493270874,
-0.5768118500709534,
0.9691479802131653,
-0.5216806530952454,
0.07895738631486893,
0.7953600883483887,
0.18567807972431183,
0.6808847188949585,
0.19981370866298676,
-0.30905652046203613,
-0.25954657793045044,
0.1620096117258072,
-0.44996926188468933,
-0.8244467377662659,
0.5865716338157654,
-0.34993883967399597,
-0.6983886361122131,
-0.030688438564538956,
-0.6289772391319275,
-0.6104338765144348,
-0.07542327791452408,
0.4013303220272064,
0.39578646421432495,
-0.04059838876128197,
-0.005875217262655497,
0.6516411304473877,
-0.25782904028892517,
0.3607955873012543,
0.30640512704849243,
-0.11233808845281601,
-0.08029057085514069,
0.7073526978492737,
0.11821199953556061,
0.38588643074035645,
0.09400574117898941,
0.24339421093463898,
-0.5785349011421204,
-0.2796880304813385,
-0.8087705373764038,
0.19397446513175964,
-0.6842911243438721,
-0.3866274654865265,
-0.7191098928451538,
-0.07021517306566238,
-0.3987424969673157,
-0.3020767569541931,
-0.08274316787719727,
-0.5788484811782837,
-0.2983834147453308,
-0.23449546098709106,
0.8387925028800964,
0.5865103602409363,
0.16787585616111755,
0.46648484468460083,
-0.9739633798599243,
0.45806097984313965,
0.6360320448875427,
-0.03381058946251869,
-0.0908140167593956,
-0.34059762954711914,
-0.12437888979911804,
0.23612743616104126,
-0.08784739673137665,
-0.9153566956520081,
0.24118474125862122,
0.4259791076183319,
0.4226643443107605,
0.06606771796941757,
0.1676005721092224,
0.7831935286521912,
-0.5798711180686951,
1.0523428916931152,
-0.1307317316532135,
-0.7526736259460449,
0.9600449800491333,
-0.46483927965164185,
0.7673174738883972,
0.8438475131988525,
0.4660033881664276,
-0.5105394721031189,
-0.30856043100357056,
-0.5492494106292725,
-0.4409489333629608,
0.9001315832138062,
0.01693795993924141,
0.5650196671485901,
-0.2394639551639557,
0.5238664746284485,
0.4864095151424408,
0.31695106625556946,
-0.4621325135231018,
-0.022827673703432083,
-0.08416423201560974,
-0.2508731484413147,
-0.007842432707548141,
-0.014600243419408798,
-0.11430470645427704,
-0.19602349400520325,
0.6616475582122803,
-0.6197621822357178,
0.17242760956287384,
0.21431632339954376,
-0.16735242307186127,
-0.27306509017944336,
0.29506969451904297,
0.4233046770095825,
0.5778305530548096,
0.1557629406452179,
-0.03850216791033745,
0.43047115206718445,
-0.1344548761844635,
0.14308352768421173,
0.037894539535045624,
-0.459818571805954,
-0.029308684170246124,
0.3185618817806244,
0.7415814995765686,
-0.3586091995239258,
-0.7372187972068787,
0.36455026268959045,
0.2966793179512024,
-0.20814728736877441,
0.09147777408361435,
0.3598795235157013,
0.11505775898694992,
0.04935916140675545,
0.4344955384731293,
-0.3486301302909851,
-0.08002355694770813,
-0.47091051936149597,
0.1556125432252884,
0.5308563709259033,
-0.030845150351524353,
-0.33065056800842285,
0.523819625377655,
0.02090846747159958,
-0.10806412249803543,
0.5528228878974915,
-0.05403818562626839,
-0.2675471603870392,
0.46103477478027344,
0.48600825667381287,
0.6383839845657349,
-0.197453573346138,
0.44766440987586975,
0.5734320282936096,
0.09495241940021515,
-0.009538942947983742,
0.5975359678268433,
-0.3449067771434784,
-0.737198531627655,
-0.5467489361763,
-0.6314849257469177,
-0.5425101518630981,
0.29338735342025757,
-0.37982338666915894,
0.29519063234329224,
-0.5253159999847412,
-0.07502596080303192,
0.18553029000759125,
0.02021537907421589,
-0.8679291605949402,
0.42477500438690186,
0.07695535570383072,
0.8456279039382935,
-0.9753398895263672,
0.6695266962051392,
0.6770597100257874,
-0.3823767304420471,
-0.7009172439575195,
0.032677244395017624,
-0.03211914747953415,
-0.8403584957122803,
0.4868839979171753,
0.18046452105045319,
-0.012338961474597454,
0.22638002038002014,
-0.9149066805839539,
-0.4628435969352722,
0.8853728175163269,
0.4286777973175049,
-0.4629931151866913,
0.03614894673228264,
0.5101683139801025,
0.6522378921508789,
-0.3567252457141876,
0.018813608214259148,
0.5210258960723877,
0.46183833479881287,
0.2886452376842499,
-0.47993558645248413,
-0.11715656518936157,
-0.15992695093154907,
-0.1782357096672058,
-0.0880870446562767,
-0.18872107565402985,
0.5931613445281982,
-0.2710740566253662,
-0.24175724387168884,
0.1277623176574707,
0.46854346990585327,
0.47966745495796204,
0.4643874764442444,
0.3160110414028168,
0.1660708338022232,
0.9351264238357544,
-0.14076420664787292,
1.1537801027297974,
-0.11875027418136597,
-0.010188663378357887,
1.148607611656189,
-0.4165790379047394,
0.7298659682273865,
0.4862556755542755,
-0.04164411500096321,
0.21581704914569855,
0.6678626537322998,
0.10181356221437454,
0.3184727430343628,
0.14998841285705566,
-0.3002963364124298,
-0.644359827041626,
-0.23859988152980804,
-0.1453787386417389,
0.4267304837703705,
0.24300019443035126,
-0.18915291130542755,
-0.4576464891433716,
0.12065808475017548,
-0.18884320557117462,
0.01873953826725483,
-0.2509680688381195,
1.0376811027526855,
0.1154821440577507,
-0.9468176364898682,
0.8203914165496826,
-0.45486825704574585,
0.23464836180210114,
-0.6695651412010193,
-0.09303144365549088,
-0.32988807559013367,
-0.41416847705841064,
-0.11790651082992554,
-1.029051661491394,
0.26433518528938293,
0.41048306226730347,
-0.30067819356918335,
-0.27654844522476196,
0.7635762691497803,
-0.5592370629310608,
-0.4453168213367462,
-0.35502105951309204,
1.088826298713684,
0.09459467232227325,
-0.19392642378807068,
-0.5228230953216553,
-0.2982727289199829,
-0.2178708016872406,
-0.26980355381965637,
0.07889657467603683,
0.4014965891838074,
-0.09903670847415924,
0.6621160507202148,
0.9211043119430542,
0.10030194371938705,
0.15749867260456085,
0.19642089307308197,
0.8442192077636719,
-0.5382394790649414,
-0.4689920246601105,
-0.8046422004699707,
0.6138510704040527,
-0.01830352284014225,
-0.23778019845485687,
0.6011977195739746,
0.34582599997520447,
0.560235321521759,
-0.2409282922744751,
1.032081961631775,
0.20229312777519226,
0.7941854596138,
-0.7670305371284485,
0.4986421465873718,
-0.5671555995941162,
0.1385791152715683,
-0.13386833667755127,
-0.9363781809806824,
-0.4031732976436615,
0.2848756015300751,
-0.45141541957855225,
0.02980794943869114,
0.3365894556045532,
1.2018158435821533,
0.06461431831121445,
0.12240716069936752,
0.4656877815723419,
-0.0363125316798687,
0.15448921918869019,
0.568222165107727,
1.0138849020004272,
-0.2244529277086258,
0.3878195583820343,
-0.1102588027715683,
0.20713959634304047,
-0.00900659803301096,
-0.7901016473770142,
-0.9938390254974365,
-0.632020115852356,
-0.2964286506175995,
-0.1058151051402092,
0.04755249246954918,
0.9611197113990784,
0.7917500138282776,
-0.845562756061554,
0.22712479531764984,
-0.18212822079658508,
-0.15614399313926697,
0.04149451479315758,
-0.22448617219924927,
0.24541202187538147,
-0.5019217133522034,
-0.8578280210494995,
0.6560857892036438,
0.1575739085674286,
0.2653668224811554,
-0.14307112991809845,
0.08128569275140762,
-0.15639610588550568,
0.41038402915000916,
0.45994630455970764,
0.5257326364517212,
-0.6098126173019409,
-0.3644438087940216,
0.3428918421268463,
0.05330350995063782,
0.10677843540906906,
0.6771109104156494,
-1.1920711994171143,
0.613418459892273,
0.654930055141449,
1.0281507968902588,
0.47540152072906494,
0.3944796323776245,
0.619148313999176,
-1.160707712173462,
0.012167802080512047,
0.254025399684906,
-0.01996499113738537,
0.5400694608688354,
-0.5491734147071838,
0.31793132424354553,
-0.027925292029976845,
-0.3451605439186096,
-0.7462798357009888,
0.31018608808517456,
-0.7394809722900391,
-0.21151551604270935,
1.1636860370635986,
-0.045426901429891586,
-0.3143620193004608,
-0.23507855832576752,
-0.3123473525047302,
0.04631291329860687,
-0.2935599982738495,
0.5001625418663025,
0.6937590837478638,
-0.3482269048690796,
-0.34300872683525085,
-0.5265781879425049,
0.8418394327163696,
0.5588865280151367,
-1.0851794481277466,
0.3141661584377289,
0.6952550411224365,
0.20035499334335327,
-0.04451870173215866,
0.6437330842018127,
0.1753857582807541,
0.5830326676368713,
-0.0941777229309082,
-0.25854894518852234,
-0.1991894245147705,
-0.42923203110694885,
-0.4232148230075836,
0.16854053735733032,
0.19422857463359833,
-0.11687382310628891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13022v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13022v2
|
LLMs can learn self-restraint through iterative self-reflection
| 2024-05-15T13:35:43 | 2024-07-03T14:46:52 |
Alexandre Piché, Aristides Milios, Dzmitry Bahdanau, Chris Pal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In order to be deployed safely, Large Language Models (LLMs) must be capable
of dynamically adapting their behavior based on their level of knowledge and
uncertainty associated with specific topics. This adaptive behavior, which we
refer to as self-restraint, is non-trivial to teach since it depends on the
internal knowledge of an LLM. By default, LLMs are trained to maximize the next
token likelihood, which does not teach the model to modulate its answer based
on its level of uncertainty. In order to learn self-restraint, we devise a
utility function that can encourage the model to produce responses only when it
is confident in them. This utility function can be used to score generation of
different length and abstention. To optimize this function, we introduce
ReSearch, a process of "self-reflection" consisting of iterative self-prompting
and self-evaluation. We use the ReSearch algorithm to generate synthetic data
on which we finetune our models. Compared to their original versions, our
resulting models generate fewer \emph{hallucinations} overall at no additional
inference cost, for both known and unknown topics, as the model learns to
selectively restrain itself. In addition, our method elegantly incorporates the
ability to abstain by augmenting the samples generated by the model during the
search procedure with an answer expressing abstention.
|
[
-0.37332049012184143,
-0.8032318949699402,
0.6241952776908875,
0.3360248804092407,
-0.15024736523628235,
0.10384739190340042,
-0.13364174962043762,
-0.14374275505542755,
0.20735986530780792,
0.6260383129119873,
-0.5235474705696106,
-0.3650415241718292,
-0.27173691987991333,
0.24757586419582367,
-0.28885671496391296,
0.911811888217926,
-0.15033267438411713,
0.05852936953306198,
0.04319576919078827,
0.07542433589696884,
-0.4230383336544037,
-0.6252126693725586,
-0.27986979484558105,
-0.15010449290275574,
0.6141299605369568,
0.44727033376693726,
0.08029114454984665,
0.8385205864906311,
0.2864066958427429,
0.3933369219303131,
0.20472705364227295,
-0.07223677635192871,
-0.5656434297561646,
0.32800671458244324,
-0.5300019979476929,
-0.21906724572181702,
0.05156654119491577,
0.10547108203172684,
0.6335275769233704,
0.35812458395957947,
-0.5001705288887024,
0.011241961270570755,
0.33624520897865295,
0.5393362641334534,
-0.7506018280982971,
-0.219822496175766,
-0.7620207667350769,
0.06362000107765198,
0.025900620967149734,
-0.4349301755428314,
-0.5506739020347595,
-0.1516658216714859,
-0.03398847579956055,
-0.37792062759399414,
0.09163758158683777,
-0.035568442195653915,
0.5589500069618225,
0.44843214750289917,
-0.3785896301269531,
-0.40670540928840637,
-0.7718479037284851,
0.8329141139984131,
-0.5576553344726562,
0.11516865342855453,
0.5386591553688049,
-0.033414825797080994,
-0.14233635365962982,
-0.5596522092819214,
-0.19043275713920593,
-0.457733154296875,
0.1869848370552063,
0.10136990249156952,
0.3310263752937317,
0.008567082695662975,
0.010319708846509457,
0.20035068690776825,
-0.48337382078170776,
0.41445350646972656,
-0.5896654725074768,
-0.1391667127609253,
0.8907881379127502,
0.2993350625038147,
-0.10958213359117508,
-0.3557162284851074,
-0.5922686457633972,
-0.13599976897239685,
-0.6742810606956482,
-0.16366419196128845,
0.13041386008262634,
0.34515631198883057,
0.26223281025886536,
0.5240395069122314,
-0.018443193286657333,
0.248120978474617,
0.18688248097896576,
-0.29685601592063904,
-0.0718224048614502,
0.05634047091007233,
-0.1189587190747261,
0.06658432632684708,
0.8981810808181763,
0.21849147975444794,
0.04448855668306351,
-0.02468540146946907,
-0.3656758964061737,
-0.05013743042945862,
0.8105994462966919,
-0.7539774775505066,
-0.2857167422771454,
0.14411184191703796,
-0.4459376931190491,
-0.3849727213382721,
-0.46171602606773376,
-0.7317602038383484,
-0.34860169887542725,
-0.15470364689826965,
0.7991215586662292,
-0.3072655498981476,
-0.23102371394634247,
0.12176664173603058,
0.226559117436409,
0.25773054361343384,
0.1544395387172699,
-1.0346616506576538,
0.5053207874298096,
0.35993438959121704,
0.9085264801979065,
-0.4936600923538208,
-0.5064422488212585,
-0.21274735033512115,
0.19218268990516663,
-0.5717632174491882,
0.5831208229064941,
-0.21636906266212463,
-0.8404124975204468,
-0.16033606231212616,
-0.030827974900603294,
-0.15987199544906616,
-0.6043520569801331,
0.4881114065647125,
-0.3501066267490387,
0.12600821256637573,
-0.2279897779226303,
-0.8207135200500488,
-0.26298758387565613,
0.22064831852912903,
-0.40039896965026855,
0.8449506163597107,
0.22045686841011047,
-0.6319194436073303,
0.1135893166065216,
-0.4051157832145691,
-0.3194090723991394,
-0.026993032544851303,
-0.37500399351119995,
-0.5042063593864441,
0.2869938910007477,
0.053440313786268234,
0.479712575674057,
0.048831939697265625,
0.2297690361738205,
-0.5265515446662903,
-0.08411822468042374,
0.32445621490478516,
-0.4185669720172882,
0.5555316805839539,
0.5066021084785461,
-0.3277275860309601,
0.27648431062698364,
-0.5933414697647095,
0.02555973269045353,
0.386605441570282,
-0.31049445271492004,
-0.484394907951355,
0.13766607642173767,
-0.4129517674446106,
0.14521797001361847,
0.03661639988422394,
-0.43924450874328613,
0.2560881972312927,
-0.31657272577285767,
0.22204487025737762,
1.1403305530548096,
0.2940025329589844,
0.3521144986152649,
-0.3973242938518524,
0.5548624992370605,
-0.3439701795578003,
0.30712437629699707,
-0.04781991243362427,
0.18535584211349487,
-0.9395334720611572,
-0.16459926962852478,
0.029787186533212662,
0.41954758763313293,
-0.5350343585014343,
0.30760911107063293,
0.2701053023338318,
-0.44316402077674866,
-0.5575138330459595,
0.5366929769515991,
0.36934787034988403,
0.6729028820991516,
0.3855838477611542,
-0.44899097084999084,
-0.45898088812828064,
-0.5902677178382874,
-0.06338173151016235,
-0.09179514646530151,
0.2955726385116577,
0.028772229328751564,
0.5325800776481628,
0.20804253220558167,
0.6411851644515991,
-0.4696655869483948,
-0.3577665686607361,
-0.1574428230524063,
0.43681347370147705,
-0.21678908169269562,
0.6014544367790222,
0.3562605679035187,
-0.39580872654914856,
-0.40802761912345886,
-0.4372571110725403,
-1.1063899993896484,
-0.05244183540344238,
-0.28482645750045776,
0.047577787190675735,
0.36205241084098816,
0.6984874606132507,
-0.27558133006095886,
0.3527646064758301,
0.20794954895973206,
-0.15968789160251617,
0.7950009703636169,
-0.3125339150428772,
-0.27001988887786865,
-0.8846185207366943,
-0.09207584708929062,
-0.1311982423067093,
-0.12491260468959808,
-0.5578011274337769,
0.21947942674160004,
0.0072137098759412766,
0.19354023039340973,
-0.3823268413543701,
0.5487251877784729,
-0.5342530012130737,
0.20711784064769745,
-0.7436204552650452,
0.021818581968545914,
-0.02321952022612095,
0.34970957040786743,
0.3657107353210449,
0.8581765294075012,
0.5661551356315613,
-1.0275626182556152,
-0.09786498546600342,
0.06051180511713028,
-0.3923755884170532,
0.23781773447990417,
-0.5480951070785522,
0.2840026319026947,
-0.05599900335073471,
-0.3098515570163727,
-0.8005592823028564,
-0.1710418313741684,
0.2803701162338257,
-0.08002776652574539,
0.4574004113674164,
-0.026064034551382065,
-0.13258793950080872,
-0.4999556541442871,
-0.425997257232666,
0.19189901649951935,
0.41087689995765686,
-0.6235716938972473,
0.5071832537651062,
0.33797746896743774,
-0.26111316680908203,
-0.6932964324951172,
-0.47611233592033386,
0.006078772712498903,
-0.46005120873451233,
-0.14719174802303314,
0.13683199882507324,
-0.5422705411911011,
-0.3144848942756653,
-0.06940340250730515,
-0.06114876642823219,
0.007226417772471905,
0.5107867121696472,
0.20919550955295563,
0.25344550609588623,
0.10908812284469604,
0.4346182942390442,
-0.0010953741148114204,
0.04828604310750961,
0.3368140757083893,
-0.13964779675006866,
0.44093310832977295,
-0.09050053358078003,
-0.5631309747695923,
-0.3763377070426941,
0.33440282940864563,
0.1730724722146988,
-0.020744461566209793,
0.652754008769989,
0.2959420084953308,
0.1152472198009491,
-0.4448043704032898,
-0.7394520044326782,
-0.47414064407348633,
-0.6503663659095764,
0.11652842909097672,
-0.5524594783782959,
-1.0899018049240112,
0.3538910746574402,
-0.01600136049091816,
0.07304435223340988,
0.3089137077331543,
0.742266833782196,
-0.10552848130464554,
0.9660838842391968,
0.6588096022605896,
-0.00883200392127037,
0.30676230788230896,
-0.10834698379039764,
0.10019972920417786,
-0.7537521719932556,
-0.22085008025169373,
-0.417648047208786,
0.05536551773548126,
-0.6794523000717163,
-0.32072046399116516,
0.3281061351299286,
-0.011625914834439754,
-0.16739124059677124,
-0.0024689948186278343,
-0.9620445966720581,
0.44308894872665405,
0.5562878251075745,
-0.02561221644282341,
0.1542568802833557,
-0.09240265935659409,
-0.20892690122127533,
-0.20534947514533997,
-0.45139646530151367,
-0.42158186435699463,
1.0240833759307861,
0.5177896022796631,
1.4991928339004517,
0.030242253094911575,
1.1044037342071533,
0.1889728307723999,
0.4439798593521118,
-0.9561713933944702,
0.6303204894065857,
0.3024402856826782,
-0.5188778042793274,
-0.44514042139053345,
-0.5058037638664246,
-0.9126467704772949,
0.35978826880455017,
0.06536878645420074,
-0.8163070678710938,
0.15263938903808594,
0.2787364721298218,
-0.5037094354629517,
0.10100121796131134,
-0.5006132125854492,
0.46467939019203186,
-0.8064358830451965,
-0.7806637287139893,
-0.29080730676651,
-0.4231530427932739,
0.4672635495662689,
-0.2321499139070511,
0.059229642152786255,
-0.19575011730194092,
0.05391452834010124,
0.6963202953338623,
-0.04840685799717903,
0.9716938138008118,
-0.2582383453845978,
-0.31705325841903687,
0.6093699932098389,
0.6849638819694519,
0.2717920243740082,
-0.1740397810935974,
-0.08526691794395447,
-0.3997357487678528,
-0.019923998042941093,
-0.1433311551809311,
-0.4554305076599121,
0.5986254811286926,
-0.6315351724624634,
-1.2160403728485107,
-0.4243069589138031,
-0.526113748550415,
-0.10021159052848816,
0.15306714177131653,
0.355363130569458,
0.044677119702100754,
-0.36433082818984985,
0.0504663847386837,
0.86246657371521,
-0.19289110600948334,
0.8094300031661987,
0.887427806854248,
-0.640949010848999,
-0.39633384346961975,
0.8774920105934143,
0.4284473955631256,
0.25372380018234253,
0.0838986188173294,
0.591099202632904,
-0.627750813961029,
-0.6250544786453247,
-0.049079637974500656,
0.26988741755485535,
-0.7446157336235046,
-0.23323418200016022,
-0.6061891913414001,
-0.35405242443084717,
-0.4097849428653717,
-0.1929243803024292,
-0.5156952738761902,
-0.42944398522377014,
-0.42371895909309387,
-0.3462062180042267,
0.2600768506526947,
1.0900720357894897,
-0.4409414231777191,
0.24343985319137573,
-0.5192620158195496,
0.024994663894176483,
0.496148020029068,
0.20662640035152435,
0.10181282460689545,
-0.8161937594413757,
-0.19203738868236542,
-0.47742506861686707,
-0.7188300490379333,
-0.7783976197242737,
0.7633599042892456,
0.09934595972299576,
0.6742526292800903,
0.6016857624053955,
0.516289234161377,
0.48813995718955994,
-0.39835068583488464,
0.530918300151825,
0.07907062768936157,
-0.9433650970458984,
0.6416935324668884,
-0.23385007679462433,
0.015239418484270573,
0.674139678478241,
0.5730164051055908,
-0.20627520978450775,
-0.3222261965274811,
-0.3470030426979065,
-0.6792370676994324,
0.49493080377578735,
-0.15191829204559326,
0.430881530046463,
-0.18748140335083008,
0.5468226671218872,
0.15992292761802673,
0.17539171874523163,
-1.2318559885025024,
0.06969305127859116,
-0.4336335062980652,
-0.11185905337333679,
0.07329709082841873,
-0.5706685781478882,
-0.5726991295814514,
-0.37974923849105835,
0.6366639733314514,
-0.45228174328804016,
0.2948712706565857,
0.46329739689826965,
-0.26869311928749084,
-0.0036889619659632444,
0.2883075773715973,
0.6637869477272034,
0.44054731726646423,
-0.15403668582439423,
0.48356470465660095,
0.303350031375885,
-0.10133820027112961,
0.4240296185016632,
-0.25194257497787476,
-0.1490079015493393,
-0.34961041808128357,
0.07119812071323395,
0.6263854503631592,
-0.05747522413730621,
-0.5241740345954895,
0.4360634982585907,
0.0231198500841856,
-0.3795825242996216,
-0.47567257285118103,
0.19363126158714294,
-0.018854385241866112,
0.07886113971471786,
0.2055538147687912,
-0.5499866604804993,
0.20194312930107117,
-0.4293960928916931,
0.40282636880874634,
0.5416574478149414,
-0.29725971817970276,
-0.21984216570854187,
0.5035063028335571,
0.11482492089271545,
-0.2294176071882248,
0.4356659948825836,
-0.4191392660140991,
-0.45858046412467957,
0.3218235969543457,
0.9786062240600586,
1.0559813976287842,
-0.8218162655830383,
0.4014994204044342,
0.4470316767692566,
0.39523348212242126,
-0.17047050595283508,
0.390912264585495,
-0.2583342492580414,
-0.7576971054077148,
-0.35511335730552673,
-0.6620073914527893,
-0.2634170353412628,
0.22435754537582397,
-0.7780080437660217,
-0.1884576678276062,
-0.9421889185905457,
-0.12948916852474213,
-0.4756021499633789,
-0.1388176530599594,
-0.08902890235185623,
0.13752852380275726,
-0.0597059391438961,
0.9659717679023743,
-0.6025885343551636,
0.7898461818695068,
0.10685195028781891,
-0.33296629786491394,
-0.9850351810455322,
0.07343399524688721,
0.03470483422279358,
-0.9203243851661682,
0.5433614253997803,
0.3328023850917816,
-0.4902147352695465,
-0.05381712689995766,
-0.8505899906158447,
-0.9204314947128296,
0.7359294295310974,
0.16843251883983612,
-0.515923023223877,
0.1424054503440857,
-0.07872289419174194,
0.543492317199707,
-0.411853551864624,
-0.061659593135118484,
0.27267417311668396,
0.30380237102508545,
0.1288348138332367,
-0.6528135538101196,
0.1521541178226471,
-0.03144301846623421,
-0.07380077242851257,
-0.03431442379951477,
-0.9100601673126221,
0.8103262186050415,
-0.3968478739261627,
-0.24096278846263885,
0.1468982845544815,
0.5726057291030884,
0.19443988800048828,
0.22359856963157654,
0.44645676016807556,
0.3946225345134735,
0.7296116948127747,
0.2221192866563797,
0.8005293011665344,
-0.35975319147109985,
0.4282078742980957,
1.5396281480789185,
-0.6625921130180359,
0.878078818321228,
0.5904987454414368,
0.27069082856178284,
0.5520194172859192,
0.5684862732887268,
-0.19696252048015594,
0.767320454120636,
0.27348190546035767,
-0.3322170376777649,
-0.4140843152999878,
-0.35616937279701233,
-0.023517068475484848,
0.7689299583435059,
0.5265352725982666,
-0.48308825492858887,
-0.09584222733974457,
0.2266802340745926,
0.17528794705867767,
0.28807780146598816,
-0.21900005638599396,
0.9430625438690186,
0.38655194640159607,
-0.9804906249046326,
0.8222811222076416,
-0.09597558528184891,
0.3215681314468384,
-0.6580570340156555,
0.2659476399421692,
-0.109684519469738,
0.23378562927246094,
0.02396995946764946,
-0.8077849745750427,
0.359008252620697,
-0.1655866801738739,
0.2005118876695633,
-0.4073972702026367,
0.7610556483268738,
-0.30447328090667725,
-0.30692198872566223,
0.6151883602142334,
0.5951479077339172,
0.030434420332312584,
0.18217864632606506,
-0.6544607281684875,
0.0425792895257473,
-0.11365461349487305,
-0.5537123084068298,
0.43675497174263,
0.1321924775838852,
0.07894624769687653,
1.2191088199615479,
0.17749133706092834,
-0.035638224333524704,
0.08749768137931824,
0.04490656405687332,
0.8925829529762268,
-0.7012527585029602,
-0.40284162759780884,
-0.9790542721748352,
0.15587610006332397,
0.002911952091380954,
-0.12154408544301987,
0.9177183508872986,
0.32754021883010864,
0.6853818297386169,
0.01933722384274006,
0.800055980682373,
0.13560804724693298,
0.5934751629829407,
-0.7443180680274963,
0.5191543698310852,
-0.708308219909668,
0.3747839629650116,
-0.011363731697201729,
-0.41177529096603394,
-0.0301411971449852,
0.8237513303756714,
-0.333211749792099,
0.15949708223342896,
0.6516402363777161,
0.9174854159355164,
0.2969346046447754,
-0.2258690744638443,
0.5071649551391602,
0.18305978178977966,
0.13724201917648315,
0.20762157440185547,
1.1874213218688965,
0.21265463531017303,
0.38838115334510803,
-0.5801612138748169,
-0.12350831925868988,
-0.13897089660167694,
-0.7970424890518188,
-1.0306971073150635,
-0.5703330636024475,
-0.11340668797492981,
-0.3161731958389282,
0.03473720699548721,
1.0916361808776855,
0.8567195534706116,
-0.6213255524635315,
-0.6033317446708679,
-0.23915500938892365,
0.0952674150466919,
-0.05659494921565056,
-0.21619774401187897,
0.19035859405994415,
-0.7174102067947388,
-0.45633822679519653,
0.7745494842529297,
0.33299538493156433,
0.3840828239917755,
-0.7234014272689819,
-0.12522423267364502,
-0.20707739889621735,
0.37177354097366333,
0.37398460507392883,
0.5178722739219666,
-0.5076800584793091,
-0.40089139342308044,
0.0787653774023056,
-0.15180571377277374,
0.18765345215797424,
0.8934178352355957,
-0.5902031660079956,
0.6986104846000671,
0.07489809393882751,
0.5281664133071899,
0.5750890970230103,
0.041307177394628525,
0.539940357208252,
-0.8440855741500854,
-0.07043516635894775,
0.3720259964466095,
0.18557995557785034,
0.4123309552669525,
-0.5085782408714294,
0.6273061633110046,
0.037418100982904434,
-0.9361351728439331,
-0.857843816280365,
0.48113247752189636,
-0.5516007542610168,
-0.6734492778778076,
1.0064780712127686,
-0.18661542236804962,
-0.1951199769973755,
-0.24126175045967102,
-0.2628450095653534,
0.19001492857933044,
-0.2457415908575058,
1.511607050895691,
0.42980045080184937,
-0.42855754494667053,
-0.5105172395706177,
-0.3066191077232361,
0.6404101848602295,
0.7290102243423462,
-0.7849540710449219,
0.2610502541065216,
0.14307332038879395,
0.5449350476264954,
0.19644448161125183,
0.7893410921096802,
0.1083693727850914,
-0.05364840105175972,
0.023022929206490517,
0.22824044525623322,
0.12987306714057922,
-0.5840362310409546,
-0.5230010151863098,
0.28917476534843445,
0.5588810443878174,
-0.1332782655954361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09300v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09300v1
|
Comparing the Efficacy of GPT-4 and Chat-GPT in Mental Health Care: A Blind Assessment of Large Language Models for Psychological Support
| 2024-05-15T12:44:54 | 2024-05-15T12:44:54 |
Birger Moell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Background: Rapid advancements in natural language processing have led to the
development of large language models with the potential to revolutionize mental
health care. These models have shown promise in assisting clinicians and
providing support to individuals experiencing various psychological challenges.
Objective: This study aims to compare the performance of two large language
models, GPT-4 and Chat-GPT, in responding to a set of 18 psychological prompts,
to assess their potential applicability in mental health care settings.
Methods: A blind methodology was employed, with a clinical psychologist
evaluating the models' responses without knowledge of their origins. The
prompts encompassed a diverse range of mental health topics, including
depression, anxiety, and trauma, to ensure a comprehensive assessment.
Results: The results demonstrated a significant difference in performance
between the two models (p > 0.05). GPT-4 achieved an average rating of 8.29 out
of 10, while Chat-GPT received an average rating of 6.52. The clinical
psychologist's evaluation suggested that GPT-4 was more effective at generating
clinically relevant and empathetic responses, thereby providing better support
and guidance to potential users.
Conclusions: This study contributes to the growing body of literature on the
applicability of large language models in mental health care settings. The
findings underscore the importance of continued research and development in the
field to optimize these models for clinical use. Further investigation is
necessary to understand the specific factors underlying the performance
differences between the two models and to explore their generalizability across
various populations and mental health conditions.
|
[
-0.2954099476337433,
-0.8328668475151062,
1.020207405090332,
0.5602309107780457,
-0.05705065652728081,
-0.05368293821811676,
-0.39848390221595764,
-0.6919800639152527,
-0.07702229917049408,
0.07795286178588867,
-0.621386706829071,
-0.31024742126464844,
-0.6852144598960876,
0.4657182991504669,
-0.028702260926365852,
0.8257052302360535,
-0.13975217938423157,
0.3019839823246002,
0.281064510345459,
0.28921636939048767,
-1.0025585889816284,
-0.6628458499908447,
-0.8986374735832214,
-0.13591623306274414,
0.3244222104549408,
-0.07164379954338074,
0.770565390586853,
-0.19771866500377655,
0.8918065428733826,
0.2939101755619049,
0.12273374199867249,
-0.25676658749580383,
-0.4851040244102478,
0.07031609117984772,
-0.09131388366222382,
-0.10643740743398666,
-0.5932549834251404,
0.1631556749343872,
0.3571794629096985,
0.46515458822250366,
-0.4019012749195099,
0.027249202132225037,
0.15350787341594696,
0.3346593976020813,
-0.3754001557826996,
0.3750162720680237,
-0.4580005705356598,
0.14798784255981445,
0.11989349126815796,
0.12903721630573273,
-0.27721503376960754,
-0.5814521908760071,
0.4104052186012268,
-0.518080472946167,
0.13980944454669952,
-0.2548442482948303,
0.5808064937591553,
0.09541811048984528,
-0.3571227788925171,
-0.34689778089523315,
-0.7655576467514038,
0.5087398290634155,
-1.0993763208389282,
0.3476475477218628,
0.45641791820526123,
0.35862886905670166,
-0.050242580473423004,
-0.6663177013397217,
-0.5854231715202332,
-0.40865957736968994,
-0.004744048696011305,
0.42334574460983276,
-0.5259702205657959,
0.33081474900245667,
0.5558866262435913,
0.3997964859008789,
-0.8072896599769592,
0.05549440160393715,
-0.315044105052948,
-0.2770828902721405,
0.41619324684143066,
0.2864580750465393,
0.2633192837238312,
-0.04552455246448517,
-0.08188242465257645,
0.20395785570144653,
-0.08880145847797394,
-0.1650131195783615,
-0.0571015290915966,
0.14088112115859985,
-0.19018641114234924,
0.6292186975479126,
-0.10288497805595398,
0.34253448247909546,
-0.016800811514258385,
-0.4773311913013458,
0.06683813035488129,
-0.2756204605102539,
-0.3537484109401703,
-0.2775590121746063,
1.0278087854385376,
0.6624075174331665,
0.34865331649780273,
-0.3011306822299957,
-0.038306884467601776,
0.3594492971897125,
0.2600165903568268,
-0.7643530964851379,
-0.18712346255779266,
0.11666800826787949,
-0.5268253684043884,
0.2114664614200592,
-0.5370675325393677,
-0.7628099322319031,
-0.5578659176826477,
-0.2113519012928009,
0.361205518245697,
-0.5653804540634155,
-0.5379921197891235,
0.25342464447021484,
-0.04998690262436867,
0.31706753373146057,
0.597162127494812,
-0.7078232765197754,
0.5294790267944336,
0.46623241901397705,
1.1811846494674683,
-0.2585565447807312,
0.02835998497903347,
-0.1877758949995041,
-0.18687595427036285,
-0.316778302192688,
0.5373180508613586,
-0.4849886894226074,
-0.34553271532058716,
0.18271636962890625,
-0.0749715119600296,
-0.3739040791988373,
-0.21152862906455994,
0.7930675745010376,
-0.1468232125043869,
0.4726608991622925,
-0.48291143774986267,
-0.5247656106948853,
-0.02504916489124298,
0.38844677805900574,
-0.5724326968193054,
0.6250414252281189,
0.4224959909915924,
-0.8405364155769348,
0.17088386416435242,
-0.7364482879638672,
-0.17766514420509338,
0.32589271664619446,
-0.2856401205062866,
-0.1011095643043518,
0.04050499200820923,
0.1750398725271225,
0.5417301058769226,
-0.5141490697860718,
0.103559210896492,
-0.5539373755455017,
-0.4607017934322357,
0.4301093518733978,
-0.6451712250709534,
0.4015538990497589,
0.046878304332494736,
-0.5016146302223206,
-0.08672201633453369,
-0.37462562322616577,
0.105851911008358,
0.3013373017311096,
-0.27155500650405884,
-0.18362019956111908,
-0.27711841464042664,
0.18836097419261932,
0.5571280121803284,
0.00854918546974659,
-0.5418972373008728,
-0.04237152636051178,
-0.3536369502544403,
0.39102229475975037,
0.4227278530597687,
0.1463613212108612,
-0.184550479054451,
-0.1680763065814972,
0.8101273775100708,
-0.3236564099788666,
0.3736381530761719,
0.022678636014461517,
-0.9394168257713318,
0.00032940515666268766,
-0.5242984294891357,
0.11459843069314957,
0.5921281576156616,
-0.6590826511383057,
0.1737050712108612,
-0.0001114149927161634,
-0.3712928593158722,
-0.6055120229721069,
-0.356035441160202,
0.37671732902526855,
0.5189513564109802,
0.39771774411201477,
-0.34241172671318054,
-0.2812109589576721,
-0.8793460130691528,
-0.2381739318370819,
-0.1014675498008728,
-0.05314503237605095,
0.45150434970855713,
0.36465734243392944,
-0.3301786780357361,
0.48612746596336365,
-0.36687642335891724,
-0.332101047039032,
-0.2622821033000946,
-0.024065056815743446,
0.07569416612386703,
0.11587189882993698,
0.5898591876029968,
-0.4111047685146332,
-0.667685329914093,
0.009677018038928509,
-0.7731304168701172,
-0.10105110704898834,
0.29658788442611694,
0.036973562091588974,
0.2359931617975235,
-0.16320982575416565,
-0.790067195892334,
0.574495255947113,
0.7933167815208435,
-0.5054008960723877,
0.6486797332763672,
-0.2500828802585602,
0.4320698082447052,
-0.7498614192008972,
0.10805846750736237,
-0.11258428543806076,
-0.18652422726154327,
-0.8213781714439392,
-0.31115853786468506,
0.022843625396490097,
-0.3289039433002472,
-0.2407779097557068,
0.2901535928249359,
-0.45177850127220154,
0.12258467078208923,
-0.24567502737045288,
0.24058251082897186,
-0.2636343836784363,
0.5375469326972961,
-0.0713849663734436,
0.7330971360206604,
0.5752174258232117,
-0.07829464226961136,
0.3679463863372803,
0.21353088319301605,
-0.16921848058700562,
0.6335264444351196,
-0.7761096954345703,
0.18624946475028992,
0.3215751051902771,
0.3987744152545929,
-1.1954045295715332,
-0.21080395579338074,
0.41123002767562866,
-0.2992219030857086,
0.14281059801578522,
0.1932581514120102,
-0.4223255515098572,
-0.6067585349082947,
-0.10593222826719284,
0.22446510195732117,
0.511699378490448,
0.19523675739765167,
0.24135851860046387,
0.14431241154670715,
-0.567013144493103,
-0.2841407358646393,
-0.5598028302192688,
0.1767054796218872,
-0.39169323444366455,
-0.40458667278289795,
0.10190404951572418,
-0.21510809659957886,
-0.21599268913269043,
-0.2326844036579132,
-0.12659023702144623,
-0.06463801115751266,
-0.015103359706699848,
0.2066667526960373,
0.28021419048309326,
-0.25766226649284363,
0.2165650874376297,
-0.17669017612934113,
0.03481690585613251,
0.24170251190662384,
0.05341048911213875,
0.6200859546661377,
-0.3580681383609772,
-0.4775345027446747,
-0.6857129335403442,
0.660283625125885,
0.7315187454223633,
-0.2628806531429291,
0.9451706409454346,
0.5291959047317505,
-0.5160526633262634,
0.44142401218414307,
-0.9330792427062988,
-0.2158801108598709,
-0.3549935221672058,
0.24292464554309845,
-0.34634914994239807,
-1.005115270614624,
0.4506463408470154,
0.20474714040756226,
-0.13286982476711273,
0.29088470339775085,
0.7574841976165771,
0.14807617664337158,
1.3199337720870972,
0.5074703097343445,
-0.06028546392917633,
0.3161976933479309,
0.0032046479173004627,
0.47575968503952026,
-0.7186543345451355,
0.10297968983650208,
-0.3518664538860321,
-0.06988845765590668,
-0.6589641571044922,
-0.3737559914588928,
0.3354571759700775,
-0.17434310913085938,
-0.3596583604812622,
-0.08289162069559097,
-0.5361356735229492,
-0.22638435661792755,
-0.08042392879724503,
0.27990958094596863,
0.41299188137054443,
-0.14981529116630554,
-0.16456353664398193,
-0.36545491218566895,
-0.5001832842826843,
-0.55438631772995,
0.9935035109519958,
0.6584092378616333,
0.5791860818862915,
0.4042147397994995,
0.20923064649105072,
0.1157035306096077,
0.5518511533737183,
-0.776367723941803,
0.3342013657093048,
0.19469794631004333,
-0.7253618240356445,
-0.39469948410987854,
-0.4824827313423157,
-1.0085011720657349,
0.48230692744255066,
-0.192989319562912,
-1.0757391452789307,
-0.014986521564424038,
-0.151627779006958,
-0.4175649881362915,
-0.07017286121845245,
-1.1497724056243896,
0.8703643083572388,
-0.30482470989227295,
-0.03735295683145523,
-0.1057557612657547,
-0.4925837814807892,
0.5558804869651794,
-0.5990453362464905,
0.1569042056798935,
-0.3257395029067993,
0.016947297379374504,
0.6729371547698975,
-0.14708459377288818,
0.6366267800331116,
-0.22175800800323486,
-0.25368595123291016,
-0.05947203189134598,
-0.07147286832332611,
0.37300950288772583,
0.23872138559818268,
-0.2144087851047516,
0.18424482643604279,
0.34749770164489746,
-0.1880502849817276,
-0.7315952777862549,
0.7277839779853821,
-0.9734377264976501,
-0.7880793213844299,
-0.37977099418640137,
-0.5132755041122437,
-0.586575448513031,
0.3594053089618683,
0.1354072093963623,
0.561025857925415,
-0.2966873049736023,
-0.01266782358288765,
0.46797290444374084,
-0.4179655909538269,
0.2563551962375641,
0.9537432789802551,
-0.42521363496780396,
-0.3453739583492279,
0.20013242959976196,
0.13368277251720428,
0.33919933438301086,
0.03344077244400978,
0.2278638333082199,
-0.3423354923725128,
-0.3849702775478363,
-0.03904014453291893,
0.7202996015548706,
-0.4111330807209015,
-0.07604949921369553,
-0.7289131283760071,
-0.31741857528686523,
-0.7558847069740295,
0.08532344549894333,
-0.28809118270874023,
-0.1451936513185501,
0.3188871741294861,
-0.09819100797176361,
0.5328525900840759,
0.6754040718078613,
0.20623332262039185,
0.10116621106863022,
-0.49243175983428955,
0.1769183874130249,
0.15145787596702576,
0.6258620619773865,
0.07537876814603806,
-0.24603141844272614,
-0.13282416760921478,
0.1160866990685463,
-0.42236512899398804,
-1.5322332382202148,
0.31380754709243774,
-0.05357494577765465,
0.5273430347442627,
0.35257434844970703,
0.06823400408029556,
0.8024089932441711,
-0.620861291885376,
0.8212352991104126,
0.45470699667930603,
-0.8298876285552979,
0.472768634557724,
-0.6314128041267395,
0.4229779541492462,
0.37575238943099976,
0.6251158714294434,
-0.6953498125076294,
-0.5726726055145264,
-0.6549682021141052,
-0.6305148601531982,
0.7055606245994568,
0.671743631362915,
-0.11338920146226883,
-0.10275308042764664,
0.34714800119400024,
-0.02605523355305195,
0.255281925201416,
-0.7134485244750977,
-0.16250360012054443,
-0.15817663073539734,
-0.10726480931043625,
-0.2324182689189911,
-0.20517846941947937,
-0.3425810635089874,
0.02125725708901882,
0.30320417881011963,
-0.040793150663375854,
0.9766682982444763,
0.3735710382461548,
0.35399603843688965,
-0.24768215417861938,
0.46351727843284607,
0.3608430027961731,
0.8627117872238159,
-0.23063243925571442,
-0.11184773594141006,
0.31415557861328125,
-0.7945225238800049,
-0.067173071205616,
0.46745243668556213,
0.24840156733989716,
0.16164341568946838,
0.37945204973220825,
0.930327832698822,
0.2868521809577942,
-0.601821780204773,
0.6773607730865479,
-0.4787635803222656,
-0.38242587447166443,
-0.16674663126468658,
-0.08642284572124481,
0.11454486101865768,
0.4129285216331482,
0.06383112818002701,
-0.3639637529850006,
0.29423680901527405,
-0.5647094249725342,
-0.14362579584121704,
0.45118629932403564,
-0.3180992603302002,
-0.37206363677978516,
0.4856768250465393,
-0.14486253261566162,
-0.48602765798568726,
0.6549125909805298,
-0.017054634168744087,
-0.326848566532135,
0.23499269783496857,
0.8210964798927307,
0.7072209715843201,
-0.33927828073501587,
0.32392963767051697,
0.2687835693359375,
0.3565824627876282,
-0.1377377212047577,
0.3242960572242737,
0.045235972851514816,
-0.5787728428840637,
-0.42524227499961853,
-0.30339810252189636,
-0.511458158493042,
0.6362686157226562,
-0.8020818829536438,
-0.14486142992973328,
-0.26646387577056885,
-0.7039719223976135,
-0.16310523450374603,
0.32830262184143066,
-1.0759950876235962,
0.16441267728805542,
0.23858176171779633,
0.9187614917755127,
-0.757938027381897,
0.5814322233200073,
0.8411020040512085,
-0.5507150292396545,
-1.317992091178894,
0.3264392018318176,
0.07680109143257141,
-0.5370254516601562,
0.01595613919198513,
0.20384132862091064,
0.10681533068418503,
-0.059441354125738144,
-0.21451355516910553,
-1.006541132926941,
1.1462050676345825,
0.5189751386642456,
-0.32977914810180664,
-0.0874117761850357,
0.07284465432167053,
0.9679750204086304,
-0.17384134232997894,
0.7365879416465759,
0.6267579793930054,
0.648284375667572,
0.03775506466627121,
-1.5200384855270386,
0.19135811924934387,
-0.1749306321144104,
0.10817650705575943,
-0.10305029898881912,
-0.657537043094635,
0.5564355850219727,
0.09215530008077621,
-0.3959372937679291,
0.19940246641635895,
0.19060325622558594,
0.6137496829032898,
0.27861499786376953,
0.3353811204433441,
0.16313888132572174,
0.9536343216896057,
-0.0819987952709198,
1.0930172204971313,
-0.2021525651216507,
0.4248151481151581,
0.8546103239059448,
-0.7575085759162903,
0.7463560104370117,
0.15048165619373322,
-0.4393530488014221,
0.26264479756355286,
0.4580116271972656,
0.20249827206134796,
0.42441385984420776,
-0.019507182762026787,
-0.31577035784721375,
0.17859500646591187,
0.10127463936805725,
-0.56158447265625,
0.06280514597892761,
0.41213372349739075,
-0.16410456597805023,
-0.23872441053390503,
0.3408101201057434,
0.23811350762844086,
-0.24837471544742584,
-0.1855233907699585,
0.5829075574874878,
0.3077337443828583,
-0.7599977850914001,
0.6794390678405762,
0.06676322221755981,
0.3245885372161865,
-0.7575368881225586,
0.03238545358181,
-0.2849462032318115,
0.3068467378616333,
0.00789103377610445,
-0.7185940742492676,
0.2067674994468689,
0.38849374651908875,
-0.06852766126394272,
-0.18258534371852875,
0.8395191431045532,
-0.10394465178251266,
-0.41823408007621765,
0.46973180770874023,
0.6879006028175354,
0.39236560463905334,
-0.24784758687019348,
-0.9470390677452087,
-0.05473434925079346,
-0.13656620681285858,
-0.3543025553226471,
0.4451315104961395,
0.7317897081375122,
-0.22578027844429016,
0.6325384378433228,
0.3772549033164978,
0.2795148193836212,
-0.009225372225046158,
0.1565665751695633,
0.7784537076950073,
-0.5651591420173645,
-0.4358697831630707,
-0.6784197688102722,
0.13336922228336334,
0.06734942644834518,
-0.3072787821292877,
0.9857804775238037,
0.2084062397480011,
0.2311040163040161,
-0.14891986548900604,
0.9426751732826233,
-0.07488729804754257,
0.6913021802902222,
-0.2532695233821869,
0.5474327802658081,
-0.22428089380264282,
0.018920719623565674,
-0.6270202994346619,
-0.9138551950454712,
-0.3111618459224701,
0.8041861057281494,
-0.8798445463180542,
0.37838977575302124,
1.0750401020050049,
0.6543443202972412,
0.19819548726081848,
0.25152209401130676,
0.5422162413597107,
0.528979480266571,
0.5315746068954468,
0.7708930969238281,
1.0171433687210083,
-0.12655290961265564,
0.19866734743118286,
-0.007923489436507225,
-0.4491218626499176,
0.09267941862344742,
-0.5751198530197144,
-0.9606178998947144,
-0.2912750542163849,
-0.08997968584299088,
-0.11204427480697632,
0.27429553866386414,
0.7247597575187683,
0.3082316219806671,
-0.47803837060928345,
0.0634702667593956,
0.2913776934146881,
-0.4264707565307617,
-0.4308423697948456,
-0.20194074511528015,
0.39922019839286804,
-0.016034888103604317,
-0.2690819203853607,
0.22366581857204437,
0.29174983501434326,
-0.059946589171886444,
-0.38282454013824463,
0.02447095327079296,
-0.03742111474275589,
0.08942306786775589,
0.63314288854599,
-0.030952846631407738,
-0.886152982711792,
-0.18231484293937683,
0.13582903146743774,
-0.355741947889328,
-0.01738806813955307,
0.657560408115387,
-0.6142403483390808,
0.3055143356323242,
0.1901678740978241,
0.4368492066860199,
0.3970027267932892,
-0.014336849562823772,
0.6849185228347778,
-0.08473615348339081,
-0.15347552299499512,
0.15902958810329437,
0.3771713078022003,
0.4251631200313568,
-0.5752480030059814,
0.5539219975471497,
0.20228083431720734,
-0.7405075430870056,
-0.6320656538009644,
-0.010736766271293163,
-0.9590479731559753,
-0.05709587037563324,
1.2954362630844116,
-0.5513505339622498,
0.3008805513381958,
-0.30250805616378784,
-0.6341863870620728,
0.3347846567630768,
-0.4839531183242798,
0.857482373714447,
0.915123462677002,
-0.33067312836647034,
-0.2740110456943512,
-1.1143100261688232,
0.3825512230396271,
0.17768144607543945,
-0.680349588394165,
-0.09541390836238861,
0.55720454454422,
0.37172409892082214,
-0.18097451329231262,
1.048332929611206,
-0.2593185007572174,
0.32478582859039307,
-0.3423619866371155,
-0.0028833395335823298,
0.2825949490070343,
0.307415246963501,
-0.42457953095436096,
0.14725598692893982,
-0.002843645168468356,
0.24634672701358795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13021v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13021v1
|
IM-RAG: Multi-Round Retrieval-Augmented Generation Through Learning Inner Monologues
| 2024-05-15T12:41:20 | 2024-05-15T12:41:20 |
Diji Yang, Jinmeng Rao, Kezhen Chen, Xiaoyuan Guo, Yawen Zhang, Jie Yang, Yi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Although the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) paradigms can use external
knowledge to enhance and ground the outputs of Large Language Models (LLMs) to
mitigate generative hallucinations and static knowledge base problems, they
still suffer from limited flexibility in adopting Information Retrieval (IR)
systems with varying capabilities, constrained interpretability during the
multi-round retrieval process, and a lack of end-to-end optimization. To
address these challenges, we propose a novel LLM-centric approach, IM-RAG, that
integrates IR systems with LLMs to support multi-round RAG through learning
Inner Monologues (IM, i.e., the human inner voice that narrates one's
thoughts). During the IM process, the LLM serves as the core reasoning model
(i.e., Reasoner) to either propose queries to collect more information via the
Retriever or to provide a final answer based on the conversational context. We
also introduce a Refiner that improves the outputs from the Retriever,
effectively bridging the gap between the Reasoner and IR modules with varying
capabilities and fostering multi-round communications. The entire IM process is
optimized via Reinforcement Learning (RL) where a Progress Tracker is
incorporated to provide mid-step rewards, and the answer prediction is further
separately optimized via Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT). We conduct extensive
experiments with the HotPotQA dataset, a popular benchmark for retrieval-based,
multi-step question-answering. The results show that our approach achieves
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance while providing high flexibility in
integrating IR modules as well as strong interpretability exhibited in the
learned inner monologues.
|
[
-0.7143604755401611,
-0.6593928337097168,
0.360746294260025,
-0.13619926571846008,
-0.2927977740764618,
0.3492644131183624,
-0.3731319010257721,
-0.4047171175479889,
0.46233585476875305,
0.6661477088928223,
-0.7351449728012085,
-0.11313492059707642,
-0.28596723079681396,
0.16422198712825775,
-0.16229674220085144,
1.2097783088684082,
0.24787217378616333,
0.024099919945001602,
-0.32355010509490967,
-0.12861429154872894,
-0.3439345359802246,
-0.5462584495544434,
-0.695537269115448,
-0.5155161619186401,
0.754510223865509,
0.8016813397407532,
0.16580922901630402,
0.15387539565563202,
0.2387237697839737,
0.3292332589626312,
0.17115581035614014,
0.6878727078437805,
-0.619717001914978,
0.5466349720954895,
-0.294389545917511,
-0.4875941872596741,
-0.024886220693588257,
-0.09830351918935776,
0.5085806250572205,
0.1636177897453308,
-0.3473051190376282,
0.46352311968803406,
-0.02730020321905613,
0.9133343696594238,
-0.5824754238128662,
0.030956527218222618,
-0.9262263178825378,
0.04782313108444214,
-0.3149764835834503,
-0.4624500572681427,
-0.5945059657096863,
-0.19368992745876312,
0.029115770012140274,
-0.4828523099422455,
-0.07769597321748734,
0.3566846549510956,
0.6218750476837158,
0.4240902364253998,
-0.21496202051639557,
-0.6430150270462036,
-0.666718602180481,
0.6692460775375366,
-0.6265060305595398,
0.11500802636146545,
0.14516915380954742,
0.5206160545349121,
-0.22544240951538086,
-0.600470244884491,
-0.673931896686554,
-0.32531434297561646,
-0.22889213263988495,
0.20706193149089813,
0.1395268589258194,
-0.09465673565864563,
0.06110726296901703,
0.4430248439311981,
-0.38993245363235474,
-0.14729925990104675,
-0.5256415605545044,
0.05247102677822113,
0.3747711479663849,
0.09181350469589233,
-0.03707663342356682,
-0.2764701843261719,
-0.5078223347663879,
0.11906809359788895,
-0.3266778290271759,
0.05842846632003784,
0.2604224681854248,
0.5188701748847961,
0.306718647480011,
0.6868668794631958,
-0.2354239821434021,
0.443340003490448,
0.21447661519050598,
-0.3242351710796356,
0.016968902200460434,
-0.09315324574708939,
-0.04388599842786789,
0.13591104745864868,
0.6311284899711609,
-0.17225106060504913,
0.18925154209136963,
-0.19735907018184662,
-0.2931995987892151,
-0.15508683025836945,
0.6719098687171936,
-0.7232871055603027,
-0.09209777414798737,
0.08682311326265335,
-0.2354329377412796,
-0.3123151957988739,
-0.018806282430887222,
-0.9176300764083862,
-0.4726410210132599,
-0.6186516284942627,
0.6251735687255859,
-0.5449161529541016,
-0.3492150604724884,
0.01685236766934395,
-0.04961051791906357,
0.2203846126794815,
0.2271045744419098,
-0.4933170676231384,
0.32841646671295166,
0.4546326696872711,
0.5354574918746948,
-0.009395726025104523,
-0.1403607875108719,
-0.6826591491699219,
0.006142328958958387,
-0.0976916179060936,
0.9394795298576355,
-0.46016281843185425,
-0.09651277214288712,
-0.25085747241973877,
-0.3703666627407074,
-0.055677056312561035,
-0.6903330683708191,
0.35289251804351807,
-0.5872719883918762,
0.41166260838508606,
0.011714898981153965,
-0.3819780647754669,
-0.24941737949848175,
0.4471661150455475,
-0.35610514879226685,
1.0135828256607056,
-0.012373327277600765,
-0.8307031393051147,
0.022949006408452988,
-0.677255392074585,
-0.24595285952091217,
0.009245221503078938,
-0.33083873987197876,
-0.3731953501701355,
0.2629719078540802,
0.13371098041534424,
0.15525926649570465,
-0.5885569453239441,
0.04839600622653961,
-0.023525021970272064,
-0.25221943855285645,
0.2625604569911957,
-0.24960380792617798,
0.3311447501182556,
0.36568397283554077,
-0.2582831084728241,
0.1229114979505539,
-0.7401598691940308,
0.29257431626319885,
0.2061346471309662,
-0.3624620735645294,
-0.2272954136133194,
-0.13673892617225647,
-0.4255826473236084,
0.283840537071228,
0.20108622312545776,
-0.4962478578090668,
0.3229581117630005,
-0.1979299932718277,
-0.08105484396219254,
0.826274573802948,
-0.057381320744752884,
0.2769051194190979,
-0.5819949507713318,
0.6094077229499817,
0.17009420692920685,
0.014046899974346161,
-0.4756160378456116,
-0.1712503284215927,
-0.9939783811569214,
-0.2692217528820038,
0.09952650964260101,
0.6042397022247314,
-1.0664341449737549,
0.00028395268600434065,
-0.04705283045768738,
-0.5445279479026794,
-0.870214581489563,
0.12020693719387054,
0.7321441769599915,
0.5707694292068481,
0.5122929215431213,
-0.1998298019170761,
-0.6321880221366882,
-0.7376049160957336,
-0.3159560561180115,
-0.07366453111171722,
0.21959321200847626,
0.44381779432296753,
0.223543182015419,
-0.06296563893556595,
0.7393724918365479,
-0.3329322040081024,
-0.4863157272338867,
-0.4179249703884125,
0.3827041983604431,
0.42458799481391907,
0.23291662335395813,
-0.020323047414422035,
-0.8285459876060486,
-0.498016893863678,
0.07423572987318039,
-0.7520734071731567,
-0.15647709369659424,
-0.06342752277851105,
-0.21314091980457306,
0.20409102737903595,
0.5994957685470581,
-0.4999563694000244,
0.30962708592414856,
0.30131107568740845,
-0.2052285522222519,
0.9569523334503174,
-0.22611039876937866,
0.17563818395137787,
-1.0899614095687866,
-0.00010001403279602528,
-0.24068070948123932,
-0.08275128155946732,
-0.45610153675079346,
0.11663977056741714,
-0.23560947179794312,
0.08277611434459686,
-0.27416089177131653,
0.5856860876083374,
-0.5847715735435486,
0.01765132136642933,
-0.3655399680137634,
0.234122633934021,
-0.01577533408999443,
0.7603889107704163,
-0.4088802635669708,
0.9534000158309937,
0.1387466937303543,
-0.6930875182151794,
0.20686191320419312,
0.15158799290657043,
-0.28500521183013916,
0.6430596113204956,
-0.2027902901172638,
0.40044453740119934,
-0.5992295742034912,
0.16002224385738373,
-0.7714951038360596,
-0.20686666667461395,
0.0175311416387558,
-0.6448901295661926,
0.5470616221427917,
-0.1431201547384262,
-0.4658999741077423,
-0.21737156808376312,
-0.12664924561977386,
0.2682173550128937,
0.2818610966205597,
-0.620728611946106,
0.7708144783973694,
0.550451934337616,
-0.17233629524707794,
-0.8135830163955688,
-0.13309457898139954,
0.09342078864574432,
-0.2806420624256134,
-0.5335444808006287,
0.027097754180431366,
-0.22461766004562378,
-0.2710482180118561,
-0.1993066966533661,
-0.2256741225719452,
0.18989235162734985,
-0.12095233052968979,
0.03122883290052414,
0.02168145217001438,
-0.25943803787231445,
0.31083646416664124,
-0.02367912046611309,
-0.2582797408103943,
-0.10187657922506332,
-0.38589775562286377,
0.6580430269241333,
-0.2535542845726013,
-0.24620917439460754,
0.1140042394399643,
0.3912028670310974,
0.7140930891036987,
-0.4875622093677521,
0.7131779193878174,
0.5778136253356934,
-0.04715626314282417,
-0.5539100170135498,
-0.8314235210418701,
-0.3438732326030731,
-0.4388899505138397,
0.036970485001802444,
-0.6629214286804199,
-0.9688583612442017,
0.3483199179172516,
-0.3590702414512634,
0.17918699979782104,
0.0781148225069046,
0.43975794315338135,
-0.2830890417098999,
0.8074265122413635,
0.4699871838092804,
0.16474223136901855,
0.41458842158317566,
-0.18103624880313873,
0.28624236583709717,
-1.1451624631881714,
-0.2867465317249298,
-0.4269399344921112,
-0.29483717679977417,
-0.44868743419647217,
-0.5347400903701782,
0.7481041550636292,
0.23423293232917786,
-0.3175412118434906,
-0.07498622685670853,
-0.6595578193664551,
0.5402283072471619,
0.6960015892982483,
0.18671640753746033,
0.41733506321907043,
-0.07295369356870651,
-0.5507598519325256,
-0.08508528769016266,
-0.6436293721199036,
-0.4432083070278168,
0.8440064191818237,
0.03469983860850334,
0.8707536458969116,
0.08835992217063904,
0.8022650480270386,
0.08856642246246338,
0.4148983657360077,
-0.6257591843605042,
0.6155713200569153,
-0.2637176215648651,
-0.611596405506134,
-0.2860254645347595,
-0.4547998905181885,
-0.6475726366043091,
0.7586448192596436,
-0.3327200412750244,
-0.6897480487823486,
-0.185042142868042,
0.03482304513454437,
-0.13618655502796173,
0.4784844219684601,
-0.5270086526870728,
0.5265510678291321,
-0.3066934049129486,
-0.3214499354362488,
-0.2245495766401291,
-0.6449388861656189,
0.49489977955818176,
-0.047658976167440414,
0.4208477735519409,
-0.15644891560077667,
0.2491072714328766,
0.3029891550540924,
-0.10384292900562286,
0.5523741245269775,
-0.21261346340179443,
0.1224697083234787,
0.30763372778892517,
0.07967063784599304,
0.49026334285736084,
0.043925940990448,
-0.23046772181987762,
-0.23447757959365845,
-0.2165030539035797,
-0.06143782287836075,
-0.6132427453994751,
0.4951722323894501,
-0.5350764989852905,
-0.7317197918891907,
-0.35432299971580505,
-0.5376102328300476,
-0.24992609024047852,
0.312163770198822,
0.18674339354038239,
0.43008628487586975,
-0.019210107624530792,
0.25714370608329773,
0.8535435199737549,
-0.30444762110710144,
0.01989997737109661,
0.5684448480606079,
-0.7023442387580872,
-0.5499966740608215,
0.9151713252067566,
0.02285981923341751,
0.28180834650993347,
0.4656476378440857,
0.43633338809013367,
-0.07610972970724106,
-0.28835272789001465,
-0.435129314661026,
0.3766994774341583,
-0.6902194023132324,
-0.4725894033908844,
-0.8961334824562073,
-0.4251680374145508,
-0.16922351717948914,
0.08508912473917007,
-0.3618394732475281,
-0.2961943447589874,
-0.03898095712065697,
0.05386572331190109,
0.22832730412483215,
0.7075731158256531,
-0.13516944646835327,
0.010766234248876572,
-0.649152934551239,
0.6497507691383362,
0.35739776492118835,
0.23064963519573212,
0.0334143191576004,
-0.5676015019416809,
-0.5179358720779419,
0.021205509081482887,
-0.31028226017951965,
-0.645757794380188,
0.34684237837791443,
0.07996117323637009,
0.4190308749675751,
0.05961117520928383,
0.28739821910858154,
0.9194989204406738,
-0.6909968256950378,
0.3886544108390808,
0.06374198943376541,
-0.6196144819259644,
0.49121204018592834,
-0.10554509609937668,
0.46765702962875366,
0.7406132221221924,
0.04079414904117584,
-0.46299514174461365,
-0.7769729495048523,
-0.34096625447273254,
-0.9087812900543213,
0.7520934343338013,
-0.06651121377944946,
-0.0779634416103363,
-0.12362615764141083,
0.35660451650619507,
0.24526774883270264,
0.35189178586006165,
-0.7194259762763977,
-0.24179503321647644,
0.018129147589206696,
0.017614422366023064,
0.10654271394014359,
-0.19063954055309296,
-0.03367646411061287,
-0.21776756644248962,
1.008031964302063,
-0.4805365800857544,
0.35971882939338684,
0.29789069294929504,
-0.05084807053208351,
-0.2749859392642975,
0.4460048973560333,
0.40207356214523315,
0.4763275384902954,
-0.13245229423046112,
0.15552489459514618,
0.09151557087898254,
-0.1730724275112152,
0.014318074099719524,
0.02123568020761013,
0.047816112637519836,
0.05766911059617996,
-0.15088658034801483,
0.6785818338394165,
0.2422810047864914,
-0.6777209043502808,
0.10958671569824219,
-0.1916629821062088,
0.07270429283380508,
-0.7030261754989624,
0.058189284056425095,
0.06853475421667099,
0.6175848245620728,
0.6684421896934509,
0.024347243830561638,
0.17974328994750977,
-0.5045871138572693,
0.38397684693336487,
0.6169649362564087,
-0.27520114183425903,
0.0636383518576622,
0.47184863686561584,
-0.18723717331886292,
-0.31243953108787537,
0.5977991819381714,
-0.26487430930137634,
-0.5372099280357361,
0.4399997293949127,
0.495109885931015,
0.9754244685173035,
-0.1586487591266632,
0.15229515731334686,
0.4840520918369293,
0.4019702076911926,
0.22756201028823853,
0.29175570607185364,
-0.17100383341312408,
-0.6240569949150085,
-0.5221461653709412,
-0.7965791821479797,
-0.4982648193836212,
0.05680440738797188,
-0.6927728056907654,
0.23085759580135345,
-0.23392564058303833,
-0.014585742726922035,
-0.034267403185367584,
0.028804641216993332,
-0.40766751766204834,
0.08443733304738998,
0.2629397511482239,
0.8466848731040955,
-0.031600527465343475,
0.8845576047897339,
0.6676713824272156,
-0.5303131937980652,
-0.7695899605751038,
-0.031228890642523766,
0.04140404984354973,
-0.6902827024459839,
0.5686780214309692,
0.4543791711330414,
-0.4061444103717804,
0.0595577135682106,
-0.6013540625572205,
-0.8553784489631653,
1.1379424333572388,
0.3209235966205597,
-0.28179481625556946,
-0.1855352520942688,
-0.032565053552389145,
0.45965197682380676,
-0.5652061700820923,
0.4037753641605377,
0.23947711288928986,
0.3455974757671356,
0.3553515076637268,
-0.9811354875564575,
-0.23434144258499146,
-0.1823030561208725,
-0.2436201423406601,
0.49314457178115845,
-0.789412796497345,
0.8097941875457764,
-0.3714616000652313,
-0.2360268235206604,
0.09223484992980957,
0.5935831069946289,
0.5429964661598206,
0.36826202273368835,
0.5019012093544006,
0.7225587368011475,
0.6630054712295532,
0.10705555230379105,
0.8525597453117371,
-0.2191077023744583,
0.12102745473384857,
1.4346709251403809,
-0.05171689763665199,
0.7585894465446472,
0.5810132026672363,
0.15248730778694153,
0.6798278093338013,
-0.0524788424372673,
0.5378209948539734,
0.47304123640060425,
0.5184935927391052,
-0.4939175248146057,
-0.18541114032268524,
-0.14722296595573425,
-0.011496768333017826,
0.519734799861908,
0.5367640256881714,
-0.05741631239652634,
-0.2922074496746063,
0.1505613923072815,
0.037165384739637375,
0.22368258237838745,
-0.1388619840145111,
1.2307606935501099,
0.18591566383838654,
-0.9291331171989441,
0.5538670420646667,
-0.2680971026420593,
0.8024314045906067,
-0.7091382145881653,
-0.28064268827438354,
-0.3534353971481323,
0.3577508330345154,
-0.056149180978536606,
-0.5372331738471985,
0.30116888880729675,
-0.04638737440109253,
-0.2928764522075653,
-0.34113094210624695,
0.7767757177352905,
-0.6611440181732178,
-0.25870564579963684,
0.30359894037246704,
0.5731537342071533,
0.14797334372997284,
-0.02523479238152504,
-0.7570931911468506,
-0.1271057277917862,
0.04185999929904938,
-0.336629182100296,
0.49085137248039246,
0.8902731537818909,
0.18548081815242767,
0.8439330458641052,
0.704325258731842,
-0.021755870431661606,
0.19819724559783936,
-0.13097544014453888,
1.0920442342758179,
-0.58806973695755,
-0.3102266192436218,
-0.46988698840141296,
0.7490657567977905,
-0.01648477278649807,
-0.08515733480453491,
0.6001238822937012,
0.4835599660873413,
0.7984317541122437,
0.1356307864189148,
0.6767675876617432,
-0.14316649734973907,
1.0583839416503906,
-0.5137788653373718,
0.5372171401977539,
-0.7107291221618652,
0.2688223123550415,
-0.09473517537117004,
-0.7568808794021606,
0.064040407538414,
0.5100499987602234,
0.15930262207984924,
-0.17605389654636383,
0.6149861216545105,
0.8235763907432556,
0.0013620968675240874,
-0.03669123724102974,
0.4410250782966614,
0.2812628448009491,
0.34860458970069885,
0.35955679416656494,
0.8925554156303406,
-0.3243161141872406,
0.6182208061218262,
-0.22041456401348114,
-0.18796545267105103,
-0.07942305505275726,
-0.630086362361908,
-0.7574595212936401,
-0.7187387347221375,
0.13425853848457336,
-0.3954574465751648,
0.03522466868162155,
1.0516480207443237,
0.46294209361076355,
-0.5436305999755859,
-0.424312025308609,
0.17977549135684967,
0.19364187121391296,
-0.01331965159624815,
-0.2958410382270813,
-0.20024406909942627,
-0.9931713342666626,
-0.5422542095184326,
0.5020337700843811,
0.45500487089157104,
-0.44362860918045044,
-0.5210466980934143,
-0.05928469076752663,
-0.5403986573219299,
0.33799436688423157,
0.748691201210022,
0.360379695892334,
-0.6881527304649353,
-0.07043883949518204,
0.15555395185947418,
0.0022095865570008755,
0.15428318083286285,
0.9374796748161316,
-1.042517066001892,
0.8615878820419312,
0.13896137475967407,
0.7505748867988586,
0.6504473686218262,
-0.0748426765203476,
0.4013443887233734,
-0.7494056224822998,
0.012454774230718613,
0.5326103568077087,
0.14347000420093536,
0.20899179577827454,
-0.30399197340011597,
0.5311758518218994,
-0.2128215879201889,
-0.8141000270843506,
-0.7339045405387878,
0.3180675208568573,
-0.5138297080993652,
-0.3845883309841156,
0.9747929573059082,
0.018084900453686714,
-0.1083860918879509,
-0.2063412219285965,
-0.44196632504463196,
0.2558673918247223,
-0.32880696654319763,
0.908176064491272,
0.6358027458190918,
-0.2644777297973633,
-0.40669742226600647,
-0.6231539249420166,
0.4068528115749359,
0.39239636063575745,
-0.9060758948326111,
0.07609798014163971,
0.600355327129364,
-0.02630537375807762,
0.44429945945739746,
0.7098355889320374,
-0.21013936400413513,
0.013545230962336063,
-0.3472088575363159,
0.18503963947296143,
-0.0793871283531189,
-0.558109700679779,
-0.019937394186854362,
0.171766459941864,
0.014041237533092499,
-0.02068924717605114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09293v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09293v1
|
Do language models capture implied discourse meanings? An investigation with exhaustivity implicatures of Korean morphology
| 2024-05-15T12:34:40 | 2024-05-15T12:34:40 |
Hagyeong Shin, Sean Trott
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Markedness in natural language is often associated with non-literal meanings
in discourse. Differential Object Marking (DOM) in Korean is one instance of
this phenomenon, where post-positional markers are selected based on both the
semantic features of the noun phrases and the discourse features that are
orthogonal to the semantic features. Previous work has shown that
distributional models of language recover certain semantic features of words --
do these models capture implied discourse-level meanings as well? We evaluate
whether a set of large language models are capable of associating discourse
meanings with different object markings in Korean. Results suggest that
discourse meanings of a grammatical marker can be more challenging to encode
than that of a discourse marker.
|
[
-0.10536520183086395,
-0.8745237588882446,
1.0367634296417236,
-0.0493929460644722,
-0.6096965074539185,
-0.13114038109779358,
0.19811789691448212,
-0.5861254930496216,
0.25907063484191895,
0.618121862411499,
-0.264157235622406,
-0.45755600929260254,
-0.7717956304550171,
0.039748650044202805,
-0.45761623978614807,
0.46894946694374084,
-0.21826212108135223,
-0.05550127103924751,
-0.3474576771259308,
-0.06021464988589287,
-0.16500809788703918,
-0.7316305041313171,
-0.24151484668254852,
-0.3239797055721283,
0.3284761607646942,
-0.12848353385925293,
1.055585265159607,
1.1296281814575195,
0.3496429920196533,
0.3474944233894348,
-0.27561327815055847,
-0.07687978446483612,
-0.15531153976917267,
0.2425287663936615,
-0.20237858593463898,
-0.42741259932518005,
-0.45692282915115356,
0.3000282347202301,
0.728802502155304,
1.2666932344436646,
0.4015192985534668,
0.0650646910071373,
-0.048946499824523926,
0.30621814727783203,
-0.5360580682754517,
0.3107230067253113,
-0.4817560613155365,
-0.11094188690185547,
-0.2034163922071457,
-0.05476990342140198,
-0.5402412414550781,
-0.29829883575439453,
0.27715206146240234,
-0.4820939004421234,
-0.19030915200710297,
-0.1619190275669098,
1.4344244003295898,
0.14082837104797363,
-0.8394166231155396,
-0.6731563806533813,
-0.7435263395309448,
0.6906493306159973,
-0.6502476930618286,
0.33752113580703735,
0.499551385641098,
0.09372499585151672,
0.08587224781513214,
-0.559421718120575,
-0.514193058013916,
-0.4343765676021576,
-0.5103920102119446,
0.2406536042690277,
0.009467589668929577,
0.27165865898132324,
0.3498680889606476,
0.1894485056400299,
-0.2767694294452667,
0.1897827684879303,
-0.019423674792051315,
-0.14880096912384033,
0.7527599334716797,
0.3668407201766968,
0.7119954228401184,
-0.6564690470695496,
-0.4272090792655945,
0.1768779158592224,
-0.9407221078872681,
0.047282714396715164,
0.6647287607192993,
0.4928506910800934,
-0.04274345189332962,
0.8600948452949524,
-0.161958247423172,
0.6723222136497498,
-0.18265400826931,
-0.2807254195213318,
-0.14973977208137512,
-0.2064867466688156,
0.019143765792250633,
-0.0005170732620172203,
0.4305073618888855,
0.2962939143180847,
0.2719474136829376,
-0.16610637307167053,
-0.19068926572799683,
0.23640987277030945,
-0.03192596137523651,
-0.5705021619796753,
-0.21920132637023926,
0.0426926389336586,
-0.5534167885780334,
-0.20476488769054413,
0.3750529885292053,
-0.495035320520401,
-0.3342306315898895,
-0.4468246102333069,
0.002328143920749426,
-0.1146911159157753,
-0.8307647705078125,
0.2723548412322998,
-0.11338367313146591,
0.5249457359313965,
0.3151935935020447,
-0.6991015076637268,
0.378799170255661,
0.9237250089645386,
0.6955731511116028,
-0.3298119306564331,
0.046235643327236176,
0.02568419650197029,
0.10420109331607819,
-0.5501197576522827,
1.0184905529022217,
-0.9780904054641724,
-0.46797189116477966,
0.3520353436470032,
0.26621049642562866,
-0.40826719999313354,
-0.5609389543533325,
0.5339372158050537,
-0.5432484745979309,
0.13859161734580994,
-0.19274654984474182,
-0.9321471452713013,
-0.40406760573387146,
0.07826398313045502,
-0.5257939100265503,
1.086893916130066,
0.18573349714279175,
-0.41053852438926697,
0.3591829836368561,
0.036973513662815094,
-0.5693739056587219,
0.20522943139076233,
-0.1643289029598236,
-0.11214594542980194,
0.3463597297668457,
-0.5045886039733887,
0.588546872138977,
0.06446869671344757,
0.40613436698913574,
-0.22414641082286835,
-0.26010459661483765,
0.5613319873809814,
-0.18860462307929993,
0.6392401456832886,
-0.20650339126586914,
-0.33119624853134155,
-0.12661850452423096,
-1.0038913488388062,
0.11402164399623871,
0.05172990635037422,
-0.2526604235172272,
-0.8090488314628601,
0.02125387266278267,
-0.13492301106452942,
0.6439891457557678,
0.2581780254840851,
-0.463113397359848,
0.01994752511382103,
-0.43480467796325684,
-0.01232622005045414,
0.626430869102478,
0.09301288425922394,
0.6862621307373047,
-0.16406479477882385,
0.8344091176986694,
0.020289357751607895,
-0.30340978503227234,
-0.18400242924690247,
-0.9144082069396973,
-0.8710752725601196,
-0.38571304082870483,
0.3649860620498657,
0.4449854791164398,
-0.4491974413394928,
0.31884634494781494,
-0.19559451937675476,
-0.2573617994785309,
-0.4352184236049652,
-0.5013960003852844,
0.7750239372253418,
0.4106024205684662,
-0.14796802401542664,
0.06119751185178757,
-0.5766128301620483,
-1.1028120517730713,
-0.16498567163944244,
-0.379884272813797,
0.08600510656833649,
0.5939240455627441,
0.6985131502151489,
0.32341355085372925,
0.7554178833961487,
-0.795554518699646,
-0.11739988625049591,
-0.21336834132671356,
0.2530007064342499,
-0.18332742154598236,
-0.0012700140941888094,
0.6728793382644653,
-0.77060866355896,
-0.6504726409912109,
0.30202412605285645,
-0.8521276712417603,
-0.48897281289100647,
-0.021124396473169327,
-0.21755433082580566,
0.17654743790626526,
0.49191609025001526,
-0.7413855791091919,
0.6287224292755127,
0.20570266246795654,
-0.5848652124404907,
0.6467071175575256,
0.04230489581823349,
0.20755669474601746,
-0.7163763642311096,
0.08664955198764801,
-0.3274213373661041,
-0.28296300768852234,
-1.0154144763946533,
0.047656651586294174,
0.06598103046417236,
0.13845151662826538,
-0.7046388387680054,
0.8978447914123535,
-0.4363512098789215,
-0.15794241428375244,
-0.8081825971603394,
0.46731218695640564,
0.1519489288330078,
0.2803615927696228,
0.47846898436546326,
0.5225309729576111,
0.4012736678123474,
-0.8575399518013,
0.04235537722706795,
0.07753384858369827,
-0.013225749135017395,
0.6289721727371216,
-0.4414202570915222,
0.07457403838634491,
-0.3910078704357147,
-0.17717596888542175,
-1.31132173538208,
-0.5260689854621887,
0.3503074645996094,
0.003711982164531946,
0.07931940257549286,
-0.4250330328941345,
-0.27376294136047363,
-0.17803344130516052,
-0.10311762243509293,
0.1445266306400299,
0.45203104615211487,
-0.06006830930709839,
0.39396020770072937,
0.6317437887191772,
0.006585173308849335,
-0.3149365484714508,
-0.4141158163547516,
-0.13065730035305023,
-0.3827771246433258,
-0.4177773892879486,
0.30480143427848816,
0.45470184087753296,
-0.5510786771774292,
0.20614054799079895,
0.15053501725196838,
-0.32504501938819885,
0.261806845664978,
0.5044599771499634,
0.4440515637397766,
-0.1735682189464569,
0.04618953540921211,
0.33939963579177856,
0.0410076379776001,
0.31899264454841614,
0.05389578267931938,
0.5449885129928589,
0.35747963190078735,
-0.5056723952293396,
-0.421369731426239,
0.549664318561554,
0.4633914530277252,
0.22247609496116638,
0.6748628616333008,
-0.1096353679895401,
-0.6696370244026184,
0.08373013138771057,
-0.31879886984825134,
-0.010642880573868752,
-0.39044779539108276,
0.38849571347236633,
-0.7203713655471802,
-0.6289209723472595,
0.8952158093452454,
-0.38704395294189453,
-0.3655790686607361,
0.6036185622215271,
0.13852429389953613,
0.004116432275623083,
1.2377040386199951,
0.37456804513931274,
0.5478174090385437,
0.13882827758789062,
0.058624714612960815,
0.13619139790534973,
-0.9316071271896362,
-0.18060122430324554,
-0.7191177606582642,
-0.07551447302103043,
-0.5793300867080688,
-0.2853071689605713,
-0.2268281728029251,
0.005405092146247625,
0.10345929861068726,
0.32203546166419983,
-0.31110140681266785,
0.46214088797569275,
0.2862108051776886,
-0.3279584050178528,
0.3053191006183624,
-0.40033912658691406,
-0.1230984702706337,
-0.5439013242721558,
-0.3000723719596863,
-1.180631399154663,
0.7284348011016846,
0.044622473418712616,
0.30215129256248474,
-0.2330506294965744,
0.2958415150642395,
-0.08610404282808304,
0.06004849821329117,
-0.5917725563049316,
0.8683555722236633,
-0.16611799597740173,
-0.5476999282836914,
-0.025128653272986412,
-0.07164113968610764,
-0.9867307543754578,
0.4012281000614166,
0.20420248806476593,
-0.8978172540664673,
0.3401242196559906,
-0.08899684250354767,
0.18350282311439514,
0.1895734965801239,
-0.5030527114868164,
0.8111492991447449,
-0.10510049015283585,
-0.04348185658454895,
0.2951503396034241,
-0.34690067172050476,
0.4807012677192688,
0.2147550880908966,
0.06986533105373383,
-0.5291479825973511,
-0.07328791916370392,
0.603195309638977,
-0.14237016439437866,
0.8812116384506226,
-0.44247525930404663,
-0.62324458360672,
0.4925117492675781,
0.4024093747138977,
0.6336023807525635,
-0.11198151111602783,
-0.09726598858833313,
-0.04222087189555168,
-0.1789700835943222,
-0.1354125440120697,
-0.5867941379547119,
0.4096201956272125,
-0.4633318781852722,
-0.7137750387191772,
-0.3405095636844635,
-0.29542863368988037,
0.15236574411392212,
0.23877272009849548,
0.30520641803741455,
0.3741455674171448,
-0.35826781392097473,
-0.30983972549438477,
0.4596829414367676,
-0.317135214805603,
0.3185872435569763,
0.4005577564239502,
-0.48191189765930176,
0.16432906687259674,
0.8087431192398071,
0.33730170130729675,
0.6192197799682617,
0.14558623731136322,
0.02749621868133545,
-0.527685821056366,
-0.4557533264160156,
-0.513346791267395,
0.3442067801952362,
-0.9567626118659973,
0.02462027221918106,
-0.808879017829895,
-0.4831373691558838,
-0.18558825552463531,
-0.2809389531612396,
-0.5481405258178711,
-0.8140233755111694,
-0.49152350425720215,
-0.29770225286483765,
0.10654889047145844,
0.9683065414428711,
0.26055097579956055,
0.20678439736366272,
-0.4284150004386902,
0.3158853054046631,
0.03322818502783775,
0.0678570419549942,
-0.060896873474121094,
-0.7042258381843567,
0.08196701109409332,
0.2519180178642273,
-0.026098694652318954,
-1.052912712097168,
0.2700790464878082,
0.14504440128803253,
0.36487284302711487,
0.5580453276634216,
0.042053382843732834,
0.639154314994812,
-0.6522570252418518,
0.907662570476532,
-0.21636763215065002,
-0.9529803395271301,
0.5779929161071777,
-0.5939183235168457,
0.4634174406528473,
0.01312478817999363,
0.3795608580112457,
-0.7365581393241882,
-1.0380624532699585,
-0.4138844609260559,
-0.8079348802566528,
0.6565359830856323,
0.005373811349272728,
0.6744622588157654,
-0.4283830523490906,
0.44674620032310486,
0.4522917866706848,
0.10603214800357819,
-0.9873403310775757,
-0.4060031473636627,
-0.07627065479755402,
-0.09656775742769241,
0.700257420539856,
-0.7172611951828003,
-0.05361822247505188,
-0.04029376804828644,
0.48162373900413513,
0.09351132065057755,
0.3140411674976349,
-0.02686367556452751,
-0.28009018301963806,
0.1748029887676239,
0.27891257405281067,
0.8097113370895386,
0.6817741990089417,
0.2410682737827301,
0.519180178642273,
-0.12883298099040985,
-0.526565670967102,
0.5685218572616577,
0.01962827518582344,
-0.6134682893753052,
0.3688831031322479,
0.24423107504844666,
0.8218704462051392,
0.37459027767181396,
-0.5149611830711365,
0.5159052610397339,
0.3557141423225403,
-0.32515251636505127,
-0.23472745716571808,
-0.14875268936157227,
0.16788144409656525,
-0.05589025095105171,
0.1712840497493744,
-0.3926813304424286,
0.30755341053009033,
-0.4161447584629059,
-0.05013309046626091,
0.6124044060707092,
-0.44156211614608765,
-0.8299646377563477,
0.7216176390647888,
-0.20366354286670685,
0.019462138414382935,
0.3169936537742615,
-0.710746169090271,
-0.7872106432914734,
0.6062178611755371,
0.7214228510856628,
0.7786511182785034,
-0.37068238854408264,
0.7984029054641724,
0.27479663491249084,
0.11301302909851074,
-0.02347773313522339,
0.5290496945381165,
0.25905999541282654,
-0.7215291857719421,
-0.44931331276893616,
-0.5263237953186035,
-0.28154847025871277,
-0.13924092054367065,
-0.550089418888092,
0.2594316303730011,
-0.16230575740337372,
-0.006150597240775824,
0.03569971024990082,
-0.6012077927589417,
-0.3279939889907837,
0.17922183871269226,
0.3086976408958435,
-0.06260990351438522,
-0.9786319732666016,
0.6749148964881897,
0.7723304629325867,
-0.17674973607063293,
-0.7442582845687866,
-0.2989828586578369,
-0.11155655235052109,
-0.4514338970184326,
1.1176592111587524,
0.28118276596069336,
-0.2492673397064209,
-0.26354166865348816,
-0.18017593026161194,
-1.3521127700805664,
0.6727364659309387,
0.5767517685890198,
0.22500446438789368,
0.036037664860486984,
0.9619662165641785,
0.7550910115242004,
-0.39345625042915344,
0.12993206083774567,
0.45646747946739197,
0.45326223969459534,
-0.02535642310976982,
-0.8323443531990051,
0.45247212052345276,
-0.15550634264945984,
0.19338186085224152,
0.340425968170166,
-0.2650047242641449,
1.0574042797088623,
0.44591861963272095,
-0.8778207898139954,
-0.00945976935327053,
0.4181007444858551,
0.009027947671711445,
0.17862625420093536,
0.11147153377532959,
0.38739749789237976,
0.7283533215522766,
-0.29625022411346436,
0.9977712631225586,
-0.1285647600889206,
0.16777057945728302,
1.0143897533416748,
-0.7702373266220093,
0.5818063020706177,
0.20282337069511414,
-0.19206026196479797,
0.669511079788208,
0.33586856722831726,
0.2792228162288666,
0.5410206317901611,
0.18154402077198029,
-0.3286014497280121,
-0.17066821455955505,
-0.6007813215255737,
-0.21801534295082092,
0.7850466966629028,
0.4144666790962219,
-0.41032832860946655,
-0.1021776795387268,
0.3566414713859558,
0.4361761510372162,
0.4273023009300232,
-0.2944515347480774,
0.9859122037887573,
0.25537416338920593,
-0.7967652678489685,
0.48748645186424255,
-0.10559334605932236,
0.10282778739929199,
-0.2802305221557617,
-0.13244621455669403,
-0.14748677611351013,
-0.011126277968287468,
0.029544468969106674,
-0.7660419344902039,
0.6239219903945923,
-0.13556642830371857,
0.13969539105892181,
-0.48284879326820374,
1.0796595811843872,
-0.39954906702041626,
-0.4710216522216797,
0.3594093322753906,
0.6698270440101624,
0.28657597303390503,
-0.005995415151119232,
-0.22730383276939392,
-0.1603899598121643,
-0.3596969246864319,
-0.2272992581129074,
0.26132023334503174,
0.6919828653335571,
-0.1275271624326706,
0.5089166164398193,
0.12479597330093384,
0.1694854199886322,
0.5389938354492188,
0.05019938200712204,
0.5810145139694214,
-0.5426123142242432,
-0.4871550500392914,
-0.9446441531181335,
0.6226187944412231,
-0.27919167280197144,
-0.3564383089542389,
0.9766079187393188,
0.4458794593811035,
0.8304810523986816,
-0.3517375886440277,
0.46590298414230347,
0.033985719084739685,
0.4778438210487366,
-0.6472550630569458,
0.4788948595523834,
-0.16257831454277039,
-0.0326232835650444,
-0.5621451735496521,
-0.9329106211662292,
-0.47464028000831604,
0.5242146253585815,
-0.48935776948928833,
-0.02459479495882988,
0.8370314836502075,
0.42622366547584534,
-0.11539820581674576,
0.05324790999293327,
0.5438622832298279,
-0.023377254605293274,
0.0777849331498146,
0.04085903614759445,
1.356109857559204,
-0.3070853352546692,
0.2590022683143616,
-0.3521535396575928,
0.17379698157310486,
0.07394592463970184,
-0.5252804756164551,
-0.901922881603241,
-0.8420746922492981,
-0.659298300743103,
-0.0722484141588211,
0.023272499442100525,
0.4881133437156677,
0.49622875452041626,
-0.7180468440055847,
-0.17276397347450256,
-0.12688210606575012,
0.12727287411689758,
-0.15025147795677185,
-0.25904446840286255,
0.682585597038269,
-0.256883829832077,
-1.0227255821228027,
0.09839504957199097,
0.5032175779342651,
0.4375040531158447,
-0.08375140279531479,
0.12401845306158066,
-0.4898501932621002,
0.1566665768623352,
0.5798434019088745,
-0.025949787348508835,
-0.8597524762153625,
-0.7536015510559082,
0.21794219315052032,
-0.2093140184879303,
0.12837591767311096,
0.8365291357040405,
-0.42366617918014526,
0.2214527428150177,
0.33521604537963867,
0.33093392848968506,
0.10664130747318268,
0.07335732877254486,
0.5832847952842712,
-0.9997445940971375,
0.6501895785331726,
0.2954173684120178,
0.40491586923599243,
0.39072126150131226,
-0.45076924562454224,
0.40114131569862366,
0.24750308692455292,
-0.31271761655807495,
-1.004791021347046,
0.7283751964569092,
-0.581509530544281,
-0.40682166814804077,
1.3990427255630493,
-0.5460354089736938,
-0.115566685795784,
-0.5513912439346313,
-0.36254996061325073,
0.24787390232086182,
0.16705617308616638,
0.619961142539978,
1.1683776378631592,
-0.05147749185562134,
-0.07349296659231186,
-0.775544285774231,
0.7097830176353455,
0.2783602774143219,
-0.8206120729446411,
0.29411599040031433,
0.5573509335517883,
-0.2645328640937805,
0.05226490646600723,
0.6095401644706726,
-0.1698784977197647,
0.2550009787082672,
-0.014384567737579346,
-0.35662713646888733,
0.4514860510826111,
-0.18163418769836426,
-0.12109875679016113,
0.1898081749677658,
0.17774799466133118,
-0.17505815625190735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09279v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09279v1
|
Sign of the Times: Evaluating the use of Large Language Models for Idiomaticity Detection
| 2024-05-15T11:55:14 | 2024-05-15T11:55:14 |
Dylan Phelps, Thomas Pickard, Maggie Mi, Edward Gow-Smith, Aline Villavicencio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the recent ubiquity of large language models and their high zero-shot
prompted performance across a wide range of tasks, it is still not known how
well they perform on tasks which require processing of potentially idiomatic
language. In particular, how well do such models perform in comparison to
encoder-only models fine-tuned specifically for idiomaticity tasks? In this
work, we attempt to answer this question by looking at the performance of a
range of LLMs (both local and software-as-a-service models) on three
idiomaticity datasets: SemEval 2022 Task 2a, FLUTE, and MAGPIE. Overall, we
find that whilst these models do give competitive performance, they do not
match the results of fine-tuned task-specific models, even at the largest
scales (e.g. for GPT-4). Nevertheless, we do see consistent performance
improvements across model scale. Additionally, we investigate prompting
approaches to improve performance, and discuss the practicalities of using LLMs
for these tasks.
|
[
-0.1878916174173355,
-0.32676517963409424,
0.7573443651199341,
0.49312350153923035,
-0.520616352558136,
0.06548523157835007,
-0.005531953182071447,
-0.7538104057312012,
-0.047790560871362686,
0.3410564959049225,
-0.43182480335235596,
-0.5690162181854248,
-0.8251176476478577,
0.5040767788887024,
-0.6525508165359497,
0.6115149855613708,
-0.07240478694438934,
0.1341305822134018,
-0.10705125331878662,
-0.2019829899072647,
-0.2270515412092209,
-0.3677196800708771,
-0.6334913969039917,
-0.7363554835319519,
0.2703491747379303,
0.32005730271339417,
0.6135648488998413,
0.6022047400474548,
0.6133934259414673,
0.1395956426858902,
-0.19748108088970184,
0.17928506433963776,
-0.17478640377521515,
0.3346216082572937,
-0.009670460596680641,
-0.37963688373565674,
-0.3620428442955017,
0.09649795293807983,
0.6323721408843994,
0.5765860676765442,
0.21212975680828094,
0.35052332282066345,
0.021583275869488716,
0.4477861225605011,
-0.35894662141799927,
0.28379011154174805,
-0.7609277963638306,
0.0931546613574028,
-0.4071762263774872,
-0.19071578979492188,
-0.20605017244815826,
-0.354605108499527,
-0.1800050288438797,
-0.31316062808036804,
-0.13749824464321136,
-0.04574644938111305,
0.8012027144432068,
0.36728528141975403,
-0.4329754412174225,
-0.6141232848167419,
-0.7815985679626465,
0.6701566576957703,
-1.1473249197006226,
0.2690015137195587,
0.28704825043678284,
0.20933055877685547,
-0.1801123172044754,
-0.4412820339202881,
-0.7520783543586731,
-0.2726501226425171,
0.07529062777757645,
-0.05961664021015167,
-0.608981192111969,
-0.12098851799964905,
0.7577201724052429,
0.4314381778240204,
-0.4974896311759949,
0.5932065844535828,
-0.15469537675380707,
0.12005266547203064,
0.5985230803489685,
0.45969200134277344,
-0.037933338433504105,
-0.2969183921813965,
-0.4484824240207672,
0.18886137008666992,
-0.9229350686073303,
0.30203598737716675,
0.44475314021110535,
0.4317871630191803,
-0.12073780596256256,
0.6513808965682983,
-0.3720545768737793,
0.8338473439216614,
-0.10279394686222076,
-0.16914305090904236,
-0.09643929451704025,
-0.46787601709365845,
-0.048285286873579025,
-0.16998291015625,
0.7015631198883057,
0.2643500566482544,
0.3294422924518585,
-0.15683750808238983,
-0.5642620921134949,
0.4130598306655884,
-0.40076878666877747,
-0.9094797968864441,
-0.2054441273212433,
0.2804512083530426,
-0.2789909541606903,
-0.27438318729400635,
-0.10413752496242523,
-0.19690966606140137,
-0.6453019976615906,
-0.5421340465545654,
0.47755926847457886,
-0.32019978761672974,
-0.2199801653623581,
0.47551098465919495,
-0.10598796606063843,
0.3406659662723541,
0.2826857566833496,
-0.6141664385795593,
0.1162344291806221,
0.8706300258636475,
1.0923587083816528,
-0.17864811420440674,
-0.07706347852945328,
-0.735084056854248,
-0.09884615987539291,
-0.23803117871284485,
0.694812536239624,
-0.49671831727027893,
-0.3577025532722473,
0.014922850765287876,
-0.04193001985549927,
0.03363071382045746,
-0.7484211325645447,
0.4838190972805023,
-0.3896970748901367,
-0.20744705200195312,
-0.3792610466480255,
-0.6800936460494995,
-0.04162757843732834,
0.4255567193031311,
-0.49131861329078674,
0.9821850061416626,
0.011955276131629944,
-0.40952423214912415,
0.657140851020813,
-0.89559406042099,
-0.6734051704406738,
0.22157453000545502,
-0.26179373264312744,
-0.33376049995422363,
0.24609605967998505,
0.2689879536628723,
0.8335622549057007,
-0.4680236876010895,
0.09209718555212021,
-0.19164663553237915,
-0.7093801498413086,
0.4223124384880066,
-0.3239888548851013,
0.9966082572937012,
0.3709639012813568,
-0.5442919731140137,
-0.10476139187812805,
-0.682420551776886,
-0.0437193401157856,
0.17219646275043488,
-0.36770492792129517,
-0.2488977462053299,
0.01429655309766531,
-0.09403213858604431,
0.3843744099140167,
0.16008810698986053,
-0.5711174607276917,
0.3325784206390381,
-0.22113828361034393,
0.6622517108917236,
0.5115264058113098,
-0.022031696513295174,
0.002168558072298765,
-0.3464566767215729,
0.8800023794174194,
0.31238001585006714,
0.12737995386123657,
-0.3774109482765198,
-0.5886737108230591,
-0.6466320157051086,
-0.30353641510009766,
0.012038642540574074,
0.4136327803134918,
-0.5804307460784912,
0.2418157309293747,
-0.31352442502975464,
-0.6947193741798401,
-0.548079788684845,
0.19549575448036194,
0.192302867770195,
0.2795336842536926,
0.06282959133386612,
-0.2641000747680664,
-0.2750605344772339,
-0.8336437344551086,
-0.49122339487075806,
-0.34472477436065674,
-0.07374307513237,
-0.01678932085633278,
0.4341399371623993,
-0.032943256199359894,
0.7205098271369934,
-0.06471604108810425,
-0.04264487326145172,
0.13119401037693024,
0.32873114943504333,
0.6791394352912903,
0.025295816361904144,
0.7802801132202148,
-0.5348594784736633,
-0.5487268567085266,
-0.014066648669540882,
-0.6450166702270508,
-0.4069974720478058,
-0.06387549638748169,
0.523670494556427,
0.2914888560771942,
0.5261338353157043,
-0.34230294823646545,
0.3184535503387451,
0.7464593648910522,
-0.5351868271827698,
0.5249893665313721,
0.039275895804166794,
0.31388425827026367,
-0.7958808541297913,
0.016820892691612244,
-0.11740622669458389,
-0.2627873718738556,
-0.5752694606781006,
-0.10868283361196518,
0.1265825480222702,
-0.23428112268447876,
-0.3572864830493927,
0.6620426177978516,
-0.6236755847930908,
-0.31272026896476746,
-0.23545093834400177,
0.17338122427463531,
-0.08251073956489563,
-0.023921463638544083,
-0.11846169084310532,
0.9336792230606079,
0.510387659072876,
-0.718997597694397,
0.35086092352867126,
-0.02683446928858757,
-0.7688599228858948,
0.7320257425308228,
-0.7751507759094238,
0.2794143557548523,
0.0015342712868005037,
-0.288443386554718,
-1.1784917116165161,
-0.03637201711535454,
0.21804551780223846,
-0.31677332520484924,
0.0493772067129612,
-0.2873395085334778,
-0.8984800577163696,
-0.40731245279312134,
-0.019781004637479782,
0.25612878799438477,
0.35208362340927124,
-0.8256719708442688,
0.28655123710632324,
0.10955572128295898,
0.1397986263036728,
-0.4135051667690277,
-0.5423480868339539,
0.26474228501319885,
-0.5319542288780212,
-0.7049896717071533,
-0.03381748124957085,
0.005021387245506048,
-0.6449708938598633,
-0.21339014172554016,
0.09945116192102432,
0.3820188343524933,
0.481812983751297,
0.4940767288208008,
-0.006441637873649597,
-0.22384174168109894,
0.3300105035305023,
-0.1905556172132492,
-0.07538847625255585,
-0.05983380973339081,
-0.31049543619155884,
0.6049782633781433,
-0.32419291138648987,
-0.8032242059707642,
-0.31849437952041626,
0.2697199583053589,
1.0522712469100952,
-0.45413506031036377,
0.6153469085693359,
0.40529295802116394,
-0.4136948883533478,
-0.07759091258049011,
-0.4684443473815918,
-0.19213657081127167,
-0.46201568841934204,
0.025657963007688522,
-0.4235629141330719,
-0.734496533870697,
0.6766517758369446,
-0.031159577891230583,
0.24335461854934692,
0.17700675129890442,
0.5229676365852356,
-0.07294712215662003,
1.2281708717346191,
0.3251234292984009,
-0.1553647369146347,
0.6756017208099365,
-0.06442650407552719,
0.5455045104026794,
-0.4219173789024353,
-0.07584165036678314,
-0.5746370553970337,
-0.3929940164089203,
-0.5476754307746887,
-0.17291519045829773,
0.5746380090713501,
-0.022007694467902184,
-0.18059875071048737,
0.5677254796028137,
-0.3880815804004669,
0.23242942988872528,
0.3417060971260071,
-0.34351789951324463,
0.7972517013549805,
0.04127596691250801,
0.3036583960056305,
-0.016078999266028404,
-0.6964098811149597,
-0.7827896475791931,
0.9231675863265991,
0.32800576090812683,
0.7594620585441589,
0.11554106324911118,
0.5445535182952881,
0.30523085594177246,
0.18404297530651093,
-1.0069687366485596,
0.5921428203582764,
-0.30006036162376404,
-0.5076026916503906,
-0.21236231923103333,
-0.16204151511192322,
-0.9652429819107056,
0.05293095111846924,
-0.24767035245895386,
-0.5620130300521851,
0.13517935574054718,
0.09828010201454163,
-0.27857428789138794,
0.3200439512729645,
-0.3841802775859833,
0.7484292984008789,
-0.44687506556510925,
-0.016142042353749275,
-0.039151377975940704,
-0.13601036369800568,
0.18584834039211273,
-0.04344798997044563,
0.21181708574295044,
-0.7214984893798828,
-0.0495784692466259,
0.4050615429878235,
0.04124775156378746,
0.6635779142379761,
-0.12006577849388123,
-0.3346511423587799,
0.09248823672533035,
0.24727420508861542,
0.8159281015396118,
-0.06467467546463013,
-0.3966396450996399,
0.2672606110572815,
0.3813309967517853,
-0.3098699748516083,
-0.33770570158958435,
0.6458622217178345,
-0.2636067867279053,
-0.5320626497268677,
-0.43463134765625,
-0.5957100987434387,
-0.13512030243873596,
0.13402961194515228,
0.48676544427871704,
0.5993155837059021,
0.014004901982843876,
0.11431074142456055,
0.40405020117759705,
0.30810150504112244,
0.43894073367118835,
0.7342924475669861,
-0.32956039905548096,
0.2803930342197418,
0.5283846855163574,
0.3185671269893646,
0.41699036955833435,
0.09691727161407471,
-0.03302078694105148,
-0.19308409094810486,
-0.7727604508399963,
-0.4038906395435333,
0.3842122554779053,
-0.8334475755691528,
-0.1974470466375351,
-0.386736661195755,
0.09084899723529816,
-0.4817488193511963,
-0.07910328358411789,
-0.13434644043445587,
-0.4814402461051941,
-0.2063191831111908,
0.1159500777721405,
0.7438501119613647,
0.850742757320404,
0.08162077516317368,
0.26074162125587463,
-0.6272869110107422,
-0.020584911108016968,
0.0356215201318264,
0.2999758720397949,
-0.23535722494125366,
-0.6603831648826599,
-0.2251879721879959,
-0.15393944084644318,
0.030688971281051636,
-0.9201661348342896,
0.1342107355594635,
0.1615777462720871,
0.425727903842926,
0.5881337523460388,
0.07647693902254105,
0.44783100485801697,
-0.12923301756381989,
0.7635773420333862,
0.10495258122682571,
-0.9382544159889221,
0.4826028645038605,
-0.5066442489624023,
0.7474847435951233,
0.17887508869171143,
0.45974186062812805,
-0.9214156270027161,
-0.4329321086406708,
-0.32482245564460754,
-0.7278727889060974,
0.32100313901901245,
-0.14936575293540955,
0.11849858611822128,
-0.21742302179336548,
0.3862880766391754,
0.15797708928585052,
0.20129519701004028,
-0.7021389603614807,
-0.03457317873835564,
0.09361916035413742,
-0.16757600009441376,
0.004511156585067511,
-0.09556746482849121,
-0.20882730185985565,
-0.05161508545279503,
0.5556334853172302,
-0.39605703949928284,
0.06295105814933777,
-0.17411966621875763,
0.03263420611619949,
-0.12721097469329834,
0.37974610924720764,
0.36390191316604614,
0.8270838260650635,
0.21121211349964142,
0.147587850689888,
0.10826640576124191,
-0.17331887781620026,
0.1960647851228714,
0.15018288791179657,
-0.4547790586948395,
0.1617976427078247,
0.3799628019332886,
0.8271594643592834,
0.11867839097976685,
-0.8647189736366272,
0.46855854988098145,
0.05243919417262077,
0.20719732344150543,
-0.5069893598556519,
0.18473052978515625,
0.1303090900182724,
0.6211941242218018,
0.1609877496957779,
-0.3666299879550934,
0.07371178269386292,
-0.6325600743293762,
-0.33694735169410706,
0.6802798509597778,
-0.37909838557243347,
-0.38582712411880493,
0.5827930569648743,
-0.07292027771472931,
-0.4099407494068146,
0.6660590767860413,
-0.29426565766334534,
-0.41027945280075073,
0.6252930760383606,
0.6025910973548889,
0.8148337602615356,
0.03534854203462601,
0.05643681436777115,
0.3781377077102661,
0.45295554399490356,
-0.06998453289270401,
0.603135883808136,
-0.13293853402137756,
-0.6541685461997986,
-0.295303076505661,
-0.4770219922065735,
-0.4610883295536041,
0.21418249607086182,
-0.6711477041244507,
0.5183064937591553,
-0.45110997557640076,
-0.46350470185279846,
0.055375777184963226,
-0.05885767191648483,
-1.0134022235870361,
-0.10227110981941223,
0.0959697812795639,
0.9702938795089722,
-0.9989224672317505,
0.6108232140541077,
0.8835029602050781,
-0.3185718059539795,
-0.503911018371582,
-0.131209135055542,
0.11560288071632385,
-0.7539728879928589,
0.5772798657417297,
0.15383459627628326,
-0.3165763020515442,
-0.13203935325145721,
-0.5465096235275269,
-0.7300052642822266,
1.2109802961349487,
0.3327275812625885,
-0.6867459416389465,
0.023898189887404442,
0.23398323357105255,
0.5119806528091431,
-0.4126955270767212,
-0.15951810777187347,
0.7998743057250977,
0.46324652433395386,
-0.11134730279445648,
-1.0798918008804321,
-0.006037052720785141,
-0.08252259343862534,
-0.07072069495916367,
0.3176359236240387,
-0.3402235507965088,
0.8384047746658325,
-0.19280554354190826,
-0.5068187713623047,
0.1956249624490738,
0.43903353810310364,
0.2945754826068878,
0.5617716312408447,
0.5227240920066833,
0.18925224244594574,
0.8467479348182678,
-0.3772975504398346,
1.0144282579421997,
-0.4172322452068329,
0.10018673539161682,
0.8789862990379333,
-0.40631943941116333,
0.8601887822151184,
0.6205893158912659,
-0.36848458647727966,
0.083523690700531,
0.5578268766403198,
-0.037714648991823196,
0.03792863339185715,
0.05164022371172905,
-0.3662532866001129,
-0.48232269287109375,
-0.1931898444890976,
-0.28186798095703125,
0.6023451685905457,
0.5044201612472534,
-0.3371385633945465,
-0.2833832800388336,
0.08669950067996979,
0.1449069231748581,
0.2201625108718872,
-0.28475651144981384,
0.4214162826538086,
0.14027036726474762,
-0.6229749321937561,
0.48497429490089417,
-0.179355189204216,
0.8328343033790588,
-0.5786120891571045,
0.11349590867757797,
-0.2547558844089508,
0.2521824240684509,
-0.1460307538509369,
-0.9613422155380249,
0.15896302461624146,
0.11390547454357147,
-0.08287432789802551,
-0.12144530564546585,
0.615366518497467,
-0.3363259434700012,
-0.40546342730522156,
0.47982436418533325,
0.4693588316440582,
0.3289591073989868,
-0.0610218346118927,
-0.48124179244041443,
0.2229411005973816,
-0.33664533495903015,
0.040983520448207855,
0.1448756903409958,
0.4492952525615692,
0.01295956876128912,
0.7078911066055298,
0.48909127712249756,
0.19143390655517578,
0.08254216611385345,
-0.050315145403146744,
0.4181436002254486,
-0.41077563166618347,
-0.3382151424884796,
-0.7813604474067688,
0.2866762578487396,
0.06369481235742569,
-0.4823542833328247,
0.9980663061141968,
0.3934962749481201,
0.9320343732833862,
-0.037652887403964996,
0.592677116394043,
0.24023696780204773,
0.6287679076194763,
-0.7034150958061218,
0.5835863947868347,
-0.6291742920875549,
0.4694785177707672,
-0.1546345055103302,
-0.8346216082572937,
-0.2906087636947632,
0.37891489267349243,
-0.5851701498031616,
-0.16831934452056885,
0.022351738065481186,
0.8697466850280762,
-0.05934165045619011,
0.150432288646698,
0.5648152828216553,
0.1093956008553505,
0.48142874240875244,
0.42261579632759094,
1.1642894744873047,
-0.357805073261261,
0.3146820664405823,
-0.14928093552589417,
-0.09066248685121536,
-0.31790053844451904,
-1.2866461277008057,
-0.8134784698486328,
-0.7729490399360657,
-0.3492158353328705,
-0.3226500451564789,
-0.04348313435912132,
1.0425333976745605,
0.42758774757385254,
-0.7947360873222351,
-0.3836161494255066,
0.31910640001296997,
-0.10390492528676987,
-0.4011368155479431,
-0.12053991854190826,
-0.008024248294532299,
-0.1335497498512268,
-0.7926359176635742,
0.6447903513908386,
0.396531879901886,
0.22417673468589783,
-0.35503748059272766,
-0.03975459188222885,
0.018276924267411232,
0.2567981779575348,
0.6936451196670532,
0.4542069137096405,
-0.8292407989501953,
-0.35146188735961914,
0.20539017021656036,
-0.0734960064291954,
0.007699852809309959,
0.8915756344795227,
-0.536008894443512,
0.5618196129798889,
0.5314961671829224,
0.3255029320716858,
0.524785041809082,
-0.26563480496406555,
0.3223164677619934,
-0.44872552156448364,
0.06539692729711533,
0.2989599108695984,
0.62354975938797,
0.5546694993972778,
-0.35337182879447937,
0.7539779543876648,
0.040843456983566284,
-0.5317656993865967,
-0.9571284055709839,
0.5579075813293457,
-0.51444411277771,
-0.00734319444745779,
1.197687029838562,
-0.10537540167570114,
0.20626087486743927,
-0.23109112679958344,
0.12448122352361679,
-0.0720517709851265,
-0.11409853398799896,
0.679413378238678,
0.8457322120666504,
-0.4232560396194458,
0.019984858110547066,
-0.5937849879264832,
0.3706035017967224,
0.3561071455478668,
-0.47611868381500244,
0.10835988819599152,
0.4547981321811676,
0.429184228181839,
0.08349254727363586,
0.7075578570365906,
-0.307716965675354,
0.340313196182251,
-0.2750294506549835,
-0.26289647817611694,
-0.35575681924819946,
-0.25553417205810547,
-0.7970259189605713,
-0.18248769640922546,
0.7097935676574707,
-0.01997222937643528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13020v1
|
Using Combinatorial Optimization to Design a High quality LLM Solution
| 2024-05-15T11:13:39 | 2024-05-15T11:13:39 |
Samuel Ackerman, Eitan Farchi, Rami Katan, Orna Raz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce a novel LLM based solution design approach that utilizes
combinatorial optimization and sampling. Specifically, a set of factors that
influence the quality of the solution are identified. They typically include
factors that represent prompt types, LLM inputs alternatives, and parameters
governing the generation and design alternatives. Identifying the factors that
govern the LLM solution quality enables the infusion of subject matter expert
knowledge. Next, a set of interactions between the factors are defined and
combinatorial optimization is used to create a small subset $P$ that ensures
all desired interactions occur in $P$. Each element $p \in P$ is then developed
into an appropriate benchmark. Applying the alternative solutions on each
combination, $p \in P$ and evaluating the results facilitate the design of a
high quality LLM solution pipeline. The approach is especially applicable when
the design and evaluation of each benchmark in $P$ is time-consuming and
involves manual steps and human evaluation. Given its efficiency the approach
can also be used as a baseline to compare and validate an autoML approach that
searches over the factors governing the solution.
|
[
-0.775582492351532,
-0.49766039848327637,
0.5625584721565247,
0.5595082640647888,
-0.5222269296646118,
0.5134895443916321,
0.07616014778614044,
-0.0022051625419408083,
0.16966821253299713,
0.6682896614074707,
-0.9134402871131897,
-0.25434234738349915,
-0.2832350730895996,
0.2615969479084015,
-0.1377115398645401,
0.42620420455932617,
-0.3667610287666321,
0.3548968434333801,
-0.5481963157653809,
-0.09680343419313431,
-0.3271227180957794,
-0.3791525065898895,
-0.4884467124938965,
-0.535613477230072,
0.23829305171966553,
0.43271565437316895,
0.31918251514434814,
0.8631072640419006,
0.6531885862350464,
0.262298583984375,
-0.2234829068183899,
0.6369662880897522,
-0.8107767701148987,
0.24166177213191986,
-0.11137916892766953,
-0.2905372083187103,
-0.16479600965976715,
0.31300875544548035,
0.3045097887516022,
0.6822335124015808,
-0.35594531893730164,
0.5384342074394226,
0.23072917759418488,
0.5742924809455872,
-0.9257183074951172,
-0.20577022433280945,
-0.4194457530975342,
0.3933451175689697,
-0.16818436980247498,
-0.6966327428817749,
-0.1899958699941635,
-0.2306012660264969,
-0.2692664861679077,
-0.7784307599067688,
0.109412282705307,
0.3817006051540375,
0.38681718707084656,
0.675067126750946,
-0.05011526122689247,
-0.48989439010620117,
-0.888274610042572,
0.9793272018432617,
-0.8252136707305908,
0.0936211422085762,
0.06565241515636444,
0.435879111289978,
-0.5292289853096008,
-0.4037098288536072,
-0.2809561491012573,
0.07356003671884537,
0.01639631763100624,
0.5431122183799744,
0.30006223917007446,
-0.1283159852027893,
0.08801779896020889,
0.5087720155715942,
-0.762076199054718,
0.27543503046035767,
-0.19695617258548737,
-0.2327292263507843,
0.9372787475585938,
0.7490844130516052,
-0.07547883689403534,
-0.044253118336200714,
-0.910503625869751,
0.19788697361946106,
-0.6854619383811951,
0.2849070727825165,
0.7570720911026001,
0.14838531613349915,
0.3166677951812744,
0.48704516887664795,
-0.1738690733909607,
0.6776208281517029,
0.14631278812885284,
-0.4630892872810364,
-0.03874839469790459,
-0.6533898711204529,
-0.24121208488941193,
-0.2927756607532501,
0.5387420654296875,
0.12125055491924286,
-0.2054562121629715,
0.10328227281570435,
-0.5583942532539368,
-0.2958028018474579,
0.4484972655773163,
-0.7745850086212158,
-0.1718652993440628,
0.492778480052948,
-0.6319505572319031,
-0.5432981252670288,
-0.0314827524125576,
-0.7424429059028625,
-0.18308737874031067,
-0.6189278364181519,
0.5747992992401123,
-0.0944608673453331,
0.05053163319826126,
-0.09264965355396271,
-0.05720430240035057,
0.21854709088802338,
0.12107016891241074,
-0.7270094156265259,
0.4167118966579437,
0.8479136824607849,
0.6544501185417175,
-0.7135007977485657,
-0.08907017111778259,
-0.7753459811210632,
0.2957472503185272,
-0.46287497878074646,
1.0392214059829712,
-0.38487836718559265,
-0.9668751955032349,
-0.2897750437259674,
-0.4966014623641968,
0.23494000732898712,
-1.0073436498641968,
0.45220521092414856,
-0.5463482737541199,
0.12982061505317688,
-0.06995799392461777,
-0.7778046131134033,
0.12348324060440063,
0.01727946288883686,
-0.6377246379852295,
0.8122204542160034,
0.3137679994106293,
-0.33803412318229675,
0.3538203537464142,
-0.6421787738800049,
-0.23379258811473846,
0.5348315238952637,
-0.18949878215789795,
-0.646127462387085,
0.3290156424045563,
0.2520569860935211,
-0.039195284247398376,
-0.2523234188556671,
0.10597661882638931,
-0.20779776573181152,
-0.44298943877220154,
0.2603312134742737,
-0.08393604308366776,
0.9274346232414246,
0.7047045230865479,
0.08582482486963272,
0.40010809898376465,
-0.8434725999832153,
0.30055394768714905,
-0.06254852563142776,
-0.7131692171096802,
0.024326752871274948,
0.0480579137802124,
0.04580673947930336,
0.23278802633285522,
0.2671026885509491,
-0.4186582565307617,
0.0036670039407908916,
-0.1472659409046173,
0.45181602239608765,
0.9221360683441162,
0.5242865681648254,
0.33709993958473206,
-0.5399588942527771,
0.8011314272880554,
-0.19989013671875,
0.49587661027908325,
0.1074041947722435,
-0.14270804822444916,
-0.8832389116287231,
-0.3567388653755188,
0.20910733938217163,
0.5726785063743591,
-0.49659568071365356,
0.540111780166626,
0.4587242901325226,
-0.3326442241668701,
-0.23992282152175903,
0.7240251898765564,
0.35558125376701355,
0.36008164286613464,
0.14213767647743225,
-0.6294510364532471,
-0.5352616906166077,
-0.8815174698829651,
0.03577916696667671,
0.07774800062179565,
0.01589331030845642,
0.3445023000240326,
0.27881869673728943,
0.04611944779753685,
1.2431626319885254,
-0.6313647627830505,
-0.23016902804374695,
-0.12499512732028961,
0.30596768856048584,
0.7946048974990845,
0.3608839809894562,
0.45702481269836426,
-0.5480870008468628,
-0.4510781168937683,
-0.5169764161109924,
-0.5479548573493958,
-0.5015744566917419,
-0.23968744277954102,
-0.6656360030174255,
-0.13936330378055573,
0.418215811252594,
-0.3749445080757141,
0.21736308932304382,
0.35725274682044983,
0.08610174059867859,
0.784440279006958,
-0.33571717143058777,
-0.0862896516919136,
-1.2163817882537842,
0.01895543374121189,
0.05871059373021126,
0.2694512605667114,
-0.432224303483963,
0.4147983193397522,
-0.08928173035383224,
-0.39033928513526917,
-0.6134098172187805,
0.3496154248714447,
-0.4858194589614868,
-0.12331566959619522,
-0.40671977400779724,
-0.34186381101608276,
0.16688284277915955,
0.43848684430122375,
-0.302864134311676,
1.0966848134994507,
0.14088083803653717,
-0.5033550262451172,
0.7262147068977356,
0.1536438763141632,
-0.2012546956539154,
1.043054461479187,
-0.8089873194694519,
0.06732331961393356,
-0.10498842597007751,
-0.08080267161130905,
-1.043694019317627,
0.00473447609692812,
0.09958454221487045,
-0.2518446147441864,
0.19570738077163696,
0.033223431557416916,
-0.5981234312057495,
-0.6017313599586487,
-0.3529113829135895,
0.27671465277671814,
0.4022568166255951,
-0.5899208188056946,
0.5190309286117554,
0.21062351763248444,
-0.1391620635986328,
-0.14672870934009552,
-0.3518913984298706,
-0.07297710329294205,
-0.35755255818367004,
-0.6250677704811096,
0.5146846771240234,
-0.5883378386497498,
-0.2603796720504761,
-0.19558078050613403,
-0.33702516555786133,
-0.26976221799850464,
0.18968525528907776,
0.010513314977288246,
0.33809080719947815,
-0.01468860637396574,
-0.20909273624420166,
-0.12803958356380463,
-0.6487626433372498,
0.16574205458164215,
-0.4206308126449585,
0.6053854823112488,
0.4989471435546875,
-0.6169368624687195,
-0.6241370439529419,
0.9738780856132507,
0.4761461615562439,
-0.39914339780807495,
0.19868242740631104,
0.6573573350906372,
-0.23615819215774536,
-0.5984676480293274,
-0.5645170211791992,
-0.09075132012367249,
-0.565119743347168,
0.10811369866132736,
-0.5243108868598938,
-0.39648303389549255,
0.6563833951950073,
-0.08014004677534103,
0.19361139833927155,
-0.09451644122600555,
0.9168436527252197,
-0.44662734866142273,
0.826169490814209,
0.3446934223175049,
0.016966817900538445,
0.36579829454421997,
-0.5410742163658142,
0.4136645793914795,
-0.8740965127944946,
-0.10159517079591751,
-0.472981333732605,
-0.4313410222530365,
-0.35856613516807556,
-0.3071165978908539,
0.6866636276245117,
0.31647181510925293,
-0.25474783778190613,
0.35307154059410095,
-0.5705442428588867,
0.3442640006542206,
1.0649824142456055,
-0.0053259385749697685,
0.4188730716705322,
-0.00830857828259468,
-0.5873448848724365,
0.04471714422106743,
-0.7459055185317993,
-0.40057966113090515,
1.0315569639205933,
0.06684358417987823,
0.9369018077850342,
0.2570587694644928,
1.2912043333053589,
0.13093779981136322,
0.08159411698579788,
-0.7255659103393555,
0.46931540966033936,
0.19789475202560425,
-0.4284668564796448,
-0.23654505610466003,
-0.3380160629749298,
-1.0056833028793335,
0.11632301658391953,
-0.17379331588745117,
-0.5570327639579773,
0.14506401121616364,
0.005486409179866314,
-0.7304891347885132,
0.15099802613258362,
-0.4225807189941406,
0.37382271885871887,
-0.5023809671401978,
-0.4975150227546692,
-0.17737184464931488,
-0.3700910806655884,
0.1573270857334137,
-0.2059924155473709,
0.2742326557636261,
-0.1461208015680313,
-0.25113481283187866,
0.3549805283546448,
-0.8645918965339661,
0.3519468903541565,
0.021861091256141663,
-0.05737724527716637,
0.47993704676628113,
0.11034592241048813,
0.43197882175445557,
0.12740281224250793,
-0.23285029828548431,
-0.45658257603645325,
-0.12373432517051697,
-0.5639607906341553,
-0.759476363658905,
0.7024801969528198,
-0.8943300843238831,
-0.6809194684028625,
-0.10641703754663467,
-0.7317309975624084,
-0.3586466908454895,
0.04794760048389435,
0.2622793912887573,
0.478100061416626,
0.2569243907928467,
-0.03892380744218826,
0.48040226101875305,
-0.019174423068761826,
0.8215768933296204,
0.4921439588069916,
0.14289256930351257,
-0.7828680872917175,
1.1773946285247803,
0.2077292501926422,
0.3664741814136505,
0.27527502179145813,
0.21610905230045319,
-0.38900521397590637,
-1.3025885820388794,
-0.39995869994163513,
-0.012841325253248215,
-0.5806344151496887,
-0.24703946709632874,
-0.08393629640340805,
-0.38637301325798035,
-0.29051604866981506,
-0.20612800121307373,
-0.25017091631889343,
0.030196750536561012,
-0.548712968826294,
0.2365528643131256,
0.06294651329517365,
0.5019155144691467,
-0.07316680252552032,
0.1706642061471939,
-0.6621370911598206,
0.31805121898651123,
0.7355352640151978,
0.7122665643692017,
-0.15507976710796356,
-0.28049540519714355,
-0.11529707908630371,
-0.4060076177120209,
-0.5953282117843628,
-0.9792523384094238,
0.658547043800354,
-0.0020552403293550014,
1.454772710800171,
0.409463495016098,
0.1349615752696991,
0.44235172867774963,
-0.20216739177703857,
0.5429140329360962,
0.028329772874712944,
-0.6557921171188354,
0.7259833812713623,
-0.4639706611633301,
0.17768137156963348,
0.6025498509407043,
0.36528611183166504,
-0.11864578723907471,
-0.14261113107204437,
-0.6037905812263489,
-1.0204365253448486,
0.12964527308940887,
0.47881951928138733,
-0.2662772536277771,
0.454123318195343,
0.468449205160141,
0.13363343477249146,
0.34584343433380127,
-0.250568151473999,
-0.4076581597328186,
0.10194263607263565,
-0.11985447257757187,
0.0029927189461886883,
-0.2653947174549103,
-0.4220266342163086,
-0.13952243328094482,
0.7544488906860352,
-0.2438722401857376,
0.23857684433460236,
-0.11671197414398193,
-0.022275984287261963,
-0.1319682002067566,
-0.09979709982872009,
0.7076845765113831,
1.0954526662826538,
-0.2581619322299957,
-0.21512627601623535,
0.13854771852493286,
-0.22935490310192108,
0.43664586544036865,
0.00865892507135868,
-0.1891407072544098,
-0.13431143760681152,
0.2678757309913635,
0.3502483069896698,
-0.200689896941185,
-0.39674267172813416,
0.13179439306259155,
0.34630534052848816,
-0.3425755500793457,
-0.2654314339160919,
0.3310670256614685,
0.1933220475912094,
0.4407914876937866,
0.8584914207458496,
-0.18680934607982635,
0.3407473862171173,
-0.17993488907814026,
0.454007625579834,
0.5254722237586975,
-0.040855612605810165,
0.36896270513534546,
0.5530604720115662,
0.46132349967956543,
-0.9720746278762817,
0.3396871089935303,
-0.46062299609184265,
-0.18546557426452637,
0.7694564461708069,
0.6305791139602661,
0.634711742401123,
-0.04857742413878441,
0.03174598515033722,
0.3602934181690216,
-0.04777902737259865,
0.4553029239177704,
0.32259681820869446,
-0.060657888650894165,
-0.5547062754631042,
-0.6221746802330017,
-0.7837203145027161,
-0.779410719871521,
0.13324463367462158,
-0.7255847454071045,
0.2595888078212738,
-0.6632615923881531,
0.002021242631599307,
-0.31511712074279785,
0.38206151127815247,
-0.5604435205459595,
0.11925274133682251,
0.03628704696893692,
0.8950163125991821,
-0.6978805661201477,
0.3845842778682709,
0.43941208720207214,
-0.3292582631111145,
-0.8352250456809998,
-0.35422763228416443,
0.35742443799972534,
-1.1089624166488647,
0.46395719051361084,
-0.3764750361442566,
0.0003252036985941231,
0.09431034326553345,
-0.40669021010398865,
-1.1140944957733154,
1.3717563152313232,
-0.021563732996582985,
-0.4493432939052582,
0.38695603609085083,
0.13828042149543762,
0.3824025094509125,
-0.6474267840385437,
0.04002496972680092,
0.6359456181526184,
0.4747157692909241,
0.37586110830307007,
-0.6775689721107483,
-0.08780656009912491,
-0.5510823130607605,
0.6213759183883667,
0.1308356076478958,
-0.6918408274650574,
0.7189195156097412,
-0.05979139357805252,
-0.17923244833946228,
0.27431488037109375,
0.48791807889938354,
0.8355855941772461,
0.1641949713230133,
0.4482736885547638,
0.8156862854957581,
0.5754435062408447,
-0.010648125782608986,
0.7867672443389893,
-0.5429467558860779,
0.61289381980896,
0.9506675004959106,
-0.19748102128505707,
0.7135838866233826,
0.9368166923522949,
-0.5798317790031433,
0.09982674568891525,
1.1670974493026733,
-0.2707069516181946,
0.6308574676513672,
0.9090542793273926,
-0.4751591086387634,
-0.306610107421875,
-0.21845956146717072,
-0.21934205293655396,
0.2748725712299347,
0.31831851601600647,
-0.1916041225194931,
-0.4768036901950836,
-0.18745577335357666,
-0.6379621624946594,
0.13339029252529144,
-0.29804727435112,
0.6965926885604858,
-0.148113414645195,
-0.5720458626747131,
0.40579336881637573,
-0.2343921810388565,
0.7252657413482666,
-0.09693949669599533,
0.15395307540893555,
-0.47306013107299805,
-0.10403703153133392,
-0.24925827980041504,
-0.643671452999115,
0.22131413221359253,
-0.6196032166481018,
-0.15114809572696686,
-0.4664965569972992,
0.4596253037452698,
-0.21644710004329681,
-0.7852394580841064,
-0.0779154971241951,
0.8058109879493713,
0.013962467201054096,
0.26188892126083374,
-0.5075499415397644,
0.14879082143306732,
-0.2545919120311737,
-0.09721213579177856,
0.17679515480995178,
0.0762174129486084,
0.33703529834747314,
0.804458737373352,
0.9026208519935608,
0.27637791633605957,
-0.019074151292443275,
0.09135756641626358,
0.8233321309089661,
-0.4517115652561188,
-0.5317763686180115,
-0.6309958696365356,
0.47915124893188477,
-0.2200719565153122,
-0.3956117033958435,
0.2906776964664459,
0.654683530330658,
0.6653360724449158,
0.06693102419376373,
0.7346422672271729,
0.6064854860305786,
0.4963165521621704,
-0.7725286483764648,
0.33945003151893616,
-0.34540989995002747,
0.3776662051677704,
-0.17793132364749908,
-1.2877144813537598,
-0.30779361724853516,
0.6447398066520691,
-0.011703411117196083,
-0.004143004305660725,
0.6117191910743713,
0.9663735628128052,
0.05102774500846863,
-0.03443967178463936,
0.10899211466312408,
-0.3845715820789337,
0.6488891243934631,
0.859607994556427,
0.9554438591003418,
0.10727144777774811,
0.6151893734931946,
-0.3019791543483734,
-0.3710702657699585,
-0.5612541437149048,
-1.0511142015457153,
-0.5099085569381714,
-0.3676195740699768,
-0.34519270062446594,
-0.18079878389835358,
-0.09810292720794678,
1.0534284114837646,
1.0953607559204102,
-0.793821394443512,
-0.5904334783554077,
-0.35388779640197754,
-0.015282349660992622,
-0.30305102467536926,
-0.2974938750267029,
-0.0193962212651968,
-0.7646083235740662,
-0.5828278064727783,
0.3090185821056366,
0.520592987537384,
0.12310589104890823,
-0.9040738344192505,
-0.0322471484541893,
0.09431379288434982,
0.20209358632564545,
0.41097864508628845,
-0.054682835936546326,
-0.6464559435844421,
-0.21747364103794098,
0.20480096340179443,
-0.07353470474481583,
0.2715126574039459,
1.1308231353759766,
-0.5453192591667175,
0.4267488420009613,
0.7573411464691162,
0.9121685028076172,
0.8383423686027527,
0.12136129289865494,
0.835080623626709,
-0.5757039189338684,
-0.13902708888053894,
0.3539772629737854,
0.42534345388412476,
-0.008277790620923042,
-0.4402683675289154,
0.6003012657165527,
0.34100961685180664,
-0.5677752494812012,
-0.40730342268943787,
0.574912965297699,
-1.2064905166625977,
-0.18010228872299194,
1.0648077726364136,
-0.07564797252416611,
-0.016192499548196793,
-0.1965435892343521,
-0.22851969301700592,
-0.07199619710445404,
-0.24219995737075806,
0.8116520643234253,
0.856440007686615,
-0.9991276264190674,
-0.23641112446784973,
-0.39724841713905334,
0.026074836030602455,
0.37226858735084534,
-0.8765869140625,
-0.5164652466773987,
0.33152440190315247,
0.2770625650882721,
0.18924055993556976,
0.3355000913143158,
-0.08661569654941559,
0.1615900695323944,
-0.16971078515052795,
-0.2868621349334717,
-0.42240089178085327,
-0.006837246008217335,
-0.06505347043275833,
0.5821574330329895,
0.18476121127605438,
-0.34886685013771057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09250v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09250v1
|
New Textual Corpora for Serbian Language Modeling
| 2024-05-15T11:05:16 | 2024-05-15T11:05:16 |
Mihailo Škorić, Nikola Janković
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper will present textual corpora for Serbian (and Serbo-Croatian),
usable for the training of large language models and publicly available at one
of the several notable online repositories. Each corpus will be classified
using multiple methods and its characteristics will be detailed. Additionally,
the paper will introduce three new corpora: a new umbrella web corpus of
Serbo-Croatian, a new high-quality corpus based on the doctoral dissertations
stored within National Repository of Doctoral Dissertations from all
Universities in Serbia, and a parallel corpus of abstract translation from the
same source. The uniqueness of both old and new corpora will be accessed via
frequency-based stylometric methods, and the results will be briefly discussed.
|
[
-0.472939133644104,
-0.5821239352226257,
0.49443405866622925,
0.4675288498401642,
-0.18927812576293945,
0.16675733029842377,
-0.5272568464279175,
-0.576271653175354,
0.3930628001689911,
0.735691487789154,
-0.3354339003562927,
-0.8567118644714355,
-0.5455049276351929,
0.4788765609264374,
-0.49521470069885254,
0.9993621706962585,
-0.4819534420967102,
0.5512238144874573,
-0.21106593310832977,
-0.11701759696006775,
-0.05069953203201294,
-0.505153477191925,
0.28986063599586487,
0.08633401989936829,
0.4620608687400818,
0.4109249711036682,
0.5250909328460693,
0.27867215871810913,
0.558579683303833,
0.350897878408432,
0.1601496785879135,
-0.29662707448005676,
-0.07047855854034424,
0.3838137984275818,
-0.21049445867538452,
-0.36986562609672546,
-0.4547577500343323,
0.021828025579452515,
0.837842583656311,
0.8873195052146912,
-0.17406582832336426,
0.40193694829940796,
-0.23740233480930328,
0.5006338357925415,
-0.6658394932746887,
0.5127455592155457,
-0.3642273545265198,
-0.19409191608428955,
-0.4089605212211609,
-0.18432670831680298,
-0.6249796748161316,
-0.5674816966056824,
0.24597285687923431,
-0.9260536432266235,
0.14355912804603577,
0.047997672110795975,
0.6988547444343567,
-0.01816306635737419,
-0.44958022236824036,
-0.655886709690094,
-0.6323155164718628,
0.7059300541877747,
-0.4352070391178131,
0.45426034927368164,
0.41343656182289124,
0.4549630880355835,
0.05776418745517731,
-0.6716230511665344,
-0.1830190122127533,
-0.27418890595436096,
0.11848019063472748,
0.02730661816895008,
-0.19570881128311157,
0.034099336713552475,
-0.05600462108850479,
0.34403541684150696,
-0.5539580583572388,
-0.020763086155056953,
-0.6117388010025024,
-0.16323280334472656,
0.5623608827590942,
-0.014164733700454235,
0.3887181878089905,
-0.1118713989853859,
-0.16064296662807465,
0.1574346423149109,
-0.5688959360122681,
-0.44265419244766235,
0.7769866585731506,
0.18538634479045868,
-0.2164008766412735,
0.931005597114563,
-0.35721689462661743,
0.6476610898971558,
-0.19734029471874237,
-0.42205458879470825,
0.6829544305801392,
-0.3747314214706421,
0.0030014996882528067,
0.18198223412036896,
0.49895477294921875,
0.01583709381520748,
0.29150936007499695,
-0.13187874853610992,
0.11510513722896576,
0.30770963430404663,
0.14208753407001495,
-0.5374305248260498,
-0.48239564895629883,
-0.07851282507181168,
-0.6021179556846619,
-0.306063175201416,
0.2148253321647644,
-0.7415087819099426,
0.09676147252321243,
-0.5600219368934631,
-0.09333667159080505,
-0.45200079679489136,
-0.3075375258922577,
0.11231561750173569,
-0.05986325070261955,
-0.1714470237493515,
0.21304553747177124,
-0.9291425943374634,
0.6347628831863403,
0.5791869759559631,
0.7023144960403442,
-0.47880861163139343,
-0.35389450192451477,
-0.19372905790805817,
0.11252498626708984,
-0.46084296703338623,
0.7472493052482605,
-0.6487703323364258,
0.13801328837871552,
0.2285357266664505,
0.25560563802719116,
0.13506066799163818,
-0.41038206219673157,
0.7629715204238892,
-0.585595965385437,
0.32665956020355225,
0.17288754880428314,
-0.4986896514892578,
-0.2758076786994934,
0.002462107688188553,
-0.8130181431770325,
1.0725877285003662,
0.5665510892868042,
-1.1129062175750732,
0.15908075869083405,
-0.595014750957489,
-0.1766575127840042,
0.2951565086841583,
0.1730654090642929,
-0.12108678370714188,
0.16929969191551208,
-0.10195175558328629,
0.45568132400512695,
-0.40906375646591187,
0.5764787793159485,
-0.370613694190979,
-0.008452421985566616,
0.34007877111434937,
0.00395902618765831,
0.9635730385780334,
0.4478991627693176,
0.0529945082962513,
0.25558504462242126,
-1.2199289798736572,
0.21084147691726685,
-0.26713818311691284,
-0.5159042477607727,
-0.6186510920524597,
-0.04189470410346985,
0.4989243447780609,
0.18340881168842316,
0.3420529067516327,
-0.624554455280304,
0.27987104654312134,
-0.540484607219696,
0.27436894178390503,
0.22448483109474182,
-0.02274792455136776,
0.6489289402961731,
-0.01351277343928814,
0.756037175655365,
-0.08088476210832596,
-0.09507862478494644,
-0.004651182796806097,
-0.7190992832183838,
-0.40285372734069824,
-0.5210750699043274,
0.6847112774848938,
0.4112413823604584,
-0.958644688129425,
0.32064196467399597,
-0.1664557158946991,
-0.6038207411766052,
-0.5085172653198242,
-0.3181958794593811,
0.3952728509902954,
0.035829078406095505,
0.277238130569458,
-0.47153204679489136,
-1.1209403276443481,
-0.7233307361602783,
0.0441216416656971,
-0.18646201491355896,
-0.15796519815921783,
0.012857060879468918,
0.7678333520889282,
-0.27900147438049316,
0.9217709302902222,
-0.29294922947883606,
0.15041987597942352,
-0.3194904923439026,
0.43080106377601624,
-0.11979703605175018,
0.2718556225299835,
0.6788723468780518,
-0.6644402146339417,
-0.459390252828598,
-0.11504290997982025,
-0.6286830306053162,
-0.5074922442436218,
0.37939924001693726,
0.02034619450569153,
0.6973962783813477,
0.19229653477668762,
-0.37616097927093506,
0.02509748563170433,
0.9094678163528442,
-0.2615180015563965,
0.9159182906150818,
-0.20671451091766357,
0.15421321988105774,
-1.0687038898468018,
-0.023931866511702538,
-0.05878804251551628,
0.017875822260975838,
-0.6481255888938904,
0.23505012691020966,
0.20544861257076263,
-0.0874088704586029,
-0.7419662475585938,
0.47450920939445496,
-0.7535812854766846,
-0.5765584707260132,
-0.18139375746250153,
0.21194863319396973,
-0.16527238488197327,
0.3194490969181061,
0.11349637806415558,
0.5939852595329285,
0.7038074731826782,
-0.5107289552688599,
0.6060037612915039,
0.5856610536575317,
-0.8358758687973022,
0.3621087968349457,
-0.40934473276138306,
-0.2533758282661438,
-0.19783316552639008,
0.38670021295547485,
-0.7266632914543152,
-0.5614169239997864,
0.37819209694862366,
-0.42882391810417175,
0.30619481205940247,
-0.4492957293987274,
-0.3688398599624634,
-0.2285313904285431,
-0.23905529081821442,
0.4720217287540436,
0.12547554075717926,
-0.2348780781030655,
0.19586418569087982,
0.7151106595993042,
-0.6678115725517273,
-0.3727263808250427,
-0.6190811991691589,
0.2005576640367508,
-0.06732629239559174,
-0.7370515465736389,
0.3887527287006378,
-0.18228375911712646,
-0.5182707905769348,
0.039442092180252075,
0.46885278820991516,
-0.4287561774253845,
0.19602975249290466,
0.2050987184047699,
0.6865066885948181,
-0.38276246190071106,
0.10593898594379425,
0.010501828975975513,
-0.22415791451931,
-0.012228392995893955,
-0.47292348742485046,
0.7270638942718506,
-0.06499458849430084,
-0.15334555506706238,
-0.418242484331131,
0.6845096349716187,
0.49130988121032715,
-0.3044058382511139,
0.7685602307319641,
0.40105482935905457,
-0.2929750084877014,
0.11641574651002884,
-0.4516504108905792,
0.2885884642601013,
-0.36991605162620544,
0.3391420841217041,
-0.44765833020210266,
-0.7369914054870605,
0.3524281978607178,
-0.05040151998400688,
-0.22944939136505127,
0.42218732833862305,
0.9771444797515869,
0.20191478729248047,
0.8628258109092712,
0.6766337156295776,
0.03932179510593414,
0.40164732933044434,
-0.08264244347810745,
0.09731144458055496,
-0.81986403465271,
-0.382007360458374,
-0.9284138083457947,
0.0875132605433464,
-0.9289532899856567,
-0.38587746024131775,
-0.12876741588115692,
0.01319075282663107,
-0.24966658651828766,
0.7474310994148254,
-0.5186095833778381,
0.32914021611213684,
0.570470929145813,
-0.44750046730041504,
0.45571503043174744,
0.04997916519641876,
-0.2269529402256012,
-0.1466851383447647,
-0.49658361077308655,
-0.99432772397995,
1.2015137672424316,
0.31440991163253784,
0.777330756187439,
0.02330811135470867,
0.6086944937705994,
-0.15337243676185608,
0.3002350330352783,
-0.674181342124939,
0.3988151550292969,
0.017284749075770378,
-1.0866774320602417,
-0.1944911926984787,
-0.5372807383537292,
-0.7196076512336731,
0.12952286005020142,
-0.3735177218914032,
-0.6485213041305542,
0.3375704884529114,
-0.20669129490852356,
0.3357853889465332,
0.024842020124197006,
-0.6234016418457031,
0.8374375700950623,
-0.07110302895307541,
0.0262078195810318,
0.11688292026519775,
-0.5660240054130554,
0.34014803171157837,
0.054937295615673065,
0.3316681385040283,
-0.3727607727050781,
-0.3589325547218323,
0.7379501461982727,
0.13278977572917938,
0.42053624987602234,
-0.058555033057928085,
-0.1814897209405899,
0.1375354528427124,
0.1894816905260086,
0.27575936913490295,
-0.1338016539812088,
-0.13099347054958344,
0.2789328396320343,
0.37751394510269165,
-0.32768312096595764,
-0.15933848917484283,
0.41746050119400024,
-0.7022489309310913,
-0.0273884329944849,
-0.7054938673973083,
-0.6076721549034119,
-0.05529836565256119,
0.23766514658927917,
0.4776977598667145,
0.5321826338768005,
-0.5736985206604004,
0.38564667105674744,
0.3639637529850006,
-0.528466522693634,
0.11013603210449219,
0.6747581362724304,
-0.1803843379020691,
-0.55521160364151,
0.7947415709495544,
0.22521941363811493,
0.26861584186553955,
0.27131137251853943,
-0.11488337069749832,
-0.16096298396587372,
-0.8425599336624146,
-0.38741010427474976,
0.3231813609600067,
-0.5377928018569946,
-0.20088322460651398,
-0.6689932942390442,
-0.004305692855268717,
-0.7296013236045837,
-0.0937114730477333,
-0.2413148581981659,
-0.8693917989730835,
-0.3384881019592285,
-0.06056082621216774,
0.2128206193447113,
0.9389042854309082,
0.12939606606960297,
-0.02638235129415989,
-0.599064290523529,
0.3296562135219574,
-0.4570842683315277,
0.43924981355667114,
-0.38641470670700073,
-0.25223982334136963,
-0.251995712518692,
0.08771799504756927,
-0.2722172439098358,
-0.973990797996521,
0.828389585018158,
0.12925180792808533,
0.5269814729690552,
0.14039619266986847,
0.264710932970047,
0.10065768659114838,
-0.7108144760131836,
0.6785085797309875,
0.29424673318862915,
-0.8208189010620117,
0.36583322286605835,
-0.6358216404914856,
0.0045318081974983215,
0.5272772908210754,
0.9150686264038086,
-0.5229284167289734,
-0.5953450202941895,
-0.5018448233604431,
-0.8981745839118958,
0.7325423955917358,
0.06210440769791603,
-0.0534617118537426,
-0.18915493786334991,
0.059488289058208466,
0.36716148257255554,
0.31898394227027893,
-0.6445517539978027,
-0.31683745980262756,
-0.29308202862739563,
-0.5568322539329529,
-0.08633560687303543,
-0.6113366484642029,
-0.1273745745420456,
-0.2829933166503906,
0.8641036748886108,
-0.13143324851989746,
0.31357142329216003,
-0.22264991700649261,
-0.30450186133384705,
0.06371185928583145,
0.5980291366577148,
0.6113579869270325,
0.8607067465782166,
-0.08798312395811081,
0.10794024914503098,
0.1774943768978119,
-0.5388661026954651,
0.27874085307121277,
-0.08704628795385361,
-0.26970839500427246,
0.37844404578208923,
0.1843252182006836,
0.6488213539123535,
0.9185073971748352,
-0.6461653113365173,
0.46639952063560486,
0.14187076687812805,
-0.6033320426940918,
-0.8421401977539062,
-0.26495298743247986,
0.3341597020626068,
0.08377661556005478,
0.24857115745544434,
-0.06309807300567627,
0.32913219928741455,
-0.9521805047988892,
0.048450637608766556,
-0.02890532836318016,
-0.04991539195179939,
-0.29664620757102966,
0.4057026207447052,
0.061855290085077286,
-0.3066876530647278,
0.1836465746164322,
-0.25456783175468445,
-0.5624048113822937,
0.20463602244853973,
0.804236114025116,
0.4898127615451813,
-0.14179809391498566,
0.4768519699573517,
0.44436487555503845,
-0.19625906646251678,
-0.5194761157035828,
0.23197083175182343,
0.09754954278469086,
-0.48572838306427,
-0.20767620205879211,
-0.8639901876449585,
-0.6972096562385559,
-0.43593278527259827,
-0.8305308818817139,
0.4027586579322815,
-0.16003867983818054,
0.10108716785907745,
0.21184706687927246,
0.2040279060602188,
-0.05798768252134323,
-0.07057349383831024,
0.04305649548768997,
0.906196117401123,
-0.7687221169471741,
1.1414778232574463,
0.432331383228302,
-0.6371472477912903,
-0.39838677644729614,
-0.5118170976638794,
-0.046335093677043915,
-0.34115707874298096,
0.8791670203208923,
-0.22154049575328827,
-0.07265623658895493,
-0.20097748935222626,
-0.5150624513626099,
-1.2757620811462402,
0.9891328811645508,
0.6017012596130371,
-0.4178336262702942,
-0.3903889060020447,
-0.03480459004640579,
0.6220113635063171,
-0.5851008296012878,
0.23836064338684082,
0.4250338077545166,
0.5501397252082825,
-0.19341902434825897,
-0.8405730128288269,
-0.3138217031955719,
-0.4377728998661041,
0.21067646145820618,
0.13625818490982056,
-0.038465339690446854,
0.9938856959342957,
0.4007500410079956,
-0.3430531919002533,
0.5956929922103882,
0.6774813532829285,
0.24687336385250092,
0.19041813910007477,
-0.05120157077908516,
0.3261263966560364,
0.6803046464920044,
-0.32360851764678955,
0.9866259694099426,
-0.4996431767940521,
0.27659204602241516,
1.1787598133087158,
-0.36473938822746277,
1.0002275705337524,
0.21257540583610535,
-0.16039863228797913,
0.7543492317199707,
0.4454686641693115,
-0.20116743445396423,
0.4115160405635834,
0.341185599565506,
-0.37717026472091675,
0.20202238857746124,
0.07725651562213898,
-0.5582879185676575,
0.48584097623825073,
0.2027018815279007,
-0.23482482135295868,
-0.005246922839432955,
0.4424799978733063,
0.0649949461221695,
0.3054894804954529,
-0.10513424128293991,
0.6826331615447998,
-0.21508808434009552,
-0.6250839233398438,
0.40145403146743774,
0.3872030973434448,
0.8416285514831543,
-0.5146278142929077,
0.2866950035095215,
0.2934080958366394,
0.10378313064575195,
-0.31139442324638367,
-0.5077810287475586,
0.5653355121612549,
0.2434011846780777,
-0.18798041343688965,
-0.37485820055007935,
0.5933412909507751,
-0.5509334206581116,
-0.7619090676307678,
0.5097711086273193,
0.16650034487247467,
0.5342326760292053,
0.14193925261497498,
-0.26922667026519775,
0.16479891538619995,
-0.5033076405525208,
-0.1839541494846344,
0.3609522581100464,
0.6508621573448181,
-0.07204663753509521,
0.6920448541641235,
0.4898408353328705,
0.36706751585006714,
0.31680965423583984,
0.2943632900714874,
0.688679039478302,
-0.5534992814064026,
-0.4351879954338074,
-0.08552973717451096,
0.10731885582208633,
-0.024981485679745674,
-0.38520997762680054,
0.8686442375183105,
0.7888770699501038,
1.145117163658142,
-0.34369271993637085,
0.7977139949798584,
-0.12062092125415802,
0.83681720495224,
-0.4392539858818054,
0.7325514554977417,
-0.16489140689373016,
-0.03814290836453438,
-0.6082612872123718,
-1.040696382522583,
-0.408688485622406,
0.7640318274497986,
-0.3086160123348236,
-0.24649837613105774,
0.8909159898757935,
0.5712886452674866,
0.085499607026577,
0.31750133633613586,
0.23913948237895966,
0.2685980796813965,
-0.09859486669301987,
0.2704615890979767,
0.7670531272888184,
-0.33419325947761536,
0.5139322876930237,
-0.13523125648498535,
-0.12260198593139648,
-0.3717924654483795,
-0.6965377926826477,
-0.4858608841896057,
-1.0246919393539429,
-0.3238605260848999,
-0.15176378190517426,
0.11562364548444748,
1.1539033651351929,
0.5087310671806335,
-1.06220543384552,
-0.3122510313987732,
-0.11347192525863647,
-0.13034316897392273,
0.08858883380889893,
-0.15676018595695496,
0.03995520621538162,
-0.3643691837787628,
-0.7483821511268616,
0.33618253469467163,
0.20743079483509064,
0.05301851034164429,
-0.34184014797210693,
-0.2404264360666275,
-0.528183102607727,
-0.10326255857944489,
0.5451699495315552,
0.15473376214504242,
-0.6262246370315552,
-0.2729203402996063,
-0.045404158532619476,
-0.2919040620326996,
0.1742589920759201,
0.9321443438529968,
-0.5918101072311401,
0.0800255760550499,
0.7045750617980957,
0.18475131690502167,
0.6617137789726257,
-0.3133574426174164,
0.5852327346801758,
-0.45720618963241577,
0.3661663234233856,
0.34150171279907227,
0.5503718852996826,
0.4523533582687378,
0.2325533628463745,
0.46704718470573425,
0.21882237493991852,
-0.3528746962547302,
-0.7529014945030212,
0.21483241021633148,
-1.0939210653305054,
-0.4592214822769165,
1.1341851949691772,
-0.42488014698028564,
-0.3443934917449951,
-0.6461918354034424,
-0.31078389286994934,
0.3562997877597809,
-0.22808529436588287,
0.5958258509635925,
0.9833033680915833,
0.44977983832359314,
-0.19134259223937988,
-0.6763842105865479,
0.42714303731918335,
-0.3062833249568939,
-0.9600711464881897,
0.20102421939373016,
0.7020153999328613,
0.41019004583358765,
0.23139934241771698,
0.5213912129402161,
-0.5719980597496033,
0.22949303686618805,
0.1354459822177887,
0.35317346453666687,
-0.10491012781858444,
-0.8038411140441895,
-0.2396533191204071,
0.35055646300315857,
-0.1060967668890953,
0.18807610869407654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16893v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16893v1
|
A Survey on Transformers in NLP with Focus on Efficiency
| 2024-05-15T10:32:41 | 2024-05-15T10:32:41 |
Wazib Ansar, Saptarsi Goswami, Amlan Chakrabarti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advent of transformers with attention mechanisms and associated
pre-trained models have revolutionized the field of Natural Language Processing
(NLP). However, such models are resource-intensive due to highly complex
architecture. This limits their application to resource-constrained
environments. While choosing an appropriate NLP model, a major trade-off exists
over choosing accuracy over efficiency and vice versa. This paper presents a
commentary on the evolution of NLP and its applications with emphasis on their
accuracy as-well-as efficiency. Following this, a survey of research
contributions towards enhancing the efficiency of transformer-based models at
various stages of model development along with hardware considerations has been
conducted. The goal of this survey is to determine how current NLP techniques
contribute towards a sustainable society and to establish a foundation for
future research.
|
[
-0.5328994393348694,
-0.49550360441207886,
0.3225443959236145,
0.3179275691509247,
0.1652802675962448,
-0.027241995558142662,
-0.3567221462726593,
-0.5712149143218994,
-0.03754961118102074,
0.444241464138031,
-0.3727381229400635,
-0.04282638058066368,
-0.6990458965301514,
0.49850142002105713,
-0.5573325157165527,
0.6776278614997864,
0.3085339069366455,
-0.15901726484298706,
-0.1997028887271881,
-0.30520540475845337,
-0.29504716396331787,
-0.511063277721405,
-0.7141668796539307,
-0.40263891220092773,
0.20840568840503693,
-0.005729449447244406,
0.8985562324523926,
0.2298581600189209,
0.9604616761207581,
0.45616257190704346,
-0.24709172546863556,
0.05855729058384895,
-0.30801957845687866,
0.3619420528411865,
-0.35522693395614624,
-0.429186075925827,
-0.39680102467536926,
-0.04829185828566551,
0.5675771832466125,
0.6316746473312378,
-0.2100430279970169,
0.4923613369464874,
0.2711348235607147,
0.6062437891960144,
-0.7003155946731567,
0.19525283575057983,
-0.6312627792358398,
0.1885032057762146,
-0.0898275151848793,
-0.41498833894729614,
-0.6761412024497986,
-0.16495494544506073,
0.33969545364379883,
-0.48671388626098633,
0.45283231139183044,
0.052478041499853134,
0.5524868965148926,
0.7959482073783875,
0.07163316756486893,
-0.33562618494033813,
-1.1598742008209229,
1.193260908126831,
-0.6422505378723145,
0.7838649749755859,
0.006243498995900154,
0.3218736946582794,
0.1233668327331543,
-0.9759775400161743,
-0.34277382493019104,
-0.08015885949134827,
-0.33078667521476746,
0.27584129571914673,
-0.5574617981910706,
-0.030168384313583374,
0.38982683420181274,
0.24437806010246277,
-0.20775921642780304,
0.21986764669418335,
-0.20294088125228882,
0.12074736505746841,
0.4295167028903961,
-0.016530118882656097,
0.2589888274669647,
-0.41318100690841675,
-0.062406353652477264,
-0.1870553344488144,
-0.190101757645607,
0.07827558368444443,
0.22368796169757843,
0.20348644256591797,
0.27160754799842834,
0.6967319846153259,
-0.08553258329629898,
0.8571640849113464,
-0.05263158679008484,
-0.2330358624458313,
-0.08169280737638474,
-0.4934508800506592,
-0.22580377757549286,
-0.17629486322402954,
0.5268931984901428,
0.40738072991371155,
0.2091408222913742,
-0.4310428500175476,
-0.16551879048347473,
0.11438842862844467,
0.855876088142395,
-0.48484915494918823,
-0.1976233273744583,
0.00310731353238225,
-0.5703837871551514,
-0.3524373769760132,
-0.26499155163764954,
-0.8770557045936584,
-0.07996369898319244,
-0.3315032124519348,
0.046706393361091614,
-0.17828108370304108,
-0.1993682086467743,
0.2788993716239929,
-0.10754348337650299,
0.20523883402347565,
0.08887942880392075,
-1.0803638696670532,
0.3939318060874939,
0.7157564759254456,
0.8837515711784363,
-0.14884209632873535,
0.165736585855484,
-0.16764426231384277,
-0.07253848761320114,
0.10452158004045486,
0.8975355625152588,
-0.35074087977409363,
-0.32003992795944214,
-0.02065344713628292,
-0.15435244143009186,
-0.0296392273157835,
-0.45651888847351074,
1.0958391427993774,
-0.5259720683097839,
0.1627517193555832,
-0.11851418763399124,
-0.17184509336948395,
-0.22605814039707184,
0.08740521222352982,
-0.7824841141700745,
1.071094274520874,
0.2715422213077545,
-0.924562394618988,
0.2564224600791931,
-1.1730751991271973,
-0.5082979798316956,
0.039175111800432205,
0.44439810514450073,
-0.2696400582790375,
0.3807066082954407,
0.24950270354747772,
0.5120034217834473,
-0.5122944116592407,
0.3169058859348297,
0.2823389172554016,
-0.23046931624412537,
0.09882847219705582,
-0.6829677224159241,
0.6903864741325378,
0.19590957462787628,
-0.3552034795284271,
-0.07461981475353241,
-0.7628394961357117,
-0.0008478667587041855,
-0.10012922435998917,
-0.22856654226779938,
-0.2744373083114624,
0.18401409685611725,
0.15467846393585205,
0.23517461121082306,
0.06802068650722504,
-0.3913751542568207,
-0.0921296551823616,
-0.4790964424610138,
0.4450295865535736,
0.5665246248245239,
-0.3805842399597168,
0.6691468358039856,
-0.1487293839454651,
0.685818612575531,
-0.6074310541152954,
0.4612862169742584,
-0.1269722580909729,
-0.5089832544326782,
-0.994167149066925,
0.01314396969974041,
0.39607107639312744,
0.42694544792175293,
-0.4942244589328766,
0.6233643889427185,
-0.4382319748401642,
-0.7118253111839294,
-0.7599067687988281,
-0.10475423187017441,
-0.10613660514354706,
0.365715354681015,
0.6157656311988831,
-0.13982902467250824,
-0.7565538883209229,
-0.9276856780052185,
-0.46917998790740967,
0.03213786706328392,
-0.1260979026556015,
0.3668076694011688,
0.06850160658359528,
-0.2458636611700058,
1.1199527978897095,
-0.5258069038391113,
0.039269059896469116,
-0.6659587621688843,
-0.1689348816871643,
0.22015099227428436,
0.49736520648002625,
0.5889159440994263,
-0.8594266772270203,
-0.4691809117794037,
-0.13045647740364075,
-0.5985087752342224,
-0.2996688485145569,
-0.19896377623081207,
-0.16200204193592072,
0.061091504991054535,
0.45657411217689514,
-0.8699678778648376,
0.1483146697282791,
0.737941324710846,
0.08460807055234909,
0.39864102005958557,
-0.016246100887656212,
-0.07140056788921356,
-0.8071051836013794,
0.33185216784477234,
0.172775536775589,
-0.296797513961792,
-0.8668711185455322,
0.0616217702627182,
-0.22300909459590912,
-0.02557789720594883,
-0.3212180733680725,
0.26293420791625977,
-0.3730340301990509,
-0.010793953202664852,
-0.1702451854944229,
0.1240939199924469,
-0.04615398496389389,
0.24757112562656403,
0.05905560031533241,
0.7699559330940247,
0.22761888802051544,
-0.738804280757904,
0.2747267186641693,
0.21976469457149506,
-0.3194662928581238,
0.4510378837585449,
-0.7672832012176514,
0.03831978514790535,
-0.19559992849826813,
-0.04305701702833176,
-0.5609381198883057,
0.08173185586929321,
0.12492483109235764,
-0.2948248088359833,
0.3411504626274109,
0.3271585702896118,
-0.3966008424758911,
-0.6034964919090271,
-0.1129746288061142,
0.07057387381792068,
0.7392244338989258,
-0.5007455945014954,
0.8002617359161377,
0.4806974530220032,
-0.1950952410697937,
-0.7040336728096008,
-0.6490378975868225,
0.09601055830717087,
-0.10386953502893448,
-0.595466673374176,
0.3061581552028656,
0.1607387810945511,
-0.4066186249256134,
-0.1035662293434143,
-0.2683810293674469,
0.11693116277456284,
0.2752019166946411,
-0.09675760567188263,
0.06011106073856354,
-0.12945008277893066,
0.40604591369628906,
-0.3253883421421051,
-0.23602870106697083,
0.15522846579551697,
-0.22107258439064026,
0.7913020253181458,
-0.06917548179626465,
-0.12663356959819794,
-0.529922366142273,
0.3131456673145294,
0.28574901819229126,
-0.2620336413383484,
0.7356417179107666,
0.4526294767856598,
-0.05375958979129791,
-0.11952120065689087,
-0.7511706948280334,
-0.12433230876922607,
-0.5283113718032837,
0.5535033345222473,
0.030012795701622963,
-0.6859766840934753,
0.1315630078315735,
-0.2992645800113678,
0.42781683802604675,
0.7481614351272583,
0.24906736612319946,
-0.02197139710187912,
0.8082504868507385,
1.1459704637527466,
0.1459735631942749,
0.5927263498306274,
-0.2981385588645935,
0.6414787769317627,
-0.9576284885406494,
-0.07410968840122223,
-0.9340994358062744,
-0.36705413460731506,
-0.7943875789642334,
-0.34106898307800293,
0.15864598751068115,
-0.1567223072052002,
0.047161784023046494,
0.7778919339179993,
-1.0322908163070679,
0.21171028912067413,
0.4421983063220978,
-0.1827847808599472,
0.44542163610458374,
-0.230032816529274,
0.556353747844696,
-0.1637435257434845,
-1.0569099187850952,
-0.7154850363731384,
0.989082396030426,
0.29778265953063965,
0.5819234848022461,
-0.021233534440398216,
0.25243672728538513,
0.2404496967792511,
0.500790536403656,
-0.7755891680717468,
0.41567063331604004,
-0.16958361864089966,
-0.518561065196991,
-0.4498988389968872,
-0.32768723368644714,
-0.9355452060699463,
0.10025035589933395,
-0.22215215861797333,
-0.5064831972122192,
0.08846057206392288,
0.08376123011112213,
-0.3011022210121155,
0.4251877963542938,
-0.6346950531005859,
0.7984911799430847,
-0.16905075311660767,
-0.1489391028881073,
-0.1742035448551178,
-0.573763370513916,
0.33364787697792053,
-0.22558951377868652,
-0.12529867887496948,
0.08509677648544312,
0.08403337001800537,
0.7088717222213745,
-0.031114468351006508,
0.3983641564846039,
-0.017590871080756187,
0.03427261859178543,
0.3090287744998932,
-0.5423722267150879,
0.46650683879852295,
-0.2591807544231415,
-0.37045976519584656,
0.16579467058181763,
-0.46404826641082764,
-0.09298437088727951,
-0.5653597712516785,
0.347854346036911,
-0.3593316972255707,
-0.5719605684280396,
-0.21342246234416962,
-0.5065525770187378,
-0.20540548861026764,
0.14312046766281128,
0.26856911182403564,
0.30853816866874695,
-0.1247967928647995,
0.6008886694908142,
0.603147029876709,
-0.2862820327281952,
0.7755994200706482,
0.07429278641939163,
-0.03085791878402233,
0.0799512043595314,
0.35931167006492615,
0.3527011275291443,
0.40231215953826904,
0.436323344707489,
0.020198773592710495,
-0.48574674129486084,
-0.38284027576446533,
-0.10604952275753021,
-0.06748094409704208,
-0.7071606516838074,
-0.46778982877731323,
-1.2452564239501953,
-0.18603795766830444,
-0.4100187122821808,
-0.41398969292640686,
-0.6776948571205139,
-0.43975818157196045,
-0.16485001146793365,
-0.13682709634304047,
0.23734453320503235,
0.6477581858634949,
0.08328971266746521,
0.40588700771331787,
-0.7008064389228821,
0.5385875701904297,
0.39745911955833435,
0.4473792314529419,
0.24334587156772614,
-0.16960352659225464,
-0.3476901352405548,
-0.13268481194972992,
-0.46988147497177124,
-0.5654951930046082,
0.48133397102355957,
0.2276502251625061,
0.6487383246421814,
0.1304730921983719,
0.21973516047000885,
0.33973461389541626,
-0.43763068318367004,
0.8309350609779358,
0.19504529237747192,
-0.9404726624488831,
0.3966657221317291,
0.062058620154857635,
0.3685401678085327,
0.46427860856056213,
0.3165079951286316,
-0.6699498891830444,
-0.33497852087020874,
-0.788115382194519,
-0.9045417308807373,
0.7312793731689453,
0.4052538573741913,
0.30494073033332825,
0.25792768597602844,
0.2187201827764511,
0.09498635679483414,
0.1798945814371109,
-0.5171617269515991,
-0.2866441011428833,
-0.32089999318122864,
-0.050495781004428864,
-0.16953016817569733,
-0.1121840849518776,
0.296828955411911,
-0.3271292448043823,
0.602080762386322,
-0.0714590921998024,
0.30183422565460205,
0.22445762157440186,
-0.21221013367176056,
0.23597893118858337,
0.5242705345153809,
0.25036168098449707,
0.5651226043701172,
0.05917275324463844,
0.06729225069284439,
0.4451439380645752,
-0.6310776472091675,
0.15617682039737701,
-0.1740046590566635,
-0.38170716166496277,
0.3263970911502838,
0.20745329558849335,
0.6554379463195801,
0.4219496548175812,
-0.5050489902496338,
0.17833992838859558,
-0.21211308240890503,
0.2425573319196701,
-0.20398324728012085,
0.12901292741298676,
0.16734832525253296,
0.12909293174743652,
0.281432569026947,
0.7995928525924683,
0.38138699531555176,
-0.36070314049720764,
0.056335728615522385,
0.41270408034324646,
-0.2756514251232147,
-0.21740533411502838,
0.6459551453590393,
0.40510767698287964,
-0.6738929748535156,
0.6639842391014099,
0.012286392971873283,
-0.5579388737678528,
0.3623216152191162,
0.530142068862915,
1.120951771736145,
-0.17148305475711823,
0.09261474013328552,
0.3547401428222656,
0.5137696266174316,
-0.19623830914497375,
-0.1283501237630844,
-0.3734280467033386,
-0.7793027758598328,
-0.6625296473503113,
-0.8893325924873352,
-0.4533488154411316,
-0.13067451119422913,
-0.6532766819000244,
0.2777448892593384,
-0.1731829047203064,
-0.6776071190834045,
0.08018993586301804,
-0.21111220121383667,
-0.8677424788475037,
0.1777956783771515,
-0.15060356259346008,
0.8506591320037842,
-0.4982660412788391,
0.3428162932395935,
0.4614027738571167,
0.08297304064035416,
-0.5469862818717957,
-0.0627732053399086,
-0.5831671357154846,
-0.2881922721862793,
0.703369140625,
0.3298338055610657,
-0.4567349851131439,
0.2334749698638916,
-0.39677491784095764,
-0.892069399356842,
0.7482972741127014,
0.2591681182384491,
-0.42318296432495117,
-0.11881745606660843,
0.16663844883441925,
0.7617495059967041,
0.04416494816541672,
0.31646475195884705,
0.8525583148002625,
0.6952725648880005,
-0.5272287130355835,
-0.8228798508644104,
-0.2924305200576782,
-0.4272996187210083,
0.28190430998802185,
0.2061758041381836,
-0.5667445659637451,
0.3734237551689148,
0.0715329721570015,
-0.4856419265270233,
-0.2072148621082306,
0.7008076906204224,
-0.26364195346832275,
-0.07502610236406326,
0.5699796676635742,
0.3663528263568878,
0.4348655343055725,
-0.265439510345459,
1.26862370967865,
-0.5389111042022705,
0.39776939153671265,
0.6198689937591553,
-0.05458802729845047,
0.6545688509941101,
0.377913236618042,
-0.5401521921157837,
0.15724942088127136,
-0.024241752922534943,
-0.1585877388715744,
0.2730696499347687,
0.021179884672164917,
-0.25139763951301575,
-0.18477235734462738,
-0.49803462624549866,
-0.13995471596717834,
0.7084484696388245,
0.11981966346502304,
-0.25717923045158386,
-0.153455913066864,
-0.09075362980365753,
-0.16918590664863586,
0.1505623608827591,
-0.14709310233592987,
0.6750859618186951,
-0.06875672936439514,
-0.6996614933013916,
0.1630057394504547,
0.026226749643683434,
1.2582284212112427,
-0.5063992142677307,
0.17739005386829376,
0.33076900243759155,
0.04550192132592201,
-0.1827183961868286,
-0.49575889110565186,
0.8276347517967224,
0.21826839447021484,
-0.29234325885772705,
-0.7657967209815979,
0.8946903944015503,
0.11928410828113556,
-0.446778804063797,
0.2808939218521118,
0.4601851999759674,
-0.11233975738286972,
-0.05909687280654907,
-0.4103528559207916,
-0.08282431215047836,
-0.007166770286858082,
-0.3770562410354614,
-0.1404867023229599,
0.06918330490589142,
0.44674593210220337,
0.6798245310783386,
0.638645350933075,
0.012340551242232323,
0.22678525745868683,
0.009124982170760632,
0.5573480129241943,
-0.6761173009872437,
-0.24842692911624908,
-0.7231625914573669,
0.6323758363723755,
-0.39697378873825073,
-0.3732331693172455,
0.7717276215553284,
0.3943970501422882,
0.7791245579719543,
-0.17239052057266235,
0.7533683180809021,
-0.03858022764325142,
0.5412245392799377,
-0.2800919711589813,
0.8415833115577698,
-0.24001841247081757,
0.024946782737970352,
-0.39340898394584656,
-1.2651469707489014,
-0.3229081332683563,
0.6693390607833862,
-0.1874564290046692,
0.04351193457841873,
0.5929425358772278,
0.4482448399066925,
-0.017906539142131805,
0.3528766334056854,
0.2627209424972534,
-0.060395676642656326,
0.3197596073150635,
0.1257733702659607,
0.6752139329910278,
-0.5187188982963562,
0.3781525790691376,
-0.540772557258606,
0.010317042469978333,
-0.149871364235878,
-0.8374607563018799,
-0.37613633275032043,
-0.3393559753894806,
-0.12619298696517944,
0.21796581149101257,
-0.06760701537132263,
0.6670334935188293,
0.5584439635276794,
-0.6158545017242432,
0.02180212363600731,
-0.3374210298061371,
-0.05868278816342354,
-0.37571853399276733,
-0.20405606925487518,
0.37866541743278503,
-0.611100971698761,
-0.9926085472106934,
0.20518967509269714,
0.4801304042339325,
-0.08967220783233643,
-0.4164658784866333,
0.34213048219680786,
-0.19156742095947266,
0.06075504049658775,
0.9532542824745178,
0.013671737164258957,
-0.42617180943489075,
-0.33402904868125916,
0.47003182768821716,
0.037179235368967056,
0.25373342633247375,
0.7981404066085815,
-0.7845817804336548,
0.3123069405555725,
0.6714768409729004,
0.8110399842262268,
0.1881950944662094,
0.05421888828277588,
0.653247058391571,
-0.5269553065299988,
0.09539175033569336,
0.6442890763282776,
0.2994512915611267,
0.6653625965118408,
-0.2894671559333801,
0.6863377094268799,
0.047763172537088394,
-0.8436711430549622,
-0.7076959609985352,
0.19373217225074768,
-0.9010969400405884,
0.059487998485565186,
0.8288583755493164,
0.10003647953271866,
-0.027347104623913765,
-0.2989714741706848,
-0.1894451230764389,
0.5392568111419678,
-0.17086279392242432,
0.7933412194252014,
0.6089969277381897,
-0.22802278399467468,
-0.17286786437034607,
-0.6679271459579468,
0.6529565453529358,
0.6218572854995728,
-0.9253115057945251,
0.01490163803100586,
0.018655426800251007,
-0.3206881880760193,
0.6908008456230164,
0.30858874320983887,
-0.012415995821356773,
-0.09288721531629562,
0.07100502401590347,
0.24639610946178436,
0.3469800651073456,
-0.3376692235469818,
-0.23938912153244019,
0.3741209805011749,
-0.10742373764514923,
0.21904565393924713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09589v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09589v2
|
Unveiling Hallucination in Text, Image, Video, and Audio Foundation Models: A Comprehensive Survey
| 2024-05-15T10:16:25 | 2024-05-20T06:30:06 |
Pranab Sahoo, Prabhash Meharia, Akash Ghosh, Sriparna Saha, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The rapid advancement of foundation models (FMs) across language, image,
audio, and video domains has shown remarkable capabilities in diverse tasks.
However, the proliferation of FMs brings forth a critical challenge: the
potential to generate hallucinated outputs, particularly in high-stakes
applications. The tendency of foundation models to produce hallucinated content
arguably represents the biggest hindrance to their widespread adoption in
real-world scenarios, especially in domains where reliability and accuracy are
paramount. This survey paper presents a comprehensive overview of recent
developments that aim to identify and mitigate the problem of hallucination in
FMs, spanning text, image, video, and audio modalities. By synthesizing recent
advancements in detecting and mitigating hallucination across various
modalities, the paper aims to provide valuable insights for researchers,
developers, and practitioners. Essentially, it establishes a clear framework
encompassing definition, taxonomy, and detection strategies for addressing
hallucination in multimodal foundation models, laying the foundation for future
research in this pivotal area.
|
[
-0.8582829833030701,
-1.1301062107086182,
0.521151602268219,
0.33573344349861145,
-0.040648479014635086,
-0.1408870369195938,
-0.15701234340667725,
-0.6813430190086365,
0.41774529218673706,
0.5610798001289368,
-0.6835646033287048,
-0.4715009927749634,
-0.7824358344078064,
0.11018170416355133,
-0.7518255114555359,
0.6005277633666992,
0.028060702607035637,
0.06654198467731476,
-0.5082117319107056,
-0.12266855686903,
-0.8380827903747559,
-0.556391179561615,
-0.23722533881664276,
-0.384867787361145,
-0.011652042157948017,
0.0858251228928566,
0.7122614979743958,
0.17318426072597504,
0.6390758156776428,
0.2567277252674103,
0.049162331968545914,
0.10963530093431473,
-0.2776934504508972,
0.5061179399490356,
0.1788310706615448,
0.11510905623435974,
-0.23381228744983673,
-0.2734518349170685,
0.5913620591163635,
0.8787432312965393,
0.06481164693832397,
-0.18950258195400238,
-0.10417677462100983,
0.7547807097434998,
-0.8852472305297852,
-0.10812181979417801,
-0.6039389967918396,
0.3644275665283203,
0.014289520680904388,
-0.5869724750518799,
-0.5671871900558472,
-0.11611033976078033,
0.009781391359865665,
-0.19623398780822754,
0.5098680257797241,
-0.37496572732925415,
0.5067030191421509,
0.6158081293106079,
-0.3626551926136017,
-0.55748051404953,
-1.048522710800171,
0.7262094616889954,
-0.24808135628700256,
1.024749994277954,
0.5156832337379456,
0.4788210093975067,
-0.16550052165985107,
-0.6423856616020203,
-0.35865962505340576,
-0.13753187656402588,
0.012051565572619438,
-0.3224051296710968,
-0.030748017132282257,
-0.03768021985888481,
0.03981689736247063,
0.4100814759731293,
-0.5192715525627136,
-0.31334975361824036,
-0.09063419699668884,
-0.4004685580730438,
0.3390727639198303,
0.018825028091669083,
0.25891268253326416,
-0.2179224044084549,
-0.24369333684444427,
-0.15848365426063538,
-0.537961483001709,
-0.29372525215148926,
0.00208116602152586,
-0.06029919162392616,
0.05599962919950485,
0.5927906632423401,
-0.2435348480939865,
0.6684396266937256,
-0.053640443831682205,
-0.2468489557504654,
0.23832303285598755,
-0.4008728265762329,
-0.30771464109420776,
0.08779578655958176,
0.43342819809913635,
0.24933846294879913,
-0.05833251401782036,
-0.3714945614337921,
-0.5473449230194092,
0.44373849034309387,
0.41807010769844055,
-0.8498802781105042,
-0.1168084368109703,
0.4523075520992279,
-0.6018890142440796,
-0.4726096987724304,
0.15847691893577576,
-0.9589458703994751,
-0.816500723361969,
-0.345499724149704,
0.6080251932144165,
-0.44660618901252747,
-0.6888856887817383,
0.4531181752681732,
-0.18961754441261292,
0.16721725463867188,
0.14984166622161865,
-1.0091562271118164,
0.340225487947464,
0.3876371383666992,
0.9455931186676025,
-0.30286267399787903,
-0.15489763021469116,
-0.4319208264350891,
0.05591963604092598,
-0.23959881067276,
0.8919911980628967,
-0.5268574357032776,
-0.47312942147254944,
0.17578931152820587,
-0.04629147797822952,
0.1178457960486412,
-0.6999779939651489,
0.31600889563560486,
-0.10857349634170532,
-0.05807940661907196,
-0.2216365784406662,
-0.07805506139993668,
-0.26898765563964844,
0.3423759639263153,
-0.9145979285240173,
0.915412962436676,
0.09128601104021072,
-0.5215091705322266,
0.27494290471076965,
-0.35934776067733765,
-0.6118056774139404,
-0.4023100435733795,
-0.6168766021728516,
-0.623421311378479,
0.5671426653862,
0.07262583076953888,
0.7528978586196899,
-0.3376343548297882,
0.8254344463348389,
-0.085189089179039,
-0.7757085561752319,
0.29234328866004944,
-0.5522216558456421,
0.2874206304550171,
0.12181663513183594,
-0.8507333397865295,
0.21185949444770813,
-0.9506769776344299,
-0.4029228687286377,
0.08482781797647476,
0.3421121835708618,
-0.14942073822021484,
0.10712798684835434,
0.3169671297073364,
0.25277262926101685,
-0.332754522562027,
0.01997857727110386,
-0.30234065651893616,
0.19492407143115997,
0.24519646167755127,
0.5256322026252747,
0.02413344942033291,
0.31502094864845276,
-0.3588590919971466,
0.4119669497013092,
0.028605878353118896,
0.14566978812217712,
-0.42066171765327454,
-0.2695505917072296,
-0.3979594111442566,
-0.40855351090431213,
-0.10307318717241287,
0.01717519760131836,
-0.5265594124794006,
0.31017228960990906,
-0.12679423391819,
-0.4428110718727112,
-0.25154751539230347,
-0.16537436842918396,
0.2391231507062912,
0.382682204246521,
0.4978768229484558,
-0.4261549413204193,
-0.6363872289657593,
-0.8197951316833496,
0.07035566866397858,
0.2351607233285904,
0.1626158058643341,
0.22494354844093323,
0.6180611848831177,
-0.47813594341278076,
0.7314140796661377,
-0.2570083439350128,
-0.7168209552764893,
0.009201180189847946,
0.2859521508216858,
-0.2799479365348816,
0.5817147493362427,
0.7674322724342346,
-1.3089860677719116,
-0.024000711739063263,
-0.14704619348049164,
-1.0741761922836304,
0.15519408881664276,
-0.40809330344200134,
0.13892978429794312,
0.19882887601852417,
0.4486892521381378,
-0.8028796315193176,
0.5683196783065796,
0.43617361783981323,
-0.3567470610141754,
0.78519207239151,
0.41884520649909973,
0.567551851272583,
-0.6271576285362244,
0.14345146715641022,
-0.18976837396621704,
0.07889365404844284,
-0.6381159424781799,
0.06781566888093948,
-0.24719293415546417,
-0.07079421728849411,
-0.26870840787887573,
0.18767736852169037,
-0.5637052655220032,
-0.468447744846344,
-0.1469026356935501,
-0.09178413450717926,
-0.14866138994693756,
0.23249058425426483,
0.46731632947921753,
0.5326318740844727,
0.760583758354187,
-0.6521126627922058,
0.3345279097557068,
0.49642664194107056,
-0.38420337438583374,
0.4544863700866699,
-0.400241881608963,
-0.16330119967460632,
-0.3429625332355499,
0.2638425827026367,
-1.0511595010757446,
-0.6014971137046814,
0.29358986020088196,
-0.6076812148094177,
0.24982118606567383,
0.2887265980243683,
-0.33128654956817627,
-0.02667354792356491,
-0.4717552661895752,
0.44188013672828674,
0.24437175691127777,
-0.5234007239341736,
0.9156574606895447,
0.2698671519756317,
0.24100463092327118,
-0.8265926837921143,
-0.9074234962463379,
0.08672948181629181,
-0.12677918374538422,
-0.8793936967849731,
0.5829854011535645,
-0.33232206106185913,
-0.2323503941297531,
0.04283961281180382,
-0.5379020571708679,
-0.14377693831920624,
0.265327125787735,
0.47005337476730347,
-0.12987397611141205,
-0.27034980058670044,
0.038833148777484894,
0.10371183604001999,
0.021284595131874084,
0.32415127754211426,
0.029418600723147392,
0.7292633652687073,
-0.08346152305603027,
-0.44890764355659485,
-0.47168731689453125,
0.5795799493789673,
0.9149208068847656,
-0.15353022515773773,
0.7661543488502502,
0.7721030712127686,
-1.0376917123794556,
-0.08677087724208832,
-0.803297221660614,
-0.7213724851608276,
-0.4392329454421997,
0.4269753396511078,
-0.6454256176948547,
-0.622559130191803,
0.4910185635089874,
-0.24991169571876526,
-0.19877637922763824,
0.08435171097517014,
0.5281742811203003,
0.3568558990955353,
1.0716476440429688,
0.7525040507316589,
0.4069083631038666,
0.3395541310310364,
-0.43995025753974915,
0.22644191980361938,
-0.5088362097740173,
-0.7220212817192078,
-0.4679487943649292,
-0.036662548780441284,
-0.1399572491645813,
-0.23251070082187653,
0.1650644838809967,
0.014976189471781254,
0.3352718651294708,
0.18501967191696167,
-0.7257830500602722,
0.40383443236351013,
-0.02312200516462326,
-0.01671736314892769,
0.4346357583999634,
0.33349287509918213,
0.0032577537931501865,
-0.1880233734846115,
-0.3024815320968628,
-0.42941728234291077,
0.8347744345664978,
0.2623240649700165,
0.6003862619400024,
0.2737845480442047,
0.6649840474128723,
0.541123628616333,
0.1310221552848816,
-0.638057291507721,
0.43521690368652344,
0.15093669295310974,
-0.7472848296165466,
-0.3134821057319641,
-0.12727820873260498,
-0.32507920265197754,
0.37612229585647583,
-0.48311975598335266,
-0.6755393743515015,
0.5069496631622314,
0.09779103845357895,
-0.21235442161560059,
0.30087924003601074,
-0.3033720552921295,
1.0740488767623901,
-0.06495772302150726,
-0.5263188481330872,
-0.23760953545570374,
-0.5633862018585205,
0.8285043239593506,
-0.23259779810905457,
0.259500116109848,
0.09773528575897217,
0.34948527812957764,
0.27304697036743164,
0.024448763579130173,
0.7792637944221497,
-0.19448737800121307,
-0.28593870997428894,
0.2803850769996643,
0.3026873469352722,
0.3338620662689209,
0.11356386542320251,
0.04104426130652428,
-0.007793810684233904,
-0.09358206391334534,
-0.10172001272439957,
-0.43953415751457214,
0.7096482515335083,
-0.3976743519306183,
-0.36785435676574707,
-0.4447912573814392,
-0.40499788522720337,
-0.42187997698783875,
0.05264994874596596,
0.5198202133178711,
0.5864880084991455,
-0.5745886564254761,
0.6209515929222107,
1.084583044052124,
-0.09438250213861465,
0.44708919525146484,
-0.12278181314468384,
-0.404415488243103,
-0.40247347950935364,
1.131622314453125,
-0.17474119365215302,
0.047847818583250046,
0.10389604419469833,
-0.2003735452890396,
-0.39302995800971985,
-0.8306249380111694,
-0.24742278456687927,
0.17021271586418152,
-0.896496593952179,
-0.24076932668685913,
-0.9940069913864136,
-0.14283441007137299,
-0.6585853695869446,
-0.471999853849411,
-0.5056381821632385,
-0.4256495237350464,
-0.4647367000579834,
-0.18986600637435913,
0.07755906134843826,
0.5835346579551697,
-0.11524021625518799,
0.18924368917942047,
-0.5706473588943481,
0.8755320310592651,
0.07763426005840302,
0.4278485178947449,
0.19879554212093353,
-0.1659020185470581,
0.03895947337150574,
-0.15699505805969238,
-0.318355917930603,
-0.9574390649795532,
0.2732737064361572,
0.0444490909576416,
0.5347187519073486,
0.7008581757545471,
0.014123895205557346,
0.6340944766998291,
-0.059724096208810806,
0.7986007928848267,
0.4368840754032135,
-0.9166697263717651,
0.48748013377189636,
-0.05808524787425995,
-0.23318073153495789,
0.5309301614761353,
0.5882936120033264,
-0.42606180906295776,
-0.13210800290107727,
-0.30142468214035034,
-0.6987257599830627,
0.2629816234111786,
0.37836384773254395,
0.141764298081398,
0.0034130162093788385,
0.004059526603668928,
0.4573255181312561,
0.4122222661972046,
-0.8779451847076416,
0.09621301293373108,
-0.5729144811630249,
-0.1323632001876831,
0.24125441908836365,
-0.35461220145225525,
-0.07964117079973221,
-0.1792880743741989,
0.6526522040367126,
-0.09361714869737625,
0.34214484691619873,
0.2858879566192627,
-0.6270430684089661,
-0.26807907223701477,
0.05715104937553406,
0.8638623356819153,
0.6080461740493774,
-0.4471345841884613,
0.22062352299690247,
-0.46457937359809875,
-0.5083600878715515,
0.2811067998409271,
-0.05313408002257347,
-0.33786335587501526,
0.25920072197914124,
0.30421504378318787,
0.8363879323005676,
0.3583419620990753,
-0.8220483064651489,
0.6344829797744751,
0.0642622709274292,
-0.45754939317703247,
-0.7511119246482849,
-0.11787455528974533,
-0.21615555882453918,
0.0724855363368988,
0.5495898723602295,
0.2902883291244507,
0.4794112741947174,
-0.594918966293335,
0.4648822247982025,
0.5724284648895264,
-0.5635057091712952,
-0.3365722596645355,
0.8671126961708069,
0.19865255057811737,
-0.11007865518331528,
0.4487687349319458,
0.06787790358066559,
-0.28391677141189575,
0.5527181625366211,
0.7136834263801575,
1.0101144313812256,
-0.2649616003036499,
0.30777236819267273,
0.16844986379146576,
0.5084134936332703,
-0.3803757131099701,
0.3706406354904175,
-0.2777370512485504,
-0.7337735295295715,
-0.07142102718353271,
-0.765448272228241,
-0.06712820380926132,
0.4824944734573364,
-0.6457213163375854,
0.39336371421813965,
-0.4204847514629364,
-0.3578115701675415,
0.04724448174238205,
-0.39553123712539673,
-0.37011003494262695,
0.3108341693878174,
0.2338782548904419,
0.672701895236969,
-1.015838623046875,
0.4011363387107849,
0.49282923340797424,
-0.5154849290847778,
0.1553577184677124,
-0.021583901718258858,
0.18687289953231812,
-0.01038869097828865,
0.28813159465789795,
0.6689471006393433,
-0.516862690448761,
0.07778264582157135,
-0.41846874356269836,
-0.37255173921585083,
1.1572502851486206,
0.14479392766952515,
-0.10867892950773239,
-0.12859216332435608,
0.4299335181713104,
0.17741093039512634,
-0.5120178461074829,
-0.07071728259325027,
0.7269982099533081,
0.7035716772079468,
0.19345586001873016,
-0.27080219984054565,
0.16379722952842712,
-0.2009260207414627,
-0.09839238971471786,
0.15790638327598572,
-0.29227593541145325,
0.5395646691322327,
-0.18380126357078552,
-0.24598382413387299,
0.2732808291912079,
0.6599664688110352,
0.3921528160572052,
0.6099667549133301,
0.6588709950447083,
0.34726232290267944,
0.47056838870048523,
-0.28892654180526733,
0.6007680892944336,
-0.047447569668293,
-0.12983977794647217,
0.7315873503684998,
-0.2444581836462021,
0.3734159767627716,
0.8058129549026489,
0.2977427542209625,
0.1681813895702362,
0.6744318008422852,
-0.21402686834335327,
0.6722209453582764,
0.02749553509056568,
-0.36913278698921204,
-0.41181159019470215,
-0.43977832794189453,
-0.6682097911834717,
0.5108230113983154,
0.6000834703445435,
-0.3186984956264496,
0.14430834352970123,
0.46133658289909363,
-0.4782024025917053,
0.26836854219436646,
0.11042476445436478,
0.45211872458457947,
-0.07987990230321884,
-0.48549363017082214,
0.7002890706062317,
-0.09749863296747208,
0.8698339462280273,
-0.46785926818847656,
-0.44673189520835876,
-0.2767435610294342,
-0.14617985486984253,
-0.3511978089809418,
-0.08420255780220032,
0.5912436246871948,
-0.1525880992412567,
-0.31387490034103394,
-0.12294038385152817,
0.8466486930847168,
-0.20763447880744934,
-0.1693831980228424,
0.5598069429397583,
0.4556620121002197,
0.1330757737159729,
-0.5063563585281372,
-0.11699433624744415,
0.6492787003517151,
-0.144720196723938,
-0.2397240251302719,
0.07016676664352417,
0.31385284662246704,
-0.19598408043384552,
0.5982372760772705,
0.6350753903388977,
-0.3518846333026886,
0.13057290017604828,
0.11937389522790909,
0.77394700050354,
-0.938206136226654,
-0.27853143215179443,
-0.4470144808292389,
0.5193561315536499,
-0.021103907376527786,
-0.18890108168125153,
0.23564739525318146,
0.5707070827484131,
0.7964624762535095,
-0.4409697353839874,
0.6112182140350342,
-0.06685484200716019,
-0.227333202958107,
-0.6305769681930542,
0.867742121219635,
-0.8160521984100342,
0.2336585372686386,
-0.649090051651001,
-1.0997514724731445,
-0.5585877299308777,
0.6142650842666626,
0.499820351600647,
-0.09750557690858841,
0.9308173060417175,
0.9462845921516418,
-0.14491026103496552,
0.32443156838417053,
0.5643118619918823,
0.0446556881070137,
0.0008957319660112262,
0.299136221408844,
1.0805604457855225,
-0.5179929733276367,
0.590378999710083,
-0.5591464638710022,
-0.19170352816581726,
-0.49797436594963074,
-0.8976925611495972,
-0.8949182629585266,
-0.9559400677680969,
-0.3975224494934082,
-0.3357582986354828,
0.0689200609922409,
0.49469685554504395,
0.679432213306427,
-0.9571504592895508,
-0.08314624428749084,
-0.22918187081813812,
0.17606551945209503,
-0.4599953293800354,
-0.18808303773403168,
0.26469019055366516,
-0.03591711446642876,
-0.5248693823814392,
0.4769863188266754,
0.22515136003494263,
0.5213884115219116,
-0.507442831993103,
-0.1524181067943573,
-0.053908951580524445,
0.00716352416202426,
0.7714602947235107,
0.2193673551082611,
-0.8964971899986267,
-0.09859208017587662,
0.3998172879219055,
-0.012915694154798985,
0.07671556621789932,
1.174340009689331,
-0.8460643291473389,
0.24704056978225708,
0.5354332327842712,
0.7731932997703552,
0.4002070426940918,
-0.40917888283729553,
0.34115901589393616,
-0.7269510626792908,
0.3617103695869446,
0.19029688835144043,
0.34038615226745605,
0.6242714524269104,
-0.5484699606895447,
0.8948541879653931,
0.5859304666519165,
0.010749192908406258,
-1.355053424835205,
0.2664755880832672,
-0.8591407537460327,
-0.7037597894668579,
0.7191073298454285,
0.5768062472343445,
0.11239474266767502,
-0.08213966339826584,
-0.00864639412611723,
0.2396543323993683,
0.03424745798110962,
1.2289663553237915,
0.941792368888855,
0.01051128376275301,
-0.2293299436569214,
-0.5251629948616028,
0.6496278643608093,
0.5236824750900269,
-0.8415091633796692,
0.1778198629617691,
0.9698452949523926,
-0.2147103101015091,
0.4350128471851349,
0.6399290561676025,
-0.4647518992424011,
0.5758297443389893,
0.085484080016613,
0.1847619116306305,
-0.048744358122348785,
-1.0942190885543823,
-0.5369797348976135,
0.42998433113098145,
-0.22240515053272247,
0.10609855502843857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09223v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09223v1
|
Word Alignment as Preference for Machine Translation
| 2024-05-15T10:04:19 | 2024-05-15T10:04:19 |
Qiyu Wu, Masaaki Nagata, Zhongtao Miao, Yoshimasa Tsuruoka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The problem of hallucination and omission, a long-standing problem in machine
translation (MT), is more pronounced when a large language model (LLM) is used
in MT because an LLM itself is susceptible to these phenomena. In this work, we
mitigate the problem in an LLM-based MT model by guiding it to better word
alignment. We first study the correlation between word alignment and the
phenomena of hallucination and omission in MT. Then we propose to utilize word
alignment as preference to optimize the LLM-based MT model. The preference data
are constructed by selecting chosen and rejected translations from multiple MT
tools. Subsequently, direct preference optimization is used to optimize the
LLM-based model towards the preference signal. Given the absence of evaluators
specifically designed for hallucination and omission in MT, we further propose
selecting hard instances and utilizing GPT-4 to directly evaluate the
performance of the models in mitigating these issues. We verify the rationality
of these designed evaluation methods by experiments, followed by extensive
results demonstrating the effectiveness of word alignment-based preference
optimization to mitigate hallucination and omission.
|
[
-0.3377237915992737,
-0.7286865711212158,
0.8249532580375671,
0.020184490829706192,
-0.5379650592803955,
-0.23058871924877167,
-0.32857459783554077,
-0.28567391633987427,
0.35984188318252563,
0.6926288604736328,
-0.432155579328537,
-0.3190457820892334,
-0.6723827123641968,
0.41912055015563965,
-0.1264100819826126,
1.1463770866394043,
-0.462919145822525,
0.1491524577140808,
-0.260417640209198,
-0.30973321199417114,
-0.7983947396278381,
-0.6821296811103821,
-0.34757015109062195,
-0.6031110286712646,
0.5840664505958557,
0.11448036879301071,
1.122538685798645,
0.9311056733131409,
0.8406137228012085,
0.2610507607460022,
0.02665974386036396,
0.22596268355846405,
-0.4280134439468384,
0.1262194812297821,
-0.029981154948472977,
-0.18727798759937286,
-0.8084249496459961,
-0.05191868171095848,
0.460041880607605,
0.647953450679779,
-0.1216374859213829,
0.019248567521572113,
0.09592612832784653,
0.9302487373352051,
-0.4022039771080017,
-0.182565376162529,
-0.8350684642791748,
0.20171460509300232,
-0.07406336069107056,
-0.4437411427497864,
-0.3983120918273926,
-0.5141082406044006,
0.05872032418847084,
-0.4903066158294678,
0.020959025248885155,
0.27025648951530457,
0.8849262595176697,
0.6416981816291809,
-0.1848791241645813,
-0.23025105893611908,
-0.8196943402290344,
0.8957255482673645,
-0.51817786693573,
0.526355504989624,
0.42529064416885376,
0.18744437396526337,
-0.25870075821876526,
-0.009301786310970783,
-0.6548523306846619,
-0.011768977157771587,
0.12488197535276413,
0.19568496942520142,
0.06354319304227829,
0.09499061852693558,
0.07046844065189362,
0.3423060476779938,
-0.7979080677032471,
0.17481163144111633,
-0.32463765144348145,
-0.30861231684684753,
0.2457067221403122,
0.28956106305122375,
0.3451932668685913,
-0.3075870871543884,
-0.23229053616523743,
-0.08600381016731262,
-0.8367752432823181,
-0.42220765352249146,
0.43768978118896484,
0.3982415199279785,
0.36119163036346436,
1.0662190914154053,
0.17956514656543732,
0.6937028169631958,
0.07811039686203003,
-0.044438499957323074,
0.5429580211639404,
-0.042406029999256134,
-0.44877544045448303,
0.3527505099773407,
0.7511121034622192,
0.6700207591056824,
0.07227092236280441,
-0.4928695559501648,
-0.363209068775177,
0.2679368257522583,
0.5837301015853882,
-0.650456964969635,
0.2579116225242615,
0.44079190492630005,
-0.48568618297576904,
-0.2588600814342499,
-0.10998241603374481,
-0.5617946982383728,
-0.3494410812854767,
-0.7287703156471252,
0.6466735601425171,
-0.5570091009140015,
-0.02283918298780918,
0.2505333423614502,
0.07815412431955338,
0.11482890695333481,
0.3103409707546234,
-0.9549641013145447,
0.15773895382881165,
0.8140124678611755,
0.8419734239578247,
-0.7667584419250488,
-0.3884449601173401,
-0.6644872426986694,
0.34123241901397705,
-0.366008996963501,
0.5241724848747253,
-0.36433732509613037,
-0.5116630792617798,
-0.16637161374092102,
0.08414541184902191,
-0.12495320290327072,
-0.5972265005111694,
0.8816054463386536,
-0.39750853180885315,
0.41281503438949585,
-0.4239206910133362,
-0.6934695839881897,
-0.48665958642959595,
0.1634996235370636,
-0.46813830733299255,
0.7224057912826538,
0.11466870456933975,
-0.6605501174926758,
0.4031166732311249,
-0.589924156665802,
-0.4668635427951813,
0.002905490342527628,
-0.08591172099113464,
-0.6506053805351257,
0.4208109974861145,
0.17907854914665222,
0.21878719329833984,
0.004205097910016775,
0.3783075511455536,
-0.2522448003292084,
-0.5925408601760864,
0.05305289104580879,
-0.2946484088897705,
0.4809066653251648,
0.42640239000320435,
-0.4557543396949768,
0.22520743310451508,
-0.5193070769309998,
-0.06924901902675629,
0.12645599246025085,
-0.20663589239120483,
-0.5281819701194763,
0.11990120261907578,
-0.11859803646802902,
0.10880713164806366,
0.23367412388324738,
-0.207850381731987,
0.3873859643936157,
-0.6344689726829529,
0.17921218276023865,
0.9733183979988098,
-0.31663748621940613,
0.5738825798034668,
-0.27978023886680603,
0.4000178277492523,
-0.037895288318395615,
0.2605118751525879,
0.6324452757835388,
-0.2892798185348511,
-0.7993639707565308,
-0.21682696044445038,
0.1618669033050537,
0.5618024468421936,
-0.6765298843383789,
0.7459902167320251,
-0.4564911425113678,
-0.04643451049923897,
-0.881210446357727,
0.18170306086540222,
0.1502375602722168,
0.46207430958747864,
0.5080255270004272,
-0.25281256437301636,
-0.5120440721511841,
-0.963645875453949,
-0.1792304813861847,
0.05903175473213196,
0.13388797640800476,
0.013675062917172909,
0.3300165832042694,
-0.4799608290195465,
0.8240550756454468,
-0.5178903937339783,
-0.45144858956336975,
-0.20290005207061768,
-0.15647399425506592,
0.25642845034599304,
0.29141879081726074,
0.3591908812522888,
-0.8035346865653992,
-0.20617493987083435,
0.14926029741764069,
-0.7812429666519165,
-0.09116272628307343,
0.034511856734752655,
-0.4633590281009674,
0.5591467618942261,
0.1477966010570526,
-0.6445766687393188,
0.4484163522720337,
0.584260106086731,
0.09194168448448181,
0.3969205319881439,
-0.3080691993236542,
0.2240450382232666,
-1.1810675859451294,
0.15205681324005127,
-0.28431403636932373,
-0.12236139923334122,
-0.5833985209465027,
0.024039611220359802,
0.22109583020210266,
0.15990276634693146,
-0.45902207493782043,
0.28570106625556946,
-0.3669087886810303,
-0.09320535510778427,
-0.4591236412525177,
0.3778659701347351,
0.03164363652467728,
0.3874623477458954,
0.24900469183921814,
0.853736400604248,
0.03599908575415611,
-0.6406557559967041,
0.046468473970890045,
0.4748512804508209,
0.012561304494738579,
0.3196873962879181,
-0.5182911157608032,
0.41008272767066956,
-0.1777735948562622,
-0.17820042371749878,
-0.8768659234046936,
-0.015734029933810234,
0.7414835095405579,
-0.25292468070983887,
0.40684258937835693,
0.09830023348331451,
-0.5196292400360107,
-0.40127116441726685,
-0.32724642753601074,
0.29623761773109436,
0.4061618149280548,
-0.5154668688774109,
0.40043962001800537,
0.3060503602027893,
0.09227308630943298,
-0.46307119727134705,
-0.5932544469833374,
-0.02938137575984001,
-0.5214263200759888,
-0.352867066860199,
0.36575254797935486,
-0.34087464213371277,
-0.10229334980249405,
-0.2582060694694519,
-0.29472842812538147,
0.2927001416683197,
-0.006819295696914196,
0.4563123881816864,
0.5807400941848755,
-0.013040008954703808,
0.1740262806415558,
-0.025092236697673798,
-0.3572743237018585,
-0.13754138350486755,
-0.1977144479751587,
0.780698835849762,
0.003940839320421219,
-0.5515583753585815,
-0.2505618929862976,
0.26582852005958557,
0.6287858486175537,
-0.16986413300037384,
0.8402158617973328,
0.5687510371208191,
-0.20193038880825043,
0.3100798428058624,
-0.6785498261451721,
-0.1868470013141632,
-0.4505244195461273,
0.2950604557991028,
-0.4814123511314392,
-0.707904577255249,
0.2732565402984619,
0.19165591895580292,
-0.025115489959716797,
0.4679449200630188,
0.5546914935112,
0.06989409774541855,
1.2032097578048706,
0.4805105924606323,
-0.497841477394104,
0.15626956522464752,
0.17139917612075806,
0.5135321617126465,
-1.217656135559082,
0.13745610415935516,
-0.6289156675338745,
-0.3038201332092285,
-0.6235144138336182,
-0.11892705410718918,
0.4145977199077606,
-0.10201453417539597,
-0.04450373724102974,
0.5574734807014465,
-0.8117788434028625,
0.29921942949295044,
0.3078228533267975,
0.04737039655447006,
0.33316823840141296,
0.35771769285202026,
-0.29096266627311707,
-0.38884416222572327,
-0.3072780668735504,
-0.8056532740592957,
1.0117895603179932,
0.21334952116012573,
0.4774074852466583,
0.19302190840244293,
0.801565945148468,
-0.11626365780830383,
0.19303704798221588,
-0.9752836227416992,
0.42815718054771423,
0.009983772411942482,
-0.4689394235610962,
-0.333652526140213,
-0.5255671143531799,
-1.000767707824707,
0.478715717792511,
-0.1232084110379219,
-0.7000566720962524,
-0.3060682415962219,
-0.054510876536369324,
-0.2247963845729828,
0.2535412907600403,
-0.5156540870666504,
0.8831726312637329,
-0.3516690135002136,
-0.2758091986179352,
-0.10716115683317184,
-0.5583016872406006,
0.314861923456192,
-0.3391338884830475,
0.2610640525817871,
0.06095152348279953,
0.051816027611494064,
0.4527105391025543,
-0.39910998940467834,
0.4253433048725128,
0.18551921844482422,
-0.2586427330970764,
-0.18259693682193756,
0.3771291673183441,
0.826809287071228,
-0.5321301221847534,
-0.3558386564254761,
0.16610625386238098,
-0.3135499060153961,
0.06450106203556061,
-0.4616451859474182,
0.7285794615745544,
-0.9051369428634644,
-0.9094821810722351,
-0.3191790282726288,
-0.5840715765953064,
-0.0543157123029232,
0.344049870967865,
0.4854348599910736,
0.09823617339134216,
-0.059582341462373734,
-0.05346275493502617,
0.48196539282798767,
-0.19086295366287231,
0.42305830121040344,
0.2351023554801941,
-0.7049542665481567,
-0.5780922770500183,
1.1467375755310059,
0.16462290287017822,
0.34042590856552124,
0.3779565095901489,
0.3851330578327179,
-0.3580892086029053,
-0.8813097476959229,
-0.5580183267593384,
0.36924847960472107,
-0.5986013412475586,
-0.0369076170027256,
-0.9548395276069641,
-0.1180998682975769,
-0.35589271783828735,
-0.20131835341453552,
-0.168524831533432,
-0.34146735072135925,
-0.4223715364933014,
-0.11978445202112198,
0.1895466148853302,
0.3870111107826233,
0.29628297686576843,
0.37298479676246643,
-0.7415097951889038,
0.4740540087223053,
-0.05271919071674347,
0.23692238330841064,
-0.3334946632385254,
-0.7076020836830139,
-0.016529489308595657,
-0.04468415677547455,
-0.6804609298706055,
-0.7750352621078491,
0.6330123543739319,
-0.28641796112060547,
0.5467706918716431,
0.5720377564430237,
0.036413297057151794,
0.866459846496582,
-0.682307779788971,
0.6114615797996521,
0.26366642117500305,
-0.9535133838653564,
0.39256712794303894,
-0.3410457968711853,
0.13240830600261688,
0.6139079332351685,
0.3030327558517456,
-0.5718395113945007,
-0.5666552186012268,
-0.3419003188610077,
-0.8199408054351807,
0.6050493121147156,
0.487295925617218,
-0.08017505705356598,
-0.11132413893938065,
0.2652857005596161,
0.5061116218566895,
0.5027749538421631,
-0.7985003590583801,
-0.29759207367897034,
-0.05546404793858528,
-0.15676966309547424,
-0.2892078757286072,
-0.21990947425365448,
-0.06513451039791107,
-0.2305392324924469,
0.8899622559547424,
0.03005339950323105,
0.06368740648031235,
0.08265712112188339,
-0.36306101083755493,
-0.4894985854625702,
0.19517093896865845,
0.8180233836174011,
0.6542685031890869,
-0.3924129009246826,
0.065704345703125,
0.1690095067024231,
-0.47296470403671265,
0.11177410930395126,
-0.3005644679069519,
-0.4840443730354309,
0.07504376024007797,
-0.13344641029834747,
0.7892353534698486,
-0.14562438428401947,
-0.07774237543344498,
0.323460191488266,
0.28872719407081604,
-0.193398579955101,
-0.04587562382221222,
-0.13899928331375122,
0.13312949240207672,
-0.12863227725028992,
0.05677361413836479,
0.2999280095100403,
0.2884802520275116,
-0.2570347189903259,
-0.13302481174468994,
0.7207088470458984,
-0.5257201790809631,
-0.17586475610733032,
0.706762969493866,
-0.02905070222914219,
-0.5115621089935303,
0.5894116163253784,
-0.00440041022375226,
-0.7480509281158447,
0.29197341203689575,
0.5953990817070007,
1.001912236213684,
-0.3217398226261139,
-0.012934976257383823,
0.08478008955717087,
0.5906011462211609,
-0.2889585793018341,
0.022396251559257507,
0.34638068079948425,
-0.7924144268035889,
-0.35466673970222473,
-0.6006526947021484,
-0.2841910719871521,
0.1635310798883438,
-0.5314168334007263,
0.5085763931274414,
-0.1784721463918686,
-0.4445537030696869,
-0.20859625935554504,
-0.1084655374288559,
-0.588003933429718,
-0.0640399381518364,
0.018648548051714897,
0.3697524964809418,
-0.6692787408828735,
0.8852989077568054,
0.4435763657093048,
-0.4043371081352234,
-0.5820536613464355,
-0.012865238822996616,
0.2070239633321762,
-0.8686929941177368,
0.4882793128490448,
0.3144637942314148,
-0.2967657148838043,
-0.12190675735473633,
-0.20291228592395782,
-0.671863853931427,
0.7585539817810059,
0.3781343996524811,
-0.6192353367805481,
0.25045883655548096,
0.4092092216014862,
0.38325297832489014,
-0.30141666531562805,
0.010745806619524956,
0.45638254284858704,
0.755325436592102,
0.08906450122594833,
-0.8470150828361511,
0.16836725175380707,
0.20493538677692413,
0.17178429663181305,
0.662314236164093,
-0.4729655385017395,
0.3931899666786194,
-0.06298399716615677,
-0.1577700823545456,
0.13100148737430573,
0.4155653715133667,
0.20293477177619934,
0.17675916850566864,
0.44313040375709534,
0.5655590295791626,
0.6539827585220337,
0.05355794355273247,
0.890968918800354,
-0.013871783390641212,
0.22353994846343994,
1.1436972618103027,
-0.5734186172485352,
0.8198751211166382,
1.1437040567398071,
-0.17300759255886078,
-0.2621780335903168,
0.6671558022499084,
0.05747445672750473,
0.6006442904472351,
0.343488484621048,
0.06697497516870499,
-0.14552845060825348,
0.05351822450757027,
-0.5703746676445007,
0.3086821734905243,
0.06832906603813171,
-0.3610837757587433,
-0.0035120814573019743,
-0.05658598989248276,
0.1237814798951149,
-0.03466970846056938,
-0.014292018488049507,
0.7420624494552612,
0.05547871068120003,
-0.7851830720901489,
0.6483986973762512,
-0.007895302027463913,
0.44824838638305664,
-0.38763532042503357,
0.12974406778812408,
-0.31818410754203796,
0.14397573471069336,
-0.25082772970199585,
-0.40304267406463623,
0.4334797263145447,
-0.3456890285015106,
-0.2584531009197235,
-0.23920968174934387,
0.3933522701263428,
-0.44004949927330017,
-0.4839698374271393,
0.3665860891342163,
0.4894561171531677,
0.5366196036338806,
-0.3248622417449951,
-0.46454328298568726,
0.3581041991710663,
0.19498857855796814,
-0.16839347779750824,
0.4269521236419678,
0.48562100529670715,
-0.09080721437931061,
0.4241308867931366,
0.6461961269378662,
0.2875807583332062,
-0.16575774550437927,
0.0963045209646225,
0.6983681917190552,
-0.6667070984840393,
-0.1369272619485855,
-1.3216743469238281,
0.10525069385766983,
0.0437743104994297,
-0.04018409922719002,
0.8664558529853821,
0.7380266785621643,
0.4693446159362793,
-0.18111786246299744,
0.6567583680152893,
0.32017260789871216,
0.2818123400211334,
-0.6106247305870056,
0.695405900478363,
-0.7535883188247681,
0.30416062474250793,
-0.7449624538421631,
-1.6107584238052368,
-0.4700125753879547,
0.6206629276275635,
-0.43693801760673523,
-0.09945984929800034,
1.044281005859375,
0.8775433301925659,
-0.07179223746061325,
0.14364008605480194,
0.591958224773407,
-0.13342764973640442,
0.2004493921995163,
0.4784809648990631,
0.6807742118835449,
-0.43288302421569824,
0.519568145275116,
-0.015160899609327316,
-0.06914793699979782,
-0.47470995783805847,
-1.1524370908737183,
-0.8116298913955688,
-0.5127251744270325,
-0.4364234507083893,
-0.4085807204246521,
-0.032816559076309204,
1.195403814315796,
0.27234113216400146,
-0.6851947903633118,
-0.2308785319328308,
0.04969139024615288,
0.3804064095020294,
-0.31647512316703796,
-0.16144220530986786,
0.532379686832428,
-0.371829092502594,
-0.7409141659736633,
0.2381717413663864,
0.5466452836990356,
0.35050660371780396,
0.06139088422060013,
-0.29257628321647644,
0.14891290664672852,
-0.2118900865316391,
0.5780812501907349,
-0.23317094147205353,
-0.9577845931053162,
-0.5018110871315002,
0.17510665953159332,
-0.28827157616615295,
0.49188145995140076,
0.601634681224823,
-0.18696044385433197,
0.44318556785583496,
0.3665353059768677,
0.5731754899024963,
0.12406393140554428,
-0.011203370057046413,
0.804681122303009,
-0.13756874203681946,
0.015800517052412033,
-0.09494150429964066,
0.3679251968860626,
0.3915883004665375,
-0.6041898131370544,
0.5905967354774475,
0.12572216987609863,
-0.6006889343261719,
-0.7263022661209106,
-0.019907450303435326,
-0.9626150131225586,
-0.15745419263839722,
1.3477680683135986,
0.3828800320625305,
-0.47978031635284424,
0.05450081452727318,
-0.5258401036262512,
0.4313143491744995,
-0.34850460290908813,
1.045401930809021,
1.1582988500595093,
0.10932145267724991,
0.1802256554365158,
-0.6516127586364746,
0.3596128225326538,
0.7735049724578857,
-0.547845184803009,
0.06710882484912872,
0.5460668802261353,
0.01864684373140335,
0.21676205098628998,
0.306356817483902,
-0.3584285378456116,
-0.14367415010929108,
-0.5626091361045837,
0.3677000105381012,
-0.0999513790011406,
-0.23888011276721954,
-0.4596259891986847,
-0.022898655384778976,
0.16424934566020966,
-0.44936567544937134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09221v1
|
Bridging the gap in online hate speech detection: a comparative analysis of BERT and traditional models for homophobic content identification on X/Twitter
| 2024-05-15T10:02:47 | 2024-05-15T10:02:47 |
Josh McGiff, Nikola S. Nikolov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, H.5; I.2; J.5
|
Our study addresses a significant gap in online hate speech detection
research by focusing on homophobia, an area often neglected in sentiment
analysis research. Utilising advanced sentiment analysis models, particularly
BERT, and traditional machine learning methods, we developed a nuanced approach
to identify homophobic content on X/Twitter. This research is pivotal due to
the persistent underrepresentation of homophobia in detection models. Our
findings reveal that while BERT outperforms traditional methods, the choice of
validation technique can impact model performance. This underscores the
importance of contextual understanding in detecting nuanced hate speech. By
releasing the largest open-source labelled English dataset for homophobia
detection known to us, an analysis of various models' performance and our
strongest BERT-based model, we aim to enhance online safety and inclusivity.
Future work will extend to broader LGBTQIA+ hate speech detection, addressing
the challenges of sourcing diverse datasets. Through this endeavour, we
contribute to the larger effort against online hate, advocating for a more
inclusive digital landscape. Our study not only offers insights into the
effective detection of homophobic content by improving on previous research
results, but it also lays groundwork for future advancements in hate speech
analysis.
|
[
-0.6193134188652039,
-0.6890607476234436,
0.17973431944847107,
0.10623985528945923,
-0.18883605301380157,
0.04985898733139038,
-0.20628081262111664,
-0.9381581544876099,
0.14698441326618195,
0.029657747596502304,
-0.685881495475769,
-0.32570019364356995,
-0.7480534315109253,
0.05608604848384857,
-0.5765098333358765,
0.8319518566131592,
0.40321028232574463,
0.27608999609947205,
-0.021574735641479492,
-0.07904195785522461,
-0.14331559836864471,
-0.4727992117404938,
-0.5686191320419312,
-0.0005747408722527325,
0.8414084315299988,
-0.08359828591346741,
0.7557434439659119,
0.2851412892341614,
0.4900892674922943,
0.19771628081798553,
-0.380705863237381,
-0.22414322197437286,
-0.5949434638023376,
0.3851701319217682,
-0.1255812793970108,
-0.004467417486011982,
-0.25081419944763184,
-0.05921363830566406,
0.4956513047218323,
0.4152261018753052,
0.09430162608623505,
-0.04253866523504257,
0.037284646183252335,
0.3344052731990814,
-0.5073604583740234,
-0.2821251153945923,
-0.9357328414916992,
0.21214944124221802,
-0.3320077359676361,
0.3380357623100281,
-0.24283438920974731,
-0.466639906167984,
0.3554883599281311,
-0.15053772926330566,
0.2744722366333008,
-0.0031057531014084816,
0.7506617903709412,
-0.05504017695784569,
-0.27850639820098877,
-0.541651725769043,
-0.6051877737045288,
0.9896339774131775,
-0.8151367902755737,
0.795116662979126,
0.1677170693874359,
0.11108340322971344,
0.2383652776479721,
-0.49698466062545776,
-0.6351703405380249,
-0.09192489832639694,
0.1513848602771759,
-0.12696824967861176,
-0.5754378437995911,
-0.1434965431690216,
-0.04924343526363373,
0.259101927280426,
-0.6323720216751099,
0.19819553196430206,
-0.40845155715942383,
-0.20454348623752594,
0.7152203321456909,
-0.25051286816596985,
0.1811845898628235,
-0.38116854429244995,
-0.5447427034378052,
-0.027409126982092857,
-0.24375741183757782,
0.05472594127058983,
0.5744925141334534,
0.6321653127670288,
0.05525446683168411,
0.08278543502092361,
0.4551301896572113,
0.40653330087661743,
-0.12513409554958344,
0.026379914954304695,
0.44073715806007385,
0.3676689863204956,
-0.16665580868721008,
0.07233023643493652,
0.5645319223403931,
0.4200230836868286,
0.2602733075618744,
-0.22422613203525543,
-0.29791367053985596,
0.1635105013847351,
0.5851300358772278,
-0.5072070956230164,
0.012384858913719654,
0.18870966136455536,
-0.5374194979667664,
-0.17258088290691376,
-0.05105200037360191,
-0.94012451171875,
-0.9964856505393982,
-0.021574407815933228,
0.3377454876899719,
-0.5323959589004517,
-0.37952545285224915,
-0.3344488739967346,
-0.4724683463573456,
0.34984290599823,
0.4920606315135956,
-0.5918877124786377,
0.2180619090795517,
0.8497010469436646,
0.7639818787574768,
-0.42853260040283203,
0.09377174079418182,
-0.05913225933909416,
-0.27632397413253784,
-0.12862224876880646,
0.3715713918209076,
-0.640559732913971,
-0.16301770508289337,
0.2317325472831726,
-0.28655657172203064,
0.3642767071723938,
-0.44213390350341797,
0.8728108406066895,
-0.6059924960136414,
0.25199517607688904,
-0.2746046781539917,
-0.7643654942512512,
-0.2457009106874466,
0.3627980947494507,
-0.5423119068145752,
0.9865463376045227,
0.24956203997135162,
-1.0145001411437988,
0.576415479183197,
-0.6456224322319031,
-0.2906923294067383,
0.0759347602725029,
-0.14988699555397034,
-0.5497108101844788,
0.2834547162055969,
0.06165382266044617,
0.4181894063949585,
-0.12610337138175964,
0.05127733200788498,
-0.7499200701713562,
-0.10693490505218506,
0.3105843663215637,
-0.08703012019395828,
0.9938549399375916,
0.3992384672164917,
-0.7923318147659302,
0.24077321588993073,
-0.4214925169944763,
-0.17839354276657104,
0.17838719487190247,
0.18802061676979065,
-0.5353544354438782,
0.11580455303192139,
0.47878143191337585,
0.34568801522254944,
-0.009276056662201881,
-1.0049734115600586,
-0.37696513533592224,
-0.23985116183757782,
0.23658517003059387,
1.1131633520126343,
-0.4549610912799835,
0.0296726506203413,
-0.21898393332958221,
0.3343741297721863,
-0.19480670988559723,
0.3998337686061859,
0.5620092749595642,
-0.9190587401390076,
-0.3003274202346802,
-0.34607216715812683,
0.11426772177219391,
0.34571683406829834,
-0.28028595447540283,
0.5694066882133484,
0.00864899531006813,
-0.42445817589759827,
-0.5677734017372131,
-0.04423873499035835,
0.25904250144958496,
0.5343141555786133,
0.4324120283126831,
-0.30022498965263367,
-1.0830929279327393,
-0.8508317470550537,
-0.35951876640319824,
-0.30703869462013245,
0.004182491451501846,
0.347496896982193,
0.3485366404056549,
-0.3390718698501587,
1.1108258962631226,
0.09909476339817047,
-0.1915496289730072,
-0.35022103786468506,
0.30438581109046936,
-0.06964334100484848,
0.15412281453609467,
0.7602969408035278,
-1.3316489458084106,
-0.7578672170639038,
-0.3239741027355194,
-0.5487369298934937,
-0.2662948668003082,
0.27223682403564453,
0.07326152175664902,
0.21330323815345764,
0.1376323699951172,
0.17891043424606323,
0.4569358825683594,
0.5959407687187195,
-0.5660515427589417,
0.0870974138379097,
0.6601765155792236,
0.31840139627456665,
-0.6470036506652832,
-0.275928795337677,
0.16039873659610748,
-0.38456064462661743,
-0.9639118313789368,
0.13514810800552368,
-0.22133231163024902,
0.1060650497674942,
-0.6268335580825806,
0.21933820843696594,
-0.05155950039625168,
0.06642670184373856,
-0.26252833008766174,
0.15471337735652924,
-0.42541155219078064,
0.10959231108427048,
0.12788550555706024,
0.5007836818695068,
0.4742577075958252,
-0.23639793694019318,
0.26576653122901917,
0.33246856927871704,
-0.3735440969467163,
0.37139782309532166,
-0.29555559158325195,
0.09100042283535004,
-0.10749693959951401,
0.05148642882704735,
-1.3128443956375122,
-0.07182839512825012,
0.48154938220977783,
-0.8202483057975769,
-0.01950911432504654,
-0.003928530961275101,
-0.2934943735599518,
-0.45976880192756653,
-0.7821632623672485,
0.2585911750793457,
0.7168658375740051,
-0.43002814054489136,
0.3987307846546173,
0.7350327372550964,
-0.26326417922973633,
-0.46499550342559814,
-0.7144802808761597,
-0.07198639214038849,
-0.43611231446266174,
-0.703053891658783,
0.4082966148853302,
-0.043595485389232635,
-0.6055423021316528,
-0.1461338847875595,
-0.02829143963754177,
-0.43813517689704895,
0.22016756236553192,
0.34010955691337585,
0.10478181391954422,
-0.03351037949323654,
0.1538931131362915,
-0.043565601110458374,
0.4233691990375519,
0.36045390367507935,
-0.003946417942643166,
0.6036586165428162,
-0.0644821897149086,
0.01951504871249199,
-0.29221776127815247,
0.5932953357696533,
0.45962655544281006,
0.49904197454452515,
0.8679561614990234,
1.0887552499771118,
-0.5554780960083008,
-0.14930345118045807,
-0.5445622801780701,
-0.0904105007648468,
-0.4112076759338379,
0.044674500823020935,
0.15298686921596527,
-1.248759150505066,
0.3973315358161926,
0.3939129412174225,
0.11469840258359909,
0.5200205445289612,
0.514506459236145,
-0.38932281732559204,
0.8491597175598145,
0.7146430611610413,
-0.27906277775764465,
0.5082054138183594,
0.2464553713798523,
0.22906999289989471,
-0.4134196937084198,
-0.03574105724692345,
-0.5040952563285828,
-0.3463568091392517,
-0.6440675854682922,
-0.26714208722114563,
0.37245625257492065,
-0.39875513315200806,
-0.1644195169210434,
0.22893044352531433,
-0.4845034182071686,
0.0511237271130085,
0.497930109500885,
0.08886449784040451,
-0.10391531139612198,
0.1262156218290329,
0.04472693055868149,
-0.5525418519973755,
-0.3583132028579712,
-0.2759372293949127,
1.0855605602264404,
0.5989468097686768,
0.34452956914901733,
0.3390353322029114,
0.6173334121704102,
0.9594540596008301,
0.461593896150589,
-0.5572890043258667,
0.3808819651603699,
-0.05657622590661049,
-1.1457722187042236,
-0.3909793198108673,
-0.44708868861198425,
-0.7472299933433533,
0.08032142370939255,
-0.191703200340271,
-1.0668609142303467,
0.14880278706550598,
0.019481442868709564,
-0.1845514178276062,
0.8243749737739563,
-0.2757967710494995,
0.5623155832290649,
-0.01354161649942398,
-0.47894102334976196,
-0.16137737035751343,
-0.8995226621627808,
0.34804871678352356,
-0.19247190654277802,
0.636302649974823,
-0.17971649765968323,
0.015929482877254486,
0.9248522520065308,
-0.16790197789669037,
1.0310710668563843,
-0.43728747963905334,
-0.5142571926116943,
0.2192104607820511,
-0.10601098090410233,
0.16880150139331818,
-0.33130523562431335,
-0.4844335615634918,
0.43112215399742126,
-0.4105592370033264,
-0.26690158247947693,
-0.05959358438849449,
0.5290820598602295,
-0.8327766060829163,
-0.2569412589073181,
-0.33770933747291565,
-0.5421332120895386,
-0.37708356976509094,
-0.18800130486488342,
0.24341435730457306,
0.033951740711927414,
-0.303431898355484,
0.3465185761451721,
0.8492085933685303,
-0.24770784378051758,
0.3964068293571472,
0.035145681351423264,
-0.4215955436229706,
-0.5550024509429932,
0.6782034039497375,
0.0163419172167778,
-0.041011299937963486,
0.34734833240509033,
0.30633047223091125,
-0.5071073174476624,
-0.5352962613105774,
-0.0826398953795433,
0.02517416886985302,
-0.6784735321998596,
-0.017030058428645134,
-0.6663992404937744,
-0.11496058851480484,
-0.9608273506164551,
-0.3310561180114746,
-0.19612810015678406,
-0.21077421307563782,
-0.049840886145830154,
0.1524808257818222,
0.5225003361701965,
0.9236316680908203,
-0.48420289158821106,
0.4209757149219513,
-0.6636289954185486,
0.4765769839286804,
0.4330728054046631,
0.3009564280509949,
-0.021166155114769936,
-0.8084754347801208,
-0.028059115633368492,
-0.06496833264827728,
-0.20509645342826843,
-1.2263450622558594,
0.5160412192344666,
0.07434257119894028,
0.3881167471408844,
0.5401806831359863,
0.2760448455810547,
0.6055693626403809,
-0.315067321062088,
0.9736874103546143,
0.2647044360637665,
-1.0978970527648926,
0.537493109703064,
-0.34388020634651184,
-0.40194910764694214,
0.42783787846565247,
0.981813907623291,
-0.5976716876029968,
-0.4510818421840668,
-0.8282573819160461,
-0.9663400053977966,
0.6308623552322388,
0.55364590883255,
0.0605180449783802,
0.025000646710395813,
-0.021012941375374794,
0.4654865264892578,
0.4727157950401306,
-1.133002519607544,
-0.5006274580955505,
-0.18014557659626007,
0.011109777726233006,
0.11858879029750824,
-0.5043152570724487,
-0.086409792304039,
-0.5741300582885742,
0.8268261551856995,
0.3515363037586212,
0.5100347995758057,
0.14380834996700287,
-0.1689998060464859,
-0.09312041848897934,
0.22243556380271912,
0.25552406907081604,
0.6901980042457581,
-0.5682796835899353,
-0.15066218376159668,
0.08380874991416931,
-0.434622585773468,
-0.1240067407488823,
0.004107958171516657,
-0.08790966123342514,
0.4775894284248352,
0.4407290816307068,
0.6829580068588257,
-0.13433143496513367,
-0.7034139633178711,
0.7159343361854553,
0.024090148508548737,
-0.3166702091693878,
-0.35936883091926575,
-0.21722975373268127,
-0.3853147327899933,
0.29389336705207825,
0.5678419470787048,
-0.17416909337043762,
0.4156429171562195,
-0.45113319158554077,
0.5470004677772522,
0.3874240517616272,
-0.7235186696052551,
-0.18956321477890015,
0.5925744771957397,
0.18520545959472656,
-0.31962138414382935,
0.3854806125164032,
-0.26042884588241577,
-0.79509037733078,
0.39976760745048523,
0.48264655470848083,
1.0408138036727905,
-0.30157142877578735,
0.27163082361221313,
0.18253134191036224,
0.27793750166893005,
0.590705156326294,
0.40188032388687134,
-0.1573922485113144,
-0.8745569586753845,
0.027302352711558342,
-0.6127379536628723,
-0.5549367666244507,
0.20358191430568695,
-0.7995162606239319,
0.021515589207410812,
-0.7203909158706665,
-0.20918725430965424,
0.04537801444530487,
-0.104076087474823,
-0.3046596944332123,
0.36488914489746094,
0.9783155918121338,
0.8242597579956055,
-0.9237123727798462,
0.5339126586914062,
0.46954143047332764,
0.05886978283524513,
-0.41819384694099426,
0.2333153933286667,
0.48527494072914124,
-0.6920464634895325,
0.45286309719085693,
0.38989052176475525,
-0.2610001266002655,
-0.1878191977739334,
-0.7558135390281677,
-0.42274585366249084,
0.46019598841667175,
0.13052377104759216,
-0.5083786249160767,
0.24644869565963745,
0.16874787211418152,
0.6324748396873474,
-0.4099235534667969,
0.21481093764305115,
0.40136635303497314,
0.5598189830780029,
0.1729537844657898,
-0.6806118488311768,
-0.1322772353887558,
-0.21401119232177734,
-0.09230121225118637,
0.14234478771686554,
-0.3325130045413971,
1.0935609340667725,
0.2865249514579773,
-0.17939211428165436,
-0.11465364694595337,
0.6765871047973633,
-0.005126548931002617,
0.4332047998905182,
0.9441983103752136,
0.4629635214805603,
0.7927232980728149,
-0.07313524931669235,
0.7691231966018677,
0.11743976175785065,
0.37916675209999084,
1.0137219429016113,
-0.3240896761417389,
0.8540692329406738,
0.36966386437416077,
-0.31672102212905884,
0.7374761700630188,
0.6010986566543579,
-0.012641217559576035,
0.41679254174232483,
0.389883816242218,
-0.4160751700401306,
-0.3295895755290985,
-0.35084882378578186,
-0.48586034774780273,
0.29310181736946106,
0.41458433866500854,
-0.4257330596446991,
-0.32740893959999084,
0.30419522523880005,
0.027552230283617973,
0.19749777019023895,
-0.5006136894226074,
0.6998166441917419,
-0.24380840361118317,
0.07358817756175995,
0.4167945086956024,
-0.03319522365927696,
1.0937838554382324,
-0.6612381339073181,
0.25081759691238403,
-0.01887494884431362,
0.1070626974105835,
-0.12501446902751923,
-0.799490213394165,
0.5019128918647766,
0.41310498118400574,
-0.10782520473003387,
-0.4987414479255676,
0.7424472570419312,
-0.07503986358642578,
-0.12239104509353638,
0.7827669382095337,
0.38349249958992004,
0.28720971941947937,
-0.29623398184776306,
-0.9871700406074524,
0.4267826974391937,
0.3167498707771301,
0.07401255518198013,
0.2678919732570648,
0.2856205999851227,
0.062321845442056656,
0.5219702124595642,
0.46291106939315796,
-0.016793403774499893,
0.3398648500442505,
0.16109740734100342,
0.9163869619369507,
-0.8362414240837097,
-0.6269690990447998,
-0.9302753210067749,
0.5200167894363403,
-0.3681275248527527,
-0.37952756881713867,
0.9960967898368835,
0.4671380817890167,
1.0894769430160522,
-0.03715943172574043,
0.8045679330825806,
-0.5822657942771912,
1.0311650037765503,
0.05635853856801987,
0.6543586850166321,
-0.6241781115531921,
0.04520832374691963,
-0.7872411608695984,
-0.662975013256073,
-0.5860093235969543,
0.6660938262939453,
-0.28043439984321594,
-0.13016961514949799,
0.3958464562892914,
0.6427780389785767,
0.09087841957807541,
0.3370502293109894,
0.4846201241016388,
0.3915208578109741,
0.2806088328361511,
0.12855853140354156,
0.9759475588798523,
-0.45774227380752563,
0.4438759386539459,
-0.38035669922828674,
-0.2270018607378006,
-0.3037697970867157,
-0.801094651222229,
-0.8749704957008362,
-0.6443232297897339,
-0.29163146018981934,
-0.41369444131851196,
0.18588438630104065,
1.1896626949310303,
0.6422334909439087,
-1.1051794290542603,
-0.32474491000175476,
0.11488949507474899,
0.2637418210506439,
-0.12250325828790665,
-0.2881888449192047,
-0.13237938284873962,
-0.2828201651573181,
-0.780414342880249,
0.2605406641960144,
0.08763661980628967,
-0.2086503505706787,
-0.10042553395032883,
-0.03731367364525795,
-0.5586411356925964,
0.23757874965667725,
0.673412024974823,
0.17175354063510895,
-0.8159953355789185,
-0.28786349296569824,
-0.25221821665763855,
-0.03567463532090187,
0.2727492153644562,
0.7210322022438049,
-0.6442001461982727,
0.33188918232917786,
0.46069493889808655,
0.7908928990364075,
0.0812188908457756,
-0.1376015990972519,
0.2949587404727936,
-0.8965066075325012,
0.0395800843834877,
0.5356626510620117,
0.298238068819046,
0.3301190137863159,
-0.32875964045524597,
0.3603600859642029,
0.43136677145957947,
-0.23267269134521484,
-0.9375560879707336,
0.1538459211587906,
-0.9507161974906921,
-0.45565715432167053,
0.9525344371795654,
-0.19071531295776367,
-0.13739709556102753,
-0.3540817201137543,
-0.16073893010616302,
0.2208653688430786,
-0.6500711441040039,
1.0000337362289429,
0.5913434028625488,
-0.1972779780626297,
-0.06929311901330948,
-0.08065636456012726,
0.5116339921951294,
0.31413957476615906,
-0.5475024580955505,
0.11431039124727249,
0.5033439993858337,
-0.14230398833751678,
0.18496446311473846,
0.19193123281002045,
0.11347845196723938,
0.24077346920967102,
-0.20283956825733185,
0.2934795916080475,
0.36021414399147034,
-0.40859338641166687,
-0.5674853324890137,
0.5862672328948975,
-0.32962289452552795,
-0.19456323981285095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09220v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09220v2
|
ALPINE: Unveiling the Planning Capability of Autoregressive Learning in Language Models
| 2024-05-15T09:59:37 | 2024-05-27T05:25:05 |
Siwei Wang, Yifei Shen, Shi Feng, Haoran Sun, Shang-Hua Teng, Wei Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we present the findings of our Project ALPINE which stands for
``Autoregressive Learning for Planning In NEtworks." Project ALPINE initiates a
theoretical investigation into the development of planning capabilities in
Transformer-based language models through their autoregressive learning
mechanisms, aiming to identify any potential limitations in their planning
abilities. We abstract planning as a network path-finding task where the
objective is to generate a valid path from a specified source node to a
designated target node. In terms of expressiveness, we show that the
Transformer is capable of executing path-finding by embedding the adjacency and
reachability matrices within its weights. Our theoretical analysis of the
gradient-based learning dynamic of the Transformer reveals that the Transformer
is capable of learning both the adjacency matrix and a limited form of the
reachability matrix. These theoretical insights are then validated through
experiments, which demonstrate that the Transformer indeed learns the adjacency
matrix and an incomplete reachability matrix, which aligns with the predictions
made in our theoretical analysis. Additionally, when applying our methodology
to a real-world planning benchmark, called Blocksworld, our observations remain
consistent. Our theoretical and empirical analyses further unveil a potential
limitation of Transformer in path-finding: it cannot identify reachability
relationships through transitivity, and thus would fail when path concatenation
is needed to generate a path. In summary, our findings shed new light on how
the internal mechanisms of autoregressive learning enable planning in networks.
This study may contribute to our understanding of the general planning
capabilities in other related domains.
|
[
-0.4705992639064789,
-0.5419946908950806,
0.2450539469718933,
0.13945046067237854,
0.2279588133096695,
0.031828418374061584,
-0.05334821715950966,
-0.3714219033718109,
0.3488873243331909,
0.32866209745407104,
-0.9562337398529053,
-0.19405874609947205,
-0.48786771297454834,
-0.11893222481012344,
-0.5963348150253296,
0.4877278506755829,
-0.44678544998168945,
-0.5095951557159424,
0.2290063500404358,
-0.2522084414958954,
-0.534995436668396,
-0.185915008187294,
-0.7427160739898682,
-0.4036918580532074,
0.495368093252182,
0.3989521861076355,
0.7832014560699463,
0.879102349281311,
0.36085769534111023,
0.2516106367111206,
0.057806845754384995,
0.0464777946472168,
-0.20193447172641754,
0.4915961027145386,
-0.1954553723335266,
-0.23356246948242188,
-0.3784201741218567,
-0.24363574385643005,
0.8813145160675049,
0.7562718987464905,
-0.3927410840988159,
0.09301266819238663,
-0.008878552354872227,
1.0306508541107178,
-0.6542553305625916,
0.3673747777938843,
-0.8368499875068665,
0.3330213725566864,
0.06903090327978134,
0.01401726808398962,
-0.21071957051753998,
0.1310190111398697,
0.044802021235227585,
-0.5264106392860413,
0.44163426756858826,
0.10594594478607178,
0.5762532353401184,
0.44828522205352783,
-0.4377060830593109,
-0.496285617351532,
-1.166695475578308,
0.4419817626476288,
-0.12058716267347336,
0.53617262840271,
0.415717214345932,
0.7432013154029846,
0.017831578850746155,
-0.7041845321655273,
-0.43142497539520264,
0.07784764468669891,
-0.18586474657058716,
-0.045626841485500336,
-0.2342892736196518,
-0.1653793454170227,
0.37474945187568665,
0.31433770060539246,
-0.7008869647979736,
0.20672234892845154,
-0.34116825461387634,
-0.205668106675148,
0.659602165222168,
0.333541601896286,
0.09157746285200119,
-0.10004060715436935,
-0.0782175064086914,
-0.10778465121984482,
-0.6369472146034241,
0.20887531340122223,
0.42931678891181946,
0.3774546682834625,
0.11403051018714905,
0.4059458076953888,
-0.41258153319358826,
0.6285945773124695,
-0.33901870250701904,
0.6958016157150269,
0.05157413333654404,
-0.17462235689163208,
-0.1401158571243286,
-0.1334659457206726,
0.7951269745826721,
-0.22146959602832794,
0.11958343535661697,
-0.3642166256904602,
-0.5743279457092285,
-0.20408283174037933,
0.392599880695343,
-0.4719378650188446,
-0.6357076168060303,
-0.008542242459952831,
-0.388016015291214,
-0.0765329897403717,
-0.3600345253944397,
-0.5271180868148804,
0.08182734996080399,
-0.019016677513718605,
0.1869889795780182,
-0.345695823431015,
-0.6068052649497986,
0.03869974613189697,
0.06823930889368057,
0.19275279343128204,
0.23499837517738342,
-1.0474152565002441,
0.6987119913101196,
0.39749595522880554,
0.8223761916160583,
0.03223983198404312,
-0.5228156447410583,
-0.38725003600120544,
0.071312814950943,
-0.5100321769714355,
0.7484760880470276,
-0.253682404756546,
-0.5725657343864441,
0.22813254594802856,
0.005349382758140564,
-0.2721143066883087,
-0.4957251250743866,
0.2054157853126526,
-0.7068345546722412,
-0.14358577132225037,
-0.14134782552719116,
-0.061538588255643845,
-0.36860084533691406,
0.11754272133111954,
-0.8606468439102173,
0.8025693297386169,
0.01878749020397663,
-0.32501527667045593,
0.44429776072502136,
-0.6593626737594604,
-0.8058006763458252,
-0.060906246304512024,
0.02141227014362812,
-0.39036932587623596,
-0.2140609622001648,
-0.10417231917381287,
0.3896966874599457,
-0.14210377633571625,
0.496473491191864,
0.09857488423585892,
0.061932943761348724,
-0.04754440858960152,
-0.4047497808933258,
0.9142934679985046,
0.12793533504009247,
-0.5579803586006165,
-0.08718859404325485,
-0.718639612197876,
-0.10479271411895752,
0.16445161402225494,
-0.15721076726913452,
-0.03809860348701477,
0.46336886286735535,
-0.2464274764060974,
0.5978378653526306,
-0.22710852324962616,
-0.3089450001716614,
0.27011603116989136,
-0.336128830909729,
0.3592033088207245,
0.7039706707000732,
-0.14500792324543,
0.5886699557304382,
-0.17869345843791962,
0.5573688745498657,
-0.3749670088291168,
0.2188071310520172,
-0.3048876225948334,
-0.33151671290397644,
-0.8757078051567078,
0.28568315505981445,
0.10876738280057907,
0.3945702612400055,
-0.6258143782615662,
0.2995959520339966,
-0.10465370863676071,
-0.5105272531509399,
-0.04306760057806969,
-0.09415339678525925,
0.35671213269233704,
0.38688746094703674,
0.6890437602996826,
-0.43107423186302185,
-0.36357882618904114,
-0.8044552206993103,
-0.12128143012523651,
-0.42720967531204224,
0.12246689200401306,
0.3632095158100128,
0.5386675000190735,
0.06109076365828514,
0.9447376728057861,
-0.6642265915870667,
-0.5101015567779541,
-0.2735253572463989,
0.29185640811920166,
0.06126270443201065,
0.48415324091911316,
0.31580519676208496,
-0.9629596471786499,
-0.528351366519928,
-0.2602914869785309,
-0.5925721526145935,
0.029153108596801758,
-0.12760473787784576,
0.028360916301608086,
-0.22113466262817383,
0.45371052622795105,
-0.504221498966217,
0.4159717559814453,
0.40756237506866455,
-0.17040812969207764,
0.4958009719848633,
-0.20076385140419006,
-0.4614298641681671,
-0.6382727026939392,
-0.15583020448684692,
0.09085299074649811,
-0.10627976059913635,
-0.5493942499160767,
-0.15228158235549927,
0.04648953303694725,
0.03669245168566704,
-0.34698644280433655,
0.542661190032959,
-0.7091960310935974,
-0.12026336044073105,
-0.22265447676181793,
-0.08418335020542145,
-0.25788721442222595,
0.6104205846786499,
0.04631438106298447,
0.5081749558448792,
0.8573875427246094,
-1.0045100450515747,
0.3002723455429077,
0.30547577142715454,
-0.08865047246217728,
0.33319664001464844,
-0.4852110743522644,
-0.18021799623966217,
-0.02128060720860958,
0.4119677245616913,
-0.855928361415863,
0.030208885669708252,
0.2666671574115753,
-0.3327360153198242,
0.506233811378479,
-0.3623703122138977,
-0.4046565890312195,
-0.2953181862831116,
0.37053099274635315,
0.5125835537910461,
0.6170492768287659,
-0.35789358615875244,
0.815036416053772,
0.6014983654022217,
0.1292615830898285,
-0.5052238702774048,
-0.6051834225654602,
-0.015112852677702904,
-0.012985187582671642,
-0.4215397536754608,
0.26963597536087036,
0.08039205521345139,
-0.19452045857906342,
0.2753884196281433,
0.044493015855550766,
-0.18595843017101288,
0.16480594873428345,
0.4769970178604126,
0.060321904718875885,
-0.016984550282359123,
0.1430618166923523,
-0.08834972977638245,
-0.36229783296585083,
0.49170684814453125,
-0.6351069808006287,
0.5400992631912231,
0.05507412925362587,
-0.5675173401832581,
-0.16314300894737244,
0.12766703963279724,
0.29786217212677,
-0.46057260036468506,
0.5309065580368042,
0.15308064222335815,
-0.3748009502887726,
-0.6459791660308838,
-0.1669664978981018,
0.056462254375219345,
-0.47500112652778625,
0.2328721433877945,
-0.3781590163707733,
-0.4683271646499634,
0.6575120687484741,
-0.3029857575893402,
0.15718844532966614,
0.8208858966827393,
0.03198124095797539,
0.22344134747982025,
0.8854688405990601,
0.7503005862236023,
0.1627308428287506,
0.18972092866897583,
-0.9629949927330017,
0.07119818031787872,
-1.222347617149353,
-0.401297390460968,
-0.45847466588020325,
-0.4751898944377899,
-0.685648500919342,
-0.2028859257698059,
0.13741225004196167,
-0.40451157093048096,
-0.153451070189476,
0.6694595217704773,
-0.36503326892852783,
0.11723674088716507,
0.35452011227607727,
-0.43755361437797546,
0.10025828331708908,
-0.36592787504196167,
-0.49347785115242004,
0.20569290220737457,
-1.015720248222351,
-0.1747174859046936,
0.7472827434539795,
0.329121470451355,
0.5190730094909668,
0.047947898507118225,
0.44151726365089417,
0.20757555961608887,
0.3019373118877411,
-0.7672878503799438,
0.5929980874061584,
0.1658124476671219,
-0.7401794791221619,
-0.6356979608535767,
-0.4267987012863159,
-0.9746460318565369,
0.17668990790843964,
-0.23323000967502594,
-0.7247846126556396,
0.5584350228309631,
0.3557032346725464,
0.024224065244197845,
0.6766926646232605,
-0.2042827159166336,
0.6371774077415466,
-0.2058221399784088,
-0.30363231897354126,
-0.1728745400905609,
-0.6157804131507874,
-0.029983824118971825,
-0.18765908479690552,
0.3748491108417511,
-0.2062608301639557,
0.24977722764015198,
0.8081378936767578,
-0.07968182116746902,
0.7239081859588623,
-0.3707069158554077,
0.024765493348240852,
0.2759096622467041,
0.5926711559295654,
0.6719956398010254,
-0.244800865650177,
-0.1319884955883026,
0.17282870411872864,
-0.70737224817276,
-0.22586961090564728,
-0.6185914874076843,
0.569004237651825,
-0.48198166489601135,
-0.4168313145637512,
-0.2635382413864136,
-0.47083204984664917,
-0.26989537477493286,
0.315292626619339,
0.15661269426345825,
0.7832311391830444,
-0.6210914254188538,
-0.15474861860275269,
0.38202059268951416,
0.029454898089170456,
0.8550304770469666,
0.5502448678016663,
-0.3930673599243164,
-0.11799316108226776,
0.8549094796180725,
0.6137427687644958,
0.3386845290660858,
0.48327645659446716,
-0.16041193902492523,
-0.24667510390281677,
-0.7044569253921509,
-0.35670989751815796,
0.3871549367904663,
-0.6061575412750244,
0.1554400622844696,
-0.7041972875595093,
-0.5564325451850891,
0.02895917184650898,
-0.20799566805362701,
-0.6368060111999512,
-0.810359001159668,
0.0913483202457428,
-0.14208373427391052,
-0.2795420289039612,
1.2975269556045532,
-0.3613780736923218,
0.4085540771484375,
-0.302627831697464,
-0.25323960185050964,
0.3223838806152344,
0.28090497851371765,
0.3186550438404083,
-0.23701658844947815,
-0.5014455318450928,
0.018827030435204506,
-0.5690813660621643,
-0.6151797771453857,
0.697213351726532,
0.02967003732919693,
0.6260899901390076,
0.2586477994918823,
0.23262573778629303,
0.33456000685691833,
-0.8972756862640381,
0.552038311958313,
0.04931778088212013,
-0.6601841449737549,
0.7055925130844116,
-0.2071312516927719,
0.15006427466869354,
0.40471336245536804,
0.6856375932693481,
-0.49462804198265076,
-0.5127224326133728,
-1.1600929498672485,
-1.1197854280471802,
0.5574979782104492,
0.5028015971183777,
0.05799821764230728,
0.18676386773586273,
0.18789087235927582,
0.01396819669753313,
0.20861521363258362,
-0.5445407629013062,
-0.4895314872264862,
-0.11691240966320038,
0.44538605213165283,
-0.3858223259449005,
-0.2617795169353485,
-0.04011920467019081,
-0.09413463622331619,
0.8121910095214844,
0.0005220364546403289,
0.3037307560443878,
0.0880713239312172,
0.07736735045909882,
-0.35203438997268677,
-0.07768836617469788,
0.36575186252593994,
0.9062777161598206,
-0.1043914258480072,
0.3453874886035919,
0.1912062168121338,
-0.2570490837097168,
0.2827787697315216,
0.14231596887111664,
-0.24318023025989532,
0.10311989486217499,
0.46753454208374023,
0.9091507196426392,
-0.23003268241882324,
-0.14422224462032318,
0.3073088824748993,
-0.3134039640426636,
-0.44845911860466003,
-0.515287458896637,
0.21275821328163147,
-0.28975480794906616,
0.12290444225072861,
0.571527898311615,
0.4188922643661499,
0.21102403104305267,
-0.2612457573413849,
0.2856799066066742,
0.5454418659210205,
-0.9756660461425781,
-0.6035179495811462,
0.6372134685516357,
0.0361526682972908,
-0.9187051653862,
0.7604787945747375,
-0.2685057520866394,
-0.6667280793190002,
0.7551727890968323,
0.5825746655464172,
1.1171936988830566,
-0.45857685804367065,
0.4137789011001587,
0.3815101683139801,
0.5280161499977112,
0.07717645913362503,
-0.1556188464164734,
-0.30288925766944885,
-0.9022714495658875,
-0.17319345474243164,
-0.3803265690803528,
-0.2050655484199524,
-0.16015836596488953,
-0.52522873878479,
0.08585867285728455,
-0.18394435942173004,
-0.0227292999625206,
-0.24844974279403687,
-0.23291176557540894,
-0.6907385587692261,
0.3967269957065582,
-0.42576712369918823,
1.0572638511657715,
-1.0219731330871582,
0.5574042797088623,
0.617861807346344,
-0.026175696402788162,
-1.0729727745056152,
0.37277403473854065,
0.022250551730394363,
-0.9784713983535767,
1.1210302114486694,
0.08254389464855194,
-0.4113616645336151,
0.11170171946287155,
-0.063757985830307,
-0.9193879961967468,
1.2280157804489136,
-0.1632908433675766,
-0.22862328588962555,
-0.281672865152359,
-0.006344410590827465,
0.28955575823783875,
-0.41696321964263916,
0.2664535939693451,
-0.1493416130542755,
0.24803456664085388,
0.46820107102394104,
-0.9667860269546509,
0.11257746070623398,
-0.29277142882347107,
-0.0817747414112091,
0.696463406085968,
-0.6151513457298279,
0.7718109488487244,
-0.08498194813728333,
-0.4164680242538452,
-0.519741415977478,
0.7050220966339111,
-0.5288819670677185,
0.14347496628761292,
0.7790694832801819,
0.3969780206680298,
0.567939817905426,
0.13776777684688568,
1.0115398168563843,
-0.4408324360847473,
0.45932790637016296,
0.7412384152412415,
-0.17308230698108673,
0.6933184266090393,
0.08831865340471268,
-0.06462831050157547,
0.664774477481842,
0.49362727999687195,
0.4724509119987488,
0.9301252961158752,
0.19000515341758728,
-0.12639695405960083,
-0.08832349628210068,
0.051833007484674454,
-0.024818170815706253,
0.3131379187107086,
0.38065865635871887,
-0.24286694824695587,
-0.3286888897418976,
-0.12518256902694702,
0.022457242012023926,
-0.22884058952331543,
-0.3395102322101593,
0.5276084542274475,
0.08958197385072708,
-0.8002052307128906,
0.5394143462181091,
-0.30516672134399414,
-0.03703264147043228,
-0.6531296372413635,
-0.07668635994195938,
0.0995410606265068,
0.06746287643909454,
-0.09459483623504639,
-0.9229831099510193,
0.7369153499603271,
-0.49408531188964844,
0.07404825091362,
-0.5227768421173096,
0.6325555443763733,
-0.06956932693719864,
-0.1826494336128235,
0.5637766122817993,
0.5191376209259033,
-0.1634187549352646,
0.236576646566391,
-0.5107928514480591,
-0.20976223051548004,
-0.08765911310911179,
-0.21665972471237183,
0.2976449728012085,
0.6943467855453491,
0.26553094387054443,
1.030815601348877,
0.4932512044906616,
0.467564195394516,
-0.08530493080615997,
-0.49922803044319153,
0.9443448781967163,
-0.39919471740722656,
-0.4421575665473938,
-0.8774003386497498,
0.6168627738952637,
0.023030048236250877,
-0.13117283582687378,
0.5913708209991455,
0.7415915131568909,
1.0323939323425293,
0.3706924617290497,
0.7797605395317078,
-0.042625874280929565,
0.20098020136356354,
-0.6420772671699524,
0.34949207305908203,
-0.4481249749660492,
0.5341120362281799,
0.15586034953594208,
-0.990260660648346,
-0.2777847945690155,
0.8164932727813721,
-0.6353210806846619,
-0.10187578201293945,
0.8353256583213806,
0.6206831336021423,
-0.30940335988998413,
-0.12721256911754608,
0.20286020636558533,
0.12258943915367126,
0.4450289011001587,
0.4959687292575836,
0.8547462224960327,
-0.16160283982753754,
0.38794270157814026,
-0.356486976146698,
-0.43011900782585144,
0.11848124861717224,
-0.7857152819633484,
-0.65335613489151,
-1.1396851539611816,
-0.16429419815540314,
-0.3231663107872009,
0.2262805998325348,
0.6191783547401428,
0.6915387511253357,
-0.34927618503570557,
-0.7338847517967224,
-0.5663241744041443,
0.267267107963562,
-0.27127745747566223,
-0.21382056176662445,
0.26924020051956177,
-0.41925039887428284,
-0.21934448182582855,
0.3508385419845581,
0.2856115996837616,
-0.11402766406536102,
-0.5767109394073486,
-0.19675137102603912,
-0.320828914642334,
-0.06179247051477432,
0.17385102808475494,
0.7029500603675842,
-0.09299066662788391,
0.03758549317717552,
0.011653213761746883,
0.27685481309890747,
0.0700114294886589,
1.0061627626419067,
-0.7394209504127502,
0.44204452633857727,
0.24991655349731445,
0.28025496006011963,
0.7660345435142517,
-0.39627760648727417,
0.793134331703186,
-0.533730149269104,
-0.041288696229457855,
0.2136826515197754,
0.4127972424030304,
0.1666020005941391,
-0.2630731761455536,
0.5793411731719971,
0.15278254449367523,
-0.9441700577735901,
-0.43957602977752686,
0.8266735076904297,
-0.3398681581020355,
-0.08785062283277512,
1.129733920097351,
0.004291965160518885,
-0.22902964055538177,
-0.20691917836666107,
0.02412736602127552,
0.2288590967655182,
-0.1865076869726181,
0.6489187479019165,
0.3381090462207794,
-0.5602564215660095,
0.05840203911066055,
-0.6513504385948181,
0.6512632966041565,
-0.028444331139326096,
-0.2842463254928589,
0.3715592324733734,
0.4096870720386505,
-0.04297253116965294,
0.43980658054351807,
1.0417777299880981,
0.4354548752307892,
-0.10330252349376678,
-0.1280919462442398,
-0.23270104825496674,
-0.22342230379581451,
-0.7428122162818909,
-0.17058037221431732,
0.13885043561458588,
0.07146606594324112,
-0.1410263627767563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09186v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09186v1
|
HumanRankEval: Automatic Evaluation of LMs as Conversational Assistants
| 2024-05-15T08:47:26 | 2024-05-15T08:47:26 |
Milan Gritta, Gerasimos Lampouras, Ignacio Iacobacci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) as conversational assistants recently became popular
tools that help people accomplish a variety of tasks. These typically result
from adapting LMs pretrained on general domain text sequences through further
instruction-tuning and possibly preference optimisation methods. The evaluation
of such LMs would ideally be performed using human judgement, however, this is
not scalable. On the other hand, automatic evaluation featuring auxiliary LMs
as judges and/or knowledge-based tasks is scalable but struggles with assessing
conversational ability and adherence to instructions. To help accelerate the
development of LMs as conversational assistants, we propose a novel automatic
evaluation task: HumanRankEval (HRE). It consists of a large-scale, diverse and
high-quality set of questions, each with several answers authored and scored by
humans. To perform evaluation, HRE ranks these answers based on their
log-likelihood under the LM's distribution, and subsequently calculates their
correlation with the corresponding human rankings. We support HRE's efficacy by
investigating how efficiently it separates pretrained and instruction-tuned LMs
of various sizes. We show that HRE correlates well with human judgements and is
particularly responsive to model changes following instruction-tuning.
|
[
-0.33347681164741516,
-0.6072601675987244,
0.38556671142578125,
0.21830417215824127,
0.0939064621925354,
0.26805347204208374,
-0.4938372075557709,
-0.3290732502937317,
0.13459983468055725,
0.2526428699493408,
-0.41874635219573975,
-0.3546857237815857,
-0.5114195942878723,
0.09730203449726105,
-0.2990887463092804,
0.7768955826759338,
0.2708268463611603,
0.1512461006641388,
-0.5127444863319397,
-0.11401458084583282,
-0.6087315678596497,
-0.5668323636054993,
-0.8109949231147766,
-0.23191870748996735,
0.38846954703330994,
0.5282846093177795,
0.8006241917610168,
0.4972958266735077,
0.6707397103309631,
0.41500505805015564,
-0.036641329526901245,
0.2550724744796753,
-0.4140878915786743,
0.10135588049888611,
-0.21314096450805664,
-0.35307779908180237,
-0.7637795805931091,
0.15809540450572968,
0.67424076795578,
0.8922850489616394,
-0.2921518087387085,
0.4038849472999573,
0.27977195382118225,
0.816974401473999,
-0.5937150120735168,
0.017930377274751663,
-0.6069222092628479,
-0.18607395887374878,
0.21315103769302368,
-0.1927778571844101,
-0.5664862990379333,
-0.6439284086227417,
0.359396755695343,
-0.36479321122169495,
0.1146419569849968,
0.13406804203987122,
0.6355540752410889,
0.36850953102111816,
-0.15048250555992126,
-0.3246113359928131,
-0.4345748722553253,
0.8321820497512817,
-0.5955039858818054,
0.4796997308731079,
0.6091540455818176,
0.5127092599868774,
0.04853162169456482,
-0.4120733439922333,
-0.3348514139652252,
-0.7211097478866577,
-0.05839076265692711,
-0.0432739183306694,
0.005847841966897249,
0.011820478364825249,
-0.03041338175535202,
0.3509945869445801,
-0.5988101959228516,
0.28954046964645386,
-0.06256179511547089,
-0.26373445987701416,
0.7648321390151978,
0.19207143783569336,
0.4204462766647339,
-0.2225879579782486,
-0.029573649168014526,
-0.28924164175987244,
-0.28613314032554626,
-0.07147832214832306,
0.3056740164756775,
0.3292093575000763,
0.06674454361200333,
0.29082542657852173,
-0.31362688541412354,
0.7783727049827576,
0.1713998168706894,
-0.0055308095179498196,
0.20030170679092407,
0.013428578153252602,
-0.13030287623405457,
-0.13661447167396545,
0.8164085149765015,
0.31983208656311035,
0.5048077702522278,
-0.38478484749794006,
-0.0903283953666687,
-0.0668991282582283,
0.5792262554168701,
-0.7074790596961975,
-0.44849124550819397,
0.11283457279205322,
-0.4445447027683258,
-0.6436874866485596,
0.020870456472039223,
-0.6105795502662659,
-0.517157793045044,
-0.3056938350200653,
0.7641498446464539,
-0.01792537420988083,
0.06298265606164932,
0.00017033050244208425,
0.1806873232126236,
-0.01818179339170456,
0.5499602556228638,
-0.8998668789863586,
0.47928282618522644,
0.48630574345588684,
0.6348391175270081,
-0.6766262054443359,
-0.37032467126846313,
-0.6958515644073486,
-0.28395575284957886,
-0.37166327238082886,
0.7267074584960938,
-0.561057448387146,
-0.5403527021408081,
-0.07439543306827545,
0.07352416217327118,
-0.22338949143886566,
-0.7754825949668884,
0.6157255172729492,
-0.7476441860198975,
0.5001899600028992,
-0.005725524388253689,
-0.6551738977432251,
0.16844993829727173,
0.2899709641933441,
-0.6301109790802002,
1.0129945278167725,
0.09463413804769516,
-0.35984253883361816,
0.1355084329843521,
-0.9626194834709167,
-0.3760046064853668,
0.1897682398557663,
-0.010875561274588108,
-0.40130650997161865,
-0.24926504492759705,
0.29301726818084717,
0.3565937578678131,
-0.4015463590621948,
0.05871743708848953,
-0.21646688878536224,
-0.3351280987262726,
0.3024715781211853,
-0.5070704817771912,
0.643747866153717,
0.06569685786962509,
-0.21888421475887299,
0.3746407628059387,
-0.6739423871040344,
0.29029354453086853,
-0.023550303652882576,
-0.5752405524253845,
-0.16864003241062164,
0.08500918745994568,
-0.08107610791921616,
0.02495766244828701,
0.45856061577796936,
-0.3649098873138428,
0.1282230168581009,
-0.326610267162323,
0.08092836290597916,
0.8699583411216736,
-0.014794317074120045,
0.6153656840324402,
-0.27095094323158264,
0.6742809414863586,
-0.4208891689777374,
0.31101852655410767,
0.03433294966816902,
-0.4837692677974701,
-0.9046939015388489,
-0.14857728779315948,
0.43440157175064087,
0.6997127532958984,
-0.3666318655014038,
0.7834911346435547,
-0.38657146692276,
-0.6528048515319824,
-0.7431792616844177,
0.45536795258522034,
0.5756401419639587,
0.47254061698913574,
0.3598317801952362,
-0.4316751956939697,
-0.4168607294559479,
-0.9088664054870605,
-0.37465810775756836,
-0.3394579589366913,
-0.35822010040283203,
0.5867089033126831,
0.11286000162363052,
-0.2980475425720215,
1.001490592956543,
-0.6051309704780579,
-0.3514902591705322,
-0.02308747172355652,
0.12283969670534134,
-0.07325120270252228,
0.4246489703655243,
0.07562925666570663,
-0.5723831653594971,
-0.5774123668670654,
0.08236853778362274,
-0.671377420425415,
-0.30814695358276367,
0.16248942911624908,
-0.1852373331785202,
0.012216116301715374,
0.4930301010608673,
-0.2938508987426758,
0.12681904435157776,
0.3307339549064636,
-0.28181666135787964,
0.616159975528717,
-0.2805757522583008,
0.3002493977546692,
-0.9414448142051697,
0.019258705899119377,
-0.08101204037666321,
-0.492950439453125,
-0.47802841663360596,
-0.0072226631455123425,
0.10967632383108139,
-0.15778619050979614,
-0.1981370896100998,
0.6369459629058838,
-0.3307819962501526,
-0.2600398361682892,
-0.06722290068864822,
0.2867761552333832,
-0.03885848820209503,
0.6276381611824036,
0.12323746830224991,
0.80088210105896,
0.3300372362136841,
-0.5559099316596985,
0.27513250708580017,
0.19265703856945038,
-0.4107351005077362,
0.4997670650482178,
-0.7559595108032227,
0.43853485584259033,
0.3094865381717682,
-0.08171059936285019,
-0.9564946889877319,
-0.15969882905483246,
-0.11778918653726578,
-0.4898987412452698,
0.0872083231806755,
-0.07280920445919037,
-0.35619938373565674,
-0.2889474630355835,
-0.2005104273557663,
0.2938462495803833,
0.643591046333313,
-0.5703535676002502,
0.4036898612976074,
0.6283444762229919,
-0.35487785935401917,
-0.22953370213508606,
-0.06377127021551132,
0.16297772526741028,
-0.16746726632118225,
-0.5211498141288757,
0.14095228910446167,
-0.3928545415401459,
-0.35532495379447937,
-0.3522358536720276,
0.21203456819057465,
-0.1523600071668625,
0.22928489744663239,
0.28177812695503235,
0.4285489022731781,
-0.11315321922302246,
0.18003302812576294,
-0.18284457921981812,
0.07219672203063965,
0.08223278075456619,
-0.183651402592659,
0.5043176412582397,
-0.4662986099720001,
-0.601100742816925,
-0.6707146763801575,
-0.040174227207899094,
0.5944074392318726,
-0.18846997618675232,
0.3689245581626892,
0.4859037399291992,
-0.20876197516918182,
0.03527573123574257,
-0.8348254561424255,
-0.23169897496700287,
-0.49798783659935,
0.5501830577850342,
-0.15072448551654816,
-0.6996649503707886,
0.2182123363018036,
0.026546603068709373,
0.13965070247650146,
0.29135793447494507,
0.8303470611572266,
-0.25953999161720276,
1.2877222299575806,
0.42863762378692627,
-0.35267481207847595,
0.4624384343624115,
0.039013054221868515,
-0.15989969670772552,
-0.6673787236213684,
-0.10658147931098938,
-0.5548847317695618,
-0.2838208079338074,
-0.46547600626945496,
-0.5864661931991577,
0.42931729555130005,
-0.1186254695057869,
-0.04368576779961586,
0.26405563950538635,
-0.49151185154914856,
0.6103765368461609,
0.3833169639110565,
0.15139150619506836,
0.36260461807250977,
-0.12043548375368118,
0.06750857830047607,
0.0756763145327568,
-0.5627690553665161,
-0.8099319338798523,
1.132965326309204,
0.5151422023773193,
0.661699116230011,
0.16266509890556335,
0.71539705991745,
0.8743002414703369,
0.5776849985122681,
-0.8895931243896484,
0.6487452983856201,
-0.1347225457429886,
-0.32624581456184387,
-0.7189083099365234,
-0.3925029933452606,
-0.9840864539146423,
0.38780564069747925,
-0.11686167865991592,
-0.7881947159767151,
-0.00796043872833252,
0.2753552794456482,
-0.34089237451553345,
-0.14026986062526703,
-1.0374369621276855,
0.9301123023033142,
-0.3419422507286072,
-0.34649285674095154,
-0.3990151286125183,
-0.5389842391014099,
0.04340756684541702,
0.0072035291232168674,
0.18076752126216888,
0.06212462857365608,
0.15187235176563263,
1.2020269632339478,
-0.4181324541568756,
0.7230232357978821,
-0.16514819860458374,
-0.23515672981739044,
0.0913931354880333,
0.19295626878738403,
0.30989599227905273,
-0.020788731053471565,
-0.22779619693756104,
-0.05600395426154137,
0.13098107278347015,
-0.3629319965839386,
-0.8049389123916626,
0.7596380710601807,
-0.9252834916114807,
-0.663250207901001,
-0.12435389310121536,
-0.5945380926132202,
-0.6889667510986328,
0.1259690225124359,
-0.17736080288887024,
0.37331971526145935,
-0.5516997575759888,
0.11551865935325623,
0.6092501878738403,
-0.12577641010284424,
0.17995649576187134,
0.6823713183403015,
-0.3767670691013336,
-0.19961842894554138,
1.0664875507354736,
-0.2463291436433792,
0.3958706557750702,
0.4048827588558197,
0.3194248080253601,
-0.35816651582717896,
-0.23604853451251984,
-0.5953319072723389,
-0.02520020119845867,
-0.6522340774536133,
0.08802949637174606,
-0.41158249974250793,
-0.09163094311952591,
-0.3122727870941162,
-0.07224822044372559,
-0.2976568639278412,
-0.4573698043823242,
-0.2578461468219757,
0.12318065762519836,
0.02425275556743145,
0.7095067501068115,
0.18420816957950592,
0.1080842986702919,
-0.6468213200569153,
0.3627483546733856,
0.9343730807304382,
0.2460438460111618,
0.08660774677991867,
-0.8773614168167114,
-0.3115616738796234,
0.07390487194061279,
-0.21679970622062683,
-0.6953848600387573,
0.3005150556564331,
0.3600212335586548,
0.5747165083885193,
0.4089503884315491,
-0.1405472606420517,
0.6593800783157349,
-0.5902022123336792,
0.5483363270759583,
-0.05851166322827339,
-0.7871868014335632,
0.5656476616859436,
-0.17609724402427673,
0.27409595251083374,
0.7876747250556946,
0.20018893480300903,
-0.4442581832408905,
-0.3044656217098236,
-0.519507884979248,
-0.4769640564918518,
0.7242573499679565,
0.20198750495910645,
0.04931354150176048,
-0.017602594569325447,
0.12332920730113983,
-0.06809485703706741,
0.09621656686067581,
-0.41576075553894043,
-0.05486645922064781,
0.042675212025642395,
-0.17468994855880737,
-0.20428016781806946,
-0.3003785312175751,
-0.0653267502784729,
-0.2824822962284088,
0.6751644015312195,
-0.09503684937953949,
0.12865018844604492,
-0.02118118479847908,
-0.5943285226821899,
-0.035742148756980896,
0.35824596881866455,
0.3926145136356354,
0.6144033670425415,
-0.48478031158447266,
-0.07858908921480179,
0.43537092208862305,
-0.3992060124874115,
0.09570684283971786,
-0.014763440936803818,
0.09840087592601776,
-0.09506530314683914,
0.4157060980796814,
0.6782367825508118,
0.4840434491634369,
-0.8775771260261536,
0.5221284031867981,
-0.3388376832008362,
0.07796897739171982,
-0.229821115732193,
0.24538931250572205,
0.18570828437805176,
-0.00012652197619900107,
0.3225574493408203,
0.03848487511277199,
0.16301676630973816,
-0.5486783981323242,
0.22049692273139954,
0.44723960757255554,
-0.6045008301734924,
-0.12941968441009521,
0.3799397647380829,
0.571822464466095,
-0.9254724383354187,
0.48755037784576416,
-0.32061684131622314,
-0.4928109347820282,
0.4990652799606323,
0.1683880239725113,
0.8887070417404175,
-0.5313923358917236,
0.1363527625799179,
0.26689839363098145,
0.14843182265758514,
0.037470731884241104,
-0.013418412767350674,
-0.3983055055141449,
-0.7572802901268005,
-0.12422414869070053,
-0.8061888217926025,
-0.6165907979011536,
-0.154022216796875,
-1.0528751611709595,
0.1444547474384308,
-0.26471227407455444,
-0.10671193897724152,
-0.026184290647506714,
-0.011757676489651203,
-0.7520642876625061,
0.2632964849472046,
0.05332542955875397,
0.8382548093795776,
-0.7776715755462646,
0.8138329386711121,
0.6961076259613037,
-0.1778419017791748,
-0.6352375745773315,
0.15591157972812653,
-0.15093359351158142,
-0.9939720034599304,
0.8578980565071106,
-0.032891515642404556,
-0.2725171148777008,
0.2210182249546051,
-0.05532466992735863,
-0.539986789226532,
1.0152596235275269,
0.328495055437088,
-0.570332944393158,
-0.08174135535955429,
0.06959869712591171,
0.8006413578987122,
-0.25569117069244385,
0.6206448078155518,
0.6495934128761292,
0.3113647997379303,
-0.18696539103984833,
-1.3467212915420532,
-0.2784080505371094,
-0.4132699966430664,
-0.09614604711532593,
-0.0776667594909668,
-0.4958096444606781,
0.48045000433921814,
-0.16780318319797516,
0.05815045163035393,
0.14665934443473816,
0.5671409368515015,
0.18619267642498016,
0.0006658501806668937,
0.8374252319335938,
0.3914346694946289,
0.9423874616622925,
0.2373850792646408,
1.0520786046981812,
-0.2651652693748474,
0.35249608755111694,
1.1658010482788086,
-0.3741741180419922,
1.135109305381775,
0.2541463375091553,
-0.5250275731086731,
0.686391294002533,
0.47244706749916077,
0.2373267263174057,
0.24513663351535797,
0.1768219769001007,
-0.24596692621707916,
-0.5500964522361755,
-0.02635558694601059,
-0.1219039335846901,
0.6319458484649658,
0.1856597661972046,
-0.3313148319721222,
-0.10081380605697632,
-0.10487779974937439,
-0.29860273003578186,
0.32732588052749634,
-0.31462574005126953,
1.0734014511108398,
-0.10658448189496994,
-0.8971728086471558,
0.7305035591125488,
0.022793272510170937,
0.4505777359008789,
-0.4727973937988281,
-0.011906917206943035,
-0.04817328229546547,
0.19357813894748688,
-0.1300860345363617,
-0.5792039036750793,
-0.06619669497013092,
0.1307125985622406,
-0.17954804003238678,
-0.2303886115550995,
0.7068402171134949,
-0.3520664870738983,
-0.5549347996711731,
0.16324737668037415,
0.602115273475647,
0.3817778527736664,
-0.15275713801383972,
-0.8217868208885193,
-0.1158895269036293,
-0.07010877132415771,
-0.2597704231739044,
0.5988790988922119,
-0.10712478309869766,
-0.35087886452674866,
0.9419020414352417,
0.6724474430084229,
0.07439202070236206,
-0.07351064682006836,
0.4647499620914459,
0.6345425248146057,
-0.33774834871292114,
-0.5716410875320435,
-0.7877124547958374,
0.27120205760002136,
-0.2552800178527832,
-0.16546232998371124,
0.7827762365341187,
0.4683581590652466,
0.4482116997241974,
-0.10205719619989395,
0.674757182598114,
0.23274309933185577,
0.6592925190925598,
-0.3521033823490143,
0.9280669093132019,
-0.42125511169433594,
0.4044352173805237,
-0.2982322573661804,
-0.8528628349304199,
-0.09077667444944382,
0.7377018928527832,
-0.5571919083595276,
0.13050445914268494,
0.5711364150047302,
0.9751011729240417,
0.10233275592327118,
-0.0718299075961113,
0.4534792900085449,
-0.024291422218084335,
0.2548125684261322,
0.36244329810142517,
0.8066437840461731,
-0.21089254319667816,
0.5655046701431274,
-0.10176357626914978,
-0.4230957329273224,
-0.42973825335502625,
-0.6816844940185547,
-0.9866818189620972,
-0.560720682144165,
-0.31598666310310364,
-0.10769950598478317,
0.23019196093082428,
1.1355011463165283,
0.963786244392395,
-0.9498745799064636,
-0.5326113700866699,
0.1111660748720169,
0.17770856618881226,
-0.0855550616979599,
-0.2736710011959076,
0.5120568871498108,
-0.3872395157814026,
-0.8503875136375427,
0.6210105419158936,
0.24381281435489655,
-0.36546799540519714,
-0.5657235980033875,
-0.39001065492630005,
-0.1268414705991745,
-0.03235403448343277,
0.7290312647819519,
0.2630438804626465,
-0.6919665336608887,
-0.21586772799491882,
-0.024794433265924454,
-0.24605576694011688,
-0.062112778425216675,
0.6372390985488892,
-0.9478682279586792,
0.6524508595466614,
0.32017847895622253,
0.8093802332878113,
0.085711270570755,
0.3038349151611328,
0.61753910779953,
-0.7596526741981506,
-0.0559438094496727,
0.30221259593963623,
0.2326062023639679,
0.4611508548259735,
-0.23363348841667175,
0.32198238372802734,
-0.03821102902293205,
-0.8300362825393677,
-0.9067097306251526,
0.03872469440102577,
-0.9163656234741211,
-0.012626213021576405,
1.1788766384124756,
-0.04586242511868477,
0.006524326279759407,
-0.052252549678087234,
-0.44701728224754333,
0.05778411775827408,
-0.40482714772224426,
1.1648807525634766,
0.6343338489532471,
-0.1878213733434677,
-0.05973101407289505,
-0.3734418451786041,
0.5289846658706665,
0.8229784369468689,
-1.093026041984558,
-0.0343627966940403,
0.26830363273620605,
0.2545568645000458,
0.21816466748714447,
0.6552131175994873,
0.025435756891965866,
0.5434280037879944,
-0.44889143109321594,
0.14227698743343353,
0.06466227024793625,
-0.06999169290065765,
-0.37543681263923645,
0.12034710496664047,
0.6259112358093262,
-0.2977820038795471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13019v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13019v2
|
A Comprehensive Survey of Accelerated Generation Techniques in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-15T07:36:56 | 2024-05-24T07:40:27 |
Mahsa Khoshnoodi, Vinija Jain, Mingye Gao, Malavika Srikanth, Aman Chadha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the crucial importance of accelerating text generation in large
language models (LLMs) for efficiently producing content, the sequential nature
of this process often leads to high inference latency, posing challenges for
real-time applications. Various techniques have been proposed and developed to
address these challenges and improve efficiency. This paper presents a
comprehensive survey of accelerated generation techniques in autoregressive
language models, aiming to understand the state-of-the-art methods and their
applications. We categorize these techniques into several key areas:
speculative decoding, early exiting mechanisms, and non-autoregressive methods.
We discuss each category's underlying principles, advantages, limitations, and
recent advancements. Through this survey, we aim to offer insights into the
current landscape of techniques in LLMs and provide guidance for future
research directions in this critical area of natural language processing.
|
[
-0.3626250922679901,
-1.2222899198532104,
0.5387539267539978,
0.40921133756637573,
-0.11879733949899673,
0.41588905453681946,
-0.29127398133277893,
-0.3682969808578491,
-0.10942742973566055,
0.4315595328807831,
-0.6549286842346191,
-0.24200905859470367,
-0.5993117690086365,
0.22300931811332703,
-0.7756931781768799,
0.6159889101982117,
-0.3657509386539459,
-0.21830463409423828,
-0.09363356977701187,
0.29219651222229004,
-0.16095148026943207,
-0.4785688817501068,
-0.915004312992096,
-0.21459205448627472,
0.3191608786582947,
0.24104857444763184,
0.4673027992248535,
0.9270814061164856,
0.41032832860946655,
0.3022417426109314,
-0.006913456600159407,
0.2517830431461334,
-0.3937286138534546,
0.7455230355262756,
0.212021142244339,
-0.11537367105484009,
-0.3916584551334381,
-0.2409462183713913,
0.8769255876541138,
0.6280909776687622,
-0.32551419734954834,
0.19257476925849915,
-0.2138144075870514,
0.4695076644420624,
-0.8663742542266846,
-0.08547835797071457,
-0.5396648049354553,
0.032669100910425186,
-0.5254533886909485,
-0.4675407409667969,
-0.5614272952079773,
-0.5690796971321106,
-0.13521495461463928,
-0.1605980098247528,
0.5260560512542725,
0.2298005074262619,
0.34434396028518677,
0.1048244833946228,
-0.3850925862789154,
-0.48403200507164,
-1.0422570705413818,
0.9200050830841064,
-0.9178457856178284,
0.422092467546463,
-0.051276519894599915,
0.227181538939476,
-0.3938526511192322,
-0.9362220168113708,
-0.6059491634368896,
-0.17456676065921783,
0.21695151925086975,
-0.09635379165410995,
-0.06648340821266174,
0.09321827441453934,
0.33791384100914,
0.7755611538887024,
-0.6457793712615967,
0.595396101474762,
0.16649803519248962,
-0.13956186175346375,
0.715537428855896,
0.3328019082546234,
0.07935748249292374,
-0.1348545402288437,
-0.1460707187652588,
-0.28228408098220825,
-0.8436986207962036,
-0.23814325034618378,
0.5415985584259033,
0.020525889471173286,
0.05217066779732704,
0.5720525979995728,
-0.4472925364971161,
0.9082733988761902,
-0.04713800176978111,
0.0023500968236476183,
0.06904703378677368,
-0.5427228212356567,
-0.012913450598716736,
-0.02445124089717865,
0.8830543756484985,
0.03366447240114212,
0.06470728665590286,
-0.1181907132267952,
-0.3912133276462555,
0.04061185196042061,
-0.2512021064758301,
-0.8627476096153259,
-0.020884718745946884,
0.2602787911891937,
-0.39806702733039856,
-0.37683454155921936,
-0.36893969774246216,
-0.8507342338562012,
-0.014881148003041744,
0.1880572885274887,
-0.18232934176921844,
-0.12891347706317902,
-0.39482811093330383,
0.1936430037021637,
-0.010164902545511723,
0.2955039143562317,
0.1313912272453308,
-1.0498384237289429,
0.17430151998996735,
0.5270447134971619,
0.5972933173179626,
-0.285741925239563,
0.009826923720538616,
-0.7503384351730347,
0.026207031682133675,
-0.5279792547225952,
0.859331488609314,
-0.5322324633598328,
-0.38874322175979614,
0.35615020990371704,
-0.30624812841415405,
0.1692003458738327,
-0.23041114211082458,
0.6555454134941101,
-0.9001747965812683,
0.1791505217552185,
0.1890481412410736,
-0.6050097942352295,
0.0223056860268116,
-0.028632234781980515,
-0.5628998279571533,
1.129725694656372,
-0.14492784440517426,
-0.5794008374214172,
0.23019710183143616,
-0.42584654688835144,
-0.7933591604232788,
-0.07074186950922012,
0.06027276813983917,
-0.35536450147628784,
0.5317790508270264,
0.40374770760536194,
0.6890478730201721,
-0.6989324688911438,
0.49325546622276306,
0.06317444890737534,
0.005757185164839029,
0.13455981016159058,
-0.7844853401184082,
0.21098656952381134,
0.4969934821128845,
-0.3077297508716583,
-0.184613436460495,
-0.9534081220626831,
0.14031869173049927,
0.38119274377822876,
-0.2654086649417877,
-0.09727208316326141,
0.3460730314254761,
-0.12739995121955872,
0.20791323482990265,
0.37507954239845276,
-0.37770259380340576,
0.24745959043502808,
-0.4971018135547638,
0.39424702525138855,
0.5532265305519104,
0.3556015193462372,
0.21607252955436707,
0.09455469995737076,
0.71037358045578,
-0.11380377411842346,
-0.07022058963775635,
-0.9221672415733337,
-0.3469447195529938,
-0.7927263379096985,
0.14067378640174866,
0.15032126009464264,
0.45169198513031006,
-0.9644333720207214,
0.41591355204582214,
-0.05783236771821976,
-0.5734426975250244,
-0.3737627863883972,
0.10474163293838501,
0.5676699876785278,
0.4567282199859619,
0.20839181542396545,
-0.10761091858148575,
-0.4857083559036255,
-0.7210572957992554,
-0.38259461522102356,
-0.22297824919223785,
0.3223283290863037,
0.09094325453042984,
0.035902246832847595,
-0.10308137536048889,
0.6126450300216675,
-0.6129941344261169,
0.6772648692131042,
-0.275519460439682,
0.7712729573249817,
0.047629646956920624,
0.4712182581424713,
0.30721285939216614,
-0.603270411491394,
-0.34939730167388916,
-0.2747136652469635,
-0.5869346857070923,
-0.36863023042678833,
-0.18922054767608643,
0.08275902271270752,
0.5236571431159973,
0.6754863262176514,
-0.5145774483680725,
0.1800120770931244,
0.6488398313522339,
-0.09975643455982208,
0.3358623683452606,
-0.20121468603610992,
0.2611401677131653,
-0.8121098279953003,
-0.13313035666942596,
0.03455447778105736,
-0.3120531439781189,
-0.79509037733078,
0.16064947843551636,
-0.019763480871915817,
0.17176476120948792,
-0.42883580923080444,
0.6716898083686829,
-0.9593231678009033,
-0.15566006302833557,
-0.6478049755096436,
0.18719764053821564,
-0.04846853390336037,
0.01339550968259573,
0.26653534173965454,
0.8216535449028015,
0.71209716796875,
-0.8217473030090332,
0.4756394326686859,
0.05884457752108574,
-0.3463927209377289,
-0.2602234184741974,
-0.40129920840263367,
0.16904741525650024,
-0.4068748652935028,
0.34445953369140625,
-1.0846301317214966,
-0.14262056350708008,
0.005649018567055464,
-0.4286831319332123,
0.46079882979393005,
0.18329373002052307,
-0.9681848287582397,
-0.5612756013870239,
-0.03746805712580681,
0.5469774603843689,
0.8166503310203552,
-0.4680975377559662,
0.16214534640312195,
0.10943684726953506,
-0.4894323945045471,
-0.6492390036582947,
-0.5601446032524109,
0.25651344656944275,
-0.22767947614192963,
-0.579160213470459,
0.13437704741954803,
-0.0038342627231031656,
-0.3916272819042206,
-0.24433760344982147,
0.3683837354183197,
0.29864683747291565,
0.13116686046123505,
-0.2952731251716614,
0.17375300824642181,
-0.37011581659317017,
0.0064098709262907505,
0.21442627906799316,
-0.07220183312892914,
-0.011279789730906487,
-0.27526527643203735,
0.8016696572303772,
0.22171081602573395,
-0.16175493597984314,
-0.13191187381744385,
0.4853648245334625,
0.2254372239112854,
-0.27973470091819763,
0.5238635540008545,
0.6026184558868408,
-0.12717066705226898,
-0.23358681797981262,
-0.8960535526275635,
-0.2296142578125,
-0.48082563281059265,
0.3972437083721161,
0.022237181663513184,
-0.7955227494239807,
0.4454442262649536,
-0.3074580132961273,
0.4398155212402344,
0.5815417170524597,
0.9529927968978882,
0.3886459171772003,
1.235617995262146,
0.6453154683113098,
0.1337212771177292,
0.48660391569137573,
-0.03170624002814293,
0.16397830843925476,
-0.6151649951934814,
-0.07325271517038345,
-0.7041900157928467,
0.03904883563518524,
-0.7872015237808228,
-0.5584930777549744,
-0.06671573966741562,
0.10590081661939621,
0.10221365839242935,
0.13302244246006012,
-0.24485105276107788,
0.05222909152507782,
0.23300136625766754,
-0.7225620746612549,
0.6012858748435974,
0.2043980360031128,
-0.06720898300409317,
0.03928230330348015,
-0.8566370010375977,
-0.3016677796840668,
0.8944517970085144,
0.3648172616958618,
0.8835181593894958,
-0.06132402643561363,
0.5809814929962158,
0.28878477215766907,
0.42999136447906494,
-0.5437301397323608,
0.6562528014183044,
-0.2176205813884735,
-0.585501492023468,
-0.16495318710803986,
-0.5118734836578369,
-0.7899008989334106,
-0.0015566475922241807,
-0.21438200771808624,
-0.41117769479751587,
0.05066957324743271,
0.34311044216156006,
-0.21770386397838593,
0.25680670142173767,
-0.4401426613330841,
0.3810498118400574,
-0.35178816318511963,
-0.6135429739952087,
-0.160448357462883,
-0.5540216565132141,
0.6514804363250732,
-0.27308258414268494,
0.12041635066270828,
0.017874687910079956,
-0.22215822339057922,
0.5794827342033386,
-0.27475467324256897,
0.3406175374984741,
-0.2825765907764435,
-0.5954314470291138,
0.49401700496673584,
-0.06759481877088547,
1.0839171409606934,
-0.1391855627298355,
-0.11022182554006577,
-0.23065073788166046,
-0.7221282124519348,
-0.10179567337036133,
-0.4028896689414978,
0.8402281403541565,
-0.24704943597316742,
-0.4324054419994354,
-0.28540822863578796,
-0.5016241073608398,
-0.5272772908210754,
0.24239684641361237,
0.46180713176727295,
0.5679365992546082,
-0.17734242975711823,
-0.0971154272556305,
0.7798702120780945,
-0.42949026823043823,
0.9648301005363464,
0.5339849591255188,
-0.38401827216148376,
-0.30459064245224,
0.8610251545906067,
-0.0605044886469841,
0.4265868365764618,
0.3841956555843353,
-0.06618650257587433,
-0.6118118762969971,
-1.0785746574401855,
-0.38375356793403625,
0.30862244963645935,
-0.48779916763305664,
-0.14353330433368683,
-0.9865338802337646,
-0.07568015158176422,
-0.7140387892723083,
-0.18766465783119202,
-0.32909098267555237,
-0.6455042958259583,
-0.18692459166049957,
-0.23758086562156677,
0.40993940830230713,
0.6955353021621704,
0.09537036716938019,
0.6376956105232239,
-0.9120786190032959,
0.4492262303829193,
0.0036056512035429478,
0.029608918353915215,
0.26742035150527954,
-0.1913185715675354,
-0.30414319038391113,
-0.23496076464653015,
-0.2005196064710617,
-0.5412059426307678,
0.6276867389678955,
0.1472790539264679,
0.6207122206687927,
0.33578598499298096,
-0.01974305883049965,
0.6333268284797668,
-0.6656250357627869,
0.8929887413978577,
0.13805998861789703,
-0.4909563958644867,
0.42447641491889954,
-0.4231998026371002,
0.2179245501756668,
0.2609265148639679,
0.42944803833961487,
-0.4692862629890442,
-0.5359894633293152,
-0.6296724677085876,
-1.2491810321807861,
0.41312655806541443,
0.157891184091568,
0.18812225759029388,
-0.27121853828430176,
0.4412922263145447,
0.15330064296722412,
0.4155038595199585,
-0.41472548246383667,
-0.2973189949989319,
0.07017508894205093,
-0.04790819063782692,
-0.3219073414802551,
-0.31675615906715393,
0.32125115394592285,
0.23670583963394165,
0.8350998759269714,
-0.08679645508527756,
0.1531699150800705,
0.1962047666311264,
-0.12035613507032394,
-0.3820541501045227,
0.2694622278213501,
0.5932158827781677,
0.36229875683784485,
-0.03351657837629318,
-0.23641788959503174,
-0.13441987335681915,
-0.37745654582977295,
0.32506585121154785,
0.31825363636016846,
-0.28441140055656433,
0.007167245261371136,
0.31396356225013733,
0.969435453414917,
-0.0703696683049202,
-0.778997004032135,
0.2814014256000519,
-0.2289944887161255,
-0.05105946958065033,
-0.43212488293647766,
0.054262325167655945,
-0.10950512439012527,
0.025057226419448853,
0.6534242033958435,
-0.274054616689682,
0.21784242987632751,
-0.447457492351532,
0.10230628401041031,
0.4250348210334778,
0.05008573830127716,
-0.2383795529603958,
0.8523851633071899,
0.24114872515201569,
-0.1095556691288948,
0.7524726390838623,
-0.1401534527540207,
0.05910956487059593,
0.4236725866794586,
0.7133268117904663,
1.253978967666626,
-0.20629237592220306,
-0.038602087646722794,
0.3175496757030487,
0.1983518749475479,
-0.23575317859649658,
0.29664692282676697,
-0.2638797461986542,
-0.6106505990028381,
-1.0611017942428589,
-0.9073309302330017,
-0.2501217722892761,
0.056313686072826385,
-0.42351916432380676,
-0.0368216335773468,
-0.21334092319011688,
-0.2700435221195221,
-0.14830181002616882,
0.0011218760628253222,
-0.33046120405197144,
0.1733090579509735,
0.3492954671382904,
1.1647342443466187,
-0.664107084274292,
0.49241629242897034,
0.5291865468025208,
0.23722688853740692,
-0.46020495891571045,
0.2581331133842468,
-0.10503106564283371,
-0.7300010919570923,
0.7510164380073547,
-0.23793581128120422,
-0.30111417174339294,
0.47901254892349243,
-0.5526217818260193,
-0.8037121295928955,
0.7937819957733154,
0.015476440079510212,
-0.6131075620651245,
-0.3876165747642517,
0.03865353763103485,
0.5264959335327148,
-0.4103158116340637,
0.27362996339797974,
0.6092342138290405,
0.5815429091453552,
0.23195889592170715,
-0.35822081565856934,
-0.033921632915735245,
-0.1350238174200058,
0.23782801628112793,
0.39241576194763184,
-0.7129514217376709,
0.7272821664810181,
-0.06904897093772888,
-0.36855947971343994,
0.5116288661956787,
0.9790220856666565,
0.42970511317253113,
0.13414457440376282,
0.3061234951019287,
0.3779813349246979,
0.29038819670677185,
-0.1124899610877037,
1.166104793548584,
-0.5621654987335205,
0.09609154611825943,
0.6594072580337524,
-0.3885248601436615,
0.6243661642074585,
0.24872134625911713,
0.13780370354652405,
0.3857676684856415,
0.6122878193855286,
0.07254520058631897,
0.29468774795532227,
0.20358967781066895,
-0.39182886481285095,
-0.2842811346054077,
-0.16419829428195953,
-0.39420855045318604,
0.186308354139328,
0.5585487484931946,
-0.4510073959827423,
-0.3899283707141876,
0.019743289798498154,
0.10214754939079285,
-0.031083479523658752,
-0.28697970509529114,
0.7809484004974365,
-0.0481969378888607,
-1.1034430265426636,
0.5951071977615356,
0.27343177795410156,
0.7840738296508789,
-0.6854040026664734,
-0.06555451452732086,
-0.19559337198734283,
-0.1254882514476776,
-0.05030866339802742,
-0.6269566416740417,
-0.01230828557163477,
0.2850041389465332,
-0.0975821241736412,
-0.6144060492515564,
0.8463283181190491,
-0.2688823640346527,
-0.5398825407028198,
0.07458017766475677,
0.6848646402359009,
0.016438482329249382,
0.37511759996414185,
-0.40021875500679016,
0.14943461120128632,
-0.15615242719650269,
-0.6922444105148315,
-0.027316873893141747,
0.44091081619262695,
-0.05837706848978996,
0.720586359500885,
0.6797875165939331,
0.4351723790168762,
0.4883372187614441,
0.0064214481972157955,
0.736045241355896,
-0.8751258850097656,
-0.23522207140922546,
-0.845963716506958,
0.42972472310066223,
0.17980097234249115,
-0.11861896514892578,
1.091368317604065,
0.5362442135810852,
0.45613816380500793,
0.09773072600364685,
0.9162115454673767,
-0.00010200510587310418,
0.6283177137374878,
-0.8897460699081421,
0.3010478615760803,
-0.29613980650901794,
0.18846437335014343,
-0.2926081717014313,
-0.9785702228546143,
-0.17017923295497894,
0.08542584627866745,
-0.1348283290863037,
0.15298129618167877,
0.491644024848938,
0.4844498634338379,
0.3794413208961487,
-0.0361642949283123,
0.10837457329034805,
0.505766749382019,
0.47289276123046875,
0.26343241333961487,
1.076833963394165,
-0.3720402121543884,
0.3296971321105957,
-0.06195622682571411,
-0.1338559240102768,
-0.16696922481060028,
-1.164594054222107,
-0.5473566055297852,
-0.3671410381793976,
-0.3521002233028412,
-0.11388702690601349,
0.12680083513259888,
0.5217984318733215,
0.5996183156967163,
-0.3692317605018616,
-0.17203927040100098,
-0.46540847420692444,
-0.27442899346351624,
-0.03757067769765854,
-0.21375100314617157,
0.14520379900932312,
-0.5282751321792603,
-0.9950402975082397,
0.6909038424491882,
0.1637512892484665,
0.21145601570606232,
-0.6616283059120178,
0.06299722194671631,
-0.27454328536987305,
0.23394809663295746,
0.6351622343063354,
0.6106098890304565,
-0.25142812728881836,
0.30883151292800903,
0.14177082479000092,
0.08363532274961472,
-0.10173165798187256,
1.1871297359466553,
-1.004611611366272,
0.25614768266677856,
0.9153599143028259,
0.5398025512695312,
0.5328361988067627,
0.2939611077308655,
0.762500524520874,
-0.7783141732215881,
0.26135626435279846,
0.34617629647254944,
0.18172071874141693,
0.46881869435310364,
-0.3586297631263733,
0.18644052743911743,
0.13878893852233887,
-0.6295655369758606,
-1.001588225364685,
0.4539470374584198,
-0.5137892961502075,
-0.0484391413629055,
1.0789616107940674,
0.18182525038719177,
-0.18350112438201904,
-0.033185310661792755,
0.3103727698326111,
0.3202727437019348,
-0.4047321677207947,
0.42739757895469666,
0.6316449046134949,
-0.33917900919914246,
-0.2642291188240051,
-0.6466745734214783,
0.4657954275608063,
0.29380109906196594,
-0.8111617565155029,
0.4344066381454468,
0.7761114239692688,
-0.2672240138053894,
0.04717302694916725,
0.6908754110336304,
-0.303911417722702,
0.005663597956299782,
-0.0478653609752655,
0.00955707486718893,
0.04910421743988991,
-0.2991151809692383,
-0.4347250461578369,
0.15554003417491913,
0.29002511501312256,
0.33138981461524963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09153v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09153v1
|
Adapting Abstract Meaning Representation Parsing to the Clinical Narrative -- the SPRING THYME parser
| 2024-05-15T07:32:43 | 2024-05-15T07:32:43 |
Jon Z. Cai, Kristin Wright-Bettner, Martha Palmer, Guergana K. Savova, James H. Martin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper is dedicated to the design and evaluation of the first AMR parser
tailored for clinical notes. Our objective was to facilitate the precise
transformation of the clinical notes into structured AMR expressions, thereby
enhancing the interpretability and usability of clinical text data at scale.
Leveraging the colon cancer dataset from the Temporal Histories of Your Medical
Events (THYME) corpus, we adapted a state-of-the-art AMR parser utilizing
continuous training. Our approach incorporates data augmentation techniques to
enhance the accuracy of AMR structure predictions. Notably, through this
learning strategy, our parser achieved an impressive F1 score of 88% on the
THYME corpus's colon cancer dataset. Moreover, our research delved into the
efficacy of data required for domain adaptation within the realm of clinical
notes, presenting domain adaptation data requirements for AMR parsing. This
exploration not only underscores the parser's robust performance but also
highlights its potential in facilitating a deeper understanding of clinical
narratives through structured semantic representations.
|
[
0.20757868885993958,
-0.4446415305137634,
1.0318268537521362,
0.035176727920770645,
-0.3238498866558075,
0.09752364456653595,
-0.23450590670108795,
-0.5406678318977356,
0.4359363913536072,
0.043184030801057816,
-0.39953529834747314,
-0.7124317288398743,
-0.7836456894874573,
0.21785448491573334,
-0.0882529690861702,
1.079092025756836,
-0.15938708186149597,
0.3309936225414276,
-0.06743252277374268,
-0.35237589478492737,
-0.4041193723678589,
-0.21408617496490479,
-0.8944722414016724,
-0.18811848759651184,
0.5961198806762695,
0.1389220952987671,
0.4627113938331604,
1.0616471767425537,
0.6288598775863647,
0.23751869797706604,
0.1408565193414688,
0.03634358569979668,
-0.22514303028583527,
0.30103304982185364,
-0.38676688075065613,
-0.4057013690471649,
-0.7573719620704651,
-0.1146150529384613,
0.746577799320221,
0.9542549848556519,
0.008179320022463799,
-0.11364568769931793,
-0.11075019836425781,
0.4775694012641907,
-0.44388633966445923,
0.29359832406044006,
-0.41501638293266296,
0.1680184304714203,
-0.23113061487674713,
-0.593038022518158,
-0.5044682621955872,
-0.22693225741386414,
-0.011735804378986359,
-0.9388683438301086,
0.19614659249782562,
-0.0068425885401666164,
0.7311655879020691,
-0.08195657283067703,
-0.5942738652229309,
-0.4050721228122711,
-0.6040716767311096,
0.706268310546875,
-0.5262325406074524,
0.21716637909412384,
-0.06673689931631088,
0.6431742906570435,
-0.1466645896434784,
-1.1480860710144043,
-0.30925479531288147,
-0.10890568047761917,
-0.23883651196956635,
0.34721559286117554,
-0.1278488039970398,
0.12061043828725815,
0.03329867869615555,
0.7144535183906555,
-0.6019874811172485,
-0.3554847538471222,
-0.43603917956352234,
-0.15117469429969788,
0.469767689704895,
0.6039946675300598,
0.38532623648643494,
-0.04449671134352684,
-0.20221705734729767,
-0.2589871287345886,
-0.27611643075942993,
0.04078437387943268,
-0.42196065187454224,
0.45359188318252563,
-0.3975825011730194,
0.3409660756587982,
-0.03823669254779816,
0.5537794232368469,
-0.10539022088050842,
-0.19992956519126892,
0.32751333713531494,
-0.3846733570098877,
-0.24269789457321167,
0.2940118610858917,
0.6872972249984741,
0.514261782169342,
0.1801747828722,
-0.1312377005815506,
0.11053313314914703,
0.2514566481113434,
0.5829495191574097,
-0.6536602973937988,
-0.21617171168327332,
0.2028713971376419,
-0.7276270389556885,
-0.21790437400341034,
0.07776429504156113,
-0.730049192905426,
-0.5426043272018433,
-0.09647562354803085,
-0.027094978839159012,
-0.6585125923156738,
0.09832045435905457,
0.48980265855789185,
-0.2801176905632019,
0.1280391365289688,
0.8357310891151428,
-0.7976536750793457,
0.7150652408599854,
0.7087511420249939,
1.0083125829696655,
0.032319504767656326,
0.016165491193532944,
-0.5872219204902649,
0.5686991810798645,
-0.05908900871872902,
0.9597403407096863,
-0.6630910038948059,
-0.4651763141155243,
-0.06716618686914444,
0.31486690044403076,
-0.5854225158691406,
-0.3688376545906067,
0.9914907813072205,
-0.15544769167900085,
0.19935648143291473,
-0.31904342770576477,
-0.5788351893424988,
-0.1339981108903885,
0.29081544280052185,
-0.5404614210128784,
0.1181928887963295,
0.7983083724975586,
-0.5371555685997009,
0.3548709750175476,
-1.0321543216705322,
-0.6602967381477356,
0.16814903914928436,
-0.4571239650249481,
-0.09809482842683792,
0.2973710000514984,
0.14690697193145752,
0.10485653579235077,
-0.2763851583003998,
-0.2489670068025589,
-0.05308889225125313,
0.04665149003267288,
0.29709944128990173,
0.10133514553308487,
0.486289918422699,
0.37928658723831177,
0.08572671562433243,
-0.03169311583042145,
-0.8214563727378845,
-0.0017886025598272681,
0.1514090746641159,
-0.2340819239616394,
-0.2257285863161087,
0.00362789467908442,
0.17963658273220062,
0.16170930862426758,
-0.11590466648340225,
-0.765148937702179,
0.22569157183170319,
-0.5641558170318604,
0.4340018630027771,
0.4202162027359009,
0.4160920977592468,
0.3094042241573334,
-0.7027300596237183,
0.791610062122345,
0.30046236515045166,
-0.15567795932292938,
-0.6595606207847595,
-0.544295608997345,
-0.3902153968811035,
-0.17950484156608582,
0.2149984985589981,
0.49008870124816895,
0.0434463694691658,
0.10067956894636154,
-0.5930147767066956,
-0.14894039928913116,
-0.665789783000946,
-0.23134611546993256,
0.47734490036964417,
1.0547033548355103,
0.6490995287895203,
-0.5273582339286804,
-0.7178541421890259,
-0.7593902945518494,
-0.41685935854911804,
-0.5151243209838867,
-0.22040818631649017,
0.2043793499469757,
0.1837436705827713,
-0.10611049085855484,
0.6195824146270752,
-0.6798056960105896,
-0.4654324948787689,
-0.18168963491916656,
0.033617082983255386,
0.22759036719799042,
0.5167858600616455,
0.3769386112689972,
-0.43567895889282227,
-0.4720567762851715,
0.4580024778842926,
-0.7453561425209045,
-0.3369666337966919,
-0.4151667058467865,
0.09357118606567383,
-0.29156503081321716,
0.46233612298965454,
-0.45045191049575806,
0.6409897208213806,
0.16220155358314514,
-0.7748755812644958,
0.3915209472179413,
-0.14811348915100098,
0.6191667318344116,
-1.2788687944412231,
0.08092360198497772,
0.09231635928153992,
-0.6071248054504395,
-0.5129663944244385,
-0.15028828382492065,
0.2796001732349396,
0.1517837941646576,
-0.15064576268196106,
0.5488193035125732,
-0.2547297179698944,
0.26078808307647705,
-0.2788640856742859,
-0.16767625510692596,
0.57326740026474,
0.01689055562019348,
0.05618890002369881,
0.5973433256149292,
0.03131500259041786,
-0.3780703544616699,
0.07078289240598679,
0.5694027543067932,
-0.07202284783124924,
0.6494261622428894,
-0.5426303148269653,
-0.1500949263572693,
-0.02267887070775032,
0.1653510481119156,
-0.900127112865448,
-0.29751056432724,
0.28394854068756104,
-0.6415037512779236,
0.2973094582557678,
-0.31796684861183167,
-0.22667457163333893,
0.011448928155004978,
-0.25657474994659424,
0.4133824110031128,
0.3490833640098572,
-0.06681513786315918,
0.47616761922836304,
0.24326875805854797,
-0.317766398191452,
0.06191083788871765,
-0.9664025902748108,
0.3181563913822174,
-0.3031006157398224,
-0.7755654454231262,
0.6305342316627502,
0.10546216368675232,
-0.4233829975128174,
-0.02967206761240959,
-0.08070182055234909,
-0.006939217913895845,
-0.08520369976758957,
0.04672884941101074,
-0.16851459443569183,
-0.8567503690719604,
-0.08259614557027817,
0.22082294523715973,
-0.40602338314056396,
0.1916428953409195,
-0.02195887453854084,
0.11620493978261948,
0.015498755499720573,
-0.3310273587703705,
-0.4341886639595032,
0.5139279365539551,
0.75853431224823,
0.1303749978542328,
0.6809751987457275,
0.14394553005695343,
-0.5992203950881958,
0.0634373351931572,
-0.11587107181549072,
-0.01569073647260666,
-0.3737282156944275,
0.21498332917690277,
-0.31141600012779236,
-0.7612457275390625,
0.5841366052627563,
-0.15689942240715027,
-0.08338912576436996,
0.4531526565551758,
0.5191073417663574,
-0.13646143674850464,
0.885380744934082,
0.21124409139156342,
0.3075619637966156,
0.1748618334531784,
0.2771145701408386,
0.04960634931921959,
-1.0653941631317139,
-0.14462578296661377,
-0.32893431186676025,
-0.3732379078865051,
-0.28091731667518616,
-0.49998947978019714,
0.7918244004249573,
-0.44069749116897583,
-0.1032123789191246,
0.0833551213145256,
-0.35040000081062317,
0.1345054656267166,
0.019251415506005287,
0.3497503101825714,
0.40582695603370667,
-0.085140660405159,
0.035650406032800674,
-0.3386160433292389,
-0.13580648601055145,
-0.6807560920715332,
0.9333570003509521,
0.5994229912757874,
0.5886927247047424,
0.2965524196624756,
0.15380433201789856,
0.41588252782821655,
0.0028883437626063824,
-0.8570635318756104,
0.3123241662979126,
-0.23151078820228577,
-0.17255280911922455,
-0.027881525456905365,
-0.1352834850549698,
-1.0597296953201294,
0.2481667548418045,
-0.11760017275810242,
-0.7681453824043274,
0.20211319625377655,
-0.014340657740831375,
-0.5811609029769897,
-0.018147442489862442,
-0.7554765343666077,
1.004441738128662,
0.032937079668045044,
-0.19407382607460022,
-0.06193019077181816,
-0.6891357898712158,
0.19874057173728943,
0.003993838559836149,
0.30343106389045715,
-0.010402069427073002,
-0.33445456624031067,
0.5504902005195618,
-0.6544500589370728,
0.6294952034950256,
-0.12593679130077362,
0.3065709173679352,
-0.06461968272924423,
0.23179945349693298,
0.211571604013443,
0.37684953212738037,
-0.15753135085105896,
-0.3951296806335449,
0.24515871703624725,
-0.5864125490188599,
-0.7610021829605103,
0.5911378860473633,
-0.5201537609100342,
-0.4545908570289612,
-0.596278965473175,
-0.41684532165527344,
-0.4948822259902954,
0.11189854890108109,
-0.16410599648952484,
0.49637794494628906,
-0.591557502746582,
0.020141851156949997,
0.38432759046554565,
-0.02812291868031025,
0.20839834213256836,
0.4271060824394226,
0.11998768895864487,
-0.7160235643386841,
0.1586896777153015,
-0.4456266462802887,
0.11427807062864304,
0.679175853729248,
0.42865118384361267,
-0.12298630177974701,
-0.9030150175094604,
-0.4671131670475006,
0.30835649371147156,
-0.8512862920761108,
-0.22271212935447693,
-0.9738672971725464,
-0.19889043271541595,
-0.7871576547622681,
-0.46626564860343933,
-0.1642116904258728,
-0.8994807004928589,
-0.37396156787872314,
-0.16975153982639313,
0.614883542060852,
0.5515797138214111,
0.056993525475263596,
0.7153056263923645,
-1.1148359775543213,
0.14742879569530487,
-0.27358365058898926,
0.14978215098381042,
-0.3974299132823944,
-0.7667061686515808,
-0.5186411142349243,
-0.1674482524394989,
-0.47565189003944397,
-0.8924501538276672,
0.48383957147598267,
0.591709315776825,
0.2890479564666748,
0.48967474699020386,
-0.18064893782138824,
0.9165974259376526,
-0.6747205257415771,
0.6957038640975952,
0.28841686248779297,
-0.6356096267700195,
0.7977940440177917,
-0.649144172668457,
0.6211698651313782,
0.8791052103042603,
0.1859741508960724,
-0.8572861552238464,
-0.2814105153083801,
-0.660125732421875,
-0.5235554575920105,
0.7110326886177063,
0.13606777787208557,
-0.0000011747629287128802,
-0.010867724195122719,
0.6376816630363464,
0.3274134695529938,
-0.052662648260593414,
-0.4873003661632538,
-0.1416337937116623,
-0.28347936272621155,
-0.6426213979721069,
-0.06911396980285645,
-0.25876379013061523,
-0.20844270288944244,
-0.4396825134754181,
0.2793523669242859,
-0.16538497805595398,
0.2907440960407257,
0.4840874671936035,
-0.20688042044639587,
-0.3230871260166168,
0.3806126117706299,
0.5823984146118164,
0.8412761688232422,
-0.40683984756469727,
0.23497043550014496,
-0.09050459414720535,
-0.9366743564605713,
-0.05945015326142311,
0.18951869010925293,
0.20929665863513947,
0.14445841312408447,
0.8393980264663696,
0.6091902256011963,
0.3003324866294861,
-0.6825037002563477,
0.7204891443252563,
-0.3297572433948517,
0.03405260667204857,
-0.39367640018463135,
0.13183149695396423,
-0.05404290556907654,
-0.005092019215226173,
0.3004215657711029,
-0.01362546905875206,
0.4608601927757263,
-0.5723105669021606,
0.5126357078552246,
-0.03855152800679207,
-0.5856863260269165,
-0.8063005208969116,
0.6981948614120483,
-0.11546862125396729,
0.046660300344228745,
0.22423085570335388,
0.2579536437988281,
-0.17597071826457977,
0.21761846542358398,
0.8389571905136108,
0.9266027808189392,
-0.43545883893966675,
0.10873677581548691,
0.4846944510936737,
0.12942790985107422,
0.44233885407447815,
0.26484546065330505,
0.09492688626050949,
-0.5260525345802307,
-0.2699348032474518,
-0.7277694940567017,
-0.2718558609485626,
0.11494256556034088,
-0.6568390727043152,
0.4669637680053711,
-0.8089152574539185,
0.03804341331124306,
0.3488215208053589,
-0.07754199206829071,
-0.2448909729719162,
0.6040565371513367,
0.20899783074855804,
1.1014289855957031,
-0.9476919770240784,
0.8036324381828308,
1.2965667247772217,
-0.40998414158821106,
-0.27995407581329346,
-0.0825539156794548,
0.2939032018184662,
-0.8502922654151917,
0.1506582647562027,
-0.023671001195907593,
0.30560746788978577,
-0.19608069956302643,
0.03767983987927437,
-0.49650436639785767,
1.124221920967102,
0.3097986578941345,
-0.3132402002811432,
-0.17232142388820648,
0.6457703709602356,
0.7578524947166443,
-1.038316249847412,
0.44065403938293457,
0.6070908904075623,
0.26928403973579407,
0.35201677680015564,
-0.7422537803649902,
0.47511550784111023,
-0.3517131805419922,
-0.13502830266952515,
0.1416330337524414,
-0.3590445816516876,
0.6727124452590942,
0.03309231996536255,
-0.16884657740592957,
0.05473431572318077,
0.5558904409408569,
0.3472832143306732,
0.7990154027938843,
0.3294222354888916,
0.5026726722717285,
0.6812918782234192,
0.04455958306789398,
1.1073695421218872,
-0.17131327092647552,
-0.19634605944156647,
1.061432123184204,
-0.12333059310913086,
0.4407529830932617,
0.5485593676567078,
-0.22460749745368958,
0.8374846577644348,
0.5443597435951233,
0.3009161055088043,
0.6393400430679321,
0.06365074962377548,
-0.6672253608703613,
-0.06374753266572952,
-0.03605872392654419,
-0.37858349084854126,
0.3012782633304596,
0.7722848057746887,
-0.8637723922729492,
-0.5050545334815979,
-0.0973815843462944,
0.34411177039146423,
0.4440534710884094,
-0.173524871468544,
0.8803128004074097,
0.3685997426509857,
-0.29630985856056213,
0.43890291452407837,
0.07100626081228256,
-0.23903924226760864,
-0.7275576591491699,
-0.22856424748897552,
-0.09523063898086548,
0.30287501215934753,
-0.2839539349079132,
-0.6643341183662415,
0.5919484496116638,
-0.07870417833328247,
-0.36275413632392883,
-0.3433627486228943,
0.6670239567756653,
-0.036255791783332825,
-0.580272376537323,
0.13375812768936157,
0.5500654578208923,
0.05258343368768692,
0.19791710376739502,
-0.7525129318237305,
0.3469139337539673,
-0.12411526590585709,
-0.06574518978595734,
0.5376075506210327,
0.8710996508598328,
0.0002489544276613742,
0.1951952576637268,
0.33522430062294006,
0.3075407147407532,
-0.14319007098674774,
0.08277074992656708,
1.1107969284057617,
-1.1958123445510864,
-0.6861879229545593,
-0.8091515898704529,
0.7023243308067322,
-0.1101163774728775,
-0.38652804493904114,
0.5173583626747131,
0.7276641130447388,
0.5146287679672241,
-0.031216587871313095,
0.989403247833252,
-0.010031042620539665,
0.8550123572349548,
-0.6090571880340576,
0.6711464524269104,
-0.4433303475379944,
0.320696622133255,
-0.23009872436523438,
-0.43518686294555664,
-0.5136476159095764,
0.37285012006759644,
-0.24277691543102264,
-0.05570955574512482,
1.2900158166885376,
0.43731698393821716,
-0.4318123459815979,
0.3303585648536682,
0.20020906627178192,
0.357797235250473,
0.426479697227478,
0.8457958698272705,
0.586933970451355,
-0.6528935432434082,
0.18327157199382782,
-0.1001826599240303,
-0.4726199209690094,
-0.03247002139687538,
-0.9693727493286133,
-0.5209982991218567,
-0.6235876083374023,
-0.5699926614761353,
-0.6815787553787231,
0.21898022294044495,
0.9110268354415894,
0.4232982397079468,
-1.2128781080245972,
-0.10000158101320267,
-0.02108195796608925,
-0.3268935978412628,
-0.16323263943195343,
-0.18319807946681976,
0.33631905913352966,
-0.5420411825180054,
-0.5172076225280762,
0.7945762276649475,
0.45384305715560913,
0.08523077517747879,
0.47819310426712036,
-0.006763838231563568,
-0.1881985068321228,
-0.18396149575710297,
0.5376380681991577,
0.4961121082305908,
-0.31584611535072327,
-0.40378040075302124,
-0.30480796098709106,
0.0002596447884570807,
0.7247439622879028,
1.3186360597610474,
-0.7803872227668762,
0.5521483421325684,
0.1445753574371338,
0.7113983631134033,
0.4201855957508087,
0.16504758596420288,
0.8686683177947998,
-0.485038161277771,
-0.10801039636135101,
0.5683164000511169,
0.4952826201915741,
0.232854962348938,
-0.41777995228767395,
0.5100035071372986,
0.450345903635025,
-0.2602437138557434,
-0.7454898357391357,
0.05354529991745949,
-1.5413669347763062,
-0.07253241539001465,
1.0916147232055664,
-0.28852957487106323,
-0.5766596794128418,
-0.5074950456619263,
-0.1491941213607788,
0.22738660871982574,
-0.40708354115486145,
0.65365070104599,
0.44432246685028076,
-0.45547300577163696,
-0.2817053496837616,
-0.5856240391731262,
0.5833203196525574,
0.13825218379497528,
-0.621509850025177,
0.1880912333726883,
0.5854896306991577,
0.1922779679298401,
-0.02288254164159298,
0.8994261622428894,
-0.7274010181427002,
0.5291382670402527,
-0.18796561658382416,
-0.270576536655426,
0.07010690867900848,
0.16704660654067993,
-0.6079297065734863,
0.13121668994426727,
0.23936612904071808,
-0.1644050031900406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13018v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13018v1
|
Continued Pretraining for Domain Adaptation of Wav2vec2.0 in Automatic Speech Recognition for Elementary Math Classroom Settings
| 2024-05-15T06:59:33 | 2024-05-15T06:59:33 |
Ahmed Adel Attia, Dorottya Demszky, Tolulope Ogunremi, Jing Liu, Carol Espy-Wilson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, eess.AS
|
Creating Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems that are robust and
resilient to classroom conditions is paramount to the development of AI tools
to aid teachers and students. In this work, we study the efficacy of continued
pretraining (CPT) in adapting Wav2vec2.0 to the classroom domain. We show that
CPT is a powerful tool in that regard and reduces the Word Error Rate (WER) of
Wav2vec2.0-based models by upwards of 10%. More specifically, CPT improves the
model's robustness to different noises, microphones, classroom conditions as
well as classroom demographics. Our CPT models show improved ability to
generalize to different demographics unseen in the labeled finetuning data.
|
[
-0.1433527171611786,
-0.40149256587028503,
0.2001899629831314,
0.17096228897571564,
-0.327566534280777,
0.1322230100631714,
-0.44264158606529236,
-0.19711750745773315,
-0.6712464690208435,
0.19370028376579285,
-0.39703500270843506,
-0.1056373193860054,
-0.7296619415283203,
-0.16081373393535614,
-0.37690073251724243,
0.9184972643852234,
-0.3033003509044647,
0.4442328214645386,
-0.5126034021377563,
-0.13430596888065338,
-1.08432137966156,
-0.9903861284255981,
-0.9253550171852112,
-0.5686894655227661,
-0.03751794993877411,
0.3666018843650818,
0.36202117800712585,
0.33016714453697205,
0.5873475670814514,
0.26322367787361145,
0.49621817469596863,
-0.3994447886943817,
-0.5625869631767273,
-0.013724494725465775,
-0.27045273780822754,
-0.3812505602836609,
-0.38372284173965454,
0.11354062706232071,
0.6775223612785339,
0.797331690788269,
-0.4574412703514099,
-0.13337741792201996,
0.5567566752433777,
0.7478254437446594,
-0.2849520444869995,
0.21715185046195984,
-0.630034863948822,
-0.06971746683120728,
-0.08835646510124207,
-0.1741219311952591,
-0.31692755222320557,
-0.4037540555000305,
0.6520871520042419,
-0.8420591354370117,
0.233916774392128,
-0.48624882102012634,
0.443489670753479,
0.35916635394096375,
-0.24991069734096527,
-0.2849996089935303,
-0.9326159954071045,
0.8967616558074951,
-0.21925535798072815,
0.9899774789810181,
0.7585616111755371,
0.3115929663181305,
0.07261190563440323,
-0.9528683423995972,
-0.43449804186820984,
-0.11573953181505203,
0.32707667350769043,
0.4773448407649994,
-0.34246230125427246,
-0.06111433357000351,
0.1339268833398819,
-0.050294384360313416,
-0.47175946831703186,
0.055071961134672165,
-0.6303427219390869,
-0.39907097816467285,
0.24136079847812653,
-0.08908402919769287,
0.1822080761194229,
0.6335521936416626,
-0.3594331443309784,
-0.3535788357257843,
-0.5892665386199951,
0.4070172905921936,
0.18868601322174072,
0.18716038763523102,
-0.011509847827255726,
0.35544946789741516,
0.38039687275886536,
0.557558536529541,
-0.1298460215330124,
-0.03749687969684601,
0.17909260094165802,
-0.2554197311401367,
0.015712756663560867,
0.27212464809417725,
0.18335841596126556,
0.20146936178207397,
0.7708410620689392,
0.1889210194349289,
-0.2909550666809082,
0.6053891777992249,
0.22867456078529358,
-0.704575777053833,
-0.8257489800453186,
-0.32557713985443115,
-0.27603408694267273,
0.0340031273663044,
-0.01271923165768385,
-0.2372533529996872,
0.12996216118335724,
-0.8575975298881531,
0.6930911540985107,
-0.5799098610877991,
-0.263526052236557,
0.1615239679813385,
-0.11819189786911011,
0.1674167960882187,
0.6136146783828735,
-0.8669908046722412,
0.8700873255729675,
0.6290213465690613,
0.6625823974609375,
-0.3779279291629791,
-0.27512773871421814,
-0.7433103919029236,
-0.11068705469369888,
-0.22285673022270203,
0.7323917746543884,
-0.5058800578117371,
-0.8826749920845032,
-0.15910841524600983,
-0.11205977201461792,
-0.3528706431388855,
-0.7544708251953125,
0.4894862771034241,
-0.6637739539146423,
0.3266790509223938,
-0.11005770415067673,
-0.5878310799598694,
0.11177240312099457,
-0.02158196084201336,
-0.2818627953529358,
1.008764386177063,
0.4370432496070862,
-0.21017926931381226,
0.2932693064212799,
-0.555427074432373,
-0.5322415828704834,
-0.00974965002387762,
-0.0002900643739849329,
-0.6251124143600464,
0.05357933044433594,
0.1314362734556198,
-0.13712188601493835,
0.21662217378616333,
-0.06849155575037003,
-0.02565324492752552,
-0.47686076164245605,
0.25266051292419434,
-0.4303445518016815,
0.6049370765686035,
0.032492246478796005,
-0.11021436005830765,
-0.10648377239704132,
-0.6199981570243835,
0.018396049737930298,
-0.04300102964043617,
-0.6676842570304871,
-0.4438667595386505,
0.11108390986919403,
0.15635107457637787,
0.14005713164806366,
-0.004246156197041273,
-0.34008073806762695,
0.007101485971361399,
-0.20747783780097961,
0.30757787823677063,
0.7517861723899841,
-0.1794210970401764,
0.29385659098625183,
-0.3926245868206024,
0.5160013437271118,
-0.12496340274810791,
-0.21829582750797272,
-0.04444565623998642,
-0.5359703898429871,
-0.7921014428138733,
-0.3141484260559082,
0.5688832402229309,
0.849113941192627,
-0.540393590927124,
0.4712173640727997,
-0.31317394971847534,
-0.1457221359014511,
-0.21895521879196167,
0.03038054332137108,
0.5562182068824768,
0.5983772873878479,
0.5561298727989197,
-0.6336332559585571,
-0.8014077544212341,
-0.2216835469007492,
-0.21416860818862915,
-0.04696644842624664,
-0.487713485956192,
0.2272063046693802,
0.40162017941474915,
-0.35232892632484436,
0.9988654851913452,
-0.33917349576950073,
-0.4714277982711792,
-0.009292595088481903,
-0.11555279791355133,
-0.14569884538650513,
0.8360145688056946,
0.4836136996746063,
-0.7027953267097473,
-0.6250185966491699,
-0.3565801978111267,
-0.13234570622444153,
-0.037527214735746384,
-0.014878543093800545,
-0.0249941423535347,
0.17825421690940857,
0.3446824848651886,
-0.015241377986967564,
0.536216676235199,
0.3617106080055237,
-0.22454456984996796,
0.5180308818817139,
-0.12346211075782776,
-0.09810852259397507,
-0.7772251963615417,
-0.14640085399150848,
-0.17975400388240814,
-0.5023521780967712,
-0.7429052591323853,
-0.496349960565567,
0.03052181378006935,
-0.46559402346611023,
-0.31001582741737366,
0.1315295398235321,
-0.19511641561985016,
-0.13113535940647125,
-0.32955145835876465,
0.16842761635780334,
-0.19536100327968597,
0.2916002869606018,
0.35817307233810425,
1.0598900318145752,
0.7270715832710266,
-0.7494345307350159,
0.20731018483638763,
0.4247760474681854,
-0.10887093842029572,
0.678062379360199,
-0.9112005829811096,
0.5542001724243164,
0.25787580013275146,
0.4066496193408966,
-0.861010730266571,
0.04965926706790924,
-0.033034734427928925,
-0.8909904360771179,
0.4243939220905304,
-0.15795962512493134,
0.0038219070993363857,
-0.37848538160324097,
-0.26615217328071594,
0.5389527678489685,
0.7628122568130493,
-0.8723371028900146,
0.47258707880973816,
0.37435007095336914,
-0.37584179639816284,
-0.12565073370933533,
-0.5753259062767029,
-0.23406723141670227,
0.22115793824195862,
-0.46156826615333557,
0.23653753101825714,
-0.3260970413684845,
-0.06410278379917145,
0.026819972321391106,
-0.36032095551490784,
-0.30192288756370544,
0.08955901861190796,
0.2607439160346985,
0.4414018392562866,
-0.44163063168525696,
-0.0029343150090426207,
-0.06726109981536865,
-0.3352886140346527,
0.07389085739850998,
-0.666159451007843,
0.7081242799758911,
-0.04137692227959633,
-0.23628360033035278,
-0.8438166379928589,
0.14725399017333984,
0.26264986395835876,
-0.20304694771766663,
0.38004374504089355,
0.43430307507514954,
-0.7068996429443359,
-0.06003214791417122,
-0.2463303506374359,
-0.25338292121887207,
-0.5068739056587219,
0.5734004974365234,
-0.4639926552772522,
-0.8863682746887207,
0.19173167645931244,
-0.1067502498626709,
-0.17511838674545288,
0.33037450909614563,
0.46146684885025024,
-0.07237318158149719,
0.8160687685012817,
0.7108860015869141,
-0.07803204655647278,
0.7751250267028809,
-0.24906879663467407,
0.01916274055838585,
-0.9607335329055786,
-0.24825601279735565,
-0.45325595140457153,
0.06743136793375015,
-0.24383307993412018,
-0.23886416852474213,
0.3087792992591858,
0.1024860367178917,
-0.11431335657835007,
0.3098456561565399,
-0.4893024265766144,
0.531105637550354,
0.6382670402526855,
0.20396184921264648,
-0.05100925639271736,
0.2887091636657715,
0.31324502825737,
-0.37479761242866516,
-0.34083321690559387,
-0.09825938194990158,
1.0803463459014893,
0.37356361746788025,
0.6462515592575073,
0.3293929398059845,
0.5123888254165649,
0.16867975890636444,
0.3980039954185486,
-0.9471874237060547,
0.15772712230682373,
-0.46935784816741943,
-0.4546361267566681,
-0.47450733184814453,
-0.26676660776138306,
-0.9710359573364258,
0.06915764510631561,
-0.10924060642719269,
-0.5290977358818054,
0.16965845227241516,
0.3251252770423889,
-0.5317121148109436,
-0.12880656123161316,
-0.6070156097412109,
0.5703059434890747,
0.02999611385166645,
-0.1769077181816101,
-0.38452470302581787,
-0.3380161225795746,
0.015464340336620808,
-0.6669663786888123,
0.09583862870931625,
0.20376969873905182,
0.148969367146492,
1.2087314128875732,
-0.7021125555038452,
0.5461052060127258,
-0.3593282997608185,
0.09313395619392395,
0.7292865514755249,
-0.08107445389032364,
0.3532654345035553,
-0.15559110045433044,
-0.024187462404370308,
0.1515427529811859,
0.19299764931201935,
-0.25657686591148376,
-0.4502439498901367,
0.6575269103050232,
-1.1638914346694946,
-0.4392124116420746,
-0.48946812748908997,
-0.3421311378479004,
-0.4411216080188751,
0.20553672313690186,
0.3146921396255493,
0.9031046032905579,
-0.025459179654717445,
0.5600990653038025,
0.6745891571044922,
0.14215689897537231,
0.3195057511329651,
0.49515265226364136,
0.16675572097301483,
-0.6661999225616455,
1.1486231088638306,
0.34348148107528687,
0.17237693071365356,
-0.12396644800901413,
0.3376457393169403,
-0.5778922438621521,
-0.5419228672981262,
-0.11657129228115082,
-0.25387102365493774,
-0.6574366688728333,
-0.2034684717655182,
-0.4801652431488037,
-0.40763795375823975,
-0.6985819339752197,
-0.5418831706047058,
-0.4020329713821411,
-0.6232829689979553,
-0.5772277116775513,
-0.04388431832194328,
0.22055476903915405,
0.5212386250495911,
-0.20951028168201447,
0.6694769263267517,
-0.7171114683151245,
0.2580048143863678,
0.9068388938903809,
0.2918859124183655,
-0.3847111761569977,
-1.2071763277053833,
-0.1495773196220398,
-0.04010060429573059,
-0.35868096351623535,
-0.33596718311309814,
0.10980332642793655,
0.8211286664009094,
0.3781411349773407,
-0.05383933708071709,
-0.1149924248456955,
0.6389403939247131,
-0.745101273059845,
0.7949600219726562,
0.5218451619148254,
-1.1019200086593628,
0.5356569886207581,
-0.25533485412597656,
0.2132648378610611,
0.5715003609657288,
0.030406739562749863,
-0.30722224712371826,
0.214619979262352,
-0.27914685010910034,
-0.7208533883094788,
0.7912871837615967,
0.32961538434028625,
0.4847169518470764,
0.4795002341270447,
0.46891385316848755,
-0.0010748321656137705,
-0.12146034091711044,
-0.49943241477012634,
-0.11004909127950668,
-0.7726090550422668,
-0.4100877642631531,
-0.1511489599943161,
-0.3430701494216919,
-0.05777173861861229,
-0.6256037950515747,
0.6438918709754944,
0.08157169073820114,
0.1610262244939804,
0.05164770409464836,
-0.2722941040992737,
-0.12259942293167114,
0.10481198132038116,
0.6851553320884705,
0.71620112657547,
-0.09762996435165405,
0.15683192014694214,
0.5449072122573853,
-1.2360421419143677,
0.26549413800239563,
0.375794380903244,
0.2914235591888428,
-0.2381480485200882,
0.665989100933075,
0.7196179032325745,
0.13585636019706726,
-0.3197975158691406,
0.8077232241630554,
-0.4204562306404114,
-0.40051060914993286,
-0.7738898396492004,
0.33393052220344543,
-0.32112985849380493,
0.04871424660086632,
0.4722347855567932,
0.36409521102905273,
0.014371738769114017,
-0.4689999222755432,
0.6133731603622437,
0.14520154893398285,
-0.4749915301799774,
-0.4658806324005127,
0.7844666838645935,
0.2625582814216614,
-0.628555953502655,
0.8508399724960327,
0.272151917219162,
-0.8619951605796814,
0.503231406211853,
1.111858606338501,
0.752055823802948,
-0.7351148724555969,
-0.4514061212539673,
0.477886825799942,
0.03638485074043274,
-0.07362019270658493,
0.24192969501018524,
-0.229109525680542,
-0.8310635089874268,
-0.01373360026627779,
-0.31419089436531067,
-0.4682583212852478,
-0.168496772646904,
-0.9050887227058411,
0.31030037999153137,
-0.7038782835006714,
-0.1517162173986435,
-0.009492567740380764,
0.0498860627412796,
-0.698907196521759,
0.5779288411140442,
0.24822565913200378,
0.5120611786842346,
-0.6695447564125061,
1.2492265701293945,
0.7352843880653381,
0.16971802711486816,
-0.8521499633789062,
0.030007440596818924,
0.07498861849308014,
-0.7900235652923584,
0.5923886299133301,
0.05298726260662079,
-0.3688078224658966,
0.36552295088768005,
-0.4194281995296478,
-0.8720282912254333,
1.0304394960403442,
0.027524160221219063,
-0.8704332709312439,
0.5199599862098694,
-0.031245552003383636,
0.5722941756248474,
-0.3069019615650177,
-0.30407950282096863,
0.6974425315856934,
0.12531235814094543,
0.21122834086418152,
-0.9248442649841309,
-0.3049187660217285,
-0.10457240045070648,
0.12554003298282623,
-0.1938154399394989,
-0.23353196680545807,
0.6349082589149475,
-0.3929376006126404,
-0.1578451544046402,
0.006139805540442467,
0.8634210228919983,
0.4642753303050995,
0.5215290784835815,
0.8225864171981812,
0.4563671946525574,
0.8187501430511475,
-0.22767823934555054,
0.6312580108642578,
-0.19034339487552643,
0.3676315248012543,
1.2524136304855347,
-0.2018263041973114,
0.9748883843421936,
0.16028180718421936,
-0.5100551247596741,
0.33272936940193176,
0.6248137354850769,
-0.08534140884876251,
0.8310103416442871,
0.15804773569107056,
-0.5432946681976318,
-0.24084638059139252,
-0.009838725440204144,
-0.7407795786857605,
0.31803321838378906,
0.4671999216079712,
0.1556406170129776,
0.3835255205631256,
0.3443831205368042,
0.01326195988804102,
0.0471046157181263,
-0.35553330183029175,
0.7202507853507996,
0.21516232192516327,
-0.45562782883644104,
0.6028508543968201,
-0.2883552014827728,
0.4848170578479767,
-0.5061948299407959,
-0.04890113323926926,
0.0368475541472435,
0.5730119943618774,
-0.08139007538557053,
-0.5941770672798157,
0.15589722990989685,
0.03721038997173309,
-0.23240692913532257,
-0.14015474915504456,
0.7856525182723999,
-0.580512285232544,
-0.47677820920944214,
0.09355459362268448,
-0.018872205168008804,
0.01954774558544159,
0.09605927765369415,
-0.48759686946868896,
0.2714972198009491,
-0.029116084799170494,
-0.14746282994747162,
0.1957959234714508,
0.10777034610509872,
0.018160976469516754,
0.3218329846858978,
0.9681212902069092,
-0.23756542801856995,
-0.11418262869119644,
0.3085152506828308,
1.075315237045288,
-0.2303861528635025,
-0.4264252483844757,
-0.6128831505775452,
0.42755624651908875,
0.37252238392829895,
-0.29134824872016907,
0.6646499037742615,
0.6715066432952881,
1.0530928373336792,
-0.08394894003868103,
0.7783393263816833,
0.30126693844795227,
0.6047506928443909,
-0.5137300491333008,
0.5765582323074341,
-0.1689838021993637,
0.1837666630744934,
-0.15683864057064056,
-0.8491280674934387,
-0.47169700264930725,
0.9422710537910461,
-0.21937251091003418,
0.214787095785141,
0.6649435758590698,
0.32874369621276855,
-0.24886342883110046,
0.02863725647330284,
0.2908957898616791,
-0.06197310611605644,
0.4702794551849365,
0.39328402280807495,
0.796156644821167,
-0.5020112991333008,
0.5182793140411377,
-0.280631422996521,
-0.54380863904953,
-0.019451558589935303,
-0.22913281619548798,
-0.8933320045471191,
-0.47356733679771423,
-0.5743198990821838,
-0.4566619098186493,
0.1885717213153839,
0.9251826405525208,
0.797819197177887,
-1.0459774732589722,
-0.04117204248905182,
-0.06519267708063126,
-0.41301435232162476,
-0.012740013189613819,
-0.17067822813987732,
0.6146714687347412,
-0.20441648364067078,
-0.42719751596450806,
0.4936172068119049,
-0.136537104845047,
0.3310834467411041,
0.3076002895832062,
-0.3683044910430908,
0.34017330408096313,
0.20263931155204773,
0.7053082585334778,
0.3453107476234436,
-0.22146596014499664,
-0.5382099151611328,
-0.07540270686149597,
0.05777180939912796,
0.0725526511669159,
0.7907244563102722,
-0.7704671621322632,
0.6123117208480835,
0.13530033826828003,
0.6168882250785828,
0.3957752585411072,
0.2831447124481201,
0.44192060828208923,
-0.579715371131897,
0.28855445981025696,
0.2914581000804901,
0.3573771119117737,
0.3878725469112396,
-0.1777888536453247,
0.4806766211986542,
0.7244935631752014,
-0.6777519583702087,
-0.8627938628196716,
-0.0175552386790514,
-0.8536434173583984,
0.12549714744091034,
0.993647038936615,
-0.3848606050014496,
0.047558024525642395,
-0.3257831335067749,
-0.4359038770198822,
0.3680197298526764,
-0.3251030743122101,
0.44939154386520386,
0.5185598731040955,
-0.1417623609304428,
-0.13713330030441284,
-0.3876570463180542,
0.515393078327179,
0.4209691286087036,
-0.5253685116767883,
-0.07715578377246857,
0.45329099893569946,
0.6501501202583313,
0.01780886761844158,
0.8705276846885681,
-0.08623083680868149,
0.5544840693473816,
0.12440918385982513,
-0.12194261699914932,
0.03188801184296608,
-0.4851229786872864,
-0.6043649315834045,
-0.2944277822971344,
0.1786758154630661,
-0.5506475567817688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13017v1
|
A Systematic Analysis on the Temporal Generalization of Language Models in Social Media
| 2024-05-15T05:41:06 | 2024-05-15T05:41:06 |
Asahi Ushio, Jose Camacho-Collados
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In machine learning, temporal shifts occur when there are differences between
training and test splits in terms of time. For streaming data such as news or
social media, models are commonly trained on a fixed corpus from a certain
period of time, and they can become obsolete due to the dynamism and evolving
nature of online content. This paper focuses on temporal shifts in social media
and, in particular, Twitter. We propose a unified evaluation scheme to assess
the performance of language models (LMs) under temporal shift on standard
social media tasks. LMs are tested on five diverse social media NLP tasks under
different temporal settings, which revealed two important findings: (i) the
decrease in performance under temporal shift is consistent across different
models for entity-focused tasks such as named entity recognition or
disambiguation, and hate speech detection, but not significant in the other
tasks analysed (i.e., topic and sentiment classification); and (ii) continuous
pre-training on the test period does not improve the temporal adaptability of
LMs.
|
[
0.08917245268821716,
-1.0125021934509277,
0.4110657274723053,
0.6389011144638062,
-0.2975550889968872,
0.4417456388473511,
-0.40381503105163574,
-0.39129725098609924,
0.03954019770026207,
0.05432881787419319,
-0.7715556621551514,
-0.4482956826686859,
-0.7840877175331116,
0.044656869024038315,
-0.7932496070861816,
0.8111637234687805,
-0.14770574867725372,
-0.02411893755197525,
0.4348245859146118,
-0.29123055934906006,
-0.11615674197673798,
-0.21625785529613495,
-0.9468176960945129,
-0.21931016445159912,
0.5989577174186707,
-0.29527005553245544,
0.7888307571411133,
0.39644795656204224,
0.5742621421813965,
0.33915722370147705,
-0.06532473862171173,
-0.07522996515035629,
-0.40021005272865295,
-0.16139072179794312,
-0.4380052089691162,
-0.21862319111824036,
-0.3060511350631714,
-0.037390682846307755,
0.9792883992195129,
0.8982773423194885,
-0.11544574052095413,
0.6272180080413818,
0.015104086138308048,
0.5197839140892029,
-0.648128092288971,
0.06770982593297958,
-0.8608337044715881,
-0.06782298535108566,
-0.11049692332744598,
-0.24216516315937042,
-0.22384625673294067,
-0.5994294285774231,
0.06362985074520111,
-0.3700799345970154,
0.38541141152381897,
-0.3445996940135956,
1.1312708854675293,
0.19661496579647064,
-0.24352248013019562,
0.08814670890569687,
-1.2715505361557007,
0.7398701906204224,
-0.7352549433708191,
0.5656253099441528,
-0.055537912994623184,
0.582038164138794,
0.19508498907089233,
-0.7663623094558716,
-0.5129491090774536,
0.03784063830971718,
0.24608929455280304,
-0.13718542456626892,
-0.26632171869277954,
-0.11124709248542786,
0.20661205053329468,
-0.10413351655006409,
-0.41941314935684204,
0.09145856648683548,
-0.22058798372745514,
0.16119235754013062,
0.5574381351470947,
0.027417857199907303,
0.5249267220497131,
-0.01859857141971588,
0.004876063670963049,
0.19855982065200806,
-0.37808772921562195,
0.21847796440124512,
0.3031346797943115,
0.44013988971710205,
-0.23156125843524933,
0.2576490342617035,
-0.12568162381649017,
0.3994775116443634,
-0.03001599945127964,
-0.030182970687747,
0.1685687154531479,
-0.24108649790287018,
-0.2978774905204773,
-0.3116177022457123,
0.8674362301826477,
0.6746294498443604,
0.6193124651908875,
-0.44155192375183105,
-0.05145949125289917,
0.49333980679512024,
0.2083040326833725,
-0.6143100261688232,
0.1800169050693512,
0.10523749142885208,
-0.4744453728199005,
-0.21264630556106567,
-0.13042281568050385,
-0.3450886011123657,
0.01658071018755436,
-0.34284883737564087,
0.16014604270458221,
-0.2901991605758667,
-0.4870251417160034,
0.09747646003961563,
-0.11916719377040863,
0.1570219099521637,
0.13699084520339966,
-0.663139283657074,
0.3707948923110962,
0.6903619170188904,
0.9540838003158569,
-0.31370797753334045,
-0.3431270122528076,
-0.2459253966808319,
0.12008032947778702,
-0.5859206318855286,
0.6853522658348083,
-0.702523410320282,
-0.16070818901062012,
0.38014066219329834,
0.43107736110687256,
-0.5574461221694946,
-0.2643078863620758,
0.3726155757904053,
-0.7354161739349365,
-0.004246015101671219,
-0.09998282045125961,
-0.36799898743629456,
0.17599886655807495,
-0.27686232328414917,
-0.5526869297027588,
1.0072792768478394,
0.040912069380283356,
-0.7272541522979736,
0.6582914590835571,
-0.7111556529998779,
-0.43687018752098083,
-0.019588885828852654,
0.033428214490413666,
-0.24648797512054443,
0.09352196007966995,
0.4202783405780792,
0.6778972148895264,
0.05391945317387581,
0.45569178462028503,
-0.5569993853569031,
-0.5492384433746338,
0.41989168524742126,
-0.13957110047340393,
0.8855658173561096,
0.27981024980545044,
-0.45323097705841064,
-0.06576929241418839,
-0.6270566582679749,
-0.004503075499087572,
0.2837899923324585,
-0.3220910131931305,
-0.39141756296157837,
0.4442257583141327,
0.2746596336364746,
0.25761446356773376,
-0.12748774886131287,
-0.6843047142028809,
0.16512034833431244,
-0.15702266991138458,
0.8771912455558777,
0.8693151473999023,
0.023326890543103218,
0.5822521448135376,
-0.1811397820711136,
0.2677820324897766,
-0.061749137938022614,
0.44640398025512695,
0.40613582730293274,
-0.2019168883562088,
-0.8250648379325867,
0.1572265774011612,
0.3633444011211395,
0.5249792337417603,
-0.8362515568733215,
0.2653979957103729,
-0.8695763945579529,
-0.3052603602409363,
-0.6202154159545898,
0.12528902292251587,
0.00215320847928524,
-0.10616924613714218,
0.23482581973075867,
0.08872547745704651,
-0.5767583250999451,
-0.7608053088188171,
-0.5867627263069153,
-0.3355056941509247,
-0.18905691802501678,
-0.18199589848518372,
0.3663807213306427,
-0.5804077386856079,
0.8462217450141907,
0.004056444391608238,
0.3988232910633087,
-0.3773605227470398,
0.4419523775577545,
-0.05246616527438164,
-0.09400124847888947,
0.6003355979919434,
-0.7875415086746216,
-0.4183413088321686,
-0.16323401033878326,
-0.5954854488372803,
-0.4263981878757477,
-0.3466901183128357,
0.20637153089046478,
0.6129939556121826,
0.6607165336608887,
-0.2288195639848709,
0.31638580560684204,
0.7858841419219971,
-0.27209746837615967,
0.16922076046466827,
0.48355385661125183,
0.29254186153411865,
-0.91743403673172,
-0.05165857449173927,
0.024330763146281242,
-0.3405866026878357,
-0.6984203457832336,
-0.26419541239738464,
0.1659349501132965,
0.0712033212184906,
-0.5872607231140137,
0.7987636923789978,
-0.37685060501098633,
-0.09680193662643433,
-0.09432567656040192,
0.08103527128696442,
-0.4185278117656708,
0.33958470821380615,
-0.016384059563279152,
0.140752911567688,
0.25055164098739624,
-0.8820658922195435,
-0.2914084196090698,
-0.5321338772773743,
-0.4298243522644043,
0.18537846207618713,
-0.7123803496360779,
0.5233215689659119,
-0.15927749872207642,
-0.06498806178569794,
-0.9601067900657654,
0.19036158919334412,
0.06781089305877686,
-0.5541388988494873,
0.10398515313863754,
-0.2597214877605438,
-0.7370041012763977,
-0.31051114201545715,
-0.08523929864168167,
0.14876338839530945,
0.3781528174877167,
-0.2224542647600174,
0.4624669551849365,
0.27715957164764404,
-0.17736226320266724,
-0.36328059434890747,
-0.6093935370445251,
-0.12878350913524628,
-0.2213052660226822,
-0.7697893977165222,
0.5681780576705933,
-0.0774378627538681,
-0.6319770812988281,
0.380386620759964,
-0.10029413551092148,
-0.07625117152929306,
0.24444153904914856,
0.24124740064144135,
0.138136088848114,
-0.09653166681528091,
0.338739275932312,
0.12235773354768753,
0.31038495898246765,
-0.10590095072984695,
0.07498911023139954,
0.6303281784057617,
0.010033214464783669,
-0.03938210383057594,
-0.3046517074108124,
0.20220135152339935,
0.19479820132255554,
0.09003244340419769,
0.773933470249176,
0.9732380509376526,
-0.4918114244937897,
-0.2077462077140808,
-0.7819415926933289,
0.08639539033174515,
-0.4116886854171753,
0.2739887535572052,
-0.06676200777292252,
-1.0548412799835205,
0.5377903580665588,
0.15044118463993073,
0.3804734945297241,
0.6773467659950256,
0.5047253370285034,
-0.2704549729824066,
1.075413465499878,
0.8500813841819763,
-0.10601494461297989,
0.9933822751045227,
-0.11354213207960129,
0.013385076075792313,
-0.4392940104007721,
0.23776975274085999,
-0.33841192722320557,
-0.34996479749679565,
-0.6875174641609192,
-0.21474589407444,
-0.036894381046295166,
0.14756013453006744,
-0.2812859117984772,
0.2736995220184326,
-0.1640675663948059,
0.31304705142974854,
-0.1758825182914734,
-0.15277627110481262,
0.18029075860977173,
0.13002969324588776,
0.22702625393867493,
-0.08463705331087112,
-0.5076217651367188,
-0.5514116883277893,
1.0249171257019043,
0.4466921091079712,
0.34906360507011414,
0.07984711974859238,
0.34407031536102295,
0.562229335308075,
0.4612819254398346,
-0.2148871123790741,
0.5830304622650146,
-0.27738529443740845,
-0.5022084712982178,
-0.5792979598045349,
-0.4101846218109131,
-1.0540372133255005,
0.036698807030916214,
-0.09761325269937515,
-0.6740685701370239,
-0.13485419750213623,
-0.3862963914871216,
-0.30794358253479004,
0.40333518385887146,
-0.6481612324714661,
0.5481569766998291,
-0.1992974728345871,
-0.0869554877281189,
-0.25405973196029663,
-0.5583468079566956,
0.07586603611707687,
0.019584815949201584,
0.5550619959831238,
-0.6729471683502197,
-0.16994543373584747,
1.0713469982147217,
-0.015436846762895584,
0.9499271512031555,
-0.25870829820632935,
0.48437654972076416,
0.24368849396705627,
0.10679009556770325,
0.194053053855896,
-0.08296504616737366,
0.2808937132358551,
0.27837103605270386,
0.27650755643844604,
-0.5172160863876343,
-0.6892743110656738,
0.44356662034988403,
-0.9019231200218201,
-0.16238285601139069,
-0.17483356595039368,
-0.3868580758571625,
-0.25836896896362305,
0.014745072461664677,
0.09370026737451553,
0.11244357377290726,
-0.6313092708587646,
0.17280851304531097,
0.23673363029956818,
-0.0494568832218647,
0.8969351053237915,
0.8142227530479431,
-0.47186508774757385,
0.13226021826267242,
0.34854286909103394,
0.3638046085834503,
0.40827488899230957,
0.4609559178352356,
0.2692403197288513,
-0.2642970085144043,
-0.4742557406425476,
-0.08508619666099548,
0.301113486289978,
-0.6075233221054077,
0.4773982763290405,
-0.8223273158073425,
-0.27134427428245544,
-0.8854276537895203,
-0.10079846531152725,
-0.3453470766544342,
-0.58223956823349,
-0.024547845125198364,
-0.12023019045591354,
0.20411571860313416,
0.6524965167045593,
0.026332151144742966,
0.4442088007926941,
-0.7435605525970459,
0.3626739978790283,
0.15974703431129456,
0.20938411355018616,
-0.3262878954410553,
-0.7408925890922546,
-0.17570960521697998,
-0.06219978258013725,
-0.13620030879974365,
-0.8457367420196533,
0.10700162500143051,
0.24447990953922272,
0.6064230799674988,
0.2598143219947815,
-0.4250812828540802,
0.495917409658432,
-0.7343602180480957,
0.7156518697738647,
0.05179176479578018,
-0.8784940838813782,
0.41835588216781616,
-0.6124213337898254,
0.5135079026222229,
0.34012123942375183,
0.6153562068939209,
-1.0129331350326538,
-0.4352234899997711,
-0.6766405701637268,
-0.7742295265197754,
0.1691017597913742,
0.24126523733139038,
0.22254586219787598,
-0.08086703717708588,
0.3339521586894989,
-0.15001121163368225,
0.19293691217899323,
-0.6442978978157043,
-0.175966277718544,
0.013443936593830585,
0.25888481736183167,
-0.31956854462623596,
-0.2501905560493469,
0.19505363702774048,
-0.3506336212158203,
0.2871890068054199,
0.11658230423927307,
0.3717004954814911,
-0.1335911899805069,
-0.4238111972808838,
-0.20224185287952423,
0.5388619303703308,
0.3012324273586273,
1.0679303407669067,
-0.4989568591117859,
-0.2389005571603775,
0.13008248805999756,
-0.1699424535036087,
0.05015555024147034,
0.17948392033576965,
-0.14785797894001007,
0.5676518082618713,
0.658755898475647,
0.7731522917747498,
0.5127593874931335,
-0.08798326551914215,
0.22776326537132263,
-0.09035157412290573,
0.08256657421588898,
-0.33449625968933105,
-0.24917487800121307,
0.28066182136535645,
0.239557147026062,
0.3163473904132843,
-0.22126729786396027,
-0.010996052995324135,
-0.9101170897483826,
-0.02758353389799595,
0.005101559683680534,
-0.33917590975761414,
-0.6931796073913574,
0.46924325823783875,
0.10755098611116409,
-0.4439898431301117,
0.33076512813568115,
-0.2301238477230072,
-0.2876797318458557,
0.3441692292690277,
0.28281939029693604,
1.3114566802978516,
-0.6289803981781006,
0.5364705920219421,
0.2277628481388092,
0.49161073565483093,
-0.11996455490589142,
0.2796435058116913,
0.17809593677520752,
-0.888920247554779,
-0.4515993893146515,
-0.741113543510437,
-0.12442921102046967,
0.1781042516231537,
-0.6036402583122253,
0.27472004294395447,
-0.5015771985054016,
-0.6533175706863403,
0.3656335473060608,
-0.23710738122463226,
-1.0130006074905396,
0.0652351826429367,
0.08798360824584961,
0.5068342685699463,
-1.0691779851913452,
0.7229094505310059,
0.616708517074585,
-0.1017979308962822,
-0.35508301854133606,
0.05051262304186821,
0.12500911951065063,
-0.6537002921104431,
0.7697322964668274,
-0.07866176217794418,
-0.08787522464990616,
-0.3885015845298767,
-0.5919931530952454,
-0.6429435610771179,
0.9418689608573914,
0.26812514662742615,
-0.7041270732879639,
-0.5448608994483948,
0.40741005539894104,
0.9613736867904663,
-0.3907615542411804,
0.1386912316083908,
0.590050220489502,
0.09683383256196976,
-0.1871965527534485,
-1.115718960762024,
-0.1726294457912445,
-0.3279343545436859,
0.3364512324333191,
0.21216772496700287,
-0.49454936385154724,
0.9534352421760559,
0.11564083397388458,
-1.0028351545333862,
-0.34202197194099426,
0.40707671642303467,
-0.09323645383119583,
0.3049248158931732,
0.6631330251693726,
0.19980134069919586,
0.41957104206085205,
-0.17137393355369568,
1.2306617498397827,
-0.15834921598434448,
0.27450594305992126,
1.0236278772354126,
-0.16683068871498108,
0.8950336575508118,
0.3314039409160614,
-0.4160887598991394,
0.4000377058982849,
0.7190609574317932,
0.23446248471736908,
0.428032249212265,
0.08029535412788391,
0.17847658693790436,
-0.3606891930103302,
-0.10471366345882416,
-0.39248213171958923,
-0.010059264488518238,
0.3790505826473236,
-0.40664589405059814,
-0.46396318078041077,
-0.07825072854757309,
0.3177473545074463,
-0.041400663554668427,
-0.4740217328071594,
0.4685734510421753,
0.21758610010147095,
-0.4498762786388397,
0.4945210814476013,
0.10270193964242935,
0.5913922786712646,
-0.4558134377002716,
0.30741313099861145,
-0.12006130069494247,
0.41151875257492065,
-0.09489145129919052,
-0.6136534214019775,
0.5540089011192322,
0.059577759355306625,
-0.1209123283624649,
-0.2357126921415329,
0.6778829097747803,
-0.056216318160295486,
-0.8975875377655029,
0.8407789468765259,
0.5075709819793701,
-0.0363614484667778,
-0.2341800481081009,
-0.9511180520057678,
0.31311097741127014,
-0.3001842200756073,
-0.24997201561927795,
0.20029586553573608,
0.43575459718704224,
-0.26149407029151917,
0.5761548280715942,
0.5518235564231873,
0.19547902047634125,
0.530907928943634,
0.6136364936828613,
0.6502777338027954,
-0.5865148305892944,
-0.2504351735115051,
-1.011488676071167,
0.3459129333496094,
0.03755359351634979,
-0.27800554037094116,
0.7562576532363892,
0.28264233469963074,
0.9408327341079712,
0.17823317646980286,
0.8158349394798279,
0.020900558680295944,
0.8526705503463745,
-0.7901113033294678,
0.6128856539726257,
-0.5578551292419434,
0.05998329818248749,
-0.5698710680007935,
-1.0428708791732788,
-0.1495518982410431,
0.05721816420555115,
-0.634207546710968,
0.0015820743283256888,
0.9174479842185974,
0.4940088093280792,
0.12303399294614792,
-0.07451847940683365,
0.2627283036708832,
0.09803914278745651,
0.35560083389282227,
0.3604310154914856,
0.9851653575897217,
-0.3417592942714691,
0.3905984163284302,
-0.32968923449516296,
0.07549556344747543,
-0.09324468672275543,
-0.7182967066764832,
-1.2577427625656128,
-0.8354356288909912,
-0.5087653994560242,
-0.31496912240982056,
0.7687874436378479,
0.7899196743965149,
0.45757418870925903,
-0.7154116630554199,
-0.3223192095756531,
0.3848389983177185,
-0.09511063247919083,
-0.38442879915237427,
-0.21877330541610718,
0.4066765010356903,
-0.41339245438575745,
-0.7564752697944641,
0.11932307481765747,
0.1346643567085266,
-0.15615880489349365,
-0.07084935158491135,
0.3696024417877197,
-0.5209592580795288,
0.1788366287946701,
0.7158764600753784,
0.1773713231086731,
-0.6688868403434753,
-0.49236613512039185,
0.4088951349258423,
-0.12600645422935486,
-0.0677686482667923,
0.9350542426109314,
-0.13383153080940247,
0.19948355853557587,
0.6464200019836426,
0.44940659403800964,
0.6067038178443909,
-0.10471159964799881,
0.30210551619529724,
-0.5776670575141907,
0.051600247621536255,
0.17993177473545074,
0.38216254115104675,
0.4089142084121704,
0.11147276312112808,
0.630760669708252,
0.4037584662437439,
-0.6164421439170837,
-0.7201904654502869,
-0.015264720655977726,
-0.70843106508255,
-0.41582050919532776,
1.5592949390411377,
0.1902628242969513,
-0.22750990092754364,
-0.15143230557441711,
0.5462179183959961,
0.5618132948875427,
-0.3677210509777069,
0.9325829744338989,
0.9728408455848694,
0.22245445847511292,
-0.15728089213371277,
-0.9521299004554749,
0.4665714204311371,
0.10107145458459854,
-0.4361160695552826,
-0.2122248262166977,
0.06134561076760292,
0.7146323919296265,
0.15756253898143768,
0.9171859622001648,
-0.2483304888010025,
0.1508721113204956,
-0.32997697591781616,
0.020084794610738754,
0.3661401867866516,
-0.4713342487812042,
-0.32759809494018555,
-0.26473352313041687,
-0.25085076689720154,
-0.21281222999095917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09055v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09055v1
|
A safety realignment framework via subspace-oriented model fusion for large language models
| 2024-05-15T03:04:05 | 2024-05-15T03:04:05 |
Xin Yi, Shunfan Zheng, Linlin Wang, Xiaoling Wang, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The current safeguard mechanisms for large language models (LLMs) are indeed
susceptible to jailbreak attacks, making them inherently fragile. Even the
process of fine-tuning on apparently benign data for downstream tasks can
jeopardize safety. One potential solution is to conduct safety fine-tuning
subsequent to downstream fine-tuning. However, there's a risk of catastrophic
forgetting during safety fine-tuning, where LLMs may regain safety measures but
lose the task-specific knowledge acquired during downstream fine-tuning. In
this paper, we introduce a safety realignment framework through
subspace-oriented model fusion (SOMF), aiming to combine the safeguard
capabilities of initially aligned model and the current fine-tuned model into a
realigned model. Our approach begins by disentangling all task vectors from the
weights of each fine-tuned model. We then identify safety-related regions
within these vectors by subspace masking techniques. Finally, we explore the
fusion of the initial safely aligned LLM with all task vectors based on the
identified safety subspace. We validate that our safety realignment framework
satisfies the safety requirements of a single fine-tuned model as well as
multiple models during their fusion. Our findings confirm that SOMF preserves
safety without notably compromising performance on downstream tasks, including
instruction following in Chinese, English, and Hindi, as well as
problem-solving capabilities in Code and Math.
|
[
-0.2256302684545517,
-0.7394039034843445,
0.5667577385902405,
-0.03047936223447323,
-0.27493342757225037,
0.3788016140460968,
-0.14777186512947083,
-0.4183731973171234,
-0.24360428750514984,
0.7309938669204712,
-0.6950433254241943,
-0.49837732315063477,
-0.5122280716896057,
-0.3842344582080841,
-0.29926636815071106,
0.9124366044998169,
-0.17758280038833618,
-0.1806035041809082,
-0.012618668377399445,
0.10440011322498322,
-0.7435855269432068,
-0.6326741576194763,
-0.48302918672561646,
-0.17631250619888306,
0.4029442071914673,
0.571753203868866,
0.830941379070282,
1.0482639074325562,
0.57196444272995,
0.32664796710014343,
-0.10944736748933792,
0.07832031697034836,
-0.6890755295753479,
-0.018579961732029915,
-0.5099244117736816,
-0.44696667790412903,
-0.5697783827781677,
-0.38896122574806213,
0.6305426955223083,
0.4957655370235443,
-0.21123629808425903,
0.05980926752090454,
0.07282193005084991,
0.5646446943283081,
-0.7492818832397461,
-0.13022752106189728,
-0.6390073299407959,
0.06926580518484116,
-0.08410152047872543,
0.049294255673885345,
-0.30997225642204285,
-0.3873642086982727,
-0.16219085454940796,
-0.4134422540664673,
-0.0040322295390069485,
0.2527823746204376,
1.2146072387695312,
0.37286943197250366,
-0.25070178508758545,
0.45377588272094727,
-0.7825168967247009,
1.0399445295333862,
-0.5691952705383301,
0.32558515667915344,
0.25577640533447266,
0.42711713910102844,
-0.4327353239059448,
-0.13254165649414062,
-0.5776625275611877,
0.1307714879512787,
-0.08611978590488434,
-0.056666355580091476,
0.07597348839044571,
0.2638104557991028,
-0.015357544645667076,
-0.038041193038225174,
-0.6654704809188843,
0.534961998462677,
-0.42870229482650757,
-0.41083407402038574,
0.6765576004981995,
0.300578236579895,
0.5832227468490601,
0.02333715558052063,
-0.8534234762191772,
-0.19916966557502747,
-1.1209204196929932,
-0.16257604956626892,
0.417789489030838,
0.5409989356994629,
-0.16333894431591034,
0.14371077716350555,
-0.2605685889720917,
0.8465743064880371,
-0.14727520942687988,
-0.4466537535190582,
0.033644143491983414,
-0.39013469219207764,
-0.4103286862373352,
0.22269000113010406,
0.7363407015800476,
0.3633544445037842,
0.2559249997138977,
-0.1514120250940323,
-0.10914557427167892,
0.02794545143842697,
0.4928170442581177,
-0.39162975549697876,
0.05319959297776222,
0.24599239230155945,
-0.4875757694244385,
-0.6051328182220459,
-0.12185465544462204,
-0.5818740129470825,
-0.29693567752838135,
-0.5177883505821228,
0.5415737628936768,
-0.40660983324050903,
-0.4477810263633728,
0.29900693893432617,
0.3866788446903229,
0.1320798695087433,
-0.12966765463352203,
-0.9711549282073975,
0.016052722930908203,
1.2432048320770264,
0.5154805779457092,
0.047448355704545975,
-0.5450713634490967,
-0.42171669006347656,
0.44942671060562134,
-0.38991785049438477,
0.3077235519886017,
-0.4985129237174988,
-0.215179443359375,
0.09443562477827072,
0.1386115998029709,
-0.3062582314014435,
-0.44002094864845276,
0.4094791114330292,
-0.5461116433143616,
-0.34204307198524475,
-0.27979862689971924,
-0.17999295890331268,
-0.17188435792922974,
0.34637677669525146,
-0.3500691056251526,
0.5548078417778015,
-0.14791302382946014,
-0.5888058543205261,
0.09697368741035461,
-0.038350142538547516,
-0.44157227873802185,
-0.3372264802455902,
-0.22290314733982086,
-0.7917693257331848,
-0.163082554936409,
-0.04564817249774933,
0.48364177346229553,
-0.2517203092575073,
0.6879453063011169,
-0.2460460513830185,
-0.31507784128189087,
0.0652080550789833,
-0.14836262166500092,
0.6041705012321472,
0.28940990567207336,
-0.13047194480895996,
0.48608362674713135,
-0.6780166029930115,
-0.21268591284751892,
-0.0049189296551048756,
-0.1836724430322647,
-0.3794476389884949,
0.15089772641658783,
-0.029313882812857628,
0.44325053691864014,
0.4519541263580322,
-0.6456141471862793,
-0.02456728182733059,
-0.41360223293304443,
0.3316861093044281,
0.9823402166366577,
-0.019317470490932465,
0.46024802327156067,
-0.3317752778530121,
0.5417636036872864,
-0.018196728080511093,
0.4699086546897888,
-0.0031703291460871696,
0.0005315092275850475,
-0.860276997089386,
-0.3748489320278168,
0.30770745873451233,
0.6605476140975952,
-0.5546534061431885,
0.6939995288848877,
-0.24587257206439972,
-0.4377356469631195,
-0.3777684271335602,
0.14465691149234772,
0.9285961389541626,
0.5193907618522644,
0.22409747540950775,
-0.10625667124986649,
-0.4589103162288666,
-1.0222747325897217,
-0.05149504169821739,
-0.14427927136421204,
0.1163785308599472,
-0.15932022035121918,
0.12612983584403992,
-0.19167160987854004,
0.7408336997032166,
-0.5502614378929138,
-0.4693853259086609,
-0.2928543984889984,
-0.02229001373052597,
-0.07133614271879196,
0.8737074732780457,
0.46620917320251465,
-0.811176061630249,
-0.04321880266070366,
0.09263528883457184,
-0.654859185218811,
0.02233719639480114,
-0.2691565454006195,
-0.5420904159545898,
-0.07961159199476242,
0.897165060043335,
-0.304360955953598,
-0.007702382281422615,
0.5170007944107056,
-0.3728312849998474,
0.4736214578151703,
-0.16749237477779388,
-0.08568765223026276,
-1.025097131729126,
-0.05699892342090607,
-0.21563462913036346,
-0.27963772416114807,
-0.7698343992233276,
0.6302561163902283,
0.30376890301704407,
-0.21385636925697327,
-0.5857506394386292,
0.19889461994171143,
-0.2026381641626358,
0.2088126391172409,
-0.4031153917312622,
0.11096037179231644,
-0.29091933369636536,
0.3895055651664734,
0.03733036667108536,
0.4217173755168915,
0.677748441696167,
-0.5649077296257019,
-0.057021912187337875,
0.17409050464630127,
-0.250403493642807,
0.2499728947877884,
-0.30892807245254517,
-0.11136956512928009,
-0.26394203305244446,
-0.10540829598903656,
-0.8062534332275391,
-0.2685955762863159,
0.11311451345682144,
0.055429596453905106,
0.5702540874481201,
-0.16938501596450806,
-0.34537795186042786,
-0.03749338537454605,
-0.10347259044647217,
0.3429841995239258,
0.44132551550865173,
-0.4779805541038513,
0.7195393443107605,
0.6367315053939819,
-0.4577150046825409,
-0.8500846028327942,
-0.3495873808860779,
-0.08935296535491943,
-0.31388190388679504,
-0.6183309555053711,
0.43541809916496277,
0.3714975416660309,
-0.09125039726495743,
-0.16675390303134918,
-0.3320865035057068,
-0.025103477761149406,
0.39162105321884155,
0.5001235604286194,
0.674963653087616,
0.015746407210826874,
0.05224015936255455,
0.40728759765625,
-0.5845358967781067,
-0.050191767513751984,
-0.14060865342617035,
0.5303946733474731,
0.015381617471575737,
-0.556114673614502,
-0.10453817993402481,
0.28303027153015137,
0.6581531763076782,
-0.5018665194511414,
0.9230974316596985,
0.42791393399238586,
-0.55165696144104,
-0.02978556975722313,
-0.4695020318031311,
-0.3075219690799713,
-0.5415021777153015,
0.508415699005127,
-0.31284040212631226,
-1.3344407081604004,
0.5450578331947327,
-0.20595581829547882,
0.34582141041755676,
0.17582891881465912,
0.3473066985607147,
-0.04049026593565941,
0.9957624077796936,
1.1336978673934937,
-0.3703193664550781,
0.3483007550239563,
0.18461105227470398,
0.9414591789245605,
-0.4926031231880188,
-0.20442667603492737,
-0.497581422328949,
-0.4389810264110565,
-0.4762251377105713,
-0.32141420245170593,
0.4642688035964966,
0.22652514278888702,
-0.34151142835617065,
0.5511705875396729,
-0.36242106556892395,
0.5764994025230408,
0.3010292053222656,
0.07165665924549103,
0.19748945534229279,
-0.2530968487262726,
-0.09960558265447617,
-0.00972957443445921,
-0.6810297966003418,
-0.5815809369087219,
0.7523578405380249,
0.6820652484893799,
0.7759699821472168,
0.26219141483306885,
0.9052453637123108,
-0.27536681294441223,
-0.002534395083785057,
-0.24193300306797028,
0.8927332162857056,
-0.26601481437683105,
-0.6219868063926697,
-0.2961905896663666,
-0.27750593423843384,
-0.5161114931106567,
0.3684897720813751,
-0.44218888878822327,
-0.950444221496582,
0.27136966586112976,
0.4500141739845276,
-0.9085104465484619,
0.2777431607246399,
-0.6208457946777344,
1.0339652299880981,
-0.3399888277053833,
-0.4843822121620178,
-0.5966951251029968,
-0.8294012546539307,
0.7199878096580505,
-0.3517425060272217,
0.47649624943733215,
-0.5173228979110718,
0.4667361378669739,
0.5712560415267944,
-0.26662635803222656,
0.9610337018966675,
-0.07178683578968048,
-0.2771519422531128,
-0.05328073725104332,
0.21943950653076172,
0.49862417578697205,
-0.08600825071334839,
0.13523010909557343,
0.12299750000238419,
0.14947989583015442,
-0.20805010199546814,
-0.28168463706970215,
1.0411585569381714,
-0.5421754121780396,
-0.8572559356689453,
-0.35743123292922974,
-0.6583086848258972,
-0.26171886920928955,
0.31015250086784363,
-0.05034632235765457,
0.13995780050754547,
0.055746980011463165,
-0.04637499526143074,
0.8747080564498901,
-0.40989354252815247,
0.4127064645290375,
0.5586394667625427,
-0.242919459939003,
0.20423878729343414,
1.2973955869674683,
-0.012741385959088802,
0.5384045839309692,
0.4137265682220459,
-0.13053758442401886,
-0.02849293313920498,
-0.47306153178215027,
-0.46560660004615784,
-0.013112310320138931,
-0.562222421169281,
-0.40484005212783813,
-0.4197428524494171,
-0.3910488188266754,
-0.11766937375068665,
-0.5565458536148071,
-0.5809115767478943,
-0.21514801681041718,
-0.1336687058210373,
-0.3896600306034088,
0.12346623837947845,
0.1782771199941635,
-0.0918608009815216,
0.21050183475017548,
-0.9159879088401794,
0.30100956559181213,
0.3070234954357147,
0.42428168654441833,
-0.16446267068386078,
-0.2861310541629791,
-0.22647331655025482,
-0.1534120738506317,
-0.21480077505111694,
-0.504629373550415,
0.19036747515201569,
-0.0028480789624154568,
0.34306663274765015,
0.43194812536239624,
0.21332284808158875,
0.6551467180252075,
-0.6864109635353088,
0.5339840650558472,
0.32712870836257935,
-0.764967679977417,
0.37950238585472107,
-0.5017396807670593,
-0.0436755008995533,
0.6094111800193787,
0.146142840385437,
-0.28165024518966675,
-0.48627346754074097,
-0.2441839724779129,
-1.094723105430603,
0.5175368189811707,
-0.1839064359664917,
0.23710981011390686,
0.2583686411380768,
0.1602010428905487,
-0.005912940017879009,
0.008875730447471142,
-0.544308066368103,
-0.020611193031072617,
0.1514039784669876,
-0.42218706011772156,
0.2596941292285919,
-0.4862762987613678,
-0.44239550828933716,
-0.0497029647231102,
0.7285744547843933,
-0.0910978838801384,
0.09331165999174118,
-0.40119537711143494,
-0.014559082686901093,
-0.19180643558502197,
0.5237717032432556,
0.5913585424423218,
0.6706579327583313,
-0.2326502948999405,
0.3166731595993042,
0.19369381666183472,
-0.35496723651885986,
0.43663111329078674,
0.12897543609142303,
-0.20129604637622833,
-0.5739452242851257,
0.23826155066490173,
0.6602442264556885,
0.5982442498207092,
-0.9460292458534241,
0.18806768953800201,
0.19090111553668976,
-0.12564732134342194,
0.02226589433848858,
0.6664223670959473,
0.10552434623241425,
0.13196676969528198,
0.04266791045665741,
0.17391309142112732,
-0.24371889233589172,
-0.38771843910217285,
0.1807558834552765,
0.4396185874938965,
-0.4585942029953003,
-0.0767802894115448,
0.8305343985557556,
0.2202676236629486,
0.006827449891716242,
0.19477646052837372,
-0.059178926050662994,
-0.6977115273475647,
0.6575742363929749,
0.6319965124130249,
0.721986711025238,
-0.27529576420783997,
-0.04709449037909508,
0.3376573622226715,
0.6451545357704163,
-0.26295754313468933,
0.28040075302124023,
0.3179127275943756,
-0.8327779173851013,
-0.5088644623756409,
-0.8464194536209106,
-0.14777323603630066,
0.11808738857507706,
-0.44449442625045776,
0.14469873905181885,
-0.8118148446083069,
-0.06562796235084534,
-0.23727045953273773,
-0.6690941452980042,
-0.10793173313140869,
0.43406662344932556,
0.22183911502361298,
0.712165355682373,
-1.1975489854812622,
0.847586989402771,
0.5622444152832031,
-0.0713079497218132,
-0.9539036750793457,
0.23942413926124573,
0.2932962477207184,
-0.39217621088027954,
0.3771475851535797,
-0.04356219992041588,
-0.3329567313194275,
0.016540631651878357,
-0.32072362303733826,
-1.1868364810943604,
0.9965493083000183,
0.6746473908424377,
-1.100945234298706,
0.07255581021308899,
0.13471883535385132,
0.30716976523399353,
-0.0006235419423319399,
-0.5968711376190186,
0.8726285099983215,
0.2768319845199585,
-0.2415027767419815,
-1.1018102169036865,
0.2614579498767853,
-0.014077878557145596,
0.12430300563573837,
0.4123668372631073,
-0.8214841485023499,
0.7332204580307007,
-0.14054693281650543,
-0.22364850342273712,
-0.12018423527479172,
0.644490122795105,
0.5489184260368347,
-0.04485348239541054,
0.6223934292793274,
0.5574063062667847,
0.39489099383354187,
-0.3326707184314728,
0.6853147745132446,
-0.37184789776802063,
0.2622653841972351,
1.021691083908081,
-0.2992405593395233,
0.9430082440376282,
0.4719623327255249,
0.14694525301456451,
0.12984105944633484,
0.3868800103664398,
0.3555234670639038,
0.8611099720001221,
-0.025351952761411667,
-0.24084313213825226,
-0.6178739666938782,
-0.09000928699970245,
-0.29769688844680786,
0.46795380115509033,
0.3214193284511566,
-0.21644334495067596,
-0.09024082124233246,
0.2087683230638504,
0.3026156425476074,
0.338308721780777,
-0.24692393839359283,
0.6055026054382324,
0.04986639320850372,
-0.7910619378089905,
0.5433215498924255,
0.46333104372024536,
0.4538123607635498,
-0.5122665762901306,
0.14055529236793518,
0.08219610899686813,
0.42681586742401123,
-0.15950031578540802,
-0.6359321475028992,
0.47657158970832825,
-0.033922724425792694,
-0.15551595389842987,
-0.30625253915786743,
0.9949577450752258,
-0.634431004524231,
-0.3977912962436676,
0.3348052203655243,
-0.22611211240291595,
-0.4560965299606323,
0.3799487054347992,
-0.3745245933532715,
0.5196727514266968,
0.17163869738578796,
0.18730047345161438,
0.7231425642967224,
-0.26089900732040405,
-0.25277042388916016,
0.7488185167312622,
0.49946412444114685,
-0.1381981521844864,
0.13287921249866486,
-0.07489533722400665,
0.9842429161071777,
-0.45360705256462097,
-0.7074851989746094,
-0.847182035446167,
0.6504443883895874,
0.08190733194351196,
-0.01082573551684618,
0.5858901739120483,
0.24334800243377686,
0.887710452079773,
-0.13379651308059692,
0.8985726833343506,
-0.03229573369026184,
0.4504640996456146,
-0.8013924956321716,
1.0436455011367798,
-0.41330572962760925,
0.23168174922466278,
-0.436402827501297,
-0.6240969896316528,
-0.46544307470321655,
0.723694384098053,
-0.49486207962036133,
-0.348820298910141,
0.27983272075653076,
1.1513150930404663,
-0.25053897500038147,
-0.12989139556884766,
0.3365098834037781,
0.11655667424201965,
0.4129871726036072,
0.6606925129890442,
0.49463945627212524,
-0.25653502345085144,
0.23150791227817535,
-0.3205348551273346,
-0.3029857277870178,
-0.387240469455719,
-0.9093943238258362,
-0.7627980709075928,
-0.5036047101020813,
-0.48084011673927307,
-0.11463350057601929,
0.26216232776641846,
0.829360842704773,
0.7731423377990723,
-0.9836758971214294,
0.07532209157943726,
-0.044773247092962265,
0.16339321434497833,
-0.3708867132663727,
-0.11689995974302292,
0.3436134159564972,
-0.23409615457057953,
-0.5033315420150757,
0.6535752415657043,
0.6993343234062195,
-0.2492624968290329,
-0.21016427874565125,
-0.13847161829471588,
-0.19764557480812073,
-0.030411452054977417,
0.19648830592632294,
0.5362601280212402,
-0.6875418424606323,
-0.6602797508239746,
-0.17872406542301178,
-0.2030680775642395,
-0.3934101462364197,
0.5441746711730957,
-0.26543936133384705,
0.5767777562141418,
0.45293447375297546,
0.7994468212127686,
-0.0350094772875309,
0.14664524793624878,
0.8405023813247681,
-0.9137458205223083,
0.44807833433151245,
-0.14371676743030548,
0.4108324944972992,
0.18485108017921448,
-0.46942806243896484,
0.2085721641778946,
-0.1549994945526123,
-0.40898486971855164,
-0.9470838308334351,
0.5115967988967896,
-0.761187732219696,
-0.22109389305114746,
0.8944568634033203,
-0.2133086770772934,
-0.14312644302845,
-0.3447033166885376,
-0.344833105802536,
0.3428812623023987,
0.18935079872608185,
0.9677014946937561,
0.48471924662590027,
0.2501745820045471,
-0.2190021276473999,
-0.3471584618091583,
0.5684337019920349,
0.7093034982681274,
-0.7100763320922852,
0.27636951208114624,
0.29892924427986145,
0.28313612937927246,
0.23575538396835327,
0.2532334327697754,
-0.1671629250049591,
0.38914188742637634,
-0.3121039569377899,
0.09521336853504181,
-0.1143677830696106,
-0.5638925433158875,
-0.27763524651527405,
0.19977176189422607,
0.15614773333072662,
-0.4125775098800659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09017v1
|
A Japanese-Chinese Parallel Corpus Using Crowdsourcing for Web Mining
| 2024-05-15T00:54:40 | 2024-05-15T00:54:40 |
Masaaki Nagata, Makoto Morishita, Katsuki Chousa, Norihito Yasuda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Using crowdsourcing, we collected more than 10,000 URL pairs (parallel top
page pairs) of bilingual websites that contain parallel documents and created a
Japanese-Chinese parallel corpus of 4.6M sentence pairs from these websites. We
used a Japanese-Chinese bilingual dictionary of 160K word pairs for document
and sentence alignment. We then used high-quality 1.2M Japanese-Chinese
sentence pairs to train a parallel corpus filter based on statistical language
models and word translation probabilities. We compared the translation accuracy
of the model trained on these 4.6M sentence pairs with that of the model
trained on Japanese-Chinese sentence pairs from CCMatrix (12.4M), a parallel
corpus from global web mining. Although our corpus is only one-third the size
of CCMatrix, we found that the accuracy of the two models was comparable and
confirmed that it is feasible to use crowdsourcing for web mining of parallel
data.
|
[
-0.4243106544017792,
-0.23117749392986298,
0.6046562790870667,
0.44669586420059204,
-0.1826869547367096,
0.12577055394649506,
-0.41107723116874695,
-0.631365954875946,
0.2616146206855774,
0.5104905366897583,
-0.5688389539718628,
-0.7022234201431274,
-0.4586910903453827,
0.5796075463294983,
-0.34750255942344666,
0.773840069770813,
-0.07492562383413315,
0.40582039952278137,
-0.4078601598739624,
-0.24384571611881256,
0.08688993006944656,
-0.5271446704864502,
-0.5389238595962524,
0.04995639994740486,
0.5922866463661194,
0.42322471737861633,
0.9603341221809387,
0.8297321796417236,
0.8030836582183838,
0.3421747386455536,
0.5163517594337463,
0.25891056656837463,
-0.39328643679618835,
-0.3177393674850464,
-0.36146706342697144,
-0.7359108328819275,
-0.28551897406578064,
0.1440608650445938,
0.4711345434188843,
0.8677412867546082,
-0.22338947653770447,
0.2271801084280014,
0.021037984639406204,
0.5068053603172302,
-0.4424089789390564,
0.1945645958185196,
-0.6390106678009033,
0.030939655378460884,
-0.9048831462860107,
0.12402058392763138,
-0.21107593178749084,
-0.291630357503891,
-0.3930964767932892,
-1.2102689743041992,
0.6766474843025208,
0.24571794271469116,
1.019706130027771,
0.0847272276878357,
0.07545725256204605,
-0.007219721097499132,
0.026850448921322823,
0.8792847990989685,
-0.540828287601471,
0.3248767554759979,
0.9744558930397034,
0.2037980854511261,
0.0787447988986969,
-0.7345362305641174,
-0.7234282493591309,
-0.20378224551677704,
-0.3022667467594147,
0.21336199343204498,
0.19048522412776947,
-0.04620528221130371,
0.3672735095024109,
0.17176416516304016,
-0.9435137510299683,
0.5037668347358704,
-0.3696672320365906,
-0.2784648537635803,
0.6420708298683167,
0.30432483553886414,
0.6547623872756958,
-0.30115342140197754,
-0.251147598028183,
-0.2126816064119339,
-0.4047054648399353,
-0.2184467613697052,
0.6843106746673584,
0.5263314843177795,
-0.1876097470521927,
0.5178403258323669,
-0.6118612885475159,
0.5695661306381226,
-0.16733644902706146,
-0.2215675711631775,
0.11138013750314713,
-0.44201427698135376,
0.16910748183727264,
-0.028166117146611214,
1.1656084060668945,
0.6886612772941589,
0.5442990660667419,
-0.38228875398635864,
0.10830511897802353,
0.11118897050619125,
0.2528689205646515,
-0.7344759702682495,
-0.40641099214553833,
0.05670192837715149,
-0.722955584526062,
-0.15852002799510956,
0.5193176865577698,
-0.8182448744773865,
-0.24007032811641693,
-0.20309565961360931,
-0.1384337842464447,
-0.18424957990646362,
-0.3718712627887726,
0.04104353487491608,
-0.514218807220459,
-0.17095138132572174,
-0.02236444503068924,
-0.7982008457183838,
0.5070456266403198,
0.8280945420265198,
1.1778709888458252,
-0.33190372586250305,
-0.6398889422416687,
-0.3559803366661072,
0.1545715034008026,
-0.037967413663864136,
0.6711806654930115,
-0.3399440348148346,
-0.3998473286628723,
0.06378193944692612,
0.016963796690106392,
-0.0415613017976284,
-0.5931826829910278,
0.606200635433197,
-0.4909384548664093,
0.018742181360721588,
-0.3438616693019867,
-0.4344603419303894,
0.06895337253808975,
0.14408756792545319,
-1.030256748199463,
0.5031805038452148,
-0.19585053622722626,
-0.9748113751411438,
0.15993252396583557,
-0.3618171811103821,
-0.3632694184780121,
0.36630403995513916,
-0.03314319625496864,
-0.2533295750617981,
-0.21337471902370453,
0.6103469729423523,
0.33908283710479736,
-0.4311743378639221,
0.11223619431257248,
-0.7202948331832886,
-0.25456488132476807,
0.29768282175064087,
-0.2594819962978363,
1.1442105770111084,
0.43613961338996887,
0.07817944884300232,
-0.41191741824150085,
-0.7363355755805969,
-0.062164925038814545,
0.1347140371799469,
-0.2298949658870697,
-0.6074720025062561,
-0.013130457140505314,
0.4636891782283783,
0.1211114153265953,
0.5873113870620728,
-0.868520975112915,
0.045782867819070816,
-0.1785125881433487,
0.19102656841278076,
0.4538425803184509,
-0.17931601405143738,
0.09738365560770035,
-0.3640647530555725,
0.373097687959671,
-0.0628688782453537,
0.10848244279623032,
-0.0678161233663559,
-0.6010666489601135,
-0.6294126510620117,
-0.06440228968858719,
0.3065432012081146,
0.5385813117027283,
-0.7385899424552917,
0.3076639473438263,
-0.4991323947906494,
-0.658750057220459,
-0.820913553237915,
0.20644140243530273,
0.37327587604522705,
0.38999322056770325,
0.46241679787635803,
-0.5929592847824097,
-0.7641828656196594,
-0.8577873706817627,
-0.5286737680435181,
-0.2617788016796112,
-0.058934908360242844,
-0.08411193639039993,
0.08674473315477371,
0.10689692944288254,
1.053037166595459,
-0.4380542039871216,
-0.16898159682750702,
0.012756441719830036,
0.2650662958621979,
0.33547767996788025,
0.4801238775253296,
0.2531738579273224,
-0.9952324032783508,
-0.8474713563919067,
0.16867947578430176,
-0.8866375684738159,
-0.2984216809272766,
-0.05943060666322708,
-0.20770171284675598,
0.0184970423579216,
0.3678380250930786,
-0.5518299341201782,
0.13880160450935364,
0.48816537857055664,
0.07106602191925049,
0.3637872636318207,
-0.17917463183403015,
0.2685199975967407,
-1.3251527547836304,
0.10311061143875122,
0.43466681241989136,
-0.43571406602859497,
-0.3951181173324585,
0.43570977449417114,
0.1596408188343048,
-0.1588842123746872,
-0.19788382947444916,
0.3196847438812256,
-0.5970569849014282,
-0.02618304081261158,
-0.5442861914634705,
0.4297059178352356,
-0.09111213684082031,
0.48759520053863525,
0.1934349536895752,
0.6330405473709106,
0.24927426874637604,
-0.4036424160003662,
0.6535093784332275,
0.13755473494529724,
-0.5931291580200195,
0.5036717057228088,
-0.30500975251197815,
0.12328902631998062,
0.16006584465503693,
0.24106955528259277,
-0.8213421106338501,
-0.34467533230781555,
0.0164590235799551,
-0.585159420967102,
-0.1879095584154129,
0.06970823556184769,
-0.8013113141059875,
-0.5710479617118835,
-0.358979731798172,
0.22523002326488495,
0.3464447259902954,
-0.7978149056434631,
-0.19084139168262482,
0.5729359984397888,
-0.4348132312297821,
-0.39284592866897583,
-0.7701280117034912,
0.12132582068443298,
-0.018594566732645035,
-0.5805500149726868,
0.43134787678718567,
0.17663773894309998,
-0.3642030358314514,
0.22894878685474396,
0.2876129150390625,
-0.36961692571640015,
0.03573916107416153,
0.21037837862968445,
0.31747376918792725,
-0.19809496402740479,
-0.20404517650604248,
-0.11379743367433548,
-0.16183286905288696,
0.11363542824983597,
-0.047625113278627396,
0.7205259799957275,
0.18059617280960083,
-0.41135403513908386,
-0.7419264316558838,
0.32752886414527893,
0.3218122124671936,
-0.09450676292181015,
0.8303443789482117,
0.7761052846908569,
-0.41000664234161377,
0.23616723716259003,
-0.6469613909721375,
0.0675264224410057,
-0.40675774216651917,
0.36214011907577515,
-0.4306764602661133,
-0.6387826800346375,
0.4215031564235687,
0.12433608621358871,
0.02326659858226776,
0.6661637425422668,
0.47155213356018066,
-0.011791233904659748,
1.1593024730682373,
0.30912721157073975,
-0.8012722134590149,
0.04763065278530121,
0.0337723009288311,
-0.1548490971326828,
-0.4335252344608307,
-0.041520942002534866,
-0.7073566317558289,
-0.40102818608283997,
-0.9226146936416626,
-0.3519607484340668,
0.1037251204252243,
0.20280799269676208,
-0.1497972160577774,
0.5650849938392639,
-0.3520088493824005,
0.4467184543609619,
1.045320987701416,
0.36765697598457336,
0.5524899959564209,
0.2797486484050751,
0.07549590617418289,
-0.0800386294722557,
-0.5284550786018372,
-0.21688663959503174,
1.2699906826019287,
-0.09024420380592346,
0.24609820544719696,
0.06655631214380264,
0.7215505242347717,
0.009988936595618725,
0.19040295481681824,
-0.1436590701341629,
0.5521180033683777,
-0.5195456147193909,
-0.6086614727973938,
-0.3603169620037079,
-0.4432152509689331,
-0.9642956256866455,
0.18753349781036377,
-0.2724513113498688,
-0.3545032739639282,
-0.20305359363555908,
-0.32305359840393066,
-0.22341987490653992,
0.6208091974258423,
-0.46472179889678955,
0.7880512475967407,
-0.3046528398990631,
-0.4455050826072693,
-0.7381780743598938,
-0.488254576921463,
0.2988649010658264,
0.008998805657029152,
0.4428609609603882,
-0.1733679324388504,
-0.1459069699048996,
0.729371964931488,
-0.7703912258148193,
0.7682251930236816,
-0.15798653662204742,
0.46406814455986023,
0.1899176836013794,
-0.29113829135894775,
0.40287312865257263,
0.0022313883528113365,
-0.1172606498003006,
0.7243416905403137,
-0.16321910917758942,
-0.7840426564216614,
-0.24614381790161133,
0.8559491634368896,
-1.1251578330993652,
-0.7580916285514832,
-0.45395103096961975,
-0.5041627883911133,
-0.10970353335142136,
0.2431601881980896,
0.3325362205505371,
-0.05484272167086601,
-0.2395332008600235,
0.2299632877111435,
-0.019550949335098267,
-0.13355450332164764,
0.5053380131721497,
0.5598449110984802,
-0.13319893181324005,
-0.5307866334915161,
1.018575668334961,
0.01901574805378914,
-0.005510204471647739,
0.7811991572380066,
0.16674074530601501,
-0.23579049110412598,
-0.5097615122795105,
-0.5425484776496887,
0.3026193678379059,
-0.005127170588821173,
-0.10773473232984543,
-0.5977146625518799,
-0.22134929895401,
-0.7497748136520386,
0.1190299466252327,
-0.053930457681417465,
-0.41237738728523254,
-0.0608622282743454,
-0.15061040222644806,
0.4362546503543854,
0.32948145270347595,
-0.3435104787349701,
0.12980620563030243,
-1.1519287824630737,
0.5314562320709229,
0.0398019514977932,
0.21655668318271637,
-0.12438826262950897,
-0.10910401493310928,
-0.600681483745575,
0.19757194817066193,
-0.04478616639971733,
-0.7655525207519531,
0.5746035575866699,
-0.21838945150375366,
0.6025778651237488,
0.46121078729629517,
-0.1417098045349121,
1.0969305038452148,
-0.4526745676994324,
0.7592660188674927,
0.41942235827445984,
-0.6178955435752869,
0.32130351662635803,
-0.46589136123657227,
0.3167249262332916,
0.7629410624504089,
0.7993541955947876,
-0.7441723942756653,
-0.5547100901603699,
-0.6296497583389282,
-0.5401040315628052,
0.959472119808197,
0.24238058924674988,
-0.15746282041072845,
-0.09843046218156815,
0.30266743898391724,
0.21584217250347137,
-0.07709036767482758,
-0.6564854979515076,
-0.1261330544948578,
-0.25065404176712036,
-0.5253496170043945,
-0.253158301115036,
0.03418511152267456,
0.20624558627605438,
-0.10475162416696548,
0.5527911186218262,
0.09404020011425018,
-0.3381751477718353,
0.08035174757242203,
-0.34163805842399597,
-0.007564221974462271,
-0.18377870321273804,
-0.07896017283201218,
0.5586403608322144,
-0.023951509967446327,
-0.028804441913962364,
0.23255306482315063,
-0.6569333076477051,
-0.35729750990867615,
0.4067313075065613,
-0.25327396392822266,
0.28068599104881287,
0.3361099064350128,
0.6923542022705078,
0.0037226255517452955,
-0.9204667806625366,
0.4254242777824402,
0.2256820946931839,
-0.028881259262561798,
-0.3070063292980194,
-0.1723203808069229,
0.32729506492614746,
-0.0692390501499176,
0.0929691419005394,
-0.12676092982292175,
0.33052656054496765,
-0.34176430106163025,
0.08585575222969055,
0.09773588925600052,
-0.00786060094833374,
-0.15905970335006714,
0.7369728088378906,
0.3239096403121948,
-0.24867422878742218,
1.0041592121124268,
-0.14503289759159088,
-0.3791566789150238,
0.6865646243095398,
0.40263211727142334,
0.6917519569396973,
-0.20175239443778992,
0.3047172725200653,
0.8499612212181091,
0.06724683940410614,
-0.5152197480201721,
-0.15058694779872894,
-0.2832147479057312,
-0.8142257332801819,
-0.17626096308231354,
-0.7583173513412476,
-0.6371070146560669,
-0.19291110336780548,
-0.8911073207855225,
0.2882929742336273,
-0.2951244115829468,
0.12244649976491928,
-0.054779935628175735,
0.20173202455043793,
-0.5183223485946655,
0.14832237362861633,
0.3713808059692383,
0.6342679262161255,
-0.6853354573249817,
1.0865005254745483,
0.7209242582321167,
-0.646120548248291,
-0.6258490085601807,
-0.08010300248861313,
0.0021295465994626284,
-1.0239895582199097,
0.5265117883682251,
0.37175220251083374,
0.27522361278533936,
-0.12948599457740784,
-0.3331325352191925,
-0.9350259900093079,
1.0973916053771973,
0.2014373540878296,
-0.9887893795967102,
-0.10932162404060364,
0.666714608669281,
0.5354838371276855,
0.1481257826089859,
0.23503196239471436,
0.16066572070121765,
0.38966476917266846,
-0.5200081467628479,
-1.10928475856781,
-0.04188056290149689,
-0.4797632694244385,
0.18135523796081543,
0.08582396805286407,
-1.0014675855636597,
0.9528904557228088,
0.29123541712760925,
-0.3858546018600464,
0.30816832184791565,
0.8729787468910217,
0.5567927956581116,
0.35052454471588135,
0.7197356224060059,
0.8931850790977478,
0.8323476314544678,
0.10746748745441437,
1.0811069011688232,
-0.4628361463546753,
0.21377027034759521,
0.9169818162918091,
-0.2780366837978363,
1.0400382280349731,
0.12661121785640717,
-0.5282483100891113,
0.7513362765312195,
0.6185060739517212,
-0.2713422477245331,
0.34148427844047546,
0.04188407585024834,
-0.2314852625131607,
-0.42835965752601624,
-0.06766016781330109,
-0.12880942225456238,
0.18682920932769775,
0.22251349687576294,
-0.09928478300571442,
-0.35661596059799194,
0.10140808671712875,
0.11107716709375381,
0.7615013718605042,
-0.5371191501617432,
0.5215352177619934,
0.13404683768749237,
-1.0746127367019653,
-0.01612185686826706,
0.5481046438217163,
0.8556904792785645,
-0.3316434323787689,
0.3493773341178894,
-0.30979791283607483,
0.22285184264183044,
-0.273105263710022,
-0.6974243521690369,
0.1728857308626175,
0.486505925655365,
-0.2530691623687744,
-0.23382839560508728,
0.5986926555633545,
-0.3901185393333435,
-0.6777696013450623,
0.17296388745307922,
0.39359021186828613,
0.4415873885154724,
-0.4239276647567749,
-0.7042064070701599,
-0.27639660239219666,
0.04298114404082298,
0.07745622843503952,
0.5960037708282471,
0.2695135772228241,
-0.18818405270576477,
0.24608823657035828,
1.0624470710754395,
0.28456220030784607,
0.2431962639093399,
0.3829348385334015,
0.4291607141494751,
-0.8731798529624939,
-0.6479448080062866,
-0.9734663367271423,
0.01421304140239954,
-0.6670092344284058,
-0.14207404851913452,
0.9971320033073425,
1.1288154125213623,
1.3393391370773315,
0.09756913036108017,
1.0932930707931519,
0.07666036486625671,
0.7566693425178528,
-0.537185549736023,
0.733088493347168,
-0.3953723609447479,
-0.26565253734588623,
0.12353826314210892,
-0.7273546457290649,
-0.26339468359947205,
0.3243028223514557,
-0.010879568755626678,
-0.38126838207244873,
0.6690263152122498,
0.9830055236816406,
-0.016687307506799698,
0.32187211513519287,
0.14373718202114105,
0.2894764244556427,
-0.009653139859437943,
0.8129317164421082,
0.5487121939659119,
-0.25927814841270447,
0.7446797490119934,
-0.6475927233695984,
-0.14752565324306488,
-0.0033302432857453823,
-0.3988542854785919,
-0.6800089478492737,
-0.597774863243103,
-0.10797953605651855,
-0.14016713201999664,
-0.004422820173203945,
0.8197820782661438,
0.4490167796611786,
-0.8668975830078125,
-0.706292986869812,
-0.3509465157985687,
-0.22736863791942596,
-0.2644055187702179,
-0.19917874038219452,
0.20047174394130707,
-0.607626736164093,
-1.262578010559082,
0.22376421093940735,
0.06369572877883911,
-0.4670531749725342,
-0.33396995067596436,
0.0168248750269413,
-0.3828568458557129,
-0.49890556931495667,
0.16940182447433472,
0.2612285017967224,
-0.6368595957756042,
0.07471036911010742,
-0.015579271130263805,
-0.5226486325263977,
-0.009662432596087456,
0.7952242493629456,
-0.624711275100708,
0.39620915055274963,
0.6043380498886108,
0.5631128549575806,
0.765541136264801,
0.3002042770385742,
0.5443441867828369,
-0.5854048132896423,
0.42133593559265137,
-0.17627723515033722,
0.4379231929779053,
0.5351762175559998,
-0.11964549124240875,
0.46642130613327026,
0.6424999833106995,
-0.3173806667327881,
-0.5027698278427124,
-0.06772906333208084,
-1.150760293006897,
-0.5122987627983093,
0.953244149684906,
-0.2864016592502594,
-0.21296900510787964,
-0.14608575403690338,
-0.0010339826112613082,
0.5160905122756958,
-0.10660894215106964,
0.6993247270584106,
0.8953897953033447,
0.14856481552124023,
0.19407238066196442,
-0.25600045919418335,
0.1814045011997223,
0.15866944193840027,
-0.6530175805091858,
-0.2517417073249817,
0.2903513014316559,
0.08843053132295609,
0.3972836136817932,
0.6352634429931641,
-0.0773305743932724,
0.352546364068985,
0.2318427711725235,
0.20209191739559174,
-0.12837883830070496,
0.16738905012607574,
0.11511895805597305,
0.5472347140312195,
-0.14109432697296143,
-0.3899182975292206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.09006v1
|
Spatial Semantic Recurrent Mining for Referring Image Segmentation
| 2024-05-15T00:17:48 | 2024-05-15T00:17:48 |
Jiaxing Yang, Lihe Zhang, Jiayu Sun, Huchuan Lu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Referring Image Segmentation (RIS) consistently requires language and
appearance semantics to more understand each other. The need becomes acute
especially under hard situations. To achieve, existing works tend to resort to
various trans-representing mechanisms to directly feed forward language
semantic along main RGB branch, which however will result in referent
distribution weakly-mined in space and non-referent semantic contaminated along
channel. In this paper, we propose Spatial Semantic Recurrent Mining
(S\textsuperscript{2}RM) to achieve high-quality cross-modality fusion. It
follows a working strategy of trilogy: distributing language feature, spatial
semantic recurrent coparsing, and parsed-semantic balancing. During fusion,
S\textsuperscript{2}RM will first generate a constraint-weak yet
distribution-aware language feature, then bundle features of each row and
column from rotated features of one modality context to recurrently correlate
relevant semantic contained in feature from other modality context, and finally
resort to self-distilled weights to weigh on the contributions of different
parsed semantics. Via coparsing, S\textsuperscript{2}RM transports information
from the near and remote slice layers of generator context to the current slice
layer of parsed context, capable of better modeling global relationship
bidirectional and structured. Besides, we also propose a Cross-scale Abstract
Semantic Guided Decoder (CASG) to emphasize the foreground of the referent,
finally integrating different grained features at a comparatively low cost.
Extensive experimental results on four current challenging datasets show that
our proposed method performs favorably against other state-of-the-art
algorithms.
|
[
-0.3450663685798645,
-0.3467976748943329,
0.6116349101066589,
0.23555614054203033,
-0.511793315410614,
-0.33511826395988464,
0.09946593642234802,
-0.6018034219741821,
0.0314270555973053,
0.7188071608543396,
-0.82610684633255,
-0.7306166291236877,
-0.4555305242538452,
0.18586230278015137,
-0.3567637503147125,
0.7924965023994446,
-0.0645824745297432,
-0.0008730387198738754,
-0.18766160309314728,
-0.6035049557685852,
-0.6948961019515991,
-0.13548116385936737,
-0.23993869125843048,
-0.4151838421821594,
0.40889427065849304,
0.3949931859970093,
0.8246282935142517,
0.9023285508155823,
0.4927065670490265,
0.36156269907951355,
0.15784677863121033,
0.28183814883232117,
-0.17994336783885956,
0.4004378318786621,
-0.5370195508003235,
-0.26653149724006653,
0.0868053287267685,
-0.48980340361595154,
0.7951228618621826,
0.6371203064918518,
-0.09562364220619202,
-0.20898090302944183,
-0.31716644763946533,
0.6013181805610657,
-0.48413172364234924,
0.14148716628551483,
-0.7750228643417358,
0.10742490738630295,
-0.23687432706356049,
-0.3250722289085388,
-0.20294450223445892,
-0.030482690781354904,
0.30521270632743835,
-0.5652338266372681,
0.30995792150497437,
0.23444496095180511,
1.102016568183899,
0.39518052339553833,
-0.07019079476594925,
-0.11738023161888123,
-0.5093668103218079,
0.8529789447784424,
-0.23746468126773834,
0.3675403892993927,
0.3398893177509308,
0.2958802878856659,
0.025056112557649612,
-0.6887872219085693,
-0.32275769114494324,
-0.05450010299682617,
-0.38583090901374817,
-0.10138004273176193,
-0.3254321813583374,
-0.38059061765670776,
0.05094952881336212,
0.2659350633621216,
-0.5254307985305786,
-0.22009363770484924,
-0.3040788471698761,
-0.1659979522228241,
0.16721804440021515,
0.2976015508174896,
0.22462324798107147,
-0.3091054856777191,
-1.027908444404602,
-0.107476145029068,
-0.7451942563056946,
-0.6202102899551392,
-0.09576697647571564,
0.32203468680381775,
-0.16292518377304077,
0.5303162932395935,
-0.027104483917355537,
0.7069205045700073,
0.24488364160060883,
0.06482232362031937,
0.21811485290527344,
-0.7125675678253174,
0.04340895637869835,
-0.028123043477535248,
0.6865952014923096,
0.4144299626350403,
0.22216938436031342,
-0.1476079374551773,
-0.10200662165880203,
-0.1130794808268547,
0.16533896327018738,
-0.3871926963329315,
-0.2978516221046448,
-0.3613381087779999,
-0.2627888023853302,
0.2452530860900879,
0.01925196871161461,
-0.7399911284446716,
-0.2916402816772461,
-0.32424652576446533,
0.19155074656009674,
-0.8393450379371643,
-0.22780132293701172,
0.15999718010425568,
-0.07756183296442032,
0.5157710909843445,
0.14460521936416626,
-0.9779077172279358,
0.09550528228282928,
0.5854183435440063,
0.823067307472229,
-0.12261604517698288,
-0.47759437561035156,
0.009740022011101246,
0.49997806549072266,
0.14948135614395142,
1.2953404188156128,
-0.6028355956077576,
-0.5111899971961975,
-0.10357792675495148,
0.09815562516450882,
-0.10087917000055313,
-0.8301772475242615,
0.08038559556007385,
-0.4184907078742981,
0.18399156630039215,
-0.09272228926420212,
-0.09449177235364914,
-0.028164494782686234,
0.24531641602516174,
-0.591925859451294,
1.074214220046997,
0.373874306678772,
-0.7381433248519897,
0.4551280736923218,
-0.3169426918029785,
-0.5038300156593323,
0.02956341952085495,
-0.253559947013855,
-0.5701169371604919,
-0.36228621006011963,
0.39467379450798035,
0.3869003355503082,
-0.30339106917381287,
0.1566011756658554,
-0.3052593469619751,
-0.031254515051841736,
0.0879925787448883,
0.13298077881336212,
0.16965626180171967,
0.43471306562423706,
-0.22667880356311798,
0.24999207258224487,
-0.5111585855484009,
-0.009650680236518383,
0.11085429787635803,
0.1824108213186264,
-0.6180701851844788,
-0.030139857903122902,
0.1294161081314087,
0.20780867338180542,
0.27211207151412964,
-0.4378242492675781,
-0.2477312535047531,
-0.4580727815628052,
0.2553514242172241,
0.43518751859664917,
0.3912302255630493,
0.6221778392791748,
-0.2935847342014313,
0.05647514760494232,
0.3196055293083191,
-0.10913703590631485,
-0.41322118043899536,
-0.25945132970809937,
-0.6171562075614929,
-0.4323700964450836,
-0.10684572905302048,
0.42612335085868835,
-0.854517936706543,
0.8521575927734375,
-0.6025825142860413,
-0.3587936460971832,
-0.22010304033756256,
0.05599002540111542,
0.42717310786247253,
0.4449786841869354,
0.4744020700454712,
-0.24455250799655914,
-0.7096485495567322,
-1.2176941633224487,
0.20060229301452637,
0.0664319097995758,
-0.0886281207203865,
0.310239315032959,
0.14355415105819702,
-0.48839065432548523,
1.2550181150436401,
-0.7662572264671326,
-0.4929249584674835,
-0.43930473923683167,
0.16615566611289978,
-0.05443136394023895,
0.43743038177490234,
0.5109859108924866,
-0.6816211938858032,
-0.33372578024864197,
0.20671358704566956,
-0.6577959060668945,
-0.20962992310523987,
-0.1344045251607895,
-0.310336172580719,
0.16216422617435455,
0.45257508754730225,
-0.3815246820449829,
0.17853695154190063,
0.24505138397216797,
-0.40654417872428894,
0.01896185427904129,
-0.1015026792883873,
0.11932229995727539,
-1.2027335166931152,
0.11047820746898651,
0.32361531257629395,
-0.16232599318027496,
-0.34298306703567505,
0.08677998185157776,
-0.26879173517227173,
-0.3279736638069153,
-0.42967888712882996,
0.23676227033138275,
-0.4517024755477905,
-0.4539068341255188,
-0.33869388699531555,
0.1229182779788971,
-0.08245555311441422,
0.659952700138092,
0.6724409461021423,
0.49358558654785156,
0.45161542296409607,
-0.3420693278312683,
0.32321691513061523,
0.2240200638771057,
-0.32856500148773193,
0.688924252986908,
-0.45672762393951416,
-0.13659846782684326,
-0.13259471952915192,
0.2502990961074829,
-1.0414294004440308,
0.24257729947566986,
0.38318881392478943,
-0.25274962186813354,
0.2089007943868637,
-0.16421343386173248,
-0.45479002594947815,
0.14165440201759338,
-0.12454625964164734,
0.7344622015953064,
0.09768874943256378,
-0.4569249451160431,
0.4498651325702667,
0.49878790974617004,
-0.08147940039634705,
-0.1816171109676361,
-0.6330353617668152,
-0.11918538063764572,
-0.29665854573249817,
-0.8776444792747498,
0.4219275414943695,
0.5420342087745667,
0.09034512937068939,
0.3630203306674957,
-0.10367348790168762,
-0.09181123226881027,
-0.46065807342529297,
0.2920449674129486,
0.2739655375480652,
-0.09614391624927521,
-0.19846457242965698,
-0.44877541065216064,
-0.6381794810295105,
-0.023186229169368744,
-0.27976781129837036,
0.6742969155311584,
-0.1498432457447052,
-0.33430561423301697,
-0.2147400975227356,
0.5579982399940491,
0.5234253406524658,
-0.041594721376895905,
0.30900469422340393,
0.741786003112793,
-0.3149760961532593,
-0.09262564033269882,
-0.3540043532848358,
-0.052732814103364944,
-0.401509165763855,
0.5978595614433289,
-0.3163984417915344,
-0.8423935174942017,
0.5345380902290344,
-0.15428803861141205,
-0.1500597447156906,
0.37761133909225464,
0.43444281816482544,
0.03988482803106308,
0.5016135573387146,
0.22933124005794525,
-0.17601719498634338,
0.5866943001747131,
-0.2868078052997589,
0.19044512510299683,
-0.8964110016822815,
-0.49940112233161926,
-0.3834982216358185,
-0.17989327013492584,
-0.4507153332233429,
-0.8338266611099243,
0.44324666261672974,
-0.43991997838020325,
-0.10159918665885925,
0.6091671586036682,
-0.4553076922893524,
0.4001610577106476,
0.34259989857673645,
0.1260577142238617,
-0.016835100948810577,
0.5638036131858826,
-0.05063840374350548,
-0.2882438600063324,
-0.6127225756645203,
0.12698903679847717,
0.42657625675201416,
0.5169438123703003,
1.118839979171753,
-0.12563174962997437,
0.59278804063797,
0.2939039468765259,
-0.02987172082066536,
-0.5904661417007446,
0.7334924340248108,
-0.04398590698838234,
-0.2651315927505493,
-0.2796759009361267,
-0.3515282869338989,
-1.0706329345703125,
0.3402041494846344,
-0.24930867552757263,
-0.3951071798801422,
0.27188631892204285,
-0.0826609656214714,
-0.23272110521793365,
0.24499258399009705,
-0.40886926651000977,
0.6210858225822449,
0.09831210970878601,
-0.5385006070137024,
-0.359634131193161,
-0.8276380896568298,
0.24092723429203033,
0.3091021776199341,
-0.09633593261241913,
-0.07900390028953552,
0.07814449816942215,
0.4478466808795929,
-0.4840753674507141,
0.7720741629600525,
-0.16634654998779297,
-0.07896602898836136,
0.48564261198043823,
0.032556843012571335,
0.36989352107048035,
-0.24273954331874847,
0.38489416241645813,
0.5715922117233276,
0.09253254532814026,
-0.21949143707752228,
-0.5803005695343018,
0.8838205933570862,
-0.6957257986068726,
-0.28392493724823,
-0.5813486576080322,
-0.42432281374931335,
-0.27493172883987427,
-0.04597973823547363,
0.29537320137023926,
0.3217010796070099,
0.07818322628736496,
0.0018373009515926242,
0.5725021958351135,
-0.05026570335030556,
0.0736502930521965,
0.3496831953525543,
0.07669392228126526,
-0.8579626083374023,
1.0346519947052002,
-0.30853983759880066,
0.13342870771884918,
0.5673165917396545,
0.0511448010802269,
-0.6220057606697083,
-0.4404600262641907,
-0.32786959409713745,
0.5973472595214844,
-0.6348246932029724,
-0.5240700244903564,
-0.3586565852165222,
-0.3535378575325012,
-0.3167998194694519,
-0.2447139322757721,
-0.3043043911457062,
-0.13736893236637115,
0.0396709106862545,
0.14397907257080078,
0.29151174426078796,
0.4883567690849304,
-0.18568004667758942,
0.22871746122837067,
-0.9228693246841431,
0.4304296374320984,
0.13577908277511597,
0.3401842415332794,
-0.1506354808807373,
-0.2646616995334625,
-0.33102715015411377,
-0.24918872117996216,
-0.130188450217247,
-0.5318034291267395,
0.2831592261791229,
-0.20138493180274963,
0.40101921558380127,
0.4045691192150116,
-0.2516880929470062,
1.0933672189712524,
-0.4503548741340637,
0.5206321477890015,
0.39098042249679565,
-0.49292686581611633,
0.5756407976150513,
-0.44200846552848816,
0.5118488073348999,
0.6028943657875061,
0.02554978057742119,
-0.6745576858520508,
-0.19612665474414825,
-0.38639163970947266,
-1.1862061023712158,
0.8891114592552185,
0.08515118807554245,
-0.2034926861524582,
-0.3589543402194977,
0.35987138748168945,
-0.013710110448300838,
-0.25732675194740295,
-0.8681550621986389,
-0.48410454392433167,
-0.07314835488796234,
-0.15183866024017334,
0.4446893632411957,
-0.41976454854011536,
-0.013666353188455105,
-0.016242770478129387,
0.46130838990211487,
0.2311394363641739,
0.4391620457172394,
0.37669941782951355,
0.00936905387789011,
-0.20219388604164124,
0.13269570469856262,
0.5453855395317078,
0.3167133629322052,
-0.14647063612937927,
0.27546367049217224,
0.12518061697483063,
-0.2832740545272827,
0.011102255433797836,
-0.09933260083198547,
-0.13843725621700287,
0.09260707348585129,
0.5291066765785217,
0.5177546143531799,
0.7613639831542969,
-0.3991929888725281,
0.3465707302093506,
0.2482369989156723,
-0.222285658121109,
-0.38213813304901123,
-0.07321351021528244,
-0.2155776470899582,
0.12176153063774109,
0.2567019760608673,
0.25946876406669617,
0.10141747444868088,
-0.5399724841117859,
0.5730369091033936,
0.45804980397224426,
-0.3910253345966339,
-0.13617371022701263,
-0.04397718608379364,
0.24741016328334808,
0.13265788555145264,
0.6446128487586975,
0.0712645947933197,
-0.3935379981994629,
0.20866455137729645,
0.855141282081604,
0.8697866201400757,
-0.13787569105625153,
-0.11513502150774002,
0.5872533321380615,
-0.018516207113862038,
0.10085110366344452,
-0.11307811737060547,
-0.3790208697319031,
-0.9000944495201111,
-0.26053154468536377,
-0.5547677874565125,
-0.1024131327867508,
-0.011794131249189377,
-0.545168936252594,
0.18392342329025269,
-0.41472500562667847,
0.07962870597839355,
-0.3566840887069702,
-0.27466580271720886,
-0.2797333002090454,
0.07186654210090637,
0.32274332642555237,
0.8022111654281616,
-0.7763132452964783,
0.7847948670387268,
0.7547600269317627,
-0.05054781585931778,
-0.38675177097320557,
-0.14861835539340973,
-0.13068647682666779,
-1.12042236328125,
0.7006545662879944,
-0.02345963567495346,
-0.5555731654167175,
-0.22058376669883728,
-0.05344965308904648,
-1.0051082372665405,
1.1394296884536743,
-0.21689161658287048,
-0.3017790615558624,
0.09457666426897049,
0.46139535307884216,
0.4211217761039734,
-0.5824976563453674,
-0.20183005928993225,
0.5609349012374878,
0.5924050807952881,
0.8816913366317749,
-0.5729126334190369,
0.26214855909347534,
-0.09931332617998123,
0.3188301622867584,
0.5935256481170654,
-0.29941922426223755,
0.3122386932373047,
-0.18699602782726288,
-0.7616652846336365,
0.3175656795501709,
0.8149095177650452,
0.3661074638366699,
0.4104224443435669,
0.7151100635528564,
0.9297544956207275,
0.035104524344205856,
-0.14708594977855682,
0.5733333826065063,
-0.2410079836845398,
0.3022218942642212,
1.1760916709899902,
-0.5283353924751282,
0.6854797005653381,
0.5871460437774658,
-0.11603991687297821,
0.7727706432342529,
0.40811118483543396,
-0.2451603263616562,
1.0869981050491333,
0.046840228140354156,
-0.4258803427219391,
-0.40950414538383484,
-0.22476491332054138,
-0.4159793555736542,
0.5261136293411255,
0.47406628727912903,
-0.3410510718822479,
-0.9702510237693787,
-0.025701677426695824,
-0.14807473123073578,
0.3035638630390167,
-0.2602306604385376,
0.9203711152076721,
-0.06166651472449303,
-0.7280965447425842,
0.32747870683670044,
0.06391456723213196,
0.5826291441917419,
-0.9803005456924438,
-0.23662491142749786,
-0.11530096083879471,
0.18914608657360077,
-0.2427075356245041,
-1.000779390335083,
0.7606924176216125,
-0.3388212025165558,
-0.24806217849254608,
-0.23697210848331451,
0.6752654910087585,
-0.719189465045929,
-0.241804838180542,
0.17256850004196167,
0.11342301219701767,
0.057668086141347885,
0.22078543901443481,
-0.6744216680526733,
0.17260664701461792,
0.04049350321292877,
0.3336757719516754,
0.41216275095939636,
0.6326229572296143,
-0.03692919388413429,
0.5455502867698669,
0.5603570342063904,
0.09352075308561325,
-0.27985140681266785,
0.022505711764097214,
0.8952140808105469,
-1.0304365158081055,
-0.4990098774433136,
-0.796648383140564,
0.24033580720424652,
0.007965216413140297,
0.03259330615401268,
0.6343578100204468,
0.6422962546348572,
0.6149489283561707,
-0.19037853181362152,
0.3697566092014313,
-0.0896153524518013,
0.26103848218917847,
-0.6450530886650085,
0.15820854902267456,
-0.08700459450483322,
0.30288100242614746,
0.001165536348707974,
-0.780932605266571,
-0.5972726345062256,
0.8411121964454651,
-0.2888452708721161,
-0.06008500978350639,
0.8468486666679382,
1.0845128297805786,
-0.04227670654654503,
-0.23092642426490784,
0.26507866382598877,
-0.14290766417980194,
-0.05786707624793053,
0.8221312165260315,
0.9617751836776733,
-0.2989179491996765,
0.6078250408172607,
-0.1486424207687378,
0.025725966319441795,
-0.07709724456071854,
-0.663966953754425,
-0.5064354538917542,
-0.8748853206634521,
-0.3930854797363281,
-0.2883932292461395,
-0.10585617274045944,
0.7052053809165955,
0.8584346771240234,
-0.4703570306301117,
-0.05704627186059952,
-0.09743135422468185,
0.23443804681301117,
-0.030176442116498947,
-0.29389140009880066,
0.236976757645607,
-0.38364896178245544,
-0.5806125402450562,
0.23638816177845,
0.7553081512451172,
-0.04098417982459068,
-0.32976675033569336,
0.08117413520812988,
-0.21494852006435394,
-0.3338043689727783,
0.4660634994506836,
0.3768642246723175,
-0.6265241503715515,
-0.5317060351371765,
-0.3266923725605011,
-0.10281160473823547,
0.14685432612895966,
1.045337438583374,
-0.8259074687957764,
0.1882416307926178,
0.37592974305152893,
0.354804664850235,
0.56801837682724,
0.2558194398880005,
0.4485211670398712,
-0.9118702411651611,
0.22392264008522034,
0.015601077117025852,
0.6530689001083374,
0.46415090560913086,
-0.2667933702468872,
0.4975142776966095,
0.3857848346233368,
-0.37556761503219604,
-0.2009793221950531,
0.49636679887771606,
-1.2760009765625,
-0.2481728047132492,
1.3512344360351562,
-0.1236330196261406,
-0.3679795563220978,
-0.3023158311843872,
-0.25227126479148865,
-0.12935934960842133,
-0.19795933365821838,
0.5861945748329163,
0.439322829246521,
-0.32351574301719666,
-0.2827109098434448,
0.44814613461494446,
0.3140279948711395,
0.2706831693649292,
-0.3900907635688782,
0.3632430136203766,
0.866896390914917,
0.5290497541427612,
0.458291620016098,
0.4685462713241577,
-0.49844759702682495,
0.2901849150657654,
0.03446927294135094,
-0.04890335723757744,
-0.16695664823055267,
-0.31193283200263977,
-0.36071351170539856,
0.2636565864086151,
-0.029113465920090675,
-0.42789143323898315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08997v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08997v2
|
LLM-Assisted Rule Based Machine Translation for Low/No-Resource Languages
| 2024-05-14T23:41:44 | 2024-05-16T16:24:58 |
Jared Coleman, Bhaskar Krishnamachari, Khalil Iskarous, Ruben Rosales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose a new paradigm for machine translation that is particularly useful
for no-resource languages (those without any publicly available bilingual or
monolingual corpora): LLM-RBMT (LLM-Assisted Rule Based Machine Translation).
Using the LLM-RBMT paradigm, we design the first language
education/revitalization-oriented machine translator for Owens Valley Paiute
(OVP), a critically endangered Indigenous American language for which there is
virtually no publicly available data. We present a detailed evaluation of the
translator's components: a rule-based sentence builder, an OVP to English
translator, and an English to OVP translator. We also discuss the potential of
the paradigm, its limitations, and the many avenues for future research that it
opens up.
|
[
-0.11350294202566147,
-0.7966482043266296,
0.5112472772598267,
0.3754240870475769,
-0.3411872684955597,
-0.15091045200824738,
-0.16000421345233917,
-0.43598514795303345,
0.1711035519838333,
0.8928603529930115,
-0.5023588538169861,
-0.6453087329864502,
-0.7125082612037659,
0.3569810390472412,
-0.5113685131072998,
0.9786620140075684,
-0.3199232816696167,
-0.03900124505162239,
0.13018542528152466,
-0.23134781420230865,
-0.46909621357917786,
-0.19987809658050537,
-0.5541990995407104,
-0.30620548129081726,
0.4944505989551544,
0.6639091372489929,
0.7466336488723755,
1.3460296392440796,
0.7529212236404419,
0.2420591562986374,
0.030821753665804863,
0.21523387730121613,
-0.3444092869758606,
-0.097655288875103,
-0.05601344630122185,
-0.48709869384765625,
-0.9308993220329285,
-0.0966179296374321,
0.7418718934059143,
0.792604923248291,
-0.014847864396870136,
0.2974287271499634,
-0.13708649575710297,
0.6244361400604248,
-0.4864223599433899,
0.2074514925479889,
-0.7442514300346375,
0.33516132831573486,
-0.36682379245758057,
-0.652418851852417,
-0.3658076226711273,
-0.6361050605773926,
0.0058967117220163345,
-0.4859045743942261,
-0.16501981019973755,
0.1462046056985855,
0.36246034502983093,
0.5449005961418152,
-0.7730146646499634,
-0.0714520588517189,
-0.785638689994812,
0.9178816676139832,
-0.5762127637863159,
0.3111874461174011,
0.5420613884925842,
0.15772248804569244,
-0.40706419944763184,
-0.6327365040779114,
-0.5588924884796143,
-0.2019416093826294,
-0.20186865329742432,
-0.02587983012199402,
-0.11160150170326233,
0.16194762289524078,
-0.0862489715218544,
0.4402877390384674,
-0.466909795999527,
0.2585684061050415,
-0.3913806974887848,
0.04883171245455742,
0.35158678889274597,
0.1959524005651474,
0.2644280791282654,
-0.27047738432884216,
-0.7471338510513306,
0.13450703024864197,
-0.6633719801902771,
-0.2665603756904602,
0.00787126924842596,
0.6624590158462524,
-0.17239545285701752,
0.719409704208374,
-0.3493984043598175,
0.7132108211517334,
-0.482534795999527,
-0.3993009924888611,
0.3371967077255249,
-0.284174382686615,
-0.5309842228889465,
0.1364087611436844,
0.7460087537765503,
0.2662874162197113,
-0.2863723337650299,
-0.24535006284713745,
-0.4270488917827606,
-0.1949416697025299,
0.03798031061887741,
-0.7057994604110718,
0.219319149851799,
-0.02297000028192997,
-0.7312278151512146,
-0.2327936440706253,
-0.3321225047111511,
-0.728752076625824,
-0.3523140251636505,
-0.24478839337825775,
0.4348641037940979,
-0.4096488654613495,
-0.2159336358308792,
0.18362300097942352,
0.053623560816049576,
0.4360446035861969,
0.5351795554161072,
-0.7843096852302551,
0.3767302334308624,
0.48730844259262085,
0.8233031630516052,
0.04873059689998627,
-0.42099955677986145,
-0.5812718272209167,
-0.025344572961330414,
-0.15124177932739258,
0.5478572249412537,
-0.536345899105072,
-0.4872170090675354,
0.004268566612154245,
0.17330195009708405,
0.06038922071456909,
-0.512164294719696,
0.9232589602470398,
-0.6015456318855286,
0.1686403453350067,
0.07644756883382797,
-0.07514092326164246,
-0.311001181602478,
0.22198684513568878,
-0.34761640429496765,
0.8663656115531921,
0.24403172731399536,
-0.4277946352958679,
0.10426260530948639,
-0.7999086380004883,
-0.6484594941139221,
0.27235540747642517,
-0.011056995950639248,
-0.2972835898399353,
0.002806092845275998,
-0.12795338034629822,
0.1813170164823532,
-0.6203520894050598,
0.12378163635730743,
0.02039247564971447,
-0.30347174406051636,
-0.023368462920188904,
-0.6477844715118408,
0.8943890929222107,
0.3959335386753082,
-0.3070521056652069,
-0.05452455207705498,
-0.8333156704902649,
0.11593598127365112,
0.1921183466911316,
-0.7355406284332275,
-0.19289085268974304,
0.03306278586387634,
0.10880652070045471,
0.18269112706184387,
0.48313698172569275,
-0.4487875699996948,
0.48474910855293274,
0.01752736233174801,
0.4017373323440552,
0.743305504322052,
-0.09451262652873993,
0.635526716709137,
-0.29990068078041077,
0.6369377374649048,
-0.40017884969711304,
0.21412768959999084,
-0.2601901888847351,
-0.48865702748298645,
-1.0089384317398071,
-0.2117668241262436,
0.16346123814582825,
0.9873466491699219,
-0.8413062691688538,
0.4262550175189972,
-0.18763674795627594,
-0.2917235791683197,
-1.0137563943862915,
0.1439700424671173,
0.42925724387168884,
0.737480878829956,
0.8172947764396667,
-0.484110951423645,
-0.6410650014877319,
-1.1117879152297974,
0.13804686069488525,
-0.18284016847610474,
0.13066932559013367,
0.23296326398849487,
0.3332919776439667,
-0.6074796915054321,
0.5937915444374084,
-0.10402247309684753,
-0.5635063648223877,
-0.07650762051343918,
-0.01651857979595661,
0.19159109890460968,
0.3381088078022003,
0.29233282804489136,
-0.6074493527412415,
-0.4942077398300171,
0.5433109402656555,
-0.7788342237472534,
-0.28964313864707947,
0.022989241406321526,
-0.10943431407213211,
0.30414149165153503,
0.3968246877193451,
-0.2914145886898041,
0.22202201187610626,
0.6549092531204224,
-0.055773213505744934,
0.08689214289188385,
-0.30191799998283386,
0.3597554862499237,
-0.9645044207572937,
0.21731634438037872,
-0.19930320978164673,
-0.21635408699512482,
-0.6307017207145691,
-0.015018977224826813,
-0.000013955736903881188,
-0.09932244569063187,
-0.6609753966331482,
0.4169256389141083,
-0.2942143976688385,
-0.013399606570601463,
-0.5211758017539978,
0.3122538626194,
-0.4784456789493561,
0.3566603660583496,
0.17589586973190308,
0.6226237416267395,
0.12175654619932175,
-0.4750480353832245,
0.31192222237586975,
0.3452952802181244,
-0.11010908335447311,
0.5856863260269165,
-0.3320569396018982,
0.2492714375257492,
-0.0375567264854908,
-0.11507200449705124,
-0.28825560212135315,
-0.07704387605190277,
0.562379777431488,
-0.3736271262168884,
0.3877454102039337,
-0.49709126353263855,
-0.38311564922332764,
-0.05823688209056854,
-0.17063750326633453,
0.2790096402168274,
0.7748376727104187,
-0.43086695671081543,
0.1871550977230072,
0.3897245526313782,
-0.3484417200088501,
-0.6592448353767395,
-0.8306769132614136,
0.25518596172332764,
-0.14549502730369568,
-0.49793511629104614,
0.13489244878292084,
0.04121794551610947,
-0.2445966601371765,
0.2990637421607971,
0.1171254813671112,
-0.37403833866119385,
0.27496159076690674,
-0.03144082799553871,
0.4124598503112793,
-0.5091774463653564,
-0.12351780384778976,
0.04429982602596283,
-0.16740275919437408,
-0.18233606219291687,
-0.5358700156211853,
0.4261280596256256,
-0.3563392162322998,
-0.06494645029306412,
-0.5505605936050415,
0.410440057516098,
0.5215729475021362,
-0.4167972207069397,
0.7646026611328125,
0.3930557668209076,
-0.191228449344635,
-0.24894343316555023,
-0.20391955971717834,
0.11641712486743927,
-0.42770251631736755,
0.4585748016834259,
-0.11227723956108093,
-1.01881742477417,
0.036323320120573044,
-0.27596670389175415,
-0.027036510407924652,
0.28943726420402527,
0.6192044019699097,
0.17915208637714386,
0.45111992955207825,
0.9523162841796875,
-0.05436728149652481,
0.6270329356193542,
0.09199511259794235,
0.1605348289012909,
-0.8559353947639465,
-0.21591337025165558,
-0.5550276041030884,
-0.2665618658065796,
-0.9011942744255066,
-0.5772753357887268,
0.29775744676589966,
0.05745121091604233,
-0.06899874657392502,
0.7457590103149414,
-0.5424142479896545,
0.3568655252456665,
0.7297770977020264,
-0.07738175243139267,
0.6520029306411743,
-0.013022341765463352,
0.22878111898899078,
0.07772858440876007,
-0.6972253918647766,
-1.0068572759628296,
1.102502465248108,
0.3606376349925995,
0.45608392357826233,
0.08770531415939331,
0.7984758615493774,
0.4336097836494446,
0.527681827545166,
-0.8417010307312012,
0.6487746834754944,
-0.17238199710845947,
-0.48586505651474,
-0.4529142677783966,
-0.6507633924484253,
-1.0068373680114746,
0.3963368833065033,
-0.5412117838859558,
-0.4107009470462799,
-0.05443268641829491,
0.20348483324050903,
-0.058937132358551025,
0.49550071358680725,
-0.7063766121864319,
0.9327261447906494,
-0.5589538812637329,
-0.3643825948238373,
-0.000703027006238699,
-0.6811318397521973,
0.466202974319458,
-0.32643911242485046,
0.39282670617103577,
-0.06847212463617325,
-0.29828593134880066,
0.23657260835170746,
-0.29541462659835815,
0.6590225100517273,
0.024591095745563507,
-0.0661468505859375,
0.22511136531829834,
0.2004954218864441,
0.4791315793991089,
-0.0833480954170227,
-0.14573609828948975,
0.188016876578331,
-0.2969987392425537,
-0.4077686369419098,
-0.33509963750839233,
0.5920122265815735,
-0.8064097762107849,
-0.7409314513206482,
-0.3472011685371399,
-0.47457247972488403,
0.22960801422595978,
0.6516463160514832,
-0.094672791659832,
-0.15491732954978943,
-0.23736532032489777,
0.31923210620880127,
0.5825367569923401,
-0.29913073778152466,
0.21263012290000916,
0.9881055355072021,
-0.027752183377742767,
-0.5332625508308411,
1.006951928138733,
0.06469691544771194,
0.21130964159965515,
0.7564761638641357,
0.13190957903862,
0.07293974608182907,
-0.9654286503791809,
-0.5845984220504761,
0.10492845624685287,
-0.3977505564689636,
-0.1722416877746582,
-0.48874038457870483,
-0.1721896231174469,
-0.1752123087644577,
-0.16868682205677032,
-0.4539650082588196,
-0.5065211653709412,
-0.1795186996459961,
0.16590701043605804,
0.1869623214006424,
0.7010286450386047,
-0.04194999486207962,
0.20875558257102966,
-0.7677950263023376,
0.28301680088043213,
0.14691397547721863,
0.23204602301120758,
-0.45722293853759766,
-0.722976803779602,
-0.1801695078611374,
-0.07528714835643768,
-0.3096051514148712,
-0.5831223130226135,
0.41759955883026123,
-0.09957817941904068,
0.5030677318572998,
0.10677792131900787,
0.2263006865978241,
0.37852051854133606,
-0.8738194704055786,
0.43230438232421875,
0.20826999843120575,
-0.7496250867843628,
0.6175842881202698,
-0.3502792418003082,
-0.07795576751232147,
0.44186732172966003,
0.28470098972320557,
-1.0791921615600586,
-0.31304776668548584,
-0.18043245375156403,
-0.8775528073310852,
0.8590710163116455,
0.06425797939300537,
0.17505685985088348,
-0.2006935328245163,
0.2231028974056244,
0.3014755845069885,
0.41290614008903503,
-0.9053377509117126,
-0.3731473386287689,
-0.2855026125907898,
-0.03582175076007843,
0.11515524983406067,
-0.09856352210044861,
0.010522422380745411,
0.0966738760471344,
0.7816503643989563,
0.09732196480035782,
0.21900133788585663,
0.254543662071228,
0.0038509638980031013,
-0.343936949968338,
0.7620505690574646,
0.6425002217292786,
0.23020823299884796,
-0.38867053389549255,
0.20999054610729218,
0.2961459159851074,
-0.3297889530658722,
0.2361457496881485,
0.2865123748779297,
-0.7224171757698059,
-0.3509485125541687,
0.45159730315208435,
0.7474297881126404,
-0.038881126791238785,
-0.431270569562912,
0.2619609236717224,
0.11887919902801514,
-0.2889401912689209,
-0.351711243391037,
0.008771758526563644,
-0.14608162641525269,
0.31851914525032043,
0.2152097523212433,
0.2388153225183487,
-0.05374310538172722,
-0.6958375573158264,
0.03782561421394348,
0.3111428916454315,
-0.3758191764354706,
-0.24875567853450775,
0.763441264629364,
0.5924132466316223,
-0.750963032245636,
0.5657166838645935,
-0.2723812162876129,
-0.26683539152145386,
0.2721581757068634,
0.5188485980033875,
0.946211040019989,
-0.15297316014766693,
0.07867902517318726,
0.011510727927088737,
0.8895605206489563,
-0.04529659450054169,
0.12647776305675507,
-0.01916673220694065,
-0.5182464718818665,
-0.39513155817985535,
-0.5983291268348694,
-0.4357152283191681,
0.250507116317749,
-0.45649024844169617,
0.587011992931366,
-0.4454846978187561,
-0.09077595919370651,
-0.3827036917209625,
-0.08578937500715256,
-0.46244800090789795,
-0.09907460957765579,
0.047603096812963486,
0.9791802763938904,
-0.6480086445808411,
1.1113896369934082,
0.8447113037109375,
-0.4600942134857178,
-0.2239510715007782,
-0.12801556289196014,
-0.07695144414901733,
-1.0189130306243896,
0.6783860921859741,
-0.4025873839855194,
-0.29834502935409546,
0.25525856018066406,
-0.24156498908996582,
-0.6178833842277527,
1.378631830215454,
0.65824294090271,
-0.28884196281433105,
0.20746666193008423,
0.2626206874847412,
0.46538111567497253,
-0.1338607519865036,
-0.15127849578857422,
0.3868618905544281,
0.5991555452346802,
-0.03844272345304489,
-1.2502940893173218,
-0.1090446263551712,
-0.14674457907676697,
-0.04787982627749443,
0.5518882274627686,
-0.8321901559829712,
0.783311128616333,
-0.17084114253520966,
-0.40086284279823303,
0.27360373735427856,
0.5124311447143555,
-0.289112389087677,
0.33576810359954834,
0.09345684945583344,
0.5027522444725037,
0.6237604022026062,
0.09054556488990784,
1.103469729423523,
-0.23729835450649261,
0.18242746591567993,
1.1530306339263916,
-0.2462502419948578,
0.9956343770027161,
0.7052108645439148,
-0.27700597047805786,
0.1675553023815155,
0.34247538447380066,
0.12999211251735687,
0.4700089693069458,
0.10363767296075821,
-0.5330554246902466,
-0.06345585733652115,
-0.5666714906692505,
-0.4657800495624542,
0.49284669756889343,
0.02329178713262081,
-0.5479402542114258,
-0.1913481056690216,
-0.340276300907135,
0.22337877750396729,
0.3639237880706787,
-0.4044888913631439,
0.4523361921310425,
0.13552457094192505,
-0.2854098677635193,
0.6547595262527466,
0.5343639850616455,
0.6312317848205566,
-0.6173591613769531,
-0.2368645966053009,
-0.35970616340637207,
0.26350048184394836,
-0.27543503046035767,
-0.6000110507011414,
0.3484449088573456,
0.02807646617293358,
-0.18997521698474884,
-0.6111279726028442,
0.5133818984031677,
-0.5648177862167358,
-0.2801472842693329,
0.3245798349380493,
0.71856290102005,
0.2351500540971756,
0.5568516254425049,
-0.5283330082893372,
0.08410242199897766,
0.010076062753796577,
-0.047350991517305374,
0.36435315012931824,
0.6475609540939331,
-0.1993005871772766,
0.7619646191596985,
0.5150372385978699,
0.27417439222335815,
0.14288058876991272,
-0.4134252965450287,
0.6739474534988403,
-0.674754798412323,
-0.06520701944828033,
-0.768656313419342,
0.3226625621318817,
0.3842076063156128,
-0.18730005621910095,
0.9110609889030457,
0.632101833820343,
1.0905170440673828,
-0.15172402560710907,
0.9146854281425476,
-0.17806896567344666,
0.24188895523548126,
-0.5508133769035339,
0.658877968788147,
-0.5935820937156677,
0.21769572794437408,
-0.11003100872039795,
-0.8890799880027771,
-0.5162678360939026,
0.5776731967926025,
-0.2845056354999542,
-0.32076603174209595,
0.7720115184783936,
0.6574133038520813,
-0.03381611779332161,
-0.17787733674049377,
0.5279853343963623,
0.21382802724838257,
0.005475889891386032,
0.7077299356460571,
0.6255390644073486,
-0.38173234462738037,
0.919774055480957,
-0.10197651386260986,
-0.49174758791923523,
-0.3566444516181946,
-1.1209816932678223,
-0.6152157187461853,
-0.2719237208366394,
-0.24431101977825165,
-0.16486746072769165,
-0.11938164383172989,
1.2156199216842651,
0.5109215974807739,
-0.5384321808815002,
-0.49624496698379517,
-0.08264148235321045,
0.4897063374519348,
0.023442300036549568,
-0.13873176276683807,
0.020203029736876488,
-0.26095181703567505,
-0.812080442905426,
0.7900517582893372,
0.6912952661514282,
0.20497947931289673,
-0.18084271252155304,
-0.2858693599700928,
-0.14740459620952606,
-0.18359892070293427,
0.8338541388511658,
0.5333572030067444,
-0.5251449942588806,
-0.2342766523361206,
0.12421583384275436,
-0.18124549090862274,
0.17739784717559814,
0.7647455930709839,
-0.412494033575058,
0.4331609010696411,
0.2168809324502945,
0.9161840677261353,
0.23569272458553314,
-0.29905691742897034,
0.5366286635398865,
-0.4230033755302429,
0.40951231122016907,
0.2381652593612671,
0.26427382230758667,
0.2780761420726776,
-0.09198145568370819,
0.5768010020256042,
0.4764094054698944,
-0.4984973073005676,
-0.7536547780036926,
0.46560952067375183,
-0.7890605330467224,
0.1678563803434372,
0.940721869468689,
0.032624997198581696,
-0.45934563875198364,
-0.11098427325487137,
-0.3693029582500458,
0.16211670637130737,
-0.4206174910068512,
0.7138122916221619,
0.31802645325660706,
-0.07962329685688019,
-0.38199517130851746,
-1.008025050163269,
0.32059046626091003,
0.1509760469198227,
-0.8037868142127991,
0.04756128042936325,
0.4018792510032654,
0.0407782606780529,
0.03699116036295891,
0.9173339009284973,
-0.3176495134830475,
0.1884273737668991,
-0.09766533225774765,
0.37059473991394043,
-0.23917195200920105,
-0.09341137856245041,
-0.2436685711145401,
-0.022862089797854424,
0.48610013723373413,
-0.2474576234817505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08989v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08989v1
|
What is it for a Machine Learning Model to Have a Capability?
| 2024-05-14T23:03:52 | 2024-05-14T23:03:52 |
Jacqueline Harding, Nathaniel Sharadin
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
What can contemporary machine learning (ML) models do? Given the
proliferation of ML models in society, answering this question matters to a
variety of stakeholders, both public and private. The evaluation of models'
capabilities is rapidly emerging as a key subfield of modern ML, buoyed by
regulatory attention and government grants. Despite this, the notion of an ML
model possessing a capability has not been interrogated: what are we saying
when we say that a model is able to do something? And what sorts of evidence
bear upon this question? In this paper, we aim to answer these questions, using
the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) as a running example. Drawing
on the large philosophical literature on abilities, we develop an account of ML
models' capabilities which can be usefully applied to the nascent science of
model evaluation. Our core proposal is a conditional analysis of model
abilities (CAMA): crudely, a machine learning model has a capability to X just
when it would reliably succeed at doing X if it 'tried'. The main contribution
of the paper is making this proposal precise in the context of ML, resulting in
an operationalisation of CAMA applicable to LLMs. We then put CAMA to work,
showing that it can help make sense of various features of ML model evaluation
practice, as well as suggest procedures for performing fair inter-model
comparisons.
|
[
-0.23408731818199158,
-0.41756027936935425,
0.784019410610199,
0.09946136921644211,
-0.15510913729667664,
-0.04091288894414902,
-0.28213492035865784,
-0.5083467364311218,
-0.19038958847522736,
0.6412080526351929,
-0.37076207995414734,
0.013466646894812584,
-0.9896975159645081,
0.12702226638793945,
-0.6204225420951843,
0.8855445384979248,
0.09989463537931442,
0.3070615828037262,
-0.45668932795524597,
-0.3100604712963104,
-0.6898759007453918,
-0.7964562773704529,
-0.3871457278728485,
-0.14524762332439423,
0.5674557685852051,
0.23334448039531708,
0.875123918056488,
0.42737331986427307,
0.9041902422904968,
0.44315871596336365,
-0.11583135277032852,
0.04087581858038902,
-0.42604073882102966,
-0.012321471236646175,
-0.24784031510353088,
-0.7171841263771057,
-0.5975925326347351,
0.31038859486579895,
1.0695394277572632,
0.9624301791191101,
0.4673328995704651,
0.1924521028995514,
0.2578733563423157,
0.5843633413314819,
-0.5129731893539429,
0.14823196828365326,
-0.9668009281158447,
0.026505667716264725,
0.28585413098335266,
0.14494860172271729,
-0.2511226534843445,
-0.03975651040673256,
0.42893585562705994,
-0.24284912645816803,
0.08639629185199738,
-0.12886352837085724,
0.736128568649292,
0.43359407782554626,
-0.43819496035575867,
-0.33601924777030945,
-0.681178867816925,
0.992976188659668,
-0.6462572813034058,
0.26795119047164917,
0.39421725273132324,
0.8009099364280701,
0.11851193755865097,
-0.8652827739715576,
-0.48649197816848755,
-0.7403063774108887,
-0.1487947702407837,
-0.3087231516838074,
-0.12365979701280594,
0.03352626785635948,
0.5279924273490906,
0.41744616627693176,
-0.13589374721050262,
0.336925208568573,
-0.41918957233428955,
-0.17917566001415253,
0.6291269063949585,
0.1293342560529709,
0.20303767919540405,
-0.17216624319553375,
-0.12144939601421356,
0.13131919503211975,
-0.3861905634403229,
0.29139935970306396,
0.2822227478027344,
0.3158179223537445,
0.02397219091653824,
1.0098668336868286,
0.018221881240606308,
0.5862439870834351,
-0.4053766429424286,
-0.11384503543376923,
-0.19237151741981506,
-0.063602976500988,
-0.45154181122779846,
-0.3426608145236969,
0.3991760015487671,
-0.11354319006204605,
0.13551004230976105,
-0.28535017371177673,
-0.49656206369400024,
0.196075901389122,
0.5242382287979126,
-0.801365077495575,
-0.034642573446035385,
0.16907650232315063,
-0.7421838641166687,
-0.14786703884601593,
0.03071724995970726,
-0.34038951992988586,
-0.5320493578910828,
-0.5309363007545471,
0.8462674021720886,
-0.13918672502040863,
-0.3244342803955078,
-0.08632607012987137,
-0.44424188137054443,
0.10642530024051666,
-0.010328863747417927,
-0.5799265503883362,
0.32644569873809814,
0.946945309638977,
0.664413332939148,
-0.0035636108368635178,
-0.34525221586227417,
-0.28137513995170593,
-0.40518566966056824,
-0.21705955266952515,
0.30401381850242615,
-0.5576305389404297,
-0.3624922037124634,
-0.2519124746322632,
0.32572200894355774,
-0.020863451063632965,
-0.35729265213012695,
0.3617140054702759,
-0.5115315318107605,
-0.11006145179271698,
-0.5468144416809082,
-0.6433143019676208,
-0.5182794332504272,
0.035516899079084396,
-0.7523288130760193,
0.31896013021469116,
0.1855362355709076,
-0.6218041181564331,
0.7636138200759888,
-0.5491295456886292,
-0.28317680954933167,
0.048641689121723175,
-0.2751186192035675,
-0.7631081342697144,
0.2473835051059723,
-0.2923368811607361,
0.7057185769081116,
-0.3413241505622864,
0.4762512445449829,
-0.8658617734909058,
-0.12124448269605637,
0.7659366130828857,
-0.7480157613754272,
0.8213338255882263,
0.20922325551509857,
-0.2746962010860443,
0.24720816314220428,
-0.742437481880188,
0.14678262174129486,
-0.0493176206946373,
-0.23139774799346924,
-0.03229917958378792,
0.25213027000427246,
-0.36662882566452026,
0.16039781272411346,
0.36929652094841003,
-0.09636414796113968,
0.0629168376326561,
-0.12273193150758743,
0.6389744281768799,
0.4795924723148346,
-0.3934984803199768,
0.4488614797592163,
-0.5649054050445557,
0.5202345252037048,
-0.553082287311554,
0.11548411101102829,
-0.0363309383392334,
-0.769431471824646,
-0.9168815612792969,
-0.6625962257385254,
0.5408445596694946,
0.477369099855423,
-0.4611528813838959,
0.5379561185836792,
-0.0780397579073906,
-0.5185995101928711,
-0.7291176319122314,
0.464978963136673,
0.4701482951641083,
0.31773388385772705,
0.025663675740361214,
-0.43950819969177246,
-0.6907932162284851,
-1.061110258102417,
-0.24896027147769928,
-0.20046785473823547,
-0.08410446345806122,
0.5890450477600098,
0.6135370135307312,
-0.0010473760776221752,
0.8493754863739014,
0.25259020924568176,
0.10189539194107056,
-0.3852965533733368,
-0.02671549655497074,
0.22873960435390472,
0.28175970911979675,
0.5603634119033813,
-1.067999243736267,
0.11269508302211761,
0.059925541281700134,
-1.2828611135482788,
0.09697514027357101,
0.05026578530669212,
0.05140911787748337,
-0.00857308879494667,
0.1246628686785698,
-0.43048036098480225,
0.5500897169113159,
0.4636715352535248,
-0.36606547236442566,
0.3942078948020935,
-0.5012556314468384,
0.17872126400470734,
-0.4380587637424469,
0.3294474482536316,
-0.20392881333827972,
-0.1229046955704689,
-0.6317194104194641,
0.21896235644817352,
0.19370317459106445,
-0.3629496693611145,
-0.3764815330505371,
0.7415616512298584,
-0.14943327009677887,
-0.6411598324775696,
-0.6316118240356445,
0.005809854716062546,
-0.18598739802837372,
-0.001070470199920237,
0.12391669303178787,
0.39828792214393616,
0.5855633616447449,
-0.9554398655891418,
0.10295218974351883,
-0.24984394013881683,
-0.5299085974693298,
0.32907894253730774,
-0.5790981650352478,
-0.030524319037795067,
-0.03609166294336319,
0.03481521084904671,
-0.7277873754501343,
-0.3727835714817047,
-0.12859320640563965,
-0.4739794433116913,
0.16503039002418518,
-0.2749793231487274,
-0.166402667760849,
-0.5564383268356323,
0.1711650788784027,
0.21095120906829834,
0.4986872673034668,
-0.33840423822402954,
0.6995647549629211,
0.6096733212471008,
-0.025998160243034363,
-0.6020196676254272,
-0.5841837525367737,
0.2461874634027481,
-0.25617170333862305,
-0.8632216453552246,
0.22625403106212616,
0.0112218726426363,
-0.5295812487602234,
0.1408044397830963,
0.2716596722602844,
-0.19969527423381805,
0.7981756925582886,
0.45376846194267273,
0.4057264029979706,
-0.25986284017562866,
0.24354727566242218,
-0.15128733217716217,
-0.27464964985847473,
0.00026589835761114955,
-0.2040240615606308,
0.14868615567684174,
-0.4143542945384979,
-0.5298618078231812,
-0.39051803946495056,
-0.037239789962768555,
0.5272993445396423,
-0.20101067423820496,
0.7483248114585876,
0.4589555561542511,
-0.4904267191886902,
-0.16462913155555725,
-0.3288513123989105,
-0.23961877822875977,
-0.4132232069969177,
0.5038806796073914,
-0.5113667845726013,
-0.7069216370582581,
0.3774625062942505,
0.28339266777038574,
0.25011178851127625,
0.4698871374130249,
0.7039415836334229,
0.0005650453385896981,
0.8921024799346924,
1.0160995721817017,
-0.03243296965956688,
0.20565927028656006,
-0.4528365433216095,
0.48989546298980713,
-0.4506836533546448,
-0.27460959553718567,
-0.5155715346336365,
-0.41712290048599243,
-0.7418227791786194,
-0.38102611899375916,
0.14261963963508606,
0.2775879502296448,
-0.2730310559272766,
0.27532243728637695,
-0.14505991339683533,
0.0638708770275116,
0.43869075179100037,
0.06390971690416336,
0.23519320785999298,
-0.37983423471450806,
0.06085168570280075,
0.1717526912689209,
-0.8072330951690674,
-1.0413542985916138,
1.1228413581848145,
0.6851069331169128,
0.21376825869083405,
-0.035688214004039764,
0.18275803327560425,
0.4769878685474396,
0.7164328098297119,
-0.8875361084938049,
0.7648597955703735,
-0.28399568796157837,
-0.8269021511077881,
-0.31144097447395325,
-0.45779791474342346,
-0.7776339650154114,
0.23171402513980865,
-0.5560634136199951,
-0.46783825755119324,
0.012880817987024784,
0.17354869842529297,
-0.12031735479831696,
0.6783040165901184,
-0.7785405516624451,
0.7946257591247559,
-0.6290398240089417,
-0.18631282448768616,
-0.3530811071395874,
-0.28916457295417786,
0.49173295497894287,
-0.19174961745738983,
0.13532239198684692,
-0.29706090688705444,
-0.1252959966659546,
0.6600978374481201,
-0.22648189961910248,
0.8383359313011169,
-0.2509862780570984,
0.06764554977416992,
0.3894883990287781,
-0.013060716912150383,
-0.015377013944089413,
-0.11186628043651581,
-0.47413522005081177,
0.2944527864456177,
0.2363501340150833,
-0.4641730785369873,
-0.8000836968421936,
0.39209431409835815,
-0.6787223815917969,
-0.6772311925888062,
0.041150666773319244,
-0.4204392731189728,
-0.19896966218948364,
0.12446530908346176,
-0.09753052890300751,
0.12191131711006165,
-0.2655724287033081,
0.3935340642929077,
0.1929357945919037,
-0.27742481231689453,
0.472330778837204,
0.5813923478126526,
-0.42774972319602966,
-0.10039759427309036,
1.140575885772705,
0.4340772032737732,
0.18164817988872528,
0.09865979850292206,
0.16522763669490814,
-0.15503011643886566,
-0.5861771702766418,
-0.35237592458724976,
0.009300990961492062,
-0.9476070404052734,
0.09369269013404846,
-0.5028320550918579,
-0.5466390252113342,
-0.19905292987823486,
-0.1324382722377777,
-0.14611423015594482,
-0.5467197895050049,
-0.2192830741405487,
0.005363720469176769,
0.13328634202480316,
0.8953987956047058,
-0.061073970049619675,
0.08244088292121887,
-0.4290962517261505,
0.30094292759895325,
0.6025965809822083,
0.1499796062707901,
0.08968573063611984,
-0.7140515446662903,
-0.05837903544306755,
0.008286729454994202,
-0.2970776855945587,
-0.48265230655670166,
0.3400973975658417,
0.04029860347509384,
0.881291389465332,
0.4652544856071472,
-0.14649617671966553,
0.17606262862682343,
-0.207225039601326,
0.5931851863861084,
-0.0835602805018425,
-0.8122273683547974,
0.2611478269100189,
0.058995455503463745,
-0.31617340445518494,
0.2349444478750229,
0.5843838453292847,
-0.07741528749465942,
-0.5229904055595398,
-0.6481208801269531,
-0.3131014108657837,
0.1271357387304306,
0.2655109465122223,
0.40359726548194885,
0.3183099329471588,
0.35147425532341003,
0.4568868577480316,
0.324062317609787,
-0.8771376013755798,
0.1049640029668808,
-0.22661492228507996,
0.11997669190168381,
-0.34436917304992676,
-0.3120172917842865,
0.0435139462351799,
-0.28289395570755005,
0.5789036154747009,
-0.0437503308057785,
0.2360653579235077,
-0.20465372502803802,
-0.19612126052379608,
0.2888704240322113,
0.38094931840896606,
0.09158779680728912,
1.0390795469284058,
-0.19084185361862183,
0.13131976127624512,
0.2432052493095398,
-0.0009068550425581634,
0.05427585914731026,
0.14907076954841614,
-0.12159743160009384,
-0.4278077185153961,
0.5086755156517029,
0.7914252281188965,
0.0892833024263382,
-0.7152854204177856,
0.3605155646800995,
0.05778844654560089,
-0.23257645964622498,
-0.02525494620203972,
0.3930146098136902,
-0.21655014157295227,
0.3280850350856781,
0.35061272978782654,
0.01455513946712017,
0.0013537406921386719,
-0.7545536160469055,
0.2527601420879364,
0.7080118060112,
-0.4591173827648163,
-0.18803361058235168,
0.31913137435913086,
0.02552313543856144,
-0.7011582851409912,
0.460010290145874,
-0.2145799696445465,
-0.731563925743103,
0.9787859320640564,
0.2972944974899292,
0.8020750880241394,
0.12890870869159698,
0.03496399521827698,
0.012066410854458809,
0.4572397768497467,
0.12986212968826294,
0.29069215059280396,
0.005169690120965242,
-0.6711542010307312,
-0.3593742847442627,
-0.7212033867835999,
-0.5144926309585571,
0.25719180703163147,
-0.3672507405281067,
0.42057153582572937,
-0.5241400599479675,
-0.5271632075309753,
0.16883373260498047,
0.2371034175157547,
-0.892104983329773,
0.3787657618522644,
0.052953630685806274,
0.6717109680175781,
-0.6271184086799622,
0.8671031594276428,
0.21957583725452423,
-0.27279138565063477,
-0.45144373178482056,
-0.40868574380874634,
-0.1061793640255928,
-0.9027448296546936,
0.8517647385597229,
0.5031453371047974,
-0.17638783156871796,
-0.38713183999061584,
-0.4428645968437195,
-0.49799633026123047,
0.9262194037437439,
0.5342115163803101,
-0.4692683815956116,
0.08769798278808594,
-0.047199420630931854,
0.5072769522666931,
-0.649115800857544,
0.19742891192436218,
0.673272967338562,
0.5955740213394165,
-0.30324724316596985,
-1.117817759513855,
-0.16630001366138458,
-0.165950208902359,
-0.08079918473958969,
-0.3654894232749939,
-0.34520813822746277,
0.7249460220336914,
-0.4703517556190491,
-0.11122865974903107,
0.5109996199607849,
0.825356125831604,
0.004371549002826214,
0.6518736481666565,
0.5603666305541992,
0.3541429936885834,
1.0600796937942505,
0.14242368936538696,
1.3995622396469116,
-0.337089478969574,
0.1151805892586708,
0.7766677141189575,
-0.21035712957382202,
0.9024200439453125,
0.044116128236055374,
-0.2579789459705353,
0.20936934649944305,
0.5956293940544128,
-0.2061712145805359,
0.3311839699745178,
0.356008917093277,
-0.26530081033706665,
-0.5080314874649048,
0.06760060042142868,
-0.15141667425632477,
0.6900801658630371,
0.23619146645069122,
-0.8368728756904602,
0.30990415811538696,
0.27979347109794617,
-0.34825044870376587,
0.06562258303165436,
-0.5404798984527588,
0.4750557243824005,
0.2741122543811798,
-0.8760972619056702,
0.3355366587638855,
0.10704489797353745,
0.26861438155174255,
-0.45458683371543884,
-0.06117747351527214,
0.407920777797699,
0.20482197403907776,
0.015481325797736645,
-0.7470203042030334,
0.36991965770721436,
0.13029886782169342,
-0.345106303691864,
0.12515027821063995,
0.8475074172019958,
0.2275216281414032,
-0.9457370638847351,
0.450528085231781,
0.524353563785553,
0.4382006525993347,
0.2673308253288269,
-0.6981194615364075,
0.016287025064229965,
-0.3706066906452179,
0.3022714853286743,
0.3468737006187439,
0.30655333399772644,
0.09052260220050812,
1.063795804977417,
0.3206613063812256,
0.16802023351192474,
0.0031889150850474834,
-0.1668633073568344,
0.6255630850791931,
-0.558718740940094,
-0.1015777438879013,
-0.8372563719749451,
0.37372279167175293,
0.05515187978744507,
-0.16236965358257294,
0.7022538185119629,
0.30128782987594604,
0.6149498224258423,
0.308284193277359,
1.155341386795044,
-0.15691684186458588,
0.375000536441803,
-0.7053263187408447,
0.8338313102722168,
-0.5796529650688171,
0.6147934794425964,
0.04601001739501953,
-0.6288590431213379,
-0.12959516048431396,
0.6704955697059631,
-0.8075673580169678,
0.35204020142555237,
0.30975043773651123,
0.721575915813446,
-0.1144496351480484,
0.15083172917366028,
0.8123566508293152,
0.031359121203422546,
0.2527351379394531,
0.2916805148124695,
1.132818341255188,
0.0347738154232502,
0.24170254170894623,
-0.29914945363998413,
-0.38448548316955566,
-0.20442645251750946,
-1.1538187265396118,
-1.1361075639724731,
-0.7277761101722717,
0.11013743281364441,
-0.4586782157421112,
0.07793544977903366,
0.5445994138717651,
0.9238168001174927,
-0.6535606384277344,
-0.2732771933078766,
0.13917367160320282,
0.4157577455043793,
-0.07101017236709595,
-0.08495829254388809,
0.2876303493976593,
-0.6514564752578735,
-0.43004703521728516,
0.42819494009017944,
0.21176469326019287,
0.019559966400265694,
-0.8226775527000427,
-0.22459657490253448,
0.4278663992881775,
0.13369005918502808,
0.5961145162582397,
0.42116716504096985,
-0.6727340817451477,
-0.1184060201048851,
-0.2520759701728821,
0.09434857964515686,
-0.2690490782260895,
1.0552738904953003,
-0.7447046041488647,
0.5635987520217896,
0.16583587229251862,
1.0230404138565063,
0.18298117816448212,
-0.6675193905830383,
0.5679646730422974,
-0.06636175513267517,
0.13769181072711945,
0.3033430874347687,
0.5984619855880737,
0.31601160764694214,
-0.0011326017556712031,
0.30402907729148865,
0.0746525228023529,
-0.6454313397407532,
-0.8244081139564514,
0.10580175369977951,
-0.6864068508148193,
-0.6026780009269714,
0.9401676654815674,
-0.44743403792381287,
-0.15577468276023865,
-0.16340415179729462,
-0.02101203240454197,
0.17085382342338562,
0.2729838788509369,
0.9110257029533386,
0.6448607444763184,
0.04739607125520706,
0.20488804578781128,
-0.9384317994117737,
0.3316313624382019,
0.43367800116539,
-0.5782477259635925,
-0.08286789059638977,
0.13874652981758118,
0.21863093972206116,
-0.11282029747962952,
0.35471686720848083,
0.092330701649189,
0.4207312762737274,
-0.07261855900287628,
-0.4054897725582123,
-0.0332532674074173,
-0.6559866666793823,
-0.47224098443984985,
0.2147744745016098,
0.40742236375808716,
0.15692058205604553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08944v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08944v1
|
Challenges in Deploying Long-Context Transformers: A Theoretical Peak Performance Analysis
| 2024-05-14T20:17:22 | 2024-05-14T20:17:22 |
Yao Fu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DC
|
Transformer-based long context generative models power emerging AI
applications like hour-long video understanding and project-level coding agent.
Deploying long context transformers (e.g., 100K to 10M tokens) is prohibitively
expensive compared to short context (e.g., 4K tokens) model variants. Reducing
the cost of long-context transformers is becoming a pressing research and
engineering challenge starting from the year of 2024. This work describes a
concurrent programming framework for quantitatively analyzing the efficiency
challenges in serving multiple long-context requests under limited size of GPU
high-bandwidth memory (HBM) regime. We give a detailed analysis of how all
additional computational costs, compared to 4K context, trace back to
\textit{one single source: the large size of the KV cache}. We use a 34B
GPT-3.5 level model of 50K context on A100 NVLink as a running example, and
describe how its large KV cache causes four types of deployment challenges: (1)
prefilling long inputs takes much longer compute time and GPU memory than short
inputs; (2) after prefilling, the large KV cache residing on the GPU HBM
substantially restricts the number of concurrent users being served; (3) during
decoding, repeatedly reading the KV cache from HBM to SM largely increases
latency; (4) when KV cache memory overflows, swapping it from HBM to DDR causes
significant context switching latency. We use this framework to analyze
existing works and identify possibilities of combining them to build end-to-end
systems. Overall, this work offers a foundational framework for analyzing long
context transformer deployment and identifies directions towards reducing the
inference cost of 1M context to be as cheap as 4K.
|
[
-0.8586515784263611,
-0.7544569373130798,
0.43090662360191345,
0.7198255062103271,
-0.1473514437675476,
-0.21938073635101318,
-0.2632395327091217,
-0.5802794694900513,
-0.37653622031211853,
0.6304274797439575,
-0.5702459812164307,
0.10034575313329697,
-0.32965585589408875,
0.11097344011068344,
-0.39992794394493103,
0.7238278388977051,
-0.27126559615135193,
-0.6743796467781067,
-0.283587247133255,
-0.15359514951705933,
-0.7885289192199707,
-0.4636395275592804,
-0.4913695156574249,
-0.10072826594114304,
0.306705117225647,
0.2779174745082855,
0.5940409898757935,
0.32931581139564514,
0.7180867195129395,
0.3095327317714691,
0.031434524804353714,
-0.188241645693779,
-0.6679181456565857,
0.25460493564605713,
-0.07960541546344757,
-0.13942229747772217,
-0.4916825294494629,
-0.1704235076904297,
0.8579081892967224,
0.4203869104385376,
-0.17596407234668732,
0.20963184535503387,
0.056697383522987366,
0.645982027053833,
-0.9093529582023621,
0.17249977588653564,
-0.34205344319343567,
0.10035576671361923,
-0.5182573199272156,
-0.09733030200004578,
-0.5839201807975769,
0.2459656000137329,
0.2846405506134033,
-0.5958638191223145,
0.13639001548290253,
0.14150412380695343,
0.7711718678474426,
0.7352150082588196,
-0.5912900567054749,
-0.032774668186903,
-1.009623408317566,
1.0048842430114746,
-0.33997783064842224,
0.3996884822845459,
-0.027939757332205772,
0.7374818325042725,
-0.10910823196172714,
-0.7547042965888977,
-0.4276374280452728,
-0.1388973891735077,
-0.011342222802340984,
0.23341374099254608,
-0.21183347702026367,
0.000013843178749084473,
0.5312991738319397,
0.41528114676475525,
-0.36949917674064636,
0.028104303404688835,
-0.24722345173358917,
0.10328632593154907,
0.23361165821552277,
0.25715479254722595,
-0.1704457551240921,
-0.33093568682670593,
-0.7230704426765442,
0.06451933830976486,
-0.5841677784919739,
0.13249099254608154,
0.2823158800601959,
-0.014700834639370441,
-0.3673250675201416,
0.32053235173225403,
-0.1002454161643982,
0.494558185338974,
-0.022665053606033325,
-0.03140464797616005,
0.06478485465049744,
-0.45320984721183777,
-0.3733850419521332,
-0.27226561307907104,
0.3622976839542389,
0.37812522053718567,
-0.10341193526983261,
-0.21053917706012726,
-0.24441663920879364,
0.10452762246131897,
0.8635006546974182,
-1.02774178981781,
0.1425035446882248,
0.12234923243522644,
-0.38446804881095886,
0.06989341229200363,
-0.32954487204551697,
-1.0055829286575317,
0.08557236939668655,
-0.021427849307656288,
0.455356627702713,
-0.13141386210918427,
-0.1531922072172165,
0.08699891716241837,
-0.19756172597408295,
0.5365238785743713,
0.11335728317499161,
-0.8093083500862122,
0.43844303488731384,
0.7342446446418762,
0.8248569965362549,
-0.46117398142814636,
-0.1758323311805725,
-0.18411576747894287,
0.25889351963996887,
0.15656690299510956,
0.4547337591648102,
-0.14610730111598969,
-0.6076191663742065,
0.043977245688438416,
0.2338961362838745,
-0.1208905279636383,
-0.6201967597007751,
0.6520331501960754,
-0.6607627868652344,
-0.18906374275684357,
-0.3327086865901947,
-0.3239612579345703,
0.21067015826702118,
0.21044306457042694,
-0.7564761638641357,
1.0888441801071167,
0.6492421627044678,
-0.580705463886261,
0.2969699203968048,
-0.6979844570159912,
-0.45825472474098206,
0.34936630725860596,
-0.09952658414840698,
-0.4868229925632477,
0.13380378484725952,
-0.012963621877133846,
0.5071549415588379,
-0.6088406443595886,
0.23154723644256592,
0.21628381311893463,
-0.5671505928039551,
-0.16836164891719818,
-0.46140965819358826,
0.49354448914527893,
0.4378606379032135,
-0.7479279041290283,
0.12488630414009094,
-0.5334662795066833,
-0.28328952193260193,
0.0780133605003357,
-0.2126215249300003,
0.11523505300283432,
0.2599852979183197,
0.18247754871845245,
0.12067606300115585,
0.12394211441278458,
-0.4194831848144531,
0.31196269392967224,
0.03925471380352974,
0.567510187625885,
0.6757864356040955,
-0.2761290371417999,
0.3546971380710602,
-0.05873982608318329,
0.6285406947135925,
-0.025883352383971214,
0.6970953941345215,
-0.29349687695503235,
-0.4275539815425873,
-0.6168797612190247,
-0.19622521102428436,
-0.3146451413631439,
0.13579748570919037,
-0.7108173966407776,
0.14524883031845093,
-0.5620409846305847,
-0.1217224970459938,
-0.22007441520690918,
-0.04025469347834587,
0.2577866017818451,
0.7029145359992981,
0.6253220438957214,
-0.3360424339771271,
-0.3817812204360962,
-1.0925354957580566,
0.25641509890556335,
0.03086492419242859,
0.09090932458639145,
0.5793824791908264,
0.6224419474601746,
-0.35748493671417236,
1.013250470161438,
-0.3835708796977997,
0.01881302334368229,
0.041402265429496765,
0.0009535600547678769,
0.2557736933231354,
0.5058706998825073,
0.5214149355888367,
-0.9892917275428772,
-0.45813265442848206,
0.0290317852050066,
-0.6563472747802734,
0.06941720843315125,
-0.17554080486297607,
-0.1523205041885376,
0.22404499351978302,
0.46912097930908203,
-0.7786830067634583,
0.4589524567127228,
0.7415287494659424,
-0.016836224123835564,
0.8702898025512695,
-0.1320662945508957,
0.11099570244550705,
-0.9044222235679626,
0.2607269287109375,
-0.06748352199792862,
0.08879929780960083,
-0.3515605032444,
0.4087768495082855,
0.1281987428665161,
-0.2645821273326874,
-0.4865844249725342,
0.2277539223432541,
-0.2667660713195801,
-0.005305627826601267,
-0.2834196388721466,
-0.3583514988422394,
-0.16702668368816376,
0.517633855342865,
-0.290099173784256,
1.149428129196167,
0.31275832653045654,
-0.6860097050666809,
0.3341579735279083,
-0.1078123077750206,
-0.501342236995697,
0.7433488368988037,
-0.6471577882766724,
-0.05261550843715668,
-0.1287936121225357,
0.6327419877052307,
-0.7063868641853333,
-0.20292149484157562,
-0.045237183570861816,
0.06698884814977646,
0.20889520645141602,
-0.2724614441394806,
-0.31110838055610657,
-0.537653923034668,
0.04667022451758385,
1.080075979232788,
0.7183292508125305,
-0.7582072615623474,
0.6489110589027405,
0.300647497177124,
0.17951054871082306,
-0.8722224235534668,
-0.4742276966571808,
0.21098828315734863,
-0.3631008565425873,
-0.9852197766304016,
0.8319272994995117,
-0.09989681094884872,
0.07183545082807541,
-0.016335897147655487,
-0.2604428231716156,
0.018646657466888428,
0.17435197532176971,
0.46701812744140625,
0.05611051991581917,
-0.32944023609161377,
-0.049519043415784836,
-0.07902643084526062,
-0.33951494097709656,
0.2550060451030731,
-0.4077165126800537,
0.5124186873435974,
-0.3033287227153778,
-0.4220399558544159,
-0.3043859899044037,
0.568182647228241,
0.7308408617973328,
-0.012652388773858547,
0.6561508178710938,
0.8682214617729187,
-0.12582755088806152,
-0.1659497767686844,
-0.7420234680175781,
0.24484090507030487,
-0.5047141313552856,
0.4760425090789795,
-0.5617544651031494,
-0.7646827697753906,
0.5560187697410583,
-0.2615576982498169,
0.20471930503845215,
0.5677034258842468,
0.5156423449516296,
0.07048998028039932,
0.7548909783363342,
0.6224031448364258,
-0.22004012763500214,
0.43874311447143555,
-0.39074084162712097,
0.29001209139823914,
-0.7739707827568054,
-0.25358298420906067,
-0.3631678521633148,
-0.3636346757411957,
-0.6663166284561157,
-0.6653993725776672,
0.543407142162323,
-0.027231162413954735,
-0.3110645115375519,
0.46513327956199646,
-0.5092182159423828,
0.3416149616241455,
0.1987072229385376,
-0.2642594575881958,
0.035243142396211624,
-0.15572866797447205,
0.05679707229137421,
0.245314359664917,
-0.6340439915657043,
-0.14371398091316223,
0.7148721814155579,
0.3421157896518707,
0.6688424944877625,
0.2915647029876709,
0.22363127768039703,
0.14686433970928192,
0.24304278194904327,
-0.7215232849121094,
0.417880654335022,
0.22103555500507355,
-0.6748877167701721,
-0.401315301656723,
-0.4950011670589447,
-0.8335321545600891,
0.13040095567703247,
0.11384745687246323,
-0.5758507251739502,
0.06100834906101227,
0.13101069629192352,
-0.17593331634998322,
0.2822130620479584,
-0.6381155252456665,
0.9431886672973633,
-0.04386334493756294,
-0.678342342376709,
-0.38086822628974915,
-0.7747518420219421,
0.11853056401014328,
-0.045317474752664566,
0.010051554068922997,
-0.018585771322250366,
0.14803218841552734,
0.38351401686668396,
-0.2344127744436264,
0.361703485250473,
-0.26548662781715393,
-0.005621510092169046,
0.29531314969062805,
-0.4090406000614166,
0.6257564425468445,
0.08759161829948425,
-0.08449584245681763,
0.017886338755488396,
-0.13447009027004242,
-0.8081839680671692,
-0.5423724055290222,
0.8354301452636719,
-0.5934051871299744,
-0.4687020778656006,
-0.11312264204025269,
-0.4846769869327545,
-0.01986756920814514,
-0.02797905169427395,
0.4427834749221802,
0.19678710401058197,
-0.1837923675775528,
0.5546292066574097,
0.37231943011283875,
-0.19591431319713593,
0.6389280557632446,
-0.16671644151210785,
0.1004464402794838,
0.009587645530700684,
0.6461926102638245,
-0.0338190533220768,
0.38403382897377014,
0.1838718205690384,
-0.10561416298151016,
-0.23862920701503754,
-0.552372395992279,
-0.5023064017295837,
-0.1130826398730278,
-0.43987002968788147,
0.04981467127799988,
-0.3818209171295166,
-0.16105948388576508,
-0.14530451595783234,
-0.2813930809497833,
-0.6818075776100159,
0.17127619683742523,
-0.006127603352069855,
0.28269731998443604,
-0.049923673272132874,
0.3853858709335327,
0.34048473834991455,
0.8203521370887756,
-0.2981140911579132,
0.30376115441322327,
0.32563015818595886,
0.6598747372627258,
0.407797247171402,
-0.26674389839172363,
-0.6870914101600647,
-0.2699810862541199,
-0.5802214741706848,
-0.5280893445014954,
0.25861725211143494,
-0.25282832980155945,
0.4409332275390625,
0.394672155380249,
0.009217258542776108,
1.0326188802719116,
-0.6477035284042358,
0.8987143039703369,
0.033572111278772354,
-0.9077770709991455,
0.07414200156927109,
-0.39781320095062256,
0.47450876235961914,
0.4762856066226959,
0.5030723214149475,
-0.48785558342933655,
0.2146771401166916,
-0.3066371977329254,
-1.1486283540725708,
0.4900244176387787,
0.43879270553588867,
0.1531503051519394,
-0.12317303568124771,
0.46349477767944336,
0.03272353112697601,
-0.07046812027692795,
-0.35218295454978943,
-0.31002625823020935,
-0.2853015065193176,
0.22031402587890625,
-0.23248131573200226,
-0.30233678221702576,
-0.2113221138715744,
-0.38889721035957336,
0.3671392500400543,
-0.2365892380475998,
0.5210692882537842,
-0.021505147218704224,
-0.2923412621021271,
0.09680020064115524,
0.41731834411621094,
0.6472314596176147,
0.7959397435188293,
-0.37863850593566895,
0.010414852760732174,
0.31751537322998047,
-0.27291497588157654,
-0.059946682304143906,
-0.10475911945104599,
0.11967150121927261,
-0.17580628395080566,
-0.08363417536020279,
0.989687979221344,
0.5737058520317078,
-0.5648666620254517,
0.6309023499488831,
-0.10983698815107346,
-0.06644584983587265,
-0.6145460605621338,
-0.2742263376712799,
0.046796876937150955,
0.262951523065567,
0.6174851059913635,
-0.06560736149549484,
-0.053214240819215775,
-0.2722424566745758,
0.10449331253767014,
0.42992696166038513,
-0.2654428780078888,
-0.38141271471977234,
0.5164771676063538,
0.35646283626556396,
-0.10881805419921875,
0.9876421093940735,
0.02213783748447895,
-0.378603458404541,
0.6522603034973145,
0.7439983487129211,
0.6941404342651367,
-0.04850685968995094,
-0.15074053406715393,
0.1060187891125679,
0.07410307973623276,
-0.27593621611595154,
-0.17117571830749512,
-0.44024452567100525,
-0.30707842111587524,
-0.7172639966011047,
-0.6877599358558655,
-0.3843979835510254,
0.13206608593463898,
-0.8947474956512451,
0.22741945087909698,
-0.08166364580392838,
-0.5400571227073669,
-0.04434843733906746,
-0.10154539346694946,
-0.9217211604118347,
-0.0701337605714798,
-0.028706075623631477,
0.6411731243133545,
-0.4273247718811035,
0.675497829914093,
0.11203068494796753,
0.11915430426597595,
-0.4299110472202301,
-0.2880333364009857,
-0.19403010606765747,
-0.565837025642395,
0.6146294474601746,
0.3339994251728058,
-0.06307478249073029,
-0.05623139068484306,
-0.31416139006614685,
-0.729211151599884,
1.176214337348938,
0.20563173294067383,
-0.42850610613822937,
-0.46613672375679016,
0.1427159309387207,
0.33771875500679016,
-0.21601702272891998,
0.42137610912323,
0.5477805733680725,
0.61797696352005,
0.12712381780147552,
-0.9899628758430481,
0.14133144915103912,
-0.13496652245521545,
0.0032005899120122194,
0.5818573832511902,
-0.7432141304016113,
1.017889142036438,
-0.040357377380132675,
-0.42253902554512024,
0.08660633116960526,
0.5808907747268677,
-0.15035022795200348,
0.3086174726486206,
0.6023979783058167,
0.541252076625824,
0.19884292781352997,
0.04250473901629448,
1.1097413301467896,
-0.5382272601127625,
0.623894989490509,
0.552255392074585,
-0.049023717641830444,
0.7913987636566162,
0.8502547144889832,
-0.2656148374080658,
0.44889938831329346,
0.22261913120746613,
-0.1703842729330063,
0.1824505776166916,
0.34690341353416443,
-0.5052928328514099,
-0.05438460409641266,
-0.059464216232299805,
-0.6745712757110596,
0.4075299799442291,
0.21850872039794922,
-0.1209278479218483,
-0.21771591901779175,
-0.0004659593105316162,
-0.2491946965456009,
-0.6310251951217651,
0.011151093058288097,
0.25669431686401367,
0.1376039832830429,
-0.7857162952423096,
0.6801915168762207,
-0.08385103940963745,
0.8120324611663818,
-0.40592801570892334,
0.17587296664714813,
0.10257188230752945,
0.3109610080718994,
-0.15741628408432007,
-0.3774009048938751,
0.33354422450065613,
-0.12820205092430115,
-0.25743594765663147,
-0.3685210645198822,
0.2642705738544464,
0.2369055598974228,
-0.010557052679359913,
0.3587104380130768,
0.2216162234544754,
0.046448398381471634,
-0.278348445892334,
-0.31055259704589844,
0.28843095898628235,
-0.37934616208076477,
-0.28864729404449463,
0.6244352459907532,
0.038043588399887085,
-0.16979892551898956,
0.6701517701148987,
0.5243882536888123,
-0.34761297702789307,
0.14371919631958008,
-0.0004749049840029329,
0.9095699191093445,
-0.7618021368980408,
-0.47961482405662537,
-0.7237523198127747,
0.5358282923698425,
-0.06616143882274628,
-0.32325252890586853,
0.6259462237358093,
0.5529960989952087,
0.7772698998451233,
-0.06665702909231186,
0.4582907259464264,
-0.1072835847735405,
-0.43314889073371887,
-0.2511535882949829,
0.49818769097328186,
-0.5868810415267944,
0.19381488859653473,
-0.23956625163555145,
-1.0385816097259521,
0.11447089910507202,
0.1858547478914261,
-0.01879299245774746,
-0.10695185512304306,
0.7837012410163879,
0.5081539750099182,
-0.29743245244026184,
0.17232860624790192,
0.2498534470796585,
-0.015552371740341187,
0.5976190567016602,
0.871874988079071,
0.8132502436637878,
-0.4863937795162201,
0.5726792216300964,
-0.37124332785606384,
-0.20839452743530273,
-0.4274415075778961,
-0.9048571586608887,
-0.33711111545562744,
-0.68097323179245,
-0.011464198119938374,
-0.22856450080871582,
0.146837517619133,
0.5101137161254883,
0.9914867281913757,
-0.44499847292900085,
-0.4502052366733551,
-0.08558306843042374,
-0.1434391736984253,
-0.2757456302642822,
-0.2647033929824829,
0.24576695263385773,
-0.3584217131137848,
-0.6298899054527283,
0.4027557075023651,
0.37616515159606934,
-0.1695292443037033,
-0.43044278025627136,
-0.17299960553646088,
0.17022138833999634,
-0.22553332149982452,
0.967019259929657,
0.40017786622047424,
-0.6653915047645569,
-0.5522356629371643,
0.12009367346763611,
-0.06514903157949448,
0.2553977966308594,
1.1324101686477661,
-0.8570539951324463,
0.41017794609069824,
0.37854549288749695,
0.8467934131622314,
1.1831210851669312,
0.09152645617723465,
0.4456001818180084,
-0.7822175621986389,
0.24191558361053467,
0.2776350975036621,
0.11091578006744385,
-0.07839269936084747,
-0.29230889678001404,
0.2799740135669708,
0.2169179916381836,
-0.9103696942329407,
-0.8112640976905823,
0.41262027621269226,
-1.406164526939392,
-0.16290664672851562,
0.8741455078125,
-0.08924466371536255,
-0.1935417503118515,
-0.2882510721683502,
0.15304304659366608,
0.21004913747310638,
-0.20306377112865448,
0.766459047794342,
0.6925520300865173,
-0.3854791820049286,
-0.04786665365099907,
-0.846670925617218,
0.4515109956264496,
0.5857152938842773,
-0.5870987772941589,
0.06499611586332321,
0.2801748812198639,
-0.018242450430989265,
0.23627479374408722,
0.3053532540798187,
-0.024944132193922997,
0.20578336715698242,
0.11459024995565414,
-0.06477075070142746,
-0.11231541633605957,
-0.44147172570228577,
-0.19678354263305664,
0.5606911778450012,
-0.34607580304145813,
-0.006186405662447214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08932v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08932v1
|
Self-supervised vision-langage alignment of deep learning representations for bone X-rays analysis
| 2024-05-14T19:53:20 | 2024-05-14T19:53:20 |
Alexandre Englebert, Anne-Sophie Collin, Olivier Cornu, Christophe De Vleeschouwer
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper proposes leveraging vision-language pretraining on bone X-rays
paired with French reports to address downstream tasks of interest on bone
radiography. A practical processing pipeline is introduced to anonymize and
process French medical reports. Pretraining then consists in the
self-supervised alignment of visual and textual embedding spaces derived from
deep model encoders. The resulting image encoder is then used to handle various
downstream tasks, including quantification of osteoarthritis, estimation of
bone age on pediatric wrists, bone fracture and anomaly detection. Our approach
demonstrates competitive performance on downstream tasks, compared to
alternatives requiring a significantly larger amount of human expert
annotations. Our work stands as the first study to integrate French reports to
shape the embedding space devoted to bone X-Rays representations, capitalizing
on the large quantity of paired images and reports data available in an
hospital. By relying on generic vision-laguage deep models in a
language-specific scenario, it contributes to the deployement of vision models
for wider healthcare applications.
|
[
0.17836059629917145,
0.07993967086076736,
0.7716704607009888,
-0.048516180366277695,
-0.4118213951587677,
0.18767286837100983,
0.3041061758995056,
-0.6789867877960205,
0.5445212125778198,
0.693699836730957,
-0.4650474488735199,
-0.6806638240814209,
-0.6891708374023438,
0.061353132128715515,
-0.14728276431560516,
0.41590845584869385,
-0.15433362126350403,
0.5828205943107605,
-0.04585342854261398,
-0.26532384753227234,
-0.4662712812423706,
-0.21267180144786835,
-0.31615132093429565,
-0.44161903858184814,
0.18957877159118652,
0.17788481712341309,
0.8261830806732178,
1.1711071729660034,
0.7160893678665161,
0.2517370581626892,
0.8881503343582153,
-0.02360713668167591,
-0.1432766169309616,
-0.12018965929746628,
-0.24245774745941162,
-0.2749425172805786,
-0.5854267477989197,
-0.2124468982219696,
0.3266226053237915,
0.7367951273918152,
0.23973824083805084,
-0.053718894720077515,
-0.3173389434814453,
0.7516098618507385,
-0.5177295207977295,
0.12211395055055618,
-0.047761525958776474,
0.34378936886787415,
-0.1554320603609085,
-0.5909998416900635,
-0.27161431312561035,
-0.19726449251174927,
0.3152286112308502,
-0.35352644324302673,
0.048109956085681915,
-0.21228180825710297,
0.9971755743026733,
0.36811158061027527,
-0.16905759274959564,
-0.39090830087661743,
-0.37604519724845886,
0.6856785416603088,
-0.3593248128890991,
0.5511559844017029,
0.34604987502098083,
0.36633437871932983,
0.2972877323627472,
-0.9682485461235046,
0.1288822442293167,
-0.04572872444987297,
-0.4674872159957886,
0.2241431474685669,
-0.20055681467056274,
0.1819661408662796,
-0.32498833537101746,
0.48626744747161865,
-0.9253489375114441,
0.3013905882835388,
-0.6335551142692566,
-0.3018203675746918,
1.0487871170043945,
-0.04786187782883644,
0.5509698390960693,
-0.23438967764377594,
-0.5852463841438293,
-0.244577556848526,
-0.7282808423042297,
-0.2233637124300003,
0.024883029982447624,
0.15374432504177094,
-0.37126410007476807,
0.4986141622066498,
-0.47855621576309204,
0.6850792765617371,
0.07671032845973969,
-0.07147607952356339,
0.7584855556488037,
-0.12757709622383118,
-0.41352784633636475,
0.38901254534721375,
0.8327656388282776,
0.4362287223339081,
0.170232892036438,
-0.314449280500412,
-0.09139653295278549,
0.15538614988327026,
0.1659100353717804,
-0.7170537114143372,
-0.7576444745063782,
0.34819185733795166,
-0.5277222394943237,
-0.4645348787307739,
-0.08239994198083878,
-0.5251829624176025,
-0.44252821803092957,
-0.2093254029750824,
0.7628535032272339,
-0.1628991961479187,
-0.14731577038764954,
0.6809577345848083,
0.25674372911453247,
0.10160302370786667,
0.03349403664469719,
-0.6974858641624451,
0.18649525940418243,
0.03747722506523132,
0.5361196398735046,
0.1133250892162323,
0.003992253914475441,
-0.5181119441986084,
0.33425116539001465,
-0.30511292815208435,
0.703278124332428,
-0.38815370202064514,
-0.31868359446525574,
-0.026023799553513527,
0.22381442785263062,
0.015067864209413528,
-0.3744466304779053,
0.11080695688724518,
-0.21821874380111694,
0.15106813609600067,
0.03991328924894333,
-0.2755759060382843,
-0.09406793862581253,
0.10727910697460175,
-0.635162353515625,
0.7658800482749939,
0.20804040133953094,
-0.5059570074081421,
0.6558669209480286,
-0.2201261818408966,
-0.4048881232738495,
0.23216363787651062,
-0.9859691262245178,
-0.24170523881912231,
-0.13598421216011047,
0.7697381377220154,
0.8658474683761597,
-0.3417230248451233,
0.25868210196495056,
0.10371486097574234,
0.19030094146728516,
0.024813253432512283,
-0.006398191209882498,
0.636934757232666,
0.14134705066680908,
-0.353179931640625,
0.15497304499149323,
-0.5424423217773438,
0.13355527818202972,
0.3023557960987091,
0.29027774930000305,
-0.2860887348651886,
0.0015582647174596786,
-0.2980349063873291,
0.3645079731941223,
0.24156183004379272,
-0.6938619613647461,
0.26652052998542786,
-0.4471387267112732,
0.17623679339885712,
0.37837961316108704,
-0.14893440902233124,
0.340887188911438,
-0.18549078702926636,
0.5883416533470154,
-0.2515009343624115,
0.2858976721763611,
-0.2600861191749573,
-0.1919289231300354,
-0.25351688265800476,
-0.36182016134262085,
0.14729635417461395,
0.5513989329338074,
-0.6482254862785339,
0.14155182242393494,
-0.5815795660018921,
-0.3199092745780945,
-0.8330472707748413,
0.22762486338615417,
0.5611944198608398,
0.5116604566574097,
0.43848344683647156,
-0.5882818102836609,
-0.7530009746551514,
-0.8376310467720032,
0.20367123186588287,
0.007917731069028378,
0.27618375420570374,
0.22327856719493866,
0.2690527141094208,
-0.19915764033794403,
1.0053699016571045,
-0.7604354023933411,
-0.7810585498809814,
-0.17985622584819794,
0.10550002008676529,
0.1561783105134964,
0.6209906935691833,
0.8170526027679443,
-0.8039296269416809,
-0.5046921968460083,
0.2933281660079956,
-1.371038556098938,
-0.05735907331109047,
0.028077656403183937,
0.13703195750713348,
-0.03372340649366379,
0.8987545371055603,
-0.01257138978689909,
0.32095906138420105,
0.7548999190330505,
0.059216227382421494,
0.09820626676082611,
-0.42405325174331665,
0.22214259207248688,
-1.0162218809127808,
-0.177322655916214,
0.08207148313522339,
-0.5213822722434998,
-0.37167635560035706,
0.059139445424079895,
0.1551896333694458,
-0.18639186024665833,
-0.4723019003868103,
0.49257776141166687,
-0.751719057559967,
0.04612775146961212,
-0.02182924747467041,
0.0732623040676117,
0.1990204155445099,
-0.06176634132862091,
0.6896439790725708,
0.23538359999656677,
0.9159349203109741,
-0.12802033126354218,
0.16611731052398682,
0.10176987200975418,
-0.31800341606140137,
0.11545846611261368,
-0.5636420249938965,
0.16639716923236847,
-0.07670295238494873,
0.015219422057271004,
-0.9487915635108948,
-0.4447089433670044,
0.2370903044939041,
-0.5989351868629456,
0.6884215474128723,
-0.45735952258110046,
-0.0834466889500618,
-0.5148787498474121,
-0.39040422439575195,
0.5541567206382751,
0.37942585349082947,
-0.6433016657829285,
0.5672876834869385,
0.575930655002594,
-0.007757203653454781,
-0.8968371152877808,
-1.113133192062378,
-0.03354519233107567,
0.1693142205476761,
-0.8652622699737549,
0.5497952103614807,
0.3510589003562927,
0.1250435709953308,
0.29955199360847473,
-0.22300583124160767,
-0.4138917624950409,
-0.4410496652126312,
0.26195240020751953,
0.30227068066596985,
-0.5381131172180176,
0.09569133073091507,
-0.16213785111904144,
-0.39637690782546997,
-0.040217410773038864,
-0.5103145241737366,
0.4945204555988312,
0.13155829906463623,
-0.3222666084766388,
-0.5999700427055359,
0.3412151038646698,
0.21736888587474823,
-0.3524669408798218,
0.23186670243740082,
0.5408787727355957,
-0.4724837839603424,
0.22031031548976898,
-0.7374453544616699,
-0.0063949692994356155,
-0.49682632088661194,
0.5015207529067993,
-0.19889816641807556,
-0.7844271063804626,
0.2662767171859741,
-0.07509449869394302,
-0.25805187225341797,
0.41807833313941956,
0.3955845236778259,
-0.3458242118358612,
1.1678410768508911,
0.9167189598083496,
-0.10525437444448471,
-0.07416041940450668,
-0.6101672053337097,
0.2797783315181732,
-0.4383998215198517,
-0.28130507469177246,
-0.10374228656291962,
0.0009513628901913762,
-0.34887930750846863,
-0.3867058753967285,
-0.01916523277759552,
-0.2063896358013153,
0.13386625051498413,
0.20840080082416534,
-0.7273895740509033,
0.5696548819541931,
-0.19304043054580688,
0.24638822674751282,
0.06208954378962517,
-0.05963134765625,
0.24629637598991394,
-0.22496028244495392,
-0.7316279411315918,
-0.37202873826026917,
1.2078673839569092,
0.3568449318408966,
1.0932164192199707,
-0.21736261248588562,
1.2189297676086426,
0.2927268445491791,
0.16758468747138977,
-0.6520310640335083,
0.19026519358158112,
-0.781181812286377,
-0.5550337433815002,
-0.17599646747112274,
-0.088514044880867,
-1.0767245292663574,
0.08494795113801956,
-0.2864970266819,
-0.7995161414146423,
0.5158674120903015,
0.30732300877571106,
-0.8167945742607117,
0.2608981132507324,
-0.835358738899231,
1.198598027229309,
-0.5027236938476562,
-0.2039548009634018,
-0.095039002597332,
-0.6600471138954163,
0.08670315146446228,
-0.10847064852714539,
0.3374778628349304,
-0.2830509841442108,
0.11621033400297165,
0.4973534941673279,
-0.23372535407543182,
1.133646011352539,
-0.24111251533031464,
0.03842421993613243,
0.09767516702413559,
-0.03582208603620529,
0.07335737347602844,
0.2061140090227127,
0.3213234841823578,
0.09178616851568222,
0.12080242484807968,
-0.35874760150909424,
-0.17564912140369415,
0.6240062117576599,
-0.8315404653549194,
-0.435722291469574,
-0.640964925289154,
-0.5556632280349731,
-0.03904879465699196,
0.27501335740089417,
0.5611997842788696,
0.7261056900024414,
-0.11237502843141556,
0.0810864046216011,
0.4948883354663849,
0.004600062035024166,
0.1519370675086975,
0.27174729108810425,
-0.49718034267425537,
-0.2522074282169342,
0.977583110332489,
0.5557971000671387,
-0.001324774813838303,
0.6427024006843567,
0.20507238805294037,
-0.2641645669937134,
-0.7691243290901184,
-0.4867020845413208,
0.35505643486976624,
-0.8625876307487488,
-0.45781823992729187,
-0.5779378414154053,
-0.2128446400165558,
-0.5180386304855347,
-0.6631960272789001,
-0.6552900075912476,
-0.05084146931767464,
-0.13898329436779022,
-0.20925942063331604,
0.16904427111148834,
0.7331779599189758,
-0.3107611835002899,
0.3458235263824463,
-0.9143494963645935,
0.2900128662586212,
0.27103230357170105,
0.12223707139492035,
-0.4246337413787842,
-0.31428101658821106,
-0.506190299987793,
-0.3274013102054596,
0.3406706154346466,
-0.7603906989097595,
0.6718852519989014,
0.08315585553646088,
0.5639700889587402,
0.35044097900390625,
0.10639391839504242,
0.5551232695579529,
-0.24114273488521576,
0.3416125774383545,
0.36869820952415466,
-0.7017250657081604,
0.7075772285461426,
-0.18517599999904633,
0.1581985354423523,
0.6075627207756042,
0.5906330943107605,
0.09950409084558487,
-0.013122394680976868,
-0.31359708309173584,
-0.9567383527755737,
0.6571481227874756,
-0.21012617647647858,
0.03694847598671913,
-0.2424660176038742,
0.31532976031303406,
0.14206142723560333,
-0.24432042241096497,
-0.7555816769599915,
-0.01935090497136116,
-0.09854716062545776,
-0.3780745565891266,
0.041288647800683975,
-0.16316692531108856,
-0.2495059221982956,
-0.2936892509460449,
0.436675488948822,
-0.3378329277038574,
0.07506122440099716,
0.6047307848930359,
-0.6834385395050049,
-0.19385585188865662,
-0.3267158269882202,
0.19269992411136627,
0.7999112010002136,
-0.4129899740219116,
0.20980311930179596,
0.06018299236893654,
-0.617865264415741,
0.16075174510478973,
-0.05175194516777992,
0.31398075819015503,
0.05276729539036751,
0.5134693384170532,
0.3636273741722107,
0.2730492055416107,
-0.406604140996933,
0.7751649618148804,
0.014888186007738113,
-0.42045438289642334,
-0.43772369623184204,
-0.20200668275356293,
-0.027326583862304688,
0.3286755084991455,
0.4461333751678467,
0.09004701673984528,
0.11564812064170837,
-0.34393224120140076,
0.49466732144355774,
0.2290542870759964,
-0.8099220395088196,
-0.2820056080818176,
0.5818870663642883,
0.1940133273601532,
0.5268816947937012,
0.48157715797424316,
-0.1366564929485321,
-0.07873454689979553,
0.5404139757156372,
0.25764259696006775,
0.8107783198356628,
-0.5008479952812195,
0.36168935894966125,
0.3873986303806305,
0.4070841670036316,
-0.005768716335296631,
0.3177780508995056,
0.22234012186527252,
-0.8603742718696594,
-0.9624289870262146,
-0.262112021446228,
0.14574971795082092,
-0.1694881170988083,
-0.9509564638137817,
0.34057149291038513,
-0.33135053515434265,
-0.07038115710020065,
0.14087854325771332,
-0.14033791422843933,
-0.6745427846908569,
0.8348290920257568,
0.42644113302230835,
0.6402909755706787,
-1.1233670711517334,
1.337105631828308,
0.6351537704467773,
-0.6206302046775818,
-0.6547821760177612,
-0.26686209440231323,
-0.07228688150644302,
-1.402723789215088,
1.0813511610031128,
0.32234427332878113,
-0.3997258245944977,
-0.08079938590526581,
-0.2891700267791748,
-0.9311332702636719,
1.295007348060608,
0.661663830280304,
-0.39265742897987366,
-0.07317162305116653,
0.12268846482038498,
0.28844720125198364,
-0.7055761218070984,
-0.2784014940261841,
0.4446951448917389,
-0.021348807960748672,
-0.02840445749461651,
-0.7659958004951477,
0.0733511820435524,
-0.09592880308628082,
-0.3600201904773712,
0.29411056637763977,
-0.3662016987800598,
0.5685720443725586,
-0.3204825520515442,
-0.20808936655521393,
-0.1852797269821167,
0.7122674584388733,
-0.3315933048725128,
0.08360607177019119,
0.2972668409347534,
0.6466737985610962,
0.5271913409233093,
-0.025332052260637283,
1.2343677282333374,
-0.39591342210769653,
0.21978694200515747,
1.0980108976364136,
-0.37356412410736084,
0.5355194211006165,
0.38459697365760803,
0.0684816762804985,
0.3740709722042084,
0.39454078674316406,
-0.0667315274477005,
0.7797915935516357,
-0.22645820677280426,
-0.08899249136447906,
-0.45225438475608826,
-0.020243406295776367,
-0.5305865406990051,
0.6550473570823669,
0.30182719230651855,
-0.577137291431427,
-0.26932597160339355,
0.23231369256973267,
-0.043735239654779434,
-0.037319429218769073,
-0.4818166494369507,
0.4891291856765747,
0.09585399180650711,
-0.1400088518857956,
0.3815324306488037,
-0.332681804895401,
0.5108967423439026,
-0.8957332968711853,
-0.030073659494519234,
0.07811549305915833,
0.3473829925060272,
-0.7136042714118958,
-0.9892245531082153,
0.47444790601730347,
-0.33672139048576355,
-0.1516202986240387,
-0.2825075685977936,
0.784100353717804,
-0.15854448080062866,
-0.3529670536518097,
0.6873874068260193,
0.4055909216403961,
0.16515007615089417,
0.20369775593280792,
-0.4878678023815155,
-0.002555539133027196,
0.18708956241607666,
0.06894124299287796,
0.5980126261711121,
0.3388358950614929,
-0.21618390083312988,
0.44039931893348694,
0.3066718876361847,
-0.022410163655877113,
0.0849570482969284,
0.20359079539775848,
0.9043975472450256,
-0.2829480469226837,
-0.429767370223999,
-0.7299553751945496,
0.658056378364563,
-0.060433048754930496,
-0.1814630925655365,
0.458397775888443,
0.5794792175292969,
0.9379441142082214,
-0.10642890632152557,
0.6502371430397034,
0.08729922026395798,
0.09119683504104614,
-0.8553815484046936,
0.6692970991134644,
-0.5256096720695496,
-0.0491466224193573,
-0.10446193069219589,
-0.4240344762802124,
-0.761076033115387,
0.8650175333023071,
-0.5282610654830933,
-0.15962770581245422,
0.7024771571159363,
0.7840314507484436,
-0.1235162690281868,
-0.4085097312927246,
0.5622490644454956,
0.036529362201690674,
0.006811927072703838,
0.24003513157367706,
0.28574350476264954,
-0.470081090927124,
0.5318734645843506,
-0.5932532548904419,
-0.2555525302886963,
-0.24646584689617157,
-0.8972005248069763,
-0.7338302135467529,
-0.3825799524784088,
-0.8265063762664795,
-0.1613001674413681,
0.18290384113788605,
0.8568252921104431,
1.0179572105407715,
-0.7786382436752319,
-0.31681039929389954,
0.37556731700897217,
-0.571448802947998,
-0.03552794083952904,
-0.07659249752759933,
1.0328953266143799,
-0.43090030550956726,
-0.27814939618110657,
0.6012436747550964,
0.6558917164802551,
-0.0932299941778183,
-0.20018039643764496,
-0.13739190995693207,
-0.06280162185430527,
-0.3065430521965027,
0.45346224308013916,
0.5603483319282532,
-0.4071033000946045,
-0.3594692051410675,
0.20433849096298218,
-0.26472699642181396,
0.5186201930046082,
0.5746229887008667,
-0.9929517507553101,
1.076643466949463,
0.37961262464523315,
0.5316254496574402,
0.6330878734588623,
-0.39427313208580017,
0.608792245388031,
-0.9426833391189575,
0.3204471170902252,
0.3107183873653412,
0.5646873116493225,
0.47730129957199097,
-0.32975900173187256,
0.7187474370002747,
-0.020422928035259247,
-0.24649293720722198,
-0.745228111743927,
0.023340536281466484,
-0.9809123277664185,
-0.22771382331848145,
0.5288610458374023,
-0.3302816152572632,
-0.35717853903770447,
-0.23633027076721191,
-0.2091190069913864,
0.13788485527038574,
0.1597311794757843,
0.434690922498703,
0.22882285714149475,
-0.40860557556152344,
-0.38900694251060486,
-0.6556298732757568,
0.3891764283180237,
0.2543419897556305,
-0.4219370484352112,
-0.3276134431362152,
0.054209038615226746,
0.1097622811794281,
0.2949213683605194,
1.0692484378814697,
-0.5733664035797119,
0.5190841555595398,
0.007565568201243877,
0.3871808648109436,
0.11976192891597748,
-0.16839797794818878,
-0.4076899588108063,
0.12483970075845718,
0.159947469830513,
-0.42170989513397217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08888v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08888v1
|
Large Language Models for Human-Machine Collaborative Particle Accelerator Tuning through Natural Language
| 2024-05-14T18:05:44 | 2024-05-14T18:05:44 |
Jan Kaiser, Annika Eichler, Anne Lauscher
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, physics.acc-ph
|
Autonomous tuning of particle accelerators is an active and challenging field
of research with the goal of enabling novel accelerator technologies
cutting-edge high-impact applications, such as physics discovery, cancer
research and material sciences. A key challenge with autonomous accelerator
tuning remains that the most capable algorithms require an expert in
optimisation, machine learning or a similar field to implement the algorithm
for every new tuning task. In this work, we propose the use of large language
models (LLMs) to tune particle accelerators. We demonstrate on a
proof-of-principle example the ability of LLMs to successfully and autonomously
tune a particle accelerator subsystem based on nothing more than a natural
language prompt from the operator, and compare the performance of our LLM-based
solution to state-of-the-art optimisation algorithms, such as Bayesian
optimisation (BO) and reinforcement learning-trained optimisation (RLO). In
doing so, we also show how LLMs can perform numerical optimisation of a highly
non-linear real-world objective function. Ultimately, this work represents yet
another complex task that LLMs are capable of solving and promises to help
accelerate the deployment of autonomous tuning algorithms to the day-to-day
operations of particle accelerators.
|
[
-0.40498268604278564,
-0.7746294140815735,
0.682046115398407,
-0.009220241568982601,
-0.18933837115764618,
0.32365554571151733,
-0.4340916574001312,
-0.4746610224246979,
0.01587088778614998,
0.6279373168945312,
-0.792467474937439,
-0.3274017870426178,
-0.5204867124557495,
0.35192498564720154,
-0.15416793525218964,
0.6056209802627563,
-0.016333112493157387,
0.10662592202425003,
-0.09357208758592606,
0.23286664485931396,
-0.39403221011161804,
-0.2081851065158844,
-1.0637229681015015,
-0.7021788954734802,
0.3484835922718048,
0.277535617351532,
0.8068470358848572,
0.6053353548049927,
0.5748366713523865,
0.4196411967277527,
-0.07022857666015625,
0.5575196743011475,
-0.2813655138015747,
-0.23008714616298676,
-0.6613426804542542,
-0.30286353826522827,
-0.4418014585971832,
-0.16321039199829102,
0.431558221578598,
0.7761679887771606,
-0.18083511292934418,
-0.19141186773777008,
-0.12280508130788803,
0.5865189433097839,
-0.4925927221775055,
0.4258948564529419,
-0.7256420850753784,
0.0909598246216774,
-0.03400781378149986,
-0.3158622682094574,
-0.38042473793029785,
-0.12285084277391434,
-0.10604426264762878,
-0.7501484751701355,
0.2764475345611572,
0.3760976791381836,
0.6562393307685852,
0.4938800632953644,
-0.3356437385082245,
-0.28829360008239746,
-0.7828317880630493,
0.9632420539855957,
-0.701381266117096,
0.21447862684726715,
0.4212700128555298,
0.2724752426147461,
-0.6843288540840149,
-0.3721521496772766,
-0.3549162447452545,
-0.21120716631412506,
-0.07736917585134506,
-0.04225188121199608,
-0.25386205315589905,
0.40839529037475586,
0.038336414843797684,
0.2984604239463806,
-0.47379446029663086,
0.550275444984436,
-0.08891120553016663,
-0.2988477349281311,
0.6891354322433472,
0.3038015365600586,
-0.031943731009960175,
0.07524550706148148,
0.175550177693367,
0.03605429455637932,
-0.3483595550060272,
-0.285012423992157,
0.2203705906867981,
0.5498366355895996,
-0.1453644186258316,
0.44983044266700745,
-0.5283890962600708,
0.8336549401283264,
0.16944599151611328,
-0.079027459025383,
-0.0654669851064682,
-0.2869008183479309,
-0.2005259394645691,
0.14691103994846344,
1.060764193534851,
0.05678544193506241,
0.5744053721427917,
-0.2613193094730377,
-0.10154829174280167,
0.16330614686012268,
0.36860597133636475,
-0.595191240310669,
-0.23961272835731506,
-0.030708888545632362,
-0.11254529654979706,
-0.3761374354362488,
-0.2831243872642517,
-0.7260280251502991,
-0.3744893968105316,
-0.6143128275871277,
0.5654304027557373,
-0.17203406989574432,
0.08365054428577423,
0.5382335186004639,
0.1710788458585739,
0.03218507021665573,
0.08916490525007248,
-1.1807746887207031,
0.4350835084915161,
0.9694380164146423,
0.7716296315193176,
0.1872720867395401,
-0.2516479790210724,
-1.0353410243988037,
0.1249367967247963,
-0.28069278597831726,
0.7287308573722839,
-0.6178129315376282,
-0.45880362391471863,
-0.061459019780159,
0.038694996386766434,
-0.05431675910949707,
-0.671534538269043,
0.6445155143737793,
-0.37637731432914734,
0.22496995329856873,
0.08866763859987259,
-0.6852192282676697,
0.005965428426861763,
-0.2107442319393158,
-0.2297929972410202,
0.684846043586731,
-0.04701412841677666,
-0.21310216188430786,
0.07381570339202881,
-0.7104852795600891,
-0.6766090393066406,
0.1445440948009491,
-0.2086099535226822,
-0.5300754904747009,
0.41060584783554077,
0.46233266592025757,
0.5464708209037781,
-0.5974666476249695,
0.5513160228729248,
-0.2941672205924988,
-0.14357663691043854,
0.07050315290689468,
-0.2737651467323303,
0.3528112769126892,
0.16238924860954285,
-0.12361419200897217,
0.38918599486351013,
-0.6096880435943604,
-0.13648715615272522,
0.02293526753783226,
0.09599781036376953,
0.15627971291542053,
0.27286750078201294,
-0.29071179032325745,
0.06987695395946503,
0.5894284248352051,
-0.5810763239860535,
0.2532709836959839,
-0.8287913203239441,
0.5676791667938232,
0.7340165972709656,
0.04301981255412102,
0.2130463570356369,
-0.2973255515098572,
0.6697973608970642,
-0.426102876663208,
0.168897807598114,
-0.026767387986183167,
-0.668935239315033,
-0.4884043335914612,
-0.22556647658348083,
0.08122731000185013,
0.40060311555862427,
-0.48263612389564514,
0.7750253081321716,
-0.006215221248567104,
-0.4375230669975281,
-0.8441155552864075,
0.47398173809051514,
0.4009249806404114,
0.8557164669036865,
0.3475044369697571,
-0.05488620325922966,
-0.5207880139350891,
-1.1009994745254517,
-0.32506728172302246,
-0.07082487642765045,
-0.1727074682712555,
0.43224772810935974,
0.4319704473018646,
-0.2661435306072235,
0.9037392139434814,
-0.457847535610199,
-0.3505517840385437,
-0.1303611546754837,
0.4020586609840393,
0.30142250657081604,
0.2539273202419281,
0.04276625066995621,
-0.49502602219581604,
-0.37137556076049805,
0.46186333894729614,
-0.780460774898529,
-0.3660390377044678,
0.13943202793598175,
-0.1184801533818245,
0.04974344000220299,
0.5638012886047363,
-0.5536441206932068,
0.08823826909065247,
0.6369296312332153,
-0.25154566764831543,
0.49627378582954407,
-0.6853724122047424,
-0.09778176993131638,
-0.8756192326545715,
0.0027328445576131344,
-0.020004641264677048,
-0.5124353170394897,
-0.3586880564689636,
0.04571092128753662,
0.012319290079176426,
-0.21650460362434387,
-0.5362049341201782,
0.7136703729629517,
-0.19893446564674377,
-0.13821740448474884,
-0.8858634829521179,
0.45339807868003845,
-0.07914233952760696,
0.2981853783130646,
0.1454707682132721,
0.768365740776062,
0.8221601843833923,
-0.6171764731407166,
0.6781994700431824,
0.2829643487930298,
-0.38815218210220337,
0.319082111120224,
-0.7677087187767029,
0.018695073202252388,
-0.050085391849279404,
0.12031370401382446,
-0.3901931643486023,
-0.4183715283870697,
0.06065205857157707,
-0.38065019249916077,
0.1655201017856598,
-0.10652167350053787,
-0.9051834344863892,
-0.2740880250930786,
0.2825881242752075,
0.3132880926132202,
0.6350938677787781,
-0.5355806350708008,
0.6228704452514648,
0.44499635696411133,
-0.021626371890306473,
-0.08716128766536713,
-0.14296413958072662,
0.054818831384181976,
0.04472830519080162,
-0.7084072828292847,
0.43598780035972595,
-0.13533411920070648,
-0.17760834097862244,
-0.15073226392269135,
0.30382564663887024,
0.18418803811073303,
0.3310132622718811,
0.11277114599943161,
0.11170431971549988,
-0.003616157453507185,
0.2654332220554352,
0.28500425815582275,
-0.592169463634491,
0.07065810263156891,
-0.4344927966594696,
0.6930908560752869,
-0.3947165012359619,
-0.4653737246990204,
-0.7291457653045654,
0.30110448598861694,
0.33016225695610046,
-0.4122617840766907,
0.8164257407188416,
0.6193902492523193,
-0.36009055376052856,
-0.0466524139046669,
-0.23125801980495453,
-0.3461768925189972,
-0.5988986492156982,
0.43976032733917236,
-0.13094323873519897,
-1.0364980697631836,
0.11872778832912445,
-0.3634498119354248,
0.04999572038650513,
0.3350684642791748,
0.986196756362915,
0.05895698443055153,
1.4582023620605469,
0.6759018301963806,
-0.34010547399520874,
0.1566905677318573,
0.29599910974502563,
0.1513107419013977,
-0.6748327016830444,
-0.012869305908679962,
-0.6720719337463379,
-0.30785855650901794,
-0.5853890776634216,
-0.3495985269546509,
0.46472641825675964,
-0.1550949513912201,
-0.10374026000499725,
0.11528678238391876,
-0.42696601152420044,
0.7785105109214783,
0.3036421239376068,
-0.14285339415073395,
0.337728887796402,
-0.12710987031459808,
-0.13464149832725525,
0.1520153433084488,
-0.7694299221038818,
-0.5374588370323181,
0.7080322504043579,
0.2520028054714203,
0.7288036942481995,
-0.14380502700805664,
0.5604041814804077,
-0.06464200466871262,
-0.01580352708697319,
-0.943756639957428,
0.5638207793235779,
-0.3150344491004944,
-0.5423172116279602,
-0.31000277400016785,
-0.571295976638794,
-1.302544116973877,
0.12278825789690018,
-0.258694589138031,
-0.771255373954773,
-0.39664319157600403,
0.1834481805562973,
-0.35072773694992065,
0.3242603838443756,
-0.3271334767341614,
0.9179173707962036,
-0.4948727786540985,
-0.4147850573062897,
-0.6097671985626221,
-0.5186150670051575,
-0.0243753083050251,
-0.3269231915473938,
0.6868371367454529,
-0.3529357314109802,
-0.008028704673051834,
0.6437951922416687,
-0.2904151380062103,
0.837702214717865,
0.07215896993875504,
-0.2611141800880432,
-0.09510476887226105,
0.027198271825909615,
0.704784095287323,
-0.025693239644169807,
-0.27572259306907654,
-0.047184258699417114,
-0.26222091913223267,
-0.4122619032859802,
-0.43432798981666565,
0.8800848126411438,
-0.9373610019683838,
-0.5635384917259216,
-0.23519539833068848,
-0.5808581113815308,
-0.4387314021587372,
0.4758707582950592,
0.15861907601356506,
0.4734061062335968,
-0.04014488682150841,
0.25285759568214417,
0.7515393495559692,
-0.3474627733230591,
0.37745344638824463,
0.6979745626449585,
-0.4142816960811615,
-0.08216202259063721,
0.8262158036231995,
-0.4723893702030182,
0.20996399223804474,
0.7654194831848145,
0.6186578273773193,
-0.3278334438800812,
-0.48997682332992554,
-0.3004068434238434,
0.589974582195282,
-0.2974916100502014,
-0.057483281940221786,
-0.39313259720802307,
-0.019779514521360397,
-0.5027478933334351,
-0.4777434766292572,
-0.6401813626289368,
-0.09618006646633148,
-0.5443236231803894,
0.06367477774620056,
0.44938531517982483,
0.6121873259544373,
-0.00630012433975935,
0.4280308783054352,
-0.8432872891426086,
0.5385227799415588,
0.28057488799095154,
0.5879692435264587,
-0.268431156873703,
-0.7520232796669006,
-0.47469231486320496,
0.15023767948150635,
-0.22294610738754272,
-0.31568285822868347,
0.6790888905525208,
0.4005783796310425,
0.5960984826087952,
0.11935089528560638,
-0.03702354431152344,
0.5891307592391968,
-0.5098027586936951,
0.27845895290374756,
-0.13765400648117065,
-0.8236814737319946,
0.7457501888275146,
-0.584525465965271,
0.5529118776321411,
0.5817629098892212,
0.25609511137008667,
-0.4068722426891327,
-0.40824851393699646,
-0.3412591218948364,
-0.5256343483924866,
0.7822346687316895,
0.15547770261764526,
-0.026118256151676178,
0.0003327406302560121,
0.43695104122161865,
0.08967355638742447,
0.300681471824646,
-0.3301437497138977,
-0.12697844207286835,
0.29148954153060913,
-0.44685736298561096,
-0.37866270542144775,
0.3893747925758362,
-0.07589618116617203,
-0.13422182202339172,
1.0129220485687256,
-0.3462837338447571,
-0.028596745803952217,
-0.19819344580173492,
0.10323792695999146,
-0.5664679408073425,
0.14589302241802216,
0.47008535265922546,
0.4297061562538147,
-0.2651612460613251,
-0.2007756233215332,
0.06965973973274231,
0.027201000601053238,
-0.010032154619693756,
-0.11428985744714737,
-0.022692836821079254,
-0.32712048292160034,
0.05561418458819389,
0.9167053699493408,
0.41622060537338257,
-1.0542418956756592,
0.19006378948688507,
-0.25209668278694153,
-0.36691445112228394,
-0.3215447962284088,
0.20547178387641907,
0.2940903902053833,
0.17030838131904602,
0.08064257353544235,
-0.029398512095212936,
-0.14370021224021912,
-0.42830291390419006,
0.0497397743165493,
0.6527292132377625,
-0.356731116771698,
-0.14894205331802368,
0.5655639171600342,
0.18695393204689026,
-0.8228113651275635,
0.5588714480400085,
-0.31450924277305603,
-0.27715355157852173,
0.45026251673698425,
0.4433653950691223,
1.0450379848480225,
0.049745287746191025,
0.035304658114910126,
0.19169314205646515,
0.3074950575828552,
-0.16251851618289948,
-0.11547442525625229,
0.2080831676721573,
-0.6925992369651794,
-0.7667078375816345,
-0.9937529563903809,
-0.766743540763855,
0.013480225577950478,
-0.5305375456809998,
0.531440019607544,
-0.6165309548377991,
0.08890280872583389,
0.15874041616916656,
0.14950436353683472,
-0.47879141569137573,
0.18018624186515808,
0.23448596894741058,
0.5527557134628296,
-0.631959855556488,
0.9342238903045654,
0.6850447058677673,
0.23300857841968536,
-0.6411863565444946,
-0.4889061450958252,
-0.0826522558927536,
-0.7202667593955994,
0.2836897671222687,
-0.12772560119628906,
-0.397053062915802,
0.10616843402385712,
-0.3046227991580963,
-0.9479168653488159,
0.852796196937561,
0.4039303660392761,
-0.9123000502586365,
0.1660398691892624,
0.17989696562290192,
0.7619708776473999,
-0.3196944296360016,
0.05455678328871727,
0.5235098600387573,
0.43995869159698486,
0.09180956333875656,
-1.2663687467575073,
-0.23216044902801514,
-0.004632364492863417,
-0.3300407826900482,
0.6578865051269531,
-0.920820415019989,
0.661126971244812,
0.22199513018131256,
0.22529149055480957,
0.07048702239990234,
0.6821479201316833,
0.32915496826171875,
0.0879516676068306,
0.24590259790420532,
0.3540741503238678,
0.8656267523765564,
0.24219471216201782,
1.1082406044006348,
-0.6930758953094482,
0.3961130380630493,
0.9562634825706482,
-0.46602723002433777,
0.6070603132247925,
0.28061941266059875,
-0.10674670338630676,
0.2803080677986145,
0.19316409528255463,
-0.1254415214061737,
0.2723276913166046,
0.010413594543933868,
-0.4410635232925415,
-0.6821392774581909,
-0.1572655737400055,
-0.12808546423912048,
0.5665502548217773,
0.44470685720443726,
-0.12352853268384933,
-0.3839345872402191,
-0.010045476257801056,
-0.12901586294174194,
0.37719419598579407,
-0.590329110622406,
0.7718696594238281,
0.284034788608551,
-0.6969044804573059,
0.4862091839313507,
0.5064510107040405,
0.607681930065155,
-0.708846390247345,
0.3444181978702545,
0.11192233860492706,
0.4239627420902252,
-0.07298391312360764,
-0.40074607729911804,
0.42272433638572693,
0.0035183255095034838,
-0.0426471121609211,
-0.2774796187877655,
0.7136061787605286,
-0.06463299691677094,
-0.8742274045944214,
0.29530760645866394,
0.24067631363868713,
0.1174241378903389,
-0.03474900498986244,
-0.7447687983512878,
-0.12082911282777786,
-0.11493009328842163,
0.12393911182880402,
0.7395654320716858,
0.27002090215682983,
0.05486001819372177,
1.1060690879821777,
0.4609406292438507,
0.1349600851535797,
-0.1482284814119339,
0.08286182582378387,
0.440562903881073,
-0.6884492635726929,
-0.4171673655509949,
-0.9811756610870361,
0.03663702681660652,
0.2505429983139038,
-0.2539573013782501,
0.6555353999137878,
0.4091349244117737,
0.7152676582336426,
0.062238071113824844,
0.7722980380058289,
0.4447985589504242,
0.6665921211242676,
-0.5977976322174072,
0.3929734528064728,
-0.5489019751548767,
0.17116405069828033,
-0.09912510961294174,
-0.546154797077179,
-0.367929607629776,
0.7454625964164734,
-0.3546404540538788,
0.0009150784462690353,
0.37014949321746826,
0.9825193285942078,
-0.04627470299601555,
0.15439589321613312,
0.48574623465538025,
0.28748801350593567,
0.590579092502594,
0.7577869892120361,
0.4900120198726654,
-0.11889000236988068,
0.3824255168437958,
-0.37916454672813416,
-0.24374976754188538,
-0.3879554569721222,
-1.0767920017242432,
-0.8932868838310242,
-0.08542414009571075,
-0.5031005144119263,
0.27788814902305603,
-0.01845025084912777,
1.3215736150741577,
0.5925378203392029,
-0.8004105091094971,
-0.45373573899269104,
-0.47586092352867126,
0.014825653284788132,
0.025959385558962822,
-0.13592323660850525,
-0.017207546159625053,
-0.46812868118286133,
-0.9093872308731079,
0.9579861164093018,
0.46729281544685364,
-0.27274811267852783,
-0.4336557984352112,
-0.1637311428785324,
-0.1427900642156601,
0.16938045620918274,
0.5869616270065308,
0.4049699604511261,
-0.6489300727844238,
-0.2327197790145874,
-0.12154337018728256,
0.00467417947947979,
0.03904355317354202,
0.5560265779495239,
-1.0299851894378662,
0.5660164952278137,
0.2384875863790512,
0.7149577140808105,
0.6606106162071228,
-0.1109607070684433,
0.6885680556297302,
-0.7816240191459656,
0.06664151698350906,
0.33572709560394287,
0.4159463346004486,
0.2501797080039978,
-0.14566968381404877,
0.13548102974891663,
0.1320720762014389,
-0.9504668116569519,
-0.5137050747871399,
0.3889043629169464,
-0.9181665778160095,
-0.28954920172691345,
0.9320926070213318,
0.20720620453357697,
-0.2724657952785492,
-0.1732608824968338,
-0.3586898744106293,
0.3685407340526581,
-0.5024789571762085,
0.8999903202056885,
0.5478154420852661,
-0.31741416454315186,
-0.04314596951007843,
-0.47240081429481506,
0.28650009632110596,
0.7390344142913818,
-0.7482033371925354,
0.19790904223918915,
0.37318626046180725,
0.045104604214429855,
-0.08721332997083664,
0.37103524804115295,
0.03999120369553566,
0.10127199441194534,
-0.3715992569923401,
-0.05046295374631882,
-0.23234599828720093,
-0.20352980494499207,
-0.5373744368553162,
0.09331702440977097,
0.29309913516044617,
0.249263197183609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08784v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08784v1
|
Refinement of an Epilepsy Dictionary through Human Annotation of Health-related posts on Instagram
| 2024-05-14T17:27:59 | 2024-05-14T17:27:59 |
Aehong Min, Xuan Wang, Rion Brattig Correia, Jordan Rozum, Wendy R. Miller, Luis M. Rocha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
We used a dictionary built from biomedical terminology extracted from various
sources such as DrugBank, MedDRA, MedlinePlus, TCMGeneDIT, to tag more than 8
million Instagram posts by users who have mentioned an epilepsy-relevant drug
at least once, between 2010 and early 2016. A random sample of 1,771 posts with
2,947 term matches was evaluated by human annotators to identify
false-positives. OpenAI's GPT series models were compared against human
annotation. Frequent terms with a high false-positive rate were removed from
the dictionary. Analysis of the estimated false-positive rates of the annotated
terms revealed 8 ambiguous terms (plus synonyms) used in Instagram posts, which
were removed from the original dictionary. To study the effect of removing
those terms, we constructed knowledge networks using the refined and the
original dictionaries and performed an eigenvector-centrality analysis on both
networks. We show that the refined dictionary thus produced leads to a
significantly different rank of important terms, as measured by their
eigenvector-centrality of the knowledge networks. Furthermore, the most
important terms obtained after refinement are of greater medical relevance. In
addition, we show that OpenAI's GPT series models fare worse than human
annotators in this task.
|
[
-0.6164388656616211,
-0.6353254914283752,
0.46719205379486084,
-0.14473803341388702,
-0.3625692129135132,
-0.047380492091178894,
-0.3637022078037262,
-0.9157947897911072,
0.943733811378479,
0.39454635977745056,
-0.1418159306049347,
-0.2760624885559082,
-0.8050914406776428,
0.37964922189712524,
-0.41491392254829407,
0.8745577335357666,
-0.23716561496257782,
0.012282859534025192,
0.017189832404255867,
-0.31355583667755127,
0.006909653078764677,
-0.4545406103134155,
-0.3704589307308197,
-0.4128648638725281,
0.6082065105438232,
0.0849570482969284,
0.44988763332366943,
0.17812013626098633,
0.7138777375221252,
0.1982814222574234,
-0.43468746542930603,
0.018435319885611534,
-0.363675981760025,
-0.1826726198196411,
-0.21720953285694122,
-0.08171065151691437,
-0.29086965322494507,
-0.1052364930510521,
0.2654725909233093,
0.7900049686431885,
-0.04745333641767502,
0.38039636611938477,
0.2270524799823761,
0.555363118648529,
-0.5683363080024719,
-0.1805189549922943,
-0.34193703532218933,
-0.04397903382778168,
-0.07902445644140244,
-0.3044357895851135,
0.14548005163669586,
-0.24418480694293976,
0.4099498391151428,
-0.8424638509750366,
0.39879217743873596,
-0.12089061737060547,
1.3025566339492798,
0.10264576971530914,
-0.11776204407215118,
-0.23610571026802063,
-0.5484151244163513,
0.17532917857170105,
-0.2513408362865448,
0.379665732383728,
0.6098705530166626,
0.3471270203590393,
-0.21082836389541626,
-1.148308515548706,
-0.5962783098220825,
-0.26602834463119507,
-0.3057805299758911,
-0.10309357196092606,
-0.2755986750125885,
0.25367632508277893,
0.4758385419845581,
0.17766737937927246,
-0.3468816876411438,
-0.1258488893508911,
-0.6402904987335205,
-0.3006157875061035,
0.2893901765346527,
-0.23224321007728577,
0.313787043094635,
-0.2546958029270172,
-0.4138931334018707,
0.3899170756340027,
-0.9091343879699707,
0.08815982192754745,
0.12850213050842285,
0.15554174780845642,
0.1981421858072281,
0.7677937746047974,
-0.33693525195121765,
0.5395445227622986,
0.2868388295173645,
-0.006491844076663256,
0.5164855718612671,
-0.7343513369560242,
-0.26061731576919556,
0.2775781452655792,
0.6108565926551819,
0.7913018465042114,
0.34535735845565796,
-0.39298519492149353,
-0.14949317276477814,
0.04834745451807976,
0.5312453508377075,
-0.9618798494338989,
-0.363603800535202,
0.38248759508132935,
-0.7063446044921875,
-0.1812589168548584,
-0.038249608129262924,
-0.3975248634815216,
-0.8783838748931885,
-0.3290567994117737,
0.76019686460495,
-0.5474360585212708,
-0.2876681685447693,
0.2522929012775421,
-0.42546260356903076,
-0.1376262754201889,
0.35323306918144226,
-0.7477074265480042,
0.32279616594314575,
0.4566258490085602,
0.703923225402832,
0.48895809054374695,
-0.028838982805609703,
0.08832979202270508,
0.019902396947145462,
-0.17828623950481415,
0.9165292978286743,
-0.22742298245429993,
-0.1924954354763031,
-0.15021568536758423,
0.2534244656562805,
0.05805942788720131,
-0.7531082630157471,
0.6548894643783569,
-0.3593835234642029,
-0.1823326200246811,
-0.6632703542709351,
-0.7947132587432861,
-0.44723817706108093,
0.07638245075941086,
-0.5554822087287903,
0.35666370391845703,
-0.19178056716918945,
-0.6644142866134644,
0.8990536332130432,
-0.6392554640769958,
-0.4558621346950531,
0.35285791754722595,
-0.14372648298740387,
-0.03551119938492775,
0.04023824632167816,
0.3884807229042053,
0.4862660765647888,
-0.3485470712184906,
0.16475334763526917,
-0.12060070037841797,
-0.5001605749130249,
0.16646406054496765,
0.2612365782260895,
0.6609752774238586,
0.16946002840995789,
-0.08347690105438232,
-0.11148004233837128,
-0.8945932984352112,
-0.17105667293071747,
-0.23079511523246765,
-0.02875915914773941,
-0.8244566917419434,
0.03412146493792534,
-0.05650782957673073,
0.15775686502456665,
0.012826562859117985,
-1.1425795555114746,
0.01305556669831276,
-0.6180742383003235,
0.7803776264190674,
0.47780293226242065,
0.6031438708305359,
0.04219340533018112,
-0.5080429315567017,
0.060003671795129776,
0.26130974292755127,
0.4432016909122467,
0.08863051980733871,
-0.9925030469894409,
-0.2124757319688797,
-0.5533400774002075,
0.2466915398836136,
0.20426973700523376,
-0.4553617835044861,
0.6817574501037598,
-0.3060494363307953,
-0.4850987493991852,
-0.7353190779685974,
-0.11513466387987137,
0.13977491855621338,
0.8873785138130188,
0.5677452683448792,
-0.3540264070034027,
-0.43624523282051086,
-1.1487467288970947,
-0.63861483335495,
-0.011183719150722027,
-0.11419729143381119,
-0.08336090296506882,
0.7069211602210999,
-0.4396834075450897,
0.8930911421775818,
-0.2804783284664154,
-0.39059683680534363,
0.4672328531742096,
-0.03822550177574158,
0.18372708559036255,
0.1980239748954773,
0.5593143701553345,
-0.8735960721969604,
-0.41563501954078674,
0.15624864399433136,
-0.4769854247570038,
0.05906827002763748,
-0.0008095907978713512,
0.07513470202684402,
-0.2909645140171051,
0.41477879881858826,
-0.4948756694793701,
0.6596654653549194,
-0.026349252089858055,
-0.2602134346961975,
0.3419347405433655,
-0.013003918342292309,
0.3307652473449707,
-1.1668461561203003,
0.17788377404212952,
0.5528547167778015,
-0.07904497534036636,
-0.5330734252929688,
0.11574556678533554,
0.17247019708156586,
0.18950816988945007,
-0.21109020709991455,
0.49054914712905884,
-0.113937608897686,
0.3951733410358429,
0.1120026707649231,
0.10229741036891937,
-0.004489869810640812,
0.19186434149742126,
-0.5205571055412292,
0.4937834143638611,
0.5143828988075256,
-0.5433689951896667,
0.4374825358390808,
0.2758627235889435,
-0.4278238117694855,
0.2849433124065399,
-0.6681280732154846,
-0.2252994328737259,
-0.2600046396255493,
-0.22031359374523163,
-1.3219738006591797,
-0.29772067070007324,
0.359042763710022,
-0.5550640821456909,
0.11277155578136444,
-0.1672501266002655,
-0.7118193507194519,
-0.29797986149787903,
-0.33715125918388367,
-0.003255280666053295,
0.4999823272228241,
-0.7328016757965088,
0.3012676239013672,
0.44813621044158936,
0.10301826149225235,
-0.15001796185970306,
-0.7975090146064758,
0.2223561555147171,
-0.09324919432401657,
-0.6613251566886902,
0.6820427775382996,
0.11587875336408615,
-0.5262513160705566,
0.3888944089412689,
-0.10371984541416168,
-0.1167309582233429,
0.013133011758327484,
0.32341206073760986,
-0.22457680106163025,
0.37071457505226135,
0.6809917688369751,
0.11249558627605438,
0.25247201323509216,
0.02198551967740059,
-0.0834309384226799,
0.31306642293930054,
0.0077452403493225574,
-0.08957529813051224,
-0.5800991654396057,
0.06304403394460678,
0.30035725235939026,
-0.000008717931450519245,
0.6931127905845642,
0.23749978840351105,
-0.8707606196403503,
0.07597208768129349,
-0.3722635507583618,
-0.49290698766708374,
-0.45407652854919434,
0.1470794826745987,
-0.384039044380188,
-0.8053564429283142,
0.7129289507865906,
-0.08954296261072159,
-0.10886633396148682,
0.506419837474823,
0.4176160991191864,
-0.2808758020401001,
0.8475213646888733,
0.28925660252571106,
0.3500780463218689,
0.3174183666706085,
-0.11205147951841354,
0.25957441329956055,
-0.8515639305114746,
-0.13196362555027008,
-0.31233301758766174,
-0.3648702800273895,
-0.8210784792900085,
0.2888503968715668,
0.46739068627357483,
-0.008760319091379642,
-0.28893280029296875,
0.349210262298584,
-0.844099760055542,
0.22378525137901306,
0.43555837869644165,
0.6805894374847412,
0.19143441319465637,
0.5241212248802185,
-0.21613116562366486,
-0.1413474977016449,
-0.24993354082107544,
-0.34908828139305115,
1.5341875553131104,
0.1496777981519699,
0.3769972026348114,
0.13749268651008606,
0.7384988069534302,
0.16364794969558716,
0.5179508328437805,
-0.6473817825317383,
0.40038740634918213,
-0.32724955677986145,
-0.4286555051803589,
0.09713567048311234,
-0.2846939265727997,
-0.7160600423812866,
-0.05623278021812439,
-0.3118434548377991,
-0.79695063829422,
0.4271438419818878,
-0.10489228367805481,
-0.8274303078651428,
0.3164418041706085,
-1.093597412109375,
0.3587050139904022,
0.1476237177848816,
-0.1733824610710144,
-0.28618183732032776,
-0.5876498818397522,
0.3116193115711212,
-0.4350622892379761,
-0.07495325803756714,
0.24805933237075806,
-0.12801270186901093,
0.9814420342445374,
-0.9802770018577576,
0.7466495633125305,
-0.028407061472535133,
0.21570459008216858,
0.3435301184654236,
-0.331706702709198,
0.1085289716720581,
-0.0652010515332222,
0.06340339779853821,
0.45125094056129456,
0.12733076512813568,
-0.21842961013317108,
-0.3242592215538025,
0.7605503797531128,
-0.8196398615837097,
-0.34883373975753784,
-0.23525024950504303,
0.11567429453134537,
-0.1977214813232422,
0.26720109581947327,
0.6087427139282227,
0.5886985659599304,
0.005964196287095547,
-0.14842574298381805,
0.43713152408599854,
0.06265000253915787,
0.19585220515727997,
0.20888598263263702,
-0.05839129537343979,
-0.737312912940979,
0.6209354400634766,
0.8009155988693237,
-0.007068287115544081,
0.24787405133247375,
0.1505679488182068,
-0.11244354397058487,
-0.5321418046951294,
-0.05036327615380287,
0.5581070780754089,
-0.6890591979026794,
0.23336565494537354,
-0.32764992117881775,
-0.0859966054558754,
-0.6664955615997314,
-0.04842967912554741,
0.016499536111950874,
-0.5655286312103271,
-0.08000843226909637,
-0.20897291600704193,
0.8182855248451233,
0.8342701196670532,
0.031668614596128464,
0.1655774861574173,
-0.6790518164634705,
0.4446416199207306,
0.27566128969192505,
0.6983548998832703,
-0.2977212071418762,
-0.42016616463661194,
-0.34517568349838257,
0.1736213117837906,
-0.008578203618526459,
-0.8411555886268616,
0.06297418475151062,
0.2561364769935608,
0.41457080841064453,
0.5794631242752075,
-0.13795530796051025,
0.8320603370666504,
-0.1435246616601944,
0.6804832816123962,
0.26714444160461426,
-0.37725886702537537,
0.3239087462425232,
-0.12083172053098679,
-0.016145560890436172,
0.6656584739685059,
0.6000580191612244,
-0.6965520977973938,
0.021114740520715714,
-0.5578429102897644,
-0.8857601881027222,
0.15257121622562408,
0.16713842749595642,
-0.22479864954948425,
-0.15224546194076538,
0.9719657301902771,
0.06194782629609108,
0.3001706004142761,
-0.14908194541931152,
-0.452609121799469,
-0.242287740111351,
0.055679820477962494,
0.08719345927238464,
-0.38873574137687683,
-0.4133349359035492,
-0.7615787982940674,
0.5463637113571167,
0.09571477770805359,
0.36218494176864624,
0.6629413366317749,
-0.047751534730196,
-0.263772189617157,
-0.11654946953058243,
0.40431755781173706,
0.8451390266418457,
-0.4608445167541504,
-0.06342016160488129,
-0.3492467999458313,
-1.0326811075210571,
-0.025460077449679375,
0.48149529099464417,
-0.4427759051322937,
-0.055091749876737595,
0.35295602679252625,
0.5867562294006348,
-0.149258553981781,
-0.5193794369697571,
0.4549739956855774,
-0.23819296061992645,
-0.2999004125595093,
-0.43256211280822754,
-0.3380565047264099,
-0.12217628955841064,
0.07183657586574554,
0.26543429493904114,
0.5580445528030396,
0.14577287435531616,
-0.3544338643550873,
0.4241400957107544,
-0.014332598075270653,
-0.46823936700820923,
-0.6524439454078674,
0.7194851636886597,
0.15509916841983795,
-0.01759994775056839,
0.380130410194397,
-0.36977729201316833,
-0.31442102789878845,
0.5675152540206909,
-0.027168620377779007,
1.0715305805206299,
0.04977857694029808,
0.009664335288107395,
0.7000070810317993,
0.609911322593689,
0.019096383824944496,
0.5301668047904968,
0.21246565878391266,
-0.9043617248535156,
-0.24330586194992065,
-0.565207839012146,
0.019615141674876213,
0.0018939345609396696,
-0.40447673201560974,
0.38560566306114197,
-0.5767838954925537,
-0.7698909640312195,
0.3751739263534546,
-0.03286504000425339,
-0.5788035988807678,
0.23607848584651947,
-0.07837164402008057,
0.8150483965873718,
-0.7517966032028198,
0.6627752184867859,
1.2382514476776123,
-0.9464468955993652,
-0.6554530262947083,
0.32461047172546387,
-0.11243241280317307,
-0.39982932806015015,
0.6069577932357788,
0.1997051239013672,
0.1600499004125595,
-0.15158438682556152,
-0.545591413974762,
-0.7596929669380188,
0.9974395036697388,
-0.01347760483622551,
-0.5848742127418518,
0.1111680343747139,
0.11578550189733505,
0.8859690427780151,
-0.11232572793960571,
0.1790761649608612,
0.4115138053894043,
0.41400688886642456,
-0.14086806774139404,
-1.046352744102478,
0.16398532688617706,
-0.4478587210178375,
-0.14547602832317352,
0.2759923040866852,
-0.3940311372280121,
1.0455973148345947,
-0.22215643525123596,
-0.3991554379463196,
-0.08448847383260727,
0.11867301911115646,
-0.18330040574073792,
0.09135880321264267,
0.3958796262741089,
0.7836762070655823,
0.7895137071609497,
0.02212328463792801,
1.1121470928192139,
-0.6403895020484924,
0.3586971163749695,
0.7190707921981812,
-0.33312490582466125,
0.5902561545372009,
0.7081254720687866,
-0.1114739328622818,
0.1760721057653427,
0.8489173054695129,
0.16974209249019623,
0.6793765425682068,
-0.016459180042147636,
-0.27925801277160645,
-0.12309348583221436,
-0.1405484527349472,
-0.318752646446228,
-0.06197779253125191,
0.6123024821281433,
-0.6693299412727356,
-0.4470970630645752,
0.3345300853252411,
0.10990756750106812,
-0.10037822276353836,
-0.628763735294342,
0.6816782355308533,
0.04363282769918442,
-0.3469862639904022,
0.8438307046890259,
-0.14688777923583984,
0.6061244010925293,
-0.3724508583545685,
-0.0024504067841917276,
0.09917476773262024,
0.2514388859272003,
-0.39666542410850525,
-0.7836435437202454,
0.28299614787101746,
-0.21244436502456665,
0.04393959790468216,
0.09125413000583649,
0.7901335954666138,
-0.31815454363822937,
-0.30825749039649963,
0.45412006974220276,
0.19412951171398163,
0.04452948272228241,
-0.42316773533821106,
-0.416646808385849,
-0.5956111550331116,
-0.1356307566165924,
-0.38635388016700745,
0.16376350820064545,
0.2171226590871811,
-0.18884366750717163,
0.4725923240184784,
0.5277630686759949,
0.5335966944694519,
0.08669845759868622,
0.00036919236299581826,
1.0320405960083008,
-0.4070754051208496,
-0.34322747588157654,
-0.6383227109909058,
0.10304566472768784,
-0.20353154838085175,
-0.6980528235435486,
0.7778586149215698,
0.2973129153251648,
0.8371334671974182,
0.17282640933990479,
0.9885305166244507,
-0.21568740904331207,
0.8046385645866394,
-0.13660751283168793,
1.2130112648010254,
-0.8271776437759399,
0.2663405239582062,
-0.07984300702810287,
-0.42473044991493225,
-0.5649202466011047,
0.2746603488922119,
-0.29996544122695923,
-0.04456726089119911,
0.6865247488021851,
0.9896454215049744,
0.17990680038928986,
0.10415840893983841,
0.1423068344593048,
0.633115291595459,
0.31151413917541504,
0.20529691874980927,
0.32130366563796997,
-0.5447809100151062,
-0.038043055683374405,
-0.6486725807189941,
-0.2897321581840515,
-0.3525303900241852,
-0.4045911133289337,
-0.7067071795463562,
-0.8194913268089294,
-0.3182850480079651,
-0.5250782370567322,
0.2608012557029724,
1.3414371013641357,
0.2748446464538574,
-0.6539078950881958,
0.2505137622356415,
0.02577468380331993,
-0.12343001365661621,
-0.6244340538978577,
-0.14017356932163239,
0.4475702941417694,
0.07940186560153961,
-0.3101414144039154,
0.18419897556304932,
0.03623828664422035,
-0.2181398570537567,
0.0032637149561196566,
0.3392137885093689,
-0.359034925699234,
-0.05962817370891571,
0.6529062986373901,
0.139325812458992,
-0.5633953213691711,
-0.6566985845565796,
-0.05395988002419472,
-0.24568191170692444,
0.0960099995136261,
0.5269091725349426,
-0.8953577876091003,
0.9368616938591003,
0.7128661870956421,
0.1798705756664276,
0.17081081867218018,
0.009117118082940578,
0.16688548028469086,
-0.5746549963951111,
-0.009994768537580967,
0.19039057195186615,
0.6114444732666016,
0.16954770684242249,
-0.29880738258361816,
0.4309004843235016,
0.708190381526947,
-0.3827448785305023,
-0.5527783036231995,
-0.019334973767399788,
-0.7357664108276367,
-0.32032933831214905,
1.0415157079696655,
0.21808192133903503,
-0.6028315424919128,
-0.3181419372558594,
-0.1727166473865509,
0.09418602287769318,
-0.4463541507720947,
0.8981814384460449,
0.6524946689605713,
-0.15850403904914856,
0.29443225264549255,
-0.5288390517234802,
0.6207818388938904,
-0.10286358743906021,
-0.35312584042549133,
-0.2679188847541809,
0.24429403245449066,
0.4924938976764679,
0.28992751240730286,
0.6361714601516724,
-0.14474020898342133,
0.3185178339481354,
-0.13894237577915192,
0.5940427184104919,
-0.22473524510860443,
0.07831095159053802,
-0.46000996232032776,
0.23216812312602997,
-0.11827083677053452,
-0.33646905422210693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08760v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08760v2
|
Is the Pope Catholic? Yes, the Pope is Catholic. Generative Evaluation of Non-Literal Intent Resolution in LLMs
| 2024-05-14T16:48:56 | 2024-06-19T19:07:47 |
Akhila Yerukola, Saujas Vaduguru, Daniel Fried, Maarten Sap
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Humans often express their communicative intents indirectly or non-literally,
which requires their interlocutors -- human or AI -- to understand beyond the
literal meaning of words. While most existing work has focused on
discriminative evaluations, we present a new approach to generatively evaluate
large language models' (LLMs') intention understanding by examining their
responses to non-literal utterances. Ideally, an LLM should respond in line
with the true intention of a non-literal utterance, not its literal
interpretation. Our findings show that LLMs struggle to generate pragmatically
relevant responses to non-literal language, achieving only 50-55% accuracy on
average. While explicitly providing oracle intentions significantly improves
performance (e.g., 75% for Mistral-Instruct), this still indicates challenges
in leveraging given intentions to produce appropriate responses. Using
chain-of-thought to make models spell out intentions yields much smaller gains
(60% for Mistral-Instruct). These findings suggest that LLMs are not yet
effective pragmatic interlocutors, highlighting the need for better approaches
for modeling intentions and utilizing them for pragmatic generation.
|
[
-0.11236689239740372,
-0.7810512781143188,
0.7420688271522522,
0.6101627945899963,
-0.5170881152153015,
-0.15372683107852936,
-0.4698511064052582,
-0.39736953377723694,
0.15748071670532227,
0.3645683825016022,
-0.6970837116241455,
-0.5546481013298035,
-0.639435887336731,
0.39139652252197266,
-0.48196104168891907,
0.8445322513580322,
0.05700862407684326,
0.2651463747024536,
-0.0720820277929306,
0.15541745722293854,
-0.13234786689281464,
-0.27955010533332825,
-0.7268782258033752,
-0.3090386688709259,
0.3486916720867157,
0.33266010880470276,
0.7672058939933777,
0.4826838970184326,
0.7500489950180054,
0.3278975188732147,
-0.2623010575771332,
0.24674400687217712,
-0.6189391016960144,
-0.16946952044963837,
-0.26761820912361145,
-0.3999567925930023,
-0.2596588730812073,
0.27522093057632446,
0.7571278810501099,
0.6937578916549683,
-0.11847006529569626,
0.21685808897018433,
-0.07869260758161545,
0.5848755240440369,
-0.5018386244773865,
0.17087171971797943,
-0.9037671685218811,
0.2245492935180664,
0.16593338549137115,
-0.5262096524238586,
-0.7307436466217041,
-0.39966997504234314,
0.3645597994327545,
-0.6284178495407104,
0.24216586351394653,
-0.050696782767772675,
0.5041151642799377,
0.2100941240787506,
-0.48091551661491394,
-0.7311277389526367,
-0.7640036344528198,
0.8858655691146851,
-0.7321999073028564,
0.5480488538742065,
0.3489323556423187,
0.06495680660009384,
-0.3723769187927246,
-0.6623281836509705,
-0.6145310997962952,
-0.5538720488548279,
0.018347224220633507,
0.18289779126644135,
-0.15547671914100647,
0.44445306062698364,
0.2191106677055359,
0.5982781052589417,
-0.4489811360836029,
0.17851926386356354,
-0.39207717776298523,
0.03244014456868172,
0.7803652286529541,
0.25114548206329346,
0.3211680054664612,
-0.00798021350055933,
-0.5251551866531372,
-0.023620983585715294,
-0.7002355456352234,
0.1057400330901146,
0.3323931097984314,
0.2761242389678955,
-0.0859946683049202,
0.7894898056983948,
0.11770624667406082,
0.7750176191329956,
0.15255172550678253,
-0.38859230279922485,
-0.28577709197998047,
-0.6295036673545837,
-0.3868672549724579,
0.25916287302970886,
0.7844217419624329,
0.5203812718391418,
0.6136766672134399,
-0.24824626743793488,
-0.1370534896850586,
0.1631559431552887,
0.47070714831352234,
-0.8444783687591553,
0.12751416862010956,
0.1864437758922577,
-0.5094639658927917,
-0.1879173070192337,
0.09343745559453964,
-0.36740776896476746,
-0.13503091037273407,
-0.3990556001663208,
0.03599400445818901,
-0.4044332206249237,
-0.07135254889726639,
0.17802314460277557,
-0.18815673887729645,
0.4505970776081085,
0.5353614687919617,
-0.8788551688194275,
0.18269941210746765,
0.8531523942947388,
0.5608313083648682,
0.1772359311580658,
-0.3178909122943878,
-0.5889193415641785,
0.23116092383861542,
-0.7957963347434998,
0.6666679382324219,
-0.6300159096717834,
-0.7638662457466125,
0.06480284035205841,
-0.0083615155890584,
-0.15277376770973206,
-0.6383141875267029,
0.8764310479164124,
-0.28476545214653015,
-0.040051236748695374,
-0.26320427656173706,
-0.5073012709617615,
-0.12205591052770615,
0.23796933889389038,
-0.4369491934776306,
0.6808391809463501,
-0.1468074768781662,
-0.3910597860813141,
0.4918394088745117,
-0.7137720584869385,
-0.4087570905685425,
0.15769928693771362,
-0.33762890100479126,
-0.15074944496154785,
0.5352230072021484,
0.005927602294832468,
0.28749603033065796,
-0.4722195863723755,
0.5873419642448425,
-0.2890653610229492,
-0.5057414174079895,
0.5858613848686218,
-0.620890736579895,
0.5452040433883667,
-0.022882523015141487,
-0.29259613156318665,
0.35233911871910095,
-0.578335165977478,
0.1878051906824112,
-0.03239031881093979,
-0.33336442708969116,
-0.31713101267814636,
0.1926240175962448,
-0.20132587850093842,
0.36645790934562683,
0.33426547050476074,
-0.46593743562698364,
0.2713824510574341,
-0.6307593584060669,
0.5308400392532349,
1.0056676864624023,
-0.023753196001052856,
0.4472655951976776,
-0.20204384624958038,
0.43917548656463623,
-0.17325058579444885,
0.5306586623191833,
0.08782961964607239,
-0.6959854364395142,
-0.7568509578704834,
-0.1960730403661728,
-0.23189102113246918,
0.3418503999710083,
-0.6918835043907166,
0.1879139095544815,
-0.37647104263305664,
-0.40098536014556885,
-0.4493038058280945,
0.29516923427581787,
0.8220739364624023,
0.28219184279441833,
0.12425253540277481,
-0.11375752091407776,
-0.37196511030197144,
-1.1034374237060547,
-0.6155271530151367,
-0.854963481426239,
0.0830787718296051,
0.304402232170105,
0.5441724061965942,
0.036175843328237534,
0.7231556177139282,
-0.19805589318275452,
-0.2215929478406906,
-0.3376774191856384,
0.32021915912628174,
0.23394982516765594,
0.10267815738916397,
0.26081958413124084,
-1.1238468885421753,
-0.44020602107048035,
0.07725075632333755,
-0.7639980316162109,
0.11439478397369385,
-0.22930945456027985,
0.042636774480342865,
-0.08427195996046066,
0.24314039945602417,
-0.6897756457328796,
0.5466696619987488,
0.48626309633255005,
-0.34073832631111145,
0.5249534249305725,
-0.3550645411014557,
0.11161065846681595,
-0.6801051497459412,
-0.2538061738014221,
0.07900384813547134,
0.21086890995502472,
-0.7986811995506287,
-0.14362508058547974,
0.050674114376306534,
-0.002611960982903838,
-0.8820317983627319,
0.697257399559021,
-0.4236515164375305,
-0.3529435992240906,
-0.11660928279161453,
0.09344540536403656,
-0.03170039877295494,
0.26942363381385803,
0.4535953402519226,
1.103484869003296,
0.12722179293632507,
-0.8437834978103638,
0.2248396873474121,
0.36336755752563477,
-0.45007774233818054,
0.4354611039161682,
-0.6485966444015503,
0.18402552604675293,
-0.2354917973279953,
0.17104274034500122,
-1.0103857517242432,
-0.22387255728244781,
0.31994885206222534,
-0.4541104733943939,
-0.0006274096085689962,
-0.07467198371887207,
-0.6978417634963989,
-0.42822837829589844,
-0.2705278694629669,
0.3980778753757477,
0.3245573341846466,
-0.6261920928955078,
0.4511856436729431,
0.028769994154572487,
0.021743284538388252,
-0.36523202061653137,
-0.8769726157188416,
0.13967083394527435,
-0.2630636990070343,
-0.7429256439208984,
0.3824915587902069,
-0.15407037734985352,
-0.5739574432373047,
-0.20973409712314606,
0.04164661094546318,
-0.21509097516536713,
-0.0032344539649784565,
0.152831569314003,
0.25511062145233154,
-0.055928152054548264,
0.02560059353709221,
-0.00612798985093832,
0.2085765302181244,
0.3402234613895416,
-0.06542040407657623,
0.15861786901950836,
-0.22245436906814575,
-0.5415676832199097,
-0.88093101978302,
0.2570747435092926,
0.6798278093338013,
-0.20189526677131653,
0.738598108291626,
0.2737884223461151,
-0.15897724032402039,
-0.025677992030978203,
-0.4541349411010742,
-0.4540214538574219,
-0.45477592945098877,
0.163822740316391,
-0.4286821484565735,
-0.7810129523277283,
0.32442426681518555,
-0.1901041567325592,
0.14991414546966553,
0.006665355525910854,
0.7399831414222717,
-0.026512661948800087,
0.9663105010986328,
0.4126456677913666,
0.5270779132843018,
0.3720727860927582,
-0.2603839337825775,
0.5988954901695251,
-0.9900676608085632,
-0.2149255871772766,
-0.2376583218574524,
-0.2306193858385086,
-0.7204758524894714,
-0.652336061000824,
0.25394439697265625,
0.26631268858909607,
0.2404266744852066,
0.2386326789855957,
-0.6030673384666443,
0.12967549264431,
0.10040398687124252,
-0.21655701100826263,
0.4832085072994232,
-0.04236448183655739,
0.11688968539237976,
-0.24167664349079132,
-0.47347700595855713,
-0.854089081287384,
0.9302399158477783,
0.323781818151474,
0.8537635207176208,
0.30648285150527954,
0.6135523915290833,
-0.024492787197232246,
0.6799271106719971,
-0.989907443523407,
0.6998835206031799,
-0.12167877703905106,
-0.6343419551849365,
-0.3081606328487396,
-0.2590245008468628,
-0.8437862992286682,
0.5171576738357544,
0.14340287446975708,
-0.7853814363479614,
0.3547336757183075,
0.20611558854579926,
-0.13814671337604523,
0.17152056097984314,
-0.7440898418426514,
0.7084426283836365,
-0.356533020734787,
-0.1517980545759201,
-0.042772553861141205,
-0.34686166048049927,
0.6271501183509827,
-0.08829472213983536,
0.17446941137313843,
-0.20679275691509247,
-0.1887202113866806,
0.572976291179657,
-0.3492455780506134,
0.9636779427528381,
-0.0008597218547947705,
-0.40110915899276733,
0.4721926748752594,
-0.13208068907260895,
0.7797718048095703,
0.1537630259990692,
-0.283943235874176,
0.11162477731704712,
-0.25334033370018005,
-0.05268397182226181,
-0.9486557245254517,
0.5362019538879395,
-0.47980761528015137,
-0.7453266978263855,
-0.2895558476448059,
-0.5350196957588196,
-0.05208480358123779,
-0.16111895442008972,
0.31501126289367676,
0.09473679959774017,
-0.553095281124115,
0.025486944243311882,
0.5487406253814697,
-0.26325857639312744,
0.33920565247535706,
0.8675850629806519,
-0.1234532818198204,
-0.27880674600601196,
0.7276612520217896,
0.0512687973678112,
0.4016624391078949,
0.4251628518104553,
0.23453973233699799,
-0.6759704351425171,
-0.47128644585609436,
-0.44144606590270996,
0.38915613293647766,
-0.7161172032356262,
0.17860735952854156,
-0.3993368148803711,
-0.1396523416042328,
-0.32601499557495117,
-0.189383864402771,
-0.2845578193664551,
-0.19442106783390045,
-0.4388085901737213,
-0.11054588109254837,
0.27856531739234924,
0.755705714225769,
0.06286051124334335,
0.3545137643814087,
-0.6153680682182312,
0.3001600205898285,
0.30698662996292114,
-0.07037220150232315,
-0.1689651757478714,
-0.40380752086639404,
0.247004896402359,
0.23112785816192627,
-0.3471717834472656,
-0.8494501709938049,
0.3820381760597229,
0.382129043340683,
0.49542269110679626,
0.7131134271621704,
0.19847175478935242,
0.983287513256073,
-0.5412026047706604,
0.7016769051551819,
0.29888784885406494,
-0.9672357439994812,
0.7927724123001099,
-0.16265608370304108,
0.1505722552537918,
0.4600852131843567,
0.34642836451530457,
-0.495502769947052,
-0.5695264339447021,
-0.5229448676109314,
-0.5325618982315063,
0.7466773390769958,
0.45283621549606323,
0.24912618100643158,
-0.5232999324798584,
0.5011665225028992,
-0.16789306700229645,
0.29896509647369385,
-0.7152241468429565,
-0.14924077689647675,
0.23401907086372375,
0.0450156070291996,
-0.1349707543849945,
-0.409028023481369,
-0.20648892223834991,
-0.3160414397716522,
0.4426102340221405,
-0.18453720211982727,
0.5195362567901611,
0.38822823762893677,
-0.14479508996009827,
-0.16861559450626373,
0.5736420750617981,
0.9652523398399353,
1.0180675983428955,
-0.08240918815135956,
0.08327324688434601,
0.09339562803506851,
-0.445183128118515,
0.2705481946468353,
-0.25632819533348083,
-0.038215480744838715,
0.10372533649206161,
0.5376428961753845,
0.7371044158935547,
0.4030468761920929,
-0.8052206635475159,
0.7118982672691345,
-0.4068555235862732,
-0.2690163850784302,
-0.5785782337188721,
-0.06468480825424194,
0.019569814205169678,
0.0726713016629219,
0.15728096663951874,
-0.3761926591396332,
0.2527364194393158,
-0.6656022667884827,
-0.05391732230782509,
0.6688392162322998,
-0.5913977026939392,
-0.4641789495944977,
0.3196944296360016,
0.15604861080646515,
-0.5066964030265808,
0.8348331451416016,
-0.32492807507514954,
-0.5710335373878479,
0.7109094262123108,
0.8861317038536072,
0.9511388540267944,
-0.33532676100730896,
0.3767658770084381,
0.1905335783958435,
0.4664255976676941,
0.1854434758424759,
0.6333470344543457,
-0.3352578282356262,
-0.6935230493545532,
-0.7772521376609802,
-0.7066608667373657,
-0.3196665346622467,
0.09513090550899506,
-0.79618901014328,
0.11771290749311447,
-0.50253826379776,
-0.21576793491840363,
0.043212924152612686,
-0.2449180781841278,
-0.42737749218940735,
0.0868411585688591,
-0.2493690401315689,
0.943601667881012,
-0.6993656158447266,
0.8843262791633606,
0.8342926502227783,
-0.18773682415485382,
-0.8098625540733337,
0.14161907136440277,
-0.18175046145915985,
-0.8993020057678223,
1.2858715057373047,
0.2389775961637497,
-0.2762918472290039,
-0.03483137488365173,
-0.26980137825012207,
-0.46027910709381104,
0.8679304122924805,
0.49842754006385803,
-0.721833348274231,
-0.24775445461273193,
0.5152214169502258,
0.570388913154602,
-0.33787238597869873,
0.26817965507507324,
0.35750502347946167,
0.7187888026237488,
0.293620765209198,
-1.0265934467315674,
-0.12861086428165436,
-0.17148710787296295,
0.3402613401412964,
0.3637714982032776,
-0.5495096445083618,
0.7567635178565979,
-0.39583873748779297,
-0.46679502725601196,
0.1674453467130661,
0.6633536219596863,
0.4013761579990387,
0.3712863326072693,
0.4022417366504669,
0.6247285604476929,
0.5205152034759521,
0.03117741458117962,
1.3008867502212524,
-0.2846146821975708,
0.1781528741121292,
0.9442870020866394,
-0.22689396142959595,
0.7168758511543274,
0.8326262831687927,
-0.22573654353618622,
0.21697010099887848,
0.6210957765579224,
0.3096468448638916,
0.4055456519126892,
0.3067314326763153,
-0.6569440960884094,
-0.3068573772907257,
-0.44842103123664856,
-0.12930484116077423,
0.5513982772827148,
0.6567137837409973,
-0.7098820209503174,
-0.14331300556659698,
-0.03252248093485832,
-0.29999637603759766,
0.1321692168712616,
-0.3224942684173584,
0.907155454158783,
0.2523823380470276,
-0.9667538404464722,
0.7025731205940247,
0.00881161354482174,
0.4256342649459839,
-0.3977523148059845,
-0.2992299795150757,
0.20783905684947968,
0.12570911645889282,
-0.2232845574617386,
-0.8297185897827148,
0.37358322739601135,
0.06802865862846375,
-0.2654820680618286,
-0.29802989959716797,
0.47373494505882263,
-0.3055970370769501,
-0.4789286255836487,
0.47705140709877014,
0.16951540112495422,
0.47702065110206604,
0.011798073537647724,
-0.840995728969574,
0.20020495355129242,
-0.04252040758728981,
0.13959267735481262,
0.06851531565189362,
0.41031184792518616,
-0.3456377685070038,
0.6928998827934265,
0.9906356334686279,
0.06529911607503891,
0.32526859641075134,
0.21045516431331635,
0.5891963839530945,
-0.5668321847915649,
-0.23692116141319275,
-1.086037278175354,
0.2823038101196289,
0.11349369585514069,
-0.38532307744026184,
0.7389306426048279,
0.4824768602848053,
0.843662440776825,
-0.018902108073234558,
0.4385414719581604,
0.2564769387245178,
-0.047406330704689026,
-0.5673409700393677,
0.09788046032190323,
-0.4573039412498474,
0.2649247944355011,
-0.15800979733467102,
-1.076586127281189,
-0.009815596975386143,
0.9057583212852478,
-0.8435966968536377,
-0.07682470232248306,
0.6532620191574097,
0.6353195309638977,
0.04606478288769722,
0.29557764530181885,
0.644227147102356,
0.024150995537638664,
0.3316931128501892,
0.5997896790504456,
1.4636808633804321,
-0.3105044364929199,
0.4179805815219879,
-0.3310266137123108,
-0.2759881615638733,
-0.2115689069032669,
-0.8436582684516907,
-0.8786112666130066,
-0.49133920669555664,
-0.21054524183273315,
0.06388015300035477,
0.2509615421295166,
0.7888706922531128,
0.6367102265357971,
-0.3746357560157776,
-0.3431474566459656,
-0.55091392993927,
0.14700216054916382,
-0.03676057234406471,
-0.2572062313556671,
0.1241338923573494,
-0.4803904592990875,
-0.9336993098258972,
0.5335078835487366,
0.6555612683296204,
0.18289320170879364,
-0.4973561763763428,
-0.30633097887039185,
-0.24015705287456512,
0.1563197374343872,
0.746555745601654,
0.17498967051506042,
-1.3016176223754883,
-0.1842573881149292,
-0.08910185843706131,
-0.08433318883180618,
0.05654139444231987,
0.9274663329124451,
-0.3773850202560425,
0.4517394006252289,
0.28454089164733887,
0.3847506642341614,
0.3110094368457794,
0.08232776075601578,
0.4833125174045563,
-0.5075328946113586,
0.3269732594490051,
0.49778634309768677,
0.15729819238185883,
0.19324827194213867,
-0.6765048503875732,
0.24477727711200714,
-0.14529797434806824,
-0.5294967293739319,
-0.8090112209320068,
0.4511483609676361,
-0.7132784128189087,
-0.15899407863616943,
1.1712241172790527,
-0.2864536941051483,
-0.5053250193595886,
-0.007012124173343182,
-0.0961679220199585,
0.10394200682640076,
-0.43258899450302124,
0.4520171582698822,
0.7521910071372986,
-0.5606802105903625,
-0.019963936880230904,
-0.5841660499572754,
0.44750919938087463,
0.4518580734729767,
-0.719536542892456,
0.13868437707424164,
0.2404995858669281,
-0.03776244819164276,
0.2553732693195343,
0.8181118965148926,
-0.20545920729637146,
0.4576210379600525,
-0.3586512804031372,
-0.03238823264837265,
0.3559071123600006,
-0.4041903614997864,
-0.17999982833862305,
-0.2253555804491043,
0.4562196433544159,
-0.006462058052420616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08751v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08751v1
|
From Text to Context: An Entailment Approach for News Stakeholder Classification
| 2024-05-14T16:35:21 | 2024-05-14T16:35:21 |
Alapan Kuila, Sudeshna Sarkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Navigating the complex landscape of news articles involves understanding the
various actors or entities involved, referred to as news stakeholders. These
stakeholders, ranging from policymakers to opposition figures, citizens, and
more, play pivotal roles in shaping news narratives. Recognizing their
stakeholder types, reflecting their roles, political alignments, social
standing, and more, is paramount for a nuanced comprehension of news content.
Despite existing works focusing on salient entity extraction, coverage
variations, and political affiliations through social media data, the automated
detection of stakeholder roles within news content remains an underexplored
domain. In this paper, we bridge this gap by introducing an effective approach
to classify stakeholder types in news articles. Our method involves
transforming the stakeholder classification problem into a natural language
inference task, utilizing contextual information from news articles and
external knowledge to enhance the accuracy of stakeholder type detection.
Moreover, our proposed model showcases efficacy in zero-shot settings, further
extending its applicability to diverse news contexts.
|
[
-0.2711194157600403,
-0.5620996952056885,
0.737319827079773,
0.09391030669212341,
-0.39305227994918823,
0.3179738223552704,
-0.17361176013946533,
-0.5661750435829163,
0.5699080228805542,
0.6056510806083679,
-0.08004450052976608,
-0.539699137210846,
-0.8262799382209778,
0.1481567919254303,
-0.4717903733253479,
1.0793099403381348,
-0.42080047726631165,
-0.4149279296398163,
-0.20590895414352417,
0.04041695222258568,
-0.039327871054410934,
-0.08586108684539795,
-0.6056562662124634,
-0.023231934756040573,
0.43325021862983704,
0.6731055974960327,
0.49782639741897583,
0.4921216368675232,
-0.017639940604567528,
0.25802597403526306,
-0.1426941454410553,
0.251071035861969,
-0.018842751160264015,
-0.18576085567474365,
-0.2527690827846527,
-0.5235431790351868,
0.2565448582172394,
0.3997308611869812,
0.2698718011379242,
0.54046630859375,
0.1936371773481369,
0.15253494679927826,
0.1733551174402237,
0.16720053553581238,
-0.925550639629364,
0.06279003620147705,
-0.9004990458488464,
0.023492148146033287,
-0.020128954201936722,
-0.5182633399963379,
-0.5607683062553406,
-0.3621354401111603,
0.2759747803211212,
-0.7663938999176025,
0.5830612778663635,
0.05449748411774635,
1.0792856216430664,
0.18605157732963562,
-1.1250181198120117,
-0.5048322081565857,
-0.2938900291919708,
0.6605628728866577,
-0.585335373878479,
0.19715330004692078,
0.6533821225166321,
0.1370858997106552,
-0.16491933166980743,
-0.26872318983078003,
-0.7387195229530334,
0.13289152085781097,
-0.21443599462509155,
0.15922674536705017,
0.07543504983186722,
0.09371131658554077,
-0.15718664228916168,
0.3536497950553894,
-0.16140778362751007,
0.08539757877588272,
-0.2709595859050751,
-0.0564449205994606,
0.522550106048584,
-0.5980431437492371,
0.20480506122112274,
-0.884673535823822,
-0.3519456088542938,
0.3979499340057373,
-0.5897530317306519,
0.3865640163421631,
0.48991769552230835,
0.2886485159397125,
-0.43017277121543884,
0.6418580412864685,
-0.3693888783454895,
0.5836926102638245,
0.5442458987236023,
-0.11515914648771286,
-0.019387301057577133,
-0.03841501474380493,
-0.27023664116859436,
0.7283767461776733,
0.25401321053504944,
0.37387946248054504,
0.11381181329488754,
-0.1711747795343399,
0.13531509041786194,
-0.0035534296184778214,
0.4223252832889557,
-0.4719412922859192,
0.07994229346513748,
0.22235073149204254,
-0.5331131815910339,
-0.5951855182647705,
0.5802402496337891,
-0.6183549761772156,
-0.6240822076797485,
-0.49151164293289185,
0.42886096239089966,
-0.14074721932411194,
-0.31862789392471313,
0.06507808715105057,
-0.46770158410072327,
0.4776860773563385,
0.6717309951782227,
-0.631912112236023,
0.004479744005948305,
0.8449493646621704,
0.8274782299995422,
-0.2355014979839325,
0.3189733922481537,
-0.5741416811943054,
0.7554355263710022,
-0.4234442412853241,
0.8113266825675964,
-0.7837442755699158,
-0.08403156697750092,
0.3428278863430023,
-0.007862493395805359,
-0.19401787221431732,
-0.29706642031669617,
0.7489216923713684,
-0.5012012124061584,
0.5430471301078796,
-0.2894512414932251,
-0.7262009382247925,
-0.46060121059417725,
0.4533563554286957,
-0.614059567451477,
0.7125502824783325,
0.20319390296936035,
-1.0804327726364136,
1.168142318725586,
-0.6775279641151428,
-0.5230714082717896,
0.12401087582111359,
-0.2900872826576233,
-0.2220974862575531,
0.47842976450920105,
0.3715558350086212,
0.6490274667739868,
0.018896669149398804,
0.5808824300765991,
-0.17988716065883636,
-0.22122320532798767,
0.25621655583381653,
-0.12943722307682037,
0.28086671233177185,
-0.09327895939350128,
-0.38029247522354126,
0.38405418395996094,
-0.7436068654060364,
-0.4805065393447876,
-0.3061305284500122,
-0.29566529393196106,
-0.8218570947647095,
0.28075653314590454,
0.19400472939014435,
0.21419785916805267,
-0.15299327671527863,
-0.6578291654586792,
0.0032877044286578894,
-0.10028035938739777,
0.5313772559165955,
0.4162580370903015,
0.6331676244735718,
0.7445967197418213,
-0.01565439999103546,
0.06774745881557465,
0.20900997519493103,
-0.00133835943415761,
-0.23427918553352356,
-0.32917651534080505,
-0.9131158590316772,
-0.5623283982276917,
0.4502279460430145,
0.3047735095024109,
-1.2296878099441528,
0.9332197904586792,
-0.19993050396442413,
-0.22002749145030975,
-0.31925174593925476,
-0.253475159406662,
-0.18262335658073425,
0.42125922441482544,
0.3352886140346527,
0.09218357503414154,
-0.48160451650619507,
-0.8971578478813171,
-0.70289146900177,
-0.4465840756893158,
-0.3314034342765808,
-0.06995922327041626,
0.4708879292011261,
-0.12141343951225281,
1.2404178380966187,
-0.27636340260505676,
-0.1570136398077011,
-0.2023504674434662,
0.6885085105895996,
0.0945269837975502,
0.37480008602142334,
0.10943984985351562,
-1.384960651397705,
-0.4499503970146179,
0.30015939474105835,
-0.4512075185775757,
-0.020323188975453377,
-0.39627981185913086,
-0.0773824155330658,
0.2924622893333435,
0.4770306646823883,
-0.6264339685440063,
0.7893753051757812,
-0.02360493503510952,
-0.5419997572898865,
0.01342112384736538,
0.34977731108665466,
0.3601361811161041,
-1.1343365907669067,
-0.07739627361297607,
0.33957868814468384,
-0.3690434396266937,
-0.7701988816261292,
-0.21979762613773346,
0.08181656152009964,
0.014024060219526291,
-0.2831447422504425,
0.2463957816362381,
-0.22536839544773102,
0.018348559737205505,
-0.30618390440940857,
-0.13336390256881714,
0.12043576687574387,
0.028187617659568787,
0.4870491921901703,
0.1728370189666748,
0.36770695447921753,
-0.5864492654800415,
-0.30126482248306274,
0.21174274384975433,
-0.3151727616786957,
0.7952109575271606,
-0.4294131398200989,
-0.30784904956817627,
-0.5408710241317749,
0.49811816215515137,
-1.0140657424926758,
-0.6190625429153442,
0.46827998757362366,
-0.5999886393547058,
0.3185046911239624,
-0.4552639424800873,
-0.8009979724884033,
-0.0454070009291172,
-0.3401722311973572,
-0.03795362636446953,
0.005000215955078602,
-0.32531654834747314,
0.7275936007499695,
0.40610364079475403,
-0.042688608169555664,
-0.19708408415317535,
-0.5526424646377563,
0.2487667053937912,
-0.7436416745185852,
-0.27125421166419983,
0.707232654094696,
0.573830246925354,
-0.007101071998476982,
0.44203969836235046,
-0.531225860118866,
-0.4838147461414337,
0.10314416885375977,
0.3341405391693115,
0.0813172310590744,
-0.010823801159858704,
0.1976517289876938,
0.3464280068874359,
-0.18481363356113434,
-0.20688480138778687,
0.1724027693271637,
0.11137878894805908,
0.3044281303882599,
-0.2341424524784088,
-0.3637930452823639,
0.6276001930236816,
0.5484431385993958,
-0.5387295484542847,
0.6540238857269287,
0.7627403736114502,
-0.5928943753242493,
-0.0647323951125145,
-0.7228699326515198,
0.08172823488712311,
-0.3529319763183594,
0.018737930804491043,
-0.0007836144068278372,
-1.0557605028152466,
0.43538975715637207,
-0.006538454908877611,
0.023575641214847565,
0.6137738823890686,
-0.02343027852475643,
0.1894133985042572,
0.649124026298523,
0.776099443435669,
-0.14282839000225067,
0.20396018028259277,
0.007116612978279591,
0.2708067297935486,
-0.3711484372615814,
-0.28218770027160645,
-0.46986839175224304,
-0.2104816436767578,
-0.5939730405807495,
-0.5192093849182129,
0.19367524981498718,
0.2901158034801483,
-0.15854837000370026,
0.5729697942733765,
-0.5238041877746582,
0.2725451588630676,
0.14972078800201416,
-0.12547245621681213,
0.3499900698661804,
-0.033020880073308945,
0.4859299957752228,
-0.11848517507314682,
-0.37726891040802,
-0.7347805500030518,
0.47767043113708496,
0.7919489741325378,
0.5579625964164734,
-0.004002558533102274,
1.206816554069519,
0.3475536108016968,
0.7434123754501343,
-0.8884313702583313,
0.1969468742609024,
0.08197476714849472,
-0.7248219847679138,
-0.04353111609816551,
-0.1957455575466156,
-0.4851056933403015,
0.3248770236968994,
-0.2259899079799652,
-0.7348456382751465,
0.7567856311798096,
-0.33460137248039246,
-0.37194710969924927,
0.18716397881507874,
-0.6839081048965454,
0.7714527249336243,
-0.0010134994518011808,
0.18758459389209747,
-0.2119133323431015,
-0.4412018060684204,
0.29608073830604553,
-0.09724615514278412,
0.2697400450706482,
-0.3679291009902954,
-0.5044256448745728,
0.6146822571754456,
0.08495965600013733,
0.9190568923950195,
-0.47087863087654114,
-0.04053748399019241,
0.37276625633239746,
-0.3409021496772766,
0.2366059273481369,
0.3974974453449249,
-0.07514068484306335,
0.059416722506284714,
-0.11285484582185745,
-0.20531833171844482,
-0.3086918294429779,
0.3562079966068268,
-0.5635313391685486,
-0.18834325671195984,
-0.5853414535522461,
-0.29778775572776794,
-0.2770439386367798,
-0.07216207683086395,
0.25202715396881104,
-0.00007264830492204055,
-0.149044468998909,
0.497204065322876,
0.4077494740486145,
-0.019477931782603264,
0.6336782574653625,
0.7968873381614685,
0.32463186979293823,
-0.24057504534721375,
0.8116009831428528,
0.20708557963371277,
-0.1918226182460785,
0.6002839803695679,
-0.009343589656054974,
-0.29446175694465637,
-0.4476454555988312,
-0.31236910820007324,
-0.23058995604515076,
-0.590501606464386,
-0.2667347192764282,
-0.7313805818557739,
-0.10176822543144226,
-0.17182506620883942,
-0.5932430028915405,
-0.012699684128165245,
-0.1600700169801712,
-0.6138415932655334,
-0.19334135949611664,
0.18434666097164154,
0.5048425197601318,
0.31181883811950684,
0.5384984612464905,
-0.5111587643623352,
0.563490629196167,
0.258007675409317,
0.3237278461456299,
-0.33359476923942566,
-0.43489310145378113,
-0.08323626965284348,
-0.21973025798797607,
-0.382582426071167,
-1.1745800971984863,
0.27823713421821594,
0.38847967982292175,
0.9977864623069763,
0.7099646925926208,
0.45399579405784607,
0.6507945656776428,
-0.5919103622436523,
0.7131267786026001,
0.2743859887123108,
-1.2753957509994507,
0.6492622494697571,
-0.25104841589927673,
-0.22486090660095215,
1.0336946249008179,
0.9665679931640625,
-0.6128097772598267,
-0.40920284390449524,
-0.5638043284416199,
-1.0004386901855469,
0.5030826926231384,
0.3359113037586212,
0.026299795135855675,
-0.19981980323791504,
0.2776462435722351,
0.30306607484817505,
0.5067745447158813,
-0.9550463557243347,
0.2803052067756653,
-0.5397182106971741,
-0.3391578793525696,
0.02757956273853779,
-0.1897464245557785,
-0.056837327778339386,
-0.19946007430553436,
0.4542694091796875,
-0.5600335597991943,
0.09529194235801697,
0.5450493097305298,
-0.3365814983844757,
-0.3573509156703949,
0.5152578949928284,
0.34677594900131226,
0.8663901686668396,
-0.17499853670597076,
0.36023932695388794,
-0.17851193249225616,
0.04221639782190323,
-0.002317989943549037,
0.40180474519729614,
-0.28149309754371643,
0.3801463842391968,
0.3805926442146301,
0.5710358619689941,
0.7065858840942383,
-0.17473842203617096,
0.6697948575019836,
0.12220297008752823,
-0.2085999697446823,
-0.39063695073127747,
-0.15010614693164825,
-0.1312577873468399,
0.22374944388866425,
1.0353816747665405,
-0.08747192472219467,
0.5141580700874329,
-0.7700102925300598,
0.5250282883644104,
0.36926713585853577,
-0.6591365933418274,
-0.1409076750278473,
0.21851707994937897,
0.4277200996875763,
0.08187941461801529,
-0.32054606080055237,
-0.15141461789608002,
-0.5863844156265259,
0.5185360312461853,
0.22125987708568573,
1.0946487188339233,
-0.20781591534614563,
0.6569010615348816,
0.14278309047222137,
0.2978212833404541,
-0.0006110375397838652,
-0.12786217033863068,
-0.08152303099632263,
-0.670857310295105,
-0.649871826171875,
-0.5399524569511414,
-0.41495245695114136,
0.08787546306848526,
-0.8866463899612427,
0.29739004373550415,
-0.3840673267841339,
0.05980675294995308,
0.7040507197380066,
0.0862194076180458,
-0.24559080600738525,
-0.011593070812523365,
0.3455451726913452,
1.1312534809112549,
-1.2306157350540161,
0.5030860900878906,
0.719595193862915,
-0.2557127773761749,
-0.24483826756477356,
0.9310532212257385,
-0.08246738463640213,
-0.27620652318000793,
0.3899451792240143,
0.7931147217750549,
0.6015253663063049,
-0.25251805782318115,
-0.8041476607322693,
-0.3944782018661499,
0.8224746584892273,
0.13755948841571808,
-0.00339557696133852,
0.033616986125707626,
0.2098350077867508,
0.2993949055671692,
-0.649716854095459,
-0.15570653975009918,
0.23838655650615692,
0.7000597715377808,
0.2580944895744324,
-0.7516927719116211,
-0.017190542072057724,
0.02172239124774933,
-0.027742119506001472,
0.16695347428321838,
-0.29283493757247925,
0.6420092582702637,
0.25344783067703247,
-0.19366168975830078,
-0.4547506868839264,
1.0071269273757935,
0.09596091508865356,
0.6775116920471191,
0.8616005778312683,
0.17858093976974487,
0.4465154707431793,
0.01231680903583765,
0.769296407699585,
-0.11369865387678146,
0.20604582130908966,
0.6535839438438416,
-0.3594733774662018,
0.8222155570983887,
0.5783796906471252,
0.12185101211071014,
0.6792209148406982,
0.8921890258789062,
0.07552845776081085,
0.7063600420951843,
-0.003228537505492568,
-0.4454220235347748,
-0.3972753584384918,
-0.45153361558914185,
-0.10567537695169449,
0.6956494450569153,
0.47697126865386963,
-0.30604827404022217,
-0.5311995148658752,
-0.23208004236221313,
-0.05888122320175171,
0.33696192502975464,
-0.5996034145355225,
0.7464973330497742,
0.0960327684879303,
-0.646384596824646,
-0.11927754431962967,
0.4362204074859619,
0.8771538734436035,
-0.5155431628227234,
-0.21402810513973236,
0.4167005717754364,
-0.18752562999725342,
-0.46447062492370605,
-0.9939029216766357,
0.5757619738578796,
-0.007540414575487375,
-0.2274693250656128,
-0.07542218267917633,
1.0964529514312744,
-0.829457700252533,
-0.33718621730804443,
-0.12606005370616913,
0.24122387170791626,
-0.2780039608478546,
-0.6865729093551636,
-0.31698116660118103,
-0.15179552137851715,
-0.12938739359378815,
-0.041588786989450455,
0.0668301209807396,
0.5907148122787476,
-0.32672902941703796,
0.0475701168179512,
0.6092608571052551,
-0.34694018959999084,
-0.2816234230995178,
-0.2677649259567261,
0.8549935221672058,
-0.4623565971851349,
-0.9023209810256958,
-0.6727620363235474,
0.6417584419250488,
-0.6664878726005554,
-0.4535295367240906,
0.8464616537094116,
0.6943716406822205,
0.6103853583335876,
-0.1310805380344391,
0.6617434620857239,
-0.2841510474681854,
0.5180505514144897,
-0.19643257558345795,
0.6110529899597168,
-0.45683303475379944,
-0.474532812833786,
-0.09696822613477707,
-0.4815704822540283,
-0.14408399164676666,
0.6315945982933044,
-0.4188530445098877,
-0.34816640615463257,
0.3083432614803314,
0.12148765474557877,
-0.1677580028772354,
0.1970452219247818,
0.029686594381928444,
-0.3987747132778168,
0.1850755363702774,
0.2534641623497009,
0.8575485348701477,
-0.09181268513202667,
0.11939279735088348,
-0.0877782478928566,
-0.14090301096439362,
-0.2688956558704376,
-1.1038163900375366,
-1.0360106229782104,
-0.5392462015151978,
-0.6292368769645691,
0.16293899714946747,
-0.08724496513605118,
1.022882103919983,
0.8960114121437073,
-1.0561457872390747,
0.1277487426996231,
-0.12533986568450928,
0.29980984330177307,
0.12893201410770416,
-0.33480989933013916,
0.3255697190761566,
-0.26722732186317444,
-0.4380950927734375,
0.0649162232875824,
0.36550620198249817,
-0.15433432161808014,
0.04555782675743103,
0.07212555408477783,
-0.4168180227279663,
0.21852760016918182,
0.6710214614868164,
0.2617248296737671,
-0.9443156719207764,
-0.6132650375366211,
-0.3225044310092926,
0.009779325686395168,
-0.09481579065322876,
0.9308954477310181,
-0.5819994211196899,
0.13729260861873627,
0.2911125421524048,
0.8756113052368164,
0.4108785390853882,
0.25803884863853455,
0.11653847992420197,
-1.1456345319747925,
0.34030890464782715,
0.25432589650154114,
0.03308955579996109,
0.42804229259490967,
-0.6254132986068726,
0.3824034333229065,
0.3052190840244293,
-0.11250467598438263,
-0.6990149021148682,
0.13607807457447052,
-1.1760377883911133,
-0.21593058109283447,
1.2754530906677246,
-0.06981068104505539,
-0.1477261334657669,
-0.5744369029998779,
-0.12494663149118423,
0.4437248706817627,
-0.4580644369125366,
0.5404279828071594,
0.34494632482528687,
0.18784970045089722,
-0.5289450883865356,
-0.7248847484588623,
0.5268270969390869,
-0.2883889377117157,
-1.053147315979004,
-0.10746917873620987,
0.3701944947242737,
0.0882950946688652,
0.41269004344940186,
0.46250519156455994,
0.012013910338282585,
-0.058687973767519,
-0.4767758846282959,
0.12831291556358337,
0.14632627367973328,
-0.32601866126060486,
-0.08726389706134796,
0.1679667979478836,
-0.3468681573867798,
-0.4201927185058594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08729v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08729v1
|
Targeted Augmentation for Low-Resource Event Extraction
| 2024-05-14T16:15:31 | 2024-05-14T16:15:31 |
Sijia Wang, Lifu Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Addressing the challenge of low-resource information extraction remains an
ongoing issue due to the inherent information scarcity within limited training
examples. Existing data augmentation methods, considered potential solutions,
struggle to strike a balance between weak augmentation (e.g., synonym
augmentation) and drastic augmentation (e.g., conditional generation without
proper guidance). This paper introduces a novel paradigm that employs targeted
augmentation and back validation to produce augmented examples with enhanced
diversity, polarity, accuracy, and coherence. Extensive experimental results
demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed paradigm. Furthermore, identified
limitations are discussed, shedding light on areas for future improvement.
|
[
-0.3718512952327728,
-0.5759333372116089,
0.4332551062107086,
0.07921037077903748,
-0.476168155670166,
0.2735915780067444,
-0.4436190724372864,
-0.5125002264976501,
0.42858561873435974,
0.18969298899173737,
-0.8383811712265015,
-0.34426531195640564,
-0.44888561964035034,
0.17457064986228943,
-0.36499693989753723,
1.075046181678772,
-0.0818941593170166,
-0.26086530089378357,
-0.12673473358154297,
-0.49126195907592773,
-0.8028591871261597,
-0.4242573082447052,
-0.5840171575546265,
-0.33350327610969543,
0.40632081031799316,
0.8153436183929443,
0.5409509539604187,
0.6190935373306274,
0.5914549231529236,
0.15036648511886597,
0.006983112543821335,
0.3202036917209625,
-0.4988187849521637,
0.03550875559449196,
-0.3438142240047455,
-0.35929688811302185,
-0.3298878073692322,
0.3468572497367859,
0.8436643481254578,
1.0220829248428345,
0.12701697647571564,
0.372043639421463,
0.20647279918193817,
0.3722957670688629,
-1.0271681547164917,
-0.2205219715833664,
-0.8513573408126831,
0.3682574927806854,
-0.23126138746738434,
-0.21027515828609467,
-0.15503165125846863,
-0.14184273779392242,
0.02948795072734356,
-0.5705812573432922,
0.500603437423706,
-0.12668079137802124,
0.9235093593597412,
0.21484553813934326,
-0.18594451248645782,
-0.016968321055173874,
-0.8574346303939819,
1.1124705076217651,
-0.48779740929603577,
0.3279416859149933,
0.1569824516773224,
0.30985110998153687,
0.021097823977470398,
-0.7538068294525146,
-0.6835166811943054,
-0.018470045179128647,
-0.08529122173786163,
0.2591613233089447,
-0.16761305928230286,
-0.047747574746608734,
0.6343238353729248,
0.46422627568244934,
-0.16357378661632538,
0.2993817925453186,
-0.277193546295166,
-0.12372438609600067,
0.6419411897659302,
0.14356383681297302,
0.0635564997792244,
-0.43466195464134216,
-0.28116917610168457,
-0.17618021368980408,
-0.5572865605354309,
-0.007925137877464294,
0.385945200920105,
0.43801069259643555,
-0.26891762018203735,
0.9176118969917297,
-0.5172276496887207,
0.5122494101524353,
0.3625129759311676,
-0.06696856766939163,
0.2398444265127182,
-0.8826086521148682,
-0.05010329186916351,
0.15929225087165833,
0.48018884658813477,
0.25009068846702576,
-0.4977850019931793,
-0.24002167582511902,
-0.168382465839386,
-0.15561139583587646,
-0.08074158430099487,
-0.9491246938705444,
-0.036359477788209915,
0.31433719396591187,
-0.6325161457061768,
-0.31934854388237,
0.0826810896396637,
-1.1956251859664917,
-0.3518730401992798,
-0.27030327916145325,
0.4287838935852051,
-0.36871203780174255,
-0.15695659816265106,
-0.2754661738872528,
-0.6857854127883911,
0.19441205263137817,
0.4522232413291931,
-0.5913622379302979,
-0.15094518661499023,
0.748049259185791,
0.9707453846931458,
-0.5830187797546387,
0.07512948662042618,
-1.0251688957214355,
0.1452527493238449,
0.014121947810053825,
0.5512213110923767,
-0.7836236953735352,
-0.4704044461250305,
-0.3044010400772095,
-0.08072543144226074,
0.4548290967941284,
-0.5348192453384399,
0.7013533711433411,
-0.4633987545967102,
0.35732200741767883,
-0.3183920383453369,
-0.22572948038578033,
-0.10388229042291641,
0.17928099632263184,
-0.7014795541763306,
0.9302009344100952,
0.2975054085254669,
-0.4001809358596802,
0.8964042663574219,
-0.3951662480831146,
-0.563605010509491,
0.29279881715774536,
-0.6158415675163269,
-0.6915884613990784,
0.15263047814369202,
0.3144419193267822,
0.10740511864423752,
-0.11075718700885773,
0.15649911761283875,
-0.39094308018684387,
-0.2647470533847809,
0.04839468002319336,
-0.5622258186340332,
0.527661144733429,
0.14678283035755157,
-0.4221149981021881,
-0.22385865449905396,
-1.1148706674575806,
-0.12447916716337204,
0.10008938610553741,
-0.5744672417640686,
-0.3812538981437683,
0.061288781464099884,
0.10101749747991562,
0.16477543115615845,
0.49242138862609863,
-0.7585856318473816,
0.27158692479133606,
-0.6517209410667419,
-0.10561802238225937,
0.44498175382614136,
0.3452483117580414,
0.7667852640151978,
-0.28550705313682556,
0.564854621887207,
0.061743464320898056,
0.05093735456466675,
-0.14087973535060883,
-0.3572004437446594,
-0.3880285918712616,
-0.5774700045585632,
0.3779597282409668,
0.61072838306427,
-1.1507062911987305,
0.5743936896324158,
-0.4427321255207062,
-0.201288104057312,
-0.46210089325904846,
0.40421533584594727,
0.010325566865503788,
0.7780295610427856,
0.5519757866859436,
-0.36629730463027954,
-1.1919492483139038,
-0.92473304271698,
-0.3072926998138428,
-0.021980714052915573,
-0.14045481383800507,
0.32886624336242676,
0.032739512622356415,
-0.06181810423731804,
1.1794160604476929,
-0.2574058175086975,
-0.15768024325370789,
-0.5618873238563538,
0.34022611379623413,
0.4468119740486145,
0.6255171298980713,
0.4011495113372803,
-1.041905164718628,
-0.16478867828845978,
0.20363445580005646,
-0.7102134227752686,
-0.0466415174305439,
-0.5546087622642517,
0.1136792004108429,
-0.29095062613487244,
0.166494682431221,
-0.2442825883626938,
0.6764699220657349,
0.2704505920410156,
0.12155953049659729,
0.2577316462993622,
0.1812942773103714,
0.34411105513572693,
-0.9030226469039917,
-0.1468619555234909,
-0.05077589675784111,
-0.06768398731946945,
-0.6533740758895874,
-0.09669459611177444,
-0.07146139442920685,
-0.5029491782188416,
-0.32996654510498047,
0.5264359712600708,
-0.41399815678596497,
-0.19798801839351654,
-0.5843705534934998,
0.31727075576782227,
0.2794550955295563,
0.1372610330581665,
0.11439323425292969,
0.5758888125419617,
0.04834144935011864,
-0.3872343599796295,
0.5872792601585388,
0.34352749586105347,
0.048550669103860855,
0.6491625905036926,
-0.4489857852458954,
-0.14247049391269684,
-0.22118712961673737,
0.0692463144659996,
-0.6336885094642639,
-0.4488692283630371,
0.2987741231918335,
-0.2513923943042755,
0.39067867398262024,
-0.4804885983467102,
-0.34580934047698975,
-0.32743343710899353,
-0.45868852734565735,
0.7156059741973877,
0.8538211584091187,
-0.8890305757522583,
0.7084025740623474,
0.26162290573120117,
-0.2661261558532715,
-0.5975435376167297,
-0.6465490460395813,
0.24513135850429535,
-0.39494892954826355,
-0.4012695550918579,
0.3073520362377167,
0.36401745676994324,
-0.24666273593902588,
-0.04538778215646744,
-0.20523391664028168,
0.042929261922836304,
0.07082393020391464,
0.12634006142616272,
0.4120386242866516,
-0.17469581961631775,
0.14905397593975067,
0.16758611798286438,
0.2127242088317871,
-0.3424285352230072,
-0.23433293402194977,
0.2740895748138428,
0.3030478060245514,
-0.6709611415863037,
-0.6776154637336731,
0.7593084573745728,
-0.055391788482666016,
-0.1423739641904831,
0.515518069267273,
0.9107533097267151,
-0.6751819252967834,
0.011889243498444557,
-0.7394437789916992,
-0.4827199876308441,
-0.4996887445449829,
0.4738689064979553,
-0.1725982427597046,
-0.6222677826881409,
0.41583937406539917,
-0.1591978222131729,
-0.00754063343629241,
0.4916960299015045,
0.23677024245262146,
-0.1338043510913849,
1.1008937358856201,
0.4515266418457031,
0.1707564741373062,
0.8028942942619324,
-0.1614638864994049,
0.02595852129161358,
-0.8706758618354797,
-0.1144423633813858,
-0.4753555655479431,
-0.4316442906856537,
-0.5859694480895996,
-0.3363525867462158,
0.4053577780723572,
0.20756497979164124,
0.42459210753440857,
0.3099604845046997,
-0.554521381855011,
0.163112074136734,
0.38365671038627625,
0.3652222156524658,
0.34594884514808655,
0.34850072860717773,
0.467830091714859,
-0.24067051708698273,
-0.9786629676818848,
-0.33798205852508545,
0.9805848598480225,
0.12018749862909317,
0.4687073230743408,
-0.04438626393675804,
0.9316257834434509,
0.38313034176826477,
0.49908003211021423,
-0.7180641889572144,
0.500060498714447,
0.0016113963210955262,
-0.661058247089386,
-0.4826878309249878,
-0.49991437792778015,
-0.9006509780883789,
0.031107155606150627,
-0.696770191192627,
-0.6845453381538391,
0.9306889176368713,
0.17471343278884888,
-0.4616988003253937,
0.19738300144672394,
-0.6423932909965515,
0.5746092200279236,
-0.0885210782289505,
-0.5178611278533936,
-0.13998964428901672,
-0.3441704213619232,
0.22305265069007874,
-0.3783526122570038,
0.2413855642080307,
-0.06760042905807495,
-0.33541184663772583,
0.82004314661026,
-0.348075270652771,
0.7213357090950012,
-0.22643961012363434,
0.3442299962043762,
0.5503859519958496,
-0.30680689215660095,
1.0914356708526611,
0.12317826598882675,
-0.22566421329975128,
0.03947712481021881,
-0.3444487154483795,
-0.560937762260437,
-0.7098355889320374,
0.5197260975837708,
-0.29559534788131714,
-0.5017843246459961,
-0.011089315637946129,
-0.4659472703933716,
-0.30122634768486023,
0.08118444681167603,
0.2147788554430008,
0.3528289496898651,
-0.1452159434556961,
0.2545757293701172,
0.22986969351768494,
-0.21451586484909058,
0.5314375162124634,
0.2758912146091461,
0.28068798780441284,
-0.5473957657814026,
1.2133046388626099,
0.03772231563925743,
0.07466161251068115,
0.24518266320228577,
0.045464251190423965,
0.003171310294419527,
-0.9941478371620178,
-0.3473692834377289,
-0.01168881356716156,
-0.6707975268363953,
-0.1533910632133484,
-0.7089765071868896,
0.06093714013695717,
-0.39194440841674805,
-0.24367699027061462,
-0.27562278509140015,
-0.6960039734840393,
-0.5918152332305908,
-0.14687833189964294,
0.1728995442390442,
0.16409604251384735,
-0.5364555716514587,
0.3975905776023865,
-0.9816738963127136,
0.46630316972732544,
0.19471152126789093,
0.011116137728095055,
-0.19956956803798676,
-0.30657556653022766,
-0.4811270534992218,
0.1027073785662651,
-0.32372236251831055,
-0.9571146368980408,
0.2637673616409302,
0.4069443345069885,
0.738506555557251,
0.3384876549243927,
0.1665116846561432,
0.7889463901519775,
-0.22064979374408722,
0.7424275875091553,
0.511588990688324,
-0.6720564365386963,
1.1927036046981812,
-0.04421045258641243,
-0.05322633311152458,
0.8728758096694946,
0.2474752962589264,
-0.19224736094474792,
-0.33154985308647156,
-1.0530788898468018,
-0.9633195996284485,
0.6721389293670654,
0.35066288709640503,
-0.06544208526611328,
-0.028037769719958305,
0.5876790881156921,
0.39877820014953613,
0.4011053442955017,
-0.4932294189929962,
0.0693708136677742,
-0.07655161619186401,
-0.17600540816783905,
-0.023175416514277458,
-0.07031206786632538,
-0.14857681095600128,
0.025705859065055847,
0.5375874042510986,
-0.042562730610370636,
-0.16495899856090546,
0.3359776735305786,
-0.10903466492891312,
-0.2509770095348358,
0.2777875065803528,
0.1823771744966507,
0.5132623314857483,
-0.23688071966171265,
-0.09003539383411407,
0.6126763820648193,
-0.5105310678482056,
-0.010489952750504017,
0.5406025648117065,
-0.44940242171287537,
0.23269429802894592,
0.5720464587211609,
0.5937960147857666,
-0.116363525390625,
-0.5845181941986084,
0.5727493762969971,
0.29694992303848267,
0.24350488185882568,
-0.06782541424036026,
0.09758403897285461,
-0.8420699834823608,
0.508979320526123,
0.7653616666793823,
-0.04959376901388168,
0.5443130731582642,
-0.4531949460506439,
0.43696022033691406,
0.8358198404312134,
-0.45703640580177307,
-0.23822160065174103,
0.48193520307540894,
0.2668709456920624,
-0.11179793626070023,
0.3636334240436554,
-0.5183875560760498,
-0.06342468410730362,
0.5767338871955872,
0.12306111305952072,
0.6730393171310425,
0.18321165442466736,
-0.08338549733161926,
0.524400532245636,
0.38939836621284485,
0.2991251051425934,
0.41241762042045593,
-0.5004281401634216,
-0.535983681678772,
-0.8496941328048706,
-0.5205545425415039,
-0.5109462141990662,
0.2217094898223877,
-0.9243021607398987,
0.4753301441669464,
-0.23871037364006042,
-0.44929319620132446,
-0.1366148293018341,
0.04611872509121895,
-0.8324750661849976,
0.17561765015125275,
0.152200847864151,
0.7621436715126038,
-0.82140052318573,
0.39849767088890076,
0.7480790019035339,
-0.6076359748840332,
-0.4780981242656708,
-0.04099424183368683,
-0.23435674607753754,
-0.5707388520240784,
0.6239425539970398,
-0.0818156972527504,
0.394496887922287,
-0.2447042018175125,
-0.33010995388031006,
-0.6526265144348145,
1.050601601600647,
0.06937788426876068,
-0.5435665249824524,
-0.2612760663032532,
0.1813952475786209,
0.22051189839839935,
-0.2994477450847626,
-0.11485083401203156,
0.5596315860748291,
0.5303496718406677,
0.3442782759666443,
-0.6759868860244751,
0.20064221322536469,
0.15128476917743683,
-0.14174194633960724,
0.0324363075196743,
-0.2578696310520172,
0.45289096236228943,
-0.14211617410182953,
-0.6112337112426758,
0.005282181315124035,
0.9064022898674011,
0.20576941967010498,
0.7515748143196106,
0.5619955062866211,
0.4891345500946045,
0.5756021738052368,
-0.2483547329902649,
0.9577725529670715,
0.08508433401584625,
0.272528737783432,
1.1685632467269897,
-0.26669472455978394,
0.3283049464225769,
0.6084352731704712,
-0.11502580344676971,
0.16731810569763184,
0.6506863832473755,
-0.2251654714345932,
0.7009375095367432,
-0.353933185338974,
-0.4881521761417389,
-0.3930637240409851,
-0.5211511850357056,
-0.412058025598526,
0.543226420879364,
0.4578983187675476,
-0.24834918975830078,
-0.35548537969589233,
0.4593231678009033,
-0.367419570684433,
-0.23545940220355988,
-0.5297204852104187,
0.906322181224823,
-0.10513683408498764,
-0.5288637280464172,
0.35579732060432434,
-0.05998605117201805,
0.5211637616157532,
-0.11175637692213058,
-0.2718338072299957,
-0.1300143301486969,
-0.0870990976691246,
-0.3641221225261688,
-0.534119188785553,
0.3186534345149994,
-0.05533672496676445,
-0.2095528393983841,
-0.030394170433282852,
0.8329485058784485,
-0.28286176919937134,
-0.3898514211177826,
-0.004231797531247139,
0.5658838748931885,
-0.08471307158470154,
0.04229285940527916,
-0.3865443170070648,
0.244990736246109,
0.043966326862573624,
-0.009441646747291088,
0.26867353916168213,
0.5111852884292603,
0.10462382435798645,
0.042869649827480316,
0.8065930008888245,
0.5851541757583618,
-0.1234518364071846,
-0.054864540696144104,
0.9265693426132202,
-0.5236302018165588,
-0.5724593997001648,
-0.7473973035812378,
0.49729686975479126,
-0.7643349170684814,
-0.00003929275044356473,
0.7437888979911804,
0.6767024397850037,
0.6078951954841614,
0.18916596472263336,
1.1218045949935913,
0.028932292014360428,
0.5079602003097534,
-0.3507435619831085,
0.0006693279137834907,
-0.6548689603805542,
0.34400948882102966,
-0.06558392196893692,
-0.6650010943412781,
0.0011713843559846282,
0.11779581755399704,
-0.5049013495445251,
-0.10962869226932526,
0.24219194054603577,
0.42915359139442444,
-0.24959702789783478,
0.0281703919172287,
0.2736538052558899,
-0.20641812682151794,
0.22283419966697693,
0.4269156754016876,
1.008941411972046,
-0.4107361435890198,
0.7509399652481079,
-0.3721272349357605,
-0.5595868229866028,
-0.5877508521080017,
-0.9171741604804993,
-0.7254031300544739,
-0.4469805955886841,
-0.5625448822975159,
-0.38229572772979736,
0.20297391712665558,
1.01461660861969,
0.8738879561424255,
-1.011027455329895,
0.3373132348060608,
0.10442879796028137,
0.289156973361969,
-0.06648886203765869,
-0.25157874822616577,
0.159023255109787,
-0.3670428991317749,
-0.6915569305419922,
0.7261953353881836,
0.43403518199920654,
0.3304653763771057,
0.11878661811351776,
0.3969154953956604,
-0.052751269191503525,
-0.05040061101317406,
0.5588173270225525,
0.730539858341217,
-0.24801522493362427,
-0.5113597512245178,
-0.4166666865348816,
0.13802632689476013,
0.2013280689716339,
0.7215195894241333,
-0.9742622375488281,
0.2808571755886078,
0.41589421033859253,
0.9326196908950806,
0.6532418131828308,
0.3265353739261627,
0.4310031831264496,
-1.3683449029922485,
0.48830392956733704,
0.4834986925125122,
0.2787858545780182,
0.37534379959106445,
-0.597163736820221,
0.29823532700538635,
0.5422458052635193,
-0.01255588885396719,
-1.0949344635009766,
0.5212140083312988,
-1.1285569667816162,
0.08000165224075317,
1.1629550457000732,
0.309563547372818,
0.04414176568388939,
-0.17826208472251892,
-0.06198513135313988,
0.48828408122062683,
-0.3365541398525238,
0.6349726915359497,
0.420467734336853,
-0.379650741815567,
-0.14359602332115173,
-0.29689323902130127,
0.4335435926914215,
0.15870532393455505,
-0.8580661416053772,
-0.32224801182746887,
0.7114835977554321,
-0.14760929346084595,
0.4939649999141693,
0.2715679109096527,
0.020856758579611778,
0.5204233527183533,
0.043031275272369385,
0.02119465358555317,
-0.04901207983493805,
0.03418046981096268,
-0.4857524633407593,
0.4862752854824066,
-0.14228923618793488,
-0.3063437342643738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13016v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13016v1
|
The Evolution of Darija Open Dataset: Introducing Version 2
| 2024-05-14T15:08:32 | 2024-05-14T15:08:32 |
Aissam Outchakoucht, Hamza Es-Samaali
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Darija Open Dataset (DODa) represents an open-source project aimed at
enhancing Natural Language Processing capabilities for the Moroccan dialect,
Darija. With approximately 100,000 entries, DODa stands as the largest
collaborative project of its kind for Darija-English translation. The dataset
features semantic and syntactic categorizations, variations in spelling, verb
conjugations across multiple tenses, as well as tens of thousands of translated
sentences. The dataset includes entries written in both Latin and Arabic
alphabets, reflecting the linguistic variations and preferences found in
different sources and applications. The availability of such dataset is
critical for developing applications that can accurately understand and
generate Darija, thus supporting the linguistic needs of the Moroccan community
and potentially extending to similar dialects in neighboring regions. This
paper explores the strategic importance of DODa, its current achievements, and
the envisioned future enhancements that will continue to promote its use and
expansion in the global NLP landscape.
|
[
-0.6317112445831299,
-0.42664408683776855,
0.4517265558242798,
0.4800553023815155,
-0.2334027737379074,
0.01946285553276539,
-0.15588942170143127,
-0.42244085669517517,
0.4737263023853302,
0.8412527441978455,
-0.4504857063293457,
-0.4849122166633606,
-0.7672653794288635,
0.21386940777301788,
-0.31789228320121765,
1.1784099340438843,
0.03430648893117905,
-0.08425122499465942,
-0.008870808407664299,
-0.5050681233406067,
-0.7061867713928223,
-0.503470778465271,
-0.4626363515853882,
0.04086726903915405,
0.6376249194145203,
0.4807433485984802,
1.0166436433792114,
0.6768587231636047,
0.5541349649429321,
0.1982237696647644,
-0.24443210661411285,
0.46288740634918213,
-0.5355033278465271,
0.2983909249305725,
-0.47675690054893494,
-0.5016764998435974,
-0.4698081314563751,
-0.27251213788986206,
0.49617671966552734,
0.8173553943634033,
-0.3948821723461151,
0.3049909174442291,
-0.42267391085624695,
1.2012218236923218,
-0.47596845030784607,
0.08353385329246521,
-0.6012835502624512,
-0.5373173952102661,
-0.8165408968925476,
0.27332228422164917,
0.11125005781650543,
-0.4571371078491211,
-0.008031065575778484,
-0.429519921541214,
-0.139418825507164,
-0.2720867991447449,
0.7676373720169067,
0.3471643328666687,
-0.7369149923324585,
-0.6543827056884766,
-0.5895645618438721,
0.7441253662109375,
-0.25274673104286194,
0.2674572467803955,
0.4785141050815582,
0.7158192992210388,
-0.763491153717041,
-0.6849196553230286,
-0.5707758665084839,
0.4346858561038971,
0.41863104701042175,
-0.11061035096645355,
-0.20073461532592773,
-0.13768213987350464,
-0.169218510389328,
0.5082072615623474,
-0.39423733949661255,
0.1796158403158188,
-0.44020870327949524,
0.2761368751525879,
0.6567081809043884,
0.06863399595022202,
0.4534296989440918,
-0.279899537563324,
-0.223539337515831,
-0.03997170552611351,
-1.0107409954071045,
-0.0888439193367958,
0.6310766339302063,
0.26610520482063293,
-0.07973773032426834,
0.6582348942756653,
-0.3323744535446167,
0.6750166416168213,
-0.493197500705719,
0.216831773519516,
0.5387044548988342,
-0.3325521945953369,
-0.08117564022541046,
0.0094715291634202,
0.4241570830345154,
0.0785936713218689,
-0.011878583580255508,
-0.1373191773891449,
-0.2536225914955139,
0.1469849795103073,
0.3879717290401459,
-0.6203444600105286,
-0.1498897224664688,
0.3445221781730652,
-0.40938445925712585,
-0.38698333501815796,
0.10574079304933548,
-1.293121576309204,
-0.44293761253356934,
-0.20994874835014343,
-0.109989233314991,
-0.04635108634829521,
-0.31198614835739136,
0.39084744453430176,
0.09666422009468079,
-0.17222638428211212,
0.4169341027736664,
-1.076607346534729,
0.7414876222610474,
0.8685386180877686,
0.9666984677314758,
-0.2651350498199463,
0.23870041966438293,
-0.363914430141449,
0.06221950799226761,
-0.7105669975280762,
0.8396881222724915,
-0.3837476968765259,
-0.38130563497543335,
-0.15637920796871185,
0.03655664995312691,
0.3554583191871643,
-0.6730864644050598,
0.7892592549324036,
-0.6310972571372986,
0.07710842043161392,
-0.33616262674331665,
-0.033000651746988297,
-0.5737228989601135,
-0.18923592567443848,
-0.9697654843330383,
1.0594581365585327,
0.35575175285339355,
-0.3045898377895355,
0.2468443065881729,
-0.6955156326293945,
-0.10853566974401474,
0.15722443163394928,
-0.15273766219615936,
-0.32005056738853455,
0.4981440305709839,
0.4704762399196625,
0.03014027327299118,
-0.6851181983947754,
0.5145030617713928,
0.009372827596962452,
0.07295405119657516,
0.2925642430782318,
-0.22632604837417603,
1.046656847000122,
0.3224734961986542,
-0.11293551325798035,
-0.28155988454818726,
-0.976447343826294,
0.025928925722837448,
-0.026486476883292198,
-0.21790245175361633,
-0.477731317281723,
0.18705028295516968,
0.14017821848392487,
0.6336594223976135,
0.07141904532909393,
-0.6091248989105225,
0.3983454704284668,
-0.7572872638702393,
0.1409161388874054,
0.7329061031341553,
0.22558103501796722,
0.2717021107673645,
-0.3899577856063843,
0.797868549823761,
0.019810521975159645,
0.0800749734044075,
0.097946897149086,
-0.9708501696586609,
-0.47411760687828064,
-0.453896164894104,
0.577522873878479,
0.4181998074054718,
-0.660853922367096,
0.023554084822535515,
-0.45468637347221375,
-0.4555002450942993,
-0.6238204836845398,
0.1594511717557907,
0.13568805158138275,
-0.05334063991904259,
0.31845876574516296,
-0.3641470670700073,
-0.9644056558609009,
-0.8905285000801086,
0.16822417080402374,
0.07696929574012756,
0.22687707841396332,
0.2790408432483673,
0.5050442814826965,
-0.41232794523239136,
0.8184347748756409,
-0.2944298982620239,
-0.5078181028366089,
-0.3435880243778229,
0.03850293532013893,
0.6851073503494263,
0.2791455090045929,
0.8872296810150146,
-0.9555635452270508,
-0.3760201930999756,
0.3800157904624939,
-0.5801748633384705,
-0.4017254710197449,
-0.08520372211933136,
-0.42093315720558167,
0.21904821693897247,
-0.021708175539970398,
-0.43912768363952637,
0.5242770314216614,
0.9480417370796204,
-0.3053693175315857,
0.2671774923801422,
0.059287793934345245,
0.00774515513330698,
-1.327912449836731,
-0.08836358040571213,
-0.7125616669654846,
-0.028376663103699684,
-0.7274113297462463,
-0.11337848007678986,
-0.17454886436462402,
0.047854773700237274,
-0.27584517002105713,
0.8160884976387024,
-0.518036961555481,
-0.2887367308139801,
-0.18629378080368042,
0.2337358146905899,
-0.31549325585365295,
0.041724901646375656,
-0.3349536955356598,
1.0103548765182495,
0.5349287986755371,
-0.4846460521221161,
0.5241039395332336,
0.715076744556427,
-0.7396305799484253,
0.23170208930969238,
-0.46222352981567383,
0.09280213713645935,
0.03329138457775116,
-0.003431151621043682,
-0.6160544753074646,
-0.26486092805862427,
0.21749074757099152,
-0.3735007047653198,
0.04157845303416252,
0.17268006503582,
-0.4130399525165558,
-0.19095216691493988,
-0.08700462430715561,
0.40074652433395386,
0.47828835248947144,
-0.7617621421813965,
0.3859700560569763,
0.7153060436248779,
-0.4141993820667267,
-0.9086878299713135,
-0.5719370245933533,
0.6387342214584351,
0.12313663214445114,
-0.6648446917533875,
0.2652222514152527,
0.1426583081483841,
-0.5779452919960022,
0.0020701780449599028,
-0.08617658168077469,
-0.06482263654470444,
0.1812867522239685,
0.6247997283935547,
0.15040090680122375,
-0.12030605971813202,
0.13530713319778442,
0.32654252648353577,
-0.0548681877553463,
-0.050317827612161636,
-0.2789476215839386,
0.4599638879299164,
0.08457539230585098,
0.10197536647319794,
-0.2461778074502945,
0.363943874835968,
0.4303462505340576,
-0.19057075679302216,
1.154845952987671,
-0.07427085936069489,
-0.21266677975654602,
-0.7430973052978516,
-0.23343195021152496,
0.3736715316772461,
-0.38870206475257874,
0.2411884367465973,
-0.5002743601799011,
-0.3887964189052582,
0.5579692721366882,
-0.33056074380874634,
-0.16233870387077332,
0.3280241787433624,
0.47664812207221985,
0.04504568502306938,
0.7253378629684448,
0.5823294520378113,
0.05711028352379799,
0.14122812449932098,
-0.25992706418037415,
0.17675745487213135,
-0.8738443851470947,
-0.5199783444404602,
-0.649463951587677,
-0.34943220019340515,
-0.6925427913665771,
-0.5026690363883972,
0.10157515853643417,
0.1478791981935501,
0.3105667233467102,
0.3924475908279419,
-0.040654391050338745,
0.3848453462123871,
0.40886184573173523,
-0.11765436083078384,
0.2296980321407318,
0.18112525343894958,
0.13357561826705933,
-0.20051170885562897,
-0.3476392328739166,
-0.6729326248168945,
1.4597814083099365,
0.2680014967918396,
0.45511922240257263,
0.7963067293167114,
0.6222614049911499,
0.42220965027809143,
-0.18594011664390564,
-0.47210344672203064,
0.5104016661643982,
-0.3488178551197052,
-0.481852650642395,
-0.10396535694599152,
-0.12334328889846802,
-0.929090142250061,
0.10424473136663437,
0.05487816035747528,
-0.3538685739040375,
0.616983950138092,
-0.3464876115322113,
0.1614067107439041,
0.06784771382808685,
-0.11222273856401443,
0.7486289739608765,
-0.22658993303775787,
-0.09393222630023956,
-0.2565496265888214,
-0.5197033286094666,
0.2823362648487091,
-0.4149744212627411,
0.252802312374115,
-0.19542114436626434,
-0.49834901094436646,
0.6909009218215942,
-0.49658024311065674,
0.3654131591320038,
0.010167133994400501,
-0.29174304008483887,
0.14248238503932953,
0.10257206857204437,
0.4021756947040558,
0.1072411835193634,
-0.33539023995399475,
0.611193060874939,
-0.07747986167669296,
-0.46850651502609253,
-0.6795750856399536,
0.608312726020813,
-0.7877097725868225,
-0.32735976576805115,
-0.8063912391662598,
-0.6242011785507202,
-0.23955704271793365,
0.17034243047237396,
-0.21012063324451447,
0.5901634693145752,
-0.4833233654499054,
0.44019556045532227,
0.5045825242996216,
-0.15984544157981873,
0.05749009549617767,
0.2839035987854004,
-0.6952846050262451,
-0.6533653140068054,
0.831911563873291,
0.20219296216964722,
0.2132827788591385,
0.14897631108760834,
-0.2078201174736023,
-0.1824120283126831,
-1.0333061218261719,
-0.6376111507415771,
0.37293553352355957,
-0.6936445236206055,
-0.32501158118247986,
-0.6104335188865662,
0.07532472908496857,
-0.2779046595096588,
-0.16408580541610718,
-0.2619000971317291,
-0.976586639881134,
-0.29775360226631165,
-0.1896757036447525,
0.3329247832298279,
1.2124372720718384,
-0.2943924069404602,
0.2867805063724518,
-0.2832278311252594,
0.5828861594200134,
0.009893403388559818,
0.23017090559005737,
-0.551740825176239,
-0.2444530725479126,
-0.02301241084933281,
0.17356160283088684,
-0.041557908058166504,
-1.025468111038208,
0.5688121914863586,
0.31538641452789307,
0.4375848174095154,
0.2194298505783081,
-0.21971307694911957,
0.4794140160083771,
-0.3349441885948181,
0.8742643594741821,
-0.16786685585975647,
-0.7476189732551575,
0.6699814796447754,
-0.4924321174621582,
0.0970732718706131,
0.5142273902893066,
0.36509940028190613,
-0.6968168020248413,
-0.04760519787669182,
-0.24993149936199188,
-0.642266035079956,
1.043942928314209,
0.5314655303955078,
0.08869613707065582,
-0.17428438365459442,
0.22548499703407288,
0.5196672081947327,
0.4091680347919464,
-0.156941756606102,
-0.4036044478416443,
-0.23793402314186096,
-0.26756003499031067,
0.011457055807113647,
-0.4808124601840973,
-0.03798488900065422,
0.020486673340201378,
1.073213815689087,
0.06529680639505386,
-0.005936185363680124,
-0.41349107027053833,
0.08092186599969864,
0.14375907182693481,
0.2112271636724472,
0.41383638978004456,
0.8163912296295166,
-0.20252126455307007,
-0.2253943830728531,
-0.14893785119056702,
-0.9072902202606201,
0.1526436060667038,
-0.1383020132780075,
-0.3968496322631836,
0.2517249584197998,
-0.16597911715507507,
0.8311241269111633,
-0.038117364048957825,
-0.9263575077056885,
0.4011060893535614,
0.06656216830015182,
-0.07850206643342972,
-0.20747776329517365,
-0.14299751818180084,
-0.2387513518333435,
0.09719984233379364,
0.17842335999011993,
0.15169231593608856,
0.1139814630150795,
-0.6759465336799622,
0.13623790442943573,
0.24761317670345306,
0.0002756078902166337,
-0.25063592195510864,
0.3993361294269562,
0.09261468052864075,
-0.05930722504854202,
0.5519256591796875,
-0.24878816306591034,
-0.4055761694908142,
0.7933294177055359,
0.5994278788566589,
0.7843518853187561,
-0.41165775060653687,
0.6894952058792114,
0.3878389298915863,
0.3196853697299957,
-0.06575389206409454,
0.6868290305137634,
-0.04931114614009857,
-0.32231441140174866,
0.12278719991445541,
-0.9575527906417847,
-0.3115796148777008,
-0.07833278179168701,
-0.6752913594245911,
0.42464661598205566,
-0.1986088752746582,
0.0069334921427071095,
-0.08687538653612137,
-0.004694710019975901,
-0.43874239921569824,
0.008075844496488571,
-0.1892220377922058,
0.8655222654342651,
-0.4923863112926483,
1.0063903331756592,
0.5408449172973633,
-0.42920932173728943,
-0.12543590366840363,
-0.3730631470680237,
0.09239339083433151,
-0.6630256175994873,
1.1525651216506958,
-0.08015252649784088,
-0.12359333783388138,
-0.1142345666885376,
-0.3193756341934204,
-1.3362441062927246,
0.9434678554534912,
0.23040089011192322,
-0.4002198278903961,
-0.08444501459598541,
0.33819425106048584,
0.5781620740890503,
-0.36365842819213867,
-0.27789750695228577,
0.42558303475379944,
0.26014024019241333,
-0.039535041898489,
-0.6741750836372375,
-0.17223133146762848,
-0.2358933985233307,
0.536813497543335,
0.5865379571914673,
-0.18080586194992065,
0.8814454674720764,
-0.06412868946790695,
-0.6043725609779358,
0.5252162218093872,
0.7464001774787903,
-0.4154394865036011,
0.05008690059185028,
-0.08663957566022873,
0.7005839943885803,
0.7369188070297241,
-0.3182048499584198,
0.8760327100753784,
0.04756256192922592,
-0.005403067916631699,
1.388916254043579,
-0.3066505789756775,
0.808515191078186,
0.3811066150665283,
-0.36410295963287354,
1.0075243711471558,
0.323026567697525,
0.12191390991210938,
0.8319337964057922,
0.14282956719398499,
-0.4612729251384735,
0.28724440932273865,
-0.3917613923549652,
-0.3834288418292999,
0.671595573425293,
0.8102964162826538,
-0.1516903042793274,
-0.32300877571105957,
0.3571707308292389,
-0.03128671646118164,
0.38650617003440857,
-0.3172149360179901,
0.8398065567016602,
-0.10018442571163177,
-0.584344744682312,
0.4720119535923004,
-0.06202733516693115,
0.20723648369312286,
-0.666020393371582,
-0.23374201357364655,
-0.30879533290863037,
0.21510864794254303,
-0.21075472235679626,
-0.8662678599357605,
0.5902385115623474,
0.02621598169207573,
-0.22879371047019958,
-0.14237910509109497,
0.3474605977535248,
-0.2806284725666046,
-0.27621376514434814,
0.41694962978363037,
0.38136255741119385,
0.38876622915267944,
0.0028215048369020224,
-0.5272641777992249,
0.346077561378479,
-0.1227438673377037,
-0.019331006333231926,
0.14491070806980133,
0.6519868969917297,
-0.24375884234905243,
0.6417063474655151,
0.7378479242324829,
0.6438737511634827,
0.320608913898468,
-0.05148130655288696,
0.8084285855293274,
-0.471885621547699,
-0.4049428403377533,
-0.33377188444137573,
0.1968080848455429,
-0.1010727658867836,
-0.4895414412021637,
0.9821264147758484,
0.4960983395576477,
0.7836577892303467,
0.1274530440568924,
0.7094265222549438,
-0.3205728828907013,
0.6982630491256714,
-0.5355687737464905,
0.4968659579753876,
-0.2874283790588379,
0.22541898488998413,
0.0024759965017437935,
-1.0223863124847412,
-0.2020176351070404,
0.23842619359493256,
-0.14938099682331085,
-0.20701418817043304,
0.702006459236145,
0.8746032118797302,
0.15488895773887634,
0.26336294412612915,
0.17550769448280334,
0.34644538164138794,
0.24176762998104095,
0.42877817153930664,
0.4886777102947235,
-0.7072127461433411,
0.284830778837204,
-0.3156258761882782,
-0.2548065781593323,
-0.03542301058769226,
-0.7286663055419922,
-0.8306681513786316,
-1.0099034309387207,
0.041091468185186386,
-0.4116038382053375,
0.5345498323440552,
0.8588723540306091,
0.2787203788757324,
-1.1662076711654663,
-0.2148548811674118,
-0.3440563976764679,
0.06647739559412003,
-0.4346134662628174,
-0.10879912972450256,
0.15855273604393005,
-0.25225186347961426,
-0.7169022560119629,
0.6736290454864502,
0.5321711301803589,
-0.07198011130094528,
-0.22984270751476288,
-0.07706624269485474,
-0.6818006038665771,
0.21577849984169006,
0.47478562593460083,
0.5540266633033752,
-0.6535605788230896,
0.17190822958946228,
-0.24803145229816437,
-0.06525018066167831,
-0.10235485434532166,
0.3728898763656616,
-0.9282124638557434,
1.0118610858917236,
0.4306124746799469,
0.9887731671333313,
0.22276878356933594,
0.011048031039536,
0.6920294761657715,
-0.4529535174369812,
0.25592535734176636,
0.19006232917308807,
0.06498111039400101,
0.31794118881225586,
-0.17466853559017181,
0.9305210113525391,
0.048430509865283966,
-0.6452310681343079,
-0.9674565196037292,
0.2434084713459015,
-1.0048378705978394,
-0.1904538869857788,
0.9646421670913696,
0.1783415526151657,
-0.23925194144248962,
-0.5901288986206055,
-0.4955703318119049,
-0.06595690548419952,
-0.42549222707748413,
0.7312763929367065,
0.8214848637580872,
0.14826074242591858,
0.14905981719493866,
-1.1400809288024902,
0.8012681007385254,
0.27516981959342957,
-1.2154459953308105,
-0.0004487608093768358,
0.6538357734680176,
-0.1990029662847519,
0.09703035652637482,
0.48759758472442627,
-0.23375657200813293,
0.4781305491924286,
-0.08534212410449982,
-0.1940288245677948,
-0.08035357296466827,
-0.7440788149833679,
-0.6483516693115234,
0.027731601148843765,
-0.26950758695602417,
-0.3646825850009918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18841v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18841v2
|
Navigating LLM Ethics: Advancements, Challenges, and Future Directions
| 2024-05-14T15:03:05 | 2024-06-28T02:56:09 |
Junfeng Jiao, Saleh Afroogh, Yiming Xu, Connor Phillips
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This study addresses ethical issues surrounding Large Language Models (LLMs)
within the field of artificial intelligence. It explores the common ethical
challenges posed by both LLMs and other AI systems, such as privacy and
fairness, as well as ethical challenges uniquely arising from LLMs. It
highlights challenges such as hallucination, verifiable accountability, and
decoding censorship complexity, which are unique to LLMs and distinct from
those encountered in traditional AI systems. The study underscores the need to
tackle these complexities to ensure accountability, reduce biases, and enhance
transparency in the influential role that LLMs play in shaping information
dissemination. It proposes mitigation strategies and future directions for LLM
ethics, advocating for interdisciplinary collaboration. It recommends ethical
frameworks tailored to specific domains and dynamic auditing systems adapted to
diverse contexts. This roadmap aims to guide responsible development and
integration of LLMs, envisioning a future where ethical considerations govern
AI advancements in society.
|
[
-0.04581766575574875,
-0.6716614961624146,
0.8868149518966675,
0.06937141716480255,
0.06766477972269058,
0.3654356896877289,
-0.31490400433540344,
-0.8280239701271057,
-0.24408511817455292,
0.958182692527771,
-0.6011845469474792,
-0.24824002385139465,
-0.7863039970397949,
0.21370157599449158,
-0.4394359290599823,
0.8392184376716614,
-0.008478344418108463,
0.40746986865997314,
-0.529519259929657,
-0.0965949296951294,
-0.26466989517211914,
-0.7563449144363403,
-0.9007104635238647,
-0.3327973484992981,
0.5306233167648315,
0.1887851506471634,
0.7846625447273254,
1.018858790397644,
0.6422026753425598,
0.4647761285305023,
-0.3137032985687256,
0.09711825102567673,
-0.5045260787010193,
0.14051559567451477,
-0.10095024853944778,
-0.39389434456825256,
-0.5791363716125488,
0.23203392326831818,
0.4825257658958435,
0.577693521976471,
-0.1469709873199463,
0.3233538568019867,
-0.11623364686965942,
0.6677166223526001,
-0.4584302306175232,
0.08112955838441849,
-0.3508441150188446,
0.06334853917360306,
-0.15671320259571075,
-0.19188478589057922,
-0.27309226989746094,
-0.5720564126968384,
0.15812833607196808,
-0.5338966250419617,
-0.5623162388801575,
0.23262152075767517,
0.37838879227638245,
0.4723452925682068,
-0.4213513135910034,
-0.7768054604530334,
-0.9393507242202759,
1.067415475845337,
-0.8022646903991699,
0.34530776739120483,
0.3809911608695984,
0.11817112565040588,
-0.15734808146953583,
-0.806052029132843,
-0.6702367663383484,
-0.13507762551307678,
0.27835485339164734,
-0.2450721561908722,
-0.04064735770225525,
0.14186835289001465,
0.006081602536141872,
0.19308821856975555,
-0.14675216376781464,
0.6690707802772522,
-0.2595537304878235,
-0.05572440102696419,
0.9306210875511169,
0.3762897253036499,
0.29149800539016724,
0.18234755098819733,
-0.19971930980682373,
0.15663625299930573,
-0.8989636301994324,
-0.09153670072555542,
0.7404038310050964,
-0.053281255066394806,
-0.1461864709854126,
0.486093670129776,
0.1397247165441513,
0.3498465418815613,
-0.4471181035041809,
-0.12236342579126358,
0.21995829045772552,
-0.38995447754859924,
-0.21026611328125,
0.20372220873832703,
0.5668555498123169,
0.36798030138015747,
0.5926212668418884,
-0.003459559753537178,
-0.17128796875476837,
-0.27724552154541016,
0.25110363960266113,
-0.493195116519928,
0.20608274638652802,
0.5609697103500366,
-0.7533981204032898,
-0.41338014602661133,
-0.0468023307621479,
-0.5753528475761414,
-0.693446159362793,
-0.8195096850395203,
0.3132137656211853,
-0.1708788126707077,
-0.17622292041778564,
0.2106015533208847,
-0.13917972147464752,
0.5781844258308411,
0.5986032485961914,
-0.6493982076644897,
0.14581748843193054,
1.084852695465088,
0.4483540654182434,
0.07325107604265213,
-0.1713569015264511,
-0.4863373339176178,
0.3953976035118103,
-0.23876330256462097,
0.2237233817577362,
-0.7938644289970398,
-0.43832236528396606,
0.19876548647880554,
-0.12554633617401123,
0.22340983152389526,
-0.41500189900398254,
0.5123438239097595,
-0.42610642313957214,
0.038483213633298874,
-0.055948901921510696,
-0.7000246047973633,
-0.4676494300365448,
0.25396019220352173,
-0.31307393312454224,
0.4487903416156769,
-0.163773775100708,
-0.31252583861351013,
-0.047086670994758606,
-0.9908092617988586,
-0.3619447350502014,
0.31051087379455566,
-0.517707347869873,
-0.2863338589668274,
-0.03884647786617279,
-0.1116507276892662,
0.4441368281841278,
-0.37376004457473755,
0.47835540771484375,
-0.1043354719877243,
-0.40974777936935425,
0.23262891173362732,
-0.7091040015220642,
1.2286310195922852,
0.08452814072370529,
-0.47897475957870483,
0.2919424772262573,
-0.7509626746177673,
0.011375319212675095,
0.23442387580871582,
-0.21370576322078705,
-0.3165336549282074,
0.41280221939086914,
0.07574475556612015,
-0.07536323368549347,
0.5514589548110962,
-0.33362895250320435,
0.014052039943635464,
-0.09777665883302689,
0.8416077494621277,
1.2932807207107544,
-0.059888798743486404,
0.32853925228118896,
-0.4830520451068878,
0.44824519753456116,
-0.33465278148651123,
0.5610735416412354,
-0.12191801518201828,
-0.4979875683784485,
-0.7302800416946411,
-0.06394559890031815,
0.03356248140335083,
0.8161440491676331,
-0.18430200219154358,
0.6080775260925293,
-0.2794243395328522,
-0.3925780653953552,
-0.8363373875617981,
0.11835487186908722,
0.14774055778980255,
0.2907465994358063,
0.10526429116725922,
0.1075076162815094,
-0.12708136439323425,
-1.085871696472168,
-0.3432583808898926,
-0.2661186158657074,
-0.013178673572838306,
0.6913662552833557,
0.5367448329925537,
-0.578831136226654,
0.5519289970397949,
0.1964748352766037,
-0.2052069753408432,
-0.1134202778339386,
-0.0040072184056043625,
0.10265884548425674,
0.811613917350769,
0.051481034606695175,
-1.142632007598877,
0.030407126992940903,
-0.007723386399447918,
-1.0047205686569214,
0.1825791448354721,
-0.23014648258686066,
0.14332054555416107,
0.10900501906871796,
0.6042786240577698,
-0.5108994245529175,
0.4590076208114624,
0.3838200569152832,
-0.28349992632865906,
0.33757707476615906,
-0.04781892150640488,
0.28094395995140076,
-0.7883785367012024,
-0.07661271840333939,
-0.32969930768013,
-0.2135130912065506,
-0.5680740475654602,
0.20559267699718475,
-0.2952507734298706,
0.1566307097673416,
-0.627589762210846,
0.5434699654579163,
-0.5391029715538025,
-0.3083497881889343,
-0.1607915610074997,
0.13937856256961823,
-0.14183849096298218,
-0.08165740966796875,
-0.15136250853538513,
0.6323348879814148,
0.5728594064712524,
-0.6509802341461182,
0.5808156132698059,
0.4418862462043762,
-0.1508876383304596,
0.6722858548164368,
-0.45621052384376526,
0.392777681350708,
-0.1383369117975235,
0.18703211843967438,
-0.18913990259170532,
-0.011457258835434914,
0.35677090287208557,
-0.5666871070861816,
0.08509120345115662,
0.30787259340286255,
-0.8273992538452148,
-0.059583552181720734,
-0.5389280319213867,
0.728151261806488,
0.6442620158195496,
-0.2609914541244507,
0.8613454103469849,
0.5207605361938477,
-0.4042479693889618,
-0.8023799061775208,
-0.7813881039619446,
0.4858355224132538,
-0.34200170636177063,
-0.7433074116706848,
0.1670248657464981,
-0.202785462141037,
-0.872963547706604,
-0.02856653369963169,
0.366412878036499,
0.28083255887031555,
0.4697847068309784,
0.16099609434604645,
0.2001819610595703,
-0.19372937083244324,
-0.3325470983982086,
-0.050588540732860565,
0.04064396768808365,
0.4859415590763092,
-0.11147155612707138,
0.4453432261943817,
-0.11698338389396667,
-0.43442341685295105,
-0.6968696713447571,
0.6574303507804871,
0.5497854351997375,
-0.2616707980632782,
0.6071746945381165,
0.4793286919593811,
-0.7484487295150757,
0.013773842714726925,
-0.7726073861122131,
-0.20037004351615906,
-0.5510642528533936,
0.375387579202652,
0.284462034702301,
-1.2312731742858887,
0.5831199884414673,
-0.17682361602783203,
0.43519875407218933,
0.22154247760772705,
0.8570983409881592,
-0.11821490526199341,
0.8747338056564331,
0.9776686429977417,
-0.2606865167617798,
0.26759281754493713,
-0.06442184001207352,
0.47374293208122253,
-1.022949457168579,
-0.5876905918121338,
-0.6312887072563171,
-0.23951204121112823,
-0.9217286109924316,
-0.42879462242126465,
0.29977086186408997,
-0.1492212414741516,
-0.529771089553833,
-0.36011725664138794,
-0.4710283875465393,
0.67951899766922,
0.6546546220779419,
-0.3269764482975006,
0.745206892490387,
-0.3674671947956085,
0.3956139385700226,
0.18249304592609406,
-0.42053982615470886,
-1.092443585395813,
0.9112690687179565,
0.642268180847168,
0.7699182629585266,
0.25792843103408813,
0.6053890585899353,
0.5292932391166687,
0.15540249645709991,
-0.5989254713058472,
0.7247042655944824,
-0.037350576370954514,
-0.5641968250274658,
-0.5374141335487366,
-0.29599422216415405,
-0.7599138021469116,
-0.02597927674651146,
-0.018020475283265114,
-1.0865304470062256,
0.11717280000448227,
-0.2785259187221527,
-0.20146818459033966,
0.5133657455444336,
-0.23240584135055542,
0.39554929733276367,
-0.5458135604858398,
-0.29473909735679626,
-0.45931515097618103,
-1.1122279167175293,
0.4007638990879059,
-0.06872259080410004,
0.4153209924697876,
-0.21575263142585754,
-0.3541685938835144,
0.8466171622276306,
-0.08224644511938095,
0.8087372183799744,
0.27790117263793945,
-0.2074139416217804,
0.13670802116394043,
-0.04821155220270157,
0.49966683983802795,
0.23786576092243195,
-0.3237861692905426,
0.45547935366630554,
-0.08593505620956421,
-0.17755325138568878,
-0.014309903606772423,
0.7083221077919006,
-0.8457710146903992,
-0.9520600438117981,
-0.6047712564468384,
-0.856289267539978,
-0.18231892585754395,
0.4010087251663208,
-0.12796777486801147,
0.04746704548597336,
-0.07112054526805878,
0.23200318217277527,
0.9383625388145447,
-0.6269243955612183,
0.5341050624847412,
0.45153293013572693,
0.034714169800281525,
-0.08812738209962845,
0.8191829323768616,
-0.12351721525192261,
0.20001444220542908,
0.06480788439512253,
0.11300989985466003,
-0.3650646209716797,
-0.9517599940299988,
-0.4410032331943512,
0.3015115559101105,
-0.8844367861747742,
-0.07449623197317123,
-0.5310443043708801,
-0.6133757829666138,
-0.38403552770614624,
-0.46332651376724243,
-0.23163734376430511,
-0.02025279775261879,
-0.6988785266876221,
-0.01085311733186245,
0.4791880249977112,
1.0160787105560303,
0.06816709041595459,
0.06943558156490326,
-0.7979345321655273,
0.050478871911764145,
-0.11048581451177597,
0.23094700276851654,
-0.007385095115751028,
-0.3636001944541931,
0.2502232789993286,
-0.06142083927989006,
-0.18190008401870728,
-0.2710501551628113,
0.04871702566742897,
-0.21114271879196167,
0.6625069379806519,
0.20934836566448212,
-0.0013389750383794308,
0.4206365644931793,
-0.6957957148551941,
0.9517818093299866,
-0.06128731369972229,
-1.081517219543457,
0.31419289112091064,
-0.5141310691833496,
-0.19689959287643433,
0.4857250452041626,
0.43499672412872314,
-0.5881468057632446,
-0.6417735815048218,
-0.6128776669502258,
-1.0597161054611206,
0.42920881509780884,
0.29357728362083435,
0.5386198163032532,
0.343441367149353,
0.5047523379325867,
0.12392793595790863,
0.4899958074092865,
-0.7894240617752075,
-0.27100175619125366,
0.4005202651023865,
-0.3103114366531372,
0.07193466275930405,
-0.03941644728183746,
-0.35212934017181396,
-0.14911822974681854,
0.5786683559417725,
0.24035273492336273,
0.2125236541032791,
0.10216283798217773,
0.08509180694818497,
-0.07599622756242752,
0.22197283804416656,
0.8058748245239258,
1.0262625217437744,
0.1366782933473587,
-0.2585047781467438,
-0.0862179547548294,
-0.2521819472312927,
0.14027999341487885,
0.07855748385190964,
-0.12326513230800629,
-0.44503870606422424,
0.4878230094909668,
0.4287164509296417,
-0.28723132610321045,
-0.9784404039382935,
0.4745137095451355,
-0.02072659507393837,
-0.22359983623027802,
-0.8260151147842407,
-0.06882408261299133,
0.24050572514533997,
0.6475419998168945,
0.5352802276611328,
-0.24300037324428558,
0.26020458340644836,
-0.6704153418540955,
0.06913582980632782,
0.5630369186401367,
0.0768512412905693,
0.11827096343040466,
0.7758656144142151,
0.35927098989486694,
-0.7154839634895325,
0.7432328462600708,
0.2060764729976654,
-0.4609280824661255,
0.9023410081863403,
0.20698116719722748,
0.7114274501800537,
-0.11034639924764633,
-0.10268520563840866,
-0.45628830790519714,
0.6488646268844604,
-0.1349075734615326,
0.13825783133506775,
0.16577669978141785,
-0.6605179905891418,
-0.2899185121059418,
-0.5145370364189148,
-0.8968915939331055,
0.30721399188041687,
-0.402133584022522,
0.1742490977048874,
-0.680094838142395,
0.17558138072490692,
-0.14884617924690247,
-0.04442039877176285,
-0.4211840033531189,
0.07464942336082458,
0.42625692486763,
0.7501537203788757,
-0.22859637439250946,
0.581914484500885,
0.3233412206172943,
-0.13288408517837524,
-0.40562567114830017,
-0.09074049443006516,
0.29173582792282104,
-1.0970032215118408,
0.3639233410358429,
0.25070738792419434,
-0.3645370304584503,
0.09440872073173523,
-0.6969906091690063,
-0.609112024307251,
1.3353139162063599,
0.2620643675327301,
-0.7260698080062866,
-0.218180850148201,
0.27993154525756836,
0.2903125286102295,
-0.5306414365768433,
-0.11395174264907837,
0.4949767291545868,
0.7583431005477905,
-0.2977372109889984,
-0.7767414450645447,
0.009574834257364273,
0.04946271330118179,
-0.008926664479076862,
0.04377976432442665,
-0.9384459853172302,
0.8526097536087036,
-0.17392198741436005,
0.07071426510810852,
0.45761623978614807,
0.5138128995895386,
0.3173559606075287,
0.5300896763801575,
0.2333345264196396,
0.15172675251960754,
0.8421609997749329,
0.20747904479503632,
0.9094818234443665,
-0.23027262091636658,
-0.07399425655603409,
0.7298537492752075,
-0.5878870487213135,
0.5177012085914612,
0.733147382736206,
0.05594039335846901,
0.19456322491168976,
0.7537356019020081,
-0.2639244794845581,
-0.07756753265857697,
0.5709967613220215,
-0.2564757764339447,
-0.0034180041402578354,
-0.6183090806007385,
-0.29211151599884033,
0.46260780096054077,
0.5859410762786865,
-0.4947647452354431,
0.20099316537380219,
0.007039990741759539,
0.14482395350933075,
0.19701865315437317,
-0.5836655497550964,
0.6079035997390747,
0.31011682748794556,
-0.2750794589519501,
-0.06762994825839996,
0.17869196832180023,
0.8172861337661743,
-0.3797461986541748,
-0.18215933442115784,
0.08085600286722183,
0.09474126994609833,
-0.13539592921733856,
-0.8448927402496338,
0.2696080207824707,
0.07678698748350143,
0.10489125549793243,
-0.4635300934314728,
0.5101889967918396,
-0.16956427693367004,
-0.5233215689659119,
0.4671677350997925,
0.6160022020339966,
0.17101319134235382,
0.36522138118743896,
-0.8352562785148621,
0.5029957890510559,
-0.14079074561595917,
-0.34809213876724243,
0.3068576753139496,
0.30373457074165344,
-0.15492463111877441,
1.1885597705841064,
0.7134364247322083,
0.18807294964790344,
0.02554185688495636,
-0.03166482225060463,
0.5739853978157043,
-0.7583748698234558,
-0.3981953263282776,
-1.1481980085372925,
0.2983540892601013,
-0.10151904821395874,
-0.2796085774898529,
0.4412992596626282,
0.23780669271945953,
0.8138898015022278,
0.37350720167160034,
0.7035207152366638,
0.1446806937456131,
0.16317875683307648,
-0.7695627808570862,
0.9787054061889648,
-0.5640841126441956,
0.6228737235069275,
0.019634483382105827,
-0.7185677289962769,
-0.2495587170124054,
0.4806751012802124,
-0.024419555440545082,
0.3114127814769745,
0.2750733196735382,
0.38993215560913086,
0.39896178245544434,
0.25227370858192444,
0.25893253087997437,
0.1993253529071808,
0.4493921995162964,
0.3454299867153168,
0.9451714158058167,
-0.12839962542057037,
0.1752670705318451,
-0.020361466333270073,
-0.011129196733236313,
-0.13504727184772491,
-0.9843229651451111,
-0.6578319668769836,
-0.40519389510154724,
-0.2554257810115814,
-0.09937198460102081,
0.17224115133285522,
0.9284684658050537,
0.47414299845695496,
-0.4516228437423706,
-0.4871879518032074,
0.023898232728242874,
0.4036456048488617,
0.19438637793064117,
-0.24101196229457855,
0.08859552443027496,
0.1836411952972412,
-0.9733554720878601,
0.18503086268901825,
0.6048139333724976,
0.09476914256811142,
-0.6954780220985413,
-0.2225429117679596,
-0.31630754470825195,
0.45409414172172546,
0.6286929249763489,
0.14365129172801971,
-1.019936442375183,
-0.5783094167709351,
-0.1498059779405594,
-0.08789481967687607,
-0.04775680601596832,
0.722758948802948,
-0.30783015489578247,
-0.030581476166844368,
0.14816923439502716,
1.3001633882522583,
-0.14956016838550568,
-0.08251930773258209,
0.7634124755859375,
-0.06197483092546463,
0.09116445481777191,
1.0429226160049438,
0.20515452325344086,
0.35728639364242554,
-0.7646187543869019,
0.5409610271453857,
0.0009357715607620776,
-0.9547734260559082,
-1.1686081886291504,
0.32301440834999084,
-0.9652612805366516,
-0.2650434970855713,
1.1795086860656738,
0.01501950342208147,
-0.261916846036911,
-0.26273098587989807,
0.1437661349773407,
0.02427474781870842,
-0.31183576583862305,
0.5271268486976624,
0.7359060049057007,
-0.3803543150424957,
-0.17592808604240417,
-0.7680507898330688,
0.42440125346183777,
0.31218892335891724,
-0.9465057253837585,
0.24328847229480743,
0.507795512676239,
0.18403074145317078,
-0.012065504677593708,
0.6002553701400757,
-0.4115030765533447,
0.20278875529766083,
-0.4399969279766083,
-0.1950201541185379,
-0.10084062814712524,
-0.31834903359413147,
-0.41253870725631714,
-0.2898007929325104,
0.10295584797859192,
0.07890012115240097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08644v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08644v1
|
Thinking Tokens for Language Modeling
| 2024-05-14T14:21:43 | 2024-05-14T14:21:43 |
David Herel, Tomas Mikolov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
How much is 56 times 37? Language models often make mistakes in these types
of difficult calculations. This is usually explained by their inability to
perform complex reasoning. Since language models rely on large training sets
and great memorization capability, naturally they are not equipped to run
complex calculations. However, one can argue that humans also cannot perform
this calculation immediately and require a considerable amount of time to
construct the solution. In order to enhance the generalization capability of
language models, and as a parallel to human behavior, we propose to use special
'thinking tokens' which allow the model to perform much more calculations
whenever a complex problem is encountered.
|
[
-0.1490974724292755,
-0.8007155060768127,
0.4286799132823944,
0.5131099224090576,
-0.4594927132129669,
0.103949174284935,
-0.16907024383544922,
-0.4843340814113617,
0.06479959189891815,
0.4097086191177368,
-0.2618147134780884,
0.008344450034201145,
-0.513559877872467,
0.003080297028645873,
-0.2598455548286438,
0.8423183560371399,
0.15674073994159698,
0.19386082887649536,
0.22464996576309204,
-0.0965883806347847,
-0.5671688318252563,
-0.8691149950027466,
-0.8483148813247681,
-0.1469215601682663,
0.22583284974098206,
0.36848336458206177,
0.8215872049331665,
0.3830605447292328,
0.6268025636672974,
0.38917621970176697,
-0.4204031527042389,
-0.017996162176132202,
-0.3423076570034027,
-0.21452520787715912,
-0.24044904112815857,
-1.1061055660247803,
-0.6639899611473083,
-0.2041870653629303,
0.6843337416648865,
0.8488646149635315,
-0.07443776726722717,
0.2636543810367584,
-0.5090196132659912,
0.8282002806663513,
-0.4111061692237854,
0.3142681121826172,
-0.6508995294570923,
0.5605722069740295,
-0.14496676623821259,
0.36385810375213623,
-0.169686958193779,
-0.16035684943199158,
0.4255589246749878,
-0.557991623878479,
0.26559752225875854,
0.11544166505336761,
0.4131930470466614,
-0.10898075997829437,
-0.18839463591575623,
-0.06580918282270432,
-0.6222172975540161,
0.9560468792915344,
-1.1012943983078003,
0.08421964198350906,
0.3104429543018341,
0.35511845350265503,
-0.2575724124908447,
-0.6621021628379822,
-0.9652325510978699,
-0.4215587377548218,
0.07647950202226639,
-0.47082704305648804,
-0.28667548298835754,
0.1763005256652832,
0.7771611213684082,
0.27622148394584656,
-0.34470054507255554,
-0.25106313824653625,
-0.4581579566001892,
-0.25703704357147217,
0.516015350818634,
0.6308360695838928,
0.46964868903160095,
-0.4129564166069031,
-0.23112702369689941,
-0.12021318823099136,
-0.36782166361808777,
0.24275879561901093,
0.2270730584859848,
0.4543171525001526,
-0.08540882170200348,
0.6724898815155029,
-0.17756231129169464,
0.7461515665054321,
-0.0019504715455695987,
0.012599176727235317,
0.2805318832397461,
-0.4325360357761383,
-0.5313175916671753,
-0.23167458176612854,
0.6400620937347412,
0.3616645038127899,
0.6281291246414185,
-0.16908909380435944,
-0.2557419240474701,
0.15279676020145416,
0.2970905303955078,
-0.6326345205307007,
-0.04265361651778221,
0.16724051535129547,
-0.26379773020744324,
-0.2967933416366577,
-0.05271483585238457,
-0.6687424182891846,
-0.02806810289621353,
-0.2913835346698761,
0.5151450037956238,
-0.3823281228542328,
-0.354839950799942,
0.6190110445022583,
-0.47785332798957825,
-0.08523120731115341,
0.24837765097618103,
-0.6329894661903381,
0.48577743768692017,
0.5260716676712036,
0.783286452293396,
-0.10284294933080673,
-0.31744104623794556,
-0.2700606882572174,
-0.028782321140170097,
-0.6440185904502869,
0.747204065322876,
-0.6590328216552734,
-0.6287207007408142,
-0.3061513602733612,
0.044919099658727646,
-0.0585513710975647,
-0.5135970711708069,
0.5137434005737305,
-0.2536819875240326,
-0.02969728782773018,
-0.527254581451416,
-0.6028646230697632,
-0.11842060089111328,
0.09061586111783981,
-0.8733496069908142,
1.0883158445358276,
0.08528611809015274,
-0.8900128602981567,
0.06631653755903244,
-0.9228881597518921,
-0.39280253648757935,
0.2884620130062103,
0.16376939415931702,
-0.2797338664531708,
0.4791496694087982,
-0.011145314201712608,
0.409091979265213,
-0.32753050327301025,
0.5501523613929749,
-0.13561071455478668,
-0.4249740242958069,
0.6532945036888123,
-0.34884804487228394,
0.9097285866737366,
0.2431710660457611,
-0.9251385927200317,
0.1699623316526413,
-0.5659032464027405,
0.13125263154506683,
0.17653609812259674,
-0.5685817003250122,
-0.22654324769973755,
-0.041533347219228745,
0.06699231266975403,
0.2700398862361908,
0.12611202895641327,
-0.6333369612693787,
0.23414741456508636,
-0.7634173631668091,
0.2913864552974701,
0.724891722202301,
-0.31428131461143494,
0.3128442168235779,
-0.558347225189209,
0.7283592224121094,
0.22485513985157013,
0.10768922418355942,
0.022018849849700928,
-0.684064507484436,
-1.2875992059707642,
0.2515020966529846,
0.14808589220046997,
0.4348083436489105,
-0.5396652221679688,
0.04597436636686325,
-0.21316011250019073,
-0.7743576765060425,
-0.43847543001174927,
-0.0362619087100029,
0.858508288860321,
0.16707628965377808,
0.2976970970630646,
-0.3942038416862488,
-0.5699946284294128,
-0.8559563159942627,
-0.6660747528076172,
-0.16256631910800934,
0.23615646362304688,
0.2854818105697632,
0.8093647360801697,
0.11209512501955032,
0.9352847337722778,
-0.44344082474708557,
0.01014645490795374,
-0.4241369962692261,
0.27790355682373047,
0.11297187954187393,
0.5508641004562378,
0.7369451522827148,
-0.8663429021835327,
-0.381162166595459,
-0.01132164429873228,
-0.39072364568710327,
0.15350940823554993,
-0.050433043390512466,
-0.11583033204078674,
0.2129693627357483,
0.3997677266597748,
-0.8036379218101501,
0.6564543843269348,
0.3072195053100586,
-0.8412573337554932,
0.8761427402496338,
-0.1410200148820877,
-0.06246533617377281,
-0.8702961802482605,
0.25012823939323425,
-0.028199493885040283,
-0.22213304042816162,
-0.7909187078475952,
0.20710311830043793,
-0.07598603516817093,
-0.30184632539749146,
-0.8134971857070923,
0.7912351489067078,
-0.37422633171081543,
0.10335888713598251,
-0.13878001272678375,
-0.03416964411735535,
-0.12810522317886353,
0.599206805229187,
-0.26600122451782227,
0.7744400501251221,
0.40564680099487305,
-0.6280762553215027,
0.5637619495391846,
-0.18563780188560486,
-0.43020710349082947,
0.42578908801078796,
-0.8334978818893433,
0.28793907165527344,
-0.16925202310085297,
0.35135307908058167,
-0.8261339664459229,
-0.10083513706922531,
0.08367287367582321,
-0.23316296935081482,
-0.01734718307852745,
0.20553278923034668,
-0.5046435594558716,
-0.4536166191101074,
-0.23785993456840515,
0.7658708095550537,
0.22228406369686127,
-0.007979373447597027,
0.7892652153968811,
0.6651687622070312,
-0.25528109073638916,
-0.5833725333213806,
-0.8759936094284058,
0.3152134418487549,
-0.14180070161819458,
-0.35356640815734863,
0.3192412853240967,
-0.3074597120285034,
-0.5361555218696594,
0.23746885359287262,
0.1797942817211151,
-0.021197350695729256,
0.09739524871110916,
0.2091807872056961,
0.057315755635499954,
0.01315548550337553,
0.5511852502822876,
-0.15567627549171448,
-0.17285411059856415,
0.2330549657344818,
-0.37109556794166565,
0.6624093055725098,
-0.346401184797287,
-0.5760704874992371,
-0.594556450843811,
0.6674479246139526,
0.9742144346237183,
-0.34474876523017883,
0.6780576705932617,
0.20626689493656158,
-0.6569393277168274,
-0.12503349781036377,
-0.6954852342605591,
0.21963511407375336,
-0.43588072061538696,
0.7611427307128906,
-0.6521974205970764,
-0.886058509349823,
0.6799304485321045,
0.4287920296192169,
0.09110645204782486,
0.7232335805892944,
0.8014718890190125,
0.2659936547279358,
1.1761748790740967,
0.5385171175003052,
-0.202450230717659,
0.5369657874107361,
-0.10966389626264572,
0.37471941113471985,
-0.5186396241188049,
-0.5343145132064819,
-0.5105959177017212,
-0.3507891595363617,
-0.19518603384494781,
-0.9051292538642883,
0.036172352731227875,
-0.1635718047618866,
-0.23807336390018463,
0.16920921206474304,
-0.43933382630348206,
0.6608394980430603,
0.5702342391014099,
0.09938792139291763,
0.11165934056043625,
-0.11676111817359924,
-0.41985586285591125,
-0.07545644044876099,
-0.6826406121253967,
-0.40301433205604553,
1.163527011871338,
0.2912173569202423,
0.6858139634132385,
0.16119293868541718,
0.07948288321495056,
0.26801347732543945,
0.3126741647720337,
-0.9199011921882629,
0.7869827151298523,
-0.1193133294582367,
-1.1305631399154663,
-0.5968455076217651,
-0.5517101883888245,
-0.762030839920044,
0.02441565692424774,
-0.13569095730781555,
-0.6606005430221558,
-0.05107984319329262,
0.21604524552822113,
-0.29552996158599854,
0.5384999513626099,
-0.7838221788406372,
0.7326894998550415,
-0.2287830412387848,
0.19199499487876892,
-0.6807122230529785,
-0.5580297112464905,
0.0368717685341835,
-0.18250179290771484,
0.3168827295303345,
-0.3032045364379883,
0.2601669728755951,
1.1138311624526978,
-0.46431031823158264,
1.169649362564087,
-0.22276999056339264,
0.18450404703617096,
0.6063554286956787,
0.21301446855068207,
0.4692637622356415,
-0.4594210386276245,
-0.07611547410488129,
-0.3160126209259033,
-0.04260413721203804,
-0.5865344405174255,
-0.6226398348808289,
0.27626296877861023,
-0.5965369939804077,
-0.6402357220649719,
-0.34061339497566223,
-0.6948369741439819,
-0.06746875494718552,
0.08431756496429443,
0.036562271416187286,
0.4859185218811035,
-0.15481966733932495,
0.011993205174803734,
0.39277663826942444,
-0.054272521287202835,
0.5685174465179443,
0.3427514433860779,
-0.4119141101837158,
-0.4489147663116455,
0.9498799443244934,
0.5131190419197083,
0.4686020314693451,
0.36005038022994995,
0.15383799374103546,
-0.08177478611469269,
-0.19332532584667206,
-0.03949272260069847,
0.4411744475364685,
-0.7905446290969849,
-0.056511566042900085,
-0.7112789750099182,
0.020469732582569122,
-0.27914488315582275,
0.12484189122915268,
-0.24965380132198334,
-0.9890952706336975,
-0.20692820847034454,
-0.339653342962265,
0.26367437839508057,
0.7306973338127136,
0.008367104455828667,
0.16715450584888458,
-0.781719446182251,
0.17913629114627838,
0.8425025343894958,
0.4788500666618347,
0.5667716860771179,
-0.4431932270526886,
-0.532025158405304,
0.10033996403217316,
-0.06367177516222,
-0.9401577115058899,
0.20362740755081177,
0.11535089462995529,
0.6877095103263855,
0.22467906773090363,
-0.17390069365501404,
0.9125288128852844,
-0.5519011616706848,
0.6897580027580261,
0.1567002236843109,
-1.5410877466201782,
0.38332468271255493,
-0.11396995186805725,
0.30922603607177734,
0.053679946810007095,
0.04288658872246742,
-0.7800436615943909,
-0.4824412167072296,
-0.7872694730758667,
-0.6492389440536499,
0.5738030076026917,
0.21743661165237427,
0.5089712142944336,
-0.21547767519950867,
0.5547398924827576,
-0.32246994972229004,
0.030562613159418106,
-0.6967896819114685,
-0.14376133680343628,
-0.2198835015296936,
-0.040419358760118484,
-0.027536040171980858,
-0.5764946937561035,
-0.08834396302700043,
-0.5751466751098633,
0.5138640403747559,
-0.29554101824760437,
0.37923213839530945,
0.03319812938570976,
-0.014928719028830528,
-0.2510772943496704,
0.4281666576862335,
0.8812015652656555,
0.8443379998207092,
0.07603202015161514,
0.16453838348388672,
0.7410104274749756,
-0.41624361276626587,
0.14435122907161713,
-0.29009273648262024,
0.4512459933757782,
0.1305832415819168,
0.18862131237983704,
0.9506464004516602,
0.4418099522590637,
-1.1412022113800049,
0.5150430202484131,
-0.15262024104595184,
-0.08797232061624527,
-0.19614405930042267,
0.19432899355888367,
0.5036451816558838,
0.34746646881103516,
0.2988886833190918,
-0.019207265228033066,
-0.03235224634408951,
-0.6391116976737976,
0.09644447267055511,
0.37243878841400146,
-0.6409519910812378,
-0.601311206817627,
0.4923914670944214,
0.2142040878534317,
-0.8339260220527649,
0.494579017162323,
-0.21828779578208923,
-0.9743008017539978,
0.8538249135017395,
0.8669036626815796,
0.9458173513412476,
-0.20277158915996552,
0.3248615264892578,
0.2166842222213745,
0.03751978650689125,
-0.26965636014938354,
0.6463032364845276,
0.1727072298526764,
-0.7566659450531006,
-0.6269813179969788,
-0.7269681692123413,
-0.6090459227561951,
-0.193656787276268,
-0.624883770942688,
0.09721585363149643,
-0.45768046379089355,
-0.7649409770965576,
0.08514649420976639,
-0.06056409701704979,
-0.8384420871734619,
0.5981886386871338,
0.058119695633649826,
1.1445786952972412,
-0.9498775005340576,
0.5317681431770325,
0.87875896692276,
-0.16216610372066498,
-1.11272132396698,
-0.43157678842544556,
-0.24157904088497162,
-0.549144446849823,
0.976613461971283,
0.13437281548976898,
-0.18488164246082306,
-0.20256246626377106,
-0.6193754076957703,
-0.6527805924415588,
0.4221908152103424,
0.5198072195053101,
-0.7123730182647705,
-0.4227287471294403,
0.16052663326263428,
0.6203601360321045,
-0.3917831778526306,
-0.06885069608688354,
0.5419381260871887,
0.41766679286956787,
-0.20904269814491272,
-1.3461790084838867,
0.11661422252655029,
-0.5569400787353516,
0.08058371394872665,
0.2071736752986908,
-0.5883931517601013,
1.3768764734268188,
-0.4553793668746948,
-0.17281410098075867,
-0.12285921722650528,
0.20659378170967102,
0.1533357799053192,
-0.0631931871175766,
0.6993042826652527,
0.7498959302902222,
0.7450165748596191,
0.21465952694416046,
1.0290472507476807,
-0.2154580056667328,
0.6634889245033264,
0.688683807849884,
0.30366408824920654,
0.8707889318466187,
0.41255509853363037,
-0.637167751789093,
0.29790642857551575,
0.17528389394283295,
0.20057789981365204,
0.08556824922561646,
0.3898225426673889,
-0.3173379600048065,
-0.5392953157424927,
-0.13693328201770782,
-0.2349139004945755,
0.43598201870918274,
0.47456398606300354,
-0.12772700190544128,
0.07269521802663803,
-0.11456068605184555,
0.38997921347618103,
-0.2809875011444092,
-0.278745174407959,
0.6001163721084595,
0.2711946666240692,
-0.6338984370231628,
0.28357619047164917,
-0.039572909474372864,
0.28826892375946045,
-0.3172273635864258,
-0.0685654729604721,
0.019310379400849342,
0.15109165012836456,
-0.0019070325652137399,
-0.7556611895561218,
0.36367523670196533,
0.13925141096115112,
-0.21837890148162842,
0.1061396524310112,
0.336692750453949,
-0.10635322332382202,
-0.9970287084579468,
0.10878343880176544,
0.5499879717826843,
0.21767866611480713,
-0.09170618653297424,
-0.7162221670150757,
-0.16117540001869202,
0.18450096249580383,
-0.2022619992494583,
0.1486527919769287,
0.7376699447631836,
-0.25398728251457214,
0.987197995185852,
0.7863509654998779,
0.27330029010772705,
0.2241201102733612,
-0.009566742926836014,
0.9662047028541565,
-1.1252305507659912,
-0.6026350855827332,
-1.1960622072219849,
0.7482234835624695,
0.030396264046430588,
-0.6048941612243652,
0.3281726837158203,
0.3984161615371704,
0.6493911743164062,
-0.013461485505104065,
0.785169243812561,
0.14303705096244812,
0.4889725148677826,
-0.4459473192691803,
0.6903202533721924,
-0.4461685121059418,
0.16319067776203156,
-0.3519187569618225,
-0.8601360321044922,
-0.4073599576950073,
0.8268973231315613,
-0.23687255382537842,
-0.09215840697288513,
0.6800272464752197,
0.43103092908859253,
0.3537791669368744,
0.0899893268942833,
0.2260918766260147,
0.1714373677968979,
0.707569420337677,
0.5874196290969849,
0.665052056312561,
-0.09009204804897308,
0.5206749439239502,
-0.07959406077861786,
-0.038934607058763504,
-0.3316972553730011,
-0.6659654378890991,
-1.1149564981460571,
-0.5740745663642883,
0.0395524799823761,
-0.15243764221668243,
-0.017912939190864563,
1.12583589553833,
0.6573485732078552,
-0.8945900201797485,
-0.37050876021385193,
-0.19367215037345886,
0.13667169213294983,
0.01849203370511532,
-0.22305108606815338,
0.4836679995059967,
-0.5000445246696472,
-0.8840028047561646,
-0.0404801070690155,
0.3548099994659424,
0.3801184892654419,
-0.5010270476341248,
0.2473750114440918,
0.012527606450021267,
0.3244893252849579,
0.4577764868736267,
0.11436624079942703,
-0.842544436454773,
-0.36877110600471497,
0.15870119631290436,
-0.18467199802398682,
0.08285220712423325,
0.8894969820976257,
-0.9024496078491211,
0.973528265953064,
0.6229290962219238,
0.49227678775787354,
0.5474161505699158,
-0.08885779976844788,
0.8340834975242615,
-0.2808888852596283,
0.36741429567337036,
0.4861668348312378,
0.3216117024421692,
0.35221490263938904,
-0.043420903384685516,
0.11462000757455826,
0.40993350744247437,
-0.356505423784256,
-1.0009647607803345,
0.26618385314941406,
-0.6513309478759766,
-0.23672668635845184,
0.7677582502365112,
-0.36090660095214844,
-0.31732726097106934,
-0.15730150043964386,
-0.4624248147010803,
0.14224861562252045,
-0.3340911567211151,
0.8845614194869995,
0.8796830177307129,
-0.1946287751197815,
0.15787135064601898,
-0.4451514184474945,
0.4611038863658905,
0.7249242067337036,
-0.6509789228439331,
0.018815936520695686,
-0.02031715214252472,
0.3211993873119354,
0.4086904525756836,
0.7371588945388794,
-0.04532130807638168,
0.37726524472236633,
0.26720404624938965,
-0.1447182148694992,
0.13484224677085876,
-0.2222891002893448,
0.000436266913311556,
0.22164441645145416,
0.1679559201002121,
0.014158393256366253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08619v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08619v2
|
ALMol: Aligned Language-Molecule Translation LLMs through Offline Preference Contrastive Optimisation
| 2024-05-14T13:59:24 | 2024-05-15T09:08:40 |
Dimitris Gkoumas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM
|
The field of chemistry and Artificial Intelligence (AI) intersection is an
area of active research that aims to accelerate scientific discovery. The
integration of large language models (LLMs) with scientific modalities has
shown significant promise in this endeavour. However, challenges persist in
effectively addressing training efficacy and the out-of-distribution problem,
particularly as existing approaches rely on larger models and datasets. In this
context, we focus on machine language-molecule translation and deploy a novel
training approach called contrastive preference optimisation, which avoids
generating translations that are merely adequate but not perfect. To ensure
generalisability and mitigate memorisation effects, we conduct experiments
using only 10\% of the data. Our results demonstrate that our models achieve up
to a 32\% improvement compared to counterpart models. We also introduce a
scalable fine-grained evaluation methodology that accommodates responsibility.
|
[
-0.3178957402706146,
-0.5513406991958618,
0.6202945113182068,
-0.2836248278617859,
-0.14379972219467163,
0.1554279327392578,
-0.3274025022983551,
-0.41750645637512207,
0.14083494246006012,
0.48736125230789185,
-0.3802758753299713,
-0.44996652007102966,
-0.5960478782653809,
0.16754184663295746,
-0.15808643400669098,
1.0653330087661743,
-0.2929316461086273,
0.47627943754196167,
-0.5739471912384033,
-0.5365740060806274,
0.35623082518577576,
-0.31010136008262634,
-0.5759720802307129,
-0.5090384483337402,
0.4414701759815216,
0.3027147352695465,
0.6366366147994995,
1.0702548027038574,
0.9847139716148376,
0.3181583881378174,
-0.1591598391532898,
0.4572006165981293,
-0.5731035470962524,
-0.002255058381706476,
-0.3044246435165405,
-0.5896438360214233,
-0.5249527096748352,
0.2017836570739746,
0.3105684518814087,
0.8228012919425964,
-0.09933294355869293,
-0.19653615355491638,
-0.10212869942188263,
0.9752792119979858,
-0.7193202972412109,
0.0503840409219265,
-0.7454483509063721,
0.07060364633798599,
0.05328129604458809,
-0.0624740831553936,
-0.20443716645240784,
-0.2777475416660309,
0.23172527551651,
-0.6472127437591553,
-0.0033316879998892546,
0.2512298822402954,
0.5856982469558716,
0.3735327124595642,
-0.629767894744873,
-0.6855352520942688,
-0.4356110394001007,
1.0460702180862427,
-0.6904498338699341,
0.1261276751756668,
0.18016619980335236,
0.2576298117637634,
-0.2543242573738098,
-0.6400527358055115,
-0.5813356637954712,
-0.36592671275138855,
0.03667255491018295,
0.2256261706352234,
-0.033484723418951035,
0.44382908940315247,
-0.330082505941391,
0.3826729655265808,
-0.4048803448677063,
-0.023055465891957283,
-0.3230219781398773,
-0.029937371611595154,
0.5602046847343445,
0.10949798673391342,
0.14180974662303925,
0.08070448040962219,
-0.36257046461105347,
0.06095311790704727,
-0.6368173956871033,
-0.1586494892835617,
0.28421396017074585,
0.37533241510391235,
0.010095663368701935,
0.6932673454284668,
-0.10422351956367493,
0.6790992617607117,
0.16340461373329163,
0.1162567138671875,
0.2454921305179596,
-0.5830236673355103,
-0.07990021258592606,
0.32759585976600647,
0.8736424446105957,
0.37842628359794617,
0.03720598295331001,
-0.07399329543113708,
-0.17453275620937347,
-0.008348517119884491,
-0.04733961448073387,
-1.011861801147461,
-0.3909403681755066,
0.49108776450157166,
-0.256218284368515,
-0.37137889862060547,
-0.29211515188217163,
-0.5937625765800476,
-0.3326214849948883,
-0.26680248975753784,
0.5147155523300171,
-0.4238019585609436,
0.23764753341674805,
0.04705508053302765,
0.04191699996590614,
-0.38699114322662354,
0.22642666101455688,
-1.1945950984954834,
0.11160383373498917,
0.2789144217967987,
0.7436878681182861,
-0.6863406300544739,
0.027457749471068382,
-0.5241836905479431,
0.5462722182273865,
-0.24267549812793732,
0.7640073895454407,
-0.5263625979423523,
-0.4638301730155945,
-0.16857372224330902,
-0.2427006959915161,
-0.016271159052848816,
-0.7695088386535645,
0.45503878593444824,
-0.47218087315559387,
0.4330117106437683,
0.11575563251972198,
-0.7385134696960449,
-0.02366488054394722,
0.21064423024654388,
-0.4595009684562683,
0.7568361759185791,
0.24661485850811005,
-0.27732494473457336,
0.15605267882347107,
-1.0211154222488403,
-0.11399804055690765,
-0.2608128786087036,
-0.31739965081214905,
-0.5331375598907471,
-0.03069087117910385,
0.23603111505508423,
0.1867333948612213,
-0.22957901656627655,
0.14277444779872894,
-0.4473254382610321,
-0.13849014043807983,
0.5221546292304993,
-0.05816110596060753,
0.5641378164291382,
0.42059779167175293,
-0.2838832139968872,
0.545332133769989,
-0.5819234848022461,
0.055247727781534195,
-0.2031143605709076,
-0.5170960426330566,
-0.3047761619091034,
-0.3050782382488251,
0.1666664332151413,
0.41589727997779846,
0.5198041796684265,
-0.44890549778938293,
0.43141305446624756,
-0.5055148601531982,
0.8278571963310242,
0.7469225525856018,
-0.31479907035827637,
0.8269211053848267,
-0.11563557386398315,
0.376694917678833,
0.1463320106267929,
0.13313956558704376,
0.0979088693857193,
-0.23272491991519928,
-0.9094592332839966,
-0.6022774577140808,
0.1761702597141266,
0.438492089509964,
-0.6868083477020264,
0.5997644662857056,
-0.26231756806373596,
-0.3079921007156372,
-0.8559880256652832,
0.6763134002685547,
0.5875748991966248,
0.44441699981689453,
0.5379001498222351,
-0.17530590295791626,
-0.2764972448348999,
-1.1491844654083252,
-0.17155452072620392,
-0.0741972029209137,
0.08454451709985733,
0.5967685580253601,
0.4521406590938568,
-0.6370044350624084,
0.9751055240631104,
-0.5049325823783875,
-0.42251086235046387,
-0.43655043840408325,
0.026251280680298805,
0.17323917150497437,
0.44374072551727295,
0.3116065561771393,
-0.9771312475204468,
-0.6877127289772034,
0.38225963711738586,
-0.7030841708183289,
-0.20934507250785828,
0.3028859794139862,
-0.39365002512931824,
0.5075021982192993,
0.7229077816009521,
-0.7049177289009094,
-0.04212985932826996,
0.6651813387870789,
0.004470078274607658,
-0.18784919381141663,
-0.377064049243927,
0.24249574542045593,
-1.2337474822998047,
0.31800365447998047,
-0.33849865198135376,
-0.1980506181716919,
-0.7269023060798645,
-0.025641553103923798,
0.12233873456716537,
-0.10000235587358475,
-1.054272174835205,
0.7836809754371643,
-0.38501182198524475,
0.06443087756633759,
-0.4050109386444092,
0.4060683846473694,
0.10906945914030075,
0.41615134477615356,
0.0323256254196167,
0.7940986156463623,
0.16244052350521088,
-0.470874547958374,
0.3465498685836792,
0.2716589868068695,
-0.18036581575870514,
0.38608887791633606,
-0.4357467293739319,
0.10670579969882965,
0.11438358575105667,
0.20093421638011932,
-1.0309808254241943,
-0.3552977442741394,
0.3836096227169037,
-0.29520556330680847,
0.27227458357810974,
0.16495446860790253,
-0.0412667877972126,
0.024428825825452805,
-0.3105470538139343,
0.754191517829895,
0.4503769278526306,
-0.5166419744491577,
0.8142303228378296,
0.34341925382614136,
-0.0895901471376419,
-0.41460585594177246,
-0.5142597556114197,
-0.23026949167251587,
-0.4375964403152466,
-0.5620648264884949,
0.4817340075969696,
-0.26757675409317017,
-0.4908541142940521,
0.05617557466030121,
-0.05214289575815201,
-0.10352515429258347,
-0.18754160404205322,
-0.013802140019834042,
0.3345136344432831,
-0.040350306779146194,
-0.10632092505693436,
-0.017288638278841972,
-0.11921223998069763,
-0.16063056886196136,
-0.2923702895641327,
0.5627080798149109,
-0.2169620394706726,
-0.19307741522789001,
-0.32214128971099854,
0.38546469807624817,
0.682283878326416,
-0.13033205270767212,
0.6710137128829956,
0.31244581937789917,
0.11434967070817947,
0.03952410817146301,
-0.11177027970552444,
-0.16107355058193207,
-0.5606079697608948,
0.6647340655326843,
-0.053180813789367676,
-0.5956021547317505,
0.3879254162311554,
0.003126968163996935,
-0.2724940776824951,
0.3144766688346863,
0.5665838718414307,
-0.3020605146884918,
1.1948401927947998,
0.4822750389575958,
-0.07290541380643845,
0.49364984035491943,
-0.19879940152168274,
0.42838001251220703,
-0.7216194868087769,
-0.2268953174352646,
-0.24305935204029083,
-0.29174819588661194,
-0.5067712068557739,
-0.46193748712539673,
0.7068639993667603,
0.30496394634246826,
0.1411837637424469,
0.1337297260761261,
-0.2809707522392273,
0.5791370272636414,
0.5031677484512329,
0.16377347707748413,
0.2928280830383301,
0.20290367305278778,
-0.11295942962169647,
0.041122861206531525,
-0.6900245547294617,
-0.3248315751552582,
1.4238710403442383,
-0.06539745628833771,
0.6086242198944092,
0.19563540816307068,
0.6312624216079712,
0.21515755355358124,
0.21773003041744232,
-0.8798887133598328,
0.5243683457374573,
-0.24396638572216034,
-0.6303641200065613,
-0.25512439012527466,
-0.5101092457771301,
-1.0082993507385254,
0.06331493705511093,
-0.29366326332092285,
-0.3133125305175781,
-0.0039243618957698345,
0.3833305835723877,
-0.17221708595752716,
0.08948251605033875,
-0.5979195237159729,
0.8142462968826294,
-0.5032128095626831,
-0.6839231252670288,
-0.4323406219482422,
-0.8553878664970398,
0.17493799328804016,
-0.20798003673553467,
0.2366085648536682,
-0.028565388172864914,
-0.11841316521167755,
0.5716729164123535,
-0.37350454926490784,
0.20447883009910583,
0.3492428958415985,
-0.06122567132115364,
0.0810404047369957,
-0.1348254233598709,
0.495113343000412,
-0.4291406571865082,
-0.11103927344083786,
0.1645325869321823,
-0.17264717817306519,
-0.756014347076416,
-0.7844933271408081,
0.8045597672462463,
-0.7579258680343628,
-0.5266028046607971,
-0.3346788287162781,
-1.0262433290481567,
-0.20012210309505463,
0.22389855980873108,
0.274550199508667,
0.025575870648026466,
-0.1111832708120346,
0.14004479348659515,
0.644328236579895,
-0.09648053348064423,
0.46061408519744873,
0.6123964190483093,
-0.3828655183315277,
-0.6719202399253845,
1.1407716274261475,
-0.18714720010757446,
0.7983689904212952,
0.5044357180595398,
0.16931621730327606,
-0.4282923936843872,
-0.7323630452156067,
-0.5841013193130493,
0.17851340770721436,
-0.842125415802002,
0.2702896296977997,
-0.544322669506073,
-0.10250198096036911,
-0.37107086181640625,
-0.4549100995063782,
-0.5476844906806946,
-0.741138756275177,
-0.14771457016468048,
0.14358606934547424,
0.3052208423614502,
0.556011974811554,
-0.03442727401852608,
0.3057886064052582,
-0.8039875626564026,
0.27036622166633606,
0.09855662286281586,
-0.1407502293586731,
-0.5547889471054077,
-0.4707117974758148,
-0.5002084374427795,
0.03998783975839615,
-0.4442961513996124,
-0.41911521553993225,
0.47426021099090576,
0.4300585687160492,
0.5463331341743469,
0.6497413516044617,
-0.1060502827167511,
0.37241828441619873,
-0.4168013334274292,
0.5216723084449768,
0.2291608452796936,
-0.8064889311790466,
0.5957784056663513,
-0.5771647095680237,
0.09748420864343643,
0.7925750017166138,
0.5207189917564392,
-0.22024333477020264,
-0.27800223231315613,
-0.4354539215564728,
-1.2834986448287964,
0.5221258997917175,
0.3887777030467987,
-0.2424217015504837,
0.12441810965538025,
0.2774984836578369,
0.07248615473508835,
0.5251645445823669,
-0.5713226199150085,
-0.4391791522502899,
0.021654648706316948,
-0.6633489727973938,
-0.44329002499580383,
0.14886826276779175,
-0.39918026328086853,
-0.17051571607589722,
0.9283154010772705,
-0.061242058873176575,
-0.02819054387509823,
-0.15899479389190674,
-0.1318666934967041,
0.051643256098032,
0.2582206130027771,
0.7233790755271912,
0.4753289818763733,
-0.5561621189117432,
0.12415654957294464,
-0.13012053072452545,
-0.44911858439445496,
0.39058172702789307,
0.03911355137825012,
-0.2183200865983963,
-0.2186979055404663,
0.15998466312885284,
0.6221635937690735,
-0.22196339070796967,
-1.0069072246551514,
0.30222058296203613,
0.3729415833950043,
-0.01964000053703785,
0.09435034543275833,
0.27519121766090393,
0.12304557114839554,
0.11591994017362595,
0.03540074825286865,
0.29821649193763733,
0.2754390239715576,
-0.7446193099021912,
0.09403245896100998,
0.6316131353378296,
-0.5311334133148193,
-0.014892456121742725,
0.6219377517700195,
0.4690385162830353,
-0.13268500566482544,
0.5237075686454773,
-0.06090061739087105,
-0.5009291768074036,
0.6747546195983887,
0.38258296251296997,
0.7098003625869751,
-0.44481709599494934,
-0.224939227104187,
0.010199303738772869,
-0.1760016828775406,
0.09938056766986847,
0.039173778146505356,
0.01865696720778942,
-0.7715811133384705,
0.30812615156173706,
-0.4428073763847351,
-0.6863822937011719,
-0.06879543513059616,
-0.6793115735054016,
0.3233315944671631,
-0.1958082914352417,
0.07031044363975525,
-0.1280396431684494,
0.017555737867951393,
-0.1666949987411499,
0.2621373236179352,
-0.16241443157196045,
0.5208254456520081,
-0.8495990037918091,
1.1711078882217407,
0.6784725189208984,
-0.33189675211906433,
-0.10128515213727951,
-0.23062734305858612,
0.16641853749752045,
-0.9369688630104065,
0.8049399852752686,
0.21044234931468964,
-0.3317117393016815,
0.1798768788576126,
-0.3458539843559265,
-0.9532849192619324,
0.9384096264839172,
0.4324759542942047,
-0.5396698117256165,
0.3274667263031006,
0.49190235137939453,
0.5883114337921143,
-0.6860610246658325,
0.3432500958442688,
0.726158857345581,
0.47569647431373596,
0.15086138248443604,
-0.6764378547668457,
-0.2516426146030426,
-0.5249649882316589,
-0.2481275200843811,
0.2708043158054352,
-0.6326384544372559,
0.7690632343292236,
-0.15380123257637024,
0.16725343465805054,
0.2561693787574768,
0.40914177894592285,
0.4241073727607727,
0.32967284321784973,
0.18023478984832764,
0.39716678857803345,
0.5941305756568909,
0.00540508097037673,
1.0029405355453491,
-0.6341271996498108,
0.20535318553447723,
1.0801506042480469,
-0.4252883791923523,
0.9777200818061829,
1.1267329454421997,
-0.2376832365989685,
-0.007176060229539871,
0.7370267510414124,
0.07058804482221603,
1.0088924169540405,
0.2687600255012512,
-0.5360154509544373,
-0.18652984499931335,
-0.5986824035644531,
-0.3333037495613098,
0.3052651584148407,
0.44500836730003357,
-0.5688105225563049,
0.17172901332378387,
0.0029683243483304977,
-0.056807950139045715,
0.23068103194236755,
-0.3899478018283844,
0.545133113861084,
-0.014895494095981121,
-0.6384288668632507,
0.6961982250213623,
0.06739621609449387,
0.5406584143638611,
-0.763741135597229,
0.05437802895903587,
-0.4804074764251709,
0.6455773711204529,
-0.12283238768577576,
-0.4942660629749298,
0.04854895547032356,
-0.4034302234649658,
-0.2980620861053467,
-0.051013026386499405,
0.08956422656774521,
-0.9276357293128967,
-0.5053978562355042,
0.4168291389942169,
0.2646300494670868,
0.3298615515232086,
0.2304007112979889,
-0.5546749234199524,
-0.1097833663225174,
0.29711243510246277,
-0.15391170978546143,
0.5037587881088257,
0.05657511577010155,
-0.1649150252342224,
0.9025024175643921,
0.5313537120819092,
0.04393981024622917,
-0.15139634907245636,
-0.43359553813934326,
0.9106350541114807,
-0.5145964622497559,
-0.33139097690582275,
-1.015298843383789,
0.3787368834018707,
-0.004979525227099657,
-0.23760953545570374,
0.7598772644996643,
0.9133928418159485,
0.7625806927680969,
-0.11549006402492523,
0.845778226852417,
0.30406904220581055,
0.15507984161376953,
-0.9346139430999756,
0.7113234996795654,
-0.6289175152778625,
0.33735892176628113,
0.010175507515668869,
-1.0171940326690674,
-0.24688024818897247,
0.5135266780853271,
-0.21838165819644928,
0.05963366478681564,
0.9549748301506042,
1.066698670387268,
-0.24823340773582458,
-0.2875439524650574,
0.2688398063182831,
0.20006848871707916,
0.47152411937713623,
0.8175774216651917,
0.6086927652359009,
-0.4013407528400421,
0.6520824432373047,
-0.1837155520915985,
-0.023300299420952797,
-0.4602116644382477,
-0.8414031267166138,
-1.0683097839355469,
-0.33117255568504333,
-0.2398095726966858,
-0.38084876537323,
0.2808709740638733,
1.4121671915054321,
0.6480355858802795,
-1.0836459398269653,
-0.4862082600593567,
-0.3531951904296875,
-0.3216729760169983,
0.24077928066253662,
-0.1208985298871994,
0.6262854933738708,
-0.13229599595069885,
-1.0130398273468018,
0.582442045211792,
0.4934373199939728,
0.3014976382255554,
-0.2915623188018799,
-0.47577813267707825,
-0.23434457182884216,
0.27831390500068665,
0.32659560441970825,
0.18579141795635223,
-0.8189764618873596,
0.2371370494365692,
-0.08156999945640564,
-0.40589237213134766,
0.4773837625980377,
0.6375534534454346,
-0.43150565028190613,
0.5756679773330688,
0.3883138597011566,
0.6837682127952576,
0.4734465479850769,
0.07858528941869736,
0.8334894776344299,
-0.3354821503162384,
0.36918625235557556,
0.11692433059215546,
0.2576758861541748,
0.4509187638759613,
-0.3032672107219696,
0.6200335621833801,
0.2120221108198166,
-0.57254958152771,
-0.6009687781333923,
0.29233112931251526,
-1.1129841804504395,
-0.4646850526332855,
1.2139904499053955,
-0.22709819674491882,
-0.29565051198005676,
-0.02369789592921734,
-0.3485742211341858,
0.2607494592666626,
-0.6624608039855957,
1.070863962173462,
0.747701108455658,
-0.5718106031417847,
0.24985770881175995,
-0.4268236458301544,
0.6920329332351685,
0.9798809885978699,
-0.8954904675483704,
-0.15444760024547577,
0.4876261055469513,
-0.06780901551246643,
0.2234848141670227,
0.34420204162597656,
-0.009331267327070236,
0.04193277657032013,
-0.33300861716270447,
0.23318271338939667,
-0.21139343082904816,
-0.26217377185821533,
-0.4915967583656311,
-0.038711290806531906,
-0.05528412014245987,
-0.14770138263702393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13015v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13015v1
|
Assisted Debate Builder with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-14T13:42:12 | 2024-05-14T13:42:12 |
Elliot Faugier, Frédéric Armetta, Angela Bonifati, Bruno Yun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce ADBL2, an assisted debate builder tool. It is based on the
capability of large language models to generalise and perform relation-based
argument mining in a wide-variety of domains. It is the first open-source tool
that leverages relation-based mining for (1) the verification of
pre-established relations in a debate and (2) the assisted creation of new
arguments by means of large language models. ADBL2 is highly modular and can
work with any open-source large language models that are used as plugins. As a
by-product, we also provide the first fine-tuned Mistral-7B large language
model for relation-based argument mining, usable by ADBL2, which outperforms
existing approaches for this task with an overall F1-score of 90.59% across all
domains.
|
[
-0.5499274134635925,
-1.3389956951141357,
0.42315438389778137,
0.14721450209617615,
-0.2580130696296692,
-0.1972782164812088,
0.0038533664774149656,
-0.32100915908813477,
0.10422714054584503,
0.3686907887458801,
-0.41294464468955994,
-0.24624188244342804,
-0.3585546016693115,
-0.28578969836235046,
-0.13193416595458984,
1.0559778213500977,
-0.03417098522186279,
0.2811291515827179,
-0.34801289439201355,
-0.19596990942955017,
-0.40829455852508545,
-0.4330769181251526,
-0.9369197487831116,
-0.44835466146469116,
0.6042507886886597,
0.33837956190109253,
0.8711259961128235,
0.33233240246772766,
0.2560116946697235,
0.29481351375579834,
-0.3597935438156128,
0.47498857975006104,
-0.2701808214187622,
0.3940819203853607,
-0.6369077563285828,
-0.3658771216869354,
-0.93825763463974,
-0.18997302651405334,
0.3326677978038788,
0.3949180543422699,
-0.26559051871299744,
0.18400052189826965,
-0.3124009370803833,
0.5534537434577942,
-0.48249027132987976,
0.24350717663764954,
-1.1602587699890137,
-0.34999653697013855,
-0.4524412453174591,
-0.1452202945947647,
-0.49501094222068787,
-0.3443571627140045,
-0.059609994292259216,
-0.3858434557914734,
-0.023758064955472946,
0.11641441285610199,
0.7136572599411011,
0.1308906525373459,
-0.6771026849746704,
-0.6734502911567688,
-0.4435584247112274,
0.3631109297275543,
-0.7857937812805176,
0.21111050248146057,
0.2421744167804718,
0.14717626571655273,
-0.517588198184967,
-0.8412283062934875,
-0.5483714938163757,
0.09730048477649689,
-0.17807221412658691,
-0.01315232738852501,
-0.46944597363471985,
0.2499178946018219,
0.32411816716194153,
0.2921411395072937,
-0.5006611347198486,
0.1283717155456543,
-0.45383673906326294,
-0.11220444738864899,
0.7731158137321472,
0.2007199227809906,
0.05923166126012802,
-0.3696107864379883,
-0.3104461431503296,
0.34322696924209595,
-0.9389951229095459,
-0.036789022386074066,
0.682660698890686,
0.017329003661870956,
0.25224336981773376,
0.46451249718666077,
-0.03535613417625427,
0.843919038772583,
0.10845977813005447,
0.18737368285655975,
-0.29194480180740356,
-0.2645474672317505,
-0.1755378544330597,
0.26676177978515625,
0.9175050258636475,
0.3473290205001831,
0.1233627051115036,
0.254359632730484,
0.028530342504382133,
0.203698992729187,
0.05780040845274925,
-0.9993228912353516,
-0.9179522395133972,
0.36106953024864197,
-0.3087320029735565,
-0.1821223795413971,
-0.17415066063404083,
-0.7107166051864624,
-0.7092053294181824,
0.11466467380523682,
0.20589669048786163,
-0.07112295925617218,
-0.7793574929237366,
0.07132019847631454,
-0.15380898118019104,
0.021436983719468117,
0.4480931758880615,
-0.7185207605361938,
0.4180487394332886,
0.714841902256012,
0.6163763999938965,
0.077139712870121,
0.19859646260738373,
-0.8615427017211914,
0.17541933059692383,
-0.6586828231811523,
1.4849698543548584,
-0.49655506014823914,
-0.35545846819877625,
0.1636403650045395,
-0.1964159905910492,
0.19926968216896057,
-0.772735595703125,
0.6128974556922913,
-0.9690505862236023,
0.42993640899658203,
-0.03748025745153427,
-0.766091525554657,
-0.128816157579422,
0.30260154604911804,
-1.005208134651184,
0.976140022277832,
-0.022525792941451073,
-0.9168540835380554,
0.2709575295448303,
-0.8759446144104004,
-0.5715950131416321,
0.4129325747489929,
-0.20668049156665802,
-0.43396785855293274,
-0.24001668393611908,
-0.022797001525759697,
0.11497440934181213,
-0.6234323382377625,
0.5728601813316345,
-0.5306852459907532,
0.12509377300739288,
0.027712523937225342,
-0.10931277275085449,
1.150826334953308,
0.22913073003292084,
-0.19672246277332306,
0.2504362463951111,
-0.5579348802566528,
0.028051884844899178,
0.11040741950273514,
-0.19859379529953003,
-0.49945953488349915,
0.3128237724304199,
-0.1656060367822647,
0.24234351515769958,
0.19735290110111237,
-0.6959050297737122,
0.40510135889053345,
-0.5681328177452087,
0.4458112120628357,
0.5998004674911499,
0.35238590836524963,
-0.05438544601202011,
0.13742268085479736,
0.43813860416412354,
0.12782062590122223,
-0.3247860074043274,
-0.27730506658554077,
-0.8335832953453064,
-0.6234641075134277,
-0.02669212408363819,
0.6484922170639038,
0.5000109076499939,
-0.5155172348022461,
0.38115137815475464,
0.017732510343194008,
-0.40765905380249023,
-0.7790576219558716,
0.26990699768066406,
0.3026261031627655,
0.2018546611070633,
0.31983113288879395,
-0.22306732833385468,
-0.8089141249656677,
-0.9586252570152283,
-0.0539172887802124,
-0.9292766451835632,
0.24357596039772034,
0.42050865292549133,
0.29682785272598267,
-0.14193715155124664,
1.0661146640777588,
-0.8467805981636047,
-0.20169024169445038,
-0.29005616903305054,
0.3693842589855194,
-0.08281998336315155,
0.2784794867038727,
0.48761552572250366,
-0.6521359086036682,
-0.747438907623291,
0.12310846149921417,
-0.6018921136856079,
-0.1957148313522339,
-0.05472305417060852,
-0.3238244950771332,
0.48943495750427246,
0.4472021162509918,
-0.9796925187110901,
0.3140428066253662,
0.273177832365036,
-0.6870254278182983,
0.5984647870063782,
0.08829048275947571,
-0.058528803288936615,
-1.2503591775894165,
0.06410132348537445,
-0.15463796257972717,
-0.28341302275657654,
-0.5510210990905762,
0.005898407660424709,
-0.09017208218574524,
-0.007445130497217178,
-0.25342801213264465,
0.901444137096405,
-0.24731305241584778,
0.4335651993751526,
-0.48291563987731934,
0.20199526846408844,
0.1028151735663414,
0.2214433252811432,
0.22329336404800415,
0.526059091091156,
0.4477386474609375,
-0.33509182929992676,
0.8931759595870972,
0.5605376958847046,
-0.37384694814682007,
0.8119839429855347,
-0.9128534197807312,
0.3662530481815338,
0.19705021381378174,
0.41877973079681396,
-1.2789536714553833,
-0.19093380868434906,
0.12046380341053009,
-0.4837985336780548,
0.34779706597328186,
-0.3789963126182556,
-0.5580383539199829,
-0.4471016228199005,
-0.2693195044994354,
0.19658927619457245,
0.2234506905078888,
-0.6315673589706421,
0.4279254078865051,
0.8326882123947144,
-0.7540798187255859,
-0.4773443937301636,
-0.26647651195526123,
0.10870448499917984,
-0.18771634995937347,
-0.8130029439926147,
0.2666766941547394,
-0.3591381907463074,
-0.6829366683959961,
0.324078232049942,
0.04882771894335747,
-0.35704687237739563,
-0.16946850717067719,
0.1769966185092926,
0.2813990116119385,
-0.31292763352394104,
0.2005760818719864,
0.12882249057292938,
0.08689967542886734,
0.47668933868408203,
0.2041763812303543,
0.2211221307516098,
-0.0030436343513429165,
-0.25215989351272583,
-0.026822058483958244,
0.5752050280570984,
0.46011438965797424,
-0.336087703704834,
0.5763251185417175,
0.45985326170921326,
-0.36010244488716125,
-0.43433135747909546,
-0.770463764667511,
-0.022932803258299828,
-0.4863702058792114,
0.6350411772727966,
-0.5752674341201782,
-0.8899471163749695,
0.4321715235710144,
-0.2483101785182953,
0.630586564540863,
0.5172855854034424,
0.890312671661377,
0.31271547079086304,
1.2591838836669922,
0.1529972106218338,
0.10038863122463226,
0.10857830196619034,
0.07937300950288773,
0.30918529629707336,
-0.689842700958252,
-0.28490182757377625,
-0.29656633734703064,
-0.22580872476100922,
-0.13490398228168488,
-0.4399888813495636,
-0.01130236592143774,
0.1615840494632721,
-0.21856507658958435,
0.25429728627204895,
-0.26419925689697266,
0.20362676680088043,
0.37142983078956604,
-0.24626348912715912,
0.3194660246372223,
-0.15345638990402222,
0.0034289539325982332,
-0.07421166449785233,
-0.8042861819267273,
-0.29567745327949524,
0.881222665309906,
0.43131503462791443,
0.7444394826889038,
0.318305641412735,
0.3976651430130005,
0.35254740715026855,
0.6297484040260315,
-1.0968507528305054,
0.7067810297012329,
0.16934017837047577,
-1.2634328603744507,
-0.14761042594909668,
-0.465264230966568,
-0.9721400141716003,
0.3880627155303955,
-0.16176749765872955,
-0.489075630903244,
-0.059218112379312515,
0.3453406095504761,
-0.37919434905052185,
0.6278656721115112,
-0.8234302997589111,
1.1392210721969604,
-0.0968964546918869,
-0.6878636479377747,
-0.4329909384250641,
-0.26457077264785767,
0.5888867378234863,
0.14810903370380402,
0.2650100290775299,
0.09829562902450562,
0.3549078106880188,
0.964556872844696,
-0.5012512803077698,
0.40360990166664124,
-0.48042458295822144,
-0.357678085565567,
0.8110394477844238,
0.35074347257614136,
0.5073882937431335,
0.33853235840797424,
-0.12993083894252777,
-0.3277548551559448,
-0.07075071334838867,
-0.14995118975639343,
-0.6868586540222168,
1.0192257165908813,
-0.5035567879676819,
-1.0368980169296265,
-0.21034972369670868,
-0.4626188576221466,
-0.18922586739063263,
0.06360612064599991,
-0.3594091832637787,
0.5878984928131104,
-0.5312256813049316,
0.3924691379070282,
0.5616461038589478,
-0.09048669785261154,
0.19190514087677002,
0.7692864537239075,
-0.20412613451480865,
-0.5928261280059814,
0.5589002370834351,
-0.06691393256187439,
-0.05194530636072159,
-0.00505086500197649,
0.23289941251277924,
-0.580535352230072,
-0.404964417219162,
-0.6888369917869568,
0.11119171977043152,
-0.7014583349227905,
-0.6932858824729919,
-0.8225934505462646,
-0.3032453656196594,
-0.20918378233909607,
0.10501490533351898,
-0.5456475019454956,
-0.6725536584854126,
0.1845310926437378,
-0.3701246976852417,
0.5208029747009277,
1.0059083700180054,
0.05450717732310295,
-0.04266917333006859,
-0.5017605423927307,
0.37968501448631287,
0.6672351360321045,
0.5152522921562195,
0.02658175863325596,
-0.46766939759254456,
-0.20235632359981537,
-0.17217805981636047,
-0.5668255090713501,
-1.0801489353179932,
-0.0885678306221962,
0.14875192940235138,
0.5608257055282593,
0.625488817691803,
0.2184259593486786,
0.7312446236610413,
-0.694797694683075,
1.0738699436187744,
0.23092670738697052,
-0.663106381893158,
0.6405815482139587,
-0.2657186686992645,
-0.0658574253320694,
0.22933579981327057,
0.31273677945137024,
0.03746882453560829,
-0.23576568067073822,
-0.897608757019043,
-0.8386313915252686,
0.8344787359237671,
-0.07929224520921707,
-0.158808171749115,
-0.21024712920188904,
0.017768612131476402,
-0.01732584275305271,
0.12003348767757416,
-0.7767260670661926,
-0.29805752635002136,
0.042639635503292084,
-0.06631612032651901,
0.44659504294395447,
-0.5508517622947693,
-0.4388395845890045,
-0.2995157241821289,
0.8279569149017334,
0.09624229371547699,
-0.23491719365119934,
0.01805647648870945,
0.009003696031868458,
-0.5708306431770325,
0.435648649930954,
0.26366597414016724,
0.7771075367927551,
-0.18045295774936676,
0.3345027565956116,
0.20514632761478424,
-0.017534781247377396,
0.20312124490737915,
0.5048392415046692,
-0.03155716881155968,
0.35481953620910645,
0.3299925923347473,
0.9680936932563782,
0.010785791091620922,
-0.6509253978729248,
0.4187878966331482,
0.09115806967020035,
-0.5948431491851807,
-0.16950061917304993,
-0.15984255075454712,
0.6012387871742249,
0.21077404916286469,
0.08550525456666946,
-0.11685161292552948,
0.17984680831432343,
-0.7114784121513367,
0.3754161596298218,
0.8593765497207642,
-0.4252314567565918,
-0.36432963609695435,
0.8991496562957764,
0.43741506338119507,
-0.485239714384079,
0.2643671929836273,
-0.41132035851478577,
-0.5512544512748718,
0.28767040371894836,
0.5680209398269653,
0.6692021489143372,
-0.41341954469680786,
0.3167983591556549,
0.518997848033905,
0.03355037420988083,
0.12767517566680908,
0.20314957201480865,
0.04918891191482544,
-0.4723741412162781,
-0.35070958733558655,
-0.3977762460708618,
-0.506398618221283,
0.4373248219490051,
-0.44179150462150574,
0.36000746488571167,
-0.35739243030548096,
-0.14329217374324799,
0.36864325404167175,
0.4934447705745697,
-0.19576817750930786,
-0.04897824674844742,
0.18759922683238983,
0.9378548860549927,
-0.7094767689704895,
0.9897874593734741,
1.332503080368042,
-0.01123473234474659,
-0.5169840455055237,
-0.41801905632019043,
-0.00954548642039299,
-0.19815920293331146,
0.7328818440437317,
-0.04700716212391853,
-0.36277034878730774,
-0.07190243899822235,
-0.5258115530014038,
-0.2836416959762573,
0.810357391834259,
0.34975579380989075,
-0.13239078223705292,
0.13223080337047577,
-0.2917627692222595,
0.5241104364395142,
-0.38729241490364075,
0.450786828994751,
0.3830340802669525,
0.3936503827571869,
0.21324925124645233,
-0.8707051873207092,
0.15370707213878632,
-0.5875356793403625,
-0.4065268039703369,
0.383609414100647,
-0.6191487908363342,
0.7747935652732849,
-0.25080883502960205,
-0.13784080743789673,
-0.054853279143571854,
0.7482680082321167,
0.3137875497341156,
0.31346237659454346,
0.6763325929641724,
0.6018099784851074,
0.52488774061203,
0.2587262690067291,
0.47280073165893555,
-0.2705196440219879,
0.23543423414230347,
1.2882168292999268,
-0.5279030799865723,
0.9887248873710632,
0.13254578411579132,
-0.24105705320835114,
1.042760968208313,
0.419182687997818,
0.13738109171390533,
0.25413012504577637,
0.23975799977779388,
-0.2915031909942627,
-0.4427497982978821,
-0.23938453197479248,
-0.4383467733860016,
0.23374836146831512,
0.7185799479484558,
-0.13859118521213531,
-0.3554679751396179,
-0.7586061358451843,
0.24288906157016754,
0.3324544429779053,
-0.1989412158727646,
1.0445466041564941,
0.08369379490613937,
-1.1047934293746948,
0.6173222064971924,
0.14511406421661377,
0.3746764659881592,
-0.8658344745635986,
-0.3335835337638855,
0.005323412828147411,
0.25532054901123047,
-0.2872787415981293,
-0.9630566835403442,
0.21341897547245026,
0.20101329684257507,
-0.11206725984811783,
0.1042107343673706,
0.9402348399162292,
-0.8236520290374756,
-0.16030392050743103,
0.43330273032188416,
0.6268051266670227,
-0.11678379029035568,
0.05118442699313164,
-0.804152250289917,
-0.009831639006733894,
0.01009242795407772,
-0.6119065284729004,
0.2647218406200409,
0.5324873924255371,
-0.018950166180729866,
0.3557206392288208,
0.415964275598526,
0.3289104700088501,
-0.2964240610599518,
-0.0755399540066719,
1.1304281949996948,
-0.374271959066391,
-0.42391055822372437,
-0.9830498695373535,
0.6410756707191467,
-0.48411640524864197,
-0.13507193326950073,
0.750665009021759,
0.9203736782073975,
0.452646404504776,
0.06670587509870529,
0.7868288159370422,
-0.2873924970626831,
0.593870997428894,
-0.23214954137802124,
0.5857914090156555,
-0.5275677442550659,
0.008256209082901478,
-0.22553184628486633,
-0.7494586706161499,
-0.09825552254915237,
0.6934019327163696,
-0.19700631499290466,
-0.5046135783195496,
0.8528661727905273,
0.8475003242492676,
-0.22310157120227814,
0.08933358639478683,
-0.1207038089632988,
0.23560024797916412,
0.5930325984954834,
0.745830237865448,
0.6548082828521729,
-0.3563210666179657,
0.9525255560874939,
0.259575217962265,
-0.44920557737350464,
-0.05026305839419365,
-0.7382307052612305,
-1.3870784044265747,
-0.40574678778648376,
-0.6385144591331482,
-0.5577777624130249,
0.021043449640274048,
1.05801260471344,
0.6701073050498962,
-1.036275029182434,
-0.3554246425628662,
0.024277564138174057,
0.26246070861816406,
0.16398100554943085,
-0.24564777314662933,
0.37383410334587097,
-0.17155157029628754,
-0.5473566055297852,
0.5010231733322144,
0.08670707046985626,
-0.4156668186187744,
-0.4469996690750122,
-0.05310256779193878,
-0.591307520866394,
0.37321096658706665,
0.7704516649246216,
0.3032096028327942,
-0.7193247079849243,
-0.0384429506957531,
-0.44770199060440063,
0.18479879200458527,
0.02692851983010769,
0.8206000328063965,
-0.6330207586288452,
0.8396826982498169,
0.5117656588554382,
0.5483161211013794,
0.2533895671367645,
0.41635406017303467,
0.8291928768157959,
-0.6573871970176697,
0.35623329877853394,
0.009697798639535904,
0.3628411889076233,
0.5491974353790283,
-0.06563492864370346,
0.4623180031776428,
0.16525989770889282,
-0.6554334759712219,
-1.0434678792953491,
0.5557586550712585,
-0.679257869720459,
-0.3506070673465729,
1.362427830696106,
-0.38490888476371765,
0.24657538533210754,
-0.29480957984924316,
-0.5980883836746216,
0.06293404847383499,
-0.4603327214717865,
0.6335041522979736,
0.8766530752182007,
-0.15350018441677094,
0.10690785944461823,
-0.5038555264472961,
0.8844844102859497,
0.3117924630641937,
-0.7769666910171509,
0.4667832851409912,
0.785727322101593,
0.08225588500499725,
0.22610662877559662,
0.9274351596832275,
-0.17499510943889618,
0.2495582550764084,
0.2945478558540344,
-0.1961187869310379,
-0.2532074451446533,
-0.35725435614585876,
0.1919168382883072,
0.564429521560669,
0.41353893280029297,
0.15283749997615814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08603v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08603v1
|
A Comprehensive Survey of Large Language Models and Multimodal Large Language Models in Medicine
| 2024-05-14T13:42:05 | 2024-05-14T13:42:05 |
Hanguang Xiao, Feizhong Zhou, Xingyue Liu, Tianqi Liu, Zhipeng Li, Xin Liu, Xiaoxuan Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Since the release of ChatGPT and GPT-4, large language models (LLMs) and
multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have garnered significant attention
due to their powerful and general capabilities in understanding, reasoning, and
generation, thereby offering new paradigms for the integration of artificial
intelligence with medicine. This survey comprehensively overviews the
development background and principles of LLMs and MLLMs, as well as explores
their application scenarios, challenges, and future directions in medicine.
Specifically, this survey begins by focusing on the paradigm shift, tracing the
evolution from traditional models to LLMs and MLLMs, summarizing the model
structures to provide detailed foundational knowledge. Subsequently, the survey
details the entire process from constructing and evaluating to using LLMs and
MLLMs with a clear logic. Following this, to emphasize the significant value of
LLMs and MLLMs in healthcare, we survey and summarize 6 promising applications
in healthcare. Finally, the survey discusses the challenges faced by medical
LLMs and MLLMs and proposes a feasible approach and direction for the
subsequent integration of artificial intelligence with medicine. Thus, this
survey aims to provide researchers with a valuable and comprehensive reference
guide from the perspectives of the background, principles, and clinical
applications of LLMs and MLLMs.
|
[
-0.16490301489830017,
-0.7869231104850769,
1.0302128791809082,
-0.08941333740949631,
0.06664414703845978,
0.08670215308666229,
-0.483256071805954,
-0.48306915163993835,
0.07564894109964371,
0.6861335635185242,
-0.50801682472229,
-0.5274381637573242,
-0.8082463145256042,
0.08384199440479279,
-0.22401581704616547,
0.9301244020462036,
-0.02574767917394638,
0.7219263911247253,
-0.23118115961551666,
-0.23006029427051544,
-0.22506210207939148,
-0.9085614085197449,
-0.48152562975883484,
-0.49516159296035767,
0.7577409148216248,
-0.1417897790670395,
0.4819929599761963,
0.2563386559486389,
0.791251540184021,
0.3284843862056732,
-0.0479549802839756,
0.08453331142663956,
-0.03716364875435829,
0.31202182173728943,
-0.08109460026025772,
-0.2689603567123413,
-0.6322741508483887,
-0.01831241138279438,
0.6369093656539917,
0.9841925501823425,
-0.23883585631847382,
0.02892575040459633,
-0.19104234874248505,
0.6157715916633606,
-0.3185294270515442,
0.23916907608509064,
-0.17403048276901245,
0.12539096176624298,
-0.23171263933181763,
-0.22672903537750244,
-0.23078690469264984,
-0.22150667011737823,
0.23914261162281036,
-0.17508137226104736,
-0.26519620418548584,
0.06451854109764099,
0.28028711676597595,
0.10816270112991333,
-0.9320537447929382,
-0.473279744386673,
-0.7403023838996887,
0.8374793529510498,
-0.9662765264511108,
0.6582040190696716,
0.07850117236375809,
0.46321621537208557,
-0.36139288544654846,
-1.001968502998352,
-0.42323392629623413,
-0.5965049266815186,
0.08502047508955002,
-0.03953307494521141,
-0.055803462862968445,
0.2230384200811386,
0.014501658268272877,
0.314472496509552,
-0.6986209154129028,
0.3418015241622925,
-0.44081443548202515,
-0.07716068625450134,
0.6506026983261108,
0.546773374080658,
0.5421525835990906,
0.1724209040403366,
-0.17987853288650513,
0.33188560605049133,
-0.7415530681610107,
-0.2878684997558594,
-0.3564791977405548,
0.013886738568544388,
-0.2587534487247467,
0.6928879022598267,
0.05403345823287964,
0.7989625334739685,
-0.43467599153518677,
-0.8352013230323792,
0.4475557208061218,
-0.7313113808631897,
-0.4077596366405487,
-0.26255208253860474,
1.0010008811950684,
0.3914855420589447,
0.03264801949262619,
-0.037749312818050385,
-0.0888996347784996,
-0.11282585561275482,
0.09856409579515457,
-0.5819157958030701,
0.0040298160165548325,
0.5548744797706604,
-0.7696651220321655,
-0.21634280681610107,
-0.5719248652458191,
-0.7452293634414673,
-0.6452204585075378,
-0.4666588306427002,
-0.07755213230848312,
-0.4056093990802765,
-0.27937716245651245,
0.30179348587989807,
0.17611320316791534,
0.24482780694961548,
0.4422565996646881,
-0.7760043144226074,
0.29584547877311707,
0.7036992907524109,
0.6955649256706238,
-0.3925657570362091,
-0.17151056230068207,
-0.0013355504488572478,
0.1782405525445938,
-0.3513363003730774,
0.700252115726471,
-0.4139544367790222,
-0.34537819027900696,
0.35823869705200195,
-0.05942616984248161,
-0.1826734095811844,
-0.505632221698761,
0.45031675696372986,
-0.29746490716934204,
0.25139352679252625,
-0.10310421139001846,
-0.49783504009246826,
-0.23228923976421356,
0.7580065131187439,
-0.6210168600082397,
0.3465734124183655,
0.012288114055991173,
-0.44859007000923157,
0.11045407503843307,
-0.9401118159294128,
-0.4406942129135132,
0.1098860651254654,
-0.29144877195358276,
-0.3277219831943512,
0.15473422408103943,
0.272616446018219,
0.7219782471656799,
-0.7977629899978638,
0.4890250861644745,
-0.2648885250091553,
0.14357317984104156,
0.46042153239250183,
-0.35636115074157715,
0.8892582058906555,
0.34546127915382385,
0.01806812360882759,
0.6055874824523926,
-0.5446639657020569,
-0.08509451150894165,
0.1597500592470169,
-0.388777494430542,
-0.04822218045592308,
0.21139873564243317,
0.3917078375816345,
0.47818541526794434,
0.38394373655319214,
-0.21655984222888947,
0.4164077341556549,
-0.20643673837184906,
0.8019930124282837,
0.4379969835281372,
0.12758462131023407,
0.2761368155479431,
-0.40549200773239136,
0.5127266049385071,
-0.016298575326800346,
0.5633593797683716,
-0.2746047377586365,
-0.5938799977302551,
-0.33388808369636536,
-0.5171566605567932,
0.09494983404874802,
0.5131521821022034,
-0.5363278985023499,
0.17970015108585358,
-0.20886710286140442,
-0.5738648772239685,
-0.5210393071174622,
0.14163577556610107,
-0.012712597846984863,
0.20761168003082275,
0.25056353211402893,
0.08780369907617569,
-0.3716222643852234,
-0.9094540476799011,
-0.06887149810791016,
-0.2276596873998642,
0.04763045161962509,
0.49391213059425354,
0.5765147805213928,
-0.8697801232337952,
0.3593759834766388,
-0.26389071345329285,
-0.187805637717247,
-0.5273937582969666,
-0.286081463098526,
0.23945973813533783,
0.33964771032333374,
0.5571900010108948,
-0.8564310669898987,
-0.2077721804380417,
0.2241668999195099,
-0.8076913356781006,
0.13892939686775208,
0.1055181697010994,
0.18628616631031036,
0.06540081650018692,
0.38449209928512573,
-0.7332647442817688,
-0.07961375266313553,
0.9179742932319641,
-0.24814024567604065,
0.6300562620162964,
-0.23777258396148682,
0.32052868604660034,
-1.2375479936599731,
0.19459645450115204,
0.0002733110450208187,
-0.1835472285747528,
-0.8165035843849182,
0.221433624625206,
-0.028871189802885056,
0.07452282309532166,
-0.31480923295021057,
0.7677754759788513,
-0.5428459644317627,
0.1769055426120758,
-0.08255941420793533,
-0.1449962556362152,
-0.13282690942287445,
0.0564001090824604,
-0.15524043142795563,
0.3767806589603424,
0.6570620536804199,
-0.43765854835510254,
0.7908927202224731,
0.22984498739242554,
-0.2853258550167084,
0.49371767044067383,
-0.5475055575370789,
-0.18457777798175812,
-0.035146456211805344,
0.4209272861480713,
-0.8015676140785217,
-0.309672087430954,
0.36969122290611267,
-0.35295480489730835,
0.3647221028804779,
0.1467621922492981,
-0.564612090587616,
-0.5496969819068909,
-0.1824047565460205,
0.4647066295146942,
0.6081131100654602,
-0.027322283014655113,
0.5402571558952332,
0.6994562745094299,
-0.47735220193862915,
-0.37968677282333374,
-0.7513797879219055,
0.3978419303894043,
-0.14035388827323914,
-0.39213821291923523,
0.19671694934368134,
-0.2678382992744446,
-0.5383583307266235,
-0.19881722331047058,
0.24114319682121277,
-0.13153454661369324,
-0.1735745668411255,
0.01102244108915329,
0.5306153893470764,
-0.4601824879646301,
0.31704214215278625,
-0.17615041136741638,
0.09939512610435486,
0.18258915841579437,
-0.2812633514404297,
0.6307864189147949,
0.014873959124088287,
-0.7668335437774658,
-0.2543647587299347,
0.567595362663269,
1.0367822647094727,
-0.36251676082611084,
0.6545740365982056,
0.4571804702281952,
-0.314450204372406,
0.36643388867378235,
-0.7513635754585266,
-0.1583109349012375,
-0.32071834802627563,
0.732297956943512,
0.09847267717123032,
-1.0089709758758545,
0.3135524094104767,
-0.2766585648059845,
0.25357505679130554,
0.37466874718666077,
1.189735770225525,
-0.07301269471645355,
1.1330294609069824,
0.4738408327102661,
-0.21423354744911194,
0.13121993839740753,
0.07764142751693726,
0.3368471562862396,
-0.864399254322052,
-0.5954026579856873,
-0.48421910405158997,
-0.18097257614135742,
-0.7002286314964294,
-0.5274838805198669,
0.7285851240158081,
-0.408628910779953,
-0.18739408254623413,
-0.40236303210258484,
-0.4042699337005615,
-0.1508152037858963,
0.25814560055732727,
-0.018271243199706078,
0.31112679839134216,
-0.31190651655197144,
-0.16065959632396698,
0.004048490431159735,
-0.6057013273239136,
-0.413128137588501,
1.3360661268234253,
0.6139509677886963,
0.7845034599304199,
0.2058369219303131,
0.4222249686717987,
0.09212567657232285,
0.30439406633377075,
-0.9626923203468323,
0.39500677585601807,
-0.05628153681755066,
-0.882469892501831,
-0.28157150745391846,
-0.25096940994262695,
-0.9804250001907349,
0.15691795945167542,
-0.2010795772075653,
-0.6667147874832153,
-0.15418145060539246,
-0.0031602762173861265,
-0.2568342685699463,
0.4166969060897827,
-0.40151265263557434,
0.8179864883422852,
-0.6524764895439148,
-0.03012966364622116,
-0.21050037443637848,
-0.8208661079406738,
0.6155633926391602,
-0.18542388081550598,
0.3982403576374054,
-0.19328910112380981,
-0.330905556678772,
0.47360771894454956,
-0.011557135730981827,
0.7204305529594421,
0.1360487937927246,
-0.30335918068885803,
-0.12186948955059052,
-0.3457270860671997,
0.22926369309425354,
-0.03803509846329689,
0.017569389194250107,
0.425872802734375,
0.15320494771003723,
-0.23832325637340546,
-0.3656519949436188,
0.7741860747337341,
-0.5758285522460938,
-0.45757290720939636,
-0.6606083512306213,
-0.6927391290664673,
-0.45001643896102905,
0.2784682810306549,
0.009535348042845726,
0.38873550295829773,
-0.27835813164711,
0.1438123881816864,
0.5742441415786743,
-0.4227542281150818,
0.21902808547019958,
0.5356480479240417,
-0.49818381667137146,
-0.4284931719303131,
0.5974665284156799,
-0.1445181965827942,
0.1449834406375885,
0.3555998206138611,
0.24026066064834595,
-0.5360287427902222,
-1.095762014389038,
-0.3325287103652954,
0.49274012446403503,
-0.48331013321876526,
0.15786117315292358,
-0.6822605729103088,
-0.45164912939071655,
-0.6627705693244934,
-0.045213207602500916,
-0.17505969107151031,
0.10322937369346619,
-0.03887111321091652,
0.36596205830574036,
0.2863192856311798,
1.0973881483078003,
0.3582979142665863,
0.07314544916152954,
-1.0630191564559937,
0.31753259897232056,
0.11789054423570633,
0.3709104359149933,
-0.1629950851202011,
-0.061614278703927994,
-0.08905793726444244,
0.0696345716714859,
-0.08116470277309418,
-0.978052020072937,
0.45987921953201294,
-0.019501136615872383,
0.8897316455841064,
0.5347259640693665,
-0.4570031762123108,
0.3910636603832245,
-0.8970977663993835,
1.0606963634490967,
0.48029178380966187,
-0.44547462463378906,
0.21250860393047333,
-0.423978716135025,
0.22764672338962555,
0.15344467759132385,
0.4527503550052643,
-0.8911470770835876,
-0.11770673096179962,
-0.2183755338191986,
-0.8382014632225037,
0.26193952560424805,
-0.17118433117866516,
0.06590059399604797,
0.1163809597492218,
0.11345023661851883,
-0.038224898278713226,
0.32014116644859314,
-0.529610276222229,
-0.34586918354034424,
0.21658511459827423,
-0.46454134583473206,
-0.37893247604370117,
-0.24758280813694,
-0.4139935374259949,
-0.24725767970085144,
0.48653697967529297,
-0.11374955624341965,
0.3456757068634033,
-0.09469206631183624,
0.05979723110795021,
0.117294542491436,
0.6824744343757629,
0.8347036242485046,
0.745475172996521,
0.08128073066473007,
0.0010920896893367171,
0.10560381412506104,
-0.509769856929779,
0.19246116280555725,
0.15394583344459534,
0.024868469685316086,
-0.06337066739797592,
0.6105630397796631,
0.5647557377815247,
0.21812479197978973,
-1.150736689567566,
0.4492197036743164,
0.1047254428267479,
-0.11976385861635208,
-0.4414665102958679,
-0.18647350370883942,
0.4163343608379364,
0.4859805405139923,
0.09394301474094391,
-0.09832798689603806,
0.2580409049987793,
-0.5930981636047363,
0.024534011259675026,
0.722180962562561,
-0.28154703974723816,
-0.2806916832923889,
0.43930986523628235,
0.04500093683600426,
-0.1256638467311859,
0.4620089828968048,
0.35365739464759827,
-0.25971299409866333,
0.4138997495174408,
0.6168639659881592,
0.5389196276664734,
-0.3667859435081482,
-0.03344597667455673,
0.03873084485530853,
0.10646243393421173,
-0.10308755934238434,
0.22091802954673767,
0.3303276598453522,
-0.5539498329162598,
-0.5059609413146973,
-0.5779072046279907,
-0.3531450629234314,
0.4081305265426636,
-0.3741336762905121,
0.22864173352718353,
-0.27870243787765503,
-0.352524071931839,
0.2941795885562897,
-0.1960304081439972,
-0.5452831983566284,
0.1147751584649086,
0.4793280363082886,
0.7684930562973022,
-0.46497809886932373,
0.882169246673584,
1.0273476839065552,
-0.30970150232315063,
-0.44640395045280457,
-0.11461269855499268,
0.31709596514701843,
-0.9454910159111023,
0.5036613345146179,
-0.25249695777893066,
0.20285503566265106,
-0.1549573540687561,
-0.4644899070262909,
-0.7257388234138489,
0.9112839698791504,
0.11442279815673828,
-0.7020406126976013,
-0.45132675766944885,
0.2169545739889145,
0.5846446752548218,
-0.5067353844642639,
0.24288715422153473,
0.7370468974113464,
0.6075906753540039,
0.06459322571754456,
-1.1944119930267334,
-0.12597736716270447,
-0.29141494631767273,
-0.0486648865044117,
0.22320827841758728,
-0.49346262216567993,
1.0686612129211426,
-0.28165706992149353,
0.20780989527702332,
0.32769080996513367,
0.03558356314897537,
0.39873093366622925,
0.29900139570236206,
0.04284695163369179,
0.33465084433555603,
0.45791691541671753,
-0.10028251260519028,
1.110093116760254,
-0.41397038102149963,
0.24717266857624054,
0.5670456290245056,
-0.653769850730896,
0.6616098880767822,
0.5283840298652649,
-0.4989413321018219,
0.21675518155097961,
0.4388217628002167,
0.009812742471694946,
0.06392687559127808,
0.18087881803512573,
-0.49772948026657104,
-0.1512576937675476,
-0.08837134391069412,
-0.6814768314361572,
0.35161009430885315,
0.7571053504943848,
-0.6040880084037781,
-0.22848418354988098,
0.26006582379341125,
0.10062114894390106,
-0.18374204635620117,
-0.45552748441696167,
0.8730888366699219,
0.24378204345703125,
-0.49455901980400085,
0.3301737308502197,
0.06319546699523926,
0.5436539649963379,
-1.0193123817443848,
-0.19880804419517517,
0.13620983064174652,
0.13830314576625824,
-0.04162587597966194,
-0.7229894399642944,
-0.020316321402788162,
-0.1609472632408142,
-0.09905548393726349,
-0.16299380362033844,
0.662108838558197,
-0.48387131094932556,
-0.6674261093139648,
0.1522884964942932,
0.7925524711608887,
0.13546212017536163,
0.23819485306739807,
-0.7645019292831421,
0.12168319523334503,
-0.07413294911384583,
-0.2776908874511719,
0.3680323660373688,
0.2987675368785858,
-0.19559559226036072,
0.9272447824478149,
0.8117814660072327,
0.4951840341091156,
0.04499519243836403,
0.0657891035079956,
0.8241140842437744,
-0.8901482224464417,
-0.07472844421863556,
-1.1566643714904785,
0.36536705493927,
0.06532522290945053,
-0.14943087100982666,
0.5823706984519958,
0.47180116176605225,
0.1903141438961029,
-0.09494262933731079,
1.0381306409835815,
0.0985768586397171,
0.5293624401092529,
-0.5151901245117188,
0.9541440010070801,
-0.7537699937820435,
0.030874034389853477,
-0.13813981413841248,
-0.5235342383384705,
-0.6572049260139465,
0.25593408942222595,
-0.2147553265094757,
0.1975008249282837,
0.7425956726074219,
0.40975722670555115,
0.2661072015762329,
-0.21416601538658142,
0.4872746169567108,
0.37741437554359436,
0.5221060514450073,
0.6819298267364502,
0.8638925552368164,
-0.0537467896938324,
0.07490557432174683,
0.13309121131896973,
-0.16102392971515656,
-0.5205317139625549,
-0.6182907223701477,
-0.7651564478874207,
-0.5180264115333557,
-0.12606771290302277,
-0.1285811960697174,
0.04854410141706467,
1.1607935428619385,
0.6728427410125732,
-0.8984897136688232,
-0.1575004905462265,
0.32723283767700195,
0.020894203335046768,
-0.17098967730998993,
-0.07004345208406448,
0.36845076084136963,
-0.1625550091266632,
-0.6867825388908386,
0.3133746087551117,
0.6284816861152649,
0.1935247927904129,
-0.6461711525917053,
-0.13939175009727478,
-0.2807971239089966,
0.058978479355573654,
0.9118965268135071,
0.2801562547683716,
-1.0261127948760986,
0.1670888215303421,
0.18315841257572174,
-0.4761435091495514,
0.12029489129781723,
1.0543575286865234,
-0.4995471239089966,
0.23843041062355042,
0.3957504332065582,
0.6265689134597778,
0.013370583765208721,
-0.4990828037261963,
0.508762538433075,
0.018132071942090988,
0.1288258284330368,
0.6439729928970337,
0.6384518146514893,
0.25503769516944885,
-0.14100730419158936,
0.23808172345161438,
0.1285138726234436,
-0.565403401851654,
-0.874150812625885,
0.3324747085571289,
-1.0669671297073364,
-0.42555931210517883,
1.2519803047180176,
0.08073046058416367,
-0.0387352779507637,
-0.3190591633319855,
-0.27569544315338135,
0.10001124441623688,
0.037695128470659256,
0.5736335515975952,
0.5955671072006226,
-0.4063820242881775,
-0.2471458464860916,
-0.9433383345603943,
0.425809770822525,
0.12146427482366562,
-1.119678020477295,
-0.2605798840522766,
0.7657877206802368,
0.33090847730636597,
0.008162779733538628,
0.8887197971343994,
-0.533626914024353,
0.08223322778940201,
-0.3573680520057678,
0.1952715665102005,
0.011739758774638176,
-0.11281602084636688,
-0.3485599458217621,
0.21341277658939362,
0.22166115045547485,
0.055155474692583084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13014v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13014v1
|
QCRD: Quality-guided Contrastive Rationale Distillation for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-14T13:07:10 | 2024-05-14T13:07:10 |
Wei Wang, Zhaowei Li, Qi Xu, Yiqing Cai, Hang Song, Qi Qi, Ran Zhou, Zhida Huang, Tao Wang, Li Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Deploying large language models (LLMs) poses challenges in terms of resource
limitations and inference efficiency. To address these challenges, recent
research has focused on using smaller task-specific language models, which are
enhanced by distilling the knowledge rationales generated by LLMs. However,
previous works mostly emphasize the effectiveness of positive knowledge, while
overlooking the knowledge noise and the exploration of negative knowledge. In
this paper, we first propose a general approach called quality-guided
contrastive rationale distillation for reasoning capacity learning, considering
contrastive learning perspectives. For the learning of positive knowledge, we
collect positive rationales through self-consistency to denoise the LLM
rationales generated by temperature sampling. For the negative knowledge
distillation, we generate negative rationales using temperature sampling for
the iteration-before smaller language models themselves. Finally, a contrastive
loss is designed to better distill the positive and negative rationales into
the smaller language model, where an online-update discriminator is used to
judge the qualities of rationales and assign weights for better optimizing the
training process. Through extensive experiments on multiple reasoning tasks, we
demonstrate that our method consistently outperforms the previous distillation
methods and produces higher-quality rationales.
|
[
-0.47196662425994873,
-0.5517005324363708,
0.7874912023544312,
-0.01626446470618248,
-0.5253825783729553,
-0.05291572958230972,
-0.24613972008228302,
0.10037795454263687,
-0.1684294492006302,
0.49587538838386536,
-0.22523468732833862,
-0.25219959020614624,
-0.5448117852210999,
0.13330169022083282,
-0.16318649053573608,
0.6960985660552979,
0.0265341866761446,
0.40791893005371094,
-0.23168031871318817,
-0.2978440821170807,
-0.37146613001823425,
-0.6586015820503235,
-0.7528761625289917,
-0.6333379149436951,
0.5229026079177856,
0.35917994379997253,
0.41720810532569885,
0.4075542092323303,
0.11045370995998383,
0.31320086121559143,
-0.24507777392864227,
0.30554860830307007,
-0.8206861615180969,
0.25712457299232483,
-0.4815026819705963,
-0.39166590571403503,
0.061120159924030304,
0.13247482478618622,
0.3306128978729248,
0.5111434459686279,
-0.3759354054927826,
-0.16763029992580414,
0.34145045280456543,
0.7036224007606506,
-0.678414523601532,
0.05160357803106308,
-0.7431325912475586,
-0.28929853439331055,
0.31490597128868103,
-0.19972068071365356,
-0.4043886661529541,
-0.4549720287322998,
0.055656157433986664,
-0.6843761801719666,
0.1789577156305313,
-0.017034096643328667,
0.7443859577178955,
0.3382716774940491,
-0.6192694306373596,
-0.30194419622421265,
-0.5616591572761536,
1.3821423053741455,
-0.879802405834198,
0.4248701333999634,
0.556692361831665,
0.377915620803833,
-0.06864465028047562,
-0.5209531188011169,
-0.7769944071769714,
-0.17389357089996338,
-0.10377386957406998,
0.029203511774539948,
-0.06497755646705627,
0.1461676061153412,
0.2993292510509491,
0.35144147276878357,
-0.24928970634937286,
-0.06658577919006348,
-0.27325594425201416,
-0.15644562244415283,
0.5035673379898071,
0.06423850357532501,
-0.12649905681610107,
0.1155332699418068,
-0.1495881825685501,
-0.2182159423828125,
-0.41914770007133484,
-0.24213992059230804,
0.10336267948150635,
0.1523369550704956,
-0.0875973254442215,
0.4437972605228424,
-0.4666985869407654,
0.5648868083953857,
0.4098685085773468,
-0.591219425201416,
0.07450216263532639,
-0.4375074803829193,
-0.2964133322238922,
-0.07991348206996918,
0.5662806630134583,
0.3673134744167328,
0.14225415885448456,
0.06768795847892761,
-0.18198317289352417,
-0.08656908571720123,
-0.04571525752544403,
-1.0748345851898193,
-0.5624696016311646,
0.1395481824874878,
-0.2806893289089203,
-0.190431609749794,
-0.45369890332221985,
-0.5893834829330444,
-0.5277481079101562,
-0.7190378308296204,
0.3574572503566742,
-0.5795175433158875,
-0.33361193537712097,
0.2276274561882019,
-0.41641688346862793,
0.22526662051677704,
0.5301353335380554,
-0.8779613375663757,
0.06203492358326912,
0.3990934491157532,
0.5812933444976807,
0.019490618258714676,
0.10974178463220596,
-0.626092791557312,
-0.005753444042056799,
-0.3019437789916992,
0.663325846195221,
-0.4821052849292755,
-0.3674618899822235,
-0.26942920684814453,
-0.28099387884140015,
0.1416887491941452,
-0.6861664652824402,
0.5081707835197449,
-0.6408677697181702,
0.31618157029151917,
-0.6387649774551392,
-0.6670905351638794,
-0.36108118295669556,
0.5183560252189636,
-0.6411201357841492,
0.6345112323760986,
0.36172887682914734,
-0.8407473564147949,
0.3419312834739685,
-0.044422049075365067,
-0.29313552379608154,
-0.05571656674146652,
-0.4188362956047058,
-0.28911229968070984,
0.2706379294395447,
0.2454741895198822,
0.3771601617336273,
-0.6755933165550232,
0.34151047468185425,
-0.3257705867290497,
-0.04048222675919533,
0.31695014238357544,
-0.5287775993347168,
0.9365404844284058,
0.5294982194900513,
-0.1601768136024475,
0.10808073729276657,
-0.7768679261207581,
0.012393249198794365,
-0.03261706233024597,
-0.5210442543029785,
-0.5772327780723572,
-0.10594732314348221,
-0.3274376094341278,
0.36242398619651794,
0.03462543338537216,
-0.27508237957954407,
-0.02979649417102337,
-0.06123169884085655,
0.5474595427513123,
0.4914669394493103,
0.08282940834760666,
0.5964497923851013,
-0.41510510444641113,
0.5367861390113831,
0.30666694045066833,
0.019485367462038994,
0.07521802932024002,
-0.10073300451040268,
-0.8198658227920532,
-0.48457980155944824,
0.1772543042898178,
0.36817529797554016,
-1.2189778089523315,
0.3347371220588684,
0.07582730799913406,
-0.42728760838508606,
-0.4358254075050354,
0.3326529264450073,
0.3270973861217499,
0.9295926094055176,
0.6297798752784729,
0.17442503571510315,
-0.2260819673538208,
-0.7588678598403931,
0.14865642786026,
-0.23601028323173523,
-0.060767196118831635,
0.14214065670967102,
0.24636809527873993,
-0.09494375437498093,
0.7114366292953491,
-0.5333636403083801,
-0.09321556240320206,
-0.5227165222167969,
0.26296699047088623,
0.18800944089889526,
0.6281206011772156,
0.4008488953113556,
-0.7655965685844421,
-0.4911481440067291,
-0.06632442027330399,
-0.6911553144454956,
-0.2006141096353531,
-0.19076387584209442,
-0.2566872239112854,
0.293080598115921,
0.646824300289154,
-0.3860832452774048,
-0.09500524401664734,
0.7857983708381653,
-0.29045701026916504,
0.6928635239601135,
-0.229203999042511,
0.4286026954650879,
-1.1619881391525269,
-0.08037218451499939,
0.3680875599384308,
-0.03187548369169235,
-0.5372930765151978,
0.11572199314832687,
-0.02767970599234104,
0.18828780949115753,
-0.36705297231674194,
0.7256788611412048,
-0.5388422608375549,
0.47476500272750854,
-0.27057942748069763,
0.23148277401924133,
0.5194116830825806,
0.3920039236545563,
0.12879545986652374,
0.48708632588386536,
0.4070170521736145,
-0.6532901525497437,
0.2852763235569,
-0.21325381100177765,
-0.3841925263404846,
0.7549441456794739,
-0.5009505748748779,
-0.18912845849990845,
-0.06661216169595718,
0.19310066103935242,
-0.9423789381980896,
-0.016728581860661507,
0.029524611309170723,
-0.06376927345991135,
0.2968626022338867,
-0.2722645401954651,
-0.285996675491333,
-0.008615068159997463,
-0.19638004899024963,
0.7173610925674438,
0.8571436405181885,
-0.691685676574707,
0.7251200079917908,
0.3199785053730011,
-0.055626481771469116,
-0.48896488547325134,
-0.7993860840797424,
-0.3030596077442169,
-0.6004128456115723,
-0.4561399817466736,
0.12248574942350388,
-0.08326946943998337,
-0.6146618723869324,
-0.15179777145385742,
-0.21969731152057648,
-0.41639119386672974,
0.18781548738479614,
-0.28464603424072266,
0.05093131959438324,
-0.17768564820289612,
0.2446824014186859,
0.2149747759103775,
-0.08979597687721252,
0.06535656005144119,
-0.3329794704914093,
0.4512397050857544,
0.1275072544813156,
-0.29331979155540466,
-0.6027284264564514,
0.15008395910263062,
0.2876919209957123,
0.04965001344680786,
0.6836011409759521,
0.4590228796005249,
-0.2107267528772354,
-0.37071913480758667,
-0.9276303052902222,
-0.49714118242263794,
-0.4986441731452942,
0.24711346626281738,
-0.371250182390213,
-1.1216036081314087,
0.4720210134983063,
-0.1297617256641388,
0.011586183682084084,
0.3662833273410797,
0.33609750866889954,
-0.17521046102046967,
0.9460555911064148,
0.381636381149292,
0.0490521602332592,
0.36206570267677307,
-0.22371292114257812,
0.2764340937137604,
-0.6771185398101807,
-0.19243085384368896,
-0.6549229025840759,
-0.09493005275726318,
-0.4049195945262909,
-0.8734478950500488,
0.08115144819021225,
0.7923184037208557,
-0.3314126431941986,
-0.015598279424011707,
-0.43756023049354553,
0.6386321783065796,
0.5955005288124084,
0.0001676727260928601,
0.49407100677490234,
0.0970572829246521,
-0.2353121042251587,
-0.10485086590051651,
-0.8390448689460754,
-0.3891482353210449,
0.7813849449157715,
0.16445928812026978,
1.0317280292510986,
0.07619579881429672,
0.9417305588722229,
0.00886181928217411,
0.3197031319141388,
-0.7470037341117859,
0.4904848337173462,
-0.1255498081445694,
-0.4401956796646118,
-0.5502017736434937,
-0.7708412408828735,
-0.5995931029319763,
0.6037757396697998,
-0.047946829348802567,
-0.2575990557670593,
0.3232114315032959,
0.5853694081306458,
-0.2553746700286865,
0.21900010108947754,
-0.8799234628677368,
0.7228818535804749,
-0.2513424754142761,
-0.4471096098423004,
-0.6474285125732422,
-0.15805411338806152,
0.5677474737167358,
-0.10950061678886414,
0.26856911182403564,
-0.11573275923728943,
0.19024375081062317,
0.32000160217285156,
-0.620034396648407,
0.7830176949501038,
-0.3694760203361511,
-0.26112836599349976,
0.536652147769928,
0.222212553024292,
0.4918590486049652,
0.17851805686950684,
-0.4257200360298157,
0.04081294685602188,
0.06456784904003143,
-0.5972298979759216,
-0.6518996953964233,
0.7775388360023499,
-0.564480185508728,
-0.821118950843811,
-0.3761061131954193,
-0.31037190556526184,
-0.2710381746292114,
0.1102205440402031,
0.08729161322116852,
0.3476039171218872,
-0.0962311178445816,
0.26795417070388794,
0.8340364694595337,
-0.43516865372657776,
0.13674525916576385,
0.5135312080383301,
-0.02440747804939747,
-0.44742169976234436,
1.1436926126480103,
0.030700309202075005,
0.6054711937904358,
0.4615987241268158,
0.4482198655605316,
-0.5392237305641174,
-0.9283391237258911,
-0.11078029870986938,
0.2307703197002411,
-0.9426921606063843,
-0.176699697971344,
-0.3868545889854431,
-0.1305067241191864,
-0.36440521478652954,
-0.297927588224411,
-0.13565011322498322,
-0.39900049567222595,
-0.5538702607154846,
0.06408911943435669,
0.35674169659614563,
0.2802862524986267,
-0.18408454954624176,
0.08765910565853119,
-0.6907469034194946,
0.4451228976249695,
0.6837752461433411,
0.08898090571165085,
0.10456062108278275,
-0.8316266536712646,
-0.2639854848384857,
0.19753220677375793,
-0.33961835503578186,
-0.47324225306510925,
0.5748468041419983,
0.05236751213669777,
0.7359806299209595,
0.3333323299884796,
0.4943305552005768,
0.665428638458252,
-0.07903909683227539,
0.7313470840454102,
0.5401128530502319,
-0.8048896193504333,
0.3254742920398712,
-0.21446040272712708,
0.6414281725883484,
0.8478721380233765,
0.5546560287475586,
-0.2525189518928528,
-0.45900437235832214,
-0.40658479928970337,
-0.7868700623512268,
0.3634233772754669,
-0.01409667357802391,
-0.0007976266788318753,
-0.3036186397075653,
0.3358052968978882,
0.07047810405492783,
0.174098938703537,
-0.6181942224502563,
-0.019374964758753777,
-0.44386544823646545,
-0.2328595370054245,
-0.09282732009887695,
-0.33074483275413513,
-0.20561246573925018,
-0.39872634410858154,
0.8929558396339417,
-0.36443430185317993,
-0.346084862947464,
0.20208044350147247,
-0.18300959467887878,
0.3337104022502899,
0.5080430507659912,
0.4276163876056671,
0.6439259648323059,
-0.06693240255117416,
0.35786959528923035,
0.3574192225933075,
-0.05343661084771156,
0.14125722646713257,
0.040036045014858246,
0.059731293469667435,
-0.2258804738521576,
0.16058287024497986,
0.5477452874183655,
0.0018438462866470218,
-0.682777464389801,
0.261300265789032,
-0.2593729496002197,
-0.505107581615448,
-0.09231777489185333,
0.15213602781295776,
0.4632645845413208,
0.5006511807441711,
0.20995058119297028,
-0.2842749059200287,
0.127222940325737,
-0.45325642824172974,
0.006186472252011299,
0.4042510986328125,
-0.27753350138664246,
0.01671626791357994,
0.3579305112361908,
0.44888725876808167,
0.34034764766693115,
0.9086210131645203,
-0.5831753015518188,
-0.3247191309928894,
0.5529899001121521,
0.34730926156044006,
0.7555806040763855,
-0.2069961279630661,
0.27429869771003723,
0.7445542216300964,
-0.09144293516874313,
-0.4223630130290985,
0.32624486088752747,
-0.06595561653375626,
-0.8905000686645508,
-0.6184495091438293,
-0.7990301251411438,
-0.3997235596179962,
0.36930426955223083,
-0.562832236289978,
0.1485908478498459,
-0.438371866941452,
-0.08344893157482147,
-0.14754748344421387,
-0.08334752172231674,
-0.5607461333274841,
0.27481305599212646,
-0.053887613117694855,
0.7034935355186462,
-0.5744673609733582,
1.3133238554000854,
0.1646611988544464,
-0.42325398325920105,
-0.9635688066482544,
-0.15798331797122955,
0.07453172653913498,
-0.5740434527397156,
0.8442777395248413,
-0.16001488268375397,
-0.2698405385017395,
0.06473340839147568,
-0.32832807302474976,
-0.7158533930778503,
1.2239928245544434,
0.6103113889694214,
-0.9275365471839905,
0.17385053634643555,
-0.20762205123901367,
0.5594902038574219,
-0.31773319840431213,
0.06262235343456268,
0.630734384059906,
0.3731929063796997,
0.4403826594352722,
-0.6511817574501038,
0.2595081329345703,
-0.004223481751978397,
-0.023526346310973167,
0.03289465606212616,
-0.43234342336654663,
0.9109750986099243,
-0.40456053614616394,
-0.3766504228115082,
-0.12633313238620758,
0.45757153630256653,
0.6677058935165405,
0.10745054483413696,
0.5230602622032166,
0.5678647756576538,
0.8436028361320496,
-0.04384437948465347,
0.9187873005867004,
-0.3074358105659485,
0.20746055245399475,
1.43827223777771,
-0.39865610003471375,
0.7820491194725037,
0.7795314788818359,
0.030879102647304535,
0.4432487487792969,
0.2920742332935333,
0.04301971569657326,
0.6549751162528992,
0.5235338807106018,
-0.5141074657440186,
-0.5421709418296814,
-0.24187079071998596,
-0.211435005068779,
-0.09626638144254684,
0.3036136031150818,
-0.3499355912208557,
-0.2819975018501282,
-0.1255311369895935,
-0.1707024723291397,
0.29377272725105286,
-0.18113601207733154,
0.7686989903450012,
0.3446563482284546,
-0.7990360260009766,
1.0359965562820435,
-0.1224936991930008,
0.7330536842346191,
-0.4889606535434723,
-0.19416660070419312,
-0.4191240668296814,
0.2117806226015091,
-0.14414629340171814,
-0.5741890668869019,
0.19750045239925385,
-0.20461152493953705,
-0.2213376760482788,
-0.35979360342025757,
0.4423105716705322,
-0.6689644455909729,
-0.3189220130443573,
0.3218773603439331,
0.4860142469406128,
-0.042862970381975174,
-0.05830001458525658,
-0.6003944277763367,
0.00983444880694151,
0.1895124614238739,
-0.241446852684021,
0.6308525204658508,
0.7820569276809692,
0.16063286364078522,
0.7455127835273743,
0.48469555377960205,
0.006809464655816555,
-0.20118464529514313,
0.45520249009132385,
1.0871788263320923,
-0.6817488670349121,
-0.4590427279472351,
-0.8520460724830627,
0.5271682143211365,
-0.1994219273328781,
-0.1533263921737671,
0.6492682099342346,
0.38693979382514954,
1.0149790048599243,
0.05213021859526634,
0.9550922513008118,
0.1547115296125412,
0.30969303846359253,
-0.7528103590011597,
0.5557774901390076,
-0.4608948826789856,
0.5655224919319153,
0.09478277713060379,
-0.7880212068557739,
-0.032762523740530014,
0.796525239944458,
-0.305742472410202,
0.041644029319286346,
0.8617317080497742,
0.899351179599762,
0.08327995985746384,
-0.1743086874485016,
0.61264568567276,
0.2899084687232971,
0.5262347459793091,
0.49975666403770447,
0.8813089728355408,
-0.1258181631565094,
0.6205974817276001,
-0.4482465088367462,
-0.17692053318023682,
-0.16405744850635529,
-1.1310280561447144,
-1.0761849880218506,
-0.6351878643035889,
-0.5754066705703735,
-0.4951622784137726,
-0.02203413099050522,
0.8690211176872253,
0.6967707276344299,
-0.8220357298851013,
-0.2743500769138336,
-0.3141629695892334,
0.1852973848581314,
-0.14284713566303253,
-0.25462764501571655,
0.1634417176246643,
-0.5827298164367676,
-0.49860912561416626,
0.265090674161911,
-0.12236996740102768,
0.15064217150211334,
-0.27753743529319763,
-0.4521220624446869,
-0.09103210270404816,
0.22120843827724457,
0.6960607171058655,
0.2786572277545929,
-0.719764769077301,
-0.1798921525478363,
-0.3730303943157196,
-0.30956342816352844,
-0.12919831275939941,
0.8136985301971436,
-0.7543643712997437,
0.4358777105808258,
0.8115496635437012,
0.5455448627471924,
0.5527570843696594,
0.009840015321969986,
0.7508202791213989,
-0.4366177022457123,
-0.027068747207522392,
0.39007964730262756,
0.4015776216983795,
0.3487829267978668,
0.005899548996239901,
0.2862361669540405,
0.12474365532398224,
-0.5797460079193115,
-0.688416063785553,
0.18730270862579346,
-0.9450408816337585,
-0.7294811010360718,
1.4408557415008545,
-0.294808030128479,
0.1311001479625702,
-0.4184384047985077,
-0.319905161857605,
0.1634817123413086,
-0.5717175006866455,
1.1181199550628662,
0.7287579774856567,
-0.14040450751781464,
-0.3099650740623474,
-0.26478755474090576,
0.6984503865242004,
0.2953697741031647,
-0.8377731442451477,
0.236237570643425,
0.8663015365600586,
0.41760700941085815,
0.0816919207572937,
0.6728070378303528,
-0.0060224225744605064,
0.09871447831392288,
0.076040118932724,
-0.0979258194565773,
-0.02628978341817856,
-0.08412104845046997,
-0.4668697118759155,
0.2248203456401825,
0.4756002426147461,
0.2855442464351654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08570v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08570v1
|
Rethinking the adaptive relationship between Encoder Layers and Decoder Layers
| 2024-05-14T13:05:16 | 2024-05-14T13:05:16 |
Yubo Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This article explores the adaptive relationship between Encoder Layers and
Decoder Layers using the SOTA model Helsinki-NLP/opus-mt-de-en, which
translates German to English. The specific method involves introducing a
bias-free fully connected layer between the Encoder and Decoder, with different
initializations of the layer's weights, and observing the outcomes of
fine-tuning versus retraining. Four experiments were conducted in total. The
results suggest that directly modifying the pre-trained model structure for
fine-tuning yields suboptimal performance. However, upon observing the outcomes
of the experiments with retraining, this structural adjustment shows
significant potential.
|
[
-0.2246239185333252,
-1.0239475965499878,
0.2487746924161911,
-0.01691333018243313,
-0.2541801333427429,
-0.35433873534202576,
0.038579341024160385,
-0.6497265100479126,
0.22065727412700653,
0.6864044666290283,
-0.5991016626358032,
-0.010680856183171272,
-0.681830644607544,
0.20029041171073914,
-0.17796608805656433,
1.0941919088363647,
-0.17169420421123505,
0.20690174400806427,
-0.0520118810236454,
-0.21390117704868317,
-0.7474475502967834,
-0.45991283655166626,
-0.9735270142555237,
-0.5712018013000488,
0.39222052693367004,
0.2871757745742798,
0.7802257537841797,
0.6605244278907776,
0.4140721261501312,
0.259500652551651,
-0.1365351676940918,
0.003805803833529353,
-0.42630526423454285,
0.2106611132621765,
-0.35296812653541565,
-0.6886141896247864,
-0.6764718294143677,
-0.46330371499061584,
0.7928064465522766,
0.5499752759933472,
-0.05210292339324951,
0.23100546002388,
0.25586366653442383,
1.0636998414993286,
-0.6647485494613647,
-0.22962768375873566,
-0.7337008714675903,
0.05302593857049942,
0.1235371008515358,
-0.703967273235321,
-0.4813617765903473,
0.13856521248817444,
0.10013411939144135,
-0.6981214284896851,
0.2991667687892914,
-0.12392652034759521,
0.7607920169830322,
0.4776465594768524,
-0.23001894354820251,
-0.2481619119644165,
-0.8903940320014954,
0.3518025279045105,
-0.5678732991218567,
0.5761050581932068,
0.39724892377853394,
0.26046568155288696,
-0.22489050030708313,
-0.6727716326713562,
-0.19782614707946777,
-0.00020004015823360533,
0.25599539279937744,
0.3076806664466858,
-0.05115268751978874,
-0.2590009570121765,
0.30265164375305176,
0.21302054822444916,
-0.10847833752632141,
0.19059239327907562,
-0.4410399794578552,
0.051083728671073914,
0.5896710753440857,
0.1538848727941513,
0.41188883781433105,
0.07367905974388123,
-0.4721585512161255,
0.03228210657835007,
-0.562451958656311,
0.11498961597681046,
0.41746005415916443,
0.33904874324798584,
-0.1613568365573883,
0.33106836676597595,
0.004745596554130316,
0.6426120400428772,
0.35450252890586853,
0.2515689432621002,
0.3191583752632141,
-0.09024561196565628,
-0.4527474343776703,
0.5410864949226379,
0.3960041105747223,
0.45445454120635986,
0.3270784020423889,
-0.22194936871528625,
-0.37611305713653564,
0.0714116320014,
0.6595310568809509,
-0.5744484663009644,
-0.20606830716133118,
0.09630968421697617,
-0.5356454849243164,
-0.14975498616695404,
-0.27388957142829895,
-0.5222586393356323,
-0.133961483836174,
-0.34769105911254883,
1.0672544240951538,
-0.507938802242279,
-0.3981885015964508,
0.7516334652900696,
-0.084527388215065,
0.2544057071208954,
0.22301214933395386,
-1.0434746742248535,
0.4696417450904846,
0.40456706285476685,
0.6628905534744263,
0.20810583233833313,
-0.654026210308075,
-0.11431743204593658,
0.21696045994758606,
-0.4448471665382385,
0.8754057288169861,
-0.5114507079124451,
0.019384384155273438,
-0.05348435416817665,
0.2802750766277313,
-0.1346193104982376,
-0.5083950757980347,
0.7364541292190552,
-0.9340553879737854,
-0.0013723899610340595,
-0.36676687002182007,
-0.5589256882667542,
0.0161848533898592,
0.09356151521205902,
-0.9204949736595154,
0.8726721405982971,
0.15219846367835999,
-0.9943538308143616,
0.4148304760456085,
-0.7981544137001038,
-0.31038960814476013,
-0.13387435674667358,
0.36346834897994995,
-0.5571283102035522,
0.41681012511253357,
0.3632873296737671,
0.3271888494491577,
-0.13307355344295502,
0.10340824723243713,
-0.027701102197170258,
-0.4402414858341217,
0.20983059704303741,
0.04618234187364578,
0.8615366816520691,
0.3037196695804596,
-0.060820288956165314,
0.20248840749263763,
-1.1600768566131592,
-0.1949380785226822,
0.08057817071676254,
-0.6759918332099915,
-0.5109695196151733,
0.1942191869020462,
-0.012241331860423088,
0.13612423837184906,
-0.04937556013464928,
-0.4447447657585144,
-0.0019859711173921824,
-0.37324222922325134,
0.8916153311729431,
0.6666718125343323,
0.14051170647144318,
0.7064034342765808,
-0.30679088830947876,
0.4026329517364502,
0.2646951675415039,
0.1409258246421814,
-0.21250395476818085,
0.013014886528253555,
-0.9331901669502258,
0.11095329374074936,
0.5619012117385864,
0.3644603490829468,
-0.903393030166626,
0.38811057806015015,
-0.35766756534576416,
-0.32190990447998047,
-0.866108775138855,
-0.08499183505773544,
0.28681352734565735,
0.461370050907135,
0.6148892641067505,
-0.5742470622062683,
-0.6022689342498779,
-0.9111928343772888,
-0.5949475169181824,
0.21489790081977844,
-0.23691760003566742,
0.11355091631412506,
0.5487912893295288,
-0.2912677526473999,
0.4203598201274872,
-0.13325275480747223,
-0.4040444493293762,
-0.06779536604881287,
-0.20624350011348724,
0.1261308193206787,
0.9211364388465881,
0.6276131272315979,
-0.4771280586719513,
-0.3905922472476959,
0.08130434900522232,
-0.6161243915557861,
0.07915785163640976,
-0.11656968295574188,
-0.37008145451545715,
-0.07304336130619049,
0.7979405522346497,
-0.39326682686805725,
0.03382038325071335,
0.5369912981987,
-0.517509937286377,
0.5960949063301086,
-0.47325950860977173,
-0.019131682813167572,
-1.117238998413086,
-0.18670155107975006,
-0.18830163776874542,
-0.17065700888633728,
-0.9525113701820374,
0.5628502368927002,
0.11121893674135208,
0.044492218643426895,
-0.3616066575050354,
0.01756540685892105,
-0.5088258981704712,
-0.410997599363327,
-0.20355868339538574,
-0.15754975378513336,
0.10332753509283066,
0.49685782194137573,
0.06602870672941208,
0.5419715046882629,
0.720613956451416,
-0.651199460029602,
0.029769333079457283,
0.09839259833097458,
-0.671856701374054,
0.5552038550376892,
-0.9184681177139282,
0.43398264050483704,
-0.2937084138393402,
0.1033889502286911,
-0.5961822867393494,
0.06296088546514511,
0.11782623827457428,
-0.36382731795310974,
0.20660240948200226,
-0.18414568901062012,
-0.288316935300827,
0.16988293826580048,
-0.11243797838687897,
0.5739809274673462,
0.2660110890865326,
-0.3767986595630646,
0.9920338988304138,
0.3302375376224518,
0.06170739233493805,
-0.3688538670539856,
-0.960934042930603,
0.021217329427599907,
-0.17129932343959808,
-0.689409613609314,
0.461104154586792,
0.12063959985971451,
0.22530107200145721,
0.11044777184724808,
-0.2238578498363495,
-0.12442611157894135,
0.345158189535141,
0.03189833089709282,
-0.14783331751823425,
-0.7104294300079346,
0.019001025706529617,
0.1751994788646698,
-0.1582137942314148,
0.20718902349472046,
-0.5576245188713074,
0.5714426040649414,
0.0689515620470047,
0.04596604406833649,
-0.47225669026374817,
0.2510658800601959,
0.452506422996521,
-0.2717001140117645,
1.0191377401351929,
0.45655596256256104,
-0.3415471017360687,
-0.2379378229379654,
-0.2520256042480469,
-0.014269938692450523,
-0.5283001065254211,
0.5912007689476013,
-1.064555287361145,
-0.8069081902503967,
0.8439100980758667,
0.28235480189323425,
-0.14430274069309235,
0.4326131343841553,
0.5341769456863403,
-0.21030475199222565,
0.8948910236358643,
0.8451708555221558,
0.12506772577762604,
0.6509880423545837,
-0.23437871038913727,
0.05973462760448456,
-1.1019383668899536,
-0.2653796374797821,
-0.5016284584999084,
-0.5397338271141052,
-0.6427031755447388,
-0.051886316388845444,
0.05396731570363045,
0.39966243505477905,
-0.4944179654121399,
0.4365505874156952,
-0.5944736003875732,
0.5771785974502563,
0.4245719313621521,
0.5398355722427368,
0.1982833743095398,
0.0599370002746582,
0.019654301926493645,
0.03912360221147537,
-0.8994940519332886,
-0.38724616169929504,
0.8592100143432617,
0.6424083709716797,
0.8224278092384338,
0.27648526430130005,
0.30922266840934753,
0.1305072158575058,
-0.3096207082271576,
-0.4511762261390686,
0.1918928027153015,
-0.29396915435791016,
-0.5254288911819458,
-0.3504183888435364,
-0.12222392857074738,
-0.9330657124519348,
0.17324121296405792,
-0.4097796082496643,
-0.3694836497306824,
0.5929093360900879,
0.2741023302078247,
-0.3478734791278839,
0.3216897249221802,
-0.9142768979072571,
0.772408127784729,
0.009776948019862175,
-0.35978075861930847,
-0.1462407261133194,
-0.5868449807167053,
0.016709716990590096,
-0.0662810206413269,
0.06357418745756149,
0.21477912366390228,
0.15290401875972748,
0.9415051341056824,
0.1601388305425644,
0.7282499670982361,
-0.3336726129055023,
-0.2157120704650879,
0.09368591755628586,
0.3608696758747101,
0.21004295349121094,
-0.12776120007038116,
-0.21222084760665894,
0.07167967408895493,
0.2515091896057129,
-0.7787811756134033,
-0.6152456402778625,
0.47118955850601196,
-1.3112883567810059,
-0.5647538900375366,
0.06591877341270447,
-0.6963526606559753,
-0.08917491137981415,
0.31754791736602783,
0.2863900065422058,
0.4853546917438507,
-0.06311510503292084,
0.3669171631336212,
0.5861154794692993,
-0.23308144509792328,
0.10719481110572815,
0.6823438405990601,
-0.06484128534793854,
-0.08230680972337723,
0.5222590565681458,
0.311948299407959,
0.49083688855171204,
0.6586252450942993,
0.21422195434570312,
0.13028214871883392,
-0.6313020586967468,
-0.37892553210258484,
-0.18686304986476898,
-0.6288554072380066,
-0.0949433371424675,
-0.7431963086128235,
-0.5487563610076904,
-0.2498839795589447,
-0.16861321032047272,
-0.5572859048843384,
-0.17449167370796204,
-0.2963572144508362,
-0.310372918844223,
0.19395554065704346,
0.5417363047599792,
0.11371812969446182,
0.40233153104782104,
-0.6036855578422546,
0.2391032874584198,
0.3070148229598999,
0.5012385845184326,
0.14937616884708405,
-1.0242397785186768,
-0.6718549132347107,
0.19111637771129608,
-0.21756863594055176,
-0.6335679292678833,
0.21459443867206573,
0.4863935708999634,
0.36202117800712585,
0.014143990352749825,
0.002894495613873005,
0.6332569718360901,
-0.7663388252258301,
0.6519982218742371,
0.006908665876835585,
-1.0502033233642578,
0.6403464078903198,
-0.30399757623672485,
0.49205249547958374,
0.29500702023506165,
0.33292263746261597,
-0.09370296448469162,
-0.1819947510957718,
-0.49376416206359863,
-0.6968018412590027,
0.7837162017822266,
-0.024028943851590157,
0.4485834836959839,
0.3920762836933136,
0.6852553486824036,
0.18687604367733002,
-0.201804056763649,
-0.6911593675613403,
0.14400529861450195,
-0.6164640784263611,
0.00804508849978447,
-0.09427108615636826,
-0.7721449136734009,
-0.027612946927547455,
-0.31045815348625183,
0.4497966468334198,
-0.021059727296233177,
0.4889773726463318,
0.3870193064212799,
-0.35881367325782776,
-0.31740009784698486,
0.2479025423526764,
0.5367524027824402,
0.723389744758606,
-0.3770780563354492,
0.4681727886199951,
0.33738455176353455,
-0.49054208397865295,
0.06193999946117401,
-0.4894428551197052,
-0.362172394990921,
-0.231728196144104,
0.6442018747329712,
1.4778480529785156,
0.47651737928390503,
-0.0612645223736763,
0.11720732599496841,
-0.047334905713796616,
-0.559963583946228,
0.006604913156479597,
0.184756338596344,
0.17749515175819397,
0.39407506585121155,
0.22162367403507233,
0.42996150255203247,
-0.0061758714728057384,
-0.7348050475120544,
0.1518498957157135,
0.08475026488304138,
-0.5440590977668762,
-0.7813148498535156,
0.7287866473197937,
0.1810230314731598,
-0.6984708309173584,
0.37816885113716125,
0.3470931649208069,
-0.5202096104621887,
0.49208325147628784,
1.037595510482788,
0.8556962609291077,
-0.511715829372406,
-0.05462098866701126,
0.38785505294799805,
0.5219587087631226,
-0.13968141376972198,
0.26169461011886597,
-0.045606113970279694,
-1.3004769086837769,
-0.4477291703224182,
-0.7130370140075684,
0.16533513367176056,
0.09902261197566986,
-1.1596025228500366,
0.20346681773662567,
-0.38085705041885376,
-0.14915621280670166,
0.2505498230457306,
-0.0750507339835167,
-0.7227955460548401,
0.3884064257144928,
-0.367067813873291,
1.2265198230743408,
-1.238555908203125,
1.1643593311309814,
0.7345448136329651,
-0.2946630120277405,
-0.7898250818252563,
-0.04276193678379059,
-0.6725637316703796,
-0.9142212271690369,
0.5258265137672424,
-0.18821755051612854,
-0.18661481142044067,
0.22556503117084503,
-0.257257878780365,
-0.9421392679214478,
0.9002394080162048,
0.7741193175315857,
-0.5001962184906006,
-0.03910496458411217,
-0.13137443363666534,
0.8924576640129089,
-0.5943019986152649,
0.06526380032300949,
0.7676343321800232,
0.076723612844944,
-0.3516082465648651,
-0.7623755931854248,
-0.010574182495474815,
-0.3844502866268158,
0.33603957295417786,
-0.05037045106291771,
-0.5069690346717834,
0.9134024977684021,
0.14014020562171936,
-0.38790708780288696,
-0.2155650556087494,
0.5584573149681091,
-0.28492873907089233,
-0.04931376129388809,
0.6339529752731323,
0.6218308806419373,
0.07835471630096436,
0.21211157739162445,
0.9022924304008484,
-0.23728036880493164,
0.15584714710712433,
1.2543553113937378,
-0.019943946972489357,
1.0294221639633179,
0.5890912413597107,
-0.23168429732322693,
0.6565250754356384,
0.4874316155910492,
0.05243730545043945,
0.8662341237068176,
-0.21115553379058838,
0.2761209309101105,
-0.18610627949237823,
-0.036592379212379456,
-0.5847784280776978,
0.5792744755744934,
0.14392367005348206,
-0.40856418013572693,
0.07203082740306854,
0.02341833896934986,
-0.408447802066803,
0.24073055386543274,
-0.5944214463233948,
0.9128866791725159,
-0.0009745529969222844,
-0.4637139141559601,
0.7569120526313782,
0.07731065899133682,
0.5166894197463989,
-0.3836425244808197,
0.36207273602485657,
-0.07397974282503128,
0.2501414716243744,
-0.42703768610954285,
-0.699713945388794,
0.5936954617500305,
-0.08244717866182327,
-0.5766617655754089,
-0.06257957965135574,
0.7953175902366638,
-0.39990025758743286,
-0.5634360909461975,
0.6605751514434814,
0.298562228679657,
-0.10101474076509476,
0.2723696529865265,
-0.6439307928085327,
0.23815061151981354,
-0.09457111358642578,
-0.36723750829696655,
0.5396515727043152,
0.5133668184280396,
0.06840408593416214,
0.43649935722351074,
0.6406304836273193,
0.14297452569007874,
0.3484814763069153,
0.38862675428390503,
0.8676328659057617,
-0.5602755546569824,
-0.8245255351066589,
-0.8583961725234985,
0.5683180093765259,
0.3436414301395416,
-0.19359774887561798,
0.5167214870452881,
0.28466469049453735,
1.1494371891021729,
-0.2914595603942871,
0.35647544264793396,
0.18066945672035217,
0.29710009694099426,
-1.0004284381866455,
0.6216878294944763,
-0.6295763254165649,
0.3360670506954193,
-0.2290475219488144,
-1.201524257659912,
-0.20758473873138428,
0.6876906156539917,
-0.03640785068273544,
-0.07593639194965363,
0.6295427680015564,
0.9779160022735596,
-0.16925813257694244,
0.182125985622406,
0.3417739272117615,
0.7074874043464661,
0.00999411940574646,
0.5999783873558044,
0.7781820893287659,
-0.954448938369751,
-0.0035912480670958757,
-0.06447798013687134,
-0.15317431092262268,
-0.11849083751440048,
-0.8105276823043823,
-0.769896388053894,
-0.7018246054649353,
-0.19967243075370789,
-0.21101824939250946,
0.3206122815608978,
0.5060508251190186,
0.41496753692626953,
-0.9300497770309448,
-0.18411564826965332,
-0.05805834382772446,
-0.12346837669610977,
-0.5766721963882446,
-0.14643265306949615,
0.4739571213722229,
-0.16047731041908264,
-0.45613425970077515,
0.20501834154129028,
0.23918749392032623,
-0.24653342366218567,
-0.14436304569244385,
-0.04691118374466896,
-0.17746661603450775,
0.13459926843643188,
0.6382937431335449,
-0.011708557605743408,
-0.5620317459106445,
-0.48379844427108765,
-0.1338803619146347,
0.07059748470783234,
0.1280420422554016,
0.8549607396125793,
-0.6288108229637146,
0.569203794002533,
0.45806077122688293,
0.8642382025718689,
0.5870389342308044,
-0.20705747604370117,
0.7493797540664673,
-0.6502732038497925,
0.21135419607162476,
-0.15725234150886536,
0.2728132903575897,
0.2258511334657669,
-0.42519447207450867,
0.24388866126537323,
-0.24149949848651886,
-0.6007723808288574,
-0.9569693207740784,
0.14580348134040833,
-0.601047694683075,
-0.3245733082294464,
0.7494796514511108,
-0.08638617396354675,
-0.49174731969833374,
-0.14757150411605835,
-0.11481475830078125,
0.23524823784828186,
0.09999057650566101,
1.0028178691864014,
0.4624979496002197,
0.10876577347517014,
-0.48152899742126465,
-0.5316269397735596,
0.5159872770309448,
0.5079473257064819,
-0.3173266351222992,
-0.0479915626347065,
-0.07181139290332794,
0.5466902256011963,
0.16760945320129395,
0.7279793620109558,
0.03894125670194626,
0.27402615547180176,
0.29874682426452637,
-0.13370804488658905,
-0.20240145921707153,
-0.49938973784446716,
-0.5206589102745056,
-0.03024398908019066,
0.1832914799451828,
-0.3005085587501526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19342v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.19342v1
|
Sonos Voice Control Bias Assessment Dataset: A Methodology for Demographic Bias Assessment in Voice Assistants
| 2024-05-14T12:53:32 | 2024-05-14T12:53:32 |
Chloé Sekkat, Fanny Leroy, Salima Mdhaffar, Blake Perry Smith, Yannick Estève, Joseph Dureau, Alice Coucke
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Recent works demonstrate that voice assistants do not perform equally well
for everyone, but research on demographic robustness of speech technologies is
still scarce. This is mainly due to the rarity of large datasets with
controlled demographic tags. This paper introduces the Sonos Voice Control Bias
Assessment Dataset, an open dataset composed of voice assistant requests for
North American English in the music domain (1,038 speakers, 166 hours, 170k
audio samples, with 9,040 unique labelled transcripts) with a controlled
demographic diversity (gender, age, dialectal region and ethnicity). We also
release a statistical demographic bias assessment methodology, at the
univariate and multivariate levels, tailored to this specific use case and
leveraging spoken language understanding metrics rather than transcription
accuracy, which we believe is a better proxy for user experience. To
demonstrate the capabilities of this dataset and statistical method to detect
demographic bias, we consider a pair of state-of-the-art Automatic Speech
Recognition and Spoken Language Understanding models. Results show
statistically significant differences in performance across age, dialectal
region and ethnicity. Multivariate tests are crucial to shed light on mixed
effects between dialectal region, gender and age.
|
[
-0.6528509259223938,
-0.3046584129333496,
-0.1648486852645874,
0.26293498277664185,
0.26786452531814575,
0.12317319214344025,
-0.006108174566179514,
-0.20630569756031036,
0.18160633742809296,
0.6967434883117676,
-0.6747329235076904,
-0.19022147357463837,
-0.5426137447357178,
-0.09808605909347534,
-0.11255165934562683,
0.7233884334564209,
0.3317253887653351,
0.6263118982315063,
-0.12227772176265717,
-0.17325584590435028,
-0.6943625807762146,
-0.19722074270248413,
-0.7498832941055298,
-0.15006586909294128,
0.1739177405834198,
0.3659316599369049,
0.4227744936943054,
0.33400750160217285,
0.052347246557474136,
0.2345433533191681,
-0.37439626455307007,
0.03514411672949791,
-0.37250998616218567,
0.14615224301815033,
0.08041460812091827,
-0.2905837893486023,
-0.7058627009391785,
0.1771136373281479,
0.5543454885482788,
0.7607901692390442,
-0.24469979107379913,
0.36544132232666016,
-0.002315229270607233,
0.6677706241607666,
-0.5196167826652527,
-0.0587647445499897,
-0.8308199644088745,
0.1140373945236206,
-0.24415287375450134,
-0.29104286432266235,
-0.14943952858448029,
-0.3588723838329315,
0.327694296836853,
-0.4992332458496094,
0.4620928466320038,
0.08747883886098862,
0.12008583545684814,
0.34578126668930054,
-0.49526405334472656,
-0.35590478777885437,
-0.8195043802261353,
0.9493955373764038,
-0.5405283570289612,
0.5475324988365173,
0.40801265835762024,
0.4253863990306854,
-0.15748488903045654,
0.29236969351768494,
-0.48177874088287354,
-0.24552024900913239,
0.33884814381599426,
0.1562512069940567,
-0.0004172207845840603,
-0.13061413168907166,
0.14178572595119476,
0.21603883802890778,
-0.6451977491378784,
0.1281595081090927,
-0.6472073197364807,
-0.34547486901283264,
0.6277583837509155,
-0.03826776519417763,
0.47787952423095703,
-0.13686978816986084,
-0.2304842472076416,
-0.18220053613185883,
-0.6093295812606812,
0.01963125169277191,
0.8365230560302734,
0.606550395488739,
-0.23653867840766907,
0.5378041863441467,
-0.061097338795661926,
0.6824782490730286,
-0.014211983419954777,
-0.2693522274494171,
0.37534040212631226,
-0.20825670659542084,
-0.0639965608716011,
0.23355889320373535,
0.6367398500442505,
0.32583773136138916,
0.5039764642715454,
-0.0849008560180664,
-0.11334478110074997,
0.027146104723215103,
0.2615017294883728,
-0.24748848378658295,
0.38373512029647827,
0.2539948523044586,
-0.48284801840782166,
-0.11847744137048721,
0.0805673897266388,
-1.398508071899414,
-0.558023989200592,
-0.48336923122406006,
0.02451702579855919,
0.10611109435558319,
-0.3526734709739685,
-0.1464424580335617,
-0.18991351127624512,
-0.03303524851799011,
0.23064391314983368,
-0.9271040558815002,
0.6390926837921143,
0.40475350618362427,
0.5295934677124023,
-0.5771374106407166,
-0.3426789343357086,
-0.3495910167694092,
-0.12860210239887238,
-0.45660462975502014,
0.4543039798736572,
-0.48561784625053406,
-0.555401623249054,
-0.15292656421661377,
-0.09473234415054321,
-0.2709859311580658,
-0.9301129579544067,
0.4114948809146881,
-0.4668940007686615,
0.5034546852111816,
0.011645790189504623,
-0.21901598572731018,
0.03719388321042061,
-0.3456863462924957,
-0.8688532114028931,
0.8459538817405701,
0.042842429131269455,
-0.37272047996520996,
0.8617498874664307,
-0.6759578585624695,
-0.3012399971485138,
-0.34728825092315674,
-0.20687274634838104,
-0.42426204681396484,
-0.1486896425485611,
0.38856935501098633,
0.18271967768669128,
-0.4912644028663635,
0.4804805517196655,
-0.2748221457004547,
-0.38246655464172363,
0.2918798327445984,
-0.609223484992981,
0.9501868486404419,
0.35674214363098145,
-0.4354693293571472,
-0.03683312609791756,
-0.7257099747657776,
-0.37650635838508606,
-0.03516039252281189,
0.0007022203644737601,
-0.19049786031246185,
0.07058960944414139,
0.20817747712135315,
0.07754312455654144,
0.08299615234136581,
-0.6240028142929077,
-0.17721588909626007,
0.01837765984237194,
0.0655917376279831,
0.5389428734779358,
-0.09959803521633148,
0.5412665009498596,
-0.3759412169456482,
0.9099969863891602,
-0.05516379699110985,
0.4417012631893158,
0.258309930562973,
-0.4333899915218353,
-0.21995769441127777,
-0.16440558433532715,
0.16733019053936005,
0.6528963446617126,
-0.4543396234512329,
0.7014797329902649,
-0.15512190759181976,
-0.29741787910461426,
-0.5937579870223999,
0.4214983582496643,
0.4072480797767639,
0.4692862033843994,
0.22114674746990204,
-0.3604964017868042,
-0.4034200608730316,
-0.9601446390151978,
-0.10159826278686523,
-0.1907128542661667,
-0.35929837822914124,
0.5023173689842224,
0.13203012943267822,
0.013665618374943733,
0.7096737027168274,
-0.03548481687903404,
-0.43769338726997375,
-0.19174620509147644,
0.19408434629440308,
-0.017667021602392197,
0.6609079837799072,
0.6324436664581299,
-0.8165622353553772,
0.030133606866002083,
-0.07365305721759796,
-0.3238367736339569,
-0.5529875755310059,
-0.0845671147108078,
0.031202789396047592,
-0.19910435378551483,
0.06329230219125748,
-0.08969330787658691,
0.15901921689510345,
0.7778341174125671,
-0.2706652581691742,
0.19487781822681427,
0.3315483331680298,
0.42457032203674316,
-0.8653923869132996,
0.010505108162760735,
0.4409720003604889,
-0.027855195105075836,
-0.534427285194397,
-0.5548197031021118,
-0.2676371932029724,
-0.20250722765922546,
-0.428274005651474,
0.28608113527297974,
-0.2914048135280609,
-0.6058959364891052,
-0.22579903900623322,
0.02243898995220661,
-0.12567512691020966,
0.3892817497253418,
-0.21561436355113983,
1.3332569599151611,
0.3821934461593628,
-0.4326983094215393,
0.3549506962299347,
0.25484827160835266,
-0.13283514976501465,
0.761527955532074,
-0.7109309434890747,
0.30457964539527893,
-0.14738605916500092,
0.212874174118042,
-0.972309947013855,
-0.01663975976407528,
0.003299376694485545,
-0.7535375356674194,
0.19441354274749756,
-0.20236563682556152,
0.014761229045689106,
-0.17032122611999512,
-0.22649802267551422,
0.36318355798721313,
0.3759279251098633,
-0.258771151304245,
0.5432040095329285,
1.0203226804733276,
-0.5530351400375366,
-0.6515985131263733,
-0.5467525720596313,
-0.15232296288013458,
-0.550480842590332,
-0.3058352768421173,
-0.13517245650291443,
0.05452254042029381,
-0.325375497341156,
-0.4033692479133606,
-0.12596692144870758,
-0.32967668771743774,
-0.027560103684663773,
0.22465281188488007,
0.25275081396102905,
-0.010191153734922409,
-0.032668113708496094,
0.21022619307041168,
0.08768381178379059,
0.07863831520080566,
-0.09593606740236282,
0.5381848812103271,
0.19992241263389587,
-0.28633952140808105,
-0.47190698981285095,
0.2871534824371338,
0.92847740650177,
-0.07616999745368958,
0.17775695025920868,
0.3345988690853119,
-0.28723829984664917,
-0.17094317078590393,
-0.6450079679489136,
-0.006427771411836147,
-0.3620310127735138,
0.0651298463344574,
-0.21486122906208038,
-0.7501699924468994,
0.7906627058982849,
0.16020454466342926,
-0.011626826599240303,
0.5514777898788452,
0.541761040687561,
0.06461170315742493,
1.1176472902297974,
0.05979673191905022,
-0.3116116523742676,
0.4995565712451935,
-0.036198802292346954,
-0.5046986937522888,
-0.933556854724884,
-0.2904999256134033,
-0.9272456169128418,
-0.09827537089586258,
-0.7147207260131836,
-0.16382858157157898,
0.397165983915329,
-0.6181842684745789,
-0.15572252869606018,
0.15583913028240204,
-0.43819504976272583,
0.1603807508945465,
0.6219313740730286,
0.04924255609512329,
-0.022118380293250084,
-0.03815213963389397,
0.14298385381698608,
-0.217950701713562,
-0.38556089997291565,
-0.6574439406394958,
1.2713868618011475,
0.4664621353149414,
0.943999171257019,
0.09951728582382202,
0.14525187015533447,
0.8812128901481628,
-0.08130848407745361,
-0.496197372674942,
0.200803741812706,
-0.44979801774024963,
-0.7653139233589172,
-0.5115198493003845,
-0.7263039946556091,
-0.9022014141082764,
0.18373003602027893,
-0.15235741436481476,
-0.6913298964500427,
0.6366726756095886,
0.28500959277153015,
-0.162042498588562,
0.11999351531267166,
-0.8358902335166931,
0.5852400064468384,
-0.30520057678222656,
-0.21963408589363098,
0.137177512049675,
-0.5709635615348816,
0.24912194907665253,
-0.2844993472099304,
0.2209523618221283,
-0.21960186958312988,
0.12496074289083481,
1.24996817111969,
-0.006378736346960068,
0.7143319845199585,
-0.5959726572036743,
-0.023999352008104324,
0.16884459555149078,
-0.04049061983823776,
-0.031271081417798996,
-0.18920771777629852,
-0.22021393477916718,
0.1865869164466858,
0.2693018317222595,
-0.5084967017173767,
-0.485790491104126,
0.6527370810508728,
-1.0259521007537842,
-0.16397222876548767,
-0.18917204439640045,
-0.5448314547538757,
-0.6464979648590088,
0.029237404465675354,
-0.04295393079519272,
0.527042806148529,
-0.39186951518058777,
0.2849922478199005,
0.7616008520126343,
-0.3934912085533142,
-0.2515994906425476,
0.39316919445991516,
-0.1358083188533783,
-0.4610099196434021,
0.5662771463394165,
0.23721517622470856,
0.3686973750591278,
0.143069788813591,
0.4509463310241699,
-0.44550976157188416,
-0.28943967819213867,
-0.7669328451156616,
-0.05010741204023361,
-0.3898622691631317,
0.18543991446495056,
-0.33788037300109863,
0.18038374185562134,
-0.7808990478515625,
0.34271305799484253,
-0.4086003005504608,
-0.2634083330631256,
-0.04736752808094025,
0.09378722310066223,
0.10227620601654053,
0.8701626658439636,
0.17812511324882507,
0.5998281836509705,
-0.1880750209093094,
0.560571551322937,
0.5635026097297668,
0.2618834674358368,
-0.2252870798110962,
-0.4397149980068207,
0.14818193018436432,
0.03447091951966286,
-0.06319499015808105,
-1.0033550262451172,
0.17434459924697876,
-0.03487778455018997,
0.7573325037956238,
0.2736697793006897,
-0.25686708092689514,
0.233263298869133,
-0.19162461161613464,
1.026450514793396,
-0.09447836875915527,
-1.0263769626617432,
0.5030180811882019,
-0.5778231024742126,
0.23764315247535706,
0.7804396152496338,
0.03278869390487671,
-0.44741877913475037,
-0.13592135906219482,
-0.6366168856620789,
-0.4641903340816498,
0.7248574495315552,
0.054430779069662094,
0.09851720184087753,
0.4304153025150299,
0.1987673044204712,
0.2799629271030426,
0.5508615970611572,
-0.32780784368515015,
-0.22279304265975952,
-0.16286002099514008,
-0.2692926824092865,
-0.09690575301647186,
-0.12352506816387177,
-0.3218533992767334,
-0.03661544248461723,
0.6842793822288513,
-0.18810339272022247,
0.37898996472358704,
0.01828704960644245,
0.2119288444519043,
-0.3905198872089386,
0.44057950377464294,
0.8381175994873047,
0.9640371203422546,
-0.4033986032009125,
0.02580549567937851,
0.3901539444923401,
-0.6867510676383972,
0.1796412318944931,
0.15420261025428772,
-0.3140392005443573,
-0.0616321861743927,
0.2673002779483795,
0.7353106737136841,
-0.2163730263710022,
-0.6371281743049622,
0.5437843203544617,
-0.3595069944858551,
-0.10831151902675629,
-0.34444305300712585,
-0.011518982239067554,
-0.3410739600658417,
-0.2823631167411804,
0.3687014579772949,
0.10359492152929306,
0.4783247113227844,
-0.2956792116165161,
0.1812465637922287,
0.4700644612312317,
-0.6764832139015198,
0.009084396064281464,
0.7362154126167297,
0.3119695484638214,
-0.10402856767177582,
-0.04415835067629814,
0.240363210439682,
-0.4454890787601471,
0.9635732769966125,
0.19459348917007446,
0.9202771186828613,
-0.6375369429588318,
0.20386727154254913,
0.09269808232784271,
0.6054021120071411,
0.1760244220495224,
0.309533953666687,
-0.09194187074899673,
-0.7426515817642212,
-0.19418558478355408,
-0.17171385884284973,
-0.6643785238265991,
0.2926361858844757,
-0.9075036644935608,
0.04471687227487564,
-0.33392277359962463,
-0.30026310682296753,
0.035649623721838,
-0.06610473245382309,
-0.632769763469696,
0.5301487445831299,
0.08727877587080002,
0.7397465109825134,
-1.317501187324524,
0.3932602107524872,
0.5366926193237305,
-0.03696703910827637,
-0.53203284740448,
0.19100090861320496,
0.49738380312919617,
-0.8886519074440002,
0.46903541684150696,
-0.29968997836112976,
-0.5098813772201538,
-0.5896143317222595,
-0.44295835494995117,
-0.5935987830162048,
0.7020120620727539,
0.30984359979629517,
-0.4044208824634552,
0.37994661927223206,
0.15008869767189026,
0.4936845898628235,
-0.46934759616851807,
0.41619959473609924,
0.7020136713981628,
0.25915515422821045,
0.04127217084169388,
-1.184775471687317,
-0.38151663541793823,
-0.40328121185302734,
0.2057894617319107,
-0.07441278547048569,
-0.5780035853385925,
0.5649474859237671,
0.43962526321411133,
0.29832354187965393,
-0.2794976234436035,
0.4263564646244049,
0.23382842540740967,
0.7705106735229492,
1.1092225313186646,
0.12679293751716614,
0.6257436275482178,
-0.06307396292686462,
0.6250922679901123,
-0.1522815078496933,
0.13431468605995178,
1.033726453781128,
-0.4220743477344513,
0.35380521416664124,
0.4862096309661865,
-0.4209039509296417,
-0.03667037934064865,
0.5500385761260986,
0.30527547001838684,
0.3106934130191803,
0.3060726225376129,
-0.20168520510196686,
0.1756467968225479,
-0.5218822360038757,
-0.3228588104248047,
0.6635858416557312,
0.4069986641407013,
-0.4330771267414093,
0.25075098872184753,
0.2469884753227234,
0.14071781933307648,
0.13045775890350342,
-0.035986173897981644,
0.9996203780174255,
-0.3056461215019226,
-0.6529614925384521,
0.15962502360343933,
-0.5439965128898621,
0.6111223697662354,
-0.6083402037620544,
-0.04638650640845299,
-0.1649782657623291,
-0.13919827342033386,
-0.0867406353354454,
-0.5689284801483154,
0.08029334992170334,
0.2852565348148346,
-0.07059885561466217,
-0.10965734720230103,
0.5415844321250916,
-0.39201226830482483,
-0.39852362871170044,
0.3481183350086212,
0.6076938509941101,
0.10857553780078888,
0.36763715744018555,
-0.7732807397842407,
0.31912440061569214,
0.012240223586559296,
-0.08487680554389954,
-0.06640186905860901,
0.1315225064754486,
-0.02469000779092312,
0.4547376334667206,
0.4974689483642578,
0.8364437222480774,
0.3087382912635803,
0.5129364728927612,
0.4226566255092621,
-0.17963171005249023,
-0.4575237035751343,
-0.20048213005065918,
0.07402908802032471,
-0.2645514905452728,
-0.6621710062026978,
0.618649423122406,
0.6677033305168152,
0.7319777607917786,
0.10758519172668457,
1.038520097732544,
0.14055131375789642,
1.1299725770950317,
-0.5634523630142212,
0.4600924849510193,
-0.47334033250808716,
0.20104683935642242,
-0.5186336040496826,
-0.7974304556846619,
-0.12592379748821259,
0.41852158308029175,
-0.5335562229156494,
0.5660569071769714,
-0.0008387890993617475,
0.873314619064331,
-0.1430661678314209,
0.3865622878074646,
0.22759416699409485,
-0.2376653403043747,
0.20984768867492676,
0.04813685640692711,
0.811893105506897,
-0.06398365646600723,
0.09057562053203583,
-0.3247701823711395,
-0.5996072292327881,
0.06273335963487625,
-0.4395577311515808,
-0.699840247631073,
-0.4048388600349426,
-0.03707032650709152,
-0.23911264538764954,
0.21252889931201935,
1.0577709674835205,
1.0122301578521729,
-1.0696403980255127,
-0.6337778568267822,
0.2244521826505661,
0.04154522716999054,
-0.3688584268093109,
-0.2517266869544983,
0.03473958745598793,
0.14537930488586426,
-1.0386849641799927,
0.5752407312393188,
-0.12289299815893173,
0.028688086196780205,
-0.7190200090408325,
-0.04269888997077942,
0.0662345215678215,
-0.016133785247802734,
0.054518695920705795,
0.3412167429924011,
-0.5440571308135986,
0.11523463577032089,
0.12745343148708344,
0.11654440313577652,
-0.04695400968194008,
1.0466790199279785,
-0.2596559524536133,
0.8986096978187561,
0.4859311580657959,
0.5285714864730835,
0.13734854757785797,
0.3108940124511719,
0.7661911249160767,
-0.5215041637420654,
0.16440699994564056,
0.324234277009964,
0.3613484799861908,
0.4614209532737732,
-0.5134077072143555,
0.25190016627311707,
0.04650455713272095,
-0.7244724035263062,
-0.4940742254257202,
-0.0231766439974308,
-1.1049950122833252,
-0.008144086226820946,
0.9874614477157593,
0.3080204427242279,
-0.0056471796706318855,
-0.2671014964580536,
-0.42061272263526917,
0.2993556559085846,
-0.8474137187004089,
0.743130624294281,
0.4873579144477844,
-0.173115536570549,
-0.23510095477104187,
-1.0396379232406616,
0.4429793655872345,
0.677593469619751,
-0.948411762714386,
-0.03540325164794922,
0.6635838747024536,
0.1274978518486023,
0.2242392748594284,
0.4761357009410858,
-0.3351021409034729,
0.3021353781223297,
-0.15842004120349884,
0.18662361800670624,
0.3070218563079834,
-0.4636930823326111,
-0.6880214810371399,
-0.019172975793480873,
-0.09749814122915268,
-0.4246354103088379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08562v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08562v1
|
The Unseen Targets of Hate -- A Systematic Review of Hateful Communication Datasets
| 2024-05-14T12:50:33 | 2024-05-14T12:50:33 |
Zehui Yu, Indira Sen, Dennis Assenmacher, Mattia Samory, Leon Fröhling, Christina Dahn, Debora Nozza, Claudia Wagner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Machine learning (ML)-based content moderation tools are essential to keep
online spaces free from hateful communication. Yet, ML tools can only be as
capable as the quality of the data they are trained on allows them. While there
is increasing evidence that they underperform in detecting hateful
communications directed towards specific identities and may discriminate
against them, we know surprisingly little about the provenance of such bias. To
fill this gap, we present a systematic review of the datasets for the automated
detection of hateful communication introduced over the past decade, and unpack
the quality of the datasets in terms of the identities that they embody: those
of the targets of hateful communication that the data curators focused on, as
well as those unintentionally included in the datasets. We find, overall, a
skewed representation of selected target identities and mismatches between the
targets that research conceptualizes and ultimately includes in datasets. Yet,
by contextualizing these findings in the language and location of origin of the
datasets, we highlight a positive trend towards the broadening and
diversification of this research space.
|
[
-0.7657675743103027,
-0.4906389117240906,
0.2568701207637787,
-0.18568751215934753,
-0.0001718658022582531,
0.19758112728595734,
-0.03195060044527054,
-0.4796122908592224,
0.43204036355018616,
0.5677928924560547,
-0.8296300172805786,
-0.42723074555397034,
-1.124942421913147,
0.061943620443344116,
-0.7271400690078735,
1.339043378829956,
0.21267950534820557,
-0.015997005626559258,
0.16364189982414246,
-0.6921668648719788,
-0.14194265007972717,
-0.47104358673095703,
-0.10632898658514023,
-0.18044091761112213,
1.07077157497406,
0.2538057565689087,
0.6185805201530457,
1.0281542539596558,
0.7177830934524536,
0.11910675466060638,
0.10744137316942215,
-0.008817632682621479,
-0.8736302852630615,
0.2539660632610321,
-0.17783264815807343,
-0.3248481750488281,
0.21110546588897705,
0.4256044328212738,
0.34012603759765625,
0.6930893659591675,
0.3383595943450928,
0.265285462141037,
0.059354860335588455,
0.6914137005805969,
-0.7434173226356506,
-0.3957124948501587,
-0.7614542245864868,
0.30489224195480347,
-0.37645432353019714,
0.11192558705806732,
-0.3817334771156311,
-0.460884153842926,
-0.1096750944852829,
-0.5206755995750427,
0.3980652987957001,
0.09661451727151871,
0.5868850946426392,
0.4692654609680176,
-0.45841217041015625,
-0.6075568795204163,
-0.8819538354873657,
1.0090886354446411,
-0.4086880087852478,
0.19137628376483917,
0.2702673673629761,
0.4290168583393097,
0.04048502445220947,
-0.15790753066539764,
-0.27166813611984253,
0.009656732901930809,
-0.08442222326993942,
-0.05399483069777489,
-0.5962236523628235,
-0.15272092819213867,
0.4167351722717285,
0.26506152749061584,
-0.5360763669013977,
0.4127647280693054,
-0.5871023535728455,
-0.36105862259864807,
0.708183228969574,
0.22330498695373535,
0.1802259385585785,
0.007528290152549744,
-0.22051069140434265,
-0.028949370607733727,
-0.7416477799415588,
-0.40701761841773987,
0.9329054355621338,
0.4734466075897217,
-0.017055470496416092,
0.8108898401260376,
-0.04399522766470909,
0.4537702798843384,
0.08312837779521942,
0.05142896994948387,
0.11751364171504974,
-0.036327019333839417,
-0.1601773202419281,
0.056139737367630005,
0.7961154580116272,
0.393089234828949,
0.35823553800582886,
-0.12051984667778015,
-0.0943603366613388,
0.6809043884277344,
0.6181424856185913,
-0.5720576643943787,
-0.4633170962333679,
0.028804639354348183,
-0.6241114139556885,
-0.5704113245010376,
0.17115247249603271,
-0.4531322121620178,
-0.8186193704605103,
-0.1381063014268875,
0.09391805529594421,
-0.03760847449302673,
-0.2355681210756302,
-0.49762895703315735,
-0.5417020916938782,
-0.11394242942333221,
0.24039947986602783,
-0.41587623953819275,
0.25193971395492554,
0.5526896715164185,
0.4670966863632202,
-0.5314851403236389,
-0.025905048474669456,
-0.27605703473091125,
-0.18435823917388916,
-0.43244075775146484,
0.5604916214942932,
-0.6328176856040955,
-0.0702430009841919,
0.09449721872806549,
-0.04618663340806961,
0.537779688835144,
-0.7252134680747986,
0.788229763507843,
-0.687893807888031,
0.34776991605758667,
-0.3872840106487274,
-0.44872304797172546,
-0.3172433376312256,
0.3341929614543915,
-0.8640922904014587,
0.8345881700515747,
0.30843544006347656,
-0.7864416837692261,
0.6222096681594849,
-0.5479527711868286,
-0.26624593138694763,
0.11671480536460876,
-0.1253969669342041,
-0.4355640709400177,
0.05414726957678795,
0.013480892404913902,
0.39295080304145813,
0.026504598557949066,
0.14221696555614471,
-0.5957100987434387,
-0.30093657970428467,
0.2304156869649887,
-0.32340461015701294,
1.1148550510406494,
0.5246477723121643,
-0.6381214261054993,
0.19444134831428528,
-0.5902068614959717,
-0.2983103096485138,
0.16586989164352417,
0.10140074789524078,
-0.5710212588310242,
-0.139969602227211,
0.1054474264383316,
0.30516546964645386,
-0.3583637475967407,
-0.54395991563797,
-0.1990470439195633,
-0.010196570307016373,
0.026759129017591476,
1.012238621711731,
-0.2319338023662567,
0.4683650732040405,
-0.6290558576583862,
0.3823738694190979,
0.3280702829360962,
0.48328089714050293,
0.11792164295911789,
-0.40960603952407837,
-0.9400524497032166,
0.0588342621922493,
-0.04328327625989914,
0.25383326411247253,
-0.36306869983673096,
0.48035141825675964,
0.05567098781466484,
-0.9470948576927185,
-0.649972140789032,
0.056762438267469406,
0.39282745122909546,
0.2694341838359833,
0.4963117837905884,
-0.44856351613998413,
-0.9024454355239868,
-1.1551107168197632,
-0.6038627624511719,
-0.06768627464771271,
-0.0298516396433115,
0.40291544795036316,
0.47766929864883423,
-0.5034354329109192,
0.7650432586669922,
-0.14928743243217468,
-0.3324871361255646,
-0.08344486355781555,
0.14701169729232788,
0.02501928247511387,
0.30310261249542236,
0.4731186330318451,
-0.8655430674552917,
-0.6774489283561707,
-0.43533262610435486,
-0.7323668599128723,
-0.26665198802948,
0.0888364166021347,
-0.15856528282165527,
-0.17951464653015137,
0.18843534588813782,
-0.009952814318239689,
0.23431019484996796,
0.7605904936790466,
-0.3268684446811676,
0.5090059041976929,
0.813711941242218,
0.4489438235759735,
-0.636849582195282,
0.1955295354127884,
0.16246992349624634,
0.04721122235059738,
-0.7952206134796143,
-0.13854332268238068,
-0.15300364792346954,
0.0907360389828682,
-0.4721475839614868,
0.32608285546302795,
-0.3178290128707886,
-0.009873908013105392,
-0.2525814473628998,
-0.10681726038455963,
-0.23796217143535614,
0.21964801847934723,
-0.2829671800136566,
0.1793546825647354,
0.29527783393859863,
-0.4752984344959259,
0.5866508483886719,
0.1823674887418747,
-0.3644120991230011,
0.7981957793235779,
-0.3346542418003082,
0.07854194939136505,
-0.18346965312957764,
0.18523260951042175,
-0.418271005153656,
-0.17115278542041779,
0.8665193915367126,
-0.6078536510467529,
-0.2662171721458435,
-0.49299541115760803,
-0.32200706005096436,
-0.500569760799408,
-0.1275240182876587,
0.5424126982688904,
0.38756251335144043,
-0.37833812832832336,
0.1133805438876152,
0.8414320945739746,
0.17632277309894562,
-0.753504753112793,
-0.842737078666687,
0.0697716772556305,
-0.5179654359817505,
-0.0918704941868782,
0.003373152343556285,
-0.08644189685583115,
-0.6298573017120361,
-0.0559699609875679,
-0.05267201364040375,
-0.2266681045293808,
0.04442477226257324,
0.6064808368682861,
-0.03245672956109047,
-0.08819453418254852,
0.026128794997930527,
-0.19908824563026428,
0.03375120460987091,
0.39585787057876587,
-0.295549213886261,
0.31190747022628784,
0.5858103036880493,
-0.537244975566864,
-0.14800916612148285,
0.5124650597572327,
0.4784792363643646,
0.18879073858261108,
0.6449231505393982,
0.5763457417488098,
-0.22483092546463013,
-0.4595014154911041,
-0.6857660412788391,
-0.4232727289199829,
-0.38723206520080566,
0.06337542831897736,
0.2832746207714081,
-1.083113670349121,
0.4323350787162781,
0.31501126289367676,
0.1741124391555786,
0.6748839616775513,
0.37645187973976135,
-0.05445186421275139,
0.8965478539466858,
0.7605912685394287,
-0.3171224594116211,
0.4972102642059326,
0.030557451769709587,
0.2174413800239563,
-0.34563079476356506,
-0.3005221486091614,
-0.6548981070518494,
-0.39735645055770874,
-0.5765490531921387,
-0.3749816417694092,
0.25987547636032104,
-0.4420793354511261,
-0.4116035997867584,
0.2820333242416382,
-0.863145649433136,
0.4577288329601288,
0.5547336935997009,
-0.0992070734500885,
0.15146443247795105,
0.1628946214914322,
0.3603450059890747,
-0.28027239441871643,
-0.6421306133270264,
-0.5654355883598328,
1.394330620765686,
0.37576550245285034,
0.6053115129470825,
-0.19341766834259033,
0.4206818640232086,
1.0132471323013306,
0.6695094108581543,
-0.681841254234314,
0.19584716856479645,
0.06188540533185005,
-0.8889270424842834,
-0.08480940014123917,
-0.46380046010017395,
-0.9265940189361572,
-0.09379146993160248,
-0.07091079652309418,
-0.3035183250904083,
0.1405385434627533,
0.11234261095523834,
0.10902290046215057,
0.48948585987091064,
-0.1501988023519516,
0.8161618709564209,
-0.09067730605602264,
-0.022242732346057892,
-0.2105286866426468,
-0.5469263195991516,
0.4451850950717926,
-0.14987777173519135,
0.25696298480033875,
-0.4027456045150757,
0.1968017965555191,
1.0991843938827515,
-0.012069057673215866,
0.795904278755188,
-0.2575243413448334,
-0.13306672871112823,
0.2526877224445343,
0.24081647396087646,
0.4261205196380615,
-0.5571576952934265,
-0.0069359298795461655,
0.3748522698879242,
-0.49147850275039673,
-0.5422781109809875,
-0.2681759297847748,
0.5884003639221191,
-0.6006367802619934,
-0.04787056893110275,
-0.2174747884273529,
-0.48226070404052734,
-0.19013670086860657,
0.40817269682884216,
0.25813859701156616,
0.2700682282447815,
-0.46182113885879517,
0.21016141772270203,
0.9133232831954956,
-0.050050098448991776,
-0.14092159271240234,
0.41776689887046814,
0.14267019927501678,
-0.256241112947464,
0.9044567942619324,
0.12623858451843262,
0.08252520114183426,
0.07090398669242859,
-0.25864407420158386,
-0.08463601768016815,
-0.6099257469177246,
-0.32644122838974,
0.003365699201822281,
-0.6401835680007935,
-0.24808824062347412,
-0.7899078726768494,
-0.1021975576877594,
-0.3311086595058441,
-0.2637079358100891,
-0.413227915763855,
-0.0655047744512558,
-0.24009469151496887,
0.04775374010205269,
0.13181692361831665,
1.169916033744812,
-0.2923598289489746,
0.26340797543525696,
-0.42522111535072327,
0.4718160331249237,
0.10885784029960632,
0.3675859272480011,
-0.27357110381126404,
-0.6625937223434448,
-0.3512251377105713,
0.41602015495300293,
-0.14242589473724365,
-0.931580126285553,
0.38537630438804626,
-0.39396461844444275,
0.5821670889854431,
0.6382409930229187,
0.23746158182621002,
0.4305590093135834,
-0.17378385365009308,
0.5854539275169373,
0.07913815230131149,
-0.35243624448776245,
0.5805435180664062,
-0.5093713998794556,
-0.17800398170948029,
0.4513767957687378,
1.1306793689727783,
-0.8570653796195984,
-0.7864046692848206,
-0.8337879776954651,
-0.41743963956832886,
0.6555743217468262,
0.23373405635356903,
-0.006836872547864914,
0.1216576024889946,
-0.30638283491134644,
0.5095049738883972,
0.25961068272590637,
-0.835809588432312,
-0.8764958381652832,
-0.3011632263660431,
-0.24043479561805725,
0.030117612332105637,
-0.32558244466781616,
-0.7353050708770752,
-0.01363333035260439,
0.6710031628608704,
-0.012673444114625454,
0.14230400323867798,
-0.3042813539505005,
-0.16297870874404907,
-0.43009358644485474,
0.11566749960184097,
0.11200177669525146,
0.4346249997615814,
0.056704215705394745,
0.05158986896276474,
-0.25960350036621094,
-0.4634553790092468,
0.16419243812561035,
-0.027883103117346764,
-0.5101832747459412,
0.19402363896369934,
0.25032079219818115,
0.5770859718322754,
-0.16476181149482727,
-0.6723552346229553,
0.5720419883728027,
0.1420823335647583,
-0.24063673615455627,
-0.24314002692699432,
0.1081053614616394,
-0.5325388312339783,
0.2554631233215332,
0.5364689826965332,
0.3190780580043793,
0.2571236193180084,
-0.39295703172683716,
0.2981589734554291,
0.4671051502227783,
-0.7382466793060303,
-0.1687249392271042,
0.34968477487564087,
0.17786866426467896,
-0.06655910611152649,
0.5890247821807861,
-0.14776074886322021,
-0.5567803978919983,
0.46419429779052734,
0.059822216629981995,
0.5966368317604065,
-0.04095840081572533,
0.46225816011428833,
0.4529625475406647,
0.6379430890083313,
0.2788722515106201,
-0.37420302629470825,
-0.11036480963230133,
-0.8487615585327148,
0.06048250198364258,
-0.4591202139854431,
-0.3731200397014618,
0.4425355792045593,
-0.6876019835472107,
0.10736636817455292,
-0.4915110766887665,
0.12669503688812256,
0.20219206809997559,
0.037216924130916595,
-0.6011673212051392,
0.27766817808151245,
0.4568730294704437,
0.6704211831092834,
-1.1717301607131958,
0.27045121788978577,
0.3077959418296814,
-0.10598298162221909,
-0.3553900718688965,
-0.1675957441329956,
0.6341555118560791,
-0.7515265345573425,
0.5177545547485352,
0.20013801753520966,
0.19060173630714417,
-0.08343589305877686,
-0.8507956266403198,
-0.7924690246582031,
0.4131655991077423,
0.08733166009187698,
-0.46176743507385254,
0.28108111023902893,
0.3706296682357788,
0.4543781280517578,
-0.38107556104660034,
0.18911351263523102,
0.3773663341999054,
0.45022377371788025,
-0.3089901804924011,
-0.6383408308029175,
0.07368934154510498,
-0.26720568537712097,
-0.44476956129074097,
0.3341361880302429,
-0.3787878453731537,
0.5962929725646973,
0.07923804223537445,
-0.3540056347846985,
-0.37927335500717163,
0.3151020407676697,
-0.039366841316223145,
0.2451217770576477,
0.43613767623901367,
0.6787999868392944,
0.39192408323287964,
-0.10850933939218521,
0.47558051347732544,
0.2353854924440384,
0.012325801886618137,
0.8465865254402161,
0.18575328588485718,
0.06470576673746109,
0.2863439619541168,
-0.15715040266513824,
0.5741121172904968,
0.5323814153671265,
-0.7162127494812012,
0.42472726106643677,
0.3035491704940796,
-0.14685040712356567,
-0.08405092358589172,
-0.5647879838943481,
-0.23996780812740326,
0.3464720845222473,
0.5146111249923706,
-0.75056391954422,
-0.36360713839530945,
0.1270315945148468,
0.02545943669974804,
0.2233196347951889,
-0.38936740159988403,
0.7792295217514038,
-0.3055785596370697,
-0.4455493986606598,
0.4790079891681671,
-0.06460102647542953,
0.8962274789810181,
-0.5112310647964478,
0.13718433678150177,
-0.17272883653640747,
-0.07353346794843674,
-0.4421582818031311,
-0.8159124851226807,
0.5658915638923645,
0.16046524047851562,
-0.40463799238204956,
-0.5803776383399963,
0.7711264491081238,
-0.243048757314682,
0.008195741102099419,
0.3216616213321686,
0.5361708402633667,
0.3032337725162506,
-0.4431614279747009,
-1.0024702548980713,
0.6209975481033325,
0.00915647204965353,
0.06115568429231644,
0.4290456473827362,
0.3135535717010498,
0.026271404698491096,
0.5942851305007935,
0.6996046900749207,
0.10573368519544601,
0.15957538783550262,
0.08659978955984116,
0.9993554949760437,
-0.5924434661865234,
-0.2664400637149811,
-0.618039608001709,
0.31891489028930664,
-0.2489355355501175,
-0.37654465436935425,
1.029367446899414,
0.708870530128479,
1.3219187259674072,
0.1500115990638733,
1.003896713256836,
-0.16647936403751373,
0.9968130588531494,
0.21319521963596344,
0.7616254687309265,
-0.3272637128829956,
-0.13530269265174866,
-0.34333840012550354,
-0.8780387043952942,
-0.34330928325653076,
0.3677038848400116,
-0.22529339790344238,
-0.0639880821108818,
0.23231272399425507,
0.9804468750953674,
-0.26552674174308777,
0.07843706011772156,
0.2646489441394806,
0.3246730864048004,
0.21622322499752045,
0.2870188057422638,
0.8717938661575317,
-0.5121718645095825,
0.7219702005386353,
-0.4987473487854004,
-0.1562672108411789,
-0.4015604853630066,
-0.523550271987915,
-0.8674132227897644,
-0.6284745931625366,
-0.2892136573791504,
-0.4687146842479706,
0.21367226541042328,
0.5702386498451233,
0.748649537563324,
-1.0130325555801392,
-0.03878458961844444,
0.03629903495311737,
0.3046649694442749,
-0.027035441249608994,
-0.28649914264678955,
-0.20761220157146454,
0.04007166251540184,
-0.5951675772666931,
0.21997398138046265,
0.24503669142723083,
0.05779612064361572,
-0.5149940252304077,
-0.15201129019260406,
0.13607066869735718,
-0.02087673544883728,
0.49742794036865234,
0.5918098092079163,
-0.8056076765060425,
-0.04867320507764816,
-0.2645756006240845,
-0.5031003355979919,
-0.07297982275485992,
0.9260796904563904,
-0.8748928904533386,
0.14715030789375305,
0.10673695802688599,
0.6774381399154663,
-0.06953441351652145,
-0.07097326964139938,
0.3050699532032013,
-0.5071938037872314,
0.03892606869339943,
0.8563658595085144,
-0.08022043853998184,
0.4592556059360504,
-0.16485291719436646,
0.47474244236946106,
0.5612515211105347,
-0.40673354268074036,
-1.159156322479248,
0.45758509635925293,
-0.6948621273040771,
-0.38265806436538696,
1.1062736511230469,
0.21538250148296356,
-0.01882380060851574,
-0.5291690826416016,
-0.1886526644229889,
0.3080451488494873,
-0.3223862051963806,
1.0772567987442017,
0.4610859751701355,
0.09437103569507599,
-0.07610020041465759,
-0.31800752878189087,
0.798575222492218,
0.36391758918762207,
-0.8342177271842957,
0.20490510761737823,
1.027481198310852,
0.023118244484066963,
0.14283201098442078,
0.33800509572029114,
-0.07465134561061859,
0.17120756208896637,
0.19279003143310547,
-0.04376249015331268,
0.2129237949848175,
-0.48665177822113037,
-0.027583589777350426,
0.2674168646335602,
-0.37141016125679016,
0.15743540227413177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08553v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08553v2
|
Improving Transformers with Dynamically Composable Multi-Head Attention
| 2024-05-14T12:41:11 | 2024-06-04T14:49:36 |
Da Xiao, Qingye Meng, Shengping Li, Xingyuan Yuan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Multi-Head Attention (MHA) is a key component of Transformer. In MHA,
attention heads work independently, causing problems such as low-rank
bottleneck of attention score matrices and head redundancy. We propose
Dynamically Composable Multi-Head Attention (DCMHA), a parameter and
computation efficient attention architecture that tackles the shortcomings of
MHA and increases the expressive power of the model by dynamically composing
attention heads. At the core of DCMHA is a $\it{Compose}$ function that
transforms the attention score and weight matrices in an input-dependent way.
DCMHA can be used as a drop-in replacement of MHA in any transformer
architecture to obtain the corresponding DCFormer. DCFormer significantly
outperforms Transformer on different architectures and model scales in language
modeling, matching the performance of models with ~1.7x-2.0x compute. For
example, DCPythia-6.9B outperforms open source Pythia-12B on both pretraining
perplexity and downstream task evaluation. The code and models are available at
https://github.com/Caiyun-AI/DCFormer.
|
[
-0.445250928401947,
-0.5042074918746948,
0.46622326970100403,
0.4815193712711334,
-0.16376422345638275,
0.37945935130119324,
-0.37479469180107117,
-0.4725387990474701,
0.2521178424358368,
0.07235096395015717,
-0.7862804532051086,
0.06954024732112885,
-0.676115870475769,
0.08352747559547424,
-0.24206645786762238,
0.5063953399658203,
-0.005791151896119118,
-0.4294995367527008,
-0.12331821769475937,
-0.3083801567554474,
-0.7102006077766418,
-0.32082104682922363,
-0.6079220175743103,
-0.41256535053253174,
0.8868633508682251,
0.606946587562561,
0.7937633395195007,
0.6984531879425049,
0.7990424633026123,
0.3998352289199829,
-0.11346936225891113,
0.1120510920882225,
-0.4926939308643341,
0.31112605333328247,
-0.08780763298273087,
-0.30742987990379333,
-0.8449466228485107,
-0.037995610386133194,
0.7528653740882874,
0.49941885471343994,
-0.3721171021461487,
0.3415025472640991,
0.2071591466665268,
0.7019268274307251,
-0.6233846545219421,
0.4671652615070343,
-0.7095609903335571,
-0.07027720659971237,
-0.15406359732151031,
-0.2581658661365509,
-0.4642844498157501,
0.09912995249032974,
0.14939986169338226,
-0.48601070046424866,
0.05652947351336479,
0.011841840110719204,
0.7187096476554871,
0.7694736123085022,
-0.10335075110197067,
0.23102125525474548,
-0.7832323312759399,
0.9089669585227966,
-0.16487735509872437,
0.7615436911582947,
-0.19323545694351196,
0.7638238072395325,
0.22950613498687744,
-0.6782702207565308,
-0.6394096612930298,
-0.21111567318439484,
-0.14747293293476105,
0.3845018148422241,
-0.5105616450309753,
0.04749952629208565,
0.31031808257102966,
0.6272976994514465,
-0.20324566960334778,
-0.1929624080657959,
0.08271228522062302,
-0.09033513069152832,
0.21321161091327667,
0.1975831687450409,
0.23447276651859283,
-0.0626569613814354,
0.06061916798353195,
-0.3683108389377594,
-0.5949217677116394,
0.03579447790980339,
0.21806620061397552,
0.1796446442604065,
-0.35256269574165344,
0.3248128294944763,
-0.36485639214515686,
0.640981137752533,
0.6106681823730469,
-0.11638042330741882,
0.22766351699829102,
-0.19797606766223907,
-0.3650380074977875,
-0.19419480860233307,
0.4903143644332886,
-0.08617240190505981,
0.06218283250927925,
-0.3359433710575104,
0.05872422829270363,
0.21872764825820923,
0.8327370285987854,
-0.7979776859283447,
-0.37349799275398254,
0.44130903482437134,
-0.49156564474105835,
-0.37420815229415894,
-0.1775200068950653,
-0.898904025554657,
-0.22182512283325195,
-0.5493245720863342,
0.30615758895874023,
-0.002473796484991908,
-0.373026043176651,
-0.10307124257087708,
0.18307068943977356,
0.07648023962974548,
0.2709144353866577,
-1.127437710762024,
0.01733558066189289,
0.3972088694572449,
0.6740122437477112,
-0.4766751527786255,
-0.35180068016052246,
-0.8078556060791016,
0.10557480901479721,
0.13930436968803406,
0.8750993609428406,
-0.602020263671875,
-0.07914423197507858,
-0.2340008020401001,
-0.008292569778859615,
-0.44350382685661316,
-0.7323753833770752,
0.48667389154434204,
-0.598351240158081,
-0.16168224811553955,
0.07948889583349228,
0.06680756062269211,
-0.22714006900787354,
0.35913047194480896,
-0.911028265953064,
0.6882784366607666,
0.3614296615123749,
-0.7897723913192749,
-0.05955684185028076,
-0.6989189982414246,
-0.46381881833076477,
-0.0419427715241909,
-0.1925242394208908,
-0.6448675394058228,
0.12357129901647568,
0.39279165863990784,
0.24410413205623627,
-0.25476062297821045,
0.2607422471046448,
-0.09743291884660721,
-0.4806983768939972,
0.15098978579044342,
-0.6792747974395752,
0.5875371694564819,
0.04577801004052162,
-0.6031123399734497,
0.5288559794425964,
-1.0535712242126465,
-0.18284611403942108,
0.13748173415660858,
-0.5261975526809692,
0.27930647134780884,
-0.032853249460458755,
0.19416506588459015,
0.24751615524291992,
0.21734385192394257,
-0.2872121334075928,
0.04762033745646477,
-0.33693554997444153,
0.29180946946144104,
0.5939362049102783,
-0.16920232772827148,
0.3364024758338928,
-0.3047961890697479,
0.7425047755241394,
0.21425656974315643,
0.23250281810760498,
-0.14762289822101593,
-0.2626895308494568,
-1.0373777151107788,
-0.49403420090675354,
0.10676269233226776,
0.4129808247089386,
-0.7706220149993896,
0.510108470916748,
-0.2971767485141754,
-0.6891664266586304,
-0.6098705530166626,
-0.16255953907966614,
0.2497406303882599,
0.511980414390564,
0.4857397973537445,
-0.18855562806129456,
-0.6095395684242249,
-0.8169066309928894,
-0.18000078201293945,
0.07072591036558151,
0.04089445620775223,
0.35777711868286133,
-0.11160792410373688,
-0.44564226269721985,
0.5832942724227905,
-0.5543163418769836,
-0.39620527625083923,
-0.4222605526447296,
-0.06369923055171967,
0.21954913437366486,
0.2803021967411041,
0.4209572672843933,
-0.5722072720527649,
-0.5766918659210205,
0.007606836501508951,
-0.48736223578453064,
-0.194235160946846,
-0.018963048234581947,
-0.17376136779785156,
-0.01316987443715334,
0.20006948709487915,
-0.9530972242355347,
0.15916399657726288,
0.8716946840286255,
-0.10202093422412872,
0.7665871977806091,
0.02876708097755909,
0.25922685861587524,
-0.9686156511306763,
0.4074566066265106,
-0.27422407269477844,
-0.2558593153953552,
-0.6379002928733826,
0.3861199617385864,
0.124356709420681,
-0.3047352731227875,
-0.5324606895446777,
0.21941106021404266,
-0.5119262933731079,
0.29618534445762634,
-0.5304442644119263,
0.07520338147878647,
0.05795610323548317,
0.9691223502159119,
-0.11562354117631912,
0.7453240156173706,
0.7276802062988281,
-0.7214632034301758,
0.43966877460479736,
0.44585296511650085,
-0.30429014563560486,
0.5593758821487427,
-0.7013980746269226,
0.27979913353919983,
0.010425441898405552,
0.16142606735229492,
-0.8031548261642456,
-0.2791494131088257,
0.41429752111434937,
-0.2622009217739105,
0.4465958774089813,
0.12437482923269272,
-0.28989335894584656,
-0.4673697054386139,
-0.30992841720581055,
0.6598184704780579,
0.21028576791286469,
-0.6307404041290283,
0.8952643871307373,
0.4949242174625397,
-0.22753553092479706,
-0.6513614654541016,
-0.40061628818511963,
0.04021921381354332,
-0.19749584794044495,
-0.39415591955184937,
0.6043148040771484,
-0.15358974039554596,
-0.07104665040969849,
-0.23740734159946442,
-0.27897778153419495,
0.08264965564012527,
0.03680012375116348,
0.006339487619698048,
0.18170244991779327,
-0.0552322082221508,
-0.05239846184849739,
0.02098003402352333,
-0.4172990322113037,
0.10206659138202667,
0.0599125474691391,
0.8141998052597046,
0.2753428816795349,
-0.13524200022220612,
-0.7473383545875549,
0.43508434295654297,
1.0218757390975952,
-0.6614753603935242,
0.4460141062736511,
0.6051231026649475,
-0.2532884180545807,
-0.11821454018354416,
-0.36410000920295715,
-0.25260621309280396,
-0.5393333435058594,
0.4702707529067993,
-0.5370138883590698,
-0.796941876411438,
0.41963881254196167,
0.21243147552013397,
0.11062107235193253,
0.48587673902511597,
1.0142258405685425,
0.16604845225811005,
1.0967798233032227,
0.8130894899368286,
-0.02644583396613598,
0.8094760179519653,
-0.15271590650081635,
0.4205942451953888,
-0.99977046251297,
-0.10959859192371368,
-0.3935278654098511,
-0.4715884029865265,
-0.665881335735321,
-0.4363994300365448,
0.4316686987876892,
-0.5785908102989197,
0.09984634816646576,
0.6684432625770569,
-0.7259911298751831,
0.22539296746253967,
0.41628819704055786,
0.1363469511270523,
0.3272513449192047,
-0.21623486280441284,
0.10915789753198624,
-0.07898052781820297,
-0.5894848704338074,
-0.23424185812473297,
0.7702011466026306,
0.5236016511917114,
0.8079060912132263,
0.1309046745300293,
0.26713719964027405,
-0.12302805483341217,
0.26803016662597656,
-1.1408865451812744,
0.3524650037288666,
-0.10578335076570511,
-0.28328099846839905,
-0.16174350678920746,
-0.44354337453842163,
-0.824996292591095,
0.5131474137306213,
-0.004670970607548952,
-0.5738555192947388,
0.2814079821109772,
0.4116891026496887,
-0.702721893787384,
0.08086346089839935,
-0.5918724536895752,
0.892999529838562,
0.08540389686822891,
-0.2965777814388275,
-0.726047158241272,
-0.5614534020423889,
0.2949616014957428,
-0.19056545197963715,
-0.14013421535491943,
-0.14187365770339966,
0.2689525783061981,
0.5753145813941956,
0.008297201246023178,
0.5228725671768188,
-0.09897526353597641,
-0.31419041752815247,
0.172495037317276,
-0.1532532274723053,
0.5358263254165649,
0.16741548478603363,
0.11872872710227966,
0.022663768380880356,
-0.18397623300552368,
-0.06341130286455154,
-0.6925062537193298,
0.6256766319274902,
-0.6704601049423218,
-0.789175808429718,
-0.30684515833854675,
-0.9875828623771667,
-0.3667551875114441,
0.2370937615633011,
-0.06113346293568611,
0.5149134397506714,
-0.014144805260002613,
0.31294193863868713,
0.7041361331939697,
-0.11332505941390991,
0.6287809610366821,
0.35580873489379883,
0.14870890974998474,
-0.48573359847068787,
0.8802966475486755,
0.055324986577034,
0.13525839149951935,
0.7060425281524658,
0.1693808138370514,
-0.16970205307006836,
-0.24925485253334045,
-0.4057851731777191,
0.07004287093877792,
-0.648587703704834,
-0.4151879847049713,
-1.0625892877578735,
-0.15311235189437866,
-0.3037317097187042,
0.2802532911300659,
-0.5760790705680847,
-0.24060355126857758,
-0.10367641597986221,
0.25799787044525146,
0.015956297516822815,
0.37949416041374207,
0.336628794670105,
0.6494438648223877,
-0.7504426836967468,
0.8336147665977478,
0.5977956056594849,
0.5015884041786194,
0.4451203942298889,
-0.5317795872688293,
-0.43266427516937256,
-0.23003417253494263,
-0.7057771682739258,
-0.6099518537521362,
0.2799542248249054,
0.11556987464427948,
0.6865224838256836,
0.3792102336883545,
-0.15432196855545044,
0.6819590926170349,
-0.8083164095878601,
0.192812979221344,
0.018662910908460617,
-0.922735869884491,
0.20559851825237274,
-0.35058602690696716,
0.8419927358627319,
0.5743993520736694,
-0.04313945770263672,
-0.4926378130912781,
-0.6877070069313049,
-0.5229107737541199,
-0.6375938653945923,
0.8949779868125916,
0.3704220652580261,
0.15898938477039337,
0.34409481287002563,
0.1000521183013916,
0.05347238853573799,
0.3233044445514679,
-0.5702619552612305,
-0.4582279324531555,
-0.13249389827251434,
-0.3814491033554077,
0.08039256930351257,
-0.27584153413772583,
0.04283245652914047,
-0.5024909377098083,
0.5742782354354858,
-0.19469621777534485,
0.5946561694145203,
-0.1640165150165558,
-0.3036690056324005,
-0.28649646043777466,
0.05431234464049339,
0.5477263331413269,
0.8245741724967957,
-0.16008588671684265,
0.34460780024528503,
0.040904439985752106,
-0.723781406879425,
0.18724346160888672,
0.30716410279273987,
-0.070350781083107,
-0.1056109294295311,
0.022398440167307854,
0.7501227855682373,
0.37056830525398254,
-0.5843333005905151,
0.18893831968307495,
-0.3100966513156891,
0.2827080190181732,
-0.024591239169239998,
0.07200937718153,
0.27629709243774414,
0.15925338864326477,
0.27763697504997253,
0.49247097969055176,
0.13291378319263458,
-0.4260181486606598,
0.44994473457336426,
0.26192787289619446,
-0.36199167370796204,
-0.48433008790016174,
0.7809740900993347,
0.3510001599788666,
-0.2363738715648651,
0.39413779973983765,
0.08785494416952133,
-0.532037615776062,
0.44615310430526733,
0.4303297698497772,
0.9872596859931946,
-0.4936094284057617,
-0.030729660764336586,
0.24288709461688995,
0.2488202601671219,
0.3054361045360565,
0.12348123639822006,
-0.21025928854942322,
-0.4880942702293396,
-0.530966579914093,
-0.5193578004837036,
-0.6954616904258728,
0.09517882019281387,
-0.3528544008731842,
0.5895024538040161,
-0.3240183889865875,
0.014512692578136921,
0.24042317271232605,
-0.18695691227912903,
-0.6912410855293274,
0.5074595212936401,
0.14661042392253876,
0.5494123697280884,
-0.4126834571361542,
0.9843490123748779,
0.5993430018424988,
-0.27605992555618286,
-0.686760663986206,
0.4132273495197296,
-0.26947036385536194,
-0.6802927255630493,
0.15731298923492432,
0.5850023627281189,
-0.47609928250312805,
0.3096623718738556,
-0.018282659351825714,
-0.9659123420715332,
1.0028947591781616,
0.6731599569320679,
-0.7154646515846252,
0.036550719290971756,
0.018015841022133827,
0.31342461705207825,
-0.25547611713409424,
0.3388262987136841,
0.6713793873786926,
0.42067208886146545,
-0.05524434894323349,
-0.8456953763961792,
0.05852796137332916,
-0.18679969012737274,
-0.1992415487766266,
0.08574255555868149,
-1.2089576721191406,
0.7007734775543213,
-0.16731545329093933,
-0.4335995018482208,
-0.2177577018737793,
0.7910362482070923,
0.3548120856285095,
-0.20276041328907013,
0.6895119547843933,
0.5457135438919067,
0.6150132417678833,
-0.10282577574253082,
0.8785991668701172,
-0.5249320864677429,
0.3864806294441223,
0.9438071250915527,
-0.029973940923810005,
0.701819658279419,
0.6363114714622498,
-0.10841593146324158,
0.45296210050582886,
0.40951091051101685,
0.0886516124010086,
0.6012426018714905,
0.10441944003105164,
-0.20636402070522308,
-0.18343503773212433,
-0.0013373654801398516,
-0.1464398056268692,
0.8510710597038269,
-0.08275385946035385,
-0.09736912697553635,
-0.14567147195339203,
0.06792335957288742,
-0.12083490937948227,
-0.08723875135183334,
-0.16757695376873016,
0.6356101632118225,
0.11799979209899902,
-0.8433193564414978,
0.7024127840995789,
0.08648864179849625,
0.713988721370697,
-0.44490206241607666,
-0.03584406524896622,
-0.2279060035943985,
0.6683596968650818,
-0.10517463833093643,
-0.26314982771873474,
0.714065670967102,
-0.13229726254940033,
-0.5102413296699524,
-0.21805250644683838,
0.6550814509391785,
-0.4980471730232239,
-0.4677755534648895,
0.2652617394924164,
0.32832464575767517,
-0.29058679938316345,
-0.5631217956542969,
-0.57618248462677,
0.5156355500221252,
-0.23541085422039032,
-0.3260916769504547,
0.13558825850486755,
0.08473339676856995,
0.08718115091323853,
0.7503398656845093,
0.35095858573913574,
-0.1872285008430481,
-0.07003910839557648,
0.4662986397743225,
0.871310293674469,
-0.49833405017852783,
-0.5521958470344543,
-0.8721598386764526,
0.5530540943145752,
0.046743955463171005,
-0.12441111356019974,
0.5558355450630188,
0.24035024642944336,
0.3920325040817261,
-0.3280442953109741,
0.5762397050857544,
-0.1406739354133606,
0.4889558255672455,
-0.08262452483177185,
1.084243655204773,
-0.5607064366340637,
-0.12693975865840912,
-0.22281301021575928,
-1.354149341583252,
-0.484422892332077,
0.5194964408874512,
0.18886137008666992,
0.06350060552358627,
0.9752453565597534,
0.6059905886650085,
-0.2744916081428528,
-0.24862845242023468,
0.4907782971858978,
-0.003815971314907074,
0.5245825052261353,
0.7225750684738159,
0.7106744647026062,
-0.5362776517868042,
0.7240549325942993,
-0.34941330552101135,
-0.38117048144340515,
-0.18588252365589142,
-0.7607747912406921,
-0.8242356777191162,
-0.3643897473812103,
-0.6216742396354675,
0.008236459456384182,
-0.28531649708747864,
0.7029423713684082,
0.6652812957763672,
-1.042396903038025,
-0.14148777723312378,
-0.028744693845510483,
0.09879203885793686,
-0.7195881009101868,
-0.25631240010261536,
0.3187117874622345,
-0.5837976336479187,
-1.1259870529174805,
0.39176082611083984,
0.5992134213447571,
-0.23748570680618286,
-0.5062147974967957,
0.1710394024848938,
-0.12504880130290985,
0.16757705807685852,
0.8220869898796082,
-0.12828873097896576,
-0.5794859528541565,
-0.40682560205459595,
0.19374734163284302,
-0.1292695552110672,
0.4067463278770447,
0.7230432033538818,
-0.6292438507080078,
0.36513426899909973,
0.5763154029846191,
0.8878722786903381,
0.17059844732284546,
-0.018929099664092064,
0.6721105575561523,
-0.7987187504768372,
0.3568589687347412,
0.134402796626091,
0.4046775698661804,
0.5391532778739929,
-0.4585184156894684,
0.1781483292579651,
0.24463224411010742,
-0.5795984864234924,
-0.640947163105011,
0.2714090645313263,
-1.4310758113861084,
0.3341531753540039,
0.8888043165206909,
-0.0018570112297311425,
-0.29947492480278015,
0.006719137076288462,
-0.47108447551727295,
0.6410344839096069,
-0.26173844933509827,
1.1506260633468628,
0.5136021375656128,
-0.018402112647891045,
-0.5454509258270264,
-0.2838900089263916,
0.44948774576187134,
0.5440678596496582,
-0.9925803542137146,
0.482098251581192,
0.08209037780761719,
-0.08641306310892105,
0.42656421661376953,
0.33439669013023376,
-0.12516289949417114,
0.46784070134162903,
-0.05718531459569931,
0.14548946917057037,
0.08090076595544815,
-0.6393285989761353,
-0.31803473830223083,
0.31702151894569397,
0.036894362419843674,
-0.549842357635498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08546v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08546v1
|
Analysing Cross-Speaker Convergence in Face-to-Face Dialogue through the Lens of Automatically Detected Shared Linguistic Constructions
| 2024-05-14T12:34:25 | 2024-05-14T12:34:25 |
Esam Ghaleb, Marlou Rasenberg, Wim Pouw, Ivan Toni, Judith Holler, Aslı Özyürek, Raquel Fernández
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conversation requires a substantial amount of coordination between dialogue
participants, from managing turn taking to negotiating mutual understanding.
Part of this coordination effort surfaces as the reuse of linguistic behaviour
across speakers, a process often referred to as alignment. While the presence
of linguistic alignment is well documented in the literature, several questions
remain open, including the extent to which patterns of reuse across speakers
have an impact on the emergence of labelling conventions for novel referents.
In this study, we put forward a methodology for automatically detecting shared
lemmatised constructions -- expressions with a common lexical core used by both
speakers within a dialogue -- and apply it to a referential communication
corpus where participants aim to identify novel objects for which no
established labels exist. Our analyses uncover the usage patterns of shared
constructions in interaction and reveal that features such as their frequency
and the amount of different constructions used for a referent are associated
with the degree of object labelling convergence the participants exhibit after
social interaction. More generally, the present study shows that automatically
detected shared constructions offer a useful level of analysis to investigate
the dynamics of reference negotiation in dialogue.
|
[
-0.7335079312324524,
-0.6223647594451904,
0.3462050259113312,
-0.1576327234506607,
-0.15792274475097656,
0.11331148445606232,
-0.24214006960391998,
-0.5579642653465271,
0.44987380504608154,
0.4385879933834076,
-0.46314188838005066,
-0.43479129672050476,
-0.7493173480033875,
0.29105886816978455,
-0.5552140474319458,
0.7056066989898682,
-0.011053608730435371,
-0.37093013525009155,
-0.3764929473400116,
-0.6986165642738342,
-0.4547296166419983,
-0.48189443349838257,
-0.38085928559303284,
-0.4815003275871277,
0.4098780155181885,
0.32045039534568787,
1.103508710861206,
0.4627365171909332,
0.2600390911102295,
0.4676881432533264,
-0.021134596318006516,
0.2150712013244629,
-0.3285194933414459,
0.21994267404079437,
-0.4256093502044678,
-0.0540529303252697,
-0.23526808619499207,
0.01094464398920536,
0.6961199045181274,
1.0599801540374756,
-0.07202944159507751,
0.044658880680799484,
0.31119638681411743,
0.21213053166866302,
-0.5432419776916504,
0.08682245016098022,
-0.5936188101768494,
0.051332417875528336,
-0.2339337021112442,
-0.4376184344291687,
-0.29896295070648193,
-0.09510930627584457,
0.20037366449832916,
-0.3875758945941925,
0.27722012996673584,
-0.09182030707597733,
0.9166772365570068,
0.12334022670984268,
-0.28964075446128845,
-0.5455853343009949,
-0.4248009920120239,
0.7038983702659607,
-0.5327288508415222,
0.4010416269302368,
0.029134785756468773,
0.21836772561073303,
-0.2876528203487396,
-0.41227033734321594,
-0.657616913318634,
0.17416761815547943,
-0.460315078496933,
-0.21266810595989227,
-0.19833509624004364,
-0.18144017457962036,
0.21780750155448914,
0.18203747272491455,
-0.3247930407524109,
-0.04882113263010979,
-0.10827764123678207,
-0.21589992940425873,
0.4872048497200012,
0.061923425644636154,
0.5485736727714539,
-0.030629798769950867,
-0.23633939027786255,
0.2131330519914627,
-0.357587069272995,
-0.2949136197566986,
0.19981133937835693,
0.39700132608413696,
-0.2926918566226959,
0.4262678027153015,
-0.20266011357307434,
0.9680696725845337,
0.5563681721687317,
0.10442591458559036,
0.3927510678768158,
-0.7266987562179565,
0.11665516346693039,
0.31077250838279724,
1.1379308700561523,
0.6389236450195312,
0.7801411151885986,
-0.06406257301568985,
0.04162224009633064,
-0.22715391218662262,
0.11142043024301529,
-0.2012973576784134,
-0.07272867858409882,
-0.2196214646100998,
-0.21261495351791382,
0.018549082800745964,
-0.30839088559150696,
-0.38279208540916443,
-0.10339563339948654,
-0.37980562448501587,
0.07771435379981995,
-0.05843380466103554,
-0.45851194858551025,
0.07096906006336212,
-0.046861618757247925,
0.4778348505496979,
0.25894978642463684,
-0.8681595921516418,
0.4276701807975769,
0.7552512288093567,
0.7858878374099731,
-0.19410604238510132,
-0.3410853147506714,
-0.4191893935203552,
0.24775013327598572,
-0.06520229578018188,
0.9160023927688599,
-0.5604977011680603,
-0.6120045781135559,
0.1580083668231964,
0.11297877877950668,
-0.14996738731861115,
-0.5986834764480591,
0.16652843356132507,
-0.22158969938755035,
0.36192166805267334,
-0.20725680887699127,
-0.4867425858974457,
0.2095755785703659,
0.4535089135169983,
-0.5657954812049866,
0.8760392069816589,
-0.16048601269721985,
-0.8302150964736938,
0.31515610218048096,
-0.06081850454211235,
-0.20408952236175537,
0.1733899861574173,
-0.694135308265686,
-0.43085452914237976,
-0.057040028274059296,
0.06068155914545059,
0.4490215480327606,
-0.11955665796995163,
0.294196754693985,
-0.22490420937538147,
-0.2843349874019623,
0.2931271493434906,
-0.023342547938227654,
0.7001614570617676,
0.029875928536057472,
-0.3974079191684723,
-0.3156481385231018,
-0.5047019720077515,
-0.25064438581466675,
-0.09268992394208908,
0.21228890120983124,
-0.5270168781280518,
0.023976566269993782,
-0.6168885827064514,
0.042426303029060364,
0.2721864581108093,
-0.28806814551353455,
0.04090864956378937,
-0.12166643142700195,
-0.09063594043254852,
0.19814802706241608,
0.19891203939914703,
0.1519681066274643,
-0.6436887979507446,
0.18065734207630157,
0.08278005570173264,
-0.12173398584127426,
-0.22137469053268433,
-0.7346979379653931,
-0.7783162593841553,
0.07795921713113785,
-0.16403234004974365,
0.5439130663871765,
-0.47043171525001526,
0.5533881783485413,
-0.5062258243560791,
-0.23494675755500793,
-0.48449206352233887,
0.18946269154548645,
0.6566229462623596,
0.28444981575012207,
0.11390272527933121,
-0.6299267411231995,
-0.5198059678077698,
-1.0527399778366089,
-0.5100164413452148,
-0.2568228840827942,
0.2833400070667267,
0.43330562114715576,
0.21420802175998688,
-0.1324934959411621,
1.3418036699295044,
-0.2394215166568756,
0.0775216668844223,
-0.12406641989946365,
0.5683251619338989,
0.11188359558582306,
0.5082557797431946,
0.6189670562744141,
-0.7613718509674072,
-0.885303258895874,
0.2594839036464691,
-0.7706016898155212,
-0.5313656330108643,
-0.22534197568893433,
-0.09905602037906647,
0.1920330673456192,
0.836043655872345,
-0.28877580165863037,
0.3907657563686371,
0.4717036187648773,
-0.25099754333496094,
0.5484049320220947,
0.09735124558210373,
0.4449901580810547,
-1.01338529586792,
-0.07625161856412888,
-0.19189485907554626,
-0.4100487530231476,
-0.6502475142478943,
-0.14861264824867249,
-0.5812572836875916,
0.14630088210105896,
-0.504800021648407,
0.5351359248161316,
-0.7707269191741943,
-0.3730778396129608,
-0.19455298781394958,
0.7318395972251892,
-0.264636367559433,
0.4849125146865845,
0.32335254549980164,
0.7858213782310486,
0.24389347434043884,
-0.4349413514137268,
0.2479703277349472,
0.47040143609046936,
-0.26737651228904724,
1.109632134437561,
-0.4848007559776306,
0.3592241108417511,
-0.00909778755158186,
-0.02866319753229618,
-1.2035046815872192,
0.023120498284697533,
0.5057889223098755,
-0.7410938143730164,
0.15301968157291412,
-0.16474750638008118,
-0.16811861097812653,
-0.12068226933479309,
0.01004359032958746,
0.8140789866447449,
0.007585044950246811,
-0.434029757976532,
0.7840118408203125,
0.6408209800720215,
-0.3577417731285095,
-0.6100949645042419,
-0.5364911556243896,
0.059909503906965256,
-0.21314705908298492,
-0.8304973840713501,
0.18537019193172455,
-0.03937912359833717,
-0.5764839053153992,
-0.13427041471004486,
-0.021299194544553757,
-0.008214655332267284,
-0.01964273862540722,
0.3804170787334442,
0.016732191666960716,
-0.07553239911794662,
-0.20370489358901978,
-0.13710622489452362,
-0.1035979762673378,
-0.10729373246431351,
0.1135621890425682,
0.7549346685409546,
-0.13424737751483917,
-0.4465687572956085,
-0.6120702028274536,
0.5790280103683472,
0.4475100040435791,
0.15121358633041382,
0.7082462906837463,
0.47720983624458313,
-0.1992303431034088,
0.2523120939731598,
-0.8137476444244385,
0.26091521978378296,
-0.488552451133728,
0.024975065141916275,
-0.7567151784896851,
-0.9649868607521057,
0.8993901610374451,
-0.01198649313300848,
0.08628483861684799,
0.33528777956962585,
0.7687168717384338,
-0.06738711148500443,
0.46455979347229004,
0.5285004377365112,
-0.07408949732780457,
0.47488686442375183,
0.27800410985946655,
0.2839537560939789,
-0.6742970943450928,
-0.2986814081668854,
-0.6229680776596069,
-0.2417297214269638,
-0.5143117904663086,
-0.7732496857643127,
0.0023724937345832586,
-0.027581607922911644,
0.18227793276309967,
0.9442110657691956,
-0.42967671155929565,
0.5740373730659485,
0.2794765532016754,
-0.29264965653419495,
0.6445895433425903,
-0.1386774629354477,
-0.3209775686264038,
-0.024516521021723747,
-0.45219501852989197,
-0.4065593183040619,
0.5310153365135193,
-0.11859291046857834,
0.4349682927131653,
0.09451606869697571,
1.088183879852295,
0.35186219215393066,
0.2578178644180298,
-0.7686885595321655,
0.826569139957428,
0.2923815846443176,
-0.2326284646987915,
-0.1324167549610138,
-0.41519948840141296,
-1.2242321968078613,
0.18554125726222992,
-0.1180921345949173,
-1.0411765575408936,
0.3534533679485321,
-0.051991868764162064,
-0.3151921033859253,
-0.058664824813604355,
-0.5645614266395569,
0.9020582437515259,
0.07600817829370499,
-0.22677741944789886,
-0.31141602993011475,
-0.6958431005477905,
0.16802643239498138,
-0.18474102020263672,
0.33663368225097656,
-0.17776621878147125,
0.19594955444335938,
0.800101637840271,
-0.14163675904273987,
0.9193772673606873,
0.15549756586551666,
-0.556853175163269,
0.48655393719673157,
0.07822702080011368,
0.28453531861305237,
-0.2582330107688904,
0.16656744480133057,
0.3076498806476593,
0.08325867354869843,
-0.3418538272380829,
-0.6294819712638855,
0.7117589712142944,
-0.6020709872245789,
-0.7325530052185059,
-0.5033105611801147,
-0.5432494282722473,
-0.25338730216026306,
0.1139000952243805,
0.14538609981536865,
0.3039190471172333,
-0.5755192637443542,
-0.020737813785672188,
0.4200946092605591,
-0.22924239933490753,
0.3410024642944336,
0.7495172023773193,
-0.06697537750005722,
-0.30555260181427,
0.6875402927398682,
0.010507377795875072,
0.6728570461273193,
0.1976635903120041,
-0.14985984563827515,
0.04693162068724632,
-0.27650710940361023,
0.025970954447984695,
0.49763402342796326,
-0.4666975140571594,
0.10158225148916245,
-0.6405114531517029,
-0.26860469579696655,
-0.5330568552017212,
-0.32586371898651123,
-0.24982506036758423,
-0.47124558687210083,
0.04917610436677933,
0.13221631944179535,
-0.0554666705429554,
0.46670299768447876,
-0.3651737868785858,
0.43540138006210327,
-0.9946774244308472,
0.21555881202220917,
0.207516610622406,
-0.1048591211438179,
-0.1664990335702896,
-0.3347591757774353,
-0.39929670095443726,
0.0683954730629921,
-0.1311771422624588,
-0.8097631931304932,
0.06922724843025208,
0.3592311441898346,
0.7628905773162842,
0.3544914722442627,
0.020391948521137238,
0.6748668551445007,
-0.432622492313385,
0.6922696232795715,
0.325650155544281,
-0.909512996673584,
0.3631219267845154,
-0.5616723895072937,
0.6342220306396484,
0.6459876894950867,
0.4353601038455963,
-1.080879807472229,
-0.6052975058555603,
-0.6661885380744934,
-0.7320520281791687,
0.5010617971420288,
0.20055435597896576,
0.07135651260614395,
-0.2353115826845169,
0.15880334377288818,
0.0626521036028862,
0.10434895753860474,
-0.5649452805519104,
-0.17365293204784393,
0.36767998337745667,
-0.07568363845348358,
0.14218437671661377,
-0.20253632962703705,
-0.6321058869361877,
-0.09449400752782822,
0.31469517946243286,
-0.1983651965856552,
0.3718615770339966,
-0.10418399423360825,
-0.22542791068553925,
-0.1930598020553589,
0.17581962049007416,
0.3999834954738617,
0.32408979535102844,
-0.026793304830789566,
0.10667683929204941,
0.026109425351023674,
-0.09424638748168945,
-0.03604843467473984,
0.08246616274118423,
0.06556478142738342,
0.3680116832256317,
0.4546511173248291,
0.5835995078086853,
0.5648738145828247,
-0.5803986191749573,
0.5775020122528076,
-0.11171077191829681,
-0.10933611541986465,
-0.24638135731220245,
-0.13537292182445526,
0.10627194494009018,
0.33072584867477417,
-0.14934243261814117,
-0.09165912866592407,
0.05429387837648392,
-0.8837263584136963,
0.8747389316558838,
0.573207437992096,
-0.2701115906238556,
-0.3174680471420288,
0.0406336672604084,
0.5187855362892151,
-0.532272219657898,
0.5119691491127014,
-0.11689002066850662,
-0.6174437999725342,
0.22144222259521484,
0.250375360250473,
0.9398451447486877,
-0.27333641052246094,
0.13659293949604034,
0.3215917646884918,
-0.08998775482177734,
0.19381514191627502,
-0.07571075856685638,
-0.7828088402748108,
-1.320747971534729,
-0.3136594891548157,
-0.36912479996681213,
-0.5108626484870911,
-0.585811197757721,
-0.9395799040794373,
0.30944401025772095,
-0.022334082052111626,
-0.24163849651813507,
0.19713054597377777,
-0.09109770506620407,
-0.37552982568740845,
-0.24619588255882263,
0.4695243835449219,
0.5266613364219666,
-0.9186971783638,
0.7874835133552551,
0.2664750814437866,
-0.08179185539484024,
-0.431973397731781,
0.057545777410268784,
0.5359120965003967,
-0.9388794302940369,
0.5187504887580872,
0.17725065350532532,
-0.6094874739646912,
-0.22077861428260803,
-0.1827867329120636,
-0.8353450894355774,
0.764054536819458,
0.2643527686595917,
-0.7379807233810425,
-0.22733809053897858,
0.48070791363716125,
0.4010433852672577,
-0.45658087730407715,
0.33778631687164307,
0.9445239901542664,
0.2359319031238556,
0.5092255473136902,
-1.605053424835205,
0.08143384009599686,
-0.2214026153087616,
-0.4877234995365143,
0.6540340781211853,
-0.7999603748321533,
0.3741054832935333,
0.1169695034623146,
-0.5703068971633911,
0.30918508768081665,
0.5187363624572754,
0.001131537719629705,
0.28898319602012634,
0.6036108732223511,
0.721049964427948,
0.5669922828674316,
-0.13638313114643097,
0.3475837707519531,
-0.5834507346153259,
0.41374701261520386,
1.527264952659607,
-0.3055184781551361,
0.7542502880096436,
0.5286438465118408,
0.058786723762750626,
0.7818459868431091,
0.17341789603233337,
-0.0009063982288353145,
0.2136891633272171,
0.038177307695150375,
-0.46523118019104004,
-0.33739134669303894,
-0.5169520974159241,
-0.4019676148891449,
0.39047935605049133,
0.6521469354629517,
-0.22716425359249115,
-0.47269946336746216,
-0.16084131598472595,
-0.04160763695836067,
0.31689703464508057,
0.012605249881744385,
0.9423959255218506,
0.280772864818573,
-0.8860343098640442,
0.6871065497398376,
-0.7134387493133545,
0.5885170102119446,
-0.25209975242614746,
0.22908125817775726,
-0.12965184450149536,
0.07721461355686188,
-0.2409445196390152,
-0.970990777015686,
0.7007843255996704,
-0.2989310026168823,
0.0596492663025856,
-0.35248684883117676,
0.42191416025161743,
-0.8886446952819824,
0.09244424849748611,
0.6142982244491577,
0.5233725309371948,
0.36964109539985657,
0.5404267311096191,
-0.6347973942756653,
0.2712060809135437,
-0.06464356929063797,
0.20162898302078247,
0.2604992985725403,
0.6388697028160095,
-0.08436048775911331,
0.5174990296363831,
0.0630754753947258,
-0.09790228307247162,
0.09628745168447495,
0.28332099318504333,
0.7020507454872131,
-0.6454015970230103,
-0.14747723937034607,
-0.749039888381958,
0.41382402181625366,
-0.3210616409778595,
-0.21293926239013672,
0.8031171560287476,
0.48870202898979187,
1.0872726440429688,
0.3316497504711151,
0.32719743251800537,
-0.01401654165238142,
0.5788437128067017,
-0.16072437167167664,
0.2624559700489044,
-0.49156588315963745,
0.13123172521591187,
-0.4805866777896881,
-0.7081454992294312,
-0.2687470018863678,
0.5734745264053345,
-0.3229464590549469,
-0.24738310277462006,
0.5942702293395996,
0.8611205220222473,
-0.10697045177221298,
0.03580832481384277,
0.2726672887802124,
0.04914151132106781,
0.1025092676281929,
0.6255631446838379,
0.8154162764549255,
-0.22106698155403137,
0.5887521505355835,
0.11516373604536057,
-0.11328362673521042,
-0.14766879379749298,
-0.7046759724617004,
-0.9473556280136108,
-0.6864930987358093,
-0.7184853553771973,
-0.36737126111984253,
0.20772603154182434,
0.9428156018257141,
0.40011343359947205,
-0.8059205412864685,
-0.7101361751556396,
0.1372147500514984,
-0.032292045652866364,
-0.10904407501220703,
-0.2043590545654297,
-0.04778899624943733,
-0.3701663613319397,
-0.9857771396636963,
0.26462650299072266,
0.37641361355781555,
0.10416118800640106,
0.006747331935912371,
-0.15838953852653503,
-0.6022163033485413,
0.1836058348417282,
0.14930802583694458,
0.7035832405090332,
-0.5410114526748657,
-0.333131343126297,
-0.49013346433639526,
-0.0881156399846077,
0.20366455614566803,
1.0112708806991577,
-0.7898613810539246,
0.6384155750274658,
0.6239603161811829,
0.6009275913238525,
0.2957412600517273,
0.2691522240638733,
1.070292592048645,
-0.8662780523300171,
0.38682517409324646,
0.06829080730676651,
0.3121919333934784,
0.47335922718048096,
-0.005391611251980066,
0.38942909240722656,
0.5289583802223206,
-0.5898340940475464,
-0.7980948090553284,
0.5032470226287842,
-1.0650290250778198,
0.0004364674969110638,
0.8548315167427063,
-0.2490086704492569,
-0.024186691269278526,
-0.4253813326358795,
-0.22301726043224335,
0.41723188757896423,
-0.2563660442829132,
0.6953895688056946,
1.059186339378357,
-0.2621343731880188,
-0.1942925751209259,
0.08030400425195694,
0.5652958750724792,
0.5859712958335876,
-0.4250234067440033,
0.05568205565214157,
0.35472992062568665,
0.12642990052700043,
0.7312374711036682,
0.8214623928070068,
0.10664329677820206,
0.15673242509365082,
-0.17191630601882935,
-0.33678439259529114,
0.497564435005188,
-0.1539536416530609,
0.12214849889278412,
0.04796180501580238,
-0.11597280949354172,
-0.21402092278003693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00006v1
|
A Prompt-driven Task Planning Method for Multi-drones based on Large Language Model
| 2024-05-14T12:24:39 | 2024-05-14T12:24:39 |
Yaohua Liu
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the rapid development of drone technology, the application of
multi-drones is becoming increasingly widespread in various fields. However,
the task planning technology for multi-drones still faces challenges such as
the complexity of remote operation and the convenience of human-machine
interaction. To address these issues, this paper proposes a prompt-driven task
planning method for multi-drones based on large language models. By introducing
the Prompt technique, appropriate prompt information is provided for the
multi-drone system.
|
[
-0.6618809700012207,
-0.6566599607467651,
0.514748752117157,
0.4667348563671112,
-0.16908910870552063,
0.271157443523407,
-0.16129940748214722,
-0.18556617200374603,
0.42529505491256714,
0.5328711867332458,
-1.0400536060333252,
-0.23341086506843567,
-0.4132865071296692,
0.2179117500782013,
0.28475305438041687,
0.4636901319026947,
0.21573017537593842,
-0.1629379689693451,
0.5010344386100769,
-0.050811585038900375,
-1.0704764127731323,
-0.9038242101669312,
-0.7079105377197266,
0.4061219096183777,
0.7083306908607483,
0.7965413331985474,
0.561577558517456,
0.391328901052475,
0.29833173751831055,
0.3752255141735077,
-0.1859913170337677,
0.3247542381286621,
0.43964284658432007,
0.5165452361106873,
-0.22700394690036774,
-0.21623441576957703,
-0.2137165069580078,
-0.45635852217674255,
0.5734431743621826,
0.5146681666374207,
-0.03370525315403938,
0.2816842794418335,
-0.19905559718608856,
0.2688648998737335,
-0.633720338344574,
0.20368357002735138,
-0.25610703229904175,
0.17797327041625977,
-0.21735069155693054,
-0.30212926864624023,
-0.36713477969169617,
0.30634409189224243,
-0.21334652602672577,
-0.7545933723449707,
-0.19972500205039978,
0.13386143743991852,
0.28468626737594604,
0.22517168521881104,
-0.6977036595344543,
-0.15586231648921967,
-0.8411393165588379,
0.8594287037849426,
-0.36466479301452637,
0.2408425360918045,
0.31194350123405457,
0.6845597624778748,
-0.48067420721054077,
-0.17616987228393555,
-0.8391185998916626,
-0.5980271100997925,
0.3843146860599518,
-0.16425026953220367,
0.12649381160736084,
0.0940287858247757,
0.6075318455696106,
-0.555624783039093,
-0.4096417725086212,
0.23588624596595764,
-0.11726576089859009,
-0.09806033223867416,
0.2593892812728882,
0.3215816915035248,
0.3746539354324341,
-0.625747561454773,
-0.4087972640991211,
0.2480446994304657,
-0.53037428855896,
0.6233897805213928,
0.4449586868286133,
0.9679722189903259,
-0.22182722389698029,
1.1181987524032593,
-0.7225770950317383,
0.9266820549964905,
0.03706212714314461,
-0.4879609942436218,
0.1335565447807312,
-0.6956791877746582,
-0.20507895946502686,
-0.23204639554023743,
0.4740910530090332,
0.3772381544113159,
0.1780490130186081,
0.36853837966918945,
-0.356332391500473,
-0.15348787605762482,
0.10838913917541504,
-0.5246942043304443,
0.33816632628440857,
0.465287983417511,
-0.43046391010284424,
-0.005954153370112181,
-0.2262112945318222,
-0.9876258373260498,
-0.5537216663360596,
-0.3388915956020355,
0.11999566853046417,
-0.1441422998905182,
-0.5905142426490784,
0.022544635459780693,
-0.14521129429340363,
-0.06226355955004692,
0.3764245808124542,
-0.6806140542030334,
0.14786137640476227,
0.4663917124271393,
0.9815870523452759,
0.4152536392211914,
-0.6937769651412964,
-1.1592369079589844,
0.2801089286804199,
-0.21379494667053223,
0.7525873184204102,
-0.510762095451355,
-0.39247366786003113,
0.39434677362442017,
0.04732746258378029,
0.26397696137428284,
0.1284332573413849,
0.6014536023139954,
-0.4282732307910919,
0.04871121421456337,
-0.6873526573181152,
-0.013473966158926487,
-0.597442626953125,
0.500143826007843,
-0.7257880568504333,
0.8146128058433533,
-0.03391197323799133,
-0.6828758716583252,
0.3865526616573334,
-0.9222754836082458,
-0.5227781534194946,
0.362722247838974,
-0.24989089369773865,
-0.07214458286762238,
-0.48310714960098267,
0.49468204379081726,
0.9192752838134766,
-0.3858487904071808,
0.7430531978607178,
0.003563622711226344,
-0.07625433057546616,
-0.01507582701742649,
0.11808055639266968,
1.1545356512069702,
0.288752943277359,
-0.4359053671360016,
0.6394064426422119,
-0.4036727249622345,
-0.28283318877220154,
-0.11932653933763504,
-0.3778027296066284,
-0.0035024816170334816,
0.2894812524318695,
0.08126518130302429,
0.6057977080345154,
0.23140385746955872,
-0.39837002754211426,
0.697341799736023,
-0.2358412891626358,
0.2604122459888458,
0.5829468965530396,
0.15941475331783295,
0.45257285237312317,
-0.5077140927314758,
1.152956247329712,
-0.11848177760839462,
0.33048808574676514,
-0.6727105975151062,
-0.49981093406677246,
-0.29007017612457275,
-0.47958266735076904,
-0.2843684256076813,
0.5703423023223877,
-1.0991442203521729,
0.7353522777557373,
0.16940541565418243,
-0.5897419452667236,
0.21997198462486267,
-0.21931304037570953,
0.2749112844467163,
0.12201239913702011,
0.3876909017562866,
0.1762741208076477,
-0.533416211605072,
-0.5011449456214905,
0.12901264429092407,
-0.02406107634305954,
0.3331162929534912,
0.16430765390396118,
0.5182593464851379,
0.01149151660501957,
0.5884060859680176,
-0.4246101379394531,
-0.21223826706409454,
-0.6088876128196716,
0.15174120664596558,
0.16474220156669617,
0.3770577013492584,
0.8120269775390625,
-1.1288586854934692,
-0.11535795778036118,
-0.1330733299255371,
-0.38780805468559265,
0.23960961401462555,
-0.48259180784225464,
0.030182674527168274,
0.24790841341018677,
0.31993210315704346,
-1.2800740003585815,
0.1595948040485382,
0.32005205750465393,
-0.3967067003250122,
1.0209523439407349,
0.06220803037285805,
0.4646713435649872,
-1.3815910816192627,
0.11524590104818344,
0.11637364327907562,
0.0874929204583168,
-0.5829824805259705,
0.5880140066146851,
-0.12021387368440628,
-0.3239555358886719,
-0.5362744331359863,
0.5499770641326904,
-0.6220470666885376,
-0.21925438940525055,
-0.3739811182022095,
-0.30242741107940674,
-0.27686807513237,
0.6340805292129517,
-0.12689797580242157,
0.9247859716415405,
1.0244593620300293,
-0.9707449674606323,
0.7751988768577576,
0.3259942829608917,
-0.11701115220785141,
0.5430085062980652,
-0.4289207458496094,
-0.1691049486398697,
-0.1979570984840393,
0.524808943271637,
-1.0301495790481567,
-0.4200286567211151,
0.6497322916984558,
-0.41675469279289246,
-0.07450245320796967,
-0.4851921796798706,
-0.4423538148403168,
-0.7095203995704651,
-0.3471156656742096,
0.5161701440811157,
0.19047358632087708,
-0.48095405101776123,
0.9127870202064514,
0.23028682172298431,
-0.6391920447349548,
-1.0096994638442993,
0.027960607782006264,
0.28179293870925903,
-0.3952641189098358,
-0.39507126808166504,
0.14255079627037048,
-0.24647432565689087,
-0.2156984806060791,
-0.39233991503715515,
0.18370652198791504,
-0.20347556471824646,
-0.056997958570718765,
0.5437485575675964,
0.2665504813194275,
0.1396254599094391,
0.3707881569862366,
-0.10997029393911362,
0.007785214576870203,
-0.01607264205813408,
-0.2720276713371277,
0.8736171126365662,
0.5109952688217163,
-0.08087429404258728,
-0.5485825538635254,
0.8698639273643494,
0.8533884882926941,
-0.7724420428276062,
0.4385927617549896,
0.18352735042572021,
-0.5992594361305237,
-0.17578324675559998,
-0.4822555482387543,
0.052290335297584534,
-0.515610933303833,
0.30898717045783997,
-0.9199258685112,
-0.4159766733646393,
0.4397439956665039,
-0.40505701303482056,
0.15265119075775146,
0.32245466113090515,
0.5224457383155823,
0.2165551632642746,
0.9790182709693909,
0.9166199564933777,
-0.049496740102767944,
0.7457363605499268,
-0.06665009260177612,
-0.16554249823093414,
-0.48059847950935364,
-0.5439260601997375,
-1.1991748809814453,
0.10117918252944946,
-0.0012764063430950046,
-0.5125610828399658,
0.1646859496831894,
-0.03842407837510109,
-0.7281957864761353,
0.2915509343147278,
-0.5727458000183105,
0.043992914259433746,
0.6710643172264099,
-0.2128005027770996,
0.023596417158842087,
-0.1678715944290161,
-0.14117050170898438,
0.3798028826713562,
-0.6250054836273193,
-0.26352357864379883,
0.7449674606323242,
-0.2290520966053009,
0.3007940649986267,
0.021966030821204185,
0.3247883915901184,
0.2543637156486511,
-0.5955480933189392,
-0.9743871688842773,
0.7357503771781921,
0.35731270909309387,
-0.5863702893257141,
-0.5344722867012024,
-0.1992747038602829,
-1.0609829425811768,
0.06372757256031036,
-0.3518854081630707,
-0.6602796316146851,
0.04439481720328331,
-0.14953400194644928,
-0.5510609149932861,
0.22293724119663239,
-0.5321758985519409,
0.5460513234138489,
-0.061338748782873154,
0.3424186706542969,
-0.25401750206947327,
-0.6746700406074524,
0.44020774960517883,
-0.2134418785572052,
0.45311859250068665,
-0.33138346672058105,
-0.17680388689041138,
1.1354503631591797,
-0.5555290579795837,
0.6766831278800964,
-0.7050235271453857,
0.1006130576133728,
0.6868210434913635,
0.035911452025175095,
0.7576964497566223,
0.12053222954273224,
-0.0583779439330101,
-0.3125259578227997,
-0.2847922742366791,
-0.35318318009376526,
-0.3034457266330719,
0.5509607791900635,
-0.5952434539794922,
-0.4256739318370819,
-0.4238184094429016,
-0.5222396850585938,
-0.016442304477095604,
0.38308247923851013,
0.19378958642482758,
0.5894286036491394,
0.025253575295209885,
-0.5785086154937744,
-0.13617202639579773,
-0.5153597593307495,
1.008476972579956,
0.37265631556510925,
-0.2647489905357361,
-0.3188050389289856,
0.1936279684305191,
0.4126138985157013,
-0.07392195612192154,
0.41497787833213806,
0.06655443459749222,
-0.3692438006401062,
-0.479021817445755,
-0.8366225957870483,
-0.07444258779287338,
-0.4718252122402191,
-0.6168003678321838,
-0.9093571305274963,
0.36360523104667664,
-0.3650364577770233,
-0.6482634544372559,
-0.13679055869579315,
-0.3625073730945587,
0.03101109154522419,
0.1320650428533554,
0.7288435697555542,
0.742048442363739,
0.14613591134548187,
0.43051910400390625,
-0.7396275401115417,
0.9537057876586914,
0.10534634441137314,
-0.1059279665350914,
0.04106553643941879,
-0.08794429153203964,
0.025408782064914703,
0.09301885217428207,
-0.10206831991672516,
-1.0816401243209839,
0.30739468336105347,
-0.42348578572273254,
0.4951702952384949,
-0.004690094385296106,
0.1979142129421234,
0.44704490900039673,
-0.5119693279266357,
1.062146782875061,
0.5161136388778687,
-1.0313674211502075,
0.6734386682510376,
-0.6639929413795471,
0.40843716263771057,
0.009574837982654572,
0.3676472008228302,
-0.4828238785266876,
-0.007832745090126991,
-0.3743290901184082,
-0.6902182102203369,
0.5956512093544006,
-0.33716869354248047,
0.06952929496765137,
0.13779088854789734,
0.14916135370731354,
0.12849639356136322,
0.3534611165523529,
-0.5840001106262207,
-0.09513138979673386,
-0.08054928481578827,
0.0765882357954979,
-0.21996645629405975,
-0.17771263420581818,
0.09205988049507141,
-0.12315783649682999,
0.3168789744377136,
-0.36446550488471985,
0.4009042978286743,
-0.11371033638715744,
0.33802610635757446,
-0.35371822118759155,
0.5035463571548462,
0.803967297077179,
0.5349836945533752,
0.37823477387428284,
-0.02388441376388073,
0.08210645616054535,
-0.2970147132873535,
0.82088303565979,
0.23589374125003815,
-0.16408245265483856,
-0.2289111614227295,
0.09841098636388779,
0.12242679297924042,
-0.18540142476558685,
-0.6663769483566284,
0.8193562030792236,
0.36063963174819946,
0.07002564519643784,
-0.4186500608921051,
-0.15715979039669037,
0.0849711149930954,
0.5178133845329285,
0.5665866732597351,
0.6219565272331238,
0.14969678223133087,
-0.2839967906475067,
-0.17844581604003906,
0.42703548073768616,
0.16717670857906342,
-0.176161527633667,
0.477699339389801,
0.296695739030838,
-0.6525121331214905,
0.15266339480876923,
-0.6438459157943726,
-0.6583623886108398,
0.9851457476615906,
0.4708045721054077,
0.7721917629241943,
-0.6426142454147339,
0.45331746339797974,
0.5918213129043579,
0.4888676404953003,
-0.44897642731666565,
1.0544935464859009,
0.04619583487510681,
-0.29521822929382324,
-1.1321320533752441,
-0.18932479619979858,
-0.3136214315891266,
-0.30827951431274414,
-0.19260172545909882,
0.6047019362449646,
-0.6474588513374329,
-0.1683746576309204,
0.08349961787462234,
0.2403845638036728,
-0.8970263600349426,
0.31345292925834656,
-0.1841273158788681,
0.9066748023033142,
-0.4041087031364441,
0.6290252208709717,
0.9666733741760254,
-0.48447108268737793,
-1.292616367340088,
0.06238647922873497,
-0.04703474044799805,
-0.4935755729675293,
0.8300296664237976,
0.3068656921386719,
-0.6387592554092407,
-0.04341736435890198,
-0.5344400405883789,
-0.7918833494186401,
0.6128765344619751,
0.13354818522930145,
-0.6525033116340637,
-0.05371906980872154,
-0.5693423748016357,
-0.12109577655792236,
-0.26087310910224915,
0.024126049131155014,
-0.16306841373443604,
0.8390721082687378,
-0.08718013763427734,
-1.0642296075820923,
0.45079636573791504,
-0.04878804460167885,
-0.20588034391403198,
0.4767039120197296,
-0.6667014360427856,
0.9856597781181335,
-0.6834059953689575,
-0.29994529485702515,
0.25259527564048767,
0.5185651183128357,
0.11541195213794708,
0.14882506430149078,
0.74355548620224,
-0.20944048464298248,
0.8865590691566467,
0.5028864145278931,
0.6459406018257141,
0.009078465402126312,
0.10599939525127411,
0.7899199724197388,
-0.5310529470443726,
0.8231359124183655,
0.3045540452003479,
0.061644259840250015,
0.21325083076953888,
0.2662408649921417,
-0.07366936653852463,
0.3587450385093689,
0.15297015011310577,
-0.5098786354064941,
-0.09928163141012192,
-0.5773892402648926,
-0.31042376160621643,
0.6634345054626465,
0.04071880131959915,
0.264847069978714,
-0.1086469441652298,
0.7818034291267395,
0.14655345678329468,
-0.03344056382775307,
-0.698768138885498,
0.5312443375587463,
-0.5027708411216736,
-1.0488948822021484,
0.4127303957939148,
0.46636876463890076,
0.8863603472709656,
-0.5079193115234375,
-0.10359708219766617,
0.40348508954048157,
-0.5339378714561462,
-0.09852239489555359,
-0.605587899684906,
0.022145841270685196,
0.2459789663553238,
-0.10656165331602097,
0.03936319425702095,
0.7419387698173523,
-0.17453603446483612,
-0.3141111433506012,
0.20968188345432281,
0.8010428547859192,
-0.23026399314403534,
-0.34784042835235596,
-0.4230131506919861,
0.05423863232135773,
-0.04589665308594704,
-0.19805097579956055,
-0.07348597049713135,
0.46663981676101685,
0.07731770724058151,
0.9158964157104492,
0.685230016708374,
0.07324312627315521,
-0.0025460137985646725,
-0.20004327595233917,
0.9504384398460388,
-1.203884482383728,
-1.1116880178451538,
-0.8445155024528503,
0.6162287592887878,
0.16648221015930176,
-0.5556492209434509,
0.5268251895904541,
0.23860307037830353,
0.37758946418762207,
-0.2665364742279053,
0.9994881749153137,
-0.22948871552944183,
0.6035595536231995,
-0.5706897377967834,
0.1298353672027588,
-0.23665601015090942,
-0.1533830463886261,
-0.3048926889896393,
-0.9929614663124084,
-0.3246912658214569,
0.4174099564552307,
0.10196978598833084,
0.19246099889278412,
0.6572553515434265,
0.6115544438362122,
0.20917220413684845,
-0.1560622751712799,
0.30763372778892517,
-0.11269640922546387,
0.356711745262146,
0.5931496024131775,
1.1183485984802246,
0.20054012537002563,
0.47804534435272217,
-0.1103394627571106,
-0.37952879071235657,
-0.3791949152946472,
-0.8300511240959167,
-1.0191566944122314,
-0.8820624351501465,
-0.07041403651237488,
0.00096044538076967,
0.016079161316156387,
1.460695743560791,
0.7900481820106506,
-0.04529031366109848,
-0.03843982517719269,
-0.0433042086660862,
-0.04044711962342262,
-0.5305949449539185,
-0.12956252694129944,
0.11794374138116837,
-0.23659123480319977,
-0.4709157645702362,
0.7940496802330017,
0.13106366991996765,
0.20805488526821136,
-0.41525736451148987,
-0.05373489484190941,
-0.3259720802307129,
-0.0841633677482605,
0.5982136726379395,
0.3635621666908264,
-0.8132617473602295,
-0.40001440048217773,
-0.08523913472890854,
-0.07848735898733139,
-0.19492602348327637,
1.0077861547470093,
-0.7860082387924194,
0.1758933961391449,
0.3011196553707123,
0.43838757276535034,
0.11973750591278076,
-0.028753774240612984,
0.5082976222038269,
-0.8279220461845398,
0.588069498538971,
0.20917122066020966,
0.41873225569725037,
0.23366472125053406,
-0.7961940169334412,
0.1058112233877182,
-0.2237422615289688,
-0.6103957891464233,
-0.4805704653263092,
0.6466296911239624,
-1.5520597696304321,
-0.586951494216919,
1.1139426231384277,
-0.09323959052562714,
0.3286217749118805,
-0.49952155351638794,
-1.050938606262207,
0.44366100430488586,
-0.6081364154815674,
0.3805638253688812,
0.6277039051055908,
0.20995447039604187,
-0.22108815610408783,
-0.5366666316986084,
0.4487346410751343,
0.14967870712280273,
-1.0226961374282837,
0.3250989615917206,
0.7504540681838989,
-0.15218734741210938,
0.25204700231552124,
0.9355156421661377,
0.6368392109870911,
0.4596109092235565,
0.17677201330661774,
0.24458296597003937,
-0.23810487985610962,
-0.9737862348556519,
-0.20256032049655914,
0.6291086673736572,
0.2795126140117645,
-0.3928162157535553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08514v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08514v1
|
Falcon 7b for Software Mention Detection in Scholarly Documents
| 2024-05-14T11:37:26 | 2024-05-14T11:37:26 |
AmeerAli Khan, Qusai Ramadan, Cong Yang, Zeyd Boukhers
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DL
|
This paper aims to tackle the challenge posed by the increasing integration
of software tools in research across various disciplines by investigating the
application of Falcon-7b for the detection and classification of software
mentions within scholarly texts. Specifically, the study focuses on solving
Subtask I of the Software Mention Detection in Scholarly Publications (SOMD),
which entails identifying and categorizing software mentions from academic
literature. Through comprehensive experimentation, the paper explores different
training strategies, including a dual-classifier approach, adaptive sampling,
and weighted loss scaling, to enhance detection accuracy while overcoming the
complexities of class imbalance and the nuanced syntax of scholarly writing.
The findings highlight the benefits of selective labelling and adaptive
sampling in improving the model's performance. However, they also indicate that
integrating multiple strategies does not necessarily result in cumulative
improvements. This research offers insights into the effective application of
large language models for specific tasks such as SOMD, underlining the
importance of tailored approaches to address the unique challenges presented by
academic text analysis.
|
[
-0.6565768718719482,
-0.39264678955078125,
0.42853277921676636,
0.17557582259178162,
-0.2856849133968353,
0.2545836269855499,
0.016369754448533058,
-0.47514402866363525,
0.41780829429626465,
0.4493711590766907,
-0.5182451605796814,
-0.5632339119911194,
-0.789432168006897,
0.2976956367492676,
-0.5011650323867798,
1.2337725162506104,
0.08681793510913849,
0.18971778452396393,
-0.03999320790171623,
-0.22695915400981903,
-0.3508710265159607,
-0.22921158373355865,
-0.6389101147651672,
-0.13404710590839386,
0.6578117609024048,
0.4752473533153534,
0.36099773645401,
0.6965387463569641,
1.3508621454238892,
0.23019278049468994,
-0.08205629140138626,
0.14849701523780823,
-0.362155556678772,
0.18066449463367462,
-0.3125463128089905,
-0.5051416754722595,
-0.3948345482349396,
-0.006624862551689148,
0.9373088479042053,
0.468228816986084,
0.07732685655355453,
0.49035412073135376,
-0.14672687649726868,
0.6449421644210815,
-0.7581877112388611,
0.3904803991317749,
-0.6591485142707825,
0.0017850497970357537,
-1.05483877658844,
-0.2757280468940735,
-0.35345935821533203,
0.04887416213750839,
-0.24498820304870605,
-0.9631881713867188,
0.4115118384361267,
0.3123953342437744,
0.6609813570976257,
0.36975276470184326,
0.17309971153736115,
-0.6708916425704956,
-0.37636834383010864,
0.6607859134674072,
-0.7314851880073547,
0.12965618073940277,
0.08417273312807083,
0.302389919757843,
-0.5420079231262207,
-0.815381646156311,
-0.5579807758331299,
-0.261766642332077,
0.21589888632297516,
0.3141268789768219,
-0.07952892035245895,
0.07866790145635605,
0.4019375145435333,
0.28876572847366333,
-0.4483832120895386,
0.0190790556371212,
-0.7731059789657593,
-0.06939671188592911,
0.471018522977829,
-0.03109852783381939,
0.35659870505332947,
-0.14827917516231537,
-0.19683876633644104,
0.12718449532985687,
-0.6038846373558044,
-0.13289789855480194,
0.3951028883457184,
0.3815188407897949,
0.3627225160598755,
0.3727712333202362,
0.09057296067476273,
0.574733555316925,
-0.05365830659866333,
-0.21722650527954102,
0.25679776072502136,
-0.2834215462207794,
-0.14019596576690674,
0.30731645226478577,
0.6699535846710205,
0.29402559995651245,
-0.027296217158436775,
-0.2675013542175293,
-0.050856415182352066,
0.38122764229774475,
0.6262539625167847,
-0.47832635045051575,
-0.17723768949508667,
-0.007384742144495249,
-0.5987030267715454,
-0.35184431076049805,
0.43328917026519775,
-0.5013824701309204,
-0.9237610101699829,
0.0577508769929409,
0.1330297738313675,
-0.275969922542572,
-0.4288376271724701,
-0.029429322108626366,
-0.6046357750892639,
-0.11618508398532867,
0.3739602267742157,
-0.7700353264808655,
0.3714590072631836,
0.9541472792625427,
0.9274399280548096,
-0.37901774048805237,
-0.5912034511566162,
-0.8762689232826233,
0.3900304436683655,
-0.518893837928772,
1.0296616554260254,
-0.8019998669624329,
-0.5264967083930969,
-0.12792488932609558,
0.11519011855125427,
-0.010175291448831558,
-0.8181485533714294,
0.7207736968994141,
-0.54558265209198,
-0.24711082875728607,
-0.6561716198921204,
-0.5640299320220947,
-0.2444906383752823,
0.33335599303245544,
-0.6785052418708801,
1.23443603515625,
0.3989826738834381,
-1.3459036350250244,
0.6085264682769775,
-0.9291324615478516,
-0.30223217606544495,
0.4585298001766205,
-0.2721906304359436,
-0.38185980916023254,
0.17356538772583008,
-0.2865360975265503,
0.39859914779663086,
-0.46663883328437805,
0.23151913285255432,
-0.5511355996131897,
-0.8694393634796143,
-0.044873010367155075,
0.4175339937210083,
0.44388052821159363,
0.41810962557792664,
-0.4726674556732178,
0.38215649127960205,
-0.4466628432273865,
-0.5887330174446106,
-0.14966817200183868,
-0.3161703050136566,
-0.7237897515296936,
-0.16083231568336487,
0.26467788219451904,
-0.27469509840011597,
-0.04090132936835289,
-0.6912898421287537,
0.6183484792709351,
-0.1894947588443756,
0.10643112659454346,
0.2065795212984085,
-0.09333966672420502,
0.6063224673271179,
-0.28987234830856323,
0.7522174715995789,
0.3311481177806854,
0.039384715259075165,
-0.1575278341770172,
-0.34923240542411804,
-0.6476694345474243,
-0.2632543444633484,
0.6600748300552368,
0.3986959457397461,
-1.0038036108016968,
0.017921794205904007,
-0.2505324184894562,
-0.5886409878730774,
-0.7249236702919006,
0.13759490847587585,
0.36225470900535583,
0.4713487923145294,
0.5126213431358337,
-0.2750268876552582,
-0.8238341808319092,
-0.6597582101821899,
-0.5569233894348145,
-0.27022117376327515,
0.07153882086277008,
0.05555379390716553,
0.6413225531578064,
-0.3582594394683838,
0.7302428483963013,
-0.458944171667099,
-0.6540084481239319,
-0.30897247791290283,
0.4689359664916992,
-0.08978278189897537,
0.275579035282135,
0.7994030714035034,
-0.7671427726745605,
-0.5069702863693237,
-0.09535878896713257,
-0.8037800788879395,
-0.48319098353385925,
-0.2562631070613861,
-0.043185655027627945,
0.09719276428222656,
0.9180647134780884,
-0.28891587257385254,
0.24043366312980652,
-0.14764006435871124,
-0.015506569296121597,
0.4501400589942932,
-0.02318429760634899,
0.21754993498325348,
-0.9542980790138245,
0.07646838575601578,
0.3786580562591553,
0.22088129818439484,
-0.4252510666847229,
0.31839877367019653,
0.24315451085567474,
0.24401694536209106,
-0.3054715096950531,
0.5216695666313171,
-0.6543655395507812,
-0.1823916882276535,
-0.6461979150772095,
0.16504773497581482,
-0.3508998155593872,
-0.2624295651912689,
0.06381984800100327,
0.8082924485206604,
0.4171530604362488,
-0.46002089977264404,
0.1723909080028534,
-0.03627060726284981,
-0.1390584409236908,
0.6014325022697449,
-0.3419119417667389,
-0.2652819752693176,
-0.4091627597808838,
0.3262539207935333,
-0.8819109201431274,
-0.038866642862558365,
0.43055886030197144,
-0.5443404912948608,
0.34250813722610474,
-0.2616668939590454,
-0.3578997552394867,
-0.3460802435874939,
-0.5861126184463501,
-0.10155042260885239,
0.1288396716117859,
-0.21845397353172302,
0.6014569401741028,
0.7637044787406921,
-0.21072450280189514,
-0.6214051842689514,
-0.5692876577377319,
0.29644039273262024,
-0.35776418447494507,
-0.46269211173057556,
0.676757276058197,
0.1802533119916916,
-0.30316147208213806,
-0.08652370423078537,
-0.28904131054878235,
0.23201057314872742,
0.2204049974679947,
0.43224090337753296,
0.3211025893688202,
-0.16823726892471313,
0.24998055398464203,
0.16840188205242157,
-0.35061901807785034,
0.06493434309959412,
-0.5100095868110657,
0.13566868007183075,
-0.018326325342059135,
-0.07519847899675369,
0.20832204818725586,
0.3903645873069763,
0.6333428025245667,
-0.22430962324142456,
0.6779791712760925,
1.143082618713379,
-0.24259687960147858,
-0.286866694688797,
-0.5828016996383667,
-0.023612258955836296,
-0.45190176367759705,
0.36084872484207153,
-0.46861812472343445,
-0.7149916887283325,
0.5267199873924255,
-0.2539997100830078,
0.300628125667572,
0.5779359936714172,
0.25148096680641174,
-0.1910126954317093,
0.5150383114814758,
0.5935559272766113,
-0.22706744074821472,
0.5125094652175903,
-0.3608534336090088,
0.033916451036930084,
-1.1606327295303345,
-0.15480270981788635,
-1.0233162641525269,
-0.29889121651649475,
-0.437485009431839,
-0.365172415971756,
0.2805369198322296,
0.005342445801943541,
-0.20056678354740143,
0.2586134374141693,
-0.8504404425621033,
0.27689096331596375,
0.7219008803367615,
-0.28193530440330505,
0.18668897449970245,
-0.01535158883780241,
-0.15880781412124634,
-0.14478513598442078,
-0.600042998790741,
-0.5523800253868103,
0.8581506013870239,
0.3225245475769043,
0.8347426056861877,
0.029219601303339005,
0.9476921558380127,
0.5686489343643188,
0.8261297941207886,
-0.9564669728279114,
0.5835853815078735,
-0.4982253611087799,
-0.5275404453277588,
-0.1422034353017807,
-0.25068801641464233,
-0.7562018632888794,
0.1296287178993225,
-0.15801960229873657,
-0.39824655652046204,
0.06594837456941605,
-0.02325863391160965,
-0.22284339368343353,
0.03517983853816986,
-0.5984970331192017,
0.8627585172653198,
0.2834889888763428,
-0.13566304743289948,
0.16361667215824127,
-0.5978199243545532,
0.15966293215751648,
-0.09796126186847687,
0.5117796659469604,
0.09653270244598389,
-0.10735725611448288,
1.1942695379257202,
-0.08916746079921722,
0.3143194615840912,
-0.4538477659225464,
0.12695705890655518,
0.3642253279685974,
0.013185462914407253,
0.4155484735965729,
-0.14693661034107208,
-0.06532043218612671,
0.09919866174459457,
0.4328354299068451,
-0.24017074704170227,
-0.31959447264671326,
0.8934485912322998,
-0.711516261100769,
-0.5648100972175598,
-0.9743698835372925,
-0.7915579676628113,
0.032702431082725525,
0.42839646339416504,
0.3842160701751709,
0.07343078404664993,
0.2783128321170807,
0.5003563761711121,
0.5077922344207764,
0.05024728924036026,
0.3768545091152191,
0.8327227234840393,
-0.30092012882232666,
-0.23440901935100555,
0.9983101487159729,
0.6305766105651855,
-0.3461373448371887,
0.24414721131324768,
-0.004364208783954382,
-0.33071261644363403,
-0.9605430364608765,
-0.6472817063331604,
0.32553762197494507,
-0.74205482006073,
-0.08988025039434433,
-0.8408938050270081,
-0.04779006540775299,
-0.5082314610481262,
-0.2622697949409485,
-0.05978064984083176,
-0.08972751349210739,
-0.4799879789352417,
-0.004816316533833742,
0.21058085560798645,
0.7113558053970337,
0.3379107713699341,
0.41988733410835266,
-0.8911535143852234,
0.19849663972854614,
-0.6180019378662109,
0.16864828765392303,
0.011404501274228096,
-0.5762602686882019,
-0.37601974606513977,
-0.28620803356170654,
-0.27737241983413696,
-0.8721702694892883,
0.15605707466602325,
0.11416004598140717,
0.7596226930618286,
0.1791962832212448,
0.3057814836502075,
0.5882143378257751,
-0.33852070569992065,
0.7206104397773743,
0.07408612966537476,
-0.6976751685142517,
0.3740670680999756,
-0.5505675077438354,
0.5262547731399536,
0.8625305891036987,
0.6477311849594116,
-0.45237696170806885,
-0.5190425515174866,
-0.5271259546279907,
-0.5974501967430115,
0.7163968682289124,
-0.12733067572116852,
-0.1767088621854782,
-0.020070770755410194,
0.530989944934845,
-0.05713990330696106,
0.3129369616508484,
-0.43891268968582153,
-0.06407485902309418,
-0.09992671012878418,
-0.404458224773407,
0.08363336324691772,
-0.15910616517066956,
-0.024712592363357544,
-0.012177535332739353,
1.0073401927947998,
-0.3010684847831726,
-0.08965301513671875,
0.04794147610664368,
-0.16373054683208466,
0.09080632030963898,
0.13615994155406952,
0.6166485548019409,
0.5324442386627197,
-0.1365087479352951,
0.3802165687084198,
-0.06879658997058868,
-1.1730573177337646,
-0.15172626078128815,
0.08643225580453873,
-0.4472712576389313,
0.15933266282081604,
0.3295722007751465,
0.16359728574752808,
0.08588430285453796,
-0.3165491223335266,
0.14537546038627625,
0.07584382593631744,
-0.23548351228237152,
-0.05646553263068199,
0.44858503341674805,
0.32622790336608887,
0.2730448246002197,
0.6499408483505249,
0.1993216574192047,
0.7618024349212646,
-0.5715417861938477,
-0.012576691806316376,
0.4509172737598419,
-0.5676923394203186,
0.026917487382888794,
0.48642483353614807,
-0.010740210302174091,
-0.2428838461637497,
0.23990249633789062,
-0.46667736768722534,
-0.47643035650253296,
0.7751500010490417,
0.5726355910301208,
0.6975032687187195,
0.05599936470389366,
0.2992668151855469,
0.06943309307098389,
0.48870548605918884,
-0.27228066325187683,
0.3520464301109314,
-0.04101745784282684,
-0.34182918071746826,
0.029337720945477486,
-0.7917242646217346,
-0.5197100043296814,
-0.03473477438092232,
-0.5277502536773682,
0.46636688709259033,
-0.5388967990875244,
-0.5574134588241577,
0.8087562322616577,
0.18634803593158722,
-0.011491011828184128,
0.05600133538246155,
-0.12092246115207672,
1.1122597455978394,
-0.8210899829864502,
0.7963142991065979,
1.1953014135360718,
-0.6864289045333862,
-0.8293504118919373,
-0.04059184342622757,
0.13118202984333038,
-0.001600224175490439,
0.6990713477134705,
0.11681858450174332,
-0.31574055552482605,
0.00977554265409708,
-0.3584325313568115,
-0.5895718932151794,
0.8392507433891296,
0.3380751311779022,
-0.42385241389274597,
0.24557645618915558,
-0.20393626391887665,
0.5079826712608337,
-0.3980458676815033,
0.4602959454059601,
0.48330292105674744,
0.6332923173904419,
0.5009403824806213,
-0.8641728162765503,
-0.08191516995429993,
-0.628227949142456,
0.18343918025493622,
0.4565620720386505,
-0.7414807081222534,
0.7964507341384888,
0.14593231678009033,
0.02228069305419922,
-0.276583194732666,
0.7164692878723145,
0.5490400791168213,
0.8346574902534485,
0.38775843381881714,
0.22127865254878998,
0.7058330178260803,
-0.24664902687072754,
0.6771970987319946,
-0.18499448895454407,
0.29432523250579834,
0.9615510702133179,
-0.4300495684146881,
0.637671947479248,
0.5988091826438904,
-0.27700135111808777,
0.36900874972343445,
0.9491824507713318,
-0.35663342475891113,
0.3733988404273987,
0.43259111046791077,
-0.24254731833934784,
0.1198657676577568,
-0.308308482170105,
-0.7778719067573547,
0.15951769053936005,
0.45951947569847107,
-0.3761570155620575,
-0.1812622994184494,
0.2271106094121933,
0.2737857699394226,
-0.002572727855294943,
-0.4967387914657593,
0.7077246904373169,
0.05715109407901764,
-0.9522303342819214,
0.2806338965892792,
0.35537660121917725,
0.8848602771759033,
-0.6590449213981628,
-0.007464519701898098,
-0.11627384275197983,
0.33200952410697937,
-0.6208333969116211,
-0.43996748328208923,
0.5574169158935547,
0.0202957596629858,
-0.5750479698181152,
0.16453328728675842,
1.0298593044281006,
-0.1552099883556366,
-0.6045979261398315,
0.14969655871391296,
-0.0479021780192852,
0.3214716911315918,
-0.18133684992790222,
-0.5799584984779358,
0.49034181237220764,
-0.3013022840023041,
0.1474318653345108,
0.5753306746482849,
0.26870784163475037,
-0.26038599014282227,
0.6030405163764954,
0.6735199689865112,
0.2172122746706009,
0.00881460402160883,
0.1404043734073639,
0.9703745245933533,
-0.37650439143180847,
-0.7862879037857056,
-0.6825408935546875,
0.1496790498495102,
-0.23034662008285522,
-0.12128884345293045,
1.0995553731918335,
0.7628989219665527,
0.7311239838600159,
-0.33363184332847595,
1.000680685043335,
0.07873862981796265,
0.6310110092163086,
-0.11022935062646866,
0.8549638986587524,
-0.5166976451873779,
0.6163312792778015,
-0.5908896923065186,
-0.8839749693870544,
-0.5214519500732422,
0.7360298037528992,
-0.4426022469997406,
0.04247215390205383,
0.8578060269355774,
0.75403892993927,
-0.12961065769195557,
0.3036470115184784,
-0.042508095502853394,
-0.040615472942590714,
0.38484030961990356,
-0.1363925188779831,
0.5752190947532654,
-0.43335258960723877,
0.30204537510871887,
0.3451468348503113,
-0.29851973056793213,
-0.38929983973503113,
-0.847724199295044,
-0.8820600509643555,
-0.5045209527015686,
-0.48874035477638245,
-0.464303195476532,
0.2064925879240036,
0.6753450036048889,
0.4167148470878601,
-0.9107927083969116,
-0.24173597991466522,
-0.06669802963733673,
-0.0004987320280633867,
-0.17834022641181946,
-0.22238647937774658,
0.2777167558670044,
-0.5624773502349854,
-0.4741622805595398,
0.24158620834350586,
0.6998555064201355,
-0.31427866220474243,
-0.562016487121582,
0.11839929968118668,
-0.4532688856124878,
-0.03595488518476486,
0.31474176049232483,
0.15749023854732513,
-0.5598822832107544,
0.03952491283416748,
0.4116547405719757,
-0.14873673021793365,
-0.26652079820632935,
0.8474053740501404,
-0.6354795098304749,
0.5021611452102661,
0.6476714015007019,
0.7271934747695923,
0.5426524877548218,
-0.010556057095527649,
0.15382914245128632,
-0.27070721983909607,
-0.06972593814134598,
0.08179479837417603,
0.24020259082317352,
0.3234825134277344,
-0.3399355411529541,
0.7620678544044495,
0.4719271957874298,
-0.4776321053504944,
-1.1498315334320068,
-0.29866164922714233,
-1.0356271266937256,
-0.34473755955696106,
1.054870367050171,
-0.4468090832233429,
-0.27994683384895325,
-0.5538333058357239,
-0.6002060770988464,
0.18684172630310059,
-0.40427166223526,
0.9008733034133911,
0.8312476873397827,
0.08275091648101807,
-0.19725991785526276,
-0.5792897939682007,
0.5917129516601562,
0.06002533808350563,
-0.8261889815330505,
-0.21925362944602966,
0.35583484172821045,
0.29787540435791016,
0.5289810299873352,
0.8478823900222778,
-0.02816462330520153,
0.45239153504371643,
0.2529796063899994,
-0.06347601860761642,
-0.400315523147583,
-0.4818313717842102,
0.11508350074291229,
0.5759879350662231,
0.15795952081680298,
-0.1469116508960724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08502v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08502v1
|
Archimedes-AUEB at SemEval-2024 Task 5: LLM explains Civil Procedure
| 2024-05-14T11:04:16 | 2024-05-14T11:04:16 |
Odysseas S. Chlapanis, Ion Androutsopoulos, Dimitrios Galanis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The SemEval task on Argument Reasoning in Civil Procedure is challenging in
that it requires understanding legal concepts and inferring complex arguments.
Currently, most Large Language Models (LLM) excelling in the legal realm are
principally purposed for classification tasks, hence their reasoning rationale
is subject to contention. The approach we advocate involves using a powerful
teacher-LLM (ChatGPT) to extend the training dataset with explanations and
generate synthetic data. The resulting data are then leveraged to fine-tune a
small student-LLM. Contrary to previous work, our explanations are not directly
derived from the teacher's internal knowledge. Instead they are grounded in
authentic human analyses, therefore delivering a superior reasoning signal.
Additionally, a new `mutation' method generates artificial data instances
inspired from existing ones. We are publicly releasing the explanations as an
extension to the original dataset, along with the synthetic dataset and the
prompts that were used to generate both. Our system ranked 15th in the SemEval
competition. It outperforms its own teacher and can produce explanations
aligned with the original human analyses, as verified by legal experts.
|
[
-0.359389990568161,
-0.5443518757820129,
0.9223081469535828,
-0.14485473930835724,
-0.549034833908081,
-0.11254867911338806,
-0.07290659099817276,
-0.22633203864097595,
-0.1998632252216339,
0.7231055498123169,
-0.3538757264614105,
-0.4143449068069458,
-0.551132321357727,
0.19747744500637054,
-0.5036191940307617,
0.7949358820915222,
-0.09972357004880905,
0.6182851791381836,
-0.38785070180892944,
-0.1700322926044464,
-0.2887803018093109,
-0.5633305311203003,
-0.6878697872161865,
-0.45611125230789185,
0.5307698249816895,
0.6635490655899048,
0.37000709772109985,
0.9512001276016235,
0.4049491882324219,
0.34835320711135864,
-0.2270493358373642,
-0.057293567806482315,
-0.36476069688796997,
0.18555201590061188,
-0.46157655119895935,
-0.700072705745697,
-0.2777235209941864,
-0.06658758223056793,
0.24829985201358795,
0.7773332595825195,
-0.16078174114227295,
-0.1744467318058014,
-0.10803661495447159,
0.5666664838790894,
-0.18942837417125702,
0.06865356117486954,
-0.5761420130729675,
0.20946620404720306,
-0.33800551295280457,
-0.5525060296058655,
-0.3097262382507324,
-0.5094925165176392,
0.1211320012807846,
-0.2551601231098175,
0.4633775055408478,
0.09488549083471298,
0.8216806650161743,
0.35253027081489563,
-0.725667417049408,
-0.3249894976615906,
-0.7454325556755066,
0.25659051537513733,
-0.685406506061554,
0.15276901423931122,
-0.0005457408260554075,
0.6775810718536377,
-0.2763892412185669,
-1.007148027420044,
-0.4228556156158447,
-0.11046451330184937,
0.3346324861049652,
0.18516062200069427,
0.02667301520705223,
0.25403186678886414,
0.4071956276893616,
0.528389036655426,
-0.6167342662811279,
0.09430127590894699,
-0.8164857029914856,
-0.299257755279541,
0.6666519045829773,
0.20195117592811584,
0.1530955731868744,
0.10548724234104156,
-0.34817859530448914,
0.15064971148967743,
-1.1349247694015503,
0.022939886897802353,
0.4578985571861267,
-0.0524434968829155,
0.07313735783100128,
0.5236829519271851,
0.010690870694816113,
0.3742409944534302,
0.046797771006822586,
0.2578214108943939,
-0.052835818380117416,
0.08095887303352356,
-0.24180351197719574,
0.3513467311859131,
0.46911612153053284,
0.03912797197699547,
0.2259623259305954,
-0.05096616595983505,
-0.18920493125915527,
0.3150995969772339,
0.11845332384109497,
-0.8262428045272827,
-0.2860426902770996,
0.1879246085882187,
-0.3957434594631195,
-0.46787503361701965,
0.007210767362266779,
-0.759655237197876,
-0.5829011797904968,
-0.6139183640480042,
0.3798893988132477,
-0.1471574604511261,
0.13062630593776703,
0.4657335877418518,
-0.02792995609343052,
0.20067353546619415,
0.6708922386169434,
-0.7272040247917175,
0.27693942189216614,
0.7534421682357788,
0.2706543803215027,
0.012406055815517902,
-0.18237057328224182,
-0.5985236167907715,
0.21415679156780243,
-0.4296562671661377,
1.187192678451538,
-0.6939923763275146,
-0.2361225038766861,
-0.10355331003665924,
0.26650023460388184,
0.2510180175304413,
-0.6237146258354187,
1.045619010925293,
-0.3410302996635437,
0.4540365934371948,
-0.37214234471321106,
-0.7009878754615784,
-0.4568620026111603,
0.03479703515768051,
-0.4189910292625427,
0.6730297207832336,
-0.1617458611726761,
-0.38117676973342896,
0.494888037443161,
-0.7429566383361816,
-0.5502188801765442,
0.2682749032974243,
-0.4163290858268738,
-0.5239746570587158,
0.11975903064012527,
0.4164402186870575,
0.4263034760951996,
-0.46780747175216675,
0.43281662464141846,
-0.5108997821807861,
-0.336917519569397,
0.03541961684823036,
-0.3583294749259949,
0.8903219699859619,
0.5010730028152466,
-0.5964221358299255,
0.08171580731868744,
-0.3301418721675873,
-0.4461040794849396,
0.19671346247196198,
-0.4063168168067932,
0.04477404057979584,
0.1095217764377594,
-0.6761724948883057,
0.14330175518989563,
-0.06521177291870117,
-0.42042797803878784,
0.1777951419353485,
-0.5475888252258301,
0.6357489824295044,
1.054912805557251,
0.36236801743507385,
0.4399740993976593,
-0.37007632851600647,
0.8680936694145203,
-0.09328887611627579,
0.04911699518561363,
-0.2811945676803589,
-0.425043523311615,
-0.7016709446907043,
0.004540688823908567,
0.3488894999027252,
0.41728854179382324,
-0.39186760783195496,
-0.36096981167793274,
-0.3670198619365692,
-0.4649915099143982,
-0.3773772120475769,
-0.06929046660661697,
-0.07309725135564804,
0.4821809232234955,
0.05605291202664375,
-0.14095298945903778,
-0.8098393082618713,
-0.8231666088104248,
-0.3359581232070923,
-0.20031236112117767,
0.14746339619159698,
0.5278520584106445,
0.5966983437538147,
-0.05126265808939934,
0.74589604139328,
-0.08057121932506561,
0.11355087161064148,
-0.1309359073638916,
0.24035108089447021,
0.31989073753356934,
0.3571954667568207,
0.4436076283454895,
-0.663696825504303,
-0.004382648039609194,
-0.07603717595338821,
-0.7996649742126465,
-0.6701952219009399,
-0.26166054606437683,
-0.2368716299533844,
0.22933335602283478,
0.7131375670433044,
-0.2056683897972107,
0.28589391708374023,
0.07111760228872299,
-0.4565940499305725,
0.7366832494735718,
-0.02746208757162094,
0.3191913366317749,
-0.9918561577796936,
-0.40660715103149414,
-0.28481194376945496,
-0.35659587383270264,
-0.3150377571582794,
0.3095378577709198,
-0.2665086090564728,
-0.4448578953742981,
-0.5607991814613342,
0.3724278509616852,
-0.5900987982749939,
-0.1337147057056427,
-0.32160133123397827,
0.1865171492099762,
-0.07460483908653259,
0.3258060812950134,
-0.10942813754081726,
0.5725919008255005,
0.793542742729187,
-0.6262932419776917,
0.6783836483955383,
0.04159994050860405,
0.03480594977736473,
0.7844694256782532,
-0.7876920700073242,
0.2369222193956375,
-0.09464862197637558,
0.2501789331436157,
-0.9724917411804199,
-0.3956550061702728,
0.07668352127075195,
-0.5404752492904663,
0.12240676581859589,
-0.590747058391571,
-0.39011910557746887,
-0.5095426440238953,
-0.13553965091705322,
0.19022412598133087,
0.4089694619178772,
-0.6531518697738647,
0.8249173164367676,
0.5316259860992432,
-0.3437257707118988,
-0.37012481689453125,
-0.5722269415855408,
0.3489414155483246,
-0.760402262210846,
-1.0055843591690063,
0.08042779564857483,
-0.04935297742486,
-0.30298662185668945,
0.15707890689373016,
-0.2507754862308502,
-0.005030294414609671,
0.2629089653491974,
0.41664522886276245,
0.20191891491413116,
-0.5829542875289917,
0.06879857927560806,
0.21807175874710083,
-0.04877259209752083,
0.6015095114707947,
-0.036342572420835495,
0.4609973728656769,
-0.2638299763202667,
-0.6206914782524109,
-0.2710098326206207,
0.266126811504364,
0.7673941850662231,
-0.06481564044952393,
0.26317715644836426,
0.08273263275623322,
-0.36596813797950745,
-0.3077020049095154,
-0.608668327331543,
-0.4423040747642517,
-0.48927509784698486,
0.0032148186583071947,
-0.6321592926979065,
-1.065061092376709,
0.5641017556190491,
-0.5879780650138855,
0.28883397579193115,
0.35146602988243103,
0.7870535254478455,
-0.05628134682774544,
1.0977338552474976,
-0.06132790073752403,
-0.01823575235903263,
0.011014245450496674,
-0.1129424050450325,
0.21013586223125458,
-0.5364895462989807,
-0.197831392288208,
-0.8054659962654114,
-0.14128687977790833,
-0.46145376563072205,
-0.4315788745880127,
0.38096359372138977,
-0.10143643617630005,
-0.3847031891345978,
0.188106507062912,
-0.41579270362854004,
0.4615113437175751,
0.4059448540210724,
-0.12592525780200958,
0.16203150153160095,
0.022505879402160645,
-0.29134517908096313,
0.11592889577150345,
-0.6110403537750244,
-0.8020455241203308,
0.9499284625053406,
0.4669337868690491,
0.8025696873664856,
0.242385596036911,
0.9694153666496277,
0.26774895191192627,
0.0037431654054671526,
-0.5449326038360596,
0.8582205176353455,
0.014410736970603466,
-0.7126951217651367,
-0.1982652097940445,
-0.3080138862133026,
-1.1828364133834839,
0.652131199836731,
-0.12244921922683716,
-0.409953236579895,
0.1099696233868599,
0.1885215938091278,
-0.3534858822822571,
0.1375109702348709,
-0.5833455324172974,
0.7522915005683899,
-0.1964920461177826,
-0.5344521403312683,
-0.34983861446380615,
-0.3987800180912018,
0.4196324646472931,
0.2191765159368515,
0.33981361985206604,
-0.06396925449371338,
0.16675782203674316,
0.6021722555160522,
-0.7272197008132935,
0.6323472857475281,
-0.2546238899230957,
-0.1230393797159195,
0.4221208989620209,
0.15775026381015778,
0.6461713910102844,
0.09919719398021698,
-0.11868904531002045,
-0.47338685393333435,
-0.07052013278007507,
-0.35145169496536255,
-0.6942325830459595,
0.5267737507820129,
-0.4533780515193939,
-1.0309370756149292,
-0.4847297966480255,
-0.18557003140449524,
0.03155437484383583,
-0.15846121311187744,
0.06074543297290802,
0.5211626291275024,
0.014699656516313553,
0.4114978313446045,
0.7049009203910828,
-0.09134693443775177,
0.21043938398361206,
0.7564106583595276,
0.036806441843509674,
-0.2037079930305481,
0.8175147175788879,
0.022088048979640007,
-0.23432953655719757,
-0.06903941184282303,
0.5361785888671875,
-0.4489808976650238,
-0.710849404335022,
-0.6185757517814636,
0.22437819838523865,
-0.9049115180969238,
0.08412869274616241,
-0.5253552198410034,
-0.15476547181606293,
-0.4751991033554077,
-0.3508381247520447,
-0.12471189349889755,
-0.5182389616966248,
-0.22921137511730194,
-0.33082669973373413,
-0.007980268448591232,
0.6170772910118103,
-0.09555180370807648,
-0.1261529177427292,
-0.5684882402420044,
0.1396787017583847,
0.4520164132118225,
-0.11070254445075989,
-0.3689482510089874,
-0.9951133131980896,
0.27440258860588074,
-0.17501802742481232,
-0.23728112876415253,
-1.0795278549194336,
0.13122142851352692,
0.05834627151489258,
0.8182896971702576,
0.5442757606506348,
0.010816234163939953,
0.7141616940498352,
-0.5732839703559875,
0.7312435507774353,
-0.4365721046924591,
-0.8076082468032837,
0.9678074717521667,
-0.5081519484519958,
0.02596469223499298,
0.28075069189071655,
0.12242681533098221,
-0.416809618473053,
-0.6402961015701294,
-0.8233558535575867,
-0.9367413520812988,
0.6429218053817749,
0.06963816285133362,
0.13601481914520264,
0.2052120864391327,
0.5019676089286804,
0.16910749673843384,
-0.06830362975597382,
-0.8026614785194397,
0.1476586014032364,
0.052839212119579315,
-0.10544558614492416,
0.45371314883232117,
-0.3884027600288391,
-0.41173163056373596,
-0.24264849722385406,
0.9201759099960327,
-0.1508781611919403,
0.2502949833869934,
0.1339840292930603,
-0.1357019692659378,
-0.13090597093105316,
0.4861513674259186,
0.9343729019165039,
0.795114278793335,
0.3518500030040741,
0.5371423959732056,
0.44878754019737244,
-0.2541894018650055,
0.16417615115642548,
0.24420247972011566,
0.06644503027200699,
-0.08191303163766861,
0.5016323924064636,
0.7690722346305847,
0.10887062549591064,
-0.55427086353302,
0.49751999974250793,
-0.029447389766573906,
-0.6883692741394043,
-0.6623730063438416,
0.16295041143894196,
0.20705078542232513,
0.5986862778663635,
0.2715831696987152,
-0.041988637298345566,
0.30008018016815186,
-0.5827710628509521,
0.40812915563583374,
0.1446741819381714,
-0.15701821446418762,
-0.2939637005329132,
1.0013444423675537,
0.26507332921028137,
-0.14671774208545685,
0.105171337723732,
-0.05562150105834007,
-0.7396824359893799,
0.7391538619995117,
0.46812137961387634,
0.5791958570480347,
-0.2814358174800873,
0.20226572453975677,
0.3056577742099762,
0.2269824892282486,
-0.1991966962814331,
0.5603459477424622,
-0.0404159277677536,
-0.477297306060791,
-0.42149418592453003,
-0.3137231767177582,
-0.5330363512039185,
0.27149009704589844,
-0.35633352398872375,
0.41040870547294617,
-0.27279990911483765,
0.42614075541496277,
0.04439721629023552,
-0.19699817895889282,
-0.3160683512687683,
0.1645413637161255,
0.09251387417316437,
0.7359110713005066,
-1.038188099861145,
0.4484046697616577,
0.8493101596832275,
-0.31217360496520996,
-1.073610544204712,
-0.34610220789909363,
0.41307157278060913,
-0.8966066241264343,
0.515626072883606,
-0.12736459076404572,
-0.10444443672895432,
-0.25854137539863586,
-0.7748676538467407,
-0.4658188819885254,
1.0679426193237305,
0.8410356044769287,
-0.5377586483955383,
0.14787524938583374,
0.16336417198181152,
0.600559651851654,
-0.27034181356430054,
0.04648565873503685,
0.42195919156074524,
0.4466317892074585,
0.5067826509475708,
-0.46752142906188965,
0.06470721960067749,
-0.28954625129699707,
-0.29912978410720825,
0.08028353750705719,
-0.2289973646402359,
0.5850967168807983,
-0.24453215301036835,
-0.20611171424388885,
-0.22256581485271454,
0.689318060874939,
0.35184693336486816,
0.42482587695121765,
0.566245973110199,
0.8221164345741272,
0.7801216840744019,
-0.4260376989841461,
1.0414973497390747,
-0.26154178380966187,
0.20268510282039642,
1.1457393169403076,
-0.29606929421424866,
0.403310090303421,
0.40449783205986023,
-0.08566650003194809,
0.5457050204277039,
1.0088354349136353,
-0.24123424291610718,
0.3026405870914459,
0.39086854457855225,
-0.4996353089809418,
-0.44485709071159363,
-0.02330734208226204,
-0.283233642578125,
0.576594889163971,
0.17447109520435333,
-0.49295610189437866,
-0.3400397002696991,
0.0938582792878151,
0.059554509818553925,
0.05860532447695732,
-0.414762407541275,
0.7775387763977051,
0.18828730285167694,
-0.9317933320999146,
0.2541876435279846,
0.018773434683680534,
-0.10224774479866028,
-0.046413060277700424,
-0.22396577894687653,
-0.2727334499359131,
0.19358012080192566,
-0.175901398062706,
-0.913378119468689,
0.26652398705482483,
0.060369785875082016,
0.30420199036598206,
-0.3108483850955963,
0.8260537981987,
-0.2916441261768341,
-0.15209607779979706,
-0.22555004060268402,
0.32039403915405273,
0.7536136507987976,
0.028436772525310516,
-0.6717286109924316,
-0.11781638115644455,
0.004270258825272322,
-0.2502344846725464,
-0.10658404976129532,
0.9998665452003479,
-0.39828526973724365,
0.678608238697052,
0.4376729726791382,
0.259475439786911,
0.09625975787639618,
0.48987796902656555,
0.8957563042640686,
-0.3525553047657013,
-0.4611127972602844,
-0.9967172145843506,
0.5599491000175476,
-0.03318122774362564,
-0.09846506267786026,
0.37108954787254333,
0.8126034736633301,
0.573490560054779,
-0.015614645555615425,
0.6271317601203918,
0.14426468312740326,
0.5610803961753845,
-0.6488654613494873,
0.26944607496261597,
-0.4873933494091034,
0.46928295493125916,
-0.20961575210094452,
-0.7163951992988586,
0.1085132360458374,
0.736149251461029,
-0.33617401123046875,
-0.0673903077840805,
0.8647462725639343,
0.8296130895614624,
-0.12968780100345612,
0.3711155951023102,
0.2916809618473053,
0.20932534337043762,
0.4956877827644348,
0.6468444466590881,
0.9159514307975769,
-0.08619392663240433,
0.775935173034668,
0.01020450796931982,
-0.038326192647218704,
-0.32430216670036316,
-0.8785544037818909,
-0.8602792024612427,
-0.5685380697250366,
-0.22632203996181488,
-0.2641701102256775,
0.18036450445652008,
0.798831045627594,
0.6733937859535217,
-0.7741190195083618,
-0.12157577276229858,
-0.4015730917453766,
0.03549347445368767,
0.13530293107032776,
-0.25561580061912537,
0.2227412611246109,
-0.19721974432468414,
-0.7625113725662231,
0.4982861578464508,
0.3195499777793884,
0.09127754718065262,
-0.15876786410808563,
-0.1855393350124359,
0.05417754873633385,
0.3281421661376953,
0.42755943536758423,
0.26610249280929565,
-0.8354213833808899,
-0.5750463604927063,
-0.144785538315773,
0.09406077116727829,
0.13552270829677582,
0.979894757270813,
-0.48698893189430237,
0.4620533287525177,
0.5958307385444641,
0.9454100131988525,
0.6264446973800659,
0.08992361277341843,
0.8624981045722961,
-0.289933443069458,
-0.07445169240236282,
0.6042406558990479,
0.8330223560333252,
0.10582214593887329,
-0.3208588659763336,
1.025604486465454,
0.37294793128967285,
-0.8329638838768005,
-0.9099760055541992,
0.28734222054481506,
-0.8552963137626648,
-0.28308507800102234,
0.9911587238311768,
-0.2788001000881195,
-0.32407012581825256,
-0.2424544095993042,
-0.41559037566185,
0.2554927468299866,
-0.2869535982608795,
0.9655638337135315,
0.8701493740081787,
-0.36824366450309753,
-0.6437298059463501,
-0.6476985812187195,
0.3406151235103607,
0.6675440669059753,
-1.1416096687316895,
-0.2658606171607971,
0.7507798671722412,
0.40095219016075134,
-0.22234150767326355,
0.5676528215408325,
-0.4862850606441498,
0.7169374823570251,
-0.13607917726039886,
-0.1705661565065384,
-0.13078080117702484,
-0.2358933389186859,
-0.40778329968452454,
0.40511056780815125,
0.0427878238260746,
-0.02639857493340969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08497v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08497v1
|
Is Less More? Quality, Quantity and Context in Idiom Processing with Natural Language Models
| 2024-05-14T10:54:20 | 2024-05-14T10:54:20 |
Agne Knietaite, Adam Allsebrook, Anton Minkov, Adam Tomaszewski, Norbert Slinko, Richard Johnson, Thomas Pickard, Dylan Phelps, Aline Villavicencio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Compositionality in language models presents a problem when processing
idiomatic expressions, as their meaning often cannot be directly derived from
their individual parts. Although fine-tuning and other optimization strategies
can be used to improve representations of idiomatic expressions, this depends
on the availability of relevant data. We present the Noun Compound Synonym
Substitution in Books - NCSSB - datasets, which are created by substitution of
synonyms of potentially idiomatic English noun compounds in public domain book
texts. We explore the trade-off between data quantity and quality when training
models for idiomaticity detection, in conjunction with contextual information
obtained locally (from the surrounding sentences) or externally (through
language resources). Performance on an idiomaticity detection task indicates
that dataset quality is a stronger factor for context-enriched models, but that
quantity also plays a role in models without context inclusion strategies.
|
[
-0.5092728734016418,
-0.5535557866096497,
0.3461224436759949,
0.11464063823223114,
-0.6112329363822937,
0.14628362655639648,
-0.19325612485408783,
-0.5239637494087219,
0.005589579232037067,
0.2970269024372101,
-0.38114866614341736,
-0.31102848052978516,
-0.5873972773551941,
0.3337181508541107,
-0.43372660875320435,
0.8188880085945129,
-0.2496015429496765,
0.411924809217453,
-0.7289565801620483,
-0.46230587363243103,
-0.5561640858650208,
-0.6479853391647339,
-0.3384033441543579,
-0.5309417843818665,
0.3397384285926819,
0.2892807722091675,
0.7220792174339294,
0.8424227833747864,
0.5716937780380249,
0.19621261954307556,
-0.2819131314754486,
0.19894124567508698,
-0.34913429617881775,
0.14807133376598358,
-0.22741080820560455,
-0.1837729513645172,
-0.08537381142377853,
0.27765509486198425,
0.7866103649139404,
0.9671993255615234,
0.002778357360512018,
0.01986965537071228,
0.0007622326374985278,
0.7741400003433228,
-0.534247875213623,
0.23050619661808014,
-0.581268846988678,
-0.16903023421764374,
-0.03966023772954941,
0.046749673783779144,
-0.09824834018945694,
-0.2486414611339569,
0.1374262273311615,
-0.601054310798645,
0.15520235896110535,
0.015125362202525139,
1.063050389289856,
0.17580313980579376,
-0.3880343437194824,
-0.44762516021728516,
-0.4237833619117737,
0.9384863972663879,
-0.802091121673584,
0.25458166003227234,
0.4506519138813019,
-0.03897497430443764,
-0.14790260791778564,
-0.3764953315258026,
-0.7822824120521545,
-0.2272268682718277,
-0.44417813420295715,
-0.1281423717737198,
-0.19537894427776337,
0.09825028479099274,
0.1538173407316208,
0.6273776888847351,
-0.4104991853237152,
0.08168277144432068,
-0.2896978259086609,
0.08362974226474762,
0.6259809136390686,
0.37166735529899597,
0.08573409914970398,
-0.47229331731796265,
-0.29164546728134155,
-0.15157103538513184,
-0.806860089302063,
0.33807599544525146,
0.503147304058075,
0.6639882326126099,
-0.18121257424354553,
0.5018370747566223,
-0.522242546081543,
0.9789642095565796,
-0.30273687839508057,
-0.2981499433517456,
0.14870259165763855,
-0.7713475227355957,
-0.09614754468202591,
-0.11908084899187088,
0.3183734714984894,
0.2617218792438507,
-0.21720241010189056,
-0.09220276772975922,
-0.3786849081516266,
0.2989612817764282,
-0.2749411165714264,
-0.7086907625198364,
-0.32906612753868103,
0.2062370479106903,
-0.32214245200157166,
-0.07155762612819672,
0.29532548785209656,
-0.17340296506881714,
-0.1939670294523239,
-0.9616459608078003,
0.18369728326797485,
-0.3916606307029724,
-0.03782637044787407,
0.25960293412208557,
-0.5516226887702942,
0.24915489554405212,
0.17927950620651245,
-0.6313296556472778,
0.567633330821991,
0.7399959564208984,
1.047073483467102,
-0.31808948516845703,
-0.04468974843621254,
-0.5021910071372986,
0.09196896851062775,
-0.5061550140380859,
0.983760416507721,
-0.6363609433174133,
-0.5717349052429199,
-0.21130694448947906,
-0.008561828173696995,
0.16792407631874084,
-0.901797354221344,
0.5486915707588196,
-0.2847428321838379,
0.3436538875102997,
-0.6611261963844299,
-1.0360103845596313,
-0.24313867092132568,
0.18593241274356842,
-0.7815688848495483,
1.128712773323059,
0.43013522028923035,
-0.4892371892929077,
0.6378462314605713,
-0.5590240955352783,
-0.7560643553733826,
0.12616819143295288,
-0.01905796118080616,
-0.103298619389534,
0.42960500717163086,
0.11842168867588043,
0.42070865631103516,
-0.45666858553886414,
0.28517377376556396,
-0.18545092642307281,
-0.41959303617477417,
0.4696798324584961,
-0.3141857087612152,
0.518818199634552,
0.016642997041344643,
0.19241176545619965,
-0.3434472978115082,
-0.7964291572570801,
0.00010748855129349977,
-0.0596369169652462,
-0.5577462911605835,
-0.7797612547874451,
0.1373605579137802,
0.3095730245113373,
0.2411070168018341,
0.16843090951442719,
-0.5005194544792175,
0.23201295733451843,
-0.5611577033996582,
0.3466021716594696,
0.4053953289985657,
0.0490022674202919,
0.6030393838882446,
-0.606757640838623,
0.34300696849823,
0.26859959959983826,
-0.0614381842315197,
0.02406785450875759,
-0.36781051754951477,
-0.4725426137447357,
-0.45574331283569336,
0.3371920585632324,
0.2583179771900177,
-0.6562771201133728,
0.25897765159606934,
-0.4171178340911865,
-0.3485294282436371,
-0.36553025245666504,
0.38059669733047485,
0.3423755466938019,
0.3757456839084625,
0.2264528125524521,
-0.2326691895723343,
-0.4004151225090027,
-0.876518964767456,
-0.42321041226387024,
0.17849759757518768,
0.10115554183721542,
0.008413477800786495,
0.636690080165863,
0.06545235216617584,
1.1548720598220825,
-0.4963216185569763,
-0.38218870759010315,
-0.29910531640052795,
0.35239318013191223,
0.4677956700325012,
0.44878435134887695,
0.5772206783294678,
-0.9859745502471924,
-0.5075715780258179,
-0.062334541231393814,
-0.4215966761112213,
0.0388949029147625,
0.00619897386059165,
0.030696090310811996,
0.3009493947029114,
0.40545615553855896,
-0.4895544648170471,
0.2696835696697235,
0.485025554895401,
-0.09149758517742157,
0.3063303530216217,
0.022003410384058952,
-0.05599942430853844,
-0.9775087237358093,
-0.024586765095591545,
0.0370631106197834,
-0.03263905271887779,
-0.6462334394454956,
0.2317926436662674,
-0.10880903899669647,
0.1005733534693718,
-0.4261617660522461,
0.9998511672019958,
-0.5482162833213806,
-0.09809556603431702,
-0.3417361378669739,
0.2879447042942047,
0.4631352424621582,
0.15586496889591217,
0.10871873795986176,
0.986245334148407,
0.4944729208946228,
-0.8447794914245605,
0.5523807406425476,
0.2688976526260376,
-0.7040020227432251,
0.920552670955658,
-0.534571647644043,
-0.27821996808052063,
-0.2942286729812622,
0.017837408930063248,
-0.8032437562942505,
-0.5218223333358765,
0.10235510766506195,
-0.12458886951208115,
0.15123498439788818,
-0.12708623707294464,
-0.953213632106781,
-0.10589348524808884,
-0.33955082297325134,
0.1842302531003952,
0.08805479854345322,
-0.5864832401275635,
0.09575282037258148,
0.32105568051338196,
-0.0684051513671875,
-0.25944504141807556,
-0.9132480025291443,
0.0982038602232933,
-0.10856864601373672,
-0.3454892635345459,
0.5083217024803162,
-0.024106521159410477,
-0.38658812642097473,
0.26859182119369507,
-0.12371418625116348,
-0.32151851058006287,
0.3172270655632019,
-0.1176578551530838,
0.11175835132598877,
-0.11046367883682251,
0.705962598323822,
0.504645586013794,
-0.07422558963298798,
-0.25405240058898926,
-0.16497814655303955,
0.3505879342556,
-0.12093281000852585,
-0.30745673179626465,
-0.5032908320426941,
0.6530320048332214,
0.22997987270355225,
0.05914462357759476,
0.8499405384063721,
0.22670820355415344,
-0.4723217785358429,
0.022165728732943535,
-0.07466274499893188,
-0.40792614221572876,
-0.4391164183616638,
-0.029160451143980026,
-0.23435501754283905,
-0.5962251424789429,
0.41266530752182007,
0.44404536485671997,
-0.19392448663711548,
0.1581481248140335,
0.17030736804008484,
-0.1973600536584854,
0.9164428114891052,
0.19513386487960815,
0.02403421513736248,
0.45292308926582336,
-0.3828597664833069,
0.48801347613334656,
-0.663691520690918,
0.1157703623175621,
-0.3528408408164978,
-0.27262625098228455,
-0.5290791392326355,
-0.23980264365673065,
0.3668944239616394,
0.06873767822980881,
0.012509312480688095,
0.4582004249095917,
-0.5026603937149048,
0.716458797454834,
0.718349814414978,
0.08878634870052338,
0.6947908997535706,
0.14941222965717316,
0.3924624025821686,
-0.19923335313796997,
-0.7784450054168701,
-0.6073593497276306,
0.6838458180427551,
-0.1021762415766716,
0.4873131513595581,
0.30910882353782654,
0.4676843583583832,
0.17839963734149933,
0.26690441370010376,
-1.0682460069656372,
0.3852860927581787,
-0.49181827902793884,
-0.8288945555686951,
-0.13926732540130615,
-0.3961520791053772,
-0.7687672972679138,
0.18246491253376007,
-0.21154701709747314,
-0.38532230257987976,
0.34978312253952026,
0.07756137102842331,
-0.30557796359062195,
0.1491716206073761,
-0.5897629261016846,
0.8592489361763,
-0.17708516120910645,
-0.05940958485007286,
-0.15904971957206726,
-0.24891149997711182,
0.28764620423316956,
-0.06944764405488968,
0.1920921504497528,
-0.3127838969230652,
-0.13720543682575226,
0.3209352195262909,
-0.443185955286026,
0.4672471582889557,
0.10713758319616318,
0.021960968151688576,
0.29875925183296204,
0.13637113571166992,
0.3872627019882202,
0.0014899122761562467,
-0.17887775599956512,
0.10836835950613022,
0.42746078968048096,
-0.7557467222213745,
-0.5414517521858215,
0.5734219551086426,
-0.3969488739967346,
-0.29317963123321533,
-0.5808017253875732,
-0.5368497967720032,
-0.21263879537582397,
-0.07749763131141663,
0.5067321062088013,
0.6374967694282532,
0.07856651395559311,
0.42918312549591064,
0.2568366229534149,
-0.012435607612133026,
0.3087442219257355,
0.18513767421245575,
0.17363639175891876,
-0.10722041130065918,
1.0236949920654297,
0.4945352077484131,
0.42802006006240845,
0.43938279151916504,
0.25724682211875916,
-0.33219778537750244,
-0.5373861193656921,
-0.11433693766593933,
0.13367551565170288,
-0.9774664044380188,
-0.4122719466686249,
-0.4192747175693512,
0.02847493626177311,
-0.3440110981464386,
-0.13572673499584198,
-0.19362671673297882,
-0.3194713890552521,
-0.57365882396698,
-0.08339770883321762,
0.781183660030365,
0.5321077108383179,
-0.15450315177440643,
0.6752603054046631,
-0.6896592974662781,
0.21361832320690155,
0.2404627501964569,
0.44425004720687866,
-0.20769254863262177,
-0.5826902985572815,
-0.4939226508140564,
0.10855571925640106,
-0.031027015298604965,
-0.7546504735946655,
0.5248082280158997,
0.40989795327186584,
0.39504343271255493,
0.27293819189071655,
0.19223344326019287,
0.6402614712715149,
0.06525737792253494,
0.7529049515724182,
-0.07940971851348877,
-1.1483718156814575,
0.184556782245636,
-0.41816452145576477,
0.2959762513637543,
0.6931695938110352,
0.38297078013420105,
-0.6643366813659668,
-0.1362767517566681,
-0.38807085156440735,
-0.8847514986991882,
0.5798876881599426,
-0.027310453355312347,
0.5390568971633911,
-0.10026881843805313,
0.20488086342811584,
0.30853188037872314,
0.5892184376716614,
-0.8576852083206177,
-0.16390331089496613,
0.0011941965203732252,
-0.15202639997005463,
0.13723117113113403,
-0.17104697227478027,
-0.09231458604335785,
-0.6486957669258118,
0.7147595286369324,
-0.1758899688720703,
0.10868421196937561,
-0.05564719811081886,
-0.10607031732797623,
0.2005288451910019,
0.14658860862255096,
0.3979378938674927,
0.5657787322998047,
-0.02761533111333847,
-0.019902318716049194,
-0.07695385813713074,
0.03291619196534157,
0.0909254178404808,
0.0933869257569313,
-0.18325628340244293,
0.3758123517036438,
0.22127467393875122,
0.6954070329666138,
0.4184020161628723,
-0.8825743198394775,
0.560113251209259,
0.20425856113433838,
0.06125883013010025,
-0.40864795446395874,
-0.001521550351753831,
-0.002744403202086687,
-0.01786503940820694,
0.16720116138458252,
-0.2925587594509125,
0.3430474102497101,
-0.6018254160881042,
-0.046627625823020935,
0.43581509590148926,
-0.09738945215940475,
-0.026910902932286263,
0.09282893687486649,
-0.20885592699050903,
0.07789711654186249,
0.5699496865272522,
-0.6728912591934204,
-0.19539333879947662,
0.5077977180480957,
0.09931889921426773,
0.4383552372455597,
0.44891688227653503,
0.38132238388061523,
0.183676615357399,
0.02945106476545334,
-0.3091243803501129,
0.28408336639404297,
0.08518379181623459,
-0.84309983253479,
-0.44565242528915405,
-0.4348321259021759,
-0.6298112869262695,
0.15875808894634247,
-0.6913650035858154,
0.44962602853775024,
-0.4377233386039734,
-0.07514205574989319,
0.007945620454847813,
-0.11370757967233658,
-0.6408822536468506,
0.10657594352960587,
-0.237846240401268,
0.6986938118934631,
-0.9092691540718079,
0.6744968295097351,
0.8066352009773254,
-0.6858940720558167,
-0.6506174206733704,
-0.1380448341369629,
-0.19348791241645813,
-0.05848908796906471,
0.7960904836654663,
0.1942710429430008,
0.1027304008603096,
-0.20348535478115082,
-0.7203266620635986,
-0.9766040444374084,
0.7377129197120667,
0.3267335593700409,
-0.19289301335811615,
0.11659039556980133,
0.03665228933095932,
0.6511383056640625,
-0.2887360155582428,
-0.33936992287635803,
0.6697444915771484,
0.5654255747795105,
-0.012375789694488049,
-0.3655341863632202,
-0.2218601107597351,
-0.00017655437113717198,
0.10824184864759445,
0.16578882932662964,
-0.10204969346523285,
1.2364097833633423,
0.286102831363678,
-0.6378169059753418,
0.4105262756347656,
0.3778766989707947,
0.16778451204299927,
0.49265891313552856,
0.08940532803535461,
0.4257706105709076,
0.6529486179351807,
-0.3826393783092499,
1.4092507362365723,
-0.4128793776035309,
0.32646968960762024,
1.1770546436309814,
-0.21086496114730835,
0.7718920707702637,
0.6143178939819336,
-0.30142128467559814,
0.5345177054405212,
0.82547527551651,
0.041199978440999985,
0.5138180255889893,
0.038874804973602295,
-0.45942288637161255,
-0.2805175185203552,
-0.3600509464740753,
-0.15923967957496643,
0.46860095858573914,
0.44181808829307556,
-0.18984849750995636,
-0.3055446147918701,
0.1451714187860489,
0.04746239259839058,
0.6154912114143372,
0.016063515096902847,
0.735777735710144,
0.011917327530682087,
-0.48508980870246887,
0.6975852251052856,
0.14179657399654388,
0.5285835862159729,
-0.25844940543174744,
0.029848508536815643,
-0.5708255767822266,
-0.10516876727342606,
-0.1760759800672531,
-0.685671865940094,
0.402813583612442,
-0.23480436205863953,
-0.4576779007911682,
-0.0950101763010025,
0.2518499493598938,
-0.4324774742126465,
-0.49088844656944275,
0.14510513842105865,
0.6468625068664551,
0.11674787849187851,
-0.29726946353912354,
-0.5068390369415283,
-0.2730099856853485,
-0.5580258369445801,
-0.010095289908349514,
0.25525838136672974,
0.4330265522003174,
0.09212306886911392,
0.4765647351741791,
0.7024609446525574,
0.24023482203483582,
-0.12712140381336212,
-0.1439625471830368,
0.8012380599975586,
-0.5303119421005249,
-0.4935956597328186,
-0.6749364137649536,
0.3079386353492737,
-0.33817291259765625,
-0.39162498712539673,
0.6491504907608032,
0.4878154695034027,
1.2158104181289673,
-0.15320958197116852,
0.7395411133766174,
0.19444602727890015,
0.7036004662513733,
-0.6252955198287964,
0.2877116799354553,
-0.6510186791419983,
0.33306196331977844,
-0.19837075471878052,
-0.8500058054924011,
-0.28963959217071533,
0.7076308131217957,
-0.4084955155849457,
-0.23197172582149506,
0.4759160876274109,
0.8361106514930725,
-0.25231918692588806,
-0.09966066479682922,
0.38185039162635803,
-0.17837749421596527,
0.13765907287597656,
0.07235543429851532,
0.7133210897445679,
-0.6402145028114319,
0.04297684133052826,
-0.3785859942436218,
0.2687947750091553,
-0.25697243213653564,
-1.06434965133667,
-0.46362414956092834,
-0.8641754984855652,
-0.39956173300743103,
-0.21683315932750702,
-0.09113560616970062,
1.29860258102417,
0.5703524351119995,
-0.9106404185295105,
-0.33058151602745056,
-0.39486539363861084,
0.536614716053009,
-0.3541402816772461,
-0.32158222794532776,
0.07078031450510025,
-0.3212031424045563,
-0.7968159914016724,
0.41780802607536316,
0.1211482360959053,
0.32105374336242676,
-0.20645996928215027,
0.02479534037411213,
-0.2899366319179535,
0.3062979280948639,
0.767328679561615,
0.25493550300598145,
-0.6541429758071899,
-0.18606707453727722,
-0.08224134892225266,
-0.16200578212738037,
0.2855953574180603,
0.7614975571632385,
-0.7006472945213318,
0.465114951133728,
0.7163232564926147,
0.6126474142074585,
0.0027749270666390657,
0.004746549762785435,
0.4803982377052307,
-1.0314894914627075,
0.3535725474357605,
0.2216474562883377,
0.44197335839271545,
0.7977378368377686,
-0.15337353944778442,
0.46380576491355896,
0.6617639064788818,
0.0073327478021383286,
-1.1307626962661743,
0.5174258351325989,
-0.641149640083313,
-0.5996446013450623,
1.2561402320861816,
0.12173783779144287,
-0.002789134858176112,
-0.1206754818558693,
-0.2398558408021927,
-0.011044502258300781,
-0.510807454586029,
0.5331122875213623,
0.9500070214271545,
-0.11925685405731201,
-0.08912701159715652,
-0.5316392183303833,
0.5333033204078674,
0.2161143571138382,
-0.8217594027519226,
-0.018643030896782875,
0.5891425013542175,
0.012583733536303043,
0.054086171090602875,
0.17586655914783478,
-0.019756145775318146,
0.17082208395004272,
-0.23869436979293823,
-0.020327573642134666,
-0.0015160369221121073,
-0.07056386023759842,
-0.5349866151809692,
-0.2280990332365036,
0.14518295228481293,
0.0012688597198575735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17441v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17441v2
|
When Large Language Models Meet Optical Networks: Paving the Way for Automation
| 2024-05-14T10:46:33 | 2024-06-25T03:23:00 |
Danshi Wang, Yidi Wang, Xiaotian Jiang, Yao Zhang, Yue Pang, Min Zhang
|
cs.NI
|
cs.NI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SY, eess.SY
|
Since the advent of GPT, large language models (LLMs) have brought about
revolutionary advancements in all walks of life. As a superior natural language
processing (NLP) technology, LLMs have consistently achieved state-of-the-art
performance on numerous areas. However, LLMs are considered to be
general-purpose models for NLP tasks, which may encounter challenges when
applied to complex tasks in specialized fields such as optical networks. In
this study, we propose a framework of LLM-empowered optical networks,
facilitating intelligent control of the physical layer and efficient
interaction with the application layer through an LLM-driven agent (AI-Agent)
deployed in the control layer. The AI-Agent can leverage external tools and
extract domain knowledge from a comprehensive resource library specifically
established for optical networks. This is achieved through user input and
well-crafted prompts, enabling the generation of control instructions and
result representations for autonomous operation and maintenance in optical
networks. To improve LLM's capability in professional fields and stimulate its
potential on complex tasks, the details of performing prompt engineering,
establishing domain knowledge library, and implementing complex tasks are
illustrated in this study. Moreover, the proposed framework is verified on two
typical tasks: network alarm analysis and network performance optimization. The
good response accuracies and sematic similarities of 2,400 test situations
exhibit the great potential of LLM in optical networks.
|
[
-0.47150862216949463,
-0.8353620767593384,
0.5107484459877014,
0.10456661134958267,
0.03729351609945297,
-0.2430793046951294,
-0.15816976130008698,
-0.8521679639816284,
0.137155681848526,
0.8856360912322998,
-0.41433653235435486,
-0.1630694419145584,
-0.44959670305252075,
0.428566038608551,
-0.39977163076400757,
0.5142147541046143,
0.009320556186139584,
0.04602847620844841,
0.34284260869026184,
0.19838649034500122,
-0.16548657417297363,
-0.20574583113193512,
-1.0087977647781372,
-0.5759435296058655,
0.4789118468761444,
-0.09122272580862045,
0.897661566734314,
0.5822821259498596,
0.8716704845428467,
0.5375698804855347,
0.041940364986658096,
0.5429280400276184,
0.08952701091766357,
0.04168489947915077,
-0.32334455847740173,
-0.46595385670661926,
-0.8485674262046814,
-0.12374880164861679,
0.5318427085876465,
0.6624352335929871,
-0.15970803797245026,
-0.4923989474773407,
0.11970402300357819,
0.8296708464622498,
-0.09923942387104034,
0.28130966424942017,
-0.7637831568717957,
0.31890198588371277,
0.15487277507781982,
-0.7107657194137573,
-0.16884486377239227,
0.10023913532495499,
-0.01186361350119114,
-0.7526518702507019,
-0.1542464643716812,
0.18177258968353271,
0.6867380738258362,
0.5005135536193848,
-0.41165247559547424,
-0.44928449392318726,
-1.0010982751846313,
0.556134045124054,
-0.6797552108764648,
0.23351845145225525,
0.2861534059047699,
0.5836656093597412,
-0.38242775201797485,
-0.2616751492023468,
-0.5820968747138977,
-0.5012125372886658,
0.10468003153800964,
0.09822504222393036,
-0.06976576894521713,
0.47525346279144287,
0.07959378510713577,
0.11110800504684448,
-0.20888318121433258,
0.5311281681060791,
-0.2550188899040222,
0.0361233651638031,
0.6701998710632324,
0.2932772934436798,
0.2954897880554199,
0.11334342509508133,
-0.4039188325405121,
0.3356664478778839,
-0.5933306813240051,
-0.4002147614955902,
0.27373334765434265,
0.34605684876441956,
0.21586477756500244,
0.8821812868118286,
-0.5308042168617249,
0.7117955684661865,
-0.03477470949292183,
-0.2645179331302643,
-0.03140037879347801,
-0.21081998944282532,
-0.4385935366153717,
0.07763831317424774,
0.8569855093955994,
0.18084140121936798,
0.4677298367023468,
-0.4478036165237427,
-0.5583384037017822,
-0.14577500522136688,
0.29098284244537354,
-0.23352870345115662,
0.19848503172397614,
0.4081471264362335,
-0.23362132906913757,
-0.2522169351577759,
-0.16777294874191284,
-0.49110838770866394,
-0.5254696607589722,
-0.7508931756019592,
0.4165447950363159,
-0.13619178533554077,
-0.40073180198669434,
0.491280734539032,
0.1409722864627838,
0.2923203110694885,
0.6897300481796265,
-0.6615775227546692,
0.20941783487796783,
0.842406690120697,
0.6081683039665222,
-0.12327675521373749,
-0.4220678210258484,
-0.2506241500377655,
0.4743281304836273,
-0.5204446315765381,
0.3486618101596832,
-0.2656700611114502,
0.12381061911582947,
0.04126451164484024,
0.033249594271183014,
0.018971337005496025,
-0.5931128263473511,
0.00219234311953187,
-1.11812424659729,
0.02743436209857464,
0.4837408661842346,
-0.4229799509048462,
-0.18843990564346313,
0.34615519642829895,
-0.6465299129486084,
0.5138899683952332,
-0.21178358793258667,
-0.09776494652032852,
0.04057333618402481,
-0.7436710000038147,
-0.3230799734592438,
0.3253146708011627,
-0.12737107276916504,
-0.15922948718070984,
-0.1596396118402481,
-0.14899787306785583,
0.7576932907104492,
-0.5915634632110596,
0.5297701358795166,
-0.20244862139225006,
0.04509705305099487,
0.07988713681697845,
-0.3908247947692871,
0.723422110080719,
0.060151029378175735,
-0.6421213150024414,
0.053352296352386475,
-0.9123064875602722,
-0.04845920950174332,
-0.04606800898909569,
-0.3685513436794281,
-0.06221349537372589,
0.18001040816307068,
-0.05392121151089668,
0.22015084326267242,
0.3153381645679474,
-0.43745332956314087,
0.22878779470920563,
-0.34698376059532166,
0.5065618753433228,
0.8299477696418762,
-0.15683850646018982,
0.5568476319313049,
-0.06987220048904419,
0.5805431008338928,
-0.1528717428445816,
0.12152045220136642,
0.17641581594944,
-0.25178855657577515,
-0.6215863227844238,
-0.07023142278194427,
-0.47328487038612366,
0.858831524848938,
-1.1374614238739014,
0.8631755709648132,
-0.13147811591625214,
-0.45885783433914185,
-0.04847606271505356,
0.5895734429359436,
0.17210324108600616,
0.49777907133102417,
0.250534325838089,
-0.04482385516166687,
-0.08164474368095398,
-0.8337022662162781,
0.13115978240966797,
-0.001548092346638441,
-0.058503519743680954,
0.5272709727287292,
0.28291094303131104,
-0.3757128119468689,
0.9220127463340759,
-0.22688257694244385,
-1.0151413679122925,
-0.4303063750267029,
-0.3216957151889801,
0.3128526210784912,
0.5362920761108398,
0.11233245581388474,
-0.991182267665863,
-0.050896529108285904,
0.4017607867717743,
-1.2466338872909546,
-0.35417717695236206,
-0.3200932741165161,
-0.13920091092586517,
0.1861477792263031,
0.6522161960601807,
-0.6571667790412903,
0.14090275764465332,
0.469431608915329,
-0.3033982515335083,
0.7154726982116699,
-0.27912354469299316,
-0.0884101539850235,
-0.9245664477348328,
-0.11913967877626419,
0.12048376351594925,
-0.14597462117671967,
-0.5337778925895691,
0.2129695564508438,
-0.5524313449859619,
-0.23845896124839783,
-0.3613043427467346,
0.5583687424659729,
-0.6128761768341064,
-0.2614282965660095,
-0.4893905818462372,
0.2023533135652542,
0.027924485504627228,
0.6375895142555237,
0.3097287118434906,
0.6527692079544067,
0.823883056640625,
-0.7328581213951111,
0.7820989489555359,
-0.020726751536130905,
-0.20761245489120483,
0.3890160620212555,
-0.8798831105232239,
-0.23699162900447845,
0.024309152737259865,
-0.04818900302052498,
-0.3901287615299225,
-0.2094612568616867,
0.3518241345882416,
0.12476900219917297,
0.04380715265870094,
0.10492800176143646,
-0.742851197719574,
-0.04226122796535492,
0.3149398863315582,
0.038464006036520004,
0.1282275915145874,
-0.27933868765830994,
1.2845982313156128,
0.31440985202789307,
-0.02801966480910778,
-0.24688933789730072,
-0.689972460269928,
0.5112269520759583,
-0.14495699107646942,
-0.7549369931221008,
0.1486242115497589,
0.09239387512207031,
-0.36687323451042175,
-0.03497965261340141,
0.265206515789032,
-0.1849541813135147,
0.32783976197242737,
-0.013137473724782467,
0.05236366018652916,
-0.2919324040412903,
0.2323082685470581,
-0.18732373416423798,
-0.335105836391449,
0.09604837745428085,
-0.59498131275177,
0.6343273520469666,
-0.16348868608474731,
-0.5589134693145752,
-0.6938713788986206,
0.3704413175582886,
0.5202431678771973,
-0.49988773465156555,
0.5560235381126404,
0.40398725867271423,
-0.13501816987991333,
-0.635697603225708,
-0.5118848085403442,
-0.4616563320159912,
-0.6336057782173157,
0.6603842377662659,
-0.16664038598537445,
-0.8898024559020996,
0.4506818354129791,
-0.11845265328884125,
0.031600791960954666,
0.09817883372306824,
0.24188435077667236,
0.023392846807837486,
0.9562064409255981,
0.6030183434486389,
-0.11398672312498093,
0.5652888417243958,
-0.183026522397995,
0.25950899720191956,
-0.6889643669128418,
-0.059362366795539856,
-0.24156059324741364,
-0.2061830312013626,
-0.2099597305059433,
-0.21025694906711578,
0.5933218598365784,
0.339731365442276,
-0.36981627345085144,
0.2695731818675995,
-0.45899325609207153,
0.3027327358722687,
0.18688437342643738,
0.2262531965970993,
0.6037129759788513,
0.14809761941432953,
0.27016857266426086,
0.5513446927070618,
-0.7659919261932373,
-0.6069385409355164,
0.5249594449996948,
0.4708034098148346,
0.8112392425537109,
0.3172222971916199,
0.24528227746486664,
0.3330872058868408,
-0.13165590167045593,
-0.6562445163726807,
0.9530882835388184,
-0.05312974750995636,
-0.5040291547775269,
-0.7179417014122009,
-0.586255669593811,
-0.7397032380104065,
0.08182124048471451,
-0.131301611661911,
-0.6602537631988525,
0.19305665791034698,
0.1899528056383133,
-0.07792234420776367,
0.39271727204322815,
-0.39184895157814026,
0.3511589467525482,
-0.7402988076210022,
-0.4438113272190094,
-0.2260846197605133,
-0.36782917380332947,
0.07524202018976212,
-0.11936682462692261,
0.016458023339509964,
-0.24635101854801178,
-0.37629377841949463,
0.38325241208076477,
-0.5162945985794067,
1.145913004875183,
-0.05912769213318825,
-0.4444598853588104,
0.23065300285816193,
0.14208906888961792,
0.6207150220870972,
-0.174305722117424,
-0.3200725018978119,
0.30078110098838806,
-0.690131664276123,
-0.1515665054321289,
-0.7124210000038147,
0.36983391642570496,
-0.6043497920036316,
-0.719148576259613,
-0.09649483114480972,
-0.39582255482673645,
-0.2193698287010193,
0.4362155497074127,
-0.19666674733161926,
0.7115339040756226,
0.4256950616836548,
0.11157789826393127,
0.7102872133255005,
-0.1888471394777298,
0.50101637840271,
0.7868590354919434,
-0.3872278034687042,
-0.04818021133542061,
0.7395415902137756,
0.003958724904805422,
0.6708502173423767,
0.6470938920974731,
0.08590521663427353,
-0.001009269617497921,
-0.6947709918022156,
-0.4471394121646881,
0.01816355623304844,
-0.6251800656318665,
-0.11615072190761566,
-0.5346904993057251,
-0.31731870770454407,
-0.18169748783111572,
-0.31651464104652405,
-0.21012678742408752,
0.00881880708038807,
-0.3149792551994324,
-0.1311780959367752,
0.35100796818733215,
0.7850812077522278,
-0.0008645220077596605,
0.5956765413284302,
-0.5110805034637451,
0.2977484464645386,
0.3394756019115448,
0.4499038755893707,
0.31992289423942566,
0.0622912161052227,
-0.16127316653728485,
-0.2287774682044983,
-0.07158511132001877,
-0.6747521758079529,
0.48405322432518005,
0.5737642645835876,
0.5552824139595032,
0.6192773580551147,
-0.20792806148529053,
0.14884869754314423,
-0.6223971247673035,
0.5019384622573853,
0.08757482469081879,
-0.668341875076294,
0.33364954590797424,
-0.5453920364379883,
-0.11501806974411011,
0.08986179530620575,
0.11915546655654907,
-0.10482650250196457,
-0.47939571738243103,
-0.2363802045583725,
-0.8956316709518433,
0.5950997471809387,
-0.08271089196205139,
0.061459481716156006,
0.11037161201238632,
0.356281578540802,
-0.45360955595970154,
0.4401705861091614,
-0.7470393776893616,
-0.06798204034566879,
0.0698041170835495,
-0.06152161955833435,
-0.16982048749923706,
0.2509809136390686,
-0.10558156669139862,
0.21866260468959808,
0.6872174143791199,
-0.5183447003364563,
0.2738381326198578,
0.43074703216552734,
0.05543563514947891,
0.08897727727890015,
0.11748682707548141,
0.3156467378139496,
0.5738555788993835,
0.154220849275589,
0.0882776603102684,
-0.09706419706344604,
-0.26249945163726807,
0.024865608662366867,
-0.002152368426322937,
-0.25582069158554077,
-0.3975693881511688,
0.6772716045379639,
0.7025812268257141,
0.06838672608137131,
-0.7427681088447571,
0.22830435633659363,
0.4014654755592346,
0.16049671173095703,
-0.46497443318367004,
0.5539140701293945,
-0.09720861911773682,
0.4560681879520416,
0.6466339230537415,
0.10296189785003662,
0.21006451547145844,
-0.4887841045856476,
0.09608637541532516,
0.6703175902366638,
-0.3882458806037903,
-0.021362317726016045,
0.7063391804695129,
0.26948055624961853,
-0.36897873878479004,
0.2684668004512787,
-0.01838066801428795,
-0.693587064743042,
1.0583610534667969,
0.40763381123542786,
0.7182934284210205,
0.18891389667987823,
0.2404184192419052,
-0.16176830232143402,
0.501541256904602,
-0.05057671666145325,
0.12271483987569809,
-0.0008655454148538411,
-1.1508527994155884,
-0.4431309998035431,
-0.70286625623703,
-0.01318502426147461,
-0.1649669110774994,
-0.18968862295150757,
-0.0073028868064284325,
-0.6783559918403625,
0.03626874461770058,
-0.16061745584011078,
0.07853962481021881,
-0.598985493183136,
0.35086748003959656,
-0.105320505797863,
1.0723930597305298,
-0.5973433256149292,
0.7819530963897705,
0.4622642993927002,
-0.317762166261673,
-1.1297779083251953,
-0.5349765419960022,
-0.0680500715970993,
-0.9901747107505798,
0.9335010647773743,
-0.10471664369106293,
-0.4206194579601288,
0.20982736349105835,
-0.4186420738697052,
-0.5958034992218018,
1.201664686203003,
0.15460427105426788,
-0.7205910682678223,
-0.07749765366315842,
0.4787428081035614,
0.7150763273239136,
-0.41314947605133057,
0.23464249074459076,
-0.006800028961151838,
0.48414912819862366,
0.0004693212977144867,
-0.8190993666648865,
-0.1451958268880844,
-0.31376150250434875,
-0.00872172974050045,
-0.03439144045114517,
-0.6036856770515442,
0.510540246963501,
-0.0015848071780055761,
0.15058764815330505,
-0.031901679933071136,
0.6656448245048523,
0.06362807005643845,
0.1102471649646759,
0.5684791207313538,
0.23475612699985504,
0.39733588695526123,
-0.004188551567494869,
1.1777899265289307,
-0.4127318263053894,
-0.15281765162944794,
0.746440052986145,
-0.4535962641239166,
0.6685788631439209,
0.37825530767440796,
-0.01922299526631832,
-0.04310692101716995,
0.14627905189990997,
-0.07722903788089752,
0.26194503903388977,
-0.06367860734462738,
-0.30661439895629883,
-0.3647703230381012,
-0.23519036173820496,
-0.1368923783302307,
0.47766387462615967,
0.2435643970966339,
-0.3587866425514221,
-0.1449035108089447,
0.2930046021938324,
-0.09350322186946869,
-0.0019521128851920366,
-0.7791236042976379,
1.0555225610733032,
0.26908260583877563,
-0.46593236923217773,
0.1490476429462433,
-0.04989038035273552,
0.7110239863395691,
-0.8857957720756531,
0.06890475004911423,
0.07181871682405472,
0.40746018290519714,
-0.3280194401741028,
-0.8390817642211914,
0.20278845727443695,
-0.23229487240314484,
-0.1721189320087433,
-0.18164166808128357,
0.6505178809165955,
-0.48284393548965454,
-0.42843058705329895,
0.7066668272018433,
0.25944647192955017,
0.15252238512039185,
-0.002019635634496808,
-0.6208235621452332,
0.012030964717268944,
-0.11056404560804367,
-0.2499249279499054,
0.22098767757415771,
0.6371597647666931,
0.03023342229425907,
1.122063159942627,
0.722635805606842,
0.6866162419319153,
0.2533925771713257,
-0.08430404961109161,
0.6332693099975586,
-0.19953708350658417,
-0.4124549925327301,
-0.5379438996315002,
0.219457745552063,
-0.1005731076002121,
-0.3840879201889038,
0.6324627995491028,
0.09515101462602615,
0.5704435110092163,
0.03936140239238739,
0.5621245503425598,
0.09653601795434952,
0.06367889046669006,
-0.8608003854751587,
0.7731932997703552,
-0.8209539651870728,
0.6936634182929993,
-0.27439168095588684,
-1.0078791379928589,
-0.34938591718673706,
0.4905737042427063,
-0.36086392402648926,
0.06988938897848129,
-0.00265859579667449,
1.1221750974655151,
-0.048223719000816345,
-0.11522069573402405,
0.31708937883377075,
0.2628423273563385,
0.6959680318832397,
0.4600059986114502,
0.5099656581878662,
-0.13034313917160034,
0.19107462465763092,
-0.2169790267944336,
-0.40687957406044006,
-0.14311613142490387,
-1.0287672281265259,
-0.5821870565414429,
-0.395305335521698,
-0.14959926903247833,
-0.11303623765707016,
0.1090022474527359,
0.9107033610343933,
0.7060038447380066,
-0.6194179058074951,
-0.2674923539161682,
-0.4563535451889038,
0.19546225666999817,
-0.2940322458744049,
-0.25512123107910156,
0.316186785697937,
-0.38264212012290955,
-0.5899783372879028,
0.5056897401809692,
0.4608352482318878,
0.028095686808228493,
-0.6388712525367737,
-0.25176888704299927,
0.12691201269626617,
0.057626646012067795,
0.5942816734313965,
0.26936301589012146,
-0.5693710446357727,
-0.08939006179571152,
-0.07121535390615463,
-0.35106194019317627,
-0.2702859342098236,
0.38291484117507935,
-0.4250607192516327,
0.13178065419197083,
0.268434077501297,
0.8099885582923889,
-0.3091448247432709,
-0.14675305783748627,
0.7656087875366211,
-0.31537216901779175,
0.10217975080013275,
0.375807523727417,
0.4671706557273865,
0.18015363812446594,
-0.5663658976554871,
0.4382098913192749,
-0.029197311028838158,
-0.6907574534416199,
-0.5023155808448792,
0.42136290669441223,
-1.1655315160751343,
-0.2726767361164093,
1.1714723110198975,
0.04356851056218147,
-0.20569676160812378,
-0.2013590782880783,
-0.2021341472864151,
-0.08711545914411545,
-0.27040091156959534,
0.7214750051498413,
0.19495828449726105,
-0.10554856061935425,
-0.33586063981056213,
-0.4651407301425934,
0.3725162744522095,
0.3055107593536377,
-0.9418704509735107,
-0.10673564672470093,
0.3861403465270996,
-0.15000617504119873,
0.42776820063591003,
0.4752787947654724,
0.015152822248637676,
0.03151192143559456,
-0.42130404710769653,
0.029522337019443512,
-0.5059097409248352,
-0.7893775701522827,
-0.2989499866962433,
0.3807750344276428,
-0.07952933758497238,
0.37127676606178284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13013v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13013v1
|
Amplifying Aspect-Sentence Awareness: A Novel Approach for Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-05-14T10:29:59 | 2024-05-14T10:29:59 |
Adamu Lawan, Juhua Pu, Haruna Yunusa, Jawad Muhammad, Aliyu Umar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) is increasingly crucial in Natural
Language Processing (NLP) for applications such as customer feedback analysis
and product recommendation systems. ABSA goes beyond traditional sentiment
analysis by extracting sentiments related to specific aspects mentioned in the
text; existing attention-based models often need help to effectively connect
aspects with context due to language complexity and multiple sentiment
polarities in a single sentence. Recent research underscores the value of
integrating syntactic information, such as dependency trees, to understand
long-range syntactic relationships better and link aspects with context.
Despite these advantages, challenges persist, including sensitivity to parsing
errors and increased computational complexity when combining syntactic and
semantic information. To address these issues, we propose Amplifying
Aspect-Sentence Awareness (A3SN), a novel technique designed to enhance ABSA
through amplifying aspect-sentence awareness attention. Following the
transformer's standard process, our innovative approach incorporates multi-head
attention mechanisms to augment the model with sentence and aspect semantic
information. We added another multi-head attention module: amplify
aspect-sentence awareness attention. By doubling its focus between the sentence
and aspect, we effectively highlighted aspect importance within the sentence
context. This enables accurate capture of subtle relationships and
dependencies. Additionally, gated fusion integrates feature representations
from multi-head and amplified aspect-sentence awareness attention mechanisms,
which is essential for ABSA. Experimental results across three benchmark
datasets demonstrate A3SN's effectiveness and outperform state-of-the-art
(SOTA) baseline models.
|
[
-0.5995590686798096,
-0.8596755266189575,
0.5922797918319702,
0.5453818440437317,
-0.2516888678073883,
-0.15869614481925964,
0.026287822052836418,
-0.6745045185089111,
0.4952206313610077,
0.6132561564445496,
-0.6227015852928162,
-0.362190842628479,
-0.299615740776062,
0.14985087513923645,
-0.413797527551651,
0.9816415905952454,
0.09522683173418045,
-0.09548131376504898,
-0.2964571416378021,
-0.3714710772037506,
-0.4214298129081726,
-0.6369705200195312,
-0.4262622892856598,
-0.03478500247001648,
0.4170014262199402,
0.3831127882003784,
0.5231532454490662,
0.47623658180236816,
0.7932746410369873,
0.2199673056602478,
-0.25292518734931946,
-0.11022263765335083,
0.19380904734134674,
0.3731362819671631,
-0.2658303380012512,
-0.3656589388847351,
-0.7402068972587585,
-0.312516450881958,
0.40776994824409485,
0.8186221718788147,
0.1574590653181076,
-0.07252413779497147,
0.1948973834514618,
0.959137499332428,
-0.5666738152503967,
0.32341885566711426,
-0.3663630783557892,
0.061939045786857605,
-0.01012079231441021,
0.08549957722425461,
-0.1426641345024109,
-0.08034928888082504,
0.3249111473560333,
-0.3866535425186157,
0.21236681938171387,
0.13857752084732056,
0.6835787296295166,
0.26787039637565613,
-0.21295559406280518,
-0.13364584743976593,
-0.7721127271652222,
0.6445774435997009,
-0.5181165933609009,
0.4750656187534332,
0.10464967042207718,
-0.12796127796173096,
0.29680806398391724,
-0.28855252265930176,
-0.6451887488365173,
0.19651171565055847,
-0.19965966045856476,
0.2682188153266907,
-0.4006267189979553,
0.3480800688266754,
0.084980808198452,
0.8303667306900024,
-0.1713162511587143,
-0.19269397854804993,
-0.06957495957612991,
-0.11849742382764816,
0.39473313093185425,
-0.15252533555030823,
0.09621357917785645,
-0.6453473567962646,
-0.3577531576156616,
0.03403168544173241,
-0.6684738993644714,
0.19679945707321167,
0.24143733084201813,
0.45335569977760315,
-0.0012001852737739682,
0.6482738852500916,
-0.45092350244522095,
0.6312341094017029,
0.14031988382339478,
0.1854376494884491,
0.37036260962486267,
-0.5529845952987671,
-0.1235947459936142,
0.10889367759227753,
0.8066160678863525,
0.2809315323829651,
-0.3737715482711792,
0.021452659741044044,
-0.25751227140426636,
0.00019963490194641054,
0.5275876522064209,
-0.5607456564903259,
-0.1330203413963318,
0.5897804498672485,
-0.33977434039115906,
-0.12541337311267853,
0.19571630656719208,
-0.9628282785415649,
-0.4995461404323578,
-0.2943297326564789,
0.44008922576904297,
-0.5260189771652222,
-0.2557874321937561,
-0.11976957321166992,
-0.009298542514443398,
0.2558135986328125,
0.05721408128738403,
-0.8276801109313965,
0.016283581033349037,
1.0085363388061523,
0.8977307677268982,
0.020983293652534485,
-0.2256905734539032,
-0.37363481521606445,
0.14507825672626495,
-0.10507256537675858,
1.042262077331543,
-0.43381839990615845,
-0.18943096697330475,
-0.09877989441156387,
-0.20448529720306396,
0.03950517624616623,
-0.33909136056900024,
0.7090812921524048,
-0.24156442284584045,
0.05619601160287857,
-0.11407744139432907,
-0.26144540309906006,
-0.6065425872802734,
0.41202080249786377,
-0.6473814249038696,
0.7755541801452637,
0.2563183009624481,
-0.8017104864120483,
0.20048022270202637,
-0.8974988460540771,
-0.8367981910705566,
-0.016842976212501526,
-0.11979882419109344,
-0.7244927883148193,
0.4390241801738739,
0.7064365148544312,
0.4646780788898468,
0.051108669489622116,
0.032653920352458954,
-0.19173535704612732,
0.21629361808300018,
0.2644367218017578,
-0.2964377999305725,
0.3561258018016815,
-0.07776489108800888,
-0.2756991386413574,
0.48667991161346436,
-0.3684753477573395,
-0.3238990604877472,
-0.34823077917099,
0.15654009580612183,
-0.4572017788887024,
-0.10246472805738449,
-0.08906377106904984,
0.2043123096227646,
0.3178354799747467,
-0.6627838611602783,
-0.06325574219226837,
-0.9004729986190796,
0.35985067486763,
0.38974422216415405,
0.4821881055831909,
0.4811329245567322,
-0.15073426067829132,
0.5791298151016235,
0.3032655417919159,
0.46523162722587585,
-0.5837475061416626,
-0.41649144887924194,
-1.036075472831726,
-0.10559716820716858,
-0.08582858741283417,
0.4091629981994629,
-0.7709061503410339,
0.9274353981018066,
-0.1953636109828949,
-0.35584503412246704,
-0.6736304759979248,
0.18974295258522034,
0.41114941239356995,
0.3403645157814026,
0.3866455554962158,
-0.5879522562026978,
-0.7520419359207153,
-1.1719563007354736,
-0.33975881338119507,
-0.5399917960166931,
0.06933032721281052,
0.26478269696235657,
0.18009799718856812,
0.12578141689300537,
1.1720513105392456,
-0.5521244406700134,
-0.798891007900238,
-0.9023604989051819,
0.1278352588415146,
0.041313767433166504,
0.2852518856525421,
0.31057700514793396,
-0.9054312705993652,
-0.1813024878501892,
0.21214081346988678,
-0.5198887586593628,
-0.03383497893810272,
-0.169733926653862,
-0.08256573975086212,
0.14357399940490723,
0.1462472528219223,
-0.5793840885162354,
0.235386461019516,
0.5398870706558228,
-0.3943621516227722,
0.2713683545589447,
0.2183072715997696,
0.08491969108581543,
-1.2904807329177856,
-0.10118778049945831,
0.28300201892852783,
-0.1512317657470703,
-0.6531781554222107,
0.12438403069972992,
0.0845150500535965,
-0.0825667455792427,
-0.47475481033325195,
0.1509668081998825,
-0.31380659341812134,
-0.22282211482524872,
-0.5169594883918762,
0.06120458245277405,
0.3857421875,
0.6412971019744873,
0.08858305215835571,
0.5517991185188293,
0.6286937594413757,
-0.4093061089515686,
0.2883260250091553,
0.3605249226093292,
-0.039861902594566345,
0.8627942204475403,
-0.42878568172454834,
-0.05702311173081398,
-0.09045484662055969,
0.2812059223651886,
-0.6613081097602844,
-0.24487674236297607,
0.27027782797813416,
-0.3475702702999115,
0.013932839967310429,
0.020376844331622124,
-0.13216355443000793,
-0.3389042317867279,
-0.5078521966934204,
0.29546263813972473,
-0.05523206666111946,
-0.40528082847595215,
1.2243261337280273,
0.5757951140403748,
-0.4499861001968384,
-0.39079996943473816,
-0.5473414659500122,
0.14265495538711548,
-0.2544471025466919,
-0.42936667799949646,
0.2021166980266571,
0.3782842755317688,
-0.2817873954772949,
0.0730120912194252,
-0.3609146177768707,
0.005351544823497534,
0.08837445080280304,
0.41195639967918396,
0.2050912231206894,
-0.1255088746547699,
0.08165156841278076,
0.03594806045293808,
-0.17745409905910492,
0.22422336041927338,
-0.2687562108039856,
0.4037943482398987,
-0.43887120485305786,
-0.22746019065380096,
-0.6340177059173584,
0.5678736567497253,
0.4744876027107239,
-0.45732054114341736,
0.40940603613853455,
0.322427362203598,
-0.3834574222564697,
0.08677802234888077,
-0.5615550875663757,
-0.3801300525665283,
-0.3890416920185089,
0.6354798078536987,
-0.22143828868865967,
-0.7866406440734863,
0.30877387523651123,
0.21172159910202026,
-0.014721205458045006,
0.4992225468158722,
0.19900137186050415,
-0.047712747007608414,
1.0081257820129395,
0.8227925300598145,
-0.27282458543777466,
0.862017810344696,
-0.11209474503993988,
0.5938554406166077,
-1.2816370725631714,
-0.15486116707324982,
-0.5067051649093628,
-0.15749336779117584,
-0.1374954730272293,
-0.20417022705078125,
0.49504101276397705,
0.2308298498392105,
0.18823875486850739,
0.4551207423210144,
-0.4910535514354706,
0.2799696922302246,
0.39997974038124084,
0.20646549761295319,
0.40486106276512146,
-0.33988258242607117,
0.46554115414619446,
0.0698525458574295,
-0.34540873765945435,
-0.27212318778038025,
0.8523979783058167,
0.5163726210594177,
0.3183363378047943,
0.07846850156784058,
0.39978307485580444,
0.13879293203353882,
0.38036131858825684,
-1.2180935144424438,
0.4876427948474884,
-0.27418527007102966,
-0.3101743757724762,
-0.1444716453552246,
-0.3359234631061554,
-0.5239097476005554,
0.30245527625083923,
-0.16638343036174774,
-0.7949442863464355,
0.34045079350471497,
0.1863050013780594,
-0.6809903979301453,
0.0759369283914566,
-0.7825077772140503,
0.8229978680610657,
-0.07197889685630798,
-0.23553255200386047,
-0.15555517375469208,
-0.5789362788200378,
0.32472336292266846,
0.021206239238381386,
0.27710968255996704,
-0.09363962709903717,
0.04795258492231369,
0.7882394790649414,
-0.24321797490119934,
0.8970336318016052,
-0.10359641164541245,
-0.09573734551668167,
0.1812278777360916,
-0.12521618604660034,
0.5113620162010193,
0.11482127755880356,
0.11478241533041,
0.12687361240386963,
-0.4222317039966583,
-0.11811036616563797,
-0.8109882473945618,
0.699573278427124,
-0.436669260263443,
-0.8963009119033813,
-0.3859988749027252,
-0.6436878442764282,
-0.554773211479187,
0.09048369526863098,
-0.15720754861831665,
0.3421565592288971,
-0.041310135275125504,
0.3150516450405121,
0.5413451194763184,
0.16091960668563843,
0.52080237865448,
0.40835464000701904,
-0.35726693272590637,
-0.5006200671195984,
0.8203237056732178,
-0.19405224919319153,
0.1464385837316513,
0.6494337916374207,
0.18568144738674164,
-0.2666163444519043,
-0.5820697546005249,
-0.37612777948379517,
0.09551744163036346,
-0.47124993801116943,
-0.4185207784175873,
-1.161597728729248,
-0.24731385707855225,
-0.420021116733551,
0.007769620046019554,
-0.5360905528068542,
-0.6225805878639221,
0.0326966717839241,
-0.2849551737308502,
0.5824001431465149,
0.710507869720459,
0.18543504178524017,
0.49271172285079956,
-0.6941922903060913,
0.39442166686058044,
0.17581787705421448,
0.31911763548851013,
-0.07609664648771286,
-0.13110877573490143,
-0.34615230560302734,
-0.27103015780448914,
-0.5609158873558044,
-0.9321319460868835,
0.4125327467918396,
0.09395913779735565,
0.32097747921943665,
0.4865742623806,
0.07215246558189392,
0.3538303077220917,
0.0888657420873642,
0.9919832348823547,
0.1407310515642166,
-1.2210752964019775,
0.9562271237373352,
-0.20233717560768127,
0.45983824133872986,
0.6529208421707153,
-0.03148631006479263,
-0.5693099498748779,
-0.9577714204788208,
-0.4933888912200928,
-1.3259637355804443,
0.7917253375053406,
0.2886446714401245,
0.0001407656673109159,
0.047695569694042206,
0.2686862349510193,
0.11354080587625504,
0.19114360213279724,
-0.7210329174995422,
-0.19443191587924957,
-0.5426688194274902,
-0.40399107336997986,
0.11904371529817581,
-0.06278859823942184,
-0.04870991408824921,
-0.0566733218729496,
0.8752964735031128,
-0.22863127291202545,
0.06177078187465668,
0.4385320842266083,
-0.020704979076981544,
0.17523051798343658,
0.5574038028717041,
0.1168336421251297,
0.32315656542778015,
-0.1376502513885498,
0.27909889817237854,
0.07015139609575272,
-0.666253387928009,
-0.16229279339313507,
0.26069390773773193,
-0.31595292687416077,
-0.14549218118190765,
0.29119253158569336,
0.8219972848892212,
0.13603456318378448,
-0.3313034176826477,
0.6057212352752686,
-0.022684304043650627,
0.22111831605434418,
-0.17567680776119232,
-0.08235200494527817,
-0.10157012194395065,
0.14951008558273315,
0.5244778394699097,
0.4198702573776245,
0.44299057126045227,
-0.5006117224693298,
0.2661576271057129,
0.341079443693161,
-0.9982649683952332,
-0.44653427600860596,
0.2222534418106079,
0.5154200792312622,
-0.14388854801654816,
0.15477684140205383,
-0.15794047713279724,
-0.7274009585380554,
0.5494998097419739,
0.2945428192615509,
1.2980375289916992,
-0.28515762090682983,
0.1905873864889145,
0.16938738524913788,
0.31986263394355774,
-0.0279607605189085,
0.21210037171840668,
-0.027515605092048645,
-0.6915827989578247,
-0.4711145758628845,
-0.6431231498718262,
-0.6378622055053711,
-0.0492369644343853,
-0.7755525708198547,
-0.008019237779080868,
-0.3189098834991455,
-0.023708181455731392,
0.13956210017204285,
-0.13773570954799652,
-0.2335166186094284,
0.21183934807777405,
-0.28032535314559937,
0.38530248403549194,
-0.9605160355567932,
0.5003587603569031,
0.8850674033164978,
-0.5465344786643982,
-0.6031689643859863,
0.4080190360546112,
-0.08049482852220535,
-0.278967022895813,
-0.04492215812206268,
0.6419622898101807,
-0.0539989210665226,
-0.21997839212417603,
0.012004115618765354,
-0.6618264317512512,
0.8708614706993103,
0.018224705010652542,
-0.4550970792770386,
0.3065358102321625,
0.11722255498170853,
0.5473340749740601,
-0.6953250169754028,
0.1319224238395691,
0.7417835593223572,
0.36160361766815186,
-0.030474577099084854,
-0.6736295223236084,
0.11464297771453857,
-0.23439088463783264,
0.035139620304107666,
0.3944670259952545,
-0.6457362771034241,
0.5956030488014221,
0.05179876089096069,
-0.17596228420734406,
-0.21130289137363434,
1.1799471378326416,
0.17129123210906982,
0.38613104820251465,
0.8534786105155945,
0.34815967082977295,
0.29914620518684387,
-0.1997591257095337,
1.006239652633667,
-0.5268173813819885,
0.14272871613502502,
1.0999641418457031,
-0.29349392652511597,
1.0635151863098145,
0.7488083839416504,
-0.02594660595059395,
0.607320249080658,
0.18667751550674438,
0.35217806696891785,
0.3955877125263214,
-0.2944415211677551,
-0.41888806223869324,
-0.14261695742607117,
-0.5587736964225769,
-0.1005728468298912,
0.5078560709953308,
0.5232855677604675,
-0.351507306098938,
-0.015573645941913128,
0.3965413272380829,
-0.03706568107008934,
0.16534258425235748,
-0.4498240649700165,
1.0552798509597778,
0.08186635375022888,
-0.722897469997406,
-0.4286476671695709,
-0.1713389754295349,
0.7133106589317322,
-0.4737068712711334,
0.22058862447738647,
-0.3366667330265045,
0.32920122146606445,
-0.4107845723628998,
-1.043645977973938,
0.783138632774353,
0.06448115408420563,
-0.3719078004360199,
-0.191304013133049,
0.5222839713096619,
-0.29636964201927185,
-0.6848952174186707,
0.09290885180234909,
0.4269842803478241,
-0.18859602510929108,
-0.6003260612487793,
-0.3665356934070587,
0.07162899523973465,
0.0422663576900959,
-0.3499995470046997,
0.2332151085138321,
0.4691210091114044,
0.013157621026039124,
0.4259345829486847,
0.3332644999027252,
-0.0183284729719162,
-0.5889374613761902,
0.35126426815986633,
0.9189009070396423,
-0.7614507675170898,
-0.7862449288368225,
-0.7270932197570801,
0.28339213132858276,
-0.2321934998035431,
-0.36787065863609314,
0.888354480266571,
0.7883158326148987,
0.5259541869163513,
0.262787789106369,
0.9163430333137512,
-0.07489639520645142,
0.5617244839668274,
-0.4892868995666504,
0.5053964257240295,
-0.2586612403392792,
0.5458821654319763,
-0.20026430487632751,
-1.0997428894042969,
-0.5828724503517151,
0.3978089988231659,
-0.4256269335746765,
0.04091223329305649,
0.9382266402244568,
0.7438549995422363,
0.06924788653850555,
0.6117932796478271,
-0.07970333099365234,
0.34479573369026184,
0.3894495368003845,
0.4296343922615051,
0.6906138062477112,
-0.3100762665271759,
0.5808981657028198,
-0.6777967810630798,
-0.3276103436946869,
-0.035199858248233795,
-0.7072545289993286,
-0.5658656358718872,
-0.5965211987495422,
-0.5097395777702332,
-0.3736341893672943,
-0.04627445340156555,
0.7851356267929077,
0.4271250069141388,
-0.9121590256690979,
0.0940578430891037,
-0.3639100193977356,
0.29030758142471313,
-0.7818745970726013,
-0.3257516026496887,
0.47615909576416016,
-0.3872966170310974,
-0.5745601654052734,
0.3999527096748352,
0.7665376663208008,
-0.02041860856115818,
-0.6086764931678772,
0.3188009560108185,
-0.052377406507730484,
0.08187530189752579,
0.6344670057296753,
0.1371229588985443,
-0.6884089708328247,
-0.4165918231010437,
-0.13404154777526855,
0.10954128950834274,
0.20790967345237732,
1.0184694528579712,
-0.6847454309463501,
0.3191819190979004,
0.4369462728500366,
0.34630751609802246,
0.22878263890743256,
0.38389894366264343,
0.8019636273384094,
-1.0677422285079956,
0.07233975827693939,
0.3902515470981598,
0.3390755355358124,
0.7651850581169128,
-0.5399405360221863,
0.2799932062625885,
0.043991513550281525,
-0.20867742598056793,
-0.5227590799331665,
0.45998895168304443,
-1.2776727676391602,
-0.1854051947593689,
1.1885851621627808,
-0.254933625459671,
-0.4312747120857239,
-0.44182825088500977,
-0.34351518750190735,
0.06927056610584259,
-0.668712317943573,
0.8466306924819946,
0.5505463480949402,
-0.46502143144607544,
-0.277993768453598,
-0.06025393307209015,
0.4663929343223572,
0.6436820030212402,
-1.2499840259552002,
0.5515658855438232,
0.4516890347003937,
-0.38251587748527527,
0.46836942434310913,
0.2959155738353729,
-0.11652252078056335,
0.21609772741794586,
-0.1097891703248024,
0.17951712012290955,
-0.03910454735159874,
-0.4512012302875519,
-0.6366553902626038,
0.5332368612289429,
-0.037367675453424454,
-0.17037752270698547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08477v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08477v1
|
Enhancing Gender-Inclusive Machine Translation with Neomorphemes and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-14T10:02:50 | 2024-05-14T10:02:50 |
Andrea Piergentili, Beatrice Savoldi, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine translation (MT) models are known to suffer from gender bias,
especially when translating into languages with extensive gendered morphology.
Accordingly, they still fall short in using gender-inclusive language, also
representative of non-binary identities. In this paper, we look at
gender-inclusive neomorphemes, neologistic elements that avoid binary gender
markings as an approach towards fairer MT. In this direction, we explore
prompting techniques with large language models (LLMs) to translate from
English into Italian using neomorphemes. So far, this area has been
under-explored due to its novelty and the lack of publicly available evaluation
resources. We fill this gap by releasing Neo-GATE, a resource designed to
evaluate gender-inclusive en-it translation with neomorphemes. With Neo-GATE,
we assess four LLMs of different families and sizes and different prompt
formats, identifying strengths and weaknesses of each on this novel task for
MT.
|
[
-0.390761137008667,
-0.4789643883705139,
0.5102751851081848,
0.20637920498847961,
-0.21480043232440948,
-0.03263409063220024,
-0.1708855926990509,
-0.4930362403392792,
0.03146161884069443,
0.39561039209365845,
-0.9894289970397949,
-0.37337610125541687,
-0.604432225227356,
0.8380438089370728,
-0.4108911454677582,
1.0603517293930054,
-0.022022197023034096,
0.32720983028411865,
0.04285329207777977,
0.10679113864898682,
-0.5988011360168457,
-0.2991214096546173,
-0.46102389693260193,
-0.3450400233268738,
0.6758759021759033,
0.2292468249797821,
0.8045057654380798,
0.53948974609375,
0.13237038254737854,
0.30085915327072144,
-0.29784539341926575,
0.40212035179138184,
-0.0712357833981514,
0.21316492557525635,
-0.5009962320327759,
-0.43668657541275024,
-0.7095504403114319,
-0.00625657057389617,
0.7915101051330566,
0.7528928518295288,
0.22777283191680908,
0.0264382753521204,
0.2343427836894989,
0.38972145318984985,
-0.3674396574497223,
-0.0035242855083197355,
-0.5956348776817322,
0.12709453701972961,
0.006605302449315786,
-0.1604420244693756,
-0.2756522297859192,
-0.391618549823761,
-0.14799609780311584,
-0.5694558024406433,
0.15291722118854523,
0.2674606442451477,
0.47457507252693176,
0.05646679922938347,
-0.3577052354812622,
-0.4306160807609558,
-0.7530125975608826,
0.9122394323348999,
-0.7008791565895081,
0.5384945273399353,
0.47562333941459656,
0.37054499983787537,
-0.4341703951358795,
-0.20983217656612396,
-0.5992107391357422,
-0.3718903064727783,
0.19186708331108093,
-0.10186177492141724,
-0.4539146423339844,
-0.1596015840768814,
0.12193121016025543,
0.013670787215232849,
-0.5461967587471008,
0.45811429619789124,
-0.1438976675271988,
-0.2782256603240967,
0.23147307336330414,
0.0714801698923111,
0.46538835763931274,
-0.3620486855506897,
-0.22856684029102325,
-0.05610515922307968,
-0.7603937387466431,
-0.3369600772857666,
0.6895513534545898,
0.7023988962173462,
-0.09613042324781418,
0.7438392043113708,
0.05573474243283272,
0.6151244640350342,
-0.11045460402965546,
0.1110839992761612,
0.34220579266548157,
-0.28492751717567444,
0.12728551030158997,
0.05407179519534111,
0.877475380897522,
0.3989061713218689,
0.3193199634552002,
-0.34881022572517395,
-0.3489471971988678,
-0.2641133666038513,
0.14359299838542938,
-0.9598708152770996,
0.5760235786437988,
0.17139574885368347,
-0.3989568054676056,
-0.01720345951616764,
-0.08301814645528793,
-0.8051026463508606,
-0.5031261444091797,
-0.2498125433921814,
0.28659892082214355,
-0.5592436790466309,
-0.21835407614707947,
0.07064426690340042,
-0.3939248323440552,
0.024901455268263817,
0.5157784223556519,
-0.9118055701255798,
0.09958788752555847,
0.8735319972038269,
0.8396203517913818,
0.11964157223701477,
-0.17278507351875305,
-0.6043766736984253,
0.14533062279224396,
-0.44472718238830566,
0.5049665570259094,
-0.7169085741043091,
-0.6689160466194153,
-0.03291735053062439,
0.2775866985321045,
-0.10348489135503769,
-0.4736025035381317,
0.5404951572418213,
-0.179380401968956,
0.664482831954956,
-0.14559876918792725,
-0.10217583924531937,
-0.3909439444541931,
0.38539838790893555,
-0.48393872380256653,
0.7416791915893555,
0.2280268371105194,
-0.7889231443405151,
0.08666211366653442,
-0.5968973636627197,
-0.16991719603538513,
0.04380897805094719,
-0.2606653869152069,
-0.12596014142036438,
0.2742028534412384,
0.2641478478908539,
0.22650347650051117,
-0.6033504009246826,
0.2691836357116699,
-0.2578406035900116,
-0.2027704119682312,
0.4825994074344635,
-0.4599743187427521,
0.7269964218139648,
0.19005829095840454,
-0.4817664325237274,
0.4173673689365387,
-0.42655032873153687,
-0.2502780556678772,
-0.10598461329936981,
0.20937535166740417,
-0.3858014941215515,
-0.18747001886367798,
0.10647843778133392,
0.46509379148483276,
0.2802284359931946,
-0.414559930562973,
0.2559158504009247,
-0.31886324286460876,
0.7120494246482849,
1.024361491203308,
-0.43721750378608704,
0.6241863369941711,
-0.1697799265384674,
0.8474909067153931,
-0.14062735438346863,
0.16194289922714233,
-0.08680063486099243,
-0.6906301975250244,
-0.4838239550590515,
-0.5136273503303528,
0.6625876426696777,
0.6624775528907776,
-1.1779201030731201,
0.540285587310791,
-0.4026031494140625,
-0.1942741870880127,
-0.8080204725265503,
0.24036261439323425,
0.27073946595191956,
0.3156503140926361,
0.13638941943645477,
-0.21149404346942902,
-0.3507208824157715,
-0.9974513053894043,
0.05605600029230118,
-0.23425163328647614,
-0.27323517203330994,
0.3158067762851715,
0.7704307436943054,
-0.7171429395675659,
0.7231735587120056,
0.1654437780380249,
-0.07669409364461899,
-0.30532628297805786,
0.18166378140449524,
0.39243319630622864,
0.5843385457992554,
0.4093710780143738,
-0.5133974552154541,
0.09885092824697495,
0.30377212166786194,
-0.5451823472976685,
-0.3572023808956146,
0.11900246888399124,
-0.1623285710811615,
0.06958554685115814,
0.32152247428894043,
-0.6395153999328613,
0.15328659117221832,
0.7960106730461121,
-0.47714924812316895,
0.37339240312576294,
-0.3584492802619934,
0.30959799885749817,
-1.1746779680252075,
0.22254478931427002,
-0.1523253172636032,
-0.5245617628097534,
-0.43376198410987854,
0.059832483530044556,
0.16790010035037994,
-0.1761259287595749,
-0.5703390836715698,
0.7934916615486145,
-0.4939233064651489,
-0.28996768593788147,
-0.4805009663105011,
0.2135322391986847,
-0.046425145119428635,
-0.036785561591386795,
0.023704037070274353,
0.7914580702781677,
0.3773117661476135,
-0.549329936504364,
-0.028077641502022743,
0.1380133330821991,
0.17674683034420013,
0.6364162564277649,
-0.6553910970687866,
0.2675934135913849,
-0.25141817331314087,
0.18129537999629974,
-0.7171904444694519,
0.09085170179605484,
0.8295021057128906,
-0.5495159029960632,
0.25239482522010803,
-0.31662535667419434,
-0.6157833337783813,
-0.3275738060474396,
-0.3456394374370575,
0.4185861051082611,
0.36516183614730835,
-0.2331942468881607,
0.43064579367637634,
-0.026851879432797432,
-0.40690210461616516,
-0.4454796016216278,
-0.5197679996490479,
0.44701433181762695,
-0.2025655210018158,
-0.5324583649635315,
0.39844775199890137,
-0.14256562292575836,
-0.059424176812171936,
0.06193108856678009,
0.2403469979763031,
-0.038528405129909515,
0.20285776257514954,
0.09475899487733841,
0.4116266369819641,
0.011022737249732018,
0.0027892030775547028,
0.27576324343681335,
-0.40633925795555115,
-0.14023350179195404,
-0.605212390422821,
0.7629721164703369,
-0.002502390183508396,
-0.18336865305900574,
-0.6078927516937256,
0.7275592088699341,
0.6329346299171448,
-0.21713626384735107,
0.7920753359794617,
0.7895385026931763,
-0.5087488889694214,
-0.11451227962970734,
-0.21865639090538025,
-0.487114280462265,
-0.43773287534713745,
0.35415390133857727,
-0.3355918824672699,
-1.196002721786499,
0.5105072259902954,
-0.04446249082684517,
0.17123766243457794,
0.4699181616306305,
0.5162312388420105,
0.03383788838982582,
1.465098261833191,
0.7235389351844788,
0.057523827999830246,
0.5098702907562256,
0.05254320800304413,
0.08836387097835541,
-1.0315812826156616,
-0.1699274480342865,
-1.128162145614624,
-0.422860711812973,
-0.9469624161720276,
-0.7807620763778687,
0.3481616675853729,
-0.08329132199287415,
-0.02625792846083641,
0.4112393856048584,
-0.4159426689147949,
-0.009707385674118996,
0.5332272052764893,
-0.1854488104581833,
0.39972880482673645,
0.13999921083450317,
-0.10143417119979858,
-0.3132166862487793,
-0.8195054531097412,
-0.740668535232544,
0.7134729623794556,
0.3748106360435486,
0.5226025581359863,
0.04484930634498596,
0.45816555619239807,
0.1742500513792038,
0.2630883753299713,
-0.7860723733901978,
0.5840064287185669,
-0.2289620190858841,
-0.8690927624702454,
-0.0017767604440450668,
-0.9778415560722351,
-1.2526143789291382,
0.2498004138469696,
-0.48984330892562866,
-0.6017745137214661,
0.3277212083339691,
-0.1569758951663971,
-0.008746910840272903,
0.23579375445842743,
-0.20590859651565552,
0.7460495829582214,
-0.32653847336769104,
-0.25066784024238586,
-0.24374155700206757,
-0.27787265181541443,
0.1372586339712143,
-0.03824111074209213,
0.6631372570991516,
-0.11690215021371841,
-0.516591489315033,
0.5144655108451843,
-0.20187993347644806,
0.7945348024368286,
0.08490829914808273,
-0.30486440658569336,
-0.1134631410241127,
0.37790447473526,
0.3449089825153351,
-0.08309880644083023,
-0.35679230093955994,
0.4785057306289673,
-0.3340966999530792,
-0.2470909208059311,
-0.551228404045105,
0.5143016576766968,
-0.6821819543838501,
-0.457075297832489,
-0.46761462092399597,
-0.8362752795219421,
-0.020067641511559486,
0.5031262040138245,
0.23820747435092926,
0.24266667664051056,
-0.04998243972659111,
0.06059576943516731,
0.6477896571159363,
-0.5180258750915527,
0.37542256712913513,
0.5125473737716675,
-0.49379315972328186,
-0.7134996652603149,
0.7343341708183289,
0.09453561902046204,
0.1483519822359085,
0.24546125531196594,
0.3615542948246002,
-0.4948256015777588,
-0.6913148164749146,
-1.054851770401001,
0.4034259021282196,
-0.3239375054836273,
-0.04533388093113899,
-0.7317317128181458,
0.03996368497610092,
-0.5999113917350769,
-0.12014800310134888,
-0.20573778450489044,
-0.673062801361084,
-0.26770785450935364,
0.031063448637723923,
0.31629806756973267,
0.5508264899253845,
0.02450932003557682,
0.3917487561702728,
-0.8745301961898804,
0.4406690001487732,
0.2711751461029053,
0.017109688371419907,
-0.3349846601486206,
-0.8149160146713257,
0.07763062417507172,
0.0438389927148819,
-0.13755939900875092,
-1.035071849822998,
0.5435446500778198,
-0.09941127151250839,
0.6262733340263367,
0.3805399537086487,
-0.2505899965763092,
0.46955591440200806,
-0.8891478776931763,
0.5545495748519897,
0.5377212166786194,
-0.9818421006202698,
0.523649275302887,
-0.6600023508071899,
0.12956368923187256,
0.3458992838859558,
0.47068509459495544,
-0.7932602763175964,
-0.4611554741859436,
-0.40817540884017944,
-0.8501877784729004,
0.6128997206687927,
0.4249346852302551,
0.45635315775871277,
-0.15212443470954895,
0.2823675870895386,
0.45850688219070435,
0.5571441650390625,
-0.7393611073493958,
0.11560352146625519,
-0.0958283320069313,
-0.268787682056427,
-0.017481161281466484,
-0.029401494190096855,
0.010930451564490795,
-0.05722324177622795,
0.7398759126663208,
-0.062324441969394684,
0.2213985025882721,
0.1602836400270462,
-0.11986033618450165,
0.07472695410251617,
0.6398545503616333,
0.4606432318687439,
0.4262402355670929,
-0.059787265956401825,
0.11212475597858429,
0.08804889768362045,
-0.1486877053976059,
0.20835596323013306,
0.1770290732383728,
-0.7393282651901245,
0.31305447220802307,
0.3049323558807373,
0.7358489632606506,
-0.025573458522558212,
-0.4456019103527069,
0.1737040877342224,
-0.1209435984492302,
-0.07626766711473465,
0.09506536275148392,
0.007314799353480339,
0.02371229976415634,
0.13133463263511658,
0.1663224697113037,
-0.00171015749219805,
0.31043457984924316,
-0.7729130983352661,
-0.21911627054214478,
0.57715904712677,
-0.8753135800361633,
-0.34273818135261536,
0.6866806745529175,
0.49966052174568176,
-0.6097861528396606,
0.6013338565826416,
-0.3786166310310364,
-0.5175459980964661,
0.28157714009284973,
0.7632201313972473,
1.2256206274032593,
-0.5488865375518799,
0.3135506212711334,
0.34569814801216125,
0.966471254825592,
-0.0938170924782753,
0.2242024689912796,
0.16569994390010834,
-0.46496084332466125,
-0.41154101490974426,
-0.3145360052585602,
-0.4704222083091736,
-0.3922919034957886,
-0.2215997278690338,
0.2813545763492584,
-0.5726339221000671,
-0.5292360782623291,
-0.46781519055366516,
-0.27565836906433105,
-0.4534488916397095,
-0.11182781308889389,
0.2798263728618622,
0.8104757070541382,
-0.8744838833808899,
0.46624717116355896,
0.8328081369400024,
-0.15153633058071136,
-0.28624215722084045,
-0.3585697412490845,
-0.028941050171852112,
-0.560403048992157,
0.33804166316986084,
0.35733696818351746,
-0.28059086203575134,
-0.048053957521915436,
-0.22812843322753906,
-0.2786575257778168,
0.7323535084724426,
0.7140915989875793,
-0.6190307140350342,
-0.04501477628946304,
0.3617647886276245,
0.26699700951576233,
-0.5067433714866638,
0.6298533082008362,
0.1349145770072937,
0.8239094018936157,
-0.0620754137635231,
-0.9006962180137634,
-0.0015957182040438056,
-0.4357275068759918,
0.22583414614200592,
0.1449923813343048,
-0.33431917428970337,
0.7789111733436584,
0.10333613306283951,
-0.0374312698841095,
0.14861294627189636,
0.5401051640510559,
0.30154451727867126,
0.3559667766094208,
0.9012953042984009,
0.14033940434455872,
0.8365429043769836,
-0.12146760523319244,
0.9946458339691162,
0.05571489781141281,
-0.2638840973377228,
0.7874066233634949,
-0.21747951209545135,
0.5945464968681335,
0.4774242043495178,
0.1313815414905548,
0.6866779923439026,
0.45747441053390503,
0.3073977828025818,
-0.04020703583955765,
0.16729901731014252,
-0.24163921177387238,
-0.4246215224266052,
-0.6263125538825989,
-0.5683164000511169,
0.26728466153144836,
0.3186854124069214,
-0.4088442921638489,
-0.22673052549362183,
0.02050216868519783,
0.23138581216335297,
0.09623350203037262,
-0.4348430633544922,
0.5028569102287292,
0.33462977409362793,
-0.48373788595199585,
0.22629696130752563,
0.3624234199523926,
0.7642678022384644,
-0.7588133215904236,
-0.050394173711538315,
-0.19741111993789673,
-0.14084284007549286,
-0.07842393964529037,
-0.4104919731616974,
0.06713312119245529,
0.4702723026275635,
-0.3754713535308838,
-0.5311710238456726,
0.48365023732185364,
-0.36702707409858704,
-1.0520011186599731,
0.386540949344635,
0.6663708090782166,
0.17548346519470215,
-0.17906714975833893,
-0.8292593955993652,
0.030994661152362823,
-0.008272680453956127,
0.24033434689044952,
0.24923716485500336,
0.6936286091804504,
-0.50236976146698,
0.7430801391601562,
0.8292732238769531,
0.22837188839912415,
0.026994358748197556,
0.10993846505880356,
0.6011130213737488,
-0.889869749546051,
-0.6105260848999023,
-0.9232717752456665,
0.5243070125579834,
0.008771000429987907,
-0.2309746891260147,
0.9382230639457703,
0.33621251583099365,
0.37509918212890625,
0.1441223919391632,
0.4207235872745514,
0.007337414659559727,
0.3044079840183258,
-0.36229127645492554,
0.5384553670883179,
-0.5442308187484741,
0.22963334619998932,
-0.4604266881942749,
-1.3832979202270508,
-0.10460034012794495,
0.5751608610153198,
-0.2052610218524933,
0.10161533951759338,
0.4516180753707886,
0.912004292011261,
-0.09669064730405807,
-0.015771711245179176,
0.23311243951320648,
0.1365237832069397,
0.30563005805015564,
0.6851154565811157,
1.2510204315185547,
-0.34071195125579834,
0.5383700132369995,
0.1578788012266159,
-0.43250396847724915,
-0.2012462317943573,
-1.1804462671279907,
-0.829973042011261,
-0.17826779186725616,
-0.41223663091659546,
-0.400343656539917,
0.15563338994979858,
1.1030890941619873,
0.6530510783195496,
-0.6166483163833618,
-0.3170253038406372,
0.1134796142578125,
0.5742683410644531,
-0.17104865610599518,
-0.05659433454275131,
-0.08283490687608719,
-0.033992379903793335,
-1.1740034818649292,
0.4478357136249542,
0.24184094369411469,
0.07907155156135559,
-0.3301873505115509,
-0.18494655191898346,
0.17577368021011353,
-0.06664182245731354,
0.3532351851463318,
-0.11467064917087555,
-0.3395281732082367,
-0.04345887154340744,
0.18340563774108887,
-0.02458024211227894,
-0.1865054816007614,
0.7878479361534119,
-0.5555946826934814,
0.43858620524406433,
0.706533670425415,
0.44609302282333374,
0.08685087412595749,
-0.27854037284851074,
0.8356895446777344,
-0.3352753221988678,
0.4766514301300049,
0.47036516666412354,
0.37237250804901123,
0.5533555746078491,
-0.08279721438884735,
0.33081087470054626,
0.19261354207992554,
-0.25717195868492126,
-0.8444795608520508,
0.31128984689712524,
-0.7453848719596863,
-0.4370911121368408,
1.1974440813064575,
0.07517939805984497,
-0.5019781589508057,
-0.039961423724889755,
-0.3314290940761566,
0.23607157170772552,
-0.37351346015930176,
0.5433386564254761,
0.5206707119941711,
0.4449922442436218,
-0.10905908048152924,
-0.899106502532959,
-0.03533569723367691,
0.5739520192146301,
-0.6729798316955566,
-0.10601848363876343,
0.7215624451637268,
0.12230998277664185,
0.09522701054811478,
0.36658474802970886,
-0.4474654197692871,
0.3337382674217224,
-0.3621860444545746,
0.29402467608451843,
-0.1793670356273651,
-0.3509613871574402,
-0.573776364326477,
-0.13844002783298492,
0.14138835668563843,
0.05310484766960144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08469v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08469v1
|
GPT-3.5 for Grammatical Error Correction
| 2024-05-14T09:51:09 | 2024-05-14T09:51:09 |
Anisia Katinskaia, Roman Yangarber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper investigates the application of GPT-3.5 for Grammatical Error
Correction (GEC) in multiple languages in several settings: zero-shot GEC,
fine-tuning for GEC, and using GPT-3.5 to re-rank correction hypotheses
generated by other GEC models. In the zero-shot setting, we conduct automatic
evaluations of the corrections proposed by GPT-3.5 using several methods:
estimating grammaticality with language models (LMs), the Scribendi test, and
comparing the semantic embeddings of sentences. GPT-3.5 has a known tendency to
over-correct erroneous sentences and propose alternative corrections. For
several languages, such as Czech, German, Russian, Spanish, and Ukrainian,
GPT-3.5 substantially alters the source sentences, including their semantics,
which presents significant challenges for evaluation with reference-based
metrics. For English, GPT-3.5 demonstrates high recall, generates fluent
corrections, and generally preserves sentence semantics. However, human
evaluation for both English and Russian reveals that, despite its strong
error-detection capabilities, GPT-3.5 struggles with several error types,
including punctuation mistakes, tense errors, syntactic dependencies between
words, and lexical compatibility at the sentence level.
|
[
0.042381707578897476,
-1.0577155351638794,
0.8890955448150635,
0.3282252252101898,
0.02313828095793724,
-0.23966096341609955,
-0.36163967847824097,
-0.2808537483215332,
-0.11601485311985016,
-0.07102701812982559,
-0.28090739250183105,
-0.7645294070243835,
-0.4831674098968506,
0.33858755230903625,
-0.15689700841903687,
1.2151042222976685,
-0.43342745304107666,
0.37105682492256165,
0.11140084266662598,
0.1104535385966301,
-0.6785874366760254,
-0.8101468682289124,
-0.5891274213790894,
0.02326270192861557,
0.5468406081199646,
0.6396609544754028,
0.7982862591743469,
0.38792604207992554,
0.6173720359802246,
0.27797144651412964,
0.16068150103092194,
-0.086990587413311,
-0.112745501101017,
-0.07775366306304932,
-0.22845464944839478,
-0.30445197224617004,
-0.829845666885376,
0.07235287874937057,
0.8380554914474487,
0.4749756455421448,
-0.30961769819259644,
-0.1257886439561844,
-0.17370468378067017,
0.7061877846717834,
-0.750990092754364,
0.36106613278388977,
-0.3441270589828491,
0.003906763158738613,
-0.3669827878475189,
0.0969039648771286,
-0.3288906514644623,
-0.5123451948165894,
-0.1533823162317276,
-0.6913087964057922,
0.6258034110069275,
-0.3449469804763794,
0.9252062439918518,
0.1621265709400177,
-0.21833869814872742,
-0.17265959084033966,
-0.7286269068717957,
0.4370541572570801,
-0.7022519707679749,
0.09374106675386429,
0.5096173882484436,
0.12813538312911987,
-0.08700762689113617,
-0.45485156774520874,
-0.5966746807098389,
-0.35330212116241455,
-0.07790911197662354,
0.386471688747406,
-0.1396988332271576,
0.2990742623806,
0.4109322428703308,
0.4114343523979187,
-0.6641293168067932,
-0.023780880495905876,
-0.21339699625968933,
-0.16153311729431152,
0.298654705286026,
-0.027501005679368973,
0.36961689591407776,
-0.11994810402393341,
0.2676714360713959,
0.12477223575115204,
-0.6452788710594177,
-0.2954624593257904,
0.6433037519454956,
0.518395185470581,
0.10574012249708176,
0.5711051821708679,
-0.38998568058013916,
0.8859763741493225,
-0.07393466681241989,
0.026164745911955833,
0.24827556312084198,
-0.3864218592643738,
-0.27146846055984497,
-0.14311066269874573,
0.6556557416915894,
0.5122593641281128,
0.2618604004383087,
-0.0015952662797644734,
-0.07162103801965714,
0.2928416132926941,
0.13598816096782684,
-0.26958587765693665,
-0.2582471966743469,
-0.11673153191804886,
0.02682649716734886,
-0.18477773666381836,
0.3493162989616394,
-0.5669906139373779,
0.028430772945284843,
-0.1456247866153717,
0.6951085925102234,
-0.3317282795906067,
0.1938040852546692,
0.4953972399234772,
0.04300986975431442,
0.06332898139953613,
0.5623943209648132,
-1.1958945989608765,
0.46571335196495056,
0.5503001809120178,
0.8515027165412903,
0.12656360864639282,
-0.7380170822143555,
-0.6060835123062134,
0.12764610350131989,
-0.3127666115760803,
0.9213736653327942,
-0.30372852087020874,
-0.428140252828598,
0.1981615275144577,
0.25244829058647156,
-0.5192528963088989,
-0.1827458292245865,
0.6346293091773987,
-0.17400933802127838,
0.6687553524971008,
-0.28086018562316895,
-0.6127631664276123,
-0.1381448656320572,
0.29546400904655457,
-0.664917528629303,
1.150078535079956,
0.28756260871887207,
-0.5647776126861572,
0.4602040946483612,
-0.8721683621406555,
-0.5139409899711609,
-0.11633079499006271,
0.18087832629680634,
-0.583379328250885,
0.08069397509098053,
0.38798436522483826,
0.37198036909103394,
-0.012548740021884441,
0.059746645390987396,
0.015344386920332909,
-0.6572532057762146,
-0.1967436969280243,
-0.2867731750011444,
0.4357275664806366,
-0.13776426017284393,
-0.5695877075195312,
0.11687049269676208,
-0.5663823485374451,
0.08382779359817505,
-0.002332372823730111,
-0.3757046163082123,
-0.03210877254605293,
-0.06360431015491486,
-0.1666487157344818,
0.023535216227173805,
-0.0699356347322464,
-0.6053469777107239,
0.4670095145702362,
-0.12263788282871246,
0.2969729006290436,
0.578914225101471,
0.05931884050369263,
0.21631339192390442,
-0.1224716529250145,
0.6344380974769592,
-0.1878257393836975,
0.12250613421201706,
-0.02989431656897068,
-0.7819467782974243,
-0.8960041999816895,
0.12184561043977737,
0.5533177256584167,
1.0758310556411743,
-0.5877822637557983,
0.30718106031417847,
-0.2125469297170639,
-0.42352724075317383,
-0.40195339918136597,
-0.06284687668085098,
0.5508737564086914,
0.3219079077243805,
0.45449888706207275,
0.12975503504276276,
-0.4154880940914154,
-0.7667458653450012,
-0.5311850905418396,
-0.45347702503204346,
0.07724207639694214,
-0.13494695723056793,
0.780731737613678,
0.14316043257713318,
0.7104995250701904,
-0.6333694458007812,
-0.3196732699871063,
-0.08342215418815613,
0.29026928544044495,
0.0042763059027493,
0.4845271706581116,
0.4185524582862854,
-0.3173918128013611,
-0.6739130616188049,
0.2746005058288574,
-0.4795829951763153,
-0.2522953450679779,
0.027973681688308716,
0.18400917947292328,
0.6133278608322144,
0.3471941351890564,
-0.5918009281158447,
0.3314816355705261,
0.4731927216053009,
-0.5402632355690002,
0.8165020942687988,
-0.4640684127807617,
0.51469886302948,
-0.8951115012168884,
-0.11603444069623947,
0.002672801958397031,
-0.2953036427497864,
-0.6531116366386414,
0.022582627832889557,
0.3648739159107208,
0.06540980190038681,
-0.45173490047454834,
0.2455078810453415,
-0.4082445502281189,
0.07313742488622665,
0.19705933332443237,
0.17078298330307007,
-0.2542969584465027,
0.3144663870334625,
-0.18017888069152832,
1.0336310863494873,
0.3755605220794678,
-0.18332457542419434,
0.5422110557556152,
0.06809958815574646,
0.03552310913801193,
0.7013447880744934,
-0.3921406865119934,
0.36304971575737,
-0.07834181934595108,
0.05882720276713371,
-0.7107611894607544,
-0.3212447166442871,
0.4257817268371582,
-0.6101410388946533,
0.2682163119316101,
-0.20021671056747437,
-0.6946682929992676,
-0.1952189952135086,
-0.3502378463745117,
0.13619866967201233,
0.2344694435596466,
-0.22167661786079407,
0.18154434859752655,
-0.04863510653376579,
-0.33840569853782654,
-0.5182304382324219,
-0.6206054091453552,
0.24404467642307281,
-0.005903915036469698,
-0.5906497836112976,
0.17361071705818176,
0.1342962384223938,
-0.27423015236854553,
0.0709773376584053,
0.13939452171325684,
0.174576073884964,
-0.14937762916088104,
-0.11945376545190811,
0.30561280250549316,
-0.211534783244133,
0.21946197748184204,
-0.3655455410480499,
-0.22215047478675842,
-0.3553341031074524,
-0.3492336869239807,
0.12880000472068787,
-0.7044959664344788,
-0.6111379265785217,
-0.2039525806903839,
0.38782960176467896,
0.31360551714897156,
0.19028452038764954,
0.44022586941719055,
0.500555694103241,
-0.42522162199020386,
0.2915043234825134,
-0.8437950015068054,
0.37802308797836304,
-0.32818126678466797,
0.44860440492630005,
-0.40718168020248413,
-0.925439178943634,
0.6990461349487305,
0.5817140936851501,
-0.38656434416770935,
0.7631003260612488,
0.533723771572113,
0.067360520362854,
0.8112736940383911,
0.6064768433570862,
-0.2717943787574768,
0.29789999127388,
0.1545802652835846,
0.2928242087364197,
-0.5367811322212219,
0.02479317970573902,
-0.8103176355361938,
0.06950846314430237,
-0.7178394198417664,
-0.35317835211753845,
0.2595900595188141,
0.08131926506757736,
-0.2772669792175293,
0.40627139806747437,
-0.10707084089517593,
0.885756254196167,
0.5215887427330017,
-0.10938312858343124,
0.5110990405082703,
-0.03311183303594589,
-0.1776401251554489,
-0.2213815152645111,
-0.4658583700656891,
-0.5569785237312317,
0.8049151301383972,
0.1739433854818344,
0.611025869846344,
0.33434540033340454,
0.40399667620658875,
0.010449342429637909,
0.22011598944664001,
-0.9090573787689209,
0.344710111618042,
-0.5003083944320679,
-0.6878088712692261,
-0.4403647780418396,
-0.27070531249046326,
-0.493466854095459,
0.30739954113960266,
0.2071009874343872,
-0.8329769968986511,
-0.12016350030899048,
0.3092838227748871,
-0.6018977761268616,
0.37394431233406067,
-1.1756078004837036,
1.2648513317108154,
0.03783337399363518,
-0.3511163890361786,
0.15908528864383698,
-0.681298017501831,
0.06575293093919754,
0.16061662137508392,
-0.10169675201177597,
-0.0763477012515068,
-0.1146160140633583,
0.36825957894325256,
-0.20735056698322296,
0.7813639044761658,
-0.26867997646331787,
-0.17285636067390442,
0.06628101319074631,
0.031357262283563614,
0.5621448159217834,
0.062456149607896805,
-0.009714106097817421,
0.05465250834822655,
0.014473638497292995,
-0.3153298795223236,
-0.6366196870803833,
0.545308530330658,
-0.6677219867706299,
-0.5223093628883362,
-0.7926283478736877,
-0.4200812876224518,
-0.3839135468006134,
0.1503138393163681,
0.3729259967803955,
0.09606167674064636,
-0.4920179843902588,
-0.10674597322940826,
0.13236938416957855,
0.11922469735145569,
0.4510335326194763,
0.7792836427688599,
-0.07379884272813797,
-0.4348044693470001,
0.7101032733917236,
0.27034878730773926,
0.4195551872253418,
0.24595151841640472,
-0.11410126090049744,
-0.13807587325572968,
-0.6227626204490662,
-0.6398953199386597,
0.246660053730011,
-0.8039422035217285,
-0.19379548728466034,
-0.3113115429878235,
-0.021316517144441605,
-0.47612398862838745,
-0.25753965973854065,
-0.2288048416376114,
-0.49270689487457275,
-0.33568647503852844,
-0.32577693462371826,
0.3255608081817627,
0.8574519753456116,
-0.22824802994728088,
0.5726197957992554,
-0.7305164933204651,
0.11561217904090881,
0.2515796422958374,
0.6369888782501221,
-0.6962199807167053,
-0.34754833579063416,
-0.3004528880119324,
-0.13300558924674988,
-0.3055752217769623,
-0.9528821706771851,
0.15572194755077362,
0.3061751425266266,
0.3807154893875122,
-0.2660813629627228,
-0.8246197700500488,
0.9650832414627075,
-0.7320596575737,
1.1275545358657837,
-0.06211911141872406,
-1.3237502574920654,
0.7187516093254089,
-0.8825432062149048,
0.507451593875885,
0.5776986479759216,
0.01158964168280363,
-1.0998960733413696,
-0.37054476141929626,
-0.7558630704879761,
-0.6380815505981445,
0.8167651295661926,
0.3914242386817932,
-0.08669018000364304,
-0.22437608242034912,
0.591392993927002,
-0.16030913591384888,
-0.08276074379682541,
-0.7545800805091858,
0.04467633366584778,
-0.18368995189666748,
-0.10778068751096725,
-0.3465108573436737,
-0.32653728127479553,
-0.017479175701737404,
-0.23921705782413483,
1.0435010194778442,
-0.3284027874469757,
0.23545227944850922,
0.44460174441337585,
-0.24316246807575226,
-0.25630059838294983,
0.6735719442367554,
0.9855200052261353,
0.6756877899169922,
-0.2329552322626114,
0.07371217757463455,
0.5138876438140869,
-0.8325334787368774,
0.2911916673183441,
0.26006487011909485,
-0.26613321900367737,
0.1677902191877365,
0.25081318616867065,
0.6030195951461792,
0.1616288721561432,
0.0095741618424654,
0.5458512902259827,
-0.09620683640241623,
-0.3024578094482422,
-0.3623929023742676,
-0.28781622648239136,
-0.09185484051704407,
-0.24420109391212463,
0.03360580652952194,
0.100691057741642,
0.007690011989325285,
-0.3651966452598572,
0.04782656952738762,
0.1587277203798294,
-0.2395278662443161,
-0.44004878401756287,
0.3249978721141815,
0.061218634247779846,
-0.06104784831404686,
0.5479960441589355,
-0.5089993476867676,
-0.5675957202911377,
0.4523308277130127,
0.6841803193092346,
0.9375370740890503,
-0.5583676099777222,
0.45789286494255066,
0.4341892600059509,
0.5047216415405273,
-0.5842245817184448,
0.4487206041812897,
0.5635005235671997,
-0.8376311659812927,
-0.7087212800979614,
-0.19998802244663239,
-0.39159509539604187,
0.13038672506809235,
-0.48519644141197205,
0.4501423239707947,
-0.306903213262558,
-0.13393229246139526,
-0.08700532466173172,
-0.11387389153242111,
-0.30766940116882324,
0.043466102331876755,
0.013807207345962524,
0.4857978820800781,
-1.043363094329834,
0.7034724354743958,
0.9080289602279663,
-0.4766787886619568,
-0.7964942455291748,
0.039745625108480453,
0.40586304664611816,
-0.5744633078575134,
0.3442849814891815,
-0.16714216768741608,
-0.32861000299453735,
0.05834313854575157,
-0.32332971692085266,
-0.7017103433609009,
0.8413521647453308,
0.592107355594635,
-0.34257569909095764,
0.012155035510659218,
0.15382660925388336,
0.6095942258834839,
-0.09499827772378922,
0.14370359480381012,
0.9497928619384766,
0.5744825005531311,
-0.21074099838733673,
-1.4554331302642822,
-0.07938382774591446,
-0.24864420294761658,
0.21190664172172546,
0.3866918683052063,
-0.43154600262641907,
0.948948323726654,
-0.13528183102607727,
-0.14087951183319092,
0.29776692390441895,
0.20285633206367493,
-0.008426888845860958,
-0.26067957282066345,
0.21202538907527924,
0.7953464388847351,
0.6825016140937805,
-0.5141182541847229,
0.972870945930481,
0.15971973538398743,
0.7250319719314575,
1.1758818626403809,
-0.252856969833374,
0.8228045105934143,
0.36243143677711487,
-0.34413543343544006,
0.4336521029472351,
0.653944730758667,
-0.2351939082145691,
0.2873671054840088,
0.08423663675785065,
-0.5016749501228333,
0.1418095976114273,
0.320281058549881,
-0.44007131457328796,
0.27095457911491394,
0.24806690216064453,
-0.09670610725879669,
-0.3229423463344574,
-0.1947394162416458,
0.5950836539268494,
-0.027285167947411537,
-0.3057720959186554,
0.6837027668952942,
-0.39480292797088623,
-0.829555332660675,
0.3101657032966614,
0.2600823640823364,
0.4123494029045105,
-0.3753267824649811,
-0.2230813056230545,
-0.30574360489845276,
0.4916676878929138,
-0.3211788535118103,
-0.7866305112838745,
0.3057524859905243,
0.33481356501579285,
-0.16946834325790405,
-0.09362831711769104,
0.6783119440078735,
-0.39465147256851196,
-0.5883681178092957,
0.03380056098103523,
0.5520730018615723,
0.04528201371431351,
-0.33331334590911865,
-0.4057127833366394,
-0.11779027432203293,
-0.09388317167758942,
0.007959499955177307,
-0.057977210730314255,
0.35279831290245056,
-0.034361474215984344,
0.15813347697257996,
0.39797815680503845,
0.3435229957103729,
0.033044978976249695,
0.5773747563362122,
0.5308293104171753,
-0.8274312019348145,
-0.5463274121284485,
-1.0170576572418213,
0.5944417715072632,
0.03340422734618187,
-0.4639700651168823,
0.8233525156974792,
0.5527724623680115,
1.1881862878799438,
-0.4159931540489197,
0.9135547876358032,
-0.2608030438423157,
0.4625752568244934,
-0.8335532546043396,
0.2152823656797409,
-0.02939537912607193,
0.034858252853155136,
-0.62479567527771,
-1.0119644403457642,
-1.0510587692260742,
0.8304400444030762,
-0.5787718296051025,
0.22365732491016388,
1.393014669418335,
0.8639629483222961,
0.17739225924015045,
0.14974120259284973,
0.4222323000431061,
0.16969262063503265,
0.2500455379486084,
0.4178179204463959,
0.7700214982032776,
-0.7143000960350037,
0.36689493060112,
-0.1743355095386505,
-0.17450766265392303,
-0.08491083979606628,
-0.8742024898529053,
-0.48207026720046997,
-0.42912188172340393,
-0.3685627579689026,
-0.2908022105693817,
0.6292765140533447,
0.7686768174171448,
0.4034046232700348,
-0.9504261016845703,
-0.17938435077667236,
-0.17163008451461792,
-0.09407113492488861,
-0.4425951838493347,
-0.1945374757051468,
0.33285677433013916,
-0.6847630143165588,
-0.8581560254096985,
0.333660364151001,
0.29507797956466675,
0.282218873500824,
-0.012051205150783062,
0.10269913077354431,
-0.3028436005115509,
-0.6587343215942383,
0.5728460550308228,
0.249106764793396,
-0.891124963760376,
-0.8682512640953064,
0.10548757016658783,
-0.07616309821605682,
0.19647039473056793,
0.9679287075996399,
-0.3902875781059265,
0.4004945158958435,
0.4424315392971039,
0.13265465199947357,
0.3098880648612976,
0.14943914115428925,
0.802060604095459,
-0.8587749600410461,
0.08615021407604218,
0.09063033759593964,
0.5571882128715515,
0.5639453530311584,
-0.48939698934555054,
0.8861072659492493,
0.5580553412437439,
-0.7917750477790833,
-0.32892051339149475,
0.006368380505591631,
-0.7080124020576477,
0.11347641795873642,
1.2521209716796875,
-0.20117059350013733,
0.07180777937173843,
-0.20631298422813416,
-0.43667668104171753,
0.19318430125713348,
-0.38203445076942444,
0.6571909189224243,
1.5501211881637573,
-0.18225079774856567,
-0.09616920351982117,
-1.165873646736145,
0.7075965404510498,
0.577078640460968,
-0.8986888527870178,
0.14678828418254852,
0.8426125645637512,
0.3822225034236908,
0.17045733332633972,
0.6032315492630005,
-0.5311148762702942,
0.5880641341209412,
-0.03316691890358925,
0.12290574610233307,
0.179575577378273,
-0.2147715538740158,
-0.8854350447654724,
-0.18666383624076843,
0.1282554417848587,
-0.1431029736995697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08468v1
|
Challenges and Opportunities in Text Generation Explainability
| 2024-05-14T09:44:52 | 2024-05-14T09:44:52 |
Kenza Amara, Rita Sevastjanova, Mennatallah El-Assady
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The necessity for interpretability in natural language processing (NLP) has
risen alongside the growing prominence of large language models. Among the
myriad tasks within NLP, text generation stands out as a primary objective of
autoregressive models. The NLP community has begun to take a keen interest in
gaining a deeper understanding of text generation, leading to the development
of model-agnostic explainable artificial intelligence (xAI) methods tailored to
this task. The design and evaluation of explainability methods are non-trivial
since they depend on many factors involved in the text generation process,
e.g., the autoregressive model and its stochastic nature. This paper outlines
17 challenges categorized into three groups that arise during the development
and assessment of attribution-based explainability methods. These challenges
encompass issues concerning tokenization, defining explanation similarity,
determining token importance and prediction change metrics, the level of human
intervention required, and the creation of suitable test datasets. The paper
illustrates how these challenges can be intertwined, showcasing new
opportunities for the community. These include developing probabilistic
word-level explainability methods and engaging humans in the explainability
pipeline, from the data design to the final evaluation, to draw robust
conclusions on xAI methods.
|
[
-0.17731168866157532,
-0.49137821793556213,
0.6996234059333801,
0.24654562771320343,
-0.07664281874895096,
0.20375500619411469,
0.04394795373082161,
-0.6000582575798035,
-0.2537834346294403,
0.19468370079994202,
-0.8883600234985352,
-0.022810399532318115,
-0.574593722820282,
0.26621127128601074,
-0.6560109257698059,
1.1065047979354858,
-0.5360317826271057,
-0.5557196736335754,
-0.42645400762557983,
-0.13747024536132812,
-0.44275981187820435,
-0.5412235856056213,
-0.9905235171318054,
-0.4017953872680664,
0.44330018758773804,
0.42064374685287476,
0.7133433222770691,
0.9646297693252563,
0.28369536995887756,
0.31888243556022644,
0.038901135325431824,
-0.10806334763765335,
-0.039977412670850754,
0.22895246744155884,
-0.18423672020435333,
-0.5181476473808289,
-0.07458551973104477,
-0.018098978325724602,
0.5290143489837646,
0.6535300612449646,
-0.23907946050167084,
0.28206583857536316,
-0.009331239387392998,
0.6831096410751343,
-0.4066283702850342,
0.09610854834318161,
-0.600924551486969,
0.03905955329537392,
-0.32817792892456055,
-0.2715888023376465,
-0.17742565274238586,
-0.24342933297157288,
0.1962622106075287,
-0.5767145752906799,
0.5395272374153137,
0.1387518048286438,
0.6896833777427673,
0.33516427874565125,
-0.3629657030105591,
-0.9827591776847839,
-0.6779512166976929,
0.76751309633255,
-0.772680401802063,
0.01774788275361061,
0.1828967034816742,
0.30205509066581726,
-0.14494632184505463,
-0.6914228200912476,
-0.7031295895576477,
0.050775591284036636,
-0.0016689073527231812,
-0.04833154007792473,
-0.32060468196868896,
-0.33361130952835083,
0.13377851247787476,
0.5752977132797241,
-0.5447234511375427,
0.30182933807373047,
0.09603694826364517,
0.1299641877412796,
0.7780332565307617,
0.22202280163764954,
0.3624686002731323,
-0.5717419981956482,
-0.2425602227449417,
-0.07964674383401871,
-0.3649722933769226,
0.21145586669445038,
0.7261374592781067,
0.14735659956932068,
0.11059926450252533,
0.39249753952026367,
-0.09610368311405182,
0.3313070237636566,
-0.215429425239563,
0.3690386414527893,
0.11595497280359268,
-0.6152665019035339,
-0.012293387204408646,
0.0029912611935287714,
0.6046174168586731,
-0.006384129635989666,
-0.04665710777044296,
-0.11407091468572617,
-0.14400909841060638,
-0.014772143214941025,
0.3236892521381378,
-0.41540324687957764,
-0.08474314212799072,
0.47556138038635254,
-0.810081958770752,
-0.8329157829284668,
-0.2670213580131531,
-0.7133823037147522,
-0.45507919788360596,
-0.16971322894096375,
0.3526313900947571,
-0.34410256147384644,
-0.5173607468605042,
-0.08922400325536728,
-0.3744392693042755,
0.44755885004997253,
0.22286517918109894,
-1.1571913957595825,
0.05642794072628021,
0.5715552568435669,
0.6430984735488892,
-0.16625434160232544,
-0.17841604351997375,
-0.08677113801240921,
0.16698649525642395,
-0.15437597036361694,
0.7183856964111328,
-0.20778322219848633,
-0.21482136845588684,
-0.10695188492536545,
-0.31541556119918823,
-0.17480994760990143,
-0.3582187592983246,
0.5617167949676514,
-0.062286149710416794,
0.4121127724647522,
-0.02339095249772072,
-0.44608351588249207,
-0.17065350711345673,
0.056759629398584366,
-0.4819459617137909,
0.624248206615448,
0.1896073967218399,
-0.7565839290618896,
0.5687302947044373,
-0.9893104434013367,
-0.46350064873695374,
0.17426742613315582,
-0.17525434494018555,
-0.4361587464809418,
0.4366793632507324,
0.1150001809000969,
0.15886852145195007,
-0.398489385843277,
0.47907620668411255,
0.1781539022922516,
0.12290679663419724,
0.43323853611946106,
-0.8834713101387024,
0.8312371969223022,
0.4054851531982422,
-0.6447893381118774,
0.14917342364788055,
-0.9999685883522034,
0.25904688239097595,
0.23792074620723724,
-0.05842125043272972,
-0.08898885548114777,
0.49774590134620667,
0.004169134888797998,
0.1984279751777649,
0.03470819443464279,
-0.09485045820474625,
-0.14415761828422546,
-0.5048590898513794,
0.8992034196853638,
0.6943562030792236,
0.04640889912843704,
0.24296000599861145,
-0.2970554232597351,
0.7431369423866272,
-0.010428082197904587,
0.16666334867477417,
-0.6839268803596497,
-0.688790500164032,
-0.6150102615356445,
0.19535553455352783,
0.1374310553073883,
0.5126990675926208,
-0.8560975790023804,
0.24139238893985748,
0.052391063421964645,
-0.7211108207702637,
-0.5409262180328369,
0.2029455453157425,
0.44250547885894775,
0.5225096940994263,
0.12482372671365738,
-0.07810918241739273,
-0.5158751606941223,
-0.9056304693222046,
-0.5446788668632507,
-0.5836933851242065,
-0.13199520111083984,
0.06717231869697571,
0.46358054876327515,
-0.21827712655067444,
1.0729022026062012,
-0.3153761029243469,
0.05748331546783447,
-0.4518173933029175,
0.8176693916320801,
0.03510940074920654,
0.6228635907173157,
0.257929265499115,
-1.064827799797058,
-0.2048717886209488,
-0.10571844130754471,
-0.891130805015564,
-0.3078622817993164,
-0.5740644931793213,
0.2331668883562088,
0.2713813781738281,
0.5742734670639038,
-0.520348846912384,
0.64629065990448,
0.2181660383939743,
-0.3706730008125305,
0.5501131415367126,
-0.42345884442329407,
0.019304046407341957,
-0.985196590423584,
0.08347014337778091,
0.03551056981086731,
-0.23503799736499786,
-0.7965806126594543,
0.18854622542858124,
-0.26383066177368164,
-0.37000778317451477,
-0.3915846645832062,
0.48528027534484863,
-0.45182734727859497,
0.2378053516149521,
-0.3514564633369446,
0.18491196632385254,
0.050785791128873825,
0.03344489261507988,
-0.10565773397684097,
0.4378443956375122,
0.28075993061065674,
-0.6363646984100342,
0.30517005920410156,
0.3660549521446228,
-0.32529425621032715,
0.2181514948606491,
-0.8021001219749451,
-0.3049429953098297,
-0.35219234228134155,
0.15334467589855194,
-0.8628605604171753,
-0.2916319966316223,
0.2586250603199005,
-0.695934534072876,
0.02635486051440239,
0.4341219663619995,
-0.4843274652957916,
-0.4300621449947357,
-0.11404040455818176,
0.4582729637622833,
0.499497652053833,
-0.4788915812969208,
0.4795992374420166,
0.0737040787935257,
-0.4115680158138275,
-0.41089609265327454,
-0.6304111480712891,
0.4629437327384949,
-0.6807543635368347,
-0.6036092042922974,
0.3650641441345215,
-0.08790898323059082,
-0.473616361618042,
-0.10478238016366959,
0.1455938071012497,
-0.04947026073932648,
0.49372631311416626,
0.2628178894519806,
-0.0984075665473938,
0.0081236707046628,
0.20306554436683655,
0.07507305592298508,
-0.5651013851165771,
0.4943043291568756,
-0.09002025425434113,
0.03949172794818878,
0.05933299660682678,
-0.23670494556427002,
-0.493520587682724,
0.6319561004638672,
0.0913931354880333,
0.03899131715297699,
0.524844765663147,
0.5926517844200134,
-0.39241352677345276,
-0.2789963185787201,
-0.14173109829425812,
0.1180996224284172,
-0.4602164328098297,
0.30212727189064026,
-0.28335368633270264,
-0.4021262228488922,
0.6704699993133545,
0.13716286420822144,
0.2627304792404175,
0.7118446230888367,
0.6235462427139282,
-0.009299339726567268,
1.2643541097640991,
0.777803897857666,
0.4559774398803711,
0.3773038387298584,
0.2204309105873108,
0.3996638059616089,
-0.23786182701587677,
-0.02487925998866558,
-0.581640362739563,
-0.1471196860074997,
-0.7065838575363159,
-0.16093523800373077,
-0.21492482721805573,
0.08133073151111603,
0.2403060793876648,
0.3502878248691559,
-0.5571028590202332,
0.2475854456424713,
0.6721639633178711,
-0.3302643597126007,
0.47437581419944763,
-0.16351568698883057,
0.35024625062942505,
-0.0862535908818245,
-0.80401611328125,
-0.671984851360321,
0.7282360196113586,
0.5886686444282532,
0.42094460129737854,
0.16876879334449768,
0.5539951324462891,
0.3642726242542267,
0.343320369720459,
-0.474465548992157,
0.3003003001213074,
-0.05515958368778229,
-0.6759346723556519,
-0.41686490178108215,
-0.571709394454956,
-0.8506613373756409,
-0.01432939525693655,
-0.4280581474304199,
-0.6785569190979004,
0.09448379278182983,
0.35905972123146057,
-0.2657932937145233,
0.11908692121505737,
-0.8889767527580261,
0.9394698739051819,
-0.2274981141090393,
-0.004346905276179314,
-0.015916744247078896,
-0.8138738870620728,
0.2848030626773834,
-0.36112624406814575,
0.3972499966621399,
0.01692301407456398,
0.01786852814257145,
0.7712250351905823,
-0.455797404050827,
0.5903470516204834,
-0.20771414041519165,
-0.38560643792152405,
0.42231976985931396,
-0.34147408604621887,
0.27529749274253845,
0.04431270435452461,
-0.22144226729869843,
-0.11333129554986954,
-0.017108047381043434,
-0.18727731704711914,
-0.7404971122741699,
0.44642555713653564,
-0.489147812128067,
-0.6413394212722778,
-0.19248226284980774,
-0.5440244674682617,
-0.1019635871052742,
0.008135839365422726,
0.6644073128700256,
0.4423286020755768,
-0.14143413305282593,
-0.09453681111335754,
0.5707288384437561,
-0.588836133480072,
0.64897221326828,
-0.0038742702454328537,
-0.24048574268817902,
-0.1322873830795288,
1.2030712366104126,
0.09339020401239395,
0.2110559046268463,
0.13523919880390167,
0.37617409229278564,
-0.24525748193264008,
-0.7822408676147461,
-0.5924116969108582,
-0.17448945343494415,
-0.5903238654136658,
0.10186000168323517,
-0.5707319974899292,
-0.24153953790664673,
-0.29555732011795044,
-0.4076778292655945,
-0.06244931370019913,
-0.6541652083396912,
-0.5842640399932861,
-0.0887317806482315,
0.06930003315210342,
0.8119531869888306,
-0.06691626459360123,
0.5889797806739807,
-0.6069304347038269,
0.3306760787963867,
0.29186809062957764,
0.22282537817955017,
0.28287920355796814,
-0.4049302339553833,
-0.22441181540489197,
-0.02238226868212223,
-0.3586261570453644,
-0.7857718467712402,
0.39091458916664124,
0.09833415597677231,
0.5025979280471802,
0.4064677953720093,
0.08837684988975525,
0.4736482501029968,
-0.36471644043922424,
0.8121616840362549,
0.28601622581481934,
-1.1881511211395264,
0.790863573551178,
-0.30038270354270935,
0.18475991487503052,
0.5827212333679199,
0.3206821084022522,
-0.42962828278541565,
-0.5547299385070801,
-0.9635805487632751,
-1.3249353170394897,
0.49889591336250305,
0.6986576318740845,
0.11570809781551361,
-0.009834027849137783,
0.7748000025749207,
0.5225008726119995,
0.33956223726272583,
-0.7764797806739807,
-0.2551405727863312,
-0.26395511627197266,
-0.46946150064468384,
-0.19068515300750732,
-0.16593031585216522,
0.06821568310260773,
0.14072442054748535,
0.709113359451294,
0.01875385455787182,
0.15378040075302124,
0.0671357810497284,
-0.1234687939286232,
-0.027085453271865845,
0.4126218557357788,
0.6980550289154053,
0.8508249521255493,
0.0046942285262048244,
-0.042274050414562225,
-0.08403994888067245,
-0.10845757275819778,
0.2628338932991028,
0.2886847257614136,
-0.26450252532958984,
0.07103753089904785,
0.5269591212272644,
0.9238380193710327,
-0.16848325729370117,
-0.6138712763786316,
0.44800513982772827,
-0.2589971125125885,
-0.5296436548233032,
-0.5626983046531677,
0.24294383823871613,
-0.11475037783384323,
0.07249055802822113,
0.738634467124939,
-0.09828320145606995,
0.1545775681734085,
-0.5910887122154236,
0.03404825180768967,
0.2552000880241394,
-0.5637757182121277,
-0.3165842592716217,
1.0986461639404297,
0.16713295876979828,
-0.47056251764297485,
0.4153170883655548,
-0.3779260516166687,
-0.19277772307395935,
0.8641583919525146,
0.5514815449714661,
0.9130617380142212,
-0.021009117364883423,
0.40079498291015625,
-0.017843397334218025,
0.3683396577835083,
0.20823855698108673,
0.0617978610098362,
-0.04679429903626442,
-0.5574695467948914,
-0.41219642758369446,
-0.3174762427806854,
-0.47400689125061035,
0.1039237231016159,
-0.6689296960830688,
0.12764377892017365,
-0.15125392377376556,
-0.020757153630256653,
0.4457343518733978,
-0.16600912809371948,
-0.3300764262676239,
0.4063538908958435,
-0.022738683968782425,
0.8796985745429993,
-0.9831801652908325,
0.21653984487056732,
0.5262835025787354,
-0.38164302706718445,
-0.4069109857082367,
0.030453553423285484,
0.03171404451131821,
-0.7074629664421082,
0.4660569429397583,
0.380447655916214,
0.17156705260276794,
0.03601740300655365,
-0.5889175534248352,
-0.4208053648471832,
0.9239656329154968,
0.11566855013370514,
-0.06989658623933792,
-0.5012742280960083,
0.22213436663150787,
0.6101190447807312,
-0.43176063895225525,
0.19864097237586975,
0.4751247465610504,
0.5833232402801514,
-0.03451051935553551,
-0.3595844507217407,
0.08151116222143173,
-0.31317856907844543,
0.32366040349006653,
0.0377376489341259,
-0.31725284457206726,
0.4675297439098358,
-0.30140379071235657,
-0.425353080034256,
0.21631601452827454,
0.8797218203544617,
0.1275995969772339,
0.5843830108642578,
0.8218201398849487,
0.3127329647541046,
0.6139116883277893,
-0.05153890326619148,
1.007194995880127,
0.014294668100774288,
-0.0473901741206646,
1.1254924535751343,
0.09403426945209503,
0.5573185682296753,
0.6152756214141846,
0.087714783847332,
0.5965535044670105,
0.7039114236831665,
0.019241483882069588,
0.13605248928070068,
0.5378278493881226,
-0.3572460412979126,
0.010235821828246117,
-0.07052803039550781,
-0.22209414839744568,
0.5920811295509338,
0.3284318447113037,
-0.6485157012939453,
-0.24869965016841888,
0.35213321447372437,
-0.1227756217122078,
0.2485308051109314,
-0.28698039054870605,
0.8006574511528015,
-0.048302408307790756,
-0.5674676299095154,
-0.024114487692713737,
0.1270449161529541,
0.40331682562828064,
-0.5486334562301636,
-0.055213768035173416,
0.23505116999149323,
0.07897913455963135,
-0.33297014236450195,
-0.7645708322525024,
0.6962774395942688,
0.042549580335617065,
-0.5697391033172607,
-0.6068801283836365,
0.6799178123474121,
-0.15342871844768524,
-0.4271557033061981,
0.016766458749771118,
0.547572135925293,
0.16997788846492767,
-0.05114138498902321,
-0.7592611312866211,
-0.19666308164596558,
0.27157166600227356,
-0.4002576470375061,
0.19619514048099518,
0.7488941550254822,
-0.12879115343093872,
0.9708951115608215,
0.49104776978492737,
-0.016122203320264816,
-0.049261439591646194,
-0.2179267406463623,
0.566441535949707,
-0.8465409278869629,
-0.44175204634666443,
-0.8809049129486084,
0.6066198945045471,
0.06611239910125732,
-0.49603158235549927,
0.6686825156211853,
0.11011683940887451,
0.19343702495098114,
0.21575042605400085,
1.114088535308838,
-0.3185901641845703,
0.5697930455207825,
-0.3430728018283844,
0.812637209892273,
-0.4383380711078644,
0.14419670403003693,
-0.30098435282707214,
-0.650714099407196,
-0.21261656284332275,
0.3785954713821411,
0.029789896681904793,
0.02930564247071743,
0.5899407267570496,
0.18459077179431915,
0.32338815927505493,
0.22416895627975464,
-0.02663346379995346,
0.003653873223811388,
0.5058883428573608,
0.4045078754425049,
0.8201521039009094,
-0.4826752245426178,
0.9018532037734985,
0.024746377021074295,
-0.46373888850212097,
0.07245300710201263,
-1.2547848224639893,
-0.3980335295200348,
-0.7835837602615356,
-0.5862971544265747,
-0.18579421937465668,
-0.19132034480571747,
0.3682481348514557,
0.3812049329280853,
-0.5935491323471069,
0.010289814323186874,
-0.5882424712181091,
0.3019189238548279,
-0.30818676948547363,
-0.32069429755210876,
0.08763515949249268,
-0.5361712574958801,
-0.5402097702026367,
0.2191329449415207,
0.018711699172854424,
0.1963912695646286,
-0.39866310358047485,
0.2814790904521942,
-0.056744277477264404,
0.1259339451789856,
0.5056333541870117,
0.5901214480400085,
-0.3456597328186035,
-0.2852242887020111,
-0.4069936275482178,
0.2776781916618347,
-0.16687576472759247,
0.8787479996681213,
-0.6938795447349548,
0.4792291522026062,
0.31540539860725403,
0.6948897838592529,
0.1509723961353302,
0.14537671208381653,
1.1555495262145996,
-0.6179194450378418,
-0.16620826721191406,
-0.04689977318048477,
0.005632439628243446,
0.4131174087524414,
-0.40101832151412964,
0.5271676778793335,
0.016635848209261894,
-0.709574282169342,
-0.9070622324943542,
0.577789843082428,
-0.48726585507392883,
-0.273298978805542,
0.6336133480072021,
-0.12370136380195618,
-0.13335812091827393,
-0.4826628863811493,
0.04439590126276016,
0.3677044212818146,
0.015130450017750263,
0.687584638595581,
0.8365525007247925,
-0.39983445405960083,
-0.37559986114501953,
-0.7093827128410339,
0.8197405338287354,
0.39855122566223145,
-1.0172100067138672,
0.609160840511322,
0.1645156890153885,
-0.1272418051958084,
0.3727394938468933,
0.4948391020298004,
-0.12264831364154816,
0.02172270230948925,
0.13739942014217377,
0.034009840339422226,
0.02142929844558239,
-0.020859796553850174,
-0.5007455945014954,
0.13223667442798615,
0.08322153985500336,
0.15334101021289825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08460v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08460v1
|
Evaluating LLMs at Evaluating Temporal Generalization
| 2024-05-14T09:31:31 | 2024-05-14T09:31:31 |
Chenghao Zhu, Nuo Chen, Yufei Gao, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) highlights the urgent
need for evolving evaluation methodologies that keep pace with improvements in
language comprehension and information processing. However, traditional
benchmarks, which are often static, fail to capture the continually changing
information landscape, leading to a disparity between the perceived and actual
effectiveness of LLMs in ever-changing real-world scenarios. Furthermore, these
benchmarks do not adequately measure the models' capabilities over a broader
temporal range or their adaptability over time. We examine current LLMs in
terms of temporal generalization and bias, revealing that various temporal
biases emerge in both language likelihood and prognostic prediction. This
serves as a caution for LLM practitioners to pay closer attention to mitigating
temporal biases. Also, we propose an evaluation framework Freshbench for
dynamically generating benchmarks from the most recent real-world
prognostication prediction. Our code is available at
https://github.com/FreedomIntelligence/FreshBench. The dataset will be released
soon.
|
[
-0.09129095077514648,
-0.718011200428009,
0.9221677780151367,
0.49661239981651306,
-0.16443361341953278,
0.18479086458683014,
-0.3807109296321869,
-0.43791282176971436,
-0.27583321928977966,
0.051996517926454544,
-0.5671189427375793,
-0.5624510049819946,
-0.48881441354751587,
-0.04917663708329201,
-0.31584566831588745,
0.8783451914787292,
-0.01784261129796505,
0.265520304441452,
-0.25488027930259705,
-0.19727955758571625,
-0.3361867070198059,
-0.47875016927719116,
-0.6435546875,
-0.6732340455055237,
0.27532505989074707,
-0.0007796849240548909,
0.7052843570709229,
0.5584931373596191,
0.4424148499965668,
0.23409049212932587,
-0.24562229216098785,
-0.2874949276447296,
-0.3891029953956604,
0.2762623131275177,
-0.28650668263435364,
-0.4343888759613037,
-0.4478747844696045,
0.0959024652838707,
0.9677977561950684,
1.1108428239822388,
-0.24333122372627258,
0.20102733373641968,
-0.15468630194664001,
0.5616393089294434,
-0.7013112306594849,
0.16427160799503326,
-0.6987192630767822,
0.3461173176765442,
-0.11900801956653595,
-0.10050322860479355,
-0.26955127716064453,
-0.5897091627120972,
0.4166138172149658,
-0.47703254222869873,
0.022303303703665733,
0.023381048813462257,
0.5650578737258911,
0.12584805488586426,
-0.2927527129650116,
0.057982537895441055,
-0.9131559729576111,
0.9053175449371338,
-0.7786755561828613,
0.4715990424156189,
-0.0491216666996479,
0.8722606897354126,
-0.3387221395969391,
-0.924759030342102,
-0.18376199901103973,
-0.4997532069683075,
0.40116310119628906,
0.10718122869729996,
-0.3245614171028137,
-0.10017646104097366,
0.17567875981330872,
0.486661434173584,
-0.38710135221481323,
0.32212090492248535,
-0.09242094308137894,
-0.2245320975780487,
0.368044376373291,
0.479370653629303,
0.2160571962594986,
0.11613789945840836,
-0.38175347447395325,
0.1987161934375763,
-0.6128705739974976,
-0.07513376325368881,
0.3906009793281555,
-0.00006212558946572244,
-0.14549513161182404,
0.06814417988061905,
-0.3258480131626129,
0.5647444725036621,
-0.2321525365114212,
0.03688522055745125,
0.381255179643631,
-0.2618865370750427,
-0.316069632768631,
-0.2764333486557007,
0.7191062569618225,
0.6257614493370056,
0.4721549451351166,
-0.46046867966651917,
-0.014140038751065731,
0.007746551185846329,
0.22050414979457855,
-0.7303038239479065,
0.00901867263019085,
0.29080063104629517,
-0.529201090335846,
-0.3421621024608612,
-0.16538573801517487,
-0.9742498993873596,
-0.38355347514152527,
-0.14969401061534882,
0.059896644204854965,
-0.251292884349823,
-0.16875699162483215,
0.18421970307826996,
-0.18511782586574554,
-0.15292999148368835,
0.326463907957077,
-0.4084326922893524,
0.20051942765712738,
0.4622064530849457,
0.736129879951477,
-0.2276313155889511,
-0.18468941748142242,
-0.537185788154602,
0.14732123911380768,
-0.4006916582584381,
0.8231822848320007,
-0.7895182967185974,
-0.6033880710601807,
0.1190347746014595,
0.015191394835710526,
0.018428277224302292,
-0.7995729446411133,
0.6798784136772156,
-0.5245887637138367,
0.14455397427082062,
-0.02073916606605053,
-0.3341943323612213,
0.1260475218296051,
0.2753446698188782,
-0.4736807346343994,
0.8151669502258301,
0.16329769790172577,
-0.47348976135253906,
0.6341552138328552,
-0.32947638630867004,
-0.12074708193540573,
-0.0181643757969141,
-0.16811907291412354,
-0.5275170803070068,
0.27776363492012024,
0.25553789734840393,
0.4558078646659851,
-0.42626985907554626,
0.7497267127037048,
-0.6178795099258423,
-0.45113807916641235,
0.32711198925971985,
-0.5770016312599182,
0.35056886076927185,
0.30481094121932983,
-0.35152924060821533,
0.1694534420967102,
-0.7288906574249268,
0.09158999472856522,
0.13751038908958435,
-0.42562150955200195,
-0.16783766448497772,
0.37890198826789856,
-0.04284530133008957,
-0.02895815670490265,
0.2563649117946625,
-0.4064129590988159,
0.2646884322166443,
-0.44150272011756897,
0.4394402801990509,
0.8799622058868408,
0.2043355107307434,
0.3623190224170685,
-0.33469218015670776,
0.5820084810256958,
0.0809415802359581,
0.4225544035434723,
-0.001904584001749754,
-0.20758883655071259,
-0.5644499659538269,
0.054664600640535355,
0.2358669638633728,
0.45789408683776855,
-0.4686618149280548,
0.1873069703578949,
-0.6996446251869202,
-0.599858820438385,
-0.06509428471326828,
-0.0072196898981928825,
0.5389971137046814,
0.22807717323303223,
0.27116525173187256,
-0.417928546667099,
-0.7109634280204773,
-1.111860990524292,
-0.5457870960235596,
-0.22206874191761017,
-0.2528007924556732,
0.13265438377857208,
0.2079225778579712,
-0.63279789686203,
0.8125964403152466,
-0.22443576157093048,
-0.08999807387590408,
-0.2652256190776825,
-0.0014119661645963788,
0.32051053643226624,
0.24265633523464203,
0.5365597009658813,
-0.3219894468784332,
0.02216576226055622,
-0.137053981423378,
-0.7992217540740967,
-0.31627559661865234,
-0.040023643523454666,
0.20100361108779907,
0.0858321562409401,
0.5638160109519958,
-0.07619250565767288,
0.25116628408432007,
0.5931310653686523,
-0.05923430249094963,
0.7619093060493469,
0.029753530398011208,
0.11237569898366928,
-0.6449151039123535,
0.04784678667783737,
0.029394013807177544,
-0.14245030283927917,
-0.46463581919670105,
0.013667743653059006,
-0.19994883239269257,
0.03745001554489136,
-0.4052318036556244,
0.9377397298812866,
-0.5827431082725525,
-0.22817286849021912,
-0.07412971556186676,
0.20992594957351685,
-0.312318354845047,
0.0665174126625061,
-0.1499851495027542,
0.6727299094200134,
0.4133497178554535,
-0.5630171298980713,
0.08101645857095718,
-0.3238872289657593,
-0.6991791725158691,
0.17501330375671387,
-0.626288652420044,
0.005638535600155592,
-0.10697567462921143,
0.40348684787750244,
-0.5438570976257324,
0.014526034705340862,
0.033426433801651,
-0.16068793833255768,
0.3417221009731293,
-0.1880301684141159,
-0.39651456475257874,
-0.3621756434440613,
-0.43819791078567505,
0.40361088514328003,
0.44394275546073914,
-0.3017159700393677,
0.6127462983131409,
0.21922358870506287,
-0.20012201368808746,
-0.476962149143219,
-0.6410015821456909,
0.17127428948879242,
-0.2105785608291626,
-0.4570768177509308,
0.355404257774353,
-0.200881689786911,
-0.8286527991294861,
0.04363313317298889,
-0.33768704533576965,
0.3060941696166992,
0.2726805508136749,
0.1872808039188385,
0.17001040279865265,
-0.1583632528781891,
0.16039887070655823,
0.003770628944039345,
-0.20178520679473877,
0.06438934803009033,
-0.20676790177822113,
0.5809582471847534,
-0.3017883896827698,
-0.4458000063896179,
-0.024952391162514687,
-0.024742623791098595,
0.48804140090942383,
0.05551201105117798,
0.668403685092926,
0.5704674124717712,
-0.39293375611305237,
-0.108366459608078,
-0.9528767466545105,
0.014192265458405018,
-0.38521578907966614,
0.5873766541481018,
-0.2764708995819092,
-0.7998813390731812,
0.6326257586479187,
-0.4504055380821228,
0.10595937073230743,
0.5235946774482727,
0.6970600485801697,
0.18149004876613617,
0.7955455183982849,
0.3288770914077759,
-0.18839745223522186,
0.5681085586547852,
-0.15297023952007294,
0.023059286177158356,
-1.0666766166687012,
-0.3457570970058441,
-0.3018459677696228,
-0.19019605219364166,
-0.5186119675636292,
-0.45840322971343994,
0.5260892510414124,
0.22909151017665863,
-0.257120281457901,
-0.19714395701885223,
-0.2698782682418823,
0.26809796690940857,
0.07906118035316467,
-0.08210331946611404,
0.3055482506752014,
0.08305498212575912,
-0.3706526756286621,
-0.12719769775867462,
-0.5394652485847473,
-0.9100968837738037,
1.3664501905441284,
0.5692606568336487,
0.6955728530883789,
0.0291028693318367,
0.3574557900428772,
0.4332575798034668,
0.6073993444442749,
-0.3820936381816864,
0.6059682369232178,
-0.18939881026744843,
-0.4310884475708008,
-0.16535553336143494,
-0.5130917429924011,
-1.0878124237060547,
0.32984524965286255,
-0.024112703278660774,
-0.8545997738838196,
0.18528032302856445,
-0.07593885809183121,
-0.22249959409236908,
0.270311564207077,
-0.5665166974067688,
0.6448535323143005,
-0.27631112933158875,
-0.5996497869491577,
-0.2988150119781494,
-0.560873806476593,
0.3710152804851532,
-0.033218882977962494,
0.4765688180923462,
-0.5557344555854797,
-0.3202402889728546,
0.6976411938667297,
-0.20191796123981476,
0.8022539615631104,
-0.3869148790836334,
0.09626273065805435,
-0.010492956265807152,
-0.014827225357294083,
0.20823334157466888,
0.3261744976043701,
-0.5195840001106262,
0.2886841595172882,
0.18469767272472382,
-0.46356499195098877,
-0.45315444469451904,
0.9079208970069885,
-0.703100323677063,
-0.7042101621627808,
-0.5562604069709778,
-0.48882338404655457,
-0.6914597153663635,
-0.003028005827218294,
0.0840361937880516,
0.41733890771865845,
-0.7814295887947083,
-0.04895714670419693,
0.349500447511673,
-0.43639934062957764,
0.4623141586780548,
0.8473274111747742,
-0.37367546558380127,
-0.3005540072917938,
0.4886956810951233,
-0.036147527396678925,
0.3411971628665924,
0.24200890958309174,
0.3623712956905365,
-0.135811448097229,
-0.9123077988624573,
-0.4188341498374939,
0.09449827671051025,
-0.7273047566413879,
0.06663355976343155,
-0.6016607880592346,
-0.07272658497095108,
-0.26649951934814453,
-0.032052647322416306,
-0.09545718878507614,
-0.35266727209091187,
-0.08426619321107864,
-0.13822084665298462,
0.11400893330574036,
0.6874140501022339,
0.11379440128803253,
0.10423948615789413,
-0.8069161176681519,
0.03612726554274559,
0.0656648650765419,
0.36391833424568176,
0.012969539500772953,
-0.47475558519363403,
-0.20248183608055115,
-0.06653790175914764,
-0.22793349623680115,
-0.6168674826622009,
0.13634756207466125,
0.2964968681335449,
1.1959640979766846,
0.1921287477016449,
-0.2799700200557709,
0.5267866253852844,
-0.6557639837265015,
0.8284876346588135,
-0.0029978046659380198,
-0.7531545758247375,
0.589989960193634,
-0.3551875352859497,
0.7493464946746826,
0.5928648710250854,
0.2784785330295563,
-0.5012757778167725,
-0.45335912704467773,
-0.42702415585517883,
-0.843730628490448,
0.32654160261154175,
-0.13968758285045624,
0.0765347108244896,
-0.17735637724399567,
0.4784863591194153,
0.17531777918338776,
0.21123409271240234,
-0.5627639293670654,
-0.11476225405931473,
0.08296315371990204,
-0.02944951318204403,
-0.15201616287231445,
-0.5205194354057312,
-0.021748436614871025,
-0.07405804097652435,
0.5291617512702942,
-0.11858911067247391,
0.3698456585407257,
0.042819034308195114,
-0.09462060779333115,
-0.13753463327884674,
0.6502408981323242,
0.5598944425582886,
1.0242356061935425,
-0.4119625389575958,
-0.0857212170958519,
0.5275419354438782,
-0.3454119861125946,
0.1597166657447815,
0.3116901218891144,
-0.0299143698066473,
-0.045332036912441254,
0.7767504453659058,
0.6873660683631897,
0.5829988718032837,
-0.9003965258598328,
0.3834284842014313,
-0.07233498990535736,
0.11709436029195786,
-0.4782722592353821,
-0.007655270863324404,
0.04320080578327179,
0.34250783920288086,
0.516752302646637,
-0.046449948102235794,
0.11279147118330002,
-0.8614338040351868,
-0.08957812190055847,
0.40217599272727966,
-0.33030185103416443,
-0.3469693958759308,
0.6636067032814026,
0.10220668464899063,
0.07279324531555176,
0.5504798293113708,
-0.18142685294151306,
-0.46968698501586914,
0.5964732766151428,
0.29997819662094116,
1.0513055324554443,
-0.38139334321022034,
-0.21915508806705475,
0.198963925242424,
0.3472473621368408,
-0.03496408462524414,
0.1334874927997589,
0.28481951355934143,
-0.5632622838020325,
-0.4071115255355835,
-0.9170497059822083,
-0.3733280897140503,
0.11593979597091675,
-0.5418713092803955,
0.11798842251300812,
-0.5465543866157532,
-0.48165765404701233,
-0.30977383255958557,
0.009058119729161263,
-0.6911420226097107,
0.3291831910610199,
0.015992099419236183,
1.016707181930542,
-0.5902037024497986,
0.7515501976013184,
0.7489290237426758,
-0.17527249455451965,
-0.16494965553283691,
0.2353944331407547,
0.10987367480993271,
-0.9093092083930969,
0.7780560851097107,
0.06741903722286224,
-0.04838115721940994,
-0.3851287364959717,
-0.1266731321811676,
-0.6990699768066406,
1.264343500137329,
0.38043466210365295,
-0.8956063389778137,
-0.1789393573999405,
-0.04344528168439865,
0.8561191558837891,
-0.3502810597419739,
0.4414031207561493,
0.6209228038787842,
0.5978654026985168,
-0.27644750475883484,
-0.9454883933067322,
-0.09991446882486343,
-0.3411547839641571,
0.2632175385951996,
0.1886221170425415,
-0.5771620273590088,
0.5339024066925049,
-0.18774700164794922,
-0.44787123799324036,
0.12172748893499374,
0.5571590065956116,
0.22471269965171814,
0.49590736627578735,
0.4106188714504242,
0.6560338735580444,
0.4660341441631317,
-0.3314482867717743,
1.297748327255249,
-0.35903361439704895,
0.03147586062550545,
1.0630072355270386,
-0.4191540479660034,
0.761206865310669,
0.3639236092567444,
-0.49332645535469055,
0.6218507885932922,
0.4839842617511749,
-0.1033056378364563,
0.4210954010486603,
0.5652205348014832,
-0.29624563455581665,
-0.145980566740036,
-0.1466187834739685,
-0.6225513219833374,
-0.06586788594722748,
0.38579821586608887,
-0.4275209903717041,
-0.3248617351055145,
-0.02728872559964657,
0.055773671716451645,
0.18256504833698273,
-0.22704201936721802,
0.5629218816757202,
0.12160865217447281,
-0.6081204414367676,
0.3957478404045105,
0.1345263123512268,
0.6503679156303406,
-0.7747078537940979,
0.24539858102798462,
-0.2707955539226532,
0.36556458473205566,
-0.12204700708389282,
-0.7074283957481384,
0.43520355224609375,
-0.046404510736465454,
-0.33973318338394165,
-0.10516401380300522,
0.46648651361465454,
-0.07428938150405884,
-0.6945465803146362,
0.6010689735412598,
0.606793224811554,
0.07319461554288864,
0.14017054438591003,
-0.6626563668251038,
0.6410630941390991,
-0.14938634634017944,
-0.2897782623767853,
0.6122908592224121,
0.14918915927410126,
-0.34730878472328186,
1.0265848636627197,
0.4843701422214508,
0.30034270882606506,
0.08410537242889404,
0.5765410661697388,
0.7937399744987488,
-0.46774742007255554,
-0.010495384223759174,
-0.9567974209785461,
0.21229465305805206,
0.06805641949176788,
-0.24468083679676056,
0.6591790914535522,
0.6894596219062805,
0.712567925453186,
0.02805105410516262,
0.7473000288009644,
0.33943480253219604,
0.5549125075340271,
-0.6959750652313232,
0.4148319363594055,
-0.5386205315589905,
0.6459851861000061,
-0.18143761157989502,
-1.0483794212341309,
-0.21882161498069763,
0.15376654267311096,
-0.7232391238212585,
0.42795512080192566,
0.7475510239601135,
0.5196539759635925,
0.15954096615314484,
-0.10333122313022614,
0.3960050344467163,
0.24082931876182556,
0.34736761450767517,
0.6468534469604492,
1.028110384941101,
-0.15022215247154236,
0.4208603799343109,
-0.15756572782993317,
-0.39783546328544617,
-0.21461839973926544,
-1.1652227640151978,
-0.8499165177345276,
-0.29066094756126404,
-0.31937849521636963,
0.026067713275551796,
0.6441183090209961,
0.7493455410003662,
0.48842310905456543,
-0.703807532787323,
-0.20786665380001068,
0.11999712139368057,
-0.16883282363414764,
-0.10628221929073334,
-0.27219924330711365,
0.150723397731781,
-0.36020639538764954,
-0.7778297662734985,
0.7029173970222473,
0.4525637626647949,
-0.019669976085424423,
-0.4750679135322571,
0.02979210391640663,
-0.0321863517165184,
-0.033463168889284134,
0.4924171268939972,
0.05261842906475067,
-0.9903473854064941,
-0.26692721247673035,
-0.20215117931365967,
0.0716557726264,
-0.2119361311197281,
0.8420677781105042,
-0.9821967482566833,
0.4838548004627228,
0.32775047421455383,
0.5814185738563538,
0.4505991041660309,
-0.16818605363368988,
0.8433940410614014,
-0.43324822187423706,
-0.035711564123630524,
0.30207666754722595,
0.6163963675498962,
0.4531630873680115,
-0.09491700679063797,
0.805138885974884,
0.2655649781227112,
-0.6232420802116394,
-0.8508700728416443,
0.23222605884075165,
-0.6593852639198303,
-0.3170180916786194,
1.112541675567627,
-0.14239402115345,
0.027494274079799652,
-0.18969619274139404,
0.23860670626163483,
0.080793097615242,
-0.3566945195198059,
0.6234932541847229,
0.7763769626617432,
0.03955486789345741,
-0.023171503096818924,
-0.8880209922790527,
0.1968379020690918,
0.49980589747428894,
-0.8288761973381042,
-0.05759124457836151,
0.5589772462844849,
0.5478150248527527,
-0.03519956022500992,
0.5752034783363342,
-0.41909751296043396,
0.290101021528244,
-0.24628567695617676,
-0.04409029707312584,
-0.05928689241409302,
-0.0008208518847823143,
-0.5720653533935547,
0.016527846455574036,
0.33583223819732666,
0.3129171133041382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08454v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08454v1
|
How Alignment Helps Make the Most of Multimodal Data
| 2024-05-14T09:20:59 | 2024-05-14T09:20:59 |
Christian Arnold, Andreas Küpfer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
When studying political communication, combining the information from text,
audio, and video signals promises to reflect the richness of human
communication more comprehensively than confining it to individual modalities
alone. However, when modeling such multimodal data, its heterogeneity,
connectedness, and interaction are challenging to address. We argue that
aligning the respective modalities can be an essential step in entirely using
the potential of multimodal data because it informs the model with human
understanding. Exploring aligned modalities unlocks promising analytical
leverage. First, it allows us to make the most of information in the data,
which inter alia opens the door to better quality predictions. Second, it is
possible to answer research questions that span multiple modalities with
cross-modal queries. Finally, alignment addresses concerns about model
interpretability. We illustrate the utility of this approach by analyzing how
German MPs address members of the far-right AfD in their speeches, and
predicting the tone of video advertising in the context of the 2020 US
presidential race. Our paper offers important insights to all keen to analyze
multimodal data effectively.
|
[
-0.6700515151023865,
-0.5763335227966309,
0.5076513290405273,
-0.04959367215633392,
-0.3203883469104767,
0.1523459404706955,
-0.29778796434402466,
-0.3246803879737854,
0.17927539348602295,
0.1689324676990509,
-0.7414463758468628,
-0.29626891016960144,
-0.6013045907020569,
-0.25081130862236023,
-0.2999608814716339,
0.8734531998634338,
0.2726869285106659,
0.3485150933265686,
-0.25351130962371826,
-0.6328509449958801,
-0.4927932024002075,
-0.2676291763782501,
0.02340235561132431,
-0.4199255704879761,
0.596783459186554,
0.45556700229644775,
1.272762417793274,
0.9469621777534485,
0.6562228798866272,
0.3426956534385681,
0.3246900141239166,
0.0373084656894207,
-0.5086251497268677,
0.18795043230056763,
-0.2118956446647644,
-0.23735733330249786,
-0.29802781343460083,
0.3913573920726776,
0.6620445251464844,
0.7010900378227234,
0.036741506308317184,
0.03245823457837105,
-0.13830377161502838,
0.5043433308601379,
-0.5823274850845337,
-0.08533159643411636,
-0.5325276255607605,
-0.09756743162870407,
-0.4056742489337921,
-0.44326943159103394,
-0.17828676104545593,
0.09308776259422302,
0.1496524065732956,
-0.5368824601173401,
-0.16638833284378052,
0.08230854570865631,
0.9775504469871521,
0.30016642808914185,
-1.0678199529647827,
-0.17255863547325134,
-0.893440842628479,
0.7653623223304749,
-0.42593076825141907,
0.868159294128418,
0.14858011901378632,
0.5816180109977722,
-0.06328406929969788,
-0.29664018750190735,
-0.8346651196479797,
0.4408358335494995,
-0.05505254119634628,
0.18317639827728271,
-0.1114993691444397,
0.0779327005147934,
-0.08400804549455643,
0.2690980136394501,
-0.43739053606987,
-0.01933765597641468,
-0.3020140826702118,
-0.26562240719795227,
0.6319407224655151,
0.2687821388244629,
0.38367360830307007,
-0.42582181096076965,
-0.6261873245239258,
-0.29176852107048035,
-0.24882008135318756,
0.019598819315433502,
0.5967026948928833,
0.5567504167556763,
-0.25073739886283875,
0.8611717820167542,
0.040842995047569275,
0.9811073541641235,
0.17576149106025696,
-0.10548190027475357,
0.018502632156014442,
-0.9342736601829529,
-0.17692877352237701,
-0.02560172788798809,
0.8211540579795837,
0.6719591617584229,
-0.09692734479904175,
0.21173229813575745,
-0.062235746532678604,
0.320728063583374,
0.37409675121307373,
-0.438566118478775,
-0.08155525475740433,
0.304553359746933,
-0.6419459581375122,
0.04710734263062477,
0.2730936110019684,
-1.0141408443450928,
-0.4234578609466553,
-0.8643509745597839,
0.509257972240448,
-0.2855561077594757,
-0.37923574447631836,
-0.027713004499673843,
0.01761992648243904,
0.1080564334988594,
0.24822688102722168,
-0.9096199870109558,
-0.11003242433071136,
0.8430164456367493,
0.5574338436126709,
0.06020013242959976,
-0.0846470445394516,
-0.4797041714191437,
0.3167314827442169,
-0.344890296459198,
0.7116076350212097,
-0.958664059638977,
0.14051136374473572,
-0.005681600887328386,
-0.06050937995314598,
-0.07046110928058624,
-0.03182908892631531,
0.44823357462882996,
-0.5013120174407959,
0.7086663246154785,
-0.46472442150115967,
-0.44497212767601013,
-0.16134268045425415,
0.18655942380428314,
-1.041572093963623,
0.5065052509307861,
-0.3082692623138428,
-0.6866993308067322,
0.6913850903511047,
-0.5521149039268494,
-0.17562134563922882,
-0.6449206471443176,
-0.4152899384498596,
-0.4247087836265564,
0.20298607647418976,
0.27267903089523315,
0.3407495617866516,
-0.04165392741560936,
0.45592233538627625,
-0.44424739480018616,
0.09612179547548294,
0.31934744119644165,
-0.5026970505714417,
0.5634201765060425,
0.41793593764305115,
-0.1454620063304901,
0.27543649077415466,
-0.7655466198921204,
-0.307016521692276,
-0.36262887716293335,
-0.09845332056283951,
-0.42054927349090576,
0.17276091873645782,
0.2966221570968628,
0.4876570999622345,
0.053057193756103516,
-0.3986648917198181,
-0.043134938925504684,
0.14613619446754456,
0.27667710185050964,
1.0152878761291504,
-0.560127317905426,
0.8583593964576721,
-0.3296377956867218,
0.48645827174186707,
0.11231696605682373,
0.16289778053760529,
-0.2146914005279541,
-0.2604414224624634,
-0.13438671827316284,
-0.3493918180465698,
0.49162420630455017,
0.4064798951148987,
-0.39272764325141907,
0.049520667642354965,
-0.31089526414871216,
-0.4418618381023407,
-0.7889758348464966,
-0.0250377357006073,
0.11247264593839645,
0.3223641812801361,
0.01763036847114563,
-0.2798004448413849,
-0.7838638424873352,
-1.0153480768203735,
-0.3740652799606323,
-0.21677535772323608,
0.38056260347366333,
0.27087175846099854,
0.26964491605758667,
-0.025118175894021988,
0.9335751533508301,
-0.12550199031829834,
-0.06218568608164787,
0.18267294764518738,
0.3253312408924103,
-0.020417409017682076,
0.39451470971107483,
0.2426844835281372,
-1.4532318115234375,
-0.2838018238544464,
0.20002099871635437,
-0.49779748916625977,
-0.14753226935863495,
-0.4235501289367676,
-0.32767966389656067,
-0.08854996412992477,
0.26122742891311646,
-0.45651477575302124,
0.16968877613544464,
0.9857171773910522,
-0.4806208610534668,
-0.0662480890750885,
0.28201884031295776,
0.5997322797775269,
-1.189494013786316,
0.049446336925029755,
0.02627486176788807,
-0.3988550007343292,
-0.7339372634887695,
-0.5277326703071594,
-0.03366066515445709,
-0.19993773102760315,
-0.1702992022037506,
0.4631248712539673,
-0.5942984223365784,
-0.16705526411533356,
-0.04001151770353317,
0.10939996689558029,
0.05755879357457161,
0.005703624803572893,
-0.1605660766363144,
0.6723015308380127,
0.25582271814346313,
0.035450730472803116,
0.35854870080947876,
0.3875318765640259,
-0.5399775505065918,
0.9831222295761108,
-0.14307445287704468,
-0.04744381830096245,
-0.47520822286605835,
0.15571294724941254,
-1.5884790420532227,
-0.5841588973999023,
0.06634850054979324,
-0.5342717170715332,
0.2884535491466522,
0.15503208339214325,
-0.1419999748468399,
0.07034493237733841,
-0.12626859545707703,
0.6610980033874512,
-0.0925489142537117,
-0.3893960416316986,
0.9347856044769287,
0.7733671069145203,
0.012426376342773438,
-0.8423377275466919,
-0.4802507162094116,
0.02437749132514,
-0.47217369079589844,
-0.8586240410804749,
0.40099257230758667,
0.12573859095573425,
-0.34460780024528503,
0.06539866328239441,
-0.3510226011276245,
-0.06303069740533829,
-0.2159893661737442,
0.3737518787384033,
0.25560131669044495,
-0.2640095353126526,
0.29870837926864624,
-0.3573284447193146,
-0.09800665825605392,
-0.3583284318447113,
0.015420357696712017,
0.4583565890789032,
0.07574901729822159,
-0.6226486563682556,
-0.8583492636680603,
0.7051738500595093,
0.8668157458305359,
-0.16688165068626404,
0.6541292071342468,
0.7358452677726746,
-0.19808776676654816,
0.5226122140884399,
-0.6602923274040222,
-0.23933272063732147,
-0.4077240824699402,
0.2416491061449051,
-0.12045949697494507,
-0.6503923535346985,
0.5423120260238647,
0.054766133427619934,
0.07527770102024078,
0.052975431084632874,
0.45018842816352844,
-0.17748664319515228,
1.529541254043579,
1.0079411268234253,
-0.07760864496231079,
0.8790178894996643,
0.3082677721977234,
0.4387193024158478,
-0.38506704568862915,
-0.5538707375526428,
-0.4512409567832947,
-0.720834493637085,
-0.5555243492126465,
-0.3334932029247284,
0.39959433674812317,
-0.18292564153671265,
-0.02284197136759758,
0.20898902416229248,
-0.3800242245197296,
0.3466050326824188,
0.26505476236343384,
-0.13866202533245087,
0.18038716912269592,
0.17858880758285522,
0.427230566740036,
-0.48607945442199707,
-0.6024459004402161,
-0.4882390797138214,
0.8535146117210388,
0.3178342282772064,
1.0579943656921387,
0.16818486154079437,
0.3837078809738159,
0.00132572406437248,
0.08959197998046875,
-0.6064592003822327,
0.1714136302471161,
0.09711495041847229,
-0.8471341133117676,
-0.09226106852293015,
-0.24908943474292755,
-0.925652801990509,
0.4471035301685333,
-0.5327982902526855,
-0.4744579792022705,
0.3585127592086792,
0.17367905378341675,
-0.3685881793498993,
0.14555136859416962,
-0.6580255627632141,
0.9912294745445251,
-0.39276498556137085,
-0.32544267177581787,
-0.1689814031124115,
-1.113452434539795,
0.21667665243148804,
0.08736251294612885,
0.5731173157691956,
-0.2757743000984192,
-0.2830306589603424,
0.8384771347045898,
0.14974342286586761,
0.6887778639793396,
0.0536394827067852,
-0.09841082245111465,
-0.039524782449007034,
-0.4541969299316406,
0.0763312503695488,
-0.21680831909179688,
0.1972585916519165,
-0.2211022526025772,
0.06929510086774826,
-0.42285993695259094,
-0.6312471032142639,
0.4952680170536041,
-0.7308276295661926,
-0.6439272165298462,
-0.3422289192676544,
-1.0084184408187866,
-0.133601114153862,
0.07190312445163727,
-0.04912101849913597,
0.5141961574554443,
-0.23764577507972717,
0.3977534770965576,
0.39222264289855957,
0.44116753339767456,
0.3859100639820099,
0.06599927693605423,
-0.059833697974681854,
-0.6030962467193604,
0.8412653207778931,
0.259310781955719,
0.43110164999961853,
0.3763987123966217,
0.012899943627417088,
-0.5375643372535706,
-0.0010670977644622326,
-0.3575880527496338,
0.2270491123199463,
-0.6819067001342773,
-0.36245763301849365,
-0.590401828289032,
0.25336307287216187,
-0.39378994703292847,
-0.1411866992712021,
-0.47282910346984863,
-0.5432208776473999,
-0.24216648936271667,
-0.07219333201646805,
-0.11011087149381638,
0.5737128257751465,
-0.49411433935165405,
0.5498301982879639,
-0.4863739609718323,
0.317092627286911,
0.3178805112838745,
0.21725979447364807,
-0.3767749071121216,
-0.022242460399866104,
-0.11849605292081833,
0.32373732328414917,
-0.546503484249115,
-1.319899559020996,
0.05458598583936691,
0.3165484368801117,
0.5428247451782227,
0.6973406672477722,
-0.13121892511844635,
0.9751138687133789,
-0.439027339220047,
0.7958582639694214,
0.2640380263328552,
-0.8619080781936646,
0.36855611205101013,
-0.527660608291626,
0.10115519165992737,
0.5800974369049072,
0.7031504511833191,
-0.5815815329551697,
-0.1867375522851944,
-0.5612512826919556,
-0.6645714640617371,
0.500632643699646,
0.02121145650744438,
0.3054645359516144,
0.2765222489833832,
-0.14589491486549377,
0.23821821808815002,
0.33530205488204956,
-0.7070842981338501,
0.0077782487496733665,
-0.3945317566394806,
-0.49268877506256104,
-0.14293503761291504,
-0.08019813150167465,
-0.81643146276474,
-0.24808792769908905,
0.32460883259773254,
-0.2762005031108856,
0.26598212122917175,
-0.10094467550516129,
0.09589916467666626,
-0.4326353967189789,
0.2589176595211029,
0.786256730556488,
1.0195270776748657,
-0.06724227219820023,
0.31245312094688416,
-0.5343896150588989,
0.07397784292697906,
0.20363382995128632,
0.06461352854967117,
0.412070095539093,
0.09576903283596039,
0.38858333230018616,
0.6722453832626343,
-0.043635569512844086,
-0.49619728326797485,
0.643356204032898,
0.03885756805539131,
0.07914887368679047,
0.17721889913082123,
-0.2838248610496521,
0.1443576216697693,
0.5934661030769348,
0.2879225015640259,
0.22134549915790558,
-0.1439526379108429,
-0.9679757952690125,
0.39990222454071045,
1.1150161027908325,
-0.4616510272026062,
-0.3819218575954437,
0.842540442943573,
0.2222992181777954,
-0.27121812105178833,
0.34275227785110474,
0.4502047002315521,
-0.47215986251831055,
0.3733324706554413,
0.5063934922218323,
0.3288542926311493,
-0.388976126909256,
0.17596641182899475,
-0.10839536041021347,
0.16545313596725464,
0.1903381496667862,
0.2936720848083496,
-0.05481942743062973,
-0.7520464062690735,
-0.6219578981399536,
-0.3086076080799103,
-0.17527349293231964,
-0.07734213024377823,
-0.698159396648407,
0.31146663427352905,
-0.13645480573177338,
-0.5637727975845337,
0.5433735251426697,
-0.14915448427200317,
-0.3543824851512909,
0.15392781794071198,
0.39610758423805237,
0.5215643048286438,
-1.4621186256408691,
0.38651877641677856,
0.6735501289367676,
-0.17775937914848328,
-0.6706995964050293,
-0.18660159409046173,
0.6500527858734131,
-0.7288285493850708,
0.3478933572769165,
0.16207733750343323,
-0.03341449424624443,
-0.3767171800136566,
-0.7183691263198853,
-0.7749871611595154,
0.865206778049469,
0.501544713973999,
-0.3154197633266449,
0.04100887477397919,
0.2407311052083969,
0.20105765759944916,
-0.6470937132835388,
0.17281244695186615,
0.34953024983406067,
0.7351701855659485,
0.0255897119641304,
-0.9350346922874451,
-0.03672788292169571,
-0.13957063853740692,
-0.1663406789302826,
0.6507812738418579,
-0.6702134013175964,
0.9326152205467224,
0.07951536029577255,
-0.5049600601196289,
-0.2798233926296234,
0.8826050758361816,
-0.34742024540901184,
0.568686306476593,
0.5643686056137085,
0.5253923535346985,
0.7440496683120728,
-0.1701786369085312,
0.739429235458374,
-0.17897355556488037,
0.1537110060453415,
0.8370813727378845,
-0.03281242400407791,
0.4326731562614441,
1.0332998037338257,
0.18943805992603302,
0.4263036847114563,
0.5959088206291199,
0.07500921189785004,
0.6171557903289795,
-0.4356098175048828,
-0.23991361260414124,
-0.5681139826774597,
-0.34192413091659546,
-0.30614539980888367,
0.8889508247375488,
0.23877505958080292,
-0.07747310400009155,
-0.40062496066093445,
0.24544237554073334,
-0.10289793461561203,
0.5631647109985352,
0.13254381716251373,
0.8078373074531555,
-0.3033770024776459,
-0.7405456304550171,
0.21391287446022034,
-0.45989689230918884,
0.39691993594169617,
-0.37210190296173096,
-0.054300710558891296,
0.12815934419631958,
-0.06913647055625916,
-0.37606632709503174,
-0.8505905270576477,
0.4962383210659027,
-0.5658299922943115,
-0.4131793975830078,
-0.31610313057899475,
0.38268035650253296,
-0.8237305879592896,
-0.11222080886363983,
0.08060526102781296,
0.6115268468856812,
-0.22790201008319855,
0.3731307089328766,
-0.6503901481628418,
0.4654885232448578,
0.1181289479136467,
-0.09206530451774597,
0.35666003823280334,
0.46741873025894165,
-0.02900826185941696,
0.48606356978416443,
0.6876131892204285,
-0.12070434540510178,
0.054206348955631256,
-0.315883606672287,
0.9543622136116028,
-0.4952659606933594,
-0.208279088139534,
-0.9914804100990295,
0.852239191532135,
-0.2510935962200165,
-0.22911950945854187,
0.6905204653739929,
0.565839946269989,
0.807239294052124,
0.330304354429245,
0.522112250328064,
-0.1941925585269928,
0.09826046973466873,
-0.49950018525123596,
0.4232909679412842,
-0.8220706582069397,
-0.11149059981107712,
-0.23285487294197083,
-0.8107378482818604,
-0.26059356331825256,
0.6946670413017273,
-0.32194533944129944,
-0.1654568761587143,
0.452259361743927,
0.9626005291938782,
-0.5673649311065674,
0.3484935760498047,
0.10180798172950745,
-0.08701254427433014,
0.4529373049736023,
0.28493794798851013,
1.090478539466858,
-0.3475988209247589,
0.6888753175735474,
-0.43983152508735657,
-0.11997434496879578,
-0.1686580330133438,
-0.9764352440834045,
-0.6169542074203491,
-1.0921142101287842,
-0.06900784373283386,
-0.38529276847839355,
-0.04065053537487984,
0.884750485420227,
1.0553255081176758,
-0.42098429799079895,
-0.31335002183914185,
0.5199881196022034,
0.23408059775829315,
-0.1646241396665573,
-0.1663002073764801,
0.22541946172714233,
-0.14462830126285553,
-0.9671233296394348,
0.09972672164440155,
0.29568883776664734,
0.10918544232845306,
-0.06577712297439575,
0.2118893563747406,
-0.687161386013031,
0.17275992035865784,
0.34009796380996704,
0.20764076709747314,
-0.7704309225082397,
-0.596146821975708,
-0.04773781821131706,
-0.23795057833194733,
0.3223842978477478,
1.0845377445220947,
-0.4412287771701813,
0.810840368270874,
0.7131275534629822,
0.6725866794586182,
0.06237257644534111,
0.648488461971283,
0.9426742196083069,
-0.6076350808143616,
0.33135277032852173,
0.2611261010169983,
0.028134528547525406,
0.6005982160568237,
-0.2606795132160187,
0.32343828678131104,
-0.09549126774072647,
-0.7333866953849792,
-0.9317921996116638,
0.3972298800945282,
-1.2861597537994385,
-0.14644227921962738,
0.9196897745132446,
0.43206650018692017,
-0.24736468493938446,
-0.08128669857978821,
-0.3192380964756012,
0.4770667552947998,
-0.3203234374523163,
0.5695939660072327,
1.0586315393447876,
-0.2808854579925537,
-0.3176557123661041,
-0.7507289052009583,
0.5155141949653625,
0.7137006521224976,
-0.43220072984695435,
-0.009260361082851887,
0.7564753890037537,
0.05597701668739319,
0.41030633449554443,
0.4473579227924347,
-0.06581813842058182,
0.2051628977060318,
-0.12295234948396683,
-0.49255552887916565,
0.25338664650917053,
-0.5209099650382996,
-0.3435615301132202,
0.2370481640100479,
-0.43654051423072815,
-0.4292393922805786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08427v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08427v1
|
Impact of Stickers on Multimodal Chat Sentiment Analysis and Intent Recognition: A New Task, Dataset and Baseline
| 2024-05-14T08:42:49 | 2024-05-14T08:42:49 |
Yuanchen Shi, Biao Ma, Fang Kong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Stickers are increasingly used in social media to express sentiment and
intent. When finding typing troublesome, people often use a sticker instead.
Despite the significant impact of stickers on sentiment analysis and intent
recognition, little research has been conducted. To address this gap, we
propose a new task: Multimodal chat Sentiment Analysis and Intent Recognition
involving Stickers (MSAIRS). Additionally, we introduce a novel multimodal
dataset containing Chinese chat records and stickers excerpted from several
mainstream social media platforms. Our dataset includes paired data with the
same text but different stickers, and various stickers consisting of the same
images with different texts, allowing us to better understand the impact of
stickers on chat sentiment and intent. We also propose an effective multimodal
joint model, MMSAIR, for our task, which is validated on our datasets and
indicates that visual information of stickers counts. Our dataset and code will
be publicly available.
|
[
0.024198953062295914,
-0.457424521446228,
0.33398348093032837,
0.49892446398735046,
-0.29312664270401,
0.12687991559505463,
-0.2124425172805786,
-0.267574667930603,
0.5557742714881897,
0.23640337586402893,
-0.36404383182525635,
-0.26962289214134216,
-0.8754903674125671,
-0.2739742696285248,
0.030563808977603912,
1.1287676095962524,
0.026378892362117767,
0.02923804335296154,
-0.42832258343696594,
-0.3116757273674011,
-0.41857919096946716,
-0.5083279013633728,
-0.5544558763504028,
0.2959000766277313,
0.841691255569458,
0.42841655015945435,
0.42240214347839355,
-0.05424906313419342,
0.9647278189659119,
0.28577765822410583,
-0.15786844491958618,
0.3309718668460846,
-0.569946825504303,
-0.018781207501888275,
0.4813794791698456,
-0.18197134137153625,
-0.43694454431533813,
-0.04653718322515488,
0.5357083678245544,
-0.021099762991070747,
0.05677434056997299,
0.05809904634952545,
0.03691664710640907,
0.4408625662326813,
-0.7038418650627136,
0.358582079410553,
-0.4729849100112915,
-0.11029951274394989,
-0.19196416437625885,
-0.17281115055084229,
-0.4651665985584259,
-0.19865040481090546,
0.027200423181056976,
-0.41039642691612244,
-0.24550537765026093,
-0.3016875982284546,
0.7400838732719421,
-0.10517796874046326,
-0.8144217133522034,
-0.37710946798324585,
-0.6984158158302307,
0.8564492464065552,
-0.646407961845398,
0.4397416412830353,
-0.0067374212667346,
0.47587352991104126,
-0.06286153942346573,
-0.5397011637687683,
-0.5348345637321472,
-0.07320546358823776,
-0.23184125125408173,
0.12157709151506424,
0.001045999233610928,
-0.044481560587882996,
0.03628632053732872,
0.2228243499994278,
-0.37190061807632446,
-0.24935565888881683,
-0.541813850402832,
-0.416220486164093,
0.5776314735412598,
0.1062055304646492,
0.5495610237121582,
-0.2514101266860962,
-0.443331241607666,
-0.15670734643936157,
-0.27434828877449036,
0.5972675681114197,
-0.12967729568481445,
0.3654021918773651,
-0.27040472626686096,
0.5798082947731018,
-0.07490061223506927,
0.4964948296546936,
0.0014059103559702635,
-0.6173067092895508,
0.46447035670280457,
-0.4131720960140228,
0.16304288804531097,
-0.20941409468650818,
0.9821821451187134,
0.9768836498260498,
0.22614867985248566,
0.3059385120868683,
-0.03195720911026001,
0.04508486017584801,
-0.19175800681114197,
-0.9500876069068909,
-0.3487905263900757,
0.3062036633491516,
-0.7191081643104553,
-0.22730150818824768,
0.22443775832653046,
-0.6644003987312317,
-0.6487188339233398,
-0.169777050614357,
0.1758345365524292,
-0.3332170248031616,
-0.501855731010437,
-0.17065075039863586,
-0.44111475348472595,
0.34199169278144836,
0.4879978895187378,
-0.5603019595146179,
-0.13456539809703827,
0.7081242203712463,
1.0520613193511963,
-0.007665371987968683,
-0.041870567947626114,
-0.2735564410686493,
0.18296609818935394,
-0.07350675761699677,
1.0301448106765747,
-0.9680017828941345,
-0.4877628982067108,
-0.0559607595205307,
0.024943308904767036,
-0.3003057837486267,
-0.02797655574977398,
0.42495205998420715,
-0.43948933482170105,
0.3050316572189331,
-0.37590157985687256,
-0.44642946124076843,
-0.2951163351535797,
0.23847974836826324,
-0.75762939453125,
0.5713562369346619,
-0.3136925995349884,
-0.5654342174530029,
0.40353819727897644,
-1.035651445388794,
-0.6157405972480774,
0.037038832902908325,
-0.17686425149440765,
-0.3987605571746826,
0.22008472681045532,
0.15236249566078186,
0.6871192455291748,
0.21265047788619995,
0.0421377532184124,
-0.6950259804725647,
-0.24256111681461334,
0.826064944267273,
-0.6863200068473816,
0.567290186882019,
0.09784398972988129,
0.1066235601902008,
0.15639780461788177,
-0.5580422282218933,
-0.14491070806980133,
-0.11444143950939178,
-0.25105664134025574,
-0.4835266172885895,
0.3274121582508087,
0.5414844155311584,
0.6283862590789795,
0.654583752155304,
-0.7741731405258179,
0.1251278966665268,
0.18764032423496246,
0.29316455125808716,
0.7065158486366272,
0.08327082544565201,
0.17785261571407318,
-0.1369568258523941,
0.21719101071357727,
0.5140891671180725,
0.5333594083786011,
-0.36765000224113464,
-0.8805510997772217,
-0.3988816440105438,
-0.5758240818977356,
0.07768529653549194,
0.29598209261894226,
-0.6526613831520081,
0.14276023209095,
-0.5135251879692078,
-0.5686286091804504,
-0.5296351909637451,
0.0450107678771019,
0.4500896632671356,
-0.07896750420331955,
-0.06575433909893036,
-0.2507253885269165,
-0.336896151304245,
-0.6929945349693298,
-0.1668398082256317,
-0.08505413681268692,
0.12390971928834915,
0.3996336758136749,
0.24231979250907898,
-0.2186651974916458,
0.8560625910758972,
-0.8280696272850037,
-0.6653883457183838,
-0.21639898419380188,
0.29641270637512207,
-0.08933540433645248,
0.3634696900844574,
0.666731595993042,
-1.1760964393615723,
-0.7916313409805298,
0.008502882905304432,
-0.5377035737037659,
0.31926432251930237,
-0.13902857899665833,
-0.01755952276289463,
0.2668928802013397,
0.4819873571395874,
-0.36371538043022156,
0.2707767188549042,
0.873615026473999,
-0.3118589520454407,
0.22046852111816406,
0.07308091968297958,
0.5260974168777466,
-1.1543078422546387,
-0.06887766718864441,
0.2566268742084503,
0.07375213503837585,
-0.8666494488716125,
-0.3667495548725128,
0.034508056938648224,
-0.06905761361122131,
-0.7375732064247131,
0.5736279487609863,
-0.326585054397583,
0.32662612199783325,
-0.47692981362342834,
-0.020764019340276718,
-0.04870007559657097,
0.5783022046089172,
-0.010814640671014786,
0.7938316464424133,
0.40338829159736633,
-0.32811272144317627,
0.010765879414975643,
0.20649196207523346,
-0.1830277293920517,
0.5319973230361938,
-0.6408448219299316,
0.2007482349872589,
-0.3239986002445221,
0.3738207519054413,
-1.571171760559082,
-0.30312058329582214,
0.42909669876098633,
-0.4599541425704956,
0.11469346284866333,
-0.10216377675533295,
-0.31178683042526245,
-0.26505517959594727,
-0.7687438130378723,
0.22322557866573334,
0.11720336228609085,
-0.23534294962882996,
0.8804029226303101,
0.8441063165664673,
-0.02488107979297638,
-0.46138155460357666,
-0.3730298578739166,
-0.030846793204545975,
-0.34612563252449036,
-0.47598758339881897,
-0.05363961681723595,
-0.26638033986091614,
0.22161144018173218,
-0.2735998332500458,
0.04243122413754463,
-0.3925533890724182,
-0.050445664674043655,
0.6068434715270996,
0.470964640378952,
-0.028882082551717758,
0.01347824651747942,
-0.0015316782519221306,
-0.0666126161813736,
0.003257275791838765,
0.35779520869255066,
0.36172348260879517,
-0.4150765836238861,
-0.3363687992095947,
-0.6483571529388428,
0.1309308558702469,
0.8629355430603027,
-0.36878007650375366,
0.9621304869651794,
0.8501064777374268,
-0.19381840527057648,
0.5038166046142578,
-0.6284438371658325,
0.02667233720421791,
-0.5444965958595276,
0.2781051993370056,
-0.48066726326942444,
-0.9566583037376404,
0.2969856858253479,
0.00935052428394556,
0.19656774401664734,
0.13464459776878357,
0.4088820517063141,
-0.4959449768066406,
1.4034417867660522,
0.6388048529624939,
-0.35946986079216003,
0.8187516927719116,
0.03298167884349823,
0.34613651037216187,
-0.7344760894775391,
-0.13551320135593414,
-0.0694144144654274,
-0.5921680331230164,
-0.8505518436431885,
-0.5350305438041687,
0.39151233434677124,
-0.44508233666419983,
0.39062193036079407,
0.26214492321014404,
-0.3413134515285492,
0.5348047614097595,
0.3846951127052307,
0.46990031003952026,
0.19439779222011566,
-0.1519775390625,
0.4537873864173889,
-0.30948150157928467,
-0.42418739199638367,
-0.46030494570732117,
1.0772795677185059,
0.23479409515857697,
0.5496928095817566,
-0.014136863872408867,
0.47539427876472473,
0.16733503341674805,
0.5488635897636414,
-0.7934555411338806,
0.5609545111656189,
-0.6130291223526001,
-0.5782662034034729,
-0.15507416427135468,
-0.3219451904296875,
-0.9049610495567322,
0.09245399385690689,
-0.1282281130552292,
-0.7021275162696838,
0.18687933683395386,
0.20168258249759674,
-0.18781141936779022,
0.023104535415768623,
-0.6920695304870605,
1.017580270767212,
-0.41311129927635193,
0.16124622523784637,
-0.13842003047466278,
-0.7706249356269836,
0.5383481979370117,
0.0832161083817482,
0.5154094696044922,
-0.44560569524765015,
0.03819701820611954,
1.0769516229629517,
-0.02452687732875347,
1.221098780632019,
-0.44936758279800415,
-0.185182586312294,
0.3012319803237915,
-0.2593308389186859,
0.26711761951446533,
-0.1710735708475113,
0.3221673369407654,
0.23342102766036987,
0.13291692733764648,
-0.18476572632789612,
-0.5920358896255493,
0.7336047887802124,
-0.5641598105430603,
-0.0905923917889595,
-0.20322683453559875,
-0.6082211136817932,
0.013793496415019035,
0.29531705379486084,
-0.19638285040855408,
0.7271042466163635,
-0.40732690691947937,
0.3598737418651581,
0.371201753616333,
0.103061243891716,
0.4438023567199707,
0.423867791891098,
-0.2586819529533386,
-0.5684021711349487,
1.557431697845459,
0.0887124240398407,
0.01697685569524765,
0.6245836615562439,
0.3010512888431549,
-0.25112077593803406,
-0.07642406970262527,
-0.11270841211080551,
0.26612454652786255,
-0.6972371935844421,
-0.10539519041776657,
-0.5676215887069702,
-0.07572528719902039,
-0.46665868163108826,
0.04904584586620331,
-0.2575611174106598,
-0.47496166825294495,
-0.23256585001945496,
0.3022729456424713,
0.6329821944236755,
0.6413381695747375,
0.016604887321591377,
0.569694459438324,
-1.09067702293396,
0.4965425133705139,
0.29521381855010986,
0.4801936745643616,
-0.21472059190273285,
-0.061566248536109924,
-0.3095627427101135,
0.44078102707862854,
-0.34460723400115967,
-0.6666234135627747,
0.08125390857458115,
0.3307337462902069,
0.39997100830078125,
0.930855393409729,
-0.021979203447699547,
0.7225922346115112,
-0.389646053314209,
0.6499737501144409,
0.3356432318687439,
-0.5673824548721313,
0.49318185448646545,
-0.37830090522766113,
0.15351063013076782,
0.6163772940635681,
0.3703962564468384,
-0.8768709897994995,
-0.5331658124923706,
-0.2169434279203415,
-0.437249094247818,
0.598659336566925,
0.2549522817134857,
0.41157546639442444,
0.0866059735417366,
-0.15575183928012848,
-0.06801442056894302,
0.29800257086753845,
-0.860887348651886,
-0.4246394634246826,
-0.24583397805690765,
-0.32950639724731445,
-0.36664924025535583,
-0.2771659791469574,
-0.021609293296933174,
-0.24725322425365448,
0.30089452862739563,
-0.090541310608387,
0.5316948890686035,
-0.3907182514667511,
-0.0382605716586113,
0.2257322520017624,
0.22106140851974487,
0.7184165716171265,
0.12657414376735687,
-0.38184699416160583,
-0.07829016447067261,
-0.27841320633888245,
-0.559938907623291,
0.009886374697089195,
-0.043444033712148666,
0.015161172486841679,
0.12288273870944977,
-0.09093909710645676,
0.8358722925186157,
0.2882462739944458,
-0.6963343620300293,
0.8891369700431824,
-0.2564839720726013,
-0.012013246305286884,
-0.16507741808891296,
-0.19800467789173126,
0.19723770022392273,
0.021786747500300407,
-0.04442576318979263,
0.4317435324192047,
0.386478066444397,
-0.4189068675041199,
0.1749936193227768,
0.6251735091209412,
-0.7123771905899048,
-0.5209922194480896,
0.2869831323623657,
0.43459418416023254,
-0.11913837492465973,
0.289422869682312,
-0.012386433780193329,
-0.6925322413444519,
0.4488043189048767,
0.2901512384414673,
0.8726745247840881,
-0.31307560205459595,
0.3820222020149231,
0.08964845538139343,
0.15225514769554138,
0.15817663073539734,
0.3882359266281128,
-0.1372983753681183,
-0.7727305293083191,
-0.24603857100009918,
-0.14588068425655365,
-0.6213507652282715,
-0.15303616225719452,
-0.39851635694503784,
0.457559198141098,
-0.17019759118556976,
-0.30609220266342163,
0.11210692673921585,
-0.5387906432151794,
-0.4409312307834625,
0.13930104672908783,
0.37197962403297424,
0.42565399408340454,
-0.8783351182937622,
0.5609443187713623,
0.9555453658103943,
-0.30639174580574036,
-0.416940838098526,
0.17524699866771698,
0.1796495020389557,
-0.6947849988937378,
0.3272338807582855,
0.6773092150688171,
-0.27392032742500305,
-0.24757292866706848,
-0.5219621658325195,
-0.9231864213943481,
0.8643055558204651,
-0.27718585729599,
-0.2291289120912552,
0.16888034343719482,
0.3175293207168579,
0.6367327570915222,
-0.12397205084562302,
0.5093052983283997,
0.16310453414916992,
0.49680647253990173,
0.24807043373584747,
-0.7039265632629395,
-0.16925248503684998,
-0.5831984877586365,
-0.006292672827839851,
0.32246333360671997,
-0.9333555698394775,
0.5266867280006409,
0.011284765787422657,
-0.26372992992401123,
-0.3427414298057556,
0.7243695855140686,
0.4078885018825531,
0.6133805513381958,
0.656841516494751,
-0.010431487113237381,
0.3989963233470917,
-0.0010221536504104733,
0.7500761151313782,
-0.5071050524711609,
0.3015233278274536,
0.8428924679756165,
-0.4066636860370636,
1.2897764444351196,
0.5969706177711487,
-0.04409831017255783,
0.6789747476577759,
0.10802885890007019,
0.08127150684595108,
0.6287228465080261,
-0.2010083794593811,
-0.2599271833896637,
-0.06747996062040329,
-0.33865803480148315,
-0.18689335882663727,
0.7266068458557129,
0.6098759770393372,
-0.019064834341406822,
-0.03977012261748314,
0.6393308043479919,
0.11366603523492813,
-0.3326717019081116,
0.00020864418183919042,
1.0255966186523438,
-0.10528428852558136,
-0.3792404234409332,
0.09952031075954437,
-0.24014921486377716,
1.0487526655197144,
-0.49366581439971924,
0.061414387077093124,
0.06212268024682999,
0.39117345213890076,
-0.1162446141242981,
-0.9791234731674194,
0.2014848291873932,
-0.15429750084877014,
-0.03967570513486862,
-0.27945977449417114,
1.1566787958145142,
-0.4076777994632721,
-0.8515987992286682,
0.2564065754413605,
0.36540186405181885,
0.15800920128822327,
-0.27386710047721863,
-0.686091423034668,
0.056780219078063965,
-0.03679540008306503,
-0.24954861402511597,
0.32880207896232605,
0.5328754186630249,
-0.02619132399559021,
0.5459214448928833,
0.6967964768409729,
-0.30561381578445435,
0.08060365915298462,
0.12731128931045532,
1.0543888807296753,
-0.3795661926269531,
-0.3894260823726654,
-0.691473662853241,
0.6720126271247864,
-0.30313512682914734,
-0.25132933259010315,
0.9858865141868591,
0.5857726335525513,
0.4434182941913605,
-0.30689194798469543,
0.8444901704788208,
-0.3060120642185211,
0.621099054813385,
-0.1714053452014923,
0.7927041053771973,
-0.6741303205490112,
0.03367387130856514,
-0.39490553736686707,
-0.39678576588630676,
-0.3161312937736511,
0.34738433361053467,
-0.2674759328365326,
0.026564735919237137,
0.36193832755088806,
0.937393069267273,
-0.16206541657447815,
0.05470513179898262,
0.1670183539390564,
-0.17144404351711273,
0.47964930534362793,
0.427503377199173,
1.0944690704345703,
-0.7312459945678711,
0.8401790857315063,
-0.6170515418052673,
-0.37568366527557373,
-0.4132138192653656,
-0.7592793107032776,
-1.0824507474899292,
-0.7905954122543335,
-0.41542500257492065,
-0.06976620852947235,
-0.21619528532028198,
0.7693887948989868,
0.32598116993904114,
-1.0673668384552002,
-0.4007818102836609,
0.42377641797065735,
0.07664511352777481,
-0.27159583568573,
-0.36356183886528015,
0.20556260645389557,
-0.12024621665477753,
-0.5670425891876221,
0.15918496251106262,
0.1797986477613449,
0.2332325428724289,
0.225420743227005,
-0.036474958062171936,
-0.32776814699172974,
0.02672305330634117,
0.8933814167976379,
0.04557332769036293,
-0.5721785426139832,
-0.29059305787086487,
0.2682936489582062,
-0.2924734354019165,
0.30880045890808105,
0.9415630102157593,
-0.3969728648662567,
0.5518203377723694,
0.62018883228302,
0.16254551708698273,
0.0918671116232872,
-0.11448237299919128,
0.4385157823562622,
-0.7222173810005188,
-0.10128290951251984,
-0.23026743531227112,
0.39570412039756775,
0.2881503999233246,
-0.24618619680404663,
-0.04547540470957756,
0.15391872823238373,
-0.4777590334415436,
-0.7294886708259583,
-0.21443387866020203,
-1.4764227867126465,
-0.2202184498310089,
1.1510868072509766,
-0.08051774650812149,
-0.11415867507457733,
-0.16060300171375275,
-0.768680989742279,
0.05786147341132164,
-0.8609212040901184,
0.6792803406715393,
0.7117968797683716,
-0.13623078167438507,
-0.24201060831546783,
0.017508244141936302,
0.3236786425113678,
0.09084340929985046,
-0.8871086835861206,
0.001653054147027433,
0.5354235172271729,
0.09641887992620468,
0.45053303241729736,
0.9798747301101685,
0.1137019544839859,
0.43596968054771423,
-0.2287231832742691,
-0.060103509575128555,
0.05828339606523514,
-0.5176755785942078,
-0.25096550583839417,
0.0629892647266388,
-0.12476854026317596,
-0.6304478645324707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08402v1
|
Investigating the 'Autoencoder Behavior' in Speech Self-Supervised Models: a focus on HuBERT's Pretraining
| 2024-05-14T07:55:37 | 2024-05-14T07:55:37 |
Valentin Vielzeuf
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Self-supervised learning has shown great success in Speech Recognition.
However, it has been observed that finetuning all layers of the learned model
leads to lower performance compared to resetting top layers. This phenomenon is
attributed to the ''autoencoder'' behavior: top layers contain information
closer to the input and are less suitable for tasks that require linguistic
information, such as Speech Recognition.To better our understanding of this
behavior, we propose to study the evolution of high-level information within
the model during pretraining. We focus on the HuBERT model, which exhibits a
less pronounced ''autoencoder'' behavior. By experimentally exploring various
factors that may have an impact, we aim to improve the training procedure and
enhance the top layers of HuBERT for high-level tasks.Furthermore, our
experiments demonstrate that these improvements in the training procedure
result in faster convergence and competitive performance on downstream tasks.
|
[
-0.48481857776641846,
-0.835898220539093,
0.18752095103263855,
0.08867797255516052,
0.11634758859872818,
-0.24218270182609558,
-0.10810759663581848,
-0.2612846791744232,
0.21960701048374176,
0.5710256695747375,
-0.35345733165740967,
-0.05012989416718483,
-0.7680732607841492,
0.10617748647928238,
-0.6242819428443909,
1.014853835105896,
0.11790009588003159,
-0.1091587096452713,
-0.25655630230903625,
0.45437031984329224,
-0.20572054386138916,
-0.9517515897750854,
-0.8178551197052002,
-0.5159857273101807,
0.511906087398529,
0.193076491355896,
0.3266337215900421,
1.1091248989105225,
0.46129587292671204,
0.3814309537410736,
0.1599833369255066,
-0.34959864616394043,
-0.6871325373649597,
0.25926584005355835,
-0.033286646008491516,
-0.07619919627904892,
-0.5705528259277344,
0.06674551218748093,
0.7101433277130127,
0.6425835490226746,
-0.43299412727355957,
0.17195653915405273,
0.4299353063106537,
0.41065794229507446,
-0.7748917937278748,
0.23844149708747864,
-0.34353116154670715,
0.11534925550222397,
-0.19240958988666534,
-0.3782901167869568,
-0.18444372713565826,
0.20383405685424805,
0.19335812330245972,
-0.5637252330780029,
0.3535846173763275,
-0.16088952124118805,
0.8770610094070435,
0.44139981269836426,
-0.13896653056144714,
-0.003535374067723751,
-1.0478523969650269,
0.46591028571128845,
-0.42637068033218384,
0.5452730655670166,
0.731427788734436,
-0.011310233734548092,
0.048892516642808914,
-0.6640142202377319,
-0.23517769575119019,
-0.4541856348514557,
-0.14093099534511566,
-0.04681943356990814,
-0.3068176209926605,
0.12728579342365265,
0.47160208225250244,
0.3448641002178192,
-0.6330674290657043,
0.3713204562664032,
-0.5251845717430115,
-0.15229938924312592,
0.6280709505081177,
-0.08654678612947464,
0.02973979525268078,
-0.26556485891342163,
-0.24582363665103912,
-0.4148615598678589,
-0.10564465075731277,
0.26753780245780945,
0.33818143606185913,
0.18628664314746857,
0.030613726004958153,
0.21591517329216003,
-0.46157756447792053,
0.6514949798583984,
0.5687413215637207,
0.22114311158657074,
0.4430933892726898,
0.06562437117099762,
-0.3880294859409332,
0.37233981490135193,
0.7780031561851501,
-0.13314959406852722,
0.539151668548584,
-0.00413333298638463,
-0.4983333647251129,
-0.41236910223960876,
0.4527556002140045,
-0.8671793341636658,
-0.8198497891426086,
-0.025233833119273186,
-0.5125077962875366,
-0.2811390459537506,
0.041162941604852676,
-0.09561076015233994,
0.20468732714653015,
-0.8224279880523682,
0.9424071311950684,
-0.3542393445968628,
-0.3856528103351593,
0.02082737535238266,
0.006955637130886316,
0.1883307844400406,
-0.0654497817158699,
-1.2318849563598633,
0.5189670920372009,
0.5245696306228638,
0.5938203930854797,
-0.2894446849822998,
-0.7773593068122864,
-0.778445303440094,
0.1925891786813736,
-0.3671793043613434,
0.41491714119911194,
-0.24122625589370728,
-0.2774879038333893,
-0.40780535340309143,
-0.02315065637230873,
-0.21793842315673828,
-0.8370588421821594,
0.05172688886523247,
-0.38083207607269287,
0.032834045588970184,
-0.2711719274520874,
-0.5876821279525757,
0.21307726204395294,
-0.04737214744091034,
-0.43953606486320496,
1.105161190032959,
0.04565171152353287,
-0.6268656849861145,
0.3754350543022156,
-0.7019164562225342,
-0.7185186147689819,
-0.10350196063518524,
-0.2783198058605194,
-0.524978756904602,
0.18948955833911896,
0.38654986023902893,
0.8847341537475586,
0.2574998438358307,
0.36125460267066956,
-0.30106326937675476,
-0.297554612159729,
0.12661826610565186,
-0.19415877759456635,
0.8676231503486633,
0.1281433403491974,
-0.5180543065071106,
0.010119176469743252,
-0.8916223049163818,
-0.1578960120677948,
0.18180018663406372,
-0.1673634648323059,
-0.5617727637290955,
-0.25562649965286255,
-0.28866133093833923,
0.3031980097293854,
0.07406619936227798,
-0.5286726355552673,
0.0874619260430336,
-0.22256428003311157,
0.3510328531265259,
0.7184140086174011,
0.0948718935251236,
0.4859182834625244,
-0.30689042806625366,
0.23467156291007996,
0.17054466903209686,
0.6035816669464111,
-0.10117516666650772,
-0.08600611239671707,
-0.9902222156524658,
-0.13357308506965637,
0.382894903421402,
0.5970658659934998,
-0.3203306198120117,
0.5223584771156311,
-0.13349151611328125,
-0.21511419117450714,
-0.6384972929954529,
0.3686122000217438,
0.41611385345458984,
0.6109948754310608,
0.6935431957244873,
-0.6125847101211548,
-0.40472498536109924,
-1.1205893754959106,
-0.0941249281167984,
0.02230001986026764,
0.0410347543656826,
0.1193690299987793,
0.5093632340431213,
-0.2951085567474365,
0.9887300729751587,
-0.33005428314208984,
-0.2856751084327698,
-0.019443588331341743,
0.5761157870292664,
-0.035001035779714584,
1.0059950351715088,
0.5272465348243713,
-0.40188920497894287,
-0.31338635087013245,
-0.3107077181339264,
-0.6949795484542847,
-0.16709508001804352,
-0.03678818419575691,
-0.11494535207748413,
-0.14849166572093964,
0.990347683429718,
-0.35284659266471863,
0.3715832531452179,
0.29434359073638916,
0.3093236982822418,
0.43170976638793945,
-0.41389769315719604,
-0.08170802891254425,
-0.6001628041267395,
-0.18120382726192474,
-0.2686907947063446,
-0.022434301674365997,
-0.8473654389381409,
-0.45848900079727173,
-0.14829795062541962,
-0.10800188779830933,
-0.002308939816430211,
0.1484498679637909,
-0.5455932021141052,
-0.3359055817127228,
-0.39823469519615173,
-0.1944309026002884,
-0.1480582058429718,
0.3898704946041107,
0.2533417046070099,
0.7191064357757568,
0.9530033469200134,
-1.0029362440109253,
0.38555455207824707,
0.0680226981639862,
-0.31948593258857727,
0.4314830005168915,
-0.8191136121749878,
0.2302994579076767,
-0.33378732204437256,
-0.114845409989357,
-0.7838547229766846,
-0.22816002368927002,
-0.18152447044849396,
-0.5279058218002319,
0.8146657347679138,
0.006719601806253195,
-0.26854845881462097,
-0.2539137005805969,
0.0356866754591465,
0.5181265473365784,
0.5832918882369995,
-0.5899975895881653,
0.41378286480903625,
0.4876076281070709,
-0.31593644618988037,
-0.4542626142501831,
-0.7508461475372314,
0.05989021435379982,
-0.2007257491350174,
-0.36655193567276,
0.3032742142677307,
-0.06726918369531631,
-0.046618569642305374,
-0.16591618955135345,
-0.00617812667042017,
-0.14836055040359497,
0.16843347251415253,
0.04766396805644035,
-0.17300449311733246,
-0.3157474100589752,
0.1545068472623825,
-0.06379301100969315,
-0.2160242646932602,
0.3848675787448883,
-0.538946270942688,
0.4248946011066437,
-0.03835275024175644,
-0.02168433554470539,
-0.8027536869049072,
0.150441974401474,
0.15356671810150146,
-0.4722326993942261,
0.5470349788665771,
0.8262964487075806,
-0.1832878142595291,
-0.3329213261604309,
-0.6008412837982178,
-0.598349928855896,
-0.51516193151474,
0.3396016061306,
-0.549449622631073,
-0.7674717903137207,
0.21241983771324158,
0.14370913803577423,
-0.46563640236854553,
0.3180365264415741,
0.39383772015571594,
-0.5170441269874573,
0.8744435906410217,
0.5467265248298645,
-0.1766529679298401,
0.7370871305465698,
-0.6481733918190002,
-0.04940599203109741,
-0.9325209259986877,
-0.23712502419948578,
-0.24212393164634705,
-0.18627923727035522,
-0.6125403642654419,
-0.08007839322090149,
0.28310227394104004,
0.12723897397518158,
-0.45463693141937256,
0.4896557331085205,
-0.487299382686615,
0.2083243429660797,
0.8140130043029785,
0.038422778248786926,
-0.0432489849627018,
0.07178204506635666,
-0.0997815728187561,
0.1435125321149826,
-1.0682889223098755,
0.05515526607632637,
0.7485645413398743,
0.26860353350639343,
1.063064694404602,
-0.35064998269081116,
1.071803092956543,
0.29622724652290344,
-0.013290557079017162,
-0.40268653631210327,
0.35122328996658325,
-0.2214564085006714,
-0.5317413806915283,
-0.6722567677497864,
-0.5554535984992981,
-1.166276216506958,
0.1013898253440857,
-0.16631655395030975,
-0.5489705204963684,
0.5191941857337952,
0.6855353713035583,
-0.4571179449558258,
-0.02999291941523552,
-0.4132970869541168,
1.1116290092468262,
-0.5578897595405579,
-0.21414601802825928,
-0.02765033394098282,
-0.7289503216743469,
0.11356697231531143,
-0.1317748874425888,
0.20362624526023865,
-0.011837401427328587,
0.3905028700828552,
0.7622591853141785,
-0.22948314249515533,
0.8280245661735535,
-0.3456434905529022,
-0.16330786049365997,
-0.0065294429659843445,
0.11383899301290512,
0.2601410448551178,
-0.29570484161376953,
0.229570209980011,
0.17046362161636353,
-0.08281170576810837,
-0.3317299485206604,
-0.569443941116333,
0.5624039173126221,
-0.9740245342254639,
-0.5282639861106873,
-0.2781311571598053,
-0.20737522840499878,
-0.22811150550842285,
-0.023539461195468903,
0.6696532964706421,
0.7151468396186829,
-0.2640324532985687,
0.23496659100055695,
0.8024428486824036,
0.03509574010968208,
0.38039901852607727,
0.380466490983963,
-0.3109895586967468,
-0.20032396912574768,
0.9840855002403259,
0.52363520860672,
0.38715028762817383,
0.42739033699035645,
0.29297930002212524,
-0.06158246099948883,
-0.5897207856178284,
-0.12225519865751266,
0.15463268756866455,
-0.43642258644104004,
0.07627461850643158,
-0.6221407651901245,
-0.5242133736610413,
-0.6657401919364929,
0.17308978736400604,
-0.48136720061302185,
-0.38851621747016907,
-0.5342000126838684,
-0.10814592987298965,
-0.07893531769514084,
0.7452993392944336,
-0.550434410572052,
0.5807600021362305,
-0.4533384144306183,
0.2950126826763153,
0.7933270335197449,
0.22417719662189484,
-0.0448010079562664,
-0.8094728589057922,
-0.4909268021583557,
-0.16066943109035492,
-0.010539169423282146,
-0.49665480852127075,
0.25641027092933655,
0.591626763343811,
0.5867166519165039,
0.4696853756904602,
0.04229965806007385,
0.6721848249435425,
-0.5208641290664673,
0.41998234391212463,
-0.15269602835178375,
-0.9906460642814636,
0.8852350115776062,
-0.38393256068229675,
0.43254154920578003,
0.41586732864379883,
0.527168869972229,
-0.037971239537000656,
-0.24238987267017365,
-0.6673139929771423,
-0.5041837096214294,
0.7514309883117676,
0.27289801836013794,
0.3210306465625763,
0.08462175726890564,
0.5527372360229492,
-0.12775766849517822,
0.23900723457336426,
-0.6693498492240906,
-0.14764313399791718,
-0.5447522401809692,
0.21222807466983795,
-0.39543622732162476,
-0.24337582290172577,
0.052510373294353485,
-0.7470123171806335,
0.6089510917663574,
0.0708165392279625,
0.3514389395713806,
0.42907750606536865,
-0.35505545139312744,
-0.01833520270884037,
0.044129472225904465,
0.3695875406265259,
0.36363404989242554,
-0.24244336783885956,
0.05852396413683891,
0.20488792657852173,
-0.34457653760910034,
0.0908992812037468,
0.3372141420841217,
-0.2571254372596741,
-0.2429400235414505,
0.6369884014129639,
1.390795350074768,
0.329078733921051,
0.014501777477562428,
0.6881586313247681,
0.048685163259506226,
-0.3579217493534088,
-0.4184003472328186,
0.3942762613296509,
-0.4911516606807709,
0.2007768303155899,
0.2530007064342499,
-0.14383795857429504,
0.47339075803756714,
-0.48825564980506897,
0.38359373807907104,
0.28972378373146057,
-0.40164637565612793,
-0.36446836590766907,
0.6397063732147217,
0.05382988974452019,
-0.316599041223526,
0.8215711116790771,
-0.11617504805326462,
-0.5648190379142761,
0.4616449773311615,
0.640845775604248,
0.9037336111068726,
-0.9847070574760437,
-0.0028312643989920616,
0.3060745894908905,
0.3892149031162262,
-0.005227462854236364,
0.13161726295948029,
-0.5095392465591431,
-0.5956798791885376,
-0.5611572861671448,
-0.7023182511329651,
0.04415418580174446,
0.24812299013137817,
-1.0879734754562378,
-0.02626977488398552,
-0.26537850499153137,
-0.5240596532821655,
0.06919209659099579,
-0.5374994277954102,
-0.6903601288795471,
0.4394546151161194,
0.2418832629919052,
0.4105941653251648,
-0.5036003589630127,
1.0037128925323486,
0.4892280101776123,
-0.014718306250870228,
-0.6488243341445923,
0.15009455382823944,
-0.35111111402511597,
-0.5966131091117859,
1.2089248895645142,
0.161659836769104,
-0.40339693427085876,
0.44166299700737,
-0.5084661245346069,
-1.256222128868103,
0.8393473029136658,
0.4309830069541931,
-0.6005881428718567,
-0.19835121929645538,
0.2014465481042862,
0.474131315946579,
-0.3537006080150604,
-0.03358615189790726,
0.5786952972412109,
0.1787910759449005,
-0.25900688767433167,
-1.301217794418335,
-0.4135156571865082,
-0.20424659550189972,
0.20058611035346985,
0.1622428297996521,
-0.4597298800945282,
1.1534605026245117,
-0.1351305991411209,
0.042249489575624466,
-0.25777602195739746,
0.746674656867981,
-0.4099404811859131,
0.11207576841115952,
0.5994508266448975,
0.542198121547699,
0.6599602103233337,
0.06218494102358818,
0.8981305360794067,
-0.4231445789337158,
0.4559704065322876,
1.2589102983474731,
-0.013807185925543308,
0.9887250065803528,
0.05988062173128128,
0.01307114027440548,
0.5705728530883789,
0.37943556904792786,
-0.09230418503284454,
0.5654372572898865,
0.5017810463905334,
0.14391455054283142,
-0.5082002878189087,
0.1368899792432785,
-0.2668231725692749,
0.9352351427078247,
0.22883741557598114,
-0.35770872235298157,
0.21071016788482666,
0.5996108651161194,
-0.3148890435695648,
-0.37534430623054504,
-0.5162995457649231,
0.8902163505554199,
0.10930680483579636,
-0.5367318987846375,
0.8920657634735107,
-0.35067465901374817,
0.4006357192993164,
-0.49060580134391785,
0.25271090865135193,
0.06687764823436737,
0.17175550758838654,
-0.12812480330467224,
-0.4176565706729889,
0.08958651125431061,
-0.30990511178970337,
-0.13147874176502228,
-0.4432397186756134,
0.6988630294799805,
-0.6205522418022156,
-0.13980743288993835,
0.6242877840995789,
0.47790995240211487,
0.2869582176208496,
-0.1506747603416443,
-0.7347879409790039,
-0.04819381237030029,
-0.45950794219970703,
-0.3104090988636017,
0.428598016500473,
0.2930307686328888,
0.2604132294654846,
0.5453580021858215,
0.5322601795196533,
-0.03803602606058121,
0.3397127389907837,
0.1991298496723175,
0.7225551605224609,
-0.510722279548645,
-0.5872493386268616,
-0.8703286647796631,
0.17370030283927917,
-0.15453609824180603,
-0.19003798067569733,
0.7433651685714722,
0.6056818962097168,
1.1944284439086914,
-0.126239612698555,
0.4970771074295044,
0.348599910736084,
0.5446718335151672,
-0.7034462094306946,
0.6455376744270325,
-0.4951353073120117,
-0.05821789428591728,
-0.2793269753456116,
-0.7760176658630371,
0.12027820199728012,
0.9825112819671631,
-0.3120447099208832,
0.40103262662887573,
0.3981405198574066,
0.4875739812850952,
-0.3342813551425934,
-0.14083334803581238,
0.4317763149738312,
0.6366562843322754,
-0.0864226445555687,
0.10695236176252365,
0.9351101517677307,
-0.1796512007713318,
0.32011091709136963,
-0.6145416498184204,
-0.31475698947906494,
-0.1437513828277588,
-0.6058323383331299,
-1.0442821979522705,
-0.8269941210746765,
-0.33793672919273376,
-0.07870621979236603,
0.3459111154079437,
0.8551507592201233,
1.1594514846801758,
-0.7698410749435425,
-0.6374363303184509,
0.03900062292814255,
-0.6405192017555237,
-0.06981586664915085,
-0.2029934972524643,
0.1876877099275589,
-0.6139780282974243,
-0.33261629939079285,
0.5838951468467712,
0.2410728484392166,
0.305154949426651,
-0.33243849873542786,
-0.0074905576184391975,
-0.053213685750961304,
-0.0499781034886837,
0.6567280888557434,
0.38013672828674316,
-0.33993133902549744,
-0.015414565801620483,
0.03620409220457077,
0.02853969857096672,
0.23238906264305115,
0.9493876695632935,
-0.8829179406166077,
0.4616679549217224,
0.22841447591781616,
0.5473477840423584,
1.035419225692749,
0.25607624650001526,
0.5391226410865784,
-0.6501060724258423,
-0.28358563780784607,
0.11269505321979523,
0.1781773865222931,
0.4276561141014099,
-0.3807043135166168,
0.16542768478393555,
0.16376180946826935,
-0.9496789574623108,
-0.6509562134742737,
0.11916337162256241,
-0.6035245060920715,
-0.08008163422346115,
0.8616918921470642,
0.07570693641901016,
-0.04698015749454498,
-0.04705483838915825,
-0.042005520313978195,
0.3298773467540741,
-0.30606991052627563,
0.7866796255111694,
0.6883628964424133,
-0.8187965750694275,
-0.33560147881507874,
-0.6965622305870056,
0.8896403312683105,
0.5088323950767517,
-0.6729469299316406,
0.12105260044336319,
0.21879716217517853,
0.34751424193382263,
0.20741313695907593,
0.7165632843971252,
0.3962993919849396,
0.17371046543121338,
-0.2161521315574646,
-0.09580022841691971,
-0.20789609849452972,
-0.6862012147903442,
-0.6232479214668274,
-0.06862232834100723,
0.16988009214401245,
-0.17846469581127167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08400v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08400v1
|
Stylometric Watermarks for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-14T07:54:54 | 2024-05-14T07:54:54 |
Georg Niess, Roman Kern
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) has made it
increasingly difficult to distinguish between text written by humans and
machines. Addressing this, we propose a novel method for generating watermarks
that strategically alters token probabilities during generation. Unlike
previous works, this method uniquely employs linguistic features such as
stylometry. Concretely, we introduce acrostica and sensorimotor norms to LLMs.
Further, these features are parameterized by a key, which is updated every
sentence. To compute this key, we use semantic zero shot classification, which
enhances resilience. In our evaluation, we find that for three or more
sentences, our method achieves a false positive and false negative rate of
0.02. For the case of a cyclic translation attack, we observe similar results
for seven or more sentences. This research is of particular of interest for
proprietary LLMs to facilitate accountability and prevent societal harm.
|
[
0.032011520117521286,
-0.9130510091781616,
0.6670696139335632,
0.25061675906181335,
-0.5002109408378601,
0.2175108939409256,
-0.15752530097961426,
-0.8602407574653625,
0.41421204805374146,
0.5558207631111145,
-0.39878901839256287,
-0.5159748792648315,
-0.667793333530426,
0.06316360086202621,
-0.49498915672302246,
1.0816580057144165,
-0.28138217329978943,
-0.1650966852903366,
-0.05864739045500755,
-0.2636755406856537,
-0.22915323078632355,
-0.8143765330314636,
-0.5937018990516663,
-0.05975781008601189,
0.619833767414093,
0.05775109678506851,
0.8041709065437317,
1.096724033355713,
0.5587537884712219,
0.2629868984222412,
-0.1412695050239563,
-0.04259500280022621,
-0.2366255223751068,
0.35847023129463196,
0.028375081717967987,
-0.46304851770401,
-0.16356562077999115,
-0.09720714390277863,
0.6395507454872131,
0.504264771938324,
0.05463901534676552,
0.3628503084182739,
-0.02573918178677559,
0.36628541350364685,
-0.49142876267433167,
0.14204907417297363,
-0.8819022178649902,
0.16764603555202484,
-0.6569971442222595,
-0.3977351784706116,
-0.36208096146583557,
-0.27957528829574585,
0.001784451655112207,
-0.35148051381111145,
0.19439899921417236,
0.23347361385822296,
0.993652880191803,
0.2613605558872223,
-0.2115667760372162,
-0.23478512465953827,
-0.6630857586860657,
0.8089110255241394,
-0.9276940226554871,
0.20583657920360565,
0.12552745640277863,
0.15972577035427094,
-0.30030784010887146,
-0.6063723564147949,
-0.6575101017951965,
-0.3373616933822632,
0.29439401626586914,
-0.16467790305614471,
-0.2227470576763153,
-0.2005874216556549,
0.1824408620595932,
0.17050638794898987,
-0.2934780716896057,
0.05098062753677368,
-0.12921325862407684,
-0.4311736524105072,
0.7994835376739502,
0.3682979643344879,
0.5783092975616455,
-0.04514164477586746,
-0.4891951084136963,
-0.24193130433559418,
-0.8542583584785461,
0.05524576082825661,
0.5227599740028381,
0.516154408454895,
-0.19507186114788055,
0.629493772983551,
0.18127323687076569,
0.5393279790878296,
-0.1725025773048401,
-0.20885249972343445,
0.12464167177677155,
-0.24446627497673035,
-0.04458199068903923,
0.3597651720046997,
0.9140061140060425,
0.22935980558395386,
0.3972324728965759,
-0.1274755597114563,
-0.1964121311903,
0.2191770076751709,
0.21295541524887085,
-0.6944417953491211,
-0.06580907851457596,
-0.06813319772481918,
-0.1281057745218277,
-0.6749533414840698,
-0.055296096950769424,
-0.6014856696128845,
-0.6062629818916321,
-0.10314758121967316,
0.49020031094551086,
-0.49648258090019226,
-0.0965237021446228,
0.17561279237270355,
-0.15828078985214233,
0.076193667948246,
0.11178961396217346,
-0.7986820340156555,
0.14710763096809387,
0.5711640119552612,
0.8981384038925171,
-0.26308393478393555,
-0.35007280111312866,
-0.39737215638160706,
0.24713844060897827,
-0.5677886009216309,
0.7946256995201111,
-0.7653447985649109,
-0.155912846326828,
-0.08095288276672363,
-0.0550868920981884,
0.1388901174068451,
-0.43292751908302307,
0.1572965681552887,
-0.6470310091972351,
-0.10140512138605118,
0.013289960101246834,
-0.6243650913238525,
-0.025556501001119614,
0.2191205769777298,
-0.5477637052536011,
0.9200154542922974,
0.060777269303798676,
-0.8154198527336121,
0.34298425912857056,
-0.39889293909072876,
-0.5501513481140137,
0.18325719237327576,
-0.16605530679225922,
-0.7210890054702759,
0.22031284868717194,
-0.1723550707101822,
0.2846004366874695,
-0.20418980717658997,
0.2599146366119385,
-0.5166849493980408,
-0.2081165462732315,
0.6425967812538147,
-0.597665548324585,
0.5673580169677734,
-0.0881001278758049,
-0.5534353852272034,
0.2773905396461487,
-0.6559440493583679,
0.10943575948476791,
0.3066212832927704,
-0.501099705696106,
-0.35114791989326477,
-0.01853329688310623,
0.2299242913722992,
-0.02820485085248947,
0.4501286447048187,
-0.6303714513778687,
0.08555704355239868,
-0.4505888521671295,
0.5663250088691711,
0.9405435919761658,
0.4208976924419403,
0.06431720405817032,
-0.25027528405189514,
0.5287530422210693,
0.21778306365013123,
0.15252754092216492,
-0.13926149904727936,
-0.586155891418457,
-0.775460422039032,
-0.5196987986564636,
0.18767543137073517,
0.43542930483818054,
-0.7965571880340576,
0.556269109249115,
-0.3972598612308502,
-0.765555739402771,
-0.43451181054115295,
0.2967921495437622,
0.5152766108512878,
0.3251560628414154,
0.4240249991416931,
-0.4387401342391968,
-0.3457549512386322,
-0.8559096455574036,
-0.53153395652771,
-0.35320430994033813,
-0.048521023243665695,
0.2931818664073944,
0.5003657341003418,
-0.10676564276218414,
0.9593976736068726,
-0.5782871842384338,
-0.1428080052137375,
-0.1344575434923172,
0.2056622952222824,
0.1486901491880417,
0.35306137800216675,
0.6593196988105774,
-0.4439554214477539,
-0.3481946885585785,
-0.14198561012744904,
-0.511695146560669,
-0.3226577937602997,
-0.12397497147321701,
-0.037456054240465164,
0.36042991280555725,
0.46754613518714905,
-0.637962818145752,
0.4742114841938019,
0.6470897197723389,
-0.6367657780647278,
0.6106124520301819,
-0.169441357254982,
0.05779721587896347,
-1.0854856967926025,
0.1633680760860443,
0.026327036321163177,
-0.10095102339982986,
-0.6831468343734741,
0.11187807470560074,
0.001230698311701417,
0.011491098441183567,
-0.5775142908096313,
0.7130089998245239,
-0.21945294737815857,
0.045810867100954056,
-0.2787221372127533,
-0.12043850868940353,
-0.10900893062353134,
0.2879112660884857,
-0.004211933817714453,
0.5326451659202576,
0.32452884316444397,
-0.4441896677017212,
0.5017645955085754,
0.055844128131866455,
-0.3685604929924011,
0.390188068151474,
-0.860604465007782,
0.20217213034629822,
-0.19611310958862305,
0.0408080630004406,
-1.0825833082199097,
-0.1399589627981186,
0.17340996861457825,
-0.2835007607936859,
0.29364219307899475,
-0.11478276550769806,
-0.7387095093727112,
-0.051294174045324326,
-0.4266119599342346,
0.36138537526130676,
0.2340860217809677,
-0.35885629057884216,
0.29701367020606995,
0.3662557005882263,
-0.3556712865829468,
-0.16380755603313446,
-0.6757996678352356,
0.4926547706127167,
-0.4414083957672119,
-0.5595241189002991,
0.29056432843208313,
-0.11195484548807144,
-0.21087181568145752,
-0.004385944921523333,
-0.03108699806034565,
0.04812375083565712,
0.35372060537338257,
0.36794304847717285,
0.5674334764480591,
-0.11755204200744629,
0.037415243685245514,
-0.10319583863019943,
-0.18198572099208832,
-0.14743869006633759,
-0.217911034822464,
0.7502856254577637,
-0.005352446343749762,
-0.32099276781082153,
-0.49218931794166565,
0.1674148291349411,
0.688687801361084,
-0.23130802810192108,
0.6765638589859009,
0.35597506165504456,
-0.4416947662830353,
-0.1519152969121933,
-0.43640172481536865,
-0.27745798230171204,
-0.5106504559516907,
0.30258023738861084,
-0.19249974191188812,
-0.9549758434295654,
0.4907476603984833,
0.38857409358024597,
0.05058394372463226,
0.39025405049324036,
0.434325635433197,
0.10752993077039719,
0.8183212280273438,
0.5749711990356445,
-0.45602697134017944,
0.6576458811759949,
0.21095605194568634,
0.2881941795349121,
-0.6002579927444458,
0.021738775074481964,
-0.41281887888908386,
-0.37692970037460327,
-0.583576500415802,
-0.46833336353302,
0.31864243745803833,
0.1710190773010254,
-0.41517335176467896,
0.7242403030395508,
-0.6399086117744446,
0.25186365842819214,
0.44016486406326294,
-0.07412877678871155,
0.2343558818101883,
0.3560105562210083,
-0.21143141388893127,
-0.4065798223018646,
-0.3353710472583771,
-0.5964046120643616,
0.9097739458084106,
0.43037518858909607,
0.7840725183486938,
0.15300332009792328,
0.6209973692893982,
0.37324708700180054,
0.7142349481582642,
-0.6304700374603271,
0.5815117359161377,
-0.029250366613268852,
-0.7298367619514465,
-0.43655726313591003,
-0.6279943585395813,
-0.9633887410163879,
-0.03795113414525986,
-0.32379451394081116,
-0.8368127942085266,
-0.09095865488052368,
-0.03564388304948807,
-0.32845279574394226,
0.35099276900291443,
-0.41739997267723083,
0.7889828085899353,
-0.5680520534515381,
-0.47909700870513916,
0.06112944334745407,
-0.39557507634162903,
-0.15363216400146484,
-0.3052368760108948,
0.19369949400424957,
-0.4466829001903534,
-0.31527262926101685,
0.7848173975944519,
-0.3082241415977478,
1.0905616283416748,
-0.2472366988658905,
-0.31747642159461975,
0.24116359651088715,
0.45159122347831726,
0.5746721029281616,
-0.21699032187461853,
-0.07228697836399078,
0.3533787727355957,
0.020023414865136147,
-0.29441341757774353,
-0.2542895972728729,
0.5770992040634155,
-0.6792347431182861,
-0.5253592133522034,
-0.5285545587539673,
-0.5742926597595215,
-0.23336245119571686,
0.4194684624671936,
0.09162972867488861,
0.18768227100372314,
-0.03420151397585869,
0.08839499205350876,
0.25124624371528625,
-0.4179920554161072,
0.6908222436904907,
0.6211472153663635,
0.0532841719686985,
-0.6580373644828796,
1.042584776878357,
0.2625962197780609,
0.2590219974517822,
0.0644112080335617,
0.24048639833927155,
-0.26478567719459534,
-0.7708581686019897,
-0.4929363429546356,
0.34566038846969604,
-0.5278664827346802,
-0.331601619720459,
-0.31738269329071045,
-0.32615038752555847,
-0.2775757610797882,
-0.29859495162963867,
-0.24140572547912598,
-0.2905084192752838,
-0.3108549118041992,
-0.14348503947257996,
0.6746958494186401,
0.5370389223098755,
0.19999384880065918,
0.14195460081100464,
-0.957711935043335,
0.2180076241493225,
0.2519461214542389,
0.3574662506580353,
-0.10290424525737762,
-0.7622653841972351,
0.007319638971239328,
0.0752548947930336,
-0.21690285205841064,
-0.6541371941566467,
0.5483741164207458,
0.3619903326034546,
0.3646194338798523,
0.38867515325546265,
0.03849456459283829,
0.9434829354286194,
-0.7941775918006897,
0.7798287272453308,
0.4889223575592041,
-1.0903902053833008,
0.4692590832710266,
-0.4147687256336212,
0.09755434095859528,
0.43294328451156616,
0.1152300015091896,
-0.7378590703010559,
-0.7024770379066467,
-0.6854479908943176,
-1.1911412477493286,
0.2421869933605194,
0.09155786037445068,
0.6483343243598938,
-0.22345753014087677,
0.5759434103965759,
-0.09748753905296326,
0.2584399878978729,
-0.6419591307640076,
-0.14726227521896362,
-0.034526363015174866,
-0.581014096736908,
-0.14620374143123627,
-0.2617316246032715,
-0.15533176064491272,
-0.011986042372882366,
0.5067620873451233,
-0.26699596643447876,
0.0007334713009186089,
0.22435222566127777,
0.00820008385926485,
-0.22823084890842438,
0.28499534726142883,
0.6213361024856567,
0.31390589475631714,
0.1510406881570816,
0.4360086917877197,
0.22837011516094208,
-0.5417082905769348,
0.27706286311149597,
-0.02709430828690529,
-0.42566025257110596,
0.012309834361076355,
0.7367365956306458,
0.6990274786949158,
0.38631507754325867,
-0.8054167628288269,
0.4749026894569397,
0.1717412769794464,
-0.014859153889119625,
-0.4310677945613861,
0.06902702152729034,
0.15631666779518127,
0.25880366563796997,
0.441281259059906,
-0.04231278970837593,
-0.23098354041576385,
-0.6762994527816772,
0.2931704521179199,
0.54459148645401,
-0.5399796366691589,
-0.5166581273078918,
0.7869428396224976,
-0.0816364735364914,
-0.19562740623950958,
0.21081498265266418,
0.023694491013884544,
-0.50180584192276,
0.5057931542396545,
0.6231979727745056,
0.9335431456565857,
-0.3596283793449402,
0.13145135343074799,
0.14740025997161865,
0.3685510456562042,
-0.15853272378444672,
0.18492457270622253,
0.12273482233285904,
-1.0738574266433716,
-0.1442076414823532,
-1.1347984075546265,
-0.3101964294910431,
-0.0005639040609821677,
-0.4533032476902008,
0.04933637008070946,
-0.8021311163902283,
-0.4001173675060272,
0.34208813309669495,
-0.13550512492656708,
-0.20965984463691711,
0.14319244027137756,
0.4764735698699951,
0.5787463784217834,
-0.9226604700088501,
0.7508910298347473,
0.5439887642860413,
-0.20299911499023438,
-0.47925642132759094,
-0.076356902718544,
0.07814579457044601,
-0.8841878771781921,
0.6317809224128723,
0.1329660713672638,
-0.22101426124572754,
-0.00542624993249774,
-0.6454771757125854,
-1.0003548860549927,
0.8958166837692261,
0.7637225985527039,
-0.49116846919059753,
0.14227262139320374,
0.5646079182624817,
0.8922930359840393,
-0.35739269852638245,
-0.44983306527137756,
0.4491877555847168,
0.5101625323295593,
-0.06417795270681381,
-0.8540100455284119,
0.3261224627494812,
-0.26073572039604187,
0.27879220247268677,
0.23757843673229218,
-0.5613875389099121,
0.6685707569122314,
-0.0542670339345932,
-0.49930086731910706,
0.14838513731956482,
0.3860360383987427,
0.5860744714736938,
0.04819285869598389,
0.4867102801799774,
0.6242412328720093,
0.5755755305290222,
-0.16048750281333923,
1.080554485321045,
-0.5216410756111145,
0.27358299493789673,
1.077062726020813,
-0.4414604604244232,
1.2056275606155396,
0.8657968640327454,
-0.06921643018722534,
0.40422147512435913,
0.5029481053352356,
-0.418887734413147,
0.2926315665245056,
0.58109450340271,
-0.42877209186553955,
-0.31976065039634705,
-0.44005849957466125,
-0.10341723263263702,
0.42419329285621643,
0.28112104535102844,
-0.5071832537651062,
0.053299736231565475,
-0.10550397634506226,
0.3736763894557953,
0.07207643240690231,
-0.12578940391540527,
0.745911717414856,
0.24601265788078308,
-0.2769283652305603,
0.4757448434829712,
0.20671793818473816,
0.7403438687324524,
-0.5724735856056213,
0.1487712860107422,
-0.006514933425933123,
0.2760826647281647,
-0.16328226029872894,
-0.8391183614730835,
0.32125207781791687,
0.19903217256069183,
0.04512885957956314,
-0.2763259708881378,
0.48437389731407166,
-0.5091363787651062,
-0.7798861265182495,
0.3295481204986572,
0.09728787839412689,
0.01894519105553627,
-0.0068139065988361835,
-0.4826655983924866,
0.34714996814727783,
-0.16868215799331665,
-0.42686381936073303,
0.18273647129535675,
0.32283759117126465,
-0.20576775074005127,
0.7208854556083679,
0.9538242220878601,
0.4445302486419678,
0.18089859187602997,
-0.014118046499788761,
0.7280720472335815,
-0.9114948511123657,
-0.3593041002750397,
-1.133287787437439,
0.20750145614147186,
-0.13523881137371063,
-0.3308720588684082,
0.9315512776374817,
0.55780029296875,
0.6400810480117798,
-0.0574856773018837,
0.815575897693634,
0.05886191502213478,
0.1475629210472107,
-0.41321852803230286,
0.8871480822563171,
-0.32640692591667175,
0.24843767285346985,
-0.32385459542274475,
-0.9381927847862244,
-0.7501152753829956,
0.38595688343048096,
-0.34740498661994934,
-0.20478755235671997,
0.4821031391620636,
0.7944684028625488,
0.28382542729377747,
-0.33535099029541016,
0.29740265011787415,
0.1529063880443573,
0.4890100955963135,
0.5223677754402161,
0.7076734900474548,
-0.4559219777584076,
0.690761387348175,
-0.027692187577486038,
-0.01731906086206436,
-0.2665955424308777,
-0.8157706260681152,
-0.7846742868423462,
-0.37675920128822327,
-0.5488827228546143,
-0.3581853210926056,
-0.03732524439692497,
0.6794630289077759,
0.49616265296936035,
-0.9192324280738831,
-0.04105515033006668,
-0.02831997722387314,
-0.17166881263256073,
-0.08188524842262268,
-0.23813873529434204,
0.3316638171672821,
-0.1932850331068039,
-0.46127137541770935,
0.29288774728775024,
0.702944278717041,
0.46278196573257446,
-0.26230359077453613,
0.011001731269061565,
0.1866435408592224,
0.41094088554382324,
0.36748206615448,
0.11937252432107925,
-0.576296329498291,
-0.8899377584457397,
-0.04391898587346077,
-0.25207963585853577,
-0.014590313658118248,
0.7711653113365173,
-0.2641637921333313,
0.2925916314125061,
0.40880048274993896,
0.5400134921073914,
0.4666749835014343,
-0.12494789808988571,
0.397186279296875,
-0.8370034694671631,
0.28416427969932556,
0.2534046471118927,
0.47071734070777893,
0.5858849883079529,
-0.23440413177013397,
0.24254897236824036,
0.5171033143997192,
-0.1352161169052124,
-0.9254663586616516,
0.393984854221344,
-0.7565123438835144,
-0.040551334619522095,
1.1363844871520996,
-0.2761213481426239,
-0.5080647468566895,
-0.14105527102947235,
-0.0627531185746193,
0.12948614358901978,
-0.14065544307231903,
1.1802126169204712,
0.6874079704284668,
0.19127464294433594,
-0.08428609371185303,
-0.2764172852039337,
0.435607373714447,
0.23907656967639923,
-0.7761738896369934,
0.3126607835292816,
0.34182608127593994,
0.6887044310569763,
0.5111716389656067,
0.29835647344589233,
-0.41908878087997437,
0.05978759005665779,
0.07858368009328842,
0.22237811982631683,
-0.0698104128241539,
-0.10335201770067215,
-0.235310897231102,
0.28745076060295105,
0.2679867148399353,
0.05603497102856636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08839v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08839v1
|
PromptMind Team at EHRSQL-2024: Improving Reliability of SQL Generation using Ensemble LLMs
| 2024-05-14T07:16:56 | 2024-05-14T07:16:56 |
Satya K Gundabathula, Sriram R Kolar
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper presents our approach to the EHRSQL-2024 shared task, which aims
to develop a reliable Text-to-SQL system for electronic health records. We
propose two approaches that leverage large language models (LLMs) for prompting
and fine-tuning to generate EHRSQL queries. In both techniques, we concentrate
on bridging the gap between the real-world knowledge on which LLMs are trained
and the domain specific knowledge required for the task. The paper provides the
results of each approach individually, demonstrating that they achieve high
execution accuracy. Additionally, we show that an ensemble approach further
enhances generation reliability by reducing errors. This approach secured us
2nd place in the shared task competition. The methodologies outlined in this
paper are designed to be transferable to domain-specific Text-to-SQL problems
that emphasize both accuracy and reliability.
|
[
-0.017845436930656433,
-0.6893507242202759,
0.9693776965141296,
0.09210849553346634,
-0.2001987248659134,
-0.04385513812303543,
-0.07184772938489914,
-0.3346191346645355,
0.06966730952262878,
0.5553597211837769,
-0.8478833436965942,
-0.5241855382919312,
-0.26634418964385986,
0.331854909658432,
-0.2529639005661011,
0.9342607855796814,
0.03164568170905113,
0.14081387221813202,
-0.6182963848114014,
-0.23676501214504242,
-0.6791609525680542,
-0.5541248321533203,
-0.893862247467041,
-0.3121717572212219,
0.3885141611099243,
0.4346499443054199,
0.436045378446579,
0.4209616482257843,
0.49919983744621277,
0.21530547738075256,
-0.021453751251101494,
0.35652804374694824,
-0.4594660997390747,
0.7989864349365234,
-0.13280630111694336,
-0.5297964811325073,
-0.6349619626998901,
-0.7921288013458252,
0.4930402636528015,
0.5067700147628784,
-0.7575334906578064,
0.11968166381120682,
0.17424917221069336,
0.8879992365837097,
-0.3266136348247528,
0.1112293004989624,
-0.8765912652015686,
0.022222688421607018,
-0.3088780641555786,
-0.3618953824043274,
-0.5065571069717407,
-0.322180837392807,
-0.13859811425209045,
-0.5718315243721008,
0.12146645784378052,
0.5112032294273376,
0.4378710091114044,
0.5820313692092896,
-0.29780957102775574,
-0.1726890206336975,
-0.46833473443984985,
0.9172313213348389,
-0.6321966648101807,
0.253648042678833,
0.412395179271698,
0.25509878993034363,
-0.3808864951133728,
-0.7744177579879761,
-0.5337314009666443,
0.13461321592330933,
-0.006148995365947485,
0.0007362135802395642,
-0.07920800894498825,
0.0815526619553566,
0.15311317145824432,
0.06884156912565231,
-0.6830951571464539,
0.2725682854652405,
-0.12659724056720734,
-0.10438647866249084,
0.9271708130836487,
0.5576059818267822,
0.4473077654838562,
-0.19685888290405273,
-0.19987663626670837,
0.3222293257713318,
-0.8230761885643005,
-0.2819068133831024,
-0.19690056145191193,
0.3928569257259369,
0.27710944414138794,
0.5370045900344849,
-0.3329312801361084,
0.7712945938110352,
0.31512171030044556,
0.10879683494567871,
0.32729408144950867,
-0.3833300471305847,
-0.17129167914390564,
0.31335312128067017,
0.8598725199699402,
0.25229719281196594,
-0.1952017992734909,
-0.23046882450580597,
-0.49176687002182007,
-0.1689213663339615,
0.31359875202178955,
-0.45412155985832214,
-0.34530016779899597,
0.8632206916809082,
-0.4422909915447235,
-0.2715320587158203,
-0.4627164304256439,
-0.6529446244239807,
-0.38888081908226013,
-0.3916945457458496,
0.6890228390693665,
-0.7016427516937256,
-0.03133111819624901,
-0.11947974562644958,
-0.01455842424184084,
0.06820392608642578,
0.34233278036117554,
-0.8524571657180786,
0.4318126440048218,
0.7697619795799255,
0.5766113996505737,
-0.6729240417480469,
-0.2235337197780609,
-0.703270673751831,
0.32919520139694214,
-0.18754126131534576,
0.8446339964866638,
0.011295750737190247,
-0.4414770305156708,
-0.018283748999238014,
-0.14370276033878326,
-0.07714331895112991,
-0.7073180675506592,
0.6546472311019897,
-0.5045318007469177,
0.21466051042079926,
-0.3926539421081543,
-0.8894053101539612,
0.43594950437545776,
0.2984108030796051,
-0.5770124793052673,
0.8923870921134949,
-0.1733623594045639,
-0.6288591027259827,
0.2650378942489624,
-0.4569728374481201,
-0.5101658701896667,
0.5572445392608643,
-0.5241311192512512,
-0.7593176960945129,
-0.048023074865341187,
0.3447761833667755,
0.6247262954711914,
-0.37248241901397705,
0.40060028433799744,
-0.07086697220802307,
-0.21075241267681122,
-0.0026584328152239323,
-0.0319875106215477,
0.7401286363601685,
0.21420858800411224,
-0.08879484236240387,
0.17113463580608368,
-0.6157011985778809,
0.44187819957733154,
0.2864474356174469,
-0.11516691744327545,
-0.19702626764774323,
0.23871810734272003,
-0.10123378038406372,
-0.029049336910247803,
0.29441216588020325,
-0.18033766746520996,
-0.12435871362686157,
-0.2605372965335846,
0.2705307900905609,
0.6295567154884338,
0.4994122385978699,
0.3572045862674713,
-0.6931570768356323,
0.5577881932258606,
-0.0017163930460810661,
0.2485858052968979,
-0.23484458029270172,
-0.5174750685691833,
-0.381944477558136,
-0.02596406452357769,
0.13411301374435425,
0.7328844666481018,
-1.0598869323730469,
0.697792649269104,
-0.19940634071826935,
-0.45025715231895447,
-0.1826280951499939,
-0.10445445030927658,
0.294558048248291,
0.5844628810882568,
0.5123071670532227,
-0.22991806268692017,
-0.46705618500709534,
-0.7026990652084351,
-0.42546895146369934,
-0.1775544136762619,
-0.1333990842103958,
0.3831104338169098,
0.1693873405456543,
-0.11770565062761307,
0.7857099175453186,
-0.5063472986221313,
-0.26591163873672485,
-0.23334676027297974,
-0.08471614867448807,
0.29401883482933044,
0.6355334520339966,
0.3015687167644501,
-0.6100026965141296,
-0.30711257457733154,
-0.22792546451091766,
-0.9043569564819336,
0.14041738212108612,
0.19259241223335266,
-0.29540902376174927,
0.41181880235671997,
0.36003270745277405,
-0.8201655149459839,
-0.02433840185403824,
0.38917413353919983,
-0.33501380681991577,
0.5685478448867798,
-0.15499241650104523,
0.3910907506942749,
-1.3082094192504883,
-0.15738029778003693,
-0.04950563609600067,
-0.05362069606781006,
-0.6278501152992249,
-0.16128607094287872,
-0.100287064909935,
-0.3021130859851837,
-0.35950469970703125,
0.3569827377796173,
-0.5472787618637085,
0.036641448736190796,
0.263841837644577,
-0.27175086736679077,
-0.16729509830474854,
0.19959913194179535,
-0.1117057129740715,
0.6940943598747253,
0.6236292123794556,
-0.6698582768440247,
0.37695756554603577,
0.6211055517196655,
-0.29240575432777405,
1.1064125299453735,
-0.8203156590461731,
0.19322103261947632,
-0.01967589184641838,
0.1728450506925583,
-0.7856221199035645,
-0.7983359694480896,
-0.01402382180094719,
-0.4758595824241638,
0.4990779161453247,
0.03447927534580231,
-0.49232080578804016,
-0.41163450479507446,
-0.0907047837972641,
0.21268677711486816,
0.9270370602607727,
-0.39841020107269287,
0.41646668314933777,
0.5271251201629639,
-0.5915967226028442,
-0.3904619812965393,
-0.7866206169128418,
0.13397185504436493,
-0.1737239509820938,
-0.7842637300491333,
0.6231221556663513,
0.1644161194562912,
-0.31656765937805176,
0.04270727559924126,
0.020146679133176804,
-0.3173164129257202,
-0.06242135167121887,
0.05536170303821564,
0.3428335189819336,
-0.13882341980934143,
0.7000183463096619,
0.3015446960926056,
0.17389878630638123,
0.19854509830474854,
-0.4778875410556793,
0.3674960732460022,
0.3426050543785095,
-0.5768011808395386,
-0.5712320804595947,
0.6248638033866882,
0.3708324432373047,
-0.2638123333454132,
0.860988199710846,
0.15207228064537048,
-0.49675410985946655,
-0.5575165152549744,
-0.5659850239753723,
-0.5151975750923157,
-0.46241697669029236,
0.24562568962574005,
0.014365531504154205,
-0.9429939389228821,
0.3366766571998596,
-0.1539563536643982,
0.12682344019412994,
0.6108768582344055,
0.5001598596572876,
-0.4056391716003418,
0.8336023688316345,
0.42239364981651306,
0.2270098775625229,
0.2194424718618393,
0.30955591797828674,
-0.09397938847541809,
-0.6065236926078796,
-0.4271376132965088,
-0.6592994332313538,
0.13169914484024048,
-0.25416386127471924,
-0.4232185482978821,
0.9242680668830872,
-0.14635001122951508,
-0.39146697521209717,
-0.025363221764564514,
-0.7819377779960632,
0.2554529309272766,
0.4025152027606964,
0.5108082294464111,
0.3069031834602356,
0.2820604145526886,
0.019572654739022255,
-0.06158210709691048,
-0.9337175488471985,
-0.44493451714515686,
1.1051583290100098,
-0.10139944404363632,
0.6260467171669006,
0.20936596393585205,
1.1522789001464844,
0.357283353805542,
-0.11083349585533142,
-0.43550288677215576,
0.5927476286888123,
0.023450590670108795,
-0.5031003355979919,
-0.7278503775596619,
-0.5432882308959961,
-1.1338762044906616,
-0.20270194113254547,
-0.37846022844314575,
-0.6888524293899536,
-0.2678792476654053,
0.5437915325164795,
-0.7065696120262146,
0.13768596947193146,
-0.5437570810317993,
0.8040217757225037,
-0.20903551578521729,
-0.5063574314117432,
-0.0886668935418129,
-0.7821691036224365,
0.4652310609817505,
-0.14980725944042206,
0.10151185095310211,
0.15762841701507568,
0.05115586146712303,
0.7736643552780151,
-0.6282694339752197,
0.6520644426345825,
-0.03995409980416298,
0.03830501809716225,
0.4397565722465515,
-0.06707533448934555,
0.7505529522895813,
-0.04497644677758217,
-0.46205729246139526,
-0.013006447814404964,
0.015300972387194633,
-0.46339187026023865,
-0.4167189598083496,
0.7549088597297668,
-0.48043879866600037,
-0.5302138924598694,
-0.38105958700180054,
-0.4080662131309509,
-0.5637693405151367,
0.22863832116127014,
0.414753258228302,
0.6298624873161316,
-0.20958232879638672,
0.002656095428392291,
1.159428358078003,
-0.3211796283721924,
0.2419559508562088,
0.2188379317522049,
0.058288443833589554,
-0.31602564454078674,
0.7047631144523621,
0.20788998901844025,
0.18523846566677094,
0.42697542905807495,
-0.1167260929942131,
-0.4239584505558014,
-0.7322744727134705,
-0.5326370596885681,
0.07639387995004654,
-0.5280987620353699,
-0.3451635241508484,
-0.7881563305854797,
-0.145442396402359,
-0.5390753149986267,
0.00952767115086317,
-0.12491258233785629,
-0.48193174600601196,
-0.4307270050048828,
-0.0555926151573658,
0.7680888772010803,
0.7020578384399414,
0.3016097843647003,
0.10542342811822891,
-1.3312671184539795,
0.0012097298167645931,
0.5326200723648071,
0.2640589475631714,
-0.09801427274942398,
-0.44657403230667114,
-0.07940579205751419,
-0.4881367087364197,
-0.2557471692562103,
-1.08726966381073,
0.2419959008693695,
0.18572913110256195,
0.8063251376152039,
-0.29668861627578735,
0.3310285210609436,
0.2744620740413666,
-0.941404402256012,
1.087530255317688,
0.3946135938167572,
-0.8344013094902039,
0.9101311564445496,
-0.6536480784416199,
0.26749056577682495,
0.7506458163261414,
0.3127458691596985,
-0.22825440764427185,
-0.17127618193626404,
-0.8375841379165649,
-0.9814102053642273,
0.41681957244873047,
0.2595047652721405,
-0.2628721296787262,
-0.08390650898218155,
0.5446287989616394,
0.009746021591126919,
0.40497300028800964,
-0.033058859407901764,
-0.31800344586372375,
0.25923705101013184,
-0.6623675227165222,
0.0141035420820117,
-0.24274636805057526,
-0.17148208618164062,
0.05549358204007149,
0.6774018406867981,
-0.1145409345626831,
0.428168386220932,
0.22860735654830933,
0.10825033485889435,
-0.39377468824386597,
0.4460059106349945,
0.31120529770851135,
0.7588046193122864,
0.03563934564590454,
-0.07549750804901123,
0.44711965322494507,
-0.31515073776245117,
0.15392573177814484,
0.1318245679140091,
-0.23946788907051086,
0.13186873495578766,
0.27751821279525757,
0.6912596821784973,
-0.062190551310777664,
-0.6440894603729248,
0.25237923860549927,
0.036429513245821,
-0.13011173903942108,
-0.4040911793708801,
0.11195259541273117,
0.2677682936191559,
-0.009341577999293804,
0.5465830564498901,
0.13363923132419586,
0.2961503565311432,
-0.3119893968105316,
0.709513783454895,
0.34774500131607056,
-0.40570569038391113,
-0.1872609704732895,
0.797659695148468,
0.3290107846260071,
-0.4638139605522156,
0.4639071524143219,
-0.21961703896522522,
-0.3351978063583374,
0.709159255027771,
0.4305178225040436,
0.6992461085319519,
-0.6804313659667969,
-0.003945743199437857,
0.4744422137737274,
0.04188620299100876,
-0.5366285443305969,
0.7221643328666687,
0.27903082966804504,
-0.5038905739784241,
-0.5465757846832275,
-0.37412285804748535,
-0.7261383533477783,
-0.3178751468658447,
-0.8546501398086548,
0.24112647771835327,
-0.21631771326065063,
-0.21247662603855133,
-0.19911661744117737,
-0.22936709225177765,
-0.6720471978187561,
0.28888723254203796,
-0.1337476372718811,
0.619983971118927,
-0.678869903087616,
0.6905730366706848,
0.7796460390090942,
-0.09310518950223923,
-1.166237235069275,
-0.020656265318393707,
0.16312475502490997,
-0.662629246711731,
0.33311501145362854,
-0.22421523928642273,
0.2815908193588257,
0.2196546494960785,
-0.657857358455658,
-0.7190520167350769,
1.5097812414169312,
0.06535841524600983,
-0.9196416139602661,
-0.017064346000552177,
-0.300250768661499,
0.4231919050216675,
-0.03031059168279171,
-0.11666149646043777,
0.47423243522644043,
0.2594670355319977,
0.19126419723033905,
-1.0476590394973755,
0.334063857793808,
0.11846987903118134,
-0.15301069617271423,
0.4077528119087219,
-0.49290090799331665,
0.7745169997215271,
-0.40951937437057495,
-0.21186788380146027,
0.12611734867095947,
0.731616735458374,
0.8171950578689575,
0.5613081455230713,
0.43677136301994324,
0.6145784258842468,
1.2320917844772339,
-0.10089047253131866,
1.2632290124893188,
-0.280426949262619,
0.2866351008415222,
1.289326786994934,
-0.7592461109161377,
0.8904002904891968,
0.5707928538322449,
-0.48681640625,
0.3098599314689636,
0.39953896403312683,
0.28321242332458496,
0.3898439407348633,
0.06157854571938515,
-0.47691601514816284,
-0.3665730357170105,
-0.2577943503856659,
-0.3880687355995178,
-0.09154067188501358,
0.5090645551681519,
-0.24307069182395935,
0.08514785766601562,
-0.24563057720661163,
-0.0975203737616539,
0.13762179017066956,
-0.47341710329055786,
0.9789592623710632,
0.3993244171142578,
-0.9980961084365845,
0.2109583020210266,
-0.41177666187286377,
0.5543304681777954,
-0.43215420842170715,
0.00872732326388359,
0.007684164214879274,
0.09534016996622086,
-0.3653617203235626,
-0.858557403087616,
0.25281184911727905,
-0.1462630033493042,
-0.1669439971446991,
0.05286458879709244,
1.082924723625183,
-0.46340692043304443,
-0.33849331736564636,
-0.24771174788475037,
0.7723245620727539,
0.027727726846933365,
0.09753916412591934,
-0.6895557641983032,
0.0849439725279808,
-0.06020527705550194,
-0.0344330295920372,
0.37026819586753845,
0.7571774125099182,
0.08833317458629608,
0.5150131583213806,
0.38710564374923706,
0.23951448500156403,
-0.10749593377113342,
-0.04191788285970688,
0.5276980996131897,
-0.5317227244377136,
-0.4465390145778656,
-0.78000807762146,
0.4435167610645294,
-0.30807122588157654,
-0.1909802109003067,
0.6581884026527405,
0.2511197626590729,
0.24319152534008026,
-0.12252163887023926,
0.9120224118232727,
0.05222966521978378,
0.8921733498573303,
-0.7511776089668274,
0.8450363278388977,
-0.4282754361629486,
0.23775739967823029,
-0.07568158954381943,
-0.6698037385940552,
-0.4147008955478668,
0.15521681308746338,
-0.0612306110560894,
-0.0041444324888288975,
0.8087821006774902,
0.6142038106918335,
0.45115697383880615,
-0.0010815489804372191,
0.3167280852794647,
0.10933452099561691,
0.1731864959001541,
0.6280640959739685,
0.7096335291862488,
-0.37634703516960144,
0.3459448218345642,
0.07430928200483322,
-0.17474275827407837,
-0.06685370951890945,
-0.8313092589378357,
-0.6356615424156189,
-0.47488975524902344,
-0.5005981922149658,
-0.5415263175964355,
0.4607909917831421,
1.1651052236557007,
0.5096921920776367,
-0.9105024933815002,
0.06387601047754288,
-0.26360052824020386,
0.06499672681093216,
-0.17660431563854218,
-0.17804279923439026,
0.5434286594390869,
-0.6143695712089539,
-0.3762954771518707,
0.23236432671546936,
0.3121742904186249,
0.0003411412762943655,
-0.11177736520767212,
0.017881294712424278,
0.2333836406469345,
0.040370430797338486,
0.49488601088523865,
0.20468680560588837,
-0.4771900773048401,
-0.13499878346920013,
0.17001594603061676,
-0.2494918704032898,
-0.15264733135700226,
0.5397564172744751,
-0.6829994320869446,
0.11966649442911148,
0.5991926789283752,
0.7481071352958679,
0.16974511742591858,
0.17782674729824066,
0.7014370560646057,
-0.7356690764427185,
-0.2382798045873642,
0.6023929119110107,
0.39553505182266235,
0.5074644684791565,
-0.7004885673522949,
0.39971765875816345,
0.1723494678735733,
-1.0777294635772705,
-0.7870767712593079,
0.23195724189281464,
-0.9938746690750122,
-0.08350128680467606,
1.1963791847229004,
0.045702625066041946,
-0.3025607764720917,
-0.31242528557777405,
0.05617872253060341,
0.19672918319702148,
-0.5248557925224304,
0.6415596008300781,
0.2861044704914093,
-0.36773431301116943,
-0.15248697996139526,
-0.5055513978004456,
0.8351387977600098,
0.7974445223808289,
-1.128024935722351,
-0.2759351432323456,
0.5224339962005615,
0.2753566801548004,
-0.054901476949453354,
1.0064531564712524,
-0.0936683937907219,
0.3708272874355316,
-0.17040923237800598,
0.24505503475666046,
0.36307859420776367,
-0.022370101884007454,
-0.4116273820400238,
0.2625878155231476,
0.31333407759666443,
-0.08970316499471664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08373v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08373v1
|
PromptMind Team at MEDIQA-CORR 2024: Improving Clinical Text Correction with Error Categorization and LLM Ensembles
| 2024-05-14T07:16:36 | 2024-05-14T07:16:36 |
Satya Kesav Gundabathula, Sriram R Kolar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper describes our approach to the MEDIQA-CORR shared task, which
involves error detection and correction in clinical notes curated by medical
professionals. This task involves handling three subtasks: detecting the
presence of errors, identifying the specific sentence containing the error, and
correcting it. Through our work, we aim to assess the capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs) trained on a vast corpora of internet data that contain
both factual and unreliable information. We propose to comprehensively address
all subtasks together, and suggest employing a unique prompt-based in-context
learning strategy. We will evaluate its efficacy in this specialized task
demanding a combination of general reasoning and medical knowledge. In medical
systems where prediction errors can have grave consequences, we propose
leveraging self-consistency and ensemble methods to enhance error correction
and error detection performance.
|
[
0.18357965350151062,
-0.5426886677742004,
0.7230185866355896,
0.38825884461402893,
0.0019699311815202236,
0.15706266462802887,
-0.04996893182396889,
-0.3248782455921173,
0.25306418538093567,
0.39636021852493286,
-0.8950580954551697,
-0.628557026386261,
-0.6079688668251038,
0.5056890249252319,
-0.11603587120771408,
1.0702663660049438,
-0.32474181056022644,
0.5133900046348572,
-0.5750069618225098,
-0.4060042202472687,
-1.02045476436615,
-0.48801109194755554,
-0.9996156096458435,
-0.18228590488433838,
0.7071364521980286,
0.7789527177810669,
0.3058675527572632,
0.38030412793159485,
0.8601856231689453,
0.24136057496070862,
0.3376505374908447,
0.47043663263320923,
-0.39744699001312256,
0.36613208055496216,
-0.1259995400905609,
-0.6380969882011414,
-0.8207862973213196,
-0.13566428422927856,
0.3484496772289276,
0.5409456491470337,
-0.40032386779785156,
-0.11915013939142227,
-0.043519776314496994,
0.601837694644928,
-0.3260863721370697,
0.20309525728225708,
-0.3325395882129669,
0.21821391582489014,
-0.14130519330501556,
-0.48152071237564087,
-0.46970170736312866,
-0.26264822483062744,
0.1092408150434494,
-0.7871727347373962,
0.42610013484954834,
0.4146762490272522,
0.263119101524353,
0.7876656651496887,
-0.21847093105316162,
-0.6439205408096313,
-0.27117231488227844,
0.7477127313613892,
-0.4876713156700134,
0.11027425527572632,
0.595095694065094,
0.26191437244415283,
-0.38850387930870056,
-0.8168920278549194,
-0.5110906958580017,
0.2190786600112915,
-0.16994300484657288,
0.383042573928833,
-0.15905895829200745,
0.31473153829574585,
0.20412993431091309,
0.22793114185333252,
-0.603043794631958,
0.2652237117290497,
-0.24278254806995392,
-0.38836047053337097,
0.663001298904419,
0.4751445949077606,
0.6962243318557739,
0.023284556344151497,
-0.17329883575439453,
-0.044874850660562515,
-0.6111814379692078,
-0.10709714144468307,
-0.2626645565032959,
0.18787722289562225,
-0.24391044676303864,
0.2996187210083008,
-0.13125941157341003,
0.5337626338005066,
0.18495367467403412,
-0.3888387978076935,
0.27391451597213745,
-0.25057515501976013,
-0.2999590039253235,
0.3809523284435272,
0.6965720653533936,
0.400823712348938,
-0.31437286734580994,
-0.09551595151424408,
-0.21623173356056213,
0.011448970064520836,
0.319218248128891,
-0.24843741953372955,
-0.3748883903026581,
0.554344892501831,
-0.494747519493103,
-0.07872288674116135,
-0.4579416513442993,
-0.5707614421844482,
-0.6817469596862793,
-0.31096696853637695,
0.6582077741622925,
-0.3820981979370117,
0.3579934537410736,
0.27026045322418213,
0.025396307930350304,
-0.34544438123703003,
0.9828537106513977,
-0.6025561690330505,
0.3209270238876343,
0.5654367804527283,
0.6902171969413757,
-0.3432234525680542,
-0.2961258590221405,
-0.6749901175498962,
0.06963314861059189,
-0.15373021364212036,
0.9517489075660706,
-0.06220320984721184,
-0.2665001451969147,
-0.175653874874115,
0.0824311375617981,
-0.3576456904411316,
-0.5915831923484802,
0.8043259978294373,
-0.21838799118995667,
0.5332664251327515,
-0.4380306601524353,
-0.8050658702850342,
-0.09428862482309341,
0.31381523609161377,
-0.6736792325973511,
0.5971935391426086,
0.206304669380188,
-0.814014196395874,
0.31747180223464966,
-0.7892753481864929,
-0.2645428478717804,
0.3280012905597687,
-0.2921093702316284,
-0.5976579189300537,
-0.13793917000293732,
0.4138270318508148,
0.5966349840164185,
-0.19741672277450562,
0.5480591058731079,
0.009868738241493702,
-0.36490297317504883,
0.18646280467510223,
-0.17942114174365997,
0.7846683263778687,
0.09988532215356827,
-0.2122460901737213,
0.4278382956981659,
-0.8334403038024902,
-0.15429964661598206,
-0.057386912405490875,
-0.2778141498565674,
-0.4278514087200165,
-0.07933440059423447,
-0.1833697408437729,
-0.07497520744800568,
0.16902612149715424,
-0.47268563508987427,
0.36082765460014343,
0.005469020921736956,
0.29506832361221313,
0.6315815448760986,
0.17112576961517334,
0.2504456341266632,
-0.649482011795044,
0.6191694140434265,
0.18245269358158112,
0.33739665150642395,
-0.38192659616470337,
-0.546967625617981,
-0.6508996486663818,
-0.45537811517715454,
0.15259088575839996,
0.8702161908149719,
-0.8642486929893494,
0.3466174006462097,
-0.0745375007390976,
-0.34816524386405945,
-0.5519164204597473,
0.017801104113459587,
0.3533374071121216,
0.8841891288757324,
0.7441724538803101,
-0.16994790732860565,
-0.9403562545776367,
-0.5989533066749573,
-0.2947807013988495,
-0.11718655377626419,
0.1100698858499527,
0.2643827497959137,
0.387464702129364,
-0.686210572719574,
0.792320191860199,
-0.29426977038383484,
-0.6566808819770813,
-0.24906682968139648,
0.30962204933166504,
0.34724634885787964,
0.7947036027908325,
0.10622720420360565,
-0.5791721940040588,
-0.3992999196052551,
-0.23106689751148224,
-0.8526044487953186,
-0.3716611862182617,
-0.2593982219696045,
0.1865089386701584,
0.15158860385417938,
0.5973218083381653,
-0.40595880150794983,
0.29035770893096924,
0.5210731029510498,
-0.3070439100265503,
0.2511608302593231,
-0.5548678040504456,
0.2631065845489502,
-1.0898497104644775,
-0.2383114993572235,
-0.22398042678833008,
-0.15483909845352173,
-0.7374764084815979,
-0.2928627133369446,
0.18456648290157318,
0.3252582550048828,
-0.10343900322914124,
0.529589056968689,
-0.374927818775177,
0.35464346408843994,
-0.07231571525335312,
-0.28567177057266235,
-0.1615818291902542,
0.4154527187347412,
-0.12644143402576447,
0.7943118810653687,
0.360972136259079,
-0.474008709192276,
0.355488657951355,
0.5837873816490173,
-0.08525605499744415,
0.8181920051574707,
-0.44297921657562256,
0.20546302199363708,
-0.1936691552400589,
0.4437439739704132,
-1.015953540802002,
-0.805217981338501,
0.3612252175807953,
-0.4834384024143219,
0.43009403347969055,
0.1862860918045044,
-0.4423244595527649,
-0.33751022815704346,
0.0388636589050293,
0.5336652994155884,
0.2863965928554535,
-0.4582533538341522,
0.4849185049533844,
0.43387922644615173,
-0.3678499758243561,
-0.790088415145874,
-0.6011232137680054,
0.19701920449733734,
0.04423194378614426,
-0.46973535418510437,
0.3026409149169922,
-0.0018785387510433793,
-0.2666042745113373,
-0.1403336375951767,
0.06500044465065002,
-0.11669483035802841,
0.06773795932531357,
0.39368727803230286,
0.3239451050758362,
0.06867699325084686,
0.5347905158996582,
0.20057198405265808,
0.055136386305093765,
-0.1174582988023758,
-0.11516358703374863,
0.3555904030799866,
0.009158751927316189,
-0.41921138763427734,
-0.6211108565330505,
0.24991440773010254,
0.3728715181350708,
0.07209459692239761,
0.5936295986175537,
0.3849179148674011,
-0.5008252859115601,
-0.1860680878162384,
-0.6707740426063538,
-0.10732152312994003,
-0.42036712169647217,
0.22560681402683258,
0.2447805106639862,
-1.0884817838668823,
0.6409392356872559,
0.2240285575389862,
-0.20600509643554688,
0.5311875343322754,
0.40034082531929016,
-0.5525579452514648,
0.8263629078865051,
0.6703903079032898,
0.07039518654346466,
-0.10563801229000092,
-0.10538309067487717,
0.03664957731962204,
-0.6899665594100952,
-0.38859885931015015,
-0.4941522181034088,
-0.20638573169708252,
-0.3472263813018799,
-0.6179848909378052,
0.8684883117675781,
-0.2424839586019516,
-0.17339633405208588,
-0.08625758439302444,
-0.42018866539001465,
0.15941132605075836,
0.6667265295982361,
0.5123651623725891,
0.2535632848739624,
-0.008039678446948528,
-0.1394183188676834,
-0.1435936540365219,
-0.985633373260498,
-0.19233129918575287,
0.9474904537200928,
0.345030814409256,
0.7285142540931702,
-0.1603125035762787,
0.7570561170578003,
0.4914088249206543,
0.507696807384491,
-0.7394548058509827,
0.33801957964897156,
-0.15151867270469666,
-0.3564642071723938,
-0.30746549367904663,
-0.19742126762866974,
-0.7882349491119385,
-0.20107793807983398,
-0.21082983911037445,
-0.3215934932231903,
0.11697112768888474,
0.3751181662082672,
-0.7420266270637512,
0.19763553142547607,
-0.5183064937591553,
0.9998856782913208,
-0.10127507150173187,
-0.26539480686187744,
-0.13828450441360474,
-0.9731044769287109,
0.3330437242984772,
-0.13085976243019104,
0.2675265073776245,
0.20282216370105743,
-0.17419083416461945,
0.7860764265060425,
-0.41375112533569336,
1.0633800029754639,
-0.15906529128551483,
-0.06732815504074097,
0.1820158213376999,
-0.07426057010889053,
0.5009518265724182,
-0.12683415412902832,
0.24483844637870789,
-0.0432012639939785,
-0.021322231739759445,
-0.42591914534568787,
-0.4489156901836395,
0.11819350719451904,
-0.7286202907562256,
-0.4876755475997925,
-0.5939387679100037,
-0.8620253205299377,
-0.4150325655937195,
0.11906225234270096,
0.4877191483974457,
0.7746990919113159,
-0.12135554105043411,
0.07049000263214111,
0.8306580185890198,
-0.39169520139694214,
0.2950609028339386,
0.5530611872673035,
0.08983369916677475,
-0.4745146930217743,
0.5914509296417236,
0.07048799097537994,
-0.1629938781261444,
0.633892834186554,
0.11216076463460922,
-0.2848256230354309,
-0.9020942449569702,
-0.3290393650531769,
0.22650562226772308,
-0.7959302663803101,
-0.3714557886123657,
-1.139892816543579,
-0.007989880628883839,
-0.4607287645339966,
-0.06658463180065155,
0.047101665288209915,
-0.19975966215133667,
-0.5137504935264587,
0.10734760761260986,
0.5413213968276978,
0.7346279621124268,
-0.20534181594848633,
0.7211326956748962,
-1.2537420988082886,
0.008061331696808338,
0.1306380182504654,
0.13051965832710266,
-0.1974993497133255,
-0.5471872091293335,
-0.26110196113586426,
-0.28520214557647705,
-0.07700251787900925,
-0.6432451605796814,
0.47174832224845886,
0.14055489003658295,
0.5772684216499329,
0.18382054567337036,
0.1237049549818039,
0.6569317579269409,
-0.5949626564979553,
0.7353954315185547,
0.3185271918773651,
-0.8112956285476685,
0.7283000946044922,
-0.5335211157798767,
0.22223438322544098,
0.7375907897949219,
0.4654006063938141,
-1.0110182762145996,
-0.39896252751350403,
-0.6956419944763184,
-0.3805694580078125,
0.6456087231636047,
-0.15448960661888123,
-0.3089500963687897,
-0.027054494246840477,
0.43075910210609436,
0.24154585599899292,
0.17272083461284637,
-0.34974220395088196,
-0.02908659167587757,
0.1933029741048813,
-0.9517679214477539,
-0.300387442111969,
-0.3867110311985016,
-0.291673868894577,
-0.15204976499080658,
0.5374233722686768,
-0.47536343336105347,
0.37241315841674805,
0.826454222202301,
-0.20491895079612732,
-0.3987201452255249,
0.2885243892669678,
1.0103304386138916,
0.6970349550247192,
-0.21019336581230164,
0.06435080617666245,
0.215049609541893,
-0.8280032277107239,
0.23101772367954254,
-0.14081259071826935,
-0.05655301734805107,
-0.06354014575481415,
0.6421871185302734,
0.658695638179779,
0.1569383293390274,
-0.9370022416114807,
0.6652269959449768,
-0.40795648097991943,
-0.006633198820054531,
-0.46027129888534546,
-0.020131699740886688,
-0.08462106436491013,
0.09049941599369049,
0.44224119186401367,
0.6413329243659973,
0.321159690618515,
-0.3755941390991211,
0.47133076190948486,
0.10450178384780884,
-0.46656474471092224,
-0.3449169397354126,
0.5086004137992859,
0.02150838077068329,
-0.34333670139312744,
0.3514854609966278,
-0.18421852588653564,
-0.6602381467819214,
0.6980178952217102,
0.39498475193977356,
0.8151894807815552,
-0.434095174074173,
0.11746680736541748,
0.342441201210022,
0.04683877155184746,
-0.5170194506645203,
0.3873428404331207,
0.2638380229473114,
-0.8595006465911865,
-0.537803590297699,
-0.08526353538036346,
-0.7611516118049622,
0.026916828006505966,
-0.5136588215827942,
0.25553974509239197,
-0.5575225949287415,
0.11595819890499115,
-0.33562469482421875,
-0.07762030512094498,
-0.45702558755874634,
0.5200071334838867,
-0.2371080219745636,
0.8720874190330505,
-0.626304566860199,
0.7111980319023132,
0.7751325964927673,
-0.21182604134082794,
-1.0234673023223877,
-0.1067778468132019,
0.2684710621833801,
-0.8829707503318787,
0.7345702648162842,
0.11798505485057831,
0.19983620941638947,
-0.18635444343090057,
-0.8019434809684753,
-0.6705315113067627,
1.1169112920761108,
-0.15294399857521057,
-0.780250072479248,
-0.08325671404600143,
-0.1930173635482788,
0.7484496235847473,
-0.4686467945575714,
0.19894753396511078,
0.30193382501602173,
0.09365915507078171,
0.1671440750360489,
-1.102623701095581,
0.0688968151807785,
0.06742554903030396,
-0.6116899847984314,
-0.05542532354593277,
-0.5824205279350281,
1.0208650827407837,
-0.3776998519897461,
-0.10538213700056076,
0.1652919203042984,
0.49678143858909607,
0.30994701385498047,
0.7134202718734741,
0.41149190068244934,
0.7379269003868103,
1.3917421102523804,
-0.000051049410103587434,
1.0453009605407715,
-0.10207784920930862,
0.1359669268131256,
1.332249402999878,
-0.37640881538391113,
0.630971372127533,
0.4512315094470978,
-0.21013900637626648,
0.4559065103530884,
0.7513267397880554,
0.18341556191444397,
0.40045228600502014,
-0.12718705832958221,
-0.27497705817222595,
-0.07343117147684097,
-0.14152173697948456,
-0.18214160203933716,
0.2974608838558197,
0.6124929785728455,
-0.20489618182182312,
-0.02311606891453266,
0.1940876990556717,
-0.001551886205561459,
0.04766211658716202,
-0.6783571839332581,
0.7449926137924194,
0.03597799316048622,
-0.98491370677948,
0.31582096219062805,
-0.3131074905395508,
0.7543360590934753,
-0.24230460822582245,
-0.11265640705823898,
-0.36782515048980713,
0.5201483368873596,
-0.25375205278396606,
-0.44912755489349365,
0.21959640085697174,
-0.19032101333141327,
-0.22640274465084076,
-0.15747934579849243,
0.9741775393486023,
-0.5633704662322998,
-0.32201454043388367,
-0.028823062777519226,
0.5276685357093811,
-0.00957155879586935,
0.18652653694152832,
-0.6934941411018372,
-0.05425753816962242,
-0.01983906701207161,
0.4938739836215973,
0.07145266979932785,
0.45767202973365784,
-0.07762609422206879,
0.8631787896156311,
0.31790125370025635,
0.08854939788579941,
-0.08342643827199936,
0.005327052902430296,
0.41544201970100403,
-0.5344329476356506,
-0.6702958941459656,
-0.6966689825057983,
0.2891509234905243,
-0.08459499478340149,
-0.23130178451538086,
0.6963902711868286,
0.3268599808216095,
0.705034613609314,
-0.23801033198833466,
0.7845513820648193,
0.24666474759578705,
1.1140761375427246,
-0.6067731976509094,
0.5239184498786926,
-0.5220576524734497,
0.17394377291202545,
-0.12495113164186478,
-0.2611270546913147,
-0.6858456134796143,
0.4388068616390228,
-0.13710905611515045,
-0.3524017333984375,
0.9730732440948486,
0.7149563431739807,
0.1959516704082489,
0.3562089204788208,
0.2136581391096115,
0.3448394536972046,
0.19394761323928833,
0.6593009233474731,
0.9810206890106201,
-0.6459619998931885,
-0.07493992149829865,
-0.07380177825689316,
-0.240653857588768,
-0.3385053277015686,
-0.7822369337081909,
-0.8325147032737732,
-0.45196154713630676,
-0.4749080538749695,
-0.5022284388542175,
0.17259721457958221,
1.4797625541687012,
0.3592662513256073,
-1.1162387132644653,
-0.011441715992987156,
-0.23533843457698822,
0.14685063064098358,
-0.14253760874271393,
-0.1394098997116089,
0.5100548267364502,
-0.6796379089355469,
-0.4386965036392212,
0.39059826731681824,
0.5052284598350525,
0.12228241562843323,
-0.026664022356271744,
-0.061264462769031525,
-0.08173088729381561,
-0.22225025296211243,
0.3027969300746918,
0.11756853759288788,
-0.5115706324577332,
-0.2201649248600006,
0.24993456900119781,
-0.47026047110557556,
0.2424047440290451,
1.0173038244247437,
-0.6353525519371033,
0.36958545446395874,
0.5522118806838989,
0.8513526916503906,
-0.21219106018543243,
-0.14368189871311188,
0.549067497253418,
-0.4275013208389282,
-0.10907496511936188,
0.4825212359428406,
0.4467785358428955,
0.5492864847183228,
-0.6426681876182556,
0.6996271014213562,
0.6107931733131409,
-0.7960715293884277,
-0.8297765851020813,
-0.2986087501049042,
-1.165893793106079,
-0.15399578213691711,
0.7361067533493042,
-0.3318052291870117,
-0.42095494270324707,
-0.5240464806556702,
-0.4194938540458679,
0.2474280744791031,
-0.2387399822473526,
0.7948334217071533,
0.5239014029502869,
-0.2559727430343628,
-0.2679031193256378,
-0.4506714642047882,
0.9402280449867249,
0.5812287926673889,
-0.8538208603858948,
-0.3791598677635193,
0.4174971580505371,
0.2615909278392792,
0.21563221514225006,
1.0750921964645386,
0.0827048122882843,
0.6814195513725281,
-0.2278502732515335,
0.14857156574726105,
0.25936904549598694,
-0.34850993752479553,
-0.6420621275901794,
0.053230851888656616,
-0.3328894078731537,
-0.08593221008777618
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.