id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06906v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06906v1
|
Finding structure in logographic writing with library learning
| 2024-05-11T04:23:53 | 2024-05-11T04:23:53 |
Guangyuan Jiang, Matthias Hofer, Jiayuan Mao, Lionel Wong, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, Roger P. Levy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
One hallmark of human language is its combinatoriality -- reusing a
relatively small inventory of building blocks to create a far larger inventory
of increasingly complex structures. In this paper, we explore the idea that
combinatoriality in language reflects a human inductive bias toward
representational efficiency in symbol systems. We develop a computational
framework for discovering structure in a writing system. Built on top of
state-of-the-art library learning and program synthesis techniques, our
computational framework discovers known linguistic structures in the Chinese
writing system and reveals how the system evolves towards simplification under
pressures for representational efficiency. We demonstrate how a library
learning approach, utilizing learned abstractions and compression, may help
reveal the fundamental computational principles that underlie the creation of
combinatorial structures in human cognition, and offer broader insights into
the evolution of efficient communication systems.
|
[
-0.11841000616550446,
-0.4034353792667389,
0.39202868938446045,
-0.006102331448346376,
-0.07009854912757874,
0.3386491537094116,
-0.20400944352149963,
-0.5209810137748718,
0.3824707865715027,
0.12032812833786011,
-0.6990199685096741,
-0.30584070086479187,
-0.4815813899040222,
0.0429503358900547,
-0.09633377194404602,
0.5036545991897583,
0.1286681592464447,
0.059016719460487366,
-0.11000723391771317,
-0.1734769642353058,
-0.3561297357082367,
-0.6392346620559692,
-0.5008670687675476,
-0.6657311320304871,
0.43819722533226013,
0.24316592514514923,
0.652664065361023,
0.971136748790741,
0.27808815240859985,
0.33590567111968994,
0.03306928277015686,
0.19064083695411682,
-0.5741845965385437,
0.0861557126045227,
0.19042815268039703,
-0.622164785861969,
0.07665187865495682,
-0.43247929215431213,
0.8191944360733032,
1.2700810432434082,
0.07648269087076187,
-0.018404221162199974,
0.1324833333492279,
0.9596472978591919,
-0.5892325043678284,
0.6545397043228149,
-0.3260906934738159,
0.13409382104873657,
-0.4951930642127991,
-0.3025802969932556,
-0.5337029099464417,
-0.1280839890241623,
-0.12566114962100983,
-0.7311276793479919,
0.24593067169189453,
0.25476014614105225,
0.678551197052002,
0.08741641789674759,
-0.06245947256684303,
-0.7413570284843445,
-0.5408257246017456,
0.6777521967887878,
-0.24261073768138885,
0.49248257279396057,
0.28659236431121826,
0.19088907539844513,
-0.30485832691192627,
-0.7243663668632507,
-0.3131906986236572,
-0.20820581912994385,
-0.28570565581321716,
-0.06693219393491745,
0.005590949207544327,
0.07182198762893677,
0.3648752272129059,
0.39724913239479065,
-0.6624273061752319,
-0.12772732973098755,
-0.5075045824050903,
-0.3284439146518707,
0.4432176947593689,
0.055142588913440704,
0.9806302785873413,
-0.06931212544441223,
-0.1338977962732315,
-0.42967307567596436,
-0.8118623495101929,
0.1107512041926384,
0.5434955954551697,
0.4235357344150543,
0.14653705060482025,
0.457312673330307,
0.2550736367702484,
0.5035377740859985,
-0.14008867740631104,
-0.03566773608326912,
0.156795933842659,
-0.20709827542304993,
-0.1429472118616104,
0.262578547000885,
0.5690075755119324,
-0.11239998042583466,
0.22166554629802704,
-0.30193719267845154,
-0.1921185553073883,
0.2342614084482193,
0.32566118240356445,
-0.630929708480835,
-0.7315038442611694,
-0.21598069369792938,
-0.6396332383155823,
-0.20474787056446075,
0.5402002930641174,
0.0422385036945343,
-0.4319927394390106,
-0.1925698220729828,
0.08844728022813797,
-0.7319101095199585,
-0.028498755767941475,
0.09278231859207153,
-0.6420694589614868,
0.17972595989704132,
0.12203983962535858,
-1.2964731454849243,
0.32814446091651917,
0.6768524646759033,
0.74198979139328,
0.07033257186412811,
-0.4048113226890564,
-0.2105918526649475,
0.3380185663700104,
-0.5476757287979126,
1.0090678930282593,
-0.37762969732284546,
-0.26459869742393494,
-0.05874137207865715,
-0.25677764415740967,
0.1467576026916504,
-0.6645433306694031,
0.8532083034515381,
-0.28441357612609863,
-0.17227396368980408,
-0.4369311034679413,
-0.6285346150398254,
-0.08136779069900513,
-0.10501040518283844,
-1.2139321565628052,
0.8589240312576294,
0.20159992575645447,
-0.7450985312461853,
0.31310170888900757,
-0.6092332601547241,
-0.74869704246521,
0.41037485003471375,
-0.5235860347747803,
-0.5394212603569031,
0.31897592544555664,
0.03453292325139046,
0.28872254490852356,
-0.06741032749414444,
-0.09033364057540894,
-0.12874284386634827,
-0.7511605024337769,
0.3274514079093933,
0.0626692995429039,
1.2593884468078613,
0.3844785988330841,
-0.23590923845767975,
-0.0509081594645977,
-0.5818618535995483,
-0.1435093730688095,
0.16932716965675354,
-0.7128896117210388,
-0.617245614528656,
0.2557409107685089,
0.048455409705638885,
-0.13688482344150543,
0.1448248326778412,
-0.4162045419216156,
0.5317243337631226,
-0.4620636999607086,
0.37073227763175964,
0.7033791542053223,
-0.08068308234214783,
0.6058764457702637,
-0.5472795367240906,
0.23353318870067596,
-0.1657392382621765,
-0.22827811539173126,
-0.39983463287353516,
-0.19048964977264404,
-0.7545517683029175,
-0.24425259232521057,
-0.14820069074630737,
0.20730039477348328,
-0.7347162365913391,
0.35281193256378174,
-0.19099779427051544,
-0.23562851548194885,
-0.12326588481664658,
0.2600935995578766,
0.5286335349082947,
-0.05742314085364342,
-0.031102025881409645,
-0.41458991169929504,
-0.6804928779602051,
-0.8469162583351135,
-0.33297744393348694,
-0.327406108379364,
-0.08667738735675812,
0.07489947974681854,
0.1564445048570633,
-0.14425906538963318,
0.45113351941108704,
-0.6407415270805359,
-0.011598533019423485,
-0.41168680787086487,
0.3741532266139984,
0.16437764465808868,
0.3798180818557739,
0.5047239661216736,
-0.6305559277534485,
-0.3436553478240967,
-0.06037120148539543,
-0.6444557905197144,
-0.32522454857826233,
-0.6485112905502319,
-0.21198758482933044,
0.19427940249443054,
0.7409309148788452,
-0.3652952015399933,
0.31860023736953735,
0.18027277290821075,
-0.36880066990852356,
0.6044220924377441,
-0.012129354290664196,
-0.22734995186328888,
-0.6837500929832458,
0.10583756119012833,
-0.3058511018753052,
0.21029113233089447,
-0.6411269903182983,
0.2716030478477478,
0.09761055558919907,
0.022905826568603516,
0.15693677961826324,
0.23833811283111572,
-1.1658269166946411,
-0.20273908972740173,
-0.18208381533622742,
-0.21936234831809998,
-0.12482200562953949,
0.6437615752220154,
-0.056580036878585815,
0.42702025175094604,
0.4840982258319855,
-0.38644400238990784,
0.011826839298009872,
0.048669010400772095,
-0.6694738864898682,
0.2640612721443176,
-0.2660994827747345,
-0.04110075160861015,
-0.3894936442375183,
0.08407177776098251,
-1.0780479907989502,
-0.24296972155570984,
0.22553466260433197,
-0.4854261875152588,
0.385273277759552,
0.20854978263378143,
-0.48029443621635437,
-0.23946385085582733,
-0.4509360194206238,
0.5878903865814209,
0.08042075484991074,
-0.6050926446914673,
0.5534701347351074,
0.4443875551223755,
0.007798049133270979,
-0.5637328028678894,
-0.6765760183334351,
0.043637219816446304,
0.14597459137439728,
-0.7411384582519531,
0.4552948474884033,
-0.37109267711639404,
-0.2040046751499176,
-0.20228877663612366,
-0.0713159441947937,
-0.0746193453669548,
0.21184000372886658,
0.4150705337524414,
0.22474311292171478,
-0.09735234826803207,
0.2933785319328308,
-0.08709368854761124,
0.25125032663345337,
0.20613957941532135,
-0.46105822920799255,
0.7355825304985046,
-0.038846082985401154,
-0.1889650523662567,
-0.31632542610168457,
0.41636237502098083,
0.4802074432373047,
0.12212671339511871,
0.3509845733642578,
0.3297502100467682,
-0.37578409910202026,
-0.843761682510376,
-0.10966240614652634,
-0.1162518635392189,
-0.5102445483207703,
0.3235049545764923,
-0.5641631484031677,
-0.7703206539154053,
0.3768657147884369,
-0.07617083936929703,
-0.044846318662166595,
0.2895040810108185,
0.6478808522224426,
0.05119026079773903,
0.4770837724208832,
0.8386422991752625,
0.06936442106962204,
0.6928059458732605,
-0.16912627220153809,
0.32659655809402466,
-0.5024383068084717,
-0.4013250470161438,
-0.45462363958358765,
-0.35129788517951965,
-0.35009828209877014,
-0.4518016278743744,
0.12967577576637268,
0.37267398834228516,
-0.19174696505069733,
0.4920404553413391,
-0.7607513666152954,
0.6324491500854492,
0.6620119214057922,
-0.022526249289512634,
0.3123425543308258,
0.23634006083011627,
-0.4528309404850006,
0.15251238644123077,
-0.691693127155304,
-0.37471503019332886,
0.823948323726654,
0.0719025582075119,
0.8912609815597534,
0.20384475588798523,
1.0195893049240112,
0.3208591341972351,
0.4069657027721405,
-0.8969910740852356,
0.41404303908348083,
-0.21524858474731445,
-0.2401261180639267,
-0.333824098110199,
-0.3059578835964203,
-1.066367745399475,
-0.014208481647074223,
-0.2672661542892456,
-0.719490647315979,
0.47109606862068176,
0.026979709044098854,
0.01606428436934948,
0.18811039626598358,
-0.5832839012145996,
0.6596163511276245,
-0.17545121908187866,
-0.1562223732471466,
0.08522671461105347,
-0.5771788954734802,
0.4730861186981201,
0.15949894487857819,
0.25844430923461914,
0.3653060793876648,
0.1551676094532013,
0.6087289452552795,
-0.46927592158317566,
1.0021294355392456,
0.33563554286956787,
-0.03349853679537773,
0.455796480178833,
0.2854919731616974,
0.21920888125896454,
-0.342987984418869,
0.04694816842675209,
-0.10622662305831909,
-0.08256454765796661,
-0.4065753221511841,
-0.6754620671272278,
0.4185161888599396,
-0.8711906671524048,
-0.0318988673388958,
-0.3999195992946625,
-0.5909643173217773,
0.27069586515426636,
0.32732972502708435,
0.3167581856250763,
0.5205602645874023,
-0.5119447112083435,
0.08075594156980515,
0.39787745475769043,
-0.040503762662410736,
0.41910624504089355,
-0.1734769195318222,
-0.10319267958402634,
-0.14584103226661682,
0.9072576761245728,
0.1927589327096939,
0.003325819969177246,
0.8435935974121094,
0.2497396320104599,
-0.03649327531456947,
-0.4760735034942627,
-0.25234556198120117,
0.33145779371261597,
-1.0377782583236694,
-0.04931052401661873,
-0.3393515646457672,
-0.1603820025920868,
-0.4732247591018677,
-0.48845767974853516,
0.00435494864359498,
-0.6780802011489868,
-0.22401198744773865,
-0.14148342609405518,
-0.3122299313545227,
1.0989716053009033,
-0.07086040079593658,
0.23256711661815643,
-0.3164691627025604,
0.22497981786727905,
0.24464887380599976,
0.3143779933452606,
0.33845263719558716,
0.17350518703460693,
-0.4675524830818176,
-0.35322675108909607,
-0.4979565739631653,
-0.8144045472145081,
0.309522420167923,
0.223882794380188,
0.756234347820282,
0.6741206645965576,
-0.1535140722990036,
0.5628954172134399,
-0.3412892818450928,
0.5839489102363586,
0.2888627350330353,
-0.9773358702659607,
0.13089093565940857,
-0.2792279124259949,
0.37193745374679565,
0.25234171748161316,
0.25481587648391724,
-0.5839314460754395,
-0.21427442133426666,
-0.5252386927604675,
-0.7465670108795166,
0.5007494688034058,
0.34635066986083984,
-0.17926141619682312,
-0.057588130235672,
0.5355132222175598,
-0.12717027962207794,
-0.07067839801311493,
-1.0939891338348389,
-0.32373496890068054,
-0.20289774239063263,
-0.27935677766799927,
0.26428279280662537,
-0.11267702281475067,
-0.002219890709966421,
-0.1940932720899582,
0.40023505687713623,
-0.24099735915660858,
0.3042328953742981,
0.05782156065106392,
-0.2731280028820038,
-0.09130633622407913,
0.14828123152256012,
0.43003812432289124,
0.5521531105041504,
-0.10242022573947906,
0.4080100655555725,
-0.46004581451416016,
-0.5181209444999695,
-0.1724870353937149,
-0.17740599811077118,
-0.2609155774116516,
-0.1292347013950348,
0.8302599191665649,
0.7661435604095459,
0.1726645529270172,
-0.8796494603157043,
0.23247501254081726,
0.06222621724009514,
-0.2595178782939911,
-0.3832723796367645,
0.18706545233726501,
0.3591187596321106,
0.06948455423116684,
0.6662722229957581,
-0.14461059868335724,
0.33057740330696106,
-1.0348366498947144,
0.27296552062034607,
0.6991784572601318,
-0.1535738706588745,
-0.2591140866279602,
0.3603963851928711,
-0.10174346715211868,
-0.44102898240089417,
0.6115089654922485,
-0.18823198974132538,
-0.49782729148864746,
0.6067952513694763,
0.7486898899078369,
1.1152023077011108,
-0.056808654218912125,
0.34799668192863464,
0.5436393618583679,
0.38706761598587036,
-0.11796371638774872,
0.29863789677619934,
-0.5282765030860901,
-0.8372961282730103,
-0.19156932830810547,
-0.8795157074928284,
-0.2669193148612976,
-0.34329214692115784,
-0.397612988948822,
0.23831376433372498,
-0.6238499879837036,
0.25530359148979187,
0.21554845571517944,
0.05683793127536774,
-0.27091556787490845,
-0.13120241463184357,
0.5911847949028015,
0.49339190125465393,
-0.8209380507469177,
0.8598111271858215,
0.6565821170806885,
-0.4563606083393097,
-1.1293126344680786,
-0.25461336970329285,
0.08028119802474976,
-0.7547124624252319,
1.1925475597381592,
0.36911478638648987,
-0.44777315855026245,
-0.37620216608047485,
-0.7703180909156799,
-0.8364168405532837,
1.2051764726638794,
0.28047096729278564,
-0.3102923333644867,
-0.19055725634098053,
0.23301470279693604,
0.5996341109275818,
-0.635733962059021,
0.052398260682821274,
0.2839065492153168,
0.36610814929008484,
0.2878308594226837,
-0.4072686433792114,
0.28558218479156494,
-0.5642746686935425,
0.20463906228542328,
0.36999088525772095,
-0.27760809659957886,
1.2133547067642212,
-0.26142778992652893,
-1.0186636447906494,
0.1786743700504303,
0.6476538181304932,
0.2055753618478775,
0.007830390706658363,
0.2757914364337921,
0.5408385992050171,
0.9128668308258057,
-0.025912465527653694,
0.9871706962585449,
-0.13837316632270813,
0.13157625496387482,
0.7779449820518494,
0.24187780916690826,
0.4507555365562439,
0.5233632326126099,
-0.07849331945180893,
1.102522373199463,
0.3038445711135864,
-0.11632304638624191,
0.11146386712789536,
0.7200353741645813,
-0.185688778758049,
-0.15718455612659454,
-0.021762259304523468,
0.2576085329055786,
0.279710054397583,
0.43791526556015015,
-0.44256940484046936,
-0.2460731863975525,
-0.23994246125221252,
-0.05565407872200012,
0.31828221678733826,
-0.1790994554758072,
0.7012710571289062,
0.05741281434893608,
-0.6823199987411499,
0.8194435834884644,
-0.11998385936021805,
0.5458737015724182,
-0.5779958963394165,
-0.2694695293903351,
-0.09026014059782028,
0.09735679626464844,
-0.24606896936893463,
-0.6178306341171265,
0.3126147389411926,
-0.6141685247421265,
-0.3546639680862427,
-0.27833423018455505,
0.6644138693809509,
-0.44258034229278564,
-0.5673065781593323,
0.11108718812465668,
0.2683279514312744,
0.1887940764427185,
0.18927215039730072,
-0.4926339089870453,
0.514182984828949,
0.06495796889066696,
-0.11806861311197281,
0.1293054223060608,
0.43780308961868286,
-0.3287080228328705,
0.5291461944580078,
0.7692205905914307,
0.15157125890254974,
0.1345416009426117,
0.06392668932676315,
0.9335960149765015,
-0.8012070059776306,
-0.7049975395202637,
-0.8130412101745605,
0.11905069649219513,
-0.2278272956609726,
-0.03977568447589874,
0.5520724654197693,
0.6204500794410706,
1.0041818618774414,
-0.1456303894519806,
0.8820013999938965,
-0.07669654488563538,
-0.015711279585957527,
-0.3964938819408417,
0.7546947598457336,
-0.26986750960350037,
0.2864987254142761,
-0.5186633467674255,
-0.7750742435455322,
-0.7222813367843628,
0.7747891545295715,
0.02587185800075531,
-0.3648849427700043,
0.8831494450569153,
0.8533943295478821,
0.09861407428979874,
0.06675589829683304,
0.10461089015007019,
0.06392108649015427,
0.4165365695953369,
0.7223158478736877,
0.6465780138969421,
-0.20720306038856506,
0.6431179642677307,
-0.35460543632507324,
-0.37219077348709106,
-0.04894350841641426,
-0.8184229731559753,
-1.0253536701202393,
-1.0510894060134888,
-0.003472398268058896,
-0.23923715949058533,
-0.01782187633216381,
0.7539572715759277,
0.36663785576820374,
-0.5335037112236023,
-0.8048561215400696,
-0.31010162830352783,
0.2852761149406433,
-0.4627992808818817,
-0.26222947239875793,
0.8443767428398132,
-0.5065106749534607,
-0.686862051486969,
0.16438499093055725,
0.5891956090927124,
-0.015556877478957176,
-0.23746056854724884,
-0.14447486400604248,
-0.1848277449607849,
0.09091517329216003,
0.6905469298362732,
0.7621902823448181,
-0.6047177314758301,
-0.04990629479289055,
0.01989363320171833,
-0.3437255322933197,
0.1525629311800003,
1.3435004949569702,
-0.5888460278511047,
0.5531556606292725,
0.8898690938949585,
0.687773585319519,
0.425177663564682,
-0.04806792363524437,
0.4471348822116852,
-0.7582416534423828,
-0.009582816623151302,
0.10988415777683258,
0.5586102604866028,
0.4978351294994354,
-0.3832789361476898,
0.30145272612571716,
0.3152574598789215,
-0.42576080560684204,
-0.6008381843566895,
0.6412787437438965,
-1.1888341903686523,
-0.920297384262085,
0.6526179313659668,
0.179628387093544,
-0.5573284029960632,
-0.19080163538455963,
-0.42953363060951233,
0.25635606050491333,
-0.20045319199562073,
0.8600906729698181,
0.6839818358421326,
-0.5103878378868103,
-0.2022329419851303,
0.2434314787387848,
0.663507878780365,
0.11000150442123413,
-0.6119832992553711,
0.2534857392311096,
0.8826175332069397,
0.06809388846158981,
0.6060032248497009,
0.8709034323692322,
0.04188643768429756,
0.20994515717029572,
0.2928960621356964,
0.22504106163978577,
-0.13352267444133759,
-0.31782108545303345,
0.120704285800457,
0.44295501708984375,
0.09304314106702805,
0.3416541814804077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08014v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08014v1
|
Robot Detection System 1: Front-Following
| 2024-05-11T03:56:23 | 2024-05-11T03:56:23 |
Jinwei Lin
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL
|
Front-following is more technically difficult to implement than the other two
human following technologies, but front-following technology is more practical
and can be applied in more areas to solve more practical problems.
Front-following technology has many advantages not found in back-following and
side-by-side technologies. In this paper, we will discuss basic and significant
principles and general design idea of this technology. Besides, various of
novel and special useful methods will be presented and provided. We use enough
beautiful figures to display our novel design idea. Our research result is open
source in 2018, and this paper is just to expand the research result
propagation granularity. Abundant magic design idea are included in this paper,
more idea and analyzing can sear and see other paper naming with a start of
Robot Design System with Jinwei Lin, the only author of this series papers.
|
[
-0.712810218334198,
-0.49213895201683044,
0.4530088007450104,
0.17147387564182281,
-0.3747790455818176,
0.052818745374679565,
0.40411487221717834,
-0.6661431193351746,
0.46090003848075867,
0.6106050610542297,
-0.6430550217628479,
-0.5171602964401245,
-0.4965437054634094,
0.08762715011835098,
-0.3980804681777954,
0.26947206258773804,
0.012210479006171227,
-0.3156362771987915,
0.5623569488525391,
-0.18649086356163025,
-0.6045736074447632,
-0.4188491404056549,
-0.5157381892204285,
-0.06946903467178345,
0.7011004686355591,
0.3156801462173462,
0.9335305094718933,
0.5716083645820618,
0.7282684445381165,
0.40968239307403564,
0.12682212889194489,
0.11907617002725601,
0.27629125118255615,
-0.06644608825445175,
-0.17180390655994415,
-0.5817977786064148,
-0.6662620902061462,
-0.23019763827323914,
0.3853153884410858,
0.3895103633403778,
0.37196382880210876,
-0.23504449427127838,
-0.016934016719460487,
0.9552618265151978,
-0.5867170691490173,
-0.0774664431810379,
0.2877689599990845,
0.24116264283657074,
-0.5314578413963318,
-0.3404288589954376,
-0.3110308051109314,
-0.22234804928302765,
-0.10942365974187851,
-0.5713096857070923,
0.036095842719078064,
0.24977166950702667,
0.8219640254974365,
0.10097098350524902,
-0.13306473195552826,
-0.24280907213687897,
-0.7743606567382812,
0.35090669989585876,
-0.45022913813591003,
0.517596423625946,
0.324741393327713,
0.5405842065811157,
-0.2145419418811798,
-0.3170278072357178,
-0.748795211315155,
-0.19192571938037872,
-0.025342265143990517,
0.034649044275283813,
-0.28363633155822754,
-0.12112226337194443,
0.08586158603429794,
-0.036532167345285416,
-0.753167450428009,
0.08174069970846176,
-0.10718761384487152,
-0.1816982626914978,
0.7404406070709229,
0.028626568615436554,
0.25698602199554443,
0.07143980264663696,
-0.4862252473831177,
-0.5245816111564636,
-0.2024846076965332,
0.004934362135827541,
0.43636438250541687,
0.3688334822654724,
-0.13224850594997406,
0.43107694387435913,
-0.759255051612854,
0.503521203994751,
-0.013288880698382854,
-0.07935179024934769,
0.511862576007843,
-0.6154770255088806,
-0.1451367288827896,
-0.6775718331336975,
0.48163092136383057,
0.5141691565513611,
0.5297000408172607,
-0.16787566244602203,
-0.47567522525787354,
0.267567902803421,
0.218075692653656,
-0.54741370677948,
-0.2149430811405182,
0.23080706596374512,
-0.8755872249603271,
-0.4526572525501251,
0.3729647397994995,
-0.5876408815383911,
-0.3354358971118927,
-0.05354900285601616,
0.5959628820419312,
-0.4282452464103699,
-0.6019957661628723,
0.23292581737041473,
-0.2611640989780426,
0.5441876649856567,
0.4768289029598236,
-0.5753693580627441,
0.22834715247154236,
0.8985806703567505,
0.9734277129173279,
-0.00807342678308487,
0.06481853872537613,
-0.3569800853729248,
-0.188689723610878,
-0.5877631306648254,
0.9535979628562927,
-0.07953653484582901,
-0.40149006247520447,
-0.056652966886758804,
0.44124603271484375,
0.40554529428482056,
-0.4647364020347595,
0.3253655433654785,
-0.6463862061500549,
0.23397940397262573,
-0.17670372128486633,
-0.1928667575120926,
-0.5014527440071106,
-0.0334438793361187,
-0.4859926104545593,
0.3980562686920166,
-0.041512131690979004,
-0.6229972243309021,
0.36937129497528076,
-0.6908368468284607,
-0.764245867729187,
0.44464996457099915,
-0.17487385869026184,
-0.46060431003570557,
-0.053952813148498535,
-0.11713935434818268,
0.3896496593952179,
0.2658665180206299,
-0.155950665473938,
-0.15396149456501007,
-0.37828242778778076,
-0.0663774162530899,
0.16176196932792664,
0.9088829159736633,
0.6688134074211121,
-0.1298891007900238,
0.15495096147060394,
-0.5807473659515381,
-0.07722847908735275,
0.4528611898422241,
0.1405971199274063,
-0.48250138759613037,
0.34093838930130005,
-0.16019423305988312,
0.047773346304893494,
0.12231317162513733,
-0.5611606240272522,
0.0251768808811903,
-0.13287906348705292,
-0.2614579498767853,
0.7289533615112305,
-0.20287971198558807,
0.545769214630127,
-0.4056057333946228,
0.6125400066375732,
-0.3089458644390106,
0.3592493534088135,
-0.2540956735610962,
-0.8203518390655518,
-0.4804637134075165,
-0.2059514969587326,
0.14410832524299622,
0.8587937951087952,
-0.9573345184326172,
0.8983364701271057,
0.6597005128860474,
-0.27373483777046204,
-0.0034903425257653,
-0.1580434888601303,
0.5171763896942139,
0.0958387479186058,
0.03484676405787468,
-0.48218095302581787,
-0.7051597833633423,
-0.8759975433349609,
-0.12425677478313446,
-0.029223069548606873,
-0.33306291699409485,
-0.2672945261001587,
0.6172962188720703,
-0.019597798585891724,
0.7267565131187439,
-0.5379884243011475,
-0.20528018474578857,
0.13775120675563812,
-0.3691452741622925,
0.30435910820961,
0.5240318179130554,
0.7406672239303589,
-0.9733521938323975,
-0.2538709342479706,
0.17734605073928833,
-1.0461708307266235,
-0.08002789318561554,
0.20680326223373413,
-0.42499613761901855,
0.17923539876937866,
0.21407873928546906,
-0.4189259111881256,
1.057570457458496,
0.03672386705875397,
-0.21099427342414856,
0.2513507306575775,
0.15626972913742065,
0.10130688548088074,
-0.8711230158805847,
-0.02075491100549698,
0.31706443428993225,
0.03639188036322594,
-0.8194674849510193,
0.5044585466384888,
-0.06162181869149208,
-0.020825648680329323,
-0.2068721204996109,
0.3632051646709442,
-0.011859764344990253,
-0.355734646320343,
-1.1002787351608276,
0.15270502865314484,
0.028558477759361267,
0.3184434473514557,
0.060183096677064896,
0.31616348028182983,
0.23932231962680817,
-0.8687333464622498,
0.6894904971122742,
0.09454343467950821,
-0.0055838096886873245,
0.5615391731262207,
-0.5327082276344299,
0.20298507809638977,
-0.020645875483751297,
0.5009103417396545,
-1.1389305591583252,
-0.24320325255393982,
1.0545463562011719,
-0.7648932337760925,
-0.05592206120491028,
0.1390373706817627,
-0.7574707865715027,
-1.074141025543213,
-0.3419840931892395,
-0.12659604847431183,
0.6143354773521423,
-0.4852675497531891,
0.4495779275894165,
0.10012812912464142,
0.011848203837871552,
-0.4090834856033325,
-0.6263304948806763,
-0.18969516456127167,
-0.20508283376693726,
-1.085766077041626,
0.15423040091991425,
0.03471517562866211,
-0.5038074254989624,
-0.301413357257843,
-0.24386481940746307,
0.009147307835519314,
0.19074495136737823,
-0.02598581649363041,
0.4375930726528168,
-0.28059884905815125,
0.22857004404067993,
-0.27558788657188416,
-0.6794957518577576,
-0.08357807993888855,
-0.19471679627895355,
0.5695838928222656,
-0.058749228715896606,
-0.38811030983924866,
-1.1619060039520264,
0.4835526645183563,
0.01879165507853031,
0.10020390152931213,
0.06985591351985931,
0.4690074324607849,
-0.5799804329872131,
-0.08751355856657028,
-0.09282504767179489,
-0.24828389286994934,
-0.6602070331573486,
0.11330610513687134,
-0.6359081268310547,
-0.1297760307788849,
0.5329723954200745,
0.12974987924098969,
0.19218841195106506,
0.24186201393604279,
0.3244362473487854,
-0.26595041155815125,
1.0152298212051392,
1.1809422969818115,
0.14105504751205444,
0.8896372318267822,
-0.02726627141237259,
0.05645357817411423,
-0.3426368236541748,
-0.23921802639961243,
-0.6918284893035889,
-0.33723482489585876,
-0.6358895897865295,
-0.10929237306118011,
-0.03871886804699898,
0.16637107729911804,
-0.5164502263069153,
0.7293556928634644,
-0.9645891189575195,
-0.1017485111951828,
0.7812023758888245,
0.3955909013748169,
0.3939405083656311,
-0.085622638463974,
-0.12889210879802704,
0.3630978465080261,
-0.29577919840812683,
-0.5411836504936218,
0.6184267401695251,
0.45759037137031555,
0.789722204208374,
0.021317757666110992,
0.7092565894126892,
0.4327857494354248,
-0.1488255113363266,
-0.8665322065353394,
0.7141358256340027,
-0.27365753054618835,
-0.47725483775138855,
-0.3381267786026001,
0.17906317114830017,
-0.8777527809143066,
0.3927205204963684,
0.2532094419002533,
-0.4558619260787964,
0.41474443674087524,
0.10859265178442001,
-0.4165440797805786,
0.4302918016910553,
-0.7418617606163025,
0.12676960229873657,
-0.1272422820329666,
-0.20510220527648926,
-0.0929218977689743,
-1.0527715682983398,
0.250349223613739,
0.015148681588470936,
0.25138619542121887,
0.0694974958896637,
0.12239089608192444,
1.0339269638061523,
-0.5501649379730225,
0.5542975068092346,
-0.47766536474227905,
-0.34937572479248047,
0.8114737272262573,
-0.0297782551497221,
0.5621564984321594,
-0.2892930507659912,
0.08864405751228333,
-0.28031083941459656,
-0.6438859105110168,
-0.4963727295398712,
-0.5220539569854736,
0.06463206559419632,
-0.245372474193573,
-0.777807354927063,
-0.4684171676635742,
-0.2656264901161194,
0.26073354482650757,
0.32928311824798584,
0.117280013859272,
-0.16883863508701324,
0.2677159011363983,
-0.033727023750543594,
0.47322481870651245,
-0.11841005831956863,
0.6054745316505432,
0.4588759243488312,
-0.7516718506813049,
-0.1999230831861496,
0.797853410243988,
-0.059201546013355255,
0.1124633327126503,
0.4325835704803467,
0.1926126331090927,
0.09344927966594696,
-0.36816054582595825,
-0.5502102375030518,
0.07700816541910172,
-0.49575889110565186,
-0.14148257672786713,
-0.36411935091018677,
-0.2449592798948288,
-0.4861834943294525,
-0.293797105550766,
-0.4334157705307007,
-0.1651182323694229,
0.016880745068192482,
0.2709050476551056,
0.7392081618309021,
0.7596601843833923,
-0.516822874546051,
0.6043457388877869,
-0.1886354237794876,
0.7347769141197205,
0.27361106872558594,
0.4069397449493408,
0.11250433325767517,
-0.2832792103290558,
-0.16087476909160614,
0.12144589424133301,
-0.5758681297302246,
-0.37831753492355347,
0.2938396632671356,
-0.867315411567688,
0.43073856830596924,
0.6628811359405518,
-0.03285251557826996,
0.25360673666000366,
-0.09499026834964752,
0.0827641412615776,
0.1976277232170105,
-0.5199838280677795,
0.6789315342903137,
-0.37615731358528137,
0.023261783644557,
0.018792416900396347,
0.1651015281677246,
-0.36960139870643616,
0.022648854181170464,
-0.4012347161769867,
-0.20059198141098022,
0.480578750371933,
0.2776047885417938,
-0.3854333162307739,
0.45124679803848267,
0.18023443222045898,
0.22685247659683228,
0.010660503059625626,
-0.4004484713077545,
-0.1871407926082611,
-0.34449830651283264,
0.14609825611114502,
0.11166772991418839,
0.5353968143463135,
-0.006459123454988003,
0.034223560243844986,
0.2107325941324234,
-0.05720064789056778,
0.8119322657585144,
0.12857340276241302,
0.6029302477836609,
-0.13092900812625885,
-0.062149643898010254,
0.7772796750068665,
0.1844252049922943,
-0.3857184648513794,
-0.31378844380378723,
-0.04775235429406166,
-0.3277203142642975,
-0.048268552869558334,
-0.18029475212097168,
-0.17152883112430573,
-0.06204010918736458,
0.2762221395969391,
0.2323114424943924,
-0.4704027771949768,
0.20285873115062714,
0.4292183220386505,
0.5473045706748962,
-0.38745129108428955,
-0.41050851345062256,
0.5017380118370056,
0.1642204076051712,
0.8448216319084167,
0.8720302581787109,
0.5891662240028381,
-0.02407553419470787,
-0.7122524380683899,
0.5172709226608276,
0.4868639409542084,
-0.25178736448287964,
-0.48540765047073364,
0.4608583152294159,
0.3140794634819031,
-1.17288076877594,
-0.0541372150182724,
-0.4634225368499756,
-0.5223166942596436,
0.9776719212532043,
0.5574387311935425,
0.6284115314483643,
-0.4789670705795288,
0.2596663534641266,
-0.2753461003303528,
0.30828607082366943,
-0.09390909224748611,
0.7958875298500061,
-0.188810795545578,
-0.8539560437202454,
-0.1871093511581421,
0.01445565652102232,
-0.6541327834129333,
-0.220259428024292,
-0.5412842035293579,
0.6495407223701477,
-0.5865959525108337,
-0.056294772773981094,
0.11921083927154541,
0.20687535405158997,
-0.589367687702179,
0.3134097754955292,
0.0765768438577652,
0.8713115453720093,
-0.6490156650543213,
0.7647653818130493,
0.38057923316955566,
-0.21408891677856445,
0.023953231051564217,
-0.004283028654754162,
0.21334142982959747,
-1.2204049825668335,
0.5670611262321472,
0.23063240945339203,
-0.5317856073379517,
-0.32063809037208557,
-0.9081218838691711,
-0.6003727912902832,
1.0940622091293335,
-0.43710726499557495,
-0.4746856689453125,
-0.21543148159980774,
-0.506686270236969,
0.4746965169906616,
-0.654424786567688,
-0.25374773144721985,
0.14127732813358307,
0.8371684551239014,
0.257107675075531,
-0.8583495020866394,
0.13728179037570953,
-0.15325894951820374,
-0.0381559319794178,
0.29214316606521606,
-1.1396369934082031,
1.0247620344161987,
-0.3022192716598511,
-0.6213246583938599,
0.7311733961105347,
0.49026238918304443,
0.5227644443511963,
1.0212599039077759,
0.38064056634902954,
0.24948763847351074,
0.3392425775527954,
0.19976234436035156,
0.8750521540641785,
0.2855836749076843,
-0.012125292792916298,
0.5982798337936401,
-0.33594727516174316,
0.43075284361839294,
0.07598870992660522,
-0.34576326608657837,
0.6019351482391357,
0.4950605034828186,
-0.18206234276294708,
0.8110668659210205,
0.32556936144828796,
-0.06030154973268509,
-0.007558569777756929,
0.23035651445388794,
-0.8251771926879883,
0.5187528729438782,
0.5109580755233765,
-0.2764486074447632,
-0.03324480354785919,
0.4065081775188446,
0.0454278364777565,
0.054413095116615295,
-0.08795882761478424,
0.22090952098369598,
-0.0493079349398613,
-0.13519816100597382,
0.20828965306282043,
-0.01713087037205696,
1.031235694885254,
-0.2725534737110138,
-0.1739758551120758,
-0.0711170956492424,
0.4149158298969269,
-0.30820223689079285,
-0.9890087842941284,
0.0024151213001459837,
-0.3820747137069702,
0.12366577982902527,
-0.03014647774398327,
1.090097188949585,
0.584001898765564,
-0.2706456780433655,
0.590964138507843,
0.6613135933876038,
0.24805797636508942,
-0.08950985223054886,
-0.155857115983963,
0.037476032972335815,
0.18666374683380127,
-0.21794293820858002,
-0.0919915959239006,
0.6409900188446045,
-0.23153938353061676,
0.9643721580505371,
0.4250607192516327,
-0.21766166388988495,
-0.0681324377655983,
-0.11268290132284164,
0.9082587361335754,
-1.2978157997131348,
-0.4933508634567261,
-0.49313807487487793,
0.37997645139694214,
-0.1304423063993454,
-0.2327122986316681,
0.9216865301132202,
0.04609307274222374,
0.7725739479064941,
0.04078913480043411,
0.7637404799461365,
-0.31559106707572937,
0.9149922132492065,
-0.0924379974603653,
0.34314754605293274,
-0.28629857301712036,
-0.00591365247964859,
-0.5956711769104004,
-0.7300763130187988,
-0.7069284915924072,
1.0175195932388306,
0.13008685410022736,
0.306538462638855,
0.6514883041381836,
0.5816643834114075,
0.1282159686088562,
0.34759730100631714,
0.3937518894672394,
-0.16862891614437103,
0.19711117446422577,
0.26317012310028076,
0.8814604878425598,
-0.7743714451789856,
0.36669033765792847,
-0.30479687452316284,
-0.6648194193840027,
-0.5858453512191772,
-0.3729504942893982,
-0.665742814540863,
-0.3740740716457367,
-0.06172309070825577,
-0.3846098482608795,
0.2722359597682953,
0.2183012217283249,
0.9214380383491516,
-0.6860268115997314,
0.010651634074747562,
-0.2654626667499542,
0.30737075209617615,
-0.12655124068260193,
-0.2082047164440155,
0.22829751670360565,
0.11163170635700226,
-0.36676543951034546,
0.3632047176361084,
0.14242523908615112,
0.15672260522842407,
-0.286115437746048,
-0.18306560814380646,
-0.36668136715888977,
-0.31525611877441406,
0.7974742650985718,
0.7336693406105042,
-0.698689341545105,
-0.8488439321517944,
0.19353914260864258,
-0.019218632951378822,
0.28875836730003357,
0.5188255310058594,
-1.0163962841033936,
0.29552099108695984,
0.5930253267288208,
0.08237500488758087,
0.1471959352493286,
0.11638102680444717,
0.4156166613101959,
-0.09432279318571091,
0.2878236770629883,
-0.1041366457939148,
0.15514704585075378,
-0.08803804963827133,
-0.26206743717193604,
0.9398754239082336,
0.5747561454772949,
-0.555701494216919,
-0.5308781266212463,
0.4631641209125519,
-0.9766361117362976,
-0.2597377598285675,
0.5843573808670044,
0.10910312086343765,
-0.11597862094640732,
-0.49749264121055603,
-0.28852230310440063,
0.4191044270992279,
-0.4433360695838928,
0.3852711319923401,
0.5420883893966675,
-0.7465750575065613,
0.07229486852884293,
-0.6558716893196106,
-0.06441369652748108,
0.030585572123527527,
-0.376421719789505,
-0.5934727787971497,
-0.005374360829591751,
0.2181558459997177,
0.8919934034347534,
0.5793706178665161,
-0.05415666475892067,
0.46997717022895813,
0.5696519017219543,
0.24418963491916656,
0.042607735842466354,
-0.4652911126613617,
-0.27840569615364075,
0.22800928354263306,
-0.2968645393848419,
-1.1703284978866577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06890v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06890v1
|
TacoERE: Cluster-aware Compression for Event Relation Extraction
| 2024-05-11T03:06:08 | 2024-05-11T03:06:08 |
Yong Guan, Xiaozhi Wang, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li, Jeff Pan, Jiaoyan Chen, Freddy Lecue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Event relation extraction (ERE) is a critical and fundamental challenge for
natural language processing. Existing work mainly focuses on directly modeling
the entire document, which cannot effectively handle long-range dependencies
and information redundancy. To address these issues, we propose a cluster-aware
compression method for improving event relation extraction (TacoERE), which
explores a compression-then-extraction paradigm. Specifically, we first
introduce document clustering for modeling event dependencies. It splits the
document into intra- and inter-clusters, where intra-clusters aim to enhance
the relations within the same cluster, while inter-clusters attempt to model
the related events at arbitrary distances. Secondly, we utilize cluster
summarization to simplify and highlight important text content of clusters for
mitigating information redundancy and event distance. We have conducted
extensive experiments on both pre-trained language models, such as RoBERTa, and
large language models, such as ChatGPT and GPT-4, on three ERE datasets, i.e.,
MAVEN-ERE, EventStoryLine and HiEve. Experimental results demonstrate that
TacoERE is an effective method for ERE.
|
[
-0.5644975900650024,
-0.6400878429412842,
0.5648754835128784,
0.10045262426137924,
-0.36615121364593506,
-0.1498422771692276,
-0.48996785283088684,
-0.8141435980796814,
0.5282455086708069,
0.12723124027252197,
-0.33536672592163086,
-0.5692696571350098,
-0.8311625123023987,
0.10336344689130783,
-0.5682783722877502,
0.8187805414199829,
0.12144853919744492,
-0.491786926984787,
0.03552097827196121,
-0.19244393706321716,
-0.34131282567977905,
-0.6791336536407471,
-0.9789712429046631,
-0.030448082834482193,
0.5799887776374817,
0.20445454120635986,
0.18181553483009338,
0.6396141648292542,
0.3840285837650299,
0.1535262018442154,
-0.4315933883190155,
0.06834914535284042,
-0.5380117297172546,
0.2766694724559784,
-0.12829893827438354,
-0.2615184187889099,
-0.32287082076072693,
-0.2818197011947632,
0.6512455344200134,
0.41445717215538025,
-0.4678443372249603,
0.1410030573606491,
0.019950607791543007,
0.39110106229782104,
-0.8191453218460083,
0.2956068217754364,
-0.4171648323535919,
-0.029080040752887726,
-0.2836865186691284,
-0.12263847142457962,
-0.5541651844978333,
-0.3904195725917816,
-0.07829766720533371,
-0.5005555748939514,
0.38628828525543213,
-0.05780729278922081,
1.1130075454711914,
0.09929221123456955,
-0.17283470928668976,
0.11985401064157486,
-0.8035827279090881,
0.6102526187896729,
-0.543548047542572,
0.5129613280296326,
0.45421093702316284,
0.19255861639976501,
-0.08911484479904175,
-0.745586633682251,
-0.5366618037223816,
0.2661132216453552,
-0.17803138494491577,
0.12479386478662491,
-0.2985471189022064,
-0.006508436519652605,
0.15725374221801758,
0.3010556697845459,
-0.3441358506679535,
0.20047031342983246,
-0.23231396079063416,
0.02023194544017315,
0.2687090039253235,
0.07148012518882751,
0.4000539481639862,
-0.19721513986587524,
-0.1613978147506714,
-0.14616745710372925,
-0.5049546360969543,
-0.31057223677635193,
-0.1431916356086731,
0.36544743180274963,
-0.09989773482084274,
0.21450136601924896,
0.19392479956150055,
0.5842013955116272,
0.1313071846961975,
-0.07911856472492218,
-0.0704704225063324,
-0.2523365616798401,
-0.2961253821849823,
0.08165187388658524,
0.8266221284866333,
0.11370158940553665,
0.14527542889118195,
-0.4796536862850189,
0.006581883877515793,
0.13532543182373047,
0.10165764391422272,
-0.8238136172294617,
-0.05125437304377556,
0.4372921586036682,
-0.4220271706581116,
-0.3826643228530884,
0.3377920091152191,
-1.2639307975769043,
-0.17203718423843384,
-0.23462839424610138,
0.20702241361141205,
-0.44115087389945984,
-0.3587713837623596,
0.002540691988542676,
-0.2677414119243622,
0.031200839206576347,
0.19038987159729004,
-0.8629909753799438,
0.6462528109550476,
0.6853329539299011,
0.7966944575309753,
-0.4507000148296356,
-0.3313463628292084,
-0.8673901557922363,
0.4287837743759155,
0.19162504374980927,
1.0818209648132324,
-0.5548900961875916,
-0.5383176803588867,
-0.14666005969047546,
-0.13843411207199097,
-0.037917401641607285,
-0.49290546774864197,
0.6802076697349548,
-0.3897087872028351,
0.23489151895046234,
0.07121740281581879,
-0.4570600092411041,
-0.09582765400409698,
0.31321194767951965,
-0.8208926916122437,
1.3105180263519287,
0.10125195980072021,
-0.8369302749633789,
0.21239253878593445,
-0.6133001446723938,
-0.611477255821228,
-0.2028367519378662,
-0.49712374806404114,
-0.4725366234779358,
0.2953462302684784,
0.5779168009757996,
0.41410937905311584,
-0.6001831293106079,
0.32138243317604065,
-0.029452431946992874,
-0.06086806580424309,
-0.22006294131278992,
0.0563046969473362,
0.39348354935646057,
0.0542728453874588,
-0.17192302644252777,
-0.04722269997000694,
-0.9707457423210144,
-0.3681393563747406,
0.09825275838375092,
-0.33938875794410706,
-0.4557434916496277,
0.03594042733311653,
0.05416514351963997,
0.1569274514913559,
0.21395455300807953,
-0.6163466572761536,
0.257531076669693,
-0.417239785194397,
0.1964655965566635,
0.48558369278907776,
0.44751542806625366,
0.6636468172073364,
0.005051529034972191,
0.5935120582580566,
0.29238107800483704,
0.33990389108657837,
-0.2555881440639496,
-0.261060506105423,
-0.6122516393661499,
-0.1626901626586914,
0.49326929450035095,
0.4271355867385864,
-0.6610015630722046,
0.6768354773521423,
-0.4747389256954193,
-0.44006359577178955,
-0.14107373356819153,
-0.5183171033859253,
0.08337198197841644,
0.5862329006195068,
0.48473846912384033,
-0.249643474817276,
-0.6421999335289001,
-0.6396288275718689,
-0.19778668880462646,
-0.2089385688304901,
0.13045352697372437,
-0.10612008720636368,
0.08383861929178238,
0.05874466150999069,
1.2515537738800049,
-0.7743155360221863,
-0.3227245807647705,
-0.18708042800426483,
0.6168449521064758,
0.13426321744918823,
0.38572028279304504,
0.7063894867897034,
-0.9654681086540222,
-0.33397307991981506,
0.3894953429698944,
-0.45504841208457947,
-0.27160245180130005,
0.16300900280475616,
0.0432872474193573,
0.1687295138835907,
0.36904555559158325,
-0.4174584448337555,
0.875946044921875,
0.5493912696838379,
-0.31243541836738586,
0.5331823229789734,
-0.04840705916285515,
0.33601051568984985,
-1.3390973806381226,
0.041574105620384216,
-0.10673774778842926,
-0.43464159965515137,
-0.6833254098892212,
-0.022174375131726265,
0.035118408501148224,
-0.17963112890720367,
-0.2901301980018616,
0.4539268910884857,
-0.5292598605155945,
0.00484466552734375,
-0.3123880624771118,
0.0675019919872284,
-0.011854128912091255,
0.5280934572219849,
0.37651190161705017,
0.5349465012550354,
0.4844752550125122,
-0.8323462605476379,
-0.2078186273574829,
0.22846968472003937,
-0.12175938487052917,
0.28157204389572144,
-0.3920600116252899,
0.2129509598016739,
-0.18644335865974426,
0.03762443736195564,
-0.3934335708618164,
-0.0672706887125969,
0.023511331528425217,
-0.43971264362335205,
0.5597813129425049,
-0.3732334077358246,
-0.7886091470718384,
0.0558321550488472,
-0.15067528188228607,
0.5300611853599548,
0.4835619032382965,
-0.7166552543640137,
1.2503567934036255,
0.6050894260406494,
-0.2801132798194885,
-0.49330583214759827,
-0.6496787667274475,
0.19966192543506622,
-0.4399043023586273,
-0.39513927698135376,
0.3030535876750946,
0.13150836527347565,
-0.10099931806325912,
0.1104527935385704,
-0.12964963912963867,
-0.5685442090034485,
-0.14112326502799988,
0.2444453090429306,
0.04973262920975685,
0.10290834307670593,
0.47982174158096313,
0.07133455574512482,
-0.23511181771755219,
-0.3579232394695282,
-0.3050180971622467,
0.7335206270217896,
0.221259206533432,
0.040646303445100784,
-0.3145449757575989,
0.7720187306404114,
0.38549330830574036,
-0.35519981384277344,
1.1102066040039062,
0.586749792098999,
-0.6841158866882324,
-0.020785678178071976,
-0.8685683012008667,
-0.2805746793746948,
-0.31833142042160034,
0.25422367453575134,
-0.2534036338329315,
-1.2892041206359863,
0.7706775665283203,
-0.2252180129289627,
0.07244140654802322,
0.6233296394348145,
0.17687326669692993,
0.25141873955726624,
0.42990821599960327,
0.962786078453064,
-0.3532290458679199,
0.672395646572113,
0.11077480763196945,
0.15329447388648987,
-0.5602265000343323,
-0.12834137678146362,
-1.06797456741333,
0.021329455077648163,
-0.11209210753440857,
-0.30001381039619446,
0.463196724653244,
0.17137625813484192,
0.051924705505371094,
0.7866863012313843,
-0.3913433253765106,
0.5751110315322876,
0.07734621316194534,
-0.09950994700193405,
0.4169074594974518,
0.13845719397068024,
0.17678476870059967,
-0.059930093586444855,
-1.0039256811141968,
-0.28141602873802185,
0.36335891485214233,
0.05714412406086922,
0.5576303005218506,
0.21238553524017334,
1.0059828758239746,
0.06913425773382187,
0.3194217383861542,
-0.5971837043762207,
0.40285158157348633,
-0.042182642966508865,
-0.2159494012594223,
-0.1840779185295105,
-0.6970133781433105,
-1.3714817762374878,
-0.09311097115278244,
-0.35384300351142883,
-1.2346824407577515,
0.6494572758674622,
0.00162281165830791,
-0.17150723934173584,
0.45765143632888794,
-0.6276655793190002,
0.5009030699729919,
0.41240862011909485,
-0.12488143891096115,
-0.17521901428699493,
-0.6600070595741272,
0.029692774638533592,
-0.30069398880004883,
0.5421592593193054,
0.18984676897525787,
-0.020770197734236717,
1.0049034357070923,
-0.5713270902633667,
0.8326897025108337,
0.2460133135318756,
0.0058016120456159115,
0.45369285345077515,
0.3227322995662689,
0.692252516746521,
-0.09390229731798172,
-0.15095077455043793,
0.11903724819421768,
0.1581176519393921,
-0.29889577627182007,
-0.754175066947937,
0.5229987502098083,
-0.4307878613471985,
-0.1495891660451889,
-0.22960805892944336,
-0.25693514943122864,
-0.02687203511595726,
0.19542622566223145,
0.445095956325531,
0.8610954880714417,
-0.4119873344898224,
-0.42767804861068726,
0.40656864643096924,
-0.009039122611284256,
0.7927480936050415,
0.3814687430858612,
-0.27234914898872375,
-0.5171491503715515,
0.665097713470459,
-0.034874532371759415,
0.0837622880935669,
0.7087399959564209,
0.11691726744174957,
0.014947117306292057,
-0.44714146852493286,
0.1895115226507187,
0.398286908864975,
-0.645861804485321,
-0.4901183247566223,
-0.8220111131668091,
0.05283026397228241,
-0.5064122080802917,
-0.10653168708086014,
-0.5138057470321655,
-0.8040336966514587,
-0.3522004783153534,
-0.11718262732028961,
0.2853267192840576,
0.8948946595191956,
-0.24885086715221405,
0.4704897999763489,
-1.4838567972183228,
0.12194578349590302,
0.014998672530055046,
0.25835004448890686,
0.15889997780323029,
-0.24636133015155792,
-0.37814703583717346,
-0.7157127261161804,
0.007270015310496092,
-1.0527747869491577,
0.42087945342063904,
0.1452365219593048,
0.2818075120449066,
0.36937689781188965,
0.14547787606716156,
0.6786853075027466,
-0.4677671194076538,
0.80996173620224,
0.4546537399291992,
-0.7773553133010864,
0.8222304582595825,
-0.21346013247966766,
0.271068811416626,
0.7036780118942261,
0.21806593239307404,
-0.48626837134361267,
-0.2729004919528961,
-1.139101266860962,
-0.8156983256340027,
0.5671146512031555,
0.48597773909568787,
-0.5452713966369629,
-0.6349033713340759,
0.5438700318336487,
0.05740419775247574,
0.08824805915355682,
-0.7927077412605286,
-0.12890936434268951,
0.57071453332901,
-0.1934063583612442,
0.06806587427854538,
-0.5605109930038452,
0.009625877253711224,
0.11119349300861359,
0.501926839351654,
0.34279170632362366,
0.39048805832862854,
0.4900209605693817,
-0.10024958848953247,
-0.11549188196659088,
0.45694202184677124,
0.21189361810684204,
0.5928114056587219,
-0.20828089118003845,
0.27595657110214233,
0.278749942779541,
-0.4908273220062256,
-0.13427869975566864,
0.27216288447380066,
0.22677485644817352,
0.200093075633049,
0.5254774689674377,
0.2627620995044708,
0.1943669468164444,
-0.36600828170776367,
0.5688822269439697,
-0.3450644314289093,
0.12573079764842987,
-0.16534210741519928,
-0.26260772347450256,
-0.09257476031780243,
0.09715145081281662,
0.1721603274345398,
-0.10888147354125977,
0.11891346424818039,
-0.40274399518966675,
0.18508309125900269,
-0.2406950294971466,
-0.5974307060241699,
-0.3899785280227661,
0.4624653458595276,
0.2479509860277176,
-0.2246885597705841,
0.40137362480163574,
-0.055355943739414215,
-0.4685121774673462,
0.5744785070419312,
0.4543810188770294,
0.8046174049377441,
-0.31137365102767944,
-0.27286601066589355,
0.7738391757011414,
0.35563528537750244,
-0.24128824472427368,
0.08596852421760559,
-0.1732655018568039,
-0.6465962529182434,
-0.8402553200721741,
-0.6099998950958252,
-0.11204824596643448,
-0.2385147213935852,
-0.9437153339385986,
0.4595986604690552,
0.003335192333906889,
-0.3370814025402069,
-0.22706633806228638,
-0.3710883557796478,
-0.3843638300895691,
0.057182785123586655,
-0.0785810574889183,
1.1306571960449219,
-0.7052926421165466,
0.773993194103241,
0.5378315448760986,
-0.3739650845527649,
-0.8648948669433594,
-0.15879523754119873,
-0.22726522386074066,
-0.1708059161901474,
0.43984362483024597,
-0.047201402485370636,
-0.09328734874725342,
0.06785232573747635,
-0.28602081537246704,
-0.4809664487838745,
0.9596070051193237,
0.22049126029014587,
-0.6638832688331604,
-0.021551676094532013,
-0.10893866419792175,
0.32414644956588745,
-0.3596348166465759,
0.10150156170129776,
0.7060139179229736,
0.45771563053131104,
0.015471335500478745,
-1.0060468912124634,
-0.01727227121591568,
0.014448490925133228,
-0.15810900926589966,
1.1890842914581299,
-0.4313100278377533,
0.2686966359615326,
0.1931586116552353,
-0.6726554036140442,
0.006825227756053209,
0.8340594172477722,
-0.09014643728733063,
0.22585302591323853,
0.5640177726745605,
0.7792290449142456,
0.7328407168388367,
-0.11373879015445709,
1.2285687923431396,
-0.09365105628967285,
0.4675893783569336,
1.4833869934082031,
-0.008071955293416977,
0.9116366505622864,
0.5757829546928406,
-0.11934914439916611,
0.3392591178417206,
0.4035601019859314,
0.5106502175331116,
0.2670135200023651,
-0.19849003851413727,
-0.6597236394882202,
-0.20271791517734528,
-0.3002520501613617,
-0.2595674693584442,
0.20628345012664795,
0.43329277634620667,
-0.3014606535434723,
-0.4751616418361664,
-0.26264768838882446,
0.1369561105966568,
0.20843859016895294,
-0.3184441328048706,
0.926748514175415,
0.14990456402301788,
-0.5316030979156494,
0.046571508049964905,
-0.14823457598686218,
0.37473249435424805,
-0.6590375304222107,
0.04031142219901085,
-0.033996231853961945,
-0.3044860363006592,
-0.15785881876945496,
-0.5514478087425232,
0.4832669496536255,
0.12556226551532745,
-0.4208572506904602,
0.21954235434532166,
1.0237051248550415,
-0.4526346027851105,
-0.1673707365989685,
0.5175788402557373,
0.6197724342346191,
0.28011849522590637,
-0.12233585119247437,
-0.07518479228019714,
0.1495407223701477,
-0.043510086834430695,
-0.12899641692638397,
0.4112517833709717,
0.5371682047843933,
0.018514476716518402,
0.2232518196105957,
0.3727189004421234,
0.26510560512542725,
-0.17585833370685577,
0.2746250629425049,
1.0468496084213257,
-0.8027099370956421,
-0.7072131633758545,
-0.9565426707267761,
0.3350886106491089,
-0.3984573781490326,
-0.18747475743293762,
0.12619544565677643,
0.5663830041885376,
0.2542451024055481,
0.14489775896072388,
0.555678129196167,
-0.2539232075214386,
0.5426215529441833,
-0.3922029435634613,
0.35137367248535156,
-0.2513306140899658,
0.17398013174533844,
-0.1385778784751892,
-1.0669516324996948,
-0.688264012336731,
0.18682345747947693,
-0.1465461701154709,
-0.25298240780830383,
1.0481376647949219,
0.6109161972999573,
-0.16609005630016327,
0.15589843690395355,
0.18635326623916626,
0.19377660751342773,
0.42354482412338257,
0.5912996530532837,
0.7412854433059692,
-0.3590441942214966,
0.7245568037033081,
-0.20377525687217712,
-0.35477280616760254,
0.2117684930562973,
-1.3102792501449585,
-0.9453790783882141,
-0.7936629056930542,
-0.48462140560150146,
-0.0724901556968689,
0.04887241870164871,
0.8712390661239624,
0.6932328343391418,
-0.5637791156768799,
-0.12078312039375305,
-0.07018809765577316,
-0.08056270331144333,
-0.10161940008401871,
-0.24254924058914185,
0.6685732007026672,
-0.22671020030975342,
-0.64107745885849,
0.29453372955322266,
0.6210099458694458,
0.19992101192474365,
0.5773088335990906,
0.322811096906662,
-0.3460421860218048,
-0.21493250131607056,
0.7464323043823242,
0.4274377226829529,
-0.16062119603157043,
-0.3983978033065796,
-0.6311725378036499,
0.23368534445762634,
0.35183900594711304,
0.8221520781517029,
-0.750048041343689,
0.2101624310016632,
0.47343888878822327,
0.5660668611526489,
0.8092591166496277,
0.11107795685529709,
0.7938094735145569,
-1.0350892543792725,
0.41053590178489685,
0.19370949268341064,
0.5265107750892639,
0.03788217902183533,
-0.47176510095596313,
0.9866754412651062,
0.06424090266227722,
-0.5945029258728027,
-0.5316842794418335,
0.31035444140434265,
-1.506274700164795,
-0.23529848456382751,
1.0619176626205444,
-0.015969974920153618,
-0.33777958154678345,
-0.12026703357696533,
-0.28204020857810974,
0.5324798822402954,
-0.4997459650039673,
0.6387554407119751,
0.707291305065155,
-0.21476532518863678,
-0.43237119913101196,
-0.18797816336154938,
0.22038735449314117,
0.1713738590478897,
-1.049555778503418,
0.06927425414323807,
0.3283519446849823,
-0.10440999269485474,
0.3267831802368164,
0.5736201405525208,
-0.3856266736984253,
0.27394500374794006,
-0.154363214969635,
0.5586835741996765,
-0.003059377195313573,
-0.25330349802970886,
-0.4671039581298828,
0.45132213830947876,
0.04484353959560394,
0.0527486652135849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06886v1
|
Event GDR: Event-Centric Generative Document Retrieval
| 2024-05-11T02:55:11 | 2024-05-11T02:55:11 |
Yong Guan, Dingxiao Liu, Jinchen Ma, Hao Peng, Xiaozhi Wang, Lei Hou, Ru Li
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Generative document retrieval, an emerging paradigm in information retrieval,
learns to build connections between documents and identifiers within a single
model, garnering significant attention. However, there are still two
challenges: (1) neglecting inner-content correlation during document
representation; (2) lacking explicit semantic structure during identifier
construction. Nonetheless, events have enriched relations and well-defined
taxonomy, which could facilitate addressing the above two challenges. Inspired
by this, we propose Event GDR, an event-centric generative document retrieval
model, integrating event knowledge into this task. Specifically, we utilize an
exchange-then-reflection method based on multi-agents for event knowledge
extraction. For document representation, we employ events and relations to
model the document to guarantee the comprehensiveness and inner-content
correlation. For identifier construction, we map the events to well-defined
event taxonomy to construct the identifiers with explicit semantic structure.
Our method achieves significant improvement over the baselines on two datasets,
and also hopes to provide insights for future research.
|
[
-0.270041823387146,
-0.5969443321228027,
0.8436219692230225,
-0.166250079870224,
-0.3500607907772064,
0.1988305151462555,
-0.06116122007369995,
-0.6116482019424438,
0.4098590314388275,
0.14405348896980286,
-0.4209586977958679,
-0.5057120323181152,
-0.5549784302711487,
-0.2154078632593155,
-0.7482779026031494,
1.000012755393982,
-0.06285519152879715,
-0.10215656459331512,
-0.3579114079475403,
-0.1415051966905594,
0.12531425058841705,
-0.8595731258392334,
-0.7448593378067017,
-0.3915828764438629,
0.4393097460269928,
0.03690051659941673,
0.372353732585907,
0.3871999680995941,
0.7877123355865479,
0.15570802986621857,
-0.0681966245174408,
0.309480220079422,
-0.3897689878940582,
0.2988011837005615,
-0.23935452103614807,
-0.36235830187797546,
-0.40100544691085815,
0.011630747467279434,
0.716743528842926,
0.4270191490650177,
-0.33716464042663574,
-0.16053807735443115,
0.07504752278327942,
0.4412534236907959,
-0.7258169054985046,
0.3603973984718323,
-0.5526307225227356,
0.2156958281993866,
-0.503923237323761,
-0.6647781729698181,
-0.544058084487915,
-0.0697307214140892,
-0.052825748920440674,
-0.833082914352417,
0.967993438243866,
-0.23933564126491547,
0.8221099376678467,
-0.34100809693336487,
-0.4915629029273987,
-0.5489769577980042,
-0.8404603004455566,
0.5510436296463013,
-0.09878028929233551,
0.4651212990283966,
0.3136041760444641,
0.16691908240318298,
-0.16212834417819977,
-1.1111687421798706,
-0.853693962097168,
0.10210815817117691,
-0.14458318054676056,
0.21219652891159058,
-0.04322080686688423,
0.15565770864486694,
0.009455366060137749,
0.38074302673339844,
-0.5148520469665527,
-0.1591377556324005,
-0.18067248165607452,
0.04635178670287132,
0.6961053013801575,
0.340629518032074,
0.4216710329055786,
-0.27612951397895813,
-0.47438502311706543,
-0.2413758933544159,
-0.4408342242240906,
-0.3157966136932373,
0.47319892048835754,
0.49813956022262573,
-0.18449103832244873,
0.565986692905426,
-0.20997783541679382,
0.41120681166648865,
0.0844372808933258,
0.004826804623007774,
0.3593035936355591,
-0.9145311117172241,
0.03897107020020485,
0.016646509990096092,
0.7457635998725891,
0.3460268974304199,
-0.2498551905155182,
-0.5686200857162476,
-0.0883081704378128,
-0.0180681049823761,
0.3119800090789795,
-0.9433603882789612,
-0.026905829086899757,
0.20723187923431396,
-0.7651218771934509,
-0.21393775939941406,
0.2739007771015167,
-0.9010316133499146,
-0.34016525745391846,
-0.46029913425445557,
0.6117397546768188,
-0.4360540509223938,
-0.35526198148727417,
-0.1699422299861908,
-0.6967692971229553,
0.55555260181427,
0.7142745852470398,
-0.8418204188346863,
0.1621081382036209,
0.9289900660514832,
0.9474887251853943,
-0.21018528938293457,
-0.03472733870148659,
-0.81576007604599,
0.41786864399909973,
-0.1277681291103363,
0.6752868890762329,
-0.8554792404174805,
-0.8529792428016663,
0.11373765766620636,
0.018081683665513992,
0.00654198694974184,
-0.27652567625045776,
0.5729357004165649,
-0.9427319169044495,
0.257419228553772,
-0.3089524507522583,
-0.6644319891929626,
0.13943901658058167,
0.20191533863544464,
-0.53676837682724,
0.6460280418395996,
0.09117370843887329,
-0.8121612071990967,
0.5384858250617981,
-0.4582732915878296,
-0.49956297874450684,
0.3991870582103729,
-0.8369439840316772,
-0.20484231412410736,
0.12489093095064163,
-0.0827903226017952,
0.23800873756408691,
-0.3525938093662262,
0.19671288132667542,
-0.13852275907993317,
-0.06247244402766228,
-0.17526738345623016,
-0.05319054797291756,
0.4420081377029419,
0.008425521664321423,
0.0863637700676918,
-0.0808766633272171,
-0.9525622725486755,
-0.16060037910938263,
-0.01151364017277956,
-0.39651891589164734,
-0.48691511154174805,
0.30813077092170715,
0.2774616479873657,
0.15940144658088684,
0.2317783683538437,
-0.6313772797584534,
0.5224968194961548,
0.0379783995449543,
-0.014810501597821712,
0.48918551206588745,
0.40067964792251587,
0.836215078830719,
-0.2166942059993744,
0.41375502943992615,
0.33562496304512024,
0.40495407581329346,
-0.21233147382736206,
-0.5449371933937073,
-0.3952791690826416,
-0.21799245476722717,
-0.0027406432200223207,
0.2362557351589203,
-0.9526532888412476,
0.3195723593235016,
-0.366089791059494,
-0.27444472908973694,
-0.5415002703666687,
0.20059184730052948,
0.2934754490852356,
0.5579095482826233,
0.41114118695259094,
-0.8170571327209473,
-0.6095978617668152,
-0.5347113013267517,
0.2685192823410034,
-0.39349251985549927,
0.056193701922893524,
0.06168138235807419,
0.3019692897796631,
-0.4044620990753174,
0.8956292271614075,
-0.46186336874961853,
-0.966615617275238,
-0.3455786108970642,
0.6725270748138428,
0.059132207185029984,
0.3727160692214966,
0.5642969012260437,
-1.2673910856246948,
-0.5355103611946106,
0.40424206852912903,
-0.7790833115577698,
0.3568804860115051,
0.06683587282896042,
-0.17858392000198364,
0.45805788040161133,
0.5461068153381348,
-0.8810701966285706,
0.5797877311706543,
0.005356252659112215,
-0.3734337389469147,
0.3262607753276825,
-0.3844102919101715,
0.08751827478408813,
-1.0349634885787964,
0.19389474391937256,
-0.25477612018585205,
0.193241149187088,
-0.7384190559387207,
0.2204568088054657,
0.3212863504886627,
0.06817105412483215,
-0.10269411653280258,
0.6757827997207642,
-0.47072815895080566,
-0.06835979223251343,
-0.30513763427734375,
0.36408117413520813,
0.4862568974494934,
0.19686123728752136,
0.24416476488113403,
0.5463674664497375,
0.309609591960907,
-0.5898475050926208,
0.28254398703575134,
0.6061233878135681,
-0.4013473391532898,
0.9067092537879944,
-0.2853317856788635,
0.2908472418785095,
-0.69099360704422,
0.2433188557624817,
-0.6882575750350952,
-0.1603841334581375,
0.27905991673469543,
-0.401567280292511,
0.6213176846504211,
-0.48825153708457947,
-0.7979063987731934,
-0.02090621553361416,
-0.27255770564079285,
0.26450613141059875,
0.1614707112312317,
-0.6720637083053589,
1.1808878183364868,
0.31134331226348877,
-0.2568805515766144,
-0.5320771932601929,
-0.293853759765625,
0.09486261755228043,
0.052850715816020966,
-0.4269779324531555,
0.713291347026825,
-0.04034269228577614,
-0.2748633027076721,
0.4226887822151184,
0.07619249075651169,
0.07041919231414795,
-0.24143196642398834,
0.0976916030049324,
0.31430143117904663,
-0.054854318499565125,
0.4065103232860565,
-0.3505026698112488,
-0.05167822167277336,
-0.16580814123153687,
-0.1343890279531479,
0.5370560884475708,
0.39548537135124207,
-0.5620251297950745,
-0.3854159414768219,
0.7736561894416809,
0.3810373842716217,
-0.5521557331085205,
0.8362983465194702,
0.8248487710952759,
-0.19505883753299713,
-0.1605067104101181,
-0.6380055546760559,
-0.13399112224578857,
-0.39345529675483704,
0.395228773355484,
-0.6291576623916626,
-0.6464263796806335,
0.840155303478241,
0.4700244963169098,
-0.21240688860416412,
0.5274742841720581,
0.31886160373687744,
-0.10087968409061432,
1.0024076700210571,
0.7740442156791687,
-0.18867437541484833,
0.6777092814445496,
-0.41454243659973145,
0.1740017831325531,
-1.313410758972168,
-0.6382265686988831,
-0.730466365814209,
-0.038695499300956726,
-0.13789048790931702,
-0.792366087436676,
0.28718018531799316,
0.08680509030818939,
0.039752256125211716,
0.005593887530267239,
-0.30397316813468933,
0.07939055562019348,
0.5764992237091064,
-0.0036468536127358675,
0.6170682907104492,
-0.15747860074043274,
0.04084666073322296,
0.08110184222459793,
-0.39480340480804443,
-0.12704184651374817,
1.1886042356491089,
-0.241636261343956,
0.8178192973136902,
0.26274019479751587,
0.8638865351676941,
0.3215671479701996,
0.46608027815818787,
-0.4735836982727051,
0.3069896697998047,
-0.17481745779514313,
-0.6223745346069336,
-0.11173763871192932,
-0.5073862671852112,
-0.8720680475234985,
0.5141355395317078,
0.0609288364648819,
-0.9196615219116211,
0.8620104789733887,
-0.4742794334888458,
-0.030574388802051544,
0.1906648725271225,
-0.564379096031189,
0.631252646446228,
0.035006407648324966,
-0.1745050996541977,
-0.3670703172683716,
-0.6398696303367615,
0.07540880143642426,
-0.1248759776353836,
0.408801794052124,
0.05027252063155174,
0.010526629164814949,
0.5995946526527405,
-0.0668598860502243,
0.56201171875,
-0.15713323652744293,
0.08953022211790085,
0.33543336391448975,
0.042484987527132034,
0.7859383225440979,
0.1423034369945526,
-0.3805427551269531,
-0.4086552858352661,
-0.051012590527534485,
-0.011730767786502838,
-0.7698777318000793,
0.46885281801223755,
-0.9109153747558594,
-0.4994713366031647,
-0.22008173167705536,
-0.1327192187309265,
0.17349450290203094,
-0.013857409358024597,
0.24519644677639008,
0.9110939502716064,
-0.521673321723938,
0.09974975138902664,
0.5706756711006165,
0.13161936402320862,
0.5170027613639832,
0.9265779256820679,
-0.27639806270599365,
-0.4307910203933716,
0.871782124042511,
0.12873169779777527,
0.2109462320804596,
0.8119451999664307,
-0.3174181580543518,
-0.3218337893486023,
-0.39068955183029175,
-0.27847978472709656,
0.09258236736059189,
-1.1191449165344238,
-0.3395252823829651,
-1.1661615371704102,
-0.38439086079597473,
-0.4304499328136444,
-0.09596104919910431,
-0.16030670702457428,
-0.2982814908027649,
-0.6695598363876343,
-0.2808838188648224,
0.057908233255147934,
0.5860567092895508,
-0.3493303656578064,
0.12013237923383713,
-0.7943776249885559,
0.6049188375473022,
0.19863484799861908,
0.2803630530834198,
0.3288911283016205,
-0.321236789226532,
-0.230258047580719,
-0.4389362633228302,
-0.5620807409286499,
-0.7570331692695618,
0.28605416417121887,
0.5979092121124268,
0.8278217911720276,
0.6823986172676086,
0.2898959219455719,
0.37504976987838745,
-0.2935743033885956,
0.5640191435813904,
0.15605145692825317,
-0.6995261907577515,
0.8611900806427002,
-0.11756454408168793,
-0.14388176798820496,
0.4576681852340698,
0.3838537335395813,
-0.6621378660202026,
-0.44695934653282166,
-0.9845680594444275,
-1.0960391759872437,
0.9302660226821899,
0.11456061154603958,
0.056211236864328384,
-0.27136537432670593,
0.30504927039146423,
0.17179682850837708,
0.2430000603199005,
-0.3627403974533081,
-0.08114990592002869,
0.14955882728099823,
-0.060888439416885376,
-0.29978489875793457,
-0.45708325505256653,
-0.390016108751297,
0.04887071251869202,
0.5719709992408752,
-0.236289381980896,
0.3861968517303467,
0.5581682920455933,
-0.043589022010564804,
-0.2980562150478363,
0.267243891954422,
0.1801932007074356,
0.6125563979148865,
-0.5818657875061035,
0.25896456837654114,
-0.3909665048122406,
-0.4240380525588989,
0.19172371923923492,
0.5611690878868103,
-0.2960156798362732,
0.16927748918533325,
0.5284707546234131,
0.6226347088813782,
-0.052294254302978516,
-0.29589301347732544,
0.7088727951049805,
-0.3555164039134979,
-0.08123532682657242,
-0.2382562756538391,
-0.05233334004878998,
-0.20110861957073212,
0.4198736846446991,
0.8545819520950317,
-0.405331552028656,
0.3400121331214905,
-0.8182955980300903,
0.4548228681087494,
0.7216597199440002,
-0.4367145001888275,
-0.496170312166214,
0.7663580775260925,
0.3057996928691864,
-0.14306966960430145,
0.8174371123313904,
-0.5902329087257385,
-0.36528998613357544,
0.7306879162788391,
0.3796111047267914,
0.8842057585716248,
0.07402590662240982,
0.5088967680931091,
0.246970534324646,
0.1618024855852127,
0.102239228785038,
0.4217737317085266,
-0.35565808415412903,
-0.9433333277702332,
-0.2439776360988617,
-0.9234722852706909,
-0.5440833568572998,
-0.06710599362850189,
-0.800039529800415,
0.14181537926197052,
0.0662449449300766,
-0.1737639605998993,
0.10535896569490433,
0.3483774960041046,
-0.8392212986946106,
-0.09015265107154846,
0.08589834719896317,
0.8707705140113831,
-0.5070466995239258,
0.9608960151672363,
0.6798747777938843,
-0.7907692193984985,
-0.25901445746421814,
-0.07546815276145935,
-0.06810461729764938,
-0.316010445356369,
0.6988555788993835,
-0.09660125523805618,
0.4050791561603546,
0.0070886267349123955,
-0.02250559628009796,
-0.8557332158088684,
1.1652065515518188,
-0.07430581003427505,
-0.3489682674407959,
-0.23350727558135986,
0.11933749169111252,
0.626157820224762,
-0.44697487354278564,
0.30564531683921814,
0.16813167929649353,
0.36493679881095886,
0.43741580843925476,
-0.6452262997627258,
-0.043944984674453735,
-0.25473523139953613,
0.1633138507604599,
0.3720003664493561,
-0.5136186480522156,
0.7983223795890808,
-0.19165199995040894,
-0.7283069491386414,
0.1041564792394638,
0.7842242121696472,
-0.12906469404697418,
0.46873146295547485,
0.056235749274492264,
0.773577868938446,
0.824996292591095,
-0.03465854376554489,
1.2670410871505737,
-0.22746209800243378,
0.39551427960395813,
1.1430768966674805,
-0.5460323691368103,
0.7135408520698547,
0.4488179385662079,
-0.12494625151157379,
0.2647378742694855,
0.05225902795791626,
0.2049802839756012,
1.0370557308197021,
-0.2404477447271347,
-0.7981851100921631,
-0.19882573187351227,
-0.3836750090122223,
-0.6495597958564758,
0.15754534304141998,
0.544033408164978,
-0.34041592478752136,
-0.5862618088722229,
0.13549448549747467,
-0.2753686010837555,
-0.18005065619945526,
-0.11679630726575851,
1.0229119062423706,
0.13769955933094025,
-0.2885091304779053,
-0.3474879562854767,
0.05271352455019951,
0.2716812193393707,
-0.7765076756477356,
0.06356510519981384,
-0.38402092456817627,
0.4247004985809326,
0.0540938675403595,
-0.8042462468147278,
0.23929020762443542,
-0.5252557992935181,
-0.49115487933158875,
-0.09749874472618103,
0.7976822257041931,
-0.5870537757873535,
-0.1401258409023285,
0.7289595603942871,
0.4815753400325775,
-0.33746999502182007,
0.0014571408974006772,
-0.0762641504406929,
0.4141397178173065,
-0.3687817454338074,
-0.25098082423210144,
0.7202070951461792,
0.8435357809066772,
0.08429858833551407,
0.41632258892059326,
0.6203848123550415,
0.058588989078998566,
-0.18009968101978302,
0.43027806282043457,
0.92624431848526,
-0.49647775292396545,
-0.4806574881076813,
-0.6420773267745972,
0.3804346024990082,
-0.2198774367570877,
-0.12233778834342957,
0.32643747329711914,
0.7689231038093567,
0.8233615159988403,
0.04467321187257767,
0.9786037802696228,
-0.3355620503425598,
0.2286531925201416,
-0.22731806337833405,
0.6476811170578003,
-0.6231035590171814,
-0.1897636502981186,
-0.16789068281650543,
-0.645544707775116,
-0.17538468539714813,
0.2099933624267578,
0.07313308119773865,
-0.28486573696136475,
0.4287218451499939,
0.7771332859992981,
-0.018260717391967773,
0.06006097048521042,
0.09646859019994736,
-0.050953105092048645,
0.8207691311836243,
0.26743215322494507,
0.948203980922699,
-0.5006606578826904,
0.399567186832428,
-0.15026123821735382,
-0.16740109026432037,
-0.569961428642273,
-0.6721638441085815,
-0.6013108491897583,
-1.317550778388977,
-0.4140147864818573,
-0.1655038744211197,
0.38909825682640076,
0.7220032811164856,
0.4206730127334595,
-0.5594565272331238,
0.045538678765296936,
0.10019536316394806,
0.24765682220458984,
0.084294892847538,
-0.2927788197994232,
0.5839817523956299,
-0.8169872164726257,
-0.6121478080749512,
0.2487248182296753,
0.4217033088207245,
0.17032238841056824,
0.12599103152751923,
0.016255317255854607,
-0.14016024768352509,
-0.1859218180179596,
0.6897889971733093,
0.2594480812549591,
-0.23026075959205627,
-0.4920915365219116,
-0.38714754581451416,
-0.4302769899368286,
0.06780245155096054,
0.6086104512214661,
-0.6721905469894409,
0.584033191204071,
0.4863758683204651,
0.5127021670341492,
0.8057754635810852,
0.03276057541370392,
0.6251007914543152,
-0.9273063540458679,
0.1464185118675232,
0.10249917209148407,
0.18457262217998505,
0.2417023479938507,
-0.4781012237071991,
0.7184836268424988,
0.4553365409374237,
-0.4258378744125366,
-0.7858052849769592,
0.11502619832754135,
-1.1701847314834595,
0.06012320518493652,
1.017634391784668,
0.12488410621881485,
0.08557678759098053,
-0.14099690318107605,
-0.030348600819706917,
0.20752419531345367,
-0.26908284425735474,
0.8927765488624573,
0.5800722241401672,
-0.1295759081840515,
-0.20177729427814484,
-0.38202106952667236,
0.588949978351593,
-0.29065844416618347,
-0.6522766351699829,
-0.12000864744186401,
0.28838828206062317,
-0.15819613635540009,
0.5209171772003174,
1.242296576499939,
-0.3157888352870941,
0.20879395306110382,
-0.03291283920407295,
0.47627153992652893,
0.2990078628063202,
-0.5959081649780273,
0.1102467030286789,
0.4807202219963074,
0.0019775081891566515,
-0.16540642082691193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12999v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12999v1
|
An Assessment of Model-On-Model Deception
| 2024-05-10T23:24:18 | 2024-05-10T23:24:18 |
Julius Heitkoetter, Michael Gerovitch, Laker Newhouse
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The trustworthiness of highly capable language models is put at risk when
they are able to produce deceptive outputs. Moreover, when models are
vulnerable to deception it undermines reliability. In this paper, we introduce
a method to investigate complex, model-on-model deceptive scenarios. We create
a dataset of over 10,000 misleading explanations by asking Llama-2 7B, 13B,
70B, and GPT-3.5 to justify the wrong answer for questions in the MMLU. We find
that, when models read these explanations, they are all significantly deceived.
Worryingly, models of all capabilities are successful at misleading others,
while more capable models are only slightly better at resisting deception. We
recommend the development of techniques to detect and defend against deception.
|
[
-0.22129549086093903,
-0.9287644624710083,
0.8344622254371643,
0.03766990825533867,
0.003806490683928132,
0.1547466218471527,
0.44852831959724426,
-0.5273492336273193,
-0.25671783089637756,
0.591711163520813,
-0.5563701391220093,
0.20833076536655426,
-0.7169792056083679,
0.05862222611904144,
-0.4680613875389099,
0.6971733570098877,
-0.01578252762556076,
0.07866228371858597,
-0.37376415729522705,
0.12505631148815155,
-0.46492958068847656,
-0.6696701645851135,
-0.45219501852989197,
-0.4062251150608063,
0.38828256726264954,
0.10645714402198792,
0.8873199820518494,
0.40333253145217896,
0.5089700222015381,
0.2464303821325302,
0.08047759532928467,
0.21031084656715393,
-0.5644689798355103,
0.14543604850769043,
-0.1264336109161377,
-0.9364715814590454,
-0.4734918773174286,
0.5189872980117798,
0.19601598381996155,
0.42241567373275757,
-0.203261598944664,
0.35676923394203186,
-0.267255961894989,
0.15149061381816864,
-0.6389672160148621,
0.042320799082517624,
-0.9355447292327881,
-0.2246590107679367,
-0.21851223707199097,
-0.06961874663829803,
-0.9267585277557373,
-0.2737252414226532,
0.02826833538711071,
-0.4728268086910248,
0.01657099276781082,
0.18648572266101837,
1.0329560041427612,
0.3174895942211151,
-0.48317092657089233,
-0.2612009048461914,
-1.0205596685409546,
0.8287700414657593,
-0.8285834789276123,
0.08391641825437546,
0.6362311244010925,
0.6984959244728088,
-0.09015237540006638,
-0.697681725025177,
-0.6565091609954834,
-0.6071001887321472,
-0.16517898440361023,
0.10983709245920181,
-0.4625854194164276,
-0.20375701785087585,
0.5365141034126282,
0.10016502439975739,
-0.5427318811416626,
0.08667398989200592,
-0.2784828841686249,
-0.5296817421913147,
0.6789107918739319,
0.08358816802501678,
0.38024473190307617,
0.029836757108569145,
-0.3591685891151428,
-0.19157083332538605,
-1.0325781106948853,
-0.2090834230184555,
0.8810866475105286,
-0.12404509633779526,
-0.07149610668420792,
0.7129765748977661,
-0.01053260825574398,
0.6656990051269531,
0.14179690182209015,
-0.24630939960479736,
-0.1377967745065689,
-0.2517662048339844,
-0.4647011458873749,
0.18087463080883026,
0.4113997220993042,
0.3025680184364319,
0.24467791616916656,
0.024482041597366333,
-0.40247684717178345,
0.5982957482337952,
0.3719038665294647,
-0.615888237953186,
0.08927731961011887,
0.39661478996276855,
-0.47801119089126587,
-0.8761333227157593,
-0.06567712128162384,
-0.5377317070960999,
-0.5566172003746033,
0.10120072960853577,
0.6995397210121155,
-0.27283960580825806,
-0.31268298625946045,
0.1416153758764267,
-0.011409827508032322,
0.29337814450263977,
0.203689306974411,
-0.5719253420829773,
0.060821086168289185,
0.6576350331306458,
0.3362938165664673,
0.3178139328956604,
-0.11866124719381332,
-0.44770291447639465,
0.15900985896587372,
-0.5273267030715942,
0.5965597629547119,
-0.6193773150444031,
-0.13914844393730164,
-0.12195364385843277,
-0.03585319593548775,
-0.01398061215877533,
-0.3078415095806122,
0.8140037655830383,
-0.43294453620910645,
0.47162529826164246,
-0.37212055921554565,
-0.4651166796684265,
-0.604536771774292,
0.5683891177177429,
-0.8021640181541443,
0.7327137589454651,
0.056209370493888855,
-0.9382219910621643,
0.06720495223999023,
-0.46130988001823425,
-0.02728310041129589,
-0.40643051266670227,
-0.20628145337104797,
-0.36199164390563965,
0.28442391753196716,
0.25581425428390503,
0.5338009595870972,
-0.40623384714126587,
0.36708900332450867,
-0.39811187982559204,
-0.26401329040527344,
0.8382335305213928,
-1.1429972648620605,
0.9756994247436523,
0.27683237195014954,
-0.3243953287601471,
-0.1463325023651123,
-0.8431069254875183,
-0.16206786036491394,
0.46629640460014343,
-0.12328309565782547,
-0.37314140796661377,
-0.2793801426887512,
-0.41109877824783325,
0.08141504228115082,
0.28018835186958313,
-0.5751022696495056,
-0.00189513701479882,
-0.3568294644355774,
0.35058125853538513,
0.614966630935669,
-0.15754777193069458,
-0.05973460525274277,
-0.7102765440940857,
0.7576141357421875,
0.19239184260368347,
0.41303718090057373,
-0.15269017219543457,
-0.7880606651306152,
-0.6727094054222107,
0.22679615020751953,
0.3850075304508209,
0.42375117540359497,
-0.780068576335907,
-0.18532884120941162,
-0.18979819118976593,
-0.7227165102958679,
-0.9073371887207031,
-0.34047186374664307,
0.6891189217567444,
0.5298070907592773,
-0.01683681830763817,
-0.06210435926914215,
-0.24616645276546478,
-1.1520994901657104,
-0.32439112663269043,
-0.4152681529521942,
-0.04034576565027237,
0.1209660992026329,
0.5998756289482117,
-0.06484919786453247,
0.6061373949050903,
-0.14405474066734314,
0.1612575501203537,
0.021134253591299057,
0.17854337394237518,
-0.1527240127325058,
0.3612744212150574,
0.7520317435264587,
-1.04984712600708,
-0.13872087001800537,
-0.125174880027771,
-0.6533772349357605,
-0.015616015531122684,
-0.4139014780521393,
0.1303463727235794,
0.28147146105766296,
0.2008785456418991,
-0.7750706076622009,
0.2844255566596985,
0.9636795520782471,
-0.6085165143013,
0.9053789377212524,
-0.13119013607501984,
0.16004657745361328,
-0.6943822503089905,
0.07615639269351959,
-0.20554155111312866,
-0.14945088326931,
-0.8874420523643494,
0.4107927978038788,
-0.10566897690296173,
0.2144792377948761,
-0.5015208721160889,
0.090725377202034,
-0.35632479190826416,
0.040284041315317154,
-0.026991967111825943,
-0.005114390980452299,
0.2613525986671448,
0.11762908101081848,
-0.517396867275238,
0.49345603585243225,
0.5774868726730347,
-0.3227766454219818,
0.4552038908004761,
0.15808990597724915,
-0.4053150713443756,
0.6209657788276672,
-0.5608692765235901,
0.32277700304985046,
-0.20032139122486115,
0.19905894994735718,
-1.2319653034210205,
-0.38572314381599426,
0.4472784399986267,
-0.6345331072807312,
0.27116820216178894,
-0.08643777668476105,
-0.4387442171573639,
-0.2500293254852295,
-0.019889041781425476,
0.24653810262680054,
0.321079820394516,
-0.5556817650794983,
0.9925323128700256,
0.006083867512643337,
0.35338979959487915,
-0.832476794719696,
-1.0766226053237915,
-0.11460965871810913,
-0.517626166343689,
-0.7714340686798096,
0.14816075563430786,
-0.10471613705158234,
-0.6909310817718506,
-0.11912959069013596,
-0.18637849390506744,
-0.13564756512641907,
0.5098203420639038,
0.503026008605957,
0.2197536826133728,
-0.27810999751091003,
-0.19387659430503845,
-0.1054004654288292,
-0.04385802149772644,
0.36685407161712646,
0.3162688612937927,
0.5533550977706909,
-0.15489327907562256,
-0.7499017715454102,
-0.4380386173725128,
0.04673467203974724,
0.8082384467124939,
-0.12018264085054398,
0.7850126624107361,
0.4741767644882202,
-0.4560365676879883,
0.033647675067186356,
-0.7220953106880188,
-0.249201238155365,
-0.5067398548126221,
0.057911623269319534,
-0.6742688417434692,
-0.5621269941329956,
0.6526402831077576,
0.0637018084526062,
0.06856074184179306,
0.43285003304481506,
0.5988529324531555,
0.13191254436969757,
1.3040950298309326,
0.5221090316772461,
0.07311400026082993,
-0.2764936685562134,
-0.13028772175312042,
0.3165290653705597,
-0.3113792836666107,
-0.5671343207359314,
-0.4961906969547272,
-0.014820593409240246,
-0.5120578408241272,
-0.4865475594997406,
-0.09159441292285919,
0.0544569231569767,
-0.10559654980897903,
0.34795767068862915,
-0.4278648793697357,
0.5437445640563965,
0.3535694181919098,
-0.013584022410213947,
0.6421045660972595,
-0.11316496878862381,
0.07757294923067093,
0.02841714583337307,
-0.43048006296157837,
-0.8075764179229736,
1.1381311416625977,
0.8266066312789917,
0.7912740707397461,
0.44859522581100464,
0.07977693527936935,
0.20521320402622223,
0.5897367596626282,
-0.6508054733276367,
0.46054500341415405,
0.18991363048553467,
-0.9840172529220581,
-0.19666771590709686,
-0.3645627796649933,
-0.5498675107955933,
0.31872856616973877,
-0.13285458087921143,
-0.6082819700241089,
0.12482129037380219,
0.11663643270730972,
-0.44668516516685486,
0.2251112163066864,
-0.7073639035224915,
0.6011133193969727,
-0.5269186496734619,
0.1288287490606308,
-0.26703786849975586,
-0.49123281240463257,
1.0226480960845947,
-0.4510585069656372,
0.21767622232437134,
-0.1720726639032364,
0.11660667508840561,
0.5714071393013,
-0.017696239054203033,
1.0164297819137573,
-0.06320883333683014,
-0.38571545481681824,
0.22004905343055725,
0.6811484098434448,
0.5048023462295532,
-0.22437502443790436,
-0.3312697112560272,
0.08174269646406174,
0.16637779772281647,
-0.33642640709877014,
-0.7141738533973694,
0.5114729404449463,
-0.5903264284133911,
-0.9021927714347839,
-0.28800535202026367,
-0.518204927444458,
-0.34955286979675293,
-0.04096416011452675,
0.27939093112945557,
0.3413771688938141,
-0.3465828597545624,
-0.11734816431999207,
0.5754150152206421,
-0.2326844483613968,
0.2463609278202057,
0.5331900119781494,
-0.4036438763141632,
0.1038999930024147,
0.8521042466163635,
0.003167090006172657,
0.8033734560012817,
0.08800751715898514,
0.385375052690506,
-0.18994103372097015,
-0.5408933162689209,
-0.333302766084671,
0.2533862590789795,
-0.7717651724815369,
-0.06849560886621475,
-0.1435149610042572,
-0.07184362411499023,
-0.23902525007724762,
0.13836215436458588,
-0.39924487471580505,
-0.5184116959571838,
-0.18819262087345123,
-0.31179025769233704,
0.034858107566833496,
0.9126144051551819,
0.3158126175403595,
0.5832760334014893,
-0.531374990940094,
-0.007838372141122818,
0.3639078736305237,
-0.09814457595348358,
0.05468049645423889,
-0.8127102255821228,
0.21969109773635864,
0.3178655207157135,
-0.4332486093044281,
-1.0780962705612183,
0.2937573790550232,
-0.08147964626550674,
0.7944973111152649,
0.951087474822998,
0.07477578520774841,
0.3621228039264679,
-0.13641533255577087,
0.8128507733345032,
0.12824077904224396,
-0.9711928367614746,
0.3701547086238861,
-0.2665131390094757,
-0.23897962272167206,
0.10707125812768936,
0.8973100185394287,
-0.2239805907011032,
-0.5583502054214478,
-1.0281803607940674,
-0.08016353100538254,
0.3586384356021881,
0.2547842860221863,
0.1803451031446457,
0.36390459537506104,
0.4173702597618103,
0.20639221370220184,
0.12802818417549133,
-0.9901246428489685,
-0.43649110198020935,
-0.12608645856380463,
0.09726560115814209,
0.1756030023097992,
-0.654106080532074,
-0.6504783630371094,
0.14419998228549957,
0.6263629198074341,
-0.20665134489536285,
0.20092692971229553,
0.06710954010486603,
-0.15256991982460022,
-0.2933898866176605,
0.17478539049625397,
0.7750874757766724,
1.0446199178695679,
0.04696887731552124,
0.42361268401145935,
0.04412467032670975,
-0.259632408618927,
0.2500338852405548,
-0.05122530460357666,
-0.25157850980758667,
-0.07066696882247925,
0.6551839113235474,
0.7665069699287415,
-0.19090966880321503,
-0.7405968308448792,
0.6447221636772156,
-0.0342816598713398,
-0.32996365427970886,
-0.1379610002040863,
-0.08444173634052277,
0.23539267480373383,
0.24913087487220764,
0.12451814115047455,
0.16059651970863342,
-0.042732011526823044,
-0.8218935132026672,
0.029881739988923073,
0.4428594410419464,
-0.30652397871017456,
-0.4451032876968384,
0.6050147414207458,
-0.15885275602340698,
-0.17472036182880402,
0.4430217146873474,
-0.11009741574525833,
-0.7769073247909546,
0.7307687997817993,
0.7120126485824585,
0.3219147026538849,
-0.7024510502815247,
0.6236003041267395,
0.005952250678092241,
0.8067759275436401,
-0.2912967801094055,
0.2695383131504059,
0.5714846849441528,
-0.9487096071243286,
-0.5109408497810364,
-0.3170487582683563,
-0.49260783195495605,
0.5064987540245056,
-0.5062782168388367,
-0.037081606686115265,
-0.45482394099235535,
-0.16571003198623657,
0.17748910188674927,
-0.1819048374891281,
-0.32866501808166504,
0.11888345330953598,
0.31005606055259705,
0.8684353232383728,
-1.084503412246704,
0.7911670804023743,
0.18158209323883057,
-0.5769630074501038,
-0.9492143988609314,
0.04290859401226044,
0.15500976145267487,
-1.0741949081420898,
0.7130958437919617,
0.19901221990585327,
-0.07887408882379532,
-0.2633153796195984,
-0.7972521185874939,
-0.7376748919487,
0.9208535552024841,
0.7735710144042969,
-0.6153126358985901,
-0.019688578322529793,
0.5222495198249817,
0.4904179573059082,
-0.42685019969940186,
0.3515445291996002,
0.8538103699684143,
0.8014307022094727,
0.017167039215564728,
-1.1184055805206299,
0.502608597278595,
0.33324941992759705,
-0.12170448899269104,
-0.33450138568878174,
-0.5394140481948853,
0.9677102565765381,
-0.39996254444122314,
-0.26283109188079834,
0.24785734713077545,
0.3654199242591858,
0.2062978744506836,
0.3148484230041504,
0.6500747203826904,
0.566318929195404,
0.9415754079818726,
-0.18107473850250244,
1.1121230125427246,
0.17581944167613983,
0.3063421845436096,
0.8578671216964722,
-0.04515708610415459,
0.7655555009841919,
0.3698389232158661,
-0.024674342945218086,
0.40498486161231995,
0.5724844932556152,
-0.44319096207618713,
0.4896102845668793,
0.34140488505363464,
-0.01761995628476143,
-0.628128707408905,
-0.19023990631103516,
-0.08850237727165222,
0.7578880190849304,
0.5264797806739807,
-0.4118548035621643,
-0.19532012939453125,
0.1852259337902069,
0.21276497840881348,
0.02907281182706356,
-0.14132989943027496,
0.10033133625984192,
0.2245279997587204,
-0.4863344132900238,
0.6366676688194275,
0.12213944643735886,
0.4678534269332886,
-0.3007446229457855,
-0.0883331447839737,
-0.12213300168514252,
0.22361913323402405,
-0.15493160486221313,
-0.5391378402709961,
0.33003219962120056,
-0.21770885586738586,
0.12567397952079773,
-0.006835041102021933,
0.8153882622718811,
-0.28532761335372925,
-0.611515998840332,
0.2108718901872635,
0.7784332036972046,
0.17770245671272278,
-0.26357993483543396,
-0.9165292382240295,
0.27654147148132324,
0.11723926663398743,
-0.30199867486953735,
0.24514906108379364,
0.2967959940433502,
-0.17517930269241333,
1.2453057765960693,
0.5532414317131042,
-0.1470378339290619,
-0.005527064204216003,
-0.07882944494485855,
0.4996151328086853,
-0.20427998900413513,
-0.1422663927078247,
-0.9573975205421448,
0.36413949728012085,
0.09175366908311844,
0.016500137746334076,
1.019708514213562,
0.2920491099357605,
0.771796703338623,
0.04959135502576828,
0.681584894657135,
0.13564343750476837,
0.3905940055847168,
-0.5146159529685974,
0.9446663856506348,
-0.5049050450325012,
0.4716394543647766,
0.012524428777396679,
-0.7392041683197021,
-0.11311297863721848,
0.45660582184791565,
-0.25853201746940613,
-0.11518173664808273,
0.6337779760360718,
0.8847514986991882,
-0.20914849638938904,
0.21735166013240814,
0.7495412826538086,
0.7527756690979004,
0.4811067283153534,
0.3754864037036896,
1.21820867061615,
-0.5848250985145569,
0.7744305729866028,
-0.2030104696750641,
-0.038654059171676636,
-0.2224052995443344,
-0.9570770859718323,
-0.9691372513771057,
-0.5412891507148743,
-0.3842924237251282,
-0.6602632999420166,
-0.06827384978532791,
0.15504442155361176,
0.4383184015750885,
-0.6619527339935303,
0.03712095692753792,
0.3453652560710907,
0.15779954195022583,
-0.21584175527095795,
-0.15372112393379211,
0.2234288901090622,
0.36504217982292175,
-0.6486868858337402,
0.5658178925514221,
-0.2805185914039612,
0.37657758593559265,
-0.905813455581665,
0.16997498273849487,
0.09185756742954254,
0.47434282302856445,
0.37504443526268005,
-0.09096059948205948,
-1.09364914894104,
-0.6251425743103027,
-0.1138521283864975,
-0.031676337122917175,
-0.18925969302654266,
0.5950217247009277,
-0.5237306356430054,
0.2181422859430313,
0.22599181532859802,
0.5824210047721863,
0.12763957679271698,
0.09653070569038391,
0.7941874265670776,
-0.4516344666481018,
-0.11498693376779556,
0.23708026111125946,
0.301383376121521,
0.4787428677082062,
-0.5919688940048218,
0.43914559483528137,
0.1968398541212082,
-0.4230472445487976,
-1.1334989070892334,
0.2930218577384949,
-1.1041427850723267,
-0.45805540680885315,
1.0283656120300293,
-0.38925880193710327,
-0.0821061059832573,
-0.1589328497648239,
-0.033405352383852005,
0.017167741432785988,
-0.004108255263417959,
0.9805299639701843,
1.032680630683899,
0.0477200448513031,
0.05424166098237038,
-0.917935311794281,
0.5173187851905823,
0.3803713619709015,
-0.7271393537521362,
0.2678571045398712,
0.3911272883415222,
0.4933820068836212,
0.5215958952903748,
0.18894773721694946,
-0.0971144512295723,
0.2073882520198822,
0.372825026512146,
-0.5182294249534607,
-0.38310202956199646,
-0.3379840850830078,
-0.3303506672382355,
0.15373502671718597,
0.10302536934614182,
-0.031172920018434525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06818v1
|
The Ghanaian NLP Landscape: A First Look
| 2024-05-10T21:39:09 | 2024-05-10T21:39:09 |
Sheriff Issaka, Zhaoyi Zhang, Mihir Heda, Keyi Wang, Yinka Ajibola, Ryan DeMar, Xuefeng Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite comprising one-third of global languages, African languages are
critically underrepresented in Artificial Intelligence (AI), threatening
linguistic diversity and cultural heritage. Ghanaian languages, in particular,
face an alarming decline, with documented extinction and several at risk. This
study pioneers a comprehensive survey of Natural Language Processing (NLP)
research focused on Ghanaian languages, identifying methodologies, datasets,
and techniques employed. Additionally, we create a detailed roadmap outlining
challenges, best practices, and future directions, aiming to improve
accessibility for researchers. This work serves as a foundational resource for
Ghanaian NLP research and underscores the critical need for integrating global
linguistic diversity into AI development.
|
[
-0.7864691615104675,
-0.8053548336029053,
0.17468728125095367,
0.1294202208518982,
-0.10323048382997513,
0.3247130215167999,
-0.31768491864204407,
-0.860238254070282,
0.297256737947464,
0.4336010813713074,
-0.8329821825027466,
-0.5827391743659973,
-0.9051675200462341,
0.26431789994239807,
-0.5778452157974243,
0.8482418656349182,
0.14152763783931732,
-0.50030916929245,
0.04259845241904259,
-0.50206059217453,
-0.29918745160102844,
-0.5920774936676025,
-0.7222703695297241,
-0.38432949781417847,
0.5237606763839722,
0.2680995762348175,
0.9959134459495544,
0.37885865569114685,
0.16946832835674286,
0.2733214497566223,
-0.11564801633358002,
0.5307477116584778,
-0.3258371949195862,
-0.1810341626405716,
0.08917488902807236,
-0.18589015305042267,
-0.11098654568195343,
0.07466735690832138,
0.4168044626712799,
0.8994697332382202,
-0.1742561012506485,
0.2881821393966675,
0.06259863823652267,
0.7612971067428589,
-0.6077325344085693,
0.27138176560401917,
-0.6517629027366638,
0.04146644100546837,
-0.6827440857887268,
-0.07251650094985962,
0.09441020339727402,
-0.3271767795085907,
0.11830006539821625,
-0.6075899004936218,
0.05141172185540199,
-0.2885468900203705,
0.45181411504745483,
0.19203321635723114,
-0.310491144657135,
-0.2813998758792877,
-0.5383049845695496,
0.6990256905555725,
-0.764413058757782,
-0.060800351202487946,
0.8117396831512451,
0.3400869071483612,
-0.18703226745128632,
-0.8169966340065002,
-0.5758903622627258,
0.04446606710553169,
-0.1498991847038269,
-0.2435409277677536,
-0.3588660657405853,
-0.1313791275024414,
-0.03280150517821312,
0.41272205114364624,
-0.4682757556438446,
0.39110273122787476,
-0.3601466715335846,
-0.25659868121147156,
0.8168280720710754,
0.012991707772016525,
0.7722458839416504,
0.0228925421833992,
0.38680440187454224,
0.43737009167671204,
-0.48461657762527466,
-0.1736064851284027,
0.39591139554977417,
0.6911554932594299,
-0.06194761395454407,
0.37308645248413086,
-0.34036946296691895,
0.8015995621681213,
-0.6505499482154846,
-0.08065523952245712,
0.31826043128967285,
-0.25431206822395325,
-0.039635296911001205,
0.1555805653333664,
0.8957620859146118,
-0.04027704894542694,
0.3981308341026306,
-0.17386099696159363,
0.03750542923808098,
0.4524560868740082,
0.37547290325164795,
-0.12722039222717285,
-0.05426447466015816,
0.13492895662784576,
-0.3071107864379883,
0.05785159021615982,
-0.32836398482322693,
-0.47157129645347595,
-0.44640639424324036,
-0.021902138367295265,
-0.07251078635454178,
-0.47314974665641785,
-0.17538893222808838,
-0.14311201870441437,
0.10053665935993195,
0.33797478675842285,
0.10949292778968811,
-1.2767071723937988,
0.4902656078338623,
0.9232526421546936,
1.0319992303848267,
-0.1123843789100647,
-0.4155111312866211,
0.00850434135645628,
-0.1645166575908661,
-0.03421550244092941,
0.6048455834388733,
-0.47349902987480164,
-0.7106466889381409,
0.21649837493896484,
-0.22567132115364075,
-0.02574695460498333,
-0.5767303109169006,
1.0871731042861938,
-0.38203462958335876,
0.03368425741791725,
-0.40257471799850464,
-0.11352947354316711,
-0.5221098065376282,
0.3392278552055359,
-0.7158378958702087,
0.9399649500846863,
0.5119397044181824,
-0.9384310841560364,
0.13332852721214294,
-0.8263299465179443,
-0.6477333307266235,
0.5296911597251892,
-0.28154146671295166,
-0.17996041476726532,
0.11604271084070206,
0.5383666753768921,
-0.2578365206718445,
-0.13576486706733704,
0.09443990886211395,
0.009741156361997128,
-0.40663942694664,
-0.16316552460193634,
-0.5580200552940369,
1.3234940767288208,
0.1863437443971634,
-0.6023830771446228,
-0.01035828422755003,
-0.9739460945129395,
0.13719651103019714,
0.26183268427848816,
-0.2315634936094284,
-0.3187311589717865,
0.20515425503253937,
0.3840034306049347,
0.5071213245391846,
0.05832982808351517,
-0.5715044140815735,
0.2563060522079468,
-0.6098688244819641,
0.4080508351325989,
0.39812150597572327,
-0.2615062892436981,
0.11831648647785187,
-0.1880694478750229,
0.6471224427223206,
-0.2506673038005829,
0.08620332926511765,
0.1525304913520813,
-0.9529333114624023,
-0.769036591053009,
0.1553584784269333,
0.11331832408905029,
0.6774967312812805,
-0.8077002763748169,
0.277128666639328,
-0.14334221184253693,
-0.35416898131370544,
-1.287136197090149,
0.2961394786834717,
0.06726878881454468,
0.5510414838790894,
0.4067733585834503,
-0.42201608419418335,
-0.8819816708564758,
-1.140051007270813,
-0.32575762271881104,
-0.33795690536499023,
-0.03310232236981392,
0.16353686153888702,
0.391985148191452,
-0.8033828139305115,
0.814586341381073,
-0.036144521087408066,
-0.47068119049072266,
-0.34001606702804565,
0.17341378331184387,
0.21934039890766144,
0.3812502920627594,
0.6182093620300293,
-0.803850531578064,
-0.3820250928401947,
0.2530713975429535,
-0.8276892900466919,
-0.14994299411773682,
0.2088146060705185,
-0.04506895691156387,
0.39688682556152344,
0.12251763045787811,
-0.5422428846359253,
0.6623304486274719,
0.710498034954071,
-0.325507789850235,
0.38132667541503906,
0.03293866291642189,
-0.05924248322844505,
-0.4371211528778076,
0.3484693765640259,
-0.2240016758441925,
0.07704025506973267,
-0.789010226726532,
0.14345300197601318,
-0.5061541795730591,
-0.1693444848060608,
-0.21100720763206482,
0.5759470462799072,
-0.3857950270175934,
-0.2412823736667633,
-0.3990786373615265,
0.16042448580265045,
-0.4366023540496826,
0.20402537286281586,
-0.0416361503303051,
0.830083429813385,
0.3887413442134857,
-0.5659279227256775,
0.01911662518978119,
0.6753501892089844,
-0.6204791069030762,
0.2999558746814728,
-0.4012676477432251,
0.11513285338878632,
-0.034552086144685745,
-0.11564410477876663,
-0.676167905330658,
-0.0016928311670199037,
0.2539084255695343,
-0.5543950200080872,
0.21029900014400482,
0.05082765966653824,
-0.40824416279792786,
-0.47821372747421265,
-0.05495636537671089,
0.2984890937805176,
0.3749091625213623,
-0.26028379797935486,
0.37466272711753845,
0.9248011708259583,
-0.6621428728103638,
-0.8360369205474854,
-1.073657751083374,
0.5981928110122681,
0.005709274206310511,
-0.5973832011222839,
0.15591827034950256,
0.1905527114868164,
-0.6494945287704468,
-0.33693233132362366,
0.12392116338014603,
-0.08548985421657562,
0.6230373978614807,
0.17941181361675262,
-0.1030341163277626,
-0.21780839562416077,
-0.3084029257297516,
-0.0066630542278289795,
-0.20290280878543854,
0.2881586253643036,
-0.5568206310272217,
0.6200374364852905,
-0.26788532733917236,
-0.2935146689414978,
-0.23987452685832977,
0.6899009943008423,
0.2799879014492035,
-0.37901246547698975,
0.9610438942909241,
0.932837963104248,
-0.26683732867240906,
-0.012473590672016144,
-0.24520006775856018,
0.4850232005119324,
-0.4696817398071289,
0.32793694734573364,
-0.040033210068941116,
-0.7869389057159424,
0.695582926273346,
0.17973260581493378,
0.40705379843711853,
0.7439202070236206,
0.5883681178092957,
-0.060170091688632965,
0.7938481569290161,
0.9793387055397034,
-0.5027909278869629,
0.30899378657341003,
-0.4690404236316681,
0.3275322914123535,
-0.6877542734146118,
-0.35151246190071106,
-0.7196609377861023,
-0.5017042756080627,
-0.9962780475616455,
-0.13340029120445251,
0.25286155939102173,
-0.3656952381134033,
0.10203215479850769,
-0.07452155649662018,
-0.3102073073387146,
0.3170040249824524,
0.8396416902542114,
-0.13777200877666473,
0.33014675974845886,
0.04738812893629074,
-0.10834003239870071,
-0.13035953044891357,
-0.8913466334342957,
-0.8137856721878052,
0.8420236110687256,
0.052129752933979034,
0.26555609703063965,
0.07683928310871124,
0.8269528746604919,
0.5087869167327881,
0.4028719663619995,
-0.7755376696586609,
0.3269222378730774,
-0.13127005100250244,
-0.6079744696617126,
-0.5160092115402222,
-0.26160627603530884,
-1.2506242990493774,
0.2431604266166687,
-0.05196944996714592,
-0.697516143321991,
0.09383435547351837,
-0.17550033330917358,
-0.07652842253446579,
0.3736017048358917,
-0.1817837357521057,
0.9284136295318604,
-0.2599028944969177,
0.20652064681053162,
-0.0034768451005220413,
-0.8966349363327026,
0.5612345337867737,
-0.04574694111943245,
0.7775203585624695,
-0.0673602744936943,
0.07149023562669754,
0.5857805609703064,
-0.4413309097290039,
0.5358308553695679,
-0.05339233949780464,
-0.30111753940582275,
0.5619853734970093,
0.1219698041677475,
-0.14324268698692322,
-0.11980659514665604,
-0.23006850481033325,
0.5833907723426819,
-0.44673439860343933,
-0.7140820026397705,
-0.20037198066711426,
0.7807413935661316,
-0.9144973158836365,
-0.3210201859474182,
-0.3765357434749603,
-0.7476159930229187,
-0.33364200592041016,
0.28642645478248596,
0.1961648166179657,
0.08956602215766907,
-0.4665078818798065,
-0.3436811566352844,
0.19346435368061066,
-0.41759052872657776,
0.6890600919723511,
0.18217168748378754,
-0.25410687923431396,
-0.3145771026611328,
0.8464635014533997,
0.2116445004940033,
0.13785548508167267,
-0.04444970190525055,
-0.05839512124657631,
-0.3229454755783081,
-1.0231871604919434,
-0.34818726778030396,
0.025308506563305855,
-0.8487355709075928,
0.3511386513710022,
-0.6400781273841858,
-0.2201181948184967,
-0.42553138732910156,
-0.1726478487253189,
0.024569451808929443,
-0.6762208938598633,
-0.37894678115844727,
-0.13306033611297607,
-0.000852032215334475,
0.7689239382743835,
-0.18771390616893768,
0.511935830116272,
-0.8028380870819092,
0.5391529202461243,
0.259046733379364,
0.31885942816734314,
0.12092947959899902,
-0.5165728330612183,
-0.3478650152683258,
0.12152468413114548,
-0.27389246225357056,
-0.331554651260376,
0.8480228781700134,
0.5518213510513306,
0.8463295102119446,
0.2292870283126831,
-0.11587011814117432,
0.45811206102371216,
-0.46498072147369385,
0.9275308847427368,
-0.11019235849380493,
-0.7038063406944275,
0.6890214085578918,
-0.4080941379070282,
0.6534783840179443,
0.9535484313964844,
0.6225895881652832,
-0.7860485315322876,
-0.46000242233276367,
-0.7939489483833313,
-1.025344729423523,
0.607079803943634,
0.4384151101112366,
0.05638393014669418,
-0.25625690817832947,
0.05682861804962158,
0.2980629503726959,
0.3017871379852295,
-0.5664170384407043,
-0.6536335945129395,
-0.2824433445930481,
-0.06620963662862778,
-0.5580736398696899,
-0.06120303273200989,
-0.07737325876951218,
-0.3070116639137268,
0.6341992616653442,
-0.3704672157764435,
0.008839086629450321,
-0.037343453615903854,
-0.3086661398410797,
-0.08559760451316833,
0.2813568711280823,
0.5635398030281067,
0.9720191359519958,
-0.014565735124051571,
-0.12050921469926834,
-0.01725011132657528,
-0.7910324335098267,
0.00446848850697279,
0.22970692813396454,
-0.7264716625213623,
0.33273422718048096,
0.5509732961654663,
0.7288071513175964,
-0.07300093024969101,
-0.5410149097442627,
-0.17122584581375122,
-0.0973772332072258,
0.04831087216734886,
-0.20568855106830597,
-0.13985556364059448,
0.1065332293510437,
-0.2259446233510971,
0.6527157425880432,
0.08073076605796814,
0.33499157428741455,
-0.982952892780304,
0.08070719987154007,
0.43990856409072876,
-0.2982123792171478,
-0.21387077867984772,
0.5713915228843689,
0.2403171807527542,
-0.5223250985145569,
1.0481868982315063,
-0.02057897113263607,
-0.7106757164001465,
0.5496364831924438,
0.47129568457603455,
0.965195894241333,
-0.010302409529685974,
0.2997063100337982,
0.17115572094917297,
0.807442843914032,
0.2882828414440155,
0.6037828326225281,
0.02485557831823826,
-0.5539433360099792,
-0.30071184039115906,
-0.8041567802429199,
-0.35594046115875244,
-0.07551689445972443,
-0.49716469645500183,
-0.03529711812734604,
-0.528429388999939,
-0.4269064962863922,
-0.017553752288222313,
0.3615051805973053,
-0.5676779747009277,
0.29607129096984863,
0.7767099142074585,
0.8522340655326843,
-0.6983345150947571,
0.7579628825187683,
0.4818553924560547,
-0.3261783719062805,
-0.06273137032985687,
-0.2575005292892456,
0.28603488206863403,
-0.8570700883865356,
0.44213467836380005,
0.19107623398303986,
-0.05976514145731926,
0.12618489563465118,
-0.5858633518218994,
-0.7809821963310242,
0.6959505677223206,
0.3530332148075104,
-0.2014121413230896,
0.0677645355463028,
0.2833746671676636,
0.6890901923179626,
-0.15401025116443634,
0.14801543951034546,
1.162809133529663,
0.6840318441390991,
-0.1852577179670334,
-1.07086980342865,
-0.37419456243515015,
-0.32514920830726624,
-0.05348823219537735,
0.3984713554382324,
-0.416504830121994,
0.6201356053352356,
-0.22761407494544983,
-0.4670376777648926,
0.1311008185148239,
0.7952466607093811,
0.23671936988830566,
0.4298449754714966,
0.0036228164099156857,
0.557105541229248,
0.7299757599830627,
-0.12736941874027252,
1.2753814458847046,
-0.059154264628887177,
-0.030727092176675797,
0.9492716789245605,
0.041682351380586624,
0.6368678212165833,
0.5279825329780579,
-0.6170670390129089,
0.739598274230957,
0.6115731000900269,
0.399262398481369,
0.2905828058719635,
0.24064017832279205,
-0.2907428741455078,
0.14040230214595795,
-0.5123557448387146,
-0.31165099143981934,
0.6891124844551086,
0.8118363618850708,
-0.03136584907770157,
-0.1945735514163971,
-0.31159013509750366,
-0.17613573372364044,
0.29929471015930176,
-0.7011004090309143,
0.5539796352386475,
0.29524630308151245,
-0.4982284605503082,
0.6830150485038757,
-0.024991728365421295,
0.8572233319282532,
-0.8769760727882385,
0.12225236743688583,
-0.3137645125389099,
-0.1662355661392212,
-0.4263806939125061,
-0.7078142762184143,
0.6728922724723816,
-0.1899612545967102,
0.06094249710440636,
-0.027361860498785973,
0.7207438945770264,
-0.34710702300071716,
-0.48925143480300903,
0.43734052777290344,
0.5541260838508606,
0.08621058613061905,
-0.040011778473854065,
-0.7054123282432556,
0.03858369216322899,
-0.0769907608628273,
0.11979751288890839,
0.4148060083389282,
0.3019099831581116,
-0.3063696622848511,
0.9999087452888489,
0.6476173400878906,
0.32111334800720215,
0.2611970603466034,
0.2926807999610901,
0.7698129415512085,
-0.6679062247276306,
-0.6774714589118958,
-0.9922285079956055,
0.27305805683135986,
0.0701451227068901,
-0.5481273531913757,
0.8830846548080444,
0.3445585072040558,
0.8874777555465698,
0.08919291198253632,
0.9596534371376038,
-0.12667430937290192,
0.27897417545318604,
-0.24781273305416107,
0.9136916399002075,
-0.26066476106643677,
-0.010344279929995537,
-0.4170365035533905,
-0.816721498966217,
-0.41449517011642456,
0.49966540932655334,
0.059855807572603226,
-0.024514861404895782,
0.29757893085479736,
0.15007507801055908,
0.033897705376148224,
0.03266292065382004,
0.2695519030094147,
0.09504121541976929,
0.20968933403491974,
0.4458368420600891,
0.8191448450088501,
-0.48590153455734253,
0.18430191278457642,
-0.2618938088417053,
0.04596584662795067,
0.06116851419210434,
-0.6775016188621521,
-0.591574490070343,
-0.3582804203033447,
-0.10316181927919388,
-0.06752056628465652,
-0.1592157781124115,
0.7293494343757629,
0.305056631565094,
-1.1378202438354492,
-0.46993422508239746,
0.19350486993789673,
0.14812910556793213,
-0.2680725157260895,
-0.1690063774585724,
0.17654414474964142,
-0.1883615404367447,
-0.4097616970539093,
0.6230520009994507,
0.4358397126197815,
0.025522423908114433,
-0.6006378531455994,
-0.14424651861190796,
-0.7110500335693359,
-0.21975548565387726,
0.7941636443138123,
0.9109270572662354,
-0.9053357839584351,
0.14990071952342987,
-0.3515665531158447,
-0.0010427339002490044,
0.04879286512732506,
0.7179113030433655,
-0.9319013357162476,
0.4533538818359375,
0.2841976583003998,
0.9999882578849792,
0.3006685674190521,
-0.05689908191561699,
0.7026388645172119,
-0.7722398638725281,
0.32140856981277466,
0.620354175567627,
0.34918126463890076,
0.6430492997169495,
-0.1865827888250351,
0.7886888384819031,
0.31199589371681213,
-0.3981923758983612,
-0.6954708695411682,
0.1986328363418579,
-0.7862048745155334,
-0.09051838517189026,
0.6850932836532593,
0.05793995410203934,
-0.22238904237747192,
-0.6850059628486633,
-0.2654329836368561,
0.2039995938539505,
-0.08709701150655746,
0.996232807636261,
0.760469377040863,
-0.10100124776363373,
-0.23026758432388306,
-0.7852726578712463,
0.6167464852333069,
0.24354887008666992,
-0.9615691900253296,
-0.18984003365039825,
0.5399975776672363,
-0.2263462245464325,
0.31576257944107056,
0.8388852477073669,
-0.01808985322713852,
0.25406336784362793,
0.08649391680955887,
-0.07112805545330048,
0.19446860253810883,
-0.1568485051393509,
-0.6520241498947144,
0.06930641829967499,
0.21779538691043854,
0.06611975282430649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06808v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06808v1
|
Large Language Model in Financial Regulatory Interpretation
| 2024-05-10T20:45:40 | 2024-05-10T20:45:40 |
Zhiyu Cao, Zachary Feinstein
|
q-fin.RM
|
q-fin.RM, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This study explores the innovative use of Large Language Models (LLMs) as
analytical tools for interpreting complex financial regulations. The primary
objective is to design effective prompts that guide LLMs in distilling verbose
and intricate regulatory texts, such as the Basel III capital requirement
regulations, into a concise mathematical framework that can be subsequently
translated into actionable code. This novel approach aims to streamline the
implementation of regulatory mandates within the financial reporting and risk
management systems of global banking institutions. A case study was conducted
to assess the performance of various LLMs, demonstrating that GPT-4 outperforms
other models in processing and collecting necessary information, as well as
executing mathematical calculations. The case study utilized numerical
simulations with asset holdings -- including fixed income, equities, currency
pairs, and commodities -- to demonstrate how LLMs can effectively implement the
Basel III capital adequacy requirements.
|
[
-0.15634270012378693,
-0.9937039017677307,
0.7727363109588623,
0.34668222069740295,
-0.33363133668899536,
-0.0453912690281868,
-0.15495449304580688,
-0.699823260307312,
-0.16554348170757294,
0.8343999981880188,
-0.2406703531742096,
-0.6291691064834595,
-0.5529798269271851,
0.054442040622234344,
-0.4784988760948181,
1.0491398572921753,
-0.357309490442276,
0.1140749454498291,
0.2362392693758011,
0.42142370343208313,
-0.3261587917804718,
-0.5184904336929321,
-0.4874555170536041,
-0.4800686538219452,
0.35042378306388855,
0.1880945861339569,
0.5595023036003113,
0.36948832869529724,
0.9635069370269775,
0.2957253158092499,
-0.15219923853874207,
-0.016211172565817833,
-0.40055525302886963,
-0.45196473598480225,
-0.0469459593296051,
-0.3130738139152527,
-0.594491720199585,
0.037430863827466965,
0.7037891745567322,
0.455147922039032,
-0.543830156326294,
0.08048386126756668,
-0.03725947067141533,
0.5463023781776428,
-0.2363383173942566,
0.8531910181045532,
-0.20462875068187714,
-0.2149442583322525,
-0.1557210087776184,
-0.49224528670310974,
-0.5451889634132385,
-0.38888654112815857,
0.6561670899391174,
-0.6120551228523254,
-0.0497022345662117,
0.34350958466529846,
0.7734361886978149,
0.07465701550245285,
-0.7675365805625916,
-0.7643514275550842,
-0.8099750876426697,
0.6706759333610535,
-0.8952434062957764,
0.17628665268421173,
0.20050816237926483,
0.472673624753952,
-0.13545913994312286,
-0.8164162039756775,
-0.33613669872283936,
-0.16847580671310425,
-0.28204840421676636,
-0.10765271633863449,
-0.3086491525173187,
0.2349248230457306,
0.3512679934501648,
0.5117349028587341,
-0.1849534958600998,
0.22025784850120544,
-0.7077561020851135,
-0.20711174607276917,
0.5114782452583313,
0.24609854817390442,
0.1939706653356552,
-0.1287120282649994,
-0.4098612666130066,
0.006417299620807171,
-0.9806737899780273,
-0.15232202410697937,
0.5046669840812683,
0.49825355410575867,
-0.3624715805053711,
0.43739423155784607,
-0.05991736054420471,
0.782978355884552,
-0.34596896171569824,
-0.38562047481536865,
0.19322505593299866,
-0.21743527054786682,
-0.4093112349510193,
0.07618195563554764,
0.3621102571487427,
0.39778000116348267,
0.3194112777709961,
0.16931210458278656,
-0.5567730665206909,
-0.3799017369747162,
0.11957559734582901,
-0.9428960680961609,
0.046348992735147476,
0.07067568600177765,
-0.4488910138607025,
-0.29665181040763855,
0.13276663422584534,
-0.7839547395706177,
-0.24712905287742615,
-0.7709064483642578,
0.4513184428215027,
-0.12394480407238007,
-0.1401629000902176,
0.6305425763130188,
0.004803806077688932,
0.6116520762443542,
0.24671895802021027,
-1.0766220092773438,
0.5779090523719788,
0.8887340426445007,
0.7887899279594421,
0.031153326854109764,
0.3663453459739685,
-0.5247293710708618,
0.45514270663261414,
-0.10684330761432648,
0.5809445381164551,
-0.4253756105899811,
-0.5169457793235779,
0.1987093836069107,
-0.03936341032385826,
0.0715211033821106,
-0.33369457721710205,
0.5793558359146118,
-0.7782894968986511,
-0.1944810152053833,
-0.0671638548374176,
-0.5763945579528809,
-0.4903751611709595,
0.13219185173511505,
-0.9325330853462219,
0.22171910107135773,
0.10325578600168228,
-0.5295941233634949,
0.21054020524024963,
-0.9758715033531189,
-0.4306647479534149,
0.21384969353675842,
-0.32746368646621704,
-0.2918548285961151,
0.09805876016616821,
0.16729897260665894,
0.5537798404693604,
-0.8635669946670532,
0.3848487138748169,
-0.24055849015712738,
-0.39472541213035583,
0.3285449743270874,
-0.5684451460838318,
0.39068496227264404,
0.2876996695995331,
-0.30497506260871887,
0.33602041006088257,
-0.5556808710098267,
-0.20606018602848053,
0.07259944081306458,
-0.3054030239582062,
-0.2748912274837494,
0.12262310087680817,
0.34070608019828796,
-0.017250631004571915,
0.3983928859233856,
-0.19676603376865387,
0.10716758668422699,
-0.4125133752822876,
0.7857823371887207,
0.8452150821685791,
0.17206178605556488,
0.1755007654428482,
-0.29097068309783936,
0.6105929613113403,
-0.3622475862503052,
0.05407986789941788,
-0.017660191282629967,
-0.24777072668075562,
-0.30759039521217346,
-0.5275670886039734,
0.25437840819358826,
0.5759698748588562,
-0.2801811695098877,
0.08398955315351486,
-0.13903765380382538,
-0.2630165219306946,
-0.05102973058819771,
0.13916939496994019,
0.09675772488117218,
0.25837084650993347,
0.1208544373512268,
0.16152414679527283,
-0.46872368454933167,
-1.1181367635726929,
0.010390705429017544,
-0.11846421658992767,
0.05000326409935951,
0.14769792556762695,
0.6689133048057556,
-0.2866646945476532,
0.556313157081604,
-0.657207190990448,
-0.3090742230415344,
-0.3663574159145355,
0.32270291447639465,
0.5859363675117493,
0.29673904180526733,
0.7333305478096008,
-0.9428592920303345,
-0.1959749162197113,
0.28164172172546387,
-0.47652432322502136,
-0.05188697949051857,
-0.17391572892665863,
0.03065418265759945,
0.1205543652176857,
0.725674569606781,
-0.37889501452445984,
0.29571086168289185,
0.6388574838638306,
-0.3553493618965149,
0.6697486042976379,
-0.40718600153923035,
0.11143279075622559,
-0.6506330966949463,
0.29734113812446594,
0.27387216687202454,
-0.17746451497077942,
-0.5858222842216492,
0.2699984610080719,
0.14185811579227448,
0.1518036127090454,
-0.2322365790605545,
0.6308463215827942,
-0.5484409928321838,
-0.11647741496562958,
-0.09205074608325958,
0.141956627368927,
-0.12628959119319916,
0.17762888967990875,
-0.1940685212612152,
0.7592266798019409,
0.39412087202072144,
-0.49414870142936707,
0.5884796380996704,
0.1279861330986023,
-0.8505781292915344,
0.3822350800037384,
-0.7970429062843323,
-0.3945735692977905,
0.15067702531814575,
0.2678269147872925,
-0.8760355710983276,
-0.45043012499809265,
-0.03161159157752991,
0.24787047505378723,
0.5732358694076538,
0.098393015563488,
-0.7161686420440674,
-0.5063185691833496,
0.06884898245334625,
0.5162790417671204,
0.5032165050506592,
-0.3606564700603485,
0.765436589717865,
0.3278079926967621,
-0.4754476845264435,
-0.4243060350418091,
-0.6463431715965271,
0.057380616664886475,
-0.5419040322303772,
-0.4917478561401367,
0.05375750735402107,
-0.058281779289245605,
-0.6912615895271301,
-0.06891027092933655,
-0.11974222958087921,
0.04255405068397522,
0.2285870611667633,
0.14610213041305542,
0.7837855219841003,
-0.21797284483909607,
-0.21133741736412048,
-0.18980883061885834,
-0.1119336262345314,
0.34671750664711,
-0.26064690947532654,
0.3718552887439728,
-0.4205339252948761,
-0.4202149212360382,
-0.6867804527282715,
0.23986539244651794,
0.8372828364372253,
-0.17580610513687134,
0.6347734928131104,
0.10811305791139603,
-0.26471441984176636,
-0.16168835759162903,
-0.6401315331459045,
0.17115822434425354,
-0.5304023623466492,
0.33308494091033936,
-0.5179058909416199,
-1.1506882905960083,
0.7813124656677246,
-0.10912077128887177,
0.20947608351707458,
0.5259361863136292,
0.8913863301277161,
0.3273170590400696,
0.9026965498924255,
0.715614378452301,
-0.00039315473986789584,
0.45250943303108215,
-0.10732812434434891,
0.36009493470191956,
-0.5071895122528076,
-0.3942965865135193,
-0.43667489290237427,
-0.07850132137537003,
-0.3958052098751068,
-0.5300201177597046,
0.4025007486343384,
-0.15269319713115692,
-0.30183467268943787,
0.08185791969299316,
0.04615316912531853,
0.5452408194541931,
0.18815948069095612,
-0.1540590226650238,
0.4231695830821991,
0.049998488277196884,
-0.21323262155056,
0.15881146490573883,
-0.2035810947418213,
-0.7337718605995178,
1.163905382156372,
0.8002907037734985,
1.0846549272537231,
0.391353577375412,
0.409614235162735,
0.25559335947036743,
0.9187735915184021,
-0.8229207992553711,
0.24765145778656006,
-0.14427483081817627,
-0.6965004205703735,
-0.27363473176956177,
-0.751624584197998,
-0.42789986729621887,
0.10650290548801422,
0.1304710954427719,
-0.5928053259849548,
-0.038100406527519226,
-0.009810750372707844,
-0.7324371933937073,
0.2827998399734497,
-0.6888774633407593,
0.7611845135688782,
-0.1649458408355713,
0.022836364805698395,
-0.3442787826061249,
-0.20799502730369568,
0.8283933997154236,
-0.6358541250228882,
0.7316741347312927,
-0.17753998935222626,
-0.1557210385799408,
0.4764954447746277,
-0.4004349410533905,
0.9053888320922852,
-0.03935408592224121,
-0.891112744808197,
0.4533216059207916,
0.05362435430288315,
0.6472575068473816,
0.16125811636447906,
-0.23140844702720642,
0.0995912179350853,
0.21740634739398956,
-0.30569177865982056,
-0.39009109139442444,
0.7951393723487854,
-0.7122076749801636,
-0.709373950958252,
-0.47336673736572266,
-0.9117567539215088,
-0.10632225126028061,
0.14085358381271362,
-0.2477702498435974,
0.49573057889938354,
-0.36332011222839355,
0.2356320470571518,
0.40285202860832214,
-0.20010307431221008,
0.19638852775096893,
0.8253666758537292,
-0.4575173258781433,
-0.31402531266212463,
0.6662843227386475,
-0.08370696753263474,
0.5034447908401489,
0.2737784683704376,
0.202333003282547,
-0.6694114208221436,
-0.6770265102386475,
-0.09098134934902191,
0.42109113931655884,
-0.8527263402938843,
-0.11338149756193161,
-0.12692715227603912,
-0.23816612362861633,
-0.3935898542404175,
-0.07835713773965836,
0.10298191756010056,
-0.13919369876384735,
-0.2948387861251831,
-0.29824361205101013,
0.46058598160743713,
1.10275137424469,
-0.17970505356788635,
0.47434675693511963,
-0.8746196031570435,
0.2596069276332855,
0.340453565120697,
0.5765690207481384,
-0.1395217627286911,
-0.6721430420875549,
-0.21696196496486664,
-0.3104286193847656,
0.08328273892402649,
-0.5746583342552185,
0.3312545716762543,
-0.0761045441031456,
0.6438094973564148,
0.6256392002105713,
-0.24972277879714966,
0.6423333883285522,
-0.6244247555732727,
0.25706490874290466,
0.2915894687175751,
-1.1718732118606567,
0.03861737251281738,
-0.7206889390945435,
0.04911123961210251,
0.154663547873497,
0.1497081220149994,
-0.6714783906936646,
-0.29805850982666016,
-0.2130090743303299,
-0.9041363596916199,
0.6047006845474243,
0.025864552706480026,
0.08674518018960953,
0.12896698713302612,
0.6932404637336731,
-0.07186725735664368,
0.25979292392730713,
-0.5872669816017151,
0.030349230393767357,
0.35832515358924866,
-0.2798610329627991,
-0.16871891915798187,
-0.5521636605262756,
-0.4391738474369049,
-0.04160867631435394,
0.6209306716918945,
-0.03361473232507706,
-0.1899862140417099,
-0.0731578841805458,
0.274344265460968,
-0.1257561445236206,
0.29068121314048767,
0.9085884690284729,
1.0008292198181152,
-0.2986411154270172,
-0.0678221583366394,
0.1412983387708664,
-0.365740031003952,
0.05407385528087616,
0.23118725419044495,
0.061388611793518066,
-0.2749524712562561,
0.4508499503135681,
0.5261708498001099,
0.5985475778579712,
-0.9517987966537476,
0.4895998537540436,
-0.12346131354570389,
-0.5365784764289856,
-0.37955451011657715,
-0.18292924761772156,
0.22063203155994415,
0.43103763461112976,
0.5529891848564148,
-0.2142518162727356,
0.1704609990119934,
-0.6130853295326233,
0.4081904888153076,
0.26706424355506897,
-0.2622184157371521,
-0.1798999160528183,
0.6365705132484436,
0.2790466845035553,
0.24206556379795074,
0.4242837727069855,
0.04862537235021591,
-0.3724329471588135,
0.8006991744041443,
0.6160097122192383,
0.7391575574874878,
-0.12825943529605865,
0.08523309975862503,
0.12060492485761642,
0.4078836441040039,
-0.5534417629241943,
0.38362014293670654,
0.4293787479400635,
-0.34503889083862305,
-0.9669249653816223,
-0.8612578511238098,
-0.5518046617507935,
0.22104032337665558,
-0.7648003101348877,
0.4373836815357208,
-0.7582873702049255,
0.0025907333474606276,
0.25480490922927856,
-0.1654662936925888,
-0.6626896262168884,
-0.08159414678812027,
0.3735657036304474,
0.945376455783844,
-0.6621703505516052,
0.5715031623840332,
0.4381590187549591,
-0.23362290859222412,
-0.8524819612503052,
-0.24976874887943268,
0.42103472352027893,
-0.9938717484474182,
0.712109386920929,
0.0839189738035202,
-0.1060640960931778,
-0.10333798825740814,
-0.5125410556793213,
-0.9071477651596069,
1.071311354637146,
0.33435410261154175,
-0.912268877029419,
-0.1963239312171936,
0.12493941932916641,
0.3943147361278534,
-0.3575027883052826,
-0.18105308711528778,
1.0419846773147583,
0.8113014101982117,
0.441621869802475,
-0.9927029013633728,
-0.008910475298762321,
-0.06439686566591263,
-0.26307862997055054,
0.500872015953064,
-0.708491861820221,
0.971892237663269,
-0.25762850046157837,
-0.09223074465990067,
0.24115954339504242,
0.6452640891075134,
0.17328017950057983,
-0.0024823297280818224,
0.4042593240737915,
0.2600844204425812,
0.6979365944862366,
-0.1928383708000183,
1.155705213546753,
-0.4259992837905884,
0.6010456085205078,
0.8303342461585999,
-0.4401378035545349,
0.7551162838935852,
0.3449711799621582,
-0.1619035005569458,
0.4038659334182739,
0.5954991579055786,
-0.12451036274433136,
0.1911298632621765,
0.5738937258720398,
-0.3717193603515625,
-0.24759770929813385,
0.03512989729642868,
-0.20059071481227875,
0.30806392431259155,
0.5702136158943176,
-0.23383240401744843,
-0.18758243322372437,
-0.2704865634441376,
-0.03937679901719093,
-0.050713442265987396,
-0.47614800930023193,
0.5007422566413879,
0.4720887839794159,
-0.26076412200927734,
0.06868685036897659,
0.2631428837776184,
0.2484653890132904,
-0.9220248460769653,
-0.09452079981565475,
0.20026247203350067,
0.4077252149581909,
-0.05333218351006508,
-0.6503303647041321,
0.3456157445907593,
0.12235431373119354,
0.014860928989946842,
-0.4733252227306366,
0.1446898728609085,
-0.2768835723400116,
-0.7939996123313904,
0.2899494469165802,
0.16566316783428192,
0.08205568790435791,
0.027050111442804337,
-0.3872291147708893,
0.17758700251579285,
-0.009652667678892612,
-0.3336569368839264,
-0.008613362908363342,
0.7591596841812134,
-0.10442031919956207,
0.5570381283760071,
0.7834529876708984,
0.19965004920959473,
-0.3600902259349823,
0.3004333972930908,
0.6907297968864441,
-0.8464146852493286,
-0.718431830406189,
-1.0124050378799438,
0.1519116312265396,
0.13772675395011902,
-0.07348725944757462,
0.5871095657348633,
0.5846442580223083,
0.4870627820491791,
0.02706947736442089,
0.7760024070739746,
0.2575969994068146,
0.18173158168792725,
-0.8641430735588074,
0.6146973967552185,
-0.40619587898254395,
0.6550462245941162,
-0.3480801284313202,
-0.8748986721038818,
-0.6594749689102173,
0.45735424757003784,
-0.6936569809913635,
-0.10382787883281708,
0.567715048789978,
0.4392421245574951,
0.06337932497262955,
0.22618956863880157,
0.2794228494167328,
0.45048826932907104,
0.6658454537391663,
0.4446040391921997,
0.6783743500709534,
-0.005812305957078934,
0.6294639110565186,
0.3813896179199219,
-0.11716213077306747,
-0.45618540048599243,
-0.9565780758857727,
-0.7528682351112366,
-0.10157156735658646,
-0.11605880409479141,
-0.19399474561214447,
-0.5344736576080322,
0.8653867840766907,
0.24836261570453644,
-0.8595480918884277,
-0.6586722731590271,
0.16375069320201874,
-0.06066152825951576,
0.1260901540517807,
-0.1619645357131958,
0.3734847605228424,
-0.2718057334423065,
-0.7700579166412354,
0.2325143665075302,
0.4983169138431549,
0.4951726794242859,
-0.5771083831787109,
-0.08258391171693802,
0.15543623268604279,
0.29373130202293396,
0.5765447616577148,
-0.0008292950806207955,
-0.7624197602272034,
-0.4131384491920471,
-0.2734868824481964,
-0.23640985786914825,
-0.23982791602611542,
1.1492016315460205,
0.08937986195087433,
0.23160125315189362,
0.34914517402648926,
0.579282283782959,
0.5749250650405884,
0.11432716250419617,
0.8962050676345825,
-0.1939423829317093,
0.2934587895870209,
0.014672576449811459,
0.5864577889442444,
-0.008992240764200687,
-0.21122436225414276,
0.38857439160346985,
0.04680943861603737,
-0.46247240900993347,
-0.6213181614875793,
0.0652310848236084,
-0.9574751257896423,
-0.40928977727890015,
1.3008553981781006,
-0.19078955054283142,
-0.43155983090400696,
-0.018247468397021294,
-0.2919805347919464,
-0.25691843032836914,
-0.3523610532283783,
0.5354053974151611,
1.155526876449585,
0.12885475158691406,
0.19455812871456146,
-1.2307515144348145,
0.48376476764678955,
0.049150772392749786,
-0.6957172751426697,
0.2506825029850006,
0.8257296085357666,
0.41163426637649536,
-0.052798088639974594,
0.41225168108940125,
-0.3623911440372467,
0.17393580079078674,
-0.19909223914146423,
-0.11385954916477203,
0.08236023038625717,
-0.1797182559967041,
-0.5341554880142212,
0.14729754626750946,
0.03131047263741493,
0.45606958866119385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06807v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06807v1
|
Tackling Execution-Based Evaluation for NL2Bash
| 2024-05-10T20:45:34 | 2024-05-10T20:45:34 |
Ngoc Phuoc An Vo, Brent Paulovicks, Vadim Sheinin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Given recent advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs), the task of
translating from natural language prompts to different programming languages
(code generation) attracts immense attention for wide application in different
domains. Specially code generation for Bash (NL2Bash) is widely used to
generate Bash scripts for automating different tasks, such as performance
monitoring, compilation, system administration, system diagnostics, etc.
Besides code generation, validating synthetic code is critical before using
them for any application. Different methods for code validation are proposed,
both direct (execution evaluation) and indirect validations (i.e. exact/partial
match, BLEU score). Among these, Execution-based Evaluation (EE) can validate
the predicted code by comparing the execution output of model prediction and
expected output in system. However, designing and implementing such an
execution-based evaluation system for NL2Bash is not a trivial task. In this
paper, we present a machinery for execution-based evaluation for NL2Bash. We
create a set of 50 prompts to evaluate some popular LLMs for NL2Bash. We also
analyze several advantages and challenges of EE such as syntactically different
yet semantically equivalent Bash scripts generated by different LLMs, or
syntactically correct but semantically incorrect Bash scripts, and how we
capture and process them correctly.
|
[
-0.22542792558670044,
-0.9527332782745361,
0.6250778436660767,
0.6352980136871338,
-0.11476075649261475,
0.29251551628112793,
-0.3139994740486145,
-0.3833693265914917,
0.13477064669132233,
0.6292082071304321,
-0.5728781819343567,
-0.4929841458797455,
-0.21039314568042755,
0.4084117114543915,
-0.33653488755226135,
0.9108949303627014,
-0.20167018473148346,
-0.1360064595937729,
-0.4471505582332611,
-0.1197332888841629,
-0.9119230508804321,
-0.22410736978054047,
-0.7354651093482971,
-0.17152664065361023,
0.027363598346710205,
0.29222315549850464,
0.29545581340789795,
0.27055224776268005,
0.5261353254318237,
0.2869780957698822,
0.09148948639631271,
0.2721622884273529,
-0.336475670337677,
0.43136727809906006,
-0.26887246966362,
-0.4498863220214844,
-0.35092082619667053,
-0.25240635871887207,
0.41142737865448,
0.46580106019973755,
-0.25687116384506226,
0.3770424723625183,
-0.13499227166175842,
0.468820184469223,
-0.47719109058380127,
0.05906233191490173,
-0.6723638772964478,
0.017559215426445007,
0.08802708983421326,
-0.14791075885295868,
-0.8046277165412903,
-0.5557672381401062,
-0.12638971209526062,
-0.1936643272638321,
-0.09810080379247665,
0.2325676530599594,
0.8139055371284485,
0.2511940002441406,
-0.09966582804918289,
-0.6268120408058167,
-0.5266716480255127,
0.8345324397087097,
-0.9022076725959778,
0.17075391113758087,
-0.1153254508972168,
0.5563960671424866,
-0.2316531091928482,
-0.7391175627708435,
-0.7328146696090698,
-0.5739589929580688,
-0.15443862974643707,
0.23684953153133392,
-0.4384606182575226,
0.07400577515363693,
0.7289608120918274,
0.13375858962535858,
-0.717565655708313,
0.35345837473869324,
-0.11372701078653336,
-0.18151769042015076,
0.3514782190322876,
0.3250281810760498,
0.302048921585083,
-0.5422202944755554,
-0.5174906253814697,
-0.1128394603729248,
-0.3761926591396332,
0.11712078750133514,
0.6037380695343018,
0.23445618152618408,
-0.028054075315594673,
0.71219801902771,
-0.4297890365123749,
0.6385420560836792,
0.15262866020202637,
0.19798344373703003,
0.2866714298725128,
-0.03889254480600357,
-0.22203058004379272,
-0.11693776398897171,
0.6462340354919434,
0.5720457434654236,
0.18244487047195435,
-0.1309601217508316,
-0.5552927255630493,
0.5036607980728149,
0.576967179775238,
-0.9117926359176636,
0.1105138435959816,
0.5178475379943848,
-0.4137727916240692,
-0.3698037564754486,
0.07505573332309723,
-0.9857445955276489,
-0.2662407457828522,
-0.3182702660560608,
0.44997239112854004,
-0.3649454116821289,
-0.08433810621500015,
-0.15958715975284576,
-0.08697262406349182,
0.502708911895752,
0.4383942484855652,
-0.43247678875923157,
0.43336784839630127,
0.9326216578483582,
0.7550230026245117,
-0.5222896337509155,
-0.046267978847026825,
-0.8898345828056335,
-0.09668617695569992,
-0.4477526843547821,
0.556037425994873,
-0.42132294178009033,
-0.26096242666244507,
-0.09546566009521484,
-0.0696588009595871,
0.16675755381584167,
-0.6248177289962769,
0.455849826335907,
-0.7411620020866394,
0.20736318826675415,
-0.07924573123455048,
-0.7434521913528442,
-0.18534202873706818,
0.30021458864212036,
-0.5178805589675903,
1.2389534711837769,
0.2215426117181778,
-0.4876880645751953,
0.1256120353937149,
-0.9735762476921082,
-0.4981589913368225,
0.18878920376300812,
-0.07891478389501572,
-0.24505828320980072,
0.17874352633953094,
0.0714402049779892,
0.19512929022312164,
-0.16859503090381622,
0.2790025770664215,
-0.10095515847206116,
-0.45459845662117004,
0.07335440069437027,
-0.3292429447174072,
0.8427825570106506,
0.09307834506034851,
-0.7443608641624451,
0.18907377123832703,
-0.7652838230133057,
0.4135088324546814,
0.02295881137251854,
-0.10399739444255829,
0.11709591001272202,
-0.104293093085289,
-0.018887870013713837,
0.012330451980233192,
0.47369033098220825,
-0.5487392544746399,
0.0421333909034729,
-0.34768566489219666,
-0.09326110780239105,
0.813974916934967,
0.059771738946437836,
0.13543537259101868,
-0.05369141697883606,
0.8712358474731445,
-0.4274002015590668,
0.12721677124500275,
-0.3123854696750641,
-0.6191116571426392,
-0.6679945588111877,
-0.001671035890467465,
0.4636707305908203,
0.9981169700622559,
-0.6931663751602173,
0.8188740611076355,
0.04139222949743271,
-0.6949268579483032,
-0.4262314736843109,
0.13518793880939484,
0.4417399764060974,
0.5912567973136902,
0.36331427097320557,
-0.2879345118999481,
-0.7693131566047668,
-0.9126440286636353,
-0.020719867199659348,
-0.374763160943985,
-0.06402264535427094,
0.35019251704216003,
0.40354400873184204,
-0.6416527032852173,
1.1268306970596313,
-0.3016056716442108,
0.20541122555732727,
-0.527617871761322,
0.06424285471439362,
0.5487778782844543,
0.37331169843673706,
0.43602341413497925,
-0.16425484418869019,
-0.38362568616867065,
0.1685193032026291,
-0.8517276644706726,
-0.7990673184394836,
-0.3587661385536194,
-0.1986677199602127,
0.5994477272033691,
0.35547274351119995,
-0.549889326095581,
0.36353299021720886,
0.8090815544128418,
-0.03838329389691353,
1.1064203977584839,
-0.09090915322303772,
0.10720816254615784,
-0.735491156578064,
0.4487663507461548,
-0.4175828695297241,
-0.4548766314983368,
-0.31002846360206604,
0.49186626076698303,
0.008639754727482796,
-0.2539181113243103,
-0.13282497227191925,
0.6601352095603943,
-0.1958482265472412,
-0.3361501693725586,
-0.3646644651889801,
0.14565019309520721,
0.30475056171417236,
0.27873632311820984,
-0.037910230457782745,
0.7502375245094299,
0.4182427227497101,
-0.474337637424469,
0.6745592951774597,
0.009708845987915993,
-0.5427002310752869,
0.4977225661277771,
-0.9334714412689209,
0.4611854553222656,
0.2059396356344223,
0.4435940086841583,
-0.7700363993644714,
-0.047940757125616074,
0.15852151811122894,
-0.30305230617523193,
0.19065339863300323,
0.0003881388111039996,
-0.5203484296798706,
-0.41757214069366455,
-0.333122581243515,
-0.11765757203102112,
0.8898060321807861,
-0.5679363012313843,
0.5528395771980286,
-0.09592820703983307,
-0.15425434708595276,
-0.7568506002426147,
-0.46384868025779724,
0.15146857500076294,
-0.12858104705810547,
-0.5337755084037781,
0.11150890588760376,
-0.006790910381823778,
-0.46824145317077637,
-0.11051123589277267,
-0.1704782396554947,
0.5410899519920349,
0.1815328150987625,
0.28558388352394104,
0.44425851106643677,
-0.23835907876491547,
-0.14639723300933838,
0.3255835473537445,
-0.1826624870300293,
0.12025371938943863,
-0.12766166031360626,
0.6243797540664673,
-0.1661304533481598,
-0.6444270014762878,
-0.4001670479774475,
0.382571280002594,
0.13860100507736206,
-0.05870654806494713,
0.25300511717796326,
0.7062442898750305,
-0.32464465498924255,
-0.5137053728103638,
-0.7025095820426941,
-0.23770540952682495,
-0.4673325717449188,
0.3794022798538208,
-0.26059243083000183,
-0.49824780225753784,
0.41989636421203613,
-0.3209817409515381,
0.30365926027297974,
0.27517619729042053,
0.8694583773612976,
-0.1968860924243927,
0.7336822152137756,
0.1526726931333542,
0.31583699584007263,
0.15402352809906006,
-0.019281137734651566,
0.29874691367149353,
-0.7581050992012024,
-0.1677127331495285,
-0.3695871829986572,
-0.3459671437740326,
-0.48665186762809753,
-0.6237963438034058,
0.18381619453430176,
0.23919779062271118,
0.1857973337173462,
0.7013049125671387,
-0.392417311668396,
0.44354838132858276,
0.4069571793079376,
-0.26520591974258423,
0.010283648036420345,
-0.07787691056728363,
-0.4501800537109375,
0.22353386878967285,
-0.1994761973619461,
-0.9845561981201172,
0.9086335897445679,
0.39710304141044617,
0.5987011790275574,
0.12584823369979858,
0.8461152911186218,
0.8045433163642883,
0.2445538341999054,
-0.7455241680145264,
0.7648690342903137,
0.11185479164123535,
-0.3863911032676697,
-0.1459987312555313,
-0.5734156370162964,
-0.7018023133277893,
-0.09042399376630783,
0.13984458148479462,
-0.9855312705039978,
-0.19333137571811676,
0.06324838846921921,
-0.39365097880363464,
0.015497496351599693,
-1.106253981590271,
0.8613799214363098,
-0.37337225675582886,
-0.2584916949272156,
-0.1882147639989853,
-0.541542649269104,
0.1766578108072281,
-0.003853693138808012,
0.09823205322027206,
-0.12526023387908936,
-0.0025030113756656647,
0.6665440201759338,
-0.4115643799304962,
0.6195183992385864,
-0.5360676646232605,
-0.19817817211151123,
0.4140966832637787,
0.4138113856315613,
0.6362063884735107,
0.2691631317138672,
-0.38232728838920593,
0.20890754461288452,
0.004063665866851807,
-0.17101308703422546,
-0.6718023419380188,
0.6180395483970642,
-0.2650916576385498,
-0.5799252390861511,
-0.27192479372024536,
-0.20352281630039215,
-0.23919585347175598,
0.017355358228087425,
0.1474674940109253,
0.4133348762989044,
-0.2012152075767517,
-0.22170746326446533,
0.27047351002693176,
-0.6238061785697937,
0.3798137903213501,
0.3298661708831787,
-0.8217400312423706,
-0.2586744427680969,
0.8297415375709534,
-0.4471129775047302,
0.2479991912841797,
0.3108915090560913,
0.047548726201057434,
-0.41311973333358765,
-0.39841607213020325,
-0.9708543419837952,
-0.08996215462684631,
-0.765364408493042,
-0.43002456426620483,
-0.5946453213691711,
0.009419547393918037,
-0.15944893658161163,
-0.3347403407096863,
-0.1650187373161316,
-0.38698744773864746,
0.055450208485126495,
-0.05587009713053703,
0.4223465025424957,
0.883121907711029,
-0.06818978488445282,
0.21317072212696075,
-0.5579445362091064,
0.34107106924057007,
0.19176016747951508,
0.44550803303718567,
-0.03614451736211777,
-0.44569170475006104,
-0.1006830558180809,
-0.1364627331495285,
-0.36857447028160095,
-1.0044885873794556,
0.04537888616323471,
-0.04760250076651573,
0.5539991855621338,
0.26554760336875916,
-0.1407890021800995,
0.5142213106155396,
-0.6852197051048279,
0.7415496706962585,
0.04571213573217392,
-1.293979287147522,
0.7625705003738403,
0.055938322097063065,
-0.015237795189023018,
0.5973676443099976,
-0.027650170028209686,
-0.6426084041595459,
-0.30717340111732483,
-0.550987184047699,
-0.8773830533027649,
0.7067986726760864,
0.26795661449432373,
0.21306289732456207,
-0.18430909514427185,
0.16196590662002563,
0.43977826833724976,
0.19773654639720917,
-0.5122841000556946,
-0.10013613849878311,
0.06340590864419937,
-0.09024803340435028,
0.4320923089981079,
-0.07183683663606644,
0.20295578241348267,
0.14604313671588898,
0.6432549357414246,
-0.2721902132034302,
0.37378934025764465,
-0.1413930505514145,
-0.3970588743686676,
-0.0189062487334013,
0.15214964747428894,
0.3740198314189911,
0.5623409152030945,
-0.3317857086658478,
-0.26185721158981323,
0.47943249344825745,
-0.16809509694576263,
0.06775170564651489,
-0.17985327541828156,
-0.30411961674690247,
0.27427738904953003,
0.5528427362442017,
0.930518388748169,
-0.07026667892932892,
-1.1279419660568237,
0.4439247250556946,
0.04365226626396179,
0.23980702459812164,
-0.19202622771263123,
0.12728329002857208,
0.04930219054222107,
0.13265904784202576,
0.23210015892982483,
0.13140837848186493,
0.3784542381763458,
-0.5761777758598328,
0.3336901366710663,
0.3651489317417145,
-0.09963691979646683,
-0.155176043510437,
0.17630036175251007,
0.15528205037117004,
-0.4474278390407562,
0.6000538468360901,
-0.7236831784248352,
-0.6557356119155884,
0.8627603054046631,
0.6444702744483948,
0.7719483375549316,
-0.14748167991638184,
0.059425946325063705,
0.42256397008895874,
0.23176123201847076,
0.35595864057540894,
0.5241491794586182,
0.10369845479726791,
-0.44932135939598083,
-0.794609546661377,
-1.1036372184753418,
-0.8626618385314941,
-0.076457180082798,
-0.7478485703468323,
0.6541492938995361,
-0.635928750038147,
-0.16510581970214844,
-0.18419155478477478,
-0.14034834504127502,
-0.6499115824699402,
0.10213077813386917,
0.3167216181755066,
1.031548261642456,
-0.5810050368309021,
0.5063539743423462,
0.8158661723136902,
0.06645803898572922,
-0.581182599067688,
0.10751985013484955,
-0.35140225291252136,
-0.6959393620491028,
0.5272998213768005,
0.5900170207023621,
-0.0036298048216849566,
-0.2341224104166031,
-0.04057386517524719,
-0.3672720789909363,
0.7921980619430542,
0.3729318380355835,
-0.7530364394187927,
-0.021239005029201508,
-0.04948122054338455,
0.6453890204429626,
-0.13951142132282257,
0.7594153881072998,
0.7030628323554993,
0.6441490054130554,
-0.15642300248146057,
-0.9634278416633606,
0.11607103049755096,
-0.15861548483371735,
0.13507188856601715,
0.05731460452079773,
-0.2663419842720032,
0.3862362205982208,
-0.3961382210254669,
-0.3270513415336609,
0.23340651392936707,
0.5389169454574585,
0.6380705833435059,
0.3445914685726166,
0.5954867005348206,
0.4690254032611847,
0.7245659828186035,
-0.11939200758934021,
1.232474684715271,
-0.20092462003231049,
0.40788668394088745,
1.0103036165237427,
-0.8526161909103394,
0.8777328729629517,
0.3662588894367218,
-0.47669392824172974,
0.9053804874420166,
0.3408540189266205,
-0.2908734679222107,
0.11853756010532379,
0.5603424310684204,
0.09358027577400208,
0.012348925694823265,
0.05625635012984276,
-0.23042581975460052,
0.7162825465202332,
0.36343804001808167,
-0.06579933315515518,
-0.29196563363075256,
-0.24105598032474518,
-0.11243528127670288,
0.08648432791233063,
0.046159759163856506,
0.8042505979537964,
-0.08757465332746506,
-0.7698785066604614,
0.4250064492225647,
0.39281418919563293,
0.8050938844680786,
-0.7312816381454468,
-0.22537542879581451,
-0.1304277628660202,
-0.09119509905576706,
-0.27224472165107727,
-0.7165996432304382,
0.6021520495414734,
0.5362358689308167,
-0.010611248202621937,
-0.10904201865196228,
0.6339339017868042,
0.05424673110246658,
-0.5302534699440002,
0.6231912970542908,
0.5106618404388428,
0.2263861447572708,
0.01932070218026638,
-0.6968795657157898,
0.26731789112091064,
0.14772538840770721,
-0.28374239802360535,
-0.010325569659471512,
0.3898676037788391,
-0.2197156399488449,
0.43785083293914795,
0.823062539100647,
0.15309034287929535,
0.011451792903244495,
0.23139812052249908,
0.4034956693649292,
-0.44609329104423523,
-0.48912158608436584,
-0.9898345470428467,
0.3483719229698181,
-0.2645553946495056,
-0.12667278945446014,
0.7021014094352722,
0.6593146920204163,
0.5592028498649597,
-0.25954726338386536,
0.7730728983879089,
-0.4648389220237732,
0.5479370355606079,
-0.6033921837806702,
0.45322686433792114,
-0.21966122090816498,
0.3152504563331604,
-0.4159058928489685,
-1.128078818321228,
0.04459446296095848,
0.7035264372825623,
-0.14166858792304993,
0.22444675862789154,
0.7303887009620667,
0.7293238639831543,
0.17091794312000275,
0.09259053319692612,
0.29025259613990784,
-0.004885835573077202,
0.2491784691810608,
0.4538003206253052,
0.9182816743850708,
-0.25184985995292664,
0.30371689796447754,
-0.3027142286300659,
-0.2852199077606201,
-0.4477936625480652,
-1.1986830234527588,
-0.582328736782074,
-0.23383158445358276,
-0.31387412548065186,
-0.5694541931152344,
-0.04514363408088684,
1.1148641109466553,
0.33149781823158264,
-1.2108244895935059,
-0.32705438137054443,
0.004130534362047911,
-0.004073764197528362,
-0.3748115301132202,
-0.35548117756843567,
0.3081834614276886,
-0.42678868770599365,
-0.7596874237060547,
0.5757638812065125,
0.43696367740631104,
-0.34356653690338135,
-0.30686724185943604,
-0.09226234257221222,
0.25852298736572266,
0.20194298028945923,
0.6869071125984192,
-0.08598585426807404,
-0.8400036096572876,
-0.2971529960632324,
0.06459030508995056,
-0.06254281103610992,
-0.19399286806583405,
0.6372396945953369,
-1.0392687320709229,
0.26126042008399963,
0.4489337205886841,
0.9234703183174133,
-0.02307576686143875,
0.11578042060136795,
0.5531123876571655,
-0.9868097901344299,
-0.2633473873138428,
0.40731215476989746,
0.4716579020023346,
0.4698076546192169,
-0.3590427041053772,
0.5696728825569153,
0.03694755584001541,
-0.3215734660625458,
-1.1341300010681152,
0.29378238320350647,
-1.2449300289154053,
0.08772291243076324,
1.3527953624725342,
-0.28445446491241455,
-0.05106356367468834,
0.09181857109069824,
-0.31955745816230774,
0.2719125747680664,
-0.49484747648239136,
0.7114960551261902,
0.5603743195533752,
-0.10466857999563217,
0.2443353533744812,
-0.7218023538589478,
0.2532216012477875,
0.5657260417938232,
-1.147475004196167,
0.13019432127475739,
0.27576208114624023,
0.2266121804714203,
0.3589419424533844,
0.21871605515480042,
-0.02001422643661499,
0.5108908414840698,
-0.08541753888130188,
0.37239161133766174,
0.04292271286249161,
-0.08118454366922379,
-0.37122923135757446,
0.008271502330899239,
-0.0016327709890902042,
-0.07390942424535751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06802v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06802v1
|
Summarizing Radiology Reports Findings into Impressions
| 2024-05-10T20:29:25 | 2024-05-10T20:29:25 |
Raul Salles de Padua, Imran Qureshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Patient hand-off and triage are two fundamental problems in health care.
Often doctors must painstakingly summarize complex findings to efficiently
communicate with specialists and quickly make decisions on which patients have
the most urgent cases. In pursuit of these challenges, we present (1) a model
with state-of-art radiology report summarization performance using (2) a novel
method for augmenting medical data, and (3) an analysis of the model
limitations and radiology knowledge gain. We also provide a data processing
pipeline for future models developed on the the MIMIC CXR dataset. Our best
performing model was a fine-tuned BERT-to-BERT encoder-decoder with 58.75/100
ROUGE-L F1, which outperformed specialized checkpoints with more sophisticated
attention mechanisms. We investigate these aspects in this work.
|
[
-0.23854359984397888,
-0.12347031384706497,
0.7702385187149048,
0.04956820607185364,
-0.29313960671424866,
0.21285173296928406,
0.12173545360565186,
-0.7761648893356323,
0.28980106115341187,
0.5844592452049255,
-0.25812631845474243,
-0.16538006067276,
-0.9350553750991821,
0.05330781266093254,
-0.4545665979385376,
1.1614774465560913,
0.2640095353126526,
0.50379878282547,
-0.3400895297527313,
-0.14245633780956268,
-0.26484858989715576,
-0.39878976345062256,
-0.340660959482193,
-0.42192235589027405,
0.2531207799911499,
0.4674173593521118,
1.046645164489746,
0.5775400400161743,
0.8898418545722961,
0.19057460129261017,
-0.03817848861217499,
0.23262324929237366,
-0.42096418142318726,
-0.08193181455135345,
0.03121235780417919,
-0.2747683525085449,
-0.7404935359954834,
-0.46298012137413025,
0.4975222945213318,
0.944580078125,
0.02820676937699318,
0.02283054031431675,
-0.22052016854286194,
0.7700584530830383,
-0.5697003602981567,
0.1798669546842575,
-0.03192799165844917,
-0.07082168757915497,
0.2219923436641693,
-0.47654852271080017,
-0.45482784509658813,
-0.39661458134651184,
0.5163324475288391,
-0.5494464635848999,
0.29992860555648804,
-0.10886723548173904,
0.7726356387138367,
0.1674780398607254,
-0.09710296243429184,
-0.43104133009910583,
-0.7825407385826111,
0.45668965578079224,
-0.6223471760749817,
0.1159314513206482,
0.08224063366651535,
0.5698723793029785,
0.35880494117736816,
-1.1335902214050293,
0.003414026228711009,
0.03256472945213318,
-0.3534882366657257,
0.44132381677627563,
-0.4019200801849365,
0.0945814698934555,
0.3031900227069855,
0.635632336139679,
-0.3449787497520447,
-0.2299666702747345,
-0.4805658757686615,
0.062748983502388,
0.5427913069725037,
0.5313628911972046,
0.4998527467250824,
-0.18013429641723633,
-0.40398189425468445,
-0.38641270995140076,
-0.33234986662864685,
-0.03580529987812042,
-0.35750213265419006,
-0.016433412209153175,
-0.12426269054412842,
0.41275328397750854,
-0.5040982365608215,
0.7708485126495361,
0.2782355546951294,
0.06408518552780151,
0.16359534859657288,
-0.2188875377178192,
-0.19485731422901154,
-0.016319608315825462,
0.5850430727005005,
0.7967191934585571,
-0.010317833162844181,
-0.023423783481121063,
-0.20291240513324738,
-0.36254194378852844,
0.3577571213245392,
-0.7248313426971436,
-0.29415014386177063,
0.4192807674407959,
-0.8035857081413269,
-0.47020718455314636,
0.19995364546775818,
-0.5619985461235046,
-0.23919636011123657,
-0.3568098247051239,
0.4928860366344452,
-0.8008390069007874,
-0.18149620294570923,
0.3851545453071594,
-0.3634590208530426,
0.04008709266781807,
0.5851755142211914,
-0.4227442443370819,
0.5060259103775024,
0.3342866599559784,
0.7784931063652039,
0.1974649727344513,
0.18534475564956665,
-0.45550233125686646,
0.1905113011598587,
-0.02136557176709175,
0.9091441631317139,
-0.47738516330718994,
-0.6505575776100159,
-0.13900749385356903,
-0.1477327197790146,
0.12649044394493103,
-0.5333882570266724,
0.11608564853668213,
-0.44433873891830444,
0.14738322794437408,
-0.5739616751670837,
-0.42452260851860046,
-0.2314305305480957,
0.0953945592045784,
-0.6386833190917969,
0.5595109462738037,
0.5554152131080627,
-0.933998167514801,
0.23857824504375458,
-0.5199477076530457,
-0.6615425944328308,
0.1992976814508438,
-0.09109973162412643,
-0.3823786675930023,
0.4165416955947876,
0.5979154109954834,
0.534907341003418,
-0.2204848676919937,
-0.07847860455513,
0.01627371832728386,
-0.284626841545105,
0.30796322226524353,
0.4041503369808197,
0.6508263349533081,
0.3006012439727783,
0.18070366978645325,
-0.0021487572230398655,
-0.5302469730377197,
0.07523929327726364,
-0.023858580738306046,
0.011227034032344818,
-0.2548271417617798,
-0.03315377235412598,
0.057846229523420334,
0.17078541219234467,
0.4319683611392975,
-0.4469658136367798,
-0.008099738508462906,
-0.287767231464386,
0.14446395635604858,
0.15192268788814545,
0.3080814778804779,
0.18137988448143005,
-0.9685877561569214,
0.5484166741371155,
0.11510239541530609,
0.3264402449131012,
-0.5508117079734802,
-0.21251513063907623,
-0.5566586256027222,
-0.41579824686050415,
0.1787807196378708,
0.46548524498939514,
-0.6216779351234436,
-0.10300330072641373,
-0.7403638958930969,
-0.4718877971172333,
-0.7210969924926758,
-0.6464368104934692,
0.522923469543457,
0.5657890439033508,
0.541008472442627,
-0.4862207770347595,
-0.47493839263916016,
-1.0102050304412842,
0.021952418610453606,
0.09730476886034012,
-0.3166014552116394,
0.3175260126590729,
0.04419874772429466,
0.16959935426712036,
0.7880882620811462,
-0.8596925735473633,
-0.3665202260017395,
-0.837413489818573,
0.24242858588695526,
0.2378835529088974,
0.20738328993320465,
0.4788827896118164,
-0.3596811294555664,
-0.4465911090373993,
0.04876922070980072,
-0.859900951385498,
-0.033732820302248,
-0.2355143427848816,
0.2747099697589874,
-0.17909309267997742,
0.589410126209259,
-0.2696003019809723,
0.38071486353874207,
0.04109262675046921,
0.0005523388390429318,
0.3023788332939148,
-0.6650956273078918,
0.4447297751903534,
-0.933215856552124,
0.15453462302684784,
-0.28814294934272766,
-0.6455255746841431,
-0.7154422998428345,
0.06245972961187363,
0.141078382730484,
-0.13716524839401245,
-0.13061150908470154,
0.043190598487854004,
-0.768488883972168,
-0.22639550268650055,
-0.4007508158683777,
-0.1522049903869629,
0.12329330295324326,
0.12700966000556946,
0.4445454776287079,
0.24243749678134918,
0.5325933694839478,
-0.4797545075416565,
0.1382443606853485,
0.3818446397781372,
-0.2851278483867645,
0.57771897315979,
-0.9086424112319946,
0.22953206300735474,
-0.4390154182910919,
0.2320551872253418,
-0.9117658734321594,
-0.5228408575057983,
-0.1909494400024414,
-0.7539063096046448,
0.6423134803771973,
-0.08428061008453369,
-0.24116861820220947,
-0.3902975022792816,
-0.4748656749725342,
0.4363393783569336,
0.6228908896446228,
-0.19836771488189697,
0.7654848098754883,
0.46912339329719543,
-0.3112705647945404,
-0.45386379957199097,
-0.760892391204834,
0.25378715991973877,
0.20752738416194916,
-0.563532292842865,
0.24982845783233643,
0.2724166810512543,
-0.22668740153312683,
0.019478481262922287,
0.3988153040409088,
-0.0851670578122139,
-0.42554301023483276,
0.16827993094921112,
0.2896510064601898,
0.028454532846808434,
-0.2332056760787964,
0.05821411684155464,
-0.03567253798246384,
0.30779409408569336,
0.1238408088684082,
0.35525763034820557,
0.04468109458684921,
-0.2899280786514282,
-0.3107079863548279,
0.604400098323822,
0.916997492313385,
-0.060036174952983856,
0.3821019232273102,
0.17735007405281067,
-0.4933682680130005,
0.14652571082115173,
-0.5864602327346802,
-0.29680001735687256,
-0.30621758103370667,
0.5682333707809448,
-0.12145402282476425,
-0.31790632009506226,
0.7402998805046082,
0.1549668163061142,
-0.04197714850306511,
0.20473136007785797,
0.4953209459781647,
-0.355828195810318,
1.0913500785827637,
0.5138152241706848,
0.03458520025014877,
0.11644446849822998,
-0.30060213804244995,
-0.04207910597324371,
-0.9158784747123718,
-0.3521876037120819,
-0.1530233472585678,
0.02631772868335247,
-0.2212260216474533,
-0.3576998710632324,
0.9001725316047668,
-0.5742799043655396,
0.6022018790245056,
0.0984060987830162,
-0.6550542116165161,
0.22563084959983826,
0.31138554215431213,
0.752723217010498,
0.5410543084144592,
-0.2070186585187912,
0.23942872881889343,
-0.10442735999822617,
-0.9127207398414612,
-0.0942174568772316,
1.2460647821426392,
0.38845178484916687,
0.83176589012146,
-0.08937516808509827,
0.5342400074005127,
0.3704109489917755,
0.15354017913341522,
-0.6525999903678894,
0.3706323206424713,
-0.36752596497535706,
-0.44493260979652405,
-0.10388610512018204,
-0.01756265014410019,
-0.5197407603263855,
-0.051683761179447174,
-0.26717180013656616,
-0.15026217699050903,
0.2570277154445648,
0.28136691451072693,
-0.7462557554244995,
0.16143770515918732,
-0.500139057636261,
0.11876579374074936,
0.031478401273489,
-0.11093184351921082,
-0.5466678738594055,
-1.0197564363479614,
0.43055298924446106,
0.18859907984733582,
0.4019962251186371,
0.23248831927776337,
0.03342261537909508,
0.5324106216430664,
-0.7226845622062683,
0.7373285293579102,
-0.21996915340423584,
0.3067084550857544,
0.139411062002182,
0.0031308357138186693,
0.4468376040458679,
-0.053625211119651794,
0.4164760410785675,
0.006073367316275835,
0.2945597469806671,
-0.3040271997451782,
-0.4418109655380249,
0.274957537651062,
-0.6918779015541077,
-0.1966853141784668,
-0.5241913795471191,
-1.0826120376586914,
-0.22162950038909912,
0.009318792261183262,
0.6698740124702454,
0.8604009747505188,
-0.32040929794311523,
-0.23394335806369781,
0.6304954886436462,
-0.34177306294441223,
0.18114310503005981,
0.4635013937950134,
-0.24054434895515442,
-0.5330976843833923,
0.8798177242279053,
0.3250417411327362,
0.5628745555877686,
0.6660933494567871,
0.05165602266788483,
-0.01890457421541214,
-0.6968768835067749,
-0.2074732780456543,
0.40847498178482056,
-0.6961953639984131,
-0.17987744510173798,
-0.8636602163314819,
-0.36925721168518066,
-0.43578997254371643,
-0.30485212802886963,
-0.3592544198036194,
-0.6188467741012573,
-0.09897901117801666,
0.2341446578502655,
0.2682648003101349,
0.9143044948577881,
-0.30252161622047424,
0.5022746920585632,
-0.8937348127365112,
0.3092908561229706,
0.1607418954372406,
0.03944011032581329,
0.07357890903949738,
-0.490546315908432,
-0.5281520485877991,
-0.10430442541837692,
-0.05659346655011177,
-0.6469531655311584,
0.3953996002674103,
-0.15644778311252594,
0.17902106046676636,
0.4040015935897827,
0.2921004295349121,
0.5079323053359985,
-0.05590289458632469,
0.3460785746574402,
0.26394274830818176,
-0.7645362019538879,
0.5395169854164124,
-0.6523478031158447,
0.7599929571151733,
0.45274898409843445,
0.09673310071229935,
-0.46482276916503906,
-0.7008276581764221,
-0.7891068458557129,
-0.8316810131072998,
0.8470385670661926,
0.04590308666229248,
-0.26216408610343933,
-0.012465178035199642,
0.1720055490732193,
-0.05693196505308151,
-0.1754871904850006,
-0.1329367607831955,
0.023681901395320892,
-0.18111152946949005,
-0.1685619205236435,
0.25973308086395264,
-0.5402928590774536,
-0.15511704981327057,
-0.16938404738903046,
0.24197711050510406,
-0.006473770830780268,
0.4263226091861725,
0.7550522089004517,
-0.37914028763771057,
-0.06764311343431473,
0.0789082944393158,
0.6580374240875244,
1.0170049667358398,
-0.6262395977973938,
0.1213066428899765,
0.32552370429039,
-0.7160592675209045,
-0.3346482217311859,
-0.07285568863153458,
-0.05450034141540527,
0.20384973287582397,
0.6991215348243713,
0.4405594766139984,
0.2165864259004593,
-0.4368646442890167,
0.6047295928001404,
-0.17446699738502502,
-0.09171368181705475,
-0.10505886375904083,
-0.058430079370737076,
-0.061712734401226044,
-0.01898191124200821,
0.618290364742279,
0.18226836621761322,
0.6270593404769897,
-0.21938958764076233,
0.426753431558609,
0.24189163744449615,
-0.6110377907752991,
-0.37850552797317505,
0.5453121662139893,
0.18225763738155365,
0.310538649559021,
0.4224525988101959,
0.33924174308776855,
-0.3618311583995819,
0.6523083448410034,
0.2517988979816437,
0.6804931163787842,
-0.2604927122592926,
0.13906997442245483,
0.6597017645835876,
0.17458683252334595,
-0.0360388346016407,
0.3064979314804077,
-0.06588929146528244,
-0.3720303475856781,
-0.501323938369751,
0.20939485728740692,
-0.7278614640235901,
-0.13227133452892303,
-1.5422543287277222,
0.4361436665058136,
-0.6894656419754028,
-0.20412805676460266,
0.038625020533800125,
-0.46909666061401367,
-0.3339715003967285,
0.5156465768814087,
0.03570687025785446,
0.9634930491447449,
-0.5187951326370239,
0.501014232635498,
0.5682293772697449,
-0.3788549602031708,
-0.5654020309448242,
-0.12335871160030365,
-0.1406872272491455,
-1.026232123374939,
0.30473509430885315,
0.06642521917819977,
-0.3168451488018036,
-0.03615444898605347,
-0.2778054177761078,
-0.6759756803512573,
0.9478517174720764,
0.022890787571668625,
-0.5410587787628174,
-0.18954795598983765,
0.23124925792217255,
0.4865328073501587,
-0.535057008266449,
0.6484329700469971,
0.5726918578147888,
0.11031489074230194,
0.22089524567127228,
-0.8527696132659912,
0.22537052631378174,
0.057827893644571304,
-0.21695321798324585,
0.06615489721298218,
-0.7002101540565491,
0.5350099802017212,
-0.803409993648529,
-0.09462187439203262,
-0.22634214162826538,
0.46020230650901794,
-0.0786246806383133,
0.2949419617652893,
0.42623987793922424,
0.4623749256134033,
0.42543596029281616,
-0.14900945127010345,
1.453445315361023,
-0.30102241039276123,
0.19447895884513855,
1.2219021320343018,
-0.0009615189046598971,
0.41035690903663635,
0.20786693692207336,
-0.2502795159816742,
0.30227571725845337,
0.34393876791000366,
0.09540186822414398,
0.6359348893165588,
-0.2592398226261139,
-0.19442614912986755,
-0.334629088640213,
-0.31637075543403625,
-0.5613484382629395,
0.41708996891975403,
0.3719422519207001,
-0.5202525854110718,
-0.5024204850196838,
0.053701311349868774,
0.18737474083900452,
-0.21544308960437775,
-0.41326871514320374,
1.0451008081436157,
-0.02178816683590412,
-0.6018909215927124,
0.38621845841407776,
-0.3541618287563324,
0.19917984306812286,
-0.49366438388824463,
0.032981984317302704,
-0.24315454065799713,
0.3038569986820221,
-0.307273268699646,
-0.7427498698234558,
0.5882436633110046,
-0.2545592784881592,
-0.47326233983039856,
-0.14807745814323425,
0.3865150511264801,
-0.2998034954071045,
-0.5177446007728577,
0.1470901519060135,
0.2371283918619156,
0.17534567415714264,
0.15726278722286224,
-0.23083963990211487,
0.09220314025878906,
0.11496057361364365,
0.11692176014184952,
0.3227338492870331,
0.1836400032043457,
0.0726008415222168,
0.6253211498260498,
0.2239917665719986,
0.2664385139942169,
-0.4150497317314148,
0.3126142919063568,
1.084607481956482,
-0.4610038697719574,
-0.5405755639076233,
-0.5255739092826843,
0.7296921014785767,
-0.21409159898757935,
-0.15040935575962067,
0.178937628865242,
0.6900542974472046,
0.2797068953514099,
-0.17468228936195374,
0.8757338523864746,
-0.05414805933833122,
1.0083057880401611,
-0.5554394125938416,
0.7337850332260132,
-0.3445739448070526,
0.2138211876153946,
-0.21112032234668732,
-0.2344711720943451,
-0.23530036211013794,
0.18552781641483307,
-0.21602357923984528,
0.02101879194378853,
0.7127260565757751,
0.5165156722068787,
-0.024443311616778374,
-0.09323026984930038,
0.2771446704864502,
0.26345857977867126,
0.16074199974536896,
0.8459534645080566,
0.6865583062171936,
-0.46251553297042847,
0.58632892370224,
-0.30956384539604187,
-0.6187736988067627,
-0.4106467664241791,
-0.48540472984313965,
-0.8467040061950684,
-0.42940250039100647,
-0.4776086211204529,
-0.42936140298843384,
-0.02076485939323902,
0.4080982506275177,
0.9251036047935486,
-0.7066173553466797,
-0.09180684387683868,
0.3548068404197693,
-0.264499306678772,
-0.17708437144756317,
-0.1753416657447815,
0.5849437713623047,
-0.35328423976898193,
-0.531126081943512,
0.052724532783031464,
0.4416307508945465,
0.10638906806707382,
0.04079935699701309,
0.18705308437347412,
0.12627211213111877,
0.0007388796075247228,
0.36263009905815125,
0.17119331657886505,
-0.43142828345298767,
-0.12584029138088226,
0.25311750173568726,
-0.1005588248372078,
0.263750821352005,
0.9241328835487366,
-0.7726930975914001,
0.8640519380569458,
0.2972799837589264,
0.2850978672504425,
0.8495752215385437,
0.24413451552391052,
0.8674302101135254,
-0.4253745973110199,
-0.08946633338928223,
0.3005349338054657,
0.2389908730983734,
0.47418200969696045,
-0.7464357018470764,
0.16787418723106384,
-0.16898629069328308,
-0.38407766819000244,
-0.6516860723495483,
0.00409532617777586,
-1.2339390516281128,
-0.2724916636943817,
0.6717954277992249,
-0.11791969835758209,
0.060433365404605865,
-0.1883596032857895,
-0.1805073469877243,
0.17527452111244202,
-0.3153242766857147,
0.7508625984191895,
0.4819423258304596,
-0.632777750492096,
-0.29780635237693787,
-0.2304488867521286,
0.5389387011528015,
0.3811635971069336,
-0.7262852787971497,
0.009725351817905903,
0.6102091670036316,
0.6172808408737183,
0.226154163479805,
0.767024040222168,
-0.5252105593681335,
0.852026641368866,
-0.18678894639015198,
0.11837199330329895,
-0.4857771694660187,
-0.25204765796661377,
-0.3089040219783783,
0.40338683128356934,
-0.1032351702451706,
-0.4134332239627838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06800v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06800v2
|
LLM-Generated Black-box Explanations Can Be Adversarially Helpful
| 2024-05-10T20:23:46 | 2024-05-29T15:18:59 |
Rohan Ajwani, Shashidhar Reddy Javaji, Frank Rudzicz, Zining Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are becoming vital tools that help us solve and
understand complex problems by acting as digital assistants. LLMs can generate
convincing explanations, even when only given the inputs and outputs of these
problems, i.e., in a ``black-box'' approach. However, our research uncovers a
hidden risk tied to this approach, which we call *adversarial helpfulness*.
This happens when an LLM's explanations make a wrong answer look right,
potentially leading people to trust incorrect solutions. In this paper, we show
that this issue affects not just humans, but also LLM evaluators. Digging
deeper, we identify and examine key persuasive strategies employed by LLMs. Our
findings reveal that these models employ strategies such as reframing the
questions, expressing an elevated level of confidence, and cherry-picking
evidence to paint misleading answers in a credible light. To examine if LLMs
are able to navigate complex-structured knowledge when generating adversarially
helpful explanations, we create a special task based on navigating through
graphs. Most LLMs are not able to find alternative paths along simple graphs,
indicating that their misleading explanations aren't produced by only logical
deductions using complex knowledge. These findings shed light on the
limitations of the black-box explanation setting and allow us to provide advice
on the safe usage of LLMs.
|
[
-0.2697877585887909,
-1.0256949663162231,
0.8880757093429565,
-0.01685311459004879,
-0.24549566209316254,
0.0638430044054985,
-0.09218743443489075,
-0.23637835681438446,
-0.21021321415901184,
0.49544650316238403,
-0.6797288656234741,
-0.28870683908462524,
-0.756132185459137,
-0.06761930137872696,
-0.38977959752082825,
1.1626014709472656,
0.003985569812357426,
0.07481024414300919,
-0.33833763003349304,
0.26062458753585815,
-0.4176059067249298,
-0.5864912271499634,
-0.6669371724128723,
-0.5963380336761475,
1.0018819570541382,
0.2734903395175934,
1.2076681852340698,
0.5868189930915833,
0.2525346875190735,
0.257411926984787,
-0.2320793867111206,
0.22244513034820557,
-0.8097180128097534,
0.11343389004468918,
-0.2545478940010071,
-0.8374562859535217,
-0.265241801738739,
0.012013460509479046,
0.2098507136106491,
0.8119831681251526,
-0.08918733149766922,
0.025763792917132378,
0.0988132655620575,
0.5746708512306213,
-0.5089418292045593,
-0.09494554996490479,
-0.779816210269928,
0.11786125600337982,
-0.24382749199867249,
-0.46900448203086853,
-0.4468623101711273,
-0.42080339789390564,
-0.07351995259523392,
-0.7251903414726257,
0.2424527257680893,
-0.07163342088460922,
0.6365088224411011,
0.5317820906639099,
-0.36729922890663147,
-0.49034568667411804,
-0.9757473468780518,
0.5391952991485596,
-0.4606349468231201,
-0.19869694113731384,
0.2574498951435089,
0.4180731773376465,
-0.5827376842498779,
-0.4785504937171936,
-0.5056588649749756,
-0.06276068091392517,
-0.0935053601861,
0.07895787805318832,
-0.49936506152153015,
0.052126649767160416,
0.2641485035419464,
0.024644967168569565,
-0.3769131600856781,
0.21471083164215088,
-0.36634451150894165,
-0.42925965785980225,
0.8142827153205872,
0.13428890705108643,
0.3774178624153137,
0.03982129693031311,
-0.3461892306804657,
-0.06617514789104462,
-1.1272327899932861,
0.024541353806853294,
0.64295494556427,
-0.029585974290966988,
0.11763112246990204,
0.6206960678100586,
0.22436779737472534,
0.6584451198577881,
0.0834633857011795,
-0.006565214600414038,
-0.28409135341644287,
-0.25714388489723206,
-0.15249496698379517,
0.09242187440395355,
0.7021040320396423,
0.3006155788898468,
0.668354868888855,
-0.3632369041442871,
-0.2165786176919937,
0.3081657886505127,
0.6834220886230469,
-0.4496174156665802,
-0.2856476902961731,
0.2717132270336151,
-0.2125800997018814,
-0.5888648629188538,
-0.17968858778476715,
-0.7130811214447021,
-0.9176336526870728,
0.06809161603450775,
0.5448813438415527,
-0.11524885147809982,
-0.15699610114097595,
0.1464538276195526,
-0.05340199917554855,
-0.15826287865638733,
0.4877747595310211,
-0.49100765585899353,
0.0791652500629425,
0.5919753909111023,
0.4455931782722473,
0.008796042762696743,
-0.07613218575716019,
-0.6159594058990479,
0.14468422532081604,
-0.5316072106361389,
0.7373454570770264,
-0.3707588315010071,
-0.5275776386260986,
0.1423850655555725,
0.04107580706477165,
0.40638434886932373,
-0.493621826171875,
0.41475287079811096,
-0.5090371370315552,
0.09980800747871399,
-0.36385977268218994,
-0.08769995719194412,
-0.45992839336395264,
0.2146996557712555,
-0.4184071719646454,
0.5143804550170898,
-0.25005972385406494,
-0.7777623534202576,
0.01753215864300728,
-0.5071567296981812,
-0.4682362675666809,
-0.021663926541805267,
-0.23821501433849335,
-0.4094158709049225,
0.19195879995822906,
0.29269155859947205,
0.5700435638427734,
-0.173134908080101,
0.3932073414325714,
-0.4832797646522522,
-0.4553629159927368,
0.809360146522522,
-0.8530482053756714,
0.9514718055725098,
0.2124536782503128,
-0.5351662635803223,
0.051383089274168015,
-0.5021361112594604,
-0.33301424980163574,
0.48605066537857056,
-0.22308385372161865,
-0.31754666566848755,
-0.10651247948408127,
-0.5161296129226685,
0.20967219769954681,
0.27664417028427124,
-0.2529054582118988,
-0.00545884296298027,
-0.3058445453643799,
0.22885653376579285,
1.1600171327590942,
0.13344478607177734,
0.237546905875206,
-0.3883744180202484,
0.9662893414497375,
0.057171374559402466,
0.12716084718704224,
-0.17170067131519318,
-0.5772391557693481,
-0.42779532074928284,
0.10733650624752045,
-0.050889089703559875,
0.49711087346076965,
-0.7942155599594116,
-0.08180057257413864,
0.05134178325533867,
-0.47069472074508667,
-0.6326059103012085,
0.2560044527053833,
0.6320391297340393,
0.49593016505241394,
0.07897082716226578,
0.20629996061325073,
-0.25564709305763245,
-0.9130887985229492,
-0.3311816155910492,
-0.02401299588382244,
0.05448739975690842,
0.3356474041938782,
0.3861128091812134,
-0.21298503875732422,
0.4672185480594635,
-0.5842311978340149,
0.13673171401023865,
-0.14318327605724335,
-0.09517961740493774,
-0.05006958916783333,
-0.05070585757493973,
0.2817133963108063,
-0.9430823922157288,
-0.11754783242940903,
-0.3262779712677002,
-0.7227357625961304,
-0.20787721872329712,
-0.3622819781303406,
-0.06648459285497665,
-0.1404108703136444,
0.3688991069793701,
-0.6015325784683228,
0.29162493348121643,
0.5765519142150879,
-0.38651078939437866,
0.7373706698417664,
-0.3013709485530853,
-0.353562593460083,
-0.9356825351715088,
-0.17400942742824554,
0.043082091957330704,
-0.18854565918445587,
-0.5761573910713196,
0.1636788696050644,
-0.24146020412445068,
-0.10166795551776886,
-0.3958871066570282,
0.48664379119873047,
-0.4193737804889679,
0.11384038627147675,
-0.2953789234161377,
0.5877327919006348,
0.09868098050355911,
0.322579562664032,
-0.4076870381832123,
0.7558397650718689,
0.6735885739326477,
-0.5336669683456421,
0.6067474484443665,
0.045096952468156815,
0.007587788626551628,
0.521903932094574,
-0.572966992855072,
0.1836758553981781,
-0.2233670949935913,
0.2278696894645691,
-1.288753867149353,
-0.02718024142086506,
0.3000461161136627,
-0.5369737148284912,
0.4219474792480469,
-0.08551553636789322,
-0.530162513256073,
-0.4059186279773712,
-0.30528807640075684,
0.16758720576763153,
0.29799598455429077,
-0.6222492456436157,
0.4520282447338104,
0.39273104071617126,
-0.14541040360927582,
-0.828380286693573,
-0.9834423661231995,
0.12968061864376068,
-0.4056551158428192,
-0.6198523044586182,
0.10619762539863586,
-0.16992296278476715,
-0.5125997066497803,
0.11041077226400375,
-0.28981444239616394,
0.1980273425579071,
0.6498006582260132,
0.5446521043777466,
0.3107227683067322,
-0.01508555468171835,
0.09938466548919678,
-0.3750280737876892,
-0.23596526682376862,
0.4488627314567566,
-0.05780550837516785,
0.31635212898254395,
0.035254254937171936,
-0.4967830777168274,
-0.18238835036754608,
0.23183180391788483,
0.49124059081077576,
-0.025143686681985855,
0.6975938677787781,
0.6899096369743347,
-0.28531402349472046,
-0.30867207050323486,
-0.5522933006286621,
-0.2912331819534302,
-0.507058322429657,
0.31894540786743164,
-0.20308715105056763,
-0.7044216394424438,
0.3816165030002594,
-0.08946074545383453,
0.03757130354642868,
0.17096908390522003,
0.5708644390106201,
-0.04263743758201599,
1.2664194107055664,
0.4477648437023163,
0.10517046600580215,
0.17560064792633057,
-0.3004964590072632,
0.40664374828338623,
-0.6621662974357605,
-0.3663986027240753,
-0.36237144470214844,
-0.2155429869890213,
-0.5557056665420532,
-0.31802359223365784,
0.3702894449234009,
-0.02633894793689251,
-0.08805675059556961,
-0.09703852236270905,
-0.6070176959037781,
0.2966243624687195,
0.545701265335083,
0.05186021700501442,
0.2370665818452835,
0.07070601731538773,
-0.031434062868356705,
0.14027053117752075,
-0.8815221190452576,
-0.6529767513275146,
1.2594642639160156,
0.5794073343276978,
1.138340711593628,
0.07868405431509018,
0.6581972241401672,
0.22749823331832886,
0.4188036024570465,
-0.8475815653800964,
0.6974241137504578,
-0.009679748676717281,
-0.5868926644325256,
-0.2338544726371765,
-0.47649213671684265,
-1.1209654808044434,
0.17115627229213715,
-0.32755187153816223,
-0.6174935102462769,
-0.036695513874292374,
0.2771390974521637,
-0.40098196268081665,
0.3221021592617035,
-0.7697032690048218,
0.6599817872047424,
-0.5093886852264404,
-0.3828939199447632,
-0.2157345414161682,
-0.3455376923084259,
0.4473506808280945,
-0.20553572475910187,
0.4336593449115753,
0.15354202687740326,
-0.00932165328413248,
0.6016044616699219,
-0.06685452163219452,
0.9843472242355347,
-0.30990421772003174,
-0.28992190957069397,
0.0992361307144165,
0.4255249798297882,
0.7625231146812439,
-0.06209711357951164,
-0.06708186864852905,
0.022899575531482697,
-0.41391420364379883,
-0.4398795962333679,
-0.8442923426628113,
0.8447278738021851,
-0.7832612991333008,
-1.286614179611206,
-0.23034024238586426,
-0.716540515422821,
-0.12300700694322586,
0.024169588461518288,
0.159407377243042,
0.3333985209465027,
0.010655898600816727,
0.26464763283729553,
0.879227876663208,
-0.3541024625301361,
0.036807406693696976,
0.46879446506500244,
0.009218589402735233,
-0.1275794953107834,
0.8366443514823914,
0.1396227926015854,
0.3887013792991638,
0.16001388430595398,
0.4448156952857971,
-0.4284207224845886,
-0.8994863629341125,
-0.3719384968280792,
0.3486015200614929,
-0.8592354655265808,
-0.15940901637077332,
-0.3647918105125427,
-0.03386353701353073,
-0.07145489752292633,
-0.4323441982269287,
-0.02203664742410183,
-0.432578444480896,
-0.4072623550891876,
-0.40650609135627747,
0.11041583120822906,
0.9499675035476685,
0.11947951465845108,
0.10070811212062836,
-0.36142757534980774,
0.38207828998565674,
0.6255361437797546,
-0.10066007822751999,
0.12544825673103333,
-0.3249659836292267,
-0.23809459805488586,
0.26150333881378174,
-0.5333495736122131,
-1.0857244729995728,
0.01728024333715439,
-0.3580586910247803,
0.8280177116394043,
0.5089350342750549,
0.1538633108139038,
0.6194018721580505,
-0.2625558376312256,
0.9331526160240173,
0.07680750638246536,
-0.46447551250457764,
0.41776490211486816,
-0.23223522305488586,
0.2945786118507385,
0.020357897505164146,
0.5332773923873901,
-0.2196855992078781,
-0.817387580871582,
-0.839300811290741,
-0.8228880167007446,
0.5104866623878479,
0.079053595662117,
0.15689484775066376,
0.14041590690612793,
0.485345721244812,
-0.052457164973020554,
0.21457020938396454,
-1.0197654962539673,
-0.5813552737236023,
-0.28543001413345337,
-0.06869325786828995,
-0.2176339328289032,
-0.464560329914093,
-0.7191115617752075,
0.4042016267776489,
0.6831727623939514,
-0.05023865029215813,
0.08095239847898483,
0.23535384237766266,
0.02233840711414814,
-0.513599157333374,
0.4596104323863983,
0.6433398723602295,
0.7109024524688721,
0.17104431986808777,
0.45354434847831726,
0.06850283592939377,
-0.11101207882165909,
0.22427251935005188,
0.3557390868663788,
-0.2018599957227707,
-0.2503626048564911,
0.4516334533691406,
0.586582362651825,
-0.020448142662644386,
-0.586301863193512,
0.48877474665641785,
-0.022991016507148743,
-0.24916590750217438,
-0.2536645531654358,
0.24381545186042786,
0.38063910603523254,
0.38082829117774963,
0.5114418864250183,
-0.008036147803068161,
-0.06531868129968643,
-0.7466197609901428,
-0.132050558924675,
0.934325635433197,
-0.19415660202503204,
-0.30886945128440857,
0.7492735981941223,
0.037659652531147,
-0.619746208190918,
0.0888679251074791,
-0.14448589086532593,
-0.5865866541862488,
0.546134352684021,
0.7020450830459595,
0.7118052840232849,
-0.18027269840240479,
0.40472766757011414,
-0.1334863007068634,
0.4133235812187195,
0.16267868876457214,
-0.0558992363512516,
0.06390462815761566,
-0.7277311682701111,
-0.3593301475048065,
-0.2586677670478821,
-0.4695419371128082,
0.45444607734680176,
-0.43178120255470276,
-0.10203801095485687,
-0.3536740243434906,
-0.034562863409519196,
0.2489686906337738,
0.04660223424434662,
-0.5882247686386108,
0.20056970417499542,
0.23558612167835236,
0.7777464389801025,
-0.793158233165741,
0.5011778473854065,
0.7719353437423706,
-0.2678723633289337,
-0.799504280090332,
0.22209390997886658,
0.161484032869339,
-1.0279061794281006,
0.5632670521736145,
-0.11718657612800598,
-0.43816182017326355,
-0.38811174035072327,
-0.6379141807556152,
-0.523776113986969,
0.9581488370895386,
0.6275843381881714,
-0.501359224319458,
-0.22890537977218628,
0.1532018482685089,
0.6397080421447754,
-0.2548227906227112,
0.0361400730907917,
0.2362247109413147,
0.6721183061599731,
0.02777962014079094,
-0.5746495723724365,
0.5275446772575378,
-0.02541915327310562,
0.022610483691096306,
-0.025248246267437935,
-0.4777965843677521,
0.5815011262893677,
-0.5798404216766357,
-0.1989695131778717,
-0.20135365426540375,
0.16138684749603271,
0.25639134645462036,
0.30419808626174927,
0.556455671787262,
0.21510973572731018,
0.8036746382713318,
-0.004126233514398336,
1.3447474241256714,
-0.1372680813074112,
-0.14655785262584686,
0.7832279801368713,
0.20451724529266357,
0.40495675802230835,
0.5174677968025208,
0.11369944363832474,
0.5443951487541199,
0.47215449810028076,
-0.11989100277423859,
0.3896465003490448,
0.4755672216415405,
-0.10062342882156372,
-0.381147176027298,
-0.08350057899951935,
-0.1414027363061905,
0.17859907448291779,
0.6043214797973633,
-0.37111350893974304,
-0.23250572383403778,
0.013970809057354927,
0.285994291305542,
0.3440609872341156,
-0.3753010034561157,
0.6902092695236206,
0.22308790683746338,
-0.7625716924667358,
0.8309382796287537,
-0.21803511679172516,
0.5386320352554321,
-0.6144474744796753,
-0.047377657145261765,
-0.003421386703848839,
0.23417767882347107,
-0.4009597599506378,
-1.0740853548049927,
0.2599823772907257,
-0.0008249647216871381,
0.021079571917653084,
-0.31794479489326477,
0.7911439538002014,
-0.31595152616500854,
-0.284465491771698,
0.39115476608276367,
0.4710221290588379,
0.055540502071380615,
-0.1527746468782425,
-0.8598641753196716,
-0.1665019989013672,
0.20255622267723083,
-0.27979573607444763,
0.4053788185119629,
0.58388352394104,
0.029455438256263733,
1.131325602531433,
0.7930378913879395,
0.4632798433303833,
-0.12894342839717865,
-0.12398001551628113,
0.9544997215270996,
-0.5171435475349426,
-0.2494877427816391,
-1.0198700428009033,
0.5903971195220947,
0.1295168548822403,
0.12586437165737152,
0.9642248749732971,
0.2807976007461548,
0.7928966879844666,
0.022574421018362045,
0.8534811735153198,
0.6452436447143555,
0.2546786069869995,
-0.5399751663208008,
0.5735269784927368,
-0.7237815260887146,
0.6393455862998962,
-0.08693192154169083,
-0.5447302460670471,
-0.23282790184020996,
0.35298430919647217,
-0.558761477470398,
-0.14366111159324646,
0.5508385896682739,
0.9659805297851562,
0.06364332139492035,
-0.14011250436306,
0.4238310754299164,
0.634736180305481,
0.4691837430000305,
0.5521805286407471,
0.8937996625900269,
0.0986376404762268,
1.2374229431152344,
-0.24385744333267212,
-0.1663798838853836,
-0.39454981684684753,
-0.8563621640205383,
-0.9775663614273071,
-0.2399507761001587,
-0.31062597036361694,
-0.5485094785690308,
0.3287864625453949,
0.3332265615463257,
0.5924615263938904,
-0.4240879416465759,
-0.02626553177833557,
-0.05231631547212601,
0.6798496842384338,
-0.07611382007598877,
-0.26353394985198975,
0.20932237803936005,
-0.053174495697021484,
-0.4614633321762085,
0.46176132559776306,
0.19508568942546844,
0.19386447966098785,
-0.8587513566017151,
0.06546804308891296,
0.13340935111045837,
0.20666292309761047,
0.3057433068752289,
0.07728016376495361,
-0.9562968015670776,
-0.2932107448577881,
-0.18040281534194946,
0.04625338688492775,
0.021254800260066986,
0.6906340718269348,
-0.5977090001106262,
0.6387966871261597,
0.21942083537578583,
0.6014025211334229,
0.2991943657398224,
0.04087221249938011,
0.8823866844177246,
-0.5283706784248352,
-0.024517502635717392,
0.2571951150894165,
0.33737385272979736,
0.6672146320343018,
-0.8525109887123108,
0.31132760643959045,
0.07530523836612701,
-0.5572406649589539,
-0.8782067894935608,
0.40955784916877747,
-0.5976302027702332,
-0.5001494288444519,
1.436194896697998,
-0.31950095295906067,
-0.3005518913269043,
-0.26875782012939453,
-0.39223119616508484,
0.1844674050807953,
-0.3376813232898712,
1.104913353919983,
0.8142032027244568,
-0.034059230238199234,
-0.1722719967365265,
-0.5656163692474365,
0.5926443934440613,
0.3103111684322357,
-0.6781399250030518,
0.17471212148666382,
0.2713903784751892,
0.3878788650035858,
0.39140239357948303,
0.4322914779186249,
-0.08245080709457397,
0.41710421442985535,
0.0027501194272190332,
-0.4474235475063324,
-0.5998883247375488,
-0.39144018292427063,
-0.5808954238891602,
0.220027357339859,
0.31222471594810486,
-0.0810176283121109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06772v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06772v1
|
CANAL -- Cyber Activity News Alerting Language Model: Empirical Approach vs. Expensive LLM
| 2024-05-10T18:57:35 | 2024-05-10T18:57:35 |
Urjitkumar Patel, Fang-Chun Yeh, Chinmay Gondhalekar
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, 68T50, 68T07 (Primary) 03B65, 91F20 (Secondary), I.2.7; I.2.1; I.5.1; I.5.2; I.5.4; H.3.3
|
In today's digital landscape, where cyber attacks have become the norm, the
detection of cyber attacks and threats is critically imperative across diverse
domains. Our research presents a new empirical framework for cyber threat
modeling, adept at parsing and categorizing cyber-related information from news
articles, enhancing real-time vigilance for market stakeholders. At the core of
this framework is a fine-tuned BERT model, which we call CANAL - Cyber Activity
News Alerting Language Model, tailored for cyber categorization using a novel
silver labeling approach powered by Random Forest. We benchmark CANAL against
larger, costlier LLMs, including GPT-4, LLaMA, and Zephyr, highlighting their
zero to few-shot learning in cyber news classification. CANAL demonstrates
superior performance by outperforming all other LLM counterparts in both
accuracy and cost-effectiveness. Furthermore, we introduce the Cyber Signal
Discovery module, a strategic component designed to efficiently detect emerging
cyber signals from news articles. Collectively, CANAL and Cyber Signal
Discovery module equip our framework to provide a robust and cost-effective
solution for businesses that require agile responses to cyber intelligence.
|
[
-0.1027059331536293,
-1.072358250617981,
0.2776990532875061,
0.41086545586586,
-0.43729284405708313,
0.33743610978126526,
0.11403129249811172,
-0.7639670372009277,
0.1960647702217102,
0.23761573433876038,
-0.3326893448829651,
-0.619401216506958,
-0.557833194732666,
-0.32670068740844727,
-0.8476012349128723,
0.9101687073707581,
0.41992080211639404,
-0.028606751933693886,
0.16765490174293518,
0.20762178301811218,
-0.43147051334381104,
-0.4784170687198639,
-0.7619534730911255,
0.11739767342805862,
0.4566665589809418,
0.04066796228289604,
0.278417706489563,
0.40403351187705994,
0.9216451644897461,
0.33864352107048035,
-0.23906786739826202,
-0.14033541083335876,
-0.35711485147476196,
-0.13977286219596863,
-0.04336925968527794,
-0.5090487003326416,
-0.7245103120803833,
-0.11255723983049393,
0.1778012067079544,
0.21203981339931488,
-0.13385021686553955,
0.2954501211643219,
-0.05096659064292908,
0.39043128490448,
-0.49526017904281616,
0.19072820246219635,
-1.1220890283584595,
-0.24760174751281738,
-0.3815908432006836,
-0.3524492383003235,
-0.5477270483970642,
-0.0705311968922615,
0.6035624146461487,
-0.36291611194610596,
0.18748539686203003,
0.31380411982536316,
0.8571059107780457,
-0.022341789677739143,
-0.47708064317703247,
-0.19734476506710052,
-0.8461294174194336,
0.5719362497329712,
-0.26449263095855713,
0.4971199929714203,
-0.05892927199602127,
0.3845941126346588,
0.03147142753005028,
-0.6483123302459717,
-0.12689174711704254,
0.13737322390079498,
0.4047459661960602,
0.3449779748916626,
-0.6708282828330994,
-0.06734340637922287,
-0.296528697013855,
0.212622731924057,
-0.649388313293457,
0.18675468862056732,
-0.7112141251564026,
-0.0695120319724083,
0.6590174436569214,
0.2803865969181061,
-0.07175084203481674,
0.17086966335773468,
-0.6768608689308167,
-0.09763782471418381,
-0.8560829758644104,
0.018163485452532768,
0.5169901251792908,
0.35695305466651917,
-0.49294403195381165,
0.05489944666624069,
-0.060159265995025635,
0.5978636741638184,
0.07991980016231537,
-0.4412105679512024,
0.1588880717754364,
-0.04037437587976456,
-0.2821061909198761,
0.2950921356678009,
0.5254626870155334,
0.44578054547309875,
-0.10687588900327682,
0.0937090590596199,
-0.3689884543418884,
0.020304810255765915,
0.7701493501663208,
-0.32510992884635925,
-0.14578568935394287,
0.18132078647613525,
-0.5468888878822327,
-0.6815477609634399,
-0.09199562668800354,
-0.9407356977462769,
-0.5631241798400879,
-0.17554251849651337,
0.3483976125717163,
-0.09750104695558548,
-0.4022673964500427,
0.297943651676178,
-0.19153697788715363,
0.3423852026462555,
0.6950373649597168,
-0.3726504147052765,
0.2588402032852173,
0.6940413117408752,
0.8105902671813965,
-0.1991758495569229,
0.24316386878490448,
-0.22646796703338623,
0.053552575409412384,
-0.2813250720500946,
0.8781622052192688,
0.01210877951234579,
-0.3235032856464386,
0.07477697730064392,
-0.3404201865196228,
0.07661549746990204,
-0.33858367800712585,
0.3266660273075104,
-0.9981855154037476,
-0.05997831001877785,
0.27159756422042847,
-0.15032367408275604,
-0.3140110671520233,
0.46537184715270996,
-0.5731230974197388,
0.5485155582427979,
0.14980316162109375,
-0.7951440215110779,
0.2734416127204895,
-0.6104266047477722,
-0.35735759139060974,
0.3671121597290039,
0.24179677665233612,
-0.46820497512817383,
0.12934821844100952,
0.009506848640739918,
0.3074171543121338,
-0.6051962375640869,
0.4168226420879364,
-0.5466415882110596,
0.06790146976709366,
0.16208171844482422,
-0.6292303204536438,
0.8578783869743347,
0.3842073082923889,
-0.2783656716346741,
0.21726372838020325,
-0.6662532091140747,
-0.5093130469322205,
0.1606329381465912,
-0.23160192370414734,
-0.1963416039943695,
0.20681878924369812,
0.15676020085811615,
-0.0265313982963562,
0.4014839828014374,
-0.6038461327552795,
-0.25581827759742737,
-0.38155245780944824,
0.252509206533432,
0.9496378898620605,
0.001449216390028596,
0.2454015612602234,
-0.34565746784210205,
0.5155956745147705,
0.06602107733488083,
0.36908867955207825,
-0.008268838748335838,
-0.5638566613197327,
-0.649443507194519,
-0.6575286984443665,
0.31146886944770813,
1.0670433044433594,
-0.16779102385044098,
0.32028573751449585,
-0.47046196460723877,
-0.6092475652694702,
-0.5307965874671936,
-0.017276117578148842,
0.03652030974626541,
0.3849025070667267,
0.35877230763435364,
-0.1524783968925476,
-0.765608012676239,
-0.7384416460990906,
-0.1121891662478447,
-0.5921909809112549,
0.1861463338136673,
0.1724439263343811,
0.18418088555335999,
-0.2936376631259918,
0.9627968668937683,
-0.5456048250198364,
-0.3062044680118561,
-0.5788757801055908,
0.47465553879737854,
0.4494304060935974,
0.009895562194287777,
0.6357066631317139,
-0.8348932862281799,
-0.323848158121109,
0.10603059828281403,
-0.567912757396698,
-0.2305552214384079,
-0.2721657156944275,
0.3286794424057007,
-0.016775332391262054,
0.5067119598388672,
-0.3594130873680115,
0.6740266680717468,
0.2485547661781311,
0.0656869187951088,
0.5391990542411804,
0.10550633817911148,
-0.2488943487405777,
-0.8401867151260376,
-0.02548794262111187,
0.21107009053230286,
-0.2695041000843048,
-0.6940202116966248,
-0.055322255939245224,
-0.22120091319084167,
-0.22179485857486725,
-0.6684668660163879,
0.5837211608886719,
-0.034801725298166275,
-0.1260981559753418,
-0.5374780893325806,
0.17222949862480164,
-0.2874118685722351,
0.28220170736312866,
-0.018285855650901794,
0.5795202255249023,
0.6453745365142822,
-0.5694819688796997,
0.44428640604019165,
-0.11579794436693192,
-0.39643770456314087,
0.45904627442359924,
-0.824911892414093,
-0.31038567423820496,
-0.17968522012233734,
0.21302928030490875,
-0.8437548875808716,
0.02659345604479313,
0.03769882395863533,
-0.562730073928833,
0.2602817416191101,
-0.15677185356616974,
-0.44937828183174133,
-0.4000290334224701,
-0.5857047438621521,
0.2779528796672821,
0.5365025997161865,
-0.44464877247810364,
0.5346848964691162,
0.7998844385147095,
-0.3246218264102936,
-0.33474448323249817,
-0.5211728811264038,
0.21022969484329224,
-0.6851766109466553,
-0.6708919405937195,
0.3920258581638336,
0.10861343145370483,
-0.5115881562232971,
-0.16123004257678986,
-0.33418816328048706,
-0.19904708862304688,
0.7573439478874207,
0.03566873446106911,
0.5599918961524963,
-0.21182340383529663,
-0.13815483450889587,
-0.42688167095184326,
-0.32178252935409546,
0.4577052891254425,
-0.2957712411880493,
0.4037366807460785,
-0.23737037181854248,
-0.24467600882053375,
-0.40014442801475525,
0.22070293128490448,
0.4848822355270386,
-0.25967997312545776,
0.38024377822875977,
0.6985777020454407,
-0.2655048966407776,
0.020238133147358894,
-0.36751511693000793,
-0.26683568954467773,
-0.5245209336280823,
0.3090433180332184,
-0.03966312110424042,
-0.9579302668571472,
0.34277448058128357,
-0.31837785243988037,
0.07607553899288177,
0.43515339493751526,
0.4688125550746918,
-0.3459315896034241,
1.0090422630310059,
0.820075511932373,
-0.5278636813163757,
0.6213487386703491,
-0.18542760610580444,
0.7368978261947632,
-0.5405487418174744,
-0.08533287793397903,
-0.41521939635276794,
-0.14746327698230743,
-0.7068288326263428,
0.13630884885787964,
0.7848854660987854,
0.1364814192056656,
-0.08732131123542786,
0.5365665555000305,
-0.3028952181339264,
0.0024636751040816307,
0.6116229891777039,
0.06772095710039139,
0.08595464378595352,
0.13416846096515656,
0.021144943311810493,
0.34370163083076477,
-0.7303048372268677,
-0.44113126397132874,
1.2874435186386108,
0.6099042296409607,
0.9833182692527771,
0.39460766315460205,
0.48490801453590393,
0.6589986681938171,
0.46182262897491455,
-0.6366426348686218,
0.4667545258998871,
0.09968563169240952,
-0.8458210825920105,
0.07277493923902512,
-0.1741013377904892,
-1.2841392755508423,
0.07295767962932587,
-0.2591371238231659,
-1.2499066591262817,
0.10209742188453674,
0.10487902909517288,
-0.4058687686920166,
0.32586967945098877,
-0.3424704372882843,
0.47794151306152344,
-0.4299349784851074,
-0.2623741626739502,
-0.6256857514381409,
-0.5888506174087524,
0.46617186069488525,
-0.2829403579235077,
0.5487513542175293,
-0.1435335874557495,
-0.036323823034763336,
0.5256797671318054,
0.09938687086105347,
1.1696969270706177,
0.19774074852466583,
-0.08558954298496246,
0.5306968092918396,
-0.050635483115911484,
0.5401822328567505,
0.3107546269893646,
0.34063273668289185,
0.2051217406988144,
-0.5054818987846375,
-0.07593924552202225,
-0.07306616753339767,
0.4382017254829407,
-0.7975842952728271,
-0.8881387114524841,
-0.7981898784637451,
-0.5135994553565979,
0.05127585306763649,
0.09485430270433426,
-0.01063732709735632,
0.4755939245223999,
-0.1463979333639145,
0.34070172905921936,
0.849923312664032,
-0.1578262448310852,
0.5130892395973206,
0.6853858828544617,
-0.1625494360923767,
-0.5381165742874146,
0.8905390501022339,
-0.08611886203289032,
-0.04098387435078621,
0.8122260570526123,
-0.09223586320877075,
-0.21656465530395508,
-0.9292619824409485,
0.05957585200667381,
-0.08937183022499084,
-0.4365873336791992,
-0.529346227645874,
-0.7179921865463257,
-0.4572235941886902,
-0.45782706141471863,
-0.3427741527557373,
-0.2163366824388504,
-0.04308556765317917,
-0.3029854893684387,
-0.21398016810417175,
0.3647328317165375,
0.6256380677223206,
-0.05152193829417229,
0.7865318059921265,
-0.8815200328826904,
0.2262398600578308,
0.36393749713897705,
0.03239940479397774,
-0.23538453876972198,
-0.3410068154335022,
-0.3824656009674072,
0.002685282612219453,
-0.7783885598182678,
-0.9274080395698547,
0.5720147490501404,
-0.2918745279312134,
0.6655515432357788,
0.598833441734314,
0.2070429027080536,
0.4930237829685211,
-0.18061454594135284,
0.7419551014900208,
0.26206445693969727,
-0.9619390368461609,
0.5212276577949524,
-0.7240285277366638,
0.19951678812503815,
0.14123627543449402,
0.3883107602596283,
-0.25027918815612793,
-0.2757534384727478,
-0.9301348924636841,
-1.10088312625885,
0.48174723982810974,
0.020484628155827522,
0.005035084206610918,
-0.22780728340148926,
-0.39926156401634216,
-0.4208841025829315,
0.2849539816379547,
-1.038454532623291,
0.03182283416390419,
0.028630923479795456,
-0.11293673515319824,
0.3249356150627136,
-0.19892925024032593,
-0.16078951954841614,
-0.05837779864668846,
0.7731936573982239,
-0.08277198672294617,
0.781284511089325,
0.005253791343420744,
-0.24769850075244904,
0.08429624140262604,
0.21556569635868073,
0.6546704769134521,
0.6120065450668335,
-0.39930662512779236,
0.09648413956165314,
0.432004451751709,
-0.47610777616500854,
-0.05506201088428497,
-0.06509371101856232,
-0.009505758062005043,
0.01310836523771286,
0.757542610168457,
0.6581457853317261,
0.12233923375606537,
-0.7933335304260254,
0.7483375668525696,
0.10699239373207092,
-0.05500374734401703,
-0.4747697412967682,
-0.02461814321577549,
-0.15058034658432007,
0.3679887056350708,
0.5587915182113647,
0.0795060396194458,
0.2764975428581238,
-0.40814095735549927,
0.018433963879942894,
0.5232163667678833,
-0.4502740800380707,
-0.42998769879341125,
0.6186608672142029,
0.39564499258995056,
-0.32632604241371155,
0.46052461862564087,
-0.267776757478714,
-0.7620134949684143,
0.7128618359565735,
0.6004152894020081,
1.0820120573043823,
-0.2109568566083908,
0.024433838203549385,
-0.08220349997282028,
0.7339583039283752,
0.21032185852527618,
0.4372202157974243,
0.2662583589553833,
-0.8005540370941162,
-0.14424245059490204,
-0.41351473331451416,
-0.2045067548751831,
0.5853899121284485,
-0.441841721534729,
0.716358482837677,
-0.6633004546165466,
-0.2846933603286743,
0.10015632212162018,
-0.17020085453987122,
-0.4575386643409729,
0.1512497514486313,
0.2740350067615509,
1.0921522378921509,
-0.7345581650733948,
0.6583659052848816,
0.6027805805206299,
0.16792084276676178,
-0.15554484724998474,
-0.21588608622550964,
0.553004801273346,
-0.6783869862556458,
0.6414609551429749,
0.3182657063007355,
-0.025207553058862686,
-0.17523281276226044,
-0.44155001640319824,
-0.9126107096672058,
1.212293028831482,
0.1473904401063919,
-0.39616310596466064,
0.32543739676475525,
0.1707097440958023,
0.5660954117774963,
-0.5687966346740723,
0.1414148211479187,
0.1684235781431198,
0.30562663078308105,
-0.2637390196323395,
-0.7542962431907654,
-0.5717589259147644,
-0.22293919324874878,
-0.07004868239164352,
0.39156702160835266,
-0.6216968297958374,
0.7311398983001709,
0.08580441027879715,
-0.20703080296516418,
-0.30268770456314087,
0.6417739391326904,
0.16096507012844086,
0.7250856757164001,
0.4724489450454712,
0.6282973289489746,
0.25284138321876526,
-0.027197016403079033,
0.7605924606323242,
-0.5609819889068604,
0.1866452991962433,
0.917011559009552,
-0.24698951840400696,
0.6777244806289673,
0.2605780065059662,
-0.25633201003074646,
0.3181828260421753,
0.7148922681808472,
-0.089509017765522,
0.8911973237991333,
0.2994385361671448,
-0.43219441175460815,
-0.06818611919879913,
-0.24576188623905182,
-0.15044569969177246,
0.5185645818710327,
0.6942755579948425,
-0.21767978370189667,
-0.4937267303466797,
-0.06996676325798035,
0.15076859295368195,
-0.22485055029392242,
-0.4428286552429199,
0.8437150120735168,
-0.03758702054619789,
-0.14055125415325165,
0.20851550996303558,
0.3461582362651825,
0.5967748761177063,
-0.7310964465141296,
0.3174407482147217,
0.06238241866230965,
0.28605303168296814,
0.11111760139465332,
-0.5269123315811157,
0.4927166700363159,
0.16124022006988525,
-0.0696384534239769,
-0.36825990676879883,
0.8984901905059814,
0.017141062766313553,
-0.28501707315444946,
0.45839494466781616,
0.30006319284439087,
-0.0064720269292593,
0.13222825527191162,
-0.8369353413581848,
0.039098046720027924,
-0.08279440551996231,
0.013380187563598156,
0.3480469584465027,
0.16928686201572418,
-0.30656692385673523,
0.8156555891036987,
0.7937622666358948,
-0.003179703839123249,
0.06001868098974228,
-0.346421480178833,
0.7572563886642456,
-0.39567679166793823,
-0.5943803191184998,
-0.6732006072998047,
0.5044225454330444,
-0.3603162467479706,
-0.45949965715408325,
0.5507429242134094,
0.6192652583122253,
0.777338445186615,
-0.042011652141809464,
0.7388383150100708,
0.03020951710641384,
0.2634795308113098,
-0.18287280201911926,
0.34220805764198303,
-0.2459813803434372,
0.8247566819190979,
-0.12623819708824158,
-0.6634920835494995,
-0.23673655092716217,
0.30815640091896057,
-0.34586822986602783,
-0.38105863332748413,
0.629252016544342,
0.7861166000366211,
-0.10956966131925583,
0.2302912324666977,
0.1069042831659317,
0.10260871797800064,
0.3215561509132385,
0.22507651150226593,
0.7426194548606873,
-0.3039853870868683,
0.562355637550354,
-0.05478397384285927,
-0.3096652328968048,
-0.5241753458976746,
-0.9478167295455933,
-0.8006883263587952,
-0.39100250601768494,
-0.4098972678184509,
-0.1262141466140747,
0.3252391219139099,
0.9373600482940674,
0.7698472142219543,
-0.793703556060791,
-0.4429605305194855,
-0.20826515555381775,
0.2549625635147095,
-0.337517112493515,
-0.2748517096042633,
0.05143330618739128,
-0.5827539563179016,
-0.24347764253616333,
0.4289073646068573,
0.6551287770271301,
0.16899403929710388,
-0.1972954273223877,
0.31733131408691406,
-0.4739069938659668,
0.3067471981048584,
0.658876359462738,
-0.052929189056158066,
-0.49222832918167114,
-0.23256070911884308,
0.20852252840995789,
-0.15412366390228271,
-0.1457756608724594,
0.5252590179443359,
-0.5550317168235779,
0.0014880587114021182,
0.7771039009094238,
0.9072991609573364,
0.5242165327072144,
-0.3698579967021942,
0.6067991256713867,
-0.72215336561203,
0.1330772042274475,
0.1471739411354065,
0.413241982460022,
-0.00933881662786007,
-0.4545689821243286,
0.7153825759887695,
0.4986459016799927,
-0.30287083983421326,
-0.840183675289154,
0.17537923157215118,
-1.049966812133789,
-0.4449431896209717,
0.8598375916481018,
-0.2174934297800064,
-0.35508015751838684,
-0.4069547653198242,
0.05882936343550682,
-0.03938814252614975,
-0.4616445302963257,
1.0665665864944458,
0.49792662262916565,
0.3405025601387024,
-0.086174376308918,
-0.4666726887226105,
0.16553530097007751,
0.042966585606336594,
-0.874719500541687,
-0.08639226108789444,
0.07399554550647736,
-0.029011523351073265,
0.41859322786331177,
0.22377555072307587,
-0.10578368604183197,
0.5185543894767761,
-0.11453276872634888,
-0.0660686194896698,
0.16823381185531616,
-0.7952595353126526,
-0.24400588870048523,
0.23244929313659668,
-0.2680686414241791,
-0.16559861600399017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06762v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06762v1
|
LIVE: LaTex Interactive Visual Editing
| 2024-05-10T18:28:00 | 2024-05-10T18:28:00 |
Jinwei Lin
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
LaTex coding is one of the main methods of writing an academic paper. When
writing a paper, abundant proper visual or graphic components will represent
more information volume than the textual data. However, most of the
implementation of LaTex graphic items are designed as static items that have
some weaknesses in representing more informative figures or tables with an
interactive reading experience. To address this problem, we propose LIVE, a
novel design methods idea to design interactive LaTex graphic items. To make a
lucid representation of the main idea of LIVE, we designed several novels
representing implementations that are interactive and enough explanation for
the basic level principles. Using LIVE can design more graphic items, which we
call the Gitems, and easily and automatically get the relationship of the
mutual application of a specific range of papers, which will add more vitality
and performance factors into writing of traditional papers especially the
review papers. For vividly representing the functions of LIVE, we use the
papers from NeRF as the example reference papers. The code of the
implementation project is open source.
|
[
-0.394093781709671,
-1.0867489576339722,
0.46291282773017883,
0.038561925292015076,
-0.4516766369342804,
0.5347597599029541,
-0.22164224088191986,
-0.6692796945571899,
0.6945837736129761,
0.17958074808120728,
-0.3788265883922577,
-0.4815906882286072,
-0.24306556582450867,
-0.0044108484871685505,
-0.09069844335317612,
0.8197497725486755,
-0.27407965064048767,
-0.3356708288192749,
-0.1118612289428711,
-0.21311932802200317,
-0.44639503955841064,
-0.08241330087184906,
-0.7058746814727783,
0.3039441704750061,
0.7375257015228271,
0.32878074049949646,
0.9521922469139099,
0.35962796211242676,
0.5496796369552612,
0.38817235827445984,
-0.22175799310207367,
0.1853000819683075,
-0.46185728907585144,
0.15222014486789703,
0.2349979281425476,
-0.3985140323638916,
-0.9176963567733765,
-0.03954286128282547,
0.4635922610759735,
0.21852660179138184,
0.23152442276477814,
0.06943793594837189,
0.1062159463763237,
0.31278344988822937,
-0.5272840261459351,
0.04810996353626251,
0.2458781898021698,
0.2640650272369385,
-0.1056351363658905,
-0.15186382830142975,
-0.33703380823135376,
-0.8041898608207703,
-0.3492151200771332,
-1.1907134056091309,
-0.26352840662002563,
-0.3123721182346344,
0.8494700193405151,
0.24565888941287994,
-0.10468516498804092,
-0.08684521168470383,
-0.8949441313743591,
0.2932157516479492,
-0.8391116261482239,
0.07443472743034363,
-0.21768607199192047,
0.46618103981018066,
-0.03206983581185341,
-0.8667925000190735,
-0.588286817073822,
-0.007742877583950758,
-0.08107168227434158,
0.5503519177436829,
-0.11000233143568039,
0.06482386589050293,
0.49717503786087036,
0.4258788824081421,
-0.33235466480255127,
-0.3331742584705353,
-0.23678044974803925,
0.2963540554046631,
0.5690698027610779,
0.1446596384048462,
0.8136194348335266,
0.2601296901702881,
-0.029859095811843872,
-0.08626608550548553,
-0.5042104721069336,
0.0021337501239031553,
0.30831146240234375,
-0.2377358376979828,
-0.40384045243263245,
0.4820198714733124,
-0.034292712807655334,
0.7313668727874756,
-0.19038209319114685,
-0.06412060558795929,
0.08226770907640457,
-0.37409257888793945,
-0.06436972320079803,
-0.46853238344192505,
0.2538805902004242,
0.6381116509437561,
0.41877228021621704,
0.01553705520927906,
-0.2363855093717575,
0.14963741600513458,
0.5390191078186035,
-0.5718080401420593,
-0.23765313625335693,
0.09495168179273605,
-0.6100737452507019,
-0.6130917072296143,
-0.06635402143001556,
-0.9164256453514099,
-0.302503764629364,
-0.584374189376831,
0.6033569574356079,
-0.2693912982940674,
-0.35652536153793335,
-0.22858671844005585,
-0.29370877146720886,
-0.3171471655368805,
1.0739037990570068,
-0.3855949640274048,
0.35667684674263,
0.4879467487335205,
0.8712314963340759,
-0.0010944505920633674,
-0.14433810114860535,
-0.670264720916748,
0.16335757076740265,
-0.28618618845939636,
1.0442198514938354,
-0.8188761472702026,
-0.41516175866127014,
0.16028352081775665,
0.009603467769920826,
0.41377294063568115,
-0.09288184344768524,
0.21663334965705872,
-0.6089110970497131,
0.0737283006310463,
-0.1653214395046234,
-0.3854201138019562,
-0.18335844576358795,
0.002668139059096575,
-0.8044431209564209,
0.7860345244407654,
0.19427600502967834,
-0.903903067111969,
0.5329494476318359,
-0.8759809732437134,
-0.38460373878479004,
0.6125754117965698,
-0.4276639521121979,
-0.5013478994369507,
0.4023240804672241,
0.006997303571552038,
0.11760426312685013,
0.5066532492637634,
-0.2728937268257141,
-0.36542776226997375,
-0.6616324186325073,
0.1414424031972885,
0.07250780612230301,
0.4253709018230438,
0.2565983533859253,
-0.19847647845745087,
0.4440379738807678,
-0.8929304480552673,
0.1306457668542862,
0.10836485028266907,
-0.5590188503265381,
-0.6008276343345642,
0.3759170174598694,
0.45529860258102417,
-0.24154965579509735,
0.2171090543270111,
-0.3806726038455963,
0.6642981171607971,
0.05413961037993431,
0.18907439708709717,
0.47396084666252136,
0.3770265281200409,
0.47735026478767395,
-0.4009000360965729,
0.8176445364952087,
-0.5121276378631592,
0.3946315050125122,
-0.34628215432167053,
-0.5809019804000854,
-0.665614902973175,
-0.07174055278301239,
0.387589693069458,
0.3980679214000702,
-0.8627117872238159,
-0.2384030818939209,
-0.0018347329460084438,
-0.3555442988872528,
-0.0712602436542511,
-0.13113626837730408,
0.2919829785823822,
0.14648759365081787,
0.20919175446033478,
-0.1849512755870819,
-0.34108293056488037,
-0.5599023699760437,
-0.17102104425430298,
0.20555037260055542,
-0.14907434582710266,
0.046494290232658386,
0.322480171918869,
-0.2440718412399292,
0.7576765418052673,
-0.8610645532608032,
0.07645611464977264,
-0.0029411043506115675,
0.3981599509716034,
0.10984568297863007,
0.45828893780708313,
0.8815242648124695,
-0.6238178014755249,
-0.7019787430763245,
0.042627088725566864,
-0.7952154278755188,
-0.15760537981987,
-0.30243900418281555,
-0.1579941362142563,
0.13518120348453522,
0.4667333960533142,
0.046355072408914566,
1.0927292108535767,
0.165817528963089,
-0.39161577820777893,
0.4236331582069397,
-0.5486775040626526,
0.24572815001010895,
-0.8967120051383972,
0.10422489792108536,
-0.14397427439689636,
-0.1714133471250534,
-0.42010658979415894,
0.48195743560791016,
0.15969419479370117,
-0.5367051362991333,
-0.15338419377803802,
0.58866947889328,
-0.8629672527313232,
0.27256205677986145,
-0.4760796129703522,
0.1571868360042572,
0.261525422334671,
0.3189813792705536,
0.1568494290113449,
0.807034432888031,
0.10722383111715317,
-0.4459053575992584,
0.45066115260124207,
0.18321897089481354,
-0.21698297560214996,
0.9013062119483948,
-0.7706101536750793,
0.12229322642087936,
-0.27545857429504395,
0.010612821206450462,
-0.8575850129127502,
-0.21604475378990173,
0.12957526743412018,
-0.31601589918136597,
0.3866496980190277,
-0.08771149069070816,
-0.4013082981109619,
-0.23526641726493835,
-0.4782417118549347,
0.0870414450764656,
0.4444569945335388,
-0.21547335386276245,
0.669671356678009,
0.5286689400672913,
-0.5223636627197266,
-0.18883806467056274,
-0.43113061785697937,
0.16360323131084442,
-0.1334797888994217,
-0.6829684972763062,
0.31169867515563965,
-0.37669941782951355,
-0.5234610438346863,
0.2493259161710739,
0.08388172090053558,
0.16152876615524292,
0.10004834830760956,
0.4185442328453064,
0.2997892200946808,
-0.24082885682582855,
0.10162567347288132,
0.03678470849990845,
-0.4214063286781311,
-0.3247644007205963,
0.08994399756193161,
-0.12790390849113464,
0.031278885900974274,
-0.2606084942817688,
-0.20514829456806183,
0.8582538962364197,
0.5463069081306458,
-0.09907618910074234,
0.17922714352607727,
0.31438103318214417,
-0.6010372638702393,
-0.19022788107395172,
-0.3817536234855652,
0.2843990921974182,
-0.49923446774482727,
-0.005040271207690239,
-0.4006401598453522,
-0.559438943862915,
0.5813602805137634,
-0.19352729618549347,
0.5583242177963257,
0.03201378881931305,
0.10489187389612198,
-0.2794811725616455,
0.7042309045791626,
1.012608289718628,
0.3723801076412201,
0.7624693512916565,
-0.17819084227085114,
-0.08058913797140121,
-0.7575302124023438,
-0.1386336237192154,
-0.4748515486717224,
-0.6146950721740723,
-0.14220206439495087,
-0.5390554666519165,
0.5870898962020874,
0.14424791932106018,
-0.11894461512565613,
0.38839954137802124,
-0.8398175239562988,
0.5173904895782471,
0.5626913905143738,
0.2058994472026825,
0.38192451000213623,
0.14873772859573364,
-0.3816993832588196,
-0.31196120381355286,
-0.31097540259361267,
-0.7274659872055054,
0.6071950793266296,
0.25493091344833374,
1.3982126712799072,
-0.004718754440546036,
0.44717490673065186,
0.41287174820899963,
0.45696863532066345,
-0.5220666527748108,
0.33627793192863464,
0.11742732673883438,
-0.3691348135471344,
-0.24684962630271912,
0.1887674480676651,
-0.6148143410682678,
-0.3324294686317444,
-0.4301997125148773,
-0.7711195349693298,
0.49452731013298035,
0.13019435107707977,
-0.58195561170578,
0.32127314805984497,
-0.8222017288208008,
0.7380018830299377,
-0.35558342933654785,
-0.746590793132782,
-0.1317979395389557,
-0.32650622725486755,
-0.18071837723255157,
0.0802469253540039,
0.34597742557525635,
0.3549513518810272,
-0.2403775006532669,
0.7209389209747314,
-0.6682211756706238,
0.7606080770492554,
0.026888970285654068,
-0.08093657344579697,
0.4682713747024536,
0.3316948711872101,
0.7127476930618286,
0.5635043978691101,
-0.06982602924108505,
-0.26092714071273804,
0.15983301401138306,
-0.27200624346733093,
-0.676900327205658,
0.535969078540802,
-0.6495026350021362,
-0.3210190534591675,
-0.5048913359642029,
-0.13465873897075653,
0.2289300411939621,
0.2683207094669342,
0.07754795998334885,
0.7609179019927979,
-0.45808145403862,
0.09392701834440231,
0.34387901425361633,
-0.3512938916683197,
0.6095702648162842,
0.5491501092910767,
-0.5111892223358154,
-0.9179772734642029,
0.7474084496498108,
0.5010745525360107,
0.1750587821006775,
0.5549614429473877,
-0.09681335091590881,
0.2150987982749939,
-0.5556533932685852,
-0.7370714545249939,
-0.005588066764175892,
-0.7514415979385376,
0.028640804812312126,
-0.7418882846832275,
-0.1608857959508896,
-0.18318401277065277,
-0.9969614744186401,
0.06158323958516121,
-0.2883435785770416,
-0.37424105405807495,
0.19092883169651031,
0.48891448974609375,
1.1221219301223755,
-0.30197009444236755,
0.4435017704963684,
-0.6796388626098633,
0.6322421431541443,
0.5457445383071899,
0.7595535516738892,
-0.06200670078396797,
0.007087366655468941,
-0.3201388716697693,
-0.11885590851306915,
-0.3630441129207611,
-1.1889293193817139,
0.32929256558418274,
-0.19058750569820404,
0.643595814704895,
0.6508054137229919,
-0.0667574405670166,
0.6486586332321167,
-0.46781572699546814,
0.5956364274024963,
-0.14422737061977386,
-0.7352110743522644,
0.7397681474685669,
-0.5328772664070129,
0.5053186416625977,
0.6264082193374634,
0.3149571120738983,
-0.8164798021316528,
-0.24797257781028748,
-0.912929356098175,
-0.538524329662323,
0.46575257182121277,
0.20852357149124146,
0.04940234124660492,
0.23877207934856415,
0.410534143447876,
0.21528445184230804,
0.27718260884284973,
-0.6137543320655823,
-0.03409012779593468,
-0.16102372109889984,
0.2639794945716858,
0.04876350611448288,
-0.5523415803909302,
-0.2240215241909027,
-0.24118641018867493,
0.5292642712593079,
-0.15448874235153198,
0.5835778713226318,
0.10418883711099625,
0.1453266739845276,
-0.2670007348060608,
0.17817887663841248,
0.7394329905509949,
0.8055884838104248,
-0.4761749804019928,
0.22196665406227112,
0.0695115327835083,
-0.7100006937980652,
-0.08095090091228485,
-0.24097925424575806,
-0.6007741093635559,
0.18464231491088867,
0.3828369975090027,
0.5395082831382751,
0.27549460530281067,
-0.25514739751815796,
0.32425710558891296,
-0.41785743832588196,
0.11433655768632889,
-0.5708125829696655,
0.28505268692970276,
0.21306303143501282,
0.21165218949317932,
0.1753426492214203,
0.13882271945476532,
-0.05474831536412239,
-0.5226555466651917,
0.25341475009918213,
0.22195100784301758,
-0.5155810117721558,
-0.4214594066143036,
1.108319640159607,
0.6060822010040283,
-0.9239177703857422,
0.2554517388343811,
-0.22961947321891785,
-0.24777430295944214,
0.7653447389602661,
0.501663863658905,
0.6499781608581543,
0.20003078877925873,
0.3859195411205292,
0.3478592336177826,
0.2271735966205597,
0.4705008268356323,
0.8209062814712524,
-0.13486146926879883,
-0.04378250241279602,
-0.5312649011611938,
-0.5635172128677368,
-0.7738346457481384,
0.1722070574760437,
-0.2629004120826721,
0.8403329253196716,
-0.6306177973747253,
0.13044455647468567,
0.07063350081443787,
0.05101744458079338,
-0.17208950221538544,
0.2569673955440521,
0.161778524518013,
1.080452561378479,
-0.5658077001571655,
0.5127216577529907,
1.1361854076385498,
-0.5958763360977173,
-0.5577085614204407,
-0.020036082714796066,
0.2506718635559082,
-0.26746490597724915,
0.3693684935569763,
-0.2546331286430359,
0.23621933162212372,
0.022030770778656006,
-0.7441667914390564,
-0.6702584624290466,
0.726409912109375,
-0.04870159178972244,
-0.39590758085250854,
0.02026224322617054,
-0.3555045425891876,
0.6097878217697144,
-0.373818576335907,
0.6522858738899231,
-0.3176366686820984,
0.7085393071174622,
0.14701686799526215,
-0.46456286311149597,
0.08657926321029663,
-0.9171546697616577,
-0.10911491513252258,
0.18444998562335968,
-0.6944968700408936,
0.789480447769165,
-0.1530228853225708,
-0.3667878210544586,
-0.16578245162963867,
0.508435845375061,
-0.009688337333500385,
0.40783923864364624,
0.19559791684150696,
0.41049206256866455,
0.4622027277946472,
-0.13303512334823608,
0.9249439835548401,
-0.14774416387081146,
0.06943972408771515,
1.16740882396698,
0.03837602213025093,
0.630004346370697,
0.10113980621099472,
-0.2370235174894333,
0.5204416513442993,
0.5066935420036316,
-0.07930447906255722,
0.24075108766555786,
0.2176777720451355,
-0.4878438413143158,
0.028225155547261238,
0.08731400966644287,
-0.8370963335037231,
-0.04220440983772278,
0.3240518569946289,
0.00257851998321712,
-0.38511478900909424,
0.12046495825052261,
0.42304930090904236,
0.2753068208694458,
0.03423177823424339,
0.6834928393363953,
-0.13691379129886627,
-0.41323456168174744,
0.3179607689380646,
0.010126584209501743,
0.5754437446594238,
-0.4926089942455292,
-0.5416544675827026,
-0.2864959239959717,
-0.08671420067548752,
-0.25540611147880554,
-0.8800320625305176,
0.4933793246746063,
-0.14822585880756378,
0.0789104774594307,
-0.4196580946445465,
0.9542293548583984,
0.23216906189918518,
-0.5403077006340027,
0.04869717359542847,
0.2774174213409424,
0.07941623032093048,
-0.04074757546186447,
-0.4921363592147827,
0.23227238655090332,
-0.22083614766597748,
-0.2338876873254776,
0.03762468323111534,
0.6161190867424011,
-0.05403967946767807,
0.30851978063583374,
0.5523713827133179,
0.2920337915420532,
-0.03322244808077812,
-0.009960465133190155,
1.0726975202560425,
-0.7879595160484314,
-0.7462459802627563,
-0.2952999472618103,
0.7155067920684814,
-0.44348594546318054,
-0.3007165491580963,
0.5575453639030457,
0.6612070798873901,
0.5900542736053467,
-0.35999760031700134,
0.9654645919799805,
-0.2067345231771469,
0.3126713037490845,
-0.2134370356798172,
1.0913766622543335,
-0.6601937413215637,
-0.03982778266072273,
-0.695139467716217,
-0.9301899075508118,
-0.5432941317558289,
0.6578096151351929,
-0.09062517434358597,
-0.2020777016878128,
0.8209646344184875,
0.477494478225708,
-0.13349859416484833,
0.05899607390165329,
0.3119460344314575,
0.11855755746364594,
0.19731684029102325,
0.36722368001937866,
0.8838678002357483,
-0.44652411341667175,
0.2687491774559021,
-0.37552911043167114,
-0.4684104919433594,
-0.5165043473243713,
-1.1237454414367676,
-0.9394698739051819,
-0.3909192681312561,
-0.7307485342025757,
-0.4820529818534851,
0.16676786541938782,
0.3010534942150116,
0.4897071123123169,
-0.5294192433357239,
0.11669506132602692,
-0.10539602488279343,
0.2359006702899933,
-0.4269939064979553,
-0.21676787734031677,
0.22319161891937256,
0.03643782064318657,
-0.7865438461303711,
0.22179292142391205,
0.6827840805053711,
0.2673076391220093,
-0.18027755618095398,
0.03325768932700157,
-0.2981542646884918,
0.03368972986936569,
0.4456821084022522,
0.5077695250511169,
-0.09037023782730103,
-0.4694984257221222,
-0.020439887419342995,
-0.042869843542575836,
0.1739601045846939,
0.7596016526222229,
-1.0225714445114136,
0.6250160932540894,
1.026936411857605,
0.31761935353279114,
0.3786250352859497,
0.055272724479436874,
0.4810929000377655,
-0.3327849209308624,
0.12091788649559021,
0.037713151425123215,
0.11347398906946182,
-0.18028080463409424,
-0.6171648502349854,
0.7750368714332581,
0.38502100110054016,
-0.5175321102142334,
-0.5307035446166992,
-0.007578856311738491,
-1.301578402519226,
-0.31829288601875305,
0.8654664754867554,
-0.13861438632011414,
-0.2592538297176361,
-0.2832496464252472,
-0.7270510792732239,
0.35153305530548096,
-0.2084808051586151,
0.6834841370582581,
0.4336700737476349,
0.02406666986644268,
-0.26545068621635437,
-0.9184364080429077,
0.41392549872398376,
-0.1037788912653923,
-1.1091209650039673,
-0.33211684226989746,
0.7150362133979797,
0.14871323108673096,
0.42935943603515625,
0.7347240447998047,
-0.22673898935317993,
0.4021112024784088,
0.5090407729148865,
0.36900776624679565,
-0.4302438199520111,
-0.2890186011791229,
-0.05336422100663185,
0.5413221120834351,
-0.061572156846523285,
-0.01790638640522957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06760v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06760v1
|
Opportunities for Persian Digital Humanities Research with Artificial Intelligence Language Models; Case Study: Forough Farrokhzad
| 2024-05-10T18:24:55 | 2024-05-10T18:24:55 |
Arash Rasti Meymandi, Zahra Hosseini, Sina Davari, Abolfazl Moshiri, Shabnam Rahimi-Golkhandan, Khashayar Namdar, Nikta Feizi, Mohamad Tavakoli-Targhi, Farzad Khalvati
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study explores the integration of advanced Natural Language Processing
(NLP) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques to analyze and interpret
Persian literature, focusing on the poetry of Forough Farrokhzad. Utilizing
computational methods, we aim to unveil thematic, stylistic, and linguistic
patterns in Persian poetry. Specifically, the study employs AI models including
transformer-based language models for clustering of the poems in an
unsupervised framework. This research underscores the potential of AI in
enhancing our understanding of Persian literary heritage, with Forough
Farrokhzad's work providing a comprehensive case study. This approach not only
contributes to the field of Persian Digital Humanities but also sets a
precedent for future research in Persian literary studies using computational
techniques.
|
[
-0.3696155250072479,
-0.9537942409515381,
0.7436574697494507,
0.01754869520664215,
-0.20800192654132843,
0.3495803773403168,
-0.42887967824935913,
-0.5447651147842407,
0.21426498889923096,
0.7190474271774292,
-0.7927708029747009,
-0.5995404124259949,
-0.3264966905117035,
0.1547975391149521,
-0.8062219023704529,
0.8705202341079712,
0.006411710754036903,
-0.09333497285842896,
-0.12416530400514603,
-0.07492982596158981,
-0.27683305740356445,
-0.52204829454422,
-0.4895029664039612,
-0.26958993077278137,
0.3431709408760071,
0.526664137840271,
0.9045257568359375,
0.11331845074892044,
0.5981695652008057,
0.41051918268203735,
0.19749246537685394,
-0.23487447202205658,
-0.05661092326045036,
0.04294254258275032,
-0.2905355393886566,
-0.5239728689193726,
-0.3088715374469757,
0.0651383325457573,
0.8160697221755981,
0.32112663984298706,
-0.20626285672187805,
0.36339691281318665,
-0.167947918176651,
0.9008147120475769,
-0.24010823667049408,
-0.08842650055885315,
-0.3817196786403656,
0.2563912570476532,
-0.8700811862945557,
-0.13718606531620026,
-0.27054330706596375,
-0.39366912841796875,
0.024433080106973648,
-0.4180939793586731,
0.13602982461452484,
0.19580446183681488,
0.5435594916343689,
0.2535555362701416,
-0.0018139021703973413,
-0.2256975620985031,
-1.0059670209884644,
1.1240885257720947,
-0.6844103932380676,
0.10547681897878647,
0.19917160272598267,
0.5462092161178589,
-0.2125282734632492,
-0.7456696629524231,
-0.9727472066879272,
-0.036802783608436584,
0.020240826532244682,
0.08313743025064468,
-0.5436415672302246,
-0.1684715300798416,
0.1157962754368782,
0.7472037076950073,
-0.7207207083702087,
0.11575669050216675,
-0.26595771312713623,
-0.021436557173728943,
1.0978198051452637,
0.3215406537055969,
0.8964017033576965,
-0.057501424103975296,
0.03579092398285866,
0.05881374329328537,
-0.17488621175289154,
0.3042246103286743,
0.41959211230278015,
0.21044817566871643,
-0.008031041361391544,
0.650107204914093,
-0.3455149829387665,
0.6600926518440247,
-0.06613379716873169,
0.10762704908847809,
0.16812105476856232,
-0.1865280568599701,
-0.07415316253900528,
0.18658022582530975,
0.8138629198074341,
-0.02170437201857567,
0.4201383590698242,
-0.2236843854188919,
0.05777955800294876,
0.21457746624946594,
0.44104915857315063,
-0.4509047269821167,
-0.4341951012611389,
0.5747531056404114,
-0.6957181096076965,
-0.27753880620002747,
0.05360858142375946,
-0.8704283237457275,
-0.33879566192626953,
-0.13265922665596008,
0.13746649026870728,
-0.567498505115509,
-0.39070773124694824,
-0.0031981500796973705,
-0.30563807487487793,
0.21363215148448944,
0.1529073864221573,
-0.7940525412559509,
0.39563700556755066,
0.6419200897216797,
0.7128048539161682,
-0.2677791714668274,
-0.6222280859947205,
-0.041220568120479584,
-0.010214332491159439,
-0.45305952429771423,
0.9445285797119141,
-0.7139861583709717,
-0.013709956780076027,
0.01672055944800377,
-0.1646592915058136,
0.01274046953767538,
-0.13974180817604065,
1.0341968536376953,
-0.683983325958252,
0.245852991938591,
0.4394668936729431,
-0.41669484972953796,
-0.775130569934845,
-0.03864804282784462,
-0.9887915253639221,
0.6863229870796204,
0.13437895476818085,
-0.7038202285766602,
-0.39940741658210754,
-0.9660528302192688,
-0.06973528861999512,
0.1148405447602272,
-0.23741118609905243,
-0.563340961933136,
0.3705276846885681,
0.12564559280872345,
0.45592617988586426,
-0.5687461495399475,
0.3442932367324829,
-0.048428013920784,
-0.2253798395395279,
0.4395408034324646,
-0.26398447155952454,
0.9328153133392334,
0.3561580777168274,
-0.35816285014152527,
0.22988830506801605,
-0.8633152842521667,
0.2987205386161804,
0.32240456342697144,
-0.10857813060283661,
-0.3594856858253479,
0.23573224246501923,
0.666064441204071,
0.0509367398917675,
-0.01791868731379509,
-0.6005736589431763,
0.10368292033672333,
-0.6816868185997009,
0.2556043863296509,
0.6988089680671692,
-0.27692168951034546,
0.4754939079284668,
-0.6526795029640198,
0.8146673440933228,
-0.3002954423427582,
-0.06482089310884476,
0.15735946595668793,
-0.5264951586723328,
-0.5136948823928833,
-0.1686597764492035,
0.5056877732276917,
0.5496746301651001,
-0.8994603753089905,
0.3562135398387909,
-0.281973272562027,
-0.8631040453910828,
-0.5433216094970703,
-0.052306730300188065,
0.003108846489340067,
-0.08884388953447342,
0.39651063084602356,
-0.11829966306686401,
-0.3983151614665985,
-0.6884853839874268,
-0.614331841468811,
0.14989081025123596,
0.3128167986869812,
-0.15418562293052673,
0.3841876983642578,
-0.4127040505409241,
1.0106785297393799,
-0.31732338666915894,
-0.38001447916030884,
-0.468745619058609,
0.03397650644183159,
0.38989919424057007,
0.5484848618507385,
0.6564647555351257,
-0.8436996340751648,
-0.5677459836006165,
0.20641767978668213,
-0.4735836386680603,
-0.14658047258853912,
-0.15603096783161163,
-0.13200877606868744,
-0.008934642188251019,
0.3878127932548523,
-0.2857394218444824,
0.7765163779258728,
0.7008103728294373,
-0.5683956742286682,
0.612082302570343,
0.3295726180076599,
0.38186773657798767,
-0.9823970794677734,
0.07515919208526611,
-0.12067700922489166,
0.00021615508012473583,
-1.0252275466918945,
0.31071797013282776,
-0.19358819723129272,
-0.36494800448417664,
-0.24789774417877197,
0.607706606388092,
-0.4459388852119446,
0.12336255609989166,
-0.341277152299881,
-0.20252841711044312,
-0.3233488202095032,
0.3596116900444031,
0.06762774288654327,
0.5207750201225281,
0.47913268208503723,
-0.2415241301059723,
0.6792323589324951,
0.3085574209690094,
-0.2813486158847809,
0.5634790062904358,
-0.3050541877746582,
0.04127819091081619,
0.1261393427848816,
0.1261172741651535,
-0.7714865207672119,
0.04112309217453003,
0.2856474220752716,
-0.46883541345596313,
0.12044129520654678,
0.1084011122584343,
-0.36194801330566406,
-0.37697333097457886,
-0.7119204998016357,
0.8298040628433228,
0.4165249168872833,
-0.3383689820766449,
1.0245451927185059,
0.2731269896030426,
-0.618537962436676,
-0.19494053721427917,
-0.6102597713470459,
0.38847053050994873,
-0.4913787543773651,
-0.672427237033844,
0.548931896686554,
-0.10005570203065872,
-0.6276274919509888,
-0.10173992812633514,
0.4355204105377197,
-0.4417460262775421,
0.21715743839740753,
0.271634966135025,
0.08641264587640762,
-0.48428961634635925,
-0.09346333146095276,
0.3435416519641876,
-0.2616388201713562,
0.013604913838207722,
-0.23928023874759674,
0.7148944139480591,
-0.10553736239671707,
-0.5803467035293579,
-0.9333649277687073,
0.8485649824142456,
0.6071404218673706,
-0.2872999310493469,
0.5693926215171814,
0.6207547783851624,
-0.19064213335514069,
-0.3238806128501892,
-0.5313348174095154,
0.23665876686573029,
-0.46078217029571533,
0.08655314147472382,
-0.3882492184638977,
-0.7444064021110535,
0.44251981377601624,
-0.28695183992385864,
-0.16834528744220734,
1.058322548866272,
0.5813030004501343,
-0.3230251669883728,
0.677600085735321,
0.9687414765357971,
-0.47891998291015625,
0.5526530146598816,
-0.37933579087257385,
0.021598733961582184,
-0.7340020537376404,
0.053195033222436905,
-0.9148874878883362,
-0.5071868300437927,
-0.6805992126464844,
-0.4542750418186188,
0.3334980309009552,
-0.21681895852088928,
-0.2881859838962555,
-0.4001414477825165,
-0.5990356206893921,
0.5638135671615601,
0.5981248617172241,
-0.08003673702478409,
0.4829510450363159,
0.41998788714408875,
-0.024490537121891975,
-0.04499034211039543,
-0.6388643980026245,
-0.5292031764984131,
1.1199636459350586,
0.0829857811331749,
0.5073029398918152,
0.3310186266899109,
0.6515341997146606,
0.9295398592948914,
-0.31875115633010864,
-0.5701413154602051,
0.3562145531177521,
-0.1377135068178177,
-0.3035331070423126,
-0.5277552604675293,
0.21851377189159393,
-1.273974061012268,
-0.19906997680664062,
-0.2125127762556076,
-0.6648672223091125,
0.006253500003367662,
-0.33443012833595276,
-0.4485507011413574,
0.3601282238960266,
0.0073578315787017345,
0.6461746096611023,
-0.3411100506782532,
0.06269768625497818,
-0.8919517397880554,
-0.5929576754570007,
0.14476527273654938,
-0.11229252815246582,
0.469571590423584,
0.01068560965359211,
0.17466513812541962,
0.7911117076873779,
-0.3623155653476715,
0.4977089762687683,
0.17598740756511688,
0.028492752462625504,
0.16752208769321442,
0.20631492137908936,
0.06931997090578079,
-0.37232545018196106,
-0.31175661087036133,
0.5005300641059875,
0.19161243736743927,
-0.7001164555549622,
-0.23751871287822723,
0.7784192562103271,
-1.0138505697250366,
-0.4084993600845337,
-0.8311044573783875,
-0.47572755813598633,
0.008861333131790161,
0.1078501045703888,
-0.0964052602648735,
0.38315504789352417,
-0.36147618293762207,
-0.045397236943244934,
0.3325669765472412,
-0.48944783210754395,
0.6967907547950745,
0.28860893845558167,
-0.4192235469818115,
-0.2813960313796997,
0.7660613656044006,
-0.12455284595489502,
-0.13729673624038696,
0.36688748002052307,
0.27985119819641113,
-0.08479253947734833,
-0.8418340682983398,
-0.9391301274299622,
0.18058240413665771,
-0.5685083866119385,
0.10525953024625778,
-0.22776275873184204,
-0.5700842142105103,
-0.11255371570587158,
-0.362746924161911,
-0.16751964390277863,
-0.4430992007255554,
-0.2558586001396179,
0.3645854592323303,
0.8859423398971558,
0.9507108926773071,
0.25148236751556396,
0.2624043822288513,
-0.9393078684806824,
0.3549751341342926,
0.07012947648763657,
0.25544002652168274,
0.3135618269443512,
-0.24157723784446716,
-0.35781949758529663,
-0.09162668138742447,
-0.3018460273742676,
-0.990670919418335,
0.35265976190567017,
0.2382194548845291,
0.5368470549583435,
0.09613853693008423,
0.035121798515319824,
0.4577770233154297,
-0.9034387469291687,
1.0071269273757935,
-0.03530736640095711,
-0.9658628702163696,
0.9155194163322449,
-0.6301189661026001,
0.2149033397436142,
0.34220781922340393,
0.3780384659767151,
-0.7354385256767273,
-0.4516719579696655,
-0.8804406523704529,
-0.5780971050262451,
0.7846150398254395,
0.1719169318675995,
0.21676936745643616,
0.48697853088378906,
0.296842098236084,
0.207161545753479,
0.12182407081127167,
-0.5730949640274048,
-0.21037927269935608,
-0.13880904018878937,
-0.5394510626792908,
-0.3478794991970062,
-0.13468687236309052,
0.06511983275413513,
-0.6691560745239258,
0.6479482650756836,
-0.04657986760139465,
0.36154723167419434,
0.12492653727531433,
-0.29305604100227356,
-0.0849425345659256,
0.23793213069438934,
0.5752096176147461,
0.5679095983505249,
0.43600156903266907,
-0.14999540150165558,
0.057473037391901016,
-0.5642983913421631,
-0.03554332256317139,
0.10092119127511978,
-0.24593877792358398,
-0.03622960299253464,
0.3137914836406708,
0.45891037583351135,
-0.44151392579078674,
-0.6846560835838318,
0.2523749768733978,
-0.09964021295309067,
0.11765913665294647,
-0.915886640548706,
0.12400682270526886,
-0.029063774272799492,
0.7381070852279663,
0.5231668949127197,
0.018864788115024567,
0.48961737751960754,
-0.7942066788673401,
-0.020192468538880348,
0.5405628681182861,
-0.10202649980783463,
-0.24388374388217926,
0.3468356132507324,
-0.014120305888354778,
-0.646238386631012,
0.7279207110404968,
0.28048253059387207,
-0.8258737921714783,
0.4769343435764313,
0.4103308320045471,
0.8395134210586548,
-0.20848296582698822,
0.33375421166419983,
-0.11576157063245773,
0.019889889284968376,
0.32826176285743713,
0.37183594703674316,
-0.09069667756557465,
-0.6495475769042969,
-0.3429452180862427,
-0.8517150282859802,
-0.4356556832790375,
-0.1753629595041275,
-0.17948687076568604,
0.19010940194129944,
-0.4617500901222229,
0.07177421450614929,
0.2019214779138565,
0.40069836378097534,
-0.34339872002601624,
0.11209946125745773,
0.31952500343322754,
0.48716282844543457,
-0.7570586204528809,
0.9294243454933167,
0.7759100794792175,
-0.3151678442955017,
-0.9190279245376587,
0.1753317266702652,
0.1072225272655487,
-0.5401025414466858,
0.3362810015678406,
-0.15839405357837677,
-0.26759830117225647,
0.6138553023338318,
-0.45090189576148987,
-0.7683426141738892,
0.9963791370391846,
-0.15466146171092987,
-0.2044375091791153,
0.3713703155517578,
0.13620127737522125,
0.6472507119178772,
-0.060587383806705475,
0.3137663006782532,
0.663841187953949,
0.5555322766304016,
-0.25075680017471313,
-0.940008819103241,
-0.23867930471897125,
-0.6689435243606567,
0.07239286601543427,
0.37194857001304626,
-0.6533388495445251,
1.0196378231048584,
0.2120789736509323,
-0.27220457792282104,
0.6807184219360352,
0.6112801432609558,
-0.17197367548942566,
0.5772610902786255,
0.004472506698220968,
0.6577563285827637,
0.6603829860687256,
0.03249606117606163,
1.0696780681610107,
-0.12239071726799011,
0.18118874728679657,
0.4794344902038574,
0.178036168217659,
0.7879981994628906,
0.2458423376083374,
-0.5534834861755371,
1.2206838130950928,
0.3893378973007202,
-0.10568182170391083,
0.2964564263820648,
0.41259658336639404,
-0.26752084493637085,
0.2528599202632904,
-0.18185842037200928,
-0.2997139096260071,
0.6591787934303284,
0.04815441370010376,
-0.20709878206253052,
-0.06334605813026428,
0.250089555978775,
-0.10992557555437088,
0.830345869064331,
-0.6087173223495483,
0.883009135723114,
-0.19905304908752441,
-0.5209788084030151,
0.4258196949958801,
0.47820740938186646,
0.7527856826782227,
-0.25855690240859985,
-0.0204953383654356,
0.2333664447069168,
0.3843010365962982,
-0.43340179324150085,
-0.7550526261329651,
0.7425800561904907,
-0.02024332992732525,
-0.40828409790992737,
-0.21387217938899994,
0.9732330441474915,
-0.1845584213733673,
-0.8674258589744568,
0.00518396170809865,
0.8537046313285828,
0.21593230962753296,
-0.34739333391189575,
-0.8728909492492676,
0.048454634845256805,
0.23642517626285553,
0.06217510625720024,
0.28136271238327026,
0.4700210392475128,
-0.5278381109237671,
0.4936843514442444,
0.8848246335983276,
0.5096482634544373,
-0.10623939335346222,
-0.057194117456674576,
0.829577624797821,
-0.9386366605758667,
-0.5273222327232361,
-1.2239254713058472,
0.3951902389526367,
-0.03434469550848007,
0.005087047815322876,
0.8398273587226868,
0.27263912558555603,
0.5317678451538086,
-0.12152248620986938,
0.5704066157341003,
-0.060717880725860596,
0.9092926383018494,
-0.4987606704235077,
1.333617925643921,
-0.45795390009880066,
-0.24958106875419617,
-0.5256650447845459,
-0.6192513704299927,
-0.3538455069065094,
0.7685776948928833,
-0.30708152055740356,
-0.30750197172164917,
0.7281782031059265,
0.33973240852355957,
0.13348829746246338,
0.5218365788459778,
0.05604403093457222,
0.049484699964523315,
0.1423529088497162,
0.3690776824951172,
1.3278555870056152,
-0.30247795581817627,
-0.14821138978004456,
-0.2977931797504425,
0.00599792692810297,
-0.13507357239723206,
-0.7216950058937073,
-0.8748119473457336,
-0.8241196274757385,
-0.02187357470393181,
0.08326010406017303,
-0.06809138506650925,
0.8631848096847534,
-0.060313496738672256,
-0.959953248500824,
-0.4813390076160431,
0.18841984868049622,
0.32148370146751404,
-0.26595133543014526,
-0.23652419447898865,
0.46286943554878235,
-0.13214989006519318,
-0.7504022717475891,
0.14382469654083252,
0.30119726061820984,
-0.15191470086574554,
-0.31833741068840027,
-0.010110372677445412,
-0.544550895690918,
0.09934480488300323,
0.3884613513946533,
0.12010762840509415,
-0.8894392251968384,
-0.035195279866456985,
-0.33536630868911743,
0.09881854802370071,
0.07674463838338852,
0.7408764362335205,
-0.8802616596221924,
0.18729138374328613,
0.3372613787651062,
0.7425707578659058,
0.21405816078186035,
0.015572686679661274,
0.5868725180625916,
-0.14667721092700958,
0.15409909188747406,
0.7129858136177063,
0.00004638190512196161,
0.09221463650465012,
-0.3660500943660736,
0.47138622403144836,
0.13848653435707092,
-0.6247754096984863,
-0.584526002407074,
0.0009209763375110924,
-0.860576868057251,
-0.42812901735305786,
0.7225309610366821,
0.12764115631580353,
-0.07867962121963501,
-0.3600228726863861,
-0.4420119524002075,
0.2502851188182831,
-0.13581718504428864,
0.8560589551925659,
0.9064193964004517,
-0.2841399908065796,
-0.19829653203487396,
-0.8184428215026855,
0.6758790612220764,
0.41451600193977356,
-0.682281494140625,
-0.44201281666755676,
0.700616180896759,
-0.0686757043004036,
0.38541969656944275,
0.6441864967346191,
0.10004884004592896,
0.5254420638084412,
-0.26536765694618225,
0.16145476698875427,
0.31115132570266724,
-0.3721048831939697,
-0.5130560398101807,
0.11397993564605713,
0.2608925998210907,
0.1862676441669464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06640v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06640v1
|
Linearizing Large Language Models
| 2024-05-10T17:59:08 | 2024-05-10T17:59:08 |
Jean Mercat, Igor Vasiljevic, Sedrick Keh, Kushal Arora, Achal Dave, Adrien Gaidon, Thomas Kollar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Linear transformers have emerged as a subquadratic-time alternative to
softmax attention and have garnered significant interest due to their
fixed-size recurrent state that lowers inference cost. However, their original
formulation suffers from poor scaling and underperforms compute-matched
transformers. Recent linear models such as RWKV and Mamba have attempted to
address these shortcomings by proposing novel time-mixing and gating
architectures, but pre-training large language models requires significant data
and compute investments. Thus, the search for subquadratic architectures is
limited by the availability of compute and quality pre-training datasets. As a
cost-effective alternative to pre-training linear transformers, we propose
Scalable UPtraining for Recurrent Attention (SUPRA). We present a method to
uptrain existing large pre-trained transformers into Recurrent Neural Networks
(RNNs) with a modest compute budget. This allows us to leverage the strong
pre-training data and performance of existing transformer LLMs, while requiring
5% of the training cost. We find that our linearization technique leads to
competitive performance on standard benchmarks, but we identify persistent
in-context learning and long-context modeling shortfalls for even the largest
linear models. Our code and models can be found at
https://github.com/TRI-ML/linear_open_lm.
|
[
-0.33612191677093506,
-0.22566872835159302,
0.34268468618392944,
0.18317140638828278,
-0.10325966775417328,
-0.023736096918582916,
-0.4072863459587097,
-0.07678011059761047,
0.32125094532966614,
0.4028621315956116,
-0.6582642793655396,
0.06189463660120964,
-0.34659063816070557,
-0.20709878206253052,
-0.45295074582099915,
0.9967595338821411,
0.0709298625588417,
0.06743183732032776,
-0.03750599920749664,
-0.22488859295845032,
-0.4009142518043518,
-0.5731992721557617,
-0.5641114115715027,
-0.5553422570228577,
0.5276110768318176,
0.24998754262924194,
0.9037426710128784,
0.3897360563278198,
0.2559780180454254,
0.29082217812538147,
-0.18703046441078186,
0.054415181279182434,
-0.6401733756065369,
0.10109872370958328,
-0.20854467153549194,
-0.36323362588882446,
-0.34305259585380554,
0.02997993677854538,
0.70137619972229,
0.7519850730895996,
-0.36452722549438477,
0.36585763096809387,
-0.14244502782821655,
0.6430292129516602,
-0.5503076910972595,
0.09029155969619751,
-0.7386546730995178,
0.2831500470638275,
-0.25369778275489807,
-0.045163292437791824,
-0.45913219451904297,
-0.26570436358451843,
0.1767224222421646,
-0.6409428119659424,
0.252695769071579,
-0.1464034467935562,
0.8561834692955017,
0.5557924509048462,
0.12833531200885773,
-0.10335072129964828,
-0.9924681186676025,
1.0311336517333984,
-0.8483129143714905,
0.4549676179885864,
-0.12345543503761292,
0.2632191479206085,
-0.03033445216715336,
-1.0115697383880615,
-0.4053252935409546,
-0.2437412440776825,
-0.170601025223732,
0.13840222358703613,
-0.5365638136863708,
-0.11541683226823807,
0.47939687967300415,
0.5532512068748474,
-0.33298248052597046,
-0.01760076731443405,
-0.365186870098114,
0.18424050509929657,
0.27897536754608154,
0.031469039618968964,
0.2252172827720642,
0.08433143049478531,
-0.40635520219802856,
0.08407383412122726,
-0.6766311526298523,
-0.0030891348142176867,
0.07407495379447937,
0.3256981372833252,
0.055215053260326385,
0.4206773340702057,
0.17730963230133057,
0.534794270992279,
0.24281716346740723,
0.13711443543434143,
0.05359462648630142,
-0.4690251350402832,
-0.24599501490592957,
-0.2239629179239273,
0.5834658741950989,
-0.0945403054356575,
0.5811274647712708,
-0.24586762487888336,
-0.45581087470054626,
0.03489677980542183,
0.6356963515281677,
-0.6853509545326233,
-0.20876139402389526,
-0.08579692244529724,
-0.3042878210544586,
-0.1870933324098587,
-0.45704200863838196,
-0.7736208438873291,
-0.20064334571361542,
-0.6105915904045105,
0.5677422285079956,
-0.11217616498470306,
-0.0346994623541832,
0.18627041578292847,
0.3782304525375366,
0.22648732364177704,
0.03289937227964401,
-1.1187525987625122,
0.30339863896369934,
0.3289766311645508,
0.839384913444519,
0.04745885729789734,
-0.0591416098177433,
-0.4984419047832489,
-0.21128931641578674,
-0.2889566421508789,
0.4814499318599701,
-0.4003760814666748,
-0.13752511143684387,
0.0033180059399455786,
-0.2996622323989868,
-0.06029095873236656,
-0.3303094506263733,
0.36080285906791687,
-0.5891426205635071,
0.32669422030448914,
0.07310714572668076,
-0.21778784692287445,
0.1756245642900467,
-0.21547308564186096,
-0.591434895992279,
1.2483371496200562,
0.2969053089618683,
-0.679267168045044,
0.09460855275392532,
-0.469268262386322,
-0.5058775544166565,
0.044630613178014755,
-0.2273922562599182,
-0.602123498916626,
0.2745368778705597,
0.5526336431503296,
0.4903033673763275,
-0.5361617207527161,
0.32168328762054443,
-0.19992594420909882,
-0.3805152475833893,
0.1600925475358963,
-0.23546870052814484,
0.5269848108291626,
0.285587877035141,
-0.4363308250904083,
0.38172999024391174,
-0.6741258502006531,
-0.03575993701815605,
0.1329827606678009,
-0.1416371464729309,
-0.3089781701564789,
-0.11689506471157074,
-0.011636142618954182,
0.1905403882265091,
0.31419235467910767,
-0.4471942186355591,
0.3386925756931305,
-0.672648012638092,
0.6527441740036011,
0.7158637046813965,
-0.4592072665691376,
0.7613210678100586,
-0.03746476396918297,
0.6690632700920105,
-0.257489413022995,
0.30234697461128235,
-0.15508216619491577,
-0.01839941367506981,
-1.2294232845306396,
-0.11363712698221207,
0.3975653052330017,
0.1953650265932083,
-0.6958816051483154,
0.29138708114624023,
-0.40158191323280334,
-0.4190032184123993,
-0.6508151888847351,
0.24213804304599762,
0.40189129114151,
0.4948951303958893,
0.6557167172431946,
-0.22471854090690613,
-0.8369718790054321,
-0.9558281302452087,
-0.12792323529720306,
0.5239821076393127,
-0.4085814654827118,
0.27463430166244507,
0.319938063621521,
-0.29556888341903687,
0.9834719896316528,
-0.32900893688201904,
-0.6971201300621033,
-0.7014025449752808,
0.14952200651168823,
0.5111673474311829,
0.2509482800960541,
0.4524855613708496,
-0.48019567131996155,
-0.4003349244594574,
0.0020465883426368237,
-0.42784252762794495,
-0.05670879781246185,
-0.33033421635627747,
0.24321024119853973,
0.07664802670478821,
0.750357985496521,
-0.7367766499519348,
0.40391528606414795,
0.7174923419952393,
0.1686299443244934,
0.08379420638084412,
-0.399525910615921,
-0.4710262715816498,
-1.1646592617034912,
0.23891812562942505,
0.10500328242778778,
-0.2583354711532593,
-0.8205338716506958,
-0.10116419196128845,
0.17745986580848694,
-0.48668569326400757,
-0.4249713122844696,
0.20129741728305817,
-0.5023320317268372,
-0.47980955243110657,
-0.20673489570617676,
0.29742392897605896,
-0.12632304430007935,
0.7895391583442688,
-0.001239942153915763,
0.9107484817504883,
0.29905879497528076,
-0.4277253746986389,
0.2997257113456726,
0.04687269404530525,
-0.37712594866752625,
0.08038235455751419,
-1.0773968696594238,
0.253820538520813,
-0.21415424346923828,
0.5325219631195068,
-0.7945938110351562,
0.02901122346520424,
-0.12436274439096451,
-0.29562729597091675,
0.3971427381038666,
-0.10055717825889587,
-0.14494092762470245,
-0.3314129114151001,
-0.1355837881565094,
0.6838557720184326,
0.6087490916252136,
-0.7828230857849121,
1.0190799236297607,
0.5378932952880859,
-0.1257474422454834,
-0.870782732963562,
-0.5554268956184387,
-0.16986201703548431,
-0.09183604270219803,
-0.4419361650943756,
0.2619470953941345,
0.22070330381393433,
0.08658120036125183,
-0.2007245272397995,
-0.2044270634651184,
0.18536145985126495,
-0.18190103769302368,
-0.0157451294362545,
0.2622206509113312,
-0.34857162833213806,
0.1356458067893982,
-0.4690245985984802,
-0.5102273225784302,
-0.09688904136419296,
-0.6050287485122681,
0.7551486492156982,
-0.45436498522758484,
0.08156999200582504,
-0.4462862014770508,
0.11693063378334045,
0.7750424146652222,
-0.5608317255973816,
0.6245080828666687,
0.5027657747268677,
-0.3294212520122528,
-0.40643030405044556,
-0.45526260137557983,
-0.06902946531772614,
-0.4687614440917969,
0.3754722476005554,
-0.10777038335800171,
-0.7482932806015015,
0.34024667739868164,
-0.07082797586917877,
0.3053920567035675,
0.22805717587471008,
0.6354324817657471,
-0.03463682904839516,
0.91256183385849,
0.5939040184020996,
-0.2881498336791992,
0.5859101414680481,
-0.3499455451965332,
0.4262315034866333,
-0.6641506552696228,
-0.01732589118182659,
-0.4589253067970276,
-0.5375522375106812,
-0.2258971482515335,
-0.5851559638977051,
0.33917611837387085,
-0.2615090608596802,
-0.26218071579933167,
0.5682653188705444,
-0.3566843271255493,
0.6247234344482422,
0.4840717315673828,
-0.1210070475935936,
0.07071839272975922,
0.01723872870206833,
-0.01874876208603382,
-0.2857619524002075,
-0.8461556434631348,
-0.03625261038541794,
1.1170737743377686,
0.6217467784881592,
1.284483551979065,
-0.08581920713186264,
0.246916264295578,
0.10785292834043503,
0.40559667348861694,
-0.8514859676361084,
0.3739381730556488,
-0.5019593238830566,
-0.2615002989768982,
-0.5180917382240295,
-0.5131072998046875,
-0.9373257160186768,
0.31592538952827454,
-0.2630216181278229,
-0.4946519434452057,
0.2046722024679184,
0.3029440641403198,
-0.7169949412345886,
0.40379369258880615,
-0.46579796075820923,
0.7190762162208557,
-0.21725542843341827,
-0.13441520929336548,
-0.1655922532081604,
-0.5375412106513977,
0.229728564620018,
-0.3843584358692169,
0.1035858690738678,
0.23430006206035614,
0.0928122028708458,
0.5177565813064575,
-0.3501817286014557,
0.8224561214447021,
-0.020967721939086914,
-0.17941954731941223,
-0.01784018613398075,
-0.10647949576377869,
0.5862917900085449,
0.10607516020536423,
0.35752975940704346,
0.24046805500984192,
-0.4725010097026825,
-0.42387670278549194,
-0.7572860717773438,
0.6496306657791138,
-0.8838436007499695,
-0.42876315116882324,
-0.34467843174934387,
-0.8444094657897949,
-0.41030165553092957,
0.20434728264808655,
0.37261584401130676,
0.634507417678833,
0.24619953334331512,
0.7132081985473633,
1.0225341320037842,
-0.15899597108364105,
0.39397433400154114,
0.23720256984233856,
-0.25664132833480835,
-0.371611088514328,
0.6131439208984375,
0.04141203686594963,
0.3666175603866577,
0.4922791123390198,
0.2565643787384033,
-0.49268266558647156,
-0.38991090655326843,
-0.16544923186302185,
0.2158234417438507,
-0.4501554071903229,
-0.24028737843036652,
-0.49376556277275085,
-0.3973919153213501,
-0.31405532360076904,
-0.12648698687553406,
-1.0788637399673462,
-0.3795652687549591,
-0.19617639482021332,
0.13019482791423798,
0.006880733650177717,
0.708405077457428,
0.04912412539124489,
0.42765676975250244,
-0.45318603515625,
0.5127195715904236,
0.4613913297653198,
0.31557783484458923,
0.13279961049556732,
-0.9260895252227783,
-0.34468770027160645,
-0.03314759582281113,
-0.05773119628429413,
-0.2686665952205658,
0.5407078862190247,
0.20119081437587738,
0.3875328302383423,
0.22633245587348938,
-0.08707717806100845,
0.7875239849090576,
-0.629919707775116,
0.41684484481811523,
0.46908754110336304,
-1.057401180267334,
0.4414030909538269,
-0.15715019404888153,
0.49046093225479126,
0.36594492197036743,
0.5237244367599487,
-0.5870649814605713,
-0.10283911973237991,
-0.38722264766693115,
-0.9546259641647339,
0.7588965892791748,
0.2984069585800171,
0.3901568651199341,
0.3733092248439789,
0.390313982963562,
-0.16919705271720886,
-0.17242518067359924,
-1.0666372776031494,
-0.2928573489189148,
-0.34611067175865173,
-0.22000513970851898,
-0.46768632531166077,
-0.3245238661766052,
0.03473718464374542,
-0.2946382761001587,
0.655104398727417,
0.06553200632333755,
-0.08353981375694275,
0.04110004007816315,
-0.22589141130447388,
-0.17036573588848114,
0.31219422817230225,
0.6045064926147461,
0.6334164142608643,
-0.17137759923934937,
0.10637526214122772,
0.4497690796852112,
-0.40453410148620605,
0.1427779197692871,
0.03243658319115639,
-0.3447521924972534,
0.06134578213095665,
0.050343289971351624,
0.8349639177322388,
0.9982651472091675,
-0.4613768756389618,
0.470425546169281,
-0.2956888973712921,
-0.09296827763319016,
-0.6414126753807068,
-0.1828668713569641,
0.18074867129325867,
0.2721029222011566,
0.28547704219818115,
0.09207209944725037,
-0.43610429763793945,
-0.2903877794742584,
0.31775858998298645,
0.3340284824371338,
-0.5444055199623108,
-0.22664430737495422,
0.6493842601776123,
0.2924964725971222,
-0.30991220474243164,
0.6296582221984863,
0.3601280450820923,
-0.29705795645713806,
0.23685455322265625,
0.4958702325820923,
0.8021740317344666,
-0.3850195109844208,
-0.04121685400605202,
0.35317933559417725,
0.37746456265449524,
-0.18034783005714417,
-0.0787985548377037,
0.030241362750530243,
-0.6347591876983643,
-0.6639323234558105,
-0.71258544921875,
-0.20313352346420288,
0.5834587812423706,
-0.7614693641662598,
0.34045153856277466,
-0.6158206462860107,
-0.19721589982509613,
0.05826611816883087,
-0.1809924691915512,
-0.4670315384864807,
0.04986582323908806,
0.22318977117538452,
0.7465634346008301,
-0.6396714448928833,
1.0596815347671509,
0.46610769629478455,
-0.4417389929294586,
-0.8926085233688354,
-0.21620064973831177,
-0.4774852395057678,
-0.6733462810516357,
0.6323350667953491,
0.09492342919111252,
-0.3156636953353882,
0.2072305679321289,
-0.3503531217575073,
-1.129809021949768,
0.957778811454773,
0.3760538399219513,
-0.8000844717025757,
-0.345885694026947,
0.18364879488945007,
0.7030615210533142,
-0.5474269986152649,
0.20219220221042633,
0.6784003376960754,
-0.037685997784137726,
-0.026759425178170204,
-0.7271522283554077,
-0.1147443950176239,
-0.04588625580072403,
0.4119076430797577,
0.30695414543151855,
-0.5474593639373779,
1.1726826429367065,
-0.1880892962217331,
-0.4280627965927124,
0.07264161854982376,
0.979191243648529,
0.0025723378639668226,
-0.03612016141414642,
0.6256434917449951,
0.6881617307662964,
0.41470205783843994,
-0.06214097514748573,
0.7968159914016724,
-0.2693789005279541,
0.703595757484436,
1.2444895505905151,
-0.18922750651836395,
0.8105319142341614,
0.5100156664848328,
-0.229014053940773,
0.3774815499782562,
0.18306542932987213,
-0.011492293328046799,
0.2915215790271759,
0.3724968731403351,
-0.08414321392774582,
-0.5576637387275696,
-0.08159740269184113,
-0.49939557909965515,
0.4028474986553192,
0.330524206161499,
-0.3234972059726715,
-0.3780615031719208,
-0.054114654660224915,
-0.15397699177265167,
0.23448660969734192,
-0.4432734549045563,
0.37568792700767517,
0.2597629129886627,
-0.508490264415741,
0.7195703983306885,
-0.31289345026016235,
0.7823333740234375,
-0.8467350602149963,
0.2958807051181793,
-0.6008140444755554,
0.5816649198532104,
-0.029390640556812286,
-0.39679771661758423,
0.20007279515266418,
0.09327331930398941,
-0.04646529257297516,
-0.5350537300109863,
0.6244499683380127,
-0.47470536828041077,
-0.43666765093803406,
0.2873916029930115,
0.1071765273809433,
-0.19617228209972382,
0.1426369845867157,
-0.5977680683135986,
-0.10147806257009506,
-0.06898605823516846,
-0.3466172218322754,
0.3840217888355255,
0.01606575958430767,
0.09213006496429443,
0.8794415593147278,
0.7428410053253174,
0.05070123448967934,
0.030146075412631035,
0.4782606363296509,
0.9440528154373169,
-0.6051328182220459,
-0.4727647006511688,
-0.5852373242378235,
0.33982476592063904,
0.08890917897224426,
-0.23811978101730347,
0.5510804653167725,
0.34372633695602417,
0.8321629762649536,
-0.24956904351711273,
0.4077397882938385,
0.33355239033699036,
0.5426350831985474,
-0.4600560963153839,
0.7186563014984131,
-0.637976348400116,
0.31200066208839417,
-0.024276427924633026,
-1.0472168922424316,
-0.22012144327163696,
0.656122088432312,
-0.2171289473772049,
0.016776956617832184,
0.4044399857521057,
0.6754567623138428,
-0.2132176011800766,
-0.09317195415496826,
0.4422434866428375,
0.28053122758865356,
0.15595589578151703,
0.8182603120803833,
0.8998501896858215,
-0.41645655035972595,
0.8621415495872498,
-0.2681976556777954,
-0.292972207069397,
-0.08567358553409576,
-0.822355329990387,
-1.0553438663482666,
-0.33382707834243774,
0.03982103615999222,
-0.24256590008735657,
-0.14145678281784058,
0.7349541187286377,
0.7127074599266052,
-0.8820856213569641,
-0.20696419477462769,
-0.21680940687656403,
-0.2660614848136902,
0.05967402458190918,
-0.1501261442899704,
0.2000129073858261,
-0.7163047790527344,
-0.7214375734329224,
0.40988269448280334,
0.32488390803337097,
-0.006359288934618235,
-0.7072715163230896,
0.07199008762836456,
-0.17557762563228607,
0.24032896757125854,
0.5769978761672974,
0.6359012126922607,
-0.642119288444519,
-0.21296875178813934,
0.09409554302692413,
-0.11851942539215088,
0.014027352444827557,
1.183371663093567,
-0.7443163394927979,
0.3251441717147827,
0.33253252506256104,
0.8974071145057678,
0.7113797068595886,
0.04980112612247467,
0.8280997276306152,
-1.0228520631790161,
0.39713263511657715,
0.3149488568305969,
0.5232742428779602,
0.23520143330097198,
-0.1698651760816574,
0.47992801666259766,
0.047064315527677536,
-0.595868706703186,
-0.7038494944572449,
0.3216148018836975,
-0.8230235576629639,
-0.08991263806819916,
1.0690741539001465,
-0.19210796058177948,
-0.1004120409488678,
-0.07843340188264847,
-0.02823106199502945,
0.13177041709423065,
-0.05553935840725899,
0.7485160827636719,
0.36499980092048645,
0.13694994151592255,
-0.1149238869547844,
-0.4414413869380951,
0.5435959100723267,
0.8075246810913086,
-0.5453914999961853,
0.35760870575904846,
0.141973078250885,
0.11978207528591156,
0.3872368335723877,
0.40782076120376587,
-0.0945744439959526,
0.1733667254447937,
-0.19422116875648499,
0.1919746845960617,
0.08658064901828766,
-0.5148054957389832,
-0.5526688694953918,
0.019246047362685204,
-0.2881968021392822,
0.06169476732611656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06639v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06639v1
|
Value Augmented Sampling for Language Model Alignment and Personalization
| 2024-05-10T17:59:04 | 2024-05-10T17:59:04 |
Seungwook Han, Idan Shenfeld, Akash Srivastava, Yoon Kim, Pulkit Agrawal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Aligning Large Language Models (LLMs) to cater to different human
preferences, learning new skills, and unlearning harmful behavior is an
important problem. Search-based methods, such as Best-of-N or Monte-Carlo Tree
Search, are performant, but impractical for LLM adaptation due to their high
inference cost. On the other hand, using Reinforcement Learning (RL) for
adaptation is computationally efficient, but performs worse due to the
optimization challenges in co-training the value function and the policy. We
present a new framework for reward optimization, Value Augmented Sampling
(VAS), that can maximize different reward functions using data sampled from
only the initial, frozen LLM. VAS solves for the optimal reward-maximizing
policy without co-training the policy and the value function, making the
optimization stable, outperforming established baselines, such as PPO and DPO,
on standard benchmarks, and achieving comparable results to Best-of-128 with
lower inference cost. Unlike existing RL methods that require changing the
weights of the LLM, VAS does not require access to the weights of the
pre-trained LLM. Thus, it can even adapt LLMs (e.g., ChatGPT), which are
available only as APIs. In addition, our algorithm unlocks the new capability
of composing several rewards and controlling the extent of each one during
deployment time, paving the road ahead for the future of aligned, personalized
LLMs.
|
[
-0.17096306383609772,
-0.4071144759654999,
0.41307154297828674,
0.13029979169368744,
-0.010150301270186901,
0.36881449818611145,
-0.4783223271369934,
-0.10475384443998337,
0.3057106137275696,
0.5662249326705933,
-0.678755521774292,
-0.3694188594818115,
-0.3967243432998657,
-0.02892560511827469,
0.14655925333499908,
0.9455453753471375,
-0.03351902589201927,
-0.2269967794418335,
-0.31023740768432617,
-0.12323668599128723,
-0.4585909843444824,
-0.5434779524803162,
-0.6097567677497864,
-0.2396174669265747,
0.5590660572052002,
0.47267112135887146,
0.22215615212917328,
0.6722590327262878,
0.14120985567569733,
0.3452744483947754,
-0.03974964842200279,
0.39738842844963074,
-0.7335827946662903,
0.17895567417144775,
-0.20189860463142395,
-0.4066942632198334,
-0.4505602717399597,
-0.1143762469291687,
0.41452446579933167,
0.4029747247695923,
-0.3286128640174866,
0.0681556984782219,
-0.019737254828214645,
0.7149712443351746,
-0.9752848744392395,
0.06366907060146332,
-0.7247105240821838,
-0.22270725667476654,
-0.0521833598613739,
-0.4321214556694031,
-0.4430162310600281,
-0.49661120772361755,
0.01676625944674015,
-0.8698906302452087,
-0.23846057057380676,
0.09228543937206268,
0.8261674642562866,
0.3988604247570038,
-0.21668602526187897,
-0.1775340437889099,
-0.5995010137557983,
1.0397017002105713,
-0.5021827220916748,
0.20728428661823273,
0.2915799021720886,
0.38410070538520813,
-0.3777982294559479,
-0.2969586253166199,
-0.5765374898910522,
-0.14903293550014496,
0.3182624578475952,
0.12248441576957703,
-0.05636514350771904,
0.08267916738986969,
-0.007378044538199902,
0.3176047205924988,
-0.3360689878463745,
0.4397186040878296,
-0.12164105474948883,
-0.1675838828086853,
0.7893081307411194,
-0.008691554889082909,
0.19194355607032776,
0.15484195947647095,
-0.4768977761268616,
-0.5818262100219727,
-0.8183553814888,
0.4735836386680603,
0.5918684601783752,
0.5448417663574219,
-0.1648058295249939,
0.45582690834999084,
-0.3236437141895294,
0.7638757228851318,
0.18829020857810974,
-0.3028528094291687,
0.5039991736412048,
-0.15359099209308624,
-0.12947657704353333,
0.14062567055225372,
0.6175169944763184,
0.21527308225631714,
0.40694817900657654,
0.015719879418611526,
-0.3310721814632416,
-0.3654981553554535,
0.320431113243103,
-0.5838039517402649,
-0.02512747049331665,
0.24234075844287872,
-0.07243191450834274,
-0.5071501731872559,
-0.29390302300453186,
-0.5047918558120728,
-0.39445173740386963,
-0.3632297217845917,
0.29383155703544617,
-0.1684579849243164,
-0.1343488246202469,
0.0359778106212616,
0.09566901624202728,
0.010367868468165398,
0.3693449795246124,
-1.4356226921081543,
0.4603743553161621,
0.6091830730438232,
0.5567468404769897,
-0.5149025917053223,
-0.25981470942497253,
-0.8970447778701782,
0.0035588755272328854,
-0.37261125445365906,
0.9085882902145386,
-0.50286865234375,
-0.20745185017585754,
0.11538643389940262,
-0.1795254945755005,
0.07024914771318436,
-0.6111945509910583,
0.4798640310764313,
-0.7838029265403748,
0.09149490296840668,
-0.3658559322357178,
-0.5061019659042358,
0.0034890577662736177,
0.35335442423820496,
-0.5657835602760315,
1.1181312799453735,
0.4854062497615814,
-0.3614291846752167,
0.446685254573822,
-0.5329537391662598,
-0.10636559873819351,
0.11983446776866913,
-0.28285083174705505,
-0.5385571718215942,
0.03328145667910576,
0.47826310992240906,
0.1567496359348297,
-0.11221484839916229,
0.20926357805728912,
-0.4564855694770813,
-0.3817480802536011,
0.2946472465991974,
-0.2622337341308594,
0.5566684007644653,
0.22433151304721832,
-0.09159575402736664,
0.5112159848213196,
-0.6430909037590027,
0.11205817759037018,
0.04419199749827385,
-0.5008000135421753,
-0.4864141345024109,
0.17578774690628052,
-0.0212083887308836,
0.06853692978620529,
0.30365225672721863,
-0.5267577171325684,
0.5715411305427551,
-0.6381335854530334,
0.06591616570949554,
1.1280491352081299,
-0.1385490447282791,
0.5585250854492188,
-0.3233318626880646,
0.7413530945777893,
-0.19327500462532043,
-0.08066033571958542,
-0.11528830975294113,
-0.010326188057661057,
-0.3552838861942291,
-0.5606111884117126,
0.47963544726371765,
0.6272607445716858,
-0.5652731657028198,
0.684447169303894,
-0.5704418420791626,
-0.1592300981283188,
-0.738689661026001,
0.07810166478157043,
0.32411879301071167,
0.4485408067703247,
0.3751586675643921,
-0.26558616757392883,
-0.5246033668518066,
-0.6516354084014893,
-0.2231753170490265,
-0.1478511542081833,
-0.11102006584405899,
0.39850038290023804,
0.10864649713039398,
0.038687609136104584,
1.0496885776519775,
-0.41326063871383667,
-0.1171165257692337,
-0.17108187079429626,
-0.10785724967718124,
0.17437823116779327,
0.2873251140117645,
0.2782060205936432,
-0.6571907997131348,
-0.5218623280525208,
0.006641920190304518,
-0.22824116051197052,
-0.4626902937889099,
-0.1894262433052063,
0.027228944003582,
0.2020391821861267,
0.34752586483955383,
0.1314467489719391,
0.0898737832903862,
0.9337124824523926,
-0.11246330291032791,
0.3518006503582001,
-0.34926852583885193,
0.1230887621641159,
-1.1044299602508545,
-0.05743227154016495,
-0.160782128572464,
-0.35552993416786194,
-0.4530988335609436,
-0.34216055274009705,
-0.03306592255830765,
0.14226190745830536,
-0.37878096103668213,
0.886192798614502,
-0.3866809010505676,
-0.10622309148311615,
-0.5640507340431213,
0.07269144803285599,
-0.10768119990825653,
0.6575019955635071,
0.15934355556964874,
0.9810186624526978,
0.27150821685791016,
-0.6610013842582703,
0.29925790429115295,
0.23955681920051575,
-0.2664523422718048,
0.5763795375823975,
-0.3224680423736572,
0.09742656350135803,
-0.05202844738960266,
0.21702523529529572,
-0.6902709603309631,
-0.04669126123189926,
0.25132665038108826,
-0.37592509388923645,
0.21955335140228271,
-0.1984495222568512,
-0.09980729222297668,
0.1719321608543396,
-0.382692813873291,
0.5396780371665955,
0.6624062657356262,
-0.8486531972885132,
0.4036574363708496,
0.5656790733337402,
-0.31934458017349243,
-0.7768370509147644,
-0.3401227593421936,
-0.10615604370832443,
-0.22668065130710602,
-0.21119748055934906,
0.7137467265129089,
-0.07493964582681656,
-0.018767066299915314,
0.007418487686663866,
-0.04221139848232269,
0.16615450382232666,
0.14464685320854187,
0.03421151265501976,
0.23158158361911774,
0.1130342036485672,
0.19547228515148163,
0.060893796384334564,
-0.28684771060943604,
-0.3482076823711395,
-0.3173820674419403,
0.6205313801765442,
-0.0007387239020317793,
-0.5906925201416016,
-0.18853051960468292,
0.13951368629932404,
0.2827662527561188,
-0.2803972661495209,
0.5428337454795837,
0.35620471835136414,
-0.14783920347690582,
-0.22301945090293884,
-0.49351754784584045,
0.060226403176784515,
-0.4960048794746399,
0.45334580540657043,
-0.39965564012527466,
-1.1762540340423584,
0.2241019904613495,
-0.26015469431877136,
0.1894245147705078,
0.14696069061756134,
0.8975762128829956,
-0.002479439601302147,
0.9253057837486267,
0.6597387194633484,
-0.3175623416900635,
0.7849933505058289,
0.1840735226869583,
0.21516107022762299,
-1.0269758701324463,
-0.26384493708610535,
-0.34212416410446167,
-0.3065844178199768,
-0.819481611251831,
-0.33753281831741333,
0.4111572504043579,
0.031048346310853958,
-0.2902792692184448,
0.03451725095510483,
-0.629440426826477,
0.4119609594345093,
0.75618976354599,
-0.04975578933954239,
0.1389673352241516,
0.24122722446918488,
-0.011299632489681244,
-0.10250105708837509,
-0.5810743570327759,
-0.3098577857017517,
1.2458264827728271,
0.09334946423768997,
0.779822587966919,
0.02437152899801731,
0.9862043261528015,
0.1690051555633545,
0.357443243265152,
-0.660528302192688,
0.238862082362175,
0.0060292016714811325,
-0.12606020271778107,
-0.5287574529647827,
-0.44538038969039917,
-1.1860620975494385,
0.263058066368103,
-0.31825515627861023,
-1.018804907798767,
0.22050337493419647,
0.4926195442676544,
-0.5137157440185547,
0.16039150953292847,
-0.6453648805618286,
0.6732766032218933,
-0.5600058436393738,
-0.35525450110435486,
-0.08161208033561707,
-0.3625119924545288,
0.2835291922092438,
-0.12636595964431763,
0.3030931055545807,
-0.3027491271495819,
-0.1525896191596985,
0.5191443562507629,
-0.2943361699581146,
0.6249663829803467,
-0.17901280522346497,
0.04853791743516922,
0.07465748488903046,
-0.22469258308410645,
0.6574960947036743,
-0.16469436883926392,
-0.04008682817220688,
-0.3462422788143158,
0.2162175178527832,
-0.5736821293830872,
-0.6527407169342041,
0.7351354360580444,
-0.8094371557235718,
-0.45437416434288025,
-0.6269503831863403,
-0.7582154273986816,
-0.3066158592700958,
0.07486221194267273,
-0.08462241291999817,
-0.11183690279722214,
-0.2957451641559601,
-0.0018005961319431663,
0.7279475331306458,
-0.5275006294250488,
0.27002909779548645,
0.4345018267631531,
-0.36005067825317383,
-0.6229456663131714,
1.1390458345413208,
-0.2902138829231262,
0.3776724338531494,
0.7221816182136536,
0.43126532435417175,
-0.40029972791671753,
-0.5845961570739746,
-0.35513290762901306,
0.04695266857743263,
-0.33323630690574646,
-0.1300615817308426,
-0.29274609684944153,
0.007346657570451498,
-0.5607736706733704,
-0.2905690670013428,
-0.5906659960746765,
-0.09296958893537521,
-0.1963670253753662,
0.09515930712223053,
0.5354056358337402,
0.15152859687805176,
-0.2119465470314026,
0.2579593062400818,
-0.6814737915992737,
0.19836458563804626,
0.3468065559864044,
0.3997396230697632,
-0.3859812617301941,
-0.4784061014652252,
-0.2875661849975586,
0.11286833137273788,
-0.17102082073688507,
-0.6080179214477539,
0.561428964138031,
-0.022453881800174713,
0.5395172238349915,
0.21115969121456146,
0.030477596446871758,
0.7884076237678528,
-0.464526891708374,
0.5765896439552307,
0.11061237007379532,
-0.8162376880645752,
0.2012915462255478,
-0.0779423639178276,
0.21119116246700287,
0.8146989941596985,
0.13400612771511078,
-0.8175303339958191,
0.28157883882522583,
-0.5876169204711914,
-0.8249852061271667,
0.7413801550865173,
-0.09513463079929352,
0.16751134395599365,
0.21538761258125305,
0.3450404107570648,
-0.09318520128726959,
0.26342669129371643,
-0.6730723977088928,
0.00025480444310232997,
0.05200924351811409,
-0.496571809053421,
-0.15243476629257202,
-0.23151448369026184,
-0.20513145625591278,
-0.13322573900222778,
0.7899317145347595,
-0.4757726788520813,
0.16677680611610413,
-0.09918997436761856,
-0.03273764252662659,
-0.13154447078704834,
0.2835581302642822,
0.6903030276298523,
0.30983084440231323,
-0.28875643014907837,
0.018472474068403244,
0.2505751848220825,
-0.16611900925636292,
0.30929824709892273,
0.05882303789258003,
-0.13287635147571564,
-0.4701055884361267,
0.07980335503816605,
1.0573183298110962,
0.29774150252342224,
-1.0412888526916504,
0.6271845102310181,
0.03834708407521248,
-0.1198321282863617,
-0.33904150128364563,
0.18728114664554596,
0.06698737293481827,
0.3223305940628052,
0.049207549542188644,
-0.27749335765838623,
-0.14024099707603455,
-0.34971103072166443,
0.12105987221002579,
0.6178739666938782,
-0.2144242227077484,
-0.18344895541667938,
0.3400092124938965,
-0.04794831573963165,
-0.5204341411590576,
0.4991092085838318,
-0.20943211019039154,
-0.3880864977836609,
0.31116431951522827,
0.5375572443008423,
0.8547139167785645,
-0.4105952978134155,
0.103252112865448,
0.20270194113254547,
0.14911814033985138,
-0.050797536969184875,
0.3113681972026825,
-0.06543581932783127,
-1.0720323324203491,
-0.5942336916923523,
-0.6865686178207397,
-0.5987023711204529,
0.19407488405704498,
-0.6091060638427734,
0.3379788398742676,
-0.18181711435317993,
0.2889959514141083,
-0.4542490243911743,
0.0026345679070800543,
-0.48630988597869873,
0.18970470130443573,
0.24455319344997406,
0.7022477388381958,
-0.952233076095581,
0.9402469396591187,
0.5540716648101807,
-0.20269913971424103,
-0.7403948307037354,
-0.24772828817367554,
0.11030726879835129,
-1.1477521657943726,
0.488645076751709,
-0.3238257169723511,
-0.05696907266974449,
0.13491691648960114,
-0.39424577355384827,
-1.250921607017517,
1.0845239162445068,
0.4423075318336487,
-0.5812272429466248,
-0.07723867893218994,
-0.04780862480401993,
0.4236016869544983,
-0.5130563378334045,
0.24823065102100372,
0.5768659114837646,
0.3079588711261749,
0.2877947986125946,
-0.6851744055747986,
-0.1232379674911499,
-0.1314738392829895,
0.2710275650024414,
0.2305724024772644,
-0.41419050097465515,
0.49156996607780457,
-0.05380962789058685,
0.13030532002449036,
-0.15294679999351501,
0.5827275514602661,
0.9087392687797546,
-0.010786020196974277,
0.6948515176773071,
0.6277965903282166,
0.9043748378753662,
0.0474570132791996,
1.072876214981079,
-0.2401690036058426,
0.1757355034351349,
1.240505337715149,
-0.30872195959091187,
0.8858650326728821,
0.7742632627487183,
-0.24416477978229523,
0.3511916995048523,
0.8601839542388916,
0.07361815869808197,
0.7841300368309021,
0.529035747051239,
-0.36954107880592346,
-0.152713343501091,
-0.13132959604263306,
-0.09005437046289444,
0.275850385427475,
0.2798624634742737,
-0.06164129823446274,
-0.16490444540977478,
-0.05870484933257103,
-0.12748266756534576,
0.29166167974472046,
-0.1015738844871521,
0.8999423384666443,
-0.17971280217170715,
-0.8401625156402588,
0.6722888946533203,
0.06264261156320572,
0.6779745221138,
-0.648297905921936,
-0.06987181305885315,
-0.031143086031079292,
0.11835766583681107,
-0.14741265773773193,
-0.4155341386795044,
0.09400611370801926,
-0.04606863856315613,
0.014594562351703644,
-0.6168952584266663,
0.4047147333621979,
-0.6431094408035278,
-0.23403242230415344,
0.04902200773358345,
0.32634133100509644,
-0.0013631234178319573,
0.01904609613120556,
-0.6035937070846558,
0.2687453031539917,
0.09123814105987549,
-0.43886587023735046,
0.6946350932121277,
0.12276262789964676,
-0.2995798587799072,
0.6174017786979675,
0.8401505351066589,
0.48008283972740173,
0.05099734663963318,
0.056360118091106415,
0.8269031643867493,
-0.4901834726333618,
-0.657444179058075,
-0.7402515411376953,
0.5313490033149719,
-0.04846952483057976,
-0.31371966004371643,
0.32098421454429626,
0.5622634887695312,
1.0920714139938354,
0.18589304387569427,
0.9483160376548767,
0.23087657988071442,
0.6581728458404541,
-0.6960031986236572,
0.20236574113368988,
-0.709669291973114,
0.40287116169929504,
-0.1460328847169876,
-0.7641795873641968,
-0.19614726305007935,
0.48755943775177,
-0.49145951867103577,
0.01931791938841343,
0.4866316616535187,
0.8728899955749512,
0.026403995230793953,
-0.4533635973930359,
0.29717931151390076,
-0.317838191986084,
0.543327808380127,
0.6058275699615479,
0.520500898361206,
-0.05606936663389206,
0.2626582086086273,
-0.18903841078281403,
-0.4001131057739258,
-0.4094986915588379,
-1.0826499462127686,
-0.44185492396354675,
-0.6744987368583679,
-0.21864007413387299,
-0.2679997980594635,
0.10689542442560196,
1.401680827140808,
0.6875376105308533,
-0.8677666783332825,
-0.3828458786010742,
-0.14108873903751373,
0.18448635935783386,
-0.4540492296218872,
-0.14110885560512543,
0.45917433500289917,
-0.5362071394920349,
-0.978816032409668,
0.5602149367332458,
0.45005568861961365,
-0.04696812480688095,
-0.07567588239908218,
-0.38759133219718933,
-0.1815289407968521,
0.006894791964441538,
0.3985387980937958,
0.7172273993492126,
-0.7352423667907715,
-0.3740953207015991,
0.04211434721946716,
-0.04482000693678856,
0.39800992608070374,
0.730372965335846,
-0.8898544907569885,
0.8288376927375793,
0.5133617520332336,
1.2353897094726562,
0.655544638633728,
0.17734283208847046,
0.6491395235061646,
-0.7013078331947327,
0.1289674937725067,
0.39404296875,
0.13373388350009918,
0.27504459023475647,
-0.33530962467193604,
0.10470990091562271,
-0.011653701774775982,
-0.5943740606307983,
-0.9105831384658813,
0.43438467383384705,
-1.0813895463943481,
-0.023491429165005684,
1.0015555620193481,
-0.033763304352760315,
-0.3227214813232422,
0.16761164367198944,
-0.1467542201280594,
0.3319753408432007,
-0.40624651312828064,
0.9866890907287598,
0.5574948191642761,
-0.3055873215198517,
-0.3246500492095947,
-0.2419373095035553,
0.710295557975769,
0.5733628869056702,
-1.0116239786148071,
-0.04170732572674751,
0.3438059985637665,
0.341239869594574,
-0.16104726493358612,
0.868810772895813,
-0.006742265075445175,
0.032159045338630676,
-0.48031213879585266,
0.6058314442634583,
-0.1615276336669922,
-0.042721740901470184,
-0.6536309719085693,
-0.06805486232042313,
0.4447564482688904,
-0.32773271203041077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06636v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06636v2
|
Federated Document Visual Question Answering: A Pilot Study
| 2024-05-10T17:53:05 | 2024-05-22T11:01:22 |
Khanh Nguyen, Dimosthenis Karatzas
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
An important handicap of document analysis research is that documents tend to
be copyrighted or contain private information, which prohibits their open
publication and the creation of centralised, large-scale document datasets.
Instead, documents are scattered in private data silos, making extensive
training over heterogeneous data a tedious task. In this work, we explore the
use of a federated learning (FL) scheme as a way to train a shared model on
decentralised private document data. We focus on the problem of Document VQA, a
task particularly suited to this approach, as the type of reasoning
capabilities required from the model can be quite different in diverse domains.
Enabling training over heterogeneous document datasets can thus substantially
enrich DocVQA models. We assemble existing DocVQA datasets from diverse domains
to reflect the data heterogeneity in real-world applications. We explore the
self-pretraining technique in this multi-modal setting, where the same data is
used for both pretraining and finetuning, making it relevant for privacy
preservation. We further propose combining self-pretraining with a Federated
DocVQA training method using centralized adaptive optimization that outperforms
the FedAvg baseline. With extensive experiments, we also present a
multi-faceted analysis on training DocVQA models with FL, which provides
insights for future research on this task. We show that our pretraining
strategies can effectively learn and scale up under federated training with
diverse DocVQA datasets and tuning hyperparameters is essential for practical
document tasks under federation.
|
[
-0.3968941271305084,
-0.6842959523200989,
0.5038738250732422,
0.11522991210222244,
-0.07318762689828873,
0.008618157356977463,
0.0013229986652731895,
-0.25283291935920715,
-0.17054642736911774,
0.4959375858306885,
-0.9978222250938416,
-0.4393618404865265,
-0.4536020755767822,
0.19279590249061584,
-0.3102099597454071,
0.8364325761795044,
-0.3452044427394867,
0.37312641739845276,
-0.823878288269043,
-0.36509060859680176,
-0.20726704597473145,
-0.6198558807373047,
-0.10693222284317017,
-0.18893937766551971,
0.27939939498901367,
0.5448336005210876,
0.44909268617630005,
0.49063658714294434,
0.5763806700706482,
0.4100419878959656,
0.4739709794521332,
0.12762971222400665,
-0.7919266819953918,
0.16652795672416687,
-0.21989822387695312,
-0.7829762101173401,
-0.1421942263841629,
0.40152353048324585,
0.6817531585693359,
0.5657288432121277,
-0.08642912656068802,
0.11967616528272629,
-0.2989950180053711,
0.5474761724472046,
-0.6930188536643982,
0.42050066590309143,
-0.27728134393692017,
0.5078958868980408,
-0.1486164778470993,
-0.23138003051280975,
-0.19524823129177094,
-0.21933120489120483,
0.2537493109703064,
-1.1396005153656006,
0.6063079237937927,
0.1268346756696701,
1.0837643146514893,
0.35090941190719604,
-0.09043687582015991,
-0.17365334928035736,
-0.6160299777984619,
0.5513247847557068,
-0.16123667359352112,
0.578406810760498,
0.46075308322906494,
0.45015379786491394,
0.2336648851633072,
-1.2762870788574219,
-0.7231637239456177,
0.39521339535713196,
-0.18985743820667267,
0.4210997521877289,
-0.17906281352043152,
0.0472162701189518,
0.1769450306892395,
0.7573919892311096,
-0.43826213479042053,
0.08739694952964783,
-0.3798663318157196,
-0.41198334097862244,
0.4969303011894226,
0.047673169523477554,
0.044746220111846924,
-0.03351953625679016,
-0.6664541959762573,
-0.34477534890174866,
-0.1761239469051361,
0.14315052330493927,
0.40699464082717896,
0.0696861743927002,
-0.04180051013827324,
0.3257627487182617,
-0.5418838262557983,
0.5306729674339294,
0.38927826285362244,
-0.18919119238853455,
0.3550717532634735,
-0.46828433871269226,
-0.5552477836608887,
-0.4177170395851135,
0.6805269718170166,
0.031387437134981155,
0.09190011024475098,
-0.2297598421573639,
-0.33051395416259766,
-0.4873451292514801,
0.3027121126651764,
-0.6707990169525146,
-0.13819029927253723,
0.26122552156448364,
-0.2873443365097046,
-0.2698807120323181,
-0.004967221058905125,
-0.6203836798667908,
-0.2677464485168457,
-0.6816866993904114,
0.7054808139801025,
-0.29379478096961975,
-0.1938338279724121,
0.030609384179115295,
-0.19232292473316193,
0.40685370564460754,
0.6812219619750977,
-0.9686306118965149,
0.31423091888427734,
0.8685843348503113,
0.6114338636398315,
0.2728550434112549,
-0.7554242014884949,
-1.0489121675491333,
-0.15833456814289093,
-0.11224547028541565,
0.6442347764968872,
-0.2539311349391937,
-0.3003289997577667,
0.10169687867164612,
0.2727191150188446,
-0.4130317270755768,
-0.09506582468748093,
0.2808206081390381,
-0.6032376289367676,
0.974563479423523,
-0.43476635217666626,
-0.5645411610603333,
-0.08534339815378189,
0.5228800773620605,
-0.6758401393890381,
0.49416252970695496,
0.3952024579048157,
-1.13198721408844,
0.3984782099723816,
-0.41277605295181274,
-0.16429223120212555,
0.158932164311409,
-0.77813720703125,
-0.6863064169883728,
-0.1511206030845642,
0.44824501872062683,
0.68768310546875,
-0.17980186641216278,
0.1553642302751541,
-0.27449318766593933,
-0.2511133849620819,
-0.1954433172941208,
-0.30530068278312683,
0.8435893058776855,
0.18140412867069244,
-0.3729117214679718,
0.24783237278461456,
-0.5374231934547424,
0.00001701046494417824,
0.147251695394516,
-0.2844681143760681,
-0.3669707179069519,
-0.6795787215232849,
-0.020123813301324844,
0.10130204260349274,
0.270033061504364,
-0.5093681812286377,
0.23174433410167694,
-0.3250059187412262,
0.11741649359464645,
0.7886368036270142,
0.09187919646501541,
0.6001343131065369,
-0.40052634477615356,
0.6885871887207031,
0.0498310811817646,
0.545953094959259,
0.07681571692228317,
-0.15952220559120178,
-0.5214348435401917,
-0.4008020758628845,
0.33374255895614624,
0.2527700662612915,
-1.0395848751068115,
-0.19991493225097656,
-0.350735604763031,
-0.37674465775489807,
-0.5064978003501892,
0.13529428839683533,
0.5526824593544006,
0.6202919483184814,
0.15363986790180206,
-0.3904859721660614,
-0.04951166734099388,
-0.7622167468070984,
0.25694921612739563,
0.03703629970550537,
0.08436623215675354,
0.43105989694595337,
0.48798975348472595,
-0.15246179699897766,
0.8639155626296997,
-0.4233722984790802,
-0.6291436553001404,
0.20248816907405853,
0.4807533323764801,
-0.3810407817363739,
0.3426198661327362,
0.6346604228019714,
-1.324584722518921,
-0.3169761300086975,
-0.1086999699473381,
-0.8921400308609009,
0.1720457226037979,
-0.3070843517780304,
-0.19373059272766113,
0.15148019790649414,
0.5124781727790833,
-0.3232254385948181,
0.21415790915489197,
0.5951014161109924,
-0.3243800699710846,
0.5561704039573669,
-0.5946781635284424,
0.2072957158088684,
-0.9505627155303955,
-0.0647272914648056,
-0.3764823377132416,
-0.28384506702423096,
-0.5024151802062988,
0.41696956753730774,
0.14488303661346436,
-0.5369049310684204,
-0.3942912817001343,
0.4220571219921112,
-0.822008490562439,
-0.32797032594680786,
-0.028263363987207413,
-0.07080015540122986,
0.24823978543281555,
0.6225895285606384,
0.2540777921676636,
0.9086989164352417,
0.7359055280685425,
-0.010625345632433891,
0.17848122119903564,
0.7456506490707397,
0.02056290954351425,
0.8625278472900391,
-0.29873692989349365,
0.1694502979516983,
-0.38065940141677856,
0.07363741099834442,
-0.705161988735199,
-0.48675596714019775,
0.23901192843914032,
-0.25475433468818665,
0.3253370523452759,
0.1356962025165558,
-0.4747191071510315,
-0.2480793297290802,
-0.12119623273611069,
0.04796909540891647,
-0.061032019555568695,
-0.9161452054977417,
0.8766644597053528,
0.29005900025367737,
0.1412278413772583,
-0.9182330965995789,
-0.42864131927490234,
-0.31755709648132324,
-0.018544131889939308,
-0.9379889965057373,
0.07224015146493912,
-0.06447695195674896,
-0.012615256942808628,
0.049633532762527466,
-0.2595031261444092,
-0.5030522346496582,
0.3361316919326782,
0.7240852117538452,
-0.007919356226921082,
-0.4178543984889984,
0.300266832113266,
0.07304660230875015,
0.04514690116047859,
0.027172330766916275,
-0.29816409945487976,
0.28928476572036743,
-0.6389604210853577,
-0.3466455936431885,
-0.29152703285217285,
0.5821003913879395,
0.4961426258087158,
-0.7855015397071838,
0.8330081701278687,
0.8099649548530579,
-0.25271284580230713,
-0.35772547125816345,
-0.4741014838218689,
0.10604541748762131,
-0.5219716429710388,
-0.2454034984111786,
-0.5272267460823059,
-1.0803885459899902,
0.3935469686985016,
-0.15681114792823792,
0.11059051007032394,
0.23385824263095856,
0.5259862542152405,
-0.22966596484184265,
0.0674954503774643,
1.0770152807235718,
0.08376729488372803,
0.5069815516471863,
-0.5192063450813293,
-0.1985832154750824,
-0.1757608950138092,
-0.2613047957420349,
-0.3103785812854767,
0.17765796184539795,
-0.375201016664505,
-0.5630679726600647,
0.2723918855190277,
-0.01230536587536335,
-0.04112772271037102,
0.056967150419950485,
-0.3558695316314697,
0.5871188044548035,
0.7045865058898926,
0.17387636005878448,
0.394966721534729,
0.02544555440545082,
-0.14769519865512848,
0.26838961243629456,
-0.7958407998085022,
0.045228295028209686,
1.156947374343872,
0.25574105978012085,
0.6815769672393799,
-0.2963273525238037,
1.0731500387191772,
0.17618437111377716,
0.36164361238479614,
-0.4619901180267334,
0.14042864739894867,
-0.04167899861931801,
-0.6186844110488892,
-0.665542721748352,
-0.4850497841835022,
-0.7197849154472351,
0.27120956778526306,
-0.488347589969635,
-0.2724876403808594,
0.6503706574440002,
-0.017359090968966484,
-0.37691861391067505,
0.01715499721467495,
-0.7991173267364502,
1.0224546194076538,
-0.1934771090745926,
-0.4797869622707367,
0.03891992196440697,
-0.8614466190338135,
0.35887420177459717,
-0.3906305730342865,
0.09672916680574417,
0.3121882379055023,
0.39969485998153687,
0.6895049810409546,
-0.5677237510681152,
0.7316418886184692,
-0.2465386539697647,
0.045043520629405975,
0.061106547713279724,
-0.3739830553531647,
0.1934872567653656,
0.1820303052663803,
-0.04198957607150078,
0.2073928564786911,
0.2485796958208084,
-0.5858736038208008,
-0.6310409307479858,
0.5765359401702881,
-1.1020601987838745,
-0.7465653419494629,
-0.524797797203064,
-0.5226456522941589,
-0.39223241806030273,
0.4614681005477905,
0.38506096601486206,
0.6461543440818787,
-0.24526001513004303,
0.4535388648509979,
0.8377100229263306,
0.12500636279582977,
0.19350649416446686,
0.6929282546043396,
0.1327269822359085,
-0.28865665197372437,
0.6619818210601807,
0.1471245437860489,
0.3617728650569916,
0.5051220655441284,
0.20627133548259735,
-0.30242908000946045,
-0.537566602230072,
-0.17470352351665497,
0.35292717814445496,
-1.0347557067871094,
-0.10024196654558182,
-0.7797336578369141,
-0.28110647201538086,
-0.4808027446269989,
-0.3143250644207001,
-0.3734305799007416,
-0.21562542021274567,
-0.4395146071910858,
-0.1437305063009262,
0.12454544752836227,
0.315832257270813,
-0.2447705715894699,
0.38776105642318726,
-0.6164675354957581,
0.40104353427886963,
0.6850062608718872,
0.5147284269332886,
-0.28566989302635193,
0.06388328969478607,
-0.15872400999069214,
-0.09681065380573273,
-0.07659468054771423,
-0.5205907821655273,
0.02071687951683998,
0.21044611930847168,
0.7903560996055603,
0.26515525579452515,
0.40472865104675293,
0.4070257842540741,
-0.3255296051502228,
0.39297449588775635,
0.09272817522287369,
-0.7018724083900452,
0.2346813678741455,
-0.43774598836898804,
0.2030922770500183,
1.0809996128082275,
0.8017143607139587,
-0.1821894645690918,
-0.37557536363601685,
-0.8538458347320557,
-0.3337680399417877,
0.6944087147712708,
0.43479183316230774,
-0.013148263096809387,
0.5430419445037842,
0.34122544527053833,
0.2891022861003876,
0.27829474210739136,
-0.4725298583507538,
-0.08295227587223053,
-0.7322393655776978,
-0.08837844431400299,
-0.0779913142323494,
0.23062440752983093,
-0.6287980079650879,
-0.23234379291534424,
0.4039941728115082,
-0.43047472834587097,
0.244064599275589,
0.5517017841339111,
-0.07064902037382126,
-0.12927213311195374,
0.059569865465164185,
0.1772121638059616,
0.693281352519989,
-0.2276197075843811,
-0.2502128481864929,
-0.32520660758018494,
-0.5694871544837952,
0.06434864550828934,
0.6418801546096802,
-0.11930914223194122,
-0.11742773652076721,
0.3610823452472687,
0.9311702847480774,
0.04091433435678482,
-0.3490363359451294,
1.002502202987671,
-0.7351998090744019,
-0.7704450488090515,
-0.24597251415252686,
0.14705613255500793,
0.03523367643356323,
0.46077612042427063,
0.09477947652339935,
-0.024567853659391403,
-0.026170983910560608,
-0.6199087500572205,
0.38165557384490967,
0.27394434809684753,
-0.2614939510822296,
0.004297188483178616,
0.7476902008056641,
0.2780623137950897,
-0.21036870777606964,
0.5377562046051025,
0.06949868053197861,
-0.393412321805954,
0.47587665915489197,
0.06981447339057922,
0.6126711964607239,
0.016845421865582466,
0.6890677213668823,
0.02375268004834652,
0.22722509503364563,
-0.15335023403167725,
0.243911474943161,
-0.6720098853111267,
-0.6262215375900269,
0.16341911256313324,
-0.6312549710273743,
-0.725565493106842,
0.18403896689414978,
-0.7156760692596436,
-0.07744971662759781,
-0.620411217212677,
0.18539336323738098,
0.22610460221767426,
0.39276787638664246,
-1.0826201438903809,
0.5430309176445007,
0.0994778722524643,
0.8021802306175232,
-0.8969954252243042,
0.8206185698509216,
0.4484141767024994,
-0.7270703911781311,
-1.1471290588378906,
0.16186955571174622,
0.038384824991226196,
-0.6566344499588013,
0.3554456830024719,
0.11642845720052719,
0.12116333097219467,
0.09126526117324829,
-0.6017582416534424,
-0.6030392646789551,
1.4274181127548218,
0.15631388127803802,
-0.46988633275032043,
-0.2554647922515869,
0.19137786328792572,
0.6997088193893433,
-0.33940261602401733,
-0.08607044070959091,
0.2202291339635849,
0.24116426706314087,
0.11235792189836502,
-0.7366605997085571,
0.026251336559653282,
-0.14550715684890747,
-0.3449711799621582,
-0.21899297833442688,
-0.8196353912353516,
1.033347487449646,
0.06236717104911804,
-0.3977676331996918,
-0.1638745814561844,
0.7863603234291077,
-0.21482795476913452,
0.5960697531700134,
0.6035121083259583,
0.29095983505249023,
1.229880452156067,
0.11340464651584625,
1.144708514213562,
-0.0366060733795166,
0.502174973487854,
1.478013038635254,
-0.11882682889699936,
0.4037802219390869,
0.36344388127326965,
0.315666139125824,
0.10874540358781815,
0.4074626564979553,
-0.10692891478538513,
0.5875719785690308,
-0.21099042892456055,
-0.25187140703201294,
-0.43899446725845337,
0.13574166595935822,
-0.4612210988998413,
0.6543441414833069,
-0.005898234434425831,
-0.3028101623058319,
-0.5478124022483826,
0.3018821179866791,
-0.3740725517272949,
0.33941125869750977,
-0.13090910017490387,
0.7533363103866577,
-0.017945051193237305,
-0.47855818271636963,
0.487975537776947,
-0.1545436531305313,
0.30738958716392517,
-0.7330283522605896,
0.2540627419948578,
-0.5046574473381042,
0.04023592174053192,
-0.12220260500907898,
-0.5807527899742126,
0.18401017785072327,
-0.166820228099823,
-0.21568509936332703,
-0.5885956883430481,
0.7445598840713501,
-0.28416135907173157,
-0.22155922651290894,
0.05198999121785164,
0.9180122017860413,
-0.1664472222328186,
-0.06248035281896591,
-0.6244691014289856,
-0.34990912675857544,
-0.09471771121025085,
-0.23624931275844574,
0.5209231376647949,
0.7095984220504761,
-0.11561886221170425,
0.584187924861908,
0.6150379180908203,
-0.40991148352622986,
-0.03880399838089943,
0.06761714816093445,
1.1649724245071411,
-0.15096744894981384,
-0.8984658718109131,
0.006870483048260212,
0.24573905766010284,
-0.12142789363861084,
-0.46160992980003357,
0.8043748736381531,
0.3818470239639282,
1.1236697435379028,
-0.2710501253604889,
0.5237667560577393,
0.20108799636363983,
0.18641297519207,
-0.5004342198371887,
1.1285028457641602,
-0.6973094940185547,
-0.2228359431028366,
-0.16871200501918793,
-0.4585280120372772,
0.014960089698433876,
0.30914613604545593,
-0.5611501336097717,
-0.6345180869102478,
0.584208071231842,
0.6357841491699219,
-0.35147732496261597,
0.37122946977615356,
0.36274832487106323,
-0.12139307707548141,
0.2980470657348633,
0.3021846115589142,
0.60842365026474,
-0.3877093493938446,
0.4281209707260132,
-0.7430909276008606,
-0.16763657331466675,
0.03142629936337471,
-0.5061156153678894,
-0.954273521900177,
-1.004359483718872,
-0.32442760467529297,
-0.001587491831742227,
0.23521928489208221,
0.42582640051841736,
0.8291656374931335,
-0.2873550057411194,
0.24373050034046173,
0.016435883939266205,
0.019967230036854744,
-0.03418029844760895,
-0.23006023466587067,
0.337956964969635,
-0.12183137983083725,
-0.4509836435317993,
0.25930821895599365,
-0.035577498376369476,
0.20546473562717438,
-0.3891093134880066,
0.033988744020462036,
-0.36482343077659607,
0.0005835662595927715,
0.18020661175251007,
0.41297608613967896,
-0.17660821974277496,
-0.34183916449546814,
-0.04109107330441475,
-0.2781440317630768,
0.28935691714286804,
0.7392024397850037,
-0.6879567503929138,
0.8051519989967346,
0.5550082921981812,
0.9522799253463745,
0.8026736974716187,
0.39045432209968567,
0.5755754113197327,
-0.9207713603973389,
0.27800682187080383,
0.1760953962802887,
0.19018203020095825,
0.40733107924461365,
-0.7856205701828003,
0.5220134258270264,
0.35277774930000305,
-0.4949941635131836,
-0.6264456510543823,
-0.1030268594622612,
-0.9784784913063049,
-0.37880146503448486,
0.6150301694869995,
-0.7297921776771545,
-0.47849240899086,
0.01060763094574213,
0.007427292875945568,
0.2572631537914276,
0.0039992136880755424,
0.6320416331291199,
0.6941236853599548,
0.11311069130897522,
-0.24199344217777252,
-0.231791689991951,
0.5728372931480408,
0.20593422651290894,
-1.1157779693603516,
-0.01884554885327816,
0.7529000639915466,
0.4606948792934418,
0.23865407705307007,
1.1095967292785645,
0.10774394869804382,
0.5147217512130737,
0.38987022638320923,
-0.29377785325050354,
-0.5909862518310547,
-0.5341821312904358,
-0.555036723613739,
0.5542116761207581,
-0.42321571707725525,
-0.3444770574569702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06634v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06634v2
|
Multimodal LLMs Struggle with Basic Visual Network Analysis: a VNA Benchmark
| 2024-05-10T17:51:35 | 2024-06-10T15:28:16 |
Evan M. Williams, Kathleen M. Carley
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We evaluate the zero-shot ability of GPT-4 and LLaVa to perform simple Visual
Network Analysis (VNA) tasks on small-scale graphs. We evaluate the Vision
Language Models (VLMs) on 5 tasks related to three foundational network science
concepts: identifying nodes of maximal degree on a rendered graph, identifying
whether signed triads are balanced or unbalanced, and counting components. The
tasks are structured to be easy for a human who understands the underlying
graph theoretic concepts, and can all be solved by counting the appropriate
elements in graphs. We find that while GPT-4 consistently outperforms LLaVa,
both models struggle with every visual network analysis task we propose. We
publicly release the first benchmark for the evaluation of VLMs on foundational
VNA tasks.
|
[
-0.27727341651916504,
-0.7218479514122009,
0.6283936500549316,
0.25278201699256897,
-0.2933347821235657,
0.19686979055404663,
0.13458451628684998,
-0.4861290752887726,
0.2095506638288498,
0.3902702331542969,
-0.5888286232948303,
-0.4870874583721161,
-0.5562108755111694,
0.37607213854789734,
-0.3296465575695038,
0.5277473330497742,
-0.1305980384349823,
0.08202346414327621,
-0.3144735097885132,
-0.41670897603034973,
-0.44683167338371277,
-0.2503277063369751,
-0.6010310649871826,
-0.27547487616539,
0.8416129350662231,
0.41690823435783386,
0.28461602330207825,
0.46436044573783875,
0.9259713292121887,
0.41045165061950684,
-0.047841545194387436,
0.18382872641086578,
-0.5953514575958252,
-0.007987544871866703,
0.1567709892988205,
-0.35904660820961,
-0.6027178168296814,
-0.095584437251091,
0.7462413311004639,
0.8134318590164185,
0.16246716678142548,
0.38437148928642273,
-0.11655212193727493,
0.8809244632720947,
-0.34506115317344666,
0.4113265573978424,
-0.5962840914726257,
0.1211773082613945,
-0.46381503343582153,
-0.1493542194366455,
-0.23455481231212616,
-0.05229532718658447,
0.037281375378370285,
-0.5996677875518799,
0.17032784223556519,
0.020351769402623177,
1.0224623680114746,
0.2964199483394623,
-0.7931081056594849,
0.1758589893579483,
-0.29652273654937744,
0.5448258519172668,
-0.3626979887485504,
0.29430317878723145,
-0.13414433598518372,
0.6565271019935608,
0.05196449160575867,
-0.9962921142578125,
-0.5343552231788635,
-0.3629455864429474,
0.32271766662597656,
0.1569763422012329,
-0.5867890119552612,
0.24308517575263977,
0.47990313172340393,
0.20174388587474823,
-0.5781225562095642,
-0.036443404853343964,
-0.7559618949890137,
-0.2167275995016098,
0.26132211089134216,
0.4653608798980713,
0.20670492947101593,
-0.324516624212265,
-0.47210693359375,
0.14110350608825684,
-0.5721919536590576,
0.014979568310081959,
0.2496776431798935,
0.2718295156955719,
-0.17633484303951263,
0.9224410057067871,
-0.6523403525352478,
0.8663026690483093,
-0.2304265797138214,
-0.0029820865020155907,
0.5402566194534302,
-0.7322179675102234,
-0.6669881939888,
-0.5314769744873047,
0.6464264988899231,
0.5268195271492004,
0.43933144211769104,
-0.04441426321864128,
0.006098189856857061,
0.3788348138332367,
0.2558678686618805,
-0.685637354850769,
-0.5329979062080383,
-0.012329784221947193,
-0.3841570019721985,
-0.387927770614624,
-0.3851233720779419,
-0.4575625956058502,
-0.34279361367225647,
-0.3927781283855438,
0.586004376411438,
-0.08590248972177505,
-0.1261579543352127,
-0.10551133006811142,
-0.30774834752082825,
0.4185656011104584,
0.5049349665641785,
-0.4354287087917328,
0.4841594994068146,
0.33153027296066284,
1.085822343826294,
-0.3827038109302521,
-0.3697752356529236,
-0.4088353216648102,
-0.1750289648771286,
-0.11066053062677383,
0.894654393196106,
-0.08178060501813889,
-0.1476517617702484,
-0.5059657692909241,
0.19266532361507416,
-0.3096046447753906,
-0.3243572413921356,
-0.005494299810379744,
-0.3611735999584198,
-0.43712303042411804,
-0.5704885125160217,
-0.3195079267024994,
-0.299810528755188,
0.6088172197341919,
-0.8242948055267334,
0.555367648601532,
0.031511902809143066,
-0.7333974242210388,
0.3151123523712158,
-0.5825966000556946,
-0.08281509578227997,
0.2204132080078125,
-0.6094575524330139,
-0.22767861187458038,
0.15033262968063354,
-0.03318259119987488,
0.38930490612983704,
-0.1688133031129837,
-0.22445479035377502,
-0.5241469740867615,
-0.34229931235313416,
-0.007081165909767151,
-0.5259096622467041,
0.8952437043190002,
-0.04156899079680443,
-0.23751458525657654,
0.41137558221817017,
-0.7473495006561279,
0.2429640144109726,
0.3584020733833313,
-0.1435592621564865,
0.07329849898815155,
-0.16623935103416443,
-0.16151534020900726,
0.08602117747068405,
0.13004061579704285,
-0.5191613435745239,
0.3513498604297638,
-0.10856840014457703,
0.34386515617370605,
0.770493745803833,
-0.14380747079849243,
0.08871335536241531,
0.050052862614393234,
0.4376269280910492,
-0.027285272255539894,
0.16888442635536194,
0.02076883614063263,
-0.8953189849853516,
-0.7909186482429504,
-0.3448578715324402,
0.0901559591293335,
0.4879060685634613,
-1.3184106349945068,
-0.46361106634140015,
-0.3959387540817261,
-0.4937238097190857,
-0.03095257468521595,
0.548797070980072,
0.5687025785446167,
0.46331289410591125,
0.23317871987819672,
-0.802639365196228,
-0.4018709659576416,
-1.1033945083618164,
0.02304987795650959,
-0.049768730998039246,
0.27136218547821045,
0.4016858637332916,
0.6318063139915466,
-0.22632969915866852,
0.8257526755332947,
-0.42303624749183655,
-0.35959529876708984,
-0.3023192584514618,
0.19240446388721466,
0.04175616800785065,
-0.03340417146682739,
0.6395363807678223,
-0.60500568151474,
-0.5414630174636841,
0.11614619940519333,
-1.1179137229919434,
-0.14049771428108215,
0.4232850968837738,
0.27855178713798523,
-0.12572546303272247,
0.47372016310691833,
-0.47839558124542236,
0.4871923327445984,
0.6847375631332397,
-0.3086411654949188,
0.5387066602706909,
-0.01503448560833931,
0.0734122097492218,
-0.5202032327651978,
0.03887856379151344,
0.230346217751503,
-0.43416616320610046,
-0.7756867408752441,
0.07270945608615875,
0.05004651099443436,
-0.17361681163311005,
-0.6666544079780579,
0.36983388662338257,
-0.6711897253990173,
-0.6143597364425659,
-0.15918856859207153,
0.12856809794902802,
-0.048338208347558975,
0.6190008521080017,
-0.3408752381801605,
0.7541360259056091,
0.5818896889686584,
-0.4019048810005188,
0.6322446465492249,
-0.12190841883420944,
-0.1985599398612976,
0.6016456484794617,
-0.8305152058601379,
0.059663206338882446,
-0.04073495790362358,
0.011380808427929878,
-1.3301279544830322,
-0.18709643185138702,
0.36218497157096863,
-0.2773612439632416,
0.10375545918941498,
-0.3017011284828186,
-0.24056990444660187,
-0.505084216594696,
-0.3224128186702728,
0.4922691583633423,
0.1127578616142273,
-0.20249159634113312,
0.5517527461051941,
0.26212891936302185,
0.22756370902061462,
-0.5931445360183716,
-0.6762329936027527,
0.32239776849746704,
-0.06069840490818024,
-0.834467887878418,
0.04738524183630943,
-0.008558588102459908,
-0.2445194572210312,
0.17031580209732056,
-0.26946911215782166,
-0.24588192999362946,
0.14662981033325195,
0.33092862367630005,
0.08828992396593094,
-0.48474907875061035,
-0.2634487748146057,
-0.4641905426979065,
-0.30806058645248413,
-0.07504978030920029,
-0.07931023836135864,
0.2584228217601776,
-0.7680113315582275,
-0.7049925327301025,
-0.36825862526893616,
-0.06783981621265411,
0.5507097244262695,
-0.07585237175226212,
0.0761968120932579,
0.6584259867668152,
-0.008914167061448097,
0.14047011733055115,
-0.4404996633529663,
0.1690218597650528,
-0.5150566101074219,
0.4006548523902893,
-0.5733357667922974,
-0.7223485708236694,
0.3457052409648895,
-0.16913250088691711,
-0.23871281743049622,
0.3805759847164154,
0.3910976052284241,
-0.2977767884731293,
0.6870966553688049,
0.8427848219871521,
0.24229390919208527,
0.3969089388847351,
-0.5296156406402588,
0.006374054122716188,
-0.8140552043914795,
0.05271368846297264,
-0.03237178921699524,
-0.45846131443977356,
-0.46599826216697693,
-0.5938392281532288,
0.5337934494018555,
0.04295295849442482,
-0.20105336606502533,
0.344188928604126,
-0.28951847553253174,
0.5387440323829651,
0.5116230249404907,
0.21809352934360504,
0.33500322699546814,
0.2712700366973877,
-0.21875159442424774,
0.038582153618335724,
-0.6350269317626953,
-0.33365002274513245,
1.3875412940979004,
0.2639926075935364,
0.49812760949134827,
0.32511815428733826,
0.5129609704017639,
0.2385169267654419,
0.29170459508895874,
-0.7587558627128601,
0.7402718663215637,
-0.2642810344696045,
-0.42108333110809326,
-0.30660003423690796,
-0.4528938829898834,
-0.8176935911178589,
0.5504922866821289,
0.036824654787778854,
-0.8266213536262512,
0.26809731125831604,
0.339532732963562,
-0.016884975135326385,
0.312866747379303,
-0.6827393770217896,
1.1067456007003784,
-0.37730100750923157,
-0.4144367277622223,
0.14777930080890656,
-0.7032386660575867,
0.8255763053894043,
0.21124078333377838,
-0.06739103049039841,
-0.4025537967681885,
-0.12407179921865463,
0.4619123041629791,
-0.30701881647109985,
1.1414284706115723,
-0.18292248249053955,
0.3420273959636688,
0.32390302419662476,
0.032317712903022766,
0.1477055549621582,
-0.2994273006916046,
0.2811800539493561,
0.5581381916999817,
0.013827510178089142,
-0.5846050977706909,
-0.4150035083293915,
0.5188494920730591,
-0.6677248477935791,
-0.44143539667129517,
-0.47610557079315186,
-0.11394801735877991,
-0.14281395077705383,
0.22294437885284424,
0.10232943296432495,
0.48624905943870544,
-0.11230414360761642,
0.3572782874107361,
0.4430219531059265,
0.2108440399169922,
0.4988929331302643,
0.3609796166419983,
-0.46469631791114807,
-0.2987084984779358,
0.9968934059143066,
0.2575777471065521,
0.5697295665740967,
-0.011559080332517624,
-0.04997653141617775,
-0.01853550225496292,
-0.72440505027771,
-0.7683740854263306,
0.051823921501636505,
-1.0391230583190918,
-0.12116481363773346,
-0.48989033699035645,
-0.2557474672794342,
0.07743126899003983,
0.23217222094535828,
-0.324849396944046,
-0.28925856947898865,
-0.032267309725284576,
-0.01815114915370941,
0.1947394162416458,
0.7636158466339111,
-0.07081031799316406,
0.4565136134624481,
-0.35532277822494507,
0.5505382418632507,
0.675070583820343,
0.24989688396453857,
-0.14441385865211487,
-0.11879051476716995,
-0.026081588119268417,
-0.31665804982185364,
-0.4708718955516815,
-0.9724100828170776,
0.10819967836141586,
0.004886199254542589,
0.6057372689247131,
0.2683057487010956,
-0.6079028844833374,
0.7459585070610046,
-0.5295513272285461,
0.8200830221176147,
0.4865027964115143,
-0.885679304599762,
0.15575455129146576,
-0.24101422727108002,
0.06229207292199135,
0.6099812984466553,
0.051329050213098526,
-0.16562797129154205,
0.07461635023355484,
-0.24424368143081665,
-0.7458968758583069,
0.2935277223587036,
0.5022181272506714,
-0.0641196221113205,
-0.05916193127632141,
0.014631766825914383,
-0.3922404944896698,
0.38629552721977234,
-0.9173722267150879,
-0.41048702597618103,
-0.4582813084125519,
-0.06465225666761398,
-0.20527273416519165,
-0.20517577230930328,
-0.22661522030830383,
-0.40075066685676575,
-0.006132963579148054,
-0.5114133358001709,
0.2832542359828949,
0.1829083263874054,
-0.29781854152679443,
-0.02502884529531002,
-0.10375646501779556,
0.8317988514900208,
0.964323103427887,
-0.29490000009536743,
0.27189573645591736,
0.21600008010864258,
-0.44913575053215027,
0.18427817523479462,
-0.20645366609096527,
-0.08586330711841583,
0.16873715817928314,
0.598324716091156,
0.8794772624969482,
0.39592844247817993,
-0.3186483085155487,
0.8713175058364868,
-0.26225337386131287,
-0.3256227970123291,
-0.06476274132728577,
-0.03366214781999588,
0.2470315545797348,
0.26164594292640686,
0.20068538188934326,
0.26566842198371887,
0.18757404386997223,
-0.3851473033428192,
0.18092826008796692,
0.5670547485351562,
-0.4113103151321411,
-0.37222060561180115,
0.5445691347122192,
0.3597448468208313,
-0.1396944671869278,
0.4662109613418579,
-0.39165735244750977,
-0.39335963129997253,
1.116249680519104,
0.2502796947956085,
0.8359861969947815,
0.21781374514102936,
0.2575049102306366,
0.029277021065354347,
0.5687467455863953,
0.1799795925617218,
0.5645524859428406,
0.0334814228117466,
-0.7837767004966736,
-0.4346179664134979,
-0.3988422751426697,
-0.4857710599899292,
-0.10332977026700974,
-0.3924373686313629,
0.09237248450517654,
-0.43455269932746887,
-0.3313368558883667,
0.23051652312278748,
0.0021541959140449762,
-1.1455186605453491,
0.10750608891248703,
-0.00181818928103894,
0.7485193014144897,
-0.9049160480499268,
0.8667462468147278,
0.524098813533783,
-0.660431981086731,
-0.7300483584403992,
-0.4472186863422394,
0.5768416523933411,
-1.0208379030227661,
1.197251796722412,
0.18512572348117828,
-0.37523043155670166,
0.16317732632160187,
-0.629301905632019,
-0.8238236904144287,
1.430165410041809,
0.2021060734987259,
-0.5876141786575317,
0.09116585552692413,
-0.13606853783130646,
0.35653355717658997,
-0.2596031725406647,
0.3060314655303955,
0.22814275324344635,
0.5098766684532166,
0.17442747950553894,
-1.1047697067260742,
-0.16043148934841156,
-0.28683891892433167,
-0.016168834641575813,
-0.1960008591413498,
-0.6426979303359985,
1.4107859134674072,
-0.269060879945755,
-0.23521989583969116,
-0.0026723849587142467,
0.4928368031978607,
0.21005240082740784,
0.6726901531219482,
0.6050135493278503,
0.5165625810623169,
0.6419114470481873,
-0.010936056263744831,
1.115471363067627,
-0.11817122995853424,
0.24944445490837097,
1.1031012535095215,
-0.4845742881298065,
0.649218738079071,
0.5796611309051514,
-0.2247646301984787,
0.16352340579032898,
0.4254148304462433,
-0.11479505896568298,
0.4251137971878052,
0.30764082074165344,
-0.013185299001634121,
-0.2411247342824936,
0.25232261419296265,
-0.34907302260398865,
0.5676067471504211,
0.17128612101078033,
-0.029938699677586555,
-0.3991225063800812,
-0.07462989538908005,
-0.32062435150146484,
-0.3367343246936798,
-0.4723982810974121,
0.648142397403717,
0.29839977622032166,
0.014839033596217632,
0.5461394786834717,
-0.16521818935871124,
0.4131525158882141,
-0.6077573299407959,
-0.03225011005997658,
-0.2821991741657257,
0.14237970113754272,
-0.1863303929567337,
-0.7476054430007935,
0.175278440117836,
-0.024868683889508247,
-0.05286456272006035,
0.14983108639717102,
0.7678107619285583,
0.09343346208333969,
-0.5172833204269409,
0.4710647165775299,
0.852919340133667,
0.4152674973011017,
-0.02058221399784088,
-0.6684929132461548,
0.3234792947769165,
0.007593571674078703,
-0.20945090055465698,
0.25654199719429016,
0.3959433138370514,
-0.14276495575904846,
0.8939676880836487,
0.5573264360427856,
0.09300713986158371,
0.4382944107055664,
0.186050146818161,
1.0630172491073608,
-0.7912787199020386,
0.10647278279066086,
-0.85500168800354,
0.5141724944114685,
-0.3807491958141327,
-0.323837012052536,
0.9637597799301147,
0.358519047498703,
0.7136505246162415,
-0.1280471831560135,
0.5401763916015625,
0.15915583074092865,
-0.15007124841213226,
-0.56137615442276,
0.3961029052734375,
-0.8200656771659851,
0.22810770571231842,
-0.33939042687416077,
-0.9395893812179565,
-0.42261040210723877,
0.39919593930244446,
-0.2366572767496109,
-0.07287479192018509,
0.8648799061775208,
0.6988238096237183,
-0.3943454623222351,
-0.44983187317848206,
0.6615211367607117,
0.09233727306127548,
0.3108587861061096,
0.5000478029251099,
0.8413165807723999,
-0.40641024708747864,
0.5809940099716187,
-0.2382960319519043,
-0.13414213061332703,
-0.29680150747299194,
-1.172730803489685,
-0.9136877655982971,
-0.18870888650417328,
-0.25187361240386963,
-0.12161079049110413,
0.04569273069500923,
0.40640950202941895,
0.7334945797920227,
-0.4364754259586334,
-0.34596386551856995,
-0.09920790046453476,
0.22871902585029602,
-0.21426908671855927,
-0.16032816469669342,
0.3059689402580261,
-0.22997593879699707,
-0.3069492280483246,
0.5952058434486389,
0.6416860222816467,
0.03620576858520508,
-0.38262349367141724,
0.009804358705878258,
-0.004147849045693874,
-0.038884617388248444,
0.7913627028465271,
0.4892323315143585,
-0.9893937110900879,
-0.4682250916957855,
-0.024018386378884315,
-0.3035326600074768,
0.1947222352027893,
0.7309419512748718,
-0.640711784362793,
0.6934334635734558,
0.5434828400611877,
0.4769013822078705,
0.6151633262634277,
0.05612071603536606,
0.2621171474456787,
-0.7478080987930298,
0.03954341635107994,
-0.1340504139661789,
0.5888705849647522,
0.2999041974544525,
0.16749107837677002,
0.7377865314483643,
0.7321053743362427,
-0.3432061970233917,
-0.8557829260826111,
0.3611223101615906,
-1.4433515071868896,
-0.12312877923250198,
0.9021884799003601,
-0.18207134306430817,
-0.4139057695865631,
-0.1956952065229416,
-0.09053146094083786,
-0.12486261129379272,
0.2090972512960434,
0.15670768916606903,
0.41234225034713745,
-0.2998753786087036,
-0.3317855894565582,
-0.9638996124267578,
0.29880937933921814,
0.09584254026412964,
-0.6198095679283142,
-0.36439019441604614,
0.5190594792366028,
0.6503599286079407,
0.08028604835271835,
1.1824206113815308,
0.21159668266773224,
0.30849066376686096,
0.33776015043258667,
0.09452394396066666,
-0.5203817486763,
-0.5409080386161804,
-0.4135698974132538,
0.3844241797924042,
0.06454353034496307,
-0.4720425307750702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06626v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06626v1
|
Characterizing the Accuracy - Efficiency Trade-off of Low-rank Decomposition in Language Models
| 2024-05-10T17:40:02 | 2024-05-10T17:40:02 |
Chakshu Moar, Michael Pellauer, Hyoukjun Kwon
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged and presented their general
problem-solving capabilities with one model. However, the model size has
increased dramatically with billions of parameters to enable such broad
problem-solving capabilities. In addition, due to the dominance of
matrix-matrix and matrix-vector multiplications in LLMs, the compute-to-model
size ratio is significantly lower than that of CNNs. This shift pushes LLMs
from a computation-bound regime to a memory-bound regime. Therefore, optimizing
the memory footprint and traffic is an important optimization direction for
LLMs today.
Model compression methods such as quantization and parameter pruning have
been actively explored for achieving the memory footprint and traffic
optimization. However, the accuracy-efficiency trade-off of rank pruning for
LLMs is not well-understood yet. Therefore, we characterize the
accuracy-efficiency trade-off of a low-rank decomposition method, specifically
Tucker decomposition, on recent language models, including an open-source LLM,
Llama 2.
We formalize the low-rank decomposition design space and show that the
decomposition design space is enormous (e.g., O($2^{37}$) for Llama2-7B). To
navigate such a vast design space, we formulate the design space and perform
thorough case studies of accuracy-efficiency trade-offs using six widely used
LLM benchmarks on BERT and Llama 2 models. Our results show that we can achieve
a 9\% model size reduction with minimal accuracy drops, which range from 4\%p
to 10\%p, depending on the difficulty of the benchmark, without any retraining
to recover accuracy after decomposition. The results show that low-rank
decomposition can be a promising direction for LLM-based applications that
require real-time service in scale (e.g., AI agent assist and real-time coding
assistant), where the latency is as important as the model accuracy.
|
[
-0.40338048338890076,
-0.6571381688117981,
0.7423582077026367,
-0.012551079504191875,
-0.2669161558151245,
0.2415713220834732,
-0.35355332493782043,
-0.2978048026561737,
0.07456526905298233,
0.23812812566757202,
-0.3858557939529419,
-0.3194338381290436,
-0.6019619703292847,
-0.21355028450489044,
-0.2763616442680359,
0.27443528175354004,
0.07913770526647568,
-0.1579941213130951,
-0.3999944031238556,
0.009853838011622429,
-0.2541853189468384,
-0.7034751176834106,
-0.8740944266319275,
-0.07785168290138245,
0.5037461519241333,
0.3156510889530182,
0.6076593995094299,
0.9175570011138916,
0.6432264447212219,
0.22820430994033813,
-0.40599510073661804,
0.09277666360139847,
-0.8089182376861572,
0.061350803822278976,
0.2780836224555969,
-0.4024742543697357,
-0.7845432758331299,
-0.036849312484264374,
0.899218738079071,
0.7655858993530273,
-0.17030061781406403,
0.37840911746025085,
0.05710677057504654,
0.4520537853240967,
-0.7641876339912415,
0.20269691944122314,
-0.5010479092597961,
-0.21766406297683716,
-0.2098253220319748,
-0.07007933408021927,
-0.5913418531417847,
-0.3756825029850006,
-0.23086251318454742,
-0.3460451066493988,
-0.03289046138525009,
0.1079707220196724,
0.824405312538147,
0.5312987565994263,
-0.21103543043136597,
0.14236041903495789,
-0.7084747552871704,
1.1188846826553345,
-1.0051630735397339,
0.4355420470237732,
0.3675086200237274,
0.30208703875541687,
-0.14225730299949646,
-0.5641614198684692,
-0.29947414994239807,
0.007386685349047184,
-0.14780154824256897,
-0.22871358692646027,
-0.43453261256217957,
0.22321394085884094,
0.17714925110340118,
0.3386666178703308,
-0.4103788435459137,
0.5481715202331543,
-0.37037739157676697,
-0.12134554982185364,
0.5794364809989929,
0.24692288041114807,
0.011385230347514153,
-0.0029376596212387085,
0.013879888691008091,
-0.05187330022454262,
-0.8753209114074707,
0.10100433975458145,
0.268705278635025,
0.13947804272174835,
0.0614178329706192,
0.36204996705055237,
-0.16583463549613953,
0.8636809587478638,
-0.22989946603775024,
-0.6475706100463867,
-0.16839975118637085,
-0.14145486056804657,
-0.3275201916694641,
-0.2931699752807617,
0.5905603766441345,
0.20080043375492096,
0.10342922061681747,
-0.273479163646698,
-0.20749953389167786,
0.13726705312728882,
0.2789645791053772,
-1.0452324151992798,
-0.22158460319042206,
0.08411025255918503,
-0.7535795569419861,
-0.451093465089798,
-0.36961281299591064,
-0.4759465456008911,
0.06619139015674591,
-0.12208183109760284,
0.3168261647224426,
-0.05205339565873146,
-0.09909748286008835,
0.030948705971240997,
0.24353136122226715,
0.36506715416908264,
0.44968143105506897,
-0.6896663904190063,
0.5374453067779541,
0.9469625949859619,
0.9734042286872864,
-0.32890892028808594,
0.08045409619808197,
-0.5463687777519226,
0.05077812448143959,
-0.47586631774902344,
0.5479534268379211,
-0.4520164728164673,
-0.35633987188339233,
-0.27403026819229126,
-0.36339372396469116,
-0.032097890973091125,
-0.6184317469596863,
0.5084234476089478,
-0.5384647250175476,
-0.3459431827068329,
-0.1695512980222702,
-0.4160856008529663,
-0.17081493139266968,
0.21014606952667236,
-0.6033351421356201,
1.0793921947479248,
0.07951904088258743,
-0.4433903396129608,
0.030235840007662773,
-0.4310183823108673,
-0.5096057057380676,
-0.19772566854953766,
0.05226060375571251,
-0.6568003296852112,
0.49750351905822754,
0.03916468843817711,
0.5138505101203918,
-0.6382251977920532,
0.2321939617395401,
-0.3360564708709717,
-0.7523594498634338,
0.20883667469024658,
-0.40993958711624146,
0.6235557794570923,
0.34136709570884705,
-0.121213898062706,
-0.20581258833408356,
-0.8578433394432068,
0.2422863095998764,
0.2296615093946457,
-0.648822546005249,
-0.3448321521282196,
0.2851928770542145,
-0.22166688740253448,
0.14460857212543488,
0.13474436104297638,
-0.31578412652015686,
0.2866288125514984,
-0.3642578125,
0.4608096480369568,
0.8105316758155823,
-0.1323297768831253,
0.4094972014427185,
-0.3651926815509796,
0.6563328504562378,
-0.34161102771759033,
0.377682089805603,
0.3756764233112335,
-0.4428355395793915,
-1.0361528396606445,
-0.4747461676597595,
0.43206262588500977,
0.28371408581733704,
-0.34568238258361816,
0.22840391099452972,
-0.5866619944572449,
-0.4420584440231323,
-0.6218417286872864,
-0.0027146227657794952,
0.45724552869796753,
0.20535872876644135,
0.1753816157579422,
-0.09918059408664703,
-0.30372241139411926,
-1.193784475326538,
-0.01021570060402155,
-0.23736174404621124,
-0.0045744082890450954,
0.27775776386260986,
0.20571009814739227,
-0.006498300936073065,
0.851108968257904,
-0.6652208566665649,
-0.06860853731632233,
-0.3399837911128998,
-0.17116563022136688,
0.06648305803537369,
0.4651753902435303,
0.5454822182655334,
-0.42296281456947327,
-0.3002384305000305,
-0.1940826177597046,
-0.3611393868923187,
-0.2385271191596985,
0.25577327609062195,
-0.08717859536409378,
0.22800205647945404,
0.29143309593200684,
-0.524356484413147,
0.4671179950237274,
0.7591825723648071,
0.052891116589307785,
0.3207055926322937,
-0.036219313740730286,
-0.01802472397685051,
-0.7275254726409912,
0.182621568441391,
-0.27269062399864197,
-0.24168804287910461,
-0.7627036571502686,
0.16706684231758118,
-0.07760299742221832,
-0.0668400451540947,
-0.401970237493515,
0.4959537088871002,
-0.5475518107414246,
-0.5049880146980286,
-0.1307011991739273,
-0.044562824070453644,
0.006828120909631252,
0.7301578521728516,
-0.014773598872125149,
1.0253218412399292,
0.24505852162837982,
-0.5551618337631226,
-0.19282709062099457,
0.08177062124013901,
-0.43530887365341187,
0.19126060605049133,
-0.6009603142738342,
0.29236161708831787,
0.06958096474409103,
0.01864682324230671,
-1.0494263172149658,
0.16116203367710114,
0.1959221363067627,
-0.29217806458473206,
0.2236914336681366,
-0.4473360478878021,
-0.7618633508682251,
0.0234941765666008,
-0.42143675684928894,
0.715657651424408,
0.8949005007743835,
-0.46425381302833557,
0.39721015095710754,
0.5192185044288635,
-0.1738879680633545,
-0.460482120513916,
-0.7829558253288269,
0.002722055884078145,
-0.22848616540431976,
-0.6683908104896545,
0.32735326886177063,
-0.12340468168258667,
-0.6337170600891113,
-0.043995410203933716,
-0.07674834877252579,
0.020312227308750153,
0.401059627532959,
0.2080780416727066,
0.23375968635082245,
-0.15993577241897583,
-0.016431499272584915,
0.114375539124012,
-0.20553289353847504,
-0.020355965942144394,
0.08734693378210068,
0.6190429925918579,
-0.05037660896778107,
-0.377543181180954,
-0.2848083972930908,
0.25883540511131287,
0.5206108093261719,
-0.11129659414291382,
0.8450427651405334,
0.2628059387207031,
-0.2445736825466156,
-0.2641371488571167,
-0.6145780682563782,
0.051034945994615555,
-0.4359215199947357,
0.1664666384458542,
-0.42899590730667114,
-0.7639903426170349,
0.4873955249786377,
-0.12013693153858185,
0.16099585592746735,
0.3656727373600006,
0.6183214783668518,
0.04914926737546921,
0.9906904697418213,
0.5954601168632507,
-0.038381580263376236,
0.3051721155643463,
-0.5237959027290344,
0.5323778986930847,
-0.9745047688484192,
0.005787718575447798,
-0.6475650668144226,
-0.6372410655021667,
-0.41118940711021423,
-0.6269128918647766,
0.43154826760292053,
0.025759104639291763,
-0.049652885645627975,
0.15621140599250793,
-0.4455909729003906,
0.3643176853656769,
0.5620502233505249,
-0.1436045914888382,
0.4334084689617157,
0.08747893571853638,
0.25191766023635864,
-0.14716482162475586,
-0.9792735576629639,
-0.3544449210166931,
1.0869461297988892,
0.5276831984519958,
0.7637236714363098,
0.34599900245666504,
0.7139984965324402,
0.2648427188396454,
0.2302352637052536,
-1.128541350364685,
0.7351805567741394,
-0.21570375561714172,
-0.1281493455171585,
-0.26950177550315857,
-0.5800737142562866,
-0.7851271033287048,
0.4549916684627533,
0.13272668421268463,
-0.6107966899871826,
0.23985633254051208,
0.1602398157119751,
-0.22241659462451935,
0.3679691553115845,
-0.6143197417259216,
0.6846038699150085,
-0.12962864339351654,
-0.30695852637290955,
-0.3943428695201874,
-0.396665096282959,
0.44456735253334045,
-0.050499327480793,
0.2532816529273987,
-0.24216899275779724,
-0.08032647520303726,
0.9813901782035828,
-0.693377673625946,
0.5603117346763611,
-0.11855025589466095,
-0.13256852328777313,
-0.029418641701340675,
0.5036357045173645,
0.7793473601341248,
-0.12660548090934753,
-0.22229628264904022,
0.350791335105896,
-0.07383713871240616,
-0.4374854266643524,
-0.42588645219802856,
0.7774346470832825,
-0.7985538244247437,
-0.4323923885822296,
-0.2735695242881775,
-0.5058122873306274,
-0.2819698452949524,
-0.12411992996931076,
0.09477376937866211,
0.6307259202003479,
-0.01867022179067135,
0.1772976666688919,
0.6211354732513428,
-0.14166180789470673,
0.5006664395332336,
0.2972673177719116,
-0.14042498171329498,
-0.09320193529129028,
0.9120395183563232,
0.2901333272457123,
0.4660116136074066,
0.43489524722099304,
0.03855836018919945,
-0.16097639501094818,
-1.110416054725647,
-0.17460261285305023,
0.3541460633277893,
-0.7308582067489624,
-0.29082241654396057,
-0.3106003701686859,
-0.3210093080997467,
-0.2257017344236374,
-0.35843828320503235,
-0.5948809385299683,
-0.542317807674408,
-0.3412517309188843,
0.07131890207529068,
0.0821833610534668,
0.5661488175392151,
0.023349246010184288,
0.49885135889053345,
-0.3179336488246918,
0.137492835521698,
0.23591779172420502,
0.3361554443836212,
0.19047091901302338,
-0.606074333190918,
-0.3414044678211212,
-0.17962169647216797,
-0.01469549909234047,
-0.49052152037620544,
0.42832550406455994,
0.17258262634277344,
0.5753719806671143,
0.16462470591068268,
0.14046072959899902,
0.7421441674232483,
-0.2035258412361145,
0.6982634663581848,
-0.19108814001083374,
-0.8909143805503845,
0.20313461124897003,
-0.06761659681797028,
0.22190283238887787,
0.4838787019252777,
-0.09691061079502106,
-0.3575522303581238,
-0.3516079783439636,
-0.6124433279037476,
-0.8251359462738037,
0.813572883605957,
0.29986223578453064,
-0.2230658233165741,
0.2511165738105774,
0.28897562623023987,
-0.11354108154773712,
0.12594813108444214,
-0.5754796862602234,
-0.4441794157028198,
0.28156089782714844,
-0.029297633096575737,
-0.16698169708251953,
-0.7283543944358826,
-0.014680788852274418,
-0.2521878480911255,
0.7222068309783936,
-0.033830493688583374,
0.5686928629875183,
-0.36218225955963135,
-0.37106430530548096,
0.12197021394968033,
0.38433244824409485,
0.6942789554595947,
0.9106655716896057,
-0.27005240321159363,
0.31668975949287415,
0.14333663880825043,
-0.24619817733764648,
0.3947932720184326,
-0.25436869263648987,
-0.2595677077770233,
-0.08782809972763062,
0.3919265866279602,
0.6970891356468201,
0.3953027129173279,
-0.5613262057304382,
0.34105244278907776,
-0.1153780072927475,
-0.1072155088186264,
-0.1006307303905487,
-0.024624859914183617,
0.07444175332784653,
0.02460191212594509,
0.3032926619052887,
-0.03231852874159813,
0.16986185312271118,
-0.17373278737068176,
-0.2046370655298233,
0.5327606797218323,
0.17142513394355774,
-0.26476284861564636,
0.5083091259002686,
0.18577149510383606,
-0.4010259509086609,
0.6066949367523193,
-0.29248782992362976,
-0.3344295918941498,
0.508700430393219,
0.3225480020046234,
0.7835803627967834,
0.08942374587059021,
0.043673764914274216,
0.234255850315094,
0.28577035665512085,
-0.03215593472123146,
-0.11323581635951996,
-0.1795220673084259,
-0.4592443108558655,
-0.6962089538574219,
-0.8055880069732666,
-0.33358365297317505,
0.30403491854667664,
-0.6431697010993958,
0.05896240472793579,
-0.6708401441574097,
-0.16352559626102448,
-0.24361594021320343,
0.20582054555416107,
-0.5199743509292603,
-0.11101964861154556,
0.08351975679397583,
0.7002409100532532,
-0.5224972367286682,
0.9787287712097168,
0.38718146085739136,
0.038919925689697266,
-0.8439252972602844,
0.10894667357206345,
0.05719597637653351,
-0.9547240138053894,
0.7802364230155945,
-0.07451470196247101,
-0.3662113845348358,
0.1641252487897873,
-0.3476395606994629,
-0.9798573851585388,
1.0369380712509155,
0.7070409059524536,
-0.5794374346733093,
-0.08725825697183609,
0.0007789693190716207,
0.33427050709724426,
-0.07781152427196503,
0.07611627131700516,
0.7109350562095642,
0.46453192830085754,
0.025886161252856255,
-1.0107084512710571,
0.11182083189487457,
-0.09537462145090103,
0.4146769344806671,
0.455695778131485,
-0.800060510635376,
0.9909858703613281,
0.016364997252821922,
-0.2565595805644989,
0.07442915439605713,
0.1947726011276245,
0.20694364607334137,
-0.1342802792787552,
0.4263240396976471,
0.6501339077949524,
0.29953742027282715,
-0.15595762431621552,
0.9811651706695557,
-0.2701047658920288,
0.4605577886104584,
0.5372291207313538,
-0.08968944847583771,
1.0624407529830933,
0.5762947797775269,
-0.5121434926986694,
0.24939267337322235,
0.6231212019920349,
0.2984910309314728,
0.5331770777702332,
0.2785152792930603,
-0.08482000231742859,
-0.44492778182029724,
-0.04334079474210739,
-0.18860891461372375,
0.46574777364730835,
0.2469829022884369,
-0.12215767800807953,
-0.21225187182426453,
-0.4295032024383545,
0.34780076146125793,
-0.2646505534648895,
-0.25015324354171753,
0.7554660439491272,
0.020572230219841003,
-0.5937718152999878,
0.9608088135719299,
0.2864990532398224,
0.5935693979263306,
-0.4779515564441681,
-0.010909601114690304,
-0.4058898389339447,
0.3189491033554077,
-0.010082501918077469,
-0.5041723251342773,
0.2981274425983429,
-0.15876829624176025,
-0.18873122334480286,
-0.4172587990760803,
0.6758366823196411,
-0.19112791121006012,
-0.424762487411499,
0.3113998472690582,
0.4743818938732147,
0.2685404121875763,
0.08216248452663422,
-0.39690276980400085,
0.7621302604675293,
-0.1267932802438736,
-0.3223227560520172,
0.6429135799407959,
-0.21476157009601593,
0.008715779520571232,
0.7597410678863525,
0.6218923330307007,
0.426302433013916,
0.010334803722798824,
-0.16416868567466736,
0.7783982753753662,
-0.27813753485679626,
-0.5464866161346436,
-0.7620012164115906,
0.335088312625885,
-0.03798284754157066,
0.07382320612668991,
0.6239566206932068,
0.571994960308075,
0.6564052104949951,
0.10481563210487366,
0.6394318342208862,
-0.06712185591459274,
0.5150636434555054,
-0.6729280948638916,
0.6112958788871765,
-0.7514402866363525,
0.5672934055328369,
-0.07041677087545395,
-0.8689187169075012,
-0.2141415774822235,
0.6558927297592163,
-0.3691951632499695,
-0.004005519673228264,
0.4512666165828705,
0.8653635382652283,
-0.13163569569587708,
-0.6421453952789307,
0.5198521018028259,
0.061187323182821274,
0.44457510113716125,
0.6651759147644043,
0.7145779728889465,
-0.34387117624282837,
0.6242896318435669,
-0.43038347363471985,
-0.17995288968086243,
-0.6359595060348511,
-0.7018364071846008,
-0.7333336472511292,
-0.484393447637558,
-0.2104085087776184,
-0.08490816503763199,
0.05360262840986252,
0.5985466837882996,
0.9397100210189819,
-0.5097209811210632,
-0.4007391631603241,
0.29853031039237976,
0.1712103933095932,
-0.3186984658241272,
-0.1892247498035431,
0.4896974265575409,
-0.03844919055700302,
-0.6453239321708679,
0.5187181830406189,
0.4319455027580261,
-0.09237594902515411,
-0.4217572808265686,
-0.37642133235931396,
-0.08609353005886078,
0.12412524968385696,
0.7958583235740662,
0.2110569030046463,
-0.9010593891143799,
-0.3166840374469757,
0.040126752108335495,
-0.12831836938858032,
0.19772064685821533,
0.9166766405105591,
-0.7165135145187378,
0.09808170795440674,
0.47606292366981506,
0.757147490978241,
0.6233006119728088,
0.12303540110588074,
0.46141546964645386,
-0.8966511487960815,
0.27971985936164856,
0.15341152250766754,
0.25887390971183777,
0.1791304647922516,
-0.26974421739578247,
0.5915203094482422,
0.20092466473579407,
-0.618859052658081,
-1.2122013568878174,
0.19317233562469482,
-1.1355509757995605,
-0.3051498234272003,
1.3446203470230103,
-0.10942039638757706,
-0.23469278216362,
0.07111267745494843,
-0.08067142963409424,
-0.032003726810216904,
-0.3516390919685364,
0.626865804195404,
0.5666860342025757,
-0.2700308859348297,
-0.4767623841762543,
-0.5506359934806824,
0.5085832476615906,
0.4234910309314728,
-0.812503457069397,
0.10758043080568314,
0.5659582018852234,
0.230386883020401,
-0.07649890333414078,
0.8487333655357361,
0.0930795669555664,
0.13793078064918518,
0.008367646485567093,
-0.004583205562084913,
-0.4118978679180145,
-0.2570793330669403,
-0.3309905230998993,
0.23209798336029053,
0.6082746982574463,
-0.3162870407104492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06604v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06604v1
|
Explaining Text Similarity in Transformer Models
| 2024-05-10T17:11:31 | 2024-05-10T17:11:31 |
Alexandros Vasileiou, Oliver Eberle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
As Transformers have become state-of-the-art models for natural language
processing (NLP) tasks, the need to understand and explain their predictions is
increasingly apparent. Especially in unsupervised applications, such as
information retrieval tasks, similarity models built on top of foundation model
representations have been widely applied. However, their inner prediction
mechanisms have mostly remained opaque. Recent advances in explainable AI have
made it possible to mitigate these limitations by leveraging improved
explanations for Transformers through layer-wise relevance propagation (LRP).
Using BiLRP, an extension developed for computing second-order explanations in
bilinear similarity models, we investigate which feature interactions drive
similarity in NLP models. We validate the resulting explanations and
demonstrate their utility in three corpus-level use cases, analyzing
grammatical interactions, multilingual semantics, and biomedical text
retrieval. Our findings contribute to a deeper understanding of different
semantic similarity tasks and models, highlighting how novel explainable AI
methods enable in-depth analyses and corpus-level insights.
|
[
-0.37636008858680725,
-0.4806292653083801,
0.655503511428833,
0.04998016357421875,
-0.10713346302509308,
-0.274513840675354,
-0.1593610793352127,
-0.7571551203727722,
-0.3164754807949066,
0.6100769639015198,
-0.4824095368385315,
-0.1391855925321579,
-0.4839610755443573,
0.03867695853114128,
-0.7162360548973083,
1.1897515058517456,
0.12110816687345505,
-0.18357375264167786,
-0.5300995111465454,
-0.17839893698692322,
-0.31647178530693054,
-0.38642722368240356,
-0.3860585391521454,
-0.9526740312576294,
0.7385309934616089,
0.1642303466796875,
1.090851902961731,
0.5822224617004395,
0.9078429341316223,
0.3173099458217621,
-0.2965812087059021,
-0.24108263850212097,
-0.40870094299316406,
0.29013752937316895,
-0.560108482837677,
-0.6480557322502136,
0.027958622202277184,
-0.18305115401744843,
0.5228944420814514,
1.179540753364563,
0.21268026530742645,
0.06792168319225311,
0.44924959540367126,
0.7592119574546814,
-0.21650852262973785,
0.08785732835531235,
-0.7630665898323059,
0.11668732017278671,
0.04228338971734047,
-0.36035674810409546,
-0.48944035172462463,
0.05394933000206947,
0.42061570286750793,
-0.2724875807762146,
0.7982335090637207,
0.17235958576202393,
1.1119674444198608,
0.2729051411151886,
-0.26214465498924255,
-0.29526394605636597,
-1.0309611558914185,
0.5353940725326538,
-0.5076050758361816,
0.48407453298568726,
0.19574014842510223,
0.2941656708717346,
-0.09131817519664764,
-0.9641370177268982,
-0.8561948537826538,
0.04208590090274811,
-0.6496059894561768,
0.10817667841911316,
-0.41723260283470154,
0.09009142220020294,
0.13982415199279785,
0.5409210324287415,
-0.7657767534255981,
0.28985482454299927,
-0.37892672419548035,
-0.01961546204984188,
0.2267063409090042,
-0.12991228699684143,
0.11528308689594269,
-0.29921242594718933,
-0.5877878665924072,
-0.1835026890039444,
-0.48233237862586975,
0.3361506760120392,
0.19595001637935638,
0.2601959705352783,
-0.11270937323570251,
0.6705392599105835,
0.31801512837409973,
0.6308375000953674,
0.01598419062793255,
0.33666959404945374,
0.18519756197929382,
-0.3913821280002594,
-0.33791419863700867,
-0.022690750658512115,
0.6755918860435486,
0.45496782660484314,
0.15215611457824707,
-0.43824291229248047,
0.12775380909442902,
0.045502327382564545,
0.4402359127998352,
-0.729224681854248,
-0.07079363614320755,
0.13678283989429474,
-1.0572630167007446,
-0.2986772358417511,
0.08712265640497208,
-0.9629207849502563,
-0.3412006199359894,
-0.27688661217689514,
0.4191420376300812,
-0.4226739704608917,
-0.2640514075756073,
0.07306869328022003,
-0.2359091341495514,
0.5269357562065125,
-0.17648816108703613,
-1.1370092630386353,
0.3000123202800751,
0.9967644810676575,
0.7562975287437439,
-0.18952348828315735,
-0.38034042716026306,
-0.2613442838191986,
0.10885181277990341,
-0.13781701028347015,
0.8954858779907227,
-0.6911769509315491,
-0.18786852061748505,
-0.1260835826396942,
-0.11376413702964783,
0.06580790877342224,
-0.6213068962097168,
0.5908129215240479,
-0.5744834542274475,
0.51689612865448,
0.004420183598995209,
-0.35541483759880066,
-0.49129733443260193,
-0.08573508262634277,
-0.6362687349319458,
1.1822121143341064,
-0.02951689437031746,
-1.129649043083191,
0.3434537351131439,
-0.677737832069397,
-0.4624212980270386,
-0.19721642136573792,
0.10501620918512344,
-0.6173765063285828,
0.38776981830596924,
0.0563620962202549,
0.6128426194190979,
-0.38430798053741455,
0.13992157578468323,
-0.25019416213035583,
-0.35724937915802,
0.3363571763038635,
-0.5833734273910522,
0.5401647090911865,
0.07656724750995636,
-0.20026540756225586,
0.34459325671195984,
-0.5033658742904663,
-0.22557713091373444,
0.01499790046364069,
0.1532677710056305,
-0.5835403203964233,
0.05471590533852577,
0.007053875830024481,
0.09238489717245102,
0.06658681482076645,
-0.1792294830083847,
-0.08194457739591599,
-0.7330969572067261,
0.4680415689945221,
0.4266998767852783,
-0.0666322186589241,
0.7831807732582092,
-0.33483633399009705,
0.34102848172187805,
0.058940257877111435,
0.030671266838908195,
-0.47150713205337524,
-0.6209269165992737,
-0.40045925974845886,
-0.05000254139304161,
0.16441293060779572,
0.3428986668586731,
-0.3577962815761566,
-0.027852440252900124,
-0.4866189956665039,
-0.4159223437309265,
-0.6922541260719299,
0.014404283836483955,
0.542346715927124,
0.8955729603767395,
0.7031669020652771,
-0.026372363790869713,
-0.4169994592666626,
-1.3602526187896729,
-0.752033531665802,
-0.17625576257705688,
-0.36348429322242737,
0.18198424577713013,
0.2399398684501648,
-0.3703327476978302,
0.9730492830276489,
-0.07807411253452301,
-0.03482373431324959,
-0.5604652762413025,
0.2608581781387329,
0.5587791204452515,
0.2114522010087967,
0.6662501692771912,
-1.2056894302368164,
-0.3596598505973816,
0.16158044338226318,
-0.4727161228656769,
-0.2326907366514206,
-0.26959341764450073,
-0.011459780856966972,
-0.10016398131847382,
0.5466434955596924,
-0.5261272192001343,
0.5900161862373352,
0.5379902124404907,
-0.28331971168518066,
0.1641828715801239,
-0.5314674377441406,
-0.02189829759299755,
-1.068304181098938,
0.1491498500108719,
-0.11377047002315521,
-0.4338606297969818,
-0.8995700478553772,
0.26670992374420166,
-0.15419434010982513,
-0.17678029835224152,
-0.028810057789087296,
0.3233429193496704,
-0.3513055741786957,
-0.5157988667488098,
-0.4235818684101105,
0.3712068200111389,
0.3208620250225067,
0.24276508390903473,
-0.008716285228729248,
0.5864532589912415,
0.44609564542770386,
-0.5620278120040894,
-0.02710132673382759,
0.3201180696487427,
-0.12122893333435059,
0.18616235256195068,
-0.9859642386436462,
-0.07298824191093445,
-0.3811156153678894,
0.0015141605399549007,
-1.167778730392456,
0.015524492599070072,
-0.026188412681221962,
-0.5424519181251526,
0.18928544223308563,
-0.2643783688545227,
-0.44664451479911804,
-0.32873478531837463,
-0.16007427871227264,
0.4460742473602295,
0.5798191428184509,
-0.8196367025375366,
0.9311246871948242,
0.02311771735548973,
-0.13457413017749786,
-0.6427755951881409,
-0.7749718427658081,
-0.10145792365074158,
-0.3742803633213043,
-0.4364229738712311,
0.9315817356109619,
0.1350516676902771,
-0.3016418218612671,
0.14862971007823944,
-0.12430855631828308,
-0.1060943529009819,
0.2566649317741394,
0.5794057250022888,
0.2883787155151367,
-0.2991476356983185,
0.20806965231895447,
0.09087824076414108,
-0.28225263953208923,
0.20923347771167755,
0.05532786622643471,
0.5813663005828857,
-0.04285664111375809,
-0.39495861530303955,
-0.5076991319656372,
0.36734870076179504,
0.40105175971984863,
-0.19818243384361267,
0.8644553422927856,
0.7391563653945923,
-0.2816384732723236,
-0.025883927941322327,
-0.11243101954460144,
-0.3521815240383148,
-0.456481009721756,
0.4251953959465027,
-0.537483811378479,
-0.8328209519386292,
0.6714309453964233,
0.06468773633241653,
0.05764119327068329,
0.5892623662948608,
0.6076733469963074,
-0.30674299597740173,
0.9791405200958252,
0.9105700254440308,
0.04989571496844292,
0.32986170053482056,
0.10541003197431564,
0.6457459926605225,
-0.4951757788658142,
-0.5315033197402954,
-0.7041153907775879,
-0.3613181412220001,
-0.8466416597366333,
-0.4872229993343353,
0.11940082162618637,
0.4553390443325043,
0.006840044166892767,
0.5130160450935364,
-0.5089177489280701,
0.5171677470207214,
0.5299707651138306,
-0.1594211906194687,
0.27326008677482605,
0.18968476355075836,
-0.17934946715831757,
-0.0075195119716227055,
-0.6485573053359985,
-0.3539104759693146,
0.5301370024681091,
0.5213901400566101,
0.5421786308288574,
0.19525490701198578,
0.3754235804080963,
0.26227006316185,
0.07657492160797119,
-0.4910586476325989,
0.20827481150627136,
-0.27051737904548645,
-0.4466569721698761,
-0.16458319127559662,
-0.21013759076595306,
-1.2067492008209229,
0.34177878499031067,
-0.5410304665565491,
-0.7949970364570618,
0.07373858243227005,
0.2206469625234604,
-0.08812499046325684,
0.209477499127388,
-0.5119503140449524,
0.7726269364356995,
0.12474352866411209,
-0.3321872353553772,
-0.5911256074905396,
-0.803280770778656,
0.04061819985508919,
0.1612113118171692,
0.34451356530189514,
0.22374987602233887,
0.12837719917297363,
0.3990844488143921,
-0.2781807482242584,
0.6083924770355225,
0.17079560458660126,
-0.026579834520816803,
-0.047829777002334595,
0.2366071343421936,
0.20511500537395477,
-0.08939751982688904,
-0.348320335149765,
0.19803498685359955,
0.013874194584786892,
-0.26275113224983215,
-0.8929598927497864,
0.7598652839660645,
-0.42452412843704224,
-0.5663353204727173,
-0.09161414951086044,
-0.5902639627456665,
0.08027263730764389,
0.0825563371181488,
0.34627074003219604,
0.4143522083759308,
0.23270347714424133,
0.2662934958934784,
0.6013096570968628,
-0.37901777029037476,
0.5773136019706726,
0.20650306344032288,
-0.6068000197410583,
0.32071632146835327,
0.595929741859436,
-0.4488949179649353,
0.23150350153446198,
0.8221539258956909,
0.398558109998703,
-0.32668212056159973,
-0.5241572856903076,
-0.20502525568008423,
0.20805592834949493,
-0.6312423944473267,
-0.05317259952425957,
-0.6648545861244202,
-0.3330968916416168,
-0.23435357213020325,
-0.2223977893590927,
-0.10959476977586746,
-0.46950218081474304,
-0.25847238302230835,
-0.24699954688549042,
0.3567914068698883,
0.9621069431304932,
-0.016023725271224976,
0.2227129340171814,
-0.6573925018310547,
0.74896240234375,
0.2423860877752304,
0.5969464778900146,
0.1427716165781021,
-0.8544602394104004,
-0.14585289359092712,
-0.022100945934653282,
-0.1388784646987915,
-0.9918789267539978,
0.2688082754611969,
0.40477246046066284,
0.5151859521865845,
0.435982882976532,
-0.1425921767950058,
0.5865930318832397,
-0.5213295221328735,
0.704249918460846,
0.012259670533239841,
-0.9548529982566833,
0.4523053467273712,
-0.01680479198694229,
0.1486562043428421,
0.3649841547012329,
0.475821316242218,
-0.497130811214447,
-0.27860113978385925,
-0.44993236660957336,
-0.881696879863739,
0.45112553238868713,
0.442503958940506,
0.3185737431049347,
0.15643690526485443,
0.6820642352104187,
0.40301862359046936,
-0.14582648873329163,
-0.9437598586082458,
-0.44676798582077026,
-0.32124626636505127,
-0.36747413873672485,
-0.03287864103913307,
-0.2935119867324829,
0.1732373833656311,
0.09902837872505188,
0.4685530960559845,
-0.05398997291922569,
0.601177990436554,
0.3051479458808899,
-0.2024995982646942,
0.036339882761240005,
0.4298016130924225,
0.5159984230995178,
0.5455987453460693,
0.03465326130390167,
0.4976896643638611,
0.020053165033459663,
-0.2643333077430725,
-0.4128670394420624,
0.38897982239723206,
0.04365227371454239,
0.23609484732151031,
0.9303693771362305,
0.727016031742096,
0.2251765877008438,
-0.5307995676994324,
0.6064766049385071,
0.005110896658152342,
0.022653017193078995,
-0.09617402404546738,
0.022477591410279274,
0.17509955167770386,
0.5068612694740295,
0.4359601140022278,
0.198752298951149,
0.38426855206489563,
-0.7297150492668152,
0.13691926002502441,
0.545613169670105,
-0.8218107223510742,
-0.4688541293144226,
0.7818896174430847,
-0.21017716825008392,
-0.6157988905906677,
0.4107077419757843,
0.2381744384765625,
-0.7463576793670654,
0.6043516397476196,
0.5141585469245911,
0.41847115755081177,
-0.06560324132442474,
0.10721155256032944,
0.20700016617774963,
0.19809505343437195,
0.063468798995018,
0.10983400046825409,
-0.14365293085575104,
-0.7315953969955444,
-0.5165939331054688,
-0.4655110239982605,
-0.26812446117401123,
0.08019357174634933,
-0.9487035274505615,
0.18965557217597961,
-0.15506790578365326,
0.18974025547504425,
0.6222160458564758,
-0.5910897254943848,
-0.8029309511184692,
-0.03174774348735809,
0.19315364956855774,
0.7134712338447571,
-0.7771996855735779,
0.6574523448944092,
0.5313118100166321,
-0.43137046694755554,
-0.7354744672775269,
0.24742025136947632,
-0.35571810603141785,
-0.8305849432945251,
0.6676890254020691,
0.49973341822624207,
-0.15804028511047363,
-0.3168415427207947,
-0.10500013828277588,
-0.5038572549819946,
0.8203440308570862,
0.27564936876296997,
-0.6109915971755981,
-0.15811429917812347,
0.5502285361289978,
1.059956431388855,
-0.3255546987056732,
0.615081787109375,
0.32670876383781433,
0.44390198588371277,
-0.34714508056640625,
-0.8981143236160278,
-0.03426073491573334,
-0.15856246650218964,
0.09318290650844574,
0.2253923863172531,
-0.24031734466552734,
0.37364402413368225,
-0.5050600171089172,
-0.03457016497850418,
0.07342725992202759,
0.8243579268455505,
-0.21111313998699188,
0.475538432598114,
0.6028148531913757,
0.3595406711101532,
0.4305667281150818,
0.02937125414609909,
1.1578736305236816,
-0.27063432335853577,
0.37035757303237915,
1.244386911392212,
-0.2183917611837387,
0.8348941802978516,
0.6436551213264465,
-0.11354700475931168,
1.09561026096344,
0.37626147270202637,
-0.06813334673643112,
0.4232541024684906,
-0.028440147638320923,
0.07024049758911133,
-0.17518241703510284,
-0.2180498093366623,
-0.22296307981014252,
0.6779257655143738,
0.09412715584039688,
-1.0354851484298706,
-0.2398560643196106,
0.20615173876285553,
-0.43166178464889526,
0.4561792314052582,
-0.29708585143089294,
0.9201437830924988,
-0.03641171380877495,
-0.5861751437187195,
0.334229975938797,
-0.17098163068294525,
0.35379287600517273,
-0.275238573551178,
-0.17516110837459564,
0.01347784698009491,
0.2828270494937897,
-0.20805983245372772,
-1.2453631162643433,
0.6604677438735962,
-0.13664783537387848,
-0.8835828304290771,
-0.5348137021064758,
0.7363247871398926,
-0.5122032165527344,
-0.3122435212135315,
0.6942499876022339,
0.23125243186950684,
0.1808350682258606,
0.09387829154729843,
-0.7564492225646973,
-0.26622945070266724,
-0.024305393919348717,
-0.23513534665107727,
0.2949305474758148,
0.4057258069515228,
-0.0800265520811081,
0.9080660939216614,
0.45295509696006775,
-0.19129355251789093,
-0.07822449505329132,
0.2952948212623596,
0.8082632422447205,
-0.5205907225608826,
-0.18679021298885345,
-0.9236558079719543,
0.3498883545398712,
-0.04795793816447258,
0.022647645324468613,
0.4130097031593323,
0.6997837424278259,
0.550735592842102,
-0.02745109796524048,
0.5154053568840027,
0.17593558132648468,
0.9697296619415283,
-0.4080128073692322,
0.5386810898780823,
-0.48751577734947205,
0.46169599890708923,
-0.07727552950382233,
-1.1798361539840698,
-0.2831018269062042,
0.5000680685043335,
-0.04036179557442665,
-0.03239981457591057,
0.6638186573982239,
0.7521478533744812,
-0.5066037774085999,
0.10723021626472473,
0.2721334397792816,
0.45623326301574707,
0.05710315331816673,
0.29071566462516785,
0.5445017218589783,
-0.3668876588344574,
0.8074579238891602,
-0.45183899998664856,
0.05129729583859444,
-0.09141232073307037,
-1.076852798461914,
-1.1022590398788452,
-0.8639000058174133,
-0.05311442166566849,
-0.3292824923992157,
-0.014201180078089237,
0.5820270776748657,
0.5064334869384766,
-0.7115699052810669,
0.21695588529109955,
-0.21281322836875916,
0.3513711392879486,
-0.35911470651626587,
-0.3016577363014221,
0.4706869125366211,
-0.16169990599155426,
-0.5218257904052734,
0.22175297141075134,
0.32772454619407654,
-0.07463037967681885,
-0.1398569643497467,
0.24919277429580688,
0.0015414381632581353,
0.048654716461896896,
0.44364452362060547,
0.1516651213169098,
-0.9295118451118469,
-0.4494950473308563,
-0.06393875181674957,
0.14371787011623383,
0.11500672996044159,
1.018701434135437,
-1.017207145690918,
0.3130887746810913,
0.8142802119255066,
0.6859517097473145,
0.52940434217453,
0.022494375705718994,
0.6482728719711304,
-0.446979820728302,
0.0985136404633522,
0.03966522216796875,
0.3411525785923004,
0.5243055820465088,
-0.39413854479789734,
0.4394994378089905,
-0.1345386803150177,
-0.6067044734954834,
-0.7680782079696655,
0.4925493896007538,
-1.0326569080352783,
-0.42358967661857605,
0.9010986089706421,
-0.18393751978874207,
0.014076342806220055,
-0.21319152414798737,
0.051587894558906555,
0.3701155185699463,
0.06133926659822464,
0.8245406150817871,
0.3186316192150116,
-0.17853273451328278,
-0.48348167538642883,
-0.3331769108772278,
0.4907192289829254,
0.6482183933258057,
-0.5260075926780701,
0.21343816816806793,
-0.13098540902137756,
0.14170661568641663,
0.1834115982055664,
-0.16267943382263184,
-0.025541983544826508,
0.10223961621522903,
-0.41789016127586365,
-0.08821991086006165,
0.04874127358198166,
-0.2121943235397339,
-0.4404242932796478,
0.2711891233921051,
-0.009371119551360607,
0.27670010924339294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06563v1
|
What Can Natural Language Processing Do for Peer Review?
| 2024-05-10T16:06:43 | 2024-05-10T16:06:43 |
Ilia Kuznetsov, Osama Mohammed Afzal, Koen Dercksen, Nils Dycke, Alexander Goldberg, Tom Hope, Dirk Hovy, Jonathan K. Kummerfeld, Anne Lauscher, Kevin Leyton-Brown, Sheng Lu, Mausam, Margot Mieskes, Aurélie Névéol, Danish Pruthi, Lizhen Qu, Roy Schwartz, Noah A. Smith, Thamar Solorio, Jingyan Wang, Xiaodan Zhu, Anna Rogers, Nihar B. Shah, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The number of scientific articles produced every year is growing rapidly.
Providing quality control over them is crucial for scientists and, ultimately,
for the public good. In modern science, this process is largely delegated to
peer review -- a distributed procedure in which each submission is evaluated by
several independent experts in the field. Peer review is widely used, yet it is
hard, time-consuming, and prone to error. Since the artifacts involved in peer
review -- manuscripts, reviews, discussions -- are largely text-based, Natural
Language Processing has great potential to improve reviewing. As the emergence
of large language models (LLMs) has enabled NLP assistance for many new tasks,
the discussion on machine-assisted peer review is picking up the pace. Yet,
where exactly is help needed, where can NLP help, and where should it stand
aside? The goal of our paper is to provide a foundation for the future efforts
in NLP for peer-reviewing assistance. We discuss peer review as a general
process, exemplified by reviewing at AI conferences. We detail each step of the
process from manuscript submission to camera-ready revision, and discuss the
associated challenges and opportunities for NLP assistance, illustrated by
existing work. We then turn to the big challenges in NLP for peer review as a
whole, including data acquisition and licensing, operationalization and
experimentation, and ethical issues. To help consolidate community efforts, we
create a companion repository that aggregates key datasets pertaining to peer
review. Finally, we issue a detailed call for action for the scientific
community, NLP and AI researchers, policymakers, and funding bodies to help
bring the research in NLP for peer review forward. We hope that our work will
help set the agenda for research in machine-assisted scientific quality control
in the age of AI, within the NLP community and beyond.
|
[
-0.3274969458580017,
-0.6301186680793762,
0.6125767230987549,
0.435833603143692,
-0.16906152665615082,
-0.05787401646375656,
-0.1579270362854004,
-0.8234612941741943,
0.041145529597997665,
0.5943554639816284,
-0.37214192748069763,
-0.3819176256656647,
-0.9433174133300781,
0.8484427332878113,
-0.505314826965332,
1.1706572771072388,
-0.13971486687660217,
0.4042878746986389,
-0.32632631063461304,
-0.03228374943137169,
-0.466752290725708,
-0.5298351049423218,
-0.9504249095916748,
-0.45717281103134155,
0.5723862051963806,
0.01679149456322193,
0.6466948390007019,
0.3863923251628876,
0.8836879134178162,
0.3216545283794403,
-0.41405266523361206,
0.2587658762931824,
-0.032376568764448166,
0.18451900780200958,
-0.09399054199457169,
-0.3263927400112152,
-0.7372658848762512,
0.2779352068901062,
0.7423975467681885,
0.7611327767372131,
0.10100479423999786,
0.01649644784629345,
0.23300981521606445,
1.1859021186828613,
-0.02274048887193203,
0.20121178030967712,
-0.4239209294319153,
0.28174129128456116,
-0.08797892928123474,
0.0018493742682039738,
-0.12271153181791306,
-0.35351619124412537,
0.2249613255262375,
-0.46463826298713684,
0.4176958203315735,
0.08526020497083664,
0.4950106143951416,
0.4538055658340454,
-0.12564368546009064,
-0.2662929892539978,
-0.8142918348312378,
0.5468417406082153,
-0.6148519515991211,
0.28510403633117676,
0.757176399230957,
0.0001880373602034524,
-0.29159820079803467,
-0.6139904856681824,
-0.5567563772201538,
-0.34165483713150024,
-0.04721897840499878,
-0.22411148250102997,
-0.07977738976478577,
0.10288328677415848,
0.20879815518856049,
0.41110125184059143,
-0.397707462310791,
-0.1430962085723877,
-0.39678311347961426,
-0.1410817950963974,
0.662300169467926,
-0.08159615844488144,
0.188998281955719,
-0.27548396587371826,
0.16874699294567108,
-0.05762055143713951,
-0.534153401851654,
-0.05537238344550133,
0.19841504096984863,
0.18044452369213104,
0.4305592179298401,
0.6432185769081116,
-0.525765597820282,
0.7973898649215698,
-0.04855235666036606,
0.4761061370372772,
-0.028366822749376297,
-0.6908693909645081,
-0.24617642164230347,
0.04235124960541725,
0.7516844868659973,
0.2626243233680725,
0.03833116963505745,
0.023972928524017334,
-0.2933005690574646,
-0.11401670426130295,
0.3332107961177826,
-0.6740966439247131,
-0.060394905507564545,
0.4192701280117035,
-0.6187771558761597,
-0.14955709874629974,
0.07206030935049057,
-0.637069046497345,
-0.5691362023353577,
-0.6496177911758423,
0.12504589557647705,
0.07484389841556549,
0.022977463901042938,
0.2304261326789856,
-0.24375228583812714,
-0.056006357073783875,
0.45496630668640137,
-0.7192448973655701,
0.5900602340698242,
1.009765625,
0.9796323776245117,
-0.09945324063301086,
-0.16748744249343872,
-0.5807566046714783,
-0.1932518184185028,
-0.09228429943323135,
0.8117279410362244,
-0.5817213654518127,
-0.17525988817214966,
-0.22651337087154388,
0.08340303599834442,
0.23321421444416046,
-0.42887455224990845,
0.6015430092811584,
-0.47332143783569336,
0.349276065826416,
-0.17547789216041565,
-0.40882155299186707,
-0.05701829865574837,
0.34342870116233826,
-0.6697819232940674,
0.794867217540741,
-0.3504052758216858,
-0.6299378275871277,
0.16202057898044586,
-0.7314189672470093,
-0.31743374466896057,
0.042675018310546875,
0.15006208419799805,
-0.5338510870933533,
0.16930048167705536,
0.6504999399185181,
0.46281352639198303,
-0.38843291997909546,
0.565604031085968,
-0.22520330548286438,
-0.1090022400021553,
0.20823749899864197,
-0.2964690327644348,
0.6528311371803284,
-0.041788678616285324,
-0.29695791006088257,
0.25221267342567444,
-0.5987887382507324,
-0.13302668929100037,
-0.0016716961981728673,
-0.2177848368883133,
-0.24813467264175415,
0.25368037819862366,
0.12419873476028442,
-0.20511482656002045,
-0.051182541996240616,
-0.6095907092094421,
0.18118003010749817,
-0.48716503381729126,
0.7209588289260864,
0.6487538814544678,
0.14719820022583008,
0.6431352496147156,
-0.15554454922676086,
0.2632421851158142,
-0.5602322220802307,
0.42696601152420044,
-0.22279925644397736,
-1.0256363153457642,
-0.5986536145210266,
0.3020137846469879,
0.5183908939361572,
0.3068724572658539,
-0.5893346071243286,
0.45269036293029785,
0.3919169306755066,
-0.4871525764465332,
-0.9349325299263,
0.297427773475647,
0.3580639064311981,
0.4763087332248688,
0.5031367540359497,
-0.46804696321487427,
-0.6221293807029724,
-0.6461359262466431,
-0.2000238299369812,
-0.31266528367996216,
-0.23800607025623322,
0.12246110290288925,
0.3568495512008667,
-0.1370140016078949,
0.9711736440658569,
-0.28911781311035156,
-0.7807337045669556,
0.08010848611593246,
0.2544814646244049,
0.21406187117099762,
0.4837311804294586,
-0.03823225572705269,
-0.9598430395126343,
-0.2643011510372162,
-0.05036480352282524,
-0.7674508094787598,
-0.38951054215431213,
0.1009640097618103,
0.10126861929893494,
0.33769428730010986,
0.5376520156860352,
-0.5218972563743591,
0.1952970027923584,
0.524915874004364,
-0.19882342219352722,
0.40270161628723145,
-0.33473771810531616,
0.12321114540100098,
-0.45469197630882263,
0.2235291600227356,
0.0516241081058979,
-0.18475458025932312,
-0.4192415773868561,
0.061036065220832825,
-0.3198452293872833,
-0.47102347016334534,
0.044840097427368164,
0.42517831921577454,
-0.3656485080718994,
-0.0894244834780693,
-0.4572369158267975,
0.21205349266529083,
0.06640630215406418,
-0.0038084459956735373,
0.35481300950050354,
0.37565210461616516,
0.4174625873565674,
-0.4228825867176056,
0.48712146282196045,
0.3013285994529724,
-0.2073049694299698,
0.6235945820808411,
-1.1444315910339355,
0.4156854450702667,
-0.2917952239513397,
0.506364643573761,
-0.5611109733581543,
-0.025892596691846848,
0.44979825615882874,
-0.5243728160858154,
0.17479652166366577,
-0.18376009166240692,
-0.5631030201911926,
-0.304477721452713,
-0.2749324142932892,
-0.07014165073633194,
0.1919981688261032,
-0.13128024339675903,
0.37666070461273193,
0.6442360877990723,
-0.5259741544723511,
-0.51231849193573,
-0.35809117555618286,
0.6827303171157837,
0.3676115572452545,
-0.4392894208431244,
0.19263030588626862,
-0.03844767436385155,
-0.40101107954978943,
0.17181891202926636,
0.05647537484765053,
-0.21424400806427002,
0.07121395319700241,
0.19168442487716675,
0.14929497241973877,
0.05094004422426224,
0.2898314595222473,
-0.07552102953195572,
-0.4629398286342621,
0.22776810824871063,
-0.4453422725200653,
0.1972026526927948,
-0.3280998468399048,
-0.2639217674732208,
-0.43752455711364746,
0.48549124598503113,
0.1478733867406845,
-0.260751873254776,
0.149716317653656,
0.6123536825180054,
-0.34348124265670776,
-0.09614463895559311,
-0.6164626479148865,
-0.40317127108573914,
-0.38084444403648376,
0.39719316363334656,
0.39317718148231506,
-0.8979912400245667,
-0.004140566568821669,
0.29345080256462097,
0.24699200689792633,
0.38241681456565857,
0.47259050607681274,
-0.38611873984336853,
1.0213971138000488,
0.7017360329627991,
-0.11780243366956711,
0.4145849645137787,
-0.07703936845064163,
0.2725023925304413,
-0.7599213123321533,
-0.21621587872505188,
-0.9449354410171509,
-0.5123523473739624,
-0.4145983159542084,
-0.5151783227920532,
0.33793216943740845,
-0.18867191672325134,
0.21469902992248535,
0.31654322147369385,
-0.9819288849830627,
0.444985955953598,
0.6136111617088318,
-0.06400357931852341,
0.6529726982116699,
-0.18260473012924194,
0.3699016571044922,
-0.12336090952157974,
-0.6058832406997681,
-0.7293083667755127,
0.9356767535209656,
0.4657460153102875,
0.47034016251564026,
-0.6523175239562988,
0.5563357472419739,
0.506015419960022,
0.437021940946579,
-0.7052076458930969,
0.7491234540939331,
-0.13089697062969208,
-0.5204878449440002,
-0.37222227454185486,
-0.2493221014738083,
-0.7694427967071533,
0.07794508337974548,
-0.3904200494289398,
-0.10589324682950974,
0.08023005723953247,
0.14502717554569244,
0.10079935193061829,
0.304024875164032,
-0.48896822333335876,
0.6021007895469666,
-0.051671162247657776,
-0.2006785273551941,
-0.4612959325313568,
-0.8315356969833374,
0.07140084356069565,
-0.09943569451570511,
0.19688904285430908,
-0.25195813179016113,
0.08673623204231262,
0.8596780896186829,
-0.29051730036735535,
0.8768203258514404,
-0.2707754671573639,
-0.008049499243497849,
0.2651035785675049,
0.04844678193330765,
0.19953015446662903,
0.36279940605163574,
-0.0810120552778244,
0.4157421290874481,
0.1444142460823059,
0.00864587165415287,
-0.34214797616004944,
0.4930080473423004,
-0.661047637462616,
-0.6357905864715576,
-0.6139448285102844,
-0.34542879462242126,
-0.0597476102411747,
0.07045155018568039,
-0.04748155176639557,
0.2168390303850174,
-0.0128076933324337,
0.23853349685668945,
0.4635617733001709,
-0.06794682145118713,
0.49723392724990845,
0.39754197001457214,
-0.2711350917816162,
-0.41667258739471436,
0.7385551333427429,
-0.02631785348057747,
-0.2244521528482437,
0.39053282141685486,
0.2734307646751404,
-0.19678477942943573,
-0.8045217990875244,
-0.4361082911491394,
0.17018546164035797,
-0.469545841217041,
-0.2590239346027374,
-0.7999487519264221,
-0.03854953870177269,
-0.4203282594680786,
0.1135847195982933,
-0.2200755625963211,
-0.5033355355262756,
-0.4377288520336151,
0.10731455683708191,
0.2647532820701599,
1.0059258937835693,
-0.09559206664562225,
-0.1021680012345314,
-0.9602323770523071,
0.4922325313091278,
0.3636341989040375,
0.46633797883987427,
0.13743431866168976,
-0.17687056958675385,
0.060563717037439346,
-0.10545428097248077,
-0.23104815185070038,
-0.4880797564983368,
0.2712630331516266,
0.42221757769584656,
0.24897466599941254,
-0.05475496128201485,
-0.04633353650569916,
0.3416205644607544,
-0.7330207228660583,
0.7604232430458069,
-0.13212692737579346,
-0.8696314692497253,
0.6668180227279663,
0.033281732350587845,
0.19549664855003357,
0.5805351138114929,
0.41383424401283264,
-1.0954731702804565,
-0.6398792862892151,
-0.2894713282585144,
-0.8327208757400513,
0.6252701282501221,
0.22717906534671783,
0.1807108223438263,
0.1102210059762001,
0.42239511013031006,
0.10611267387866974,
0.33620941638946533,
-0.8207165002822876,
0.15987268090248108,
-0.15606500208377838,
0.20134423673152924,
-0.05035529285669327,
-0.025366488844156265,
-0.25115084648132324,
-0.17797856032848358,
0.683910608291626,
-0.21922454237937927,
0.3381047546863556,
0.8112176060676575,
0.11031474173069,
-0.390097051858902,
0.3560723066329956,
0.3704850673675537,
0.35699501633644104,
-0.17619480192661285,
-0.03273383900523186,
-0.16688494384288788,
-0.4156200587749481,
-0.03391114994883537,
0.26335206627845764,
-0.4910759925842285,
0.03863995149731636,
0.34700649976730347,
0.47696301341056824,
-0.08564417064189911,
-0.48786383867263794,
0.20304176211357117,
-0.1936022788286209,
-0.1533960998058319,
-0.08278772979974747,
-0.10206170380115509,
-0.15774929523468018,
0.19870314002037048,
0.6499838829040527,
0.18624350428581238,
0.23337195813655853,
-0.2898070514202118,
0.10880984365940094,
0.5647264122962952,
-0.3584893047809601,
-0.39965805411338806,
0.6560693383216858,
0.40197721123695374,
-0.734278678894043,
0.6873231530189514,
-0.14793945848941803,
-0.4844389855861664,
0.6800895929336548,
0.2120063304901123,
1.0299582481384277,
0.19364877045154572,
0.2326459288597107,
0.29701611399650574,
0.49422797560691833,
-0.22020675241947174,
0.024171559140086174,
-0.1721162497997284,
-0.33769097924232483,
-0.8612119555473328,
-0.707906186580658,
-0.9421574473381042,
-0.2089276760816574,
-0.2276100069284439,
0.21906931698322296,
-0.7082322239875793,
-0.3322388529777527,
0.03369951993227005,
0.05696035921573639,
-0.3293261229991913,
-0.05194002017378807,
0.34698930382728577,
0.7909945249557495,
-0.6947564482688904,
0.4206830561161041,
0.6181483864784241,
-0.1777040958404541,
-0.2407236397266388,
-0.24289798736572266,
-0.04892977327108383,
-0.44310036301612854,
0.6430886387825012,
0.2380528450012207,
-0.12795758247375488,
-0.1587013155221939,
-0.9929328560829163,
-0.5264268517494202,
0.43317246437072754,
0.08272649347782135,
-0.45411473512649536,
-0.21720755100250244,
-0.07273148000240326,
1.0885721445083618,
-0.022427000105381012,
0.10892713069915771,
0.3698204457759857,
0.6733676195144653,
-0.26797541975975037,
-0.9916577339172363,
-0.12983322143554688,
-0.3535352647304535,
-0.0179207194596529,
0.1020607203245163,
-0.2608148157596588,
0.44018515944480896,
-0.16064494848251343,
-0.021405989304184914,
0.06884381920099258,
0.7319610118865967,
0.2459649294614792,
0.5363537073135376,
0.34210872650146484,
0.3067593276500702,
0.5823199152946472,
-0.2208578735589981,
1.0389952659606934,
-0.08165280520915985,
0.19789095222949982,
0.7685360908508301,
-0.40641748905181885,
0.9072538018226624,
0.722115695476532,
-0.47441744804382324,
0.24504107236862183,
0.4631179869174957,
-0.3627641797065735,
0.0783846527338028,
0.10618133097887039,
-0.02137753926217556,
0.052396051585674286,
-0.49408742785453796,
-0.18358995020389557,
0.21749113500118256,
0.12909017503261566,
-0.22265812754631042,
-0.05478017032146454,
0.055763185024261475,
-0.2034280002117157,
0.36096224188804626,
-0.5233879685401917,
0.8217653632164001,
0.23841829597949982,
-0.7763274312019348,
0.013670790009200573,
0.19942504167556763,
0.7003443837165833,
-0.7965412139892578,
-0.3592710793018341,
0.1247737929224968,
-0.08662271499633789,
-0.39956557750701904,
-0.9637676477432251,
0.7160828113555908,
0.1957840472459793,
-0.2164371758699417,
-0.8005638122558594,
0.771268367767334,
-0.23047779500484467,
-0.37883421778678894,
0.24406997859477997,
0.3483409881591797,
0.1607864797115326,
-0.27511143684387207,
-0.7588728070259094,
0.08297710865736008,
-0.20867502689361572,
-0.2182120829820633,
0.3347596824169159,
0.08744070678949356,
-0.0992305800318718,
0.6580083966255188,
0.9867784380912781,
0.6438354849815369,
-0.09361818432807922,
0.13454709947109222,
0.5380097031593323,
-0.43015334010124207,
-0.2979467809200287,
-0.6189835667610168,
0.08905874192714691,
-0.06235013157129288,
-0.22087013721466064,
0.40070003271102905,
0.09370885789394379,
0.8294201493263245,
0.025229958817362785,
0.42795735597610474,
-0.330478698015213,
0.3315998911857605,
-0.5405119061470032,
0.7409432530403137,
-0.24459095299243927,
0.06977563351392746,
-0.2926078140735626,
-1.2130022048950195,
-0.9265638589859009,
0.6994807720184326,
-0.12972600758075714,
-0.09095189720392227,
0.669786810874939,
0.5018748044967651,
0.4833458662033081,
0.24947898089885712,
-0.09751825034618378,
0.12054018676280975,
0.6009921431541443,
0.21571554243564606,
0.6968418955802917,
-0.34244564175605774,
0.4533541202545166,
-0.3946753442287445,
0.06576625257730484,
-0.010468640364706516,
-1.2423373460769653,
-0.5852004289627075,
-0.6310576796531677,
-0.32479327917099,
-0.24903835356235504,
0.02598918043076992,
1.157528281211853,
0.4482564330101013,
-0.9278135299682617,
-0.22610244154930115,
-0.2604389190673828,
0.24189433455467224,
-0.3839958906173706,
-0.17580929398536682,
0.48339563608169556,
-0.42786985635757446,
-1.0509454011917114,
0.44007259607315063,
0.5539636611938477,
-0.07890936732292175,
-0.44405481219291687,
0.12955841422080994,
-0.11923282593488693,
-0.4544466733932495,
0.4997350871562958,
0.3581809103488922,
-0.6368052363395691,
0.03753622621297836,
0.057951122522354126,
-0.061860907822847366,
0.09416506439447403,
1.0827577114105225,
-0.7616548538208008,
0.7028599977493286,
0.5571910738945007,
0.9628941416740417,
0.18181242048740387,
-0.22498440742492676,
0.7289581298828125,
-0.6453768014907837,
-0.11161116510629654,
0.7189950942993164,
0.3671858310699463,
0.5963066220283508,
-0.36147233843803406,
0.7463476657867432,
0.37213191390037537,
-0.9142066240310669,
-0.7963900566101074,
-0.12681613862514496,
-0.8944307565689087,
-0.006628196220844984,
0.8707168102264404,
0.1298096776008606,
-0.06308626383543015,
-0.42034485936164856,
-0.5756618976593018,
0.06577439606189728,
-0.44063863158226013,
0.9544439911842346,
0.9451279044151306,
-0.17290636897087097,
-0.2242230325937271,
-0.5103580951690674,
0.6504948735237122,
0.4998188018798828,
-0.8556273579597473,
0.2643723487854004,
0.32222622632980347,
-0.12945790588855743,
0.2885080873966217,
0.7595643997192383,
-0.35183918476104736,
0.2445102334022522,
-0.5813021063804626,
0.12206591665744781,
-0.14556147158145905,
-0.31022852659225464,
-1.0110646486282349,
0.18981298804283142,
0.1440429985523224,
0.46913713216781616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06551v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06551v1
|
ADSumm: Annotated Ground-truth Summary Datasets for Disaster Tweet Summarization
| 2024-05-10T15:49:01 | 2024-05-10T15:49:01 |
Piyush Kumar Garg, Roshni Chakraborty, Sourav Kumar Dandapat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Online social media platforms, such as Twitter, provide valuable information
during disaster events. Existing tweet disaster summarization approaches
provide a summary of these events to aid government agencies, humanitarian
organizations, etc., to ensure effective disaster response. In the literature,
there are two types of approaches for disaster summarization, namely,
supervised and unsupervised approaches. Although supervised approaches are
typically more effective, they necessitate a sizable number of disaster event
summaries for testing and training. However, there is a lack of good number of
disaster summary datasets for training and evaluation. This motivates us to add
more datasets to make supervised learning approaches more efficient. In this
paper, we present ADSumm, which adds annotated ground-truth summaries for eight
disaster events which consist of both natural and man-made disaster events
belonging to seven different countries. Our experimental analysis shows that
the newly added datasets improve the performance of the supervised
summarization approaches by 8-28% in terms of ROUGE-N F1-score. Moreover, in
newly annotated dataset, we have added a category label for each input tweet
which helps to ensure good coverage from different categories in summary.
Additionally, we have added two other features relevance label and key-phrase,
which provide information about the quality of a tweet and explanation about
the inclusion of the tweet into summary, respectively. For ground-truth summary
creation, we provide the annotation procedure adapted in detail, which has not
been described in existing literature. Experimental analysis shows the quality
of ground-truth summary is very good with Coverage, Relevance and Diversity.
|
[
-0.5263667106628418,
-0.5069399476051331,
0.41109028458595276,
0.3747987449169159,
-0.5328746438026428,
0.06245775520801544,
-0.08396685123443604,
0.0759461298584938,
0.5077207684516907,
0.596834123134613,
-0.14032669365406036,
-0.8953307271003723,
-0.722959578037262,
-0.04298606887459755,
-0.46830543875694275,
1.3439441919326782,
-0.16639335453510284,
-0.3113272786140442,
-0.03456604480743408,
-0.47786036133766174,
-0.09947025030851364,
-0.4642222821712494,
-0.31218498945236206,
0.008967418223619461,
0.3026185929775238,
0.6805415153503418,
0.7391213774681091,
0.730650007724762,
0.6475350260734558,
0.13803094625473022,
-0.1067749559879303,
0.5372046232223511,
-0.31605079770088196,
-0.3326074481010437,
-0.2498079538345337,
-0.02221210114657879,
-0.5173065662384033,
0.013494374230504036,
0.3662962317466736,
0.5960779190063477,
-0.37953832745552063,
0.4312003254890442,
-0.0019078176701441407,
0.7874993085861206,
-0.7650705575942993,
0.2418464571237564,
-0.35834363102912903,
-0.09103595465421677,
0.2511467933654785,
-0.6144430637359619,
-0.0017534478101879358,
-0.677962064743042,
-0.0010740597499534488,
-0.6045489311218262,
0.5158462524414062,
-0.3914022743701935,
0.6828794479370117,
0.379445880651474,
-0.9104373455047607,
-0.4038247764110565,
-0.41454291343688965,
0.6427520513534546,
-0.6456761360168457,
-0.168779194355011,
0.2751888334751129,
0.4093479812145233,
0.038995083421468735,
-0.37230971455574036,
-0.09025198221206665,
0.31883689761161804,
-0.33164477348327637,
0.4593678414821625,
0.372518926858902,
0.027960382401943207,
0.10925048589706421,
0.40427514910697937,
-0.5841209292411804,
-0.3609819710254669,
-0.45070189237594604,
-0.1389736831188202,
0.9253810048103333,
0.353757381439209,
0.07404983043670654,
-0.42296460270881653,
-0.4807594120502472,
0.018460070714354515,
-0.630827009677887,
-0.4084182381629944,
0.1999443769454956,
0.39111989736557007,
-0.5679020285606384,
0.4820711314678192,
-0.487176775932312,
0.5457529425621033,
-0.6521322727203369,
-0.44945523142814636,
0.08039524406194687,
-0.2986694276332855,
-0.08918668329715729,
0.32698559761047363,
0.5681089758872986,
1.1262807846069336,
0.2933964431285858,
-0.15121643245220184,
-0.1397019475698471,
0.17856763303279877,
-0.04246218129992485,
-0.9670924544334412,
-0.41709104180336,
0.1255446821451187,
-0.4025421440601349,
-0.6050477027893066,
0.34952306747436523,
-0.696928858757019,
-0.6373469829559326,
-0.41841331124305725,
0.32867735624313354,
-0.29735463857650757,
-0.2550737261772156,
0.1746939718723297,
-0.42349928617477417,
-0.1648840457201004,
0.7841203212738037,
-0.4019250273704529,
0.5257921814918518,
0.5388675332069397,
1.03122079372406,
0.25153598189353943,
-0.04413598030805588,
-0.3491385281085968,
0.40142762660980225,
-0.2749002277851105,
1.00155770778656,
0.009271945804357529,
-0.15785880386829376,
0.004486524034291506,
-0.18704871833324432,
-0.05240669846534729,
-0.37257030606269836,
0.5570851564407349,
-0.364375501871109,
0.10216430574655533,
-0.4328276216983795,
-0.2856352925300598,
-0.814987063407898,
0.25342512130737305,
-0.4751109480857849,
0.8265894055366516,
-0.03728407621383667,
-1.1488384008407593,
0.32646191120147705,
-0.7148774266242981,
-1.0074187517166138,
-0.3857719600200653,
-0.15575210750102997,
-0.530337393283844,
0.3037000000476837,
0.6330059170722961,
0.6317265033721924,
-0.1690533608198166,
0.6423860192298889,
-0.19836533069610596,
-0.4546143412590027,
-0.08292734622955322,
-0.10137651115655899,
0.9500384330749512,
0.20867522060871124,
-0.14860808849334717,
-0.08176234364509583,
-0.7643774747848511,
-0.3902079463005066,
0.17989514768123627,
-0.41222211718559265,
-0.18517997860908508,
0.10426371544599533,
0.462472528219223,
0.13742497563362122,
-0.20002156496047974,
-0.08548874408006668,
0.04685119912028313,
0.08696381747722626,
0.1366029679775238,
0.44190332293510437,
0.5677602291107178,
0.13544721901416779,
-0.677972137928009,
0.22131481766700745,
0.026588421314954758,
-0.14917731285095215,
-0.5987903475761414,
-0.2800949811935425,
-0.8072900176048279,
-0.21425431966781616,
0.23488590121269226,
0.7195309996604919,
-0.617933452129364,
0.44997864961624146,
-0.5204146504402161,
-0.44268354773521423,
-0.2881331741809845,
-0.031134016811847687,
0.04671088978648186,
0.6628462076187134,
0.6234938502311707,
0.006421581842005253,
-0.9850716590881348,
-0.7131528854370117,
-0.27856147289276123,
-0.2467261105775833,
-0.36889883875846863,
0.189163476228714,
0.5193268060684204,
-0.14121417701244354,
1.095320701599121,
-0.6923540234565735,
-0.4713098704814911,
-0.44360411167144775,
0.3966391086578369,
0.022898467257618904,
0.13314755260944366,
0.9116438627243042,
-1.0450140237808228,
-0.21167530119419098,
-0.33436840772628784,
-1.0605554580688477,
-0.19582833349704742,
-0.2989642918109894,
0.3360415995121002,
0.12812618911266327,
-0.051459647715091705,
-0.2107621282339096,
0.6022951602935791,
0.24798078835010529,
-0.1928689032793045,
0.2781582474708557,
0.044560763984918594,
0.6281644701957703,
-1.4092357158660889,
0.07677051424980164,
-0.07844372093677521,
-0.4352206289768219,
-0.38287290930747986,
-0.18783201277256012,
0.1704496443271637,
-0.02454509027302265,
-0.40680500864982605,
0.3217827379703522,
-0.3483946621417999,
-0.25983837246894836,
-0.35459232330322266,
0.5173524022102356,
0.016796711832284927,
0.12403751164674759,
0.3502051532268524,
0.4540925621986389,
0.5173515677452087,
-0.7631233930587769,
0.6063066720962524,
0.3394313156604767,
-0.10350804775953293,
0.29755574464797974,
-0.3645942211151123,
-0.31493598222732544,
-0.5645724534988403,
0.4952127933502197,
-1.0618528127670288,
-0.6377193331718445,
-0.08177343755960464,
-0.5791873931884766,
-0.11782827228307724,
-0.2580011785030365,
-0.6720839142799377,
-0.20267793536186218,
-0.7614135146141052,
-0.26706019043922424,
0.2613341510295868,
-0.3840351998806,
0.6298871636390686,
0.6341663002967834,
-0.12698064744472504,
-0.31383535265922546,
-0.9084256887435913,
0.4869673550128937,
-0.6120152473449707,
-0.43550339341163635,
-0.07707999646663666,
-0.0014757015742361546,
-0.36654022336006165,
0.1693457067012787,
-0.24745753407478333,
0.0339796207845211,
0.5240193009376526,
0.19702783226966858,
-0.16002415120601654,
-0.08607200533151627,
-0.17255833745002747,
0.0774802416563034,
-0.37663698196411133,
-0.10189212113618851,
0.16780990362167358,
0.0839473158121109,
-0.08701170235872269,
-0.0040239072404801846,
-0.27290233969688416,
0.4518379867076874,
0.25157615542411804,
0.027514606714248657,
0.9209848046302795,
0.5826918482780457,
-0.7853955626487732,
0.2339506447315216,
-0.43116822838783264,
-0.1588241010904312,
-0.2643912434577942,
0.1929587572813034,
-0.11400357633829117,
-0.5812165141105652,
0.7382093667984009,
-0.018040571361780167,
0.3609364926815033,
0.6198500394821167,
0.40285587310791016,
-0.1568315476179123,
0.6400505900382996,
0.27013951539993286,
-0.2289528250694275,
0.15695232152938843,
-0.44399020075798035,
-0.29737308621406555,
-0.4148592948913574,
0.06241878867149353,
-0.18234044313430786,
-0.012528091669082642,
-0.2488621175289154,
-0.18769827485084534,
0.2495339810848236,
0.12946657836437225,
0.09629639238119125,
0.5317771434783936,
-0.1516643613576889,
0.37398386001586914,
0.2762838304042816,
0.16539856791496277,
0.6268965005874634,
0.07495784759521484,
0.6189298629760742,
0.05703110247850418,
-0.7120828628540039,
-0.7447823882102966,
0.9049171209335327,
0.3078054189682007,
0.5903882384300232,
0.28937992453575134,
0.697894811630249,
0.562585175037384,
0.8005916476249695,
-0.5242423415184021,
0.46832889318466187,
0.006457319483160973,
-0.7258539795875549,
-0.012224719859659672,
-0.6795555353164673,
-0.291448712348938,
0.2819967269897461,
-0.06291669607162476,
-0.25070691108703613,
-0.2250291109085083,
0.21719872951507568,
-0.5833715200424194,
0.3211101293563843,
-0.6118730902671814,
0.1898822784423828,
0.011776427738368511,
0.37292397022247314,
-0.19303829967975616,
-1.0061839818954468,
0.4911786615848541,
-0.07861309498548508,
0.5115808248519897,
-0.22932858765125275,
-0.18661119043827057,
1.001374363899231,
-0.42519208788871765,
0.6927298903465271,
-0.06074776500463486,
-0.017826031893491745,
0.5795212984085083,
-0.1529221385717392,
0.44463053345680237,
0.6904379725456238,
0.014851787127554417,
-0.019960252568125725,
-0.5199090242385864,
-0.5488604307174683,
-0.34797224402427673,
0.5889101624488831,
-0.5198282599449158,
-0.20946504175662994,
-0.47905123233795166,
-0.5085864663124084,
-0.1048331931233406,
0.06283336132764816,
0.4115617871284485,
0.8815456628799438,
-0.0992380827665329,
0.14379285275936127,
0.5669634342193604,
-0.15282775461673737,
0.42028525471687317,
0.5898115634918213,
0.2132512331008911,
-0.9359716176986694,
0.6461742520332336,
0.48324480652809143,
-0.10842889547348022,
0.4221442937850952,
0.13048993051052094,
-0.04577150195837021,
-0.5592706799507141,
-0.5269920229911804,
0.10961693525314331,
-0.789993166923523,
-0.7470828294754028,
-1.025816559791565,
-0.2511618733406067,
-0.4871934950351715,
-0.449800968170166,
-0.3186336159706116,
-0.7291274666786194,
-0.06652652472257614,
-0.7109696269035339,
0.661621630191803,
0.5520716905593872,
-0.4435007572174072,
0.5442246794700623,
-0.860238254070282,
0.764855682849884,
-0.04468262195587158,
0.15996228158473969,
-0.3481997549533844,
-0.5318169593811035,
-0.3980376422405243,
0.2931740880012512,
-0.1904284507036209,
-0.7106034159660339,
0.035062357783317566,
0.30962732434272766,
0.13642217218875885,
0.7495536804199219,
0.39999833703041077,
0.8041175603866577,
-0.25766223669052124,
0.5550041198730469,
0.028347184881567955,
-0.5510117411613464,
0.8420862555503845,
-0.7508986592292786,
0.022444775328040123,
0.7808226943016052,
0.3691513240337372,
-0.47121280431747437,
-0.34035050868988037,
-0.7559914588928223,
-0.956885576248169,
0.7778317928314209,
0.5592817068099976,
-0.04949996992945671,
0.12239868938922882,
0.03448463976383209,
0.025622716173529625,
0.3772108554840088,
-0.10997388511896133,
-0.7083624601364136,
-0.1233789399266243,
-0.3316824436187744,
-0.291082501411438,
-0.6152426600456238,
-0.39348044991493225,
0.20800018310546875,
0.7604665160179138,
0.12160801142454147,
-0.20744942128658295,
-0.015677103772759438,
-0.37822362780570984,
-0.08167294412851334,
-0.09089810401201248,
0.7547656893730164,
0.8443471193313599,
-0.8232955932617188,
0.5445895195007324,
0.3601172864437103,
-0.540734589099884,
-0.018225181847810745,
0.5131474137306213,
-0.20871064066886902,
0.3765430748462677,
0.8793792128562927,
0.5531246662139893,
0.10223886370658875,
-0.6285758018493652,
0.6414053440093994,
-0.30019044876098633,
-0.24254347383975983,
-0.30041393637657166,
0.011719579808413982,
-0.022480161860585213,
0.01978539675474167,
0.805556058883667,
0.19458381831645966,
0.7530949115753174,
-0.35723450779914856,
0.5414633750915527,
-0.5199760794639587,
-0.2219560444355011,
-0.40739184617996216,
0.6856786608695984,
0.22959159314632416,
0.0384393036365509,
0.21413344144821167,
-0.14029796421527863,
-0.5059428811073303,
0.5578223466873169,
0.2260797619819641,
0.6846431493759155,
-0.45882150530815125,
0.3498765230178833,
0.45188623666763306,
0.532416045665741,
-0.2274908870458603,
0.3194696307182312,
-0.043497234582901,
-0.38067078590393066,
-0.3450949490070343,
-0.35270625352859497,
-0.27370354533195496,
0.27500948309898376,
-0.7071359157562256,
0.35023701190948486,
-0.19214022159576416,
0.022396976128220558,
-0.3794112503528595,
0.00683567626401782,
-0.3348928689956665,
0.7473531365394592,
-0.08756381273269653,
0.9619368314743042,
-1.3938788175582886,
-0.11321967095136642,
1.1334067583084106,
-0.2638895809650421,
-0.32006195187568665,
0.039573874324560165,
0.11941660195589066,
-0.2866445779800415,
-0.1369916796684265,
0.44758346676826477,
0.3241269290447235,
0.02798609808087349,
-0.17005105316638947,
-0.6972525119781494,
1.088982105255127,
0.3639274835586548,
0.2650950849056244,
0.18565580248832703,
0.108701191842556,
0.3445670008659363,
-0.16989728808403015,
0.2929893732070923,
0.3043875992298126,
0.36439257860183716,
0.07793398201465607,
-0.5040445327758789,
0.09937852621078491,
-0.015393059700727463,
-0.08417576551437378,
0.28281864523887634,
-0.7012509107589722,
0.2821805477142334,
-0.6269994378089905,
-0.39153504371643066,
-0.2971532642841339,
0.827007532119751,
0.39636585116386414,
0.7596854567527771,
0.40343794226646423,
0.7308692336082458,
0.350771427154541,
-0.23228809237480164,
0.8535523414611816,
0.0850825235247612,
0.8245172500610352,
1.1818264722824097,
0.30334100127220154,
0.2024868130683899,
0.0873226523399353,
-0.11109542101621628,
-0.12338810414075851,
1.0558327436447144,
0.3551281988620758,
0.7298008799552917,
-0.04484262317419052,
-0.08270945399999619,
-0.31750911474227905,
-0.32708531618118286,
-0.36543482542037964,
0.10972132533788681,
0.5641511678695679,
-0.20199184119701385,
-0.9936768412590027,
0.10031142830848694,
0.26795387268066406,
0.1352638602256775,
-0.20887014269828796,
0.85791015625,
0.20725300908088684,
-0.06938182562589645,
0.3280414044857025,
0.05799266695976257,
0.1393774151802063,
-0.0816405713558197,
-0.14829446375370026,
-0.4081226885318756,
-0.0504184365272522,
-0.5191424489021301,
-0.8105618953704834,
0.5722509026527405,
-0.003421763889491558,
0.005929377395659685,
0.13855335116386414,
0.530478298664093,
-0.3148498833179474,
-0.46969103813171387,
0.08281019330024719,
0.11472662538290024,
0.3783981502056122,
-0.349194198846817,
-0.30511870980262756,
-0.020570270717144012,
-0.2349233776330948,
-0.5296120643615723,
-0.08396676182746887,
0.5674633979797363,
-0.19479131698608398,
0.6173453330993652,
0.33268699049949646,
0.03657190874218941,
-0.37129566073417664,
0.12102866917848587,
1.023875117301941,
-0.6751779913902283,
-0.7414022088050842,
-0.9125431180000305,
0.6673087477684021,
-0.3781508207321167,
-0.0964057520031929,
0.9530830383300781,
1.0921989679336548,
0.49287134408950806,
-0.0726931244134903,
1.2355139255523682,
-0.23748616874217987,
0.8944329023361206,
-0.411647230386734,
0.5440632700920105,
-0.44131067395210266,
0.09651947021484375,
-0.22290964424610138,
-0.8629510998725891,
-0.6500014066696167,
0.4562065601348877,
-0.14785565435886383,
0.0392460823059082,
0.25596073269844055,
0.3558274507522583,
-0.23983052372932434,
-0.14596159756183624,
0.03445656597614288,
-0.03599100932478905,
0.0975615382194519,
0.32520216703414917,
0.6226252913475037,
-0.9330253601074219,
0.4304253160953522,
-0.26228955388069153,
-0.5407830476760864,
-0.8535172343254089,
-0.8303216099739075,
-1.2210476398468018,
-0.5045022368431091,
-0.4445347189903259,
-0.2691853642463684,
0.13376761972904205,
0.6721580028533936,
0.4504733085632324,
-1.1572500467300415,
0.17135465145111084,
0.054171234369277954,
0.22289106249809265,
-0.05132686719298363,
-0.2568369507789612,
0.8410743474960327,
0.060619864612817764,
-0.23813915252685547,
0.048294201493263245,
0.27471724152565,
0.14399874210357666,
0.4099537432193756,
0.08651205152273178,
-0.10059597343206406,
0.038770582526922226,
0.5738699436187744,
-0.2334413081407547,
-0.20102539658546448,
-0.0960727408528328,
-0.393460750579834,
-0.054258279502391815,
-0.15836234390735626,
0.6716386079788208,
-0.5482346415519714,
0.12471883744001389,
0.5162716507911682,
0.681864857673645,
0.26114243268966675,
0.8744618892669678,
0.32661449909210205,
-0.9270040392875671,
0.30745840072631836,
-0.018837612122297287,
0.23711232841014862,
0.6578416228294373,
-0.4000152051448822,
0.9769989252090454,
0.36767980456352234,
-0.033740974962711334,
-0.9415785074234009,
0.03622357174754143,
-0.7056122422218323,
-0.025309696793556213,
1.3527321815490723,
-0.027633270248770714,
0.2279631793498993,
-0.28987860679626465,
-0.24066391587257385,
0.6079421639442444,
-0.49943116307258606,
1.0500396490097046,
0.4442827105522156,
0.1313692331314087,
0.02439103275537491,
-0.6343908905982971,
0.5017170906066895,
-0.2688070237636566,
-0.8731786608695984,
0.08350528031587601,
0.38214462995529175,
0.3503936231136322,
0.13102982938289642,
0.6208441853523254,
0.10234669595956802,
0.31048664450645447,
-0.29291853308677673,
-0.024405963718891144,
-0.23283839225769043,
-0.508067786693573,
-0.1029232069849968,
0.07456441223621368,
-0.41589680314064026,
-0.35494816303253174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06549v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06549v1
|
Sampling the Swadesh List to Identify Similar Languages with Tree Spaces
| 2024-05-10T15:46:05 | 2024-05-10T15:46:05 |
Garett Ordway, Vic Patrangenaru
|
stat.AP
|
stat.AP, cs.CL
|
Communication plays a vital role in human interaction. Studying language is a
worthwhile task and more recently has become quantitative in nature with
developments of fields like quantitative comparative linguistics and
lexicostatistics. With respect to the authors own native languages, the
ancestry of the English language and the Latin alphabet are of the primary
interest. The Indo-European Tree traces many modern languages back to the
Proto-Indo-European root. Swadesh's cognates played a large role in developing
that historical perspective where some of the primary branches are Germanic,
Celtic, Italic, and Balto-Slavic. This paper will use data analysis on open
books where the simplest singular space is the 3-spider - a union T3 of three
rays with their endpoints glued at a point 0 - which can represent these tree
spaces for language clustering. These trees are built using a single linkage
method for clustering based on distances between samples from languages which
use the Latin Script. Taking three languages at a time, the barycenter is
determined. Some initial results have found both non-sticky and sticky sample
means. If the mean exhibits non-sticky properties, then one language may come
from a different ancestor than the other two. If the mean is considered sticky,
then the languages may share a common ancestor or all languages may have
different ancestry.
|
[
-0.3081232011318207,
-0.46660712361335754,
0.12363425642251968,
0.013123998418450356,
-0.2817087471485138,
0.24406440556049347,
-0.2601810693740845,
-0.6200513243675232,
0.7148141264915466,
0.18904303014278412,
-0.38212090730667114,
-0.5024154186248779,
-0.24324287474155426,
0.22377343475818634,
-0.3132123053073883,
0.8116247057914734,
0.01829780824482441,
-0.10063934326171875,
0.07884763926267624,
-0.6679719686508179,
0.11091932654380798,
-0.39652857184410095,
-0.1783316433429718,
0.25186747312545776,
0.2896069884300232,
0.361877977848053,
0.6923543810844421,
0.6728449463844299,
0.42449116706848145,
0.3472771644592285,
-0.38037315011024475,
-0.18427085876464844,
-0.37671443819999695,
0.5339581966400146,
-0.20229464769363403,
-0.6877620816230774,
0.029273124411702156,
0.007497926242649555,
0.649228036403656,
0.9269919991493225,
0.050799041986465454,
0.22714562714099884,
0.045920323580503464,
0.45976823568344116,
-0.39853233098983765,
-0.04213666915893555,
-0.4980804920196533,
-0.06653819978237152,
-0.9081296920776367,
-0.39295393228530884,
-0.24921569228172302,
-0.8780362606048584,
0.10569894313812256,
-0.4257453978061676,
0.5215867161750793,
0.15101730823516846,
0.8003086447715759,
-0.12452064454555511,
-0.32947295904159546,
-0.3977949321269989,
-0.8225153088569641,
0.7921557426452637,
-0.49349841475486755,
0.2006157785654068,
0.31242695450782776,
0.32719752192497253,
-0.22161121666431427,
-0.031463053077459335,
-0.40150755643844604,
-0.12262842059135437,
0.030439386144280434,
0.0708284080028534,
-0.323868066072464,
-0.16132952272891998,
-0.026789164170622826,
0.553443431854248,
-0.7612674236297607,
0.03162357211112976,
-0.9082916975021362,
0.1449742615222931,
0.4771639108657837,
-0.27741849422454834,
0.6914845108985901,
0.015384068712592125,
-0.12715023756027222,
-0.10797041654586792,
-0.9415093660354614,
0.21221698820590973,
0.5465521216392517,
0.6079319715499878,
0.11190283298492432,
0.9368112683296204,
0.1783587783575058,
0.7132620811462402,
-0.11694974452257156,
-0.4664980173110962,
0.12103761732578278,
-0.4499582350254059,
0.06760580837726593,
-0.17301522195339203,
0.21685919165611267,
0.24615366756916046,
0.48364007472991943,
-0.04480956494808197,
0.24850568175315857,
0.10383947193622589,
-0.1255149394273758,
-0.47205692529678345,
-0.0005540069541893899,
-0.014447352848947048,
-0.6425076723098755,
0.1116618663072586,
0.11610601097345352,
-0.6806675791740417,
-0.18631653487682343,
-0.10092494636774063,
-0.31847864389419556,
-0.6478966474533081,
-0.6129282712936401,
-0.4308710992336273,
-0.4292193353176117,
0.3684787452220917,
-0.13751204311847687,
-0.9744006991386414,
0.7722139358520508,
0.5019354820251465,
0.6591646671295166,
-0.4195012152194977,
-0.5932862758636475,
-0.24064788222312927,
0.0907021090388298,
-0.48090022802352905,
0.9055612683296204,
-0.9880325198173523,
-0.41898101568222046,
0.11515043675899506,
0.03855699673295021,
-0.1871202439069748,
-0.597276508808136,
0.2540317177772522,
-0.3545280992984772,
0.2234039604663849,
-0.023687541484832764,
-0.45891237258911133,
-0.3115364611148834,
0.04614000394940376,
-0.5945177674293518,
1.1107121706008911,
0.40438127517700195,
-0.8824119567871094,
0.6607829332351685,
-0.11809436976909637,
-0.43098175525665283,
0.42453762888908386,
-0.5093256831169128,
-0.0791785940527916,
0.3697771430015564,
-0.20645713806152344,
0.03537929430603981,
-0.01843499392271042,
-0.042536161839962006,
-0.5961759686470032,
-0.45167970657348633,
-0.12920419871807098,
0.008081000298261642,
1.1172280311584473,
0.42650771141052246,
-0.35284268856048584,
0.017551640048623085,
-0.7526264190673828,
0.026507243514060974,
-0.14179223775863647,
-0.24713777005672455,
-1.0191023349761963,
0.09107134491205215,
0.11243857443332672,
0.011065015569329262,
-0.007902632467448711,
-0.8768994808197021,
0.48330938816070557,
-0.5602407455444336,
-0.13248956203460693,
0.4810418486595154,
0.09616822004318237,
0.3884718716144562,
-0.16329391300678253,
0.9362308979034424,
0.05662672966718674,
-0.09681380540132523,
0.08194015920162201,
-0.6974006295204163,
-0.4727412760257721,
-0.21614255011081696,
0.22705619037151337,
0.48624899983406067,
-0.46249979734420776,
0.5036391615867615,
-0.2081492692232132,
-0.7835912108421326,
-0.5541761517524719,
0.09122301638126373,
0.08932218700647354,
-0.17451111972332,
0.0477655827999115,
-0.25428247451782227,
-0.6793793439865112,
-0.7535524964332581,
-0.2176833301782608,
-0.3128150403499603,
0.22017902135849,
0.12536674737930298,
0.3403075039386749,
-0.013869581744074821,
1.2103354930877686,
-0.25399523973464966,
-0.03208934888243675,
-0.15935364365577698,
-0.27020835876464844,
0.36855176091194153,
0.2546280026435852,
0.6265516877174377,
-0.3954964578151703,
-0.8544253706932068,
0.3144512474536896,
-0.3278394937515259,
-0.08187180012464523,
0.3208047151565552,
0.10022023320198059,
0.4511696696281433,
0.49491164088249207,
-0.3609488606452942,
0.5964020490646362,
0.7915937304496765,
-0.4182957708835602,
0.33987677097320557,
-0.08190413564443588,
0.11245166510343552,
-1.2709083557128906,
0.3052311837673187,
-0.12007144838571548,
0.3753888010978699,
-0.5204023718833923,
0.18576566874980927,
-0.2778575122356415,
-0.23122109472751617,
-0.14487363398075104,
0.7139765024185181,
-0.6505239009857178,
-0.1314869523048401,
-0.057950470596551895,
0.28358879685401917,
-0.6166841983795166,
0.2920583486557007,
0.070250503718853,
0.6851443648338318,
0.4879574477672577,
-0.39304786920547485,
0.0002425486600259319,
0.05018094927072525,
-0.12375795841217041,
0.5722589492797852,
-0.30892640352249146,
-0.3014659285545349,
-0.1943131387233734,
0.010853278450667858,
-1.2854264974594116,
0.23630644381046295,
-0.005132886115461588,
-0.5316361784934998,
0.017048176378011703,
-0.2921311855316162,
-0.14880532026290894,
-0.33463409543037415,
-0.5647494196891785,
0.5597115159034729,
0.42080479860305786,
-0.446707159280777,
0.2025335282087326,
0.6524918079376221,
-0.6683415174484253,
-0.40559858083724976,
-0.4415815770626068,
-0.2223883420228958,
-0.4452463388442993,
-0.6005656123161316,
-0.030817456543445587,
-0.04750485718250275,
-0.5590310096740723,
0.0859806090593338,
-0.33396199345588684,
-0.19602639973163605,
-0.039822693914175034,
0.41332027316093445,
0.2576918601989746,
-0.3587877154350281,
-0.01298998948186636,
0.016930870711803436,
0.0056536137126386166,
-0.4288107454776764,
-0.4271196722984314,
0.3033056855201721,
-0.2459532618522644,
-0.5226238965988159,
0.12634560465812683,
0.5105528235435486,
0.5663033723831177,
-0.05225604400038719,
0.41338875889778137,
0.23686212301254272,
-0.29580798745155334,
0.12856809794902802,
-0.33580806851387024,
0.10902735590934753,
-0.35091981291770935,
-0.052178192883729935,
-0.6077859401702881,
-1.0775575637817383,
0.3866420388221741,
0.07086313515901566,
0.270943820476532,
0.5008325576782227,
0.4291110932826996,
-0.06486161798238754,
0.6302605867385864,
0.8931794762611389,
-0.4192250967025757,
0.36025524139404297,
0.11886782944202423,
0.5510073900222778,
-0.33850592374801636,
0.07910066843032837,
-1.1753325462341309,
-0.19953568279743195,
-1.071715235710144,
-0.4416849911212921,
0.1199810653924942,
0.17760585248470306,
0.2439538836479187,
0.7892541885375977,
-0.27627718448638916,
0.5476614832878113,
0.6179549694061279,
-0.753648042678833,
0.34722042083740234,
0.5167073607444763,
-0.4553140103816986,
-0.2736242115497589,
-0.4990975856781006,
-0.5941150784492493,
0.7329446077346802,
0.17511087656021118,
0.8154858946800232,
0.4368876814842224,
0.9891205430030823,
-0.039068371057510376,
0.19608110189437866,
-0.5375316739082336,
0.4717937707901001,
-0.11423389613628387,
-0.6497194766998291,
-0.31668078899383545,
0.005469581577926874,
-1.5107357501983643,
0.34031975269317627,
0.2112116813659668,
-0.994476318359375,
0.4266105890274048,
-0.11688274145126343,
-0.15110880136489868,
0.16009213030338287,
-0.7669946551322937,
0.3310253620147705,
-0.0014726504450663924,
-0.17737051844596863,
-0.1591995507478714,
-0.6707087755203247,
0.23919284343719482,
0.30834221839904785,
0.35845085978507996,
-0.03711686655879021,
-0.008585365489125252,
1.014933705329895,
-0.33660656213760376,
0.9205574989318848,
-0.18698029220104218,
0.023309826850891113,
0.5078082084655762,
0.4570247232913971,
0.020486261695623398,
-0.43381819128990173,
0.08873061835765839,
-0.16290326416492462,
0.7320964336395264,
-0.7129408121109009,
-0.11261231452226639,
0.6190185546875,
-0.6958847641944885,
-0.35467514395713806,
-0.695592999458313,
-0.24963416159152985,
-0.3150549530982971,
0.3800443112850189,
0.05377337336540222,
0.2653536796569824,
-0.43891555070877075,
0.39531010389328003,
0.23226867616176605,
-0.04974246397614479,
0.5598878264427185,
0.5256686806678772,
-0.44422677159309387,
-0.12652409076690674,
0.7747852802276611,
0.12099890410900116,
-0.13388942182064056,
0.28555214405059814,
0.22581709921360016,
-0.2771828770637512,
-0.5058759450912476,
-0.17248961329460144,
0.41537150740623474,
-0.3861290514469147,
0.023025279864668846,
-0.19087767601013184,
-0.13968001306056976,
-0.46318408846855164,
-0.26598218083381653,
-0.023215822875499725,
-0.4813363552093506,
0.18013042211532593,
-0.23652389645576477,
0.38373449444770813,
1.029953122138977,
0.06460445374250412,
0.21825428307056427,
-0.7936418652534485,
-0.05847382918000221,
0.11570801585912704,
0.33322426676750183,
-0.11786723881959915,
0.007067810744047165,
0.0757094994187355,
-0.2002781182527542,
-0.011012059636414051,
-1.0517314672470093,
0.44130799174308777,
0.2957175076007843,
0.8821662664413452,
0.6404303908348083,
-0.36580413579940796,
0.7557618021965027,
-0.24969391524791718,
0.7113365530967712,
0.006962036248296499,
-0.4941340982913971,
0.46953466534614563,
-0.5080683827400208,
0.2663537263870239,
0.8588660359382629,
0.6515021920204163,
-0.9780359268188477,
-0.7485905885696411,
-0.8762386441230774,
-0.694368839263916,
0.4783547818660736,
0.19763769209384918,
-0.24946893751621246,
-0.27778738737106323,
-0.2695748209953308,
0.3251548409461975,
-0.0536116361618042,
-0.6307239532470703,
-0.05847054719924927,
0.248550683259964,
-0.30904102325439453,
-0.19239690899848938,
-0.03348661586642265,
-0.07697855681180954,
-0.4013536274433136,
0.3921978771686554,
-0.12359242886304855,
-0.0843028724193573,
-0.20962591469287872,
-0.2925628125667572,
-0.3153385818004608,
0.5477551221847534,
0.531355082988739,
0.9435481429100037,
-0.20495279133319855,
0.5415346026420593,
-0.097394660115242,
-0.7835583090782166,
0.10326915234327316,
-0.06612001359462738,
-0.1810314804315567,
0.11371276527643204,
0.45967015624046326,
0.33120888471603394,
0.17259646952152252,
-0.6141817569732666,
0.2703085243701935,
0.02118457295000553,
0.027855124324560165,
-0.29553020000457764,
-0.1498367190361023,
0.22899943590164185,
0.05827254429459572,
0.4521845877170563,
0.20167817175388336,
0.012560968287289143,
-0.8865991830825806,
0.2840195298194885,
0.38245871663093567,
-0.2418215274810791,
-0.40006861090660095,
-0.05855337530374527,
0.24118317663669586,
-0.44282248616218567,
0.41936638951301575,
-0.1507773995399475,
-0.45056816935539246,
0.5416249632835388,
0.7441022992134094,
0.45076197385787964,
-0.4257274568080902,
0.18412691354751587,
0.5072439908981323,
0.36171337962150574,
0.4538986384868622,
0.419342041015625,
-0.23692525923252106,
-0.45326778292655945,
-0.19127501547336578,
-0.7572239637374878,
-0.22934505343437195,
-0.15715904533863068,
-0.6523278951644897,
0.17189374566078186,
-0.0952422246336937,
0.2539820671081543,
-0.16597917675971985,
0.21360185742378235,
-0.2892072796821594,
-0.17690956592559814,
0.12235382944345474,
1.2055643796920776,
-1.288246512413025,
0.8986130952835083,
0.4972878396511078,
-0.17748913168907166,
-0.7345377206802368,
-0.004073563031852245,
0.2169949859380722,
-0.7645204663276672,
0.5344176292419434,
-0.0020446465350687504,
-0.22680720686912537,
-0.1197059229016304,
-0.23165802657604218,
-1.1091957092285156,
0.8499876856803894,
-0.2909836173057556,
-0.47311460971832275,
0.16434569656848907,
-0.16628798842430115,
0.9940141439437866,
-0.28964903950691223,
0.36628252267837524,
0.7878804802894592,
0.34398847818374634,
0.159756138920784,
-0.7315035462379456,
-0.012399952858686447,
-0.7669492959976196,
0.16629306972026825,
0.5120305418968201,
-0.12212993949651718,
0.6556493639945984,
0.002128385240212083,
-0.5467128157615662,
0.1773870587348938,
0.5361856818199158,
0.8826864957809448,
-0.0754743367433548,
0.47889092564582825,
0.32353338599205017,
0.8852350115776062,
0.14922213554382324,
0.7239859700202942,
-0.44538238644599915,
0.03999157249927521,
0.832166314125061,
-0.3947041928768158,
1.128423810005188,
0.9076159000396729,
-0.6174535155296326,
0.5083393454551697,
0.7862309813499451,
-0.05060867965221405,
0.14880439639091492,
0.43815484642982483,
-0.2529942989349365,
0.5671588778495789,
0.05821917951107025,
-0.5468307733535767,
0.30427002906799316,
0.3638845682144165,
0.03998726233839989,
-0.5808209776878357,
-0.12948530912399292,
0.18061505258083344,
0.0707550197839737,
0.056946080178022385,
0.4928452968597412,
-0.1391335427761078,
-1.1757498979568481,
0.4916437566280365,
-0.22963418066501617,
0.7728227972984314,
-0.7150470018386841,
-0.0026913953479379416,
-0.440530925989151,
0.1546025574207306,
-0.3104778230190277,
-0.7826316952705383,
0.47623810172080994,
-0.08030226826667786,
0.10441664606332779,
0.028231503441929817,
0.7299898266792297,
-0.6821592450141907,
-0.37460580468177795,
0.35937026143074036,
0.7320695519447327,
0.663297712802887,
0.4366987645626068,
-0.1125769093632698,
-0.09260176122188568,
0.06989400088787079,
-0.01919694058597088,
0.16827332973480225,
0.004243212286382914,
-0.5576692223548889,
0.34655293822288513,
0.434579461812973,
0.5569018125534058,
0.4795459806919098,
-0.047943562269210815,
0.38842669129371643,
-0.808789074420929,
-0.5489827394485474,
-0.5826612114906311,
0.15361055731773376,
-0.09067896008491516,
-0.36409613490104675,
1.1846280097961426,
0.9187780618667603,
0.6852154731750488,
-0.22172051668167114,
0.7468751072883606,
-0.5189118981361389,
0.9892033338546753,
-0.020887965336441994,
0.5222424864768982,
-0.3390706181526184,
-0.20183345675468445,
-0.2938745617866516,
-1.075986385345459,
-0.10355733335018158,
0.4913214445114136,
-0.12363976240158081,
-0.11491621285676956,
1.1879456043243408,
0.7571215629577637,
-0.11610179394483566,
0.19493632018566132,
0.11942827701568604,
0.16078101098537445,
0.10152312368154526,
0.21295872330665588,
0.7065054774284363,
-0.04571457952260971,
0.6748266816139221,
-0.08058914542198181,
-0.5851926803588867,
-0.1884460300207138,
-0.4673905074596405,
-0.7508457899093628,
-1.0769047737121582,
0.11347522586584091,
-0.31688588857650757,
-0.19832174479961395,
0.828279972076416,
0.5375010371208191,
-1.075972557067871,
-0.7383670210838318,
0.11262211203575134,
0.0755239948630333,
-0.4758740961551666,
-0.19740945100784302,
0.33751749992370605,
-0.1781667023897171,
-0.6517183184623718,
0.610166609287262,
0.4720214307308197,
0.26430657505989075,
-0.2399512529373169,
0.06597722321748734,
-0.4863514006137848,
-0.01678495481610298,
0.47817671298980713,
0.8602010011672974,
-0.7204094529151917,
-0.16077251732349396,
0.17300070822238922,
-0.23310129344463348,
0.029461326077580452,
1.1579992771148682,
-0.5674875974655151,
0.28391313552856445,
0.7430364489555359,
0.3261275589466095,
0.5798782110214233,
-0.08300726860761642,
0.40435364842414856,
-0.8805525898933411,
0.25452330708503723,
0.1786022186279297,
0.2468290627002716,
0.07213391363620758,
0.042837291955947876,
0.6083433628082275,
0.3445456326007843,
-0.2760983109474182,
-0.6918506026268005,
0.2241813987493515,
-1.139768362045288,
-0.3395026624202728,
1.085120677947998,
0.029113495722413063,
-0.5620379447937012,
-0.550671398639679,
-0.42959141731262207,
-0.07044236361980438,
-0.008426239714026451,
0.5545707941055298,
0.8569387197494507,
-0.20802287757396698,
-0.051746588200330734,
-0.14224499464035034,
0.5142586827278137,
0.18874530494213104,
-0.7929723858833313,
-0.06139519810676575,
0.29684939980506897,
0.49882715940475464,
0.4840623736381531,
1.0073671340942383,
-0.2085130214691162,
0.09512781351804733,
0.17710649967193604,
0.05845927819609642,
0.5996667146682739,
-0.3707071542739868,
-0.4475453197956085,
0.36682063341140747,
0.3553358018398285,
-0.09071606397628784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06545v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06545v1
|
Mitigating Hallucinations in Large Language Models via Self-Refinement-Enhanced Knowledge Retrieval
| 2024-05-10T15:40:50 | 2024-05-10T15:40:50 |
Mengjia Niu, Hao Li, Jie Shi, Hamed Haddadi, Fan Mo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7; H.3.3
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across
various domains, although their susceptibility to hallucination poses
significant challenges for their deployment in critical areas such as
healthcare. To address this issue, retrieving relevant facts from knowledge
graphs (KGs) is considered a promising method. Existing KG-augmented approaches
tend to be resource-intensive, requiring multiple rounds of retrieval and
verification for each factoid, which impedes their application in real-world
scenarios.
In this study, we propose Self-Refinement-Enhanced Knowledge Graph Retrieval
(Re-KGR) to augment the factuality of LLMs' responses with less retrieval
efforts in the medical field. Our approach leverages the attribution of
next-token predictive probability distributions across different tokens, and
various model layers to primarily identify tokens with a high potential for
hallucination, reducing verification rounds by refining knowledge triples
associated with these tokens. Moreover, we rectify inaccurate content using
retrieved knowledge in the post-processing stage, which improves the
truthfulness of generated responses. Experimental results on a medical dataset
demonstrate that our approach can enhance the factual capability of LLMs across
various foundational models as evidenced by the highest scores on truthfulness.
|
[
-0.10794709622859955,
-0.8362525701522827,
0.8355141282081604,
-0.057798005640506744,
-0.23984870314598083,
0.05010515823960304,
-0.2410135418176651,
-0.4563430845737457,
0.5619833469390869,
0.8852881789207458,
-0.31652504205703735,
-0.619369387626648,
-0.5862552523612976,
0.3228670060634613,
-0.22092165052890778,
0.7998185157775879,
0.007570778485387564,
-0.0019011314725503325,
-0.29611748456954956,
-0.09536007791757584,
-0.41159412264823914,
-0.7680306434631348,
-0.48571163415908813,
-0.5786058306694031,
0.718656063079834,
0.31354615092277527,
0.6033512949943542,
0.5359696745872498,
0.5454635620117188,
0.27516475319862366,
0.14697833359241486,
0.4512134790420532,
-0.5690271854400635,
0.33144667744636536,
-0.04288092628121376,
-0.18816466629505157,
-0.4393891990184784,
-0.27014511823654175,
0.35461997985839844,
0.7746508121490479,
-0.19607391953468323,
-0.01667124219238758,
-0.055646345019340515,
0.7965334057807922,
-0.5674773454666138,
0.3689931035041809,
-0.7033835649490356,
0.21344710886478424,
0.1291826069355011,
-0.3460189700126648,
-0.4350401759147644,
-0.527506947517395,
0.14220239222049713,
-0.5651446580886841,
0.29193365573883057,
0.09665066748857498,
0.6604845523834229,
0.4760458171367645,
-0.3972189724445343,
-0.27297699451446533,
-0.5105130672454834,
0.3723907470703125,
-0.8134097456932068,
0.8135367035865784,
0.531970202922821,
0.3196820318698883,
-0.29316446185112,
-0.9975757598876953,
-0.6499960422515869,
-0.38811326026916504,
-0.5002284646034241,
-0.06624707579612732,
-0.11065609753131866,
0.08377739787101746,
0.28555992245674133,
0.1698598712682724,
-0.44621750712394714,
-0.085955910384655,
-0.35785508155822754,
-0.6510670185089111,
0.38505125045776367,
0.0955670028924942,
0.23232044279575348,
-0.455136239528656,
-0.09757910668849945,
0.06859520077705383,
-0.7339870929718018,
-0.49064743518829346,
-0.001076913671568036,
0.30754607915878296,
0.35113725066185,
0.7281084060668945,
-0.44228383898735046,
0.5623019933700562,
0.06828130036592484,
-0.4245968461036682,
0.6970240473747253,
-0.27580323815345764,
-0.12261506170034409,
0.19829337298870087,
0.7724460959434509,
0.357553631067276,
0.0901576429605484,
-0.5101454257965088,
-0.2522953450679779,
-0.1814395636320114,
0.546467661857605,
-0.9095679521560669,
-0.5366392731666565,
0.2724260091781616,
-0.5517475008964539,
-0.2908737063407898,
-0.2789829969406128,
-0.7016856670379639,
-0.7040872573852539,
-0.4573550224304199,
0.5128999352455139,
-0.655867338180542,
-0.2794610559940338,
0.11054032295942307,
0.11847752332687378,
-0.1882047802209854,
0.2896936237812042,
-0.6854447722434998,
-0.0010022525675594807,
0.5956141948699951,
0.7206904888153076,
-0.13025067746639252,
-0.07118561118841171,
-0.30398231744766235,
0.33169716596603394,
-0.3407662510871887,
0.7814029455184937,
-0.45410487055778503,
-0.2601258456707001,
-0.1584419310092926,
-0.020288828760385513,
0.16390731930732727,
-0.7654380798339844,
0.5998495221138,
-0.5697231888771057,
0.02854652889072895,
-0.5317221879959106,
-0.48213034868240356,
-0.2663561701774597,
0.49220988154411316,
-0.5878974795341492,
0.8192963004112244,
-0.04698001593351364,
-0.8092405200004578,
0.36280733346939087,
-0.35229671001434326,
-0.6994087100028992,
0.0066986833699047565,
-0.6554951071739197,
-0.5466139316558838,
0.13121284544467926,
0.49918216466903687,
0.5669425129890442,
-0.12495553493499756,
0.42440083622932434,
-0.3383641541004181,
-0.21347591280937195,
0.08951541781425476,
-0.33606669306755066,
0.2986208498477936,
0.2261691689491272,
-0.14906086027622223,
0.11364299058914185,
-0.8850098848342896,
0.16923490166664124,
0.0659886971116066,
-0.05994409695267677,
-0.2956168055534363,
-0.16854193806648254,
-0.5356623530387878,
0.28933826088905334,
0.15802915394306183,
-0.5188891291618347,
0.10209332406520844,
-0.518588662147522,
0.22371026873588562,
0.6667676568031311,
0.10189058631658554,
-0.100526362657547,
-0.3299310505390167,
0.2189919352531433,
0.08492205291986465,
0.1214098408818245,
0.07375386357307434,
-0.3157194256782532,
-0.6034414172172546,
-0.5179564356803894,
0.21281929314136505,
0.22265610098838806,
-0.960315465927124,
0.55584716796875,
-0.5175312757492065,
-0.5039693713188171,
-0.8442017436027527,
0.0728532001376152,
0.40989452600479126,
1.122544765472412,
0.6361818313598633,
-0.15353015065193176,
-0.5984611511230469,
-0.9602634310722351,
-0.24035929143428802,
-0.26170194149017334,
0.04064161702990532,
0.5349830985069275,
0.449786901473999,
-0.5722482204437256,
0.866051971912384,
-0.6951838731765747,
-0.5200327038764954,
-0.0814867690205574,
0.09914536774158478,
0.10975755006074905,
0.25087037682533264,
0.11627896130084991,
-0.6265129446983337,
-0.25761184096336365,
0.058247849345207214,
-0.9411932826042175,
-0.20225149393081665,
0.1477174609899521,
0.08937888592481613,
0.27516546845436096,
0.4988640546798706,
-0.6179386973381042,
0.47360485792160034,
0.26338768005371094,
-0.25642743706703186,
0.7599631547927856,
-0.4285009503364563,
0.3328308165073395,
-0.8534727096557617,
0.23443549871444702,
-0.46741536259651184,
-0.1921693980693817,
-0.45362386107444763,
-0.08769864588975906,
0.005339378025382757,
0.07886319607496262,
0.0786082074046135,
0.5440367460250854,
-0.38550645112991333,
-0.017226338386535645,
-0.4443454146385193,
0.19881664216518402,
0.1084163710474968,
0.20197677612304688,
0.05489647388458252,
0.6300420761108398,
0.4627789855003357,
-0.5104743242263794,
0.46627816557884216,
0.2307482659816742,
-0.2558456361293793,
0.23765045404434204,
-0.4362717270851135,
0.22107046842575073,
-0.35514676570892334,
0.37171754240989685,
-0.8946072459220886,
-0.3681486248970032,
0.42342445254325867,
-0.4950215816497803,
0.21068516373634338,
0.015158234164118767,
-0.6773961186408997,
-0.4565534293651581,
-0.10260383039712906,
0.4073256254196167,
0.38580062985420227,
-0.6916863918304443,
0.8357754349708557,
0.3990490138530731,
-0.0020052476320415735,
-0.7230358719825745,
-0.6261651515960693,
0.12028418481349945,
0.060481488704681396,
-0.5062194466590881,
0.2739582359790802,
-0.020922400057315826,
-0.03368425741791725,
-0.024829519912600517,
-0.36911430954933167,
0.2517041862010956,
-0.08567466586828232,
0.2018277943134308,
0.17321406304836273,
-0.02334211766719818,
0.5325630307197571,
-0.10136231034994125,
-0.22278885543346405,
0.22770854830741882,
-0.3311512768268585,
0.6928912997245789,
0.0699736624956131,
-0.47322261333465576,
-0.39849427342414856,
0.019685884937644005,
0.600389838218689,
-0.14723160862922668,
0.8116931915283203,
0.6804160475730896,
-0.6154137849807739,
0.1190653070807457,
-1.1319085359573364,
-0.7043583393096924,
-0.4779380261898041,
0.5100302696228027,
-0.5466854572296143,
-0.976062536239624,
0.6551517248153687,
-0.2063073217868805,
-0.3462067246437073,
0.4201100766658783,
0.71755450963974,
0.053582094609737396,
0.8587020635604858,
0.23924857378005981,
-0.033694274723529816,
0.002681717276573181,
0.03173098340630531,
0.6135708093643188,
-0.933784544467926,
-0.6881946325302124,
-0.3144908547401428,
0.07590042054653168,
-0.48350679874420166,
-0.4561375379562378,
0.5250182151794434,
-0.17528694868087769,
0.023129111155867577,
-0.0638018548488617,
-0.5803738832473755,
0.3966890573501587,
0.18689818680286407,
0.4716935455799103,
0.47205841541290283,
0.21360339224338531,
-0.4638396203517914,
-0.08742338418960571,
-0.6345548629760742,
-0.29540759325027466,
1.2357490062713623,
0.23937109112739563,
0.6949175000190735,
0.022068491205573082,
0.7282711863517761,
0.16196084022521973,
0.4454313814640045,
-0.5881267786026001,
0.5464167594909668,
0.015210065059363842,
-0.5012797117233276,
-0.42041853070259094,
-0.9227273464202881,
-0.8468353152275085,
0.3369213044643402,
-0.37188586592674255,
-0.7936593890190125,
0.021246332675218582,
0.14139273762702942,
-0.5144596099853516,
0.2724694013595581,
-0.6216384172439575,
0.6158080101013184,
-0.15299807488918304,
-0.18430030345916748,
-0.24466381967067719,
-0.5660080313682556,
0.386121541261673,
-0.42885151505470276,
0.28304579854011536,
-0.056249041110277176,
0.21726447343826294,
0.551221489906311,
-0.5120697021484375,
0.8807776570320129,
0.00006654080789303407,
-0.2978358566761017,
0.049988601356744766,
0.19190354645252228,
0.7688524723052979,
0.01188628189265728,
-0.21812742948532104,
0.14933091402053833,
-0.07762283086776733,
-0.09286590665578842,
-0.9191131591796875,
0.7888757586479187,
-0.743831217288971,
-0.9125475287437439,
-0.20417465269565582,
-0.5016627311706543,
-0.4666289687156677,
0.3593292534351349,
0.15746964514255524,
0.38537657260894775,
0.11728911846876144,
0.14038532972335815,
0.5844395756721497,
-0.24248450994491577,
-0.1904478222131729,
0.6362300515174866,
-0.5041052103042603,
-0.5987173914909363,
0.9821354150772095,
0.4102916717529297,
0.1347939819097519,
0.031448427587747574,
0.33330753445625305,
-0.584168016910553,
-0.5731636881828308,
-0.1239217221736908,
0.5640316009521484,
-0.9133999347686768,
-0.38144803047180176,
-1.105107069015503,
-0.32896310091018677,
-0.9625882506370544,
0.15482766926288605,
-0.37060680985450745,
-0.3455730974674225,
-0.22495146095752716,
-0.3989061415195465,
0.4285409152507782,
0.5609013438224792,
-0.14028814435005188,
-0.04740798473358154,
-0.6097607612609863,
0.6059105396270752,
0.15544606745243073,
0.5791492462158203,
0.17546720802783966,
-0.7378883957862854,
-0.11965735256671906,
-0.10723468661308289,
-0.00012670467549469322,
-0.8402680158615112,
0.4541758894920349,
-0.16568692028522491,
0.5550194978713989,
0.4421330690383911,
0.30020254850387573,
0.9579193592071533,
-0.4743151068687439,
0.40257540345191956,
0.2898303270339966,
-0.5777254104614258,
0.38903579115867615,
0.11076869815587997,
-0.03689766675233841,
0.6215357184410095,
0.2825291156768799,
-0.5102685689926147,
-0.3246430456638336,
-0.5703799724578857,
-0.8887343406677246,
0.29791897535324097,
0.2194896936416626,
0.023801537230610847,
-0.11481212824583054,
0.9155846834182739,
0.15938052535057068,
0.17322386801242828,
-0.7282954454421997,
-0.35732603073120117,
-0.19335685670375824,
-0.3355017602443695,
0.19743967056274414,
-0.46739131212234497,
-0.24971239268779755,
-0.49467962980270386,
0.8294038772583008,
-0.20635376870632172,
0.10620266944169998,
0.5829830765724182,
0.10591712594032288,
-0.1180993914604187,
0.0845012441277504,
0.25322267413139343,
0.6149692535400391,
-0.20508241653442383,
0.48758313059806824,
0.37545597553253174,
-0.42466336488723755,
0.013982863165438175,
0.09735918790102005,
-0.07335306704044342,
-0.09246648848056793,
0.3984968662261963,
0.616105854511261,
-0.022212909534573555,
-0.6551026105880737,
0.40183335542678833,
0.07235796004533768,
0.05654342472553253,
-0.289331316947937,
-0.07557471841573715,
-0.06343284994363785,
0.34800106287002563,
0.2643067538738251,
-0.15025694668293,
0.3779264986515045,
-0.5204795002937317,
0.5487391352653503,
0.4594564437866211,
-0.376151442527771,
-0.032862190157175064,
0.4308924376964569,
-0.03740189969539642,
-0.12217007577419281,
0.8446406126022339,
-0.11529257893562317,
-0.5984997749328613,
0.23359224200248718,
0.9588116407394409,
0.64958256483078,
-0.13823653757572174,
0.12362641841173172,
0.5418654084205627,
0.2640995383262634,
-0.11837545782327652,
0.1984448879957199,
0.23560486733913422,
-0.8424316644668579,
-0.4614369869232178,
-0.48359155654907227,
0.00031646498246118426,
0.21014942228794098,
-0.43262767791748047,
0.14567869901657104,
-0.3071485161781311,
-0.4648243188858032,
-0.22427898645401,
-0.04983917623758316,
-0.3811483681201935,
0.39356085658073425,
0.1353880912065506,
0.5129114389419556,
-0.45208171010017395,
0.9239929914474487,
0.26429641246795654,
-0.37151604890823364,
-0.8776512145996094,
0.10635921359062195,
-0.21258129179477692,
-0.9494032859802246,
0.6479597091674805,
0.20623737573623657,
-0.33750176429748535,
0.01596160978078842,
-0.3701621890068054,
-0.8923951983451843,
1.175406575202942,
0.49506738781929016,
-0.6120001673698425,
-0.13279756903648376,
0.2876226305961609,
0.5938002467155457,
-0.2938705086708069,
0.25276681780815125,
0.6644845008850098,
0.4631493389606476,
0.3883397579193115,
-0.7854406833648682,
0.5645914077758789,
-0.06369531154632568,
-0.32843858003616333,
-0.049412332475185394,
-0.5113673210144043,
0.533240795135498,
-0.5709307789802551,
-0.12299083918333054,
-0.2727823257446289,
0.8093926906585693,
0.6059329509735107,
0.21577414870262146,
0.512523353099823,
0.6150744557380676,
1.2757219076156616,
0.11507086455821991,
0.9650286436080933,
-0.5167856812477112,
0.29939889907836914,
1.147929072380066,
-0.31882908940315247,
0.6205717921257019,
0.585947573184967,
0.18935294449329376,
0.53922039270401,
0.2727392613887787,
-0.013475680723786354,
0.4904804527759552,
0.3273402452468872,
-0.1393975168466568,
-0.5061056613922119,
-0.3120773434638977,
-0.5453541874885559,
0.17924751341342926,
0.2734462022781372,
-0.5274286866188049,
-0.06425444036722183,
0.011305614374577999,
0.35680845379829407,
-0.08049768954515457,
-0.1211509183049202,
0.7513986229896545,
0.15032637119293213,
-0.5678209066390991,
0.7156568169593811,
-0.2174254208803177,
0.3090246319770813,
-0.4589410126209259,
-0.2218761295080185,
-0.23810026049613953,
0.03541124239563942,
-0.3168211877346039,
-0.5096229314804077,
0.26727333664894104,
-0.16295768320560455,
-0.1383301317691803,
0.08873681724071503,
0.9681396484375,
-0.40296509861946106,
-0.6341514587402344,
0.3820525109767914,
0.4989601671695709,
0.2049752175807953,
-0.3484061658382416,
-0.558422327041626,
0.12665636837482452,
0.025047853589057922,
-0.14990542829036713,
0.0503508485853672,
0.6894500255584717,
0.17099034786224365,
1.0848798751831055,
0.6255685091018677,
0.24189499020576477,
-0.13862480223178864,
0.3009687662124634,
1.0774810314178467,
-0.658439040184021,
-0.26581957936286926,
-0.9163692593574524,
0.007999323308467865,
-0.10940850526094437,
0.11915341764688492,
0.7311420440673828,
0.6021437048912048,
0.5925034880638123,
0.026368089020252228,
0.7434796690940857,
0.15993976593017578,
0.5252570509910583,
-0.5460976362228394,
1.1373275518417358,
-0.6469801664352417,
0.4100266098976135,
-0.18135717511177063,
-0.38677671551704407,
-0.6195991039276123,
0.7103617191314697,
-0.4940093159675598,
0.1229262501001358,
0.670996367931366,
1.0080819129943848,
0.20693357288837433,
-0.11477310955524445,
0.49095723032951355,
0.6948013305664062,
0.27624988555908203,
0.1580444723367691,
0.6289557218551636,
-0.2054775506258011,
0.5624221563339233,
-0.2079225480556488,
0.008569516241550446,
-0.3192802965641022,
-0.6562362909317017,
-0.9261597990989685,
-0.4267752766609192,
-0.38238033652305603,
-0.7455141544342041,
0.20833827555179596,
1.0552009344100952,
0.57451993227005,
-0.7433789372444153,
0.28298652172088623,
0.2243388444185257,
0.20619365572929382,
0.027503248304128647,
-0.1794983595609665,
0.78230881690979,
-0.5974320769309998,
-0.07066948711872101,
0.30889907479286194,
0.22621718049049377,
-0.04352221637964249,
-0.32230255007743835,
-0.06874959170818329,
0.21346406638622284,
0.03996256738901138,
0.6006661057472229,
-0.047107696533203125,
-0.9275034070014954,
-0.6542170643806458,
0.04349201172590256,
-0.22324348986148834,
0.24048517644405365,
0.7922869324684143,
-1.1851413249969482,
0.6842248439788818,
0.21868565678596497,
0.6321330666542053,
0.33974871039390564,
-0.006212451029568911,
0.4171532392501831,
-0.572418749332428,
-0.20835140347480774,
0.28517210483551025,
0.3663597106933594,
0.4687265455722809,
-0.6368646025657654,
0.4826887845993042,
0.48532700538635254,
-0.3664534091949463,
-0.8232176303863525,
0.2013331949710846,
-0.67610764503479,
-0.35209351778030396,
1.150909185409546,
-0.044083353132009506,
-0.14751222729682922,
-0.33425986766815186,
-0.24770499765872955,
0.4852954149246216,
-0.14401113986968994,
1.5437562465667725,
0.6716504693031311,
-0.20778030157089233,
-0.07873478531837463,
-0.3526049852371216,
0.597332239151001,
0.46020132303237915,
-0.8020594120025635,
0.47240564227104187,
0.4559328854084015,
0.3975694477558136,
0.19227109849452972,
0.8014932870864868,
-0.34484046697616577,
-0.13755249977111816,
-0.23566748201847076,
0.19830071926116943,
-0.21314534544944763,
-0.49328184127807617,
0.011588829569518566,
0.2022329717874527,
-0.002855772152543068,
0.3107793927192688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06541v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06541v1
|
ATSumm: Auxiliary information enhanced approach for abstractive disaster Tweet Summarization with sparse training data
| 2024-05-10T15:36:56 | 2024-05-10T15:36:56 |
Piyush Kumar Garg, Roshni Chakraborty, Sourav Kumar Dandapat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
The abundance of situational information on Twitter poses a challenge for
users to manually discern vital and relevant information during disasters. A
concise and human-interpretable overview of this information helps
decision-makers in implementing efficient and quick disaster response. Existing
abstractive summarization approaches can be categorized as sentence-based or
key-phrase-based approaches. This paper focuses on sentence-based approach,
which is typically implemented as a dual-phase procedure in literature. The
initial phase, known as the extractive phase, involves identifying the most
relevant tweets. The subsequent phase, referred to as the abstractive phase,
entails generating a more human-interpretable summary. In this study, we adopt
the methodology from prior research for the extractive phase. For the
abstractive phase of summarization, most existing approaches employ deep
learning-based frameworks, which can either be pre-trained or require training
from scratch. However, to achieve the appropriate level of performance, it is
imperative to have substantial training data for both methods, which is not
readily available. This work presents an Abstractive Tweet Summarizer (ATSumm)
that effectively addresses the issue of data sparsity by using auxiliary
information. We introduced the Auxiliary Pointer Generator Network (AuxPGN)
model, which utilizes a unique attention mechanism called Key-phrase attention.
This attention mechanism incorporates auxiliary information in the form of
key-phrases and their corresponding importance scores from the input tweets. We
evaluate the proposed approach by comparing it with 10 state-of-the-art
approaches across 13 disaster datasets. The evaluation results indicate that
ATSumm achieves superior performance compared to state-of-the-art approaches,
with improvement of 4-80% in ROUGE-N F1-score.
|
[
-0.2847745418548584,
-0.7538063526153564,
0.3706980049610138,
0.39879298210144043,
-0.6373962163925171,
0.43879443407058716,
-0.07948688417673111,
-0.325402170419693,
0.5681829452514648,
0.18056371808052063,
-0.5055962204933167,
-0.36953556537628174,
-0.6511937379837036,
0.2180948555469513,
-0.6193857789039612,
0.908360481262207,
0.045542918145656586,
-0.4619206488132477,
0.2544928193092346,
-0.08501596748828888,
-0.2907378077507019,
-0.2766418159008026,
-0.8374778032302856,
-0.03891859948635101,
0.28458207845687866,
0.6660782694816589,
0.6528524160385132,
0.46180784702301025,
0.6129061579704285,
0.30822858214378357,
0.09908206760883331,
0.2654474675655365,
-0.5596824288368225,
-0.20237931609153748,
0.07147420942783356,
0.14074395596981049,
-0.42569833993911743,
-0.386150062084198,
0.5334559679031372,
0.5145465135574341,
-0.10649534314870834,
0.0685289204120636,
0.14175555109977722,
0.48569178581237793,
-0.6272428631782532,
0.18006424605846405,
-0.8067914843559265,
0.032922521233558655,
0.2602342665195465,
-0.7457023859024048,
-0.01799541898071766,
-0.5820674896240234,
0.22715246677398682,
-0.5514776110649109,
0.5142413377761841,
-0.13604876399040222,
0.5326125621795654,
0.30671069025993347,
-0.5306915044784546,
-0.16714729368686676,
-0.3265824317932129,
0.6197139024734497,
-0.6270719170570374,
-0.043315690010786057,
0.22041718661785126,
0.12202195823192596,
0.07039681822061539,
-0.5304906368255615,
-0.5013247728347778,
0.21871435642242432,
-0.07010385394096375,
0.3949275016784668,
0.08957701921463013,
0.296219140291214,
-0.05592097342014313,
0.3510400056838989,
-0.31230464577674866,
-0.2914784550666809,
-0.35540491342544556,
-0.0260334312915802,
0.7059176564216614,
0.26385173201560974,
0.23850098252296448,
-0.6868519186973572,
-0.38532009720802307,
0.2648296654224396,
-0.7006547451019287,
-0.35992431640625,
0.04410867393016815,
0.3542528748512268,
-0.3896777629852295,
0.7265834808349609,
-0.2688521444797516,
0.2573312520980835,
-0.05051801726222038,
-0.10650221258401871,
0.18925108015537262,
-0.39306074380874634,
-0.21052610874176025,
0.4231158494949341,
0.8150370121002197,
0.741300642490387,
0.2698855698108673,
-0.38042333722114563,
-0.3368588984012604,
-0.06412514299154282,
0.3290911018848419,
-0.8162370324134827,
-0.2530234158039093,
0.2303268164396286,
-0.6373259425163269,
-0.6326878666877747,
-0.021176915615797043,
-0.5320606827735901,
-0.4247245192527771,
-0.18048754334449768,
0.3628820776939392,
-0.6526764035224915,
-0.15530498325824738,
-0.34213387966156006,
-0.2556948959827423,
-0.15756767988204956,
0.6552814245223999,
-0.7908794283866882,
0.3248361051082611,
0.732399046421051,
1.345305323600769,
-0.007326935883611441,
0.11422045528888702,
-0.33705583214759827,
0.3286367356777191,
-0.082501120865345,
0.8942525386810303,
-0.23491141200065613,
-0.5008142590522766,
0.03802487254142761,
-0.22364002466201782,
-0.20064906775951385,
-0.26719415187835693,
0.8361238837242126,
-0.38291752338409424,
-0.15922830998897552,
-0.19199985265731812,
-0.39874640107154846,
-0.3629213869571686,
0.21044868230819702,
-0.45476511120796204,
0.6827738285064697,
0.08479027450084686,
-1.1354780197143555,
0.37682652473449707,
-0.6190674901008606,
-0.847342848777771,
-0.03834007680416107,
-0.2661888897418976,
-0.30638161301612854,
0.4356250464916229,
0.5416418313980103,
0.5557354092597961,
-0.17767669260501862,
0.20198491215705872,
-0.20569922029972076,
-0.4437013268470764,
0.02650473453104496,
-0.35435378551483154,
0.4351457953453064,
0.02155514433979988,
-0.024124249815940857,
0.14657804369926453,
-0.8446052670478821,
-0.06976200640201569,
-0.16257597506046295,
-0.3356151878833771,
-0.2427034080028534,
0.17748424410820007,
0.3785178065299988,
0.24197609722614288,
-0.09698978811502457,
-0.2706890404224396,
-0.03819228336215019,
-0.6075395345687866,
0.31254929304122925,
0.7256534099578857,
0.484713613986969,
0.5024839043617249,
-0.4746509790420532,
0.3082621991634369,
-0.3519403636455536,
-0.16202616691589355,
-0.4147840738296509,
-0.23755237460136414,
-0.7234833240509033,
-0.2728797495365143,
-0.056939661502838135,
0.7050809860229492,
-0.7996963262557983,
0.45409372448921204,
-0.6726451516151428,
-0.0765385702252388,
-0.39651551842689514,
-0.2167312651872635,
0.17996306717395782,
0.7236164808273315,
0.523601233959198,
-0.02204626426100731,
-1.141826868057251,
-0.6793128848075867,
-0.06891851872205734,
-0.31095409393310547,
-0.2412608563899994,
0.16034314036369324,
0.4884001910686493,
0.08008284866809845,
0.8858314156532288,
-0.4856903553009033,
-0.23398524522781372,
-0.7353692650794983,
0.29086828231811523,
0.07391363382339478,
0.32799574732780457,
0.4451857805252075,
-0.8292577862739563,
-0.46589428186416626,
-0.13449504971504211,
-0.7101356387138367,
-0.09330911934375763,
-0.24957461655139923,
0.035969704389572144,
0.10514789074659348,
0.09212473034858704,
-0.5644347071647644,
0.4807508587837219,
-0.025643471628427505,
-0.23632210493087769,
0.2145654261112213,
0.06940514594316483,
0.445838063955307,
-1.3659313917160034,
0.07643695175647736,
-0.04533296078443527,
-0.4237280488014221,
-0.6634443998336792,
-0.12920650839805603,
0.08311408758163452,
-0.07715412974357605,
-0.2537207305431366,
0.36900728940963745,
-0.510312020778656,
0.022734614089131355,
-0.5946992039680481,
-0.003476772690191865,
-0.3083743751049042,
0.1899513155221939,
0.339988648891449,
0.4881601333618164,
0.2192961424589157,
-0.5191937685012817,
0.26558783650398254,
0.40010422468185425,
-0.05805332213640213,
0.1196250319480896,
-0.7825624346733093,
-0.2619931697845459,
-0.3659277558326721,
0.36944642663002014,
-1.0619510412216187,
-0.5377141237258911,
0.3651564419269562,
-0.5743511915206909,
0.37213531136512756,
-0.11812534183263779,
-0.4768131375312805,
-0.179176464676857,
-0.7536488175392151,
0.13794977962970734,
0.49254950881004333,
-0.19950859248638153,
0.7713238000869751,
0.4479163587093353,
-0.4655416011810303,
-0.40901699662208557,
-0.6750205159187317,
0.4323008060455322,
-0.49124738574028015,
-0.6753690838813782,
0.43625903129577637,
0.3243405818939209,
-0.18917948007583618,
-0.04749839007854462,
-0.3525282144546509,
-0.2291812300682068,
0.21664880216121674,
0.21767744421958923,
0.22294466197490692,
0.05492343753576279,
-0.06800400465726852,
0.07646466791629791,
-0.19567318260669708,
0.12289416790008545,
0.15416471660137177,
0.3906497359275818,
0.2054293006658554,
0.17593935132026672,
-0.3678536117076874,
0.7109364867210388,
0.05893099308013916,
0.30459296703338623,
0.8766837120056152,
0.4131462574005127,
-0.5554207563400269,
0.3318707346916199,
-0.539095938205719,
-0.3465430736541748,
-0.3811383545398712,
0.43051859736442566,
-0.08035269379615784,
-0.4736730754375458,
0.5909074544906616,
0.06632684916257858,
0.31864988803863525,
0.4919389486312866,
0.28663191199302673,
-0.16945084929466248,
0.7158600091934204,
0.5647671222686768,
-0.40258583426475525,
0.445247620344162,
-0.292995810508728,
0.004058872349560261,
-0.6074547171592712,
-0.1170879527926445,
-0.22596874833106995,
-0.08609943091869354,
-0.10682553052902222,
-0.3443506062030792,
0.46273303031921387,
-0.11024320870637894,
0.006150619592517614,
0.12225302308797836,
-0.13720394670963287,
0.2885122001171112,
-0.02783169411122799,
0.3800794184207916,
0.43313273787498474,
0.09603091329336166,
0.6119309663772583,
0.07427913695573807,
-0.723587691783905,
-0.4447951316833496,
0.9422569274902344,
0.29581305384635925,
0.7875788807868958,
0.17415852844715118,
0.7716509103775024,
0.3997876048088074,
0.5071365833282471,
-0.7293012142181396,
0.4279211163520813,
0.16972006857395172,
-0.31404975056648254,
-0.2922251224517822,
-0.628442645072937,
-0.5156242251396179,
0.42994049191474915,
-0.23760536313056946,
-0.7020578384399414,
0.0032409990672022104,
0.27291005849838257,
-0.5836731195449829,
-0.07753337174654007,
-0.7949997782707214,
0.3645516633987427,
-0.022399460896849632,
0.02848152071237564,
-0.42441946268081665,
-0.9823750853538513,
0.5188473463058472,
-0.08144596964120865,
0.357839971780777,
-0.09267326444387436,
-0.5623824596405029,
0.6031855344772339,
-0.7228066325187683,
0.8476712107658386,
0.044145237654447556,
0.13837869465351105,
0.18732309341430664,
-0.3487808108329773,
0.6833544373512268,
0.4903023838996887,
0.07530488818883896,
-0.3263055086135864,
-0.6936178803443909,
-0.2949613332748413,
-0.45656269788742065,
0.6646665930747986,
-0.5454651117324829,
-0.30789807438850403,
-0.3640816807746887,
-0.6094778180122375,
-0.2982349395751953,
0.014325344935059547,
0.6265456676483154,
0.7528591156005859,
-0.33099791407585144,
0.09099630266427994,
0.6286635398864746,
0.02334604412317276,
0.7661399245262146,
0.20082351565361023,
0.49289068579673767,
-0.6248226761817932,
0.8165443539619446,
0.10148745775222778,
0.07209964841604233,
0.7837351560592651,
0.05807028338313103,
-0.26894891262054443,
-0.6005087494850159,
-0.2926625907421112,
0.02131759561598301,
-0.6647220253944397,
-0.469333291053772,
-1.3371963500976562,
-0.3050333261489868,
-0.5005993247032166,
-0.38731902837753296,
-0.18678943812847137,
-0.8427556753158569,
-0.23098322749137878,
-0.34234628081321716,
0.376800537109375,
0.23671092092990875,
0.0074022808112204075,
0.28265005350112915,
-0.8679801821708679,
0.7123112082481384,
-0.3404949903488159,
-0.08366430550813675,
0.1661321222782135,
-0.6976267695426941,
-0.2957116365432739,
-0.05189395695924759,
-0.2233523726463318,
-0.8938758969306946,
0.28302207589149475,
0.6942169070243835,
0.2640603184700012,
0.5441126227378845,
0.3187635838985443,
0.7939179539680481,
-0.45817410945892334,
0.4119855463504791,
0.31464847922325134,
-0.6259359121322632,
0.6100586652755737,
-0.45841675996780396,
0.39153552055358887,
0.7104113101959229,
0.47620779275894165,
-0.35866016149520874,
-0.592001736164093,
-0.6515528559684753,
-1.377590298652649,
0.6953812837600708,
0.6924183964729309,
0.2108825445175171,
-0.050678614526987076,
-0.1345384269952774,
0.0695662572979927,
0.45331647992134094,
-0.34657615423202515,
-0.3301146626472473,
-0.3383777141571045,
-0.35666629672050476,
-0.030968010425567627,
-0.5522814989089966,
0.005497935693711042,
-0.15601816773414612,
0.7061606049537659,
0.15716542303562164,
0.23389489948749542,
0.08932077139616013,
-0.2877945601940155,
0.09952715784311295,
0.12442242354154587,
0.36116716265678406,
0.5711352825164795,
-0.5249600410461426,
0.027737174183130264,
0.23501434922218323,
-0.6617178916931152,
0.004256687127053738,
0.5045450925827026,
-0.2630305290222168,
0.3347136676311493,
0.8395984172821045,
0.5809241533279419,
0.5173618793487549,
-0.5921902060508728,
0.5540751814842224,
-0.2110341638326645,
-0.048555102199316025,
-0.5017105937004089,
-0.10690948367118835,
-0.21869239211082458,
-0.028493421152234077,
0.8666602373123169,
0.231828510761261,
0.7973077893257141,
-0.6509287357330322,
0.16672779619693756,
-0.005512849427759647,
-0.028287967666983604,
-0.34947940707206726,
0.4354608654975891,
0.4543718993663788,
0.1973881721496582,
0.31217092275619507,
0.11126928776502609,
-0.4448765218257904,
0.4429120719432831,
0.26197752356529236,
1.0682013034820557,
-0.41516628861427307,
0.25273746252059937,
0.3704026937484741,
0.4281308352947235,
0.001981301698833704,
0.5846317410469055,
-0.2929808497428894,
-0.525477409362793,
-0.4874529540538788,
-0.28691816329956055,
-0.006084888242185116,
0.10729523748159409,
-0.32916104793548584,
0.1888444423675537,
-0.34446823596954346,
0.014637568034231663,
-0.04916077479720116,
-0.22223342955112457,
-0.25425443053245544,
0.4317273497581482,
-0.2635374367237091,
0.9108915328979492,
-0.8720457553863525,
0.13606493175029755,
0.7640583515167236,
-0.31791120767593384,
-0.6904090642929077,
0.29076844453811646,
-0.08191981166601181,
-0.47065281867980957,
0.07121969759464264,
0.31341448426246643,
0.3020361661911011,
0.11154322326183319,
-0.05056485906243324,
-0.7890313267707825,
0.7935798168182373,
0.24318726360797882,
-0.019854389131069183,
-0.26826560497283936,
0.04549870640039444,
0.32563507556915283,
-0.28657519817352295,
0.5383838415145874,
0.3950929343700409,
0.185106098651886,
0.44865140318870544,
-0.6091197729110718,
0.28873905539512634,
-0.26977407932281494,
0.05650788173079491,
0.3453306555747986,
-0.47926947474479675,
0.3296118378639221,
-0.3976649045944214,
-0.49773988127708435,
-0.06353899836540222,
0.8994916677474976,
-0.012484756298363209,
0.3928481936454773,
0.44231748580932617,
0.2784029543399811,
0.4770652949810028,
-0.10078216344118118,
1.1663177013397217,
-0.15862029790878296,
0.2573404312133789,
1.2188599109649658,
0.28044629096984863,
0.6068488955497742,
0.46396389603614807,
0.10775262117385864,
-0.11150702834129333,
0.6821168065071106,
0.41990771889686584,
1.0334583520889282,
-0.07473980635404587,
-0.5280453562736511,
-0.07398055493831635,
-0.2336455136537552,
-0.4164973199367523,
0.13441291451454163,
0.4787258803844452,
-0.5989498496055603,
-0.5894777178764343,
0.11475158482789993,
-0.013525410555303097,
-0.25210246443748474,
-0.49602118134498596,
0.9776844382286072,
0.30718183517456055,
-0.32939276099205017,
0.47070637345314026,
0.060230109840631485,
0.5726335048675537,
-0.41076841950416565,
-0.031164471060037613,
-0.20099440217018127,
0.0031059717293828726,
-0.6548506617546082,
-0.603698194026947,
0.735390305519104,
0.23771043121814728,
-0.09203308075666428,
0.044083647429943085,
0.8470056056976318,
-0.3708361089229584,
-0.5825557112693787,
-0.2785259783267975,
0.2892201244831085,
0.018198871985077858,
-0.3121248185634613,
-0.41135990619659424,
0.0282279085367918,
-0.16408313810825348,
-0.28571581840515137,
-0.009535413235425949,
0.49809032678604126,
0.03609875217080116,
0.6976563930511475,
0.08635327219963074,
0.03613585606217384,
-0.2203110009431839,
0.20002798736095428,
1.1339213848114014,
-0.4744485020637512,
-0.8773649334907532,
-1.0086561441421509,
0.644551694393158,
-0.5096309781074524,
-0.11091054975986481,
0.7963375449180603,
0.7877318263053894,
0.17729945480823517,
-0.10512389987707138,
1.2949849367141724,
-0.3695865273475647,
0.7019978165626526,
-0.4848298728466034,
0.3965380787849426,
-0.32227736711502075,
0.348585844039917,
-0.5716098546981812,
-0.8128035664558411,
-0.15143385529518127,
0.6140785217285156,
-0.03603249415755272,
0.023125380277633667,
0.6401795148849487,
0.2992130517959595,
-0.2416168451309204,
0.20332804322242737,
-0.19185633957386017,
0.09012811630964279,
0.13794001936912537,
0.443194180727005,
0.7560559511184692,
-0.5351012945175171,
0.5842251777648926,
-0.23192349076271057,
-0.4491887092590332,
-0.5135487914085388,
-0.7452560663223267,
-1.1287307739257812,
-0.42758214473724365,
-0.2394919991493225,
-0.21189196407794952,
0.31088194251060486,
1.0706738233566284,
0.3344820439815521,
-0.6820942163467407,
0.22243787348270416,
-0.24189318716526031,
0.05017692223191261,
0.11024048179388046,
-0.21103179454803467,
0.5937395095825195,
-0.1629960685968399,
-0.34387579560279846,
0.23217004537582397,
0.2617568373680115,
0.12809547781944275,
0.2817463278770447,
0.1460385024547577,
0.017139963805675507,
0.057013995945453644,
0.6728475093841553,
-0.05789808928966522,
-0.32910260558128357,
-0.2715966999530792,
-0.32896971702575684,
0.026471324265003204,
-0.12821127474308014,
0.9874919056892395,
-0.6154537200927734,
0.048687681555747986,
0.572080135345459,
0.6835827231407166,
0.23665198683738708,
0.614705502986908,
0.7981104254722595,
-1.0118191242218018,
0.29726478457450867,
0.3442644774913788,
0.3086124062538147,
0.5392696857452393,
-0.6202762126922607,
0.7089861035346985,
0.17448781430721283,
-0.12816938757896423,
-0.6541795134544373,
-0.08771980553865433,
-0.8849419951438904,
0.04750240966677666,
1.1366937160491943,
0.08932937681674957,
0.09061823040246964,
-0.4200960099697113,
-0.24876746535301208,
0.36457329988479614,
-0.9538533687591553,
1.2189325094223022,
0.32990652322769165,
0.001490602851845324,
-0.28486111760139465,
-0.3430118262767792,
0.5003282427787781,
-0.1021878644824028,
-0.8303885459899902,
-0.20359507203102112,
0.5555515885353088,
0.06919323652982712,
-0.17872008681297302,
1.061825156211853,
0.2002306580543518,
0.41610926389694214,
-0.14046761393547058,
-0.3009708821773529,
-0.10971492528915405,
-0.2964632511138916,
0.011792621575295925,
0.2398463636636734,
-0.3935074806213379,
-0.3036517798900604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06524v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06524v1
|
Prompting Large Language Models with Knowledge Graphs for Question Answering Involving Long-tail Facts
| 2024-05-10T15:10:20 | 2024-05-10T15:10:20 |
Wenyu Huang, Guancheng Zhou, Mirella Lapata, Pavlos Vougiouklis, Sebastien Montella, Jeff Z. Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Although Large Language Models (LLMs) are effective in performing various NLP
tasks, they still struggle to handle tasks that require extensive, real-world
knowledge, especially when dealing with long-tail facts (facts related to
long-tail entities). This limitation highlights the need to supplement LLMs
with non-parametric knowledge. To address this issue, we analysed the effects
of different types of non-parametric knowledge, including textual passage and
knowledge graphs (KGs). Since LLMs have probably seen the majority of factual
question-answering datasets already, to facilitate our analysis, we proposed a
fully automatic pipeline for creating a benchmark that requires knowledge of
long-tail facts for answering the involved questions. Using this pipeline, we
introduce the LTGen benchmark. We evaluate state-of-the-art LLMs in different
knowledge settings using the proposed benchmark. Our experiments show that LLMs
alone struggle with answering these questions, especially when the long-tail
level is high or rich knowledge is required. Nonetheless, the performance of
the same models improved significantly when they were prompted with
non-parametric knowledge. We observed that, in most cases, prompting LLMs with
KG triples surpasses passage-based prompting using a state-of-the-art
retriever. In addition, while prompting LLMs with both KG triples and documents
does not consistently improve knowledge coverage, it can dramatically reduce
hallucinations in the generated content.
|
[
-0.41526755690574646,
-0.8833304047584534,
0.964583694934845,
0.07841648161411285,
-0.2806571125984192,
0.030504519119858742,
-0.2356427013874054,
-0.35749688744544983,
0.022317688912153244,
0.7762637734413147,
-0.6173652410507202,
-0.705514132976532,
-0.4821503758430481,
0.3233526051044464,
-0.42093533277511597,
0.9604439735412598,
-0.10942716151475906,
-0.1854715645313263,
-0.5325049161911011,
-0.20001234114170074,
-0.49976813793182373,
-0.3247893154621124,
-0.7467478513717651,
-0.3457288444042206,
0.9400879740715027,
0.08427554368972778,
0.6536216139793396,
0.409184068441391,
0.037057261914014816,
0.1724536120891571,
-0.011425073258578777,
0.3437098264694214,
-0.45875251293182373,
0.36656028032302856,
-0.18253125250339508,
-0.5808396339416504,
-0.20935755968093872,
-0.30100494623184204,
0.716950535774231,
0.9638259410858154,
-0.08188958466053009,
0.25392815470695496,
0.159160315990448,
0.8697819113731384,
-0.40274885296821594,
0.3247333765029907,
-0.5063983798027039,
0.011443257331848145,
-0.08236768841743469,
-0.5477707386016846,
-0.5271005034446716,
-0.4250709116458893,
0.1721784919500351,
-0.6188890933990479,
0.21033282577991486,
0.2884834110736847,
0.5848434567451477,
0.4114617705345154,
-0.5312638878822327,
-0.3646795451641083,
-0.3586314022541046,
0.690713107585907,
-0.7175722122192383,
0.6232975125312805,
0.29893630743026733,
0.1739574819803238,
-0.29287001490592957,
-0.6969298124313354,
-0.4231529235839844,
-0.29724541306495667,
-0.20295527577400208,
-0.049718715250492096,
-0.1923300325870514,
0.08719345182180405,
0.5670532584190369,
-0.12937888503074646,
-0.6312481760978699,
0.09687778353691101,
-0.28021326661109924,
-0.26902341842651367,
0.4161713421344757,
0.2940143942832947,
0.16401028633117676,
-0.2994876801967621,
-0.3547166585922241,
-0.17221011221408844,
-0.8393353819847107,
0.09916334599256516,
0.414889395236969,
0.3617779314517975,
0.012272398918867111,
0.6388261914253235,
-0.41088661551475525,
1.0876591205596924,
-0.12636549770832062,
-0.12192247807979584,
0.27871280908584595,
-0.2481420636177063,
-0.05776521563529968,
-0.03812554106116295,
0.8833841681480408,
0.48823484778404236,
0.48436716198921204,
-0.46870139241218567,
-0.10274022817611694,
-0.4620994031429291,
-0.08660642802715302,
-0.7457931041717529,
-0.01175413653254509,
0.2968953847885132,
-0.29822415113449097,
-0.020031532272696495,
-0.36176401376724243,
-1.2011854648590088,
-0.6412906050682068,
-0.31028902530670166,
0.5164932012557983,
-0.4642942249774933,
-0.20699293911457062,
0.10281222313642502,
-0.3904941976070404,
0.4774011969566345,
0.32378068566322327,
-0.633306622505188,
0.14071309566497803,
0.465397447347641,
0.8240957856178284,
-0.14198333024978638,
-0.17475062608718872,
-0.8321162462234497,
0.2646343410015106,
-0.45401716232299805,
0.9091704487800598,
-0.46873044967651367,
-0.3223514258861542,
0.10850202292203903,
0.01543564535677433,
-0.19256484508514404,
-0.5396564602851868,
0.5152360796928406,
-0.7019957304000854,
0.2520439624786377,
-0.7694172859191895,
-0.7520013451576233,
-0.14551861584186554,
0.3279649317264557,
-0.587158203125,
1.159708023071289,
-0.008420470170676708,
-1.0214301347732544,
0.1518847644329071,
-0.5174439549446106,
-0.32559847831726074,
0.026928965002298355,
-0.26835760474205017,
-0.13531123101711273,
-0.09122762829065323,
0.591354250907898,
0.4677952229976654,
-0.5064607858657837,
0.41984057426452637,
-0.40939101576805115,
-0.1904362291097641,
0.11741228401660919,
-0.3813832104206085,
0.7256098389625549,
-0.022548599168658257,
-0.1639396697282791,
-0.03207428380846977,
-0.635705292224884,
0.15508100390434265,
0.20464283227920532,
-0.18567895889282227,
-0.3087354302406311,
0.061273250728845596,
-0.49445584416389465,
0.13175217807292938,
0.2586698830127716,
-0.41755223274230957,
0.09078521281480789,
-0.21709825098514557,
0.3157714307308197,
0.6895841360092163,
0.32502564787864685,
0.09463408589363098,
-0.4527125656604767,
0.5370977520942688,
-0.09157350659370422,
-0.18273617327213287,
-0.007560029160231352,
-0.5386091470718384,
-0.7358379364013672,
0.002644471824169159,
0.23762200772762299,
0.39284172654151917,
-1.1023198366165161,
0.1930529773235321,
-0.2903858721256256,
-0.40183088183403015,
-0.164287731051445,
0.26174503564834595,
0.18414543569087982,
0.9416516423225403,
0.4565739333629608,
0.1982479691505432,
-0.3396778106689453,
-0.7790634036064148,
-0.37025967240333557,
-0.3799523413181305,
-0.2189047783613205,
0.4294952154159546,
0.3963726758956909,
0.3288293778896332,
0.9131777882575989,
-0.6019524335861206,
-0.07991005480289459,
-0.2305988222360611,
0.3980960547924042,
0.22684690356254578,
-0.14677941799163818,
0.42987480759620667,
-0.45784279704093933,
-0.41710108518600464,
-0.38741350173950195,
-0.9441919326782227,
-0.3347354829311371,
0.0904705822467804,
-0.025913067162036896,
0.21255412697792053,
0.7925189137458801,
-0.7565009593963623,
-0.057434599846601486,
0.529159426689148,
-0.07442042231559753,
0.5528317093849182,
-0.2487955242395401,
0.09239591658115387,
-0.910092294216156,
0.16382993757724762,
0.04436091333627701,
-0.10830596089363098,
-0.6099081039428711,
-0.04205404967069626,
0.12431786209344864,
-0.13780951499938965,
-0.4108162820339203,
0.7033369541168213,
-0.30319055914878845,
-0.18639551103115082,
-0.036390796303749084,
0.3739349842071533,
0.11184997111558914,
0.4785130023956299,
0.4643412232398987,
0.9212651252746582,
0.5524743795394897,
-0.6076873540878296,
0.40640702843666077,
0.11826234310865402,
-0.38531729578971863,
0.3667602837085724,
-0.718528687953949,
0.2610316276550293,
-0.46903756260871887,
0.4115954041481018,
-0.9832875728607178,
-0.10430267453193665,
0.05806078761816025,
-0.299579381942749,
0.20561088621616364,
-0.26867949962615967,
-0.9145629405975342,
-0.38032397627830505,
-0.21227441728115082,
0.009392887353897095,
0.5732088685035706,
-0.5093308091163635,
0.6795413494110107,
-0.09349125623703003,
-0.3359593451023102,
-0.6312327980995178,
-0.29866066575050354,
0.2628953456878662,
-0.3954726457595825,
-0.7031536102294922,
0.04992261156439781,
-0.0051340037025511265,
-0.0610620491206646,
-0.023406539112329483,
0.006228263955563307,
0.1000264585018158,
-0.22547215223312378,
-0.06188272684812546,
0.2890256345272064,
-0.34296712279319763,
0.4365050494670868,
-0.018948057666420937,
-0.029489830136299133,
0.4463339149951935,
-0.38312795758247375,
0.5003517270088196,
0.019898738712072372,
-0.31169289350509644,
-0.21172739565372467,
0.21087726950645447,
0.5373576283454895,
-0.3042954206466675,
0.9137036800384521,
0.4312194585800171,
-0.05364924296736717,
-0.32543641328811646,
-0.7285950183868408,
-0.3351286053657532,
-0.43751266598701477,
0.23117825388908386,
-0.2220359593629837,
-0.9184564352035522,
0.40383675694465637,
-0.09498099237680435,
0.05558153614401817,
0.35150858759880066,
0.5199080109596252,
-0.2664472758769989,
0.9691503643989563,
0.24063749611377716,
0.003694117534905672,
0.1328103095293045,
-0.029032640159130096,
0.23904699087142944,
-0.7218921184539795,
-0.21791981160640717,
-0.5501038432121277,
-0.029579168185591698,
-0.5856064558029175,
-0.5020092725753784,
0.5325613021850586,
-0.0021570115350186825,
-0.07878997921943665,
0.05906485393643379,
-0.15029621124267578,
0.35033881664276123,
0.4797973036766052,
0.15525852143764496,
0.3895584046840668,
-0.1790408343076706,
-0.1961951106786728,
0.2190258800983429,
-0.8559138178825378,
-0.3415897786617279,
1.2449665069580078,
0.23786546289920807,
0.8734255433082581,
-0.16140031814575195,
0.6922265291213989,
0.06546716392040253,
-0.016891686245799065,
-0.6054628491401672,
0.7257842421531677,
0.06943774223327637,
-0.5922457575798035,
-0.5084540247917175,
-0.6269193291664124,
-0.8733505606651306,
0.02778652310371399,
-0.03972813859581947,
-0.5706529021263123,
0.1191156804561615,
0.04494893178343773,
-0.4536895751953125,
0.345799058675766,
-0.5459858179092407,
0.6557243466377258,
-0.22384272515773773,
-0.3299786150455475,
0.07718422263860703,
-0.6828871369361877,
0.25703874230384827,
-0.23571451008319855,
0.25132009387016296,
-0.18952679634094238,
-0.14805538952350616,
0.8489482998847961,
-0.1718604415655136,
0.9107934236526489,
-0.5040445327758789,
-0.21405033767223358,
0.4443117082118988,
-0.0039558713324368,
0.9664399027824402,
-0.0627749040722847,
-0.2748832702636719,
-0.11048291623592377,
0.1811213493347168,
-0.2786196768283844,
-0.831591010093689,
0.5376025438308716,
-0.6341328620910645,
-0.856680691242218,
-0.1890186369419098,
-0.8643998503684998,
-0.7384614944458008,
0.1615123152732849,
0.13631924986839294,
0.37538039684295654,
0.2262820601463318,
0.4555758535861969,
1.082103967666626,
-0.43700265884399414,
0.18733125925064087,
0.5777095556259155,
-0.26325857639312744,
-0.1335851401090622,
0.7327510714530945,
0.2530325949192047,
0.43965163826942444,
0.3479576110839844,
0.3707985579967499,
-0.7795423865318298,
-0.6522054076194763,
-0.4799659848213196,
0.4792119860649109,
-0.9072840809822083,
-0.1751328855752945,
-0.8549156188964844,
-0.30311623215675354,
-0.31027403473854065,
0.1733030080795288,
0.06635884940624237,
-0.2173149734735489,
-0.14267432689666748,
-0.12805625796318054,
0.6125879287719727,
0.4249686896800995,
0.18732008337974548,
-0.14973443746566772,
-0.8618065714836121,
0.485197514295578,
0.6237775683403015,
0.30147379636764526,
0.1737736016511917,
-0.43570029735565186,
-0.022928811609745026,
-0.04477742314338684,
0.07030290365219116,
-0.8091801404953003,
0.054957691580057144,
0.0068308524787425995,
0.6106204986572266,
0.12342226505279541,
0.535186767578125,
0.6028380393981934,
-0.4541957974433899,
0.7011587023735046,
-0.010377996601164341,
-0.5181440711021423,
0.2967563569545746,
-0.6989865899085999,
0.23856434226036072,
0.48206618428230286,
0.4539511799812317,
-0.5618455410003662,
-0.6429693698883057,
-0.28707632422447205,
-0.6523424386978149,
0.5528362393379211,
0.08024469017982483,
0.19519446790218353,
-0.17236149311065674,
0.3281852900981903,
0.09751991927623749,
0.43214449286460876,
-0.6825027465820312,
-0.1427641063928604,
-0.15050120651721954,
-0.20818708837032318,
0.012135176919400692,
-0.07737541943788528,
-0.1723724901676178,
-0.07158585637807846,
0.5982049107551575,
-0.28767454624176025,
0.13220222294330597,
0.2005942314863205,
0.014410610310733318,
-0.14205893874168396,
0.32218512892723083,
0.3208676278591156,
0.7818008065223694,
-0.3641095459461212,
0.14784611761569977,
0.4310249090194702,
0.15256249904632568,
-0.02414015308022499,
0.11272267997264862,
-0.26146048307418823,
-0.04740903899073601,
0.39154285192489624,
0.8182139992713928,
-0.019068405032157898,
-0.7851982116699219,
0.37771865725517273,
0.07578287273645401,
-0.49070867896080017,
-0.13006770610809326,
0.11014170199632645,
0.5465254783630371,
0.1624288409948349,
0.4031898081302643,
-0.5170693397521973,
-0.11209524422883987,
-0.45128366351127625,
0.05891506373882294,
0.5783907771110535,
-0.2330804169178009,
0.05375407636165619,
0.5036327242851257,
0.10303790122270584,
0.02336801588535309,
0.7166740298271179,
0.02960919588804245,
-0.3437730669975281,
0.5116405487060547,
0.46827244758605957,
0.4281461238861084,
0.1817849725484848,
0.3530556857585907,
0.36896809935569763,
0.20468544960021973,
0.0010443800128996372,
0.17434963583946228,
-0.09150605648756027,
-0.5462508201599121,
-0.7307294607162476,
-0.6440173387527466,
-0.43600380420684814,
0.4097786843776703,
-0.5977644920349121,
0.3352659344673157,
-0.34577250480651855,
0.0834047943353653,
0.06770261377096176,
-0.10815813392400742,
-0.6592060327529907,
0.20864197611808777,
0.20249971747398376,
1.0552316904067993,
-0.846098780632019,
0.8733670711517334,
0.3259464204311371,
-0.4031941592693329,
-0.8447941541671753,
0.21189777553081512,
-0.1880166083574295,
-0.9834235906600952,
0.7499892711639404,
0.0541861429810524,
-0.10595983266830444,
0.26914066076278687,
-0.478186696767807,
-0.8695859909057617,
1.0702764987945557,
0.44343653321266174,
-0.4861967861652374,
-0.44905465841293335,
0.4898240864276886,
0.617020845413208,
-0.15981435775756836,
0.04468309134244919,
0.37904682755470276,
0.7206330299377441,
0.3686563968658447,
-0.664056122303009,
0.2458265721797943,
0.08097108453512192,
-0.2518150210380554,
0.5012848377227783,
-0.5703825950622559,
0.5997670888900757,
-0.06544037908315659,
-0.030070669949054718,
-0.005307618994265795,
0.553239107131958,
0.4346996545791626,
0.33504942059516907,
0.7258838415145874,
0.5134574770927429,
0.8437591791152954,
0.04870247095823288,
0.9605202078819275,
-0.4730091989040375,
0.1367073804140091,
1.0151472091674805,
-0.42903760075569153,
0.8005625605583191,
0.6211341619491577,
-0.27144211530685425,
0.6014754772186279,
0.6187571287155151,
-0.11644940078258514,
0.3803137540817261,
0.18209178745746613,
-0.210145965218544,
-0.4776543080806732,
-0.2582171559333801,
-0.42713552713394165,
0.012929108925163746,
0.3193044066429138,
-0.2993658483028412,
-0.5455121994018555,
-0.10315880179405212,
0.015124795027077198,
-0.1515786498785019,
-0.18064773082733154,
0.7031232714653015,
0.12058396637439728,
-0.9962695240974426,
0.7242013812065125,
-0.24595730006694794,
0.3230935335159302,
-0.8520799279212952,
0.08790332078933716,
-0.21043545007705688,
-0.4646218419075012,
-0.16174834966659546,
-1.124241828918457,
0.21740281581878662,
0.10294623672962189,
-0.06760642677545547,
-0.2215510606765747,
0.5891609787940979,
-0.35847949981689453,
-0.47733601927757263,
0.5002868175506592,
0.8503814935684204,
0.07221540063619614,
-0.12601448595523834,
-0.6407613754272461,
-0.25858190655708313,
-0.07784982025623322,
-0.27129775285720825,
0.4358352720737457,
0.5315791368484497,
-0.16717751324176788,
0.7967543601989746,
0.7784885764122009,
-0.013730698265135288,
0.09515618532896042,
0.3443716764450073,
0.8576525449752808,
-0.5743797421455383,
-0.28935980796813965,
-0.6521973609924316,
0.2776898741722107,
-0.06345773488283157,
0.14948484301567078,
0.7801113724708557,
0.39623528718948364,
0.445189505815506,
0.12637682259082794,
0.7899161577224731,
0.000305123976431787,
0.6826637983322144,
-0.7540269494056702,
0.5609121918678284,
-0.6265779733657837,
0.1664888709783554,
-0.1418117880821228,
-0.9721567630767822,
-0.056225866079330444,
-0.04710889235138893,
-0.555406928062439,
0.06241069734096527,
0.8420014381408691,
0.8247955441474915,
0.22515720129013062,
0.04204355925321579,
0.32678574323654175,
0.15565699338912964,
0.18050795793533325,
0.53014075756073,
0.9287617206573486,
0.04471905156970024,
0.8882972002029419,
-0.08959534019231796,
0.053593870252370834,
0.04438168555498123,
-1.0681153535842896,
-1.1512892246246338,
-0.5064461827278137,
-0.25791072845458984,
-0.34779810905456543,
0.18500454723834991,
0.7085492610931396,
0.3182825446128845,
-0.5612845420837402,
-0.16817696392536163,
-0.17715518176555634,
0.17796936631202698,
0.03757968172430992,
-0.21171194314956665,
0.6367814540863037,
-0.5890066027641296,
-0.46939900517463684,
0.4504210352897644,
0.15354079008102417,
-0.07227013260126114,
-0.30904942750930786,
0.044727008789777756,
-0.12859371304512024,
0.23910537362098694,
0.4757964313030243,
0.23029787838459015,
-0.6682993769645691,
-0.4662633538246155,
0.29527395963668823,
0.24313531816005707,
0.156965434551239,
0.734136700630188,
-0.8902256488800049,
0.33577144145965576,
0.6521009206771851,
0.6363731622695923,
0.5218415856361389,
-0.027147211134433746,
0.5222249627113342,
-0.7529253959655762,
-0.14106690883636475,
0.16150955855846405,
0.34035712480545044,
0.37347349524497986,
-0.26414334774017334,
0.35265931487083435,
0.1075868234038353,
-0.5050026178359985,
-0.8093120455741882,
0.15610085427761078,
-0.5807279944419861,
-0.3030204474925995,
1.254679799079895,
-0.07771483808755875,
-0.25017744302749634,
-0.28813645243644714,
-0.04612355679273605,
0.20646989345550537,
-0.36004653573036194,
0.5744390487670898,
0.99017733335495,
-0.26775532960891724,
-0.37031054496765137,
-0.8289666175842285,
0.4125974476337433,
0.4570501744747162,
-0.9059471487998962,
0.41801634430885315,
0.3987691104412079,
0.5182084441184998,
-0.06605949252843857,
0.5288786292076111,
-0.11202364414930344,
0.02347859926521778,
-0.15240269899368286,
-0.25745266675949097,
-0.15760867297649384,
-0.17303229868412018,
-0.001544635510072112,
0.3602716624736786,
0.21247392892837524,
0.26002562046051025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06499v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06499v1
|
Aspect-based Sentiment Evaluation of Chess Moves (ASSESS): an NLP-based Method for Evaluating Chess Strategies from Textbooks
| 2024-05-10T14:23:43 | 2024-05-10T14:23:43 |
Haifa Alrdahi, Riza Batista-Navarro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The chess domain is well-suited for creating an artificial intelligence (AI)
system that mimics real-world challenges, including decision-making. Throughout
the years, minimal attention has been paid to investigating insights derived
from unstructured chess data sources. In this study, we examine the complicated
relationships between multiple referenced moves in a chess-teaching textbook,
and propose a novel method designed to encapsulate chess knowledge derived from
move-action phrases. This study investigates the feasibility of using a
modified sentiment analysis method as a means for evaluating chess moves based
on text. Our proposed Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) method represents
an advancement in evaluating the sentiment associated with referenced chess
moves. By extracting insights from move-action phrases, our approach aims to
provide a more fine-grained and contextually aware `chess move'-based sentiment
classification. Through empirical experiments and analysis, we evaluate the
performance of our fine-tuned ABSA model, presenting results that confirm the
efficiency of our approach in advancing aspect-based sentiment classification
within the chess domain. This research contributes to the area of game-playing
by machines and shows the practical applicability of leveraging NLP techniques
to understand the context of strategic games.
|
[
-0.28455308079719543,
-0.8311723470687866,
0.3919355869293213,
0.16165155172348022,
-0.43948397040367126,
-0.008724164217710495,
-0.07095354795455933,
-0.45037171244621277,
0.5223860740661621,
0.5866469144821167,
-0.6406816244125366,
-0.6847038269042969,
-0.3124309778213501,
-0.06154213845729828,
-0.196274995803833,
0.8756169676780701,
0.0016441099578514695,
0.3442069888114929,
-0.47432971000671387,
-0.35873717069625854,
-0.7108485102653503,
-0.5249053835868835,
-0.6318821310997009,
-0.4761435091495514,
-0.26992112398147583,
0.38064688444137573,
0.5679469704627991,
0.3606145977973938,
1.0040266513824463,
0.4103921055793762,
-0.3388204574584961,
-0.037348296493291855,
-0.01156917680054903,
0.37341204285621643,
-0.6044474244117737,
-0.5156657099723816,
-0.6541645526885986,
0.013928649015724659,
0.3465602695941925,
0.36019575595855713,
-0.11489585041999817,
-0.028244175016880035,
-0.056626174598932266,
0.9531065821647644,
-0.4147195816040039,
0.26671862602233887,
-0.27240556478500366,
0.48360729217529297,
-0.03418822959065437,
-0.0388806089758873,
-0.26274919509887695,
-0.0853724554181099,
0.37883108854293823,
-0.6831246018409729,
0.026775646954774857,
-0.10468348860740662,
0.5409706830978394,
-0.13802383840084076,
0.11359213292598724,
-0.6005498766899109,
-0.6643627285957336,
0.9717521667480469,
-0.7004825472831726,
0.03673858195543289,
0.3224620819091797,
0.09236137568950653,
0.0687289759516716,
-0.42802000045776367,
-0.5944634079933167,
-0.08554047346115112,
-0.022225715219974518,
0.32982736825942993,
-0.016664667055010796,
0.21880142390727997,
0.022368934005498886,
0.4710092544555664,
-0.24166974425315857,
-0.18898165225982666,
-0.16063278913497925,
0.12592680752277374,
1.0164012908935547,
0.1218298077583313,
0.36002835631370544,
-0.5456249117851257,
-0.42885124683380127,
-0.3542267680168152,
-0.3930027484893799,
0.5669037103652954,
0.3703943192958832,
0.3059607446193695,
0.00034332976792939007,
0.5815094113349915,
-0.3938518762588501,
0.4925009310245514,
0.40642789006233215,
-0.14799343049526215,
0.08321087062358856,
-0.22247469425201416,
0.02799287624657154,
0.10310500860214233,
0.7633821964263916,
0.8096637725830078,
-0.21896442770957947,
-0.17725709080696106,
-0.1800214946269989,
-0.014951991848647594,
0.6474199295043945,
-0.5722957253456116,
-0.31473517417907715,
0.28805041313171387,
-0.5473366975784302,
-0.6222260594367981,
0.060292791575193405,
-1.2395648956298828,
-0.5209944248199463,
-0.35625386238098145,
0.7455070614814758,
-0.7360426187515259,
0.35489100217819214,
-0.0007792084361426532,
-0.19545811414718628,
0.7789736390113831,
0.29371801018714905,
-0.6590278148651123,
0.19569307565689087,
0.9774686098098755,
0.6596150994300842,
-0.32115522027015686,
-0.00990232266485691,
-0.17336083948612213,
-0.390741229057312,
-0.4975813031196594,
1.1103439331054688,
-0.8172620534896851,
-0.5648142099380493,
0.29710912704467773,
-0.31077510118484497,
0.3570294976234436,
-0.5347758531570435,
0.6655582785606384,
-0.3438965976238251,
0.2676037847995758,
-0.28817304968833923,
-0.6782450675964355,
-0.6842319369316101,
0.7505209445953369,
-0.5526145696640015,
0.9742060303688049,
-0.17320169508457184,
-0.4800262451171875,
0.2900874614715576,
-0.778370201587677,
-0.7386755347251892,
0.006113430485129356,
0.06867217272520065,
-0.6061236262321472,
0.31612738966941833,
0.4578354060649872,
0.5040134787559509,
-0.218796506524086,
-0.21063530445098877,
-0.39077746868133545,
-0.14882689714431763,
0.6552879810333252,
-0.10659360885620117,
0.22330810129642487,
-0.2471635788679123,
-0.3082292079925537,
-0.013430573046207428,
-0.502529501914978,
0.20754382014274597,
-0.3377099335193634,
-0.11616414785385132,
-0.6871527433395386,
0.5141538977622986,
-0.5568636059761047,
0.28332310914993286,
0.46244698762893677,
-0.42806652188301086,
0.4889565110206604,
-0.5404936075210571,
-0.11824226379394531,
0.5571426749229431,
0.2528305649757385,
0.5341668725013733,
-0.391621857881546,
0.7066718935966492,
-0.20604285597801208,
0.45229393243789673,
0.07188577950000763,
-0.36951228976249695,
-0.8599006533622742,
-0.10558341443538666,
0.14348523318767548,
0.5900464057922363,
-1.0372123718261719,
0.6542477011680603,
-0.09592844545841217,
-0.5738959312438965,
-0.7632426023483276,
0.10382341593503952,
0.4056009352207184,
0.15078790485858917,
0.7306028008460999,
-0.6391291618347168,
-0.16493143141269684,
-0.6924276947975159,
-0.50251305103302,
-0.24314941465854645,
0.4056122899055481,
0.485670804977417,
0.3238922655582428,
0.2685546278953552,
0.7602120637893677,
-0.5546169877052307,
-0.5502508282661438,
-0.41524046659469604,
0.33250537514686584,
-0.08601537346839905,
0.4493686556816101,
0.49026045203208923,
-0.5658040046691895,
-0.4120710790157318,
0.016827313229441643,
-0.7602453231811523,
0.10729821771383286,
-0.2342311143875122,
-0.5282850861549377,
-0.12017551809549332,
0.33642828464508057,
-0.21075722575187683,
0.5702269077301025,
0.30177879333496094,
-0.5367212891578674,
0.3346666097640991,
0.0011763195507228374,
0.46086806058883667,
-1.0001400709152222,
-0.1650407761335373,
-0.012557758949697018,
-0.029541954398155212,
-0.5792348980903625,
0.41218653321266174,
-0.39396095275878906,
0.09985461831092834,
-0.3385814130306244,
0.3400309085845947,
-0.0048618437722325325,
-0.047925010323524475,
-0.44624409079551697,
0.33436691761016846,
-0.019213760271668434,
0.635454535484314,
0.44168171286582947,
0.2649143636226654,
0.5865728855133057,
-0.5308893322944641,
0.44254061579704285,
0.2576908767223358,
-0.1621221899986267,
1.1715236902236938,
-0.3324113190174103,
0.24442636966705322,
0.09037600457668304,
-0.10401331633329391,
-0.7575320601463318,
0.2865211069583893,
0.288831889629364,
-0.4488217234611511,
0.5552334785461426,
-0.043922558426856995,
0.016854191198945045,
-0.14523206651210785,
-0.8870201706886292,
0.09412334859371185,
0.2937251031398773,
-0.39738911390304565,
0.9460646510124207,
0.4826197922229767,
-0.31863415241241455,
-0.8484349846839905,
-0.27346301078796387,
-0.1841488927602768,
-0.3173459470272064,
-0.1369057446718216,
0.3285421133041382,
-0.18345725536346436,
-0.4108444154262543,
-0.01738007180392742,
-0.31435707211494446,
-0.23950134217739105,
0.24218927323818207,
0.1450577974319458,
0.11262685805559158,
-0.1765708327293396,
-0.10699238628149033,
0.3884127736091614,
0.1971007138490677,
0.2758221924304962,
-0.19593434035778046,
0.2670687139034271,
-0.06553788483142853,
-0.2515179216861725,
-0.4002426862716675,
0.3468165099620819,
0.2453736960887909,
-0.22130781412124634,
0.46949926018714905,
0.29756373167037964,
-0.10601738095283508,
-0.4830038547515869,
-0.09483645856380463,
-0.1179237961769104,
-0.4474097788333893,
0.6042162775993347,
-0.05477843061089516,
-0.3980088531970978,
0.3448646068572998,
-0.2655709683895111,
0.18960511684417725,
0.5488064885139465,
0.06377401202917099,
-0.49746671319007874,
0.5488901138305664,
0.6232419013977051,
-0.0869181752204895,
0.40517279505729675,
-0.44466957449913025,
-0.038568709045648575,
-1.2034759521484375,
-0.5485149621963501,
-0.5944640040397644,
-0.8715457320213318,
-0.45702388882637024,
-0.573205828666687,
0.03250916674733162,
0.3698568642139435,
0.09829482436180115,
0.34574899077415466,
-0.46697482466697693,
0.5067149996757507,
0.3048703372478485,
0.23588693141937256,
0.17828159034252167,
-0.13872142136096954,
0.02421489730477333,
-0.24690751731395721,
-0.4167957305908203,
-0.39847883582115173,
1.153477430343628,
0.006975248921662569,
0.5167932510375977,
0.4538511037826538,
0.7101759910583496,
0.6271688938140869,
0.5547979474067688,
-1.44166898727417,
0.7490941882133484,
-0.30631333589553833,
-0.5352292060852051,
-0.3335016667842865,
-0.06526461243629456,
-0.6380930542945862,
0.2576778829097748,
-0.7188699841499329,
-0.5889759659767151,
0.18700915575027466,
-0.13136711716651917,
-0.2540150582790375,
0.269230455160141,
-0.01449957862496376,
0.7683501243591309,
-0.2606199383735657,
-0.35375696420669556,
-0.3261592388153076,
-0.1691974252462387,
0.17088186740875244,
-0.09712919592857361,
0.2793796956539154,
0.22457341849803925,
0.06124382093548775,
1.1284315586090088,
-0.4922846555709839,
0.7225019931793213,
-0.1591668576002121,
-0.05196806415915489,
0.6254289150238037,
0.38191157579421997,
0.13702674210071564,
-0.014471008442342281,
0.05004333704710007,
0.21737362444400787,
-0.16999521851539612,
-0.018005918711423874,
-0.7936006784439087,
0.5794149041175842,
-0.8574509620666504,
-0.41471967101097107,
-0.6590111255645752,
-0.19428490102291107,
-0.397460401058197,
-0.09732292592525482,
-0.005397253204137087,
0.49828433990478516,
-0.5615564584732056,
0.3515958786010742,
0.45587921142578125,
-0.1460578441619873,
0.5708369016647339,
0.8581017255783081,
-0.17301476001739502,
-0.5016871690750122,
0.9698882102966309,
-0.18851982057094574,
-0.30801936984062195,
0.9830620884895325,
0.3649599850177765,
-0.39514195919036865,
-0.7288615107536316,
-0.06227480620145798,
0.0854724645614624,
-0.5851469039916992,
-0.42006081342697144,
0.14425919950008392,
0.22869336605072021,
-0.03254806995391846,
-0.43626123666763306,
-0.5771169066429138,
-0.4094894528388977,
-0.0715532973408699,
-0.07952731847763062,
0.20585036277770996,
0.997133731842041,
-0.06258964538574219,
0.5687400698661804,
-0.6692456007003784,
-0.014232907444238663,
0.436485230922699,
0.27553465962409973,
-0.15323658287525177,
-0.6232821345329285,
-0.1826111227273941,
-0.1539209932088852,
-0.8137092590332031,
-1.1304280757904053,
0.4427548348903656,
0.16708838939666748,
0.45648160576820374,
0.5125035643577576,
0.21592140197753906,
0.33600619435310364,
-0.3335249125957489,
1.1560959815979004,
0.05936158448457718,
-1.160688042640686,
0.548716127872467,
-0.05682804808020592,
-0.1307380348443985,
0.5995348691940308,
0.4015468955039978,
-0.22807641327381134,
-0.06736519187688828,
-0.7175379991531372,
-0.8895445466041565,
0.9530348777770996,
0.160613551735878,
-0.021612342447042465,
0.17604784667491913,
0.6160694360733032,
-0.013284732587635517,
0.36575058102607727,
-0.510147750377655,
-0.3624105155467987,
-0.2802753746509552,
-0.3680790066719055,
-0.0057433247566223145,
-0.011631004512310028,
0.03859295696020126,
-0.11052876710891724,
0.8636834621429443,
-0.035712968558073044,
0.3182021975517273,
0.12299269437789917,
-0.21832537651062012,
0.20571453869342804,
0.30763670802116394,
0.377765953540802,
0.3031567931175232,
-0.07462744414806366,
-0.34650298953056335,
0.23394902050495148,
-0.7621367573738098,
0.09041867405176163,
0.06639187037944794,
-0.3594556152820587,
-0.06148543208837509,
0.6373518705368042,
0.5686476230621338,
0.337035596370697,
-0.47726866602897644,
0.5352956652641296,
0.015491627156734467,
-0.1247829720377922,
-0.1438494175672531,
-0.05102712661027908,
-0.3639523983001709,
0.48536086082458496,
0.05694737657904625,
0.15815138816833496,
0.35277259349823,
-0.632083535194397,
0.3051448166370392,
0.5111651420593262,
-0.9444090723991394,
-0.5511993765830994,
0.08157069236040115,
0.3233656585216522,
-0.43360960483551025,
0.35550281405448914,
-0.328914612531662,
-0.7732324004173279,
0.4381139576435089,
0.08119803667068481,
1.0651663541793823,
-0.5289089679718018,
0.5385532379150391,
0.2126246839761734,
0.24087639153003693,
0.13898566365242004,
0.3985927999019623,
-0.0009288440342061222,
-0.662198543548584,
-0.4962219297885895,
-0.7981162071228027,
-0.5337838530540466,
0.21364791691303253,
-0.9067437648773193,
0.04373791441321373,
-0.6859660744667053,
-0.21693630516529083,
-0.1768907904624939,
0.36211535334587097,
-0.516170859336853,
0.19056710600852966,
0.06822378188371658,
0.35542482137680054,
-0.8022137880325317,
0.37852221727371216,
1.2897863388061523,
-0.39449673891067505,
-0.45212671160697937,
0.20704565942287445,
-0.13142801821231842,
-0.42998793721199036,
0.3330158591270447,
-0.18120205402374268,
-0.08043569326400757,
-0.669727087020874,
-0.5081402063369751,
-0.4379270076751709,
0.8108935952186584,
-0.2975870370864868,
-0.08884617686271667,
0.3774040639400482,
-0.07484549283981323,
0.6672826409339905,
-0.2196081578731537,
0.12165161967277527,
0.427484929561615,
0.28459641337394714,
0.09974753111600876,
-0.37361595034599304,
-0.2687297463417053,
0.09245605021715164,
-0.21613404154777527,
0.20730642974376678,
-0.6277495622634888,
0.6421043276786804,
0.1808846890926361,
0.2849859893321991,
0.050573453307151794,
1.1839936971664429,
-0.0794544368982315,
0.34370777010917664,
0.1335977017879486,
0.5618875026702881,
0.46262919902801514,
-0.013106610625982285,
0.8471341133117676,
-0.3462589383125305,
0.565091073513031,
0.8096747994422913,
-0.05305774137377739,
1.3709965944290161,
0.07778061926364899,
-0.328285276889801,
0.8727295994758606,
0.15713512897491455,
0.3185617923736572,
0.6439602971076965,
0.1007365733385086,
-0.10310328006744385,
-0.3410864472389221,
0.1529206782579422,
-0.022977197542786598,
0.9426312446594238,
0.6211124658584595,
-0.11147011071443558,
-0.15901124477386475,
-0.020220458507537842,
0.21125423908233643,
0.3786216080188751,
-0.7673827409744263,
1.1503936052322388,
-0.06074100360274315,
-0.737381637096405,
-0.29467085003852844,
0.31713390350341797,
0.798477053642273,
-0.6184965372085571,
-0.2820325791835785,
-0.38839098811149597,
0.46209537982940674,
0.10632877051830292,
-0.9818373322486877,
0.19227717816829681,
0.057055629789829254,
-0.0551321767270565,
0.2112065702676773,
0.5095092058181763,
-0.3930235803127289,
-0.48340538144111633,
-0.018937651067972183,
0.24008458852767944,
0.1392536461353302,
-0.09865844994783401,
-1.0422838926315308,
-0.15866093337535858,
0.17766834795475006,
-0.17178264260292053,
0.47995713353157043,
0.7667849063873291,
0.12135690450668335,
0.22375087440013885,
0.2905222475528717,
-0.005132710095494986,
-0.5783714056015015,
-0.6064539551734924,
0.5418305993080139,
-0.755739688873291,
-0.5371849536895752,
-0.7931256294250488,
0.30095115303993225,
-0.16622649133205414,
-0.4158943295478821,
0.7891041040420532,
0.36073359847068787,
0.3761027157306671,
0.007523813750594854,
0.6492913365364075,
0.07157240808010101,
0.3256745934486389,
-0.7369179129600525,
0.5873950123786926,
-0.4432191848754883,
0.14515458047389984,
-0.5459601283073425,
-0.7898481488227844,
-0.02395361289381981,
0.9970356225967407,
-0.21952542662620544,
-0.0447692796587944,
0.9002025127410889,
0.21631616353988647,
0.12362468987703323,
0.36865556240081787,
0.06818222254514694,
0.11102525889873505,
0.2401888221502304,
0.27890607714653015,
0.5529759526252747,
-0.5011298656463623,
0.20373502373695374,
-0.556479811668396,
-0.22153174877166748,
-0.24560868740081787,
-0.9340162873268127,
-1.1071823835372925,
-0.5760977268218994,
-0.6383549571037292,
-0.3404419720172882,
-0.03701654449105263,
0.8406071662902832,
0.20396700501441956,
-0.7605475187301636,
-0.19503198564052582,
0.48793825507164,
0.15128780901432037,
-0.8755673766136169,
-0.28905242681503296,
0.9090428352355957,
-0.42434754967689514,
-0.6729288101196289,
0.5078395009040833,
0.13383546471595764,
-0.12620551884174347,
-0.29977110028266907,
0.07323317974805832,
-0.2554969787597656,
0.5333039164543152,
0.8772082328796387,
0.29422158002853394,
-0.2982332706451416,
-0.36502203345298767,
0.07995160669088364,
0.35466980934143066,
-0.1340196430683136,
0.7116352915763855,
-0.6555981636047363,
0.6967307925224304,
0.5968162417411804,
0.5211492776870728,
0.16565139591693878,
0.3709193766117096,
0.5636208057403564,
-0.7959964275360107,
-0.013285305351018906,
0.3012543320655823,
0.17698827385902405,
0.46713748574256897,
-0.24246442317962646,
0.19105221331119537,
0.38319334387779236,
-0.20933184027671814,
-0.20374450087547302,
-0.15572026371955872,
-1.0076771974563599,
-0.48704713582992554,
1.0166754722595215,
-0.3584287166595459,
-0.4842817783355713,
0.1382065862417221,
-0.20126904547214508,
-0.08703122287988663,
-0.4944932460784912,
0.9269117712974548,
0.9872113466262817,
-0.36554720997810364,
0.5755710601806641,
-0.2180064618587494,
0.8821721076965332,
0.281599760055542,
-0.8172062039375305,
-0.1047481894493103,
0.544071614742279,
-0.22015336155891418,
0.4910103976726532,
0.26086604595184326,
-0.08338012546300888,
0.09485357999801636,
-0.08529163897037506,
0.2783850133419037,
0.2486015260219574,
-0.5156546235084534,
-0.4087950885295868,
0.24990637600421906,
-0.1372741460800171,
-0.3864331841468811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06483v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06483v1
|
LyS at SemEval-2024 Task 3: An Early Prototype for End-to-End Multimodal Emotion Linking as Graph-Based Parsing
| 2024-05-10T14:03:37 | 2024-05-10T14:03:37 |
Ana Ezquerro, David Vilares
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper describes our participation in SemEval 2024 Task 3, which focused
on Multimodal Emotion Cause Analysis in Conversations. We developed an early
prototype for an end-to-end system that uses graph-based methods from
dependency parsing to identify causal emotion relations in multi-party
conversations. Our model comprises a neural transformer-based encoder for
contextualizing multimodal conversation data and a graph-based decoder for
generating the adjacency matrix scores of the causal graph. We ranked 7th out
of 15 valid and official submissions for Subtask 1, using textual inputs only.
We also discuss our participation in Subtask 2 during post-evaluation using
multi-modal inputs.
|
[
-0.479390949010849,
-0.9141074419021606,
0.7534500956535339,
0.34618067741394043,
-0.12407130002975464,
-0.2613110840320587,
0.15937916934490204,
-0.5876368284225464,
0.5071187019348145,
0.1186693087220192,
-0.9088767170906067,
-0.34366655349731445,
-0.49051883816719055,
0.25197088718414307,
-0.052462395280599594,
0.8187751770019531,
-0.1582377403974533,
0.010858798399567604,
-0.5769952535629272,
-0.2225951999425888,
-0.40490612387657166,
-0.5590325593948364,
-0.7570173144340515,
-0.3297000229358673,
1.012104868888855,
0.49064478278160095,
0.14409099519252777,
-0.05127221718430519,
0.2859477400779724,
0.3358120322227478,
0.12058990448713303,
0.008118611760437489,
-0.5614256262779236,
0.3312482237815857,
-0.1578703224658966,
-0.07540877908468246,
-0.8690187931060791,
-0.07775072008371353,
0.1589294672012329,
0.42079469561576843,
0.12395152449607849,
0.15639549493789673,
0.07388557493686676,
0.6478387713432312,
-0.6876853704452515,
0.5587815642356873,
-0.2159050852060318,
0.04122385010123253,
-0.21848541498184204,
-0.4526807367801666,
-0.5875948071479797,
-0.11660711467266083,
-0.2399681955575943,
-0.25270047783851624,
-0.18492260575294495,
0.05743630975484848,
0.6897051334381104,
0.24952910840511322,
-1.0306072235107422,
-0.31791189312934875,
-0.1550123393535614,
0.3478069603443146,
-0.6355999112129211,
0.5090814232826233,
0.3324500620365143,
0.08284197747707367,
-0.05338828265666962,
-0.9025688171386719,
-0.42608314752578735,
0.20191936194896698,
-0.002542538335546851,
0.3883303105831146,
-0.5156617164611816,
0.29324105381965637,
0.17549927532672882,
-0.10837844014167786,
-0.41819724440574646,
-0.06985580176115036,
-0.3523465096950531,
-0.40697014331817627,
0.4957756996154785,
0.3933166563510895,
0.3972128629684448,
-0.2950269281864166,
-0.25298619270324707,
0.23413793742656708,
-0.5048932433128357,
0.195415660738945,
0.6768304705619812,
0.12385506927967072,
-0.200904980301857,
0.67962247133255,
-0.27427271008491516,
0.4465043842792511,
-0.14191319048404694,
0.3021259903907776,
0.5006449222564697,
-0.6045076251029968,
-0.09400134533643723,
0.11780526489019394,
0.8564555644989014,
0.5998196601867676,
0.053643904626369476,
0.26529309153556824,
0.0919191762804985,
0.27456212043762207,
0.029262028634548187,
-0.7895665764808655,
-0.19624923169612885,
0.2626041769981384,
-0.5866597294807434,
-0.16784550249576569,
-0.4337117671966553,
-1.0477323532104492,
-0.6131188869476318,
-0.30714091658592224,
0.42494234442710876,
-0.15059664845466614,
-0.23183698952198029,
-0.11257144808769226,
0.05676775053143501,
-0.09734448790550232,
0.48372092843055725,
-0.6595796346664429,
0.274772971868515,
0.3548552393913269,
0.5733692646026611,
0.07090707868337631,
-0.3303675651550293,
-0.3713840842247009,
-0.126228928565979,
-0.005760095547884703,
0.872003972530365,
-0.44801536202430725,
-0.13805259764194489,
-0.1577860414981842,
0.4653969407081604,
-0.15057682991027832,
-0.14614790678024292,
0.7790101766586304,
-0.27670592069625854,
0.19540008902549744,
-0.3704122304916382,
-0.29276901483535767,
-0.262727290391922,
0.4175518751144409,
-0.7034896612167358,
0.8123799562454224,
0.01798289641737938,
-0.8453962206840515,
0.014555595815181732,
-0.7505661845207214,
-0.5610504746437073,
-0.05165357515215874,
-0.1801689863204956,
-0.2599587142467499,
-0.055850572884082794,
0.12086430191993713,
0.4933951199054718,
-0.36496615409851074,
0.4205820560455322,
-0.5154825448989868,
-0.07499629259109497,
0.1110839769244194,
-0.38605478405952454,
0.534045398235321,
0.11178851872682571,
-0.4232625365257263,
0.5378538966178894,
-0.7610235214233398,
-0.19694337248802185,
0.12317993491888046,
-0.09043550491333008,
-0.11128784716129303,
0.05473028123378754,
-0.08886901289224625,
0.6398980617523193,
0.43135786056518555,
-0.8792449235916138,
-0.20271919667720795,
-0.10105584561824799,
0.40447670221328735,
0.9787502884864807,
0.28396445512771606,
0.08299974352121353,
0.17157498002052307,
0.5672374367713928,
0.27832522988319397,
0.2043931484222412,
-0.6388991475105286,
-0.6512832045555115,
-0.9670776724815369,
0.1553344875574112,
-0.10104218870401382,
0.3699565827846527,
-0.5939581394195557,
-0.024401040747761726,
-0.02636844292283058,
-0.3466914892196655,
-0.04029647260904312,
-0.30118340253829956,
0.2938244044780731,
0.6677533984184265,
0.22783903777599335,
-0.1642196625471115,
-0.8283507227897644,
-1.0451908111572266,
-0.03491504117846489,
-0.207649365067482,
0.41404280066490173,
0.5605654716491699,
0.557881772518158,
-0.3103063702583313,
0.6469417810440063,
-0.43542689085006714,
-0.12081074714660645,
-0.09075815975666046,
0.4023068845272064,
-0.02948767878115177,
0.2482612282037735,
0.3935687839984894,
-0.41948217153549194,
-0.306609183549881,
-0.0027090739458799362,
-0.920854389667511,
-0.4493437707424164,
0.15784011781215668,
-0.15778031945228577,
0.17895255982875824,
0.7379655241966248,
-0.3231382369995117,
0.4356045424938202,
0.664683997631073,
-0.7169622778892517,
0.3832824230194092,
0.08403629064559937,
0.5586320757865906,
-1.111240267753601,
-0.0442916564643383,
0.0037011108361184597,
-0.14494459331035614,
-0.6916825175285339,
-0.6325662136077881,
-0.016010167077183723,
-0.5143540501594543,
-0.5854382514953613,
0.33544808626174927,
-0.13376757502555847,
-0.04223021864891052,
0.09329039603471756,
0.07744485139846802,
0.08668231219053268,
0.841162919998169,
-0.2541861832141876,
0.3856399357318878,
0.3480641841888428,
-0.14794902503490448,
0.6430903077125549,
0.23286780714988708,
0.04583596810698509,
0.7394475936889648,
-0.6740374565124512,
0.28277313709259033,
-0.1694786697626114,
0.19453087449073792,
-1.3326830863952637,
-0.30278417468070984,
0.38661131262779236,
-0.4101223647594452,
-0.043858934193849564,
0.04746776446700096,
-0.2813839614391327,
-0.3445814847946167,
-0.0919397845864296,
0.5786867737770081,
-0.006591997109353542,
-0.24712209403514862,
0.7746620178222656,
0.43656861782073975,
-0.6076892614364624,
-0.0982256755232811,
-0.49666598439216614,
0.20765560865402222,
-0.14101378619670868,
-1.0350478887557983,
0.017320498824119568,
0.04099613428115845,
0.02364175394177437,
0.10904587060213089,
0.14463312923908234,
0.07367321848869324,
-0.17202715575695038,
0.5753326416015625,
0.019185801967978477,
-0.08853666484355927,
-0.06832228600978851,
-0.03483009710907936,
-0.4355960190296173,
0.45732539892196655,
0.3137805163860321,
0.547822892665863,
-0.33515238761901855,
-0.7064816951751709,
-0.4296926259994507,
0.6536939144134521,
0.6796658635139465,
-0.19768831133842468,
0.3389754891395569,
0.6271589994430542,
-0.3717000186443329,
0.1796427220106125,
-0.38371315598487854,
0.06721294671297073,
-0.41957569122314453,
0.6339899301528931,
-0.31336426734924316,
-1.1868691444396973,
0.657878577709198,
-0.5475375056266785,
-0.4254569411277771,
0.42294952273368835,
0.6934913992881775,
-0.08353138715028763,
1.4810876846313477,
0.39929473400115967,
0.15874210000038147,
0.45491573214530945,
0.17928805947303772,
0.4779833257198334,
-0.719304084777832,
-0.6644169688224792,
-0.40197697281837463,
-0.4558585286140442,
-0.4025587737560272,
-0.2335304617881775,
0.46063879132270813,
-0.17922443151474,
-0.30574139952659607,
0.16396935284137726,
-0.0439525730907917,
0.04466276243329048,
0.3190591633319855,
0.1119740679860115,
-0.1821144074201584,
-0.2837526798248291,
0.0006573438295163214,
-0.1533537656068802,
-0.5097360610961914,
-0.115214042365551,
0.5831292271614075,
0.46202099323272705,
0.5986105799674988,
0.17026296257972717,
0.5701777935028076,
0.27212268114089966,
0.006434131413698196,
-0.7295039296150208,
0.8418632745742798,
0.29000917077064514,
-0.2939010560512543,
-0.14653509855270386,
-0.26484954357147217,
-0.8773589730262756,
0.16516244411468506,
0.07671696692705154,
-1.0320143699645996,
0.5191646218299866,
0.0032748805824667215,
0.03804793208837509,
-0.16592690348625183,
-0.7526969909667969,
1.3734164237976074,
-0.17815189063549042,
-0.5268183350563049,
-0.0694495439529419,
-0.6898167133331299,
0.4381437599658966,
0.07566776871681213,
0.38540032505989075,
-0.391097754240036,
0.4001108407974243,
0.9872329831123352,
-0.400619775056839,
1.0399444103240967,
-0.37802577018737793,
-0.06173979490995407,
0.4517422616481781,
0.17547288537025452,
0.6500721573829651,
-0.06257081776857376,
0.026857059448957443,
0.013528301380574703,
-0.04388326779007912,
-0.12241318821907043,
-0.6554968357086182,
0.6126018166542053,
-0.6586716175079346,
-0.24484221637248993,
-0.2392023801803589,
-0.3409627377986908,
-0.351479172706604,
0.12508302927017212,
-0.0457918606698513,
0.6954553723335266,
-0.1912282109260559,
0.31982406973838806,
0.2096548229455948,
-0.2021082043647766,
0.6654554605484009,
0.24498169124126434,
-0.10083040595054626,
-0.5610833168029785,
1.015964150428772,
-0.2181759774684906,
-0.047564394772052765,
-0.06730809807777405,
0.29738906025886536,
-0.2868283689022064,
0.020576896145939827,
-0.19522987306118011,
-0.05267060548067093,
-1.033592700958252,
-0.34482938051223755,
-0.847613513469696,
0.03594554215669632,
-0.5356890559196472,
-0.18900492787361145,
-0.4535212516784668,
-0.28932952880859375,
-0.3344932496547699,
-0.21309281885623932,
0.004253886174410582,
0.7095346450805664,
-0.0911545380949974,
0.03591208532452583,
-0.7412161231040955,
0.13132956624031067,
0.36383238434791565,
0.17275643348693848,
-0.16211915016174316,
0.04170926660299301,
-0.3252969980239868,
-0.09220494329929352,
-0.38183653354644775,
-1.1867808103561401,
0.3370104134082794,
0.16509473323822021,
0.49601441621780396,
0.403407484292984,
-0.060204800218343735,
0.8868197798728943,
-0.4771443009376526,
1.0851576328277588,
0.46537351608276367,
-1.101061224937439,
0.8405771851539612,
-0.5051637887954712,
0.1900312900543213,
0.3229339122772217,
0.2418244630098343,
-0.5971990823745728,
-0.0621865876019001,
-0.5163118839263916,
-1.0443389415740967,
0.8064807057380676,
0.09406101703643799,
-0.028806697577238083,
-0.21770386397838593,
-0.008493448607623577,
-0.1857311725616455,
0.11261066049337387,
-0.741211473941803,
-0.11316390335559845,
-0.3258265256881714,
-0.3076963424682617,
-0.019146371632814407,
-0.7302149534225464,
-0.14516443014144897,
-0.09936816245317459,
0.466177374124527,
-0.26886942982673645,
0.49923253059387207,
0.024484146386384964,
-0.012265480123460293,
-0.23381449282169342,
0.5384215116500854,
0.8107843399047852,
0.4509478807449341,
-0.053822100162506104,
0.4802703857421875,
0.24354960024356842,
-0.04256949573755264,
0.1940435767173767,
0.055203892290592194,
0.3598290681838989,
-0.17746371030807495,
0.5230990052223206,
1.1119998693466187,
0.4706185758113861,
-0.43180587887763977,
0.7875565886497498,
-0.06036117672920227,
-0.23182052373886108,
-0.002895602025091648,
-0.5142441391944885,
0.23628947138786316,
0.5355188250541687,
0.03423740714788437,
-0.03262527659535408,
0.5408684611320496,
-0.49970901012420654,
0.41497910022735596,
0.0750088095664978,
-0.6956470012664795,
-0.6836392879486084,
0.7317267060279846,
0.4605749547481537,
-0.06426019221544266,
0.22810380160808563,
-0.22740213572978973,
-0.6379802227020264,
0.6061214804649353,
0.6998546123504639,
0.8605291247367859,
-0.3188386559486389,
0.1612454354763031,
0.41680023074150085,
0.020367352291941643,
0.4267346262931824,
0.7391531467437744,
0.0461612194776535,
-0.6120350360870361,
-0.4782182574272156,
-0.4378703832626343,
-0.3712562322616577,
-0.20038580894470215,
-0.6559210419654846,
0.3495606482028961,
0.05576051026582718,
-0.2102089375257492,
-0.2255508452653885,
-0.3904712200164795,
-0.6563968062400818,
0.19133105874061584,
0.29390180110931396,
0.3940295875072479,
-1.1694401502609253,
0.32206979393959045,
0.7426435351371765,
-0.3611539304256439,
-0.7204607129096985,
-0.7062685489654541,
0.36965349316596985,
-0.5604159235954285,
1.0110422372817993,
0.13555052876472473,
-0.2145841419696808,
0.06589118391275406,
-0.476537823677063,
-0.5685103535652161,
1.1185789108276367,
0.33892226219177246,
-0.2919710576534271,
0.044336091727018356,
0.23250249028205872,
0.3427470624446869,
-0.3073429763317108,
0.6087684631347656,
0.19486010074615479,
0.37143179774284363,
0.2879508137702942,
-0.8011115789413452,
0.19673582911491394,
-0.6777082085609436,
-0.3522215783596039,
0.3056882619857788,
-0.7101467847824097,
0.9720188975334167,
0.19165706634521484,
-0.0602019764482975,
-0.5508508086204529,
0.6613659858703613,
0.03975704684853554,
0.5582969188690186,
0.5091407895088196,
0.5747458934783936,
0.5224572420120239,
-0.13665871322155,
0.7023029923439026,
-0.4119526147842407,
0.4488079845905304,
1.2130320072174072,
-0.4937121570110321,
0.6025755405426025,
0.5436820387840271,
-0.0902927964925766,
0.5480422973632812,
0.8042970895767212,
0.4234172999858856,
0.4617394804954529,
0.07567202299833298,
-0.3420032858848572,
-0.276809424161911,
-0.5473138689994812,
-0.3423886001110077,
0.5190287828445435,
0.46241772174835205,
-0.16295555233955383,
-0.47056370973587036,
0.26621013879776,
0.07662466168403625,
-0.4672088325023651,
-0.1515689194202423,
0.8149594664573669,
0.1170387789607048,
-0.43383485078811646,
0.011008869856595993,
-0.1909319907426834,
0.2429690808057785,
-0.5311354398727417,
-0.19696064293384552,
-0.10360468178987503,
-0.03314603865146637,
-0.36254367232322693,
-0.8315086364746094,
0.2973901629447937,
-0.24685588479042053,
0.13119640946388245,
-0.4257407486438751,
1.0276697874069214,
-0.4499196410179138,
-0.2730415165424347,
0.43523189425468445,
0.5023205876350403,
0.14921090006828308,
-0.05530356988310814,
-0.4149533808231354,
0.4124935269355774,
-0.17442351579666138,
-0.5678062438964844,
0.25457701086997986,
0.7863808870315552,
-0.08799932152032852,
0.27798840403556824,
0.5024906992912292,
-0.4582209587097168,
0.01650739647448063,
0.5665695071220398,
1.0194603204727173,
-0.6457890272140503,
-0.5322359204292297,
-0.9674953818321228,
0.8077909350395203,
0.08677864819765091,
-0.30893445014953613,
0.7460070848464966,
0.4844232201576233,
0.34875044226646423,
0.1719469428062439,
0.5806640386581421,
-0.2753468155860901,
-0.056368373334407806,
-0.3406110107898712,
0.24400018155574799,
-0.6782088875770569,
-0.20338961482048035,
-0.6802952289581299,
-0.7358212471008301,
-0.08519463986158371,
0.27897822856903076,
-0.15486840903759003,
-0.231393501162529,
0.986969530582428,
0.6888394355773926,
0.16800864040851593,
0.3885989785194397,
0.4569120407104492,
0.1329302042722702,
0.463962197303772,
0.84071946144104,
1.092328667640686,
-0.2875402569770813,
0.3962654173374176,
-0.140508770942688,
-0.13890841603279114,
-0.18306513130664825,
-1.0107309818267822,
-0.659706175327301,
-0.9738101959228516,
-0.34094396233558655,
-0.4935782253742218,
-0.12189704924821854,
0.6823437809944153,
0.3161177635192871,
-0.6027005910873413,
-0.042075447738170624,
-0.12692610919475555,
-0.04791717976331711,
0.3109239339828491,
-0.23800897598266602,
0.2730582356452942,
-0.3962046504020691,
-0.44185447692871094,
0.5662835240364075,
0.651150643825531,
-0.29395246505737305,
-0.015621786937117577,
-0.1462058275938034,
-0.32649651169776917,
-0.10176782310009003,
0.962968111038208,
0.02007221058011055,
-0.525888204574585,
-0.7117513418197632,
-0.08904024213552475,
0.10526138544082642,
0.09277718514204025,
0.9687010049819946,
-0.5322189927101135,
0.5449308753013611,
0.8115423321723938,
0.41891005635261536,
0.6122826933860779,
-0.007020384073257446,
0.4932326078414917,
-0.5696399807929993,
0.17054420709609985,
0.135965034365654,
0.7229467034339905,
0.12880469858646393,
-0.39109665155410767,
0.5654176473617554,
0.46505388617515564,
-0.7652904987335205,
-0.6413815021514893,
0.3012290298938751,
-1.1144120693206787,
0.12818604707717896,
1.0353177785873413,
-0.23902341723442078,
-0.3559696674346924,
-0.13188569247722626,
-0.5044229030609131,
0.474237322807312,
-0.2929586172103882,
0.05937580391764641,
0.7143820524215698,
-0.8431499004364014,
-0.5566016435623169,
-0.5535753965377808,
0.09173484891653061,
0.37701934576034546,
-1.2509032487869263,
-0.0686490386724472,
0.8837140202522278,
-0.0823049321770668,
0.15426784753799438,
0.9939786791801453,
-0.12422767281532288,
0.09745406359434128,
0.25423702597618103,
0.3045860528945923,
-0.20593124628067017,
-0.46717366576194763,
-0.2026005983352661,
0.425632119178772,
-0.3088095784187317,
-0.08227349072694778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06468v1
|
Pseudo-Prompt Generating in Pre-trained Vision-Language Models for Multi-Label Medical Image Classification
| 2024-05-10T13:27:32 | 2024-05-10T13:27:32 |
Yaoqin Ye, Junjie Zhang, Hongwei Shi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The task of medical image recognition is notably complicated by the presence
of varied and multiple pathological indications, presenting a unique challenge
in multi-label classification with unseen labels. This complexity underlines
the need for computer-aided diagnosis methods employing multi-label zero-shot
learning. Recent advancements in pre-trained vision-language models (VLMs) have
showcased notable zero-shot classification abilities on medical images.
However, these methods have limitations on leveraging extensive pre-trained
knowledge from broader image datasets, and often depend on manual prompt
construction by expert radiologists. By automating the process of prompt
tuning, prompt learning techniques have emerged as an efficient way to adapt
VLMs to downstream tasks. Yet, existing CoOp-based strategies fall short in
performing class-specific prompts on unseen categories, limiting
generalizability in fine-grained scenarios. To overcome these constraints, we
introduce a novel prompt generation approach inspirited by text generation in
natural language processing (NLP). Our method, named Pseudo-Prompt Generating
(PsPG), capitalizes on the priori knowledge of multi-modal features. Featuring
a RNN-based decoder, PsPG autoregressively generates class-tailored embedding
vectors, i.e., pseudo-prompts. Comparative evaluations on various multi-label
chest radiograph datasets affirm the superiority of our approach against
leading medical vision-language and multi-label prompt learning methods. The
source code is available at https://github.com/fallingnight/PsPG
|
[
-0.40050023794174194,
-0.5641725063323975,
0.8169474005699158,
-0.14944787323474884,
-0.5720648169517517,
-0.20092323422431946,
0.06548748910427094,
-0.30560824275016785,
0.1496918499469757,
0.17484097182750702,
-0.8434857726097107,
-0.5658189058303833,
-0.4429718554019928,
0.5620889663696289,
0.14746248722076416,
1.1445915699005127,
0.1963089406490326,
0.05635599046945572,
-0.22343498468399048,
-0.04517299309372902,
-0.6769454479217529,
-0.5362963676452637,
-0.5303734540939331,
0.04115154221653938,
0.647132158279419,
0.35769546031951904,
0.4757867455482483,
0.39891359210014343,
0.17647622525691986,
0.24422316253185272,
0.4296029806137085,
0.44868117570877075,
0.022159570828080177,
0.12350718677043915,
0.20808613300323486,
-0.17252224683761597,
-0.08447227627038956,
0.07953527569770813,
0.4387478828430176,
0.5321723818778992,
0.10097849369049072,
-0.10484659671783447,
-0.14950710535049438,
0.335588276386261,
-0.536500096321106,
0.2601548731327057,
-0.3219427764415741,
0.2752336859703064,
-0.14937527477741241,
-0.6896734237670898,
-0.49390462040901184,
-0.34355998039245605,
0.3637167811393738,
-0.7325014472007751,
0.32621508836746216,
0.11241176724433899,
0.9787690043449402,
0.31206613779067993,
-0.15987350046634674,
-0.5000861883163452,
-0.19039493799209595,
0.6082583069801331,
-0.3038279414176941,
0.21466679871082306,
0.4097190499305725,
0.5410887002944946,
-0.104887455701828,
-1.044897198677063,
-0.39473748207092285,
-0.2440921515226364,
-0.2728591561317444,
0.31887391209602356,
-0.3164631426334381,
0.15210303664207458,
0.1903589516878128,
0.016444219276309013,
-0.9372542500495911,
0.07437469065189362,
-0.27433955669403076,
-0.5201888680458069,
0.16534797847270966,
0.2078760862350464,
0.4719628095626831,
-0.4413485825061798,
-0.43435147404670715,
-0.06390278786420822,
-0.5502434372901917,
0.08124072104692459,
-0.12431100010871887,
0.21939142048358917,
-0.03354671970009804,
0.3718057870864868,
-0.06147845461964607,
1.1792182922363281,
0.2021646797657013,
-0.3952041566371918,
0.6104885339736938,
-0.32335972785949707,
-0.1625135987997055,
0.22254076600074768,
1.04412841796875,
0.43743282556533813,
-0.06912676244974136,
0.1764727681875229,
-0.14805608987808228,
0.2786009907722473,
0.10818550735712051,
-0.6612556576728821,
-0.5536834001541138,
-0.029075609520077705,
-0.6467849016189575,
-0.4506997764110565,
-0.2733192443847656,
-0.6165533065795898,
-0.37055113911628723,
-0.23001496493816376,
0.5337584018707275,
-0.3505937159061432,
0.10487630218267441,
0.13771893084049225,
-0.04951607808470726,
0.15677094459533691,
0.28017210960388184,
-0.26270774006843567,
-0.32182446122169495,
-0.041291460394859314,
0.8232147693634033,
0.23204027116298676,
-0.22651460766792297,
-0.9357577562332153,
-0.196916401386261,
-0.2957247495651245,
0.9691727757453918,
-0.38922545313835144,
-0.5550862550735474,
-0.09728842973709106,
0.002309746341779828,
-0.04451563209295273,
-0.31534987688064575,
0.4273473024368286,
-0.11917279660701752,
0.7439824342727661,
-0.34548866748809814,
-0.2427717000246048,
0.07531385123729706,
0.3086490035057068,
-0.3127463757991791,
0.7609684467315674,
0.09882805496454239,
-0.6613166928291321,
0.3623722195625305,
-0.4322071671485901,
-0.2794492244720459,
0.4854915142059326,
-0.6143017411231995,
-0.7079088091850281,
0.10030701756477356,
0.4634374976158142,
0.6319540739059448,
-0.46894973516464233,
0.535718560218811,
-0.15193650126457214,
0.03848959505558014,
0.24057580530643463,
-0.47045445442199707,
0.5387891530990601,
0.29947784543037415,
-0.10601576417684555,
0.2589510679244995,
-0.8072159886360168,
0.08501259237527847,
0.2308303564786911,
0.2863582372665405,
-0.23237298429012299,
-0.30423036217689514,
-0.31573939323425293,
0.6597145199775696,
0.18461142480373383,
-0.38616329431533813,
0.3059103786945343,
-0.24205973744392395,
0.01599426381289959,
0.5320088863372803,
0.26271745562553406,
0.17045529186725616,
-0.46221670508384705,
0.72889643907547,
0.188985213637352,
0.4063614010810852,
-0.8138313889503479,
-0.8623443841934204,
-0.44632384181022644,
-0.7608681917190552,
-0.02912037819623947,
0.6261268258094788,
-1.4429247379302979,
0.429534912109375,
0.24781672656536102,
-0.42867738008499146,
-0.49345436692237854,
-0.22975744307041168,
0.6786453723907471,
1.2204760313034058,
0.5758323669433594,
-0.29981711506843567,
-0.5841698050498962,
-0.8297320008277893,
0.019449718296527863,
-0.18550077080726624,
-0.04999686777591705,
0.4205585718154907,
-0.023084063082933426,
-0.30053645372390747,
0.8830602765083313,
-0.8666718006134033,
-0.5371292233467102,
-0.20823153853416443,
0.6223522424697876,
0.2972085177898407,
0.22096799314022064,
0.7898792028427124,
-0.5816901922225952,
-0.4620664417743683,
-0.3079070746898651,
-0.9906001687049866,
-0.6717622876167297,
-0.3362886607646942,
0.1094890609383583,
-0.003724377602338791,
0.546703577041626,
-0.29475346207618713,
0.42237675189971924,
0.3121357560157776,
-0.2895442843437195,
0.7427591681480408,
-0.5870662331581116,
0.15129965543746948,
-1.0968281030654907,
-0.1008366271853447,
0.23197098076343536,
-0.3161395788192749,
-0.6238723993301392,
-0.35012057423591614,
0.132346510887146,
-0.4577667713165283,
-0.4674187898635864,
0.4895961284637451,
-0.643493115901947,
0.15504808723926544,
-0.2999770939350128,
-0.22954338788986206,
0.1681917905807495,
0.2899731695652008,
0.5290131568908691,
0.452338844537735,
1.1639524698257446,
-0.8160418272018433,
0.21842031180858612,
0.25081515312194824,
0.007009072694927454,
0.7321127653121948,
-0.4931443929672241,
0.04758179187774658,
-0.4404546916484833,
0.4196819067001343,
-0.9143288731575012,
-0.1419205218553543,
0.5399790406227112,
-0.5123391151428223,
0.48961135745048523,
-0.249526709318161,
-0.32214412093162537,
-0.6397297382354736,
-0.1430247575044632,
0.5348280668258667,
0.6309303045272827,
-0.5847738981246948,
0.3556050658226013,
0.13900160789489746,
-0.06655696779489517,
-0.4649992287158966,
-0.5302746295928955,
0.09039029479026794,
0.01901652105152607,
-0.21909338235855103,
0.0884149968624115,
-0.23219868540763855,
0.3036900460720062,
0.014100980013608932,
0.1718602031469345,
-0.003967232536524534,
-0.17582212388515472,
0.20887796580791473,
0.6772831082344055,
-0.20523183047771454,
0.2331075817346573,
0.10695253312587738,
-0.37061595916748047,
-0.12172795832157135,
-0.6230542659759521,
0.401010662317276,
-0.19325487315654755,
-0.22740380465984344,
-0.5487970113754272,
0.2775661051273346,
0.3426430821418762,
-0.3540204167366028,
0.5485303997993469,
0.5937552452087402,
-0.23704929649829865,
-0.20552437007427216,
-0.1705065369606018,
-0.31976497173309326,
-0.49497541785240173,
0.2145553082227707,
-0.27631068229675293,
-0.6035370826721191,
0.1971360296010971,
-0.19667170941829681,
-0.10710268467664719,
0.25227782130241394,
0.5177029371261597,
-0.3606056272983551,
0.9093480110168457,
0.4306384027004242,
0.39730480313301086,
0.2921449542045593,
0.005566146690398455,
0.15293729305267334,
-0.3127391040325165,
-0.4121370017528534,
-0.44229596853256226,
-0.003590925829485059,
-0.3374216854572296,
-0.4647890329360962,
0.8312755823135376,
-0.08341165632009506,
0.24724267423152924,
0.09046734124422073,
-0.8160694241523743,
0.4941663444042206,
0.3889199197292328,
0.25990360975265503,
-0.13220219314098358,
-0.03956014662981033,
-0.22440961003303528,
-0.1965259313583374,
-0.9301985502243042,
-0.17805981636047363,
0.9044097065925598,
-0.13286598026752472,
0.36326226592063904,
-0.29975882172584534,
0.9457452893257141,
0.2678796648979187,
0.18544572591781616,
-0.849991500377655,
0.46233218908309937,
-0.20291566848754883,
-0.09556441754102707,
0.08982457965612411,
-0.49515819549560547,
-0.9621537327766418,
0.015602314844727516,
-0.5252698063850403,
-0.18280838429927826,
0.2733006477355957,
0.4765583574771881,
-0.6094112396240234,
0.025124268606305122,
-0.6592669486999512,
0.9392913579940796,
-0.4240529537200928,
0.04782189056277275,
0.43586060404777527,
-1.00653874874115,
0.27743014693260193,
-0.16684378683567047,
0.2569025456905365,
0.25601324439048767,
0.006314441561698914,
0.41876691579818726,
-0.4780224859714508,
0.9362725615501404,
-0.4863743484020233,
0.13365699350833893,
0.2985518276691437,
-0.10687660425901413,
0.2534862160682678,
0.08065735548734665,
0.36389774084091187,
0.09685003757476807,
-0.2394675463438034,
-0.2692895531654358,
-0.33870041370391846,
0.4424179494380951,
-0.6477718353271484,
-0.1325199156999588,
-0.7676705718040466,
-0.22914248704910278,
-0.308827668428421,
0.2869625687599182,
0.9605698585510254,
0.8813807368278503,
0.08489071577787399,
-0.30636870861053467,
0.8062527179718018,
-0.9387915134429932,
0.5155359506607056,
0.5515866279602051,
-0.2067953199148178,
-0.4218663275241852,
1.1058746576309204,
0.04698561504483223,
-0.01830204389989376,
0.31565818190574646,
0.4575113356113434,
-0.43955352902412415,
-0.42803168296813965,
-0.6563456654548645,
0.25449076294898987,
-0.60860675573349,
-0.5948912501335144,
-0.6574849486351013,
-0.1134595051407814,
-0.2985950708389282,
-0.3717840909957886,
-0.07680749148130417,
-0.03687113896012306,
-0.6745447516441345,
0.11203129589557648,
0.28142228722572327,
0.43358492851257324,
-0.2253970503807068,
0.41664960980415344,
-1.1084938049316406,
0.7051152586936951,
0.35941481590270996,
0.0885656327009201,
-0.39346757531166077,
-0.4729246497154236,
0.04214884713292122,
-0.38831421732902527,
-0.009557846002280712,
-1.0957945585250854,
0.4988245964050293,
0.33938977122306824,
0.545388400554657,
0.4024951756000519,
0.4285242259502411,
0.5801259279251099,
-0.6367191076278687,
0.7936907410621643,
0.9062482118606567,
-0.6293288469314575,
0.7636058330535889,
-0.164662167429924,
0.42421475052833557,
0.49903348088264465,
0.5695258378982544,
-0.3401257395744324,
-0.2529151439666748,
-0.5555600523948669,
-0.8131192326545715,
0.8327353596687317,
-0.20733389258384705,
-0.16762661933898926,
-0.45576849579811096,
0.17499062418937683,
0.3046097755432129,
0.2201216220855713,
-0.6090846657752991,
-0.5075950026512146,
-0.538615882396698,
-0.4092629551887512,
-0.07808174937963486,
-0.2313254177570343,
0.0865136981010437,
-0.129306361079216,
0.4804079830646515,
-0.36151742935180664,
0.3026858866214752,
0.40291762351989746,
-0.31087997555732727,
0.08665186911821365,
0.1611095517873764,
0.7031376957893372,
0.2986947298049927,
0.06596779078245163,
0.23587703704833984,
-0.2616270184516907,
-0.35077401995658875,
0.2250608205795288,
0.1545577198266983,
-0.21601930260658264,
0.3721078038215637,
0.20164404809474945,
0.9722415208816528,
-0.05748854577541351,
-0.5346553325653076,
0.7778147459030151,
-0.5199043154716492,
-0.2622857093811035,
-0.10180441290140152,
-0.24825753271579742,
-0.43584761023521423,
-0.07896910607814789,
0.4185695946216583,
0.46957188844680786,
0.151317298412323,
-0.2813723683357239,
0.5714462995529175,
0.2496332824230194,
-0.3579333424568176,
-0.2866881787776947,
0.3725167214870453,
0.07478472590446472,
-0.07154669612646103,
0.5614216327667236,
-0.6051491498947144,
-0.530151903629303,
0.3308427929878235,
0.5587295293807983,
0.8036912083625793,
-0.30627068877220154,
0.6341068744659424,
0.5130276679992676,
0.2084290236234665,
-0.12430109828710556,
0.2889654040336609,
-0.16039568185806274,
-0.47274041175842285,
-0.3398532271385193,
-0.5412247180938721,
-0.092884361743927,
0.21846112608909607,
-0.5022735595703125,
0.5326974987983704,
-0.6606859564781189,
-0.27587392926216125,
-0.04527618736028671,
-0.42302101850509644,
-0.5542880892753601,
0.5499480962753296,
0.44216081500053406,
0.30749374628067017,
-1.0661077499389648,
0.7013019323348999,
0.8159743547439575,
-0.3523648679256439,
-0.852301299571991,
0.13810555636882782,
0.1531989723443985,
-0.7424058318138123,
0.3900830149650574,
0.47970569133758545,
-0.05080337077379227,
-0.09537617117166519,
-0.3779866397380829,
-0.3326682150363922,
0.5998026132583618,
0.2391083836555481,
-0.6137585043907166,
-0.1082603707909584,
-0.10540491342544556,
0.5081344246864319,
-0.16717825829982758,
0.3938089609146118,
-0.05548582971096039,
0.29788729548454285,
0.27267539501190186,
-0.9297574162483215,
-0.024636665359139442,
-0.1501973569393158,
-0.2998480796813965,
0.18604643642902374,
-0.09721609950065613,
0.6869862079620361,
-0.3014083206653595,
-0.08480360358953476,
-0.08314360678195953,
0.3985799551010132,
0.5100655555725098,
0.63074791431427,
0.4467768967151642,
0.4201732277870178,
0.896748423576355,
-0.032502442598342896,
1.1313468217849731,
-0.18740777671337128,
-0.004137175623327494,
1.003758430480957,
-0.11351647973060608,
0.11288416385650635,
0.29166215658187866,
0.16068078577518463,
0.38205885887145996,
0.72817063331604,
-0.0034465233329683542,
0.791558027267456,
-0.05314713343977928,
-0.315277636051178,
-0.45078885555267334,
-0.2081284075975418,
-0.5555770993232727,
0.35799720883369446,
0.34991225600242615,
-0.4956221878528595,
-0.4086720645427704,
0.48102301359176636,
-0.2861673831939697,
-0.09127412736415863,
-0.5296276211738586,
0.9559604525566101,
0.20694218575954437,
-0.5666041970252991,
0.7699368596076965,
-0.29558104276657104,
0.7638001441955566,
-0.8615175485610962,
-0.09262953698635101,
0.1387617290019989,
-0.16122135519981384,
-0.17862097918987274,
-0.5561435222625732,
0.09459914267063141,
0.029092619195580482,
-0.19064059853553772,
-0.3344722092151642,
0.7403826713562012,
-0.44690972566604614,
-0.44208014011383057,
0.00004257613545632921,
0.499924898147583,
0.22046062350273132,
0.23172186315059662,
-0.8754100799560547,
-0.15443985164165497,
0.09674500674009323,
-0.017874637618660927,
0.39996248483657837,
0.623400092124939,
-0.08358485251665115,
0.29459279775619507,
0.7518659234046936,
0.09652870893478394,
0.061099182814359665,
0.09603190422058105,
0.7373934388160706,
-0.29928427934646606,
-0.7944768071174622,
-0.6588242053985596,
0.432992547750473,
0.16399070620536804,
-0.29413169622421265,
0.43490374088287354,
0.29363304376602173,
0.5245397090911865,
-0.3754061162471771,
0.7375555634498596,
0.039079099893569946,
0.2746032476425171,
-0.5378390550613403,
0.6027699112892151,
-0.6502950191497803,
0.0801590085029602,
-0.41514965891838074,
-0.45992255210876465,
-0.6692021489143372,
0.7053307294845581,
-0.17846214771270752,
-0.008955523371696472,
0.7686280012130737,
0.6627798676490784,
0.08273593336343765,
-0.19743400812149048,
0.5145885348320007,
-0.09247303009033203,
0.10363946110010147,
0.5336195230484009,
0.8058386445045471,
-0.030718790367245674,
0.44171929359436035,
-0.19104593992233276,
-0.500161349773407,
-0.15568473935127258,
-0.9783478379249573,
-0.8618122935295105,
-0.6022364497184753,
-0.5404446125030518,
-0.32585301995277405,
-0.12187856435775757,
0.9794678092002869,
0.7297431230545044,
-0.5541733503341675,
0.418408066034317,
-0.032853834331035614,
-0.3209684193134308,
-0.0061204941011965275,
-0.16001473367214203,
0.4645499587059021,
-0.5732486844062805,
-0.26815590262413025,
0.5691080093383789,
0.5117244124412537,
0.24646559357643127,
0.09952966868877411,
-0.028542332351207733,
0.10941499471664429,
-0.22707204520702362,
0.5517740249633789,
0.5601151585578918,
-0.341412216424942,
0.22206440567970276,
0.03355521336197853,
-0.13134583830833435,
0.11382979899644852,
0.8659164309501648,
-1.2173093557357788,
0.8707776069641113,
0.3739287853240967,
0.5415201783180237,
0.14317145943641663,
-0.16447454690933228,
0.32440322637557983,
-1.090689778327942,
0.34792107343673706,
0.42355427145957947,
0.3865101933479309,
0.43595170974731445,
-0.4247252345085144,
-0.13517063856124878,
0.41384583711624146,
-0.3688015639781952,
-0.8544508218765259,
0.5312290191650391,
-0.8446980714797974,
-0.5111651420593262,
0.7685639262199402,
-0.16709890961647034,
-0.2639770805835724,
-0.343117892742157,
-0.4783610701560974,
0.4201245903968811,
-0.2824031114578247,
0.5053090453147888,
-0.00759879918769002,
-0.40822136402130127,
-0.43277761340141296,
-0.03946186974644661,
0.7021651864051819,
0.3309030830860138,
-0.8375205993652344,
-0.37278151512145996,
0.884568452835083,
0.15055453777313232,
0.2171902060508728,
0.8561423420906067,
-0.06573553383350372,
0.6584368944168091,
-0.44861283898353577,
0.052111923694610596,
-0.4649309515953064,
-0.6702492237091064,
-0.488799512386322,
0.2523634433746338,
-0.04717431589961052,
-0.46995699405670166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06725v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06725v3
|
On the Shape of Brainscores for Large Language Models (LLMs)
| 2024-05-10T13:22:20 | 2024-05-15T02:46:45 |
Jingkai Li
|
q-bio.NC
|
q-bio.NC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With the rise of Large Language Models (LLMs), the novel metric "Brainscore"
emerged as a means to evaluate the functional similarity between LLMs and human
brain/neural systems. Our efforts were dedicated to mining the meaning of the
novel score by constructing topological features derived from both human fMRI
data involving 190 subjects, and 39 LLMs plus their untrained counterparts.
Subsequently, we trained 36 Linear Regression Models and conducted thorough
statistical analyses to discern reliable and valid features from our
constructed ones. Our findings reveal distinctive feature combinations
conducive to interpreting existing brainscores across various brain regions of
interest (ROIs) and hemispheres, thereby significantly contributing to
advancing interpretable machine learning (iML) studies. The study is enriched
by our further discussions and analyses concerning existing brainscores. To our
knowledge, this study represents the first attempt to comprehend the novel
metric brainscore within this interdisciplinary domain.
|
[
-0.2926831841468811,
-0.7677977681159973,
0.7282012104988098,
0.11123275011777878,
-0.09612306952476501,
0.1665641814470291,
-0.5360801219940186,
-0.4455665349960327,
0.46421727538108826,
0.344589501619339,
-0.5728330016136169,
-0.7761083841323853,
-0.5045366287231445,
0.07299833744764328,
-0.48761293292045593,
1.054558515548706,
0.2922138273715973,
0.19059471786022186,
-0.5409739017486572,
-0.2266516387462616,
-0.22861391305923462,
-0.6321464776992798,
-0.583408534526825,
-0.685370922088623,
0.7408202290534973,
0.09407564997673035,
0.5078364610671997,
0.49121004343032837,
0.6491751074790955,
0.2729543149471283,
-0.19778922200202942,
0.19194191694259644,
-0.32630449533462524,
-0.15577153861522675,
0.07720750570297241,
-0.7044281363487244,
-0.8001759052276611,
-0.06371553987264633,
0.8570071458816528,
1.1209049224853516,
-0.04318004474043846,
0.2593100666999817,
0.34696805477142334,
0.7048381567001343,
-0.06582427769899368,
0.06696774065494537,
-0.8001048564910889,
0.12191759049892426,
-0.45402440428733826,
-0.36767733097076416,
-0.34373316168785095,
-0.3145970404148102,
0.026776233687996864,
-0.1110001802444458,
0.05707073211669922,
0.1910323202610016,
0.5568351149559021,
0.26047152280807495,
-0.364099383354187,
-0.1471627801656723,
-0.21234670281410217,
0.7071395516395569,
-0.5967426300048828,
0.4977690577507019,
-0.05098289996385574,
0.433905690908432,
-0.3841314911842346,
-0.37053343653678894,
-0.37098026275634766,
-0.03327718377113342,
-0.08735823631286621,
-0.21869555115699768,
-0.07757949084043503,
-0.11762373149394989,
0.1437472701072693,
0.1949150413274765,
-0.5730292201042175,
0.4386397898197174,
-0.6283181309700012,
-0.21604205667972565,
0.8457781076431274,
0.5572707056999207,
0.20583230257034302,
-0.2671915292739868,
-0.44176435470581055,
0.2951527237892151,
-0.7637283205986023,
0.15310907363891602,
0.36121663451194763,
0.48446568846702576,
-0.4642212390899658,
0.595156192779541,
-0.14883701503276825,
0.828087329864502,
-0.3546561002731323,
-0.2946113646030426,
0.5591586828231812,
0.12690575420856476,
-0.08723660558462143,
-0.01596475951373577,
0.7730705142021179,
0.35158148407936096,
0.8406477570533752,
-0.48626992106437683,
-0.23106418550014496,
-0.23257744312286377,
0.3937124013900757,
-0.4178706705570221,
-0.08688916265964508,
0.19920696318149567,
-0.6238858699798584,
-0.20801898837089539,
0.05055030807852745,
-0.2695808708667755,
-0.5023921728134155,
-0.5533190965652466,
0.0350409671664238,
-0.5321393013000488,
-0.2574087679386139,
0.212382510304451,
-0.10782857239246368,
0.38369670510292053,
0.3882025480270386,
-0.6023954153060913,
0.623634934425354,
0.9237086176872253,
1.1649516820907593,
-0.7282471060752869,
-0.39750906825065613,
0.25653892755508423,
-0.23117367923259735,
-0.19055891036987305,
1.1205953359603882,
-0.38276711106300354,
-0.19316576421260834,
-0.2800496518611908,
-0.10008791089057922,
0.1713644117116928,
-0.6076492667198181,
0.5143160820007324,
-0.39595097303390503,
-0.12312690913677216,
-0.22053317725658417,
-0.4645601511001587,
-0.6049137115478516,
0.46047624945640564,
-0.41642269492149353,
0.7520480155944824,
0.17199882864952087,
-0.6564505696296692,
0.25482624769210815,
-0.608616292476654,
-0.403842955827713,
0.21409399807453156,
-0.48373115062713623,
-0.10110349953174591,
0.4343382716178894,
-0.07593949139118195,
0.7142040133476257,
-0.5676364898681641,
0.10644318908452988,
-0.5093706846237183,
-0.3596026301383972,
0.6271129846572876,
-0.1494312882423401,
0.8717077374458313,
0.037360768765211105,
0.033688317984342575,
0.09555159509181976,
-0.5068756937980652,
0.37877678871154785,
0.12965285778045654,
-0.22225642204284668,
-0.3607277572154999,
0.052903033792972565,
0.34761708974838257,
0.17103953659534454,
0.3620666563510895,
-0.5531216859817505,
0.1367453932762146,
-0.03460418060421944,
0.6195243000984192,
0.7247602343559265,
-0.12099238485097885,
0.05709713697433472,
-0.4467594027519226,
0.34497517347335815,
0.14181268215179443,
-0.05866660550236702,
0.18897287547588348,
-0.6235516667366028,
-0.37076273560523987,
-0.5950642824172974,
0.09930936992168427,
0.3004671037197113,
0.09062685817480087,
0.8224145174026489,
-0.5501469373703003,
-0.8799207210540771,
-0.3757157623767853,
-0.10765241831541061,
0.24580545723438263,
0.2339230477809906,
0.20275577902793884,
-0.5136619806289673,
-0.4618510901927948,
-1.3235819339752197,
-0.39213433861732483,
0.07674037665128708,
-0.139105424284935,
0.4719206690788269,
0.5605342984199524,
-0.22704851627349854,
1.1131092309951782,
-0.6847417950630188,
-0.4212975800037384,
0.028535224497318268,
-0.17816410958766937,
0.524265468120575,
0.3147537410259247,
0.5664389729499817,
-0.340976744890213,
-0.20509909093379974,
0.04007226973772049,
-1.0690282583236694,
0.09127330780029297,
0.22272199392318726,
0.05739663913846016,
-0.025076095014810562,
0.5558561682701111,
-0.627501368522644,
-0.08224237710237503,
0.4147768020629883,
-0.3979858458042145,
0.6966626644134521,
-0.0485476553440094,
0.20772427320480347,
-0.8210200071334839,
0.14887377619743347,
0.038899511098861694,
0.043910715728998184,
-0.23901960253715515,
-0.14938713610172272,
-0.03717440366744995,
0.12493935972452164,
-0.2329990416765213,
0.619380533695221,
-0.5832054018974304,
-0.5845627188682556,
-0.16245350241661072,
0.2896187901496887,
-0.2613460421562195,
0.5475708842277527,
-0.2502477765083313,
0.444431334733963,
0.6543349623680115,
-0.40598660707473755,
0.14497536420822144,
0.25684958696365356,
-0.6868684887886047,
0.8137215375900269,
-0.6311670541763306,
0.29528486728668213,
-0.17762666940689087,
0.1839243471622467,
-0.9220442771911621,
-0.08901306241750717,
-0.39176079630851746,
-0.65687495470047,
-0.014117233455181122,
0.08516247570514679,
-0.39320215582847595,
-0.30177605152130127,
-0.05131999030709267,
0.48345819115638733,
0.6314994096755981,
-0.2210867702960968,
0.38309672474861145,
0.9976925253868103,
-0.05476672947406769,
-0.17670513689517975,
-0.7736639380455017,
0.24715720117092133,
-0.6686378717422485,
-0.686174213886261,
0.47853565216064453,
-0.14750342071056366,
-0.3339959979057312,
0.0646052360534668,
0.21428993344306946,
-0.129786416888237,
0.2055659145116806,
0.45436590909957886,
0.05099409073591232,
-0.4799061119556427,
-0.07643592357635498,
-0.1452501267194748,
0.07410044968128204,
0.5477359294891357,
-0.2763323187828064,
0.606843888759613,
-0.18678715825080872,
-0.11129717528820038,
-0.2724163830280304,
0.2536056339740753,
0.8882418274879456,
-0.06875406205654144,
0.4933871328830719,
0.3585086464881897,
-0.7941499352455139,
-0.36494162678718567,
-0.4519157111644745,
-0.3764282166957855,
-0.4137675166130066,
0.6747815012931824,
-0.6177698969841003,
-1.1002615690231323,
0.7213204503059387,
-0.026404432952404022,
-0.10489711165428162,
0.31367355585098267,
0.8654419779777527,
-0.13883163034915924,
0.8766394257545471,
0.5543692708015442,
-0.0946262925863266,
0.0830027163028717,
-0.031552549451589584,
0.23823080956935883,
-1.3239450454711914,
-0.5667188763618469,
-0.41010725498199463,
-0.7465518116950989,
-0.3451415002346039,
-0.4960564374923706,
0.6421688795089722,
-0.23141615092754364,
-0.11281095445156097,
0.10353579372167587,
-0.4351958930492401,
0.5180496573448181,
0.038843411952257156,
0.2017199844121933,
0.06643830984830856,
0.3400505781173706,
-0.2882416248321533,
-0.2603905498981476,
-0.4128168225288391,
-0.3628593981266022,
1.271408200263977,
0.5013672709465027,
0.6964721083641052,
-0.03146626800298691,
0.42429083585739136,
0.32250267267227173,
0.15471403300762177,
-0.9543935060501099,
0.7322590351104736,
-0.17557261884212494,
-0.6423316597938538,
-0.17194382846355438,
-0.39438489079475403,
-0.7812307476997375,
0.2905382513999939,
-0.4286411702632904,
-1.0131356716156006,
-0.19408252835273743,
-0.27874886989593506,
-0.4085085391998291,
0.28656482696533203,
-0.4509367346763611,
0.6044079065322876,
-0.539280354976654,
-0.09644995629787445,
-0.5194604992866516,
-0.26767417788505554,
0.5774766802787781,
-0.1217324510216713,
0.14777378737926483,
-0.2927333116531372,
-0.22300761938095093,
0.9431915283203125,
0.15970909595489502,
0.7738580107688904,
0.01562868431210518,
-0.09022898972034454,
0.04566604271531105,
0.11741580814123154,
-0.13983243703842163,
0.09965164214372635,
-0.23502150177955627,
0.7328152060508728,
-0.2883125841617584,
-0.23450610041618347,
-0.6383110284805298,
1.033729076385498,
-0.8371955156326294,
-0.49735984206199646,
-0.4866964817047119,
-1.055922031402588,
-0.3260791599750519,
0.24193546175956726,
-0.10476864129304886,
0.5699572563171387,
-0.3710441291332245,
0.42181509733200073,
0.35715609788894653,
0.04774383828043938,
0.11772004514932632,
0.3773706555366516,
-0.23315222561359406,
-0.2520122826099396,
0.5639135837554932,
0.22729171812534332,
-0.21240751445293427,
0.23584428429603577,
-0.044344931840896606,
-0.3387162983417511,
-1.0558662414550781,
-0.03550364077091217,
0.5245832204818726,
-0.5546947717666626,
-0.0923880860209465,
-0.6920416951179504,
-0.5374816656112671,
-0.13179224729537964,
-0.13080613315105438,
-0.360217809677124,
-0.34236305952072144,
0.006140798795968294,
0.01601582206785679,
0.30798929929733276,
0.9078812599182129,
0.2261877954006195,
0.13922864198684692,
-0.7204084992408752,
-0.04442649707198143,
-0.20542369782924652,
0.4680204391479492,
0.1022999957203865,
-0.624279797077179,
-0.48517993092536926,
-0.09457410871982574,
0.1435568481683731,
-0.5555490851402283,
0.23740005493164062,
0.2778433561325073,
0.7520090937614441,
0.3739278316497803,
-0.3272670805454254,
0.4969984292984009,
-0.6583602428436279,
0.446557879447937,
0.19533367455005646,
-0.5327416062355042,
0.01659836247563362,
-0.3389994204044342,
0.42806607484817505,
0.3198261559009552,
0.6198520064353943,
-0.5138376355171204,
-0.15498201549053192,
-0.4134456515312195,
-0.5155292749404907,
0.3500555455684662,
-0.0037295345682650805,
0.07812660187482834,
0.027945049107074738,
0.7357227802276611,
0.3233049511909485,
0.03058292344212532,
-0.5653045177459717,
-0.21468867361545563,
0.5238876938819885,
-0.4375847578048706,
-0.14598897099494934,
-0.018355529755353928,
-0.11456434428691864,
-0.384420782327652,
0.19241443276405334,
-0.3319080173969269,
0.3580225706100464,
-0.009915445931255817,
-0.15331551432609558,
0.14729957282543182,
-0.05898442491889,
0.44485825300216675,
0.6543189287185669,
-0.2716805338859558,
0.2089845985174179,
0.3354962468147278,
-0.6153130531311035,
-0.05054839700460434,
-0.30173084139823914,
-0.06094448268413544,
-0.33654844760894775,
0.3973637819290161,
0.8211179971694946,
0.3038729131221771,
-0.7692936658859253,
0.05968847870826721,
-0.042799655348062515,
-0.11698656529188156,
-0.7206873893737793,
0.12377940863370895,
0.3409770131111145,
0.4774174392223358,
0.3856748342514038,
0.3559463322162628,
0.22049781680107117,
-0.39133185148239136,
0.27728405594825745,
0.7788599729537964,
-0.7246848344802856,
-0.6332399249076843,
0.1237720176577568,
0.15199759602546692,
-0.3635163903236389,
0.8065083026885986,
-0.01345102395862341,
-0.5755316615104675,
0.5572962760925293,
0.5911255478858948,
0.9807722568511963,
0.1141853779554367,
-0.10329604148864746,
0.48935189843177795,
0.39134538173675537,
0.27288615703582764,
0.1645924597978592,
0.21867448091506958,
-0.941414475440979,
-0.1829187572002411,
-1.006779670715332,
-0.015958132222294807,
0.026226479560136795,
-0.5366341471672058,
0.5082877278327942,
-0.4500047564506531,
-0.3107808530330658,
0.017038313671946526,
-0.0947115570306778,
-0.5954537987709045,
0.47704076766967773,
0.5464191436767578,
0.8928871750831604,
-0.7231348156929016,
1.0083905458450317,
0.9246537685394287,
0.16618850827217102,
-0.36425837874412537,
-0.09771842509508133,
0.2939803898334503,
-0.8554437756538391,
0.6529591083526611,
0.305094450712204,
-0.23239433765411377,
0.14440929889678955,
-0.13730460405349731,
-0.9876621961593628,
1.07450270652771,
0.25659996271133423,
-0.3283308744430542,
-0.49230459332466125,
0.18657739460468292,
0.49568498134613037,
-0.875676691532135,
0.48926809430122375,
0.8602897524833679,
0.17416070401668549,
-0.4047866761684418,
-0.5849449038505554,
0.20878319442272186,
-0.39427638053894043,
-0.18545474112033844,
0.2612954080104828,
-0.580781102180481,
0.9749061465263367,
-0.37463027238845825,
-0.14394032955169678,
-0.10882851481437683,
0.6394456028938293,
0.3905028998851776,
-0.16219907999038696,
0.6441386938095093,
0.6678073406219482,
0.7917892932891846,
-0.12621402740478516,
0.8402854800224304,
-0.3633032441139221,
0.3381863832473755,
0.57474684715271,
-0.1755930632352829,
0.8545639514923096,
0.40860745310783386,
-0.30517464876174927,
0.6244545578956604,
0.6741759181022644,
-0.08158595114946365,
0.21334652602672577,
0.5332417488098145,
0.2085367739200592,
-0.3322771191596985,
-0.04740384593605995,
-0.29431241750717163,
0.8228780627250671,
0.7466151714324951,
-0.07461755722761154,
-0.12701942026615143,
-0.23629231750965118,
-0.0018014884553849697,
0.079642653465271,
-0.15701912343502045,
0.4760405719280243,
0.5229039192199707,
-0.5082132816314697,
0.6102389097213745,
-0.11791111528873444,
0.9807515740394592,
-0.6894420981407166,
0.2567088007926941,
-0.22134914994239807,
0.2942609488964081,
-0.4326825737953186,
-0.9747029542922974,
0.5495169162750244,
0.015227957628667355,
-0.222034752368927,
0.042491234838962555,
0.2315557301044464,
-0.15793566405773163,
-0.43408894538879395,
0.5167657732963562,
0.5716468691825867,
0.49464115500450134,
-0.19435784220695496,
-0.7609337568283081,
0.13021259009838104,
-0.1394502967596054,
-0.13967439532279968,
0.3407845199108124,
0.4683988690376282,
-0.20674555003643036,
0.6663241386413574,
0.5274154543876648,
0.15673506259918213,
-0.08220825344324112,
-0.1710149049758911,
0.6386957168579102,
-1.1894526481628418,
-0.5641244053840637,
-0.8648805022239685,
0.567756712436676,
-0.11015033721923828,
-0.7187604308128357,
0.6263841390609741,
0.7371687889099121,
0.6554842591285706,
-0.09369917958974838,
0.6598597764968872,
-0.1905905157327652,
0.34274181723594666,
-0.654881477355957,
1.1753047704696655,
-0.7814681529998779,
0.08264687657356262,
-0.049577780067920685,
-1.2288771867752075,
-0.4418947994709015,
0.27097275853157043,
-0.3288537263870239,
0.12380607426166534,
1.09536874294281,
0.8034209609031677,
-0.16953453421592712,
-0.09710551053285599,
0.39114511013031006,
0.4511144757270813,
0.10459663718938828,
0.6721650958061218,
0.6964071989059448,
-0.14686812460422516,
0.05664056912064552,
0.00011608388012973592,
-0.35301268100738525,
-0.2499965876340866,
-0.6610062718391418,
-1.0391179323196411,
-0.8174834251403809,
-0.3066841661930084,
-0.1700727939605713,
-0.15809112787246704,
0.7799719572067261,
0.8190219402313232,
-0.77497798204422,
-0.7207328677177429,
0.3060736358165741,
0.0896906778216362,
-0.21724532544612885,
-0.18595625460147858,
0.32744818925857544,
-0.374324232339859,
-0.7426231503486633,
0.43791893124580383,
0.47104930877685547,
-0.3707129657268524,
-0.7014041543006897,
0.0061361175030469894,
-0.18593783676624298,
0.05309981480240822,
0.5961278676986694,
-0.2023046761751175,
-0.8112308979034424,
-0.4310398995876312,
0.27137237787246704,
-0.3993614912033081,
0.16580495238304138,
1.0517182350158691,
-0.7363498210906982,
-0.14567343890666962,
0.5117833614349365,
0.5638011693954468,
0.2360944151878357,
-0.4597492516040802,
0.5082154870033264,
-0.45369768142700195,
0.3133278489112854,
0.19876728951931,
0.5396286845207214,
0.6864614486694336,
-0.2805936932563782,
0.43587297201156616,
0.21158909797668457,
-0.4177643358707428,
-0.8499966859817505,
0.2927170395851135,
-1.3415958881378174,
-0.12757934629917145,
0.9103103280067444,
-0.019481608644127846,
-0.6465049386024475,
-0.021201569586992264,
0.04424650967121124,
-0.1180168092250824,
0.02532336674630642,
0.9884613156318665,
0.5331395864486694,
-0.24990497529506683,
-0.06024467945098877,
-0.42995336651802063,
0.40313443541526794,
0.20359721779823303,
-0.7975788712501526,
-0.16350755095481873,
0.2631060779094696,
0.3462834060192108,
0.27947044372558594,
0.2840074896812439,
-0.405184268951416,
0.036973632872104645,
-0.07845056802034378,
0.2827319800853729,
0.009471266530454159,
-0.4386689066886902,
-0.29625141620635986,
0.36354583501815796,
0.13017624616622925,
0.27146100997924805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06459v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06459v3
|
Are EEG-to-Text Models Working?
| 2024-05-10T13:10:55 | 2024-06-14T02:27:00 |
Hyejeong Jo, Yiqian Yang, Juhyeok Han, Yiqun Duan, Hui Xiong, Won Hee Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This work critically analyzes existing models for open-vocabulary EEG-to-Text
translation. We identify a crucial limitation: previous studies often employed
implicit teacher-forcing during evaluation, artificially inflating performance
metrics. Additionally, they lacked a critical benchmark - comparing model
performance on pure noise inputs. We propose a methodology to differentiate
between models that truly learn from EEG signals and those that simply memorize
training data. Our analysis reveals that model performance on noise data can be
comparable to that on EEG data. These findings highlight the need for stricter
evaluation practices in EEG-to-Text research, emphasizing transparent reporting
and rigorous benchmarking with noise inputs. This approach will lead to more
reliable assessments of model capabilities and pave the way for robust
EEG-to-Text communication systems.
|
[
-0.04897645488381386,
-0.7847932577133179,
0.8608154654502869,
0.3322778046131134,
-0.29228055477142334,
-0.5647718906402588,
-0.5998998284339905,
-0.795249342918396,
-0.3740358352661133,
0.3359350562095642,
-0.3078170716762543,
-0.5099580883979797,
-0.614493191242218,
0.18368354439735413,
-0.9083516597747803,
0.9006920456886292,
-0.17799842357635498,
0.30125483870506287,
-0.5453535318374634,
0.080321304500103,
-0.6498029828071594,
-0.20299841463565826,
-0.5601006150245667,
-0.319800466299057,
0.35045668482780457,
0.03637286275625229,
0.23813308775424957,
0.4271014332771301,
0.38674965500831604,
0.11566174775362015,
-0.23965369164943695,
0.022559374570846558,
-0.5236451625823975,
-0.0379495769739151,
-0.09119026362895966,
-0.6127509474754333,
-0.5846490859985352,
-0.0033133707474917173,
0.6357526183128357,
0.8225705623626709,
-0.1014138013124466,
0.35327863693237305,
0.247739776968956,
0.43917301297187805,
-0.7165119647979736,
0.16869300603866577,
-0.542504072189331,
-0.0019682159181684256,
0.09099065512418747,
0.20809435844421387,
-1.1071555614471436,
-0.3472382426261902,
0.22950705885887146,
-0.4755311906337738,
-0.1008438840508461,
-0.11553701758384705,
0.9562791585922241,
0.07761578261852264,
-0.46405914425849915,
-0.2820446491241455,
-1.1215494871139526,
0.581203818321228,
-0.6358190774917603,
0.73089998960495,
0.5333061814308167,
0.04344094172120094,
0.19809864461421967,
-1.159271001815796,
-0.35581207275390625,
-0.21195602416992188,
0.06321163475513458,
0.33276069164276123,
-0.19835759699344635,
0.04497397318482399,
0.25612160563468933,
0.2697676718235016,
-0.12551823258399963,
-0.005300188437104225,
-0.7939180135726929,
0.2298785299062729,
0.43095663189888,
-0.20433233678340912,
0.20371145009994507,
0.11960434168577194,
-0.44858530163764954,
-0.043595049530267715,
-0.3162800669670105,
-0.06230168044567108,
0.29430651664733887,
0.12749427556991577,
-0.21020442247390747,
0.42740440368652344,
0.03799429535865784,
0.4241935908794403,
0.18379870057106018,
0.09907370060682297,
0.12927548587322235,
-0.11374718695878983,
-0.2005879431962967,
0.07874708622694016,
0.6287209391593933,
0.462612509727478,
0.34520915150642395,
-0.7264653444290161,
-0.49504944682121277,
-0.031167542561888695,
0.4926352798938751,
-0.7412369251251221,
-0.2663336396217346,
0.15855367481708527,
-0.8430540561676025,
-0.17287471890449524,
-0.14013820886611938,
-1.0617234706878662,
-0.07017958909273148,
-0.343429833650589,
0.958017110824585,
-0.48192691802978516,
-0.42228248715400696,
0.3630868196487427,
-0.16540202498435974,
-0.0661032423377037,
0.3695983588695526,
-0.7531135678291321,
0.5641017556190491,
0.4115773141384125,
0.9506409168243408,
-0.3304573595523834,
-0.20344328880310059,
-0.15625344216823578,
0.12387420982122421,
-0.514495313167572,
0.8086926937103271,
-0.3337444067001343,
-0.4478748142719269,
0.11944515258073807,
-0.165127232670784,
-0.3456583023071289,
-0.3478802442550659,
0.8638551831245422,
-0.503837525844574,
0.2838984727859497,
-0.390134334564209,
-0.718364417552948,
-0.1682634949684143,
-0.22460299730300903,
-0.5030816197395325,
0.883833646774292,
-0.17173433303833008,
-0.4373987019062042,
0.4661685824394226,
-0.62425297498703,
-0.239048570394516,
-0.14796636998653412,
-0.07452456653118134,
-0.4374728202819824,
0.6087328195571899,
0.023938143625855446,
0.3411043882369995,
-0.23474524915218353,
0.16570065915584564,
-0.15536631643772125,
-0.532367467880249,
0.31293633580207825,
-0.6090415716171265,
0.7421364188194275,
0.1374693512916565,
-0.1291009783744812,
-0.08825408667325974,
-0.9443226456642151,
0.14528299868106842,
0.10948211699724197,
-0.21867257356643677,
-0.4237353503704071,
0.3854057192802429,
0.15549612045288086,
-0.017368357628583908,
0.20050400495529175,
-0.6761458516120911,
-0.1410583108663559,
-0.2979467213153839,
0.45640885829925537,
0.6225148439407349,
-0.3300139009952545,
0.1735927164554596,
-0.3042832612991333,
0.13715440034866333,
-0.06323041021823883,
0.0892176404595375,
-0.310014933347702,
-0.3325040936470032,
-0.5924181342124939,
-0.2905452847480774,
0.6231648921966553,
0.3606932759284973,
-0.24179144203662872,
0.3253551423549652,
-0.44221314787864685,
-0.4827378988265991,
-0.6342970728874207,
-0.4073340594768524,
0.09246886521577835,
0.8055358529090881,
0.6650363206863403,
-0.48588064312934875,
-0.19827356934547424,
-0.698808491230011,
-0.32481586933135986,
-0.3239714801311493,
-0.2738057076931,
0.1713162064552307,
0.4925127327442169,
-0.09683327376842499,
0.5615153908729553,
-0.08311963826417923,
-0.2146732211112976,
0.24725116789340973,
0.49703216552734375,
-0.280339777469635,
0.41634681820869446,
0.5380661487579346,
-0.4265657663345337,
-0.30655020475387573,
0.016693158075213432,
-0.7921117544174194,
-0.2153262197971344,
-0.136055588722229,
0.07045535743236542,
-0.05174368992447853,
0.8045582175254822,
-0.38626769185066223,
0.7652013301849365,
0.4112034738063812,
-0.36654406785964966,
0.6232173442840576,
-0.29991471767425537,
0.24975897371768951,
-0.5563016533851624,
0.2556886374950409,
-0.08072369545698166,
-0.17301315069198608,
-0.6571015119552612,
0.007043201941996813,
0.45488440990448,
0.04744591936469078,
-0.30197879672050476,
0.4038640260696411,
-0.478237509727478,
0.09375867247581482,
-0.2333708256483078,
0.0443129688501358,
-0.15647725760936737,
0.4245859980583191,
0.04602308198809624,
0.7740951180458069,
0.6081778407096863,
-0.716553807258606,
-0.19534721970558167,
0.5411819815635681,
-0.4749450385570526,
0.7469894886016846,
-0.8470842242240906,
0.27256444096565247,
-0.19023366272449493,
-0.05855834111571312,
-0.9451063275337219,
-0.002205491065979004,
-0.15126463770866394,
-0.5183321237564087,
0.368405818939209,
-0.10106276720762253,
-0.6655405759811401,
-0.00909876823425293,
0.03363316133618355,
0.6088404655456543,
0.9289774298667908,
-0.7222230434417725,
0.48435795307159424,
0.15834878385066986,
0.07737702876329422,
-0.04166756942868233,
-0.8906950354576111,
0.16968576610088348,
0.1004464328289032,
-0.4751679599285126,
0.5487030148506165,
0.05484745278954506,
-0.09082536399364471,
-0.0008703118073754013,
-0.37679776549339294,
-0.3110752999782562,
-0.09106061607599258,
0.15104521811008453,
0.23913326859474182,
-0.25772249698638916,
0.32949137687683105,
0.04567549377679825,
0.2820837199687958,
0.5342956185340881,
-0.350737601518631,
-0.0032971962355077267,
0.13397116959095,
-0.3512214422225952,
-0.263389527797699,
0.24862562119960785,
0.5718287825584412,
-0.29796266555786133,
0.851934015750885,
0.4897736608982086,
-0.5968371629714966,
-0.41463977098464966,
-0.4710676074028015,
-0.3945479393005371,
-0.45080167055130005,
0.5786668062210083,
-0.30972692370414734,
-0.4015291929244995,
0.18406051397323608,
-0.42811715602874756,
0.10692349076271057,
0.2963980734348297,
0.3179016411304474,
-0.24774518609046936,
1.1790798902511597,
0.8499914407730103,
0.6221597194671631,
0.4458267390727997,
0.28155916929244995,
0.2529295086860657,
-0.7693411111831665,
-0.3616445064544678,
-0.4814200699329376,
-0.21264414489269257,
-0.22216640412807465,
-0.04580235853791237,
0.45136576890945435,
0.16626985371112823,
-0.015865566208958626,
0.05911140516400337,
-0.5637617707252502,
0.3531235158443451,
0.2368171066045761,
0.49196431040763855,
0.3200204074382782,
0.33548715710639954,
-0.15905311703681946,
-0.27330854535102844,
-0.594505250453949,
-0.6169688701629639,
1.5216248035430908,
0.4308580458164215,
0.6422097682952881,
-0.08071848750114441,
0.3017924427986145,
0.029660366475582123,
0.3470105826854706,
-0.37154820561408997,
0.6290203332901001,
-0.1389472782611847,
-0.5030457377433777,
-0.14993980526924133,
-0.2519146203994751,
-1.0253233909606934,
0.11960744857788086,
-0.2604314088821411,
-1.137190580368042,
0.28955554962158203,
-0.2093009501695633,
-0.13864417374134064,
0.5155418515205383,
-0.7997190356254578,
0.6848835349082947,
-0.038883209228515625,
-0.6190274357795715,
-0.293822318315506,
-0.341781347990036,
0.3357844650745392,
-0.023576540872454643,
0.10187923163175583,
0.011318128556013107,
-0.07781390100717545,
0.8691629767417908,
-0.06711062788963318,
0.7742288708686829,
0.0764244794845581,
-0.21245597302913666,
0.2859063744544983,
0.14545905590057373,
0.2823910415172577,
-0.23085199296474457,
-0.15529760718345642,
0.537010133266449,
0.3044615089893341,
-0.3494206666946411,
-0.2898485064506531,
0.5128289461135864,
-0.924034833908081,
-0.1572800725698471,
-0.1426098793745041,
-0.5121894478797913,
-0.2689702808856964,
0.21664124727249146,
0.5122436881065369,
0.19660869240760803,
-0.5005434155464172,
0.2957608699798584,
1.1332978010177612,
0.11931174248456955,
0.4456537961959839,
0.48297902941703796,
-0.2869349420070648,
-0.20930027961730957,
0.7348947525024414,
0.45034316182136536,
0.2164050191640854,
0.10412956029176712,
-0.2629796266555786,
-0.10362210124731064,
-0.5403748750686646,
-0.24617667496204376,
0.2260022759437561,
-0.7525439858436584,
0.19341708719730377,
-0.6833739280700684,
-0.14518499374389648,
-0.2530289888381958,
0.04609663784503937,
-0.6533512473106384,
-0.20037251710891724,
-0.38401317596435547,
-0.11297855526208878,
0.19900251924991608,
0.7807952761650085,
-0.08434922993183136,
0.30033862590789795,
-0.4624492824077606,
0.4672970473766327,
0.43291130661964417,
0.8665061593055725,
0.1624850630760193,
-0.7079179883003235,
-0.4904341995716095,
0.03687165677547455,
-0.4227913022041321,
-1.4648371934890747,
0.2088795155286789,
0.1584661304950714,
0.22859174013137817,
0.08722646534442902,
0.06306897103786469,
0.490831583738327,
-0.7045161724090576,
0.7074608206748962,
0.32551801204681396,
-1.17234206199646,
0.4116116762161255,
-0.2440561205148697,
0.03741171956062317,
0.45162370800971985,
0.2286645919084549,
-0.33620375394821167,
-0.1195991039276123,
-0.5412517786026001,
-0.88018399477005,
0.6460991501808167,
0.3616117835044861,
-0.004966436419636011,
0.09028030931949615,
0.5000572800636292,
0.15920688211917877,
0.30732667446136475,
-0.8724162578582764,
-0.24649234116077423,
-0.1259436458349228,
-0.30409905314445496,
0.14181166887283325,
-0.3325308561325073,
-0.10126147419214249,
-0.37067854404449463,
0.30247610807418823,
0.13049854338169098,
0.87874436378479,
0.3762844204902649,
-0.1698152720928192,
-0.437855988740921,
0.22212828695774078,
0.369371622800827,
0.5918344259262085,
-0.16380006074905396,
-0.08077685534954071,
0.26892006397247314,
-0.6182399392127991,
0.02309596538543701,
0.08794033527374268,
-0.5331164002418518,
0.30390480160713196,
0.15981680154800415,
0.8475281000137329,
0.223196879029274,
-0.5370044112205505,
0.7556988000869751,
-0.11888272315263748,
-0.5065978169441223,
-0.18448294699192047,
-0.02807900495827198,
-0.011471553705632687,
-0.0702870711684227,
0.15418650209903717,
0.4219105839729309,
0.03328031301498413,
-0.10650736838579178,
0.05017062649130821,
0.12720853090286255,
-0.7691816687583923,
-0.6690772771835327,
1.1761139631271362,
0.3016722500324249,
-0.3270059823989868,
0.5388436913490295,
0.19780854880809784,
0.05939822271466255,
0.672755241394043,
0.6710795760154724,
1.2117925882339478,
-0.0033286986872553825,
-0.02032780461013317,
0.4194531738758087,
0.5883222222328186,
-0.6353986263275146,
0.4508846402168274,
-0.034801121801137924,
-0.23535944521427155,
-0.526333749294281,
-0.19426541030406952,
-0.4102630913257599,
0.2997332811355591,
-1.0633463859558105,
0.5208168029785156,
-0.19479632377624512,
-0.3238774538040161,
-0.07143966853618622,
-0.616029679775238,
-0.8226495981216431,
0.3158421516418457,
0.08738173544406891,
0.9549686908721924,
-0.784720242023468,
0.6582155823707581,
0.7448596358299255,
-0.43734779953956604,
-0.4800451993942261,
0.17888225615024567,
-0.4578554034233093,
-0.4098558723926544,
0.3225381076335907,
0.11114449799060822,
0.19786658883094788,
0.08138150721788406,
-0.9328279495239258,
-0.6363146901130676,
0.919764518737793,
0.5303187966346741,
-0.4668619930744171,
-0.08838052302598953,
-0.09747745841741562,
0.6952787041664124,
-0.03544779121875763,
0.5810465216636658,
0.3506855368614197,
0.6013906598091125,
-0.5068976879119873,
-1.169507384300232,
-0.20024928450584412,
-0.10401757061481476,
-0.25240734219551086,
0.004395164083689451,
-0.7989221215248108,
0.8743967413902283,
0.03272872790694237,
-0.4143657386302948,
-0.06635662913322449,
0.9654176831245422,
-0.3334907591342926,
0.48572292923927307,
0.10271132737398148,
0.36878663301467896,
0.718937337398529,
-0.1262797862291336,
0.6904973983764648,
-0.2731179893016815,
0.2424025535583496,
1.1024922132492065,
-0.36591464281082153,
1.0492068529129028,
0.6775428652763367,
-0.2538524568080902,
0.34795883297920227,
0.2171882688999176,
-0.04996524006128311,
0.5027947425842285,
0.12345194071531296,
-0.17497286200523376,
-0.13981467485427856,
0.06988406181335449,
-0.3657330274581909,
0.03375864401459694,
0.3183804154396057,
-0.35238221287727356,
-0.14048852026462555,
0.09694480895996094,
-0.2999204397201538,
0.5215364098548889,
-0.42894792556762695,
0.8035287261009216,
0.0862446203827858,
-0.6847497820854187,
0.5313165187835693,
0.19751833379268646,
0.6638749837875366,
-0.5280866026878357,
0.027384096756577492,
0.022744856774806976,
0.0648379772901535,
-0.07517951726913452,
-0.3047631084918976,
0.27379778027534485,
0.31692934036254883,
-0.25637051463127136,
-0.3634960949420929,
0.6393709778785706,
-0.549750566482544,
-0.41063031554222107,
0.3905017077922821,
0.6127959489822388,
0.13285648822784424,
0.037996456027030945,
-0.18382377922534943,
-0.029938070103526115,
-0.05944427102804184,
-0.25082120299339294,
0.3287602663040161,
0.6181356906890869,
0.19793592393398285,
0.4251297116279602,
0.24628925323486328,
0.32698944211006165,
0.37536370754241943,
-0.4402526915073395,
0.3169506788253784,
-0.5655465126037598,
-0.32389795780181885,
-0.7139377593994141,
0.49807003140449524,
0.133628711104393,
-0.5392723679542542,
0.691107451915741,
0.3919934034347534,
0.984117865562439,
-0.18426290154457092,
0.7433935403823853,
0.3025684058666229,
0.48772475123405457,
-0.4850374460220337,
0.7756759524345398,
-0.4111112356185913,
0.18610219657421112,
-0.08697489649057388,
-0.549572229385376,
0.1907949447631836,
0.5074602961540222,
-0.21047011017799377,
0.04273632913827896,
0.9950495362281799,
0.4509563446044922,
-0.23925472795963287,
0.36345216631889343,
0.6134569048881531,
0.4557124376296997,
0.011060631833970547,
0.5139623880386353,
0.7306367754936218,
-0.9781067371368408,
0.7106141448020935,
-0.07919612526893616,
-0.12170585989952087,
-0.10614175349473953,
-0.8949487805366516,
-0.9375820755958557,
-0.5896837711334229,
-0.7915775179862976,
-0.39409586787223816,
0.2775716781616211,
0.5529386401176453,
0.7495054602622986,
-0.5982709527015686,
-0.39234283566474915,
-0.2571184039115906,
-0.14206136763095856,
-0.6459833979606628,
-0.09652876853942871,
0.31456267833709717,
-0.369094580411911,
-0.7843131422996521,
0.4578193426132202,
0.030073337256908417,
0.17962095141410828,
-0.05073241889476776,
0.06757768988609314,
0.06829813867807388,
0.6458612680435181,
0.47527316212654114,
0.2608630061149597,
-0.48194262385368347,
-0.1373753398656845,
-0.038918815553188324,
-0.2783767879009247,
0.1117352768778801,
0.5042588710784912,
-0.7824439406394958,
0.5569730401039124,
0.2967011034488678,
0.5665645003318787,
0.7260717749595642,
-0.4797132611274719,
0.595113217830658,
-0.625447690486908,
-0.015584206208586693,
0.09138932824134827,
-0.0013142485404387116,
-0.11377889662981033,
-0.26169535517692566,
0.37766650319099426,
-0.029753847047686577,
-0.69450443983078,
-1.1949520111083984,
-0.20095740258693695,
-0.7469019293785095,
-0.3975851833820343,
1.167547345161438,
-0.16714079678058624,
-0.27344897389411926,
-0.016709856688976288,
-0.14361093938350677,
0.2642987370491028,
-0.22032269835472107,
1.042240023612976,
1.0364145040512085,
0.18909558653831482,
-0.0314081571996212,
-0.8824183940887451,
0.3756501078605652,
0.6836438775062561,
-0.5183462500572205,
0.002751670079305768,
0.35687056183815,
0.04225749149918556,
-0.0549711138010025,
0.38066765666007996,
-0.29804718494415283,
0.5458466410636902,
0.2621709704399109,
0.3883470594882965,
-0.06206526607275009,
-0.30211132764816284,
-0.4268949627876282,
0.3454667329788208,
0.0017761127091944218,
-0.3435727059841156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06454v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06454v2
|
E2TP: Element to Tuple Prompting Improves Aspect Sentiment Tuple Prediction
| 2024-05-10T13:04:21 | 2024-05-16T11:37:51 |
Mohammad Ghiasvand Mohammadkhani, Niloofar Ranjbar, Saeedeh Momtazi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generative approaches have significantly influenced Aspect-Based Sentiment
Analysis (ABSA), garnering considerable attention. However, existing studies
often predict target text components monolithically, neglecting the benefits of
utilizing single elements for tuple prediction. In this paper, we introduce
Element to Tuple Prompting (E2TP), employing a two-step architecture. The
former step focuses on predicting single elements, while the latter step
completes the process by mapping these predicted elements to their
corresponding tuples. E2TP is inspired by human problem-solving, breaking down
tasks into manageable parts, using the first step's output as a guide in the
second step. Within this strategy, three types of paradigms, namely
E2TP($diet$), E2TP($f_1$), and E2TP($f_2$), are designed to facilitate the
training process. Beyond dataset-specific experiments, our paper addresses
cross-domain scenarios, demonstrating the effectiveness and generalizability of
the approach. By conducting a comprehensive analysis on various benchmarks, we
show that E2TP achieves new state-of-the-art results in nearly all cases.
|
[
-0.39536750316619873,
-0.7173293828964233,
0.5458475351333618,
0.5339106321334839,
-0.6306442618370056,
0.09543263912200928,
-0.04868489131331444,
-0.30220597982406616,
0.11486902087926865,
0.10707433521747589,
-0.5884848833084106,
-0.15301842987537384,
-0.5234795212745667,
0.14315460622310638,
-0.16241464018821716,
1.0349416732788086,
0.019910356029868126,
-0.06282786279916763,
-0.2902202010154724,
0.12343195080757141,
-0.5492269396781921,
-0.3434907793998718,
-1.000598430633545,
-0.5415360331535339,
0.5578005313873291,
0.7699336409568787,
0.3232625722885132,
0.19769065082073212,
0.09673294425010681,
0.14941054582595825,
-0.02966451458632946,
0.1491411179304123,
-0.31415021419525146,
0.5647773146629333,
-0.10982390493154526,
-0.4858208894729614,
-0.22079701721668243,
0.032881371676921844,
0.12124443799257278,
0.6646352410316467,
0.048529721796512604,
-0.011625661514699459,
0.680351734161377,
0.9504566192626953,
-0.374191015958786,
0.27169185876846313,
-0.5513850450515747,
0.2783382534980774,
-0.007820012979209423,
-0.2757112681865692,
-0.4977998435497284,
-0.10001745820045471,
0.2758612036705017,
-0.6593464612960815,
0.4323711097240448,
0.3082505166530609,
0.5597953200340271,
0.10617576539516449,
-0.22989027202129364,
0.04504970833659172,
-0.572666347026825,
0.6304368376731873,
-0.19269490242004395,
0.22060012817382812,
0.49664753675460815,
0.07780887186527252,
-0.08870422095060349,
-0.5802008509635925,
-0.6230870485305786,
0.2505894601345062,
-0.131215900182724,
0.43890058994293213,
-0.017221370711922646,
0.1050899401307106,
0.008256733417510986,
0.3892695903778076,
-0.4507467746734619,
-0.017813000828027725,
-0.15757021307945251,
-0.08162117749452591,
0.24913474917411804,
-0.21877655386924744,
-0.12756851315498352,
-0.39369088411331177,
-0.3890245854854584,
-0.10749075561761856,
-0.7380698919296265,
0.29736730456352234,
0.07185321301221848,
0.42969319224357605,
-0.38876157999038696,
0.6543290615081787,
-0.25008562207221985,
0.43362635374069214,
0.32219576835632324,
0.3557417690753937,
0.15049245953559875,
-0.21498419344425201,
-0.17043760418891907,
-0.1860739141702652,
0.707861065864563,
0.5565966367721558,
0.019511306658387184,
-0.014140763320028782,
0.05748371407389641,
0.013676072470843792,
0.39708182215690613,
-0.6335951685905457,
-0.4799911081790924,
0.7815423607826233,
-0.3562895357608795,
-0.4113606810569763,
0.1897716224193573,
-1.3372581005096436,
-0.6972038745880127,
-0.38602516055107117,
0.2346768081188202,
-0.7307654619216919,
-0.4544709026813507,
-0.17900878190994263,
-0.26470786333084106,
0.3066951334476471,
0.6048229336738586,
-0.9278530478477478,
0.019366731867194176,
1.3532887697219849,
1.1097713708877563,
-0.16606225073337555,
-0.33867207169532776,
-0.6846305727958679,
-0.07789240777492523,
-0.182844340801239,
1.3601340055465698,
-0.7407571077346802,
-0.4837091863155365,
0.36161336302757263,
-0.3628920018672943,
0.144077330827713,
-0.2907958924770355,
0.5212241411209106,
-0.07173605263233185,
0.5356795787811279,
-0.5488280057907104,
-0.18126952648162842,
-0.4865269660949707,
0.5368127822875977,
-0.6708789467811584,
1.4165254831314087,
0.31088972091674805,
-0.8847123384475708,
0.504731297492981,
-0.6430975198745728,
-0.7940495610237122,
-0.17251735925674438,
-0.277549147605896,
-0.7644569277763367,
0.5541970729827881,
0.41656357049942017,
0.5702883005142212,
-0.4199507236480713,
-0.3210359215736389,
-0.29582443833351135,
0.08394262194633484,
0.030950255692005157,
-0.2065919190645218,
0.23380734026432037,
0.007477820850908756,
-0.34762856364250183,
0.13980893790721893,
-0.3619230091571808,
-0.09623746573925018,
0.11427013576030731,
-0.04997015371918678,
-0.3837818205356598,
0.03508869931101799,
0.2249448299407959,
0.4155726432800293,
-0.2434321492910385,
-0.45483124256134033,
0.3384510576725006,
-0.6376877427101135,
0.44742146134376526,
0.7925978899002075,
0.1787133812904358,
0.5017310380935669,
-0.3840707540512085,
0.4598122537136078,
0.17680120468139648,
-0.01637098379433155,
-0.2703001797199249,
-0.6934146881103516,
-0.8072612881660461,
0.009494059719145298,
0.1821753829717636,
0.2653873860836029,
-0.948366641998291,
0.3178349733352661,
-0.17888185381889343,
-0.4756736755371094,
-0.3072963356971741,
-0.13229309022426605,
0.45738887786865234,
0.435517281293869,
0.4176228940486908,
-0.4584018886089325,
-0.4634818732738495,
-0.5376063585281372,
-0.20031015574932098,
-0.6136026978492737,
-0.1502840518951416,
-0.08057669550180435,
0.2796030640602112,
0.508983314037323,
0.8976656794548035,
-0.27243924140930176,
-0.5847333073616028,
-0.7057026028633118,
0.6084956526756287,
-0.059662554413080215,
0.41897767782211304,
0.3892841339111328,
-0.8563755750656128,
-0.5776771903038025,
-0.11405730247497559,
-0.41734668612480164,
-0.03239968791604042,
-0.2894521951675415,
-0.2492670714855194,
0.27886077761650085,
0.056077275425195694,
-0.4903775751590729,
0.4124113619327545,
0.4557262659072876,
-0.48240724205970764,
0.30834639072418213,
0.1795857548713684,
0.057527825236320496,
-1.477501392364502,
-0.04856406897306442,
0.3386218249797821,
-0.17129532992839813,
-0.6597765684127808,
-0.20177839696407318,
-0.06160464882850647,
-0.03695274889469147,
-0.4225064516067505,
0.37814176082611084,
-0.3779716491699219,
-0.15147435665130615,
-0.3215603828430176,
-0.34503766894340515,
0.3695560693740845,
0.5810521245002747,
0.3982031047344208,
0.7504426836967468,
0.36118003726005554,
-0.5628106594085693,
0.013245445676147938,
0.3371186852455139,
-0.0003241332888137549,
0.9648027420043945,
-0.650917112827301,
0.5757876038551331,
-0.189457505941391,
0.32580262422561646,
-1.2318671941757202,
-0.10420657694339752,
0.5056058168411255,
-0.6947019100189209,
0.3758969008922577,
-0.31259119510650635,
-0.4044824540615082,
-0.12960262596607208,
-0.786738395690918,
0.24904455244541168,
0.24311764538288116,
-0.33850133419036865,
1.1733088493347168,
0.19388972222805023,
-0.5246636271476746,
-0.3874845802783966,
-0.5265761613845825,
0.017501356080174446,
-0.16423653066158295,
-0.3607083559036255,
0.5026128888130188,
0.26463887095451355,
0.06684738397598267,
-0.17027461528778076,
-0.14704084396362305,
0.15670841932296753,
0.09102402627468109,
0.4959336817264557,
0.18987372517585754,
0.14623573422431946,
0.04958704113960266,
0.2778482139110565,
-0.27518975734710693,
0.09636424481868744,
-0.319614440202713,
1.0054657459259033,
0.07161977887153625,
-0.13472792506217957,
-0.6498484015464783,
0.7469110488891602,
0.23554913699626923,
-0.3016498386859894,
0.43436095118522644,
0.44495436549186707,
-0.34930503368377686,
-0.3211151659488678,
-0.4136850833892822,
-0.2793201804161072,
-0.4404098391532898,
0.5654191970825195,
-0.5868848562240601,
-0.5497031211853027,
0.18632926046848297,
-0.18226464092731476,
0.3977236747741699,
0.2213732749223709,
0.5927911400794983,
-0.40567725896835327,
0.9234947562217712,
0.6851904988288879,
-0.2696186304092407,
0.6356133222579956,
-0.4187625050544739,
0.20723167061805725,
-1.1053346395492554,
-0.45138782262802124,
-0.635585606098175,
-0.40486636757850647,
-0.11755875498056412,
-0.48328420519828796,
0.6336608529090881,
0.09950095415115356,
-0.21179845929145813,
0.16302523016929626,
-0.4953257441520691,
0.1855885088443756,
0.666508138179779,
0.12780021131038666,
0.052698563784360886,
0.5633386373519897,
-0.02819684147834778,
-0.013941876590251923,
-0.5561707019805908,
-0.17395281791687012,
1.2343536615371704,
0.3849301040172577,
0.46660947799682617,
0.055769070982933044,
0.6497247815132141,
0.5077418684959412,
0.2409978210926056,
-1.250683307647705,
0.4582100808620453,
0.040214769542217255,
-0.05660277605056763,
-0.11036299169063568,
-0.024874825030565262,
-1.023471713066101,
0.17179898917675018,
-0.3553011119365692,
-0.5959219932556152,
0.057313222438097,
0.37746158242225647,
-0.5579515695571899,
-0.029820261523127556,
-0.41965949535369873,
0.6136884689331055,
-0.04615667462348938,
-0.560684084892273,
-0.34065547585487366,
-0.5384535193443298,
-0.3166345953941345,
0.2338016778230667,
0.08800756186246872,
-0.0490015409886837,
-0.13362887501716614,
0.6801326274871826,
-0.2933464050292969,
0.893317699432373,
-0.38870319724082947,
0.16509035229682922,
0.21205992996692657,
0.2740021347999573,
0.6655689477920532,
0.12265060842037201,
-0.09962350130081177,
0.041496392339468,
-0.32931068539619446,
-0.2955947816371918,
-0.6490716338157654,
0.3111177980899811,
-0.7440046668052673,
-0.4846932590007782,
-0.6532105207443237,
-0.18592135608196259,
-0.5975579619407654,
-0.004518219735473394,
0.5360559821128845,
0.3811730146408081,
-0.006288761273026466,
0.130151629447937,
0.5808900594711304,
0.17756366729736328,
0.4470154941082001,
0.2278955578804016,
-0.11269721388816833,
-0.48093342781066895,
0.672893226146698,
-0.343108594417572,
0.0724998489022255,
0.6415470242500305,
0.3936597406864166,
-0.5820395350456238,
-0.5235369801521301,
-0.5214524269104004,
0.0804058164358139,
-0.4390402138233185,
-0.46252432465553284,
-0.6177372336387634,
0.1974005401134491,
-0.6583499908447266,
-0.007516850717365742,
-0.35710379481315613,
-0.5080932974815369,
-0.13580147922039032,
-0.2957811653614044,
0.37074822187423706,
0.5001899003982544,
0.0726991817355156,
0.150013267993927,
-0.610704779624939,
0.2114320695400238,
0.29996100068092346,
0.1839122772216797,
-0.008786734193563461,
-0.6406586170196533,
-0.02569758892059326,
-0.1470530927181244,
-0.5514833927154541,
-1.0924185514450073,
0.23309765756130219,
0.48438918590545654,
0.10379708558320999,
0.4337562024593353,
0.1807297170162201,
0.42042306065559387,
-0.40237078070640564,
1.012587070465088,
0.3436189591884613,
-0.8029515147209167,
0.7922073006629944,
-0.1161874532699585,
-0.006272811442613602,
0.7141035795211792,
0.2590542733669281,
-0.9431841373443604,
-0.26777130365371704,
-0.214463472366333,
-1.0349500179290771,
0.596271812915802,
0.22245019674301147,
0.12768015265464783,
0.17824788391590118,
0.28857117891311646,
0.4866591691970825,
0.21988922357559204,
-0.5243739485740662,
-0.2958870828151703,
-0.7174882888793945,
-0.36321282386779785,
0.23780597746372223,
-0.25411131978034973,
-0.10664407908916473,
-0.16348275542259216,
0.9131250381469727,
-0.3705157935619354,
0.7245391011238098,
0.3194103240966797,
0.15279701352119446,
-0.19017855823040009,
0.31347012519836426,
0.17523401975631714,
0.3156318664550781,
0.13143686950206757,
0.11418841779232025,
-0.29621660709381104,
-0.41657039523124695,
0.03737194836139679,
0.27417245507240295,
-0.4218846261501312,
-0.0971158966422081,
0.196913942694664,
0.7212477922439575,
-0.11662236601114273,
-0.15745626389980316,
0.5001418590545654,
0.04341527074575424,
-0.13935354351997375,
-0.5425743460655212,
-0.24888183176517487,
-0.2720226049423218,
0.08533737808465958,
0.4461829960346222,
0.006473990622907877,
0.15809020400047302,
-0.7148920297622681,
0.06894014030694962,
0.2088836431503296,
-0.4816480278968811,
-0.6467373967170715,
0.5532914400100708,
0.5525446534156799,
-0.15822820365428925,
0.5207416415214539,
-0.40812695026397705,
-0.8657898306846619,
0.31215235590934753,
0.4035971760749817,
1.0745408535003662,
-0.2209252566099167,
0.6708930134773254,
0.30111458897590637,
0.20125114917755127,
-0.1035248264670372,
0.6315945386886597,
0.022906193509697914,
-0.807795524597168,
-0.41268354654312134,
-0.4905443489551544,
-0.526831328868866,
0.20190457999706268,
-0.6438751220703125,
0.2616090476512909,
-0.6219996809959412,
0.07256797701120377,
0.12286430597305298,
-0.093604177236557,
-0.6059878468513489,
0.11337658017873764,
0.28404203057289124,
0.8213763236999512,
-0.9565256237983704,
0.7590499520301819,
1.2568491697311401,
-0.5554240345954895,
-0.8555127382278442,
0.31396907567977905,
0.48719310760498047,
-0.7032952904701233,
0.0024515758268535137,
0.6155171990394592,
0.10977627336978912,
-0.19243857264518738,
-0.14282888174057007,
-0.32048922777175903,
0.809097170829773,
-0.18024607002735138,
-0.35297441482543945,
-0.030652843415737152,
0.5362545847892761,
0.3301876485347748,
-0.34308257699012756,
0.21627900004386902,
0.5302464962005615,
0.43028831481933594,
0.1826706826686859,
-0.6665334701538086,
0.1531137228012085,
-0.40652069449424744,
0.1861390322446823,
0.17804419994354248,
-0.6542165279388428,
0.7168485522270203,
-0.07642664760351181,
-0.1094856783747673,
-0.033762987703084946,
1.1487215757369995,
0.14956074953079224,
0.5613289475440979,
0.8444061875343323,
0.5045853853225708,
0.5012444257736206,
-0.33394938707351685,
0.9610277414321899,
-0.2995230555534363,
0.24817147850990295,
1.1567116975784302,
-0.238517627120018,
1.161903977394104,
0.7196440100669861,
-0.378113716840744,
0.711571216583252,
0.8349857926368713,
0.17139939963817596,
0.6372897028923035,
-0.31445062160491943,
-0.29989615082740784,
-0.2431449443101883,
-0.22877176105976105,
-0.2881702780723572,
0.5341573357582092,
0.4280611574649811,
-0.20121003687381744,
0.0032668362837284803,
0.0337497740983963,
0.29754209518432617,
0.102993443608284,
-0.45504212379455566,
0.9202641248703003,
0.15697802603244781,
-1.0608596801757812,
-0.07729364931583405,
-0.056366488337516785,
0.724936306476593,
-0.32836517691612244,
-0.16323159635066986,
-0.43112894892692566,
-0.048834167420864105,
-0.233768492937088,
-1.0377494096755981,
0.3364899158477783,
-0.10399342328310013,
-0.1404573917388916,
-0.22331158816814423,
0.7234259843826294,
-0.3885059952735901,
-0.40481236577033997,
-0.021778028458356857,
0.548205554485321,
-0.20377981662750244,
-0.7711029648780823,
-0.8352243304252625,
-0.20931527018547058,
-0.015189748257398605,
-0.46744245290756226,
0.36461585760116577,
0.5076836347579956,
0.12608429789543152,
0.3860344886779785,
0.47884756326675415,
0.04156598448753357,
-0.5575314164161682,
0.10564415156841278,
0.8905491232872009,
-0.5376951098442078,
-0.8296400904655457,
-0.6416565179824829,
0.6314011216163635,
-0.299128919839859,
-0.37391161918640137,
0.3896481394767761,
0.6820873618125916,
0.7408519387245178,
0.031623952090740204,
1.2014505863189697,
-0.3764480948448181,
0.7823242545127869,
-0.6082584261894226,
0.3607937693595886,
-0.44044265151023865,
0.21714165806770325,
-0.029202476143836975,
-1.0695101022720337,
-0.09722236543893814,
0.5563231706619263,
-0.15862086415290833,
-0.02559584751725197,
0.8789898157119751,
0.5726155042648315,
0.011283641681075096,
0.37052732706069946,
-0.10440585762262344,
0.02178730070590973,
0.35131511092185974,
0.5695340037345886,
0.6811640858650208,
-0.14392760396003723,
0.44277551770210266,
-0.7436830997467041,
-0.28923913836479187,
-0.21941521763801575,
-0.8803096413612366,
-0.844022810459137,
-0.8112913370132446,
-0.2919709086418152,
-0.6921862363815308,
-0.056562598794698715,
1.3505096435546875,
0.49300628900527954,
-0.8244008421897888,
0.1977493166923523,
-0.2712966203689575,
-0.10894681513309479,
-0.7413625717163086,
-0.24469345808029175,
0.5160011053085327,
-0.39397749304771423,
-0.8208092451095581,
0.09034573286771774,
0.41156747937202454,
-0.12041409313678741,
-0.23574921488761902,
0.19113358855247498,
0.3102322220802307,
-0.040474094450473785,
0.8142921328544617,
0.19883830845355988,
-0.6045071482658386,
-0.5573552250862122,
-0.18613004684448242,
0.22672580182552338,
0.3560272753238678,
1.137270450592041,
-0.7391076683998108,
0.42108720541000366,
0.6961988806724548,
0.6616430878639221,
0.2209034562110901,
0.2529577910900116,
0.7915514707565308,
-0.8676071166992188,
0.1718144416809082,
0.4020553529262543,
0.3397955298423767,
0.4440358877182007,
-0.3614187240600586,
0.5517600178718567,
0.2668476402759552,
-0.21929824352264404,
-0.4469875693321228,
0.44326865673065186,
-1.2427417039871216,
-0.14912277460098267,
1.492006540298462,
-0.2804316580295563,
-0.15078018605709076,
-0.4740144610404968,
-0.376325398683548,
0.15970700979232788,
-0.8626126050949097,
1.1094553470611572,
0.42799726128578186,
-0.3715175688266754,
-0.3911162316799164,
-0.09228865057229996,
0.5913029909133911,
0.8207839131355286,
-1.0081158876419067,
0.15477395057678223,
0.47465288639068604,
0.19000795483589172,
-0.019240466877818108,
0.5803548097610474,
0.07684499770402908,
0.36837589740753174,
-0.1787496954202652,
-0.09088192135095596,
-0.31276142597198486,
-0.5183574557304382,
-0.17845739424228668,
0.43701571226119995,
0.1234845444560051,
-0.24881349503993988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06424v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06424v2
|
Improving Instruction Following in Language Models through Proxy-Based Uncertainty Estimation
| 2024-05-10T12:14:11 | 2024-05-19T17:35:43 |
JoonHo Lee, Jae Oh Woo, Juree Seok, Parisa Hassanzadeh, Wooseok Jang, JuYoun Son, Sima Didari, Baruch Gutow, Heng Hao, Hankyu Moon, Wenjun Hu, Yeong-Dae Kwon, Taehee Lee, Seungjai Min
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Assessing response quality to instructions in language models is vital but
challenging due to the complexity of human language across different contexts.
This complexity often results in ambiguous or inconsistent interpretations,
making accurate assessment difficult. To address this issue, we propose a novel
Uncertainty-aware Reward Model (URM) that introduces a robust uncertainty
estimation for the quality of paired responses based on Bayesian approximation.
Trained with preference datasets, our uncertainty-enabled proxy not only scores
rewards for responses but also evaluates their inherent uncertainty. Empirical
results demonstrate significant benefits of incorporating the proposed proxy
into language model training. Our method boosts the instruction following
capability of language models by refining data curation for training and
improving policy optimization objectives, thereby surpassing existing methods
by a large margin on benchmarks such as Vicuna and MT-bench. These findings
highlight that our proposed approach substantially advances language model
training and paves a new way of harnessing uncertainty within language models.
|
[
0.09857113659381866,
-0.5126133561134338,
0.6919645667076111,
0.04161575436592102,
-0.1004486083984375,
0.13509196043014526,
-0.046644896268844604,
0.09426658600568771,
-0.04596713185310364,
0.5161770582199097,
-0.5698816180229187,
-0.4171869158744812,
-0.9395755529403687,
-0.49382084608078003,
0.12700387835502625,
0.7762758731842041,
-0.01917424239218235,
0.2797476053237915,
-0.057714492082595825,
0.009163200855255127,
-0.5905194282531738,
-0.3991900384426117,
-0.8434330224990845,
-0.30709967017173767,
0.5444604158401489,
0.32533782720565796,
0.873077392578125,
0.7496392130851746,
0.3344622850418091,
0.2962053418159485,
0.13426581025123596,
0.21743108332157135,
-0.2780795991420746,
0.12134575098752975,
-0.44337862730026245,
-0.5237012505531311,
-0.42734000086784363,
0.20711591839790344,
0.7977197170257568,
1.0607390403747559,
-0.5298791527748108,
0.018245244398713112,
0.1692461520433426,
0.6224753260612488,
-0.9808076620101929,
0.28021708130836487,
-0.4759981036186218,
-0.22362518310546875,
0.1553744226694107,
-0.05454731360077858,
-0.4676935076713562,
-0.422801673412323,
0.30007031559944153,
-0.46676772832870483,
0.03734976798295975,
-0.0669170394539833,
0.7336660623550415,
0.3039340674877167,
-0.11687847971916199,
-0.17091205716133118,
-0.4886203706264496,
0.8379083275794983,
-0.9247297644615173,
0.6108962297439575,
0.6937835812568665,
0.2645605206489563,
-0.5897250175476074,
-0.590302050113678,
-0.23221974074840546,
-0.08716680854558945,
0.2657034397125244,
0.3330519199371338,
0.0804051086306572,
0.12846678495407104,
-0.22431468963623047,
0.08401978760957718,
-0.4228469431400299,
0.1751059740781784,
0.09036310017108917,
-0.08834965527057648,
0.4217466413974762,
0.16543619334697723,
0.10982592403888702,
0.026415619999170303,
-0.3010736405849457,
-0.5876107811927795,
-0.3810044229030609,
0.5736453533172607,
0.7157018780708313,
0.6183223724365234,
-0.26052072644233704,
0.31032082438468933,
-0.36363083124160767,
0.7268669605255127,
-0.16273382306098938,
0.04879062622785568,
-0.14393505454063416,
0.18289043009281158,
-0.03691871091723442,
-0.23764677345752716,
0.6480458974838257,
0.2731715440750122,
-0.13002389669418335,
-0.24682345986366272,
-0.33047351241111755,
-0.041556719690561295,
0.3995395600795746,
-0.5390743017196655,
-0.32236266136169434,
0.31525737047195435,
-0.21405565738677979,
-0.24481621384620667,
0.31353959441185,
-0.9162769913673401,
-0.3177569508552551,
-0.034977566450834274,
0.6318356990814209,
-0.20063674449920654,
-0.24824494123458862,
0.5221166014671326,
-0.053092822432518005,
-0.0023706303909420967,
0.3347642123699188,
-0.9692970514297485,
0.4308934807777405,
0.7985622882843018,
0.5540314316749573,
-0.14554519951343536,
-0.21144971251487732,
-1.1146169900894165,
0.20644862949848175,
-0.48975634574890137,
0.686492383480072,
-0.9338994026184082,
-0.48987868428230286,
0.17798615992069244,
-0.11505040526390076,
-0.05090762674808502,
-0.26211851835250854,
0.5155696272850037,
-0.5765325427055359,
0.2966936230659485,
-0.12580996751785278,
-0.7590888142585754,
-0.06740546226501465,
0.09506262838840485,
-0.6991698741912842,
1.1157293319702148,
0.4079118072986603,
-0.5115298628807068,
0.18342790007591248,
-0.2949877679347992,
-0.01347903162240982,
-0.029800500720739365,
0.06732679903507233,
-0.2913571000099182,
0.2885356843471527,
0.33457961678504944,
0.3539700210094452,
-0.2867753207683563,
0.4125749468803406,
-0.4910881817340851,
-0.5483589768409729,
0.3991474211215973,
-0.7880699634552002,
0.4053283631801605,
-0.05224744230508804,
-0.37246087193489075,
0.12826186418533325,
-0.5070223212242126,
0.292831689119339,
-0.11592715233564377,
-0.3045017421245575,
-0.5749318599700928,
0.20854143798351288,
-0.4315715730190277,
-0.10361888259649277,
0.21948079764842987,
-0.34820735454559326,
0.21137723326683044,
-0.4468803107738495,
0.0008455896168015897,
1.1305906772613525,
0.0353827029466629,
0.6178939342498779,
-0.17749370634555817,
0.6717125773429871,
-0.443085640668869,
0.3776749074459076,
0.07101450115442276,
-0.48975318670272827,
-0.6074008345603943,
-0.16380706429481506,
0.610608696937561,
0.5250614285469055,
-0.6374983787536621,
0.032572221010923386,
-0.33261165022850037,
-0.36084306240081787,
-0.9903276562690735,
0.05362149700522423,
0.6728106737136841,
0.41665518283843994,
0.4095354378223419,
-0.3824305236339569,
-0.1982065737247467,
-0.5051649808883667,
-0.36063915491104126,
-0.673119068145752,
-0.10570576786994934,
0.10723638534545898,
0.24350765347480774,
-0.008887166157364845,
0.6457075476646423,
-0.42129966616630554,
0.3597237765789032,
-0.14864058792591095,
0.5260100364685059,
0.19177085161209106,
0.7028189301490784,
-0.015658633783459663,
-0.7280287742614746,
-0.36895552277565,
-0.2808467149734497,
-0.27325305342674255,
-0.15056948363780975,
-0.14820672571659088,
-0.41932815313339233,
0.06376808881759644,
0.08678438514471054,
-0.14598852396011353,
0.45172592997550964,
0.5330101847648621,
-0.15923137962818146,
0.34710463881492615,
-0.16696666181087494,
0.34898990392684937,
-0.9864662289619446,
-0.2499869465827942,
-0.11100364476442337,
-0.15544134378433228,
-0.4374005198478699,
0.05400585010647774,
0.13925626873970032,
0.3262218236923218,
-0.35755687952041626,
0.8518281579017639,
-0.28469663858413696,
0.09242743253707886,
-0.49139174818992615,
-0.18762697279453278,
-0.012813098728656769,
0.5286921262741089,
0.5984271168708801,
0.60035640001297,
0.5612881779670715,
-0.3648218512535095,
0.08596600592136383,
-0.04965553432703018,
-0.33117544651031494,
0.5133315324783325,
-0.6320045590400696,
0.026697158813476562,
0.05034321919083595,
0.0020453864708542824,
-0.9572196006774902,
-0.4434192180633545,
0.4423132836818695,
-0.6709126234054565,
0.5563209652900696,
-0.5171819925308228,
-0.2016449123620987,
-0.24446091055870056,
-0.29231205582618713,
0.11016473919153214,
0.5225688815116882,
-0.5019901394844055,
0.3350472152233124,
0.23207077383995056,
-0.33359622955322266,
-0.938697338104248,
-0.4279143214225769,
-0.2622857093811035,
-0.09330582618713379,
-0.03421127423644066,
0.2384009212255478,
-0.09874451905488968,
-0.09983444958925247,
0.020280832424759865,
-0.5799170136451721,
-0.2393406629562378,
0.26994040608406067,
0.32120102643966675,
0.3419892191886902,
0.12886011600494385,
0.10409664362668991,
0.36802002787590027,
-0.19017939269542694,
0.3153902292251587,
-0.29002559185028076,
0.36224040389060974,
0.06496081501245499,
-0.5817434787750244,
-0.4936579167842865,
0.3121196925640106,
0.10165499895811081,
-0.09091023355722427,
0.718871533870697,
0.7272708415985107,
-0.29031500220298767,
-0.23087696731090546,
-0.607917070388794,
-0.3240029215812683,
-0.5098095536231995,
0.2611905038356781,
-0.3671856224536896,
-0.8796419501304626,
0.3939538598060608,
-0.04139203578233719,
-0.0914592519402504,
0.008684261702001095,
0.1520625203847885,
-0.21600696444511414,
1.2866827249526978,
0.692787766456604,
-0.21361438930034637,
0.608902633190155,
0.005903471261262894,
-0.10917878150939941,
-0.7635899186134338,
-0.2815368175506592,
-0.5568170547485352,
0.16817031800746918,
-0.6015288829803467,
-0.5060579180717468,
0.20225593447685242,
0.30696526169776917,
-0.4209335446357727,
0.08404304832220078,
-0.19038338959217072,
0.14163266122341156,
0.9992830753326416,
0.4159000515937805,
-0.22092992067337036,
0.0817403793334961,
-0.08215934038162231,
-0.010224640369415283,
-0.8830468654632568,
-0.6000924110412598,
1.1234972476959229,
0.3439076244831085,
1.200701355934143,
0.12819154560565948,
0.6734804511070251,
0.29070958495140076,
0.3094896972179413,
-0.4876895248889923,
0.17070907354354858,
0.1823517084121704,
-0.2269238531589508,
-0.4401867985725403,
-0.7287336587905884,
-0.8170351386070251,
0.03804546222090721,
-0.0789484903216362,
-1.0399560928344727,
0.02934195287525654,
0.012001034803688526,
-0.5311819911003113,
0.22880181670188904,
-0.5373555421829224,
0.9812042117118835,
-0.16781654953956604,
-0.8436853289604187,
0.09594596922397614,
-0.9184190630912781,
-0.11898404359817505,
0.2760222852230072,
0.2395550161600113,
-0.10431661456823349,
-0.1781107783317566,
0.7301712036132812,
-0.48026904463768005,
0.8002674579620361,
-0.23659966886043549,
0.008288976736366749,
0.35839664936065674,
0.25308510661125183,
0.656822144985199,
0.33599263429641724,
-0.33681511878967285,
-0.23271293938159943,
-0.14645420014858246,
-0.7376724481582642,
-1.0251193046569824,
0.595700740814209,
-0.658923327922821,
-0.7902831435203552,
-0.4288875460624695,
-0.9445292949676514,
-0.5796554088592529,
-0.1694849729537964,
0.004423322156071663,
0.3271050751209259,
0.15529578924179077,
-0.25434592366218567,
0.7471439838409424,
-0.3193439245223999,
0.45031556487083435,
0.7757552862167358,
0.20505209267139435,
-0.5732681155204773,
0.8051986694335938,
-0.15596722066402435,
0.47872355580329895,
0.6526991128921509,
0.2606651186943054,
-0.6283590197563171,
-0.5133745670318604,
-0.43754440546035767,
-0.00869661383330822,
-0.3907495141029358,
-0.22486762702465057,
-0.35703375935554504,
0.02168387733399868,
-0.579781174659729,
-0.2295258641242981,
-0.645394504070282,
-0.18883642554283142,
-0.0248882919549942,
-0.05017274245619774,
0.2487507313489914,
0.6790217757225037,
-0.2157873511314392,
0.7691938877105713,
-0.7570383548736572,
-0.14434458315372467,
0.4531174898147583,
0.7223074436187744,
-0.23534701764583588,
-0.9109966158866882,
-0.2664903700351715,
0.5307710766792297,
-0.004806942772120237,
-1.0471421480178833,
0.4970354437828064,
-0.04526180773973465,
0.8690870404243469,
0.2775832712650299,
0.22734327614307404,
0.8487328290939331,
-0.29827621579170227,
0.8174453973770142,
-0.0821584165096283,
-0.9113572835922241,
0.7845650315284729,
-0.19983378052711487,
0.36278411746025085,
0.54021817445755,
0.566429615020752,
-0.2729557752609253,
-0.4956572353839874,
-0.6513402462005615,
-0.7286401987075806,
0.7434346675872803,
0.1751740276813507,
0.30317744612693787,
-0.13693548738956451,
0.5820726752281189,
0.0771036148071289,
0.38744595646858215,
-0.6361212134361267,
-0.08338114619255066,
-0.06235389783978462,
-0.3462051451206207,
-0.025035005062818527,
-0.300728976726532,
0.0795808807015419,
0.06136125698685646,
0.9191450476646423,
-0.12377053499221802,
0.3747517764568329,
-0.21365037560462952,
0.1459542065858841,
-0.13838915526866913,
0.2628921866416931,
0.2511655390262604,
0.3061569631099701,
-0.5938756465911865,
0.22332924604415894,
0.005702647380530834,
-0.3044068217277527,
0.21028785407543182,
0.22301264107227325,
0.09298569709062576,
-0.004820642527192831,
0.28791341185569763,
0.7987959980964661,
0.3632054924964905,
-0.8425783514976501,
0.604358434677124,
-0.03527373448014259,
0.25178563594818115,
0.05639767646789551,
0.2136860340833664,
-0.03881114721298218,
0.3474237322807312,
0.1499762386083603,
-0.10144276916980743,
0.3343273401260376,
-0.331283301115036,
0.20853716135025024,
0.43069925904273987,
-0.8342952132225037,
-0.19886146485805511,
0.7262964844703674,
-0.2672021985054016,
-0.2397843897342682,
0.5382000207901001,
-0.3262808322906494,
-0.40707236528396606,
0.4472947418689728,
0.591764509677887,
0.5545421838760376,
-0.8883121013641357,
0.6593061089515686,
0.32349011301994324,
0.292410671710968,
-0.48580577969551086,
0.5123049020767212,
0.0544101819396019,
-0.7464599013328552,
-0.32748860120773315,
-0.6614234447479248,
-0.7818726301193237,
-0.026284465566277504,
-1.1394110918045044,
-0.13442692160606384,
-0.20373952388763428,
-0.18228092789649963,
-0.4760574996471405,
-0.1197279840707779,
-0.47293776273727417,
0.19872981309890747,
-0.16932331025600433,
0.6043512225151062,
-0.9003370404243469,
0.8172389268875122,
0.7700775265693665,
-0.6439511775970459,
-0.996288001537323,
-0.13677753508090973,
-0.10590193420648575,
-0.6447881460189819,
0.31260183453559875,
0.06083713099360466,
-0.19569538533687592,
-0.15643459558486938,
-0.520432710647583,
-0.8937960267066956,
0.7225683331489563,
0.5624736547470093,
-0.2107226550579071,
0.14134639501571655,
0.2829734981060028,
0.3932482898235321,
-0.35540157556533813,
0.509498119354248,
0.41056281328201294,
0.20547623932361603,
0.01728980429470539,
-0.3285840153694153,
-0.20540671050548553,
-0.20807629823684692,
0.3001585602760315,
0.19600127637386322,
-0.3959905207157135,
0.5627926588058472,
-0.05669696256518364,
0.07138144224882126,
0.3434675931930542,
0.8999128937721252,
0.3157794773578644,
0.3413478136062622,
0.3243957459926605,
0.38384291529655457,
0.7314291596412659,
-0.030825428664684296,
1.0834063291549683,
-0.16533870995044708,
0.21395830810070038,
1.7152204513549805,
-0.12617100775241852,
1.2542829513549805,
0.6261134147644043,
-0.2407766580581665,
0.7814056277275085,
1.1065422296524048,
0.45791491866111755,
0.7179895639419556,
0.17321103811264038,
-0.33215558528900146,
-0.5146510601043701,
-0.31269145011901855,
-0.07764839380979538,
0.1328454613685608,
0.5545274615287781,
-0.2793360650539398,
-0.04532010853290558,
-0.024964725598692894,
0.043064627796411514,
0.4223518669605255,
-0.3583332300186157,
0.5044320821762085,
-0.19979135692119598,
-0.8995416760444641,
0.27434659004211426,
0.048654790967702866,
0.3505822718143463,
-0.6049452424049377,
-0.35658442974090576,
-0.43335816264152527,
-0.16454200446605682,
0.3222757577896118,
-0.7890377640724182,
-0.11990607529878616,
0.04575933888554573,
-0.012316015549004078,
-0.19495107233524323,
0.2967015504837036,
-0.6472830772399902,
-0.4964170753955841,
0.2297600507736206,
0.5592172145843506,
0.2015654593706131,
-0.1400565654039383,
-0.7812624573707581,
0.07166828960180283,
-0.20901156961917877,
-0.26029548048973083,
0.2931143641471863,
0.23445571959018707,
-0.027075881138443947,
0.831315279006958,
0.37212347984313965,
0.03062942996621132,
0.21122008562088013,
0.0997038334608078,
0.5936382412910461,
-0.16381964087486267,
-0.28859078884124756,
-0.6117069721221924,
0.7090612649917603,
0.04593438655138016,
-0.21754923462867737,
0.4636302888393402,
0.34465518593788147,
1.0392650365829468,
-0.05060704052448273,
0.6334856748580933,
0.22044222056865692,
0.5169400572776794,
-0.5815421938896179,
0.3333495855331421,
-0.4635317921638489,
0.48425909876823425,
-0.43405142426490784,
-0.7243101000785828,
-0.10471925884485245,
0.700401246547699,
-0.4240363836288452,
0.10675074905157089,
0.41996461153030396,
0.9762129187583923,
-0.1555618792772293,
-0.08243272453546524,
0.2302774041891098,
-0.20682495832443237,
-0.0003869759966619313,
0.5777642726898193,
0.706503689289093,
-0.5096227526664734,
0.3018830716609955,
-0.5840256810188293,
-0.33453169465065,
0.07789666950702667,
-0.7282042503356934,
-0.658691942691803,
-0.5878345966339111,
-0.443236380815506,
-0.33302342891693115,
0.585563063621521,
1.0678139925003052,
0.7521669864654541,
-0.8587531447410583,
-0.5072479844093323,
-0.24302667379379272,
0.3478585183620453,
-0.7412481904029846,
-0.2032318264245987,
0.6046280264854431,
-0.6780956983566284,
-1.014313817024231,
0.4554979205131531,
0.08651267737150192,
0.09170470386743546,
-0.020536618307232857,
-0.3773324191570282,
-0.34293827414512634,
0.4082869589328766,
0.21068048477172852,
0.15317630767822266,
-0.747127890586853,
-0.5420566201210022,
0.015476055443286896,
-0.22414405643939972,
-0.28587019443511963,
0.29449263215065,
-0.6620575785636902,
0.8756171464920044,
0.29786890745162964,
0.9979392290115356,
0.314512699842453,
0.12279524654150009,
0.8518598079681396,
-0.6649436950683594,
-0.014160786755383015,
0.1323307752609253,
0.30425524711608887,
0.2813742160797119,
-0.2680988013744354,
0.7859258055686951,
0.03915463387966156,
-0.3752763271331787,
-0.8756135702133179,
0.1805337369441986,
-1.0067315101623535,
-0.24298594892024994,
1.079826831817627,
-0.8033638596534729,
-0.2672441005706787,
0.14456748962402344,
0.109288290143013,
0.511793315410614,
-0.6091907620429993,
1.0191640853881836,
0.6922929883003235,
0.07083987444639206,
-0.343430757522583,
-0.7136175632476807,
0.35454902052879333,
0.8261900544166565,
-0.6540148854255676,
-0.17498445510864258,
0.3450486361980438,
0.16159412264823914,
-0.3282000720500946,
0.313954621553421,
-0.023502597585320473,
0.4644269645214081,
0.16020379960536957,
0.13503380119800568,
0.10753429681062698,
-0.4286365211009979,
-0.32458269596099854,
0.1121005043387413,
0.1976710557937622,
-0.445590615272522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06414v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06414v1
|
Can Large Language Models Replicate ITS Feedback on Open-Ended Math Questions?
| 2024-05-10T11:53:53 | 2024-05-10T11:53:53 |
Hunter McNichols, Jaewook Lee, Stephen Fancsali, Steve Ritter, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Intelligent Tutoring Systems (ITSs) often contain an automated feedback
component, which provides a predefined feedback message to students when they
detect a predefined error. To such a feedback component, we often resort to
template-based approaches. These approaches require significant effort from
human experts to detect a limited number of possible student errors and provide
corresponding feedback. This limitation is exemplified in open-ended math
questions, where there can be a large number of different incorrect errors. In
our work, we examine the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to
generate feedback for open-ended math questions, similar to that of an
established ITS that uses a template-based approach. We fine-tune both
open-source and proprietary LLMs on real student responses and corresponding
ITS-provided feedback. We measure the quality of the generated feedback using
text similarity metrics. We find that open-source and proprietary models both
show promise in replicating the feedback they see during training, but do not
generalize well to previously unseen student errors. These results suggest that
despite being able to learn the formatting of feedback, LLMs are not able to
fully understand mathematical errors made by students.
|
[
-0.2596207857131958,
-0.805742084980011,
0.6728209257125854,
0.16383154690265656,
-0.07539394497871399,
-0.0955585390329361,
-0.6645180583000183,
-0.07830546051263809,
0.0641709566116333,
0.5373453497886658,
-0.5544314980506897,
-0.24539092183113098,
-0.3549392521381378,
0.2472413182258606,
-0.5589501261711121,
1.1660090684890747,
-0.2747892737388611,
0.6622985005378723,
-0.5788854360580444,
-0.20665274560451508,
-0.19489456713199615,
-0.6088862419128418,
-0.6248698830604553,
-0.06001373752951622,
0.2918219268321991,
0.398275762796402,
0.625175952911377,
0.48061710596084595,
0.4704993665218353,
0.27550700306892395,
0.07608497887849808,
0.11832240223884583,
-0.4857081174850464,
-0.1875683218240738,
-0.3253817856311798,
-0.7845242023468018,
-0.47524428367614746,
0.07869604229927063,
0.8835727572441101,
1.0746958255767822,
-0.1899414360523224,
0.19262176752090454,
0.3905780613422394,
0.5134132504463196,
-0.41864413022994995,
0.25121548771858215,
-0.4194629490375519,
0.13089033961296082,
0.014612145721912384,
0.16188427805900574,
-0.6632857918739319,
-0.8642027974128723,
0.008482489734888077,
-0.5213068127632141,
-0.008894081227481365,
-0.19423194229602814,
0.40773144364356995,
0.23014132678508759,
-0.05455412715673447,
-0.7032436728477478,
-1.0398143529891968,
0.8562748432159424,
-1.0903812646865845,
0.19778357446193695,
0.2261272668838501,
0.4085369408130646,
-0.1651427298784256,
-0.27267876267433167,
-0.6668534278869629,
-0.3223521411418915,
-0.028080610558390617,
0.24491535127162933,
-0.11802935600280762,
-0.17648881673812866,
0.35459470748901367,
0.2697836756706238,
-0.21934588253498077,
0.318083792924881,
-0.5967766642570496,
0.010479746386408806,
0.4364893436431885,
0.32357078790664673,
0.22265876829624176,
0.07141957432031631,
0.05211073160171509,
-0.14937666058540344,
-0.6407052278518677,
0.224570170044899,
0.5210809707641602,
0.33210694789886475,
0.042414795607328415,
0.8841724991798401,
0.17321088910102844,
0.9057919383049011,
-0.24108843505382538,
-0.18714016675949097,
-0.139825239777565,
-0.15485094487667084,
-0.01496568601578474,
-0.25069621205329895,
0.755165159702301,
0.2859317362308502,
0.6961480379104614,
-0.12072191387414932,
-0.5832945704460144,
0.10978353768587112,
0.1824961155653,
-0.6208998560905457,
-0.06139834225177765,
0.16793112456798553,
-0.070400170981884,
-0.14357927441596985,
0.4010014832019806,
-0.7674514055252075,
-0.24456000328063965,
-0.6277858018875122,
0.4999310076236725,
-0.4077785313129425,
-0.07835347950458527,
0.24893997609615326,
0.23491224646568298,
-0.07052740454673767,
0.8097273707389832,
-0.5742588043212891,
0.4908892512321472,
0.7090189456939697,
0.7856062650680542,
-0.1936560869216919,
-0.27656394243240356,
-0.610448956489563,
-0.2693488299846649,
-0.5329790115356445,
0.7819530963897705,
-0.520856499671936,
-0.3337821960449219,
-0.032544445246458054,
-0.32829219102859497,
-0.10731548070907593,
-0.6789084672927856,
0.03422277048230171,
-0.5295526385307312,
0.5154295563697815,
-0.21727833151817322,
-0.7656728625297546,
0.019626742228865623,
0.3066192865371704,
-0.4340357780456543,
0.5724887251853943,
0.277843177318573,
-0.7157130241394043,
-0.10843285173177719,
-0.44936758279800415,
0.13192705810070038,
-0.15002159774303436,
-0.23080553114414215,
-0.4064730405807495,
0.42154955863952637,
0.13681472837924957,
0.11943332105875015,
-0.4421928822994232,
0.29320186376571655,
-0.49081337451934814,
-0.33423569798469543,
0.5756177306175232,
-0.40555357933044434,
0.6287561058998108,
-0.06911326199769974,
-0.27064624428749084,
0.22868214547634125,
-0.90538489818573,
0.2910870909690857,
0.11197318136692047,
-0.40846821665763855,
-0.3517104685306549,
-0.18330487608909607,
-0.3410482704639435,
0.017092451453208923,
0.08537191897630692,
-0.708607017993927,
0.4287172853946686,
-0.15379230678081512,
0.22662770748138428,
1.172602653503418,
-0.2839010953903198,
0.28280940651893616,
-0.5195251107215881,
0.8407776355743408,
0.07753252238035202,
-0.1377464234828949,
-0.46158942580223083,
-0.29662278294563293,
-0.8639246821403503,
-0.2085474282503128,
0.3651692271232605,
0.4070689380168915,
-0.470084011554718,
0.2061118483543396,
-0.39121749997138977,
-0.5149970650672913,
-0.4928380250930786,
0.3082265853881836,
0.4011167883872986,
0.5532547235488892,
0.14502982795238495,
-0.2973032593727112,
-0.34699007868766785,
-0.550644040107727,
-0.2427159994840622,
0.03513413667678833,
-0.2547246515750885,
0.4453362822532654,
0.5677919387817383,
0.06289500743150711,
1.0491498708724976,
-0.40013062953948975,
-0.29480645060539246,
0.05249737575650215,
-0.1775212436914444,
0.21620109677314758,
0.20574478805065155,
0.5679800510406494,
-0.0936589390039444,
-0.5502496361732483,
-0.2397812008857727,
-0.828545331954956,
-0.19719412922859192,
0.012104034423828125,
0.23880907893180847,
0.11274059861898422,
0.38932177424430847,
-0.2909414768218994,
0.27099767327308655,
0.5308428406715393,
-0.31461286544799805,
0.7891534566879272,
-0.2403840869665146,
-0.2371339201927185,
-1.0632470846176147,
0.01519406121224165,
-0.042978186160326004,
0.04595477133989334,
-0.29865244030952454,
-0.0011146144242957234,
0.09382517635822296,
-0.11355005949735641,
-0.17768335342407227,
0.7372145652770996,
-0.19637160003185272,
-0.2713615298271179,
-0.15505501627922058,
0.15929383039474487,
-0.27977848052978516,
0.46275222301483154,
-0.241658017039299,
0.8019324541091919,
0.34692370891571045,
-0.42667582631111145,
0.4351743161678314,
0.11933574080467224,
-0.3553522825241089,
1.00635826587677,
-0.922089159488678,
0.1994783580303192,
-0.32313743233680725,
0.378926545381546,
-0.973838746547699,
-0.2850833237171173,
0.035247910767793655,
-0.5946547985076904,
0.01496275793761015,
-0.13146822154521942,
-0.6437920928001404,
-0.4502839148044586,
-0.3241329491138458,
0.33469176292419434,
0.5565083026885986,
-0.6333194375038147,
0.4036949872970581,
-0.16960060596466064,
-0.4097755551338196,
-0.589043378829956,
-0.2885446846485138,
-0.260330468416214,
0.29997721314430237,
-0.5383287072181702,
-0.46719297766685486,
-0.4058339297771454,
-0.5254225134849548,
0.21827107667922974,
0.10258179157972336,
0.028860334306955338,
0.00073724560206756,
0.22213250398635864,
0.42536160349845886,
-0.5090064406394958,
0.2105908989906311,
-0.22637659311294556,
0.05971783772110939,
0.265529602766037,
-0.7345544695854187,
0.5070161819458008,
-0.24823351204395294,
-0.8590292930603027,
-0.3263397514820099,
0.31247034668922424,
0.9553655982017517,
-0.4238799512386322,
0.6575069427490234,
-0.011204026639461517,
-0.44613370299339294,
-0.3452848494052887,
-0.4961692690849304,
-0.4013510048389435,
-0.42026060819625854,
0.2533058822154999,
-0.12188849598169327,
-0.9207994341850281,
0.7309601902961731,
0.1698279231786728,
0.39233455061912537,
0.3399342894554138,
0.7073585391044617,
-0.15997368097305298,
1.2741644382476807,
0.5387094020843506,
0.03836170956492424,
0.2447703778743744,
-0.4033817946910858,
0.06942980736494064,
-0.6305417418479919,
-0.27012941241264343,
-0.7731139659881592,
-0.11948196589946747,
-0.08247126638889313,
-0.21148785948753357,
0.4000338912010193,
0.14676699042320251,
-0.2620895504951477,
-0.06608272343873978,
-0.17947323620319366,
0.48286381363868713,
0.7052111625671387,
-0.014629377983510494,
0.33782243728637695,
0.21268126368522644,
-0.4509690999984741,
-0.3690169155597687,
-0.5861769914627075,
-0.4580956995487213,
1.0937618017196655,
0.33913174271583557,
1.1242679357528687,
0.13896045088768005,
0.4832516610622406,
-0.2721285820007324,
0.8222207427024841,
-0.8046033978462219,
0.42396506667137146,
-0.12239163368940353,
-0.1270054429769516,
-0.3632502257823944,
-0.7173286080360413,
-0.6192574501037598,
0.0042664967477321625,
-0.04591884836554527,
-0.7143579721450806,
-0.384242445230484,
0.11205704510211945,
-0.22398442029953003,
0.8837960362434387,
-0.3663230836391449,
0.4533103108406067,
-0.0827835202217102,
-0.32694095373153687,
0.08923915028572083,
-0.07250794768333435,
0.3291477859020233,
-0.39400771260261536,
0.46914124488830566,
0.34384626150131226,
0.36099380254745483,
0.9387547969818115,
-0.8844004273414612,
0.9331318736076355,
-0.09413917362689972,
-0.6033667325973511,
0.4408752918243408,
0.3861149549484253,
0.2482994645833969,
0.08360481262207031,
-0.07334885746240616,
-0.21358439326286316,
-0.19575120508670807,
-0.3250822126865387,
-1.1130717992782593,
0.7744224667549133,
-1.0796219110488892,
-0.7187296748161316,
-0.15522712469100952,
-0.5390166640281677,
-0.20661354064941406,
0.25191250443458557,
0.09240718185901642,
0.8378323316574097,
0.3455848693847656,
0.21707163751125336,
0.59544438123703,
-0.04099515825510025,
0.24061496555805206,
0.7713638544082642,
-0.3745664656162262,
-0.6067777276039124,
0.9069973230361938,
0.3305400311946869,
0.32920628786087036,
-0.11909136176109314,
0.3522323966026306,
-0.1864168643951416,
-0.3972685933113098,
-0.7498980164527893,
0.5905320644378662,
-0.8558667898178101,
-0.3125734329223633,
-0.5509589314460754,
-0.23628206551074982,
-0.2692750096321106,
-0.25354090332984924,
-0.6091400384902954,
-0.421030730009079,
-0.40515172481536865,
-0.09014241397380829,
0.2868795096874237,
1.3029505014419556,
0.01498565636575222,
0.1885404884815216,
-1.0247067213058472,
-0.1904984414577484,
0.37684330344200134,
0.8466881513595581,
0.3969009816646576,
-0.7502226233482361,
-0.18300043046474457,
0.3480052053928375,
-0.10117242485284805,
-0.7212989330291748,
0.176592618227005,
0.01846921071410179,
0.20931527018547058,
0.34682899713516235,
0.06110680475831032,
0.39403194189071655,
-0.5627226233482361,
0.8974184393882751,
0.19387254118919373,
-0.8768033385276794,
0.3771734833717346,
-0.25250738859176636,
0.434239000082016,
0.16484254598617554,
0.5020009875297546,
-0.48414719104766846,
-0.6629666686058044,
-0.3197442293167114,
-0.2833525240421295,
0.707627534866333,
-0.137039452791214,
0.40379467606544495,
-0.011896398849785328,
0.5442947149276733,
0.212409108877182,
0.08672579377889633,
-0.6591534614562988,
0.03692326694726944,
-0.16745929419994354,
-0.40741774439811707,
-0.08271559327840805,
-0.11144015938043594,
-0.2621229588985443,
0.0032286588102579117,
0.34228959679603577,
-0.3628727197647095,
0.18598443269729614,
0.004866699688136578,
0.08197446912527084,
-0.5876815319061279,
0.3437685966491699,
0.8162177801132202,
0.931115448474884,
-0.013032694347202778,
-0.03491927683353424,
-0.01212639082223177,
-0.3470826745033264,
0.19567619264125824,
-0.16458949446678162,
-0.30440545082092285,
0.04655963554978371,
0.428622841835022,
0.5723188519477844,
0.08014865219593048,
-0.8866354823112488,
0.7026138305664062,
-0.2167537659406662,
-0.2911601960659027,
-0.611657440662384,
0.007139424327760935,
-0.10998629778623581,
0.034419767558574677,
0.32272565364837646,
-0.036820363253355026,
-0.4116687476634979,
-0.6079451441764832,
0.17819111049175262,
0.6024654507637024,
-0.4972323179244995,
-0.642153799533844,
0.6762203574180603,
-0.11567842960357666,
-0.6484060883522034,
0.916664719581604,
0.26858532428741455,
-0.7820587754249573,
0.6605625152587891,
0.7616577744483948,
0.5531385540962219,
-0.19183050096035004,
0.05878099054098129,
0.4117482304573059,
-0.000861179200001061,
-0.19768546521663666,
0.38822782039642334,
0.19775359332561493,
-0.4902699887752533,
-0.5809292793273926,
-0.4862947463989258,
-0.8179649114608765,
0.011666899546980858,
-0.8898282647132874,
0.4274808466434479,
-0.8783405423164368,
0.13222791254520416,
-0.11687995493412018,
-0.399689257144928,
-0.6094749569892883,
0.21834412217140198,
-0.24631904065608978,
0.8550398945808411,
-0.5733903050422668,
0.39075732231140137,
1.0435011386871338,
-0.4401296377182007,
-0.9651128649711609,
-0.2591268718242645,
-0.08350023627281189,
-0.6682641506195068,
0.7243176698684692,
0.08429273217916489,
0.032214969396591187,
-0.09332982450723648,
-0.6878645420074463,
-0.7730742692947388,
0.679561197757721,
0.3779076933860779,
-0.4147656559944153,
-0.3262702226638794,
0.3231152594089508,
0.8417747616767883,
-0.26100316643714905,
0.6851950287818909,
-0.07635282725095749,
0.0883510485291481,
0.11764750629663467,
-1.2223423719406128,
-0.11402300000190735,
-0.23708771169185638,
-0.19713319838047028,
0.15900351107120514,
-0.6432273983955383,
1.1299805641174316,
-0.49874377250671387,
0.07959651201963425,
0.17025013267993927,
0.5929443836212158,
0.14755643904209137,
0.10237087309360504,
0.42606282234191895,
0.8263324499130249,
0.5817777514457703,
0.0013426457298919559,
1.133795976638794,
-0.28363531827926636,
0.46033158898353577,
1.1448185443878174,
-0.06595078110694885,
0.9144980311393738,
0.3163062036037445,
-0.2828626334667206,
0.4202803671360016,
0.21751947700977325,
-0.07794954627752304,
0.07265787571668625,
0.6369903683662415,
-0.004733098670840263,
-0.14429301023483276,
0.041543811559677124,
-0.31193602085113525,
0.2711247205734253,
0.4675711393356323,
-0.23576365411281586,
-0.37932267785072327,
0.16640600562095642,
0.0015412208158522844,
0.34604889154434204,
-0.3291705250740051,
0.8650506138801575,
0.11643645167350769,
-0.9182454347610474,
0.5416409969329834,
-0.01930336095392704,
0.6158908605575562,
-0.6539384722709656,
-0.19170799851417542,
-0.4623153805732727,
0.4999334514141083,
-0.15104927122592926,
-0.7500554919242859,
0.1623217910528183,
0.12558935582637787,
-0.1898157000541687,
0.07164792716503143,
0.012942863628268242,
-0.3781304359436035,
-0.5007741451263428,
0.006764867343008518,
0.5416601300239563,
-0.13203656673431396,
0.16712109744548798,
-0.1908111870288849,
0.023531226441264153,
0.02701384387910366,
-0.055879849940538406,
0.37487173080444336,
0.24228055775165558,
-0.06328713893890381,
0.9124259352684021,
0.7002356052398682,
0.11570426821708679,
0.2106659710407257,
-0.0892864465713501,
0.8598085045814514,
-0.39266112446784973,
-0.46040794253349304,
-0.8281029462814331,
0.37083500623703003,
0.1352105289697647,
-0.34240829944610596,
0.8571484088897705,
0.287886381149292,
1.2351874113082886,
-0.27387186884880066,
0.8897770643234253,
0.5567247271537781,
0.8199636340141296,
-0.4910520911216736,
0.30120131373405457,
-0.4960663616657257,
0.5035869479179382,
-0.3190051317214966,
-1.2094990015029907,
-0.29181087017059326,
0.5113587975502014,
-0.21947266161441803,
0.0915684625506401,
0.5508603453636169,
0.4809342920780182,
-0.21558651328086853,
0.24067634344100952,
0.14951717853546143,
0.28388723731040955,
0.5347129702568054,
0.4810139238834381,
0.9684900641441345,
-0.03302977606654167,
0.6297943592071533,
-0.16357728838920593,
-0.3528675436973572,
-0.23322167992591858,
-0.3542693853378296,
-1.0545532703399658,
-0.3825390338897705,
-0.3013184368610382,
-0.7993229031562805,
-0.06711634248495102,
1.0893200635910034,
0.17256243526935577,
-1.0160577297210693,
-0.20945826172828674,
0.017374694347381592,
-0.04945182427763939,
0.23208418488502502,
-0.25706779956817627,
0.5152152180671692,
-0.30221423506736755,
-0.828984260559082,
-0.09263592958450317,
0.1797076016664505,
0.348148375749588,
-0.7179876565933228,
0.1356957107782364,
0.6342402696609497,
0.27844542264938354,
0.3400181233882904,
0.18525618314743042,
-0.7428897619247437,
-0.4332265555858612,
0.612459659576416,
-0.1925317645072937,
-0.14895384013652802,
1.0845602750778198,
-0.5805601477622986,
0.6367343068122864,
0.3311604857444763,
0.914140522480011,
-0.10722404718399048,
-0.26493459939956665,
0.8300801515579224,
-0.4946707487106323,
-0.17551928758621216,
0.29235467314720154,
0.5112448334693909,
0.3347504436969757,
-0.08452587574720383,
0.2909483015537262,
0.28822827339172363,
-0.40346285700798035,
-0.9362183809280396,
0.15186730027198792,
-0.48392561078071594,
-0.02630186267197132,
1.1481194496154785,
-0.656686007976532,
-0.15952090919017792,
0.3910582363605499,
-0.29640305042266846,
-0.16338208317756653,
-0.1818668693304062,
0.7986918091773987,
0.8908557295799255,
0.08341461420059204,
-0.16478511691093445,
-0.359271764755249,
0.09220536053180695,
0.6736174821853638,
-0.6200478672981262,
0.02589240111410618,
0.5040236711502075,
0.439220666885376,
0.3535005748271942,
0.46368423104286194,
-0.20612135529518127,
0.4586106836795807,
-0.166711688041687,
-0.31069502234458923,
-0.11285000294446945,
-0.3224886655807495,
-0.5894436240196228,
0.19214846193790436,
0.2598765194416046,
0.2816006541252136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06410v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06410v1
|
Potential and Limitations of LLMs in Capturing Structured Semantics: A Case Study on SRL
| 2024-05-10T11:44:05 | 2024-05-10T11:44:05 |
Ning Cheng, Zhaohui Yan, Ziming Wang, Zhijie Li, Jiaming Yu, Zilong Zheng, Kewei Tu, Jinan Xu, Wenjuan Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) play a crucial role in capturing structured
semantics to enhance language understanding, improve interpretability, and
reduce bias. Nevertheless, an ongoing controversy exists over the extent to
which LLMs can grasp structured semantics. To assess this, we propose using
Semantic Role Labeling (SRL) as a fundamental task to explore LLMs' ability to
extract structured semantics. In our assessment, we employ the prompting
approach, which leads to the creation of our few-shot SRL parser, called
PromptSRL. PromptSRL enables LLMs to map natural languages to explicit semantic
structures, which provides an interpretable window into the properties of LLMs.
We find interesting potential: LLMs can indeed capture semantic structures, and
scaling-up doesn't always mirror potential. Additionally, limitations of LLMs
are observed in C-arguments, etc. Lastly, we are surprised to discover that
significant overlap in the errors is made by both LLMs and untrained humans,
accounting for almost 30% of all errors.
|
[
-0.18790805339813232,
-0.6308878660202026,
0.7527583837509155,
0.2282138466835022,
-0.19434809684753418,
-0.19975441694259644,
-0.17847763001918793,
-0.5351192355155945,
-0.09720335900783539,
0.4410945475101471,
-0.6667913198471069,
-0.5002856850624084,
-0.7537851333618164,
0.6050268411636353,
-0.28913599252700806,
0.874707043170929,
0.015614477917551994,
0.13679662346839905,
-0.3511463403701782,
0.12214888632297516,
-0.4380641579627991,
-0.40667226910591125,
-0.6971964240074158,
-0.26947900652885437,
0.7766560316085815,
0.4681824743747711,
0.5915436744689941,
0.6196170449256897,
0.3944033682346344,
0.24075226485729218,
-0.36202895641326904,
0.020452115684747696,
-0.17811113595962524,
0.325188547372818,
-0.08633282035589218,
-0.4483983814716339,
-0.3620608448982239,
0.16673587262630463,
1.1347987651824951,
0.9634078145027161,
0.012904352508485317,
0.12335959076881409,
0.07996194809675217,
0.5024041533470154,
-0.451717734336853,
0.12673522531986237,
-0.6075631976127625,
0.23971343040466309,
-0.4676567316055298,
-0.24412623047828674,
-0.6131612658500671,
0.012815034948289394,
0.08681879937648773,
-0.4467405378818512,
0.06995762139558792,
0.08202044665813446,
0.7256922125816345,
0.4181528389453888,
-0.5194990038871765,
-0.35596004128456116,
-0.49979639053344727,
0.7991837859153748,
-0.8270065784454346,
0.4302717447280884,
0.26092246174812317,
0.2736666202545166,
-0.4912889003753662,
-0.7791520357131958,
-0.4807051718235016,
-0.6333026885986328,
-0.2612944543361664,
0.05005877465009689,
0.12528109550476074,
0.19548970460891724,
0.7027963399887085,
0.014863449148833752,
-0.4210309684276581,
0.38196125626564026,
-0.21015125513076782,
-0.2949957847595215,
0.4228211045265198,
0.37021270394325256,
0.4904469847679138,
-0.5630978345870972,
-0.6428549885749817,
0.2333153635263443,
-0.8415142297744751,
0.28149279952049255,
0.22441720962524414,
0.6584538221359253,
0.07436969876289368,
0.7343910932540894,
0.035968247801065445,
0.8630296587944031,
-0.4232890009880066,
-0.09751582145690918,
-0.25266939401626587,
-0.24793793261051178,
-0.16428561508655548,
0.15049441158771515,
0.5729391574859619,
0.16501262784004211,
0.3393750488758087,
0.05577227473258972,
-0.10154382139444351,
-0.016659054905176163,
0.16922271251678467,
-0.6043289303779602,
0.16446587443351746,
0.21541492640972137,
-0.3930923342704773,
-0.061690181493759155,
0.06709045171737671,
-0.5489370226860046,
-0.2799321115016937,
-0.12971413135528564,
-0.021887334063649178,
-0.07660196721553802,
0.06070519611239433,
0.031942229717969894,
-0.29332607984542847,
0.6762468218803406,
0.38274526596069336,
-0.7400122284889221,
0.32220786809921265,
0.6758559942245483,
0.7006176114082336,
-0.2724657356739044,
-0.182196244597435,
-0.6517811417579651,
0.2870487868785858,
-0.324623167514801,
0.9113809466362,
-0.49255162477493286,
-0.52213054895401,
0.022992009297013283,
-0.05059065297245979,
-0.06278564780950546,
-0.3519841134548187,
0.6296225786209106,
-0.6303761601448059,
0.01102368999272585,
-0.29877811670303345,
-0.6729341745376587,
0.391860693693161,
0.5204683542251587,
-0.6620457172393799,
0.9733607172966003,
-0.08269518613815308,
-0.7452216744422913,
0.42413783073425293,
-0.3720880448818207,
-0.30210500955581665,
0.31986671686172485,
-0.5449742078781128,
-0.05562085658311844,
0.08652879297733307,
-0.16869960725307465,
0.28586408495903015,
-0.11593548953533173,
0.3122349977493286,
-0.1073845624923706,
-0.2817141115665436,
0.5772101283073425,
-0.29055503010749817,
0.6776449680328369,
0.0863708034157753,
0.1117197722196579,
0.21082639694213867,
-0.6879824995994568,
0.004534911829978228,
-0.03398844599723816,
-0.6894479393959045,
-0.34759023785591125,
0.20599135756492615,
-0.19941282272338867,
0.42350876331329346,
0.30161798000335693,
-0.4127372205257416,
0.3603605031967163,
-0.3719289004802704,
0.460288941860199,
0.8304839134216309,
-0.15801674127578735,
0.4740283191204071,
0.12432754784822464,
0.7248241305351257,
-0.05920550227165222,
-0.01723192073404789,
-0.13483624160289764,
-0.3013141453266144,
-0.5231732130050659,
-0.3514976501464844,
0.5092467069625854,
0.519369900226593,
-0.514853298664093,
0.3338281512260437,
-0.052640002220869064,
0.035602688789367676,
-0.29259976744651794,
0.21204908192157745,
0.3930263817310333,
0.7774989604949951,
0.28996869921684265,
-0.14232683181762695,
-0.6514185070991516,
-1.0790789127349854,
-0.31783992052078247,
-0.23983699083328247,
-0.11860667914152145,
0.25241485238075256,
0.4288329780101776,
-0.12926067411899567,
1.328192114830017,
-0.3397892713546753,
-0.4866299629211426,
-0.6039132475852966,
-0.14556939899921417,
0.13843047618865967,
0.31148454546928406,
0.09182059019804001,
-0.6368230581283569,
-0.15936599671840668,
-0.42632853984832764,
-0.8282393217086792,
-0.542165994644165,
-0.06849699467420578,
-0.02644304186105728,
0.1366284191608429,
0.8235522508621216,
-1.0486730337142944,
0.34526365995407104,
0.28635093569755554,
-0.4025270640850067,
0.5958601832389832,
-0.162007138133049,
-0.3411336839199066,
-0.9040644764900208,
-0.054174669086933136,
0.0521497018635273,
-0.3144022524356842,
-0.6306994557380676,
-0.14839334785938263,
0.09570286422967911,
-0.11223123222589493,
-0.6862787008285522,
0.6310971975326538,
-0.584551990032196,
-0.4174532890319824,
-0.3210316598415375,
0.5062733292579651,
-0.060255758464336395,
0.09269816428422928,
0.2510869801044464,
0.6190661787986755,
0.31187671422958374,
-0.591010570526123,
0.03649467974901199,
0.41429275274276733,
-0.1882791668176651,
0.4070734977722168,
-0.6975117325782776,
-0.12516245245933533,
-0.2639877498149872,
0.6009174585342407,
-1.1004464626312256,
-0.2985244393348694,
0.3063053488731384,
-0.28047749400138855,
0.4179789423942566,
-0.33643844723701477,
-0.44885843992233276,
-0.16809695959091187,
-0.30808165669441223,
0.16455970704555511,
0.3420465588569641,
-0.20628562569618225,
0.5870174765586853,
0.30635085701942444,
-0.042505115270614624,
-0.602031409740448,
-0.7412287592887878,
0.2986984848976135,
-0.2050299346446991,
-0.5947715044021606,
0.32321566343307495,
0.11866679787635803,
-0.4042819142341614,
0.17713090777397156,
-0.37401282787323,
0.17267990112304688,
0.26513394713401794,
0.21567444503307343,
0.5238282084465027,
-0.2623935043811798,
0.12190712988376617,
-0.11588046699762344,
-0.4902867078781128,
0.1717243492603302,
-0.07483290135860443,
0.24668104946613312,
-0.14719094336032867,
-0.4165567457675934,
-0.5194482207298279,
0.4705718755722046,
0.24217265844345093,
0.0454312302172184,
0.6925625205039978,
0.1497839242219925,
-0.33024853467941284,
-0.3579857349395752,
-0.276047945022583,
-0.09003312885761261,
-0.4294741749763489,
0.19679519534111023,
-0.3637624979019165,
-1.0749202966690063,
0.42465001344680786,
-0.11939853429794312,
-0.021750470623373985,
0.4551260471343994,
0.2823871970176697,
-0.2135927975177765,
0.9722859859466553,
0.584994375705719,
0.25425317883491516,
0.2587150037288666,
0.0514354407787323,
0.04952114820480347,
-1.0025169849395752,
-0.29984545707702637,
-0.7336555123329163,
-0.21295660734176636,
-0.50657057762146,
-0.17611315846443176,
0.23124845325946808,
0.27299821376800537,
0.0804467424750328,
0.21493668854236603,
-0.2731499671936035,
0.44154611229896545,
0.37091246247291565,
-0.2982928454875946,
0.41291776299476624,
-0.24680159986019135,
-0.016080709174275398,
-0.32339149713516235,
-0.7341210246086121,
-0.996921718120575,
0.28537502884864807,
0.45948755741119385,
1.022175669670105,
0.09656387567520142,
0.6037893295288086,
0.18405184149742126,
0.1683046668767929,
-1.0562725067138672,
0.9437979459762573,
0.014219704084098339,
-0.39067137241363525,
-0.3351443409919739,
-0.3639316260814667,
-0.9784437417984009,
0.41452550888061523,
-0.05457676574587822,
-0.48675018548965454,
0.021233929321169853,
0.10510727018117905,
-0.27042341232299805,
-0.09038089960813522,
-0.551665186882019,
1.0151170492172241,
-0.22833044826984406,
-0.1582542359828949,
0.21329541504383087,
-1.0644891262054443,
0.35247910022735596,
0.228482186794281,
0.22083145380020142,
-0.21340470016002655,
-0.3376367390155792,
0.8170543909072876,
-0.36477717757225037,
1.2468273639678955,
-0.14859656989574432,
-0.34717226028442383,
0.2818344831466675,
0.12787486612796783,
0.3834061622619629,
0.0008111559436656535,
0.054171398282051086,
0.05873905122280121,
0.04607072472572327,
-0.34014615416526794,
-0.5775373578071594,
0.5132397413253784,
-0.5316153168678284,
-0.7663581371307373,
-0.7364222407341003,
-0.5480272173881531,
-0.3487384617328644,
0.15591520071029663,
0.09920217841863632,
0.3975963294506073,
-0.0998246893286705,
0.07123301178216934,
0.5537018179893494,
-0.0942939817905426,
0.45989763736724854,
0.6414588093757629,
0.03040327876806259,
0.07826574146747589,
0.3910423815250397,
0.2444717288017273,
0.33985570073127747,
0.19614548981189728,
0.31063026189804077,
-0.44337546825408936,
-0.6484711170196533,
-0.3645475208759308,
0.26640841364860535,
-0.9301890134811401,
-0.193632110953331,
-0.6457619071006775,
-0.34534841775894165,
-0.3817393183708191,
-0.22756129503250122,
-0.10664002597332001,
-0.46725034713745117,
-0.44483697414398193,
-0.1926356852054596,
0.12057989835739136,
0.7153688073158264,
0.10553092509508133,
0.21942642331123352,
-0.89485102891922,
0.13612492382526398,
0.2560065686702728,
0.09765703231096268,
-0.17595912516117096,
-0.5376290678977966,
0.14132793247699738,
-0.40178194642066956,
0.1077151671051979,
-0.9813648462295532,
0.18662585318088531,
0.10568498820066452,
0.8409324288368225,
0.10836873948574066,
0.08659476786851883,
0.8177376985549927,
-0.7327038645744324,
1.0632892847061157,
-0.0130173210054636,
-0.9368134140968323,
0.8158453106880188,
-0.057566769421100616,
0.3074430823326111,
0.4972809851169586,
0.42116349935531616,
-0.6698781251907349,
-0.5737162828445435,
-0.42089858651161194,
-0.8207800984382629,
0.8304129242897034,
-0.07596968114376068,
0.05503934249281883,
-0.4029688537120819,
0.4395284950733185,
-0.14502528309822083,
-0.012921060435473919,
-0.8572583198547363,
0.08420682698488235,
0.16454535722732544,
-0.21885550022125244,
0.2165926843881607,
-0.7498859167098999,
-0.1558254212141037,
0.11370880901813507,
0.40152987837791443,
-0.0752997025847435,
-0.17398704588413239,
0.5330280661582947,
-0.37419232726097107,
0.07545273005962372,
0.6405335068702698,
0.6503497362136841,
0.5865529775619507,
0.11992676556110382,
0.7792730331420898,
0.2725766897201538,
-0.19180859625339508,
-0.0032410346902906895,
-0.14440464973449707,
-0.24599872529506683,
-0.0807853639125824,
0.7928864359855652,
0.47876104712486267,
0.5587722659111023,
-0.9766266942024231,
0.38765814900398254,
0.10298295319080353,
0.08882348984479904,
-0.4160943925380707,
-0.057444989681243896,
0.144672229886055,
0.32680562138557434,
0.28893375396728516,
-0.31824755668640137,
-0.06634623557329178,
-0.5388368368148804,
0.27852073311805725,
0.691107988357544,
-0.4432143568992615,
-0.22679486870765686,
0.41935354471206665,
0.05350250005722046,
-0.40313369035720825,
0.5545783042907715,
-0.04669899493455887,
-0.5351287126541138,
0.5414397120475769,
0.8230295777320862,
0.5582029819488525,
-0.1895410716533661,
0.10261552035808563,
0.10618966817855835,
0.36664602160453796,
-0.07146104425191879,
-0.06971300393342972,
-0.13438749313354492,
-0.8564835786819458,
-0.666793167591095,
-0.6540767550468445,
-0.5266014933586121,
-0.22143250703811646,
-0.5795018672943115,
0.2667069733142853,
-0.3947482407093048,
-0.02895713970065117,
-0.21691256761550903,
-0.06634586304426193,
-0.16623616218566895,
-0.22535434365272522,
0.12473905086517334,
1.2729560136795044,
-0.8772304654121399,
0.795136034488678,
0.5934043526649475,
-0.393567830324173,
-0.8853910565376282,
-0.13858690857887268,
0.12215593457221985,
-0.6974462866783142,
1.3523353338241577,
0.2544720470905304,
-0.3182762563228607,
0.04353183135390282,
-0.7236688137054443,
-0.4573824107646942,
0.9748304486274719,
0.2615980803966522,
-0.33156618475914,
-0.22984178364276886,
0.1439397931098938,
0.5399409532546997,
-0.46892938017845154,
0.018922043964266777,
0.5852932333946228,
0.5241428017616272,
0.3977672755718231,
-0.6765024065971375,
0.16820040345191956,
0.059786491096019745,
0.27132537961006165,
0.007370808161795139,
-0.21413414180278778,
0.756648063659668,
-0.19200529158115387,
-0.5103785395622253,
-0.06855496764183044,
0.6745218634605408,
0.5259661674499512,
0.21988743543624878,
0.42021074891090393,
0.3631959855556488,
0.6010227799415588,
0.1087140217423439,
1.1582297086715698,
0.1467348337173462,
0.23529930412769318,
1.1105400323867798,
-0.6856796741485596,
0.9168201088905334,
0.6188154220581055,
-0.08405239135026932,
0.3978361487388611,
0.6585096120834351,
0.16571283340454102,
0.22808842360973358,
0.17113280296325684,
-0.4120534062385559,
-0.5950470566749573,
-0.42320623993873596,
-0.1637604683637619,
0.29781386256217957,
0.49014291167259216,
-0.14404845237731934,
-0.6016646027565002,
-0.08628437668085098,
-0.14924633502960205,
0.035853996872901917,
-0.2514057755470276,
0.7346599698066711,
0.4544873833656311,
-0.4459356665611267,
0.0011887358268722892,
-0.0545886792242527,
0.4971870481967926,
-0.8605372309684753,
-0.18838006258010864,
-0.05163830891251564,
-0.11608443409204483,
-0.3018781840801239,
-1.011661171913147,
0.4209994673728943,
0.08449441939592361,
-0.04358832165598869,
-0.6201301217079163,
1.1211165189743042,
-0.4674852192401886,
-0.20837852358818054,
0.3790969252586365,
0.548655092716217,
0.2774110734462738,
0.39872875809669495,
-0.4608663022518158,
0.38518643379211426,
-0.4355390965938568,
-0.3297880291938782,
0.3778552711009979,
0.38502249121665955,
-0.19825667142868042,
0.6354913711547852,
0.5306220054626465,
0.2473507672548294,
0.23341113328933716,
0.06506995856761932,
0.6618950366973877,
-0.9688321948051453,
-0.31062886118888855,
-1.1053723096847534,
0.5300326347351074,
-0.013553804717957973,
-0.11279264837503433,
0.9120837450027466,
0.4048214554786682,
0.6479397416114807,
0.005633131600916386,
0.4778454899787903,
-0.05662098899483681,
0.20831549167633057,
-0.8649941682815552,
0.1284778118133545,
-0.2691240906715393,
0.4499148726463318,
0.013424639590084553,
-0.7085012197494507,
-0.623149573802948,
0.758662223815918,
-0.3472251892089844,
-0.17612701654434204,
0.6776611804962158,
0.6512495279312134,
0.1472070813179016,
-0.1273341178894043,
0.4155389964580536,
0.2025635838508606,
0.3837863504886627,
0.4687155783176422,
1.2664015293121338,
0.07692275941371918,
0.5656298995018005,
0.37079259753227234,
-0.2597905695438385,
-0.17771226167678833,
-1.1709492206573486,
-0.8092350363731384,
-0.3231366276741028,
-0.28822532296180725,
-0.44643715023994446,
-0.19155414402484894,
0.9954600930213928,
0.4404207766056061,
-0.5393853187561035,
-0.11334463208913803,
-0.03783959522843361,
0.438182532787323,
0.22682277858257294,
-0.257721483707428,
0.16140300035476685,
-0.6516596674919128,
-0.6224897503852844,
0.6885783076286316,
0.44569477438926697,
0.07330386340618134,
-0.36889567971229553,
0.046615466475486755,
-0.24587197601795197,
-0.007241536397486925,
0.8590388894081116,
0.36790287494659424,
-0.9664793610572815,
-0.5752255320549011,
0.02156294696033001,
-0.4708475172519684,
-0.06799416244029999,
1.0658283233642578,
-0.7464759349822998,
0.015177146531641483,
0.6172139048576355,
0.675269603729248,
0.19315767288208008,
0.029459979385137558,
0.36202719807624817,
-0.9600086808204651,
0.08598048239946365,
0.13286513090133667,
0.47420835494995117,
0.2571876049041748,
-0.1878831386566162,
0.4092099666595459,
0.31587427854537964,
-0.3764764368534088,
-0.8531245589256287,
0.5912019610404968,
-1.3792415857315063,
-0.37273919582366943,
1.2981178760528564,
0.04000909626483917,
-0.2772125005722046,
-0.24265243113040924,
-0.22002749145030975,
0.12468857318162918,
-0.12025195360183716,
0.21323637664318085,
0.8336141109466553,
-0.3499048948287964,
-0.2164074331521988,
-0.8594497442245483,
0.5170645713806152,
0.23375874757766724,
-0.6873931884765625,
0.13038496673107147,
0.7976511716842651,
0.39606785774230957,
0.11969310790300369,
0.8980687260627747,
-0.19909590482711792,
-0.003340147202834487,
-0.18704339861869812,
-0.18460942804813385,
-0.08435103297233582,
-0.431691437959671,
-0.6366698145866394,
0.2180939018726349,
0.4233086109161377,
-0.01920083910226822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06373v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06373v3
|
LLM Discussion: Enhancing the Creativity of Large Language Models via Discussion Framework and Role-Play
| 2024-05-10T10:19:14 | 2024-05-18T16:33:46 |
Li-Chun Lu, Shou-Jen Chen, Tsung-Min Pai, Chan-Hung Yu, Hung-yi Lee, Shao-Hua Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown exceptional proficiency in natural
language processing but often fall short of generating creative and original
responses to open-ended questions. To enhance LLM creativity, our key insight
is to emulate the human process of inducing collective creativity through
engaging discussions with participants from diverse backgrounds and
perspectives. To this end, we propose LLM Discussion, a three-phase discussion
framework that facilitates vigorous and diverging idea exchanges and ensures
convergence to creative answers. Moreover, we adopt a role-playing technique by
assigning distinct roles to LLMs to combat the homogeneity of LLMs. We evaluate
the efficacy of the proposed framework with the Alternative Uses Test,
Similarities Test, Instances Test, and Scientific Creativity Test through both
LLM evaluation and human study. Our proposed framework outperforms single-LLM
approaches and existing multi-LLM frameworks across various creativity metrics.
|
[
-0.7932721972465515,
-1.0105842351913452,
0.5989121794700623,
0.5607105493545532,
-0.41842955350875854,
0.260015606880188,
-0.4301688075065613,
-0.46902453899383545,
0.2614426910877228,
0.5230167508125305,
-0.4901072382926941,
-0.46057814359664917,
-0.32250386476516724,
0.20475807785987854,
-0.2817404866218567,
0.6631646156311035,
-0.0926496610045433,
0.11131688952445984,
-0.38169237971305847,
-0.03671198710799217,
-0.42471182346343994,
-0.2791424095630646,
-0.7152078747749329,
-0.4513906240463257,
0.9993321895599365,
0.5977380275726318,
0.4763062000274658,
0.3861280083656311,
0.369340717792511,
0.3760276138782501,
-0.27463847398757935,
0.13747917115688324,
-0.5846048593521118,
0.3882606625556946,
-0.32531318068504333,
-0.5041329264640808,
-0.47617998719215393,
-0.026002949103713036,
0.6997250914573669,
0.782802939414978,
-0.25443437695503235,
0.003218800760805607,
0.2501709759235382,
0.5104545950889587,
-0.26189494132995605,
0.07445187866687775,
-0.6760036945343018,
0.15913771092891693,
-0.2712547779083252,
-0.2784035801887512,
-0.16503620147705078,
-0.366454154253006,
0.08621237426996231,
-0.3038313090801239,
0.07721303403377533,
-0.18479518592357635,
0.29283997416496277,
-0.007081459742039442,
-0.2501322627067566,
-0.22333361208438873,
-0.9059674143791199,
0.5810788869857788,
-0.8775392770767212,
-0.05112244561314583,
0.04282527044415474,
0.08470514416694641,
-0.2246035933494568,
-0.5387693643569946,
-0.8454646468162537,
0.04923689737915993,
0.4549551010131836,
0.13632002472877502,
0.03844718262553215,
-0.09905855357646942,
0.01633715257048607,
0.5676287412643433,
-0.35568004846572876,
0.3990246653556824,
-0.13114795088768005,
0.17275480926036835,
0.6866117119789124,
0.3973162770271301,
0.021921634674072266,
0.15154466032981873,
-0.10554023832082748,
0.3141520023345947,
-0.5994601249694824,
0.03385342285037041,
0.5178331732749939,
0.11900210380554199,
0.04555584862828255,
0.6322581768035889,
-0.2809889614582062,
0.5410143733024597,
-0.025161156430840492,
-0.10514669120311737,
0.011084186844527721,
-0.3772071599960327,
-0.12279155850410461,
-0.37152138352394104,
0.6852176785469055,
0.664135217666626,
-0.09518187493085861,
-0.15992343425750732,
-0.1313706636428833,
-0.20267215371131897,
0.28183597326278687,
-0.9128287434577942,
0.1781661957502365,
0.07873807102441788,
-0.3650871217250824,
-0.37634384632110596,
0.17274685204029083,
-1.0474830865859985,
-0.6372389793395996,
-0.2986380159854889,
0.1502438187599182,
0.1655815839767456,
-0.3761341869831085,
0.2928868532180786,
-0.24280773103237152,
0.09287738054990768,
0.6195273399353027,
-0.8628259897232056,
0.4052153527736664,
0.791290819644928,
0.646852970123291,
-0.3279239237308502,
-0.2275649607181549,
-0.05310317501425743,
0.2587064504623413,
-0.42253315448760986,
0.8158007860183716,
-0.4167884588241577,
-0.5496044754981995,
-0.06477013230323792,
-0.3018149733543396,
0.2121145874261856,
-0.6267952919006348,
0.514577329158783,
-0.3690180480480194,
0.5761857628822327,
-0.3554514944553375,
-0.5072195529937744,
-0.16348634660243988,
0.5850333571434021,
-0.6784660816192627,
0.6047815680503845,
-0.157637819647789,
-0.7552450299263,
0.26893460750579834,
-0.9006772637367249,
-0.37786221504211426,
0.5010785460472107,
-0.42705172300338745,
-0.15288786590099335,
0.15748123824596405,
0.15402652323246002,
0.47647571563720703,
-0.6747641563415527,
0.4107953906059265,
-0.37697288393974304,
-0.41511380672454834,
0.5915040969848633,
-0.4147487282752991,
0.3462403416633606,
0.16922160983085632,
-0.39120781421661377,
0.43020668625831604,
-0.4749017059803009,
0.15103337168693542,
0.17359542846679688,
-0.5520681142807007,
-0.000017764568838174455,
-0.12244313210248947,
0.07549440860748291,
0.2534719705581665,
0.13148561120033264,
-0.4418330788612366,
0.332032173871994,
-0.7244920134544373,
0.4103966951370239,
0.7280893921852112,
0.16283577680587769,
0.6223074793815613,
-0.831912636756897,
0.6375919580459595,
-0.21218065917491913,
0.13999661803245544,
-0.008168519474565983,
-0.675944447517395,
-0.9115608930587769,
-0.1787462830543518,
-0.1365421861410141,
0.3415181338787079,
-0.5292748808860779,
0.4591886103153229,
-0.08338046818971634,
-0.7503302693367004,
-0.48473837971687317,
0.538665771484375,
0.014418469741940498,
0.2096310555934906,
0.1469016671180725,
-0.49909764528274536,
-0.6367394924163818,
-0.7703092694282532,
-0.2696492373943329,
-0.14213505387306213,
-0.14941047132015228,
0.2591925859451294,
0.27689775824546814,
-0.12994086742401123,
1.0707489252090454,
-0.2016027867794037,
-0.1453315019607544,
-0.6666549444198608,
0.3870242238044739,
0.18793120980262756,
0.3045923709869385,
0.28810667991638184,
-0.6616523861885071,
-0.5323663353919983,
-0.30002766847610474,
-0.6685346961021423,
-0.22255569696426392,
-0.14037254452705383,
-0.20365381240844727,
0.2966339886188507,
0.4140545129776001,
-0.680477499961853,
0.3330921232700348,
0.5250232219696045,
-0.21058683097362518,
0.31110405921936035,
0.19473718106746674,
0.18261873722076416,
-1.2267906665802002,
0.06114775314927101,
-0.2794581949710846,
0.09556570649147034,
-0.46411460638046265,
0.06724810600280762,
-0.5108124017715454,
-0.08249334990978241,
-0.3801769018173218,
0.6666135191917419,
-0.23469142615795135,
0.29300692677497864,
-0.4520169794559479,
0.3686891794204712,
0.024070298299193382,
0.21805936098098755,
0.037204042077064514,
0.5138235688209534,
0.456613153219223,
-0.4027703106403351,
0.4522019326686859,
0.06601346284151077,
-0.40257975459098816,
0.48650062084198,
-0.6982637643814087,
0.24456115067005157,
-0.12472265958786011,
0.41791749000549316,
-0.9711532592773438,
-0.21055138111114502,
0.1207098588347435,
-0.03585981950163841,
0.09602492302656174,
0.12196701765060425,
-0.6866030097007751,
-0.5025662779808044,
-0.6100165843963623,
0.38449937105178833,
0.3597741723060608,
-0.2641063332557678,
0.5229703783988953,
0.4366343319416046,
-0.7112590074539185,
-0.32770052552223206,
-0.6915320754051208,
0.34695854783058167,
-0.6326166987419128,
-1.0182018280029297,
0.5070637464523315,
-0.6272537708282471,
-0.4245312213897705,
-0.05706700682640076,
0.00318063679151237,
0.18569518625736237,
0.28310033679008484,
0.1841561496257782,
0.22281454503536224,
-0.2900219261646271,
0.11588826030492783,
-0.3115895390510559,
0.30128130316734314,
-0.0024601579643785954,
-0.007085752673447132,
0.961031436920166,
-0.337879478931427,
-0.4263061583042145,
-0.1551004946231842,
0.5572234392166138,
0.41939830780029297,
0.04154350236058235,
0.5756609439849854,
0.4830925762653351,
-0.1985335797071457,
-0.32107627391815186,
-0.8853418827056885,
0.003060125047340989,
-0.5225856900215149,
0.33785736560821533,
-0.015110241249203682,
-1.5623615980148315,
0.6111190319061279,
0.03681153431534767,
0.27308329939842224,
0.1963035613298416,
1.0150296688079834,
-0.044403549283742905,
0.6931024789810181,
0.7168400287628174,
0.31411364674568176,
0.43054091930389404,
-0.048532310873270035,
0.5403647422790527,
-0.851539671421051,
-0.25238338112831116,
-0.22187156975269318,
-0.4551234841346741,
-0.15867136418819427,
-0.8090343475341797,
0.11875221878290176,
0.3537171185016632,
-0.008775582537055016,
-0.03551292046904564,
-0.1658971756696701,
0.6571403741836548,
0.1382049322128296,
-0.2565978765487671,
0.235684335231781,
-0.15424273908138275,
-0.34292110800743103,
-0.12391266971826553,
-0.6997023224830627,
-0.9110804796218872,
0.8198674917221069,
0.49509862065315247,
0.7920048236846924,
0.37529096007347107,
0.8143083453178406,
-0.08218962699174881,
0.655982494354248,
-0.8251452445983887,
0.8280813097953796,
0.2773173451423645,
-0.5235863327980042,
-0.6368127465248108,
-0.449825644493103,
-0.815461277961731,
0.43462783098220825,
-0.2117260992527008,
-0.6942999362945557,
-0.2345792055130005,
-0.09986516833305359,
-0.2921847105026245,
0.4553673267364502,
-0.22049187123775482,
0.8201098442077637,
-0.19036376476287842,
-0.6369192004203796,
-0.27673569321632385,
-0.2757270038127899,
0.5791584253311157,
-0.18581853806972504,
0.4379914104938507,
0.036000870168209076,
0.0891931802034378,
0.7793442010879517,
0.05491636320948601,
0.8386615514755249,
0.16538619995117188,
-0.5532237887382507,
0.546602725982666,
0.1131075769662857,
-0.00852836575359106,
0.3773929476737976,
-0.07428953796625137,
-0.0890384390950203,
-0.6040939092636108,
-0.09055972844362259,
-0.6887006163597107,
0.8058834671974182,
-0.45133984088897705,
-1.1826952695846558,
-0.1002119705080986,
-0.7737008929252625,
-0.32222065329551697,
0.050583615899086,
0.006876119878143072,
0.050164446234703064,
-0.5828295350074768,
0.4648810625076294,
0.37141504883766174,
-0.19624751806259155,
0.5989515781402588,
0.3995327651500702,
-0.4809177815914154,
-0.5188487768173218,
0.46250680088996887,
-0.0646694153547287,
0.4455958306789398,
-0.025313718244433403,
0.32685497403144836,
-0.09697811305522919,
-0.5120809078216553,
0.013890036381781101,
0.16894365847110748,
-0.9543125629425049,
-0.18072828650474548,
-0.699856698513031,
-0.1348608434200287,
-0.5225567817687988,
-0.23778711259365082,
-0.22561918199062347,
-0.6509785652160645,
-0.3088591694831848,
-0.06379205733537674,
0.117919921875,
0.8627966046333313,
-0.11817479878664017,
0.23018944263458252,
-0.7328687906265259,
0.041529931128025055,
0.6426271200180054,
0.332123726606369,
0.4461669921875,
-0.4461396038532257,
-0.20016202330589294,
-0.006295692175626755,
-0.7512193322181702,
-0.4922151565551758,
0.26606491208076477,
-0.07423506677150726,
0.8358209729194641,
0.38338181376457214,
-0.38435810804367065,
0.6462200284004211,
-0.4653506577014923,
1.2286187410354614,
0.3778396546840668,
-0.9200496673583984,
0.3927370011806488,
-0.36664584279060364,
0.34272047877311707,
0.4056110680103302,
0.15373671054840088,
-0.7606115937232971,
-0.6522343158721924,
-0.5638970732688904,
-0.9855384230613708,
0.409959077835083,
0.14662118256092072,
0.24157655239105225,
-0.052522312849760056,
-0.0623844712972641,
0.10838637501001358,
0.36050862073898315,
-0.9246496558189392,
0.13250209391117096,
0.011381800286471844,
0.03532092273235321,
-0.08233894407749176,
-0.2730559706687927,
-0.6200239658355713,
-0.33413010835647583,
0.4537712335586548,
-0.09616944193840027,
0.10188353806734085,
-0.037292636930942535,
0.3035958409309387,
-0.5209124088287354,
0.7409453392028809,
0.7520911693572998,
0.7857041954994202,
0.2063145637512207,
0.4062051475048065,
0.23431546986103058,
-0.0970480814576149,
0.06590081006288528,
-0.01153527945280075,
0.0768585279583931,
-0.41807591915130615,
0.34369415044784546,
0.5181176662445068,
0.11200013756752014,
-0.5912545919418335,
0.3071669638156891,
-0.3229747712612152,
-0.40746358036994934,
-0.09232697635889053,
0.30743229389190674,
0.8324459791183472,
0.504702091217041,
0.1364670842885971,
0.04826372116804123,
-0.09143321216106415,
-0.8983100056648254,
0.2153645157814026,
0.3250671625137329,
-0.14616501331329346,
0.06747960299253464,
0.419360876083374,
0.34644749760627747,
-0.5945965647697449,
0.1326383352279663,
-0.17149825394153595,
-0.6991413831710815,
0.6419447064399719,
0.6504987478256226,
0.8016215562820435,
-0.16481032967567444,
0.2432366907596588,
-0.16761983931064606,
0.21256546676158905,
-0.34163540601730347,
0.4936623275279999,
-0.006106078624725342,
-0.930610716342926,
-0.4899592697620392,
-0.5451528429985046,
-0.3867303431034088,
0.21556678414344788,
-0.2660050094127655,
0.3185517191886902,
-0.613180935382843,
-0.1832432746887207,
-0.26500892639160156,
0.0950033962726593,
-0.42025840282440186,
-0.2901192605495453,
0.3167860507965088,
0.705993115901947,
-0.5724177360534668,
0.5537912249565125,
0.4879978597164154,
-0.43096959590911865,
-0.588808000087738,
0.18335457146167755,
-0.07748217135667801,
-0.18154436349868774,
0.6526939272880554,
0.30585411190986633,
-0.1976126879453659,
-0.15475793182849884,
-0.7733372449874878,
-0.6757104992866516,
1.1523836851119995,
0.16863705217838287,
-0.4826242923736572,
0.23528718948364258,
0.24265632033348083,
0.7290637493133545,
-0.7464165687561035,
-0.03076215833425522,
0.0896780788898468,
0.43122661113739014,
0.5779856443405151,
-1.0082175731658936,
-0.02393624559044838,
-0.4609282314777374,
0.06227521598339081,
-0.2586462199687958,
-0.6826823949813843,
0.9079872965812683,
-0.31281039118766785,
-0.16367977857589722,
0.44970786571502686,
0.6910240650177002,
0.661034345626831,
0.2883734107017517,
0.6071633100509644,
0.4697577953338623,
0.6253596544265747,
0.19645456969738007,
0.6102137565612793,
-0.07455722242593765,
0.25783243775367737,
1.0888381004333496,
-0.8203577995300293,
0.746504545211792,
0.6948400735855103,
0.21820779144763947,
0.39441174268722534,
0.33126720786094666,
-0.07894802838563919,
0.28376299142837524,
0.8137056231498718,
-0.45672905445098877,
-0.2898833751678467,
-0.20138004422187805,
-0.2968473732471466,
0.25233858823776245,
0.1924915313720703,
-0.14877024292945862,
-0.08551598340272903,
-0.008119795471429825,
0.01508235838264227,
0.5139347910881042,
-0.05721702426671982,
0.6798040866851807,
0.2295188456773758,
-0.6588941812515259,
0.29880207777023315,
0.128467857837677,
0.908867359161377,
-0.36528125405311584,
-0.18387861549854279,
-0.199836865067482,
-0.029347209259867668,
-0.13635851442813873,
-1.0415561199188232,
0.21696406602859497,
0.06603045761585236,
-0.0786333829164505,
-0.5307731628417969,
0.46002882719039917,
-0.744548499584198,
-0.3405456244945526,
0.3617679178714752,
0.5856107473373413,
-0.0403595007956028,
0.20767316222190857,
-0.5244839191436768,
0.2788316011428833,
-0.29807570576667786,
-0.2307635247707367,
0.20464147627353668,
0.7410241961479187,
0.08347734808921814,
0.6793675422668457,
0.5429866909980774,
0.23191013932228088,
-0.11968353390693665,
0.5073674917221069,
1.1240017414093018,
-0.5124414563179016,
-0.6149978041648865,
-0.8439063429832458,
0.5753535628318787,
-0.45751136541366577,
-0.2226770967245102,
0.6966906189918518,
0.5659943222999573,
0.8778191208839417,
-0.07731064409017563,
0.7033976912498474,
0.01695256680250168,
0.3881942629814148,
-0.47825127840042114,
0.8498680591583252,
-0.4176437258720398,
0.6621639132499695,
-0.5114725232124329,
-1.0595437288284302,
-0.47786903381347656,
0.9114077687263489,
-0.06255987286567688,
0.09474874287843704,
0.7622476816177368,
0.733703076839447,
0.11778490990400314,
0.4600812494754791,
0.2701761722564697,
0.252666711807251,
0.6269742250442505,
0.479461133480072,
1.4428918361663818,
0.05493646487593651,
0.2493508905172348,
-0.0605938620865345,
-0.2758403718471527,
0.0961584821343422,
-1.0676164627075195,
-1.2357678413391113,
-0.32994940876960754,
-0.18498514592647552,
-0.13548560440540314,
-0.4509858191013336,
1.2529265880584717,
0.3837929666042328,
-0.3259977698326111,
-0.7646101117134094,
-0.15579494833946228,
0.0970693975687027,
0.0709301307797432,
-0.2784070074558258,
-0.21810640394687653,
-0.12406449019908905,
-0.5993242263793945,
0.48650485277175903,
0.4484592080116272,
-0.026813488453626633,
-0.6525831818580627,
-0.052283138036727905,
-0.14574503898620605,
0.3368232250213623,
0.7527110576629639,
-0.05533237382769585,
-0.9098010063171387,
-0.15239451825618744,
-0.03830702602863312,
-0.05108269304037094,
-0.028911760076880455,
1.085316777229309,
-0.32308346033096313,
0.29174041748046875,
0.49511775374412537,
0.6432251930236816,
0.3200780749320984,
-0.09304609149694443,
0.7241876125335693,
-0.4797194302082062,
0.342133104801178,
0.5494915843009949,
0.1945829540491104,
0.4957059919834137,
-0.26243460178375244,
0.3266804814338684,
0.34092167019844055,
-0.6320884227752686,
-0.740668773651123,
0.4692693054676056,
-1.0011327266693115,
-0.3451237380504608,
1.154984474182129,
-0.082602359354496,
0.06027719005942345,
-0.01120267529040575,
-0.3705557882785797,
0.21006304025650024,
-0.3209242522716522,
1.0074564218521118,
1.03818678855896,
-0.22601325809955597,
-0.1934249848127365,
-0.28069719672203064,
0.3297101855278015,
0.2673584818840027,
-0.9705016613006592,
0.14995619654655457,
0.2434929460287094,
0.18344908952713013,
0.15580110251903534,
0.7771382927894592,
-0.41042396426200867,
-0.11662986874580383,
-0.47394299507141113,
0.04225795343518257,
0.09805579483509064,
-0.39420682191848755,
-0.25421085953712463,
0.38883641362190247,
0.3536214828491211,
0.5785781741142273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06346v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06346v1
|
Akal Badi ya Bias: An Exploratory Study of Gender Bias in Hindi Language Technology
| 2024-05-10T09:26:12 | 2024-05-10T09:26:12 |
Rishav Hada, Safiya Husain, Varun Gumma, Harshita Diddee, Aditya Yadavalli, Agrima Seth, Nidhi Kulkarni, Ujwal Gadiraju, Aditya Vashistha, Vivek Seshadri, Kalika Bali
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing research in measuring and mitigating gender bias predominantly
centers on English, overlooking the intricate challenges posed by non-English
languages and the Global South. This paper presents the first comprehensive
study delving into the nuanced landscape of gender bias in Hindi, the third
most spoken language globally. Our study employs diverse mining techniques,
computational models, field studies and sheds light on the limitations of
current methodologies. Given the challenges faced with mining gender biased
statements in Hindi using existing methods, we conducted field studies to
bootstrap the collection of such sentences. Through field studies involving
rural and low-income community women, we uncover diverse perceptions of gender
bias, underscoring the necessity for context-specific approaches. This paper
advocates for a community-centric research design, amplifying voices often
marginalized in previous studies. Our findings not only contribute to the
understanding of gender bias in Hindi but also establish a foundation for
further exploration of Indic languages. By exploring the intricacies of this
understudied context, we call for thoughtful engagement with gender bias,
promoting inclusivity and equity in linguistic and cultural contexts beyond the
Global North.
|
[
-0.16654755175113678,
-0.6763788461685181,
0.025899576023221016,
0.15039131045341492,
0.015035453252494335,
0.04000303894281387,
-0.11262597143650055,
-0.6107192039489746,
0.10582339763641357,
0.262376993894577,
-0.7169896960258484,
-0.20009317994117737,
-0.6207927465438843,
0.29136353731155396,
-0.5080985426902771,
0.7464307546615601,
0.38964414596557617,
0.5687528252601624,
0.3845345377922058,
-0.353370726108551,
-1.0174438953399658,
-0.37410226464271545,
-0.32082393765449524,
-0.37111252546310425,
-0.06572839617729187,
0.6593896150588989,
0.4908579885959625,
0.280746191740036,
0.24985642731189728,
0.20179010927677155,
-0.19977599382400513,
0.16938434541225433,
-0.38303622603416443,
0.26185959577560425,
-0.22388412058353424,
-0.8180110454559326,
0.015120048075914383,
0.21530993282794952,
0.4514743387699127,
0.6857837438583374,
-0.26951032876968384,
0.4407684803009033,
0.049088023602962494,
0.8000497817993164,
-0.9011456370353699,
0.04867175221443176,
-0.6449975371360779,
0.10595596581697464,
-0.7094427943229675,
0.14728456735610962,
-0.10412460565567017,
-0.6689978837966919,
0.020320847630500793,
-0.2268802970647812,
0.4223358929157257,
0.1066315695643425,
0.8175859451293945,
0.050683192908763885,
-0.4072872996330261,
-0.27783480286598206,
-0.8770394325256348,
0.9876670837402344,
-0.6506760716438293,
0.47136178612709045,
0.5136013627052307,
0.32327473163604736,
0.18348516523838043,
0.10159935057163239,
-0.8548264503479004,
0.18618153035640717,
-0.08901292830705643,
-0.13477790355682373,
-0.16162267327308655,
-0.5820309519767761,
0.008865888230502605,
0.3881418704986572,
-0.23242320120334625,
-0.014166857115924358,
-0.619908332824707,
0.18407012522220612,
0.2285015732049942,
-0.09705641865730286,
0.8321441411972046,
-0.3006282150745392,
-0.1433417797088623,
-0.020286813378334045,
-1.1404402256011963,
-0.12361354380846024,
0.88878333568573,
0.6653133630752563,
-0.17832636833190918,
0.697306752204895,
0.05909564346075058,
0.7255066633224487,
0.2443114072084427,
-0.038467951118946075,
0.21327844262123108,
-0.49816077947616577,
-0.08089713007211685,
0.304633229970932,
0.7352993488311768,
0.3718266189098358,
0.23748114705085754,
0.0680365040898323,
0.23231053352355957,
0.03938905522227287,
0.13072098791599274,
-0.16903550922870636,
0.2665366530418396,
-0.214324951171875,
-0.40938442945480347,
-0.24922813475131989,
-0.04774167761206627,
-1.27048659324646,
-0.8235173225402832,
0.08313696086406708,
-0.08217035233974457,
-0.29745128750801086,
-0.7005540132522583,
-0.13816656172275543,
-0.1065167561173439,
0.6830635666847229,
-0.1769329309463501,
-1.1239441633224487,
0.07519722729921341,
0.5766420960426331,
0.743300199508667,
0.4025667607784271,
-0.325810045003891,
-0.21474285423755646,
0.22528083622455597,
-0.49594810605049133,
0.7702995538711548,
-0.8537380695343018,
-0.6605642437934875,
0.08274062722921371,
-0.4307684898376465,
0.06397420912981033,
-0.5552065968513489,
0.5951387286186218,
-0.2775649428367615,
0.09430421143770218,
-0.5304103493690491,
0.18845604360103607,
0.11323797702789307,
-0.01622580923140049,
-0.46928974986076355,
1.065913200378418,
0.03284403309226036,
-1.0350137948989868,
0.9776338934898376,
-0.7495226860046387,
-0.5411497354507446,
-0.02788521535694599,
-0.6135544776916504,
-0.18469181656837463,
0.10714279860258102,
0.28429388999938965,
0.03763246908783913,
-0.5439896583557129,
0.42000165581703186,
-0.09622637927532196,
-0.3128725588321686,
0.003265372244641185,
-0.1200636625289917,
0.808300793170929,
0.3348366320133209,
-0.7132829427719116,
-0.09848491847515106,
-0.5612202286720276,
-0.16640737652778625,
0.08756522089242935,
0.26480236649513245,
-0.7229111194610596,
-0.14169979095458984,
0.2008936107158661,
0.1622803658246994,
-0.23462627828121185,
-1.0523289442062378,
0.07813069969415665,
-0.8487647175788879,
0.6220124363899231,
0.8054229617118835,
-0.5810368657112122,
0.745964765548706,
0.10620158165693283,
0.34009358286857605,
-0.17186997830867767,
0.10213373601436615,
0.2055208832025528,
-0.2925041615962982,
-0.5195204615592957,
0.10024116933345795,
0.24486950039863586,
0.28422096371650696,
-0.48909857869148254,
0.033020056784152985,
-0.10862109810113907,
-0.3146103024482727,
-1.129859447479248,
0.26374784111976624,
0.4955849349498749,
0.4322925806045532,
0.08673973381519318,
-0.07507992535829544,
-0.7811759114265442,
-1.4450339078903198,
-0.5114539861679077,
-0.3015401363372803,
0.2970333397388458,
0.11367681622505188,
0.20559537410736084,
-0.10325715690851212,
1.1699074506759644,
-0.6788780689239502,
-0.8096367716789246,
-0.7306420207023621,
0.2152606099843979,
0.030904695391654968,
0.3160404562950134,
0.3242807984352112,
-1.0169728994369507,
-0.5011838674545288,
0.019306674599647522,
-0.8454528450965881,
-0.5663052797317505,
0.43604665994644165,
-0.32753488421440125,
0.25403791666030884,
0.5111130475997925,
-0.5881483554840088,
0.5497674345970154,
0.45956721901893616,
-0.6522062420845032,
0.2023492455482483,
0.3681153357028961,
0.24974721670150757,
-0.8393228650093079,
0.17648433148860931,
0.171113058924675,
0.04573623836040497,
-0.5727221965789795,
0.4546211361885071,
-0.18258506059646606,
0.02021167054772377,
-0.3406054973602295,
0.7265467047691345,
-0.5103417634963989,
0.13885392248630524,
-0.4800722301006317,
-0.13761703670024872,
-0.2533402442932129,
-0.1150360107421875,
-0.10383433103561401,
1.097627878189087,
0.38452038168907166,
-0.4634542167186737,
-0.25850024819374084,
0.47628286480903625,
-0.1310543715953827,
0.774412214756012,
-0.5690078735351562,
0.11026216298341751,
-0.31197303533554077,
0.19016145169734955,
-0.7137064933776855,
-0.2108869105577469,
0.4254812002182007,
-0.638613224029541,
0.36858442425727844,
-0.19103586673736572,
-0.5202756524085999,
-0.26431143283843994,
-0.21010367572307587,
0.48073452711105347,
0.25647708773612976,
-0.46939581632614136,
0.347366064786911,
0.894710123538971,
0.18086901307106018,
-0.7250927090644836,
-1.0703811645507812,
0.08773818612098694,
-0.44630154967308044,
-0.3633885681629181,
-0.2890094816684723,
0.05225294828414917,
-0.7965709567070007,
-0.4438555836677551,
-0.2567845284938812,
-0.16506804525852203,
-0.18986666202545166,
0.36056122183799744,
0.1328645795583725,
0.06651610136032104,
-0.14276988804340363,
-0.01008068211376667,
-0.07150223106145859,
-0.11180320382118225,
-0.005324436351656914,
0.7037259340286255,
-0.2068871557712555,
-0.21996186673641205,
-0.17127534747123718,
0.8522676825523376,
0.31614407896995544,
0.06869811564683914,
0.8066961765289307,
0.745079755783081,
-0.4217628836631775,
0.007807526271790266,
-0.9618929028511047,
0.13114146888256073,
-0.42944610118865967,
0.12318748235702515,
-0.27710220217704773,
-0.7172729969024658,
0.24991843104362488,
0.2604938745498657,
-0.24885952472686768,
0.6053547859191895,
0.34687095880508423,
0.0882125124335289,
0.8946054577827454,
1.2111477851867676,
-0.5877101421356201,
-0.06243583559989929,
0.0439385324716568,
0.7890141010284424,
-0.8996995091438293,
-0.20429573953151703,
-0.7707244157791138,
-0.04673605412244797,
-0.7015896439552307,
-0.0765458419919014,
0.2828425467014313,
0.0015524962218478322,
-0.23841159045696259,
-0.00363164278678596,
-0.6382809281349182,
0.51399165391922,
0.6431547999382019,
0.06328297406435013,
0.28915247321128845,
-0.3999766707420349,
0.2864309251308441,
-0.3518121838569641,
-0.41750356554985046,
-0.5190975666046143,
1.0505427122116089,
0.07655816525220871,
0.47709017992019653,
0.5503246784210205,
0.3625818192958832,
0.5828807353973389,
0.36471936106681824,
-0.052040524780750275,
0.4440619647502899,
-0.10415121912956238,
-1.1569167375564575,
-0.24989262223243713,
-0.10554265230894089,
-0.8498626351356506,
0.059978220611810684,
0.16886189579963684,
-0.8006579279899597,
0.25271525979042053,
0.09099554270505905,
-0.12382891774177551,
0.516707718372345,
-1.0081734657287598,
0.3459599018096924,
0.28397074341773987,
-0.5065827965736389,
0.07619982957839966,
-0.7027407288551331,
0.852747917175293,
0.05026639997959137,
0.6520891785621643,
0.11737877875566483,
0.19669055938720703,
0.5209011435508728,
-0.48414573073387146,
0.9977840781211853,
-0.23085343837738037,
-0.1720087230205536,
0.3534667491912842,
0.049246449023485184,
0.08702044934034348,
0.05214676633477211,
-0.14498646557331085,
0.35092273354530334,
-0.2573852241039276,
-0.5450966954231262,
-0.09971436858177185,
1.0416481494903564,
-0.8596962094306946,
-0.6029124855995178,
-0.731702983379364,
-0.2588081955909729,
-0.3465058505535126,
0.20936480164527893,
0.25770413875579834,
0.0464688315987587,
-0.07827682793140411,
-0.3549593985080719,
0.6922473311424255,
-0.3188658654689789,
0.3598859906196594,
0.28452757000923157,
-0.2735801637172699,
0.3721049427986145,
0.6671140789985657,
0.025874337181448936,
0.0048592584207654,
0.1509411633014679,
0.3353411853313446,
-0.14776605367660522,
-0.28472012281417847,
-0.729833722114563,
0.018669549375772476,
-0.719512939453125,
-0.15169315040111542,
-0.6867946982383728,
-0.1580088883638382,
-0.5330973267555237,
-0.09741099178791046,
-0.6358402967453003,
0.008747899904847145,
0.19468970596790314,
-0.2719724178314209,
0.2130623757839203,
1.165231466293335,
-0.1683698147535324,
0.47523877024650574,
-0.26672008633613586,
0.44185951352119446,
0.13831870257854462,
0.45047488808631897,
0.12851080298423767,
-0.20154552161693573,
0.15961596369743347,
-0.045960161834955215,
-0.13711319863796234,
-0.8404375910758972,
0.6005715131759644,
-0.045075368136167526,
0.3064890503883362,
0.052249372005462646,
-0.2831389605998993,
0.5633080005645752,
-0.27126508951187134,
1.0852924585342407,
0.2601686716079712,
-0.9391210675239563,
0.922731876373291,
-0.5142267942428589,
0.4217721223831177,
0.8432234525680542,
0.25753164291381836,
-0.4271269738674164,
-0.32021525502204895,
-0.3651474118232727,
-1.2845991849899292,
0.8325563073158264,
0.16997061669826508,
0.3768753409385681,
-0.3576236665248871,
0.30711129307746887,
0.7479265928268433,
0.3078024685382843,
-1.0887863636016846,
-0.7554935216903687,
-0.1607845425605774,
0.09624607115983963,
0.17024631798267365,
-0.27485042810440063,
0.07154650241136551,
-0.1654059737920761,
0.6904850602149963,
0.09552831202745438,
0.3275171220302582,
0.3463965356349945,
-0.24362517893314362,
-0.2231440395116806,
0.5801107883453369,
0.44962257146835327,
0.7335659265518188,
-0.14396479725837708,
0.01325888093560934,
0.196822389960289,
-0.9601336121559143,
0.16983912885189056,
-0.1763981133699417,
-0.7086707353591919,
-0.03329216316342354,
0.1290276050567627,
0.42761683464050293,
-0.13175110518932343,
-0.5184386372566223,
0.41581761837005615,
-0.024249039590358734,
0.33271077275276184,
-0.5250927209854126,
-0.1582537740468979,
-0.15496018528938293,
0.0741233080625534,
0.7496800422668457,
0.2853910028934479,
0.438975989818573,
-0.903294563293457,
-0.46590933203697205,
0.5183937549591064,
-0.7310267686843872,
-0.17762549221515656,
0.7930160164833069,
0.17444129288196564,
-0.11791858077049255,
0.3734911382198334,
-0.2800878584384918,
-0.5497580766677856,
0.22999869287014008,
0.4362415671348572,
0.898118257522583,
-0.3035750985145569,
0.12842251360416412,
0.5652535557746887,
0.5111335515975952,
-0.023202350363135338,
0.23241570591926575,
0.28870683908462524,
-0.4370116889476776,
-0.3723008632659912,
-0.706697404384613,
0.024862533435225487,
0.16358959674835205,
-0.4605116844177246,
0.4069620966911316,
-0.0930733010172844,
-0.08498349040746689,
-0.27950409054756165,
-0.30941376090049744,
-0.7093909978866577,
0.18182188272476196,
0.2023123949766159,
0.6228225231170654,
-1.0272338390350342,
0.42270225286483765,
0.5189314484596252,
-0.5041395425796509,
-0.6649072170257568,
0.1642029881477356,
0.3644680380821228,
-0.8843523263931274,
1.0269761085510254,
0.04058690369129181,
-0.47279417514801025,
-0.3014909625053406,
-0.5919885039329529,
-0.9727961421012878,
0.7555139660835266,
-0.12349304556846619,
-0.3686763346195221,
0.10866525024175644,
0.28275933861732483,
0.4664933383464813,
-0.24839681386947632,
0.6284761428833008,
0.6998149752616882,
0.5601838827133179,
-0.41762080788612366,
-0.9684790372848511,
-0.08301839977502823,
-0.4519888758659363,
-0.020965753123164177,
0.4553217589855194,
-1.0134830474853516,
0.6078154444694519,
-0.04251016676425934,
-0.11691118776798248,
-0.04011239856481552,
0.7049447298049927,
0.11844378709793091,
0.544419527053833,
0.28354722261428833,
0.29105037450790405,
0.3058077394962311,
-0.1356840878725052,
1.0575987100601196,
0.1395796239376068,
-0.35759440064430237,
1.1855883598327637,
-0.5380228161811829,
0.36769556999206543,
0.701440155506134,
-0.4042341411113739,
0.32584214210510254,
0.18096886575222015,
0.25750336050987244,
0.43121087551116943,
0.4225383996963501,
-0.2058866024017334,
0.2459843009710312,
-0.7233979105949402,
-0.47721049189567566,
0.7088713645935059,
0.1114862784743309,
-0.028630748391151428,
-0.11875057220458984,
0.19453385472297668,
0.3604115843772888,
0.5783856511116028,
-0.3573092520236969,
0.42161765694618225,
0.01594429463148117,
-0.723697304725647,
0.036624372005462646,
0.10682281851768494,
1.1822850704193115,
-0.7676967978477478,
-0.26732882857322693,
-0.3621717393398285,
0.034802939742803574,
-0.2916596233844757,
-0.6158509850502014,
0.6002339124679565,
0.2126741260290146,
-0.3382633924484253,
-0.08897817879915237,
0.9308309555053711,
-0.2546344995498657,
-0.4144325852394104,
0.17906054854393005,
0.7437129020690918,
-0.0911022499203682,
0.057817429304122925,
-0.09695743769407272,
0.3910432755947113,
0.22664731740951538,
0.22734875977039337,
0.6080251336097717,
0.10850460082292557,
-0.23293089866638184,
0.8587805032730103,
0.40104663372039795,
0.30605125427246094,
0.20808875560760498,
0.35638660192489624,
0.5733916163444519,
-0.7980822920799255,
-0.23092448711395264,
-1.058887004852295,
0.21226458251476288,
-0.08518759161233902,
-0.5080211162567139,
1.0856181383132935,
0.5611205101013184,
0.9159078598022461,
0.13888363540172577,
1.149271845817566,
-0.3158015012741089,
0.7825044393539429,
-0.2811643183231354,
0.867993175983429,
-0.2561652660369873,
0.4448109567165375,
-0.5122511386871338,
-0.8995445966720581,
-0.10971904546022415,
0.4604529142379761,
-0.25555601716041565,
0.2939217984676361,
0.48602938652038574,
0.530672550201416,
-0.10138089209794998,
0.5240635871887207,
-0.045071087777614594,
0.41576912999153137,
-0.03935371711850166,
0.0793243795633316,
0.8766653537750244,
-0.5463994741439819,
0.48160645365715027,
-0.16553841531276703,
-0.3282057046890259,
0.2855633795261383,
-0.6588584184646606,
-0.6831960678100586,
-0.534913182258606,
-0.17512930929660797,
-0.12856705486774445,
0.2872273623943329,
0.891788125038147,
0.6406354904174805,
-0.4781041443347931,
-0.4164595603942871,
-0.0799231231212616,
0.1500363051891327,
0.11011948436498642,
-0.31761792302131653,
0.3161115050315857,
-0.029968036338686943,
-0.8359322547912598,
0.33236050605773926,
0.11827332526445389,
-0.5119325518608093,
-0.543005108833313,
0.2627590298652649,
-0.8413324952125549,
-0.10298186540603638,
0.45934319496154785,
0.26550495624542236,
-0.6180331707000732,
-0.07353899627923965,
-0.1278645098209381,
0.02535005658864975,
0.15244802832603455,
0.8494535684585571,
-0.6928232908248901,
0.5712328553199768,
0.17075207829475403,
0.018081173300743103,
0.18462812900543213,
-0.17596596479415894,
0.7846872210502625,
-0.6995015740394592,
-0.03654433414340019,
0.03853101655840874,
0.11028532683849335,
0.7152328491210938,
-0.5897710919380188,
0.796316921710968,
0.07409171015024185,
-0.3326832056045532,
-1.0088982582092285,
0.29870927333831787,
-0.5286679267883301,
-0.3459329307079315,
1.4077816009521484,
0.4050076901912689,
-0.20027127861976624,
-0.39239656925201416,
-0.5122145414352417,
0.41995441913604736,
-0.41960591077804565,
0.8962904214859009,
0.939447820186615,
0.029321273788809776,
-0.08729595690965652,
-1.0870195627212524,
0.3578026592731476,
0.5805536508560181,
-0.3231622278690338,
0.2394888997077942,
0.20789305865764618,
0.1568072885274887,
0.12001698464155197,
0.7815124988555908,
-0.29934120178222656,
-0.032893821597099304,
-0.11591514199972153,
0.3472176194190979,
0.3568648397922516,
-0.002934711752459407,
-0.346203088760376,
-0.0026535457000136375,
0.16141390800476074,
0.11881004273891449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06331v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06331v1
|
LMD3: Language Model Data Density Dependence
| 2024-05-10T09:03:27 | 2024-05-10T09:03:27 |
John Kirchenbauer, Garrett Honke, Gowthami Somepalli, Jonas Geiping, Daphne Ippolito, Katherine Lee, Tom Goldstein, David Andre
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We develop a methodology for analyzing language model task performance at the
individual example level based on training data density estimation. Experiments
with paraphrasing as a controlled intervention on finetuning data demonstrate
that increasing the support in the training distribution for specific test
queries results in a measurable increase in density, which is also a
significant predictor of the performance increase caused by the intervention.
Experiments with pretraining data demonstrate that we can explain a significant
fraction of the variance in model perplexity via density measurements. We
conclude that our framework can provide statistical evidence of the dependence
of a target model's predictions on subsets of its training data, and can more
generally be used to characterize the support (or lack thereof) in the training
data for a given test task.
|
[
-0.4166252911090851,
-0.9433629512786865,
0.6960248947143555,
0.21031586825847626,
0.07359588146209717,
-0.3963877558708191,
0.1611586958169937,
-0.08420446515083313,
0.08957072347402573,
0.8913062810897827,
-0.226691335439682,
-0.5567867159843445,
-0.5652937293052673,
0.034279994666576385,
-0.5948323011398315,
0.6817813515663147,
-0.21513961255550385,
0.2560466527938843,
-0.27871423959732056,
-0.11252590268850327,
-0.4733869433403015,
-0.5564197897911072,
-0.4084789752960205,
-0.11785254627466202,
0.5109208822250366,
0.5493474006652832,
0.8435945510864258,
0.915421724319458,
0.5077939033508301,
0.2589845359325409,
0.16971415281295776,
-0.5321611762046814,
-0.5866894125938416,
0.0870525985956192,
0.053755227476358414,
-0.8885005712509155,
-0.33168143033981323,
0.10489140450954437,
0.9769051671028137,
0.9362949132919312,
-0.40274709463119507,
-0.40392884612083435,
0.12457675486803055,
0.3372693955898285,
-0.6733971238136292,
0.11215600371360779,
-0.5712675452232361,
0.051372505724430084,
-0.5437384247779846,
-0.37350866198539734,
-0.1254882514476776,
-0.004005821887403727,
0.29365724325180054,
-0.3299962282180786,
0.734479546546936,
-0.10593502223491669,
0.4795736074447632,
0.2921432852745056,
-0.18764179944992065,
-0.22309227287769318,
-0.6463403105735779,
0.9978783130645752,
-0.8030169010162354,
0.2923782169818878,
0.9192196130752563,
0.22188115119934082,
0.06291960179805756,
-0.631791889667511,
-0.6304799318313599,
-0.3110754191875458,
0.04254648834466934,
-0.05132918432354927,
0.1998470276594162,
0.2024986296892166,
0.4141902029514313,
0.5969656109809875,
-0.2517338991165161,
0.10969582200050354,
-0.4329625070095062,
-0.058915138244628906,
0.4687979817390442,
0.3335493505001068,
0.48871079087257385,
-0.12812651693820953,
-0.14900650084018707,
0.014804606325924397,
-0.7089723348617554,
-0.12420721352100372,
0.41221436858177185,
0.34341511130332947,
-0.1639581173658371,
0.9255593419075012,
-0.390608549118042,
0.7924948930740356,
-0.2797594666481018,
-0.349292516708374,
0.399294912815094,
-0.2897064685821533,
-0.2820000946521759,
0.01869369111955166,
0.7488783597946167,
0.2687795162200928,
0.12469853460788727,
-0.22960016131401062,
-0.4259765148162842,
-0.1799323558807373,
0.15814997255802155,
-0.7541165947914124,
-0.20884430408477783,
0.23914670944213867,
-0.34915557503700256,
-0.1571771800518036,
0.013266045600175858,
-0.7463977932929993,
-0.7524614334106445,
-0.3072129786014557,
0.389619916677475,
-0.5292924046516418,
-0.6019015312194824,
0.3711395859718323,
-0.14277219772338867,
-0.16569815576076508,
-0.07395587116479874,
-1.264223337173462,
0.6430076360702515,
0.4809090495109558,
1.0110092163085938,
-0.6230219602584839,
-0.7341814041137695,
-0.35779914259910583,
0.3495650887489319,
-0.2651974558830261,
0.7974596619606018,
-0.48433127999305725,
-0.49114790558815,
0.035462457686662674,
0.009149213321506977,
-0.17933274805545807,
-0.8384414315223694,
0.3394150137901306,
-0.09579221159219742,
-0.010131260380148888,
-0.27769961953163147,
-0.8739792108535767,
0.006794574670493603,
-0.08404373377561569,
-1.0862724781036377,
1.0942760705947876,
0.4629440903663635,
-0.9389447569847107,
0.45342913269996643,
-0.4970053434371948,
-0.2686590850353241,
0.003657383844256401,
-0.33445778489112854,
-0.28677600622177124,
0.060992490500211716,
-0.05381743609905243,
0.8004046082496643,
-0.4160749316215515,
0.13354164361953735,
-0.5069913864135742,
-0.5879179239273071,
0.12420821189880371,
-0.2510073184967041,
0.6182705163955688,
-0.00692749721929431,
-0.47710761427879333,
-0.046308375895023346,
-1.2254163026809692,
-0.27066168189048767,
0.06834389269351959,
-0.29538479447364807,
-0.5698816180229187,
0.2872017025947571,
-0.3596423864364624,
-0.09241519868373871,
0.08307888358831406,
-0.4245239496231079,
-0.20420287549495697,
-0.5052700638771057,
0.11640346795320511,
0.45597952604293823,
0.2713690996170044,
0.6432918310165405,
-0.29860061407089233,
0.7811745405197144,
0.16969183087348938,
-0.098063163459301,
0.36722531914711,
-0.3375847339630127,
-0.4561079144477844,
-0.12457343935966492,
0.13784000277519226,
0.4458571672439575,
-0.5874943733215332,
-0.0320795401930809,
-0.08984735608100891,
-0.30341121554374695,
-0.4483761787414551,
0.39079269766807556,
0.1273682564496994,
0.4643515348434448,
0.5372399687767029,
-0.08732080459594727,
-0.7566661238670349,
-1.194738745689392,
-0.014134516008198261,
0.02473902329802513,
-0.07370606809854507,
-0.05176333338022232,
0.41199544072151184,
-0.11949241161346436,
0.944353461265564,
-0.47110244631767273,
-0.14318977296352386,
-0.7066649794578552,
0.03185287117958069,
0.045985009521245956,
0.6576120257377625,
0.6064332723617554,
-0.6174566149711609,
-0.4030860364437103,
-0.24289575219154358,
-0.728757381439209,
-0.2039579451084137,
0.1950109750032425,
-0.1343582570552826,
0.09487239271402359,
0.6156134009361267,
-0.44318974018096924,
0.25450053811073303,
0.6602441668510437,
-0.1727685183286667,
0.60404372215271,
-0.03618946298956871,
-0.12231799215078354,
-0.9655672311782837,
-0.16952656209468842,
0.12673218548297882,
0.16436359286308289,
-0.962881863117218,
-0.2542732059955597,
-0.06010640412569046,
0.2006923258304596,
-0.44779008626937866,
0.3552401065826416,
-0.22919662296772003,
-0.24811331927776337,
-0.09415555745363235,
0.11104186624288559,
-0.27363115549087524,
0.06644944101572037,
0.08824261277914047,
0.8120368719100952,
0.7437940835952759,
-0.7363221049308777,
0.17886365950107574,
0.11551021039485931,
-0.6237441897392273,
0.5821504592895508,
-0.8367232084274292,
-0.16780047118663788,
0.09234978258609772,
-0.3170243501663208,
-1.047361135482788,
-0.2383313924074173,
-0.06773978471755981,
-0.09539192169904709,
-0.11067015677690506,
0.03826653212308884,
-0.6983115077018738,
-0.10544861108064651,
-0.11186066269874573,
0.07291820645332336,
0.20302796363830566,
-0.20929555594921112,
0.4997243881225586,
0.5755770802497864,
-0.04875679314136505,
-0.3966977596282959,
-0.8267947435379028,
-0.3273320496082306,
-0.6791157126426697,
-0.48299285769462585,
0.1971290111541748,
-0.11722663789987564,
-0.6438247561454773,
-0.3731682002544403,
-0.027130937203764915,
-0.3676280975341797,
0.1994016319513321,
0.2764943242073059,
-0.026471925899386406,
-0.22861060500144958,
-0.028523176908493042,
-0.17468860745429993,
0.11483168601989746,
0.45578449964523315,
0.3872990310192108,
0.7249232530593872,
0.3697650134563446,
-0.010634822770953178,
-0.3968660235404968,
0.1982201486825943,
0.29505661129951477,
0.0890161469578743,
0.9563511610031128,
0.397382527589798,
-0.2540043592453003,
-0.2860434651374817,
-0.5527955293655396,
-0.07767324149608612,
-0.49457114934921265,
0.6154102087020874,
-0.7376731038093567,
-0.554334282875061,
0.4635198414325714,
0.47506996989250183,
-0.32244232296943665,
0.4164462983608246,
0.5838518142700195,
-0.054992951452732086,
1.477168321609497,
0.6500570774078369,
0.13002179563045502,
0.5779562592506409,
-0.34256500005722046,
-0.29295042157173157,
-0.6275679469108582,
-0.036457519978284836,
-0.25556477904319763,
-0.1273743361234665,
-0.3420548141002655,
-0.3834512233734131,
0.057229746133089066,
0.3585502803325653,
-0.11104776710271835,
0.10193701088428497,
0.0007871317793615162,
0.44239935278892517,
0.46434518694877625,
0.06827456504106522,
0.02620323747396469,
-0.07470472902059555,
-0.06864133477210999,
-0.10537923127412796,
-0.5675824284553528,
-0.21322600543498993,
1.3672665357589722,
0.41321495175361633,
0.6291525363922119,
0.07425019890069962,
0.6658838987350464,
0.06288473308086395,
0.06933396309614182,
-0.44253769516944885,
0.7246576547622681,
0.0211455300450325,
-0.4966466724872589,
-0.4281406104564667,
-0.5485899448394775,
-1.0586886405944824,
-0.0032194035593420267,
0.050140876322984695,
-0.6321017742156982,
0.048959292471408844,
-0.047367505729198456,
-0.1480054408311844,
0.0454469658434391,
-0.8413586020469666,
0.9283123016357422,
-0.047663815319538116,
-0.2632013261318207,
-0.16696697473526,
-0.421550989151001,
0.47452348470687866,
-0.12686091661453247,
0.06004029139876366,
-0.152548149228096,
-0.07593204081058502,
1.1898419857025146,
-0.5167433619499207,
0.8941230773925781,
-0.49612075090408325,
-0.3984697461128235,
0.22875677049160004,
0.28818920254707336,
0.47668036818504333,
-0.04629362002015114,
-0.34798115491867065,
-0.1870785653591156,
0.22687110304832458,
-0.6230802536010742,
-0.6523864269256592,
0.7363065481185913,
-0.8340214490890503,
-0.5989949703216553,
-0.02137402817606926,
-1.2281649112701416,
-0.6402683258056641,
0.2675960659980774,
0.14012965559959412,
0.4625356197357178,
-0.07981470972299576,
0.4249928593635559,
0.6078367233276367,
-0.06649021059274673,
0.31011494994163513,
0.5674838423728943,
-0.3504039943218231,
-0.0690077543258667,
0.9519325494766235,
0.4882006049156189,
0.7506842613220215,
0.24288418889045715,
0.28324395418167114,
-0.21074415743350983,
-1.0512062311172485,
0.1545456051826477,
0.3033899664878845,
-0.9861698746681213,
0.20944446325302124,
-0.7260827422142029,
-0.01859983801841736,
-0.29282423853874207,
0.010528037324547768,
-0.24283017218112946,
-0.4371274709701538,
-0.2187240570783615,
-0.40115877985954285,
0.2990052402019501,
1.1173056364059448,
0.20578645169734955,
0.7260140776634216,
-0.32269519567489624,
0.303205281496048,
0.252998024225235,
0.47306445240974426,
-0.21343167126178741,
-0.28679731488227844,
-0.6380561590194702,
0.04700634256005287,
-0.11782772094011307,
-1.0026432275772095,
0.3420909643173218,
-0.00025543911033309996,
0.8628951907157898,
0.365823358297348,
-0.2691579759120941,
0.5927577018737793,
-0.2063296139240265,
0.9085726141929626,
0.02988789603114128,
-0.9983459115028381,
0.6267333030700684,
-0.5321124792098999,
0.17278629541397095,
0.4237593114376068,
0.5015096664428711,
0.09857799112796783,
-0.78270423412323,
-0.911517322063446,
-0.5819353461265564,
0.6892959475517273,
0.029452430084347725,
-0.1196918934583664,
-0.17775610089302063,
0.5205701589584351,
0.18169890344142914,
0.11479765921831131,
-0.6301493644714355,
-0.3199983835220337,
-0.10955754667520523,
-0.20766200125217438,
-0.29662689566612244,
-0.5391514301300049,
-0.1676369607448578,
-0.41055402159690857,
0.21786202490329742,
-0.10185874253511429,
0.09926997870206833,
-0.06619124114513397,
-0.21478666365146637,
0.03590109199285507,
-0.19998274743556976,
0.645115077495575,
1.0834280252456665,
-0.46781954169273376,
0.44590461254119873,
0.38984063267707825,
-0.6587862372398376,
0.020345842465758324,
-0.0020701971370726824,
0.04986351355910301,
0.05026450753211975,
0.4025895297527313,
0.8279664516448975,
0.2763441503047943,
-0.601232647895813,
0.355314701795578,
0.19983261823654175,
-0.45348408818244934,
-0.18313567340373993,
0.3831455409526825,
0.15553948283195496,
0.14296658337116241,
0.1271592527627945,
-0.24310791492462158,
0.32167214155197144,
-0.48550140857696533,
0.368573933839798,
0.22509640455245972,
-0.4023590087890625,
-0.3265382647514343,
0.5866153836250305,
-0.2700590491294861,
-0.043430641293525696,
0.23642121255397797,
0.009482905268669128,
-0.12060225009918213,
0.7145273089408875,
0.9016246795654297,
0.37619543075561523,
-0.516749918460846,
0.18839427828788757,
0.27907881140708923,
-0.07560679316520691,
-0.6038258075714111,
0.6557747721672058,
0.27353912591934204,
-0.8757002353668213,
-0.283379465341568,
-0.36768120527267456,
-0.2183251976966858,
0.302983820438385,
-0.8528077602386475,
0.5335316061973572,
-0.4664013385772705,
0.11189450323581696,
0.0004060200590174645,
-0.10858284682035446,
-0.48039475083351135,
0.5031309723854065,
-0.030774153769016266,
0.6204232573509216,
-0.695688784122467,
1.1504790782928467,
0.19407635927200317,
-0.6791900396347046,
-0.7956019639968872,
0.13317248225212097,
0.010606463067233562,
-0.9999969005584717,
0.7623933553695679,
-0.009677882306277752,
0.08590690046548843,
0.34769678115844727,
-0.4597027599811554,
-1.0548171997070312,
1.1873078346252441,
0.3179691433906555,
-0.3385763168334961,
0.05984947085380554,
0.5252659916877747,
0.5559840202331543,
-0.5011301636695862,
0.10347561538219452,
1.1868009567260742,
0.2483184039592743,
-0.2657245397567749,
-0.6664630770683289,
0.1410341113805771,
0.00599210150539875,
0.24056309461593628,
0.10167602449655533,
-0.03194542974233627,
1.2721713781356812,
0.03388041630387306,
-0.14077790081501007,
0.1082107201218605,
0.5445631146430969,
0.3740759789943695,
-0.10901428014039993,
0.6771665811538696,
0.46628594398498535,
0.7118527293205261,
0.06638740748167038,
1.6017132997512817,
-0.3241749405860901,
0.3784034550189972,
1.0183501243591309,
-0.3163306415081024,
0.9835971593856812,
0.5694826245307922,
-0.3821028172969818,
0.27559733390808105,
0.39955824613571167,
0.011414398439228535,
0.710813581943512,
0.41193628311157227,
-0.16310928761959076,
0.11161071807146072,
-0.0449034757912159,
-0.36233845353126526,
0.22805450856685638,
0.38336679339408875,
-0.5039532780647278,
-0.009531490504741669,
0.3085037171840668,
0.09034351259469986,
-0.11966433376073837,
-0.21269822120666504,
0.5216678977012634,
-0.11516755819320679,
-0.6440014243125916,
1.0086971521377563,
-0.2444903403520584,
0.4747115671634674,
-0.6920868754386902,
0.07403971254825592,
-0.3555622398853302,
0.3432243764400482,
-0.28078964352607727,
-0.9655799269676208,
0.4361061155796051,
-0.4516274333000183,
-0.20304188132286072,
-0.19810323417186737,
0.285004585981369,
-0.48939213156700134,
-0.35791295766830444,
0.4446636438369751,
0.6213952898979187,
0.2671453654766083,
-0.02152365632355213,
-0.6442910432815552,
0.2332419902086258,
0.030519206076860428,
-0.37132805585861206,
0.5881674885749817,
0.5707778334617615,
0.17993515729904175,
0.6728563904762268,
0.2774328887462616,
0.41214519739151,
0.22797942161560059,
0.5179837942123413,
0.5574766397476196,
-0.5768206715583801,
-0.36888307332992554,
-1.0474295616149902,
0.24466785788536072,
0.007120133843272924,
-0.37084752321243286,
1.0303984880447388,
0.6542585492134094,
0.4946458041667938,
0.051276080310344696,
0.9130063652992249,
-0.03367660194635391,
0.8857796788215637,
-0.7433054447174072,
0.4729401469230652,
-0.506751298904419,
0.6008290648460388,
-0.28445661067962646,
-1.0138283967971802,
-0.387337863445282,
0.45883238315582275,
-0.6514531373977661,
-0.0337822362780571,
1.1214803457260132,
1.0967669486999512,
-0.09197591245174408,
0.027422696352005005,
0.45987990498542786,
0.560187816619873,
0.2541796565055847,
0.1592606008052826,
0.8558468222618103,
-0.1558462381362915,
0.4003140926361084,
-0.6747919321060181,
0.048379503190517426,
0.07949639856815338,
-0.39038366079330444,
-1.0628726482391357,
-0.7400287985801697,
-0.215645894408226,
-0.5382430553436279,
-0.16383597254753113,
0.37363192439079285,
0.4180041551589966,
-0.8145359754562378,
-0.690753698348999,
-0.6362677812576294,
-0.07360447198152542,
-0.31051963567733765,
-0.3225244879722595,
0.2659861743450165,
-0.47664299607276917,
-0.7718327045440674,
0.5966562032699585,
-0.16643862426280975,
0.36901918053627014,
-0.5257649421691895,
-0.14554424583911896,
-0.24552030861377716,
-0.029939256608486176,
0.29648447036743164,
-0.035961516201496124,
-0.6034945845603943,
-0.16062377393245697,
-0.19630303978919983,
-0.2012181580066681,
0.13709603250026703,
0.919917643070221,
-0.42992347478866577,
0.2656293213367462,
0.5029898285865784,
0.36591896414756775,
0.39570996165275574,
-0.11835544556379318,
1.129162311553955,
-0.8955499529838562,
0.4104412794113159,
0.08837518095970154,
0.47711312770843506,
0.34141451120376587,
-0.25850483775138855,
0.6064176559448242,
0.287094384431839,
-0.4993816614151001,
-1.0848883390426636,
0.039897605776786804,
-0.7729917168617249,
-0.18769383430480957,
1.523105263710022,
0.05590933561325073,
-0.09442571550607681,
-0.4296363294124603,
-0.25053736567497253,
0.12841103971004486,
-0.051170073449611664,
0.6702238321304321,
0.8774433135986328,
-0.22536373138427734,
-0.5230676531791687,
-1.399729609489441,
0.7719635367393494,
0.6328516006469727,
-0.7598406672477722,
0.03303491696715355,
0.23646000027656555,
0.49761712551116943,
0.015358641743659973,
0.7911272048950195,
0.07552250474691391,
0.03578687086701393,
0.18576397001743317,
-0.02461297996342182,
0.22366680204868317,
-0.08725696057081223,
-0.20273743569850922,
0.384874165058136,
0.01502241101115942,
-0.055759452283382416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06321v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06321v2
|
Correlation Dimension of Natural Language in a Statistical Manifold
| 2024-05-10T08:48:03 | 2024-05-15T07:46:01 |
Xin Du, Kumiko Tanaka-Ishii
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cond-mat.stat-mech, cs.AI
|
The correlation dimension of natural language is measured by applying the
Grassberger-Procaccia algorithm to high-dimensional sequences produced by a
large-scale language model. This method, previously studied only in a Euclidean
space, is reformulated in a statistical manifold via the Fisher-Rao distance.
Language exhibits a multifractal, with global self-similarity and a universal
dimension around 6.5, which is smaller than those of simple discrete random
sequences and larger than that of a Barab\'asi-Albert process. Long memory is
the key to producing self-similarity. Our method is applicable to any
probabilistic model of real-world discrete sequences, and we show an
application to music data.
|
[
-0.59742271900177,
-0.849563479423523,
0.44614800810813904,
0.2964741289615631,
-0.2862417697906494,
0.025173045694828033,
-0.28731387853622437,
-0.5532189011573792,
0.7751179933547974,
0.49449461698532104,
-0.4029577970504761,
-0.5603434443473816,
-0.18998685479164124,
-0.17844602465629578,
-0.7316407561302185,
0.9434475898742676,
0.2462477833032608,
-0.1136246845126152,
-0.19699536263942719,
-0.28494685888290405,
-0.06334953755140305,
-0.7491819858551025,
-0.41972002387046814,
0.3067948520183563,
0.5677017569541931,
0.24110740423202515,
0.7182336449623108,
0.837581217288971,
0.954844057559967,
0.44480714201927185,
0.03324928507208824,
0.003317117691040039,
-0.4710124135017395,
0.18647167086601257,
0.14510108530521393,
-0.3617323935031891,
-0.28381872177124023,
0.24906684458255768,
1.1180737018585205,
0.9000217914581299,
0.04289218783378601,
0.4014037847518921,
0.18131762742996216,
0.9518982172012329,
-0.1081690788269043,
0.3219073712825775,
0.00994221493601799,
0.13472159206867218,
-0.7062316536903381,
-0.4329966902732849,
0.06638021022081375,
-0.8731396794319153,
0.2147568017244339,
-0.6595643162727356,
0.49696746468544006,
0.2081259936094284,
0.3314683735370636,
-0.007029182743281126,
-0.329013854265213,
-0.5179746747016907,
-1.086634635925293,
0.9486451745033264,
-0.28522568941116333,
0.5515199303627014,
0.37565627694129944,
0.3002206087112427,
-0.37843871116638184,
-0.2578284740447998,
-0.7887251377105713,
-0.22575722634792328,
-0.052089717239141464,
0.03189026191830635,
0.0056970021687448025,
-0.38199281692504883,
-0.06641889363527298,
0.6342684030532837,
-0.9286739826202393,
-0.30079400539398193,
-0.48555970191955566,
-0.09849565476179123,
0.7109408974647522,
0.22547881305217743,
0.146427184343338,
-0.2342033088207245,
-0.2349345088005066,
-0.4004642069339752,
-0.4133506715297699,
0.1166878268122673,
0.6455236077308655,
0.40310603380203247,
-0.13050112128257751,
0.3182416558265686,
0.07065629959106445,
0.7457619905471802,
-0.360946387052536,
-0.5083097219467163,
0.26055872440338135,
-0.42017874121665955,
0.025634540244936943,
0.0073220012709498405,
1.0244367122650146,
-0.06458751112222672,
0.4957490563392639,
-0.11502128839492798,
0.39193060994148254,
0.013866703025996685,
0.010789012536406517,
-0.4754316806793213,
-0.38726186752319336,
0.03350276127457619,
-0.5042306184768677,
0.01082935743033886,
0.1317955106496811,
-0.9912495017051697,
-0.19431419670581818,
-0.5962614417076111,
0.3428066670894623,
-0.8030758500099182,
-0.24772442877292633,
-0.04133220389485359,
0.1703748255968094,
-0.05662301927804947,
-0.2047605663537979,
-0.8499394059181213,
0.602979838848114,
0.8748452663421631,
1.1804975271224976,
-0.07710172235965729,
-0.5672938227653503,
-0.20280928909778595,
0.22627811133861542,
-0.7310426235198975,
1.1473437547683716,
-0.634741485118866,
-0.36941656470298767,
-0.13020312786102295,
-0.34040209650993347,
0.08694395422935486,
-0.592982828617096,
0.35510268807411194,
-0.34276509284973145,
0.44164106249809265,
-0.32991963624954224,
-0.7416381239891052,
-0.4331974685192108,
-0.213057741522789,
-0.6104369163513184,
0.7082281112670898,
0.03313835337758064,
-0.8573628067970276,
0.41677170991897583,
-0.4499126374721527,
-0.3690769076347351,
-0.2036086618900299,
-0.3309648633003235,
-0.49518102407455444,
0.05124862492084503,
-0.23810191452503204,
0.3518346846103668,
-0.5359521508216858,
0.09104815870523453,
-0.6633359789848328,
-0.3181850016117096,
0.5702645778656006,
-0.5299695730209351,
0.555890679359436,
0.44705718755722046,
0.27348199486732483,
-0.08978354930877686,
-1.0848616361618042,
0.08897817879915237,
-0.13332246243953705,
-0.4544060528278351,
-0.4008750915527344,
-0.008066989481449127,
0.09004352986812592,
-0.031619664281606674,
0.1153770238161087,
-0.46985170245170593,
0.037396010011434555,
-0.30402442812919617,
0.2121501863002777,
0.46973058581352234,
0.1971024125814438,
0.4336935579776764,
-0.46042999625205994,
0.3274294435977936,
0.23295296728610992,
-0.026677340269088745,
0.08877753466367722,
-0.49408385157585144,
-0.4784429371356964,
-0.7747953534126282,
0.485537052154541,
0.42708197236061096,
0.07070080190896988,
0.7361616492271423,
-0.5438393950462341,
-0.6712442636489868,
-0.4399503171443939,
0.26741304993629456,
0.1883459836244583,
0.15323108434677124,
0.33614450693130493,
-0.7506325840950012,
-0.36829042434692383,
-0.9312791228294373,
-0.14523206651210785,
-0.24881309270858765,
-0.11565002799034119,
0.1429750770330429,
0.1937607228755951,
0.023133696988224983,
0.9286680221557617,
-0.4916031062602997,
-0.8409218192100525,
0.35804131627082825,
0.3342777192592621,
0.6402259469032288,
0.6660833954811096,
0.8312399387359619,
-0.21491222083568573,
-0.6200830936431885,
-0.11824329197406769,
-0.8449457883834839,
0.1308986097574234,
-0.06686405837535858,
-0.1476917266845703,
0.10316989570856094,
0.24657736718654633,
-0.5711767077445984,
0.2860816419124603,
0.6005958914756775,
-0.30461254715919495,
0.3214742839336395,
-0.5094071626663208,
0.36852923035621643,
-1.2169281244277954,
-0.03460017964243889,
0.23062816262245178,
0.08601327240467072,
-0.6858557462692261,
-0.20907597243785858,
-0.34840965270996094,
0.06930908560752869,
-0.06398656219244003,
0.29747065901756287,
-0.5231451392173767,
-0.48754119873046875,
-0.007088970858603716,
0.2126663476228714,
-0.3656744062900543,
0.4509107768535614,
-0.030363932251930237,
0.912179708480835,
0.7125312685966492,
-0.6940916180610657,
0.46043357253074646,
0.13801632821559906,
-0.7319366931915283,
0.8379855155944824,
-0.31586402654647827,
-0.16092213988304138,
-0.23004624247550964,
0.1914212703704834,
-1.2099530696868896,
-0.11966700106859207,
-0.30540990829467773,
-0.41686058044433594,
0.14587317407131195,
0.2779703438282013,
-0.505609393119812,
-0.2627994120121002,
-0.27400457859039307,
0.7184529304504395,
0.4215031564235687,
-0.3650727868080139,
0.19012200832366943,
0.6566397547721863,
-0.28188684582710266,
-0.026678577065467834,
-0.6631725430488586,
0.04955049976706505,
-0.6068704128265381,
-0.6082963943481445,
0.17585152387619019,
-0.112750343978405,
-0.40675434470176697,
-0.18468274176120758,
0.24709174036979675,
-0.12837892770767212,
-0.30031082034111023,
0.23109924793243408,
-0.1623392552137375,
-0.45911315083503723,
0.40661805868148804,
-0.349732369184494,
-0.2350304126739502,
0.11824972182512283,
-0.37911954522132874,
0.7762936949729919,
-0.25501108169555664,
-0.41160187125205994,
-0.7461780905723572,
0.5836651921272278,
0.5962814092636108,
0.05007490515708923,
0.6061437129974365,
0.5499211549758911,
-0.23134078085422516,
0.18960711359977722,
-0.3510226607322693,
0.022811926901340485,
-0.4724816679954529,
0.25098419189453125,
-0.4607965052127838,
-0.8239668607711792,
0.8062018156051636,
0.12352625280618668,
-0.436555415391922,
0.35734647512435913,
0.5756131410598755,
-0.31976351141929626,
0.7158735394477844,
0.35099881887435913,
-0.46695876121520996,
0.3363024890422821,
-0.43250513076782227,
0.5596559047698975,
-0.7728794813156128,
-0.18335016071796417,
-0.7430943846702576,
-0.38731053471565247,
-0.7772148251533508,
-0.6412469148635864,
0.5015807747840881,
0.20239686965942383,
-0.5189891457557678,
0.28738242387771606,
-0.2829013168811798,
0.5325179100036621,
0.9217100143432617,
-0.2704903185367584,
0.18555161356925964,
0.23364949226379395,
-0.3323005735874176,
-0.3041173219680786,
-0.392082154750824,
-0.34863120317459106,
0.841077446937561,
0.2522602379322052,
0.7018077373504639,
0.653243362903595,
0.9408712983131409,
0.07861081510782242,
0.06827892363071442,
-0.5363697409629822,
0.4470922648906708,
-0.22770194709300995,
-0.4142380654811859,
-0.6765597462654114,
-0.507678210735321,
-1.105880618095398,
0.0020307363010942936,
-0.2101554125547409,
-0.8172636032104492,
0.14052848517894745,
-0.02862636186182499,
-0.4018459618091583,
0.284682959318161,
-0.48817160725593567,
0.4212186634540558,
0.052405159920454025,
-0.19062216579914093,
-0.3240751028060913,
-0.2806903123855591,
0.37071290612220764,
-0.32254478335380554,
0.5216181874275208,
-0.17692579329013824,
0.4178774058818817,
1.0092450380325317,
-0.2893199920654297,
0.7765427231788635,
0.17056401073932648,
-0.24776974320411682,
0.5248206257820129,
0.7233292460441589,
0.010680100880563259,
0.22421714663505554,
0.15702812373638153,
0.20998337864875793,
0.2575463652610779,
-0.41601282358169556,
-0.5334182977676392,
1.1001259088516235,
-0.9539311528205872,
-0.4599587321281433,
-0.5055543184280396,
-0.5811396241188049,
-0.3316580355167389,
0.0023315472062677145,
0.04574202746152878,
0.6767886877059937,
-0.43820586800575256,
0.39690032601356506,
0.32828548550605774,
-0.3039507269859314,
0.6010974049568176,
0.3167996108531952,
-0.4293361008167267,
-0.47088423371315,
1.0520877838134766,
0.5512976050376892,
-0.01850610412657261,
0.4296507239341736,
0.3216705918312073,
-0.4659918248653412,
-0.11993568390607834,
-0.03424212709069252,
0.32631799578666687,
-0.402452677488327,
-0.20512665808200836,
-0.5380733013153076,
-0.3413733243942261,
-0.5220090746879578,
-0.051449187099933624,
-0.43837770819664,
-0.5282937288284302,
-0.10923744738101959,
0.09252258390188217,
0.6712623238563538,
0.8155533671379089,
-0.6627052426338196,
0.18228529393672943,
-0.8297338485717773,
0.13310910761356354,
0.672596275806427,
0.6202850937843323,
0.26395559310913086,
-0.7030214071273804,
-0.28427380323410034,
-0.076757051050663,
-0.18486741185188293,
-0.6055712103843689,
0.6229498386383057,
0.5659871101379395,
0.5373609662055969,
0.7996866703033447,
-0.30796194076538086,
0.8822613954544067,
-0.5729515552520752,
0.7762174606323242,
0.2396327555179596,
-0.8813918828964233,
0.25707492232322693,
-0.6731505990028381,
0.23887242376804352,
0.19751432538032532,
0.5811150670051575,
-0.6364267468452454,
-0.4518997371196747,
-0.603820264339447,
-0.257742702960968,
0.01162057463079691,
0.2604963779449463,
0.18599046766757965,
-0.48106104135513306,
0.21719516813755035,
-0.035042066127061844,
-0.11719776690006256,
-0.23273196816444397,
-0.21002602577209473,
-0.1453542709350586,
-0.31674835085868835,
-0.7025172114372253,
-0.25811251997947693,
-0.2619318962097168,
-0.4713432490825653,
0.20175224542617798,
-0.1524052917957306,
0.8191849589347839,
0.03857962787151337,
0.2417679876089096,
-0.29565659165382385,
0.12878373265266418,
1.0017025470733643,
0.6965442299842834,
-0.24246852099895477,
0.4406886100769043,
0.07825551182031631,
-0.5247145891189575,
0.1793089210987091,
-0.3909015655517578,
0.6328667998313904,
-0.274346262216568,
0.7917506098747253,
0.32805997133255005,
0.05425097420811653,
-0.12319222837686539,
0.30322274565696716,
0.06873050332069397,
-0.30222177505493164,
-0.6478230357170105,
0.12051654607057571,
0.3331387937068939,
0.25121504068374634,
0.24899505078792572,
-0.026745686307549477,
0.2286662757396698,
-0.8766819834709167,
0.4828666150569916,
0.29885607957839966,
-0.5320330858230591,
-0.6347156167030334,
0.4165213108062744,
-0.40627920627593994,
-0.5415588021278381,
0.6907641887664795,
0.0035403859801590443,
-0.24110911786556244,
0.4684666395187378,
0.7111786603927612,
0.5821239352226257,
-0.3083295226097107,
0.2998371422290802,
0.5433592200279236,
-0.10861488431692123,
0.04401308298110962,
0.427558958530426,
0.07836609333753586,
-0.7292749881744385,
-0.2379683256149292,
-1.0718491077423096,
0.031614772975444794,
0.02431396394968033,
-0.6888329982757568,
-0.22606076300144196,
-0.5499655604362488,
-0.00969669595360756,
0.3425469994544983,
0.04613494127988815,
-0.6016084551811218,
-0.01950759068131447,
-0.19969604909420013,
0.5366321802139282,
-0.9380194544792175,
1.1618330478668213,
0.11202312260866165,
-0.41191694140434265,
-0.6413528323173523,
-0.0186087004840374,
0.36443543434143066,
-0.6233672499656677,
0.8501249551773071,
-0.033294275403022766,
-0.1718556433916092,
-0.17150874435901642,
-0.2548382878303528,
-1.3651362657546997,
0.9070799350738525,
0.10939612984657288,
-0.439364492893219,
0.6049014329910278,
0.5932657718658447,
1.2022688388824463,
-0.4906257092952728,
-0.08262546360492706,
0.7350267767906189,
0.1927594244480133,
0.16944384574890137,
-0.797356367111206,
-0.384833961725235,
-0.026762617751955986,
0.3054206073284149,
0.5459323525428772,
-0.8947976231575012,
1.0319766998291016,
0.008800353854894638,
-0.23539996147155762,
-0.014918291941285133,
0.9775267243385315,
0.2773217558860779,
-0.3751574456691742,
0.3876993656158447,
0.8043429851531982,
0.9048239588737488,
0.15803775191307068,
0.7610065937042236,
-0.7437869906425476,
0.6414295434951782,
0.859559953212738,
-0.3226124346256256,
1.0251821279525757,
0.44460687041282654,
-0.6453196406364441,
0.528009295463562,
0.4237107038497925,
0.18751667439937592,
0.492220014333725,
0.5382729172706604,
-0.3425813317298889,
-0.25703078508377075,
0.19957096874713898,
-0.35746854543685913,
0.6533887982368469,
0.3689545691013336,
-0.20379546284675598,
0.025479085743427277,
-0.17460621893405914,
-0.07954173535108566,
0.43105459213256836,
0.17680014669895172,
0.889746367931366,
0.1568600833415985,
-0.40647655725479126,
0.5915585160255432,
-0.38352882862091064,
0.26338720321655273,
-0.1859705150127411,
-0.04800218343734741,
-0.36251720786094666,
0.31037870049476624,
0.20099209249019623,
-1.0403255224227905,
0.7289133667945862,
-0.34930744767189026,
-0.22367389500141144,
0.21781955659389496,
0.000795251689851284,
-0.4320629835128784,
-0.6805452108383179,
0.46612152457237244,
0.2982384264469147,
0.4991009533405304,
0.3942224979400635,
-0.42732056975364685,
-0.3312634527683258,
-0.3122984766960144,
-0.16908492147922516,
0.42683351039886475,
0.6946448087692261,
0.013006803579628468,
0.8161629438400269,
0.8163960576057434,
0.3039957582950592,
0.3370823562145233,
-0.030611233785748482,
0.49080193042755127,
-0.9616580009460449,
-0.682499349117279,
-0.5882695913314819,
-0.15170346200466156,
-0.045035649091005325,
-0.23227153718471527,
0.7552706599235535,
0.8224048018455505,
0.8161062598228455,
-0.11084064096212387,
0.48625320196151733,
0.12499958276748657,
1.0305336713790894,
-0.43713584542274475,
0.516583263874054,
-0.24183794856071472,
0.06513796001672745,
-0.37902283668518066,
-1.2868709564208984,
-0.5043755769729614,
0.9955372214317322,
-0.1660204529762268,
-0.10093990713357925,
0.8705636262893677,
0.8825281858444214,
-0.2799886167049408,
0.022754445672035217,
0.5246357917785645,
0.21824036538600922,
0.3755064904689789,
0.3628270924091339,
0.4598538279533386,
-0.24798332154750824,
0.28973713517189026,
-0.23274874687194824,
-0.3353792428970337,
0.1397898644208908,
-0.5744006037712097,
-0.8806372284889221,
-1.1455641984939575,
-0.1585361659526825,
-0.23646095395088196,
-0.26765307784080505,
0.8868384957313538,
0.5938373804092407,
-1.0305922031402588,
-0.6258702278137207,
0.11279965937137604,
-0.16993875801563263,
-0.38651242852211,
-0.21681366860866547,
0.7092283964157104,
-0.30388179421424866,
-0.5068021416664124,
0.2530110776424408,
0.47023674845695496,
0.21734893321990967,
-0.7485504746437073,
0.02904476784169674,
-0.29912206530570984,
0.36036208271980286,
0.5427166819572449,
0.2124292105436325,
-0.48480093479156494,
-0.8101769089698792,
-0.3068692982196808,
-0.14515937864780426,
0.2533455789089203,
0.7572733163833618,
-0.4119534492492676,
0.21817970275878906,
0.8180147409439087,
0.17875830829143524,
0.3096064329147339,
-0.1394907832145691,
0.4338160753250122,
-0.7400792241096497,
0.27202141284942627,
-0.2361287772655487,
0.20851294696331024,
0.11704185605049133,
-0.17040249705314636,
0.37575146555900574,
0.20801886916160583,
-0.8113579154014587,
-0.37243908643722534,
0.2623235881328583,
-0.9960028529167175,
-0.1526755541563034,
0.9614202976226807,
-0.03671771287918091,
-0.41212570667266846,
-0.18977996706962585,
0.13871395587921143,
0.06523247063159943,
-0.1610417515039444,
1.0991554260253906,
0.7704703211784363,
-0.13868263363838196,
-0.06748415529727936,
-0.4306575655937195,
0.738151490688324,
-0.004980613011866808,
-0.47541284561157227,
-0.015812948346138,
0.3956184685230255,
0.4263284504413605,
0.8330082297325134,
0.6017323732376099,
-0.31136906147003174,
-0.09369213879108429,
0.13393932580947876,
0.08345849066972733,
0.5480177402496338,
-0.7181326746940613,
-0.1422639936208725,
0.32879653573036194,
-0.11582212895154953,
-0.061794817447662354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06319v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06319v1
|
Decoding Emotions in Abstract Art: Cognitive Plausibility of CLIP in Recognizing Color-Emotion Associations
| 2024-05-10T08:45:23 | 2024-05-10T08:45:23 |
Hanna-Sophia Widhoelzl, Ece Takmaz
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
This study investigates the cognitive plausibility of a pretrained multimodal
model, CLIP, in recognizing emotions evoked by abstract visual art. We employ a
dataset comprising images with associated emotion labels and textual rationales
of these labels provided by human annotators. We perform linguistic analyses of
rationales, zero-shot emotion classification of images and rationales, apply
similarity-based prediction of emotion, and investigate color-emotion
associations. The relatively low, yet above baseline, accuracy in recognizing
emotion for abstract images and rationales suggests that CLIP decodes emotional
complexities in a manner not well aligned with human cognitive processes.
Furthermore, we explore color-emotion interactions in images and rationales.
Expected color-emotion associations, such as red relating to anger, are
identified in images and texts annotated with emotion labels by both humans and
CLIP, with the latter showing even stronger interactions. Our results highlight
the disparity between human processing and machine processing when connecting
image features and emotions.
|
[
-0.5856895446777344,
-0.3797047734260559,
0.6520704030990601,
0.18841880559921265,
-0.5014441609382629,
0.22661031782627106,
-0.23624595999717712,
-0.8833483457565308,
0.5254623889923096,
-0.022404097020626068,
-0.6330559253692627,
-0.36442863941192627,
-0.593062162399292,
0.32166391611099243,
-0.37967196106910706,
0.8071135878562927,
-0.2523994445800781,
-0.031098568812012672,
-0.20497499406337738,
-0.5954453349113464,
-0.5226086974143982,
-0.7988523840904236,
-0.32131415605545044,
0.06847192347049713,
0.43466031551361084,
0.06706737726926804,
0.5247146487236023,
0.26754894852638245,
0.37475210428237915,
0.3419041931629181,
0.16438181698322296,
-0.329257607460022,
-0.5877051949501038,
-0.1418515294790268,
-0.03661806136369705,
-0.48372602462768555,
-0.15616784989833832,
0.27687913179397583,
-0.023829558864235878,
0.03787907212972641,
0.27377182245254517,
-0.08861982822418213,
-0.29599136114120483,
0.76340651512146,
-1.0446887016296387,
0.2692643105983734,
-0.4438820481300354,
0.43862155079841614,
-0.1246735081076622,
-0.3219056725502014,
-0.35171133279800415,
-0.3724772036075592,
0.3028585910797119,
-0.8234020471572876,
0.051904790103435516,
-0.1309678703546524,
0.9445719718933105,
0.2078082263469696,
-0.5277493000030518,
-0.6683576107025146,
-0.6215692162513733,
0.7450811862945557,
-0.07408065348863602,
-0.0015059218276292086,
0.3168238401412964,
0.21482166647911072,
0.3736957609653473,
-0.6964524984359741,
-0.9436289072036743,
0.17192979156970978,
0.046617042273283005,
0.47100767493247986,
-0.6344102621078491,
0.34610939025878906,
0.49025043845176697,
0.45900291204452515,
-0.10475907474756241,
-0.5467004776000977,
-0.5301892757415771,
-0.412484347820282,
0.7364076375961304,
0.38568729162216187,
0.9633830785751343,
0.03466962277889252,
-0.5575336217880249,
-0.30920156836509705,
-0.4401078522205353,
0.24651961028575897,
0.41938868165016174,
-0.4111332595348358,
-0.06607884913682938,
0.5676343441009521,
0.16268068552017212,
0.07313007116317749,
-0.15844890475273132,
-0.011779365129768848,
0.2446586936712265,
-0.22486193478107452,
0.0549267902970314,
0.09406758844852448,
0.9124595522880554,
0.9345727562904358,
0.7051220536231995,
0.18435871601104736,
0.03231964632868767,
0.7745864391326904,
0.2641110420227051,
-0.784920334815979,
-0.7747927308082581,
0.12969408929347992,
-0.5678480863571167,
0.08100961148738861,
0.06854917854070663,
-0.9391607642173767,
-0.3017873764038086,
-0.2872335910797119,
0.7491652965545654,
-0.7195176482200623,
-0.25529131293296814,
0.16136057674884796,
-0.4860113561153412,
-0.01886792853474617,
0.3513542413711548,
-0.6818712949752808,
0.22211241722106934,
0.24346663057804108,
0.8294039368629456,
-0.2643815577030182,
-0.22612610459327698,
0.3450756072998047,
-0.20413826406002045,
-0.27240705490112305,
0.9791430234909058,
-0.5766819715499878,
-0.29108479619026184,
-0.07359889894723892,
0.2033659666776657,
-0.21232445538043976,
-0.40151306986808777,
0.8448126316070557,
-0.46358394622802734,
-0.13046807050704956,
-0.47376930713653564,
-0.3756956160068512,
-0.6008923649787903,
0.1832677274942398,
-1.0574394464492798,
0.6158760190010071,
-0.10381761938333511,
-0.7439535856246948,
0.10463231801986694,
-0.6559464931488037,
-0.19186072051525116,
-0.2471482753753662,
-0.17490562796592712,
-0.16542033851146698,
0.3366481363773346,
-0.20123805105686188,
0.0683993473649025,
-0.016101017594337463,
-0.32075291872024536,
-0.7517825365066528,
-0.569652259349823,
0.5704318881034851,
0.049346208572387695,
0.4984632432460785,
0.19819271564483643,
-0.15592747926712036,
0.27720966935157776,
-0.6007798910140991,
-0.030014388263225555,
0.3643256723880768,
0.035507407039403915,
-0.4515077769756317,
-0.09077715873718262,
-0.026701681315898895,
0.45427003502845764,
0.1606607735157013,
-0.7861568927764893,
-0.18901462852954865,
0.21104726195335388,
0.49775710701942444,
0.7478874921798706,
0.08934954553842545,
0.32476815581321716,
-0.13708873093128204,
0.7745641469955444,
0.11814358085393906,
-0.1266331523656845,
-0.4376353323459625,
-0.1549748182296753,
-0.7254364490509033,
-0.504327118396759,
0.009610823355615139,
0.5272330045700073,
-0.4019518494606018,
0.06515518575906754,
0.37327057123184204,
-0.12165796011686325,
-0.4675842821598053,
-0.4120875597000122,
0.2733442783355713,
0.5307517647743225,
0.22058986127376556,
-0.4731591045856476,
-0.6315884590148926,
-0.9792072176933289,
-0.09748899936676025,
0.19029977917671204,
-0.005426234100013971,
0.36986613273620605,
0.7339997291564941,
-0.14030404388904572,
0.9838110208511353,
-0.81500244140625,
-0.31924089789390564,
0.3559160530567169,
0.8987292647361755,
-0.290584534406662,
0.3173900544643402,
0.730968713760376,
-0.5911281108856201,
-0.34065425395965576,
-0.2415306717157364,
-0.7928057909011841,
0.03824641928076744,
-0.04229886084794998,
-0.24614520370960236,
0.19547799229621887,
0.18833138048648834,
-0.45785343647003174,
1.030747890472412,
0.29584428668022156,
-0.2938539683818817,
0.8079574108123779,
-0.15673759579658508,
0.5560781359672546,
-0.18443520367145538,
-0.04802565649151802,
-0.009624443016946316,
0.2475552260875702,
-0.38595402240753174,
-0.5594801306724548,
0.04610875993967056,
-0.35764312744140625,
-0.498512864112854,
0.29750359058380127,
-0.5987454652786255,
-0.3681407868862152,
-0.6574323773384094,
-0.19779518246650696,
0.2889294922351837,
0.8810664415359497,
0.7305068373680115,
0.6862120628356934,
0.5128438472747803,
-0.2604784667491913,
0.11112719029188156,
0.356376588344574,
-0.5357972383499146,
0.8827378749847412,
-0.6795753836631775,
0.22624905407428741,
-0.3359545171260834,
0.09642358124256134,
-1.161742925643921,
-0.2167799025774002,
0.315233051776886,
-0.11142121255397797,
-0.007749781012535095,
0.02761387638747692,
-0.2073979377746582,
-0.0590643547475338,
-0.6122291684150696,
1.1001594066619873,
0.5700903534889221,
-0.20563150942325592,
0.6554011106491089,
0.25836965441703796,
-0.31570571660995483,
-0.30751729011535645,
-0.5051009058952332,
-0.07902146875858307,
-0.16008718311786652,
-0.5376230478286743,
0.10342589020729065,
-0.2863706648349762,
-0.06822885572910309,
0.1083810031414032,
0.10147488862276077,
-0.3961673676967621,
-0.017142608761787415,
0.6403329372406006,
0.26893579959869385,
0.027090266346931458,
-0.08361966907978058,
-0.1548491269350052,
0.06755636632442474,
0.3613995909690857,
0.5516604781150818,
0.10645543038845062,
-0.4310174882411957,
-0.5451169013977051,
-0.5668659210205078,
0.5821018218994141,
0.8927016854286194,
-0.1437119096517563,
0.43927738070487976,
0.6183741092681885,
-0.43339401483535767,
0.276867151260376,
-0.07942301779985428,
-0.15946193039417267,
-0.34376785159111023,
0.30911189317703247,
-0.2638148069381714,
-0.5006069540977478,
0.7753064632415771,
-0.0773356631398201,
-0.3907047212123871,
0.23177805542945862,
0.4516167938709259,
-0.5877006649971008,
1.2793811559677124,
0.5721276998519897,
0.32210636138916016,
0.6800684332847595,
-0.3709842562675476,
0.01670547015964985,
-1.0777677297592163,
-0.09514184296131134,
-0.23475070297718048,
-0.9079350233078003,
-0.24083459377288818,
-0.22189290821552277,
0.36273202300071716,
0.2565789222717285,
-0.185794860124588,
-0.19177953898906708,
-0.36183589696884155,
0.7381283640861511,
0.38846760988235474,
0.2413204312324524,
0.06577293574810028,
-0.11418680846691132,
0.06640313565731049,
-0.4853818416595459,
-0.33742377161979675,
-0.31344056129455566,
0.8253290057182312,
0.3316371440887451,
0.6243261098861694,
0.024580851197242737,
0.3169320523738861,
0.27954643964767456,
0.4177034795284271,
-1.0992156267166138,
0.3569936156272888,
0.045370884239673615,
-0.5380011796951294,
0.21879196166992188,
0.10770335048437119,
-0.9250668287277222,
0.18380063772201538,
-0.861843466758728,
-0.9031451940536499,
0.5695623755455017,
0.2547107934951782,
-0.11034639179706573,
0.11397062242031097,
-0.7243221998214722,
1.1239246129989624,
-0.4043308198451996,
-0.2959408760070801,
-0.25894805788993835,
-0.5540159940719604,
0.8903658986091614,
0.15182539820671082,
0.23964858055114746,
-0.4054467976093292,
0.16225747764110565,
0.8290749788284302,
-0.43852972984313965,
0.8439936637878418,
0.22118084132671356,
0.32357433438301086,
0.4561053216457367,
0.41478878259658813,
0.13036230206489563,
-0.4142675995826721,
0.293191522359848,
0.2449258416891098,
0.19113704562187195,
-0.4130643904209137,
-0.6400666832923889,
0.1273479014635086,
-0.7762634754180908,
-0.13310202956199646,
-0.6149814128875732,
-0.7676807045936584,
0.054179511964321136,
-0.05098586529493332,
0.44924986362457275,
0.2287573665380478,
-0.06748276203870773,
-0.20213861763477325,
0.41881880164146423,
-0.19927364587783813,
0.3748020827770233,
0.06809315085411072,
0.21755479276180267,
-0.8249039053916931,
1.015618920326233,
-0.06116330996155739,
0.10160849988460541,
-0.1817689836025238,
0.19391456246376038,
-0.3750261068344116,
-0.4761425256729126,
-0.08362209796905518,
0.21054871380329132,
-1.0041731595993042,
-0.0998372882604599,
-0.3254181146621704,
0.36488020420074463,
0.21210767328739166,
-0.3690967261791229,
-0.30967438220977783,
-0.3524489104747772,
-0.5480951070785522,
-0.04364899545907974,
0.5919110178947449,
0.7783161401748657,
0.05648647993803024,
-0.035728588700294495,
-0.9652233719825745,
0.20720335841178894,
0.518042266368866,
0.385757714509964,
0.21318002045154572,
-0.22651202976703644,
-0.024890804663300514,
-0.2940920889377594,
-0.482245534658432,
-1.2786861658096313,
0.4469909369945526,
0.24917976558208466,
0.10220407694578171,
0.8845505714416504,
0.5451245903968811,
0.7388017177581787,
-0.39869382977485657,
0.6948085427284241,
0.5686454772949219,
-1.2896430492401123,
0.2919866740703583,
-0.3630068600177765,
0.13850148022174835,
0.567607581615448,
0.6874929666519165,
-0.34335216879844666,
0.009655325673520565,
-0.5417712330818176,
-0.9459737539291382,
0.7888493537902832,
0.10413458198308945,
0.001953487517312169,
-0.3473741412162781,
-0.012236494570970535,
0.03396157547831535,
0.15787148475646973,
-0.8796368837356567,
-0.07930611819028854,
-0.5568075180053711,
-0.5385150909423828,
0.3052729666233063,
-0.5169879198074341,
-0.41815030574798584,
-0.019698703661561012,
-0.042418621480464935,
-0.2273201048374176,
0.5094709992408752,
0.32735762000083923,
-0.4828302264213562,
-0.24523243308067322,
0.10322938114404678,
0.9835973381996155,
0.32198888063430786,
-0.5247674584388733,
0.2074960172176361,
-0.039841439574956894,
-0.3495722711086273,
0.30503085255622864,
-0.3311958611011505,
0.016100117936730385,
-0.12652264535427094,
0.6181378364562988,
0.9890387058258057,
0.42219486832618713,
-1.0909029245376587,
0.6856091618537903,
-0.2626039385795593,
-0.31818893551826477,
-0.34913119673728943,
-0.2718767523765564,
-0.02004016563296318,
0.42587363719940186,
0.1264672577381134,
0.25683528184890747,
0.43656718730926514,
-0.912176251411438,
-0.0713740885257721,
0.549679696559906,
-0.48865461349487305,
-0.7930510640144348,
0.49980324506759644,
0.2361113727092743,
-0.040943779051303864,
0.38500654697418213,
-0.10243212431669235,
-0.9842537641525269,
0.5818976759910583,
0.29897186160087585,
0.751800537109375,
0.3930807411670685,
-0.1201607957482338,
0.5236295461654663,
-0.21595677733421326,
-0.11133451014757156,
0.39116668701171875,
-0.20455868542194366,
-0.7603172063827515,
-0.3668718636035919,
-0.19683699309825897,
-0.6743557453155518,
-0.29427334666252136,
-0.8564920425415039,
-0.014791766181588173,
-0.5969969630241394,
-0.3207983076572418,
-0.3090381324291229,
-0.2766514718532562,
-0.45514899492263794,
0.08586657792329788,
0.4214715361595154,
0.7400555610656738,
-1.1339715719223022,
0.39784225821495056,
0.7176355719566345,
-0.5634230375289917,
-0.7728254795074463,
-0.3334996700286865,
0.04952103644609451,
-0.3406468331813812,
1.1884232759475708,
0.26650577783584595,
-0.329203337430954,
-0.4244999289512634,
-0.5511887669563293,
-0.5407304167747498,
1.1088155508041382,
0.46709609031677246,
-0.05810990557074547,
0.5200151205062866,
-0.3449513912200928,
0.6289083361625671,
-0.38488325476646423,
0.696919858455658,
0.38679999113082886,
0.29635149240493774,
0.5316980481147766,
-0.41649264097213745,
0.03149747475981712,
-0.2992774546146393,
-0.189618781208992,
0.2269871085882187,
-0.5912221074104309,
1.2356634140014648,
-0.2980465292930603,
-0.945922315120697,
-0.06196076422929764,
0.7303550839424133,
0.33936724066734314,
0.6443620920181274,
0.5234870910644531,
0.5086860060691833,
0.6469770073890686,
-0.1849941462278366,
1.0590002536773682,
-0.22268737852573395,
0.3270009160041809,
0.6620889902114868,
-0.23975634574890137,
0.8322259783744812,
0.3598506450653076,
-0.27222445607185364,
0.8036906123161316,
0.4971783757209778,
0.19937221705913544,
0.5781037211418152,
0.08557761460542679,
-0.49780774116516113,
-0.16079306602478027,
-0.2131051868200302,
-0.04645751416683197,
0.30513790249824524,
0.2436896562576294,
-0.1995657980442047,
-0.10536841303110123,
0.09003439545631409,
-0.12308940291404724,
0.12869882583618164,
-0.522470235824585,
0.7030296921730042,
-0.029354508966207504,
-0.320353239774704,
0.42169106006622314,
-0.376182496547699,
0.7730739712715149,
-0.4285273551940918,
-0.31312504410743713,
0.2214840203523636,
-0.12320020794868469,
-0.35516437888145447,
-0.9919795393943787,
0.4717386066913605,
0.06210847944021225,
-0.3113069236278534,
-0.0009682556265033782,
0.7280328273773193,
-0.42647749185562134,
-0.10998950153589249,
0.20175182819366455,
-0.15768103301525116,
0.4406443238258362,
-0.2527386248111725,
-0.6419541239738464,
0.6263332962989807,
-0.0942961648106575,
-0.02046620473265648,
0.3908064067363739,
0.5409755706787109,
-0.09962841123342514,
0.30681952834129333,
0.5557605028152466,
-0.1503339409828186,
-0.0488554909825325,
-0.42529380321502686,
0.4873363673686981,
-0.9075109958648682,
-0.2656862735748291,
-0.7219700217247009,
0.668601393699646,
0.07799531519412994,
-0.1948229968547821,
0.18670028448104858,
0.020958207547664642,
0.5391659736633301,
-0.6484857797622681,
0.7266305685043335,
0.1989862471818924,
-0.13925279676914215,
-0.6100765466690063,
0.3958643078804016,
-0.30105867981910706,
-0.40701839327812195,
-0.5456770062446594,
-0.502480685710907,
-0.13967964053153992,
0.9534045457839966,
-0.4739612936973572,
-0.2402145266532898,
0.9049494862556458,
0.3577471077442169,
0.09185027331113815,
0.37098610401153564,
0.16298863291740417,
-0.02373463474214077,
-0.17092767357826233,
0.8837955594062805,
1.2472853660583496,
-0.06830094754695892,
0.6387753486633301,
-0.4684509038925171,
-0.21148422360420227,
-0.3193818926811218,
-1.2809226512908936,
-0.7933239936828613,
-0.4644578695297241,
-0.5297891497612,
-0.25095173716545105,
-0.4180053770542145,
0.8650714159011841,
0.5182624459266663,
-0.7883793115615845,
0.05408858880400658,
0.25608158111572266,
0.19145575165748596,
-0.08198331296443939,
-0.19219528138637543,
0.41236811876296997,
0.22804045677185059,
-0.8546038866043091,
-0.17990224063396454,
0.4722329080104828,
0.43829044699668884,
0.1800071895122528,
-0.25632694363594055,
0.1746881604194641,
0.07338773459196091,
0.6907907724380493,
0.7862510681152344,
-0.6661811470985413,
-0.3309573829174042,
-0.2513726055622101,
0.0973302572965622,
0.34016817808151245,
1.1446051597595215,
-0.48618754744529724,
0.5928022265434265,
0.6545657515525818,
0.4471403658390045,
0.4623659551143646,
0.19476540386676788,
0.5134853720664978,
-0.4688102900981903,
0.21409060060977936,
0.2296399474143982,
0.7713162302970886,
0.2166120409965515,
-0.1441641002893448,
0.3733101189136505,
0.4560677111148834,
-0.31069377064704895,
-0.6243310570716858,
0.6626845598220825,
-1.4244078397750854,
-0.27892404794692993,
0.4543737471103668,
-0.5451202988624573,
-0.49217489361763,
0.0755539983510971,
-0.5721055865287781,
0.07104049623012543,
-0.359396755695343,
0.7751403450965881,
0.995559811592102,
-0.7764202952384949,
-0.46568211913108826,
-0.22799116373062134,
0.42186540365219116,
0.3527906835079193,
-0.6737651824951172,
-0.043490536510944366,
0.9415461421012878,
0.24593298137187958,
0.48877209424972534,
0.5502898693084717,
-0.14490485191345215,
0.6085022687911987,
0.08303636312484741,
0.5784357786178589,
-0.21043148636817932,
-0.10353697836399078,
-0.47266292572021484,
0.41638249158859253,
0.0385025329887867,
-0.4587968587875366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06306v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06306v1
|
A NLP Approach to "Review Bombing" in Metacritic PC Videogames User Ratings
| 2024-05-10T08:31:04 | 2024-05-10T08:31:04 |
Javier Coronado-Blázquez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Many videogames suffer "review bombing" -a large volume of unusually low
scores that in many cases do not reflect the real quality of the product- when
rated by users. By taking Metacritic's 50,000+ user score aggregations for PC
games in English language, we use a Natural Language Processing (NLP) approach
to try to understand the main words and concepts appearing in such cases,
reaching a 0.88 accuracy on a validation set when distinguishing between just
bad ratings and review bombings. By uncovering and analyzing the patterns
driving this phenomenon, these results could be used to further mitigate these
situations.
|
[
-0.8649094700813293,
-0.8461096286773682,
0.43355846405029297,
0.5318979620933533,
-0.317178875207901,
0.347837895154953,
-0.006425600033253431,
-0.7225269675254822,
0.13906793296337128,
0.6405149698257446,
-0.6846265196800232,
-0.5110746026039124,
-0.7238199710845947,
0.23711003363132477,
-0.3245624601840973,
1.2112312316894531,
0.1955893337726593,
0.026247898116707802,
-0.018221069127321243,
0.20879685878753662,
-0.5987343192100525,
-0.8581175208091736,
-0.7012706995010376,
-0.098338782787323,
0.22648969292640686,
0.3981349468231201,
1.0179237127304077,
0.08579577505588531,
1.1225908994674683,
0.22713136672973633,
-0.14318643510341644,
0.22310157120227814,
-0.6467295289039612,
-0.009370293468236923,
-0.18287117779254913,
-0.4302583932876587,
-0.2858659029006958,
0.026582809165120125,
0.05182947218418121,
0.4024564027786255,
0.027767842635512352,
0.28148549795150757,
0.28924721479415894,
0.6282631158828735,
-0.5447306632995605,
-0.2314232885837555,
-0.29077816009521484,
0.4575740694999695,
0.038454052060842514,
-0.503055214881897,
-0.6017712950706482,
-0.0745340883731842,
-0.1426142007112503,
-0.49895843863487244,
0.38144269585609436,
-0.15597988665103912,
0.6842569708824158,
0.1543896645307541,
-0.08369380980730057,
-0.33252018690109253,
-0.9898878335952759,
0.9108224511146545,
-0.7747520804405212,
-0.11834413558244705,
0.5480229258537292,
0.1454138159751892,
-0.476980060338974,
-0.07637613266706467,
-0.3704034388065338,
-0.013945896178483963,
-0.21747395396232605,
0.25855377316474915,
-0.5027129650115967,
0.33985355496406555,
0.43030259013175964,
0.21021665632724762,
-0.6436120271682739,
-0.10010684281587601,
-0.4760015904903412,
-0.12516409158706665,
0.8657397031784058,
0.2400912493467331,
0.47367873787879944,
-0.701967179775238,
-0.6498223543167114,
-0.02999907173216343,
-0.49650654196739197,
0.17319020628929138,
0.4950821101665497,
0.11936888843774796,
0.1556292623281479,
0.6011530756950378,
-0.2294185310602188,
0.5787293314933777,
0.09559214115142822,
-0.20907318592071533,
0.21067628264427185,
-0.5905781984329224,
-0.33756837248802185,
-0.03751930221915245,
0.8585873246192932,
0.8777730464935303,
0.11463057994842529,
0.005884282756596804,
-0.14344392716884613,
0.5962234139442444,
0.6366243958473206,
-0.6696643233299255,
-0.09167422354221344,
0.4605211019515991,
-0.8252221941947937,
-0.5371488928794861,
0.21707357466220856,
-0.9246138334274292,
-0.38598397374153137,
-0.060343172401189804,
0.48265865445137024,
-0.15531036257743835,
-0.016154346987605095,
0.3177669942378998,
-0.5195828676223755,
-0.14110763370990753,
0.10289652645587921,
-0.3867959678173065,
0.35326460003852844,
0.6157134175300598,
0.6731278300285339,
-0.32320207357406616,
-0.2153904139995575,
-0.3877357244491577,
-0.16502587497234344,
-0.42995527386665344,
1.2259939908981323,
-0.3489665985107422,
-0.8295076489448547,
-0.17047862708568573,
-0.2863559424877167,
0.6592559814453125,
-0.671344518661499,
0.868928849697113,
-0.28572288155555725,
0.40513724088668823,
-0.250264436006546,
-0.44094622135162354,
-0.17287437617778778,
0.4749675691127777,
-0.4455944299697876,
0.8403147459030151,
-0.14921599626541138,
-0.5747824311256409,
0.5740387439727783,
-0.36317774653434753,
-0.33858683705329895,
0.22536097466945648,
0.18948575854301453,
-0.12534891068935394,
0.6068828105926514,
0.3090222179889679,
0.5011818408966064,
-0.10693395137786865,
0.14491873979568481,
-0.143642395734787,
-0.7071846723556519,
0.21530863642692566,
-0.45365431904792786,
0.6806665062904358,
0.3363707959651947,
-0.2874656319618225,
0.07907529920339584,
-0.37470415234565735,
0.4168967008590698,
-0.39426159858703613,
-0.3684467375278473,
-0.17532426118850708,
0.39088982343673706,
0.49391964077949524,
0.6648858189582825,
-0.1426958590745926,
-0.2422025501728058,
0.4032733142375946,
-0.5943288207054138,
0.10657187551259995,
0.4053056240081787,
0.6228987574577332,
0.16670942306518555,
-0.39246878027915955,
0.7426124811172485,
-0.04324934259057045,
0.5164176225662231,
0.22043459117412567,
-0.9122927188873291,
-0.36316677927970886,
0.04757501929998398,
-0.1888279765844345,
0.47729018330574036,
-0.760162889957428,
0.7484711408615112,
0.07356348633766174,
-0.6527432799339294,
-0.38535431027412415,
0.28087082505226135,
0.5187831521034241,
0.17621761560440063,
0.47691768407821655,
-0.46958741545677185,
-0.752936065196991,
-0.7197335958480835,
-0.4533451795578003,
-0.6330215334892273,
-0.19600355625152588,
0.19866763055324554,
0.30291441082954407,
-0.3834826648235321,
0.6790926456451416,
-0.5234233140945435,
-0.6953405737876892,
-0.38360869884490967,
0.6870191097259521,
0.29553744196891785,
0.12699665129184723,
0.290343701839447,
-0.8490805625915527,
-0.3845609426498413,
-0.2934226989746094,
-0.4001198410987854,
-0.33148428797721863,
-0.2147037833929062,
-0.11050649732351303,
-0.032396066933870316,
0.5835041403770447,
-0.24777168035507202,
0.5855962634086609,
0.653636634349823,
-0.7362489700317383,
0.6147719025611877,
0.03983345627784729,
0.6409332156181335,
-0.9642294049263,
-0.28447240591049194,
-0.03715497627854347,
-0.058421988040208817,
-0.4269676208496094,
0.32435211539268494,
-0.496565043926239,
0.14567001163959503,
-0.49816766381263733,
0.09452717751264572,
-0.16482704877853394,
0.03088114969432354,
-0.6321671605110168,
0.2138870507478714,
0.2206859141588211,
0.17443889379501343,
0.14990802109241486,
0.5501734614372253,
0.023540426045656204,
-0.4871717691421509,
0.603910505771637,
0.16234207153320312,
-0.6220617890357971,
0.7651754021644592,
-0.4074503481388092,
-0.10250694304704666,
-0.18216919898986816,
0.1884673684835434,
-1.3041480779647827,
0.007627492304891348,
-0.019739385694265366,
-0.6811794638633728,
-0.23056422173976898,
-0.14776496589183807,
-0.4513230621814728,
-0.4553241431713104,
-0.31424593925476074,
0.1427024006843567,
0.5400134921073914,
-0.3192197382450104,
0.24188834428787231,
0.6039989590644836,
0.08810057491064072,
-0.5720664262771606,
-0.7476344108581543,
0.23874838650226593,
-0.21199367940425873,
-0.32864832878112793,
0.3817596137523651,
-0.24944214522838593,
-0.46268758177757263,
0.11999643594026566,
0.04761756956577301,
-0.1640663892030716,
0.12833774089813232,
0.32591015100479126,
0.016425715759396553,
-0.15704993903636932,
0.03664928674697876,
-0.39698275923728943,
-0.3206615149974823,
0.40729618072509766,
0.2613338828086853,
0.5858957767486572,
0.04707961529493332,
0.0046697636134922504,
-0.24210050702095032,
0.6512879133224487,
0.26178863644599915,
0.11133299022912979,
0.41435909271240234,
0.5962393879890442,
-0.3651435077190399,
-0.5156882405281067,
-0.474396675825119,
-0.3284590542316437,
-0.41678449511528015,
0.7132550477981567,
-0.24542389810085297,
-0.4729614853858948,
0.3787674605846405,
0.39182254672050476,
-0.11924773454666138,
0.5446141362190247,
0.6667646765708923,
-0.4516778886318207,
1.4957455396652222,
0.43839868903160095,
-0.4219607710838318,
0.053627386689186096,
0.10661514103412628,
0.25330331921577454,
-0.38877394795417786,
-0.18823657929897308,
-0.7917804718017578,
-0.6969872117042542,
-0.7357529997825623,
-0.562120795249939,
0.3295975625514984,
0.22543248534202576,
-0.0788888931274414,
0.33517181873321533,
-0.7399535775184631,
0.7964460253715515,
0.3474387228488922,
0.041181109845638275,
0.35023775696754456,
0.18729625642299652,
0.16198594868183136,
-0.2796672582626343,
-0.25680917501449585,
-0.37035122513771057,
0.7617217898368835,
0.22795438766479492,
0.6796385049819946,
0.3925425708293915,
0.5193867683410645,
0.7654051184654236,
0.37698400020599365,
-0.9678851962089539,
0.5007607936859131,
-0.2380065619945526,
-0.9741724729537964,
-0.19673152267932892,
-0.5818604230880737,
-0.6053591966629028,
-0.18101796507835388,
-0.5668042898178101,
-0.6640732288360596,
0.025624481961131096,
-0.18046218156814575,
-0.28361019492149353,
0.2075810581445694,
-0.6183472275733948,
0.7481266856193542,
-0.33521008491516113,
-0.2596602141857147,
-0.30604520440101624,
-0.350422739982605,
0.4053247570991516,
0.14107342064380646,
0.4358890950679779,
-0.15698933601379395,
-0.016826307401061058,
0.9503923058509827,
-0.1078837588429451,
0.5871977210044861,
-0.21214841306209564,
0.2683562636375427,
0.44925811886787415,
0.4293190836906433,
0.1532944291830063,
0.06506664305925369,
0.2960997521877289,
0.18349042534828186,
0.04195161908864975,
-0.4007076621055603,
-0.5636662840843201,
0.5199676156044006,
-0.9579490423202515,
-0.23342621326446533,
-0.7015710473060608,
-0.13000987470149994,
-0.46548306941986084,
-0.07084769755601883,
0.7201453447341919,
-0.05101118981838226,
-0.21207058429718018,
0.19563686847686768,
0.4044751226902008,
-0.3599916994571686,
0.3012183606624603,
0.3857305347919464,
-0.7335957884788513,
-0.41479018330574036,
0.5897773504257202,
0.013425586745142937,
0.07136785984039307,
0.34355244040489197,
0.2182522863149643,
-0.16253235936164856,
-0.5399261116981506,
-0.3196532130241394,
-0.01604221574962139,
-0.5521891117095947,
-0.3909975290298462,
-0.32764318585395813,
-0.14382560551166534,
0.06825675070285797,
-0.14701376855373383,
-0.2385847121477127,
0.09257440268993378,
-0.11242139339447021,
-0.35677507519721985,
0.11608988791704178,
1.267999529838562,
0.21724876761436462,
0.4702080190181732,
-0.6785553693771362,
0.6064597964286804,
0.03705804422497749,
0.6611343026161194,
-0.26361578702926636,
-0.7826258540153503,
-0.19115465879440308,
-0.2417396754026413,
-0.31944751739501953,
-1.2236050367355347,
0.5769830346107483,
-0.17878565192222595,
0.2319178730249405,
0.57752525806427,
-0.2157389521598816,
0.9057502150535583,
-0.1848592311143875,
1.1766986846923828,
0.14209407567977905,
-0.8239779472351074,
0.4256315231323242,
-0.30110201239585876,
0.3951011598110199,
0.8316598534584045,
0.682994544506073,
-0.6223961114883423,
-0.32134151458740234,
-0.6394525170326233,
-0.7434223294258118,
0.5631881952285767,
-0.04944983497262001,
0.164036825299263,
-0.18873967230319977,
0.18737055361270905,
-0.10370123386383057,
0.35415107011795044,
-0.7315087914466858,
-0.3830902874469757,
0.0944654792547226,
0.12045653164386749,
-0.6045984625816345,
-0.78300940990448,
0.15397681295871735,
-0.11806634813547134,
0.8284077644348145,
0.18477573990821838,
0.33814987540245056,
0.12599824368953705,
0.17602099478244781,
-0.46275830268859863,
0.3216848373413086,
0.5024226307868958,
0.5950096249580383,
-0.5679132342338562,
0.16189172863960266,
-0.24376565217971802,
-0.7634026408195496,
0.32676106691360474,
-0.5671510696411133,
-0.2084079384803772,
0.026956424117088318,
0.30329445004463196,
0.1506282091140747,
0.16836699843406677,
-0.6898171901702881,
0.6521930694580078,
-0.3111295700073242,
-0.1873622089624405,
-0.045278020203113556,
-0.1225476861000061,
-0.11348853260278702,
-0.32009682059288025,
0.4767465591430664,
0.46760886907577515,
0.6335293054580688,
-0.7571337223052979,
0.5940598249435425,
0.5156018137931824,
-0.6770368814468384,
-0.18521155416965485,
0.24732676148414612,
0.22531701624393463,
-0.28601449728012085,
0.634343683719635,
-0.3957154154777527,
-0.6140797138214111,
0.35371050238609314,
0.6329073309898376,
0.9800900816917419,
-0.1911834180355072,
0.5744261145591736,
0.6137662529945374,
0.7006087303161621,
-0.16457830369472504,
0.5469171404838562,
0.3611597418785095,
-0.7343477606773376,
-0.908447265625,
-0.8418521881103516,
-0.5001877546310425,
0.31776633858680725,
-0.7193487882614136,
0.42589202523231506,
-0.5843945145606995,
-0.41672709584236145,
0.003061724128201604,
0.16692908108234406,
-0.4044220447540283,
0.4918980002403259,
0.3595485985279083,
0.6148985624313354,
-1.1971670389175415,
0.13826322555541992,
0.4823686182498932,
-0.5384693145751953,
-0.9270439743995667,
-0.0007737791165709496,
0.08314498513936996,
-0.1769482046365738,
0.5531882643699646,
0.02980710379779339,
-0.07684551924467087,
-0.4222792088985443,
-0.4518984258174896,
-0.541899561882019,
-0.14772403240203857,
-0.14492447674274445,
-0.36300358176231384,
0.03424135223031044,
0.19270232319831848,
0.9609499573707581,
-0.20459653437137604,
0.6498193144798279,
0.5784439444541931,
0.5431932210922241,
-0.40232372283935547,
-0.5323480367660522,
-0.3309660851955414,
-0.463331937789917,
-0.33379480242729187,
0.3084689676761627,
-0.15997187793254852,
0.4818119406700134,
0.26998910307884216,
-0.176266610622406,
-0.2595366835594177,
0.20415055751800537,
0.07261413335800171,
0.42453378438949585,
0.32629045844078064,
0.5142806172370911,
0.21248485147953033,
-0.3143779933452606,
1.154677391052246,
-0.10968160629272461,
0.32476234436035156,
0.7870107293128967,
0.16181150078773499,
1.3653829097747803,
0.5403245091438293,
-0.5619110465049744,
0.4170146584510803,
0.41975632309913635,
-0.05252552404999733,
0.2888147234916687,
0.2101214975118637,
-0.059608619660139084,
-0.22941581904888153,
0.013780570589005947,
-0.008509565144777298,
0.5911231637001038,
0.3551807999610901,
-0.3712148070335388,
-0.05385769531130791,
0.16855981945991516,
-0.054138440638780594,
0.3137838840484619,
-0.587703287601471,
1.1293158531188965,
-0.11519606411457062,
-0.752016544342041,
0.45878955721855164,
0.21336472034454346,
0.890286922454834,
-0.37508830428123474,
-0.09720267355442047,
-0.06409133970737457,
0.03251364082098007,
-0.722277820110321,
-0.8983415365219116,
0.5099440217018127,
0.25596562027931213,
-0.666340708732605,
-0.2452838271856308,
0.4492577314376831,
0.011499065905809402,
-0.6675748229026794,
0.5631080269813538,
0.5492327809333801,
0.3711625635623932,
-0.2454630583524704,
-0.700661301612854,
0.19688928127288818,
0.23177139461040497,
-0.24969084560871124,
0.23239172995090485,
-0.014852149412035942,
0.10707707703113556,
0.1685187667608261,
0.6077556610107422,
0.5465511083602905,
0.16419580578804016,
-0.12934178113937378,
0.29055169224739075,
-0.7969022989273071,
-0.5964322090148926,
-0.9596647620201111,
0.2806650400161743,
-0.09177321195602417,
-0.5250995755195618,
1.0305310487747192,
0.6525188684463501,
0.9012192487716675,
-0.24565067887306213,
0.7912566065788269,
0.010279468260705471,
0.5983982086181641,
-0.3390192985534668,
0.7361426949501038,
-0.19740906357765198,
0.4005865156650543,
-0.6577990651130676,
-1.3202711343765259,
-0.5648152232170105,
0.6805828213691711,
-0.43929505348205566,
0.13597539067268372,
0.5688396096229553,
0.5765435099601746,
0.16855421662330627,
0.007957084104418755,
0.5070555210113525,
0.4771251380443573,
0.2749316096305847,
0.5333700776100159,
1.0189685821533203,
-0.4609542191028595,
0.48443812131881714,
-0.3715278208255768,
-0.2470676749944687,
-0.34412169456481934,
-0.8158736824989319,
-0.7105000019073486,
-0.3210327923297882,
-0.1536594182252884,
-0.7104064226150513,
-0.1039617508649826,
0.7782301902770996,
0.5479118824005127,
-0.8919524550437927,
-0.37003403902053833,
-0.10139507800340652,
0.08034779876470566,
-0.6031481623649597,
-0.3532278537750244,
0.12538045644760132,
-0.35304757952690125,
-0.694421648979187,
0.40907683968544006,
0.2685355246067047,
-0.39696869254112244,
-0.48955875635147095,
0.08397959172725677,
0.08484987169504166,
0.3038526177406311,
0.49302947521209717,
-0.007544809021055698,
-0.7031717896461487,
-0.20556826889514923,
-0.10358963906764984,
-0.18280792236328125,
0.009419054724276066,
0.676115870475769,
-1.0222735404968262,
0.724051296710968,
0.8826866745948792,
0.3476591110229492,
0.00830509327352047,
0.4328513741493225,
0.3940601050853729,
-0.7781650424003601,
-0.050756342709064484,
0.488349974155426,
-0.005895816721022129,
0.25280997157096863,
-0.5035467743873596,
0.2424963265657425,
0.1775200366973877,
-0.7664372324943542,
-0.9521273970603943,
0.26589375734329224,
-1.076257348060608,
-0.3364033102989197,
0.9969503879547119,
0.26929938793182373,
-0.04244080185890198,
-0.3604373037815094,
-0.5451915264129639,
-0.4952794015407562,
-0.29668882489204407,
1.155935287475586,
0.9588426351547241,
-0.1620086133480072,
0.32004451751708984,
-0.6050020456314087,
0.9717082977294922,
0.2314877063035965,
-0.7203308343887329,
-0.18131916224956512,
0.49536433815956116,
0.030291616916656494,
0.6591989398002625,
0.360215961933136,
-0.1669515073299408,
0.7135956287384033,
0.028514327481389046,
0.10131608694791794,
0.2491476833820343,
-0.38787731528282166,
-0.43484359979629517,
0.6873365640640259,
0.1920916885137558,
0.342117041349411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06301v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06301v1
|
Learning from String Sequences
| 2024-05-10T08:09:53 | 2024-05-10T08:09:53 |
David Lindsay, Sian Lindsay
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The Universal Similarity Metric (USM) has been demonstrated to give
practically useful measures of "similarity" between sequence data. Here we have
used the USM as an alternative distance metric in a K-Nearest Neighbours (K-NN)
learner to allow effective pattern recognition of variable length sequence
data. We compare this USM approach with the commonly used string-to-word vector
approach. Our experiments have used two data sets of divergent domains: (1)
spam email filtering and (2) protein subcellular localization. Our results with
this data reveal that the USM-based K-NN learner (1) gives predictions with
higher classification accuracy than those output by techniques that use the
string-to-word vector approach, and (2) can be used to generate reliable
probability forecasts.
|
[
-0.18271023035049438,
-0.2430451214313507,
0.24740727245807648,
-0.5140441060066223,
-0.4395328760147095,
0.19613666832447052,
-0.18305134773254395,
-0.46831321716308594,
0.12998773157596588,
0.2906791865825653,
-0.23409537971019745,
-0.6879622340202332,
-0.5019805431365967,
0.20675262808799744,
-0.5516464710235596,
0.8379241824150085,
0.2957119643688202,
0.20354443788528442,
-0.3353748917579651,
-0.1399141550064087,
-0.19970308244228363,
-0.6926511526107788,
-0.5190544724464417,
-0.5106509923934937,
0.9170578122138977,
0.4655272960662842,
0.32157522439956665,
0.6998131275177002,
0.862628161907196,
0.31810349225997925,
0.10123012214899063,
-0.05156484246253967,
-0.40860968828201294,
0.010921857319772243,
-0.3020639717578888,
-0.8722459673881531,
0.15350300073623657,
0.2231670618057251,
0.5765307545661926,
0.8613315224647522,
0.07618173211812973,
0.20746588706970215,
-0.06420623511075974,
1.1850899457931519,
-0.27914953231811523,
-0.11555542051792145,
-0.4629009962081909,
0.4762004613876343,
-0.2772841453552246,
-0.20780031383037567,
-0.21188417077064514,
-0.6105172634124756,
0.47039321064949036,
-0.3718932867050171,
0.4531651735305786,
0.17824997007846832,
0.7329927086830139,
0.09303930401802063,
-0.4257636070251465,
-0.3922961354255676,
-0.8899568915367126,
0.8665568232536316,
-0.48971909284591675,
0.5903125405311584,
0.35412368178367615,
0.506908655166626,
-0.5160007476806641,
-0.458679735660553,
-0.3566228151321411,
-0.01859309896826744,
0.08697832375764847,
0.20013345777988434,
-0.05722441151738167,
-0.24599233269691467,
0.2787753641605377,
0.3740454316139221,
-0.7398883104324341,
0.07732660323381424,
-0.7484815120697021,
-0.13352404534816742,
0.6046207547187805,
0.1737445741891861,
0.12346863001585007,
-0.09348538517951965,
-0.5447410941123962,
-0.27301281690597534,
-0.7222217917442322,
0.3536926507949829,
0.46136564016342163,
0.4699740409851074,
0.1693684607744217,
0.28266602754592896,
-0.054159753024578094,
0.5168098211288452,
-0.1363479197025299,
-0.23912425339221954,
-0.01316815335303545,
0.13454927504062653,
-0.13944897055625916,
0.038932301104068756,
0.6524459719657898,
0.3816962242126465,
0.32066184282302856,
-0.3548785448074341,
0.07542511820793152,
0.09346739947795868,
0.39595261216163635,
-0.5986480116844177,
-0.4926741421222687,
-0.21844469010829926,
-0.768028974533081,
0.06216990202665329,
0.5998043417930603,
-0.6941534876823425,
-0.008686651475727558,
-0.5075398087501526,
0.30978846549987793,
-0.6121745705604553,
0.15008269250392914,
0.008217934519052505,
-0.44175317883491516,
0.347826212644577,
-0.13707123696804047,
-0.6265864968299866,
0.6515516638755798,
0.6626615524291992,
1.1230113506317139,
-0.5196837186813354,
-0.16712486743927002,
-0.30088603496551514,
-0.2314208745956421,
-0.3544750213623047,
0.7276352047920227,
-0.6575163006782532,
-0.5241241455078125,
-0.3130446672439575,
-0.18566307425498962,
0.0008111443603411317,
-0.7041870355606079,
0.2066393494606018,
-0.7731820940971375,
0.1452893167734146,
-0.2076777070760727,
-0.9930788278579712,
-0.7151735424995422,
-0.14262065291404724,
-0.558555543422699,
0.8874126076698303,
0.3091900050640106,
-0.7176074981689453,
0.5106157660484314,
-0.40951573848724365,
-0.21917866170406342,
0.1218954548239708,
0.050513315945863724,
-0.48705747723579407,
0.43828463554382324,
-0.389495313167572,
0.7813827991485596,
-0.12956979870796204,
-0.2750576436519623,
-0.4431559145450592,
-0.8025091290473938,
0.3689614534378052,
-0.3805444836616516,
0.31795066595077515,
0.3797518312931061,
0.09783145785331726,
-0.3517581522464752,
-0.8709135055541992,
-0.07364091277122498,
-0.033277612179517746,
-0.393521785736084,
-0.8436842560768127,
-0.0912453755736351,
-0.34242963790893555,
0.14824533462524414,
-0.1733379364013672,
-0.6229786276817322,
0.16432100534439087,
-0.35172900557518005,
0.20783232152462006,
0.8128235340118408,
-0.1511906087398529,
0.5346006155014038,
-0.5024263858795166,
0.4548853933811188,
0.2821566164493561,
-0.19898317754268646,
-0.11044090986251831,
-0.5444976687431335,
-0.3998516798019409,
-0.2582976222038269,
0.7046355605125427,
0.5499089956283569,
-0.37777718901634216,
0.4467875063419342,
-0.541425883769989,
-0.5559269785881042,
-0.1163436770439148,
0.06173117086291313,
0.3410013020038605,
0.35130688548088074,
0.3024385869503021,
-0.8371482491493225,
-0.6477113366127014,
-0.38994261622428894,
-0.5371906161308289,
-0.05829741060733795,
-0.4265703558921814,
0.4691539704799652,
0.44382622838020325,
-0.20187510550022125,
0.8514931201934814,
-0.49312466382980347,
-0.17816153168678284,
0.20501387119293213,
0.07115580886602402,
0.28425517678260803,
0.2931213676929474,
0.23803092539310455,
-0.837431788444519,
-0.7368863821029663,
-0.09653211385011673,
-0.5701416730880737,
0.35449540615081787,
0.14356684684753418,
0.05551045015454292,
0.08905410021543503,
0.250214159488678,
-0.09301460534334183,
0.6653805375099182,
0.21655695140361786,
-0.5681890249252319,
0.27577635645866394,
-0.28977644443511963,
0.2397576868534088,
-1.1713699102401733,
-0.14229658246040344,
0.26492297649383545,
-0.4555051922798157,
-0.7696226239204407,
-0.3654860556125641,
-0.03848309814929962,
0.33116382360458374,
-0.44374656677246094,
0.35719096660614014,
-0.24482150375843048,
-0.6747617125511169,
-0.3493291735649109,
-0.14585372805595398,
-0.2401410937309265,
0.34474921226501465,
-0.002590167336165905,
0.5961282849311829,
0.5176330208778381,
-0.9070515036582947,
0.4354827404022217,
0.24908602237701416,
-0.6272034049034119,
0.6878805160522461,
-0.2342558056116104,
0.23376375436782837,
-0.08160039782524109,
0.0824444368481636,
-0.9106530547142029,
-0.05334918573498726,
0.009573426097631454,
-0.7626400589942932,
0.3363625407218933,
0.07307541370391846,
-0.1864895522594452,
-0.7460454702377319,
-0.36917275190353394,
0.4747523069381714,
0.8932527899742126,
-0.9935867190361023,
0.10284721851348877,
0.14542412757873535,
0.06367325782775879,
-0.4217028021812439,
-0.4635077118873596,
-0.21300746500492096,
-0.7369738221168518,
-0.0265957098454237,
0.14598555862903595,
-0.06846340000629425,
0.1386837512254715,
-0.21335196495056152,
-0.3639138638973236,
-0.14592283964157104,
0.12385134398937225,
0.48233088850975037,
0.14657747745513916,
-0.2658589482307434,
0.19942007958889008,
-0.4262060225009918,
-0.010282575152814388,
-0.02034282125532627,
-0.7685952186584473,
0.13126283884048462,
0.04934392869472504,
-0.136095330119133,
-0.28541144728660583,
0.3598877489566803,
0.01559326983988285,
0.3154344856739044,
0.3089906871318817,
0.4654757082462311,
-0.42415207624435425,
-0.22233149409294128,
-0.12353025376796722,
-0.38459479808807373,
-0.4769541621208191,
0.10658244043588638,
-0.3600129783153534,
-1.0708911418914795,
0.3104564845561981,
-0.42168647050857544,
-0.3569360375404358,
0.21211402118206024,
-0.06839961558580399,
-0.3928614854812622,
0.7748565077781677,
0.8826717138290405,
-0.34408342838287354,
0.45763418078422546,
-0.25648853182792664,
0.20254622399806976,
-0.8468589782714844,
-0.29474717378616333,
-0.5210084915161133,
-0.6728561520576477,
-0.5545244812965393,
-0.6784651875495911,
-0.08214402943849564,
0.34217414259910583,
-0.21436351537704468,
0.6863199472427368,
-0.2932431697845459,
0.5739346742630005,
0.7558635473251343,
-0.024190232157707214,
0.047835301607847214,
0.36182472109794617,
-0.6178815960884094,
-0.1421782225370407,
-0.6775750517845154,
-0.5187102556228638,
1.2353192567825317,
0.18133816123008728,
0.692280650138855,
-0.0008600520668551326,
0.8011329770088196,
0.35583579540252686,
0.3300939202308655,
-0.7253898978233337,
0.343157559633255,
-0.6653302907943726,
-0.012250611558556557,
-0.34689050912857056,
-0.7303016185760498,
-1.1972039937973022,
0.04537444934248924,
-0.0553332157433033,
-0.8184787631034851,
-0.16467386484146118,
-0.1789425015449524,
-0.21953298151493073,
0.714466392993927,
-0.1723560243844986,
0.3315078914165497,
0.06896252185106277,
0.4439264237880707,
0.165938138961792,
-0.7719283103942871,
-0.00021643278887495399,
-0.18009425699710846,
0.15500162541866302,
-0.3270295560359955,
-0.0662175863981247,
1.013770580291748,
-0.3448041081428528,
0.7034332752227783,
0.18037720024585724,
-0.1090407446026802,
0.3846666216850281,
-0.15219634771347046,
0.05148915946483612,
-0.07860571891069412,
0.05339553579688072,
0.5458566546440125,
-0.20397019386291504,
-0.39465048909187317,
-0.5649497509002686,
0.7768552303314209,
-0.6267645359039307,
-0.2862175405025482,
-0.5026774406433105,
-0.45908138155937195,
-0.04887266084551811,
0.08273343741893768,
0.37478139996528625,
0.46839770674705505,
-0.25284215807914734,
0.06097222492098808,
0.6139307618141174,
-0.01284016016870737,
0.5789222121238708,
0.9056261777877808,
0.02533612959086895,
-0.42132994532585144,
1.1365760564804077,
-0.0023529641330242157,
-0.06164167821407318,
0.7960569858551025,
0.45228320360183716,
-0.5720177292823792,
-0.31774967908859253,
-0.11505991965532303,
-0.04733636602759361,
-0.48316195607185364,
-0.5804125070571899,
-0.3793795704841614,
-0.211537167429924,
0.02268732152879238,
-0.07393717020750046,
-0.12013094872236252,
-0.4642212390899658,
-0.2054452896118164,
-0.15175461769104004,
0.7437297105789185,
1.0647670030593872,
-0.3763870298862457,
0.1571008265018463,
-1.0284314155578613,
0.09739984571933746,
0.24110613763332367,
0.6080693602561951,
-0.177343487739563,
-0.7368685603141785,
-0.3032774031162262,
0.02966245450079441,
-0.35187169909477234,
-0.6647759079933167,
0.3075554668903351,
0.6977050304412842,
0.3340531289577484,
0.5203776955604553,
-0.15214531123638153,
0.5438156127929688,
-0.8667166233062744,
0.9159265756607056,
0.3624815046787262,
-0.6313002705574036,
0.4880578815937042,
-0.029731448739767075,
0.31685110926628113,
0.25158098340034485,
1.02959144115448,
-0.7877604365348816,
-0.4332670569419861,
-0.7211398482322693,
-0.42901328206062317,
0.4201262593269348,
0.057149361819028854,
0.06524844467639923,
-0.21172885596752167,
0.9616016745567322,
0.645818293094635,
0.08643697202205658,
-0.026899956166744232,
-0.6873340010643005,
0.02487103082239628,
-0.18857838213443756,
-0.7346259951591492,
0.05830725282430649,
0.5034161806106567,
-0.25213897228240967,
0.40072694420814514,
-0.20059603452682495,
0.5690197944641113,
0.134466752409935,
0.1006363183259964,
-0.1396494060754776,
0.0707865059375763,
0.47162485122680664,
0.4595106244087219,
-0.06844139844179153,
0.30728697776794434,
0.3337107300758362,
-0.818943202495575,
0.45700401067733765,
-0.24433398246765137,
-0.05105823650956154,
0.33882832527160645,
0.23894791305065155,
0.3472825288772583,
0.14572006464004517,
-0.4446514844894409,
0.3840101957321167,
-0.21332907676696777,
-0.34453830122947693,
0.10331366956233978,
0.13826392590999603,
-0.025531485676765442,
0.22805318236351013,
0.15356746315956116,
0.17463356256484985,
0.31979575753211975,
-0.3181628882884979,
0.7153846621513367,
0.371869832277298,
-0.8157722353935242,
-0.6458650231361389,
0.43299177289009094,
-0.18335865437984467,
-0.5190324187278748,
0.5259313583374023,
-0.042202532291412354,
-0.7417541146278381,
0.7594759464263916,
0.7259384989738464,
0.5976155400276184,
-0.6473045945167542,
0.343817800283432,
0.4466482698917389,
-0.31940653920173645,
-0.3933534026145935,
0.5447792410850525,
-0.024714969098567963,
-0.5460851192474365,
-0.06281337887048721,
-0.7127944231033325,
-0.1344587653875351,
0.15393517911434174,
-0.9236258864402771,
-0.05174295976758003,
-0.4469422996044159,
-0.00020373145525809377,
0.06650867313146591,
0.2957019507884979,
-0.7772267460823059,
0.37337827682495117,
0.08348962664604187,
0.8824606537818909,
-0.7695106863975525,
0.7463452816009521,
0.8715477585792542,
0.028543220832943916,
-0.6510992050170898,
-0.11563146114349365,
0.1071772649884224,
-0.42731040716171265,
0.6298098564147949,
0.6243678331375122,
0.11899328231811523,
-0.3910968601703644,
-0.1756906658411026,
-0.9776991009712219,
1.1909068822860718,
-0.008793804794549942,
-0.8258612155914307,
0.3207113444805145,
0.3638363480567932,
0.6297783851623535,
-0.5877379775047302,
0.12055654078722,
0.5308728218078613,
-0.2203679233789444,
0.14855340123176575,
-0.5136804580688477,
-0.14481958746910095,
-0.04337090253829956,
0.4040394723415375,
0.7740524411201477,
-0.6498681902885437,
0.6899111270904541,
-0.24939106404781342,
-0.24099110066890717,
0.17998455464839935,
0.887937068939209,
-0.13506899774074554,
0.3764615058898926,
0.4438241124153137,
0.5763454437255859,
1.0821822881698608,
0.2575148046016693,
0.7090158462524414,
0.025132382288575172,
0.3550199270248413,
1.0064128637313843,
-0.13007159531116486,
1.1725717782974243,
0.28162238001823425,
-0.5323566794395447,
0.7960696816444397,
0.7960535883903503,
-0.19270959496498108,
0.7526167035102844,
0.8183301091194153,
-0.21873030066490173,
-0.017911018803715706,
0.20444278419017792,
-0.2134379893541336,
0.36975371837615967,
0.41526103019714355,
-0.19409732520580292,
-0.08102250844240189,
0.03413044661283493,
-0.5369769930839539,
0.38915109634399414,
-0.5523439645767212,
0.9985938668251038,
0.635587751865387,
-0.23722238838672638,
0.4245367646217346,
-0.05312987416982651,
0.76188063621521,
-0.21768048405647278,
-0.11383352428674698,
-0.1758945733308792,
0.2722610831260681,
0.029255129396915436,
-0.43428748846054077,
0.41103407740592957,
0.015868064016103745,
-0.37067896127700806,
0.237062007188797,
0.8369453549385071,
-0.40191343426704407,
-0.45392802357673645,
0.29077351093292236,
0.19978904724121094,
0.7224406003952026,
0.23915450274944305,
-0.7103347778320312,
-0.7259475588798523,
-0.34539517760276794,
0.16289320588111877,
0.3875732123851776,
0.3821667432785034,
-0.04280293360352516,
0.6749181747436523,
0.6957159638404846,
0.14811941981315613,
0.12067343294620514,
-0.07548849284648895,
0.4207973778247833,
-0.9853376150131226,
-0.5159066915512085,
-0.873598039150238,
-0.3136250376701355,
0.030220935121178627,
-0.052028629928827286,
0.9823959469795227,
0.7118674516677856,
1.2928270101547241,
-0.20709314942359924,
0.7586187124252319,
0.40976908802986145,
0.8994214534759521,
-0.3903101682662964,
0.2452346831560135,
-0.4343183636665344,
0.1882275640964508,
-0.1629631072282791,
-1.1197668313980103,
-0.30954909324645996,
0.6982007026672363,
-0.014299928210675716,
0.045025844126939774,
0.6275826096534729,
0.47723037004470825,
-0.200332373380661,
0.329845130443573,
0.7034263014793396,
-0.27414581179618835,
-0.05830835923552513,
0.9800108075141907,
1.0455641746520996,
-0.6863487362861633,
0.3151344358921051,
-0.30716079473495483,
-0.05273546278476715,
-0.12699849903583527,
-0.8626059889793396,
-1.4746623039245605,
-0.675331711769104,
-0.28950580954551697,
-0.16693450510501862,
0.17332765460014343,
1.010604977607727,
0.6624417304992676,
-0.9931662082672119,
-0.06654851138591766,
-0.14376820623874664,
0.20032888650894165,
-0.40373486280441284,
-0.06755556911230087,
0.36771392822265625,
-0.1373147815465927,
-0.4494765102863312,
0.24573040008544922,
0.28410372138023376,
0.4051910638809204,
0.10489650070667267,
-0.19407640397548676,
0.04908335581421852,
0.3949795067310333,
0.350754976272583,
0.44094929099082947,
-0.6533985733985901,
-0.6755108833312988,
-0.04104001447558403,
-0.035359106957912445,
0.3175356984138489,
0.7763630151748657,
-0.7228928804397583,
0.19533449411392212,
0.4156954884529114,
0.556160569190979,
-0.06851199269294739,
0.20070280134677887,
0.7398200631141663,
-0.8278781175613403,
-0.21824301779270172,
-0.05322754755616188,
0.17163366079330444,
0.43614867329597473,
-0.5579708218574524,
0.5375280380249023,
0.21080631017684937,
-0.5242053270339966,
-0.29901552200317383,
0.3695276379585266,
-0.47184452414512634,
-0.11547605693340302,
0.9425944089889526,
-0.551796019077301,
-0.3813333809375763,
-0.2844682037830353,
0.08945274353027344,
0.2608186900615692,
-0.3385034203529358,
0.7437518239021301,
0.4658862352371216,
0.004687943961471319,
0.3032938838005066,
-0.23475727438926697,
0.894492506980896,
0.24734066426753998,
-0.5910859704017639,
-0.45764926075935364,
0.019623860716819763,
0.6879583597183228,
0.15467920899391174,
0.2892080545425415,
0.13173998892307281,
0.3379773199558258,
-0.19753475487232208,
-0.38574835658073425,
0.3018600642681122,
-0.6748330593109131,
-0.7082744836807251,
-0.1832844316959381,
-0.2784298360347748,
-0.2991445064544678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06295v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06295v1
|
Aspect-oriented Consumer Health Answer Summarization
| 2024-05-10T07:52:43 | 2024-05-10T07:52:43 |
Rochana Chaturvedi, Abari Bhattacharya, Shweta Yadav
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, H.4.3; I.2.7; J.3; J.7; K.6.4
|
Community Question-Answering (CQA) forums have revolutionized how people seek
information, especially those related to their healthcare needs, placing their
trust in the collective wisdom of the public. However, there can be several
answers in response to a single query, which makes it hard to grasp the key
information related to the specific health concern. Typically, CQA forums
feature a single top-voted answer as a representative summary for each query.
However, a single answer overlooks the alternative solutions and other
information frequently offered in other responses. Our research focuses on
aspect-based summarization of health answers to address this limitation.
Summarization of responses under different aspects such as suggestions,
information, personal experiences, and questions can enhance the usability of
the platforms. We formalize a multi-stage annotation guideline and contribute a
unique dataset comprising aspect-based human-written health answer summaries.
We build an automated multi-faceted answer summarization pipeline with this
dataset based on task-specific fine-tuning of several state-of-the-art models.
The pipeline leverages question similarity to retrieve relevant answer
sentences, subsequently classifying them into the appropriate aspect type.
Following this, we employ several recent abstractive summarization models to
generate aspect-based summaries. Finally, we present a comprehensive human
analysis and find that our summaries rank high in capturing relevant content
and a wide range of solutions.
|
[
-0.403369277715683,
-0.7137749195098877,
0.7157109975814819,
0.08812712132930756,
-0.30629709362983704,
0.07481008768081665,
0.2905636727809906,
-0.6304952502250671,
0.8681851029396057,
0.8501406908035278,
-0.45571258664131165,
-0.5206032991409302,
-0.41123470664024353,
0.01167019922286272,
-0.1425361931324005,
1.2739202976226807,
0.2341737002134323,
-0.1247357726097107,
-0.3391626477241516,
-0.30494192242622375,
-0.09755066782236099,
-0.7408402562141418,
-0.5717705488204956,
-0.23454248905181885,
0.8262967467308044,
0.8895232081413269,
0.48595696687698364,
0.47082045674324036,
0.49895426630973816,
0.24726064503192902,
-0.3535824716091156,
0.04913770407438278,
-0.006029191892594099,
0.25266143679618835,
-0.055828459560871124,
-0.3573453426361084,
-0.9521735906600952,
-0.19332797825336456,
0.05922345444560051,
1.0938040018081665,
-0.1422433704137802,
0.6400203108787537,
0.46325013041496277,
0.9026675224304199,
-0.475403755903244,
-0.06856141984462738,
-0.1922544687986374,
0.12973205745220184,
0.04035838693380356,
-0.18787918984889984,
0.10426042973995209,
-0.2929520308971405,
0.13971605896949768,
-0.7106943130493164,
0.3056495487689972,
0.026578180491924286,
0.37714433670043945,
0.1806892603635788,
-0.6772280335426331,
-0.17624212801456451,
-0.6739529371261597,
0.4348425567150116,
-0.8989202976226807,
0.01094834879040718,
0.32661405205726624,
0.22194929420948029,
0.09207381308078766,
-0.5628136992454529,
-0.3580220341682434,
0.5144611597061157,
-0.45846688747406006,
0.42375412583351135,
-0.13439898192882538,
0.36260297894477844,
-0.13546022772789001,
0.6666645407676697,
-0.6349408030509949,
-0.3019219934940338,
-0.44181308150291443,
-0.4411487281322479,
0.6967187523841858,
0.41354450583457947,
0.09302355349063873,
-0.561155378818512,
0.01907903142273426,
0.09642868489027023,
-0.5113528370857239,
0.5114160776138306,
-0.2629149258136749,
0.2083214372396469,
-0.13499361276626587,
0.7036556005477905,
-0.9621309041976929,
0.3346066474914551,
0.2723970115184784,
-0.41795673966407776,
0.27347856760025024,
-0.5184349417686462,
0.10226339101791382,
0.07913100719451904,
0.496753066778183,
0.90793776512146,
-0.5795717239379883,
-0.08262211084365845,
0.028486724942922592,
-0.6735787987709045,
0.2762070596218109,
-0.8801857829093933,
-0.378914475440979,
0.9871509075164795,
-0.9534410834312439,
-0.24605697393417358,
0.030154813081026077,
-0.6855463981628418,
-0.5439192652702332,
-0.37124043703079224,
0.14820146560668945,
0.04735029488801956,
-0.21966564655303955,
-0.037689801305532455,
-0.19799600541591644,
-0.06116124987602234,
0.37838295102119446,
-0.5027245283126831,
0.325697124004364,
0.8266262412071228,
0.7464913725852966,
-0.10522085428237915,
0.1719932109117508,
-0.6002092361450195,
0.1608695536851883,
0.17048850655555725,
0.902226448059082,
-0.13090653717517853,
-0.46908998489379883,
-0.022987104952335358,
0.2248973250389099,
0.32056725025177,
-0.5361517667770386,
0.3029472529888153,
-0.2934291660785675,
0.20932945609092712,
-0.7713765501976013,
-0.20987291634082794,
-0.44604557752609253,
0.7513126730918884,
-0.5375983715057373,
0.5226280689239502,
0.12075257301330566,
-1.0758024454116821,
0.23132647573947906,
-0.6073552966117859,
-0.5203370451927185,
0.05308912321925163,
-0.1391906887292862,
-0.5684314370155334,
0.38890331983566284,
0.7050774693489075,
0.3377665877342224,
-0.16225537657737732,
-0.08161044120788574,
-0.22353504598140717,
0.0006009340286254883,
0.44983047246932983,
-0.06702127307653427,
0.4436394274234772,
0.18160094320774078,
-0.10197019577026367,
0.5656278729438782,
-0.5009044408798218,
-0.015874871984124184,
-0.33102092146873474,
-0.2879861295223236,
-0.23498161137104034,
-0.023251943290233612,
0.022010067477822304,
0.4514055550098419,
0.4601641595363617,
-0.5541008710861206,
-0.07977037131786346,
-0.312905490398407,
0.40419846773147583,
0.3766271471977234,
0.8585056662559509,
0.1564769446849823,
-0.7456799745559692,
0.792537271976471,
0.4129529893398285,
0.6307111978530884,
-0.5499861836433411,
-0.7151262164115906,
-0.613786518573761,
-0.017169289290905,
-0.038864534348249435,
0.43820467591285706,
-0.8925297260284424,
0.31982094049453735,
-0.22893603146076202,
-0.46640288829803467,
-0.6127392649650574,
0.12235243618488312,
0.5229105353355408,
0.7949579358100891,
0.5807141661643982,
-0.6800570487976074,
-0.10163300484418869,
-1.219444751739502,
-0.14180730283260345,
-0.4602925777435303,
-0.238224059343338,
0.32477229833602905,
0.12510696053504944,
0.3218245506286621,
0.7659977078437805,
-0.8656806349754333,
-0.16722357273101807,
-0.5324634909629822,
0.15787149965763092,
0.15267302095890045,
0.19015230238437653,
0.3472576141357422,
-0.9253274202346802,
-0.07923620194196701,
0.00014699452731292695,
-0.5356109142303467,
-0.057755496352910995,
0.051286906003952026,
-0.07821217179298401,
-0.23146046698093414,
0.164181649684906,
-0.032508451491594315,
0.49890974164009094,
0.33600354194641113,
-0.3777778744697571,
0.40740516781806946,
-0.12166471779346466,
0.5531072616577148,
-1.440972089767456,
0.2100810408592224,
-0.1353595107793808,
-0.37981298565864563,
-0.506703794002533,
0.1902044713497162,
-0.17004752159118652,
-0.143752321600914,
-0.4898684024810791,
0.3075905740261078,
0.004769749939441681,
-0.026149380952119827,
-0.4998612701892853,
-0.005560536868870258,
0.25091779232025146,
0.5754037499427795,
0.10041210055351257,
0.4384622573852539,
0.09011729806661606,
-0.6718651652336121,
0.20639462769031525,
0.3285672962665558,
0.1770823895931244,
0.6380682587623596,
-0.9209421873092651,
0.1004180908203125,
-0.47910258173942566,
0.519134521484375,
-0.8556045889854431,
-0.6438913941383362,
0.48515042662620544,
-0.5238569378852844,
-0.4495701193809509,
0.12023493647575378,
-0.15500517189502716,
-0.28120681643486023,
-0.6619753837585449,
0.540152370929718,
0.11205323040485382,
-0.1444711536169052,
0.6161046028137207,
0.7363324165344238,
-0.7973759770393372,
-0.43328654766082764,
-0.6744230389595032,
-0.06835546344518661,
-0.2929393947124481,
-0.30901968479156494,
0.20073334872722626,
-0.13289916515350342,
-0.18096113204956055,
0.12482759356498718,
-0.2094324827194214,
-0.31922438740730286,
0.13926534354686737,
0.4590502083301544,
-0.10641853511333466,
-0.20341460406780243,
0.17559313774108887,
0.35059109330177307,
0.04266265407204628,
0.2759341597557068,
-0.23417165875434875,
0.2518840432167053,
-0.10000549256801605,
-0.41556665301322937,
-0.455949604511261,
1.1437177658081055,
0.43074607849121094,
-0.34757307171821594,
0.4420574903488159,
0.17732256650924683,
-0.5000014901161194,
0.5982663035392761,
-0.3348807394504547,
-0.15160837769508362,
-0.3830316364765167,
0.3636658489704132,
-0.04681926220655441,
-1.0934358835220337,
0.7216212749481201,
0.27320045232772827,
0.5456860661506653,
0.4564017057418823,
0.41887563467025757,
-0.3310700058937073,
0.8669734597206116,
0.501969039440155,
-0.13242360949516296,
0.02280334196984768,
0.01765667274594307,
0.017860621213912964,
-0.9798383712768555,
-0.4864639937877655,
-0.4690135419368744,
-0.4964841604232788,
-0.3949492275714874,
-0.2848316729068756,
0.9827504754066467,
0.060291364789009094,
-0.0514889694750309,
0.17209944128990173,
-0.9318463802337646,
0.0244159959256649,
0.44818687438964844,
0.7172584533691406,
0.6809374094009399,
-0.4753706455230713,
0.250438928604126,
0.05305945873260498,
-0.5467777848243713,
-0.36993640661239624,
1.1043978929519653,
0.34694963693618774,
0.4002282917499542,
0.4266752600669861,
0.7902066111564636,
0.16273579001426697,
0.5625776052474976,
-0.6660457253456116,
0.3135201036930084,
-0.12422958016395569,
-0.5793927311897278,
-0.17727439105510712,
-0.39298057556152344,
-0.7368549108505249,
0.13694259524345398,
-0.319156676530838,
-0.7001940011978149,
0.33694612979888916,
0.5977451205253601,
-0.8415461778640747,
0.0746321901679039,
-0.3262847661972046,
0.590126633644104,
-0.18608368933200836,
-0.03741401806473732,
-0.12491391599178314,
-0.818034291267395,
0.4272196590900421,
0.07490121573209763,
0.4966703951358795,
-0.07299866527318954,
-0.036665573716163635,
0.6535789966583252,
-0.6375060677528381,
0.641507089138031,
-0.06397457420825958,
0.20894233882427216,
0.32821139693260193,
-0.3859063982963562,
-0.1941782683134079,
0.5648002624511719,
0.15647903084754944,
-0.2748757302761078,
0.2186061292886734,
-0.7928795218467712,
-0.6145193576812744,
0.5371809005737305,
-0.5364426970481873,
-0.733809232711792,
-0.3215577006340027,
-0.17774680256843567,
-0.2860579788684845,
0.02196415886282921,
0.27718985080718994,
0.5958532691001892,
-0.14041882753372192,
-0.10657248646020889,
0.6704348921775818,
-0.3911357522010803,
0.25231310725212097,
0.4398081302642822,
-0.44666779041290283,
-0.6201817393302917,
0.585766613483429,
-0.18904125690460205,
0.061600279062986374,
0.5439343452453613,
0.3045192062854767,
-0.0632990375161171,
-0.49172893166542053,
-0.4610922634601593,
-0.007503129076212645,
-0.6668211817741394,
-0.37922000885009766,
-0.8429567217826843,
-0.3080022633075714,
-0.5820081830024719,
-0.028490129858255386,
-0.10599083453416824,
-0.7321313619613647,
0.01642945595085621,
-0.06367680430412292,
0.4012793302536011,
0.9508360624313354,
0.02096535451710224,
0.4010844826698303,
-1.1244992017745972,
0.41144248843193054,
0.6526411175727844,
0.05298978462815285,
0.21933172643184662,
-0.19840966165065765,
-0.33480584621429443,
0.05698520317673683,
-0.7692930698394775,
-1.0227605104446411,
0.019670844078063965,
0.04600725322961807,
0.3346083164215088,
0.44438594579696655,
0.32934558391571045,
0.5498269200325012,
-0.05329860374331474,
1.2083131074905396,
0.3404027223587036,
-0.6690322756767273,
0.7617416977882385,
-0.18368598818778992,
0.7741342782974243,
0.9948858022689819,
0.20985491573810577,
-0.9729318022727966,
-0.6340554356575012,
-0.44658470153808594,
-1.2983849048614502,
0.1519925892353058,
0.1337924599647522,
0.06566530466079712,
0.024063492193818092,
0.572434663772583,
0.12718243896961212,
0.2064516395330429,
-0.38947004079818726,
-0.48402294516563416,
-0.5133157968521118,
-0.17751842737197876,
0.24409373104572296,
-0.0930916965007782,
-0.18431459367275238,
-0.2642223536968231,
0.612240195274353,
-0.2577637732028961,
-0.011582749895751476,
0.6405708193778992,
0.01945129968225956,
0.10599785298109055,
0.7378101944923401,
0.3730156123638153,
0.8073500990867615,
-0.1863640546798706,
0.28348711133003235,
-0.017114199697971344,
-0.6401928067207336,
-0.05555303022265434,
0.15075936913490295,
-0.11216521263122559,
-0.03686134144663811,
0.4752548038959503,
0.1748332977294922,
0.23805665969848633,
-0.4746342897415161,
0.609184741973877,
-0.3306358754634857,
-0.028999891132116318,
-0.3992583453655243,
0.01782100833952427,
0.23949280381202698,
0.07516339421272278,
0.49954062700271606,
-0.008096140809357166,
0.8594833016395569,
-0.5529913902282715,
0.32945069670677185,
-0.010725632309913635,
-0.8351348042488098,
-0.4735610783100128,
0.7770121693611145,
0.514539897441864,
-0.1864091157913208,
0.4395427703857422,
-0.005076989531517029,
-0.4128616154193878,
0.5891729593276978,
-0.05681698024272919,
0.7947614192962646,
-0.14467817544937134,
0.46251967549324036,
0.467928946018219,
0.06719765067100525,
0.2897128760814667,
0.4131571352481842,
-0.15431778132915497,
-0.16529648005962372,
-0.6748148202896118,
-0.3869147300720215,
-0.60830157995224,
0.0750509575009346,
-1.1932765245437622,
-0.18704754114151,
-0.40447041392326355,
-0.06648106873035431,
0.3302518427371979,
-0.16762787103652954,
-0.5793886780738831,
0.38864126801490784,
-0.0044823638163506985,
0.8035038113594055,
-0.8420979380607605,
0.43642061948776245,
1.1788153648376465,
-0.6930204629898071,
-0.7877663969993591,
0.38930901885032654,
0.1912175863981247,
-0.24524518847465515,
-0.2944275438785553,
0.19460394978523254,
0.0527929924428463,
-0.6701915860176086,
-0.40937340259552,
-0.5192326307296753,
1.3570917844772339,
-0.13941581547260284,
-0.3029991686344147,
-0.13703106343746185,
0.30531302094459534,
0.5724664926528931,
-0.5271914005279541,
0.33496931195259094,
0.5549697279930115,
0.1965494006872177,
0.09752565622329712,
-1.0191986560821533,
0.13861727714538574,
-0.2935042083263397,
-0.15537548065185547,
0.00927337072789669,
-0.703071117401123,
0.6664839386940002,
-0.1284167617559433,
0.17026424407958984,
-0.03891923278570175,
0.9079826474189758,
0.3263136148452759,
0.7659249305725098,
0.5881321430206299,
0.3223719894886017,
0.5183386206626892,
0.15438631176948547,
0.9418220520019531,
-0.3806435763835907,
0.15057402849197388,
1.451173186302185,
0.28086400032043457,
0.8107706308364868,
0.2936657667160034,
-0.10754993557929993,
0.45406270027160645,
0.7864099144935608,
0.9108097553253174,
0.5051684379577637,
0.07535217702388763,
-0.4157266914844513,
-0.3276033103466034,
-0.43174025416374207,
-0.19388101994991302,
0.47490257024765015,
0.3424735367298126,
-0.39343544840812683,
-0.21982388198375702,
0.013270432129502296,
0.10741791874170303,
0.1950800120830536,
-0.5365174412727356,
1.240583896636963,
0.1610608845949173,
-0.6607635617256165,
-0.1227656826376915,
-0.09902728348970413,
0.48845672607421875,
-0.10015879571437836,
-0.14243479073047638,
-0.5211648941040039,
-0.2525539696216583,
-0.4642552137374878,
-0.9570332765579224,
0.6054873466491699,
-0.06230456009507179,
-0.566307783126831,
0.014675160869956017,
0.34472212195396423,
-0.41641128063201904,
-0.5447850227355957,
-0.2515636682510376,
0.6241103410720825,
0.26361972093582153,
-0.3731493353843689,
-0.7429986596107483,
-0.31542229652404785,
-0.028572486713528633,
-0.24731798470020294,
0.19743400812149048,
0.3855512738227844,
-0.15279775857925415,
0.35478776693344116,
0.16678506135940552,
0.06267279386520386,
-0.44436290860176086,
-0.27617284655570984,
1.0531927347183228,
-0.660377025604248,
-0.7583173513412476,
-0.2650417685508728,
0.8627499938011169,
-0.3802854120731354,
-0.7356184124946594,
0.3644143044948578,
0.8784887194633484,
0.34858235716819763,
0.31713569164276123,
0.9562816619873047,
-0.11051473766565323,
1.0015214681625366,
-0.2968738377094269,
0.8279834985733032,
-0.7622871398925781,
0.3253708481788635,
-0.10786527395248413,
-0.6205977201461792,
-0.169803649187088,
-0.0927480012178421,
0.056677963584661484,
-0.22051827609539032,
0.5590277910232544,
0.5008031129837036,
0.05522192269563675,
0.16745911538600922,
-0.055155761539936066,
0.08292678743600845,
0.41368624567985535,
0.6270772218704224,
0.37279054522514343,
-0.1958681046962738,
0.5829274654388428,
-0.6557134985923767,
-0.4403350055217743,
-0.1921667456626892,
-0.7186684012413025,
-0.5234783887863159,
-0.8106433749198914,
-0.6015334129333496,
-0.38426879048347473,
0.03836994618177414,
0.8669174909591675,
0.8004105091094971,
-0.9921787977218628,
0.12140844762325287,
0.3581886291503906,
0.020858362317085266,
-0.48155733942985535,
-0.2177494615316391,
0.5372103452682495,
0.181482195854187,
-0.17426463961601257,
-0.16920620203018188,
0.352129191160202,
-0.20390352606773376,
-0.357951819896698,
0.23940595984458923,
0.3233930468559265,
-0.043880660086870193,
0.4996813237667084,
0.37865757942199707,
-0.719934344291687,
-0.4370776116847992,
0.15708498656749725,
-0.009290218353271484,
0.21198545396327972,
0.9950810074806213,
-0.6215602159500122,
0.41243255138397217,
0.2659846544265747,
0.43349552154541016,
0.3497500419616699,
0.5115841627120972,
0.429719477891922,
-0.8211332559585571,
-0.08319966495037079,
0.37282073497772217,
0.04901180416345596,
0.5178584456443787,
-0.7514755725860596,
0.031683214008808136,
-0.3229842782020569,
-0.5827200412750244,
0.020044676959514618,
0.2743675410747528,
-1.269423246383667,
-0.34871041774749756,
0.9822483658790588,
-0.3640229105949402,
-0.2607739567756653,
-0.6756949424743652,
-0.2507069706916809,
0.05268483608961105,
-0.5834060907363892,
0.9540641903877258,
0.4959196448326111,
-0.6612281203269958,
-0.23387135565280914,
-0.3110731840133667,
0.34138229489326477,
0.15216048061847687,
-1.298892855644226,
0.10132025182247162,
0.4741864800453186,
0.46334534883499146,
0.1393173187971115,
1.0420655012130737,
-0.16642455756664276,
0.5833479762077332,
-0.42454537749290466,
0.08716800808906555,
0.03924284130334854,
-0.015322309918701649,
-0.26227784156799316,
0.4484604597091675,
0.28025832772254944,
-0.2535249590873718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06275v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06275v1
|
Pruning as a Domain-specific LLM Extractor
| 2024-05-10T07:05:02 | 2024-05-10T07:05:02 |
Nan Zhang, Yanchi Liu, Xujiang Zhao, Wei Cheng, Runxue Bao, Rui Zhang, Prasenjit Mitra, Haifeng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable proficiency across a
wide array of NLP tasks. However, the escalation in model size also engenders
substantial deployment costs. While few efforts have explored model pruning
techniques to reduce the size of LLMs, they mainly center on general or
task-specific weights. This leads to suboptimal performance due to lacking
specificity on the target domain or generality on different tasks when applied
to domain-specific challenges. This work introduces an innovative unstructured
dual-pruning methodology, D-Pruner, for domain-specific compression on LLM. It
extracts a compressed, domain-specific, and task-agnostic LLM by identifying
LLM weights that are pivotal for general capabilities, like linguistic
capability and multi-task solving, and domain-specific knowledge. More
specifically, we first assess general weight importance by quantifying the
error incurred upon their removal with the help of an open-domain calibration
dataset. Then, we utilize this general weight importance to refine the training
loss, so that it preserves generality when fitting into a specific domain.
Moreover, by efficiently approximating weight importance with the refined
training loss on a domain-specific calibration dataset, we obtain a pruned
model emphasizing generality and specificity. Our comprehensive experiments
across various tasks in healthcare and legal domains show the effectiveness of
D-Pruner in domain-specific compression. Our code is available at
https://github.com/psunlpgroup/D-Pruner.
|
[
-0.10544286668300629,
-0.5867214202880859,
0.34635964035987854,
0.1340009868144989,
-0.4153217673301697,
0.10588762909173965,
-0.4593374729156494,
-0.020427588373422623,
0.003965525887906551,
0.43152114748954773,
-0.6441162824630737,
-0.4558054506778717,
-0.592234194278717,
0.06683117896318436,
-0.25612083077430725,
0.8673373460769653,
0.0013803924666717649,
-0.15318083763122559,
-0.3015689253807068,
0.13635258376598358,
-0.569287896156311,
-0.8407912254333496,
-0.4272855222225189,
-0.36967217922210693,
0.5698744058609009,
0.23025158047676086,
0.4663955271244049,
0.5432991981506348,
0.5580010414123535,
0.2000735104084015,
-0.2079727053642273,
0.3329264521598816,
-0.5740109086036682,
-0.03240704536437988,
-0.18679362535476685,
-0.404671847820282,
-0.47694334387779236,
-0.0028206508141011,
0.5711119771003723,
0.7187226414680481,
-0.4173770546913147,
0.35035738348960876,
0.09175904095172882,
0.5951588749885559,
-0.40156713128089905,
0.060209229588508606,
-0.7533304691314697,
-0.07995413988828659,
-0.22939522564411163,
-0.40365225076675415,
-0.2650817930698395,
-0.012242461554706097,
-0.15669533610343933,
-0.44881153106689453,
0.48237183690071106,
-0.07317861914634705,
1.0612868070602417,
0.6100972890853882,
-0.5750452280044556,
0.14102375507354736,
-0.8249605894088745,
1.026371955871582,
-0.6649336814880371,
0.26336637139320374,
0.04202280566096306,
0.16185496747493744,
-0.0481998585164547,
-0.7542144060134888,
-0.4313320815563202,
0.09325888752937317,
-0.07465654611587524,
-0.03079555183649063,
-0.13240106403827667,
0.1773274540901184,
0.11653546243906021,
0.6734224557876587,
-0.5187733173370361,
0.2361196130514145,
-0.4483683407306671,
-0.13990795612335205,
0.7819001078605652,
-0.004727012477815151,
0.45147794485092163,
0.12204410880804062,
-0.3518098294734955,
0.0011823645327240229,
-1.000638484954834,
-0.1436585783958435,
0.42526382207870483,
0.12309600412845612,
0.32094645500183105,
0.4678424596786499,
0.16799697279930115,
0.7419347167015076,
-0.1042659655213356,
-0.5422888398170471,
0.17278704047203064,
-0.2371111363172531,
-0.3252814710140228,
-0.322105348110199,
0.5068113207817078,
0.2952415943145752,
0.4165633022785187,
-0.3780337870121002,
-0.29316720366477966,
0.1773366630077362,
0.5684966444969177,
-0.7870506048202515,
-0.4593838155269623,
0.34089168906211853,
-0.4568260610103607,
-0.31365838646888733,
-0.1052197515964508,
-0.561822235584259,
-0.17428165674209595,
-0.5143777132034302,
0.20749637484550476,
-0.27184680104255676,
-0.400768518447876,
0.33828529715538025,
-0.08594302088022232,
-0.01590527780354023,
0.41864731907844543,
-0.658600389957428,
0.514411211013794,
0.8569968938827515,
0.7647590637207031,
-0.5072358846664429,
0.08379794657230377,
-0.3421249985694885,
0.12620145082473755,
-0.008348416537046432,
0.4050549864768982,
-0.3468746542930603,
-0.23858720064163208,
-0.057405538856983185,
0.07657584547996521,
-0.2610136568546295,
-0.8419390916824341,
0.8955668210983276,
-0.6466054320335388,
-0.20834386348724365,
0.1164729967713356,
-0.5361185073852539,
-0.4050299823284149,
0.2627047896385193,
-0.6784408092498779,
0.8537802696228027,
0.2325131744146347,
-0.6629469990730286,
0.26691412925720215,
-0.2265472114086151,
-0.5971537232398987,
0.28888261318206787,
-0.34165865182876587,
-0.6692010164260864,
0.4545632302761078,
0.2249930202960968,
0.5139151215553284,
-0.6746360063552856,
0.6198056936264038,
-0.04157346487045288,
-0.3925325274467468,
-0.048736050724983215,
-0.32933908700942993,
0.7825835347175598,
0.037723902612924576,
0.08733120560646057,
0.033903639763593674,
-0.6585310101509094,
0.15555647015571594,
0.5573801398277283,
-0.5605389475822449,
-0.4093441367149353,
-0.0864080935716629,
0.014636732637882233,
0.3557167053222656,
0.14942340552806854,
-0.5943030118942261,
0.5270536541938782,
-0.4113916754722595,
0.6334013938903809,
0.5766708850860596,
0.13702788949012756,
0.37243136763572693,
-0.5014333128929138,
0.6994149684906006,
-0.14603544771671295,
0.012872094288468361,
0.34705379605293274,
-0.28394845128059387,
-0.5600626468658447,
-0.722457766532898,
0.6039392352104187,
0.5248332023620605,
-0.501110851764679,
0.6701981425285339,
-0.6253471970558167,
-0.2807941734790802,
-0.5861392021179199,
0.28438887000083923,
0.3033854067325592,
0.3804140090942383,
0.3096967041492462,
-0.43605855107307434,
-0.4618435800075531,
-1.0452219247817993,
-0.13920576870441437,
0.10730008035898209,
-0.32251495122909546,
0.23858760297298431,
0.46234676241874695,
-0.09464220702648163,
1.1094045639038086,
-0.7498126029968262,
-0.5969269871711731,
-0.4007628262042999,
-0.057270050048828125,
0.31050682067871094,
0.4591456949710846,
0.3015408217906952,
-1.2005493640899658,
-0.3644413650035858,
-0.21500085294246674,
-0.45302069187164307,
-0.26598867774009705,
-0.13956011831760406,
0.21784409880638123,
-0.38232389092445374,
0.015412847511470318,
-0.748310387134552,
0.45877155661582947,
0.6039882898330688,
0.06630779802799225,
0.7815190553665161,
-0.2925572097301483,
-0.1630113422870636,
-0.6958979368209839,
0.20453643798828125,
0.04190906137228012,
-0.17960146069526672,
-0.9217405915260315,
0.03354085609316826,
0.25026997923851013,
-0.1205005869269371,
-0.3903312087059021,
0.49761539697647095,
-0.7484411597251892,
-0.007844679057598114,
-0.1927678883075714,
-0.11462298035621643,
0.3544834852218628,
0.7484279870986938,
0.25621819496154785,
0.8310586810112,
0.3149511516094208,
-0.8093116283416748,
0.14750321209430695,
0.24934019148349762,
-0.30420786142349243,
0.10710185766220093,
-0.7195970416069031,
0.30092671513557434,
-0.010595615953207016,
0.025119688361883163,
-0.5993592739105225,
0.1393488198518753,
0.12501396238803864,
-0.037049975246191025,
0.731987476348877,
-0.41875243186950684,
-0.5596680641174316,
-0.543124258518219,
-0.2906419634819031,
0.4705674648284912,
0.632354199886322,
-0.43871966004371643,
0.4503205120563507,
0.6769798994064331,
-0.25236940383911133,
-0.41581130027770996,
-0.7261933088302612,
-0.043406590819358826,
-0.4868658483028412,
-0.648770272731781,
0.9751123785972595,
-0.22582614421844482,
-0.2795669138431549,
-0.14225873351097107,
-0.5659727454185486,
-0.1922643482685089,
0.22134312987327576,
0.2797119915485382,
0.17861616611480713,
0.10963919013738632,
0.18875177204608917,
0.003689964534714818,
-0.057244908064603806,
0.02338220551609993,
-0.2873314619064331,
0.4334767162799835,
0.3002025783061981,
-0.46048110723495483,
-0.2934971749782562,
0.2764071226119995,
0.2623322904109955,
-0.4376296401023865,
0.5880858898162842,
0.24846255779266357,
-0.2510412931442261,
-0.6874458193778992,
-0.5858170390129089,
-0.23236224055290222,
-0.47349581122398376,
0.4543014168739319,
-0.37938162684440613,
-0.9016461372375488,
0.15924851596355438,
-0.582550585269928,
0.3193798065185547,
0.3149070143699646,
0.5197280049324036,
0.433010995388031,
0.8371793031692505,
0.7542211413383484,
-0.10857827216386795,
0.21509020030498505,
-0.38391849398612976,
0.4102570116519928,
-0.9905780553817749,
0.00821805838495493,
-0.40750521421432495,
-0.3344915807247162,
0.11162132024765015,
-0.7733547687530518,
0.16472464799880981,
0.23616327345371246,
0.04545431211590767,
0.25150585174560547,
-0.9398919343948364,
0.2861899733543396,
0.4118562340736389,
0.0018857774557545781,
0.3764542043209076,
0.24799703061580658,
0.10136672109365463,
-0.20493727922439575,
-0.7693808674812317,
-0.5247006416320801,
1.0453832149505615,
0.49623769521713257,
0.5057804584503174,
0.15072067081928253,
0.69929438829422,
0.17561788856983185,
0.36526724696159363,
-0.9821470379829407,
0.5417038798332214,
-0.304892897605896,
-0.44484907388687134,
-0.17323440313339233,
-0.7069486975669861,
-0.9216670989990234,
0.5818542838096619,
0.07729419320821762,
-0.5754919648170471,
0.03248775005340576,
0.15182127058506012,
-0.3317292630672455,
0.39046382904052734,
-0.5113967061042786,
0.6754177808761597,
-0.30081599950790405,
-0.02063104324042797,
-0.14580631256103516,
-0.40799063444137573,
0.43990397453308105,
-0.3723628520965576,
0.31574293971061707,
-0.37739297747612,
-0.2336270660161972,
0.8358467817306519,
-0.46250125765800476,
0.8120760321617126,
-0.2727198898792267,
-0.13114970922470093,
0.21219870448112488,
0.1999734491109848,
0.47917190194129944,
-0.04568254575133324,
0.09546057134866714,
0.4051772654056549,
-0.14964401721954346,
-0.07615262269973755,
-0.6952933669090271,
0.5786693692207336,
-0.625481128692627,
-0.9170743823051453,
-0.2171270102262497,
-0.5941078066825867,
-0.3020148277282715,
0.09503433853387833,
-0.11769901216030121,
0.41596341133117676,
-0.0965929850935936,
0.021267568692564964,
0.5858154892921448,
-0.22985303401947021,
0.08955851197242737,
0.6393219232559204,
0.21234889328479767,
-0.2966414988040924,
0.9531326293945312,
0.14979399740695953,
0.12309678643941879,
0.5343241095542908,
0.14694328606128693,
0.09056808054447174,
-1.0423699617385864,
-0.11300834268331528,
0.5008880496025085,
-0.5507678389549255,
-0.5557302832603455,
-0.4911884665489197,
-0.34265485405921936,
-0.32900309562683105,
0.048062555491924286,
-0.1287899613380432,
-0.5708640813827515,
-0.23373258113861084,
-0.06325531005859375,
0.13541078567504883,
0.4845725893974304,
0.23489539325237274,
0.41043776273727417,
-0.8578629493713379,
0.2765575051307678,
0.21103474497795105,
0.061850037425756454,
-0.11066853255033493,
-0.6956073045730591,
-0.06976950168609619,
-0.11771345138549805,
-0.13813015818595886,
-0.674443781375885,
0.8842324614524841,
0.5044659376144409,
0.5964967012405396,
0.23526377975940704,
0.31906136870384216,
0.6064678430557251,
-0.7236437797546387,
0.5968459248542786,
0.2680189609527588,
-0.48146378993988037,
0.3447970449924469,
-0.0060790954157710075,
0.18372495472431183,
0.5397063493728638,
0.3435085415840149,
-0.37818682193756104,
0.004500059876590967,
-0.5376213192939758,
-1.0981857776641846,
0.6524569988250732,
0.1610255241394043,
-0.12557677924633026,
0.07975360006093979,
0.5723781585693359,
-0.019327007234096527,
0.3587995171546936,
-0.6162023544311523,
-0.249887153506279,
0.289673388004303,
-0.39597955346107483,
-0.03083345666527748,
-0.48683980107307434,
-0.5255711674690247,
-0.22213627398014069,
0.6997555494308472,
-0.07006875425577164,
0.04080826789140701,
0.2024029940366745,
-0.4283463954925537,
0.14843113720417023,
0.2928604483604431,
0.08109204471111298,
0.5730780363082886,
-0.09427196532487869,
0.17224419116973877,
0.04232285916805267,
-0.5514671802520752,
0.25319916009902954,
0.09959737211465836,
-0.20904940366744995,
-0.08206180483102798,
0.24994508922100067,
0.3472670316696167,
0.24400489032268524,
-0.7825562357902527,
0.7527926564216614,
-0.19085988402366638,
-0.4201277196407318,
-0.24391832947731018,
-0.10726768523454666,
-0.03526637703180313,
-0.1237553209066391,
0.3723689913749695,
-0.045113272964954376,
0.10148228704929352,
-0.11350677162408829,
0.2607307732105255,
0.3607829809188843,
-0.22315996885299683,
-0.4142889678478241,
0.4343344271183014,
0.3069739043712616,
-0.1882859170436859,
0.6793864369392395,
-0.04360334202647209,
-0.4967189431190491,
0.5851669311523438,
0.49662989377975464,
0.7644044756889343,
-0.0810505747795105,
-0.009574763476848602,
0.21181347966194153,
0.20540489256381989,
-0.16934342682361603,
-0.07244973629713058,
-0.1336842030286789,
-0.6983914971351624,
-0.6945528984069824,
-0.8137596845626831,
-0.0029907936695963144,
0.10947416722774506,
-0.5599360466003418,
0.0890807956457138,
-0.3365265429019928,
-0.27326226234436035,
-0.10476502776145935,
0.2665407061576843,
-0.6767089366912842,
0.2414582073688507,
-0.06099322438240051,
0.9187225103378296,
-0.6121401786804199,
1.1449012756347656,
0.5944594144821167,
-0.2610867917537689,
-0.9162886738777161,
-0.09753944724798203,
0.2538316547870636,
-0.7401442527770996,
0.7805685997009277,
0.18302056193351746,
0.1162567138671875,
-0.009013203904032707,
-0.09432906657457352,
-0.7861250042915344,
1.2616833448410034,
0.4493260979652405,
-0.9012616276741028,
-0.3624110221862793,
0.03351985290646553,
0.2440001219511032,
-0.25317659974098206,
-0.16198760271072388,
0.5266897678375244,
0.31866565346717834,
0.07810994982719421,
-1.0546379089355469,
0.23212678730487823,
-0.24225781857967377,
0.05501668155193329,
0.38706067204475403,
-0.43109631538391113,
0.7802720665931702,
0.02939552441239357,
-0.5055673718452454,
-0.18776443600654602,
0.3739405572414398,
0.12406663596630096,
-0.1085430458188057,
0.7851912975311279,
0.5671988129615784,
0.8895822167396545,
-0.009553276002407074,
0.8508287072181702,
-0.4183216094970703,
0.3255942463874817,
0.979459285736084,
-0.5230391621589661,
0.5134137868881226,
0.6547811627388,
-0.2672094404697418,
0.07249722629785538,
0.40173304080963135,
-0.03945225849747658,
0.49196961522102356,
0.6605274677276611,
-0.2896459996700287,
-0.23968662321567535,
-0.138261616230011,
-0.06593214720487595,
0.14822305738925934,
0.3518780767917633,
-0.19233748316764832,
-0.14754126965999603,
-0.1299251765012741,
0.164447620511055,
-0.006608585361391306,
-0.32417425513267517,
0.6838011145591736,
0.3471478223800659,
-0.5673804879188538,
0.7082552909851074,
0.18968209624290466,
0.8703551292419434,
-0.8638051152229309,
-0.012557977810502052,
0.08792797476053238,
0.5200333595275879,
-0.17140667140483856,
-0.36764928698539734,
0.4612392783164978,
-0.17226211726665497,
-0.05660494789481163,
-0.7895058393478394,
1.056098461151123,
-0.4215356409549713,
-0.1462368220090866,
0.47204890847206116,
0.4822993874549866,
0.11314882338047028,
-0.5060815215110779,
-0.7216435074806213,
0.14298826456069946,
0.21552674472332,
-0.4725656509399414,
0.7197697758674622,
0.3407299518585205,
0.007634126115590334,
0.6654309034347534,
0.6018034219741821,
0.5033586621284485,
-0.3364226222038269,
0.20064418017864227,
1.164984107017517,
-0.42220255732536316,
-0.11485426872968674,
-0.6246219277381897,
0.49672216176986694,
-0.20190416276454926,
-0.1884038895368576,
0.7336803674697876,
0.540199339389801,
0.550778329372406,
-0.06744812428951263,
0.6750247478485107,
-0.06906908750534058,
0.6280329823493958,
-0.33274587988853455,
0.43914759159088135,
-0.6531308889389038,
0.35879266262054443,
0.23519720137119293,
-0.7003610134124756,
-0.5285534262657166,
0.4214188754558563,
-0.36511340737342834,
-0.19003091752529144,
0.545498788356781,
0.7918095588684082,
-0.034227773547172546,
-0.34908527135849,
0.3729889392852783,
-0.08431252092123032,
0.33154627680778503,
0.46646004915237427,
0.3527620732784271,
-0.07548066973686218,
0.7914615869522095,
-0.4107947051525116,
-0.40819862484931946,
-0.006631325930356979,
-0.7545080780982971,
-0.8075093030929565,
-0.41222214698791504,
-0.5697636604309082,
-0.019957834854722023,
0.012878986075520515,
0.6406455636024475,
0.9574993848800659,
-0.5936287641525269,
-0.1046699583530426,
0.01017956342548132,
-0.09670324623584747,
-0.5328906774520874,
-0.216545969247818,
0.5229274034500122,
-0.11349164694547653,
-0.5320969223976135,
0.6010246276855469,
0.24640706181526184,
-0.2606619596481323,
-0.08127300441265106,
0.05709757283329964,
-0.2687669098377228,
-0.00016685326409060508,
0.3931243121623993,
0.23027385771274567,
-0.7026448249816895,
-0.08703102916479111,
-0.27799269556999207,
0.11109761893749237,
0.008022105321288109,
1.1558862924575806,
-0.6933650970458984,
0.036744363605976105,
0.23731456696987152,
0.6017258167266846,
0.45392775535583496,
0.3281494379043579,
0.7793778777122498,
-1.1944102048873901,
0.29896417260169983,
0.5718113780021667,
0.404312402009964,
0.29048311710357666,
-0.4148677587509155,
0.7378217577934265,
0.3230959177017212,
-0.713092029094696,
-0.8998182415962219,
0.3130498230457306,
-0.833315372467041,
-0.5706652402877808,
1.3025764226913452,
-0.43820735812187195,
-0.40875375270843506,
-0.16277748346328735,
-0.32459720969200134,
0.09037607908248901,
-0.23252251744270325,
0.4375860095024109,
0.46435868740081787,
0.16633905470371246,
-0.068831667304039,
-0.5279598236083984,
0.550015926361084,
0.36832427978515625,
-0.481518417596817,
0.3958266079425812,
0.4074939489364624,
0.3742242455482483,
0.08733390271663666,
0.6717916131019592,
-0.04068528860807419,
-0.18654192984104156,
-0.15948837995529175,
0.2960866093635559,
-0.36550477147102356,
-0.3419124186038971,
-0.5553737878799438,
0.4399758279323578,
0.07995729893445969,
-0.1001434326171875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06270v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06270v3
|
XAI4LLM. Let Machine Learning Models and LLMs Collaborate for Enhanced In-Context Learning in Healthcare
| 2024-05-10T06:52:44 | 2024-06-03T16:23:28 |
Fatemeh Nazary, Yashar Deldjoo, Tommaso Di Noia, Eugenio di Sciascio
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) into healthcare diagnostics
offers a promising avenue for clinical decision-making. This study outlines the
development of a novel method for zero-shot/few-shot in-context learning (ICL)
by integrating medical domain knowledge using a multi-layered structured
prompt. We also explore the efficacy of two communication styles between the
user and LLMs: the Numerical Conversational (NC) style, which processes data
incrementally, and the Natural Language Single-Turn (NL-ST) style, which
employs long narrative prompts.
Our study systematically evaluates the diagnostic accuracy and risk factors,
including gender bias and false negative rates, using a dataset of 920 patient
records in various few-shot scenarios. Results indicate that traditional
clinical machine learning (ML) models generally outperform LLMs in zero-shot
and few-shot settings. However, the performance gap narrows significantly when
employing few-shot examples alongside effective explainable AI (XAI) methods as
sources of domain knowledge. Moreover, with sufficient time and an increased
number of examples, the conversational style (NC) nearly matches the
performance of ML models. Most notably, LLMs demonstrate comparable or superior
cost-sensitive accuracy relative to ML models.
This research confirms that, with appropriate domain knowledge and tailored
communication strategies, LLMs can significantly enhance diagnostic processes.
The findings highlight the importance of optimizing the number of training
examples and communication styles to improve accuracy and reduce biases in LLM
applications.
|
[
-0.07071523368358612,
-0.7584002614021301,
0.8286066055297852,
0.00611354224383831,
-0.30561551451683044,
-0.01492883637547493,
-0.09708841890096664,
-0.6315655708312988,
-0.18367746472358704,
0.2854343354701996,
-0.5578206777572632,
-0.8095649480819702,
-0.5079704523086548,
0.19121317565441132,
-0.13655443489551544,
0.8979488611221313,
-0.031172867864370346,
0.5195407867431641,
-0.26607054471969604,
-0.26515328884124756,
-0.6440712213516235,
-0.616669237613678,
-0.8925122618675232,
-0.6600812077522278,
0.523809015750885,
0.47134459018707275,
0.38055509328842163,
0.6700024008750916,
0.5444989204406738,
0.16061727702617645,
-0.019798643887043,
0.27373409271240234,
-0.28826627135276794,
0.13195881247520447,
0.17696958780288696,
-0.4369322657585144,
-0.45699116587638855,
-0.06787607818841934,
0.484101265668869,
0.9267681837081909,
-0.00009712259634397924,
-0.0989881381392479,
0.08890696614980698,
0.4590844511985779,
-0.4293305575847626,
0.22059014439582825,
-0.354094922542572,
0.37603437900543213,
-0.0918918177485466,
-0.6061754822731018,
-0.5410219430923462,
-0.041912633925676346,
0.552832305431366,
-0.3966040313243866,
-0.02208729274570942,
-0.04228628799319267,
0.5367989540100098,
0.2780928313732147,
-0.5944857597351074,
-0.46925464272499084,
-0.5133203268051147,
0.6761659383773804,
-0.7712597846984863,
0.1909196376800537,
0.23489910364151,
0.5093280076980591,
0.00730601791292429,
-0.556273341178894,
-0.305164635181427,
-0.2982712388038635,
-0.3010078966617584,
0.18218928575515747,
-0.22225970029830933,
0.1840917319059372,
0.2522827088832855,
-0.16858670115470886,
-0.649520754814148,
0.5507907271385193,
-0.22035442292690277,
0.008699927479028702,
0.5678906440734863,
0.5376485586166382,
0.3148602843284607,
-0.13186314702033997,
-0.4972476661205292,
0.244379460811615,
-0.9254060387611389,
0.0006595498416572809,
-0.44847196340560913,
0.5234671235084534,
-0.41898080706596375,
0.3083503544330597,
-0.14013472199440002,
0.7413049936294556,
0.10380633175373077,
-0.7475228905677795,
0.24089959263801575,
-0.3153893053531647,
-0.34430643916130066,
0.4740283489227295,
0.6975373029708862,
0.33955466747283936,
-0.04467817023396492,
-0.09244468063116074,
0.07231409847736359,
-0.04745318368077278,
0.13457880914211273,
-0.8088194131851196,
0.12732239067554474,
0.36171862483024597,
-0.5012185573577881,
-0.4457665681838989,
-0.4053932726383209,
-0.3416440188884735,
-0.3942077159881592,
-0.4474296569824219,
0.21531036496162415,
-0.6202764511108398,
0.07133268564939499,
0.08988512307405472,
0.07032009214162827,
0.2396223098039627,
0.5260990262031555,
-0.5446327328681946,
0.13572776317596436,
0.44062912464141846,
0.8122864961624146,
-0.24781900644302368,
0.012911559082567692,
-0.6444244980812073,
0.2089802771806717,
-0.3745380640029907,
0.7232652902603149,
-0.422131210565567,
-0.5292792320251465,
0.046394601464271545,
-0.22248494625091553,
-0.062319979071617126,
-0.54335618019104,
0.40443092584609985,
-0.17697298526763916,
0.3393247425556183,
0.011630222201347351,
-0.6128793954849243,
-0.09996824711561203,
0.47736504673957825,
-0.18326935172080994,
0.6949237585067749,
0.3220171332359314,
-0.4776720702648163,
0.685430645942688,
-0.7928351759910583,
-0.4219125211238861,
0.47860267758369446,
-0.5140756964683533,
-0.5696283578872681,
-0.19004735350608826,
0.263808012008667,
0.8065533638000488,
-0.27770471572875977,
0.5357025265693665,
-0.2458469718694687,
-0.41621968150138855,
0.15620659291744232,
-0.3784424960613251,
0.7424520254135132,
0.059062547981739044,
-0.4213443398475647,
0.16531996428966522,
-0.5748894214630127,
-0.022461093962192535,
0.1403716802597046,
-0.15229755640029907,
-0.2781800329685211,
-0.3908497393131256,
-0.36006128787994385,
0.4122120141983032,
-0.18714824318885803,
-0.3032768964767456,
0.1890467256307602,
-0.5397132039070129,
0.23550577461719513,
0.4016667604446411,
0.1367509663105011,
0.3186793327331543,
-0.645165741443634,
0.6356728672981262,
0.5376633405685425,
0.20174340903759003,
-0.6708914041519165,
-0.539695680141449,
-0.5099108219146729,
-0.5281552672386169,
-0.06832300126552582,
0.7230134010314941,
-0.7317436337471008,
0.19876472651958466,
-0.06394007056951523,
-0.29308682680130005,
-0.5682944655418396,
0.031015601009130478,
0.5529930591583252,
1.150641918182373,
0.4342423975467682,
-0.036813490092754364,
-0.5470353960990906,
-0.6658506989479065,
-0.00486757094040513,
-0.08273667842149734,
-0.00538213225081563,
0.782470703125,
0.2745857238769531,
-0.44589492678642273,
0.6305285692214966,
-0.2504642903804779,
-0.3626420497894287,
-0.5187729001045227,
0.16561855375766754,
0.2824386954307556,
0.29487648606300354,
0.5745471715927124,
-0.4011676609516144,
-0.6591144800186157,
0.18570299446582794,
-1.134935975074768,
-0.036985136568546295,
-0.14039933681488037,
0.08852113038301468,
0.3394455313682556,
0.2728770077228546,
-0.3140987753868103,
0.6891093254089355,
0.3605406582355499,
-0.20134301483631134,
0.3358824551105499,
-0.2698764503002167,
0.17688266932964325,
-0.9146233201026917,
-0.133522167801857,
0.3507500886917114,
-0.44566428661346436,
-0.8153113126754761,
-0.1421709954738617,
0.10328223556280136,
-0.17307601869106293,
-0.7442238926887512,
0.7401667833328247,
-0.2670555114746094,
0.13280293345451355,
-0.17209921777248383,
0.13682414591312408,
0.09167298674583435,
0.286212295293808,
0.2030874490737915,
0.6269739270210266,
0.7484397292137146,
-0.7566506862640381,
-0.04358293116092682,
0.34235984086990356,
-0.3459135890007019,
0.7797220945358276,
-0.7934501767158508,
0.0791013091802597,
-0.29233166575431824,
0.46638911962509155,
-0.9331157803535461,
-0.051877111196517944,
0.1974727064371109,
-0.29416796565055847,
0.48927825689315796,
-0.07878110557794571,
-0.2612908184528351,
-0.12469267100095749,
-0.12540243566036224,
0.4477892816066742,
0.5073836445808411,
-0.5085765719413757,
0.24612492322921753,
0.05323392152786255,
-0.21904657781124115,
-0.48709240555763245,
-0.8658018708229065,
0.10602257400751114,
-0.4134872257709503,
-0.6291253566741943,
0.5179588794708252,
-0.16617226600646973,
-0.15719106793403625,
-0.3649978041648865,
0.24575462937355042,
-0.07688599824905396,
0.19081439077854156,
0.17262829840183258,
0.6044678092002869,
-0.4648391902446747,
0.26941967010498047,
0.1233585774898529,
-0.1938800811767578,
-0.06902699172496796,
-0.24614961445331573,
0.3665682077407837,
-0.04633711650967598,
-0.49649670720100403,
-0.8748727440834045,
0.4905410706996918,
0.4543667733669281,
0.22991926968097687,
0.7782198786735535,
0.4423605501651764,
-0.3333980143070221,
-0.22161531448364258,
-0.2328794002532959,
-0.409567654132843,
-0.3546665608882904,
0.07813944667577744,
-0.29337409138679504,
-0.978492259979248,
0.21250954270362854,
-0.20306208729743958,
-0.11335241794586182,
0.307159960269928,
0.7748374342918396,
-0.4842642545700073,
1.2944166660308838,
0.6555182933807373,
0.05771837383508682,
0.2228730469942093,
-0.21583135426044464,
0.33832094073295593,
-0.6652024984359741,
-0.362631231546402,
-0.4038509726524353,
-0.19538788497447968,
-0.48274514079093933,
-0.20586267113685608,
0.9648242592811584,
-0.18134529888629913,
-0.3972843587398529,
-0.25928401947021484,
-0.47408008575439453,
0.22801372408866882,
0.3993033170700073,
0.4734640419483185,
0.37730252742767334,
-0.16872531175613403,
-0.3025900721549988,
-0.06837690621614456,
-0.9500827193260193,
-0.48176297545433044,
1.2436330318450928,
0.41370436549186707,
0.5506958365440369,
0.07219522446393967,
0.6814463138580322,
0.26864975690841675,
0.36225825548171997,
-1.000101089477539,
0.07486376166343689,
-0.19308437407016754,
-0.28722646832466125,
-0.15378737449645996,
-0.24233295023441315,
-0.8880850672721863,
0.004744502250105143,
-0.113950714468956,
-0.5204130411148071,
0.06622391939163208,
0.13170292973518372,
-0.7560988664627075,
-0.0014406598638743162,
-0.5407612323760986,
0.7954341173171997,
-0.4375879466533661,
-0.1780310422182083,
0.16259701550006866,
-0.8328927159309387,
0.426296204328537,
-0.025152117013931274,
0.011893621645867825,
-0.04474327340722084,
-0.009370259940624237,
0.3368314206600189,
-0.27337872982025146,
1.1201465129852295,
0.019128024578094482,
-0.004151395056396723,
-0.09365163743495941,
-0.032153282314538956,
0.3093281686306,
0.1243271604180336,
-0.0009435665560886264,
0.32788410782814026,
0.03059963509440422,
-0.35347163677215576,
-0.6726288795471191,
0.5054115056991577,
-0.7871891260147095,
-0.3018631637096405,
-0.44153714179992676,
-0.49055424332618713,
-0.4743465781211853,
-0.03041764721274376,
0.3575093150138855,
0.8344587683677673,
-0.08607601374387741,
0.05822094902396202,
0.8374335169792175,
-0.39284300804138184,
0.14858943223953247,
0.7478846907615662,
0.1467115432024002,
0.03879346698522568,
0.4299073815345764,
-0.002161611570045352,
0.2670363783836365,
0.4078412353992462,
0.4586261510848999,
-0.14373622834682465,
-0.6543405652046204,
-0.525936484336853,
0.19485969841480255,
-0.7631357312202454,
-0.41625499725341797,
-0.7406137585639954,
-0.4409874975681305,
-0.38628894090652466,
-0.42457079887390137,
-0.03607100620865822,
0.023859666660428047,
-0.5784647464752197,
-0.034866638481616974,
0.2760321795940399,
0.5034147500991821,
0.22193562984466553,
0.4884713590145111,
-0.7790265679359436,
0.125586599111557,
-0.16211111843585968,
0.07560607045888901,
-0.03653614595532417,
-0.7530565857887268,
-0.16605144739151,
-0.024735383689403534,
-0.16825242340564728,
-0.7638534307479858,
0.5796033143997192,
0.2849162518978119,
0.6706322431564331,
0.6649957299232483,
-0.07520845532417297,
0.7405287027359009,
-0.460655152797699,
0.7358481884002686,
0.3067457973957062,
-0.7258067727088928,
0.702537477016449,
-0.20897996425628662,
0.4322553277015686,
0.4827611446380615,
0.8354825377464294,
-0.6284617781639099,
-0.1682276427745819,
-0.5107148289680481,
-0.431410551071167,
0.6533124446868896,
-0.28963199257850647,
-0.06297613680362701,
-0.20602284371852875,
0.4995970129966736,
0.250761479139328,
-0.03885902836918831,
-0.3023297190666199,
-0.5034580230712891,
0.16501271724700928,
-0.4546431005001068,
-0.1175035759806633,
-0.2838524281978607,
-0.5047595500946045,
-0.4777907729148865,
0.5108663439750671,
-0.5996944904327393,
0.47704845666885376,
0.3175818622112274,
-0.09040510654449463,
0.003098208224400878,
0.24884828925132751,
0.7249729633331299,
0.8075019121170044,
-0.08971815556287766,
0.004929482936859131,
0.2702576220035553,
-0.11321680247783661,
0.10474912822246552,
-0.14105258882045746,
-0.10750648379325867,
0.03754828870296478,
0.5402351021766663,
1.0429962873458862,
0.33375856280326843,
-0.7792595028877258,
0.5795032382011414,
-0.10613556951284409,
-0.3693127930164337,
-0.190497487783432,
-0.07747285813093185,
-0.1699276715517044,
0.2786918580532074,
0.09722232818603516,
-0.006490595638751984,
0.2486792504787445,
-0.49996015429496765,
0.3641376793384552,
0.4902295172214508,
-0.7398163080215454,
-0.10615529119968414,
0.4056096076965332,
0.13663966953754425,
-0.1498277634382248,
0.6657623648643494,
-0.02452540211379528,
-0.2452743947505951,
0.4652283191680908,
0.7793380618095398,
0.6124668121337891,
-0.027362417429685593,
0.3979854881763458,
0.2268887609243393,
-0.038262296468019485,
0.08611361682415009,
0.1936715841293335,
-0.05217067524790764,
-0.7465475797653198,
-0.45875272154808044,
-0.15253204107284546,
-0.5836811661720276,
0.16083230078220367,
-0.518820583820343,
0.5749541521072388,
-0.6074285507202148,
-0.04506294056773186,
0.08790698647499084,
0.12647037208080292,
-0.7455726861953735,
0.2615787088871002,
0.37375563383102417,
0.9623159170150757,
-0.6812006831169128,
0.8440876603126526,
0.45997291803359985,
-0.4282117187976837,
-0.7816872000694275,
-0.1986939162015915,
0.4381381869316101,
-1.057671308517456,
0.8744298219680786,
0.25902992486953735,
0.0781218484044075,
-0.244290292263031,
-0.5906313061714172,
-0.5933535695075989,
1.2558482885360718,
0.3364487290382385,
-0.43444517254829407,
-0.058761514723300934,
0.10904845595359802,
0.6623783111572266,
-0.7302462458610535,
0.5613211989402771,
0.6640275716781616,
0.1668505221605301,
0.41368311643600464,
-1.023288369178772,
0.009998434223234653,
-0.02941831946372986,
-0.1858348250389099,
0.011179236695170403,
-0.3402797281742096,
0.6299608945846558,
-0.3284468650817871,
-0.25001057982444763,
-0.037461403757333755,
0.380197674036026,
0.4401733875274658,
0.7302886247634888,
0.07361194491386414,
0.3873260021209717,
0.9588969945907593,
0.019598696380853653,
1.2640670537948608,
-0.36839044094085693,
-0.08842770755290985,
0.9374746084213257,
-0.5938621163368225,
0.5791559219360352,
0.243948295712471,
0.003651117440313101,
0.6002770662307739,
0.6806527376174927,
0.3816330134868622,
0.37645775079727173,
-0.10073462128639221,
-0.5169419050216675,
-0.13369141519069672,
-0.3856235444545746,
-0.2694043219089508,
0.4664314389228821,
0.6142562627792358,
-0.5510257482528687,
-0.22067932784557343,
0.24573512375354767,
0.21063627302646637,
-0.17341938614845276,
-0.17433609068393707,
1.1267755031585693,
0.15801140666007996,
-0.41261398792266846,
0.745281994342804,
-0.08525773882865906,
0.7224776744842529,
-0.735812783241272,
-0.16160549223423004,
-0.3053250312805176,
0.10570532828569412,
-0.24631300568580627,
-0.6167677044868469,
0.23505355417728424,
-0.1096804067492485,
-0.1824101060628891,
-0.27493858337402344,
0.6472662091255188,
-0.4310765564441681,
-0.42360690236091614,
0.11587201803922653,
0.6977576613426208,
0.19655559957027435,
0.10438781976699829,
-0.8695733547210693,
-0.05267445743083954,
-0.15636901557445526,
0.2125074416399002,
0.571313202381134,
0.3584640622138977,
-0.21998420357704163,
0.7715022563934326,
0.549627959728241,
0.1313619464635849,
-0.3230558931827545,
0.18336468935012817,
0.6719446778297424,
-0.5564071536064148,
-0.37087735533714294,
-0.8944278955459595,
0.4680900275707245,
0.007151896599680185,
-0.32579898834228516,
0.4882233142852783,
0.16126181185245514,
0.6738255023956299,
0.28777197003364563,
0.8996253609657288,
0.6082879900932312,
0.55203777551651,
-0.4944192171096802,
0.5123120546340942,
-0.5319933295249939,
0.30737441778182983,
-0.044502269476652145,
-0.08408820629119873,
-0.7027772068977356,
0.41690555214881897,
-0.25284549593925476,
0.12253409624099731,
0.7854345440864563,
0.6759081482887268,
0.11923028528690338,
0.016697892919182777,
0.7039505243301392,
0.10519209504127502,
0.43152564764022827,
0.5896404385566711,
0.6626178622245789,
-0.23551306128501892,
0.13505269587039948,
-0.3877468705177307,
-0.4536423087120056,
-0.43023812770843506,
-0.9608050584793091,
-0.9849048256874084,
-0.3205731511116028,
-0.4226984977722168,
-0.14918160438537598,
0.18589915335178375,
1.1012673377990723,
1.0775452852249146,
-0.5941428542137146,
-0.07361515611410141,
0.2261621505022049,
0.0042368764989078045,
-0.24294114112854004,
-0.20460672676563263,
0.2919732332229614,
-0.5899670124053955,
-0.43581417202949524,
0.7218717932701111,
0.6826145648956299,
0.11553096026182175,
-0.3763565421104431,
-0.16058358550071716,
0.035105518996715546,
-0.11199522018432617,
0.8946226835250854,
0.0638163685798645,
-0.5911931395530701,
0.1683138608932495,
0.024974819272756577,
-0.3163187801837921,
0.3250409662723541,
0.903976559638977,
-1.080227255821228,
0.36985376477241516,
0.16933554410934448,
0.8274457454681396,
0.26915663480758667,
-0.06508926302194595,
0.6037726402282715,
-0.67014080286026,
0.18895117938518524,
0.4614470601081848,
0.286746621131897,
0.3288551867008209,
-0.798080325126648,
0.2670518159866333,
0.2032344490289688,
-0.45573490858078003,
-0.6690118908882141,
0.02623133175075054,
-0.8427892327308655,
-0.3634830415248871,
1.0533725023269653,
-0.19104228913784027,
-0.1897735297679901,
-0.3159717321395874,
-0.21799173951148987,
-0.0243564210832119,
-0.4068778455257416,
0.53824782371521,
0.2184719741344452,
-0.7136591076850891,
-0.23697052896022797,
-0.5869787931442261,
0.5619035363197327,
0.33555203676223755,
-0.9241762757301331,
-0.5524089336395264,
0.37222471833229065,
0.2547213137149811,
-0.2472740113735199,
0.7647777795791626,
-0.08064411580562592,
0.40141862630844116,
-0.44167083501815796,
-0.18655142188072205,
-0.09195543825626373,
-0.41971084475517273,
-0.5999969840049744,
0.05928819254040718,
-0.043208349496126175,
0.059662800282239914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06258v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06258v2
|
Automatic Generation of Model and Data Cards: A Step Towards Responsible AI
| 2024-05-10T06:14:07 | 2024-06-19T03:36:01 |
Jiarui Liu, Wenkai Li, Zhijing Jin, Mona Diab
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In an era of model and data proliferation in machine learning/AI especially
marked by the rapid advancement of open-sourced technologies, there arises a
critical need for standardized consistent documentation. Our work addresses the
information incompleteness in current human-generated model and data cards. We
propose an automated generation approach using Large Language Models (LLMs).
Our key contributions include the establishment of CardBench, a comprehensive
dataset aggregated from over 4.8k model cards and 1.4k data cards, coupled with
the development of the CardGen pipeline comprising a two-step retrieval
process. Our approach exhibits enhanced completeness, objectivity, and
faithfulness in generated model and data cards, a significant step in
responsible AI documentation practices ensuring better accountability and
traceability.
|
[
-0.09708360582590103,
-0.6623795628547668,
0.5011501908302307,
-0.2812804579734802,
-0.04274206981062889,
-0.35773777961730957,
-0.018997415900230408,
-0.5162907242774963,
-0.15883898735046387,
0.8558597564697266,
-0.4153463840484619,
-0.7590840458869934,
-0.3869645297527313,
-0.060493726283311844,
-0.5185763239860535,
0.9578049182891846,
-0.1793116331100464,
0.1123354583978653,
-0.5900092124938965,
0.09505264461040497,
-0.44875118136405945,
-0.42109647393226624,
-0.6996928453445435,
-0.6888821721076965,
0.424770712852478,
0.47493621706962585,
0.799018144607544,
1.4230962991714478,
0.5689470171928406,
0.28519517183303833,
0.3812030255794525,
0.4038878083229065,
-0.19600504636764526,
0.0674854964017868,
-0.2539766728878021,
-0.6109612584114075,
-1.207558035850525,
0.2752220630645752,
0.6165479421615601,
0.4771030843257904,
-0.297442764043808,
0.334707111120224,
-0.06724844872951508,
0.547795832157135,
-0.2900097072124481,
0.5941872596740723,
-0.7063682675361633,
-0.1165919080376625,
-0.24190187454223633,
-0.36778655648231506,
-0.5386447310447693,
-0.12536147236824036,
-0.3689025342464447,
-0.8083230257034302,
0.5476102232933044,
-0.015358442440629005,
0.6032172441482544,
0.4782518744468689,
-0.09179180860519409,
-0.5427475571632385,
-0.8268951177597046,
0.49303823709487915,
-0.7341446280479431,
0.009168150834739208,
0.5294302701950073,
0.42651352286338806,
-0.4270416498184204,
-0.8256881237030029,
-0.4339427947998047,
-0.2936188280582428,
0.02234642766416073,
-0.016120150685310364,
-0.03642207756638527,
0.008589543402194977,
0.48480066657066345,
0.24054422974586487,
-0.43558070063591003,
0.40506404638290405,
-0.48022064566612244,
-0.12079992890357971,
1.3220288753509521,
0.44763243198394775,
0.2655508816242218,
-0.15673622488975525,
0.050546180456876755,
-0.18511459231376648,
-0.9112931489944458,
-0.4035315215587616,
0.8403254151344299,
0.4477871060371399,
-0.13999879360198975,
0.8721795082092285,
-0.030312949791550636,
0.6693786978721619,
-0.22335658967494965,
0.008054723031818867,
0.11177212744951248,
-0.42108073830604553,
-0.24927634000778198,
0.05224154517054558,
0.7897059917449951,
0.13307969272136688,
0.3291013240814209,
-0.06302068382501602,
-0.2838417589664459,
0.04176677018404007,
0.5512186884880066,
-0.5803012251853943,
-0.27686765789985657,
0.38340306282043457,
-0.5568354725837708,
-0.5157025456428528,
0.14719054102897644,
-0.639067530632019,
-0.49001526832580566,
-0.8170249462127686,
0.011245849542319775,
0.023411188274621964,
-0.31922873854637146,
-0.2921406328678131,
-0.13229325413703918,
0.29085108637809753,
0.4337489604949951,
-0.6757572889328003,
-0.09854505956172943,
0.8407305479049683,
0.37288039922714233,
-0.24269980192184448,
-0.14228184521198273,
-0.48701825737953186,
0.47230008244514465,
-0.6060336828231812,
0.5695338845252991,
-0.5774954557418823,
-0.5037263035774231,
0.13721981644630432,
-0.055851049721241,
0.3461968004703522,
-0.6456313729286194,
0.8221365809440613,
-0.19325608015060425,
0.0015182651113718748,
0.1895502507686615,
-0.7248398661613464,
0.13005530834197998,
0.3311704695224762,
-0.7125607132911682,
0.9293856024742126,
-0.14169080555438995,
-0.6634997725486755,
0.36046722531318665,
-0.858452558517456,
-0.2763921916484833,
0.3728279173374176,
-0.5635971426963806,
-0.6933196783065796,
0.022416768595576286,
0.2003205567598343,
0.7352558970451355,
-0.579507052898407,
0.820602536201477,
-0.4620662033557892,
-0.29800084233283997,
-0.06251345574855804,
-0.5894141793251038,
0.8694810271263123,
0.19409045577049255,
-0.2554599642753601,
0.1939818263053894,
-1.090984582901001,
0.10700980573892593,
0.3131203353404999,
-0.35237717628479004,
0.03061419352889061,
0.28265413641929626,
0.1309313029050827,
0.14524957537651062,
0.18783368170261383,
-0.2973727285861969,
0.528313934803009,
-0.038762181997299194,
0.4119755029678345,
0.8054265379905701,
-0.07265524566173553,
0.3097873032093048,
-0.3961855471134186,
0.4025360643863678,
0.1361844837665558,
0.26717913150787354,
-0.682179868221283,
-0.3860810101032257,
-0.7177312970161438,
-0.10142840445041656,
0.2089581936597824,
0.4178304672241211,
-0.2596246302127838,
0.8803476691246033,
-0.4673375189304352,
-0.8616480231285095,
-0.42147332429885864,
0.10806421935558319,
0.1629936695098877,
0.550971508026123,
0.23002052307128906,
-0.07590799033641815,
-0.4147903025150299,
-0.9708636403083801,
0.11271403729915619,
-0.5035808086395264,
-0.1605057418346405,
0.5763220191001892,
0.4338056445121765,
-0.5058695673942566,
0.8351799249649048,
-0.21888673305511475,
-0.20796099305152893,
-0.13203774392604828,
0.26683399081230164,
-0.020375169813632965,
0.8387129902839661,
0.20768944919109344,
-0.7011713981628418,
-0.2225266396999359,
-0.018971571698784828,
-0.9541382789611816,
0.03743540123105049,
-0.2539619505405426,
-0.2886628210544586,
0.47808638215065,
0.7556434869766235,
-0.7868649363517761,
0.7287436127662659,
0.1444561779499054,
-0.06748071312904358,
0.18922963738441467,
-0.4849293529987335,
-0.2569970488548279,
-1.2039822340011597,
0.636793851852417,
-0.1794191300868988,
-0.2042638063430786,
-0.49104300141334534,
0.14778484404087067,
0.013071100227534771,
-0.31120792031288147,
-0.06768680363893509,
0.7178698778152466,
-0.4335077404975891,
-0.11338122934103012,
-0.25167709589004517,
0.1557627022266388,
-0.06745163351297379,
0.1291733980178833,
0.011501334607601166,
0.43527498841285706,
0.6635803580284119,
-0.7745007276535034,
0.5263479948043823,
0.2582918703556061,
0.07443806529045105,
0.758452296257019,
-0.7004371285438538,
0.214034765958786,
-0.45083877444267273,
0.4511933922767639,
-0.6504701972007751,
-0.6739180088043213,
0.5389088988304138,
-0.4789218306541443,
0.6660588383674622,
-0.1538112461566925,
-0.9044858813285828,
-0.5368664264678955,
0.17865930497646332,
0.08141209185123444,
0.7178928256034851,
-0.638120174407959,
1.0064553022384644,
0.4834178686141968,
0.020784428343176842,
-0.19331638514995575,
-0.5928717851638794,
0.1039934828877449,
-0.0902222990989685,
-0.6379179954528809,
0.20878440141677856,
-0.24946530163288116,
-0.24744385480880737,
-0.033272698521614075,
0.150470569729805,
-0.0072273071855306625,
0.024197112768888474,
0.5005260705947876,
0.41242000460624695,
-0.0632888525724411,
0.31813502311706543,
-0.1962805986404419,
-0.21633993089199066,
0.2873357832431793,
-0.2134552001953125,
0.3989250063896179,
0.306268572807312,
-0.6348671317100525,
-0.6179988384246826,
0.3611256778240204,
0.6640593409538269,
-0.36478954553604126,
0.3726601302623749,
0.5549896955490112,
-0.5047802925109863,
-0.3805214464664459,
-0.44127336144447327,
0.15357717871665955,
-0.41912415623664856,
0.11277348548173904,
-0.23555496335029602,
-0.10712569206953049,
0.6264705061912537,
0.09255879372358322,
0.6138780117034912,
0.9173021912574768,
0.6173150539398193,
-0.03554375097155571,
1.20545494556427,
0.7478607296943665,
-0.06756202131509781,
0.15501706302165985,
-0.11895309388637543,
0.19001521170139313,
-0.2961103618144989,
-0.41897132992744446,
-0.7317407727241516,
-0.09637576341629028,
-0.6908155679702759,
-0.32307878136634827,
0.0957513079047203,
0.06923983991146088,
-0.16786903142929077,
-0.09061096608638763,
-0.6197989583015442,
0.3301849961280823,
0.6495469212532043,
-0.004444482736289501,
0.32875335216522217,
0.13969069719314575,
0.21971027553081512,
0.47719210386276245,
-0.8985759019851685,
-0.8562779426574707,
1.5084749460220337,
0.4932514727115631,
0.7668590545654297,
-0.3493711054325104,
0.9646342992782593,
0.3996288776397705,
0.6073287129402161,
-0.3790881633758545,
0.4990992844104767,
-0.007192614022642374,
-0.8305093050003052,
-0.33236899971961975,
-0.3697136640548706,
-0.9440142512321472,
-0.510825514793396,
0.03492588922381401,
-0.36722680926322937,
-0.06617695838212967,
0.5224716663360596,
0.004085765685886145,
0.258196622133255,
-0.4667985439300537,
0.910280704498291,
-0.25299426913261414,
-0.4413225054740906,
-0.26116296648979187,
-0.6309981346130371,
0.4845777153968811,
-0.21300767362117767,
0.09971288591623306,
-0.13203668594360352,
0.1368257999420166,
0.6213124394416809,
-0.6728992462158203,
0.8441511988639832,
-0.29055970907211304,
-0.3428727984428406,
0.6330569982528687,
-0.25357586145401,
0.9031683802604675,
-0.019710130989551544,
-0.16718128323554993,
0.1380338817834854,
-0.288089394569397,
-0.42820724844932556,
-0.3714776635169983,
0.561316192150116,
-0.6568717956542969,
-0.41753101348876953,
-0.11885855346918106,
-0.6900238394737244,
0.09386447817087173,
0.20811612904071808,
0.12156235426664352,
0.22235123813152313,
-0.3102049231529236,
-0.050641581416130066,
0.6214888691902161,
-0.1823941022157669,
0.3736116886138916,
0.4815361499786377,
-0.04252253845334053,
-0.05665337294340134,
0.9255107045173645,
0.044298671185970306,
-0.08095236867666245,
-0.10469790548086166,
-0.0979294553399086,
-0.17259757220745087,
-0.3961162567138672,
-0.6306585669517517,
0.2828219532966614,
-0.6577149629592896,
-0.4076027572154999,
-0.5160260796546936,
-0.5557841062545776,
-0.42828691005706787,
-0.10022938996553421,
-0.41651806235313416,
-0.22162821888923645,
-0.6551908850669861,
-0.11751528084278107,
0.2246646136045456,
1.0850143432617188,
-0.23048491775989532,
0.11786703765392303,
-0.9760963916778564,
0.388357937335968,
-0.01401348877698183,
0.44378963112831116,
-0.008239139802753925,
-0.24188505113124847,
-0.08813216537237167,
0.09963444620370865,
-0.19585829973220825,
-0.5235366821289062,
0.06482549756765366,
0.04203050211071968,
0.8407498598098755,
0.44067493081092834,
-0.10057687759399414,
0.5895615816116333,
-0.494818776845932,
0.7652143836021423,
0.045599427074193954,
-0.7427465319633484,
0.6776924133300781,
-0.6161615252494812,
0.11200471222400665,
0.22827503085136414,
0.26551008224487305,
-0.28744691610336304,
-0.4978160262107849,
-1.2084155082702637,
-0.7730856537818909,
0.8373480439186096,
0.06393659114837646,
0.2508486807346344,
0.061327967792749405,
0.5972363948822021,
0.18612177670001984,
0.08209613710641861,
-0.41012200713157654,
-0.27922940254211426,
-0.10489343106746674,
-0.5360137820243835,
-0.10271602869033813,
-0.1503722369670868,
-0.23466327786445618,
0.014855788089334965,
0.9246962666511536,
-0.17330820858478546,
0.2069360464811325,
-0.07408738136291504,
0.339061975479126,
-0.1812201291322708,
0.05756133422255516,
0.4413094222545624,
0.8385602235794067,
0.11800603568553925,
-0.1531195193529129,
-0.4302588105201721,
-0.3223104178905487,
0.0208330899477005,
0.3130454421043396,
-0.6701761484146118,
0.14040261507034302,
0.40270382165908813,
0.5997333526611328,
-0.5544291138648987,
-0.7590897679328918,
0.31116852164268494,
0.02117195539176464,
-0.3663073778152466,
-0.695361852645874,
0.39742714166641235,
0.10050614923238754,
0.06033268943428993,
0.12711384892463684,
-0.08216365426778793,
-0.18325549364089966,
-0.46339553594589233,
0.4283201992511749,
0.44062942266464233,
-0.01344106625765562,
0.007863600738346577,
0.8295183777809143,
0.2885339558124542,
-0.3763177990913391,
1.0247704982757568,
-0.1602477729320526,
0.036616548895835876,
0.829961895942688,
0.35630178451538086,
0.6847687363624573,
-0.23705847561359406,
0.2814333438873291,
0.6867783665657043,
0.27564242482185364,
-0.35941872000694275,
0.2869676947593689,
-0.09494189918041229,
-0.31910648941993713,
-0.13819792866706848,
-0.40896469354629517,
-0.2918297350406647,
0.20198944211006165,
-0.7136204242706299,
0.5203876495361328,
-0.4737083911895752,
0.018949082121253014,
-0.17779381573200226,
-0.09567275643348694,
-0.8995647430419922,
0.30243533849716187,
0.32124748826026917,
0.9783392548561096,
-0.8445283770561218,
0.9733108282089233,
0.3009701073169708,
-0.6603633165359497,
-1.0037777423858643,
-0.14395453035831451,
-0.2473164051771164,
-0.8094342350959778,
0.6110947728157043,
-0.008269799873232841,
0.39934971928596497,
0.1244189590215683,
-0.8514212369918823,
-0.7639675140380859,
1.300784707069397,
0.19433537125587463,
-0.6383346915245056,
-0.19543731212615967,
0.37748855352401733,
0.6066485047340393,
-0.5106939673423767,
0.1274205893278122,
0.5288882255554199,
0.6842154264450073,
0.19291968643665314,
-0.6589023470878601,
-0.1300927847623825,
-0.3709563612937927,
-0.13020707666873932,
0.11596731096506119,
-0.3674546778202057,
0.5590024590492249,
0.015209653414785862,
-0.3033010959625244,
0.07647810131311417,
0.596975564956665,
0.298411101102829,
0.35430261492729187,
0.0628720372915268,
0.6661501526832581,
1.1314846277236938,
0.046042732894420624,
1.0188417434692383,
-0.40882888436317444,
-0.1346055567264557,
1.177941083908081,
-0.23165448009967804,
0.8037657737731934,
0.18185193836688995,
0.17162546515464783,
0.05531955882906914,
0.5805920362472534,
-0.522798478603363,
-0.25655853748321533,
0.359128475189209,
0.21859166026115417,
-0.34277716279029846,
-0.2825966477394104,
-0.21901071071624756,
0.5883355140686035,
0.3365252912044525,
-0.8682188391685486,
-0.2826105058193207,
-0.24027715623378754,
-0.05708995833992958,
0.048614080995321274,
-0.6183898448944092,
0.6725074052810669,
-0.22051021456718445,
-0.9387068748474121,
0.24297484755516052,
0.24202905595302582,
0.04758267104625702,
-0.3832511007785797,
-0.366266131401062,
-0.36714792251586914,
0.12173368781805038,
-0.23471879959106445,
-0.7354889512062073,
0.41366803646087646,
0.34595787525177,
-0.3099171221256256,
-0.3739902973175049,
0.6686531901359558,
-0.5201656222343445,
-0.9741644859313965,
0.004252795595675707,
0.4420510232448578,
0.4808639883995056,
0.3215937614440918,
-0.7323275208473206,
0.12495537102222443,
-0.003949545789510012,
-0.0006042782915756106,
-0.09328971803188324,
0.2902415096759796,
-0.2534477114677429,
0.5887033343315125,
0.5671757459640503,
-0.021602993831038475,
0.21245141327381134,
0.0007791505195200443,
0.6867032647132874,
-0.3945365250110626,
-0.3423919379711151,
-0.8276119232177734,
0.7450269460678101,
-0.2932303249835968,
-0.02798367105424404,
0.49965769052505493,
0.7236306071281433,
0.7955135107040405,
0.1290225237607956,
1.0944528579711914,
-0.07286881655454636,
0.5023939609527588,
-0.4696599841117859,
0.8469623327255249,
-0.6013674736022949,
0.16857847571372986,
0.11201754957437515,
-1.0686157941818237,
-0.3910279870033264,
0.2998332381248474,
0.03133055567741394,
-0.04380198195576668,
0.1608223170042038,
0.9179614782333374,
-0.19990842044353485,
-0.2582552134990692,
0.08467413485050201,
0.05238543078303337,
0.7009223699569702,
0.2837497591972351,
0.41629886627197266,
-0.48167160153388977,
0.6185808777809143,
0.22121988236904144,
-0.0007161611574701965,
-0.06332793086767197,
-0.9573720097541809,
-0.9858821630477905,
-0.49512264132499695,
-0.5660208463668823,
-0.08718714863061905,
-0.25229692459106445,
0.6769116520881653,
0.6545069813728333,
-0.4071868360042572,
-0.10613450407981873,
-0.6005024909973145,
0.08651294559240341,
0.29249307513237,
-0.15852977335453033,
0.3641924560070038,
-0.4918941855430603,
-0.7753689289093018,
0.14595966041088104,
0.11406582593917847,
0.35975000262260437,
-0.6032562255859375,
-0.3404616415500641,
0.3063519299030304,
0.2315160632133484,
0.11420553177595139,
0.37156233191490173,
-0.6777703166007996,
0.11949578672647476,
-0.3454723060131073,
-0.33556610345840454,
0.14162927865982056,
0.7788653373718262,
-0.45437943935394287,
0.42046138644218445,
0.4728473424911499,
0.5877566933631897,
0.2623957097530365,
0.11080712080001831,
0.7946209907531738,
-0.5352442860603333,
-0.0666162446141243,
0.21521204710006714,
0.19378778338432312,
0.3492049276828766,
-0.47741568088531494,
0.7426207661628723,
0.044059474021196365,
-0.6179119944572449,
-0.901024580001831,
0.31042832136154175,
-0.7742680907249451,
-0.07378433644771576,
0.9331110119819641,
-0.09671817719936371,
-0.37316593527793884,
0.12882740795612335,
-0.05068978667259216,
0.49547749757766724,
-0.10167596489191055,
0.626056969165802,
0.545055091381073,
-0.08750171214342117,
0.0725899338722229,
-0.5649797320365906,
0.41578155755996704,
-0.16161182522773743,
-1.1901748180389404,
0.6202084422111511,
0.7891176342964172,
-0.10912839323282242,
0.2673474848270416,
0.6730024218559265,
-0.26719117164611816,
0.09279301017522812,
0.2924225330352783,
0.3835966885089874,
-0.36868563294410706,
-0.5645627379417419,
-0.021927202120423317,
0.09800197929143906,
0.08925971388816833,
0.07795330137014389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06239v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06239v1
|
SaudiBERT: A Large Language Model Pretrained on Saudi Dialect Corpora
| 2024-05-10T04:22:54 | 2024-05-10T04:22:54 |
Faisal Qarah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we introduce SaudiBERT, a monodialect Arabic language model
pretrained exclusively on Saudi dialectal text. To demonstrate the model's
effectiveness, we compared SaudiBERT with six different multidialect Arabic
language models across 11 evaluation datasets, which are divided into two
groups: sentiment analysis and text classification. SaudiBERT achieved average
F1-scores of 86.15\% and 87.86\% in these groups respectively, significantly
outperforming all other comparative models. Additionally, we present two novel
Saudi dialectal corpora: the Saudi Tweets Mega Corpus (STMC), which contains
over 141 million tweets in Saudi dialect, and the Saudi Forums Corpus (SFC),
which includes 15.2 GB of text collected from five Saudi online forums. Both
corpora are used in pretraining the proposed model, and they are the largest
Saudi dialectal corpora ever reported in the literature. The results confirm
the effectiveness of SaudiBERT in understanding and analyzing Arabic text
expressed in Saudi dialect, achieving state-of-the-art results in most tasks
and surpassing other language models included in the study. SaudiBERT model is
publicly available on \url{https://huggingface.co/faisalq/SaudiBERT}.
|
[
-0.499855101108551,
-0.494980126619339,
0.41342297196388245,
0.47646206617355347,
-0.33052858710289,
0.2726910412311554,
-0.47502559423446655,
-0.32541361451148987,
0.16474035382270813,
0.7423482537269592,
-0.38907957077026367,
-1.0605080127716064,
-0.6761833429336548,
0.08256127685308456,
-0.45968055725097656,
1.1021500825881958,
-0.13353100419044495,
0.3079894781112671,
0.24106158316135406,
-0.31170594692230225,
0.21002599596977234,
-0.9141935110092163,
-0.2793823480606079,
0.2569447457790375,
0.4777001440525055,
0.5896087288856506,
0.8528137803077698,
0.14171350002288818,
0.18608970940113068,
0.3120291233062744,
0.2969956398010254,
-0.060359831899404526,
-0.4064520299434662,
0.02639634534716606,
0.17905965447425842,
-0.158688485622406,
-0.3490231931209564,
-0.22115740180015564,
0.756837785243988,
1.0353126525878906,
-0.103948675096035,
0.1563282161951065,
-0.1367286890745163,
0.8319776058197021,
-0.8393067717552185,
0.001287886523641646,
-0.4623376429080963,
-0.11330955475568771,
-0.11814817041158676,
0.04968595877289772,
-0.45895978808403015,
-0.2854045629501343,
0.35782870650291443,
-0.21268989145755768,
0.17773602902889252,
0.21123304963111877,
0.5640296339988708,
-0.16626296937465668,
-0.6751934885978699,
-0.4284234344959259,
-0.6327342391014099,
0.9055860638618469,
-0.49299126863479614,
0.6735361814498901,
0.139964759349823,
0.3591688275337219,
0.1789981573820114,
-0.6674808859825134,
-0.5415729284286499,
-0.7122510671615601,
0.3120819628238678,
0.14431582391262054,
0.07194796949625015,
0.2203475534915924,
0.00035704553010873497,
-0.06268453598022461,
-0.427347332239151,
-0.2886514365673065,
-0.47682803869247437,
-0.25807124376296997,
0.37587663531303406,
-0.14980913698673248,
0.21982978284358978,
0.045161522924900055,
-0.41669610142707825,
-0.08851410448551178,
-0.9793119430541992,
0.12214794009923935,
0.6488659381866455,
0.2713013291358948,
-0.1238938719034195,
0.25165194272994995,
-0.10216370224952698,
0.3932182192802429,
-0.30199235677719116,
0.13126683235168457,
0.24325910210609436,
-0.2226180136203766,
-0.13938747346401215,
0.5679911971092224,
1.0454003810882568,
-0.07376068085432053,
0.5957575440406799,
-0.07504721730947495,
-0.37061044573783875,
-0.2839606702327728,
0.45811334252357483,
-1.11031973361969,
-0.40688228607177734,
0.27616509795188904,
-0.464833527803421,
-0.40085190534591675,
0.11398658901453018,
-0.5730434656143188,
-0.21384769678115845,
-0.22786945104599,
0.2789716124534607,
-0.3674841821193695,
-0.40845444798469543,
-0.060236647725105286,
0.14195778965950012,
-0.0820414274930954,
0.429531067609787,
-0.888738214969635,
0.4027937054634094,
0.4703490436077118,
0.9345024824142456,
-0.140306755900383,
-0.3895367383956909,
-0.44731682538986206,
-0.12800054252147675,
-0.5756059288978577,
0.4191763699054718,
-0.6260051131248474,
-0.5665447115898132,
0.5984800457954407,
-0.09081123024225235,
0.2033785879611969,
-0.48910802602767944,
0.48451486229896545,
-0.9392500519752502,
0.023881707340478897,
-0.19158895313739777,
-0.2924540042877197,
-0.14714540541172028,
0.0874025821685791,
-0.9228575825691223,
0.44634726643562317,
0.49404874444007874,
-0.9428920745849609,
0.26843002438545227,
-0.5901943445205688,
-0.25819137692451477,
-0.17152081429958344,
-0.0875711515545845,
-0.20061656832695007,
-0.20942378044128418,
0.09882201999425888,
0.18326179683208466,
-0.34222444891929626,
0.21234846115112305,
-0.588470458984375,
-0.39501625299453735,
0.4405950605869293,
-0.2008492350578308,
0.8871708512306213,
0.1824851632118225,
-0.2510213851928711,
0.5727355480194092,
-0.5937063694000244,
0.0751742571592331,
-0.2644641101360321,
0.02969646081328392,
-0.05593825504183769,
-0.25617513060569763,
0.6769835948944092,
0.4592844545841217,
0.42603597044944763,
-0.6207875609397888,
0.07919726520776749,
-0.46040040254592896,
0.28462761640548706,
0.6751154661178589,
-0.17943596839904785,
0.3104342818260193,
-0.1712692379951477,
0.7616432309150696,
0.252451092004776,
-0.0820695012807846,
0.09499853104352951,
0.1558622568845749,
-1.0007420778274536,
-0.5959773063659668,
0.7120993733406067,
0.3724619448184967,
-0.6331291198730469,
0.43451035022735596,
-0.2737599015235901,
-0.7048722505569458,
-0.6524460911750793,
0.02938094176352024,
0.04937491565942764,
0.18807506561279297,
0.4074900150299072,
-0.2188500612974167,
-0.6824206709861755,
-1.164344310760498,
-0.06320086121559143,
-0.1820376068353653,
0.15300413966178894,
-0.017449920997023582,
0.5542576313018799,
-0.356241911649704,
0.5892364978790283,
-0.058204520493745804,
0.08663217723369598,
-0.6687341332435608,
0.3800520598888397,
-0.016601117327809334,
0.15150079131126404,
0.676770031452179,
-0.6803330779075623,
-0.6841855645179749,
-0.200923889875412,
-0.5059632658958435,
-0.20635294914245605,
0.18110719323158264,
-0.21809662878513336,
0.5723602771759033,
0.43277719616889954,
-0.42707332968711853,
0.15508005023002625,
0.6692924499511719,
-0.053620077669620514,
1.0705475807189941,
-0.03156771883368492,
0.5169842839241028,
-0.9700657725334167,
0.1314428299665451,
-0.07864135503768921,
-0.47233593463897705,
-0.736727774143219,
-0.2131333351135254,
0.20231908559799194,
-0.06867013871669769,
-0.5442222952842712,
0.27126607298851013,
-0.18234661221504211,
0.14015506207942963,
-0.4783717095851898,
0.09323275089263916,
-0.28865569829940796,
0.5113426446914673,
0.23185612261295319,
1.0525615215301514,
0.767566442489624,
-0.4715496599674225,
0.21208380162715912,
0.03611716255545616,
-0.718396008014679,
-0.23136602342128754,
-0.864831805229187,
0.1711949110031128,
-0.23977233469486237,
0.15303492546081543,
-1.1946301460266113,
0.054799169301986694,
0.08840334415435791,
-0.2466629147529602,
0.23265978693962097,
-0.011049184016883373,
-0.46044328808784485,
0.09615249186754227,
-0.5655059814453125,
0.31889498233795166,
0.39269059896469116,
-0.41023126244544983,
0.3231891095638275,
0.43601134419441223,
-0.5461196303367615,
-0.798792839050293,
-0.14961466193199158,
-0.11932969838380814,
-0.1056707575917244,
-0.5062904953956604,
0.0979541763663292,
0.13501368463039398,
-0.23323309421539307,
-0.3187103569507599,
-0.08633947372436523,
-0.1915690302848816,
-0.03146636486053467,
0.42944613099098206,
0.7409060001373291,
-0.3462706506252289,
0.2833794057369232,
0.005248032044619322,
0.1413322538137436,
0.1493266224861145,
-0.14621861279010773,
0.8413525819778442,
-0.5470985770225525,
-0.076628178358078,
-0.26178738474845886,
0.5709695219993591,
0.8478889465332031,
-0.2626493275165558,
1.3080999851226807,
0.5185052752494812,
-0.05675293132662773,
-0.06506141275167465,
-0.3202253580093384,
0.01714816503226757,
-0.4702271819114685,
0.755988597869873,
-0.3682590126991272,
-1.0775128602981567,
0.12162277102470398,
-0.17454861104488373,
0.014362323097884655,
0.44193556904792786,
0.7064122557640076,
0.06304748356342316,
1.279712200164795,
0.6990265250205994,
-0.597212553024292,
0.4056372344493866,
-0.02522885799407959,
0.3035013973712921,
-0.47163715958595276,
0.1492987722158432,
-0.590050458908081,
0.15755584836006165,
-0.9930640459060669,
-0.025333447381854057,
0.4907004237174988,
0.21715982258319855,
-0.746842086315155,
0.3563854992389679,
0.07788334041833878,
-0.0615214966237545,
0.454866886138916,
-0.21280287206172943,
0.14398469030857086,
0.13934139907360077,
-0.18313507735729218,
-0.11569070816040039,
-0.4832327961921692,
-1.034342646598816,
1.2824256420135498,
0.2532622516155243,
0.5394920110702515,
0.3638928532600403,
0.6850088834762573,
0.5519983172416687,
0.6734955310821533,
-0.6900102496147156,
0.3778539001941681,
0.15575267374515533,
-0.6364669799804688,
-0.17990301549434662,
-0.4943287670612335,
-0.7381399869918823,
0.2656387686729431,
-0.1943468451499939,
-0.8279210329055786,
-0.4003567099571228,
0.10161104053258896,
-0.09522445499897003,
-0.16598796844482422,
-0.5827624201774597,
1.2150096893310547,
-0.36931806802749634,
-0.44895946979522705,
-0.4257982671260834,
-0.5893165469169617,
0.3341789245605469,
-0.1970410794019699,
0.23982161283493042,
-0.05159706622362137,
-0.2736176550388336,
0.9205073714256287,
-0.5243446826934814,
0.3423922657966614,
-0.2144136279821396,
0.015970729291439056,
0.40523651242256165,
0.09748515486717224,
0.31034353375434875,
-0.06419046223163605,
-0.266472727060318,
0.44257402420043945,
0.5356948375701904,
-0.5887373685836792,
-0.556923508644104,
0.6863924860954285,
-1.3891270160675049,
-0.4075961709022522,
-0.5754705667495728,
-0.2229365110397339,
-0.5774824023246765,
0.18238365650177002,
0.22423280775547028,
0.6458561420440674,
-0.5903093814849854,
0.13744395971298218,
0.08197835087776184,
-0.20677323639392853,
0.0731281191110611,
0.6028087139129639,
-0.6593244075775146,
-0.4503941237926483,
0.7483246922492981,
0.0005713817081414163,
0.2733208239078522,
0.380730539560318,
-0.10580196231603622,
-0.5022628903388977,
-0.44808492064476013,
-0.7300026416778564,
0.22388799488544464,
-0.7144735455513,
0.21770323812961578,
-0.8772215843200684,
-0.18133702874183655,
-0.6644096374511719,
-0.09202487021684647,
-0.545337438583374,
-0.30252769589424133,
0.2050331085920334,
0.20778417587280273,
-0.043617378920316696,
0.7123538851737976,
0.21138693392276764,
0.4583335220813751,
-0.9318699240684509,
-0.03151753172278404,
-0.03880203142762184,
-0.13044977188110352,
0.005398526322096586,
-0.6799827814102173,
-0.29982224106788635,
0.25763848423957825,
-0.3228122889995575,
-0.9179027080535889,
0.47724831104278564,
-0.04486162215471268,
0.14184458553791046,
0.4895085394382477,
0.06655187904834747,
0.297494500875473,
-0.6087296605110168,
0.6532261967658997,
0.34436607360839844,
-1.1403006315231323,
0.11222553998231888,
-0.3326159715652466,
0.36920779943466187,
1.0725537538528442,
0.9599269032478333,
-0.8073438405990601,
-0.3068297505378723,
-0.6036373972892761,
-0.8428174257278442,
0.5049933195114136,
0.15847310423851013,
-0.007777255028486252,
0.11803082376718521,
-0.18226993083953857,
0.3541891574859619,
0.931562602519989,
-0.4116566479206085,
-0.3530735969543457,
-0.357147753238678,
-0.5784412622451782,
-0.09757789969444275,
-0.316714882850647,
0.1622030884027481,
-0.3091443181037903,
0.9052802920341492,
0.1210477277636528,
0.42908257246017456,
-0.09754914790391922,
-0.48350656032562256,
0.06051280349493027,
0.4633138179779053,
0.6703017354011536,
0.9307805299758911,
-0.23632317781448364,
0.3374139964580536,
0.09832723438739777,
-0.4254818260669708,
0.08807580918073654,
0.08005130290985107,
0.10282831639051437,
0.09523593634366989,
0.5522404909133911,
0.4907040596008301,
0.014398166909813881,
-1.0358402729034424,
0.7444784045219421,
0.06414229422807693,
-0.1351729929447174,
-0.6785981059074402,
0.024086978286504745,
0.16495530307292938,
-0.029914045706391335,
0.1433214545249939,
0.09392223507165909,
0.24625800549983978,
-0.8806154727935791,
0.12028167396783829,
0.3803792893886566,
-0.6798785924911499,
-0.23220385611057281,
0.23236852884292603,
0.17885544896125793,
-0.03152205049991608,
0.5853219032287598,
-0.2747145891189575,
-1.1911370754241943,
0.42847031354904175,
0.46729931235313416,
0.4691306948661804,
-0.002340505365282297,
0.2117716372013092,
0.4465358853340149,
0.14906220138072968,
0.04122167080640793,
0.1267489641904831,
-0.3348555862903595,
-0.8662570714950562,
-0.2486204206943512,
-0.6510294079780579,
-0.7074418663978577,
0.30987733602523804,
-0.2651565670967102,
0.1468982994556427,
-0.615446150302887,
0.060103368014097214,
0.18635176122188568,
0.29003575444221497,
-0.611671507358551,
-0.013275406323373318,
0.1967533975839615,
0.883437991142273,
-0.6678651571273804,
0.9789336323738098,
0.7074291706085205,
-0.4286486506462097,
-0.7038333415985107,
0.09712419658899307,
-0.22016820311546326,
-0.7210009694099426,
0.7997931838035583,
0.5627692937850952,
-0.7902106642723083,
-0.06297655403614044,
-0.8490585088729858,
-0.552867591381073,
0.3286491632461548,
0.34037792682647705,
-0.6957089304924011,
0.37513479590415955,
0.25702542066574097,
0.4761224687099457,
-0.6078650951385498,
0.6434484124183655,
0.5369288921356201,
0.2569631040096283,
-0.1331213265657425,
-0.8003979325294495,
-0.08779972046613693,
-0.37900230288505554,
-0.25485530495643616,
0.42581474781036377,
-0.7109885215759277,
0.6916046738624573,
-0.045967694371938705,
-0.03012966923415661,
0.3093239367008209,
0.9699743390083313,
0.17237181961536407,
-0.08357466757297516,
0.5969399213790894,
-0.10528422892093658,
0.7966241240501404,
0.25268277525901794,
0.7407714128494263,
-0.75565505027771,
0.3301387131214142,
1.0179529190063477,
-0.591920018196106,
0.9380648136138916,
0.2914544343948364,
-0.27129054069519043,
0.8735625147819519,
0.43973639607429504,
0.41120487451553345,
0.701910674571991,
0.41152194142341614,
-0.8575118780136108,
-0.5197590589523315,
-0.16148804128170013,
-0.40095606446266174,
0.5960239768028259,
0.13801325857639313,
-0.4627626836299896,
-0.04673285409808159,
0.07125826925039291,
0.24150601029396057,
-0.0072687771171331406,
-0.2389136105775833,
0.2188868224620819,
-0.022648852318525314,
-0.7512919306755066,
0.6038119196891785,
0.3452983498573303,
0.5448826551437378,
-0.7529657483100891,
0.17089968919754028,
0.3330211937427521,
0.26778551936149597,
0.10810589045286179,
-0.31727370619773865,
-0.09767463803291321,
0.151050865650177,
0.020451288670301437,
-0.11158028990030289,
0.7468314170837402,
-0.7218722105026245,
-0.6000047922134399,
0.12856334447860718,
0.5737603306770325,
0.3415251672267914,
-0.3885273337364197,
-0.4293373227119446,
0.20215080678462982,
-0.03908631578087807,
-0.16061389446258545,
0.2509593963623047,
0.36711037158966064,
0.14156122505664825,
0.3472972512245178,
0.37982892990112305,
0.15655800700187683,
-0.2665497064590454,
0.24937370419502258,
0.6549744009971619,
-0.8056765198707581,
-0.36447611451148987,
-0.8851094841957092,
0.0404280386865139,
-0.24960047006607056,
-0.3371759355068207,
0.6802076101303101,
0.7066899538040161,
0.6521356701850891,
-0.20569781959056854,
1.1539772748947144,
0.1441219300031662,
0.46123936772346497,
-0.30166223645210266,
0.9680213332176208,
-0.38979437947273254,
-0.2772600054740906,
-0.10712369531393051,
-0.7862874865531921,
0.21002604067325592,
0.907712996006012,
-0.49285250902175903,
0.44110870361328125,
0.8151739835739136,
0.8977776765823364,
0.016379335895180702,
0.5004863739013672,
0.3014478087425232,
0.12521737813949585,
0.11035823822021484,
0.5853509902954102,
1.0798938274383545,
-0.26476994156837463,
0.3457905650138855,
-0.23378226161003113,
-0.11016002297401428,
-0.38024061918258667,
-0.5200381278991699,
-1.2148374319076538,
-0.6473692059516907,
-0.11417499929666519,
-0.48329365253448486,
0.11046549677848816,
1.6933951377868652,
0.7125429511070251,
-1.0087480545043945,
-0.524612307548523,
0.032562751322984695,
-0.1400739699602127,
0.25990575551986694,
-0.1422683149576187,
0.36657261848449707,
-0.2764914035797119,
-0.5320984721183777,
0.14655336737632751,
0.18083973228931427,
-0.0971512570977211,
-0.4454454481601715,
-0.04468904808163643,
-0.19786784052848816,
0.019500363618135452,
0.721693217754364,
-0.017009763047099113,
-0.1520223170518875,
-0.5013183951377869,
0.019338997080922127,
-0.5902000665664673,
0.08263280242681503,
0.910986602306366,
-0.6469514966011047,
0.22587139904499054,
0.12276826798915863,
0.34255990386009216,
0.594006359577179,
-0.07081007212400436,
0.5474170446395874,
-0.3629765212535858,
0.27430760860443115,
0.27446499466896057,
0.34914469718933105,
0.48501670360565186,
0.1907854676246643,
0.09514417499303818,
-0.031132832169532776,
-0.5171231031417847,
-0.3186971843242645,
0.2605481445789337,
-1.0353477001190186,
-0.11258979141712189,
1.1750366687774658,
0.01460425928235054,
-0.3506604731082916,
-0.2548619210720062,
-0.5024974346160889,
0.5256593823432922,
-0.7262871265411377,
0.7967549562454224,
1.0103281736373901,
0.2033044993877411,
0.00037176316254772246,
-0.8369455933570862,
0.39883169531822205,
0.6469928622245789,
-0.682667076587677,
-0.016206666827201843,
0.41994819045066833,
0.25478968024253845,
0.04941532760858536,
0.726378858089447,
0.27987396717071533,
0.46973633766174316,
-0.023032942786812782,
0.17526531219482422,
0.1177763044834137,
-0.6066880226135254,
-0.02114739827811718,
0.4598395526409149,
0.5454607605934143,
-0.09188362956047058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06221v1
|
For the Misgendered Chinese in Gender Bias Research: Multi-Task Learning with Knowledge Distillation for Pinyin Name-Gender Prediction
| 2024-05-10T03:16:07 | 2024-05-10T03:16:07 |
Xiaocong Du, Haipeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Achieving gender equality is a pivotal factor in realizing the UN's Global
Goals for Sustainable Development. Gender bias studies work towards this and
rely on name-based gender inference tools to assign individual gender labels
when gender information is unavailable. However, these tools often inaccurately
predict gender for Chinese Pinyin names, leading to potential bias in such
studies. With the growing participation of Chinese in international activities,
this situation is becoming more severe. Specifically, current tools focus on
pronunciation (Pinyin) information, neglecting the fact that the latent
connections between Pinyin and Chinese characters (Hanzi) behind convey
critical information. As a first effort, we formulate the Pinyin name-gender
guessing problem and design a Multi-Task Learning Network assisted by Knowledge
Distillation that enables the Pinyin embeddings in the model to possess
semantic features of Chinese characters and to learn gender information from
Chinese character names. Our open-sourced method surpasses commercial
name-gender guessing tools by 9.70\% to 20.08\% relatively, and also
outperforms the state-of-the-art algorithms.
|
[
0.1929575800895691,
-0.5670934319496155,
0.3445638120174408,
0.2503168284893036,
-0.07731664180755615,
0.0996783971786499,
-0.08478425443172455,
-0.06889870762825012,
-0.253213107585907,
0.1622716337442398,
-1.0382299423217773,
-0.33774396777153015,
-0.6848171949386597,
0.028551820665597916,
0.03626635670661926,
0.6690943241119385,
0.14788012206554413,
0.6953444480895996,
0.36050131916999817,
0.13296066224575043,
-0.8463274836540222,
-0.21905502676963806,
-0.48517802357673645,
-0.4099457263946533,
0.6404851675033569,
0.5300823450088501,
0.23069941997528076,
0.45002391934394836,
0.3410714566707611,
0.22888003289699554,
-0.12129047513008118,
0.49932342767715454,
-0.436985045671463,
0.04114822298288345,
0.18049684166908264,
-0.37935009598731995,
-0.24990808963775635,
0.17060723900794983,
0.35400524735450745,
0.7078869938850403,
-0.22594301402568817,
0.40552130341529846,
0.43876829743385315,
0.8607550263404846,
-0.6940011978149414,
0.41306573152542114,
-0.7043702006340027,
0.4549575448036194,
-0.38529014587402344,
0.09841650724411011,
-0.21091675758361816,
-0.06629975885152817,
0.1768844872713089,
-0.5933587551116943,
0.38917800784111023,
0.19556443393230438,
0.4210004210472107,
0.1666027009487152,
-0.30364465713500977,
-0.0874415934085846,
-0.5276804566383362,
1.0728726387023926,
-0.4883113503456116,
0.38885700702667236,
0.38831743597984314,
0.4043521285057068,
-0.47995060682296753,
-0.3524133861064911,
-0.43178561329841614,
-0.21606606245040894,
0.01784616708755493,
0.08288164436817169,
0.16967245936393738,
0.03306494653224945,
0.33094334602355957,
0.019261814653873444,
-0.23636332154273987,
-0.21826118230819702,
-0.4268594980239868,
-0.15012124180793762,
0.5401328802108765,
-0.08789677917957306,
0.6796678900718689,
-0.16369381546974182,
-0.4168875515460968,
0.17188268899917603,
-0.7265568971633911,
0.02721564844250679,
0.5650959014892578,
1.0257606506347656,
0.22134381532669067,
0.212466299533844,
-0.1860702782869339,
0.4226350784301758,
0.4669268727302551,
-0.1454581916332245,
0.47117331624031067,
-0.14710702002048492,
-0.22377590835094452,
0.5091291069984436,
0.7317631840705872,
0.057768408209085464,
-0.12276042252779007,
-0.20687313377857208,
0.33622393012046814,
-0.6276766061782837,
0.09589744359254837,
-0.6454702615737915,
-0.35510656237602234,
-0.004803873132914305,
-0.6859018802642822,
-0.019293202087283134,
0.36098796129226685,
-0.7332634329795837,
-0.6382280588150024,
-0.2272462695837021,
0.3759327232837677,
-0.28620922565460205,
-0.5237912535667419,
-0.36497533321380615,
-0.7089765667915344,
-0.11811473220586777,
0.5353713631629944,
-1.1072044372558594,
-0.2512092888355255,
0.5407072305679321,
0.8665497303009033,
0.07440279424190521,
-0.42577868700027466,
-0.3082512617111206,
0.10162566602230072,
-0.26338157057762146,
0.10918688029050827,
-0.3561233580112457,
-0.3225417733192444,
-0.3239654004573822,
0.21097898483276367,
-0.15943586826324463,
-0.4892485737800598,
0.4535053074359894,
0.12550827860832214,
-0.0337153822183609,
-1.0387041568756104,
-0.0803825706243515,
-0.1990051120519638,
-0.05428245663642883,
-0.7584194540977478,
0.8531020879745483,
-0.09359798580408096,
-1.2593296766281128,
0.5318560600280762,
-0.5984026193618774,
-0.28520840406417847,
0.008542793802917004,
-0.09154257923364639,
-0.2720911204814911,
-0.12092200666666031,
0.21030525863170624,
0.3582383990287781,
-0.34964609146118164,
0.4957936704158783,
-0.24221013486385345,
-0.2944682240486145,
-0.175739586353302,
-0.5277321934700012,
1.1961803436279297,
0.16175147891044617,
-0.5541223287582397,
-0.14181675016880035,
-0.41053977608680725,
-0.37821799516677856,
0.08186701685190201,
0.06467095762491226,
-0.4944245219230652,
0.0952768474817276,
-0.07831063866615295,
0.07598906010389328,
0.296699196100235,
-0.7898052930831909,
-0.007606544066220522,
0.12383610010147095,
0.584642231464386,
0.9378929138183594,
-0.5684964656829834,
0.26385489106178284,
-0.30424177646636963,
0.0980679988861084,
0.24415268003940582,
0.3881795108318329,
0.08738090842962265,
-0.6507622003555298,
-0.5446736216545105,
0.02071494050323963,
0.32675525546073914,
0.586096465587616,
-0.9626719355583191,
0.15929900109767914,
0.20053140819072723,
-0.8171342611312866,
-0.4533468782901764,
0.29643598198890686,
0.43615198135375977,
0.7306686639785767,
0.508358895778656,
0.013064772821962833,
-0.6396065950393677,
-0.8119861483573914,
-0.6302392482757568,
-0.48952609300613403,
-0.10600578039884567,
0.30820339918136597,
0.427500456571579,
-0.06199268996715546,
0.7516515851020813,
-0.5008633136749268,
-0.7453329563140869,
-0.38107940554618835,
0.44371306896209717,
0.06188156455755234,
0.5828858613967896,
0.36445873975753784,
-1.099776029586792,
-0.3978458344936371,
-0.14928020536899567,
-0.6126428842544556,
0.10273849219083786,
0.25656935572624207,
-0.5551331043243408,
-0.2901099920272827,
0.22267167270183563,
-0.2981720268726349,
0.15661366283893585,
0.5076020359992981,
-0.08836992084980011,
0.7149681448936462,
-0.14974793791770935,
0.2241235375404358,
-1.0270463228225708,
0.1802026480436325,
0.31772515177726746,
0.26945269107818604,
-0.8595800995826721,
-0.14517220854759216,
0.24725143611431122,
0.11941932886838913,
-0.6754242181777954,
0.480136513710022,
-0.8090463876724243,
0.34280291199684143,
-0.05719031020998955,
0.025056982412934303,
-0.2597203552722931,
0.5076069235801697,
-0.18661710619926453,
0.6975312232971191,
0.35399967432022095,
-0.5614743232727051,
0.5201175808906555,
0.31940799951553345,
-0.28411245346069336,
0.39792922139167786,
-0.36254268884658813,
-0.02201029472053051,
-0.14204370975494385,
0.21969202160835266,
-0.9934713840484619,
-0.02887647971510887,
0.4158443212509155,
-0.4911554753780365,
0.27133941650390625,
-0.10439395159482956,
-0.2603349983692169,
-0.5331255197525024,
-0.23713459074497223,
0.5587804317474365,
0.24170708656311035,
-0.7059095501899719,
0.4735095202922821,
0.6760066747665405,
0.013699604198336601,
-1.3666071891784668,
-0.834402322769165,
-0.09485065937042236,
-0.21204239130020142,
-0.4664806127548218,
0.33666354417800903,
-0.04312209412455559,
-0.08790258318185806,
-0.21290570497512817,
-0.27923518419265747,
-0.5826839208602905,
0.12739574909210205,
0.24882155656814575,
0.2558573782444,
0.09355619549751282,
0.3849051296710968,
0.15231619775295258,
0.07753974944353104,
-0.09151142090559006,
-0.1062842607498169,
0.162980318069458,
0.31524547934532166,
-0.26826557517051697,
-0.537570059299469,
0.17873699963092804,
0.3966544270515442,
0.041881367564201355,
0.6345031261444092,
0.7664045095443726,
-0.5402010679244995,
-0.3656013309955597,
-0.4094018340110779,
-0.21542872488498688,
-0.4592132568359375,
0.5267254114151001,
-0.2026769518852234,
-0.7628946900367737,
0.453255832195282,
-0.16653397679328918,
0.21538691222667694,
0.5503020882606506,
0.24683837592601776,
-0.035504937171936035,
1.113928198814392,
0.7994838356971741,
-0.3486364781856537,
0.4112546145915985,
0.11050232499837875,
0.19646157324314117,
-0.9946063756942749,
-0.221610888838768,
-0.435794472694397,
-0.4909149408340454,
-0.6208006739616394,
-0.49097391963005066,
0.19228963553905487,
-0.18116164207458496,
-0.35733455419540405,
0.2899056375026703,
-0.6233660578727722,
0.12284000962972641,
0.9443703889846802,
0.4732251465320587,
0.16471344232559204,
-0.26559701561927795,
-0.19713138043880463,
-0.2640095353126526,
-0.46866872906684875,
-0.057511426508426666,
0.9039878845214844,
0.09090326726436615,
0.803934633731842,
-0.03194447606801987,
0.5183822512626648,
0.5713191032409668,
-0.04276294261217117,
-0.37654316425323486,
0.217953160405159,
-0.5644441843032837,
-0.8387311100959778,
-0.5671040415763855,
-0.6075881719589233,
-0.7540938258171082,
0.3940543234348297,
-0.0649762749671936,
-0.6942781209945679,
0.11889045685529709,
0.1263163834810257,
-0.3331091105937958,
0.5230633020401001,
-0.38654574751853943,
0.9313268661499023,
-0.2607402801513672,
-0.15916991233825684,
0.12011224776506424,
-0.5677128434181213,
0.8802966475486755,
-0.012608652003109455,
0.24842876195907593,
-0.5746070742607117,
0.4524572491645813,
0.7599630355834961,
-0.34391772747039795,
0.9076640009880066,
-0.5290920734405518,
-0.10655352473258972,
0.01034658681601286,
-0.16380290687084198,
0.019358044490218163,
-0.03333710506558418,
-0.17370985448360443,
0.6438099145889282,
-0.19332626461982727,
-0.10793153941631317,
-0.285637766122818,
0.5540823936462402,
-0.864151120185852,
-0.6412554383277893,
-0.24443984031677246,
-0.41449081897735596,
0.06429308652877808,
0.2672613859176636,
0.28526750206947327,
0.1334323287010193,
-0.41752275824546814,
-0.034834668040275574,
0.6097545027732849,
-0.35127541422843933,
0.21085697412490845,
0.05430472642183304,
0.008128900080919266,
0.02237984538078308,
0.906118631362915,
0.5132238268852234,
0.08100111037492752,
0.5292009711265564,
0.43971410393714905,
-0.17055322229862213,
0.018239257857203484,
-0.6499508619308472,
-0.017500536516308784,
-0.44668373465538025,
-0.03161263465881348,
-0.5757192969322205,
-0.5242050886154175,
-0.391272634267807,
0.3977522552013397,
-0.4556633532047272,
-0.057906609028577805,
-0.34093335270881653,
0.09687241911888123,
-0.04718409851193428,
0.4594361186027527,
-0.017953423783183098,
0.3092651069164276,
-0.7749127745628357,
0.6049689650535583,
0.5948520302772522,
0.034281376749277115,
0.21932384371757507,
-0.3129381239414215,
-0.15960116684436798,
0.6053929924964905,
-0.4746667146682739,
-1.0054683685302734,
0.4429059624671936,
0.2435787171125412,
0.7851449847221375,
0.3978007435798645,
0.36314189434051514,
0.7842194437980652,
-0.6338203549385071,
0.7675964832305908,
0.3170662820339203,
-1.1927944421768188,
0.5579927563667297,
-0.19874554872512817,
0.19750653207302094,
0.5309024453163147,
0.1657366156578064,
-0.9448713064193726,
-0.40744245052337646,
-0.24229729175567627,
-0.8128541707992554,
1.0644181966781616,
0.2499426007270813,
0.1434975117444992,
0.251115083694458,
0.20842549204826355,
0.5960347652435303,
0.4681577980518341,
-0.4739837944507599,
-0.7401475310325623,
-0.10721767693758011,
-0.16913169622421265,
0.07703861594200134,
-0.26986342668533325,
-0.00606159120798111,
-0.32604706287384033,
0.8345595598220825,
-0.14265751838684082,
0.28553837537765503,
0.1775231510400772,
-0.19725143909454346,
-0.13860011100769043,
0.15642286837100983,
0.3051222860813141,
0.626880407333374,
-0.12050767242908478,
0.016340237110853195,
0.26286834478378296,
-0.7576220631599426,
0.08195128291845322,
-0.003143810899928212,
-0.22941292822360992,
0.34003838896751404,
-0.002108578337356448,
0.841627299785614,
-0.10475031286478043,
-0.346186101436615,
0.43131932616233826,
-0.4892464280128479,
-0.330480694770813,
-0.33717021346092224,
0.04046304523944855,
0.06698048859834671,
0.40662527084350586,
0.8689094185829163,
-0.08250682801008224,
0.36720505356788635,
-0.6381145715713501,
0.004416896495968103,
0.4882420301437378,
-0.5907793045043945,
-0.08553291112184525,
0.7897585034370422,
0.4067608118057251,
-0.021810485050082207,
0.7186410427093506,
-0.19170798361301422,
-0.7870771884918213,
0.8885476589202881,
0.1623857021331787,
1.0470677614212036,
-0.6113882064819336,
0.46571221947669983,
0.7760372161865234,
0.2675408720970154,
-0.5005674958229065,
0.23823599517345428,
-0.07662148773670197,
-0.7342860698699951,
0.02131488546729088,
-0.36088061332702637,
-0.3691529333591461,
-0.16221266984939575,
-0.3904907703399658,
0.5036222338676453,
-0.27937084436416626,
-0.3738146126270294,
-0.13303445279598236,
0.05028264969587326,
-0.5368029475212097,
-0.003910332452505827,
0.4292353689670563,
0.5215310454368591,
-0.8031765818595886,
0.6982929706573486,
0.3336051404476166,
-0.14923636615276337,
-0.9801781177520752,
0.15643493831157684,
0.2724509835243225,
-0.8760207891464233,
1.1980615854263306,
0.6232715845108032,
-0.05360419675707817,
-0.1994994878768921,
-0.36003440618515015,
-0.8683534264564514,
1.3352833986282349,
0.6430557370185852,
-0.750735342502594,
-0.3215135335922241,
0.033710457384586334,
-0.0824192613363266,
-0.0012262776726856828,
0.6490669846534729,
0.23778611421585083,
0.7621472477912903,
0.07544004917144775,
-1.2266182899475098,
-0.08887144923210144,
-0.2555469572544098,
-0.02353500761091709,
0.0763908326625824,
-0.9170401096343994,
1.430220365524292,
-0.36794614791870117,
-0.37897777557373047,
-0.11479361355304718,
0.6155556440353394,
0.2836679518222809,
0.3242897093296051,
0.6031306982040405,
0.05658402293920517,
1.0660412311553955,
-0.41244709491729736,
0.16664324700832367,
-0.21043527126312256,
0.35109156370162964,
0.9849328398704529,
-0.06269245594739914,
0.35844093561172485,
0.3548918664455414,
-0.29465287923812866,
0.4791857898235321,
0.6713700890541077,
-0.1289394050836563,
0.5696961879730225,
0.33352556824684143,
0.019056441262364388,
-0.112801693379879,
-0.30445700883865356,
-0.507491946220398,
0.5438489317893982,
0.189173623919487,
-0.3328857719898224,
-0.22460702061653137,
-0.1588352471590042,
-0.04123934358358383,
-0.24031776189804077,
-0.24459421634674072,
0.4835353493690491,
0.23852092027664185,
-0.4478410482406616,
0.03105686418712139,
-0.024780284613370895,
0.9759212732315063,
-0.5602003931999207,
-0.28949597477912903,
0.08399743586778641,
0.18701696395874023,
-0.18996481597423553,
-0.3424740433692932,
-0.23345136642456055,
-0.25315073132514954,
-0.27618879079818726,
-0.11256572604179382,
0.6568530201911926,
-0.8932119011878967,
-0.640569806098938,
0.3961833715438843,
0.744587779045105,
-0.17768047749996185,
-0.2937842011451721,
-0.8677141666412354,
-0.4595383405685425,
0.05951828137040138,
0.16136331856250763,
0.2933045029640198,
0.5676649212837219,
0.17918004095554352,
0.7919163703918457,
0.4214154779911041,
0.16580241918563843,
0.23919104039669037,
0.04764894023537636,
0.34354501962661743,
-0.5031039118766785,
-0.5834710597991943,
-1.2137938737869263,
0.37139299511909485,
-0.007632291875779629,
-0.11719296872615814,
0.9493873715400696,
0.052361831068992615,
0.7605370879173279,
-0.008275640197098255,
1.0699453353881836,
-0.06885138154029846,
0.3564688265323639,
-0.26274240016937256,
1.210224986076355,
-0.7804745435714722,
-0.2659837007522583,
-0.6612291932106018,
-0.93439781665802,
-0.018414443358778954,
0.3924642503261566,
0.2600444555282593,
0.25254273414611816,
0.5142519474029541,
0.34584683179855347,
0.16341659426689148,
0.17452090978622437,
0.2680126428604126,
-0.12755045294761658,
0.2487809807062149,
0.6632506251335144,
0.7770500183105469,
-0.48931562900543213,
0.22703950107097626,
-0.46817144751548767,
-0.0606093592941761,
-0.23809634149074554,
-0.8674070239067078,
-0.8556175827980042,
-0.6736614108085632,
-0.1714799702167511,
0.15075571835041046,
0.4120166301727295,
0.9730079770088196,
0.8237807750701904,
-0.5220184326171875,
-0.2734106779098511,
0.03380131721496582,
0.5069853663444519,
-0.5648570656776428,
-0.12007112056016922,
0.3942764103412628,
-0.34675219655036926,
-1.0605199337005615,
-0.06180872023105621,
-0.07030712813138962,
-0.35344481468200684,
-0.3217466473579407,
-0.0127105712890625,
-0.2774898409843445,
-0.3388282358646393,
0.15087872743606567,
0.1202194094657898,
-0.851611852645874,
-0.17656975984573364,
-0.09136338531970978,
-0.13287879526615143,
-0.07233253866434097,
0.7742995023727417,
-0.24859270453453064,
0.6557847261428833,
0.5685287714004517,
0.4221004545688629,
-0.2831239104270935,
0.006774231791496277,
0.8147527575492859,
-0.7024403810501099,
-0.008200787007808685,
-0.15599891543388367,
0.5882815718650818,
0.39196112751960754,
-0.6202645897865295,
0.24264051020145416,
0.3599845767021179,
-0.49406784772872925,
-0.6357256174087524,
-0.06312853842973709,
-0.563992977142334,
-0.4961159825325012,
1.1391706466674805,
-0.2516994774341583,
-0.32806679606437683,
-0.15342183411121368,
-0.5626006126403809,
0.9844018220901489,
-0.7567903995513916,
0.9864137768745422,
0.7840721607208252,
0.12808455526828766,
-0.022927425801753998,
-0.6932334899902344,
0.5565927624702454,
0.22887708246707916,
-0.3201063275337219,
0.5313801169395447,
0.29476016759872437,
0.10629831999540329,
0.1265389323234558,
0.5074441432952881,
0.23126442730426788,
0.23720231652259827,
0.024606147781014442,
0.2866106331348419,
-0.18924175202846527,
-0.5112282037734985,
0.1813051402568817,
-0.10818101465702057,
-0.08643318712711334,
-0.4131408929824829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06719v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06719v1
|
Enhancing Traffic Prediction with Textual Data Using Large Language Models
| 2024-05-10T03:14:26 | 2024-05-10T03:14:26 |
Xiannan Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Traffic prediction is pivotal for rational transportation supply scheduling
and allocation. Existing researches into short-term traffic prediction,
however, face challenges in adequately addressing exceptional circumstances and
integrating non-numerical contextual information like weather into models.
While, Large language models offer a promising solution due to their inherent
world knowledge. However, directly using them for traffic prediction presents
drawbacks such as high cost, lack of determinism, and limited mathematical
capability. To mitigate these issues, this study proposes a novel approach.
Instead of directly employing large models for prediction, it utilizes them to
process textual information and obtain embeddings. These embeddings are then
combined with historical traffic data and inputted into traditional
spatiotemporal forecasting models. The study investigates two types of special
scenarios: regional-level and node-level. For regional-level scenarios, textual
information is represented as a node connected to the entire network. For
node-level scenarios, embeddings from the large model represent additional
nodes connected only to corresponding nodes. This approach shows a significant
improvement in prediction accuracy according to our experiment of New York Bike
dataset.
|
[
-0.40156370401382446,
-0.9662138819694519,
0.9728585481643677,
0.3362523913383484,
-0.5185960531234741,
0.09369105845689774,
-0.31907740235328674,
-0.6258161664009094,
0.6750571727752686,
0.6200607419013977,
-0.32815513014793396,
-0.36803722381591797,
-0.2651168704032898,
-0.2818583846092224,
-0.4811067283153534,
0.6024691462516785,
-0.10500262677669525,
0.02974395826458931,
-0.0716569572687149,
0.07932987064123154,
-0.6396058201789856,
-0.4692622125148773,
-0.6134909391403198,
-0.17786835134029388,
0.5280507206916809,
0.08523175865411758,
0.8279018402099609,
0.5328165888786316,
0.4721216857433319,
0.3422350585460663,
0.2333538681268692,
0.35796278715133667,
-0.2311657965183258,
0.1164950281381607,
-0.18716372549533844,
0.24054983258247375,
-0.1424725353717804,
-0.3972885012626648,
0.9688609838485718,
0.8316162824630737,
-0.32236239314079285,
-0.44053709506988525,
-0.18160992860794067,
0.34723174571990967,
-0.3938293755054474,
0.2405848503112793,
-0.9428876638412476,
0.03344964608550072,
-0.2953135371208191,
-0.5630378127098083,
-0.3496648669242859,
-0.22172760963439941,
0.46047642827033997,
-0.7057952880859375,
-0.03211187571287155,
0.47394439578056335,
0.6618882417678833,
0.12913843989372253,
-0.8637851476669312,
-0.10795576870441437,
-0.8149420022964478,
0.7907153367996216,
-0.43800368905067444,
0.28149229288101196,
0.511936604976654,
0.5156378746032715,
-0.11950142681598663,
-0.4944346249103546,
-0.574121356010437,
0.14744041860103607,
-0.11715831607580185,
0.23206168413162231,
0.07109124213457108,
-0.29407694935798645,
-0.11867549270391464,
-0.30346396565437317,
-0.4866958260536194,
0.046942707151174545,
-0.45148059725761414,
0.1194700077176094,
0.7389213442802429,
0.7573516368865967,
0.11725478619337082,
-0.03887040540575981,
-0.7099428176879883,
0.10471272468566895,
-0.5264995098114014,
-0.14362390339374542,
0.1417229175567627,
0.6177904009819031,
-0.38540107011795044,
0.4416085481643677,
-0.21389079093933105,
0.44837620854377747,
-0.23519210517406464,
0.13113753497600555,
0.5286597609519958,
-0.1265137940645218,
-0.13244493305683136,
0.022026855498552322,
0.8917738795280457,
0.4127763509750366,
0.38102468848228455,
-0.4334259629249573,
-0.10845902562141418,
-0.4635260999202728,
0.06807629019021988,
-0.7043407559394836,
-0.07287171483039856,
0.17025141417980194,
-0.11261741816997528,
-0.13472740352153778,
0.11279585212469101,
-1.1759001016616821,
-0.405640572309494,
-0.5551220178604126,
-0.01343074906617403,
-0.5516372919082642,
-0.49469617009162903,
0.2770208418369293,
0.10509958863258362,
-0.1304192841053009,
0.655075192451477,
-0.6082801222801208,
0.10997328907251358,
0.6002806425094604,
1.0721335411071777,
-0.2653152644634247,
-0.4724448323249817,
-0.24808192253112793,
0.6548554301261902,
-0.20034259557724,
1.0585780143737793,
-0.8552054166793823,
-0.26716965436935425,
0.26303631067276,
0.196162149310112,
-0.05547178164124489,
0.01188394334167242,
0.457248330116272,
-0.67252516746521,
-0.09976184368133545,
0.16925981640815735,
-0.5417881608009338,
-0.24770291149616241,
0.011619402095675468,
-0.8284924626350403,
0.8418424129486084,
-0.025610094889998436,
-0.9187071323394775,
0.023572269827127457,
-0.5079010725021362,
-0.80226069688797,
0.009900836274027824,
0.11739817261695862,
-0.6324331760406494,
0.08092932403087616,
0.16113664209842682,
0.5732206702232361,
-0.24559473991394043,
0.7353646159172058,
-0.5965495705604553,
-0.12973368167877197,
0.45687156915664673,
-0.3050937056541443,
0.4008747935295105,
0.10577423125505447,
-0.008153927512466908,
0.03364168852567673,
-0.39342257380485535,
-0.0448727086186409,
0.055083710700273514,
-0.03191133216023445,
-0.4730726480484009,
0.11702533066272736,
0.505486786365509,
0.17117999494075775,
0.15683607757091522,
-0.5847882628440857,
-0.02104114182293415,
-0.6143444180488586,
0.3669120669364929,
1.1438432931900024,
-0.11111631244421005,
0.7587506771087646,
-0.14999106526374817,
0.5767484307289124,
0.311960905790329,
-0.04744404926896095,
-0.06074576452374458,
-0.7205674648284912,
-0.4029243588447571,
0.3076397776603699,
0.5210058093070984,
0.4431832432746887,
-1.0349459648132324,
0.23341411352157593,
-0.8499832153320312,
-0.5129221081733704,
0.09028544276952744,
-0.40176641941070557,
-0.19707812368869781,
0.12731827795505524,
0.28681743144989014,
0.24374344944953918,
-0.7744376063346863,
-0.25649988651275635,
0.20837873220443726,
0.1478116363286972,
0.30131250619888306,
0.3084084391593933,
0.4673919379711151,
-0.12209903448820114,
0.8913573026657104,
-0.9205685257911682,
-0.027545694261789322,
-0.267499178647995,
-0.13103778660297394,
0.15091675519943237,
0.47145965695381165,
0.5940297245979309,
-0.7074787020683289,
-0.738405168056488,
0.11076679080724716,
-0.2935636341571808,
0.34609028697013855,
-0.1581973135471344,
-0.5366756319999695,
-0.0041525280103087425,
0.4052070081233978,
-0.43355152010917664,
0.4714464545249939,
0.8513801693916321,
-0.9036334753036499,
0.2567894160747528,
-0.09488625824451447,
-0.11544714123010635,
-1.1545445919036865,
-0.43516987562179565,
0.01526565570384264,
-0.6760722398757935,
-0.4446990191936493,
-0.38838452100753784,
-0.1113482415676117,
-0.4934704005718231,
-0.29286205768585205,
0.7483729720115662,
-0.12023225426673889,
0.02053019404411316,
-0.206662118434906,
-0.005763228517025709,
-0.17791414260864258,
0.17875775694847107,
0.30702176690101624,
0.6510311961174011,
0.6655762791633606,
-0.2555539011955261,
0.13751724362373352,
0.11345437169075012,
-0.6056541800498962,
-0.07432060688734055,
-0.5962126851081848,
-0.16083580255508423,
-0.17783942818641663,
0.45018470287323,
-0.6787706017494202,
-0.19756244122982025,
-0.06376712024211884,
-0.15069042146205902,
0.09704354405403137,
-0.0951557457447052,
-0.6504056453704834,
-0.08101091533899307,
0.06448501348495483,
0.5528566241264343,
0.42858800292015076,
-0.40098002552986145,
0.7608816027641296,
0.8357369899749756,
-0.18245217204093933,
-0.037875715643167496,
-0.735396146774292,
0.24483373761177063,
-0.274884968996048,
-0.5907290577888489,
0.48293226957321167,
0.07571322470903397,
0.1785239577293396,
0.09949152171611786,
0.4524606764316559,
-0.38505300879478455,
0.13931964337825775,
0.35739824175834656,
0.3570227324962616,
-0.02790769934654236,
0.36347007751464844,
0.0036793858744204044,
-0.3803311288356781,
0.04364423081278801,
-0.37523654103279114,
0.7377015948295593,
0.31589367985725403,
-0.1222180500626564,
-0.34927237033843994,
0.659218430519104,
0.5887354016304016,
-0.27319061756134033,
1.0530471801757812,
0.6677905917167664,
-0.4345948398113251,
-0.13816921412944794,
-0.1692134290933609,
-0.11483803391456604,
-0.4617285132408142,
0.4401126801967621,
-0.20576956868171692,
-0.8105717301368713,
0.15828685462474823,
-0.17798946797847748,
-0.29959312081336975,
0.17407825589179993,
0.3780938386917114,
-0.3142421841621399,
1.1580901145935059,
0.4473264813423157,
0.051772650331258774,
0.8149672746658325,
-0.13810984790325165,
0.5635043978691101,
-0.4480096399784088,
-0.36614033579826355,
-0.3710748553276062,
-0.14399376511573792,
-1.00651216506958,
-0.666892945766449,
0.5608093738555908,
-0.35036277770996094,
-0.35635295510292053,
0.14542992413043976,
0.012049742974340916,
0.24829533696174622,
0.22454378008842468,
0.2684823274612427,
0.23124808073043823,
0.4224660098552704,
-0.03445378690958023,
-0.010436070151627064,
-0.5810267925262451,
-0.28114110231399536,
1.3198354244232178,
0.2512807250022888,
0.457288920879364,
0.1703549325466156,
0.25481441617012024,
0.19206266105175018,
0.2857343554496765,
-0.42115041613578796,
0.49255019426345825,
-0.26609155535697937,
-0.4735444486141205,
-0.28191179037094116,
-0.6984894871711731,
-1.155073642730713,
-0.032558225095272064,
-0.6059523820877075,
-0.6599497199058533,
0.047211430966854095,
-0.10943584144115448,
-0.3702794909477234,
0.4933180510997772,
-0.4320446848869324,
0.5079732537269592,
-0.10603901743888855,
-0.38689565658569336,
-0.32162055373191833,
-0.20432457327842712,
-0.0017439104849472642,
-0.18577295541763306,
0.6418687701225281,
-0.39677393436431885,
-0.11932234466075897,
0.5475998520851135,
-0.5047490000724792,
0.8561983108520508,
-0.13645540177822113,
0.16090697050094604,
0.1803857684135437,
-0.1786499321460724,
0.9729022979736328,
0.05301114544272423,
-0.3401147723197937,
0.2184651494026184,
-0.18188691139221191,
-0.47405651211738586,
-0.5524066686630249,
0.7700963616371155,
-0.7174097895622253,
-0.11363901942968369,
-0.3046729862689972,
-0.5631070733070374,
-0.44547680020332336,
0.11087070405483246,
0.07810146361589432,
0.8712924718856812,
0.1238330602645874,
0.1403059959411621,
0.3035896122455597,
-0.20008759200572968,
0.6024929881095886,
0.5206437706947327,
-0.40521177649497986,
-0.5363692045211792,
0.9607892632484436,
0.12084323912858963,
-0.09317624568939209,
0.545291006565094,
0.42075443267822266,
-0.5902700424194336,
-0.7552085518836975,
-0.2031431794166565,
0.13593429327011108,
-0.39511123299598694,
-0.41892290115356445,
-0.8792990446090698,
0.0599866546690464,
-0.367401659488678,
-0.15846329927444458,
-0.3740549087524414,
-0.42954760789871216,
-0.11286260932683945,
-0.1160065308213234,
0.5236489772796631,
0.6066040396690369,
0.14755788445472717,
0.5780896544456482,
-0.652161180973053,
-0.2247743308544159,
-0.058289896696805954,
0.5544174313545227,
0.23720867931842804,
-0.1357865184545517,
-0.8799219131469727,
-0.024296127259731293,
-0.25456905364990234,
-0.5506866574287415,
0.6534680724143982,
-0.1604648232460022,
0.16128461062908173,
0.2752862870693207,
0.18535582721233368,
0.8425613641738892,
-0.9477853178977966,
0.55375075340271,
0.42884060740470886,
-0.6179477572441101,
0.4709882438182831,
-0.5994413495063782,
0.02648458629846573,
0.285424143075943,
0.310716837644577,
-0.22979356348514557,
-0.41361159086227417,
-0.40067097544670105,
-0.9191988706588745,
0.2248425930738449,
0.24739769101142883,
0.38688796758651733,
-0.16272932291030884,
0.03275851905345917,
0.1574435979127884,
0.22252157330513,
-0.6321576237678528,
0.18328998982906342,
-0.21616248786449432,
-0.3650625944137573,
-0.31120017170906067,
-0.20554471015930176,
0.31470993161201477,
-0.509961724281311,
0.4367586076259613,
0.017457103356719017,
0.2612474262714386,
-0.06261278688907623,
0.33998551964759827,
-0.038183655589818954,
0.15995587408542633,
0.44937923550605774,
0.9522671103477478,
-0.09760932624340057,
0.0506233386695385,
0.23775985836982727,
-0.39333489537239075,
-0.04683685675263405,
-0.036490630358457565,
-0.353054016828537,
0.35999563336372375,
0.3125869631767273,
0.7129650712013245,
0.21448662877082825,
-0.8207471370697021,
0.587985634803772,
0.2136378437280655,
0.12254123389720917,
-0.8564757704734802,
-0.39097774028778076,
0.014558764174580574,
0.2776082754135132,
0.2058635652065277,
0.07301061600446701,
0.17485322058200836,
-0.3271743655204773,
-0.23149138689041138,
0.14988400042057037,
-0.47959625720977783,
-0.3951903283596039,
0.5978518128395081,
0.4388827681541443,
0.2208351194858551,
0.26973333954811096,
-0.14893603324890137,
-0.6438817977905273,
0.5570030808448792,
0.4668034315109253,
0.8198086023330688,
-0.25832033157348633,
-0.05312025174498558,
0.40397727489471436,
0.043424878269433975,
-0.1023794487118721,
0.41604048013687134,
0.5413419008255005,
-0.8454208374023438,
-0.6770231127738953,
-0.7657381892204285,
-0.13401693105697632,
-0.1367543339729309,
-0.3847775161266327,
0.384196013212204,
-0.42748549580574036,
-0.4912934899330139,
-0.3226839005947113,
0.1473047137260437,
-0.8511199951171875,
0.11276683211326599,
0.04793574661016464,
0.8302630186080933,
-0.9715107679367065,
0.8874742388725281,
0.7694594264030457,
0.061504706740379333,
-0.7869716882705688,
0.1226661428809166,
-0.5319180488586426,
-0.43382376432418823,
0.36876219511032104,
0.13893701136112213,
0.03427721932530403,
-0.13578180968761444,
-0.32935598492622375,
-1.0240181684494019,
1.0410751104354858,
0.06584756076335907,
-0.7776137590408325,
-0.05815870687365532,
0.26016414165496826,
0.21435393393039703,
-0.4842333495616913,
0.035192955285310745,
0.19838128983974457,
0.5755552649497986,
0.01764056272804737,
-0.6494150757789612,
0.3237272799015045,
0.11672189831733704,
0.24699555337429047,
0.40586602687835693,
-0.4376177489757538,
0.9232944250106812,
0.06633581966161728,
-0.31112730503082275,
0.18402138352394104,
0.6657218933105469,
-0.039202410727739334,
0.6438921689987183,
0.6437438130378723,
0.5081933736801147,
0.7249848246574402,
-0.1801147311925888,
1.0729824304580688,
-0.22882728278636932,
0.37332770228385925,
1.0799751281738281,
-0.30147233605384827,
1.0639821290969849,
0.5518243312835693,
-0.19877685606479645,
0.7369585633277893,
0.5166332125663757,
0.21730932593345642,
1.1206105947494507,
-0.1610107272863388,
-0.1382383555173874,
-0.5414404273033142,
-0.3681257665157318,
-0.4574809670448303,
0.560260534286499,
0.1919626146554947,
-0.031592488288879395,
-0.028454462066292763,
0.25003331899642944,
0.08412907272577286,
0.040301982313394547,
-0.41164925694465637,
0.677599310874939,
-0.2420230358839035,
-0.4618246257305145,
0.0970274955034256,
0.1348603367805481,
0.43050357699394226,
-0.30886110663414,
0.18367668986320496,
0.10032149404287338,
0.03608228638768196,
0.03493234142661095,
-1.0205367803573608,
0.5750938057899475,
-0.20932798087596893,
-0.0877763107419014,
-0.38173002004623413,
0.3140697181224823,
-0.4479134976863861,
-0.8515163064002991,
0.32148584723472595,
0.3153243660926819,
-0.1694132685661316,
-0.08329194039106369,
-0.3396720886230469,
0.033774252980947495,
-0.14416669309139252,
0.021294018253684044,
0.27168387174606323,
0.8867395520210266,
0.04847918450832367,
0.5620282888412476,
0.7633470296859741,
0.31276363134384155,
-0.19547492265701294,
-0.015858042985200882,
1.0217512845993042,
-0.9689019918441772,
-1.0824025869369507,
-0.7890596389770508,
0.5545505285263062,
-0.2524011731147766,
-0.1326560527086258,
0.32771292328834534,
0.5424007177352905,
0.3256741166114807,
0.07715413719415665,
0.8219204545021057,
0.35997626185417175,
0.6394049525260925,
-1.0208815336227417,
0.1749260276556015,
-0.5785535573959351,
0.3440113067626953,
-0.2000042051076889,
-0.46270695328712463,
0.06196480244398117,
0.25204673409461975,
-0.7153664827346802,
-0.24032896757125854,
0.7422679662704468,
0.42002877593040466,
-0.35897549986839294,
0.41297468543052673,
0.23838666081428528,
0.1324526071548462,
0.2590658366680145,
0.7284382581710815,
1.0686794519424438,
-0.1233387291431427,
0.41989320516586304,
-0.4344991445541382,
0.07456407696008682,
-0.41642633080482483,
-0.8927127718925476,
-0.9924108982086182,
-0.7217584848403931,
-0.07556131482124329,
-0.1572432518005371,
0.06273087859153748,
0.6626855134963989,
0.9117875695228577,
-0.8055915236473083,
-0.11337122321128845,
-0.09919549524784088,
0.19638460874557495,
0.23889364302158356,
-0.2860551178455353,
0.4990094006061554,
-0.009898660704493523,
-0.6641421914100647,
0.2236795723438263,
0.22550098598003387,
0.3620259463787079,
-0.1681031584739685,
0.04440651834011078,
0.1446344256401062,
0.0363038145005703,
0.6392209529876709,
-0.4820294678211212,
-0.2421349585056305,
-0.27331069111824036,
-0.31012073159217834,
0.07756847888231277,
-0.19535909593105316,
1.001072883605957,
-0.7377906441688538,
0.007894609123468399,
0.4695833921432495,
0.5122346878051758,
0.6949402093887329,
0.0778416320681572,
0.9226730465888977,
-0.47891759872436523,
0.4820829927921295,
0.2633185386657715,
0.6210253238677979,
0.3554873466491699,
-0.29586777091026306,
0.36377060413360596,
0.09233910590410233,
-0.3337787985801697,
-0.5754629373550415,
0.22626075148582458,
-0.9068777561187744,
-0.39444753527641296,
1.0982472896575928,
-0.06085709482431412,
-0.23182742297649384,
-0.4396743178367615,
0.23701848089694977,
-0.028028471395373344,
-0.6963789463043213,
0.654689371585846,
0.28772565722465515,
0.26291197538375854,
0.011582104489207268,
-0.9804821014404297,
0.0620405487716198,
0.09502049535512924,
-0.7926747798919678,
-0.020221790298819542,
0.3658803701400757,
0.11721436679363251,
-0.1845444142818451,
0.3361043632030487,
0.18916572630405426,
-0.10898507386445999,
-0.3318968415260315,
-0.5813496112823486,
0.023137370124459267,
-0.5005010366439819,
0.17654050886631012,
0.24933312833309174,
-0.36087194085121155,
0.015232382342219353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06219v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06219v2
|
SKVQ: Sliding-window Key and Value Cache Quantization for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-10T03:06:24 | 2024-05-13T14:39:11 |
Haojie Duanmu, Zhihang Yuan, Xiuhong Li, Jiangfei Duan, Xingcheng Zhang, Dahua Lin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) can now handle longer sequences of tokens,
enabling complex tasks like book understanding and generating lengthy novels.
However, the key-value (KV) cache required for LLMs consumes substantial memory
as context length increasing, becoming the bottleneck for deployment. In this
paper, we present a strategy called SKVQ, which stands for sliding-window KV
cache quantization, to address the issue of extremely low bitwidth KV cache
quantization. To achieve this, SKVQ rearranges the channels of the KV cache in
order to improve the similarity of channels in quantization groups, and applies
clipped dynamic quantization at the group level. Additionally, SKVQ ensures
that the most recent window tokens in the KV cache are preserved with high
precision. This helps maintain the accuracy of a small but important portion of
the KV cache.SKVQ achieves high compression ratios while maintaining accuracy.
Our evaluation on LLMs demonstrates that SKVQ surpasses previous quantization
approaches, allowing for quantization of the KV cache to 2-bit keys and 1.5-bit
values with minimal loss of accuracy. With SKVQ, it is possible to process
context lengths of up to 1M on an 80GB memory GPU for a 7b model and up to 7
times faster decoding.
|
[
-0.0678877979516983,
-0.5196523070335388,
0.5505751967430115,
0.24043497443199158,
-0.6339596509933472,
0.39441588521003723,
-0.20430107414722443,
0.012026937678456306,
-0.05055989697575569,
0.436189740896225,
-0.24766303598880768,
-0.6339425444602966,
-0.3105451166629791,
-0.505873441696167,
-0.3566749095916748,
0.5704634785652161,
0.14800317585468292,
0.013606482185423374,
-0.33600643277168274,
-0.2799837291240692,
-0.38281941413879395,
-0.48448166251182556,
-0.36245569586753845,
-0.05964440479874611,
0.3642266094684601,
0.15569092333316803,
0.8137263059616089,
0.8976767063140869,
0.1702868491411209,
0.17316344380378723,
-0.4093194305896759,
-0.27040982246398926,
-0.5524084568023682,
0.4622270464897156,
0.09892062097787857,
-0.6703784465789795,
-0.4803750514984131,
-0.3411218523979187,
0.7987516522407532,
0.12353671342134476,
-0.30952978134155273,
0.18577329814434052,
-0.4935990273952484,
0.943572998046875,
-0.944783091545105,
0.08865391463041306,
-0.6479118466377258,
-0.01202465407550335,
-0.27930888533592224,
-0.015587880276143551,
-0.39415228366851807,
-0.43820175528526306,
0.06993889808654785,
-0.4419911205768585,
-0.003403212409466505,
-0.2677624523639679,
0.7758536338806152,
0.22403907775878906,
-0.7242783308029175,
0.17033551633358002,
-0.6883994936943054,
0.7978845238685608,
-1.0543904304504395,
0.5202820897102356,
0.13384529948234558,
0.19164596498012543,
-0.07272422313690186,
-0.6241416931152344,
-0.519524335861206,
-0.09683259576559067,
0.4812401533126831,
0.03981298580765724,
0.15814344584941864,
0.11049870401620865,
0.1316211223602295,
0.37391796708106995,
-0.620552122592926,
-0.024530118331313133,
-0.36182117462158203,
-0.2969934642314911,
0.4471558928489685,
0.4525803029537201,
0.01911034621298313,
-0.026095829904079437,
-0.14615356922149658,
-0.3638855516910553,
-0.934042751789093,
0.2132522016763687,
0.21740707755088806,
0.17866939306259155,
0.21667367219924927,
0.3560103476047516,
-0.5904437303543091,
0.5481749176979065,
-0.07088200747966766,
-0.5075233578681946,
0.2501165270805359,
-0.3595425486564636,
-0.24488990008831024,
-0.025661345571279526,
0.5957592129707336,
0.36049485206604004,
-0.21145226061344147,
-0.08014937490224838,
-0.2650872468948364,
0.12170463800430298,
0.3044629991054535,
-0.9061601161956787,
-0.23952871561050415,
0.1731969267129898,
-0.437460333108902,
-0.44630616903305054,
-0.4035671353340149,
-0.7047269344329834,
-0.010569896548986435,
-0.1073775365948677,
0.6806132197380066,
-0.3492499887943268,
-0.17179551720619202,
-0.05680061876773834,
-0.08746291697025299,
0.3721539080142975,
0.4285579323768616,
-0.77382493019104,
0.14204123616218567,
0.666129469871521,
0.9458445310592651,
-0.2773708701133728,
0.2999694049358368,
-0.6876503825187683,
0.26256439089775085,
-0.26690801978111267,
0.23922929167747498,
-0.7405521869659424,
-0.501139760017395,
0.009236685931682587,
-0.20094142854213715,
0.43257972598075867,
-0.2177181839942932,
0.09771986305713654,
-0.9486508369445801,
-0.16709348559379578,
-0.32052573561668396,
-0.26969802379608154,
0.012921539135277271,
0.26195386052131653,
-0.6518554091453552,
1.3446853160858154,
0.20690485835075378,
-0.44698861241340637,
0.2739955186843872,
-0.08837627619504929,
-0.3957958519458771,
0.2488606572151184,
-0.026575803756713867,
-0.2765362560749054,
0.49978914856910706,
0.20790499448776245,
0.4387950301170349,
-0.3430638313293457,
0.08783864229917526,
-0.1306583136320114,
-0.48442843556404114,
0.07721424102783203,
-0.6176626086235046,
0.29530757665634155,
0.18517076969146729,
-0.24241289496421814,
-0.08367603272199631,
-0.7373068928718567,
0.456009179353714,
-0.006576123647391796,
-0.5382859706878662,
-0.7479029297828674,
0.04924800619482994,
-0.09160882234573364,
0.34238818287849426,
0.28745585680007935,
-0.20305778086185455,
0.7052777409553528,
-0.472533255815506,
0.7660117149353027,
0.8377534747123718,
-0.1486104130744934,
0.6494771838188171,
0.21842193603515625,
0.6598244905471802,
0.1991998702287674,
0.3980291485786438,
-0.30039623379707336,
-0.2867128551006317,
-0.7003836631774902,
-0.28294625878334045,
0.5953073501586914,
0.3679327070713043,
-1.0936530828475952,
0.016745081171393394,
-0.5634700655937195,
-0.39245933294296265,
-0.5610533952713013,
-0.17500418424606323,
0.450740784406662,
0.010863169096410275,
0.01082396600395441,
-0.46769478917121887,
0.1746768206357956,
-0.6968618035316467,
0.012097099795937538,
-0.31270086765289307,
0.06124674901366234,
0.2964203953742981,
0.39374592900276184,
-0.12285761535167694,
0.9268151521682739,
-0.6164752244949341,
0.2013889104127884,
0.3186873197555542,
0.28286468982696533,
0.033580273389816284,
0.33005616068840027,
0.12302698194980621,
-0.8472772240638733,
-0.6718432307243347,
0.04025360569357872,
0.04121255874633789,
-0.09935833513736725,
0.10578568279743195,
-0.16200441122055054,
0.5636542439460754,
0.4503050446510315,
-0.6043275594711304,
0.5529830455780029,
0.751850962638855,
-0.06108584627509117,
0.6043092012405396,
-0.18052342534065247,
0.08828762173652649,
-1.1032999753952026,
-0.11569707095623016,
-0.31800907850265503,
-0.5536749958992004,
-0.3553523123264313,
0.12790872156620026,
0.412432998418808,
0.15074953436851501,
-0.6191337704658508,
0.46073025465011597,
-0.3726292848587036,
0.10638173669576645,
-0.31823307275772095,
0.1797517091035843,
-0.04392368718981743,
0.38543516397476196,
-0.0882776528596878,
0.8717368841171265,
0.31230470538139343,
-0.5648942589759827,
0.41498538851737976,
-0.09354106336832047,
-0.36092445254325867,
0.5321468114852905,
-0.3340289294719696,
0.2539078891277313,
-0.03864691033959389,
0.4151630997657776,
-0.9209428429603577,
0.2171502709388733,
-0.15174448490142822,
-0.40997231006622314,
0.2435278594493866,
-0.5511202812194824,
-0.7052355408668518,
-0.15918025374412537,
-0.48624226450920105,
0.7100702524185181,
0.753358006477356,
-0.40704572200775146,
0.5575577020645142,
0.3568223714828491,
-0.1426253467798233,
-0.8068726062774658,
-0.46488285064697266,
-0.06208371743559837,
-0.2754436731338501,
-0.5972751379013062,
0.3363260328769684,
-0.043364815413951874,
0.027993205934762955,
-0.07262229174375534,
-0.584618091583252,
-0.15398503839969635,
-0.18306559324264526,
0.30573949217796326,
0.17764785885810852,
-0.38331517577171326,
0.4925077259540558,
0.3166239261627197,
-0.1682446449995041,
-0.11620113998651505,
-0.5563187599182129,
0.7300084829330444,
-0.2823876738548279,
-0.005302201025187969,
0.11907023936510086,
0.1599111706018448,
1.034625768661499,
-0.2167215347290039,
0.9349635243415833,
0.7024862170219421,
-0.18421754240989685,
-0.22782912850379944,
-0.6182196736335754,
0.013988297432661057,
-0.5114591717720032,
0.30087465047836304,
-0.42586731910705566,
-1.2702006101608276,
0.6274340748786926,
-0.3276360034942627,
-0.14468714594841003,
0.20782949030399323,
0.7949766516685486,
0.04975859820842743,
1.151900053024292,
0.5500513911247253,
-0.44089916348457336,
0.4366888701915741,
-0.2847743630409241,
0.39299145340919495,
-0.9081317186355591,
-0.10003108531236649,
-0.32337236404418945,
-0.1498415321111679,
-0.46486321091651917,
-0.9706392884254456,
0.50206458568573,
0.2370813488960266,
-0.14900857210159302,
0.20283673703670502,
-0.43534377217292786,
0.5481942892074585,
0.4014125466346741,
-0.027451949194073677,
0.34420618414878845,
-0.2191767394542694,
-0.5420673489570618,
-0.1064922958612442,
-0.5977364778518677,
-0.29061874747276306,
0.9269223213195801,
0.24068500101566315,
1.1219013929367065,
0.039315469563007355,
0.31525349617004395,
0.128647118806839,
-0.007700727321207523,
-0.806538462638855,
0.5689312219619751,
0.08364247530698776,
-0.5161823034286499,
-0.5384129285812378,
-0.5250454545021057,
-0.5190237760543823,
0.4900380074977875,
0.034091606736183167,
-0.7756316661834717,
0.020174169912934303,
0.1950899064540863,
-0.44700586795806885,
0.13815675675868988,
-0.3269858658313751,
0.6787745952606201,
-0.16415658593177795,
-0.3303813934326172,
-0.36618971824645996,
-0.8112263679504395,
0.34942808747291565,
-0.1349458247423172,
-0.09777896106243134,
-0.12452828884124756,
-0.2625671625137329,
0.5155667662620544,
-0.48019835352897644,
0.5140654444694519,
-0.016605323180556297,
-0.2489645928144455,
-0.009614735841751099,
0.2536074221134186,
0.8844497799873352,
0.28731653094291687,
0.1706055849790573,
-0.07958761602640152,
0.45772841572761536,
-0.4103998839855194,
-0.7341055870056152,
0.9280110597610474,
-0.5736643075942993,
-0.46962878108024597,
-0.4629923403263092,
-0.41202789545059204,
-0.18102692067623138,
-0.07425951957702637,
0.0828419178724289,
0.3898735046386719,
-0.05910026282072067,
0.49939867854118347,
1.0176210403442383,
-0.26763227581977844,
0.5405567288398743,
0.7740527987480164,
-0.0913916602730751,
-0.4798007607460022,
0.9597241878509521,
0.1083296462893486,
0.7300348281860352,
0.6021227836608887,
0.10114479064941406,
-0.22216129302978516,
-0.549698531627655,
-0.3600258231163025,
0.09024404734373093,
-0.7856549024581909,
-0.5058509111404419,
-0.6050920486450195,
-0.32053473591804504,
-0.36915311217308044,
-0.1565156728029251,
-0.8649063110351562,
-0.5798315405845642,
-0.1306913048028946,
0.22007350623607635,
0.6153573989868164,
0.15243573486804962,
0.21060709655284882,
0.640799880027771,
-1.010140299797058,
0.1437561810016632,
0.39553460478782654,
0.3662228286266327,
0.2839144468307495,
-0.44303035736083984,
-0.7714988589286804,
-0.000030259290724643506,
-0.29544955492019653,
-0.5429597496986389,
0.798896074295044,
-0.13039086759090424,
0.1771908700466156,
0.3582541346549988,
0.19960646331310272,
0.9560334086418152,
-0.5915659666061401,
1.112442135810852,
0.051769912242889404,
-1.2300589084625244,
0.2699849009513855,
-0.2350759208202362,
0.7467136383056641,
0.7349656224250793,
0.21592381596565247,
-0.8820755481719971,
-0.3191477954387665,
-0.4348853528499603,
-1.3262288570404053,
0.5555644035339355,
0.1754012256860733,
0.21482206881046295,
0.1434677243232727,
0.5250842571258545,
-0.12214365601539612,
0.48168638348579407,
-0.6513665318489075,
-0.16618715226650238,
0.02399194985628128,
-0.13798418641090393,
0.2115560919046402,
-0.20411813259124756,
0.1267261952161789,
-0.2512708008289337,
0.669037401676178,
-0.27565234899520874,
0.4069675803184509,
-0.15872715413570404,
-0.2324206382036209,
-0.1994454562664032,
0.3007333278656006,
0.5872067809104919,
0.7080114483833313,
-0.08832303434610367,
0.09289087355136871,
0.32361847162246704,
-0.7153220772743225,
0.23097696900367737,
-0.5602625012397766,
-0.047967493534088135,
-0.08651979267597198,
-0.21106693148612976,
0.865671694278717,
0.20151901245117188,
-0.7925965189933777,
0.7405587434768677,
-0.26107922196388245,
-0.049349263310432434,
-0.11789055913686752,
0.054244108498096466,
0.2328420877456665,
0.5191250443458557,
0.443608820438385,
-0.39127805829048157,
-0.12587204575538635,
-0.4456213712692261,
-0.09932015836238861,
0.6338624954223633,
-0.20560450851917267,
-0.2720869481563568,
0.48204702138900757,
0.13375087082386017,
-0.20864416658878326,
0.8786645531654358,
0.06008860468864441,
-0.8081458806991577,
0.44079524278640747,
0.4023895859718323,
0.7561419606208801,
-0.22600866854190826,
0.23543748259544373,
0.003642329480499029,
0.25777608156204224,
-0.42354723811149597,
0.23182135820388794,
-0.24834054708480835,
-0.4707152545452118,
-0.7454670667648315,
-0.73349529504776,
-0.36372095346450806,
0.3822701573371887,
-0.8007245659828186,
0.18708834052085876,
-0.158430278301239,
-0.10312087088823318,
-0.44122782349586487,
0.058706436306238174,
-0.4912826716899872,
0.24662961065769196,
0.0728766992688179,
0.9135123491287231,
-0.7910833358764648,
1.5007025003433228,
0.07727666944265366,
0.09085574001073837,
-0.5641074776649475,
0.12376845628023148,
-0.07779188454151154,
-0.6182148456573486,
0.6677687168121338,
-0.059568848460912704,
0.09325610101222992,
-0.011522386223077774,
-0.6851258277893066,
-1.1088628768920898,
1.3127821683883667,
0.08974464237689972,
-0.8878205418586731,
-0.15141050517559052,
0.08482211828231812,
0.563862681388855,
-0.11298514157533646,
-0.003826851025223732,
0.6273828148841858,
0.33281436562538147,
0.42873644828796387,
-0.8567591309547424,
0.09463480114936829,
-0.13278436660766602,
0.4966021180152893,
0.6856768727302551,
-0.9050504565238953,
0.6359739899635315,
0.16176974773406982,
-0.10490305721759796,
0.24598190188407898,
0.6465604901313782,
0.2583915591239929,
0.0012909852666780353,
0.3750624358654022,
0.715741753578186,
0.5687847137451172,
-0.07271812856197357,
0.6878243684768677,
-0.24286890029907227,
0.288280189037323,
0.7524471282958984,
-0.24738354980945587,
1.108824372291565,
0.6462274193763733,
-0.1399199515581131,
0.23607902228832245,
0.518471360206604,
0.2704487442970276,
0.8774696588516235,
0.4289948046207428,
-0.53384929895401,
-0.27665889263153076,
0.48916634917259216,
-0.3361843526363373,
0.07288702577352524,
0.5873338580131531,
-0.13147974014282227,
0.1843363642692566,
0.19744376838207245,
0.03187475726008415,
-0.6141653060913086,
-0.3064979910850525,
0.6137072443962097,
0.16098834574222565,
-0.4863332211971283,
0.6113379597663879,
0.2254733145236969,
0.6417416930198669,
-0.7099247574806213,
0.1326633095741272,
-0.1444271206855774,
0.17859314382076263,
0.2545546591281891,
-0.4800209105014801,
-0.07737613469362259,
-0.2960694134235382,
-0.3886340856552124,
-0.21898995339870453,
0.4769591689109802,
-0.5564835667610168,
-0.26363980770111084,
-0.09563329070806503,
0.12319611012935638,
-0.08861357718706131,
-0.2564510107040405,
-0.3867377042770386,
0.4728720784187317,
-0.16173620522022247,
-0.34226664900779724,
0.7542309761047363,
0.6248128414154053,
-0.3484521806240082,
0.7732810974121094,
0.5589733123779297,
0.12102403491735458,
0.39651426672935486,
-0.15737222135066986,
1.1225680112838745,
-0.9401310086250305,
-0.5766409635543823,
-0.8469147086143494,
0.5434252023696899,
0.2083456665277481,
-0.26710277795791626,
0.7816751003265381,
0.5356064438819885,
0.5926632881164551,
-0.09618109464645386,
0.623940110206604,
0.16577357053756714,
-0.11059525609016418,
-0.6330128312110901,
0.5856337547302246,
-0.5763614773750305,
0.24754975736141205,
-0.32552868127822876,
-1.0057071447372437,
-0.27119120955467224,
0.6374449133872986,
-0.07776675373315811,
-0.2750301957130432,
0.6468906402587891,
0.818149983882904,
0.1598452925682068,
-0.29918330907821655,
0.4555104672908783,
0.32644280791282654,
0.4526858329772949,
0.6677325367927551,
0.7493585348129272,
-0.5018177628517151,
0.7400875687599182,
-0.003293039044365287,
-0.04133988916873932,
-0.4688712954521179,
-1.117016077041626,
-0.7524740695953369,
-0.730138897895813,
-0.45699355006217957,
-0.4716833233833313,
0.23527562618255615,
0.662056565284729,
0.9877446889877319,
-0.4546343982219696,
-0.03333050757646561,
0.12202531844377518,
0.05852416157722473,
-0.21322490274906158,
-0.3055466413497925,
0.32851848006248474,
-0.050990115851163864,
-0.5007468461990356,
0.35975098609924316,
0.6627128720283508,
0.052708256989717484,
-0.6114222407341003,
-0.21348291635513306,
0.15338583290576935,
0.3664221167564392,
0.7425899505615234,
0.08544199913740158,
-0.7880219221115112,
-0.22287298738956451,
0.047264233231544495,
-0.24787938594818115,
0.20529890060424805,
0.9483229517936707,
-1.1061676740646362,
0.6076177954673767,
0.7752002477645874,
0.5166783332824707,
1.1227936744689941,
-0.11782845854759216,
0.7345074415206909,
-0.8564146161079407,
0.06609290838241577,
0.397417277097702,
-0.18025130033493042,
-0.024789026007056236,
-0.4085316061973572,
0.17600731551647186,
0.1340084820985794,
-0.6893426775932312,
-1.0599459409713745,
-0.09389396756887436,
-1.250646948814392,
-0.28208813071250916,
1.1971489191055298,
-0.06670460104942322,
-0.45004764199256897,
0.08038341999053955,
-0.0996004119515419,
0.034849703311920166,
-0.6589275598526001,
0.7566779851913452,
0.9066396355628967,
0.4531480669975281,
-0.42973601818084717,
-0.6227630972862244,
0.4887910485267639,
0.054257869720458984,
-0.33285433053970337,
0.12153595685958862,
0.2718585133552551,
0.28227314352989197,
-0.042654700577259064,
0.6226317286491394,
-0.28517037630081177,
0.2133842557668686,
-0.11881343275308609,
-0.059589989483356476,
0.2112961858510971,
-0.2554410398006439,
-0.4523976147174835,
0.06945005804300308,
-0.16172674298286438,
-0.08421732485294342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06211v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06211v3
|
A Survey on RAG Meeting LLMs: Towards Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models
| 2024-05-10T02:48:45 | 2024-06-17T08:56:38 |
Wenqi Fan, Yujuan Ding, Liangbo Ning, Shijie Wang, Hengyun Li, Dawei Yin, Tat-Seng Chua, Qing Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
As one of the most advanced techniques in AI, Retrieval-Augmented Generation
(RAG) can offer reliable and up-to-date external knowledge, providing huge
convenience for numerous tasks. Particularly in the era of AI-Generated Content
(AIGC), the powerful capacity of retrieval in providing additional knowledge
enables RAG to assist existing generative AI in producing high-quality outputs.
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated revolutionary
abilities in language understanding and generation, while still facing inherent
limitations, such as hallucinations and out-of-date internal knowledge. Given
the powerful abilities of RAG in providing the latest and helpful auxiliary
information, Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models (RA-LLMs) have emerged
to harness external and authoritative knowledge bases, rather than solely
relying on the model's internal knowledge, to augment the generation quality of
LLMs. In this survey, we comprehensively review existing research studies in
RA-LLMs, covering three primary technical perspectives: architectures, training
strategies, and applications. As the preliminary knowledge, we briefly
introduce the foundations and recent advances of LLMs. Then, to illustrate the
practical significance of RAG for LLMs, we systematically review mainstream
relevant work by their architectures, training strategies, and application
areas, detailing specifically the challenges of each and the corresponding
capabilities of RA-LLMs. Finally, to deliver deeper insights, we discuss
current limitations and several promising directions for future research.
Updated information about this survey can be found at
https://advanced-recommender-systems.github.io/RAG-Meets-LLMs/
|
[
-0.5744622349739075,
-0.5170934796333313,
0.6146132946014404,
-0.1827501356601715,
0.02039535716176033,
0.276883065700531,
-0.4194120466709137,
-0.6762576699256897,
0.31774720549583435,
0.6539050340652466,
-0.3252919614315033,
-0.3613670766353607,
-0.7319768667221069,
0.17186109721660614,
-0.5208833813667297,
0.8784093856811523,
-0.06468036025762558,
0.1334635466337204,
-0.3638783395290375,
-0.16733501851558685,
-0.465263307094574,
-0.5111324787139893,
-0.6521303653717041,
-0.4959980547428131,
0.42875030636787415,
0.3314347267150879,
0.4166127145290375,
0.31244704127311707,
0.657465934753418,
0.29847294092178345,
-0.3587070107460022,
0.5897532105445862,
-0.5808462500572205,
0.43907877802848816,
-0.08908158540725708,
-0.49081456661224365,
-0.524936854839325,
0.11809335649013519,
0.8671473860740662,
0.665147602558136,
-0.17517580091953278,
0.2502364218235016,
0.1712367981672287,
0.8257737159729004,
-0.6424723863601685,
-0.020992811769247055,
-0.9679930806159973,
-0.04307892918586731,
-0.22833704948425293,
-0.16395673155784607,
-0.5985791683197021,
-0.12330600619316101,
-0.018389137461781502,
-0.2765018343925476,
0.13175824284553528,
0.3582163155078888,
0.6331061720848083,
0.20775017142295837,
-0.4685078561306,
-0.5759668946266174,
-0.9449099898338318,
0.8667625784873962,
-0.5546598434448242,
0.4448520839214325,
0.6479570865631104,
0.4128900468349457,
-0.44376155734062195,
-0.6790947318077087,
-0.4765833914279938,
-0.5387135744094849,
-0.042856454849243164,
0.05853762477636337,
-0.05926354601979256,
-0.09649065881967545,
0.18777664005756378,
0.7353014349937439,
-0.42307248711586,
0.17059922218322754,
-0.14593090116977692,
0.16161346435546875,
0.5832846164703369,
0.28648313879966736,
0.1653807908296585,
-0.2567611336708069,
-0.2906113564968109,
0.11864158511161804,
-0.962942361831665,
-0.2976357936859131,
0.11037297546863556,
0.19769862294197083,
-0.06221136823296547,
0.766342043876648,
-0.08365561068058014,
0.6931924223899841,
0.0124497190117836,
-0.14341691136360168,
0.05972651019692421,
-0.41712144017219543,
0.05893556773662567,
-0.42256227135658264,
0.6539562940597534,
0.11123177409172058,
0.09991905093193054,
-0.22495518624782562,
-0.44040626287460327,
-0.4101141393184662,
0.24658264219760895,
-0.5777219533920288,
0.23048250377178192,
-0.13096919655799866,
-0.48190614581108093,
-0.1454276740550995,
-0.04842586815357208,
-0.6251108050346375,
-0.5687307715415955,
-0.45163825154304504,
0.25775033235549927,
-0.23090918362140656,
-0.3825485408306122,
-0.13068293035030365,
0.06379537284374237,
0.5080531239509583,
0.42688268423080444,
-0.6636757254600525,
0.17540176212787628,
0.8333182334899902,
0.6725414395332336,
-0.38570156693458557,
-0.07754267752170563,
-0.5163099765777588,
0.1988060474395752,
-0.4440143406391144,
0.7719407081604004,
-0.5321691632270813,
-0.5698474645614624,
0.13633662462234497,
-0.2946336269378662,
0.11602747440338135,
-0.7924683690071106,
0.5078690648078918,
-0.841362476348877,
0.18636304140090942,
-0.18681927025318146,
-0.5087385773658752,
-0.07646145671606064,
0.691840410232544,
-0.5018004179000854,
0.987457811832428,
-0.07080037146806717,
-0.6674885749816895,
0.18562576174736023,
-0.27892133593559265,
-0.1704506129026413,
0.19126738607883453,
-0.3715713918209076,
-0.22540093958377838,
0.3061507046222687,
0.09471940994262695,
0.4468301236629486,
-0.7908966541290283,
0.287016361951828,
-0.11579406261444092,
-0.23528701066970825,
0.365256667137146,
-0.4162226617336273,
0.3515726923942566,
0.40640774369239807,
-0.07149507105350494,
0.1377793550491333,
-0.7132589817047119,
-0.08408059924840927,
0.1602686047554016,
-0.43457967042922974,
-0.39084669947624207,
0.02511044591665268,
-0.05594533309340477,
0.09679646790027618,
0.4726768732070923,
-0.27631261944770813,
0.26684820652008057,
-0.4036696255207062,
0.15389588475227356,
0.6633973717689514,
-0.015528135932981968,
0.5110864043235779,
-0.4985976219177246,
0.6777157783508301,
-0.2815974950790405,
-0.052246320992708206,
-0.2707625925540924,
-0.3095383644104004,
-0.7798165678977966,
-0.19349801540374756,
0.287266343832016,
0.2965756356716156,
-0.9069651961326599,
0.19137665629386902,
-0.1583367884159088,
-0.5047807097434998,
-0.4725700318813324,
0.15696465969085693,
0.39336633682250977,
0.1490810662508011,
0.17699821293354034,
-0.08001407980918884,
-0.6104605197906494,
-0.6351367831230164,
-0.1431249976158142,
-0.14449191093444824,
0.12476754933595657,
0.7183534502983093,
0.274944007396698,
-0.44607606530189514,
0.7290744781494141,
-0.3078639805316925,
-0.40914028882980347,
-0.540104866027832,
0.0129646435379982,
0.32441985607147217,
0.09870835393667221,
0.40307918190956116,
-0.7441170811653137,
-0.610908031463623,
0.18688511848449707,
-0.6489850282669067,
0.06585509330034256,
0.3596671223640442,
0.1640361100435257,
0.4456428289413452,
0.5598387122154236,
-0.6355154514312744,
0.3365018963813782,
0.7800775170326233,
-0.0006677236524410546,
0.6732117533683777,
-0.28388574719429016,
0.2183266580104828,
-1.3354312181472778,
0.1985114961862564,
-0.22231972217559814,
-0.24122676253318787,
-0.5352551341056824,
0.28091704845428467,
-0.21998636424541473,
0.012285402044653893,
-0.06781388819217682,
0.9777616262435913,
-0.7550017833709717,
-0.3624264597892761,
-0.7488890886306763,
0.23211166262626648,
-0.15438486635684967,
0.14675045013427734,
-0.11324044317007065,
1.0817426443099976,
0.31808698177337646,
-0.5993042588233948,
0.19843734800815582,
0.324175626039505,
-0.3966465890407562,
0.37608203291893005,
-0.44794729351997375,
0.27333804965019226,
-0.13658660650253296,
0.3813383877277374,
-0.9167096018791199,
-0.41596537828445435,
0.12702174484729767,
-0.6492993235588074,
0.5669952034950256,
-0.23253577947616577,
-0.5056998133659363,
-0.21039113402366638,
-0.30428996682167053,
0.5679212212562561,
0.6732816696166992,
-0.6003084778785706,
0.8060497641563416,
0.6914123892784119,
-0.22355104982852936,
-0.7880212068557739,
-0.29529809951782227,
0.2580258846282959,
-0.13988932967185974,
-0.42513400316238403,
0.20877644419670105,
-0.0710989311337471,
-0.5984591245651245,
-0.06925815343856812,
0.04302907735109329,
0.22806201875209808,
-0.200532928109169,
0.19352252781391144,
0.24333427846431732,
-0.0725870206952095,
0.05094613879919052,
-0.4459453225135803,
-0.09696389734745026,
-0.10385004431009293,
-0.09577856957912445,
0.7602221965789795,
-0.07940185070037842,
-0.4532147943973541,
-0.09576209634542465,
0.23758602142333984,
0.4484623968601227,
-0.42022812366485596,
0.7381811738014221,
0.7127654552459717,
-0.28926023840904236,
-0.2906496226787567,
-1.008549690246582,
-0.0247542355209589,
-0.46140989661216736,
0.365899920463562,
-0.24441084265708923,
-1.1795337200164795,
0.4596889913082123,
-0.2784264385700226,
0.2058926671743393,
0.4559912085533142,
0.7786844372749329,
-0.08234253525733948,
0.9246566295623779,
0.7022111415863037,
-0.16049592196941376,
0.5250945687294006,
-0.2662264108657837,
0.14439710974693298,
-1.159754991531372,
-0.3252776265144348,
-0.8085013628005981,
-0.11433318257331848,
-0.6744726896286011,
-0.6415128707885742,
0.6480538845062256,
0.10857860743999481,
-0.035207733511924744,
0.01198613177984953,
-0.31422168016433716,
0.24670229852199554,
0.4178957939147949,
-0.13425901532173157,
0.4621979296207428,
0.06901977211236954,
0.07518468052148819,
0.03010041080415249,
-0.6708765625953674,
-0.48535776138305664,
1.127606749534607,
0.310759574174881,
0.909972071647644,
0.12710560858249664,
0.6270881295204163,
0.18936499953269958,
0.4139898717403412,
-0.8235381245613098,
0.760675311088562,
-0.3251769244670868,
-0.631047248840332,
-0.15333667397499084,
-0.6452041864395142,
-1.034035086631775,
0.03844703733921051,
-0.363040953874588,
-0.3753318190574646,
-0.09045270830392838,
0.11067947745323181,
0.1913396567106247,
0.4576992392539978,
-0.23117871582508087,
0.18849851191043854,
-0.27908581495285034,
-0.26530906558036804,
-0.4712793529033661,
-0.38024619221687317,
0.4651099741458893,
-0.07791170477867126,
0.4222351610660553,
-0.053480781614780426,
-0.08097698539495468,
0.615369975566864,
-0.02963576838374138,
0.5260401368141174,
-0.03661039471626282,
-0.2768152356147766,
0.42428842186927795,
0.03836657479405403,
0.8226842284202576,
-0.1320391595363617,
-0.19574622809886932,
0.024858536198735237,
-0.37052884697914124,
-0.0067472937516868114,
-0.3568987548351288,
0.8586002588272095,
-0.7082010507583618,
-0.79380202293396,
-0.45778995752334595,
-0.6976991295814514,
-0.45412003993988037,
0.15116053819656372,
0.004965112078934908,
0.4198940098285675,
-0.07811020314693451,
0.3122994303703308,
0.6908659338951111,
-0.4579204022884369,
0.19641797244548798,
0.5238187909126282,
-0.6267671585083008,
-0.6676095724105835,
1.0034915208816528,
-0.04888622462749481,
0.29822519421577454,
0.45515257120132446,
0.055426061153411865,
-0.19253575801849365,
-0.9989442825317383,
-0.1866319328546524,
0.5179498791694641,
-0.5087261199951172,
-0.3239116966724396,
-0.5949636697769165,
-0.5093658566474915,
-0.46804529428482056,
0.13484527170658112,
-0.3107028007507324,
-0.38972628116607666,
-0.2204105406999588,
0.13827545940876007,
0.4324280321598053,
1.2015527486801147,
-0.06499923765659332,
0.05986255034804344,
-0.8548075556755066,
0.3572028577327728,
0.08149196952581406,
0.43168580532073975,
0.1548335701227188,
-0.653670608997345,
-0.5103321671485901,
-0.08317485451698303,
-0.1992560625076294,
-0.43662524223327637,
0.30991554260253906,
0.02110983431339264,
0.6571955680847168,
0.12675757706165314,
-0.02986018918454647,
0.614371120929718,
-0.6338241100311279,
0.7698445320129395,
0.04615642502903938,
-0.36558204889297485,
0.3856888711452484,
-0.4768921434879303,
0.0762619599699974,
0.493141770362854,
0.45979341864585876,
-0.4129321873188019,
-0.323097825050354,
-0.41385746002197266,
-0.9350370168685913,
0.6234167218208313,
-0.0630512461066246,
0.20662641525268555,
-0.0258316732943058,
0.659880518913269,
0.031011564657092094,
0.19744999706745148,
-0.5400722026824951,
-0.33106622099876404,
0.5150722861289978,
-0.06081070005893707,
-0.07672066986560822,
-0.5546118021011353,
0.0027900277636945248,
0.07755263894796371,
0.9199444651603699,
0.12556599080562592,
0.14321310818195343,
-0.13332100212574005,
0.09654996544122696,
-0.19791491329669952,
0.39696210622787476,
0.40172910690307617,
0.7792446613311768,
-0.14443372189998627,
-0.054368093609809875,
0.31240180134773254,
-0.499088317155838,
0.1220943033695221,
0.031001226976513863,
-0.1831718236207962,
-0.07301466912031174,
0.34397801756858826,
0.6271175146102905,
-0.06002054363489151,
-0.8097280263900757,
0.36998847126960754,
-0.15307027101516724,
-0.10062474757432938,
-0.666244626045227,
0.1724037379026413,
-0.08262287825345993,
0.3764653503894806,
0.5702725052833557,
-0.07993289828300476,
0.009523839689791203,
-0.6096083521842957,
0.10525398701429367,
0.9643589854240417,
-0.2300422191619873,
-0.08436532318592072,
0.44098424911499023,
0.10520992428064346,
-0.4321887195110321,
0.5302256941795349,
-0.1377103179693222,
-0.2572457492351532,
0.16332921385765076,
0.42595750093460083,
0.8193285465240479,
-0.14277267456054688,
-0.1536022126674652,
0.4439317584037781,
0.175243079662323,
-0.16212205588817596,
0.02917720004916191,
-0.07332026958465576,
-0.6368351578712463,
-0.6780945658683777,
-0.9350594878196716,
-0.7012572884559631,
0.3427404463291168,
-0.6463837027549744,
0.28819143772125244,
-0.1627664417028427,
-0.26982298493385315,
-0.4606125056743622,
0.2188122272491455,
-0.45543143153190613,
-0.10463427007198334,
0.07512598484754562,
0.9122887849807739,
-0.20104768872261047,
0.6393105387687683,
0.8849064111709595,
-0.17991138994693756,
-0.6498423218727112,
0.04861272871494293,
-0.20276768505573273,
-0.8124625086784363,
0.5535838603973389,
-0.1806386411190033,
-0.16447333991527557,
-0.008984694257378578,
-0.4632833003997803,
-0.9532563090324402,
1.0779238939285278,
0.14324934780597687,
-0.4838222563266754,
-0.3467598557472229,
0.1856008768081665,
0.5298125743865967,
-0.23281413316726685,
0.1841726154088974,
0.31116417050361633,
0.422803670167923,
0.4678983986377716,
-1.0382118225097656,
-0.29279711842536926,
-0.17634217441082,
0.07627938687801361,
0.2995557487010956,
-0.6187282800674438,
0.5542847514152527,
-0.12208335101604462,
-0.09373379498720169,
0.5348130464553833,
0.7695242762565613,
0.6426695585250854,
0.3525187373161316,
0.3792243003845215,
0.57493656873703,
0.31523555517196655,
0.01885182224214077,
1.0231057405471802,
-0.43947795033454895,
0.13346903026103973,
1.1107957363128662,
-0.3968599736690521,
1.0491493940353394,
0.3787253499031067,
-0.24271860718727112,
0.1497213989496231,
0.2457946240901947,
0.17153044044971466,
0.16423998773097992,
0.16506122052669525,
-0.4138481616973877,
-0.18668204545974731,
-0.4055401384830475,
-0.5508452653884888,
0.4515286087989807,
0.5680469274520874,
-0.3033864200115204,
-0.2058519423007965,
0.1933586597442627,
-0.1862945705652237,
0.2840299606323242,
-0.4541487395763397,
1.1289091110229492,
0.2865707576274872,
-0.7615746259689331,
0.49123525619506836,
0.10806062072515488,
0.796913206577301,
-0.6900038719177246,
-0.20599624514579773,
-0.2613658010959625,
0.12276671081781387,
-0.024294517934322357,
-0.8054625391960144,
0.2844903767108917,
0.2564181685447693,
-0.2994728088378906,
-0.30973395705223083,
0.9066590070724487,
-0.390540212392807,
-0.384578675031662,
0.2418988198041916,
0.7533572316169739,
0.19892463088035583,
0.19117920100688934,
-0.4463454782962799,
0.36109599471092224,
-0.2000473290681839,
-0.21100659668445587,
0.6289600133895874,
0.536666750907898,
0.09412848204374313,
0.7713106870651245,
0.4701223075389862,
0.32621052861213684,
-0.02844100631773472,
0.08268866688013077,
0.7842587828636169,
-0.6819646954536438,
-0.05206182599067688,
-0.5231329202651978,
0.1687190681695938,
0.15276211500167847,
0.025331880897283554,
0.9687880277633667,
0.5022602677345276,
0.874128520488739,
0.16055503487586975,
0.6176775097846985,
-0.046958278864622116,
0.980228066444397,
-0.5131235718727112,
0.7236939668655396,
-0.7163907289505005,
0.5072744488716125,
-0.13889697194099426,
-0.9497454762458801,
-0.1205926388502121,
0.2763357162475586,
-0.3745338022708893,
0.3641684949398041,
0.23652105033397675,
0.8090746998786926,
0.1513233333826065,
-0.13294576108455658,
0.3983134329319,
0.33092057704925537,
0.4129128158092499,
0.185987651348114,
1.2628766298294067,
-0.25352081656455994,
0.5156795978546143,
0.16019979119300842,
-0.12450104206800461,
-0.24057094752788544,
-0.6722670793533325,
-0.8852970004081726,
-0.7817563414573669,
0.03682544827461243,
-0.3287662863731384,
0.10293129831552505,
1.1375430822372437,
0.36780229210853577,
-0.5483670234680176,
-0.39955997467041016,
0.020607851445674896,
0.08482792973518372,
0.29165923595428467,
-0.18675550818443298,
0.3116607666015625,
-0.5022242665290833,
-0.829818069934845,
0.5646377205848694,
0.13985969126224518,
-0.01432865485548973,
-0.41386502981185913,
-0.21229155361652374,
-0.3091934323310852,
-0.07598407566547394,
0.7583505511283875,
0.26106390357017517,
-0.7275028228759766,
0.01943175494670868,
0.015520106069743633,
-0.14473775029182434,
-0.15552343428134918,
0.8004899621009827,
-0.7754839062690735,
0.23627878725528717,
0.5607972145080566,
0.9553787708282471,
0.5264095664024353,
-0.08734648674726486,
0.3982914090156555,
-0.6343337297439575,
-0.06962909549474716,
0.34090062975883484,
0.34558138251304626,
0.3950788974761963,
-0.12168936431407928,
0.5799455642700195,
-0.17783130705356598,
-0.9192693829536438,
-1.0898412466049194,
0.3201731741428375,
-0.8192305564880371,
-0.09901938587427139,
1.3210346698760986,
0.07180248200893402,
0.02155500277876854,
-0.01567472703754902,
-0.2547220289707184,
0.07743684947490692,
-0.007053205743432045,
0.7365599274635315,
0.5396602749824524,
-0.0800677239894867,
-0.20694877207279205,
-0.6586785316467285,
0.520704984664917,
0.25017422437667847,
-0.7946193218231201,
0.16669192910194397,
0.6119564175605774,
0.03532576560974121,
0.13854676485061646,
0.6076236367225647,
-0.2601824998855591,
0.09536711871623993,
-0.4648381471633911,
-0.011462224647402763,
-0.13219082355499268,
-0.4876769483089447,
-0.27725568413734436,
0.13339543342590332,
0.6767038702964783,
0.28327351808547974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06204v1
|
HC$^2$L: Hybrid and Cooperative Contrastive Learning for Cross-lingual Spoken Language Understanding
| 2024-05-10T02:40:49 | 2024-05-10T02:40:49 |
Bowen Xing, Ivor W. Tsang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
State-of-the-art model for zero-shot cross-lingual spoken language
understanding performs cross-lingual unsupervised contrastive learning to
achieve the label-agnostic semantic alignment between each utterance and its
code-switched data. However, it ignores the precious intent/slot labels, whose
label information is promising to help capture the label-aware semantics
structure and then leverage supervised contrastive learning to improve both
source and target languages' semantics. In this paper, we propose Hybrid and
Cooperative Contrastive Learning to address this problem. Apart from
cross-lingual unsupervised contrastive learning, we design a holistic approach
that exploits source language supervised contrastive learning, cross-lingual
supervised contrastive learning and multilingual supervised contrastive
learning to perform label-aware semantics alignments in a comprehensive manner.
Each kind of supervised contrastive learning mechanism includes both
single-task and joint-task scenarios. In our model, one contrastive learning
mechanism's input is enhanced by others. Thus the total four contrastive
learning mechanisms are cooperative to learn more consistent and discriminative
representations in the virtuous cycle during the training process. Experiments
show that our model obtains consistent improvements over 9 languages, achieving
new state-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.2148466408252716,
-0.653003990650177,
0.14959268271923065,
0.1573413610458374,
-0.2366284281015396,
0.38961324095726013,
-0.2336031198501587,
-0.6277048587799072,
0.12084966152906418,
0.37100595235824585,
-0.4495042860507965,
-0.5533700585365295,
-0.4745270907878876,
-0.0364166758954525,
0.05065682902932167,
0.964816153049469,
-0.07461828738451004,
0.4016793668270111,
-0.12090074270963669,
-0.4690805673599243,
-0.43366754055023193,
-0.27219876646995544,
-0.46873724460601807,
-0.7103620171546936,
0.6121236085891724,
0.6406334638595581,
0.4838636517524719,
0.3831702768802643,
-0.03733668476343155,
0.2620961368083954,
0.13458113372325897,
0.08948452770709991,
-0.5951070189476013,
-0.017685391008853912,
-0.33568915724754333,
-0.3302959203720093,
-0.3485863506793976,
0.031266167759895325,
0.5492920279502869,
1.0701688528060913,
0.055647388100624084,
-0.43712785840034485,
0.04479646310210228,
0.38133785128593445,
-0.6638631224632263,
0.1950874924659729,
-0.585163950920105,
0.25742778182029724,
0.02015315368771553,
-0.13832928240299225,
-0.5415247082710266,
0.18366332352161407,
0.2086121141910553,
-1.171410322189331,
-0.08318964391946793,
0.04742440581321716,
0.7528784275054932,
0.004671883303672075,
-0.4818144738674164,
-0.17292264103889465,
-0.49020540714263916,
1.0027360916137695,
-0.2994118630886078,
0.7391309142112732,
0.2199486643075943,
0.2236035168170929,
0.278060644865036,
-0.4149239957332611,
-0.5207475423812866,
-0.12368900328874588,
-0.18169009685516357,
0.6110053062438965,
-0.18638144433498383,
-0.010846773162484169,
-0.35913386940956116,
0.5389912724494934,
-0.7498409152030945,
0.5664100050926208,
-0.01757826842367649,
-0.41377896070480347,
0.42828503251075745,
-0.13905498385429382,
0.481059730052948,
0.08736925572156906,
-0.8383926749229431,
-0.14901424944400787,
-0.42572781443595886,
-0.014343108050525188,
0.08646594732999802,
0.25979647040367126,
-0.5799785256385803,
0.27766069769859314,
-0.19343112409114838,
0.8516283631324768,
0.31636878848075867,
-0.09437662363052368,
0.28116607666015625,
-0.7028297781944275,
-0.19256068766117096,
0.11893034726381302,
0.7854186296463013,
0.03685583919286728,
0.31241413950920105,
-0.5784226655960083,
0.011168847791850567,
0.24889470636844635,
-0.19785311818122864,
-0.3218616545200348,
-0.2061767876148224,
0.033736538141965866,
0.021021012216806412,
-0.2283126562833786,
-0.029925867915153503,
-0.4186882972717285,
-0.04886962100863457,
-0.49767473340034485,
0.5371153354644775,
-0.5816332101821899,
-0.3657573461532593,
0.30045899748802185,
-0.049081284552812576,
0.36424773931503296,
0.199449822306633,
-0.9732478857040405,
0.3646136522293091,
0.617760181427002,
0.5170266628265381,
-0.3623410165309906,
-0.546508252620697,
-0.9123932123184204,
0.5001252889633179,
-0.2834634482860565,
0.5021206736564636,
-0.5073484778404236,
-0.3492644429206848,
-0.16260433197021484,
-0.016726858913898468,
-0.3372008502483368,
-0.33227768540382385,
0.10029822587966919,
-0.711952269077301,
0.563904881477356,
0.2396077960729599,
-0.5299040675163269,
-0.4605639576911926,
0.23811843991279602,
-0.5654614567756653,
0.6053691506385803,
0.10471505671739578,
-0.8534033894538879,
0.19105936586856842,
-0.34806501865386963,
-0.5443574786186218,
0.1540338546037674,
-0.1544904261827469,
-0.36450013518333435,
-0.2708931267261505,
0.040775712579488754,
0.3308635354042053,
0.10599551349878311,
0.37467047572135925,
-0.0842287540435791,
-0.26731550693511963,
0.09981537610292435,
-0.19150805473327637,
1.012232780456543,
0.010283577255904675,
-0.4245245158672333,
0.35798725485801697,
-0.7746049761772156,
-0.14524398744106293,
0.07150251418352127,
-0.17727337777614594,
-0.5287047624588013,
-0.5342347025871277,
0.04150451347231865,
0.38532742857933044,
0.3189541697502136,
-0.6035699248313904,
-0.3367846608161926,
-0.40667837858200073,
0.02749270759522915,
0.4870728552341461,
-0.13812866806983948,
0.8401260375976562,
-0.06418704241514206,
0.349270761013031,
0.37568914890289307,
0.0511237271130085,
-0.14811626076698303,
-0.1326180398464203,
-0.7963742613792419,
-0.23195405304431915,
0.3785576820373535,
0.7051491737365723,
-1.1297801733016968,
0.5015141367912292,
-0.10482587665319443,
-0.32837000489234924,
-0.5477731227874756,
0.2819027602672577,
1.0475133657455444,
0.7413491010665894,
0.4806292653083801,
-0.4571002125740051,
-0.3188845217227936,
-0.6859670281410217,
-0.07832086086273193,
0.042963456362485886,
0.11281128227710724,
0.19154785573482513,
0.23736339807510376,
-0.3603493571281433,
0.7210091352462769,
-0.07273567467927933,
-0.151334747672081,
-0.24628670513629913,
0.3916800022125244,
-0.18712018430233002,
0.38959938287734985,
0.2548779547214508,
-0.9719972610473633,
-0.8404501676559448,
0.7336744070053101,
-0.7966439127922058,
-0.20977985858917236,
0.07603392750024796,
-0.2315000593662262,
0.442412793636322,
0.30205827951431274,
-0.040597643703222275,
-0.13313411176204681,
0.8872537612915039,
-0.24499939382076263,
0.4367213249206543,
-0.28551626205444336,
-0.13766448199748993,
-1.0058503150939941,
-0.07928135991096497,
0.0817447379231453,
-0.3069647550582886,
-0.8133278489112854,
-0.06513355672359467,
0.013165601529181004,
-0.0734269767999649,
-0.5156856179237366,
0.5343668460845947,
-0.7376890778541565,
-0.2820569574832916,
-0.18389703333377838,
0.5502822399139404,
0.1716255247592926,
0.571847140789032,
0.6450408697128296,
0.5095839500427246,
0.7482312917709351,
-0.528309166431427,
0.2566453218460083,
0.22131626307964325,
-0.013070211745798588,
0.749251127243042,
-0.46142974495887756,
0.09316632151603699,
0.06855734437704086,
0.30077117681503296,
-0.943469762802124,
0.007151409517973661,
0.44710129499435425,
-0.48891061544418335,
0.5074928402900696,
0.18967954814434052,
0.002808925462886691,
0.3464476764202118,
0.006195073015987873,
0.4437443017959595,
0.13984963297843933,
-0.6451897621154785,
0.6120513081550598,
0.43529874086380005,
-0.03401598334312439,
-0.782011866569519,
-0.6616410613059998,
-0.21147558093070984,
0.1395523101091385,
-0.6016374230384827,
0.661155641078949,
0.09173567593097687,
-0.25445055961608887,
0.15669232606887817,
-0.043123796582221985,
0.058513280004262924,
-0.13773992657661438,
-0.07671767473220825,
0.39771297574043274,
-0.2134997397661209,
0.0061902571469545364,
-0.11742964386940002,
-0.6093973517417908,
-0.3004590570926666,
-0.43388062715530396,
0.5484427213668823,
-0.09396734088659286,
-0.23557919263839722,
-0.3218069076538086,
0.571130633354187,
0.2594923675060272,
-0.44653427600860596,
0.5536773800849915,
0.8213948011398315,
-0.023644302040338516,
0.004794619511812925,
-0.2473733127117157,
0.01896536722779274,
-0.3467123806476593,
0.21579235792160034,
-0.464584618806839,
-1.1283866167068481,
0.31950265169143677,
0.07773924618959427,
0.06899533420801163,
0.2632952630519867,
0.48245057463645935,
0.03520938754081726,
0.6442052721977234,
0.8654106259346008,
-0.07833011448383331,
0.4251757264137268,
-0.12296567857265472,
0.2584651708602905,
-0.6033364534378052,
-0.3477865755558014,
-0.16125786304473877,
0.06090603023767471,
-0.6726975440979004,
-0.6656690239906311,
0.357137531042099,
-0.012700541876256466,
-0.042862433940172195,
0.34006452560424805,
-0.19826608896255493,
0.27057674527168274,
0.46098852157592773,
0.1701405793428421,
0.4411482512950897,
-0.02180473692715168,
-0.36289653182029724,
-0.0020074613858014345,
-0.8200085759162903,
0.09254135936498642,
0.37125107645988464,
0.006024000234901905,
0.6842189431190491,
-0.05289362370967865,
0.7660415768623352,
-0.0620916411280632,
-0.01661902666091919,
-0.6824841499328613,
0.33040669560432434,
-0.23063646256923676,
-0.25271737575531006,
-0.42858341336250305,
-0.481602281332016,
-0.961058497428894,
0.6397002935409546,
-0.13552895188331604,
-0.46931570768356323,
0.38399171829223633,
0.05132633447647095,
0.07996918261051178,
0.13431072235107422,
-0.7556682229042053,
1.0823884010314941,
-0.4466278851032257,
-0.685337245464325,
-0.5285738706588745,
-1.0123192071914673,
0.3965807259082794,
-0.10695820301771164,
0.3348103165626526,
0.2883705496788025,
-0.07554871588945389,
0.4890969395637512,
-0.06727588176727295,
1.2566941976547241,
0.03247402608394623,
-0.24238495528697968,
-0.02200191840529442,
0.06627961248159409,
0.16753998398780823,
-0.33671265840530396,
0.2043514996767044,
0.3172127306461334,
-0.2506132423877716,
-0.7247118949890137,
-0.48277464509010315,
0.6007854342460632,
-0.7182173728942871,
-0.2200598418712616,
-0.4055137634277344,
-0.8100147843360901,
-0.31195420026779175,
0.04024607688188553,
0.24705028533935547,
0.26169106364250183,
-0.3564507067203522,
-0.13908958435058594,
0.7880887389183044,
-0.3068520128726959,
0.25647658109664917,
0.926388680934906,
-0.04154187813401222,
-0.4181680381298065,
1.2995178699493408,
-0.19867803156375885,
0.7975740432739258,
0.9823368787765503,
0.0835835188627243,
-0.3706638813018799,
-0.20647121965885162,
-0.2811414301395416,
0.4950430393218994,
-0.5958732962608337,
0.12869268655776978,
-0.6514405608177185,
-0.0783134251832962,
-0.4389009177684784,
-0.46083593368530273,
-0.19953374564647675,
-0.24191217124462128,
-0.1681233048439026,
0.002661367878317833,
0.14030449092388153,
0.40638571977615356,
-0.5408669114112854,
0.15265856683254242,
-0.7040022015571594,
0.4087742269039154,
0.45149821043014526,
0.09447649121284485,
-0.14510390162467957,
-0.3876340687274933,
-0.36147835850715637,
-0.0020916073117405176,
-0.20406123995780945,
-0.8022501468658447,
0.3253942131996155,
0.2166380137205124,
0.8185184597969055,
0.35149917006492615,
0.03729597479104996,
0.5318394899368286,
-0.3572840392589569,
0.4923928678035736,
0.6768437027931213,
-1.1378334760665894,
0.40541210770606995,
-0.1626974642276764,
0.3556845486164093,
0.345483660697937,
0.5772361755371094,
-0.8052990436553955,
-0.27388304471969604,
-0.6105984449386597,
-0.5963226556777954,
0.6839894652366638,
-0.12556175887584686,
-0.2966791093349457,
0.2853952646255493,
-0.2546703815460205,
0.45429280400276184,
-0.13996721804141998,
-0.938854992389679,
-0.14241370558738708,
-0.19249698519706726,
-0.0779246985912323,
-0.34660616517066956,
0.06792157143354416,
-0.08589296042919159,
-0.2308514267206192,
0.8193619251251221,
-0.23937886953353882,
-0.22271911799907684,
-0.046258777379989624,
-0.2697650194168091,
-0.1202223151922226,
0.5193231701850891,
0.32612621784210205,
0.41678985953330994,
0.11206222325563431,
0.23929724097251892,
0.04242297634482384,
-0.05577826499938965,
0.1268358677625656,
0.1633857637643814,
-0.0745563879609108,
0.02996736206114292,
0.34004664421081543,
0.9795068502426147,
0.8370962142944336,
-0.5029646754264832,
0.3979910910129547,
0.1994144171476364,
-0.18620772659778595,
0.03459521010518074,
-0.09429521858692169,
0.3181968331336975,
0.013556569814682007,
-0.3025185465812683,
-0.25949957966804504,
0.11993563175201416,
-0.7216994762420654,
0.3853461444377899,
0.5367781519889832,
-0.6563824415206909,
-0.327776700258255,
0.3379204571247101,
0.3958797752857208,
-0.09622824192047119,
0.2538836598396301,
-0.0866304263472557,
-0.6560179591178894,
0.2634804844856262,
0.7037491202354431,
0.49057328701019287,
-0.4860388934612274,
0.5876945853233337,
0.1571189910173416,
-0.07203078269958496,
0.47399285435676575,
0.05455724149942398,
-0.6565678119659424,
-0.9453587532043457,
-0.5489653944969177,
-0.41744464635849,
-0.8309653997421265,
-0.26185229420661926,
-0.7925941944122314,
0.10377930849790573,
0.07303609699010849,
0.6887524724006653,
0.17625947296619415,
0.0687507763504982,
-0.36708712577819824,
0.3835195302963257,
0.14908535778522491,
0.6077542304992676,
-1.035987377166748,
1.0661479234695435,
0.5395256280899048,
-0.4613737463951111,
-0.6137906312942505,
-0.15593405067920685,
0.003855206770822406,
-1.0363112688064575,
0.6578429937362671,
-0.029167281463742256,
-0.46157824993133545,
0.08036932349205017,
-0.26116421818733215,
-0.4444793164730072,
0.9571819305419922,
0.16342155635356903,
-0.7288032174110413,
0.2831767201423645,
0.09566955268383026,
0.4892845153808594,
-0.41774630546569824,
0.13868007063865662,
0.4636973738670349,
0.43545711040496826,
0.3632584810256958,
-0.9399203062057495,
-0.22903327643871307,
-0.28073015809059143,
-0.17514048516750336,
0.1454496830701828,
-0.6606616377830505,
0.6586822867393494,
-0.21155162155628204,
-0.27252230048179626,
-0.2643149495124817,
0.7994383573532104,
0.3112257122993469,
0.6333699822425842,
0.6069368124008179,
0.5456657409667969,
0.5258344411849976,
-0.020195839926600456,
0.8811305165290833,
-0.20262566208839417,
0.1402074247598648,
1.075344204902649,
-0.496694415807724,
0.807353138923645,
0.5665443539619446,
0.24775366485118866,
0.6001763343811035,
0.5778721570968628,
0.2511025071144104,
0.633310854434967,
-0.21046628057956696,
-0.48345550894737244,
-0.5162538290023804,
-0.4626915156841278,
-0.15536941587924957,
0.5301644802093506,
0.3748626112937927,
0.0016442316118627787,
-0.44661006331443787,
0.18989939987659454,
-0.09626496583223343,
0.2516269385814667,
-0.11603952944278717,
0.9715322256088257,
0.19751405715942383,
-0.5670262575149536,
0.7164074182510376,
-0.26031747460365295,
0.841468334197998,
-0.6268113851547241,
-0.0660787969827652,
-0.03568563982844353,
0.09196078032255173,
-0.22572797536849976,
-0.8554441332817078,
0.07514128088951111,
-0.20029836893081665,
-0.13585759699344635,
-0.2555944621562958,
0.6647152900695801,
-1.0152804851531982,
-0.008841728791594505,
0.988911509513855,
0.5808193683624268,
0.13910320401191711,
0.44040408730506897,
-0.7623788714408875,
-0.046299047768116,
0.027055498212575912,
0.2964857518672943,
0.4942576587200165,
0.4859728217124939,
-0.029131190851330757,
0.27315154671669006,
0.48752114176750183,
0.009300579316914082,
0.0022900565527379513,
0.364410936832428,
0.7087881565093994,
-0.4019096791744232,
-0.6533219814300537,
-0.4092918634414673,
0.4839865565299988,
-0.14327757060527802,
-0.1338595449924469,
0.555695116519928,
0.3929550349712372,
1.4184985160827637,
-0.003845490515232086,
0.6823863387107849,
0.23598188161849976,
0.41107240319252014,
-0.6788250803947449,
0.33500200510025024,
-0.7266563773155212,
-0.08391805738210678,
-0.04150325432419777,
-0.6102870106697083,
-0.3422046899795532,
0.49540239572525024,
-0.3612769544124603,
-0.14514920115470886,
0.5919182896614075,
0.7117644548416138,
-0.26742616295814514,
0.045951250940561295,
0.7220247983932495,
0.09726977348327637,
-0.0129849286749959,
0.880304753780365,
0.6718994379043579,
-0.32375770807266235,
0.5059333443641663,
-0.47282081842422485,
-0.4508843719959259,
-0.15989337861537933,
-0.6429036259651184,
-0.6794127225875854,
-0.6669883131980896,
-0.4761631488800049,
-0.09045378118753433,
0.2552090287208557,
0.4248478412628174,
0.7966389060020447,
-0.8398445248603821,
-0.3276263177394867,
-0.3078230619430542,
0.17618894577026367,
-0.3470415472984314,
-0.29341524839401245,
0.16743427515029907,
-0.44328609108924866,
-0.9386162757873535,
0.5275923609733582,
0.6335525512695312,
0.009632490575313568,
-0.2736727297306061,
-0.5493535995483398,
-0.4114627242088318,
-0.21136407554149628,
0.6103936433792114,
0.5835946202278137,
-0.7726661562919617,
-0.04566675424575806,
0.027367984876036644,
-0.3116953372955322,
0.09787769615650177,
0.6449783444404602,
-0.676911473274231,
0.6683396697044373,
0.5864974856376648,
0.7830076217651367,
0.5733709931373596,
-0.3170361816883087,
0.6960496306419373,
-0.650057852268219,
0.16104717552661896,
0.09738490730524063,
0.42491185665130615,
0.6070988178253174,
-0.33383333683013916,
0.3800501525402069,
0.3548240661621094,
-0.41296863555908203,
-0.23859043419361115,
0.44068580865859985,
-1.4608824253082275,
-0.31219780445098877,
1.0125359296798706,
-0.3522782027721405,
-0.18594735860824585,
-0.2934786379337311,
-0.1447790265083313,
0.676713228225708,
-0.06794407218694687,
0.3680940866470337,
0.39583927392959595,
-0.2396581768989563,
-0.43164339661598206,
0.062492478638887405,
0.05582442134618759,
0.6973243951797485,
-0.7523549795150757,
0.0010884440271183848,
0.4348487854003906,
0.22481250762939453,
0.3082158863544464,
0.540081262588501,
-0.21998776495456696,
0.4671729505062103,
0.14205554127693176,
0.1416735053062439,
0.04968210682272911,
-0.31309938430786133,
-0.5636885762214661,
-0.16583998501300812,
-0.3250970244407654,
-0.537570059299469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06196v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06196v2
|
VLSM-Adapter: Finetuning Vision-Language Segmentation Efficiently with Lightweight Blocks
| 2024-05-10T02:23:56 | 2024-06-27T14:19:56 |
Manish Dhakal, Rabin Adhikari, Safal Thapaliya, Bishesh Khanal
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Foundation Vision-Language Models (VLMs) trained using large-scale
open-domain images and text pairs have recently been adapted to develop
Vision-Language Segmentation Models (VLSMs) that allow providing text prompts
during inference to guide image segmentation. If robust and powerful VLSMs can
be built for medical images, it could aid medical professionals in many
clinical tasks where they must spend substantial time delineating the target
structure of interest. VLSMs for medical images resort to fine-tuning base VLM
or VLSM pretrained on open-domain natural image datasets due to fewer annotated
medical image datasets; this fine-tuning is resource-consuming and expensive as
it usually requires updating all or a significant fraction of the pretrained
parameters. Recently, lightweight blocks called adapters have been proposed in
VLMs that keep the pretrained model frozen and only train adapters during
fine-tuning, substantially reducing the computing resources required. We
introduce a novel adapter, VLSM-Adapter, that can fine-tune pretrained
vision-language segmentation models using transformer encoders. Our experiments
in widely used CLIP-based segmentation models show that with only 3 million
trainable parameters, the VLSM-Adapter outperforms state-of-the-art and is
comparable to the upper bound end-to-end fine-tuning. The source code is
available at: https://github.com/naamiinepal/vlsm-adapter.
|
[
-0.4438750743865967,
-0.5558890104293823,
0.5501041412353516,
0.049841757863759995,
-0.7460557222366333,
-0.2526315152645111,
-0.2719328999519348,
-0.5650569796562195,
-0.06269973516464233,
0.7058562636375427,
-0.43454858660697937,
-0.3074284791946411,
-0.5225333571434021,
-0.09310811012983322,
-0.18242721259593964,
0.7185244560241699,
-0.012163530103862286,
0.5359815955162048,
-0.44054943323135376,
-0.4072059690952301,
-0.39353692531585693,
-0.05457479879260063,
-0.5774193406105042,
-0.12474660575389862,
0.0969075933098793,
0.28131577372550964,
0.6562978625297546,
1.0120741128921509,
0.6056770086288452,
0.25816720724105835,
-0.24091091752052307,
0.286397248506546,
-0.3002296984195709,
-0.024060502648353577,
-0.2741796374320984,
-0.409258097410202,
-0.1935853809118271,
-0.5366182923316956,
0.5648258328437805,
0.745461642742157,
0.06629978865385056,
0.21197958290576935,
-0.18482930958271027,
0.8740872740745544,
-0.7396130561828613,
-0.2276497334241867,
-0.8594313859939575,
0.03595937415957451,
-0.016007596626877785,
-0.2679465711116791,
-0.31674671173095703,
-0.23766903579235077,
0.3242638409137726,
-0.4356195330619812,
0.2765728533267975,
0.0794818103313446,
1.1784011125564575,
0.53538578748703,
0.02468278259038925,
-0.09033151715993881,
-0.6140033006668091,
0.6573302745819092,
-0.4945053160190582,
0.5226524472236633,
0.08887702971696854,
0.4565187394618988,
0.19973373413085938,
-0.8255659937858582,
-0.16089771687984467,
-0.12366221845149994,
-0.04783916473388672,
-0.16092993319034576,
-0.057583775371313095,
0.235728919506073,
0.1789228469133377,
0.43431058526039124,
-0.47691741585731506,
0.24921084940433502,
-0.5860757827758789,
-0.07677210122346878,
0.17277860641479492,
0.2968151271343231,
0.33104753494262695,
0.2890538275241852,
-0.5591164231300354,
0.10341451317071915,
-0.7224071621894836,
-0.0428888313472271,
-0.28959742188453674,
-0.005971283186227083,
-0.13047251105308533,
0.3248930871486664,
-0.12190224975347519,
1.352755069732666,
0.14541277289390564,
-0.3275575339794159,
0.14441142976284027,
-0.3339003622531891,
-0.37272560596466064,
-0.015858199447393417,
0.5106980204582214,
0.6079834699630737,
0.5405733585357666,
0.0615280382335186,
-0.21575888991355896,
0.0526232086122036,
0.23708254098892212,
-1.3775714635849,
-0.3717104494571686,
-0.04309634119272232,
-0.5774434804916382,
-0.12457412481307983,
-0.1594095081090927,
-0.7367285490036011,
-0.3948095738887787,
-0.3573087453842163,
0.36564069986343384,
-0.34388500452041626,
0.24189287424087524,
0.39811229705810547,
-0.12774844467639923,
0.38735657930374146,
0.5370016098022461,
-0.90965735912323,
0.5408876538276672,
0.18449215590953827,
0.9243977069854736,
-0.3315070569515228,
-0.054541490972042084,
-0.68785160779953,
-0.15997615456581116,
-0.21009285748004913,
0.8124055862426758,
-0.46990635991096497,
-0.28219935297966003,
-0.1927136331796646,
0.43227580189704895,
-0.08871614187955856,
-0.8779594898223877,
0.4569661617279053,
-0.37331268191337585,
-0.020523393526673317,
0.061434634029865265,
-0.32079988718032837,
0.09752147644758224,
0.42329397797584534,
-0.5119249224662781,
0.6033169031143188,
0.001677771215327084,
-0.27683764696121216,
0.37997135519981384,
-0.47406503558158875,
-0.4874362647533417,
0.2756478190422058,
-0.2071821093559265,
-0.6221113204956055,
0.27954524755477905,
0.49322110414505005,
0.48653852939605713,
-0.5134970545768738,
-0.08615178614854813,
-0.22113804519176483,
-0.2173214852809906,
0.1485365927219391,
-0.27762365341186523,
0.40534070134162903,
0.11645110696554184,
-0.05215146020054817,
0.5182763934135437,
-0.9138792753219604,
0.09603618085384369,
0.3317495584487915,
-0.11116106063127518,
-0.4820459187030792,
0.16254207491874695,
0.2709408402442932,
0.21659469604492188,
0.29723525047302246,
-0.529840886592865,
-0.02240869030356407,
-0.3448083996772766,
0.34516966342926025,
0.5750114917755127,
-0.24486693739891052,
0.4126335680484772,
-0.13261447846889496,
0.2669421136379242,
0.12165777385234833,
0.5009457468986511,
-0.47993203997612,
-0.38274869322776794,
-0.912796676158905,
-0.4304160475730896,
0.15575724840164185,
0.33976858854293823,
-0.7471688985824585,
0.17180439829826355,
-0.09393008798360825,
-0.6402760744094849,
-0.7866544723510742,
0.06367657333612442,
0.28420332074165344,
0.7936674952507019,
0.6402039527893066,
-0.376910537481308,
-0.6804256439208984,
-0.8599269390106201,
-0.1677457094192505,
0.3251931071281433,
-0.051814280450344086,
0.28804805874824524,
0.17703180015087128,
-0.407256543636322,
0.792554497718811,
-0.7939919233322144,
-0.3552510440349579,
-0.01219155266880989,
-0.618575930595398,
-0.015491103753447533,
0.5922325253486633,
0.7491589188575745,
-0.8011408448219299,
-0.5156547427177429,
0.1817181259393692,
-0.44394752383232117,
-0.02976955473423004,
0.06891454011201859,
0.18602032959461212,
-0.06003829836845398,
0.666337788105011,
-0.06687261164188385,
0.16317017376422882,
0.5552674531936646,
-0.46592703461647034,
0.4990348219871521,
-0.45477625727653503,
-0.18935346603393555,
-0.9119915962219238,
-0.04893738403916359,
0.15654371678829193,
-0.4980055093765259,
-0.6613574028015137,
0.1425083428621292,
0.31077954173088074,
-0.12781506776809692,
-0.6785891652107239,
0.597794234752655,
-0.4951860010623932,
0.02972051315009594,
-0.39532470703125,
-0.04219530150294304,
0.02568243443965912,
0.15192660689353943,
0.3079383075237274,
0.576736569404602,
0.9520020484924316,
-0.6038452982902527,
-0.05957052484154701,
0.04613878205418587,
-0.20411443710327148,
0.6641178131103516,
-0.8199988603591919,
-0.03763151913881302,
-0.21124166250228882,
-0.27837738394737244,
-0.5547874569892883,
-0.04145664721727371,
0.15051181614398956,
0.18172551691532135,
0.12728621065616608,
-0.4147053062915802,
-0.04018343240022659,
-0.3522675335407257,
-0.3192048966884613,
0.698078453540802,
0.7736150622367859,
-0.7228444814682007,
0.5303964018821716,
0.41701021790504456,
0.21258756518363953,
-0.17400217056274414,
-0.6003318428993225,
-0.19033285975456238,
0.03189586475491524,
-0.4720778465270996,
0.449187695980072,
-0.24147167801856995,
0.0180961973965168,
0.12127801030874252,
-0.2846468389034271,
-0.33449476957321167,
0.11675781011581421,
0.441739559173584,
0.4677666127681732,
-0.5710582733154297,
-0.21910227835178375,
0.08521612733602524,
-0.2987572252750397,
-0.2870578169822693,
-0.5615729093551636,
0.5814552307128906,
-0.4600038528442383,
-0.4700124263763428,
-0.1643485426902771,
-0.10967234522104263,
0.8610859513282776,
-0.5386765599250793,
0.6880583763122559,
0.7138174772262573,
-0.5476830005645752,
-0.11141478270292282,
-0.46167007088661194,
-0.16016821563243866,
-0.4961206316947937,
0.6293520927429199,
-0.15648651123046875,
-1.119410753250122,
0.04786385968327522,
-0.49012625217437744,
-0.12930084764957428,
0.3222557604312897,
0.5569080114364624,
-0.0617978498339653,
0.8494247198104858,
0.5353531241416931,
0.1345115751028061,
0.6409631967544556,
0.055685266852378845,
-0.09147834032773972,
-0.783891499042511,
-0.15257246792316437,
-0.4336724579334259,
-0.21289385855197906,
-0.1632302701473236,
-0.6859028339385986,
0.3059026300907135,
-0.007896815426647663,
0.24405904114246368,
0.056098729372024536,
-0.7394947409629822,
0.8809157609939575,
0.223422110080719,
0.09998200088739395,
0.023335279896855354,
-0.04218922555446625,
0.03207284212112427,
-0.11670877039432526,
-0.651590883731842,
-0.36694827675819397,
0.8142579793930054,
0.2746966481208801,
0.9879457354545593,
-0.42873087525367737,
0.27257052063941956,
-0.07447956502437592,
-0.019259262830018997,
-1.0057977437973022,
0.557832658290863,
-0.5465171933174133,
-0.15643621981143951,
-0.030124928802251816,
0.027904599905014038,
-0.7777695655822754,
0.38460806012153625,
-0.4103255867958069,
-0.5538442134857178,
0.3545823395252228,
0.5196256041526794,
-0.5078089237213135,
0.48936131596565247,
-0.6676852703094482,
0.9655818939208984,
-0.3609229028224945,
-0.24288588762283325,
0.0029554676730185747,
-0.7148674726486206,
0.16421431303024292,
-0.1266985535621643,
0.10421779751777649,
-0.17285636067390442,
-0.06277110427618027,
0.5838057398796082,
-0.6145954728126526,
0.7675254344940186,
-0.3292827308177948,
0.2459855079650879,
0.1677185446023941,
-0.20870882272720337,
0.19402849674224854,
-0.16914907097816467,
0.24249783158302307,
0.08718407899141312,
0.17634126543998718,
-0.443358838558197,
-0.2549884021282196,
0.6197587251663208,
-0.6036810874938965,
-0.26529720425605774,
-0.023810286074876785,
-0.44459789991378784,
-0.08039680123329163,
0.4344213008880615,
0.24536238610744476,
0.7017853856086731,
-0.26205557584762573,
0.37853142619132996,
0.7890153527259827,
-0.0683598667383194,
0.4064287841320038,
0.5747785568237305,
-0.3072667717933655,
-0.36991560459136963,
1.0436609983444214,
-0.09946614503860474,
0.4507560133934021,
0.3363262712955475,
0.326763778924942,
0.006034084130078554,
-1.1125105619430542,
-0.674872875213623,
0.1764945685863495,
-0.5480638742446899,
-0.25634562969207764,
-0.32914939522743225,
-0.3152957260608673,
0.1649349182844162,
-0.4248437285423279,
-0.6694015264511108,
-0.08360344171524048,
-0.3489891290664673,
0.22266890108585358,
0.29804250597953796,
0.4270872175693512,
0.24403510987758636,
0.5783946514129639,
-0.7888765335083008,
0.6692429780960083,
0.37558308243751526,
0.4213666021823883,
-0.3615306615829468,
-0.4535975754261017,
-0.5988361239433289,
-0.3244430422782898,
0.0002145711041521281,
-0.5929501056671143,
0.15375876426696777,
0.31093207001686096,
0.2780493497848511,
0.631464958190918,
-0.06843020766973495,
0.9253217577934265,
-0.6544999480247498,
0.6770550608634949,
0.37019553780555725,
-0.7458033561706543,
0.5388217568397522,
0.2066461741924286,
0.5537818670272827,
0.7913859486579895,
0.01531360112130642,
-0.3028676509857178,
0.030584042891860008,
-0.018214350566267967,
-0.7796483039855957,
0.6310939192771912,
-0.2453683763742447,
-0.08675672113895416,
0.15337106585502625,
0.24521015584468842,
0.20770685374736786,
0.006792391184717417,
-0.4019412398338318,
-0.3092365264892578,
-0.09451338648796082,
-0.38345086574554443,
0.1467185616493225,
-0.44618305563926697,
-0.00949554331600666,
-0.3508860468864441,
0.4510374665260315,
-0.4186963140964508,
-0.17132729291915894,
0.37250372767448425,
-0.5126320719718933,
-0.1765233725309372,
0.07222592830657959,
0.8873623013496399,
0.4416947364807129,
-0.0908866673707962,
0.39812684059143066,
0.41555866599082947,
-0.8567545413970947,
0.12018034607172012,
0.16041281819343567,
-0.38719913363456726,
0.12195219099521637,
0.1280687153339386,
1.2588446140289307,
0.14239318668842316,
-0.9888524413108826,
0.4579354226589203,
-0.3209441900253296,
-0.2520570158958435,
0.03510491922497749,
0.11790679395198822,
0.10580262541770935,
0.1433834582567215,
0.14871902763843536,
0.8182550072669983,
-0.011162676848471165,
-0.04650483280420303,
0.19427983462810516,
0.3596649765968323,
-0.7634016275405884,
-0.366452693939209,
0.6317939162254333,
0.2727093994617462,
-0.4983534812927246,
0.13794656097888947,
0.04536847025156021,
-0.3474080562591553,
0.4494587481021881,
0.7385096549987793,
0.7909606695175171,
-0.30046528577804565,
-0.15475542843341827,
0.09219910949468613,
0.44411948323249817,
-0.12728238105773926,
0.1861475259065628,
-0.005694261752068996,
-0.7098994255065918,
-0.4075179994106293,
-0.7828044295310974,
-0.21020765602588654,
0.07846473157405853,
-0.5111885666847229,
0.4680357873439789,
-0.6678030490875244,
0.02806903049349785,
-0.20366017520427704,
-0.6587307453155518,
-0.8309146761894226,
0.5707796216011047,
0.3261492848396301,
1.0688461065292358,
-0.5634227991104126,
0.9947184920310974,
0.9784154295921326,
0.1514585167169571,
-0.42854830622673035,
-0.06591782718896866,
-0.20052523910999298,
-1.0524423122406006,
0.08623119443655014,
0.32946571707725525,
-0.25944721698760986,
-0.07448830455541611,
-0.24954241514205933,
-0.48350802063941956,
0.9144737720489502,
0.4751019775867462,
-0.9128859639167786,
-0.05442316457629204,
0.11975656449794769,
0.41542017459869385,
-0.2769755721092224,
0.005102623254060745,
0.5099532008171082,
0.21016649901866913,
-0.040506280958652496,
-0.7732083201408386,
0.19134387373924255,
-0.15785042941570282,
0.05173920840024948,
0.300042062997818,
-0.47271257638931274,
0.6272568702697754,
-0.286153644323349,
0.07609105855226517,
0.12020157277584076,
0.46242833137512207,
0.11477955430746078,
0.24811983108520508,
0.8346028327941895,
0.46793365478515625,
0.5994130373001099,
-0.06088743358850479,
0.661340594291687,
-0.5096011757850647,
0.17831429839134216,
1.090118408203125,
-0.023812847211956978,
0.5959327220916748,
0.8356669545173645,
0.14866198599338531,
0.19388863444328308,
0.29516175389289856,
-0.1240088939666748,
0.6425352692604065,
0.11079256236553192,
-0.23012377321720123,
-0.4001463055610657,
-0.15261606872081757,
-0.4866832494735718,
0.2908209562301636,
0.4347986578941345,
-0.615143895149231,
-0.18255005776882172,
0.23235918581485748,
-0.24575504660606384,
0.008666346780955791,
-0.61542809009552,
0.7620883584022522,
0.21445326507091522,
-0.34382379055023193,
0.5593118071556091,
-0.03678576648235321,
0.7506284117698669,
-0.730725109577179,
0.2418188452720642,
0.18659475445747375,
0.3370291590690613,
-0.2908798158168793,
-0.6549345254898071,
0.4279608726501465,
-0.06722654402256012,
-0.15786413848400116,
0.03440821170806885,
1.0901328325271606,
-0.44150933623313904,
-0.41945913434028625,
0.19804781675338745,
0.42596912384033203,
-0.1606753170490265,
-0.090169258415699,
-0.5704002976417542,
0.3412562906742096,
0.003360909642651677,
0.0984642282128334,
0.3422285318374634,
0.3657849431037903,
0.06557436287403107,
0.42639338970184326,
0.6128581166267395,
0.155857115983963,
0.09450285136699677,
0.009795499965548515,
1.054416298866272,
-0.5110976099967957,
-0.2777937650680542,
-1.155819296836853,
0.46813255548477173,
-0.13951930403709412,
-0.3157345950603485,
0.3600132167339325,
0.7341813445091248,
0.7730948328971863,
-0.5131775140762329,
0.47623923420906067,
0.15146830677986145,
-0.11590302735567093,
-0.7252334952354431,
0.7385427355766296,
-0.6499682068824768,
-0.14051060378551483,
-0.14400112628936768,
-0.5363070964813232,
-0.5298389196395874,
0.482345849275589,
-0.2209693044424057,
-0.31589633226394653,
0.4988233149051666,
0.6430824995040894,
-0.29666367173194885,
-0.34379005432128906,
0.5802306532859802,
0.027443701401352882,
0.1848171502351761,
0.2602442502975464,
0.5129263997077942,
-0.29221582412719727,
0.5297617316246033,
-0.16452941298484802,
-0.05897067114710808,
-0.5393926501274109,
-0.6722555756568909,
-1.096892237663269,
-0.4190751910209656,
-0.3858772814273834,
-0.11844610422849655,
0.0748191699385643,
0.9529938697814941,
1.10320246219635,
-0.767243504524231,
-0.03944746404886246,
-0.10294530540704727,
0.07789020240306854,
-0.1644488424062729,
-0.12284483015537262,
0.29447615146636963,
-0.3371574282646179,
-0.5624665021896362,
0.4869496822357178,
0.501995861530304,
0.20549269020557404,
-0.010774177499115467,
-0.3140636682510376,
0.32209351658821106,
0.06643269956111908,
0.5988956093788147,
0.3774803578853607,
-0.610853910446167,
-0.13185890018939972,
-0.03774864971637726,
-0.00446616904810071,
0.3731829524040222,
0.6368530988693237,
-0.7668476104736328,
0.8221721649169922,
0.23200881481170654,
0.933502197265625,
0.551749587059021,
-0.13732369244098663,
0.30484482645988464,
-0.49038881063461304,
0.41224992275238037,
0.0638585239648819,
0.6750881671905518,
0.39126837253570557,
0.05257424712181091,
0.1662980020046234,
0.282945454120636,
-0.3076491057872772,
-0.807596743106842,
0.34631288051605225,
-1.2229700088500977,
-0.27976250648498535,
0.777832567691803,
0.042877424508333206,
-0.5055873394012451,
0.010064748115837574,
-0.7894361615180969,
-0.034402310848236084,
-0.012902792543172836,
0.2413858026266098,
-0.059651050716638565,
0.15789206326007843,
-0.3667462170124054,
-0.15080127120018005,
0.571547269821167,
0.44973450899124146,
-0.9244183897972107,
-0.3762558698654175,
0.2628408670425415,
0.49427857995033264,
0.08842399716377258,
0.5297785401344299,
-0.08539829403162003,
0.38389164209365845,
-0.09886743128299713,
0.06075689569115639,
-0.30419835448265076,
-0.31006544828414917,
-0.5102279782295227,
0.4161408841609955,
0.41052183508872986,
-0.6876927614212036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06150v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06150v1
|
Lost in Transcription: Identifying and Quantifying the Accuracy Biases of Automatic Speech Recognition Systems Against Disfluent Speech
| 2024-05-10T00:16:58 | 2024-05-10T00:16:58 |
Dena Mujtaba, Nihar R. Mahapatra, Megan Arney, J. Scott Yaruss, Hope Gerlach-Houck, Caryn Herring, Jia Bin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, eess.AS
|
Automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems, increasingly prevalent in
education, healthcare, employment, and mobile technology, face significant
challenges in inclusivity, particularly for the 80 million-strong global
community of people who stutter. These systems often fail to accurately
interpret speech patterns deviating from typical fluency, leading to critical
usability issues and misinterpretations. This study evaluates six leading ASRs,
analyzing their performance on both a real-world dataset of speech samples from
individuals who stutter and a synthetic dataset derived from the widely-used
LibriSpeech benchmark. The synthetic dataset, uniquely designed to incorporate
various stuttering events, enables an in-depth analysis of each ASR's handling
of disfluent speech. Our comprehensive assessment includes metrics such as word
error rate (WER), character error rate (CER), and semantic accuracy of the
transcripts. The results reveal a consistent and statistically significant
accuracy bias across all ASRs against disfluent speech, manifesting in
significant syntactical and semantic inaccuracies in transcriptions. These
findings highlight a critical gap in current ASR technologies, underscoring the
need for effective bias mitigation strategies. Addressing this bias is
imperative not only to improve the technology's usability for people who
stutter but also to ensure their equitable and inclusive participation in the
rapidly evolving digital landscape.
|
[
-0.14253750443458557,
-0.47393110394477844,
0.19892947375774384,
0.3948304355144501,
0.053735390305519104,
0.6203336715698242,
0.07443683594465256,
-0.3352256119251251,
0.16315528750419617,
0.009950078092515469,
-0.6000698804855347,
-0.11218537390232086,
-0.7863729000091553,
0.33123838901519775,
-1.0762414932250977,
0.7189652323722839,
0.11294960975646973,
0.485241174697876,
-0.11524830013513565,
-0.2614844739437103,
-0.6278647780418396,
-0.7028326988220215,
-0.30899640917778015,
-0.205745130777359,
0.1812661588191986,
0.3312569856643677,
0.6114670634269714,
0.47161269187927246,
0.3659003973007202,
0.28743448853492737,
-0.34084993600845337,
-0.10327066481113434,
-0.11238031834363937,
0.22468969225883484,
0.10945042967796326,
-0.04347827285528183,
-0.25481608510017395,
-0.23779535293579102,
0.9385753273963928,
0.7874879837036133,
0.0011360013158991933,
0.3012525737285614,
0.5194693207740784,
0.5753447413444519,
-0.4130764901638031,
-0.0928717777132988,
-0.4770011603832245,
0.2045455425977707,
-0.4817127585411072,
0.01604839786887169,
-0.0945984423160553,
-0.5597900748252869,
0.11182822287082672,
-0.3658210337162018,
0.5426106452941895,
-0.29793718457221985,
0.5253186821937561,
0.8658221960067749,
-0.29028359055519104,
-0.5316349864006042,
-0.8224903345108032,
0.3913813829421997,
-0.5724518895149231,
0.6779112815856934,
0.2510375380516052,
0.2479994148015976,
-0.26635119318962097,
-0.4362763464450836,
-0.623869776725769,
-0.04642975702881813,
0.1379278004169464,
0.04679166153073311,
-0.49002355337142944,
-0.07222333550453186,
0.4520603120326996,
0.38003069162368774,
-0.7996795773506165,
0.07589899003505707,
-0.48268353939056396,
-0.59755939245224,
0.4999193251132965,
-0.06213082745671272,
0.4909185767173767,
0.15023283660411835,
0.058229103684425354,
-0.12215080857276917,
-0.2689102590084076,
-0.031464241445064545,
0.4577092230319977,
0.37426406145095825,
0.05680769681930542,
0.5041916966438293,
-0.028485966846346855,
0.6207607388496399,
0.12119507044553757,
-0.20263350009918213,
0.33123061060905457,
-0.16013097763061523,
-0.16696958243846893,
0.46114808320999146,
0.5831634402275085,
-0.00256439414806664,
0.06539206951856613,
-0.16211816668510437,
-0.22524726390838623,
0.33572661876678467,
0.2180282175540924,
-0.13744083046913147,
-0.09557345509529114,
-0.002704325597733259,
-0.18721677362918854,
0.17471018433570862,
0.2826277017593384,
-0.7203900218009949,
-0.6223758459091187,
-0.23951834440231323,
0.5914896726608276,
-0.3521721661090851,
0.0004943642998114228,
-0.1168285459280014,
-0.5611368417739868,
-0.20611830055713654,
0.11211434006690979,
-0.527457058429718,
0.4514816701412201,
0.40041565895080566,
0.9882951378822327,
-0.20736823976039886,
-0.12172286212444305,
-0.47092896699905396,
-0.07268552482128143,
-0.15900054574012756,
0.4311513304710388,
-0.066451296210289,
-0.5678537487983704,
0.034862931817770004,
-0.14093002676963806,
-0.16155928373336792,
-0.7337371110916138,
0.8975468873977661,
-0.32907935976982117,
-0.23573236167430878,
-0.3103273808956146,
-0.42457011342048645,
-0.04094337299466133,
-0.22258657217025757,
-0.7829611301422119,
0.7265628576278687,
-0.025059649720788002,
-0.36767885088920593,
0.6138571500778198,
-0.6691830158233643,
-0.6327651143074036,
0.017666179686784744,
-0.3402177691459656,
-0.642166256904602,
0.31386396288871765,
0.03645507991313934,
0.04510320723056793,
-0.08434373140335083,
0.19484782218933105,
0.24701820313930511,
-0.5928966403007507,
0.6408916115760803,
-0.759864091873169,
0.8426798582077026,
0.17801277339458466,
-0.7455180287361145,
-0.15052764117717743,
-0.8831400871276855,
-0.048561837524175644,
-0.18317820131778717,
-0.4403860867023468,
-0.16803620755672455,
0.1005958840250969,
0.3030392527580261,
0.16387028992176056,
-0.21002012491226196,
-0.578557550907135,
-0.11609692871570587,
-0.2774001657962799,
0.5939357280731201,
0.5947871208190918,
-0.2573416531085968,
0.17850415408611298,
-0.35714781284332275,
0.4419947862625122,
0.06676694750785828,
0.32097795605659485,
0.06428612768650055,
-0.22432304918766022,
-0.7957707047462463,
-0.2159166783094406,
0.4957379400730133,
0.42109498381614685,
-0.5240532159805298,
0.3316255509853363,
-0.4459141492843628,
-0.3231126666069031,
-0.8552247285842896,
-0.03677304834127426,
0.8218697905540466,
0.6977670788764954,
0.4855383634567261,
-0.4624682068824768,
-0.7285743355751038,
-0.9049095511436462,
-0.5834946036338806,
-0.13292528688907623,
-0.39194750785827637,
-0.07465936243534088,
0.2743665874004364,
-0.3543694317340851,
0.8290435075759888,
0.19634823501110077,
-0.6090912818908691,
-0.029640305787324905,
0.0446973517537117,
-0.17566663026809692,
0.5185188055038452,
-0.08090651035308838,
-0.8617392182350159,
-0.37533435225486755,
-0.3223312199115753,
-0.2641313374042511,
-0.385372132062912,
-0.12471920251846313,
0.5912293195724487,
0.5721341967582703,
0.30713731050491333,
-0.10586372017860413,
0.8195971846580505,
0.5499455332756042,
-0.4574052691459656,
0.43836304545402527,
0.13746772706508636,
0.3221353590488434,
-0.36057305335998535,
0.22545455396175385,
-0.04143139719963074,
-0.14914143085479736,
-0.6988769173622131,
-0.47672563791275024,
0.05333169549703598,
0.1318952590227127,
-0.14545683562755585,
0.20669546723365784,
-0.4832390546798706,
-0.4639574885368347,
0.0753820389509201,
-0.007832708768546581,
-0.1166691854596138,
-0.03364044800400734,
-0.2773028612136841,
1.1454784870147705,
0.10973101854324341,
-0.6098839640617371,
-0.023352427408099174,
0.653610110282898,
-0.273801326751709,
0.4080999195575714,
-0.6360364556312561,
0.28473028540611267,
0.007828754372894764,
0.2217327058315277,
-0.7534849047660828,
-0.4141194820404053,
0.23770122230052948,
-0.8957579135894775,
0.36737674474716187,
-0.12885980308055878,
-0.4588598906993866,
-0.5517389178276062,
0.06012241914868355,
0.37686488032341003,
0.5739127397537231,
-0.26701614260673523,
0.41216641664505005,
0.7935105562210083,
-0.11605676263570786,
-0.6920313835144043,
-0.9292622804641724,
0.3498528003692627,
-0.2092469036579132,
-0.26208892464637756,
0.3826071619987488,
0.08371768891811371,
-0.3635525405406952,
-0.3453866243362427,
-0.5323426723480225,
-0.2648214101791382,
0.051468413323163986,
0.5292026996612549,
-0.015446406789124012,
0.13917528092861176,
0.09378471970558167,
0.041717786341905594,
-0.07675455510616302,
0.02112114056944847,
-0.1671288013458252,
0.5216580629348755,
-0.002936432370916009,
-0.6136568188667297,
-0.7985195517539978,
0.2595502734184265,
0.6259815692901611,
0.17882122099399567,
0.09633193165063858,
0.2822558581829071,
-0.41553792357444763,
-0.024701731279492378,
-0.8486536145210266,
-0.04308804124593735,
-0.37069621682167053,
0.21278607845306396,
-0.25771045684814453,
-0.6030139327049255,
0.6604499220848083,
0.4436921775341034,
-0.12891530990600586,
0.22144219279289246,
0.3178495466709137,
-0.0804310217499733,
0.8914941549301147,
0.3849168121814728,
-0.2051786482334137,
0.5586134195327759,
0.11239878088235855,
-0.05348944291472435,
-0.6432831287384033,
-0.36710914969444275,
-0.7554606199264526,
-0.3781490623950958,
-0.47237077355384827,
-0.355130672454834,
0.5470795035362244,
-0.32916733622550964,
-0.2006201297044754,
0.2583169639110565,
-0.827281653881073,
0.26254358887672424,
0.8550673127174377,
-0.026618584990501404,
0.5323520302772522,
0.004001809749752283,
0.1005716547369957,
-0.23625503480434418,
-0.6713897585868835,
-0.6659801006317139,
0.8281393647193909,
0.37699320912361145,
0.7225378155708313,
0.11074692755937576,
0.4208256006240845,
0.902345597743988,
-0.2015434354543686,
-0.6182080507278442,
0.1210368201136589,
-0.20102569460868835,
-0.6291571259498596,
-0.4794047772884369,
-0.3517957627773285,
-0.7537117004394531,
-0.10689401626586914,
0.12531132996082306,
-0.5436655879020691,
0.46606338024139404,
0.7388019561767578,
-0.5573355555534363,
0.06804043054580688,
-0.47868987917900085,
0.6902589201927185,
-0.24749240279197693,
-0.27189064025878906,
0.054972533136606216,
-0.8940151333808899,
0.05191919207572937,
-0.19694478809833527,
0.2486979067325592,
0.08030310273170471,
0.11358620971441269,
0.8221752047538757,
-0.18785160779953003,
0.6390349268913269,
-0.3710664212703705,
0.1276807188987732,
0.17378520965576172,
0.07961657643318176,
0.13954463601112366,
-0.39048686623573303,
-0.15119875967502594,
0.5934990048408508,
0.17992234230041504,
-0.13019785284996033,
-0.26094362139701843,
0.30001047253608704,
-0.6782063841819763,
-0.18126563727855682,
-0.7719755172729492,
-0.0855323001742363,
-0.2997962534427643,
0.025623977184295654,
0.47567984461784363,
0.5136188864707947,
-0.4401082396507263,
-0.05790606513619423,
0.6042719483375549,
-0.24816882610321045,
0.293186217546463,
0.3203413486480713,
0.21202941238880157,
-0.4821363389492035,
0.9198193550109863,
0.5483457446098328,
0.19642548263072968,
-0.08651406317949295,
-0.2005159705877304,
-0.4168931841850281,
-0.552208423614502,
-0.6675621271133423,
-0.11065734177827835,
-0.5897895693778992,
-0.2865130305290222,
-0.735279381275177,
-0.35570499300956726,
-0.6491416096687317,
0.01728290691971779,
-0.20671644806861877,
-0.4539315104484558,
-0.500090479850769,
0.030343985185027122,
0.1451503336429596,
0.6809386610984802,
-0.14394834637641907,
0.4193509817123413,
-0.6776638627052307,
0.28529584407806396,
0.0006174033624120057,
0.18708784878253937,
-0.19377882778644562,
-0.9622729420661926,
0.009103652089834213,
0.27952519059181213,
-0.4032311737537384,
-0.8714900016784668,
0.6013395190238953,
0.42545002698898315,
0.3834572732448578,
0.06678999960422516,
0.03753859922289848,
1.0522502660751343,
-0.5829964280128479,
0.6572823524475098,
0.1209409087896347,
-1.4852039813995361,
0.4630809426307678,
0.09643661975860596,
0.2081773728132248,
0.7278913855552673,
0.13082601130008698,
-0.9011764526367188,
-0.4702450633049011,
-0.5555511116981506,
-1.017646312713623,
0.5857395529747009,
0.21083997189998627,
-0.05257302150130272,
0.21784013509750366,
0.15245364606380463,
0.17154242098331451,
0.2870909869670868,
-0.5046113133430481,
-0.21151666343212128,
-0.41302672028541565,
-0.3790754973888397,
-0.05233577638864517,
-0.1389683336019516,
-0.04504106938838959,
-0.14273223280906677,
0.7342910170555115,
-0.06257084012031555,
0.17030225694179535,
0.6126872301101685,
-0.582320511341095,
-0.16192983090877533,
0.1552351415157318,
0.7226133346557617,
0.5084282755851746,
0.1319933533668518,
0.03017730638384819,
0.1327042579650879,
-0.7886931300163269,
0.3820725679397583,
0.261142760515213,
-0.38653987646102905,
0.43023011088371277,
0.2253391295671463,
0.5847266912460327,
0.11437191814184189,
-0.925743579864502,
0.5395691394805908,
-0.15794020891189575,
-0.0931982770562172,
-0.7478795051574707,
-0.07746358960866928,
-0.29524123668670654,
0.1398313045501709,
0.6806984543800354,
0.2905266582965851,
0.5959792137145996,
-0.2987232506275177,
0.3056173622608185,
0.4913769066333771,
-0.7671341300010681,
-0.26160579919815063,
0.7299473881721497,
0.20747491717338562,
-0.6283790469169617,
0.5220745205879211,
0.1715640127658844,
-0.5910483002662659,
0.5712305307388306,
0.3018021881580353,
0.9029731750488281,
-0.4438428282737732,
0.019515885040163994,
0.170614555478096,
0.4337826371192932,
-0.195267915725708,
-0.07478118687868118,
0.02397736720740795,
-0.44964638352394104,
-0.11537136882543564,
-0.5771512985229492,
-0.31375381350517273,
0.048469699919223785,
-0.8167324066162109,
0.2114449441432953,
-0.25036942958831787,
-0.5084372162818909,
0.20041906833648682,
-0.3079896867275238,
-0.6378875374794006,
0.08348672837018967,
0.1420573592185974,
0.7869887948036194,
-0.8041853904724121,
0.38682249188423157,
0.44910621643066406,
-0.5529485940933228,
-0.5095339417457581,
0.3895525634288788,
0.5697497725486755,
-0.6302865743637085,
0.6241252422332764,
0.15295420587062836,
-0.20330920815467834,
0.06965699791908264,
-0.021843913942575455,
-0.8845561146736145,
0.795131504535675,
0.4025769829750061,
-0.8930296301841736,
-0.07404272258281708,
0.41069886088371277,
0.5064958333969116,
0.20775702595710754,
0.11429694294929504,
0.890576958656311,
0.3263400197029114,
-0.0847153514623642,
-1.5723638534545898,
-0.11975208669900894,
-0.01577802747488022,
0.06440499424934387,
0.07091156393289566,
-0.5566645264625549,
0.4579859673976898,
0.138209730386734,
-0.6289280652999878,
-0.1390107423067093,
0.18528251349925995,
-0.016561906784772873,
0.5966212749481201,
0.47106534242630005,
0.2170921117067337,
0.7404743432998657,
-0.31924930214881897,
0.5178604125976562,
0.062458839267492294,
-0.1505606323480606,
0.9449906945228577,
-0.2819352149963379,
0.5137202739715576,
0.5624244213104248,
-0.2069818377494812,
0.12583239376544952,
0.28108859062194824,
0.20522017776966095,
0.22260312736034393,
0.4220905005931854,
-0.5210700035095215,
0.140986829996109,
-0.058838292956352234,
-0.1645517498254776,
0.48114168643951416,
0.4926764667034149,
-0.32111844420433044,
0.175203338265419,
0.2713242471218109,
-0.1957012563943863,
0.22670871019363403,
-0.16846676170825958,
1.2072131633758545,
-0.020913487300276756,
-0.42444974184036255,
0.5246307253837585,
-0.4487133324146271,
0.7667711973190308,
-0.41962930560112,
-0.021669242531061172,
-0.14660513401031494,
0.25567519664764404,
-0.25681132078170776,
-0.3738701641559601,
0.6230552196502686,
0.32069411873817444,
-0.29390132427215576,
-0.3396274745464325,
0.546096682548523,
-0.24377745389938354,
-0.4223075807094574,
0.13323719799518585,
0.40468522906303406,
0.25160276889801025,
-0.11596992611885071,
-0.5911712050437927,
0.684146523475647,
0.1293085664510727,
0.24741233885288239,
0.030312728136777878,
0.15283121168613434,
-0.1859731376171112,
0.7268242835998535,
0.4462681710720062,
0.22142741084098816,
0.2516375482082367,
0.003848779946565628,
0.7082270383834839,
-0.5154207348823547,
-0.2577119469642639,
-0.875702977180481,
0.6416468024253845,
-0.24180369079113007,
-0.3503083288669586,
0.8698503375053406,
0.6557512283325195,
0.8716904520988464,
0.03945071995258331,
0.9752031564712524,
-0.13309098780155182,
1.0505703687667847,
-0.21911010146141052,
0.9102872610092163,
-0.3632960617542267,
0.1710887998342514,
-0.5476818084716797,
-0.505198061466217,
-0.4256030023097992,
0.81061851978302,
0.003112946404144168,
-0.07357390969991684,
0.2271677553653717,
0.6489587426185608,
0.0997643917798996,
-0.15363037586212158,
0.3690283000469208,
0.12769752740859985,
0.23778948187828064,
0.08204765617847443,
0.8421857953071594,
-0.6252950429916382,
0.5476998090744019,
0.06109758839011192,
-0.430233359336853,
-0.42107677459716797,
-0.5657298564910889,
-0.26301392912864685,
-0.7981218099594116,
-0.35730424523353577,
-0.4230443835258484,
0.632017195224762,
0.9733152985572815,
0.4622650742530823,
-0.926942765712738,
-0.17680825293064117,
-0.14431172609329224,
0.01052760612219572,
-0.2548144459724426,
-0.19531512260437012,
0.17439311742782593,
-0.0769619271159172,
-0.755105197429657,
0.4405566155910492,
0.09988120198249817,
0.3882324993610382,
-0.05460432171821594,
0.052283529192209244,
0.29176411032676697,
-0.1091190055012703,
0.2891816794872284,
0.651615560054779,
-0.9364383220672607,
-0.1099584698677063,
0.006107151508331299,
0.027666831389069557,
-0.0278459545224905,
0.7268534898757935,
-0.8146583437919617,
0.48794180154800415,
0.16011454164981842,
0.64113849401474,
0.0884203240275383,
0.19447804987430573,
0.5922307968139648,
-0.7405565977096558,
-0.03045187145471573,
0.7690726518630981,
0.07392612844705582,
0.5203684568405151,
-0.15140298008918762,
0.3404718041419983,
0.17710693180561066,
-0.7271714210510254,
-1.3065173625946045,
-0.07224689424037933,
-0.6453062891960144,
0.07331473380327225,
0.9165843725204468,
0.14333182573318481,
0.1505022794008255,
-0.5922816395759583,
-0.22789709270000458,
0.6270379424095154,
-0.5795611143112183,
1.1387790441513062,
0.5649760365486145,
-0.17847974598407745,
0.14348158240318298,
-0.5945127606391907,
0.9422842264175415,
0.4532935321331024,
-0.38639548420906067,
0.3998528718948364,
1.068289041519165,
0.28669899702072144,
0.3249368369579315,
0.6166220307350159,
-0.09998631477355957,
0.28496119379997253,
0.07701650261878967,
0.16613732278347015,
0.09640953689813614,
-0.3022565245628357,
-0.8969323039054871,
-0.2829384207725525,
-0.032866884022951126,
-0.17656685411930084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06145v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06145v1
|
Reddit-Impacts: A Named Entity Recognition Dataset for Analyzing Clinical and Social Effects of Substance Use Derived from Social Media
| 2024-05-09T23:43:57 | 2024-05-09T23:43:57 |
Yao Ge, Sudeshna Das, Karen O'Connor, Mohammed Ali Al-Garadi, Graciela Gonzalez-Hernandez, Abeed Sarker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Substance use disorders (SUDs) are a growing concern globally, necessitating
enhanced understanding of the problem and its trends through data-driven
research. Social media are unique and important sources of information about
SUDs, particularly since the data in such sources are often generated by people
with lived experiences. In this paper, we introduce Reddit-Impacts, a
challenging Named Entity Recognition (NER) dataset curated from subreddits
dedicated to discussions on prescription and illicit opioids, as well as
medications for opioid use disorder. The dataset specifically concentrates on
the lesser-studied, yet critically important, aspects of substance use--its
clinical and social impacts. We collected data from chosen subreddits using the
publicly available Application Programming Interface for Reddit. We manually
annotated text spans representing clinical and social impacts reported by
people who also reported personal nonmedical use of substances including but
not limited to opioids, stimulants and benzodiazepines. Our objective is to
create a resource that can enable the development of systems that can
automatically detect clinical and social impacts of substance use from
text-based social media data. The successful development of such systems may
enable us to better understand how nonmedical use of substances affects
individual health and societal dynamics, aiding the development of effective
public health strategies. In addition to creating the annotated data set, we
applied several machine learning models to establish baseline performances.
Specifically, we experimented with transformer models like BERT, and RoBERTa,
one few-shot learning model DANN by leveraging the full training dataset, and
GPT-3.5 by using one-shot learning, for automatic NER of clinical and social
impacts. The dataset has been made available through the 2024 SMM4H shared
tasks.
|
[
-0.28673797845840454,
-0.6908145546913147,
0.6160179972648621,
0.16046462953090668,
-0.23466596007347107,
0.014900298789143562,
-0.15560004115104675,
-0.6690486669540405,
0.834497332572937,
0.6969862580299377,
-0.509232759475708,
-0.6936302185058594,
-1.0593273639678955,
0.35982546210289,
-0.41237661242485046,
1.157374382019043,
0.00860041193664074,
0.1867041289806366,
-0.0676795020699501,
-0.12126249074935913,
-0.6710520386695862,
-0.23683539032936096,
-0.49676617980003357,
0.017059985548257828,
1.1440956592559814,
0.3619498908519745,
0.24567881226539612,
-0.10572679340839386,
1.1139674186706543,
0.21307998895645142,
0.1587275117635727,
0.062344443053007126,
-0.7216454148292542,
-0.13297413289546967,
-0.4254031181335449,
0.08792223036289215,
-0.28237634897232056,
-0.17665907740592957,
0.3262370526790619,
0.5592175126075745,
-0.20492048561573029,
0.25833040475845337,
-0.016887729987502098,
0.38746178150177,
-0.6594299077987671,
-0.16588571667671204,
-0.5636454820632935,
-0.12544427812099457,
-0.18954382836818695,
-0.40641075372695923,
-0.01973537541925907,
-0.3264146149158478,
0.06993606686592102,
-0.6331459879875183,
0.04151943698525429,
-0.07275521755218506,
0.8137480616569519,
0.3849582374095917,
-0.43733513355255127,
-0.5321763753890991,
-0.7731074690818787,
0.5660959482192993,
-0.4247579872608185,
0.43117642402648926,
0.26842236518859863,
0.253349632024765,
-0.2533181607723236,
-0.7410920262336731,
-0.45317983627319336,
0.3132411241531372,
-0.48389771580696106,
-0.3956434726715088,
0.032417863607406616,
0.030833067372441292,
0.21981197595596313,
0.09849008917808533,
-0.262138307094574,
-0.20454558730125427,
-1.0391372442245483,
0.10966414958238602,
0.6797580122947693,
0.31710371375083923,
0.6230931282043457,
-0.45098552107810974,
-0.35876256227493286,
0.5823048949241638,
-0.6889687776565552,
-0.26129454374313354,
0.03584224358201027,
0.5078902244567871,
-0.23307915031909943,
0.7321525812149048,
0.0765470340847969,
0.34447652101516724,
-0.14203208684921265,
-0.13406576216220856,
0.28362131118774414,
-0.39788514375686646,
-0.0007586273131892085,
0.03584437817335129,
0.9100424647331238,
0.6195686459541321,
0.08180975168943405,
0.10746139287948608,
-0.010634677484631538,
-0.08202345669269562,
0.41518473625183105,
-0.9086708426475525,
-0.3760165572166443,
0.1268966645002365,
-0.49564242362976074,
-0.3877240717411041,
0.11647497862577438,
-0.6583262085914612,
-0.9962214231491089,
-0.4605976939201355,
0.4451234042644501,
-0.3053865432739258,
-0.3577421009540558,
-0.01039956882596016,
-0.21085534989833832,
-0.12924601137638092,
0.3571624755859375,
-0.7593066692352295,
0.6453576683998108,
0.6471146941184998,
0.9812396764755249,
-0.3607693314552307,
-0.11357734352350235,
-0.270201712846756,
0.02365959621965885,
0.012112362310290337,
0.9866142868995667,
-0.5832085013389587,
-0.43725496530532837,
-0.13846294581890106,
0.39405736327171326,
0.019255412742495537,
-0.7759158611297607,
0.519809901714325,
-0.3184466063976288,
-0.29585370421409607,
-0.5761678218841553,
-0.5495339035987854,
-0.14696690440177917,
-0.13795311748981476,
-0.7129183411598206,
0.47422555088996887,
-0.05100652202963829,
-0.9788737893104553,
0.5556216835975647,
-0.8266382813453674,
-0.68073570728302,
0.39607492089271545,
-0.19650743901729584,
-0.3091012239456177,
0.2485118955373764,
-0.10058101266622543,
0.4423789978027344,
-0.03546641394495964,
0.3795177936553955,
-0.4538835883140564,
-0.4738023281097412,
0.006190364249050617,
-0.0462578721344471,
0.6779810190200806,
-0.055520884692668915,
0.030056461691856384,
0.19239330291748047,
-0.8559606671333313,
-0.2896447479724884,
0.0870460495352745,
-0.19429683685302734,
-0.701444149017334,
0.0901045948266983,
0.42961061000823975,
0.07142939418554306,
-0.02830149419605732,
-0.6786845326423645,
-0.06698285788297653,
0.19125665724277496,
0.6292180418968201,
0.5949117541313171,
0.7276251912117004,
-0.08494485169649124,
-0.20876061916351318,
0.35634616017341614,
-0.04806187003850937,
0.19602946937084198,
0.23344704508781433,
-0.38365018367767334,
-0.09769608825445175,
-0.1889844834804535,
0.4304724633693695,
0.41974005103111267,
-0.6478443145751953,
0.16966597735881805,
-0.42936012148857117,
-0.530333399772644,
-0.32024455070495605,
0.09914322197437286,
-0.05396115407347679,
0.47640371322631836,
0.5976576209068298,
0.04494044557213783,
-0.8320291042327881,
-0.8863605260848999,
-0.5181372761726379,
0.30457380414009094,
-0.04016592353582382,
0.6483777165412903,
0.923517644405365,
-0.4802021384239197,
0.784300684928894,
-0.5853086113929749,
-0.8502261638641357,
-0.19195657968521118,
0.4143236577510834,
-0.08544577658176422,
0.09081317484378815,
0.24851280450820923,
-0.7687886357307434,
-0.6334717869758606,
-0.18397919833660126,
-0.5567278265953064,
-0.2982592284679413,
-0.038905054330825806,
-0.013876673765480518,
-0.3228016793727875,
0.35190892219543457,
-0.07463034242391586,
0.39037561416625977,
0.5272873640060425,
-0.25939854979515076,
0.3859928250312805,
0.11061897873878479,
0.24397778511047363,
-0.7946661114692688,
0.07253488153219223,
0.31507575511932373,
0.20785167813301086,
-0.5138827562332153,
-0.7368573546409607,
0.004746850114315748,
-0.1287851184606552,
-0.7168260216712952,
0.4121142327785492,
-0.3033398389816284,
-0.05915917456150055,
-0.029061956331133842,
-0.11296681314706802,
-0.11279848963022232,
-0.052206508815288544,
0.26346683502197266,
0.45490536093711853,
0.34839102625846863,
-0.40381669998168945,
0.24459056556224823,
0.0813971683382988,
-0.46468374133110046,
0.835036039352417,
-0.7410817742347717,
-0.11883269995450974,
-0.15166805684566498,
0.0009246248519048095,
-0.4338589310646057,
-0.6074731349945068,
0.5005636215209961,
-0.4617948532104492,
0.1025923416018486,
-0.21878962218761444,
-0.2814258337020874,
-0.2424287497997284,
-0.14337573945522308,
0.3018313944339752,
-0.04411592707037926,
-0.16568513214588165,
0.3571009039878845,
0.9823455214500427,
-0.13467305898666382,
-0.467246949672699,
-0.4671550989151001,
0.28142115473747253,
-0.2844575345516205,
-0.1888977289199829,
0.3869076073169708,
0.29546332359313965,
-0.24766358733177185,
0.4913631081581116,
0.23370008170604706,
0.03924807906150818,
-0.15423928201198578,
0.4571300148963928,
0.18524415791034698,
0.3319956958293915,
0.47163107991218567,
0.11099057644605637,
-0.13141345977783203,
0.24525149166584015,
0.4128613770008087,
0.30782783031463623,
-0.03367829695343971,
-0.16412198543548584,
-0.49643802642822266,
0.39913249015808105,
0.409930944442749,
-0.02431892789900303,
0.8173143863677979,
0.27486926317214966,
-0.7326996922492981,
-0.19037403166294098,
-0.2660178542137146,
-0.3313779830932617,
-0.4101932644844055,
0.2375095784664154,
-0.0323796272277832,
-0.5944069623947144,
0.29835423827171326,
-0.0037646645214408636,
-0.06438716500997543,
0.15431782603263855,
0.32802459597587585,
-0.22590862214565277,
0.6420023441314697,
0.18135447800159454,
0.305634468793869,
0.4518512487411499,
-0.23138925433158875,
0.2099146693944931,
-0.8071809411048889,
-0.15454426407814026,
0.10547273606061935,
-0.5417832136154175,
-0.48584651947021484,
-0.34549376368522644,
0.47763627767562866,
-0.4293932616710663,
0.02801492251455784,
0.3613906502723694,
-0.5594104528427124,
0.48154059052467346,
0.2076762318611145,
0.3653884828090668,
0.2924202084541321,
-0.13894197344779968,
0.5464573502540588,
-0.3490115702152252,
-0.18672890961170197,
-0.3821786940097809,
1.1923761367797852,
0.3069477677345276,
0.8081797957420349,
-0.18507671356201172,
0.6937896609306335,
0.6233563423156738,
0.7895364165306091,
-0.844990611076355,
0.4766649305820465,
-0.21984708309173584,
-0.4873071610927582,
0.018187370151281357,
-0.6164414286613464,
-0.9110906720161438,
-0.08623111248016357,
-0.5705664753913879,
-0.4731810390949249,
0.35566702485084534,
-0.16909955441951752,
-0.6650862693786621,
0.36158880591392517,
-0.5859520435333252,
0.7773832082748413,
-0.5216164588928223,
-0.21903157234191895,
-0.1786036640405655,
-0.4625275135040283,
0.22989268600940704,
-0.047523342072963715,
0.5253605246543884,
-0.3209877014160156,
-0.019964223727583885,
0.8532242774963379,
-0.474856972694397,
0.8837065696716309,
-0.3911170959472656,
0.0899103656411171,
0.3331000506877899,
-0.31510376930236816,
0.08473442494869232,
0.07039535790681839,
0.45349279046058655,
0.7011067867279053,
0.08135001361370087,
-0.01685771532356739,
-0.6484413146972656,
0.8088756203651428,
-0.5404469966888428,
-0.2044438123703003,
-0.29472094774246216,
-0.08554217219352722,
0.0943843275308609,
0.49967798590660095,
0.27910253405570984,
0.37125471234321594,
-0.26031407713890076,
0.1340542882680893,
0.3643079102039337,
-0.24750635027885437,
-0.17622362077236176,
0.4930815100669861,
-0.34279537200927734,
-0.7534748315811157,
1.0092192888259888,
0.7949705123901367,
-0.0565648153424263,
0.16238461434841156,
0.014911355450749397,
-0.17187005281448364,
-0.536786675453186,
-0.16084440052509308,
0.6022836565971375,
-0.37061676383018494,
-0.21597859263420105,
-0.7456049919128418,
-0.19738082587718964,
-0.4985005259513855,
0.021666334941983223,
-0.30429163575172424,
-0.09464696794748306,
-0.3459949195384979,
-0.2477712333202362,
0.3885687589645386,
1.1221637725830078,
-0.33865946531295776,
0.11402860283851624,
-0.8311110734939575,
0.4949002265930176,
0.23444634675979614,
0.8456065058708191,
-0.11741743981838226,
0.12921641767024994,
-0.25734269618988037,
-0.1476680040359497,
-0.10540001094341278,
-1.1588271856307983,
0.2007882297039032,
0.14862880110740662,
0.17835961282253265,
0.5634230375289917,
0.3894815742969513,
0.5041635632514954,
-0.4540424048900604,
0.35279232263565063,
0.09934546053409576,
-0.4176674485206604,
0.6338264346122742,
-0.4347240924835205,
-0.2934034466743469,
0.9301562309265137,
0.7195172905921936,
-1.0061500072479248,
0.20604346692562103,
-0.36638984084129333,
-0.8539344668388367,
0.5659606456756592,
0.38215261697769165,
0.03187725692987442,
-0.4367139935493469,
0.23595301806926727,
0.14966827630996704,
0.14452187716960907,
-0.3861519992351532,
-0.34087514877319336,
0.11562266200780869,
-0.07983564585447311,
0.3755989074707031,
-0.3826071321964264,
0.11091805249452591,
-0.29273179173469543,
0.8300302028656006,
0.4200294315814972,
0.017088770866394043,
0.20691624283790588,
-0.07102666795253754,
-0.07191673666238785,
0.11376867443323135,
0.3182510435581207,
0.38657936453819275,
-0.35835564136505127,
0.15707595646381378,
-0.00638675456866622,
-0.8111228942871094,
-0.09433262795209885,
-0.06800423562526703,
-0.3514985144138336,
0.14314144849777222,
0.15742440521717072,
0.5896632075309753,
0.42869916558265686,
-0.9302962422370911,
0.2759684920310974,
-0.24713748693466187,
-0.17279106378555298,
-0.6123201251029968,
-0.09383242577314377,
0.07232349365949631,
-0.040551263839006424,
0.22766317427158356,
-0.013720761984586716,
0.3549753725528717,
-0.4377002716064453,
0.44020986557006836,
0.1395484358072281,
-0.8016825914382935,
-0.3421836495399475,
0.4492863416671753,
0.43233242630958557,
-0.6822900176048279,
0.37031230330467224,
-0.1256762593984604,
-0.2654639482498169,
0.5166069865226746,
0.16615614295005798,
0.6526066064834595,
0.07203711569309235,
0.1836259365081787,
0.7520779967308044,
-0.03749397024512291,
0.06766530126333237,
0.24889162182807922,
0.13965646922588348,
-0.7142392992973328,
0.13820880651474,
-0.38672614097595215,
-0.27146115899086,
0.3357970714569092,
-0.6309801936149597,
0.8837733268737793,
-0.5652363896369934,
-0.6740990281105042,
0.39467549324035645,
-0.17025578022003174,
-0.3510465621948242,
-0.044676899909973145,
0.011971144936978817,
0.3275999426841736,
-0.8536918759346008,
0.23573037981987,
0.9291431307792664,
-0.37369099259376526,
-0.36153358221054077,
-0.1644095480442047,
0.2519184947013855,
-0.2618122696876526,
0.34538009762763977,
0.3522019684314728,
-0.28518104553222656,
0.04843728989362717,
-0.5447099208831787,
-0.802663266658783,
0.8530055284500122,
-0.2113528847694397,
-0.5066600441932678,
0.004007746931165457,
0.3890956938266754,
0.5772385001182556,
-0.3845396041870117,
-0.005034227855503559,
0.4547542333602905,
0.4343990385532379,
0.21386192739009857,
-0.6696606278419495,
0.10026639699935913,
-0.44678643345832825,
-0.07234293967485428,
0.48867326974868774,
-0.342804491519928,
0.5535667538642883,
-0.5556695461273193,
-0.6906125545501709,
-0.40510523319244385,
0.1671229749917984,
0.1712549477815628,
0.35372501611709595,
0.5530713796615601,
0.6641755700111389,
0.6079524755477905,
0.23788993060588837,
0.6192443370819092,
-0.2758314311504364,
0.6479366421699524,
1.2907346487045288,
-0.2759113311767578,
0.8423182368278503,
0.47290435433387756,
-0.24758397042751312,
0.5128856301307678,
0.4626094102859497,
-0.3117973506450653,
0.517334520816803,
0.17738719284534454,
-0.11919879913330078,
0.016582051292061806,
-0.4228832423686981,
-0.28083673119544983,
0.25202468037605286,
0.7944048047065735,
-0.7214599251747131,
-0.3125903606414795,
0.178641676902771,
0.0015725288540124893,
-0.11299572885036469,
-0.2453814446926117,
0.8729819655418396,
0.18213562667369843,
-0.19605012238025665,
0.2322835773229599,
-0.22050189971923828,
0.7624377608299255,
-0.22064274549484253,
-0.21954616904258728,
0.2993614673614502,
0.12709200382232666,
-0.6701262593269348,
-0.7385746240615845,
0.8148651719093323,
-0.05324437469244003,
-0.06078176200389862,
0.08077563345432281,
1.1096090078353882,
-0.38667386770248413,
-0.838997483253479,
0.4394388496875763,
0.27534225583076477,
0.22164493799209595,
-0.21497774124145508,
-0.38008782267570496,
0.06712592393159866,
-0.3332138955593109,
0.018144704401493073,
0.17133182287216187,
0.4360523819923401,
0.12124650925397873,
0.34819337725639343,
0.5572040677070618,
0.4969855844974518,
-0.29157888889312744,
0.12795178592205048,
0.4870583415031433,
-0.6213389039039612,
-0.14369414746761322,
-0.6489531993865967,
0.29477187991142273,
-0.20858892798423767,
-0.3683338463306427,
0.5195883512496948,
0.5129961967468262,
0.7161886692047119,
0.09623274952173233,
0.7777758836746216,
-0.38849514722824097,
1.0219701528549194,
0.11159641295671463,
1.1561744213104248,
-0.7036438584327698,
0.42334064841270447,
-0.3045073449611664,
-0.3633621335029602,
-0.37411460280418396,
0.45267289876937866,
-0.7047396898269653,
-0.06071104109287262,
0.36856314539909363,
0.5399587154388428,
0.1293633133172989,
0.1773119419813156,
-0.03532610088586807,
0.21310868859291077,
0.1929141730070114,
0.2980303466320038,
0.6864575147628784,
-0.48712003231048584,
0.37636059522628784,
-0.4715355932712555,
0.031678419560194016,
-0.22152547538280487,
-0.5114612579345703,
-0.793996274471283,
-0.4666942059993744,
-0.28812175989151,
-0.24789203703403473,
0.05529215559363365,
1.1066412925720215,
0.32212138175964355,
-0.8922713994979858,
0.19294586777687073,
-0.09380614012479782,
0.5500092506408691,
-0.017675254493951797,
-0.39775392413139343,
0.21506690979003906,
0.14208491146564484,
-0.49370506405830383,
-0.19991590082645416,
0.26800352334976196,
-0.13123734295368195,
-0.1925828903913498,
0.16409769654273987,
-0.2789645493030548,
-0.12874159216880798,
0.6203099489212036,
0.17126446962356567,
-0.39768874645233154,
-0.11811037361621857,
0.08583744615316391,
-0.03271811082959175,
0.13714899122714996,
0.9297751188278198,
-0.6050426959991455,
0.14390042424201965,
0.5084460973739624,
0.3481367528438568,
-0.02853516861796379,
0.15596994757652283,
0.15551595389842987,
-0.17776869237422943,
-0.6716567873954773,
0.4188801944255829,
0.37985485792160034,
0.32540085911750793,
-0.47228682041168213,
0.44524821639060974,
0.6239100098609924,
-0.3764488399028778,
-0.7984206080436707,
0.035890284925699234,
-0.5861696004867554,
-0.3394191563129425,
1.1530463695526123,
0.06886401027441025,
-0.17684854567050934,
-0.5907074213027954,
-0.3306240141391754,
-0.06514725089073181,
-0.7764416337013245,
1.0794599056243896,
0.5480148792266846,
-0.48139432072639465,
-0.41825070977211,
-0.7416489124298096,
0.36210957169532776,
-0.2565627694129944,
-0.7789314389228821,
0.18640978634357452,
0.5594907999038696,
0.6006534099578857,
0.19234375655651093,
0.863398015499115,
-0.18056538701057434,
-0.1539873331785202,
-0.03727283328771591,
0.05430212989449501,
-0.04061732813715935,
-0.26363080739974976,
-0.006398955825716257,
0.15704159438610077,
-0.7752798795700073,
0.046677276492118835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06134v1
|
Muting Whisper: A Universal Acoustic Adversarial Attack on Speech Foundation Models
| 2024-05-09T22:59:23 | 2024-05-09T22:59:23 |
Vyas Raina, Rao Ma, Charles McGhee, Kate Knill, Mark Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recent developments in large speech foundation models like Whisper have led
to their widespread use in many automatic speech recognition (ASR)
applications. These systems incorporate `special tokens' in their vocabulary,
such as $\texttt{<endoftext>}$, to guide their language generation process.
However, we demonstrate that these tokens can be exploited by adversarial
attacks to manipulate the model's behavior. We propose a simple yet effective
method to learn a universal acoustic realization of Whisper's
$\texttt{<endoftext>}$ token, which, when prepended to any speech signal,
encourages the model to ignore the speech and only transcribe the special
token, effectively `muting' the model. Our experiments demonstrate that the
same, universal 0.64-second adversarial audio segment can successfully mute a
target Whisper ASR model for over 97\% of speech samples. Moreover, we find
that this universal adversarial audio segment often transfers to new datasets
and tasks. Overall this work demonstrates the vulnerability of Whisper models
to `muting' adversarial attacks, where such attacks can pose both risks and
potential benefits in real-world settings: for example the attack can be used
to bypass speech moderation systems, or conversely the attack can also be used
to protect private speech data.
|
[
-0.17455050349235535,
-0.8917997479438782,
-0.1524873524904251,
0.03253624588251114,
-0.24042584002017975,
0.18974365293979645,
0.010429936461150646,
-0.5264189839363098,
0.31887415051460266,
0.7315176129341125,
-0.576453447341919,
-0.1857042759656906,
-0.7446107864379883,
-0.37855401635169983,
-0.9127097725868225,
1.1490410566329956,
0.567668616771698,
0.11934390664100647,
0.45749858021736145,
-0.1823718398809433,
-0.30355626344680786,
-0.7599198818206787,
-0.8575645089149475,
0.02166088856756687,
0.2103014588356018,
-0.1622040569782257,
0.8777291774749756,
0.47523370385169983,
0.2762128412723541,
0.33175867795944214,
-0.39847344160079956,
-0.1888865977525711,
-0.6603893637657166,
0.30746012926101685,
0.32631829380989075,
-0.43295449018478394,
-0.2939518988132477,
0.02191888354718685,
0.5773184299468994,
0.6233607530593872,
-0.2014314830303192,
-0.06125771626830101,
0.16007153689861298,
0.40884095430374146,
-0.5536714196205139,
-0.233916774392128,
-1.219827651977539,
0.12586736679077148,
-0.4382311701774597,
-0.07820166647434235,
-0.31355705857276917,
0.1792151778936386,
0.3984679579734802,
-0.6268392205238342,
0.28718098998069763,
-0.16294774413108826,
0.5841329097747803,
0.37281930446624756,
-0.1990990936756134,
-0.6179916262626648,
-0.7727671265602112,
0.6556008458137512,
-0.4550033211708069,
0.32133710384368896,
0.21695642173290253,
0.3194277286529541,
-0.23378412425518036,
-0.8978413343429565,
-0.4886128604412079,
-0.2534083425998688,
0.22311486303806305,
0.22436460852622986,
-0.769592821598053,
0.20224393904209137,
0.04888002201914787,
0.25945383310317993,
-0.39958256483078003,
-0.24589435756206512,
-0.5812126398086548,
-0.44083842635154724,
0.32746419310569763,
-0.09781600534915924,
0.42469632625579834,
-0.02645479328930378,
-0.6740814447402954,
-0.12279371172189713,
-0.8125266432762146,
0.1656143069267273,
0.6234270334243774,
0.532528281211853,
0.0644129291176796,
0.3350348174571991,
0.21702617406845093,
0.570475161075592,
0.0040621887892484665,
0.2174409180879593,
-0.1608908772468567,
-0.07145990431308746,
-0.3094698488712311,
0.31453457474708557,
0.8140867352485657,
0.07290466129779816,
0.25847917795181274,
-0.4633235037326813,
-0.25729185342788696,
0.26308557391166687,
0.26233339309692383,
-0.4824734926223755,
-0.24889184534549713,
0.015800444409251213,
-0.18548588454723358,
-0.566012442111969,
-0.09583906084299088,
-0.522691547870636,
-0.3016567826271057,
0.15692782402038574,
0.8211457133293152,
-0.36174651980400085,
-0.2768906056880951,
0.18416590988636017,
-0.3768622577190399,
0.022604312747716904,
-0.31353214383125305,
-0.8219473361968994,
0.5546307563781738,
0.6481452584266663,
0.7425772547721863,
0.13279816508293152,
-0.4279251992702484,
-0.9656630754470825,
0.36122116446495056,
-0.2542293071746826,
0.567166805267334,
-0.6019551753997803,
-1.116153597831726,
-0.13513246178627014,
-0.29687029123306274,
-0.19479168951511383,
-0.6019903421401978,
0.5766586065292358,
-0.3750094175338745,
0.13053679466247559,
-0.07671432197093964,
-0.4240478575229645,
-0.0477999672293663,
-0.045768674463033676,
-0.6797980070114136,
0.564207911491394,
-0.21955013275146484,
-0.5669912099838257,
0.11040939390659332,
-0.7649557590484619,
-0.5929927229881287,
-0.27870720624923706,
-0.10518337041139603,
-0.40549200773239136,
0.20446844398975372,
0.30114829540252686,
0.18378588557243347,
-0.06386465579271317,
0.09744209796190262,
-0.25131091475486755,
-0.3636925518512726,
0.6060144305229187,
-1.0286471843719482,
1.002875566482544,
0.10066048800945282,
-0.5374955534934998,
0.24073483049869537,
-0.6890866160392761,
-0.2125975340604782,
0.08248339593410492,
-0.042748887091875076,
-0.32108351588249207,
-0.23966084420681,
0.11218683421611786,
-0.11997082084417343,
-0.11501678079366684,
-0.5771709680557251,
-0.16232497990131378,
-0.6981052756309509,
0.6124473214149475,
0.8383761048316956,
0.04490208253264427,
0.3952382802963257,
-0.45889443159103394,
0.47668156027793884,
-0.2638063132762909,
0.39300450682640076,
-0.2989059388637543,
-0.4293506443500519,
-0.6063262224197388,
-0.5382001399993896,
0.49199235439300537,
0.2993790805339813,
-0.30005526542663574,
0.05563771352171898,
0.08224930614233017,
-0.5111190676689148,
-0.8879562020301819,
-0.16671675443649292,
0.757412850856781,
0.5417811274528503,
0.37809038162231445,
0.08463985472917557,
-0.4696580171585083,
-0.6341326832771301,
-0.5094189047813416,
-0.061778318136930466,
-0.10605984181165695,
0.22616825997829437,
0.173652783036232,
0.023573551326990128,
0.7553853988647461,
-0.41243425011634827,
-0.6510250568389893,
0.08346803486347198,
0.02408880740404129,
-0.10663820058107376,
0.5545353293418884,
0.6140915155410767,
-1.1481616497039795,
-0.34153038263320923,
-0.34127506613731384,
-0.47321757674217224,
0.047762610018253326,
-0.2534446716308594,
0.0429191030561924,
-0.29821786284446716,
0.46816426515579224,
-0.6665299534797668,
0.5438625812530518,
0.4906842112541199,
-0.3024003505706787,
0.6958778500556946,
0.11745292693376541,
-0.1156078428030014,
-0.8386884331703186,
-0.14520126581192017,
-0.4262616038322449,
-0.19678764045238495,
-0.9125748872756958,
0.2571023106575012,
-0.3070337772369385,
-0.5340779423713684,
-0.570587694644928,
0.5174331665039062,
-0.2628379762172699,
0.21680505573749542,
-0.33692774176597595,
-0.08083399385213852,
-0.006834725383669138,
0.34199926257133484,
-0.2669388949871063,
0.7825718522071838,
0.8479193449020386,
-0.5488357543945312,
0.4056369364261627,
0.25655433535575867,
0.17923203110694885,
0.46121081709861755,
-0.822263240814209,
0.3481598496437073,
0.2621972858905792,
0.2835056483745575,
-0.8121511936187744,
0.1975858509540558,
0.09895776212215424,
-1.0068957805633545,
0.5251161456108093,
-0.27741169929504395,
-0.20528662204742432,
0.047069404274225235,
-0.3519708812236786,
0.00671886932104826,
0.4116173982620239,
-0.7646675705909729,
0.7960965633392334,
0.7909567356109619,
-0.17277488112449646,
-0.707706093788147,
-0.694511353969574,
0.31958088278770447,
-0.343753457069397,
-0.5639894604682922,
0.44845616817474365,
-0.3225400447845459,
-0.1445416659116745,
0.0456542931497097,
-0.3268759250640869,
-0.030271446332335472,
0.31433025002479553,
0.44274163246154785,
0.1713799238204956,
-0.15251289308071136,
-0.24736428260803223,
-0.04977023974061012,
-0.4273100793361664,
0.1475965976715088,
-0.5349583625793457,
0.3987993001937866,
-0.047412604093551636,
-0.6491449475288391,
-0.43263721466064453,
0.7581743597984314,
0.7834457755088806,
-0.14773277938365936,
0.40170106291770935,
0.49027204513549805,
-0.558539867401123,
-0.2123136669397354,
-0.3835980296134949,
-0.33505716919898987,
-0.530073344707489,
0.4128442406654358,
-0.42634159326553345,
-0.7850212454795837,
0.5531997680664062,
0.07035472989082336,
0.21414117515087128,
0.28713855147361755,
0.26872187852859497,
-0.1037752702832222,
1.1597061157226562,
0.46058571338653564,
-0.47117817401885986,
0.3206126391887665,
-0.5072333812713623,
-0.1349918395280838,
-0.858198881149292,
-0.26272040605545044,
-0.5473930835723877,
-0.2047863006591797,
-0.05776399374008179,
-0.11989166587591171,
0.4152331054210663,
0.11132575571537018,
0.008743124082684517,
0.20660017430782318,
-0.5860975384712219,
0.5078737139701843,
0.6561095118522644,
-0.09793630987405777,
0.19186906516551971,
0.1477842479944229,
-0.2413031905889511,
-0.08924192190170288,
-0.38782447576522827,
-0.07824332267045975,
1.2174153327941895,
0.262114018201828,
0.7883946895599365,
0.2079542726278305,
0.5276983976364136,
0.43641942739486694,
0.048881739377975464,
-0.4818677008152008,
0.33095991611480713,
-0.6072343587875366,
-0.623487114906311,
-0.5341741442680359,
-0.2396126389503479,
-0.9294159412384033,
0.5028669238090515,
-0.1047329306602478,
-0.5259127020835876,
0.030611258000135422,
0.22843165695667267,
-0.3700818121433258,
0.5738534927368164,
-0.6351949572563171,
0.4811016619205475,
-0.04545094072818756,
0.26457640528678894,
-0.0880298987030983,
-0.4929081201553345,
0.053507015109062195,
-0.15994210541248322,
0.2111542820930481,
0.040522318333387375,
0.07675383985042572,
0.8777366280555725,
-0.40590736269950867,
1.0496126413345337,
-0.40930745005607605,
0.10818485170602798,
0.3282313644886017,
0.26536500453948975,
0.673025369644165,
-0.12521782517433167,
0.004936965182423592,
0.1437840312719345,
-0.13715225458145142,
-0.29538634419441223,
-0.6942541599273682,
0.5817763209342957,
-0.712268590927124,
-0.6863874793052673,
-0.21183086931705475,
-0.34652119874954224,
-0.29034510254859924,
-0.020346878096461296,
0.6154386401176453,
0.8149924874305725,
-0.4403420686721802,
0.18096372485160828,
0.5850425362586975,
0.3510611057281494,
0.2992149591445923,
0.6397627592086792,
-0.029612945392727852,
-0.5420047044754028,
1.2583496570587158,
0.17519305646419525,
0.45808151364326477,
0.2199379801750183,
0.35703223943710327,
-0.41715049743652344,
-0.6515289545059204,
-0.46807602047920227,
-0.15184791386127472,
-0.46048179268836975,
-0.2447172999382019,
-0.7500921487808228,
-0.4017200171947479,
-0.47152915596961975,
-0.2373632937669754,
-0.34175917506217957,
-0.5816170573234558,
-0.3767082989215851,
-0.16157890856266022,
0.3127362132072449,
0.6268165707588196,
-0.14565707743167877,
0.6494139432907104,
-0.7044172286987305,
0.3593912422657013,
0.7651230096817017,
-0.18400542438030243,
0.04443826898932457,
-0.7222622036933899,
0.08887390047311783,
0.16240571439266205,
-0.36354056000709534,
-0.913970410823822,
0.36058974266052246,
0.5115945935249329,
0.6371616125106812,
0.5638887286186218,
0.2243969738483429,
0.7612477540969849,
-0.5868861079216003,
0.6960284113883972,
0.4201643466949463,
-1.15646231174469,
0.32792335748672485,
-0.5506433248519897,
0.22927768528461456,
0.36240461468696594,
-0.11431384086608887,
-0.5563907623291016,
-0.7665132284164429,
-0.931999921798706,
-0.8767386674880981,
0.43291574716567993,
0.41880032420158386,
0.467652291059494,
0.14810816943645477,
0.08384129405021667,
-0.009522606618702412,
0.3264714777469635,
-0.5164644122123718,
-0.512745201587677,
-0.4850347936153412,
-0.13607633113861084,
0.16302035748958588,
-0.17450621724128723,
-0.3755905330181122,
0.13690140843391418,
0.6386027932167053,
0.02147052250802517,
0.07189048826694489,
0.08764689415693283,
-0.11744767427444458,
0.13368119299411774,
0.17249469459056854,
0.3525429368019104,
-0.0016277863178402185,
0.07130149751901627,
0.15738095343112946,
0.3176265060901642,
-0.6699286699295044,
0.10886573046445847,
0.2971004545688629,
-0.3779452443122864,
0.07410701364278793,
0.41959691047668457,
0.7511560320854187,
0.6667612791061401,
-0.5444435477256775,
0.7158024311065674,
-0.19008715450763702,
-0.19810964167118073,
-0.3988548815250397,
0.12040580809116364,
0.18278303742408752,
0.21124517917633057,
0.6288642287254333,
0.4719963073730469,
0.32216763496398926,
-0.4341523349285126,
0.44047462940216064,
0.8426821231842041,
-0.9610788226127625,
-0.4038274586200714,
0.8520642518997192,
0.24644529819488525,
-0.40532928705215454,
0.27921879291534424,
0.05127150937914848,
-0.8215200901031494,
0.5921266674995422,
0.880967915058136,
0.9593161344528198,
-0.6780856251716614,
-0.12593968212604523,
-0.3371487855911255,
0.3825117349624634,
0.33292749524116516,
0.11524616926908493,
-0.15799176692962646,
-0.4346371293067932,
-0.043205391615629196,
-0.5525137186050415,
-0.533872663974762,
0.1714988797903061,
-0.8722532987594604,
-0.04560963436961174,
-0.5160862803459167,
-0.1843366026878357,
0.23611292243003845,
-0.40799134969711304,
-0.40403521060943604,
0.19276532530784607,
0.1019781082868576,
0.7395921349525452,
-0.676616907119751,
0.6256985068321228,
0.269694060087204,
0.004250523168593645,
-0.685374915599823,
0.1809154599905014,
0.39305105805397034,
-0.9418396949768066,
0.35613617300987244,
0.008406599052250385,
-0.6415121555328369,
0.04452310502529144,
-0.3603343963623047,
-0.6801652908325195,
0.5998172163963318,
0.6090966463088989,
-0.2777242362499237,
-0.027393393218517303,
-0.026782087981700897,
0.20766255259513855,
-0.28522995114326477,
-0.08037838339805603,
0.38689330220222473,
0.1946728527545929,
0.12491452693939209,
-0.8517234921455383,
-0.10263469815254211,
-0.26879796385765076,
-0.456018328666687,
0.09950713068246841,
-0.7332825660705566,
0.825764000415802,
-0.21794728934764862,
-0.29170289635658264,
0.06576909869909286,
0.6938952207565308,
0.17179949581623077,
0.18068408966064453,
0.9033620953559875,
0.29876190423965454,
0.9645732045173645,
0.10371798276901245,
0.7592759132385254,
-0.15299108624458313,
0.03403129056096077,
0.923994779586792,
-0.18474455177783966,
0.8205443620681763,
0.13667166233062744,
-0.2825118899345398,
-0.07809725403785706,
0.05627603083848953,
0.037962015718221664,
0.7993277907371521,
0.27312910556793213,
-0.5835948586463928,
-0.03579561039805412,
-0.1257486343383789,
-0.4613564610481262,
0.6782312989234924,
0.5171254277229309,
0.12612523138523102,
0.03465712070465088,
0.41635990142822266,
0.3855575919151306,
0.08637404441833496,
-0.1906173974275589,
0.9237223863601685,
0.25634855031967163,
-0.10759539157152176,
0.47091737389564514,
-0.2236149162054062,
0.9461374282836914,
-1.081608772277832,
0.1774381697177887,
0.17801441252231598,
0.12268546223640442,
0.10801610350608826,
-0.2691751718521118,
0.3366093039512634,
0.03214500471949577,
-0.3997286558151245,
0.12555894255638123,
0.604787290096283,
-0.33328166604042053,
-0.5495731830596924,
0.6549955606460571,
0.10366984456777573,
0.024264730513095856,
-0.43895184993743896,
-0.8345166444778442,
0.0243271104991436,
0.22764626145362854,
-0.16017723083496094,
0.5234880447387695,
0.10306072980165482,
0.3356085419654846,
0.8712031245231628,
1.154470443725586,
0.5718881487846375,
0.22756747901439667,
0.2070094794034958,
0.9378341436386108,
-0.5294057130813599,
-0.9509521722793579,
-0.9075437188148499,
0.15570345520973206,
-0.035097476094961166,
-0.27655908465385437,
0.6372772455215454,
0.6589337587356567,
0.575104296207428,
0.32221177220344543,
0.9837006330490112,
0.44333991408348083,
0.7287909984588623,
-0.5595565438270569,
1.170955777168274,
-0.2533102035522461,
0.2432553619146347,
-0.22641342878341675,
-0.2707359194755554,
-0.18797136843204498,
0.2325008064508438,
0.2413206398487091,
-0.14453285932540894,
0.44546937942504883,
0.7970329523086548,
0.08097290992736816,
0.528037965297699,
0.4945979714393616,
0.3818046748638153,
0.5111448168754578,
0.2998877465724945,
0.820734441280365,
-0.3435170650482178,
1.2612123489379883,
-0.07890702784061432,
-0.22784405946731567,
0.06292889267206192,
-0.34101778268814087,
-0.8482619524002075,
-0.5767711400985718,
-0.08927109837532043,
-0.394972562789917,
0.47141388058662415,
0.5054592490196228,
0.9968458414077759,
-0.7821150422096252,
0.00013799828593619168,
0.31077274680137634,
-0.07239722460508347,
-0.3206919729709625,
-0.14149780571460724,
0.6575314402580261,
0.05357110872864723,
-0.5519062876701355,
1.0372653007507324,
0.16385960578918457,
0.30363768339157104,
-0.34725111722946167,
0.03867815062403679,
0.2585299611091614,
0.1087120845913887,
0.08757773041725159,
0.37649980187416077,
-0.7789589166641235,
-0.208908811211586,
0.10021185874938965,
0.23763075470924377,
-0.22103498876094818,
0.9810550808906555,
-0.83095383644104,
0.519764244556427,
-0.16740675270557404,
0.5216379761695862,
0.3332502841949463,
-0.22108852863311768,
0.6384243369102478,
-0.9629858136177063,
0.2592543661594391,
0.2554895579814911,
0.3467246890068054,
0.33827224373817444,
-0.47331419587135315,
0.06032918393611908,
0.3809732496738434,
-0.2312636524438858,
-1.086439847946167,
0.11931520700454712,
-0.6227584481239319,
-0.33103540539741516,
0.7471389174461365,
-0.15973658859729767,
-0.11043323576450348,
-0.33916398882865906,
-0.30247023701667786,
0.300396203994751,
-0.5364425182342529,
0.6213620901107788,
0.31330034136772156,
0.20057319104671478,
0.44875550270080566,
-0.48805925250053406,
0.5453236699104309,
0.3513200879096985,
-0.26573556661605835,
0.27244389057159424,
-0.08639764040708542,
0.34362125396728516,
0.16710373759269714,
0.7469354867935181,
-0.17419765889644623,
0.35291507840156555,
0.43033069372177124,
-0.44540315866470337,
-0.5083110928535461,
-0.36076685786247253,
-0.5417972803115845,
0.4777500033378601,
-0.3170316815376282,
-0.6686097979545593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06129v1
|
Narrative to Trajectory (N2T+): Extracting Routes of Life or Death from Human Trafficking Text Corpora
| 2024-05-09T22:21:40 | 2024-05-09T22:21:40 |
Saydeh N. Karabatis, Vandana P. Janeja
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Climate change and political unrest in certain regions of the world are
imposing extreme hardship on many communities and are forcing millions of
vulnerable populations to abandon their homelands and seek refuge in safer
lands. As international laws are not fully set to deal with the migration
crisis, people are relying on networks of exploiting smugglers to escape the
devastation in order to live in stability. During the smuggling journey,
migrants can become victims of human trafficking if they fail to pay the
smuggler and may be forced into coerced labor. Government agencies and
anti-trafficking organizations try to identify the trafficking routes based on
stories of survivors in order to gain knowledge and help prevent such crimes.
In this paper, we propose a system called Narrative to Trajectory (N2T+), which
extracts trajectories of trafficking routes. N2T+ uses Data Science and Natural
Language Processing techniques to analyze trafficking narratives, automatically
extract relevant location names, disambiguate possible name ambiguities, and
plot the trafficking route on a map. In a comparative evaluation we show that
the proposed multi-dimensional approach offers significantly higher geolocation
detection than other state of the art techniques.
|
[
0.13867543637752533,
-0.7619390487670898,
0.654988169670105,
-0.02348255179822445,
-0.38862064480781555,
0.4947349429130554,
0.24027982354164124,
-0.7994117736816406,
0.4422090947628021,
0.816285252571106,
-0.6987209916114807,
-0.6499907970428467,
-0.5532820820808411,
-0.08704738318920135,
-0.5942769646644592,
1.0134263038635254,
0.052599187940359116,
-0.46595433354377747,
0.05577325075864792,
-0.07362154871225357,
-0.591097891330719,
-0.4648282527923584,
-0.8722537159919739,
0.14678117632865906,
0.8679901361465454,
0.26411935687065125,
0.5687613487243652,
0.6876494884490967,
0.47403398156166077,
0.14380782842636108,
-0.04578505456447601,
0.2489478588104248,
-0.5360593795776367,
0.40254494547843933,
-0.3134513199329376,
-0.3514545261859894,
-0.21468231081962585,
-0.00947481207549572,
0.020594816654920578,
0.45527634024620056,
-0.08363797515630722,
0.10510078072547913,
-0.14833946526050568,
0.6559038758277893,
-0.46983179450035095,
-0.22459056973457336,
-0.04434711113572121,
0.01372234895825386,
-0.5744478106498718,
-0.6259693503379822,
-0.2524251639842987,
-0.9423553943634033,
0.48604926466941833,
-0.6213789582252502,
0.2778690755367279,
0.17624439299106598,
0.48102062940597534,
0.10187411308288574,
-0.8379418253898621,
-0.6435452699661255,
-0.914581298828125,
0.7279862761497498,
-0.01596621237695217,
0.07220407575368881,
0.2870975136756897,
0.5920563340187073,
-0.24123162031173706,
-0.6439433097839355,
-0.14523358643054962,
0.15822772681713104,
-0.2653893828392029,
0.061260368674993515,
-0.11556566506624222,
-0.37147271633148193,
-0.09109476208686829,
-0.24246931076049805,
-0.8473480939865112,
-0.09091585129499435,
-0.6250101327896118,
-0.41131317615509033,
0.7581108212471008,
0.5346753001213074,
0.6874914765357971,
-0.29835376143455505,
-0.675778865814209,
0.07330925762653351,
-0.7516829371452332,
0.2156168818473816,
0.8555763959884644,
0.4422466456890106,
-0.40486830472946167,
0.3634078800678253,
-0.16154985129833221,
0.46784883737564087,
-0.48493722081184387,
-0.3416629433631897,
0.2129134237766266,
-0.2421538084745407,
0.5484199523925781,
0.2514806091785431,
0.645436704158783,
0.7883437871932983,
0.14124134182929993,
-0.7098293900489807,
0.24785663187503815,
-0.18004067242145538,
0.3210779130458832,
-0.8305555582046509,
-0.07987959682941437,
0.2240877002477646,
-0.5783833265304565,
-0.37592440843582153,
-0.006354819517582655,
-1.582302451133728,
-0.6065866351127625,
0.00327488430775702,
-0.029550129547715187,
-0.37031275033950806,
-0.42194005846977234,
0.26739445328712463,
-0.4373512268066406,
0.623504638671875,
0.4493931829929352,
-0.6582622528076172,
0.027714084833860397,
0.6094846129417419,
1.553249716758728,
-0.49935978651046753,
0.04151415452361107,
-0.7082284688949585,
0.20050029456615448,
0.031110094860196114,
1.0681906938552856,
-0.4432702660560608,
-0.28659936785697937,
0.2930504083633423,
0.22167856991291046,
0.2061237394809723,
-0.06026496738195419,
0.7977633476257324,
-0.7184763550758362,
0.06892748177051544,
-0.46885108947753906,
-0.19714806973934174,
-0.5905106663703918,
0.36893370747566223,
-0.48622801899909973,
0.5559589862823486,
-0.039881788194179535,
-0.5435165166854858,
0.3147163689136505,
-0.6931899785995483,
-0.695213258266449,
0.05364001914858818,
0.26416778564453125,
-0.3296113908290863,
-0.2085113823413849,
-0.054595235735177994,
0.23846937716007233,
-0.21178695559501648,
0.29839372634887695,
-0.08464844524860382,
-0.482338011264801,
-0.4299636781215668,
-0.49247345328330994,
1.3027698993682861,
-0.040513623505830765,
-0.09102955460548401,
-0.1360464096069336,
-0.7546079754829407,
-0.3474857807159424,
0.24501413106918335,
-0.7293923497200012,
-0.2834884226322174,
0.3128260672092438,
0.3717990219593048,
0.10838323831558228,
0.13148565590381622,
-0.7237530946731567,
0.701772928237915,
-0.4483996629714966,
0.4263671636581421,
0.5349352955818176,
0.48534607887268066,
0.39571186900138855,
-0.12524615228176117,
0.7959694862365723,
-0.02972605638206005,
0.056549061089754105,
-0.1853030025959015,
-0.8189208507537842,
-0.40298426151275635,
0.5355254411697388,
-0.11510726064443588,
0.8323666453361511,
-0.7557817697525024,
0.04003757983446121,
-0.5200930237770081,
-0.5617701411247253,
0.04875160753726959,
-0.34912148118019104,
-0.0076237693428993225,
0.4885600507259369,
0.6300191879272461,
-0.06847250461578369,
-0.842961847782135,
-0.33097144961357117,
-0.2965090870857239,
-0.23481479287147522,
-0.014412904158234596,
-0.35066279768943787,
0.532653272151947,
-0.08580486476421356,
1.1177488565444946,
-0.6370363235473633,
-0.41517725586891174,
-0.35085830092430115,
0.060773737728595734,
-0.13355720043182373,
0.385085791349411,
0.5346279740333557,
-1.004162311553955,
-0.31488603353500366,
-0.12851372361183167,
-0.8694600462913513,
0.30880364775657654,
-0.33683842420578003,
-0.5760021209716797,
-0.08073042333126068,
0.23139847815036774,
-0.44074103236198425,
0.8528012633323669,
-0.05173144116997719,
-0.8169510960578918,
0.5697207450866699,
-0.3736211657524109,
-0.12594303488731384,
-0.789618730545044,
0.2645285725593567,
-0.022470541298389435,
-0.22128286957740784,
-0.7869922518730164,
-0.19257967174053192,
-0.184170663356781,
0.13406871259212494,
-0.4460550546646118,
0.4391234815120697,
-0.3280305862426758,
-0.11596635729074478,
-0.24084553122520447,
0.4305168092250824,
-0.13778850436210632,
0.2837686240673065,
0.2519560158252716,
0.49639466404914856,
0.30003827810287476,
-0.2220480889081955,
0.6035773754119873,
0.7441610097885132,
-0.23763932287693024,
0.6793373227119446,
-0.13553692400455475,
0.3260403573513031,
-0.292579710483551,
0.47790560126304626,
-0.7410269379615784,
-0.19138237833976746,
0.4868602752685547,
-0.38268643617630005,
-0.2060869336128235,
-0.49199792742729187,
-0.6443824768066406,
-0.10875632613897324,
-0.22128668427467346,
0.17348915338516235,
0.4298678934574127,
-0.1827044039964676,
0.5033554434776306,
0.4763141870498657,
0.18148696422576904,
-0.19831492006778717,
-0.6311398148536682,
0.6564531326293945,
-0.5479027628898621,
-0.5528137683868408,
0.10821177810430527,
0.05512857064604759,
0.12330499291419983,
-0.30080246925354004,
0.16835197806358337,
-0.12166296690702438,
0.3157310485839844,
0.5367000102996826,
0.3850870132446289,
0.02157987281680107,
-0.003469940274953842,
0.1594657003879547,
-0.7892804741859436,
0.33835360407829285,
-0.48110029101371765,
0.6080725789070129,
0.5324363708496094,
-0.044294364750385284,
-0.30733755230903625,
0.746286153793335,
0.5136375427246094,
-0.2983857989311218,
0.8168079257011414,
0.6650206446647644,
-0.21486422419548035,
0.3217955231666565,
-0.11994070559740067,
0.15584909915924072,
-0.376882404088974,
-0.06375439465045929,
0.10478218644857407,
-0.6418156027793884,
0.4912515878677368,
-0.41119882464408875,
0.09720485657453537,
0.40455362200737,
0.35767799615859985,
0.05059138685464859,
0.5616552829742432,
0.748661458492279,
-0.16470173001289368,
0.09420886635780334,
-0.3035934865474701,
0.6639286279678345,
-0.7735081911087036,
-0.7424643039703369,
-0.36704689264297485,
-0.6005669236183167,
-0.6388636231422424,
-0.2562214732170105,
0.5925142168998718,
-0.08680301159620285,
-0.15797829627990723,
0.6502942442893982,
-0.5007615685462952,
0.7054945230484009,
0.5138133764266968,
-0.05290950462222099,
0.6086458563804626,
0.220775306224823,
0.03753723204135895,
0.00170136580709368,
-0.23513434827327728,
-0.8357549905776978,
1.0061537027359009,
-0.2089201658964157,
0.29008948802948,
0.419587105512619,
0.42810526490211487,
0.37970975041389465,
0.060602352023124695,
-0.5303192734718323,
0.4442058205604553,
-0.057976432144641876,
-0.5742196440696716,
-0.2819688022136688,
-0.07530363649129868,
-1.3988492488861084,
-0.07098279893398285,
-0.20869238674640656,
-1.3098937273025513,
0.43502965569496155,
-0.42433395981788635,
-0.8855485320091248,
0.4776327311992645,
-0.300604909658432,
0.5855159163475037,
-0.32687297463417053,
-0.48954081535339355,
0.12906956672668457,
-1.3230310678482056,
-0.026403576135635376,
0.11962257325649261,
0.25185808539390564,
-0.25671908259391785,
-0.09350516647100449,
0.7581665515899658,
-0.3581598699092865,
0.8035258650779724,
-0.38906198740005493,
0.06121067330241203,
0.380402535200119,
0.4409351348876953,
0.6450839638710022,
-0.10259124636650085,
-0.26006993651390076,
0.18950554728507996,
-0.1414956897497177,
-0.22291024029254913,
-0.2987922728061676,
0.5603541731834412,
-0.3507738411426544,
-0.05846463143825531,
-0.21318157017230988,
-0.4815181493759155,
0.05992710962891579,
0.11030843108892441,
0.38027888536453247,
0.4563620686531067,
0.25035202503204346,
-0.08334440737962723,
0.11359652131795883,
-0.36420926451683044,
0.7611488699913025,
0.2840372622013092,
-0.05242375284433365,
-0.18492139875888824,
1.004374623298645,
0.33893245458602905,
-0.03750725835561752,
0.4571373164653778,
0.2814895808696747,
-0.4782335162162781,
-0.6458513140678406,
-0.6691320538520813,
-0.003699522465467453,
-0.5248951315879822,
-0.31541791558265686,
-0.8642726540565491,
-0.06667416542768478,
-0.18650442361831665,
-0.4397662878036499,
-0.1895422786474228,
-0.17694218456745148,
-0.2933580279350281,
-0.3739919364452362,
0.527737557888031,
0.7228592038154602,
-0.21667154133319855,
0.33025944232940674,
-0.7232616543769836,
0.31155312061309814,
-0.011866155080497265,
0.017342107370495796,
-0.06826841086149216,
-0.24222978949546814,
-0.36433517932891846,
0.04262062534689903,
-0.5955871939659119,
-1.151826024055481,
0.6520058512687683,
-0.18553829193115234,
0.17962093651294708,
0.4069277048110962,
0.27187132835388184,
0.9725303053855896,
-0.5063433647155762,
0.844641923904419,
0.08374089747667313,
-0.5758358836174011,
0.9583861827850342,
-0.6754924058914185,
-0.15514156222343445,
0.3885262906551361,
0.5643299221992493,
-0.8519178032875061,
-0.12018881738185883,
-0.1921195536851883,
-1.0532495975494385,
0.5712993144989014,
0.5426279902458191,
-0.0260647963732481,
0.19773341715335846,
0.5523698925971985,
0.15357305109500885,
0.011917991563677788,
-0.7290245890617371,
-0.3120783269405365,
0.06853190809488297,
-0.006585713010281324,
0.08751142770051956,
-0.44609564542770386,
0.24565880000591278,
-0.03791573643684387,
0.3658023178577423,
0.07853277027606964,
0.23497417569160461,
0.23644857108592987,
0.047380659729242325,
-0.18353013694286346,
-0.3000946342945099,
0.42265743017196655,
0.6168559193611145,
-0.11862765997648239,
0.17201480269432068,
-0.20761696994304657,
-0.6270691752433777,
0.6389645338058472,
-0.29015210270881653,
-0.3885865807533264,
-0.12637510895729065,
0.7451823949813843,
0.4301811158657074,
-0.12412744015455246,
-0.7040088772773743,
0.7571187019348145,
0.02510828711092472,
-0.0931207686662674,
-0.49227261543273926,
0.09419902414083481,
-0.011656401678919792,
0.5645399689674377,
0.4320872128009796,
0.25674837827682495,
0.4616628587245941,
-0.4227502644062042,
0.007129935082048178,
0.0518982894718647,
-0.47113877534866333,
-0.45790180563926697,
0.7404667139053345,
0.29855695366859436,
-0.8183428645133972,
0.7625762820243835,
-0.41848719120025635,
-0.5026079416275024,
0.48234546184539795,
0.26652994751930237,
0.767916738986969,
-0.21237939596176147,
0.47368207573890686,
0.4929944574832916,
0.5339975357055664,
-0.23108325898647308,
0.12706907093524933,
0.021250635385513306,
-0.5403150916099548,
-0.3377743363380432,
-0.5223672389984131,
0.07156853377819061,
-0.1370190978050232,
-0.6306678652763367,
0.3025582730770111,
-0.1675989180803299,
0.1702684611082077,
-0.53736811876297,
-0.037248026579618454,
-0.40636247396469116,
-0.1570657193660736,
0.24478679895401,
0.5756981372833252,
-0.865139365196228,
0.599661111831665,
0.3093357980251312,
-0.27245813608169556,
-0.5679145455360413,
0.30527445673942566,
0.43307313323020935,
-0.4240225851535797,
0.5087704062461853,
0.6340467929840088,
-0.25143688917160034,
0.04902077093720436,
-0.3967762589454651,
-1.1462345123291016,
1.26186203956604,
0.4753226637840271,
-0.39579087495803833,
-0.4201025664806366,
0.37130028009414673,
0.6674209833145142,
-0.28344032168388367,
0.03520163893699646,
0.895301878452301,
0.5863930583000183,
0.17830224335193634,
-0.36398330330848694,
0.09464560449123383,
0.025202881544828415,
-0.17360900342464447,
0.494099885225296,
-0.53824782371521,
0.4954705536365509,
-0.37065133452415466,
-0.6329907178878784,
0.30133941769599915,
-0.055925335735082626,
0.0364508219063282,
0.5631207823753357,
0.36886292695999146,
0.1600068062543869,
0.6474055051803589,
-0.13417163491249084,
0.9675654172897339,
0.12196411192417145,
0.5105271935462952,
0.9459816217422485,
-0.1808285117149353,
0.6598135232925415,
0.5848810076713562,
-0.18138203024864197,
0.9606099724769592,
0.5095076560974121,
0.19517360627651215,
0.7860240936279297,
0.1354491412639618,
-0.03324403241276741,
-0.349636435508728,
0.03936470299959183,
0.1240413561463356,
0.6914067268371582,
0.2504569888114929,
0.11148399114608765,
-0.6636795401573181,
0.3515675663948059,
0.1972200572490692,
-0.16725948452949524,
0.0792616605758667,
0.6098400950431824,
-0.2851572632789612,
-0.2756376564502716,
-0.12964825332164764,
-0.11045744270086288,
0.16358114778995514,
-0.3888629376888275,
-0.29630398750305176,
-0.29609429836273193,
-0.26712486147880554,
-0.2682735323905945,
-0.6793219447135925,
0.8529487252235413,
0.10165958106517792,
0.14448204636573792,
-0.43351876735687256,
0.60836261510849,
-0.21380198001861572,
-0.5060965418815613,
0.6766226887702942,
0.5028379559516907,
0.2523370385169983,
-0.3137330412864685,
-0.3906046748161316,
-0.055332258343696594,
0.10034237056970596,
-0.2453836053609848,
0.13705438375473022,
0.48123425245285034,
-0.08571776747703552,
0.9069740176200867,
1.0199388265609741,
0.20899896323680878,
0.018702128902077675,
-0.4641818702220917,
0.4956130385398865,
-0.9243759512901306,
-0.8093449473381042,
-1.2213705778121948,
0.7631212472915649,
-0.30802997946739197,
-0.1596897393465042,
0.6507776379585266,
0.6382588744163513,
0.30485275387763977,
0.26395177841186523,
0.5421964526176453,
-0.12065541744232178,
0.7389108538627625,
-0.5305209159851074,
0.6076403260231018,
-0.42624393105506897,
0.3983828127384186,
0.08963926136493683,
-0.6779532432556152,
-0.4239366352558136,
0.5184288024902344,
-0.3497640788555145,
-0.5033568739891052,
0.6352272033691406,
0.545817494392395,
0.018515389412641525,
-0.035421498119831085,
-0.0378594845533371,
-0.1604754775762558,
0.5999014973640442,
0.6356133222579956,
0.8711563944816589,
-0.5548023581504822,
0.769814133644104,
0.12778547406196594,
0.2493174970149994,
-0.4598653316497803,
-0.8774464130401611,
-0.6197789311408997,
-0.48445653915405273,
-0.2460450977087021,
-0.20740941166877747,
0.10994702577590942,
0.5791557431221008,
0.8616867065429688,
-0.3130267858505249,
-0.3579559326171875,
-0.21420444548130035,
0.3409254252910614,
0.02476407401263714,
-0.22559094429016113,
0.5306587815284729,
0.2518368363380432,
-0.2491006851196289,
0.48784902691841125,
0.7440339922904968,
0.09200873970985413,
-0.48644065856933594,
-0.03799770772457123,
-0.27653247117996216,
-0.2972981929779053,
0.5431044697761536,
-0.12518858909606934,
-0.4759880304336548,
-0.2851886749267578,
-0.33052316308021545,
0.2585499882698059,
0.1665324717760086,
1.124931812286377,
-0.8362310528755188,
0.3207041621208191,
0.3852717876434326,
0.4166873097419739,
0.3381979167461395,
-0.15684396028518677,
0.4150194227695465,
-0.6208739280700684,
0.24304263293743134,
0.1657179594039917,
0.07425970584154129,
0.1270689219236374,
-0.7669438719749451,
0.721346378326416,
0.526810884475708,
-0.47545671463012695,
-0.576974630355835,
0.11293484270572662,
-0.9829595685005188,
-0.09680936485528946,
1.0573700666427612,
-0.24887409806251526,
-0.3100793659687042,
-0.6306357383728027,
-0.3412220776081085,
0.2368624061346054,
-0.4627920389175415,
0.7469165921211243,
0.339615136384964,
-0.0358765572309494,
0.2513536810874939,
-1.064862608909607,
0.3037686049938202,
-0.4597318768501282,
-1.024098515510559,
-0.005725431721657515,
0.2586742043495178,
0.2142297923564911,
0.4080895781517029,
0.6321853399276733,
0.0516560934484005,
-0.09976871311664581,
-0.3314180076122284,
-0.2949557602405548,
0.11755029857158661,
-0.4895043671131134,
0.16139505803585052,
0.6483684182167053,
-0.8267725706100464,
-0.12363753467798233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06105v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06105v1
|
Can Perplexity Reflect Large Language Model's Ability in Long Text Understanding?
| 2024-05-09T21:15:49 | 2024-05-09T21:15:49 |
Yutong Hu, Quzhe Huang, Mingxu Tao, Chen Zhang, Yansong Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent studies have shown that Large Language Models (LLMs) have the
potential to process extremely long text. Many works only evaluate LLMs'
long-text processing ability on the language modeling task, with perplexity
(PPL) as the evaluation metric. However, in our study, we find that there is no
correlation between PPL and LLMs' long-text understanding ability. Besides, PPL
may only reflect the model's ability to model local information instead of
catching long-range dependency. Therefore, only using PPL to prove the model
could process long text is inappropriate. The local focus feature of PPL could
also explain some existing phenomena, such as the great extrapolation ability
of the position method ALiBi. When evaluating a model's ability in long text,
we might pay more attention to PPL's limitation and avoid overly relying on it.
|
[
-0.22900038957595825,
-0.7371559739112854,
1.0233910083770752,
0.5389450788497925,
-0.4833441376686096,
-0.12157653272151947,
-0.29317018389701843,
-0.7418347001075745,
0.09369920939207077,
0.6596255898475647,
-0.4191778600215912,
-0.3132387101650238,
-0.7110881209373474,
0.4132521450519562,
-0.5764787793159485,
0.988446056842804,
-0.0497388057410717,
-0.062119707465171814,
-0.19016200304031372,
-0.09352560341358185,
-0.11187826097011566,
-1.024604082107544,
-0.279331237077713,
-0.3811551630496979,
0.48670586943626404,
0.2888047695159912,
0.7979024648666382,
0.43034061789512634,
0.6684939861297607,
0.3976941406726837,
-0.5053134560585022,
-0.22840018570423126,
-0.608487606048584,
0.25355589389801025,
-0.29611736536026,
-0.7709193229675293,
-0.6879917979240417,
-0.050021253526210785,
1.1386865377426147,
0.9217919111251831,
0.19463969767093658,
-0.18914096057415009,
0.07073915004730225,
0.6654807329177856,
-0.32284101843833923,
-0.38894301652908325,
-0.6565786004066467,
0.16143082082271576,
-0.254407674074173,
-0.012139715254306793,
-0.30135995149612427,
0.11875182390213013,
0.5280613899230957,
-0.21475711464881897,
0.1931205540895462,
0.07673733681440353,
0.7897730469703674,
0.0032754717394709587,
-0.48026391863822937,
-0.17503371834754944,
-0.9489296078681946,
0.7024791240692139,
-1.0096144676208496,
0.13297194242477417,
0.34084752202033997,
0.23694463074207306,
-0.280862957239151,
-0.5079587697982788,
-0.941840648651123,
-0.37097159028053284,
-0.056485552340745926,
0.020716246217489243,
0.04216600954532623,
0.05538969114422798,
0.682368278503418,
0.5358973741531372,
-0.23494993150234222,
0.38953471183776855,
-0.058706678450107574,
0.014468376524746418,
0.6946553587913513,
0.4115073084831238,
0.12184835970401764,
-0.4343340992927551,
-0.7487235069274902,
0.19618099927902222,
-0.7603809833526611,
0.2598502039909363,
0.3501955270767212,
0.12339649349451065,
-0.14074616134166718,
0.6870951056480408,
-0.14114081859588623,
0.3699131906032562,
-0.19075922667980194,
-0.1853906810283661,
0.34245482087135315,
-0.2351497858762741,
-0.3883371651172638,
-0.089110367000103,
0.7409583330154419,
-0.018487825989723206,
0.1804947555065155,
-0.24224421381950378,
-0.3410198390483856,
-0.35276976227760315,
-0.016901789233088493,
-0.6190847158432007,
-0.007024765480309725,
0.2683274447917938,
-0.331225723028183,
0.029639100655913353,
0.2750368118286133,
-0.4879561960697174,
-0.7226664423942566,
-0.07797360420227051,
0.2028159648180008,
-0.25643229484558105,
-0.36888131499290466,
0.1720547378063202,
0.1004677563905716,
0.24609927833080292,
0.4363034665584564,
-0.5664138197898865,
0.18128255009651184,
0.7096642255783081,
0.725507915019989,
-0.404069185256958,
-0.7924486398696899,
-0.12894558906555176,
0.05233890563249588,
-0.09596951305866241,
0.9716646075248718,
-0.7501158714294434,
-0.37610629200935364,
0.0039473408833146095,
0.07250519841909409,
-0.07736219465732574,
-0.6239868402481079,
0.6493624448776245,
-0.5944072008132935,
0.0425756461918354,
-0.2258654087781906,
-0.6133994460105896,
-0.2592270076274872,
0.06136488914489746,
-0.5850985646247864,
0.4078989624977112,
-0.10074808448553085,
-0.9240923523902893,
0.09419272840023041,
-0.5384814143180847,
-0.49039480090141296,
-0.014662042260169983,
-0.22641119360923767,
-0.36814844608306885,
0.4034945070743561,
0.08973190933465958,
0.49678266048431396,
-0.29725757241249084,
0.2892204225063324,
-0.45624783635139465,
-0.3485545217990875,
0.7549939751625061,
-0.5806066393852234,
0.594042956829071,
-0.028727898374199867,
-0.342591255903244,
0.18812860548496246,
-0.5824806094169617,
-0.29611989855766296,
0.11340532451868057,
-0.6000727415084839,
-0.325018048286438,
0.17781709134578705,
0.007037078961730003,
0.35126417875289917,
0.28549978137016296,
-0.23612011969089508,
0.2730472981929779,
-0.596806526184082,
0.2554970681667328,
0.6767895817756653,
-0.2632372975349426,
0.444762259721756,
-0.20634682476520538,
0.8096310496330261,
0.2062215358018875,
-0.1463581919670105,
-0.2289678156375885,
-0.43727612495422363,
-0.8779866099357605,
-0.1302773505449295,
0.16285550594329834,
0.47559136152267456,
-0.5051659345626831,
0.4290703237056732,
-0.27002251148223877,
-0.10473277419805527,
-0.15206894278526306,
0.14662396907806396,
0.6160721778869629,
0.2366291731595993,
0.11340472102165222,
-0.4424368143081665,
-0.45763322710990906,
-1.0515273809432983,
-0.39304643869400024,
0.07917691022157669,
-0.24233900010585785,
0.32272589206695557,
0.5697401165962219,
-0.002479865914210677,
0.8706198930740356,
-0.33014267683029175,
-0.25367650389671326,
-0.4272216558456421,
0.20200735330581665,
0.5002649426460266,
0.2080727219581604,
0.22384193539619446,
-1.0445380210876465,
-0.29836374521255493,
-0.17223961651325226,
-0.8181735277175903,
-0.08476851880550385,
0.043452005833387375,
0.1531170755624771,
0.3892538547515869,
0.5012931227684021,
-0.6419558525085449,
0.5080294609069824,
0.49651312828063965,
-0.5531349778175354,
0.7584577202796936,
-0.405575692653656,
-0.0004017772735096514,
-0.872199296951294,
0.08207833766937256,
0.05559549853205681,
-0.17187072336673737,
-0.6827486753463745,
0.14901544153690338,
0.06595874577760696,
0.0459526889026165,
-0.34324389696121216,
0.46885451674461365,
-0.5183066725730896,
-0.1971079707145691,
-0.38308826088905334,
0.3026317358016968,
-0.10014817863702774,
0.16063624620437622,
0.21325023472309113,
0.514356791973114,
0.3498198986053467,
-0.48614421486854553,
0.35845401883125305,
0.0020007649436593056,
-0.6453773975372314,
0.35607388615608215,
-0.5178956985473633,
0.2586219310760498,
-0.13774842023849487,
0.33106565475463867,
-1.100939393043518,
-0.4004814028739929,
0.04494931921362877,
-0.2673528492450714,
0.34609484672546387,
0.12498945742845535,
-0.45368078351020813,
-0.33379122614860535,
-0.28118056058883667,
0.2938820719718933,
0.24744772911071777,
-0.30288469791412354,
0.4277722239494324,
0.21819789707660675,
-0.23839357495307922,
-0.5422089099884033,
-0.6855882406234741,
0.17779932916164398,
-0.33484700322151184,
-0.6951682567596436,
0.13705769181251526,
-0.1403467059135437,
-0.4329153597354889,
-0.28412318229675293,
-0.06049494817852974,
-0.11372312903404236,
0.1041458398103714,
0.28601720929145813,
0.16504330933094025,
-0.3190445899963379,
0.20951060950756073,
-0.2570362687110901,
0.002246533054858446,
0.16617436707019806,
0.06854677945375443,
0.45097050070762634,
-0.03526526689529419,
-0.38692712783813477,
-0.4367656409740448,
0.45986318588256836,
0.7980730533599854,
-0.11005835980176926,
0.688348650932312,
0.05542374029755592,
-0.2344980686903,
-0.04101630672812462,
-0.6740564703941345,
0.0060814437456429005,
-0.455975204706192,
0.7696962952613831,
-0.7726842761039734,
-1.1165236234664917,
0.8368809819221497,
0.06104915961623192,
-0.3382114768028259,
0.5309257507324219,
0.40729576349258423,
-0.07847720384597778,
1.1154232025146484,
0.9139096736907959,
-0.21235834062099457,
0.34079232811927795,
0.07332640886306763,
0.33235523104667664,
-1.067988634109497,
-0.15397527813911438,
-0.5811223983764648,
-0.30991098284721375,
-0.5019081830978394,
-0.250266969203949,
0.12000854313373566,
0.3445262908935547,
-0.17212612926959991,
-0.05519460141658783,
-0.18434560298919678,
0.5972720980644226,
0.02002893015742302,
0.04801904782652855,
0.6298325061798096,
0.17033030092716217,
-0.13981489837169647,
-0.21864190697669983,
-0.5564602613449097,
-0.472385436296463,
0.9843704104423523,
0.6951299905776978,
0.6605433821678162,
0.1475536823272705,
0.273762583732605,
-0.11346723884344101,
0.2963482737541199,
-0.6787086725234985,
0.69649738073349,
-0.36970797181129456,
-0.6274811625480652,
-0.5287656784057617,
-0.5815477967262268,
-0.9717415571212769,
0.2869322896003723,
-0.181117445230484,
-1.1477570533752441,
0.07387379556894302,
-0.25769928097724915,
-0.21516799926757812,
0.31813496351242065,
-0.6792635917663574,
0.5503348708152771,
-0.1998700648546219,
-0.19283944368362427,
-0.23575884103775024,
-0.5325120091438293,
0.45810139179229736,
-0.2443329393863678,
0.2596690058708191,
-0.009248277172446251,
-0.12179373949766159,
0.8295766711235046,
-0.32965442538261414,
0.6577593088150024,
0.03763116896152496,
-0.5072885155677795,
-0.006955208722501993,
0.07684096693992615,
0.5904898643493652,
-0.019430162385106087,
-0.20660500228405,
0.0960114523768425,
-0.4283321797847748,
-0.4131178557872772,
-0.6174964904785156,
0.8986818790435791,
-0.7311455011367798,
-1.2426273822784424,
-0.41470423340797424,
-0.7919169664382935,
-0.2540498971939087,
0.06228916347026825,
0.37263843417167664,
0.21106934547424316,
0.31819435954093933,
0.05075812339782715,
0.5380848050117493,
-0.264507532119751,
0.391425222158432,
0.6849655508995056,
-0.49701008200645447,
-0.0338265523314476,
0.7500790357589722,
0.3461715579032898,
0.3424944281578064,
0.4292285442352295,
0.2588854134082794,
-0.18471075594425201,
-1.0178704261779785,
-0.009972120635211468,
0.5036460161209106,
-0.7992639541625977,
0.2937673032283783,
-0.5351208448410034,
-0.25587591528892517,
-0.30735108256340027,
-0.015535159036517143,
-0.20907501876354218,
-0.26164349913597107,
-0.24752049148082733,
0.16239483654499054,
0.09894225746393204,
1.065948247909546,
0.4252007007598877,
0.136762335896492,
-0.7467931509017944,
0.15513241291046143,
0.20259760320186615,
0.4643023610115051,
0.19341591000556946,
-1.0647990703582764,
-0.252316951751709,
-0.15365006029605865,
-0.1106121763586998,
-0.7930598258972168,
0.21732456982135773,
-0.21081314980983734,
0.4823521077632904,
0.6333132982254028,
-0.06522118300199509,
0.5572741627693176,
-0.28179818391799927,
0.7513953447341919,
0.13537020981311798,
-1.093234896659851,
0.23991669714450836,
-0.4513428807258606,
0.6973161697387695,
0.22897708415985107,
0.5950916409492493,
-0.2957639992237091,
-0.6781956553459167,
-0.523841142654419,
-1.0468778610229492,
0.8299434185028076,
0.15829382836818695,
0.2693197727203369,
0.29038265347480774,
0.5730588436126709,
0.14007945358753204,
0.161680206656456,
-0.9168365001678467,
-0.14779630303382874,
0.23177731037139893,
0.2153303027153015,
-0.3030788004398346,
-0.7568025588989258,
0.008766572922468185,
-0.25992077589035034,
0.29501068592071533,
0.14026674628257751,
0.30464544892311096,
0.48729681968688965,
-0.1409546434879303,
-0.04135404899716377,
0.3262920677661896,
0.7304978370666504,
1.126774549484253,
-0.18452107906341553,
0.30443549156188965,
0.31914258003234863,
-0.575682520866394,
-0.0189985204488039,
0.18995735049247742,
0.18126873672008514,
-0.289842426776886,
0.6883779764175415,
0.6580342650413513,
0.19946753978729248,
-0.633841335773468,
0.41879042983055115,
0.07068291306495667,
-0.18515561521053314,
-0.31378185749053955,
-0.01180711854249239,
0.307853102684021,
0.6141895055770874,
0.6821293830871582,
-0.2873745262622833,
0.0004919722559861839,
-0.5820565223693848,
-0.08249735087156296,
0.39900386333465576,
-0.18442782759666443,
-0.4307534098625183,
0.4856991767883301,
0.17835669219493866,
-0.46284812688827515,
0.634681224822998,
-0.19108790159225464,
-0.8890575766563416,
0.841454803943634,
0.8516561388969421,
0.7637685537338257,
-0.38367465138435364,
-0.19104506075382233,
-0.0435580313205719,
0.12645074725151062,
0.054862186312675476,
0.12154781818389893,
0.09256896376609802,
-0.6315016746520996,
-0.7740837931632996,
-0.6798790693283081,
-0.4411483407020569,
0.5489202737808228,
-0.2906987965106964,
0.2169974148273468,
-0.5028561949729919,
0.05123065039515495,
0.2262708693742752,
0.015927277505397797,
-0.3930988609790802,
0.2289198338985443,
0.299274742603302,
0.804076075553894,
-0.6748666763305664,
1.1310844421386719,
0.8878673911094666,
-0.11569131165742874,
-0.7398354411125183,
0.44315096735954285,
-0.18581722676753998,
-0.44995424151420593,
0.9298698306083679,
0.38820841908454895,
-0.29529502987861633,
-0.3354579508304596,
-0.48275506496429443,
-0.7308982014656067,
0.7662701606750488,
0.4133339822292328,
-0.7376763224601746,
-0.07491911947727203,
0.23692035675048828,
0.6608902215957642,
-0.48073887825012207,
0.3258678913116455,
0.32520049810409546,
0.3930029273033142,
0.0019683402497321367,
-1.1681249141693115,
0.22869078814983368,
-0.3061957359313965,
0.16926713287830353,
0.13429050147533417,
-0.579762876033783,
1.129237174987793,
-0.3655679523944855,
-0.4624374210834503,
0.16220718622207642,
0.5621250867843628,
-0.012356900610029697,
0.29380854964256287,
0.5962690711021423,
0.4547809362411499,
0.6130737662315369,
0.25925952196121216,
1.271407961845398,
0.10035556554794312,
0.5390843152999878,
1.1494137048721313,
-0.5727624893188477,
1.0514888763427734,
0.43510565161705017,
-0.6456672549247742,
0.46912017464637756,
0.2552255392074585,
0.2802014946937561,
0.07200552523136139,
0.30810606479644775,
-0.3153632879257202,
-0.4475124180316925,
0.07783792167901993,
-0.32923686504364014,
0.46662637591362,
0.3609413206577301,
-0.5882512927055359,
-0.1389796882867813,
0.03354121744632721,
0.12931853532791138,
0.25279757380485535,
-0.22812142968177795,
0.5141788125038147,
0.2832249701023102,
-0.5831107497215271,
0.7480705976486206,
0.07366093248128891,
0.8476249575614929,
-0.557381272315979,
0.1991657316684723,
-0.23256123065948486,
0.21887175738811493,
-0.35111185908317566,
-1.0377362966537476,
0.24407361447811127,
-0.08243147283792496,
-0.39539262652397156,
0.19395829737186432,
0.8324775695800781,
-0.18008364737033844,
-0.31990304589271545,
0.5095832347869873,
0.39322030544281006,
0.33857420086860657,
-0.27524077892303467,
-0.3067961037158966,
-0.06943508237600327,
-0.01439734362065792,
-0.7179346084594727,
0.6357653141021729,
0.5899786353111267,
-0.038534652441740036,
0.7412540912628174,
0.5380135178565979,
0.11495303362607956,
-0.24658039212226868,
0.037016596645116806,
0.788515567779541,
-0.8585171699523926,
-0.3049740791320801,
-1.1451702117919922,
0.2624538540840149,
-0.20773600041866302,
-0.38970232009887695,
0.9310172200202942,
0.3125966787338257,
0.643610417842865,
0.1731342226266861,
0.8083009719848633,
0.2730586528778076,
0.43814268708229065,
-0.5700359344482422,
0.7695571780204773,
-0.4995676279067993,
0.5762225985527039,
-0.29695603251457214,
-1.0183123350143433,
-0.5753660202026367,
0.5627734065055847,
-1.0077484846115112,
0.06279578804969788,
0.9762982726097107,
0.5742318034172058,
0.049248017370700836,
0.2078193873167038,
0.4970610737800598,
0.7500478029251099,
-0.004378465935587883,
0.7914581298828125,
1.0882107019424438,
0.11434587836265564,
0.5122695565223694,
-0.07313798367977142,
-0.41454026103019714,
-0.3096815347671509,
-0.8865911364555359,
-1.0950720310211182,
-0.5516294240951538,
0.020839732140302658,
-0.39433830976486206,
-0.057063229382038116,
0.6149975061416626,
0.3455783426761627,
-0.6047158241271973,
-0.3431289792060852,
-0.10145632177591324,
0.4750007390975952,
0.16314485669136047,
-0.20274163782596588,
0.49551451206207275,
-0.16612710058689117,
-0.7646351456642151,
0.12762974202632904,
0.4330264627933502,
0.001845621969550848,
-0.49686750769615173,
0.013448785990476608,
-0.23705126345157623,
0.026072531938552856,
0.7259026169776917,
0.13579033315181732,
-0.7553845047950745,
-0.34685105085372925,
-0.10291014611721039,
-0.12720490992069244,
0.2614987790584564,
0.8942586779594421,
-0.6597838997840881,
0.4207654297351837,
0.4949292838573456,
0.33765387535095215,
0.34703710675239563,
-0.20030620694160461,
0.5315409302711487,
-0.21877138316631317,
0.18624691665172577,
0.09106902033090591,
0.3777281641960144,
0.2839289605617523,
-0.46438267827033997,
-0.01199901569634676,
0.1432233601808548,
-0.809063732624054,
-0.6718601584434509,
0.4918771982192993,
-0.7809228897094727,
-0.45810753107070923,
1.3794496059417725,
-0.5564938187599182,
-0.3274126350879669,
-0.26383176445961,
-0.20383979380130768,
0.0963115468621254,
-0.2279929369688034,
0.9213404655456543,
1.0018752813339233,
-0.27001482248306274,
-0.0739072933793068,
-0.6305454969406128,
0.12130317091941833,
0.7757357954978943,
-0.5864830017089844,
0.1919349879026413,
0.14736275374889374,
0.23283235728740692,
0.2612614333629608,
0.4912494421005249,
-0.028777141124010086,
0.08005914092063904,
-0.13913284242153168,
-0.41953516006469727,
0.1581149846315384,
-0.20011556148529053,
-0.6807962656021118,
0.3075421452522278,
0.5796759724617004,
0.42913109064102173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06093v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06093v1
|
Selective Fine-tuning on LLM-labeled Data May Reduce Reliance on Human Annotation: A Case Study Using Schedule-of-Event Table Detection
| 2024-05-09T20:45:58 | 2024-05-09T20:45:58 |
Bhawesh Kumar, Jonathan Amar, Eric Yang, Nan Li, Yugang Jia
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their efficacy across a broad
spectrum of tasks in healthcare applications. However, often LLMs need to be
fine-tuned on task-specific expert annotated data to achieve optimal
performance, which can be expensive and time consuming. In this study, we
fine-tune PaLM-2 with parameter efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) using noisy labels
obtained from gemini-pro 1.0 for the detection of Schedule-of-Event (SoE)
tables, which specify care plan in clinical trial protocols. We introduce a
filtering mechanism to select high-confidence labels for this table
classification task, thereby reducing the noise in the auto-generated labels.
We show that fine-tuned PaLM-2 with those labels achieves performance that
exceeds the gemini-pro 1.0 and other LLMs. Furthermore, its performance is
close to a PaLM-2 fine-tuned on labels obtained from non-expert annotators. Our
results show that leveraging LLM-generated labels through powerful models like
gemini-pro can potentially serve as a viable strategy for improving LLM
performance through fine-tuning in specialized tasks, particularly in domains
where expert annotations are scarce, expensive, or time-consuming to obtain.
|
[
-0.4090840518474579,
-0.5937900543212891,
0.48509934544563293,
-0.05883294343948364,
-0.6053969264030457,
-0.11884994059801102,
-0.2149677276611328,
-0.8315707445144653,
0.16968390345573425,
0.9101147055625916,
-0.5389471054077148,
-0.7662212252616882,
-0.786428689956665,
0.08676014840602875,
-0.002724197693169117,
1.4408940076828003,
-0.12203043699264526,
-0.16871492564678192,
0.1592922955751419,
-0.05528854951262474,
0.14566130936145782,
-0.3236459195613861,
-0.873010516166687,
-0.5555817484855652,
0.7508403658866882,
0.5672512650489807,
0.8291109204292297,
1.0739059448242188,
0.6862843632698059,
0.08547352254390717,
-0.15823745727539062,
0.5908154249191284,
-0.37978971004486084,
0.018665039911866188,
0.027418803423643112,
-0.4876466393470764,
-0.9261972904205322,
-0.004675656091421843,
0.25797268748283386,
0.4765908122062683,
0.08320751041173935,
0.40296196937561035,
0.16568933427333832,
0.6983761191368103,
-0.7532176971435547,
0.43630102276802063,
-0.7165260910987854,
0.2162589281797409,
-0.7025190591812134,
-0.28310224413871765,
-0.27590829133987427,
-0.17188109457492828,
-0.1204204112291336,
-0.7700132727622986,
0.20291920006275177,
0.11240808665752411,
0.9068480730056763,
0.5459474921226501,
0.0009958926821127534,
-0.005652986466884613,
-0.5506415367126465,
0.515914797782898,
-0.6293264031410217,
0.17485399544239044,
0.7595481276512146,
0.11152567714452744,
-0.3047798275947571,
-0.5533589720726013,
-0.3821065127849579,
-0.2814115583896637,
-0.02066604420542717,
0.07482101023197174,
0.11690495908260345,
0.3009852468967438,
0.3385904133319855,
-0.19151745736598969,
-0.3134394586086273,
0.6046077609062195,
-0.051040034741163254,
-0.31155988574028015,
0.7012771368026733,
0.03930634260177612,
0.08865434676408768,
0.20694999396800995,
-0.06778207421302795,
0.22823654115200043,
-0.7808120846748352,
-0.08256950229406357,
0.07798799127340317,
0.23655973374843597,
-0.03519483655691147,
0.2655191719532013,
-0.2908438444137573,
0.8334869146347046,
-0.0039092861115932465,
-0.4499993324279785,
-0.03263460844755173,
-0.07212452590465546,
-0.20123964548110962,
0.1688891351222992,
0.6497817039489746,
0.3801272511482239,
0.42581090331077576,
-0.2924758791923523,
-0.3177611231803894,
0.2419060468673706,
-0.06206798925995827,
-0.7715845108032227,
-0.7490536570549011,
0.01599116623401642,
-0.36025652289390564,
-0.31329646706581116,
-0.16707146167755127,
-0.28852495551109314,
-0.5433464050292969,
-0.3989982604980469,
0.22277775406837463,
-0.25067052245140076,
0.09507034718990326,
0.04460584744811058,
0.07442157715559006,
-0.21571770310401917,
0.5300843715667725,
-0.867287814617157,
0.33091169595718384,
0.7254803776741028,
0.5148000717163086,
-0.4164997637271881,
0.17570318281650543,
-0.9571971297264099,
0.35757938027381897,
-0.3940716087818146,
0.9079490900039673,
-0.5304151773452759,
-0.3909094035625458,
-0.30923768877983093,
-0.2264259308576584,
0.037089139223098755,
-0.869127094745636,
0.7907798886299133,
-0.46233439445495605,
-0.4717944860458374,
-0.36515945196151733,
-0.39692431688308716,
0.32815316319465637,
0.13596081733703613,
-0.3766965866088867,
0.9216368198394775,
0.11806116253137589,
-0.4888508915901184,
0.9815672636032104,
-0.506157398223877,
-0.6449745297431946,
0.21433314681053162,
-0.4280642569065094,
-0.9140482544898987,
-0.06225321814417839,
0.5169105529785156,
0.6103502511978149,
-0.27848559617996216,
0.3631143867969513,
-0.31892499327659607,
-0.45742523670196533,
0.29015225172042847,
-0.10836821794509888,
0.1501981019973755,
0.3209938704967499,
-0.4731251299381256,
0.24302196502685547,
-0.8899286389350891,
0.014673245139420033,
-0.24712862074375153,
-0.5626445412635803,
-0.0688987597823143,
0.28135043382644653,
0.26752933859825134,
0.14877057075500488,
0.14616325497627258,
-0.5073280930519104,
0.27939698100090027,
-0.5043529272079468,
0.33756038546562195,
0.4766272008419037,
-0.057540494948625565,
0.27464762330055237,
-0.4911153316497803,
0.2434799075126648,
0.21965841948986053,
0.4662308990955353,
0.25937753915786743,
-0.4787372946739197,
-0.7519376277923584,
-0.5808755159378052,
0.42145442962646484,
0.41199108958244324,
-0.5490798354148865,
0.522928774356842,
-0.05598389357328415,
-0.5438797473907471,
-0.5240600109100342,
0.38785794377326965,
0.5266512036323547,
0.668096125125885,
0.6122902631759644,
-0.2901815176010132,
-0.3733759820461273,
-1.206012487411499,
-0.45695415139198303,
0.1383482813835144,
-0.036118146032094955,
0.5387036204338074,
0.18258316814899445,
-0.060432352125644684,
0.6340556740760803,
-0.4911317825317383,
-0.5781576037406921,
-0.13238944113254547,
0.22084864974021912,
0.15460728108882904,
0.3810553252696991,
0.39327651262283325,
-0.48416492342948914,
-0.7558461427688599,
0.0919514074921608,
-0.1792610138654709,
-0.4398677349090576,
-0.17992961406707764,
0.02528446540236473,
0.4339997470378876,
0.5218038558959961,
-0.2047782838344574,
0.5159505009651184,
0.11941809952259064,
-0.25534749031066895,
0.27495089173316956,
-0.40571314096450806,
-0.08157481253147125,
-0.36364224553108215,
0.10662668943405151,
0.1660744696855545,
-0.22023463249206543,
-0.363559752702713,
-0.385306715965271,
0.34160712361335754,
0.31131336092948914,
-0.2423313856124878,
0.5125876665115356,
-0.4063631296157837,
0.22725501656532288,
-0.5436270833015442,
0.0752316266298294,
-0.10575327277183533,
0.2931042015552521,
0.21684762835502625,
0.6220324039459229,
0.4988980293273926,
-0.8172998428344727,
-0.48239248991012573,
0.11231404542922974,
-0.35964423418045044,
0.2464284747838974,
-0.38903021812438965,
0.10796613246202469,
-0.14528773725032806,
0.189614400267601,
-0.8813995122909546,
-0.2549087703227997,
0.4935539960861206,
0.04616328328847885,
0.6274691820144653,
-0.260700523853302,
-0.7219573259353638,
-0.2617718279361725,
-0.14599081873893738,
-0.1300043910741806,
0.49555644392967224,
-0.4441206157207489,
0.2667565643787384,
0.5433744788169861,
-0.1340702921152115,
-0.31856080889701843,
-0.6229879260063171,
-0.030603429302573204,
-0.009327379055321217,
-0.2066434919834137,
0.7936410903930664,
0.35564592480659485,
0.07516518235206604,
-0.4728582799434662,
-0.5733436346054077,
0.09722211956977844,
0.1781086027622223,
0.5079794526100159,
0.3094956576824188,
0.0770607516169548,
0.15768539905548096,
0.5498975515365601,
-0.3151080012321472,
0.019844990223646164,
-0.19856400787830353,
0.28288760781288147,
0.38763925433158875,
-0.16558769345283508,
-0.8507826328277588,
-0.06651663035154343,
0.45025354623794556,
-0.338548868894577,
0.6584835052490234,
0.8718465566635132,
-0.2923232316970825,
-0.10804512351751328,
-0.7356275320053101,
-0.5303448438644409,
-0.47514450550079346,
0.3264390230178833,
-0.36564069986343384,
-0.7933154702186584,
0.4083172082901001,
-0.2705918848514557,
0.16792887449264526,
0.44080695509910583,
0.3947528898715973,
-0.3476705253124237,
0.9500306248664856,
0.19191265106201172,
-0.23491762578487396,
0.46614107489585876,
-0.09558988362550735,
-0.16482608020305634,
-0.8811085224151611,
-0.28284752368927,
-0.6682044267654419,
-0.7309425473213196,
-0.4702341854572296,
-0.3431072235107422,
0.7392765283584595,
0.12215080112218857,
-0.304718941450119,
0.00720909284427762,
-0.8569402098655701,
0.3889399766921997,
0.5529704689979553,
0.7056179046630859,
0.32256197929382324,
-0.05897265300154686,
0.14743006229400635,
-0.09870151430368423,
-0.6895878911018372,
-0.7320712208747864,
1.0876617431640625,
0.24678972363471985,
0.6339826583862305,
-0.2261139154434204,
0.8066115379333496,
0.12189092487096786,
0.6052280068397522,
-0.3103165328502655,
0.5160232186317444,
-0.5730113387107849,
-0.43389785289764404,
-0.2579013407230377,
-0.1246289536356926,
-1.1040892601013184,
-0.052187107503414154,
-0.6049160957336426,
-1.023149847984314,
0.16711759567260742,
0.5611546635627747,
-0.6685613393783569,
0.12471884489059448,
-0.5173933506011963,
0.7191802263259888,
-0.22370846569538116,
-0.4185742735862732,
-0.18198345601558685,
-0.6223120093345642,
-0.17361360788345337,
-0.12176213413476944,
0.15786051750183105,
-0.5198253393173218,
-0.2455916702747345,
1.0196506977081299,
-0.49378782510757446,
1.0392813682556152,
-0.264210045337677,
-0.023728007450699806,
0.26584726572036743,
0.1081802099943161,
1.0200947523117065,
0.2889659106731415,
-0.22470198571681976,
0.050044022500514984,
0.07889995723962784,
-0.18822909891605377,
-0.19839569926261902,
0.6744499802589417,
-0.9183515906333923,
-0.5348195433616638,
-0.1109631136059761,
-0.43628212809562683,
-0.39344522356987,
0.057355187833309174,
0.4225465655326843,
0.1283533126115799,
0.3065151274204254,
-0.1260727345943451,
0.6584911346435547,
-0.10078059136867523,
0.20223338901996613,
0.7744803428649902,
0.17737527191638947,
-0.13272948563098907,
0.7360365986824036,
0.5038865208625793,
-0.08869941532611847,
0.5532577037811279,
0.17050839960575104,
-0.2045321762561798,
-1.0311250686645508,
-0.3309978246688843,
0.11973907053470612,
-0.23298661410808563,
-0.26573702692985535,
-0.7832192778587341,
0.07724972814321518,
-0.1590564101934433,
-0.14878590404987335,
-0.41923820972442627,
-0.4569058418273926,
-0.8283480405807495,
0.08347766846418381,
0.5647726655006409,
0.22151103615760803,
0.11147686839103699,
0.6442363262176514,
-0.719473659992218,
0.41282975673675537,
-0.1147400513291359,
0.4351751506328583,
-0.4338400065898895,
-0.6690142154693604,
-0.14366835355758667,
-0.24163684248924255,
-0.4715477526187897,
-0.8174031972885132,
0.1801876723766327,
0.4483175277709961,
0.48121458292007446,
0.3209477365016937,
0.28619927167892456,
0.6543100476264954,
-0.14933285117149353,
0.3110264539718628,
0.07838448882102966,
-0.7503539323806763,
0.8474820256233215,
-0.45110687613487244,
0.24381709098815918,
0.7318302989006042,
0.08743686228990555,
0.04952375590801239,
-0.47684794664382935,
-0.5046834349632263,
-0.9415885210037231,
0.8962205052375793,
0.03546890988945961,
-0.3488830327987671,
0.10271629691123962,
0.9235049486160278,
0.2192401885986328,
0.12512221932411194,
-0.4046509563922882,
-0.28539273142814636,
0.5281365513801575,
-0.052291110157966614,
-0.10354256629943848,
-0.3615040183067322,
-0.17645777761936188,
-0.35583627223968506,
0.4692229628562927,
-0.09937966614961624,
-0.1903679519891739,
0.26410624384880066,
0.17103493213653564,
-0.49181514978408813,
0.18499056994915009,
0.37759438157081604,
0.44248107075691223,
-0.14513781666755676,
0.02112690359354019,
0.2899013161659241,
-0.48043444752693176,
-0.26301491260528564,
0.34534767270088196,
-0.43933790922164917,
-0.1238912045955658,
0.2653195559978485,
0.8360285758972168,
0.20878548920154572,
-0.5364019870758057,
-0.01801508292555809,
0.39169538021087646,
-0.17178282141685486,
0.05282729119062424,
0.7935607433319092,
0.02411751076579094,
0.2516542375087738,
0.03810542821884155,
0.2508527338504791,
0.3735750615596771,
-0.29706719517707825,
0.20554031431674957,
0.34060588479042053,
-0.32585009932518005,
-0.02749376744031906,
0.9770218729972839,
0.18949539959430695,
-0.42289483547210693,
0.4547419548034668,
-0.10812752693891525,
-0.13493525981903076,
0.6885383725166321,
0.30099231004714966,
0.266337513923645,
-0.01836906559765339,
0.09493273496627808,
0.21296614408493042,
0.290751576423645,
-0.048897452652454376,
0.7007879614830017,
-0.17384476959705353,
-0.5560893416404724,
-0.44072285294532776,
-0.6086018085479736,
-0.46215593814849854,
0.17694520950317383,
-0.6509827971458435,
0.30694642663002014,
-0.5580726265907288,
-0.693548858165741,
0.5649219155311584,
0.03469562903046608,
-0.8402868509292603,
0.3606557846069336,
0.29507553577423096,
0.840294361114502,
-0.6444579362869263,
1.1014604568481445,
0.7467000484466553,
0.1906185746192932,
-0.8843035101890564,
-0.1821022927761078,
-0.14572732150554657,
-0.6125895380973816,
0.6269741654396057,
-0.002272118115797639,
0.1985815018415451,
-0.08310682326555252,
-0.2212882936000824,
-0.683744490146637,
0.9168986082077026,
0.5310173630714417,
-1.3342028856277466,
0.34899210929870605,
0.2911807894706726,
0.7016047239303589,
0.041733622550964355,
0.08940489590167999,
1.0174297094345093,
0.7827967405319214,
-0.11407384276390076,
-1.3393430709838867,
0.0002273451682412997,
0.14975066483020782,
-0.225961372256279,
0.5109474062919617,
-0.5842669010162354,
0.4202841818332672,
-0.3622530698776245,
0.15730135142803192,
-0.22864355146884918,
0.41683703660964966,
0.5341997742652893,
0.6659094095230103,
0.27271968126296997,
0.2540781497955322,
0.8606793880462646,
-0.4019373059272766,
0.8062874674797058,
-0.395109623670578,
0.008947831578552723,
1.200158715248108,
-0.4058375954627991,
0.7421668171882629,
0.5466277599334717,
-0.3711511194705963,
-0.13900302350521088,
0.7399568557739258,
0.003997765481472015,
0.4552854895591736,
0.3641662299633026,
-0.16424432396888733,
-0.6236395239830017,
-0.09617356956005096,
-0.2524435222148895,
0.3855619728565216,
0.7010506391525269,
-0.6465885639190674,
-0.1117817610502243,
-0.0012526478385552764,
0.1717059165239334,
0.024517318233847618,
-0.5454098582267761,
0.8687393069267273,
0.0015185823431238532,
-0.8864803910255432,
0.5581451058387756,
0.09463019669055939,
0.5712283253669739,
-0.38432443141937256,
0.20472872257232666,
0.02114148437976837,
0.35622307658195496,
-0.3360483646392822,
-0.7595320343971252,
0.3018031418323517,
-0.19157123565673828,
-0.041901007294654846,
-0.025187747552990913,
0.7510477900505066,
-0.33845603466033936,
-0.3586314022541046,
0.012665264308452606,
0.3249262273311615,
0.1694110482931137,
-0.38374072313308716,
-0.7232561707496643,
0.3438552916049957,
-0.03972931206226349,
-0.3542936444282532,
0.5618341565132141,
0.156368225812912,
-0.17069971561431885,
0.6106919646263123,
0.5214295983314514,
0.30825114250183105,
-0.3508802354335785,
0.03839200735092163,
0.8624848127365112,
-0.2726896405220032,
-0.48902472853660583,
-1.048879861831665,
0.0954202264547348,
0.08334435522556305,
-0.5462615489959717,
0.14930985867977142,
0.6646906137466431,
0.5333445072174072,
-0.2084355503320694,
0.69963139295578,
0.35845017433166504,
0.45487090945243835,
-0.44163164496421814,
0.8572216033935547,
-0.5030439496040344,
0.41432902216911316,
-0.1750856339931488,
-0.4095514416694641,
-0.6530194282531738,
0.6211186647415161,
-0.5240457653999329,
-0.05952081084251404,
-0.007116686087101698,
0.8949578404426575,
0.18229329586029053,
0.06919974088668823,
0.20281200110912323,
0.1199256181716919,
0.3537601828575134,
0.5070648193359375,
0.21780255436897278,
-0.2074030339717865,
0.45452681183815,
-0.3051552474498749,
-0.438005268573761,
-0.43476346135139465,
-0.7675155401229858,
-1.0012969970703125,
-0.30646687746047974,
-0.9294108152389526,
-0.1764392852783203,
0.465546578168869,
0.9028641581535339,
1.0476980209350586,
-0.9938948750495911,
0.2018340677022934,
-0.07549770176410675,
-0.23921196162700653,
-0.3517051041126251,
-0.06224358454346657,
0.6981077194213867,
-0.2605644166469574,
-0.49273017048835754,
0.13791584968566895,
0.5853081941604614,
-0.018078425899147987,
0.31082552671432495,
0.03713301941752434,
0.30722576379776,
-0.06958463788032532,
0.4978535771369934,
0.179371640086174,
-0.7101730704307556,
-0.11168443411588669,
-0.2631734311580658,
-0.18976829946041107,
0.05311769247055054,
0.5628967881202698,
-0.7456046938896179,
0.3499567210674286,
0.09897365421056747,
0.1913764923810959,
0.7752829194068909,
-0.16098178923130035,
0.05385642871260643,
-0.5884826183319092,
0.010436654090881348,
0.48461195826530457,
0.33923041820526123,
-0.17081938683986664,
-0.7131419777870178,
0.5923661589622498,
-0.1358514428138733,
-0.6650980114936829,
-0.6154265403747559,
0.06936848908662796,
-1.1956391334533691,
-0.15031883120536804,
1.1861428022384644,
0.0876900926232338,
0.040523093193769455,
-0.39932310581207275,
-0.5374121069908142,
0.4419005513191223,
-0.5082708597183228,
1.1400564908981323,
0.2855335772037506,
-0.7423731684684753,
-0.18491871654987335,
-0.3707723021507263,
0.9579077363014221,
0.44709721207618713,
-0.8027600049972534,
0.08041628450155258,
0.11956796795129776,
0.3318074941635132,
-0.018810788169503212,
0.8968613147735596,
-0.04233711212873459,
0.3875594437122345,
-0.44302600622177124,
-0.10576634109020233,
-0.3566058874130249,
-0.27260345220565796,
0.5080076456069946,
0.12746649980545044,
0.4228839874267578,
-0.20338134467601776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06067v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06067v2
|
HMT: Hierarchical Memory Transformer for Long Context Language Processing
| 2024-05-09T19:32:49 | 2024-05-14T06:09:52 |
Zifan He, Zongyue Qin, Neha Prakriya, Yizhou Sun, Jason Cong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Transformer-based large language models (LLM) have been widely used in
language processing applications. However, most of them restrict the context
window that permits the model to attend to every token in the inputs. Previous
works in recurrent models can memorize past tokens to enable unlimited context
and maintain effectiveness. However, they have "flat" memory architectures,
which have limitations in selecting and filtering information. Since humans are
good at learning and self-adjustment, we speculate that imitating brain memory
hierarchy is beneficial for model memorization. We propose the Hierarchical
Memory Transformer (HMT), a novel framework that enables and improves models'
long-context processing ability by imitating human memorization behavior.
Leveraging memory-augmented segment-level recurrence, we organize the memory
hierarchy by preserving tokens from early input token segments, passing memory
embeddings along the sequence, and recalling relevant information from history.
Evaluating general language modeling (Wikitext-103, PG-19) and
question-answering tasks (PubMedQA), we show that HMT steadily improves the
long-context processing ability of context-constrained and long-context models.
With an additional 0.5% - 2% of parameters, HMT can easily plug in and augment
future LLMs to handle long context effectively. Our code is open-sourced on
Github: https://github.com/OswaldHe/HMT-pytorch.
|
[
-0.0645495355129242,
-0.8936936259269714,
0.5159981846809387,
0.2591594159603119,
-0.17667843401432037,
-0.12244556099176407,
-0.20926816761493683,
-0.29504555463790894,
0.016671447083353996,
0.45018231868743896,
-0.33152809739112854,
-0.3548624813556671,
-0.1679077446460724,
-0.2381761372089386,
-0.3717433512210846,
0.9167708158493042,
0.010881319642066956,
-0.34825658798217773,
-0.14283449947834015,
-0.009636509232223034,
-0.590003252029419,
-0.8239783048629761,
-0.5980322360992432,
-0.6140655279159546,
0.5760422348976135,
0.05086478590965271,
0.5248904824256897,
0.8402268886566162,
0.21207652986049652,
0.2694459855556488,
-0.2764672636985779,
-0.19423775374889374,
-0.35888558626174927,
0.2389833927154541,
-0.27581992745399475,
-0.2826431393623352,
-0.8256022334098816,
-0.4490109384059906,
0.8440807461738586,
0.6689968109130859,
-0.38650476932525635,
-0.031440574675798416,
0.08149480819702148,
0.6599749326705933,
-0.5416629910469055,
0.21965332329273224,
-0.709185779094696,
0.032593537122011185,
-0.10110162198543549,
-0.47710561752319336,
-0.49874380230903625,
0.032564278692007065,
0.21166297793388367,
-0.248040571808815,
0.08238330483436584,
0.010114665143191814,
0.3642290234565735,
0.16177968680858612,
-0.2849118113517761,
0.0967707708477974,
-0.733788013458252,
0.7612284421920776,
-0.53676837682724,
0.5019711256027222,
0.4617295563220978,
0.321054607629776,
-0.22153402864933014,
-0.9055883884429932,
-0.2835122346878052,
-0.17066499590873718,
-0.2099757045507431,
0.05976428836584091,
-0.3104672133922577,
0.2130318284034729,
0.2241142839193344,
0.40319743752479553,
-0.4839657247066498,
-0.06634281575679779,
-0.3610180914402008,
-0.29220131039619446,
-0.21468868851661682,
0.14373259246349335,
0.2488352209329605,
-0.36540257930755615,
-0.4716682434082031,
0.03414258360862732,
-0.5968253016471863,
0.06243957579135895,
-0.22374284267425537,
0.252901166677475,
0.12742933630943298,
0.24879741668701172,
-0.0006502571632154286,
0.4953426420688629,
0.009310666471719742,
-0.2180715948343277,
0.07281821221113205,
0.06810485571622849,
-0.3649787902832031,
-0.060621824115514755,
0.2657069265842438,
0.14546875655651093,
0.009137474931776524,
-0.3796219527721405,
-0.31460291147232056,
-0.22262252867221832,
0.4482210576534271,
-0.9908795952796936,
-0.36891254782676697,
-0.0028808503411710262,
-0.350877970457077,
0.18223680555820465,
-0.13570086658000946,
-0.7617720365524292,
-0.03226098418235779,
-0.2145221084356308,
0.42551225423812866,
-0.6169739365577698,
0.02328873611986637,
0.12064899504184723,
-0.1101350337266922,
0.09931907057762146,
0.2791999578475952,
-0.9672767519950867,
0.415010005235672,
0.6701132655143738,
0.8265342116355896,
-0.4848778545856476,
-0.6306072473526001,
-0.5690797567367554,
0.5468180179595947,
0.1337883174419403,
0.6703993082046509,
-0.48674994707107544,
-0.26091548800468445,
-0.1489008516073227,
0.015026104636490345,
-0.2475922405719757,
-0.695016086101532,
0.3241734206676483,
-0.6691620349884033,
0.3083597719669342,
0.06413231790065765,
-0.38660627603530884,
0.06359870731830597,
0.44615787267684937,
-0.6698697209358215,
1.175750732421875,
0.22401970624923706,
-0.6982954740524292,
-0.06272079795598984,
-0.685578465461731,
-0.5948407053947449,
0.058870431035757065,
-0.07029050588607788,
-0.39793750643730164,
-0.001874254667200148,
0.4090772867202759,
0.2930851876735687,
-0.1388809233903885,
0.3300945460796356,
0.09205619245767593,
-0.581082284450531,
-0.047623395919799805,
-0.5897656679153442,
0.4951930344104767,
-0.12850454449653625,
-0.2630511224269867,
0.35836276412010193,
-0.5100235939025879,
-0.10111670196056366,
0.012116136960685253,
-0.8138537406921387,
-0.48876944184303284,
-0.10556507110595703,
0.10681309551000595,
0.31455928087234497,
0.23383215069770813,
-0.3476512134075165,
0.30725976824760437,
-0.2186957150697708,
0.8545922636985779,
0.7261230945587158,
-0.023474257439374924,
0.5174476504325867,
-0.4541768431663513,
0.3525424897670746,
0.3945831060409546,
-0.05775527283549309,
-0.8147122859954834,
-0.1547413468360901,
-0.5546255707740784,
-0.43224215507507324,
-0.02906165085732937,
0.3477831780910492,
-0.5989025235176086,
0.5458654165267944,
-0.6750534772872925,
0.0982525572180748,
-0.16612453758716583,
-0.04859323799610138,
0.2113766074180603,
0.7689471244812012,
0.6493903398513794,
-0.2989020347595215,
-0.7357383966445923,
-0.9794458746910095,
-0.11920963227748871,
-0.35429486632347107,
-0.33301207423210144,
0.06948288530111313,
0.44270703196525574,
-0.6247133016586304,
1.095623254776001,
-0.2661074697971344,
-0.2861922085285187,
-0.08717183023691177,
0.06516103446483612,
0.07946785539388657,
0.44070255756378174,
0.1248830258846283,
-0.5737931132316589,
0.05359946936368942,
-0.2042342722415924,
-0.20198488235473633,
0.05467936769127846,
-0.12228937447071075,
-0.23204699158668518,
0.35564878582954407,
0.6153053641319275,
-0.8537648320198059,
0.31140175461769104,
0.3245675563812256,
-0.2644107937812805,
0.4150872230529785,
-0.3453533947467804,
-0.004279471002519131,
-1.2709388732910156,
0.22022373974323273,
-0.3451736569404602,
-0.40425607562065125,
-0.5094520449638367,
-0.046986985951662064,
0.4040326178073883,
0.023465756326913834,
-0.4208841919898987,
0.6077495217323303,
-0.25571104884147644,
-0.049643512815237045,
-0.3533041477203369,
-0.22553732991218567,
-0.11657736450433731,
0.8374431133270264,
0.031200051307678223,
0.7658019065856934,
0.34204283356666565,
-0.4214659333229065,
-0.1294526308774948,
0.046051274985075,
-0.2628413736820221,
0.5335431694984436,
-0.37486016750335693,
0.2255079448223114,
-0.18767046928405762,
0.4796120822429657,
-0.9659081697463989,
-0.08889392763376236,
-0.19400525093078613,
-0.06921397894620895,
0.18459847569465637,
-0.2710094749927521,
-0.515072762966156,
-0.38886553049087524,
-0.2248709350824356,
0.6413151621818542,
0.7751819491386414,
-0.750697672367096,
0.8030861616134644,
0.3255685865879059,
-0.08569306880235672,
-0.42784419655799866,
-0.6611434817314148,
0.23790012300014496,
-0.3258517384529114,
-0.28639060258865356,
0.7750977277755737,
-0.13876229524612427,
0.23682834208011627,
-0.17521369457244873,
-0.386862576007843,
-0.19119592010974884,
-0.19565096497535706,
0.3002517521381378,
0.17457805573940277,
-0.3870711624622345,
0.14479631185531616,
-0.003045120043680072,
-0.13079415261745453,
0.0671171247959137,
-0.5476944446563721,
0.8855977654457092,
-0.4260445833206177,
-0.13853640854358673,
-0.5108126401901245,
0.27444878220558167,
1.0043015480041504,
-0.030408840626478195,
0.42909231781959534,
0.4330393970012665,
-0.5900955200195312,
-0.13166172802448273,
-0.5119596719741821,
-0.17720837891101837,
-0.4873766601085663,
0.739155113697052,
-0.37737441062927246,
-1.1924245357513428,
0.4728735685348511,
-0.07246159017086029,
-0.04926742985844612,
0.19055037200450897,
0.7831006050109863,
-0.05795901641249657,
0.7861192226409912,
0.46274346113204956,
-0.6861093640327454,
0.6496702432632446,
-0.005437071435153484,
0.1395048052072525,
-1.0153177976608276,
0.048031285405159,
-0.002543806564062834,
-0.3327050507068634,
-0.2862410843372345,
-0.4442678391933441,
0.34522247314453125,
0.09621027112007141,
-0.43971413373947144,
0.3848922848701477,
-0.27040690183639526,
0.7252527475357056,
0.5171809792518616,
0.1263500154018402,
0.36908164620399475,
0.1912650763988495,
-0.24826858937740326,
-0.020410170778632164,
-0.611754298210144,
-0.24564138054847717,
0.4157267212867737,
0.6569106578826904,
0.8483942151069641,
-0.21429400146007538,
0.6202104091644287,
0.047664958983659744,
0.305867075920105,
-0.882963240146637,
0.5600847601890564,
-0.03160445764660835,
-0.35031068325042725,
-0.45782068371772766,
-0.3745603859424591,
-0.9657010436058044,
0.4031934440135956,
0.3895767331123352,
-0.8479728698730469,
-0.12548604607582092,
0.270184725522995,
-0.3862902820110321,
0.5674239993095398,
-0.434428870677948,
0.6752581000328064,
-0.03720378130674362,
-0.26304879784584045,
-0.16453218460083008,
-0.533481776714325,
0.20556411147117615,
0.051132481545209885,
-0.09295940399169922,
0.23260948061943054,
0.1425716131925583,
0.621968150138855,
-0.11322896182537079,
0.9828619360923767,
-0.11381346732378006,
-0.025198867544531822,
0.09254170954227448,
0.31628334522247314,
0.3660447597503662,
-0.1656934767961502,
-0.0737324059009552,
0.11797972023487091,
0.10142464935779572,
-0.3489915430545807,
-0.6009541153907776,
0.7040321230888367,
-0.5164183378219604,
-0.6901342868804932,
-0.0918947085738182,
-0.9948197603225708,
-0.06961490958929062,
0.38163867592811584,
-0.03374991565942764,
0.28784626722335815,
-0.253987193107605,
0.5030652284622192,
0.3749426603317261,
0.1351359486579895,
0.49653178453445435,
0.1334524303674698,
-0.36022451519966125,
-0.4479611814022064,
0.49281054735183716,
-0.03211308270692825,
0.13877879083156586,
0.7320157289505005,
0.33461833000183105,
-0.11458934098482132,
-0.4530661404132843,
-0.3094271421432495,
-0.03486604616045952,
-0.5757104754447937,
-0.2639607787132263,
-0.698451042175293,
-0.41905421018600464,
-0.04233558848500252,
-0.054653942584991455,
-0.3798610270023346,
-0.4611724317073822,
0.14298291504383087,
-0.07661199569702148,
0.07306524366140366,
0.33572936058044434,
0.3484566807746887,
0.4807080328464508,
-0.5980408787727356,
0.49833229184150696,
0.6280177235603333,
0.5328181385993958,
0.2747820317745209,
-0.5569229125976562,
-0.3081912398338318,
0.06464371085166931,
-0.3792526423931122,
-0.3183206021785736,
0.4271213114261627,
0.005662684794515371,
0.24186624586582184,
0.07850378006696701,
-0.21404041349887848,
1.1349138021469116,
-0.8043252229690552,
0.5038142204284668,
0.0424957200884819,
-0.8632575869560242,
0.23940403759479523,
-0.4334941506385803,
0.8402047157287598,
0.40833580493927,
-0.11589803546667099,
-0.6948078870773315,
-0.22009730339050293,
-0.1992580145597458,
-0.9312753677368164,
0.7109249830245972,
0.36192458868026733,
0.04936658963561058,
-0.14459358155727386,
0.5289142727851868,
-0.04383549839258194,
0.0031395775731652975,
-0.7129399180412292,
-0.09067349880933762,
-0.1518174409866333,
-0.09127922356128693,
0.12768112123012543,
-0.37245112657546997,
0.10526920109987259,
-0.6003992557525635,
0.1868664026260376,
-0.09141931682825089,
0.44049271941185,
0.14271551370620728,
-0.2678442895412445,
-0.2601090669631958,
0.5588082671165466,
0.44190171360969543,
0.7298555374145508,
-0.48937880992889404,
0.5590123534202576,
0.2881201505661011,
-0.5787323117256165,
-0.03463682159781456,
0.02949201501905918,
-0.03732532635331154,
-0.2097986787557602,
0.15971650183200836,
0.6141782402992249,
0.6878076195716858,
-0.4752747416496277,
0.2420102059841156,
-0.07244163751602173,
0.012688016518950462,
-0.31994134187698364,
0.007497927639633417,
0.40394505858421326,
0.24354498088359833,
0.5700711011886597,
-0.028488406911492348,
-0.04874151945114136,
-0.7372137904167175,
0.4757545590400696,
0.21786081790924072,
-0.3405086398124695,
-0.49908244609832764,
0.6252959966659546,
-0.14912746846675873,
-0.5760671496391296,
0.9183045625686646,
0.41381531953811646,
-0.6429835557937622,
0.35346490144729614,
1.2726229429244995,
0.852202296257019,
-0.4413611590862274,
-0.29314765334129333,
0.2645173668861389,
0.11356528103351593,
-0.23297549784183502,
-0.01915983110666275,
-0.45830145478248596,
-0.4852123558521271,
-0.3183336555957794,
-0.7496793270111084,
-0.2637117803096771,
0.29835301637649536,
-0.6736984252929688,
0.01519825030118227,
-0.28234443068504333,
-0.0371873565018177,
-0.18287810683250427,
-0.46638765931129456,
-0.5576043128967285,
0.041280776262283325,
0.1415998637676239,
0.9105260372161865,
-0.2990761697292328,
1.50319242477417,
0.514752984046936,
0.05745181068778038,
-0.19544801115989685,
0.2648552656173706,
-0.26054954528808594,
-0.7456616163253784,
0.4679490327835083,
0.44659027457237244,
-0.25546324253082275,
0.06932716816663742,
-0.21238359808921814,
-0.6959860324859619,
1.3808467388153076,
0.35855409502983093,
-0.441190630197525,
-0.5242724418640137,
0.17696261405944824,
0.700070321559906,
-0.4051908850669861,
0.00964976754039526,
0.8356934785842896,
0.1945890635251999,
0.2663493752479553,
-0.8287522792816162,
0.11052685976028442,
-0.2922038733959198,
0.19510622322559357,
0.43518462777137756,
-0.22641417384147644,
0.8794811367988586,
-0.09023803472518921,
-0.2618429660797119,
0.2232043594121933,
0.6430988907814026,
0.5311989188194275,
0.11483868956565857,
0.5424332618713379,
0.4647108316421509,
0.603087842464447,
0.21574881672859192,
0.908403754234314,
-0.19724366068840027,
0.23472192883491516,
1.2850018739700317,
-0.135163351893425,
1.079050898551941,
0.8206004500389099,
0.02507554367184639,
0.6800119280815125,
0.12570279836654663,
0.36267200112342834,
0.5391722917556763,
-0.013769316487014294,
-0.03420517221093178,
-0.14763256907463074,
0.3040589690208435,
-0.09477929025888443,
0.20807848870754242,
0.34742921590805054,
-0.22343653440475464,
-0.4567207992076874,
-0.1438419371843338,
-0.07809621095657349,
-0.27313464879989624,
-0.262443870306015,
0.6134132742881775,
0.22871878743171692,
-0.6366950273513794,
0.6889631152153015,
0.12927187979221344,
0.7484064102172852,
-0.5583463907241821,
-0.0706351101398468,
-0.17829588055610657,
0.33245208859443665,
0.061262305825948715,
-0.6231011152267456,
0.46989771723747253,
-0.18593373894691467,
-0.5048394203186035,
-0.43208616971969604,
0.5905104279518127,
-0.7106147408485413,
-0.09628988802433014,
0.38844794034957886,
0.43967464566230774,
-0.15726153552532196,
-0.3402246832847595,
-0.526098370552063,
-0.27681228518486023,
-0.27189403772354126,
-0.45501917600631714,
0.5197487473487854,
0.18990342319011688,
-0.3556195795536041,
0.6080549359321594,
0.5118677616119385,
-0.18915198743343353,
0.06445996463298798,
0.1774364709854126,
0.7975555658340454,
-1.1584361791610718,
-0.7353677153587341,
-1.051880121231079,
0.42449402809143066,
0.1682276874780655,
-0.10683637112379074,
0.5326750874519348,
0.7053282856941223,
0.635252833366394,
-0.1823538988828659,
0.3644101321697235,
0.2196376770734787,
0.2959969937801361,
-0.39788925647735596,
0.7708359956741333,
-0.21402248740196228,
0.2229870706796646,
-0.01781548745930195,
-0.9561392664909363,
-0.6201565861701965,
0.4661570191383362,
-0.26618218421936035,
0.05106131359934807,
0.8419876098632812,
0.6691785454750061,
-0.4558112323284149,
-0.009547146037220955,
0.585310697555542,
0.3425975441932678,
0.46372413635253906,
0.8384509086608887,
0.8235449194908142,
-0.3627901077270508,
0.45648565888404846,
-0.25801345705986023,
-0.017315279692411423,
-0.13016057014465332,
-0.7443292140960693,
-1.073285460472107,
-0.6933051347732544,
0.06658723950386047,
-0.14860062301158905,
0.10900294035673141,
0.9962691068649292,
0.9493697881698608,
-0.6517617106437683,
-0.4087882936000824,
-0.06450699269771576,
0.0763244777917862,
-0.1427934616804123,
-0.2285500168800354,
0.6516742706298828,
-0.19124220311641693,
-0.5426647663116455,
0.4824691414833069,
0.6038452386856079,
-0.007507135160267353,
-0.11621099710464478,
-0.0011455717030912638,
0.11468932032585144,
-0.08327417075634003,
1.0564401149749756,
0.26629942655563354,
-0.7118009924888611,
-0.4248726963996887,
-0.012609255500137806,
-0.23892223834991455,
0.6221999526023865,
1.0450984239578247,
-1.061540961265564,
0.24652943015098572,
0.41400566697120667,
0.7705503702163696,
0.5442743897438049,
0.04346739128232002,
0.42817223072052,
-0.7156959176063538,
0.101136215031147,
0.24864108860492706,
0.5689123272895813,
0.20755290985107422,
-0.31253665685653687,
0.20016643404960632,
-0.048227641731500626,
-0.5686217546463013,
-0.6041703224182129,
0.14781814813613892,
-0.9961866736412048,
-0.2945643663406372,
1.0209150314331055,
0.14475826919078827,
-0.5836541056632996,
-0.11067242175340652,
-0.32609498500823975,
0.08223842084407806,
-0.37940454483032227,
1.0787094831466675,
0.5741996765136719,
-0.15564407408237457,
-0.2326720952987671,
-0.358053982257843,
0.16486328840255737,
0.4589278995990753,
-0.6527140140533447,
0.3897427022457123,
0.3756204843521118,
0.3350086212158203,
0.08695869147777557,
0.6753615140914917,
-0.3349076509475708,
0.3311954140663147,
-0.44604238867759705,
0.05674906075000763,
-0.0817888081073761,
-0.5703189969062805,
-0.5193177461624146,
0.36794909834861755,
-0.19279444217681885,
0.1031651720404625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06064v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06064v1
|
LLMs for XAI: Future Directions for Explaining Explanations
| 2024-05-09T19:17:47 | 2024-05-09T19:17:47 |
Alexandra Zytek, Sara Pidò, Kalyan Veeramachaneni
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
In response to the demand for Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI), we
investigate the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) to transform ML
explanations into natural, human-readable narratives. Rather than directly
explaining ML models using LLMs, we focus on refining explanations computed
using existing XAI algorithms. We outline several research directions,
including defining evaluation metrics, prompt design, comparing LLM models,
exploring further training methods, and integrating external data. Initial
experiments and user study suggest that LLMs offer a promising way to enhance
the interpretability and usability of XAI.
|
[
-0.31064721941947937,
-0.5103674530982971,
0.9724743962287903,
0.005466940812766552,
-0.21782366931438446,
-0.03046252392232418,
-0.4078637361526489,
-0.7357346415519714,
0.2008272409439087,
0.6336209774017334,
-0.9951996803283691,
-0.27740612626075745,
-0.47388455271720886,
0.13181160390377045,
-0.7273141741752625,
0.8552832007408142,
-0.3145386576652527,
0.17806832492351532,
-0.3883131146430969,
-0.09894555062055588,
-0.2949853539466858,
-0.4107094407081604,
-1.0544337034225464,
-0.6542850136756897,
1.0517791509628296,
0.6366437673568726,
0.9401966333389282,
1.0576509237289429,
0.27050188183784485,
0.344404935836792,
0.12196160852909088,
0.1073772981762886,
-0.3461779057979584,
-0.03763114660978317,
0.05415217578411102,
-0.9090200066566467,
-0.4754094183444977,
0.01427333615720272,
0.9152606725692749,
0.9319660663604736,
0.23298613727092743,
0.11915170401334763,
-0.2678591310977936,
0.6700385212898254,
-0.12770812213420868,
0.1390775442123413,
-0.22568266093730927,
0.10336975008249283,
-0.049968015402555466,
-0.502845287322998,
-0.2474977672100067,
-0.2603224515914917,
0.47580933570861816,
-0.5852735042572021,
0.058593109250068665,
0.4500037431716919,
0.5855063796043396,
0.13813844323158264,
-0.41881030797958374,
-0.4162319600582123,
-0.9916119575500488,
1.0423742532730103,
-0.6943106055259705,
0.3391985595226288,
0.24582718312740326,
0.6090481877326965,
-0.27216023206710815,
-0.8927360773086548,
-0.7326114177703857,
-0.5229226350784302,
-0.08548164367675781,
-0.03930340334773064,
-0.12167656421661377,
-0.002056925790384412,
0.010778765194118023,
0.4867932200431824,
-0.6650642156600952,
0.639668345451355,
-0.12993541359901428,
0.1406334489583969,
1.1674026250839233,
0.5705349445343018,
0.5078849196434021,
0.08371169865131378,
-0.2628708481788635,
0.09360731393098831,
-1.0163209438323975,
0.029819147661328316,
0.2613470256328583,
0.17962928116321564,
-0.10506116598844528,
0.5561761856079102,
-0.2306755930185318,
0.6709529161453247,
-0.45848536491394043,
-0.19616582989692688,
-0.10967984795570374,
-0.2984843850135803,
-0.3094364404678345,
0.1520533710718155,
0.6270239353179932,
0.4982248544692993,
0.21463201940059662,
-0.35646307468414307,
-0.2995659112930298,
-0.06046116724610329,
0.13797837495803833,
-0.6884692311286926,
-0.05781693384051323,
0.4285014569759369,
-0.8369061946868896,
-0.389791876077652,
-0.2776183485984802,
-0.6778032183647156,
-0.7076296806335449,
-0.749212920665741,
0.22748179733753204,
-0.06668517738580704,
-0.1986057609319687,
0.009360626339912415,
-0.26094263792037964,
0.4933067560195923,
0.46447110176086426,
-0.9923840165138245,
0.2838517427444458,
0.6785827875137329,
0.776839017868042,
-0.3180580139160156,
-0.2894733250141144,
-0.27881813049316406,
0.16203530132770538,
-0.3575971722602844,
0.7065090537071228,
-0.5651469230651855,
-0.343517929315567,
0.019320039078593254,
-0.13510288298130035,
0.16452452540397644,
-0.40529125928878784,
0.5403782725334167,
-0.48268479108810425,
0.35046717524528503,
-0.22399646043777466,
-0.6217260360717773,
-0.593837320804596,
0.3697679042816162,
-0.6321668028831482,
0.31192976236343384,
0.03723922371864319,
-0.41712242364883423,
0.22189396619796753,
-1.3667542934417725,
-0.35218286514282227,
0.08889791369438171,
-0.12072085589170456,
-0.15834449231624603,
0.21500344574451447,
0.39484620094299316,
0.5219594836235046,
-0.5279064178466797,
0.34406721591949463,
-0.1649136245250702,
-0.4180888533592224,
0.6068018078804016,
-0.8889323472976685,
0.9211565852165222,
0.31964901089668274,
-0.36218467354774475,
0.5200963020324707,
-0.8298941254615784,
-0.1958947777748108,
0.3742838501930237,
-0.027264146134257317,
0.002551467390730977,
0.46238237619400024,
-0.05540803074836731,
-0.02089156024158001,
0.06745660305023193,
-0.3747815191745758,
0.11100071668624878,
-0.4686376750469208,
0.8117144703865051,
0.7784692645072937,
-0.25283950567245483,
0.5755342245101929,
-0.5444403290748596,
0.7699864506721497,
-0.18778598308563232,
0.16999152302742004,
-0.6279140114784241,
-0.594901442527771,
-0.798761785030365,
-0.08785047382116318,
0.02573229931294918,
0.4415505826473236,
-0.6794006824493408,
-0.1538928896188736,
-0.41761717200279236,
-0.4340830445289612,
-0.425687313079834,
0.2409701645374298,
0.15379782021045685,
0.5417374968528748,
0.09812947362661362,
0.21425111591815948,
-0.761184573173523,
-0.7028506994247437,
-0.29468101263046265,
-0.37154847383499146,
-0.1487058401107788,
0.3525218963623047,
0.39641398191452026,
-0.5262758135795593,
0.9028936624526978,
-0.2034544199705124,
0.16172294318675995,
-0.676374077796936,
0.19981902837753296,
0.11264732480049133,
0.0665092021226883,
0.38143399357795715,
-1.10995352268219,
-0.1189398318529129,
0.05075554549694061,
-0.839911162853241,
0.06595512479543686,
-0.49437883496284485,
0.09110258519649506,
0.16771987080574036,
0.6115264892578125,
-0.5172626376152039,
0.41352328658103943,
0.4310908019542694,
-0.35496050119400024,
0.7258195281028748,
-0.09975901246070862,
-0.00816582702100277,
-0.9222834706306458,
-0.15412366390228271,
0.16495046019554138,
-0.5332888960838318,
-0.6975231170654297,
0.14771315455436707,
-0.3595430850982666,
-0.12201846390962601,
-0.4400549530982971,
0.9938751459121704,
-0.6175102591514587,
-0.2277485877275467,
-0.4883691072463989,
0.42549192905426025,
-0.0007164076087065041,
0.20175527036190033,
0.18197286128997803,
0.5974180698394775,
0.6059083938598633,
-0.6544066071510315,
0.7440415620803833,
0.1583891361951828,
-0.4378947615623474,
0.11485613137483597,
-0.7213067412376404,
-0.21674728393554688,
-0.2584514617919922,
0.28094011545181274,
-1.1247262954711914,
-0.4322548806667328,
0.31584659218788147,
-0.5533859729766846,
0.14945369958877563,
0.07790252566337585,
-0.4121054410934448,
-0.6404703259468079,
-0.24670757353305817,
0.1835021823644638,
0.5624515414237976,
-0.9214435815811157,
0.762011706829071,
0.14839376509189606,
-0.3347505033016205,
-0.23364102840423584,
-0.7913204431533813,
0.5760223865509033,
-0.6271876096725464,
-0.8477048277854919,
0.530792236328125,
-0.35812100768089294,
-0.709326982498169,
-0.11224376410245895,
0.31654682755470276,
-0.05463095381855965,
0.2763515114784241,
0.3644196093082428,
0.3098410367965698,
-0.6424105763435364,
0.07300294190645218,
-0.1159842237830162,
-0.3122714161872864,
0.4835864305496216,
-0.3031107485294342,
0.23750187456607819,
0.11003576219081879,
-0.23210443556308746,
-0.6767546534538269,
0.5219165086746216,
0.5775778293609619,
-0.009673675522208214,
0.7612411975860596,
0.4750674068927765,
-0.2822800278663635,
0.0551004484295845,
-0.2457999885082245,
-0.18790359795093536,
-0.4450216293334961,
0.3464471995830536,
-0.2677278518676758,
-0.924292266368866,
0.5631474852561951,
-0.09132944792509079,
0.2770782709121704,
0.2792375981807709,
0.86398845911026,
-0.285103976726532,
1.6781350374221802,
0.9904167652130127,
-0.1978595107793808,
0.5980914831161499,
-0.13648249208927155,
0.3465862572193146,
-0.525367259979248,
-0.16339576244354248,
-0.3815820813179016,
-0.4388672411441803,
-0.5739148259162903,
-0.04986096918582916,
0.028630591928958893,
-0.25132986903190613,
-0.05915730446577072,
-0.13161985576152802,
-0.10580650717020035,
0.6097990870475769,
0.6186403632164001,
-0.15090911090373993,
0.4037226438522339,
-0.07023332267999649,
0.45575177669525146,
0.3259042501449585,
-0.7071546316146851,
-0.7104792594909668,
0.965384840965271,
0.73732990026474,
0.8750647306442261,
0.041079096496105194,
0.5433284044265747,
0.1974841207265854,
0.5426449179649353,
-0.8350188136100769,
0.43478214740753174,
-0.005424038507044315,
-0.5477960109710693,
-0.5962429046630859,
-0.3938426971435547,
-1.0800120830535889,
0.055951833724975586,
-0.15560968220233917,
-0.9124971032142639,
-0.24184206128120422,
0.18127137422561646,
-0.5021262168884277,
0.37971290946006775,
-0.7819219827651978,
0.7112220525741577,
-0.6435111165046692,
0.15577706694602966,
-0.24271166324615479,
-0.6665288805961609,
0.5989201068878174,
0.09920129925012589,
0.1597534716129303,
0.006392176728695631,
-0.10579413920640945,
0.73462975025177,
-0.4235040247440338,
0.9297438263893127,
-0.03612654656171799,
-0.31894803047180176,
0.19770710170269012,
-0.36410975456237793,
0.18798290193080902,
0.15039430558681488,
-0.31086117029190063,
0.10597117990255356,
-0.12525157630443573,
-0.32506445050239563,
-1.0708738565444946,
0.6416081190109253,
-0.8335761427879333,
-0.8612168431282043,
-0.03479963168501854,
-0.9751884341239929,
-0.01923595741391182,
0.0613926537334919,
0.0893556997179985,
0.5615805983543396,
-0.12134452909231186,
-0.1816336065530777,
0.7289181351661682,
-0.2735176384449005,
0.49089598655700684,
0.3793559670448303,
-0.5501840710639954,
-0.07242299616336823,
1.0791476964950562,
0.10315362364053726,
0.0022684186697006226,
0.471702516078949,
0.42405757308006287,
-0.5181290507316589,
-0.8763269782066345,
-0.7236710786819458,
0.19960631430149078,
-0.6598867177963257,
0.12598000466823578,
-0.3521721065044403,
-0.1596001237630844,
-0.28451552987098694,
-0.3151912987232208,
0.04778323322534561,
-0.483433336019516,
-0.4683268964290619,
-0.09819911420345306,
0.35001707077026367,
1.0112591981887817,
0.1465856432914734,
0.6873839497566223,
-0.7590498328208923,
0.5523214340209961,
0.08784734457731247,
0.3307204246520996,
0.08415698260068893,
-0.6966924071311951,
-0.31876644492149353,
0.2791390120983124,
-0.01705029234290123,
-0.6911613941192627,
0.5101386308670044,
0.11300332844257355,
0.6736547350883484,
0.7014427781105042,
-0.20439784228801727,
0.6674496531486511,
-0.38506177067756653,
0.925514817237854,
0.21212926506996155,
-0.7331693172454834,
0.575098991394043,
-0.2119254320859909,
0.2289852350950241,
-0.01656160317361355,
0.6797609329223633,
-0.6099318861961365,
-0.08501061052083969,
-0.3543563485145569,
-0.7034105658531189,
0.5393520593643188,
-0.04321910813450813,
0.3379554748535156,
0.22806446254253387,
0.8330705761909485,
0.3227604627609253,
-0.17665508389472961,
-0.6518314480781555,
-0.3320058584213257,
0.11145064979791641,
-0.3291839361190796,
-0.46947014331817627,
-0.4122667610645294,
-0.1971016675233841,
-0.1259165108203888,
0.6483124494552612,
-0.1680932193994522,
0.48575684428215027,
0.009727319702506065,
-0.2334386110305786,
-0.16623662412166595,
0.09235550463199615,
0.79599928855896,
1.104249358177185,
0.1827394664287567,
0.08060891926288605,
0.011065613478422165,
-0.04358634725213051,
0.08866020292043686,
0.20548376441001892,
0.0026813081931322813,
-0.05251767858862877,
0.6113994717597961,
0.9792985916137695,
-0.13815265893936157,
-0.9273870587348938,
0.28907716274261475,
-0.48642027378082275,
-0.2610471546649933,
-0.6592225432395935,
0.2056037038564682,
0.1362367421388626,
0.5697596073150635,
0.28353413939476013,
-0.44542360305786133,
0.12826834619045258,
-0.7172199487686157,
-0.1297539323568344,
0.31260254979133606,
-0.3569568395614624,
-0.3328806161880493,
0.6566888093948364,
0.1402139514684677,
-0.5093104243278503,
0.7676502466201782,
0.07342948764562607,
-0.37768056988716125,
0.5585898756980896,
0.5980796217918396,
0.7561858296394348,
-0.041271716356277466,
0.2232467085123062,
-0.24242350459098816,
0.17825500667095184,
0.09871597588062286,
0.286490261554718,
-0.06655054539442062,
-0.710951566696167,
-0.7987499237060547,
-0.2562526762485504,
-0.7564048171043396,
0.14231055974960327,
-0.5089505314826965,
0.23982711136341095,
-0.2887616455554962,
0.2540057897567749,
0.39825260639190674,
0.029018154367804527,
-0.48515722155570984,
0.4571743905544281,
0.6716994643211365,
1.1839725971221924,
-0.7660403847694397,
0.8005182147026062,
0.6889710426330566,
-0.5399510860443115,
-0.659153163433075,
-0.18426716327667236,
0.05044550448656082,
-1.0960972309112549,
0.6224510669708252,
0.26971328258514404,
-0.0326872244477272,
-0.20264966785907745,
-0.9591569304466248,
-0.7236871719360352,
1.1707992553710938,
0.4387913644313812,
-0.653594434261322,
-0.21406570076942444,
0.3687748312950134,
0.5614454746246338,
-0.5069540739059448,
0.355442076921463,
0.8838860988616943,
0.6968023180961609,
-0.03079916350543499,
-0.3738635182380676,
-0.15032346546649933,
-0.22067801654338837,
0.03647291287779808,
0.00826091505587101,
-0.2806568443775177,
0.4243621826171875,
-0.5618398189544678,
0.018046699464321136,
0.623184859752655,
1.1495928764343262,
0.15800486505031586,
0.7224265336990356,
0.3672267496585846,
0.26010680198669434,
0.9436200261116028,
-0.051652733236551285,
1.5183377265930176,
-0.004207022953778505,
-0.2996503710746765,
1.0097161531448364,
-0.057358384132385254,
0.6495485305786133,
0.6103571057319641,
-0.05349031835794449,
0.9051946997642517,
0.9236430525779724,
0.07416370511054993,
0.07250337302684784,
0.3951912224292755,
-0.34208056330680847,
-0.0660041868686676,
-0.10389517992734909,
0.05030990019440651,
0.5281916260719299,
0.49406182765960693,
-0.6432027816772461,
-0.02668173797428608,
0.38934966921806335,
-0.01850278116762638,
-0.14277641475200653,
-0.6962277889251709,
0.6962137222290039,
0.19652293622493744,
-0.7220255136489868,
0.37145498394966125,
0.14325515925884247,
0.3770900368690491,
-0.5044020414352417,
-0.20680485665798187,
-0.23189003765583038,
0.13789302110671997,
-0.3124050796031952,
-1.0630918741226196,
0.3493260443210602,
0.0012118637096136808,
-0.5258808135986328,
-0.3928801119327545,
0.7346072793006897,
-0.3581639230251312,
-0.5501869916915894,
0.20171824097633362,
0.40537387132644653,
0.5771304965019226,
-0.04285039007663727,
-0.8354217410087585,
0.044354211539030075,
0.06926361471414566,
-0.280478298664093,
0.2605254054069519,
0.4939090609550476,
-0.466632217168808,
1.247536063194275,
0.6077302098274231,
-0.01802343688905239,
0.05201368406414986,
0.3092428147792816,
0.7464146614074707,
-0.9185616374015808,
-0.40763723850250244,
-1.067304253578186,
0.6165247559547424,
0.2134239375591278,
-0.018634432926774025,
0.6810803413391113,
0.09555396437644958,
0.5261395573616028,
0.1833762526512146,
0.94883131980896,
0.27581724524497986,
0.443543016910553,
-0.6639416217803955,
0.6881177425384521,
-0.6443681716918945,
0.30159974098205566,
0.10881058126688004,
-0.8600321412086487,
-0.5719666481018066,
0.30916571617126465,
-0.2264295071363449,
0.206570103764534,
0.3311294913291931,
0.7052028179168701,
0.14193911850452423,
0.3810020387172699,
0.5506299138069153,
0.29418689012527466,
0.4647861123085022,
0.3289615511894226,
1.1884323358535767,
-0.038747478276491165,
0.6472025513648987,
-0.11449096351861954,
-0.40872326493263245,
-0.2993788719177246,
-1.1154552698135376,
-0.9241983294487,
-0.39841586351394653,
-0.35559386014938354,
0.063675157725811,
0.06373774260282516,
0.7751706838607788,
0.8757073879241943,
-0.6768236756324768,
-0.3479623794555664,
-0.10075654089450836,
0.46867239475250244,
-0.1257629543542862,
-0.1967492550611496,
0.15084518492221832,
-0.3008076548576355,
-0.741890013217926,
0.6109781861305237,
0.25888994336128235,
0.03889397531747818,
-0.8632804155349731,
-0.47819748520851135,
0.2034037709236145,
0.18155640363693237,
0.8391269445419312,
0.46326473355293274,
-1.0053033828735352,
-0.1749487966299057,
0.027139749377965927,
0.2829269468784332,
0.15271981060504913,
0.9965080618858337,
-0.850407063961029,
0.35286396741867065,
0.48261967301368713,
0.8511373400688171,
0.24475409090518951,
-0.24150916934013367,
1.0605300664901733,
-0.24524042010307312,
-0.2816362679004669,
-0.015451646409928799,
0.576906144618988,
0.45987966656684875,
-0.4953072965145111,
0.4421383738517761,
-0.2636185586452484,
-0.6358954310417175,
-0.8839276432991028,
0.18333107233047485,
-0.8084325790405273,
-0.2601238191127777,
1.0749435424804688,
-0.2876838147640228,
-0.49491456151008606,
-0.16368524730205536,
-0.2552565634250641,
0.16288453340530396,
0.0436076857149601,
0.5943607687950134,
0.6159771680831909,
-0.5166918635368347,
-0.7344645857810974,
-0.6305225491523743,
0.24858969449996948,
0.29663321375846863,
-1.0278586149215698,
0.16774512827396393,
0.24815694987773895,
0.11307589709758759,
-0.02632090076804161,
0.2966369092464447,
-0.16527476906776428,
0.38570618629455566,
-0.18038922548294067,
-0.10337697714567184,
0.01800740510225296,
-0.424619197845459,
-0.7295553088188171,
-0.34737566113471985,
0.4197337329387665,
0.01634698361158371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06059v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06059v1
|
A Mixture-of-Experts Approach to Few-Shot Task Transfer in Open-Ended Text Worlds
| 2024-05-09T19:02:56 | 2024-05-09T19:02:56 |
Christopher Z. Cui, Xiangyu Peng, Mark O. Riedl
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Open-ended worlds are those in which there are no pre-specified goals or
environmental reward signal. As a consequence, an agent must know how to
perform a multitude of tasks. However, when a new task is presented to an
agent, we expect it to be able to reuse some of what it knows from previous
tasks to rapidly learn that new task. We introduce a novel technique whereby
policies for different a priori known tasks are combined into a
Mixture-of-Experts model with an attention mechanism across a mix of frozen and
unfrozen experts. The model learns when to attend to frozen task-specific
experts when appropriate and learns new experts to handle novel situations. We
work in an open-ended text-based environment in which the agent is tasked with
behaving like different types of character roles and must rapidly learn
behaviors associated with new character role types. We show that our agent both
obtains more rewards in the zero-shot setting, and discovers these rewards with
greater sample efficiency in the few-shot learning settings.
|
[
-0.3746148347854614,
-0.5607999563217163,
0.5963943600654602,
-0.28566834330558777,
-0.01833522319793701,
0.14538531005382538,
-0.28565704822540283,
-0.4797547459602356,
0.22365674376487732,
0.6680573225021362,
-0.6203526854515076,
-0.26581892371177673,
-0.6102142930030823,
0.11214970797300339,
0.00792362168431282,
1.3390737771987915,
-0.09298626333475113,
-0.6568446159362793,
-0.18843474984169006,
0.08334557712078094,
-0.4018014073371887,
0.010341799817979336,
-0.5212013721466064,
-0.5289583802223206,
0.6849753856658936,
0.7558382153511047,
0.5479112863540649,
0.21473465859889984,
0.47523564100265503,
0.3079960346221924,
0.1933247447013855,
0.25655868649482727,
-0.9305577874183655,
0.05684298649430275,
-0.6876905560493469,
-0.5367952585220337,
-0.20820169150829315,
0.09011372178792953,
0.16333332657814026,
0.37658020853996277,
0.055482618510723114,
-0.11714304238557816,
0.21798841655254364,
0.23251642286777496,
-0.8941256999969482,
0.2571738660335541,
-0.6109219789505005,
0.27068907022476196,
0.24591882526874542,
-0.5239006280899048,
-0.3860970139503479,
0.09996400773525238,
0.3976230323314667,
-1.0918041467666626,
0.07041836529970169,
-0.17142045497894287,
0.43217918276786804,
0.36838164925575256,
-0.5715761780738831,
0.05831393972039223,
-0.7272610068321228,
0.9158523678779602,
-0.26909130811691284,
-0.1881733536720276,
0.3609362244606018,
0.32803550362586975,
-0.1997826099395752,
-0.3455691635608673,
-0.5924813747406006,
0.03559800982475281,
-0.013671161606907845,
0.315079003572464,
-0.03976164013147354,
0.014984642155468464,
-0.008832050487399101,
-0.024857645854353905,
-0.19425931572914124,
0.24082201719284058,
-0.3970823287963867,
-0.06666697561740875,
0.7171485424041748,
0.2306954264640808,
-0.08361725509166718,
0.19750288128852844,
-0.609248161315918,
-0.16255277395248413,
-0.23423290252685547,
0.21500568091869354,
-0.0038924997206777334,
0.5289444923400879,
-0.23651719093322754,
0.5855807065963745,
-0.48548072576522827,
0.8221389651298523,
0.20270350575447083,
-0.5610827207565308,
0.06227187067270279,
-0.1406227946281433,
-0.13711899518966675,
-0.0639573410153389,
0.373394638299942,
0.4240880310535431,
0.3852614462375641,
-0.4339907467365265,
-0.3550691604614258,
-0.4478089213371277,
0.3833601772785187,
-0.39735132455825806,
-0.1320669949054718,
0.07293539494276047,
-0.2721339166164398,
-0.4088607728481293,
-0.1558741331100464,
-0.7931810021400452,
-0.5015515685081482,
-0.23145171999931335,
0.923316240310669,
-0.3496374189853668,
-0.31180819869041443,
-0.0375252440571785,
-0.4006396234035492,
0.16515246033668518,
0.5907278060913086,
-0.929779052734375,
0.4503468871116638,
0.5545257329940796,
0.850612461566925,
-0.3371110260486603,
-0.5996615290641785,
-0.5877538919448853,
0.43826133012771606,
-0.2555016875267029,
1.1604176759719849,
-0.5672677159309387,
-0.29546675086021423,
-0.01727083884179592,
-0.34799501299858093,
-0.3162815570831299,
-0.2679216265678406,
-0.0817180946469307,
-0.5007740259170532,
0.2527778744697571,
-0.24322712421417236,
-0.36475735902786255,
-0.26100048422813416,
0.34071776270866394,
-0.39099591970443726,
0.7845218181610107,
0.3996050953865051,
-0.625284731388092,
0.442488431930542,
-0.6896573901176453,
-0.4685456454753876,
0.1387716680765152,
-0.09519482403993607,
0.050252918154001236,
0.08644315600395203,
-0.04747043550014496,
0.6587684154510498,
0.16973020136356354,
-0.29725053906440735,
-0.23391258716583252,
-0.43727201223373413,
0.44297462701797485,
0.00042459499672986567,
0.46700212359428406,
0.1895778924226761,
-0.06253936141729355,
0.062008365988731384,
-0.42914167046546936,
0.006328042596578598,
0.07729747891426086,
-0.19902901351451874,
-0.6355754733085632,
-0.22450999915599823,
-0.028923695906996727,
0.3654188811779022,
0.22876326739788055,
-0.4924335777759552,
0.3398166596889496,
-0.19641900062561035,
0.2086447775363922,
0.7025582790374756,
0.43739598989486694,
0.7583382725715637,
-0.7321467399597168,
0.49321091175079346,
0.155487522482872,
-0.1617543250322342,
-0.30738118290901184,
-0.3551359474658966,
-0.5764414668083191,
-0.39528289437294006,
-0.025604834780097008,
0.7810989618301392,
-1.252488374710083,
0.3881050944328308,
0.009554415009915829,
-0.3369145691394806,
-0.5310748219490051,
-0.014866124838590622,
0.3255385160446167,
0.5181462168693542,
0.363328754901886,
-0.468292236328125,
0.07185594737529755,
-0.6373087763786316,
-0.28940096497535706,
0.0695716142654419,
0.05928690731525421,
0.30122143030166626,
0.7825361490249634,
0.28013166785240173,
1.236712098121643,
-0.7722976803779602,
-0.5696291327476501,
-0.38306495547294617,
0.45238327980041504,
0.019579246640205383,
0.6797536015510559,
0.5203015208244324,
-0.5777796506881714,
-0.6282177567481995,
0.2733423411846161,
-0.747136652469635,
0.32145583629608154,
-0.5192033648490906,
-0.26602911949157715,
0.03166050463914871,
0.2062479853630066,
-0.8623903393745422,
0.28003907203674316,
-0.019392073154449463,
-0.3522782623767853,
0.3641442656517029,
-0.24202871322631836,
0.39029377698898315,
-0.8880378603935242,
-0.06093144789338112,
0.16700944304466248,
-0.5334027409553528,
-0.7421050071716309,
0.2714245617389679,
-0.40659186244010925,
0.05853009223937988,
-0.7773721814155579,
0.7049962878227234,
-0.48742061853408813,
-0.14468373358249664,
-0.6594375967979431,
0.20068421959877014,
-0.1969989687204361,
1.0108076333999634,
0.25481343269348145,
0.5544289946556091,
0.7702828049659729,
-0.5706951022148132,
0.15257380902767181,
0.3937634229660034,
-0.1113949567079544,
0.9437518119812012,
-0.3686981499195099,
0.4903864860534668,
-0.4120883047580719,
0.05015736445784569,
-0.8810073137283325,
-0.1979745477437973,
0.3910454213619232,
-0.49799400568008423,
0.24800997972488403,
-0.08965293318033218,
-0.38981086015701294,
-0.06492183357477188,
-0.08026276528835297,
0.22354622185230255,
0.6482943296432495,
0.02671070396900177,
0.36212968826293945,
0.2711717486381531,
-0.30411824584007263,
-0.6307761073112488,
-0.6890749335289001,
-0.042973555624485016,
-0.13719415664672852,
-0.13874393701553345,
0.440659761428833,
-0.02202727273106575,
-0.27628013491630554,
0.4406861662864685,
-0.15670837461948395,
-0.6182490587234497,
0.16277402639389038,
-0.06899062544107437,
0.06954815238714218,
0.08250467479228973,
-0.16111047565937042,
0.32929760217666626,
-0.1910085380077362,
-0.28748488426208496,
-0.3631591498851776,
-0.12548065185546875,
0.39329442381858826,
-0.11814365535974503,
-0.2443399280309677,
0.6689751744270325,
0.4969892203807831,
-0.24342355132102966,
0.965071976184845,
0.6746604442596436,
-0.4413294792175293,
-0.3762195110321045,
-0.33141908049583435,
-0.4826752245426178,
-0.4117809236049652,
0.4307605028152466,
-0.49418970942497253,
-0.94706791639328,
0.4650035798549652,
0.12303420156240463,
0.430340975522995,
0.3005088269710541,
0.5293079018592834,
-0.0783550962805748,
0.6302859783172607,
1.1645630598068237,
-0.010417181067168713,
0.39635351300239563,
-0.2817501425743103,
-0.006067041773349047,
-0.40281882882118225,
-0.36117079854011536,
-0.4444030821323395,
-0.42498913407325745,
-0.133185476064682,
-0.5731679201126099,
0.5224803686141968,
-0.10408399999141693,
-0.10040239989757538,
0.2672557234764099,
-0.3779394030570984,
0.8594272136688232,
0.5428565740585327,
0.39483246207237244,
0.3364288806915283,
0.14271008968353271,
0.004929780028760433,
0.15641872584819794,
-0.8901639580726624,
-0.27165427803993225,
0.9400313496589661,
0.07116654515266418,
0.6445571184158325,
-0.06920980662107468,
1.0354849100112915,
0.5136027336120605,
0.22229303419589996,
-0.7215797901153564,
0.509602963924408,
0.01015178207308054,
-0.5791994333267212,
-0.510154128074646,
-0.13913069665431976,
-0.8497247695922852,
0.6158924102783203,
-0.5457157492637634,
-0.8506309390068054,
0.33002927899360657,
0.006671498063951731,
-0.7656767964363098,
0.3438325524330139,
-0.5480177998542786,
0.7166838645935059,
0.20150095224380493,
-0.7695015072822571,
-0.4789178967475891,
-0.7405881285667419,
0.3824150264263153,
-0.05557640641927719,
0.08555642515420914,
-0.08430133014917374,
-0.35142773389816284,
0.6569103002548218,
0.062237635254859924,
1.0024299621582031,
-0.30423611402511597,
0.16215696930885315,
0.4336588382720947,
0.1922553926706314,
0.5894483923912048,
-0.267513245344162,
0.06659011542797089,
-0.3083207905292511,
-0.17478704452514648,
-0.7266303300857544,
-0.6201409101486206,
0.43263790011405945,
-0.9771223664283752,
-0.35629162192344666,
-0.48991066217422485,
-0.7937819361686707,
-0.13778290152549744,
0.2866673171520233,
0.31351733207702637,
0.005221547093242407,
-0.229853555560112,
-0.16848841309547424,
0.863387405872345,
0.027799783274531364,
0.36807477474212646,
0.970625638961792,
0.32690662145614624,
-0.12208656221628189,
0.8097844123840332,
0.13730008900165558,
0.26590752601623535,
0.5766757726669312,
-0.1777878999710083,
0.10768377035856247,
-0.5998587608337402,
-0.07037048041820526,
-0.05348191037774086,
-0.6806331276893616,
-0.2589384913444519,
-0.7467594146728516,
0.01695895940065384,
-0.42753878235816956,
-0.580272376537323,
-0.22762303054332733,
-0.16251879930496216,
-0.49458304047584534,
0.02131248079240322,
0.44375449419021606,
0.6532080173492432,
-0.0912591740489006,
0.5292119979858398,
-0.8533914089202881,
0.3393290936946869,
0.4719690680503845,
0.010016080923378468,
0.10296296328306198,
-0.5924009084701538,
-0.5916844606399536,
-0.11201208829879761,
-0.27057403326034546,
-1.063888669013977,
0.585181474685669,
0.13782799243927002,
0.9646313786506653,
0.22427703440189362,
0.3087693452835083,
0.3675772547721863,
-0.3905465602874756,
0.5461463332176208,
0.24657811224460602,
-0.7454915046691895,
0.07184579223394394,
-0.5212023854255676,
0.34523656964302063,
0.8116194009780884,
0.5477668642997742,
-0.5460308790206909,
-0.49554213881492615,
-0.49877411127090454,
-0.6401869058609009,
1.0171387195587158,
0.13229629397392273,
-0.012443376705050468,
0.16483069956302643,
0.26570531725883484,
0.604917585849762,
0.471487432718277,
-0.5584546327590942,
0.025730226188898087,
0.09022253006696701,
-0.14561007916927338,
-0.2268223613500595,
0.1687098741531372,
-0.32132411003112793,
0.06094319000840187,
0.3514351546764374,
-0.41011008620262146,
0.5640415549278259,
0.39687931537628174,
-0.419929563999176,
-0.2755446434020996,
0.45152977108955383,
0.5532960891723633,
0.5338778495788574,
-0.16723665595054626,
0.20243395864963531,
0.14495106041431427,
-0.06894233077764511,
0.24031998217105865,
0.08839284628629684,
-0.1382710188627243,
-0.4352867901325226,
0.45316120982170105,
0.9152389764785767,
0.3829958140850067,
-0.5766007304191589,
0.4694571793079376,
0.5396790504455566,
-0.509589433670044,
0.06893951445817947,
0.3099607527256012,
-0.30900877714157104,
0.5657241344451904,
0.5321506857872009,
0.45276394486427307,
0.2605263292789459,
-0.6334928274154663,
0.44048136472702026,
0.08832385390996933,
-0.44040647149086,
-0.34854498505592346,
0.4866305887699127,
0.3993197977542877,
-0.2441137433052063,
0.4434334635734558,
-0.3627355396747589,
-0.359803706407547,
0.7972302436828613,
0.37455490231513977,
0.9839054942131042,
-0.024020157754421234,
0.6038697957992554,
-0.017567012459039688,
0.34616416692733765,
-0.22832147777080536,
0.22350113093852997,
-0.2027239352464676,
-0.8519364595413208,
-0.6276082992553711,
0.01850084774196148,
-0.5888619422912598,
-0.20316699147224426,
-0.5234542489051819,
0.011579178273677826,
-0.2645248472690582,
0.05126658454537392,
-0.05057777091860771,
-0.10309336334466934,
-0.9697798490524292,
-0.050350118428468704,
0.14484602212905884,
0.7282091379165649,
-1.1545041799545288,
0.5410253405570984,
0.8824282288551331,
-0.4472358524799347,
-0.29779696464538574,
0.10192174464464188,
0.0655096173286438,
-0.653835654258728,
0.27701535820961,
0.05172005668282509,
0.00770240044221282,
0.16179203987121582,
-0.6071998476982117,
-0.8006517291069031,
1.005223035812378,
0.11450738459825516,
-0.27456095814704895,
-0.1379457712173462,
-0.28161895275115967,
0.5887545943260193,
-0.5637500882148743,
0.5472655892372131,
0.35584262013435364,
0.44057968258857727,
0.11955484747886658,
-0.9603095054626465,
-0.10033636540174484,
0.010835455730557442,
-0.4893355071544647,
0.02177353762090206,
-0.8673819899559021,
0.9120221734046936,
-0.5380553603172302,
0.07416147738695145,
-0.1878756284713745,
0.8407973051071167,
0.18995027244091034,
0.5793012976646423,
0.5958713889122009,
0.22794583439826965,
0.5428275465965271,
0.4374614953994751,
0.9235162734985352,
-0.05187026411294937,
0.35849082469940186,
0.9775403141975403,
-0.62334144115448,
0.849108874797821,
0.3795008957386017,
-0.034230612218379974,
0.4995894432067871,
0.5857232809066772,
0.18582212924957275,
0.9803734421730042,
-0.29659730195999146,
-0.2581036388874054,
-0.47867950797080994,
-0.2871060073375702,
0.1289122849702835,
0.3395076096057892,
0.0537521168589592,
0.030767258256673813,
-0.5038962364196777,
0.47956836223602295,
-0.11820013076066971,
0.17987839877605438,
-0.5206108689308167,
0.9614589214324951,
0.08360277116298676,
-1.0482327938079834,
0.29041650891304016,
0.008128303103148937,
0.7315365076065063,
-0.4829094111919403,
-0.264447957277298,
0.06325512379407883,
0.10074283927679062,
-0.3331107795238495,
-0.9819690585136414,
0.1403522789478302,
-0.15594157576560974,
-0.21169710159301758,
-0.3709595203399658,
0.8163306713104248,
-0.917518138885498,
-0.0622171014547348,
-0.07480496913194656,
0.7720813751220703,
0.34811341762542725,
-0.15230120718479156,
-0.6487399339675903,
-0.5708780288696289,
-0.07751403748989105,
-0.2490256428718567,
0.6841068267822266,
0.44893917441368103,
-0.08711742609739304,
0.5592153668403625,
0.15326525270938873,
-0.09069478511810303,
0.015554836019873619,
-0.4225582778453827,
0.8073737621307373,
-0.5554309487342834,
-0.9608005881309509,
-0.38060951232910156,
0.7179585695266724,
0.03922044485807419,
-0.36878693103790283,
0.5626399517059326,
0.1976517289876938,
0.7955080270767212,
-0.22399143874645233,
0.968844473361969,
-0.05038797855377197,
0.40148448944091797,
-0.5304037928581238,
0.29894259572029114,
-0.5111362338066101,
-0.2568054497241974,
-0.21211177110671997,
-0.7729417085647583,
0.07179493457078934,
0.5118986368179321,
-0.20820030570030212,
0.12911906838417053,
0.8146412968635559,
0.435533344745636,
-0.0937165841460228,
-0.307315856218338,
0.49287277460098267,
-0.02603321336209774,
-0.04309578984975815,
1.0023664236068726,
0.5228434205055237,
0.16018642485141754,
0.4210493266582489,
-0.3612988293170929,
-0.46293917298316956,
-0.13143926858901978,
-0.6015021204948425,
-0.9039615988731384,
-0.49234485626220703,
-0.5979366898536682,
0.02870573103427887,
0.35698407888412476,
1.1902586221694946,
0.7913966774940491,
-0.5079258680343628,
-0.23063573241233826,
0.27059802412986755,
0.20961561799049377,
-0.7746052742004395,
-0.24117419123649597,
-0.05045417323708534,
-0.34481555223464966,
-0.7877219319343567,
0.47123971581459045,
0.38373738527297974,
0.01584835723042488,
-0.2056870013475418,
0.04850148782134056,
-0.13002145290374756,
0.24972529709339142,
0.558396577835083,
0.4422711431980133,
-0.3680727183818817,
-0.20530037581920624,
-0.006131226662546396,
-0.11058397591114044,
-0.06848131865262985,
1.0378831624984741,
-1.0254666805267334,
0.22924381494522095,
0.7453110814094543,
0.6207671761512756,
0.5458316206932068,
-0.10821298509836197,
0.36865028738975525,
-0.7306709885597229,
0.3691387474536896,
0.27793580293655396,
-0.09147296845912933,
0.04882670193910599,
-0.6171140670776367,
0.27008315920829773,
0.382022887468338,
-0.5021637678146362,
-0.5620658993721008,
0.09516746550798416,
-1.0644822120666504,
-0.5263976454734802,
0.9563153982162476,
-0.3812640905380249,
-0.23187056183815002,
-0.38218382000923157,
-0.06874499469995499,
0.11148400604724884,
-0.8454771041870117,
0.6779457926750183,
0.6126303672790527,
-0.2277202308177948,
-0.4774037003517151,
-0.5202465653419495,
0.22048762440681458,
0.3909185230731964,
-0.8408676981925964,
-0.23012781143188477,
0.36219698190689087,
0.28029337525367737,
0.019400188699364662,
0.9710384607315063,
0.3812337815761566,
0.25822487473487854,
0.0659719705581665,
0.2415667176246643,
-0.302841454744339,
-0.6736428141593933,
-0.29314783215522766,
0.36475029587745667,
0.006370297633111477,
-0.2892552316188812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06058v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06058v1
|
Large Language Models Show Human-like Social Desirability Biases in Survey Responses
| 2024-05-09T19:02:53 | 2024-05-09T19:02:53 |
Aadesh Salecha, Molly E. Ireland, Shashanka Subrahmanya, João Sedoc, Lyle H. Ungar, Johannes C. Eichstaedt
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) become widely used to model and simulate
human behavior, understanding their biases becomes critical. We developed an
experimental framework using Big Five personality surveys and uncovered a
previously undetected social desirability bias in a wide range of LLMs. By
systematically varying the number of questions LLMs were exposed to, we
demonstrate their ability to infer when they are being evaluated. When
personality evaluation is inferred, LLMs skew their scores towards the
desirable ends of trait dimensions (i.e., increased extraversion, decreased
neuroticism, etc). This bias exists in all tested models, including GPT-4/3.5,
Claude 3, Llama 3, and PaLM-2. Bias levels appear to increase in more recent
models, with GPT-4's survey responses changing by 1.20 (human) standard
deviations and Llama 3's by 0.98 standard deviations-very large effects. This
bias is robust to randomization of question order and paraphrasing.
Reverse-coding all the questions decreases bias levels but does not eliminate
them, suggesting that this effect cannot be attributed to acquiescence bias.
Our findings reveal an emergent social desirability bias and suggest
constraints on profiling LLMs with psychometric tests and on using LLMs as
proxies for human participants.
|
[
-0.5756438374519348,
-0.7914124131202698,
0.9152208566665649,
0.16886970400810242,
-0.04026513174176216,
0.10316837579011917,
-0.40168681740760803,
-0.5256720185279846,
0.34790313243865967,
0.583509087562561,
-0.5356646180152893,
-0.4280422031879425,
-0.7979894876480103,
0.02383478358387947,
-0.35616281628608704,
1.010076642036438,
0.5009605884552002,
0.20054563879966736,
-0.2593081593513489,
-0.07709641009569168,
0.03851626068353653,
-0.9753245115280151,
-0.4983907639980316,
-0.465225487947464,
0.7143170833587646,
0.30982381105422974,
0.8338253498077393,
-0.02023753710091114,
0.34909480810165405,
0.14505304396152496,
-0.16728250682353973,
-0.23141182959079742,
-0.6615518927574158,
0.14698143303394318,
-0.18842779099941254,
-0.5437582731246948,
-0.3821936547756195,
0.20567864179611206,
0.567975640296936,
0.820824146270752,
0.07521713525056839,
0.5274248123168945,
0.08098264038562775,
0.7555899620056152,
-0.5946241021156311,
-0.010195215232670307,
-0.66832035779953,
-0.2873696982860565,
-0.37239518761634827,
0.119871586561203,
-0.2704940140247345,
-0.6759688854217529,
0.28710120916366577,
0.015770643949508667,
0.2970414459705353,
-0.20888572931289673,
0.6618416905403137,
0.06095041334629059,
-0.432730495929718,
-0.03105570562183857,
-0.7779790163040161,
0.6882780194282532,
-0.6558742523193359,
0.38303565979003906,
0.8042443990707397,
0.27557551860809326,
-0.1425510197877884,
-0.11684077233076096,
-0.6621494293212891,
-0.40062054991722107,
0.0859847441315651,
-0.10491788387298584,
0.01799323968589306,
0.009135614149272442,
0.48833584785461426,
0.01374767255038023,
-0.4150083065032959,
0.21055355668067932,
-0.37423229217529297,
-0.06459173560142517,
0.8668359518051147,
0.18975308537483215,
0.125234916806221,
0.010823819786310196,
0.06966403126716614,
-0.008070330135524273,
-0.8395887017250061,
-0.02373780868947506,
0.7737693786621094,
-0.058463308960199356,
-0.15777559578418732,
0.49978792667388916,
-0.08233218640089035,
0.3218052387237549,
0.256468266248703,
0.15353849530220032,
0.2401059865951538,
-0.0726521909236908,
-0.08021406084299088,
-0.21371647715568542,
0.6278318762779236,
0.3837030529975891,
0.5475863218307495,
0.09965534508228302,
-0.11073541641235352,
0.179832324385643,
0.2722567617893219,
-0.6363087892532349,
-0.34546470642089844,
0.2968709468841553,
-0.42015400528907776,
-0.453692764043808,
-0.12539495527744293,
-0.8413906097412109,
-0.939216136932373,
0.042054738849401474,
0.14576944708824158,
-0.10579551011323929,
-0.27160513401031494,
0.03936858847737312,
-0.15209521353244781,
0.3387816250324249,
0.31779003143310547,
-0.9872868657112122,
0.13809426128864288,
0.4731013774871826,
0.5201529860496521,
-0.1813301295042038,
-0.30894994735717773,
-0.3051515221595764,
-0.04806302487850189,
-0.28287121653556824,
0.7188643217086792,
-0.8608213067054749,
-0.47587263584136963,
-0.15868456661701202,
-0.014372793957591057,
0.23812143504619598,
-0.5046518445014954,
0.40446075797080994,
-0.5286608934402466,
0.16092543303966522,
-0.6804649829864502,
-0.10249223560094833,
-0.008418852463364601,
0.39277225732803345,
-0.46927884221076965,
0.8508480787277222,
0.06871861964464188,
-0.8126586079597473,
0.5492200255393982,
-0.384504109621048,
-0.18538056313991547,
-0.1702510267496109,
-0.396548867225647,
-0.453227162361145,
0.20185346901416779,
0.07578326761722565,
0.5204964876174927,
-0.5021560192108154,
0.24896925687789917,
-0.9291743040084839,
-0.5097700357437134,
0.6444334387779236,
-0.5890722870826721,
0.8710970282554626,
-0.1141701266169548,
-0.509053111076355,
0.005166482646018267,
-0.7010020017623901,
-0.23903922736644745,
0.1816524714231491,
-0.5229840278625488,
-0.5962415337562561,
0.011621285229921341,
-0.28221139311790466,
0.28961023688316345,
0.10769619792699814,
-0.7539194822311401,
0.09265397489070892,
-0.3791889250278473,
0.3401520252227783,
0.9962390661239624,
0.07834477722644806,
0.2645453214645386,
-0.34142088890075684,
0.44912105798721313,
0.0720532089471817,
0.25561437010765076,
0.6155911684036255,
-0.5024967193603516,
-0.5681504011154175,
-0.08420004695653915,
-0.19452206790447235,
0.1556473821401596,
-0.2912564277648926,
0.21841438114643097,
-0.2798071801662445,
-0.6829334497451782,
-0.2132101058959961,
0.09268972277641296,
0.35393133759498596,
-0.01776563748717308,
0.012340396642684937,
-0.22043177485466003,
-0.41728460788726807,
-1.119323968887329,
-0.378480464220047,
-0.2263980358839035,
-0.23643872141838074,
0.39727577567100525,
0.5944018363952637,
-0.4465494751930237,
0.7106078267097473,
-0.5666908025741577,
0.1571105420589447,
-0.3550664484500885,
-0.06726823002099991,
0.12843187153339386,
0.009476898238062859,
0.5940495729446411,
-0.6965035796165466,
-0.16493578255176544,
-0.4706783890724182,
-0.27561086416244507,
-0.30896320939064026,
0.14690905809402466,
-0.0551108680665493,
0.22446955740451813,
0.28717494010925293,
-0.6508837342262268,
0.2733544111251831,
0.6047199964523315,
-0.33621782064437866,
0.7716426253318787,
0.011629398912191391,
-0.11925291270017624,
-0.867675244808197,
-0.00577702047303319,
0.2063126116991043,
0.20961765944957733,
-0.3321780562400818,
-0.17189176380634308,
-0.024325024336576462,
0.21174196898937225,
-0.06160217523574829,
0.48868319392204285,
-0.46480774879455566,
-0.36213675141334534,
-0.0010916122701019049,
0.21334202587604523,
0.012907678261399269,
0.33986273407936096,
-0.05420152470469475,
0.46716058254241943,
0.3774736225605011,
-0.6080619096755981,
0.2636932134628296,
0.09873556345701218,
-0.36305713653564453,
0.5877737998962402,
-0.6366350054740906,
0.3511243462562561,
-0.6500870585441589,
0.5667445063591003,
-1.176455020904541,
-0.4223826229572296,
0.013534452766180038,
-0.5790738463401794,
-0.04058510810136795,
-0.045053284615278244,
-0.19415733218193054,
-0.492271363735199,
-0.5872747898101807,
0.23309579491615295,
0.4740811586380005,
-0.3585435152053833,
0.28863096237182617,
0.5651727914810181,
-0.18964074552059174,
-0.5204870700836182,
-0.6950702667236328,
0.004291360732167959,
-0.46309903264045715,
-0.35112079977989197,
-0.14256775379180908,
-0.27135276794433594,
-0.6163315176963806,
-0.44918039441108704,
0.0013097372138872743,
-0.07964008301496506,
0.0826544314622879,
0.2817121744155884,
0.23799201846122742,
0.1849367916584015,
0.08498861640691757,
-0.09512880444526672,
0.3455663025379181,
0.551489531993866,
-0.05741925910115242,
0.7297009229660034,
0.19237108528614044,
-0.3951040506362915,
0.02839381992816925,
0.22977472841739655,
0.9293626546859741,
-0.14672821760177612,
0.6332114934921265,
0.3237099349498749,
-0.24788983166217804,
-0.043804194778203964,
-0.8503460884094238,
-0.49353599548339844,
-0.40793880820274353,
0.5623120069503784,
-0.349168062210083,
-0.8926454186439514,
0.6166267395019531,
0.3104640245437622,
0.09760455042123795,
0.14547747373580933,
0.764883279800415,
0.004567106254398823,
1.291063904762268,
0.2905275225639343,
-0.1957377940416336,
0.38721904158592224,
-0.029706647619605064,
0.0835060179233551,
-0.8884464502334595,
-0.1715923547744751,
-0.5211729407310486,
-0.39679256081581116,
-0.7587258815765381,
-0.18504488468170166,
0.4217800796031952,
-0.4135817587375641,
-0.49754247069358826,
-0.07638899236917496,
-0.31822988390922546,
0.48436543345451355,
0.2844037413597107,
0.25480732321739197,
0.16619673371315002,
-0.09611155092716217,
0.0036470801569521427,
-0.10338929295539856,
-0.2787153720855713,
-0.4889519214630127,
1.391253113746643,
0.5474720597267151,
0.9219046235084534,
0.3526931703090668,
0.6028187274932861,
0.30304524302482605,
0.5127648115158081,
-0.48888134956359863,
0.5723713040351868,
0.025681668892502785,
-0.9416652321815491,
-0.5489298105239868,
-0.21115471422672272,
-0.8267475962638855,
0.27049314975738525,
-0.18804731965065002,
-0.980726420879364,
0.4222535192966461,
0.24799369275569916,
-0.38632574677467346,
0.08072399348020554,
-0.6894578337669373,
0.44958874583244324,
-0.25047767162323,
-0.6035569906234741,
-0.15219129621982574,
-0.7071956396102905,
0.6095384955406189,
-0.2712384760379791,
0.210346519947052,
-0.2712903618812561,
0.19177323579788208,
0.5606179237365723,
-0.11534662544727325,
1.1749274730682373,
-0.24600055813789368,
-0.40692681074142456,
-0.03130156174302101,
0.1427907943725586,
0.724202036857605,
0.25230979919433594,
-0.2694550156593323,
0.06641757488250732,
0.0388844758272171,
-0.5337993502616882,
-0.6191609501838684,
0.8365653157234192,
-1.000970482826233,
-0.7795749306678772,
-0.41320526599884033,
-0.24244704842567444,
-0.4957793951034546,
-0.011559601873159409,
0.20963604748249054,
0.20160599052906036,
-0.3836623728275299,
0.08903847634792328,
0.7122549414634705,
-0.47964906692504883,
0.03433886170387268,
0.5959399938583374,
-0.21316687762737274,
-0.05985347181558609,
0.4751751720905304,
0.16857492923736572,
0.6722811460494995,
0.031353674829006195,
0.4235236942768097,
-0.36717841029167175,
-0.43715232610702515,
-0.1892917901277542,
0.48344364762306213,
-0.41866952180862427,
0.2829817831516266,
-0.65364009141922,
0.016999797895550728,
-0.607459545135498,
0.03625253215432167,
-0.27737417817115784,
-0.12706787884235382,
0.07628115266561508,
-0.21001918613910675,
0.21484699845314026,
0.9652480483055115,
0.15042456984519958,
0.08382553607225418,
-0.37679797410964966,
0.2367432862520218,
0.4596615433692932,
0.34117916226387024,
0.23158079385757446,
-0.6870530247688293,
-0.030383002012968063,
0.3047645688056946,
-0.27674204111099243,
-0.9414492845535278,
0.18654364347457886,
-0.10155412554740906,
0.39335334300994873,
0.5044043660163879,
0.08167782425880432,
0.36553704738616943,
-0.16430014371871948,
0.8040173649787903,
-0.14978155493736267,
-0.5676164031028748,
0.24295036494731903,
-0.6772399544715881,
0.2657106816768646,
0.5207628607749939,
0.5710229873657227,
-0.5011098384857178,
-0.5229200720787048,
-0.6816123127937317,
-0.7542068362236023,
0.47826215624809265,
-0.2560986876487732,
0.32249370217323303,
-0.3335458040237427,
0.4076828956604004,
0.05671413987874985,
0.27241745591163635,
-0.8678562045097351,
-0.14556488394737244,
-0.04761462286114693,
0.24166321754455566,
-0.12732867896556854,
-0.7223122119903564,
-0.131906196475029,
-0.3761902153491974,
0.45846885442733765,
-0.034784846007823944,
0.1405363827943802,
0.12006877362728119,
0.14415283501148224,
-0.07222075760364532,
0.5157784819602966,
0.6960818767547607,
0.844971239566803,
-0.41460996866226196,
0.2922159433364868,
0.3056308925151825,
-0.7491132020950317,
0.1734800636768341,
-0.174192413687706,
-0.17665161192417145,
-0.2933172285556793,
0.02859833650290966,
0.508548378944397,
0.07343839108943939,
-0.5110250115394592,
0.566983699798584,
0.033954210579395294,
-0.210000678896904,
-0.7897989749908447,
-0.07559838891029358,
0.34386762976646423,
0.19197095930576324,
0.27839815616607666,
-0.32777807116508484,
-0.001718637882731855,
-0.8083882927894592,
-0.19207797944545746,
0.7661275267601013,
-0.31557565927505493,
-0.5798696279525757,
0.687896728515625,
0.2524583637714386,
-0.11116498708724976,
0.40526607632637024,
-0.275737464427948,
-0.4140605926513672,
0.44303250312805176,
0.4699740409851074,
0.8468190431594849,
-0.2473195195198059,
0.3300839960575104,
0.1808723360300064,
0.34907451272010803,
0.039168234914541245,
0.4464879333972931,
0.11427804082632065,
-0.9232714176177979,
-0.2510563135147095,
-0.7239927053451538,
-0.4099854826927185,
0.590212881565094,
-0.49527448415756226,
0.19120334088802338,
-0.46211087703704834,
-0.31414318084716797,
0.06237901747226715,
-0.1343381106853485,
-0.6245781183242798,
0.10587780177593231,
0.19891980290412903,
0.5644656419754028,
-1.0196231603622437,
0.7489652633666992,
0.8041133880615234,
-0.290202260017395,
-0.542365550994873,
0.3698679804801941,
0.23251895606517792,
-0.9928745627403259,
0.8784977197647095,
0.009629594162106514,
-0.021950997412204742,
-0.15997214615345,
-0.6378219127655029,
-0.9300146698951721,
0.7349657416343689,
0.4103752374649048,
-0.4727505147457123,
-0.2372523546218872,
0.3137024939060211,
0.6129038333892822,
-0.11399449408054352,
0.46121856570243835,
0.9396014213562012,
0.5674512982368469,
-0.11946781724691391,
-0.8466387391090393,
0.1925583928823471,
-0.008183170109987259,
0.04441549628973007,
0.22133825719356537,
-0.8302944898605347,
0.6667089462280273,
-0.4594782292842865,
0.07300485670566559,
-0.20549264550209045,
0.14623017609119415,
0.38649314641952515,
0.21909800171852112,
0.5160725116729736,
0.2537127435207367,
0.6090258955955505,
0.130870059132576,
1.0217812061309814,
-0.17708052694797516,
0.11523294448852539,
1.005398154258728,
-0.4629727602005005,
0.5051594376564026,
0.575480043888092,
-0.35429930686950684,
0.4540380835533142,
0.5339693427085876,
0.20883546769618988,
0.18278546631336212,
0.6593369245529175,
-0.2602694630622864,
-0.25374582409858704,
0.02200213633477688,
-0.10095416754484177,
0.6374930143356323,
0.48015835881233215,
-0.5795407891273499,
-0.039514485746622086,
-0.09856390208005905,
0.3903990089893341,
-0.03413734957575798,
0.0020225143525749445,
0.47152602672576904,
0.03396064043045044,
-0.5993053913116455,
0.5574852824211121,
-0.27066609263420105,
0.8369342088699341,
-0.6173409223556519,
0.16842488944530487,
-0.43793636560440063,
0.19755986332893372,
-0.2528160810470581,
-0.7129466533660889,
0.17375604808330536,
-0.09392014145851135,
-0.3496840000152588,
0.037222765386104584,
0.5117367506027222,
-0.23081284761428833,
-0.4050467610359192,
0.257660835981369,
0.5975934267044067,
0.4679248332977295,
-0.33585959672927856,
-0.38672491908073425,
0.015097512863576412,
0.11733552068471909,
-0.6003081798553467,
0.7489676475524902,
0.3217695951461792,
-0.37705713510513306,
0.815807044506073,
0.6339057087898254,
0.34247979521751404,
-0.09563124924898148,
0.29413869976997375,
0.8726417422294617,
-0.6427693963050842,
-0.25861310958862305,
-1.1387388706207275,
0.1276981681585312,
-0.2292928695678711,
-0.31225866079330444,
0.9028431177139282,
0.4287796914577484,
0.6630547046661377,
0.054292742162942886,
1.0139330625534058,
0.14024822413921356,
0.6556463837623596,
-0.14247679710388184,
0.8802667260169983,
-0.24811792373657227,
0.4816233515739441,
-0.6467218995094299,
-1.0077356100082397,
0.06097890064120293,
0.2837095558643341,
-0.8619822859764099,
0.2875007390975952,
0.44718319177627563,
0.8542354702949524,
0.21737076342105865,
-0.14962045848369598,
0.4052097201347351,
0.41707396507263184,
0.3683803379535675,
0.5044166445732117,
0.7819520235061646,
0.20724456012248993,
0.40427541732788086,
-0.06353703141212463,
-0.341964453458786,
-0.08884265273809433,
-0.5728456377983093,
-1.1543776988983154,
-0.4358508586883545,
-0.12059571593999863,
-0.5042573809623718,
0.1424902081489563,
0.8340116739273071,
0.311042845249176,
-0.49660128355026245,
-0.13363607227802277,
0.2541155219078064,
0.11537162959575653,
0.21521057188510895,
-0.3202548027038574,
0.19577264785766602,
0.15844957530498505,
-0.6245254278182983,
-0.17979028820991516,
0.05011061578989029,
0.09070225059986115,
-0.8173137307167053,
0.18381232023239136,
-0.1428445279598236,
0.30788975954055786,
0.708859384059906,
0.22185185551643372,
-0.7069076299667358,
-0.798095166683197,
0.16126959025859833,
-0.0030565934721380472,
-0.2342246174812317,
0.5885636210441589,
-0.5852436423301697,
0.10173667967319489,
0.38565489649772644,
0.300128310918808,
0.3058513104915619,
0.056696679443120956,
0.6668744087219238,
-0.5950801968574524,
-0.07177606225013733,
0.13713295757770538,
0.19713276624679565,
0.37504225969314575,
-0.483066588640213,
0.23763976991176605,
0.18495695292949677,
-0.8355830907821655,
-0.7700551748275757,
0.46588754653930664,
-0.5007402300834656,
-0.08573906123638153,
1.55474853515625,
0.28402894735336304,
-0.041086357086896896,
-0.3227972388267517,
-0.2601124942302704,
-0.1822342872619629,
-0.4414081871509552,
1.2864881753921509,
0.945259153842926,
-0.3302272856235504,
-0.052456632256507874,
-0.6863536834716797,
0.5823954939842224,
0.39621853828430176,
-0.6168985962867737,
0.37923893332481384,
0.7505339980125427,
0.5481373071670532,
0.021591076627373695,
0.8292737007141113,
-0.24261221289634705,
0.11976739019155502,
-0.25709083676338196,
-0.07819391787052155,
0.32641130685806274,
0.0774293839931488,
-0.25897204875946045,
0.04180561378598213,
0.41083258390426636,
0.09922072291374207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05966v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05966v1
|
Natural Language Processing RELIES on Linguistics
| 2024-05-09T17:59:32 | 2024-05-09T17:59:32 |
Juri Opitz, Shira Wein, Nathan Schneider
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become capable of generating highly fluent
text in certain languages, without modules specially designed to capture
grammar or semantic coherence. What does this mean for the future of linguistic
expertise in NLP? We highlight several aspects in which NLP (still) relies on
linguistics, or where linguistic thinking can illuminate new directions. We
argue our case around the acronym $RELIES$ that encapsulates six major facets
where linguistics contributes to NLP: $R$esources, $E$valuation, $L$ow-resource
settings, $I$nterpretability, $E$xplanation, and the $S$tudy of language. This
list is not exhaustive, nor is linguistics the main point of reference for
every effort under these themes; but at a macro level, these facets highlight
the enduring importance of studying machine systems vis-a-vis systems of human
language.
|
[
-0.5805084109306335,
-0.6549481153488159,
0.4139527678489685,
0.4184756278991699,
0.27210497856140137,
0.1467972844839096,
-0.23538681864738464,
-0.9162588119506836,
0.4347180724143982,
0.7475317120552063,
-0.5323429703712463,
0.04702511429786682,
-0.722657322883606,
0.350066602230072,
-0.35296517610549927,
0.9227519035339355,
0.5674213767051697,
-0.07841260731220245,
-0.4391150176525116,
-0.2368210107088089,
-0.5044021606445312,
-0.79354327917099,
-0.7555376291275024,
-0.6439313888549805,
0.4734233319759369,
0.10244984924793243,
1.0812636613845825,
0.4871239960193634,
0.3856011629104614,
0.34920355677604675,
-0.30927321314811707,
-0.17047685384750366,
-0.23588407039642334,
0.4450019299983978,
-0.39254996180534363,
-0.6783193349838257,
-0.3758859932422638,
0.06215303763747215,
0.5294510126113892,
1.2201497554779053,
0.09349910914897919,
-0.14293164014816284,
0.16640785336494446,
0.7692952752113342,
-0.36287930607795715,
0.40631455183029175,
-0.8981066942214966,
0.14074186980724335,
-0.2510380446910858,
-0.18807128071784973,
-0.26429638266563416,
0.039053574204444885,
0.45408394932746887,
-0.33983176946640015,
-0.08003783226013184,
0.0363629125058651,
0.7622982859611511,
0.49709972739219666,
-0.09874078631401062,
-0.4104377031326294,
-0.5904679894447327,
0.8059739470481873,
-0.7656491994857788,
0.5559172630310059,
0.6765725016593933,
0.027445631101727486,
-0.4104970693588257,
-0.6960336565971375,
-0.2807234525680542,
-0.3678402006626129,
-0.12052614986896515,
-0.13259339332580566,
-0.03088839165866375,
0.17669332027435303,
0.4072457551956177,
0.35746604204177856,
-0.17553479969501495,
0.43345165252685547,
-0.42871785163879395,
-0.03646133840084076,
0.4101574122905731,
-0.05032635107636452,
0.5854954719543457,
-0.027257675305008888,
0.005827967543154955,
0.5250586271286011,
-0.7860982418060303,
-0.2260422706604004,
-0.06204327940940857,
0.30801913142204285,
0.05026046186685562,
0.6153326034545898,
-0.15934331715106964,
0.6982045769691467,
-0.25011807680130005,
-0.19281572103500366,
-0.07394663989543915,
-0.1390191614627838,
-0.02884078025817871,
-0.2418477088212967,
0.6200889348983765,
-0.04900755733251572,
0.6705666184425354,
-0.26481893658638,
-0.14247927069664001,
0.04364262893795967,
0.32206058502197266,
-0.28693461418151855,
-0.3934512138366699,
0.18730665743350983,
0.026536518707871437,
0.10855810344219208,
-0.22568094730377197,
-0.5783307552337646,
-0.39858198165893555,
-0.5878970623016357,
-0.14100909233093262,
-0.34059569239616394,
-0.05664703994989395,
-0.01979634538292885,
-0.027649540454149246,
0.26544827222824097,
0.21657955646514893,
-1.2409489154815674,
0.3948191702365875,
0.9831053018569946,
0.788309633731842,
0.006163531448692083,
-0.4352377951145172,
-0.5443094372749329,
0.062299955636262894,
-0.17741864919662476,
0.9149225354194641,
-0.6127399206161499,
-0.1513862907886505,
0.11044260859489441,
-0.04555132985115051,
-0.018167339265346527,
-0.5746565461158752,
0.4937635660171509,
-0.5379012227058411,
0.014919141307473183,
-0.22499366104602814,
-0.7077636122703552,
-0.34156715869903564,
0.08084166049957275,
-0.9064728617668152,
1.1464003324508667,
-0.17593632638454437,
-0.5645532011985779,
0.31070685386657715,
-0.6338796615600586,
-0.6078559160232544,
0.3798060715198517,
-0.16634820401668549,
0.13843607902526855,
0.22564582526683807,
-0.08289708942174911,
0.492911696434021,
-0.16854484379291534,
0.38367488980293274,
-0.3502541482448578,
0.17537231743335724,
0.4241679608821869,
-0.1634289026260376,
0.9942326545715332,
-0.12983301281929016,
-0.3498290181159973,
-0.28763124346733093,
-0.9951801896095276,
-0.023323774337768555,
-0.3484291136264801,
-0.5152279138565063,
-0.24929513037204742,
0.40242376923561096,
-0.025985632091760635,
0.2308841496706009,
0.21624241769313812,
-0.16898436844348907,
0.034950777888298035,
-0.803073525428772,
0.6164000630378723,
0.6436361074447632,
-0.47716715931892395,
0.6591024398803711,
-0.09640102833509445,
0.5895320177078247,
-0.6036269664764404,
-0.27602291107177734,
-0.06897060573101044,
-0.8715705275535583,
-1.0922259092330933,
-0.07572630047798157,
0.07267015427350998,
0.5897093415260315,
-0.6992436647415161,
0.31813913583755493,
0.06591566652059555,
-0.20001131296157837,
-0.10475964844226837,
0.2633761465549469,
0.2228335440158844,
0.09725868701934814,
0.2894820272922516,
-0.33999016880989075,
-0.8954581618309021,
-0.9170703887939453,
-0.3426624834537506,
-0.1570102423429489,
0.061848800629377365,
-0.1385519951581955,
0.4965718984603882,
-0.052636805921792984,
1.0866485834121704,
-0.1456095576286316,
-0.3748827278614044,
-0.5820185542106628,
-0.017469823360443115,
0.18629327416419983,
0.2568661570549011,
0.6074588298797607,
-0.39476433396339417,
-0.3203413188457489,
-0.09580880403518677,
-0.8560227751731873,
-0.5141614675521851,
-0.0062302593141794205,
0.04858587682247162,
0.4823712706565857,
0.739424467086792,
-0.8590885400772095,
0.1858213245868683,
0.7317832708358765,
-0.2354428917169571,
0.6138181686401367,
-0.22359439730644226,
-0.6216080784797668,
-0.6256652474403381,
0.2878841459751129,
0.026463959366083145,
-0.15841305255889893,
-0.9008147120475769,
0.23869626224040985,
-0.45644164085388184,
-0.12036248296499252,
-0.2078881561756134,
0.605675995349884,
-0.5854009389877319,
-0.3521416485309601,
-0.5574889183044434,
0.1412883996963501,
0.01885858364403248,
0.15003305673599243,
0.22220271825790405,
0.44567346572875977,
0.5872308015823364,
-0.736217737197876,
0.28784120082855225,
0.023649610579013824,
-0.06704142689704895,
0.577907919883728,
-0.48324498534202576,
0.07685917615890503,
0.16086725890636444,
0.13102568686008453,
-0.42386749386787415,
-0.2706826329231262,
0.11497575044631958,
-0.3918193280696869,
0.307039737701416,
-0.141618013381958,
-0.5534754991531372,
-0.2681785821914673,
0.0008452375186607242,
0.008446769788861275,
0.19395136833190918,
0.019409622997045517,
0.5428720712661743,
0.9105910658836365,
-0.38227277994155884,
-0.5309925675392151,
-0.9052118062973022,
0.6836722493171692,
0.15697212517261505,
-0.5391831994056702,
-0.15356050431728363,
0.1201922670006752,
-0.7526845932006836,
0.0012232366716489196,
0.3014242649078369,
-0.2315608263015747,
0.43055498600006104,
0.2842958867549896,
0.15531764924526215,
-0.2945188283920288,
0.322512686252594,
-0.39539140462875366,
-0.42035841941833496,
0.28644973039627075,
-0.5578362345695496,
0.5879165530204773,
-0.18506325781345367,
-0.12391213327646255,
-0.15534642338752747,
0.44567546248435974,
0.5643713474273682,
-0.1397220343351364,
0.6733875870704651,
0.20115111768245697,
-0.3209129869937897,
-0.4794679880142212,
-0.43673771619796753,
-0.09750578552484512,
-0.4214949309825897,
0.5034173727035522,
-0.09635583311319351,
-1.0226022005081177,
0.41284507513046265,
0.4678748846054077,
0.18962223827838898,
0.6425427198410034,
0.5071390271186829,
-0.2765912115573883,
0.5779234766960144,
0.9741514325141907,
-0.18661023676395416,
0.33963727951049805,
-0.04542418569326401,
0.44345465302467346,
-0.5246933102607727,
-0.04059353470802307,
-0.6714480519294739,
-0.251956582069397,
-0.7206912040710449,
-0.28191015124320984,
0.19656851887702942,
-0.3085571229457855,
0.07142871618270874,
0.4135390818119049,
-0.1914622038602829,
0.43996572494506836,
0.8279837369918823,
-0.37568387389183044,
0.4111103415489197,
-0.1397770345211029,
0.209894061088562,
-0.15241602063179016,
-0.8495502471923828,
-0.5966517329216003,
0.8893923759460449,
0.31247174739837646,
0.5621619820594788,
-0.29561036825180054,
0.26531705260276794,
0.16348111629486084,
0.1046973243355751,
-1.0974012613296509,
0.8971793055534363,
-0.170368030667305,
-0.6059068441390991,
-0.22536666691303253,
-0.0757705494761467,
-1.0673115253448486,
0.15697841346263885,
-0.441277414560318,
-0.5552144050598145,
-0.11190327256917953,
0.007056681904941797,
-0.2826816141605377,
0.25352784991264343,
-0.2884717583656311,
0.48033326864242554,
-0.24199843406677246,
-0.10836435109376907,
-0.16872425377368927,
-0.6165434718132019,
0.22138792276382446,
0.03402414545416832,
0.45946982502937317,
-0.2832423150539398,
-0.14659340679645538,
0.8170820474624634,
-0.3854512572288513,
1.037011742591858,
0.11842015385627747,
-0.32284221053123474,
0.17156551778316498,
0.07255685329437256,
-0.021695667877793312,
-0.14382758736610413,
-0.0034860006999224424,
0.2302435338497162,
0.005715772043913603,
-0.31457260251045227,
-0.27284154295921326,
0.6268258690834045,
-0.3958801031112671,
-0.7620526552200317,
-0.6180379390716553,
-0.8077319264411926,
-0.3977178931236267,
0.3440069854259491,
0.08255340903997421,
0.42170417308807373,
-0.17006179690361023,
0.08345452696084976,
0.7101457118988037,
-0.17965732514858246,
0.4333648681640625,
0.08925318717956543,
-0.5411291122436523,
-0.14628686010837555,
0.8476236462593079,
0.41767334938049316,
0.4022389352321625,
0.277396559715271,
0.056529369205236435,
-0.09935661405324936,
-0.6688681840896606,
-0.17112794518470764,
0.44487276673316956,
-1.018487811088562,
-0.02973654307425022,
-0.8469493389129639,
-0.4055316746234894,
-0.24901272356510162,
-0.30916765332221985,
-0.4388139545917511,
-0.5034158825874329,
-0.37122052907943726,
-0.06360796093940735,
0.3589324653148651,
1.0412923097610474,
-0.1068059653043747,
0.10076534748077393,
-0.9208453893661499,
0.21198062598705292,
0.2521706819534302,
0.33073344826698303,
-0.1343574821949005,
-0.40042200684547424,
-0.42691364884376526,
-0.10821912437677383,
-0.09267327189445496,
-0.49218040704727173,
0.4273171126842499,
0.7154248952865601,
0.7313651442527771,
0.11544428765773773,
-0.254605233669281,
0.14828647673130035,
-0.46768391132354736,
0.7869827151298523,
-0.019491592422127724,
-0.965126097202301,
0.3507424294948578,
-0.2823439836502075,
0.4882476031780243,
0.5398324728012085,
0.35732755064964294,
-0.7915234565734863,
-1.0346932411193848,
-0.602314829826355,
-0.8947843313217163,
0.5404017567634583,
-0.011847184039652348,
0.17722541093826294,
-0.13153329491615295,
0.05218280106782913,
0.13536034524440765,
0.007495866157114506,
-0.9006014466285706,
-0.07688501477241516,
0.21587854623794556,
0.1422472894191742,
-0.05859146639704704,
-0.32333147525787354,
0.05183956399559975,
-0.25413426756858826,
0.515977144241333,
-0.23139409720897675,
-0.01125296764075756,
-0.13796573877334595,
-0.25963935256004333,
0.19509337842464447,
0.19916944205760956,
0.4231821894645691,
0.8965194821357727,
0.21463310718536377,
0.48332202434539795,
0.13449501991271973,
-0.49595510959625244,
-0.16306155920028687,
-0.2783897817134857,
-0.41134291887283325,
0.17252731323242188,
0.6514317989349365,
0.4615817666053772,
0.6407359838485718,
-0.6290549635887146,
0.049750685691833496,
0.4813807010650635,
-0.2202889621257782,
-0.4612525701522827,
-0.05992136523127556,
0.4847271144390106,
0.15671364963054657,
0.29197537899017334,
0.3163447678089142,
0.0434139221906662,
-1.0535578727722168,
0.2632385492324829,
0.503934919834137,
-0.4523329734802246,
-0.5268383622169495,
0.4749663770198822,
0.1311652660369873,
-0.172135591506958,
0.4289584159851074,
-0.0016935426974669099,
-0.8240504264831543,
0.47492608428001404,
0.3756791353225708,
0.9235880374908447,
-0.00651965057477355,
-0.043360501527786255,
0.1942494809627533,
0.40053147077560425,
-0.26350077986717224,
0.15169687569141388,
0.23819614946842194,
-0.625705897808075,
-0.7992528080940247,
-0.858430027961731,
-0.4176323711872101,
-0.14843477308750153,
-0.27867016196250916,
0.3802025318145752,
-0.7563521862030029,
-0.13448165357112885,
0.19735294580459595,
-0.26343855261802673,
-0.44484883546829224,
0.16569535434246063,
0.5402705073356628,
0.7811897397041321,
-0.7663289308547974,
0.8151525855064392,
0.6242495775222778,
-0.21812182664871216,
-0.37142834067344666,
-0.22285254299640656,
0.19371581077575684,
-0.7968922853469849,
1.033170461654663,
0.27811434864997864,
-0.2770947515964508,
-0.00734588410705328,
-0.4701632857322693,
-1.0427052974700928,
0.5400765538215637,
0.4057855010032654,
-0.19713003933429718,
-0.18277081847190857,
0.24007801711559296,
0.7847546339035034,
-0.28727197647094727,
0.1656865030527115,
0.8420054912567139,
0.5070372819900513,
-0.15163324773311615,
-1.267885446548462,
-0.1694004386663437,
-0.19499871134757996,
0.01383210439234972,
0.14323608577251434,
-0.1449529081583023,
0.7872892618179321,
-0.11209654062986374,
-0.4156750738620758,
-0.02668110653758049,
0.72698575258255,
-0.0006334519130177796,
0.09042768180370331,
0.12562230229377747,
0.6396939158439636,
0.6579538583755493,
-0.08450427651405334,
1.016472339630127,
-0.2093961536884308,
-0.010142616927623749,
1.0880032777786255,
-0.08154024928808212,
0.9950148463249207,
0.5364860892295837,
-0.5501654744148254,
0.48050567507743835,
0.34819620847702026,
0.12049809098243713,
-0.02096887119114399,
0.2153603583574295,
-0.12137433141469955,
-0.20972028374671936,
-0.24349269270896912,
-0.15868927538394928,
0.7018419504165649,
0.7662959098815918,
-0.2298928052186966,
-0.29308220744132996,
0.06349635869264603,
0.1414109170436859,
0.31966128945350647,
-0.3150545358657837,
0.8341602087020874,
0.5140771269798279,
-0.8402070999145508,
0.5348495244979858,
-0.40088951587677,
0.8120723962783813,
-0.5969017148017883,
0.12497584521770477,
-0.12917447090148926,
-0.07171709835529327,
-0.48001354932785034,
-0.9155014157295227,
0.8438160419464111,
-0.13507507741451263,
-0.20006266236305237,
-0.3996076285839081,
0.8015351891517639,
-0.2683448791503906,
-0.4915454685688019,
0.5158072113990784,
0.7374871969223022,
0.31295374035835266,
-0.0846712663769722,
-0.5499690175056458,
-0.006427297368645668,
-0.30738234519958496,
-0.3328712284564972,
0.5122562050819397,
0.5359367728233337,
0.055823542177677155,
0.9478932023048401,
0.4841321110725403,
0.5075582265853882,
0.3305828869342804,
0.09737075120210648,
0.7171155214309692,
-0.6569773554801941,
-0.3467373549938202,
-0.8973878026008606,
0.1646299809217453,
0.15215080976486206,
-0.2741822600364685,
0.7141382694244385,
0.27499696612358093,
0.7152814865112305,
0.051948510110378265,
0.8948584198951721,
-0.32785505056381226,
0.41121065616607666,
-0.6628486514091492,
0.8195596933364868,
-0.38345572352409363,
0.374966561794281,
-0.10279001295566559,
-0.9897933602333069,
-0.7621675133705139,
0.4698028862476349,
-0.47073715925216675,
-0.043323442339897156,
0.7923727631568909,
0.5458274483680725,
0.26282379031181335,
0.08896824717521667,
0.4831402599811554,
0.13669155538082123,
0.16801750659942627,
0.24117323756217957,
0.9142236709594727,
0.0960543155670166,
0.26756760478019714,
-0.18142947554588318,
-0.11238600313663483,
-0.22061434388160706,
-0.8424046635627747,
-0.6787794232368469,
-0.6514149308204651,
-0.19229406118392944,
-0.1759612262248993,
-0.32437118887901306,
0.8608395457267761,
0.3988627791404724,
-0.7713865041732788,
-0.5195057392120361,
-0.17398948967456818,
0.11955074965953827,
0.07943994551897049,
-0.24332574009895325,
-0.004929373972117901,
-0.9904405474662781,
-0.7283511161804199,
0.38830527663230896,
0.8264457583427429,
-0.30234411358833313,
-0.4334489703178406,
0.15963071584701538,
-0.534058153629303,
-0.0867520123720169,
0.8894917964935303,
0.6890081167221069,
-1.0419846773147583,
-0.3889855742454529,
0.028259718790650368,
-0.08454972505569458,
0.1527332067489624,
0.7941694259643555,
-0.7446607947349548,
0.340783953666687,
0.5959163308143616,
0.7368525266647339,
-0.10564994812011719,
-0.524752676486969,
0.9039019346237183,
-0.40834084153175354,
0.18537703156471252,
0.5175468325614929,
0.47244012355804443,
0.4587107300758362,
-0.0339975580573082,
0.518520712852478,
0.6299369931221008,
-0.7006574869155884,
-0.5374456644058228,
0.47289949655532837,
-0.8550785779953003,
-0.25467991828918457,
1.1704224348068237,
-0.11246910691261292,
-0.2910946309566498,
-0.7988467216491699,
-0.11268867552280426,
-0.1425548642873764,
-0.06187811121344566,
0.510129988193512,
0.8856489062309265,
-0.13192199170589447,
-0.4866529107093811,
-1.0526785850524902,
0.6672215461730957,
0.5720471739768982,
-0.6813765168190002,
0.06605619192123413,
0.4515814185142517,
-0.011169953271746635,
0.35508447885513306,
0.8262120485305786,
0.17799170315265656,
0.017882097512483597,
0.14672330021858215,
0.14877142012119293,
0.4329977035522461,
-0.2591598331928253,
-0.22853964567184448,
0.19741541147232056,
0.4874524772167206,
0.5965667366981506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05957v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05957v1
|
OpenBA-V2: Reaching 77.3% High Compression Ratio with Fast Multi-Stage Pruning
| 2024-05-09T17:53:28 | 2024-05-09T17:53:28 |
Dan Qiao, Yi Su, Pinzheng Wang, Jing Ye, Wenjing Xie, Yuechi Zhou, Yuyang Ding, Zecheng Tang, Jikai Wang, Yixin Ji, Yue Wang, Pei Guo, Zechen Sun, Zikang Zhang, Juntao Li, Pingfu Chao, Wenliang Chen, Guohong Fu, Guodong Zhou, Qiaoming Zhu, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have played an important role in many fields due
to their powerful capabilities.However, their massive number of parameters
leads to high deployment requirements and incurs significant inference costs,
which impedes their practical applications. Training smaller models is an
effective way to address this problem. Therefore, we introduce OpenBA-V2, a
3.4B model derived from multi-stage compression and continual pre-training from
the original 15B OpenBA model. OpenBA-V2 utilizes more data, more flexible
training objectives, and techniques such as layer pruning, neural pruning, and
vocabulary pruning to achieve a compression rate of 77.3\% with minimal
performance loss. OpenBA-V2 demonstrates competitive performance compared to
other open-source models of similar size, achieving results close to or on par
with the 15B OpenBA model in downstream tasks such as common sense reasoning
and Named Entity Recognition (NER). OpenBA-V2 illustrates that LLMs can be
compressed into smaller ones with minimal performance loss by employing
advanced training objectives and data strategies, which may help deploy LLMs in
resource-limited scenarios.
|
[
-0.42855900526046753,
-0.6723237037658691,
0.4023626446723938,
0.3027917146682739,
-0.3543755114078522,
-0.3234207034111023,
-0.4155628979206085,
-0.46351557970046997,
-0.22057965397834778,
0.6931740641593933,
-0.46096915006637573,
-0.2250322848558426,
-0.6735476851463318,
-0.1262723207473755,
-0.26015856862068176,
0.5678868889808655,
-0.051603469997644424,
0.11644633114337921,
-0.08933020383119583,
0.15359698235988617,
-0.5980556607246399,
-0.5072606205940247,
-0.7424925565719604,
-0.13806994259357452,
0.46609368920326233,
0.6240608096122742,
0.545357346534729,
0.537400484085083,
0.5350387692451477,
0.2434048354625702,
-0.3073805868625641,
0.024099430069327354,
-0.6591576933860779,
0.09831638634204865,
0.14305777847766876,
-0.6722321510314941,
-0.3988114595413208,
0.017185062170028687,
0.6465737819671631,
0.5496665835380554,
-0.39630287885665894,
0.3027443587779999,
0.04178573936223984,
0.813885509967804,
-0.39146432280540466,
0.29030919075012207,
-0.7389258742332458,
0.04236012324690819,
-0.1084461510181427,
0.07859843969345093,
-0.5900769829750061,
-0.32433465123176575,
-0.3657730221748352,
-0.27930203080177307,
0.16730108857154846,
0.025427548214793205,
0.9550336003303528,
0.20638702809810638,
-0.2826659083366394,
0.10733678936958313,
-0.8179595470428467,
0.8438121676445007,
-0.8171800374984741,
0.34051036834716797,
0.1593645215034485,
0.4782121479511261,
-0.14019843935966492,
-0.6857738494873047,
-0.5203081965446472,
-0.2417827695608139,
0.2519519031047821,
-0.07555519044399261,
-0.17553411424160004,
0.03974628448486328,
0.3538403809070587,
0.36188921332359314,
-0.47744297981262207,
0.45104116201400757,
-0.8725711107254028,
-0.08771882951259613,
0.1898285448551178,
0.008180852979421616,
-0.040571290999650955,
0.03680788725614548,
-0.4120135009288788,
0.030523663386702538,
-0.9760950207710266,
-0.13398133218288422,
0.4884004592895508,
0.4948475956916809,
0.1420023888349533,
0.6150997281074524,
-0.13253292441368103,
0.7956545948982239,
-0.3168926537036896,
-0.2879401743412018,
0.14549881219863892,
-0.3462010622024536,
-0.33890220522880554,
-0.15895943343639374,
0.5566586852073669,
0.18235386908054352,
0.32103925943374634,
0.19160610437393188,
-0.21892116963863373,
0.02942078933119774,
0.4117482900619507,
-1.1160448789596558,
-0.11863414943218231,
0.1349223554134369,
-0.7081570625305176,
-0.14137718081474304,
0.08491068333387375,
-0.6197636127471924,
-0.1143883690237999,
-0.48013433814048767,
0.4156772494316101,
-0.47350308299064636,
-0.18405362963676453,
0.10675370693206787,
0.11442632973194122,
0.22934222221374512,
0.6256682872772217,
-0.6954818964004517,
0.4916107952594757,
0.8201537132263184,
1.2147493362426758,
0.10264671593904495,
0.08371184021234512,
-0.6328872442245483,
0.11458481103181839,
-0.34373074769973755,
0.4726945757865906,
-0.2311023622751236,
-0.18632666766643524,
0.04710856080055237,
-0.15968415141105652,
0.2898809015750885,
-0.822486162185669,
0.639755368232727,
-0.421736478805542,
-0.0386938638985157,
0.11420509219169617,
-0.3157332241535187,
-0.12080566585063934,
0.105971559882164,
-0.9524143934249878,
0.9779285192489624,
0.37471872568130493,
-0.34253278374671936,
0.24175113439559937,
-0.42568084597587585,
-0.32284101843833923,
-0.011166531592607498,
-0.10110588371753693,
-0.4741480052471161,
0.33639857172966003,
0.13542349636554718,
0.328697144985199,
-0.6484710574150085,
-0.168850377202034,
-0.2501126527786255,
-0.24684639275074005,
-0.22042207419872284,
-0.3317820429801941,
0.6465588808059692,
0.34418508410453796,
0.11729908734560013,
0.06886409968137741,
-0.5642092823982239,
0.020339686423540115,
0.21888862550258636,
-0.6709801554679871,
-0.19441697001457214,
-0.1460357904434204,
-0.17835313081741333,
0.38724246621131897,
0.23943202197551727,
-0.5879573225975037,
0.4478501081466675,
-0.4816058278083801,
0.4013897776603699,
0.5909167528152466,
-0.1338341385126114,
0.3419960141181946,
-0.1957194209098816,
0.5525104403495789,
0.25365176796913147,
0.4682033956050873,
0.044095784425735474,
-0.6498662829399109,
-0.7032313346862793,
-0.4146266281604767,
0.4363054037094116,
0.4221293032169342,
-0.41271519660949707,
0.5137942433357239,
-0.2598077356815338,
-0.6521452069282532,
-0.560212254524231,
0.47877296805381775,
0.27341321110725403,
0.4283049702644348,
0.4168630540370941,
-0.4769504964351654,
-0.5015610456466675,
-1.0529239177703857,
0.09640026837587357,
-0.1410934329032898,
-0.21378456056118011,
0.16751806437969208,
0.32357171177864075,
-0.007667738478630781,
0.7513152956962585,
-0.587586522102356,
-0.5862652063369751,
-0.7530853748321533,
0.25342878699302673,
0.4318830668926239,
0.46603161096572876,
0.5703550577163696,
-0.6676453948020935,
-0.3296739161014557,
-0.29388752579689026,
-0.15567761659622192,
-0.26176515221595764,
0.11399203538894653,
-0.0062532564625144005,
0.45675215125083923,
0.5711209774017334,
-0.7604994773864746,
0.4649733901023865,
0.7512138485908508,
0.14199699461460114,
0.4832398295402527,
-0.34119343757629395,
-0.1850377321243286,
-1.0941506624221802,
-0.16409215331077576,
0.056428369134664536,
-0.01786837726831436,
-0.5642002820968628,
-0.024967791512608528,
0.2589240074157715,
-0.16102071106433868,
-0.6688161492347717,
0.40374597907066345,
-0.8916318416595459,
-0.19497913122177124,
-0.2590194344520569,
0.0875067189335823,
-0.10432133823633194,
0.3677864968776703,
-0.05765901505947113,
0.8568403720855713,
0.37423601746559143,
-0.7886108756065369,
0.3489334285259247,
0.3669438660144806,
-0.811567485332489,
-0.03858279064297676,
-0.5966026782989502,
0.09332018345594406,
-0.08667594939470291,
0.35870903730392456,
-0.7045682072639465,
-0.14283519983291626,
-0.08222480118274689,
-0.3962318003177643,
0.5664414763450623,
-0.2838652431964874,
-0.6066732406616211,
-0.6140621900558472,
-0.45971807837486267,
0.3080519139766693,
0.977398693561554,
-0.465288370847702,
0.4748615026473999,
0.1830115169286728,
-0.35562583804130554,
-0.3902958631515503,
-0.941940426826477,
-0.11185088008642197,
-0.0005963718285784125,
-0.7249475121498108,
0.3256399631500244,
0.027339445427060127,
-0.06149454414844513,
-0.10153882950544357,
-0.38033637404441833,
-0.09062978625297546,
0.04931492358446121,
0.16155411303043365,
0.2410508692264557,
-0.32763463258743286,
-0.115981824696064,
-0.18601620197296143,
0.0346476174890995,
-0.13734634220600128,
-0.2585923373699188,
0.704862117767334,
0.232439786195755,
-0.3072909712791443,
-0.2981656789779663,
0.29196855425834656,
0.24893999099731445,
-0.338021457195282,
1.155837059020996,
0.5880880951881409,
-0.3731189966201782,
-0.29865896701812744,
-0.45786625146865845,
-0.10607166588306427,
-0.4273664951324463,
0.565492570400238,
-0.4333135187625885,
-0.7644675970077515,
0.1427571326494217,
-0.15901967883110046,
0.10658153891563416,
0.3122759461402893,
0.688170313835144,
0.30762267112731934,
0.9225137233734131,
0.7074396014213562,
-0.05378498509526253,
0.6223703026771545,
-0.2654018998146057,
0.4638776183128357,
-0.8608130812644958,
-0.32832276821136475,
-0.8944368362426758,
-0.2473921924829483,
-0.23585499823093414,
-0.7579672336578369,
0.3208025395870209,
0.5883210897445679,
-0.20085716247558594,
0.43002283573150635,
-0.192868173122406,
0.41832637786865234,
0.8190061450004578,
0.2475084513425827,
-0.09655995666980743,
0.11976365000009537,
0.34170055389404297,
0.34950965642929077,
-0.7114147543907166,
-0.6189290285110474,
1.0412992238998413,
0.6058882474899292,
0.8373976349830627,
0.7017133235931396,
0.6013993620872498,
-0.03353983163833618,
0.30056968331336975,
-0.9385193586349487,
0.7620278000831604,
-0.21683624386787415,
-0.5677345395088196,
-0.3284083902835846,
-0.625430703163147,
-0.9500352144241333,
0.012601438909769058,
-0.04250170662999153,
-0.8476694822311401,
-0.25150930881500244,
0.3056524395942688,
-0.4155457019805908,
0.3733792304992676,
-0.7821810245513916,
0.7685481309890747,
-0.12887164950370789,
-0.30026599764823914,
-0.3810831308364868,
-0.6767280697822571,
0.5979837775230408,
-0.27742722630500793,
0.1573030799627304,
-0.09345869719982147,
-0.35911083221435547,
0.7142443060874939,
-0.7578699588775635,
0.5759426951408386,
-0.2929941415786743,
0.002143473830074072,
0.4168660640716553,
0.12019432336091995,
0.4587336480617523,
-0.19746142625808716,
-0.1492261290550232,
0.14095598459243774,
-0.3041480481624603,
-0.5034811496734619,
-0.5975891947746277,
0.6923443675041199,
-0.7712662220001221,
-0.6893340945243835,
-0.22343997657299042,
-0.4244769513607025,
-0.289826899766922,
-0.03961952403187752,
-0.03385413810610771,
0.517076313495636,
-0.04184237867593765,
0.5204329490661621,
0.6843019127845764,
-0.46378442645072937,
0.39725878834724426,
0.4778365194797516,
-0.1384693682193756,
-0.4049404263496399,
0.6374024748802185,
0.10406309366226196,
0.6259088516235352,
0.531690776348114,
0.07783737033605576,
-0.18387869000434875,
-0.8863614797592163,
-0.10275330394506454,
0.24667863547801971,
-0.6460052132606506,
-0.5358723402023315,
-0.4636822044849396,
-0.3276992738246918,
-0.7523027062416077,
0.19068151712417603,
-0.2540455758571625,
-0.4222268760204315,
-0.24613505601882935,
-0.08793753385543823,
0.22749210894107819,
0.8489824533462524,
-0.2551148533821106,
0.5821572542190552,
-1.024441123008728,
0.4136596620082855,
0.1762263923883438,
0.399795264005661,
-0.16973434388637543,
-0.8866580128669739,
-0.4905189573764801,
-0.3230551481246948,
-0.38725215196609497,
-0.9690208435058594,
0.514156699180603,
0.28750017285346985,
0.4037126898765564,
0.35644879937171936,
-0.19378845393657684,
0.41793087124824524,
-0.5466223359107971,
1.0150341987609863,
0.30539900064468384,
-0.6575146913528442,
0.458692729473114,
-0.024773864075541496,
0.24815551936626434,
0.31469327211380005,
0.5643205642700195,
-0.020618952810764313,
0.06930872052907944,
-0.47196733951568604,
-1.143503189086914,
1.038167119026184,
0.12613116204738617,
-0.049073733389377594,
0.1224534884095192,
0.2999066114425659,
0.1418694108724594,
0.29076626896858215,
-0.6674889922142029,
0.03672162443399429,
0.15881475806236267,
-0.39076897501945496,
-0.24299848079681396,
-0.6437174677848816,
0.0061822873540222645,
-0.10698823630809784,
0.8606006503105164,
0.01274021714925766,
0.506939172744751,
-0.13285931944847107,
-0.12386089563369751,
-0.003976976498961449,
0.21433252096176147,
0.5515954494476318,
0.32096824049949646,
-0.4078314006328583,
-0.013460492715239525,
-0.03803253173828125,
-0.5094717144966125,
0.13455075025558472,
0.08956998586654663,
-0.03520704433321953,
-0.1457400619983673,
0.33914220333099365,
0.9336742758750916,
-0.003606031881645322,
-0.4748510420322418,
0.5895599126815796,
0.02951653115451336,
-0.23058246076107025,
-0.14480023086071014,
0.10986366868019104,
0.01941731385886669,
0.1430937945842743,
0.05170922353863716,
0.020631426945328712,
-0.14931519329547882,
-0.8687953948974609,
-0.032369907945394516,
0.1849779188632965,
-0.12337619066238403,
-0.05724671483039856,
0.45582613348960876,
0.22122250497341156,
-0.38578012585639954,
0.6613789796829224,
0.1004161611199379,
-0.4765000343322754,
0.6395708322525024,
0.4781670570373535,
0.7140423655509949,
-0.3273959159851074,
-0.13468213379383087,
0.5105791091918945,
0.6370090246200562,
-0.42095205187797546,
0.44835036993026733,
0.18319189548492432,
-0.4556252360343933,
-0.5098437666893005,
-0.806174099445343,
-0.3957105875015259,
0.40897563099861145,
-0.6410645842552185,
0.49508631229400635,
-0.46696701645851135,
-0.10383926331996918,
-0.17021246254444122,
-0.006599088665097952,
-0.6452387571334839,
0.27963075041770935,
0.1563689410686493,
1.6010022163391113,
-0.5618452429771423,
1.0464662313461304,
0.38160470128059387,
-0.7762682437896729,
-1.0018326044082642,
-0.057779308408498764,
-0.002206729957833886,
-0.522303581237793,
0.7403960227966309,
0.3677055835723877,
0.17267417907714844,
-0.14014257490634918,
-0.5537014603614807,
-0.8821075558662415,
1.132035493850708,
0.5107694864273071,
-0.940719485282898,
-0.09383724629878998,
-0.08165306597948074,
0.2330537736415863,
-0.3462991714477539,
0.33776649832725525,
0.5530023574829102,
0.49585118889808655,
-0.022619519382715225,
-0.9511204957962036,
-0.07556156069040298,
0.04053308069705963,
0.21737420558929443,
0.41357842087745667,
-0.7630245685577393,
1.1270124912261963,
-0.26202157139778137,
0.039463892579078674,
0.46777766942977905,
0.8866145610809326,
0.13264332711696625,
-0.12324026972055435,
0.5457109212875366,
0.46646425127983093,
0.4652195870876312,
-0.2619527578353882,
0.9833998680114746,
-0.3996097147464752,
0.07360932976007462,
1.172238826751709,
-0.37318041920661926,
1.126517415046692,
0.4423104524612427,
-0.20721563696861267,
0.3333044648170471,
0.5154600739479065,
0.1067657396197319,
0.43282586336135864,
0.4251061975955963,
-0.25552231073379517,
-0.060014985501766205,
0.008654328994452953,
-0.27065035700798035,
0.06631869822740555,
0.22933430969715118,
-0.2598530054092407,
0.18751032650470734,
-0.08356067538261414,
0.06084369868040085,
-0.03426384925842285,
-0.505233108997345,
0.6377244591712952,
0.1880817413330078,
-0.7458846569061279,
0.37240442633628845,
0.2418302297592163,
0.4682026207447052,
-0.9741984009742737,
0.09642048180103302,
-0.23880606889724731,
0.40573030710220337,
-0.020947249606251717,
-0.7705654501914978,
0.21632352471351624,
0.04783403500914574,
-0.08334663510322571,
-0.2853904962539673,
0.7373979091644287,
-0.44595542550086975,
-0.318560391664505,
0.3969510793685913,
0.3585038483142853,
0.3514324724674225,
-0.22918543219566345,
-0.40713679790496826,
0.3385167717933655,
-0.06856311112642288,
-0.5404248237609863,
0.38146859407424927,
0.46353912353515625,
0.11129428446292877,
0.5817839503288269,
0.3522740602493286,
0.5284754633903503,
0.18634800612926483,
0.35561156272888184,
0.8883859515190125,
-0.6620221734046936,
-0.1947721391916275,
-0.5152390003204346,
0.3268081843852997,
-0.15911541879177094,
-0.07702211290597916,
0.5123630166053772,
0.6287326812744141,
0.9258877038955688,
-0.15990082919597626,
0.6938035488128662,
-0.11274807155132294,
0.6132566332817078,
-0.8275189995765686,
0.15169018507003784,
-0.6449258327484131,
0.13462918996810913,
0.012079978361725807,
-1.125025749206543,
-0.17069658637046814,
0.4201680123806,
-0.1473812609910965,
0.31714296340942383,
0.6925544738769531,
0.9049124717712402,
-0.1332772821187973,
-0.23243474960327148,
0.36840125918388367,
0.5077998042106628,
0.4064357876777649,
0.7071349024772644,
0.4207453429698944,
-0.25185954570770264,
0.8835681080818176,
-0.1402091532945633,
-0.452056348323822,
-0.3910330533981323,
-0.8394010663032532,
-0.7410010099411011,
-0.29877036809921265,
-0.1991441249847412,
-0.3981754183769226,
-0.08105204999446869,
1.0268970727920532,
0.8654689788818359,
-0.6107765436172485,
-0.3074137270450592,
-0.13268809020519257,
-0.34181010723114014,
-0.11686670035123825,
-0.15307752788066864,
-0.0613052099943161,
-0.33226528763771057,
-0.6550226807594299,
0.6247634887695312,
0.2502496838569641,
0.2032020539045334,
-0.5663737058639526,
-0.1719396859407425,
-0.32274332642555237,
0.44118228554725647,
0.6627970337867737,
0.21359141170978546,
-0.6199460029602051,
-0.12463710457086563,
-0.4823661148548126,
0.004015977960079908,
0.019309425726532936,
0.7577205896377563,
-0.7639380693435669,
-0.01960487850010395,
0.6136445999145508,
0.4685453176498413,
0.5698391795158386,
0.14409027993679047,
0.671054482460022,
-0.6862514615058899,
0.39389386773109436,
0.11141268908977509,
0.502879798412323,
0.3861480951309204,
0.010174442082643509,
0.737917423248291,
0.0888642743229866,
-0.5296293497085571,
-0.9857625365257263,
0.5206338763237,
-1.0761938095092773,
-0.4917607307434082,
1.4197968244552612,
-0.09680365771055222,
-0.3489171862602234,
0.28443583846092224,
-0.4802473187446594,
0.42896702885627747,
-0.3941221833229065,
0.32923415303230286,
0.5994216203689575,
0.07526112347841263,
-0.12883591651916504,
-0.7403662204742432,
0.2989933490753174,
0.384697288274765,
-0.834369421005249,
0.006408293731510639,
0.6142104268074036,
0.10400710254907608,
0.0770668163895607,
0.4832379221916199,
-0.06564425677061081,
-0.07810211926698685,
0.11239621788263321,
0.19824793934822083,
-0.31821170449256897,
-0.7812423706054688,
-0.41846364736557007,
0.5719749927520752,
0.39327549934387207,
-0.1790360063314438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05955v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05955v3
|
Smurfs: Leveraging Multiple Proficiency Agents with Context-Efficiency for Tool Planning
| 2024-05-09T17:49:04 | 2024-06-24T02:44:57 |
Junzhi Chen, Juhao Liang, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has opened up unprecedented
possibilities for automating complex tasks that are often comparable to human
performance. Despite their capabilities, LLMs still encounter difficulties in
completing tasks that require high levels of accuracy and complexity due to
their inherent limitations in handling multifaceted problems single-handedly.
This paper introduces `Smurfs', a cutting-edge multi-agent framework designed
to revolutionize the application of LLMs. By seamlessly transforming a
conventional LLM into a synergistic multi-agent ensemble, Smurfs can enhance
the model's ability to solve complex tasks at no additional cost. This is
achieved through innovative prompting strategies that allocate distinct roles
within the model, thereby facilitating collaboration among specialized agents
and forming an intelligent multi-agent system. Our empirical investigation on
both open-ended task of StableToolBench and closed-ended task on HotpotQA
showcases Smurfs' superior capability in intricate tool utilization scenarios.
Notably, Smurfs outmatches all the baseline methods in both experiments,
setting new state-of-the-art performance. Furthermore, through comprehensive
ablation studies, we dissect the contribution of the core components of the
multi-agent framework to its overall efficacy. This not only verifies the
effectiveness of the framework, but also sets a route for future exploration of
multi-agent LLM systems.
|
[
-0.5582593083381653,
-0.7231953740119934,
0.48706352710723877,
0.07628276944160461,
-0.034972213208675385,
0.39288726449012756,
-0.4481041133403778,
-0.14071786403656006,
-0.015314910560846329,
0.6384012699127197,
-0.7448387742042542,
-0.3484093248844147,
-0.6436052322387695,
0.08768586814403534,
-0.5690445899963379,
0.7834813594818115,
0.27861717343330383,
-0.19780167937278748,
-0.3519328236579895,
-0.3929460644721985,
-0.15130868554115295,
-0.4774448275566101,
-0.49073219299316406,
-0.5373991131782532,
0.554590106010437,
0.7148063778877258,
0.8790513873100281,
0.46240830421447754,
0.5585408806800842,
0.5573402047157288,
0.32133790850639343,
0.3721866309642792,
-0.29635199904441833,
0.5120956897735596,
-0.08590592443943024,
-0.22133439779281616,
-0.4848122000694275,
-0.2682463526725769,
0.5075717568397522,
0.5225577354431152,
-0.3663245141506195,
0.14754152297973633,
0.025062352418899536,
0.6391351222991943,
-0.7901490330696106,
-0.04094943776726723,
-0.6733130812644958,
-0.2752923369407654,
-0.3234573304653168,
-0.32149216532707214,
-0.38607844710350037,
0.17017017304897308,
0.0740143358707428,
-0.3374978005886078,
0.07328414171934128,
-0.2971755862236023,
0.26524871587753296,
0.6242559552192688,
-0.36390137672424316,
-0.2978767156600952,
-0.9527535438537598,
0.8013551235198975,
-0.5629129409790039,
0.43917158246040344,
-0.021915240213274956,
0.5883772969245911,
-0.3303903043270111,
-0.9504572153091431,
-0.3307851552963257,
0.17417636513710022,
0.08915631473064423,
-0.20603764057159424,
0.02822248265147209,
0.08630190044641495,
0.15834589302539825,
0.152586430311203,
-0.5789732336997986,
0.09586219489574432,
-0.2013392597436905,
-0.08289927989244461,
0.6003203988075256,
0.24451769888401031,
0.09358566999435425,
0.4575386345386505,
-0.21648123860359192,
-0.02412169985473156,
-0.5956304669380188,
0.10076549649238586,
0.24471409618854523,
0.5240482091903687,
0.07985567301511765,
0.6005908250808716,
-0.17500467598438263,
0.6978513598442078,
-0.19052939116954803,
-0.6165971159934998,
0.17631253600120544,
-0.1695231944322586,
-0.5664037466049194,
-0.3732762038707733,
0.7060631513595581,
-0.046042293310165405,
0.37847402691841125,
-0.23235154151916504,
-0.19645676016807556,
-0.046485014259815216,
0.1535264402627945,
-0.9007206559181213,
-0.02456093393266201,
0.4590360224246979,
-0.01777537539601326,
-0.4677029550075531,
-0.13318020105361938,
-0.5848486423492432,
-0.6583250164985657,
-0.14450335502624512,
0.37118688225746155,
-0.2191298007965088,
-0.5745824575424194,
0.14938503503799438,
-0.17417830228805542,
-0.02286355569958687,
0.26806485652923584,
-0.583224892616272,
0.4246063232421875,
0.5991073250770569,
0.7302882671356201,
0.10035963356494904,
-0.723668098449707,
-0.7716109156608582,
0.41775840520858765,
-0.005008310545235872,
1.0468165874481201,
-0.6176705360412598,
-0.29774582386016846,
-0.012633773498237133,
0.0602269284427166,
-0.07210976630449295,
-0.28894925117492676,
0.1462898850440979,
-0.34193602204322815,
-0.10560113936662674,
-0.3445530831813812,
-0.20404724776744843,
-0.1403799206018448,
0.30282819271087646,
-0.7417697310447693,
0.9883750081062317,
0.11414998769760132,
-0.4906655550003052,
0.2922675609588623,
-0.8138094544410706,
-0.5375192165374756,
0.20608875155448914,
-0.11247152090072632,
-0.35140272974967957,
-0.25682002305984497,
0.1103951558470726,
0.6971005797386169,
-0.46561548113822937,
0.21740449965000153,
-0.36676421761512756,
-0.48623156547546387,
0.1899472177028656,
-0.12088391929864883,
0.7564373016357422,
0.27870115637779236,
-0.42150452733039856,
0.5455024242401123,
-0.1773471236228943,
-0.10305430740118027,
0.17769555747509003,
-0.0846395343542099,
-0.04371664673089981,
0.17369402945041656,
0.0042096953839063644,
0.4672039747238159,
0.1672133207321167,
-0.271485835313797,
0.1930685192346573,
-0.4185735881328583,
0.5666017532348633,
0.8296072483062744,
-0.21028414368629456,
0.7178489565849304,
-0.5011888742446899,
0.6246179342269897,
-0.3098934590816498,
0.1902538686990738,
-0.27842873334884644,
-0.23709869384765625,
-0.5301916003227234,
-0.4427932798862457,
0.07609976083040237,
0.4523017704486847,
-0.8709837198257446,
0.06376248598098755,
-0.04223480448126793,
-0.6892354488372803,
-0.4164116084575653,
0.3890613913536072,
0.0593317374587059,
0.08120846748352051,
0.06577888876199722,
-0.04567853361368179,
-0.3171023428440094,
-0.5972975492477417,
-0.2275087684392929,
0.08551652729511261,
0.4242844879627228,
0.3010570704936981,
0.2662772238254547,
-0.2980177104473114,
0.7338184118270874,
-0.1931317150592804,
-0.5162954926490784,
-0.5912240147590637,
-0.23352402448654175,
-0.06079604849219322,
0.28338590264320374,
0.6778839230537415,
-0.9385204315185547,
-0.617618203163147,
0.1257668286561966,
-0.5838379263877869,
-0.05115269124507904,
-0.019428834319114685,
-0.13268360495567322,
0.26053622364997864,
0.6214092373847961,
-0.7352271676063538,
0.08160395175218582,
0.6915037631988525,
-0.1736244559288025,
0.5954057574272156,
-0.11068346351385117,
0.06757861375808716,
-0.802478015422821,
0.2555842399597168,
-0.2483375519514084,
-0.19108927249908447,
-0.7347661852836609,
0.3343154788017273,
-0.11151135712862015,
0.04954604431986809,
-0.6052847504615784,
0.784692108631134,
-0.5711381435394287,
-0.30479830503463745,
-0.5393528938293457,
0.22859247028827667,
-0.09476158767938614,
0.5254667401313782,
-0.3545008897781372,
0.8935520648956299,
0.5780007243156433,
-0.4298363924026489,
0.5469871759414673,
-0.08297134190797806,
0.2553517818450928,
0.6367723345756531,
-0.37569624185562134,
0.14083944261074066,
-0.06969735771417618,
-0.0035518277436494827,
-0.8595054745674133,
-0.23709622025489807,
-0.015970539301633835,
-0.330885112285614,
0.1588781327009201,
-0.12896111607551575,
-0.8500441908836365,
-0.4348032474517822,
-0.30022722482681274,
0.2181226909160614,
0.26113584637641907,
-0.2698225677013397,
1.0881325006484985,
0.7413930296897888,
-0.30050644278526306,
-0.9221391677856445,
-0.38192448019981384,
0.07595507800579071,
-0.2768154442310333,
-0.6794601678848267,
0.1068219542503357,
-0.35196447372436523,
-0.35202497243881226,
-0.024018047377467155,
-0.14412908256053925,
-0.06944053620100021,
0.33526521921157837,
0.38661420345306396,
-0.1435110718011856,
-0.012184513732790947,
0.2065187245607376,
0.1856662780046463,
-0.10702471435070038,
-0.2197788804769516,
-0.15321481227874756,
0.6777207851409912,
-0.44864845275878906,
-0.4649161100387573,
0.01645440049469471,
0.329910546541214,
0.9663264751434326,
-0.6694086790084839,
0.6838787794113159,
0.6811266541481018,
-0.46289733052253723,
-0.26457518339157104,
-0.9269706010818481,
-0.25920411944389343,
-0.6257039308547974,
0.23790399730205536,
-0.5791887044906616,
-0.9968802332878113,
0.4926024079322815,
-0.44718462228775024,
0.602764904499054,
0.16012893617153168,
0.7853432893753052,
0.08020604401826859,
1.148061990737915,
0.8892002701759338,
0.06562452763319016,
0.46552202105522156,
-0.33247828483581543,
0.03168892860412598,
-0.5189610719680786,
-0.16298715770244598,
-0.5381236672401428,
-0.19499433040618896,
-0.31726697087287903,
-0.3697843849658966,
0.4107709527015686,
-0.199850395321846,
-0.11991052329540253,
0.24812720715999603,
-0.45970574021339417,
0.6216031908988953,
0.22967715561389923,
-0.29284873604774475,
0.3089424669742584,
-0.019088925793766975,
-0.256702184677124,
0.3309656083583832,
-0.8130199909210205,
-0.6078672409057617,
1.1246898174285889,
0.17096053063869476,
0.37344613671302795,
0.10861232876777649,
0.6301063299179077,
0.21413341164588928,
0.40136367082595825,
-0.7803539037704468,
0.6846445202827454,
-0.21599134802818298,
-0.574225127696991,
-0.7081087231636047,
0.02037910185754299,
-1.0181326866149902,
0.6813912987709045,
-0.25154608488082886,
-0.5029623508453369,
-0.13459143042564392,
0.024327324703335762,
-0.3300739824771881,
0.398659348487854,
-0.7366757988929749,
0.931178629398346,
-0.11455260217189789,
-0.5251688361167908,
-0.21857739984989166,
-0.6440381407737732,
0.1874741166830063,
-0.15215660631656647,
0.6565436720848083,
-0.4304749369621277,
-0.09486688673496246,
0.44218555092811584,
-0.2789389193058014,
0.5599896311759949,
-0.34433507919311523,
0.19989167153835297,
0.32289087772369385,
0.11199288070201874,
0.5964290499687195,
-0.19666913151741028,
-0.4834139943122864,
-0.2514035701751709,
0.09635930508375168,
-0.43149369955062866,
-0.4706745147705078,
0.8522871136665344,
-0.5493011474609375,
-0.44508251547813416,
-0.30079421401023865,
-0.8470980525016785,
-0.20581693947315216,
0.6824119091033936,
-0.16461095213890076,
0.4753957986831665,
-0.4017523527145386,
0.05300858989357948,
0.4828657805919647,
0.19152742624282837,
0.652032196521759,
0.5188032388687134,
0.031021704897284508,
-0.13040660321712494,
0.7696179747581482,
0.21834473311901093,
0.19886267185211182,
-0.05425230413675308,
-0.028629224747419357,
-0.0946447104215622,
-0.5762591361999512,
-0.6340177059173584,
0.3294096291065216,
-0.8096823692321777,
-0.3892054855823517,
-0.8143524527549744,
-0.2146136313676834,
-0.5142641663551331,
-0.5649902820587158,
-0.4396788775920868,
-0.16328652203083038,
0.00689108157530427,
0.06100095063447952,
0.18831028044223785,
0.686764121055603,
-0.10017023980617523,
0.5837920904159546,
-0.6338951587677002,
0.10258215665817261,
0.27978867292404175,
0.2262905389070511,
-0.08678774535655975,
0.10079953819513321,
-0.3456469774246216,
-0.07908381521701813,
-0.21435046195983887,
-0.7965015172958374,
0.5148224234580994,
0.1996276080608368,
0.9247485995292664,
0.31585434079170227,
0.15957827866077423,
0.5452134609222412,
-0.39823946356773376,
0.34618571400642395,
-0.22933250665664673,
-0.7557356953620911,
0.1500982791185379,
-0.40445318818092346,
0.45330774784088135,
0.5171080827713013,
0.027479853481054306,
-0.4089939594268799,
-0.7136029601097107,
-0.7498389482498169,
-0.8165112137794495,
0.7504924535751343,
0.12805910408496857,
-0.2140769511461258,
0.3947136104106903,
0.07906936854124069,
0.1999092698097229,
0.5643730163574219,
-0.4457726776599884,
-0.16970588266849518,
0.0038663195446133614,
-0.17650556564331055,
-0.33564701676368713,
0.02848827838897705,
-0.2502831816673279,
0.08431512862443924,
0.62558513879776,
-0.4198038578033447,
0.043974943459033966,
-0.21368706226348877,
-0.4352421462535858,
-0.4452762305736542,
0.3874683082103729,
0.7097243666648865,
0.624606728553772,
0.061159733682870865,
0.3117237091064453,
0.20764708518981934,
-0.2712605595588684,
0.1589154154062271,
0.28782299160957336,
0.25010085105895996,
-0.3958064913749695,
0.1871006041765213,
0.19996453821659088,
0.13714978098869324,
-0.7950912117958069,
0.4726090133190155,
-0.0007088895072229207,
-0.08225713670253754,
-0.334402471780777,
0.26283806562423706,
0.35671859979629517,
0.5516146421432495,
0.38654816150665283,
0.25580301880836487,
0.249834805727005,
-0.3380894064903259,
0.235057532787323,
0.654916524887085,
-0.08795984834432602,
-0.07608399540185928,
0.1373743712902069,
0.31475919485092163,
-0.38344186544418335,
0.19440096616744995,
-0.09539008885622025,
-0.4405401945114136,
0.6504034399986267,
0.2589278817176819,
0.7773985266685486,
-0.5846253633499146,
0.20072123408317566,
-0.07296988368034363,
0.5939511060714722,
-0.1408761590719223,
0.28013113141059875,
-0.1822039932012558,
-0.657762348651886,
-0.48431089520454407,
-0.4595544934272766,
-0.31746453046798706,
-0.07803703099489212,
-0.23967863619327545,
0.3129878342151642,
-0.3927913308143616,
-0.1925855278968811,
-0.005293035414069891,
0.13538990914821625,
-0.7169766426086426,
-0.026964660733938217,
-0.14918909966945648,
0.768702507019043,
-0.8016065955162048,
0.821351945400238,
0.9555823802947998,
-0.05092921853065491,
-0.5029854774475098,
-0.2485738843679428,
0.3318221867084503,
-0.6954723000526428,
-0.027165880426764488,
0.21630166471004486,
-0.5546976327896118,
0.30221784114837646,
-0.4177643954753876,
-0.9507193565368652,
1.3541936874389648,
0.4599184989929199,
-0.2637422978878021,
-0.11876655369997025,
0.03246917575597763,
0.29524853825569153,
-0.4221799075603485,
0.17673800885677338,
0.7279729843139648,
0.5784679651260376,
0.2942633628845215,
-1.168168067932129,
0.0701586902141571,
-0.3425315320491791,
-0.3581598103046417,
0.4953324794769287,
-0.6315873861312866,
0.6893721222877502,
-0.5235372185707092,
-0.15188534557819366,
0.07154649496078491,
0.2735578417778015,
0.4688766598701477,
0.32432055473327637,
0.7027748823165894,
0.17773376405239105,
0.577744722366333,
0.027244608849287033,
0.642069399356842,
-0.24473369121551514,
0.07571399956941605,
0.7513142824172974,
-0.4573744833469391,
0.6549341082572937,
0.5192160606384277,
0.0767047181725502,
0.47440212965011597,
0.34354493021965027,
0.2324601411819458,
0.49943193793296814,
-0.10598576813936234,
-0.3353341817855835,
-0.4934225380420685,
-0.13879571855068207,
-0.1765880435705185,
0.30241283774375916,
0.714951753616333,
0.13909858465194702,
-0.4470617175102234,
0.39146995544433594,
-0.05047966167330742,
0.016530778259038925,
-0.11846569925546646,
0.7873268127441406,
0.09413866698741913,
-0.569794237613678,
0.12293052673339844,
0.13396018743515015,
0.5281688570976257,
-0.5524671673774719,
0.129620760679245,
0.24568423628807068,
0.323117196559906,
-0.2698597311973572,
-0.6164190173149109,
0.3330114483833313,
-0.30033859610557556,
0.01229038368910551,
-0.39532527327537537,
1.1530030965805054,
-0.4919812083244324,
-0.18618148565292358,
0.3267541527748108,
0.9442411661148071,
-0.010082213208079338,
-0.23908375203609467,
-0.8867266178131104,
0.3391019403934479,
-0.37228044867515564,
-0.22173836827278137,
0.256648451089859,
0.6169850826263428,
0.03648556023836136,
0.9278320670127869,
0.6944921612739563,
-0.011657001450657845,
-0.10932005196809769,
0.00933074951171875,
1.008017897605896,
-0.4411134123802185,
-0.5089427828788757,
-0.8718500137329102,
0.8467935919761658,
-0.04627280682325363,
0.17010453343391418,
0.6080713272094727,
0.3961397409439087,
0.6888554692268372,
0.23354198038578033,
0.7386236190795898,
0.08123345673084259,
0.5270587801933289,
-0.050500430166721344,
0.7160516381263733,
-0.7198464870452881,
0.2776508927345276,
-0.4773937463760376,
-0.7578068375587463,
-0.31499844789505005,
0.4798819422721863,
-0.12461645901203156,
0.2027713656425476,
0.5279638767242432,
0.7184462547302246,
-0.024165716022253036,
-0.1124768778681755,
0.4925113320350647,
-0.06968972086906433,
0.42858654260635376,
0.41785281896591187,
0.5907222628593445,
-0.07430414855480194,
0.6911183595657349,
-0.4442459046840668,
-0.3114914298057556,
-0.43168261647224426,
-0.6552174091339111,
-1.099224328994751,
-0.8234533071517944,
-0.03757236897945404,
0.030789153650403023,
0.07368161529302597,
1.0577342510223389,
0.8746329545974731,
-0.440888911485672,
-0.7290005683898926,
0.0802973285317421,
0.3109920620918274,
-0.36507880687713623,
-0.16286808252334595,
0.0029738328885287046,
-0.4161916971206665,
-0.6100937724113464,
0.5488581657409668,
0.4810730516910553,
0.1200653463602066,
-0.5638375878334045,
-0.2846042215824127,
-0.2084178775548935,
0.16451780498027802,
0.752132773399353,
0.26516976952552795,
-0.7496074438095093,
0.19016660749912262,
0.351960152387619,
-0.25482121109962463,
-0.3090701103210449,
0.8648773431777954,
-0.9211310744285583,
0.33339130878448486,
0.26429101824760437,
0.561888575553894,
0.420107901096344,
-0.35787540674209595,
0.5848113298416138,
-0.660905659198761,
0.440952867269516,
0.34123167395591736,
0.33644986152648926,
0.3542293608188629,
-0.2884575426578522,
0.49661415815353394,
-0.004236028529703617,
-0.6410397291183472,
-1.184198021888733,
0.21929045021533966,
-0.7566816806793213,
-0.4983013868331909,
1.040073037147522,
0.14138545095920563,
0.030997447669506073,
-0.33024531602859497,
-0.2543661594390869,
0.20993338525295258,
-0.40116047859191895,
0.4999883770942688,
0.7002028822898865,
-0.21524374186992645,
-0.3746713399887085,
-0.5160003304481506,
0.5265702605247498,
0.37697264552116394,
-0.8733208179473877,
0.1277758628129959,
0.49814510345458984,
0.36703673005104065,
0.17047345638275146,
1.0578449964523315,
0.07026053220033646,
0.48290708661079407,
-0.1965930312871933,
-0.04835447296500206,
-0.5340355038642883,
-0.7920309901237488,
-0.10308093577623367,
0.5112623572349548,
0.39686375856399536,
0.3144443929195404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05938v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05938v2
|
DOLOMITES: Domain-Specific Long-Form Methodical Tasks
| 2024-05-09T17:25:31 | 2024-05-28T17:53:48 |
Chaitanya Malaviya, Priyanka Agrawal, Kuzman Ganchev, Pranesh Srinivasan, Fantine Huot, Jonathan Berant, Mark Yatskar, Dipanjan Das, Mirella Lapata, Chris Alberti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Experts in various fields routinely perform methodical writing tasks to plan,
organize, and report their work. From a clinician writing a differential
diagnosis for a patient, to a teacher writing a lesson plan for students, these
tasks are pervasive, requiring to methodically generate structured long-form
output for a given input. We develop a typology of methodical tasks structured
in the form of a task objective, procedure, input, and output, and introduce
DoLoMiTes, a novel benchmark with specifications for 519 such tasks elicited
from hundreds of experts from across 25 fields. Our benchmark further contains
specific instantiations of methodical tasks with concrete input and output
examples (1,857 in total) which we obtain by collecting expert revisions of up
to 10 model-generated examples of each task. We use these examples to evaluate
contemporary language models highlighting that automating methodical tasks is a
challenging long-form generation problem, as it requires performing complex
inferences, while drawing upon the given context as well as domain knowledge.
|
[
0.169887974858284,
-0.8052494525909424,
0.748758852481842,
0.11405026912689209,
0.33759212493896484,
0.07154055684804916,
-0.3420717120170593,
-0.23995737731456757,
0.19764766097068787,
0.5309180021286011,
-0.6533593535423279,
-0.5346919894218445,
-0.5922434329986572,
0.22364647686481476,
-0.439900279045105,
1.0878692865371704,
-0.7662307024002075,
0.04338221997022629,
-0.217970609664917,
0.32661378383636475,
-0.07235922664403915,
-0.564294159412384,
-0.33500009775161743,
-0.4380747973918915,
0.4578796327114105,
0.456802636384964,
0.5575166344642639,
0.6151702404022217,
0.7499545812606812,
0.3829137682914734,
0.38140517473220825,
0.050725869834423065,
-0.2868752181529999,
0.5242406129837036,
-0.23495033383369446,
-0.3489869236946106,
-0.7532815933227539,
0.29322442412376404,
0.34240344166755676,
1.2480688095092773,
-0.008755461312830448,
0.5172011852264404,
-0.24902598559856415,
0.5988389849662781,
-0.5126091241836548,
0.18764886260032654,
-0.31415584683418274,
0.18710105121135712,
-0.3456733524799347,
-0.4839000701904297,
-0.22187598049640656,
-0.2871185541152954,
-0.15591631829738617,
-0.39823833107948303,
0.4274919629096985,
-0.2019852250814438,
0.1789132058620453,
0.3168191909790039,
-0.06565522402524948,
-0.6622833609580994,
-0.728056788444519,
0.8756309747695923,
-0.7618526220321655,
-0.028523793444037437,
0.5570220351219177,
0.3818179666996002,
-0.3515351116657257,
-1.0051387548446655,
-0.4578346014022827,
-0.5208543539047241,
-0.061569370329380035,
-0.05030248314142227,
0.08916054666042328,
-0.007604219950735569,
0.39570003747940063,
0.5321331024169922,
-0.5369431972503662,
0.08698984235525131,
-0.32966944575309753,
0.14672991633415222,
0.8740319609642029,
0.30689799785614014,
0.5492062568664551,
-0.19470766186714172,
-0.08129233121871948,
0.3104381263256073,
-0.7544630765914917,
0.02737058699131012,
0.428434282541275,
0.06600438058376312,
0.13247153162956238,
0.6645212769508362,
-0.8019030094146729,
0.8810586333274841,
0.06547573208808899,
-0.1181541159749031,
0.10187569260597229,
-0.4344465732574463,
-0.15518534183502197,
-0.08176127821207047,
0.6977705359458923,
0.3363402187824249,
0.3156120777130127,
-0.4394443929195404,
-0.48720452189445496,
-0.0596308559179306,
0.5642322301864624,
-0.6571478247642517,
-0.5501068234443665,
0.22273147106170654,
-0.48587071895599365,
-0.5788484215736389,
-0.3717738389968872,
-0.43569082021713257,
-0.09593895077705383,
-0.5555564165115356,
0.39464640617370605,
-0.297802597284317,
-0.06488408893346786,
0.12567180395126343,
0.11428604274988174,
-0.46869713068008423,
0.3431316018104553,
-0.9942644834518433,
0.8488613963127136,
0.301646888256073,
0.5435288548469543,
-0.16684351861476898,
-0.5000330209732056,
-0.44303783774375916,
0.1628641039133072,
-0.33138298988342285,
0.8306623697280884,
-0.5512898564338684,
-0.3238603472709656,
-0.15459953248500824,
-0.1735243797302246,
-0.22304227948188782,
-0.6127928495407104,
0.30813679099082947,
-0.10737091302871704,
0.18567901849746704,
-0.017197299748659134,
-0.37242063879966736,
-0.27527910470962524,
0.02073161117732525,
-0.47044530510902405,
1.242702841758728,
0.47638875246047974,
-0.34015846252441406,
0.24612756073474884,
-0.6735332608222961,
-0.5741415023803711,
0.37973180413246155,
-0.4066884517669678,
-0.04910296946763992,
0.40709298849105835,
-0.24918904900550842,
0.7250769734382629,
-0.4494462013244629,
0.6039456725120544,
0.09022276848554611,
-0.08054186403751373,
0.40188729763031006,
-0.1398119330406189,
0.6369147896766663,
-0.02762281894683838,
-0.9809471964836121,
0.24415001273155212,
-0.8198366761207581,
0.17328201234340668,
0.1152125895023346,
-0.05360862612724304,
-0.1360051929950714,
0.38200142979621887,
0.010047072544693947,
0.43975603580474854,
0.4877930283546448,
-0.5236494541168213,
0.2654598653316498,
0.02240465022623539,
0.5619890093803406,
0.48395800590515137,
-0.17119808495044708,
0.09891936182975769,
-0.6387582421302795,
0.3310854136943817,
-0.2727423906326294,
-0.11098770052194595,
-0.026358064264059067,
-0.1319882869720459,
-0.569391131401062,
-0.25499680638313293,
0.15731987357139587,
0.33345168828964233,
-0.6341956853866577,
0.3132866322994232,
-0.4163598418235779,
-0.9004501700401306,
-0.027122877538204193,
0.3002784848213196,
0.5606529712677002,
0.6980106830596924,
0.22925694286823273,
-0.45810583233833313,
-0.011167683638632298,
-0.9429035782814026,
-0.2466297745704651,
0.2392181009054184,
0.0765259638428688,
0.10371667891740799,
0.7129630446434021,
0.3534451425075531,
0.6778690218925476,
-0.6516785025596619,
-0.1923431009054184,
-0.22712981700897217,
0.40279656648635864,
0.35832592844963074,
0.4382183253765106,
0.43974170088768005,
-0.7109264135360718,
-0.5790053606033325,
-0.18579955399036407,
-1.0192195177078247,
-0.25688520073890686,
-0.1460932493209839,
0.03704844415187836,
0.036541104316711426,
0.5655450820922852,
-0.6611464023590088,
0.3304193913936615,
0.4078071415424347,
-0.3704264760017395,
0.5235424041748047,
-0.3294765055179596,
0.3646670877933502,
-0.8395548462867737,
0.3051208555698395,
0.0322224497795105,
-0.3143770396709442,
-0.8780136704444885,
0.19249369204044342,
0.03147681802511215,
-0.11436246335506439,
-0.19134198129177094,
0.4568665027618408,
-0.5060784816741943,
0.1083434447646141,
-0.24258537590503693,
0.08426745235919952,
-0.28796133399009705,
0.5611065030097961,
0.32296285033226013,
0.6842283010482788,
0.5612174868583679,
-0.620868444442749,
0.6019638776779175,
-0.07577173411846161,
-0.14918452501296997,
0.5993584394454956,
-0.7230652570724487,
0.055302783846855164,
0.1767697036266327,
0.1160762682557106,
-0.918952226638794,
-0.5132781863212585,
0.24391506612300873,
-0.39372676610946655,
0.3857692778110504,
0.3046785891056061,
-0.8598043322563171,
-0.4983815550804138,
-0.43819305300712585,
0.5300872325897217,
0.6360191106796265,
0.06682827323675156,
0.26615071296691895,
0.17604735493659973,
-0.7832339406013489,
-0.2450607717037201,
-0.506600558757782,
0.16374951601028442,
0.15169304609298706,
-0.3612721860408783,
0.6747995018959045,
-0.24819162487983704,
-0.4164851903915405,
0.07010835409164429,
-0.17872275412082672,
-0.2264840006828308,
0.25101953744888306,
0.4360560178756714,
0.057864923030138016,
-0.007706059608608484,
-0.1305963397026062,
0.10256718844175339,
0.025056662037968636,
0.2502855062484741,
0.03286554291844368,
0.5432689189910889,
0.42614835500717163,
-0.5405483245849609,
-0.4418376684188843,
0.7163073420524597,
0.5039312839508057,
-0.21893538534641266,
0.17870907485485077,
-0.060067951679229736,
-0.500685453414917,
-0.4523579180240631,
-0.5084145069122314,
-0.17913466691970825,
-0.4373617172241211,
0.3948279321193695,
-0.4166525602340698,
-0.29410138726234436,
0.2390030473470688,
-0.17087803781032562,
0.3200783133506775,
0.5083834528923035,
0.9048227071762085,
-0.005648909602314234,
0.5614948272705078,
0.25711867213249207,
0.31216225028038025,
-0.013162101618945599,
-0.15527527034282684,
0.4993133842945099,
-0.46262115240097046,
-0.21314150094985962,
-0.5434280633926392,
-0.3981934189796448,
-0.262262761592865,
-0.6842362284660339,
0.14013929665088654,
-0.12891477346420288,
0.2086661010980606,
0.4348098933696747,
-0.6821436285972595,
0.05920948088169098,
0.7332188487052917,
-0.01183957140892744,
0.20424559712409973,
-0.12624765932559967,
0.24034810066223145,
-0.03240319713950157,
-0.5271334052085876,
-0.8439146280288696,
1.3417412042617798,
0.056894462555646896,
0.47558510303497314,
-0.03389851376414299,
1.2789403200149536,
0.4420764744281769,
0.5035105347633362,
-0.7406559586524963,
0.832476794719696,
-0.08771566301584244,
-0.6409193277359009,
-0.3735722601413727,
-0.14566832780838013,
-0.6931252479553223,
-0.25677555799484253,
0.18376000225543976,
-0.5759612917900085,
-0.2976197302341461,
0.18807248771190643,
-0.21525302529335022,
0.2080479860305786,
-0.2606506943702698,
0.8332902193069458,
-0.24204884469509125,
-0.31570976972579956,
-0.3237486779689789,
-0.5521771311759949,
-0.015277939848601818,
-0.22651366889476776,
0.3427593410015106,
-0.38555943965911865,
-0.05703675001859665,
0.7166500091552734,
-0.2809346914291382,
1.0845364332199097,
-0.10693511366844177,
-0.10408604145050049,
0.3246050477027893,
0.43928152322769165,
0.2722921073436737,
-0.27190595865249634,
-0.15734270215034485,
0.07010778039693832,
-0.05302165448665619,
-0.3523978292942047,
-0.48645302653312683,
0.7371683716773987,
-0.42476633191108704,
-0.5539272427558899,
-0.31849488615989685,
-0.8684856295585632,
-0.09929367154836655,
0.4893134832382202,
0.18323606252670288,
0.899835467338562,
-0.29123684763908386,
-0.18684323132038116,
0.5461931228637695,
0.3655640482902527,
0.7095053791999817,
0.3506561517715454,
0.23028001189231873,
0.04013941437005997,
0.9817632436752319,
0.43410569429397583,
0.17776654660701752,
0.4559522569179535,
-0.2487078458070755,
0.14240491390228271,
-1.0889276266098022,
-0.5817743539810181,
0.2739831209182739,
-0.7144427299499512,
-0.12398243695497513,
-0.620280385017395,
-0.24731257557868958,
-0.5002304911613464,
-0.47437718510627747,
-0.21445079147815704,
-0.7327011227607727,
-0.0843077227473259,
0.23988384008407593,
-0.13252398371696472,
1.2203360795974731,
0.12027262151241302,
-0.1271374374628067,
-0.7624154090881348,
0.6425203084945679,
0.15642204880714417,
0.36692750453948975,
-0.11574328690767288,
-0.20257897675037384,
-0.15382476150989532,
-0.1794491708278656,
-0.5639981031417847,
-0.7933380603790283,
0.19776323437690735,
-0.04748883843421936,
0.9603568315505981,
-0.23755556344985962,
0.05406443402171135,
0.14776046574115753,
-0.9237366914749146,
0.7881003022193909,
0.22349362075328827,
-0.971332848072052,
0.588276743888855,
-0.5257525444030762,
0.1344558745622635,
0.6733702421188354,
0.7649093270301819,
-0.39511507749557495,
-0.5039153099060059,
-0.5652117133140564,
-0.839156448841095,
0.6023168563842773,
0.3081473708152771,
0.20666372776031494,
-0.3994664251804352,
0.3248426020145416,
0.5190863609313965,
0.4851137697696686,
-0.7480385899543762,
-0.11389804631471634,
-0.0003560209006536752,
-0.8508378267288208,
-0.08086035400629044,
-0.3510501980781555,
-0.6178166270256042,
0.057022009044885635,
0.2850889265537262,
-0.06245474889874458,
0.10024233162403107,
0.45101290941238403,
-0.3795759975910187,
-0.13160552084445953,
0.21922241151332855,
0.822364866733551,
1.353025197982788,
0.04862452298402786,
0.22098878026008606,
-0.16616594791412354,
-0.3944084346294403,
0.12118854373693466,
0.41790059208869934,
-0.1326752007007599,
0.04237687587738037,
0.5391989946365356,
0.1763596385717392,
0.5045587420463562,
-0.7918458580970764,
0.41877511143684387,
0.3269832730293274,
-0.6715114116668701,
-0.5310859084129333,
0.1662132292985916,
-0.0743977501988411,
-0.003178765531629324,
0.522127091884613,
-0.007008892018347979,
0.590461254119873,
-0.5536156892776489,
0.09353768080472946,
0.11751163005828857,
-0.238986536860466,
-0.6384447813034058,
0.4871760606765747,
0.45225030183792114,
-0.657352089881897,
0.17741312086582184,
-0.18177707493305206,
-0.09642625600099564,
0.5281792879104614,
0.41355955600738525,
0.8258935213088989,
-0.196478009223938,
0.21044819056987762,
0.1948395073413849,
-0.07532831281423569,
-0.130818173289299,
0.5339503884315491,
-0.3630158007144928,
-0.04194058105349541,
-0.46834293007850647,
-0.5473055243492126,
-0.3676207363605499,
-0.1886066049337387,
-0.7419132590293884,
-0.012814944609999657,
-0.415255069732666,
-0.1979786902666092,
0.36229774355888367,
-0.16703984141349792,
-0.6002777218818665,
0.4364141821861267,
-0.019216684624552727,
0.6572273969650269,
-0.6789886355400085,
0.3600817024707794,
1.0408453941345215,
-0.21710926294326782,
-0.5747876763343811,
-0.10609157383441925,
-0.0991959348320961,
-0.7789363265037537,
1.3023930788040161,
0.12624520063400269,
-0.2012457698583603,
-0.15651123225688934,
-0.16740098595619202,
-0.8011533617973328,
1.080816626548767,
-0.2732590436935425,
-0.5583173632621765,
-0.5284740328788757,
0.041756872087717056,
0.48590007424354553,
-0.461405485868454,
-0.02219025418162346,
0.1665084958076477,
0.2973926365375519,
-0.2958833575248718,
-1.279159665107727,
0.4909938871860504,
-0.3529813885688782,
-0.2553716003894806,
0.4780893921852112,
-0.30267834663391113,
1.0208584070205688,
-0.10649752616882324,
0.04614216089248657,
0.06533702462911606,
0.3540090024471283,
0.1178702786564827,
0.41824764013290405,
0.28714630007743835,
0.40791088342666626,
0.5294781923294067,
0.026579808443784714,
1.1238218545913696,
-0.7213422656059265,
0.014298409223556519,
0.9820681214332581,
-0.36589670181274414,
0.6349694728851318,
0.5809327960014343,
-0.21357715129852295,
0.5477272272109985,
0.5615547895431519,
-0.008591348305344582,
0.30751827359199524,
0.5959465503692627,
-0.2705497443675995,
-0.18033018708229065,
0.006320538464933634,
-0.1762842833995819,
0.4427816569805145,
0.08919477462768555,
-0.5368096828460693,
-0.2957421541213989,
-0.2714937925338745,
0.36353692412376404,
0.4947783052921295,
-0.40729179978370667,
0.5048138499259949,
-0.0761648416519165,
-1.1119745969772339,
0.34504592418670654,
-0.08965384215116501,
0.29224705696105957,
-0.41971060633659363,
-0.21177920699119568,
0.19584935903549194,
0.05799088999629021,
-0.3454779386520386,
-0.8097196221351624,
0.2606236934661865,
-0.10521940141916275,
-0.43673232197761536,
-0.5780127048492432,
0.34886807203292847,
-0.3507310450077057,
-0.6627796292304993,
0.011068184860050678,
0.6278555393218994,
0.2766890525817871,
0.12170831859111786,
-0.3814471662044525,
-0.2600623667240143,
-0.16932958364486694,
-0.595596432685852,
0.1932041496038437,
0.3944638669490814,
-0.2115723341703415,
0.4835524559020996,
0.26009640097618103,
0.35945725440979004,
0.06428506225347519,
-0.012652553617954254,
0.9228185415267944,
-0.7679884433746338,
-0.000988168641924858,
-0.6541715860366821,
0.49337008595466614,
-0.3566734492778778,
-0.44836369156837463,
0.7236672043800354,
0.44881582260131836,
0.7670885920524597,
-0.1359781175851822,
0.8571917414665222,
-0.2865496873855591,
0.5558674931526184,
-0.551682710647583,
0.4375496208667755,
-0.4765382409095764,
-0.4404410421848297,
-0.043293844908475876,
-0.8180497884750366,
-0.22671955823898315,
0.31590747833251953,
-0.6325176358222961,
0.13699811697006226,
1.0174980163574219,
0.2631690502166748,
-0.0030064487364143133,
-0.2609214186668396,
0.2650243639945984,
-0.17648464441299438,
0.25766101479530334,
0.5870742201805115,
0.4930580258369446,
-0.1121440976858139,
0.03538096696138382,
-0.5211331248283386,
-0.5136227607727051,
-0.24625292420387268,
-0.7254787087440491,
-1.129166841506958,
-0.643973708152771,
-0.4349718391895294,
0.10811474919319153,
-0.008437423035502434,
0.7872507572174072,
0.6679878234863281,
-0.5506798028945923,
-0.5364121198654175,
-0.0806906446814537,
-0.2785657048225403,
-0.1627296358346939,
-0.18248248100280762,
0.3079287111759186,
-0.7618188261985779,
-0.8582751154899597,
0.3635985553264618,
0.45970818400382996,
-0.06917980313301086,
-0.20865145325660706,
0.4542088508605957,
0.06007414683699608,
-0.00932865310460329,
0.4476776719093323,
0.06534279882907867,
-0.630942702293396,
-0.009490168653428555,
0.14286932349205017,
-0.23649287223815918,
-0.11230930685997009,
1.3263423442840576,
-0.45709508657455444,
0.2735648453235626,
0.36526575684547424,
0.2809710204601288,
0.27835947275161743,
-0.4180474281311035,
0.7824697494506836,
-0.28520286083221436,
-0.032563216984272,
0.6195583343505859,
0.24108776450157166,
0.3535692095756531,
-0.3385488986968994,
0.4858832359313965,
0.10255558043718338,
-0.7332232594490051,
-0.9734901189804077,
0.31014567613601685,
-0.8937082290649414,
-0.48166465759277344,
0.8520561456680298,
-0.3582562804222107,
-0.20907273888587952,
-0.1544835865497589,
-0.005347522906959057,
0.10194173455238342,
-0.0229533389210701,
0.9853664636611938,
0.7226548790931702,
-0.5199464559555054,
0.27911266684532166,
-0.7997307181358337,
0.752829909324646,
0.508169949054718,
-0.9427064061164856,
0.26817968487739563,
0.5751754641532898,
0.5212200880050659,
0.3342994451522827,
1.145017147064209,
-0.17374977469444275,
0.48820793628692627,
0.1343301385641098,
0.2635854184627533,
-0.24502472579479218,
-0.3992723524570465,
0.33072784543037415,
0.4436650276184082,
0.34177157282829285,
0.14833031594753265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05904v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05904v2
|
Does Fine-Tuning LLMs on New Knowledge Encourage Hallucinations?
| 2024-05-09T17:00:22 | 2024-05-13T07:29:58 |
Zorik Gekhman, Gal Yona, Roee Aharoni, Matan Eyal, Amir Feder, Roi Reichart, Jonathan Herzig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
When large language models are aligned via supervised fine-tuning, they may
encounter new factual information that was not acquired through pre-training.
It is often conjectured that this can teach the model the behavior of
hallucinating factually incorrect responses, as the model is trained to
generate facts that are not grounded in its pre-existing knowledge. In this
work, we study the impact of such exposure to new knowledge on the capability
of the fine-tuned model to utilize its pre-existing knowledge. To this end, we
design a controlled setup, focused on closed-book QA, where we vary the
proportion of the fine-tuning examples that introduce new knowledge. We
demonstrate that large language models struggle to acquire new factual
knowledge through fine-tuning, as fine-tuning examples that introduce new
knowledge are learned significantly slower than those consistent with the
model's knowledge. However, we also find that as the examples with new
knowledge are eventually learned, they linearly increase the model's tendency
to hallucinate. Taken together, our results highlight the risk in introducing
new factual knowledge through fine-tuning, and support the view that large
language models mostly acquire factual knowledge through pre-training, whereas
fine-tuning teaches them to use it more efficiently.
|
[
-0.38310208916664124,
-0.9830938577651978,
0.7802883386611938,
-0.3465803265571594,
-0.35566622018814087,
-0.25908392667770386,
-0.4411059319972992,
-0.5189084410667419,
-0.03426455706357956,
0.6300531029701233,
-0.43411141633987427,
-0.4142089784145355,
-0.6630046367645264,
-0.06742274016141891,
-0.26053446531295776,
1.2931255102157593,
0.27089864015579224,
-0.03810757398605347,
-0.1556423008441925,
0.20471079647541046,
-0.6509947180747986,
-0.582427442073822,
-0.45657628774642944,
-0.296466201543808,
0.5356721878051758,
0.46110498905181885,
1.0422533750534058,
0.6052464246749878,
0.4076548218727112,
0.2621796429157257,
-0.05588666722178459,
0.48517611622810364,
-0.7962313294410706,
0.04174348711967468,
-0.3175809979438782,
-0.891322910785675,
-0.24942328035831451,
0.15954948961734772,
0.5726549625396729,
0.8086970448493958,
-0.14289195835590363,
0.2194470465183258,
0.04107829928398132,
0.6236588954925537,
-0.686085045337677,
0.17622743546962738,
-1.2050994634628296,
0.017672380432486534,
0.0450177900493145,
-0.6354780793190002,
-0.3756081461906433,
-0.4861328601837158,
0.28729143738746643,
-0.7324068546295166,
0.21402861177921295,
0.13747647404670715,
1.0757297277450562,
0.657336950302124,
-0.3229741156101227,
-0.49075940251350403,
-0.7229498624801636,
0.6141165494918823,
-0.6153214573860168,
0.364520400762558,
0.3409629166126251,
0.17729878425598145,
-0.32849863171577454,
-0.3682788908481598,
-0.67147296667099,
-0.4637860059738159,
-0.17310649156570435,
-0.21378397941589355,
0.11760477721691132,
0.027484901249408722,
0.5594071745872498,
0.3525741696357727,
-0.12457659840583801,
0.29644259810447693,
-0.6088693737983704,
-0.22147758305072784,
0.5367710590362549,
0.2989567816257477,
0.1889546811580658,
-0.13644734025001526,
-0.099425308406353,
0.012244882993400097,
-0.6293059587478638,
-0.016625577583909035,
0.4231271743774414,
0.5625030398368835,
0.11624198406934738,
0.7476612329483032,
-0.234490767121315,
0.6687447428703308,
0.32645702362060547,
-0.30080994963645935,
0.1916223168373108,
-0.2233390212059021,
-0.47174060344696045,
0.20703940093517303,
0.3590430021286011,
0.5272294878959656,
0.7627970576286316,
-0.2461809366941452,
-0.24992601573467255,
0.2403506189584732,
0.4291243255138397,
-0.7528213858604431,
-0.23353280127048492,
-0.11880748718976974,
-0.238547682762146,
-0.4457765817642212,
-0.01130546722561121,
-0.5365928411483765,
-0.6500779986381531,
-0.7808345556259155,
0.7687260508537292,
-0.47424277663230896,
-0.11480164527893066,
0.6521417498588562,
-0.010344451293349266,
0.3623278737068176,
0.5222948789596558,
-1.013493537902832,
0.31812146306037903,
0.7409772276878357,
0.5826291441917419,
-0.1878616362810135,
-0.3429754376411438,
-0.6433890461921692,
0.10586562007665634,
-0.6108376383781433,
0.7559360861778259,
-0.54047691822052,
-0.0054393974132835865,
0.1294018179178238,
0.19295084476470947,
-0.025468576699495316,
-0.8688769340515137,
0.24237637221813202,
-0.5766592025756836,
0.04969244450330734,
-0.4198443293571472,
-0.5645965337753296,
-0.20675736665725708,
0.08070102334022522,
-0.30227166414260864,
0.46211445331573486,
-0.060769107192754745,
-0.7165082693099976,
0.5545804500579834,
0.06426355242729187,
-0.5209475755691528,
-0.3224041759967804,
-0.3862422704696655,
-0.3262617290019989,
0.4923650622367859,
-0.07249979674816132,
0.650689423084259,
-0.0494830384850502,
0.3816353380680084,
-0.23849564790725708,
-0.5629479885101318,
0.5118044018745422,
-0.2996905744075775,
0.49058693647384644,
0.10708140581846237,
-0.32093706727027893,
-0.023653240874409676,
-0.8506953120231628,
-0.16036154329776764,
-0.19777579605579376,
-0.31258198618888855,
-0.45661163330078125,
-0.08460730314254761,
-0.6332345604896545,
0.19506406784057617,
0.181449294090271,
-0.12395084649324417,
0.2571524977684021,
-0.5204020738601685,
-0.08792972564697266,
0.917844831943512,
0.3367416560649872,
0.4137936532497406,
-0.7075773477554321,
0.16535139083862305,
0.23679900169372559,
0.0011963234283030033,
0.04948544129729271,
-0.13571546971797943,
-1.0488524436950684,
0.147609144449234,
0.017526190727949142,
0.4581141769886017,
-0.4326622486114502,
0.30805161595344543,
-0.1277323067188263,
-0.3379117250442505,
-0.5600550174713135,
0.2100645750761032,
0.16681450605392456,
0.3867558538913727,
0.23452308773994446,
-0.07752925157546997,
-0.38296398520469666,
-0.8863106966018677,
-0.18520337343215942,
0.11545006930828094,
0.0027983523905277252,
0.34757059812545776,
0.3631155788898468,
-0.2533942759037018,
0.3929627239704132,
-0.6082382202148438,
-0.39218389987945557,
0.19138123095035553,
0.039560023695230484,
0.09105075150728226,
0.4964323043823242,
0.28042054176330566,
-0.28655463457107544,
-0.17502467334270477,
0.14995180070400238,
-0.7840350866317749,
0.14057031273841858,
-0.3000975549221039,
-0.19026589393615723,
0.4455304741859436,
0.6419536471366882,
-0.6740162968635559,
0.19802919030189514,
0.3123403787612915,
-0.2735878825187683,
0.8021531105041504,
-0.28879064321517944,
0.08484882116317749,
-1.0675297975540161,
-0.30844974517822266,
-0.32562491297721863,
0.12682567536830902,
-0.43840107321739197,
-0.09929266571998596,
-0.1494351625442505,
0.243072047829628,
-0.2807106077671051,
0.19392049312591553,
-0.36397331953048706,
0.12483830749988556,
-0.40555283427238464,
0.4080502986907959,
-0.12044165283441544,
0.4494291841983795,
-0.016165761277079582,
0.7844221591949463,
0.4991210401058197,
-1.034533143043518,
0.022133732214570045,
0.13296911120414734,
-0.7938274145126343,
0.10318011045455933,
-0.2962895333766937,
0.0524010956287384,
-0.19967825710773468,
-0.45505452156066895,
-0.5068581700325012,
-0.3501759171485901,
-0.011583001352846622,
-0.407528281211853,
0.5382223725318909,
0.2153487652540207,
-0.4992721378803253,
0.060933832079172134,
-0.08144702762365341,
0.07866115868091583,
0.6345798969268799,
-0.4228402376174927,
0.31198516488075256,
0.3608907163143158,
0.03267379850149155,
-0.444480299949646,
-0.7650802731513977,
-0.287232369184494,
-0.11404434591531754,
-0.48430126905441284,
0.10175665467977524,
-0.006719524972140789,
-0.3791154623031616,
-0.024481164291501045,
-0.38188815116882324,
0.18146948516368866,
0.31212303042411804,
0.24820204079151154,
0.08330919593572617,
-0.2645859122276306,
0.4113391637802124,
0.25063303112983704,
0.07381851226091385,
0.4102553725242615,
-0.293250173330307,
0.549951434135437,
-0.1896199882030487,
-0.3433123826980591,
-0.7345429062843323,
-0.16518083214759827,
0.6515952348709106,
-0.11562547087669373,
1.0425585508346558,
0.21532922983169556,
-0.4356985092163086,
-0.33355405926704407,
-0.8164826035499573,
-0.5368821620941162,
-0.4742406904697418,
0.5087373852729797,
-0.44759660959243774,
-1.2011804580688477,
0.5568351149559021,
-0.05362163856625557,
-0.14326027035713196,
0.2863291800022125,
0.8369147777557373,
-0.13716496527194977,
0.8540910482406616,
0.8149547576904297,
0.18569721281528473,
0.38607749342918396,
-0.06039678677916527,
0.27594873309135437,
-0.643894612789154,
-0.3657829463481903,
-0.4546181857585907,
-0.13018448650836945,
-0.8358427286148071,
-0.2753312587738037,
0.09566491097211838,
0.18081584572792053,
-0.31854262948036194,
-0.07282228767871857,
-0.34793204069137573,
0.5221542119979858,
0.4135562479496002,
0.33326777815818787,
0.6230794191360474,
0.09369809925556183,
-0.09613759815692902,
0.08158670365810394,
-0.6175040602684021,
-0.5487060546875,
1.2375308275222778,
0.3367559313774109,
1.0605791807174683,
-0.007851851172745228,
0.5346842408180237,
0.013764397241175175,
0.02984897419810295,
-0.7757315635681152,
0.3430298864841461,
0.06341522186994553,
-0.5399728417396545,
-0.42150235176086426,
-0.300564706325531,
-0.6645802855491638,
-0.07148343324661255,
-0.4817374050617218,
-0.721391499042511,
0.38375264406204224,
0.3162855803966522,
-0.7222864031791687,
0.39984914660453796,
-0.7401831746101379,
0.49051904678344727,
-0.13396021723747253,
-0.4206382632255554,
-0.33503490686416626,
-0.4185865819454193,
0.6806075572967529,
-0.3362097144126892,
0.0912707969546318,
-0.06051967293024063,
0.3594522476196289,
0.5939615964889526,
-0.005936714354902506,
0.9745698571205139,
-0.06527423113584518,
-0.42343318462371826,
0.06136436387896538,
0.3448987901210785,
0.7569449543952942,
0.3086094260215759,
0.011836174875497818,
-0.26452863216400146,
0.1487412303686142,
-0.27617061138153076,
-0.8102545142173767,
0.5929608941078186,
-1.0028972625732422,
-1.168786883354187,
-0.39882922172546387,
-0.8018175959587097,
-0.3313717246055603,
-0.0232570581138134,
0.1969338208436966,
0.05526164919137955,
0.08174581825733185,
0.2289869338274002,
1.1490187644958496,
-0.37194398045539856,
-0.32525280117988586,
0.6493992805480957,
-0.3320535123348236,
-0.017476346343755722,
0.8453782200813293,
0.3599581718444824,
0.688978910446167,
0.15271298587322235,
0.0465349480509758,
0.06225968897342682,
-0.792011559009552,
0.14382942020893097,
0.3771747350692749,
-0.6455114483833313,
-0.2291530966758728,
-0.5858495235443115,
-0.43168726563453674,
-0.4172936975955963,
-0.0413859598338604,
-0.26653361320495605,
-0.2834048569202423,
-0.4767967164516449,
-0.35404103994369507,
0.3398929238319397,
0.602450966835022,
0.06599029898643494,
0.253364622592926,
-0.4834287762641907,
0.23233789205551147,
0.5221330523490906,
0.4087315797805786,
0.012256740592420101,
-0.9508057236671448,
-0.5957769155502319,
0.12916792929172516,
-0.11149057000875473,
-0.5928763747215271,
0.051453061401844025,
-0.04568815976381302,
0.5723314881324768,
0.7278115749359131,
0.21222801506519318,
0.7377273440361023,
-0.5466198325157166,
0.4778097867965698,
-0.2520350515842438,
-0.6009750366210938,
0.3561166524887085,
-0.33197706937789917,
0.17844532430171967,
0.7502614259719849,
0.3657301664352417,
-0.2626352310180664,
-0.6599424481391907,
-0.4164016842842102,
-0.19299082458019257,
0.5564924478530884,
-0.2790251076221466,
0.4993729591369629,
-0.15222212672233582,
0.7433847784996033,
0.2967422306537628,
0.4353754222393036,
-0.7563926577568054,
-0.07277718186378479,
-0.058468569070100784,
0.18198423087596893,
-0.11048255115747452,
-0.5950524210929871,
-0.23744070529937744,
-0.705125093460083,
0.7725420594215393,
-0.10842389613389969,
0.09485258907079697,
0.01949317753314972,
-0.30404040217399597,
-0.3991943299770355,
0.23759040236473083,
0.7788708209991455,
0.6567474603652954,
-0.3864614963531494,
0.29530754685401917,
0.38289204239845276,
-0.2972947657108307,
-0.07881485670804977,
-0.08468271046876907,
-0.3744077682495117,
-0.3442709445953369,
0.2850764989852905,
1.1740518808364868,
0.3611893057823181,
-0.484178364276886,
0.25986966490745544,
0.26507487893104553,
-0.44575923681259155,
-0.2523382902145386,
0.4338027536869049,
-0.01341815572232008,
0.49243736267089844,
0.04578185826539993,
0.24864237010478973,
-0.056962721049785614,
-0.7450487017631531,
0.3040637671947479,
0.6934086680412292,
-0.37229129672050476,
-0.3123054504394531,
0.5444077849388123,
-0.2426794171333313,
-0.13586018979549408,
0.7155543565750122,
-0.2784045934677124,
-0.4352249503135681,
0.34198227524757385,
0.6793949007987976,
0.6823820471763611,
-0.12341015785932541,
0.12005375325679779,
0.2880445420742035,
0.6896628737449646,
0.022465424612164497,
0.11562227457761765,
0.08228961378335953,
-0.9779482483863831,
-0.49121037125587463,
-0.9214295744895935,
-0.0752105712890625,
0.37817588448524475,
-0.6481586694717407,
0.465832382440567,
-0.48340293765068054,
-0.05039158836007118,
-0.2768044173717499,
0.06354426592588425,
-0.6446926593780518,
0.1585780829191208,
0.07662155479192734,
0.807527482509613,
-0.8696207404136658,
0.9867777824401855,
0.24510644376277924,
-0.4036114811897278,
-0.9560797214508057,
0.3407106101512909,
-0.22423811256885529,
-0.7299129366874695,
0.6167956590652466,
0.15947937965393066,
-0.17350706458091736,
0.1534181833267212,
-0.49129122495651245,
-1.0125679969787598,
1.01747727394104,
0.4872889220714569,
-0.5577936172485352,
-0.2428179681301117,
0.1736249178647995,
0.6036552786827087,
-0.23927223682403564,
-0.2880587577819824,
0.7797452807426453,
0.4565252959728241,
0.03534678742289543,
-0.790164053440094,
0.24517519772052765,
0.10412618517875671,
-0.3233358561992645,
0.067888543009758,
-0.5671755075454712,
0.973518967628479,
-0.6464413404464722,
-0.40432438254356384,
-0.1139543429017067,
0.678271472454071,
0.14516764879226685,
0.1402311623096466,
0.37848779559135437,
0.5662835240364075,
1.0747337341308594,
0.050374992191791534,
0.7997520565986633,
-0.3546393811702728,
0.10659430921077728,
1.3034805059432983,
-0.2386932224035263,
0.671091616153717,
0.6113772392272949,
0.10158967226743698,
0.44346800446510315,
0.5427879095077515,
-0.2299817055463791,
0.5940655469894409,
0.35910624265670776,
-0.10789745301008224,
-0.4675346910953522,
-0.06706312298774719,
-0.4407719671726227,
0.25172361731529236,
0.3980143964290619,
-0.27628982067108154,
-0.03070790506899357,
0.15118345618247986,
0.032253749668598175,
0.21488429605960846,
-0.2585853636264801,
0.8175337910652161,
0.19966961443424225,
-0.7461735010147095,
0.8869161009788513,
-0.2763175070285797,
0.5663892030715942,
-0.4246697723865509,
0.14357155561447144,
-0.16959212720394135,
0.05962824448943138,
-0.3065992295742035,
-0.44980162382125854,
0.42570874094963074,
-0.3307189643383026,
-0.3694590628147125,
0.265470415353775,
0.45241788029670715,
-0.37471240758895874,
-0.36500558257102966,
0.19816425442695618,
0.5995395183563232,
0.12971815466880798,
-0.17731843888759613,
-0.13485342264175415,
-0.06308072060346603,
0.09448017179965973,
-0.2607049345970154,
0.46029698848724365,
0.85758376121521,
-0.07161134481430054,
0.696475088596344,
0.6606768369674683,
0.18292644619941711,
0.33611083030700684,
0.10109950602054596,
1.010636806488037,
-0.5922033786773682,
-0.07699380815029144,
-0.8956093192100525,
0.21998335421085358,
0.19721396267414093,
-0.055724047124385834,
0.8105822205543518,
0.5871292948722839,
1.0998138189315796,
-0.2454477995634079,
0.6427562832832336,
0.33822858333587646,
0.3172096908092499,
-0.9775156378746033,
0.8882508873939514,
-0.7588001489639282,
0.47525671124458313,
-0.10809367895126343,
-0.6709463596343994,
-0.259925901889801,
0.553794264793396,
-0.4243911802768707,
-0.10279545933008194,
0.9504866003990173,
1.1451051235198975,
0.08708996325731277,
-0.14357396960258484,
0.6757685542106628,
0.7436548471450806,
-0.006984227802604437,
0.4029719829559326,
0.8286625146865845,
-0.092827707529068,
0.3502771854400635,
-0.39562758803367615,
-0.10937194526195526,
-0.16871778666973114,
-0.5957785248756409,
-1.2607805728912354,
-0.6663009524345398,
-0.1799730807542801,
-0.44635939598083496,
0.22203148901462555,
0.8406893014907837,
0.28179633617401123,
-0.9019420146942139,
-0.1296088695526123,
-0.093487948179245,
0.21683543920516968,
0.05255897715687752,
-0.23171068727970123,
0.2874535322189331,
-0.9589903354644775,
-0.6144312620162964,
0.03652627393603325,
0.07810916006565094,
0.3297542631626129,
-0.23916542530059814,
0.0799930989742279,
-0.19562393426895142,
0.18816840648651123,
0.5755072236061096,
-0.016509484499692917,
-0.7819719314575195,
-0.5484780669212341,
0.21606089174747467,
-0.11883407831192017,
-0.017438536509871483,
0.7038537263870239,
-0.8295879364013672,
0.2514975965023041,
0.1440381109714508,
0.709652304649353,
0.39166322350502014,
-0.23681023716926575,
0.6017323136329651,
-0.32082152366638184,
0.175322026014328,
-0.020255260169506073,
0.051752541214227676,
0.09221503138542175,
-0.6210575103759766,
0.01581295020878315,
0.1853720247745514,
-0.6267613172531128,
-0.9967442154884338,
0.2515169084072113,
-0.6691182255744934,
-0.42196357250213623,
1.0533006191253662,
0.4430302679538727,
-0.18178369104862213,
-0.034819819033145905,
-0.2509765326976776,
0.5349238514900208,
-0.06061539798974991,
1.3949447870254517,
0.9044337272644043,
-0.022779475897550583,
-0.002661199774593115,
-0.9013383388519287,
1.0004481077194214,
0.5021023154258728,
-0.6763861775398254,
0.26831334829330444,
0.4257185757160187,
0.36786049604415894,
0.11245843768119812,
0.2993735373020172,
0.05809425190091133,
0.1367059350013733,
-0.15622247755527496,
-0.06485696882009506,
-0.2043532282114029,
-0.5446686148643494,
-0.30729031562805176,
-0.007946785539388657,
0.3708961308002472,
0.08386828750371933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05894v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05894v2
|
Efficient LLM Comparative Assessment: a Product of Experts Framework for Pairwise Comparisons
| 2024-05-09T16:45:27 | 2024-06-09T17:56:11 |
Adian Liusie, Vatsal Raina, Yassir Fathullah, Mark Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LLM-as-a-judge approaches are a practical and effective way of assessing a
range of text tasks, aligning with human judgements especially when applied in
a comparative assessment fashion. However, when using pairwise comparisons to
rank a set of candidates the computational costs scale quadratically with the
number of candidates, which can have practical limitations. This paper
introduces a Product of Expert (PoE) framework for efficient LLM Comparative
Assessment. Here individual comparisons are considered experts that provide
information on a pair's score difference. The PoE framework combines the
information from these experts to yield an expression that can be maximized
with respect to the underlying set of candidates, and is highly flexible where
any form of expert can be assumed. When Gaussian experts are used one can
derive simple closed-form solutions for the optimal candidate ranking, as well
as expressions for selecting which comparisons should be made to maximize the
probability of this ranking. Our approach enables efficient comparative
assessment, where by using only a small subset of the possible comparisons, one
can generate score predictions that correlate as well to human judgements as
the predictions when all comparisons are used. We evaluate the approach on
multiple NLG tasks and demonstrate that our framework can yield considerable
computational savings when performing pairwise comparative assessment. When N
is large, with as few as 2% of comparisons the PoE solution can achieve similar
performance to when all comparisons are used.
|
[
-0.25933563709259033,
-0.5096749663352966,
0.5753311514854431,
0.554108202457428,
-0.06387534737586975,
0.33094295859336853,
-0.24208587408065796,
-0.5922139883041382,
0.2669190764427185,
0.21426983177661896,
0.07332845032215118,
-0.42195838689804077,
-0.5353214740753174,
0.20211461186408997,
-0.3568326234817505,
0.5782582759857178,
0.12523508071899414,
-0.0838172659277916,
-0.41008928418159485,
-0.2982426881790161,
-0.09918121248483658,
-0.28556597232818604,
-0.9772042036056519,
-0.38115713000297546,
0.4560092091560364,
0.38963842391967773,
0.5793431401252747,
0.3774973750114441,
1.1116604804992676,
0.4414990246295929,
-0.17503005266189575,
0.2915387749671936,
-0.41271477937698364,
0.14164115488529205,
-0.22783446311950684,
-0.5274227857589722,
-0.7500737905502319,
0.23585520684719086,
0.42214056849479675,
0.5449560284614563,
-0.23691479861736298,
0.3485041558742523,
-0.07557468861341476,
0.8298357129096985,
-0.6859931349754333,
-0.04554184153676033,
-0.9189818501472473,
0.2812330424785614,
0.0457066185772419,
-0.37616419792175293,
-0.3931257426738739,
-0.35271453857421875,
0.055998269468545914,
-0.6687238812446594,
0.30186519026756287,
0.4072227478027344,
0.5219550132751465,
0.374986469745636,
-0.44645068049430847,
0.0578499473631382,
-0.3779519498348236,
0.85108882188797,
-0.6780117154121399,
0.2302265167236328,
0.1314874142408371,
0.3499375283718109,
0.0338858924806118,
-0.6193650960922241,
-0.5325572490692139,
-0.5609245300292969,
-0.07807739824056625,
0.47890588641166687,
-0.26447030901908875,
0.39583620429039,
0.35464802384376526,
0.41778436303138733,
-0.5694680213928223,
0.34260231256484985,
-0.1594826728105545,
-0.19096292555332184,
1.1518055200576782,
0.1615457385778427,
0.03059660829603672,
-0.2806243896484375,
-0.8635061979293823,
0.023902133107185364,
-0.6694086194038391,
-0.03924139589071274,
0.7071393132209778,
-0.06934913992881775,
0.21890445053577423,
0.3502937853336334,
-0.45648688077926636,
0.8862049579620361,
0.15285776555538177,
-0.3667866289615631,
0.19354835152626038,
-0.28748348355293274,
-0.19453711807727814,
-0.1513315737247467,
0.9497315287590027,
0.9145328402519226,
-0.012049808166921139,
-0.33004483580589294,
-0.5511260628700256,
0.09881146997213364,
0.5095961689949036,
-0.6677192449569702,
-0.42304420471191406,
-0.05619875341653824,
-0.6360269784927368,
-0.663415789604187,
-0.0036222273483872414,
-0.903411328792572,
-0.4155542254447937,
-0.26179933547973633,
0.7566424608230591,
0.34996411204338074,
0.0019270579796284437,
0.024035340175032616,
-0.10406721383333206,
0.11974021792411804,
0.34266361594200134,
-0.7213130593299866,
0.6815958619117737,
0.6540930271148682,
0.8029623627662659,
-0.648536741733551,
-0.048846688121557236,
-0.9198858737945557,
-0.2695223093032837,
-0.42154309153556824,
0.907914400100708,
-0.34095197916030884,
-0.39224472641944885,
-0.2915523052215576,
-0.713243305683136,
-0.08904682099819183,
-0.7640489339828491,
0.8616799712181091,
-0.6217150688171387,
0.09311269968748093,
-0.14814211428165436,
-0.6019794344902039,
-0.2383769154548645,
0.4128221869468689,
-0.6469138860702515,
1.3473880290985107,
-0.06030131131410599,
-0.7514472007751465,
0.4163297116756439,
-0.568396806716919,
-0.28176063299179077,
0.22718700766563416,
-0.32493728399276733,
-0.4030430316925049,
-0.005728169810026884,
0.3176162540912628,
0.6988252997398376,
-0.37775474786758423,
0.08797284215688705,
-0.32318657636642456,
-0.4799240231513977,
0.06683307886123657,
-0.2126096487045288,
0.5776293873786926,
0.22673019766807556,
-0.4814775586128235,
0.253919392824173,
-0.775898814201355,
0.09767258912324905,
-0.06866317987442017,
-0.47098761796951294,
-0.24067530035972595,
0.1811826378107071,
-0.16065996885299683,
-0.07050313800573349,
0.19650499522686005,
-0.48496177792549133,
0.15393398702144623,
-0.43356558680534363,
0.20490846037864685,
0.9413691163063049,
-0.07835082709789276,
0.5150763988494873,
-0.54459547996521,
0.4984596371650696,
-0.5374085903167725,
0.22434622049331665,
0.3275763690471649,
-0.7096744179725647,
-0.7514639496803284,
-0.07648620754480362,
0.5786858797073364,
0.7625322341918945,
-0.5223208069801331,
0.5701099634170532,
-0.17804619669914246,
-0.5864430665969849,
-0.5934385061264038,
0.4670886695384979,
0.5126534700393677,
0.8179041743278503,
0.22410067915916443,
-0.4665209949016571,
-0.22792550921440125,
-1.0225948095321655,
-0.4118451774120331,
-0.5483734011650085,
-0.0467260479927063,
0.29180827736854553,
0.31183984875679016,
0.2589251697063446,
0.7844066023826599,
-0.44781622290611267,
-0.25476983189582825,
-0.15633006393909454,
0.01721949316561222,
0.42967596650123596,
0.19670724868774414,
0.6093428730964661,
-0.8897923231124878,
-0.8196781873703003,
0.18001843988895416,
-0.7358569502830505,
-0.44422104954719543,
-0.22429223358631134,
-0.11344778537750244,
0.011978955939412117,
0.47849041223526,
-0.29708319902420044,
0.37205520272254944,
0.4789107143878937,
-0.1519051343202591,
0.6011070013046265,
-0.42503365874290466,
0.39099958539009094,
-0.727994978427887,
0.190340057015419,
0.20648624002933502,
-0.4993252456188202,
-0.4677651822566986,
0.5574361681938171,
-0.061466388404369354,
0.422031044960022,
-0.27627113461494446,
0.6340001225471497,
-0.256087064743042,
-0.26835232973098755,
-0.14481070637702942,
0.5869601964950562,
0.1130320280790329,
0.3802327811717987,
-0.26267534494400024,
0.785057783126831,
0.3067472577095032,
-0.31156986951828003,
0.5673771500587463,
0.19272607564926147,
-0.5572972893714905,
0.7808013558387756,
-0.7867417931556702,
0.4668480157852173,
0.33430105447769165,
0.03088764287531376,
-0.92757248878479,
0.30176258087158203,
0.165513813495636,
-0.5222686529159546,
0.16978031396865845,
0.01338549330830574,
-0.6052758097648621,
-0.21402844786643982,
-0.7631754875183105,
0.14850088953971863,
0.48639675974845886,
-0.8429350256919861,
0.5920372605323792,
0.23000259697437286,
-0.26856428384780884,
-0.9052009582519531,
-0.5806773900985718,
0.2566179037094116,
-0.4915563762187958,
-0.7651170492172241,
0.7325396537780762,
-0.34112781286239624,
-0.7995502352714539,
-0.07210267335176468,
-0.2980891466140747,
0.17900413274765015,
0.34717658162117004,
0.04974181577563286,
0.3463134169578552,
-0.07285262644290924,
0.07169116288423538,
-0.048228465020656586,
-0.340552419424057,
0.13176925480365753,
0.022660689428448677,
-0.07312197983264923,
-0.15590742230415344,
-0.3487355411052704,
-0.1257418394088745,
0.44906947016716003,
0.21242651343345642,
-0.16793467104434967,
0.13620342314243317,
0.5734376907348633,
-0.14949367940425873,
-0.24782593548297882,
-1.0939964056015015,
0.029312796890735626,
-0.5227932333946228,
0.2698117196559906,
-0.4207013249397278,
-0.5779204368591309,
0.5598174333572388,
-0.02623632550239563,
0.17564688622951508,
0.5584599375724792,
0.5544906854629517,
-0.16423799097537994,
0.9080897569656372,
0.47592729330062866,
-0.27095016837120056,
0.1979825347661972,
-0.2567204236984253,
0.5078394412994385,
-0.7649686932563782,
-0.2112906277179718,
-0.5334653258323669,
-0.6903452277183533,
-0.47872811555862427,
-0.4476865530014038,
0.6126661896705627,
0.3072900176048279,
-0.09349864721298218,
0.07955343276262283,
-0.7175998091697693,
0.7179533243179321,
0.7674276828765869,
0.19879767298698425,
0.5716667771339417,
-0.009198976680636406,
-0.31128180027008057,
0.18788239359855652,
-0.6574609279632568,
-0.47979921102523804,
1.4449691772460938,
0.18394359946250916,
0.4248984456062317,
0.12044985592365265,
0.9105648994445801,
0.5911189317703247,
0.28374582529067993,
-0.8733218312263489,
0.8728429675102234,
-0.1573348194360733,
-0.2527174949645996,
-0.08021022379398346,
-0.6240727305412292,
-0.6165320873260498,
0.4328545928001404,
-0.6312094330787659,
-0.81903076171875,
0.07354947179555893,
0.04304792732000351,
-0.5585939288139343,
0.49655672907829285,
-0.7839544415473938,
0.5505609512329102,
-0.39533793926239014,
-0.6569317579269409,
-0.5826674103736877,
-0.732353687286377,
0.10387560725212097,
-0.1951783448457718,
-0.08910251408815384,
-0.17046770453453064,
-0.4066372513771057,
1.1182224750518799,
-0.17800630629062653,
0.42460593581199646,
-0.2325829416513443,
0.4293747842311859,
0.15848477184772491,
0.029822027310729027,
0.45012325048446655,
0.17589563131332397,
-0.5979253053665161,
0.008014402352273464,
-0.2451273500919342,
-0.2931956946849823,
-0.8289280533790588,
0.7437670230865479,
-0.7492154240608215,
-0.6868818998336792,
-0.2137913703918457,
-0.3013773262500763,
-0.1999058872461319,
0.050588399171829224,
0.08481085300445557,
0.33067241311073303,
-0.04721404239535332,
0.04539705812931061,
0.48670241236686707,
-0.014689311385154724,
0.39729130268096924,
0.46225184202194214,
-0.18159304559230804,
-0.4413449168205261,
0.7961129546165466,
-0.07961183786392212,
0.09024116396903992,
0.6450803875923157,
0.4264281094074249,
-0.5062934160232544,
-0.977115273475647,
-0.1716768741607666,
-0.10574290156364441,
-0.8700354099273682,
-0.5179387331008911,
-0.5058407187461853,
0.13787108659744263,
0.024910511448979378,
-0.4006284475326538,
0.04329238086938858,
-0.5924142003059387,
0.22892725467681885,
-0.39168378710746765,
0.28099262714385986,
0.7888834476470947,
-0.13952021300792694,
0.3215102255344391,
-0.29556897282600403,
0.38708725571632385,
0.6892532110214233,
0.22903801500797272,
-0.09146276116371155,
-0.27831587195396423,
0.1374780535697937,
-0.5741211175918579,
-0.5889778137207031,
-0.8377811908721924,
0.22663600742816925,
0.3358497619628906,
1.0793204307556152,
0.47374677658081055,
0.18458521366119385,
0.4364033639431,
-0.11717814952135086,
0.6788058876991272,
0.31114476919174194,
-0.9673864245414734,
0.25549691915512085,
-0.1929495632648468,
-0.29923903942108154,
0.8458853363990784,
0.16595637798309326,
-0.16360688209533691,
-0.2894541919231415,
-0.7443714141845703,
-1.0000580549240112,
0.41988176107406616,
0.1997467279434204,
-0.254384845495224,
0.19153207540512085,
0.3809998035430908,
0.24446021020412445,
0.10678506642580032,
-0.5616862177848816,
-0.1851879507303238,
0.4365272521972656,
-0.03382248431444168,
-0.23531489074230194,
-0.13191543519496918,
-0.19585122168064117,
-0.42601478099823,
0.5517822504043579,
-0.2915770709514618,
0.31349706649780273,
0.30322372913360596,
-0.12269221991300583,
0.1865154206752777,
0.14947885274887085,
0.23941506445407867,
0.5617458820343018,
-0.30764803290367126,
0.2707309126853943,
0.7369740009307861,
-0.09968364983797073,
-0.018230030313134193,
0.06972763687372208,
0.05304981395602226,
-0.11514083296060562,
0.5319945216178894,
0.5415911674499512,
0.40380969643592834,
-0.49366295337677,
0.7595030069351196,
0.024830885231494904,
-0.4954374134540558,
-0.010949144139885902,
-0.004557167179882526,
0.14881356060504913,
0.38529568910598755,
0.29290708899497986,
0.48634374141693115,
0.5417308807373047,
-0.1765710562467575,
0.31673845648765564,
0.29486820101737976,
-0.012703371234238148,
0.07544121891260147,
0.6492018699645996,
0.6635004281997681,
-0.6336574554443359,
0.5992706418037415,
-0.5621964335441589,
-0.7369764447212219,
0.7918117046356201,
0.12433776259422302,
0.8053022623062134,
-0.04711027815937996,
0.05775907263159752,
0.30659955739974976,
0.2094227522611618,
-0.16956277191638947,
0.24025604128837585,
-0.43264034390449524,
-0.7589354515075684,
-0.35287410020828247,
-0.47418028116226196,
-0.8369600176811218,
-0.34737956523895264,
-0.6181462407112122,
0.24415147304534912,
-0.4311946630477905,
-0.2663206160068512,
0.018509017303586006,
0.5275698900222778,
-0.8288429975509644,
0.11889775842428207,
0.03823188692331314,
0.9777041077613831,
-0.7435670495033264,
0.4591207206249237,
0.5839600563049316,
-0.1137593537569046,
-0.7373309135437012,
-0.20285803079605103,
-0.03655457869172096,
-0.9409914612770081,
0.4855225086212158,
0.25906622409820557,
-0.29355230927467346,
-0.29700469970703125,
-0.06633535772562027,
-0.2945570945739746,
1.0240404605865479,
0.5896773934364319,
-0.6852765679359436,
0.0909164696931839,
-0.21059764921665192,
0.6583144068717957,
-0.3473411798477173,
0.8321911096572876,
0.48549970984458923,
0.5270902514457703,
-0.1998813897371292,
-1.0585979223251343,
-0.03304116800427437,
-0.6156249046325684,
-0.2673601508140564,
0.08792533725500107,
-0.6918198466300964,
0.5327463746070862,
-0.29681363701820374,
0.044633060693740845,
0.015717968344688416,
0.5305877923965454,
0.14538872241973877,
0.6172727346420288,
0.8715317249298096,
0.5571245551109314,
0.8651204705238342,
0.12370062619447708,
0.9458823204040527,
-0.5534375309944153,
0.44992324709892273,
0.9072349071502686,
-0.2566829025745392,
1.1906356811523438,
0.40007999539375305,
-0.5661754608154297,
0.2539074420928955,
0.6546736359596252,
-0.22306086122989655,
0.21477672457695007,
0.434181809425354,
-0.3696106970310211,
-0.4943297505378723,
0.09803668409585953,
-0.0647248849272728,
0.5006263256072998,
-0.01978386752307415,
-0.3442205786705017,
-0.14525333046913147,
-0.5450129508972168,
-0.3927918076515198,
0.4854283630847931,
-0.40507999062538147,
0.7544780969619751,
0.2600879371166229,
-0.5733303427696228,
0.17627716064453125,
0.0896863043308258,
1.0443986654281616,
-0.35053080320358276,
-0.027199069038033485,
-0.11685680598020554,
0.1591300517320633,
-0.5774524211883545,
-0.7692897915840149,
0.21917320787906647,
-0.09028737992048264,
0.009902837686240673,
-0.5100504755973816,
0.9058167338371277,
-0.1831931173801422,
-0.5790578126907349,
0.6965050101280212,
0.5843007564544678,
0.15754975378513336,
-0.20427872240543365,
-0.7586476802825928,
-0.2782602310180664,
-0.14712825417518616,
-0.20495745539665222,
0.23644396662712097,
-0.314093679189682,
-0.010588801465928555,
0.6827070116996765,
0.38362932205200195,
0.3090112805366516,
0.09164410829544067,
-0.08460290729999542,
0.4671233296394348,
-0.29106178879737854,
-0.6242569088935852,
-0.7001515030860901,
0.26789039373397827,
-0.48730871081352234,
-0.35364431142807007,
0.6027618646621704,
0.6600062251091003,
0.732119083404541,
0.32642847299575806,
0.6889588236808777,
0.2711513042449951,
0.4338054358959198,
-0.47684425115585327,
0.7989540696144104,
-0.6561426520347595,
0.4097139239311218,
-0.26159846782684326,
-1.1158679723739624,
-0.3626995086669922,
0.7826788425445557,
-0.3966015875339508,
-0.008298886939883232,
0.7013630270957947,
0.9009668827056885,
0.06643079221248627,
0.027585580945014954,
0.3949699103832245,
-0.12545165419578552,
0.2876037359237671,
0.6332201361656189,
0.7819885611534119,
-0.2721593379974365,
0.3214357793331146,
-0.4615322947502136,
-0.4555588662624359,
-0.24019426107406616,
-0.9298056960105896,
-0.9280113577842712,
-0.33698391914367676,
-0.45256271958351135,
0.10393647104501724,
0.08569260686635971,
1.1309826374053955,
0.7847223281860352,
-0.47625279426574707,
-0.31766632199287415,
0.30408212542533875,
0.2927144765853882,
-0.3858247697353363,
-0.19039055705070496,
0.4625631868839264,
-0.15424023568630219,
-0.5995382070541382,
0.6720930337905884,
0.3711596131324768,
-0.6448371410369873,
-0.18576394021511078,
-0.033452313393354416,
0.1934698522090912,
0.05270887166261673,
0.680423378944397,
-0.14678332209587097,
-0.6655739545822144,
-0.39557868242263794,
-0.08502084016799927,
0.056198637932538986,
0.21368791162967682,
0.7049937844276428,
-0.9234139323234558,
0.7307904362678528,
0.8855313062667847,
0.7255347967147827,
0.3509314954280853,
0.021275358274579048,
0.5624867081642151,
-0.5463951826095581,
-0.13594205677509308,
0.2757537364959717,
0.3340857923030853,
0.2499292641878128,
-0.3810863196849823,
0.8833486437797546,
0.22342947125434875,
-0.656863272190094,
-0.7293221354484558,
0.03257056698203087,
-1.5627025365829468,
0.17987942695617676,
1.0897308588027954,
-0.35013097524642944,
0.15835779905319214,
0.09702999889850616,
-0.186519593000412,
-0.18292050063610077,
-0.38328975439071655,
1.0001264810562134,
0.3682253062725067,
-0.3515094816684723,
0.23081868886947632,
-0.5351012349128723,
0.2027631402015686,
0.6063836812973022,
-0.745303750038147,
-0.45836493372917175,
-0.2107267826795578,
0.2727682590484619,
0.06454914808273315,
0.817054271697998,
0.0734119638800621,
0.22684891521930695,
0.13981759548187256,
-0.03500761091709137,
-0.12551826238632202,
-0.2195795625448227,
-0.4154107868671417,
0.4045554995536804,
0.23484276235103607,
-0.22460299730300903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06715v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06715v1
|
Enhancing Creativity in Large Language Models through Associative Thinking Strategies
| 2024-05-09T16:42:29 | 2024-05-09T16:42:29 |
Pronita Mehrotra, Aishni Parab, Sumit Gulwani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper explores the enhancement of creativity in Large Language Models
(LLMs) like vGPT-4 through associative thinking, a cognitive process where
creative ideas emerge from linking seemingly unrelated concepts. Associative
thinking strategies have been found to effectively help humans boost
creativity. However, whether the same strategies can help LLMs become more
creative remains under-explored. In this work, we investigate whether prompting
LLMs to connect disparate concepts can augment their creative outputs. Focusing
on three domains -- Product Design, Storytelling, and Marketing -- we introduce
creativity tasks designed to assess vGPT-4's ability to generate original and
useful content. By challenging the models to form novel associations, we
evaluate the potential of associative thinking to enhance the creative
capabilities of LLMs. Our findings show that leveraging associative thinking
techniques can significantly improve the originality of vGPT-4's responses.
|
[
-0.6555739641189575,
-0.8555216789245605,
0.7125608921051025,
0.22294101119041443,
-0.46312257647514343,
0.664277970790863,
-0.25332343578338623,
-0.6090777516365051,
0.3216560482978821,
0.3652145564556122,
-0.6374066472053528,
-0.2627622187137604,
-0.27382999658584595,
0.0923873633146286,
-0.17365345358848572,
0.9467748999595642,
-0.2410241663455963,
-0.2694897949695587,
-0.1838054209947586,
-0.24906191229820251,
-0.7798209190368652,
-0.5729489326477051,
-0.5473567843437195,
-0.258584201335907,
0.5467522144317627,
0.19173820316791534,
0.7446138858795166,
0.43599122762680054,
0.49967676401138306,
0.36087244749069214,
0.032453835010528564,
0.34620141983032227,
-0.5199158787727356,
0.23231181502342224,
-0.3494817614555359,
-0.5380557179450989,
-0.377413809299469,
-0.09861216694116592,
0.4518493115901947,
0.4725903272628784,
-0.1547616571187973,
0.06750171631574631,
-0.1295306235551834,
0.6518526673316956,
-0.37899330258369446,
0.2281143218278885,
-0.7455867528915405,
0.08874846994876862,
-0.1167064979672432,
-0.2697066068649292,
0.08177421241998672,
-0.3584834337234497,
0.11340116709470749,
-0.6937857866287231,
0.14965713024139404,
-0.04148956760764122,
0.35768237709999084,
0.04808539152145386,
-0.012905282899737358,
-0.5907977223396301,
-1.0451353788375854,
0.43429887294769287,
-0.6679473519325256,
0.11083374172449112,
-0.09155401587486267,
-0.010011824779212475,
0.018659835681319237,
-0.5739955902099609,
-1.071197271347046,
-0.015930084511637688,
0.4115128815174103,
0.18965722620487213,
-0.32690513134002686,
-0.2200237214565277,
0.305943101644516,
0.6957916617393494,
-0.46233615279197693,
0.09612628072500229,
-0.25851544737815857,
0.14840206503868103,
0.6341083645820618,
0.19014497101306915,
0.4298556447029114,
0.2542676627635956,
-0.4061247706413269,
0.13929812610149384,
-0.5973044633865356,
0.007687283214181662,
0.4398246705532074,
-0.13719619810581207,
0.10149753838777542,
0.760836660861969,
-0.23285755515098572,
0.28498026728630066,
-0.06381262093782425,
0.06729793548583984,
0.4819261133670807,
-0.6277086138725281,
0.028806323185563087,
-0.00937245786190033,
0.5421952605247498,
0.381766140460968,
0.1735154241323471,
-0.17860963940620422,
-0.45267391204833984,
0.29464107751846313,
0.3411811292171478,
-0.49900275468826294,
-0.41276925802230835,
0.0033330100122839212,
-0.20168104767799377,
-0.2180456966161728,
-0.06369943916797638,
-0.3659712076187134,
-0.28746140003204346,
-0.4573596119880676,
0.7032480239868164,
-0.42511311173439026,
-0.4174197018146515,
0.3561124801635742,
-0.4743736684322357,
0.07044896483421326,
0.2605198919773102,
-1.1852753162384033,
0.25360482931137085,
0.8259361386299133,
0.8392881155014038,
-0.34994393587112427,
-0.28016674518585205,
-0.07243311405181885,
0.31695032119750977,
-0.489841490983963,
1.0524396896362305,
-0.5330724716186523,
-0.3285183608531952,
-0.013757728971540928,
-0.33393725752830505,
0.37351736426353455,
-0.5509225130081177,
0.3144727349281311,
-0.5186966061592102,
0.07150425016880035,
-0.6088607907295227,
-0.3990967273712158,
-0.18246442079544067,
0.3630503714084625,
-0.7644982933998108,
0.6142472624778748,
0.07288030534982681,
-0.639312207698822,
0.291543185710907,
-0.6232966184616089,
-0.6525444984436035,
0.5722929239273071,
-0.5216960310935974,
-0.45201829075813293,
0.4991271495819092,
0.3034251034259796,
0.01401679776608944,
-0.33504822850227356,
-0.0851767361164093,
-0.34833982586860657,
-0.08551793545484543,
0.5944277048110962,
-0.36038103699684143,
0.46674156188964844,
0.042233213782310486,
-0.5295146107673645,
0.0791136622428894,
-0.6140103340148926,
0.2514510452747345,
0.4532618820667267,
-0.3624187111854553,
-0.4286293387413025,
-0.5592580437660217,
-0.3636026680469513,
0.45967137813568115,
0.28916653990745544,
-0.26450303196907043,
0.5174117684364319,
-0.489461749792099,
0.5071914792060852,
0.7891732454299927,
0.33451440930366516,
0.5361435413360596,
-0.7674858570098877,
0.7110668420791626,
-0.10375025868415833,
-0.18810902535915375,
-0.17245399951934814,
-0.7699345946311951,
-0.8331843614578247,
0.0036467411555349827,
-0.1605578362941742,
0.19082200527191162,
-1.2808465957641602,
-0.0008598007261753082,
-0.11966521292924881,
-0.7097861766815186,
-0.4819026291370392,
0.42512091994285583,
0.33039212226867676,
0.24677376449108124,
0.09055888652801514,
-0.7878310084342957,
-0.3988948166370392,
-0.5923430919647217,
-0.2913734018802643,
-0.037692680954933167,
-0.03325534984469414,
0.10509583353996277,
0.548389732837677,
0.07020389288663864,
0.5397382974624634,
-0.5828509330749512,
-0.24915726482868195,
-0.35038068890571594,
0.34664541482925415,
0.19624726474285126,
0.10964026302099228,
0.4531501829624176,
-0.8165821433067322,
-0.5789663195610046,
0.10181180387735367,
-0.60395348072052,
-0.14216868579387665,
-0.2595289945602417,
-0.1274292916059494,
0.10728512704372406,
0.14269325137138367,
-1.0805799961090088,
0.2845872640609741,
0.19455033540725708,
-0.1336548626422882,
0.6916115283966064,
-0.2960846722126007,
0.09990515559911728,
-0.8541203141212463,
-0.3675284683704376,
-0.07635529339313507,
0.4933395981788635,
-0.52534019947052,
-0.01695350930094719,
-0.2571360766887665,
0.032980069518089294,
-0.3656752109527588,
0.5058702230453491,
-0.7273680567741394,
-0.2882685661315918,
-0.4515489637851715,
0.25798308849334717,
0.09824807941913605,
0.4514937102794647,
0.10521799325942993,
0.7450171709060669,
0.5431895852088928,
-0.40120866894721985,
0.5012392997741699,
0.5601261258125305,
-0.5649774670600891,
0.5054029822349548,
-0.49310779571533203,
0.40317022800445557,
-0.2689509391784668,
0.13024383783340454,
-1.0659669637680054,
-0.012500645592808723,
-0.020455023273825645,
-0.23067092895507812,
-0.16536270081996918,
0.38140997290611267,
-0.8072251081466675,
-0.6174007058143616,
-0.26863372325897217,
0.37950870394706726,
0.43009600043296814,
-0.4928601384162903,
0.41752704977989197,
0.32696130871772766,
-0.6013999581336975,
-0.08175406605005264,
-0.776408314704895,
0.038667917251586914,
-0.5981197953224182,
-0.6198130249977112,
0.7077640891075134,
-0.48025497794151306,
-0.29753562808036804,
0.06288530677556992,
-0.12033572793006897,
0.22810140252113342,
-0.05578254908323288,
-0.055898766964673996,
0.24165137112140656,
-0.2709078788757324,
0.07958435267210007,
-0.33730483055114746,
0.23765702545642853,
0.09918791800737381,
-0.4960762858390808,
0.7063131928443909,
-0.18258719146251678,
-0.35250288248062134,
-0.16285617649555206,
0.3810300827026367,
0.45523807406425476,
-0.5528523325920105,
0.33575454354286194,
0.7158282995223999,
-0.07861094176769257,
-0.4385950565338135,
-0.5813109278678894,
0.01927170716226101,
-0.563484787940979,
0.27707502245903015,
-0.3754812479019165,
-1.0085182189941406,
0.6566532850265503,
0.07353945821523666,
-0.013795753940939903,
0.02814907766878605,
1.0929639339447021,
0.09510046988725662,
0.8483948111534119,
0.721433699131012,
0.12326689064502716,
0.5356016159057617,
-0.3795296549797058,
0.6560021638870239,
-0.9208354353904724,
-0.30347347259521484,
0.04322135075926781,
-0.40588319301605225,
-0.49921590089797974,
-0.5429837107658386,
0.23280349373817444,
-0.2614751160144806,
-0.12891949713230133,
0.10797590017318726,
-0.45435598492622375,
0.6867296695709229,
0.7867675423622131,
-0.021883241832256317,
0.5199379324913025,
-0.11549156159162521,
-0.10992315411567688,
0.16399510204792023,
-0.6075031757354736,
-0.31778034567832947,
0.9588891267776489,
0.21333827078342438,
0.6852061748504639,
0.480795681476593,
0.615621030330658,
-0.0676058679819107,
0.16726765036582947,
-0.8875697255134583,
0.5049633979797363,
0.09896325320005417,
-0.41087865829467773,
-0.22276976704597473,
-0.27391517162323,
-0.6720795631408691,
0.1518602818250656,
-0.1854403018951416,
-0.7645593881607056,
0.03812088072299957,
-0.11334221065044403,
-0.6190303564071655,
0.2343001365661621,
-0.6284653544425964,
0.51237553358078,
-0.5347373485565186,
-0.558380126953125,
-0.1208965927362442,
-0.17034046351909637,
0.44105246663093567,
-0.5426321029663086,
0.22998513281345367,
0.12135066092014313,
-0.061732493340969086,
0.5460444092750549,
-0.09974996745586395,
0.536561131477356,
0.40767669677734375,
-0.5429235696792603,
0.7020331621170044,
0.04167599603533745,
0.4856955409049988,
0.03331843763589859,
0.14494618773460388,
0.018346233293414116,
-0.5392258763313293,
-0.1633152812719345,
-0.8863052725791931,
0.8155368566513062,
-0.5193682312965393,
-1.0394341945648193,
-0.11647112667560577,
-0.9676998853683472,
-0.44692808389663696,
0.3495452105998993,
0.24076080322265625,
0.10701896995306015,
-0.05345870554447174,
0.12987200915813446,
0.37035977840423584,
-0.07731866836547852,
0.6019647717475891,
0.5338560938835144,
-0.019842645153403282,
-0.5497776865959167,
0.77435702085495,
0.24257969856262207,
0.5676231384277344,
0.09435596317052841,
-0.008505885489284992,
-0.3279533088207245,
-0.6950516104698181,
-0.01566218212246895,
0.2059478610754013,
-0.8072088360786438,
-0.11684320122003555,
-0.5575000643730164,
-0.21628741919994354,
-0.3037402331829071,
-0.12939897179603577,
-0.22960811853408813,
-0.5450897812843323,
0.022540003061294556,
-0.2329268902540207,
0.13367357850074768,
0.7543854117393494,
-0.17895027995109558,
0.273415744304657,
-0.5228885412216187,
0.29156380891799927,
0.5285131335258484,
0.26998013257980347,
0.4305481016635895,
-0.15676581859588623,
-0.29338932037353516,
0.10191532969474792,
-0.8800889253616333,
-0.5554975271224976,
0.471823126077652,
0.022195512428879738,
0.6432567238807678,
0.3009430468082428,
-0.2935509979724884,
0.5158499479293823,
-0.6589715480804443,
0.9243254661560059,
0.35235193371772766,
-0.7246701121330261,
0.2137843370437622,
-0.504199206829071,
0.5808641910552979,
0.0742608979344368,
0.4544464945793152,
-0.2069263905286789,
-0.3602651059627533,
-0.6753432154655457,
-0.8173007965087891,
0.19236287474632263,
0.6264190673828125,
0.38795632123947144,
-0.20191051065921783,
0.06921380013227463,
0.09568766504526138,
0.5930742621421814,
-0.8104468584060669,
-0.024228369817137718,
-0.12139833718538284,
0.05995001643896103,
-0.0780365914106369,
0.054044075310230255,
-0.12860944867134094,
-0.2832214832305908,
0.4369271695613861,
0.023583579808473587,
0.26423731446266174,
-0.14595432579517365,
0.44456610083580017,
-0.35734274983406067,
0.1387345939874649,
0.4428274631500244,
0.6368116736412048,
0.2702479660511017,
0.38120749592781067,
0.07390039414167404,
-0.2677372097969055,
0.21294112503528595,
-0.11903657764196396,
0.2532880902290344,
-0.20455904304981232,
0.24895532429218292,
0.8492697477340698,
0.012403487227857113,
-0.575766384601593,
0.3450133800506592,
-0.18516846001148224,
-0.2449508160352707,
-0.23101380467414856,
0.3391049802303314,
0.3928055763244629,
0.6362301707267761,
0.34535253047943115,
0.0894256979227066,
0.11684302240610123,
-1.028904676437378,
0.2522599697113037,
0.6079697608947754,
0.03334030508995056,
-0.42447325587272644,
0.6882199048995972,
-0.02540714107453823,
-0.5372061729431152,
0.2733674645423889,
-0.2855733335018158,
-0.6640294194221497,
0.6374954581260681,
0.974478006362915,
0.8026059865951538,
-0.20098023116588593,
0.2244427502155304,
-0.05069294571876526,
0.19671322405338287,
-0.17844663560390472,
0.26190540194511414,
-0.24323908984661102,
-0.8899876475334167,
-0.509145200252533,
-0.4655306935310364,
-0.27340802550315857,
0.5087798237800598,
-0.231697216629982,
0.36945897340774536,
-0.3924625813961029,
-0.17234189808368683,
0.3441902697086334,
-0.02192542888224125,
-0.7103567123413086,
0.06161968410015106,
0.28523242473602295,
0.3786579668521881,
-0.7684717774391174,
0.5446160435676575,
0.6761654019355774,
-0.7501453757286072,
-0.8730030059814453,
0.22502759099006653,
-0.011847728863358498,
-0.722000241279602,
0.6457269191741943,
0.15205958485603333,
-0.03729422390460968,
0.15043789148330688,
-0.37195834517478943,
-1.0874426364898682,
1.002655029296875,
0.07713156193494797,
-0.4252580404281616,
-0.2869218587875366,
0.3252946138381958,
0.7423412203788757,
-0.6237497329711914,
-0.24197304248809814,
0.5742206573486328,
0.10219388455152512,
0.4924171268939972,
-0.9076778888702393,
0.07014957070350647,
-0.6025354266166687,
0.1295395940542221,
0.16917569935321808,
-0.5852306485176086,
0.9958794116973877,
-0.5891221761703491,
-0.22159342467784882,
0.3380008041858673,
0.6367231011390686,
0.5302683115005493,
0.3012114465236664,
0.2782324552536011,
0.704279899597168,
0.6664724946022034,
0.28214576840400696,
0.7755386233329773,
-0.046720169484615326,
0.1772441565990448,
1.0881726741790771,
-0.28782153129577637,
0.6864704489707947,
0.48129159212112427,
0.11911392211914062,
0.527636706829071,
0.22446385025978088,
-0.2533513307571411,
0.8723878860473633,
0.2769417464733124,
-0.5694859623908997,
-0.031320344656705856,
-0.03846198692917824,
-0.25129538774490356,
0.4298371374607086,
0.43492546677589417,
-0.25308817625045776,
-0.00953196082264185,
0.293916255235672,
-0.22799237072467804,
0.16746823489665985,
-0.2941747307777405,
0.9247719645500183,
0.3360231816768646,
-0.8119696974754333,
0.5573144555091858,
-0.4151872396469116,
0.43745264410972595,
-0.1673811376094818,
-0.2712671160697937,
-0.060124143958091736,
0.11716984212398529,
0.0026058380026370287,
-1.1709095239639282,
0.23961545526981354,
-0.18399149179458618,
0.12686237692832947,
-0.2253897339105606,
0.564283013343811,
-0.47822102904319763,
-0.3167847990989685,
-0.05638858675956726,
0.5747913122177124,
-0.1982675939798355,
-0.009560204111039639,
-0.5328564643859863,
0.31769540905952454,
0.09386482834815979,
0.006042378954589367,
0.14460723102092743,
1.047756314277649,
0.06752733886241913,
0.6372670531272888,
0.771675169467926,
0.2848338186740875,
-0.2979903817176819,
-0.0035699668806046247,
1.0921050310134888,
-0.5469281673431396,
-0.783079206943512,
-0.9331421852111816,
0.5977364778518677,
-0.1387745440006256,
-0.22088979184627533,
0.9007619023323059,
0.46622639894485474,
1.1282824277877808,
-0.3248599171638489,
1.185808539390564,
0.2265900820493698,
0.03569323197007179,
-0.5618027448654175,
0.5415493249893188,
-0.2270897775888443,
0.48111534118652344,
-0.5777193903923035,
-1.2462211847305298,
-0.17155516147613525,
0.5808277726173401,
-0.6880488991737366,
0.11481554806232452,
0.7823396921157837,
0.47438186407089233,
-0.12000566720962524,
0.2772769331932068,
0.2724549472332001,
0.30586084723472595,
0.5254693031311035,
0.7219723463058472,
1.2973105907440186,
0.02121896855533123,
0.26362094283103943,
-0.19483518600463867,
-0.267814964056015,
0.20692013204097748,
-0.8708075284957886,
-1.0454679727554321,
-0.7253944277763367,
-0.2981220781803131,
-0.08740565925836563,
-0.1513332724571228,
0.6537517309188843,
0.1827840507030487,
-0.15580537915229797,
0.013010048307478428,
-0.4884774684906006,
-0.17471085488796234,
-0.062103092670440674,
-0.17660357058048248,
0.0720624104142189,
-0.21474352478981018,
-0.5641636848449707,
0.08269315212965012,
0.5306527614593506,
0.3074435889720917,
-0.4943607449531555,
0.20871850848197937,
0.13079805672168732,
0.4091488718986511,
0.8198951482772827,
0.07451311498880386,
-0.7192931771278381,
-0.18276815116405487,
-0.09544096887111664,
0.24055418372154236,
0.10148385912179947,
0.8189042806625366,
-0.5444853901863098,
0.5281919240951538,
0.3717285394668579,
0.6564807295799255,
0.41775578260421753,
0.18754896521568298,
0.6431994438171387,
-0.5069520473480225,
0.13549067080020905,
0.4327532649040222,
0.2723165452480316,
0.5868576169013977,
-0.3453136086463928,
0.26818060874938965,
0.24221093952655792,
-0.6163237690925598,
-0.4449012577533722,
0.6249721646308899,
-0.8462297916412354,
-0.2798009216785431,
1.3086390495300293,
0.07595830410718918,
-0.2932758927345276,
0.1716611385345459,
-0.5104389786720276,
0.07358915358781815,
-0.1478547751903534,
1.1265166997909546,
0.8739904165267944,
-0.4008446931838989,
-0.13203012943267822,
-0.49551624059677124,
0.5410526990890503,
0.20105479657649994,
-0.8888972401618958,
0.03541170433163643,
0.3899015486240387,
0.25174322724342346,
0.33653590083122253,
0.8526160717010498,
-0.08584824204444885,
0.25832870602607727,
-0.04394179582595825,
-0.16755223274230957,
0.0536256767809391,
-0.09059631079435349,
0.08062554895877838,
0.04139106720685959,
0.3270024061203003,
0.13010671734809875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06714v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06714v2
|
Towards a Path Dependent Account of Category Fluency
| 2024-05-09T16:36:56 | 2024-05-14T02:10:05 |
David Heineman, Reba Koenen, Sashank Varma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Category fluency is a widely studied cognitive phenomenon, yet two
conflicting accounts have been proposed as the underlying retrieval mechanism
-- an optimal foraging process deliberately searching through memory (Hills et
al., 2012) and a random walk sampling from a semantic network (Abbott et al.,
2015). Evidence for both accounts has centered around predicting human patch
switches, where both existing models of category fluency produce paradoxically
identical results. We begin by peeling back the assumptions made by existing
models, namely that each named example only depends on the previous example, by
(i) adding an additional bias to model the category transition probability
directly and (ii) relying on a large language model to predict based on the
entire existing sequence. Then, we present evidence towards resolving the
disagreement between each account of foraging by reformulating models as
sequence generators. To evaluate, we compare generated category fluency runs to
a bank of human-written sequences by proposing a metric based on n-gram
overlap. We find category switch predictors do not necessarily produce
human-like sequences, in fact the additional biases used by the Hills et al.
(2012) model are required to improve generation quality, which are later
improved by our category modification. Even generating exclusively with an LLM
requires an additional global cue to trigger the patch switching behavior
during production. Further tests on only the search process on top of the
semantic network highlight the importance of deterministic search to replicate
human behavior.
|
[
-0.27758559584617615,
-0.5775272250175476,
0.4666728675365448,
0.03545285388827324,
0.03321795538067818,
-0.017617464065551758,
0.20287345349788666,
-0.6041953563690186,
0.4253218472003937,
0.8041138648986816,
-0.5929669141769409,
-0.06176941469311714,
-0.3101208508014679,
0.20468340814113617,
-0.5288377404212952,
0.7310004234313965,
0.20423850417137146,
-0.299181193113327,
0.05980512127280235,
0.06699107587337494,
-0.7868324518203735,
-0.4831870496273041,
-0.7082644701004028,
-0.4910362660884857,
0.7241951823234558,
0.1691681295633316,
0.6682711839675903,
0.46147969365119934,
0.28745710849761963,
0.1830415278673172,
-0.04474208131432533,
-0.0031293011270463467,
-0.37396007776260376,
0.08328880369663239,
-0.35604944825172424,
-0.7460706830024719,
-0.2664707899093628,
-0.0578119158744812,
0.5539767742156982,
0.6733843088150024,
-0.5423666834831238,
-0.31315937638282776,
-0.0032112221233546734,
0.6830529570579529,
-0.486336350440979,
-0.18506287038326263,
-1.004301905632019,
0.059254374355077744,
-0.4472114145755768,
-0.6320111155509949,
-0.7232034802436829,
-0.02706339582800865,
0.21942494809627533,
-0.5103564858436584,
0.5947340130805969,
0.06106290966272354,
0.6435480117797852,
0.033134669065475464,
-0.7090608477592468,
-0.2796688973903656,
-0.7556905150413513,
0.6351171135902405,
-0.3444350063800812,
0.35214298963546753,
0.6591996550559998,
0.04923605918884277,
-0.3378134071826935,
-0.7688282132148743,
-0.23972320556640625,
-0.11650101840496063,
0.007635337300598621,
0.015499431639909744,
-0.18335600197315216,
-0.03168760612607002,
0.16058389842510223,
0.39690226316452026,
-0.3672698140144348,
-0.23140408098697662,
-0.3558002710342407,
-0.2891713082790375,
0.574259877204895,
0.4167003929615021,
0.3382991850376129,
-0.28532031178474426,
-0.47432637214660645,
-0.17186787724494934,
-0.5858439803123474,
0.23326179385185242,
0.31918612122535706,
0.4177916347980499,
0.6477388739585876,
0.5770704746246338,
-0.242011159658432,
0.8149935007095337,
-0.04277000576257706,
0.012878886424005032,
0.03607748821377754,
-0.4054473340511322,
-0.14199142158031464,
-0.008499271236360073,
0.46698781847953796,
0.25284257531166077,
0.3205910325050354,
-0.2602301239967346,
-0.4151610732078552,
0.0311932023614645,
0.5664749145507812,
-0.30539435148239136,
-0.3442874550819397,
-0.21243815124034882,
-0.2936694025993347,
-0.06695928424596786,
0.07876936346292496,
-0.7962417006492615,
-0.4135954678058624,
0.00978639256209135,
0.42015573382377625,
-0.553487241268158,
-0.3659279942512512,
0.47159692645072937,
-0.11935844272375107,
0.11755991727113724,
0.14735734462738037,
-1.090855360031128,
0.4920528531074524,
0.6239176392555237,
0.8803670406341553,
-0.2723093628883362,
-0.40835922956466675,
-0.49728715419769287,
0.10402916371822357,
-0.47413894534111023,
0.8056652545928955,
-0.6476015448570251,
-0.4978175461292267,
-0.010702709667384624,
0.08984403312206268,
-0.5605496764183044,
-0.42068925499916077,
0.16477417945861816,
-0.7569833993911743,
0.09993880242109299,
-0.36679598689079285,
-0.5597099661827087,
-0.530105471611023,
-0.027709417045116425,
-0.8645316362380981,
0.9116398096084595,
0.08696809411048889,
-0.7324307560920715,
0.8185499906539917,
-0.3462883532047272,
-0.47407644987106323,
-0.0359516441822052,
0.16509999334812164,
-0.1392204612493515,
0.024643532931804657,
-0.16375303268432617,
0.20457831025123596,
-0.098264679312706,
0.5388008952140808,
-0.06578850001096725,
-0.47914478182792664,
0.3596617877483368,
-0.46075159311294556,
0.742828369140625,
0.09302748739719391,
-0.24867971241474152,
-0.2778637707233429,
-0.7255870699882507,
-0.10816075652837753,
-0.14665564894676208,
-0.5200357437133789,
-0.5882958173751831,
0.5285372138023376,
-0.022197529673576355,
0.33042028546333313,
-0.09198129177093506,
-0.2960462272167206,
0.2797042429447174,
-0.3042440414428711,
0.23722676932811737,
0.7916794419288635,
0.380256325006485,
0.14617833495140076,
-0.5580676198005676,
0.6377218961715698,
-0.05890485644340515,
0.0007849438698031008,
-0.1321406066417694,
-0.7449131608009338,
-0.5676614046096802,
-0.019282668828964233,
0.03991354629397392,
0.42410513758659363,
-0.5204553604125977,
0.0802769735455513,
-0.09335749596357346,
-0.13949009776115417,
-0.3046914041042328,
0.055267538875341415,
0.2894546389579773,
0.25617715716362,
0.3765927255153656,
-0.9354090094566345,
-0.6864884495735168,
-0.5823859572410583,
-0.47117432951927185,
-0.600540280342102,
0.1785077601671219,
0.22845767438411713,
0.3120480477809906,
-0.22556456923484802,
1.1245856285095215,
-0.4104287326335907,
-0.08446009457111359,
-0.23682083189487457,
0.029073985293507576,
0.1931571215391159,
0.5087428092956543,
0.11397678405046463,
-0.7814720869064331,
-0.07168613374233246,
-0.1914968639612198,
-0.2261153608560562,
0.10213306546211243,
-0.4324547350406647,
-0.4508197009563446,
0.23347926139831543,
0.5724722146987915,
-0.574643611907959,
0.4277164340019226,
0.14951267838478088,
-0.7036499381065369,
0.5365681648254395,
0.03352918475866318,
0.07273472845554352,
-0.9227879047393799,
0.19686304032802582,
0.05974527820944786,
0.006107807159423828,
-0.7466093897819519,
-0.10949575155973434,
-0.2539685368537903,
0.483317106962204,
-0.27906203269958496,
0.5693057775497437,
-0.2688610851764679,
-0.20288994908332825,
0.13555321097373962,
-0.2712514102458954,
0.08905437588691711,
0.4599009156227112,
0.11584551632404327,
0.668181836605072,
0.19194741547107697,
-0.7514896392822266,
-0.23030029237270355,
0.1748761236667633,
-0.5289173126220703,
0.25008952617645264,
-0.27526479959487915,
-0.15423859655857086,
0.13592198491096497,
0.36956313252449036,
-1.2117300033569336,
-0.2825069725513458,
0.2537637948989868,
-0.077046699821949,
0.4951638877391815,
-0.17384740710258484,
-0.5400159358978271,
-0.2919294834136963,
-0.013809467665851116,
0.2952168583869934,
0.7089062333106995,
-0.3418441116809845,
0.20294970273971558,
0.36161309480667114,
0.26956114172935486,
-0.4152635931968689,
-0.8461253643035889,
0.06762531399726868,
-0.3674132823944092,
-0.46747344732284546,
0.07230411469936371,
-0.046972524374723434,
-0.1240227147936821,
-0.3094330132007599,
-0.4896460473537445,
-0.055252641439437866,
0.30417898297309875,
-0.0984855368733406,
0.19891785085201263,
-0.4342031478881836,
0.2548278272151947,
-0.37777474522590637,
0.06181308627128601,
0.2489008605480194,
-0.41760146617889404,
0.494111567735672,
0.05228793993592262,
-0.3101641833782196,
0.08837645500898361,
0.010320157743990421,
0.246856689453125,
-0.08502595871686935,
0.4775851368904114,
0.363402783870697,
-0.11042802035808563,
-0.010279241017997265,
-0.4815794825553894,
-0.12659502029418945,
-0.45697641372680664,
0.4359259605407715,
-0.4116872549057007,
-0.6672590970993042,
0.574415385723114,
-0.007212902884930372,
-0.06990326941013336,
0.5369400382041931,
0.32397449016571045,
0.11474208533763885,
0.9583967328071594,
0.6984604597091675,
0.42182686924934387,
0.6311907768249512,
-0.25820285081863403,
-0.03609776124358177,
-1.0256747007369995,
-0.17561005055904388,
-0.19741494953632355,
-0.05271495133638382,
-0.8845544457435608,
-0.5251385569572449,
-0.015284805558621883,
0.18922579288482666,
-0.10042250156402588,
0.28324100375175476,
-0.533567488193512,
0.39857620000839233,
0.4930092990398407,
0.1929110735654831,
0.37293359637260437,
0.22711515426635742,
-0.32372739911079407,
0.11075732111930847,
-1.0625369548797607,
-0.3655034899711609,
1.096832036972046,
-0.025724075734615326,
0.7430126070976257,
0.12632712721824646,
0.7777780294418335,
0.25392210483551025,
0.23152829706668854,
-0.6735866069793701,
0.7714964151382446,
-0.16900812089443207,
-0.9268415570259094,
-0.3701268434524536,
-0.15724030137062073,
-1.5335906744003296,
0.43820348381996155,
0.0778961032629013,
-1.0897531509399414,
0.49515944719314575,
0.2727231979370117,
-0.016629787161946297,
0.7063762545585632,
-0.629371702671051,
0.7507688999176025,
0.16360419988632202,
-0.510569155216217,
0.011579475365579128,
-0.8674300909042358,
0.7315077185630798,
-0.11383281648159027,
0.047851767390966415,
-0.10975430905818939,
0.010953905992209911,
0.819614589214325,
-0.27190327644348145,
1.1351248025894165,
0.03957409784197807,
-0.042565181851387024,
0.5930169224739075,
0.467007040977478,
0.28940603137016296,
-0.36220768094062805,
-0.2168371081352234,
-0.06163642928004265,
-0.08044898509979248,
-0.3181439936161041,
-0.29147234559059143,
0.2460920661687851,
-0.5027050375938416,
-0.7928851246833801,
-0.523943305015564,
-0.2998998165130615,
-0.3233547508716583,
0.19768057763576508,
0.2836083471775055,
0.4506057798862457,
-0.3975137770175934,
-0.11329291015863419,
0.7365618944168091,
0.07759521156549454,
0.26784512400627136,
0.29951831698417664,
-0.4113251268863678,
-0.14003527164459229,
1.0960423946380615,
0.2406526505947113,
0.5552093386650085,
0.655439555644989,
0.2601340413093567,
-0.2004552185535431,
-0.20407027006149292,
-0.1867520958185196,
0.12809376418590546,
-0.8377830982208252,
-0.02814028412103653,
-0.7380660772323608,
-0.1817369908094406,
0.024909889325499535,
-0.2404966801404953,
0.04535522311925888,
-0.3278537690639496,
-0.281936913728714,
-0.009057563729584217,
0.6620009541511536,
0.9986640214920044,
-0.19087211787700653,
-0.019052617251873016,
-0.5294641852378845,
-0.005311896093189716,
0.5716173052787781,
0.3925946056842804,
0.47991663217544556,
-0.3890163004398346,
-0.20911405980587006,
-0.00412379577755928,
-0.3111220896244049,
-1.0509907007217407,
0.3721628487110138,
0.3347185254096985,
0.6179832220077515,
0.17357249557971954,
-0.1892087757587433,
0.7157905101776123,
-0.4287266135215759,
0.8631863594055176,
0.2532157003879547,
-0.7534937262535095,
0.5312560200691223,
-0.3894580602645874,
0.1917000561952591,
0.6008720397949219,
0.2887327969074249,
-0.7644264698028564,
-0.5385221242904663,
-0.8383069038391113,
-0.9336836934089661,
1.055120825767517,
0.1117730364203453,
-0.19750042259693146,
-0.4982275366783142,
0.11909911036491394,
0.3241954445838928,
-0.022992409765720367,
-0.5297653079032898,
0.1466868370771408,
-0.19413749873638153,
0.17295297980308533,
-0.44613152742385864,
-0.09570819139480591,
0.09768975526094437,
-0.14022277295589447,
0.4920053482055664,
-0.07636279612779617,
0.11187371611595154,
0.41400420665740967,
-0.009527808055281639,
-0.216949462890625,
0.2423371821641922,
0.528720498085022,
0.6263145804405212,
-0.38013485074043274,
0.40504351258277893,
-0.1265178918838501,
-0.8691917061805725,
0.33226028084754944,
-0.5044375061988831,
-0.29563167691230774,
0.07239443808794022,
0.423500120639801,
0.7445600628852844,
0.5693709254264832,
-0.6065254211425781,
0.09531597048044205,
0.22551676630973816,
-0.10076430439949036,
0.1324792504310608,
0.469098299741745,
0.12053568661212921,
0.03955139219760895,
0.3593890964984894,
0.5687288641929626,
0.4036449193954468,
-0.6959008574485779,
0.49467217922210693,
0.24166038632392883,
-0.4122390151023865,
-0.41146111488342285,
0.6578323245048523,
-0.007926641963422298,
-0.5668131113052368,
0.6250089406967163,
-0.22423654794692993,
-0.26840317249298096,
0.7836529016494751,
0.6547576785087585,
1.0596895217895508,
-0.2795032262802124,
0.4155300259590149,
0.46982306241989136,
0.47306954860687256,
-0.6017374396324158,
0.1905203014612198,
-0.07889118045568466,
-0.5865282416343689,
-0.27416443824768066,
-0.62173992395401,
-0.05837060138583183,
-0.29113420844078064,
-0.7790722846984863,
0.10164926201105118,
-0.003663667943328619,
-0.2646571397781372,
-0.3295738399028778,
-0.03731067478656769,
-0.6554587483406067,
0.22404973208904266,
-0.17215347290039062,
0.8987290263175964,
-0.7700098156929016,
0.7353954315185547,
0.5158124566078186,
-0.49041804671287537,
-0.7130975723266602,
0.46714869141578674,
-0.3111145794391632,
-0.9566894769668579,
0.4541146755218506,
0.16988682746887207,
-0.09694229066371918,
0.08442308008670807,
-0.23227234184741974,
-1.1443469524383545,
1.1333516836166382,
-0.06968356668949127,
-0.3266068398952484,
-0.10406336188316345,
-0.1916591376066208,
0.5788735151290894,
-0.38173729181289673,
0.09039807319641113,
0.5406590700149536,
0.17953252792358398,
0.3614090085029602,
-0.5727075934410095,
0.2097935974597931,
-0.1127232238650322,
0.38759034872055054,
0.3896172046661377,
-0.549614667892456,
0.826924204826355,
-0.32808780670166016,
-0.43088552355766296,
0.06968427449464798,
0.21818970143795013,
0.38866692781448364,
0.5245640873908997,
0.6288207173347473,
0.24440041184425354,
0.8334798812866211,
0.41726967692375183,
1.2620786428451538,
-0.03305968642234802,
0.2936551868915558,
0.8044061064720154,
-0.24822555482387543,
1.0256295204162598,
0.6594617962837219,
-0.4235357642173767,
0.6724550127983093,
1.013200044631958,
0.17102788388729095,
0.774616003036499,
0.38263869285583496,
0.017690099775791168,
-0.45607468485832214,
0.15371736884117126,
-0.21354250609874725,
0.31762582063674927,
0.4516615867614746,
-0.28920236229896545,
-0.06285744905471802,
-0.3702349364757538,
-0.25517258048057556,
-0.2990531027317047,
-0.3169051706790924,
0.6439183950424194,
-0.014120583422482014,
-1.1906837224960327,
0.6519079208374023,
-0.35410529375076294,
0.49230149388313293,
-0.6148332357406616,
-0.09249116480350494,
-0.33786800503730774,
-0.20873281359672546,
-0.1557389199733734,
-0.7735723853111267,
0.24518772959709167,
-0.3069916367530823,
-0.2572683095932007,
-0.11244669556617737,
0.6397956013679504,
-0.32602640986442566,
-0.49478551745414734,
0.220394104719162,
0.5510690212249756,
0.367867648601532,
0.5579108595848083,
-0.5135459303855896,
-0.20357179641723633,
0.232540100812912,
-0.49518269300460815,
0.49364030361175537,
0.5807403326034546,
-0.27779582142829895,
0.49206238985061646,
0.7513977885246277,
-0.13156981766223907,
0.45890894532203674,
-0.052958086133003235,
0.3974975645542145,
-0.7543388605117798,
-0.5178411602973938,
-0.8046639561653137,
0.44186320900917053,
0.20706620812416077,
-0.4568595290184021,
0.5099371671676636,
0.3406253457069397,
0.7008288502693176,
0.05323821306228638,
0.44477835297584534,
-0.0005010223248973489,
0.029662083834409714,
-0.7183193564414978,
0.34528616070747375,
-0.7903430461883545,
0.518799364566803,
-0.4109481871128082,
-0.6896938681602478,
-0.14095371961593628,
0.590013325214386,
-0.07742674648761749,
0.1898927092552185,
0.8670191168785095,
0.8231356739997864,
-0.23363688588142395,
-0.05002846568822861,
0.3289929926395416,
0.12540051341056824,
0.07628649473190308,
0.7488202452659607,
0.7817290425300598,
-0.3860093057155609,
0.4699888229370117,
0.2054590880870819,
-0.002026389352977276,
-0.5648372173309326,
-0.6869151592254639,
-0.497434139251709,
-0.860429048538208,
-0.332908034324646,
-0.6154502034187317,
0.10732670873403549,
0.47693607211112976,
0.544272780418396,
-0.3318724036216736,
-0.5931494235992432,
-0.6650443077087402,
0.42444345355033875,
-0.5233007669448853,
-0.27431347966194153,
-0.026882058009505272,
-0.31262606382369995,
-0.12673169374465942,
0.24633732438087463,
0.21292373538017273,
-0.08697932213544846,
-0.3327164649963379,
-0.11065679043531418,
-0.6323796510696411,
0.49272578954696655,
0.3885316848754883,
0.6301149129867554,
-1.004623532295227,
-0.17256517708301544,
0.2595192790031433,
-0.3482626676559448,
0.3652723729610443,
1.017400860786438,
-0.9510705471038818,
0.6676572561264038,
0.5093044638633728,
0.327820748090744,
0.6313086152076721,
-0.29588863253593445,
0.5567313432693481,
-0.543639600276947,
-0.25110408663749695,
0.09550470113754272,
0.2525448501110077,
0.23220282793045044,
-0.3418762683868408,
0.7779960632324219,
0.5201929807662964,
-0.5340717434883118,
-0.8692026734352112,
0.5134848952293396,
-0.8514613509178162,
-0.23981083929538727,
1.207961916923523,
0.06821101903915405,
-0.4137234389781952,
-0.22055241465568542,
-0.10679204016923904,
0.12994031608104706,
-0.28588390350341797,
0.8811290264129639,
0.6849349737167358,
-0.4437786936759949,
0.19099141657352448,
-0.593016505241394,
0.3896869719028473,
0.5442460179328918,
-0.1997668445110321,
0.04024660214781761,
0.25271347165107727,
0.22767314314842224,
0.3172253966331482,
1.074239730834961,
0.22822779417037964,
0.33315232396125793,
0.3251791000366211,
0.11924783140420914,
0.4958403408527374,
-0.21371014416217804,
-0.2610226273536682,
0.06363652646541595,
0.001346894889138639,
0.06400565057992935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05860v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05860v1
|
The Perspectivist Paradigm Shift: Assumptions and Challenges of Capturing Human Labels
| 2024-05-09T15:48:07 | 2024-05-09T15:48:07 |
Eve Fleisig, Su Lin Blodgett, Dan Klein, Zeerak Talat
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Longstanding data labeling practices in machine learning involve collecting
and aggregating labels from multiple annotators. But what should we do when
annotators disagree? Though annotator disagreement has long been seen as a
problem to minimize, new perspectivist approaches challenge this assumption by
treating disagreement as a valuable source of information. In this position
paper, we examine practices and assumptions surrounding the causes of
disagreement--some challenged by perspectivist approaches, and some that remain
to be addressed--as well as practical and normative challenges for work
operating under these assumptions. We conclude with recommendations for the
data labeling pipeline and avenues for future research engaging with
subjectivity and disagreement.
|
[
-0.6805334091186523,
-0.35432949662208557,
0.5461028218269348,
-0.21401889622211456,
0.12202800810337067,
0.06419575214385986,
-0.08754544705152512,
-0.601690948009491,
-0.28314825892448425,
0.6137944459915161,
-0.49735191464424133,
-0.16740474104881287,
-0.9682212471961975,
0.27223116159439087,
-0.12412752956151962,
1.0487372875213623,
-0.2683241367340088,
-0.23528645932674408,
-0.4315915107727051,
-0.26021498441696167,
-0.42253005504608154,
-0.9921327829360962,
-0.3155684173107147,
-0.40486180782318115,
1.1505941152572632,
0.635583221912384,
0.9734272360801697,
0.6704331040382385,
0.7111504673957825,
0.2918677031993866,
-0.06078261137008667,
0.047035958617925644,
-0.03957808390259743,
0.47379931807518005,
-0.08492811769247055,
-0.6365167498588562,
-0.06215932220220566,
0.15754492580890656,
0.3832491934299469,
0.9186843633651733,
0.37287211418151855,
0.34978318214416504,
-0.18779045343399048,
0.7199587225914001,
-0.74443519115448,
0.16805434226989746,
-0.40775617957115173,
0.563791811466217,
-0.587266743183136,
0.2586306035518646,
-0.35326704382896423,
-0.1885567605495453,
0.46525755524635315,
-0.7829446196556091,
0.49903959035873413,
-0.27251139283180237,
1.028878927230835,
0.8422052264213562,
-0.6399863362312317,
-0.0049147638492286205,
-0.9736761450767517,
0.749433159828186,
-0.33655908703804016,
0.38994479179382324,
0.5609103441238403,
0.5384176969528198,
0.250833660364151,
-0.699022650718689,
-0.5479888319969177,
0.2247786670923233,
0.15777546167373657,
-0.252175897359848,
-0.07477963715791702,
-0.4579542577266693,
0.4660760164260864,
-0.1724337935447693,
0.050811316817998886,
0.3140643239021301,
-0.3800179660320282,
-0.11751437187194824,
0.8353719115257263,
0.17459416389465332,
-0.16554701328277588,
0.10537070035934448,
-0.5359837412834167,
-0.3094165027141571,
-0.7087770700454712,
-0.09569068998098373,
0.47996845841407776,
0.11125404387712479,
0.37928155064582825,
0.3652162253856659,
0.07564038038253784,
0.8054862022399902,
0.2659163177013397,
0.26953044533729553,
0.39365869760513306,
0.06660734862089157,
-0.04610336944460869,
0.20282532274723053,
0.7159306406974792,
0.43689578771591187,
0.013404118828475475,
-0.013657788746058941,
-0.3004649877548218,
0.2710629999637604,
0.4987228810787201,
-0.15956926345825195,
-0.5754626989364624,
0.2188149243593216,
-0.04361293092370033,
-0.3081747591495514,
0.3020595908164978,
-0.8344630002975464,
-0.7455711364746094,
-0.6489121913909912,
0.287722647190094,
0.012276222929358482,
-0.15743887424468994,
-0.3224533200263977,
-0.28011128306388855,
0.09512094408273697,
0.7531821727752686,
-0.9028163552284241,
-0.17850464582443237,
0.8289431929588318,
0.3765498399734497,
-0.17003457248210907,
-0.23562629520893097,
0.16925233602523804,
0.2457689791917801,
-0.5809169411659241,
1.026293158531189,
-0.48972707986831665,
-0.39201435446739197,
-0.12191814184188843,
-0.21395254135131836,
-0.16906777024269104,
-0.8251612782478333,
0.5826157331466675,
-0.1511767953634262,
0.22568760812282562,
-0.8486604690551758,
-0.646389901638031,
-0.017591064795851707,
0.27363085746765137,
-0.45593973994255066,
0.8664650321006775,
0.01654447801411152,
-0.9541152715682983,
0.8544232845306396,
-0.8643602728843689,
-0.12640425562858582,
0.2795509099960327,
-0.4407232999801636,
-0.6380481123924255,
0.04471765458583832,
0.025190282613039017,
0.3231617510318756,
-0.06231028586626053,
0.36649858951568604,
-0.1263267695903778,
-0.19978110492229462,
0.9156498312950134,
-0.19916950166225433,
0.8926134705543518,
0.6309798359870911,
-0.2399560809135437,
0.12483187019824982,
-0.6982820630073547,
-0.5649129748344421,
0.08105262368917465,
-0.2933069169521332,
-0.31107860803604126,
0.3382630944252014,
0.09170558303594589,
0.2340581864118576,
0.14853300154209137,
-0.6575934290885925,
0.24393615126609802,
0.5557430386543274,
0.45738470554351807,
0.9521016478538513,
-0.15896011888980865,
0.26530131697654724,
-0.398965448141098,
0.23550087213516235,
0.4219089150428772,
0.27844300866127014,
-0.03371041268110275,
-0.39016345143318176,
-0.8707261681556702,
0.07278287410736084,
0.4334096610546112,
0.32637661695480347,
-0.46586278080940247,
0.38290032744407654,
-0.11278581619262695,
-0.5855339765548706,
-0.6593180894851685,
-0.050692442804574966,
0.08554378896951675,
0.8696736097335815,
0.5090892910957336,
-0.2691497206687927,
-0.7473259568214417,
-0.7654091715812683,
-0.3072441816329956,
-0.32967135310173035,
-0.1202990859746933,
0.15689288079738617,
0.3512077033519745,
-0.306514173746109,
1.2589904069900513,
-0.47787436842918396,
-0.15462933480739594,
0.3558063805103302,
0.503682017326355,
-0.12233677506446838,
0.9109734296798706,
0.05744224041700363,
-1.3007675409317017,
-0.2542326748371124,
-0.058369237929582596,
-1.1458491086959839,
0.014480243436992168,
0.00088901212438941,
0.16245096921920776,
0.38266587257385254,
0.4959369897842407,
-0.3310803174972534,
0.3865523934364319,
0.17347577214241028,
-0.23355774581432343,
0.39385440945625305,
0.1964838206768036,
0.03655794635415077,
-0.5466404557228088,
0.03593044728040695,
0.4218599796295166,
0.17989684641361237,
-0.6839603781700134,
-0.2589648962020874,
-0.34717893600463867,
-0.05027865245938301,
-0.33235296607017517,
0.1647091805934906,
-0.24992473423480988,
0.11416894197463989,
0.06183692067861557,
-0.2395097315311432,
-0.23502898216247559,
-0.12893743813037872,
0.31101158261299133,
0.41198980808258057,
0.15864966809749603,
-0.6525728702545166,
0.23711934685707092,
0.5964077115058899,
0.025986922904849052,
1.0461995601654053,
-0.3700442612171173,
0.5553206205368042,
-0.5804513096809387,
0.47363394498825073,
-1.1684516668319702,
-0.4104672968387604,
0.7123421430587769,
-0.4576042890548706,
0.416596382856369,
-0.32488054037094116,
-0.3776093125343323,
-0.48993268609046936,
-0.13357435166835785,
0.3373262584209442,
0.3404165506362915,
-0.43299463391304016,
0.24918672442436218,
0.571029007434845,
-0.010868494398891926,
-0.7620258331298828,
-1.0596539974212646,
0.37306302785873413,
-0.5823941230773926,
-0.43011918663978577,
0.019075049087405205,
0.23659193515777588,
-0.5298972129821777,
-0.02576538920402527,
-0.36282074451446533,
-0.3058137595653534,
0.17555087804794312,
0.35072773694992065,
0.2860265374183655,
-0.12777875363826752,
0.23285436630249023,
-0.38924768567085266,
-0.606712281703949,
0.2257716804742813,
-0.22587250173091888,
-0.0017532702768221498,
0.40714454650878906,
-0.2303842157125473,
-0.3587677478790283,
0.25144219398498535,
0.058984339237213135,
-0.02908044308423996,
0.140093594789505,
0.5575271248817444,
-0.17449592053890228,
0.5472975969314575,
-0.8196470141410828,
0.03722076863050461,
-0.37198522686958313,
0.03914811089634895,
-0.258289098739624,
-0.78693026304245,
0.18292544782161713,
-0.408099502325058,
0.48140913248062134,
0.41228750348091125,
0.2832055687904358,
-0.6192657947540283,
0.6845875978469849,
0.47787538170814514,
0.2673165202140808,
0.31932124495506287,
-0.024334590882062912,
0.03329829126596451,
-0.916930079460144,
-0.3330264687538147,
-0.7519912719726562,
-0.6707053184509277,
-0.4687470495700836,
-0.31721246242523193,
0.3809283971786499,
-0.22996565699577332,
-0.6191731095314026,
0.16394057869911194,
-1.0234800577163696,
0.09387032687664032,
0.39012300968170166,
-0.09543749690055847,
0.39444318413734436,
-0.2534934878349304,
0.5825323462486267,
-0.4153319299221039,
-0.6255285143852234,
-0.9642735719680786,
0.8163889050483704,
0.4130059480667114,
0.5203847289085388,
-0.1181078627705574,
0.8999446630477905,
0.1435253769159317,
0.5736825466156006,
-0.41680997610092163,
0.36790600419044495,
0.1795065551996231,
-1.1983232498168945,
-0.3004205524921417,
-0.1894819438457489,
-1.191124677658081,
0.6020450592041016,
-0.17342741787433624,
-0.9650251865386963,
0.7339257001876831,
0.421387642621994,
0.09651373326778412,
0.30046823620796204,
-0.549207866191864,
1.1102781295776367,
-0.13153302669525146,
-0.3297306001186371,
0.5592271685600281,
-1.2868479490280151,
0.1834350824356079,
-0.005994455423206091,
0.1860683113336563,
-0.4621681571006775,
-0.20618829131126404,
0.9833848476409912,
-0.31970787048339844,
1.0640456676483154,
-0.5419201850891113,
-0.19647549092769623,
0.3310810327529907,
-0.10828596353530884,
0.10822997242212296,
-0.47432565689086914,
0.1631680428981781,
0.25683924555778503,
0.041579362004995346,
-0.4912247061729431,
-0.01768217794597149,
-0.004619112238287926,
-0.8919888138771057,
-0.5411242842674255,
-0.571491539478302,
-0.40895241498947144,
-0.27409058809280396,
-0.23592711985111237,
0.7524971961975098,
-0.2360210120677948,
-0.0754399448633194,
-0.08734655380249023,
0.7367972731590271,
0.1842145323753357,
0.3950752019882202,
-0.14655552804470062,
-0.00400331849232316,
-0.10676208138465881,
0.9472228288650513,
0.6313154101371765,
-0.0028223509434610605,
0.30250808596611023,
0.16823792457580566,
-0.27198418974876404,
-0.3020244538784027,
-0.46338239312171936,
-0.17882676422595978,
-0.9451502561569214,
-0.0922764390707016,
-0.5404694676399231,
0.4136544466018677,
-0.24742497503757477,
-0.47097980976104736,
-0.38588646054267883,
-0.41497355699539185,
-0.3550402522087097,
0.01640889421105385,
0.10059162229299545,
0.7389823198318481,
-0.12636438012123108,
-0.0690450444817543,
-0.596977949142456,
-0.15763992071151733,
0.2863050401210785,
-0.377784788608551,
-0.23698987066745758,
-0.14673477411270142,
-0.1403084248304367,
-0.07058601081371307,
-0.5090419054031372,
-0.815031111240387,
-0.14509673416614532,
-0.604001522064209,
0.3563588559627533,
0.1924140304327011,
0.19885793328285217,
0.5820735096931458,
-0.09825614094734192,
0.9026250243186951,
0.3097440004348755,
-0.9586069583892822,
0.37891340255737305,
-0.37555181980133057,
0.02963119000196457,
0.6696826815605164,
0.6906816959381104,
-0.8250386118888855,
-0.22570249438285828,
-0.6824718117713928,
-1.0197784900665283,
0.2824876308441162,
-0.18633128702640533,
-0.25945231318473816,
0.3151296079158783,
0.219945028424263,
0.3358389139175415,
0.2958533763885498,
-0.5027037858963013,
-0.2482815831899643,
-0.5342177152633667,
-0.12403900176286697,
-0.22953607141971588,
0.027656489983201027,
-0.5144916772842407,
-0.33123138546943665,
-0.00020447700808290392,
-0.21663790941238403,
0.13583877682685852,
0.3873966634273529,
-0.07955176383256912,
-0.22439627349376678,
0.40291762351989746,
0.2539164125919342,
1.0971744060516357,
0.16821616888046265,
0.6065788269042969,
0.07905182242393494,
0.026850996538996696,
0.6109272837638855,
0.36251336336135864,
-0.6906747817993164,
0.07218701392412186,
0.2928231656551361,
0.7692040801048279,
0.11417748034000397,
-0.4023485481739044,
0.1656389981508255,
0.3397403657436371,
-0.41980212926864624,
-0.31544098258018494,
-0.24776118993759155,
0.03975151106715202,
0.14383640885353088,
0.6054239869117737,
0.2929059565067291,
0.017286941409111023,
-0.3894735872745514,
0.013107187114655972,
-0.040669750422239304,
-0.6145423650741577,
-0.2791745066642761,
0.9834467768669128,
0.007633686065673828,
-0.22117237746715546,
0.4717489778995514,
0.30376505851745605,
-0.44536712765693665,
0.44607454538345337,
0.2004987746477127,
0.5022271871566772,
-0.2781705856323242,
0.25233933329582214,
-0.15267512202262878,
0.021005205810070038,
-0.16984857618808746,
-0.3793523907661438,
-0.3846276104450226,
-0.9191762804985046,
-0.22927440702915192,
0.21518616378307343,
-0.984704315662384,
-0.5190335512161255,
-0.8528368473052979,
-0.03313658386468887,
-0.36780503392219543,
-0.4314879775047302,
0.4799605906009674,
-0.17913517355918884,
-0.6822994947433472,
0.15114441514015198,
0.33257776498794556,
0.35725152492523193,
-0.9440613985061646,
0.48986512422561646,
1.2174301147460938,
-0.6151392459869385,
-0.40795794129371643,
0.07170341163873672,
0.4047541320323944,
-0.3140657842159271,
0.8992348909378052,
-0.11690843850374222,
0.31378188729286194,
-0.3732942044734955,
-1.0002540349960327,
-0.41375142335891724,
0.8871981501579285,
0.4354815185070038,
-0.5656604766845703,
0.16172024607658386,
0.009013562463223934,
0.4755001366138458,
-0.1263120472431183,
-0.20170634984970093,
0.677087128162384,
1.059882402420044,
0.07234428822994232,
-0.5991604924201965,
-0.013654859736561775,
0.30261874198913574,
0.10525816679000854,
0.3309699594974518,
-0.7653391361236572,
1.0943362712860107,
-0.13267186284065247,
-0.20632049441337585,
-0.34810560941696167,
0.5478100180625916,
0.18956246972084045,
0.8453603386878967,
0.44952574372291565,
0.5331664681434631,
0.9580626487731934,
-0.3061842918395996,
0.9577076435089111,
0.4968286454677582,
0.5337733030319214,
0.8637915849685669,
-0.586760401725769,
0.5811541676521301,
0.7322141528129578,
-0.48425933718681335,
0.2524072527885437,
0.8654012084007263,
-0.40493354201316833,
0.08637456595897675,
0.22936132550239563,
-0.3297399580478668,
-0.2671501040458679,
-0.11629123985767365,
-0.2506715953350067,
0.554541289806366,
0.23189955949783325,
-0.10302088409662247,
-0.009085766039788723,
-0.14896155893802643,
0.33624452352523804,
0.16438965499401093,
0.05593115836381912,
0.9078142642974854,
-0.23630614578723907,
-0.7505863308906555,
0.39126917719841003,
-0.4429529011249542,
0.6778820157051086,
-0.015899112448096275,
0.032089632004499435,
0.14371006190776825,
0.21068218350410461,
-0.5395352840423584,
-0.7433981895446777,
0.3097321689128876,
-0.1514388620853424,
-0.020878208801150322,
-0.44820693135261536,
0.6418639421463013,
-0.19370849430561066,
-0.27921825647354126,
-0.2808957099914551,
0.4676086902618408,
0.3247290253639221,
0.11874416470527649,
-0.5664647817611694,
0.5765534043312073,
0.053099945187568665,
-0.0525469146668911,
0.5066086649894714,
0.5138530731201172,
0.009649836458265781,
0.2781260907649994,
0.394403338432312,
-0.23056325316429138,
0.09922527521848679,
-0.579442024230957,
0.7278842926025391,
-0.6642407774925232,
-0.029652856290340424,
-0.816943347454071,
0.4539751708507538,
-0.11408702284097672,
-0.6976454854011536,
0.6270262598991394,
0.45719462633132935,
0.9794358611106873,
0.026612594723701477,
0.8843610286712646,
-0.16040951013565063,
0.5321028232574463,
-0.23902440071105957,
0.23084145784378052,
-0.141265407204628,
-0.10196639597415924,
-0.43065953254699707,
-0.836362361907959,
-0.6184219717979431,
1.0377382040023804,
-0.33583956956863403,
-0.08264593034982681,
0.3119589686393738,
-0.09486716240644455,
0.20094873011112213,
0.1617773473262787,
0.002635740442201495,
-0.05559360608458519,
0.5196511149406433,
0.6268117427825928,
1.2076882123947144,
-0.24486398696899414,
0.2605263888835907,
-0.267692506313324,
0.03518804535269737,
-0.1639677733182907,
-0.7787911891937256,
-0.35511457920074463,
-0.9037085771560669,
-0.9471657276153564,
-0.40548038482666016,
0.13454404473304749,
1.0355693101882935,
0.7320908308029175,
-0.49943408370018005,
-0.24447819590568542,
0.12455593049526215,
0.2617557942867279,
-0.34314000606536865,
-0.2080247700214386,
0.15782292187213898,
-0.3315131664276123,
-0.7747739553451538,
-0.1044020727276802,
0.09754586219787598,
0.1659228354692459,
-0.16144300997257233,
0.06286182999610901,
-0.0981307402253151,
-0.3981669843196869,
0.31253406405448914,
0.8852452635765076,
-0.6900070905685425,
-0.4937630891799927,
-0.6440157890319824,
-0.006325210444629192,
0.6447274684906006,
1.1236469745635986,
-0.6823762655258179,
0.39031746983528137,
0.21685035526752472,
0.8562356233596802,
0.7134879231452942,
0.2579778730869293,
0.36798781156539917,
-0.670360267162323,
0.08552584797143936,
0.6429603695869446,
-0.06406014412641525,
0.7540073990821838,
-0.3253900110721588,
0.7534528970718384,
0.47892633080482483,
-0.8334925770759583,
-0.9935116767883301,
0.31423622369766235,
-0.7251977324485779,
-0.3773171603679657,
0.5663298964500427,
-0.3224309980869293,
-0.10675277560949326,
-0.5000784397125244,
0.016239553689956665,
0.17206929624080658,
-0.20156672596931458,
0.7806718945503235,
0.6701332330703735,
-0.7476080656051636,
-0.21126779913902283,
-0.34381675720214844,
0.3922194540500641,
0.26290398836135864,
-0.6569249033927917,
0.21088889241218567,
0.6757152080535889,
0.23756453394889832,
0.6639447808265686,
0.7224842309951782,
-0.23471035063266754,
-0.12004783749580383,
0.18168658018112183,
0.055555135011672974,
0.06697584688663483,
-0.25369784235954285,
-0.2202148735523224,
0.2827942669391632,
0.22032581269741058,
-0.49482324719429016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05852v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05852v1
|
Pre-trained Text-to-Image Diffusion Models Are Versatile Representation Learners for Control
| 2024-05-09T15:39:54 | 2024-05-09T15:39:54 |
Gunshi Gupta, Karmesh Yadav, Yarin Gal, Dhruv Batra, Zsolt Kira, Cong Lu, Tim G. J. Rudner
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO, stat.ML
|
Embodied AI agents require a fine-grained understanding of the physical world
mediated through visual and language inputs. Such capabilities are difficult to
learn solely from task-specific data. This has led to the emergence of
pre-trained vision-language models as a tool for transferring representations
learned from internet-scale data to downstream tasks and new domains. However,
commonly used contrastively trained representations such as in CLIP have been
shown to fail at enabling embodied agents to gain a sufficiently fine-grained
scene understanding -- a capability vital for control. To address this
shortcoming, we consider representations from pre-trained text-to-image
diffusion models, which are explicitly optimized to generate images from text
prompts and as such, contain text-conditioned representations that reflect
highly fine-grained visuo-spatial information. Using pre-trained text-to-image
diffusion models, we construct Stable Control Representations which allow
learning downstream control policies that generalize to complex, open-ended
environments. We show that policies learned using Stable Control
Representations are competitive with state-of-the-art representation learning
approaches across a broad range of simulated control settings, encompassing
challenging manipulation and navigation tasks. Most notably, we show that
Stable Control Representations enable learning policies that exhibit
state-of-the-art performance on OVMM, a difficult open-vocabulary navigation
benchmark.
|
[
-0.405770480632782,
-0.6545603275299072,
0.6498184204101562,
0.1473691463470459,
-0.07979495823383331,
-0.15754397213459015,
-0.17906542122364044,
-0.11607405543327332,
-0.0627763643860817,
0.5019261240959167,
-0.18744084239006042,
-0.4405282437801361,
-0.9501334428787231,
-0.225068137049675,
-0.25452619791030884,
0.859749972820282,
-0.47237884998321533,
-0.08520134538412094,
-0.2619083523750305,
-0.023959282785654068,
-0.42929062247276306,
-0.37309882044792175,
-0.6020546555519104,
-0.5272710919380188,
0.590239942073822,
-0.018145956099033356,
0.7639751434326172,
0.38185885548591614,
0.14917513728141785,
0.31633272767066956,
0.11122902482748032,
0.1575094759464264,
-0.6048850417137146,
-0.10247839987277985,
-0.4465767741203308,
-0.4248131215572357,
-0.00750983040779829,
0.16493937373161316,
0.738466739654541,
0.623974621295929,
-0.2134305238723755,
-0.5492572784423828,
0.23768609762191772,
0.4309346079826355,
-0.8365625739097595,
0.21334035694599152,
-0.3975583016872406,
0.20491139590740204,
0.1688990592956543,
-0.211117222905159,
-0.6724112033843994,
-0.22499032318592072,
0.29980772733688354,
-0.8967824578285217,
-0.308025985956192,
-0.250464528799057,
1.126641035079956,
0.34806597232818604,
-0.580216109752655,
-0.38079729676246643,
-0.8901996612548828,
0.4829062521457672,
-0.20424777269363403,
0.17006295919418335,
0.49941056966781616,
0.4334770143032074,
-0.26782217621803284,
-0.8446847796440125,
-0.3753258287906647,
-0.20656980574131012,
-0.09652724117040634,
0.34437814354896545,
-0.211286261677742,
0.22320012748241425,
-0.10268225520849228,
-0.311193585395813,
-0.039766836911439896,
0.3950324058532715,
-0.29126325249671936,
-0.06890177726745605,
0.2669658064842224,
0.06501404941082001,
0.27731016278266907,
0.2909412682056427,
-0.5663065314292908,
-0.47334685921669006,
-0.48991379141807556,
0.1590929925441742,
-0.029716333374381065,
0.0655946135520935,
-0.2653672397136688,
0.4543535113334656,
0.22106441855430603,
0.5532140135765076,
0.21041321754455566,
0.05154695734381676,
-0.03242751210927963,
-0.01761055365204811,
-0.3148559033870697,
-0.2961069345474243,
0.7989819049835205,
0.33595341444015503,
0.3806179165840149,
-0.19766418635845184,
-0.2907736301422119,
-0.003960362169891596,
0.5377290844917297,
-0.8082189559936523,
0.028466101735830307,
-0.11770626157522202,
-0.49967876076698303,
-0.11984504759311676,
0.09974560886621475,
-0.6980820298194885,
-0.3496157228946686,
-0.2652698755264282,
0.8729021549224854,
-0.35790500044822693,
-0.23404501378536224,
0.2608622908592224,
-0.29390519857406616,
0.40106460452079773,
0.6854279637336731,
-0.7214720845222473,
0.3396856188774109,
0.145554780960083,
0.8850200176239014,
-0.35237735509872437,
-0.29973408579826355,
-0.3534024655818939,
0.3804052472114563,
-0.5920537710189819,
0.5200818777084351,
-0.8141962289810181,
-0.5985012650489807,
0.3522007465362549,
0.04741613194346428,
-0.21028581261634827,
-0.5024518370628357,
-0.19147254526615143,
-0.7982104420661926,
0.08641916513442993,
-0.031104328110814095,
-0.3634342551231384,
-0.1640293151140213,
0.28113335371017456,
-0.6058734059333801,
0.4463529586791992,
0.0637018233537674,
-0.520089864730835,
0.3651731014251709,
-0.513401210308075,
-0.4207748770713806,
-0.35757210850715637,
-0.3602561950683594,
-0.30514422059059143,
-0.08912992477416992,
0.05118241533637047,
0.7035593390464783,
0.2681204378604889,
0.11537628620862961,
-0.14346913993358612,
-0.3264369070529938,
-0.05246663838624954,
-0.6179249882698059,
0.24427179992198944,
0.001075478969141841,
-0.38146892189979553,
0.2504447400569916,
-0.19938254356384277,
-0.35249942541122437,
0.07962235063314438,
-0.3261377513408661,
-0.4515019655227661,
0.3080076575279236,
-0.18103399872779846,
0.10123937577009201,
0.1348728984594345,
-0.10347975790500641,
0.26238009333610535,
-0.15010413527488708,
0.37634921073913574,
0.8885167241096497,
-0.0020304613281041384,
1.0500372648239136,
-0.08717481791973114,
0.67560875415802,
0.32427290081977844,
-0.19483943283557892,
-0.4853556156158447,
-0.30289262533187866,
-0.5143278241157532,
-0.1332210749387741,
-0.058336157351732254,
0.5140892863273621,
-1.2318998575210571,
0.07413129508495331,
-0.10848377645015717,
-0.3058817386627197,
-0.23356710374355316,
-0.19596034288406372,
0.35995790362358093,
0.4760255813598633,
0.48471349477767944,
-0.23677432537078857,
0.30947425961494446,
-0.560100793838501,
0.058466095477342606,
0.18435166776180267,
0.04704760015010834,
0.286725789308548,
0.7073161005973816,
-0.44056156277656555,
0.7576231956481934,
-0.3704943358898163,
-0.3893737494945526,
-0.133123517036438,
0.3159949481487274,
-0.32375818490982056,
0.6298910975456238,
0.6080482602119446,
-1.0131785869598389,
-0.2705385982990265,
0.19482696056365967,
-0.6666488647460938,
0.2826800048351288,
-0.30887869000434875,
-0.4248659908771515,
0.10770200937986374,
0.8324944972991943,
-0.5090620517730713,
0.7708009481430054,
0.4541179835796356,
-0.4424297511577606,
0.34484001994132996,
-0.6672943830490112,
0.18719984591007233,
-0.8373902440071106,
-0.04504205286502838,
0.12984102964401245,
-0.6051577925682068,
-0.26670828461647034,
0.0838441252708435,
0.008970636874437332,
-0.11003363877534866,
-0.5752931833267212,
0.5274789333343506,
-0.4228125810623169,
-0.01953876204788685,
-0.2699566185474396,
0.17489252984523773,
-0.06973399966955185,
0.6478213667869568,
0.6005262732505798,
0.7348950505256653,
0.8546034693717957,
-1.0211844444274902,
-0.23421937227249146,
0.17402717471122742,
-0.16213186085224152,
0.47203904390335083,
-0.6175123453140259,
-0.08045164495706558,
-0.5460132360458374,
0.3426022231578827,
-0.7782518267631531,
-0.2320774495601654,
0.25067630410194397,
-0.16343867778778076,
0.5946422219276428,
-0.0993867814540863,
-0.23243871331214905,
0.049061715602874756,
0.05138731002807617,
0.3121696710586548,
0.7933990359306335,
-0.4309012293815613,
0.9028916954994202,
0.3400403559207916,
0.26715558767318726,
-0.4996861219406128,
-0.8117021322250366,
-0.5509070158004761,
-0.1111752986907959,
0.03233633562922478,
0.49284473061561584,
0.24070140719413757,
0.046120889484882355,
0.21904875338077545,
0.0378151498734951,
-0.34782645106315613,
0.028376730158925056,
0.3204120993614197,
0.05850166827440262,
0.01182542648166418,
0.09910283237695694,
0.3044576942920685,
-0.039963871240615845,
0.0733371302485466,
-0.5612874031066895,
0.3939695656299591,
0.16234193742275238,
-0.42589718103408813,
-0.41017085313796997,
0.20452946424484253,
0.6037817001342773,
-0.23064358532428741,
0.8332784175872803,
0.3864738643169403,
-0.22619929909706116,
-0.26586273312568665,
0.11860417574644089,
-0.01840859465301037,
-0.47547727823257446,
0.36138129234313965,
-0.20528528094291687,
-0.8814253211021423,
0.3970763385295868,
-0.46824589371681213,
0.16571733355522156,
0.256677508354187,
0.3095615804195404,
-0.5279660224914551,
0.9433666467666626,
0.8615269660949707,
-0.001025809091515839,
0.777008593082428,
-0.43856751918792725,
-0.42761895060539246,
-0.3696902096271515,
-0.45463424921035767,
-0.35944485664367676,
-0.44218987226486206,
-0.4467332661151886,
-0.8504029512405396,
0.29689911007881165,
0.16327805817127228,
-0.6652318239212036,
0.04957932233810425,
-0.3223911225795746,
0.54245924949646,
0.2511662542819977,
0.41299518942832947,
-0.05565398931503296,
0.14746907353401184,
-0.3288644552230835,
0.16520576179027557,
-0.7708576321601868,
-0.5943517088890076,
0.7143833637237549,
0.3427165150642395,
1.2363591194152832,
-0.23346450924873352,
0.5684680938720703,
0.5613640546798706,
0.22272080183029175,
-0.6140947937965393,
0.47436508536338806,
-0.27200865745544434,
-0.022967884317040443,
-0.17861653864383698,
-0.30754005908966064,
-1.0925947427749634,
0.3211279809474945,
-0.3353208005428314,
-0.5442374348640442,
0.3392072319984436,
0.4133695065975189,
-0.272143691778183,
0.5087668299674988,
-0.7361977100372314,
1.0229706764221191,
-0.15197917819023132,
-0.5235422253608704,
-0.2708345949649811,
-0.744598925113678,
0.0023025493137538433,
0.1742240935564041,
0.0050818417221307755,
0.15161418914794922,
-0.3916465640068054,
0.47552019357681274,
-0.33261945843696594,
1.0189017057418823,
-0.3251095712184906,
0.01995537430047989,
0.29326972365379333,
0.23252800107002258,
0.40602418780326843,
-0.15736354887485504,
0.18826696276664734,
0.0630224347114563,
-0.23531772196292877,
-0.5763127207756042,
-0.5233194828033447,
0.31713351607322693,
-0.9634392857551575,
-0.34682878851890564,
-0.32265567779541016,
0.07219837605953217,
0.0015623676590621471,
0.18351632356643677,
0.5910552740097046,
0.5097633600234985,
-0.32314664125442505,
0.15428516268730164,
0.9912605881690979,
-0.3818719685077667,
0.5560651421546936,
0.18747776746749878,
-0.4056112468242645,
-0.2011762261390686,
0.7205358147621155,
-0.012253091670572758,
0.6206759810447693,
0.6834127306938171,
-0.0007355873240157962,
-0.2711338996887207,
-0.42918670177459717,
-0.41799598932266235,
-0.0744723379611969,
-0.685797929763794,
-0.17291629314422607,
-0.4052428901195526,
-0.26782262325286865,
0.1741267293691635,
-0.5215703248977661,
-0.3063267767429352,
0.22900520265102386,
-0.9347963929176331,
-0.00221339357085526,
0.057008154690265656,
1.0745933055877686,
0.04739183187484741,
0.6715967059135437,
-0.6194278597831726,
0.380928635597229,
0.27403524518013,
0.28705090284347534,
0.10295531153678894,
-0.3729717433452606,
-0.36803629994392395,
0.016192564740777016,
-0.44279393553733826,
-1.034839153289795,
0.37762582302093506,
0.37155717611312866,
0.4019620716571808,
0.5982754826545715,
-0.05744674801826477,
0.7371928691864014,
-0.729271650314331,
0.7923535108566284,
0.26045337319374084,
-0.7636575698852539,
0.6238948702812195,
-0.15544849634170532,
0.49881452322006226,
0.39226704835891724,
0.8472273945808411,
-0.03374852240085602,
-0.3866802453994751,
-0.2727726995944977,
-0.5657724142074585,
0.6772814393043518,
0.07189849764108658,
0.5408090353012085,
-0.06789934635162354,
0.3019888699054718,
0.11214631795883179,
0.28767848014831543,
-0.7275878190994263,
0.0014489827444776893,
-0.5076009035110474,
-0.12172019481658936,
-0.10526986420154572,
0.02528318390250206,
0.22453492879867554,
0.06191499903798103,
0.2627510130405426,
-0.17292307317256927,
0.38465186953544617,
0.39563390612602234,
-0.1704740673303604,
0.2456546276807785,
-0.0323076955974102,
0.399370014667511,
0.2850515842437744,
0.1090967133641243,
0.23999139666557312,
-0.27292490005493164,
-0.5330204367637634,
0.3179222345352173,
0.09230110049247742,
-0.3480253517627716,
-0.24793003499507904,
0.34884417057037354,
0.9629749059677124,
0.2842597961425781,
-0.6028633117675781,
0.672116756439209,
0.08067712187767029,
-0.18654349446296692,
-0.057023368775844574,
0.18425485491752625,
-0.26176491379737854,
0.29455700516700745,
0.1694687008857727,
0.5391381978988647,
-0.01028553768992424,
-0.3441866934299469,
0.15993386507034302,
0.5140540599822998,
-0.6630969643592834,
-0.3364267945289612,
0.8043010830879211,
0.3155210316181183,
0.07142531871795654,
0.5668413043022156,
-0.15453019738197327,
-0.4524374008178711,
0.5547802448272705,
0.34297975897789,
0.7235485911369324,
-0.004116653930395842,
0.4635068476200104,
0.20327918231487274,
0.38437288999557495,
-0.3824906349182129,
0.012431018985807896,
-0.25994279980659485,
-0.8822402358055115,
-0.2495790421962738,
-0.31058767437934875,
-0.09198184311389923,
-0.19679869711399078,
-0.5479500889778137,
0.10842467844486237,
-0.6700584292411804,
-0.4946054518222809,
-0.5646292567253113,
-0.5896579027175903,
-0.7946644425392151,
0.149534210562706,
0.20181114971637726,
1.0648529529571533,
-0.7846323251724243,
0.7258535027503967,
0.6785129308700562,
-0.5527207255363464,
-0.6702768206596375,
0.14395390450954437,
-0.5345929861068726,
-0.5468775629997253,
0.5588270425796509,
0.24375447630882263,
-0.3851196765899658,
-0.1633020043373108,
-0.8882487416267395,
-0.5051797032356262,
0.9632766842842102,
0.5214429497718811,
-0.3395927846431732,
-0.3148162364959717,
-0.19404035806655884,
0.4737204611301422,
-0.43433743715286255,
0.30357009172439575,
0.3042301535606384,
0.2826426327228546,
0.26595932245254517,
-0.6636099219322205,
-0.30124714970588684,
0.0089883329346776,
0.12543241679668427,
0.15472473204135895,
-0.5262128114700317,
0.7107448577880859,
-0.1821613311767578,
-0.29126495122909546,
-0.08802006393671036,
0.7590821981430054,
-0.014052625745534897,
0.3320620656013489,
0.432953417301178,
0.5140498876571655,
0.44101032614707947,
-0.21225236356258392,
1.1354877948760986,
0.27721670269966125,
0.0684073194861412,
1.0626031160354614,
-0.20213201642036438,
1.1203804016113281,
0.39746609330177307,
0.16121679544448853,
0.8746887445449829,
0.6036736369132996,
0.39124125242233276,
0.864581823348999,
-0.13642078638076782,
-0.009237308986485004,
-0.28585198521614075,
0.07422596961259842,
-0.1406625509262085,
0.3198663294315338,
0.46825718879699707,
-0.543969452381134,
-0.3540056347846985,
0.6355742812156677,
-0.058607880026102066,
0.4139591157436371,
-0.734470546245575,
0.9475796818733215,
-0.026327816769480705,
-0.7121897339820862,
0.4863390624523163,
-0.2630492150783539,
0.7549826502799988,
-0.9328793883323669,
-0.3720104396343231,
0.003749626222997904,
0.035848475992679596,
-0.011535804718732834,
-1.0155435800552368,
0.15508130192756653,
-0.20817942917346954,
0.04857978969812393,
-0.5894014239311218,
0.7578262090682983,
-0.6756552457809448,
0.10401754081249237,
0.4368706941604614,
0.15000467002391815,
0.177085742354393,
0.024752220138907433,
-0.49571385979652405,
-0.07505332678556442,
-0.05570816248655319,
-0.19592563807964325,
0.1904074102640152,
0.4567756652832031,
-0.26473531126976013,
0.6927984356880188,
0.06305038928985596,
0.18722820281982422,
0.38922280073165894,
-0.35102418065071106,
0.9705599546432495,
-0.4446457624435425,
-0.6527693867683411,
-0.7033474445343018,
0.5886046886444092,
0.046910401433706284,
-0.06867033243179321,
0.16468051075935364,
0.16430270671844482,
0.8799940943717957,
-0.2388855367898941,
0.6542199850082397,
0.019339561462402344,
-0.23433318734169006,
-0.8930686116218567,
1.0332919359207153,
-0.7625075578689575,
-0.3259583115577698,
-0.07665662467479706,
-0.6084762215614319,
0.01667487621307373,
0.6342610716819763,
-0.2856075167655945,
0.21888825297355652,
0.2856650948524475,
0.5369065403938293,
-0.16102567315101624,
-0.563667893409729,
0.4768696427345276,
0.06873100996017456,
0.2592705190181732,
0.7004045248031616,
0.8861826062202454,
-0.096622034907341,
0.394797146320343,
0.1554175168275833,
-0.26879316568374634,
-0.03827693685889244,
-0.8828747868537903,
-0.9143865704536438,
-0.6642105579376221,
-0.18340015411376953,
-0.21793709695339203,
0.016457129269838333,
0.8092316389083862,
1.1104931831359863,
-0.3866018056869507,
-0.16510379314422607,
-0.3783734142780304,
0.2765461504459381,
-0.19330213963985443,
-0.12830685079097748,
0.15938866138458252,
-0.44490769505500793,
-0.7667599320411682,
0.14461660385131836,
0.37976473569869995,
0.7009556889533997,
-0.4770544171333313,
-0.48069462180137634,
0.024350780993700027,
0.15672415494918823,
0.7250840663909912,
0.41452693939208984,
-0.49845463037490845,
0.11936873942613602,
-0.2789289057254791,
-0.3628816306591034,
0.1143723726272583,
0.8683286309242249,
-1.078066349029541,
0.801889181137085,
0.4213990271091461,
0.83417147397995,
0.5824082493782043,
-0.01879776082932949,
0.6665228009223938,
-0.6386876702308655,
0.45465314388275146,
0.2746366262435913,
0.2560268044471741,
0.09559224545955658,
-0.10024275630712509,
0.09878885746002197,
-0.07333673536777496,
-0.32076969742774963,
-0.20197603106498718,
0.13426873087882996,
-0.8488231301307678,
-0.479518860578537,
0.9477778673171997,
-0.47014114260673523,
-0.43300721049308777,
0.13404759764671326,
-0.4037744104862213,
0.09426136314868927,
-0.5309131741523743,
0.29365411400794983,
0.34043028950691223,
0.11188209056854248,
-0.3593526780605316,
-0.4087439477443695,
0.5865615606307983,
-0.023697935044765472,
-0.8681012988090515,
-0.26424258947372437,
0.5351505279541016,
-0.06690183281898499,
0.15500901639461517,
0.773497998714447,
-0.08910326659679413,
0.05183333903551102,
-0.24488796293735504,
-0.08858521282672882,
0.12730982899665833,
-0.729609489440918,
-0.3104698359966278,
0.28577297925949097,
-0.029078790917992592,
-0.46526387333869934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06713v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06713v2
|
Unveiling the Competitive Dynamics: A Comparative Evaluation of American and Chinese LLMs
| 2024-05-09T15:39:19 | 2024-05-21T05:37:58 |
Zhenhui Jiang, Jiaxin Li, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The strategic significance of Large Language Models (LLMs) in economic
expansion, innovation, societal development, and national security has been
increasingly recognized since the advent of ChatGPT. This study provides a
comprehensive comparative evaluation of American and Chinese LLMs in both
English and Chinese contexts. We proposed a comprehensive evaluation framework
that encompasses natural language proficiency, disciplinary expertise, and
safety and responsibility, and systematically assessed 16 prominent models from
the US and China under various operational tasks and scenarios. Our key
findings show that GPT 4-Turbo is at the forefront in English contexts, whereas
Ernie-Bot 4 stands out in Chinese contexts. The study also highlights
disparities in LLM performance across languages and tasks, stressing the
necessity for linguistically and culturally nuanced model development. The
complementary strengths of American and Chinese LLMs point to the value of
Sino-US collaboration in advancing LLM technology. The research presents the
current LLM competition landscape and offers valuable insights for policymakers
and businesses regarding strategic LLM investments and development. Future work
will expand on this framework to include emerging LLM multimodal capabilities
and business application assessments.
|
[
-0.05239846184849739,
-0.644363522529602,
0.5058287978172302,
0.32555413246154785,
-0.1314326673746109,
0.7121759653091431,
-0.5765765905380249,
-0.5564696788787842,
-0.11883143335580826,
0.1877320408821106,
-0.18004433810710907,
-0.26560544967651367,
-0.3538142144680023,
0.14386209845542908,
-0.15270540118217468,
0.6111000180244446,
0.08107788115739822,
0.2556058466434479,
-0.04325434938073158,
0.07381628453731537,
-0.22970500588417053,
-0.691473126411438,
-0.9678331017494202,
-0.6738457679748535,
0.2811935544013977,
-0.24087940156459808,
0.8999691009521484,
0.5228424072265625,
0.8386778831481934,
0.457542359828949,
-0.22126242518424988,
-0.04304831102490425,
-0.4314980208873749,
-0.04393557459115982,
-0.0868038684129715,
-0.15984168648719788,
-0.5054951310157776,
0.1768588423728943,
0.8215427398681641,
0.7459245324134827,
-0.31297430396080017,
-0.017971323803067207,
0.4640581011772156,
0.5031543374061584,
-0.16252274811267853,
0.45180264115333557,
-0.7134222388267517,
-0.11441546678543091,
-0.1791948676109314,
-0.13800299167633057,
-0.13807207345962524,
-0.5181658267974854,
0.5866295099258423,
-0.48400890827178955,
-0.30882611870765686,
-0.024712463840842247,
1.0088872909545898,
-0.03070308268070221,
-0.6133485436439514,
-0.2842865288257599,
-0.739339292049408,
0.9010335206985474,
-0.6594048142433167,
0.4482010006904602,
-0.44011300802230835,
0.3019413352012634,
-0.26993200182914734,
-0.9525432586669922,
-0.20226125419139862,
-0.3468180298805237,
0.30367031693458557,
0.4768599271774292,
-0.17145060002803802,
0.11539019644260406,
-0.11771413683891296,
0.37201976776123047,
-0.7716827988624573,
0.46227630972862244,
-0.5174055695533752,
-0.1346549391746521,
0.7954118847846985,
0.32072246074676514,
0.4754262864589691,
0.1405225694179535,
-0.6355845332145691,
-0.056483715772628784,
-0.7031210660934448,
0.2929587662220001,
0.18805550038814545,
0.46733468770980835,
-0.3460227847099304,
0.08479773998260498,
0.07738826423883438,
0.25486865639686584,
-0.36355865001678467,
-0.23550590872764587,
0.17029722034931183,
-0.4974132478237152,
-0.3565770387649536,
-0.098594531416893,
1.0133670568466187,
0.4533233642578125,
0.27115747332572937,
-0.437274307012558,
-0.23367249965667725,
-0.11751817911863327,
0.07500489056110382,
-0.6728816628456116,
0.17865554988384247,
0.015125083737075329,
-0.7962180376052856,
-0.09024406224489212,
0.3123842477798462,
-0.8087789416313171,
-0.4232596755027771,
-0.2641836702823639,
0.4525472819805145,
0.06368944048881531,
-0.4998711049556732,
0.2158440798521042,
-0.267589807510376,
0.7531393766403198,
0.00592523580417037,
-0.8326923847198486,
0.2829431891441345,
1.1587339639663696,
1.0153368711471558,
-0.36046063899993896,
-0.34743210673332214,
0.23398728668689728,
0.04004374518990517,
-0.548707902431488,
0.5038962364196777,
-0.2710840702056885,
-0.49486953020095825,
0.29457712173461914,
0.016604352742433548,
-0.005944244097918272,
-0.7452799677848816,
0.33206555247306824,
-0.6592252254486084,
-0.03264986723661423,
-0.5347867012023926,
-0.22187575697898865,
-0.3017781674861908,
0.5945279598236084,
-0.6421823501586914,
0.7982993125915527,
-0.12748654186725616,
-0.3865334987640381,
0.4049001634120941,
-0.7566413283348083,
-0.2902863621711731,
0.391042023897171,
-0.44568705558776855,
-0.08403143286705017,
-0.20980775356292725,
-0.3093838393688202,
0.4013005495071411,
-0.8466303944587708,
0.258468359708786,
-0.2908753454685211,
-0.5175840258598328,
0.08050272613763809,
-0.5708136558532715,
0.9674292802810669,
0.27495020627975464,
-0.42688900232315063,
0.0880395919084549,
-0.5324788689613342,
-0.12286210805177689,
0.5451777577400208,
-0.49425289034843445,
0.004639713559299707,
0.19649580121040344,
-0.41793736815452576,
0.20999449491500854,
0.7176356911659241,
-0.3028694987297058,
-0.03894994407892227,
-0.38640573620796204,
0.7807702422142029,
0.7380642294883728,
-0.04680045321583748,
0.40081149339675903,
-0.24420166015625,
0.7741708159446716,
-0.39581534266471863,
0.28918060660362244,
-0.08586939424276352,
-0.3936595320701599,
-0.6452707648277283,
-0.07232695072889328,
0.16205339133739471,
0.6731553077697754,
-0.6554353833198547,
-0.04898650571703911,
-0.37937045097351074,
-0.489959716796875,
-0.22185105085372925,
0.05698540434241295,
0.14458803832530975,
0.19070886075496674,
-0.01326898392289877,
-0.3526529371738434,
-0.39493507146835327,
-0.9643984436988831,
-0.3018125891685486,
-0.3444594144821167,
-0.01891499198973179,
0.2809388041496277,
0.14180892705917358,
-0.08579136431217194,
0.4665572941303253,
0.01584276743233204,
-0.12890812754631042,
-0.6373890042304993,
0.021001802757382393,
0.35298267006874084,
-0.012182347476482391,
0.4936929941177368,
-0.6333128809928894,
-0.7815811038017273,
0.3265226483345032,
-0.6547479629516602,
-0.06465502828359604,
-0.13021305203437805,
-0.029772523790597916,
0.20533841848373413,
0.3883090913295746,
-0.274431049823761,
0.07259462773799896,
0.6263079047203064,
-0.1357497125864029,
0.5999536514282227,
-0.2331649363040924,
0.29490143060684204,
-0.7826429009437561,
-0.06861849129199982,
-0.04721315950155258,
0.14892242848873138,
-0.6289042830467224,
0.23656004667282104,
-0.05730341747403145,
-0.005993987899273634,
-0.39835289120674133,
0.4027602970600128,
-0.7204732894897461,
-0.3210257291793823,
-0.06606463342905045,
0.556602954864502,
-0.1324755698442459,
0.09673329442739487,
0.1466766893863678,
0.893933892250061,
0.4145379960536957,
-0.489981472492218,
0.6178937554359436,
-0.11390344798564911,
-0.4849969446659088,
0.07429011166095734,
-0.8730010986328125,
-0.11872658878564835,
0.44345107674598694,
-0.045871179550886154,
-0.8023862838745117,
0.06517447531223297,
-0.22168996930122375,
-0.23815101385116577,
0.24185648560523987,
0.1812051385641098,
-0.6035676002502441,
-0.42756614089012146,
-0.4780691862106323,
0.09997816383838654,
0.8147438168525696,
-0.3995403051376343,
0.3359915018081665,
0.3966708779335022,
-0.32198455929756165,
-0.4694092273712158,
-0.5970778465270996,
0.32581695914268494,
-0.48430055379867554,
-0.8638556599617004,
0.2441597580909729,
0.10154798626899719,
-0.5516390204429626,
-0.2595010995864868,
-0.03916122391819954,
-0.2997751235961914,
0.42241209745407104,
-0.18896633386611938,
0.5802775621414185,
-0.5409541130065918,
-0.31267547607421875,
-0.4290068745613098,
-0.0012871897779405117,
0.36044326424598694,
-0.13266509771347046,
0.37938588857650757,
-0.20740407705307007,
-0.04300203546881676,
-0.3059786558151245,
-0.09569355100393295,
0.46251291036605835,
-0.36453700065612793,
0.6447262167930603,
0.42042383551597595,
-0.13661763072013855,
-0.14153549075126648,
-0.39208850264549255,
-0.01551754679530859,
-0.5886183381080627,
0.4877200126647949,
-0.05760744586586952,
-0.9087304472923279,
0.6238313913345337,
-0.19109207391738892,
0.2616235017776489,
0.42402416467666626,
0.881521999835968,
0.3880878686904907,
1.02394700050354,
0.6932693719863892,
-0.2733210325241089,
0.3302166759967804,
-0.10470058768987656,
0.5072450637817383,
-0.5990551114082336,
-0.31230470538139343,
-0.31303948163986206,
-0.3043026030063629,
-0.675030529499054,
-0.39460936188697815,
0.5125957727432251,
-0.26045119762420654,
-0.47413358092308044,
0.1669158935546875,
-0.2916004955768585,
0.46760088205337524,
0.36322978138923645,
-0.4794836938381195,
0.3882886469364166,
-0.2511536180973053,
-0.428577184677124,
-0.19721107184886932,
-0.6002193093299866,
-0.9039886593818665,
0.9905376434326172,
0.6091042160987854,
0.6851354241371155,
0.45957088470458984,
0.37681472301483154,
0.028597990050911903,
0.2327987104654312,
-0.6856088638305664,
0.5549027323722839,
-0.4257708787918091,
-0.4791910946369171,
-0.15353412926197052,
-0.4483470022678375,
-1.0154459476470947,
0.3953990936279297,
-0.12162002176046371,
-0.6299671530723572,
-0.35105443000793457,
-0.3561258316040039,
-0.6155791282653809,
0.4102116525173187,
-0.5557824373245239,
0.9041333198547363,
-0.6497209072113037,
-0.4748781621456146,
-0.17506323754787445,
-0.43049341440200806,
0.5501165390014648,
-0.06321313232183456,
0.3142424523830414,
-0.21049924194812775,
-0.372825562953949,
0.6661363840103149,
0.1085813120007515,
0.6022700071334839,
0.14495037496089935,
-0.36479347944259644,
0.16982586681842804,
-0.14197710156440735,
0.22388657927513123,
-0.11940926313400269,
-0.34449467062950134,
0.2923397719860077,
-0.09316051006317139,
-0.10776819288730621,
-0.4276490807533264,
0.8585678339004517,
-0.6984272599220276,
-0.7178770303726196,
-0.4780293405056,
-0.3550306260585785,
-0.22763605415821075,
0.2953067123889923,
0.22195784747600555,
0.22693803906440735,
-0.6953580379486084,
0.45090973377227783,
0.33493632078170776,
-0.3814522922039032,
0.778182327747345,
0.6333890557289124,
-0.08445410430431366,
-0.148796945810318,
0.7382707595825195,
0.24945244193077087,
0.41903722286224365,
0.2206587791442871,
0.20287787914276123,
-0.47549930214881897,
-0.6076115965843201,
-0.1526399850845337,
0.18285655975341797,
-0.5240263342857361,
0.08349438011646271,
-0.19851675629615784,
-0.43491068482398987,
-0.3667766749858856,
-0.28045910596847534,
-0.5224438905715942,
0.0806603655219078,
0.08913923799991608,
0.04003871604800224,
-0.24632695317268372,
1.0651921033859253,
-0.11090533435344696,
0.14202432334423065,
-0.5915006995201111,
-0.14747688174247742,
0.24378852546215057,
0.34252503514289856,
0.21658878028392792,
-0.3467859625816345,
-0.376613050699234,
-0.010385839268565178,
-0.6765164136886597,
-0.5857205390930176,
0.43153104186058044,
-0.0754876658320427,
0.9328316450119019,
0.5151787400245667,
-0.08015476912260056,
0.6088404059410095,
-0.6288757920265198,
1.4098789691925049,
0.051019567996263504,
-0.8575893044471741,
-0.004778336267918348,
-0.4154985845088959,
0.019355028867721558,
0.1041681095957756,
0.45329463481903076,
-0.45958617329597473,
-0.10315696150064468,
-0.4812672734260559,
-0.9592843055725098,
0.5247958302497864,
-0.10957835614681244,
0.22628140449523926,
0.06042004004120827,
0.15823549032211304,
-0.19918139278888702,
0.13335774838924408,
-0.9731743931770325,
-0.2823842465877533,
0.2926577925682068,
0.12574535608291626,
-0.13162478804588318,
-0.20400559902191162,
0.0557633675634861,
0.15564829111099243,
0.5647876262664795,
0.22631414234638214,
0.05963335558772087,
-0.05686640366911888,
0.1791161149740219,
0.18919317424297333,
0.3457336723804474,
0.4917612075805664,
0.6566489338874817,
-0.000508539960719645,
-0.16727688908576965,
0.24082176387310028,
-0.3882468342781067,
0.006830858066678047,
-0.21191535890102386,
-0.0014729686081409454,
-0.1762593686580658,
0.5449029207229614,
0.5798970460891724,
0.3490917384624481,
-0.7932539582252502,
0.40873926877975464,
-0.04092392325401306,
-0.3757997453212738,
-0.2549658417701721,
-0.1371203511953354,
0.16843897104263306,
0.624288022518158,
0.3015928566455841,
-0.5883432030677795,
0.2241966426372528,
-0.7524850368499756,
0.000008682654879521579,
0.7965930104255676,
-0.15847651660442352,
-0.4955916404724121,
0.8113797903060913,
0.6743378043174744,
-0.11197821795940399,
0.21387234330177307,
-0.42446088790893555,
-0.95102858543396,
0.7526963353157043,
0.5256600975990295,
0.8949148654937744,
-0.18317508697509766,
-0.1304176300764084,
0.3092461824417114,
0.6725918054580688,
-0.14178651571273804,
0.12112804502248764,
0.1644364446401596,
-0.7923641204833984,
-0.21202845871448517,
-0.2649018168449402,
-0.5544266104698181,
0.36989012360572815,
-0.5578818321228027,
0.3898822069168091,
-0.6664080619812012,
-0.2194744497537613,
-0.38657447695732117,
0.5601776838302612,
-0.5676990747451782,
-0.20978812873363495,
0.5088001489639282,
0.7417212128639221,
-0.35243335366249084,
0.5695470571517944,
0.6670030951499939,
-0.17746175825595856,
-0.8150076866149902,
0.12123385071754456,
0.49483349919319153,
-0.7488473057746887,
0.8496947884559631,
0.18184757232666016,
-0.17701512575149536,
-0.20885072648525238,
-0.04327154904603958,
-0.870853066444397,
1.440303087234497,
0.2374981939792633,
-0.38610172271728516,
0.025218389928340912,
0.28269529342651367,
0.4127139449119568,
-0.406884104013443,
0.26123860478401184,
0.8426047563552856,
0.4416588544845581,
-0.08810680359601974,
-1.3315049409866333,
-0.26690182089805603,
0.007001776713877916,
0.16030672192573547,
0.1890266388654709,
-1.303977131843567,
0.9128066897392273,
-0.10583711415529251,
-0.6897367835044861,
0.18034175038337708,
0.5141503214836121,
0.22078844904899597,
0.2043934166431427,
0.25184687972068787,
-0.04459104314446449,
0.48683831095695496,
-0.18100415170192719,
0.7923451066017151,
-0.6345776319503784,
0.27948930859565735,
0.7814573645591736,
-0.7039056420326233,
0.8997324705123901,
0.028149062767624855,
-0.4886663556098938,
0.5207350254058838,
0.6407871842384338,
-0.07735437154769897,
0.2679729759693146,
0.2989236116409302,
-0.23697872459888458,
-0.0402662567794323,
-0.15396174788475037,
-0.3867230713367462,
0.7773646712303162,
0.31403031945228577,
-0.11441773176193237,
-0.3890444040298462,
-0.6524683237075806,
0.22125622630119324,
0.15070924162864685,
-0.338490754365921,
0.6939725279808044,
0.15853290259838104,
-0.48768147826194763,
0.3415370285511017,
0.20190377533435822,
1.020950436592102,
-0.7511080503463745,
0.184843510389328,
-0.16170477867126465,
0.1115107536315918,
0.12180782854557037,
-0.7126417756080627,
0.259265273809433,
0.3211478590965271,
0.28310427069664,
-0.12045992165803909,
0.32479777932167053,
-0.3823433518409729,
-0.14735373854637146,
0.7557498216629028,
0.4104568064212799,
0.10521199554204941,
0.2299601435661316,
-1.00177800655365,
0.409140944480896,
-0.020133698359131813,
-0.33685654401779175,
0.20508544147014618,
0.545823335647583,
0.029347296804189682,
0.7271795868873596,
0.4627072513103485,
0.26872536540031433,
-0.026325123384594917,
0.11289668828248978,
0.44021254777908325,
-0.7760748863220215,
-0.43187323212623596,
-1.0361088514328003,
0.3436984121799469,
-0.1944044828414917,
-0.08911871165037155,
1.027217984199524,
0.5199116468429565,
0.6544886231422424,
0.2746320366859436,
0.8792217373847961,
0.12954381108283997,
0.2900185286998749,
-0.48695364594459534,
0.9771285057067871,
-0.5068574547767639,
0.6058252453804016,
-0.12641046941280365,
-0.8311508297920227,
-0.1254701465368271,
0.4625701606273651,
-0.247898668050766,
0.28697389364242554,
0.5238223671913147,
0.5723251104354858,
0.3267841637134552,
-0.23415778577327728,
0.6126556992530823,
0.32886990904808044,
0.48047518730163574,
0.7728338837623596,
0.9911834001541138,
-0.2062053382396698,
0.581121563911438,
-0.15460322797298431,
-0.3940750062465668,
0.03108997829258442,
-1.1724778413772583,
-0.926055371761322,
-0.3247397541999817,
-0.15414807200431824,
-0.011932707391679287,
-0.2244361788034439,
0.9690184593200684,
0.5312323570251465,
-0.3963952660560608,
-0.7622614502906799,
0.5217876434326172,
0.03226710483431816,
-0.0008135276148095727,
-0.25701990723609924,
0.0898844450712204,
-0.38336923718452454,
-0.8144861459732056,
0.4496324062347412,
0.7282531261444092,
0.16693523526191711,
-0.5873425602912903,
-0.1612444519996643,
0.14736858010292053,
0.5683190822601318,
0.7245516180992126,
0.22086752951145172,
-0.8932983875274658,
0.08821732550859451,
0.25887420773506165,
-0.06994127482175827,
-0.1855318695306778,
0.6972282528877258,
-0.3797238767147064,
0.13004516065120697,
0.3546247184276581,
0.7401313781738281,
-0.3171357214450836,
-0.04364476725459099,
0.9515921473503113,
-0.2712372839450836,
0.24626852571964264,
-0.10609505325555801,
0.3122146427631378,
0.336988627910614,
-0.1645956188440323,
0.7015523314476013,
0.08750436455011368,
-0.8670440912246704,
-0.7777326703071594,
0.02887776680290699,
-0.7542242407798767,
-0.26658692955970764,
1.2052001953125,
-0.2632145881652832,
0.10074915736913681,
-0.08983147144317627,
0.16176751255989075,
0.081109419465065,
-0.31384602189064026,
0.5483689904212952,
0.9777023196220398,
-0.03895362839102745,
0.09294667094945908,
-0.8320313692092896,
0.5801730155944824,
0.15759511291980743,
-0.4537826478481293,
0.0738266184926033,
0.07831025123596191,
0.05211201310157776,
-0.020263221114873886,
0.4008314907550812,
-0.21052806079387665,
0.23708300292491913,
-0.019681567326188087,
-0.11447750777006149,
0.1525849848985672,
-0.1522044539451599,
-0.442249059677124,
-0.06666455417871475,
0.39924344420433044,
0.052481409162282944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06712v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06712v1
|
Digital Diagnostics: The Potential Of Large Language Models In Recognizing Symptoms Of Common Illnesses
| 2024-05-09T15:12:24 | 2024-05-09T15:12:24 |
Gaurav Kumar Gupta, Aditi Singh, Sijo Valayakkad Manikandan, Abul Ehtesham
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The recent swift development of LLMs like GPT-4, Gemini, and GPT-3.5 offers a
transformative opportunity in medicine and healthcare, especially in digital
diagnostics. This study evaluates each model diagnostic abilities by
interpreting a user symptoms and determining diagnoses that fit well with
common illnesses, and it demonstrates how each of these models could
significantly increase diagnostic accuracy and efficiency. Through a series of
diagnostic prompts based on symptoms from medical databases, GPT-4 demonstrates
higher diagnostic accuracy from its deep and complete history of training on
medical data. Meanwhile, Gemini performs with high precision as a critical tool
in disease triage, demonstrating its potential to be a reliable model when
physicians are trying to make high-risk diagnoses. GPT-3.5, though slightly
less advanced, is a good tool for medical diagnostics. This study highlights
the need to study LLMs for healthcare and clinical practices with more care and
attention, ensuring that any system utilizing LLMs promotes patient privacy and
complies with health information privacy laws such as HIPAA compliance, as well
as the social consequences that affect the varied individuals in complex
healthcare contexts. This study marks the start of a larger future effort to
study the various ways in which assigning ethical concerns to LLMs task of
learning from human biases could unearth new ways to apply AI in complex
medical settings.
|
[
-0.15175528824329376,
-0.5606221556663513,
1.1205360889434814,
0.003217233344912529,
-0.17013350129127502,
-0.05440450832247734,
0.1623210608959198,
-0.9048448204994202,
0.21466068923473358,
0.10771790891885757,
-0.5287718772888184,
-0.62300705909729,
-0.8196167945861816,
0.23542198538780212,
-0.6395400762557983,
0.986128568649292,
-0.028315966948866844,
0.5201215147972107,
-0.1725771129131317,
0.3215293884277344,
-0.2783823609352112,
-0.8001944422721863,
-1.0733736753463745,
-0.4123679995536804,
0.38975468277931213,
0.07955043017864227,
0.6798799633979797,
0.4101928174495697,
0.8213055729866028,
0.22277821600437164,
0.11755946278572083,
-0.008898007683455944,
-0.11416809260845184,
0.11271486431360245,
0.09247445315122604,
-0.3769764006137848,
-0.6484897136688232,
0.057775866240262985,
0.2575271427631378,
0.559296190738678,
0.0014777531614527106,
0.0531044527888298,
-0.2695799469947815,
0.6334269642829895,
0.029974423348903656,
0.2677309811115265,
0.058079663664102554,
0.18480706214904785,
-0.22483554482460022,
-0.18159689009189606,
0.12433631718158722,
-0.5243537425994873,
0.2707449197769165,
-0.7153908014297485,
0.30029189586639404,
-0.25848421454429626,
0.7964321970939636,
0.4047236144542694,
-0.5436479449272156,
-0.5262316465377808,
-0.8954488635063171,
0.6338282823562622,
-0.5288805365562439,
0.5171638131141663,
0.31454789638519287,
0.41974321007728577,
0.05198129639029503,
-0.9940142035484314,
-0.3475863039493561,
-0.1913759857416153,
0.0942801907658577,
0.22453396022319794,
-0.2712630033493042,
0.1185842901468277,
0.2723369300365448,
0.5543903112411499,
-0.5178614258766174,
0.31994038820266724,
-0.4909530282020569,
-0.18539384007453918,
0.7129374146461487,
0.6052325963973999,
0.6551550626754761,
-0.05005772039294243,
0.008725269697606564,
0.3637228310108185,
-0.7733390927314758,
-0.12213002890348434,
0.06599345803260803,
-0.18308009207248688,
-0.3431209623813629,
0.36908575892448425,
-0.11625999957323074,
0.5889139175415039,
-0.0746413916349411,
-0.45196834206581116,
0.1627962589263916,
-0.4000697731971741,
-0.16036508977413177,
-0.09735362976789474,
0.604589581489563,
0.4589182734489441,
0.1945948749780655,
0.025446895509958267,
-0.24557572603225708,
0.17710137367248535,
0.3348137438297272,
-0.5720937848091125,
-0.2605385482311249,
0.5539354085922241,
-0.8591620326042175,
-0.3610602915287018,
-0.19158640503883362,
-0.5238485336303711,
-0.8109073042869568,
-0.6937205791473389,
0.20666925609111786,
-0.40278947353363037,
-0.19441494345664978,
0.36702993512153625,
-0.05180658400058746,
-0.03843117505311966,
0.47715258598327637,
-0.8847143054008484,
0.5285684466362,
0.7555201053619385,
0.7932279109954834,
-0.2278914600610733,
0.2219417244195938,
-0.16862516105175018,
-0.08402672410011292,
-0.21815361082553864,
0.5329921245574951,
-0.3878513276576996,
-0.49153637886047363,
-0.13132207095623016,
-0.2056683599948883,
-0.060399480164051056,
-0.8523134589195251,
0.35033920407295227,
-0.14565449953079224,
0.09469074010848999,
-0.42337319254875183,
-0.2831270694732666,
-0.004448769614100456,
0.41672608256340027,
-0.5886532664299011,
0.6691617369651794,
0.2920544445514679,
-0.6627556681632996,
0.3389095067977905,
-1.0206960439682007,
-0.3499077558517456,
0.21373803913593292,
-0.3624900281429291,
-0.4492793083190918,
0.03909182548522949,
0.20953522622585297,
0.6408089399337769,
-0.6221569180488586,
0.19051392376422882,
-0.24117165803909302,
-0.5322257876396179,
0.08185157179832458,
-0.2621132433414459,
0.8011703491210938,
0.19949573278427124,
-0.3734867572784424,
0.048459891229867935,
-0.6130004525184631,
-0.22177444398403168,
0.37854987382888794,
-0.38155099749565125,
-0.2163781225681305,
0.17461100220680237,
-0.19415804743766785,
-0.035585496574640274,
0.2536725699901581,
-0.2639276683330536,
0.3214515447616577,
-0.4608124792575836,
0.4275156557559967,
0.5854486227035522,
0.22134003043174744,
-0.05114548280835152,
-0.6930824518203735,
0.7839165329933167,
0.4041804373264313,
0.6337051391601562,
-0.02350873127579689,
-0.9357753992080688,
-0.43955788016319275,
-0.463573694229126,
0.13208289444446564,
0.6978433132171631,
-0.42685890197753906,
0.19462251663208008,
-0.09397789090871811,
-0.2724287807941437,
-0.6245377063751221,
-0.1610173135995865,
0.06623783707618713,
0.5392909049987793,
0.16602367162704468,
-0.11274812370538712,
-0.35817083716392517,
-0.7476184964179993,
-0.20927214622497559,
0.007985053583979607,
-0.29062017798423767,
0.49028605222702026,
0.21836987137794495,
-0.7922789454460144,
0.4117758870124817,
-0.32163697481155396,
-0.21517547965049744,
-0.1323222815990448,
-0.11589611321687698,
0.371206670999527,
0.13415947556495667,
0.492215633392334,
-0.7086719870567322,
-0.39850175380706787,
0.19648613035678864,
-0.8948506116867065,
-0.25302284955978394,
0.08227960765361786,
0.5493384599685669,
0.08783777803182602,
0.30450311303138733,
-0.5807245969772339,
0.3981883227825165,
0.6438357830047607,
-0.34243491291999817,
0.5288118124008179,
-0.34171023964881897,
0.2651258111000061,
-1.0232574939727783,
-0.024032024666666985,
0.2078840136528015,
-0.21126142144203186,
-0.5582355260848999,
-0.158259317278862,
-0.014997810125350952,
-0.04416320472955704,
-0.28681522607803345,
0.5614485144615173,
-0.28369539976119995,
-0.1675214171409607,
0.03586357831954956,
-0.0016623869305476546,
-0.14820756018161774,
-0.5029833316802979,
-0.3240913450717926,
0.5365740656852722,
0.6069836020469666,
-0.7322853207588196,
0.7219535708427429,
-0.14688971638679504,
-0.16181246936321259,
0.6587725877761841,
-0.6431886553764343,
0.1434774249792099,
-0.0690796822309494,
0.0009104421478696167,
-0.5940127372741699,
-0.22063151001930237,
0.44008323550224304,
-0.49560484290122986,
0.29537224769592285,
0.245236337184906,
-0.6049070358276367,
-0.6363004446029663,
-0.1463468372821808,
0.5172601342201233,
0.5167216062545776,
-0.29305124282836914,
0.39748868346214294,
0.28088513016700745,
-0.2608841061592102,
-0.38122665882110596,
-0.5184041857719421,
0.19119669497013092,
-0.41623440384864807,
-0.5726054906845093,
0.4243411719799042,
-0.10373442620038986,
-0.5993701815605164,
-0.24199113249778748,
0.02085363119840622,
-0.1507934182882309,
0.47113457322120667,
0.33008450269699097,
0.4891104996204376,
-0.0888843908905983,
0.2351791113615036,
0.01526905782520771,
-0.4020521640777588,
0.09590444713830948,
-0.3467082977294922,
0.4439215660095215,
-0.2682470977306366,
-0.6646992564201355,
-0.5795592665672302,
0.5144627094268799,
0.5735700726509094,
0.1410616636276245,
0.220646932721138,
0.44014742970466614,
-0.7099982500076294,
0.2891523241996765,
-0.3990204334259033,
-0.2811301648616791,
-0.41188010573387146,
0.19346807897090912,
-0.26618316769599915,
-0.6658503413200378,
0.6253157258033752,
-0.15026699006557465,
-0.17965877056121826,
0.4196603298187256,
0.7444245219230652,
-0.2066565752029419,
1.2114754915237427,
0.5207889080047607,
-0.09038231521844864,
0.12507306039333344,
-0.10608255118131638,
0.5277274250984192,
-0.656449556350708,
-0.3066471815109253,
-0.4296530783176422,
-0.1806393414735794,
-0.8089519143104553,
-0.17053373157978058,
0.7814892530441284,
-0.24779517948627472,
-0.23754075169563293,
-0.33022376894950867,
-0.6661208271980286,
0.20476146042346954,
0.49590593576431274,
0.38646411895751953,
0.6267975568771362,
-0.388923704624176,
-0.26947590708732605,
-0.1754177361726761,
-0.4535822570323944,
-0.6240736246109009,
1.3154641389846802,
0.5394887924194336,
0.7298259735107422,
0.20958629250526428,
0.9120708107948303,
0.4025917649269104,
0.3473318815231323,
-1.1013022661209106,
0.12404424697160721,
-0.37972262501716614,
-0.6485747694969177,
-0.11139485985040665,
-0.32420122623443604,
-1.0584427118301392,
-0.3999902009963989,
0.0017206196207553148,
-0.8081978559494019,
-0.045233990997076035,
0.23579919338226318,
-0.580112099647522,
0.064773328602314,
-0.8022297024726868,
0.7434900999069214,
-0.56670743227005,
0.1449100226163864,
-0.1848783642053604,
-0.6605601906776428,
0.3837501108646393,
-0.3042484521865845,
0.33163949847221375,
-0.013768315315246582,
-0.11498040705919266,
0.6686292886734009,
0.18610252439975739,
1.0114526748657227,
0.06969005614519119,
-0.06886887550354004,
-0.3248596489429474,
-0.011747628450393677,
0.1279110610485077,
0.1723000407218933,
0.12615111470222473,
0.3310074806213379,
0.38265061378479004,
-0.22731854021549225,
-0.4126027226448059,
0.6214564442634583,
-0.8059514760971069,
-0.6562159061431885,
-0.6576471328735352,
-0.407861590385437,
-0.3621893525123596,
0.3809133768081665,
0.21097446978092194,
0.42305904626846313,
-0.17560581862926483,
-0.35030460357666016,
0.7823245525360107,
-0.5364611148834229,
0.12477994710206985,
0.5659494400024414,
-0.12823905050754547,
0.014355228282511234,
0.71426922082901,
0.048098184168338776,
0.19710133969783783,
0.17346912622451782,
0.3519861698150635,
-0.20149768888950348,
-0.8871739506721497,
-0.24421916902065277,
0.4613944888114929,
-0.7234289050102234,
-0.06108937785029411,
-0.5043430924415588,
-0.3342350721359253,
-0.3893600106239319,
-0.186802476644516,
-0.21872569620609283,
-0.20128431916236877,
-0.7336604595184326,
0.004999338649213314,
0.3441442847251892,
1.3067848682403564,
0.05481753498315811,
0.08776694536209106,
-0.9181525707244873,
0.5987443327903748,
0.1910473257303238,
0.4677606523036957,
-0.25250503420829773,
-0.16621308028697968,
0.05830826982855797,
0.0755099505186081,
-0.4326789975166321,
-0.8144552707672119,
0.38798338174819946,
-0.16638091206550598,
0.655900776386261,
0.6389314532279968,
-0.024546930566430092,
0.5124471783638,
-0.2134423851966858,
0.9478033781051636,
0.41691651940345764,
-1.0313241481781006,
0.44152024388313293,
-0.4615999460220337,
0.060722701251506805,
0.01870393007993698,
0.8026288747787476,
-0.8043431043624878,
-0.14861704409122467,
-0.7810182571411133,
-0.5814811587333679,
0.2735174596309662,
-0.30098745226860046,
-0.05877358466386795,
-0.125285342335701,
0.5467607378959656,
0.03956272825598717,
-0.18735921382904053,
-0.46475949883461,
-0.24592259526252747,
0.002970714820548892,
-0.6894122362136841,
-0.09463126212358475,
-0.11949869245290756,
-0.3840539753437042,
-0.4449654817581177,
0.18297913670539856,
-0.05760738626122475,
0.6519085168838501,
0.4045493006706238,
0.32973915338516235,
-0.013269464485347271,
0.14967752993106842,
0.6727662682533264,
0.8339378833770752,
0.05155613645911217,
0.08115863054990768,
-0.06622543931007385,
-0.6353146433830261,
0.10620413720607758,
0.28541040420532227,
-0.03235001862049103,
-0.07837832719087601,
0.1597880870103836,
0.41742268204689026,
-0.049355391412973404,
-0.6187957525253296,
0.6372194886207581,
-0.08598515391349792,
-0.2563605010509491,
-0.3935807943344116,
-0.039554987102746964,
0.31993210315704346,
0.39656364917755127,
0.09690819680690765,
-0.13937360048294067,
0.3653649389743805,
-0.6154417395591736,
0.1774047315120697,
0.468557208776474,
-0.22521020472049713,
-0.35701170563697815,
0.6255138516426086,
0.3041320741176605,
-0.39898186922073364,
0.7585137486457825,
-0.0011771897552534938,
-0.41772177815437317,
0.7015491724014282,
0.5972711443901062,
0.4489476978778839,
-0.28336235880851746,
0.056881487369537354,
-0.04977400228381157,
0.26651203632354736,
-0.3745666444301605,
0.41445478796958923,
0.38036808371543884,
-0.6955570578575134,
-0.29637855291366577,
-0.20591294765472412,
-0.5436117649078369,
0.24451576173305511,
-0.5358573794364929,
0.40182381868362427,
-0.5663285851478577,
-0.49809175729751587,
0.06568209826946259,
0.1481722742319107,
-0.6932193636894226,
0.3752017021179199,
0.37587273120880127,
0.6460728645324707,
-0.6273714900016785,
0.7000029683113098,
0.5754124522209167,
-0.20237483084201813,
-0.6747161746025085,
-0.0030001671984791756,
0.4809662997722626,
-1.1360458135604858,
0.4708783030509949,
0.09583543241024017,
0.27985087037086487,
0.08215838670730591,
-0.21832482516765594,
-0.7507665753364563,
1.3005399703979492,
0.39590808749198914,
-0.601829469203949,
-0.30665042996406555,
0.09206163138151169,
0.5959787368774414,
-0.29052746295928955,
0.2692413628101349,
0.763763427734375,
0.5186116695404053,
-0.0527227483689785,
-1.433122992515564,
0.18473181128501892,
-0.08244853466749191,
-0.24048110842704773,
0.3333415687084198,
-0.30385708808898926,
0.8318696618080139,
-0.5259663462638855,
-0.2498548924922943,
0.02436881512403488,
-0.3057660758495331,
0.3386532962322235,
0.6448330283164978,
0.018701791763305664,
0.5433500409126282,
1.15725839138031,
-0.231608584523201,
1.5572175979614258,
-0.22092357277870178,
0.07058693468570709,
0.4598409831523895,
-0.18942025303840637,
0.33574196696281433,
0.2106676548719406,
-0.3536999225616455,
0.18145684897899628,
0.9829281568527222,
0.13243167102336884,
0.1618252694606781,
0.2526739537715912,
-0.5639492869377136,
-0.06355403363704681,
-0.014651931822299957,
-0.5618977546691895,
0.2039652317762375,
0.7776538729667664,
-0.6147364377975464,
0.006568798795342445,
-0.09611336141824722,
-0.07353481650352478,
-0.2523617148399353,
-0.35728907585144043,
0.6716979146003723,
0.32376062870025635,
-0.14265471696853638,
0.4640251696109772,
0.010628953576087952,
0.5664647221565247,
-0.5051296949386597,
-0.04965243488550186,
0.028489865362644196,
0.10978318750858307,
-0.34095463156700134,
-0.5758890509605408,
0.44430336356163025,
-0.04930197447538376,
-0.16254498064517975,
-0.1756286323070526,
0.5920746922492981,
0.24579957127571106,
-0.5056161880493164,
0.293567955493927,
0.4438539743423462,
0.4019971489906311,
-0.21112053096294403,
-0.7417930960655212,
0.16392862796783447,
-0.07124399393796921,
-0.05833769962191582,
0.2916824221611023,
0.2289518415927887,
-0.1517793834209442,
0.8559741973876953,
0.6487212181091309,
0.5379911661148071,
-0.04828943312168121,
0.19758976995944977,
0.6367142200469971,
-0.897226095199585,
-0.15710900723934174,
-0.8125039339065552,
0.4248332381248474,
-0.005787396803498268,
-0.08961395919322968,
0.23447611927986145,
0.12468469887971878,
0.5407504439353943,
0.05341915041208267,
1.1130504608154297,
0.29194867610931396,
0.6702972650527954,
-0.43344059586524963,
0.622572660446167,
-0.45060428977012634,
0.37133345007896423,
0.03565416857600212,
-0.36882609128952026,
-0.6299635767936707,
0.42433109879493713,
-0.42027345299720764,
0.18339592218399048,
0.8053850531578064,
0.4161073863506317,
0.09619907289743423,
-0.1050092950463295,
0.41058021783828735,
0.2001541554927826,
0.520073652267456,
0.6161583662033081,
0.7956729531288147,
-0.23642459511756897,
0.09033151715993881,
-0.09910938888788223,
-0.3539237976074219,
-0.27432534098625183,
-0.8064659237861633,
-0.5823408961296082,
-0.34985026717185974,
-0.2913724482059479,
-0.27268263697624207,
0.18354681134223938,
0.8633333444595337,
0.65667325258255,
-0.6527994275093079,
0.10222451388835907,
0.012799304910004139,
0.06238383427262306,
-0.32362228631973267,
-0.2150505781173706,
0.16540983319282532,
0.10209214687347412,
-0.5767866373062134,
0.2921576201915741,
0.35597237944602966,
0.5755938291549683,
-0.07241359353065491,
-0.01951097697019577,
0.4197981655597687,
-0.21944132447242737,
0.5560787320137024,
0.17305703461170197,
-0.8411968946456909,
-0.10860003530979156,
0.07733351737260818,
-0.2188013643026352,
0.030042128637433052,
0.8074233531951904,
-0.54019695520401,
0.3760475218296051,
0.1746981143951416,
0.6815356016159058,
0.3739820122718811,
-0.024202508851885796,
0.6864558458328247,
0.12532736361026764,
-0.19683627784252167,
0.6130360960960388,
0.41909828782081604,
0.34054335951805115,
-0.8538841009140015,
0.2856009900569916,
0.44409504532814026,
-0.5439085364341736,
-0.5525568127632141,
0.19736286997795105,
-1.0390681028366089,
-0.19397500157356262,
1.092079758644104,
0.009899512864649296,
0.15018029510974884,
-0.6598919630050659,
-0.055908165872097015,
0.09113197028636932,
-0.2069656401872635,
1.1285191774368286,
0.4895288050174713,
-0.6832885146141052,
-0.0577264167368412,
-0.9299120903015137,
0.5007622241973877,
0.03585353121161461,
-0.901583194732666,
-0.3382790982723236,
0.35986167192459106,
0.5911735892295837,
-0.08841454237699509,
1.0038559436798096,
-0.49878209829330444,
0.4910100996494293,
-0.2569599747657776,
-0.05005587637424469,
-0.10291144996881485,
0.002803120296448469,
-0.2941246032714844,
-0.2675761580467224,
0.25418251752853394,
-0.09412572532892227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05777v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05777v1
|
Towards a More Inclusive AI: Progress and Perspectives in Large Language Model Training for the Sámi Language
| 2024-05-09T13:54:22 | 2024-05-09T13:54:22 |
Ronny Paul, Himanshu Buckchash, Shantipriya Parida, Dilip K. Prasad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
S\'ami, an indigenous language group comprising multiple languages, faces
digital marginalization due to the limited availability of data and
sophisticated language models designed for its linguistic intricacies. This
work focuses on increasing technological participation for the S\'ami language.
We draw the attention of the ML community towards the language modeling problem
of Ultra Low Resource (ULR) languages. ULR languages are those for which the
amount of available textual resources is very low, and the speaker count for
them is also very low. ULRLs are also not supported by mainstream Large
Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT, due to which gathering artificial training
data for them becomes even more challenging. Mainstream AI foundational model
development has given less attention to this category of languages. Generally,
these languages have very few speakers, making it hard to find them. However,
it is important to develop foundational models for these ULR languages to
promote inclusion and the tangible abilities and impact of LLMs. To this end,
we have compiled the available S\'ami language resources from the web to create
a clean dataset for training language models. In order to study the behavior of
modern LLM models with ULR languages (S\'ami), we have experimented with
different kinds of LLMs, mainly at the order of $\sim$ seven billion
parameters. We have also explored the effect of multilingual LLM training for
ULRLs. We found that the decoder-only models under a sequential multilingual
training scenario perform better than joint multilingual training, whereas
multilingual training with high semantic overlap, in general, performs better
than training from scratch.This is the first study on the S\'ami language for
adapting non-statistical language models that use the latest developments in
the field of natural language processing (NLP).
|
[
-0.2618103325366974,
-0.4478292167186737,
0.22298026084899902,
-0.02396821416914463,
-0.08672700822353363,
0.1526138335466385,
-0.5133523941040039,
-0.5836204886436462,
0.09252321720123291,
0.40504175424575806,
-0.3465571999549866,
-0.26310551166534424,
-0.6068165302276611,
0.26197749376296997,
-0.2685036063194275,
1.0371934175491333,
0.11059070378541946,
0.4599395990371704,
-0.11728977411985397,
-0.451629102230072,
-0.24641111493110657,
-0.5364044904708862,
-0.559352457523346,
-0.22073650360107422,
0.4391356110572815,
0.4713027775287628,
0.525738000869751,
0.7597686052322388,
0.4208770990371704,
0.36906111240386963,
-0.15704672038555145,
-0.32757583260536194,
-0.2248222529888153,
0.14267534017562866,
-0.10851744562387466,
-0.5608429908752441,
-0.5128624439239502,
-0.24697744846343994,
0.9838386178016663,
0.7611139416694641,
-0.2944371700286865,
0.2439950406551361,
0.08102070540189743,
0.5604344010353088,
-0.42949947714805603,
0.031117580831050873,
-0.7104230523109436,
-0.1736522912979126,
-0.3631800413131714,
0.536012589931488,
-0.21939830482006073,
-0.05533548444509506,
-0.17685328423976898,
-0.3545018434524536,
-0.02583526074886322,
-0.004252657759934664,
0.47215139865875244,
0.30618277192115784,
-0.4218537509441376,
-0.24800503253936768,
-0.8015479445457458,
1.0193157196044922,
-0.7842473387718201,
0.7473399639129639,
0.48245349526405334,
0.10769703984260559,
-0.135427325963974,
-0.21496085822582245,
-0.6985646486282349,
-0.4476070702075958,
0.32708051800727844,
-0.02455615997314453,
-0.14675568044185638,
0.0973583534359932,
0.17153659462928772,
0.25286364555358887,
-0.47002893686294556,
0.7011977434158325,
-0.3613947331905365,
0.12456150352954865,
0.9114590287208557,
0.17764605581760406,
0.24984021484851837,
-0.10851730406284332,
-0.331163614988327,
0.19770576059818268,
-0.8484464883804321,
-0.14057764410972595,
0.3822401463985443,
0.4219711422920227,
-0.3428219258785248,
0.6143428087234497,
-0.11723989248275757,
0.4915282726287842,
-0.4287438988685608,
-0.2659745216369629,
0.009151074104011059,
-0.18524767458438873,
-0.11748331785202026,
-0.17977868020534515,
0.6039366722106934,
-0.11449054628610611,
0.15119194984436035,
0.013686749152839184,
-0.4051787257194519,
0.2112760692834854,
-0.20508083701133728,
-0.43040451407432556,
0.10790745168924332,
-0.09205245226621628,
-0.5209260582923889,
0.10635200142860413,
-0.6714615225791931,
-0.558485209941864,
-0.4654797613620758,
-0.4642448425292969,
0.09675662219524384,
-0.46322545409202576,
-0.4225672483444214,
-0.09684466570615768,
0.27549588680267334,
0.41549184918403625,
0.39675483107566833,
-1.0090360641479492,
0.27857890725135803,
0.5040754079818726,
0.467013955116272,
0.032454635947942734,
-0.5459508299827576,
-0.13704022765159607,
0.13433991372585297,
-0.0927974283695221,
0.9417708516120911,
-0.5947352051734924,
-0.3614908754825592,
-0.006130286492407322,
-0.3166539967060089,
-0.2172761708498001,
-0.2990180552005768,
0.41319093108177185,
-0.5198870301246643,
-0.040416643023490906,
-0.09861593693494797,
-0.6206156611442566,
-0.12692368030548096,
0.15775586664676666,
-0.5576329231262207,
1.1161987781524658,
0.20068402588367462,
-0.5361660718917847,
0.12244116514921188,
-0.8462938070297241,
-0.32511743903160095,
0.4068632423877716,
-0.424858957529068,
-0.16030099987983704,
0.12524230778217316,
-0.007939562201499939,
0.43415671586990356,
-0.6103312373161316,
0.3246694803237915,
-0.24421405792236328,
-0.19972479343414307,
0.23482264578342438,
-0.499228298664093,
0.9064527750015259,
0.2967856526374817,
-0.20438829064369202,
0.03935769572854042,
-0.6913859248161316,
-0.3029550313949585,
0.16674920916557312,
-0.45662370324134827,
-0.37053072452545166,
-0.06840089708566666,
0.21262265741825104,
0.25294339656829834,
0.2687714695930481,
-0.6650062799453735,
0.23125743865966797,
-0.11078310012817383,
0.26803427934646606,
1.0225330591201782,
-0.6250049471855164,
0.6439477801322937,
-0.1659386307001114,
0.5115174055099487,
-0.250640869140625,
0.21444231271743774,
-0.22057011723518372,
-0.36866796016693115,
-1.1064509153366089,
-0.396188348531723,
0.6842514276504517,
0.577440083026886,
-0.8334650993347168,
0.517639696598053,
-0.33615604043006897,
-0.28584036231040955,
-0.98929363489151,
0.3044024407863617,
0.37923723459243774,
0.15023063123226166,
-0.01568816602230072,
-0.3400549292564392,
-0.6080087423324585,
-0.8816652894020081,
0.003136663930490613,
-0.2516682744026184,
-0.20724698901176453,
0.1247871145606041,
0.6620975136756897,
-0.4563523232936859,
0.6015393137931824,
0.19424189627170563,
-0.24643458425998688,
-0.8173121213912964,
-0.14565755426883698,
0.06073940172791481,
0.42321309447288513,
0.3477996587753296,
-0.6088635325431824,
-0.5686891078948975,
0.16902509331703186,
-0.765532374382019,
0.1590128093957901,
0.20790381729602814,
0.13888026773929596,
0.5605407357215881,
0.3927881717681885,
-0.4821614623069763,
0.47269269824028015,
0.7341662049293518,
-0.13111768662929535,
0.28571537137031555,
-0.14990761876106262,
-0.04394383728504181,
-1.073740005493164,
0.03583608567714691,
-0.018259165808558464,
0.0820419043302536,
-0.7474045753479004,
0.20205871760845184,
-0.15597255527973175,
-0.2655007541179657,
-0.5144085884094238,
0.7984219193458557,
-0.5055992603302002,
-0.3899259865283966,
-0.3257668912410736,
0.10155981779098511,
-0.5333467125892639,
0.5790675282478333,
0.22333356738090515,
0.6950240731239319,
0.7391072511672974,
-0.6770350933074951,
0.17823290824890137,
0.31455540657043457,
-0.32358694076538086,
0.6464688181877136,
-0.5219934582710266,
0.12203047424554825,
-0.35743817687034607,
0.258337140083313,
-0.681806743144989,
-0.32483574748039246,
-0.008627653121948242,
-0.3093746304512024,
0.38404595851898193,
-0.14325948059558868,
-0.3710944950580597,
-0.08513475954532623,
-0.18698112666606903,
0.6537366509437561,
0.5577119588851929,
-0.3119350075721741,
0.6586959362030029,
0.7139999270439148,
-0.47945621609687805,
-0.6042532920837402,
-0.5670980215072632,
0.1293303668498993,
-0.1620059758424759,
-0.6738869547843933,
-0.05718579143285751,
-0.24805836379528046,
-0.31338801980018616,
-0.10327588021755219,
0.22117245197296143,
-0.01335214078426361,
0.19330137968063354,
-0.0866752341389656,
0.3092269003391266,
-0.33372077345848083,
0.15535932779312134,
-0.11291372776031494,
-0.33865979313850403,
-0.4160493314266205,
-0.11055880784988403,
0.7064714431762695,
-0.35733580589294434,
-0.5843616127967834,
-0.6163188219070435,
0.7127907276153564,
0.3953148126602173,
-0.315029114484787,
0.8732370138168335,
0.4832662343978882,
-0.44459739327430725,
0.08165142685174942,
-0.6161286234855652,
0.05021711438894272,
-0.4256070852279663,
0.5755900144577026,
-0.1656600832939148,
-1.1211777925491333,
0.7298008799552917,
0.04674651101231575,
0.24333596229553223,
0.4444006383419037,
0.5419889688491821,
-0.17768242955207825,
1.1592473983764648,
1.0602829456329346,
-0.4000909626483917,
0.6953321099281311,
-0.2752749025821686,
0.0845131203532219,
-1.1321003437042236,
-0.23201382160186768,
-0.7311561703681946,
-0.231561079621315,
-0.7495348453521729,
-0.1890726238489151,
0.3866921365261078,
0.0014900529058650136,
-0.4587800204753876,
0.21856766939163208,
-0.010103624314069748,
0.42664581537246704,
0.7056078314781189,
-0.2575088143348694,
0.2325674593448639,
-0.016812022775411606,
0.19166572391986847,
0.0044138869270682335,
-1.0857356786727905,
-0.4903474450111389,
1.161943793296814,
0.5380297899246216,
0.8806847333908081,
0.08830815553665161,
0.6063749194145203,
0.31176215410232544,
0.4492725729942322,
-0.6032600998878479,
0.5747453570365906,
-0.28975939750671387,
-0.6541659235954285,
-0.4414523243904114,
-0.28471192717552185,
-0.9545660018920898,
0.21723198890686035,
-0.3100275695323944,
-0.6222281455993652,
0.05998659133911133,
-0.11022156476974487,
-0.25134706497192383,
0.4947753846645355,
-0.34212103486061096,
0.4543296694755554,
-0.4831939935684204,
-0.1231398656964302,
-0.19416777789592743,
-0.7679568529129028,
0.2392350733280182,
0.015345720574259758,
0.6358509659767151,
-0.3330616056919098,
0.07083068788051605,
0.8028467893600464,
-0.08122983574867249,
0.8907572031021118,
0.12015998363494873,
-0.17789262533187866,
0.21421323716640472,
-0.04795239865779877,
0.6028084754943848,
-0.22218890488147736,
-0.3415237069129944,
0.49533572793006897,
-0.4980506896972656,
-0.7854297161102295,
-0.21654288470745087,
0.5299325585365295,
-0.9709027409553528,
-0.5041993856430054,
-0.4470902979373932,
-0.694389283657074,
0.04040654003620148,
0.10974658280611038,
0.23951277136802673,
0.20197376608848572,
-0.1547475904226303,
0.09314922243356705,
0.6533164381980896,
-0.18907101452350616,
0.6023995280265808,
0.554243266582489,
-0.010713373310863972,
-0.4501153528690338,
0.8237287402153015,
0.16391220688819885,
0.24295789003372192,
0.04192589595913887,
-0.03654409945011139,
-0.33799347281455994,
-0.723823070526123,
-0.7866998910903931,
0.39490920305252075,
-0.6087068319320679,
-0.3610365390777588,
-0.5692753791809082,
-0.44323423504829407,
-0.4302184581756592,
-0.11415152996778488,
-0.46531903743743896,
-0.42283326387405396,
-0.11630292981863022,
0.05883205682039261,
0.39290568232536316,
1.0073438882827759,
-0.18716134130954742,
0.6715148091316223,
-0.9399319291114807,
-0.006759267300367355,
0.09105555713176727,
0.49973854422569275,
0.0061765373684465885,
-0.6373675465583801,
-0.5197613835334778,
0.16425900161266327,
0.009440802969038486,
-0.5371025800704956,
0.20277981460094452,
0.30183762311935425,
0.7502790093421936,
0.31962594389915466,
-0.053053710609674454,
0.4232902526855469,
-0.4721498191356659,
0.8327498435974121,
0.27993860840797424,
-0.8612728714942932,
0.3544120788574219,
-0.4313284456729889,
0.005059476010501385,
0.5253261923789978,
0.2733551859855652,
-0.7903470396995544,
-0.3819258213043213,
-0.6281960010528564,
-0.8068237900733948,
0.9009707570075989,
0.2079710215330124,
0.40013641119003296,
0.07549059391021729,
0.1286468654870987,
0.3154870271682739,
0.2369614839553833,
-1.0611562728881836,
-0.16376811265945435,
0.16611209511756897,
-0.2839401662349701,
0.028256045654416084,
-0.3167989253997803,
0.20241522789001465,
-0.2578590512275696,
0.8206821084022522,
0.03159373998641968,
0.3783144950866699,
-0.32992449402809143,
-0.17582951486110687,
-0.13446949422359467,
0.4275699853897095,
0.35429221391677856,
0.341289222240448,
0.24274961650371552,
0.017399802803993225,
0.5233588814735413,
-0.26402562856674194,
0.136269673705101,
0.0772964209318161,
-0.3538297414779663,
-0.15279227495193481,
0.4030475914478302,
0.9899251461029053,
0.14500628411769867,
-0.7185491323471069,
0.3775407373905182,
-0.04026102274656296,
0.11308839172124863,
-0.41014203429222107,
0.05873352661728859,
-0.1358366161584854,
0.3636721074581146,
0.16924093663692474,
0.05396182835102081,
-0.022700650617480278,
-0.5412107706069946,
-0.08276757597923279,
0.5392428636550903,
-0.31398552656173706,
-0.4455721974372864,
0.6607281565666199,
0.47620177268981934,
-0.5188705325126648,
0.9313743114471436,
-0.12262333929538727,
-0.6296400427818298,
0.40502381324768066,
0.7296012043952942,
0.621122419834137,
-0.728169322013855,
0.2253129780292511,
0.08948012441396713,
0.4310937523841858,
-0.02714614011347294,
0.28384923934936523,
-0.06533604860305786,
-0.7662172913551331,
-0.37533897161483765,
-0.7417829036712646,
-0.3301996886730194,
0.17781759798526764,
-0.40709587931632996,
0.3265177011489868,
-0.22947031259536743,
0.1268659085035324,
-0.3665935695171356,
-0.08282676339149475,
-0.8010354042053223,
0.0737379714846611,
0.372316837310791,
0.8524199724197388,
-1.0984770059585571,
0.8016200661659241,
0.778855562210083,
-0.4929860234260559,
-0.47977447509765625,
-0.29185763001441956,
-0.2188466191291809,
-0.9456431865692139,
0.2644369304180145,
-0.06487034261226654,
0.061109039932489395,
0.06448300182819366,
-0.6319862008094788,
-1.1359317302703857,
0.929943323135376,
0.5178933143615723,
-0.3559788763523102,
0.12321954220533371,
0.3420291841030121,
0.5547845959663391,
-0.41803693771362305,
0.31961876153945923,
0.5728124380111694,
0.25638341903686523,
0.04973357170820236,
-0.9677472710609436,
-0.29088687896728516,
-0.42387261986732483,
0.3211999237537384,
0.3282754421234131,
-0.8363387584686279,
0.9782717227935791,
-0.14961865544319153,
-0.15880292654037476,
0.39749273657798767,
0.8199813961982727,
0.40673965215682983,
0.31544116139411926,
0.3763030767440796,
0.39525043964385986,
0.647274911403656,
0.11713825911283493,
1.0941157341003418,
-0.10057612508535385,
0.06472965329885483,
0.8082415461540222,
-0.5203587412834167,
0.9653821587562561,
0.3534318506717682,
-0.3519022464752197,
0.40418851375579834,
0.6222827434539795,
0.2351001650094986,
0.23158042132854462,
0.1863817274570465,
-0.6344525814056396,
-0.19225405156612396,
-0.5634157061576843,
-0.4249463677406311,
0.6301945447921753,
0.47298866510391235,
-0.0498247928917408,
-0.20882059633731842,
0.21280096471309662,
0.015859507024288177,
0.06752540916204453,
-0.5457689762115479,
0.7895246744155884,
0.1012347862124443,
-0.20858769118785858,
0.30550679564476013,
0.23636828362941742,
0.8511642217636108,
-0.6597225666046143,
0.1139029711484909,
-0.5281786918640137,
-0.026795513927936554,
0.015847081318497658,
-0.5580797791481018,
0.12004846334457397,
0.36238595843315125,
0.043194495141506195,
-0.056470904499292374,
0.7165543437004089,
-0.5535829663276672,
-0.7014323472976685,
0.2539900243282318,
0.6228327751159668,
0.49180924892425537,
0.37421345710754395,
-0.5988250374794006,
0.14456266164779663,
0.023401543498039246,
-0.002648853464052081,
0.554246723651886,
0.3824770450592041,
-0.36164042353630066,
0.7161127328872681,
0.7375579476356506,
0.10680996626615524,
0.05828075110912323,
0.013225451111793518,
0.9380885362625122,
-0.6509214043617249,
-0.49648618698120117,
-0.600410521030426,
0.7090412974357605,
0.14223690330982208,
-0.2835324704647064,
0.5931566953659058,
0.38894543051719666,
0.9845572710037231,
0.03976533189415932,
0.9956364035606384,
-0.17542977631092072,
0.36300262808799744,
-0.44789808988571167,
0.813495934009552,
-0.5165829062461853,
0.4014069736003876,
-0.05927843600511551,
-1.1023890972137451,
-0.3566548824310303,
0.6841773986816406,
-0.0069255586713552475,
0.20956891775131226,
0.13414187729358673,
0.44037458300590515,
-0.0737684890627861,
0.13181762397289276,
0.3372495472431183,
0.11855166405439377,
0.05062884837388992,
0.42463746666908264,
1.147402048110962,
-0.3904860317707062,
0.26157599687576294,
-0.1339813470840454,
-0.38132691383361816,
-0.12895655632019043,
-0.7189006209373474,
-0.7748476266860962,
-0.6523236036300659,
-0.08247852325439453,
0.05794469639658928,
-0.020118655636906624,
1.1624265909194946,
0.3933448791503906,
-0.8262547850608826,
-0.5754889845848083,
0.04410475492477417,
0.3362616300582886,
0.16800536215305328,
-0.0668865218758583,
0.3040017783641815,
-0.14291954040527344,
-0.7917337417602539,
0.3879924714565277,
0.22792302072048187,
0.20483845472335815,
-0.3329232931137085,
-0.31874868273735046,
-0.350626140832901,
0.055252693593502045,
0.661985456943512,
0.4687233865261078,
-0.5689480304718018,
-0.108751580119133,
0.15353906154632568,
0.05196978524327278,
0.04244508594274521,
0.5471054315567017,
-0.48090678453445435,
0.14291784167289734,
0.13879527151584625,
0.6578179001808167,
0.27636250853538513,
-0.438692569732666,
0.43562012910842896,
-0.6819571852684021,
0.37588953971862793,
0.30884483456611633,
0.4401758015155792,
0.5664905309677124,
-0.19138005375862122,
0.5643189549446106,
0.053749263286590576,
-0.6424497365951538,
-1.0951613187789917,
0.4688534140586853,
-0.4122101068496704,
0.03172570466995239,
1.2330831289291382,
-0.06223570555448532,
-0.264340877532959,
-0.2705015242099762,
-0.14340072870254517,
0.4283776879310608,
-0.3734068274497986,
0.8273280262947083,
0.42736753821372986,
-0.386202335357666,
-0.12713491916656494,
-0.41768205165863037,
0.3231194019317627,
0.38789695501327515,
-0.7854741215705872,
0.1442980319261551,
0.39061325788497925,
0.12016554921865463,
-0.008442445658147335,
0.9200724363327026,
0.029756715521216393,
0.1366019994020462,
0.045832183212041855,
0.42966413497924805,
0.22917085886001587,
-0.539142370223999,
-0.7944487929344177,
-0.5450111031532288,
0.2601587176322937,
-0.027465786784887314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05776v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05776v1
|
Experimental Pragmatics with Machines: Testing LLM Predictions for the Inferences of Plain and Embedded Disjunctions
| 2024-05-09T13:54:15 | 2024-05-09T13:54:15 |
Polina Tsvilodub, Paul Marty, Sonia Ramotowska, Jacopo Romoli, Michael Franke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Human communication is based on a variety of inferences that we draw from
sentences, often going beyond what is literally said. While there is wide
agreement on the basic distinction between entailment, implicature, and
presupposition, the status of many inferences remains controversial. In this
paper, we focus on three inferences of plain and embedded disjunctions, and
compare them with regular scalar implicatures. We investigate this comparison
from the novel perspective of the predictions of state-of-the-art large
language models, using the same experimental paradigms as recent studies
investigating the same inferences with humans. The results of our best
performing models mostly align with those of humans, both in the large
differences we find between those inferences and implicatures, as well as in
fine-grained distinctions among different aspects of those inferences.
|
[
-0.49034884572029114,
-1.352586269378662,
0.6703718900680542,
0.24515338242053986,
-0.2313368171453476,
-0.24957825243473053,
-0.18771669268608093,
-0.468456894159317,
-0.0036928036715835333,
0.4356948435306549,
-0.3195525109767914,
-0.13154056668281555,
-0.48067447543144226,
0.4337676763534546,
-0.5657951235771179,
0.6508790850639343,
-0.2311941683292389,
0.013168140314519405,
-0.5819360017776489,
0.0234704427421093,
-0.09019962698221207,
-0.565220057964325,
-0.1410943567752838,
-0.25594818592071533,
0.5474879145622253,
0.3043542504310608,
1.0074325799942017,
0.495881050825119,
0.5300748348236084,
0.46728524565696716,
-0.2247217297554016,
0.1943223625421524,
0.09399497509002686,
0.21522833406925201,
-0.22462736070156097,
-0.6820921897888184,
0.16170306503772736,
0.3922001123428345,
0.6256410479545593,
0.8547738194465637,
-0.006644843146204948,
-0.2475205808877945,
0.15019570291042328,
0.3656574785709381,
-0.6478445529937744,
-0.03213772922754288,
-0.5515178442001343,
0.09959818422794342,
0.11166855692863464,
0.13516414165496826,
-0.4403901696205139,
-0.5450242161750793,
0.1340218335390091,
-0.3467954695224762,
0.12705717980861664,
0.29270243644714355,
1.0998989343643188,
0.4814874529838562,
-0.6137511134147644,
-0.49040985107421875,
-0.716099739074707,
0.710676908493042,
-0.9932548403739929,
0.4409390389919281,
0.5378695726394653,
0.3844143748283386,
-0.44186222553253174,
-1.0220181941986084,
-1.082636833190918,
-1.0281847715377808,
-0.39194250106811523,
0.0639442428946495,
-0.24179047346115112,
0.30305829644203186,
0.4540107548236847,
0.29794445633888245,
-0.515449583530426,
0.39450764656066895,
-0.1579841822385788,
0.0050251600332558155,
0.5083707571029663,
-0.03644156828522682,
0.06242534890770912,
-0.004298131912946701,
-0.3312780559062958,
0.08043119311332703,
-0.8697717189788818,
-0.24549676477909088,
0.36299437284469604,
-0.09869998693466187,
-0.08455590903759003,
0.6894240379333496,
-0.30131369829177856,
0.8533757925033569,
0.07923068106174469,
0.027530252933502197,
0.08062490820884705,
-0.3154270648956299,
-0.5868962407112122,
-0.2651872932910919,
0.7561299800872803,
0.2953084409236908,
0.4891913831233978,
-0.21461665630340576,
-0.026084350422024727,
0.5034525394439697,
0.03865189850330353,
-0.4509393870830536,
-0.17676663398742676,
0.2415882647037506,
-0.2559560537338257,
-0.06329494714736938,
0.15448161959648132,
-0.5019834637641907,
-0.5609045028686523,
-0.4378192126750946,
0.39095041155815125,
-0.3429756760597229,
-0.05849149823188782,
0.20517364144325256,
-0.1517401486635208,
0.278589129447937,
0.35389941930770874,
-0.5163421630859375,
0.41415783762931824,
0.814752995967865,
0.5029387474060059,
-0.18426261842250824,
-0.6294834017753601,
-0.4319491684436798,
-0.1463128924369812,
-0.41226616501808167,
0.9594798684120178,
-0.49866199493408203,
-0.25615638494491577,
-0.05636211112141609,
0.07631328701972961,
-0.11963410675525665,
-0.7502643465995789,
0.7803587913513184,
-0.13634604215621948,
0.20599444210529327,
-0.0722220316529274,
-0.7970098853111267,
-0.31495916843414307,
0.007399748079478741,
-0.448892205953598,
0.622560441493988,
-0.11677634716033936,
-0.7891626358032227,
0.3038910925388336,
-0.506763756275177,
-0.6314229965209961,
-0.08624149858951569,
-0.33897721767425537,
-0.33195874094963074,
0.24873967468738556,
-0.29967549443244934,
0.5492067337036133,
-0.303544819355011,
0.48730331659317017,
-0.6034389734268188,
-0.42286673188209534,
1.0219255685806274,
-0.4971543848514557,
0.4838919937610626,
0.4033045172691345,
-0.5760121941566467,
0.16429217159748077,
-0.45205143094062805,
-0.25424453616142273,
-0.04886522516608238,
-0.10225164890289307,
-0.34170013666152954,
0.4115913212299347,
-0.4453553259372711,
0.22765418887138367,
0.027626099064946175,
-0.5634193420410156,
0.03593665361404419,
-0.3314370810985565,
0.7701196670532227,
0.6362476944923401,
-0.20067830383777618,
0.4529770314693451,
-0.346370667219162,
0.25238797068595886,
0.31282520294189453,
0.20067542791366577,
-0.07088019698858261,
-0.5399423837661743,
-0.8125490546226501,
-0.4132378101348877,
0.39573976397514343,
0.4150103032588959,
-0.48956364393234253,
0.20539236068725586,
0.107301265001297,
-0.343877911567688,
-0.5135447382926941,
-0.15657156705856323,
0.549297571182251,
0.5370444059371948,
0.07609730958938599,
0.1082831397652626,
-0.512412965297699,
-1.3945854902267456,
-0.5601456165313721,
-0.20824800431728363,
-0.15595601499080658,
0.29802602529525757,
0.6970488429069519,
-0.22320334613323212,
0.9687808156013489,
-0.3084337115287781,
0.5409998893737793,
-0.22721552848815918,
0.35534974932670593,
0.06328672915697098,
0.3761518895626068,
0.2854677736759186,
-1.0814716815948486,
-0.38697782158851624,
-0.219533309340477,
-0.7303891777992249,
0.009822980500757694,
-0.12363962084054947,
0.09113866835832596,
0.1948201060295105,
0.3802286386489868,
-0.7376840114593506,
0.7027076482772827,
0.5462664365768433,
-0.3831644058227539,
0.6600629687309265,
-0.3390495479106903,
0.20388852059841156,
-0.7588058114051819,
-0.48545458912849426,
0.2886228561401367,
-0.29992616176605225,
-0.6110389828681946,
0.08210734277963638,
0.1955520659685135,
0.4025307297706604,
-0.6029749512672424,
0.33901962637901306,
-0.4973996579647064,
-0.2973070740699768,
-0.24672925472259521,
0.13996921479701996,
0.054327670484781265,
0.18835942447185516,
0.06758446991443634,
0.8623642325401306,
0.4562702476978302,
-0.8781077861785889,
0.22724755108356476,
0.10762617737054825,
-0.4636833965778351,
0.2991119623184204,
-0.9153040051460266,
0.2494034320116043,
-0.20012317597866058,
0.4414631128311157,
-1.1184437274932861,
-0.33449169993400574,
0.21116089820861816,
-0.35600075125694275,
0.03906881809234619,
0.1278979331254959,
-0.9936583638191223,
-0.3725872039794922,
-0.1498912125825882,
-0.01439175195991993,
0.7364138960838318,
-0.2558463513851166,
0.2290991097688675,
0.40017205476760864,
-0.02041579969227314,
-0.29986852407455444,
-0.9197237491607666,
0.1805562674999237,
-0.4897286593914032,
-0.5430876612663269,
0.180825874209404,
-0.08256425708532333,
-1.0220955610275269,
-0.256960928440094,
0.023307982832193375,
-0.29686081409454346,
0.4687948524951935,
0.535563588142395,
0.2650306224822998,
-0.37467342615127563,
-0.022033311426639557,
0.045405130833387375,
0.1599281132221222,
-0.09198709577322006,
-0.09879026561975479,
0.18634410202503204,
-0.35077449679374695,
-0.7018429636955261,
-0.48814818263053894,
0.3437961935997009,
0.5412102937698364,
-0.07038483023643494,
0.711586058139801,
-0.13551148772239685,
-0.2526608109474182,
0.04376424849033356,
-0.6675853729248047,
-0.3418593108654022,
-0.5135905742645264,
0.11255323886871338,
-0.451333612203598,
-0.9593916535377502,
0.10668141394853592,
-0.1783769130706787,
0.034195009618997574,
0.12710194289684296,
0.4337267279624939,
-0.34890419244766235,
1.0756276845932007,
0.3264163136482239,
0.463481605052948,
0.2569649815559387,
0.07746870815753937,
0.17545796930789948,
-0.601737916469574,
0.2263871431350708,
-0.6887059211730957,
-0.24166983366012573,
-1.025783896446228,
-0.661774754524231,
0.05529133230447769,
0.09874594211578369,
-0.26154717803001404,
0.4425351023674011,
-0.1747872531414032,
0.431030809879303,
0.4635915458202362,
-0.11021420359611511,
0.21003125607967377,
-0.4232228696346283,
-0.11664767563343048,
-0.10146712511777878,
-0.5308952331542969,
-0.9121015071868896,
0.7506771087646484,
0.3028961718082428,
0.5801414251327515,
-0.0036085695028305054,
0.5481727719306946,
0.17075785994529724,
0.5611124038696289,
-0.6635679006576538,
0.6623666286468506,
-0.05608833208680153,
-0.6239048838615417,
-0.06297502666711807,
-0.20331279933452606,
-1.0736258029937744,
0.556794285774231,
-0.17458242177963257,
-0.7803003787994385,
0.11056283116340637,
0.1150839701294899,
0.029212361201643944,
0.09161043167114258,
-1.0092523097991943,
0.8156055212020874,
-0.2601519227027893,
-0.4639866054058075,
-0.17359082400798798,
-0.7445439100265503,
0.5612620711326599,
-0.015985187143087387,
0.30092889070510864,
-0.064633309841156,
-0.05108035355806351,
0.5179848074913025,
-0.26321420073509216,
1.0072507858276367,
0.12360499799251556,
-0.09330370277166367,
0.5260344743728638,
-0.11847520619630814,
0.5283545255661011,
-0.18052957952022552,
-0.1676272302865982,
0.08503900468349457,
-0.020075427368283272,
-0.24832679331302643,
-0.6226142644882202,
0.4062361717224121,
-0.5111400485038757,
-0.7719833850860596,
-0.3272833824157715,
-0.6974227428436279,
-0.11895343661308289,
-0.018187716603279114,
0.047587234526872635,
0.389080286026001,
-0.19098323583602905,
0.2833902835845947,
0.7597565650939941,
-0.2843649983406067,
0.29688695073127747,
0.849254846572876,
-0.04339536651968956,
0.11503322422504425,
0.6213913559913635,
-0.18796096742153168,
0.386764794588089,
0.4937290549278259,
0.4127424955368042,
-0.6040425300598145,
-0.7256593704223633,
-0.16472980380058289,
0.41748175024986267,
-0.708381175994873,
0.25279882550239563,
-0.6184819936752319,
0.18090391159057617,
-0.5218597054481506,
-0.057270001620054245,
-0.10316471755504608,
-0.45381683111190796,
-0.12152162939310074,
-0.14500348269939423,
0.07164028286933899,
1.007272481918335,
0.18117175996303558,
0.21127131581306458,
-0.6002805233001709,
0.2615774869918823,
0.1959909051656723,
-0.12633110582828522,
-0.41287124156951904,
-0.4982343018054962,
-0.005753739736974239,
0.3355691134929657,
-0.4184129536151886,
-1.1303339004516602,
0.06402409076690674,
0.1453600972890854,
0.6587397456169128,
0.5363684296607971,
0.09067487716674805,
0.7023835182189941,
-0.7090152502059937,
0.7462126612663269,
0.1564701795578003,
-0.8360281586647034,
0.364822655916214,
-0.3205062448978424,
-0.32152625918388367,
0.34062719345092773,
0.43645158410072327,
-0.38040509819984436,
-0.8710252046585083,
-0.8782346844673157,
-0.380083292722702,
0.0901038870215416,
0.09995928406715393,
-0.01983526535332203,
-0.3288925588130951,
0.3111380338668823,
0.31882965564727783,
0.26495084166526794,
-0.43874627351760864,
-0.20751802623271942,
0.11019846051931381,
-0.20316162705421448,
-0.31574487686157227,
-0.12056133151054382,
-0.2802836000919342,
-0.14098665118217468,
-0.0867423564195633,
-0.06192575395107269,
0.19817951321601868,
0.19029192626476288,
-0.2990442216396332,
0.2019798457622528,
0.3654489815235138,
0.9951242208480835,
1.047052025794983,
0.09306348115205765,
0.5587834119796753,
0.22512206435203552,
-0.21652507781982422,
0.19222389161586761,
0.1542683243751526,
-0.07439962774515152,
0.1648859977722168,
0.4245026707649231,
0.9229085445404053,
0.5104015469551086,
-0.7769192457199097,
0.3429277837276459,
-0.04999985545873642,
-0.2205885499715805,
-0.265776664018631,
0.10889416188001633,
0.3606460690498352,
0.31445780396461487,
0.032934628427028656,
-0.1962832510471344,
0.16350117325782776,
-0.7600263357162476,
0.43683749437332153,
0.4968847334384918,
-0.08556988835334778,
-0.37538644671440125,
0.6293845772743225,
0.2340218722820282,
-0.5267485976219177,
0.2212260216474533,
-0.2739808261394501,
-0.49371445178985596,
0.7698478698730469,
0.45852038264274597,
0.8965176939964294,
0.02483944408595562,
0.16091826558113098,
-0.0821109190583229,
0.3064267039299011,
-0.1884826421737671,
0.09182833880186081,
-0.16708187758922577,
-0.64592444896698,
-0.619511067867279,
-0.5171611309051514,
-0.8005186915397644,
-0.016081715002655983,
-0.5390987992286682,
0.2421242594718933,
-0.24843966960906982,
0.08028016239404678,
0.2333885282278061,
-0.0847715213894844,
-0.4012621343135834,
0.0855468288064003,
0.15179026126861572,
1.068239450454712,
-0.8954831957817078,
1.0129245519638062,
0.9011785984039307,
-0.4359530508518219,
-0.7229390144348145,
0.5006229877471924,
-0.0967266857624054,
-0.7269817590713501,
0.844962477684021,
0.1757270097732544,
-0.06914570927619934,
-0.037871960550546646,
-0.6386261582374573,
-0.547326922416687,
0.859142005443573,
0.3524208962917328,
-0.5886170268058777,
0.24626785516738892,
0.10680714249610901,
0.3619326651096344,
-0.2077787220478058,
0.5023993253707886,
0.7795273661613464,
0.629584014415741,
-0.008208445273339748,
-1.1169229745864868,
0.10567270219326019,
0.16004310548305511,
-0.0880163311958313,
0.1616310030221939,
-0.32549259066581726,
1.1421682834625244,
-0.19748236238956451,
-0.29483646154403687,
0.03946644812822342,
0.9382708072662354,
0.5046240091323853,
0.46541842818260193,
0.5702306032180786,
0.3505293130874634,
0.726690948009491,
-0.04448437690734863,
1.3265130519866943,
-0.06158927083015442,
0.1084115132689476,
0.931903600692749,
-0.5487192273139954,
0.7901340126991272,
0.6766515970230103,
-0.5723571181297302,
0.6558874845504761,
0.7932325005531311,
0.35466673970222473,
0.358547180891037,
0.5285950303077698,
-0.19951477646827698,
0.01093007531017065,
0.007168799638748169,
-0.06961185485124588,
0.3740849792957306,
0.4578329920768738,
-0.11795743554830551,
-0.09077480435371399,
-0.2297128140926361,
0.2070055902004242,
0.10376913100481033,
0.056698352098464966,
0.7023339867591858,
0.15543237328529358,
-1.1676429510116577,
0.9042611718177795,
0.01723119616508484,
0.8778278827667236,
-0.42334166169166565,
-0.12047910690307617,
-0.3082358241081238,
0.38590410351753235,
0.03368927538394928,
-0.8477616310119629,
0.3252599239349365,
0.03440658748149872,
0.2856917977333069,
-0.11165890097618103,
0.7770373821258545,
-0.3328979015350342,
-0.11627226322889328,
-0.031223125755786896,
0.31111210584640503,
0.5672704577445984,
-0.08032714575529099,
-0.74409019947052,
-0.058061107993125916,
-0.1279749572277069,
-0.1629219800233841,
0.4503209888935089,
0.5387638807296753,
-0.13383284211158752,
0.5871368646621704,
0.6030566692352295,
0.1184246838092804,
0.29841262102127075,
-0.19375361502170563,
0.8072301745414734,
-0.6533134579658508,
-0.37818631529808044,
-1.054313063621521,
0.5422895550727844,
-0.11674295365810394,
-0.31723830103874207,
1.0707446336746216,
0.42136242985725403,
0.4334701895713806,
0.04224161431193352,
0.8334771394729614,
0.168629452586174,
0.448800653219223,
-0.527327835559845,
0.27676013112068176,
-0.29599806666374207,
-0.08406958729028702,
-0.2412867695093155,
-0.5965468287467957,
0.03452203795313835,
0.8941906690597534,
-0.42720991373062134,
-0.19474880397319794,
0.9774894714355469,
0.7228443026542664,
-0.16159024834632874,
0.1860255002975464,
0.3586876094341278,
0.4329790771007538,
0.1452185958623886,
0.4763714373111725,
1.5354818105697632,
0.10223127901554108,
0.09770531952381134,
-0.2740100920200348,
-0.35959774255752563,
-0.5207881927490234,
-1.1389700174331665,
-0.7433304786682129,
-0.535931408405304,
-0.326413094997406,
-0.21203458309173584,
0.013846938498318195,
0.5956695079803467,
0.3778851628303528,
-0.6794421672821045,
-0.2657549977302551,
-0.5970494151115417,
0.3721338212490082,
-0.17262502014636993,
-0.20047959685325623,
0.03340727090835571,
-0.14983564615249634,
-1.0615662336349487,
0.5095974206924438,
0.2510082721710205,
0.2508825361728668,
-0.38422060012817383,
-0.15396931767463684,
-0.3150843679904938,
0.40919771790504456,
0.4349542260169983,
0.2730424106121063,
-1.0856804847717285,
-0.40634047985076904,
0.06985630095005035,
-0.16288669407367706,
-0.15221479535102844,
0.9378744959831238,
-0.7130465507507324,
-0.039761580526828766,
0.5175096988677979,
0.4270547032356262,
0.256773978471756,
0.11661391705274582,
0.678791880607605,
-0.3003007173538208,
0.580525815486908,
0.4240501821041107,
0.4815131723880768,
0.4031766355037689,
0.019800040870904922,
0.31661370396614075,
0.24126331508159637,
-0.5979461669921875,
-1.2858299016952515,
0.5489495396614075,
-0.5853044390678406,
-0.5489026308059692,
1.4169282913208008,
-0.4668264091014862,
-0.2717406153678894,
-0.21931375563144684,
-0.07789446413516998,
0.42940109968185425,
0.06918351352214813,
0.5994913578033447,
0.5443016290664673,
-0.2812635600566864,
0.07084234058856964,
-0.9439214468002319,
0.3727682828903198,
0.6081567406654358,
-0.8252807259559631,
0.014942234382033348,
0.5118562579154968,
0.23757562041282654,
0.03845156729221344,
0.42147693037986755,
0.25322413444519043,
0.11223901063203812,
0.04303224757313728,
-0.2541797459125519,
0.013807643204927444,
-0.11841108649969101,
-0.27361205220222473,
-0.31503355503082275,
0.014180275611579418,
-0.6097527742385864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05760v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05760v2
|
Similarity Guided Multimodal Fusion Transformer for Semantic Location Prediction in Social Media
| 2024-05-09T13:32:26 | 2024-06-23T10:05:18 |
Zhizhen Zhang, Ning Wang, Haojie Li, Zhihui Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Semantic location prediction aims to derive meaningful location insights from
multimodal social media posts, offering a more contextual understanding of
daily activities than using GPS coordinates. This task faces significant
challenges due to the noise and modality heterogeneity in "text-image" posts.
Existing methods are generally constrained by inadequate feature
representations and modal interaction, struggling to effectively reduce noise
and modality heterogeneity. To address these challenges, we propose a
Similarity-Guided Multimodal Fusion Transformer (SG-MFT) for predicting the
semantic locations of users from their multimodal posts. First, we incorporate
high-quality text and image representations by utilizing a pre-trained large
vision-language model. Then, we devise a Similarity-Guided Interaction Module
(SIM) to alleviate modality heterogeneity and noise interference by
incorporating both coarse-grained and fine-grained similarity guidance for
improving modality interactions. Specifically, we propose a novel
similarity-aware feature interpolation attention mechanism at the
coarse-grained level, leveraging modality-wise similarity to mitigate
heterogeneity and reduce noise within each modality. At the fine-grained level,
we utilize a similarity-aware feed-forward block and element-wise similarity to
further address the issue of modality heterogeneity. Finally, building upon
pre-processed features with minimal noise and modal interference, we devise a
Similarity-aware Fusion Module (SFM) to fuse two modalities with a
cross-attention mechanism. Comprehensive experimental results clearly
demonstrate the superior performance of our proposed method.
|
[
-0.695467472076416,
-0.7514848709106445,
0.7146369814872742,
0.1526884138584137,
-0.35172805190086365,
-0.19616730511188507,
-0.2308165431022644,
-0.5148270130157471,
0.7114331722259521,
0.19125431776046753,
-1.0488698482513428,
-0.5826197862625122,
-0.4051094651222229,
-0.1883440613746643,
-0.27015870809555054,
0.4346155524253845,
0.0864059329032898,
0.05730114504694939,
-0.42386046051979065,
-0.0023285227362066507,
-0.33441492915153503,
-0.3106972575187683,
-0.2216235250234604,
-0.1411048322916031,
0.6750971674919128,
0.12211183458566666,
0.9521234035491943,
0.4373755156993866,
0.6826394200325012,
0.3303923010826111,
0.10493800789117813,
0.27159398794174194,
-0.3275913894176483,
0.02013549581170082,
-0.23095771670341492,
-0.09099212288856506,
0.005371826700866222,
-0.1917104721069336,
0.761193573474884,
0.4317582845687866,
0.22888565063476562,
0.15508921444416046,
0.037087518721818924,
0.1490926891565323,
-0.41885626316070557,
0.08070334047079086,
-0.6972301006317139,
-0.08166021853685379,
-0.0599796436727047,
-0.3234347403049469,
0.13218605518341064,
-0.2086969017982483,
-0.012061245739459991,
-0.5545653700828552,
0.504328191280365,
0.23196761310100555,
1.0702478885650635,
0.5684181451797485,
-0.43761515617370605,
0.3094461262226105,
-0.7048975229263306,
0.6928533911705017,
-0.4936114251613617,
0.7346546053886414,
0.471664696931839,
0.5796949863433838,
-0.24895170331001282,
-0.37008729577064514,
-0.7811150550842285,
-0.14636537432670593,
-0.4852225184440613,
0.0021265284158289433,
-0.03005506470799446,
-0.1115497499704361,
0.26817891001701355,
0.09613687545061111,
-0.625951886177063,
-0.2233155071735382,
-0.3610852062702179,
-0.2865661382675171,
0.36164388060569763,
-0.06181004270911217,
-0.004008464049547911,
-0.38334110379219055,
-0.8402669429779053,
-0.1605481654405594,
-0.20777617394924164,
0.15724407136440277,
0.08208850026130676,
0.3715042471885681,
-0.15162569284439087,
0.32513144612312317,
-0.5300506949424744,
0.5102877616882324,
0.3163027763366699,
-0.4021700322628021,
0.5804283618927002,
-0.512315571308136,
0.11621317267417908,
0.12319315969944,
0.7911579608917236,
0.7448702454566956,
-0.1481594443321228,
-0.1749318242073059,
-0.24151721596717834,
-0.03471855819225311,
0.35286664962768555,
-0.5734319090843201,
-0.044858332723379135,
-0.0038849548436701298,
-0.8138450384140015,
-0.08733248710632324,
0.3773818612098694,
-0.7107546329498291,
-0.09819814562797546,
-0.36046501994132996,
0.4998553395271301,
-0.467646062374115,
-0.16705355048179626,
-0.15195395052433014,
0.007525324355810881,
0.18942366540431976,
0.23226137459278107,
-1.0280652046203613,
0.018579689785838127,
0.699475884437561,
0.9203720688819885,
-0.054886408150196075,
-0.6701378226280212,
-0.3834044933319092,
0.5377578139305115,
0.43127936124801636,
1.067947268486023,
-0.746033787727356,
-0.31932497024536133,
-0.09402419626712799,
0.28586268424987793,
-0.09018612653017044,
-0.2122327983379364,
0.6172555685043335,
-0.3542614281177521,
0.04376763105392456,
-0.254471093416214,
-0.13895830512046814,
-0.45699653029441833,
0.46005213260650635,
-0.7569025158882141,
1.116591453552246,
0.23099149763584137,
-0.5123805403709412,
0.4530288279056549,
-0.5937352776527405,
-0.556841254234314,
0.022072339430451393,
-0.21391306817531586,
-0.3012407720088959,
0.1112380251288414,
0.354911208152771,
0.6889315247535706,
-0.25404053926467896,
0.07436306774616241,
-0.5643051862716675,
-0.6370419859886169,
0.04678579419851303,
-0.45605677366256714,
0.1388162225484848,
0.12202871590852737,
-0.14515620470046997,
0.3967116177082062,
-0.5701010227203369,
-0.10521896183490753,
0.000514927611220628,
0.06717514246702194,
-0.5568347573280334,
-0.14816027879714966,
0.25653597712516785,
0.7084290385246277,
0.43819162249565125,
-0.6344044804573059,
-0.17508089542388916,
-0.30222073197364807,
0.1548624038696289,
0.585519552230835,
-0.0746799111366272,
0.8321751952171326,
-0.4224613606929779,
0.3579462170600891,
0.1554781049489975,
0.3201061189174652,
-0.1704825907945633,
-0.4607039988040924,
0.07291343808174133,
-0.23993374407291412,
0.049298111349344254,
0.19916217029094696,
-0.7601995468139648,
0.3263486623764038,
-0.8024643659591675,
-0.6212400794029236,
-0.5675583481788635,
0.19202294945716858,
0.019965799525380135,
0.5296965837478638,
0.4225684404373169,
-0.1667061448097229,
-0.17998017370700836,
-0.919062077999115,
0.06475196033716202,
0.17534787952899933,
0.009000369347631931,
0.2280000001192093,
0.026650957763195038,
-0.6656169891357422,
0.8602001070976257,
-0.604385256767273,
-0.5892276763916016,
0.16429054737091064,
-0.13469292223453522,
-0.1552462875843048,
0.4126826524734497,
0.6928667426109314,
-1.3155834674835205,
-0.3739352226257324,
0.052796319127082825,
-0.2612634599208832,
0.009203081019222736,
0.0234996285289526,
-0.21688294410705566,
-0.027110962197184563,
0.6680215001106262,
-0.6376854181289673,
0.38829001784324646,
0.6791200637817383,
-0.41139957308769226,
0.12926548719406128,
-0.006134886294603348,
0.5713751316070557,
-1.480432391166687,
-0.10002139210700989,
0.15622356534004211,
-0.16978877782821655,
-0.44054165482521057,
-0.3439162075519562,
0.11194930225610733,
-0.10076681524515152,
-0.45528843998908997,
0.466097354888916,
0.05259612947702408,
-0.13358472287654877,
-0.2893221080303192,
0.10488973557949066,
-0.09751448780298233,
0.5750131011009216,
0.0011721759801730514,
0.46662628650665283,
0.3547877371311188,
-0.3106388747692108,
0.3109590709209442,
0.15862122178077698,
-0.21367667615413666,
0.5391426086425781,
-0.16738110780715942,
-0.3368079960346222,
-0.10497409850358963,
0.294009268283844,
-1.4049686193466187,
-0.39038166403770447,
0.06081276759505272,
-0.469439834356308,
-0.06365209817886353,
-0.03149911388754845,
-0.5207648873329163,
-0.2805502116680145,
-0.49158695340156555,
0.733134388923645,
0.18179288506507874,
-0.595459520816803,
0.9803323149681091,
-0.006318970117717981,
-0.08103126287460327,
-0.5037094950675964,
-0.6006982922554016,
-0.3333297371864319,
-0.1668398082256317,
-0.7866232991218567,
0.6921308040618896,
0.11177575588226318,
0.1061093658208847,
0.4238411486148834,
-0.08617230504751205,
-0.06813114881515503,
-0.05344042927026749,
0.7911709547042847,
0.20998668670654297,
-0.08829262107610703,
0.46057429909706116,
0.31218600273132324,
-0.4453873038291931,
-0.08224719017744064,
0.022585468366742134,
0.7501027584075928,
-0.005817468278110027,
-0.638116180896759,
-0.4441259205341339,
0.556592583656311,
0.5602800846099854,
-0.25811344385147095,
0.6759073138237,
1.3988730907440186,
-0.4579956829547882,
0.29585814476013184,
-0.7723982930183411,
-0.5093287825584412,
-0.561609148979187,
0.4470835030078888,
-0.48164618015289307,
-1.1787577867507935,
0.440068781375885,
-0.23275385797023773,
-0.283854216337204,
0.378773957490921,
0.37865743041038513,
-0.3289977014064789,
0.8688937425613403,
0.6974443197250366,
-0.08759764581918716,
0.7899696230888367,
0.12681856751441956,
0.5240679383277893,
-0.3428245186805725,
-0.25246432423591614,
-0.10692127048969269,
-0.7696253657341003,
-0.6154894232749939,
-0.6208791136741638,
0.3116392195224762,
-0.27327826619148254,
0.04472866654396057,
0.4177995026111603,
-0.3057098686695099,
0.6415761709213257,
0.7618879079818726,
0.1780582219362259,
0.13063384592533112,
0.31587597727775574,
0.001888051861897111,
-0.32934367656707764,
-0.6194873452186584,
-0.06857738643884659,
0.48419567942619324,
0.05277436226606369,
0.8044054508209229,
0.05047067627310753,
0.6265546083450317,
0.17826302349567413,
-0.07332810759544373,
-0.7264291644096375,
0.5190513730049133,
-0.2033407837152481,
-0.1270802915096283,
-0.2488805055618286,
-0.4348238408565521,
-0.6139732599258423,
0.23756210505962372,
-0.573018491268158,
-0.5181010365486145,
0.15546469390392303,
0.010309151373803616,
-0.4463789463043213,
0.303270161151886,
-0.6093747019767761,
0.7636711597442627,
-0.08075344562530518,
-0.20714454352855682,
-0.2682337164878845,
-0.995076596736908,
0.11427164077758789,
-0.045799992978572845,
0.23706220090389252,
-0.28790804743766785,
0.13136212527751923,
0.28609681129455566,
-0.048859354108572006,
0.7246755957603455,
-0.21707341074943542,
-0.1450616419315338,
-0.12020116299390793,
-0.012957371771335602,
0.2615712583065033,
-0.12475059181451797,
0.1179126650094986,
0.3536844849586487,
0.003255018498748541,
-0.11615371704101562,
-0.7156107425689697,
1.3425344228744507,
-0.4814150631427765,
-0.3155469596385956,
0.06691983342170715,
-0.8932743668556213,
-0.1608765870332718,
0.2899321913719177,
0.2661925256252289,
0.49366647005081177,
0.07970085740089417,
0.22144374251365662,
0.4250372648239136,
0.26347091794013977,
0.5989529490470886,
0.15241777896881104,
-0.10260448604822159,
-0.38208523392677307,
1.1066789627075195,
0.058996692299842834,
0.0808471217751503,
0.6823063492774963,
0.02689816989004612,
-0.6373937129974365,
-0.06282205134630203,
0.007652485277503729,
0.2510867416858673,
-0.658363401889801,
-0.2891611158847809,
-0.7073674201965332,
-0.006056735757738352,
-0.5914249420166016,
-0.7621122002601624,
-0.40851014852523804,
-0.33857962489128113,
-0.012426985427737236,
0.024675097316503525,
0.3273003101348877,
0.3851134777069092,
-0.08334466069936752,
0.5409424304962158,
-0.7156998515129089,
0.42728427052497864,
0.3225996494293213,
0.5366719365119934,
-0.13952620327472687,
-0.2621578276157379,
-0.27337583899497986,
0.2238595336675644,
-0.09876950085163116,
-0.31065914034843445,
0.21077382564544678,
-0.031320150941610336,
0.4727298617362976,
0.5554506778717041,
0.09842587262392044,
0.9139955639839172,
-0.3389459550380707,
0.6483058333396912,
0.5091009140014648,
-0.46800175309181213,
0.5143988132476807,
-0.2525407671928406,
0.5672999024391174,
0.6363940834999084,
0.2752237021923065,
-0.2687603831291199,
-0.17367053031921387,
-0.321137934923172,
-0.609978199005127,
0.5123563408851624,
-0.017288057133555412,
0.08637148141860962,
0.06799490004777908,
0.2435159832239151,
0.01733597181737423,
-0.029871458187699318,
-0.7567436099052429,
-0.25198671221733093,
-0.2696625292301178,
-0.37581735849380493,
-0.19282521307468414,
-0.1476152241230011,
-0.0689195767045021,
-0.2776554822921753,
0.36322933435440063,
-0.2719772756099701,
0.428112268447876,
0.1259002834558487,
-0.008389289490878582,
-0.38398098945617676,
0.020663635805249214,
0.6357028484344482,
0.38666027784347534,
-0.19424279034137726,
0.26617947220802307,
0.2525601387023926,
-0.43315088748931885,
0.009718575514853,
0.573286235332489,
-0.1348697692155838,
0.12141004204750061,
-0.009546495042741299,
0.511370062828064,
0.4590793251991272,
-0.4905736744403839,
0.72678142786026,
-0.028357941657304764,
-0.12252214550971985,
-0.18170292675495148,
-0.06288108974695206,
0.11070851236581802,
0.7735304832458496,
0.13541176915168762,
0.47479763627052307,
0.2527669072151184,
-0.34133148193359375,
0.30809837579727173,
0.5259590148925781,
-0.8510444760322571,
-0.18301169574260712,
0.6283769607543945,
0.11610246449708939,
-0.32346001267433167,
0.10950904339551926,
-0.04010742902755737,
-0.5770218968391418,
0.22272495925426483,
0.5964658260345459,
0.8005043268203735,
-0.5541889071464539,
0.1682966649532318,
0.31600773334503174,
0.12310972809791565,
0.059527479112148285,
0.12328577041625977,
-0.3589800000190735,
-0.6162129044532776,
-0.3596026599407196,
-0.7054952383041382,
0.013757895678281784,
-0.2447921484708786,
-0.4310664236545563,
0.4599479138851166,
-0.2750072777271271,
-0.21835759282112122,
-0.08919129520654678,
-0.31624636054039,
-0.6308100819587708,
0.20746153593063354,
0.34582099318504333,
0.4432466924190521,
-0.7105016708374023,
0.7549154758453369,
0.8744275569915771,
-0.06008601188659668,
-0.596009373664856,
0.3000677227973938,
0.08324823528528214,
-0.5091402530670166,
0.14908193051815033,
0.5661503672599792,
-0.6392260193824768,
-0.3074108958244324,
-0.4349029064178467,
-0.9803078770637512,
1.691809892654419,
0.25367072224617004,
-0.3584707975387573,
0.17523105442523956,
0.37643149495124817,
0.2694527208805084,
-0.5395040512084961,
-0.07653003185987473,
0.0600736103951931,
0.3163484036922455,
0.4407557249069214,
-0.9729715585708618,
0.28538209199905396,
-0.1789851188659668,
0.25597715377807617,
0.4088533818721771,
-0.8467110991477966,
0.6077544093132019,
-0.03225017338991165,
0.020006312057375908,
-0.2166379988193512,
0.5504528284072876,
-0.041278284043073654,
0.44336992502212524,
0.5676581263542175,
0.5501238703727722,
0.2995276153087616,
-0.16329465806484222,
0.7061148285865784,
-0.3269158601760864,
0.384812593460083,
1.2091466188430786,
-0.3469139337539673,
0.8471035957336426,
0.8249427080154419,
0.32495519518852234,
0.42928874492645264,
0.36556848883628845,
-0.07096944749355316,
0.8821985125541687,
-0.4169192910194397,
-0.25801315903663635,
-0.40624335408210754,
-0.2747105062007904,
-0.4477342367172241,
0.5512872338294983,
0.19298511743545532,
-0.6508002281188965,
-0.4190591871738434,
0.19526340067386627,
-0.39881280064582825,
0.04893055930733681,
-0.2848273813724518,
0.7196612358093262,
-0.2234490066766739,
-0.32046830654144287,
0.16616028547286987,
0.06392860412597656,
0.866578221321106,
-0.810613214969635,
-0.11041760444641113,
0.19189058244228363,
0.08545724302530289,
-0.268352746963501,
-0.7571462392807007,
0.39186108112335205,
-0.6981945633888245,
-0.5387396216392517,
-0.22100424766540527,
1.2352350950241089,
-0.7526035904884338,
-0.4359472095966339,
0.4793751835823059,
0.17439323663711548,
-0.25472381711006165,
-0.3837648928165436,
-0.457584410905838,
0.14813536405563354,
0.05754348263144493,
-0.011472386308014393,
0.3466870188713074,
0.3365963399410248,
0.008855177089571953,
0.6753241419792175,
0.8013486266136169,
-0.4346662759780884,
0.009609517641365528,
0.016613921150565147,
1.0292984247207642,
-0.7705724835395813,
-0.7566832900047302,
-0.7677128314971924,
0.1751820147037506,
-0.0030870335176587105,
-0.29617539048194885,
0.6286001205444336,
0.3833736479282379,
0.9022091627120972,
-0.16537542641162872,
0.4472101926803589,
-0.10423370450735092,
0.3925659954547882,
-0.2884097695350647,
0.6251596212387085,
-0.7633082270622253,
0.10843274742364883,
-0.34754154086112976,
-1.348495364189148,
-0.3744284212589264,
0.6233088374137878,
-0.31252536177635193,
-0.01812640205025673,
0.4862396717071533,
1.1447187662124634,
-0.5914087295532227,
-0.12407748401165009,
0.6130414605140686,
-0.021658185869455338,
0.0024362271651625633,
0.3289315402507782,
0.7342818379402161,
-0.3778228759765625,
0.5792924165725708,
-0.6709051132202148,
0.07537897676229477,
-0.3899895250797272,
-0.44897228479385376,
-0.6409479975700378,
-1.0455272197723389,
-0.0218427162617445,
-0.17240069806575775,
-0.34206920862197876,
1.2215174436569214,
0.785547137260437,
-0.567588746547699,
0.17029711604118347,
0.43284815549850464,
-0.010035445913672447,
-0.23030902445316315,
-0.26584890484809875,
0.4449094235897064,
0.1629498153924942,
-0.6083933115005493,
0.12809844315052032,
0.5051975846290588,
0.18285363912582397,
-0.08706881105899811,
-0.10151343047618866,
-0.40802285075187683,
-0.20352540910243988,
0.7271661758422852,
-0.2745763659477234,
-1.002170443534851,
-0.5601072907447815,
-0.09358396381139755,
-0.17296673357486725,
-0.017701318487524986,
0.5918954610824585,
-0.6939753890037537,
0.521030604839325,
0.4527980387210846,
0.525192141532898,
0.24052846431732178,
0.3779924809932709,
0.24638602137565613,
-0.8254774808883667,
0.313823401927948,
0.039526477456092834,
0.5056038498878479,
0.24025380611419678,
-0.5606117844581604,
0.31340277194976807,
0.1356995850801468,
-0.31284159421920776,
-0.2326999306678772,
0.10224601626396179,
-1.4689109325408936,
-0.026768017560243607,
1.2820106744766235,
0.12820471823215485,
-0.272349089384079,
-0.03790856525301933,
-0.5858446359634399,
0.09874077886343002,
-0.5669158101081848,
0.7597658038139343,
0.48899510502815247,
0.08762356638908386,
-0.2836896777153015,
-0.2297946959733963,
0.45204851031303406,
0.4772302806377411,
-0.37874943017959595,
-0.29054000973701477,
0.49432373046875,
0.19497092068195343,
0.40662091970443726,
0.30782225728034973,
0.01970837078988552,
0.3960472643375397,
-0.02903733216226101,
0.029484666883945465,
-0.17055052518844604,
-0.19245994091033936,
-0.2997853457927704,
0.442790687084198,
-0.49532702565193176,
-0.2633407413959503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05758v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05758v1
|
Exploring the Potential of Human-LLM Synergy in Advancing Qualitative Analysis: A Case Study on Mental-Illness Stigma
| 2024-05-09T13:27:22 | 2024-05-09T13:27:22 |
Han Meng, Yitian Yang, Yunan Li, Jungup Lee, Yi-Chieh Lee
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Qualitative analysis is a challenging, yet crucial aspect of advancing
research in the field of Human-Computer Interaction (HCI). Recent studies show
that large language models (LLMs) can perform qualitative coding within
existing schemes, but their potential for collaborative human-LLM discovery and
new insight generation in qualitative analysis is still underexplored. To
bridge this gap and advance qualitative analysis by harnessing the power of
LLMs, we propose CHALET, a novel methodology that leverages the human-LLM
collaboration paradigm to facilitate conceptualization and empower qualitative
research. The CHALET approach involves LLM-supported data collection,
performing both human and LLM deductive coding to identify disagreements, and
performing collaborative inductive coding on these disagreement cases to derive
new conceptual insights. We validated the effectiveness of CHALET through its
application to the attribution model of mental-illness stigma, uncovering
implicit stigmatization themes on cognitive, emotional and behavioral
dimensions. We discuss the implications for future research, methodology, and
the transdisciplinary opportunities CHALET presents for the HCI community and
beyond.
|
[
-0.41493940353393555,
-0.6750703454017639,
0.544552743434906,
0.018034212291240692,
-0.08770345896482468,
0.2624776363372803,
-0.08821321278810501,
-0.6409478187561035,
0.32632264494895935,
0.14483462274074554,
-0.665443480014801,
-0.6128286123275757,
-0.3441578447818756,
-0.04765823855996132,
-0.3124527633190155,
0.7581208944320679,
-0.015191075392067432,
-0.01571744680404663,
-0.40105605125427246,
-0.11793231219053268,
-0.5505985021591187,
-0.8695303201675415,
-0.4705602526664734,
-0.5693086385726929,
0.6477554440498352,
0.37856948375701904,
0.6462157368659973,
-0.07236462831497192,
0.4499812722206116,
0.14543524384498596,
0.2998175621032715,
0.19992338120937347,
-0.31016770005226135,
0.08082371205091476,
0.0009405080927535892,
-0.4079892933368683,
-0.6944867968559265,
0.023268496617674828,
0.2639258801937103,
0.6414046883583069,
-0.37354576587677,
0.3508056700229645,
0.2611134648323059,
0.4674099385738373,
-0.8157473802566528,
-0.07867302745580673,
-0.147010937333107,
0.13275432586669922,
-0.3253248333930969,
-0.14145775139331818,
-0.14405333995819092,
-0.2811761498451233,
-0.2214665561914444,
-0.4511443078517914,
0.39898738265037537,
0.12839935719966888,
0.5707868337631226,
0.10468874871730804,
-0.20767711102962494,
-0.07297565042972565,
-0.693459153175354,
0.7310396432876587,
-0.8317259550094604,
0.16534940898418427,
0.6739277243614197,
0.16018259525299072,
-0.12813803553581238,
-0.5870623588562012,
-0.8156967163085938,
0.08620504289865494,
-0.08549315482378006,
-0.1201934665441513,
-0.14409545063972473,
-0.16689802706241608,
0.07371404021978378,
0.17537567019462585,
-0.5520477294921875,
0.44620218873023987,
-0.2533199191093445,
-0.24370518326759338,
0.8500288128852844,
0.5367262959480286,
0.6270735859870911,
-0.16881461441516876,
-0.20128318667411804,
0.3967401385307312,
-0.35971418023109436,
0.00004210391853121109,
-0.21256321668624878,
0.08003341406583786,
-0.5164876580238342,
0.3970436453819275,
-0.013705544173717499,
0.4149511754512787,
-0.19135317206382751,
0.025829298421740532,
-0.006983822211623192,
-0.22468984127044678,
-0.17256377637386322,
0.36314165592193604,
0.718672513961792,
0.6286135911941528,
-0.10963483899831772,
-0.04462844878435135,
-0.08875942975282669,
0.643706738948822,
0.3160724937915802,
-0.4113121032714844,
-0.5905640721321106,
0.491434246301651,
-0.34882691502571106,
-0.0912788063287735,
-0.07867127656936646,
-0.9705294966697693,
-0.9902973175048828,
-0.2920021116733551,
-0.12295925617218018,
-0.2283739447593689,
-0.6146107316017151,
0.2865452170372009,
-0.09541536122560501,
0.46804913878440857,
0.4706750214099884,
-0.487928181886673,
0.4928401708602905,
0.7391476035118103,
0.8962829113006592,
-0.2272280901670456,
-0.26084649562835693,
-0.2842589020729065,
0.32924848794937134,
-0.01974938064813614,
0.5158793330192566,
-0.48444661498069763,
-0.4963121712207794,
0.13468888401985168,
-0.3082277774810791,
0.2517129182815552,
-0.44122830033302307,
0.5103518962860107,
-0.07589522004127502,
-0.018728502094745636,
-0.49733638763427734,
-0.3782994747161865,
0.12356723099946976,
0.12940293550491333,
-0.5954418778419495,
0.9441527724266052,
0.22924664616584778,
-0.8061308860778809,
0.21933063864707947,
-0.47040313482284546,
-0.10341040045022964,
0.40039828419685364,
-0.4430994987487793,
-0.5097303986549377,
0.24271002411842346,
0.2041500359773636,
0.36667943000793457,
-0.8235887885093689,
0.5521078705787659,
-0.3908064365386963,
-0.4333922863006592,
0.5308067202568054,
0.10615698248147964,
0.9216582775115967,
0.07055515050888062,
-0.32398492097854614,
0.032218072563409805,
-0.5893890261650085,
-0.045970577746629715,
0.2737005352973938,
0.18393589556217194,
-0.5847103595733643,
-0.07193735986948013,
0.2620091140270233,
0.28931471705436707,
0.115943543612957,
-0.3412942886352539,
0.05415227636694908,
0.1206853836774826,
0.3256804943084717,
0.45065799355506897,
0.05371442064642906,
0.28776615858078003,
-0.4576317369937897,
0.6027782559394836,
0.08635491877794266,
0.3775964081287384,
0.18311342597007751,
-0.3547445833683014,
-0.9220005869865417,
-0.15508656203746796,
-0.08304865658283234,
0.27916502952575684,
-0.7259747982025146,
0.445339560508728,
-0.020419027656316757,
-0.18290773034095764,
-1.0312272310256958,
0.25630244612693787,
0.3526689410209656,
0.37866970896720886,
0.3245944678783417,
-0.7502413392066956,
-0.5881778001785278,
-0.8252133131027222,
-0.03272956609725952,
-0.2490290403366089,
-0.005137068685144186,
-0.30307379364967346,
0.47583454847335815,
-0.2213924527168274,
1.1610236167907715,
-0.4319601058959961,
-0.49773284792900085,
-0.4676305949687958,
0.18903210759162903,
-0.11660542339086533,
0.5425570011138916,
0.23442426323890686,
-0.7428954243659973,
-0.17497976124286652,
0.04712987318634987,
-1.1623743772506714,
-0.3972455561161041,
0.12420984357595444,
-0.0965711697936058,
-0.19328774511814117,
0.136795312166214,
-0.4057104289531708,
0.44109320640563965,
0.32654955983161926,
-0.4530199468135834,
0.6070737242698669,
0.08582260459661484,
0.24925947189331055,
-0.8051881790161133,
0.009295529685914516,
0.4192380905151367,
0.14313319325447083,
-0.8246970176696777,
0.028081879019737244,
-0.08661486953496933,
-0.3242492973804474,
-0.37644821405410767,
0.43153300881385803,
-0.5248309969902039,
0.17442476749420166,
-0.12943243980407715,
0.2548445761203766,
0.1025601178407669,
0.5245067477226257,
-0.0915311872959137,
0.3806164562702179,
0.5014796853065491,
-0.23386606574058533,
0.3211933672428131,
0.08283444494009018,
-0.2944739758968353,
1.0222653150558472,
-0.44057348370552063,
0.2260933816432953,
-0.044060517102479935,
0.21297527849674225,
-0.7673532962799072,
-0.13223855197429657,
0.4809975028038025,
-0.10622754693031311,
-0.08823345601558685,
0.28322353959083557,
-0.6621347069740295,
-0.31658104062080383,
-0.3859255015850067,
0.922107994556427,
0.4437694251537323,
-0.10524062067270279,
0.28873977065086365,
0.7581784129142761,
-0.14456388354301453,
0.03100397065281868,
-0.5747039914131165,
0.35618430376052856,
-0.6416979432106018,
-0.40608346462249756,
0.1366523653268814,
0.13512840867042542,
-0.7484284043312073,
-0.32425910234451294,
-0.09799232333898544,
-0.2118787169456482,
0.13339270651340485,
0.4219519793987274,
0.3399488031864166,
0.07865523546934128,
0.050317585468292236,
-0.21232570707798004,
-0.1327284723520279,
0.2128409743309021,
-0.10680095851421356,
0.5517722964286804,
-0.2702235281467438,
-0.518146276473999,
-0.675014078617096,
0.5748993158340454,
0.18361859023571014,
-0.3586333096027374,
0.4155428111553192,
0.6787116527557373,
-0.45726868510246277,
-0.17204484343528748,
-0.8249511122703552,
-0.04004256799817085,
-0.38293352723121643,
-0.04489264264702797,
-0.14137323200702667,
-0.9912276268005371,
0.46837562322616577,
-0.19229289889335632,
-0.21770240366458893,
-0.027359958738088608,
0.35962146520614624,
-0.37582510709762573,
0.4028611183166504,
0.9641830325126648,
-0.2652207016944885,
0.09008941799402237,
-0.22725413739681244,
0.25534412264823914,
-0.9289736747741699,
-0.5582327246665955,
-0.4462330937385559,
-0.4416389763355255,
-0.14292208850383759,
-0.5566893219947815,
0.7385204434394836,
0.15906360745429993,
-0.04463108628988266,
-0.17579419910907745,
-0.4066471457481384,
0.1105467900633812,
0.20643681287765503,
0.43543317914009094,
0.6436271667480469,
-0.18261127173900604,
0.13905774056911469,
-0.3128233551979065,
-0.7931563258171082,
-0.37738364934921265,
0.4799902141094208,
0.3150109052658081,
0.7257400155067444,
0.1828429400920868,
0.7342953681945801,
0.908216655254364,
0.4237653911113739,
-0.5161696076393127,
0.7257985472679138,
0.5187915563583374,
-0.1770726889371872,
-0.23747703433036804,
0.034460633993148804,
-1.1341438293457031,
0.32403677701950073,
-0.20612482726573944,
-1.0952095985412598,
0.4237057566642761,
0.03814878687262535,
-0.21649983525276184,
0.15965834259986877,
-0.5280672907829285,
0.5769798755645752,
-0.221467524766922,
-0.6549499034881592,
-0.39281022548675537,
-0.7505305409431458,
0.6252476572990417,
-0.2693737745285034,
0.4026520848274231,
-0.2374003529548645,
0.07077209651470184,
0.7987027764320374,
-0.3469521403312683,
1.4036779403686523,
0.08217855542898178,
-0.7367570400238037,
0.3889515995979309,
0.33552274107933044,
-0.06665925681591034,
0.08393166214227676,
-0.1841181069612503,
0.35701969265937805,
-0.15249702334403992,
-0.6712308526039124,
-0.9555618762969971,
0.7737577557563782,
-0.7640228867530823,
-0.8681904077529907,
-0.36366868019104004,
-0.5767540335655212,
-0.3885831832885742,
-0.14536835253238678,
-0.2297355681657791,
0.2713278830051422,
-0.3884442150592804,
-0.49123331904411316,
0.40711796283721924,
-0.1692335158586502,
0.29697221517562866,
0.4664866626262665,
-0.15895125269889832,
-0.1447163075208664,
0.7903276085853577,
-0.18957321345806122,
-0.007150179706513882,
0.16306205093860626,
0.09468191117048264,
0.07682910561561584,
-0.37637701630592346,
0.19304366409778595,
0.48622384667396545,
-0.656109631061554,
-0.005727817770093679,
-0.44211632013320923,
-0.16185978055000305,
-0.27037104964256287,
-0.48613643646240234,
-0.06213046610355377,
-0.16096360981464386,
0.08165478706359863,
-0.011016739532351494,
0.24316595494747162,
0.7581599950790405,
0.241604745388031,
0.2826715111732483,
-0.7400649189949036,
0.2055491954088211,
0.05239802971482277,
0.08610948175191879,
0.4722663462162018,
0.04697064310312271,
-0.6164345741271973,
-0.0689098984003067,
-0.3380547761917114,
-0.9890897274017334,
0.35418501496315,
-0.2952592372894287,
0.3451747000217438,
0.058080654591321945,
0.3793056309223175,
0.8392183184623718,
0.04005468264222145,
0.922034740447998,
0.709246039390564,
-1.0359879732131958,
0.7143605947494507,
-0.23683670163154602,
0.5466169118881226,
0.5108875036239624,
0.3504989445209503,
-0.7755683660507202,
-0.48057737946510315,
-0.7559106349945068,
-0.7433189153671265,
0.3424805998802185,
0.2669089436531067,
-0.5149971842765808,
0.24408546090126038,
0.27955716848373413,
0.23625774681568146,
0.30496713519096375,
-0.607053279876709,
-0.12395378947257996,
0.17235571146011353,
-0.026786785572767258,
-0.3320682644844055,
-0.2049371749162674,
-0.48665350675582886,
-0.4449678361415863,
0.19611725211143494,
0.038605526089668274,
0.17903344333171844,
0.2431407868862152,
-0.26445379853248596,
-0.20144644379615784,
0.330545574426651,
0.046628475189208984,
0.6031404733657837,
0.17248718440532684,
0.5815447568893433,
0.18496978282928467,
-0.12659764289855957,
0.34326648712158203,
-0.22574438154697418,
0.14132492244243622,
-0.2488672137260437,
0.6113922595977783,
0.564493715763092,
0.10771335661411285,
-0.5769155025482178,
0.3680232763290405,
0.12816306948661804,
0.06558986753225327,
-0.19616776704788208,
0.04568374156951904,
0.06311069428920746,
0.4546966850757599,
0.16247045993804932,
-0.43065115809440613,
0.23505084216594696,
-0.6043030023574829,
0.32174935936927795,
0.2949679493904114,
-0.32538002729415894,
-0.4931291937828064,
0.3803586959838867,
0.3442126512527466,
-0.5320007801055908,
0.7640059590339661,
0.13744951784610748,
-0.11045581102371216,
0.5256245136260986,
0.4322233200073242,
0.9775311350822449,
-0.24139225482940674,
0.5349949598312378,
-0.16729991137981415,
0.22618168592453003,
0.15571905672550201,
0.1360357254743576,
-0.34494709968566895,
-0.725806713104248,
-0.09732876718044281,
-0.5549415946006775,
-0.23871967196464539,
0.03682883828878403,
-0.8198639750480652,
0.1932995468378067,
-0.10303197801113129,
-0.277521014213562,
-0.13088500499725342,
0.09248150885105133,
-0.712188184261322,
-0.042872801423072815,
0.2507328689098358,
0.5203256011009216,
-0.9759877920150757,
1.0109447240829468,
0.608628511428833,
-0.30002540349960327,
-0.4411522150039673,
0.2743488550186157,
0.4260406792163849,
-0.6585745215415955,
0.46734657883644104,
-0.13151583075523376,
-0.1758388727903366,
-0.08501580357551575,
-0.4106423556804657,
-0.2742100954055786,
1.281004786491394,
0.09954791516065598,
-0.5974026322364807,
-0.0731845498085022,
0.3110450208187103,
0.7373523712158203,
-0.48616963624954224,
-0.006328182760626078,
0.8538355231285095,
0.4658229649066925,
-0.09354560822248459,
-0.9910054206848145,
0.32364434003829956,
-0.46821561455726624,
0.2232026308774948,
0.3159449100494385,
-0.6944141983985901,
0.3144037425518036,
-0.3988974988460541,
-0.3249068260192871,
-0.16008341312408447,
0.7269782423973083,
0.30317068099975586,
0.7744659185409546,
0.2814439535140991,
0.3691883981227875,
0.9668368101119995,
0.2241251915693283,
0.9164366722106934,
0.05791740491986275,
0.23773601651191711,
1.0832035541534424,
-0.7471091747283936,
0.4986967146396637,
0.7858257293701172,
-0.33512061834335327,
0.5898224115371704,
0.4312429130077362,
0.1569775938987732,
0.11173897981643677,
0.6307718753814697,
-0.599147379398346,
-0.2406083196401596,
-0.7115840911865234,
-0.1749684363603592,
0.15280036628246307,
0.5309853553771973,
0.2925165593624115,
-0.35844457149505615,
0.17285561561584473,
-0.19121448695659637,
0.30477002263069153,
-0.30964186787605286,
0.5532033443450928,
0.5310801863670349,
-0.24459676444530487,
0.7463789582252502,
-0.19013971090316772,
0.5341178178787231,
-0.4164038300514221,
-0.11501133441925049,
-0.24005667865276337,
-0.19883151352405548,
-0.38763242959976196,
-0.6513692140579224,
0.08894011378288269,
-0.24637815356254578,
0.03384226933121681,
-0.06244756281375885,
0.9883425235748291,
-0.48890385031700134,
-0.3498336374759674,
0.30474793910980225,
1.106964349746704,
-0.04078029468655586,
0.30767515301704407,
-0.5149847269058228,
0.5516939759254456,
-0.4149373769760132,
0.3284696638584137,
0.7075254321098328,
0.5736575722694397,
-0.3472531735897064,
0.9347306489944458,
0.29575908184051514,
0.10372571647167206,
-0.3253289759159088,
0.3089725375175476,
0.9989146590232849,
-0.8170339465141296,
-0.42452430725097656,
-1.0900377035140991,
0.6568080186843872,
-0.0851607397198677,
0.05462929233908653,
0.7922720909118652,
0.3515363037586212,
0.5250573754310608,
0.12019767612218857,
0.9427340626716614,
-0.10719163715839386,
-0.20671579241752625,
-0.38250765204429626,
0.36842840909957886,
-0.4849267899990082,
0.45823001861572266,
-0.5268800854682922,
-0.6187281608581543,
-0.4381442666053772,
0.29686659574508667,
-0.2111639529466629,
-0.3351488411426544,
0.7993242740631104,
0.676733136177063,
0.08267033100128174,
0.22347764670848846,
0.2918916642665863,
0.00011345291568432003,
0.41294363141059875,
0.7886579632759094,
1.1475613117218018,
-0.00597538473084569,
-0.3857581913471222,
-0.14534936845302582,
-0.496681809425354,
0.17343474924564362,
-0.6690229177474976,
-0.9717336297035217,
-0.9901782870292664,
-0.4907682538032532,
-0.40365931391716003,
0.3669418394565582,
0.9378826022148132,
0.31596025824546814,
-0.3459737002849579,
-0.8521314859390259,
0.13339321315288544,
0.20208503305912018,
-0.4058331251144409,
-0.24108465015888214,
0.22489500045776367,
-0.051289722323417664,
-0.36603373289108276,
-0.003226763801649213,
0.4291079342365265,
-0.11597894877195358,
-0.7502830028533936,
-0.1887456327676773,
-0.21800857782363892,
-0.3474375903606415,
0.6725689768791199,
0.1441127359867096,
-0.7638183236122131,
0.15338090062141418,
-0.5256109237670898,
-0.016374895349144936,
0.014918403699994087,
1.6142667531967163,
-0.8355101346969604,
0.21177059412002563,
-0.0018514642724767327,
0.6478179693222046,
0.39081069827079773,
-0.053933411836624146,
0.9352645874023438,
-0.5088527202606201,
0.13909466564655304,
0.3484017848968506,
0.15040862560272217,
0.3682856857776642,
-0.5617503523826599,
0.4258264899253845,
0.33436134457588196,
-0.2881743907928467,
-0.8347383737564087,
0.3018260896205902,
-1.1878072023391724,
-0.39083778858184814,
1.1102575063705444,
0.08769924193620682,
-0.11927016079425812,
-0.6247432827949524,
-0.3519316613674164,
0.2538599371910095,
-0.37306010723114014,
1.1817349195480347,
0.5916393995285034,
-0.5109987854957581,
-0.647182822227478,
-0.346770703792572,
0.48221930861473083,
0.46508845686912537,
-0.880961000919342,
0.1907285749912262,
0.4747711420059204,
-0.11445555090904236,
0.13190677762031555,
1.0143011808395386,
0.00024494552053511143,
0.04303259029984474,
-0.2259243279695511,
0.3458845019340515,
0.03642049804329872,
-0.1464814990758896,
-0.33864620327949524,
0.2690180838108063,
0.20517225563526154,
0.19552668929100037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05741v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05741v1
|
Can large language models understand uncommon meanings of common words?
| 2024-05-09T12:58:22 | 2024-05-09T12:58:22 |
Jinyang Wu, Feihu Che, Xinxin Zheng, Shuai Zhang, Ruihan Jin, Shuai Nie, Pengpeng Shao, Jianhua Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT have shown significant advancements
across diverse natural language understanding (NLU) tasks, including
intelligent dialogue and autonomous agents. Yet, lacking widely acknowledged
testing mechanisms, answering `whether LLMs are stochastic parrots or genuinely
comprehend the world' remains unclear, fostering numerous studies and sparking
heated debates. Prevailing research mainly focuses on surface-level NLU,
neglecting fine-grained explorations. However, such explorations are crucial
for understanding their unique comprehension mechanisms, aligning with human
cognition, and finally enhancing LLMs' general NLU capacities. To address this
gap, our study delves into LLMs' nuanced semantic comprehension capabilities,
particularly regarding common words with uncommon meanings. The idea stems from
foundational principles of human communication within psychology, which
underscore accurate shared understandings of word semantics. Specifically, this
paper presents the innovative construction of a Lexical Semantic Comprehension
(LeSC) dataset with novel evaluation metrics, the first benchmark encompassing
both fine-grained and cross-lingual dimensions. Introducing models of both
open-source and closed-source, varied scales and architectures, our extensive
empirical experiments demonstrate the inferior performance of existing models
in this basic lexical-meaning understanding task. Notably, even the
state-of-the-art LLMs GPT-4 and GPT-3.5 lag behind 16-year-old humans by 3.9%
and 22.3%, respectively. Additionally, multiple advanced prompting techniques
and retrieval-augmented generation are also introduced to help alleviate this
trouble, yet limitations persist. By highlighting the above critical
shortcomings, this research motivates further investigation and offers novel
insights for developing more intelligent LLMs.
|
[
-0.6044530272483826,
-0.9607552886009216,
0.7748337984085083,
0.1909923553466797,
-0.3856622874736786,
0.052024658769369125,
-0.2760298252105713,
-0.5756152272224426,
-0.27114254236221313,
0.43551233410835266,
-0.8178512454032898,
-0.4724562168121338,
-0.6762053370475769,
0.1041966900229454,
-0.24151082336902618,
0.6519072651863098,
0.06311972439289093,
-0.06227913871407509,
-0.15821826457977295,
-0.45061999559402466,
-0.2948479652404785,
-0.2988364100456238,
-0.49557027220726013,
-0.45812857151031494,
0.5969938039779663,
0.2014690488576889,
0.764338493347168,
0.2121903896331787,
0.4636530578136444,
0.2314838469028473,
-0.39644715189933777,
0.43973132967948914,
-0.7657573223114014,
-0.23221556842327118,
-0.2517072558403015,
-0.3323907256126404,
-0.3020496964454651,
-0.08109577745199203,
0.6336499452590942,
1.2748160362243652,
0.02200464718043804,
-0.21522344648838043,
0.37161198258399963,
0.7838733792304993,
-0.4825253486633301,
0.1730164736509323,
-1.1842224597930908,
0.11589324474334717,
0.08057437092065811,
-0.10121731460094452,
-0.2633020281791687,
0.07453867793083191,
0.14201904833316803,
-0.7987122535705566,
0.2111961543560028,
-0.0529417023062706,
0.5811633467674255,
0.3241921067237854,
-0.5109158158302307,
-0.3296433389186859,
-0.4449220597743988,
0.8461862206459045,
-0.6529861092567444,
0.4580748379230499,
0.25799360871315,
0.23774190247058868,
-0.25630953907966614,
-0.7402265071868896,
-0.7073630690574646,
-0.3265230655670166,
0.017528781667351723,
0.14157165586948395,
-0.3503805100917816,
0.21352322399616241,
-0.13101541996002197,
0.4812142848968506,
-0.666056752204895,
0.3242984414100647,
-0.2858441472053528,
-0.12840022146701813,
0.5093061923980713,
0.3813478350639343,
0.27004027366638184,
-0.11434007436037064,
-0.3624242842197418,
0.16490721702575684,
-0.7514850497245789,
-0.0035368886310607195,
0.030876561999320984,
0.2445315420627594,
-0.3608331084251404,
0.45900675654411316,
-0.34164121747016907,
0.8174304366111755,
-0.6098343133926392,
0.32285556197166443,
0.1491311490535736,
-0.5292426347732544,
-0.2309720814228058,
-0.30528756976127625,
0.715764045715332,
0.341011106967926,
0.6882752776145935,
-0.3865765929222107,
-0.25991201400756836,
0.04336534067988396,
-0.02169078215956688,
-0.5043578147888184,
0.009677272289991379,
0.08222948014736176,
-0.27342700958251953,
-0.26972076296806335,
-0.10799981653690338,
-0.2751522958278656,
-0.43671175837516785,
-0.45028385519981384,
0.42454177141189575,
-0.627053439617157,
-0.17441053688526154,
0.49589353799819946,
-0.031471483409404755,
0.35679805278778076,
0.42571496963500977,
-0.7723941802978516,
0.36451271176338196,
0.9181983470916748,
0.8659012913703918,
-0.27303361892700195,
-0.4840051233768463,
-0.30377376079559326,
-0.20857058465480804,
-0.3984586000442505,
0.7342305779457092,
-0.5973661541938782,
-0.3859391510486603,
-0.18243344128131866,
0.054851289838552475,
-0.16329197585582733,
-0.37767529487609863,
0.4171440005302429,
-0.5044816136360168,
-0.23315365612506866,
-0.23457849025726318,
-0.5068334341049194,
-0.3880384862422943,
0.41905713081359863,
-0.4576698839664459,
0.5989761352539062,
-0.04228338971734047,
-0.8029814958572388,
0.1312587559223175,
-0.5285477042198181,
-0.08088811486959457,
0.2772464454174042,
-0.3095451891422272,
0.26475492119789124,
0.3995974063873291,
0.27472400665283203,
0.5862187147140503,
-0.3830421268939972,
0.18720752000808716,
-0.45408883690834045,
-0.5832276940345764,
0.6005113124847412,
-0.8946996927261353,
0.6064208149909973,
0.2643680274486542,
-0.08537784218788147,
-0.21826913952827454,
-0.6495598554611206,
0.18320512771606445,
0.16929952800273895,
0.02249833010137081,
-0.3132266402244568,
-0.14053714275360107,
-0.06826113909482956,
-0.003004508325830102,
0.21331477165222168,
-0.3790002763271332,
-0.03744570165872574,
-0.6485950946807861,
0.7233444452285767,
0.6605820655822754,
0.056976091116666794,
0.44616276025772095,
-0.3418993055820465,
0.32337525486946106,
-0.16910916566848755,
-0.13447754085063934,
-0.10781708359718323,
-0.41303685307502747,
-0.4371826648712158,
-0.0731656402349472,
-0.0756920650601387,
0.3289066255092621,
-0.47984206676483154,
0.19534893333911896,
-0.4577246308326721,
-0.45754119753837585,
-0.4960475265979767,
0.37790802121162415,
0.19582009315490723,
0.11941206455230713,
0.18689577281475067,
-0.2146795690059662,
-0.1771344393491745,
-0.8009387850761414,
-0.4799441695213318,
-0.012259850278496742,
-0.28036263585090637,
0.7047855257987976,
0.3056771159172058,
-0.5297423005104065,
0.8314065337181091,
-0.3042489290237427,
-0.012062790803611279,
-0.49392083287239075,
0.18536266684532166,
0.2010478675365448,
0.05945068225264549,
0.3061380088329315,
-0.6536141037940979,
-0.1953636109828949,
0.29502609372138977,
-0.670443058013916,
-0.1281588226556778,
-0.11346925795078278,
0.039663031697273254,
-0.06356534361839294,
0.5987630486488342,
-0.5408163070678711,
0.3126876950263977,
0.618617832660675,
-0.22535213828086853,
0.2593855559825897,
-0.29500043392181396,
-0.11303704977035522,
-0.7011587023735046,
-0.12340003252029419,
-0.1617555022239685,
-0.09582150727510452,
-0.5327143669128418,
0.26301294565200806,
-0.09078516066074371,
0.18061278760433197,
-0.6268400549888611,
0.7729862928390503,
-0.42108723521232605,
-0.16861264407634735,
-0.23821942508220673,
0.7781296968460083,
0.11551345884799957,
0.37434589862823486,
0.08277353644371033,
0.5072830319404602,
0.41099032759666443,
-0.7058562636375427,
0.3256323039531708,
-0.07105892896652222,
-0.4444042444229126,
0.31419482827186584,
-0.9026912450790405,
0.2303449660539627,
-0.20451995730400085,
0.3490084409713745,
-1.0128352642059326,
-0.2398141622543335,
0.011336714029312134,
-0.5548573732376099,
-0.13883210718631744,
-0.002855162601917982,
-0.41131526231765747,
-0.07071249186992645,
0.0028867903165519238,
0.37240996956825256,
0.3383668065071106,
-0.5624776482582092,
0.5237603187561035,
0.32631874084472656,
-0.10197040438652039,
-0.5138060450553894,
-0.8826665282249451,
0.09836547076702118,
-0.07132375985383987,
-0.8473374843597412,
0.0025813612155616283,
-0.031901005655527115,
-0.6701689958572388,
-0.07321889698505402,
-0.12234120070934296,
-0.09926629811525345,
0.40339329838752747,
0.11161238700151443,
0.2401052713394165,
-0.3122595548629761,
0.39131641387939453,
-0.13478076457977295,
-0.013049658387899399,
0.07525201886892319,
-0.25503870844841003,
0.7963318824768066,
-0.4610179662704468,
-0.5275698304176331,
0.014427484944462776,
0.24304547905921936,
0.4719061255455017,
-0.14712363481521606,
0.7921054363250732,
0.83553546667099,
-0.3011368215084076,
-0.35740402340888977,
-0.5204823613166809,
-0.15037447214126587,
-0.45686566829681396,
0.5548921227455139,
-0.5244817137718201,
-1.0599583387374878,
0.6965378522872925,
0.0017546508461236954,
0.1481703817844391,
0.41177883744239807,
0.4785074293613434,
-0.006647581700235605,
0.7482003569602966,
0.33668622374534607,
0.07614193856716156,
-0.013938660733401775,
-0.1474374234676361,
0.2735356390476227,
-0.8322476744651794,
-0.042133741080760956,
-0.21764518320560455,
-0.22409315407276154,
-0.6750242710113525,
-0.6709868907928467,
0.13441967964172363,
0.08311554044485092,
-0.13420799374580383,
-0.25804510712623596,
-0.3771476149559021,
0.7006757259368896,
0.18499036133289337,
0.02392318844795227,
0.531711220741272,
-0.03622690960764885,
-0.19358311593532562,
0.06448744982481003,
-0.48314428329467773,
-0.48753467202186584,
0.9476751685142517,
0.4237750172615051,
0.9255191087722778,
0.10687370598316193,
0.5600475072860718,
-0.01109092216938734,
-0.06423242390155792,
-0.9607400298118591,
0.6129635572433472,
-0.26434633135795593,
-0.46833088994026184,
-0.4079201817512512,
-0.5381726622581482,
-1.087070345878601,
0.5567944049835205,
-0.03536662459373474,
-1.0153894424438477,
0.01627129688858986,
-0.18143266439437866,
-0.32833942770957947,
0.2595961391925812,
-0.6893002390861511,
0.7522491216659546,
-0.15648959577083588,
-0.1860370934009552,
-0.43597593903541565,
-0.4693963825702667,
0.5577619671821594,
-0.24016228318214417,
0.4254903495311737,
-0.356206476688385,
-0.24175848066806793,
0.5062071681022644,
-0.1681724488735199,
0.8183327317237854,
0.022845406085252762,
-0.11807633191347122,
0.24068179726600647,
-0.016740361228585243,
0.4392378330230713,
0.2942235469818115,
0.01695912331342697,
0.27386653423309326,
0.05906938388943672,
-0.4878481328487396,
-0.6891186237335205,
0.8460942506790161,
-0.7971174120903015,
-0.5131855607032776,
-0.22390583157539368,
-0.8418954014778137,
-0.4488246738910675,
-0.08417684584856033,
0.19197215139865875,
0.328169047832489,
-0.4553402066230774,
0.4389915466308594,
0.80585777759552,
-0.41417092084884644,
0.22517021000385284,
0.6808952689170837,
-0.02300867810845375,
0.11636077612638474,
0.7965712547302246,
-0.1629325896501541,
0.511482298374176,
0.2999128997325897,
0.2709333896636963,
-0.2735922932624817,
-0.7072623372077942,
-0.157038152217865,
0.25413042306900024,
-0.7988446950912476,
0.24622586369514465,
-0.9208433628082275,
-0.38547801971435547,
-0.28983983397483826,
-0.27990028262138367,
-0.17185604572296143,
-0.2912063002586365,
-0.15923750400543213,
-0.11242982000112534,
0.5202841758728027,
0.9100227952003479,
-0.2071288824081421,
0.2883351147174835,
-0.9446502327919006,
0.5139046311378479,
0.34682267904281616,
0.13989539444446564,
0.26759591698646545,
-0.7985744476318359,
0.08814148604869843,
0.3282971978187561,
-0.03123602271080017,
-0.6050803661346436,
0.3637194037437439,
0.3348511755466461,
0.7510145902633667,
0.4205489754676819,
0.08461283147335052,
0.6424651145935059,
-0.3712281882762909,
0.7970762848854065,
-0.03521931916475296,
-0.849668562412262,
0.24287579953670502,
-0.4091486632823944,
0.5572315454483032,
0.5770561695098877,
0.19763243198394775,
-0.9470617771148682,
-0.41960620880126953,
-0.5598740577697754,
-0.9354304075241089,
0.5661098957061768,
0.2116062194108963,
0.4478406310081482,
-0.013199306093156338,
0.2505311071872711,
0.19185224175453186,
-0.13725589215755463,
-0.7668614387512207,
0.02084759995341301,
0.15997566282749176,
-0.18749569356441498,
-0.32199984788894653,
-0.08796790987253189,
-0.03377141058444977,
-0.029521094635128975,
0.4200078547000885,
-0.13740645349025726,
0.010095125995576382,
0.11057809740304947,
-0.3588818907737732,
0.16815738379955292,
0.4942653775215149,
0.2958018481731415,
0.5592749118804932,
-0.09993063658475876,
0.3199329674243927,
0.5522499680519104,
-0.5245018601417542,
-0.10521230846643448,
0.07550423592329025,
0.30561500787734985,
-0.13206012547016144,
0.6289369463920593,
0.7985820174217224,
0.3792306184768677,
-0.8093666434288025,
0.37190061807632446,
-0.3453863561153412,
-0.19605739414691925,
-0.23737725615501404,
0.1015666127204895,
0.5181708335876465,
0.05588555708527565,
0.25627169013023376,
-0.15403404831886292,
0.12815171480178833,
-0.6463600993156433,
0.22724664211273193,
0.5836313962936401,
-0.4567142128944397,
-0.09284401684999466,
0.1945435255765915,
0.08344957232475281,
0.01220613718032837,
0.5361234545707703,
-0.456341952085495,
-0.3442930579185486,
0.5621719360351562,
0.3437621295452118,
0.6148408651351929,
0.1398426592350006,
0.09864215552806854,
0.14869526028633118,
0.3964661657810211,
0.039462942630052567,
0.05208948254585266,
-0.20476405322551727,
-1.0709283351898193,
-0.41276517510414124,
-0.7448462247848511,
-0.3052058219909668,
0.308787077665329,
-0.5523635149002075,
0.060707636177539825,
-0.280569851398468,
0.3369520306587219,
-0.04937300458550453,
0.1392156481742859,
-0.9625862836837769,
0.10141702741384506,
0.21261635422706604,
0.9388605356216431,
-0.8203691244125366,
0.7038919925689697,
0.4721158742904663,
-0.06832486391067505,
-0.9240648150444031,
-0.021647334098815918,
0.12596020102500916,
-1.3160429000854492,
0.5738394856452942,
0.24265146255493164,
-0.2326456755399704,
0.032321371138095856,
-0.33610275387763977,
-0.5371993780136108,
0.8043738603591919,
0.04936818778514862,
-0.8017449378967285,
-0.10158007591962814,
0.41408616304397583,
0.5292233228683472,
-0.29675593972206116,
0.4186021685600281,
0.9127840995788574,
0.46250373125076294,
0.2615036070346832,
-0.74797523021698,
-0.10120347142219543,
-0.2065621167421341,
-0.15562233328819275,
-0.14165005087852478,
-0.3761090636253357,
0.6105952858924866,
-0.24567265808582306,
-0.20448751747608185,
0.14725999534130096,
0.3576194643974304,
0.4518624544143677,
0.5664363503456116,
0.567919135093689,
0.46663716435432434,
0.7271995544433594,
-0.01996258646249771,
1.0446252822875977,
-0.22567225992679596,
0.16368483006954193,
1.1821205615997314,
0.14181861281394958,
0.7682366371154785,
0.35900580883026123,
-0.2506422996520996,
0.07424811273813248,
0.7232118248939514,
0.3479001522064209,
0.28188183903694153,
0.36172378063201904,
-0.4484005272388458,
-0.46164047718048096,
-0.18442533910274506,
-0.23722536861896515,
0.5952426791191101,
0.7672635912895203,
-0.20194387435913086,
-0.30801650881767273,
-0.028602201491594315,
-0.2899625301361084,
0.12430932372808456,
-0.36792153120040894,
0.9390751123428345,
0.6291384100914001,
-0.44164857268333435,
0.7207287549972534,
-0.33214446902275085,
0.7232187390327454,
-0.6033861041069031,
0.2470516562461853,
-0.3753606975078583,
0.11606653034687042,
-0.06054352968931198,
-0.9825900793075562,
0.23182092607021332,
0.02994585409760475,
0.3941325843334198,
0.28191766142845154,
0.6183030009269714,
-0.24393205344676971,
-0.4505249559879303,
0.4689858555793762,
0.7261583209037781,
0.3992078900337219,
-0.2479548454284668,
-0.6894732117652893,
0.2686985433101654,
0.07700369507074356,
-0.0219720508903265,
0.17753522098064423,
1.0664637088775635,
0.10350905358791351,
0.7544240355491638,
0.45833486318588257,
0.2075463831424713,
-0.008731239475309849,
0.3735206425189972,
0.646787703037262,
-0.5994552373886108,
-0.41349005699157715,
-0.9288890957832336,
0.3346211612224579,
0.031391169875860214,
-0.17734742164611816,
0.5460576415061951,
0.09263726323843002,
0.7320516109466553,
0.24913692474365234,
0.8233729600906372,
0.3846491873264313,
0.23683108389377594,
-0.5623866319656372,
0.6760156154632568,
-0.6504868865013123,
0.41126522421836853,
-0.17714399099349976,
-0.915535032749176,
-0.24430356919765472,
0.6372812986373901,
-0.40922898054122925,
-0.08941102772951126,
0.572790265083313,
0.8060181736946106,
-0.2511059045791626,
0.23525302112102509,
0.616629421710968,
0.3355467915534973,
0.22299306094646454,
0.7528873682022095,
1.1542396545410156,
-0.08599048107862473,
0.5824461579322815,
0.12032543122768402,
-0.24849240481853485,
-0.17507731914520264,
-0.6065707206726074,
-0.913203239440918,
-0.45859262347221375,
0.1276971697807312,
-0.10969164222478867,
0.14777308702468872,
0.7822840213775635,
0.39625120162963867,
-0.5093023180961609,
0.10428480803966522,
-0.6098551750183105,
0.08321526646614075,
0.17717044055461884,
-0.21453745663166046,
0.16990849375724792,
-0.5423500537872314,
-0.6739910244941711,
0.32059869170188904,
0.2388904094696045,
0.02146552875638008,
-0.3119276463985443,
-0.32670167088508606,
0.19653154909610748,
0.387734979391098,
0.561967670917511,
0.06807219982147217,
-1.0013912916183472,
-0.268220454454422,
0.06005243584513664,
-0.0895078107714653,
-0.2062140703201294,
0.5831093192100525,
-0.766751229763031,
0.2632580101490021,
0.560569703578949,
0.8402317762374878,
0.3085142970085144,
-0.25537773966789246,
0.4974464178085327,
-0.43741774559020996,
0.17214907705783844,
0.3447268605232239,
0.5139858722686768,
0.4335509240627289,
-0.23563064634799957,
0.4516996741294861,
0.11584331840276718,
-0.4799332022666931,
-0.7487707138061523,
0.4210703670978546,
-1.131446123123169,
-0.4544115364551544,
1.363945722579956,
-0.0994463562965393,
-0.2721100449562073,
-0.2409287542104721,
-0.16070443391799927,
0.034619349986314774,
-0.1564972847700119,
0.6000860929489136,
0.7052768468856812,
0.05935855209827423,
-0.17977136373519897,
-0.6341076493263245,
0.14450888335704803,
0.5460419058799744,
-0.5489169359207153,
0.3480472266674042,
0.2635209858417511,
0.23144468665122986,
-0.1366853415966034,
0.6337777972221375,
-0.10348020493984222,
0.25179439783096313,
0.11139591038227081,
-0.27350783348083496,
0.173152893781662,
0.12769661843776703,
-0.3907737135887146,
-0.2514439523220062,
0.25795236229896545,
0.003707868978381157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06710v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06710v1
|
Mobile Sequencers
| 2024-05-09T12:39:50 | 2024-05-09T12:39:50 |
Cem Bozsahin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
The article is an attempt to contribute to explorations of a common origin
for language and planned-collaborative action. It gives `semantics of change'
the central stage in the synthesis, from its history and recordkeeping to its
development, its syntax, delivery and reception, including substratal aspects.
It is suggested that to arrive at a common core, linguistic semantics must be
understood as studying through syntax mobile agent's representing, tracking and
coping with change and no change. Semantics of actions can be conceived the
same way, but through plans instead of syntax. The key point is the following:
Sequencing itself, of words and action sequences, brings in more structural
interpretation to the sequence than which is immediately evident from the
sequents themselves. Mobile sequencers can be understood as subjects
structuring reporting, understanding and keeping track of change and no change.
The idea invites rethinking of the notion of category, both in language and in
planning.
Understanding understanding change by mobile agents is suggested to be about
human extended practice, not extended-human practice. That's why linguistics is
as important as computer science in the synthesis. It must rely on
representational history of acts, thoughts and expressions, personal and
public, crosscutting overtness and covertness of these phenomena. It has
implication for anthropology in the extended practice, which is covered
briefly.
|
[
-0.43909209966659546,
-0.41189083456993103,
0.33182504773139954,
-0.0029629748314619064,
-0.1781277358531952,
0.20508618652820587,
-0.04596170783042908,
-0.33203476667404175,
0.8371835947036743,
0.5774115324020386,
-0.5784811973571777,
-0.18138475716114044,
-0.5231790542602539,
0.25466373562812805,
-0.586398184299469,
0.8403342366218567,
-0.16034086048603058,
-0.20137369632720947,
0.27908214926719666,
-0.7798882126808167,
-0.5399998426437378,
-0.42201998829841614,
-0.49222445487976074,
-0.45572105050086975,
0.6752538681030273,
0.29034218192100525,
1.070228934288025,
0.7348690032958984,
0.3337497115135193,
0.4563038945198059,
-0.22770051658153534,
0.007931465283036232,
-0.32687461376190186,
0.3454773724079132,
-0.4230543375015259,
-0.6293733716011047,
-0.36197230219841003,
-0.07574569433927536,
0.6982823014259338,
0.9351134300231934,
-0.00901904795318842,
0.0033034866210073233,
-0.21131065487861633,
1.0476322174072266,
-0.48733916878700256,
-0.08831726014614105,
-0.40147456526756287,
0.16356362402439117,
-0.12665794789791107,
-0.17610302567481995,
-0.2822571098804474,
-0.22370411455631256,
-0.12461604923009872,
-0.48820385336875916,
0.35983777046203613,
-0.32977503538131714,
0.5341778993606567,
0.15048976242542267,
-0.566239058971405,
-0.5412240624427795,
-0.9586745500564575,
0.48420169949531555,
-0.2945510447025299,
0.39853566884994507,
0.15001793205738068,
0.28395789861679077,
-0.5244965553283691,
-1.0093932151794434,
-0.8810524940490723,
0.06917966902256012,
-0.010275782085955143,
0.036706943064928055,
0.17586708068847656,
0.02753504551947117,
0.29363080859184265,
0.38851630687713623,
-0.5007707476615906,
-0.1797298640012741,
-0.7700851559638977,
-0.14245949685573578,
0.8678951859474182,
0.5293897986412048,
0.5566975474357605,
0.028240373358130455,
-0.10777848213911057,
0.0672774612903595,
-1.0771530866622925,
0.12694694101810455,
0.021435994654893875,
0.04463982582092285,
0.08277405798435211,
0.5820174813270569,
-0.4501475989818573,
0.7588082551956177,
-0.09135966002941132,
-0.23792864382266998,
0.11192299425601959,
-0.4115458130836487,
-0.3219723105430603,
0.13523513078689575,
0.6732383370399475,
0.18381577730178833,
0.04170364886522293,
-0.17800632119178772,
-0.06050996109843254,
0.28036680817604065,
0.37834179401397705,
-0.4101187586784363,
0.09725663810968399,
0.14045369625091553,
-0.585360050201416,
-0.16383245587348938,
0.06938828527927399,
-0.39352765679359436,
-0.20700880885124207,
-0.5411026477813721,
0.08800815790891647,
-0.03886783495545387,
-0.16693761944770813,
0.18281599879264832,
-0.03388146311044693,
0.4848175644874573,
0.4415056109428406,
-1.0486210584640503,
0.5833330750465393,
0.8553193211555481,
0.6323952674865723,
0.11604994535446167,
-0.7737030386924744,
-0.043370433151721954,
0.18232665956020355,
-0.47223958373069763,
0.7199933528900146,
-0.5110991597175598,
-0.9988989233970642,
-0.025065641850233078,
0.14519867300987244,
-0.13688866794109344,
-0.4147879481315613,
0.5345494151115417,
-0.5481120347976685,
0.16502539813518524,
-0.2021676003932953,
-0.43224579095840454,
-0.5627779364585876,
-0.0210613701492548,
-0.6864649057388306,
0.9219247698783875,
-0.1835179179906845,
-0.19739332795143127,
0.5726468563079834,
-0.829850435256958,
-0.8385832905769348,
0.15000344812870026,
-0.20253273844718933,
0.26926368474960327,
0.13187997043132782,
-0.37197718024253845,
0.13059666752815247,
-0.16872377693653107,
0.3278259038925171,
0.16246183216571808,
-0.3383513391017914,
0.3792382478713989,
0.18417300283908844,
0.7672353982925415,
0.25455132126808167,
-0.4245431423187256,
0.25468921661376953,
-0.8504032492637634,
0.07571342587471008,
-0.2938564717769623,
-0.4032256007194519,
-0.3855123221874237,
0.34501588344573975,
-0.23733140528202057,
0.431216299533844,
-0.06008541211485863,
-0.27993878722190857,
0.4759592115879059,
-0.25507494807243347,
0.695311427116394,
0.3254260718822479,
-0.11138320714235306,
0.9774326086044312,
-0.4936620891094208,
0.3531014025211334,
-0.34097984433174133,
0.20408767461776733,
-0.4794813394546509,
-0.6105740666389465,
-0.8607580661773682,
0.11536415666341782,
0.06965309381484985,
0.5012122988700867,
-0.30550387501716614,
0.2008429914712906,
-0.3033575415611267,
-0.5278933048248291,
-0.2048410177230835,
-0.16509602963924408,
0.1613226681947708,
-0.1143125519156456,
0.2785719633102417,
-0.6040308475494385,
-0.9788777828216553,
-0.412401020526886,
-0.4281708598136902,
-0.24801486730575562,
0.28797459602355957,
-0.06864669173955917,
0.4465867877006531,
-0.5993055701255798,
1.1170741319656372,
-0.2292649894952774,
0.07387895882129669,
-0.35360807180404663,
0.3536559045314789,
0.06797631829977036,
0.3497331142425537,
0.15219111740589142,
-1.228330135345459,
-0.29229551553726196,
-0.06155652925372124,
-0.5670978426933289,
-0.025924330577254295,
-0.281157910823822,
-0.05621415004134178,
0.07563114166259766,
0.675935685634613,
-0.9295721650123596,
0.5036189556121826,
0.39504486322402954,
-0.41683706641197205,
0.19063177704811096,
0.04479235038161278,
0.08104176819324493,
-1.249558925628662,
-0.2099318951368332,
-0.7046221494674683,
-0.056820373982191086,
-0.8221603035926819,
0.23311948776245117,
-0.38416677713394165,
-0.19886592030525208,
-0.47770774364471436,
0.6598473191261292,
-0.4967990219593048,
-0.25960811972618103,
-0.5979912877082825,
0.05530647560954094,
-0.2050149142742157,
0.010384432971477509,
0.10687240958213806,
0.465844064950943,
0.34893089532852173,
-1.0252310037612915,
0.2943580448627472,
0.3303004205226898,
0.0074125248938798904,
0.30452319979667664,
-0.29147979617118835,
0.3219314515590668,
-0.04936116188764572,
0.38168153166770935,
-0.6512219905853271,
-0.2562895715236664,
0.4394896328449249,
-0.4886488914489746,
0.003576778806746006,
0.0005894300993531942,
-0.13415277004241943,
-0.32453614473342896,
0.057192280888557434,
0.32948166131973267,
0.3881046772003174,
-0.05133975297212601,
0.7191100120544434,
0.605751097202301,
-0.05026978254318237,
-0.4763241410255432,
-0.6615532636642456,
0.30045080184936523,
-0.20178787410259247,
-0.7169944643974304,
0.4216696321964264,
0.053473010659217834,
-0.7899575233459473,
-0.0017354307929053903,
-0.22470340132713318,
-0.40457969903945923,
0.014814182184636593,
0.6468214988708496,
-0.09960266202688217,
-0.23798899352550507,
0.1955859512090683,
-0.012388039380311966,
-0.15201494097709656,
-0.03281836956739426,
-0.1670239418745041,
0.3982981741428375,
0.10259497165679932,
0.045789655297994614,
-0.27227258682250977,
0.5988488793373108,
0.839228093624115,
-0.12044734507799149,
0.6511268615722656,
0.18209508061408997,
-0.09627782553434372,
0.2584187686443329,
-0.3092014491558075,
0.030845139175653458,
-0.47633829712867737,
-0.11652693897485733,
-0.4023192226886749,
-0.9812591075897217,
0.7137391567230225,
-0.3899991512298584,
-0.1487535834312439,
0.5143935084342957,
0.6087477803230286,
0.058767255395650864,
0.39979586005210876,
0.7015665173530579,
0.2460574209690094,
0.5032427906990051,
0.0702177956700325,
0.09495431929826736,
-0.8867897391319275,
-0.08800199627876282,
-0.48864641785621643,
-0.3814008831977844,
-1.0140068531036377,
-0.528622567653656,
0.07637003809213638,
0.08032087236642838,
-0.2750876545906067,
0.7034144997596741,
-0.10529645532369614,
0.5232375860214233,
0.36006975173950195,
-0.27107277512550354,
0.19223366677761078,
-0.346777081489563,
-0.002834474900737405,
0.1435725837945938,
-0.5132049918174744,
-0.9406211376190186,
0.8632273077964783,
-0.2607966363430023,
0.6366512775421143,
0.3553590178489685,
1.0588374137878418,
0.11381632834672928,
0.27736401557922363,
-0.778196394443512,
0.8842848539352417,
0.20299647748470306,
-0.5098609328269958,
-0.21164259314537048,
0.07724667340517044,
-1.311702013015747,
0.5338500738143921,
-0.024722469970583916,
-0.6505892872810364,
0.3619194030761719,
-0.009666090831160545,
-0.11932064592838287,
0.011321828700602055,
-0.4789198338985443,
0.8594494462013245,
0.009210172109305859,
-0.36919966340065,
-0.4854309856891632,
-0.9382867217063904,
0.23933303356170654,
0.17041298747062683,
0.4182022213935852,
0.0003622249641921371,
-0.16049888730049133,
0.7538877129554749,
-0.5211017727851868,
0.963379442691803,
0.23766407370567322,
0.16341011226177216,
0.8580722808837891,
0.4174152612686157,
0.3652517795562744,
-0.2307666540145874,
0.10140945017337799,
-0.3988421857357025,
-0.037884488701820374,
-0.3370104134082794,
-0.49271026253700256,
0.49365469813346863,
-0.44032806158065796,
-0.6821169257164001,
-0.46146315336227417,
-0.5421397686004639,
0.09837033599615097,
0.35958132147789,
0.07075760513544083,
0.503574550151825,
-0.6997499465942383,
-0.12176885455846786,
0.18178421258926392,
0.050395529717206955,
0.8045228123664856,
0.5949544310569763,
-0.2944061756134033,
-0.2902859151363373,
0.3954998552799225,
0.10247019678354263,
0.10938131809234619,
0.5975958108901978,
0.1805451661348343,
-0.16159464418888092,
-0.46619439125061035,
-0.2682291567325592,
0.0508028008043766,
-0.8030762672424316,
0.2517033517360687,
-0.6142696738243103,
0.2304871380329132,
-0.33382049202919006,
-0.49831438064575195,
-0.24329522252082825,
-0.6734375953674316,
-0.0966273844242096,
0.0188912283629179,
0.21982333064079285,
1.1617223024368286,
-0.34998345375061035,
0.3350040018558502,
-1.0761394500732422,
0.23956185579299927,
0.21420618891716003,
-0.2696397006511688,
-0.18376365303993225,
-0.10367056727409363,
-0.16221736371517181,
0.07545075565576553,
-0.4454875886440277,
-0.9946664571762085,
0.38157233595848083,
0.12218260765075684,
0.40048128366470337,
0.10411036759614944,
-0.1551416516304016,
0.7224540710449219,
-0.648541271686554,
0.96664959192276,
0.07516584545373917,
-1.1888668537139893,
0.5979998707771301,
-0.31715190410614014,
0.4722272455692291,
0.4812774062156677,
0.43616050481796265,
-1.1712985038757324,
-0.25713178515434265,
-0.784929096698761,
-0.8920811414718628,
0.36035311222076416,
0.08485028147697449,
0.3483671247959137,
-0.15661948919296265,
0.3574126958847046,
0.050781045109033585,
0.312720388174057,
-0.6930398941040039,
-0.18677003681659698,
-0.06717309355735779,
0.2106960415840149,
-0.06747061759233475,
-0.2572333812713623,
-0.0733821764588356,
-0.2989012897014618,
0.3594852089881897,
0.18368187546730042,
0.18153415620326996,
0.4463866353034973,
-0.3380804657936096,
-0.040363699197769165,
0.7167502045631409,
1.189498782157898,
0.9984015226364136,
0.40022969245910645,
0.2503736615180969,
-0.13489827513694763,
-0.7129003405570984,
0.45049813389778137,
-0.4531690180301666,
-0.3217249810695648,
0.1689717024564743,
0.4408283829689026,
0.6225573420524597,
0.3997427523136139,
-0.38938087224960327,
0.05817394703626633,
0.3099890351295471,
-0.04392898827791214,
-0.3427566885948181,
0.010085862129926682,
-0.008256942965090275,
0.18109194934368134,
0.21507149934768677,
0.43671828508377075,
0.32201623916625977,
-1.1527918577194214,
0.211982861161232,
-0.12629739940166473,
-0.41626372933387756,
-0.6512470841407776,
0.33781206607818604,
0.3523997962474823,
-0.7184945344924927,
0.1380583792924881,
-0.481205016374588,
-0.6339575052261353,
0.5859323143959045,
0.6085538268089294,
0.8458251953125,
-0.6873524188995361,
0.2778165936470032,
0.3579746186733246,
0.28524547815322876,
-0.31951311230659485,
0.4253523647785187,
-0.1226312667131424,
-1.0410642623901367,
-0.5231266021728516,
-0.23360027372837067,
-0.2920171022415161,
-0.48343759775161743,
-0.6444187760353088,
0.1989363729953766,
-0.1568731963634491,
0.0040451278910040855,
-0.10488289594650269,
-0.4583514332771301,
-0.2869398891925812,
0.1688830554485321,
-0.3018835783004761,
0.8071721792221069,
-0.5672712922096252,
0.882733166217804,
1.0604990720748901,
-0.44161880016326904,
-0.8718987107276917,
0.05724088475108147,
0.20570257306098938,
-0.4070192873477936,
1.015770435333252,
-0.07147182524204254,
-0.28939196467399597,
-0.05603136867284775,
-0.16773085296154022,
-0.6953654885292053,
0.916431188583374,
-0.18954816460609436,
-0.5177541375160217,
0.17392069101333618,
0.14346575736999512,
0.6868504285812378,
-0.404114693403244,
0.021945158019661903,
0.40111199021339417,
0.284843772649765,
0.2867045998573303,
-1.2065283060073853,
0.14038985967636108,
0.06560956686735153,
-0.11082734167575836,
0.9232205152511597,
-0.5020791292190552,
0.9347919821739197,
-0.32762041687965393,
-0.5122847557067871,
0.23168273270130157,
0.2900620102882385,
-0.409524530172348,
0.638543426990509,
-0.02419498935341835,
0.3895821273326874,
0.7440034747123718,
0.05190354213118553,
1.166050910949707,
-0.0010397983714938164,
0.24496814608573914,
1.1999748945236206,
-0.611115574836731,
0.8428860902786255,
0.5058421492576599,
-0.3120626211166382,
0.7898021936416626,
0.5237530469894409,
0.6203106045722961,
0.5864282250404358,
0.2511443793773651,
-0.5892497897148132,
0.10900048911571503,
0.14262813329696655,
-0.2623249590396881,
0.7865905165672302,
0.5001296401023865,
-0.42169326543807983,
-0.19268886744976044,
0.11894294619560242,
0.10510461777448654,
0.05814668536186218,
-0.7410438656806946,
0.9440448880195618,
0.11864250898361206,
-0.872546911239624,
0.5726616978645325,
-0.13541169464588165,
0.15024340152740479,
-0.3683030307292938,
0.12174583226442337,
-0.13758423924446106,
0.018078787252306938,
-0.2469986528158188,
-0.7087180614471436,
0.8337375521659851,
-0.4604077935218811,
-0.2981358468532562,
-0.33063775300979614,
0.8036279678344727,
-0.14125904440879822,
0.04369625076651573,
0.11982188373804092,
0.569096028804779,
0.2366672307252884,
0.15628409385681152,
-0.5206031203269958,
0.22820934653282166,
-0.1164654791355133,
0.16086511313915253,
0.14794492721557617,
0.44186145067214966,
-0.4338257312774658,
0.4297361671924591,
0.45307672023773193,
-0.05408695340156555,
0.20796969532966614,
-0.24610021710395813,
0.7220919132232666,
-1.2900145053863525,
-0.5112707018852234,
-0.9800733327865601,
0.44822922348976135,
0.24537594616413116,
-0.3045269846916199,
0.41414114832878113,
0.4864072799682617,
0.9116207361221313,
-0.014561825431883335,
0.574878454208374,
-0.5522705912590027,
0.19719167053699493,
-0.556532084941864,
0.28333616256713867,
-0.0672147199511528,
-0.0660177543759346,
-0.06941182166337967,
-0.9532343149185181,
-0.3963737189769745,
0.6865254044532776,
-0.2572880685329437,
-0.3669474422931671,
1.0469379425048828,
0.6278372406959534,
0.1418871283531189,
0.2726821005344391,
0.2194482982158661,
0.08262117952108383,
-0.05801134184002876,
0.1703396588563919,
0.9962350726127625,
-0.60121089220047,
0.2524818778038025,
0.12685337662696838,
-0.00769348768517375,
-0.12979178130626678,
-0.7203106880187988,
-0.4169146716594696,
-0.998473584651947,
-0.2746264338493347,
-0.3857939541339874,
0.12891225516796112,
1.1642379760742188,
0.42001914978027344,
-0.6255357265472412,
-0.651002049446106,
-0.5296173691749573,
0.3250785171985626,
-0.37137746810913086,
-0.15672707557678223,
0.03270288556814194,
-0.14196795225143433,
-0.5223428606987,
0.6620305180549622,
0.38795021176338196,
0.1567862182855606,
0.06657130271196365,
-0.23761798441410065,
-0.3092062473297119,
-0.10758395493030548,
0.9586719274520874,
1.0176488161087036,
-0.9188772439956665,
-0.3399514853954315,
-0.17913107573986053,
-0.02281285636126995,
0.1842004805803299,
1.514526128768921,
-0.8341158628463745,
0.5220902562141418,
0.5764288306236267,
0.25014787912368774,
0.4280541241168976,
-0.41077202558517456,
0.8054494857788086,
-0.2313520312309265,
0.5625221729278564,
0.15037031471729279,
0.29274946451187134,
0.15969228744506836,
-0.0781187191605568,
0.7557238340377808,
0.45639798045158386,
-0.5937193632125854,
-0.5401982069015503,
0.7938060760498047,
-0.9349825978279114,
-0.04500449821352959,
1.0097770690917969,
0.1623552441596985,
-0.21395878493785858,
-0.3567908704280853,
-0.4755428731441498,
0.36947235465049744,
-0.09125002473592758,
0.6143588423728943,
0.6457343101501465,
-0.453315794467926,
-0.14266173541545868,
-0.37538230419158936,
0.5604382157325745,
0.07457634806632996,
-0.6585620641708374,
-0.2714434862136841,
0.4741096794605255,
0.0803312212228775,
0.538726806640625,
1.0746359825134277,
-0.09253186732530594,
0.3660348355770111,
0.13633927702903748,
0.1231793686747551,
0.5498079657554626,
-0.060659442096948624,
-0.14728675782680511,
-0.10106514394283295,
0.08775738626718521,
-0.18539957702159882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05723v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05723v1
|
Computational lexical analysis of Flamenco genres
| 2024-05-09T12:35:33 | 2024-05-09T12:35:33 |
Pablo Rosillo-Rodes, Maxi San Miguel, David Sanchez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Flamenco, recognized by UNESCO as part of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of
Humanity, is a profound expression of cultural identity rooted in Andalusia,
Spain. However, there is a lack of quantitative studies that help identify
characteristic patterns in this long-lived music tradition. In this work, we
present a computational analysis of Flamenco lyrics, employing natural language
processing and machine learning to categorize over 2000 lyrics into their
respective Flamenco genres, termed as $\textit{palos}$. Using a Multinomial
Naive Bayes classifier, we find that lexical variation across styles enables to
accurately identify distinct $\textit{palos}$. More importantly, from an
automatic method of word usage, we obtain the semantic fields that characterize
each style. Further, applying a metric that quantifies the inter-genre distance
we perform a network analysis that sheds light on the relationship between
Flamenco styles. Remarkably, our results suggest historical connections and
$\textit{palo}$ evolutions. Overall, our work illuminates the intricate
relationships and cultural significance embedded within Flamenco lyrics,
complementing previous qualitative discussions with quantitative analyses and
sparking new discussions on the origin and development of traditional music
genres.
|
[
-0.5238348841667175,
-0.6038183569908142,
-0.07444984465837479,
0.8115150332450867,
0.022880828008055687,
0.4453772306442261,
-0.4029250144958496,
-0.5284097194671631,
0.4757252037525177,
0.6834841966629028,
-0.5219915509223938,
-0.673118531703949,
-0.4200696051120758,
0.19349512457847595,
-0.38229116797447205,
1.2111072540283203,
0.07099027186632156,
-0.20900076627731323,
-0.06053423136472702,
-0.13624690473079681,
-0.09552811831235886,
-0.0279647558927536,
-0.07632001489400864,
0.06569311767816544,
0.5922467112541199,
0.26811593770980835,
0.5232334733009338,
0.586260199546814,
0.8611770272254944,
0.2856576144695282,
-0.22045771777629852,
0.36926600337028503,
-0.5202240347862244,
0.34685131907463074,
-0.02354709431529045,
-0.11110804229974747,
-0.04860308766365051,
-0.10359471291303635,
0.4973859488964081,
0.3643474280834198,
-0.19296085834503174,
0.30205342173576355,
-0.21804358065128326,
0.8689207434654236,
-0.5188269019126892,
0.14527148008346558,
-0.9165043830871582,
0.18415161967277527,
-0.7770528197288513,
-0.5820931792259216,
0.009887151420116425,
-0.9361578226089478,
0.19563345611095428,
-0.5106319189071655,
0.3770565092563629,
-0.11382729560136795,
0.9007902145385742,
0.20341794192790985,
-0.3873249590396881,
-0.6558347344398499,
-0.9380508661270142,
0.3775103986263275,
0.010117409750819206,
0.24163995683193207,
0.1699790060520172,
0.6383252143859863,
-0.44260916113853455,
-0.4436996281147003,
-0.6073640584945679,
-0.34529200196266174,
0.11762114614248276,
-0.021951498463749886,
-0.005134523380547762,
-0.08964335918426514,
-0.01380560640245676,
0.613517165184021,
-0.6476601362228394,
-0.20064255595207214,
-0.8813964128494263,
-0.21062123775482178,
0.690433144569397,
0.21687155961990356,
0.3324941098690033,
-0.2169293463230133,
-0.4902988076210022,
-0.12408223003149033,
-0.8899279236793518,
0.5297107696533203,
0.4674910306930542,
0.04175443947315216,
-0.14807501435279846,
0.4479236900806427,
-0.142678365111351,
0.8078217506408691,
-0.42121437191963196,
-0.5554590821266174,
0.20883317291736603,
-0.20552508533000946,
0.002968334127217531,
0.07580514252185822,
1.2811850309371948,
0.2960200309753418,
0.4837760627269745,
-0.3435618579387665,
0.1158105805516243,
0.22794552147388458,
0.1537034958600998,
-0.33520838618278503,
-0.42391911149024963,
-0.20113487541675568,
-0.24779735505580902,
-0.5440680980682373,
0.23006004095077515,
-0.8200637698173523,
-0.721055269241333,
-0.2352401167154312,
0.18195639550685883,
-0.3152585029602051,
-0.19568030536174774,
0.11101283133029938,
-0.3888344466686249,
0.05153238773345947,
-0.0480940118432045,
-0.6061446070671082,
0.32161909341812134,
0.6443719267845154,
0.9370702505111694,
0.12836436927318573,
0.006828147452324629,
0.1207861453294754,
-0.1108720526099205,
-0.4723149240016937,
0.7042044997215271,
-0.6493783593177795,
-0.6546802520751953,
-0.18967372179031372,
0.015913859009742737,
-0.12055909633636475,
-0.6040955781936646,
0.6849642395973206,
-0.7173760533332825,
-0.13976642489433289,
-0.3488461673259735,
-0.2779606282711029,
-0.4828183352947235,
0.03612072020769119,
-0.836699366569519,
1.1495752334594727,
0.017066651955246925,
-0.8155008554458618,
0.28761765360832214,
-0.19912898540496826,
-0.38711562752723694,
-0.2059885859489441,
-0.2715981602668762,
-0.29897356033325195,
0.09967279434204102,
-0.07516754418611526,
0.3562818765640259,
-0.7070832252502441,
0.30665498971939087,
-0.5299875736236572,
-0.48336347937583923,
0.6727296113967896,
-0.11170841008424759,
0.6872954964637756,
0.5030457973480225,
-0.3015260398387909,
0.042718321084976196,
-0.8587520718574524,
-0.34639623761177063,
-0.2792532444000244,
-0.10614088922739029,
-0.28273388743400574,
0.1212940663099289,
0.22652775049209595,
0.4785153269767761,
-0.1034020334482193,
-0.5141465067863464,
0.14117075502872467,
-0.5334615707397461,
0.37115010619163513,
0.36517658829689026,
0.10665563493967056,
0.31148236989974976,
-0.3796483278274536,
0.8039653897285461,
-0.37963244318962097,
-0.01403601374477148,
0.12593409419059753,
-0.43090349435806274,
-0.367636501789093,
-0.35895299911499023,
0.21833737194538116,
0.5922434329986572,
-0.6167653203010559,
0.23579636216163635,
-0.4806106388568878,
-0.8965117335319519,
-0.460673063993454,
-0.05427234619855881,
0.05889905244112015,
0.5051420331001282,
0.1342516392469406,
-0.1933780312538147,
-0.6494662761688232,
-0.724905252456665,
-0.09781605750322342,
-0.14899618923664093,
0.21773676574230194,
0.2142953723669052,
0.3029954433441162,
-0.006398545112460852,
1.265080451965332,
-0.2868529260158539,
-0.4443514943122864,
0.3801519274711609,
0.1971270740032196,
0.2568856179714203,
0.31563353538513184,
0.8138337135314941,
-0.7359405755996704,
-0.6242722868919373,
0.7117223739624023,
-0.5693270564079285,
-0.2898159921169281,
-0.01414700597524643,
-0.19641241431236267,
-0.44119828939437866,
0.45092448592185974,
0.318148672580719,
0.1414167881011963,
0.5406724810600281,
-0.08453202247619629,
0.48338302969932556,
0.21006213128566742,
0.3460308313369751,
-0.5648658871650696,
0.10101699084043503,
0.10461446642875671,
0.472677618265152,
-0.43563657999038696,
-0.268013596534729,
-0.07828539609909058,
0.17833632230758667,
-0.2855357527732849,
0.4873732328414917,
-0.12032043933868408,
-0.03419426828622818,
-0.21068128943443298,
-0.1446017026901245,
-0.0051180701702833176,
0.30060625076293945,
0.45661601424217224,
0.4167717397212982,
0.7260946035385132,
-0.4278102219104767,
0.904986560344696,
-0.4335920512676239,
-0.3784868121147156,
0.6441686153411865,
-0.6027625203132629,
-0.17051099240779877,
-0.3337174654006958,
0.22820612788200378,
-1.2123299837112427,
-0.1652999073266983,
0.14918829500675201,
-0.4831060767173767,
-0.10981415957212448,
-0.33804866671562195,
-0.4603154957294464,
-0.4719102382659912,
-0.316195547580719,
0.5360729098320007,
0.04760717228055,
-0.11832572519779205,
0.024767359718680382,
0.63534015417099,
-0.033877551555633545,
-0.5199556350708008,
-0.04731685295701027,
0.007632785476744175,
-0.7910619378089905,
-1.0036892890930176,
0.5228967070579529,
0.2877757251262665,
-0.5043535828590393,
-0.23125727474689484,
0.04729267954826355,
-0.3115919232368469,
0.2158416211605072,
0.43742504715919495,
0.0871337428689003,
-0.3492583632469177,
0.477847695350647,
0.36353176832199097,
0.3146550953388214,
0.21253444254398346,
-0.46218380331993103,
0.37680497765541077,
-0.3774232566356659,
0.340403288602829,
-0.3082531988620758,
-0.0006317729130387306,
0.8395846486091614,
-0.5894734859466553,
0.7271216511726379,
0.851006805896759,
-0.033761993050575256,
-0.16531851887702942,
-0.465909481048584,
0.37934213876724243,
-0.4313080608844757,
-0.02853088639676571,
-0.4173126816749573,
-0.7616109251976013,
0.7474493384361267,
-0.01316526997834444,
-0.27195289731025696,
0.8042910099029541,
0.5423698425292969,
-0.4946971535682678,
-0.03499361127614975,
0.35476693511009216,
-0.036471180617809296,
0.3855143189430237,
-0.44603273272514343,
-0.5912339091300964,
-0.5611429214477539,
-0.7427479028701782,
-0.8528880476951599,
-0.48992693424224854,
-0.9469077587127686,
-0.5102667808532715,
0.8004114031791687,
-0.08688163012266159,
-0.23788467049598694,
0.2994163930416107,
-0.5274401307106018,
0.8132928013801575,
0.13368280231952667,
-0.19947762787342072,
0.20751206576824188,
-0.050566788762807846,
-0.009719038382172585,
-0.051991257816553116,
-0.13443271815776825,
-0.29170385003089905,
1.155872106552124,
0.31922945380210876,
0.7483227849006653,
0.4300589859485626,
0.7244178056716919,
0.5257394313812256,
0.2722059190273285,
-0.7002266645431519,
0.04850585386157036,
-0.2406226098537445,
-0.5817990303039551,
-0.19947746396064758,
-0.45600298047065735,
-0.999261200428009,
0.37905555963516235,
-0.40284794569015503,
-0.6242479085922241,
0.36913079023361206,
-0.0021083191968500614,
-0.4188958704471588,
0.12263765931129456,
-0.13668741285800934,
0.9459733963012695,
-0.07284602522850037,
-0.26168009638786316,
0.11875494569540024,
-0.9234729409217834,
0.6317207217216492,
-0.06065350025892258,
0.6823499202728271,
-0.3846947252750397,
0.015238498337566853,
0.9057544469833374,
-0.32667076587677,
0.566449761390686,
0.32789161801338196,
-0.45241862535476685,
0.6640769839286804,
0.44285571575164795,
0.10316070169210434,
0.1137925386428833,
-0.219376802444458,
-0.0422927550971508,
0.33500587940216064,
-0.09938323497772217,
-0.424410879611969,
0.8888842463493347,
-0.7612940669059753,
0.35092562437057495,
-0.3006940186023712,
-0.16741912066936493,
-0.2974430322647095,
-0.21423764526844025,
0.648395836353302,
0.4085554778575897,
-0.5050027966499329,
0.162530779838562,
0.6433026194572449,
-0.053028032183647156,
0.3604012727737427,
0.19775605201721191,
-0.41101279854774475,
-0.6804623007774353,
1.154622197151184,
0.2042500525712967,
-0.014944366179406643,
0.6088512539863586,
0.3952040672302246,
-0.5037264823913574,
-0.15264485776424408,
-0.6003699898719788,
0.39527830481529236,
-0.4101201891899109,
0.06339702755212784,
-0.39152008295059204,
0.17018760740756989,
-0.16290460526943207,
-0.22777533531188965,
-0.0787726640701294,
-0.46452394127845764,
-0.2605645954608917,
0.1144212856888771,
0.6519219279289246,
0.9245399236679077,
0.11536609381437302,
0.46591970324516296,
-0.7921580672264099,
0.18484143912792206,
0.207364022731781,
0.21871277689933777,
0.029830733314156532,
-0.2954111099243164,
-0.10302358865737915,
-0.26751789450645447,
-0.22426962852478027,
-1.4922796487808228,
0.3140110671520233,
0.4837351143360138,
0.08904971927404404,
0.5687505602836609,
-0.10284052789211273,
0.5736663341522217,
-0.33641090989112854,
0.36989516019821167,
0.09655946493148804,
-0.7886412143707275,
0.5430160164833069,
-0.922516405582428,
-0.21364302933216095,
0.6654711365699768,
0.5436216592788696,
-1.052860140800476,
-0.17235024273395538,
-0.4096534550189972,
-0.632838249206543,
0.3848203420639038,
0.2276459038257599,
-0.02822820097208023,
-0.04162486270070076,
0.22338762879371643,
0.25176799297332764,
0.40961340069770813,
-0.6117525696754456,
-0.18264801800251007,
-0.1755407601594925,
-0.09449512511491776,
0.044865529984235764,
0.3740774989128113,
-0.015432244166731834,
-0.4508526027202606,
0.2989422380924225,
0.10250384360551834,
0.017110178247094154,
-0.29743432998657227,
0.06396880000829697,
-0.08175890892744064,
0.30323323607444763,
0.7380090355873108,
0.33494800329208374,
-0.04785021394491196,
0.15345893800258636,
-0.23314416408538818,
-0.6600908041000366,
0.06032383814454079,
-0.18845245242118835,
0.1810794323682785,
0.02694740518927574,
0.28282487392425537,
0.612471878528595,
0.08929233253002167,
-0.5797077417373657,
0.16495762765407562,
0.3065870702266693,
0.21995390951633453,
-0.4028577506542206,
0.15605616569519043,
0.029093146324157715,
0.07918887585401535,
0.20412662625312805,
0.15157225728034973,
0.45608076453208923,
-0.663323700428009,
0.12601208686828613,
0.39978164434432983,
-0.5808420181274414,
-0.17276975512504578,
0.3561854958534241,
0.2550658583641052,
0.018015006557106972,
0.23180603981018066,
-0.1915207952260971,
-0.4963517487049103,
0.9586314558982849,
0.07742465287446976,
0.7534803152084351,
-0.09342321753501892,
0.524316132068634,
0.2925231456756592,
0.2781234383583069,
0.11475542187690735,
0.13707487285137177,
-0.4040715992450714,
-0.23804645240306854,
-0.2478196918964386,
-1.2811366319656372,
-0.06581217050552368,
-0.4331744611263275,
-0.5133761763572693,
0.324225515127182,
-0.27959099411964417,
-0.031085098162293434,
0.17850904166698456,
-0.31000691652297974,
-0.4479280114173889,
0.21204456686973572,
0.0816630944609642,
0.37952449917793274,
-1.167933464050293,
0.7364147901535034,
0.39214104413986206,
-0.19647987186908722,
-0.4755774736404419,
-0.2773449420928955,
0.4255209267139435,
-0.4032338559627533,
0.9192114472389221,
-0.2523818910121918,
-0.5080211758613586,
-0.24869254231452942,
-0.16629531979560852,
-1.0188438892364502,
0.6640979051589966,
-0.12797580659389496,
-0.292601615190506,
0.09263841807842255,
0.1931743323802948,
0.9057121276855469,
-0.20639030635356903,
0.19717903435230255,
0.7602739334106445,
0.2850929796695709,
0.7443768382072449,
-1.2637453079223633,
-0.6054944396018982,
-0.366969496011734,
0.04297073930501938,
0.6026486158370972,
-0.348167359828949,
0.9577664136886597,
0.07325642555952072,
-0.11169114708900452,
0.09970666468143463,
0.714316189289093,
-0.047954775393009186,
0.35262706875801086,
-0.008747736923396587,
0.2882653772830963,
0.8476696610450745,
-0.4033709466457367,
0.6385618448257446,
0.08999811857938766,
0.5668442249298096,
0.7224336862564087,
-0.027877062559127808,
0.6156608462333679,
0.05252859741449356,
-0.6905412077903748,
0.827492356300354,
0.9891729354858398,
0.008389548398554325,
0.28829872608184814,
0.835494339466095,
-0.3987548053264618,
-0.004781144205480814,
-0.11828331649303436,
-0.5884391665458679,
0.9460004568099976,
0.5797568559646606,
-0.6919243931770325,
-0.08063916862010956,
0.08217350393533707,
0.29622581601142883,
0.20408330857753754,
-0.4561872184276581,
0.8005694150924683,
-0.27315863966941833,
-0.509427011013031,
0.6867501139640808,
0.0577993206679821,
0.6492272019386292,
-0.4386996924877167,
0.09951095283031464,
0.05126654729247093,
-0.11380862444639206,
-0.4658527970314026,
-0.7040479779243469,
0.3817715644836426,
-0.006544038187712431,
-0.22300280630588531,
0.16014985740184784,
0.3342304229736328,
-0.4882451891899109,
-0.6400914788246155,
-0.09322643280029297,
0.08645500242710114,
0.03779837489128113,
-0.018711229786276817,
-0.24377810955047607,
0.16341203451156616,
-0.21217022836208344,
0.4135115146636963,
-0.06143897399306297,
0.7427042126655579,
-0.3923531174659729,
0.337138831615448,
0.47059035301208496,
0.22428414225578308,
0.396830677986145,
-0.21187295019626617,
0.5804563760757446,
-0.5749258995056152,
-0.6357200145721436,
-1.025715708732605,
0.29611486196517944,
0.12487742304801941,
-0.5632712841033936,
0.6821713447570801,
0.43584707379341125,
0.6513894200325012,
-0.15626145899295807,
0.4535748362541199,
-0.14225244522094727,
0.35876840353012085,
-0.5382908582687378,
0.8801076412200928,
-0.44205549359321594,
0.42186418175697327,
-0.8660969138145447,
-0.7705320715904236,
-0.4187389314174652,
0.5280025005340576,
-0.383634090423584,
-0.22388245165348053,
0.29244622588157654,
0.65859055519104,
0.21510736644268036,
0.4372303783893585,
-0.29186689853668213,
-0.21796807646751404,
-0.026544198393821716,
0.29698657989501953,
1.0916327238082886,
0.011858886107802391,
0.4436012804508209,
-0.609217643737793,
-0.2700498402118683,
-0.31288230419158936,
-0.6194552779197693,
-0.3700019121170044,
-0.803257167339325,
-0.2779184877872467,
-0.3211422860622406,
-0.224100261926651,
0.9388161301612854,
0.3168868124485016,
-0.6428664326667786,
-0.9381670951843262,
0.3173060119152069,
0.5383462905883789,
-0.39071518182754517,
-0.24186809360980988,
0.4613191485404968,
-0.06924191117286682,
-0.40585896372795105,
0.23856733739376068,
0.2729022800922394,
-0.020795375108718872,
-0.37558624148368835,
0.04809713736176491,
0.27897417545318604,
0.05927465856075287,
0.6349102258682251,
0.6149896383285522,
-0.8894497156143188,
0.16251684725284576,
0.37227895855903625,
0.0016424403293058276,
-0.04487694799900055,
0.9888734817504883,
-0.9952541589736938,
0.8358563780784607,
0.6653273701667786,
0.23447638750076294,
0.3068896234035492,
-0.21730192005634308,
0.1199941337108612,
-0.6690694689750671,
-0.0747976154088974,
0.4528108537197113,
0.07980823516845703,
-0.029574202373623848,
-0.0034886267967522144,
0.4802805185317993,
0.5030066967010498,
-0.2840598225593567,
-0.5311214923858643,
0.038089603185653687,
-1.2056957483291626,
0.028831928968429565,
1.113970398902893,
0.15837334096431732,
-0.2056313008069992,
-0.2335735261440277,
-0.3034645915031433,
-0.01930040866136551,
-0.1724890023469925,
0.7952975034713745,
0.5348618626594543,
-0.36474332213401794,
0.27694937586784363,
-0.1838149130344391,
0.8693519830703735,
-0.4395528733730316,
-0.6254873871803284,
-0.3108483850955963,
0.8106668591499329,
0.22224919497966766,
0.31081902980804443,
0.3434983193874359,
-0.2736465036869049,
0.47192636132240295,
-0.3986275792121887,
-0.044454265385866165,
0.2793896496295929,
-0.72621750831604,
-0.17579583823680878,
0.6656985282897949,
-0.11075302213430405,
-0.27123308181762695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05705v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05705v1
|
Detecting Statements in Text: A Domain-Agnostic Few-Shot Solution
| 2024-05-09T12:03:38 | 2024-05-09T12:03:38 |
Sandrine Chausson, Björn Ross
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Many tasks related to Computational Social Science and Web Content Analysis
involve classifying pieces of text based on the claims they contain.
State-of-the-art approaches usually involve fine-tuning models on large
annotated datasets, which are costly to produce. In light of this, we propose
and release a qualitative and versatile few-shot learning methodology as a
common paradigm for any claim-based textual classification task. This
methodology involves defining the classes as arbitrarily sophisticated
taxonomies of claims, and using Natural Language Inference models to obtain the
textual entailment between these and a corpus of interest. The performance of
these models is then boosted by annotating a minimal sample of data points,
dynamically sampled using the well-established statistical heuristic of
Probabilistic Bisection. We illustrate this methodology in the context of three
tasks: climate change contrarianism detection, topic/stance classification and
depression-relates symptoms detection. This approach rivals traditional
pre-train/fine-tune approaches while drastically reducing the need for data
annotation.
|
[
-0.21507528424263,
-1.0398883819580078,
0.6132947206497192,
-0.18390561640262604,
-0.31771278381347656,
0.11162744462490082,
-0.17416785657405853,
-0.5471610426902771,
0.13753892481327057,
0.36385393142700195,
-0.47310882806777954,
-0.6110109090805054,
-0.6294309496879578,
0.2628723680973053,
-0.3728439211845398,
1.1520639657974243,
0.1950141042470932,
-0.3369200825691223,
-0.12477025389671326,
0.16832329332828522,
0.053263526409864426,
-0.05342802032828331,
-0.4454006552696228,
-0.5134585499763489,
0.4879695773124695,
0.481620728969574,
0.5189123153686523,
0.35591360926628113,
0.4635901153087616,
0.17757752537727356,
-0.1062687560915947,
0.3245786428451538,
-0.3744581639766693,
-0.06489334255456924,
-0.290776789188385,
-0.7519805431365967,
0.11351028084754944,
0.11755067855119705,
0.4409681260585785,
0.5193597674369812,
0.051885783672332764,
0.34501025080680847,
0.24141740798950195,
0.2904169261455536,
-0.9863401055335999,
0.18575620651245117,
-0.935323178768158,
-0.024053193628787994,
-0.4854983985424042,
-0.10970836132764816,
-0.5436756610870361,
-0.26664912700653076,
0.21152181923389435,
-0.6600913405418396,
0.49251776933670044,
-0.03940471634268761,
0.8704528212547302,
0.12020467966794968,
-0.4333062171936035,
-0.12966814637184143,
-0.5707436203956604,
1.027596116065979,
-0.5984210968017578,
-0.0653425008058548,
0.7432403564453125,
0.31447601318359375,
-0.010129760950803757,
-0.4648059904575348,
-0.8207470178604126,
0.2144559770822525,
-0.14309749007225037,
0.11810995638370514,
-0.3875165581703186,
-0.11283694207668304,
0.12763254344463348,
0.01608699932694435,
-0.5283524394035339,
0.16466490924358368,
-0.2371199131011963,
-0.40981587767601013,
0.6750838160514832,
0.07263774424791336,
-0.05774755775928497,
-0.635877788066864,
-0.41157492995262146,
0.2162477970123291,
-0.6128779053688049,
-0.0916876420378685,
0.19076873362064362,
0.7463280558586121,
-0.23965825140476227,
0.4355989396572113,
-0.2980576157569885,
0.6474560499191284,
-0.04200620949268341,
-0.32155707478523254,
-0.12994270026683807,
-0.27137231826782227,
-0.25429317355155945,
0.10270874947309494,
0.6965847015380859,
0.013757177628576756,
0.11806893348693848,
0.09098093211650848,
-0.07067596167325974,
0.35547879338264465,
0.17741867899894714,
-0.6563774943351746,
-0.5621668696403503,
0.16349947452545166,
-0.4340832531452179,
-0.33893877267837524,
-0.1621677130460739,
-0.7436910271644592,
-0.6816310882568359,
-0.2205095738172531,
0.3373013734817505,
-0.4949173033237457,
-0.2118847519159317,
0.04403894394636154,
-0.15123523771762848,
0.039153628051280975,
0.452507883310318,
-0.6076557636260986,
0.22737564146518707,
0.7270901799201965,
0.9398778676986694,
-0.2731671929359436,
0.19078116118907928,
-0.5204415917396545,
0.13542361557483673,
-0.4177909791469574,
1.3722296953201294,
-0.7023537158966064,
-0.2714908719062805,
0.26307353377342224,
-0.25460919737815857,
0.2278963029384613,
-0.4532879590988159,
0.5522329807281494,
-0.47990280389785767,
0.16027188301086426,
-0.33347630500793457,
-0.740149736404419,
-0.10922567546367645,
0.4798343777656555,
-0.4905776381492615,
0.8328845500946045,
0.06579840183258057,
-0.938418447971344,
0.6145992875099182,
-0.32932883501052856,
-0.2992543578147888,
0.2947935163974762,
-0.19060464203357697,
-0.5675448179244995,
0.045534711331129074,
-0.25641024112701416,
0.5402892231941223,
-0.3233959674835205,
-0.004985056351870298,
-0.2513740658760071,
-0.03267279267311096,
0.15773479640483856,
-0.2962017357349396,
0.7277020215988159,
0.2373177409172058,
-0.18942713737487793,
-0.1496821939945221,
-0.8460845947265625,
-0.07627151906490326,
0.07555638998746872,
-0.27478137612342834,
-0.6146012544631958,
0.14836736023426056,
0.17029790580272675,
-0.028678100556135178,
0.06630188971757889,
-0.6217323541641235,
0.21392661333084106,
-0.5071068406105042,
0.06111227720975876,
0.5321832895278931,
0.22701138257980347,
0.2880443334579468,
-0.27700790762901306,
0.3817085921764374,
0.2078913301229477,
-0.02096605859696865,
-0.1955430954694748,
-0.44226041436195374,
-0.5794450640678406,
-0.5245556235313416,
0.27277615666389465,
0.5833807587623596,
-1.0578652620315552,
0.2956886887550354,
0.06781162321567535,
-0.37219709157943726,
-0.2210683673620224,
0.29249095916748047,
0.4568672776222229,
0.4390053153038025,
0.5774649977684021,
-0.05325848236680031,
-0.4526110887527466,
-0.7886863946914673,
-0.5993580222129822,
-0.4295615255832672,
-0.11389932781457901,
-0.19674964249134064,
0.7324624061584473,
-0.04292431101202965,
1.338396668434143,
-0.8645690083503723,
-0.524853527545929,
-0.2954587936401367,
0.8263167142868042,
0.044245388358831406,
0.26110658049583435,
0.5893009901046753,
-0.8004477620124817,
-0.5164144039154053,
-0.10546553134918213,
-0.6332231163978577,
-0.022189946845173836,
-0.22212515771389008,
0.09181895852088928,
0.09875097870826721,
0.17739209532737732,
-0.48289021849632263,
0.5709188580513,
-0.08091079443693161,
-0.027308525517582893,
0.5195786952972412,
0.30761560797691345,
-0.2476639300584793,
-0.9290598630905151,
-0.3213038444519043,
0.5859394669532776,
-0.44197213649749756,
-0.6473402976989746,
-0.30104950070381165,
-0.16051262617111206,
0.35935378074645996,
-0.4823509454727173,
0.4278731048107147,
-0.14854484796524048,
0.45862284302711487,
-0.6212019324302673,
0.11356107890605927,
-0.016884779557585716,
0.12364707887172699,
0.29417482018470764,
0.20456384122371674,
0.49434754252433777,
-0.6381293535232544,
0.10291586071252823,
0.40660417079925537,
-0.30414944887161255,
0.803257942199707,
-0.31940001249313354,
0.1618516594171524,
-0.40030136704444885,
0.12023258954286575,
-0.9646413922309875,
-0.3603511452674866,
0.3291766345500946,
-0.41205260157585144,
0.11563363671302795,
-0.15533219277858734,
-0.48641908168792725,
-0.08789792656898499,
-0.45324403047561646,
0.10555568337440491,
0.19799640774726868,
-0.44701245427131653,
0.2608848810195923,
0.3920348286628723,
-0.11681338399648666,
-0.4284757971763611,
-0.6215581297874451,
0.0897316038608551,
-0.2654314637184143,
0.11645542085170746,
0.4245738387107849,
0.28439560532569885,
-0.4667741358280182,
0.0624869279563427,
-0.22842523455619812,
-0.44680190086364746,
0.07256168127059937,
-0.014729427173733711,
0.2821781635284424,
-0.005730436649173498,
0.355734646320343,
0.056963253766298294,
-0.13205313682556152,
-0.1652863323688507,
-0.2476942539215088,
0.1283666342496872,
-0.07301884144544601,
-0.10977194458246231,
-0.41612812876701355,
0.4392315745353699,
-0.18025681376457214,
-0.05998612940311432,
0.6251746416091919,
0.5649560689926147,
-0.7157299518585205,
-0.5199980139732361,
-0.36750566959381104,
-0.09278207272291183,
-0.38538047671318054,
-0.08524201065301895,
-0.2802158296108246,
-0.7520843148231506,
0.20824043452739716,
-0.346947580575943,
0.184080570936203,
0.553429365158081,
0.34984856843948364,
-0.28175103664398193,
0.6515241265296936,
0.8760069012641907,
0.0022104759700596333,
0.41594263911247253,
-0.2509985566139221,
0.34235695004463196,
-0.12518778443336487,
-0.0167017113417387,
-0.8200095891952515,
-0.08947653323411942,
-0.591293454170227,
-0.23716294765472412,
0.4227278530597687,
0.047298554331064224,
-0.09456690400838852,
0.4046840965747833,
-0.47821080684661865,
0.6698386669158936,
0.4064376652240753,
0.2500358819961548,
0.5044235587120056,
-0.07050183415412903,
0.2685176134109497,
-0.09468474984169006,
-0.5637131929397583,
-0.9361446499824524,
0.8477553129196167,
0.04312954843044281,
0.6834783554077148,
0.20404304563999176,
0.9637517929077148,
0.5530161261558533,
0.5101102590560913,
-1.0809149742126465,
0.5019842982292175,
-0.10640273988246918,
-0.7345983982086182,
-0.1683901995420456,
-0.3186926543712616,
-0.9953824281692505,
0.293597012758255,
-0.6929436922073364,
-0.8922953605651855,
0.2786417305469513,
0.20316894352436066,
-0.6094299554824829,
0.22803816199302673,
-0.4459163546562195,
0.6470826268196106,
0.08330544829368591,
-0.5514645576477051,
-0.4353010058403015,
-0.6677247881889343,
0.42474833130836487,
-0.2679823338985443,
0.24226948618888855,
-0.2586430311203003,
0.056082047522068024,
0.6977879405021667,
-0.08225319534540176,
1.383048415184021,
-0.2525179386138916,
-0.029758542776107788,
0.6843230128288269,
0.1102169007062912,
0.33701416850090027,
-0.06565029174089432,
0.04133588820695877,
0.030360478907823563,
0.5275559425354004,
-0.5458865761756897,
-0.35004207491874695,
0.060114357620477676,
-0.4095240831375122,
-0.3109884262084961,
-0.6432439088821411,
-0.014195792376995087,
-0.22876302897930145,
0.28801068663597107,
0.4048990309238434,
0.09406841546297073,
-0.5540702939033508,
-0.007247894071042538,
0.5779114961624146,
-0.16082461178302765,
0.4921320080757141,
0.5769874453544617,
0.12938854098320007,
-0.14252488315105438,
0.7980540990829468,
0.10812196135520935,
0.07035932689905167,
0.4682141840457916,
0.3929729163646698,
-0.1814931333065033,
-0.5778653621673584,
0.18284210562705994,
0.18127024173736572,
-0.7163753509521484,
-0.7590683698654175,
-0.5173192620277405,
0.1323598325252533,
-0.4183831810951233,
-0.10951758921146393,
-0.28021883964538574,
-0.3165971338748932,
-0.4098730981349945,
-0.15095208585262299,
0.34276023507118225,
0.611497163772583,
-0.03914887458086014,
0.7556782960891724,
-0.8573961853981018,
0.7396841645240784,
0.15834172070026398,
0.04424428194761276,
-0.3957154452800751,
-0.171110600233078,
-0.3428918719291687,
0.039191752672195435,
-0.6571995615959167,
-0.9571861028671265,
0.3668365478515625,
0.410944402217865,
0.33677786588668823,
0.6714333295822144,
0.47652000188827515,
0.33467355370521545,
-0.4137420952320099,
0.8959910273551941,
0.4442782700061798,
-1.046608328819275,
0.8217679858207703,
-0.1303003430366516,
0.05206715315580368,
0.8594910502433777,
0.8295268416404724,
-0.34126952290534973,
-0.18685461580753326,
-0.6089815497398376,
-0.4052671790122986,
0.3984448313713074,
-0.08573345094919205,
0.10186626017093658,
-0.42717936635017395,
0.37029141187667847,
0.36570867896080017,
0.18227848410606384,
-0.49722781777381897,
0.10891430824995041,
-0.09969288110733032,
-0.34290581941604614,
0.003672814229503274,
-0.08019832521677017,
-0.3701440691947937,
-0.04938273876905441,
0.6788602471351624,
-0.7347659468650818,
-0.0389675498008728,
0.282548725605011,
-0.2717214524745941,
0.033135224133729935,
0.5333312153816223,
0.11206184327602386,
0.6215410828590393,
-0.0030026354361325502,
0.4993625283241272,
0.057065244764089584,
-0.27057474851608276,
0.08202401548624039,
-0.04957999289035797,
-0.363050639629364,
0.32111725211143494,
0.560923159122467,
0.40660756826400757,
0.09285108000040054,
-0.45109492540359497,
0.6601914763450623,
0.3405062258243561,
-0.14418889582157135,
-0.15051275491714478,
-0.04208115488290787,
-0.3177475929260254,
0.4180561900138855,
0.46468472480773926,
0.048662956804037094,
0.40854454040527344,
-0.747098982334137,
0.2939101457595825,
0.5280231237411499,
-0.19484727084636688,
-0.6117633581161499,
0.5555959939956665,
0.08786221593618393,
-0.20289207994937897,
0.14210133254528046,
-0.44097545742988586,
-0.5396834015846252,
0.26393720507621765,
0.4861423373222351,
0.9096397161483765,
0.013568717986345291,
0.7326629757881165,
0.26987671852111816,
0.19963125884532928,
-0.4185400903224945,
0.08670905977487564,
-0.19542869925498962,
-1.0841432809829712,
-0.3978334665298462,
-0.533486545085907,
-0.6149008274078369,
-0.04195210710167885,
-0.5649046897888184,
0.4019775986671448,
-0.5202518105506897,
-0.44993019104003906,
0.4854295551776886,
0.1753220111131668,
-0.5231161117553711,
0.18966424465179443,
0.3452736437320709,
0.8194994330406189,
-1.1975798606872559,
0.7227040529251099,
0.529080867767334,
-0.4427749216556549,
-0.12670007348060608,
0.2966492176055908,
0.6066898703575134,
-0.42622095346450806,
0.5572317838668823,
-0.0254882350564003,
-0.4681957960128784,
-0.17032401263713837,
-1.0908119678497314,
-0.17597295343875885,
0.5566275119781494,
0.3287814259529114,
-0.31302109360694885,
0.05079251527786255,
0.03800584375858307,
0.5119325518608093,
-0.2170291692018509,
-0.09539108723402023,
0.6729424595832825,
0.41876307129859924,
-0.025915751233696938,
-0.7435048818588257,
-0.1556280106306076,
0.14179183542728424,
-0.2924309968948364,
0.08214064687490463,
-0.6286444664001465,
0.5110430121421814,
-0.1970783770084381,
-0.4054838716983795,
-0.1324623078107834,
0.8814173340797424,
0.17168129980564117,
0.734348475933075,
0.6934224367141724,
0.19161629676818848,
1.128421425819397,
0.04707988351583481,
0.8985710144042969,
0.1459771990776062,
0.6013391613960266,
1.0078516006469727,
-0.45477789640426636,
0.9310802817344666,
0.2720680236816406,
-0.35226330161094666,
0.4305570125579834,
0.6890933513641357,
0.0705660954117775,
0.5688418745994568,
0.2038390040397644,
-0.6213656663894653,
-0.5687183141708374,
-0.45203325152397156,
0.14765828847885132,
0.7403479814529419,
0.4566856026649475,
0.13249139487743378,
-0.47133901715278625,
-0.06561913341283798,
0.03911949694156647,
0.3901434540748596,
-0.23629401624202728,
0.9476157426834106,
0.29549649357795715,
-0.40890225768089294,
0.44874387979507446,
-0.0758303701877594,
0.8517687916755676,
-0.5083743333816528,
-0.2084151655435562,
0.12644463777542114,
0.01706593483686447,
-0.4505748450756073,
-0.6365100145339966,
0.5997288227081299,
0.3083065450191498,
-0.12502148747444153,
-0.2253751903772354,
1.086564540863037,
-0.36335381865501404,
-0.39302292466163635,
-0.14915917813777924,
0.5706913471221924,
0.08089184015989304,
-0.1810741126537323,
-0.4865959584712982,
-0.31089726090431213,
-0.21089859306812286,
-0.12051944434642792,
0.17344829440116882,
0.5375339984893799,
-0.07797624170780182,
0.3077913820743561,
0.3996489644050598,
0.03772691264748573,
-0.33391979336738586,
-0.03681932017207146,
0.6548334360122681,
-0.649297833442688,
-0.4561111629009247,
-0.8455095887184143,
0.26885664463043213,
-0.24314890801906586,
-0.22772528231143951,
0.6004678606987,
0.6502407789230347,
0.7314024567604065,
0.13515062630176544,
1.1714186668395996,
0.0815640240907669,
0.8129512071609497,
-0.5468050241470337,
0.24111652374267578,
-0.42268550395965576,
0.037776101380586624,
-0.30933162569999695,
-0.5578492879867554,
-0.6322675943374634,
0.7145398259162903,
-0.5083961486816406,
-0.5204662084579468,
0.7064861059188843,
0.4392479956150055,
0.0027066105976700783,
0.26135703921318054,
0.1999746859073639,
-0.04680214077234268,
0.31363147497177124,
0.3444547653198242,
0.9014121890068054,
-0.15828320384025574,
0.39356571435928345,
-0.10182183235883713,
-0.25901472568511963,
-0.07903746515512466,
-0.9317060112953186,
-0.7957912087440491,
-0.4340691566467285,
-0.9264018535614014,
-0.357382595539093,
-0.19377805292606354,
0.9249663352966309,
0.6078411340713501,
-0.8384802341461182,
0.16577567160129547,
0.12557770311832428,
0.18495242297649384,
-0.28933870792388916,
-0.2660500407218933,
0.2516687214374542,
-0.47839051485061646,
-0.6713321805000305,
0.2846212387084961,
0.28391796350479126,
-0.0630003958940506,
0.06588704138994217,
0.4997526705265045,
-0.4748612344264984,
0.28035059571266174,
0.7498307824134827,
0.36014899611473083,
-0.4857184588909149,
-0.5347976088523865,
-0.17480936646461487,
0.012620015069842339,
0.15178218483924866,
0.8705183267593384,
-0.8603927493095398,
0.29447129368782043,
0.5645864605903625,
0.895070493221283,
0.7536196708679199,
0.07995183765888214,
-0.011170949786901474,
-1.0608452558517456,
0.05762920901179314,
0.3686365485191345,
0.1373455822467804,
0.3812195956707001,
-0.33215242624282837,
0.41848570108413696,
0.4434821605682373,
-0.14455083012580872,
-0.7829005122184753,
0.36956602334976196,
-0.9772890210151672,
-0.6466440558433533,
0.9313659071922302,
-0.26756155490875244,
-0.20440274477005005,
-0.4168373644351959,
-0.0060304938815534115,
0.2090453803539276,
-0.16836853325366974,
0.8751439452171326,
0.6900343894958496,
-0.336402952671051,
-0.07945706695318222,
-0.4714019000530243,
0.4438745081424713,
0.21925251185894012,
-0.998619556427002,
0.044013556092977524,
0.7330023050308228,
0.16942960023880005,
0.4382636547088623,
0.6261035203933716,
0.1871892511844635,
0.0007546030101366341,
-0.038256943225860596,
-0.10133454948663712,
0.5351569652557373,
-0.34308624267578125,
-0.23145316541194916,
0.355207622051239,
-0.0698883980512619,
-0.28576672077178955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06001v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06001v1
|
LLM-QBench: A Benchmark Towards the Best Practice for Post-training Quantization of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-09T11:49:05 | 2024-05-09T11:49:05 |
Ruihao Gong, Yang Yong, Shiqiao Gu, Yushi Huang, Yunchen Zhang, Xianglong Liu, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) are propelling us toward
artificial general intelligence, thanks to their remarkable emergent abilities
and reasoning capabilities. However, the substantial computational and memory
requirements of LLMs limit their widespread adoption. Quan- tization, a key
compression technique, offers a viable solution to mitigate these demands by
compressing and accelerating LLMs, albeit with poten- tial risks to model
accuracy. Numerous studies have aimed to minimize the accuracy loss associated
with quantization. However, the quantization configurations in these studies
vary and may not be optimized for hard- ware compatibility. In this paper, we
focus on identifying the most effective practices for quantizing LLMs, with the
goal of balancing performance with computational efficiency. For a fair
analysis, we develop a quantization toolkit LLMC, and design four crucial
principles considering the inference efficiency, quantized accuracy,
calibration cost, and modularization. By benchmarking on various models and
datasets with over 500 experiments, three takeaways corresponding to
calibration data, quantization algorithm, and quantization schemes are derived.
Finally, a best practice of LLM PTQ pipeline is constructed. All the benchmark
results and the toolkit can be found at https://github.com/ModelTC/llmc.
|
[
-0.3032161295413971,
-0.36810725927352905,
0.5505411028862,
0.14424344897270203,
-0.46853241324424744,
-0.041786421090364456,
-0.31880122423171997,
-0.0437028594315052,
-0.37787264585494995,
0.3484055995941162,
-0.3450140357017517,
-0.7222867608070374,
-0.40083396434783936,
0.11294873058795929,
-0.22657093405723572,
0.5448896288871765,
0.040155183523893356,
0.2555600106716156,
-0.22870104014873505,
-0.22111602127552032,
-0.12950171530246735,
-0.8448255658149719,
-0.663455605506897,
-0.25748881697654724,
0.3582029938697815,
0.057431239634752274,
0.7544978260993958,
0.7650157809257507,
0.4255678653717041,
0.2277194857597351,
-0.11801344156265259,
-0.041727982461452484,
-0.3988095223903656,
0.14973680675029755,
0.1563805788755417,
-0.662348210811615,
-0.6362555623054504,
-0.07993710041046143,
0.9415636658668518,
0.6087482571601868,
-0.5515795946121216,
0.22115208208560944,
0.08162850886583328,
0.6662899255752563,
-0.8855652809143066,
0.06813771277666092,
-0.3773138225078583,
0.1733853816986084,
-0.2567719519138336,
-0.14326463639736176,
-0.3026796877384186,
-0.6794301867485046,
-0.28654029965400696,
-0.5152045488357544,
0.053587667644023895,
-0.05904139205813408,
0.4822515547275543,
0.5052154064178467,
-0.541506290435791,
0.2755369544029236,
-0.5357019305229187,
1.053360939025879,
-1.0360738039016724,
0.5966492295265198,
0.348005086183548,
0.4512585997581482,
-0.026795901358127594,
-0.6882317066192627,
-0.34404414892196655,
-0.067082479596138,
0.24976205825805664,
0.002710103988647461,
-0.12368248403072357,
0.43307915329933167,
0.40527811646461487,
0.5980089902877808,
-0.6722810864448547,
0.19316372275352478,
0.11685854196548462,
-0.39335015416145325,
0.4222872853279114,
-0.00726306764408946,
-0.01960068754851818,
0.11263837665319443,
-0.13950087130069733,
-0.33276695013046265,
-1.0671974420547485,
-0.03770030662417412,
0.394542396068573,
0.11429928243160248,
0.21896538138389587,
0.643435001373291,
-0.5172845125198364,
0.5915058255195618,
-0.2819933295249939,
0.02413521148264408,
0.21445484459400177,
-0.3672291934490204,
-0.31715336441993713,
-0.03921813517808914,
0.8355843424797058,
0.2686968743801117,
0.5244943499565125,
-0.3777523934841156,
-0.45051881670951843,
-0.01316717267036438,
0.19169849157333374,
-1.1449922323226929,
-0.17300955951213837,
0.29393529891967773,
-0.2829066812992096,
-0.19808191061019897,
-0.20510591566562653,
-0.3630954623222351,
-0.1984969526529312,
-0.35920846462249756,
0.34237855672836304,
-0.42850354313850403,
-0.13977955281734467,
0.06655168533325195,
0.11435650289058685,
0.38193678855895996,
0.1412193924188614,
-0.735913097858429,
0.3018742501735687,
0.9393458962440491,
0.7824394106864929,
0.021195117384195328,
-0.005044265650212765,
-0.9181298613548279,
0.15756970643997192,
-0.5196119546890259,
0.6475441455841064,
-0.013523735105991364,
-0.44744420051574707,
0.13623470067977905,
-0.351043164730072,
0.3223065435886383,
-0.6691591143608093,
0.6866347789764404,
-0.6049031615257263,
-0.08203005790710449,
-0.20908573269844055,
-0.7778015732765198,
0.025981759652495384,
0.25919467210769653,
-0.7039503455162048,
0.9204023480415344,
0.30060771107673645,
-0.5693448781967163,
0.24513311684131622,
-0.1231984868645668,
-0.22892116010189056,
0.14875079691410065,
-0.022556984797120094,
-0.39538660645484924,
0.4464275538921356,
0.25212371349334717,
0.33898892998695374,
-0.67880779504776,
0.5035870671272278,
-0.41083645820617676,
-0.6131475567817688,
0.1769082099199295,
-0.47297802567481995,
0.8479414582252502,
0.2887851297855377,
-0.23573938012123108,
0.14673030376434326,
-0.5202696919441223,
0.5793194770812988,
-0.16036123037338257,
-0.4022130072116852,
-0.1430947482585907,
-0.04604799672961235,
-0.29186487197875977,
-0.06775111705064774,
0.044045861810445786,
-0.2557186186313629,
0.21992848813533783,
-0.5940423011779785,
0.5563430786132812,
0.754345715045929,
-0.2833951711654663,
0.6247156262397766,
-0.3614794611930847,
0.5280295014381409,
-0.27609217166900635,
0.4693118631839752,
0.09598492085933685,
0.029950324445962906,
-0.7100817561149597,
-0.34907266497612,
0.8232578039169312,
0.5728904008865356,
-0.8022866249084473,
0.45755672454833984,
-0.4512844979763031,
-0.31978946924209595,
-0.5013458728790283,
0.1294747143983841,
0.3410865366458893,
0.11439964920282364,
0.04679048806428909,
-0.19654957950115204,
-0.3626973032951355,
-0.9164877533912659,
-0.33296895027160645,
-0.17561669647693634,
-0.40500983595848083,
-0.12651129066944122,
0.0665489137172699,
-0.0363786518573761,
0.8950157165527344,
-0.12813682854175568,
0.1281527429819107,
0.04170482978224754,
0.24260583519935608,
0.21212628483772278,
0.41796278953552246,
0.39666450023651123,
-0.673797070980072,
-0.3333953619003296,
-0.2658785879611969,
-0.6362622976303101,
-0.41886255145072937,
0.19180360436439514,
-0.31828683614730835,
0.3205471932888031,
0.5216417908668518,
-0.6585745811462402,
0.29977676272392273,
0.6485958695411682,
0.1214895248413086,
0.7129808068275452,
0.007854622788727283,
0.2025037705898285,
-0.8381762504577637,
0.10907750576734543,
-0.04546516016125679,
-0.5434601306915283,
-0.5205457806587219,
0.331940233707428,
0.1547214388847351,
0.10009521245956421,
-0.5671407580375671,
0.5873993635177612,
-0.36429521441459656,
-0.19065864384174347,
-0.09353530406951904,
0.006741434335708618,
0.02846408262848854,
0.4496413767337799,
-0.17156854271888733,
1.0553430318832397,
0.4112958014011383,
-0.5633410811424255,
0.4964160919189453,
-0.06849808245897293,
-0.406584769487381,
0.5364737510681152,
-0.8162794709205627,
0.25492313504219055,
0.2503723204135895,
0.06304124742746353,
-0.6120572090148926,
0.21021151542663574,
0.16272175312042236,
-0.28274574875831604,
0.2208588719367981,
-0.23734700679779053,
-1.1779131889343262,
-0.0742780938744545,
-0.6369779109954834,
0.6994163393974304,
0.8058784008026123,
-0.3974536955356598,
0.7456048130989075,
0.28797706961631775,
-0.17602217197418213,
-0.41791924834251404,
-0.6046338081359863,
0.06475580483675003,
-0.3760695159435272,
-0.47379207611083984,
0.5816779136657715,
-0.4196341633796692,
-0.20306284725666046,
-0.25820279121398926,
-0.2502545416355133,
-0.07837267220020294,
0.10751497000455856,
0.009821531362831593,
0.036997199058532715,
-0.22591593861579895,
0.17619720101356506,
-0.007342890836298466,
-0.18752069771289825,
0.0577986054122448,
-0.2730160653591156,
0.6322730183601379,
-0.28187668323516846,
-0.14307208359241486,
-0.3397020101547241,
0.12711410224437714,
0.2843024730682373,
-0.12827415764331818,
0.7374630570411682,
0.5057084560394287,
-0.27343258261680603,
-0.15840713679790497,
-0.6842591166496277,
-0.2630805969238281,
-0.47127729654312134,
0.1033562570810318,
-0.3132094442844391,
-0.9162089824676514,
0.3581787049770355,
-0.47842589020729065,
0.044080376625061035,
0.12274985760450363,
0.5014891028404236,
-0.17345401644706726,
1.0562665462493896,
0.6678078174591064,
-0.11960192769765854,
0.48364463448524475,
-0.2094176560640335,
0.1351756751537323,
-0.8416367173194885,
0.3591134548187256,
-0.41138115525245667,
0.01176086813211441,
-0.6423840522766113,
-0.6058496832847595,
0.44184693694114685,
0.5280994772911072,
-0.4449174702167511,
0.10781565308570862,
-0.15811365842819214,
0.48483461141586304,
0.7488206624984741,
-0.07314654439687729,
0.2906729280948639,
0.01199559960514307,
-0.11746218055486679,
0.14327600598335266,
-0.8577197194099426,
-0.44520819187164307,
1.1301311254501343,
0.17107875645160675,
0.43614262342453003,
0.19789820909500122,
0.7167837023735046,
0.18311528861522675,
0.3376614451408386,
-0.9010642170906067,
0.6914861798286438,
-0.19943417608737946,
-0.2538011074066162,
-0.4517621397972107,
-0.8680933117866516,
-0.8083905577659607,
0.339532732963562,
-0.10186102241277695,
-0.4496985971927643,
-0.11895189434289932,
0.28959280252456665,
-0.33728712797164917,
0.18621569871902466,
-0.4331043064594269,
0.8847756385803223,
-0.17168289422988892,
-0.35458073019981384,
-0.3620927035808563,
-0.5684327483177185,
0.4226143956184387,
-0.22459828853607178,
0.19686274230480194,
-0.09106875211000443,
-0.1929156333208084,
0.49264436960220337,
-0.5873568058013916,
0.5893435478210449,
0.05481051281094551,
-0.17834770679473877,
0.270211786031723,
0.15656161308288574,
0.5863792300224304,
-0.2107066810131073,
-0.23573988676071167,
0.45029348134994507,
0.35070013999938965,
-0.5402576327323914,
-0.6621650457382202,
0.37028542160987854,
-0.5661160945892334,
-0.5442104339599609,
-0.3204895853996277,
-0.47287222743034363,
-0.4302932918071747,
0.06539865583181381,
0.1972772628068924,
0.5085703134536743,
-0.15495538711547852,
0.29731810092926025,
0.729571521282196,
-0.3473634421825409,
0.2973816692829132,
0.4162059724330902,
-0.09281374514102936,
-0.7412419319152832,
0.8195724487304688,
-0.0358269177377224,
0.2573554217815399,
0.482058584690094,
0.2833137810230255,
-0.4000200629234314,
-0.7638627290725708,
-0.08494047075510025,
0.3722490072250366,
-0.7061275839805603,
-0.5582345128059387,
-0.15462319552898407,
-0.33071592450141907,
-0.6913079619407654,
0.2188110053539276,
-0.3783785104751587,
-0.4898556172847748,
-0.18319261074066162,
0.18307995796203613,
0.09891735762357712,
0.05702974274754524,
-0.14148306846618652,
0.6346828937530518,
-1.0805922746658325,
0.24784378707408905,
0.4157916009426117,
0.397998571395874,
-0.16436775028705597,
-0.400037556886673,
-0.3954790532588959,
0.07549966126680374,
-0.19929324090480804,
-0.5137465596199036,
0.3813052773475647,
0.3019079566001892,
0.6036565899848938,
0.20684513449668884,
0.2878437638282776,
0.5274569392204285,
-0.37022918462753296,
0.5281742215156555,
0.04598521441221237,
-1.0791261196136475,
0.49190089106559753,
-0.23634257912635803,
0.5524364113807678,
0.5952346324920654,
0.3076692223548889,
-0.6518241167068481,
-0.2304319143295288,
-0.4698847830295563,
-0.9325395822525024,
0.3263606131076813,
0.2598186731338501,
-0.07393627613782883,
0.1061558723449707,
0.5015620589256287,
-0.14267462491989136,
0.7082769274711609,
-0.7141832113265991,
0.02561204694211483,
0.11021210253238678,
-0.42211905121803284,
-0.08101165294647217,
-0.3742507994174957,
-0.13304273784160614,
-0.05317109450697899,
0.6096091866493225,
-0.28941068053245544,
0.04240657016634941,
-0.223180890083313,
-0.4144904613494873,
0.08252444863319397,
0.2333095520734787,
0.23822036385536194,
0.5313765406608582,
-0.12179379910230637,
0.1997496336698532,
0.09031196683645248,
-0.28718289732933044,
0.1539802998304367,
0.05514157935976982,
-0.08874639868736267,
-0.3217772841453552,
0.42729905247688293,
0.4865657389163971,
0.28713035583496094,
-0.9422404766082764,
0.5916014313697815,
-0.16162359714508057,
-0.19141732156276703,
-0.22869978845119476,
0.2312847375869751,
-0.169202983379364,
0.46688535809516907,
0.12864463031291962,
-0.43281421065330505,
0.27980899810791016,
-0.36283281445503235,
0.05078718811273575,
0.526711642742157,
0.15230892598628998,
-0.21689990162849426,
0.3644985854625702,
0.06509679555892944,
-0.16633734107017517,
0.9017510414123535,
-0.20773479342460632,
-0.6122314929962158,
0.4018953740596771,
0.02045360952615738,
0.8941690325737,
-0.2978246212005615,
0.15124350786209106,
0.32359302043914795,
0.16563723981380463,
-0.36644428968429565,
0.23431304097175598,
-0.33346930146217346,
-0.6258257031440735,
-0.8464626669883728,
-0.7329040765762329,
-0.40915152430534363,
-0.10320202261209488,
-0.5877150297164917,
0.2076776623725891,
-0.4346149265766144,
-0.4280201196670532,
-0.46817824244499207,
0.19994543492794037,
-0.5945593118667603,
0.05994847044348717,
0.2966090142726898,
0.9023604393005371,
-0.531696081161499,
1.050700306892395,
0.3012303411960602,
0.04972955211997032,
-0.740896999835968,
-0.12625405192375183,
-0.01410606037825346,
-0.7617471814155579,
0.5757517218589783,
-0.060783836990594864,
0.0010197162628173828,
0.28685447573661804,
-0.4514240026473999,
-0.7558962106704712,
1.1305394172668457,
0.6544601321220398,
-1.0167737007141113,
0.02324279211461544,
0.33715683221817017,
0.43984222412109375,
0.10744072496891022,
0.23088006675243378,
0.7693843841552734,
0.38256484270095825,
0.24632728099822998,
-0.7885344624519348,
-0.03788628429174423,
-0.11524534225463867,
0.25762397050857544,
0.3876003921031952,
-0.5956873297691345,
0.6658021807670593,
0.14309561252593994,
-0.31683722138404846,
0.43870213627815247,
0.5347078442573547,
0.6552961468696594,
0.050605133175849915,
0.5985926389694214,
0.7509177327156067,
0.7356019020080566,
-0.19552919268608093,
1.1196351051330566,
-0.4151213467121124,
0.22426781058311462,
1.0400348901748657,
-0.2390889674425125,
0.9006959795951843,
0.5007572174072266,
-0.5033243298530579,
0.03275278955698013,
0.8404251933097839,
0.03938964009284973,
0.6177150011062622,
0.6244191527366638,
-0.3575778901576996,
-0.3562939465045929,
-0.09354132413864136,
-0.16006232798099518,
0.0676058903336525,
0.016954131424427032,
0.1664348840713501,
-0.08230629563331604,
-0.1509023904800415,
-0.12889593839645386,
-0.28562840819358826,
-0.2614203691482544,
0.7192562222480774,
0.18327467143535614,
-0.44035935401916504,
0.7634434103965759,
-0.11727061122655869,
0.6309566497802734,
-0.5649506449699402,
0.05635976791381836,
-0.4460998475551605,
-0.014932621270418167,
0.13005323708057404,
-0.5652483105659485,
0.09965214878320694,
-0.10868310928344727,
-0.03534828871488571,
-0.3506564199924469,
0.22888238728046417,
-0.30819252133369446,
-0.45305970311164856,
-0.04751288518309593,
0.537916362285614,
0.21964609622955322,
-0.5656144022941589,
-0.5731145739555359,
0.30255135893821716,
-0.2600320875644684,
-0.2754155099391937,
0.4911768436431885,
0.6795706748962402,
0.0039222524501383305,
0.6994902491569519,
0.47733137011528015,
0.44855785369873047,
0.0061221434734761715,
0.4871536195278168,
0.8005204796791077,
-0.6970276236534119,
-0.3734802305698395,
-0.9032838940620422,
0.39983251690864563,
0.09772831201553345,
-0.05508246645331383,
0.47605764865875244,
0.6021324992179871,
0.7292450666427612,
0.3149615526199341,
0.46800196170806885,
0.42214474081993103,
0.21984411776065826,
-0.8406361937522888,
0.3881007730960846,
-0.6131784319877625,
0.4423629939556122,
-0.04827321693301201,
-1.2008039951324463,
-0.44900181889533997,
0.6524887681007385,
-0.1759839504957199,
0.1906309574842453,
0.7153260111808777,
0.7489031553268433,
0.28527405858039856,
-0.21023721992969513,
0.44981709122657776,
0.1250796914100647,
0.4038200378417969,
0.7328375577926636,
0.969677746295929,
-0.4375832676887512,
0.5833024382591248,
-0.36461156606674194,
-0.18821415305137634,
-0.15129242837429047,
-1.165411353111267,
-0.6254594326019287,
-0.40265896916389465,
-0.5788490176200867,
0.009562390856444836,
0.12080619484186172,
0.6534647941589355,
0.9336521029472351,
-0.5450378656387329,
-0.38607048988342285,
-0.2659192979335785,
-0.0009294936317019165,
-0.14098741114139557,
-0.18043585121631622,
0.2897041141986847,
-0.35539698600769043,
-0.727053165435791,
0.04352426901459694,
0.19539408385753632,
0.2916114628314972,
-0.22176356613636017,
-0.08633044362068176,
0.3405861258506775,
-0.09641523659229279,
0.6420668959617615,
0.052668094635009766,
-0.6140510439872742,
-0.05894738808274269,
-0.05883591249585152,
-0.13295161724090576,
0.10283812880516052,
0.9658738374710083,
-0.9115887880325317,
0.169646218419075,
0.36838236451148987,
0.6361714601516724,
0.407772421836853,
-0.03953641280531883,
0.7796051502227783,
-0.7304165363311768,
0.12107636779546738,
0.5876489281654358,
0.22671014070510864,
0.36704006791114807,
-0.2031128704547882,
0.7676575183868408,
0.0018645430682227015,
-0.7947315573692322,
-1.1010775566101074,
0.023998428136110306,
-0.8144927024841309,
-0.34047749638557434,
1.0597081184387207,
-0.14537425339221954,
-0.36097094416618347,
0.4504176676273346,
0.0139697240665555,
0.5324861407279968,
-0.1941826343536377,
0.6668508648872375,
0.6870083212852478,
0.005367732141166925,
-0.5459542274475098,
-0.6800643801689148,
0.3774181008338928,
0.4156510829925537,
-0.8162441849708557,
0.21509607136249542,
0.48711901903152466,
0.16622571647167206,
-0.4712996780872345,
0.4373694956302643,
0.027767915278673172,
0.2214842587709427,
-0.19499997794628143,
0.24179741740226746,
0.09328903257846832,
-0.09219036996364594,
-0.5511298775672913,
-0.01592850126326084,
0.24153196811676025,
0.003060460789129138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05688v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05688v1
|
Evaluating Dialect Robustness of Language Models via Conversation Understanding
| 2024-05-09T11:38:23 | 2024-05-09T11:38:23 |
Dipankar Srirag, Aditya Joshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With an evergrowing number of LLMs reporting superlative performance for
English, their ability to perform equitably for different dialects of English
(i.e., dialect robustness) needs to be ascertained. Specifically, we use
English language (US English or Indian English) conversations between humans
who play the word-guessing game of `taboo'. We formulate two evaluative tasks:
target word prediction (TWP) (i.e.predict the masked target word in a
conversation) and target word selection (TWS) (i.e., select the most likely
masked target word in a conversation, from among a set of candidate words).
Extending MD3, an existing dialectic dataset of taboo-playing conversations, we
introduce M-MD3, a target-word-masked version of MD3 with the USEng and IndEng
subsets. We add two subsets: AITrans (where dialectic information is removed
from IndEng) and AIGen (where LLMs are prompted to generate conversations). Our
evaluation uses pre-trained and fine-tuned versions of two closed-source
(GPT-4/3.5) and two open-source LLMs (Mistral and Gemma). LLMs perform
significantly better for US English than Indian English for both TWP and TWS,
for all settings. While GPT-based models perform the best, the comparatively
smaller models work more equitably for short conversations (<8 turns). Our
results on AIGen and AITrans (the best and worst-performing subset)
respectively show that LLMs may learn a dialect of their own based on the
composition of the training data, and that dialect robustness is indeed a
challenging task. Our evaluation methodology exhibits a novel way to examine
attributes of language models using pre-existing dialogue datasets.
|
[
-0.3990321159362793,
-0.8543863892555237,
0.5222164392471313,
-0.01131363119930029,
-0.4064217209815979,
0.07291945070028305,
-0.36193060874938965,
-0.4810607433319092,
0.2536666691303253,
0.4972943067550659,
-0.4866533875465393,
-0.5072102546691895,
-0.635121762752533,
0.08681678026914597,
-0.3025282025337219,
0.6322488784790039,
0.45154622197151184,
0.19969293475151062,
-0.03847045823931694,
-0.2582387328147888,
-0.551689863204956,
-0.5189306139945984,
-0.5269452333450317,
-0.3600875437259674,
0.05203277990221977,
0.3287695050239563,
0.7598053812980652,
0.7790811657905579,
0.3845944404602051,
0.3567603528499603,
-0.28166866302490234,
0.020605266094207764,
-0.6462030410766602,
0.26923805475234985,
-0.15703868865966797,
-0.618206262588501,
-0.3990687131881714,
0.055516403168439865,
0.223152294754982,
0.7336897253990173,
-0.2860994040966034,
-0.2350337654352188,
0.44937652349472046,
0.30435100197792053,
-0.3561345934867859,
0.276297003030777,
-1.1760873794555664,
-0.1972205638885498,
-0.41390952467918396,
0.04813132435083389,
-0.2842920422554016,
-0.1320318579673767,
0.24521946907043457,
-0.29683738946914673,
0.1446007788181305,
0.09576085209846497,
0.9785043001174927,
-0.052230942994356155,
-0.3913763463497162,
-0.31678587198257446,
-0.46048352122306824,
0.7760413289070129,
-0.8697512745857239,
0.5264734029769897,
0.8025758266448975,
0.19819892942905426,
-0.05075719952583313,
-0.377760112285614,
-0.4230158030986786,
-0.543999195098877,
0.012523873709142208,
0.10257457941770554,
-0.21701087057590485,
0.20873403549194336,
0.03759279102087021,
0.5421466827392578,
-0.4894567131996155,
0.28691932559013367,
-0.38529732823371887,
-0.28246504068374634,
0.48371872305870056,
0.2837679386138916,
-0.0627935603260994,
-0.31409865617752075,
-0.1677083969116211,
0.24475859105587006,
-0.613995373249054,
-0.027300437912344933,
0.4640660583972931,
0.3703390955924988,
-0.25012826919555664,
0.36532917618751526,
-0.023479808121919632,
0.6787947416305542,
0.08606041967868805,
-0.3222742974758148,
0.033048681914806366,
-0.4130832552909851,
-0.04078090563416481,
-0.5761337876319885,
0.9108244776725769,
0.4166828691959381,
0.40353113412857056,
-0.08573068678379059,
-0.222782701253891,
-0.06740949302911758,
0.08174815028905869,
-0.5635198354721069,
-0.29533448815345764,
0.21987667679786682,
-0.3613297641277313,
-0.44152966141700745,
-0.22410684823989868,
-0.8905662894248962,
-0.4635414481163025,
-0.04386817291378975,
0.31377166509628296,
-0.6667910218238831,
-0.20782369375228882,
0.019264591857790947,
0.15768887102603912,
0.24927733838558197,
0.18199338018894196,
-1.0589542388916016,
0.3308388292789459,
0.744508683681488,
0.7589199542999268,
-0.3549239933490753,
-0.22680485248565674,
-0.17285461723804474,
0.02105790376663208,
-0.42550623416900635,
0.5518792867660522,
-0.5151346921920776,
-0.6463064551353455,
0.01362584438174963,
-0.1581641435623169,
-0.15065772831439972,
-0.6286476850509644,
0.5908823013305664,
-0.28354108333587646,
0.403091162443161,
0.008684300817549229,
-0.5080448389053345,
-0.11273084580898285,
0.48323753476142883,
-0.5826935172080994,
0.875529944896698,
-0.014944429509341717,
-0.7246227264404297,
0.38604551553726196,
-0.29914912581443787,
-0.39618635177612305,
0.01717469096183777,
-0.03888675197958946,
-0.3929148316383362,
0.1388518214225769,
0.3098676800727844,
0.6111491322517395,
-0.39437568187713623,
0.39278706908226013,
-0.4640929400920868,
-0.3382056653499603,
0.36464616656303406,
-0.6270068883895874,
0.8577365279197693,
0.18207286298274994,
-0.40257081389427185,
-0.08112946152687073,
-0.6361252069473267,
-0.002830715849995613,
0.08800862729549408,
-0.06019670143723488,
-0.2998705208301544,
0.010615442879498005,
-0.3377097249031067,
-0.10704302042722702,
-0.16645003855228424,
-0.32378214597702026,
-0.2214987725019455,
-0.6155450344085693,
0.49039769172668457,
0.798155665397644,
0.051355816423892975,
0.17437057197093964,
-0.6359277963638306,
0.6501420736312866,
-0.1595616191625595,
0.13058826327323914,
-0.24972140789031982,
-0.5620487332344055,
-0.8769786357879639,
-0.3051852881908417,
0.4437890648841858,
0.6734707355499268,
-0.7054929733276367,
0.545269250869751,
-0.3524976372718811,
-0.4873502254486084,
-0.36305028200149536,
0.13279086351394653,
0.5380275249481201,
0.35202959179878235,
0.04864068329334259,
-0.6862210631370544,
-0.3140278458595276,
-0.980793297290802,
-0.26697173714637756,
-0.6108676791191101,
-0.12074467539787292,
0.49748849868774414,
0.22556154429912567,
0.020910674706101418,
0.6945143938064575,
-0.1762373447418213,
-0.10289569944143295,
-0.6315940618515015,
0.09857510775327682,
0.12150827050209045,
0.24151238799095154,
0.5235338807106018,
-0.43317878246307373,
-0.466562956571579,
-0.07576348632574081,
-0.37995144724845886,
-0.3709268271923065,
0.14698560535907745,
0.05392708629369736,
0.14247098565101624,
0.26856642961502075,
-0.30257028341293335,
0.29029715061187744,
0.6781930923461914,
-0.12612050771713257,
0.5663167238235474,
0.2927330732345581,
0.3437536358833313,
-1.4159483909606934,
-0.14917545020580292,
0.02476442977786064,
-0.3080914616584778,
-0.8109350800514221,
0.16625049710273743,
-0.15933340787887573,
-0.0658707395195961,
-0.3791833817958832,
0.37887686491012573,
-0.5346256494522095,
0.21722839772701263,
0.07009539753198624,
0.2255481630563736,
0.04976430907845497,
0.49187588691711426,
0.11842392385005951,
0.8810550570487976,
0.4665710926055908,
-0.4695010781288147,
0.022562485188245773,
0.11657045036554337,
-0.4846910536289215,
0.5650209188461304,
-0.5470868945121765,
0.3910984992980957,
0.16190484166145325,
-0.2214568853378296,
-1.004151463508606,
-0.30089280009269714,
0.12041831016540527,
-0.508875846862793,
0.42789122462272644,
-0.38333553075790405,
0.10344307869672775,
-0.12958396971225739,
-0.3587662875652313,
0.15590476989746094,
0.5146305561065674,
-0.15746460855007172,
0.36581435799598694,
0.6536272168159485,
-0.46776869893074036,
-0.5731565356254578,
-0.6354467868804932,
0.3068806231021881,
-0.561764657497406,
-0.576078474521637,
-0.14755648374557495,
0.059318650513887405,
-0.6811664700508118,
-0.283104807138443,
-0.04859734699130058,
-0.2814907133579254,
0.2461826354265213,
0.023647746071219444,
0.2004866600036621,
-0.13324183225631714,
-0.11902008205652237,
-0.32400527596473694,
0.0018449821509420872,
0.0959286242723465,
-0.14394475519657135,
0.6001026034355164,
-0.11186928302049637,
-0.47740545868873596,
-0.1260465830564499,
0.4454890489578247,
0.4803527891635895,
-0.16095292568206787,
0.5253059267997742,
0.43566104769706726,
-0.30806562304496765,
-0.2903074324131012,
-0.7371857762336731,
-0.22094468772411346,
-0.4530006945133209,
0.4596170485019684,
-0.6014949083328247,
-0.9659563899040222,
0.584275484085083,
0.17687560617923737,
-0.04585101082921028,
0.20248262584209442,
0.5715147852897644,
-0.07425952702760696,
0.7694317698478699,
0.5882123112678528,
-0.08881881833076477,
0.3259357810020447,
-0.0340346023440361,
0.18662087619304657,
-0.48911768198013306,
-0.09385477006435394,
-0.6356596350669861,
0.07415224611759186,
-0.5877127647399902,
-0.5493596792221069,
0.5980404019355774,
-0.04720957204699516,
0.19615159928798676,
0.4362027049064636,
-0.0037040298338979483,
0.5044341087341309,
0.4219580590724945,
0.14375339448451996,
0.289948433637619,
-0.00937424786388874,
-0.29298272728919983,
-0.5292038917541504,
-0.6154748201370239,
-0.6003576517105103,
1.1366863250732422,
0.5166170597076416,
0.7865137457847595,
0.3136145770549774,
0.6069607734680176,
0.14114198088645935,
0.16572462022304535,
-0.9713152050971985,
0.7295360565185547,
-0.0631793811917305,
-0.6158456802368164,
-0.25858837366104126,
-0.4073452353477478,
-1.0027879476547241,
0.23187373578548431,
-0.3218172788619995,
-0.9346957802772522,
0.0022770643699914217,
0.050559476017951965,
-0.17767593264579773,
0.26747000217437744,
-0.5094206929206848,
0.5566821694374084,
-0.1282663345336914,
-0.5987794995307922,
-0.2064109444618225,
-0.6802018880844116,
0.7108618021011353,
-0.19516843557357788,
0.33598119020462036,
-0.1392718404531479,
0.05102422088384628,
0.5939770936965942,
-0.33058130741119385,
0.7166598439216614,
0.13872995972633362,
-0.14829100668430328,
0.15010881423950195,
0.49616968631744385,
0.2174416184425354,
0.00955101940780878,
-0.29732227325439453,
0.5553428530693054,
-0.09696230292320251,
-0.24757947027683258,
-0.5716142654418945,
0.39119940996170044,
-0.47090739011764526,
-1.066391110420227,
-0.3064727485179901,
-0.4004489779472351,
-0.6660565137863159,
0.12468571960926056,
0.3369412422180176,
0.6437680125236511,
-0.5198004841804504,
0.3064836859703064,
0.6544414758682251,
0.01055013108998537,
0.19949112832546234,
0.5406876802444458,
-0.22353814542293549,
-0.43263673782348633,
0.6903833746910095,
-0.028677286580204964,
0.6010745167732239,
0.2801640033721924,
0.35973748564720154,
-0.3899410665035248,
-1.0536562204360962,
-0.39797917008399963,
0.06222342327237129,
-0.5929462909698486,
-0.06250176578760147,
-0.5921558141708374,
-0.24940413236618042,
-0.39152058959007263,
-0.029781267046928406,
-0.1397327333688736,
-0.4246944785118103,
0.050020188093185425,
-0.17754986882209778,
0.04784942790865898,
1.0249937772750854,
-0.20631647109985352,
0.2659321129322052,
-0.6766153573989868,
0.06343260407447815,
0.3859322965145111,
0.23964077234268188,
-0.40905433893203735,
-0.7661623358726501,
-0.10721339285373688,
0.07971718907356262,
-0.22516050934791565,
-1.2486737966537476,
0.37134215235710144,
0.39953455328941345,
0.5848350524902344,
0.5710347890853882,
-0.10621199011802673,
0.49584588408470154,
-0.3268890380859375,
1.1255406141281128,
-0.10070870816707611,
-1.047816276550293,
0.49118149280548096,
-0.6169099807739258,
-0.0582539364695549,
0.8171913623809814,
0.2799883782863617,
-0.3354730010032654,
-0.7008227109909058,
-0.6375746130943298,
-0.7080237865447998,
0.4777202308177948,
0.301626056432724,
0.2782708406448364,
-0.030051233246922493,
0.09470441937446594,
0.27023202180862427,
0.21678312122821808,
-0.7863564491271973,
-0.13975925743579865,
0.03140128403902054,
-0.10812769085168839,
-0.27896788716316223,
-0.47340959310531616,
-0.25235170125961304,
-0.14823393523693085,
0.6014914512634277,
-0.09959544986486435,
0.17293138802051544,
-0.16721299290657043,
-0.026735499501228333,
0.16453605890274048,
0.5051451325416565,
0.30237990617752075,
0.6228723526000977,
-0.2697409689426422,
0.20532219111919403,
0.3954385221004486,
-0.656633734703064,
0.2166927307844162,
0.03185541555285454,
-0.07304974645376205,
0.041409075260162354,
0.7201845645904541,
0.8294162154197693,
0.171621173620224,
-0.45321759581565857,
0.649165689945221,
-0.22211483120918274,
-0.15040698647499084,
0.07247690856456757,
0.12092261016368866,
0.014379307627677917,
-0.0569574348628521,
-0.05492839217185974,
0.02121490240097046,
0.31053149700164795,
-0.6632305979728699,
0.31582698225975037,
0.6332878470420837,
-0.48247209191322327,
-0.1754562258720398,
0.6407049894332886,
0.3744736909866333,
-0.3700319826602936,
0.3153691291809082,
-0.2978935241699219,
-0.7564567923545837,
0.44581863284111023,
0.5276313424110413,
1.0286357402801514,
-0.3434069752693176,
0.08722388744354248,
0.2055310308933258,
0.5928647518157959,
0.2617785334587097,
0.21590320765972137,
-0.1287657767534256,
-0.8601003885269165,
-0.2799699604511261,
-0.5400233268737793,
-0.707196056842804,
0.4539339542388916,
-0.7104709148406982,
0.22302238643169403,
-0.21740145981311798,
-0.17411521077156067,
-0.3409053683280945,
0.1071159765124321,
-0.5553686618804932,
0.09204013645648956,
0.0006536070141009986,
0.9626221656799316,
-0.9632002711296082,
0.8553674221038818,
0.4354480504989624,
0.0776832327246666,
-1.0215615034103394,
0.44392403960227966,
0.3760882616043091,
-1.008146047592163,
-0.0777771919965744,
0.017646310850977898,
-0.2247624695301056,
-0.12898029386997223,
-0.40078046917915344,
-0.5225250124931335,
0.8224197626113892,
0.4660198390483856,
-0.4768458604812622,
0.33966580033302307,
0.26463964581489563,
0.5104247331619263,
-0.17450907826423645,
0.502831220626831,
0.7980395555496216,
0.20644409954547882,
0.27493301033973694,
-1.1624119281768799,
-0.25141048431396484,
-0.46975988149642944,
-0.041224509477615356,
-0.02899468131363392,
-0.6087741851806641,
0.6984948515892029,
-0.08514966070652008,
-0.2824103534221649,
0.30302518606185913,
0.4462060332298279,
0.2042633295059204,
0.14705872535705566,
0.7791504859924316,
0.486163467168808,
0.718524158000946,
-0.3525417745113373,
0.8510211110115051,
-0.4646528363227844,
0.05003618821501732,
0.892027735710144,
-0.27458471059799194,
0.7375890016555786,
0.23051142692565918,
-0.3360920250415802,
0.29511842131614685,
0.6164761185646057,
0.442307710647583,
0.36573442816734314,
0.2179337441921234,
-0.21480366587638855,
-0.22503522038459778,
-0.10731001198291779,
-0.2667854428291321,
0.9106286764144897,
0.5635384917259216,
-0.11337059736251831,
0.05853147432208061,
-0.17944684624671936,
0.35822591185569763,
0.27364876866340637,
-0.04453694075345993,
0.9592663049697876,
0.05001194030046463,
-0.7798740863800049,
0.6598101854324341,
0.01642458327114582,
0.7845754623413086,
-0.8074379563331604,
0.10137318074703217,
-0.5981928110122681,
-0.06550045311450958,
0.13242845237255096,
-0.786339521408081,
0.3436845541000366,
0.03648941591382027,
0.23425111174583435,
-0.03961575776338577,
0.7575634717941284,
-0.6538652181625366,
-0.35768693685531616,
0.17452147603034973,
0.8684131503105164,
0.3848012685775757,
0.3180115520954132,
-0.6044308543205261,
0.2649860382080078,
0.13466347754001617,
-0.11433567851781845,
0.318511962890625,
0.4383597671985626,
0.05156918987631798,
0.7362790703773499,
0.31961357593536377,
0.39864659309387207,
-0.10333270579576492,
-0.02454153448343277,
0.7396625876426697,
-0.400575190782547,
-0.5809540152549744,
-0.7819364070892334,
0.3871031701564789,
-0.09182322770357132,
-0.32384833693504333,
0.9114987254142761,
0.4435132145881653,
0.6764281392097473,
0.21934840083122253,
0.905059278011322,
-0.04654480516910553,
0.5710163116455078,
-0.7662498354911804,
0.5541811585426331,
-0.31560322642326355,
0.6037865877151489,
-0.3099763095378876,
-0.8506607413291931,
-0.13138768076896667,
0.6912205815315247,
-0.27349820733070374,
0.145474374294281,
0.6676345467567444,
1.1836416721343994,
-0.2156243473291397,
0.30529049038887024,
0.6504085063934326,
0.3099448084831238,
0.150375634431839,
0.583644688129425,
0.980570375919342,
-0.09249735623598099,
0.39421769976615906,
-0.4606180787086487,
-0.4249979257583618,
0.1371297389268875,
-0.9432957172393799,
-0.9929481148719788,
-0.6921358704566956,
-0.02506324090063572,
-0.6153289675712585,
0.32630425691604614,
0.8510555624961853,
0.8409681916236877,
-0.8584146499633789,
-0.48634782433509827,
0.24137407541275024,
0.054487183690071106,
-0.11150310933589935,
-0.20108667016029358,
0.0133295813575387,
-0.1890445202589035,
-0.9337322115898132,
0.6794006824493408,
0.1522226482629776,
0.0039024788420647383,
-0.3918593227863312,
-0.01252842228859663,
0.12534992396831512,
0.3441646993160248,
0.3682418167591095,
0.06236235797405243,
-0.6254252195358276,
-0.44625192880630493,
-0.08288798481225967,
-0.06346537917852402,
-0.029527777805924416,
0.8332305550575256,
-0.45214006304740906,
0.5440600514411926,
0.2300931215286255,
0.4855324327945709,
0.21012935042381287,
0.08418654650449753,
0.9191482663154602,
-0.742353081703186,
0.24515344202518463,
0.32533690333366394,
0.46798670291900635,
0.48640239238739014,
-0.14727747440338135,
0.6283906102180481,
0.2780839502811432,
-0.5263803601264954,
-0.7090297937393188,
0.33189305663108826,
-0.7499087452888489,
-0.038237325847148895,
1.2959706783294678,
-0.3447861969470978,
0.028716159984469414,
-0.6526869535446167,
-0.20357726514339447,
-0.13528095185756683,
-0.05544499680399895,
0.8573560118675232,
0.8888663053512573,
0.012771802954375744,
-0.20185373723506927,
-0.5041571259498596,
0.5940442085266113,
0.508215606212616,
-0.5343535542488098,
0.07883342355489731,
0.4716479778289795,
0.23542894423007965,
-0.1119644045829773,
0.750004231929779,
-0.1104448214173317,
-0.08608122169971466,
0.09109768271446228,
-0.3423026204109192,
-0.010935028083622456,
-0.2178455889225006,
-0.6103243231773376,
0.21708989143371582,
0.30280572175979614,
-0.15100067853927612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06709v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06709v1
|
Evaluating the Efficacy of AI Techniques in Textual Anonymization: A Comparative Study
| 2024-05-09T11:29:25 | 2024-05-09T11:29:25 |
Dimitris Asimopoulos, Ilias Siniosoglou, Vasileios Argyriou, Sotirios K. Goudos, Konstantinos E. Psannis, Nikoleta Karditsioti, Theocharis Saoulidis, Panagiotis Sarigiannidis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the digital era, with escalating privacy concerns, it's imperative to
devise robust strategies that protect private data while maintaining the
intrinsic value of textual information. This research embarks on a
comprehensive examination of text anonymisation methods, focusing on
Conditional Random Fields (CRF), Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM), Embeddings from
Language Models (ELMo), and the transformative capabilities of the Transformers
architecture. Each model presents unique strengths since LSTM is modeling
long-term dependencies, CRF captures dependencies among word sequences, ELMo
delivers contextual word representations using deep bidirectional language
models and Transformers introduce self-attention mechanisms that provide
enhanced scalability. Our study is positioned as a comparative analysis of
these models, emphasising their synergistic potential in addressing text
anonymisation challenges. Preliminary results indicate that CRF, LSTM, and ELMo
individually outperform traditional methods. The inclusion of Transformers,
when compared alongside with the other models, offers a broader perspective on
achieving optimal text anonymisation in contemporary settings.
|
[
0.0014242612523958087,
-0.8635005354881287,
0.5455852746963501,
0.14455705881118774,
-0.01881338842213154,
0.3004027307033539,
-0.31098634004592896,
-0.8558741807937622,
0.02043527364730835,
0.6535969376564026,
-0.48911499977111816,
-0.5708089470863342,
-0.6119582653045654,
0.4840259850025177,
-1.0783758163452148,
0.8192189335823059,
-0.02866334468126297,
-0.09839805215597153,
-0.492851197719574,
-0.35508060455322266,
-0.1905723363161087,
-0.7969882488250732,
-0.6439376473426819,
-0.12065903097391129,
0.4061400890350342,
-0.1464756429195404,
0.9330924153327942,
1.0917280912399292,
0.9727501273155212,
0.5176220536231995,
-0.13320541381835938,
-0.21319058537483215,
-0.43217310309410095,
0.2121218740940094,
-0.24738271534442902,
-0.5276092290878296,
0.03132084757089615,
0.02123335190117359,
0.592363715171814,
0.14215445518493652,
-0.029339779168367386,
0.12000177800655365,
-0.18855668604373932,
0.542527437210083,
-0.736511766910553,
-0.05991264805197716,
-0.4643028676509857,
0.27491623163223267,
-0.24940946698188782,
-0.004829526413232088,
-0.44647106528282166,
-0.3946673572063446,
0.4686874449253082,
-0.5270510911941528,
0.36418142914772034,
0.35441720485687256,
1.2147635221481323,
0.4692472517490387,
-0.12965506315231323,
-0.6366884708404541,
-1.110363245010376,
0.9986850619316101,
-0.6553574800491333,
0.26146572828292847,
0.4898652136325836,
0.23588556051254272,
0.442863792181015,
-1.0961109399795532,
-0.5700023770332336,
-0.3500096797943115,
-0.5580811500549316,
0.27784469723701477,
-0.17678917944431305,
0.11831345409154892,
0.04138065129518509,
0.5016959309577942,
-0.3686411678791046,
0.4791809320449829,
-0.19461014866828918,
-0.36861953139305115,
0.5799644589424133,
0.25573471188545227,
0.46509799361228943,
-0.1592799425125122,
-0.6649587750434875,
-0.054515764117240906,
-0.13356474041938782,
-0.11675471812486649,
0.6621444821357727,
-0.17260527610778809,
-0.21719980239868164,
0.5657418370246887,
-0.1454935371875763,
0.30336233973503113,
0.016837703064084053,
-0.26593533158302307,
-0.02712893858551979,
-0.5066516399383545,
-0.0765356719493866,
-0.06735959649085999,
1.0990744829177856,
-0.03331771492958069,
0.3274310231208801,
-0.6939165592193604,
-0.15456394851207733,
0.04822419956326485,
0.36700305342674255,
-0.700606644153595,
-0.1413034200668335,
0.21553552150726318,
-0.8384365439414978,
-0.30516138672828674,
-0.05430779233574867,
-0.8484218716621399,
-0.4326137900352478,
-0.2826904058456421,
0.6072962880134583,
-0.47549450397491455,
0.1817636489868164,
-0.22029158473014832,
-0.25493019819259644,
0.0775664821267128,
0.2415008842945099,
-1.003833532333374,
0.36955124139785767,
0.6083943247795105,
0.7293137907981873,
-0.51237553358078,
-0.30709144473075867,
0.24511882662773132,
0.15893390774726868,
0.008151881396770477,
0.6875989437103271,
-0.7448458075523376,
-0.42433905601501465,
0.2345246523618698,
-0.16217949986457825,
-0.24523921310901642,
-0.4291411340236664,
0.4582403302192688,
-0.5005899667739868,
0.7169765830039978,
0.044332005083560944,
-0.6500049829483032,
-0.2705869972705841,
0.2159651517868042,
-0.7791344523429871,
1.104905605316162,
-0.03165298327803612,
-1.0039880275726318,
0.061925292015075684,
-0.4406683146953583,
-0.3777748644351959,
-0.09237902611494064,
-0.3214634656906128,
-0.7027260661125183,
-0.03326801210641861,
0.18729819357395172,
0.23734372854232788,
-0.310000479221344,
0.04166946932673454,
-0.19328534603118896,
-0.35008931159973145,
0.37429365515708923,
-0.7271019816398621,
0.606480062007904,
0.1251586675643921,
-0.4267449378967285,
0.11034549027681351,
-0.7554914355278015,
-0.4186978042125702,
0.22530603408813477,
-0.019391262903809547,
-0.5178689360618591,
0.27589789032936096,
0.043216485530138016,
-0.25092828273773193,
0.44267627596855164,
-0.35614627599716187,
-0.18606054782867432,
-0.5999754071235657,
0.5268386602401733,
0.5433354377746582,
-0.07285012304782867,
0.7994744777679443,
-0.33224913477897644,
0.5387860536575317,
-0.1324319988489151,
0.13686226308345795,
-0.45480722188949585,
-0.07149272412061691,
-0.7721754908561707,
-0.6342574954032898,
0.7118169665336609,
0.7060272693634033,
-0.5143153667449951,
0.1995784491300583,
-0.1796199083328247,
-0.2002575844526291,
-0.6553909778594971,
-0.03353676199913025,
0.4449312686920166,
0.5349018573760986,
0.3897901177406311,
-0.20695456862449646,
-0.40740716457366943,
-1.1754146814346313,
-0.48813891410827637,
-0.0670483410358429,
-0.137965127825737,
0.28782251477241516,
0.3509315252304077,
-0.22404751181602478,
1.043308138847351,
-0.05698775872588158,
-0.5827858448028564,
-0.2459147572517395,
0.28110870718955994,
-0.20656771957874298,
0.13650226593017578,
0.6834053993225098,
-0.7743623852729797,
-0.5388271808624268,
-0.18569116294384003,
-0.8810059428215027,
0.14531871676445007,
-0.30235400795936584,
0.10792087018489838,
0.21746018528938293,
0.36390775442123413,
-0.6784307956695557,
0.739916205406189,
0.4561257064342499,
-0.15720610320568085,
0.19954068958759308,
-0.37459084391593933,
0.3438238203525543,
-0.773658037185669,
0.23268043994903564,
-0.21796782314777374,
-0.27480965852737427,
-0.6650689244270325,
0.16725365817546844,
0.059135470539331436,
-0.05470501631498337,
-0.4136362373828888,
0.6558670401573181,
-0.6645012497901917,
0.19649824500083923,
-0.2855924367904663,
0.06684131175279617,
-0.08402077108621597,
0.3063003718852997,
0.12438192218542099,
0.761276364326477,
0.385084867477417,
-0.33947882056236267,
-0.2632123529911041,
0.2525802254676819,
0.014426902867853642,
0.22183756530284882,
-0.40886032581329346,
0.32029491662979126,
-0.36666131019592285,
0.0031423720065504313,
-0.9556840658187866,
-0.04143716022372246,
0.2836742401123047,
-0.3657661974430084,
0.3754124343395233,
0.15214544534683228,
-0.6627972722053528,
-0.16977691650390625,
-0.4582064151763916,
0.6780585646629333,
0.4962725043296814,
-0.45794111490249634,
0.8120699524879456,
0.41883543133735657,
-0.1777416467666626,
-0.7116722464561462,
-0.4946918189525604,
0.4828052818775177,
-0.5060784816741943,
-0.39660435914993286,
0.6940364837646484,
0.09115646034479141,
-0.47069817781448364,
0.27305862307548523,
0.09071483463048935,
-0.4308629035949707,
0.20475661754608154,
0.12286091595888138,
0.12584324181079865,
-0.10496751964092255,
0.16809988021850586,
-0.11371812969446182,
-0.23959924280643463,
0.10310202836990356,
0.12240871787071228,
0.23868495225906372,
0.2346094846725464,
0.11155792325735092,
-0.9641641974449158,
0.4807913303375244,
0.24182815849781036,
-0.4176999032497406,
0.8586322665214539,
0.6014919281005859,
-0.2797885239124298,
-0.17965872585773468,
-0.7192672491073608,
-0.17907500267028809,
-0.4950183928012848,
0.33639493584632874,
0.1987457573413849,
-0.8542031049728394,
0.4793763756752014,
0.11261379718780518,
0.14788466691970825,
0.579689621925354,
0.39545202255249023,
-0.2659948468208313,
0.7629187107086182,
0.8680656552314758,
-0.5275325775146484,
0.47265133261680603,
0.06679776310920715,
0.35926809906959534,
-0.09240337461233139,
-0.022196080535650253,
-0.8387037515640259,
-0.2963666617870331,
-0.8094027638435364,
-0.26093998551368713,
-0.10488341748714447,
-0.20819148421287537,
0.046121805906295776,
0.2595692574977875,
-0.577134370803833,
0.4953305721282959,
0.5798585414886475,
-0.01214386336505413,
0.4303373098373413,
-0.026219835504889488,
0.33293306827545166,
-0.1306932419538498,
-0.603517472743988,
-0.6714497208595276,
1.0310057401657104,
0.4325883090496063,
0.5191101431846619,
-0.1310754418373108,
0.8508172035217285,
0.6542419791221619,
0.5725656151771545,
-0.7151922583580017,
0.4854268431663513,
-0.36632564663887024,
-0.6994196772575378,
-0.5923977494239807,
-0.2839799225330353,
-1.0824965238571167,
0.07545027136802673,
-0.43292850255966187,
-0.9232209920883179,
-0.12105859071016312,
0.17324979603290558,
-0.29704317450523376,
0.14369738101959229,
-0.5479272603988647,
0.5896218419075012,
-0.1310303509235382,
-0.39251068234443665,
-0.2871990501880646,
-0.7028364539146423,
0.20781075954437256,
-0.09874555468559265,
0.3191315829753876,
0.0752478837966919,
-0.15116403996944427,
0.7509791254997253,
-0.16493414342403412,
0.7570463418960571,
0.36379924416542053,
0.16919252276420593,
0.3905225396156311,
-0.2394626885652542,
0.5227167010307312,
0.022846393287181854,
-0.12632159888744354,
0.5860269069671631,
0.060096170753240585,
-0.19196799397468567,
-0.33231842517852783,
0.6188712120056152,
-0.6066030859947205,
-0.5223414301872253,
-0.4955223500728607,
-0.5466634035110474,
0.07083729654550552,
0.4598363935947418,
0.3665534257888794,
0.3051491677761078,
-0.31125277280807495,
0.5208461284637451,
0.6333131194114685,
-0.33161887526512146,
1.1275819540023804,
0.30993083119392395,
0.22837509214878082,
-0.5030749440193176,
0.6092739105224609,
-0.008224088698625565,
-0.17079782485961914,
0.8509905338287354,
0.26115119457244873,
-0.45587384700775146,
-0.5189136266708374,
-0.3403044641017914,
0.24236485362052917,
-0.47885656356811523,
-0.16450554132461548,
-0.7514437437057495,
-0.37999752163887024,
-0.0764043852686882,
-0.07681279629468918,
-0.4942902624607086,
-0.44930899143218994,
-0.3848351538181305,
0.002145221224054694,
0.243168443441391,
0.6411312222480774,
0.4570198953151703,
0.263325035572052,
-0.6925200819969177,
0.5501862168312073,
-0.022637875750660896,
0.09883485734462738,
0.12710919976234436,
-0.21539217233657837,
-0.37320446968078613,
-0.20367497205734253,
-0.24006731808185577,
-0.8958204388618469,
0.3283710181713104,
0.12083699554204941,
0.4170167148113251,
0.1872190535068512,
0.10240235924720764,
0.3984738290309906,
-0.7743861079216003,
0.7638993859291077,
0.16693753004074097,
-0.8308538794517517,
0.14715392887592316,
-0.23527704179286957,
0.13735005259513855,
0.7065886855125427,
0.2590756416320801,
0.02858700603246689,
-0.7705041766166687,
-0.6143108010292053,
-1.0483535528182983,
0.5867723226547241,
0.5740242600440979,
0.3593991696834564,
0.13710716366767883,
0.40589335560798645,
0.2820262312889099,
0.3599395751953125,
-0.8039903044700623,
-0.5723481178283691,
0.008427818305790424,
-0.645505428314209,
-0.06183859705924988,
-0.34953200817108154,
0.009300370700657368,
0.1347520798444748,
0.12451968342065811,
0.4187086224555969,
0.3988784849643707,
0.33008676767349243,
-0.30089032649993896,
0.2737862169742584,
0.17486052215099335,
0.6425529718399048,
0.559148907661438,
0.153595432639122,
0.11990119516849518,
0.15031690895557404,
-0.6000768542289734,
0.028540072962641716,
0.19661834836006165,
-0.56341552734375,
0.3100588917732239,
0.5316409468650818,
0.5200138092041016,
0.2528912425041199,
-0.4942863881587982,
0.4242244064807892,
-0.06294295936822891,
-0.21289855241775513,
-0.4026227295398712,
-0.01008484698832035,
0.10330799967050552,
0.11835653334856033,
0.34195852279663086,
-0.18342353403568268,
0.35101091861724854,
-0.4458557665348053,
0.10841978341341019,
0.3671662211418152,
-0.22854657471179962,
-0.3729967176914215,
0.9494349956512451,
0.1569175273180008,
-0.8349502682685852,
0.35154542326927185,
0.3042106330394745,
-0.2532878518104553,
0.7140560746192932,
0.2245246022939682,
1.1120420694351196,
-0.3373062312602997,
0.09240370988845825,
0.15784049034118652,
0.3967802822589874,
-0.19699129462242126,
-0.3039790987968445,
-0.2639978528022766,
-0.30705827474594116,
0.005461357068270445,
-0.4187468886375427,
-0.5255094766616821,
0.12733891606330872,
-0.6642839312553406,
0.002457922790199518,
-0.46066907048225403,
-0.29143357276916504,
-0.02231127768754959,
-0.15585114061832428,
-0.8609238862991333,
0.34115156531333923,
0.03763832151889801,
0.4378882050514221,
-0.38794654607772827,
0.7073904275894165,
0.2873072028160095,
-0.05702446773648262,
-0.3241017460823059,
0.33565157651901245,
-0.07576893270015717,
-0.6443164348602295,
0.2867509424686432,
0.2967364490032196,
-0.05152548849582672,
0.05762919783592224,
-0.1620578169822693,
-0.8576592206954956,
1.0747973918914795,
0.08101625740528107,
-0.5804028511047363,
-0.06860102713108063,
0.5974663496017456,
0.9705151319503784,
-0.05402606725692749,
0.46289822459220886,
0.44709721207618713,
0.4159092903137207,
-0.4627911448478699,
-0.6946693062782288,
0.01369992084801197,
0.2138521373271942,
0.01227316539734602,
0.28704050183296204,
-0.8492809534072876,
0.2955946922302246,
0.022172048687934875,
-0.5300713777542114,
0.5060912370681763,
0.8805172443389893,
-0.2892838716506958,
0.4836910665035248,
0.2566993832588196,
0.3012435734272003,
0.4991603195667267,
0.08897598087787628,
0.8302713632583618,
-0.5888570547103882,
0.46793046593666077,
1.070523738861084,
-0.09790833294391632,
0.8086044192314148,
0.43748998641967773,
-0.07051695883274078,
0.41424867510795593,
0.3723142445087433,
-0.11767858266830444,
0.5414215922355652,
0.13780386745929718,
-0.12952342629432678,
0.17907629907131195,
-0.029865222051739693,
-0.21269963681697845,
0.5661730170249939,
-0.0027699542697519064,
-0.7804802656173706,
-0.22546809911727905,
-0.09980792552232742,
0.09394314140081406,
0.4858658015727997,
0.013768333941698074,
0.848273754119873,
0.07152029871940613,
-0.5191299319267273,
0.030237605795264244,
0.220505952835083,
0.5436672568321228,
-0.6633171439170837,
0.156040221452713,
-0.4101591408252716,
0.23585708439350128,
0.10307486355304718,
-0.2599225640296936,
0.2258584350347519,
0.13510680198669434,
-0.24698595702648163,
-0.6229876279830933,
0.7388633489608765,
-0.39080414175987244,
-0.5679731369018555,
0.31743916869163513,
0.16601049900054932,
-0.3000941276550293,
0.33120012283325195,
-0.7894627451896667,
0.031416118144989014,
-0.2547391355037689,
-0.3564029633998871,
0.4093226492404938,
0.3583439588546753,
0.03323132544755936,
0.727357029914856,
0.18493714928627014,
-0.1763763278722763,
-0.07534251362085342,
0.11291874200105667,
0.39964115619659424,
-0.7260339856147766,
-0.5488207340240479,
-1.100764513015747,
0.3058767318725586,
-0.2934008538722992,
-0.37548065185546875,
1.198447585105896,
0.5721759796142578,
0.6939793825149536,
-0.014479473233222961,
0.6166625022888184,
0.2605738937854767,
0.5715084075927734,
-0.45922642946243286,
0.974708616733551,
-0.31098422408103943,
0.4700167179107666,
-0.20895695686340332,
-0.8140566945075989,
-0.28414186835289,
0.22274260222911835,
-0.1435675024986267,
-0.10371172428131104,
0.8467656970024109,
0.5393638610839844,
0.10938376933336258,
-0.04921187460422516,
0.24389806389808655,
0.1546456664800644,
0.027999037876725197,
-0.003889232175424695,
0.8847359418869019,
-0.42099082469940186,
0.5571970343589783,
-0.5936561226844788,
-0.0038419754710048437,
0.046746402978897095,
-0.757350742816925,
-1.2113035917282104,
-0.23705002665519714,
-0.40770235657691956,
-0.03128359839320183,
0.3409094214439392,
0.3043545186519623,
0.3860950469970703,
-0.7599016427993774,
-0.22667571902275085,
0.12879249453544617,
0.09101623296737671,
-0.12207385152578354,
-0.2119680941104889,
0.6471840739250183,
-0.2182483822107315,
-0.968558669090271,
0.1232931986451149,
0.5273310542106628,
0.09520579874515533,
-0.21317161619663239,
0.2757912576198578,
0.13830561935901642,
0.47165027260780334,
0.4030342698097229,
0.17475074529647827,
-0.8023625016212463,
-0.4515971839427948,
0.24080254137516022,
-0.31001994013786316,
0.1109006255865097,
0.7390108108520508,
-0.7314625978469849,
0.42906343936920166,
0.6021767258644104,
0.8934919834136963,
0.31475719809532166,
0.3991774022579193,
0.45616263151168823,
-0.30719080567359924,
0.2489650547504425,
0.4444943964481354,
0.052872657775878906,
0.06585030257701874,
-0.5219322443008423,
0.3333202004432678,
0.04901393502950668,
-0.45849889516830444,
-0.8473363518714905,
-0.21374830603599548,
-0.6775192022323608,
-0.3938813805580139,
1.0087977647781372,
-0.0662674754858017,
-0.05857420712709427,
-0.09464878588914871,
-0.060204558074474335,
0.10982415080070496,
-0.1470169723033905,
1.4366178512573242,
0.7087218165397644,
0.1419561356306076,
-0.0364576019346714,
-0.468700647354126,
0.6230438947677612,
0.5982772707939148,
-0.6603982448577881,
-0.2586381137371063,
0.05428484454751015,
0.05317652225494385,
0.021200740709900856,
0.5496317148208618,
-0.07498354464769363,
-0.1336311399936676,
-0.0427703857421875,
-0.1191844567656517,
0.059396207332611084,
-0.3595193326473236,
-0.23518139123916626,
0.33409491181373596,
-0.49034541845321655,
-0.2605977952480316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05678v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05678v1
|
Beyond Prompts: Learning from Human Communication for Enhanced AI Intent Alignment
| 2024-05-09T11:10:29 | 2024-05-09T11:10:29 |
Yoonsu Kim, Kihoon Son, Seoyoung Kim, Juho Kim
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
AI intent alignment, ensuring that AI produces outcomes as intended by users,
is a critical challenge in human-AI interaction. The emergence of generative
AI, including LLMs, has intensified the significance of this problem, as
interactions increasingly involve users specifying desired results for AI
systems. In order to support better AI intent alignment, we aim to explore
human strategies for intent specification in human-human communication. By
studying and comparing human-human and human-LLM communication, we identify key
strategies that can be applied to the design of AI systems that are more
effective at understanding and aligning with user intent. This study aims to
advance toward a human-centered AI system by bringing together human
communication strategies for the design of AI systems.
|
[
-0.37524014711380005,
-0.530285656452179,
0.8818218111991882,
0.09316612035036087,
-0.03430895879864693,
0.21817685663700104,
-0.2950271666049957,
-0.527863085269928,
0.08188736438751221,
0.3073362112045288,
-0.9687752723693848,
-0.40405917167663574,
-0.32991868257522583,
0.21541482210159302,
0.006049425806850195,
0.6265926957130432,
-0.07043516635894775,
0.16100241243839264,
-0.6177685856819153,
0.015136836096644402,
-0.9189702868461609,
-0.36107489466667175,
-0.9093289971351624,
-0.5576082468032837,
0.6456174254417419,
0.8659470081329346,
0.6204149127006531,
0.4208792746067047,
0.48077091574668884,
0.27962252497673035,
0.2161569446325302,
0.4095815420150757,
-0.3900856375694275,
0.36680129170417786,
0.0312700979411602,
-0.6268931031227112,
-0.4192953109741211,
0.312868595123291,
0.46203887462615967,
0.5113472938537598,
-0.07888736575841904,
0.08780691027641296,
0.19645725190639496,
0.6841707825660706,
-0.4700517952442169,
0.09104379266500473,
-0.10929089784622192,
0.07016608119010925,
-0.191807359457016,
-0.4932619631290436,
-0.5773637890815735,
-0.240836039185524,
0.17425335943698883,
-0.7689701318740845,
-0.28438907861709595,
0.2023397833108902,
0.5321003198623657,
0.42645078897476196,
-0.33361348509788513,
-0.4924930930137634,
-0.8319714665412903,
0.623829185962677,
-0.4996432960033417,
0.40286725759506226,
0.30023834109306335,
0.24326016008853912,
-0.43106192350387573,
-0.4374580383300781,
-0.635743260383606,
-0.26737356185913086,
-0.08220894634723663,
0.03540808707475662,
0.03330747038125992,
0.25950419902801514,
0.17435379326343536,
-0.0996185839176178,
-0.5556036829948425,
0.3194616436958313,
-0.14985226094722748,
-0.0799340233206749,
1.0969675779342651,
0.3823530375957489,
0.47585684061050415,
0.12137875705957413,
-0.48203015327453613,
-0.15791729092597961,
-0.8639143109321594,
0.19562438130378723,
0.2928003966808319,
0.2139933556318283,
-0.18442729115486145,
0.7171978950500488,
-0.20614537596702576,
0.7279461026191711,
0.2692905068397522,
-0.04867509379982948,
-0.08534976094961166,
-0.35558056831359863,
-0.05783875659108162,
0.22322925925254822,
0.699016273021698,
0.5083919763565063,
0.17394506931304932,
-0.2876281142234802,
-0.0970742404460907,
0.006344752386212349,
0.6187798976898193,
-0.349855899810791,
0.08515667170286179,
0.13599061965942383,
-0.6307169198989868,
-0.11368393898010254,
0.12626902759075165,
-0.3662431538105011,
-0.6476245522499084,
-0.7407305240631104,
0.38895007967948914,
-0.3095933496952057,
-0.09184517711400986,
-0.010082930326461792,
-0.2093236893415451,
0.8086841702461243,
0.5070397853851318,
-1.055455207824707,
0.22031167149543762,
0.9219421744346619,
0.4556095004081726,
-0.3216594159603119,
-0.49879544973373413,
-0.3631596267223358,
0.30671000480651855,
-0.3343283236026764,
0.7519241571426392,
-0.39726385474205017,
-0.5108331441879272,
-0.101829893887043,
-0.4479874074459076,
-0.010558613575994968,
-0.2689287066459656,
0.7276003360748291,
-0.5884932279586792,
0.44072407484054565,
-0.3651520907878876,
-0.7185876965522766,
-0.2649475336074829,
0.2676982879638672,
-0.24169163405895233,
0.4922412931919098,
-0.020414605736732483,
-0.2745821177959442,
0.41349127888679504,
-1.2131156921386719,
-0.6160142421722412,
0.29223594069480896,
-0.4786961078643799,
-0.07975990325212479,
0.12067610025405884,
0.09698629379272461,
0.49811458587646484,
-0.32089343667030334,
0.09524239599704742,
0.004178666975349188,
-0.5592531561851501,
0.35152778029441833,
-0.6697244644165039,
0.7608682513237,
0.08779137581586838,
-0.6347061991691589,
0.5901848077774048,
-0.30483922362327576,
0.061206310987472534,
0.06571856141090393,
-0.4292953908443451,
-0.0059925708919763565,
0.3212103247642517,
-0.36804887652397156,
0.10473763197660446,
0.3089753985404968,
-0.15564382076263428,
0.40832096338272095,
-0.235578253865242,
0.3436301052570343,
0.9052996039390564,
-0.35441088676452637,
0.778048038482666,
-0.5974263548851013,
0.4747181236743927,
-0.3833145499229431,
0.5429790019989014,
-0.21918025612831116,
-0.7424182295799255,
-0.6056247353553772,
0.04583783820271492,
-0.28456297516822815,
0.7070492506027222,
-0.3417237102985382,
0.678014874458313,
-0.30778735876083374,
-0.17986272275447845,
-0.7316222190856934,
0.30356281995773315,
0.4462296664714813,
0.49312037229537964,
0.20427387952804565,
-0.2627449631690979,
-0.5137353539466858,
-0.6571714282035828,
-0.19446592032909393,
-0.5312988758087158,
-0.11984210461378098,
0.7360910773277283,
-0.0670977532863617,
-0.4846847355365753,
0.9744167327880859,
-0.4583466053009033,
-0.22211723029613495,
-0.49705448746681213,
0.09783929586410522,
-0.14297252893447876,
0.3029252886772156,
0.331642210483551,
-0.8370955586433411,
-0.4399074912071228,
-0.09573971480131149,
-0.8054654002189636,
0.0155365951359272,
-0.2391275018453598,
-0.333589643239975,
0.28835320472717285,
0.6321843266487122,
-0.800754964351654,
0.6744863986968994,
0.18544936180114746,
-0.44129934906959534,
0.357986718416214,
-0.11703222990036011,
0.4850190579891205,
-1.154083251953125,
-0.17429310083389282,
-0.13148558139801025,
-0.11516278982162476,
-0.635546863079071,
-0.281627893447876,
-0.17715060710906982,
-0.003946792334318161,
-0.5780124068260193,
0.633216381072998,
-0.6076588034629822,
-0.16535145044326782,
-0.3254939317703247,
0.1407512128353119,
0.06002827733755112,
0.2944127023220062,
0.17377939820289612,
1.0840682983398438,
0.3746328353881836,
-0.6050001978874207,
0.5251248478889465,
0.7179983854293823,
-0.13301965594291687,
0.7967649102210999,
-0.6867318153381348,
0.3305606245994568,
-0.20847272872924805,
0.3990905284881592,
-1.2256394624710083,
-0.35638153553009033,
0.6721689105033875,
-0.6859192848205566,
0.36516913771629333,
0.08835107833147049,
-0.12143110483884811,
-0.3272526264190674,
-0.4274240732192993,
0.5208607912063599,
0.5672162771224976,
-0.5639461874961853,
0.7900899052619934,
0.24252189695835114,
-0.0937301442027092,
-0.3965246379375458,
-0.5377872586250305,
0.3904156982898712,
-0.5635060667991638,
-0.9597763419151306,
0.42926424741744995,
-0.22475621104240417,
-0.2857779860496521,
-0.46538370847702026,
0.41912397742271423,
0.3758809268474579,
0.4239744544029236,
0.37366873025894165,
0.3635674715042114,
-0.23186473548412323,
0.058341868221759796,
-0.11615084111690521,
-0.1267312914133072,
0.2334998995065689,
-0.18723300099372864,
0.700448751449585,
0.1234133243560791,
-0.8058057427406311,
-1.4425705671310425,
0.6249585151672363,
0.46524786949157715,
0.16685880720615387,
0.7987745404243469,
0.5701502561569214,
-0.03841285780072212,
0.35965102910995483,
-0.5710474848747253,
-0.5620492696762085,
-0.5168460011482239,
-0.007189493626356125,
-0.31734028458595276,
-0.6984043121337891,
0.2646247446537018,
-0.28459084033966064,
0.2415519505739212,
0.1887209564447403,
0.4292561113834381,
-0.7642545104026794,
1.3485150337219238,
0.8580471277236938,
-0.13986770808696747,
0.6982234120368958,
0.012839979492127895,
0.05224037915468216,
-1.0812872648239136,
-0.5068017244338989,
-0.31087586283683777,
-0.7081145644187927,
-0.2782895267009735,
-0.1659773886203766,
0.2211618721485138,
0.020489022135734558,
-0.2800396680831909,
0.19726693630218506,
-0.5014508962631226,
0.2727740705013275,
0.9347688555717468,
0.2079099714756012,
0.0485219806432724,
0.05067034065723419,
0.3348889946937561,
0.01494310237467289,
-0.5892330408096313,
-0.8142057061195374,
1.0075368881225586,
0.30143070220947266,
0.9148855209350586,
0.4259704351425171,
0.8717901110649109,
0.4661019444465637,
0.4672083854675293,
-0.8402091860771179,
0.49086812138557434,
0.3131566047668457,
-0.24726331233978271,
-0.5508947968482971,
-0.19565923511981964,
-1.2396321296691895,
-0.1694958508014679,
-0.2929224669933319,
-0.9104993939399719,
-0.13707265257835388,
0.231352299451828,
-0.5213034749031067,
-0.19845281541347504,
-0.9261570572853088,
0.7695571780204773,
-0.5979933738708496,
-0.03358466178178787,
-0.34414297342300415,
-0.9381819367408752,
0.1427222639322281,
0.601412832736969,
-0.1176479160785675,
-0.14222536981105804,
-0.26368674635887146,
0.6658386588096619,
0.06882993131875992,
1.1864341497421265,
0.11746000498533249,
-0.31408175826072693,
0.2977249324321747,
-0.3523109555244446,
0.46551352739334106,
0.07873968780040741,
0.08548092842102051,
-0.10438679903745651,
-0.8507270216941833,
-0.277361124753952,
-0.5242810845375061,
0.3870686888694763,
-0.9763712882995605,
-1.0958409309387207,
-0.09452948719263077,
-0.5351467132568359,
-0.09694021940231323,
0.19530253112316132,
0.2938508987426758,
0.3285224735736847,
-0.47921013832092285,
-0.2805469036102295,
0.820088803768158,
0.06752212345600128,
0.42413246631622314,
0.30613332986831665,
0.13944879174232483,
-0.18659038841724396,
0.690143883228302,
-0.5716816186904907,
0.19832441210746765,
0.5571566820144653,
0.03743557631969452,
-0.6757871508598328,
-0.5073423981666565,
-0.6387503147125244,
0.050444766879081726,
-0.6274875998497009,
-0.17973192036151886,
-0.28550875186920166,
-0.21303635835647583,
-0.8173544406890869,
-0.4930615723133087,
0.12838327884674072,
-0.02869792841374874,
-0.9436314105987549,
0.16875092685222626,
0.24244515597820282,
0.8339887261390686,
0.06345980614423752,
0.5522864460945129,
-0.9196066856384277,
0.27973535656929016,
0.42159563302993774,
0.09118557721376419,
-0.1271100640296936,
-0.4951672852039337,
0.1402529925107956,
0.393524706363678,
-0.5837309956550598,
-0.9609322547912598,
-0.11318716406822205,
0.1297830194234848,
1.0363166332244873,
0.8177682161331177,
-0.09925830364227295,
0.5301710963249207,
-0.3682689070701599,
0.7959179282188416,
0.2389061599969864,
-0.8503163456916809,
0.7665202021598816,
-0.08857881277799606,
0.08528551459312439,
0.5517275333404541,
0.45288363099098206,
-0.863486111164093,
0.13675649464130402,
-0.528624415397644,
-0.6616725921630859,
0.8785198926925659,
0.09148349612951279,
0.20255669951438904,
0.1306154578924179,
0.6394484639167786,
0.016907544806599617,
0.024847183376550674,
-0.2640281021595001,
-0.3114725351333618,
0.25194865465164185,
-0.40907734632492065,
-0.26088201999664307,
-0.1145615503191948,
-0.4685637950897217,
-0.024304311722517014,
0.36771732568740845,
-0.1278935968875885,
0.35533931851387024,
0.0795513167977333,
-0.15595181286334991,
-0.06008675694465637,
0.2147969901561737,
1.0454362630844116,
0.6411990523338318,
0.29339051246643066,
-0.015869151800870895,
-0.09199902415275574,
-0.2711218297481537,
0.40082430839538574,
-0.019697807729244232,
-0.21910099685192108,
-0.5933176875114441,
0.3332194685935974,
0.9596918225288391,
-0.08569417893886566,
-0.708999514579773,
0.42119839787483215,
-0.37968677282333374,
-0.012982764281332493,
-0.2626357674598694,
0.6137380003929138,
0.2687770426273346,
0.4512457251548767,
0.4789840281009674,
-0.014461196959018707,
0.15853847563266754,
-0.5307578444480896,
0.23465804755687714,
0.7397274374961853,
-0.4319644570350647,
-0.21289172768592834,
0.5586749315261841,
0.6577720642089844,
-0.9094770550727844,
0.9571452140808105,
-0.1272800713777542,
-0.4097997844219208,
0.43081170320510864,
0.33609429001808167,
0.9758172631263733,
-0.2847754955291748,
0.3947356045246124,
-0.14154499769210815,
0.01704697497189045,
0.08038810640573502,
0.3851124942302704,
-0.6251844167709351,
-0.7634162306785583,
-0.3454299867153168,
0.04206636920571327,
-0.4167957007884979,
-0.40565741062164307,
-0.4491354525089264,
0.27481481432914734,
-0.10579545050859451,
-0.2782977223396301,
-0.07301850616931915,
0.04423680901527405,
-0.4819745123386383,
-0.18790112435817719,
0.5005413889884949,
0.7783457636833191,
-0.6450982093811035,
0.20039018988609314,
1.0630381107330322,
-0.1876898854970932,
-0.7445151209831238,
0.18907226622104645,
0.10657907277345657,
-0.9986221790313721,
0.5896428823471069,
0.2823544442653656,
-0.23133979737758636,
0.14255391061306,
-0.6478816270828247,
-0.6723645925521851,
1.3904985189437866,
0.24212144315242767,
-0.31244391202926636,
0.03386685252189636,
0.28752389550209045,
0.17955157160758972,
-0.5079489350318909,
0.36655062437057495,
0.5238504409790039,
0.6712031364440918,
0.05434281751513481,
-0.7087247967720032,
0.039916008710861206,
0.004458306822925806,
-0.1040206104516983,
0.17622119188308716,
-0.7276569604873657,
0.26487997174263,
-0.6239084601402283,
-0.5087195038795471,
0.31800514459609985,
1.0397398471832275,
0.4170367419719696,
0.5231865048408508,
0.36367279291152954,
0.4004856050014496,
0.8052073121070862,
-0.027472231537103653,
0.8230977058410645,
0.05445672199130058,
-0.2488088458776474,
0.786191463470459,
-0.42364656925201416,
0.5664562582969666,
0.6728366613388062,
-0.1785571426153183,
0.4427453875541687,
0.7981858253479004,
0.48693305253982544,
0.2393607348203659,
0.12621057033538818,
-0.528659999370575,
-0.2549317479133606,
-0.33098021149635315,
-0.21370643377304077,
0.49684566259384155,
0.6182171106338501,
-0.015512743033468723,
0.05196557939052582,
0.028710516169667244,
-0.20806601643562317,
-0.014017612673342228,
-0.31799519062042236,
1.4481449127197266,
-0.1049022451043129,
-0.9642020463943481,
0.3210517168045044,
-0.18817920982837677,
0.8546124696731567,
-0.25079020857810974,
-0.07516469061374664,
-0.047006819397211075,
-0.004463245626538992,
-0.1846151351928711,
-1.0145378112792969,
0.037963129580020905,
-0.37178748846054077,
-0.3036128282546997,
-0.3045130968093872,
0.7482250928878784,
-0.3938278257846832,
0.021967293694615364,
-0.021511416882276535,
0.4641798138618469,
0.17296822369098663,
0.1002790629863739,
-0.8059602975845337,
0.26446256041526794,
-0.03040311112999916,
-0.09406387805938721,
0.20706501603126526,
0.13196958601474762,
-0.0993465855717659,
0.8313314914703369,
0.5942202210426331,
-0.2677110433578491,
-0.12552931904792786,
0.17045040428638458,
0.6603973507881165,
-0.680166482925415,
-0.33699890971183777,
-0.9403069615364075,
0.5098749995231628,
-0.23684997856616974,
-0.27262142300605774,
0.5878336429595947,
0.25177478790283203,
0.6139475703239441,
0.12196356803178787,
0.7337206602096558,
0.020306263118982315,
0.007233609911054373,
-0.4466860592365265,
0.41219818592071533,
-0.3410545587539673,
0.2925633192062378,
0.09977748990058899,
-0.7870081663131714,
-0.09568142890930176,
0.4434419870376587,
-0.16623176634311676,
0.2887239456176758,
0.17112649977207184,
0.5001709461212158,
0.1067814975976944,
0.11799509823322296,
0.17304742336273193,
-0.33266958594322205,
0.6094601154327393,
0.6579020619392395,
1.4005765914916992,
-0.09323596209287643,
0.38851580023765564,
0.04950853809714317,
-0.42276376485824585,
-0.5524164438247681,
-0.7371744513511658,
-0.9056518077850342,
-0.5728813409805298,
-0.12483783811330795,
0.0563230998814106,
0.2576349377632141,
1.0905269384384155,
0.788009524345398,
-0.5020960569381714,
-0.3069497346878052,
-0.2925472557544708,
0.4103686809539795,
-0.19153867661952972,
-0.2576594352722168,
0.1671772003173828,
-0.5422698259353638,
-0.6636447906494141,
0.4361521899700165,
0.45188310742378235,
0.4902133345603943,
-0.38212770223617554,
-0.641250729560852,
-0.039936210960149765,
0.01611965335905552,
0.5680521130561829,
0.4909651577472687,
-0.8589493632316589,
-0.32119789719581604,
0.22123442590236664,
-0.40062299370765686,
0.18065914511680603,
1.1338099241256714,
-0.741995096206665,
-0.0929446592926979,
0.590915858745575,
0.8869650363922119,
-0.2185298502445221,
0.46793505549430847,
0.962567150592804,
-0.5738316774368286,
-0.0842682495713234,
0.32507258653640747,
-0.030415566638112068,
0.4972032606601715,
-0.8764787912368774,
0.1742955595254898,
-0.1976764053106308,
-0.6603008508682251,
-0.36228376626968384,
0.44413286447525024,
-0.9188876748085022,
-0.195792093873024,
1.0380948781967163,
-0.06970681995153427,
-0.006914685480296612,
-0.3020690977573395,
-0.5887985825538635,
0.3549553453922272,
-0.5944918394088745,
0.9012073278427124,
0.579738974571228,
-0.9016863107681274,
-0.13766659796237946,
0.03162820637226105,
0.8098993897438049,
0.43992388248443604,
-1.0847325325012207,
-0.07295762747526169,
0.44351714849472046,
-0.19671466946601868,
0.1490938663482666,
0.8089436888694763,
0.2684580683708191,
0.4938821792602539,
-0.514198362827301,
-0.006649430841207504,
0.20947307348251343,
-0.5010166764259338,
-0.15419447422027588,
-0.16411064565181732,
0.2472342997789383,
-0.3374359607696533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06708v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06708v5
|
LangCell: Language-Cell Pre-training for Cell Identity Understanding
| 2024-05-09T10:04:05 | 2024-06-11T07:31:13 |
Suyuan Zhao, Jiahuan Zhang, Yushuai Wu, Yizhen Luo, Zaiqing Nie
|
q-bio.GN
|
q-bio.GN, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Cell identity encompasses various semantic aspects of a cell, including cell
type, pathway information, disease information, and more, which are essential
for biologists to gain insights into its biological characteristics.
Understanding cell identity from the transcriptomic data, such as annotating
cell types, has become an important task in bioinformatics. As these semantic
aspects are determined by human experts, it is impossible for AI models to
effectively carry out cell identity understanding tasks without the supervision
signals provided by single-cell and label pairs. The single-cell pre-trained
language models (PLMs) currently used for this task are trained only on a
single modality, transcriptomics data, lack an understanding of cell identity
knowledge. As a result, they have to be fine-tuned for downstream tasks and
struggle when lacking labeled data with the desired semantic labels. To address
this issue, we propose an innovative solution by constructing a unified
representation of single-cell data and natural language during the pre-training
phase, allowing the model to directly incorporate insights related to cell
identity. More specifically, we introduce $\textbf{LangCell}$, the first
$\textbf{Lang}$uage-$\textbf{Cell}$ pre-training framework. LangCell utilizes
texts enriched with cell identity information to gain a profound comprehension
of cross-modal knowledge. Results from experiments conducted on different
benchmarks show that LangCell is the only single-cell PLM that can work
effectively in zero-shot cell identity understanding scenarios, and also
significantly outperforms existing models in few-shot and fine-tuning cell
identity understanding scenarios.
|
[
-0.2607158422470093,
-0.5755907297134399,
0.2965922951698303,
0.18692263960838318,
-0.4572407901287079,
0.5319172143936157,
-0.19773676991462708,
-0.27267345786094666,
0.0238820668309927,
0.6295461654663086,
-0.6774385571479797,
-1.0272176265716553,
-0.23306594789028168,
0.07550275325775146,
-0.5111046433448792,
1.3698683977127075,
0.11071708798408508,
0.2994350790977478,
-0.49414128065109253,
-0.5026460289955139,
0.05725026875734329,
-0.5209618806838989,
-0.33098313212394714,
-0.43450644612312317,
0.8534167408943176,
0.46031200885772705,
0.4405980110168457,
0.561150312423706,
0.12277219444513321,
0.24250319600105286,
-0.10709826648235321,
-0.022602714598178864,
-0.3999042510986328,
-0.2176869958639145,
-0.06544887274503708,
-0.4615391492843628,
-0.45242345333099365,
0.012690035626292229,
0.6450567245483398,
1.0947389602661133,
0.010530093684792519,
0.39805373549461365,
0.09939415752887726,
0.7096547484397888,
-0.3204819858074188,
0.1513804942369461,
-0.9182770848274231,
0.44970348477363586,
-0.2928353250026703,
0.1356571763753891,
-0.5936033129692078,
-0.25635433197021484,
0.013295005075633526,
-0.5639399886131287,
0.2573687434196472,
-0.3729757070541382,
0.7733970880508423,
0.16290351748466492,
-0.39485517144203186,
-0.07431171834468842,
-0.44267234206199646,
0.4531715214252472,
-0.5946845412254333,
0.0786750540137291,
0.06976548582315445,
0.21793438494205475,
0.09589774906635284,
-0.6724154353141785,
-0.3717454671859741,
-0.45183128118515015,
-0.48711857199668884,
0.4791504442691803,
0.32234126329421997,
0.4455915689468384,
0.06806349009275436,
0.022401636466383934,
-0.5455076694488525,
0.13075555860996246,
-0.34869056940078735,
-0.5365905165672302,
0.6183323264122009,
-0.05488443374633789,
0.650057315826416,
0.058165065944194794,
-0.4717867970466614,
0.10999460518360138,
-0.6237127780914307,
0.2624850571155548,
0.26714828610420227,
0.421896368265152,
-0.1270540952682495,
0.2340661585330963,
-0.0290792528539896,
0.7816001176834106,
-0.2673586308956146,
0.08875574916601181,
0.2355935424566269,
-0.458938866853714,
-0.24211540818214417,
0.6242200136184692,
0.7915499210357666,
-0.5053068995475769,
0.18532508611679077,
-0.3843950927257538,
0.18851609528064728,
-0.10329139977693558,
0.28354254364967346,
-0.9245784282684326,
-0.10278259217739105,
0.2335890233516693,
-0.5616257190704346,
-0.2878470718860626,
0.30523398518562317,
-0.8509952425956726,
-0.1354384869337082,
-0.3914182782173157,
0.4752938151359558,
-0.4680774509906769,
-0.19332784414291382,
0.05174373835325241,
0.3740076422691345,
0.30455875396728516,
0.2638154923915863,
-0.8066045641899109,
0.28698933124542236,
0.30027714371681213,
0.663145124912262,
-0.22505028545856476,
-0.5174969434738159,
-0.5804606676101685,
0.19140858948230743,
-0.17618322372436523,
0.6422926187515259,
-0.41313648223876953,
-0.6307840347290039,
-0.09097819775342941,
-0.05025193467736244,
-0.17840303480625153,
-0.3018183410167694,
0.4295283555984497,
-0.30486738681793213,
-0.13148395717144012,
-0.24559031426906586,
-0.48055198788642883,
0.10770469158887863,
-0.2943541407585144,
-0.4940149784088135,
0.5578166246414185,
0.021671442314982414,
-0.6829554438591003,
0.4721786379814148,
-1.129286289215088,
-0.4912355840206146,
0.4311544597148895,
-0.4801570773124695,
-0.6848531365394592,
0.05376275256276131,
0.1395026445388794,
0.36557304859161377,
0.10971146821975708,
0.19654618203639984,
-0.14932017028331757,
0.09508815407752991,
0.4559362828731537,
-0.006055276375263929,
0.7604454755783081,
0.34422749280929565,
-0.042809367179870605,
0.47746485471725464,
-0.6849668622016907,
0.415679007768631,
-0.05471453443169594,
-0.11612498015165329,
-0.008642672561109066,
-0.007628194987773895,
-0.1246860921382904,
-0.07081973552703857,
0.37770283222198486,
-0.7977518439292908,
0.34681397676467896,
-0.40048620104789734,
0.17338086664676666,
0.5159376859664917,
-0.3004915416240692,
0.5551031827926636,
-0.005083070136606693,
0.18265685439109802,
0.33857035636901855,
0.2298825979232788,
-0.4203505218029022,
-0.44140470027923584,
-0.5647482872009277,
-0.17283092439174652,
0.31692415475845337,
0.4126494526863098,
-0.46323561668395996,
0.26509928703308105,
-0.1541503518819809,
-0.5248798131942749,
-0.7497838735580444,
0.42223474383354187,
0.6475316882133484,
0.4925997853279114,
0.7301350831985474,
-0.0982186570763588,
-0.6236064434051514,
-1.0493645668029785,
-0.2885980010032654,
-0.019509805366396904,
0.0870947539806366,
0.14600114524364471,
0.43739649653434753,
-0.20256522297859192,
1.4880261421203613,
-0.31071510910987854,
-0.2951892912387848,
-0.6300904154777527,
0.7488542795181274,
0.12681478261947632,
0.564664363861084,
0.3244335651397705,
-0.9291730523109436,
-0.5092161893844604,
0.39869555830955505,
-0.5868804454803467,
-0.48635634779930115,
-0.1827983409166336,
0.04080364108085632,
0.0958363488316536,
0.435373455286026,
-0.35735875368118286,
0.6561144590377808,
0.47408950328826904,
-0.33469313383102417,
0.5581859350204468,
-0.5028428435325623,
-0.09150739014148712,
-0.9010685682296753,
0.2501872777938843,
-0.22875607013702393,
-0.041561346501111984,
-1.0643409490585327,
-0.40341097116470337,
0.3247663080692291,
-0.29116198420524597,
-0.512639582157135,
0.5214087963104248,
-0.38042813539505005,
-0.3803803324699402,
-0.15006190538406372,
-0.3319109380245209,
-0.12991593778133392,
0.44611838459968567,
0.13045229017734528,
0.8908684253692627,
0.478908509016037,
-0.4843403100967407,
-0.189265176653862,
0.38932231068611145,
-0.3379373848438263,
-0.013740014284849167,
-0.5710753798484802,
0.2460429072380066,
-0.44252094626426697,
0.19795916974544525,
-0.7779290676116943,
-0.11764546483755112,
0.007645460311323404,
-0.4155028760433197,
0.20331783592700958,
-0.10676125437021255,
-0.259077250957489,
-0.43758559226989746,
0.2039746344089508,
0.6894943118095398,
0.5179036259651184,
-0.5882937908172607,
0.706264317035675,
0.32772159576416016,
-0.08124452084302902,
-0.6146044135093689,
-0.6514183282852173,
-0.0073785120621323586,
0.15505248308181763,
-0.34857404232025146,
0.8219246864318848,
-0.11679782718420029,
0.09863825142383575,
-0.013913885690271854,
-0.27416089177131653,
-0.43273094296455383,
-0.0733039379119873,
0.3480747938156128,
0.2199668139219284,
-0.22167977690696716,
0.42945384979248047,
0.09661854058504105,
-0.33010274171829224,
-0.1698489487171173,
-0.3299848437309265,
0.4733276665210724,
-0.28576183319091797,
-0.5267022848129272,
-0.43491479754447937,
0.39370590448379517,
0.7508424520492554,
-0.7362161874771118,
0.7485654354095459,
0.7652223706245422,
-0.018391555175185204,
-0.28351378440856934,
-0.2513367235660553,
0.00025952656869776547,
-0.40086108446121216,
0.49896013736724854,
-0.2917538285255432,
-0.6733891367912292,
0.6717294454574585,
-0.039175547659397125,
-0.144829660654068,
0.20506185293197632,
0.4091118276119232,
-0.05008170008659363,
1.0586681365966797,
0.6611431837081909,
-0.14064474403858185,
0.16428488492965698,
0.06895522028207779,
0.23658159375190735,
-0.40669679641723633,
-0.5569205284118652,
-0.5774192214012146,
-0.06131657958030701,
-0.04743298888206482,
-0.42523083090782166,
0.38663220405578613,
0.22225144505500793,
-0.11493031680583954,
0.271883100271225,
-0.5579474568367004,
0.6470403075218201,
0.13271170854568481,
0.25407084822654724,
0.18810729682445526,
-0.24409949779510498,
-0.3527495861053467,
0.166616290807724,
-0.7602116465568542,
-0.6961048245429993,
0.911206066608429,
0.22920967638492584,
0.765135645866394,
-0.15857569873332977,
0.7949103713035583,
0.05651574209332466,
0.8241557478904724,
-0.5788742899894714,
0.6842806935310364,
-0.46348240971565247,
-0.2545572519302368,
-0.10332651436328888,
-0.5355137586593628,
-1.0307340621948242,
0.08971990644931793,
-0.13527099788188934,
-1.1801739931106567,
-0.13561178743839264,
0.19822724163532257,
-0.5988192558288574,
0.4432382881641388,
-0.7560057640075684,
1.3877973556518555,
-0.5938068628311157,
-0.18763838708400726,
0.08545704931020737,
-0.8147971630096436,
0.22329315543174744,
-0.07874327152967453,
0.18181972205638885,
-0.07687803357839584,
-0.008110342547297478,
0.8106651306152344,
-0.5854628682136536,
1.0175215005874634,
-0.20495061576366425,
0.014798193238675594,
0.4252253770828247,
-0.15035952627658844,
0.1073673665523529,
0.3686310648918152,
0.04900273308157921,
0.15344057977199554,
0.22536882758140564,
-0.6009200215339661,
-0.29632505774497986,
0.40393659472465515,
-0.930887758731842,
-0.37922394275665283,
0.17004048824310303,
-0.47699734568595886,
-0.19359274208545685,
0.05809606611728668,
0.48071399331092834,
0.562341570854187,
-0.29623597860336304,
0.25011658668518066,
0.8861256241798401,
-0.5644646883010864,
0.5372928380966187,
0.5547136068344116,
-0.5480986833572388,
-0.040885135531425476,
0.863749086856842,
-0.12053234875202179,
0.39516428112983704,
0.4615999162197113,
0.16168677806854248,
-0.36622217297554016,
-0.5776931047439575,
-0.4564802944660187,
-0.12141843140125275,
-0.4383999705314636,
-0.22293908894062042,
-0.9222642779350281,
-0.6436362862586975,
-0.2053438425064087,
-0.07942397892475128,
-0.5448502898216248,
0.16939795017242432,
-0.3919886350631714,
-0.008467145264148712,
0.12319569289684296,
0.577686071395874,
-0.028233777731657028,
0.2286108434200287,
-1.0934252738952637,
0.4320876896381378,
0.6494887471199036,
0.2291642725467682,
-0.3506305515766144,
-0.2868329882621765,
-0.25216713547706604,
0.27201327681541443,
0.16032664477825165,
-1.2710044384002686,
0.295497328042984,
0.4153469502925873,
0.7521395683288574,
0.2915695905685425,
-0.4603463113307953,
0.4279000163078308,
-0.3241136074066162,
0.5683909058570862,
0.2538042664527893,
-1.1381891965866089,
0.7255479097366333,
-0.22409415245056152,
0.635566234588623,
0.7659000754356384,
0.17049776017665863,
-0.36808592081069946,
-0.19019953906536102,
-0.37862327694892883,
-0.5463065505027771,
0.7169539332389832,
0.36334705352783203,
0.012268534861505032,
0.19591553509235382,
0.3490280210971832,
0.5055726766586304,
0.13566990196704865,
-1.0094242095947266,
-0.38533496856689453,
-0.6327158808708191,
-0.46416568756103516,
-0.0070966859348118305,
0.01563410833477974,
-0.03791205957531929,
-0.5721851587295532,
0.2704705595970154,
-0.36614421010017395,
0.20988959074020386,
0.37483617663383484,
-0.46499910950660706,
0.16946585476398468,
0.5418993234634399,
0.5749707818031311,
0.46381229162216187,
-0.3117348551750183,
0.14499936997890472,
0.3820400834083557,
-0.44828081130981445,
0.31405898928642273,
0.0858343243598938,
-0.07849840819835663,
0.0577896349132061,
0.23368023335933685,
0.6374800205230713,
0.09210828691720963,
-0.6835883855819702,
0.4554058611392975,
0.1511419117450714,
-0.24660272896289825,
-0.03563011437654495,
0.062239788472652435,
0.10379131138324738,
-0.39501485228538513,
0.5758878588676453,
0.13344673812389374,
-0.24800466001033783,
-0.7008064389228821,
0.6246876120567322,
0.4727752208709717,
-0.6009377837181091,
-0.4182055592536926,
0.5398754477500916,
0.1838170886039734,
-0.26940664649009705,
0.10900074988603592,
-0.4932171702384949,
-0.7499643564224243,
1.2022279500961304,
0.6373393535614014,
0.8098875880241394,
-0.3515196442604065,
0.7010699510574341,
0.3293139636516571,
0.099309541285038,
0.27647480368614197,
-0.14215514063835144,
-0.09756115078926086,
-1.0667338371276855,
-0.47658029198646545,
-0.9098897576332092,
-0.13743065297603607,
0.15569902956485748,
-0.5691452026367188,
0.04879407584667206,
-0.47440198063850403,
0.23228394985198975,
0.2603208124637604,
-0.17008648812770844,
-0.792380154132843,
0.13129521906375885,
0.41645073890686035,
0.7964468598365784,
-0.864203155040741,
1.4093660116195679,
0.7707096934318542,
-0.4501272439956665,
-0.7375504374504089,
-0.241948202252388,
-0.0802062600851059,
-0.6957882046699524,
1.186989665031433,
0.5294337272644043,
-0.22671572864055634,
0.3350754976272583,
-0.5059762597084045,
-0.6227678656578064,
1.0097044706344604,
0.16047783195972443,
-0.45956236124038696,
0.35583382844924927,
0.48672330379486084,
0.5389220118522644,
-0.9201453328132629,
0.1943741887807846,
0.5450608134269714,
0.5745826363563538,
0.00884268619120121,
-0.6429759860038757,
-0.21284864842891693,
-0.09469389915466309,
-0.22466546297073364,
0.28230178356170654,
-0.38728460669517517,
0.9103499054908752,
-0.40094494819641113,
-0.5060858130455017,
0.33175039291381836,
0.5680227279663086,
-0.2715948820114136,
0.31718072295188904,
0.390744686126709,
0.5129410624504089,
0.69781494140625,
-0.17994777858257294,
0.6620681881904602,
-0.2218891978263855,
0.32993873953819275,
1.2279225587844849,
-0.4109955132007599,
0.309283971786499,
0.22289928793907166,
-0.23431341350078583,
0.5274243950843811,
0.2955671548843384,
0.15620630979537964,
0.383831650018692,
0.33861738443374634,
-0.6548174619674683,
-0.34196051955223083,
-0.24954774975776672,
-0.4510032832622528,
0.5715507864952087,
0.5301214456558228,
-0.14010603725910187,
-0.4992951452732086,
0.16387970745563507,
-0.31927523016929626,
0.300496369600296,
-0.5880008339881897,
0.939601480960846,
-0.21807843446731567,
-0.28773316740989685,
0.054828744381666183,
-0.3516654074192047,
0.36294829845428467,
-0.9950170516967773,
0.18237225711345673,
-0.38666194677352905,
-0.21340644359588623,
-0.24610622227191925,
-0.6572340130805969,
0.143998920917511,
-0.18676291406154633,
-0.03742416575551033,
-0.4263322353363037,
0.7440493106842041,
-0.7852562665939331,
-0.5730292201042175,
0.40544164180755615,
0.6951200366020203,
-0.19100375473499298,
0.07448683679103851,
-0.862568736076355,
-0.1483701914548874,
0.17778919637203217,
0.07304469496011734,
0.3358040452003479,
0.19518887996673584,
0.351045697927475,
0.583145022392273,
0.5469651222229004,
0.015676379203796387,
-0.14730031788349152,
0.357056200504303,
0.8088713884353638,
-0.7989315986633301,
-0.17552629113197327,
-1.0873582363128662,
0.5825095176696777,
-0.4790417551994324,
-0.22136154770851135,
0.24062716960906982,
0.6711792945861816,
0.5395684242248535,
-0.14600718021392822,
0.8058210015296936,
0.10171294212341309,
0.35003602504730225,
-0.7552255988121033,
1.008824348449707,
-0.32062190771102905,
0.2050209790468216,
-0.04343142360448837,
-0.6107601523399353,
-0.4438193142414093,
0.4763692319393158,
-0.24625670909881592,
-0.07306934893131256,
0.8630834817886353,
1.0573598146438599,
-0.05315592139959335,
0.12668217718601227,
0.4775078296661377,
0.3557741641998291,
0.15475906431674957,
0.7415094971656799,
0.8985939621925354,
0.014152869582176208,
0.6073325276374817,
-0.08420880883932114,
-0.14432179927825928,
0.03354940935969353,
-0.8660863637924194,
-1.1061506271362305,
-0.7152280211448669,
-0.2173825055360794,
0.08361939340829849,
0.06662403047084808,
0.936400294303894,
0.977330207824707,
-0.9528416991233826,
-0.27061501145362854,
-0.4790508449077606,
0.08689765632152557,
0.14615552127361298,
-0.17761792242527008,
0.27693724632263184,
-0.908517062664032,
-0.2327726036310196,
0.44906559586524963,
0.8535686135292053,
0.38021478056907654,
-0.06345783919095993,
0.005796678364276886,
-0.1209777370095253,
-0.03342205658555031,
0.47136905789375305,
0.6408597826957703,
-0.6574135422706604,
-0.25162628293037415,
-0.3261469900608063,
-0.37077945470809937,
0.3209916055202484,
1.1171236038208008,
-0.9485018253326416,
0.4721594750881195,
0.0199328251183033,
0.857235312461853,
0.39916619658470154,
0.16488906741142273,
0.5405257344245911,
-0.7039833664894104,
0.3922857642173767,
0.3875792622566223,
0.3306617736816406,
0.18221546709537506,
-0.37124672532081604,
0.2628069221973419,
0.004796310793608427,
-0.4056144058704376,
-0.32358092069625854,
0.5735908150672913,
-1.2216261625289917,
-0.5301575660705566,
0.7465510964393616,
-0.2052333652973175,
-0.38548341393470764,
-0.24107688665390015,
-0.5237120985984802,
0.31434130668640137,
-0.265193372964859,
0.6771963834762573,
0.2965480089187622,
0.01489999145269394,
-0.1020621508359909,
-0.3763647675514221,
0.8455951809883118,
0.8021695017814636,
-1.4460417032241821,
0.025321612134575844,
0.007315953727811575,
-0.11186181753873825,
0.0951281487941742,
0.5839669704437256,
-0.23577964305877686,
0.09637250006198883,
-0.2839219570159912,
0.19025979936122894,
-0.02990710735321045,
-0.3938598334789276,
0.015505602583289146,
0.3225911557674408,
-0.1502993404865265,
-0.17130470275878906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06707v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06707v1
|
Hypothesis Testing Prompting Improves Deductive Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-09T08:46:17 | 2024-05-09T08:46:17 |
Yitian Li, Jidong Tian, Hao He, Yaohui Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Combining different forms of prompts with pre-trained large language models
has yielded remarkable results on reasoning tasks (e.g. Chain-of-Thought
prompting). However, along with testing on more complex reasoning, these
methods also expose problems such as invalid reasoning and fictional reasoning
paths. In this paper, we develop \textit{Hypothesis Testing Prompting}, which
adds conclusion assumptions, backward reasoning, and fact verification during
intermediate reasoning steps. \textit{Hypothesis Testing prompting} involves
multiple assumptions and reverses validation of conclusions leading to its
unique correct answer. Experiments on two challenging deductive reasoning
datasets ProofWriter and RuleTaker show that hypothesis testing prompting not
only significantly improves the effect, but also generates a more reasonable
and standardized reasoning process.
|
[
-0.3672654330730438,
-1.1232795715332031,
1.0436394214630127,
0.16328705847263336,
0.05384271219372749,
-0.23675338923931122,
-0.2577176094055176,
-0.1235828772187233,
-0.18884922564029694,
0.24893216788768768,
-0.6579722762107849,
-0.10995801538228989,
-0.27943119406700134,
0.38160422444343567,
-0.3401554226875305,
0.6562801003456116,
-0.14521068334579468,
0.11595426499843597,
-0.3687756061553955,
0.2265971153974533,
-0.7320008873939514,
-0.15726777911186218,
-0.8455275893211365,
-0.46320778131484985,
0.6804535388946533,
0.7659258842468262,
0.5557608604431152,
0.21984107792377472,
0.29834306240081787,
0.20950409770011902,
0.25110289454460144,
0.0489613339304924,
-0.17067819833755493,
0.5085824131965637,
-0.19543196260929108,
-0.8638937473297119,
-0.15438689291477203,
0.08168508112430573,
0.5933006405830383,
0.6724647879600525,
0.010835600085556507,
0.06752762943506241,
-0.07693995535373688,
0.5498061180114746,
-0.5981981158256531,
-0.01643497310578823,
-0.44524189829826355,
-0.4911951720714569,
0.08504105359315872,
-0.42278170585632324,
-0.6695099472999573,
-0.8025120496749878,
0.12220742553472519,
-0.4974364638328552,
0.4268471896648407,
0.18401728570461273,
0.7506197094917297,
0.3746560215950012,
-0.3729505240917206,
-0.11160632967948914,
-0.7454106211662292,
0.5108365416526794,
-0.5506594777107239,
0.6456069946289062,
0.48559534549713135,
0.3475957214832306,
-0.3543817102909088,
-0.5216205716133118,
-0.9374130964279175,
-0.5998684167861938,
-0.001982621382921934,
0.17695264518260956,
0.025486541911959648,
0.052140917629003525,
0.8908333778381348,
0.07266610115766525,
-0.62442946434021,
-0.13632901012897491,
-0.2501949071884155,
-0.039039745926856995,
0.41994500160217285,
0.024694321677088737,
0.2254374474287033,
0.27129557728767395,
0.10910560935735703,
-0.40061941742897034,
-1.157375693321228,
0.2608794569969177,
0.33155736327171326,
0.2114710658788681,
0.4024069607257843,
0.37927526235580444,
-0.42919349670410156,
0.9525228142738342,
0.25151222944259644,
-0.03436502441763878,
-0.030052540823817253,
-0.3301070034503937,
-0.07794824987649918,
0.26131558418273926,
0.17553164064884186,
0.5099169611930847,
0.4838867783546448,
0.2905925512313843,
0.05572323501110077,
0.4936683475971222,
-0.2430168092250824,
-0.9408705234527588,
-0.5205920338630676,
0.4265020191669464,
-0.32081490755081177,
-0.08490338176488876,
0.03955866023898125,
-0.4339194893836975,
-0.5832892656326294,
-0.5789718627929688,
0.559659481048584,
-0.5958520174026489,
-0.24445044994354248,
0.5207407474517822,
-0.7308998107910156,
0.24611589312553406,
0.5335028171539307,
-0.7530176043510437,
0.00537117151543498,
0.49618256092071533,
0.22436738014221191,
0.31390488147735596,
-0.5008305907249451,
-0.7900482416152954,
-0.04607267305254936,
-0.5642979145050049,
1.1902823448181152,
-0.6448218822479248,
-0.09584533423185349,
-0.1642291396856308,
-0.00660195155069232,
-0.03659197315573692,
-0.42649129033088684,
0.585617184638977,
-0.4743530750274658,
0.34157004952430725,
-0.948854923248291,
-0.5097768902778625,
-0.2400795966386795,
0.5857219099998474,
-0.4576539993286133,
1.0647205114364624,
-0.27396777272224426,
-0.7577601075172424,
0.7152665257453918,
-0.5619315505027771,
-0.5537734627723694,
-0.22653411328792572,
-0.1593296229839325,
0.0006748177693225443,
0.018930085003376007,
0.4253520965576172,
0.3825702369213104,
-0.6009129285812378,
0.24924305081367493,
-0.3020627796649933,
-0.3647516071796417,
0.45159777998924255,
-0.30130597949028015,
0.8063047528266907,
-0.08113913983106613,
-0.5058315992355347,
0.19277317821979523,
-0.5425328612327576,
0.03581232950091362,
0.1755126714706421,
-0.03058692440390587,
-0.5447017550468445,
0.05947592109441757,
-0.6382981538772583,
0.13016776740550995,
-0.3306846618652344,
-0.6202532052993774,
0.45125988125801086,
-0.11559959501028061,
0.1268656849861145,
0.5013214349746704,
0.2994081377983093,
0.15751026570796967,
-0.532349169254303,
0.43823865056037903,
-0.08233631402254105,
-0.05004334822297096,
-0.3978208005428314,
-0.787214457988739,
-0.7860628962516785,
-0.09085096418857574,
0.3302975594997406,
0.6887760758399963,
-0.4704226851463318,
0.41326284408569336,
0.12649956345558167,
-0.3883284628391266,
-0.33409494161605835,
-0.18334649503231049,
0.15541863441467285,
0.8582800030708313,
0.3518298864364624,
0.46122488379478455,
-0.6729373931884766,
-0.565479576587677,
-0.25774094462394714,
-0.4546373784542084,
-0.13422530889511108,
-0.3248681128025055,
0.6992442607879639,
-0.019976284354925156,
0.906339704990387,
-0.7374590635299683,
0.3110881447792053,
-0.2754761576652527,
0.20248408615589142,
0.27816659212112427,
0.33026987314224243,
0.2677196264266968,
-0.7928874492645264,
-0.38330787420272827,
-0.47306376695632935,
-0.37939515709877014,
-0.3324257731437683,
-0.24815109372138977,
-0.0012557492591440678,
0.011465747840702534,
0.5965695977210999,
-0.6509583592414856,
0.5091674327850342,
0.07904163002967834,
-0.42287564277648926,
1.155184030532837,
-0.16476865112781525,
0.5641133785247803,
-0.6642742156982422,
-0.022448936477303505,
-0.24407096207141876,
0.07892952114343643,
-0.2819364070892334,
-0.15910398960113525,
0.22139878571033478,
0.0394609235227108,
0.10747479647397995,
0.4408529996871948,
-0.2572045624256134,
0.42739927768707275,
-0.3823965787887573,
-0.0034980466589331627,
0.33795514702796936,
-0.1746068000793457,
0.26287519931793213,
0.7853550910949707,
0.7895271182060242,
-0.9834333658218384,
0.46832847595214844,
0.1815003901720047,
-0.1883222907781601,
0.5732014179229736,
-0.6989020109176636,
-0.010421459563076496,
-0.3789353370666504,
0.5397917628288269,
-1.5011957883834839,
-0.381991446018219,
0.011562548577785492,
-0.3767373561859131,
-0.21302878856658936,
0.22016534209251404,
-0.6632639765739441,
-0.6852987408638,
-0.38294297456741333,
0.11989782005548477,
0.7269701361656189,
-0.6846302151679993,
0.4010365307331085,
-0.40233853459358215,
-0.09394211322069168,
-0.44887402653694153,
-0.4524189233779907,
-0.1322498917579651,
-0.30180981755256653,
-0.5286470055580139,
0.17754654586315155,
-0.28015998005867004,
-0.5921429991722107,
-0.1698634922504425,
-0.050819892436265945,
0.1482141613960266,
0.1703730672597885,
-0.014125446788966656,
0.3230459690093994,
-0.16702024638652802,
0.4956752359867096,
0.3492923974990845,
-0.16710735857486725,
0.4757222831249237,
-0.3595983386039734,
0.4383546710014343,
0.041256535798311234,
-0.40172961354255676,
-0.5071114301681519,
0.28386837244033813,
0.2090163677930832,
-0.21631090342998505,
0.4633839428424835,
0.2813112139701843,
-0.45065921545028687,
-0.350032240152359,
-0.7459976077079773,
-0.946025013923645,
-0.4034443795681,
-0.07318730652332306,
-0.730826735496521,
-0.6619042754173279,
0.42621150612831116,
-0.31541451811790466,
-0.15817855298519135,
0.36866235733032227,
0.42639729380607605,
-0.0011373729212209582,
1.2308504581451416,
0.2704123258590698,
0.4395548403263092,
0.07710278034210205,
-0.01980997808277607,
0.39302417635917664,
-0.6269998550415039,
-0.04562029987573624,
-0.7596469521522522,
0.23245969414710999,
-0.2415815144777298,
-0.26708680391311646,
0.13153143227100372,
0.3626256585121155,
-0.17181730270385742,
0.16377782821655273,
-0.375342458486557,
0.8685477375984192,
0.5424292087554932,
0.1579103022813797,
0.4162583351135254,
-0.2434917539358139,
-0.3433632254600525,
-0.08732688426971436,
-0.4697108268737793,
-0.3779936730861664,
0.8110049962997437,
0.10490155965089798,
0.6829804182052612,
-0.029401201754808426,
0.6466997265815735,
-0.044009730219841,
0.29494842886924744,
-0.8868681192398071,
0.5401740074157715,
0.4305271506309509,
-0.908312976360321,
-0.38058480620384216,
-0.14255359768867493,
-0.7202054262161255,
-0.08310360461473465,
-0.1363305300474167,
-0.6066725254058838,
0.24672900140285492,
0.40731000900268555,
-0.7873814702033997,
-0.11462635546922684,
-0.7512739896774292,
0.6489052176475525,
0.046581100672483444,
-0.1844901293516159,
-0.2836053669452667,
-0.4564741253852844,
0.2751214802265167,
0.09139475226402283,
-0.12498520314693451,
0.009222080931067467,
0.38893255591392517,
0.6837109327316284,
-0.13486739993095398,
0.7388511896133423,
-0.35270997881889343,
-0.21223194897174835,
0.5092596411705017,
0.4220440089702606,
0.7284285426139832,
0.25087329745292664,
-0.01041441224515438,
-0.4936387538909912,
-0.1673620641231537,
-0.22775553166866302,
-0.9828801155090332,
0.5100342035293579,
0.03983422368764877,
-1.1140704154968262,
-0.2514316439628601,
-0.49474403262138367,
-0.4155634939670563,
0.23415115475654602,
0.3070588707923889,
0.2539474666118622,
-0.006203293800354004,
-0.03897647559642792,
1.0887290239334106,
-0.09759517759084702,
-0.012941300868988037,
0.4430379271507263,
-0.3637697696685791,
-0.07363414764404297,
0.39186474680900574,
0.00462381774559617,
0.38594087958335876,
0.23121823370456696,
0.7509550452232361,
-0.6416447758674622,
-0.4193071722984314,
-0.3205937147140503,
0.16911061108112335,
-0.8759223818778992,
-0.0726553350687027,
-0.5397395491600037,
0.19699230790138245,
-0.9039927124977112,
-0.07646006345748901,
0.1003342717885971,
-0.5650489330291748,
0.37625473737716675,
-0.43400824069976807,
0.580715000629425,
0.5216188430786133,
-0.23732468485832214,
-0.08680672198534012,
-0.5233968496322632,
0.37914416193962097,
0.7974977493286133,
-0.041849829256534576,
0.18385043740272522,
-0.4178786277770996,
0.29397332668304443,
-0.12931141257286072,
-0.15863528847694397,
-0.9272552728652954,
-0.21143928170204163,
-0.11403723061084747,
0.34947261214256287,
0.5455322861671448,
0.2196807861328125,
0.7592766880989075,
-0.5990943908691406,
0.6441665887832642,
0.10300074517726898,
-0.8783649802207947,
0.9473684430122375,
-0.48490992188453674,
0.3512577712535858,
0.5076860189437866,
0.5876134634017944,
-0.4632894694805145,
-0.2768517732620239,
-0.43583250045776367,
-0.38236066699028015,
0.24896050989627838,
0.037489164620637894,
-0.12424877285957336,
-0.3159477412700653,
0.3197740912437439,
0.2869902551174164,
-0.2549983859062195,
-0.18604817986488342,
-0.1355842500925064,
-0.07425440847873688,
-0.0643082708120346,
0.13641227781772614,
-0.3233926594257355,
-0.2752462327480316,
-0.6477150917053223,
0.6929762363433838,
-0.15514814853668213,
0.15991978347301483,
0.7228383421897888,
0.17531290650367737,
-0.07791879028081894,
0.41649478673934937,
0.5723040699958801,
0.8760255575180054,
-0.29151153564453125,
0.32795462012290955,
0.3075331449508667,
-0.13455723226070404,
0.4271254241466522,
0.31609824299812317,
-0.28471872210502625,
-0.20778848230838776,
0.43040233850479126,
0.4262114465236664,
-0.4518260061740875,
-0.6562430262565613,
0.2690403461456299,
-0.09696817398071289,
-0.3748225271701813,
-0.2300061583518982,
0.4203159809112549,
0.14421890676021576,
0.18490061163902283,
0.6573513150215149,
0.016188934445381165,
0.44541552662849426,
-0.5505257248878479,
0.332922101020813,
0.10365696251392365,
-0.11337509006261826,
-0.2114008367061615,
0.6925484538078308,
0.01994907855987549,
-0.08544814586639404,
0.6661539077758789,
-0.280167818069458,
-0.8242602944374084,
0.5942442417144775,
0.9646009206771851,
0.5342960357666016,
-0.4180421233177185,
0.4125232696533203,
0.73731529712677,
0.3756219148635864,
-0.4564448893070221,
0.679905116558075,
-0.1439811885356903,
-0.7428300976753235,
-0.8464779853820801,
0.011000427417457104,
-0.4380946159362793,
0.045260537415742874,
-0.35674160718917847,
0.2781619429588318,
-0.206926628947258,
-0.09720385819673538,
0.17682351171970367,
-0.14373555779457092,
-0.4580225646495819,
0.35877034068107605,
0.10643687099218369,
1.2624386548995972,
-1.017088532447815,
0.6786951422691345,
0.6819552779197693,
-0.27186155319213867,
-0.948411226272583,
0.2949230670928955,
-0.01220723893493414,
-0.35513612627983093,
0.9111039638519287,
0.4879942536354065,
-0.2486400008201599,
0.014516986906528473,
-0.723240852355957,
-0.7259204983711243,
0.6165071725845337,
0.3631569445133209,
-0.4429727792739868,
0.29219329357147217,
-0.13996070623397827,
0.3194992244243622,
-0.19672062993049622,
0.402285635471344,
0.6257343888282776,
0.8752558827400208,
0.06748174875974655,
-0.5587356686592102,
0.808769941329956,
-0.11235684156417847,
-0.26642173528671265,
0.20652490854263306,
-0.036810390651226044,
0.8443151116371155,
-0.759713351726532,
-0.03200850635766983,
-0.05307701602578163,
0.6489773392677307,
0.9178717136383057,
0.3432820439338684,
0.9154838919639587,
0.5024403929710388,
1.2096006870269775,
-0.30439651012420654,
1.1731892824172974,
0.13484102487564087,
-0.12109687179327011,
1.0997434854507446,
-0.6709558367729187,
0.6011971831321716,
0.5396448969841003,
-0.019933272153139114,
0.9932019114494324,
0.8019866943359375,
0.15039582550525665,
0.45883262157440186,
0.28480783104896545,
-0.04401977360248566,
-0.6366279125213623,
-0.2863786518573761,
-0.5268202424049377,
0.09620721638202667,
0.3344239592552185,
0.020120885223150253,
-0.11983145773410797,
0.12647105753421783,
0.14205704629421234,
0.08502513915300369,
0.023109713569283485,
0.21214079856872559,
-0.13248968124389648,
-1.1960203647613525,
0.5864093899726868,
-0.4381932020187378,
0.2390938699245453,
-0.45168280601501465,
-0.49353817105293274,
-0.13556678593158722,
0.26638463139533997,
-0.11393105238676071,
-0.8767780661582947,
0.0972818061709404,
-0.2954283654689789,
-0.17454366385936737,
-0.07832647114992142,
0.8940829038619995,
-0.3492644429206848,
-0.10986506938934326,
0.17447678744792938,
0.33996421098709106,
-0.0730830729007721,
-0.5245620012283325,
-0.49170324206352234,
-0.2057102620601654,
-0.0963248535990715,
-0.4319716989994049,
-0.2973838150501251,
0.5711729526519775,
-0.3215806186199188,
0.4648379385471344,
0.9650667905807495,
-0.0805027186870575,
-0.20591187477111816,
0.41351017355918884,
0.77937251329422,
-0.6225939393043518,
-0.4873248040676117,
-1.003509283065796,
0.5808069109916687,
-0.3339322805404663,
-0.15620030462741852,
1.0576237440109253,
0.3813471794128418,
0.6061534881591797,
-0.23985697329044342,
0.8028351068496704,
-0.2270008623600006,
0.49029842019081116,
-0.6239000558853149,
0.29939135909080505,
-0.22951549291610718,
-0.11858358979225159,
-0.1338547319173813,
-0.7597564458847046,
-0.4704585075378418,
0.4554312825202942,
-0.5646613836288452,
-0.15103425085544586,
1.1684987545013428,
0.7939400672912598,
0.07979492098093033,
0.31575414538383484,
0.09589426219463348,
0.3184642791748047,
0.24995559453964233,
0.31183376908302307,
1.3079769611358643,
-0.3903403580188751,
0.20309850573539734,
-0.17380164563655853,
-0.44996213912963867,
-0.026277882978320122,
-0.9005049467086792,
-1.2409263849258423,
-0.5793352723121643,
-0.4877818822860718,
-0.8208341002464294,
0.021282410249114037,
0.8187944889068604,
0.470389723777771,
-0.9180164933204651,
0.08417396247386932,
-0.43337440490722656,
0.15335683524608612,
-0.6468051671981812,
-0.2700250744819641,
0.4190065264701843,
-0.39280077815055847,
-0.4552557170391083,
0.5879068970680237,
-0.047196052968502045,
0.12779775261878967,
0.004447981249541044,
-0.05846031755208969,
-0.31354236602783203,
0.27642735838890076,
0.34168899059295654,
0.044912729412317276,
-0.5120013952255249,
-0.37916478514671326,
0.3225102424621582,
0.22050122916698456,
-0.203224316239357,
1.0334829092025757,
-0.857370913028717,
0.32573240995407104,
1.075665831565857,
0.3100203275680542,
0.21813571453094482,
0.01539914682507515,
0.7699556946754456,
-0.21340322494506836,
0.2040475308895111,
0.15707649290561676,
0.4023605287075043,
0.1498982310295105,
-0.5577198266983032,
0.4014340043067932,
0.20982176065444946,
-0.4859083294868469,
-1.0028002262115479,
0.5574869513511658,
-0.5664414167404175,
-0.4423030912876129,
1.0242893695831299,
-0.0407041572034359,
-0.2164115160703659,
-0.18650250136852264,
-0.4433274269104004,
0.19494904577732086,
-0.3766033947467804,
0.9070583581924438,
0.9327356219291687,
-0.32162708044052124,
-0.08411022275686264,
-0.3808979094028473,
0.6533637046813965,
0.752556562423706,
-0.8347605466842651,
0.2659114599227905,
0.33406302332878113,
0.24499967694282532,
0.1827811598777771,
0.5786858797073364,
0.17476291954517365,
0.6505303382873535,
0.0016426071524620056,
-0.19817599654197693,
0.0026706503704190254,
-0.606965959072113,
-0.08849570900201797,
-0.30448901653289795,
0.15306468307971954,
0.0018484758911654353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05618v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05618v1
|
An Automatic Prompt Generation System for Tabular Data Tasks
| 2024-05-09T08:32:55 | 2024-05-09T08:32:55 |
Ashlesha Akella, Abhijit Manatkar, Brij Chavda, Hima Patel
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Efficient processing of tabular data is important in various industries,
especially when working with datasets containing a large number of columns.
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated their ability on several tasks
through carefully crafted prompts. However, creating effective prompts for
tabular datasets is challenging due to the structured nature of the data and
the need to manage numerous columns. This paper presents an innovative
auto-prompt generation system suitable for multiple LLMs, with minimal
training. It proposes two novel methods; 1) A Reinforcement Learning-based
algorithm for identifying and sequencing task-relevant columns 2) Cell-level
similarity-based approach for enhancing few-shot example selection. Our
approach has been extensively tested across 66 datasets, demonstrating improved
performance in three downstream tasks: data imputation, error detection, and
entity matching using two distinct LLMs; Google flan-t5-xxl and Mixtral 8x7B.
|
[
-0.30694299936294556,
-0.791788637638092,
0.6141626238822937,
0.37934616208076477,
-0.03928149864077568,
-0.03885718807578087,
-0.037889692932367325,
-0.02987312152981758,
-0.05149935185909271,
0.34077441692352295,
-0.8446712493896484,
-0.7179721593856812,
-0.01905275508761406,
0.5398388504981995,
-0.38543641567230225,
1.1569627523422241,
-0.17764712870121002,
-0.07667119801044464,
-0.04363667219877243,
0.10526521503925323,
-0.955424427986145,
0.01083708181977272,
-0.8244983553886414,
-0.12114059180021286,
0.8148154616355896,
1.0259630680084229,
0.28923824429512024,
0.7432222962379456,
0.31002798676490784,
0.3287217915058136,
0.3681081235408783,
0.4962800145149231,
-0.20570038259029388,
0.6476091742515564,
0.07701472193002701,
-0.40125396847724915,
-0.30600500106811523,
-0.42267724871635437,
0.5592905879020691,
0.30857157707214355,
-0.19207549095153809,
0.21164175868034363,
0.06994250416755676,
0.6333287954330444,
-0.29925575852394104,
0.29718196392059326,
-0.6112095713615417,
0.4231135845184326,
-0.14897559583187103,
-0.14813874661922455,
-0.41475585103034973,
-0.5506501197814941,
-0.1500682234764099,
-0.6604780554771423,
0.04405602440237999,
0.3367197513580322,
0.37303927540779114,
0.1616465300321579,
-0.17991618812084198,
-0.49143579602241516,
-0.2834644615650177,
0.5217339992523193,
-0.608916163444519,
-0.036438196897506714,
-0.0852699726819992,
0.6235787272453308,
-0.5459693670272827,
-0.5444906949996948,
-0.7057258486747742,
-0.46955442428588867,
-0.10675162822008133,
0.032971616834402084,
0.029161961749196053,
-0.12305498868227005,
0.5631681084632874,
-0.25939375162124634,
-0.9716812968254089,
0.28801754117012024,
-0.08553113043308258,
0.10478852689266205,
0.2548598349094391,
0.8200799226760864,
0.22409702837467194,
-0.35574740171432495,
-0.21708278357982635,
-0.05318625643849373,
-0.661439836025238,
0.287447452545166,
0.401629239320755,
0.8321661353111267,
-0.034923531115055084,
0.4218922257423401,
-0.45575854182243347,
1.008984088897705,
0.1688825935125351,
-0.3488447368144989,
0.1872221678495407,
-0.19137200713157654,
-0.3327557146549225,
0.153507798910141,
0.8770153522491455,
0.0883626639842987,
0.0549912303686142,
0.046083513647317886,
-0.35418131947517395,
0.1118493378162384,
0.13977351784706116,
-0.5588259100914001,
-0.23685482144355774,
0.1666308492422104,
-0.2811985909938812,
-0.47948914766311646,
-0.07667358964681625,
-0.9496526122093201,
-0.5429384112358093,
-0.28632092475891113,
0.3402276039123535,
-0.24726620316505432,
0.2515915334224701,
-0.37173449993133545,
0.12468913942575455,
0.01578885316848755,
0.479064017534256,
-0.845897376537323,
0.11164943873882294,
0.4082071781158447,
0.5677916407585144,
-0.5026528239250183,
-0.3391505479812622,
-1.079646348953247,
0.13512937724590302,
-0.5762540698051453,
0.994544506072998,
-0.7655459642410278,
-0.25816500186920166,
0.07262465357780457,
0.0023817552719265223,
0.09257441014051437,
-0.7618959546089172,
0.2714000940322876,
-0.31201064586639404,
0.19216392934322357,
-0.4474366307258606,
-0.2603415548801422,
0.13276618719100952,
0.23998935520648956,
-0.6429927945137024,
1.1825324296951294,
0.22713971138000488,
-0.3559727072715759,
0.8332996368408203,
-0.7031132578849792,
-0.24234995245933533,
0.4447886049747467,
-0.5618260502815247,
-0.5767913460731506,
-0.3526252210140228,
0.30398520827293396,
0.6654762029647827,
-0.2438039779663086,
0.15709295868873596,
-0.1526985764503479,
-0.046018876135349274,
0.08425179868936539,
0.019738279283046722,
0.1842624396085739,
0.3171025812625885,
-0.32946279644966125,
0.36886462569236755,
-0.6451310515403748,
0.11024623364210129,
0.058047931641340256,
-0.4568796157836914,
0.29388248920440674,
-0.32094255089759827,
0.018284473568201065,
0.5433958768844604,
0.05274689570069313,
-0.2803254723548889,
0.5682976841926575,
0.03833325579762459,
0.11489178240299225,
0.3829773962497711,
0.21873626112937927,
0.33872565627098083,
-0.47518017888069153,
0.7896043062210083,
0.41439178586006165,
-0.18433888256549835,
-0.5146957635879517,
-0.20191878080368042,
-0.38273996114730835,
-0.2689345180988312,
0.20046624541282654,
0.9789820909500122,
-1.0982263088226318,
0.43789875507354736,
-0.02142878621816635,
-0.38935619592666626,
-0.06263557821512222,
0.46433398127555847,
0.45998328924179077,
0.6985971927642822,
0.3315574824810028,
-0.01900370605289936,
-0.4894360601902008,
-0.9635762572288513,
-0.023200448602437973,
0.2083073854446411,
0.042685676366090775,
0.3804636597633362,
0.4672805666923523,
0.12680041790008545,
1.0184502601623535,
-0.4576086103916168,
-0.38681280612945557,
-0.6457206606864929,
0.31117215752601624,
0.4650913178920746,
0.5164839625358582,
0.4098094701766968,
-0.4074857831001282,
-0.681602418422699,
-0.03447134047746658,
-0.6328018307685852,
-0.262010782957077,
-0.5381245613098145,
0.014767948538064957,
0.2543281316757202,
0.41915416717529297,
-0.6354517936706543,
0.3039514720439911,
-0.0836254209280014,
-0.17678210139274597,
0.5577003359794617,
-0.17477229237556458,
0.21520574390888214,
-0.9985299110412598,
0.013789370656013489,
0.15835940837860107,
-0.4507468044757843,
-0.6294112205505371,
-0.5176822543144226,
0.05675110965967178,
-0.35931336879730225,
-0.4424732029438019,
0.5446738004684448,
-0.3335322141647339,
-0.3339889943599701,
-0.31578320264816284,
0.20358029007911682,
-0.11789454519748688,
0.6490117311477661,
-0.08520133793354034,
0.7305166721343994,
0.5009443759918213,
-0.8288535475730896,
0.8802034258842468,
0.5792959928512573,
-0.4074785113334656,
0.7104476094245911,
-0.37422651052474976,
-0.26459306478500366,
-0.2844882607460022,
0.5624348521232605,
-1.1103997230529785,
-0.360088974237442,
0.4690973460674286,
-0.3114950358867645,
0.18691283464431763,
0.08363252133131027,
-0.5240567922592163,
-0.7131282091140747,
-0.026246028020977974,
0.08370000123977661,
0.47960588335990906,
-0.512150764465332,
0.15372316539287567,
0.04863560572266579,
-0.6933901906013489,
-0.637795090675354,
-0.453280508518219,
0.15215837955474854,
-0.48975592851638794,
-0.2957920730113983,
0.09301001578569412,
0.15475669503211975,
-0.0032286786008626223,
-0.1876433789730072,
0.09703803807497025,
-0.01108519732952118,
-0.1598031222820282,
0.13296301662921906,
0.24005980789661407,
-0.011938000097870827,
0.3950115144252777,
0.1515374779701233,
-0.034958865493535995,
-0.17212915420532227,
-0.3410281538963318,
0.47994163632392883,
0.04289153218269348,
-0.11348338425159454,
-0.6007333397865295,
0.5065619945526123,
0.15600240230560303,
-0.06730956584215164,
0.3071209490299225,
0.6281697750091553,
-0.3813774585723877,
-0.7481511235237122,
-0.35738617181777954,
-0.1329347789287567,
-0.5177788138389587,
0.3458697497844696,
-0.37168270349502563,
-0.38307008147239685,
0.5082873702049255,
-0.044344883412122726,
0.28357115387916565,
0.0963670164346695,
0.7453117370605469,
-0.05675860866904259,
0.95806884765625,
0.16740179061889648,
-0.10103035718202591,
0.681807816028595,
-0.019681047648191452,
0.02613568678498268,
-0.3151406943798065,
-0.3123413324356079,
-0.6415460705757141,
-0.30272918939590454,
-0.4923056364059448,
-0.1848425567150116,
0.5472014546394348,
-0.33571740984916687,
-0.37343406677246094,
0.3769890367984772,
-0.4804898202419281,
0.35981377959251404,
0.6536543369293213,
0.1866152137517929,
0.1040843203663826,
0.07244212180376053,
-0.420816034078598,
0.1792067140340805,
-0.9736979007720947,
-0.6445625424385071,
0.7096116542816162,
0.08535328507423401,
0.7893369793891907,
-0.22252202033996582,
0.8547270894050598,
0.6063417792320251,
0.09264294803142548,
-0.5945572853088379,
0.6254244446754456,
-0.09240544587373734,
-0.15371081233024597,
-0.6566042900085449,
-0.48490574955940247,
-1.118739366531372,
-0.11174707859754562,
-0.4292631149291992,
-0.7045660018920898,
-0.017744561657309532,
0.3454245924949646,
-0.8497375249862671,
-0.03366899490356445,
-0.46642738580703735,
1.0111610889434814,
-0.15562784671783447,
-0.5082064867019653,
0.13462099432945251,
-0.5672623515129089,
0.24822774529457092,
-0.007531577721238136,
0.03861493244767189,
-0.18551509082317352,
0.06797196716070175,
0.5738008618354797,
-0.4583800137042999,
0.5244171023368835,
-0.5076329112052917,
-0.08959760516881943,
0.4852917492389679,
0.11399906128644943,
0.8210923075675964,
0.16905441880226135,
-0.07417500764131546,
-0.8160420656204224,
-0.18929442763328552,
-0.17247217893600464,
-0.6838326454162598,
0.8119233250617981,
-0.12632077932357788,
-0.225077286362648,
-0.07013172656297684,
-0.730957567691803,
-0.33638620376586914,
-0.03865432366728783,
0.16226913034915924,
0.6939763426780701,
0.025127548724412918,
-0.11913903057575226,
0.6004131436347961,
-0.6223134398460388,
0.717345654964447,
0.289814293384552,
-0.07479401677846909,
-0.3529527187347412,
0.9614043235778809,
-0.07952450215816498,
-0.26286542415618896,
0.42398062348365784,
-0.11868733912706375,
-0.33908969163894653,
-0.26034098863601685,
-0.9797402024269104,
-0.17712508141994476,
-0.5215452313423157,
-0.7669453620910645,
-0.5544245839118958,
0.23257163166999817,
-0.28583675622940063,
-0.308980256319046,
0.14442463219165802,
-0.2263430953025818,
-0.4417717456817627,
-0.08492253720760345,
0.49324947595596313,
0.9359681010246277,
0.0980408638715744,
0.4060271084308624,
-0.9241158962249756,
0.630535364151001,
0.6473398804664612,
0.23058271408081055,
-0.02050568163394928,
-0.20409169793128967,
-0.1519920974969864,
-0.2765202522277832,
-0.41979554295539856,
-1.11609947681427,
0.6982095241546631,
0.026073375716805458,
0.6717160940170288,
0.149331197142601,
-0.1783556044101715,
0.4590270519256592,
-0.8096851706504822,
0.6807233691215515,
0.33738523721694946,
-0.755804717540741,
0.5735477805137634,
-0.65215003490448,
0.4969232976436615,
0.6591631174087524,
0.3586050271987915,
-0.426067590713501,
-0.3259863257408142,
-0.3836044371128082,
-0.7973186373710632,
0.8994473218917847,
-0.034478072077035904,
-0.22758732736110687,
-0.08183687180280685,
0.2574842572212219,
0.5438405871391296,
0.36966758966445923,
-0.7758251428604126,
-0.21619392931461334,
-0.01207911316305399,
-0.7117934823036194,
0.284612774848938,
0.06459864974021912,
0.13331304490566254,
0.07519462704658508,
0.6227663159370422,
-0.35007208585739136,
0.3869346082210541,
0.2139151692390442,
-0.2282394915819168,
-0.13559110462665558,
0.5500809550285339,
0.5853574275970459,
0.38727453351020813,
0.26489368081092834,
-0.2727932035923004,
0.560300350189209,
-0.05170994997024536,
0.4425260126590729,
0.09326345473527908,
-0.09222204238176346,
0.1156444251537323,
-0.10290548205375671,
0.9439609050750732,
-0.0024198798928409815,
-0.6543715596199036,
0.350210040807724,
0.09084074199199677,
-0.15975652635097504,
-0.3130725026130676,
0.2959674894809723,
-0.1679053008556366,
0.39872682094573975,
0.5808863639831543,
-0.439380407333374,
0.2932099997997284,
-0.4552043676376343,
0.373916894197464,
0.4834696352481842,
-0.035847511142492294,
0.2548774182796478,
0.39768582582473755,
0.11082792282104492,
-0.3312903940677643,
0.5135262608528137,
-0.7280997633934021,
-0.23882433772087097,
0.9134132266044617,
0.4918229579925537,
0.4382324516773224,
-0.14125187695026398,
0.5130566954612732,
0.4717974364757538,
-0.00046100025065243244,
-0.16607403755187988,
0.5053742527961731,
-0.10070033371448517,
-0.22908926010131836,
-0.163319930434227,
-0.4446219801902771,
-0.4525078237056732,
0.27160710096359253,
-0.42234107851982117,
0.5309850573539734,
-0.31463193893432617,
-0.1714545339345932,
-0.08346384763717651,
0.08767916262149811,
-0.9828277230262756,
0.3599311113357544,
0.3889220952987671,
0.7717105746269226,
-0.8856212496757507,
0.5430535078048706,
0.6008824110031128,
-0.2218116968870163,
-0.957143247127533,
-0.3565647006034851,
-0.2158302366733551,
-0.40616950392723083,
0.9341887831687927,
0.18582665920257568,
0.34538599848747253,
-0.14771021902561188,
-0.4759833514690399,
-0.5953550338745117,
1.15708327293396,
0.09909737855195999,
-0.7961490154266357,
-0.32962408661842346,
0.24607019126415253,
0.423770010471344,
-0.7645699381828308,
0.4834153354167938,
0.7278295755386353,
0.6268575191497803,
-0.12384018301963806,
-1.0323199033737183,
0.2349914014339447,
-0.03426692634820938,
-0.04636663571000099,
0.16072914004325867,
-0.3993098735809326,
0.6880338788032532,
-0.26017042994499207,
0.06763771176338196,
0.09746301174163818,
0.7042242288589478,
0.5416876077651978,
0.31586143374443054,
0.62020343542099,
0.2750105559825897,
0.7634268403053284,
0.05702647939324379,
0.5202677845954895,
-0.05678804963827133,
-0.11225231736898422,
1.1304998397827148,
-0.5458856821060181,
0.4560818672180176,
0.06604190915822983,
-0.001332316198386252,
0.6452988982200623,
0.6540899276733398,
-0.35843420028686523,
0.47686994075775146,
0.4806666672229767,
-0.2065613567829132,
-0.27745357155799866,
-0.1269683986902237,
-0.16405722498893738,
0.3300077021121979,
0.5651765465736389,
-0.3989717364311218,
-0.5599269270896912,
0.1639370322227478,
-0.24232129752635956,
-0.06350851058959961,
-0.4661868214607239,
0.9843412041664124,
-0.1182304322719574,
-0.8758043050765991,
0.3368300199508667,
-0.21729640662670135,
0.5421886444091797,
-0.5351640582084656,
-0.28443026542663574,
-0.29884546995162964,
-0.3687584400177002,
-0.3363998830318451,
-0.6097553968429565,
-0.2519429922103882,
0.2817843556404114,
-0.08372554183006287,
-0.29150402545928955,
0.5565896034240723,
-0.7674078345298767,
-0.28076860308647156,
-0.31907376646995544,
0.7272918820381165,
0.138016015291214,
0.3690567910671234,
-0.7651121020317078,
-0.23820342123508453,
0.012060287408530712,
-0.3128974437713623,
0.13262662291526794,
0.5592445135116577,
-0.10977719724178314,
0.826127290725708,
0.3048875331878662,
0.15819230675697327,
0.06903646886348724,
-0.06314562261104584,
0.8304901123046875,
-0.7653983235359192,
-0.7898107171058655,
-0.6057742834091187,
0.37168776988983154,
-0.07954036444425583,
-0.25365567207336426,
0.46792909502983093,
0.6392561793327332,
0.3074108958244324,
-0.2727176547050476,
1.041768193244934,
0.04703224077820778,
0.7602038979530334,
-0.5938854217529297,
0.3504107594490051,
-0.3148421049118042,
0.17297732830047607,
-0.3655136525630951,
-0.9125948548316956,
-0.18974782526493073,
0.5242981910705566,
-0.2895420789718628,
0.15445581078529358,
0.7885341644287109,
0.8527060747146606,
0.1147662103176117,
-0.27717125415802,
0.2096140831708908,
-0.10057984292507172,
0.2312067747116089,
0.7940415740013123,
0.81893390417099,
-0.02392585389316082,
0.7688952684402466,
0.050059035420417786,
-0.0852915421128273,
-0.3429914712905884,
-0.9456456899642944,
-0.8438386917114258,
-0.6130836009979248,
-0.20607993006706238,
-0.02507070079445839,
0.15270525217056274,
1.4127501249313354,
0.5630019307136536,
-0.9096958041191101,
-0.17633654177188873,
-0.2739063501358032,
0.04790152981877327,
0.009480088949203491,
-0.3249192535877228,
0.19104209542274475,
-0.8177239894866943,
-0.5486159920692444,
0.589905321598053,
0.1979084312915802,
0.2170063853263855,
0.01728762872517109,
0.2773955762386322,
0.09949109703302383,
-0.12008688598871231,
0.3407300114631653,
0.43594619631767273,
-0.3140309751033783,
-0.00046542746713384986,
-0.11313080042600632,
-0.40868595242500305,
0.16306476294994354,
0.9457108974456787,
-1.1527386903762817,
-0.0797695592045784,
0.6003472805023193,
0.5699794292449951,
0.25373375415802,
0.15521644055843353,
0.554695188999176,
-0.741609513759613,
0.048532672226428986,
0.38525640964508057,
0.2882864475250244,
0.33452069759368896,
-0.5113070011138916,
0.03626636415719986,
-0.21432732045650482,
-0.6735407114028931,
-0.7975178956985474,
0.3757278323173523,
-0.8914856314659119,
-0.12460250407457352,
1.1271547079086304,
-0.05356312170624733,
-0.14791718125343323,
-0.22580718994140625,
-0.3728887438774109,
0.37656235694885254,
-1.0565029382705688,
0.8714064955711365,
0.30753839015960693,
-0.45144277811050415,
-0.10658080130815506,
-0.5729971528053284,
0.8750079870223999,
0.32791346311569214,
-1.4170444011688232,
0.10722412168979645,
0.760993242263794,
0.19930723309516907,
-0.2723492383956909,
0.3360687792301178,
0.35214564204216003,
0.5444098114967346,
-0.10887420922517776,
-0.018587248399853706,
-0.275551438331604,
-0.6724846959114075,
-0.325323224067688,
0.2770363390445709,
-0.0898619294166565,
-0.09013870358467102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05616v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05616v1
|
G-SAP: Graph-based Structure-Aware Prompt Learning over Heterogeneous Knowledge for Commonsense Reasoning
| 2024-05-09T08:28:12 | 2024-05-09T08:28:12 |
Ruiting Dai, Yuqiao Tan, Lisi Mo, Shuang Liang, Guohao Huo, Jiayi Luo, Yao Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Commonsense question answering has demonstrated considerable potential across
various applications like assistants and social robots. Although fully
fine-tuned pre-trained Language Models(LM) have achieved remarkable performance
in commonsense reasoning, their tendency to excessively prioritize textual
information hampers the precise transfer of structural knowledge and undermines
interpretability. Some studies have explored combining LMs with Knowledge
Graphs(KGs) by coarsely fusing the two modalities to perform Graph Neural
Network(GNN)-based reasoning that lacks a profound interaction between
heterogeneous modalities. In this paper, we propose a novel Graph-based
Structure-Aware Prompt Learning Model for commonsense reasoning, named G-SAP,
aiming to maintain a balance between heterogeneous knowledge and enhance the
cross-modal interaction within the LM+GNNs model. In particular, an evidence
graph is constructed by integrating multiple knowledge sources, i.e.
ConceptNet, Wikipedia, and Cambridge Dictionary to boost the performance.
Afterward, a structure-aware frozen PLM is employed to fully incorporate the
structured and textual information from the evidence graph, where the
generation of prompts is driven by graph entities and relations. Finally, a
heterogeneous message-passing reasoning module is used to facilitate deep
interaction of knowledge between the LM and graph-based networks. Empirical
validation, conducted through extensive experiments on three benchmark
datasets, demonstrates the notable performance of the proposed model. The
results reveal a significant advancement over the existing models, especially,
with 6.12% improvement over the SoTA LM+GNNs model on the OpenbookQA dataset.
|
[
-0.14589886367321014,
-1.1050270795822144,
0.6812981367111206,
0.00939528364688158,
-0.35010984539985657,
0.07585367560386658,
0.05814450606703758,
-0.3426051735877991,
-0.04093503952026367,
0.2758690416812897,
-0.3723812401294708,
-0.7541685700416565,
-0.31934693455696106,
0.09155480563640594,
0.25423893332481384,
0.8107066750526428,
0.22595767676830292,
0.12650330364704132,
-0.2808094024658203,
-0.23705114424228668,
-0.5562319755554199,
-0.3840186297893524,
-0.562930703163147,
-0.0651731938123703,
0.6436237692832947,
0.4992641508579254,
0.5870015621185303,
0.44009098410606384,
-0.07914575189352036,
0.31903278827667236,
-0.4807342290878296,
0.4211810827255249,
-0.18726730346679688,
-0.018419472500681877,
-0.32855358719825745,
-0.15424136817455292,
-0.47516152262687683,
-0.09001334011554718,
0.5800352692604065,
0.8110520243644714,
0.026305796578526497,
-0.0294048972427845,
0.24449720978736877,
0.2360629439353943,
-0.36083564162254333,
0.434627890586853,
-0.7942158579826355,
-0.08270246535539627,
0.14056804776191711,
-0.10666102170944214,
-0.5294017195701599,
-0.518707275390625,
0.02969508245587349,
-0.7456431984901428,
0.18536773324012756,
0.3271450102329254,
0.8657847046852112,
0.10739126056432724,
-0.3253076672554016,
-0.15636467933654785,
-0.11961503326892853,
0.5711579918861389,
-0.6957939267158508,
0.2317952811717987,
0.35259395837783813,
0.5929189324378967,
0.10506326705217361,
-0.7597925662994385,
-0.5768120288848877,
-0.481319785118103,
-0.31185463070869446,
0.10732069611549377,
0.008605945855379105,
0.1087193414568901,
0.3194330930709839,
0.11675106734037399,
-0.5633518099784851,
0.16493964195251465,
-0.4755532741546631,
-0.3112768530845642,
0.29896584153175354,
0.34324780106544495,
0.6221266984939575,
-0.6908084750175476,
-0.7422594428062439,
0.27954524755477905,
-0.5445027947425842,
0.16184325516223907,
0.31009751558303833,
0.8743525147438049,
-0.13181070983409882,
0.48858845233917236,
-0.18399523198604584,
0.9097029566764832,
-0.08272205293178558,
0.10408364981412888,
0.2759259343147278,
-0.3965400159358978,
-0.20442555844783783,
0.06386839598417282,
0.5470459461212158,
0.21571263670921326,
0.035339511930942535,
0.05524735897779465,
-0.09500351548194885,
0.11485249549150467,
-0.17772243916988373,
-0.6544874310493469,
-0.3437437117099762,
0.18192565441131592,
-0.4340132474899292,
-0.17264139652252197,
-0.3779997229576111,
-0.5850632786750793,
-0.3603328764438629,
-0.2826285660266876,
0.20564302802085876,
-0.6700742840766907,
-0.22455236315727234,
0.01958491839468479,
-0.2500849664211273,
-0.017964033409953117,
0.8718885779380798,
-0.7806617021560669,
0.21831855177879333,
0.5867566466331482,
0.9450339078903198,
0.18174578249454498,
-0.39083752036094666,
-0.9578943252563477,
0.2660878598690033,
0.03450874611735344,
0.7491585612297058,
-0.6450679302215576,
-0.2617289125919342,
-0.23045575618743896,
-0.09018374234437943,
-0.33152246475219727,
-0.33448588848114014,
0.4981174170970917,
-0.5259442925453186,
0.5544794201850891,
-0.2859210669994354,
-0.5589649081230164,
-0.2655435800552368,
0.6707403063774109,
-0.7654091715812683,
0.8794757723808289,
0.12895959615707397,
-0.8514626026153564,
0.19519838690757751,
-0.6844351887702942,
-0.5416905283927917,
0.4179946780204773,
-0.3123985528945923,
-0.16851507127285004,
-0.43294593691825867,
0.4208487272262573,
0.547925591468811,
-0.23627431690692902,
0.5075974464416504,
-0.5470879077911377,
-0.15915752947330475,
-0.24357718229293823,
-0.44390252232551575,
1.041295051574707,
0.21068817377090454,
0.03966732323169708,
0.4075064957141876,
-0.48119840025901794,
-0.03062078356742859,
0.027797270566225052,
-0.2998005747795105,
-0.4064634442329407,
-0.195445716381073,
-0.24895423650741577,
0.32808735966682434,
0.07655543833971024,
-0.5337796211242676,
0.1475086510181427,
-0.2631984353065491,
0.5861130952835083,
0.7336364984512329,
0.12131817638874054,
0.44943615794181824,
-0.18720540404319763,
0.25273337960243225,
-0.06847012788057327,
0.3201117217540741,
-0.13384264707565308,
-0.7967970967292786,
0.16124045848846436,
-0.35535016655921936,
0.02915426902472973,
0.8036702871322632,
-0.7225459814071655,
0.15972790122032166,
-0.08350265771150589,
-0.29201245307922363,
-0.0007781232125125825,
0.13937526941299438,
0.2843432128429413,
1.3754459619522095,
0.6398836374282837,
-0.09915496408939362,
-0.1447901576757431,
-0.5861173272132874,
-0.04985959455370903,
-0.26024556159973145,
-0.04765019938349724,
0.8732100129127502,
0.23155006766319275,
0.14939484000205994,
0.9187003374099731,
-0.5873478055000305,
-0.07526476681232452,
-0.5231108069419861,
0.19580748677253723,
0.2689295709133148,
0.4441705048084259,
0.5018845796585083,
-0.9445374011993408,
-0.3842765688896179,
0.014842968434095383,
-0.6302214860916138,
-0.05309991165995598,
0.20151568949222565,
-0.04521603509783745,
0.16123849153518677,
0.6355717182159424,
-0.5711008906364441,
0.16344821453094482,
0.24187211692333221,
-0.4534423351287842,
0.7467064261436462,
-0.09830769896507263,
0.004989732056856155,
-1.1025277376174927,
0.22432927787303925,
-0.0051812101155519485,
-0.01495309080928564,
-0.46628043055534363,
-0.3547728955745697,
-0.03471342474222183,
-0.475021094083786,
-0.6327804923057556,
0.9717170596122742,
-0.44582971930503845,
-0.15943185985088348,
0.1142672598361969,
0.5855539441108704,
0.2960920035839081,
0.8856257796287537,
0.12473013997077942,
0.5359032154083252,
0.5270830392837524,
-0.7078084945678711,
0.31359726190567017,
0.461378812789917,
-0.3614777624607086,
0.5275924801826477,
-0.8006547093391418,
-0.16158133745193481,
-0.1281372606754303,
0.4050573408603668,
-1.1442784070968628,
-0.11597657203674316,
0.5787950158119202,
-0.5072017908096313,
0.051538050174713135,
-0.5481458306312561,
-0.33914217352867126,
-0.49121466279029846,
-0.016734998673200607,
0.358536958694458,
0.2690829932689667,
-0.6544235944747925,
1.0030603408813477,
-0.05961458757519722,
-0.4994775950908661,
-0.8217125535011292,
-0.4114721119403839,
-0.12563808262348175,
-0.08226875960826874,
-0.8435868620872498,
0.061136823147535324,
-0.008567895740270615,
-0.07559572905302048,
0.4067375063896179,
-0.1628228724002838,
-0.18823441863059998,
0.2528362572193146,
0.005208402406424284,
0.7926085591316223,
-0.3403865098953247,
0.47904253005981445,
0.1448720395565033,
-0.024399064481258392,
-0.030300110578536987,
-0.3409239649772644,
0.48705342411994934,
-0.29801812767982483,
-0.4486951529979706,
-0.1654796153306961,
0.23571690917015076,
0.3965716063976288,
-0.37950703501701355,
0.670231819152832,
0.45004284381866455,
-0.22836367785930634,
-0.3410952091217041,
-0.1844460517168045,
-0.27470192313194275,
-0.46359783411026,
0.44975191354751587,
-0.39548444747924805,
-1.012109637260437,
0.6766378283500671,
-0.3437581956386566,
-0.05638208985328674,
0.4064957797527313,
0.2889179289340973,
-0.05998356267809868,
0.9265044331550598,
0.22808785736560822,
-0.1543111354112625,
0.5339674949645996,
-0.1127847284078598,
0.16844342648983002,
-0.6827152967453003,
-0.36702123284339905,
-0.6139982342720032,
-0.09772997349500656,
-0.10987401753664017,
-0.5725995898246765,
0.28153347969055176,
0.2504441440105438,
-0.697079598903656,
-0.07652505487203598,
-0.4332584738731384,
0.509567379951477,
0.44982677698135376,
0.28557705879211426,
0.29929545521736145,
-0.17687734961509705,
-0.4343591332435608,
0.6399862170219421,
-1.1028268337249756,
-0.49175554513931274,
0.5072952508926392,
0.052100758999586105,
0.5334995985031128,
0.1419735550880432,
0.24890781939029694,
0.2954142391681671,
0.2746521532535553,
-0.4845585823059082,
0.7758955955505371,
-0.16974422335624695,
-0.527073323726654,
-0.7543785572052002,
-0.7414359450340271,
-0.685456395149231,
0.18734975159168243,
0.012208839878439903,
-0.8493505120277405,
0.00719904899597168,
0.3843407928943634,
-0.4289177358150482,
0.6221709847450256,
-0.8852872252464294,
1.1908210515975952,
-0.2858102321624756,
-0.5071976780891418,
-0.17820672690868378,
-0.9771987199783325,
0.4320572316646576,
0.6378514766693115,
0.08889110386371613,
-0.3198169767856598,
0.191501185297966,
0.31789958477020264,
-0.45417386293411255,
1.1658142805099487,
-0.6303220391273499,
0.023034507408738136,
0.4614515006542206,
-0.04954978823661804,
0.701422393321991,
0.264634907245636,
-0.11550257354974747,
-0.04484199732542038,
-0.5225492119789124,
-0.5325797200202942,
-0.8661956787109375,
0.4823233485221863,
-0.5708275437355042,
-0.7448857426643372,
0.06287584453821182,
-0.6115025281906128,
-0.415549635887146,
0.20837464928627014,
0.12507447600364685,
0.8105437159538269,
-0.1971939653158188,
-0.21524997055530548,
0.7094023823738098,
-0.28931158781051636,
0.24466657638549805,
0.17764297127723694,
-0.05778820440173149,
-0.4108033776283264,
0.8699882626533508,
-0.035500578582286835,
0.5426439642906189,
0.48237964510917664,
0.43408238887786865,
-0.5117040872573853,
-0.372719407081604,
-0.8725612759590149,
0.0975228101015091,
-0.9183412790298462,
-0.22014109790325165,
-0.8977171778678894,
-0.2006576806306839,
-0.3890973925590515,
-0.3656248450279236,
0.08472973108291626,
-0.49470511078834534,
-0.20223750174045563,
-0.21961231529712677,
0.48281440138816833,
0.3064897358417511,
-0.005276366602629423,
-0.0752539336681366,
-0.8690866827964783,
0.40409284830093384,
0.6415035724639893,
0.4368341565132141,
0.2909710109233856,
-0.30170002579689026,
0.018073774874210358,
-0.09433912485837936,
0.27307912707328796,
-0.895399272441864,
-0.05935419350862503,
-0.14601773023605347,
0.9525167346000671,
0.28894251585006714,
0.10634703189134598,
0.12724368274211884,
-0.2725681662559509,
0.7786995768547058,
0.3045462369918823,
-0.8862402439117432,
0.6147370338439941,
-0.581780731678009,
0.15498071908950806,
0.5633534789085388,
0.33737075328826904,
-0.4989723563194275,
-0.13933147490024567,
-0.6867937445640564,
-0.8995659351348877,
0.7014642953872681,
-0.35723772644996643,
0.14358460903167725,
-0.01869613490998745,
-0.07459055632352829,
0.11566656827926636,
0.15824195742607117,
-0.5372351408004761,
0.0758533775806427,
-0.6048214435577393,
-0.12295112013816833,
0.23398613929748535,
-0.0799228847026825,
-0.1835997998714447,
-0.26847878098487854,
0.6308220028877258,
-0.510265052318573,
-0.005357560236006975,
0.08634015172719955,
-0.10924835503101349,
0.36761876940727234,
0.5412629842758179,
0.4297158420085907,
0.2399417608976364,
-0.20995716750621796,
0.22957424819469452,
0.41655194759368896,
-0.3323858976364136,
-0.150479257106781,
0.374606192111969,
-0.20705246925354004,
-0.15128496289253235,
0.22115002572536469,
0.9961616396903992,
0.14318107068538666,
-0.4638730585575104,
0.4451090693473816,
0.1759590357542038,
-0.0522955097258091,
0.5296103954315186,
0.1110038012266159,
0.15464842319488525,
0.24813024699687958,
0.2360016107559204,
0.20507094264030457,
0.0025189861189574003,
-0.5668817758560181,
0.15992268919944763,
0.29412898421287537,
-0.13532708585262299,
-0.1426427662372589,
0.5819002389907837,
0.46113887429237366,
-0.20004834234714508,
0.7812249064445496,
-0.37718135118484497,
-0.8140520453453064,
0.8395153284072876,
0.5269002318382263,
0.5853786468505859,
-0.15351687371730804,
0.6350923180580139,
0.6081491112709045,
0.12793931365013123,
0.14671140909194946,
0.321891188621521,
-0.5288124680519104,
-0.826968252658844,
-0.34683796763420105,
-0.19561225175857544,
-0.6242611408233643,
-0.1503676027059555,
-0.2181372493505478,
0.1664169728755951,
-0.6471706032752991,
0.25411346554756165,
-0.1779281049966812,
0.07891608774662018,
-0.43762317299842834,
0.28254371881484985,
-0.009327739477157593,
1.0791517496109009,
-1.1667428016662598,
0.5300513505935669,
0.6866098642349243,
-0.6563970446586609,
-1.3244941234588623,
-0.1860755980014801,
-0.16013623774051666,
-0.7858238816261292,
0.6431325674057007,
0.11470068991184235,
-0.20219889283180237,
-0.1001819521188736,
-0.648431658744812,
-0.515777587890625,
1.1239506006240845,
0.3829438388347626,
-0.2652202844619751,
-0.07457157969474792,
-0.1579553186893463,
0.29458892345428467,
-0.2903875410556793,
0.2999374270439148,
-0.13015466928482056,
0.5887382626533508,
0.5829717516899109,
-0.5499347448348999,
0.3064636290073395,
-0.5103821158409119,
-0.35489651560783386,
0.032703887671232224,
-0.7092170119285583,
1.031551718711853,
-0.3511078953742981,
-0.3348121643066406,
-0.1887989193201065,
0.6739754676818848,
0.7061655521392822,
0.6949172019958496,
0.649672269821167,
0.3919668197631836,
1.3240375518798828,
0.20564265549182892,
0.8680422306060791,
-0.2022581249475479,
0.02868560515344143,
1.4840718507766724,
-0.5394176244735718,
0.5064420104026794,
0.07180760055780411,
0.28128695487976074,
0.7489410638809204,
0.47505152225494385,
-0.07666982710361481,
0.42034003138542175,
0.1590537428855896,
-0.2590271532535553,
-0.34015724062919617,
-0.31074395775794983,
-0.48941147327423096,
0.04861421883106232,
0.2528083920478821,
-0.13417337834835052,
-0.5411263108253479,
-0.00020500314712990075,
-0.10551635921001434,
0.2203037142753601,
-0.5499886870384216,
0.45333507657051086,
-0.08949022740125656,
-0.5294536352157593,
0.2757595479488373,
-0.18863169848918915,
0.4131537973880768,
-0.6441402435302734,
-0.1367875039577484,
-0.28367096185684204,
-0.3591482937335968,
-0.20120134949684143,
-0.8950205445289612,
0.1564505696296692,
-0.09000586718320847,
-0.23007792234420776,
-0.18659831583499908,
1.1037958860397339,
-0.35680317878723145,
-0.08317040652036667,
0.20358653366565704,
0.8672906160354614,
-0.0796142965555191,
0.13987821340560913,
-0.6169971227645874,
-0.35431969165802,
-0.2388308048248291,
-0.12578830122947693,
0.1355072557926178,
0.8350504040718079,
-0.3281014561653137,
0.6737074851989746,
0.6738402843475342,
-0.21224722266197205,
-0.2213257998228073,
0.368393212556839,
1.1611555814743042,
-0.45820507407188416,
-1.0001240968704224,
-0.551530122756958,
0.48338180780410767,
-0.26101887226104736,
-0.30265122652053833,
0.8707296848297119,
0.510803759098053,
0.5810237526893616,
0.10176247358322144,
0.721294641494751,
-0.005176495760679245,
0.30238547921180725,
-0.6488935351371765,
0.5917929410934448,
-0.38389843702316284,
0.26840585470199585,
-0.44514426589012146,
-0.5981380939483643,
-0.17398826777935028,
0.23511295020580292,
-0.6572305560112,
0.22221727669239044,
0.413312166929245,
0.7169145941734314,
-0.21337774395942688,
0.45985502004623413,
0.21443700790405273,
0.2580554187297821,
0.014561143703758717,
0.6398007869720459,
0.9188204407691956,
0.23607522249221802,
0.49517831206321716,
0.27306532859802246,
-0.056540597230196,
-0.1816890835762024,
-0.8301753401756287,
-0.8286020755767822,
-0.5673162341117859,
-0.08394446223974228,
-0.3057957887649536,
0.12137804925441742,
0.7480611205101013,
0.4789912700653076,
-0.4937955439090729,
0.2906544506549835,
-0.23963581025600433,
0.6173484921455383,
-0.2535918653011322,
-0.2795054316520691,
0.649082601070404,
-0.36950597167015076,
-0.3221362829208374,
0.44842565059661865,
0.26828593015670776,
-0.0185024905949831,
0.06050708144903183,
-0.19292886555194855,
-0.4605220556259155,
0.12439998984336853,
0.5386536121368408,
0.47254300117492676,
-0.46813449263572693,
-0.3629171848297119,
0.08847131580114365,
-0.3762750029563904,
0.17677220702171326,
0.6808239817619324,
-1.0342789888381958,
0.09987444430589676,
0.6226113438606262,
0.6471017599105835,
0.2200300246477127,
0.24411314725875854,
0.22322756052017212,
-0.7274079322814941,
-0.026833437383174896,
0.4979793131351471,
0.3657265603542328,
0.3605959713459015,
-0.5856863856315613,
0.33036336302757263,
0.4517253637313843,
-0.2369859665632248,
-0.6686584949493408,
0.40236133337020874,
-1.1877704858779907,
-0.6406562328338623,
0.9900888204574585,
-0.12645597755908966,
-0.3716028332710266,
-0.4525643587112427,
-0.24401181936264038,
0.3789360821247101,
-0.5236123204231262,
0.5377333760261536,
0.27808526158332825,
-0.03219638019800186,
-0.1118612065911293,
-0.09603758901357651,
0.34632623195648193,
0.4857945740222931,
-1.031753659248352,
0.31662631034851074,
0.899170458316803,
0.2415957748889923,
0.04920532926917076,
0.8117274641990662,
0.08293931186199188,
0.4633961319923401,
0.23987306654453278,
-0.23885679244995117,
-0.7428436279296875,
-0.5859295129776001,
-0.11982443928718567,
0.6417786478996277,
-0.23224276304244995,
-0.11513730138540268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05615v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05615v1
|
Memory-Space Visual Prompting for Efficient Vision-Language Fine-Tuning
| 2024-05-09T08:23:20 | 2024-05-09T08:23:20 |
Shibo Jie, Yehui Tang, Ning Ding, Zhi-Hong Deng, Kai Han, Yunhe Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Current solutions for efficiently constructing large vision-language (VL)
models follow a two-step paradigm: projecting the output of pre-trained vision
encoders to the input space of pre-trained language models as visual prompts;
and then transferring the models to downstream VL tasks via end-to-end
parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT). However, this paradigm still exhibits
inefficiency since it significantly increases the input length of the language
models. In this paper, in contrast to integrating visual prompts into inputs,
we regard visual prompts as additional knowledge that facilitates language
models in addressing tasks associated with visual information. Motivated by the
finding that Feed-Forward Network (FFN) of language models acts as "key-value
memory", we introduce a novel approach termed memory-space visual prompting
(MemVP), wherein visual prompts are concatenated with the weights of FFN for
visual knowledge injection. Experimental results across various VL tasks and
language models reveal that MemVP significantly reduces the training time and
inference latency of the finetuned VL models and surpasses the performance of
previous PEFT methods. Code: https://github.com/JieShibo/MemVP
|
[
-0.43562135100364685,
-0.6446332335472107,
0.7827683091163635,
0.14710421860218048,
-0.3433920443058014,
-0.23118822276592255,
-0.28776517510414124,
-0.11914721131324768,
-0.2539222836494446,
0.4053635001182556,
-0.6773597002029419,
-0.28513920307159424,
-0.29768994450569153,
-0.25178730487823486,
-0.08399384468793869,
0.45051297545433044,
-0.15525999665260315,
0.18940146267414093,
-0.34098926186561584,
-0.03318191319704056,
-0.7459269165992737,
-0.3007684350013733,
-0.6663482189178467,
0.04565386474132538,
0.7134506106376648,
0.41219237446784973,
0.5056028962135315,
0.6213133335113525,
0.4785565137863159,
0.192612424492836,
0.012861916795372963,
0.3959032893180847,
-0.14791060984134674,
-0.01891489513218403,
-0.19612784683704376,
-0.36114513874053955,
-0.15005449950695038,
-0.05538325011730194,
0.5914474725723267,
0.7680001854896545,
0.1031603217124939,
0.2347809225320816,
0.26933667063713074,
0.765930712223053,
-1.0508193969726562,
0.28067460656166077,
-0.4262813925743103,
0.024426519870758057,
-0.02104741707444191,
-0.5122678279876709,
-0.4474077522754669,
-0.09965591877698898,
0.14958617091178894,
-0.6665404438972473,
-0.017060481011867523,
0.08406294882297516,
0.9473394751548767,
0.5083513259887695,
0.14520403742790222,
0.13781656324863434,
-0.5814157724380493,
0.5911972522735596,
-0.4645129144191742,
0.5990582704544067,
0.16581200063228607,
0.48801812529563904,
0.12636896967887878,
-0.5283602476119995,
-0.7452546954154968,
-0.1852891743183136,
0.07452814280986786,
0.16624794900417328,
-0.18647249042987823,
0.22224150598049164,
0.42690300941467285,
-0.1949756145477295,
-0.5979661345481873,
0.057094600051641464,
-0.4833170771598816,
0.0481332391500473,
-0.07037895172834396,
0.22702975571155548,
0.17720869183540344,
0.07970987260341644,
-0.26948270201683044,
-0.4396299123764038,
-0.8250004649162292,
0.45560306310653687,
0.016186494380235672,
0.28578758239746094,
0.06107276678085327,
0.5961297750473022,
-0.5569304823875427,
1.3038091659545898,
0.19003893435001373,
0.16315831243991852,
-0.012142503634095192,
-0.3876258432865143,
-0.2572615146636963,
-0.29270902276039124,
0.4356273114681244,
0.8126599788665771,
0.7056687474250793,
0.23386065661907196,
-0.03742361068725586,
0.226748988032341,
0.11869150400161743,
-0.8949152827262878,
-0.44733110070228577,
-0.09606397151947021,
-0.44922930002212524,
-0.1320776343345642,
-0.10053298622369766,
-0.6936048865318298,
-0.2607468068599701,
-0.25438594818115234,
0.6443828344345093,
-0.4276893436908722,
0.12043887376785278,
0.2159765064716339,
-0.3465035855770111,
0.41871553659439087,
0.8743022680282593,
-1.0209991931915283,
-0.05891326442360878,
0.37497857213020325,
0.7429338693618774,
-0.024806266650557518,
-0.3714786767959595,
-0.9068872928619385,
-0.003278615651652217,
-0.2969503700733185,
0.7975849509239197,
-0.8230786323547363,
-0.05820297822356224,
0.016942230984568596,
-0.11152052134275436,
0.04273422062397003,
-0.6329696774482727,
-0.21651072800159454,
-0.46235525608062744,
0.006858867593109608,
-0.49718084931373596,
-0.2893247604370117,
-0.10039293766021729,
0.3553966283798218,
-0.3021727502346039,
0.6176874041557312,
0.10476654767990112,
-0.25397825241088867,
0.593170702457428,
-0.47263458371162415,
-0.055292002856731415,
0.25149938464164734,
-0.48020467162132263,
0.055129524320364,
0.08434396237134933,
0.6519728899002075,
0.8246061205863953,
-0.15285928547382355,
0.03339281678199768,
-0.3879723846912384,
-0.236288920044899,
0.021058546379208565,
-0.5361981391906738,
0.3256213665008545,
0.27848878502845764,
-0.03621221333742142,
0.1558704674243927,
-0.6504914164543152,
0.0572664737701416,
0.03847610950469971,
-0.28093889355659485,
-0.5240569114685059,
-0.14908961951732635,
-0.17958013713359833,
0.2621997892856598,
0.355910986661911,
-0.2981673777103424,
0.3902958929538727,
-0.4306613802909851,
0.33341529965400696,
0.6873425245285034,
-0.04351525008678436,
0.6874054670333862,
0.04328109323978424,
0.39598870277404785,
0.22640754282474518,
0.4227239787578583,
-0.7342942953109741,
-0.5615590214729309,
-0.660827100276947,
0.075094074010849,
0.004885946866124868,
0.7434626221656799,
-1.167089819908142,
-0.06537379324436188,
-0.14982691407203674,
-0.17024029791355133,
-0.23598864674568176,
0.10548021644353867,
0.4915391802787781,
0.7989595532417297,
0.4257655441761017,
-0.03164185956120491,
-0.1155686303973198,
-0.7841595411300659,
-0.24841779470443726,
-0.22351978719234467,
-0.12853173911571503,
0.5768650770187378,
0.2412971705198288,
0.08530950546264648,
0.756554126739502,
-0.6086575388908386,
-0.08050953596830368,
-0.01614447496831417,
-0.2791306674480438,
0.21778613328933716,
0.6226595044136047,
0.4739406704902649,
-0.6527417302131653,
-0.37098562717437744,
-0.06277954578399658,
-0.6310863494873047,
-0.2938372790813446,
-0.20825639367103577,
0.014326211996376514,
-0.12519386410713196,
0.7941372990608215,
-0.40019044280052185,
0.49801334738731384,
0.45821571350097656,
-0.6347475647926331,
0.563625156879425,
-0.3638748526573181,
0.34330734610557556,
-0.7972680926322937,
-0.03661695122718811,
-0.039362091571092606,
-0.10300865024328232,
-0.43709662556648254,
0.0973220095038414,
0.3742298185825348,
-0.28013545274734497,
-0.619458019733429,
0.8590465188026428,
-0.4750843942165375,
0.13884161412715912,
-0.09728508442640305,
0.03333869203925133,
0.1859225183725357,
0.6587592363357544,
0.030123041942715645,
0.8711999654769897,
0.6655071973800659,
-0.8436563014984131,
0.2887953519821167,
0.08238434791564941,
-0.1773819476366043,
0.6584448218345642,
-0.5203319191932678,
-0.2987910509109497,
-0.0635419711470604,
-0.2860490679740906,
-1.02363121509552,
-0.01829540729522705,
0.4341839551925659,
-0.28549444675445557,
0.3955554664134979,
-0.35201653838157654,
-0.43087702989578247,
-0.48603883385658264,
-0.10920778661966324,
0.6524417400360107,
0.6296030879020691,
-0.8233498334884644,
0.3116890788078308,
0.008153717033565044,
-0.013256309553980827,
-0.5921581983566284,
-0.5270720720291138,
0.024265453219413757,
-0.07622504979372025,
-0.7418972253799438,
0.04090696945786476,
-0.07766828685998917,
-0.0710814893245697,
-0.04129756614565849,
0.05702084302902222,
-0.09412457793951035,
-0.04813985899090767,
0.1901896744966507,
0.3130957782268524,
-0.3433963358402252,
0.14517606794834137,
0.10940685868263245,
-0.13779906928539276,
-0.19908294081687927,
-0.8149201273918152,
0.4584759473800659,
-0.41370537877082825,
-0.3301800489425659,
-0.38366127014160156,
0.21435946226119995,
0.4737636148929596,
-0.43015289306640625,
0.5687512159347534,
0.3166603446006775,
-0.26180440187454224,
-0.1597718447446823,
-0.6029897928237915,
-0.3754761517047882,
-0.4874627888202667,
0.27947887778282166,
-0.3698385953903198,
-1.12041175365448,
0.26622721552848816,
-0.5183085799217224,
-0.09128302335739136,
0.052601054310798645,
0.40221598744392395,
-0.4597425162792206,
0.9617627263069153,
0.715643584728241,
0.3350418210029602,
1.0029339790344238,
-0.24085524678230286,
-0.01585576869547367,
-0.7270342707633972,
-0.15703672170639038,
-0.10088629275560379,
-0.3982957601547241,
0.010109704919159412,
-0.9385406970977783,
0.3940970003604889,
0.18527688086032867,
-0.06850565969944,
0.1577579528093338,
-0.4928049147129059,
0.6556731462478638,
0.5048415064811707,
0.13162268698215485,
0.017987795174121857,
0.15163086354732513,
-0.41112709045410156,
-0.2110346555709839,
-0.902393639087677,
-0.14152148365974426,
0.7469136118888855,
0.08781275153160095,
0.9395467042922974,
-0.4213501513004303,
0.2790733873844147,
-0.19439761340618134,
-0.2771476209163666,
-0.754530668258667,
0.6233805418014526,
-0.24475744366645813,
0.03833572939038277,
-0.42308807373046875,
-0.15777264535427094,
-0.7293713092803955,
0.030833331868052483,
-0.2236526906490326,
-0.8147743344306946,
0.6080368757247925,
0.7289949655532837,
-0.886773943901062,
0.2030978947877884,
-0.7226758599281311,
0.9739271998405457,
-0.15558694303035736,
-0.5195019841194153,
-0.24323977530002594,
-0.4826085567474365,
0.0966111496090889,
0.24540108442306519,
-0.26644274592399597,
0.06652466952800751,
-0.045678798109292984,
0.4918881058692932,
-0.6479714512825012,
0.7705624103546143,
-0.5342625975608826,
0.10421858727931976,
0.14988994598388672,
-0.011821750551462173,
0.5822881460189819,
-0.008720003068447113,
0.49869728088378906,
-0.0588785782456398,
-0.218803271651268,
-0.15376967191696167,
-0.8358199000358582,
0.49094751477241516,
-0.27758124470710754,
-0.4290006458759308,
0.1242896169424057,
-0.4278930723667145,
-0.2321292906999588,
0.20714671909809113,
0.32670724391937256,
0.6786965727806091,
0.21261316537857056,
0.2727300226688385,
1.0410571098327637,
-0.6368259191513062,
0.40806132555007935,
0.3165768086910248,
-0.32990512251853943,
-0.11671704798936844,
0.8720093965530396,
0.10802581906318665,
0.35160982608795166,
0.7033138275146484,
0.09143964946269989,
-0.13252627849578857,
-0.42776811122894287,
-0.7157854437828064,
0.042401138693094254,
-0.6996837258338928,
-0.18642503023147583,
-0.5336683392524719,
-0.05129154771566391,
-0.06036823242902756,
-0.5746487379074097,
-0.6105114817619324,
-0.3918718993663788,
-0.27386772632598877,
0.21356117725372314,
0.5133706331253052,
0.17797908186912537,
0.1742272973060608,
0.5111778378486633,
-0.7490195631980896,
0.39582446217536926,
0.6275547742843628,
0.48083463311195374,
-0.044419992715120316,
-0.4548283815383911,
-0.34509044885635376,
-0.10431526601314545,
0.0018556518480181694,
-0.8113852739334106,
0.3036230206489563,
0.10647416859865189,
0.3464064300060272,
0.48449984192848206,
-0.2731006145477295,
1.0490334033966064,
-0.7886437773704529,
0.8076306581497192,
0.4188302457332611,
-0.7035333514213562,
0.8771976232528687,
-0.3345268666744232,
0.7194309234619141,
0.5123120546340942,
-0.17964902520179749,
-0.45895615220069885,
-0.34584277868270874,
-0.3149939477443695,
-0.8017714619636536,
0.428229421377182,
-0.1937045007944107,
0.02603798545897007,
0.09784463793039322,
0.4451245963573456,
-0.18627330660820007,
0.2835952043533325,
-0.25532999634742737,
-0.10052903741598129,
-0.18533487617969513,
-0.0625799298286438,
0.1265176385641098,
-0.2534255087375641,
0.18644016981124878,
-0.45572522282600403,
0.15530851483345032,
-0.4769529402256012,
0.31151920557022095,
0.3378547132015228,
-0.19225068390369415,
-0.09303749352693558,
0.04275788366794586,
0.6667056679725647,
0.7029901742935181,
0.04986444115638733,
0.15748031437397003,
0.2376880794763565,
-0.291729211807251,
0.04442370682954788,
-0.16067853569984436,
-0.37350648641586304,
-0.18639492988586426,
-0.0379004068672657,
1.025612235069275,
0.3408474624156952,
-0.59220290184021,
0.6921555995941162,
-0.18495717644691467,
-0.20734389126300812,
-0.045190852135419846,
0.36351245641708374,
-0.03242725878953934,
0.6670761108398438,
0.25124067068099976,
0.5324628949165344,
0.185845747590065,
-0.0833951085805893,
0.231179341673851,
0.5519472360610962,
-0.5188322067260742,
-0.10847172141075134,
0.9274736642837524,
0.07439906895160675,
-0.05885125696659088,
0.6317235231399536,
0.12285413593053818,
-0.31012773513793945,
0.41377168893814087,
0.2500356435775757,
0.6883652806282043,
0.004607322625815868,
0.14827734231948853,
0.42285141348838806,
0.3707943856716156,
-0.0971469134092331,
0.572649359703064,
-0.2562474310398102,
-0.6713935136795044,
-0.5962243676185608,
-0.6165276169776917,
-0.19813011586666107,
0.08651167899370193,
-0.3382977545261383,
0.26478293538093567,
-0.7162241339683533,
0.14046980440616608,
-0.20577913522720337,
-0.44686880707740784,
-0.8661239743232727,
0.2755756378173828,
0.5290166139602661,
1.1720364093780518,
-0.6636824607849121,
0.9022828936576843,
0.6902122497558594,
-0.2306845635175705,
-1.042406678199768,
-0.11497867107391357,
-0.20683851838111877,
-0.9319318532943726,
0.7922031879425049,
0.17507410049438477,
-0.1054932177066803,
0.10522808134555817,
-0.8408364653587341,
-0.5554157495498657,
0.9509950280189514,
0.4016066789627075,
-0.7612801790237427,
0.02939448319375515,
-0.18344105780124664,
0.34866493940353394,
-0.36790403723716736,
-0.2121964991092682,
0.21756216883659363,
0.6061373353004456,
0.18844902515411377,
-0.6705713868141174,
0.149257630109787,
-0.4600764811038971,
0.192117378115654,
0.16891293227672577,
-0.5220036506652832,
0.7992718815803528,
-0.47575461864471436,
-0.05969364941120148,
-0.012043819762766361,
0.7648455500602722,
0.26169320940971375,
0.14709433913230896,
0.543148398399353,
0.3889519274234772,
0.7072683572769165,
-0.03520001843571663,
0.8922685980796814,
-0.26839175820350647,
-0.1135052889585495,
0.9203639030456543,
0.18735332787036896,
0.8481365442276001,
0.8917109966278076,
0.12771329283714294,
0.12544113397598267,
0.4844610393047333,
-0.28236931562423706,
0.724969208240509,
-0.08018313348293304,
0.06152331084012985,
-0.43562284111976624,
0.006791101768612862,
-0.308628112077713,
0.27133482694625854,
0.43680301308631897,
-0.3655761480331421,
-0.25219786167144775,
0.24391914904117584,
-0.33930787444114685,
-0.12901431322097778,
-0.5820494890213013,
0.6250516176223755,
0.1383487582206726,
-0.8681867122650146,
0.6136507987976074,
-0.3464753031730652,
0.5869064331054688,
-0.539111852645874,
-0.2433091551065445,
-0.10735917836427689,
0.279762864112854,
0.22859250009059906,
-0.9520671367645264,
0.06488726288080215,
-0.06821935623884201,
-0.3819415271282196,
-0.49880078434944153,
0.718799889087677,
-0.6112750172615051,
-0.21558040380477905,
0.11877771466970444,
0.6431360244750977,
0.0364866778254509,
-0.5345017313957214,
-0.6431260108947754,
-0.2668946087360382,
-0.05897029861807823,
-0.18084853887557983,
0.3338467478752136,
0.5019577145576477,
-0.2610614001750946,
0.6809810400009155,
0.7668176293373108,
0.22095637023448944,
0.19301967322826385,
0.2565891146659851,
0.8723363876342773,
-0.5766248106956482,
-0.6204514503479004,
-1.1281912326812744,
0.5378007888793945,
0.12471886724233627,
-0.28414517641067505,
0.641876220703125,
0.1793501228094101,
0.7341583967208862,
-0.4434252679347992,
0.5718265771865845,
0.13723395764827728,
-0.09853731840848923,
-0.8803772330284119,
0.7379158735275269,
-0.831382155418396,
0.14702843129634857,
-0.4160376787185669,
-0.7220712304115295,
-0.5130079388618469,
0.6643672585487366,
-0.22433674335479736,
-0.10627689957618713,
0.5850858688354492,
0.9558958411216736,
-0.12717141211032867,
-0.5218374133110046,
0.665031909942627,
0.0370405837893486,
0.07382965087890625,
0.7945964336395264,
0.9453994035720825,
-0.1505824476480484,
0.4553799033164978,
-0.19208134710788727,
-0.33333247900009155,
-0.47040101885795593,
-0.8218309283256531,
-0.8050366640090942,
-0.6993462443351746,
-0.2356068193912506,
-0.18713821470737457,
0.08488957583904266,
0.646080732345581,
0.7897804379463196,
-0.6018698215484619,
0.020044652745127678,
-0.20896805822849274,
-0.036536239087581635,
-0.43751904368400574,
-0.16687771677970886,
0.07593929022550583,
-0.3283337652683258,
-0.44159820675849915,
0.3446129262447357,
0.842597484588623,
0.1987794190645218,
-0.15690401196479797,
-0.23800800740718842,
0.05920686572790146,
-0.020332077518105507,
0.6057707667350769,
0.3512307107448578,
-0.7318441867828369,
-0.27542880177497864,
0.261051744222641,
-0.04982534423470497,
0.07708384096622467,
0.698817253112793,
-1.0911415815353394,
0.8147799968719482,
0.720683217048645,
0.5989130139350891,
0.26207229495048523,
-0.14657306671142578,
0.8445048332214355,
-0.8011524081230164,
0.25911203026771545,
-0.08697863668203354,
0.5025830864906311,
0.20935221016407013,
-0.48769187927246094,
0.2611311376094818,
0.3001818358898163,
-0.21323291957378387,
-0.528434693813324,
0.1981324702501297,
-1.045837640762329,
-0.34132423996925354,
0.987971305847168,
0.025413982570171356,
-0.5249389410018921,
0.18430671095848083,
-0.45869168639183044,
0.14042586088180542,
-0.3695189654827118,
0.37051722407341003,
0.496502548456192,
0.042578913271427155,
-0.5753334760665894,
-0.5839869379997253,
0.6931509971618652,
0.4442485570907593,
-0.619208037853241,
0.15979447960853577,
0.5429269075393677,
-0.020739320665597916,
0.09024377912282944,
0.5649248957633972,
0.11960460990667343,
0.8055232167243958,
0.014264759607613087,
-0.055475857108831406,
-0.34350353479385376,
-0.7711465358734131,
-0.47988417744636536,
0.07218888401985168,
-0.0115372184664011,
-0.315900593996048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05610v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05610v1
|
Chain of Attack: a Semantic-Driven Contextual Multi-Turn attacker for LLM
| 2024-05-09T08:15:21 | 2024-05-09T08:15:21 |
Xikang Yang, Xuehai Tang, Songlin Hu, Jizhong Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable performance in various
natural language processing tasks, especially in dialogue systems. However, LLM
may also pose security and moral threats, especially in multi round
conversations where large models are more easily guided by contextual content,
resulting in harmful or biased responses. In this paper, we present a novel
method to attack LLMs in multi-turn dialogues, called CoA (Chain of Attack).
CoA is a semantic-driven contextual multi-turn attack method that adaptively
adjusts the attack policy through contextual feedback and semantic relevance
during multi-turn of dialogue with a large model, resulting in the model
producing unreasonable or harmful content. We evaluate CoA on different LLMs
and datasets, and show that it can effectively expose the vulnerabilities of
LLMs, and outperform existing attack methods. Our work provides a new
perspective and tool for attacking and defending LLMs, and contributes to the
security and ethical assessment of dialogue systems.
|
[
-0.3966754972934723,
-1.3148549795150757,
0.47244584560394287,
0.09808008372783661,
-0.17209312319755554,
0.35907280445098877,
0.08534654229879379,
-0.3785502314567566,
0.17523154616355896,
1.1721032857894897,
-0.7578096985816956,
-0.4553973972797394,
-0.770378828048706,
0.08589845150709152,
-0.6431483030319214,
1.0969887971878052,
0.3001951277256012,
0.18595436215400696,
0.027548527345061302,
-0.23259441554546356,
-0.5757041573524475,
-0.9596347212791443,
-0.5829294323921204,
0.14086972177028656,
0.7332331538200378,
0.0032151686027646065,
0.715156614780426,
-0.10190972685813904,
0.7448099255561829,
0.39657488465309143,
0.16324564814567566,
0.021292295306921005,
-0.5603365302085876,
0.4784815311431885,
-0.28368228673934937,
-0.3688873052597046,
-0.6865350604057312,
-0.1637783944606781,
0.47468453645706177,
0.44477522373199463,
-0.038172025233507156,
0.021632153540849686,
-0.15662211179733276,
0.7561846375465393,
-0.7143699526786804,
-0.4037257134914398,
-1.2777488231658936,
-0.17924617230892181,
-0.24227266013622284,
-0.39416611194610596,
-0.9415989518165588,
0.09061082452535629,
0.23350706696510315,
-0.34900498390197754,
-0.4978855848312378,
0.22349390387535095,
0.5187585353851318,
0.1882081925868988,
-0.530329167842865,
-0.647654116153717,
-0.4206002354621887,
0.8659135103225708,
-0.6493960022926331,
-0.021268116310238838,
0.009325264021754265,
0.2210325300693512,
-0.6981610059738159,
-0.6804509162902832,
-0.6836584210395813,
-0.11695333570241928,
0.05307857319712639,
-0.061496734619140625,
-0.43422946333885193,
0.11577872931957245,
0.193974107503891,
0.09470029175281525,
-0.21919438242912292,
0.13074293732643127,
-0.046983085572719574,
-0.07180680334568024,
0.6380268335342407,
0.28154051303863525,
0.604729413986206,
-0.23677773773670197,
-0.9597596526145935,
-0.08744484931230545,
-0.8027547597885132,
-0.19928039610385895,
0.4485248327255249,
0.27075091004371643,
-0.15793879330158234,
0.4914804995059967,
-0.13485418260097504,
0.921181857585907,
0.04147861897945404,
-0.33497726917266846,
-0.2952272593975067,
-0.21428100764751434,
-0.26683509349823,
0.22606268525123596,
1.1136139631271362,
0.5125276446342468,
0.08193111419677734,
0.06369364261627197,
-0.004867075942456722,
-0.17462918162345886,
0.5431758165359497,
-0.6161815524101257,
0.3311392366886139,
0.38556838035583496,
-0.027226200327277184,
-0.6492117643356323,
0.21464435756206512,
-1.0945067405700684,
-0.4503258764743805,
0.2841750681400299,
0.16366887092590332,
-0.3359115719795227,
-0.019642475992441177,
0.042680054903030396,
0.0820397436618805,
0.5028305649757385,
0.23091043531894684,
-0.4872986674308777,
0.537086546421051,
0.8151895403862,
0.8667774200439453,
-0.25190144777297974,
-0.1035606637597084,
-0.9898939728736877,
0.48723357915878296,
-0.24848395586013794,
0.5168481469154358,
-0.5465893745422363,
-0.49401670694351196,
0.09972994029521942,
-0.0796765461564064,
0.1312410831451416,
-0.07972085475921631,
0.4283071756362915,
-1.1094169616699219,
-0.05808732658624649,
0.026061464101076126,
-0.26945364475250244,
-0.19028441607952118,
0.539826512336731,
-0.8311319351196289,
0.6854010820388794,
-0.3572006821632385,
-1.0973399877548218,
-0.09635015577077866,
-0.6772813200950623,
-0.48033326864242554,
-0.21914973855018616,
-0.106489397585392,
-0.17037519812583923,
-0.05924268066883087,
0.2238336056470871,
0.44126027822494507,
-0.3680587112903595,
0.17416182160377502,
-0.6547189354896545,
0.14833831787109375,
0.799827516078949,
-0.665633499622345,
0.8710077404975891,
0.14147283136844635,
-0.1748458445072174,
0.44359487295150757,
-0.7469494938850403,
0.06520868092775345,
0.22798554599285126,
0.12440293282270432,
-0.6183772683143616,
0.18370679020881653,
-0.327814519405365,
0.38531431555747986,
0.3354814052581787,
-0.4849334955215454,
0.32321640849113464,
-0.46128299832344055,
0.4423254430294037,
0.8419031500816345,
0.4728315472602844,
0.2510584890842438,
-0.12737517058849335,
0.3480640649795532,
-0.07574208825826645,
0.39327991008758545,
-0.08088890463113785,
-0.3402754068374634,
-0.6440939903259277,
-0.23886743187904358,
-0.015927189961075783,
0.6446977257728577,
-0.9430927038192749,
0.3096170723438263,
-0.05504027381539345,
-0.4140705168247223,
-0.27245667576789856,
0.08768802881240845,
0.4236263632774353,
0.34330588579177856,
0.30986231565475464,
-0.37508293986320496,
-0.37379777431488037,
-0.6730166077613831,
-0.37255433201789856,
-0.22066323459148407,
-0.02245505340397358,
0.042617522180080414,
0.514336884021759,
-0.26497939229011536,
0.9820966720581055,
-0.661492645740509,
-0.24081723392009735,
-0.24948273599147797,
0.023434581235051155,
0.0040776957757771015,
0.2737938463687897,
0.25718793272972107,
-0.7186965942382812,
-0.3621021509170532,
-0.017254743725061417,
-0.7629157304763794,
0.02960800938308239,
-0.3629905581474304,
-0.3594319820404053,
0.1926220953464508,
0.5939306020736694,
-0.4153815507888794,
0.4911009967327118,
0.6162527799606323,
-0.18873752653598785,
0.5081896781921387,
0.10656171292066574,
-0.01648571714758873,
-1.059643268585205,
-0.188839852809906,
-0.3472018837928772,
-0.2553827464580536,
-0.985751211643219,
0.352580189704895,
-0.3498486876487732,
-0.11670473217964172,
-0.8247480392456055,
0.39991524815559387,
-0.08795405924320221,
-0.015183254145085812,
-0.23507016897201538,
0.2604304850101471,
0.06311067193746567,
0.46059098839759827,
-0.08925226330757141,
0.48318132758140564,
0.4833540618419647,
-0.5459356307983398,
0.5056362748146057,
0.1970861256122589,
-0.24249029159545898,
0.880556583404541,
-0.6448108553886414,
0.6943910121917725,
0.28050512075424194,
0.589202880859375,
-0.7719711661338806,
-0.1337440013885498,
0.2932574152946472,
-0.3145027458667755,
0.1503693163394928,
0.06649478524923325,
-0.414543092250824,
-0.06473547965288162,
-0.5319754481315613,
0.4425699710845947,
-0.07741972804069519,
-0.5452499985694885,
0.8846604228019714,
0.5062106847763062,
-0.18598628044128418,
-0.9288149476051331,
-0.43397483229637146,
0.48344093561172485,
-0.4853682816028595,
-0.7850927710533142,
0.22132013738155365,
0.01523592509329319,
-0.617455780506134,
-0.6604779958724976,
-0.03379954397678375,
-0.13067227602005005,
0.3339619040489197,
0.20608173310756683,
0.3554859757423401,
0.34411948919296265,
-0.35509032011032104,
-0.19382856786251068,
-0.12485052645206451,
0.4342130124568939,
-0.2268361896276474,
0.8447567224502563,
-0.22660787403583527,
-0.5916005969047546,
-0.5996857285499573,
0.5700763463973999,
0.8104581832885742,
-0.14934343099594116,
0.6265090703964233,
0.3436223864555359,
-0.0617937296628952,
-0.08640087395906448,
-0.5086841583251953,
-0.22966808080673218,
-0.5568816065788269,
0.5848034024238586,
-0.3820076286792755,
-0.9194055795669556,
0.3799545466899872,
-0.20928439497947693,
0.1158972755074501,
0.3127403259277344,
0.5907076001167297,
-0.01675235480070114,
0.9172553420066833,
0.3442476987838745,
-0.4322899281978607,
0.1916961669921875,
-0.01782354712486267,
0.34762147068977356,
-1.0026696920394897,
-0.3279176354408264,
-0.379153847694397,
0.08424719423055649,
-0.7017163038253784,
-0.2920801043510437,
0.4983446002006531,
0.07878053188323975,
-0.18434889614582062,
0.2943560779094696,
-0.16712027788162231,
0.19228670001029968,
0.20892909169197083,
-0.004786827135831118,
0.5185530185699463,
-0.21399769186973572,
-0.2105250060558319,
0.28978705406188965,
-0.6623844504356384,
-0.6128854751586914,
1.0420304536819458,
0.44696682691574097,
1.0214900970458984,
0.38160303235054016,
0.36352184414863586,
0.4775926470756531,
0.06757253408432007,
-0.6712837815284729,
0.6776000261306763,
0.2141398787498474,
-0.5581597089767456,
-0.3780750334262848,
-0.22917760908603668,
-0.8962723016738892,
0.35400885343551636,
-0.15877526998519897,
-0.9160585999488831,
-0.1578267514705658,
-0.16794312000274658,
-0.2492985725402832,
0.5388023853302002,
-0.47004663944244385,
0.5169594287872314,
-0.5909005403518677,
-0.4399610459804535,
-0.2823624014854431,
-0.8791408538818359,
0.4754360318183899,
-0.23413720726966858,
0.5748364925384521,
0.09668831527233124,
0.04173310846090317,
0.6778953075408936,
-0.7346813678741455,
1.3073707818984985,
0.03958112373948097,
-0.30190011858940125,
0.4579736888408661,
0.3714851140975952,
0.7414112687110901,
0.2817983031272888,
0.10885041207075119,
0.36513635516166687,
0.01230797078460455,
-0.42322802543640137,
-0.7427307963371277,
0.7545434832572937,
-0.5022830963134766,
-1.0514039993286133,
-0.6505250930786133,
-0.543044924736023,
-0.24437730014324188,
0.06412940472364426,
-0.09465111792087555,
0.4289902150630951,
-0.42519211769104004,
0.02502300776541233,
0.48848122358322144,
-0.3985123932361603,
0.5783523321151733,
0.45195189118385315,
-0.2179540991783142,
-0.600954532623291,
0.8747803568840027,
-0.31772345304489136,
1.0270898342132568,
0.44083544611930847,
0.014982763677835464,
-0.08889273554086685,
-0.21747274696826935,
-0.3300260603427887,
-0.2042541652917862,
-0.7025685906410217,
-0.35466402769088745,
-0.5853813290596008,
-0.13730855286121368,
-0.19695064425468445,
-0.1681591123342514,
-0.3403974771499634,
-0.1284043788909912,
0.22074060142040253,
0.07856617867946625,
0.5671336054801941,
0.8208719491958618,
0.5329986810684204,
0.5763469338417053,
-0.5321973562240601,
0.05865588039159775,
0.4290558695793152,
-0.012211567722260952,
0.08264090120792389,
-0.14347270131111145,
0.15500102937221527,
-0.08357606828212738,
-0.5921919941902161,
-1.1386021375656128,
0.2982427477836609,
-0.13166722655296326,
0.07764499634504318,
0.49084576964378357,
0.29833635687828064,
0.44818705320358276,
-0.6680743098258972,
0.7967371344566345,
0.5110510587692261,
-1.1477806568145752,
0.45737510919570923,
-0.14946244657039642,
0.3082905113697052,
0.4811166226863861,
0.37289807200431824,
-0.5398680567741394,
-0.4740847647190094,
-0.6186962723731995,
-0.8554370999336243,
0.4279811978340149,
0.10399974882602692,
0.1650877445936203,
-0.15935100615024567,
0.04935885965824127,
-0.12425107508897781,
0.411949098110199,
-0.9091689586639404,
-0.27002066373825073,
-0.08756453543901443,
0.09481664001941681,
0.5842576026916504,
-0.23726041615009308,
-0.46912410855293274,
0.0642920434474945,
0.6531158685684204,
-0.23013538122177124,
0.061093155294656754,
0.326007604598999,
-0.2887205481529236,
0.33016762137413025,
0.48669934272766113,
0.6271893382072449,
0.4119991958141327,
0.04316889867186546,
0.25687551498413086,
0.5783915519714355,
-0.4435499310493469,
0.17962835729122162,
-0.5551174879074097,
-0.08520917594432831,
-0.3232745826244354,
0.7815101742744446,
0.8503731489181519,
0.42534351348876953,
-0.7206357717514038,
0.6377418637275696,
-0.07328694313764572,
0.1830427348613739,
-0.4025181829929352,
-0.09004902839660645,
-0.24359965324401855,
0.020122142508625984,
0.2827214002609253,
-0.0849427580833435,
-0.024507908150553703,
-0.7060969471931458,
0.29284387826919556,
0.8534563183784485,
-0.7356804609298706,
-0.09960641711950302,
0.059119950979948044,
0.23936080932617188,
-0.3509731590747833,
0.3616904616355896,
0.12939956784248352,
-0.866150438785553,
0.2581366300582886,
0.6046633124351501,
0.6623353362083435,
-0.342177152633667,
0.03234666585922241,
-0.11802267283201218,
0.4313609302043915,
0.46915146708488464,
-0.03722350671887398,
0.15001678466796875,
-0.739888608455658,
-0.44739338755607605,
-0.5104559659957886,
-0.5324471592903137,
0.20042863488197327,
-0.7897490859031677,
0.2826065719127655,
-0.9080983400344849,
-0.2025391012430191,
-0.1947266310453415,
-0.2728787660598755,
-0.14498168230056763,
0.03332458436489105,
-0.05633121356368065,
0.6470690369606018,
-0.14986427128314972,
0.8618783354759216,
0.062157511711120605,
-0.21223366260528564,
-0.25048550963401794,
0.07765555381774902,
0.2461351901292801,
-0.8405693769454956,
0.7478082180023193,
0.031171424314379692,
-0.5757575631141663,
-0.32203471660614014,
-0.46205151081085205,
-0.8043376803398132,
0.7863073348999023,
0.14488227665424347,
-0.6561199426651001,
0.11204221099615097,
0.449539452791214,
0.24542416632175446,
-0.6893733143806458,
0.2746437191963196,
0.6250470280647278,
0.430496484041214,
0.08968731760978699,
-0.5732386112213135,
0.1442420482635498,
0.08137242496013641,
-0.1409064531326294,
0.22375060617923737,
-0.744974672794342,
0.5787849426269531,
-0.06582459807395935,
-0.050741903483867645,
-0.04477157071232796,
0.7523989081382751,
0.2346869707107544,
0.0772463008761406,
0.7251036763191223,
0.21709375083446503,
0.7055142521858215,
0.004803513176739216,
1.2365823984146118,
-0.3494936525821686,
0.007119257003068924,
1.3197133541107178,
-0.6901984214782715,
1.026077151298523,
0.7754049301147461,
0.0668800100684166,
0.7921412587165833,
0.18414989113807678,
0.1221608966588974,
0.49495914578437805,
0.5294385552406311,
-0.4749268591403961,
-0.045366741716861725,
-0.029700782150030136,
-0.15389704704284668,
0.48502665758132935,
0.6531267762184143,
0.07015412300825119,
0.058974649757146835,
0.1914023756980896,
0.43236809968948364,
0.06890881806612015,
-0.25589296221733093,
0.9979227185249329,
0.262087345123291,
-0.3700704872608185,
0.4620186984539032,
0.1559406816959381,
0.5300887823104858,
-0.7914032340049744,
0.10646841675043106,
0.3796546757221222,
-0.024949070066213608,
-0.20482179522514343,
-0.4586918354034424,
0.2979801893234253,
0.185489222407341,
0.0026018882635980844,
0.1153511330485344,
0.5306726098060608,
-0.12575988471508026,
-0.5414519906044006,
0.8094924092292786,
0.0858549177646637,
-0.3240642845630646,
-0.03390379250049591,
-0.8068405389785767,
0.5435053706169128,
-0.08669827878475189,
-0.17125681042671204,
0.44097450375556946,
0.1880977898836136,
-0.35396134853363037,
0.8415362238883972,
0.8565235137939453,
-0.05399136245250702,
0.06262582540512085,
0.14979912340641022,
0.9370795488357544,
-0.6325086951255798,
-0.3371024429798126,
-1.314021110534668,
0.34332457184791565,
-0.577536940574646,
-0.16666032373905182,
0.7452362775802612,
0.2077115923166275,
0.7942035794258118,
0.39413151144981384,
0.7009709477424622,
0.10447177290916443,
0.16461388766765594,
-0.8864396214485168,
0.5862756371498108,
-0.13117429614067078,
0.6914359331130981,
-0.6940813064575195,
-0.5351783037185669,
-0.1950496882200241,
0.20695528388023376,
-0.5219464302062988,
-0.2391226887702942,
1.0869060754776,
0.6542225480079651,
0.4235922396183014,
0.18821316957473755,
0.12337152659893036,
0.537503719329834,
0.7018636465072632,
0.4257041811943054,
0.9142153859138489,
-0.42385220527648926,
0.4284771978855133,
0.02888011559844017,
-0.27589985728263855,
0.031117109581828117,
-0.9588322639465332,
-1.250666856765747,
-0.45976516604423523,
-0.08916180580854416,
-0.4876832962036133,
0.17558452486991882,
0.7601924538612366,
0.5040856003761292,
-0.6945403814315796,
-0.4556179642677307,
0.16140781342983246,
0.33455783128738403,
-0.060362108051776886,
-0.23942121863365173,
0.344303160905838,
-0.29313695430755615,
-0.454603910446167,
0.7089715600013733,
0.529702365398407,
-0.45595383644104004,
-0.5701640248298645,
-0.07511265575885773,
-0.7311568856239319,
0.4079676866531372,
0.7626916170120239,
-0.08195890486240387,
-1.0350528955459595,
-0.5028080344200134,
-0.23560835421085358,
0.070894755423069,
-0.06292574852705002,
0.9126258492469788,
-0.4016112685203552,
0.44861680269241333,
0.1324193924665451,
0.8388323187828064,
0.14055943489074707,
-0.0682155191898346,
0.8984078168869019,
-0.698336124420166,
0.3871981203556061,
0.07369814068078995,
0.22944150865077972,
0.20478962361812592,
-0.5458030104637146,
0.27626723051071167,
0.09891880303621292,
-0.15143030881881714,
-0.8673756718635559,
0.5807058811187744,
-1.2500736713409424,
-0.4367228150367737,
1.047655701637268,
-0.1381080597639084,
-0.5856460928916931,
-0.20085221529006958,
-0.35118117928504944,
-0.12674710154533386,
-0.4400072991847992,
0.5202199220657349,
0.7443081736564636,
0.18765051662921906,
0.5804843306541443,
-0.605213463306427,
0.4047237038612366,
0.3342443108558655,
-0.93233722448349,
0.15428192913532257,
0.15616334974765778,
0.06134919077157974,
0.28668537735939026,
0.20961810648441315,
-0.3973561227321625,
-0.0983051136136055,
-0.37604543566703796,
-0.12112576514482498,
0.169969841837883,
-0.4558109939098358,
-0.16825392842292786,
0.5320864319801331,
-0.14563745260238647,
0.12751641869544983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06706v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06706v1
|
Exploring the Capabilities of Large Multimodal Models on Dense Text
| 2024-05-09T07:47:25 | 2024-05-09T07:47:25 |
Shuo Zhang, Biao Yang, Zhang Li, Zhiyin Ma, Yuliang Liu, Xiang Bai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While large multi-modal models (LMM) have shown notable progress in
multi-modal tasks, their capabilities in tasks involving dense textual content
remains to be fully explored. Dense text, which carries important information,
is often found in documents, tables, and product descriptions. Understanding
dense text enables us to obtain more accurate information, assisting in making
better decisions. To further explore the capabilities of LMM in complex text
tasks, we propose the DT-VQA dataset, with 170k question-answer pairs. In this
paper, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of GPT4V, Gemini, and various
open-source LMMs on our dataset, revealing their strengths and weaknesses.
Furthermore, we evaluate the effectiveness of two strategies for LMM: prompt
engineering and downstream fine-tuning. We find that even with automatically
labeled training datasets, significant improvements in model performance can be
achieved. We hope that this research will promote the study of LMM in dense
text tasks. Code will be released at
https://github.com/Yuliang-Liu/MultimodalOCR.
|
[
-0.34976866841316223,
-1.0556222200393677,
0.8425158262252808,
0.08391629159450531,
-0.25370579957962036,
-0.1413709670305252,
-0.46272167563438416,
-0.32503098249435425,
-0.25594326853752136,
0.3146440386772156,
-0.536888599395752,
-0.3729035556316376,
-0.5467219948768616,
0.12480966001749039,
-0.45828381180763245,
0.9308660626411438,
-0.19401338696479797,
0.08034342527389526,
-0.10106562823057175,
-0.013319333083927631,
-0.8228688836097717,
-0.40870001912117004,
-0.3429219722747803,
0.08859125524759293,
0.7960537075996399,
0.4029591381549835,
0.8289852142333984,
0.40547043085098267,
0.4180722236633301,
0.39830371737480164,
-0.04281364381313324,
0.3504047989845276,
-0.5471056699752808,
0.40505820512771606,
-0.009812839329242706,
-0.029458532109856606,
-0.32465410232543945,
-0.12622511386871338,
0.8180140852928162,
0.4482039511203766,
0.18588291108608246,
0.03825468569993973,
0.09702041745185852,
0.33933329582214355,
-0.4874415993690491,
0.14226725697517395,
-0.416016548871994,
-0.09128488600254059,
-0.1267165094614029,
-0.11955916881561279,
-0.32318902015686035,
0.012852344661951065,
0.2143084853887558,
-0.7495969533920288,
0.06020743399858475,
0.022236526012420654,
0.6872358918190002,
0.46155911684036255,
-0.9726195335388184,
-0.36195647716522217,
-1.075461745262146,
0.9970320463180542,
-0.48371070623397827,
0.5803477764129639,
0.2925442159175873,
0.32922616600990295,
0.1378408521413803,
-0.7016485929489136,
-0.6310136318206787,
-0.43872779607772827,
-0.05118886008858681,
0.17392674088478088,
0.051354024559259415,
0.11201202124357224,
0.33611777424812317,
0.31949400901794434,
-0.7319040298461914,
0.13947542011737823,
-0.30168184638023376,
-0.17573736608028412,
0.4352850317955017,
0.4038649797439575,
0.28023049235343933,
-0.3617672324180603,
-0.5192379951477051,
-0.13490474224090576,
0.12585414946079254,
0.05493529140949249,
-0.008829085156321526,
0.08373578637838364,
-0.1966475248336792,
1.0375926494598389,
-0.2369338721036911,
0.8045858144760132,
-0.20934799313545227,
-0.17328722774982452,
0.24816669523715973,
-0.9600854516029358,
-0.3254745602607727,
-0.22192694246768951,
0.828518271446228,
0.27663734555244446,
0.10719922930002213,
-0.07932300120592117,
-0.4260542690753937,
-0.23665934801101685,
0.3211997449398041,
-0.8943973183631897,
0.0605904720723629,
0.3635817766189575,
-0.5360761880874634,
-0.046260565519332886,
-0.24648286402225494,
-0.4762759208679199,
-0.45524275302886963,
-0.7550671696662903,
0.8954046368598938,
-0.5300446152687073,
-0.40504056215286255,
0.4159994423389435,
-0.31542500853538513,
0.05903305113315582,
0.48663339018821716,
-0.6673569083213806,
-0.16086561977863312,
0.5993209481239319,
0.8862943649291992,
-0.01977379433810711,
-0.1871432512998581,
-0.4454399645328522,
0.16934561729431152,
-0.08241487294435501,
0.5766670107841492,
-0.5642669200897217,
-0.2848535478115082,
-0.17031505703926086,
-0.07003478705883026,
-0.2199011892080307,
-0.25803202390670776,
0.9307132959365845,
-0.4832463562488556,
0.276990681886673,
-0.6381415724754333,
-0.3111160397529602,
-0.3098529279232025,
0.6537763476371765,
-1.0094568729400635,
0.9528825879096985,
0.0723256841301918,
-0.8597643971443176,
0.3097887933254242,
-0.4750553369522095,
-0.3155824542045593,
-0.11033028364181519,
-0.08241456747055054,
-0.30076897144317627,
0.15755939483642578,
0.3143339157104492,
0.7994152307510376,
-0.43656668066978455,
0.3810410797595978,
-0.260556697845459,
-0.2839055359363556,
0.5777962803840637,
-0.7285093069076538,
0.43780383467674255,
0.3099982440471649,
-0.2526663839817047,
0.39778345823287964,
-0.7553310990333557,
-0.09590086340904236,
-0.004530563484877348,
-0.5258694887161255,
-0.5034970641136169,
-0.17591318488121033,
0.6251145601272583,
0.3383406400680542,
0.19294074177742004,
-0.2524435520172119,
0.41011473536491394,
0.026132896542549133,
0.5320595502853394,
0.677604615688324,
-0.17383550107479095,
0.4198288023471832,
-0.3440096974372864,
0.5496642589569092,
0.13653208315372467,
0.24923627078533173,
-0.3740738332271576,
-0.4373411536216736,
-0.5964127779006958,
-0.5095588564872742,
0.35365238785743713,
0.3819478750228882,
-1.1977033615112305,
-0.08378618210554123,
-0.17240381240844727,
-0.47078728675842285,
-0.1785588413476944,
0.11314260959625244,
0.17718318104743958,
0.49921363592147827,
0.39533400535583496,
-0.08374929428100586,
-0.23500648140907288,
-0.9336240887641907,
-0.035626135766506195,
0.14158962666988373,
-0.11512915790081024,
0.45134860277175903,
0.5474084615707397,
-0.5713264346122742,
0.7845004200935364,
-0.4046320617198944,
-0.09302006661891937,
-0.21906130015850067,
0.3086506128311157,
0.01281335111707449,
0.2535442113876343,
0.4992501735687256,
-1.1358314752578735,
-0.26480287313461304,
-0.05146412551403046,
-0.7980296015739441,
0.08199378848075867,
-0.39119580388069153,
0.020839722827076912,
-0.07347501814365387,
0.3161860406398773,
-0.7955420017242432,
-0.07744710147380829,
0.6477867960929871,
-0.389209121465683,
0.5533007383346558,
-0.2633105516433716,
0.39989331364631653,
-1.243583083152771,
0.10369885712862015,
0.3838212788105011,
-0.20149129629135132,
-0.6682417988777161,
-0.058455150574445724,
0.2880776822566986,
-0.0008495275396853685,
-0.40959352254867554,
0.5109133124351501,
-0.4985809922218323,
-0.11737888306379318,
0.04057271406054497,
0.10255692154169083,
0.08150138705968857,
0.31176048517227173,
-0.07853920012712479,
0.7469809651374817,
0.368527352809906,
-0.5561155080795288,
0.42438486218452454,
0.09945656359195709,
-0.6556413769721985,
0.4565081000328064,
-0.8540593981742859,
-0.08896844834089279,
-0.3816828727722168,
0.0021922604646533728,
-1.135317087173462,
-0.34485965967178345,
0.14989705383777618,
-0.11356495320796967,
0.30210739374160767,
0.1678369790315628,
-0.6847459673881531,
-0.22631123661994934,
-0.3743528723716736,
0.6955825090408325,
0.000594297656789422,
-0.1918134242296219,
0.8825477361679077,
0.22380565106868744,
-0.21974192559719086,
-0.6009480357170105,
-0.5113283395767212,
0.1944546103477478,
-0.18899768590927124,
-0.8263325095176697,
0.26245659589767456,
-0.42626363039016724,
-0.22285489737987518,
-0.17080871760845184,
0.12028159946203232,
-0.228693425655365,
0.08361653238534927,
0.21670763194561005,
0.11099749058485031,
-0.1812879741191864,
0.48984411358833313,
0.06052945926785469,
-0.014810326509177685,
-0.13384048640727997,
-0.08388003706932068,
0.4952184855937958,
-0.06489037722349167,
-0.1529267132282257,
-0.3469693958759308,
0.2270968109369278,
0.6718259453773499,
-0.4243985712528229,
0.6096479892730713,
1.1065045595169067,
-0.27799561619758606,
-0.09910079091787338,
-0.5982716679573059,
-0.12710517644882202,
-0.5060344338417053,
0.6254002451896667,
-0.34694886207580566,
-1.0374141931533813,
0.18439489603042603,
-0.012980605475604534,
-0.04863419756293297,
0.4321373403072357,
0.798637866973877,
0.026524081826210022,
1.0908994674682617,
0.6483591794967651,
0.09174033999443054,
0.44867345690727234,
-0.18026620149612427,
-0.19567930698394775,
-0.5648009181022644,
-0.48842817544937134,
-0.5310029983520508,
-0.47658395767211914,
-0.23565149307250977,
-0.694889485836029,
0.6241257786750793,
-0.13595569133758545,
-0.2186000645160675,
0.0134953074157238,
-0.38136932253837585,
0.21650995314121246,
0.43137314915657043,
0.2428838461637497,
0.5640506744384766,
-0.14282484352588654,
0.003971590660512447,
-0.08318228274583817,
-0.6515055298805237,
-0.2970179617404938,
0.9992794394493103,
0.4635581076145172,
0.8927345871925354,
0.0770052969455719,
-0.019168518483638763,
0.26739752292633057,
-0.054335519671440125,
-0.9399484395980835,
0.4506133496761322,
0.006326057482510805,
-0.6701438426971436,
-0.34587907791137695,
-0.7809523344039917,
-0.7900747656822205,
0.20348289608955383,
-0.5390812158584595,
-0.007981184870004654,
0.03238801285624504,
-0.12072063982486725,
-0.3944554626941681,
0.011351064778864384,
-0.88173508644104,
1.0531102418899536,
-0.7157002687454224,
-0.30594268441200256,
-0.1573154777288437,
-0.4973802864551544,
0.5624991655349731,
-0.2981567680835724,
0.2553311884403229,
0.11726146191358566,
-0.41017115116119385,
0.5775337219238281,
0.016842711716890335,
0.6903623938560486,
0.0629027783870697,
-0.47085386514663696,
0.12140276283025742,
-0.12979236245155334,
0.24302557110786438,
0.32092681527137756,
0.00696571683511138,
-0.025970567017793655,
-0.07575908303260803,
-0.27444952726364136,
-0.4414401054382324,
0.8252211809158325,
-0.8836396336555481,
-0.0938982367515564,
-0.3075332045555115,
-0.8779072165489197,
-0.17776693403720856,
0.3472488522529602,
0.013925581239163876,
0.8280148506164551,
-0.12455785274505615,
0.5913257002830505,
0.8680574297904968,
-0.37021604180336,
0.5870339870452881,
0.3159917891025543,
-0.15384124219417572,
-0.36505720019340515,
0.7001640200614929,
0.315077543258667,
0.1239413395524025,
0.5132544636726379,
0.14897914230823517,
-0.36820748448371887,
-0.6254568099975586,
-0.6792511343955994,
-0.02617449313402176,
-0.4977433681488037,
-0.0935591608285904,
-1.016116976737976,
0.0590544119477272,
-0.09614615142345428,
0.08969010412693024,
-0.24131548404693604,
-0.46210363507270813,
-0.32662859559059143,
0.014529979787766933,
0.2830198407173157,
0.8747946619987488,
0.3313717544078827,
0.2171350121498108,
-0.9823919534683228,
0.6260597705841064,
0.6245999932289124,
0.26204004883766174,
-0.07550697028636932,
-0.2086336612701416,
-0.4995567798614502,
0.3020843267440796,
-0.18959666788578033,
-0.7224118709564209,
0.19553251564502716,
0.04197856783866882,
0.3416762351989746,
0.2558445930480957,
0.05533400550484657,
0.46208393573760986,
-0.19290664792060852,
0.8731803894042969,
-0.08450724184513092,
-0.8047833442687988,
0.14860232174396515,
-0.7495168447494507,
0.6845467686653137,
0.3358081579208374,
0.7380502223968506,
-0.39672550559043884,
0.04861576482653618,
-0.02691027522087097,
-0.8030452728271484,
0.4969083368778229,
0.29995572566986084,
0.18867294490337372,
0.30783671140670776,
0.3517225980758667,
0.11959443986415863,
0.4020690321922302,
-0.6979633569717407,
0.12076050043106079,
-0.2774750292301178,
-0.36616256833076477,
-0.2879304885864258,
-0.40912050008773804,
0.016174260526895523,
-0.10325457900762558,
0.34247398376464844,
-0.1857409030199051,
-0.1024576872587204,
0.2057611048221588,
-0.21841759979724884,
0.06388184428215027,
0.30251628160476685,
0.732001006603241,
0.5400532484054565,
-0.09083814918994904,
0.13989947736263275,
0.013589829206466675,
-0.5747109651565552,
-0.08039477467536926,
0.36082130670547485,
-0.09060753136873245,
-0.11502280086278915,
0.323353111743927,
0.6753924489021301,
0.3954503834247589,
-0.9938204884529114,
0.5398718118667603,
-0.385774165391922,
-0.20425651967525482,
-0.13343073427677155,
-0.128982812166214,
0.05397205054759979,
0.533113420009613,
0.38402241468429565,
0.06291373819112778,
0.31002897024154663,
-0.5920789837837219,
-0.009222806431353092,
0.5281594395637512,
-0.4421713352203369,
-0.2655990421772003,
0.7813632488250732,
0.1548081636428833,
0.3279619514942169,
0.5922873616218567,
0.09876494854688644,
-0.3356614410877228,
0.5110929608345032,
0.14147187769412994,
0.5937867164611816,
0.012494703754782677,
0.2534554600715637,
0.3011768162250519,
0.47942161560058594,
-0.2540682256221771,
0.3072309195995331,
-0.13088710606098175,
-0.5466688275337219,
-0.8065982460975647,
-0.41679346561431885,
-0.31720441579818726,
0.16363178193569183,
-0.22998784482479095,
0.4517817199230194,
-0.2710709571838379,
-0.32478249073028564,
0.033288899809122086,
-0.07860668748617172,
-0.7157357335090637,
0.3629353642463684,
0.18093374371528625,
0.6061658263206482,
-0.5239582657814026,
0.6601491570472717,
0.5866739153862,
-0.5216869115829468,
-0.6677407622337341,
-0.13887128233909607,
0.04689258337020874,
-0.4978306293487549,
0.5489892959594727,
0.37560686469078064,
0.025673864409327507,
-0.1366051733493805,
-0.5217390656471252,
-0.7630122900009155,
1.2716209888458252,
0.24958035349845886,
-0.6898247003555298,
-0.26892587542533875,
0.34935232996940613,
0.37042927742004395,
0.06954621523618698,
0.5943726301193237,
0.0952843576669693,
0.7816755771636963,
-0.049153733998537064,
-1.0464046001434326,
0.003690279321745038,
-0.24491780996322632,
-0.02288096398115158,
0.08316726237535477,
-0.7568776607513428,
1.087730050086975,
-0.061917927116155624,
-0.10448311269283295,
0.0598735548555851,
0.49329185485839844,
-0.12570156157016754,
0.3731054365634918,
0.5867373943328857,
0.5549384355545044,
0.5527181029319763,
-0.0515604205429554,
0.9974522590637207,
-0.020756976678967476,
0.3056797981262207,
0.8320611715316772,
-0.2181340605020523,
0.6527420878410339,
0.21936656534671783,
0.3973159193992615,
0.0806189477443695,
0.4937988817691803,
0.009332500398159027,
0.2490980625152588,
-0.10361940413713455,
-0.19776910543441772,
-0.4521329998970032,
-0.24662017822265625,
-0.4958246946334839,
0.5315578579902649,
0.24109138548374176,
-0.3569093346595764,
-0.0623052641749382,
0.37891829013824463,
-0.16501043736934662,
-0.13613073527812958,
-0.42209959030151367,
0.7489258646965027,
-0.025127889588475227,
-0.2947399318218231,
0.5267184972763062,
0.16750606894493103,
0.7774675488471985,
-0.6565352082252502,
0.08522733300924301,
0.061348140239715576,
0.16043829917907715,
-0.08790766447782516,
-0.8464035391807556,
0.017132049426436424,
-0.06833305954933167,
-0.33197441697120667,
-0.4236607253551483,
0.9142293930053711,
-0.4925423562526703,
-0.4651297628879547,
0.13675576448440552,
0.7209477424621582,
-0.36515572667121887,
-0.501032292842865,
-0.6135460734367371,
0.32162925601005554,
-0.1948184221982956,
-0.5913012623786926,
0.2678755223751068,
0.8494021892547607,
0.05373785272240639,
0.6746704578399658,
0.5779883861541748,
-0.5005092620849609,
-0.0038126243744045496,
0.049606211483478546,
1.0988824367523193,
-0.8312862515449524,
-0.1356734037399292,
-0.7051423192024231,
0.8532134890556335,
0.05769403651356697,
-0.4262791574001312,
1.0178776979446411,
0.7674546837806702,
0.7598161101341248,
-0.18988586962223053,
0.7920675873756409,
0.06118477135896683,
0.23305417597293854,
-0.6968454718589783,
0.6939099431037903,
-0.8572035431861877,
0.06789146363735199,
-0.3548862338066101,
-1.0474908351898193,
-0.18357080221176147,
0.13337762653827667,
-0.1341203898191452,
0.22857867181301117,
0.6091764569282532,
0.6462860107421875,
-0.27334558963775635,
0.10428673028945923,
0.32340550422668457,
0.46010175347328186,
0.33191925287246704,
0.48215505480766296,
1.0824620723724365,
-0.3961145877838135,
0.8148406744003296,
-0.11087621748447418,
-0.19926545023918152,
-0.17242132127285004,
-0.8261396884918213,
-1.0316531658172607,
-0.8523047566413879,
-0.02442764863371849,
-0.14877809584140778,
-0.2762488126754761,
0.7808647155761719,
0.6044105291366577,
-0.2550846040248871,
0.01785198412835598,
0.4125041961669922,
-0.09995052218437195,
-0.028472304344177246,
-0.14725518226623535,
0.06154707074165344,
-0.15268926322460175,
-0.7544596195220947,
0.48880594968795776,
0.15535125136375427,
0.11653119325637817,
-0.3320339620113373,
0.04635582119226456,
-0.15463918447494507,
0.0687546581029892,
0.9474583268165588,
-0.211027592420578,
-0.2705211937427521,
-0.15878115594387054,
0.36780238151550293,
-0.27283427119255066,
-0.2692221403121948,
0.9351326823234558,
-0.6921744346618652,
0.5852802395820618,
0.7336574196815491,
0.7697365283966064,
0.48628297448158264,
0.03718943148851395,
0.5117709040641785,
-0.5594850778579712,
0.07220146805047989,
0.26276087760925293,
0.27341634035110474,
0.3135840594768524,
-0.10867859423160553,
0.28991779685020447,
-0.07088899612426758,
-0.7797925472259521,
-0.5665798783302307,
0.16436423361301422,
-1.5075300931930542,
-0.48584696650505066,
1.3886252641677856,
0.496397465467453,
0.028349384665489197,
-0.268423855304718,
-0.7996590733528137,
0.19857999682426453,
-0.4298178553581238,
0.7106638550758362,
0.6708813905715942,
0.3834182024002075,
-0.2754894495010376,
-0.9717420339584351,
0.3656378984451294,
0.2952718138694763,
-0.81107097864151,
-0.17020969092845917,
0.8280407190322876,
0.03554393723607063,
-0.0016267136670649052,
0.4683246314525604,
0.13542765378952026,
0.10106239467859268,
-0.33159059286117554,
-0.27112460136413574,
-0.37607574462890625,
-0.419093519449234,
-0.3596278131008148,
0.3925647735595703,
-0.10898279398679733,
0.2450418621301651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05600v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05600v1
|
Can We Use Large Language Models to Fill Relevance Judgment Holes?
| 2024-05-09T07:39:19 | 2024-05-09T07:39:19 |
Zahra Abbasiantaeb, Chuan Meng, Leif Azzopardi, Mohammad Aliannejadi
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Incomplete relevance judgments limit the re-usability of test collections.
When new systems are compared against previous systems used to build the pool
of judged documents, they often do so at a disadvantage due to the ``holes'' in
test collection (i.e., pockets of un-assessed documents returned by the new
system). In this paper, we take initial steps towards extending existing test
collections by employing Large Language Models (LLM) to fill the holes by
leveraging and grounding the method using existing human judgments. We explore
this problem in the context of Conversational Search using TREC iKAT, where
information needs are highly dynamic and the responses (and, the results
retrieved) are much more varied (leaving bigger holes). While previous work has
shown that automatic judgments from LLMs result in highly correlated rankings,
we find substantially lower correlates when human plus automatic judgments are
used (regardless of LLM, one/two/few shot, or fine-tuned). We further find
that, depending on the LLM employed, new runs will be highly favored (or
penalized), and this effect is magnified proportionally to the size of the
holes. Instead, one should generate the LLM annotations on the whole document
pool to achieve more consistent rankings with human-generated labels. Future
work is required to prompt engineering and fine-tuning LLMs to reflect and
represent the human annotations, in order to ground and align the models, such
that they are more fit for purpose.
|
[
-0.5006335973739624,
-0.509553074836731,
0.886066198348999,
-0.33952611684799194,
-0.2719058096408844,
0.02151920646429062,
-0.3223196864128113,
-0.6402208805084229,
0.02830301597714424,
0.8687333464622498,
-0.08844778686761856,
-0.4263482391834259,
-0.5158945918083191,
-0.18857310712337494,
-0.4394296407699585,
0.6195945739746094,
0.11044564843177795,
-0.38310888409614563,
-0.2533397972583771,
-0.17653782665729523,
-0.8324175477027893,
-0.5886836051940918,
-0.21984659135341644,
-0.502728283405304,
0.514008641242981,
0.5716863870620728,
0.8889374732971191,
0.5181878805160522,
0.754572331905365,
0.2746424078941345,
-0.23617249727249146,
-0.05284612998366356,
-0.41181716322898865,
0.48516660928726196,
-0.2657848000526428,
-0.6260141730308533,
-0.2701045274734497,
0.2676825523376465,
0.5378928780555725,
0.9993864893913269,
-0.1178320050239563,
-0.030349677428603172,
0.10633645951747894,
0.48139163851737976,
-0.6499767899513245,
0.031730230897665024,
-0.8169426321983337,
0.05389588326215744,
-0.18553677201271057,
-0.287810742855072,
-0.644158124923706,
-0.19154565036296844,
0.49890998005867004,
-0.3895077705383301,
0.30664268136024475,
0.2897926867008209,
0.9601283669471741,
0.1703043133020401,
-0.45709124207496643,
-0.32212164998054504,
-0.6355254054069519,
0.8266941905021667,
-0.7035645842552185,
0.4246733486652374,
0.6356765627861023,
0.5538026094436646,
-0.3268854320049286,
-0.35912632942199707,
-0.1885397583246231,
-0.621651828289032,
-0.0848446786403656,
-0.0262626763433218,
0.34244096279144287,
0.09188771992921829,
0.43696466088294983,
0.5616308450698853,
-0.5033624768257141,
0.10844094306230545,
-0.242523193359375,
-0.21088844537734985,
0.6483700275421143,
0.021241197362542152,
0.29199081659317017,
-0.24675631523132324,
0.0026530208997428417,
-0.40100526809692383,
-0.8148919939994812,
-0.03308229520916939,
0.28080326318740845,
0.45046302676200867,
0.27842977643013,
0.8812748193740845,
-0.26399508118629456,
0.9965309500694275,
-0.08509716391563416,
0.0013396746944636106,
0.170791357755661,
-0.045123230665922165,
-0.269817590713501,
-0.06110572814941406,
0.5643740296363831,
0.15778377652168274,
0.34621503949165344,
-0.10985114425420761,
-0.3424127399921417,
0.060258496552705765,
0.4489496946334839,
-0.46181485056877136,
-0.1586018204689026,
0.03185379132628441,
-0.07435780018568039,
-0.373256653547287,
0.3156852722167969,
-0.6429405808448792,
-0.6695382595062256,
-0.34249788522720337,
0.4363836348056793,
-0.193821981549263,
-0.13911613821983337,
0.29461321234703064,
-0.13600222766399384,
0.18450108170509338,
0.4061275124549866,
-0.5904523134231567,
-0.08711668848991394,
0.5114122033119202,
0.6861322522163391,
0.26308557391166687,
-0.11748680472373962,
-0.6119996905326843,
0.13195577263832092,
-0.4091142416000366,
0.7767268419265747,
-0.9027860164642334,
-0.44268569350242615,
0.2570147216320038,
-0.2240556925535202,
0.26986971497535706,
-0.6193671226501465,
0.7369225025177002,
-0.8164507150650024,
0.3449360430240631,
-0.235770583152771,
-0.464113712310791,
-0.2716965973377228,
0.4133177101612091,
-0.7328793406486511,
1.1702123880386353,
0.27533552050590515,
-0.48490795493125916,
0.2423907369375229,
-0.5095826387405396,
-0.46925434470176697,
-0.041510362178087234,
-0.13622239232063293,
-0.28285905718803406,
0.1296081840991974,
0.059214066714048386,
0.4826609194278717,
-0.5019235014915466,
0.48674899339675903,
-0.4673587381839752,
-0.6755188703536987,
0.20848850905895233,
-0.10191719233989716,
0.43183186650276184,
0.1410885453224182,
-0.5261379480361938,
-0.3002828061580658,
-0.45910462737083435,
-0.06577704846858978,
-0.17976608872413635,
-0.6613277792930603,
-0.5625059604644775,
-0.11272210627794266,
-0.14902286231517792,
0.22851970791816711,
-0.14403392374515533,
-0.3052007853984833,
0.293729692697525,
-0.7400037050247192,
0.39288419485092163,
0.7871173620223999,
-0.19900721311569214,
0.5130465626716614,
-0.4861818253993988,
0.47743216156959534,
-0.00931667722761631,
-0.14257267117500305,
-0.40533536672592163,
-0.5850700736045837,
-1.0138214826583862,
0.09949415922164917,
0.6918010115623474,
0.37853023409843445,
-0.40508562326431274,
0.6897592544555664,
-0.4430995583534241,
-0.506624698638916,
-0.5019634366035461,
0.17154011130332947,
0.16142994165420532,
0.41073474287986755,
0.11506108194589615,
-0.5064308643341064,
-0.4818018674850464,
-0.7643162608146667,
-0.20988179743289948,
-0.38308781385421753,
-0.15211006999015808,
0.8858246207237244,
0.4514681100845337,
-0.1834152340888977,
0.9909383654594421,
-0.4252505302429199,
-0.4324185848236084,
0.0491836741566658,
0.08848672360181808,
0.29840412735939026,
0.2702408730983734,
0.33305811882019043,
-0.9146303534507751,
-0.23557424545288086,
0.10365079343318939,
-0.8718457818031311,
-0.21725168824195862,
0.04882742464542389,
-0.12456247210502625,
0.09777426719665527,
0.5246261358261108,
-0.7238789796829224,
0.45565715432167053,
0.4567849636077881,
-0.3845537304878235,
0.24052393436431885,
0.01690388098359108,
0.4783094525337219,
-0.8650049567222595,
0.05226922407746315,
0.003962394315749407,
-0.46110573410987854,
-0.15887543559074402,
0.4553651809692383,
-0.046618640422821045,
-0.315176397562027,
-0.3437608480453491,
0.8321651220321655,
-0.5769396424293518,
-0.19985909759998322,
-0.19987273216247559,
0.560788094997406,
0.22380360960960388,
0.2759879529476166,
-0.3512970209121704,
0.770976722240448,
0.34885865449905396,
-0.8045526742935181,
0.14193737506866455,
0.2788873016834259,
-0.5089432597160339,
0.2952314615249634,
-0.543209433555603,
0.17753005027770996,
0.04015573859214783,
0.29274782538414,
-1.1665782928466797,
-0.48824936151504517,
-0.13421602547168732,
-0.5050988793373108,
0.4143683910369873,
-0.2637990713119507,
-0.44585517048835754,
-0.5374396443367004,
-0.29972749948501587,
0.5416883826255798,
0.6637153029441833,
-0.6428176760673523,
0.6596500873565674,
0.5412522554397583,
-0.11954159289598465,
-0.5729045271873474,
-0.7217290997505188,
0.44094234704971313,
-0.21142816543579102,
-0.8686919808387756,
0.28185635805130005,
0.03389497846364975,
-0.23555751144886017,
-0.18391115963459015,
-0.028434522449970245,
0.1792801469564438,
0.3248264491558075,
0.44125327467918396,
0.17452311515808105,
-0.2968268096446991,
0.51211017370224,
-0.3074393570423126,
-0.03650173172354698,
-0.1660967469215393,
-0.26392149925231934,
0.5854105949401855,
-0.06331142783164978,
-0.7061207890510559,
-0.1534741222858429,
0.28350508213043213,
0.8404589295387268,
-0.13097238540649414,
0.3263257145881653,
0.07012693583965302,
-0.4776022732257843,
0.30297961831092834,
-1.278214454650879,
-0.2850249409675598,
-0.4449656009674072,
0.1477312296628952,
-0.4160507619380951,
-1.2969655990600586,
0.51576828956604,
0.03484289348125458,
0.06899958103895187,
0.5763580799102783,
0.47661373019218445,
-0.33709660172462463,
1.0147271156311035,
0.5987191200256348,
-0.23866240680217743,
0.5144152045249939,
-0.14849987626075745,
0.2577880322933197,
-1.1578445434570312,
0.2279742956161499,
-0.6076365113258362,
-0.3167984187602997,
-0.6570347547531128,
-0.4455740749835968,
0.28577178716659546,
0.1284599006175995,
-0.1334538608789444,
0.23149767518043518,
-0.4757574498653412,
0.6221262216567993,
0.5881540775299072,
0.21256479620933533,
0.298508882522583,
-0.1302308440208435,
-0.386042982339859,
0.02080480195581913,
-0.5265443921089172,
-0.6706637144088745,
1.3392547369003296,
0.21234562993049622,
0.6363753080368042,
0.103169284760952,
0.5440654754638672,
0.483317494392395,
0.580909013748169,
-0.6762641072273254,
0.510002851486206,
0.08090762794017792,
-0.6655588150024414,
-0.3971708416938782,
-0.39001649618148804,
-1.1860138177871704,
0.3946056067943573,
-0.05343626067042351,
-0.6332319378852844,
-0.0034784660674631596,
0.04890002682805061,
-0.38965243101119995,
0.26485392451286316,
-0.787254810333252,
0.601794958114624,
-0.07915489375591278,
-0.3593840003013611,
-0.08396027982234955,
-0.5339891910552979,
0.5860697627067566,
-0.1150219738483429,
0.1129661500453949,
-0.09902379661798477,
0.2889801263809204,
0.6732643842697144,
-0.351097047328949,
0.7724893689155579,
-0.06921720504760742,
-0.09692519158124924,
0.39034974575042725,
0.18228301405906677,
0.6084948182106018,
0.08374600112438202,
-0.3742934763431549,
-0.1534900814294815,
-0.4999803304672241,
-0.3486201763153076,
-0.5314589738845825,
0.780656635761261,
-0.5558792948722839,
-1.152195930480957,
-0.5873207449913025,
-0.5451675653457642,
-0.26833200454711914,
0.2641602158546448,
-0.10910376161336899,
0.27401262521743774,
-0.08784136176109314,
0.3901039958000183,
0.7979289293289185,
-0.2484995573759079,
0.13191695511341095,
0.4099903404712677,
-0.17603182792663574,
-0.06719162315130234,
0.49541452527046204,
0.03985463082790375,
0.07932031899690628,
0.3067561388015747,
0.30252328515052795,
-0.38921838998794556,
-0.580984890460968,
-0.1097867488861084,
0.32465434074401855,
-0.6928990483283997,
-0.37289753556251526,
-0.7375751733779907,
-0.16156479716300964,
-0.562076210975647,
-0.23729710280895233,
-0.09035467356443405,
-0.2360544353723526,
-0.09680196642875671,
-0.007308056578040123,
0.29031506180763245,
0.5739530324935913,
0.18298004567623138,
0.3080947995185852,
-0.8443156480789185,
0.2984767556190491,
0.548531174659729,
0.4926376938819885,
-0.013644742779433727,
-0.9843835830688477,
-0.13430531322956085,
0.09199432283639908,
-0.42170462012290955,
-0.5988146662712097,
0.21369466185569763,
-0.04986341670155525,
0.40940287709236145,
0.08324483782052994,
0.04839269071817398,
0.822040319442749,
-0.46595507860183716,
0.6645626425743103,
-0.06680181622505188,
-0.6613203883171082,
0.7435524463653564,
-0.5724493861198425,
0.3002150356769562,
0.8177841901779175,
-0.12922023236751556,
-0.6774216294288635,
-0.6564823389053345,
-0.6777874231338501,
-0.8484653234481812,
0.6543446779251099,
0.21393461525440216,
0.28388696908950806,
0.0333823636174202,
0.6169154047966003,
-0.1191733255982399,
0.10936283320188522,
-0.5804691910743713,
0.13056915998458862,
0.15960873663425446,
-0.04593537002801895,
-0.13324667513370514,
-0.43765148520469666,
-0.04680442065000534,
-0.08867602050304413,
0.6887743473052979,
-0.08263277262449265,
0.13070885837078094,
0.28430888056755066,
-0.3540753424167633,
-0.1722819209098816,
0.33705946803092957,
0.4061141014099121,
0.5715232491493225,
-0.42306584119796753,
0.06300617754459381,
-0.011400552466511726,
-0.3759038746356964,
0.2727416455745697,
0.00514176907017827,
-0.17527726292610168,
-0.09441084414720535,
0.2110338807106018,
0.5355589985847473,
0.5013050436973572,
-0.8051693439483643,
0.5310059785842896,
-0.0671824961900711,
-0.03814743831753731,
-0.3746301233768463,
0.19116270542144775,
0.05357363075017929,
0.31179964542388916,
0.21174122393131256,
-0.016914281994104385,
0.2081618309020996,
-0.6966981291770935,
0.31205353140830994,
0.49414607882499695,
-0.5346887707710266,
0.02184114418923855,
0.5316663384437561,
0.37929919362068176,
-0.5577594041824341,
0.8359629511833191,
-0.11220340430736542,
-0.6479461789131165,
0.48340314626693726,
0.20558753609657288,
0.7423443794250488,
-0.23625262081623077,
0.0026744103524833918,
0.29138824343681335,
0.32473090291023254,
-0.4620456397533417,
-0.1586030125617981,
0.06094441935420036,
-0.6172477602958679,
-0.4379233419895172,
-0.6048498749732971,
-0.5180214643478394,
0.21469227969646454,
-0.37134668231010437,
0.5110965967178345,
-0.2541992962360382,
-0.26489052176475525,
-0.13729174435138702,
0.13260456919670105,
-0.8043089509010315,
0.2758166790008545,
0.15205779671669006,
0.7862197160720825,
-0.6334900259971619,
0.5507014393806458,
0.6940650939941406,
-0.4218031167984009,
-0.5568848848342896,
0.019289754331111908,
-0.12098857015371323,
-0.6952218413352966,
0.4435853660106659,
0.4532296359539032,
0.12066593021154404,
-0.16776959598064423,
-0.3176294267177582,
-1.0095345973968506,
1.0943782329559326,
0.48195260763168335,
-0.6511275768280029,
-0.11158955842256546,
0.08108694106340408,
0.49886998534202576,
-0.26534774899482727,
0.47479677200317383,
0.6709218621253967,
0.5660443902015686,
0.16117456555366516,
-0.9051790237426758,
0.03045152872800827,
-0.2289423942565918,
-0.07841341197490692,
0.4362115263938904,
-0.494673490524292,
0.706031084060669,
-0.1813446283340454,
-0.1882193684577942,
0.18953783810138702,
0.352384477853775,
0.5386608839035034,
0.15883652865886688,
0.7151625156402588,
0.7793262600898743,
0.8666755557060242,
-0.18626588582992554,
1.2805720567703247,
-0.07674659043550491,
0.5010455846786499,
1.154691219329834,
-0.5421268343925476,
0.7994990348815918,
0.5101153254508972,
-0.11700419336557388,
0.41842785477638245,
0.7983081936836243,
0.061007801443338394,
0.1331445872783661,
0.4706079959869385,
0.043491180986166,
-0.6442515254020691,
-0.36836424469947815,
-0.40119636058807373,
0.4895153045654297,
0.2137773633003235,
-0.37282615900039673,
-0.16063283383846283,
-0.18137219548225403,
-0.374312162399292,
0.1364218294620514,
0.13627827167510986,
0.5640895366668701,
0.13236373662948608,
-0.8958234190940857,
0.4201156198978424,
0.011829720810055733,
0.578873872756958,
-0.24994738399982452,
-0.20950432121753693,
-0.2285805642604828,
-0.08872134983539581,
0.07857127487659454,
-0.854347288608551,
-0.0046844021417200565,
-0.13611817359924316,
-0.24224762618541718,
-0.09608136862516403,
0.8950696587562561,
-0.3068755865097046,
-0.600982666015625,
0.31087779998779297,
0.6071309447288513,
0.20279964804649353,
-0.40497609972953796,
-0.4881282448768616,
-0.16552309691905975,
-0.11411219090223312,
-0.4867105484008789,
0.3737056255340576,
0.37226709723472595,
-0.28077608346939087,
0.7492478489875793,
0.7790624499320984,
-0.058634333312511444,
-0.09904957562685013,
0.3695482015609741,
0.8839768171310425,
-0.9917595982551575,
-0.4974782168865204,
-0.7386986017227173,
0.3913189470767975,
-0.13621240854263306,
-0.07081455737352371,
0.3471601605415344,
0.45204290747642517,
0.7656842470169067,
0.24670030176639557,
0.8455353379249573,
0.21120920777320862,
0.5856334567070007,
-0.5339368581771851,
0.6698828935623169,
-0.708369255065918,
0.5458055138587952,
-0.29560622572898865,
-1.1566126346588135,
-0.42672044038772583,
0.583491325378418,
-0.22161920368671417,
0.3134872615337372,
0.5956969261169434,
0.8009930849075317,
-0.21708156168460846,
-0.15422752499580383,
0.6854105591773987,
0.2434946894645691,
0.5403809547424316,
0.7540538311004639,
1.0018017292022705,
-0.7494555115699768,
0.6150535345077515,
0.08442848175764084,
-0.14591073989868164,
-0.6714256405830383,
-0.7819352746009827,
-1.0314944982528687,
-0.5057764053344727,
-0.18128015100955963,
-0.2757991850376129,
-0.03154406696557999,
0.5886292457580566,
0.7416536808013916,
-0.6708659529685974,
-0.13153724372386932,
0.034643158316612244,
0.3329157531261444,
0.33821791410446167,
-0.26472729444503784,
0.20363837480545044,
-0.438265323638916,
-0.6165737509727478,
0.21562178432941437,
0.33320629596710205,
0.13631495833396912,
-0.38075509667396545,
0.04886351898312569,
-0.41671571135520935,
-0.01133066974580288,
0.5381604433059692,
0.09846772253513336,
-0.9781631231307983,
-0.7098824381828308,
0.07676555216312408,
-0.2800511419773102,
0.26267772912979126,
0.9714998006820679,
-1.1077479124069214,
0.5818411707878113,
0.5185434818267822,
0.8802982568740845,
0.46386265754699707,
-0.1341453343629837,
0.7820648550987244,
-0.7292128205299377,
-0.007697124034166336,
0.4574327766895294,
0.5926055908203125,
0.5864484310150146,
-0.41815707087516785,
0.8086850047111511,
0.12096650898456573,
-0.5977827310562134,
-1.2072484493255615,
0.15713869035243988,
-0.9306127429008484,
0.012653752230107784,
1.291791319847107,
0.03975268080830574,
-0.1069074496626854,
-0.21605601906776428,
-0.26022008061408997,
0.22461220622062683,
-0.3255724608898163,
1.2101161479949951,
1.1658488512039185,
0.17378278076648712,
0.022880919277668,
-0.6802210807800293,
0.12334001064300537,
0.6973199844360352,
-0.653919517993927,
0.16278061270713806,
0.3196491003036499,
0.031317997723817825,
0.4906608462333679,
0.5123090744018555,
-0.1832757443189621,
0.40364107489585876,
-0.46557289361953735,
0.047039758414030075,
0.1819888800382614,
-0.2931320071220398,
-0.2183607816696167,
0.09627179056406021,
0.44476214051246643,
0.20781771838665009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06705v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06705v1
|
LLMs can Find Mathematical Reasoning Mistakes by Pedagogical Chain-of-Thought
| 2024-05-09T07:37:34 | 2024-05-09T07:37:34 |
Zhuoxuan Jiang, Haoyuan Peng, Shanshan Feng, Fan Li, Dongsheng Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Self-correction is emerging as a promising approach to mitigate the issue of
hallucination in Large Language Models (LLMs). To facilitate effective
self-correction, recent research has proposed mistake detection as its initial
step. However, current literature suggests that LLMs often struggle with
reliably identifying reasoning mistakes when using simplistic prompting
strategies. To address this challenge, we introduce a unique prompting
strategy, termed the Pedagogical Chain-of-Thought (PedCoT), which is
specifically designed to guide the identification of reasoning mistakes,
particularly mathematical reasoning mistakes. PedCoT consists of pedagogical
principles for prompts (PPP) design, two-stage interaction process (TIP) and
grounded PedCoT prompts, all inspired by the educational theory of the Bloom
Cognitive Model (BCM). We evaluate our approach on two public datasets
featuring math problems of varying difficulty levels. The experiments
demonstrate that our zero-shot prompting strategy significantly outperforms
strong baselines. The proposed method can achieve the goal of reliable
mathematical mistake identification and provide a foundation for automatic math
answer grading. The results underscore the significance of educational theory,
serving as domain knowledge, in guiding prompting strategy design for
addressing challenging tasks with LLMs effectively.
|
[
-0.25676074624061584,
-1.2399612665176392,
0.8350076675415039,
0.4473303258419037,
-0.11950311809778214,
0.027383964508771896,
-0.073961541056633,
0.28402137756347656,
0.004933143965899944,
0.30158698558807373,
-1.027700424194336,
-0.35407301783561707,
-0.21909628808498383,
0.07978542149066925,
-0.20616275072097778,
0.7721459865570068,
-0.2891278564929962,
0.030186213552951813,
-0.27310460805892944,
0.45081374049186707,
-0.9672960042953491,
-0.6068170070648193,
-0.7995164394378662,
-0.2760148346424103,
0.7980924248695374,
0.5639843344688416,
0.37424206733703613,
0.49819979071617126,
0.3513748049736023,
0.17160867154598236,
-0.14842240512371063,
0.46244409680366516,
-0.3548734486103058,
0.10608844459056854,
-0.41296279430389404,
-0.5299707651138306,
-0.5250622630119324,
-0.1149611547589302,
0.2203904390335083,
0.7696303129196167,
-0.48630398511886597,
-0.10138700902462006,
0.1127481609582901,
0.7270309925079346,
-0.6250135898590088,
0.15500055253505707,
-0.6629500389099121,
0.23078040778636932,
-0.18943749368190765,
-0.3938615918159485,
-0.6592645049095154,
-0.25283515453338623,
-0.15659430623054504,
-0.4249420464038849,
0.18953272700309753,
-0.24441947042942047,
0.27512326836586,
0.3839351534843445,
-0.004210388753563166,
-0.51947420835495,
-0.49911749362945557,
0.6840535402297974,
-0.39624571800231934,
-0.09624496102333069,
0.4485306739807129,
0.18979747593402863,
-0.33052003383636475,
-0.19791796803474426,
-0.649542510509491,
0.3567061722278595,
0.2031446099281311,
0.03514097258448601,
-0.10679003596305847,
-0.1640653908252716,
0.41823387145996094,
0.009706102311611176,
-0.375447154045105,
0.0060210698284208775,
-0.1484656035900116,
-0.24777543544769287,
0.4509369432926178,
0.1928892284631729,
0.30852100253105164,
-0.07758155465126038,
-0.2020331174135208,
-0.17113712430000305,
-0.9828084111213684,
-0.058757178485393524,
0.4212278723716736,
0.21510756015777588,
0.14843998849391937,
0.4048267900943756,
0.13921652734279633,
0.7542561292648315,
0.37177813053131104,
-0.060801878571510315,
-0.11107621341943741,
-0.08474855870008469,
-0.0975218340754509,
0.3382079601287842,
0.43273577094078064,
0.13294915854930878,
0.5076444745063782,
0.25737661123275757,
-0.337249219417572,
0.3189287483692169,
0.2278204709291458,
-0.2552226185798645,
-0.7738442420959473,
0.032791439443826675,
0.2440519630908966,
-0.3680371642112732,
-0.23298873007297516,
-0.7450935244560242,
-0.2671877145767212,
-0.3651774525642395,
0.7226790189743042,
-0.46094024181365967,
-0.0795026570558548,
0.317196249961853,
0.23800134658813477,
-0.09437832981348038,
0.7932546734809875,
-0.859235942363739,
0.03773859888315201,
0.7784451246261597,
0.7691903114318848,
-0.1285833716392517,
-0.41367200016975403,
-0.5024466514587402,
0.10753989219665527,
-0.6804405450820923,
1.158258318901062,
-0.24276724457740784,
-0.38751861453056335,
-0.19729791581630707,
-0.3535550832748413,
-0.08465132862329483,
-0.5919457077980042,
0.6228529214859009,
-0.24045005440711975,
0.1203632727265358,
-0.6238883137702942,
-0.6433406472206116,
-0.17790524661540985,
0.4053667485713959,
-0.26308611035346985,
0.7988445162773132,
-0.04862527176737785,
-0.6353486180305481,
0.1300077587366104,
-0.4745791256427765,
-0.32069265842437744,
0.09543561935424805,
-0.38315024971961975,
-0.5141757130622864,
0.10257565230131149,
0.6096763014793396,
0.2815192639827728,
-0.01939966157078743,
0.3199639916419983,
-0.08483000844717026,
-0.3162224590778351,
0.24081717431545258,
-0.6849650740623474,
0.8775468468666077,
-0.02365417778491974,
-0.4657270908355713,
-0.02163049206137657,
-0.6165297627449036,
0.24180187284946442,
0.4543103873729706,
0.03438248485326767,
-0.2668350636959076,
-0.0785013809800148,
-0.6529462933540344,
0.15028150379657745,
0.027364583685994148,
-0.1890280693769455,
0.384120374917984,
-0.08140596747398376,
0.3057393431663513,
1.2763899564743042,
0.12920823693275452,
0.005260176956653595,
-0.4449600875377655,
0.465069442987442,
0.22978779673576355,
0.14166474342346191,
-0.6577560305595398,
-0.39660343527793884,
-0.8772949576377869,
-0.17700393497943878,
0.04712863638997078,
0.5543486475944519,
-0.6662169098854065,
0.3995632529258728,
0.26271817088127136,
-0.42019787430763245,
-0.1871771514415741,
0.25688353180885315,
0.41011518239974976,
0.7762141823768616,
0.38982585072517395,
0.13577140867710114,
-0.3087809085845947,
-0.3916291296482086,
-0.47589054703712463,
-0.15923847258090973,
0.2794717252254486,
0.15143610537052155,
0.3689989745616913,
-0.08155781030654907,
0.8664517998695374,
-0.49805447459220886,
-0.19535905122756958,
0.14862321317195892,
0.23489399254322052,
0.28679952025413513,
0.45208239555358887,
0.26459428668022156,
-0.38136357069015503,
-0.44890183210372925,
-0.40619537234306335,
-0.7769981622695923,
-0.3581581711769104,
-0.11906410753726959,
-0.21854348480701447,
0.02104576863348484,
0.2697185277938843,
-0.47697338461875916,
0.4664119780063629,
0.12538963556289673,
-0.3259938061237335,
0.710801362991333,
-0.19774273037910461,
0.02820332907140255,
-0.42520734667778015,
-0.4273664653301239,
-0.22917744517326355,
0.14593704044818878,
-0.32314762473106384,
-0.2656192481517792,
0.24772979319095612,
0.06463518738746643,
-0.37225309014320374,
0.3935081660747528,
-0.38519778847694397,
0.2671671509742737,
-0.15212410688400269,
0.14113682508468628,
-0.11912386864423752,
0.4144118130207062,
-0.0630427673459053,
0.823279857635498,
0.6777450442314148,
-0.84763103723526,
0.5004419088363647,
0.16728812456130981,
-0.02681235410273075,
1.1215996742248535,
-0.48662707209587097,
0.4598728120326996,
-0.16808925569057465,
0.1594773381948471,
-1.0746902227401733,
-0.12316986173391342,
0.4031839072704315,
-0.3754861354827881,
0.1600213497877121,
-0.10916772484779358,
-0.39121612906455994,
-0.6179797649383545,
-0.10641203075647354,
0.6102268099784851,
0.3494642674922943,
-0.9912083745002747,
0.17656828463077545,
-0.08872417360544205,
-0.2203960418701172,
-0.6333577036857605,
-0.45376554131507874,
-0.12943625450134277,
-0.010959098115563393,
-0.6159645915031433,
0.12190991640090942,
-0.2940751016139984,
-0.29227712750434875,
-0.3026847839355469,
-0.3261725604534149,
0.16764821112155914,
0.03639497235417366,
0.04765566810965538,
0.4217155873775482,
0.0029218292329460382,
0.4128268361091614,
0.10145381838083267,
-0.3053850829601288,
0.39384639263153076,
-0.2827252745628357,
0.6260924935340881,
-0.07750091701745987,
-0.7189200520515442,
-0.4150782525539398,
-0.03066112846136093,
0.29929426312446594,
-0.029787760227918625,
0.15457378327846527,
0.058090656995773315,
-0.49277034401893616,
-0.5187609195709229,
-0.6244398355484009,
-0.5341417193412781,
-0.4226994514465332,
-0.06288192421197891,
-0.45042428374290466,
-0.3005754053592682,
0.24206288158893585,
-0.09837967157363892,
-0.1430763453245163,
0.17214596271514893,
0.5561678409576416,
-0.3874069154262543,
0.9397668242454529,
0.15099723637104034,
0.22187799215316772,
0.1736365109682083,
-0.2747730612754822,
0.489127516746521,
-0.7005167603492737,
-0.3013046085834503,
-0.26840952038764954,
-0.12610071897506714,
0.04934470355510712,
-0.5434036254882812,
0.3698942959308624,
0.3899332284927368,
-0.31050482392311096,
0.15283332765102386,
-0.6280045509338379,
0.6864936947822571,
0.4419461786746979,
0.12968334555625916,
0.3682461977005005,
0.2597947120666504,
-0.44097819924354553,
-0.2725294828414917,
-0.8384400606155396,
-0.42770296335220337,
0.8946517109870911,
0.08803161978721619,
1.123700499534607,
-0.04104766994714737,
0.9120174646377563,
0.12410563975572586,
0.2280348688364029,
-0.805404007434845,
0.5336102247238159,
0.5117954015731812,
-0.5078264474868774,
-0.34109237790107727,
-0.44318535923957825,
-0.7014174461364746,
0.008606591261923313,
0.16150802373886108,
-0.5082035660743713,
0.0877741277217865,
0.38525882363319397,
-0.43780001997947693,
0.36748364567756653,
-0.5355298519134521,
0.7584447264671326,
-0.4712604284286499,
-0.486373633146286,
-0.16155050694942474,
-0.10545273870229721,
0.32669082283973694,
-0.3799450099468231,
0.29819491505622864,
-0.12405519187450409,
0.1592101901769638,
0.38333192467689514,
-0.5984070301055908,
0.8001292943954468,
-0.07332000881433487,
-0.36265048384666443,
0.6071450710296631,
0.7178841233253479,
0.8063081502914429,
-0.07394326478242874,
0.17682711780071259,
0.05226495862007141,
-0.23180393874645233,
-0.3386356830596924,
-0.8258784413337708,
0.7666935324668884,
-0.5257995128631592,
-0.7636637687683105,
-0.722395122051239,
-0.48059210181236267,
-0.1402645856142044,
0.014950436539947987,
0.360251784324646,
0.1719835102558136,
0.2043866366147995,
-0.2308519333600998,
0.8891407251358032,
-0.04656362906098366,
0.5781269073486328,
0.46130606532096863,
-0.18979886174201965,
-0.36863642930984497,
0.895483672618866,
0.25023818016052246,
0.20191948115825653,
-0.025157218798995018,
0.3539230227470398,
-0.3648895025253296,
-0.24736714363098145,
-0.3116719722747803,
0.4045650064945221,
-0.9873171448707581,
-0.4043991267681122,
-0.5591089725494385,
-0.21644943952560425,
-0.1770608127117157,
-0.4453187584877014,
-0.3784823417663574,
-0.05765765532851219,
-0.37461191415786743,
-0.1856526881456375,
0.31397587060928345,
0.7147431373596191,
-0.32539084553718567,
0.19379086792469025,
-0.4047182500362396,
0.03373761102557182,
0.6449832320213318,
0.09854847937822342,
0.24554620683193207,
-0.5602300763130188,
0.2681633234024048,
0.10560755431652069,
-0.6190632581710815,
-0.9081112146377563,
0.3366917371749878,
-0.29304128885269165,
0.42961031198501587,
0.3389277160167694,
0.10552368313074112,
0.9492011070251465,
-0.5111979842185974,
0.5523372888565063,
0.5470207333564758,
-1.1902620792388916,
1.0829728841781616,
-0.27782848477363586,
0.16344799101352692,
0.009766021743416786,
0.24074174463748932,
-0.5859403014183044,
-0.0696709007024765,
-0.8305211067199707,
-0.3735799193382263,
0.538384199142456,
0.09883499145507812,
0.02856362983584404,
-0.463706910610199,
0.5267000198364258,
0.02035496197640896,
0.1209644004702568,
-0.6835424304008484,
-0.25760340690612793,
-0.06660681962966919,
-0.12663789093494415,
0.2069830298423767,
-0.2554021179676056,
-0.22858594357967377,
-0.22724361717700958,
0.662339448928833,
-0.3160417675971985,
0.1810159981250763,
0.5141015648841858,
-0.04043235257267952,
-0.5179799199104309,
0.27992337942123413,
0.6173238158226013,
1.1459455490112305,
0.12170873582363129,
0.3801725506782532,
0.19955146312713623,
-0.11246982961893082,
0.38350337743759155,
-0.43046537041664124,
-0.28457704186439514,
0.00963375624269247,
0.17608970403671265,
0.290688693523407,
0.16584548354148865,
-0.5778107047080994,
0.5130643248558044,
0.20608831942081451,
-0.1186276525259018,
-0.30548539757728577,
0.10467054694890976,
-0.00900079682469368,
0.06897623836994171,
0.4823583960533142,
0.02920711785554886,
-0.12527193129062653,
-0.5485019087791443,
0.27483630180358887,
0.2720480263233185,
-0.25226137042045593,
-0.21174341440200806,
0.49896085262298584,
-0.05377177521586418,
-0.7441187500953674,
0.6719399690628052,
-0.25072452425956726,
-0.7406111359596252,
0.5834231972694397,
0.7442435026168823,
0.5503147840499878,
-0.39990735054016113,
0.5710951685905457,
0.40324318408966064,
0.1311703324317932,
-0.3742459714412689,
0.3362046480178833,
-0.0504208467900753,
-0.747303307056427,
-0.4807034134864807,
-0.19290833175182343,
-0.4114719331264496,
-0.09643630683422089,
-0.5211473703384399,
0.47128334641456604,
-0.847957968711853,
-0.005451708100736141,
-0.05697312206029892,
-0.22851921617984772,
-0.35125917196273804,
0.16332411766052246,
0.2579646110534668,
0.523194432258606,
-0.6086611151695251,
0.5445408225059509,
0.39973145723342896,
-0.30176281929016113,
-1.0269912481307983,
-0.08040626347064972,
0.3225674033164978,
-1.0821914672851562,
0.7575758099555969,
-0.04285704717040062,
-0.18644791841506958,
0.09475314617156982,
-0.6169680953025818,
-0.4978141188621521,
0.9369488954544067,
0.3357045650482178,
-0.9318210482597351,
-0.07025904208421707,
-0.21420180797576904,
0.29941028356552124,
-0.17382527887821198,
0.1727718859910965,
0.3298916220664978,
0.40946099162101746,
0.461365669965744,
-0.7216285467147827,
0.0365569181740284,
0.2165052592754364,
-0.085401751101017,
0.37657660245895386,
-0.6192001104354858,
1.2417421340942383,
-0.6669257879257202,
-0.0026956824585795403,
-0.13470856845378876,
0.38120973110198975,
0.7070296406745911,
0.41478055715560913,
0.47165387868881226,
0.757723867893219,
1.0991240739822388,
-0.2659824788570404,
0.612245500087738,
0.09837375581264496,
0.5366735458374023,
1.060439944267273,
-0.10839065909385681,
0.6420065760612488,
0.6188157796859741,
-0.37073224782943726,
0.595371425151825,
0.806288480758667,
-0.041353803128004074,
0.4142157733440399,
0.4676114618778229,
-0.2066873013973236,
-0.4707501232624054,
0.18945887684822083,
-0.39845970273017883,
0.041031211614608765,
0.5175649523735046,
-0.060425449162721634,
-0.29412922263145447,
-0.057363834232091904,
0.19301702082157135,
0.36140531301498413,
-0.6672254204750061,
0.44610559940338135,
0.12843789160251617,
-0.9112086296081543,
0.6736695170402527,
-0.4434511959552765,
0.42158424854278564,
-0.17739617824554443,
-0.26602903008461,
-0.36491692066192627,
0.4347599446773529,
-0.21988700330257416,
-0.9426102042198181,
0.1693691909313202,
-0.13509996235370636,
-0.1787041574716568,
-0.2690649628639221,
0.43471184372901917,
-0.4425341784954071,
-0.5850602984428406,
0.16272304952144623,
0.5772351026535034,
0.07440026849508286,
-0.37191230058670044,
-0.8523063063621521,
0.19528831541538239,
-0.01425482053309679,
0.2563313841819763,
-0.040136951953172684,
0.8040425181388855,
0.09159393608570099,
0.7131425738334656,
0.7161615490913391,
-0.0023506798315793276,
0.07799958437681198,
0.1428963989019394,
0.519648015499115,
-0.794773519039154,
-0.44855761528015137,
-1.1188701391220093,
0.2170618176460266,
0.07904258370399475,
-0.25435903668403625,
0.7872434854507446,
0.17803439497947693,
0.9754707217216492,
-0.15437495708465576,
0.5869244933128357,
0.37049373984336853,
0.4740753173828125,
-0.5654718279838562,
0.11425227671861649,
-0.1864822655916214,
0.6304035782814026,
-0.45703747868537903,
-1.014804482460022,
-0.4028296172618866,
1.0491716861724854,
-0.5101924538612366,
0.03572581708431244,
1.027502179145813,
0.7294646501541138,
0.24631980061531067,
0.0715218335390091,
0.41737085580825806,
0.1842222958803177,
0.3734557032585144,
0.8506897687911987,
1.07534921169281,
-0.3915238678455353,
0.5422791838645935,
-0.32545024156570435,
-0.24838678538799286,
-0.41109755635261536,
-0.8408471941947937,
-1.012585163116455,
-0.18885304033756256,
-0.7068943381309509,
-0.5827761292457581,
0.13168205320835114,
0.9226737022399902,
0.3897124230861664,
-0.6665861010551453,
-0.09903707355260849,
-0.6109495759010315,
0.5114238262176514,
-0.505438506603241,
-0.21824532747268677,
0.3072650134563446,
-0.6598596572875977,
-0.5023887157440186,
0.23367875814437866,
0.6718496680259705,
0.2243524044752121,
-0.397300660610199,
-0.06747867912054062,
0.004424349404871464,
0.1323654055595398,
0.34727367758750916,
0.2101784497499466,
-1.0106064081192017,
-0.2524232566356659,
0.19504399597644806,
-0.06544312834739685,
0.17875659465789795,
1.0830236673355103,
-0.6481094360351562,
0.7065351009368896,
0.24131745100021362,
0.5140072107315063,
0.2998826503753662,
-0.2186782956123352,
0.4350723624229431,
-0.38285234570503235,
-0.19087933003902435,
0.4138100743293762,
0.21684981882572174,
0.32944580912590027,
-0.5701346397399902,
0.5440986752510071,
0.6851951479911804,
-0.5365634560585022,
-0.8698639869689941,
0.09790346026420593,
-0.601132333278656,
-0.20521491765975952,
0.8780005574226379,
-0.24466463923454285,
-0.43278324604034424,
0.05660071596503258,
-0.5795133113861084,
-0.15056653320789337,
-0.15739285945892334,
1.031168818473816,
1.1171914339065552,
-0.21562141180038452,
-0.49061933159828186,
0.05391045659780502,
0.401050329208374,
0.7880905866622925,
-0.6871631145477295,
0.18838831782341003,
0.37968316674232483,
0.20743972063064575,
0.2442854791879654,
0.5338475704193115,
-0.12077131867408752,
0.6193385720252991,
0.020447958260774612,
-0.22898037731647491,
0.06553585827350616,
-0.666642427444458,
-0.34083065390586853,
-0.11832405626773834,
-0.1163610965013504,
0.08920323103666306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05583v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05583v1
|
OpenFactCheck: A Unified Framework for Factuality Evaluation of LLMs
| 2024-05-09T07:15:19 | 2024-05-09T07:15:19 |
Yuxia Wang, Minghan Wang, Hasan Iqbal, Georgi Georgiev, Jiahui Geng, Preslav Nakov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The increased use of large language models (LLMs) across a variety of
real-world applications calls for mechanisms to verify the factual accuracy of
their outputs. Difficulties lie in assessing the factuality of free-form
responses in open domains. Also, different papers use disparate evaluation
benchmarks and measurements, which renders them hard to compare and hampers
future progress. To mitigate these issues, we propose OpenFactCheck, a unified
factuality evaluation framework for LLMs. OpenFactCheck consists of three
modules: (i) CUSTCHECKER allows users to easily customize an automatic
fact-checker and verify the factual correctness of documents and claims, (ii)
LLMEVAL, a unified evaluation framework assesses LLM's factuality ability from
various perspectives fairly, and (iii) CHECKEREVAL is an extensible solution
for gauging the reliability of automatic fact-checkers' verification results
using human-annotated datasets. OpenFactCheck is publicly released at
https://github.com/yuxiaw/OpenFactCheck.
|
[
-0.2249215692281723,
-0.7519959211349487,
0.6880676746368408,
0.04369532689452171,
-0.024311674758791924,
0.08162616938352585,
-0.12739117443561554,
-0.3693982660770416,
-0.09977979958057404,
0.5682269930839539,
-0.4248436987400055,
-0.6504802703857422,
-0.26217329502105713,
0.09720811247825623,
-0.5033605694770813,
0.9742512106895447,
-0.30613386631011963,
-0.1198127344250679,
-0.7695859670639038,
-0.37664562463760376,
-0.09855011105537415,
-0.3129127025604248,
-0.2320539802312851,
-0.6283230185508728,
0.35584545135498047,
0.3710067570209503,
0.7761569023132324,
0.2630635201931,
0.38888630270957947,
0.4035336971282959,
0.06699720770120621,
0.49247968196868896,
-0.5357899069786072,
0.0009092221152968705,
-0.4676479697227478,
-0.40711793303489685,
-0.4350651800632477,
0.30652400851249695,
0.5396047234535217,
0.3948781490325928,
-0.11414480209350586,
0.3720077574253082,
-0.1975301206111908,
0.49808692932128906,
-0.9375962018966675,
0.03819333016872406,
-0.3551064133644104,
-0.037857621908187866,
0.03758084401488304,
0.07988186180591583,
-0.3641495108604431,
-0.9279536604881287,
-0.13880322873592377,
-0.24201276898384094,
0.24080421030521393,
0.16431313753128052,
0.8619903326034546,
0.14541277289390564,
-0.5791856050491333,
-0.23266711831092834,
-0.6694347262382507,
0.39589276909828186,
-0.718758761882782,
0.5509398579597473,
0.31735432147979736,
0.2341538518667221,
-0.23607511818408966,
-0.5943639874458313,
-0.8390347957611084,
-0.581662118434906,
-0.31473904848098755,
0.08414888381958008,
-0.19039690494537354,
0.13001039624214172,
0.22406961023807526,
0.8501448631286621,
-0.691760778427124,
0.11179579794406891,
0.01198191661387682,
-0.6212550401687622,
0.39026615023612976,
0.07599863409996033,
0.3675053119659424,
0.1578109711408615,
-0.5243481993675232,
0.1624574363231659,
-0.6786044836044312,
-0.009045158512890339,
0.5665040016174316,
0.058660730719566345,
-0.11399522423744202,
0.8146657943725586,
-0.6186774969100952,
0.45081350207328796,
-0.18390583992004395,
-0.27668872475624084,
0.14300748705863953,
-0.4812574088573456,
-0.5245636105537415,
0.008041859604418278,
0.6363424062728882,
0.16991111636161804,
-0.10029974579811096,
-0.31283050775527954,
-0.34169507026672363,
0.17159214615821838,
0.09800941497087479,
-0.770093560218811,
-0.08748378604650497,
0.519655168056488,
-0.09362608194351196,
-0.4355839490890503,
0.47518229484558105,
-0.7491068243980408,
-0.5240130424499512,
-0.28322771191596985,
0.5866422057151794,
-0.17723999917507172,
-0.24444659054279327,
0.2837531864643097,
0.2806868851184845,
-0.1093861535191536,
0.5986414551734924,
-0.37013742327690125,
0.11163708567619324,
0.88548743724823,
0.8749940991401672,
-0.19968773424625397,
-0.34462952613830566,
-0.9590820074081421,
-0.08502042293548584,
-0.31562650203704834,
0.9780924916267395,
-0.20074748992919922,
-0.011585496366024017,
0.27206286787986755,
0.0447513610124588,
0.10650419443845749,
-0.40710100531578064,
0.8442007899284363,
-0.5906066298484802,
0.18041513860225677,
-0.320078045129776,
-0.46679922938346863,
-0.13634632527828217,
0.4281212091445923,
-0.8034558892250061,
1.203881859779358,
0.09597169607877731,
-0.8001168966293335,
0.39705589413642883,
-0.790740430355072,
-0.30275875329971313,
0.1194109171628952,
-0.15494611859321594,
-0.4266716241836548,
0.049258120357990265,
-0.06642107665538788,
0.2682722806930542,
-0.41988375782966614,
0.34451064467430115,
-0.49422532320022583,
-0.4376872479915619,
0.44145676493644714,
-0.47296464443206787,
1.1033430099487305,
0.1757775843143463,
-0.49643567204475403,
0.23501841723918915,
-0.9889765381813049,
-0.08164370805025101,
-0.07126956433057785,
-0.7324843406677246,
-0.24592088162899017,
-0.18557436764240265,
-0.25237134099006653,
-0.03727107495069504,
0.1586204320192337,
-1.0566164255142212,
-0.028467128053307533,
-0.34689861536026,
0.015357059426605701,
0.7401787042617798,
-0.09209063649177551,
0.08569009602069855,
-0.29014840722084045,
0.1035771369934082,
0.13921262323856354,
0.11560651659965515,
-0.15418314933776855,
-0.20654477179050446,
-1.007094383239746,
-0.6092569828033447,
0.531756579875946,
0.5808823108673096,
-0.4831385910511017,
0.7228953838348389,
-0.08715452998876572,
-0.5633877515792847,
-0.3352121114730835,
0.12802663445472717,
0.39653468132019043,
0.6113048791885376,
0.05591665208339691,
-0.26918813586235046,
-0.4619792401790619,
-0.7432363629341125,
-0.36482474207878113,
-0.5295210480690002,
-0.1148492693901062,
-0.2016892284154892,
0.780601441860199,
-0.4593506157398224,
1.0878918170928955,
-0.38605156540870667,
0.010268419981002808,
0.25188082456588745,
0.3861355483531952,
0.0724714919924736,
0.16310334205627441,
0.19842210412025452,
-0.46326398849487305,
0.028434129431843758,
0.05833602696657181,
-0.7347922921180725,
-0.24973218142986298,
-0.01690424233675003,
-0.1144334077835083,
0.6271868348121643,
0.30279120802879333,
-0.7228326797485352,
0.5059471130371094,
0.6155112385749817,
-0.5975372195243835,
0.8550130128860474,
-0.2603110671043396,
0.604293942451477,
-0.37369489669799805,
0.44052577018737793,
-0.17282769083976746,
-0.45175701379776,
-0.2602238357067108,
0.2267729490995407,
0.19667530059814453,
0.1461745798587799,
-0.4099753201007843,
0.5231725573539734,
-0.1876896470785141,
-0.1160731166601181,
0.05231126770377159,
0.2089827060699463,
0.0819280594587326,
0.1602310687303543,
-0.48286065459251404,
0.8729560971260071,
0.1830698400735855,
-0.5616971254348755,
0.6600362658500671,
0.11934379488229752,
-0.8427287936210632,
0.7320920825004578,
-0.4213851988315582,
0.20242245495319366,
0.08038361370563507,
0.2966149151325226,
-1.195760726928711,
-0.316026896238327,
0.09751489013433456,
-0.321780264377594,
-0.12219386547803879,
-0.03274550288915634,
-0.88023442029953,
-0.3487531840801239,
-0.33556851744651794,
-0.20243090391159058,
0.06677357852458954,
-0.8794936537742615,
0.7054062485694885,
0.16623647511005402,
0.16639457643032074,
-0.6236034631729126,
-0.3580745756626129,
-0.011195539496839046,
0.295452356338501,
-0.7972446084022522,
-0.19701014459133148,
-0.32266369462013245,
-0.5160201787948608,
0.07578546553850174,
-0.4851178824901581,
-0.19254326820373535,
0.3001839816570282,
0.3466528356075287,
0.5016884803771973,
-0.3700193762779236,
0.00002040585422946606,
-0.12560699880123138,
-0.001551423454657197,
0.13091444969177246,
-0.0729847177863121,
0.1572989970445633,
-0.5513253211975098,
-0.8091838955879211,
-0.09549132734537125,
0.017765264958143234,
0.8091277480125427,
-0.2584354281425476,
0.5389586091041565,
0.6229779720306396,
-0.31342530250549316,
-0.15938332676887512,
-0.9424484372138977,
0.04814121499657631,
-0.4579080045223236,
0.1444251537322998,
-0.3028109669685364,
-1.3281939029693604,
0.3435702323913574,
-0.24136745929718018,
0.35379382967948914,
0.4502326250076294,
0.8352351784706116,
0.11972887068986893,
0.5613665580749512,
0.4892438054084778,
0.09224212169647217,
-0.20581091940402985,
0.30984264612197876,
0.31134194135665894,
-0.24790552258491516,
-0.4903425872325897,
-0.7280882000923157,
0.2717498540878296,
-0.18063846230506897,
-0.5031560659408569,
0.21363641321659088,
-0.1498427391052246,
-0.36814653873443604,
-0.028347186744213104,
0.14362134039402008,
0.7410162687301636,
0.28566035628318787,
-0.03461949899792671,
0.803991973400116,
0.18605412542819977,
-0.6829115152359009,
0.18632952868938446,
-0.13924944400787354,
-0.6096451878547668,
0.8266755938529968,
0.45888495445251465,
0.5660820603370667,
0.3168283998966217,
0.41250601410865784,
0.4320734441280365,
0.6163157224655151,
-0.6646527647972107,
0.6169266104698181,
0.03873796388506889,
-0.8094761967658997,
-0.32003024220466614,
-0.42915257811546326,
-0.34639742970466614,
0.250531405210495,
-0.32543274760246277,
-0.6697521209716797,
-0.006756746210157871,
0.21607346832752228,
-0.43717271089553833,
0.6185564398765564,
-0.4073483645915985,
0.5869622230529785,
-0.22999195754528046,
-0.577196478843689,
-0.12087728828191757,
-0.269527405500412,
0.8785971403121948,
-0.19173923134803772,
0.31544560194015503,
-0.2197992205619812,
0.08665971457958221,
0.3232467770576477,
-0.5611545443534851,
0.9049431085586548,
0.03533043712377548,
-0.48015251755714417,
0.3627847731113434,
0.48269975185394287,
0.5043179392814636,
0.24919430911540985,
-0.0017156845424324274,
0.45200252532958984,
0.0849897488951683,
-0.018090687692165375,
-0.44580551981925964,
0.8276905417442322,
-0.7380478978157043,
-0.36429646611213684,
-0.6157521605491638,
-0.2385070025920868,
-0.5085320472717285,
0.2908255457878113,
-0.07657291740179062,
0.3174937069416046,
-0.7456119060516357,
0.09356135129928589,
0.869400680065155,
-0.057983219623565674,
0.17964163422584534,
1.0367801189422607,
-0.48661860823631287,
-0.4429115056991577,
0.6785028576850891,
-0.20706798136234283,
0.05180450156331062,
0.40415704250335693,
0.2933184802532196,
-0.3486076891422272,
-0.21208065748214722,
-0.3285010755062103,
0.24879634380340576,
-0.9222403764724731,
-0.31677401065826416,
-0.5610239505767822,
-0.027919955551624298,
-0.34600213170051575,
0.17959998548030853,
-0.45984572172164917,
-0.353361576795578,
0.07017777860164642,
-0.21361111104488373,
0.24030224978923798,
0.8249463438987732,
-0.4152204096317291,
-0.065150685608387,
-0.6603268980979919,
0.4829618036746979,
0.4741970896720886,
0.8332048058509827,
-0.3752710223197937,
-0.40010809898376465,
-0.23273532092571259,
-0.09418898075819016,
-0.2370227724313736,
-0.55145263671875,
-0.2946757376194,
-0.056555528193712234,
0.6319476962089539,
0.38243624567985535,
-0.03627799451351166,
0.32217857241630554,
-0.4147969186306,
0.8195432424545288,
0.32470524311065674,
-1.0496597290039062,
0.28841209411621094,
-0.08574797958135605,
-0.014658669009804726,
0.7988511323928833,
0.3306834399700165,
-0.4527343213558197,
-0.1409369707107544,
-0.4059664309024811,
-0.5661829113960266,
0.5972150564193726,
0.12543468177318573,
-0.32491347193717957,
0.1977543979883194,
0.21140070259571075,
0.2951773703098297,
0.18256737291812897,
-0.46788614988327026,
-0.2861328721046448,
-0.23124869167804718,
-0.040531422942876816,
-0.05042605847120285,
-0.46325168013572693,
-0.5446029305458069,
0.005816829390823841,
0.7978976964950562,
-0.27465152740478516,
0.16175313293933868,
0.3658580183982849,
-0.2900145649909973,
-0.40646398067474365,
0.4811895191669464,
0.644473671913147,
0.7501240372657776,
-0.46979379653930664,
0.44627806544303894,
0.09008719772100449,
-0.4995023310184479,
0.35214951634407043,
-0.07300718128681183,
-0.2378515899181366,
0.1656947284936905,
0.2562938332557678,
0.5207107067108154,
0.3450720012187958,
-0.6582531332969666,
0.6447358727455139,
-0.0756555125117302,
-0.23624424636363983,
-0.09583695977926254,
0.0931347906589508,
0.1056702584028244,
0.148044154047966,
0.0021329447627067566,
0.13413619995117188,
0.16851012408733368,
-0.6536415219306946,
0.29254382848739624,
0.18342003226280212,
-0.18443690240383148,
-0.21828800439834595,
0.3264792859554291,
0.33831459283828735,
-0.05259521305561066,
0.4210093021392822,
-0.1719713658094406,
-0.45296281576156616,
0.4141019880771637,
0.3706492781639099,
0.9820939898490906,
-0.20805488526821136,
0.4565266966819763,
0.38756197690963745,
0.7865661978721619,
-0.21403536200523376,
0.21013185381889343,
0.13098932802677155,
-0.661529004573822,
-0.6146964430809021,
-0.7507058382034302,
-0.8405241966247559,
0.5155962705612183,
-0.2707595229148865,
0.2223634421825409,
-0.46556556224823,
0.1607837826013565,
-0.1910593956708908,
0.09332574903964996,
-0.6973183751106262,
0.3349073529243469,
0.1542881578207016,
1.152440071105957,
-0.8471254110336304,
0.6075488328933716,
0.8981490135192871,
-0.3904934227466583,
-0.4144294261932373,
0.056406885385513306,
0.4169428050518036,
-0.704906702041626,
0.6239573955535889,
0.09002912044525146,
-0.6425108313560486,
-0.5043507218360901,
-0.7920566201210022,
-0.7556366324424744,
0.942658007144928,
0.6937660574913025,
-0.5049775838851929,
0.370466411113739,
0.36133918166160583,
0.32584407925605774,
-0.28613248467445374,
0.3705942630767822,
0.7456789016723633,
0.6745615005493164,
0.09647781401872635,
-0.8455324769020081,
0.2836863696575165,
-0.015644123777747154,
-0.33091437816619873,
-0.115753673017025,
-0.629316508769989,
0.7073675990104675,
-0.27351850271224976,
-0.27496740221977234,
-0.017227811738848686,
0.7330242991447449,
0.27512842416763306,
0.3387908935546875,
0.6564306020736694,
0.6787697076797485,
0.9752070307731628,
-0.08406943827867508,
0.8722904920578003,
-0.03753098472952843,
0.6021146774291992,
1.1992213726043701,
-0.5041113495826721,
0.6924356818199158,
0.22244799137115479,
-0.28079140186309814,
0.5245693325996399,
0.28841498494148254,
-0.08257082849740982,
0.02501256763935089,
0.08603206276893616,
-0.4546279311180115,
-0.39385804533958435,
0.0642840713262558,
-0.023852037265896797,
0.5158165693283081,
0.15361735224723816,
0.170916348695755,
-0.5578495264053345,
-0.4574641287326813,
0.25830182433128357,
-0.00331692723557353,
-0.08669913560152054,
0.42628213763237,
-0.2923300564289093,
-0.6246529817581177,
0.44418343901634216,
0.179240882396698,
0.4367506206035614,
-0.6515515446662903,
-0.023998551070690155,
-0.4402504861354828,
0.14236797392368317,
-0.43485745787620544,
-0.853738009929657,
0.13710710406303406,
0.22091355919837952,
-0.06691627949476242,
0.2932012975215912,
0.9313926696777344,
-0.3401316702365875,
-0.11768388748168945,
0.1770344376564026,
0.5112070441246033,
0.009655081667006016,
-0.19211691617965698,
-0.6000276803970337,
0.4760482907295227,
0.03750641644001007,
-0.265212744474411,
0.18657182157039642,
0.29206717014312744,
0.17106343805789948,
0.49147772789001465,
0.8598107695579529,
0.05555913597345352,
-0.10744321346282959,
0.01548218447715044,
0.8036307692527771,
-0.298225998878479,
-0.25076544284820557,
-0.8029984831809998,
0.6962404847145081,
-0.15991441905498505,
-0.33056601881980896,
0.7989544868469238,
0.7218100428581238,
0.8198025226593018,
-0.10354611277580261,
0.9244424700737,
-0.07567831128835678,
0.6254408955574036,
-0.52837073802948,
0.8618507385253906,
-0.40947943925857544,
0.11530657112598419,
-0.11727388203144073,
-0.7772996425628662,
-0.3433801531791687,
0.49074190855026245,
-0.06559906154870987,
-0.22505280375480652,
1.0139275789260864,
0.9369210004806519,
-0.32414403557777405,
0.2644835114479065,
0.6176908612251282,
0.5066881775856018,
0.23835349082946777,
0.049930356442928314,
0.8258140683174133,
-0.2820461094379425,
0.3885805010795593,
-0.15289369225502014,
-0.5154227614402771,
-0.4155673384666443,
-1.34544038772583,
-1.0761616230010986,
-0.35375988483428955,
-0.5690048336982727,
-0.6278017163276672,
0.004730734042823315,
0.8385835289955139,
0.307198703289032,
-1.0089623928070068,
-0.24272839725017548,
0.26763567328453064,
0.3044479489326477,
0.1429673731327057,
-0.1982349455356598,
0.20785871148109436,
-0.35198792815208435,
-0.33098459243774414,
0.5022570490837097,
0.5527138710021973,
-0.1479419320821762,
-0.5237177014350891,
0.03171619400382042,
-0.22904840111732483,
0.510915219783783,
0.7491757869720459,
0.3850116431713104,
-0.7286719083786011,
-0.5234050154685974,
-0.35766977071762085,
-0.28637412190437317,
-0.062349800020456314,
1.0514127016067505,
-0.5567623376846313,
0.5141342878341675,
0.44261711835861206,
0.717313289642334,
0.10600029677152634,
-0.1598687469959259,
0.1916712522506714,
-0.5013753771781921,
-0.12146689742803574,
-0.21239809691905975,
0.503182590007782,
0.3489031195640564,
-0.34228041768074036,
0.6511326432228088,
0.41600093245506287,
-0.5794802904129028,
-0.9915435910224915,
0.24362540245056152,
-0.899387538433075,
-0.05610974505543709,
1.07140052318573,
-0.450981080532074,
-0.3158741593360901,
-0.3072345554828644,
-0.03480158746242523,
0.2535952627658844,
-0.25230664014816284,
0.6200889945030212,
0.8608307242393494,
0.15082228183746338,
0.353080689907074,
-0.6206141710281372,
0.32579389214515686,
0.2054421752691269,
-1.065924882888794,
0.3469943404197693,
0.7574640512466431,
0.6631045937538147,
0.24949130415916443,
0.5155872106552124,
-0.3498128652572632,
0.22531470656394958,
-0.15592695772647858,
0.23359329998493195,
-0.3742307722568512,
-0.3000422716140747,
-0.35568365454673767,
0.29135340452194214,
-0.07131937146186829,
0.09622647613286972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05581v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05581v1
|
One vs. Many: Comprehending Accurate Information from Multiple Erroneous and Inconsistent AI Generations
| 2024-05-09T07:12:45 | 2024-05-09T07:12:45 |
Yoonjoo Lee, Kihoon Son, Tae Soo Kim, Jisu Kim, John Joon Young Chung, Eytan Adar, Juho Kim
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) are nondeterministic, the same input can
generate different outputs, some of which may be incorrect or hallucinated. If
run again, the LLM may correct itself and produce the correct answer.
Unfortunately, most LLM-powered systems resort to single results which, correct
or not, users accept. Having the LLM produce multiple outputs may help identify
disagreements or alternatives. However, it is not obvious how the user will
interpret conflicts or inconsistencies. To this end, we investigate how users
perceive the AI model and comprehend the generated information when they
receive multiple, potentially inconsistent, outputs. Through a preliminary
study, we identified five types of output inconsistencies. Based on these
categories, we conducted a study (N=252) in which participants were given one
or more LLM-generated passages to an information-seeking question. We found
that inconsistency within multiple LLM-generated outputs lowered the
participants' perceived AI capacity, while also increasing their comprehension
of the given information. Specifically, we observed that this positive effect
of inconsistencies was most significant for participants who read two passages,
compared to those who read three. Based on these findings, we present design
implications that, instead of regarding LLM output inconsistencies as a
drawback, we can reveal the potential inconsistencies to transparently indicate
the limitations of these models and promote critical LLM usage.
|
[
-0.44469037652015686,
-0.7200508117675781,
0.9353465437889099,
0.15161480009555817,
0.02975749969482422,
-0.08932749181985855,
0.021771756932139397,
-0.5554052591323853,
-0.025544919073581696,
0.510617196559906,
-0.5356862545013428,
-0.0871395394206047,
-0.8510164618492126,
0.35439199209213257,
-0.44123753905296326,
0.9182054996490479,
-0.1832362562417984,
0.08418508619070053,
-0.3359249234199524,
-0.44899842143058777,
-0.5421881079673767,
-0.6115908026695251,
-0.5490500330924988,
-0.6554209589958191,
0.6039739847183228,
0.6888033151626587,
0.8111244440078735,
0.5155602693557739,
0.530504584312439,
0.22877351939678192,
0.1888798624277115,
0.3700066804885864,
-0.7761149406433105,
0.24776512384414673,
-0.04145409166812897,
-0.6667705178260803,
-0.19094069302082062,
0.06861453503370285,
0.7427972555160522,
0.5867934226989746,
0.11378956586122513,
0.18389064073562622,
0.3610791862010956,
0.7266364693641663,
-0.4884736239910126,
0.10009661316871643,
-0.530340850353241,
0.12230651080608368,
-0.08509379625320435,
-0.21543502807617188,
-0.687284529209137,
-0.2265627235174179,
0.13914744555950165,
-0.7836518287658691,
0.09481412917375565,
-0.015128137543797493,
0.8029003739356995,
0.7141461372375488,
-0.5653887987136841,
-0.4245080053806305,
-1.068142294883728,
0.6922580003738403,
-0.9301192164421082,
0.38821813464164734,
0.33296290040016174,
0.15527772903442383,
-0.07201237231492996,
-0.4647858738899231,
-0.8474478721618652,
-0.06318347156047821,
-0.121271513402462,
0.4054293930530548,
-0.22828124463558197,
0.01615397445857525,
0.34942030906677246,
-0.08642835915088654,
-0.5042012929916382,
0.30203908681869507,
-0.1276194304227829,
0.01907852478325367,
0.5400871634483337,
0.35423439741134644,
0.12797042727470398,
-0.04965653270483017,
-0.44652026891708374,
-0.11373230814933777,
-0.9116770625114441,
-0.10473168641328812,
0.6096280813217163,
0.2786096930503845,
-0.09662629663944244,
0.6156889200210571,
0.21907822787761688,
0.5351211428642273,
0.021072430536150932,
-0.24568819999694824,
0.18063674867153168,
-0.43870195746421814,
-0.2077610194683075,
-0.13628962635993958,
0.8012093305587769,
0.042807403951883316,
0.4133320748806,
-0.12038043886423111,
-0.07545991241931915,
-0.22067853808403015,
0.508590817451477,
-0.5069313645362854,
0.09523649513721466,
0.4261217415332794,
-0.5406357645988464,
-0.05844560265541077,
0.3696359097957611,
-0.6979413628578186,
-0.7551552653312683,
-0.47044727206230164,
0.5532631874084473,
-0.43698519468307495,
-0.26942482590675354,
-0.2136155664920807,
-0.11373870819807053,
-0.10764110088348389,
0.6102138757705688,
-0.64469313621521,
0.008568360470235348,
0.3993198871612549,
0.5246634483337402,
-0.12519755959510803,
-0.7870123982429504,
-0.2769331932067871,
0.18359321355819702,
-0.3728359639644623,
0.8021935820579529,
-0.42514753341674805,
-0.23016148805618286,
-0.10489490628242493,
-0.37966930866241455,
-0.33377930521965027,
-0.6079528331756592,
0.32490426301956177,
-0.38836464285850525,
-0.005875231232494116,
-0.33773601055145264,
-0.6959806680679321,
-0.23524297773838043,
0.20290841162204742,
-0.8382280468940735,
0.5028595328330994,
-0.16732525825500488,
-0.8673849701881409,
0.4217783808708191,
-0.4542549252510071,
-0.2409009337425232,
-0.1579892784357071,
-0.5775612592697144,
-0.3499238193035126,
0.3302057385444641,
-0.041566163301467896,
0.19780123233795166,
-0.2277473658323288,
0.23674555122852325,
-0.2522648572921753,
-0.276699423789978,
0.4568163752555847,
-0.8219233155250549,
0.4293185770511627,
0.2402126044034958,
-0.32133278250694275,
0.11621392518281937,
-0.7401586771011353,
-0.12235388904809952,
0.16085515916347504,
-0.6514548659324646,
-0.020183490589261055,
0.33954983949661255,
-0.2769604027271271,
0.23500511050224304,
0.23239775002002716,
-0.3306901156902313,
0.029682256281375885,
0.007680005859583616,
0.3277323544025421,
1.022884488105774,
-0.11604804545640945,
0.2969130873680115,
-0.7568044662475586,
0.5550225377082825,
0.47796475887298584,
0.053279779851436615,
-0.4781891703605652,
-0.5190465450286865,
-0.7921196818351746,
0.1350753903388977,
-0.009118041023612022,
0.5191115736961365,
-0.693192720413208,
-0.013487287797033787,
-0.23778660595417023,
-0.2726433277130127,
-0.8040956258773804,
0.3887335956096649,
0.17117856442928314,
0.47072839736938477,
0.24001750349998474,
0.08675466477870941,
-0.4310145378112793,
-0.8770289421081543,
-0.44719764590263367,
-0.5970959067344666,
0.07463584840297699,
0.6588945984840393,
0.46789464354515076,
-0.2775089144706726,
0.7897369265556335,
-0.08961810171604156,
-0.07741519808769226,
-0.33325690031051636,
0.3853980004787445,
-0.020171472802758217,
0.30305618047714233,
0.07314220070838928,
-0.6734693050384521,
-0.31381693482398987,
0.01695476844906807,
-1.0685054063796997,
0.21789291501045227,
-0.7843757271766663,
0.0667414590716362,
0.2638704478740692,
0.17340129613876343,
-0.387442946434021,
0.4568658471107483,
0.46595895290374756,
-0.1599002480506897,
0.5156047940254211,
-0.31273943185806274,
0.18889936804771423,
-0.9244862198829651,
0.018100136891007423,
-0.04473564773797989,
-0.0006702993996441364,
-0.573226809501648,
0.10307078808546066,
0.015612122602760792,
0.3126082122325897,
-0.16952283680438995,
0.39774683117866516,
-0.33442139625549316,
0.015944814309477806,
-0.0941464826464653,
0.29756632447242737,
0.19802597165107727,
0.30084648728370667,
-0.3746998906135559,
0.9624290466308594,
0.29277196526527405,
-0.48017406463623047,
0.21498343348503113,
0.1903659701347351,
-0.16996803879737854,
0.467676043510437,
-0.5255999565124512,
0.3423048257827759,
-0.7157178521156311,
0.2283734828233719,
-1.262744665145874,
-0.49653810262680054,
0.1563231647014618,
-0.5481089949607849,
0.17502433061599731,
0.18136368691921234,
-0.5212494730949402,
-0.26433518528938293,
-0.0872979462146759,
0.39153558015823364,
0.13824324309825897,
-0.7714019417762756,
0.794472336769104,
0.12201054394245148,
0.02086424082517624,
-0.8067010045051575,
-1.026903748512268,
0.07625716179609299,
-0.08382072299718857,
-0.8420277833938599,
-0.15307776629924774,
-0.13627798855304718,
-0.4955112338066101,
-0.07617929577827454,
-0.19603398442268372,
-0.10247146338224411,
0.06493060290813446,
0.515158474445343,
0.18350505828857422,
-0.40898019075393677,
0.5546358227729797,
-0.3623095452785492,
0.19417020678520203,
-0.03113466687500477,
-0.1828177571296692,
0.3848612606525421,
-0.005010765511542559,
-0.7133477330207825,
-0.4674859941005707,
0.5476183891296387,
0.8018305897712708,
-0.11190318316221237,
0.9757683873176575,
0.4319520592689514,
-0.30310437083244324,
-0.19067694246768951,
-0.7551937103271484,
-0.04296250268816948,
-0.3487810492515564,
0.2824331521987915,
-0.48739710450172424,
-0.7528520822525024,
0.7086910605430603,
0.10490554571151733,
0.3102087378501892,
0.6192235350608826,
0.35823386907577515,
-0.08667556941509247,
1.2779045104980469,
0.7136951088905334,
0.07439621537923813,
0.3090164065361023,
-0.03357383608818054,
0.3213760554790497,
-0.803695797920227,
-0.4506288766860962,
-0.5833596587181091,
-0.281005859375,
-0.4317481219768524,
0.02113915979862213,
0.30815601348876953,
0.2832489013671875,
-0.3084953725337982,
-0.10460177063941956,
-0.27903103828430176,
0.36960840225219727,
0.8362113833427429,
0.09177308529615402,
0.5571342706680298,
0.008606304414570332,
-0.07943102717399597,
0.03824744373559952,
-0.838545024394989,
-0.9984292387962341,
1.2595012187957764,
0.3702276349067688,
1.0966837406158447,
0.36257097125053406,
0.7393932938575745,
0.1780964583158493,
0.4206492006778717,
-0.832289457321167,
-0.07040472328662872,
-0.09930120408535004,
-0.7389127612113953,
-0.3184034824371338,
-0.6706489324569702,
-1.0496197938919067,
0.19646719098091125,
-0.28772690892219543,
-0.6427035927772522,
0.16106635332107544,
0.2430717796087265,
-0.5116994976997375,
0.4409683048725128,
-0.8483327627182007,
0.9580540060997009,
-0.3903009593486786,
-0.41216903924942017,
-0.2166091799736023,
-0.7418205142021179,
0.5472601652145386,
-0.33384954929351807,
0.25593647360801697,
0.1151440367102623,
0.1683564931154251,
0.5576738715171814,
-0.02510673925280571,
0.7623013257980347,
0.31031861901283264,
0.04791143909096718,
0.43077126145362854,
-0.06938791275024414,
0.5018041133880615,
0.04217934235930443,
-0.3201712965965271,
0.154870867729187,
-0.20586438477039337,
-0.3187846541404724,
-0.3792015612125397,
0.6580169200897217,
-1.2516475915908813,
-0.7559734582901001,
-0.2982717752456665,
-0.6094375848770142,
-0.004464122001081705,
0.2589276134967804,
0.5430470108985901,
0.30860692262649536,
-0.28325945138931274,
-0.18960681557655334,
0.5172873735427856,
-0.343816876411438,
0.16922926902770996,
0.4056004285812378,
-0.03271358460187912,
-0.061825964599847794,
0.7844806909561157,
0.2797585725784302,
0.5480189919471741,
0.17019405961036682,
-0.02532091923058033,
-0.3173907697200775,
-0.4594341814517975,
-0.6963551044464111,
0.2648327052593231,
-0.9654877185821533,
0.03269307687878609,
-0.5937889814376831,
-0.16690459847450256,
-0.44516992568969727,
0.30343443155288696,
-0.13033781945705414,
-0.07751505821943283,
-0.768919050693512,
0.0606783851981163,
-0.10789009928703308,
1.6262656450271606,
-0.014244155958294868,
0.3690386712551117,
-0.8541466593742371,
0.23854383826255798,
0.3695313036441803,
0.22284074127674103,
0.20428720116615295,
-0.5321474671363831,
-0.14962641894817352,
0.22196833789348602,
-0.7296206951141357,
-1.2203261852264404,
0.01930796168744564,
0.022489864379167557,
0.8087533116340637,
0.7466793656349182,
-0.07364223152399063,
0.5141519904136658,
-0.4679150879383087,
0.7460335493087769,
0.22300632297992706,
-0.8092501163482666,
0.2753475606441498,
0.026661401614546776,
0.38190558552742004,
0.4875634014606476,
0.327584832906723,
-0.6286256909370422,
-0.5291236639022827,
-0.5814807415008545,
-0.6125426888465881,
0.8032206892967224,
0.09499722719192505,
0.052643466740846634,
-0.10113883763551712,
0.23715518414974213,
0.32032716274261475,
0.10925331711769104,
-0.6349799036979675,
-0.45876872539520264,
-0.3988525867462158,
-0.14531703293323517,
0.042376112192869186,
-0.36086294054985046,
-0.07913186401128769,
0.43309667706489563,
0.5829540491104126,
-0.08252809941768646,
0.21759222447872162,
0.31371885538101196,
-0.011380409821867943,
-0.4197457730770111,
0.4649336636066437,
0.8222022652626038,
1.1034362316131592,
0.07656633108854294,
0.4704499840736389,
-0.07170266658067703,
-0.08064447343349457,
0.10201099514961243,
-0.06488384306430817,
-0.11809626966714859,
0.11976201087236404,
0.5554091334342957,
0.8857702016830444,
-0.5533011555671692,
-0.6528580784797668,
0.30603426694869995,
-0.19654114544391632,
-0.05766292288899422,
-0.3154172897338867,
-0.04082277789711952,
0.18815167248249054,
0.23749977350234985,
0.40073713660240173,
0.5105012655258179,
-0.06876976788043976,
-0.6836354732513428,
0.1546395868062973,
0.3545211851596832,
-0.01785556599497795,
-0.16381822526454926,
0.8864168524742126,
0.14899398386478424,
-0.42529764771461487,
0.9359136819839478,
-0.08368419110774994,
-0.3396756947040558,
0.7220541834831238,
0.5241496562957764,
0.6432141065597534,
-0.17180004715919495,
0.22809277474880219,
0.3746671676635742,
0.5067596435546875,
-0.3012639284133911,
0.061880968511104584,
0.3465414345264435,
-1.007728099822998,
-0.5344153046607971,
-0.23131687939167023,
-0.528883159160614,
0.3599390685558319,
-0.6167734265327454,
-0.04193590208888054,
-0.4982856214046478,
-0.3526431620121002,
0.13780097663402557,
-0.4945175349712372,
-0.905927836894989,
-0.10212557762861252,
0.243113711476326,
0.5606765151023865,
-0.8012629151344299,
0.5308338403701782,
0.6939701437950134,
-0.8288454413414001,
-0.9692339897155762,
0.2683810293674469,
0.20595277845859528,
-0.8659111261367798,
0.5631049275398254,
0.14424242079257965,
0.0017218863358721137,
-0.3114002048969269,
-0.5846688151359558,
-0.8600782752037048,
0.6672961115837097,
0.36130809783935547,
-0.7156869769096375,
-0.0570589043200016,
0.31979793310165405,
0.4319002330303192,
-0.465334951877594,
0.2888411581516266,
0.4909926950931549,
0.6891856789588928,
0.09119393676519394,
-0.9104989171028137,
-0.037688545882701874,
-0.03682450205087662,
-0.24399547278881073,
0.10690043121576309,
-0.6828531622886658,
1.0785530805587769,
-0.5722089409828186,
-0.46060097217559814,
0.09255614876747131,
0.29845207929611206,
0.3459955155849457,
0.414760947227478,
0.2663467228412628,
0.48686257004737854,
0.9726579785346985,
0.027126293629407883,
1.1530954837799072,
-0.1748361885547638,
0.20421938598155975,
1.3910990953445435,
-0.18800242245197296,
0.7760366201400757,
0.6591103076934814,
-0.17868690192699432,
0.16789209842681885,
0.4856712222099304,
0.1049039289355278,
0.007484795991331339,
0.20565013587474823,
-0.3113207519054413,
-0.42315271496772766,
-0.16337750852108002,
-0.32527485489845276,
0.2785113751888275,
0.2463236004114151,
-0.4964819848537445,
-0.23387350142002106,
-0.18238741159439087,
-0.11075888574123383,
0.0989777073264122,
0.08085855841636658,
0.791709303855896,
0.1462494432926178,
-0.9165985584259033,
0.5237268209457397,
-0.07964155077934265,
0.4610966444015503,
-0.32727688550949097,
-0.2645680606365204,
-0.3407522439956665,
0.29062315821647644,
-0.44860878586769104,
-0.8918032050132751,
0.18537841737270355,
-0.02078927308320999,
-0.3995729684829712,
-0.05905817076563835,
0.36855414509773254,
-0.3144851624965668,
-0.47372785210609436,
0.2330213487148285,
1.0401214361190796,
0.4370918571949005,
-0.09770427644252777,
-0.5652602314949036,
0.3392769396305084,
0.3084491789340973,
-0.017334433272480965,
-0.02936766855418682,
0.49158385396003723,
0.27360936999320984,
0.698992908000946,
0.30861660838127136,
0.02589038759469986,
0.31045424938201904,
0.18616896867752075,
0.5150094032287598,
-0.4690483808517456,
-0.09437594562768936,
-1.0128253698349,
0.2641870975494385,
0.056146007031202316,
-0.6878569722175598,
0.837300181388855,
0.37184953689575195,
1.012070655822754,
0.3037412464618683,
1.1951038837432861,
0.2649439871311188,
0.4281492829322815,
-0.28214046359062195,
0.41972237825393677,
-0.7429395318031311,
0.5603906512260437,
-0.06677050143480301,
-0.7644937634468079,
-0.06855753064155579,
0.6551184058189392,
0.022058861330151558,
0.09514068812131882,
0.7033993005752563,
0.4471418559551239,
0.061568260192871094,
0.2613091468811035,
0.40564706921577454,
0.5679909586906433,
0.4216132164001465,
0.6995561122894287,
1.1614465713500977,
-0.22878950834274292,
0.6676251888275146,
0.17239001393318176,
-0.08863776922225952,
-0.13196231424808502,
-0.38843464851379395,
-0.7039332985877991,
-0.2913527190685272,
-0.0829407200217247,
-0.41710248589515686,
0.014263702556490898,
0.8053105473518372,
0.5407607555389404,
-0.8781249523162842,
-0.21624897420406342,
-0.1869879513978958,
0.5437503457069397,
0.02892233617603779,
-0.21268269419670105,
0.02808743342757225,
-0.5231786966323853,
-0.6276898980140686,
0.23957917094230652,
0.23180748522281647,
0.2151167094707489,
-0.353598952293396,
-0.28260794281959534,
-0.03979707136750221,
0.2776619493961334,
0.3303736448287964,
0.1373506635427475,
-1.051915168762207,
-0.396379292011261,
-0.010759701021015644,
-0.3310399651527405,
0.3922926187515259,
0.5882497429847717,
-0.5529917478561401,
0.625932514667511,
0.5752270817756653,
0.7813664078712463,
0.34587353467941284,
0.17615097761154175,
0.5577130913734436,
-0.40453988313674927,
-0.3921087384223938,
0.08253378421068192,
0.33451735973358154,
0.37910759449005127,
-0.45295801758766174,
0.3837701678276062,
-0.0491027869284153,
-0.7689223289489746,
-0.5448954105377197,
0.5114430785179138,
-0.5826263427734375,
-0.5104329586029053,
1.077430248260498,
-0.30787310004234314,
0.14221321046352386,
-0.1786540299654007,
-0.010226677171885967,
0.2702310085296631,
-0.45176610350608826,
0.8422094583511353,
1.1565885543823242,
-0.5181823372840881,
-0.018267812207341194,
-0.7487665414810181,
0.08923299610614777,
0.6476061344146729,
-0.8740203976631165,
0.052677057683467865,
0.6334692239761353,
0.19161921739578247,
0.4330771267414093,
0.4112817943096161,
0.09027134627103806,
0.14911027252674103,
0.22886556386947632,
-0.1632070243358612,
0.10682439804077148,
-0.5696534514427185,
-0.4277815520763397,
0.06945855915546417,
0.3747778832912445,
-0.06352391839027405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05572v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05572v1
|
From Human Judgements to Predictive Models: Unravelling Acceptability in Code-Mixed Sentences
| 2024-05-09T06:40:39 | 2024-05-09T06:40:39 |
Prashant Kodali, Anmol Goel, Likhith Asapu, Vamshi Krishna Bonagiri, Anirudh Govil, Monojit Choudhury, Manish Shrivastava, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Current computational approaches for analysing or generating code-mixed
sentences do not explicitly model "naturalness" or "acceptability" of
code-mixed sentences, but rely on training corpora to reflect distribution of
acceptable code-mixed sentences. Modelling human judgement for the
acceptability of code-mixed text can help in distinguishing natural code-mixed
text and enable quality-controlled generation of code-mixed text. To this end,
we construct Cline - a dataset containing human acceptability judgements for
English-Hindi (en-hi) code-mixed text. Cline is the largest of its kind with
16,642 sentences, consisting of samples sourced from two sources: synthetically
generated code-mixed text and samples collected from online social media. Our
analysis establishes that popular code-mixing metrics such as CMI, Number of
Switch Points, Burstines, which are used to filter/curate/compare code-mixed
corpora have low correlation with human acceptability judgements, underlining
the necessity of our dataset. Experiments using Cline demonstrate that simple
Multilayer Perceptron (MLP) models trained solely on code-mixing metrics are
outperformed by fine-tuned pre-trained Multilingual Large Language Models
(MLLMs). Specifically, XLM-Roberta and Bernice outperform IndicBERT across
different configurations in challenging data settings. Comparison with
ChatGPT's zero and fewshot capabilities shows that MLLMs fine-tuned on larger
data outperform ChatGPT, providing scope for improvement in code-mixed tasks.
Zero-shot transfer from English-Hindi to English-Telugu acceptability judgments
using our model checkpoints proves superior to random baselines, enabling
application to other code-mixed language pairs and providing further avenues of
research. We publicly release our human-annotated dataset, trained checkpoints,
code-mix corpus, and code for data generation and model training.
|
[
-0.513854444026947,
-0.357553094625473,
0.3202086091041565,
0.4179133176803589,
-0.14920979738235474,
0.2803930640220642,
-0.704469621181488,
-1.0325082540512085,
-0.07644861191511154,
0.2984253764152527,
-0.26890280842781067,
-0.44151636958122253,
-0.5075643658638,
0.19790203869342804,
-0.630159854888916,
0.879599392414093,
-0.01766784116625786,
0.2063794881105423,
0.06480632722377777,
-0.40577661991119385,
-0.5598238110542297,
-0.7223784923553467,
-0.19006459414958954,
-0.48035451769828796,
0.49393001198768616,
0.472337543964386,
0.9830187559127808,
0.30178266763687134,
0.33292877674102783,
0.16842466592788696,
-0.20225763320922852,
0.1339777261018753,
-0.3625013530254364,
-0.2763931453227997,
-0.07764587551355362,
-0.39151731133461,
-0.43371453881263733,
0.03908447548747063,
0.27692317962646484,
0.6654598116874695,
-0.13921280205249786,
0.028623048216104507,
0.24132350087165833,
0.44765907526016235,
-0.4651046097278595,
0.030314229428768158,
-0.8307687044143677,
0.08729709684848785,
0.013509828597307205,
0.04063398763537407,
-0.4381132125854492,
-0.32175347208976746,
0.21130302548408508,
-0.4601408839225769,
0.14841680228710175,
-0.050265565514564514,
0.6721379160881042,
-0.043109819293022156,
-0.2599429488182068,
-0.6989706754684448,
-0.6399266123771667,
0.6419015526771545,
-0.8046765327453613,
0.40622228384017944,
0.3266766667366028,
0.26644986867904663,
-0.09089286625385284,
-0.47028303146362305,
-0.7421308755874634,
-0.1356729418039322,
-0.38199084997177124,
-0.03124758042395115,
-0.021180570125579834,
0.12769295275211334,
0.2972983717918396,
0.32090795040130615,
-0.8806536197662354,
0.09887787699699402,
-0.4600985646247864,
-0.3597653806209564,
0.6331087350845337,
-0.019873615354299545,
0.4944857656955719,
-0.2605382204055786,
-0.17306727170944214,
0.19020423293113708,
-0.5560129880905151,
0.0490155890583992,
0.17474792897701263,
0.3271793723106384,
-0.1713552623987198,
0.6323711276054382,
-0.2908213436603546,
0.8588421940803528,
-0.17024698853492737,
0.19876256585121155,
0.27394965291023254,
-0.5998314619064331,
-0.3497939109802246,
-0.019864236935973167,
0.6719874143600464,
0.39079731702804565,
0.8147575855255127,
-0.0751166045665741,
-0.3326272666454315,
0.5633312463760376,
0.24548286199569702,
-0.6557525992393494,
-0.33933866024017334,
0.3678313195705414,
-0.5110666751861572,
-0.2352377474308014,
-0.11998774856328964,
-0.8106316328048706,
-0.5762414336204529,
-0.4885503649711609,
0.12519682943820953,
-0.4850166141986847,
-0.17991235852241516,
0.3039313852787018,
-0.09362941980361938,
0.20635877549648285,
0.34937378764152527,
-0.6422778367996216,
0.16084328293800354,
0.3233296871185303,
0.762469470500946,
-0.2149963080883026,
-0.6729679107666016,
-0.13605886697769165,
-0.37296825647354126,
-0.16087567806243896,
0.5976373553276062,
-0.46955883502960205,
-0.31751784682273865,
0.09138236194849014,
-0.26545366644859314,
-0.2442469596862793,
-0.8196225166320801,
0.6752219200134277,
-0.602270245552063,
0.033586397767066956,
0.2226220965385437,
-0.4093371033668518,
-0.06364831328392029,
0.2578195333480835,
-0.5019834041595459,
0.6221238374710083,
0.20994293689727783,
-0.8196896314620972,
0.5766332745552063,
-0.6421199440956116,
-0.5707389712333679,
-0.003293875837698579,
-0.04374755173921585,
-0.16321460902690887,
-0.005571208894252777,
0.15586580336093903,
0.4963151514530182,
0.06676086783409119,
0.47154247760772705,
-0.46045422554016113,
-0.6538989543914795,
0.5988470911979675,
-0.405017614364624,
0.8715477585792542,
0.6810528039932251,
-0.11419495195150375,
0.1661582738161087,
-1.0108284950256348,
0.35302379727363586,
0.011189226061105728,
-0.47213324904441833,
0.05761636421084404,
-0.06885029375553131,
0.5590428113937378,
0.5449644923210144,
0.11344978213310242,
-0.44471511244773865,
-0.005341269075870514,
-0.31365159153938293,
0.8163139820098877,
0.4576173424720764,
-0.25994962453842163,
0.46595287322998047,
-0.339581698179245,
0.45007121562957764,
0.09882079809904099,
0.08843008428812027,
-0.11696590483188629,
-0.424213171005249,
-0.6166098117828369,
-0.13419002294540405,
0.28443124890327454,
0.7385846376419067,
-0.6281794309616089,
0.229054257273674,
-0.09512026607990265,
-0.48385849595069885,
-0.608894407749176,
0.34848010540008545,
0.37744006514549255,
-0.06809748709201813,
0.34425026178359985,
-0.38219597935676575,
-0.846281111240387,
-0.8145396709442139,
-0.5044195652008057,
-0.1548307090997696,
-0.08555829524993896,
0.21586796641349792,
0.40164464712142944,
-0.5023670792579651,
0.8345251679420471,
-0.42534294724464417,
0.12392439693212509,
-0.44075101613998413,
0.24769644439220428,
0.3187141716480255,
0.4254884123802185,
0.40426361560821533,
-0.961158812046051,
-0.5843954086303711,
0.1803426295518875,
-0.7571715116500854,
0.07970507442951202,
-0.18543531000614166,
0.03243082016706467,
0.10917650908231735,
0.1418001800775528,
-0.42424482107162476,
0.6313087940216064,
0.7971723675727844,
-0.39825543761253357,
0.7193333506584167,
-0.15085428953170776,
0.25850027799606323,
-0.8353476524353027,
-0.06972260773181915,
0.028898892924189568,
-0.48324424028396606,
-0.665359377861023,
0.2653908133506775,
0.25196656584739685,
-0.18067558109760284,
-0.5184119939804077,
0.32404232025146484,
-0.39199674129486084,
-0.27023592591285706,
-0.2663794159889221,
0.12830649316310883,
0.0015720814699307084,
0.5397412180900574,
0.11031044274568558,
0.8013533353805542,
0.41204506158828735,
-0.6806759834289551,
0.10874782502651215,
0.21565552055835724,
-0.6088752746582031,
0.5355314612388611,
-0.8067022562026978,
0.017693452537059784,
0.020828749984502792,
0.1999358832836151,
-0.9118592143058777,
-0.3108011782169342,
0.15466482937335968,
-0.6776024103164673,
0.10317307710647583,
-0.09333958476781845,
-0.5034795999526978,
-0.2078159898519516,
0.07954022288322449,
0.5865412354469299,
0.5877732634544373,
-0.6556477546691895,
0.3479555547237396,
0.1351785510778427,
0.09963206201791763,
-0.4583265781402588,
-0.8080722689628601,
0.16221769154071808,
-0.08180614560842514,
-0.7134893536567688,
0.1371309757232666,
-0.5993019938468933,
-0.35259655117988586,
-0.21543239057064056,
0.1251773238182068,
-0.5572102069854736,
0.10653571039438248,
0.38077518343925476,
0.40410056710243225,
-0.07014892995357513,
-0.3167913556098938,
-0.3863045573234558,
0.004287931602448225,
-0.10328357666730881,
-0.36238422989845276,
0.5160465240478516,
-0.16522613167762756,
-0.12028208374977112,
-0.1635698676109314,
0.21941770613193512,
0.6455201506614685,
-0.128962904214859,
0.561927855014801,
0.6606264114379883,
-0.48421430587768555,
-0.20043782889842987,
-0.17050176858901978,
0.15660525858402252,
-0.37202879786491394,
0.14517414569854736,
-0.2701038122177124,
-0.9041299819946289,
0.5468629002571106,
0.37686482071876526,
0.1641196608543396,
0.11111960560083389,
0.5571230053901672,
0.02135215699672699,
1.0262550115585327,
0.41067349910736084,
-0.15424998104572296,
0.4006716310977936,
0.07054269313812256,
0.23863452672958374,
-0.38520652055740356,
0.29694488644599915,
-0.5318544507026672,
-0.13250458240509033,
-0.7630307674407959,
-0.3575111925601959,
0.1186593770980835,
0.09131564944982529,
-0.16857074201107025,
0.5534093379974365,
-0.5189927816390991,
0.584134578704834,
0.26853612065315247,
0.30956631898880005,
0.5743398070335388,
-0.09428946673870087,
-0.16742536425590515,
-0.04440833628177643,
-0.5400751233100891,
-0.34092071652412415,
1.0367484092712402,
0.3513323664665222,
0.5518060326576233,
-0.06961195915937424,
0.4121020436286926,
0.5517094135284424,
0.4076056480407715,
-0.5336304306983948,
0.3812425136566162,
-0.12993928790092468,
-0.7912329435348511,
0.21547846496105194,
-0.6168174743652344,
-0.5737978219985962,
0.3233545422554016,
-0.2779417037963867,
-0.6847360134124756,
-0.02167336456477642,
0.16070452332496643,
-0.20952409505844116,
0.1367301046848297,
-1.075868010520935,
0.8763752579689026,
-0.26154059171676636,
-0.24684281647205353,
-0.22406931221485138,
-0.748525083065033,
0.49213898181915283,
-0.07402553409337997,
0.6513752341270447,
0.10233988612890244,
0.4093174636363983,
0.37437865138053894,
-0.06852604448795319,
0.8477429151535034,
0.08092649281024933,
0.024932123720645905,
0.38680535554885864,
0.2537611424922943,
0.1474456787109375,
0.10876049846410751,
-0.09543037414550781,
0.40039828419685364,
0.12171685695648193,
-0.6739398837089539,
-0.5367875695228577,
0.5751398205757141,
-0.8401801586151123,
0.007146678864955902,
-0.33416295051574707,
-0.5994383096694946,
-0.09789875149726868,
0.1773187816143036,
0.49915650486946106,
0.5593791604042053,
-0.06568385660648346,
-0.26098498702049255,
0.4437330961227417,
-0.39613065123558044,
0.3357319235801697,
0.45717716217041016,
-0.575427234172821,
-0.4479125142097473,
0.8880007863044739,
-0.06941251456737518,
0.5000278353691101,
0.1955004334449768,
-0.07641594856977463,
-0.019457275047898293,
-0.6459567546844482,
-0.5106695294380188,
0.1143476665019989,
-0.7042615413665771,
0.00901984702795744,
-0.4577322006225586,
-0.4379045367240906,
-0.20195290446281433,
-0.4958387613296509,
-0.20385491847991943,
-0.24848167598247528,
-0.054621610790491104,
0.00553539302200079,
0.03380071371793747,
1.0903759002685547,
0.03822849690914154,
0.19125470519065857,
-0.8966045379638672,
0.27558785676956177,
-0.12138035148382187,
0.7227370142936707,
-0.07135792821645737,
-0.7088155150413513,
-0.30713826417922974,
0.33347803354263306,
0.07665754854679108,
-0.6869673132896423,
0.4005453586578369,
-0.05446198210120201,
0.24240724742412567,
0.18970471620559692,
-0.2437034249305725,
0.6427544355392456,
-0.23631460964679718,
0.6692861914634705,
0.12024369090795517,
-1.0691630840301514,
0.3996037542819977,
-0.40702030062675476,
0.2415599226951599,
0.6670948266983032,
0.2917241156101227,
-0.6914739012718201,
-0.35870736837387085,
-0.4553675949573517,
-0.6411357522010803,
0.5868504643440247,
0.38477781414985657,
-0.09527865052223206,
0.06750725209712982,
0.3360445201396942,
0.16617687046527863,
0.2691817283630371,
-1.0641316175460815,
-0.13682955503463745,
-0.13663768768310547,
-0.30479323863983154,
-0.2169618308544159,
-0.15204642713069916,
0.32029691338539124,
-0.2233942747116089,
0.3170090913772583,
-0.027439212426543236,
0.21472816169261932,
0.1562541127204895,
-0.5263895988464355,
0.10922976583242416,
0.6624895930290222,
0.570368230342865,
0.7485820651054382,
-0.48795226216316223,
0.06681261956691742,
0.09232407063245773,
-0.5510596036911011,
-0.02044656127691269,
0.035980481654405594,
-0.1822623312473297,
-0.057468898594379425,
0.31074023246765137,
0.3838907778263092,
0.3076317012310028,
-1.098620891571045,
0.3827528953552246,
-0.2768721878528595,
-0.10741795599460602,
-0.48179373145103455,
-0.0257789958268404,
-0.059828225523233414,
0.03513959422707558,
-0.05404120683670044,
0.5986083149909973,
0.19911308586597443,
-0.5793353319168091,
0.43364301323890686,
0.04438161104917526,
-0.5520988702774048,
-0.3810005486011505,
0.5772135853767395,
0.07561863958835602,
-0.2334095984697342,
0.5808563828468323,
-0.5392069220542908,
-0.7390047311782837,
0.521729052066803,
0.4913381338119507,
0.5635672807693481,
0.16133442521095276,
0.2673581540584564,
0.4232463240623474,
0.23732952773571014,
-0.13941363990306854,
0.10717777162790298,
0.14099235832691193,
-1.0943782329559326,
-0.3649108409881592,
-0.6595838069915771,
-0.3191414177417755,
-0.17286910116672516,
-0.6874022483825684,
0.4826884865760803,
-0.49721843004226685,
0.1279260814189911,
-0.040404073894023895,
-0.10302656143903732,
-0.9377960562705994,
0.20441196858882904,
0.212934210896492,
1.0410953760147095,
-0.8607732057571411,
0.8474940657615662,
0.7333925366401672,
-0.567180335521698,
-0.8916155695915222,
-0.05064786598086357,
0.0007075952598825097,
-0.901126503944397,
0.26089560985565186,
0.31292814016342163,
0.2783009707927704,
-0.17076250910758972,
-0.4747594892978668,
-0.3803129196166992,
0.8988009095191956,
0.11930371820926666,
-0.40761467814445496,
-0.029586168006062508,
0.1206105649471283,
0.7574461698532104,
-0.5192070007324219,
0.5215003490447998,
0.814577579498291,
0.33556923270225525,
0.0017938752425834537,
-1.0242812633514404,
-0.17911837995052338,
-0.3732146620750427,
-0.21949955821037292,
0.09108933806419373,
-0.35410186648368835,
0.8393526673316956,
-0.22655273973941803,
-0.17378289997577667,
0.03231026604771614,
0.4078337848186493,
0.2683328092098236,
0.7343165278434753,
0.5597151517868042,
0.33635157346725464,
0.5763088464736938,
0.12000180780887604,
1.1098746061325073,
-0.2416384071111679,
0.32363802194595337,
1.1472336053848267,
-0.4372347891330719,
1.0067073106765747,
0.12173189222812653,
-0.37569817900657654,
0.5323406457901001,
0.5184128284454346,
0.18977831304073334,
0.12514379620552063,
0.19475439190864563,
0.021466877311468124,
-0.0974929928779602,
-0.20720304548740387,
0.03770063444972038,
0.6120226383209229,
0.41924941539764404,
-0.3967471718788147,
-0.12022724002599716,
-0.018967246636748314,
0.017891593277454376,
0.422487735748291,
-0.2797468602657318,
0.5313198566436768,
0.03688853606581688,
-0.7390971183776855,
0.7823085784912109,
-0.04407664015889168,
1.0440810918807983,
-0.3473256826400757,
0.020404553040862083,
-0.08595854789018631,
0.20567983388900757,
-0.6012974381446838,
-1.0773429870605469,
0.37083306908607483,
0.23250862956047058,
-0.3933148980140686,
-0.13031339645385742,
0.8880423307418823,
-0.6273977756500244,
-0.33690202236175537,
0.7037614583969116,
0.5210213661193848,
0.15082089602947235,
-0.19328297674655914,
-0.5863085389137268,
0.1107233539223671,
0.316500723361969,
0.2184746265411377,
0.5115665793418884,
0.22345638275146484,
0.1362582892179489,
0.4664762318134308,
0.48590415716171265,
0.19296272099018097,
-0.015079382807016373,
0.08058156073093414,
0.7450035214424133,
-0.7860506772994995,
-0.36973124742507935,
-0.6181742548942566,
0.5809157490730286,
0.04003738611936569,
-0.3762987554073334,
0.5129062533378601,
0.4147721529006958,
1.1031423807144165,
0.09067995846271515,
1.153061032295227,
-0.14366160333156586,
0.5832203030586243,
-0.4640031158924103,
0.6104968786239624,
-0.3861432373523712,
0.44306379556655884,
-0.19278201460838318,
-0.6422137022018433,
-0.31004923582077026,
0.4763033986091614,
-0.14772827923297882,
0.15847277641296387,
0.6416686177253723,
0.7763338685035706,
-0.10731802880764008,
0.3126983046531677,
0.41595518589019775,
0.20459192991256714,
0.23597002029418945,
0.8737768530845642,
0.9333558678627014,
-0.3473612368106842,
0.7476332187652588,
-0.17608554661273956,
-0.11841809749603271,
-0.20145730674266815,
-0.6523549556732178,
-1.0022722482681274,
-0.44537341594696045,
0.03472113609313965,
-0.6774476766586304,
-0.057169634848833084,
1.1257948875427246,
0.6023801565170288,
-0.907181978225708,
-0.30990931391716003,
-0.27531200647354126,
0.2159697264432907,
-0.09963764250278473,
-0.2681719660758972,
-0.1996476948261261,
-0.24192054569721222,
-0.48972752690315247,
0.17328661680221558,
0.08767583966255188,
-0.029976414516568184,
-0.1821269392967224,
-0.21106919646263123,
-0.20091499388217926,
-0.05075549706816673,
0.7058939933776855,
0.2290540188550949,
-0.4811568558216095,
-0.33424609899520874,
0.21868517994880676,
-0.3761843144893646,
0.1494334489107132,
1.0807602405548096,
-0.5489991903305054,
0.40825122594833374,
0.36244648694992065,
0.5850958228111267,
0.08625634759664536,
-0.02405332401394844,
0.7282310724258423,
-0.6319662928581238,
0.13474011421203613,
0.09005578607320786,
0.563971757888794,
0.4092298150062561,
-0.32806292176246643,
0.6659421920776367,
0.1877412348985672,
-0.7407216429710388,
-0.6299286484718323,
0.3148083984851837,
-1.067393183708191,
-0.4119986593723297,
1.1948604583740234,
-0.23252376914024353,
-0.04504682496190071,
-0.3485046327114105,
-0.3730221688747406,
0.0929015651345253,
-0.4303728938102722,
0.5223010778427124,
0.8458027839660645,
-0.027526652440428734,
-0.023738902062177658,
-0.7777627110481262,
0.333809494972229,
0.4016319215297699,
-0.7445590496063232,
0.12025913596153259,
0.6604901552200317,
0.3223264515399933,
0.06098091974854469,
0.5229469537734985,
-0.09096698462963104,
0.4474738538265228,
-0.07046730816364288,
0.1932544857263565,
0.12843888998031616,
-0.266558438539505,
-0.6077840924263,
0.042716097086668015,
0.4385204613208771,
0.22944872081279755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05513v1
|
Automatic question generation for propositional logical equivalences
| 2024-05-09T02:44:42 | 2024-05-09T02:44:42 |
Yicheng Yang, Xinyu Wang, Haoming Yu, Zhiyuan Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DM
|
The increase in academic dishonesty cases among college students has raised
concern, particularly due to the shift towards online learning caused by the
pandemic. We aim to develop and implement a method capable of generating
tailored questions for each student. The use of Automatic Question Generation
(AQG) is a possible solution. Previous studies have investigated AQG frameworks
in education, which include validity, user-defined difficulty, and personalized
problem generation. Our new AQG approach produces logical equivalence problems
for Discrete Mathematics, which is a core course for year-one computer science
students. This approach utilizes a syntactic grammar and a semantic attribute
system through top-down parsing and syntax tree transformations. Our
experiments show that the difficulty level of questions generated by our AQG
approach is similar to the questions presented to students in the textbook [1].
These results confirm the practicality of our AQG approach for automated
question generation in education, with the potential to significantly enhance
learning experiences.
|
[
-0.2417605221271515,
-1.1375575065612793,
0.633267879486084,
-0.18663766980171204,
0.0634516105055809,
-0.07580336928367615,
0.18906070291996002,
-0.23287522792816162,
-0.2310638129711151,
0.42303478717803955,
-0.7423896789550781,
-0.3809075951576233,
-0.24432846903800964,
0.5398205518722534,
-0.6923779845237732,
0.7887924313545227,
0.16328592598438263,
-0.04628860577940941,
-0.7586104869842529,
0.11511892080307007,
-0.3143239915370941,
-0.4153803586959839,
-0.901023805141449,
-0.28635284304618835,
-0.12376870214939117,
0.4561421275138855,
0.9118548631668091,
0.5716902613639832,
0.7414358854293823,
0.38883543014526367,
0.48346760869026184,
-0.08955655992031097,
-0.038291774690151215,
0.20056462287902832,
-0.2611106336116791,
-0.4668484032154083,
-0.08479525148868561,
-0.03603500500321388,
0.3849257826805115,
0.8384857773780823,
-0.32989057898521423,
0.4238538146018982,
-0.3450917899608612,
0.5738362073898315,
-0.5841020345687866,
-0.1354144960641861,
-0.8623296618461609,
0.35196056962013245,
0.1466386318206787,
-0.04054548591375351,
-0.37971580028533936,
-0.9310840964317322,
0.2791978418827057,
-0.9041267037391663,
0.38633808493614197,
-0.08421134948730469,
0.7524498105049133,
0.531983494758606,
-0.6015794277191162,
-0.4735901355743408,
-0.47272342443466187,
0.45915937423706055,
-0.6276567578315735,
0.07561520487070084,
0.17752623558044434,
0.5115191340446472,
-0.16797126829624176,
-0.9611358642578125,
-0.8022189736366272,
-0.10694680362939835,
-0.18817469477653503,
0.4326317608356476,
-0.3486312925815582,
0.09399515390396118,
0.44332852959632874,
0.3553810119628906,
-0.9243312478065491,
-0.3634254038333893,
-0.3089790344238281,
-0.183571919798851,
0.8092867732048035,
0.35807138681411743,
0.46600112318992615,
-0.35783836245536804,
-0.4346196949481964,
-0.10981328785419464,
-0.8063860535621643,
0.21381670236587524,
0.5812122225761414,
-0.06489680707454681,
0.47113609313964844,
0.4656965136528015,
-0.06794746220111847,
0.8005877137184143,
0.394992858171463,
0.05712702125310898,
-0.04976344481110573,
-0.2674950659275055,
0.0844692811369896,
0.3539470136165619,
0.491875559091568,
0.28013673424720764,
0.29319053888320923,
0.17876459658145905,
0.0448131263256073,
0.3449009954929352,
0.6234225630760193,
-0.6462739706039429,
-0.45871686935424805,
0.14258930087089539,
-0.023601921275258064,
-0.36003342270851135,
0.13905978202819824,
-0.24114258587360382,
-0.18872885406017303,
-0.5562553405761719,
0.7162480354309082,
-0.34625521302223206,
-0.023178936913609505,
0.3376995325088501,
-0.1351887285709381,
0.39195528626441956,
0.5607909560203552,
-0.3447422981262207,
0.33879554271698,
0.3919413089752197,
0.04832174628973007,
-0.38471221923828125,
-0.1212940365076065,
-0.3129409849643707,
0.1797003597021103,
-0.25611746311187744,
0.6965956091880798,
-0.4580887258052826,
-0.32157185673713684,
0.02413039654493332,
-0.2588527500629425,
-0.08043515682220459,
-0.711226761341095,
0.31899991631507874,
-0.22202922403812408,
0.7417917847633362,
-0.32729777693748474,
-0.5997117757797241,
-0.05173571780323982,
0.5176430940628052,
-0.099092036485672,
0.9666322469711304,
0.2110801488161087,
-0.6252385377883911,
0.002383562969043851,
-0.46880829334259033,
-0.1995730698108673,
0.43369966745376587,
-0.32129618525505066,
-0.39999622106552124,
-0.11448364704847336,
0.041256383061409,
0.1410420835018158,
-0.41931238770484924,
0.2779751420021057,
-0.06937608122825623,
-0.0029299291782081127,
0.2647812068462372,
-0.016334550455212593,
1.079761028289795,
0.12246677279472351,
-0.24808979034423828,
-0.10531630367040634,
-0.784066379070282,
0.4688488245010376,
0.18426921963691711,
-0.15241986513137817,
-0.3935260772705078,
0.1561911255121231,
-0.39835619926452637,
0.2698817551136017,
0.3899366557598114,
-0.5507321357727051,
0.32868924736976624,
-0.4048949182033539,
0.2589125633239746,
0.6732913851737976,
0.24149970710277557,
0.18961527943611145,
-0.4055666923522949,
0.5256211161613464,
0.15306678414344788,
0.08487899601459503,
0.048670895397663116,
-0.33877378702163696,
-0.7832586169242859,
0.12394610792398453,
0.04965538904070854,
0.964016318321228,
-0.7868526577949524,
0.5658754706382751,
0.2520201802253723,
-0.21932213008403778,
-0.3187827467918396,
0.06840815395116806,
0.416240394115448,
0.8781901597976685,
0.3626869022846222,
-0.32034358382225037,
-0.413431853055954,
-0.8477460741996765,
-0.2919621765613556,
-0.566016674041748,
-0.2402728646993637,
0.5035422444343567,
0.49333226680755615,
0.05268624424934387,
1.1277427673339844,
-0.8959973454475403,
-0.06377049535512924,
0.12364352494478226,
0.26986953616142273,
-0.1189378947019577,
0.4955594837665558,
0.5246535539627075,
-0.8452015519142151,
-0.5574317574501038,
-0.2182644158601761,
-0.8990685343742371,
-0.38702601194381714,
-0.11902813613414764,
-0.34650954604148865,
0.11094745248556137,
0.5194963216781616,
-0.5517764687538147,
0.3892156779766083,
-0.10251882672309875,
-0.6761786937713623,
0.7662047147750854,
-0.11132032424211502,
0.2640036344528198,
-1.0873517990112305,
-0.17524762451648712,
-0.2513132095336914,
-0.2209811508655548,
-0.6188860535621643,
0.27096885442733765,
0.02070280723273754,
-0.49140650033950806,
-0.47700098156929016,
0.4014017581939697,
0.10165606439113617,
0.13539470732212067,
-0.07520260661840439,
0.12367624789476395,
0.18126408755779266,
0.12079790979623795,
-0.24496881663799286,
0.5509770512580872,
0.6507676243782043,
-0.6715203523635864,
0.7327992916107178,
0.4038923382759094,
0.18836861848831177,
0.9597530961036682,
-0.6204348802566528,
0.12395063787698746,
-0.22664564847946167,
0.26955991983413696,
-0.9128441214561462,
0.00020149940974079072,
0.21771590411663055,
-0.539092481136322,
-0.1550869345664978,
0.21863599121570587,
-0.05511557683348656,
-0.4371204376220703,
-0.13895492255687714,
0.6741213798522949,
0.4599693715572357,
-0.6742522120475769,
0.5266799330711365,
-0.13777725398540497,
-0.28197038173675537,
-0.4290626049041748,
-0.32711178064346313,
-0.0021023396402597427,
-0.3348897397518158,
-0.7188919186592102,
0.23342768847942352,
-0.1842755675315857,
-0.5650040507316589,
0.27194881439208984,
-0.15658552944660187,
-0.07745962589979172,
0.13428667187690735,
-0.08175057172775269,
0.18522672355175018,
-0.28588759899139404,
0.1916222721338272,
0.14179545640945435,
0.21523365378379822,
0.6123016476631165,
-0.6281726956367493,
0.04876592382788658,
-0.27059632539749146,
-0.3804766535758972,
-0.24298028647899628,
0.5684627890586853,
0.06171135604381561,
-0.3063531816005707,
0.2693690061569214,
0.23478610813617706,
-0.6590075492858887,
-0.41470566391944885,
-0.3556525409221649,
-0.32040029764175415,
-0.49719011783599854,
0.08443670719861984,
-0.3570903241634369,
-0.5949716567993164,
0.5129421353340149,
-0.11449632793664932,
0.08983131498098373,
0.366773784160614,
0.4155316650867462,
-0.03199625760316849,
1.1059439182281494,
0.2781943380832672,
0.5048616528511047,
0.059870652854442596,
-0.05183317884802818,
0.15153294801712036,
-0.02167617343366146,
-0.17426623404026031,
-0.6146740913391113,
0.03317519277334213,
-0.5547378659248352,
0.04743846133351326,
0.5516341924667358,
0.3043191432952881,
-0.48388078808784485,
0.4419727623462677,
-0.6033185720443726,
0.6012954711914062,
0.48305395245552063,
0.12374656647443771,
0.4272187650203705,
-0.1366412341594696,
-0.10838344693183899,
0.05289051681756973,
-0.6406721472740173,
-0.41765668988227844,
0.8981688618659973,
-0.2829396724700928,
0.5248690843582153,
0.2563721537590027,
0.8143643140792847,
0.3926743268966675,
0.12598048150539398,
-0.7841314673423767,
0.6924471855163574,
-0.06871478259563446,
-0.7950630187988281,
-0.5588490962982178,
-0.5021981000900269,
-1.052811861038208,
0.19249306619167328,
-0.4401834309101105,
-0.6969518661499023,
0.11078101396560669,
0.3052891790866852,
-0.24013197422027588,
-0.058292169123888016,
-0.7988413572311401,
0.9118444919586182,
-0.11815454065799713,
-0.27367103099823,
-0.16595056653022766,
-0.6287432909011841,
0.4340366721153259,
-0.12160301208496094,
-0.13653476536273956,
0.02162358909845352,
0.358625203371048,
0.5618983507156372,
-0.5929706692695618,
0.3921564221382141,
-0.06494737416505814,
0.003762179985642433,
0.7332000732421875,
0.50232994556427,
0.2863619327545166,
0.26850053668022156,
-0.05934454873204231,
-0.20549488067626953,
0.21546348929405212,
-0.48670271039009094,
-0.8371455073356628,
0.4883178770542145,
-0.840406596660614,
-1.1188359260559082,
-0.6175023913383484,
-0.8459247946739197,
-0.110667385160923,
0.2172621786594391,
0.0025216317735612392,
0.39604470133781433,
-0.11583111435174942,
0.029460610821843147,
0.7057168483734131,
-0.4398729205131531,
0.4469164311885834,
0.5208531022071838,
0.011538554914295673,
-0.16787119209766388,
0.9427237510681152,
-0.11137740314006805,
0.40263667702674866,
0.3293394446372986,
0.6038485169410706,
-0.30856814980506897,
-0.04219558835029602,
-0.5694782137870789,
-0.027215298265218735,
-0.7233342528343201,
-0.43637168407440186,
-0.33318644762039185,
-0.4228925406932831,
-0.7944738864898682,
-0.38912490010261536,
-0.2208654284477234,
-0.8581663966178894,
-0.2335202991962433,
0.058051787316799164,
0.1710837334394455,
0.5721819400787354,
0.24340710043907166,
-0.0004483697412069887,
-0.6294714212417603,
0.515836238861084,
0.8403159379959106,
-0.1932920217514038,
-0.4803593158721924,
-0.4187794029712677,
0.4076281189918518,
-0.12381003797054291,
-1.0348602533340454,
-0.9388267397880554,
0.0777905210852623,
0.49828413128852844,
0.2762055993080139,
0.42362749576568604,
0.4977297782897949,
0.42260393500328064,
-0.4886190891265869,
0.7315875887870789,
0.297421932220459,
-1.2209813594818115,
0.7242602705955505,
-0.29160410165786743,
0.2690497040748596,
0.4808889329433441,
0.7317212820053101,
-0.2993798851966858,
-0.4712943434715271,
-0.9844987392425537,
-0.6092410683631897,
0.5040127635002136,
0.26966971158981323,
-0.057438142597675323,
-0.07559521496295929,
0.634695291519165,
0.26528504490852356,
0.24516601860523224,
-0.661186695098877,
-0.42691919207572937,
-0.6275179982185364,
-0.39252492785453796,
0.2859223484992981,
0.3848381042480469,
-0.16140396893024445,
-0.37948521971702576,
0.48187726736068726,
-0.31322145462036133,
0.13489685952663422,
0.24906687438488007,
-0.020017534494400024,
-0.24147659540176392,
0.44787395000457764,
0.19304943084716797,
0.9692772626876831,
0.031207937747240067,
0.24527525901794434,
0.36023852229118347,
-0.30076727271080017,
0.40794527530670166,
0.07674727588891983,
-0.5020214319229126,
-0.18511658906936646,
0.09208351373672485,
0.25983309745788574,
-0.29934659600257874,
-0.5970885157585144,
0.5850175619125366,
-0.11520423740148544,
-0.6962252259254456,
-0.6188860535621643,
0.4094104766845703,
-0.24222388863563538,
0.09314022213220596,
0.6047627925872803,
-0.3808661699295044,
0.3852793276309967,
-0.731094241142273,
0.3891145586967468,
0.499355673789978,
0.1366146057844162,
0.14044243097305298,
0.6107884049415588,
0.033520206809043884,
-0.5682408213615417,
0.5687049031257629,
-0.25652873516082764,
-0.5369735360145569,
0.736356258392334,
0.8782098889350891,
0.5128351449966431,
-0.4100370705127716,
0.516237735748291,
0.560400128364563,
0.10424024611711502,
-0.05124960467219353,
0.3351666331291199,
-0.02223433181643486,
-0.6739262938499451,
-0.05702561140060425,
-0.5753177404403687,
-0.8677526712417603,
-0.00403429614380002,
-0.7090868949890137,
0.23859858512878418,
-0.525654673576355,
0.07653049379587173,
-0.07813730835914612,
0.07041347026824951,
-0.4673727750778198,
0.6899797916412354,
-0.12485235184431076,
0.3519634008407593,
-0.8807271718978882,
0.34122398495674133,
1.2382566928863525,
-0.2261359542608261,
-0.7997055053710938,
-0.12361201643943787,
-0.1578156054019928,
-0.4765675663948059,
0.40333569049835205,
-0.08698252588510513,
0.21967904269695282,
0.2635413706302643,
-0.5004016757011414,
-0.6125504970550537,
0.9909785389900208,
0.4661053717136383,
-0.12693311274051666,
-0.23769064247608185,
0.708043098449707,
0.4991084039211273,
-0.39369457960128784,
0.17282642424106598,
0.5067365169525146,
0.36459070444107056,
0.2166985273361206,
-0.5290520787239075,
0.23368410766124725,
-0.4030364155769348,
-0.2967532277107239,
0.3113688826560974,
-0.27719199657440186,
0.7985482215881348,
-0.11996269971132278,
-0.18649722635746002,
-0.2996918261051178,
0.5391514897346497,
0.2623431086540222,
0.508246898651123,
0.5636788606643677,
0.7486405372619629,
0.7516840696334839,
-0.3222431242465973,
0.6195307970046997,
-0.27723580598831177,
0.12883739173412323,
0.7721721529960632,
-0.08461762964725494,
0.37105879187583923,
0.3827698826789856,
-0.15190166234970093,
0.6002153754234314,
0.3535042107105255,
-0.018096154555678368,
-0.004889409523457289,
0.6425427198410034,
-0.35142701864242554,
-0.714959442615509,
-0.03335973620414734,
-0.5547237992286682,
0.5729119181632996,
0.27974459528923035,
0.029375066980719566,
-0.5470329523086548,
-0.02497214637696743,
-0.3827403485774994,
0.5262799859046936,
-0.32063019275665283,
0.7418771386146545,
0.04375438764691353,
-0.8273245096206665,
0.5091228485107422,
0.08680606633424759,
0.013372227549552917,
-0.4427098035812378,
-0.08601748198270798,
-0.1922500878572464,
0.07539870589971542,
-0.3390280306339264,
-0.5612124800682068,
0.2886199355125427,
0.007669619284570217,
-0.03508249670267105,
-0.26727908849716187,
0.7617212533950806,
-0.387535035610199,
-0.6883940100669861,
-0.3239235281944275,
0.7948189377784729,
0.18095695972442627,
0.20446060597896576,
-0.8175974488258362,
-0.5891432762145996,
-0.24210436642169952,
-0.07763592898845673,
0.13170403242111206,
0.5907573103904724,
-0.25034353137016296,
0.6968513131141663,
0.45762529969215393,
-0.14901934564113617,
0.2537784278392792,
-0.2583468556404114,
0.6233992576599121,
-0.5666626691818237,
-0.45492807030677795,
-0.5367124080657959,
0.4427960216999054,
0.1847161054611206,
-0.3353044092655182,
0.8172171115875244,
0.5586658120155334,
1.0957658290863037,
0.050627730786800385,
0.8071387410163879,
-0.18568646907806396,
0.21942999958992004,
-0.16948345303535461,
0.3741319477558136,
-0.5553427934646606,
0.09580029547214508,
-0.5139914751052856,
-0.9719043374061584,
-0.22432976961135864,
0.8509549498558044,
-0.2713208794593811,
-0.30612844228744507,
1.0438425540924072,
0.6842257380485535,
0.015579967759549618,
0.1455887407064438,
0.09993180632591248,
-0.15609362721443176,
0.29848068952560425,
0.8808743357658386,
0.8305319547653198,
-0.627129852771759,
0.6561282873153687,
-0.23868510127067566,
-0.002271710429340601,
0.29481497406959534,
-0.869117796421051,
-1.0302996635437012,
-0.4429210424423218,
-0.8113187551498413,
-0.6099674105644226,
0.2885499596595764,
1.0717147588729858,
-0.011158820241689682,
-0.8339021801948547,
-0.19038766622543335,
-0.5194546580314636,
0.1938111037015915,
0.04041692614555359,
-0.2533406913280487,
0.35933470726013184,
-0.26325318217277527,
-0.32172584533691406,
0.024204380810260773,
-0.19698387384414673,
0.07603055983781815,
-0.13048526644706726,
0.09400990605354309,
-0.17483727633953094,
0.2461777776479721,
0.4072665870189667,
0.23248739540576935,
-0.44030794501304626,
-0.6476290822029114,
-0.01327135507017374,
-0.19257810711860657,
-0.06323256343603134,
0.7826527953147888,
-0.7629097104072571,
0.14218461513519287,
0.6176133751869202,
0.7561105489730835,
0.26360243558883667,
0.49570927023887634,
0.4297899901866913,
-0.6777687072753906,
-0.22061504423618317,
0.3969469666481018,
-0.13222627341747284,
0.1262308806180954,
-0.5194137692451477,
0.11943098157644272,
0.4416654109954834,
-0.4670320451259613,
-0.7558327913284302,
0.48442599177360535,
-0.7251723408699036,
-0.3250024616718292,
0.9321489930152893,
-0.16358740627765656,
0.07761850953102112,
-0.06037280336022377,
-0.17779715359210968,
0.2734297513961792,
0.03897939249873161,
1.2346982955932617,
0.5720020532608032,
-0.45545029640197754,
0.05850130692124367,
-0.2083323448896408,
0.5645200610160828,
0.6733872890472412,
-1.2711000442504883,
-0.17755231261253357,
0.5343464016914368,
0.17320860922336578,
0.1051110327243805,
0.21397124230861664,
-0.048523399978876114,
0.6079282760620117,
-0.15568287670612335,
0.18659783899784088,
-0.10105510801076889,
-0.2564641535282135,
0.07653893530368805,
0.5074408054351807,
-0.19903814792633057,
0.20738963782787323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05990v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05990v2
|
Special Characters Attack: Toward Scalable Training Data Extraction From Large Language Models
| 2024-05-09T02:35:32 | 2024-05-20T14:40:03 |
Yang Bai, Ge Pei, Jindong Gu, Yong Yang, Xingjun Ma
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable performance on a wide
range of tasks. However, recent studies have shown that LLMs can memorize
training data and simple repeated tokens can trick the model to leak the data.
In this paper, we take a step further and show that certain special characters
or their combinations with English letters are stronger memory triggers,
leading to more severe data leakage. The intuition is that, since LLMs are
trained with massive data that contains a substantial amount of special
characters (e.g. structural symbols {, } of JSON files, and @, # in emails and
online posts), the model may memorize the co-occurrence between these special
characters and the raw texts. This motivates us to propose a simple but
effective Special Characters Attack (SCA) to induce training data leakage. Our
experiments verify the high effectiveness of SCA against state-of-the-art LLMs:
they can leak diverse training data, such as code corpus, web pages, and
personally identifiable information, and sometimes generate non-stop outputs as
a byproduct. We further show that the composition of the training data corpus
can be revealed by inspecting the leaked data -- one crucial piece of
information for pre-training high-performance LLMs. Our work can help
understand the sensitivity of LLMs to special characters and identify potential
areas for improvement.
|
[
-0.02698754519224167,
-0.9427291750907898,
0.5266023278236389,
-0.11127875000238419,
-0.30849170684814453,
0.38933703303337097,
-0.12981204688549042,
-0.5261500477790833,
0.41976770758628845,
0.8300459384918213,
-0.37036851048469543,
-0.4891013205051422,
-0.8913687467575073,
0.13439767062664032,
-0.6426151990890503,
0.8499802350997925,
0.04802975431084633,
0.21684707701206207,
0.24636034667491913,
-0.19638343155384064,
-0.36691519618034363,
-1.055693507194519,
-0.5557539463043213,
0.1663178652524948,
0.7507230043411255,
0.16051220893859863,
0.47266894578933716,
0.6364107131958008,
0.7440157532691956,
0.24164855480194092,
-0.02350800856947899,
0.07937677204608917,
-0.7899882197380066,
0.1292150765657425,
-0.013560587540268898,
-0.6960799694061279,
-0.38460323214530945,
-0.43656352162361145,
0.7429789304733276,
0.28696921467781067,
0.1429271697998047,
0.10133626312017441,
-0.20378386974334717,
0.5546584129333496,
-0.6204013228416443,
0.04418986290693283,
-0.9950944781303406,
0.08949089795351028,
-0.7357463836669922,
-0.2647612690925598,
-0.43996211886405945,
0.07542286068201065,
-0.32228851318359375,
-0.4283546805381775,
0.1743551641702652,
0.09178180992603302,
0.8564239740371704,
0.13372710347175598,
-0.23992040753364563,
-0.30063751339912415,
-0.5929408073425293,
0.6660001873970032,
-0.6091558933258057,
0.23632563650608063,
0.2376275360584259,
0.4149128794670105,
-0.24048835039138794,
-0.6157970428466797,
-0.6292990446090698,
-0.19078312814235687,
0.12070220708847046,
-0.10068803280591965,
-0.17932677268981934,
-0.033838383853435516,
0.5962376594543457,
0.3826969265937805,
-0.5009976029396057,
0.3872969448566437,
-0.2853148281574249,
-0.15771770477294922,
0.7889034152030945,
0.1310156285762787,
0.7862054109573364,
0.13841964304447174,
-0.3984975218772888,
0.02631283737719059,
-1.1392173767089844,
-0.1348685622215271,
0.6341870427131653,
0.4199938476085663,
0.01148794312030077,
0.5214207768440247,
0.15232916176319122,
0.22845129668712616,
-0.05405035614967346,
0.13806287944316864,
0.06270957738161087,
-0.045563705265522,
-0.13866481184959412,
-0.1894581913948059,
0.9584868550300598,
-0.19078654050827026,
0.518868625164032,
-0.353358656167984,
-0.2529963254928589,
0.010327772237360477,
0.3083391785621643,
-0.7718151211738586,
-0.19182051718235016,
0.0291967261582613,
-0.22471942007541656,
-0.344676673412323,
0.03404400497674942,
-0.6629626750946045,
-0.5113596320152283,
0.17201922833919525,
0.3204868733882904,
-0.31393396854400635,
-0.1931636482477188,
0.1431407779455185,
-0.05624941363930702,
-0.11021467298269272,
-0.006693806499242783,
-1.1668933629989624,
0.08320587128400803,
0.5728214979171753,
0.4038172960281372,
-0.35749417543411255,
-0.32816213369369507,
-0.6122772097587585,
0.3151259124279022,
-0.1204981580376625,
0.7755433917045593,
-0.791818380355835,
-0.4318198263645172,
0.0921943262219429,
0.067947618663311,
-0.014352080412209034,
-0.43590420484542847,
0.3473197817802429,
-0.8137397170066833,
-0.25237637758255005,
-0.31761908531188965,
-0.5979391932487488,
0.2845604717731476,
0.16681881248950958,
-0.9774420857429504,
0.9928922653198242,
-0.14947625994682312,
-0.9162038564682007,
0.11808782070875168,
-0.42674389481544495,
-0.5455264449119568,
0.188754603266716,
-0.42306289076805115,
-0.4111517369747162,
0.1601940393447876,
0.38435614109039307,
0.745124876499176,
0.02243752032518387,
-0.21780909597873688,
-0.4670528769493103,
-0.4713464677333832,
0.7508873343467712,
-0.35463428497314453,
0.5342535972595215,
0.06768599152565002,
-0.03818141669034958,
-0.19047054648399353,
-0.7017330527305603,
-0.19047951698303223,
0.5863640904426575,
-0.4919445514678955,
-0.4390566051006317,
-0.1930324137210846,
-0.16173051297664642,
-0.04448685795068741,
0.33153101801872253,
-0.38941746950149536,
0.570076584815979,
-0.1678873747587204,
0.25303956866264343,
0.7425758242607117,
0.20141345262527466,
0.3242269456386566,
-0.01409522257745266,
0.7346655130386353,
0.08494190126657486,
-0.060242682695388794,
-0.45850205421447754,
-0.18932966887950897,
-0.5038357377052307,
-0.6932736039161682,
0.33357754349708557,
0.3779549300670624,
-0.6315889954566956,
0.19928191602230072,
-0.1459084451198578,
-0.435975044965744,
-0.418701171875,
0.3340708613395691,
0.44656115770339966,
0.13628646731376648,
0.21287287771701813,
-0.22450798749923706,
-0.6986648440361023,
-0.735347330570221,
-0.8238042593002319,
0.021092213690280914,
-0.061684153974056244,
0.2179420292377472,
0.5958479046821594,
-0.21094924211502075,
0.5238010287284851,
-0.5419161319732666,
-0.06172197684645653,
-0.4844485819339752,
-0.11758272349834442,
-0.04790600389242172,
0.3414377272129059,
0.49377357959747314,
-0.5996545553207397,
-0.45106562972068787,
-0.3335728347301483,
-0.8105177879333496,
0.10970011353492737,
-0.48036378622055054,
-0.06757687777280807,
-0.06241510808467865,
0.6212710738182068,
-0.7587477564811707,
0.25850048661231995,
0.47840845584869385,
-0.3818990886211395,
0.6707093119621277,
0.0027301006484776735,
-0.060221754014492035,
-1.003736972808838,
0.04717017337679863,
-0.08792245388031006,
-0.1546478271484375,
-0.6894172430038452,
0.3192916214466095,
0.23763996362686157,
-0.1556171476840973,
-0.5706398487091064,
0.4948025047779083,
-0.6525892019271851,
0.024111580103635788,
-0.04525679722428322,
-0.06123918294906616,
-0.14506162703037262,
0.4558553397655487,
-0.23722980916500092,
0.6710333228111267,
0.5438886880874634,
-0.24840594828128815,
0.18101075291633606,
0.15131282806396484,
-0.1235436350107193,
0.2078854888677597,
-0.5182658433914185,
0.5854241251945496,
0.1302405297756195,
0.21776215732097626,
-0.7124009728431702,
-0.13410355150699615,
-0.020180659368634224,
-0.4438480734825134,
0.8023028373718262,
-0.20917567610740662,
-0.8282033205032349,
-0.10749370604753494,
-0.18605588376522064,
0.11646784842014313,
0.3065646290779114,
-0.6107175946235657,
0.27518877387046814,
0.701241672039032,
-0.058286152780056,
-0.6972392201423645,
-0.7345844507217407,
0.3534905016422272,
-0.32429227232933044,
-0.5104466080665588,
-0.0007668344187550247,
-0.100835420191288,
0.047810811549425125,
-0.2988620102405548,
-0.12893807888031006,
-0.1950961798429489,
0.466220498085022,
0.20822231471538544,
0.31023266911506653,
-0.0748039111495018,
-0.16558806598186493,
-0.015911702066659927,
-0.11001599580049515,
0.05868116021156311,
0.1217394769191742,
0.5644254684448242,
-0.042865507304668427,
-0.5762264728546143,
-0.6802250742912292,
0.6251057982444763,
0.8036465644836426,
-0.19306239485740662,
0.9049684405326843,
0.4234046936035156,
-0.5012922286987305,
-0.41483739018440247,
-0.43775853514671326,
-0.4891356825828552,
-0.4839347004890442,
0.8020129203796387,
-0.3998207449913025,
-0.6938612461090088,
0.5373600125312805,
-0.1094055324792862,
0.019558807834982872,
0.20316897332668304,
0.297744482755661,
-0.22949470579624176,
1.2658528089523315,
0.7401794195175171,
-0.30972111225128174,
0.6502255201339722,
-0.32172226905822754,
0.27655982971191406,
-0.4137669801712036,
-0.169629767537117,
-0.4324263632297516,
-0.21534709632396698,
-0.24526186287403107,
-0.156990185379982,
-0.19593331217765808,
0.40945130586624146,
-0.052826154977083206,
0.3653942942619324,
-0.10471831262111664,
0.8805209994316101,
0.10768195241689682,
-0.15054810047149658,
0.1372479945421219,
0.29382285475730896,
-0.0974780023097992,
-0.2810794711112976,
-0.488450288772583,
-0.6439273953437805,
1.3142857551574707,
0.6157404184341431,
0.7223111987113953,
-0.15177465975284576,
0.7862997055053711,
0.23393835127353668,
0.07543455809354782,
-0.47901833057403564,
0.544790506362915,
-0.35145094990730286,
-0.4953862428665161,
-0.047101426869630814,
-0.2871183156967163,
-0.8899019360542297,
0.05847323313355446,
-0.4373442232608795,
-0.7162286639213562,
-0.18804414570331573,
0.04399973154067993,
-0.07176380604505539,
0.5784317255020142,
-0.7320191264152527,
0.6473051905632019,
-0.38348183035850525,
-0.04660077765583992,
-0.14459650218486786,
-0.4226683974266052,
0.2952612638473511,
-0.4188641309738159,
0.09057602286338806,
0.03966566175222397,
0.04179386422038078,
0.9434239864349365,
-0.28348299860954285,
0.9485134482383728,
-0.07295700162649155,
0.010918552055954933,
-0.07666334509849548,
0.1899050921201706,
1.0508882999420166,
-0.05475950241088867,
0.15295591950416565,
0.6495468020439148,
-0.13513392210006714,
-0.6419600248336792,
-0.7430972456932068,
0.4284716248512268,
-0.6887305974960327,
-0.4075389504432678,
-0.3042443096637726,
-0.5261210799217224,
-0.29502007365226746,
0.22772137820720673,
0.19280856847763062,
0.19597788155078888,
-0.10809796303510666,
0.16839230060577393,
0.9021767973899841,
0.00464530847966671,
0.3673895001411438,
0.6191341280937195,
0.008875385858118534,
-0.3130187392234802,
0.9924651384353638,
0.2538740634918213,
0.24851419031620026,
0.4116954207420349,
0.04389633983373642,
-0.0073174950666725636,
-1.0835896730422974,
-0.5386034250259399,
0.5019961595535278,
-0.5404610633850098,
-0.2327723205089569,
-0.6346290707588196,
-0.2856730818748474,
-0.33281734585762024,
-0.1620456576347351,
-0.38334590196609497,
-0.5613230466842651,
-0.41417059302330017,
-0.25354811549186707,
0.1912325918674469,
0.7953847050666809,
0.4291321337223053,
0.5226277709007263,
-1.043518304824829,
0.24955958127975464,
0.09044068306684494,
-0.07704158872365952,
-0.10002019256353378,
-0.47837135195732117,
-0.5662093758583069,
-0.2132207155227661,
-0.1886427104473114,
-1.0841118097305298,
0.5855457782745361,
-0.044589798897504807,
0.7142006158828735,
0.765974760055542,
-0.12445362657308578,
0.5568759441375732,
-0.511499285697937,
0.8276945948600769,
0.27903205156326294,
-0.6449248790740967,
0.25667235255241394,
-0.4329061210155487,
0.027438921853899956,
0.47236648201942444,
0.39377716183662415,
-0.571628987789154,
-0.7367700934410095,
-0.7584200501441956,
-0.9305860996246338,
0.6078016757965088,
0.07557867467403412,
0.24443012475967407,
0.0731993019580841,
0.4586579203605652,
0.20946244895458221,
0.13145501911640167,
-0.5862165093421936,
-0.33595818281173706,
0.09943372011184692,
-0.3838278353214264,
0.2599440813064575,
-0.6006949543952942,
-0.12277289479970932,
0.33907535672187805,
0.4098320007324219,
0.10593198239803314,
-0.018309583887457848,
-0.29950153827667236,
-0.5328031778335571,
0.21324190497398376,
0.22515437006950378,
0.234172061085701,
0.3873533606529236,
0.21409167349338531,
0.3098459839820862,
0.4884234666824341,
-0.9104608297348022,
-0.1682790219783783,
-0.27570340037345886,
-0.056638892740011215,
-0.174339160323143,
0.6689274311065674,
0.5369336605072021,
0.2837279736995697,
-0.8070234060287476,
0.5375999212265015,
-0.2954186797142029,
0.1734420508146286,
-0.14058633148670197,
0.16415682435035706,
0.18596705794334412,
0.2325221598148346,
0.6340497732162476,
-0.09589360654354095,
-0.33946892619132996,
-0.4988785684108734,
0.23556174337863922,
0.38303142786026,
-0.12624560296535492,
-0.6406867504119873,
0.29082489013671875,
0.19031889736652374,
-0.4043671488761902,
0.32387784123420715,
-0.0012050570221617818,
-0.7221291065216064,
0.5669256448745728,
0.8641663789749146,
0.7539032697677612,
-0.401408851146698,
-0.22832243144512177,
0.09838028252124786,
0.3617814779281616,
-0.10380112379789352,
0.3154948949813843,
0.052073489874601364,
-0.5270363688468933,
-0.15285754203796387,
-0.5621603727340698,
-0.21276873350143433,
0.3709312379360199,
-0.6061059236526489,
0.19578836858272552,
-0.7439837455749512,
0.1342657506465912,
-0.20592530071735382,
0.0758289247751236,
-0.5635344982147217,
0.06866975128650665,
0.3863299489021301,
0.7710183262825012,
-1.0158107280731201,
0.9348730444908142,
0.40156257152557373,
-0.4106505811214447,
-0.7499513030052185,
-0.04511985182762146,
-0.12639658153057098,
-1.0436732769012451,
0.831333577632904,
0.1607481837272644,
0.11785855144262314,
-0.3235820531845093,
-0.560734212398529,
-0.8735730648040771,
0.6545253992080688,
0.8386464715003967,
-0.9556925892829895,
-0.29217469692230225,
0.4312896132469177,
0.42803525924682617,
-0.35958829522132874,
0.13975994288921356,
0.5883890390396118,
0.30395954847335815,
-0.2238563746213913,
-0.37071797251701355,
0.35768091678619385,
-0.2945959270000458,
-0.19031363725662231,
0.09860642999410629,
-0.5367947220802307,
0.6766161918640137,
-0.24068915843963623,
-0.5018566250801086,
-0.16599515080451965,
0.6928389072418213,
0.34466275572776794,
0.05616435408592224,
0.39877769351005554,
0.5200419425964355,
1.0134426355361938,
0.16758137941360474,
0.886527419090271,
-0.2455049455165863,
0.018267404288053513,
0.9897000789642334,
-0.24207064509391785,
1.1111208200454712,
0.6054290533065796,
-0.039271995425224304,
0.3054054081439972,
0.4654920697212219,
-0.13175101578235626,
0.4003153443336487,
0.23756645619869232,
-0.21251021325588226,
-0.195180743932724,
0.3367161452770233,
-0.36965858936309814,
0.36445096135139465,
0.5306939482688904,
-0.36349812150001526,
0.061964068561792374,
0.022413108497858047,
0.4684017300605774,
-0.03964173048734665,
-0.22697918117046356,
0.7277786135673523,
0.18896953761577606,
-0.08613252639770508,
0.5430200099945068,
-0.10283728688955307,
0.5079914927482605,
-0.7460736036300659,
0.11763064563274384,
-0.23598363995552063,
0.22905880212783813,
-0.36893826723098755,
-0.3799857199192047,
0.18498975038528442,
0.3823101818561554,
-0.1183265894651413,
-0.29750171303749084,
0.679873526096344,
-0.3350589871406555,
-0.40969082713127136,
0.17490088939666748,
0.0673612728714943,
0.3811790645122528,
-0.27528703212738037,
-0.6680415272712708,
0.31414467096328735,
-0.035797011107206345,
-0.3092641532421112,
0.6456918120384216,
0.3364573121070862,
-0.04121211916208267,
0.4808407127857208,
0.9090028405189514,
0.5841506719589233,
0.2761552631855011,
0.09531400352716446,
0.8291622996330261,
-0.8131712079048157,
-0.5592970848083496,
-1.0414483547210693,
0.3022252917289734,
-0.245016947388649,
-0.06620196253061295,
1.0822519063949585,
0.5333003997802734,
0.6565391421318054,
0.03349781408905983,
0.9857375025749207,
0.5480295419692993,
0.3190518021583557,
-0.7493680715560913,
1.1260677576065063,
-0.2527220845222473,
0.5159542560577393,
-0.12001866102218628,
-0.5325280427932739,
-0.40030694007873535,
0.07431232929229736,
-0.20695655047893524,
-0.20065774023532867,
0.9720337986946106,
0.8400230407714844,
0.0319381020963192,
-0.004217212088406086,
0.43441104888916016,
0.39886578917503357,
0.6666624546051025,
0.49719715118408203,
0.8947756886482239,
-0.39891576766967773,
0.8169134259223938,
0.2077389806509018,
-0.07614419609308243,
-0.46167999505996704,
-0.6259402632713318,
-1.2316474914550781,
-0.3400228023529053,
-0.24639949202537537,
-0.3912743330001831,
0.14973893761634827,
0.36148059368133545,
0.6288884878158569,
-0.7887585759162903,
0.14643993973731995,
-0.031896185129880905,
0.06784125417470932,
0.032300133258104324,
-0.10674307495355606,
0.5474179983139038,
-0.29000356793403625,
-0.6027384400367737,
0.7708335518836975,
0.1107434630393982,
0.28403931856155396,
-0.36023369431495667,
0.08067184686660767,
0.10822853446006775,
0.3341844379901886,
0.11333045363426208,
0.605975866317749,
-0.38256630301475525,
-0.17178383469581604,
0.023773614317178726,
-0.3104681074619293,
-0.005243548657745123,
1.1060820817947388,
-0.5383893251419067,
0.24991589784622192,
0.5766358971595764,
0.8856644034385681,
0.5889144539833069,
-0.35543835163116455,
0.4171082079410553,
-0.8309782147407532,
0.07071002572774887,
0.22122040390968323,
0.6043103933334351,
0.3579699397087097,
-0.6777729392051697,
-0.006827084813266993,
0.3162137567996979,
-0.35196664929389954,
-1.301329493522644,
0.2702201008796692,
-0.8041491508483887,
-0.25759628415107727,
1.239824652671814,
-0.4746088683605194,
-0.4969158172607422,
-0.13887451589107513,
-0.22563335299491882,
0.3436841368675232,
-0.38065972924232483,
0.9052602648735046,
0.5102326273918152,
0.25756508111953735,
0.2731342017650604,
-0.5123028755187988,
0.3778601288795471,
0.37318986654281616,
-0.8607127666473389,
0.43749141693115234,
0.09044669568538666,
0.4552617371082306,
-0.04172306880354881,
0.4095054566860199,
-0.3140016794204712,
0.09854339063167572,
0.14370262622833252,
-0.08896439522504807,
-0.41234058141708374,
-0.4798411428928375,
-0.658174991607666,
0.45716843008995056,
-0.0886920690536499,
-0.2124907374382019
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.