id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08355v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08355v1
|
Seal-Tools: Self-Instruct Tool Learning Dataset for Agent Tuning and Detailed Benchmark
| 2024-05-14T06:50:19 | 2024-05-14T06:50:19 |
Mengsong Wu, Tong Zhu, Han Han, Chuanyuan Tan, Xiang Zhang, Wenliang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a new tool learning dataset Seal-Tools, which contains
self-instruct API-like tools. Seal-Tools not only offers a large number of
tools, but also includes instances which demonstrate the practical application
of tools. Seeking to generate data on a large scale while ensuring reliability,
we propose a self-instruct method to generate tools and instances, allowing
precise control over the process. Moreover, our Seal-Tools contains hard
instances that call multiple tools to complete the job, among which some are
nested tool callings. For precise and comprehensive evaluation, we use strict
format control and design three metrics from different dimensions. Therefore,
Seal-Tools can serve as a new benchmark to evaluate the tool-calling ability of
LLMs. Finally, we evaluate several prevalent LLMs and our finetuned model on
Seal-Tools. The results show that current systems are far from perfect. The
code, data and experiment results are available at
https://github.com/fairyshine/Seal-Tools .
|
[
-0.4967716336250305,
-0.47877880930900574,
0.24993857741355896,
0.07054199278354645,
-0.21894747018814087,
0.46100330352783203,
0.03463909402489662,
-0.4409218728542328,
0.1938953697681427,
0.5734071135520935,
-0.728773295879364,
-0.6413965821266174,
-0.17149852216243744,
0.2392081320285797,
-0.21053996682167053,
0.838192343711853,
0.1403994858264923,
-0.11960218846797943,
-0.21510377526283264,
0.08066056668758392,
-0.3675209581851959,
-0.1327694058418274,
-0.8153515458106995,
-0.4328062832355499,
0.26798006892204285,
0.6162475347518921,
0.6880968809127808,
1.0483242273330688,
0.3033294081687927,
0.3666495382785797,
0.4923478364944458,
0.38917046785354614,
-0.37643229961395264,
0.29376623034477234,
-0.49160993099212646,
-0.5878635048866272,
-0.7330361008644104,
0.4545825123786926,
0.2487376630306244,
0.19539505243301392,
-0.2493821233510971,
0.5124436616897583,
0.112040676176548,
0.3103274703025818,
-0.7450864315032959,
0.2922210991382599,
-0.8607025146484375,
-0.013949977234005928,
-0.24838468432426453,
-0.2690403163433075,
-0.3843878507614136,
-0.1098780483007431,
-0.16279055178165436,
-0.8450665473937988,
0.27962514758110046,
0.10244458168745041,
0.6654862761497498,
0.6600678563117981,
-0.3678770065307617,
-0.1919323056936264,
-0.47403496503829956,
0.8807011246681213,
-0.6799795031547546,
0.04939845949411392,
0.39104607701301575,
0.7707633376121521,
-0.2733529210090637,
-0.9344070553779602,
-0.034921638667583466,
-0.08561299741268158,
0.12763959169387817,
0.2994003891944885,
0.15500693023204803,
0.0005157029954716563,
0.11440140753984451,
0.2009161114692688,
-0.3110751211643219,
0.5430923104286194,
-0.20823340117931366,
-0.396631121635437,
1.0205893516540527,
0.48355358839035034,
-0.18158915638923645,
0.3360239863395691,
-0.5734139680862427,
-0.5899234414100647,
-0.7303960919380188,
0.1448514610528946,
0.6239064931869507,
0.2868383228778839,
-0.023235701024532318,
0.14099404215812683,
-0.37510013580322266,
0.4472106695175171,
0.16146017611026764,
-0.4804130792617798,
0.413368284702301,
0.10064513981342316,
-0.3173978924751282,
-0.02124239131808281,
0.7474187016487122,
0.5093950033187866,
0.28315314650535583,
-0.2497379034757614,
-0.5782842040061951,
-0.16817834973335266,
0.47345173358917236,
-0.6944253444671631,
-0.14619095623493195,
0.21856848895549774,
-0.23373126983642578,
-0.6292802691459656,
0.05060229077935219,
-0.5856795310974121,
-0.5072445869445801,
-0.3522091209888458,
0.2704884707927704,
0.0099154282361269,
-0.46723106503486633,
0.20506325364112854,
-0.09836192429065704,
0.7266528010368347,
0.3652845025062561,
-0.38486817479133606,
0.6756060123443604,
0.6793301105499268,
0.7315304279327393,
-0.3009287416934967,
-0.48865607380867004,
-0.630353569984436,
0.14051319658756256,
-0.5056277513504028,
0.9753835201263428,
-0.47087347507476807,
-0.4106212258338928,
0.03285077586770058,
0.273356556892395,
0.13932088017463684,
-0.8526579141616821,
0.28809669613838196,
-0.35088011622428894,
-0.22281266748905182,
-0.0227420125156641,
-0.6611644625663757,
-0.07212959229946136,
0.19321076571941376,
-0.6059763431549072,
1.2638615369796753,
0.18848146498203278,
-0.273477166891098,
0.4753163754940033,
-0.6321861147880554,
-0.2868266701698303,
0.27484551072120667,
-0.1473637819290161,
-0.9473088979721069,
-0.15736781060695648,
0.2360605001449585,
0.8006815910339355,
-0.5128837823867798,
-0.032111067324876785,
-0.8181778192520142,
-0.3696924149990082,
0.2663615345954895,
-0.10413230210542679,
0.4672197997570038,
0.43381214141845703,
-0.4325311779975891,
0.15295840799808502,
-0.5595099925994873,
0.3757619559764862,
0.19628827273845673,
0.24413347244262695,
0.16044871509075165,
-0.23372459411621094,
-0.23565180599689484,
0.03655136749148369,
0.29542094469070435,
-0.5190268754959106,
0.47296714782714844,
-0.23221831023693085,
0.30436840653419495,
0.9797852635383606,
0.11465106159448624,
0.2679203748703003,
-0.4668773412704468,
0.8632259368896484,
-0.22151470184326172,
0.6028034090995789,
0.07754833996295929,
0.07558788359165192,
-0.6896668076515198,
-0.40542715787887573,
0.28569409251213074,
0.33584123849868774,
-0.6612960696220398,
0.5493292212486267,
0.16136299073696136,
-0.8983383178710938,
-0.6516085267066956,
0.28787195682525635,
0.451060950756073,
0.1501816213130951,
0.0956694558262825,
-0.37886446714401245,
-0.27799853682518005,
-1.050646185874939,
-0.02546294778585434,
0.13451208174228668,
0.004114110022783279,
0.20806297659873962,
0.6743833422660828,
-0.030938012525439262,
0.9203778505325317,
-0.5133916139602661,
-0.34950485825538635,
0.21271155774593353,
-0.08407152444124222,
0.263915091753006,
0.23835137486457825,
0.6760202646255493,
-0.32490795850753784,
-0.5443772077560425,
-0.2617739737033844,
-0.8019794225692749,
-0.04973078519105911,
0.024264926090836525,
-0.2376643419265747,
0.05353936180472374,
0.811541736125946,
-0.3091410994529724,
0.3806167244911194,
0.33519044518470764,
-0.007853265851736069,
1.0100489854812622,
-0.1831670105457306,
-0.3540579378604889,
-0.8028640747070312,
-0.0897405818104744,
-0.08469340205192566,
-0.4558247923851013,
-0.40592536330223083,
0.0475165955722332,
0.12835459411144257,
-0.037846639752388,
-0.554198682308197,
0.6731677055358887,
-0.6823428869247437,
-0.29660022258758545,
-0.4897479712963104,
-0.17286987602710724,
-0.1238766759634018,
0.4247165024280548,
-0.1782323569059372,
1.1154261827468872,
0.7619314789772034,
-0.7460163831710815,
0.6820642948150635,
0.03091028891503811,
-0.15740525722503662,
0.5031486749649048,
-0.712470531463623,
0.5391392707824707,
0.3329930901527405,
0.05840795487165451,
-0.5229874849319458,
-0.15957042574882507,
0.3707917034626007,
-0.07172034680843353,
0.3261367082595825,
-0.5349717736244202,
-0.8669458031654358,
-0.38070544600486755,
-0.46515539288520813,
0.03049127385020256,
0.4431779086589813,
-0.6180064678192139,
0.44631749391555786,
0.24612176418304443,
0.040269382297992706,
-0.5983268022537231,
-0.17533688247203827,
-0.23596179485321045,
-0.44374656677246094,
-0.3566749393939972,
0.00284026307053864,
-0.20339225232601166,
-0.009110411629080772,
-0.1462865024805069,
-0.43856632709503174,
0.006208693142980337,
0.25281792879104614,
0.4208338260650635,
0.041528914123773575,
0.023693663999438286,
0.47939956188201904,
0.004025816451758146,
-0.3509545922279358,
0.1351526379585266,
-0.28987547755241394,
0.46625736355781555,
-0.5645074248313904,
-0.7623125314712524,
-0.1361774355173111,
-0.23976168036460876,
0.6273777484893799,
-0.5130371451377869,
0.36463066935539246,
0.7105705142021179,
0.09128255397081375,
-0.6839917302131653,
-0.7628902196884155,
-0.5225505232810974,
-0.6500325798988342,
-0.10042233020067215,
-0.7265978455543518,
-0.433540940284729,
0.531701922416687,
-0.680228590965271,
0.22456778585910797,
0.36188817024230957,
0.3583720624446869,
-0.1967749297618866,
0.6123121380805969,
0.5719034671783447,
-0.21774719655513763,
0.1902499496936798,
-0.5969951748847961,
-0.4730086028575897,
-0.7179527878761292,
0.03387008607387543,
-0.27007871866226196,
-0.1788603514432907,
-0.6001042127609253,
-0.1312139332294464,
0.532570481300354,
0.14334537088871002,
-0.3758743405342102,
0.2062641680240631,
-0.8793233036994934,
0.5248726010322571,
0.6519922018051147,
-0.03928098827600479,
0.21036413311958313,
-0.06078222766518593,
-0.12522825598716736,
0.31412163376808167,
-0.576021671295166,
-0.7289572954177856,
1.4302523136138916,
0.4664737582206726,
1.1091909408569336,
-0.22756251692771912,
0.8292840719223022,
0.5904718041419983,
0.16633516550064087,
-0.6208394765853882,
0.4555012285709381,
0.3855815827846527,
-0.4839681088924408,
-0.6185764670372009,
0.14005805552005768,
-1.221341609954834,
0.31755882501602173,
0.06536423414945602,
-0.5372970104217529,
0.13107454776763916,
0.0848107859492302,
-0.08411996066570282,
0.3428267538547516,
-0.648612916469574,
0.6674020290374756,
-0.3221455216407776,
-0.4003588855266571,
0.023024683818221092,
-0.5378720164299011,
0.0991329550743103,
-0.1753791868686676,
-0.1385369598865509,
-0.5639016628265381,
-0.2873804569244385,
0.6000629663467407,
-0.6417829990386963,
1.142009973526001,
-0.237200528383255,
-0.28157293796539307,
0.484657883644104,
0.07468152046203613,
0.8207507133483887,
0.23926077783107758,
-0.3584882915019989,
-0.054122913628816605,
0.2238621562719345,
-0.41623759269714355,
-0.7181551456451416,
0.398831307888031,
-0.913456380367279,
-0.5022839307785034,
-0.4749702215194702,
-0.37880590558052063,
-0.08955445140600204,
0.2733837068080902,
0.1183108314871788,
0.45302581787109375,
0.028632119297981262,
0.0037087989039719105,
0.5685331225395203,
0.15696386992931366,
0.4831516146659851,
1.1700326204299927,
-0.08430426567792892,
-0.21009525656700134,
0.9076299071311951,
0.13509826362133026,
0.17308133840560913,
-0.0699719712138176,
-0.0796554833650589,
-0.26788780093193054,
-0.3873199224472046,
-0.2482101321220398,
0.3022323548793793,
-0.44056183099746704,
-0.8303521871566772,
0.002167691709473729,
-0.359842985868454,
-0.21744373440742493,
-0.08198465406894684,
-0.8291382789611816,
0.026642542332410812,
-0.10516828298568726,
-0.20505575835704803,
0.6322276592254639,
0.8812063336372375,
-0.35335272550582886,
0.4615504741668701,
-0.42710405588150024,
0.04997120052576065,
0.30508336424827576,
0.6529030203819275,
-0.26136812567710876,
-0.07619905471801758,
-0.471491277217865,
-0.0892128124833107,
-0.5682527422904968,
-0.6785886287689209,
0.234708771109581,
0.32606762647628784,
0.8422864675521851,
0.6453207731246948,
0.5963995456695557,
0.19218862056732178,
-0.09754937142133713,
0.3274005949497223,
-0.20781801640987396,
-0.7396412491798401,
0.6065247058868408,
-0.5119054913520813,
0.3954428732395172,
0.49160516262054443,
0.241177037358284,
-0.16202916204929352,
-0.6667748093605042,
-0.8754854798316956,
-0.5318634510040283,
0.6526271104812622,
0.2656373679637909,
-0.4752036929130554,
0.3570091724395752,
0.5697028636932373,
0.46685460209846497,
0.4015919864177704,
-0.28379473090171814,
-0.470011830329895,
-0.12520214915275574,
0.23290486633777618,
-0.35152435302734375,
-0.08544137328863144,
-0.24948908388614655,
-0.08710350096225739,
0.80107581615448,
-0.5389089584350586,
0.19839386641979218,
0.08227488398551941,
-0.09194820374250412,
0.050720252096652985,
0.34850385785102844,
0.3122214674949646,
0.7406057715415955,
-0.3387940526008606,
0.012774513103067875,
0.48114413022994995,
-0.3340207040309906,
0.4165182411670685,
-0.07544690370559692,
0.03656011074781418,
-0.3152656853199005,
0.4225464463233948,
0.491045206785202,
-0.08231758326292038,
-0.3762875497341156,
0.3034905791282654,
0.25123098492622375,
-0.35524246096611023,
-0.6517032980918884,
0.3057464361190796,
-0.13856151700019836,
0.30981773138046265,
0.164805069565773,
-0.2943572402000427,
0.2517363429069519,
-0.3017049729824066,
0.2081494778394699,
0.43667739629745483,
-0.4813518524169922,
-0.2572840750217438,
0.14384686946868896,
0.4158627986907959,
-0.2361425757408142,
0.6323482990264893,
-0.6787375807762146,
-0.30854594707489014,
0.6947323083877563,
0.3655136227607727,
0.93190598487854,
-0.35300183296203613,
0.35787636041641235,
0.10837873816490173,
0.5146468281745911,
0.05633901059627533,
0.136217400431633,
-0.14244219660758972,
-0.7043280601501465,
-0.4916382133960724,
-0.32502737641334534,
-0.6228966116905212,
0.601318359375,
-0.8680611252784729,
0.1645897924900055,
-0.6146005392074585,
-0.3106188178062439,
-0.17521776258945465,
0.6044312715530396,
-1.0007574558258057,
-0.013285182416439056,
-0.33707183599472046,
1.1128418445587158,
-0.9661424160003662,
0.8072882890701294,
0.7595939636230469,
-0.2366665154695511,
-0.8017299771308899,
-0.35995474457740784,
0.21274028718471527,
-0.9040567874908447,
0.07955830544233322,
0.1650698333978653,
-0.5910270810127258,
-0.02544981613755226,
-1.0084537267684937,
-0.884328305721283,
1.2402372360229492,
0.5128803849220276,
-0.5760941505432129,
0.399406760931015,
0.12328255921602249,
0.47534793615341187,
-0.5512462854385376,
0.38440945744514465,
0.6819456219673157,
0.6787707805633545,
-0.31550395488739014,
-1.2135531902313232,
0.13478559255599976,
-0.32834088802337646,
-0.2890653908252716,
0.002867187839001417,
-0.9587417244911194,
0.4429733455181122,
0.12855592370033264,
-0.18835604190826416,
0.012454225681722164,
0.3798345923423767,
0.1847122460603714,
0.2913728654384613,
0.7591511011123657,
0.38382405042648315,
0.7136279940605164,
0.06777550280094147,
0.8971163034439087,
-0.24671028554439545,
0.33343762159347534,
1.295060157775879,
-0.23853114247322083,
0.48972684144973755,
-0.015699012205004692,
-0.10364644229412079,
0.4276473820209503,
0.7563635110855103,
-0.5656831860542297,
0.31568852066993713,
0.4213707745075226,
0.07504438608884811,
-0.6126362085342407,
-0.10241349041461945,
-0.35022857785224915,
0.570645272731781,
0.29002484679222107,
0.16913223266601562,
-0.22638480365276337,
0.05155106633901596,
-0.32164880633354187,
-0.04738930985331535,
-0.07655877619981766,
0.9009837508201599,
0.1664964109659195,
-0.3717859983444214,
0.47692635655403137,
-0.2521391212940216,
0.558049738407135,
-0.6668031811714172,
-0.10472660511732101,
-0.0515315942466259,
0.20881521701812744,
-0.1223546639084816,
-0.8637856245040894,
-0.18206451833248138,
-0.5199183225631714,
0.036618005484342575,
-0.2007351964712143,
1.0552210807800293,
-0.07692792266607285,
-0.18539699912071228,
0.2962177097797394,
0.6726245880126953,
0.5177420973777771,
-0.1419917792081833,
-0.7240473628044128,
-0.07366187125444412,
-0.2611718475818634,
-0.15148021280765533,
0.11064013838768005,
0.3739578127861023,
-0.005756556522101164,
1.3363354206085205,
0.4263637363910675,
0.07964136451482773,
-0.020646337419748306,
0.06275684386491776,
0.6362507343292236,
-0.6149056553840637,
-0.30273234844207764,
-0.41861414909362793,
0.3865165710449219,
-0.4061536490917206,
-0.25540104508399963,
0.8232019543647766,
0.8121424913406372,
0.8602138757705688,
-0.27636948227882385,
0.7754902839660645,
0.4364871680736542,
0.7047699689865112,
-0.4358685612678528,
0.5883533358573914,
-0.45964327454566956,
0.1362975388765335,
-0.07497256994247437,
-0.9162551164627075,
0.4344632029533386,
0.1293472945690155,
-0.007111686747521162,
0.1029684767127037,
0.5146852731704712,
0.9585863947868347,
-0.2708417773246765,
-0.3836105465888977,
0.4201994836330414,
0.05802943557500839,
0.33809569478034973,
0.10561718791723251,
0.9207667708396912,
-0.3842591941356659,
0.5635026693344116,
-0.34425410628318787,
-0.03804728761315346,
-0.3122501075267792,
-0.7297741174697876,
-0.9791504144668579,
-0.5589315891265869,
-0.5662649273872375,
-0.01719619147479534,
0.08896712958812714,
0.7796104550361633,
1.2378896474838257,
-0.4318678379058838,
-0.4811253845691681,
0.15104421973228455,
0.16321434080600739,
-0.6213597655296326,
-0.216889888048172,
0.3464491367340088,
-0.7182320952415466,
-0.5028371214866638,
0.549609899520874,
0.10899274051189423,
0.21782521903514862,
-0.520851731300354,
-0.18494267761707306,
0.3012898862361908,
-0.0555400587618351,
0.17809565365314484,
0.5544546246528625,
-0.584919810295105,
-0.27641424536705017,
-0.26156941056251526,
0.02593618631362915,
-0.09949976205825806,
0.6171139478683472,
-0.7691724300384521,
0.5027496814727783,
-0.1553405374288559,
0.2708275020122528,
0.9688035249710083,
-0.2642030417919159,
0.8448105454444885,
-0.9911781549453735,
0.006434292066842318,
-0.08856195956468582,
0.19516465067863464,
0.1559457927942276,
-0.40108588337898254,
1.0713481903076172,
-0.3405861258506775,
-0.6348764300346375,
-0.7244706153869629,
0.3299291133880615,
-0.9085072875022888,
-0.1582188457250595,
0.838230311870575,
-0.07267589867115021,
-0.03148432821035385,
-0.3419947922229767,
-0.13879114389419556,
0.19040711224079132,
-0.7676264047622681,
0.6379072070121765,
0.33156901597976685,
-0.16392356157302856,
-0.17684227228164673,
-0.3304886519908905,
0.7162619829177856,
0.12244020402431488,
-1.0453083515167236,
-0.09584755450487137,
0.04226909577846527,
0.6163930296897888,
0.07724158465862274,
0.45285576581954956,
0.1927500218153,
0.32151225209236145,
0.17121458053588867,
0.3988077640533447,
-0.5628356337547302,
-0.3717185854911804,
-0.0659935250878334,
-0.07757986336946487,
0.3420959711074829,
-0.2694316804409027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08317v1
|
SpeechGuard: Exploring the Adversarial Robustness of Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-05-14T04:51:23 | 2024-05-14T04:51:23 |
Raghuveer Peri, Sai Muralidhar Jayanthi, Srikanth Ronanki, Anshu Bhatia, Karel Mundnich, Saket Dingliwal, Nilaksh Das, Zejiang Hou, Goeric Huybrechts, Srikanth Vishnubhotla, Daniel Garcia-Romero, Sundararajan Srinivasan, Kyu J Han, Katrin Kirchhoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Integrated Speech and Large Language Models (SLMs) that can follow speech
instructions and generate relevant text responses have gained popularity
lately. However, the safety and robustness of these models remains largely
unclear. In this work, we investigate the potential vulnerabilities of such
instruction-following speech-language models to adversarial attacks and
jailbreaking. Specifically, we design algorithms that can generate adversarial
examples to jailbreak SLMs in both white-box and black-box attack settings
without human involvement. Additionally, we propose countermeasures to thwart
such jailbreaking attacks. Our models, trained on dialog data with speech
instructions, achieve state-of-the-art performance on spoken question-answering
task, scoring over 80% on both safety and helpfulness metrics. Despite safety
guardrails, experiments on jailbreaking demonstrate the vulnerability of SLMs
to adversarial perturbations and transfer attacks, with average attack success
rates of 90% and 10% respectively when evaluated on a dataset of carefully
designed harmful questions spanning 12 different toxic categories. However, we
demonstrate that our proposed countermeasures reduce the attack success
significantly.
|
[
-0.41480839252471924,
-1.044653296470642,
0.24753917753696442,
-0.13237634301185608,
-0.18275988101959229,
0.22932563722133636,
-0.00009661199146648869,
-0.3273822069168091,
-0.15841250121593475,
0.971972644329071,
-0.38353121280670166,
-0.2416950762271881,
-0.7635949850082397,
-0.4121597111225128,
-0.5590163469314575,
1.1242461204528809,
0.4654455780982971,
0.12519928812980652,
0.08041413873434067,
-0.10040765255689621,
-0.6899698972702026,
-0.7898730039596558,
-0.5289831757545471,
0.10855232179164886,
0.36721789836883545,
-0.08415492624044418,
0.916575014591217,
0.30517736077308655,
0.28307390213012695,
0.3079863488674164,
-0.3435319662094116,
0.040901534259319305,
-0.4113962948322296,
0.4964088797569275,
-0.08708842098712921,
-0.488787442445755,
-0.37902313470840454,
-0.06551773101091385,
0.2899763286113739,
0.1826106458902359,
-0.15525566041469574,
-0.037047114223241806,
0.020378654822707176,
0.522575855255127,
-0.67353755235672,
-0.06499183177947998,
-1.043757438659668,
-0.013776103965938091,
-0.1873631626367569,
0.002351013943552971,
-0.7361816167831421,
-0.26924219727516174,
0.23897168040275574,
-0.1243543028831482,
-0.10843218863010406,
-0.15637262165546417,
0.3679577708244324,
0.200290709733963,
-0.2510225176811218,
-0.5544126629829407,
-0.5711631178855896,
0.5478096604347229,
-0.9259229302406311,
0.05009518936276436,
0.5026973485946655,
0.3140377402305603,
-0.2112317830324173,
-0.3712576925754547,
-0.3337194323539734,
-0.5771785378456116,
0.04043692722916603,
-0.12106487900018692,
-0.4422144591808319,
0.2795339524745941,
0.25836503505706787,
-0.04896233230829239,
-0.866474449634552,
0.11282356828451157,
-0.4581957757472992,
-0.19568492472171783,
0.5613894462585449,
0.06471140682697296,
0.700963020324707,
-0.12084580957889557,
-0.41193175315856934,
-0.24211783707141876,
-0.8771911859512329,
0.08385694772005081,
0.6067374348640442,
0.47580766677856445,
-0.04556809365749359,
0.4271638095378876,
0.40332749485969543,
0.6638749241828918,
-0.25852933526039124,
-0.0584898367524147,
-0.132313072681427,
-0.22431813180446625,
0.01458042673766613,
0.2187729924917221,
0.930435061454773,
0.1499127894639969,
0.37388163805007935,
-0.5560095310211182,
-0.037540070712566376,
0.03743653744459152,
0.611948549747467,
-0.7769178152084351,
-0.2079477608203888,
0.3260025084018707,
-0.15074409544467926,
-0.6699313521385193,
0.007628652732819319,
-0.9978570342063904,
-0.8143144845962524,
0.3136715888977051,
0.45357829332351685,
-0.4202623963356018,
-0.18872006237506866,
-0.04213912785053253,
-0.00995807908475399,
0.011295612901449203,
-0.05784228444099426,
-0.7926334142684937,
0.15461653470993042,
0.6421319246292114,
0.8086853623390198,
0.0814666599035263,
-0.20415031909942627,
-0.798079252243042,
0.15412001311779022,
-0.22402101755142212,
0.30865275859832764,
-0.3252146244049072,
-0.5600900053977966,
-0.01604463718831539,
-0.0650269165635109,
-0.31750133633613586,
-0.4121095836162567,
0.4122985601425171,
-0.7491583824157715,
0.05800718069076538,
0.15600985288619995,
-0.2898919880390167,
-0.144083172082901,
0.35837721824645996,
-0.7144405245780945,
0.226507306098938,
-0.3844519853591919,
-0.8022245764732361,
-0.3007650673389435,
-0.5341115593910217,
-0.5631411671638489,
-0.23888979852199554,
0.1586798131465912,
-0.4777926206588745,
0.004964785184711218,
0.3327329754829407,
0.26887819170951843,
-0.02769222855567932,
0.23695388436317444,
-0.585721492767334,
-0.15891216695308685,
0.6175843477249146,
-0.7834435701370239,
0.9830439686775208,
0.4217274785041809,
-0.452269971370697,
0.15652038156986237,
-0.6118905544281006,
0.09965076297521591,
0.16810373961925507,
-0.10743431001901627,
-0.43946415185928345,
0.19100718200206757,
-0.18028360605239868,
0.2648088037967682,
0.03967045620083809,
-0.4752403795719147,
-0.07098132371902466,
-0.39975982904434204,
0.8787276744842529,
0.8478704690933228,
-0.037715259939432144,
0.28187450766563416,
-0.11746249347925186,
0.7036468386650085,
-0.10656983405351639,
0.298061341047287,
-0.42982181906700134,
-0.32316622138023376,
-0.22392207384109497,
-0.10585726797580719,
0.241261824965477,
0.9221470952033997,
-0.8241408467292786,
0.15048536658287048,
0.11950191855430603,
-0.7074099779129028,
-0.45520225167274475,
0.19574986398220062,
0.799588680267334,
0.3805079162120819,
0.28058508038520813,
-0.034383196383714676,
-0.3368435502052307,
-0.5926275253295898,
-0.37364256381988525,
-0.2909776270389557,
0.29803234338760376,
0.2699125409126282,
0.23828010261058807,
-0.1634729653596878,
0.31208565831184387,
-0.45068323612213135,
0.08683740347623825,
-0.24573297798633575,
-0.04427356645464897,
-0.1305769383907318,
0.473982572555542,
0.7168155312538147,
-0.8350854516029358,
-0.1526852399110794,
-0.40784674882888794,
-0.7260001301765442,
0.03490730747580528,
-0.0870436280965805,
0.10823796689510345,
-0.09466327726840973,
0.6426564455032349,
-0.7537826895713806,
0.37043625116348267,
0.6823263764381409,
-0.33760517835617065,
0.662053644657135,
-0.08785635977983475,
-0.06293150782585144,
-1.0918048620224,
-0.14758197963237762,
-0.018753910437226295,
-0.1229458600282669,
-1.1230072975158691,
0.4347198009490967,
-0.1451708972454071,
-0.6530175805091858,
-0.7045422792434692,
0.251475065946579,
-0.14520108699798584,
0.1469775140285492,
-0.3482398986816406,
0.14673931896686554,
-0.04337947443127632,
0.33137476444244385,
-0.298598051071167,
0.9311952590942383,
0.6396200656890869,
-0.47591379284858704,
0.49390971660614014,
0.19257239997386932,
-0.2884092330932617,
0.2285161316394806,
-0.9480450749397278,
0.4132923185825348,
-0.1861366331577301,
0.11176679283380508,
-0.8482702374458313,
-0.07390603423118591,
0.06275185942649841,
-0.6314725875854492,
0.46430760622024536,
-0.28308403491973877,
-0.380553662776947,
-0.15949976444244385,
-0.5045816898345947,
0.1499970406293869,
0.32863354682922363,
-0.41342535614967346,
0.4162658452987671,
0.7178680896759033,
-0.5362023115158081,
-0.727077305316925,
-0.7428480386734009,
0.39351561665534973,
-0.49019312858581543,
-0.7791504859924316,
0.03966332599520683,
-0.10858049243688583,
-0.34792688488960266,
-0.2068330943584442,
0.06361161917448044,
-0.1077963262796402,
0.492764949798584,
0.2877104580402374,
0.4793074131011963,
-0.022204214707016945,
-0.2394842505455017,
-0.318062961101532,
0.07257615029811859,
0.2929070293903351,
-0.09226970374584198,
0.6830649971961975,
-0.28692781925201416,
-0.40678849816322327,
-0.28404897451400757,
0.4016331434249878,
1.0079100131988525,
-0.490668386220932,
0.8465380072593689,
0.4949544072151184,
-0.2396824061870575,
-0.12331874668598175,
-0.23167502880096436,
-0.14192931354045868,
-0.49631351232528687,
0.49416208267211914,
-0.10680950433015823,
-0.8792335391044617,
0.41914495825767517,
0.300762802362442,
0.18608984351158142,
-0.19456517696380615,
0.4384725093841553,
-0.008853914216160774,
1.3797143697738647,
0.14695219695568085,
-0.4409436285495758,
0.5367153286933899,
0.00565097713842988,
0.2718176245689392,
-0.641637921333313,
-0.12452840805053711,
-0.557154655456543,
0.06818417459726334,
-0.6759960055351257,
-0.01943751610815525,
0.481998085975647,
-0.11654888838529587,
-0.17405320703983307,
0.5698767304420471,
-0.3461662232875824,
0.3389933407306671,
0.5312125086784363,
0.14915648102760315,
-0.1298816055059433,
-0.15675930678844452,
-0.0657557025551796,
0.15655116736888885,
-0.5247332453727722,
-0.5334030389785767,
1.1630946397781372,
0.5070286393165588,
1.273634910583496,
0.45645153522491455,
0.43493103981018066,
0.4268130362033844,
-0.16708965599536896,
-0.45983773469924927,
0.5852208733558655,
-0.4281432330608368,
-0.7648444175720215,
-0.17770293354988098,
-0.5114176869392395,
-0.8049737215042114,
0.5152506232261658,
-0.23856569826602936,
-1.0394277572631836,
-0.2343098372220993,
0.25424566864967346,
-0.49152228236198425,
0.5051535964012146,
-0.9908157587051392,
0.8321766257286072,
-0.5183355808258057,
-0.35628607869148254,
-0.045043639838695526,
-0.7922078967094421,
0.5915257334709167,
-0.06438992917537689,
0.4663624167442322,
0.027185464277863503,
0.4918910562992096,
0.5021088123321533,
-0.34835076332092285,
0.8926701545715332,
-0.4030318558216095,
0.004740436095744371,
0.30666911602020264,
0.18312910199165344,
0.6009251475334167,
0.08675099164247513,
0.009014014154672623,
-0.17041650414466858,
0.049810055643320084,
-0.3067024350166321,
-0.5018820762634277,
0.785794734954834,
-0.671492338180542,
-0.9298484921455383,
-0.3852309584617615,
-0.625116765499115,
-0.38578835129737854,
0.07078038156032562,
0.11840777844190598,
0.7311150431632996,
-0.06891898065805435,
0.18128597736358643,
1.01370370388031,
-0.498919278383255,
0.5116233229637146,
0.33302807807922363,
-0.01818799041211605,
-0.6582636833190918,
1.0248626470565796,
0.02445320039987564,
0.6323904395103455,
0.03814152628183365,
0.14083534479141235,
-0.3611849546432495,
-0.7877537608146667,
-0.7590364813804626,
-0.14362946152687073,
-0.4662066400051117,
-0.10679174959659576,
-0.3813008666038513,
-0.46373143792152405,
-0.5714994668960571,
0.061211347579956055,
-0.2856709063053131,
-0.31045982241630554,
-0.1033376082777977,
-0.12824423611164093,
0.0561642125248909,
0.5486547350883484,
0.23654912412166595,
0.2253524512052536,
-1.0335007905960083,
0.28883522748947144,
0.652771532535553,
-0.13036338984966278,
0.06207450106739998,
-0.4692428708076477,
0.0405702069401741,
0.23977917432785034,
-0.41380348801612854,
-1.087026596069336,
0.34821373224258423,
-0.010179344564676285,
0.5470982789993286,
0.4541923999786377,
0.159421905875206,
0.4996858239173889,
-0.602353572845459,
0.8063463568687439,
0.21842102706432343,
-0.7605236768722534,
0.6607425808906555,
-0.4033977687358856,
0.35320696234703064,
0.5170238018035889,
-0.031526289880275726,
-0.321914404630661,
-0.6648788452148438,
-0.4982827603816986,
-0.8537682890892029,
0.6219008564949036,
0.26049312949180603,
0.4278477132320404,
0.16630905866622925,
0.01988319680094719,
-0.25094515085220337,
0.32696932554244995,
-0.6645348072052002,
-0.32519903779029846,
-0.467772901058197,
-0.03641260787844658,
-0.0196551363915205,
-0.2258118987083435,
-0.2848612368106842,
0.14278645813465118,
0.6903631687164307,
0.17319850623607635,
-0.13873063027858734,
-0.1632593423128128,
-0.33008453249931335,
0.3689410388469696,
0.7183005213737488,
0.8701295852661133,
0.25448980927467346,
-0.11333408206701279,
0.3961630165576935,
0.06207659840583801,
-0.6746078729629517,
0.3293406069278717,
0.4704870879650116,
-0.4568028748035431,
-0.24790285527706146,
0.37115195393562317,
0.8868861794471741,
0.061230823397636414,
-0.9629395604133606,
0.45427581667900085,
-0.31065496802330017,
0.15330852568149567,
-0.3065832555294037,
0.34339186549186707,
0.06978584080934525,
0.2116517722606659,
0.15488776564598083,
0.20628297328948975,
-0.06148674711585045,
-0.7245085835456848,
0.18708038330078125,
0.9045577645301819,
-0.5855063199996948,
-0.2773861587047577,
0.7879213690757751,
-0.0064782993867993355,
-0.33759790658950806,
0.3237163722515106,
0.03730347380042076,
-0.8038579225540161,
0.6045680642127991,
0.5690818428993225,
0.7424235939979553,
-0.4766818583011627,
0.13279837369918823,
-0.02849879115819931,
0.6497367024421692,
0.12280850857496262,
-0.054503828287124634,
0.15622848272323608,
-0.5882987380027771,
-0.08382633328437805,
-0.3288818299770355,
-0.42613527178764343,
0.4517109990119934,
-0.8370294570922852,
-0.05705488473176956,
-0.6254869699478149,
-0.365700900554657,
0.16043613851070404,
-0.5304606556892395,
-0.009481978602707386,
0.03797750174999237,
0.458079993724823,
0.7788899540901184,
-0.6194186210632324,
0.6812667846679688,
0.6210886240005493,
-0.1175776943564415,
-0.5338690876960754,
-0.009227033704519272,
0.3218734562397003,
-0.6956347823143005,
0.08929326385259628,
0.2437412589788437,
-0.21261656284332275,
-0.3453700542449951,
-0.46215716004371643,
-0.6529316306114197,
0.7566795349121094,
0.6281285285949707,
-0.49509021639823914,
-0.20325833559036255,
0.14454065263271332,
0.32531899213790894,
0.01650039106607437,
-0.023250337690114975,
0.6494870781898499,
0.1439313143491745,
-0.08464742451906204,
-0.8474546670913696,
-0.11715862900018692,
-0.3290911912918091,
-0.04057442769408226,
0.203391432762146,
-0.5430728793144226,
0.7288281321525574,
-0.32306358218193054,
-0.030672410503029823,
0.19501212239265442,
0.24191850423812866,
0.47502195835113525,
0.2068367302417755,
0.698066234588623,
0.622714638710022,
0.5456109642982483,
-0.0967584103345871,
0.9234950542449951,
-0.3528789281845093,
-0.06579484045505524,
1.1400244235992432,
-0.17845892906188965,
0.6463220715522766,
0.27954286336898804,
0.028082961216568947,
0.2196454256772995,
0.11017881333827972,
-0.07246945798397064,
0.8273169994354248,
0.2807687819004059,
-0.5088162422180176,
-0.03268103674054146,
0.032571062445640564,
-0.2928757667541504,
0.5572185516357422,
0.4732322096824646,
-0.4292188584804535,
-0.2197277694940567,
0.5006811022758484,
0.5315572619438171,
0.11388953775167465,
-0.4187776446342468,
0.8993356823921204,
0.1649782657623291,
-0.7411338686943054,
0.6108066439628601,
-0.060335416346788406,
0.6018819212913513,
-0.8269146680831909,
0.19759175181388855,
0.1452191323041916,
0.3087058365345001,
-0.03291725367307663,
-0.6746116876602173,
0.16849811375141144,
0.41903620958328247,
0.01747801899909973,
-0.013928205706179142,
0.7681487202644348,
-0.3794609308242798,
-0.20623540878295898,
0.3077003061771393,
0.17012831568717957,
-0.14381615817546844,
0.03294787183403969,
-0.7936344742774963,
0.1317218840122223,
0.045337315648794174,
-0.19546076655387878,
0.6617531180381775,
-0.25687864422798157,
0.11693046241998672,
0.9481870532035828,
0.6382501125335693,
0.26074668765068054,
0.4823445677757263,
0.044145967811346054,
0.928272545337677,
-0.39868804812431335,
-0.4918195903301239,
-1.1586581468582153,
0.3351532816886902,
-0.09474030882120132,
-0.03719937428832054,
0.8194839954376221,
0.2952970564365387,
0.550987720489502,
0.1263558566570282,
1.0506341457366943,
0.10440909117460251,
0.2742963433265686,
-0.6643343567848206,
1.0384794473648071,
-0.025678636506199837,
0.5106385946273804,
-0.370760440826416,
-0.38669735193252563,
-0.07854587584733963,
0.2471657246351242,
-0.2620973587036133,
-0.17167596518993378,
0.3013262152671814,
0.9694725275039673,
0.2275015115737915,
0.22805413603782654,
0.26449504494667053,
0.23063041269779205,
0.7603878974914551,
0.5836579203605652,
0.9244498610496521,
-0.21411903202533722,
1.0003867149353027,
-0.1869971752166748,
-0.0710989460349083,
0.16108454763889313,
-0.4962819814682007,
-1.128892183303833,
-0.22002030909061432,
-0.05352575704455376,
-0.6442925333976746,
0.36657968163490295,
0.5488860011100769,
0.7964017987251282,
-0.8983943462371826,
-0.04434046894311905,
0.04629619047045708,
0.13673920929431915,
0.025410011410713196,
-0.24415621161460876,
0.31099602580070496,
-0.12208753824234009,
-0.4682038724422455,
0.831916332244873,
0.1215716004371643,
0.17082709074020386,
-0.5451893210411072,
0.1295296549797058,
-0.05312115326523781,
0.16936837136745453,
0.4660068154335022,
0.39878711104393005,
-0.6729337573051453,
-0.233126699924469,
-0.11525584757328033,
-0.16519594192504883,
-0.37103599309921265,
0.6340108513832092,
-0.3471572995185852,
0.6271157264709473,
0.23840320110321045,
0.8965892791748047,
0.2489219307899475,
0.1510143131017685,
0.515459418296814,
-0.7295601963996887,
0.2972690463066101,
0.35604745149612427,
0.44840481877326965,
0.35523250699043274,
-0.2557085454463959,
0.10642199963331223,
-0.04611247777938843,
-0.4595337212085724,
-1.0602755546569824,
0.4306013584136963,
-0.6712725758552551,
-0.5124990344047546,
1.078199863433838,
-0.5028634667396545,
-0.20675908029079437,
-0.17996226251125336,
-0.14302779734134674,
-0.07020507007837296,
-0.23730015754699707,
0.8608002662658691,
0.6563737392425537,
0.1570921540260315,
-0.2550468444824219,
-0.8561043739318848,
0.38796594738960266,
0.18159949779510498,
-0.8102220892906189,
0.2363661378622055,
0.2633872628211975,
0.26292070746421814,
0.2986205816268921,
0.13169121742248535,
-0.43104425072669983,
0.43435215950012207,
-0.015682050958275795,
-0.3948637843132019,
-0.38026532530784607,
-0.30626481771469116,
-0.4973650574684143,
0.5940344333648682,
0.083310067653656,
-0.2732756733894348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08311v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08311v1
|
A Decoupling and Aggregating Framework for Joint Extraction of Entities and Relations
| 2024-05-14T04:27:16 | 2024-05-14T04:27:16 |
Yao Wang, Xin Liu, Weikun Kong, Hai-Tao Yu, Teeradaj Racharak, Kyoung-Sook Kim, Minh Le Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Named Entity Recognition and Relation Extraction are two crucial and
challenging subtasks in the field of Information Extraction. Despite the
successes achieved by the traditional approaches, fundamental research
questions remain open. First, most recent studies use parameter sharing for a
single subtask or shared features for both two subtasks, ignoring their
semantic differences. Second, information interaction mainly focuses on the two
subtasks, leaving the fine-grained informtion interaction among the
subtask-specific features of encoding subjects, relations, and objects
unexplored. Motivated by the aforementioned limitations, we propose a novel
model to jointly extract entities and relations. The main novelties are as
follows: (1) We propose to decouple the feature encoding process into three
parts, namely encoding subjects, encoding objects, and encoding relations.
Thanks to this, we are able to use fine-grained subtask-specific features. (2)
We propose novel inter-aggregation and intra-aggregation strategies to enhance
the information interaction and construct individual fine-grained
subtask-specific features, respectively. The experimental results demonstrate
that our model outperforms several previous state-of-the-art models. Extensive
additional experiments further confirm the effectiveness of our model.
|
[
-0.773883044719696,
-0.6148857474327087,
0.4424998462200165,
0.008788718841969967,
-0.48395633697509766,
-0.060387298464775085,
-0.05445529893040657,
-0.9641175866127014,
0.5181242823600769,
0.4349622130393982,
-0.5085574388504028,
-0.3794349133968353,
-0.7819905877113342,
0.08370959013700485,
-0.4718581438064575,
1.1800498962402344,
0.037130385637283325,
-0.13816693425178528,
-0.329987496137619,
-0.37145400047302246,
-0.28546470403671265,
-0.44656240940093994,
-0.5723369717597961,
-0.1885852813720703,
0.5132611393928528,
0.050569236278533936,
0.6123269200325012,
0.6699914336204529,
0.6255435347557068,
0.23274224996566772,
0.04292439669370651,
0.3313167989253998,
-0.2572568356990814,
0.20626473426818848,
-0.5068029165267944,
-0.11793801933526993,
-0.6542087197303772,
0.13037678599357605,
0.5221461653709412,
0.9895393252372742,
-0.09827226400375366,
0.28867635130882263,
0.16062264144420624,
0.353788822889328,
-0.8504307270050049,
0.6014156341552734,
-0.552040696144104,
-0.18843881785869598,
-0.2658054232597351,
-0.1901954561471939,
-0.21706905961036682,
0.18160933256149292,
0.1655072569847107,
-0.7357870936393738,
0.24708417057991028,
-0.23979268968105316,
1.3244019746780396,
0.008147986605763435,
-0.2490864396095276,
-0.2943577170372009,
-0.6492365598678589,
0.4841555655002594,
-0.2908214330673218,
0.6196689605712891,
0.4154743552207947,
-0.05576242879033089,
0.02752136066555977,
-0.7220805883407593,
-0.1612587720155716,
0.17840945720672607,
-0.44395923614501953,
0.052172545343637466,
-0.28415173292160034,
-0.014743580482900143,
0.01245809718966484,
0.6265265941619873,
0.042505137622356415,
0.05400865897536278,
-0.40341636538505554,
0.20001907646656036,
0.6408740282058716,
-0.00042484322329983115,
0.5516557097434998,
-0.28273308277130127,
-0.7836332321166992,
0.398433119058609,
-0.5733876824378967,
0.14897863566875458,
0.11186345666646957,
0.47798952460289,
-0.08288892358541489,
0.5269277691841125,
-0.20607608556747437,
0.2952324450016022,
0.1695369929075241,
0.07503963261842728,
0.017987506464123726,
-0.4509778916835785,
-0.21148638427257538,
-0.030974889174103737,
0.9915515184402466,
0.15002407133579254,
0.13571350276470184,
-0.6220908761024475,
-0.12473204731941223,
0.016578150913119316,
-0.020405787974596024,
-0.598366379737854,
-0.6069633364677429,
0.21013453602790833,
-0.5858174562454224,
-0.09065357595682144,
0.31655821204185486,
-0.8473289012908936,
-0.27999502420425415,
-0.4714275896549225,
0.2188994139432907,
-0.413608580827713,
-0.8520625233650208,
-0.3362703323364258,
-0.12967254221439362,
0.23724216222763062,
0.2468259483575821,
-1.2573548555374146,
0.6160958409309387,
0.8690369725227356,
0.6110839247703552,
-0.5372969508171082,
-0.3438757658004761,
-0.6527673602104187,
0.3685758709907532,
-0.04438168928027153,
0.6899514198303223,
-0.7012341618537903,
-0.2695685625076294,
-0.35809218883514404,
0.30263230204582214,
0.030226437374949455,
-0.5450646877288818,
-0.12166467308998108,
-0.7854637503623962,
-0.12256217002868652,
-0.4003888666629791,
-0.6749256253242493,
0.06678374856710434,
0.23973123729228973,
-1.1733616590499878,
0.6463428139686584,
0.3067026138305664,
-0.985545814037323,
0.3615038990974426,
-0.4035514295101166,
-0.21658778190612793,
0.2847931981086731,
-0.5844834446907043,
-0.28979137539863586,
-0.03860503435134888,
0.25765299797058105,
0.5730498433113098,
-0.5388078689575195,
0.376030832529068,
-0.5414045453071594,
-0.014338575303554535,
0.05274711176753044,
0.06015972048044205,
0.748665988445282,
0.14621344208717346,
0.2943477928638458,
-0.2690138816833496,
-0.6849194765090942,
-0.33103179931640625,
0.13807101547718048,
-0.6045602560043335,
-0.7353082895278931,
-0.21143250167369843,
-0.38991615176200867,
-0.003336491994559765,
0.3949717879295349,
-0.49143850803375244,
0.3002070188522339,
0.007766398135572672,
0.1523142009973526,
0.15149594843387604,
0.5778250694274902,
0.8598403334617615,
0.14025984704494476,
0.5200896859169006,
0.5051231384277344,
-0.20186859369277954,
-0.19475340843200684,
-0.021974293515086174,
-0.48445925116539,
-0.3815842270851135,
0.8150256872177124,
0.4544333815574646,
-0.8480502367019653,
0.22577711939811707,
-0.48856860399246216,
-0.16244620084762573,
-0.394654244184494,
0.10841313749551773,
0.5541480779647827,
0.40794023871421814,
0.5292415618896484,
-0.5767108201980591,
-0.5973542332649231,
-0.8781759142875671,
-0.3183535039424896,
-0.03996420279145241,
-0.10054858028888702,
-0.04069811478257179,
0.14020396769046783,
0.07471249252557755,
0.9928324818611145,
-0.5205244421958923,
-0.2816092073917389,
-0.4925607144832611,
0.2624884247779846,
-0.029268987476825714,
0.5670369267463684,
0.5749277472496033,
-1.0739953517913818,
-0.21659135818481445,
0.20195680856704712,
-0.9794248938560486,
0.33734574913978577,
0.1482708603143692,
-0.27685078978538513,
-0.21796679496765137,
0.399090051651001,
-1.0310101509094238,
0.5004026293754578,
0.08104334026575089,
0.05246555805206299,
0.299514502286911,
0.1544693112373352,
0.10435429215431213,
-1.0738670825958252,
-0.09970417618751526,
0.06414805352687836,
-0.270740807056427,
-0.6648119688034058,
0.35671529173851013,
0.05708349868655205,
-0.07397718727588654,
-0.3196047842502594,
0.4222983121871948,
-1.1196810007095337,
-0.39689305424690247,
-0.07650738209486008,
0.1414400339126587,
0.24431075155735016,
0.6506469249725342,
0.21753178536891937,
0.38198745250701904,
0.6293721795082092,
-0.7304633259773254,
0.3531424403190613,
0.2563551664352417,
-0.03633132576942444,
0.5751073360443115,
-0.20424973964691162,
-0.07774090766906738,
-0.2976280450820923,
-0.14966252446174622,
-0.49014315009117126,
-0.38056641817092896,
0.33853021264076233,
-0.42111343145370483,
0.609711229801178,
-0.5019116997718811,
-0.21619105339050293,
0.2097681760787964,
-0.03075563721358776,
0.40948864817619324,
0.18708688020706177,
-0.4730909466743469,
1.0725661516189575,
1.120320200920105,
-0.4374014735221863,
-0.6170557141304016,
-0.606715202331543,
-0.023932047188282013,
-0.3891296684741974,
-0.38053417205810547,
0.4191077649593353,
0.5816919207572937,
-0.2274623066186905,
0.5783337354660034,
-0.38611435890197754,
-0.527821958065033,
0.052456799894571304,
0.28065919876098633,
0.3297322988510132,
-0.06815672665834427,
0.33263230323791504,
0.07392128556966782,
-0.12796218693256378,
0.06469777971506119,
0.07208850979804993,
0.29016175866127014,
0.16639944911003113,
0.05991596356034279,
-0.31898266077041626,
0.8965659141540527,
0.42943838238716125,
-0.673801600933075,
0.7533695697784424,
0.563149631023407,
-0.737881064414978,
0.1314246505498886,
-0.2758444547653198,
-0.12939958274364471,
-0.3779430687427521,
0.5963441729545593,
-0.8841325640678406,
-0.5973950624465942,
0.6719477772712708,
-0.44078195095062256,
0.16880492866039276,
0.350297749042511,
-0.0013549034483730793,
0.03312842175364494,
0.6412796378135681,
1.020207405090332,
-0.19757936894893646,
0.3159484565258026,
-0.3878450393676758,
0.33679425716400146,
-1.0742645263671875,
-0.4195135235786438,
-0.4279448986053467,
-0.07445763051509857,
-0.4337676763534546,
0.05850651115179062,
-0.13060300052165985,
0.6068640351295471,
0.3952532708644867,
0.7493466138839722,
-0.17129123210906982,
0.3433954417705536,
0.33126258850097656,
0.1996053159236908,
0.4186975955963135,
0.10130760073661804,
0.016297008842229843,
0.0054421983659267426,
-0.4409646689891815,
-0.32170042395591736,
0.5530797243118286,
0.2524912357330322,
0.6392339468002319,
0.1409199982881546,
1.0714398622512817,
0.13477663695812225,
0.212653249502182,
-0.7464900612831116,
0.710472583770752,
-0.38806164264678955,
-0.5293537378311157,
-0.25698158144950867,
-0.4036957323551178,
-1.1108464002609253,
0.29105880856513977,
-0.23060472309589386,
-1.1103583574295044,
0.6867210268974304,
0.08126580715179443,
-0.3826746940612793,
0.2794804871082306,
-0.855561375617981,
0.6914036273956299,
0.2617896497249603,
-0.41650664806365967,
0.2189638465642929,
-0.7379242777824402,
0.46261608600616455,
0.013951072469353676,
0.26456472277641296,
-0.19734041392803192,
-0.08578526973724365,
0.7687102556228638,
-0.09598369151353836,
0.37231165170669556,
-0.11486297100782394,
-0.163881316781044,
0.31274643540382385,
0.2470291703939438,
0.40096941590309143,
0.2447277158498764,
-0.07483352720737457,
0.255126029253006,
0.14422105252742767,
-0.08744597434997559,
-0.7545546293258667,
0.6585623621940613,
-0.3920347988605499,
-0.44898244738578796,
-0.17462366819381714,
-0.5758450627326965,
-0.28067517280578613,
0.30958864092826843,
0.148409903049469,
0.39483171701431274,
-0.116674043238163,
-0.0014101006090641022,
0.44805681705474854,
0.2796706259250641,
0.5414127111434937,
0.3176910877227783,
-0.1903914213180542,
-0.3522529602050781,
0.9362763166427612,
0.19007569551467896,
0.15970192849636078,
0.46662238240242004,
-0.36609259247779846,
-0.21504245698451996,
-0.3186873197555542,
-0.1081489846110344,
0.258876770734787,
-0.603236973285675,
-0.2721122205257416,
-1.0577017068862915,
-0.4770185351371765,
-0.39316076040267944,
0.6471246480941772,
-0.4720786213874817,
-0.27811694145202637,
-0.5183394551277161,
-0.21063192188739777,
0.017328614369034767,
0.5035538077354431,
-0.029036106541752815,
-0.09325879067182541,
-1.2156237363815308,
0.6888739466667175,
0.36905887722969055,
0.04343028739094734,
0.03067685291171074,
0.1647433191537857,
-0.2694377601146698,
-0.18146169185638428,
0.03806377947330475,
-1.1568946838378906,
0.2575395405292511,
-0.011641844175755978,
0.4902191758155823,
0.33094969391822815,
0.238512322306633,
0.8841786980628967,
-0.247732475399971,
0.6287042498588562,
0.1279708296060562,
-0.633988082408905,
0.37617242336273193,
-0.17610172927379608,
-0.1405770182609558,
0.5890459418296814,
0.5327261686325073,
-0.04248916730284691,
-0.27187734842300415,
-0.9098259210586548,
-0.955960750579834,
0.9954026341438293,
0.39219316840171814,
-0.18453827500343323,
0.034553006291389465,
0.4630873501300812,
0.1083088293671608,
0.34188932180404663,
-0.6587568521499634,
-0.12475795298814774,
0.41361698508262634,
-0.1793164163827896,
0.46064579486846924,
-0.47524577379226685,
-0.1602838784456253,
-0.006229414604604244,
0.47201985120773315,
0.3393082320690155,
0.29022783041000366,
0.15000292658805847,
-0.2226363718509674,
-0.0706210732460022,
0.3154629170894623,
-0.19235855340957642,
0.6260247230529785,
-0.13902492821216583,
0.5589017271995544,
-0.08562573790550232,
-0.39163386821746826,
-0.06594330817461014,
0.6415660381317139,
-0.10488143563270569,
0.056423619389534,
0.5108612179756165,
0.7150717377662659,
0.02031722664833069,
0.00007209838076960295,
0.3411391079425812,
-0.23073537647724152,
-0.002391120884567499,
-0.038741618394851685,
0.1352171003818512,
0.3260246515274048,
0.5370261669158936,
0.30248087644577026,
0.06203426420688629,
0.2913309335708618,
-0.528662919998169,
0.3677655756473541,
0.5376121997833252,
-0.21220214664936066,
-0.34442004561424255,
0.4208087921142578,
0.10638204962015152,
-0.2881874144077301,
0.2902630567550659,
-0.3659828007221222,
-0.17479164898395538,
0.5890725255012512,
0.1554725468158722,
0.6924073696136475,
-0.14575910568237305,
-0.06260088086128235,
0.30195367336273193,
0.05574001371860504,
-0.02671896666288376,
0.06057405471801758,
-0.6768763661384583,
-0.6165472269058228,
-0.0909549742937088,
-0.5999650359153748,
-0.1930459439754486,
0.36028367280960083,
-1.1526012420654297,
0.2698466181755066,
0.01645062305033207,
-0.17581598460674286,
0.3865784704685211,
0.20066453516483307,
-0.6174783706665039,
0.14025753736495972,
-0.07689429074525833,
0.40599295496940613,
-0.6813837885856628,
0.8702386021614075,
0.7792354822158813,
-0.6866488456726074,
-1.08416748046875,
0.031718529760837555,
-0.26740530133247375,
-0.28200969099998474,
0.47960343956947327,
0.16746987402439117,
0.1357441246509552,
0.009042066521942616,
-0.16831713914871216,
-0.9547735452651978,
0.9790217876434326,
0.5109246373176575,
-0.5515596270561218,
-0.46208456158638,
0.006878190208226442,
0.21459068357944489,
-0.7402312755584717,
-0.04758549854159355,
0.7958853244781494,
0.19266396760940552,
0.07741160690784454,
-0.7098276615142822,
0.20227551460266113,
-0.2891498804092407,
0.007374846376478672,
0.5399606823921204,
-0.4610353112220764,
0.8868526220321655,
-0.05749877169728279,
-0.8262286186218262,
0.08042658865451813,
0.8702477812767029,
0.12768511474132538,
0.27816349267959595,
0.5380492210388184,
0.5493477582931519,
0.5318906307220459,
-0.03040364570915699,
0.7386336326599121,
-0.18487796187400818,
0.48783668875694275,
1.6855883598327637,
-0.22811686992645264,
0.5912436842918396,
0.5741499662399292,
-0.18530718982219696,
0.3156374990940094,
0.6237847208976746,
0.1298971027135849,
0.6764901876449585,
-0.4022548198699951,
-0.24286532402038574,
-0.2837732136249542,
-0.19754788279533386,
-0.3659047484397888,
0.47739988565444946,
0.4464273750782013,
-0.5722560882568359,
-0.5758510828018188,
-0.052989061921834946,
-0.07161924988031387,
-0.29606151580810547,
-0.18672265112400055,
1.0459270477294922,
0.17740598320960999,
-0.8393086194992065,
0.13797026872634888,
-0.1664392054080963,
0.18151196837425232,
-0.3832676112651825,
-0.3137543201446533,
-0.2011011391878128,
-0.09442206472158432,
-0.2610699236392975,
-0.6428582072257996,
0.24120159447193146,
-0.11439681053161621,
-0.40048947930336,
0.21914881467819214,
0.911560595035553,
-0.9171183109283447,
-0.1530725359916687,
0.5113880038261414,
0.45310306549072266,
0.3194284737110138,
0.04127025604248047,
-0.3312757909297943,
0.0796784907579422,
-0.10452020168304443,
-0.24493996798992157,
0.3513156473636627,
0.720706045627594,
-0.03118545562028885,
0.19268891215324402,
0.49586987495422363,
0.28755080699920654,
0.02538437955081463,
0.06045346334576607,
1.0202065706253052,
-0.6023153066635132,
-0.42930734157562256,
-0.8810015916824341,
0.5790352821350098,
-0.2783082127571106,
-0.02698841504752636,
0.4565272033214569,
0.34619319438934326,
0.6726274490356445,
-0.026290571317076683,
0.547240138053894,
-0.2505892515182495,
0.3987291157245636,
-0.474412202835083,
0.35957035422325134,
-0.49655476212501526,
0.47206681966781616,
-0.2873569130897522,
-1.010714054107666,
-0.10806634277105331,
-0.005337020382285118,
0.06394524872303009,
-0.0369919016957283,
0.738562285900116,
0.3828333914279938,
-0.47427189350128174,
-0.053529299795627594,
0.08219131082296371,
-0.1306941658258438,
0.4028695225715637,
0.5517939329147339,
0.6585494875907898,
-0.5397701859474182,
0.5473134517669678,
-0.5166312456130981,
-0.1448216587305069,
0.20146675407886505,
-0.7148913741111755,
-0.8800905346870422,
-0.662215530872345,
-0.53981614112854,
0.005918656010180712,
-0.09606996178627014,
0.7291024327278137,
0.7751526236534119,
-0.480541855096817,
0.2154129594564438,
-0.22640074789524078,
0.08408956974744797,
-0.14287817478179932,
-0.26350998878479004,
0.43209731578826904,
-0.16810934245586395,
-0.8313561081886292,
0.14591659605503082,
0.5078595876693726,
0.12826880812644958,
-0.19785860180854797,
0.2113727480173111,
-0.4567025899887085,
-0.30381616950035095,
0.32486391067504883,
0.4424729645252228,
-0.5387535691261292,
0.03929789736866951,
-0.424630343914032,
-0.027802156284451485,
0.15596945583820343,
0.714228630065918,
-0.693060040473938,
0.2638970613479614,
0.4872526526451111,
0.7304654717445374,
0.5691619515419006,
0.5347663760185242,
0.33816877007484436,
-0.8716650009155273,
0.156467005610466,
0.03314179927110672,
0.4276995062828064,
0.34075653553009033,
-0.7244846820831299,
0.6185368299484253,
0.15268109738826752,
-0.1912170797586441,
-0.7038775682449341,
0.3838668167591095,
-1.0114620923995972,
-0.19768725335597992,
0.8623989820480347,
-0.6311494708061218,
-0.2854272425174713,
-0.08779752999544144,
0.19141581654548645,
0.5949511528015137,
-0.42234089970588684,
0.5350404381752014,
0.5870431065559387,
-0.3905743658542633,
-0.5890516042709351,
-0.045068930834531784,
0.3427220582962036,
-0.09968350827693939,
-0.9027423858642578,
0.17712461948394775,
0.319916695356369,
0.3076792061328888,
0.6163616180419922,
0.5477951169013977,
-0.2801182270050049,
0.10686848312616348,
-0.0124434819445014,
0.12226733565330505,
-0.26917749643325806,
-0.658460259437561,
-0.09629923850297928,
0.552444338798523,
-0.17148804664611816,
-0.6667824387550354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08304v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08304v2
|
Computational Thought Experiments for a More Rigorous Philosophy and Science of the Mind
| 2024-05-14T03:58:19 | 2024-05-15T02:32:00 |
Iris Oved, Nikhil Krishnaswamy, James Pustejovsky, Joshua Hartshorne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.NC
|
We offer philosophical motivations for a method we call Virtual World
Cognitive Science (VW CogSci), in which researchers use virtual embodied agents
that are embedded in virtual worlds to explore questions in the field of
Cognitive Science. We focus on questions about mental and linguistic
representation and the ways that such computational modeling can add rigor to
philosophical thought experiments, as well as the terminology used in the
scientific study of such representations. We find that this method forces
researchers to take a god's-eye view when describing dynamical relationships
between entities in minds and entities in an environment in a way that
eliminates the need for problematic talk of belief and concept types, such as
the belief that cats are silly, and the concept CAT, while preserving belief
and concept tokens in individual cognizers' minds. We conclude with some
further key advantages of VW CogSci for the scientific study of mental and
linguistic representation and for Cognitive Science more broadly.
|
[
-0.9234522581100464,
-0.8943825364112854,
0.9002293348312378,
-0.029637489467859268,
-0.32298094034194946,
0.28997012972831726,
-0.26016563177108765,
-0.74290531873703,
0.6705049276351929,
0.28196966648101807,
-0.5891144275665283,
0.09514473378658295,
-0.23183099925518036,
0.06591934710741043,
-0.28691667318344116,
0.6773942708969116,
0.16723570227622986,
0.08724197745323181,
-0.7812983989715576,
0.12431839853525162,
0.125761941075325,
-0.6546269059181213,
-0.5069481730461121,
-0.5977962017059326,
0.4543244242668152,
-0.15656013786792755,
0.7483951449394226,
0.1936718076467514,
0.7329117059707642,
0.32884839177131653,
0.08324428647756577,
0.11098483204841614,
-0.26618748903274536,
-0.05340218544006348,
-0.44665977358818054,
-0.6115900278091431,
-0.2724418640136719,
0.34171777963638306,
0.13676883280277252,
0.7652549147605896,
-0.2633035480976105,
0.1085858941078186,
-0.2468031942844391,
0.021632829681038857,
-0.6451281309127808,
0.27540355920791626,
-0.4490823745727539,
0.3574799597263336,
0.08370030671358109,
-0.31993257999420166,
-0.3985784351825714,
-0.3984065353870392,
0.2995045483112335,
-1.156731367111206,
0.2938078045845032,
0.22476138174533844,
0.7650688886642456,
0.238322913646698,
-0.3103732168674469,
-0.19698843359947205,
-0.9536614418029785,
0.9527028203010559,
-0.2650165557861328,
0.44544702768325806,
0.29015645384788513,
0.3657435476779938,
-0.3143373727798462,
-0.5418562889099121,
-1.2127971649169922,
-0.6631538271903992,
0.1500968337059021,
0.4277935028076172,
0.04600448161363602,
0.28099325299263,
0.42601585388183594,
0.506499171257019,
-0.26622235774993896,
-0.42355605959892273,
-0.4368336796760559,
-0.3825153112411499,
0.7192417979240417,
0.22825098037719727,
0.4974384605884552,
0.3029481768608093,
-0.10219947248697281,
-0.33607617020606995,
-0.3653777241706848,
-0.018100377172231674,
0.05367286875844002,
-0.20040826499462128,
0.11038635671138763,
0.7292159795761108,
-0.0898004025220871,
0.46010249853134155,
0.01838601939380169,
0.1664595603942871,
0.17272093892097473,
-0.21471503376960754,
-0.07278300821781158,
0.02502691186964512,
0.5187193155288696,
0.32101649045944214,
0.2369413822889328,
-0.20017802715301514,
0.3076232075691223,
0.9927257299423218,
0.7195464372634888,
-0.47156012058258057,
-0.2809271216392517,
0.10581576824188232,
-0.06843265891075134,
-0.33933866024017334,
0.04463999345898628,
-0.5753236413002014,
-0.23089899122714996,
-0.4360140562057495,
0.28311851620674133,
-0.4389864206314087,
-0.5289281010627747,
0.3411487340927124,
-0.7140032052993774,
0.2527158558368683,
0.5227987170219421,
-0.7292714715003967,
0.7129248380661011,
0.8307763934135437,
0.4663008451461792,
-0.18877042829990387,
-0.16047966480255127,
0.11629932373762131,
0.2569749653339386,
-0.5742464661598206,
0.8167054653167725,
-0.9669122695922852,
-0.7701081037521362,
-0.23222388327121735,
-0.331457257270813,
0.3676503002643585,
-0.18723107874393463,
0.39753854274749756,
-0.5544348359107971,
0.41409242153167725,
-0.943564236164093,
-0.5545395016670227,
-0.36435744166374207,
0.3934359550476074,
-0.5044901967048645,
1.1924586296081543,
-0.11800581961870193,
-0.6653079986572266,
0.209305539727211,
-0.8226786255836487,
0.03538971021771431,
0.2588263750076294,
-0.6837326884269714,
0.11202318221330643,
0.5039008259773254,
-0.2727416753768921,
-0.0049466704949736595,
-0.3721175789833069,
0.17843356728553772,
-0.8657830953598022,
-0.2666681706905365,
0.5435642600059509,
-0.009320982731878757,
0.7601040005683899,
0.3244464695453644,
-0.2557688355445862,
-0.06011234223842621,
-0.49894532561302185,
0.4543241560459137,
0.265368789434433,
0.19500404596328735,
-0.9477580189704895,
0.43472379446029663,
-0.2795557677745819,
0.08960682898759842,
0.21019403636455536,
-0.9698649048805237,
0.3648921251296997,
-0.6019821763038635,
0.5464916825294495,
0.4331578314304352,
-0.15176688134670258,
0.28015321493148804,
-0.13617880642414093,
0.16716071963310242,
-0.09201907366514206,
0.1533202826976776,
0.5129346251487732,
-0.6310257315635681,
-0.796454131603241,
-0.11504527926445007,
-0.10821663588285446,
0.3671235740184784,
-0.9081477522850037,
0.2150200605392456,
-0.12556669116020203,
-0.540449321269989,
-0.3826158344745636,
-0.48243677616119385,
0.4254278540611267,
0.4107324779033661,
0.16806428134441376,
-0.6648913621902466,
-0.5606870055198669,
-0.9821494221687317,
-0.16883708536624908,
-0.33233878016471863,
0.016114816069602966,
0.20977815985679626,
0.9882729053497314,
-0.03868863359093666,
1.1656758785247803,
-0.8547214269638062,
0.4257034361362457,
0.06452540308237076,
0.20240086317062378,
-0.20195269584655762,
0.3199280798435211,
0.515121579170227,
-0.9492921233177185,
0.04118266701698303,
0.06883764266967773,
-1.0041375160217285,
0.26775848865509033,
0.2698627710342407,
-0.30372756719589233,
-0.37122440338134766,
0.33266958594322205,
-0.8072308897972107,
0.470937043428421,
0.19732709228992462,
-0.15775734186172485,
0.47728610038757324,
-0.24311479926109314,
0.3807133436203003,
-0.8291341066360474,
-0.15215060114860535,
0.07010918855667114,
-0.04226282984018326,
-0.5696887373924255,
0.5008463263511658,
-0.11772986501455307,
-0.06483267992734909,
-0.43528422713279724,
0.2809959352016449,
-0.30117174983024597,
-0.18249467015266418,
-0.4764000177383423,
0.2777165174484253,
-0.08100435137748718,
0.4367082118988037,
0.3335014879703522,
0.7412562966346741,
0.4565839171409607,
-0.8850331902503967,
0.46618473529815674,
0.179501473903656,
-0.07931612432003021,
0.48124170303344727,
-0.5995382070541382,
0.5131596326828003,
-0.19487473368644714,
0.3727053105831146,
-0.6435568332672119,
-0.13855202496051788,
0.32758235931396484,
-0.53351229429245,
-0.4185250699520111,
0.7780380845069885,
-0.23585008084774017,
-0.6911871433258057,
-0.43157538771629333,
0.3878196179866791,
0.495798796415329,
-0.24272553622722626,
0.5176737904548645,
0.6803555488586426,
0.32415711879730225,
-0.23005922138690948,
-0.9748061895370483,
0.007654884364455938,
-0.08266400545835495,
-0.47855082154273987,
0.7370409965515137,
-0.2980746626853943,
-0.78106689453125,
0.3892383873462677,
-0.10662591457366943,
-0.11595205962657928,
0.0351235568523407,
0.22021803259849548,
0.21893775463104248,
-0.33922186493873596,
0.012396154925227165,
0.16070719063282013,
-0.07677989453077316,
0.473667174577713,
-0.4507598876953125,
0.3119826018810272,
-0.2790161073207855,
-0.500506579875946,
-0.24331572651863098,
0.5169231295585632,
0.334241658449173,
-0.20401278138160706,
0.6095273494720459,
0.20885050296783447,
-0.7293347120285034,
-0.25415894389152527,
-0.34104061126708984,
-0.19139865040779114,
-0.468315452337265,
0.19248849153518677,
-0.5264453291893005,
-0.9952478408813477,
0.36038118600845337,
-0.310292512178421,
-0.15301381051540375,
0.34744805097579956,
0.587641179561615,
-0.3163256049156189,
0.9375008344650269,
0.9634778499603271,
0.29888439178466797,
0.3740004301071167,
-0.3133321702480316,
0.4062238037586212,
-0.8665565848350525,
-0.22127115726470947,
-0.4368908107280731,
0.02548566833138466,
-0.4895020127296448,
-0.7263591289520264,
0.4495522975921631,
-0.16760562360286713,
-0.09012573957443237,
0.06049291417002678,
-0.7852276563644409,
0.6226965188980103,
0.4900132417678833,
0.06693083792924881,
0.0736248716711998,
0.07777349650859833,
-0.32651060819625854,
-0.24723133444786072,
-0.2704237699508667,
-0.47390228509902954,
0.6046343445777893,
-0.0008084099390543997,
0.5434001684188843,
0.08573604375123978,
0.4437525272369385,
0.42083293199539185,
0.3024679124355316,
-0.7861977219581604,
0.929368793964386,
0.3169465959072113,
-0.9004624485969543,
-0.1983519047498703,
-0.039539143443107605,
-0.5910143852233887,
0.5922150611877441,
-0.2137468308210373,
-0.9701108336448669,
0.1115693598985672,
0.313439279794693,
-0.35549625754356384,
0.22204506397247314,
-0.477629691362381,
0.40254661440849304,
-0.1467290222644806,
-0.3325453996658325,
-1.0049482583999634,
-0.26951125264167786,
0.5066158175468445,
0.1976451575756073,
0.032456375658512115,
0.28984370827674866,
-0.12420813739299774,
0.5946309566497803,
-0.49786776304244995,
0.793178141117096,
0.11020620167255402,
-0.08730781078338623,
0.7171884179115295,
0.03972401097416878,
0.2889541983604431,
-0.0049789962358772755,
0.15929517149925232,
0.11603295803070068,
0.24960221350193024,
-0.39750248193740845,
-0.8023233413696289,
0.5827924609184265,
-0.8003602027893066,
-0.945519208908081,
-0.8355823755264282,
-0.41280823945999146,
-0.3427113890647888,
0.005468434188514948,
0.10489112883806229,
0.05970137193799019,
-0.5737568140029907,
-0.038015540689229965,
0.984539270401001,
-0.33643829822540283,
0.007939347065985203,
0.33592644333839417,
-0.5290716886520386,
-0.2268250286579132,
0.9948599338531494,
0.051568083465099335,
0.41039249300956726,
0.29779133200645447,
0.22883278131484985,
-0.06576234102249146,
-0.28166547417640686,
-0.005547259468585253,
0.14637549221515656,
-0.49961888790130615,
0.5505864024162292,
-0.6750814318656921,
-0.2686658501625061,
-0.11627937108278275,
-0.12693874537944794,
-0.3845919668674469,
-0.4894501864910126,
-0.006782519165426493,
-0.16714125871658325,
0.4077379107475281,
0.7228754758834839,
0.09647450596094131,
0.14380817115306854,
-0.13331946730613708,
0.4956062436103821,
0.24783043563365936,
0.18580755591392517,
0.01708950847387314,
0.012259573675692081,
-0.2648927867412567,
0.2732612192630768,
-0.45769959688186646,
-1.0128167867660522,
0.0017242094036191702,
-0.061178624629974365,
0.5109004974365234,
0.21834319829940796,
-0.1559060513973236,
1.0702799558639526,
-0.4110313653945923,
0.9453665614128113,
0.30472415685653687,
-0.92624431848526,
0.49170663952827454,
-0.3643939197063446,
-0.11140839755535126,
0.24786676466464996,
0.47041505575180054,
-0.5648519992828369,
-0.5587317943572998,
-0.6329111456871033,
-0.27312105894088745,
0.2744026482105255,
0.2231665700674057,
0.18744239211082458,
-0.0713101476430893,
0.6327102184295654,
0.06208208575844765,
0.29782921075820923,
-0.43129491806030273,
-0.10348210483789444,
-0.27499282360076904,
-0.1930541843175888,
-0.013982761651277542,
0.05835265293717384,
-0.3905150294303894,
-0.5086045265197754,
0.5275442600250244,
-0.29689890146255493,
0.5434050559997559,
0.6272848844528198,
0.1971224844455719,
-0.2170654982328415,
0.0015140637988224626,
0.5750542879104614,
0.42095890641212463,
0.08940884470939636,
0.36833006143569946,
0.2227904349565506,
-0.7327019572257996,
0.06310414522886276,
-0.31472793221473694,
-0.32400450110435486,
-0.3308674395084381,
0.1456858515739441,
0.4915412962436676,
0.01840154454112053,
-0.6390719413757324,
-0.013426784425973892,
-0.24139755964279175,
-0.17932206392288208,
-0.7580820918083191,
0.27581924200057983,
0.24894219636917114,
0.34839776158332825,
-0.020905839279294014,
0.35679158568382263,
0.44094404578208923,
-0.8606301546096802,
-0.03244638815522194,
0.6008705496788025,
-0.31076088547706604,
-0.7411631345748901,
0.5438335537910461,
0.0026819927152246237,
-0.2482016235589981,
0.39385107159614563,
-0.42560499906539917,
-0.5489742159843445,
0.7135663032531738,
0.490438312292099,
0.7879437208175659,
0.009958207607269287,
0.3365204334259033,
0.18457470834255219,
0.2653363049030304,
-0.2561005651950836,
0.6134445667266846,
-0.20865517854690552,
-0.8830398917198181,
-0.4003739058971405,
-0.3367216885089874,
-0.7393645644187927,
0.13051271438598633,
-0.5765500068664551,
0.09354609996080399,
-0.5291958451271057,
-0.57704758644104,
0.31117403507232666,
0.01950795017182827,
-0.48015740513801575,
0.21539075672626495,
0.5741164088249207,
0.7161356210708618,
-0.6542736291885376,
0.966109037399292,
0.8786373138427734,
-0.4449741244316101,
-0.5155954360961914,
-0.12994836270809174,
0.08649089932441711,
-0.40552374720573425,
0.47809380292892456,
-0.07852190732955933,
-0.6202260851860046,
-0.1784224659204483,
-1.0967419147491455,
-1.268548607826233,
0.6715984344482422,
0.5213027596473694,
-0.5150137543678284,
0.05791578069329262,
-0.0005151934456080198,
1.0161889791488647,
-0.2804427444934845,
0.21484626829624176,
0.26417285203933716,
0.41325947642326355,
0.033787842839956284,
-0.7258510589599609,
-0.009595071896910667,
-0.5935956835746765,
-0.004030480980873108,
0.18660330772399902,
-0.8968347907066345,
0.8008096814155579,
-0.28401419520378113,
-0.25300899147987366,
-0.08879679441452026,
1.1015459299087524,
0.39389705657958984,
0.6367011666297913,
0.4065757691860199,
0.6512200236320496,
0.7902817130088806,
-0.02636788599193096,
1.228200078010559,
-0.0053243450820446014,
0.4426831603050232,
0.8081960082054138,
-0.39899876713752747,
0.5194734334945679,
0.8367374539375305,
-0.4079388976097107,
0.5018680691719055,
0.6768269538879395,
0.11548131704330444,
0.5847374796867371,
0.5020455718040466,
-0.24165622889995575,
-0.4878007173538208,
-0.3425596058368683,
-0.39406776428222656,
0.09853988140821457,
0.7016491889953613,
0.20338205993175507,
0.22941724956035614,
0.20726169645786285,
-0.2424974888563156,
0.17333728075027466,
-0.07666553556919098,
0.34525585174560547,
0.41802382469177246,
-0.7108076214790344,
0.26698875427246094,
-0.20724532008171082,
0.43827024102211,
-0.4862595796585083,
-0.18814140558242798,
0.3949053883552551,
0.23443228006362915,
0.019019069150090218,
-0.6335495114326477,
0.4685384929180145,
-0.019632309675216675,
-0.012111175805330276,
-0.09975852072238922,
0.7472472190856934,
0.0033888607285916805,
-0.45410919189453125,
0.3295302987098694,
0.4599541127681732,
0.3137681186199188,
0.23119451105594635,
-0.6675969362258911,
0.17803288996219635,
-0.25661715865135193,
-0.39697250723838806,
0.10740052163600922,
0.3622651696205139,
-0.4904267489910126,
0.7928341627120972,
0.6223821640014648,
0.15646491944789886,
0.18074670433998108,
-0.17837584018707275,
0.9499102234840393,
-1.0629734992980957,
-0.5195985436439514,
-0.8276878595352173,
0.0881832093000412,
-0.2662930488586426,
-0.30981558561325073,
0.6463950276374817,
0.39456772804260254,
1.0646073818206787,
-0.15097661316394806,
1.1110196113586426,
-0.29716014862060547,
-0.02549189142882824,
-0.23367761075496674,
0.2867806851863861,
-0.6834375262260437,
-0.2736492156982422,
-0.3652363121509552,
-0.621330738067627,
0.026493996381759644,
0.6492344737052917,
-0.4543435871601105,
-0.11251883953809738,
0.9386401176452637,
0.4137909710407257,
-0.16602399945259094,
0.6838675141334534,
0.3124919533729553,
0.16881337761878967,
0.33836036920547485,
0.5178673267364502,
1.2487918138504028,
-0.05009165033698082,
-0.18006068468093872,
-0.41637566685676575,
-0.1991439312696457,
0.0785645991563797,
-0.5100738406181335,
-0.9167156219482422,
-0.6884292364120483,
-0.4028054475784302,
-0.19267086684703827,
-0.007865547202527523,
0.9543665647506714,
0.46922552585601807,
-0.4982084035873413,
-0.3008188009262085,
-0.1851321905851364,
-0.2480623871088028,
-0.5070890188217163,
-0.17191192507743835,
0.047514449805021286,
-0.029962075874209404,
-0.6447796821594238,
0.2048923373222351,
0.5631703734397888,
-0.11507289111614227,
-0.7522537112236023,
0.03985995799303055,
0.07031897455453873,
0.6139093637466431,
0.6307369470596313,
0.15249373018741608,
-0.9803432822227478,
-0.6180212497711182,
0.17731769382953644,
-0.10974529385566711,
-0.1218206137418747,
0.9863834381103516,
-0.8439058065414429,
0.5826207995414734,
0.5667989253997803,
0.5182411670684814,
0.5948526263237,
-0.2726452648639679,
0.5893516540527344,
0.0521618016064167,
0.34270137548446655,
0.42600923776626587,
0.21187402307987213,
0.0246425811201334,
-0.358763724565506,
0.4943683445453644,
0.5279201865196228,
-0.09886351972818375,
-0.9192249774932861,
0.4985347390174866,
-1.2772812843322754,
-0.26325348019599915,
0.6176644563674927,
-0.004448565188795328,
-0.9030978083610535,
0.07396364212036133,
-0.3183605670928955,
0.39162972569465637,
-0.2556581497192383,
1.051016926765442,
0.9972480535507202,
-0.5082306861877441,
0.18675683438777924,
-0.9173983931541443,
0.3960335850715637,
0.5571263432502747,
-0.810539186000824,
-0.2766892910003662,
0.23814819753170013,
0.04079975560307503,
0.7034986615180969,
0.6710297465324402,
-0.03864598646759987,
0.2732832133769989,
0.29087382555007935,
0.3437325358390808,
0.14055030047893524,
-0.03572385758161545,
0.09520436823368073,
0.10675043612718582,
-0.21722783148288727,
-0.041854243725538254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08295v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08295v2
|
SpeechVerse: A Large-scale Generalizable Audio Language Model
| 2024-05-14T03:33:31 | 2024-05-31T17:47:40 |
Nilaksh Das, Saket Dingliwal, Srikanth Ronanki, Rohit Paturi, Zhaocheng Huang, Prashant Mathur, Jie Yuan, Dhanush Bekal, Xing Niu, Sai Muralidhar Jayanthi, Xilai Li, Karel Mundnich, Monica Sunkara, Sundararajan Srinivasan, Kyu J Han, Katrin Kirchhoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown incredible proficiency in performing
tasks that require semantic understanding of natural language instructions.
Recently, many works have further expanded this capability to perceive
multimodal audio and text inputs, but their capabilities are often limited to
specific fine-tuned tasks such as automatic speech recognition and translation.
We therefore develop SpeechVerse, a robust multi-task training and curriculum
learning framework that combines pre-trained speech and text foundation models
via a small set of learnable parameters, while keeping the pre-trained models
frozen during training. The models are instruction finetuned using continuous
latent representations extracted from the speech foundation model to achieve
optimal zero-shot performance on a diverse range of speech processing tasks
using natural language instructions. We perform extensive benchmarking that
includes comparing our model performance against traditional baselines across
several datasets and tasks. Furthermore, we evaluate the model's capability for
generalized instruction following by testing on out-of-domain datasets, novel
prompts, and unseen tasks. Our empirical experiments reveal that our multi-task
SpeechVerse model is even superior to conventional task-specific baselines on 9
out of the 11 tasks.
|
[
-0.14878956973552704,
-1.0119500160217285,
0.3507324457168579,
0.20485679805278778,
0.01026424951851368,
-0.07486075162887573,
-0.3985055088996887,
-0.2235497534275055,
-0.08828923106193542,
0.8031063079833984,
-0.8180392980575562,
-0.5504471659660339,
-0.7628940939903259,
-0.08205888420343399,
-0.4985632002353668,
0.9499198198318481,
0.4815812408924103,
0.04560023546218872,
-0.29967793822288513,
-0.1599404662847519,
-0.708197832107544,
-0.4176185727119446,
-0.4447295665740967,
-0.45778873562812805,
0.19350148737430573,
0.3820017874240875,
0.5501164793968201,
0.5929233431816101,
0.29913926124572754,
0.27789342403411865,
0.17665401101112366,
-0.12359289824962616,
-0.6133586764335632,
0.19745904207229614,
-0.22546406090259552,
-0.2672065198421478,
-0.5750342607498169,
0.05675715580582619,
0.7807146310806274,
1.0350228548049927,
-0.275764524936676,
0.19435124099254608,
0.016678329557180405,
0.3139134645462036,
-0.5726730823516846,
0.13456177711486816,
-0.6957433819770813,
0.03760586306452751,
-0.0007946754340082407,
-0.1572083979845047,
-0.39501312375068665,
-0.009789134375751019,
0.22291496396064758,
-0.6909735202789307,
0.3366837799549103,
-0.34794747829437256,
0.4180554449558258,
0.43556806445121765,
-0.24155652523040771,
-0.28355422616004944,
-0.9421893358230591,
1.1498663425445557,
-0.4764101505279541,
0.9226780533790588,
0.527137815952301,
0.4259152114391327,
-0.004346831236034632,
-0.5246259570121765,
-0.5716878771781921,
-0.1772187054157257,
0.5567842721939087,
-0.05419270694255829,
-0.33119022846221924,
0.17895188927650452,
0.16188944876194,
0.3318387269973755,
-0.881301760673523,
0.3307306468486786,
0.10165097564458847,
-0.27688416838645935,
0.2716524302959442,
0.19797383248806,
0.29541948437690735,
-0.02999582700431347,
-0.09721581637859344,
-0.2289685755968094,
-0.5343445539474487,
0.17065756022930145,
0.2411918044090271,
0.6176825761795044,
-0.3254002332687378,
0.5900105834007263,
-0.2581562101840973,
1.0251576900482178,
-0.0031799916177988052,
-0.4841114580631256,
0.1989176869392395,
-0.2645636200904846,
-0.444004088640213,
0.025775261223316193,
0.5261657238006592,
-0.07926404476165771,
0.08364620059728622,
-0.5748115181922913,
0.014159338548779488,
0.20247331261634827,
0.1785048544406891,
-0.8590764999389648,
-0.08718489110469818,
0.2914804518222809,
0.059575434774160385,
0.07419969141483307,
-0.33781105279922485,
-0.36904722452163696,
-0.29604753851890564,
-0.8530358672142029,
0.3630155622959137,
-0.5494091510772705,
-0.12084740400314331,
0.29935571551322937,
0.13282009959220886,
0.20429274439811707,
0.2837449610233307,
-1.0675491094589233,
0.297074556350708,
0.7943474054336548,
0.5943987965583801,
-0.1854659914970398,
-0.11305741965770721,
-1.0582754611968994,
0.3440331518650055,
-0.08415054529905319,
0.6221641898155212,
-0.8308385014533997,
-0.36829930543899536,
-0.15808017551898956,
-0.12925724685192108,
-0.1388975828886032,
-0.36950626969337463,
0.5838931202888489,
-0.32242175936698914,
0.16096924245357513,
0.05188869684934616,
-0.7498939037322998,
-0.15307734906673431,
0.08721405267715454,
-0.4987151324748993,
0.5148298740386963,
-0.033854350447654724,
-0.4265608787536621,
0.21164697408676147,
-0.4799373745918274,
-0.42889851331710815,
0.0998871922492981,
-0.3501996099948883,
-0.24350979924201965,
0.025355534628033638,
0.2535417377948761,
0.8212829232215881,
-0.29746320843696594,
0.7153828740119934,
-0.25966668128967285,
-0.4234536588191986,
-0.15054480731487274,
-0.6494210958480835,
0.7307775020599365,
0.05377878621220589,
-0.4950920045375824,
0.12989716231822968,
-0.9762164950370789,
-0.10167710483074188,
-0.034537423402071,
-0.36749863624572754,
-0.15351563692092896,
-0.0968814417719841,
0.1781194657087326,
-0.09164499491453171,
0.01747608557343483,
-0.5915533900260925,
-0.05378725007176399,
-0.5139146447181702,
0.6067184209823608,
0.5568763613700867,
-0.3229672312736511,
0.5981778502464294,
-0.09113185107707977,
0.4663563370704651,
-0.2395693063735962,
-0.2215307354927063,
-0.44839993119239807,
-0.4568977952003479,
-0.4622943699359894,
-0.5625100135803223,
0.03806566819548607,
0.8047614693641663,
-0.4786333441734314,
0.5308429598808289,
-0.48320329189300537,
-0.34237217903137207,
-0.3630395233631134,
0.3624052107334137,
0.4802851676940918,
0.7214846611022949,
0.43504464626312256,
-0.13095836341381073,
-0.4536114037036896,
-0.6989139318466187,
-0.09485939145088196,
0.2688642144203186,
-0.2616066038608551,
0.44469067454338074,
0.2730194628238678,
-0.5792790651321411,
1.2241408824920654,
-0.20427857339382172,
-0.40105846524238586,
-0.14176027476787567,
0.18474556505680084,
0.5278278589248657,
0.4746260643005371,
0.31773096323013306,
-0.7894688844680786,
-0.11404864490032196,
-0.04447750002145767,
-0.7545713782310486,
0.022855937480926514,
-0.02827133610844612,
0.19311247766017914,
-0.13159798085689545,
0.363743394613266,
-0.5697121620178223,
0.14785771071910858,
0.7732071876525879,
-0.17595897614955902,
0.5410474538803101,
-0.1777171939611435,
0.002833492821082473,
-0.9109631180763245,
0.18363822996616364,
-0.15687429904937744,
-0.34882310032844543,
-0.8068337440490723,
0.05991275608539581,
-0.13719327747821808,
-0.6161435842514038,
-0.49445459246635437,
0.5931621789932251,
-0.1746102124452591,
-0.17854347825050354,
-0.29263195395469666,
0.12661264836788177,
0.05354731157422066,
0.5544873476028442,
0.16104549169540405,
0.8377791047096252,
0.8655075430870056,
-0.7162550091743469,
0.5419732332229614,
0.2936883866786957,
-0.30857235193252563,
0.8479519486427307,
-0.7734113931655884,
0.3049149215221405,
-0.24263161420822144,
0.2648410499095917,
-0.857968807220459,
-0.38965484499931335,
-0.15593980252742767,
-0.40738698840141296,
0.40701594948768616,
0.15937337279319763,
-0.4163196384906769,
-0.19527947902679443,
0.22665345668792725,
0.16092312335968018,
0.2592346966266632,
-0.369426429271698,
0.8228431344032288,
0.5062506198883057,
-0.2960963845252991,
-0.7935362458229065,
-0.7212725281715393,
0.23246321082115173,
-0.0023820011410862207,
-0.510123074054718,
0.31311413645744324,
-0.2420848160982132,
-0.11972764879465103,
-0.13079361617565155,
-0.10665398836135864,
-0.23051607608795166,
0.021763542667031288,
0.5492998957633972,
-0.04422628507018089,
-0.3028992712497711,
0.149718776345253,
0.07575605064630508,
-0.07502789795398712,
-0.17397496104240417,
-0.5546559691429138,
0.4301285445690155,
-0.12300001084804535,
-0.3760547339916229,
-0.4597201943397522,
0.5003252029418945,
0.37161412835121155,
-0.31234052777290344,
0.48352229595184326,
0.677230954170227,
-0.4359719455242157,
-0.28463709354400635,
-0.585189700126648,
-0.07381843030452728,
-0.4363146722316742,
0.6378306746482849,
-0.25933632254600525,
-1.3734261989593506,
0.2631286680698395,
0.10959231108427048,
0.3102383613586426,
0.16842252016067505,
0.4873974621295929,
0.0034823527093976736,
0.975664496421814,
0.8793437480926514,
-0.21157021820545197,
0.30613288283348083,
-0.31008797883987427,
0.09148908406496048,
-0.46285954117774963,
-0.04652746394276619,
-0.4983203411102295,
0.08368857204914093,
0.016060885041952133,
-0.6475660800933838,
0.230935201048851,
0.16910260915756226,
-0.43750718235969543,
0.4902341067790985,
-0.44988277554512024,
0.5697291493415833,
0.47272902727127075,
-0.07163301110267639,
0.15634657442569733,
0.1856839507818222,
-0.20003585517406464,
-0.0010467724641785026,
-0.5777862071990967,
-0.35797327756881714,
1.1089668273925781,
0.43494099378585815,
0.5793866515159607,
0.12289253622293472,
0.5479723215103149,
0.37517625093460083,
0.18877369165420532,
-0.6541880369186401,
0.3866921067237854,
-0.5910859704017639,
-0.6135643124580383,
-0.5171244740486145,
-0.5325040817260742,
-0.8161029815673828,
0.21696358919143677,
-0.32105374336242676,
-0.7552949786186218,
-0.13832102715969086,
0.13359932601451874,
-0.47272518277168274,
0.13186103105545044,
-0.6023183465003967,
0.8462483882904053,
-0.10752153396606445,
-0.33638906478881836,
-0.31151121854782104,
-0.5352144241333008,
0.23835378885269165,
-0.15544088184833527,
0.5221245884895325,
-0.21160584688186646,
0.15920285880565643,
0.5479583740234375,
0.11531221866607666,
1.0752331018447876,
-0.3011608421802521,
-0.1895183026790619,
0.1283051073551178,
-0.04806483909487724,
0.254543274641037,
0.10963136702775955,
-0.07808934897184372,
0.3026048243045807,
-0.2381857931613922,
-0.32086455821990967,
-0.3416518270969391,
0.7938539981842041,
-0.9126716256141663,
-0.4661121368408203,
0.033560868352651596,
-0.846990168094635,
-0.6330146789550781,
0.40598034858703613,
0.0777168795466423,
0.866719663143158,
-0.5058220028877258,
0.4529465436935425,
1.0238345861434937,
-0.5051882863044739,
0.39997395873069763,
0.5419759750366211,
-0.03695439547300339,
-0.4743216931819916,
1.0302765369415283,
-0.14347349107265472,
0.21172846853733063,
0.7618398070335388,
0.12722378969192505,
-0.42000237107276917,
-0.45077815651893616,
-0.46531081199645996,
0.03592825308442116,
-0.7998974323272705,
0.036810316145420074,
-0.8955913782119751,
-0.031551294028759,
-0.8117578625679016,
-0.05832566320896149,
-0.48816072940826416,
-0.22190462052822113,
-0.515146791934967,
0.0017563856672495604,
-0.06096912547945976,
0.46619531512260437,
-0.04998628795146942,
0.4803251624107361,
-0.7202184796333313,
0.7056785225868225,
0.7893279790878296,
0.34458035230636597,
-0.17731042206287384,
-0.7452357411384583,
-0.03329356759786606,
0.24256710708141327,
-0.2841373682022095,
-0.5995221138000488,
0.3407710790634155,
0.7099338173866272,
0.7153406143188477,
0.45736682415008545,
-0.2772315740585327,
0.6081650257110596,
-0.8606468439102173,
0.6592305302619934,
0.4687349796295166,
-1.0014958381652832,
0.4467769265174866,
-0.6930111646652222,
0.6359177231788635,
0.3870159387588501,
0.21338313817977905,
-0.3480704426765442,
-0.5068525075912476,
-0.395190566778183,
-0.6105443239212036,
0.46866142749786377,
0.10065409541130066,
0.4062398374080658,
0.1769338697195053,
0.14812016487121582,
0.2068595588207245,
0.33356308937072754,
-0.4762886166572571,
-0.14501789212226868,
-0.457987904548645,
-0.07469438761472702,
-0.5604311227798462,
0.004561936017125845,
-0.09873373061418533,
-0.3438302278518677,
0.3590933084487915,
-0.33016687631607056,
0.3255615830421448,
-0.07743203639984131,
-0.2433091253042221,
0.016119390726089478,
0.48418307304382324,
0.8716490864753723,
0.6227526068687439,
-0.23704619705677032,
0.0828443318605423,
0.023530540987849236,
-0.6598532199859619,
0.08361507207155228,
0.2828579545021057,
0.21103835105895996,
-0.007994039915502071,
0.6150042414665222,
1.1364765167236328,
0.6879652738571167,
-0.9201707243919373,
0.5928506255149841,
-0.016249829903244972,
-0.36171847581863403,
-0.3835355341434479,
0.228515163064003,
0.40390822291374207,
0.16970162093639374,
0.43985944986343384,
0.18381823599338531,
0.19627365469932556,
-0.40920448303222656,
0.5277870297431946,
0.4285323917865753,
-0.5298532843589783,
-0.33201852440834045,
0.984302818775177,
0.15430015325546265,
-0.24657297134399414,
0.4864083528518677,
-0.05813158303499222,
-0.10513176769018173,
0.40579116344451904,
0.5326544642448425,
0.815683901309967,
-0.24413631856441498,
0.26012444496154785,
0.1954408586025238,
0.10189893841743469,
0.06898494064807892,
0.06277211755514145,
-0.35682910680770874,
-0.6030457019805908,
-0.8416730165481567,
-0.9562474489212036,
-0.5558323860168457,
0.2321237474679947,
-0.5580073595046997,
0.08346367627382278,
-0.5245451331138611,
-0.14076173305511475,
0.172748401761055,
-0.2172001302242279,
-0.939410388469696,
0.3569890558719635,
0.4451740086078644,
0.6868973970413208,
-0.7625330686569214,
1.063665747642517,
0.4804816246032715,
-0.024190261960029602,
-0.8274602293968201,
-0.4300636351108551,
0.04580267146229744,
-0.7955808639526367,
0.6558114886283875,
0.3712868392467499,
-0.19463390111923218,
0.22772008180618286,
-0.6362626552581787,
-0.8296694755554199,
0.9437972903251648,
0.9175207614898682,
-0.8407192826271057,
-0.07739564031362534,
0.4658275544643402,
0.4525485932826996,
-0.40424686670303345,
0.12842008471488953,
0.3953641951084137,
0.11777947098016739,
0.3150992691516876,
-1.10454523563385,
-0.5558502078056335,
-0.01980949006974697,
-0.218173548579216,
-0.20103074610233307,
-0.06668318063020706,
0.8513560891151428,
-0.1116180568933487,
-0.05276794731616974,
-0.14917218685150146,
0.7850983738899231,
0.4346117079257965,
0.3303295969963074,
0.502183198928833,
0.7409589886665344,
0.8509175777435303,
0.05490807443857193,
0.9259406328201294,
-0.09339930862188339,
0.1929110884666443,
1.275999665260315,
-0.3390137255191803,
0.8496521711349487,
0.3160093426704407,
-0.03435270115733147,
0.31977519392967224,
0.2185700237751007,
0.12344881147146225,
0.6645166873931885,
0.18483401834964752,
-0.2066998928785324,
-0.5860458612442017,
-0.3202723562717438,
-0.2705720067024231,
0.6013304591178894,
0.42775657773017883,
0.041413500905036926,
-0.3255771994590759,
0.5808664560317993,
-0.21222953498363495,
0.22672876715660095,
-0.42068782448768616,
0.5062930583953857,
0.1964617520570755,
-0.3213289976119995,
0.6759666204452515,
-0.1269788295030594,
0.8964865207672119,
-0.6546086668968201,
-0.15318483114242554,
0.09758060425519943,
0.2854246497154236,
-0.013569719158113003,
-0.461139053106308,
0.3104245364665985,
0.10361142456531525,
-0.4136839210987091,
-0.38039782643318176,
0.46166130900382996,
-0.5370187163352966,
-0.413371741771698,
0.23022039234638214,
0.2002667635679245,
-0.022733811289072037,
-0.2116755098104477,
-0.7302983999252319,
0.17058691382408142,
-0.22897246479988098,
-0.0950041115283966,
0.2795315086841583,
0.18092432618141174,
0.14765562117099762,
0.7232220768928528,
0.7634245753288269,
0.037385642528533936,
0.1859898865222931,
0.21043647825717926,
0.602423369884491,
-0.3588748276233673,
-0.8260119557380676,
-0.5029159188270569,
0.4139103889465332,
0.11537150293588638,
-0.20672591030597687,
0.6399419903755188,
0.42808014154434204,
0.7974878549575806,
-0.12114904820919037,
0.7415722608566284,
0.16911067068576813,
0.7791091203689575,
-0.4264916479587555,
0.5813342332839966,
-0.4303582012653351,
0.10660038888454437,
-0.30442193150520325,
-1.0390716791152954,
-0.4636456370353699,
0.5963195562362671,
-0.26553070545196533,
-0.09603951126337051,
0.2843835949897766,
0.5692769289016724,
-0.1972244530916214,
0.27298662066459656,
0.4918367862701416,
-0.03565194457769394,
0.4399876594543457,
0.7060154676437378,
0.47103777527809143,
-0.15090571343898773,
0.31193864345550537,
-0.07763532549142838,
-0.2568073272705078,
0.08258078247308731,
-0.9350893497467041,
-1.0339438915252686,
-0.5135787129402161,
-0.3062952160835266,
0.05420096591114998,
0.11398064345121384,
0.7768551707267761,
1.0196521282196045,
-0.9193110466003418,
-0.30648186802864075,
-0.15475930273532867,
-0.18098273873329163,
-0.25643694400787354,
-0.16411228477954865,
0.1952105164527893,
-0.20064450800418854,
-0.7356114983558655,
0.855830192565918,
0.31698331236839294,
-0.17432060837745667,
-0.30966705083847046,
-0.2473091036081314,
0.04325218126177788,
0.025633351877331734,
0.6093692779541016,
0.35349851846694946,
-0.7513793706893921,
-0.30457746982574463,
0.18097467720508575,
-0.13797752559185028,
-0.3227371275424957,
0.624426543712616,
-0.6639416813850403,
0.6095903515815735,
0.25027087330818176,
0.9675536155700684,
0.3329111337661743,
-0.2641063928604126,
0.5117899775505066,
-0.9493933916091919,
0.3633556067943573,
0.354240357875824,
0.049161527305841446,
0.5451186299324036,
-0.1520276963710785,
0.14098230004310608,
0.30125874280929565,
-0.5414543151855469,
-0.8593553900718689,
0.013975673355162144,
-1.1091715097427368,
-0.30872246623039246,
1.0728453397750854,
-0.12194167822599411,
-0.06347758322954178,
-0.10301011055707932,
0.18327347934246063,
0.3279619514942169,
-0.23452363908290863,
0.18018943071365356,
0.5034633874893188,
0.02453591488301754,
-0.15188638865947723,
-0.9069597125053406,
0.1266051083803177,
0.3510834574699402,
-0.4209958612918854,
0.11872179061174393,
0.6086942553520203,
0.32471588253974915,
0.1967596560716629,
0.6355814933776855,
0.08320210129022598,
0.2133866548538208,
-0.1726481020450592,
0.052733372896909714,
-0.3931995630264282,
-0.5783470273017883,
-0.5388990044593811,
0.3743707239627838,
-0.340284526348114,
-0.03307714685797691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08254v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08254v1
|
Detecting Fallacies in Climate Misinformation: A Technocognitive Approach to Identifying Misleading Argumentation
| 2024-05-14T01:01:44 | 2024-05-14T01:01:44 |
Francisco Zanartu, John Cook, Markus Wagner, Julian Garcia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Misinformation about climate change is a complex societal issue requiring
holistic, interdisciplinary solutions at the intersection between technology
and psychology. One proposed solution is a "technocognitive" approach,
involving the synthesis of psychological and computer science research.
Psychological research has identified that interventions in response to
misinformation require both fact-based (e.g., factual explanations) and
technique-based (e.g., explanations of misleading techniques) content. However,
little progress has been made on documenting and detecting fallacies in climate
misinformation. In this study, we apply a previously developed critical
thinking methodology for deconstructing climate misinformation, in order to
develop a dataset mapping different types of climate misinformation to
reasoning fallacies. This dataset is used to train a model to detect fallacies
in climate misinformation. Our study shows F1 scores that are 2.5 to 3.5 better
than previous works. The fallacies that are easiest to detect include fake
experts and anecdotal arguments, while fallacies that require background
knowledge, such as oversimplification, misrepresentation, and slothful
induction, are relatively more difficult to detect. This research lays the
groundwork for development of solutions where automatically detected climate
misinformation can be countered with generative technique-based corrections.
|
[
-0.5855045318603516,
-0.9487274289131165,
0.4998991787433624,
0.08891331404447556,
-0.1845555156469345,
0.4557590186595917,
-0.2049487829208374,
-0.21812914311885834,
0.06751798838376999,
0.17505107820034027,
-0.5117343664169312,
-0.46445852518081665,
-0.603848397731781,
-0.013993301428854465,
-0.4033723473548889,
0.7032931447029114,
0.04466565325856209,
-0.19662532210350037,
-0.21445152163505554,
0.21809445321559906,
-0.7005903124809265,
-0.30071449279785156,
-0.46576181054115295,
-0.4566190540790558,
0.18834556639194489,
0.7470095753669739,
0.7686271071434021,
0.19764894247055054,
0.4442758560180664,
0.27159398794174194,
-0.16717380285263062,
0.34571579098701477,
-0.3862532675266266,
-0.1547127366065979,
-0.0895768329501152,
-0.32741308212280273,
0.21667462587356567,
0.36098167300224304,
0.23102818429470062,
0.20077936351299286,
-0.39851734042167664,
0.29284849762916565,
-0.2319762110710144,
0.501851499080658,
-0.897352933883667,
0.20396432280540466,
-0.9381346702575684,
0.08504993468523026,
0.1584305763244629,
-0.3124459981918335,
-0.5164461135864258,
-0.3058052361011505,
0.06365389376878738,
-0.50876384973526,
0.8034849166870117,
0.11848855018615723,
0.4951538145542145,
0.5324951410293579,
-0.18105104565620422,
-0.4642118215560913,
-0.978198766708374,
0.690498948097229,
-0.5940271019935608,
0.3067564070224762,
0.20792457461357117,
0.13047422468662262,
0.015691222622990608,
-0.15814144909381866,
-0.9200959205627441,
-0.21328940987586975,
0.09254639595746994,
0.31749996542930603,
0.09693221002817154,
-0.5252965688705444,
0.32243022322654724,
-0.10019034892320633,
-0.5247383713722229,
-0.11694762110710144,
-0.4213401973247528,
-0.6283013820648193,
0.6775652170181274,
-0.07191777229309082,
0.11309309303760529,
-0.16457903385162354,
-0.4942585229873657,
-0.27170637249946594,
-0.45134779810905457,
-0.20472410321235657,
0.29901254177093506,
0.3365737497806549,
-0.12900686264038086,
0.20703217387199402,
0.2569802701473236,
0.33778584003448486,
0.2290814220905304,
-0.15332472324371338,
0.12291494011878967,
-0.44779443740844727,
-0.17864595353603363,
0.5361918807029724,
0.3487996459007263,
0.6163405179977417,
0.17092910408973694,
0.008219695650041103,
-0.09891185164451599,
0.34245550632476807,
0.29482293128967285,
-0.2657012343406677,
-0.32522857189178467,
-0.010171911679208279,
-0.24810928106307983,
-0.535368025302887,
0.12420260161161423,
-0.8109932541847229,
-0.6735985279083252,
-0.252620667219162,
0.15628336369991302,
-0.20883174240589142,
-0.5957932472229004,
0.00505323801189661,
-0.7327291369438171,
0.042141564190387726,
0.5474735498428345,
-0.2587866187095642,
-0.07497984170913696,
0.4043020009994507,
0.7501245737075806,
0.07758044451475143,
-0.23304961621761322,
0.2752287983894348,
0.02962511032819748,
-0.5434079766273499,
1.2491285800933838,
-0.8015475273132324,
-0.5995824337005615,
-0.10459592938423157,
-0.02257782220840454,
-0.2888038754463196,
-0.5205453634262085,
0.4060833156108856,
-0.42676472663879395,
0.5982661247253418,
-0.2403184026479721,
-0.27909642457962036,
-0.43360579013824463,
0.34709545969963074,
-0.6321606636047363,
1.2276780605316162,
0.06913260370492935,
-1.0996609926223755,
0.6560764312744141,
-0.7189965844154358,
-0.2574739158153534,
-0.0453014150261879,
-0.05469031631946564,
-0.6203901171684265,
-0.18570983409881592,
0.1379668116569519,
-0.015766145661473274,
-0.5462892651557922,
0.5777714848518372,
-0.32761576771736145,
-0.239400714635849,
0.4228440225124359,
-0.7137600779533386,
0.7815747261047363,
0.08351758867502213,
-0.7136863470077515,
-0.14792324602603912,
-0.519388735294342,
-0.08920133858919144,
-0.07231446355581284,
-0.21827824413776398,
-0.17396284639835358,
-0.06854993849992752,
0.01079847477376461,
0.17848892509937286,
0.036624208092689514,
-0.5986536741256714,
-0.09551049023866653,
0.16405442357063293,
0.48859110474586487,
0.6332718133926392,
0.004371743183583021,
-0.026889266446232796,
-0.49733057618141174,
0.37520259618759155,
0.4643838107585907,
0.17509247362613678,
0.15458545088768005,
-0.39914193749427795,
-0.6764125227928162,
0.18494325876235962,
-0.04514932632446289,
0.9779378175735474,
-0.8860431909561157,
0.325661301612854,
-0.07948270440101624,
-0.9309092164039612,
-0.1356552243232727,
-0.24510376155376434,
0.21425384283065796,
1.1396807432174683,
0.526975691318512,
0.15944059193134308,
-0.295632541179657,
-0.7437503337860107,
-0.3940940201282501,
-0.44467103481292725,
0.33084261417388916,
-0.03252634033560753,
0.9289143681526184,
-0.08421478420495987,
1.0677380561828613,
-0.635753333568573,
0.266348659992218,
0.1597023457288742,
0.4342131018638611,
0.06714676320552826,
0.6122622489929199,
0.6463011503219604,
-1.1420215368270874,
-0.17329105734825134,
-0.22805653512477875,
-0.6313505172729492,
0.27547895908355713,
-0.1887962818145752,
0.2803651988506317,
0.3167824149131775,
0.442468523979187,
-0.3398806154727936,
0.47848713397979736,
0.015059102326631546,
-0.44149744510650635,
0.7600917220115662,
-0.20225819945335388,
0.6683926582336426,
-0.7132638096809387,
0.10181963443756104,
0.4460412561893463,
-0.04790281504392624,
-0.576058566570282,
-0.30419549345970154,
-0.1918659210205078,
0.06716232001781464,
-0.3281427025794983,
0.24686749279499054,
-0.17622072994709015,
0.430284321308136,
-0.30444544553756714,
-0.06289497017860413,
-0.1264006495475769,
0.013904447667300701,
0.33568811416625977,
0.7868098020553589,
0.45445433259010315,
-0.5007593631744385,
0.5945594310760498,
0.15843170881271362,
-0.2297416478395462,
0.7875707745552063,
-0.11411861330270767,
0.4033043086528778,
-0.4061599671840668,
0.37829580903053284,
-0.9519420266151428,
-0.15149706602096558,
0.4989583194255829,
-0.46865642070770264,
-0.11405599862337112,
-0.10610367357730865,
-0.5394635796546936,
-0.5986999273300171,
-0.23278865218162537,
0.08589163422584534,
0.1565690040588379,
-0.43414005637168884,
0.5666290521621704,
0.3485087752342224,
0.0009038798161782324,
-0.626753568649292,
-0.977077305316925,
0.07470809668302536,
-0.5698345899581909,
-0.3363193869590759,
0.14853829145431519,
-0.25954803824424744,
-0.35490673780441284,
-0.06680386513471603,
-0.3374558091163635,
-0.4047435522079468,
0.31540679931640625,
0.10706400871276855,
0.19746533036231995,
-0.08218584954738617,
0.282437801361084,
-0.40181413292884827,
-0.1751166731119156,
0.246326744556427,
-0.16898983716964722,
0.3132905066013336,
-0.04707755148410797,
-0.04993646591901779,
-0.308092325925827,
0.36829447746276855,
0.6153275370597839,
0.3989960849285126,
0.8199367523193359,
0.4766163229942322,
-0.629105806350708,
-0.13421203196048737,
-0.8916832208633423,
-0.24013054370880127,
-0.3923885226249695,
0.003338863141834736,
-0.03796825557947159,
-0.43212711811065674,
0.33209550380706787,
-0.3039390444755554,
-0.006177916657179594,
0.6093637347221375,
0.16454266011714935,
-0.25379490852355957,
0.6420411467552185,
0.531296968460083,
-0.03389965370297432,
0.31902697682380676,
-0.3796227276325226,
0.35756033658981323,
-0.21612945199012756,
-0.6745897531509399,
-0.6470794081687927,
0.002753629582002759,
-0.5049894452095032,
-0.5456673502922058,
0.29332637786865234,
-0.22464904189109802,
-0.4355965256690979,
0.15697699785232544,
-0.6068671941757202,
0.4683447778224945,
0.4039333760738373,
0.2597915828227997,
0.3265381157398224,
0.0586068332195282,
0.3529317080974579,
0.008553449995815754,
-0.911133348941803,
-0.5976106524467468,
0.6393833160400391,
0.13759513199329376,
0.49807068705558777,
-0.03077346459031105,
0.21062058210372925,
0.9277740716934204,
0.5788424015045166,
-0.713314950466156,
0.4635891616344452,
0.1754656881093979,
-0.7340954542160034,
-0.2342274934053421,
-0.42720234394073486,
-0.4262714684009552,
0.04790901020169258,
-0.3766360580921173,
-0.3160061240196228,
0.3964115381240845,
0.35037118196487427,
0.003237728960812092,
0.32038530707359314,
-0.7398827075958252,
0.7087594866752625,
-0.08453107625246048,
0.03169160336256027,
-0.6026720404624939,
-0.5159903764724731,
0.25972115993499756,
-0.323496013879776,
0.596778154373169,
-0.012063449248671532,
0.3307590186595917,
0.8605479001998901,
-0.26764506101608276,
0.9173734784126282,
-0.5805817246437073,
-0.12579084932804108,
0.5024523138999939,
-0.016968877986073494,
0.3241689205169678,
-0.08156242221593857,
-0.3659842908382416,
0.07266750186681747,
0.03203800693154335,
-0.4962002635002136,
-0.4295346140861511,
0.38514408469200134,
-0.5675230622291565,
-0.7470056414604187,
-0.6910586357116699,
-0.20773354172706604,
-0.23566459119319916,
-0.1504722535610199,
0.37496522068977356,
0.30087971687316895,
-0.45703527331352234,
-0.17990311980247498,
0.6283538937568665,
0.19752416014671326,
0.34728124737739563,
0.6098949909210205,
0.3643617331981659,
-0.3829871714115143,
0.8128917217254639,
0.3046114146709442,
0.08715610206127167,
0.049917202442884445,
0.4562426209449768,
-0.17010289430618286,
-0.5673801898956299,
-0.005027014296501875,
0.12456341832876205,
-0.9856342673301697,
-0.2121250033378601,
-0.0005538113764487207,
-0.15906867384910583,
-0.38581278920173645,
-0.13493387401103973,
-0.15541568398475647,
-0.15133585035800934,
-0.2986806631088257,
-0.19632938504219055,
0.4020005762577057,
0.6184591054916382,
-0.22623620927333832,
0.4224720895290375,
-0.5193084478378296,
0.2425585687160492,
0.09350734204053879,
-0.07583939284086227,
0.0022932998836040497,
-0.37268176674842834,
-0.26822009682655334,
0.3475680947303772,
-0.39395883679389954,
-0.8592317700386047,
0.28379425406455994,
-0.045173004269599915,
0.4325430691242218,
0.4831267297267914,
0.08913744986057281,
0.7177240252494812,
-0.022040648385882378,
0.9274827241897583,
0.42820048332214355,
-1.1570857763290405,
0.76316899061203,
-0.010731082409620285,
0.12432269006967545,
0.5966571569442749,
0.5522156357765198,
-0.581688404083252,
-0.4182283878326416,
-1.0095336437225342,
-0.49355071783065796,
0.5766329169273376,
-0.0899580642580986,
-0.18645700812339783,
-0.04987801983952522,
0.2911280393600464,
0.31019964814186096,
0.39899924397468567,
-0.5304529666900635,
-0.09280496835708618,
-0.44170257449150085,
0.11199472099542618,
-0.15517979860305786,
-0.002149250591173768,
-0.5227207541465759,
-0.1476038247346878,
0.7236006855964661,
-0.4348127841949463,
0.12503954768180847,
0.31243792176246643,
-0.02826227806508541,
-0.09850505739450455,
0.21284812688827515,
0.6610220074653625,
0.9505193829536438,
-0.082590751349926,
0.39351996779441833,
0.24432899057865143,
-0.39886724948883057,
0.2271122932434082,
-0.04866130277514458,
-0.529354453086853,
0.12297376245260239,
0.608826220035553,
0.46674007177352905,
-0.17119796574115753,
-0.37229135632514954,
0.329923152923584,
-0.054850783199071884,
-0.3143247961997986,
-0.514369785785675,
-0.007251046597957611,
0.006562817841768265,
0.12190902978181839,
0.35864949226379395,
0.8439074754714966,
0.17612691223621368,
-0.7521550059318542,
-0.20847724378108978,
0.22594325244426727,
-0.311704158782959,
-0.29824793338775635,
0.4343087673187256,
0.42419856786727905,
-0.03633648157119751,
0.7145567536354065,
0.2098010629415512,
-0.6588342785835266,
0.8221104145050049,
0.5353837013244629,
0.6448386907577515,
-0.31634730100631714,
0.7549392580986023,
0.2689577639102936,
0.5960400104522705,
-0.33034345507621765,
0.5422160625457764,
-0.1457555741071701,
-1.0218435525894165,
-0.01581215299665928,
0.10538120567798615,
-0.3848176896572113,
0.13250064849853516,
-0.31630876660346985,
0.07221405953168869,
-0.5537130832672119,
-0.36852240562438965,
-0.14029455184936523,
-0.2214808464050293,
-0.7220761775970459,
0.4350453317165375,
0.30170032382011414,
1.259832739830017,
-1.3732255697250366,
0.19711697101593018,
0.5286142230033875,
-0.3089160621166229,
-0.4412621557712555,
0.459597110748291,
0.31180983781814575,
-0.5819236040115356,
0.730237603187561,
0.18123143911361694,
-0.9278542995452881,
-0.2971280813217163,
-1.034511685371399,
-0.6510897874832153,
0.950773298740387,
0.5991073846817017,
-0.544025719165802,
0.24379198253154755,
-0.0550210140645504,
0.32165995240211487,
-0.507652997970581,
0.46317434310913086,
0.6526257991790771,
0.9694716334342957,
0.16977566480636597,
-0.8882392644882202,
0.11684847623109818,
0.017889341339468956,
-0.165571391582489,
-0.11872071772813797,
-0.9523035883903503,
0.3148224651813507,
-0.24755559861660004,
-0.4130897521972656,
-0.4501643478870392,
0.42160511016845703,
0.09808250516653061,
0.896697998046875,
0.953660249710083,
0.4071289002895355,
1.072462797164917,
-0.21260997653007507,
0.5905836820602417,
-0.21166372299194336,
0.5124202966690063,
0.6878520846366882,
-0.22338421642780304,
0.6434054374694824,
0.4407427906990051,
0.14358149468898773,
0.7692536115646362,
0.9722845554351807,
-0.02990780584514141,
0.587450385093689,
0.23176024854183197,
-0.2931675612926483,
-0.7420098185539246,
-0.286361426115036,
-0.3429988622665405,
0.3195618987083435,
0.8017334342002869,
0.011191029101610184,
-0.0958280861377716,
0.0979432687163353,
0.16180522739887238,
0.2637377381324768,
-0.20319899916648865,
0.6846628189086914,
-0.14672571420669556,
-0.774332582950592,
0.6203972101211548,
-0.11573982238769531,
0.5103005766868591,
0.003772885072976351,
-0.16038621962070465,
-0.0035824687220156193,
-0.07641433924436569,
-0.388109415769577,
-0.9284281134605408,
0.3873229920864105,
0.049192339181900024,
-0.3017975986003876,
-0.27921614050865173,
0.5452532172203064,
-0.18066754937171936,
-0.5187897682189941,
0.047809988260269165,
0.4457928538322449,
0.0882018506526947,
0.035100165754556656,
-0.8818160891532898,
-0.08184236288070679,
0.06072496250271797,
0.061174456030130386,
-0.48391783237457275,
0.22172632813453674,
0.01830068789422512,
0.7295768857002258,
0.5333066582679749,
-0.01791367493569851,
-0.31194743514060974,
0.036907557398080826,
0.7665645480155945,
-0.8650082349777222,
-0.6253934502601624,
-0.6876835823059082,
0.27492666244506836,
-0.32059091329574585,
-0.2656571567058563,
0.2842853367328644,
0.5630282759666443,
0.6732047200202942,
-0.25249388813972473,
1.202338457107544,
0.002468455582857132,
0.4743947386741638,
-0.6460753083229065,
0.15295881032943726,
-0.08169226348400116,
0.21914243698120117,
0.11286424100399017,
-0.8878697752952576,
-0.2699083089828491,
0.47594910860061646,
-0.7270886301994324,
0.12114757299423218,
0.8947703242301941,
0.7338783144950867,
-0.01466177124530077,
0.462831974029541,
-0.10583141446113586,
0.31978148221969604,
0.32863035798072815,
0.27562597393989563,
1.0115153789520264,
-0.14183276891708374,
0.3817239999771118,
-0.02523781917989254,
-0.30256807804107666,
-0.3312109410762787,
-1.114335298538208,
-0.6241507530212402,
-0.560361921787262,
-0.9724542498588562,
-0.567791759967804,
0.26101094484329224,
0.7542998194694519,
0.629527747631073,
-0.7176751494407654,
0.003080070484429598,
-0.20232589542865753,
0.3631942868232727,
-0.2682536244392395,
-0.3164846897125244,
0.2154901623725891,
0.14996887743473053,
-0.40066269040107727,
0.6067993640899658,
0.09088297933340073,
0.026192573830485344,
-0.5104576349258423,
0.2485949993133545,
0.0032028325367718935,
0.33244946599006653,
0.05779239535331726,
0.28909242153167725,
-0.7136462330818176,
-0.6644521355628967,
-0.4349101781845093,
0.14009422063827515,
0.19710372388362885,
0.8317424654960632,
-0.8990640044212341,
0.45801031589508057,
0.5756038427352905,
0.15642528235912323,
0.2473514825105667,
-0.002554213162511587,
0.38692155480384827,
-0.39695921540260315,
-0.09970751404762268,
0.25794336199760437,
0.050933513790369034,
0.7245783805847168,
-0.5327601432800293,
0.28620848059654236,
0.6794369220733643,
-0.34392088651657104,
-0.6370057463645935,
0.12832990288734436,
-0.6896237134933472,
-0.3926895260810852,
0.7434805035591125,
0.028993412852287292,
-0.18930061161518097,
-0.35903412103652954,
-0.23095455765724182,
-0.03001243621110916,
-0.6287721395492554,
1.3944518566131592,
1.1807156801223755,
-0.13886049389839172,
0.05586456134915352,
-0.1739649772644043,
0.3855474293231964,
0.01383579708635807,
-0.9203091263771057,
0.2858383357524872,
0.5432642698287964,
0.4084395468235016,
0.5628817677497864,
0.408111035823822,
0.3542778491973877,
0.45565932989120483,
0.21629931032657623,
-0.3187178373336792,
0.06513383984565735,
-0.4601888954639435,
-0.004689738620072603,
0.15253791213035583,
-0.2062395215034485,
-0.006472098641097546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08238v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08238v1
|
Silver-Tongued and Sundry: Exploring Intersectional Pronouns with ChatGPT
| 2024-05-13T23:38:50 | 2024-05-13T23:38:50 |
Takao Fujii, Katie Seaborn, Madeleine Steeds
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
ChatGPT is a conversational agent built on a large language model. Trained on
a significant portion of human output, ChatGPT can mimic people to a degree. As
such, we need to consider what social identities ChatGPT simulates (or can be
designed to simulate). In this study, we explored the case of identity
simulation through Japanese first-person pronouns, which are tightly connected
to social identities in intersectional ways, i.e., intersectional pronouns. We
conducted a controlled online experiment where people from two regions in Japan
(Kanto and Kinki) witnessed interactions with ChatGPT using ten sets of
first-person pronouns. We discovered that pronouns alone can evoke perceptions
of social identities in ChatGPT at the intersections of gender, age, region,
and formality, with caveats. This work highlights the importance of pronoun use
for social identity simulation, provides a language-based methodology for
culturally-sensitive persona development, and advances the potential of
intersectional identities in intelligent agents.
|
[
-0.5244081020355225,
-0.9310990571975708,
0.5619367361068726,
0.16685767471790314,
-0.012620300985872746,
0.6063504815101624,
-0.02256621979176998,
-0.5424554347991943,
0.3897642493247986,
0.27345314621925354,
-0.4405665993690491,
-0.1756669282913208,
-0.38252800703048706,
-0.07770562916994095,
-0.02844473533332348,
0.813277542591095,
0.2737487256526947,
-0.16953632235527039,
-0.06440692394971848,
0.15156544744968414,
-0.39756813645362854,
-0.5279512405395508,
-0.7143256068229675,
-0.1958037167787552,
0.6332379579544067,
0.4127504825592041,
1.1240735054016113,
0.2455229014158249,
0.1614903211593628,
0.341306209564209,
0.2385839819908142,
0.11967097967863083,
-0.5192998647689819,
0.0026328142266720533,
-0.2495737224817276,
-0.29775556921958923,
-0.0710783377289772,
0.20281203091144562,
0.6731224656105042,
0.9342392086982727,
0.14461448788642883,
0.1187780573964119,
-0.16171146929264069,
0.23739944398403168,
-0.6837330460548401,
0.24967701733112335,
-0.5789552927017212,
0.11381001025438309,
-0.36156776547431946,
0.0327371321618557,
-0.11627662181854248,
-0.4156032204627991,
0.056096043437719345,
-0.5437473058700562,
0.2513362169265747,
0.18633468449115753,
0.8606675863265991,
0.06718265265226364,
-0.5883532166481018,
0.14536701142787933,
-1.0637646913528442,
0.25453218817710876,
-0.25177431106567383,
0.3260308802127838,
0.3024255037307739,
0.547348141670227,
-0.28946539759635925,
-0.4383818805217743,
-0.8031854629516602,
-0.22632312774658203,
-0.2201876938343048,
0.3854224681854248,
-0.1292835772037506,
-0.0062311203218996525,
0.11552503705024719,
0.07876825332641602,
-0.5626298189163208,
-0.003456108272075653,
-0.4322713017463684,
0.21484892070293427,
0.8023433685302734,
0.09349297732114792,
0.4767416715621948,
-0.20095039904117584,
-0.5372992157936096,
0.0838981345295906,
-0.5822447538375854,
0.19177460670471191,
0.8451510071754456,
0.3394787907600403,
0.022395232692360878,
0.5898054242134094,
0.04275966063141823,
0.13129986822605133,
0.08866095542907715,
0.00827696081250906,
0.12873177230358124,
-0.07658825069665909,
0.15688951313495636,
0.3054433763027191,
1.0397298336029053,
0.3864394426345825,
0.793079674243927,
-0.5541206002235413,
0.36219462752342224,
-0.011616867035627365,
0.17238932847976685,
-0.6014683246612549,
-0.25956636667251587,
0.17436222732067108,
-0.052713412791490555,
-0.1261349767446518,
0.2674531042575836,
-0.5990555286407471,
-0.5522165298461914,
-0.07269078493118286,
0.32327741384506226,
-0.4771661162376404,
-0.718686580657959,
0.21664363145828247,
-0.290202260017395,
0.44538113474845886,
0.22411374747753143,
-1.101808786392212,
0.4484473764896393,
0.9325394034385681,
0.5874015092849731,
-0.08305176347494125,
-0.6805879473686218,
-0.28419244289398193,
0.06904556602239609,
-0.20622500777244568,
0.5882946252822876,
-0.7409124970436096,
-0.6984763145446777,
-0.36427807807922363,
-0.002267202828079462,
-0.27306729555130005,
-0.3990962505340576,
-0.10203980654478073,
-0.30151405930519104,
-0.06443456560373306,
-0.28879913687705994,
-0.27623826265335083,
0.18773791193962097,
0.12631775438785553,
-0.22094976902008057,
0.8366710543632507,
0.11340007930994034,
-0.7335475087165833,
0.2073245346546173,
-0.5266798734664917,
-0.31214219331741333,
0.6787967085838318,
-0.4765949845314026,
-0.12694014608860016,
-0.09984239190816879,
-0.18007145822048187,
0.28941091895103455,
-0.055297642946243286,
0.21036259829998016,
-0.1965293139219284,
-0.3956197202205658,
0.6703082323074341,
-0.26758551597595215,
0.658766508102417,
-0.17193540930747986,
-0.33429086208343506,
-0.28022241592407227,
-0.5327660441398621,
-0.06029551476240158,
0.4395100772380829,
0.2810025215148926,
-0.4597538113594055,
-0.14768293499946594,
0.012294051237404346,
-0.024137238040566444,
0.1966014802455902,
-0.7298579812049866,
0.043416451662778854,
-0.2963899075984955,
0.3152547776699066,
0.6040557622909546,
0.23324832320213318,
0.2586653232574463,
-0.4135623872280121,
0.7961050271987915,
-0.0585467629134655,
0.2414560317993164,
0.02829638309776783,
-0.8114291429519653,
-0.6177107095718384,
-0.13000831007957458,
0.4234071969985962,
0.7509405612945557,
-0.7049403190612793,
0.23675501346588135,
-0.19675320386886597,
-0.6861770153045654,
-0.69967120885849,
-0.33999884128570557,
0.37726813554763794,
0.043023549020290375,
-0.10901658236980438,
-0.21405836939811707,
-0.4670886993408203,
-1.2472375631332397,
-0.5570014119148254,
-0.8329118490219116,
0.04886611923575401,
0.4782871603965759,
0.6095389723777771,
0.053822025656700134,
1.3074402809143066,
-0.3686564564704895,
0.14217326045036316,
-0.07241739332675934,
0.26533886790275574,
-0.20440107583999634,
0.3694561719894409,
0.4740009903907776,
-1.1336019039154053,
-0.6723844408988953,
0.22710643708705902,
-0.42981770634651184,
-0.14039257168769836,
-0.222657710313797,
-0.1812630593776703,
-0.5428017973899841,
0.3611031174659729,
-0.4834410846233368,
0.325935959815979,
0.47618797421455383,
-0.5412711501121521,
0.8322792649269104,
-0.06438025832176208,
0.31194111704826355,
-0.994566023349762,
0.15571635961532593,
0.04938458651304245,
-0.3988091051578522,
-0.849582314491272,
0.03734883666038513,
-0.3101516366004944,
-0.2712203860282898,
-0.6539778709411621,
0.8453075885772705,
-0.33219608664512634,
-0.2791794240474701,
-0.0424753837287426,
0.24302493035793304,
-0.24555394053459167,
0.3823786973953247,
0.05405411496758461,
1.1322709321975708,
0.3528151214122772,
-0.3129035234451294,
0.05132247880101204,
0.26827260851860046,
-0.052642740309238434,
0.9598902463912964,
-0.8061872720718384,
0.18132337927818298,
-0.4085424542427063,
-0.22450698912143707,
-1.142210602760315,
-0.33621087670326233,
0.6385260224342346,
-0.6214785575866699,
-0.1533297747373581,
-0.38078850507736206,
-0.7349247336387634,
0.05467281863093376,
0.17512927949428558,
0.4337700605392456,
0.5274799466133118,
-0.20744763314723969,
0.5640890598297119,
0.8729075789451599,
-0.516039252281189,
-0.24592037498950958,
-0.42526859045028687,
0.3339902460575104,
-0.4314708709716797,
-0.6128501296043396,
0.28507599234580994,
0.029756486415863037,
-0.5468074083328247,
-0.29766401648521423,
0.5139761567115784,
-0.07519365847110748,
0.28441140055656433,
0.45069560408592224,
-0.02145102247595787,
0.10183372348546982,
-0.01334746740758419,
-0.15609467029571533,
-0.3139771521091461,
0.08874133974313736,
0.27076050639152527,
0.655596137046814,
-0.5200538039207458,
-0.5926192998886108,
-0.14719004929065704,
0.7563392519950867,
0.5354323983192444,
-0.23360133171081543,
0.5572628974914551,
0.5626664757728577,
-0.26507478952407837,
0.44895005226135254,
-0.474032998085022,
0.037096694111824036,
-0.47232574224472046,
0.25400644540786743,
-0.5597601532936096,
-0.77236008644104,
0.8978186845779419,
-0.12369126081466675,
-0.06959869712591171,
0.002667749533429742,
0.16031034290790558,
0.015567461028695107,
1.148439884185791,
0.3723764419555664,
0.22951219975948334,
0.3587719798088074,
0.2916255593299866,
0.4568968117237091,
-0.8715669512748718,
-0.18252772092819214,
-0.3533596098423004,
-0.41398757696151733,
-0.973209023475647,
-0.4096246361732483,
0.6200351715087891,
-0.11213735491037369,
-0.4011814296245575,
0.07565391063690186,
-0.17549185454845428,
0.9291520118713379,
0.5749260187149048,
0.11436744034290314,
0.26949232816696167,
-0.441739946603775,
0.1589033156633377,
-0.33884522318840027,
-0.5036424994468689,
-0.6193962097167969,
0.4574131965637207,
0.3362853527069092,
0.5409024953842163,
0.28927603363990784,
0.7256731986999512,
0.11620854586362839,
-0.15794742107391357,
-0.5771269798278809,
0.8919467926025391,
-0.022071082144975662,
-0.5081798434257507,
-0.1423816978931427,
-0.3583817481994629,
-1.3467413187026978,
0.41800379753112793,
-0.06593411415815353,
-1.2042028903961182,
0.35088253021240234,
-0.148908793926239,
-0.4530738890171051,
0.09993951767683029,
-0.7915199398994446,
1.0527173280715942,
-0.5132012963294983,
-0.2731505036354065,
0.3794075846672058,
-0.9254407286643982,
0.2623019814491272,
0.16360382735729218,
0.13389016687870026,
-0.2768089175224304,
-0.10721081495285034,
0.4200492203235626,
-0.22472819685935974,
1.2852917909622192,
-0.08325720578432083,
0.1196700781583786,
-0.00706510990858078,
0.32321521639823914,
0.3212865889072418,
0.14973211288452148,
0.2653292119503021,
0.23592498898506165,
0.046676795929670334,
-0.35432374477386475,
-0.4818676710128784,
0.48508045077323914,
-1.0139844417572021,
-0.7189000844955444,
-0.3827458918094635,
-0.5197812914848328,
-0.25106340646743774,
0.2895320653915405,
-0.07752220332622528,
-0.04886142164468765,
-0.6992510557174683,
-0.07874869555234909,
0.43842437863349915,
-0.063063845038414,
0.015809327363967896,
0.4828217327594757,
-0.4094899296760559,
-0.26994433999061584,
0.928612470626831,
0.20050889253616333,
0.46272847056388855,
-0.02944040857255459,
0.38435402512550354,
-0.09547393023967743,
0.012582342140376568,
-0.40714526176452637,
0.3605027198791504,
-0.5049885511398315,
0.47956788539886475,
-0.7997233271598816,
-0.4245949387550354,
-0.3408207893371582,
-0.2271265983581543,
-0.5379105806350708,
-0.23690906167030334,
0.2361813336610794,
0.13954667747020721,
0.1611633449792862,
0.47725701332092285,
-0.04992147162556648,
0.5999612808227539,
-0.4286377429962158,
0.37176933884620667,
0.6967054605484009,
0.009778164327144623,
-0.365924209356308,
0.11221450567245483,
0.21024949848651886,
0.25790050625801086,
0.016968339681625366,
-1.1509959697723389,
0.07405854016542435,
0.06981606036424637,
0.6114668846130371,
0.3537236452102661,
0.13628831505775452,
0.7791942954063416,
-0.3925897479057312,
0.870518147945404,
-0.09739746898412704,
-0.7710132598876953,
0.4064791798591614,
-0.6691831946372986,
0.3512172996997833,
0.6327932476997375,
0.3495185077190399,
-1.0524051189422607,
-0.7645946741104126,
-1.052482008934021,
-0.8629862070083618,
0.3505294919013977,
0.6016772985458374,
0.27646955847740173,
-0.25268056988716125,
0.28695157170295715,
0.39695975184440613,
0.30882808566093445,
-0.7416912913322449,
-0.40617635846138,
0.0980047956109047,
-0.016047563403844833,
0.033460985869169235,
-0.04012760519981384,
-0.10563037544488907,
0.026896774768829346,
0.5528402924537659,
-0.17375583946704865,
0.24961122870445251,
-0.03292161598801613,
0.16741178929805756,
0.18050605058670044,
0.11409574002027512,
0.28756970167160034,
0.5646346211433411,
0.04784722253680229,
0.3074909746646881,
0.06835229694843292,
-0.46530938148498535,
0.14736410975456238,
0.10959281027317047,
-0.4560054540634155,
0.14189882576465607,
-0.16148655116558075,
0.7919796705245972,
0.4563477635383606,
-0.567888617515564,
0.5182552933692932,
-0.26118242740631104,
0.08676532655954361,
-0.7118989825248718,
0.15610958635807037,
0.21648094058036804,
0.6004080772399902,
0.23361395299434662,
-0.0814589187502861,
0.07958377152681351,
-0.7692431807518005,
-0.15854941308498383,
0.6218811273574829,
-0.2639104127883911,
-0.3640431761741638,
0.7048425674438477,
0.14468827843666077,
-0.7303004264831543,
0.22656910121440887,
-0.5821753144264221,
-0.7544892430305481,
0.6116501092910767,
0.4915288984775543,
0.8903673887252808,
-0.2150477021932602,
0.536099374294281,
0.21095344424247742,
0.2538788914680481,
0.25887253880500793,
0.07871256023645401,
-0.15603969991207123,
-1.107072114944458,
0.10510728508234024,
-0.1589716076850891,
-0.769352912902832,
-0.20268277823925018,
-0.3991137742996216,
0.36902129650115967,
-0.1049942895770073,
-0.3572207987308502,
-0.019188817590475082,
-0.13220594823360443,
-0.5723926424980164,
-0.2643561065196991,
0.31187039613723755,
0.18274733424186707,
-1.1555025577545166,
0.2977064251899719,
0.730564296245575,
-0.3035218417644501,
-0.39323320984840393,
0.14533811807632446,
-0.04747176170349121,
-0.7439559102058411,
0.5011900663375854,
0.17155618965625763,
-0.2680738568305969,
0.40954673290252686,
-0.3210395872592926,
-0.6149541735649109,
0.9037122130393982,
0.34005382657051086,
-0.23677217960357666,
-0.01391793042421341,
0.9218239784240723,
0.48087021708488464,
-0.33946356177330017,
0.4345830976963043,
0.7620133757591248,
0.6018341183662415,
0.08444685488939285,
-1.2498571872711182,
-0.17907148599624634,
-0.4009310007095337,
0.2581770718097687,
0.10351277887821198,
-1.050692081451416,
0.9591162204742432,
-0.13999895751476288,
-0.5734208822250366,
0.13302676379680634,
0.35510775446891785,
0.6387056708335876,
0.16155275702476501,
0.6195812225341797,
0.13229835033416748,
0.8180264234542847,
-0.1589682698249817,
0.7723560333251953,
-0.053320784121751785,
0.16046559810638428,
1.1204315423965454,
-0.4815559685230255,
0.4243037700653076,
0.5720194578170776,
-0.31514471769332886,
0.26772716641426086,
0.6345290541648865,
0.17250417172908783,
0.3141430616378784,
0.10960611701011658,
-0.4128519594669342,
-0.42070135474205017,
-0.39713025093078613,
-0.32903778553009033,
0.8475873470306396,
0.15622873604297638,
0.13860878348350525,
-0.1431070864200592,
0.20768648386001587,
0.3675803244113922,
0.026730157434940338,
0.03993959352374077,
0.9750586152076721,
-0.1637342870235443,
-0.5425747036933899,
-0.045117564499378204,
-0.24337561428546906,
0.28748100996017456,
-0.5129322409629822,
0.044733744114637375,
-0.04732656106352806,
-0.05617743730545044,
0.22915685176849365,
-1.0721522569656372,
-0.08995918184518814,
-0.20722751319408417,
0.1211680918931961,
-0.21375463902950287,
0.8643876314163208,
-0.6564569473266602,
-0.46701470017433167,
-0.04364168271422386,
0.6313324570655823,
0.5948255658149719,
-0.17818096280097961,
-0.6236487030982971,
-0.2466975301504135,
-0.32080450654029846,
-0.03625667467713356,
0.3277152478694916,
0.7205745577812195,
-0.09146126359701157,
0.5986421704292297,
0.48879486322402954,
0.18067023158073425,
0.1396506279706955,
0.016017412766814232,
0.5126343369483948,
-0.45002859830856323,
-0.797512948513031,
-0.8718779683113098,
0.7252556681632996,
-0.2692323327064514,
-0.4870202839374542,
0.7396759986877441,
0.5988050699234009,
0.7738319039344788,
0.032015182077884674,
0.9188427329063416,
-0.15721942484378815,
0.2994171679019928,
-0.3183988928794861,
0.7490594387054443,
-0.23480646312236786,
-0.08755048364400864,
-0.24185077846050262,
-0.6247832179069519,
-0.000722442870028317,
0.6247891187667847,
-0.41936323046684265,
0.1614704728126526,
0.3172875940799713,
0.8732930421829224,
-0.1547897607088089,
0.13805776834487915,
0.49578458070755005,
-0.022072462365031242,
0.3156077265739441,
0.5044927597045898,
1.2069438695907593,
-0.5848636627197266,
0.01134711503982544,
-0.32947832345962524,
0.10286110639572144,
-0.2289879024028778,
-0.674684464931488,
-0.8722478747367859,
-0.7614130973815918,
-0.5841560363769531,
-0.10030412673950195,
0.15939725935459137,
0.9016777276992798,
0.6683188676834106,
-0.1689871996641159,
-0.22726354002952576,
0.12471403181552887,
0.014645555056631565,
-0.08390596508979797,
-0.303604394197464,
-0.1504884660243988,
-0.043476685881614685,
-1.0599312782287598,
0.18016286194324493,
0.20032641291618347,
0.28762972354888916,
-0.5929535031318665,
-0.16979587078094482,
-0.15548929572105408,
0.03364916518330574,
0.4060080945491791,
0.5093786120414734,
-0.5544382333755493,
-0.7143076658248901,
-0.1265479475259781,
0.049898628145456314,
0.06745176017284393,
0.7473360300064087,
-0.7295646667480469,
0.49988213181495667,
0.29363009333610535,
0.36310189962387085,
0.2884148061275482,
0.37381795048713684,
0.7836154699325562,
-0.943306028842926,
0.3570300340652466,
0.32287031412124634,
0.24755260348320007,
0.3305336534976959,
-0.5365841388702393,
0.4250580072402954,
0.3290792405605316,
-0.5654741525650024,
-0.6896262168884277,
0.3718203008174896,
-0.8892788290977478,
-0.07305005192756653,
1.2849020957946777,
0.0073455143719911575,
-0.1626909226179123,
-0.38349398970603943,
-0.49607065320014954,
0.11988911777734756,
-0.21996068954467773,
0.7733351588249207,
0.7251711487770081,
-0.06264757364988327,
-0.5261462330818176,
-0.8560588359832764,
0.12088720500469208,
0.162001833319664,
-0.9206193089485168,
0.10356076061725616,
0.1665520966053009,
0.14579173922538757,
0.262419730424881,
0.832412838935852,
0.0994693785905838,
0.38000407814979553,
0.09831968694925308,
0.09684087336063385,
-0.03795982524752617,
-0.26197025179862976,
0.32143813371658325,
0.030158236622810364,
0.06290476769208908,
-0.2671041190624237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08237v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08237v1
|
A predictive learning model can simulate temporal dynamics and context effects found in neural representations of continuous speech
| 2024-05-13T23:36:19 | 2024-05-13T23:36:19 |
Oli Danyi Liu, Hao Tang, Naomi Feldman, Sharon Goldwater
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speech perception involves storing and integrating sequentially presented
items. Recent work in cognitive neuroscience has identified temporal and
contextual characteristics in humans' neural encoding of speech that may
facilitate this temporal processing. In this study, we simulated similar
analyses with representations extracted from a computational model that was
trained on unlabelled speech with the learning objective of predicting upcoming
acoustics. Our simulations revealed temporal dynamics similar to those in brain
signals, implying that these properties can arise without linguistic knowledge.
Another property shared between brains and the model is that the encoding
patterns of phonemes support some degree of cross-context generalization.
However, we found evidence that the effectiveness of these generalizations
depends on the specific contexts, which suggests that this analysis alone is
insufficient to support the presence of context-invariant encoding.
|
[
0.006599946413189173,
-0.6514256000518799,
0.5272831916809082,
0.31170016527175903,
-0.16050434112548828,
-0.035891953855752945,
-0.41004136204719543,
-0.5213456749916077,
0.14506730437278748,
0.08814560621976852,
-0.630524218082428,
-0.23148174583911896,
-0.36390286684036255,
-0.2834767997264862,
-0.7172003984451294,
0.5644696950912476,
0.41576698422431946,
0.3917299509048462,
-0.14879898726940155,
0.06566719710826874,
-0.6600046157836914,
-0.8397590517997742,
-0.6061667799949646,
-0.7838815450668335,
0.4287416636943817,
-0.204819917678833,
0.43371105194091797,
0.5226994156837463,
-0.23926006257534027,
0.2471381574869156,
-0.29051098227500916,
-0.5451683402061462,
-0.10704723000526428,
0.034931864589452744,
-0.2133963257074356,
-0.5779905319213867,
-0.174187570810318,
0.33762967586517334,
0.9036265015602112,
1.1174523830413818,
-0.5469421148300171,
-0.19253915548324585,
0.3873407542705536,
0.1835009902715683,
-0.17351633310317993,
0.3408299386501312,
-0.6718381643295288,
0.2182113230228424,
0.08657798171043396,
-0.5860108733177185,
-0.43705034255981445,
0.07460799813270569,
0.6740297675132751,
-0.4831598103046417,
0.21391282975673676,
-0.14736999571323395,
0.6473790407180786,
0.19021669030189514,
-0.4293728172779083,
-0.4348483979701996,
-0.8085218071937561,
0.7622383236885071,
-0.4848729372024536,
0.7569417357444763,
0.4399765729904175,
0.40721914172172546,
-0.21920828521251678,
-0.8162295818328857,
-0.38993167877197266,
-0.22546115517616272,
-0.18922306597232819,
0.21417240798473358,
-0.04862794652581215,
0.0861814096570015,
0.24191279709339142,
-0.33633315563201904,
-0.4348081648349762,
0.07159078866243362,
-0.5547910332679749,
-0.16113565862178802,
0.41513946652412415,
0.169178307056427,
0.3331393003463745,
-0.11437022686004639,
-0.3127146065235138,
-0.09363749623298645,
-0.13406139612197876,
0.5089424252510071,
0.04600450024008751,
0.47560957074165344,
-0.5860087275505066,
0.17881684005260468,
0.09537989646196365,
0.5729494690895081,
-0.019660383462905884,
-0.1720678210258484,
0.349753737449646,
-0.0017376040341332555,
-0.22072826325893402,
0.38988974690437317,
0.4338023066520691,
0.1468907594680786,
0.46673715114593506,
-0.5399879813194275,
0.005975379142910242,
0.296332448720932,
0.21503935754299164,
-0.4675547778606415,
0.011582236737012863,
0.12994621694087982,
-0.4820979833602905,
-0.2534109055995941,
-0.2926671504974365,
-0.75832599401474,
0.08319611102342606,
-0.7384424805641174,
0.10913347452878952,
-0.6006492972373962,
-0.041912876069545746,
0.06513743102550507,
-0.28787896037101746,
0.07775569707155228,
0.07314053922891617,
-1.0039082765579224,
0.3734864294528961,
0.3898966908454895,
0.6940003037452698,
-0.18582510948181152,
-0.5332854390144348,
-0.2835935354232788,
0.2157822996377945,
-0.42755916714668274,
0.5180354118347168,
-0.8890329003334045,
-0.5992113947868347,
-0.0626140758395195,
0.01293153129518032,
-0.2353651374578476,
-0.34029313921928406,
0.20679599046707153,
-0.7438144683837891,
-0.0791073739528656,
-0.3093274235725403,
-0.6197623610496521,
-0.15852904319763184,
-0.3921392560005188,
-0.6378092169761658,
0.17159457504749298,
0.060804806649684906,
-0.4251086115837097,
0.6634988784790039,
-0.5851088762283325,
-0.30986902117729187,
-0.05055910348892212,
-0.4938664734363556,
-0.14012297987937927,
0.339252233505249,
-0.07230310887098312,
0.3296753466129303,
0.20702983438968658,
0.5957213044166565,
-0.12177582085132599,
-0.579653799533844,
0.7338241934776306,
-0.4364742338657379,
0.7638092637062073,
0.19422964751720428,
-0.33977052569389343,
-0.10260209441184998,
-0.7062957882881165,
0.03969033062458038,
-0.07848861813545227,
-0.49446961283683777,
-0.2987625300884247,
0.39652159810066223,
-0.10398947447538376,
0.15735012292861938,
-0.05370360240340233,
-0.5481827259063721,
-0.006790956482291222,
-0.41471540927886963,
0.520549476146698,
0.7108328342437744,
0.17308010160923004,
0.6672375202178955,
-0.42565080523490906,
0.3637338876724243,
0.4499887526035309,
-0.24334406852722168,
-0.1432396024465561,
-0.5146095752716064,
-0.27296683192253113,
0.18607817590236664,
0.46290332078933716,
0.4633331000804901,
-0.3396663963794708,
-0.21291734278202057,
-0.3314831852912903,
0.04889047145843506,
0.08167240023612976,
-0.17089731991291046,
0.3498876690864563,
0.38739240169525146,
0.27323248982429504,
-0.10881779342889786,
-0.9385730624198914,
-0.6801685690879822,
-0.22594818472862244,
0.016110330820083618,
-0.28708961606025696,
0.31087398529052734,
0.3178439438343048,
-0.28412219882011414,
1.1623425483703613,
-0.062441468238830566,
-0.09424105286598206,
0.15710468590259552,
0.546472430229187,
0.06245822831988335,
0.5227658748626709,
0.641893208026886,
-0.6802451014518738,
0.0418078787624836,
-0.08550377935171127,
-0.9195316433906555,
0.09633812308311462,
-0.24686022102832794,
0.4112462103366852,
0.16610418260097504,
0.6252346634864807,
-0.0918743833899498,
0.6158804297447205,
0.7558834552764893,
-0.2370818704366684,
0.36071541905403137,
-0.18818016350269318,
-0.026488937437534332,
-0.6911807656288147,
-0.11089450865983963,
-0.06437868624925613,
0.1251683086156845,
-0.6374890208244324,
-0.5696204304695129,
-0.0024217069149017334,
-0.44268596172332764,
-0.4227743148803711,
0.5894066691398621,
-0.48749008774757385,
-0.3213008940219879,
-0.3197409510612488,
-0.010480057448148727,
-0.2910439968109131,
0.8065332770347595,
0.4422445595264435,
0.9311081171035767,
0.6090019345283508,
-0.8524970412254333,
-0.12658941745758057,
-0.15903832018375397,
-0.4591180682182312,
0.1828165501356125,
-0.8176489472389221,
0.14819756150245667,
-0.38479506969451904,
0.08161663264036179,
-0.5580200552940369,
-0.21272186934947968,
-0.3097515404224396,
-0.8030959963798523,
0.37484750151634216,
-0.053574979305267334,
-0.05024707317352295,
-0.018715674057602882,
0.418546587228775,
0.4767906069755554,
0.7665262222290039,
-0.42999184131622314,
0.7807285785675049,
0.39122265577316284,
0.12569588422775269,
-0.5860813856124878,
-0.8249374032020569,
-0.26999184489250183,
-0.2035241574048996,
-0.23874519765377045,
0.6427554488182068,
-0.018254073336720467,
-0.3974137604236603,
-0.005932931322604418,
0.02412625402212143,
-0.07908881455659866,
0.033593613654375076,
0.6442072987556458,
0.10207827389240265,
-0.12469048798084259,
0.3053828775882721,
0.09900081157684326,
0.16674603521823883,
0.3565411865711212,
-0.6117761135101318,
0.47920751571655273,
-0.0027192344423383474,
-0.1042017713189125,
-0.3545103967189789,
0.3310782015323639,
0.5259743928909302,
0.16770151257514954,
0.570487916469574,
0.31803378462791443,
-0.5517448782920837,
-0.33861738443374634,
-0.18734551966190338,
-0.37592440843582153,
-0.4856400489807129,
0.37177011370658875,
-0.32400792837142944,
-0.8348953127861023,
0.6767913699150085,
-0.03541514649987221,
-0.2369765341281891,
-0.03485875204205513,
0.27275437116622925,
-0.4240751564502716,
1.0797207355499268,
0.6091081500053406,
0.012956998310983181,
0.6886250972747803,
-0.17688484489917755,
-0.2959122061729431,
-0.8484407663345337,
-0.558911144733429,
-0.30549106001853943,
-0.45072558522224426,
-0.5062689185142517,
-0.24039658904075623,
0.2892279624938965,
0.10024077445268631,
-0.08056005835533142,
0.16217590868473053,
-0.2356358915567398,
0.35948339104652405,
0.4840758442878723,
0.24344943463802338,
-0.14337202906608582,
0.20891126990318298,
-0.6761593222618103,
-0.1908661425113678,
-0.7018252015113831,
-0.24000801146030426,
1.0492632389068604,
0.10239958763122559,
0.38670921325683594,
-0.3914129436016083,
0.3391040563583374,
0.4020113945007324,
-0.0551961213350296,
-0.509933590888977,
0.4396670162677765,
-0.07537665218114853,
-0.5592426061630249,
-0.3222431242465973,
-0.20579427480697632,
-1.2435442209243774,
0.011021665297448635,
-0.2650827169418335,
-1.2178874015808105,
0.5936564803123474,
0.19324205815792084,
-0.48496362566947937,
0.20321616530418396,
-0.47974368929862976,
0.3741236925125122,
-0.24020129442214966,
-0.25186794996261597,
-0.42769938707351685,
-0.5427539348602295,
0.06672348082065582,
-0.13903969526290894,
0.3808307349681854,
-0.03006497211754322,
-0.01517405267804861,
0.9168686270713806,
0.09599954634904861,
1.15617036819458,
-0.3262815773487091,
0.27824312448501587,
0.3864859640598297,
0.05478928983211517,
0.046122871339321136,
0.108485646545887,
-0.09121369570493698,
0.32854101061820984,
0.059341106563806534,
-0.3597181737422943,
-0.7427959442138672,
0.6349542737007141,
-0.9170618057250977,
-0.5162830352783203,
-0.390672504901886,
-0.6400209069252014,
-0.2986278235912323,
0.028832225129008293,
0.41103827953338623,
0.6699979305267334,
-0.43383264541625977,
0.05561111122369766,
0.5081824064254761,
-0.08127830177545547,
0.8172454833984375,
0.31609800457954407,
-0.4174511730670929,
-0.17934580147266388,
0.50216144323349,
0.40902549028396606,
-0.010683923959732056,
0.27342188358306885,
0.30414512753486633,
-0.15476416051387787,
-0.671796977519989,
0.04928743839263916,
0.11320880055427551,
-0.6226541996002197,
0.2589949071407318,
-0.4617753028869629,
-0.23413453996181488,
-0.3640044927597046,
-0.18343740701675415,
-0.0628146082162857,
-0.3915669620037079,
-0.5652112364768982,
-0.11705084145069122,
0.053198277950286865,
0.7921313643455505,
-0.3788374066352844,
0.5892540216445923,
-0.6129672527313232,
0.047871969640254974,
0.6899341940879822,
0.23997801542282104,
0.21732474863529205,
-0.6218720078468323,
-0.2769300043582916,
0.42828208208084106,
-0.08427593857049942,
-0.8764610290527344,
0.7758212685585022,
0.34450578689575195,
0.7487022876739502,
0.3578726053237915,
-0.2569790780544281,
0.6120889186859131,
-0.7139413356781006,
0.8017982244491577,
0.06450175493955612,
-1.0752161741256714,
0.7038426995277405,
-0.5014227628707886,
0.44361209869384766,
0.15293167531490326,
0.5462380647659302,
-0.37725380063056946,
-0.021319806575775146,
-0.7121264934539795,
-0.3956446349620819,
0.5649751424789429,
0.13342851400375366,
0.13378597795963287,
-0.13968418538570404,
0.5100467205047607,
-0.03523608669638634,
0.19586023688316345,
-0.3924083709716797,
-0.06994130462408066,
-0.36563292145729065,
0.4766674339771271,
-0.2785719633102417,
-0.41646715998649597,
-0.11716251820325851,
-0.3099464476108551,
0.08725904673337936,
0.1369687169790268,
0.6890975832939148,
0.13184715807437897,
0.18519407510757446,
0.08287660777568817,
0.18430256843566895,
0.9059698581695557,
0.7124195098876953,
-0.4511704742908478,
-0.10787267237901688,
0.39975929260253906,
-0.38971003890037537,
0.07345110923051834,
-0.2186027467250824,
-0.00491341995075345,
0.27263492345809937,
0.4983729422092438,
0.8438389301300049,
0.6282681822776794,
-0.4824204742908478,
0.27661046385765076,
-0.12371731549501419,
-0.12801894545555115,
-0.9290528893470764,
0.009755746461451054,
0.22589664161205292,
0.45174625515937805,
0.4447554349899292,
0.37388837337493896,
0.11636979132890701,
-0.8341925144195557,
0.4547772705554962,
0.2463201880455017,
-0.6044596433639526,
-0.6790578961372375,
0.8726082444190979,
-0.0944068506360054,
-0.46677520871162415,
0.8539226055145264,
0.0935642272233963,
-0.400055855512619,
0.7836957573890686,
0.7112802267074585,
0.7677015662193298,
-0.42412039637565613,
-0.3476167619228363,
0.5284705758094788,
-0.2234070897102356,
0.14643584191799164,
0.29330894351005554,
-0.29430052638053894,
-0.8812257647514343,
-0.33993977308273315,
-0.7555120587348938,
-0.2043904811143875,
-0.022341646254062653,
-0.8138847947120667,
0.19018717110157013,
-0.5247899889945984,
-0.5476718544960022,
0.16538050770759583,
-0.43384867906570435,
-0.6448867321014404,
0.4062826335430145,
0.4044013023376465,
0.7177765369415283,
-0.6804564595222473,
1.3536133766174316,
0.4499991536140442,
-0.1354009211063385,
-0.9329505562782288,
-0.020482394844293594,
0.08485878258943558,
-0.7078037858009338,
1.127618670463562,
0.014801311306655407,
-0.24079352617263794,
-0.21151623129844666,
-0.581506073474884,
-0.9193393588066101,
1.0965334177017212,
0.3894389867782593,
-0.699737012386322,
-0.6530043482780457,
0.03249053284525871,
0.5890509486198425,
-0.7383925914764404,
0.15198059380054474,
0.5402402281761169,
0.16744667291641235,
0.17268168926239014,
-0.9906063079833984,
-0.32011878490448,
-0.2746413052082062,
0.2760521173477173,
-0.39558476209640503,
-0.09419041126966476,
1.099427342414856,
-0.2688198387622833,
-0.5475949645042419,
-0.07708927243947983,
0.7647632360458374,
0.27366483211517334,
0.2540528476238251,
0.31361204385757446,
0.15313301980495453,
0.6702048182487488,
-0.07467848807573318,
1.0929855108261108,
-0.3931339383125305,
0.0676104724407196,
1.2861942052841187,
-0.04388003051280975,
0.7942366003990173,
0.3238602876663208,
-0.08118456602096558,
0.8482274413108826,
0.4717805087566376,
0.2938651740550995,
0.8690252304077148,
0.17149868607521057,
-0.2457500547170639,
-0.15054480731487274,
-0.10184407234191895,
-0.48927754163742065,
0.7757919430732727,
0.7353487610816956,
-0.5577008724212646,
0.13573358952999115,
0.27823981642723083,
-0.23220133781433105,
0.10303939133882523,
-0.3157176673412323,
0.582685112953186,
0.2748815417289734,
-0.6206093430519104,
0.8265758752822876,
-0.39687207341194153,
0.7458088397979736,
-0.5917205214500427,
-0.13312067091464996,
0.1878383606672287,
-0.03020574524998665,
-0.07774641364812851,
-0.4590601921081543,
0.5369130969047546,
-0.5606816411018372,
-0.35660287737846375,
-0.24614492058753967,
0.3837684690952301,
-0.4387054145336151,
-0.12421970069408417,
0.770667314529419,
0.16852432489395142,
0.16653382778167725,
0.17820166051387787,
-0.41842183470726013,
0.09521300345659256,
-0.10549810528755188,
-0.06087885797023773,
0.48544350266456604,
0.27993738651275635,
-0.054037176072597504,
0.6426393985748291,
0.5658888220787048,
0.25763094425201416,
0.24201974272727966,
0.11256115883588791,
0.596127450466156,
-0.7745151519775391,
-0.6971930861473083,
-0.7042683959007263,
0.3278771638870239,
0.04294975847005844,
-0.0654473751783371,
0.3188832998275757,
0.25442302227020264,
0.9862412810325623,
-0.20547489821910858,
0.6147635579109192,
0.43136918544769287,
0.5471234917640686,
-0.6977841258049011,
0.8654115796089172,
-0.38506776094436646,
0.21521252393722534,
-0.05994219705462456,
-0.5190432071685791,
0.013179865665733814,
0.5022419691085815,
-0.37715405225753784,
0.10148477554321289,
0.8613823056221008,
0.4870636761188507,
0.09208295494318008,
0.49727165699005127,
0.7512962818145752,
0.09800710529088974,
-0.19578123092651367,
0.5637778043746948,
0.8343538045883179,
-0.10371434688568115,
0.21929992735385895,
-0.5265964269638062,
-0.09757740050554276,
0.16018685698509216,
-0.8176305890083313,
-1.1311167478561401,
-1.0564700365066528,
-0.035723112523555756,
-0.19629095494747162,
0.3837500810623169,
0.9064817428588867,
0.9678369760513306,
-0.8660356998443604,
-0.6521459221839905,
-0.05372994765639305,
-0.29577207565307617,
-0.43026360869407654,
-0.13725094497203827,
0.10920589417219162,
-0.3125861883163452,
-0.7388660907745361,
0.798682451248169,
-0.11709597706794739,
0.39150169491767883,
0.04065766558051109,
-0.029827779158949852,
0.012424678541719913,
0.1657303422689438,
0.5714314579963684,
0.46922290325164795,
-0.7282516360282898,
-0.3154958486557007,
0.007337712217122316,
0.17816044390201569,
0.19511543214321136,
0.9986841678619385,
-1.2685226202011108,
0.3842649459838867,
0.40112200379371643,
0.21718749403953552,
0.5973181128501892,
-0.17508938908576965,
0.8930243849754333,
-0.7149925231933594,
0.5270636081695557,
0.35436713695526123,
0.6820733547210693,
-0.1172344908118248,
-0.37756872177124023,
0.2424776554107666,
0.21225880086421967,
-0.45253631472587585,
-0.5417569875717163,
0.13445019721984863,
-1.039777159690857,
-0.41449931263923645,
0.8895857334136963,
-0.1930726170539856,
-0.38636428117752075,
-0.12071070820093155,
0.2956370711326599,
0.4830634891986847,
-0.5577489733695984,
0.6969101428985596,
0.6050191521644592,
-0.26504555344581604,
-0.09055158495903015,
-0.6362408995628357,
0.518871545791626,
0.3191809356212616,
-0.17951279878616333,
-0.10303506255149841,
0.29833537340164185,
0.28296732902526855,
0.2920058071613312,
0.3461478650569916,
-0.12075015902519226,
0.45821988582611084,
0.25512853264808655,
-0.20221751928329468,
0.002040715655311942,
-0.516103982925415,
-0.5654573440551758,
0.40770837664604187,
-0.3066677749156952,
-0.1324005275964737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13012v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13012v1
|
Divergent Creativity in Humans and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T22:37:52 | 2024-05-13T22:37:52 |
Antoine Bellemare-Pepin, François Lespinasse, Philipp Thölke, Yann Harel, Kory Mathewson, Jay A. Olson, Yoshua Bengio, Karim Jerbi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The recent surge in the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led
to claims that they are approaching a level of creativity akin to human
capabilities. This idea has sparked a blend of excitement and apprehension.
However, a critical piece that has been missing in this discourse is a
systematic evaluation of LLM creativity, particularly in comparison to human
divergent thinking. To bridge this gap, we leverage recent advances in
creativity science to build a framework for in-depth analysis of divergent
creativity in both state-of-the-art LLMs and a substantial dataset of 100,000
humans. We found evidence suggesting that LLMs can indeed surpass human
capabilities in specific creative tasks such as divergent association and
creative writing. Our quantitative benchmarking framework opens up new paths
for the development of more creative LLMs, but it also encourages more granular
inquiries into the distinctive elements that constitute human inventive thought
processes, compared to those that can be artificially generated.
|
[
-0.5180934071540833,
-0.6247720122337341,
0.6952633857727051,
0.3983878493309021,
0.033376771956682205,
0.8395271301269531,
-0.48571881651878357,
-0.5749539136886597,
0.16878823935985565,
0.21066966652870178,
-0.7651335000991821,
-0.3500998616218567,
-0.5202449560165405,
0.3005916476249695,
-0.2565457224845886,
0.5183103084564209,
0.11880170553922653,
-0.07298102974891663,
-0.5774599313735962,
0.015733489766716957,
-0.3364222049713135,
-0.26177534461021423,
-0.45192062854766846,
-0.3424263298511505,
0.8736878037452698,
0.40908950567245483,
0.4598183333873749,
0.3373802602291107,
0.4932612478733063,
0.3139360845088959,
-0.439699649810791,
0.12592795491218567,
-0.6765833497047424,
0.11816458404064178,
-0.33498334884643555,
-0.5272927284240723,
-0.37843209505081177,
0.11932342499494553,
0.7650980949401855,
0.9909867644309998,
-0.09257323294878006,
0.06416090577840805,
-0.051644157618284225,
0.9158088564872742,
-0.4145101010799408,
-0.1694021224975586,
-0.49406448006629944,
0.07732806354761124,
-0.44151246547698975,
0.14430730044841766,
-0.08675166219472885,
-0.5788761973381042,
0.27760547399520874,
-0.13100135326385498,
0.3284410834312439,
-0.16262654960155487,
0.31369906663894653,
0.14261896908283234,
-0.15156178176403046,
-0.3596624732017517,
-0.8661931753158569,
0.8159152269363403,
-0.7103327512741089,
0.30276617407798767,
0.06390228122472763,
0.09763321280479431,
-0.29057207703590393,
-0.6839509010314941,
-0.7429853081703186,
-0.26276323199272156,
0.6240026354789734,
0.07198982685804367,
-0.3014112710952759,
-0.40471771359443665,
0.4399348497390747,
0.5536265969276428,
-0.5845868587493896,
0.492491215467453,
-0.20405441522598267,
0.18687120079994202,
0.9837896823883057,
0.5077197551727295,
0.37512943148612976,
0.1929967999458313,
-0.2777152955532074,
-0.039463918656110764,
-0.6947248578071594,
0.18951301276683807,
0.5666463971138,
-0.04003027081489563,
-0.08628583699464798,
0.5502575635910034,
-0.31224313378334045,
0.18821609020233154,
-0.29589176177978516,
-0.14578849077224731,
0.30486345291137695,
-0.20288750529289246,
0.0016578303184360266,
-0.24779446423053741,
0.887661874294281,
0.20961113274097443,
0.25096410512924194,
-0.31317219138145447,
-0.33506184816360474,
-0.02460509166121483,
0.2232760339975357,
-0.6938506960868835,
0.007104981224983931,
0.09532709419727325,
-0.24611732363700867,
-0.18342815339565277,
0.17189468443393707,
-0.5861417055130005,
-0.7998332381248474,
-0.1266767978668213,
0.04630260169506073,
-0.1514376699924469,
-0.5740194916725159,
0.5036019086837769,
-0.4624369442462921,
-0.030128013342618942,
0.01704261638224125,
-0.8611173033714294,
0.14290128648281097,
0.8762063980102539,
0.7471569776535034,
-0.5367854833602905,
-0.42094266414642334,
0.22273658215999603,
-0.17695556581020355,
-0.7069815397262573,
0.8932301998138428,
-0.4582335650920868,
-0.4625687301158905,
-0.06125989928841591,
-0.2937958240509033,
0.34613603353500366,
-0.7960056066513062,
0.7716992497444153,
-0.4521940052509308,
0.22160090506076813,
-0.7019311785697937,
-0.5769720673561096,
-0.2942788600921631,
0.11072719842195511,
-0.7793336510658264,
0.7179085612297058,
0.28971993923187256,
-0.6602428555488586,
0.48792779445648193,
-0.5265322923660278,
-0.3558036983013153,
0.5049968957901001,
-0.329537957906723,
-0.3729836344718933,
0.4272572994232178,
-0.14415206015110016,
0.35318127274513245,
-0.8517798185348511,
0.31756967306137085,
-0.6015304327011108,
-0.39821478724479675,
0.8808428049087524,
-0.40651145577430725,
0.8854398131370544,
0.12293870747089386,
-0.1539587378501892,
0.08885836601257324,
-0.5987722873687744,
0.054774560034275055,
0.33775079250335693,
-0.5881741642951965,
-0.00938113871961832,
-0.13708756864070892,
-0.10849166661500931,
0.301271915435791,
0.22456875443458557,
-0.6351104378700256,
0.2438938319683075,
-0.4695109724998474,
0.6408557295799255,
0.49368399381637573,
-0.06346933543682098,
0.4964064955711365,
-0.6988288164138794,
0.7063621282577515,
-0.24717114865779877,
-0.13619887828826904,
0.054779816418886185,
-0.589110255241394,
-0.5133515000343323,
-0.4748254716396332,
-0.034254856407642365,
0.31726980209350586,
-0.3463551998138428,
0.5362288951873779,
-0.43781694769859314,
-0.8608036637306213,
-0.542218804359436,
0.4133942127227783,
0.14627455174922943,
0.2580406963825226,
-0.021059533581137657,
-0.6710454821586609,
-0.463473379611969,
-0.7380695343017578,
-0.6002552509307861,
0.05083201453089714,
-0.34532758593559265,
0.22240982949733734,
0.5030871629714966,
-0.3744547665119171,
0.892255425453186,
-0.1679636389017105,
-0.030553849413990974,
-0.6337354779243469,
0.231479674577713,
0.3293977677822113,
0.2739834487438202,
0.3060263395309448,
-0.5637427568435669,
-0.43936291337013245,
-0.09442313015460968,
-0.798024594783783,
-0.2571898102760315,
-0.20639388263225555,
-0.06620869785547256,
0.08928021043539047,
0.5414698123931885,
-0.9400988817214966,
0.24242152273654938,
0.13157224655151367,
-0.27646782994270325,
0.6995212435722351,
0.15960893034934998,
-0.24808259308338165,
-0.7604057788848877,
0.01590770296752453,
-0.1485987901687622,
0.2669614851474762,
-0.5637296438217163,
-0.20873746275901794,
-0.012277232483029366,
0.2957702875137329,
-0.39506858587265015,
0.5967382788658142,
-0.6450017094612122,
-0.16054917871952057,
-0.24469968676567078,
0.14935657382011414,
-0.04383677616715431,
0.10275804251432419,
-0.07360462844371796,
0.37989485263824463,
0.7280274033546448,
-0.3176048696041107,
0.5865240693092346,
0.061046283692121506,
-0.788472056388855,
0.23474137485027313,
-0.6165087223052979,
0.25054988265037537,
-0.292111873626709,
0.26208651065826416,
-1.0632060766220093,
-0.4468248784542084,
-0.1638338565826416,
-0.18424199521541595,
0.1937590092420578,
0.3421515226364136,
-0.6425287127494812,
-0.6787109971046448,
-0.43254202604293823,
0.35602349042892456,
0.6303595900535583,
-0.26130297780036926,
0.5033308863639832,
0.3218846619129181,
-0.668329656124115,
-0.3488028645515442,
-0.7913488149642944,
0.3584969639778137,
-0.5057710409164429,
-0.8215782642364502,
0.4508858025074005,
-0.4051191210746765,
-0.5841293931007385,
-0.19815842807292938,
0.05197877064347267,
0.28516754508018494,
0.1892528235912323,
0.14281505346298218,
0.15151800215244293,
-0.16568535566329956,
0.024598218500614166,
-0.21908290684223175,
0.20662525296211243,
0.322458952665329,
-0.07519455999135971,
0.6553201079368591,
-0.20876064896583557,
-0.4684108793735504,
-0.3375813066959381,
0.15600326657295227,
0.6511258482933044,
-0.055264122784137726,
0.4626103639602661,
0.4859706163406372,
-0.14285911619663239,
-0.4341449439525604,
-0.7667484283447266,
0.13645656406879425,
-0.48448294401168823,
0.5031940937042236,
-0.16411231458187103,
-0.9602572917938232,
0.6817344427108765,
-0.08172374963760376,
0.028138013556599617,
0.31329137086868286,
0.8240901827812195,
-0.11587519198656082,
0.6807886958122253,
0.7581021785736084,
0.08359499275684357,
0.45566070079803467,
-0.36771440505981445,
0.27305328845977783,
-0.8869238495826721,
-0.5525606870651245,
-0.1305387169122696,
-0.6060405969619751,
-0.47285714745521545,
-0.49583640694618225,
0.013479663990437984,
0.1747342199087143,
-0.31078997254371643,
-0.19660361111164093,
-0.21941575407981873,
0.8471989035606384,
0.5127393007278442,
-0.22847135365009308,
0.185530886054039,
-0.2009812444448471,
-0.13949096202850342,
-0.052418142557144165,
-0.7714152336120605,
-0.6252402067184448,
1.081774115562439,
0.4954909086227417,
0.820199728012085,
0.2822323739528656,
0.6931843757629395,
0.18552064895629883,
0.5026945471763611,
-0.8057073354721069,
0.6831347346305847,
0.10141070187091827,
-0.4608452618122101,
-0.4621213376522064,
-0.3333742022514343,
-0.7842239141464233,
0.16847780346870422,
-0.1661701798439026,
-0.6736229658126831,
0.14855577051639557,
-0.43609464168548584,
-0.32554730772972107,
0.4722710847854614,
-0.46877044439315796,
0.6305442452430725,
-0.3674794137477875,
-0.5100635290145874,
-0.17122314870357513,
-0.4769367575645447,
0.48062533140182495,
-0.36285433173179626,
0.07272893935441971,
-0.23623596131801605,
-0.2574685215950012,
0.7458489537239075,
0.18821828067302704,
0.7587984204292297,
0.3107389509677887,
-0.45850884914398193,
0.4364067614078522,
0.20797692239284515,
0.15690326690673828,
0.05308953672647476,
-0.12333038449287415,
0.11325842887163162,
-0.5886713862419128,
-0.3497598171234131,
-0.4393826425075531,
0.7226825952529907,
-0.5159604549407959,
-0.6899639368057251,
-0.27612900733947754,
-0.8739851117134094,
-0.2964310348033905,
0.21130463480949402,
0.31207165122032166,
0.0036189528182148933,
-0.5541496276855469,
0.2699398696422577,
0.44471821188926697,
-0.2864450216293335,
0.8330989480018616,
0.43213531374931335,
-0.01340517122298479,
-0.42949286103248596,
0.713749885559082,
0.03647645190358162,
0.32240167260169983,
0.1080862507224083,
0.2390177845954895,
-0.5455523729324341,
-0.6091424822807312,
-0.09639647603034973,
0.4566594660282135,
-0.7491926550865173,
0.17242953181266785,
-0.4118017554283142,
-0.07571586966514587,
-0.31067153811454773,
-0.2627550959587097,
-0.34534090757369995,
-0.37015220522880554,
-0.36799511313438416,
0.05146944522857666,
-0.06782878935337067,
1.18501877784729,
-0.062082964926958084,
-0.2335132509469986,
-0.6469095349311829,
0.0274212583899498,
0.3654618263244629,
0.38160356879234314,
0.45335623621940613,
-0.6457764506340027,
-0.22102400660514832,
0.0028994474560022354,
-0.5895294547080994,
-0.4874681532382965,
0.3901803195476532,
-0.014174805022776127,
0.6640056371688843,
0.6766951680183411,
-0.32660189270973206,
0.49924400448799133,
-0.41799238324165344,
0.8858820796012878,
0.29157885909080505,
-0.7041911482810974,
0.04294194281101227,
-0.3142811059951782,
0.5492254495620728,
0.21030156314373016,
0.4894849359989166,
-0.6411787271499634,
-0.41927677392959595,
-0.6293476223945618,
-0.7537747621536255,
0.2543148398399353,
-0.035713762044906616,
0.22932563722133636,
0.048670269548892975,
0.09605949372053146,
0.31792905926704407,
0.19619221985340118,
-0.6448430418968201,
0.2651825249195099,
0.2917708158493042,
0.057653140276670456,
-0.2545223832130432,
-0.218128964304924,
-0.1773565411567688,
-0.2994048297405243,
0.24619053304195404,
0.03294380009174347,
-0.09712440520524979,
-0.10596676170825958,
0.2557547986507416,
-0.4136596620082855,
0.2630884647369385,
0.5191811323165894,
0.8855413794517517,
0.17618413269519806,
0.253596693277359,
0.3855777978897095,
-0.3649812340736389,
0.10230248421430588,
-0.2017204612493515,
0.17834073305130005,
-0.31096741557121277,
0.7125449776649475,
0.5334323048591614,
0.007333588320761919,
-1.1603683233261108,
0.4129225015640259,
-0.1398715376853943,
-0.31270208954811096,
-0.32611989974975586,
0.2829746603965759,
0.7697323560714722,
0.6231502890586853,
0.3486463725566864,
0.27615582942962646,
-0.0790829211473465,
-0.766391396522522,
-0.13370460271835327,
0.5750460624694824,
-0.08945819735527039,
-0.43802016973495483,
0.5240035057067871,
0.06110852584242821,
-0.6004538536071777,
0.5080246925354004,
-0.2586442828178406,
-0.410606324672699,
0.5658760070800781,
0.4159391522407532,
1.2809290885925293,
0.14605902135372162,
0.018420126289129257,
-0.10677443444728851,
0.13841170072555542,
-0.28477784991264343,
0.47605711221694946,
-0.09169260412454605,
-0.7026897072792053,
-0.4115712642669678,
-0.6934215426445007,
-0.34113746881484985,
0.2225336879491806,
-0.35430341958999634,
0.1396753191947937,
-0.3201611638069153,
-0.21683575212955475,
0.11472360789775848,
-0.02090732753276825,
-0.6564472317695618,
-0.03763539716601372,
0.4940498173236847,
0.8397985100746155,
-0.6258600950241089,
0.481703519821167,
0.6519415378570557,
-0.3686459958553314,
-0.3818376660346985,
0.2121892124414444,
0.018976112827658653,
-0.2850245535373688,
0.759145975112915,
0.2516522705554962,
-0.3045499920845032,
-0.15070632100105286,
-0.6176815032958984,
-0.936473548412323,
1.0994431972503662,
0.35736826062202454,
-0.6015387177467346,
-0.0007985628908500075,
0.36472564935684204,
0.8267597556114197,
-0.6322281956672668,
-0.06511186063289642,
0.7321266531944275,
0.1427137553691864,
0.26126980781555176,
-0.7629379034042358,
-0.03649967163801193,
-0.3129412531852722,
0.17426657676696777,
-0.11259538680315018,
-0.6279754638671875,
0.9611043334007263,
-0.7473693490028381,
-0.5485871434211731,
0.3517349064350128,
0.6344056725502014,
0.3370401859283447,
0.30487462878227234,
0.16715794801712036,
0.6966766715049744,
0.8673607110977173,
0.059987664222717285,
0.9068211913108826,
-0.05481882765889168,
-0.0029717586003243923,
0.7692510485649109,
-0.4908891022205353,
0.8525250554084778,
0.32787150144577026,
-0.2498319298028946,
0.649735689163208,
0.49237141013145447,
-0.07054995000362396,
0.23528717458248138,
0.4919096827507019,
-0.6151788234710693,
-0.3323194682598114,
-0.015937477350234985,
-0.035931989550590515,
0.33974531292915344,
0.2468593418598175,
-0.28319936990737915,
0.1913817971944809,
-0.11109220236539841,
-0.1909692883491516,
0.18900646269321442,
-0.16730327904224396,
0.7878792881965637,
0.2912501394748688,
-0.8111052513122559,
0.6390937566757202,
-0.25496265292167664,
0.7661688327789307,
-0.21399971842765808,
0.1663244366645813,
-0.20329847931861877,
0.14042551815509796,
-0.09115532040596008,
-1.3796747922897339,
0.15264669060707092,
0.10473962128162384,
-0.04230746254324913,
-0.31416162848472595,
0.6059247851371765,
-0.356138676404953,
-0.29344162344932556,
0.22215715050697327,
0.8158718943595886,
0.17653381824493408,
-0.004190641921013594,
-0.4000513553619385,
0.17679573595523834,
-0.1451651155948639,
-0.26223260164260864,
0.12215258926153183,
0.8196009397506714,
-0.017994090914726257,
1.0301748514175415,
0.7493765950202942,
0.40109172463417053,
-0.032406046986579895,
0.44462502002716064,
0.9362014532089233,
-0.9869673848152161,
-0.5666569471359253,
-1.0564545392990112,
0.539732813835144,
-0.194045290350914,
-0.5726638436317444,
0.7922213673591614,
0.6728690266609192,
0.9727329611778259,
-0.21477191150188446,
0.9668093323707581,
0.02164624072611332,
0.46135085821151733,
-0.15390613675117493,
0.8150295615196228,
-0.46870100498199463,
0.4618847668170929,
-0.3290151059627533,
-0.9529226422309875,
-0.2900032103061676,
0.2716158628463745,
-0.4572494328022003,
0.114998959004879,
0.5689690113067627,
0.6936488747596741,
0.11960075050592422,
0.23062755167484283,
0.24426715075969696,
0.16421012580394745,
0.31747281551361084,
0.5223146080970764,
1.6624618768692017,
0.2923101484775543,
0.023602066561579704,
-0.03584332764148712,
-0.27851614356040955,
-0.04255622997879982,
-0.858100175857544,
-1.157762885093689,
-0.47086161375045776,
-0.11047230660915375,
0.046610839664936066,
-0.5070370435714722,
0.8135496973991394,
0.3371138572692871,
-0.2131783366203308,
-0.42392244935035706,
-0.35417360067367554,
0.0727146714925766,
-0.05255384370684624,
-0.16602309048175812,
-0.08193904906511307,
-0.1335066854953766,
-0.7335541248321533,
0.38970041275024414,
0.5085381269454956,
0.309799462556839,
-0.8572712540626526,
-0.1198892667889595,
0.18127283453941345,
0.48534461855888367,
0.7714655995368958,
0.2242518961429596,
-0.9929953217506409,
0.24715960025787354,
0.06085526570677757,
-0.12250392884016037,
-0.1472255438566208,
0.8586605191230774,
-0.5606441497802734,
0.4085799753665924,
0.734411358833313,
0.5044788122177124,
0.17965050041675568,
-0.006287325639277697,
0.3692787289619446,
-0.4975212514400482,
0.024459604173898697,
0.7579766511917114,
0.1724155694246292,
0.6939937472343445,
0.02573811449110508,
0.2761516571044922,
0.34387505054473877,
-0.606497585773468,
-0.9467957019805908,
0.457258403301239,
-0.8433427810668945,
-0.34452393651008606,
1.092890977859497,
0.05563679337501526,
-0.2270716279745102,
0.0873519629240036,
-0.1555897742509842,
-0.025128083303570747,
-0.20228826999664307,
1.1801018714904785,
0.8597084283828735,
-0.420346736907959,
0.0553329698741436,
-0.31590738892555237,
0.5385299921035767,
0.24053283035755157,
-0.7607612013816833,
0.2234627902507782,
0.27912601828575134,
0.3786795735359192,
0.16857510805130005,
0.5855522751808167,
-0.10197993367910385,
0.26019713282585144,
0.09368852525949478,
0.04070253297686577,
0.18484070897102356,
-0.3669780194759369,
-0.278129905462265,
0.13944867253303528,
0.29313626885414124,
0.45009347796440125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08223v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08223v1
|
An information-theoretic model of shallow and deep language comprehension
| 2024-05-13T22:29:33 | 2024-05-13T22:29:33 |
Jiaxuan Li, Richard Futrell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT
|
A large body of work in psycholinguistics has focused on the idea that online
language comprehension can be shallow or `good enough': given constraints on
time or available computation, comprehenders may form interpretations of their
input that are plausible but inaccurate. However, this idea has not yet been
linked with formal theories of computation under resource constraints. Here we
use information theory to formulate a model of language comprehension as an
optimal trade-off between accuracy and processing depth, formalized as bits of
information extracted from the input, which increases with processing time. The
model provides a measure of processing effort as the change in processing
depth, which we link to EEG signals and reading times. We validate our theory
against a large-scale dataset of garden path sentence reading times, and EEG
experiments featuring N400, P600 and biphasic ERP effects. By quantifying the
timecourse of language processing as it proceeds from shallow to deep, our
model provides a unified framework to explain behavioral and neural signatures
of language comprehension.
|
[
-0.46908628940582275,
-1.0731558799743652,
0.8714743256568909,
0.39643755555152893,
-0.03683837503194809,
-0.10594892501831055,
-0.47188928723335266,
-0.6133326292037964,
-0.05025717243552208,
0.046360939741134644,
-0.4744187295436859,
0.008727780543267727,
-0.4596560001373291,
-0.1176903173327446,
-0.3616918623447418,
0.7563115358352661,
0.19945809245109558,
-0.22000467777252197,
0.0766245573759079,
0.13895092904567719,
-0.4971908926963806,
-0.10147032141685486,
-0.8190184831619263,
-0.5026280879974365,
0.5181788206100464,
0.2563210129737854,
0.6917460560798645,
0.5834046006202698,
0.4370114207267761,
0.17071886360645294,
-0.2750798761844635,
-0.5039332509040833,
-0.5333288311958313,
-0.08310545235872269,
-0.2787211239337921,
-0.7314385771751404,
-0.2962546646595001,
-0.13676461577415466,
0.5066997408866882,
1.313391923904419,
-0.31153109669685364,
-0.05040685087442398,
0.17360526323318481,
0.7405259609222412,
-0.7640542984008789,
0.13995769619941711,
-0.5394284725189209,
0.22987602651119232,
0.03226029872894287,
-0.27429914474487305,
-0.5554569959640503,
-0.13755153119564056,
0.342652827501297,
-0.4976657032966614,
0.3153485655784607,
-0.2225010246038437,
0.7655429840087891,
0.367362380027771,
-0.12384199351072311,
-0.05621786415576935,
-0.8414066433906555,
0.3946780860424042,
-0.7484314441680908,
0.5344324111938477,
0.9126167893409729,
0.15805338323116302,
0.5067145228385925,
-0.39618685841560364,
-0.6061562895774841,
-0.16763800382614136,
-0.3176642954349518,
0.03181825950741768,
-0.24230267107486725,
0.4127362072467804,
0.3276730477809906,
0.3636321425437927,
-0.7236044406890869,
-0.12198171764612198,
-0.6591806411743164,
0.07503382861614227,
0.22928950190544128,
-0.045317668467760086,
0.4066840708255768,
0.012215597555041313,
-0.07575759291648865,
0.18278130888938904,
-0.37379035353660583,
0.3974200487136841,
0.16046643257141113,
0.040667448192834854,
-0.18306243419647217,
0.5516500473022461,
-0.2142779380083084,
0.8361066579818726,
0.026957876980304718,
-0.03396734595298767,
-0.10002046078443527,
-0.29723742604255676,
-0.39340299367904663,
-0.10322637856006622,
0.4230789244174957,
0.1449175477027893,
0.5041753053665161,
-0.43825563788414,
-0.23896189033985138,
0.11887228488922119,
0.18134234845638275,
-0.6775196194648743,
-0.2773837745189667,
0.45128536224365234,
-0.35167601704597473,
-0.06034686043858528,
-0.15774573385715485,
-0.5040271282196045,
-0.35452741384506226,
-0.3895384967327118,
0.3395044505596161,
-0.7264038920402527,
-0.31000444293022156,
0.6208314895629883,
-0.21720662713050842,
0.08939749747514725,
-0.09043534100055695,
-0.9787362813949585,
0.5388317108154297,
0.328042209148407,
1.0049493312835693,
0.13208399713039398,
-0.3959643542766571,
-0.0741753801703453,
0.3850540220737457,
-0.3486429452896118,
0.814321756362915,
-0.6287744641304016,
0.12240505963563919,
-0.11692998558282852,
-0.3327597677707672,
-0.21364496648311615,
-0.01835990883409977,
0.4503597617149353,
-0.7459235787391663,
0.21106413006782532,
-0.05534965917468071,
-0.720241367816925,
-0.26535671949386597,
0.014124538749456406,
-0.9876195788383484,
0.3069893717765808,
0.09715348482131958,
-0.8284746408462524,
0.3142431974411011,
-0.7667122483253479,
-0.58001309633255,
0.12249954789876938,
0.0886651873588562,
0.2499505579471588,
0.2765011787414551,
0.12885913252830505,
0.3988172113895416,
-0.1919594556093216,
0.16682691872119904,
-0.3037508428096771,
-0.66550213098526,
0.46267226338386536,
-0.45661431550979614,
0.813200831413269,
0.29839271306991577,
-0.3385857045650482,
-0.46848687529563904,
-0.5115492343902588,
0.39175286889076233,
0.058749329298734665,
-0.6770828366279602,
-0.21604493260383606,
0.13269492983818054,
-0.14835308492183685,
-0.04604945704340935,
0.23399072885513306,
-0.40595880150794983,
-0.09853612631559372,
-0.8277195692062378,
0.7939336895942688,
0.532862663269043,
-0.18488359451293945,
0.7686643004417419,
-0.09952947497367859,
0.37630534172058105,
-0.1993357390165329,
0.17118506133556366,
-0.15384429693222046,
-0.051372263580560684,
-0.7735100388526917,
-0.10133074223995209,
0.516546368598938,
0.6001139879226685,
-0.31767967343330383,
0.401813805103302,
-0.36129581928253174,
-0.06827044486999512,
-0.684606671333313,
-0.06605324894189835,
0.19456559419631958,
0.15383796393871307,
0.36145445704460144,
-0.15771141648292542,
-0.19748450815677643,
-0.9200679659843445,
-0.4808255732059479,
-0.12899254262447357,
-0.2683694064617157,
0.31829819083213806,
-0.0015187327517196536,
-0.1976570338010788,
0.7162638902664185,
-0.40535858273506165,
-0.1909940391778946,
-0.3024722933769226,
0.09285213053226471,
0.42591553926467896,
0.1239340528845787,
0.4203885793685913,
-0.43229177594184875,
-0.24914604425430298,
-0.04152503237128258,
-0.5531482696533203,
-0.14866343140602112,
-0.08029159903526306,
0.014409833587706089,
0.008450968191027641,
0.3560139536857605,
-0.7073004841804504,
0.4056517779827118,
0.43639570474624634,
-0.6202844381332397,
0.08260476589202881,
-0.379010945558548,
0.0711292251944542,
-0.40910983085632324,
0.1862722784280777,
-0.14181959629058838,
-0.08834502100944519,
-0.6916989684104919,
0.30589592456817627,
0.10778732597827911,
-0.05516396090388298,
-0.13799406588077545,
0.5062414407730103,
-0.4029279947280884,
-0.033958856016397476,
-0.2521693706512451,
0.38982465863227844,
0.2235555648803711,
0.6035977005958557,
-0.03705340623855591,
0.26080650091171265,
0.63530033826828,
-0.7314754128456116,
0.024712473154067993,
-0.3566805422306061,
-0.4263301491737366,
0.6219152212142944,
-0.8470146059989929,
0.20741015672683716,
-0.3085483908653259,
-0.04493112489581108,
-1.0618469715118408,
-0.47027117013931274,
-0.06777826696634293,
-0.4796440303325653,
0.3464744985103607,
-0.1575385183095932,
-0.1647804081439972,
-0.0000650480724289082,
0.05773357301950455,
0.7587037086486816,
0.49900227785110474,
-0.2646377980709076,
0.6516713500022888,
0.40088796615600586,
-0.3801105320453644,
-0.4390876591205597,
-1.0616217851638794,
-0.0363217331469059,
0.07601515203714371,
-0.8046365976333618,
0.4288594424724579,
-0.04383918642997742,
-0.6380428671836853,
0.16820049285888672,
0.16528476774692535,
-0.5985259413719177,
-0.002109323162585497,
-0.08583952486515045,
-0.08752263337373734,
-0.19831746816635132,
0.25931158661842346,
0.1333034485578537,
0.01008239109069109,
0.2063395082950592,
-0.1819763481616974,
0.49481216073036194,
-0.13839936256408691,
-0.353424996137619,
-0.40462854504585266,
0.37451934814453125,
0.34881970286369324,
0.0001767065841704607,
0.6437745094299316,
0.3479617238044739,
-0.5864986181259155,
-0.194058358669281,
-0.5757445693016052,
-0.3599516451358795,
-0.3751978874206543,
0.30948606133461,
-0.6166278123855591,
-0.5445510149002075,
0.46054917573928833,
0.5041149854660034,
-0.01567951589822769,
0.2124636173248291,
0.062320560216903687,
-0.22436879575252533,
1.0688567161560059,
0.5948333144187927,
-0.012802948243916035,
0.5014314651489258,
-0.22555509209632874,
0.37335675954818726,
-0.5700246095657349,
-0.05363338068127632,
-0.23653215169906616,
-0.4087984561920166,
-0.0718386247754097,
-0.22023101150989532,
0.01556530874222517,
0.4990290403366089,
-0.21076425909996033,
-0.1124952882528305,
-0.2885682284832001,
0.9730462431907654,
0.4507221281528473,
0.2268373817205429,
0.24582532048225403,
0.08362052589654922,
-0.057196568697690964,
-0.09492605924606323,
-0.722861111164093,
-0.3240914046764374,
0.680939257144928,
0.44941064715385437,
0.8119906187057495,
0.11496413499116898,
0.00395605294033885,
0.23917743563652039,
-0.1955156922340393,
-0.6542028784751892,
0.25374889373779297,
0.1458183228969574,
-0.7450618743896484,
-0.5594683289527893,
-0.33229464292526245,
-1.0541318655014038,
0.14396369457244873,
0.1715063601732254,
-0.8210257291793823,
0.19892756640911102,
0.25366294384002686,
-0.42057693004608154,
0.2647097110748291,
-1.0586594343185425,
0.7638143301010132,
-0.2613208591938019,
-0.3934968411922455,
-0.6157792806625366,
-0.6328079104423523,
0.33622485399246216,
0.07412127405405045,
0.36959484219551086,
-0.006584689952433109,
-0.08945179730653763,
0.48529618978500366,
0.021003708243370056,
0.6443785429000854,
-0.1977672129869461,
0.17368392646312714,
0.1834217607975006,
0.6375089287757874,
0.3095400333404541,
0.0675702691078186,
-0.059009283781051636,
0.21330294013023376,
0.30889013409614563,
-0.7812258005142212,
-0.7117511034011841,
0.3871292471885681,
-0.8229234218597412,
-0.22835250198841095,
-0.21084757149219513,
-0.5411602258682251,
-0.18243998289108276,
0.11509265750646591,
0.4296647012233734,
0.1770886927843094,
-0.12999796867370605,
0.19255216419696808,
0.8953824043273926,
-0.125991091132164,
0.36796998977661133,
0.4716714024543762,
-0.08863840252161026,
-0.11262504011392593,
0.7708300948143005,
0.1012745052576065,
0.3535310924053192,
0.5934351682662964,
0.18158365786075592,
-0.4085734188556671,
-0.5538504719734192,
-0.16419893503189087,
0.2620638310909271,
-0.8264702558517456,
0.30213698744773865,
-0.45034024119377136,
-0.24980346858501434,
-0.24674180150032043,
-0.12310276180505753,
-0.0890592709183693,
-0.2910834848880768,
-0.17360226809978485,
-0.19882845878601074,
-0.0011043503182008862,
0.9959697723388672,
-0.27258118987083435,
0.18758678436279297,
-0.35851675271987915,
0.4605148732662201,
0.3432871401309967,
0.7669795155525208,
0.1033034399151802,
-0.7384462356567383,
-0.3610629737377167,
0.40354207158088684,
0.08137154579162598,
-0.9954577088356018,
0.04463499039411545,
0.30743664503097534,
0.4443478286266327,
0.5009732246398926,
-0.17219363152980804,
0.5559432506561279,
-0.399571031332016,
0.4781695604324341,
-0.012654068879783154,
-1.247969388961792,
0.4268154203891754,
-0.16128815710544586,
0.5548325181007385,
0.5743700265884399,
0.18226976692676544,
-0.7841171622276306,
-0.4484618008136749,
-0.4806920289993286,
-0.9909860491752625,
0.6602985262870789,
0.3066480755805969,
-0.0748281180858612,
0.22024524211883545,
0.39878547191619873,
0.2047446370124817,
-0.0054499502293765545,
-1.0880290269851685,
0.17240400612354279,
-0.14193843305110931,
-0.1567305624485016,
-0.002644321648404002,
-0.32301682233810425,
0.0726541057229042,
-0.215436652302742,
0.38331952691078186,
-0.045224715024232864,
0.5259257555007935,
0.12553942203521729,
-0.4142862856388092,
-0.19243669509887695,
0.386363685131073,
0.4510657489299774,
1.1306920051574707,
-0.169742614030838,
0.47526445984840393,
0.22756604850292206,
-0.3478352129459381,
0.05717473477125168,
-0.06117353215813637,
-0.20234555006027222,
-0.1362597942352295,
0.7212563157081604,
0.8961014747619629,
0.06541468948125839,
-0.6013253331184387,
0.5660558938980103,
-0.1880311369895935,
-0.0781668871641159,
-0.13443198800086975,
0.20997855067253113,
0.18753299117088318,
0.24704007804393768,
0.182572141289711,
0.1046353429555893,
0.31399089097976685,
-0.35320818424224854,
-0.048266902565956116,
0.21072474122047424,
-0.49989062547683716,
-0.39227214455604553,
0.5382654666900635,
-0.012972727417945862,
-0.487517774105072,
0.4632110893726349,
-0.1318119615316391,
-0.15863336622714996,
0.40755361318588257,
0.3008016347885132,
0.7195847630500793,
0.038213521242141724,
0.145625039935112,
0.18267154693603516,
0.38612765073776245,
0.07454051822423935,
0.4533235728740692,
-0.12409592419862747,
-0.5332497358322144,
-0.7869040966033936,
-0.6432088613510132,
-0.05459732562303543,
0.5447991490364075,
-0.5124244093894958,
-0.13773581385612488,
-0.3449231684207916,
-0.0727858915925026,
0.06204656511545181,
-0.3132208287715912,
-0.9923901557922363,
0.34910598397254944,
0.1409449279308319,
0.8163772225379944,
-0.6494820713996887,
0.48309701681137085,
0.3376833200454712,
-0.4298703372478485,
-0.7951117753982544,
0.2038351148366928,
-0.5868208408355713,
-0.672073483467102,
0.4724433720111847,
0.16572748124599457,
-0.254158616065979,
-0.009290769696235657,
-0.4315281808376312,
-0.8764444589614868,
0.5795865058898926,
0.8344549536705017,
-0.7366671562194824,
-0.3319692015647888,
0.11732020229101181,
0.7883784174919128,
-0.004329714458435774,
0.4363604485988617,
0.8508849143981934,
0.6160255670547485,
-0.38060262799263,
-0.6592869162559509,
-0.0013019372709095478,
-0.34870797395706177,
-0.1334708333015442,
0.03401898592710495,
-0.23864330351352692,
0.7911129593849182,
-0.351635605096817,
-0.5263208746910095,
-0.26806750893592834,
0.24269458651542664,
-0.2552609145641327,
0.09636817127466202,
0.5629475712776184,
0.5726258754730225,
0.6803505420684814,
0.051772695034742355,
1.3073803186416626,
-0.4887249171733856,
0.17442171275615692,
0.9584582448005676,
0.163014218211174,
0.7441983222961426,
0.41784921288490295,
-0.4142521023750305,
0.4945370554924011,
0.8463121056556702,
0.48019251227378845,
0.6385363340377808,
0.2148028463125229,
-0.043839648365974426,
-0.15791189670562744,
0.030934253707528114,
-0.2017228752374649,
0.16222825646400452,
0.3168545067310333,
-0.396278440952301,
0.13884063065052032,
0.094724640250206,
-0.2990594208240509,
-0.12843550741672516,
-0.22235651314258575,
0.8219671845436096,
0.021304063498973846,
-0.9451795220375061,
0.5148710012435913,
0.055374763906002045,
0.17627517879009247,
-0.33227667212486267,
0.22108587622642517,
-0.25731196999549866,
0.17936433851718903,
-0.11777637898921967,
-1.1887632608413696,
0.1514545977115631,
-0.2850838899612427,
-0.3417123556137085,
-0.07229430973529816,
0.757172167301178,
-0.522548258304596,
-0.2517792582511902,
0.5632919073104858,
0.6710728406906128,
0.36093074083328247,
-0.26701900362968445,
-0.5285602807998657,
-0.10254310071468353,
-0.15728895366191864,
-0.43371763825416565,
-0.11227748543024063,
0.7192440629005432,
0.5582175254821777,
0.5006592869758606,
0.2909858524799347,
0.5427899360656738,
0.23878537118434906,
0.24493218958377838,
0.43397602438926697,
-0.7265119552612305,
-0.8665558099746704,
-1.1990389823913574,
0.3754890561103821,
0.007794211618602276,
-0.2234065681695938,
0.1832265853881836,
0.25786149501800537,
0.9073586463928223,
0.13470347225666046,
1.0064141750335693,
-0.116205595433712,
0.3418526351451874,
-0.7498724460601807,
0.5822983384132385,
-0.42391353845596313,
0.26412931084632874,
0.0024804084096103907,
-0.9850704669952393,
0.028241746127605438,
0.8528561592102051,
-0.4406728446483612,
0.04097725450992584,
1.0138134956359863,
0.4536704421043396,
-0.4434097707271576,
0.21842841804027557,
0.3054443597793579,
0.42170006036758423,
-0.03351457417011261,
0.9296868443489075,
0.8084585666656494,
-0.06483966112136841,
0.48205453157424927,
-0.33338239789009094,
-0.1468975692987442,
-0.2768062353134155,
-0.5284082889556885,
-0.9636866450309753,
-0.6310629844665527,
0.10986986756324768,
-0.22080698609352112,
-0.03199644014239311,
0.4248446226119995,
0.750210165977478,
-0.4642904996871948,
-0.38564133644104004,
-0.48390647768974304,
0.18879283964633942,
-0.07558820396661758,
-0.28198790550231934,
0.1664021909236908,
-0.42300593852996826,
-0.41695863008499146,
0.3089144825935364,
0.4727444052696228,
0.07091491669416428,
-0.3849700689315796,
-0.20359958708286285,
-0.097914919257164,
0.48373880982398987,
0.6164662837982178,
0.17719687521457672,
-0.6803115010261536,
-0.1443828046321869,
0.07253847271203995,
-0.21686920523643494,
0.1826021373271942,
0.8925937414169312,
-0.5361751914024353,
0.6392673850059509,
0.7848870158195496,
0.7153459191322327,
0.5357868671417236,
-0.2608116865158081,
0.57352614402771,
-0.6562196612358093,
0.017791952937841415,
0.43683215975761414,
0.39803346991539,
0.3214901089668274,
-0.3610665202140808,
0.4688044786453247,
0.07517216354608536,
-0.46992021799087524,
-0.8319293856620789,
0.3728789687156677,
-0.47052934765815735,
-0.8112528324127197,
1.0009335279464722,
0.035064179450273514,
-0.3253382742404938,
-0.20682941377162933,
-0.19914868474006653,
0.10330881923437119,
-0.2959873378276825,
1.0416375398635864,
1.0671443939208984,
-0.289083331823349,
-0.17649821937084198,
-0.494415819644928,
0.4807642996311188,
0.5806290507316589,
-0.8825926780700684,
0.011628841049969196,
0.361959844827652,
0.05392104387283325,
0.2927777171134949,
0.7636309266090393,
0.41708821058273315,
0.3460024297237396,
0.1201367899775505,
-0.1915927529335022,
0.30974718928337097,
-0.5531781911849976,
-0.259276807308197,
0.33095934987068176,
0.16743901371955872,
0.21117301285266876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08213v1
|
Interpreting Latent Student Knowledge Representations in Programming Assignments
| 2024-05-13T22:01:03 | 2024-05-13T22:01:03 |
Nigel Fernandez, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in artificial intelligence for education leverage generative
large language models, including using them to predict open-ended student
responses rather than their correctness only. However, the black-box nature of
these models limits the interpretability of the learned student knowledge
representations. In this paper, we conduct a first exploration into
interpreting latent student knowledge representations by presenting InfoOIRT,
an Information regularized Open-ended Item Response Theory model, which
encourages the latent student knowledge states to be interpretable while being
able to generate student-written code for open-ended programming questions.
InfoOIRT maximizes the mutual information between a fixed subset of latent
knowledge states enforced with simple prior distributions and generated student
code, which encourages the model to learn disentangled representations of
salient syntactic and semantic code features including syntactic styles,
mastery of programming skills, and code structures. Through experiments on a
real-world programming education dataset, we show that InfoOIRT can both
accurately generate student code and lead to interpretable student knowledge
representations.
|
[
-0.12367279827594757,
-0.6920549869537354,
0.4039362668991089,
0.07403495162725449,
0.07627905905246735,
0.2967332601547241,
-0.2119358777999878,
-0.10559887439012527,
-0.11187417060136795,
0.19338205456733704,
-0.35842955112457275,
-0.36189788579940796,
-0.4012989103794098,
-0.12194393575191498,
-0.3708280324935913,
1.393582820892334,
-0.07870792597532272,
-0.23496723175048828,
-0.3935885429382324,
0.21513517200946808,
-0.43222713470458984,
-0.5983290672302246,
-0.30249613523483276,
-0.08746790885925293,
0.32230812311172485,
0.699020266532898,
0.5846725106239319,
0.3205172121524811,
0.6674237847328186,
0.08411209285259247,
0.4042990505695343,
-0.5835221409797668,
-0.7067573666572571,
-0.25641849637031555,
-0.1897604614496231,
-0.6668082475662231,
-0.2738876938819885,
0.2341698855161667,
0.3894807994365692,
0.9126050472259521,
-0.14566606283187866,
0.25895288586616516,
0.23735754191875458,
0.46736058592796326,
-0.3750106990337372,
0.534510612487793,
-0.4951995611190796,
-0.04440369829535484,
-0.002886577509343624,
-0.2736055552959442,
-0.6910005211830139,
-0.2478524148464203,
0.09849923104047775,
-0.620990514755249,
0.1357480138540268,
-0.2675984501838684,
0.7355557680130005,
0.5242034196853638,
-0.12055744975805283,
-0.4582318961620331,
-0.9749725461006165,
0.6630994081497192,
-0.5322809219360352,
0.46043434739112854,
0.4972579777240753,
0.46550092101097107,
-0.11758287996053696,
-0.7433732151985168,
-0.7855724096298218,
-0.14503023028373718,
-0.19364987313747406,
0.5080785155296326,
-0.1459176242351532,
0.24166399240493774,
0.3366572856903076,
0.5732351541519165,
-0.8596121072769165,
-0.18159569799900055,
-0.5353740453720093,
0.16289633512496948,
0.29019951820373535,
-0.0543610081076622,
0.2361220419406891,
-0.060990940779447556,
-0.50498366355896,
-0.03680338338017464,
-0.43024972081184387,
0.2816314399242401,
0.513877272605896,
0.08206479996442795,
-0.1864408403635025,
0.8910819888114929,
0.1531536877155304,
0.8988730311393738,
-0.22021473944187164,
0.12596173584461212,
-0.15052808821201324,
-0.143655464053154,
-0.12783634662628174,
-0.1779090166091919,
0.2527894973754883,
0.25676313042640686,
0.21424999833106995,
-0.2911137640476227,
-0.16704688966274261,
0.16954562067985535,
0.3627476990222931,
-0.8344795107841492,
-0.5720808506011963,
0.12707334756851196,
-0.649924635887146,
-0.23388613760471344,
0.287192165851593,
-0.5672974586486816,
-0.11711235344409943,
-0.39628779888153076,
0.23620495200157166,
-0.2015710473060608,
-0.3274134397506714,
0.2192365527153015,
0.10081686824560165,
0.1459936648607254,
0.1310259997844696,
-0.3610624372959137,
0.3104255497455597,
0.28482797741889954,
0.5401100516319275,
-0.004385209176689386,
-0.23564650118350983,
-0.31954649090766907,
0.06935939192771912,
-0.15961165726184845,
0.31777623295783997,
-0.9021362066268921,
0.08381910622119904,
-0.23726241290569305,
-0.24629001319408417,
-0.12691646814346313,
-0.08959153294563293,
-0.1402246654033661,
-0.8990228176116943,
0.24895519018173218,
0.18686074018478394,
-0.6156565546989441,
-0.09843607991933823,
0.10475198179483414,
-0.5011851191520691,
0.7186654210090637,
0.8225739002227783,
-1.006029725074768,
0.08686897158622742,
-0.7427347898483276,
0.10478967428207397,
0.11504355072975159,
-0.5499401688575745,
-0.10860490798950195,
0.004028077702969313,
-0.37045302987098694,
0.42891040444374084,
-0.0687691792845726,
0.3380243182182312,
0.0014376748586073518,
-0.5626193881034851,
0.5127221941947937,
-0.28381845355033875,
0.479366660118103,
0.3348950445652008,
-0.14435796439647675,
-0.12119825184345245,
-0.6410785913467407,
-0.15188871324062347,
0.28603288531303406,
-0.6048123240470886,
-0.3041825592517853,
-0.1958295702934265,
-0.11868330836296082,
0.042066540569067,
0.35443469882011414,
-0.4783027172088623,
0.6803060173988342,
-0.16324540972709656,
0.1588023602962494,
0.8442051410675049,
0.21367129683494568,
0.38194021582603455,
0.021379588171839714,
0.8926218152046204,
0.019122643396258354,
-0.06219605356454849,
-0.09392333030700684,
-0.48460322618484497,
-0.3790729343891144,
0.13977953791618347,
0.1903175413608551,
0.5408949851989746,
-1.1185988187789917,
-0.06894216686487198,
-0.06905580312013626,
-0.018976548686623573,
-0.4942043423652649,
0.03199610114097595,
0.3237641751766205,
0.5727962851524353,
0.32072028517723083,
-0.12629057466983795,
-0.3982079327106476,
-0.6503667831420898,
-0.25759851932525635,
-0.4231520891189575,
-0.01500551775097847,
0.23277093470096588,
0.4911419749259949,
-0.3272330164909363,
0.971940815448761,
-0.831667959690094,
-0.05214710533618927,
-0.16489064693450928,
0.4091064929962158,
0.36323389410972595,
0.607218325138092,
0.5420475602149963,
-0.8229957222938538,
-0.20535330474376678,
-0.18119579553604126,
-0.7003061771392822,
0.2029263824224472,
-0.41804900765419006,
-0.18201638758182526,
-0.24481886625289917,
0.43436795473098755,
0.09708999842405319,
0.9132360219955444,
0.45779773592948914,
-0.6744276881217957,
0.5306486487388611,
0.006933383643627167,
0.1259542852640152,
-1.0033942461013794,
0.10664280503988266,
-0.25234565138816833,
0.011768327094614506,
-0.29144981503486633,
0.19130904972553253,
0.07190927863121033,
-0.46342921257019043,
0.04091449826955795,
0.4096240997314453,
-0.28613123297691345,
-0.1905621439218521,
-0.11802569031715393,
-0.007021778263151646,
-0.17359156906604767,
0.6344767212867737,
0.01004777755588293,
0.9362361431121826,
0.3329666256904602,
-0.4821302890777588,
0.3090364336967468,
0.23169049620628357,
-0.3587113320827484,
0.4809570014476776,
-0.677005410194397,
0.2731330096721649,
-0.3239094913005829,
-0.13655157387256622,
-1.0408979654312134,
-0.4005167484283447,
-0.04348577931523323,
-0.7464772462844849,
0.3697444200515747,
-0.5183839201927185,
-0.26174259185791016,
-0.3760829567909241,
-0.036674439907073975,
0.7482928037643433,
0.4526823163032532,
-0.5063338279724121,
0.23578493297100067,
-0.06001347675919533,
-0.27498215436935425,
-0.6809307336807251,
-0.6354823708534241,
-0.260987788438797,
0.28056225180625916,
-0.23599661886692047,
-0.012796815484762192,
-0.356934517621994,
-0.38433143496513367,
0.424957275390625,
-0.1719062626361847,
-0.3689553737640381,
0.43158063292503357,
0.18304501473903656,
0.427819162607193,
-0.42607179284095764,
0.347871333360672,
0.11449624598026276,
-0.08702854067087173,
-0.026762884110212326,
-0.5932443737983704,
0.3039119839668274,
-0.3411438465118408,
-0.6501619219779968,
-0.006815196014940739,
0.10971640050411224,
0.29113924503326416,
-0.2519180178642273,
0.8877652287483215,
0.4365716874599457,
-0.4148509204387665,
-0.09633293002843857,
-0.022358402609825134,
-0.4669908583164215,
-0.3569522500038147,
0.5403175950050354,
-0.4384048879146576,
-0.6222661733627319,
0.29587507247924805,
0.03155661001801491,
0.22994957864284515,
-0.043434228748083115,
0.06890328973531723,
-0.19435927271842957,
0.8809179663658142,
0.9397561550140381,
0.10535726696252823,
0.6227244138717651,
-0.6881157159805298,
0.49391573667526245,
-0.8199777007102966,
-0.3693064749240875,
-0.37039753794670105,
-0.12227019667625427,
-0.09128838777542114,
-0.3923809230327606,
0.30394861102104187,
0.6125848889350891,
-0.17212960124015808,
0.15089142322540283,
-0.6031599640846252,
0.6725478768348694,
0.42395150661468506,
0.04396290332078934,
0.21959537267684937,
0.11295398324728012,
0.011221243068575859,
-0.10268263518810272,
-0.6044600605964661,
-0.6357346773147583,
1.2140965461730957,
0.25785398483276367,
1.0312169790267944,
0.29252415895462036,
0.5709080100059509,
0.510344922542572,
0.4322453439235687,
-0.8426299095153809,
0.12086378782987595,
-0.013992294669151306,
-0.12106705456972122,
-0.10956747829914093,
-0.5755031108856201,
-0.8078826665878296,
-0.36127883195877075,
0.12028257548809052,
-0.6865465044975281,
0.04678153991699219,
0.01330262515693903,
-0.24026083946228027,
0.27918902039527893,
-0.8765907287597656,
1.0222980976104736,
-0.1048198714852333,
-0.30231451988220215,
0.09376247972249985,
-0.45554256439208984,
0.18631671369075775,
0.01844460889697075,
0.35635906457901,
0.408272385597229,
0.16001051664352417,
1.0513029098510742,
-0.35009220242500305,
0.7087035179138184,
-0.3016026020050049,
0.016215864568948746,
0.3783937990665436,
0.46145936846733093,
0.31203848123550415,
0.2925775647163391,
-0.183406800031662,
-0.25031423568725586,
-0.06516405940055847,
-0.7809752821922302,
-0.8180777430534363,
0.6423951387405396,
-0.8865941762924194,
-0.49459031224250793,
-0.35458892583847046,
-0.8783007264137268,
-0.00873265229165554,
0.0786791667342186,
0.12304379045963287,
0.5471319556236267,
0.14729349315166473,
0.11773891001939774,
0.7711150050163269,
-0.2984555959701538,
0.06718318909406662,
0.4441221058368683,
-0.2598683536052704,
0.22453992068767548,
1.1796807050704956,
0.030136778950691223,
0.36646008491516113,
0.31238532066345215,
-0.03748198598623276,
-0.03157252073287964,
-0.5078600645065308,
-0.5109646320343018,
0.0625242069363594,
-0.9584454894065857,
-0.06518355011940002,
-0.5605815052986145,
-0.12349666655063629,
-0.3802134394645691,
-0.2711181938648224,
-0.0338534414768219,
-0.508410632610321,
-0.25943589210510254,
-0.220086008310318,
0.15488971769809723,
1.274256944656372,
0.12757913768291473,
0.4110294282436371,
-0.38542798161506653,
0.2001226395368576,
0.43057525157928467,
0.44771015644073486,
-0.12457183003425598,
-0.4363955557346344,
-0.5445374250411987,
0.10593319684267044,
-0.08160053193569183,
-1.181357502937317,
-0.20749683678150177,
0.0753435492515564,
0.5372444987297058,
0.49568241834640503,
0.30098193883895874,
0.23357006907463074,
0.2566203773021698,
0.8363082408905029,
-0.014490857720375061,
-0.6929327249526978,
0.7348134517669678,
-0.15511517226696014,
0.2268049716949463,
0.3016775846481323,
0.5107919573783875,
-0.3711642920970917,
-0.707689106464386,
-0.6775475144386292,
-0.6636728644371033,
0.9924258589744568,
0.33008837699890137,
0.03193966671824455,
0.1096678376197815,
0.45551830530166626,
0.3496015667915344,
0.405674010515213,
-0.9317734241485596,
-0.2899467647075653,
-0.5536308288574219,
-0.7102310657501221,
0.23769044876098633,
-0.241310253739357,
0.11907994002103806,
0.09168652445077896,
0.47656285762786865,
-0.22022682428359985,
0.602450430393219,
-0.13867521286010742,
-0.25655198097229004,
-0.002270063618198037,
0.40637505054473877,
0.3146429657936096,
0.8786763548851013,
-0.33376142382621765,
0.30881160497665405,
-0.48938313126564026,
-0.6140092015266418,
-0.06208803132176399,
0.2227703183889389,
-0.14064277708530426,
-0.3148626983165741,
0.5427263379096985,
0.41485610604286194,
-0.03872613608837128,
-0.6576142907142639,
0.8625275492668152,
-0.353990763425827,
0.3084620535373688,
-0.18458634614944458,
0.036914873868227005,
-0.3023568093776703,
0.0739905908703804,
0.43909430503845215,
0.19678674638271332,
0.11391903460025787,
-0.620873749256134,
0.29475462436676025,
-0.005785844288766384,
-0.48572978377342224,
-0.5108741521835327,
0.6847268342971802,
-0.13569746911525726,
0.010561159811913967,
0.7173154950141907,
-0.33313944935798645,
-0.6337810754776001,
0.8469557762145996,
0.6209771633148193,
0.4204116463661194,
-0.22736144065856934,
0.33726224303245544,
0.41613996028900146,
0.3404759168624878,
0.5571995973587036,
0.6446741819381714,
-0.29884809255599976,
-0.41162046790122986,
-0.3970916271209717,
-0.4859091341495514,
-0.2531943619251251,
0.23588095605373383,
-1.0239877700805664,
-0.13251858949661255,
-0.540117621421814,
0.3272586464881897,
-0.230864480137825,
-0.29221412539482117,
-1.0032294988632202,
0.15654867887496948,
-0.16314643621444702,
0.6128156781196594,
-1.0070213079452515,
0.7082066535949707,
1.2965595722198486,
-0.9171155095100403,
-1.1699600219726562,
0.2991761565208435,
-0.3661791682243347,
-0.6247727870941162,
0.8986258506774902,
-0.1711416095495224,
0.21100670099258423,
0.13321594893932343,
-0.839204728603363,
-0.6925199627876282,
0.735611081123352,
0.29518282413482666,
-0.29604971408843994,
-0.28138792514801025,
0.045229509472846985,
0.3604887127876282,
-0.37240320444107056,
0.51775723695755,
0.25668343901634216,
0.16677536070346832,
0.057244494557380676,
-0.5525231957435608,
-0.12566141784191132,
-0.37511900067329407,
-0.14219102263450623,
0.05121545493602753,
-0.14997977018356323,
1.1629748344421387,
-0.5656599402427673,
-0.3171710968017578,
-0.2949534058570862,
0.594933271408081,
-0.14216522872447968,
0.38025689125061035,
0.1324949562549591,
0.235941082239151,
0.7814334034919739,
-0.07587535679340363,
1.0729044675827026,
-0.3959183990955353,
0.47418805956840515,
1.2624250650405884,
0.23523585498332977,
0.5042821168899536,
0.4470951557159424,
-0.29745128750801086,
0.776587724685669,
0.5861184597015381,
0.1891898214817047,
0.5033912658691406,
0.26195988059043884,
-0.0075924331322312355,
-0.12439709901809692,
-0.13192546367645264,
-0.5619691014289856,
0.15355776250362396,
0.48627686500549316,
-0.1902630776166916,
-0.20164699852466583,
0.5421206951141357,
-0.17259182035923004,
0.15878340601921082,
-0.17414788901805878,
0.8448517918586731,
-0.08331228047609329,
-0.5145378112792969,
0.48189571499824524,
-0.07434844225645065,
0.2321452796459198,
-0.2713800370693207,
-0.8238922357559204,
-0.19834865629673004,
0.16683855652809143,
-0.5466623306274414,
-1.1120491027832031,
0.18536335229873657,
0.1674700826406479,
-0.24114814400672913,
-0.03650945425033569,
0.664006769657135,
-0.6075985431671143,
-0.2311360239982605,
0.10746747255325317,
0.3292512893676758,
0.4632400572299957,
0.026934942230582237,
-0.5870861411094666,
-0.16568893194198608,
0.26478642225265503,
-0.24421143531799316,
0.004328922368586063,
0.4283423125743866,
0.022996237501502037,
0.5081556439399719,
0.40365126729011536,
0.03599276393651962,
0.1679232120513916,
-0.12760959565639496,
1.078538179397583,
-0.36685705184936523,
-0.5311862230300903,
-0.4194026589393616,
0.5726548433303833,
0.22969286143779755,
0.03746752068400383,
0.5299403071403503,
0.6593571305274963,
1.206415057182312,
-0.2241985946893692,
1.2096765041351318,
-0.3030644655227661,
0.25961607694625854,
-0.47944292426109314,
0.4642486572265625,
-0.3762699067592621,
0.593458354473114,
-0.17904649674892426,
-0.8226567506790161,
0.28954654932022095,
0.8485586643218994,
-0.5543117523193359,
0.01985364407300949,
0.6049076318740845,
0.3977990448474884,
-0.3437608480453491,
0.022663140669465065,
0.24436070024967194,
0.40337279438972473,
0.3430751860141754,
0.7931320667266846,
1.0839852094650269,
-0.3436935842037201,
0.6117161512374878,
-0.49813705682754517,
-0.6725414991378784,
-0.305768758058548,
-0.3159794807434082,
-1.0205715894699097,
-0.7303851842880249,
-0.39247554540634155,
-0.6438782215118408,
-0.1802942156791687,
0.7858662605285645,
0.430090069770813,
-0.7135069370269775,
-0.06023741886019707,
-0.11627159267663956,
0.361120343208313,
-0.19648413360118866,
-0.389016717672348,
0.4146474003791809,
-0.20299719274044037,
-0.4537810981273651,
0.25904184579849243,
-0.020647956058382988,
0.42575231194496155,
-0.21625834703445435,
-0.1578315645456314,
0.060960959643125534,
-0.083546943962574,
0.4328412115573883,
0.10417173057794571,
-0.305409699678421,
-0.23694609105587006,
0.20384593307971954,
-0.12762930989265442,
-0.0516701377928257,
0.976674497127533,
-0.7727395296096802,
0.7807037830352783,
0.3599150776863098,
0.5587697625160217,
0.4159657061100006,
0.08117764443159103,
0.43395471572875977,
-1.003115177154541,
0.266689658164978,
0.5418378114700317,
0.11606217920780182,
0.054208189249038696,
-0.597132682800293,
0.6839096546173096,
0.14366328716278076,
-0.4261735677719116,
-0.7929726243019104,
0.30725234746932983,
-0.7318119406700134,
-0.35000789165496826,
0.8402926325798035,
-0.7460405826568604,
-0.02930251881480217,
-0.413174033164978,
-0.30589810013771057,
0.3713729679584503,
-0.2885829508304596,
0.7029274702072144,
0.479610413312912,
-0.15633338689804077,
-0.10265131294727325,
-0.726773202419281,
0.41012194752693176,
0.10784019529819489,
-0.8587080240249634,
0.024638207629323006,
0.40946903824806213,
0.1399560570716858,
0.20937016606330872,
0.6580345034599304,
0.10327659547328949,
0.41253748536109924,
0.050515592098236084,
0.12487246096134186,
-0.369035542011261,
-0.5836023688316345,
0.03976544737815857,
-0.010604122653603554,
0.43825286626815796,
-0.19316591322422028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08209v1
|
Who's in and who's out? A case study of multimodal CLIP-filtering in DataComp
| 2024-05-13T21:53:06 | 2024-05-13T21:53:06 |
Rachel Hong, William Agnew, Tadayoshi Kohno, Jamie Morgenstern
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
As training datasets become increasingly drawn from unstructured,
uncontrolled environments such as the web, researchers and industry
practitioners have increasingly relied upon data filtering techniques to
"filter out the noise" of web-scraped data. While datasets have been widely
shown to reflect the biases and values of their creators, in this paper we
contribute to an emerging body of research that assesses the filters used to
create these datasets. We show that image-text data filtering also has biases
and is value-laden, encoding specific notions of what is counted as
"high-quality" data. In our work, we audit a standard approach of image-text
CLIP-filtering on the academic benchmark DataComp's CommonPool by analyzing
discrepancies of filtering through various annotation techniques across
multiple modalities of image, text, and website source. We find that data
relating to several imputed demographic groups -- such as LGBTQ+ people, older
women, and younger men -- are associated with higher rates of exclusion.
Moreover, we demonstrate cases of exclusion amplification: not only are certain
marginalized groups already underrepresented in the unfiltered data, but
CLIP-filtering excludes data from these groups at higher rates. The
data-filtering step in the machine learning pipeline can therefore exacerbate
representation disparities already present in the data-gathering step,
especially when existing filters are designed to optimize a specifically-chosen
downstream performance metric like zero-shot image classification accuracy.
Finally, we show that the NSFW filter fails to remove sexually-explicit content
from CommonPool, and that CLIP-filtering includes several categories of
copyrighted content at high rates. Our conclusions point to a need for
fundamental changes in dataset creation and filtering practices.
|
[
-0.9009526371955872,
-0.378013014793396,
0.37917202711105347,
-0.05547880381345749,
-0.39534178376197815,
0.2823391854763031,
0.07671540975570679,
-0.7045027017593384,
0.0058151413686573505,
0.581212043762207,
-0.6965221762657166,
-0.38590988516807556,
-0.8102180361747742,
0.2559019923210144,
-0.6811633110046387,
0.8715226054191589,
-0.02050812356173992,
0.12652234733104706,
-0.669100284576416,
-0.2608965039253235,
-0.4448051452636719,
-0.7078812718391418,
-0.019998589530587196,
-0.4132428467273712,
0.19098545610904694,
0.5507792234420776,
0.8393473625183105,
0.64483642578125,
0.6772341728210449,
0.20339509844779968,
0.08672286570072174,
0.07990559190511703,
-0.5912720561027527,
-0.04132915288209915,
-0.16911783814430237,
-0.31110262870788574,
0.06284566223621368,
0.3206125497817993,
0.5146270990371704,
0.7748687863349915,
0.28677240014076233,
0.09820715337991714,
0.1962909996509552,
0.8001621961593628,
-1.0032821893692017,
-0.16789089143276215,
-0.6990920305252075,
0.3360818326473236,
-0.5148133039474487,
-0.20619900524616241,
-0.1933554708957672,
-0.23825900256633759,
0.021309826523065567,
-0.47889629006385803,
0.5676892399787903,
-0.021928586065769196,
0.6838854551315308,
0.3776230812072754,
-0.4912480115890503,
-0.17774081230163574,
-0.5742020606994629,
1.041407823562622,
-0.3058531880378723,
0.3922446668148041,
0.7751039266586304,
0.11940217763185501,
-0.29052671790122986,
-0.640561044216156,
-0.4901161193847656,
0.41790372133255005,
0.021423235535621643,
0.16614402830600739,
-0.46296367049217224,
-0.20869004726409912,
0.3770970106124878,
0.23721911013126373,
-0.2809007167816162,
0.2100932002067566,
-0.7374374270439148,
-0.027505924925208092,
0.6507381200790405,
-0.17355698347091675,
0.23017631471157074,
-0.12681663036346436,
-0.4903598427772522,
0.0032720675226300955,
-0.6638572812080383,
0.09883534908294678,
0.6326345205307007,
0.14112740755081177,
0.2848125100135803,
0.553928017616272,
0.060924042016267776,
0.32057061791419983,
-0.1081261932849884,
0.04254184663295746,
0.16601257026195526,
-0.1963580697774887,
-0.0815821960568428,
0.0330040268599987,
0.6070029139518738,
0.7875968813896179,
0.3842915892601013,
-0.014966476708650589,
-0.07108824700117111,
-0.026271356269717216,
0.14508552849292755,
-0.8663274645805359,
-0.23512311279773712,
-0.009391958825290203,
-0.8289187550544739,
-0.21963557600975037,
0.4552844166755676,
-1.1349081993103027,
-0.6220799088478088,
-0.19268125295639038,
0.323800653219223,
-0.13114166259765625,
-0.21858803927898407,
0.006541594862937927,
-0.6758806705474854,
-0.13215436041355133,
0.18221330642700195,
-0.5903905034065247,
0.6003878712654114,
0.3631901144981384,
0.7865625023841858,
-0.4700416028499603,
-0.194442018866539,
-0.6137067079544067,
-0.037393730133771896,
-0.03633954003453255,
0.837845504283905,
-0.7524187564849854,
-0.4021163284778595,
0.19219382107257843,
0.06392189860343933,
0.1894742101430893,
-0.7442699074745178,
0.4525247812271118,
-0.5349472761154175,
0.1868630200624466,
-0.4446442425251007,
-0.7372104525566101,
-0.29940205812454224,
-0.11407966166734695,
-0.9598683714866638,
0.9833524823188782,
0.08128556609153748,
-0.8062924146652222,
0.7601622939109802,
-0.7325263023376465,
-0.04309490695595741,
0.12432398647069931,
-0.2294134795665741,
-0.41064709424972534,
-0.11056757718324661,
0.6506686210632324,
0.3148503303527832,
-0.336194783449173,
-0.04362891614437103,
-0.7742099165916443,
-0.6372756958007812,
0.6845629215240479,
-0.3892219662666321,
0.6842159032821655,
0.06775274872779846,
-0.07456548511981964,
-0.22093351185321808,
-0.6616487503051758,
0.07567548006772995,
-0.10889055579900742,
0.03613102436065674,
-0.3840281069278717,
0.16209940612316132,
0.35047194361686707,
0.40773022174835205,
-0.3244452476501465,
-0.617876410484314,
-0.2508764863014221,
0.39173653721809387,
0.7652371525764465,
0.802981436252594,
0.41484883427619934,
0.2903009355068207,
-0.49668750166893005,
0.5440404415130615,
0.05777839943766594,
0.4574713110923767,
-0.1727551966905594,
-0.5817450284957886,
-0.2057131975889206,
-0.5622974038124084,
0.14791056513786316,
0.04772215709090233,
-0.6210688948631287,
0.14190326631069183,
0.23222903907299042,
-0.341066837310791,
-0.20390041172504425,
0.22956255078315735,
0.09403549134731293,
0.35337933897972107,
0.48766785860061646,
-0.7869312763214111,
-0.48342981934547424,
-0.8327133059501648,
-0.33607232570648193,
-0.059825267642736435,
-0.025726335123181343,
0.2551676630973816,
0.6236159801483154,
-0.14912532269954681,
1.3497284650802612,
-0.5449904799461365,
-0.4923619031906128,
0.057790905237197876,
0.06738963723182678,
0.27393075823783875,
0.4883778393268585,
0.49423912167549133,
-1.0647740364074707,
-0.21879681944847107,
-0.5989813804626465,
-0.6779739856719971,
-0.2541145384311676,
0.08962415158748627,
-0.19738034904003143,
-0.21027985215187073,
0.5386049151420593,
-0.22323140501976013,
0.7285110950469971,
0.4779946208000183,
-0.16391389071941376,
0.4610494077205658,
-0.05911177024245262,
0.26566874980926514,
-0.445131778717041,
-0.0009658907074481249,
0.3321888744831085,
-0.33534419536590576,
-0.34872111678123474,
-0.3605569303035736,
-0.03557230904698372,
-0.31258103251457214,
-0.4826158881187439,
0.0802883505821228,
-0.579130232334137,
-0.1850036084651947,
-0.30250629782676697,
0.24473227560520172,
0.4031706154346466,
0.3768579363822937,
-0.08055643737316132,
0.7093085646629333,
0.542681872844696,
-0.6904622316360474,
0.3740014135837555,
0.4293140172958374,
-0.5548776984214783,
0.8592405915260315,
-0.42286109924316406,
0.251547634601593,
-0.26350587606430054,
0.49126189947128296,
-0.8319048285484314,
-0.46260184049606323,
0.17772340774536133,
-0.21352064609527588,
-0.12683096528053284,
-0.6503725647926331,
-0.4355635643005371,
-0.38343119621276855,
-0.633330225944519,
0.5735199451446533,
0.36778077483177185,
-0.7691614031791687,
0.057371389120817184,
0.9013577103614807,
0.14529716968536377,
-0.599459707736969,
-0.6888696551322937,
0.006199200171977282,
-0.3546847701072693,
-0.5454652309417725,
0.4625391662120819,
0.014348987489938736,
-0.1693839132785797,
0.17358508706092834,
-0.060027845203876495,
-0.8975924849510193,
-0.02380588836967945,
0.4965631067752838,
0.20944945514202118,
0.28738948702812195,
0.2954214811325073,
0.04346345365047455,
0.3257332742214203,
0.16725939512252808,
0.028960660099983215,
0.3123047649860382,
0.33473384380340576,
-0.8406839966773987,
-0.3688719570636749,
0.8301723003387451,
0.6178885102272034,
-0.1841324269771576,
0.2711504101753235,
0.5779245495796204,
-0.2919907569885254,
-0.07733429223299026,
-0.43489325046539307,
-0.37635213136672974,
-0.40507927536964417,
0.40462374687194824,
0.19566887617111206,
-0.6578609943389893,
0.49417397379875183,
-0.11193644255399704,
0.10650866478681564,
0.2662646174430847,
0.09671562910079956,
-0.39991384744644165,
0.9084465503692627,
0.6133282780647278,
0.17311394214630127,
0.793765664100647,
-0.22545523941516876,
0.0796278864145279,
-0.6983762979507446,
-0.1053415983915329,
-0.5194032192230225,
-0.482107549905777,
-0.7606624364852905,
-0.1874881535768509,
0.511395275592804,
0.08522506803274155,
0.028011003509163857,
0.1891193687915802,
-0.5514450073242188,
0.6919576525688171,
0.8205357789993286,
0.5173787474632263,
0.39872676134109497,
-0.03700733557343483,
0.38108861446380615,
-0.38456764817237854,
-0.6752074956893921,
-0.28929629921913147,
1.364936113357544,
0.27109506726264954,
0.9043430685997009,
-0.11525096744298935,
0.3563457131385803,
0.795313835144043,
0.010431062430143356,
-0.5059365034103394,
0.33418792486190796,
-0.379300594329834,
-0.8492552042007446,
-0.039786532521247864,
-0.043410975486040115,
-0.8283722996711731,
0.4140594005584717,
-0.3967192769050598,
-0.5655246376991272,
0.8379451632499695,
0.04120859131217003,
0.04480557143688202,
0.5575436949729919,
-0.5832443237304688,
0.7473462820053101,
0.0744086280465126,
-0.40570223331451416,
-0.29744988679885864,
-0.4959831237792969,
0.4407998323440552,
-0.27847200632095337,
0.3996570110321045,
-0.575535237789154,
0.16810642182826996,
0.9176431894302368,
-0.48260697722435,
0.9216315746307373,
-0.32165101170539856,
0.4328475296497345,
0.46137985587120056,
-0.260919988155365,
0.21682322025299072,
-0.01279726903885603,
0.15458352863788605,
0.5395470261573792,
0.18552657961845398,
-0.2797732651233673,
-0.38197675347328186,
0.30254849791526794,
-0.7101221084594727,
-0.13161812722682953,
-0.37778064608573914,
-0.28562667965888977,
-0.10754703730344772,
0.03216702118515968,
0.46552565693855286,
0.7418912053108215,
-0.004585592076182365,
0.3963010013103485,
0.39307916164398193,
-0.08050704002380371,
0.6299148797988892,
0.12890079617500305,
-0.11013344675302505,
-0.6603183150291443,
0.7167418599128723,
0.36517447233200073,
0.00774438725784421,
-0.07900159806013107,
0.01452775951474905,
-0.438130646944046,
-0.26424047350883484,
-0.5823314189910889,
0.07071629166603088,
-0.9401054978370667,
-0.21803277730941772,
-0.27759915590286255,
-0.11594987660646439,
-0.33036676049232483,
-0.11070085316896439,
-0.17215695977210999,
-0.27678748965263367,
-0.4473596215248108,
0.27792981266975403,
0.29360076785087585,
0.6028308868408203,
-0.21067160367965698,
0.2595738172531128,
-0.7837454080581665,
0.20014958083629608,
0.37274453043937683,
0.3434244692325592,
-0.3965725302696228,
-0.3379181921482086,
-0.2775973975658417,
-0.24531477689743042,
-0.4921019673347473,
-0.8901436924934387,
0.175818532705307,
0.34734949469566345,
0.6205325126647949,
0.40929970145225525,
0.34514468908309937,
0.7067628502845764,
-0.2339964061975479,
0.8437655568122864,
0.22776593267917633,
-1.0631370544433594,
0.3125607967376709,
0.035798802971839905,
0.0889202281832695,
0.6454718708992004,
0.4134213328361511,
-0.8092959523200989,
-0.3900842070579529,
-0.4258110225200653,
-0.8866462707519531,
0.7384708523750305,
0.2566450238227844,
0.07855849713087082,
0.1598922610282898,
0.15173667669296265,
0.46779635548591614,
0.4897666573524475,
-0.5481986999511719,
-0.11902546882629395,
-0.34553706645965576,
0.15169581770896912,
0.4246411919593811,
-0.3418755531311035,
-0.06899384409189224,
-0.14170955121517181,
0.48842117190361023,
-0.16827990114688873,
0.1629677265882492,
0.27048665285110474,
-0.26850321888923645,
-0.2534826397895813,
0.07675382494926453,
0.1737438291311264,
0.9093199968338013,
-0.21243806183338165,
0.021226506680250168,
-0.21027743816375732,
-0.7452741265296936,
0.03112119808793068,
-0.15231288969516754,
-0.1788381189107895,
0.28391072154045105,
0.41476619243621826,
0.5963671207427979,
0.1841588020324707,
-0.727016270160675,
0.7855265736579895,
-0.18384434282779694,
-0.13808217644691467,
-0.31722572445869446,
0.06411714106798172,
-0.78946453332901,
0.048273637890815735,
0.5628897547721863,
0.3258979022502899,
0.3250020146369934,
-0.509748637676239,
0.39406317472457886,
0.38383734226226807,
-0.5213253498077393,
-0.2350902110338211,
0.5589964389801025,
0.277744323015213,
0.16028077900409698,
0.757599413394928,
0.38214603066444397,
-0.36935603618621826,
0.4972098469734192,
0.34704476594924927,
0.7130622863769531,
0.2440544217824936,
0.288717657327652,
0.2552873492240906,
0.08678310364484787,
0.003408577525988221,
-0.035912830382585526,
-0.14881645143032074,
-0.8127717971801758,
-0.46149781346321106,
-0.10666417330503464,
-0.8088686466217041,
0.09423230588436127,
-1.0270084142684937,
0.4005405008792877,
-0.2884749472141266,
-0.5057665705680847,
0.14633874595165253,
-0.20239292085170746,
-0.7314643263816833,
0.16051028668880463,
0.052719540894031525,
0.6451438665390015,
-1.152789831161499,
0.42589324712753296,
0.5520061254501343,
-0.24156223237514496,
-0.11776422709226608,
0.1256442815065384,
0.1929941177368164,
-0.48998257517814636,
0.5055899024009705,
0.23403292894363403,
0.026318036019802094,
-0.2536785900592804,
-0.8996884822845459,
-0.9385730624198914,
0.6326547265052795,
0.4649745523929596,
-0.021205008029937744,
0.20214803516864777,
0.08260665833950043,
0.12082892656326294,
-0.2996540367603302,
0.32357531785964966,
0.5833581686019897,
0.35823845863342285,
0.08503220975399017,
-0.5588847994804382,
-0.30860236287117004,
-0.134591743350029,
-0.02047630585730076,
0.20831723511219025,
-0.594804584980011,
1.0718343257904053,
0.16520151495933533,
-0.3453163206577301,
-0.47201576828956604,
0.29779350757598877,
0.05748157575726509,
0.45278504490852356,
0.6591689586639404,
0.23160573840141296,
0.7753854393959045,
-0.01977774314582348,
0.6940523982048035,
0.19662748277187347,
0.2540454864501953,
0.9236325025558472,
-0.3074430823326111,
0.5429235696792603,
0.632748007774353,
-0.261442095041275,
0.3724167048931122,
0.6570630669593811,
-0.42282912135124207,
0.6591165065765381,
-0.045114658772945404,
-0.1332208663225174,
-0.3248186707496643,
-0.43402525782585144,
-0.12119760364294052,
0.6628037691116333,
0.09697775542736053,
-0.40592682361602783,
-0.4354252815246582,
0.18079394102096558,
-0.03559587150812149,
0.15512579679489136,
-0.21872203052043915,
0.6169572472572327,
-0.10778386890888214,
-0.3736203610897064,
0.09704577177762985,
-0.11322473734617233,
0.47404932975769043,
-0.22233964502811432,
-0.07855624705553055,
-0.2726929187774658,
0.08217868953943253,
-0.3950783312320709,
-1.181495189666748,
0.17928196489810944,
0.2382756918668747,
-0.4480726420879364,
-0.27573034167289734,
0.8109498023986816,
-0.3793189227581024,
-0.13448554277420044,
0.24990200996398926,
0.3861817419528961,
0.6352891325950623,
-0.4865480959415436,
-0.5876466035842896,
0.24775446951389313,
-0.12072937190532684,
0.21955524384975433,
0.43963178992271423,
0.19782939553260803,
-0.24768289923667908,
0.5078091025352478,
0.8197786211967468,
0.0364224836230278,
0.09790681302547455,
0.12177278846502304,
0.9685739874839783,
-0.4707915782928467,
-0.45426538586616516,
-0.9251106381416321,
0.22282148897647858,
-0.43348705768585205,
-0.5760083794593811,
0.6967233419418335,
0.5720751881599426,
1.0052170753479004,
-0.01680111140012741,
0.7828452587127686,
0.09770897775888443,
0.37660932540893555,
-0.33467215299606323,
0.6491221785545349,
-0.37530389428138733,
-0.24634884297847748,
-0.525387704372406,
-1.0287340879440308,
-0.22193998098373413,
0.3201153576374054,
0.09060120582580566,
-0.048108793795108795,
0.5755982398986816,
0.49084633588790894,
-0.10213591158390045,
0.28098833560943604,
0.38332399725914,
-0.27006569504737854,
0.6281716823577881,
0.2763429284095764,
0.8118398785591125,
-0.4623548984527588,
0.6445369720458984,
-0.5318958759307861,
-0.1868886798620224,
-0.18945027887821198,
-0.9995826482772827,
-0.8359422087669373,
-0.7060711979866028,
-0.5109082460403442,
-0.08893363177776337,
-0.2943539619445801,
0.8454311490058899,
1.0644863843917847,
-0.7425611019134521,
-0.21126505732536316,
0.15760886669158936,
0.3266369104385376,
-0.3697374165058136,
-0.19137124717235565,
0.11133770644664764,
-0.09278726577758789,
-0.8066533207893372,
0.2102101743221283,
0.252549409866333,
-0.04864479601383209,
-0.4116021394729614,
0.38063502311706543,
0.04673285037279129,
-0.028379730880260468,
0.3179495632648468,
0.19487154483795166,
-0.2951202094554901,
-0.16977739334106445,
-0.3563416600227356,
0.11927217990159988,
0.2808600068092346,
0.914119303226471,
-0.7927592396736145,
0.508063793182373,
0.25718235969543457,
0.3390987813472748,
0.5066720843315125,
0.19015592336654663,
0.24669736623764038,
-0.9327345490455627,
0.12696662545204163,
0.21189476549625397,
0.49243590235710144,
0.4127778112888336,
-0.25183701515197754,
0.5292543172836304,
0.6861490607261658,
-0.7662444710731506,
-1.1228989362716675,
0.12930266559123993,
-0.5801827907562256,
-0.17726729810237885,
0.7582343220710754,
-0.08806706964969635,
-0.3032170832157135,
-0.4909156858921051,
-0.11138074100017548,
0.0117256511002779,
-0.5007674098014832,
0.8155702352523804,
0.8451584577560425,
-0.31486502289772034,
-0.2481127381324768,
-0.6677095293998718,
0.31627464294433594,
-0.14991800487041473,
-0.725157618522644,
0.07590021193027496,
0.7510294914245605,
0.24371854960918427,
-0.18243126571178436,
0.5059217214584351,
-0.16755370795726776,
0.26443782448768616,
-0.18384519219398499,
0.13768704235553741,
-0.05129146948456764,
-0.19266477227210999,
-0.18749310076236725,
0.3421068787574768,
-0.3539050221443176,
-0.6069298982620239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08172v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08172v1
|
CANTONMT: Investigating Back-Translation and Model-Switch Mechanisms for Cantonese-English Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-05-13T20:37:04 | 2024-05-13T20:37:04 |
Kung Yin Hong, Lifeng Han, Riza Batista-Navarro, Goran Nenadic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper investigates the development and evaluation of machine translation
models from Cantonese to English, where we propose a novel approach to tackle
low-resource language translations. The main objectives of the study are to
develop a model that can effectively translate Cantonese to English and
evaluate it against state-of-the-art commercial models. To achieve this, a new
parallel corpus has been created by combining different available corpora
online with preprocessing and cleaning. In addition, a monolingual Cantonese
dataset has been created through web scraping to aid the synthetic parallel
corpus generation. Following the data collection process, several approaches,
including fine-tuning models, back-translation, and model switch, have been
used. The translation quality of models has been evaluated with multiple
quality metrics, including lexicon-based metrics (SacreBLEU and hLEPOR) and
embedding-space metrics (COMET and BERTscore). Based on the automatic metrics,
the best model is selected and compared against the 2 best commercial
translators using the human evaluation framework HOPES. The best model proposed
in this investigation (NLLB-mBART) with model switch mechanisms has reached
comparable and even better automatic evaluation scores against State-of-the-art
commercial models (Bing and Baidu Translators), with a SacreBLEU score of 16.8
on our test set. Furthermore, an open-source web application has been developed
to allow users to translate between Cantonese and English, with the different
trained models available for effective comparisons between models from this
investigation and users. CANTONMT is available at
https://github.com/kenrickkung/CantoneseTranslation
|
[
-0.25622043013572693,
-0.443399041891098,
0.31058549880981445,
0.41167905926704407,
-0.4594247341156006,
-0.16218635439872742,
-0.052980855107307434,
-0.2697913646697998,
-0.13924294710159302,
0.7171368598937988,
-0.17911767959594727,
-0.24747219681739807,
-0.5931658744812012,
0.487527459859848,
-0.5829014182090759,
0.5918523669242859,
-0.3015189468860626,
0.44980791211128235,
0.2872864305973053,
-0.11759809404611588,
-0.3225904405117035,
-0.6300029158592224,
-0.9019123315811157,
-0.3968503773212433,
0.3309573829174042,
0.1307670623064041,
0.8541225790977478,
0.5723493099212646,
0.6659084558486938,
0.20675387978553772,
-0.15704040229320526,
0.19884853065013885,
-0.45031458139419556,
-0.5370153784751892,
-0.1892111748456955,
-0.4373970329761505,
-0.7149450182914734,
0.10608668625354767,
0.5309804081916809,
0.7154620885848999,
-0.029679281637072563,
0.1933683305978775,
0.10788589715957642,
0.4412529766559601,
-0.27521800994873047,
0.014422512613236904,
-0.7649005651473999,
0.09979832172393799,
-0.022667719051241875,
-0.35873445868492126,
-0.6145688891410828,
-0.32860201597213745,
-0.25301840901374817,
-0.21770034730434418,
-0.007897424511611462,
0.1697981208562851,
1.0245596170425415,
0.2989988327026367,
-0.7669728994369507,
-0.049299824982881546,
-0.47550827264785767,
1.121517300605774,
-1.1534134149551392,
0.5904407501220703,
0.3341788947582245,
0.4786612093448639,
0.12354321032762527,
-0.6882579326629639,
-0.22180338203907013,
-0.5689215660095215,
-0.1200786754488945,
0.583703339099884,
-0.0753270760178566,
-0.1469801366329193,
-0.10758893191814423,
0.23363178968429565,
-0.4629972577095032,
0.2908822000026703,
-0.5750419497489929,
-0.025595931336283684,
0.5276566743850708,
0.3932466208934784,
0.38325420022010803,
-0.5394753217697144,
-0.7011612057685852,
-0.07119788974523544,
-0.6254410743713379,
0.04536755383014679,
0.26244866847991943,
0.48486974835395813,
-0.20875555276870728,
0.5827027559280396,
0.13594724237918854,
0.7459191679954529,
-0.006387744098901749,
0.17342416942119598,
0.044902581721544266,
-0.7842768430709839,
-0.3387114107608795,
-0.020731909200549126,
0.903861939907074,
0.5276604294776917,
-0.05226439610123634,
-0.1861436665058136,
-0.5349759459495544,
-0.20848147571086884,
0.17962612211704254,
-0.886546790599823,
0.14162208139896393,
0.19173219799995422,
-1.060206413269043,
-0.36207321286201477,
-0.0034136371687054634,
-0.27636590600013733,
0.06064628064632416,
-0.37736430764198303,
0.332258403301239,
-0.7282761931419373,
-0.34436067938804626,
0.37940868735313416,
-0.028347831219434738,
0.038785818964242935,
0.2815684676170349,
-0.6996653079986572,
0.3917347192764282,
0.6264995336532593,
1.206532597541809,
-0.3166046440601349,
-0.6359679102897644,
-0.3728407621383667,
0.09664741903543472,
-0.4931032359600067,
0.41121789813041687,
-0.10204508900642395,
-0.16648419201374054,
-0.11830595135688782,
0.30236002802848816,
-0.42670437693595886,
-0.8377168774604797,
0.5063533782958984,
-0.46931490302085876,
0.08032499253749847,
0.1836107075214386,
-0.40335363149642944,
-0.5378365516662598,
0.3840596377849579,
-0.839824914932251,
0.7797669768333435,
0.14488746225833893,
-0.6161353588104248,
-0.19470913708209991,
-0.5066726803779602,
-0.46306392550468445,
-0.01997651346027851,
0.29120373725891113,
-0.10287637263536453,
0.18471269309520721,
0.1610536128282547,
0.2993909418582916,
-0.6794253587722778,
0.19396020472049713,
0.17528367042541504,
-0.44824475049972534,
0.3631349802017212,
-0.577073872089386,
1.251818060874939,
0.32299280166625977,
-0.20984862744808197,
0.1780713051557541,
-0.5700540542602539,
-0.2080274224281311,
0.023197541013360023,
-0.3706158697605133,
-0.4176124334335327,
-0.08405061066150665,
0.2566080689430237,
0.6569184064865112,
0.3953832685947418,
-0.3225308358669281,
-0.05680907517671585,
-0.5132536888122559,
0.8053004145622253,
0.4291588068008423,
-0.26788559556007385,
0.36505579948425293,
-0.3514714241027832,
0.7020130753517151,
0.334360271692276,
0.32525232434272766,
-0.03342676907777786,
-0.6553525328636169,
-0.40985020995140076,
-0.011068237945437431,
0.5235540866851807,
0.7643242478370667,
-0.6342793703079224,
0.3500812351703644,
0.02352854050695896,
-0.4291796088218689,
-1.2304375171661377,
-0.017184512689709663,
0.3180471956729889,
0.587160050868988,
0.5916971564292908,
-0.5507064461708069,
-0.3153722882270813,
-0.9269335865974426,
-0.009026344865560532,
-0.23075087368488312,
0.01329532265663147,
0.3614255487918854,
0.2622469961643219,
-0.548912763595581,
0.5625753998756409,
0.11876294016838074,
-0.1076851338148117,
-0.39502713084220886,
0.3865353465080261,
0.3421401083469391,
0.42055827379226685,
0.6871393322944641,
-0.8439246416091919,
-0.4461601674556732,
0.4936525225639343,
-0.6320347189903259,
-0.37003570795059204,
-0.4459362030029297,
-0.2343043088912964,
0.40224477648735046,
0.6872544288635254,
-0.40732553601264954,
0.21783971786499023,
0.9601771235466003,
0.13835018873214722,
0.7706373929977417,
-0.14475017786026,
0.4919813871383667,
-1.2246664762496948,
0.2403974086046219,
-0.25789952278137207,
-0.3018154799938202,
-0.41730350255966187,
0.4679776132106781,
0.339206337928772,
-0.092556893825531,
-1.028934359550476,
0.6762728095054626,
-0.3369792699813843,
-0.10959292948246002,
-0.29778388142585754,
0.2848275601863861,
-0.050543662160634995,
0.19305483996868134,
-0.12456953525543213,
0.7275431752204895,
-0.008237028494477272,
-0.5191097855567932,
0.40798482298851013,
0.2493962049484253,
-0.1924002468585968,
0.1286747008562088,
-0.6001577377319336,
0.11406753212213516,
0.48591700196266174,
-0.09748975932598114,
-0.955162763595581,
0.25294923782348633,
0.4108105003833771,
-0.4285605549812317,
-0.1452171951532364,
-0.3388608694076538,
-0.5454441905021667,
-0.1997351348400116,
0.0547054223716259,
0.30300310254096985,
0.5037933588027954,
-0.5288392305374146,
0.40868663787841797,
0.03775417059659958,
-0.15775813162326813,
-0.1151590421795845,
-0.7877052426338196,
0.5395798683166504,
-0.09066527336835861,
-0.8163082003593445,
0.4278181791305542,
0.0006147416424937546,
-0.24222417175769806,
0.10646054148674011,
0.23835434019565582,
-0.2882789075374603,
0.14647497236728668,
-0.25201526284217834,
0.32220369577407837,
-0.3249039351940155,
-0.26303619146347046,
0.2833707928657532,
-0.13225680589675903,
0.08751054853200912,
-0.3261566162109375,
0.658647894859314,
-0.1769721657037735,
-0.09913729131221771,
-0.512308657169342,
0.23862411081790924,
0.48232147097587585,
-0.39201417565345764,
0.7826652526855469,
0.818229615688324,
-0.24807123839855194,
-0.06386730074882507,
-0.20341713726520538,
-0.25852668285369873,
-0.42560476064682007,
0.6176052093505859,
-0.5988321900367737,
-0.5838246941566467,
0.5550515055656433,
-0.374629944562912,
0.023310374468564987,
0.2301279902458191,
0.8804261684417725,
0.20790909230709076,
1.4371252059936523,
0.4603443741798401,
0.06484582275152206,
0.10157377272844315,
-0.047268301248550415,
0.3176383674144745,
-0.756406307220459,
0.30378207564353943,
-0.34752440452575684,
-0.28277695178985596,
-0.6201998591423035,
-0.5098291635513306,
0.0576712004840374,
0.452406644821167,
-0.026140015572309494,
0.8221015334129333,
-0.31082478165626526,
-0.09288627654314041,
0.6226854920387268,
-0.0533057264983654,
0.4154687821865082,
-0.34268850088119507,
-0.336097776889801,
-0.1251339167356491,
-0.7543267607688904,
-0.7270589470863342,
0.8493505716323853,
0.18545623123645782,
0.6199347972869873,
0.07092460244894028,
0.5985435247421265,
-0.028331777080893517,
0.162927508354187,
-0.9743253588676453,
0.7513511180877686,
-0.6792197227478027,
-0.29632818698883057,
-0.14154215157032013,
-0.8555298447608948,
-0.9588672518730164,
0.4057442545890808,
0.21213199198246002,
0.00990050844848156,
-0.14628882706165314,
0.03947434574365616,
-0.22243887186050415,
0.382278710603714,
-0.807676374912262,
1.0496758222579956,
-0.8245813846588135,
-0.3504885137081146,
-0.30407458543777466,
-0.5530152320861816,
0.54718017578125,
-0.27871519327163696,
0.14826257526874542,
0.03693448379635811,
-0.11567261070013046,
0.35215312242507935,
-0.2924920320510864,
0.7189469933509827,
0.17378966510295868,
-0.24020017683506012,
-0.0384281650185585,
0.36188584566116333,
0.20168261229991913,
-0.14272601902484894,
-0.29214712977409363,
0.7508147954940796,
0.21010981500148773,
-0.3041113018989563,
-0.4722069203853607,
0.316419780254364,
-0.7279342412948608,
-0.5007191896438599,
-0.1707836538553238,
-0.7983128428459167,
0.192052960395813,
0.5255914330482483,
0.30644071102142334,
-0.031173093244433403,
-0.10123356431722641,
0.04753967002034187,
-0.0892292931675911,
-0.5281043648719788,
0.14335006475448608,
0.768864631652832,
-0.4914572238922119,
-0.338099867105484,
0.7921526432037354,
0.09024099260568619,
0.545596182346344,
0.43399351835250854,
0.4348877966403961,
-0.045226410031318665,
-0.5486896634101868,
-0.6054607629776001,
0.27772200107574463,
-0.3779958486557007,
0.10433220118284225,
-0.34244483709335327,
-0.47445225715637207,
-0.8303790092468262,
-0.21314863860607147,
-0.5598982572555542,
-0.44669073820114136,
-0.2081744223833084,
0.18944992125034332,
-0.1552162766456604,
0.5030739903450012,
-0.20532861351966858,
0.19517649710178375,
-1.1354870796203613,
0.21899326145648956,
-0.012158366851508617,
-0.24893970787525177,
0.12093587964773178,
-0.8292519450187683,
-0.5528265833854675,
0.13190022110939026,
-0.24739207327365875,
-0.8063356280326843,
1.0104137659072876,
-0.28763481974601746,
0.2561045289039612,
0.2698061764240265,
-0.20965738594532013,
0.5393898487091064,
-0.8478718400001526,
0.6681774258613586,
0.13008271157741547,
-0.9467129111289978,
0.29406243562698364,
-0.34286943078041077,
0.20179514586925507,
0.32945916056632996,
0.48267862200737,
-0.9197880625724792,
-0.30614975094795227,
-0.20739200711250305,
-0.9555969834327698,
0.6997232437133789,
0.16676749289035797,
-0.15185020864009857,
0.014787398278713226,
0.23167359828948975,
0.20222778618335724,
0.24212218821048737,
-0.4739498496055603,
0.18213336169719696,
-0.4436534643173218,
-0.02486959472298622,
-0.03549913316965103,
0.08815719932317734,
0.06835254281759262,
-0.23051418364048004,
0.7034450769424438,
-0.0454789362847805,
-0.015353233553469181,
-0.052564408630132675,
-0.16401611268520355,
-0.00680067203938961,
0.16895689070224762,
0.5719059705734253,
0.6731526255607605,
-0.5256858468055725,
-0.0007932952139526606,
-0.11496909707784653,
-0.2759655714035034,
-0.03618297725915909,
0.18584612011909485,
-0.5963523387908936,
0.3135272264480591,
0.1866874098777771,
0.7956138253211975,
0.35080578923225403,
-0.5633484125137329,
0.27332010865211487,
0.04540184140205383,
-0.11120488494634628,
-0.2405078411102295,
-0.3604651093482971,
0.3048085868358612,
0.02749856933951378,
-0.026995839551091194,
0.2700217366218567,
0.21692173182964325,
-0.4874715507030487,
0.17415036261081696,
0.05727184936404228,
-0.4066160321235657,
-0.6214311718940735,
0.9094935655593872,
0.37754592299461365,
-0.4531523585319519,
0.7262904047966003,
-0.30914565920829773,
-0.6065158843994141,
0.6877933144569397,
0.7572396397590637,
0.9697856307029724,
-0.459504634141922,
0.29274728894233704,
0.5035420656204224,
0.8306337594985962,
-0.3884258270263672,
0.0567028746008873,
0.4441176652908325,
-0.7474673986434937,
-0.44889259338378906,
-0.3483361303806305,
-0.6277968287467957,
0.1244473084807396,
-0.8512750267982483,
0.4191310703754425,
-0.02412344142794609,
-0.2804177701473236,
-0.45725807547569275,
-0.41242465376853943,
-0.3551773130893707,
-0.12390100210905075,
-0.0776212140917778,
1.1003801822662354,
-0.6402187347412109,
1.069651484489441,
0.7880492806434631,
-0.688216507434845,
-0.6907997131347656,
-0.03564811497926712,
-0.005028444342315197,
-0.8892657160758972,
1.0268810987472534,
0.07349693775177002,
-0.21471399068832397,
0.31249383091926575,
-0.32161664962768555,
-0.5433884859085083,
0.8860129117965698,
0.5472269654273987,
-0.6448094844818115,
-0.24874639511108398,
0.34330788254737854,
0.38976794481277466,
-0.05133010819554329,
0.261814683675766,
0.6425696611404419,
0.46666309237480164,
-0.2573454976081848,
-1.1017014980316162,
-0.09326516836881638,
-0.2778666913509369,
0.06993673741817474,
0.01831897348165512,
-0.8971849083900452,
1.2780362367630005,
0.24143707752227783,
-0.15895061194896698,
0.46355894207954407,
0.2295418232679367,
0.26224401593208313,
0.0377214252948761,
0.3546949326992035,
0.48181113600730896,
0.3090374171733856,
0.12863025069236755,
1.0562273263931274,
-0.6664562821388245,
0.3810584247112274,
1.0215684175491333,
-0.6175028085708618,
1.0737102031707764,
0.6353955864906311,
0.10608027130365372,
0.04166493937373161,
0.5321187973022461,
-0.07945816218852997,
0.5203543901443481,
0.15291982889175415,
0.11597346514463425,
-0.3017319440841675,
-0.21509823203086853,
-0.12190776318311691,
0.2978356182575226,
-0.014793550595641136,
-0.3269078731536865,
-0.18815259635448456,
0.08267101645469666,
0.013180972076952457,
0.12366310507059097,
-0.3349975049495697,
0.37114813923835754,
0.5137494206428528,
-0.6739770770072937,
0.9035980105400085,
0.5530969500541687,
0.7870275378227234,
-0.5569598078727722,
-0.03140844404697418,
-0.5862262845039368,
0.39058980345726013,
-0.0022671050392091274,
-0.3784032166004181,
0.2985309958457947,
-0.012846414931118488,
0.0877012088894844,
-0.5818992853164673,
0.45895642042160034,
-0.50048828125,
-0.6598846912384033,
0.8393621444702148,
0.560160219669342,
0.36039310693740845,
0.10478854924440384,
-1.0363320112228394,
-0.1147552877664566,
-0.058997612446546555,
0.03536541014909744,
0.31592971086502075,
0.5053486227989197,
-0.1308317631483078,
0.318905234336853,
0.5610271692276001,
0.5601313710212708,
0.2746536433696747,
0.4409005641937256,
0.22529169917106628,
-0.7402437329292297,
-0.49303126335144043,
-0.6722116470336914,
0.17739829421043396,
0.1450498104095459,
-0.32371920347213745,
1.0555213689804077,
0.674741268157959,
1.135898470878601,
-0.24572789669036865,
0.7172995805740356,
0.29342401027679443,
0.44680070877075195,
-0.6729136109352112,
1.0583982467651367,
-0.650307834148407,
0.04289006069302559,
-0.11539192497730255,
-0.6847978830337524,
-0.1548251360654831,
0.4489040672779083,
-0.10433372110128403,
-0.20949028432369232,
0.8373075723648071,
0.8565335273742676,
-0.2948441207408905,
-0.27759525179862976,
0.5661352276802063,
0.5384369492530823,
0.35952648520469666,
0.8916069269180298,
0.8475387692451477,
-0.7206035852432251,
0.6922245025634766,
-0.239928737282753,
-0.25031769275665283,
-0.34434935450553894,
-0.7063050270080566,
-0.845641553401947,
-0.38045889139175415,
-0.168639674782753,
-0.2332683950662613,
0.12869177758693695,
0.6925926804542542,
0.5500480532646179,
-0.8041588068008423,
-0.9369072318077087,
0.04192584380507469,
-0.2823416292667389,
-0.7984073758125305,
-0.22862476110458374,
0.3597882091999054,
-0.4580311179161072,
-0.9879317283630371,
0.7186364531517029,
0.31460097432136536,
-0.0868297666311264,
-0.20448189973831177,
-0.2850935161113739,
-0.35678866505622864,
0.18993061780929565,
0.7074896097183228,
-0.007282854989171028,
-0.7835689783096313,
0.06058696284890175,
0.29978078603744507,
-0.5034223198890686,
-0.015258458442986012,
0.7027024626731873,
-0.34511467814445496,
0.2479548305273056,
0.6117111444473267,
0.9935052990913391,
0.21268895268440247,
0.13112685084342957,
0.7411338686943054,
-0.3287361264228821,
0.2974506914615631,
0.21087650954723358,
0.37873005867004395,
0.34297433495521545,
-0.06857190281152725,
0.6405842304229736,
0.22546203434467316,
-0.43913397192955017,
-0.8009732961654663,
0.16472700238227844,
-0.7936107516288757,
-0.40598249435424805,
1.1249570846557617,
-0.07842756807804108,
-0.3863920569419861,
-0.0038682054728269577,
-0.3354290723800659,
0.365102082490921,
-0.08320529013872147,
0.9764808416366577,
0.7615658044815063,
0.06904724985361099,
-0.21914668381214142,
-0.8282541632652283,
0.0391140952706337,
0.7505561113357544,
-0.6648775935173035,
-0.11789990216493607,
0.1756206601858139,
-0.08784528821706772,
0.04520149156451225,
0.4004044234752655,
-0.3199750483036041,
0.3603408932685852,
-0.24930033087730408,
0.19415758550167084,
-0.2405511885881424,
-0.0338715985417366,
-0.5351437330245972,
-0.10655103623867035,
-0.2030726820230484,
-0.14140498638153076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08151v2
|
Benchmarking Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models in Biomedical NLP: Application, Robustness, and Self-Awareness
| 2024-05-13T19:51:20 | 2024-05-16T13:53:26 |
Mingchen Li, Zaifu Zhan, Han Yang, Yongkang Xiao, Jiatan Huang, Rui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLM) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
various biomedical natural language processing (NLP) tasks, leveraging the
demonstration within the input context to adapt to new tasks. However, LLM is
sensitive to the selection of demonstrations. To address the hallucination
issue inherent in LLM, retrieval-augmented LLM (RAL) offers a solution by
retrieving pertinent information from an established database. Nonetheless,
existing research work lacks rigorous evaluation of the impact of
retrieval-augmented large language models on different biomedical NLP tasks.
This deficiency makes it challenging to ascertain the capabilities of RAL
within the biomedical domain. Moreover, the outputs from RAL are affected by
retrieving the unlabeled, counterfactual, or diverse knowledge that is not well
studied in the biomedical domain. However, such knowledge is common in the real
world. Finally, exploring the self-awareness ability is also crucial for the
RAL system. So, in this paper, we systematically investigate the impact of RALs
on 5 different biomedical tasks (triple extraction, link prediction,
classification, question answering, and natural language inference). We analyze
the performance of RALs in four fundamental abilities, including unlabeled
robustness, counterfactual robustness, diverse robustness, and negative
awareness. To this end, we proposed an evaluation framework to assess the RALs'
performance on different biomedical NLP tasks and establish four different
testbeds based on the aforementioned fundamental abilities. Then, we evaluate 3
representative LLMs with 3 different retrievers on 5 tasks over 9 datasets.
|
[
-0.28253522515296936,
-0.8170284032821655,
0.6233744621276855,
0.32161766290664673,
0.09572501480579376,
0.01691906340420246,
-0.2832667827606201,
-0.8481305241584778,
0.25576746463775635,
0.39094123244285583,
-0.13741804659366608,
-0.5148289203643799,
-0.6402048468589783,
0.5660933256149292,
-0.34451740980148315,
0.8881403803825378,
0.21574075520038605,
0.10174131393432617,
-0.3839386999607086,
-0.46145689487457275,
-0.5580810904502869,
-0.5941625237464905,
-0.11069067567586899,
-0.6418139338493347,
0.5356968641281128,
-0.09106326103210449,
0.4735241234302521,
0.5671107769012451,
0.7405796051025391,
0.24604010581970215,
-0.20441435277462006,
-0.030390426516532898,
-0.3594471514225006,
0.4296224117279053,
-0.5627972483634949,
-0.1517193764448166,
-0.512399435043335,
-0.1896917074918747,
0.7915279269218445,
0.8136892318725586,
-0.0037623674143105745,
0.19254785776138306,
0.26592740416526794,
0.601582407951355,
-0.7779296636581421,
0.023604920133948326,
-0.6418716311454773,
-0.0667780339717865,
-0.03765064850449562,
-0.12124617397785187,
-0.3577507436275482,
-0.06552869081497192,
0.2617032825946808,
-0.2417020946741104,
0.09958593547344208,
0.07089860737323761,
0.6301171183586121,
0.41618838906288147,
-0.1856188178062439,
-0.29723668098449707,
-0.5302271246910095,
0.8178313374519348,
-0.7743488550186157,
0.6502017974853516,
0.4966634213924408,
0.18671180307865143,
-0.11314788460731506,
-0.7598475217819214,
-0.21659442782402039,
-0.3694220781326294,
-0.1235545203089714,
0.11883369088172913,
-0.2953937351703644,
0.08054652065038681,
0.39673012495040894,
0.3435662090778351,
-0.7095315456390381,
0.25270894169807434,
-0.17025253176689148,
-0.23751318454742432,
0.49036791920661926,
0.05174801126122475,
0.1736755520105362,
-0.22049932181835175,
-0.2671121656894684,
-0.054537080228328705,
-0.6268541216850281,
-0.27282488346099854,
-0.2398519515991211,
0.28604719042778015,
0.13908714056015015,
0.6799357533454895,
-0.3387625515460968,
0.6431429982185364,
-0.10210026055574417,
-0.08220293372869492,
0.6829777359962463,
-0.4808519184589386,
-0.212103009223938,
-0.1186787560582161,
0.8586230874061584,
-0.014722832478582859,
-0.15834812819957733,
-0.31417950987815857,
-0.22425799071788788,
-0.1420889049768448,
0.43094173073768616,
-0.8094871640205383,
0.10413194447755814,
0.3380548059940338,
-0.5377336144447327,
-0.07181886583566666,
-0.4790852963924408,
-0.9210469126701355,
-0.4719536602497101,
-0.06610152870416641,
0.7608212828636169,
-0.544135570526123,
-0.08696828782558441,
0.28166043758392334,
0.11591494828462601,
0.07156583666801453,
0.12629328668117523,
-0.7477716207504272,
0.3115535080432892,
0.6553106307983398,
0.7329768538475037,
-0.42239752411842346,
-0.24641159176826477,
-0.6386120319366455,
0.10810238867998123,
-0.020527999848127365,
0.6979793310165405,
-0.4669141173362732,
-0.34449252486228943,
-0.16735324263572693,
-0.1609913557767868,
-0.20250169932842255,
-0.8412211537361145,
0.6097093224525452,
-0.46196579933166504,
-0.20196382701396942,
-0.3612189292907715,
-0.6684550046920776,
-0.0663362517952919,
0.36806774139404297,
-0.49464595317840576,
0.8986183404922485,
-0.25714582204818726,
-0.8288465738296509,
0.22416117787361145,
-0.5586079359054565,
-0.5189793109893799,
0.16633620858192444,
-0.4068619906902313,
-0.36399227380752563,
0.10916045308113098,
0.17455752193927765,
0.6130878925323486,
-0.22348131239414215,
0.21514320373535156,
-0.41569459438323975,
-0.2593402564525604,
0.39457011222839355,
-0.21148182451725006,
0.5930328369140625,
0.07719671726226807,
-0.39945247769355774,
0.07896958291530609,
-0.7504894733428955,
0.10040977597236633,
-0.15534408390522003,
-0.30090731382369995,
-0.4958108365535736,
-0.027424005791544914,
-0.11075978726148605,
0.11563073098659515,
0.26354891061782837,
-0.508364200592041,
0.02702481485903263,
-0.6222023963928223,
0.14046505093574524,
0.4213293790817261,
0.05825800076127052,
-0.0728134736418724,
-0.2762201428413391,
0.4739244282245636,
-0.30645978450775146,
0.02092502824962139,
0.07572591304779053,
-0.38272225856781006,
-0.25045859813690186,
-0.5225332975387573,
0.2783679664134979,
0.450920432806015,
-0.5013703107833862,
0.495991975069046,
-0.14418473839759827,
-0.38904955983161926,
-0.6758661270141602,
0.2283686399459839,
0.7028249502182007,
0.6302229762077332,
0.7012763619422913,
-0.18943308293819427,
-0.4972958564758301,
-1.0221623182296753,
-0.36183759570121765,
-0.16831833124160767,
-0.07324016839265823,
0.45733529329299927,
0.6870529651641846,
-0.5852524042129517,
0.6667072772979736,
-0.2886001765727997,
-0.330335795879364,
-0.2599448263645172,
0.1587740033864975,
0.2762279510498047,
0.3110799193382263,
0.3802344501018524,
-0.5049285888671875,
-0.12969674170017242,
0.020268145948648453,
-1.0056090354919434,
-0.39152857661247253,
0.07947355508804321,
0.1454876810312271,
0.018475275486707687,
0.44574248790740967,
-0.6134271621704102,
0.41484108567237854,
0.507725715637207,
-0.07772157341241837,
0.7664869427680969,
-0.49861788749694824,
0.1057324931025505,
-0.7399380803108215,
0.4811538755893707,
-0.05147136375308037,
-0.0534370020031929,
-0.5738359093666077,
0.08077596873044968,
0.1975572109222412,
0.30268245935440063,
-0.08039478957653046,
0.7804827094078064,
-0.5252773761749268,
-0.4695420563220978,
-0.37490350008010864,
0.09160052984952927,
0.025305654853582382,
0.0770578384399414,
0.20194879174232483,
0.7394142150878906,
0.4629400074481964,
-0.5586108565330505,
-0.07302558422088623,
0.30140572786331177,
-0.31769463419914246,
0.19603122770786285,
-0.923456609249115,
0.054438017308712006,
-0.030797960236668587,
0.020657656714320183,
-0.7532052397727966,
-0.06155926361680031,
-0.024637386202812195,
-0.40086865425109863,
0.30794498324394226,
0.21547053754329681,
-0.5399017930030823,
-0.36050257086753845,
-0.1783011108636856,
0.5020437836647034,
0.39600539207458496,
-0.39053356647491455,
0.6331131458282471,
0.37722134590148926,
-0.014917110092937946,
-0.8710941672325134,
-0.5375456213951111,
0.07874830812215805,
-0.0687098503112793,
-0.2431303709745407,
0.35244032740592957,
-0.1490645408630371,
-0.2626490592956543,
-0.20258723199367523,
-0.1561078280210495,
0.1699582189321518,
0.17309868335723877,
0.3629789352416992,
0.1871933937072754,
-0.05915062129497528,
0.37404677271842957,
-0.15700778365135193,
-0.04307916387915611,
0.13103017210960388,
0.22549116611480713,
0.4130406975746155,
-0.38468295335769653,
-0.5801323056221008,
-0.31912627816200256,
0.10336390882730484,
0.3910790681838989,
-0.43788769841194153,
0.6422369480133057,
0.610502302646637,
-0.47091996669769287,
0.028000080958008766,
-0.8664120435714722,
-0.35015153884887695,
-0.4088028371334076,
0.6653569936752319,
-0.26719051599502563,
-0.8819589614868164,
0.6009602546691895,
-0.049893397837877274,
-0.0951204001903534,
0.45928576588630676,
0.797855019569397,
0.006287748459726572,
0.8414878845214844,
0.2958485186100006,
0.0011366493999958038,
0.09788823872804642,
-0.0610937736928463,
0.10235239565372467,
-1.0553909540176392,
-0.2165490984916687,
-0.7600905299186707,
-0.07111760973930359,
-0.38806912302970886,
-0.5203288793563843,
0.5024199485778809,
0.1491427719593048,
-0.05444830283522606,
0.17154711484909058,
-0.37795311212539673,
0.2044881135225296,
0.2955041825771332,
0.2183254063129425,
0.5237142443656921,
-0.13310953974723816,
-0.2962087094783783,
-0.11343900114297867,
-0.5435601472854614,
-0.5373958349227905,
1.2876235246658325,
0.4381204843521118,
0.7673463225364685,
0.02969280257821083,
0.6316856741905212,
0.22054758667945862,
0.42077362537384033,
-0.6078673601150513,
0.5768837928771973,
-0.09751903265714645,
-0.7207698822021484,
-0.14467748999595642,
-0.4703035354614258,
-1.0751562118530273,
0.2806888222694397,
-0.5526761412620544,
-0.8629453778266907,
0.12065229564905167,
0.04672842100262642,
-0.474238783121109,
0.06040128692984581,
-0.4272538423538208,
0.7958929538726807,
-0.3195837438106537,
-0.5480315089225769,
-0.43391919136047363,
-0.6717705130577087,
0.21289175748825073,
-0.27346107363700867,
0.2130047231912613,
-0.08863659203052521,
-0.0666377991437912,
0.5627118945121765,
0.13685806095600128,
0.8135440349578857,
0.12430010735988617,
0.06725919246673584,
-0.12695781886577606,
0.09127042442560196,
0.22086220979690552,
0.06823733448982239,
-0.3775394856929779,
0.3617579936981201,
0.24047231674194336,
-0.1725933998823166,
-0.42892003059387207,
0.753722608089447,
-0.6172540187835693,
-0.6168980598449707,
-0.4824877381324768,
-0.5442137122154236,
-0.5078617334365845,
0.31382957100868225,
0.1051049530506134,
0.42307305335998535,
-0.2859444320201874,
0.3895770013332367,
0.7746155858039856,
-0.6473073363304138,
0.1750364452600479,
0.718869686126709,
-0.49130141735076904,
-0.28938770294189453,
0.6810442209243774,
0.06007040664553642,
0.34398552775382996,
0.37996840476989746,
0.18358564376831055,
-0.4943537712097168,
-0.9757630228996277,
-0.10592188686132431,
0.4756321907043457,
-0.5653837323188782,
-0.2556804120540619,
-1.0654758214950562,
-0.24299068748950958,
-0.4842316210269928,
0.1101594939827919,
-0.42940041422843933,
-0.14311504364013672,
-0.2969784736633301,
0.0675671398639679,
0.24257971346378326,
0.742793619632721,
-0.3445906639099121,
-0.2106834501028061,
-0.7349017858505249,
0.49224159121513367,
0.22275832295417786,
0.46190115809440613,
0.020851584151387215,
-0.5352522134780884,
-0.24509945511817932,
-0.043257489800453186,
-0.10818099975585938,
-0.8138496279716492,
0.4639362096786499,
0.1917867660522461,
0.8568047285079956,
0.25154826045036316,
-0.018052348867058754,
0.44987744092941284,
-0.39282599091529846,
0.35732385516166687,
-0.051246240735054016,
-0.6245275735855103,
0.550073504447937,
-0.1893230378627777,
0.22729326784610748,
0.7065926194190979,
0.374442994594574,
-0.19491642713546753,
-0.31869441270828247,
-0.43912607431411743,
-0.7945346832275391,
0.2357923686504364,
0.22104598581790924,
-0.2707478702068329,
-0.31274721026420593,
0.4979451596736908,
0.1548319160938263,
0.04198244586586952,
-0.602694571018219,
-0.24027517437934875,
0.12097080051898956,
-0.10922688245773315,
-0.06810732930898666,
-0.3841398358345032,
-0.07470258325338364,
-0.2072378695011139,
0.6630863547325134,
-0.03905046358704567,
0.13274399936199188,
0.49048712849617004,
-0.21451880037784576,
0.1980821043252945,
0.35937920212745667,
0.4007260501384735,
0.5751569867134094,
-0.5304493308067322,
0.14902478456497192,
0.34757718443870544,
-0.5735023021697998,
-0.1399890035390854,
0.15493735671043396,
-0.07755009084939957,
-0.11482176929712296,
0.6145871877670288,
0.348335862159729,
0.2147478312253952,
-1.0482587814331055,
0.3756859004497528,
0.03082072176039219,
0.013170341029763222,
-0.023965345695614815,
-0.09154299646615982,
0.12912775576114655,
0.3247229754924774,
0.4178900718688965,
0.04736267775297165,
0.5407496094703674,
-0.38018980622291565,
0.40268221497535706,
0.7219202518463135,
-0.3371865153312683,
-0.2715415954589844,
0.5974405407905579,
-0.1475849598646164,
-0.2136831283569336,
0.30713188648223877,
-0.013659626245498657,
-0.3137372136116028,
0.33921870589256287,
0.7196304798126221,
0.7653030157089233,
-0.24303299188613892,
-0.11526093631982803,
0.5630632638931274,
0.20085275173187256,
-0.10502099245786667,
0.12002085149288177,
0.18986846506595612,
-0.7412634491920471,
-0.6655929684638977,
-0.7401763796806335,
-0.3027692437171936,
0.1565965861082077,
-0.8972247838973999,
-0.03909857198596001,
-0.26314249634742737,
-0.4318295419216156,
0.2552567720413208,
0.11624373495578766,
-0.6284547448158264,
0.01858837530016899,
-0.1588902324438095,
0.7165642380714417,
-0.6413797736167908,
0.8871285319328308,
0.6737152338027954,
-0.1968238800764084,
-0.4121866226196289,
-0.111069455742836,
-0.08037441223859787,
-0.8754363059997559,
0.8761111497879028,
0.12443553656339645,
-0.2603994905948639,
-0.18028289079666138,
-0.24211567640304565,
-0.7715350389480591,
1.0042096376419067,
0.2073597013950348,
-0.6035396456718445,
0.13986258208751678,
0.0471978597342968,
0.9547280669212341,
-0.2947162985801697,
0.29953479766845703,
0.4534606635570526,
0.29903513193130493,
-0.016248978674411774,
-1.184827446937561,
0.09025244414806366,
-0.22166432440280914,
-0.0826941505074501,
-0.18034276366233826,
-0.3536543548107147,
0.4049569070339203,
-0.3562473654747009,
-0.057304978370666504,
0.163442462682724,
0.47515302896499634,
0.6321067810058594,
0.2925868034362793,
0.2794830799102783,
0.43324989080429077,
0.8279434442520142,
0.23222485184669495,
1.0549144744873047,
-0.3574467897415161,
0.3076133131980896,
1.1213560104370117,
-0.6892986297607422,
1.1116421222686768,
0.555538535118103,
-0.19640061259269714,
0.09537886828184128,
0.1371465027332306,
0.12178836017847061,
0.2949104905128479,
0.14131997525691986,
-0.2702251374721527,
-0.34505051374435425,
-0.30737248063087463,
-0.6489542126655579,
0.4796082675457001,
0.5142029523849487,
-0.44464150071144104,
-0.22119566798210144,
0.2294001281261444,
-0.2638738453388214,
0.20735181868076324,
-0.09083797037601471,
0.7678340077400208,
0.07470965385437012,
-0.32574963569641113,
0.6292192339897156,
-0.26063644886016846,
0.6548253893852234,
-0.4929751455783844,
-0.1106838658452034,
-0.09001830965280533,
0.30424678325653076,
-0.06228230148553848,
-0.6642214059829712,
0.3722498416900635,
-0.05785756930708885,
-0.22926846146583557,
-0.10134956985712051,
0.8709748387336731,
-0.16210602223873138,
-0.41434532403945923,
0.7098551988601685,
0.6551674604415894,
0.24090419709682465,
-0.0561392679810524,
-0.8090447187423706,
0.3435182273387909,
-0.06464360654354095,
-0.2864503860473633,
0.6369546055793762,
0.19805747270584106,
0.16848328709602356,
1.0186939239501953,
0.41890349984169006,
0.2901971638202667,
-0.15576308965682983,
0.1683722585439682,
0.7181980609893799,
-0.7662002444267273,
0.12455716729164124,
-0.9045732021331787,
-0.0810156911611557,
0.015411981381475925,
-0.04156097024679184,
0.817409098148346,
0.6415025591850281,
0.4550132751464844,
0.07207529991865158,
0.6537773609161377,
0.10164452344179153,
1.0370861291885376,
-0.39419230818748474,
0.8266385197639465,
-0.5905640721321106,
0.6106556057929993,
-0.40617871284484863,
-0.6627890467643738,
-0.5266774296760559,
0.8026644587516785,
-0.4476718604564667,
0.21574249863624573,
0.6460716128349304,
0.7961236238479614,
0.19045788049697876,
0.03481268137693405,
0.4782537817955017,
0.5633644461631775,
0.19991107285022736,
0.4161864221096039,
0.6273216009140015,
-0.3523252308368683,
0.23837058246135712,
-0.20457524061203003,
-0.14467649161815643,
-0.18795117735862732,
-0.9877172112464905,
-0.9150735139846802,
-0.4382282793521881,
-0.3667236864566803,
-0.49718964099884033,
0.29234662652015686,
0.927139937877655,
0.5167585611343384,
-0.8304378986358643,
-0.16067761182785034,
0.2905043363571167,
0.01964971423149109,
-0.2613332271575928,
-0.16423119604587555,
0.6126755475997925,
-0.3738466501235962,
-0.30368712544441223,
0.6044222116470337,
0.5181763768196106,
-0.07689637690782547,
-0.19056382775306702,
0.07245753705501556,
-0.47699087858200073,
-0.2548842132091522,
0.7180929780006409,
0.46669480204582214,
-0.7223280072212219,
-0.2469279021024704,
0.1922464370727539,
-0.26568740606307983,
0.06239499896764755,
0.39872872829437256,
-0.9950584769248962,
0.4489775598049164,
0.33079060912132263,
0.9918830394744873,
0.4373738467693329,
-0.05848589912056923,
0.4693230986595154,
-0.4677950143814087,
-0.24861358106136322,
0.4489500820636749,
0.3234158456325531,
0.34758469462394714,
-0.11485601216554642,
0.6008919477462769,
0.09024027734994888,
-0.8776474595069885,
-0.9361530542373657,
-0.09260974079370499,
-1.0463669300079346,
-0.38230618834495544,
1.2266864776611328,
-0.027335617691278458,
0.06730184704065323,
-0.38943615555763245,
0.0033720089122653008,
0.1349465399980545,
-0.09315196424722672,
1.0458483695983887,
0.4793194830417633,
-0.2515241503715515,
0.09122630953788757,
-0.93482905626297,
0.4864899218082428,
0.7201458811759949,
-0.7268697023391724,
0.18646307289600372,
0.4453052282333374,
0.31187331676483154,
0.1942892223596573,
0.694499671459198,
-0.30640509724617004,
0.05738871172070503,
-0.38331905007362366,
0.35672321915626526,
0.12490811944007874,
-0.10368408262729645,
-0.5119242668151855,
0.1370542198419571,
0.1713228076696396,
0.2019176036119461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08142v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08142v1
|
Discursive objection strategies in online comments: Developing a classification schema and validating its training
| 2024-05-13T19:39:00 | 2024-05-13T19:39:00 |
Ashley L. Shea, Aspen K. B. Omapang, Ji Yong Cho, Miryam Y. Ginsparg, Natalie Bazarova, Winice Hui, René F. Kizilcec, Chau Tong, Drew Margolin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, I.2.7, J.4
|
Most Americans agree that misinformation, hate speech and harassment are
harmful and inadequately curbed on social media through current moderation
practices. In this paper, we aim to understand the discursive strategies
employed by people in response to harmful speech in news comments. We conducted
a content analysis of more than 6500 comment replies to trending news videos on
YouTube and Twitter and identified seven distinct discursive objection
strategies (Study 1). We examined the frequency of each strategy's occurrence
from the 6500 comment replies, as well as from a second sample of 2004 replies
(Study 2). Together, these studies show that people deploy a diversity of
discursive strategies when objecting to speech, and reputational attacks are
the most common. The resulting classification scheme accounts for different
theoretical approaches for expressing objections and offers a comprehensive
perspective on grassroots efforts aimed at stopping offensive or problematic
speech on campus.
|
[
-0.498586505651474,
-1.1547820568084717,
0.28077179193496704,
0.01684999279677868,
-0.53882896900177,
0.41448283195495605,
-0.10621283948421478,
-0.2192303091287613,
-0.12055569142103195,
0.6046802997589111,
-0.5437704920768738,
-0.3602607548236847,
-0.6894546151161194,
0.12171266227960587,
-0.7776685953140259,
1.4054725170135498,
0.19969484210014343,
0.0791843980550766,
-0.008603597059845924,
-0.21130666136741638,
-0.252518892288208,
-0.6814611554145813,
-0.5481624007225037,
0.2338215857744217,
0.7107028961181641,
0.24751988053321838,
0.4606556296348572,
0.3910817801952362,
0.5752995014190674,
0.33246439695358276,
-0.04703064262866974,
0.0533851757645607,
-0.6596165299415588,
0.1253819465637207,
-0.2802232503890991,
-0.5117211937904358,
0.19085007905960083,
0.03625169396400452,
0.3030347526073456,
0.4053209722042084,
-0.19395452737808228,
0.35215312242507935,
-0.04229247570037842,
0.570744514465332,
-0.8834797739982605,
-0.28000736236572266,
-0.6927505135536194,
0.14422020316123962,
-0.44251197576522827,
-0.32165566086769104,
-0.6481025815010071,
-0.7167619466781616,
0.029882973060011864,
-0.5898173451423645,
0.47980034351348877,
-0.2231324166059494,
0.3624154031276703,
0.13012200593948364,
-0.3962823152542114,
-0.767697811126709,
-0.8552104234695435,
0.7223824262619019,
-0.49155813455581665,
0.33832839131355286,
0.3591483235359192,
0.26499053835868835,
0.202610582113266,
-0.46838006377220154,
-0.48241305351257324,
0.06279049813747406,
0.12341387569904327,
0.003990664146840572,
-0.5382739305496216,
0.19596992433071136,
0.37251630425453186,
0.01997506059706211,
-0.3746564984321594,
0.08792456984519958,
-0.5975077152252197,
-0.11844602972269058,
0.6813642978668213,
-0.031717054545879364,
0.25875163078308105,
-0.4416338801383972,
-0.23058557510375977,
-0.027593906968832016,
-0.32391124963760376,
-0.1110118180513382,
0.7594671845436096,
0.2959405779838562,
0.10157715529203415,
0.41494882106781006,
-0.084987573325634,
0.5228419303894043,
0.26891231536865234,
-0.24187611043453217,
-0.03238401561975479,
-0.13982252776622772,
0.019546858966350555,
0.3598678708076477,
0.4251781404018402,
0.9382732510566711,
0.44758519530296326,
-0.10721942037343979,
0.11215483397245407,
0.5228739976882935,
0.6317530870437622,
-0.6131713390350342,
-0.07369054853916168,
-0.09482819586992264,
-0.6848192811012268,
-0.49192723631858826,
-0.016193894669413567,
-1.2224677801132202,
-0.9239780902862549,
0.12220636010169983,
0.2881956696510315,
-0.1281600445508957,
-0.24582722783088684,
-0.10496968030929565,
-0.2855013310909271,
0.011569084599614143,
0.3917863667011261,
-0.6436273455619812,
0.8925923109054565,
0.6291744709014893,
0.8489281535148621,
-0.26771727204322815,
0.28905558586120605,
-0.6594848036766052,
0.24929854273796082,
-0.3905521333217621,
0.7506583333015442,
-0.5442501306533813,
-0.4372614324092865,
0.3649180829524994,
-0.1057763397693634,
-0.011359361931681633,
-0.6170220375061035,
1.140690803527832,
-0.6560078859329224,
0.07590925693511963,
-0.3961654007434845,
-0.3002487123012543,
-0.6151076555252075,
-0.03310871124267578,
-0.3400804102420807,
0.6215111017227173,
0.0399765744805336,
-1.2184221744537354,
0.321321576833725,
-0.8670281767845154,
-0.7194876074790955,
0.07324419915676117,
0.07885552197694778,
-0.1677694469690323,
0.06629402935504913,
-0.06739474833011627,
0.4384244680404663,
-0.02753804624080658,
-0.08711372315883636,
-0.2386469841003418,
-0.0746648982167244,
0.19800661504268646,
-0.38896557688713074,
0.91875159740448,
0.6650148034095764,
-0.7547355890274048,
0.17596206068992615,
-0.4692457318305969,
-0.40607836842536926,
0.0926140546798706,
-0.2752991318702698,
-0.8662538528442383,
0.41961565613746643,
-0.2920975983142853,
0.2674020528793335,
-0.5672999024391174,
-0.49894729256629944,
-0.47130972146987915,
-0.3499768376350403,
0.7001819610595703,
0.9148381948471069,
0.37764468789100647,
0.167445108294487,
-0.5849243998527527,
0.33860576152801514,
0.20835168659687042,
0.32302430272102356,
0.34815889596939087,
-0.2176743894815445,
-0.8748272061347961,
0.4330725073814392,
-0.6389816403388977,
0.45812344551086426,
-0.6644543409347534,
-0.12744887173175812,
-0.1996895968914032,
-0.4601497948169708,
-0.28553590178489685,
0.09095501154661179,
0.44814327359199524,
0.41374650597572327,
0.27198725938796997,
-0.11205954849720001,
-0.6166570782661438,
-0.7569617629051208,
-0.4930562973022461,
-0.48687830567359924,
0.2359137386083603,
0.10485999286174774,
0.12070176750421524,
0.25687557458877563,
0.2872273027896881,
-0.3094122111797333,
-0.12059599906206131,
0.031922709196805954,
0.40945130586624146,
-0.3540167212486267,
0.01626737229526043,
0.5584545135498047,
-0.9238333702087402,
-0.6605815291404724,
-0.14540652930736542,
-0.43041571974754333,
0.041668184101581573,
-0.05390838906168938,
-0.026037923991680145,
0.26702365279197693,
0.5414799451828003,
-0.284301221370697,
0.3116360902786255,
0.2574571967124939,
-0.010358265601098537,
0.24226133525371552,
0.6241536736488342,
0.47853443026542664,
-0.8073866367340088,
-0.6675846576690674,
0.4905140995979309,
-0.09105729311704636,
-0.8488608598709106,
0.16112840175628662,
-0.7222774028778076,
0.3689442276954651,
-0.5801679491996765,
-0.2562505304813385,
-0.013255844824016094,
0.2653564214706421,
-0.028139151632785797,
0.2367602437734604,
-0.30552035570144653,
-0.07186352461576462,
0.020868252962827682,
0.392532616853714,
0.4784132242202759,
-0.8907655477523804,
0.5140299797058105,
0.15483546257019043,
-0.3163415193557739,
0.7779192328453064,
-0.3314702808856964,
0.3371979296207428,
-0.4022238254547119,
0.42994895577430725,
-1.112824559211731,
-0.17061008512973785,
0.5545820593833923,
-0.5079010128974915,
-0.1642758548259735,
-0.0053358301520347595,
-0.23619528114795685,
-0.6722416877746582,
-0.7555034160614014,
0.2184111624956131,
0.05023326352238655,
-0.3531295657157898,
0.48288366198539734,
0.7393463850021362,
-0.22609755396842957,
-0.3991539478302002,
-0.6268583536148071,
0.11345509439706802,
-0.7103371620178223,
-0.45686081051826477,
0.24634085595607758,
-0.1494291126728058,
-0.9168134331703186,
-0.27489611506462097,
0.04622093588113785,
-0.09295466542243958,
0.15594203770160675,
0.32222282886505127,
-0.20595243573188782,
0.017274081707000732,
-0.0018154799472540617,
-0.1781434565782547,
0.5340520739555359,
0.5060084462165833,
0.4125964641571045,
0.7481501698493958,
0.1454552859067917,
-0.045762889087200165,
-0.39841973781585693,
0.5810763835906982,
0.4403231739997864,
0.36661744117736816,
0.2989421784877777,
0.5232096910476685,
-0.2945671081542969,
-0.2510609030723572,
-0.7142362594604492,
-0.5637444257736206,
-0.44631442427635193,
0.4563511908054352,
0.14040470123291016,
-0.7661925554275513,
0.10333698987960815,
0.04881954565644264,
0.3297855854034424,
0.1590421348810196,
0.45646801590919495,
-0.1071832999587059,
1.1914374828338623,
0.23717181384563446,
-0.051929038017988205,
0.16730810701847076,
-0.047428227961063385,
0.346981406211853,
-0.23762619495391846,
-0.15626275539398193,
-0.7356763482093811,
-0.01518942229449749,
-0.7484176158905029,
-0.20792202651500702,
-0.20446132123470306,
-0.2610630989074707,
-0.2783701419830322,
0.30371811985969543,
-0.8219411373138428,
0.12942463159561157,
0.248337522149086,
-0.0738796517252922,
0.27800247073173523,
0.31502044200897217,
0.24830880761146545,
-0.30939340591430664,
-0.5073083639144897,
-0.3827415406703949,
0.5610825419425964,
0.6464248299598694,
0.7778138518333435,
0.33960071206092834,
0.3723922371864319,
0.7163273692131042,
0.47824105620384216,
-0.9941014647483826,
0.6561768651008606,
-0.2793487012386322,
-0.8889676332473755,
-0.08036842942237854,
-0.3355206251144409,
-0.4483562409877777,
0.03868010640144348,
-0.07571561634540558,
-0.9687669277191162,
0.054923366755247116,
0.08317001909017563,
-0.28988033533096313,
0.5879368782043457,
-0.6309158205986023,
0.2664509415626526,
-0.22248005867004395,
-0.3653489649295807,
-0.5127478837966919,
-0.7139581441879272,
0.4993608593940735,
-0.1575135886669159,
0.797295331954956,
0.13840888440608978,
0.21188673377037048,
1.2735872268676758,
-0.06126082316040993,
1.0363487005233765,
-0.38377025723457336,
-0.0648140087723732,
0.5509026646614075,
0.010575879365205765,
0.1958308219909668,
-0.35006120800971985,
0.13054122030735016,
-0.05735328793525696,
-0.05764171481132507,
0.24716901779174805,
-0.1600121706724167,
0.5803833603858948,
-0.8640056848526001,
-0.7758387923240662,
-0.2549355626106262,
-0.32144448161125183,
-0.21487165987491608,
0.08092542737722397,
0.3831307590007782,
0.1273590475320816,
-0.21752050518989563,
0.32736676931381226,
0.6073812246322632,
0.11954403668642044,
0.5760511159896851,
0.5210781693458557,
0.09449685364961624,
-0.4622642397880554,
1.1344722509384155,
0.23584432899951935,
0.33812740445137024,
0.18635421991348267,
0.21411722898483276,
-0.3899126946926117,
-0.6746006011962891,
-0.09109379351139069,
-0.014893346466124058,
-0.7777662873268127,
-0.14985506236553192,
-0.6287690997123718,
-0.07135211676359177,
-0.6926320791244507,
-0.09854353964328766,
0.01810934767127037,
-0.23693372309207916,
-0.11679675430059433,
-0.3412635624408722,
0.09810472279787064,
1.1408756971359253,
-0.0022775386460125446,
0.5316357016563416,
-0.46605756878852844,
0.2289060801267624,
0.48152580857276917,
0.15785935521125793,
-0.028735512867569923,
-0.5949268341064453,
0.11760888248682022,
0.03143971413373947,
-0.8236503601074219,
-1.117375373840332,
-0.14597609639167786,
0.049299851059913635,
0.6609793901443481,
0.9422376155853271,
0.7251183390617371,
0.5961426496505737,
-0.24762216210365295,
0.7444307208061218,
0.28108513355255127,
-0.5903388261795044,
0.5224820375442505,
-0.3550347089767456,
-0.41264835000038147,
0.4363524615764618,
0.9710307717323303,
-0.7046534419059753,
-0.6629336476325989,
-0.47840258479118347,
-0.6005252003669739,
0.5714907646179199,
-0.09848956763744354,
0.5061920285224915,
-0.41730940341949463,
0.10025984048843384,
0.03148999810218811,
0.33221402764320374,
-1.080493450164795,
-0.5752284526824951,
-0.6669607758522034,
0.3159322440624237,
0.28008756041526794,
-0.511175274848938,
-0.7615974545478821,
-0.3055347204208374,
0.5696567296981812,
-0.044635917991399765,
-0.04351135343313217,
-0.08557119220495224,
-0.18360468745231628,
-0.709265410900116,
0.19538061320781708,
0.6924247741699219,
0.8342429399490356,
-0.10832495987415314,
0.24400818347930908,
0.07366374135017395,
-0.7731987237930298,
0.24960161745548248,
-0.08105285465717316,
-0.4431392252445221,
0.17048105597496033,
0.07796068489551544,
0.6331709623336792,
0.26080751419067383,
-0.11827601492404938,
0.3759721517562866,
0.033794548362493515,
-0.5944958329200745,
-0.061002589762210846,
-0.020337790250778198,
-0.07789762318134308,
-0.14063449203968048,
0.4160964787006378,
-0.028451021760702133,
0.35431328415870667,
-0.7252929210662842,
0.31673601269721985,
0.46738284826278687,
-0.5190902948379517,
-0.20135514438152313,
0.5465463995933533,
0.35344403982162476,
-0.20844987034797668,
0.10648850351572037,
0.0623692087829113,
-0.5753422379493713,
0.08346863836050034,
0.7116042375564575,
0.7662063241004944,
-0.4056411385536194,
0.9232909679412842,
0.5364880561828613,
0.33354634046554565,
0.1408212035894394,
-0.1342075765132904,
0.06176917999982834,
-0.7216908931732178,
-0.042469605803489685,
-0.5491931438446045,
-0.19826269149780273,
0.26229432225227356,
-0.7016918659210205,
0.1233966127038002,
-1.1315346956253052,
-0.28249886631965637,
0.4391211271286011,
-0.00931365042924881,
0.01724008470773697,
0.07635768502950668,
0.22844192385673523,
0.7223241925239563,
-1.0676567554473877,
0.22573034465312958,
0.8012575507164001,
-0.46172234416007996,
-0.3272736668586731,
0.41907861828804016,
0.4548076391220093,
-0.6021802425384521,
0.5387415289878845,
0.1558593213558197,
-0.34910520911216736,
-0.05121815577149391,
-0.6287187337875366,
-0.43586859107017517,
0.22154417634010315,
0.1247013509273529,
-0.32467108964920044,
0.018497439101338387,
0.2501866817474365,
0.2839969992637634,
-0.16540107131004333,
-0.1684567928314209,
0.5747843980789185,
0.326235830783844,
0.1567697823047638,
-0.4995272755622864,
0.2425931990146637,
0.13070695102214813,
-0.027712512761354446,
0.198745995759964,
-0.8297397494316101,
0.7496375441551208,
-0.02863922528922558,
-0.6815226078033447,
-0.18515446782112122,
0.2333907186985016,
-0.06833472102880478,
0.38903069496154785,
1.01669442653656,
0.40440523624420166,
0.4530002176761627,
-0.07104352861642838,
0.8033760786056519,
-0.07469070702791214,
0.06470752507448196,
0.6980833411216736,
0.03266467526555061,
0.7028878331184387,
0.34267646074295044,
-0.39683547616004944,
0.6963726282119751,
0.5987363457679749,
-0.0998578667640686,
0.7338562607765198,
0.6310402154922485,
-0.6178114414215088,
-0.08498207479715347,
-0.6067992448806763,
-0.24107323586940765,
0.35610225796699524,
0.649489164352417,
-0.16546820104122162,
-0.5398260354995728,
0.23616822063922882,
0.3866640627384186,
0.7330083250999451,
-0.5590386986732483,
1.0502452850341797,
-0.15835413336753845,
-0.7030293941497803,
0.2594414949417114,
0.09514406323432922,
0.7155995965003967,
-0.41376763582229614,
-0.10647791624069214,
0.06085206940770149,
0.016894180327653885,
-0.5022039413452148,
-0.6143675446510315,
0.3450460135936737,
0.028000453487038612,
-0.04323970526456833,
0.1482091248035431,
0.8316669464111328,
0.2304144650697708,
-0.1684855967760086,
0.3085348606109619,
0.015293298289179802,
0.02416946552693844,
0.12168102711439133,
-0.8335114121437073,
0.19207380712032318,
0.0690700113773346,
0.13134422898292542,
0.29879748821258545,
0.10068190842866898,
-0.3009311854839325,
0.7411083579063416,
0.6961668133735657,
-0.06701682507991791,
0.24407044053077698,
0.3654666244983673,
1.21184504032135,
-0.28717395663261414,
-0.3181891143321991,
-0.7733978033065796,
0.2884092330932617,
-0.30264437198638916,
-0.29553189873695374,
0.9953458309173584,
0.3683614432811737,
1.0876569747924805,
0.2927595376968384,
0.883293092250824,
-0.10773885250091553,
1.0238699913024902,
-0.20604346692562103,
0.3706263601779938,
-0.030861036852002144,
-0.01569206826388836,
-0.744696855545044,
-0.84722900390625,
-0.3781692087650299,
0.9171906113624573,
-0.4861883819103241,
0.09075181931257248,
0.6467465758323669,
0.6079030632972717,
0.3479768633842468,
0.28078117966651917,
0.15639153122901917,
0.5723700523376465,
0.4254154562950134,
-0.06334094703197479,
0.944044828414917,
-0.02668391540646553,
1.0044949054718018,
-0.7850019335746765,
-0.14563485980033875,
-0.27950483560562134,
-0.5076165795326233,
-0.9961708784103394,
-0.3822294771671295,
-0.40981853008270264,
-0.6949574947357178,
0.4479643702507019,
0.6158598065376282,
0.575447678565979,
-0.8920220732688904,
-0.2933794856071472,
-0.22058556973934174,
0.24760963022708893,
-0.15795764327049255,
-0.35703691840171814,
-0.04603630304336548,
-0.1411200612783432,
-0.7201923131942749,
-0.04026174172759056,
0.10300035029649734,
-0.3529186546802521,
-0.41351625323295593,
0.02895527333021164,
-0.5438289046287537,
0.11909405887126923,
0.8600584268569946,
0.4731878340244293,
-0.8783204555511475,
-0.7163722515106201,
-0.040052250027656555,
-0.01698281057178974,
-0.14616306126117706,
0.6878063082695007,
-0.2152247428894043,
0.48562392592430115,
0.3034302592277527,
0.4150904715061188,
0.09591692686080933,
0.6163660287857056,
0.1414356827735901,
-0.5504438281059265,
0.03439328074455261,
0.4328958988189697,
-0.0847531408071518,
0.5521928668022156,
-0.40595361590385437,
0.21654555201530457,
0.5704779624938965,
-0.4961503744125366,
-0.8784430027008057,
0.21080702543258667,
-0.8504986763000488,
-0.3573181927204132,
1.1271154880523682,
0.17297664284706116,
0.08261751383543015,
-0.4984472990036011,
-0.3126787841320038,
0.16729490458965302,
-0.6023142337799072,
1.180977702140808,
0.8217405676841736,
-0.07387658953666687,
-0.2611232101917267,
-0.806067943572998,
0.7532057166099548,
0.050991546362638474,
-0.7669490575790405,
0.20632386207580566,
0.6695905923843384,
0.2611088454723358,
0.5123772025108337,
0.43814653158187866,
-0.11880485713481903,
0.38403892517089844,
-0.08061886578798294,
-0.49688586592674255,
0.4532424211502075,
-0.3580605685710907,
0.1286589354276657,
0.4134112298488617,
-0.003964367788285017,
-0.30605465173721313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13011v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13011v1
|
Unveiling Social Media Comments with a Novel Named Entity Recognition System for Identity Groups
| 2024-05-13T19:33:18 | 2024-05-13T19:33:18 |
Andrés Carvallo, Tamara Quiroga, Carlos Aspillaga, Marcelo Mendoza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
While civilized users employ social media to stay informed and discuss daily
occurrences, haters perceive these platforms as fertile ground for attacking
groups and individuals. The prevailing approach to counter this phenomenon
involves detecting such attacks by identifying toxic language. Effective
platform measures aim to report haters and block their network access. In this
context, employing hate speech detection methods aids in identifying these
attacks amidst vast volumes of text, which are impossible for humans to analyze
manually. In our study, we expand upon the usual hate speech detection methods,
typically based on text classifiers, to develop a Named Entity Recognition
(NER) System for Identity Groups. To achieve this, we created a dataset that
allows extending a conventional NER to recognize identity groups. Consequently,
our tool not only detects whether a sentence contains an attack but also tags
the sentence tokens corresponding to the mentioned group. Results indicate that
the model performs competitively in identifying groups with an average f1-score
of 0.75, outperforming in identifying ethnicity attack spans with an f1-score
of 0.80 compared to other identity groups. Moreover, the tool shows an
outstanding generalization capability to minority classes concerning sexual
orientation and gender, achieving an f1-score of 0.77 and 0.72, respectively.
We tested the utility of our tool in a case study on social media, annotating
and comparing comments from Facebook related to news mentioning identity
groups. The case study reveals differences in the types of attacks recorded,
effectively detecting named entities related to the categories of the analyzed
news articles. Entities are accurately tagged within their categories, with a
negligible error rate for inter-category tagging.
|
[
-0.5328994393348694,
-0.726447582244873,
0.18142211437225342,
0.05116219073534012,
-0.28218042850494385,
0.5669759511947632,
-0.16830973327159882,
-0.7733985185623169,
0.5717890858650208,
0.31837618350982666,
-0.28114020824432373,
-0.48245710134506226,
-0.6953092217445374,
0.10278438031673431,
-0.8469734787940979,
1.3166699409484863,
0.39308616518974304,
0.03912662714719772,
0.2985107898712158,
-0.18276701867580414,
0.027921611443161964,
-0.4482049345970154,
-0.8428786396980286,
0.007656466215848923,
0.9295274615287781,
-0.018282117322087288,
0.42269787192344666,
0.3991243541240692,
0.6698306202888489,
0.2945105731487274,
-0.1864265352487564,
0.03243698924779892,
-0.35546016693115234,
0.1063348576426506,
-0.22988606989383698,
-0.0851866602897644,
-0.26008570194244385,
-0.13208670914173126,
0.5311636328697205,
0.23096048831939697,
0.20151931047439575,
0.30404096841812134,
-0.04440699890255928,
0.326718270778656,
-0.5074214935302734,
-0.25983476638793945,
-1.0053112506866455,
0.09022408723831177,
-0.6079630255699158,
0.11906557530164719,
-0.35755038261413574,
-0.44908031821250916,
-0.05412326753139496,
-0.3077234923839569,
0.24615444242954254,
-0.03727945685386658,
0.7064284682273865,
0.11074770241975784,
-0.3633309304714203,
-0.28923892974853516,
-0.6996206641197205,
0.5517890453338623,
-0.5519114136695862,
0.46175986528396606,
0.00588232884183526,
0.32422763109207153,
-0.11980757117271423,
-0.1654728204011917,
-0.7702947854995728,
-0.015220609493553638,
-0.11038627475500107,
-0.23143020272254944,
-0.45637351274490356,
-0.05057119205594063,
0.25380998849868774,
0.22793003916740417,
-0.41676875948905945,
0.2797473073005676,
-0.49446430802345276,
-0.33613812923431396,
0.7954224944114685,
-0.18491186201572418,
0.6591943502426147,
-0.40896767377853394,
-0.45394599437713623,
0.5117931365966797,
-0.3806014657020569,
-0.047850120812654495,
0.5859856605529785,
0.5151324272155762,
0.03088449314236641,
0.41478291153907776,
-0.17603927850723267,
0.49279409646987915,
0.2571418881416321,
-0.2893047034740448,
0.45251137018203735,
0.3469787538051605,
-0.1099335178732872,
0.1833062469959259,
0.7563521265983582,
0.6150248646736145,
0.3904989957809448,
-0.5605966448783875,
-0.21742771565914154,
0.6421436071395874,
0.17200340330600739,
-0.7776522636413574,
-0.2067841738462448,
-0.28604254126548767,
-0.5212358236312866,
-0.3897007405757904,
-0.08106296509504318,
-0.9196187853813171,
-1.0045815706253052,
-0.021470405161380768,
0.21517139673233032,
-0.13901300728321075,
-0.5209957361221313,
-0.5330845713615417,
-0.5009390711784363,
0.31665536761283875,
0.4662182331085205,
-0.6361687183380127,
0.5529392957687378,
0.459311842918396,
0.7381316423416138,
-0.6161544919013977,
0.2842862904071808,
-0.7648109197616577,
0.0933723896741867,
-0.047564584761857986,
0.9237869381904602,
-0.8139392137527466,
-0.2841475009918213,
-0.22796760499477386,
-0.10304011404514313,
0.24986380338668823,
-0.6670883893966675,
0.4369761347770691,
-0.85859215259552,
-0.20996443927288055,
-0.24389038980007172,
-0.5680856108665466,
-0.13725706934928894,
0.20379972457885742,
-0.687318742275238,
0.7611780762672424,
0.02884785085916519,
-0.9977662563323975,
0.41702112555503845,
-0.6299238204956055,
-0.31008705496788025,
0.5308456420898438,
-0.42586949467658997,
-0.34065693616867065,
0.1352459192276001,
-0.04456588625907898,
0.445660799741745,
-0.1395379900932312,
-0.07415005564689636,
-0.6745237112045288,
-0.20223212242126465,
0.2153228521347046,
0.1160217672586441,
0.6724299788475037,
0.273926317691803,
-0.6330667734146118,
0.10022956132888794,
-0.7788971066474915,
-0.007837810553610325,
0.2555758059024811,
-0.21870754659175873,
-0.7324036359786987,
0.031283844262361526,
0.1756283938884735,
0.07469133287668228,
-0.15693166851997375,
-0.871764600276947,
-0.22061598300933838,
0.009385611861944199,
0.21551068127155304,
0.9512376189231873,
0.17515899240970612,
0.23112034797668457,
0.09736254066228867,
0.3904569745063782,
0.09283357858657837,
-0.09053225070238113,
0.25557941198349,
-0.3428357243537903,
-0.7802727222442627,
-0.13270415365695953,
0.27852746844291687,
0.6412898898124695,
-0.6594008207321167,
0.20350000262260437,
-0.053714122623205185,
-0.707899272441864,
-0.16289320588111877,
0.10891486704349518,
0.4449109733104706,
0.31785914301872253,
0.3407592177391052,
-0.12046914547681808,
-0.9963030815124512,
-1.0099397897720337,
-0.7272533178329468,
-0.32974502444267273,
-0.036895036697387695,
0.2490745633840561,
0.38007715344429016,
-0.2789075970649719,
0.860468327999115,
-0.32939693331718445,
-0.18874025344848633,
-0.00982794351875782,
0.1831601858139038,
-0.23377284407615662,
0.10366570204496384,
0.4628399908542633,
-1.0846213102340698,
-0.8944010734558105,
0.017052030190825462,
-0.5444697737693787,
-0.326732873916626,
0.25917187333106995,
0.08877875655889511,
0.05496922880411148,
0.6383148431777954,
0.005640027113258839,
0.4606013298034668,
0.38013723492622375,
-0.27790117263793945,
0.31750473380088806,
0.8221889138221741,
0.13112008571624756,
-0.9442636370658875,
-0.17497111856937408,
0.4117918610572815,
-0.2091561108827591,
-0.7374067306518555,
-0.2150695025920868,
-0.14954721927642822,
0.008099203929305077,
-0.448270708322525,
0.4936026632785797,
-0.3562309741973877,
0.19612982869148254,
-0.24080520868301392,
0.10047142952680588,
-0.5232314467430115,
0.32524579763412476,
-0.07177043706178665,
0.4052502512931824,
0.24213457107543945,
-0.6469618082046509,
0.2713800072669983,
-0.14578023552894592,
-0.24318867921829224,
0.9558147192001343,
-0.4662112593650818,
0.3626342713832855,
-0.3582727909088135,
0.02587100677192211,
-0.7533116340637207,
-0.2710178792476654,
0.5460289120674133,
-0.7870573401451111,
0.047331877052783966,
-0.23237034678459167,
-0.27695751190185547,
-0.27401071786880493,
-0.12656046450138092,
0.23485355079174042,
0.11464739590883255,
-0.3978880047798157,
0.7266433835029602,
1.0961439609527588,
-0.04791715741157532,
-0.59718918800354,
-0.6247789263725281,
0.309323787689209,
-0.6482518315315247,
-0.18540538847446442,
0.4292219877243042,
-0.18343859910964966,
-0.46647486090660095,
0.15647289156913757,
-0.04450251907110214,
-0.32601282000541687,
0.10578235238790512,
0.5958763957023621,
0.09806720912456512,
0.08048739284276962,
0.44947171211242676,
-0.15101741254329681,
0.23452720046043396,
0.10961796343326569,
0.24707813560962677,
0.48108211159706116,
-0.14176179468631744,
0.14436456561088562,
-0.2808428108692169,
0.40265512466430664,
0.49964961409568787,
-0.37681764364242554,
0.5557530522346497,
0.681325376033783,
-0.7425453066825867,
-0.33014971017837524,
-0.7309285402297974,
0.08520323783159256,
-0.4429020583629608,
0.35848838090896606,
-0.04820362851023674,
-1.1764863729476929,
0.5906287431716919,
0.17571590840816498,
-0.012679425068199635,
0.42307063937187195,
0.21304458379745483,
0.19632309675216675,
0.828254222869873,
0.7088207006454468,
-0.29696446657180786,
0.6386398673057556,
0.3475897014141083,
0.45545902848243713,
-0.6936758756637573,
-0.18385730683803558,
-0.40176427364349365,
-0.40643271803855896,
-0.6363297700881958,
-0.16959111392498016,
0.19691799581050873,
-0.14943277835845947,
-0.06883125752210617,
0.49508386850357056,
-0.7572654485702515,
0.6451997756958008,
0.13269877433776855,
-0.0680699571967125,
0.1771264523267746,
0.15591420233249664,
0.09614065289497375,
-0.2445504069328308,
0.20895671844482422,
-0.6106961369514465,
1.017513632774353,
0.4271073341369629,
0.5774927139282227,
0.17730456590652466,
0.882649838924408,
0.8598142862319946,
0.9900293946266174,
-0.7977469563484192,
0.8587101697921753,
-0.1256159245967865,
-0.8141531944274902,
-0.1356048434972763,
-0.4707132577896118,
-0.5908341407775879,
0.1549258530139923,
-0.1394740343093872,
-0.9381951689720154,
0.1180444285273552,
0.022920288145542145,
-0.5050994753837585,
0.6164065599441528,
-0.4849148392677307,
0.4818592965602875,
-0.14526836574077606,
0.05521879345178604,
0.09205389022827148,
-0.3302454352378845,
0.3386719524860382,
-0.23876602947711945,
0.23057687282562256,
-0.35348501801490784,
-0.10110007226467133,
1.0317522287368774,
-0.06978977471590042,
0.8074776530265808,
-0.3949812352657318,
-0.04755358025431633,
0.22988073527812958,
-0.23553068935871124,
0.1264682114124298,
-0.2590966820716858,
-0.08804541826248169,
0.269319087266922,
-0.5655463337898254,
0.14783373475074768,
-0.5095617771148682,
0.7265898585319519,
-0.45856717228889465,
-0.34521129727363586,
-0.25916343927383423,
-0.19087260961532593,
0.060352884232997894,
0.42914876341819763,
0.17832887172698975,
-0.04500110447406769,
-0.5305159687995911,
0.06410078704357147,
0.7381951212882996,
-0.026749657467007637,
0.31110742688179016,
0.6875381469726562,
-0.5212005972862244,
-0.6562350988388062,
1.0159693956375122,
0.37303608655929565,
-0.003776583820581436,
0.2873570919036865,
-0.33108028769493103,
0.017079535871744156,
-0.4535960257053375,
-0.3751402199268341,
0.21240675449371338,
-0.4983609616756439,
-0.3747962713241577,
-1.1242910623550415,
-0.25595757365226746,
-0.4524991810321808,
0.14283573627471924,
-0.02239184081554413,
-0.17883192002773285,
-0.017238279804587364,
-0.13176240026950836,
0.09871324896812439,
0.7469452619552612,
-0.03783068805932999,
0.46807441115379333,
-0.3692123293876648,
0.5051684975624084,
0.48434606194496155,
0.37705686688423157,
0.050233349204063416,
-0.35376206040382385,
-0.0424085296690464,
-0.12081090360879898,
-0.2728573977947235,
-1.4507203102111816,
0.11108125001192093,
-0.04421980306506157,
0.34383100271224976,
0.546052098274231,
0.1733608841896057,
0.5702915787696838,
-0.613589882850647,
0.3578599989414215,
0.17847883701324463,
-0.8728639483451843,
0.5431795716285706,
-0.12405722588300705,
-0.3869021236896515,
0.45177212357521057,
0.5902861952781677,
-0.7849203944206238,
-0.5282474756240845,
-0.6091600656509399,
-0.5838521122932434,
0.3726695477962494,
0.20451517403125763,
0.08511216193437576,
-0.3656417727470398,
0.26265594363212585,
-0.23842653632164001,
0.31464099884033203,
-1.2287473678588867,
-0.5653930306434631,
0.07054581493139267,
-0.012552439235150814,
0.33158132433891296,
-0.2830643057823181,
0.0653364360332489,
-0.19317036867141724,
0.7850340008735657,
0.18542924523353577,
0.24124906957149506,
0.013257919810712337,
-0.1574525088071823,
-0.10247799754142761,
0.4362643361091614,
0.09031613916158676,
0.14504331350326538,
-0.009087755344808102,
0.23531995713710785,
0.0525650791823864,
-0.3719363808631897,
0.27561670541763306,
0.25252577662467957,
-0.33132097125053406,
0.3498508632183075,
-0.14046773314476013,
0.4684872329235077,
-0.1907283514738083,
-0.5463389754295349,
0.45291075110435486,
-0.10795942693948746,
0.09289398044347763,
-0.6572205424308777,
0.1912095844745636,
0.14811702072620392,
0.2229512631893158,
0.5496036410331726,
0.04294347018003464,
0.4410172998905182,
-0.301682710647583,
0.21609893441200256,
0.6367800831794739,
-0.7601291537284851,
-0.39812594652175903,
0.35152754187583923,
0.29465973377227783,
-0.5764639973640442,
0.18640875816345215,
-0.6745642423629761,
-0.7840905785560608,
0.573923647403717,
0.4941871464252472,
0.8803631067276001,
-0.7654711008071899,
0.4540660083293915,
0.41579440236091614,
0.5659441351890564,
0.5163863301277161,
0.001053031301125884,
-0.0899115726351738,
-0.9726805686950684,
0.09629257023334503,
-0.792518675327301,
-0.19025644659996033,
0.5127447843551636,
-0.5957887172698975,
0.32243192195892334,
-0.975927472114563,
-0.35368064045906067,
0.8327347040176392,
-0.20171824097633362,
-0.36437901854515076,
0.3008999526500702,
0.660959005355835,
0.5622026324272156,
-0.9247019290924072,
0.2709325850009918,
0.8901758790016174,
-0.24004821479320526,
-0.6165136694908142,
0.07351034134626389,
0.4104612469673157,
-0.5640502572059631,
0.7403660416603088,
0.7122941017150879,
-0.2544397711753845,
-0.047922827303409576,
-0.6445759534835815,
-0.7351318001747131,
0.40029773116111755,
0.24895532429218292,
-0.512599527835846,
0.034790538251399994,
0.14915966987609863,
0.6425874829292297,
-0.44169881939888,
-0.05621029809117317,
0.2976739704608917,
0.33603930473327637,
-0.14200018346309662,
-0.7667563557624817,
0.1787959784269333,
-0.618251383304596,
-0.0667928159236908,
0.5334046483039856,
-0.6520073413848877,
0.8072165846824646,
-0.0010827045189216733,
-0.6334088444709778,
-0.3237258791923523,
0.7435762882232666,
-0.05932294577360153,
0.45572319626808167,
1.0327777862548828,
0.6563692092895508,
0.8261469602584839,
0.12423591315746307,
0.31715095043182373,
0.0732518881559372,
0.034656476229429245,
1.2113986015319824,
-0.25075337290763855,
0.598465085029602,
0.2070336490869522,
-0.12033654004335403,
0.8295853137969971,
0.3106542229652405,
-0.31284984946250916,
0.24557004868984222,
0.6890566945075989,
-0.7153286933898926,
-0.1217527836561203,
-0.628075897693634,
-0.3508860170841217,
0.4861220717430115,
0.4910435378551483,
-0.7050198316574097,
-0.19810500741004944,
0.1726572960615158,
0.43615958094596863,
0.2133396416902542,
-0.5081050395965576,
0.8105438351631165,
-0.09253758937120438,
-0.3095609247684479,
0.03526276722550392,
0.2289367914199829,
0.9325632452964783,
-0.40731707215309143,
0.04188854247331619,
0.18801575899124146,
0.20650221407413483,
-0.49535617232322693,
-0.3000383973121643,
0.30777162313461304,
0.4010078012943268,
-0.47860926389694214,
0.26947706937789917,
0.8581745028495789,
-0.4137023985385895,
-0.4645405411720276,
0.5419051647186279,
0.13645464181900024,
0.19721096754074097,
-0.3836189806461334,
-0.6282450556755066,
0.1966438591480255,
0.08945123851299286,
0.12264296412467957,
0.16629837453365326,
0.24402426183223724,
-0.0952131599187851,
0.4078981578350067,
0.4745919704437256,
0.0026649432256817818,
0.16692844033241272,
-0.016167521476745605,
0.9456279873847961,
-0.6586986780166626,
-0.48734360933303833,
-0.9835211038589478,
0.21377764642238617,
-0.6798213720321655,
-0.28345146775245667,
0.912268340587616,
0.7104436755180359,
1.026477336883545,
0.34232690930366516,
0.8694714903831482,
-0.25849583745002747,
1.2781893014907837,
0.10674290359020233,
0.6695066690444946,
-0.4804174304008484,
0.12909568846225739,
-0.7620519995689392,
-0.7548674941062927,
-0.4908010959625244,
0.42935115098953247,
-0.36415430903434753,
0.01960144378244877,
0.408652663230896,
0.8689936995506287,
0.06711660325527191,
0.10582972317934036,
0.006200967822223902,
0.2522909939289093,
0.5511995553970337,
0.16317994892597198,
0.8149170875549316,
-0.3166954815387726,
0.6490238904953003,
-0.013166815973818302,
-0.3479233384132385,
-0.01898515783250332,
-0.6703157424926758,
-1.0820831060409546,
-0.28346186876296997,
-0.5245352387428284,
-0.4571898281574249,
0.14143536984920502,
0.8286284804344177,
0.4153253138065338,
-0.778984785079956,
-0.04911453276872635,
0.3083197772502899,
0.2568412721157074,
0.22382472455501556,
-0.33965063095092773,
-0.021224530413746834,
0.03586595132946968,
-0.568970799446106,
0.16043177247047424,
0.4065870940685272,
-0.0870802104473114,
-0.25697487592697144,
0.03218604996800423,
-0.21185088157653809,
0.16604067385196686,
0.3837887942790985,
0.455276221036911,
-0.7433421015739441,
-0.3389888107776642,
-0.14350204169750214,
-0.02815025858581066,
-0.18729566037654877,
0.781365156173706,
-0.6218967437744141,
0.2587309181690216,
0.025060415267944336,
0.8828992247581482,
-0.024261685088276863,
-0.06608262658119202,
-0.13122984766960144,
-0.513477623462677,
-0.18442071974277496,
0.4036678075790405,
0.19125880300998688,
0.5746803879737854,
-0.6067615747451782,
0.3631315529346466,
0.4847666621208191,
-0.438094824552536,
-0.9958900213241577,
0.36533141136169434,
-0.7792589068412781,
0.04278193786740303,
1.0081409215927124,
-0.014210681430995464,
-0.22126616537570953,
-0.31639033555984497,
-0.10955581814050674,
0.20888584852218628,
-0.7216004133224487,
0.7764500975608826,
0.5844704508781433,
0.10204115509986877,
-0.027970731258392334,
-0.165375754237175,
0.5016449093818665,
0.12061817198991776,
-0.8815963268280029,
-0.19081172347068787,
0.6275625824928284,
0.45633530616760254,
0.4232359230518341,
0.9492768049240112,
-0.19414862990379333,
0.17043423652648926,
-0.378329873085022,
0.14319075644016266,
0.32982519268989563,
-0.26185333728790283,
-0.062465548515319824,
0.3648846447467804,
-0.4821736812591553,
-0.1721085160970688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08134v1
|
Many-Shot Regurgitation (MSR) Prompting
| 2024-05-13T19:22:40 | 2024-05-13T19:22:40 |
Shashank Sonkar, Richard G. Baraniuk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Many-Shot Regurgitation (MSR) prompting, a new black-box
membership inference attack framework for examining verbatim content
reproduction in large language models (LLMs). MSR prompting involves dividing
the input text into multiple segments and creating a single prompt that
includes a series of faux conversation rounds between a user and a language
model to elicit verbatim regurgitation. We apply MSR prompting to diverse text
sources, including Wikipedia articles and open educational resources (OER)
textbooks, which provide high-quality, factual content and are continuously
updated over time. For each source, we curate two dataset types: one that LLMs
were likely exposed to during training ($D_{\rm pre}$) and another consisting
of documents published after the models' training cutoff dates ($D_{\rm
post}$). To quantify the occurrence of verbatim matches, we employ the Longest
Common Substring algorithm and count the frequency of matches at different
length thresholds. We then use statistical measures such as Cliff's delta,
Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) distance, and Kruskal-Wallis H test to determine
whether the distribution of verbatim matches differs significantly between
$D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm post}$. Our findings reveal a striking difference in
the distribution of verbatim matches between $D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm post}$,
with the frequency of verbatim reproduction being significantly higher when
LLMs (e.g. GPT models and LLaMAs) are prompted with text from datasets they
were likely trained on. For instance, when using GPT-3.5 on Wikipedia articles,
we observe a substantial effect size (Cliff's delta $= -0.984$) and a large KS
distance ($0.875$) between the distributions of $D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm
post}$. Our results provide compelling evidence that LLMs are more prone to
reproducing verbatim content when the input text is likely sourced from their
training data.
|
[
-0.3134949803352356,
-1.0527993440628052,
0.35523101687431335,
0.0017555025406181812,
-0.39882892370224,
-0.27779480814933777,
-0.0695432648062706,
-0.15476813912391663,
-0.04548157751560211,
0.17476844787597656,
-0.7709549069404602,
-0.34939879179000854,
-0.6136873364448547,
0.4644710123538971,
-0.609870433807373,
1.0054911375045776,
0.21358540654182434,
0.3364449739456177,
-0.05536433681845665,
0.10819388926029205,
-0.7236700654029846,
-0.8158791661262512,
-0.49340373277664185,
0.07220400869846344,
0.9133005142211914,
0.19345448911190033,
0.5182823538780212,
0.40320685505867004,
0.43516039848327637,
0.24917583167552948,
-0.22423973679542542,
0.08170821517705917,
-0.816728413105011,
0.5766717195510864,
0.017224665731191635,
-0.4449942409992218,
0.04242188110947609,
-0.3055175542831421,
0.8749039173126221,
0.0082169808447361,
-0.25955790281295776,
0.06998077034950256,
0.2827688455581665,
0.7640559673309326,
-0.6658211946487427,
-0.2737148404121399,
-0.6994737982749939,
0.13222043216228485,
-0.38411056995391846,
-0.6694123148918152,
-0.7957672476768494,
-0.14733582735061646,
-0.09784239530563354,
-0.32029664516448975,
0.47398465871810913,
0.0806712806224823,
1.1061455011367798,
-0.009078196249902248,
-0.23809485137462616,
-0.2622188329696655,
-0.7517862915992737,
0.4964786767959595,
-0.4579136371612549,
0.6849218606948853,
0.3226800858974457,
0.3138549327850342,
-0.5631738901138306,
-0.40033867955207825,
-0.8636835813522339,
-0.16978010535240173,
0.047375116497278214,
0.13476987183094025,
-0.6258658766746521,
0.12819887697696686,
0.4145396649837494,
0.35390332341194153,
-1.0651944875717163,
0.06529037654399872,
-0.5832424759864807,
-0.11134238541126251,
0.26736152172088623,
0.13830909132957458,
0.29135969281196594,
-0.41987037658691406,
-0.3161080777645111,
-0.20066353678703308,
-0.7461641430854797,
-0.11589477956295013,
0.6302512884140015,
0.35429614782333374,
-0.07529869675636292,
1.063283920288086,
-0.16057130694389343,
1.0147522687911987,
0.07179678231477737,
-0.17613808810710907,
0.1505567729473114,
-0.4270240366458893,
-0.35247156023979187,
-0.0816316306591034,
1.0047615766525269,
0.5581281185150146,
0.5187498331069946,
0.3263082504272461,
-0.0718812420964241,
-0.05800952389836311,
0.35275137424468994,
-0.8096465468406677,
-0.2097267061471939,
0.1630525439977646,
-0.41341134905815125,
-0.05721760168671608,
0.2981176972389221,
-1.012782096862793,
-0.3795439898967743,
-0.2166549414396286,
0.7423270344734192,
-0.5403685569763184,
-0.03637233376502991,
0.08630336821079254,
-0.535516619682312,
0.26899147033691406,
0.22944696247577667,
-0.6793657541275024,
-0.261104941368103,
0.631559431552887,
1.116690754890442,
-0.150704488158226,
-0.6269813179969788,
-0.6931909322738647,
0.024901259690523148,
-0.2199874371290207,
1.0334763526916504,
-0.6329474449157715,
-0.3934546411037445,
0.2542705535888672,
0.23124942183494568,
-0.06879421323537827,
-0.46260327100753784,
0.327827513217926,
-0.6985251903533936,
0.13461674749851227,
-0.3391455411911011,
-0.5804460644721985,
-0.11839372664690018,
0.3025684654712677,
-0.6958562135696411,
1.055081844329834,
-0.164271280169487,
-0.9581788778305054,
0.7428508996963501,
-0.3788304328918457,
-0.19497253000736237,
-0.21734049916267395,
-0.3037465512752533,
-0.4568230211734772,
0.015919700264930725,
0.24037833511829376,
0.6349760890007019,
-0.03408883139491081,
-0.026206977665424347,
-0.23918436467647552,
-0.4299156069755554,
0.444979190826416,
-0.8183761239051819,
0.3390065133571625,
0.11609575152397156,
-0.052804093807935715,
0.277764230966568,
-0.47699061036109924,
-0.424154669046402,
0.2606348395347595,
-0.2306859940290451,
-0.24149581789970398,
0.18206967413425446,
-0.10431503504514694,
0.25904229283332825,
-0.4247129261493683,
-0.20275777578353882,
0.32466423511505127,
-0.23259775340557098,
0.09205345064401627,
0.825926661491394,
0.5870450139045715,
0.10398685187101364,
-0.7121778130531311,
0.7891731858253479,
0.14948199689388275,
0.10009720176458359,
-0.6163633465766907,
-0.6147733330726624,
-0.4281737208366394,
-0.5854921936988831,
-0.048288632184267044,
0.42779091000556946,
-0.7756531834602356,
0.2846499979496002,
-0.37991729378700256,
-0.5058116912841797,
-0.5181834697723389,
-0.02056986466050148,
0.21173585951328278,
0.349322646856308,
0.5407720804214478,
-0.05369862914085388,
-0.5069767236709595,
-0.6826967597007751,
-0.15013344585895538,
-0.15032394230365753,
-0.001405411632731557,
0.15343235433101654,
0.43946200609207153,
0.09586187452077866,
0.8527412414550781,
-0.43378791213035583,
-0.3058854043483734,
-0.2869584262371063,
0.22706961631774902,
0.06363008171319962,
0.24269887804985046,
0.512250542640686,
-0.6424354910850525,
-0.3603895902633667,
-0.25041836500167847,
-0.6863667368888855,
0.1782764047384262,
-0.34375882148742676,
-0.09730256348848343,
0.3601716458797455,
0.42785659432411194,
-0.6482517719268799,
0.5569276213645935,
0.7301580905914307,
-0.2094544917345047,
0.8941676616668701,
0.05762192979454994,
0.7375608086585999,
-1.2019325494766235,
0.045091599225997925,
0.025821952149271965,
0.019620977342128754,
-0.5734472274780273,
0.05174417048692703,
-0.17294570803642273,
-0.14118601381778717,
-0.5669515132904053,
0.32228001952171326,
-0.5824671387672424,
-0.03096979856491089,
-0.14260579645633698,
0.2067713886499405,
-0.11566518247127533,
0.06656976789236069,
-0.17062067985534668,
1.2432587146759033,
0.5093181133270264,
-0.6998624205589294,
0.2693340480327606,
0.332768052816391,
-0.2750212252140045,
0.6139318346977234,
-0.7997857332229614,
-0.05866936594247818,
-0.5425243973731995,
0.2907184958457947,
-1.448540449142456,
-0.4120323359966278,
0.2827713191509247,
-0.7432727217674255,
0.23110400140285492,
-0.5701878666877747,
-0.6175423264503479,
-0.3678513467311859,
-0.36334022879600525,
0.31050586700439453,
0.5261567831039429,
-0.34783828258514404,
0.21798045933246613,
0.11044801771640778,
-0.2623869776725769,
-0.8750350475311279,
-0.6610362529754639,
0.13241909444332123,
0.05414893478155136,
-0.5607799291610718,
-0.21408286690711975,
-0.0996491089463234,
0.07496058195829391,
-0.10513442754745483,
0.00881703570485115,
0.05095457285642624,
-0.17611725628376007,
0.29991623759269714,
0.4614264667034149,
-0.29491299390792847,
0.23107753694057465,
0.205032080411911,
0.12200645357370377,
-0.19258692860603333,
-0.07106927782297134,
0.9368026256561279,
0.300702840089798,
-0.668771505355835,
-0.6893778443336487,
0.43834662437438965,
0.4417535662651062,
-0.3384215235710144,
0.9838047623634338,
0.4283630847930908,
-0.25808513164520264,
0.05557514727115631,
-0.6992230415344238,
-0.4477792978286743,
-0.47708895802497864,
0.4676471948623657,
-0.33126330375671387,
-1.0910199880599976,
0.31631800532341003,
0.47024059295654297,
0.24745720624923706,
0.3595750033855438,
0.8202568292617798,
-0.042431943118572235,
0.7965088486671448,
0.24922196567058563,
-0.0463734045624733,
0.7330178618431091,
-0.011842617765069008,
-0.10133430361747742,
-0.41846394538879395,
-0.15186582505702972,
-0.77055823802948,
-0.07455742359161377,
-0.42205843329429626,
-0.6025725603103638,
0.23041898012161255,
0.10225984454154968,
0.04175989702343941,
0.12432477623224258,
-0.5087267756462097,
0.7069827914237976,
0.23666393756866455,
0.02463131584227085,
0.18697236478328705,
0.34575459361076355,
-0.11608776450157166,
-0.22736211121082306,
-0.8042432069778442,
-0.3610062897205353,
0.9576622247695923,
0.19246847927570343,
0.8105880618095398,
0.312583863735199,
0.6947674751281738,
0.3567105531692505,
0.333620548248291,
-1.153987169265747,
0.4603212773799896,
0.0983675867319107,
-0.7184808850288391,
-0.3211958110332489,
-0.4018675684928894,
-1.482562780380249,
0.22588840126991272,
-0.5090397596359253,
-0.6597080826759338,
0.06988400220870972,
0.3482690453529358,
-0.24884451925754547,
0.3015263080596924,
-0.4762929081916809,
0.6559335589408875,
0.4385809898376465,
-0.2031095176935196,
-0.07675769180059433,
-0.526319682598114,
0.40131229162216187,
-0.010046682320535183,
0.20798970758914948,
0.002628796035423875,
0.08006623387336731,
0.5714709758758545,
-0.0741056576371193,
0.693526029586792,
-0.14086662232875824,
-0.03185798227787018,
0.21019412577152252,
0.2946483790874481,
0.667018711566925,
-0.28867706656455994,
-0.17728376388549805,
0.012788101099431515,
-0.06638413667678833,
-0.26486530900001526,
-0.49903103709220886,
0.4225553274154663,
-0.520802915096283,
-0.6599138975143433,
-0.6393792033195496,
-0.22932825982570648,
0.15132427215576172,
0.17623531818389893,
0.5305668115615845,
0.54030841588974,
-0.13747334480285645,
0.43739983439445496,
0.6050741672515869,
-0.18282653391361237,
0.3001629114151001,
0.27854424715042114,
-0.25942176580429077,
-0.5448628664016724,
0.7020537853240967,
0.2197570502758026,
0.474983274936676,
0.3366166353225708,
0.03162709251046181,
-0.4050809442996979,
-0.7028239965438843,
-0.656667172908783,
0.45959511399269104,
-0.7375133037567139,
-0.3330916464328766,
-0.6806854605674744,
-0.23030303418636322,
-0.3746529221534729,
-0.09405001252889633,
0.06636422127485275,
0.16094842553138733,
-0.42425861954689026,
-0.20647677779197693,
0.6177330017089844,
0.9247056245803833,
0.20625919103622437,
0.38228631019592285,
-1.2801827192306519,
0.26227638125419617,
0.06646888703107834,
0.006817803252488375,
0.07503852248191833,
-1.068095326423645,
-0.019761784002184868,
-0.12167009711265564,
-0.21303746104240417,
-1.4868446588516235,
0.2745240330696106,
0.21235613524913788,
0.570419430732727,
0.5086249709129333,
0.05079119652509689,
1.0464656352996826,
-0.9256271719932556,
1.1354621648788452,
0.22270679473876953,
-0.5793408155441284,
0.4770548641681671,
-0.5082762241363525,
0.18729344010353088,
0.5292773246765137,
0.7595432996749878,
-0.7458285689353943,
-0.6723278760910034,
-0.3838983178138733,
-0.6675217747688293,
0.5299877524375916,
0.0712648257613182,
0.3621399998664856,
-0.47376954555511475,
0.38412055373191833,
-0.020111700519919395,
0.08863193541765213,
-0.6158052086830139,
-0.45427799224853516,
-0.06494007259607315,
-0.06524436175823212,
-0.18542079627513885,
-0.616377592086792,
-0.1891845166683197,
0.018278971314430237,
0.4366086721420288,
-0.06970582157373428,
0.37313106656074524,
0.5129477977752686,
-0.30964377522468567,
-0.13259436190128326,
0.3881435692310333,
1.0072779655456543,
0.7353119850158691,
0.03171980381011963,
0.16341643035411835,
0.020028214901685715,
-0.5449828505516052,
0.3969045877456665,
-0.016230428591370583,
-0.046913791447877884,
0.3101479709148407,
0.31811264157295227,
0.7114572525024414,
0.13538740575313568,
-0.5678413510322571,
0.9253597259521484,
0.023922648280858994,
-0.3145114481449127,
-0.18701305985450745,
-0.06838991492986679,
-0.02594553492963314,
0.12810789048671722,
0.5226089358329773,
-0.07682452350854874,
0.09618224203586578,
-0.36709633469581604,
0.5963106155395508,
0.39013737440109253,
-0.3632085919380188,
-0.2695411741733551,
0.3867205083370209,
-0.23720121383666992,
-0.3309621512889862,
0.5977516770362854,
-0.26171866059303284,
-0.36070823669433594,
0.10888462513685226,
0.6813439726829529,
0.6189282536506653,
-0.3655296862125397,
0.20475655794143677,
0.6798644065856934,
0.39939823746681213,
-0.23685096204280853,
0.38666826486587524,
0.320379376411438,
-0.5135517716407776,
-0.6226410269737244,
-0.5950988531112671,
-0.011379246599972248,
0.13618874549865723,
-0.7975563406944275,
0.3582848310470581,
-0.39126476645469666,
-0.24150940775871277,
0.05042243003845215,
-0.6904625296592712,
-0.2839640974998474,
-0.07680893689393997,
-0.12579475343227386,
0.8489457368850708,
-0.9809775948524475,
0.5186964869499207,
0.4464520812034607,
-0.5742795467376709,
-0.6346632838249207,
0.29155388474464417,
0.5728694200515747,
-0.730502724647522,
0.5050937533378601,
0.2270074486732483,
-0.098678819835186,
0.00777494115754962,
-0.40461066365242004,
-0.5327330827713013,
0.862922191619873,
0.34751105308532715,
-0.7538748979568481,
0.07000789791345596,
-0.15666650235652924,
0.29068148136138916,
0.14229385554790497,
0.07790901511907578,
0.23603112995624542,
0.2558416426181793,
0.37647801637649536,
-0.6869344711303711,
0.20854800939559937,
-0.02817823737859726,
-0.15945489704608917,
0.5204672813415527,
-0.4081527888774872,
0.7472818493843079,
-0.2753634452819824,
-0.41928374767303467,
0.011407229118049145,
0.7756555676460266,
0.7839003801345825,
0.0908849760890007,
0.4953680634498596,
0.1439242660999298,
0.758766770362854,
0.018716439604759216,
1.0801814794540405,
-0.13750073313713074,
0.35236990451812744,
1.0631060600280762,
-0.059452082961797714,
1.416455864906311,
0.8048840165138245,
-0.3211005628108978,
0.31044211983680725,
0.7006081938743591,
-0.3500787019729614,
0.2068958878517151,
0.229061558842659,
-0.3842948377132416,
-0.012598707340657711,
0.013660388067364693,
-0.5865312814712524,
0.12515601515769958,
0.10718856751918793,
-0.35586777329444885,
-0.12242972105741501,
0.10022144764661789,
0.26643744111061096,
-0.12531891465187073,
-0.016166402027010918,
0.9127492904663086,
-0.05058335140347481,
-0.5300223231315613,
0.6853489279747009,
-0.3058200478553772,
0.7635260224342346,
-0.8549946546554565,
-0.15436355769634247,
-0.16536130011081696,
-0.24859364330768585,
-0.24627408385276794,
-0.890903115272522,
0.25808918476104736,
0.2296549379825592,
-0.31771185994148254,
0.25904765725135803,
0.5989217758178711,
-0.5028019547462463,
-0.23994944989681244,
0.1482316255569458,
0.5751779079437256,
0.4426731467247009,
-0.16325737535953522,
-0.6990618109703064,
0.1878189742565155,
-0.09513916820287704,
-0.4697949290275574,
0.47310101985931396,
0.5522234439849854,
0.22282575070858002,
0.6037508845329285,
1.0803121328353882,
0.2620314359664917,
0.2984273135662079,
0.3104909062385559,
0.883927583694458,
-0.5995497703552246,
-0.372557133436203,
-1.1536208391189575,
0.5903542637825012,
0.015173518098890781,
-0.23613545298576355,
0.9292814135551453,
0.669016420841217,
0.6523619294166565,
-0.24692003428936005,
0.5673261284828186,
0.09407392889261246,
0.17228791117668152,
-0.841417133808136,
0.8119381070137024,
-0.7855943441390991,
-0.011382460594177246,
-0.44833192229270935,
-0.8416159749031067,
-0.3464133143424988,
0.4210941791534424,
-0.07499328255653381,
0.07041334360837936,
0.6937824487686157,
1.315464735031128,
0.026226714253425598,
-0.1663365215063095,
0.5075136423110962,
0.07543116807937622,
0.3201790153980255,
-0.14824534952640533,
1.0767712593078613,
-0.16147419810295105,
0.7483912110328674,
0.29417547583580017,
-0.16803687810897827,
-0.5671529769897461,
-0.7500340938568115,
-0.9372245073318481,
-0.6912983655929565,
0.027531584724783897,
-0.7093824148178101,
0.3466372489929199,
1.2926599979400635,
0.5068871974945068,
-0.6456959247589111,
-0.1168622151017189,
0.1643727570772171,
-0.05505005270242691,
-0.24101033806800842,
-0.3003928065299988,
0.21811357140541077,
-0.4059487581253052,
-0.5428434014320374,
0.3210635483264923,
0.1509377509355545,
0.5334623456001282,
-0.10910269618034363,
0.07734160125255585,
-0.4428741931915283,
0.10822289437055588,
0.7175483703613281,
0.22649185359477997,
-0.828401505947113,
-0.31047800183296204,
0.24655181169509888,
-0.1421193778514862,
0.23923766613006592,
0.8455469012260437,
-0.2575414478778839,
0.5222154259681702,
0.6956650018692017,
0.7099756002426147,
0.27406996488571167,
0.07572980225086212,
0.5325701832771301,
-0.9171916246414185,
0.1960201859474182,
-0.02370242401957512,
0.32410863041877747,
0.17182324826717377,
-0.3243151903152466,
0.14485307037830353,
0.4392090439796448,
-0.6576998233795166,
-1.0656685829162598,
0.11473560333251953,
-0.9602370858192444,
-0.260529488325119,
1.4793970584869385,
-0.2038496434688568,
-0.17263630032539368,
-0.20748388767242432,
-0.4996167719364166,
0.27580365538597107,
-0.6856353282928467,
0.5126199126243591,
0.9332952499389648,
0.0032596546225249767,
-0.576151430606842,
-0.7876297831535339,
0.6111945509910583,
0.28023192286491394,
-0.7236208915710449,
0.29597532749176025,
0.7757593989372253,
0.33169522881507874,
-0.07557689398527145,
0.5060309171676636,
-0.07078482210636139,
0.606916606426239,
0.15331409871578217,
0.054527830332517624,
-0.11825024336576462,
-0.47369346022605896,
-0.8703950643539429,
0.25239700078964233,
0.25057342648506165,
-0.18694616854190826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16892v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16892v1
|
Multilingual Entity Linking Using Dense Retrieval
| 2024-05-13T18:57:27 | 2024-05-13T18:57:27 |
Dominik Farhan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Entity linking (EL) is the computational process of connecting textual
mentions to corresponding entities. Like many areas of natural language
processing, the EL field has greatly benefited from deep learning, leading to
significant performance improvements. However, present-day approaches are
expensive to train and rely on diverse data sources, complicating their
reproducibility. In this thesis, we develop multiple systems that are fast to
train, demonstrating that competitive entity linking can be achieved without a
large GPU cluster. Moreover, we train on a publicly available dataset, ensuring
reproducibility and accessibility. Our models are evaluated for 9 languages
giving an accurate overview of their strengths. Furthermore, we offer
a~detailed analysis of bi-encoder training hyperparameters, a popular approach
in EL, to guide their informed selection. Overall, our work shows that building
competitive neural network based EL systems that operate in multiple languages
is possible even with limited resources, thus making EL more approachable.
|
[
-0.5920708775520325,
-0.8086215257644653,
0.44233813881874084,
0.3972918689250946,
0.0968957170844078,
0.11211533099412918,
-0.6422178149223328,
-1.0092744827270508,
0.2856171131134033,
0.28679174184799194,
-0.07537918537855148,
-0.339160293340683,
-0.2732180058956146,
0.4706193208694458,
-0.4494611918926239,
0.9561566114425659,
-0.06879127025604248,
0.0947229266166687,
-0.055632151663303375,
-0.43527042865753174,
-0.16399794816970825,
-0.4585810601711273,
-0.9967275261878967,
-0.1626124531030655,
0.9290997982025146,
0.37378519773483276,
0.6935306787490845,
0.6311907172203064,
0.48538315296173096,
0.3522237241268158,
0.1584562063217163,
0.08535503596067429,
-0.5054792165756226,
0.5206727385520935,
-0.3500758111476898,
-0.40178564190864563,
-0.11104777455329895,
-0.6239469051361084,
0.8910415172576904,
0.7525901198387146,
-0.05641836300492287,
0.17500869929790497,
0.029562203213572502,
0.7434536218643188,
-0.6664833426475525,
0.12291847169399261,
-1.0359266996383667,
-0.2048102617263794,
-0.5837703347206116,
0.20327837765216827,
-0.47231313586235046,
-0.3351745903491974,
0.2643858790397644,
-0.7721139192581177,
0.3570391833782196,
0.29534077644348145,
0.932610809803009,
0.08570796251296997,
-0.28633633255958557,
-0.41282734274864197,
-0.7111744284629822,
0.7152910828590393,
-0.22123563289642334,
0.9244787096977234,
0.2959182560443878,
0.22315627336502075,
0.33532923460006714,
-0.7099379897117615,
-0.5018697381019592,
-0.16981267929077148,
0.044488053768873215,
-0.12558762729167938,
0.18710161745548248,
-0.030987931415438652,
0.2006734311580658,
0.25758668780326843,
-0.620017409324646,
0.19027647376060486,
-0.14429867267608643,
0.05770236998796463,
0.6365107297897339,
-0.08132952451705933,
0.3360733389854431,
0.1268051415681839,
-0.26323458552360535,
0.06046894192695618,
-0.8374279737472534,
-0.5166782140731812,
0.5879615545272827,
0.37293627858161926,
0.1547664850950241,
0.6543514132499695,
-0.017532052472233772,
0.4245774447917938,
-0.0666041299700737,
0.08615069836378098,
0.4095267653465271,
-0.5187861323356628,
-0.1295597106218338,
0.34192612767219543,
0.7045305967330933,
-0.1682174801826477,
0.371787965297699,
-0.5718528628349304,
-0.2640761435031891,
-0.061788707971572876,
0.07726520299911499,
-0.5655156373977661,
-0.11889935284852982,
0.009816347621381283,
-0.3630209267139435,
0.2696956396102905,
-0.2880685031414032,
-0.8100886940956116,
0.09236708283424377,
-0.3191516399383545,
0.27107372879981995,
-0.5825867056846619,
-0.34461840987205505,
0.16204050183296204,
0.069489486515522,
-0.14993856847286224,
0.1193985790014267,
-1.0541497468948364,
0.33279117941856384,
0.30046382546424866,
0.7083521485328674,
0.06446714699268341,
-0.6866527795791626,
-0.1870747208595276,
0.6303786635398865,
-0.016197126358747482,
0.7760792970657349,
-0.5774056315422058,
-0.04616566374897957,
0.25034865736961365,
-0.01281834114342928,
-0.08882832527160645,
-0.6961532831192017,
0.6657906174659729,
-1.0086830854415894,
-0.1465304046869278,
-0.2781705856323242,
-0.6335238814353943,
-0.1285771131515503,
0.22158609330654144,
-1.1516615152359009,
1.2371472120285034,
-0.3403663635253906,
-0.92558753490448,
0.4413951337337494,
-0.43959930539131165,
-0.6623770594596863,
0.3468015491962433,
-0.08086619526147842,
-0.3078208863735199,
-0.21496830880641937,
0.1362648904323578,
0.3797779381275177,
-0.2976416349411011,
0.12362398952245712,
-0.4726194739341736,
-0.325616717338562,
-0.32416364550590515,
-0.2503044605255127,
0.5048331618309021,
0.34592294692993164,
-0.38426071405410767,
-0.3292362689971924,
-0.8454499244689941,
-0.18137989938259125,
0.2673501968383789,
-0.8711699843406677,
-0.7765395641326904,
0.029360448941588402,
0.2542981505393982,
0.06357405334711075,
0.2074122130870819,
-0.43945375084877014,
0.17001157999038696,
-0.4254148602485657,
0.11082568019628525,
0.42160603404045105,
-0.11551792174577713,
0.49668899178504944,
0.17496968805789948,
-0.0061704558320343494,
-0.03101758100092411,
-0.26881712675094604,
-0.16218292713165283,
-0.4077053368091583,
-0.9743770360946655,
-0.06934050470590591,
0.5372555255889893,
0.4947238266468048,
-1.281095027923584,
0.2095591276884079,
-0.31238511204719543,
-0.3488110899925232,
-0.8928207159042358,
0.4117158353328705,
0.23938196897506714,
0.30989184975624084,
0.646480917930603,
-0.06749022006988525,
-0.47950440645217896,
-0.8928531408309937,
-0.359584242105484,
-0.11837375164031982,
0.02408999390900135,
0.49401506781578064,
0.672795832157135,
-0.10937061905860901,
0.22860755026340485,
-0.2235206514596939,
-0.2172524780035019,
-0.24715571105480194,
0.12076994776725769,
0.06147051230072975,
0.2854626178741455,
0.6551687717437744,
-0.8039713501930237,
-0.7988502979278564,
0.3532356321811676,
-0.883734405040741,
0.2528287172317505,
-0.19761313498020172,
-0.18822601437568665,
0.11631985753774643,
0.4299006462097168,
-0.40058383345603943,
0.008585305884480476,
0.3426496684551239,
0.12125854939222336,
0.4503437578678131,
-0.28133150935173035,
0.05846787244081497,
-0.756281852722168,
0.1708461046218872,
0.4060612618923187,
0.016214391216635704,
-0.20218133926391602,
0.1730373352766037,
-0.005385799333453178,
-0.0213933065533638,
-0.45508870482444763,
0.47031739354133606,
-0.8262757062911987,
-0.20768943428993225,
0.07629645615816116,
0.4309273064136505,
-0.037610847502946854,
0.5967133641242981,
0.25162526965141296,
0.698160707950592,
0.6686804294586182,
-0.801407516002655,
0.5544928908348083,
0.10307032614946365,
-0.26952996850013733,
0.7792440056800842,
-0.7001818418502808,
0.03905467689037323,
-0.4182652533054352,
-0.06746364384889603,
-0.3331283628940582,
-0.11073628813028336,
-0.14241765439510345,
-0.15350908041000366,
0.30883723497390747,
-0.09768683463335037,
-0.7109588384628296,
-0.17009323835372925,
0.020035171881318092,
0.7509200572967529,
-0.18955297768115997,
-0.6815021634101868,
0.36064621806144714,
0.5104248523712158,
-0.15381884574890137,
-0.6234719753265381,
-0.7047878503799438,
0.15980452299118042,
-0.10323508828878403,
-0.5807812213897705,
0.42495763301849365,
-0.13492940366268158,
-0.046300482004880905,
0.34599336981773376,
0.31026774644851685,
-0.4798564314842224,
0.09057582914829254,
-0.22246015071868896,
0.06726973503828049,
-0.4049869775772095,
0.5262666344642639,
-0.031341928988695145,
0.0779092013835907,
-0.04799239709973335,
-0.3420710861682892,
0.2249843031167984,
-0.19993513822555542,
-0.453782856464386,
-0.3238353133201599,
0.7155535817146301,
0.31958693265914917,
-0.6106762290000916,
1.090186357498169,
0.6614067554473877,
-0.7594451904296875,
-0.2663812041282654,
-0.672460675239563,
0.09623173624277115,
-0.3608689606189728,
0.5899815559387207,
-0.5765674710273743,
-0.7534723281860352,
0.41419464349746704,
-0.12764997780323029,
0.0720398798584938,
0.5229364037513733,
0.7033777832984924,
0.19649621844291687,
0.7964900732040405,
0.5767420530319214,
-0.06320900470018387,
0.3732701539993286,
-0.16624991595745087,
0.24075531959533691,
-0.6202922463417053,
-0.6057896018028259,
-0.9245559573173523,
-0.3794284164905548,
-0.55063396692276,
-0.13023245334625244,
0.17699259519577026,
0.16592928767204285,
-0.5110872983932495,
0.6944333910942078,
-0.21806828677654266,
0.6723577380180359,
0.6317151188850403,
0.08317334204912186,
0.4336254894733429,
0.1323031187057495,
-0.5877838730812073,
-0.15214520692825317,
-0.8073402047157288,
-0.34892991185188293,
0.8773812651634216,
0.28580600023269653,
0.8527384400367737,
0.3818354606628418,
0.577350914478302,
0.06536881625652313,
0.19955144822597504,
-0.6019338369369507,
0.31479260325431824,
0.04838718846440315,
-0.8485907912254333,
-0.4514751136302948,
-0.37321701645851135,
-1.0387743711471558,
0.27304157614707947,
-0.7224612832069397,
-0.3431035876274109,
0.19430555403232574,
-0.18295371532440186,
-0.07682538032531738,
0.5441915988922119,
-0.7485553026199341,
0.6610385775566101,
-0.40508681535720825,
-0.7941550016403198,
-0.2815115749835968,
-0.562853217124939,
-0.011166084557771683,
-0.1703595221042633,
-0.031365636736154556,
0.05793085694313049,
-0.03308966010808945,
0.5072341561317444,
0.278719425201416,
0.34368014335632324,
0.28732606768608093,
0.1001310646533966,
0.24204149842262268,
-0.047040827572345734,
0.40655088424682617,
0.3240853548049927,
-0.43572840094566345,
0.2819918990135193,
-0.5765743255615234,
-0.5127984881401062,
-0.35854074358940125,
1.0749330520629883,
-0.7113696932792664,
-0.06471932679414749,
-0.09482982009649277,
-0.22408926486968994,
-0.16477759182453156,
0.35119307041168213,
0.17402952909469604,
0.18660347163677216,
-0.403476744890213,
0.4502873122692108,
1.0435688495635986,
-0.1599469631910324,
0.5956820249557495,
0.23768015205860138,
0.26705074310302734,
-0.36654132604599,
0.8115749359130859,
0.1085159033536911,
-0.07825414091348648,
0.641849935054779,
-0.5715605616569519,
-0.5426689982414246,
-0.40451931953430176,
-0.6708623170852661,
0.5278695821762085,
-0.5469537973403931,
-0.3170833885669708,
-0.81556636095047,
-0.10187587141990662,
-0.2597437798976898,
-0.2715606093406677,
-0.5319342017173767,
-0.07536391168832779,
-0.16928896307945251,
-0.2187741994857788,
-0.13939793407917023,
0.6935549378395081,
0.2542259693145752,
-0.10377101600170135,
-0.7147385478019714,
0.1337265968322754,
0.23726950585842133,
0.882127583026886,
0.3890305757522583,
0.35773876309394836,
-0.8084031343460083,
-0.2644926905632019,
-0.13767606019973755,
-1.1284148693084717,
0.1923685371875763,
0.356577605009079,
0.9304488897323608,
0.28547459840774536,
-0.25627070665359497,
0.6043536067008972,
-0.79160076379776,
0.5361882448196411,
0.25081124901771545,
-0.884382963180542,
0.4975630044937134,
-0.031992357224226,
-0.22424782812595367,
0.7555238008499146,
1.0000090599060059,
-0.40203389525413513,
-0.13082708418369293,
-0.4992406666278839,
-1.0321794748306274,
0.2904747426509857,
0.2124744951725006,
-0.09592138975858688,
-0.4486808478832245,
0.36674562096595764,
-0.016361944377422333,
0.15382955968379974,
-0.6691521406173706,
-0.5459253787994385,
-0.007603011559695005,
-0.1520536243915558,
0.06125864386558533,
-0.14318227767944336,
0.1022261455655098,
-0.007647962775081396,
0.9206085801124573,
-0.10077721625566483,
0.15223409235477448,
0.24520857632160187,
-0.6475757956504822,
0.06319952756166458,
0.3168318271636963,
0.09475827217102051,
0.4845956563949585,
0.16437241435050964,
0.22111493349075317,
0.355604350566864,
-0.1678188145160675,
0.0944289118051529,
0.02956502139568329,
-0.11777108162641525,
0.3317631781101227,
0.11830952763557434,
0.8696472644805908,
0.5119137763977051,
-0.5345914363861084,
0.30111560225486755,
0.0007931607542559505,
-0.02355513721704483,
-0.0916294977068901,
-0.3496722877025604,
0.34770020842552185,
0.3632113039493561,
0.23804640769958496,
-0.12794487178325653,
0.29315370321273804,
-0.42543157935142517,
0.30821314454078674,
0.3625663220882416,
-0.21859300136566162,
-0.42358049750328064,
1.0791157484054565,
0.6046370267868042,
-0.11258912086486816,
0.8353907465934753,
-0.11893177777528763,
-0.2728786766529083,
0.37313953042030334,
0.6908453702926636,
0.760600209236145,
-0.18549390137195587,
0.0838669091463089,
0.8021765351295471,
0.4079738259315491,
-0.21096038818359375,
-0.09763004630804062,
-0.01971570774912834,
-0.8007431030273438,
-0.5887052416801453,
-0.44409653544425964,
-0.28860294818878174,
-0.12235553562641144,
-0.604590117931366,
0.31676024198532104,
-0.14006932079792023,
-0.2629319131374359,
0.1496383547782898,
0.12103152275085449,
-1.1160798072814941,
0.17218786478042603,
0.3158743381500244,
1.0520081520080566,
-0.7995153665542603,
0.8029751777648926,
0.9874173402786255,
-0.7766788005828857,
-0.47971540689468384,
-0.3515867292881012,
-0.2781656086444855,
-0.5637913942337036,
0.7141994833946228,
-0.2203187495470047,
0.01894700713455677,
0.02704222872853279,
-0.281110942363739,
-0.758132815361023,
0.8818293213844299,
0.6098244786262512,
-0.620647668838501,
-0.3259110748767853,
-0.07877688109874725,
0.591453492641449,
-0.3617311120033264,
0.40212321281433105,
0.21517199277877808,
0.5077800154685974,
-0.1979098618030548,
-0.8764778971672058,
-0.13307558000087738,
-0.2347402423620224,
0.010091341100633144,
0.3826225697994232,
-0.7881367802619934,
0.5032418370246887,
-0.31975510716438293,
-0.3178735077381134,
-0.09454494714736938,
0.8914163112640381,
0.1782160997390747,
0.2507079541683197,
0.30997976660728455,
0.8226931691169739,
0.8972533941268921,
-0.05865408107638359,
0.7073262333869934,
-0.5786339044570923,
0.5851420164108276,
1.0330101251602173,
-0.6259949207305908,
1.084896445274353,
0.35883378982543945,
0.07585237920284271,
0.7212806344032288,
0.44978994131088257,
-0.13184338808059692,
0.2515573799610138,
0.10246915370225906,
-0.6177977919578552,
-0.30231359601020813,
-0.3835445046424866,
-0.42008620500564575,
0.22142763435840607,
0.30790117383003235,
-0.39508676528930664,
-0.3735833466053009,
-0.1916431188583374,
-0.04910273849964142,
0.13711759448051453,
-0.3819018304347992,
0.6811103224754333,
-0.05608058720827103,
-0.371193528175354,
0.10918465256690979,
0.010004276409745216,
0.6876538395881653,
-0.5636028051376343,
-0.09967568516731262,
-0.12763898074626923,
-0.09012310951948166,
-0.2651047706604004,
-0.716411828994751,
0.15581651031970978,
0.08225853741168976,
-0.2603415846824646,
-0.10629837960004807,
0.8731211423873901,
-0.8782941699028015,
-0.2229764759540558,
0.6344165802001953,
0.773956835269928,
0.050490546971559525,
0.015251386910676956,
-0.9044278264045715,
-0.03562070429325104,
-0.2500230073928833,
-0.32037943601608276,
0.23404815793037415,
0.7683553099632263,
-0.04813319444656372,
0.6655020117759705,
0.613848865032196,
0.21763165295124054,
0.18427640199661255,
0.19407358765602112,
0.7502444386482239,
-0.797439455986023,
-0.2534409761428833,
-0.6331458687782288,
0.21582679450511932,
-0.08019008487462997,
-0.1654067486524582,
0.8299899101257324,
0.9771420955657959,
1.4079467058181763,
0.12547527253627777,
0.7324908375740051,
0.15122193098068237,
0.1929105967283249,
-0.4074380099773407,
0.6785614490509033,
-0.4926445186138153,
0.09466519206762314,
-0.11607777327299118,
-1.236076831817627,
-0.3222515881061554,
0.38439467549324036,
0.23071281611919403,
0.019982634112238884,
0.8569018244743347,
0.5127926468849182,
-0.09179019927978516,
-0.19254274666309357,
0.28835201263427734,
0.14827962219715118,
-0.06046498939394951,
0.7901260256767273,
0.35894373059272766,
-0.45763713121414185,
0.7161655426025391,
-0.18391990661621094,
0.09963076561689377,
-0.0794408768415451,
-0.7102548480033875,
-0.6722651124000549,
-0.5084438920021057,
-0.4325339198112488,
-0.340223491191864,
0.1579778790473938,
0.8157646656036377,
0.6522302627563477,
-0.7061126232147217,
-0.22699324786663055,
0.368680864572525,
0.4480479061603546,
-0.1411093920469284,
-0.16944368183612823,
0.39675402641296387,
-0.42073261737823486,
-1.0982218980789185,
0.29740142822265625,
0.38609281182289124,
-0.10822907835245132,
-0.2095772624015808,
-0.0949549525976181,
-0.6692633032798767,
-0.14596009254455566,
0.6307569146156311,
0.36189547181129456,
-0.33405378460884094,
-0.1241067424416542,
0.06693688780069351,
-0.2882634699344635,
-0.009783679619431496,
0.7091092467308044,
-0.6655862331390381,
0.3725227117538452,
0.5341264605522156,
1.3060908317565918,
0.5126878023147583,
-0.4186665415763855,
0.24700959026813507,
-0.7614480257034302,
0.05017463490366936,
0.2270027995109558,
0.5946971774101257,
0.4373317360877991,
-0.42500945925712585,
0.617609977722168,
0.3630923628807068,
-0.7461536526679993,
-0.4256446957588196,
0.1261385828256607,
-0.6933374404907227,
-0.06290502101182938,
1.002766489982605,
-0.12339287996292114,
-0.1763199418783188,
-0.3711676299571991,
0.12556307017803192,
0.32923656702041626,
-0.4137464761734009,
0.46590444445610046,
0.6846413612365723,
0.1377667784690857,
0.10943961143493652,
-0.5609390735626221,
0.2565120458602905,
0.19246706366539001,
-0.709606409072876,
-0.3982497751712799,
0.41438183188438416,
0.17877621948719025,
0.26621970534324646,
0.5491992235183716,
0.014645395800471306,
-0.008012141101062298,
0.14957211911678314,
0.33862268924713135,
0.21212348341941833,
-0.5667659044265747,
-0.14883387088775635,
0.36802414059638977,
-0.0026739835739135742,
-0.005163933616131544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08099v1
|
KET-QA: A Dataset for Knowledge Enhanced Table Question Answering
| 2024-05-13T18:26:32 | 2024-05-13T18:26:32 |
Mengkang Hu, Haoyu Dong, Ping Luo, Shi Han, Dongmei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Due to the concise and structured nature of tables, the knowledge contained
therein may be incomplete or missing, posing a significant challenge for table
question answering (TableQA) and data analysis systems. Most existing datasets
either fail to address the issue of external knowledge in TableQA or only
utilize unstructured text as supplementary information for tables. In this
paper, we propose to use a knowledge base (KB) as the external knowledge source
for TableQA and construct a dataset KET-QA with fine-grained gold evidence
annotation. Each table in the dataset corresponds to a sub-graph of the entire
KB, and every question requires the integration of information from both the
table and the sub-graph to be answered. To extract pertinent information from
the vast knowledge sub-graph and apply it to TableQA, we design a
retriever-reasoner structured pipeline model. Experimental results demonstrate
that our model consistently achieves remarkable relative performance
improvements ranging from 1.9 to 6.5 times and absolute improvements of 11.66%
to 44.64% on EM scores across three distinct settings (fine-tuning, zero-shot,
and few-shot), in comparison with solely relying on table information in the
traditional TableQA manner. However, even the best model achieves a 60.23% EM
score, which still lags behind the human-level performance, highlighting the
challenging nature of KET-QA for the question-answering community. We also
provide a human evaluation of error cases to analyze further the aspects in
which the model can be improved. Project page: https://ketqa.github.io/.
|
[
-0.20646671950817108,
-0.908047616481781,
0.7333552837371826,
-0.12850365042686462,
-0.24171708524227142,
-0.15944050252437592,
0.3356669843196869,
-0.3393650949001312,
0.11736784875392914,
0.6510957479476929,
-0.32588109374046326,
-0.5631933808326721,
-0.4981229901313782,
-0.017582649365067482,
-0.38310614228248596,
0.8972495198249817,
0.18858176469802856,
-0.020325370132923126,
-0.08634351938962936,
-0.1442139893770218,
-0.85572749376297,
-0.49835580587387085,
-0.4055106043815613,
-0.16378438472747803,
0.4959406554698944,
0.6539375185966492,
0.6163579821586609,
0.5807449221611023,
0.5103557705879211,
0.18805256485939026,
0.03430546447634697,
0.11662886291742325,
-0.2696973383426666,
0.18258917331695557,
-0.08343157172203064,
-0.5590391755104065,
-0.4329749047756195,
-0.3704661726951599,
0.2686513662338257,
0.5036270022392273,
-0.18148711323738098,
0.3874790370464325,
-0.173274427652359,
0.880673348903656,
-0.6713742613792419,
0.40428268909454346,
-0.7251538038253784,
0.004361064173281193,
-0.13217297196388245,
-0.07850184291601181,
-0.3206390142440796,
-0.5687501430511475,
0.28449833393096924,
-0.7693566083908081,
-0.10835633426904678,
-0.07176852226257324,
0.8586515784263611,
0.37457215785980225,
-0.7089889049530029,
-0.19475093483924866,
-0.6332927942276001,
0.25894713401794434,
-0.7922912836074829,
0.6888713836669922,
0.24957171082496643,
0.6847645044326782,
-0.01414437685161829,
-1.075732946395874,
-0.696685254573822,
-0.011367803439497948,
-0.2750227153301239,
0.2955847978591919,
0.0035751727409660816,
-0.00039876275695860386,
0.39247190952301025,
0.3912539482116699,
-0.6025991439819336,
-0.36214616894721985,
-0.43199682235717773,
-0.14514249563217163,
0.4561261534690857,
0.26986390352249146,
0.2793276011943817,
-0.44555988907814026,
-0.043191101402044296,
-0.11921700090169907,
-0.5963709354400635,
0.3434160053730011,
0.13700971007347107,
0.3334500789642334,
0.31835150718688965,
0.7718672752380371,
-0.803978681564331,
0.7139894962310791,
-0.08792682737112045,
0.23742367327213287,
-0.015587742440402508,
-0.009563501924276352,
-0.34740540385246277,
0.0386095829308033,
0.3513474762439728,
0.24597769975662231,
0.06316933035850525,
-0.4128429591655731,
0.02267361991107464,
0.24646104872226715,
0.12055110186338425,
-0.8491824865341187,
-0.7903708815574646,
0.5114073157310486,
-0.3287624418735504,
-0.03466557711362839,
0.031867824494838715,
-0.8816648125648499,
-0.49203187227249146,
-0.17083868384361267,
0.9514585137367249,
-0.24764424562454224,
-0.16514593362808228,
-0.022252557799220085,
-0.3364775478839874,
0.394369512796402,
0.1065918505191803,
-0.42825570702552795,
0.22298482060432434,
0.4358052611351013,
0.4500599801540375,
0.20622804760932922,
0.3094232976436615,
-0.8457736372947693,
0.2339160144329071,
-0.2808983325958252,
0.9491071701049805,
-0.7141392230987549,
-0.04593156650662422,
-0.13618183135986328,
0.0940803810954094,
0.07249587774276733,
-0.4267723858356476,
0.9169076681137085,
-1.097941279411316,
0.38942497968673706,
-0.8528157472610474,
-0.7663512825965881,
-0.4356341063976288,
0.45025473833084106,
-0.9395245313644409,
0.913332998752594,
0.31669244170188904,
-0.7776927947998047,
0.6409465670585632,
-0.9808076024055481,
-0.04956953227519989,
0.23516157269477844,
0.10778316110372543,
-0.2849602699279785,
-0.2142103761434555,
0.5187159776687622,
0.12533888220787048,
-0.09050344675779343,
0.3084581792354584,
-0.22067423164844513,
-0.37723997235298157,
0.10209111869335175,
0.14825162291526794,
0.5384446978569031,
0.17985254526138306,
-0.037885840982198715,
-0.0646783635020256,
-0.8069074749946594,
0.4511221945285797,
-0.025719139724969864,
-0.7270160913467407,
-0.27562573552131653,
-0.02684183605015278,
-0.3016223609447479,
0.4688222408294678,
0.00909954123198986,
-0.7403244972229004,
0.07170731574296951,
-0.36454468965530396,
0.32044076919555664,
0.41567301750183105,
0.45581233501434326,
0.2815116345882416,
-0.3233985900878906,
0.4412992298603058,
0.21588267385959625,
0.02581862360239029,
0.018262552097439766,
-0.4881170392036438,
-0.8729681372642517,
0.1121797189116478,
0.9462218880653381,
0.724831223487854,
-0.8059251308441162,
0.11590576171875,
-0.3077143430709839,
-0.3398054242134094,
-0.6432663798332214,
0.0004704900202341378,
0.24917414784431458,
1.0905755758285522,
0.6583642363548279,
-0.24752764403820038,
-0.7874182462692261,
-1.0564085245132446,
-0.32344645261764526,
-0.17482416331768036,
-0.3494974374771118,
0.33199143409729004,
0.37029731273651123,
0.12350254505872726,
1.0064752101898193,
-0.48874011635780334,
-0.2692323923110962,
-0.21708054840564728,
-0.22353112697601318,
0.37250226736068726,
0.3658283054828644,
-0.04806414991617203,
-0.6393904685974121,
-0.42451468110084534,
-0.07839168608188629,
-0.8370646834373474,
-0.12072059512138367,
0.24876365065574646,
-0.5468735694885254,
-0.14268650114536285,
0.2911739945411682,
-0.6176207065582275,
0.27079230546951294,
0.15556322038173676,
-0.6419097185134888,
0.4655771553516388,
0.27691465616226196,
0.32737261056900024,
-1.1100069284439087,
0.44398587942123413,
-0.0945514366030693,
-0.024388952180743217,
-0.6968269348144531,
0.22355690598487854,
0.010381578467786312,
-0.12151050567626953,
-0.2716285288333893,
0.4104393720626831,
0.016304949298501015,
0.04029255732893944,
-0.02509830705821514,
0.23344095051288605,
0.34862220287323,
0.7332851886749268,
0.11292146891355515,
0.5477836728096008,
0.17190535366535187,
-0.6014263033866882,
0.1979498714208603,
0.7930850982666016,
-0.33006149530410767,
0.4691941738128662,
-0.8976409435272217,
0.3753197193145752,
-0.24778687953948975,
0.12108631432056427,
-0.9930524230003357,
-0.3137212097644806,
0.2283363938331604,
-0.3678833246231079,
0.14520616829395294,
-0.5212302207946777,
-0.42095524072647095,
-0.3223302960395813,
0.03245692327618599,
0.024951549246907234,
0.5568461418151855,
-0.4268755316734314,
0.7856427431106567,
0.4268931448459625,
-0.15565447509288788,
-0.6225693821907043,
-0.5065494179725647,
-0.1263299435377121,
-0.3940288722515106,
-0.8216620087623596,
0.1931341290473938,
0.16873012483119965,
-0.2883416414260864,
0.09402213990688324,
-0.26732856035232544,
-0.39790937304496765,
-0.0930805653333664,
0.011161783710122108,
0.038447216153144836,
-0.33915942907333374,
0.43687692284584045,
0.12028634548187256,
-0.05459413677453995,
0.3132028877735138,
-0.28843221068382263,
0.28209900856018066,
-0.09773877263069153,
-0.06343815475702286,
-0.3985605835914612,
0.40417855978012085,
0.33336782455444336,
-0.15464934706687927,
0.6855595111846924,
0.4134359359741211,
-0.43598291277885437,
0.17993901669979095,
-0.644698977470398,
-0.4042239189147949,
-0.41162583231925964,
0.47471946477890015,
-0.380461186170578,
-0.7759431600570679,
0.7901281118392944,
-0.02129967138171196,
0.3324333727359772,
0.7248080968856812,
0.28399723768234253,
-0.39762043952941895,
0.9438623785972595,
0.38022077083587646,
0.10710476338863373,
-0.0003347904421389103,
-0.18011371791362762,
0.05140247941017151,
-0.7732559442520142,
-0.41797611117362976,
-0.5833001732826233,
-0.4246869683265686,
-0.36352694034576416,
0.0837479904294014,
0.6305336952209473,
0.1959458887577057,
-0.5210046172142029,
0.13516202569007874,
-0.48015955090522766,
0.44453170895576477,
0.6711795330047607,
0.5738053321838379,
0.659456193447113,
-0.35490790009498596,
-0.04540508985519409,
0.0762590542435646,
-1.0475294589996338,
-0.5552954077720642,
1.2022260427474976,
0.3236640393733978,
0.31791630387306213,
0.165102019906044,
0.28558459877967834,
0.4322853982448578,
0.3103923499584198,
-0.5451636910438538,
0.336933434009552,
0.025464339181780815,
-0.7991880178451538,
-0.42497172951698303,
-0.3850645124912262,
-0.7810243964195251,
0.13466782867908478,
-0.31082066893577576,
-0.5508995056152344,
0.1740550994873047,
0.33858051896095276,
-0.5612481236457825,
0.11757925897836685,
-1.0686360597610474,
1.227326512336731,
0.1642640084028244,
-0.2786407768726349,
0.28178170323371887,
-0.6901856064796448,
0.5958121418952942,
0.0599200464785099,
-0.07457782328128815,
0.19823086261749268,
0.3690935969352722,
1.011549949645996,
-0.752082109451294,
0.4559216797351837,
-0.701088011264801,
0.08061716705560684,
0.6807795763015747,
0.15124252438545227,
0.7682520747184753,
0.2658155560493469,
-0.2013835459947586,
-0.23995237052440643,
0.5386303067207336,
-0.4527116119861603,
-0.8914216756820679,
0.24109889566898346,
-0.5676682591438293,
-0.61319899559021,
0.14413397014141083,
-0.6051881909370422,
-0.5915253162384033,
-0.031060589477419853,
-0.05717422440648079,
0.587961733341217,
0.3320388197898865,
0.4428021013736725,
0.7268055081367493,
-0.06770171970129013,
0.11048943549394608,
0.49077141284942627,
0.11268597841262817,
-0.21566447615623474,
0.6152184009552002,
0.2476605325937271,
-0.08465863019227982,
0.5843733549118042,
0.32769766449928284,
-0.8160219192504883,
-0.4755721390247345,
-0.5547290444374084,
-0.23468703031539917,
-0.8385249376296997,
-0.6033426523208618,
-0.9396350383758545,
-0.23925229907035828,
-0.14967449009418488,
0.26952576637268066,
0.040775276720523834,
-0.7198899984359741,
0.14213068783283234,
-0.22041600942611694,
0.6550713181495667,
0.3554264307022095,
0.3103024661540985,
0.39311325550079346,
-1.0592982769012451,
0.330186128616333,
0.8396921157836914,
0.4928281605243683,
0.00695324270054698,
-0.6680623292922974,
-0.08389279991388321,
0.06287527829408646,
-0.31914305686950684,
-1.0973713397979736,
0.20916984975337982,
0.11244139820337296,
0.5217931270599365,
-0.05090663209557533,
0.3006027936935425,
0.7124127149581909,
-0.07133056968450546,
0.594754695892334,
-0.41786324977874756,
-0.768383800983429,
0.6309208869934082,
-0.5523093938827515,
0.4824763834476471,
0.8401946425437927,
0.1667848527431488,
-0.44214263558387756,
-0.3081705570220947,
-0.6095610857009888,
-0.7906511425971985,
0.4898349940776825,
0.26898786425590515,
-0.3267110288143158,
0.10281241685152054,
0.6012584567070007,
0.16450698673725128,
0.17173637449741364,
-0.8704036474227905,
0.06836734712123871,
-0.3071599304676056,
-0.3337402939796448,
0.6271432042121887,
-0.29300379753112793,
-0.010205499827861786,
-0.05849764123558998,
0.8618667721748352,
-0.21230286359786987,
0.26311951875686646,
0.38664504885673523,
-0.30762070417404175,
-0.09992220997810364,
0.5357640981674194,
-0.028276117518544197,
0.7673900723457336,
-0.36222603917121887,
-0.0027132059913128614,
0.5254961848258972,
-0.472629576921463,
-0.21419736742973328,
0.14108321070671082,
-0.27199846506118774,
-0.18892335891723633,
0.092933289706707,
0.23833245038986206,
-0.19557838141918182,
-0.6417389512062073,
0.19704394042491913,
-0.054967667907476425,
-0.2745659053325653,
-0.11686601489782333,
0.0603189542889595,
0.20511789619922638,
0.5057165026664734,
0.5932624340057373,
-0.35078343749046326,
0.44347143173217773,
-0.35957130789756775,
0.44734635949134827,
0.3220081031322479,
-0.45528939366340637,
-0.05884341150522232,
0.6935775279998779,
0.10703499615192413,
-0.05723172798752785,
0.8810518980026245,
-0.07597760111093521,
-0.5822897553443909,
0.6539425253868103,
0.097015880048275,
0.33312538266181946,
0.0501164086163044,
0.1489047259092331,
0.529479444026947,
0.3189648985862732,
0.15017452836036682,
0.7860352993011475,
-0.05204182118177414,
-0.556022584438324,
-0.5808268785476685,
-0.701858401298523,
-0.32432302832603455,
0.3962384760379791,
-0.41454702615737915,
0.10296199470758438,
-0.21128465235233307,
0.10931625962257385,
-0.13933749496936798,
0.36599308252334595,
-0.8064530491828918,
0.4630061686038971,
-0.35477641224861145,
1.0522127151489258,
-0.7985058426856995,
0.5778939723968506,
0.49853354692459106,
-0.47181373834609985,
-1.2114800214767456,
-0.4255174398422241,
-0.5000171065330505,
-0.45703235268592834,
0.47793203592300415,
-0.09702058136463165,
0.5706697702407837,
0.22551554441452026,
-0.41059374809265137,
-0.9057618975639343,
1.2721714973449707,
0.3029934763908386,
-0.45354369282722473,
0.012947946786880493,
0.23853957653045654,
0.5450456738471985,
-0.0688239112496376,
0.3991982936859131,
0.7522121667861938,
0.6261564493179321,
0.24829545617103577,
-0.6685338616371155,
0.31482481956481934,
-0.28183358907699585,
-0.4229877293109894,
0.3741583824157715,
-0.46842020750045776,
0.275602251291275,
-0.05932201072573662,
-0.21275638043880463,
-0.10607248544692993,
0.7023908495903015,
0.48595088720321655,
0.3668193221092224,
0.42757999897003174,
0.8160949349403381,
0.6836152076721191,
-0.3031027615070343,
0.6954438090324402,
-0.14343909919261932,
0.08468995243310928,
1.1756916046142578,
-0.09539233148097992,
0.7718037366867065,
0.3273867666721344,
-0.2327846735715866,
0.7352810502052307,
0.676303505897522,
0.0955175831913948,
0.5420785546302795,
0.16383026540279388,
-0.006057016551494598,
-0.4642266035079956,
-0.13402637839317322,
-0.41757839918136597,
0.4951440691947937,
0.2638534605503082,
-0.38189345598220825,
-0.44683149456977844,
-0.5329644083976746,
-0.4010588824748993,
-0.0995761826634407,
-0.43859606981277466,
0.8952866792678833,
-0.1588187962770462,
-0.623865008354187,
0.07981975376605988,
-0.15805450081825256,
0.07241163402795792,
-0.5363705158233643,
-0.3490954041481018,
-0.29228445887565613,
-0.18339380621910095,
-0.3435332477092743,
-0.7183287143707275,
0.4208899736404419,
-0.16956323385238647,
-0.1982657015323639,
0.35325509309768677,
0.7931726574897766,
-0.3665463626384735,
-0.4214726388454437,
-0.3825839161872864,
0.9209945201873779,
0.0021640926133841276,
-0.3102852404117584,
-0.44139787554740906,
-0.4477400481700897,
-0.3423731327056885,
-0.22342367470264435,
0.12644177675247192,
0.5992860794067383,
-0.13005167245864868,
0.5664878487586975,
0.6934992074966431,
-0.3208746314048767,
0.10325861722230911,
0.04791451618075371,
1.0338162183761597,
-0.46804940700531006,
-0.7745371460914612,
-0.5154348015785217,
0.807174563407898,
-0.1289578378200531,
-0.152856707572937,
0.46258729696273804,
0.6165683269500732,
0.5181363224983215,
-0.08042257279157639,
0.6111589670181274,
-0.26314082741737366,
0.6896559596061707,
-0.5832093358039856,
0.7085447907447815,
-0.24059857428073883,
0.17667995393276215,
-0.4218587279319763,
-0.9660629034042358,
-0.15165327489376068,
0.29276716709136963,
-0.2602054476737976,
0.08683271706104279,
0.5647394061088562,
0.6654379367828369,
0.010608110576868057,
0.4041202664375305,
0.1449236422777176,
0.22594121098518372,
0.19283300638198853,
0.9040538668632507,
0.880570113658905,
-0.8460245132446289,
0.9340577721595764,
-0.2413439303636551,
0.017437733709812164,
0.16443993151187897,
-0.7127724289894104,
-0.7016571760177612,
-0.7009491324424744,
-0.3488200604915619,
-0.448842316865921,
0.14988771080970764,
0.5430586934089661,
0.7595037221908569,
-0.9606428146362305,
0.2969626188278198,
-0.2682926058769226,
0.026065532118082047,
-0.15467825531959534,
-0.32416054606437683,
0.7014595866203308,
-0.12158048152923584,
-0.20365013182163239,
0.2500957250595093,
-0.07975852489471436,
-0.21236252784729004,
0.07944952696561813,
0.24271062016487122,
-0.3033386170864105,
-0.08665958046913147,
0.6859864592552185,
0.34237179160118103,
-0.291899174451828,
-0.4294617772102356,
0.36252519488334656,
0.34190988540649414,
0.10040590912103653,
0.6350287199020386,
-1.2132861614227295,
0.4147428572177887,
0.4844743013381958,
0.904523491859436,
0.47880327701568604,
0.4484345614910126,
0.4915693998336792,
-0.8339818120002747,
-0.472053587436676,
0.3555499017238617,
0.244154691696167,
0.164498433470726,
-0.724030077457428,
0.5960869193077087,
0.06047368049621582,
-0.635479211807251,
-0.6252250075340271,
0.11196208000183105,
-0.9767332077026367,
-0.027422374114394188,
0.8750378489494324,
0.0025670442264527082,
-0.1496599167585373,
-0.6500377655029297,
-0.1490388810634613,
0.3566672205924988,
-0.5102637410163879,
1.2996340990066528,
0.7217705845832825,
-0.19497300684452057,
-0.28864994645118713,
-0.6767150163650513,
0.5997024774551392,
0.3735596835613251,
-1.1009598970413208,
0.07308821380138397,
0.5912470817565918,
0.3938486576080322,
-0.05172144994139671,
0.5505865812301636,
-0.31860318779945374,
0.5375288724899292,
-0.07797113060951233,
-0.16525736451148987,
-0.29719674587249756,
-0.23580458760261536,
0.0034796290565282106,
0.8306187987327576,
0.012319481931626797,
-0.15539398789405823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07990v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07990v1
|
Plot2Code: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Multi-modal Large Language Models in Code Generation from Scientific Plots
| 2024-05-13T17:59:22 | 2024-05-13T17:59:22 |
Chengyue Wu, Yixiao Ge, Qiushan Guo, Jiahao Wang, Zhixuan Liang, Zeyu Lu, Ying Shan, Ping Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The remarkable progress of Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs) has
attracted significant attention due to their superior performance in visual
contexts. However, their capabilities in turning visual figure to executable
code, have not been evaluated thoroughly. To address this, we introduce
Plot2Code, a comprehensive visual coding benchmark designed for a fair and
in-depth assessment of MLLMs. We carefully collect 132 manually selected
high-quality matplotlib plots across six plot types from publicly available
matplotlib galleries. For each plot, we carefully offer its source code, and an
descriptive instruction summarized by GPT-4. This approach enables Plot2Code to
extensively evaluate MLLMs' code capabilities across various input modalities.
Furthermore, we propose three automatic evaluation metrics, including code pass
rate, text-match ratio, and GPT-4V overall rating, for a fine-grained
assessment of the output code and rendered images. Instead of simply judging
pass or fail, we employ GPT-4V to make an overall judgement between the
generated and reference images, which has been shown to be consistent with
human evaluation. The evaluation results, which include analyses of 14 MLLMs
such as the proprietary GPT-4V, Gemini-Pro, and the open-sourced Mini-Gemini,
highlight the substantial challenges presented by Plot2Code. With Plot2Code, we
reveal that most existing MLLMs struggle with visual coding for text-dense
plots, heavily relying on textual instruction. We hope that the evaluation
results from Plot2Code on visual coding will guide the future development of
MLLMs. All data involved with Plot2Code are available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/TencentARC/Plot2Code.
|
[
-0.11926114559173584,
-0.2514266073703766,
0.45387333631515503,
0.5605055689811707,
-0.2735178470611572,
-0.012576153501868248,
-0.18901793658733368,
-0.40976235270500183,
-0.36213645339012146,
0.5170031189918518,
-0.10663799941539764,
-0.40495336055755615,
-0.6026118993759155,
0.060259755700826645,
-0.2148352712392807,
0.7732826471328735,
-0.09168222546577454,
0.2547532021999359,
-0.5902600288391113,
-0.12912076711654663,
-0.40378233790397644,
-0.6970766186714172,
-0.3534834086894989,
-0.08218427002429962,
0.4480855464935303,
-0.04609544575214386,
0.6498313546180725,
0.5733335018157959,
0.7217803597450256,
0.19215905666351318,
0.15628062188625336,
0.38044968247413635,
-0.6596978306770325,
0.08404555171728134,
0.01486972440034151,
-0.287193238735199,
-0.19995182752609253,
-0.1413416713476181,
0.5004213452339172,
0.3442188501358032,
0.38522428274154663,
0.37720683217048645,
-0.02794705145061016,
0.5633249878883362,
-0.5384495258331299,
0.6368790864944458,
-0.33448562026023865,
-0.010957767255604267,
-0.03989734873175621,
-0.25452888011932373,
-0.695171594619751,
-0.42619508504867554,
-0.34004542231559753,
-0.41420435905456543,
-0.1831386834383011,
0.04588085412979126,
0.6600129008293152,
0.27153581380844116,
-0.806064784526825,
-0.2894381582736969,
-0.2726839780807495,
0.6066155433654785,
-0.5768442749977112,
0.18401263654232025,
0.5302225947380066,
0.5191643834114075,
-0.04107953980565071,
-1.1601277589797974,
-0.3490394651889801,
-0.40639182925224304,
-0.18702135980129242,
0.2094954401254654,
-0.3898845613002777,
-0.08800578862428665,
0.5882124900817871,
-0.24867455661296844,
-0.9817443490028381,
0.049630969762802124,
-0.5864018201828003,
-0.3483215570449829,
0.5793666243553162,
0.09017004072666168,
0.3018311560153961,
-0.5543583035469055,
-0.31406864523887634,
-0.4066959321498871,
-0.5209981799125671,
0.14250892400741577,
0.3658082187175751,
-0.16731083393096924,
-0.3447534441947937,
0.7737927436828613,
0.03728098049759865,
0.2792930603027344,
-0.5339745283126831,
0.010006987489759922,
0.4722755253314972,
-0.3469123840332031,
-0.01328651886433363,
-0.3814795911312103,
0.9389245510101318,
0.9572441577911377,
0.43089938163757324,
0.13517282903194427,
-0.26421836018562317,
0.32858967781066895,
0.18097008764743805,
-1.2207865715026855,
-0.5687604546546936,
0.062081508338451385,
-0.6428278088569641,
-0.051205992698669434,
-0.007533061318099499,
-0.8094520568847656,
-0.5750992894172668,
-0.09265945106744766,
0.1916155368089676,
-0.41231104731559753,
-0.1469733715057373,
-0.2477504163980484,
-0.39250707626342773,
0.12136264890432358,
0.35214197635650635,
-0.4880632162094116,
-0.09051090478897095,
0.7703947424888611,
0.9773488640785217,
-0.11161237210035324,
-0.46338167786598206,
-0.6241477131843567,
0.026419715955853462,
-0.5451099276542664,
0.7294653654098511,
-0.5620474219322205,
-0.14190137386322021,
-0.07893035560846329,
-0.24818584322929382,
0.10297979414463043,
-0.48315808176994324,
0.4148145318031311,
-0.2949941158294678,
0.05577045679092407,
-0.3021296262741089,
-0.3990320861339569,
-0.12101465463638306,
0.0786919891834259,
-0.6549376845359802,
1.130140781402588,
0.4538092315196991,
-0.68733149766922,
0.4862067699432373,
-0.6049802899360657,
-0.30153360962867737,
0.10064389556646347,
-0.5340197086334229,
-0.44107919931411743,
-0.06992550939321518,
0.13367313146591187,
0.37577542662620544,
-0.45810213685035706,
0.39022886753082275,
-0.49182242155075073,
-0.4501115679740906,
0.48420870304107666,
-0.6362456679344177,
0.5734580159187317,
0.35722464323043823,
-0.4937095046043396,
0.4438086152076721,
-0.5239000916481018,
0.3777221739292145,
0.24005457758903503,
-0.05095178633928299,
-0.021664366126060486,
0.019935201853513718,
0.5446215271949768,
0.47066161036491394,
-0.024934861809015274,
-0.248800128698349,
0.48202821612358093,
-0.15789459645748138,
0.642834484577179,
0.4893207848072052,
-0.060689084231853485,
0.11145609617233276,
0.024669062346220016,
0.38544678688049316,
-0.3502599895000458,
0.2806122601032257,
-0.4938565790653229,
-0.8112778663635254,
-0.5062274932861328,
-0.3171030879020691,
0.08782755583524704,
0.3428027629852295,
-1.0469292402267456,
0.12778855860233307,
-0.25694718956947327,
-0.5308268666267395,
-0.12040606886148453,
0.02601710334420204,
0.5768049359321594,
-0.003934735897928476,
0.292574942111969,
-0.2707352638244629,
-0.37687426805496216,
-0.846649706363678,
0.08733529597520828,
-0.2050980031490326,
-0.2593975365161896,
0.3626263737678528,
0.671298086643219,
-0.3742116689682007,
0.7777412533760071,
-0.2683296203613281,
0.03111465647816658,
-0.09544188529253006,
0.26861241459846497,
-0.0007496052421629429,
0.3302026391029358,
0.8742075562477112,
-0.6506063938140869,
-0.4915449023246765,
0.19047637283802032,
-1.002404808998108,
-0.24948863685131073,
-0.15466749668121338,
-0.09940853714942932,
0.22322015464305878,
0.34959253668785095,
-0.45272892713546753,
0.42821377515792847,
0.7693355083465576,
-0.6591662168502808,
0.5836445093154907,
-0.5678347945213318,
0.335689902305603,
-0.4707183539867401,
0.46137404441833496,
-0.2685217261314392,
-0.1995788961648941,
-0.33532091975212097,
0.29853135347366333,
0.5633530020713806,
-0.29858988523483276,
-0.19301530718803406,
0.5210711359977722,
-0.4121844172477722,
-0.5287230610847473,
-0.24125687777996063,
-0.12244132161140442,
0.16119758784770966,
0.5632113218307495,
-0.04770585894584656,
0.8101280927658081,
0.5581486821174622,
0.05051172897219658,
0.5962849259376526,
0.02649872563779354,
-0.5273019671440125,
0.34989169239997864,
-0.6809892058372498,
0.2294495701789856,
-0.10406763106584549,
0.48739033937454224,
-0.8891845941543579,
-0.2881351709365845,
0.27135562896728516,
-0.19354768097400665,
0.12656092643737793,
-0.32093772292137146,
-0.7532282471656799,
-0.54637610912323,
-0.37359189987182617,
0.4598296880722046,
0.7980037331581116,
-0.4415194094181061,
0.16712947189807892,
-0.011406033299863338,
-0.06114557385444641,
-0.28273913264274597,
-0.7281472086906433,
0.46058255434036255,
0.11300405114889145,
-0.5529987215995789,
-0.2768142521381378,
-0.1265505850315094,
0.05962974578142166,
-0.15060143172740936,
0.061361104249954224,
0.07319992780685425,
-0.1876419633626938,
0.4241943061351776,
0.02595328353345394,
-0.05269969627261162,
-0.18745560944080353,
0.1649087518453598,
-0.41259655356407166,
0.24744971096515656,
-0.24215765297412872,
0.8093058466911316,
-0.09934768825769424,
-0.7329236268997192,
-0.19724754989147186,
0.2976475656032562,
0.713091254234314,
-0.5537109971046448,
0.09731817990541458,
0.964453399181366,
-0.15305642783641815,
-0.22125890851020813,
-0.16205669939517975,
0.07665359973907471,
-0.41842910647392273,
0.7755341529846191,
-0.40156471729278564,
-0.5968334078788757,
0.1866471767425537,
-0.0640505775809288,
-0.09234463423490524,
0.3404535949230194,
0.779945969581604,
0.051543187350034714,
1.0195783376693726,
0.42158058285713196,
0.4578700363636017,
0.08628757297992706,
-0.3365894854068756,
0.030122125521302223,
-0.4417060911655426,
-0.5614817142486572,
-0.2988320291042328,
-0.22325457632541656,
-0.3761090040206909,
-1.133928656578064,
0.4476340413093567,
0.3832985758781433,
-0.2947956919670105,
0.21903707087039948,
-0.5964215397834778,
0.38383591175079346,
0.4491896629333496,
-0.08528078347444534,
0.03418548032641411,
0.12061025202274323,
-0.07556603848934174,
-0.05570340156555176,
-0.6167992353439331,
-0.5702142119407654,
1.2558457851409912,
0.5072432160377502,
0.6854966282844543,
0.05559433996677399,
0.2665436565876007,
0.5573700666427612,
0.3849092125892639,
-0.4595681428909302,
0.40317514538764954,
-0.2013556957244873,
-0.2344837784767151,
-0.0253894180059433,
-0.7125580310821533,
-0.8315039873123169,
0.30220767855644226,
0.00675163883715868,
-0.5853999257087708,
0.0763905867934227,
0.1232864037156105,
0.07846063375473022,
-0.019299088045954704,
-0.94732666015625,
1.308668851852417,
-0.7481459379196167,
-0.36737462878227234,
-0.30425819754600525,
-0.6910141110420227,
0.3143277168273926,
-0.2096996009349823,
0.1421378254890442,
-0.23482435941696167,
-0.20814643800258636,
0.6665886044502258,
-0.28931480646133423,
0.7468555569648743,
-0.362338125705719,
-0.04434472322463989,
0.27341076731681824,
0.1788017451763153,
0.46439868211746216,
0.15139180421829224,
-0.013271504081785679,
0.2984198331832886,
0.36900651454925537,
-0.48907169699668884,
-0.5785931944847107,
0.5591433644294739,
-0.735569179058075,
0.37892991304397583,
-0.3367511034011841,
-0.43916410207748413,
-0.08020864427089691,
0.11058837920427322,
0.28848379850387573,
0.7366132736206055,
0.04904261976480484,
0.11851785331964493,
0.08189745992422104,
-0.5975649356842041,
0.40637364983558655,
0.028163190931081772,
-0.6953887343406677,
-0.6335687637329102,
1.054457426071167,
-0.20065295696258545,
0.2730514109134674,
0.19905464351177216,
0.020606989040970802,
-0.3065386712551117,
-0.5900885462760925,
-0.9121814370155334,
-0.008869343437254429,
-0.8954808712005615,
-0.4932325780391693,
-0.594875156879425,
-0.028704442083835602,
-0.34937259554862976,
-0.1034429594874382,
-0.37213611602783203,
-0.19033017754554749,
0.17641282081604004,
0.2844562530517578,
0.28595176339149475,
1.0466995239257812,
0.0962880477309227,
0.01597379520535469,
-0.5465144515037537,
0.31276363134384155,
0.11602505296468735,
0.46802037954330444,
-0.15898194909095764,
-0.12782010436058044,
-0.19471588730812073,
0.009832766838371754,
-0.15923798084259033,
-0.6710405349731445,
0.29142114520072937,
0.1753731667995453,
0.43912050127983093,
0.45358046889305115,
-0.00404057651758194,
0.5303081274032593,
-0.36220189929008484,
0.8161098957061768,
0.5196418762207031,
-0.7991426587104797,
0.30357617139816284,
-0.1402888000011444,
0.3228045105934143,
0.16155818104743958,
0.15072312951087952,
-0.5160544514656067,
-0.29603111743927,
-0.20252478122711182,
-0.7783330678939819,
0.6260408163070679,
0.408428430557251,
0.11126241832971573,
0.14892040193080902,
-0.014067612588405609,
0.2048683911561966,
0.23109745979309082,
-0.6703401207923889,
-0.17746491730213165,
-0.7708530426025391,
-0.2177840769290924,
-0.19203203916549683,
-0.46044978499412537,
-0.13403713703155518,
-0.16114301979541779,
-0.10719344764947891,
-0.5324296355247498,
0.6193450093269348,
-0.1291806846857071,
-0.2204904556274414,
-0.017200782895088196,
-0.12987060844898224,
0.6746907234191895,
0.8370826840400696,
-0.19229532778263092,
0.2527711093425751,
-0.23894529044628143,
-0.44083988666534424,
-0.15545769035816193,
0.26531580090522766,
-0.19427356123924255,
-0.15494441986083984,
0.9131052494049072,
1.0283387899398804,
0.10584200173616409,
-1.1762149333953857,
0.9552251100540161,
0.017758294939994812,
-0.26752525568008423,
0.11482037603855133,
-0.03325105458498001,
-0.049736179411411285,
0.3478681445121765,
0.3211541473865509,
0.43901926279067993,
0.15292438864707947,
-0.41971471905708313,
0.2735927700996399,
0.2595885396003723,
-0.12400221824645996,
-0.2710736095905304,
0.7081365585327148,
0.22620390355587006,
0.047460783272981644,
0.5581789016723633,
-0.5556422472000122,
-0.679220974445343,
0.7315691113471985,
0.5041170120239258,
0.6137859225273132,
0.36142733693122864,
0.27230197191238403,
0.5364506840705872,
0.5178471207618713,
0.2088409811258316,
0.2964276075363159,
0.019167520105838776,
-0.18233704566955566,
-0.7250557541847229,
-0.6030184626579285,
-0.27310311794281006,
-0.18720708787441254,
-0.41217106580734253,
0.1813354641199112,
-0.5442067384719849,
-0.041553936898708344,
-0.2793903350830078,
-0.11193302273750305,
-0.6092556118965149,
-0.1110486388206482,
0.674811601638794,
0.8284595608711243,
-0.6681004166603088,
0.9042708277702332,
0.6758418083190918,
-0.3155888617038727,
-0.5934336185455322,
-0.3131493926048279,
-0.017213964834809303,
-0.7198488116264343,
0.6456846594810486,
0.46823325753211975,
0.1279054582118988,
-0.2935827374458313,
-0.5367413759231567,
-0.6750603914260864,
1.016176700592041,
0.564003586769104,
-0.53329998254776,
0.16905103623867035,
0.26455309987068176,
0.6537861227989197,
-0.16484709084033966,
0.9227754473686218,
0.45113956928253174,
0.8165256381034851,
0.021337376907467842,
-1.125321865081787,
0.043179020285606384,
-0.5739151239395142,
0.10974834859371185,
-0.023283492773771286,
-0.5358466506004333,
0.631462574005127,
-0.30334708094596863,
-0.20685701072216034,
0.22965887188911438,
0.37228378653526306,
0.11842931807041168,
0.6484892964363098,
0.12130603939294815,
0.11668019741773605,
0.6457704305648804,
-0.2525632679462433,
1.16436767578125,
-0.4014931917190552,
0.5528886318206787,
0.8058462738990784,
-0.3524489402770996,
0.8585220575332642,
0.15898995101451874,
-0.4003157615661621,
0.18568512797355652,
0.3492760956287384,
-0.5184236168861389,
0.3993532955646515,
0.24671754240989685,
0.4549523890018463,
-0.12634767591953278,
0.16843552887439728,
-0.610954999923706,
0.46029630303382874,
0.19002628326416016,
-0.32574784755706787,
-0.25869542360305786,
0.310510516166687,
-0.023754050955176353,
0.07096431404352188,
-0.1607198864221573,
0.5071487426757812,
-0.04106456786394119,
-0.42261940240859985,
0.8451967239379883,
0.19852638244628906,
0.5571474432945251,
-0.8222314119338989,
-0.17495857179164886,
-0.3588283658027649,
0.0717916488647461,
-0.2532990574836731,
-1.0711077451705933,
0.14671631157398224,
0.22123728692531586,
0.07234489172697067,
-0.427266389131546,
0.48426884412765503,
-0.37314051389694214,
-0.4233744144439697,
0.34709012508392334,
0.30134278535842896,
0.3832187354564667,
-0.2283812165260315,
-0.7257933020591736,
0.610702633857727,
0.17438563704490662,
-0.16185538470745087,
0.31709355115890503,
0.4802035093307495,
-0.2573240399360657,
0.6467027068138123,
0.816735565662384,
-0.17017151415348053,
0.12266051769256592,
0.2905479967594147,
0.9559264779090881,
-0.5629987120628357,
-0.32586580514907837,
-0.5733386278152466,
0.427256315946579,
-0.19488397240638733,
-0.5352659225463867,
0.7646300792694092,
0.9425933361053467,
0.5119695067405701,
-0.21893294155597687,
0.747615396976471,
-0.24995633959770203,
-0.06309778243303299,
-0.4878990054130554,
0.8398386836051941,
-0.38867005705833435,
0.10073541104793549,
-0.32403531670570374,
-1.0489624738693237,
-0.3315829634666443,
0.4683457911014557,
-0.32492801547050476,
0.04849737882614136,
0.7073627710342407,
0.7358469367027283,
0.0151669355109334,
-0.33970946073532104,
0.4044446647167206,
0.1564597338438034,
0.6272041201591492,
0.7439226508140564,
0.8617104291915894,
-0.25710800290107727,
0.919701337814331,
-0.25316187739372253,
-0.4529232978820801,
-0.30437490344047546,
-0.816292405128479,
-0.9722898006439209,
-0.40034550428390503,
-0.2281358689069748,
-0.36084604263305664,
-0.05122651532292366,
0.7339482307434082,
0.7031282186508179,
-0.6830278635025024,
-0.22029957175254822,
0.24482911825180054,
-0.2813577950000763,
-0.36714741587638855,
-0.16392523050308228,
0.6634945869445801,
-0.07492665946483612,
-0.5783022046089172,
0.14634504914283752,
0.6375474333763123,
-0.18472780287265778,
-0.3112866282463074,
-0.5221145749092102,
0.47445520758628845,
-0.2997276782989502,
0.9386501908302307,
0.08390744775533676,
-0.6656396985054016,
-0.08249734342098236,
-0.2462262064218521,
-0.5152174830436707,
-0.12395919114351273,
1.0323609113693237,
-0.5889593958854675,
0.6439024209976196,
0.48713940382003784,
0.3942524790763855,
0.6837267279624939,
-0.05948180705308914,
0.2529495060443878,
-0.3750882148742676,
0.3016800582408905,
0.2260039895772934,
0.2664591372013092,
0.34265202283859253,
0.08867896348237991,
0.5819501876831055,
0.2937324345111847,
-0.469845712184906,
-0.9178061485290527,
0.09829376637935638,
-1.294270396232605,
-0.35643690824508667,
1.367661714553833,
-0.20317548513412476,
-0.004714989103376865,
0.08831146359443665,
-0.6045403480529785,
-0.2000712752342224,
-0.26073914766311646,
0.24011383950710297,
0.1315721571445465,
-0.20710021257400513,
-0.34131017327308655,
-0.7735379338264465,
0.37529611587524414,
-0.006670661270618439,
-0.8189833164215088,
0.26624855399131775,
0.7754197120666504,
0.061665989458560944,
-0.07966116815805435,
0.435287743806839,
-0.0018059535650536418,
0.43196311593055725,
0.572711706161499,
0.36896422505378723,
-0.5269734859466553,
-0.23966290056705475,
-0.07380624860525131,
0.3429321348667145,
0.1328604817390442,
0.4092678427696228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07960v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07960v3
|
AgentClinic: a multimodal agent benchmark to evaluate AI in simulated clinical environments
| 2024-05-13T17:38:53 | 2024-05-30T22:56:17 |
Samuel Schmidgall, Rojin Ziaei, Carl Harris, Eduardo Reis, Jeffrey Jopling, Michael Moor
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Diagnosing and managing a patient is a complex, sequential decision making
process that requires physicians to obtain information -- such as which tests
to perform -- and to act upon it. Recent advances in artificial intelligence
(AI) and large language models (LLMs) promise to profoundly impact clinical
care. However, current evaluation schemes overrely on static medical
question-answering benchmarks, falling short on interactive decision-making
that is required in real-life clinical work. Here, we present AgentClinic: a
multimodal benchmark to evaluate LLMs in their ability to operate as agents in
simulated clinical environments. In our benchmark, the doctor agent must
uncover the patient's diagnosis through dialogue and active data collection. We
present two open medical agent benchmarks: a multimodal image and dialogue
environment, AgentClinic-NEJM, and a dialogue-only environment,
AgentClinic-MedQA. We embed cognitive and implicit biases both in patient and
doctor agents to emulate realistic interactions between biased agents. We find
that introducing bias leads to large reductions in diagnostic accuracy of the
doctor agents, as well as reduced compliance, confidence, and follow-up
consultation willingness in patient agents. Evaluating a suite of
state-of-the-art LLMs, we find that several models that excel in benchmarks
like MedQA are performing poorly in AgentClinic-MedQA. We find that the LLM
used in the patient agent is an important factor for performance in the
AgentClinic benchmark. We show that both having limited interactions as well as
too many interaction reduces diagnostic accuracy in doctor agents. The code and
data for this work is publicly available at https://AgentClinic.github.io.
|
[
-0.4666888117790222,
-0.6826529502868652,
0.9391103982925415,
-0.08620809018611908,
-0.011731617152690887,
0.1784675270318985,
-0.4428552985191345,
-0.6009259223937988,
-0.06470842659473419,
0.47642117738723755,
-0.6250033974647522,
-0.6603296995162964,
-0.4314795136451721,
0.14931796491146088,
0.02475551888346672,
0.8188502192497253,
-0.1810990422964096,
0.629780113697052,
-0.8057066798210144,
-0.461180716753006,
-0.32998499274253845,
-0.3803447186946869,
-0.7027808427810669,
-0.6145204901695251,
0.3215031027793884,
0.2083480805158615,
1.0035630464553833,
0.47248575091362,
0.51573646068573,
0.3749890625476837,
0.33056700229644775,
0.5595330595970154,
-0.14039745926856995,
0.642387866973877,
-0.05808098986744881,
-0.1730024218559265,
-0.5676476359367371,
0.14925050735473633,
0.450880229473114,
0.6813938021659851,
-0.13324742019176483,
-0.07074274867773056,
-0.6200828552246094,
0.22524085640907288,
-0.5887663960456848,
0.5155380368232727,
-0.02285051718354225,
0.02773655764758587,
0.19323787093162537,
-0.05957326292991638,
-0.498157262802124,
-0.23481832444667816,
0.2388094663619995,
-0.7383571267127991,
0.15012460947036743,
-0.08872295171022415,
0.6543551683425903,
0.4231147766113281,
-0.5758013725280762,
-0.30986475944519043,
-0.6957734823226929,
0.32624611258506775,
-0.3184185326099396,
0.18117909133434296,
0.3919623792171478,
0.7225012183189392,
-0.056414611637592316,
-0.7333757281303406,
-0.41287848353385925,
-0.5655802488327026,
-0.013822502456605434,
0.33890438079833984,
-0.09974076598882675,
0.2805701196193695,
0.22622226178646088,
-0.10824508219957352,
-0.49832603335380554,
-0.013347707688808441,
-0.0863547995686531,
-0.2826577425003052,
0.5696906447410583,
0.4990161061286926,
0.35073235630989075,
0.16305135190486908,
-0.34263819456100464,
-0.5337249636650085,
-0.44973593950271606,
-0.19112351536750793,
-0.20483970642089844,
-0.09872768819332123,
-0.016456838697195053,
0.2904597520828247,
0.006209430750459433,
0.35100457072257996,
-0.2690775990486145,
-0.29315483570098877,
0.33833515644073486,
-0.2858854830265045,
0.09376846253871918,
0.1274302750825882,
0.6154384016990662,
0.652320921421051,
0.3738603889942169,
-0.09319373965263367,
-0.10719377547502518,
0.38986530900001526,
0.5261181592941284,
-0.6423658132553101,
-0.20898345112800598,
0.44618213176727295,
-0.38549426198005676,
-0.04051564633846283,
-0.07891654223203659,
-0.5693959593772888,
-0.6871826648712158,
-0.1972380429506302,
0.16625124216079712,
-0.4402134120464325,
-0.27361246943473816,
-0.10395098477602005,
-0.030869964510202408,
0.05918038263916969,
0.6329270601272583,
-0.09982394427061081,
0.6447986364364624,
0.5567503571510315,
0.630121648311615,
-0.10039888322353363,
-0.30785632133483887,
-0.6437852382659912,
0.10689140111207962,
-0.41951507329940796,
0.9749372601509094,
-0.6760202646255493,
-0.5514163374900818,
0.01095414999872446,
0.1444576531648636,
-0.37894320487976074,
-0.8921143412590027,
0.338485449552536,
-0.17209722101688385,
-0.06410128623247147,
-0.024579010903835297,
-0.34719765186309814,
-0.07265970855951309,
0.5300441980361938,
-0.6766969561576843,
0.5451135635375977,
0.28711017966270447,
-0.25037381052970886,
0.330623060464859,
-0.8446276187896729,
-0.27978551387786865,
0.18864163756370544,
-0.4103536903858185,
-0.48342204093933105,
-0.22698469460010529,
0.20659281313419342,
0.15733051300048828,
-0.6666548848152161,
0.31023845076560974,
-0.35573089122772217,
-0.1089087426662445,
0.6594583988189697,
-0.37352460622787476,
0.3906542956829071,
0.22712115943431854,
-0.2578871548175812,
0.27957379817962646,
-0.4289012551307678,
0.21599537134170532,
0.07754426449537277,
0.14079822599887848,
-0.12633226811885834,
0.016955692321062088,
0.013586155138909817,
0.40222904086112976,
-0.03965022414922714,
-0.3470971882343292,
0.2899925410747528,
-0.21480214595794678,
0.27675727009773254,
0.5476826429367065,
0.08069773018360138,
0.06668393313884735,
-0.6955274343490601,
0.8798232078552246,
0.1046680137515068,
0.4526163935661316,
-0.08570022135972977,
-0.48907139897346497,
-0.635328471660614,
-0.7112388014793396,
0.22373554110527039,
0.4700363576412201,
-0.9803432822227478,
-0.28946948051452637,
-0.3453903794288635,
-0.49517497420310974,
-0.8451852202415466,
-0.11819234490394592,
0.74687260389328,
0.3644503355026245,
0.3074871599674225,
-0.5599956512451172,
0.02487710490822792,
-0.991584300994873,
-0.12616302073001862,
-0.29721495509147644,
0.19923046231269836,
0.7345817685127258,
0.4993452727794647,
-0.5382751822471619,
0.5874270796775818,
-0.3803078830242157,
-0.33196184039115906,
-0.30045998096466064,
0.2179991602897644,
-0.04220572113990784,
0.409701943397522,
0.3959138095378876,
-0.5659511685371399,
-0.3058301508426666,
0.09411392360925674,
-0.8472367525100708,
-0.19967253506183624,
-0.1624884307384491,
0.0006637132610194385,
0.04997715353965759,
0.39180946350097656,
-0.8940462470054626,
0.6620646715164185,
0.4396750330924988,
-0.4084279537200928,
0.34029626846313477,
-0.7045389413833618,
0.3106478750705719,
-0.7463589310646057,
0.14993901550769806,
0.00242781825363636,
-0.6854206323623657,
-0.6784421801567078,
0.22825759649276733,
-0.0972941666841507,
-0.0625513345003128,
-0.4660973846912384,
0.7906937003135681,
-0.5620326399803162,
-0.170088529586792,
-0.1715136617422104,
0.18076853454113007,
0.0733921155333519,
0.18022464215755463,
0.06984584033489227,
0.868069052696228,
0.4006512761116028,
-0.31589019298553467,
0.5086678862571716,
0.20475727319717407,
-0.19384633004665375,
0.6950481534004211,
-0.6242564916610718,
0.21579551696777344,
-0.14204563200473785,
0.4356898069381714,
-0.7114592790603638,
-0.08632544428110123,
0.3798663020133972,
-0.2609531581401825,
0.1816837042570114,
0.03307883068919182,
-0.8428699970245361,
-0.14716486632823944,
-0.1955367922782898,
0.8238580226898193,
0.3352181315422058,
-0.19563385844230652,
0.9269852042198181,
0.2784670293331146,
-0.20664756000041962,
-0.205770343542099,
-0.37847602367401123,
-0.014094002544879913,
0.2051498144865036,
-0.5601269602775574,
0.16013242304325104,
-0.2313978672027588,
-0.5040915608406067,
-0.16525137424468994,
0.17356644570827484,
-0.15541747212409973,
0.05243011191487312,
0.5898469090461731,
0.4031333029270172,
-0.10148012638092041,
0.23979347944259644,
0.09367971867322922,
-0.37695246934890747,
0.23751933872699738,
0.17235147953033447,
0.6301267743110657,
-0.4492414593696594,
-0.8052967190742493,
-0.29045912623405457,
0.2602640986442566,
0.9089492559432983,
-0.29685941338539124,
0.6337530612945557,
0.427580326795578,
-0.2851240038871765,
-0.18491357564926147,
-0.6504190564155579,
-0.37826982140541077,
-0.3538902997970581,
0.26459693908691406,
-0.3070846498012543,
-0.28857216238975525,
0.6028000116348267,
-0.5351813435554504,
-0.25796180963516235,
0.34519484639167786,
0.8891849517822266,
0.22320373356342316,
1.360978126525879,
0.007286934647709131,
0.2615075409412384,
-0.10958168655633926,
-0.1786384880542755,
-0.09185510128736496,
-0.6858857274055481,
-0.38734376430511475,
-0.26694023609161377,
0.0525389239192009,
-0.7048004865646362,
-0.8196237087249756,
1.0418869256973267,
-0.6601336002349854,
0.06634555011987686,
-0.20270878076553345,
-0.457049161195755,
0.20962287485599518,
0.2998238205909729,
0.367508202791214,
0.381450891494751,
-0.3997429609298706,
-0.4365391135215759,
0.19697050750255585,
-0.6572359204292297,
-0.4113045334815979,
1.2028316259384155,
0.4130571782588959,
0.5499655604362488,
0.22669564187526703,
0.2981127202510834,
0.49135202169418335,
0.5767706632614136,
-0.5390119552612305,
0.47933629155158997,
0.18283209204673767,
-0.8071291446685791,
0.043241944164037704,
-0.3414284586906433,
-1.0742865800857544,
0.5496705174446106,
-0.2907565236091614,
-0.30142343044281006,
0.11624174565076828,
-0.1817297637462616,
-0.3191453814506531,
-0.1623965948820114,
-0.6500185132026672,
1.0346871614456177,
-0.20397821068763733,
-0.47782450914382935,
-0.45297807455062866,
-0.9073140025138855,
-0.04490501061081886,
0.16701310873031616,
0.3240903615951538,
-0.3555399179458618,
-0.3137325942516327,
0.17681613564491272,
-0.5444426536560059,
0.7093517780303955,
-0.17206189036369324,
0.2887003421783447,
-0.0631433054804802,
0.16211384534835815,
0.2527805268764496,
0.42803865671157837,
-0.06889978051185608,
-0.01481693796813488,
0.3819020986557007,
-0.448851078748703,
-0.6327733993530273,
0.5420951843261719,
-0.9694540500640869,
-0.3256382942199707,
-0.8585739135742188,
-0.51432865858078,
-0.49816519021987915,
0.04307851567864418,
-0.1295865923166275,
0.7551420331001282,
-0.48007458448410034,
-0.2631472647190094,
0.4862675666809082,
-0.2722984850406647,
0.038659993559122086,
0.8706522583961487,
-0.03208114579319954,
-0.32453152537345886,
0.7168651819229126,
-0.2060319185256958,
0.2896144390106201,
-0.13761010766029358,
-0.008374450728297234,
-0.2964228391647339,
-0.4873385727405548,
-0.5606333613395691,
0.4464786946773529,
-0.9486969709396362,
-0.11182685196399689,
-0.5955687165260315,
-0.3471757769584656,
-0.12423878163099289,
0.04914257675409317,
-0.55088871717453,
-0.0107425507158041,
-0.08598984777927399,
0.2829611599445343,
0.15871556103229523,
0.7124689221382141,
0.12262184172868729,
-0.10315575450658798,
-0.5289950966835022,
0.24511070549488068,
0.09146489202976227,
0.15962427854537964,
-0.23351682722568512,
0.012682733125984669,
-0.17929786443710327,
-0.05615941435098648,
-0.22366774082183838,
-0.6436068415641785,
0.44788071513175964,
0.19649358093738556,
0.7610818147659302,
0.4693991541862488,
0.30071043968200684,
0.47015872597694397,
-0.3481663167476654,
0.49760550260543823,
-0.021893491968512535,
-0.7944865822792053,
0.34963259100914,
-0.17970919609069824,
0.4250459372997284,
0.8897119760513306,
0.2177383303642273,
-0.414924681186676,
-0.5243609547615051,
-0.5490821599960327,
-0.559309720993042,
0.6108600497245789,
0.21144919097423553,
-0.3499751687049866,
-0.12291434407234192,
0.24424757063388824,
0.05957711115479469,
0.39088666439056396,
-0.32494238018989563,
-0.35035622119903564,
0.03622753173112869,
-0.35045671463012695,
-0.34457165002822876,
0.10455542057752609,
-0.6942996978759766,
-0.2976527214050293,
0.2645348012447357,
-0.3977912664413452,
0.5081453919410706,
0.581066370010376,
-0.29412341117858887,
0.02821953035891056,
0.12829254567623138,
0.7808519005775452,
0.74066162109375,
-0.023945767432451248,
0.1177552342414856,
0.1503152996301651,
-0.36751651763916016,
0.04808398708701134,
0.4984540641307831,
0.31248700618743896,
0.061061032116413116,
0.6943694353103638,
0.5507363080978394,
0.058133386075496674,
-1.3455419540405273,
0.796410858631134,
-0.3778325319290161,
-0.17355976998806,
-0.4856172800064087,
-0.015042887069284916,
-0.22806352376937866,
0.5865145921707153,
-0.014132758602499962,
0.14264808595180511,
0.3423120975494385,
-0.698975145816803,
0.056604303419589996,
0.5452069640159607,
-0.6114939451217651,
-0.1090036928653717,
0.4985946714878082,
0.18719357252120972,
-0.22540685534477234,
0.8354287147521973,
-0.1933673471212387,
-0.3542347252368927,
0.917078971862793,
0.21038872003555298,
0.6716294288635254,
-0.08645756542682648,
0.48258596658706665,
-0.1621149480342865,
0.23420937359333038,
-0.005551406182348728,
0.13838976621627808,
0.063535176217556,
-0.5990219712257385,
-0.19518373906612396,
0.15572160482406616,
-0.9068025946617126,
-0.22476185858249664,
-0.698091447353363,
-0.05731423571705818,
-0.6098692417144775,
-0.5609602332115173,
0.07444565743207932,
0.1463892012834549,
-0.7339163422584534,
0.12916913628578186,
-0.0002628819493111223,
0.6167190074920654,
-0.46716928482055664,
0.826184093952179,
0.9034188985824585,
-0.2973543107509613,
-0.5160336494445801,
-0.24157452583312988,
0.17480714619159698,
-0.9582291841506958,
0.2974347770214081,
0.1908482313156128,
-0.047419510781764984,
-0.46971696615219116,
-0.38501837849617004,
-0.2912580072879791,
1.1973848342895508,
0.3242148160934448,
-0.01975962333381176,
0.1677989512681961,
0.1465393751859665,
1.023375153541565,
-0.8658891916275024,
1.0394158363342285,
0.5058977603912354,
0.6215549111366272,
-0.08816088736057281,
-1.1442314386367798,
0.24037142097949982,
-0.6343381404876709,
-0.11631882935762405,
0.045262616127729416,
-0.7725821733474731,
0.947974681854248,
-0.1112014576792717,
-0.11651540547609329,
0.284155011177063,
-0.1573820859193802,
0.2728061079978943,
0.7650622129440308,
0.5635368824005127,
0.2834196984767914,
0.6184468269348145,
-0.17656594514846802,
1.3179659843444824,
-0.5729597806930542,
0.14718803763389587,
0.763653039932251,
-0.6469920873641968,
0.5166501402854919,
0.19977593421936035,
0.15847833454608917,
0.607754111289978,
0.45328816771507263,
-0.0923859104514122,
0.2711281478404999,
0.14122866094112396,
-0.443915456533432,
-0.5450239181518555,
-0.5636774897575378,
-0.5957927703857422,
0.48642393946647644,
0.4417077600955963,
-0.34495508670806885,
0.01891988515853882,
0.11826320737600327,
0.03633514419198036,
0.08259765058755875,
0.03308717906475067,
0.9633141756057739,
-0.07901111245155334,
-0.7777599692344666,
0.6392678022384644,
-0.0993262305855751,
-0.11733566969633102,
-0.5356533527374268,
-0.22703993320465088,
-0.030470706522464752,
0.3526797592639923,
0.12990005314350128,
-0.40712207555770874,
-0.27641475200653076,
-0.3840107023715973,
-0.13094386458396912,
-0.26745229959487915,
0.4846239984035492,
-0.31354308128356934,
-0.43296030163764954,
0.4943315386772156,
0.8488793969154358,
0.31379857659339905,
-0.009829629212617874,
-0.9315391778945923,
0.24573688209056854,
-0.4663577079772949,
-0.000392850924981758,
0.3916816711425781,
0.24805167317390442,
-0.08761016279459,
1.1234766244888306,
0.501179575920105,
0.18737547099590302,
-0.4345859885215759,
0.33138978481292725,
1.1340640783309937,
-0.45269832015037537,
-0.15228669345378876,
-0.48007360100746155,
0.09125278145074844,
-0.16548855602741241,
-0.3126145899295807,
0.31342020630836487,
0.3875875771045685,
0.3518138527870178,
0.03376058489084244,
0.5603492259979248,
0.45952531695365906,
0.5108718872070312,
-0.3199819326400757,
0.6868013143539429,
-0.666487455368042,
0.2745620608329773,
-0.17360009253025055,
-0.4755591154098511,
-0.06939931958913803,
0.5674373507499695,
-0.362269788980484,
0.40720728039741516,
0.8822054266929626,
0.7868411540985107,
0.29335904121398926,
-0.12327147275209427,
0.404212087392807,
0.3289875090122223,
0.41217419505119324,
0.6935200691223145,
1.011185646057129,
-0.1987128108739853,
0.20451544225215912,
-0.12670959532260895,
-0.2524700164794922,
-0.3246563971042633,
-0.4092368483543396,
-1.0791183710098267,
-0.3686913251876831,
-0.3613559305667877,
-0.46512722969055176,
0.4763653874397278,
1.2865216732025146,
0.9776932597160339,
-0.41175442934036255,
-0.07474175840616226,
0.2702309489250183,
0.0623052679002285,
-0.44401076436042786,
-0.14248718321323395,
0.08100980520248413,
0.027269555255770683,
-0.6292170286178589,
0.4450213313102722,
0.3819826543331146,
-0.0279216505587101,
-0.5422329902648926,
-0.3014217019081116,
-0.040789708495140076,
0.03960995748639107,
0.40529665350914,
0.1860455870628357,
-0.7771581411361694,
0.03591719642281532,
-0.07976433634757996,
-0.33356454968452454,
0.2155158668756485,
0.758489191532135,
-0.996096670627594,
0.8626461029052734,
-0.15356799960136414,
0.47860950231552124,
0.5549530386924744,
0.18763421475887299,
0.6490823030471802,
-0.06974606215953827,
0.14806398749351501,
0.6631932258605957,
0.0016944223316386342,
0.10908299684524536,
-0.20276309549808502,
0.4229153096675873,
0.15580536425113678,
-0.5681744813919067,
-0.7282225489616394,
-0.008991872891783714,
-0.9647799134254456,
-0.5167481303215027,
0.9669251441955566,
-0.23492005467414856,
-0.2546214461326599,
-0.4259161353111267,
-0.18401813507080078,
-0.0391397699713707,
-0.6321916580200195,
0.5194525122642517,
0.3952510356903076,
-0.3919064998626709,
-0.2153623402118683,
-0.740496814250946,
0.4502250552177429,
0.506964921951294,
-0.9448504447937012,
-0.3568451404571533,
0.6210787296295166,
0.17834948003292084,
0.11642264574766159,
0.7678309679031372,
-0.07696454972028732,
0.6297429203987122,
0.11337157338857651,
0.09673609584569931,
-0.3024499714374542,
-0.4027198255062103,
-0.11762837320566177,
0.1693035066127777,
0.16995716094970703,
0.0353710800409317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07940v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07940v2
|
RAID: A Shared Benchmark for Robust Evaluation of Machine-Generated Text Detectors
| 2024-05-13T17:15:14 | 2024-06-10T15:51:16 |
Liam Dugan, Alyssa Hwang, Filip Trhlik, Josh Magnus Ludan, Andrew Zhu, Hainiu Xu, Daphne Ippolito, Chris Callison-Burch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Many commercial and open-source models claim to detect machine-generated text
with extremely high accuracy (99% or more). However, very few of these
detectors are evaluated on shared benchmark datasets and even when they are,
the datasets used for evaluation are insufficiently challenging-lacking
variations in sampling strategy, adversarial attacks, and open-source
generative models. In this work we present RAID: the largest and most
challenging benchmark dataset for machine-generated text detection. RAID
includes over 6 million generations spanning 11 models, 8 domains, 11
adversarial attacks and 4 decoding strategies. Using RAID, we evaluate the
out-of-domain and adversarial robustness of 8 open- and 4 closed-source
detectors and find that current detectors are easily fooled by adversarial
attacks, variations in sampling strategies, repetition penalties, and unseen
generative models. We release our data along with a leaderboard to encourage
future research.
|
[
-0.554864764213562,
-0.6391018629074097,
0.5102251768112183,
-0.07674010843038559,
-0.07942753285169601,
0.1228579431772232,
-0.08739517629146576,
-0.21176846325397491,
-0.06298206001520157,
0.3766027092933655,
-0.4161739945411682,
-0.6185978651046753,
-0.8671351075172424,
0.3797161877155304,
-0.678260326385498,
1.0032265186309814,
-0.14831197261810303,
-0.10584842413663864,
-0.11116110533475876,
-0.3411024510860443,
-0.33160585165023804,
-0.7251356840133667,
-0.1322956681251526,
0.15695831179618835,
0.2089359313249588,
0.023104248568415642,
0.3699110746383667,
0.33631202578544617,
0.9462489485740662,
0.2821651101112366,
-0.034861788153648376,
0.5118218660354614,
-0.6400670409202576,
0.3836328387260437,
-0.13290296494960785,
-0.19773131608963013,
-0.24322375655174255,
-0.06847580522298813,
0.8444916009902954,
0.43415147066116333,
0.2131866067647934,
0.13390599191188812,
-0.10725218057632446,
0.6641827821731567,
-1.011220097541809,
-0.18974819779396057,
-0.7956849336624146,
0.01664668880403042,
-0.6757165193557739,
-0.1015806794166565,
-0.7429584264755249,
-0.374237596988678,
-0.17161838710308075,
-0.4112878143787384,
0.6512409448623657,
0.03805188462138176,
0.6582068204879761,
0.2359611839056015,
-0.44674497842788696,
-0.5342814326286316,
-0.7067326307296753,
0.8963866829872131,
-0.12008447200059891,
0.26538965106010437,
0.30655306577682495,
0.5750795006752014,
-0.3259403705596924,
-0.7110335826873779,
-0.5687070488929749,
0.302999883890152,
0.24142639338970184,
0.054848603904247284,
-0.41621455550193787,
-0.25114890933036804,
0.17193736135959625,
0.5229989290237427,
-0.7874197959899902,
-0.015963973477482796,
0.0576164573431015,
-0.20528332889080048,
0.4042666256427765,
0.21934844553470612,
0.32424598932266235,
-0.011426250450313091,
-0.739490270614624,
-0.5800804495811462,
-0.45669156312942505,
-0.2745670676231384,
0.4950673282146454,
0.18087433278560638,
0.19590359926223755,
0.49378740787506104,
-0.1054215356707573,
0.6388113498687744,
-0.09985213726758957,
0.2138177752494812,
0.2183966040611267,
-0.34438395500183105,
-0.20606619119644165,
-0.23436060547828674,
1.0590863227844238,
0.4342106282711029,
-0.15196676552295685,
-0.29058271646499634,
-0.5556674003601074,
0.5591663718223572,
0.4720423221588135,
-0.8914729952812195,
-0.2739676833152771,
0.12071400135755539,
-0.6565178632736206,
-0.6602808833122253,
0.1307690441608429,
-1.1030268669128418,
-0.801706850528717,
0.41213110089302063,
0.6398580074310303,
-0.23569472134113312,
0.029817091301083565,
0.022862009704113007,
-0.3774564564228058,
-0.1487046182155609,
-0.08355150371789932,
-0.8287840485572815,
0.28881534934043884,
0.6596976518630981,
0.6927729845046997,
-0.685905396938324,
-0.3656887412071228,
-0.7605872750282288,
-0.18220357596874237,
-0.47266870737075806,
1.065191388130188,
-0.47326406836509705,
-0.4608140289783478,
-0.009785686619579792,
-0.035250935703516006,
-0.08068342506885529,
-0.7259037494659424,
0.9967623353004456,
-0.6224502325057983,
0.22090905904769897,
-0.372339129447937,
-0.7229152917861938,
0.05681416019797325,
0.33477991819381714,
-0.9336926341056824,
0.9265776872634888,
0.23486177623271942,
-0.7084648013114929,
0.7690006494522095,
-0.5098500847816467,
-0.3713836967945099,
0.21792049705982208,
-0.1440218836069107,
-0.7919238209724426,
0.14207454025745392,
0.5527875423431396,
0.38861796259880066,
-0.46663898229599,
0.294093519449234,
-0.45610639452934265,
-0.6385359764099121,
0.4673270583152771,
-0.7155604958534241,
0.7907437682151794,
0.381889283657074,
-0.36138656735420227,
-0.05894608050584793,
-0.9077292084693909,
0.070501908659935,
0.21508485078811646,
-0.24334512650966644,
-0.20126546919345856,
-0.17830879986286163,
0.20068515837192535,
-0.40166202187538147,
0.15238963067531586,
-0.5440676808357239,
0.02898721769452095,
0.07689816504716873,
0.0957559198141098,
0.8715274930000305,
0.16486604511737823,
0.20624125003814697,
-0.4165038764476776,
0.5170256495475769,
-0.12995478510856628,
0.10673686116933823,
-0.45864182710647583,
-0.39173445105552673,
-0.3404656946659088,
-0.5412700176239014,
0.3653833866119385,
0.36307570338249207,
-0.9062299132347107,
0.3954530656337738,
-0.2854658365249634,
-0.5743697285652161,
-0.37458693981170654,
0.10066171735525131,
0.5569689273834229,
0.2756839096546173,
0.3331955075263977,
-0.43341031670570374,
-0.6468601822853088,
-0.5598101019859314,
-0.5854014158248901,
0.05797898396849632,
-0.011455191299319267,
0.16956466436386108,
0.6784393191337585,
-0.5322220921516418,
0.5029200315475464,
-0.511189341545105,
-0.17427004873752594,
-0.005996691528707743,
0.26703372597694397,
0.06435555964708328,
0.21983398497104645,
0.5106605887413025,
-0.8581466674804688,
-0.39617303013801575,
-0.2245047688484192,
-1.0955265760421753,
0.0477101095020771,
-0.06905563920736313,
-0.04641411080956459,
0.3791413903236389,
0.23015540838241577,
-0.3958195149898529,
0.3499003052711487,
0.6950576901435852,
-0.23426581919193268,
0.44988563656806946,
-0.18562911450862885,
0.5102270841598511,
-0.9217681288719177,
0.07686904072761536,
-0.18022438883781433,
-0.16863881051540375,
-0.5785559415817261,
0.598905086517334,
0.23550815880298615,
-0.3531639575958252,
-0.008824682794511318,
0.22446958720684052,
-0.33363765478134155,
-0.2740331292152405,
-0.3444961607456207,
-0.05316638946533203,
0.06832527369260788,
0.3932727575302124,
-0.4194495975971222,
1.0901514291763306,
0.45231330394744873,
-0.5073256492614746,
0.5921019315719604,
0.18920856714248657,
-0.8443378806114197,
0.8439462184906006,
-0.627112090587616,
0.3965190649032593,
-0.017822623252868652,
0.4389810264110565,
-0.883696973323822,
-0.33989405632019043,
0.10517357289791107,
-0.5466821193695068,
0.20460450649261475,
0.01412170473486185,
-0.7619349956512451,
-0.3531525135040283,
-0.3597337603569031,
0.381119042634964,
0.4354347586631775,
-1.1846078634262085,
0.26120641827583313,
0.5750019550323486,
0.3193844258785248,
-0.6620784401893616,
-0.6857127547264099,
0.2042870819568634,
-0.08219916373491287,
-0.6328354477882385,
0.3174818158149719,
-0.2904534935951233,
-0.17895647883415222,
-0.06779008358716965,
-0.08848103880882263,
-0.1374123990535736,
0.14220155775547028,
0.29168465733528137,
0.3002268373966217,
-0.16553980112075806,
-0.057089146226644516,
-0.3020728826522827,
-0.15413758158683777,
-0.029799409210681915,
-0.2714625895023346,
0.6870760321617126,
-0.2493341714143753,
-0.5362868309020996,
-0.3197369873523712,
0.337311714887619,
0.7931212186813354,
-0.0893406942486763,
0.7774340510368347,
0.685300350189209,
-0.4988778829574585,
-0.5061675310134888,
-0.33504924178123474,
0.044859860092401505,
-0.49536171555519104,
0.04650595411658287,
-0.43023014068603516,
-0.6345099210739136,
0.3964086174964905,
0.10152918100357056,
-0.15141098201274872,
0.44363540410995483,
0.5112296938896179,
0.024923089891672134,
1.014485478401184,
0.21413543820381165,
-0.11320134252309799,
0.0847286507487297,
-0.11931747943162918,
0.25046560168266296,
-0.49513065814971924,
-0.18920466303825378,
-0.5960949659347534,
-0.1614311933517456,
-0.7559323310852051,
-0.4086947739124298,
0.26853302121162415,
-0.07158206403255463,
-0.15084491670131683,
0.5206455588340759,
-0.7075477242469788,
0.4522647261619568,
0.6213115453720093,
0.17536194622516632,
0.19167353212833405,
0.18389588594436646,
-0.009290199726819992,
-0.02821171283721924,
-0.13215836882591248,
-0.3333154618740082,
1.4820129871368408,
0.038292597979307175,
0.6012186408042908,
0.1518377661705017,
0.7867301106452942,
0.7890721559524536,
0.06768668442964554,
-0.30653366446495056,
0.5463255047798157,
-0.4761098325252533,
-0.7749282717704773,
0.10279246419668198,
-0.5919741988182068,
-0.915288507938385,
0.0894865095615387,
-0.28873375058174133,
-0.3103601634502411,
0.219374880194664,
-0.17350584268569946,
0.0011046280851587653,
0.5545302033424377,
-0.7785698175430298,
0.7732433080673218,
0.11574359238147736,
-0.20355182886123657,
0.11048774421215057,
-0.2807193100452423,
0.34202373027801514,
-0.239832803606987,
0.1484801173210144,
0.21831072866916656,
0.19412006437778473,
0.5319567322731018,
-0.4725005328655243,
0.5021475553512573,
-0.17903992533683777,
0.07232613116502762,
0.46323490142822266,
0.09223051369190216,
0.6236032843589783,
-0.3550642132759094,
-0.07026414573192596,
0.03741791844367981,
-0.3147079050540924,
-0.5659592747688293,
-0.4106595814228058,
0.7687339782714844,
-0.6667957901954651,
-0.11429835855960846,
-0.5422620177268982,
-0.48936939239501953,
-0.12467481195926666,
0.3902048170566559,
0.7628867626190186,
0.65311199426651,
-0.4369220435619354,
0.44913995265960693,
0.942682683467865,
-0.24093034863471985,
0.4414626955986023,
0.1794329583644867,
-0.21846137940883636,
-0.7510808110237122,
1.277490496635437,
-0.24719879031181335,
0.16518135368824005,
0.419042706489563,
-0.0565107986330986,
-0.29108893871307373,
-0.7017486691474915,
-0.7049229741096497,
-0.34799301624298096,
-0.8080371618270874,
-0.2880246937274933,
-0.7028461694717407,
-0.08391384780406952,
-0.48389652371406555,
-0.2745445966720581,
-0.36166319251060486,
-0.1334565430879593,
-0.04512041434645653,
0.02661295235157013,
0.2920267581939697,
0.7266374230384827,
0.012244188226759434,
0.17012105882167816,
-0.6880765557289124,
0.69449383020401,
0.22487010061740875,
0.4985487461090088,
-0.28521037101745605,
-0.22608117759227753,
0.17157360911369324,
-0.1330309808254242,
-0.16864728927612305,
-0.7695456147193909,
0.327121764421463,
-0.20355704426765442,
0.4504798948764801,
0.34491807222366333,
0.32577764987945557,
0.1988227814435959,
-0.06796927750110626,
0.7398586869239807,
-0.06111982837319374,
-1.0433710813522339,
0.4093424081802368,
-0.5098091959953308,
0.18890579044818878,
0.7842189073562622,
0.23164533078670502,
-0.09460163861513138,
-0.051096074283123016,
-0.4118140935897827,
-0.41572266817092896,
0.5309358239173889,
0.3207586705684662,
-0.31305140256881714,
0.08343350142240524,
-0.18887300789356232,
0.2937283217906952,
0.30107441544532776,
-0.61809241771698,
-0.29751092195510864,
-0.11489130556583405,
-0.33382970094680786,
-0.09103765338659286,
-0.19214023649692535,
-0.19155673682689667,
0.3406978249549866,
0.46829313039779663,
0.14172782003879547,
0.3528536558151245,
-0.035428375005722046,
-0.20458784699440002,
-0.022591670975089073,
0.10229954123497009,
0.5252493619918823,
0.09367231279611588,
-0.2871481478214264,
0.2638557553291321,
0.011103833094239235,
-0.7877002358436584,
0.07137022912502289,
0.24094761908054352,
-0.4609317183494568,
-0.007788820192217827,
0.34573623538017273,
0.6949024200439453,
-0.05334778502583504,
-0.6678840517997742,
0.6447552442550659,
-0.371897429227829,
-0.05200605094432831,
-0.030155090615153313,
-0.05368480831384659,
-0.42432957887649536,
-0.014764916151762009,
0.27018171548843384,
0.7068579792976379,
0.274900883436203,
-0.525523841381073,
0.3207496702671051,
0.45546653866767883,
-0.531069278717041,
-0.02518247440457344,
0.6769908666610718,
0.04966362193226814,
-0.21493008732795715,
0.39948463439941406,
-0.6372700929641724,
-0.8907882571220398,
0.5474092960357666,
0.43786171078681946,
0.9400834441184998,
0.032140228897333145,
0.25324106216430664,
0.23117545247077942,
0.5600342154502869,
-0.21344956755638123,
0.18888606131076813,
-0.19753964245319366,
-0.6836510896682739,
0.2177225947380066,
-0.5877771973609924,
-0.6249187588691711,
0.05139007046818733,
-0.7984929084777832,
0.09289965778589249,
-0.5433744788169861,
-0.034397825598716736,
-0.06214296445250511,
0.2515667676925659,
-0.3692401647567749,
0.14558972418308258,
-0.1446421891450882,
0.718356192111969,
-0.6391986012458801,
0.48653483390808105,
0.3549920916557312,
-0.17327530682086945,
-0.1401599943637848,
0.09915976971387863,
0.2142268419265747,
-0.7826979160308838,
0.15966171026229858,
0.41048967838287354,
-0.25070157647132874,
-0.38593700528144836,
-0.5722189545631409,
-0.36067062616348267,
0.815701425075531,
-0.02020788937807083,
-0.1701027750968933,
0.3905876576900482,
0.016555223613977432,
0.6088033318519592,
-0.1755186766386032,
0.048073600977659225,
0.39500483870506287,
0.38151347637176514,
-0.13576874136924744,
-0.28746333718299866,
0.08836541324853897,
-0.39696794748306274,
-0.15103743970394135,
0.46638023853302,
-0.4732779860496521,
0.9994969964027405,
-0.01760680228471756,
-0.5794188380241394,
0.3532697856426239,
0.5231345295906067,
0.38718268275260925,
0.8296248912811279,
0.37300318479537964,
0.8338847160339355,
0.9380942583084106,
-0.1369525045156479,
1.2400730848312378,
-0.00761907733976841,
0.1784333884716034,
0.9317924976348877,
-0.5226790308952332,
0.8469271659851074,
-0.16968248784542084,
-0.05670566111803055,
0.3590254485607147,
0.23433370888233185,
-0.594786524772644,
0.630882203578949,
-0.025135040283203125,
-0.5982756018638611,
-0.09949412196874619,
-0.13438686728477478,
-0.41338101029396057,
0.3282984495162964,
0.2404111921787262,
-0.3953876197338104,
-0.05529460683465004,
-0.008453551679849625,
-0.04565838351845741,
0.5712571144104004,
-0.182332381606102,
0.4041832685470581,
-0.3586300015449524,
-0.8532108664512634,
0.7074801921844482,
-0.0689881443977356,
0.9127391576766968,
-0.17720039188861847,
0.25058916211128235,
-0.12489760667085648,
0.7366080284118652,
-0.12580443918704987,
-0.8186947107315063,
0.07693411409854889,
0.4641307294368744,
-0.2918250858783722,
-0.3702586889266968,
0.9877636432647705,
-0.06667409837245941,
-0.2865881621837616,
0.1880166381597519,
0.022639663890004158,
0.0906749814748764,
-0.18598352372646332,
-0.13208706676959991,
0.5014128088951111,
-0.00027560151647776365,
0.09616255015134811,
0.4314090311527252,
0.34351250529289246,
0.21785764396190643,
0.5050112009048462,
0.8382298946380615,
-0.22299621999263763,
0.30445635318756104,
-0.02790830284357071,
0.7323094010353088,
-0.48792532086372375,
-0.06160220503807068,
-0.7161129117012024,
0.017632795497775078,
-0.2674320340156555,
-0.4804117679595947,
0.9344956874847412,
0.6824677586555481,
0.8745334148406982,
-0.07738742977380753,
0.8166989088058472,
0.15411832928657532,
0.7484537959098816,
-0.27520015835762024,
0.9577538371086121,
-0.3777349293231964,
0.08931875228881836,
-0.3853178322315216,
-0.7929246425628662,
-0.12453222274780273,
0.2855169475078583,
0.18194694817066193,
0.01029373798519373,
0.6871439814567566,
0.6352784633636475,
0.16103298962116241,
0.5216141939163208,
0.36440715193748474,
0.050529804080724716,
0.49411699175834656,
0.7039122581481934,
0.8859725594520569,
-0.9670589566230774,
0.8789324164390564,
-0.2403419315814972,
-0.2397313416004181,
-0.12020794302225113,
-0.8266486525535583,
-1.1644021272659302,
-0.7603228092193604,
-0.051001980900764465,
-0.41204923391342163,
0.13430535793304443,
0.29051658511161804,
0.4921311140060425,
-1.013417363166809,
0.13354231417179108,
-0.38802915811538696,
0.08286833763122559,
-0.16769200563430786,
-0.2188248485326767,
0.3069467544555664,
-0.19603261351585388,
-0.790126383304596,
0.6373767256736755,
0.16568762063980103,
0.0611540861427784,
-0.21264536678791046,
0.1989562213420868,
0.18136510252952576,
0.0063583641313016415,
0.4491385221481323,
0.21310371160507202,
-0.18106530606746674,
0.05662787705659866,
0.16681064665317535,
-0.5462962985038757,
-0.34308961033821106,
0.7049511671066284,
-0.7159351706504822,
0.7058280110359192,
0.7592477202415466,
0.948231041431427,
0.4461778402328491,
-0.0579681359231472,
0.5091995596885681,
-0.6184866428375244,
-0.1797032505273819,
0.09881000965833664,
0.27578890323638916,
0.44446101784706116,
-0.24165146052837372,
0.524107813835144,
0.4768510162830353,
-0.8251940608024597,
-1.4085856676101685,
0.13980714976787567,
-0.811370849609375,
-0.339691698551178,
0.8176189064979553,
-0.14477494359016418,
-0.13290917873382568,
0.03401632979512215,
0.18484653532505035,
0.12046057730913162,
-0.23670941591262817,
0.7105417847633362,
0.7377591729164124,
0.33803799748420715,
0.21493496000766754,
-0.2555125653743744,
0.4245765507221222,
0.26300379633903503,
-0.9399573802947998,
0.0763523131608963,
0.522678792476654,
-0.08864562958478928,
0.23402300477027893,
0.5054694414138794,
-0.13706500828266144,
0.27661338448524475,
0.6379770636558533,
-0.050677698105573654,
0.11010676622390747,
-0.5709142684936523,
-0.2663929760456085,
0.533459484577179,
-0.4135650396347046,
-0.4960237741470337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07938v1
|
EconLogicQA: A Question-Answering Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models in Economic Sequential Reasoning
| 2024-05-13T17:13:47 | 2024-05-13T17:13:47 |
Yinzhu Quan, Zefang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce EconLogicQA, a rigorous benchmark designed to
assess the sequential reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs)
within the intricate realms of economics, business, and supply chain
management. Diverging from traditional benchmarks that predict subsequent
events individually, EconLogicQA poses a more challenging task: it requires
models to discern and sequence multiple interconnected events, capturing the
complexity of economic logics. EconLogicQA comprises an array of multi-event
scenarios derived from economic articles, which necessitate an insightful
understanding of both temporal and logical event relationships. Through
comprehensive evaluations, we exhibit that EconLogicQA effectively gauges a
LLM's proficiency in navigating the sequential complexities inherent in
economic contexts. We provide a detailed description of EconLogicQA dataset and
shows the outcomes from evaluating the benchmark across various leading-edge
LLMs, thereby offering a thorough perspective on their sequential reasoning
potential in economic contexts. Our benchmark dataset is available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/yinzhu-quan/econ_logic_qa.
|
[
-0.23071321845054626,
-0.7982071042060852,
0.7342544794082642,
0.2460220754146576,
-0.07379638403654099,
0.3250735104084015,
-0.1731807440519333,
-0.6110376119613647,
-0.2392825484275818,
0.2912798523902893,
-0.7771131992340088,
-0.20368222892284393,
0.018782829865813255,
0.3655718266963959,
-0.4766296446323395,
0.7772204279899597,
0.04905058443546295,
-0.25189557671546936,
-0.37312743067741394,
-0.18263466656208038,
0.05489054694771767,
-0.48999303579330444,
-0.928290843963623,
-0.30792707204818726,
0.5718774795532227,
0.061432819813489914,
0.637120246887207,
0.10257080942392349,
0.27407798171043396,
0.3349619209766388,
-0.1731610894203186,
0.1497735232114792,
-0.4173591732978821,
0.22913800179958344,
-0.37067949771881104,
-0.28585079312324524,
-0.26138386130332947,
-0.12122244387865067,
0.6357401609420776,
0.7571038603782654,
-0.6226086020469666,
0.886346697807312,
-0.08741648495197296,
0.4987327456474304,
-0.5244093537330627,
0.12590746581554413,
-0.767454981803894,
-0.08256857842206955,
0.12049882113933563,
0.06580591946840286,
-0.601209819316864,
-0.5969477891921997,
0.2473996877670288,
-0.6385664939880371,
-0.47903478145599365,
0.48905816674232483,
0.7779967784881592,
0.31277430057525635,
-0.503426194190979,
-0.02729462832212448,
-0.5047890543937683,
0.7824607491493225,
-0.6172761917114258,
0.5279635190963745,
-0.09857875853776932,
0.24136286973953247,
-0.11526386439800262,
-1.2375150918960571,
-0.6944660544395447,
0.2528727352619171,
0.23188579082489014,
0.4694213569164276,
-0.20897747576236725,
0.016149835661053658,
0.5357550978660583,
0.06681359559297562,
-0.7569801211357117,
0.15585209429264069,
-0.12614427506923676,
0.1194709986448288,
0.6477562189102173,
0.49670374393463135,
0.11976391077041626,
-0.023234406486153603,
-0.5713978409767151,
0.09846283495426178,
-0.5556527376174927,
0.2414449006319046,
0.5258527398109436,
-0.04147588834166527,
0.11687454581260681,
0.21807236969470978,
-0.5003786087036133,
0.7599511742591858,
-0.26782938838005066,
-0.21223154664039612,
0.161783829331398,
-0.3998672068119049,
-0.5939803719520569,
0.025288354605436325,
0.49852579832077026,
0.28754374384880066,
0.09470456093549728,
0.21098917722702026,
-0.2218852937221527,
-0.5107170939445496,
-0.03478467836976051,
-0.5095124840736389,
-0.09664440155029297,
0.5843642354011536,
-0.5466375350952148,
0.09730089455842972,
-0.20537523925304413,
-1.016153335571289,
-0.10925666987895966,
-0.3112426698207855,
0.4776763617992401,
0.3381587266921997,
-0.04166385903954506,
0.11343687027692795,
-0.14009302854537964,
0.5819533467292786,
0.3654777407646179,
-0.41364148259162903,
0.343757301568985,
0.9525394439697266,
0.7331112623214722,
0.27226683497428894,
-0.15410704910755157,
-0.42715245485305786,
0.08556410670280457,
-0.3570120632648468,
0.8711662292480469,
-0.39850831031799316,
0.17431889474391937,
0.08378203958272934,
0.07778536528348923,
-0.14825676381587982,
-0.5496298670768738,
0.45741209387779236,
-0.7858723402023315,
0.05575341358780861,
-0.27407148480415344,
-0.6501144766807556,
-0.4405805170536041,
0.3285020887851715,
-0.6587815284729004,
0.9566906690597534,
-0.17564183473587036,
-0.5714626908302307,
0.48640528321266174,
-0.10186954587697983,
-0.1596779227256775,
0.4480591118335724,
-0.21253018081188202,
-0.15691812336444855,
-0.2349894642829895,
-0.10088556259870529,
0.16400952637195587,
-0.6373689770698547,
0.5250177383422852,
-0.5629435777664185,
0.0348329097032547,
0.47151896357536316,
-0.37668585777282715,
0.824127197265625,
0.1034465804696083,
-0.30065229535102844,
-0.01775449328124523,
-0.8625562191009521,
0.3022831678390503,
0.04577438905835152,
-0.1788485199213028,
-0.11384766548871994,
0.26120319962501526,
0.14335644245147705,
0.44489550590515137,
0.3902472257614136,
-0.320682555437088,
0.059159860014915466,
-0.2107834666967392,
0.5935472249984741,
1.0871591567993164,
0.056573230773210526,
-0.12156818807125092,
-0.5008335709571838,
0.5644301772117615,
-0.4515499472618103,
0.23943455517292023,
-0.2688072919845581,
-0.728810727596283,
-0.6329310536384583,
-0.07616518437862396,
0.36273324489593506,
0.9338715076446533,
-0.6638654470443726,
0.2348552644252777,
0.05245993658900261,
-0.36863407492637634,
-0.12861435115337372,
-0.17199477553367615,
0.07208790630102158,
0.43739062547683716,
0.1861850619316101,
-0.28220334649086,
-0.5135940909385681,
-0.7921340465545654,
-0.5497497320175171,
-0.5030039548873901,
0.08579360693693161,
0.2952357232570648,
0.6588335633277893,
0.1493712067604065,
0.6019682884216309,
-0.4174860417842865,
0.3504277467727661,
-0.20209909975528717,
0.3326989710330963,
0.7869824767112732,
0.1746794879436493,
-0.12475566565990448,
-0.6359068155288696,
-0.18354614078998566,
0.06299436092376709,
-0.5409131646156311,
-0.2207568883895874,
-0.6797190308570862,
-0.1898832470178604,
0.26299965381622314,
0.27897465229034424,
-0.5727571249008179,
0.44056764245033264,
0.28031301498413086,
-0.42001858353614807,
0.7765734195709229,
-0.11200807243585587,
-0.05658735707402229,
-0.5480557084083557,
0.2423396110534668,
-0.12682630121707916,
-0.3755313456058502,
-0.5371192693710327,
0.32402896881103516,
-0.23395699262619019,
0.11520431935787201,
-0.301181823015213,
0.5029889345169067,
-0.21239270269870758,
-0.5979382991790771,
0.29164308309555054,
0.2703542709350586,
0.1023230031132698,
0.3609667718410492,
0.1576450914144516,
0.6871665120124817,
0.16975879669189453,
-0.2944701313972473,
0.4751877188682556,
0.366781622171402,
-0.9468193054199219,
0.5059961080551147,
-0.9189161658287048,
-0.006089822854846716,
0.10007783770561218,
0.41774749755859375,
-0.9509742856025696,
0.11824337393045425,
-0.057875797152519226,
0.028273191303014755,
-0.1832549273967743,
-0.024643637239933014,
-0.8667293787002563,
-0.4854542911052704,
0.12318290024995804,
0.4300669729709625,
0.7584034204483032,
-0.5386756062507629,
0.6198278665542603,
0.06435660272836685,
-0.62302166223526,
-0.5896333456039429,
-0.5460636615753174,
-0.03391255438327789,
-0.24800726771354675,
-0.6090448498725891,
-0.18049196898937225,
-0.2674807906150818,
-0.531114399433136,
-0.2304137945175171,
-0.24797993898391724,
-0.04636305198073387,
0.3444496691226959,
-0.33106744289398193,
0.3847035765647888,
-0.22453942894935608,
0.05475536361336708,
-0.04850611463189125,
0.025327235460281372,
0.596094012260437,
-0.7626117467880249,
0.2054578810930252,
-0.04507199674844742,
-0.15735287964344025,
-0.23992577195167542,
0.15706992149353027,
0.3964853882789612,
-0.15619078278541565,
0.6233676671981812,
0.15654732286930084,
-0.5808865427970886,
-0.38924530148506165,
-0.6536316275596619,
0.1925749033689499,
-0.46481069922447205,
0.2988390624523163,
-0.22855022549629211,
-0.6369721293449402,
0.6624628901481628,
-0.2999214231967926,
0.09604888409376144,
0.479548841714859,
0.647808313369751,
-0.00724321324378252,
0.9574813842773438,
0.04362071678042412,
0.25767359137535095,
-0.1848820596933365,
0.0035688711795955896,
0.4115230143070221,
-0.8621018528938293,
-0.5839725136756897,
-0.35705965757369995,
-0.21594397723674774,
-0.4598942697048187,
-0.4528160095214844,
0.34650805592536926,
0.10004167258739471,
-0.779561460018158,
-0.10107225179672241,
0.05265402793884277,
0.6038317680358887,
0.3455209732055664,
0.016436109319329262,
0.5861252546310425,
-0.3594357669353485,
-0.34692102670669556,
0.31140217185020447,
-0.7390925288200378,
-0.6720916032791138,
0.7774346470832825,
0.29412832856178284,
0.6340651512145996,
0.3814378082752228,
0.3882374167442322,
-0.050634901970624924,
0.051113106310367584,
-0.5791597366333008,
0.6795030832290649,
0.11646397411823273,
-0.500148594379425,
-0.40556302666664124,
-0.5080046057701111,
-0.6919082403182983,
0.2808539569377899,
-0.07661890983581543,
-1.0384031534194946,
0.44806981086730957,
-0.14143066108226776,
-0.8213390111923218,
0.40456151962280273,
-0.15816481411457062,
1.0586408376693726,
-0.5298169255256653,
-0.7161142826080322,
-0.3109569847583771,
-0.5370607376098633,
0.3365062475204468,
-0.20083023607730865,
0.5361446142196655,
-0.33935546875,
-0.4206869900226593,
0.6550517082214355,
-0.42737504839897156,
0.5811426639556885,
0.3228652775287628,
-0.19640658795833588,
0.27160611748695374,
-0.0021118219010531902,
0.558167040348053,
0.29436615109443665,
-0.05771201103925705,
0.02998652495443821,
0.2543165385723114,
-0.43265798687934875,
-0.43619370460510254,
0.4174996018409729,
-0.4649013578891754,
-0.6922010779380798,
-0.6123414635658264,
-0.23228982090950012,
-0.3885413706302643,
0.12547147274017334,
-0.10786139965057373,
0.5115495920181274,
-0.2258353978395462,
-0.1246284544467926,
0.737962007522583,
-0.5652100443840027,
0.5713782906532288,
0.4141661822795868,
-0.4396134912967682,
-0.3420369327068329,
0.5852362513542175,
0.14752523601055145,
0.4344020485877991,
0.3723719120025635,
0.039292581379413605,
-0.5308207273483276,
-0.3783816397190094,
-0.4489971995353699,
-0.06105150282382965,
-1.1295708417892456,
-0.3013184666633606,
-0.6153730154037476,
-0.1492225080728531,
0.009842575527727604,
-0.0391705185174942,
-0.07191598415374756,
-0.4889138340950012,
-0.008998445235192776,
-0.31632542610168457,
0.31312042474746704,
0.8582356572151184,
-0.06785200536251068,
-0.3359468877315521,
-0.6421389579772949,
0.0904671922326088,
0.7814049124717712,
0.33427098393440247,
0.4104689657688141,
-0.34687915444374084,
-0.13456152379512787,
-0.29576575756073,
-0.011030877009034157,
-0.8298081755638123,
0.342887818813324,
0.16247649490833282,
0.7031092643737793,
0.3341662585735321,
0.046200577169656754,
0.845003068447113,
-0.7416478991508484,
0.9436875581741333,
0.1417219191789627,
-1.2585910558700562,
0.2855621874332428,
-0.3473343849182129,
0.5534218549728394,
0.4218166470527649,
0.6865941286087036,
-0.6335200667381287,
-0.26892638206481934,
-0.6351874470710754,
-1.3852920532226562,
0.47993898391723633,
0.1756991446018219,
-0.4069672226905823,
-0.17122560739517212,
0.10664765536785126,
0.17295217514038086,
0.4672083854675293,
-0.5797566771507263,
-0.3840530216693878,
0.16524940729141235,
-0.08641479909420013,
0.11347006261348724,
-0.1492360532283783,
0.012488423846662045,
-0.22537900507450104,
0.670771062374115,
-0.011270420625805855,
-0.12380842864513397,
0.28088051080703735,
-0.006002058275043964,
0.13283653557300568,
0.4136158525943756,
0.2594023644924164,
1.1045767068862915,
-0.06518949568271637,
-0.061937667429447174,
0.42675861716270447,
-0.016496680676937103,
0.12659810483455658,
0.2669491767883301,
-0.1349240392446518,
-0.17360574007034302,
0.33257612586021423,
0.4750719368457794,
0.2949445843696594,
-1.3178608417510986,
0.18743528425693512,
-0.046698473393917084,
-0.14942806959152222,
-0.6864953637123108,
-0.538592517375946,
0.04681486636400223,
0.6189557909965515,
0.5745280385017395,
-0.29812321066856384,
0.6200080513954163,
-0.8350130915641785,
0.2470327466726303,
0.04589800536632538,
0.033143579959869385,
-0.14009396731853485,
0.7932365536689758,
0.25203168392181396,
0.17326399683952332,
0.7718425393104553,
-0.24466677010059357,
-0.7988811135292053,
1.1342607736587524,
0.3477086126804352,
0.8117256760597229,
0.05671240761876106,
0.245638906955719,
0.6950746178627014,
0.5893607139587402,
-0.3447170853614807,
0.8287213444709778,
0.16143593192100525,
-0.5589592456817627,
-0.6630918979644775,
-0.6060580015182495,
-0.681399405002594,
-0.061569806188344955,
-0.9317730069160461,
-0.05511064454913139,
-0.47543779015541077,
-0.04623832553625107,
-0.03619875758886337,
-0.10903534293174744,
-0.9297065734863281,
0.16394032537937164,
0.38202789425849915,
0.9867968559265137,
-0.5494751930236816,
0.3196036219596863,
0.5482437610626221,
-0.316972941160202,
-0.7790643572807312,
-0.1687057614326477,
0.1856974959373474,
-0.7354024052619934,
0.9295243620872498,
0.2278873473405838,
0.09936171025037766,
-0.007980816066265106,
-0.35761716961860657,
-0.9688904285430908,
1.1951167583465576,
-0.11000201851129532,
-1.1176782846450806,
0.3178536295890808,
-0.034688353538513184,
0.28530633449554443,
-0.3641761839389801,
0.6784961223602295,
0.9055827856063843,
0.6498124599456787,
-0.13099482655525208,
-0.9728119969367981,
0.1561621129512787,
-0.18469208478927612,
-0.04753177985548973,
0.33916547894477844,
-0.9516696929931641,
0.7924941778182983,
-0.17263177037239075,
-0.46826037764549255,
0.5388457179069519,
0.40492352843284607,
0.2794766128063202,
0.6709677577018738,
0.6080446243286133,
0.945658802986145,
1.1641693115234375,
-0.24439257383346558,
0.9684091210365295,
-0.30601271986961365,
0.5108199715614319,
1.2728440761566162,
-0.8529463410377502,
1.208805799484253,
0.13471215963363647,
-0.5039123892784119,
0.9894943237304688,
0.9007612466812134,
0.00300989905372262,
0.23689505457878113,
0.6981186866760254,
-0.26772409677505493,
-0.7461065649986267,
-0.08215556293725967,
-0.3050617575645447,
0.06328494846820831,
0.442086398601532,
0.07401725649833679,
0.1071934625506401,
-0.3415811061859131,
-0.3157283067703247,
-0.0772000104188919,
-0.6407129168510437,
0.84135901927948,
0.13705050945281982,
-0.4656459093093872,
0.12379209697246552,
-0.3367484211921692,
0.061867572367191315,
-0.458566278219223,
-0.06095312535762787,
-0.2601354122161865,
-0.19433921575546265,
-0.09042276442050934,
-0.8576697111129761,
0.11324045062065125,
-0.044408854097127914,
0.14775392413139343,
-0.2558838725090027,
0.32290154695510864,
-0.3916724622249603,
-0.49831777811050415,
0.3169505298137665,
0.5570982694625854,
-0.0034704734571278095,
0.3220832645893097,
-0.8522964119911194,
-0.056042660027742386,
-0.30881673097610474,
-0.2786305546760559,
0.04831935092806816,
0.6751449704170227,
0.1801401674747467,
0.7622092962265015,
0.5669909715652466,
-0.17030571401119232,
-0.025361528620123863,
0.20356984436511993,
0.38177433609962463,
-0.9017643928527832,
-0.6475245356559753,
-0.7019400596618652,
0.37362104654312134,
-0.1126464232802391,
-0.3990771770477295,
0.6558741927146912,
0.6297453045845032,
1.0402525663375854,
0.19377006590366364,
0.755139172077179,
0.22830455005168915,
0.2644961178302765,
-0.7458176016807556,
0.2568143308162689,
-0.48746663331985474,
0.3934031128883362,
-0.12238188087940216,
-0.6756287813186646,
0.04169358313083649,
0.4481225311756134,
-0.2624206840991974,
-0.019408702850341797,
0.9598734378814697,
0.2802202105522156,
0.47407329082489014,
0.4357624351978302,
0.28289794921875,
0.48689407110214233,
-0.429501473903656,
0.7781575918197632,
1.4642690420150757,
-0.1944771707057953,
0.47406744956970215,
-0.07434317469596863,
-0.0730651393532753,
0.13763538002967834,
-0.9761370420455933,
-0.6431353092193604,
-0.32034462690353394,
-0.6133407354354858,
-0.21335361897945404,
0.3060705363750458,
1.1943026781082153,
0.29933348298072815,
-0.7448452711105347,
-0.5265505313873291,
0.22297635674476624,
0.4136818051338196,
-0.5322712063789368,
-0.21966271102428436,
0.05858483165502548,
-0.29270654916763306,
-0.5810497999191284,
0.055017899721860886,
0.5524551868438721,
-0.2145523875951767,
-0.2278837412595749,
0.3966469466686249,
-0.42408400774002075,
0.5276203751564026,
0.765475869178772,
0.2498452216386795,
-0.8754302263259888,
-0.12313636392354965,
-0.05249030515551567,
0.4886983036994934,
-0.2644681930541992,
0.8735397458076477,
-0.793583869934082,
0.2571015954017639,
0.5862563848495483,
0.7930225133895874,
0.1664171814918518,
-0.06794487684965134,
0.6318839192390442,
-0.14411181211471558,
0.0010565428528934717,
0.22787906229496002,
0.6435532569885254,
-0.07604748755693436,
-0.23108212649822235,
0.6571691036224365,
0.059970006346702576,
-0.8512734770774841,
-0.7263880372047424,
0.3033156394958496,
-0.9123358726501465,
-0.3765377998352051,
0.973376452922821,
-0.34515589475631714,
-0.16920654475688934,
-0.44794905185699463,
0.39347580075263977,
-0.3421648442745209,
-0.3048511743545532,
0.34344106912612915,
0.6666735410690308,
0.11510533839464188,
-0.2550906538963318,
-0.7839189767837524,
0.16900445520877838,
0.34331485629081726,
-0.9265404343605042,
0.08282721787691116,
0.5209945440292358,
-0.05795217677950859,
-0.2282152771949768,
0.517640233039856,
0.36122122406959534,
0.4361259937286377,
-0.039232876151800156,
-0.15754136443138123,
0.6803717613220215,
-0.34180936217308044,
-0.37266650795936584,
0.13678473234176636,
0.049242064356803894,
0.3945090174674988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07932v2
|
PARDEN, Can You Repeat That? Defending against Jailbreaks via Repetition
| 2024-05-13T17:08:42 | 2024-05-14T15:56:37 |
Ziyang Zhang, Qizhen Zhang, Jakob Foerster
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown success in many natural language
processing tasks. Despite rigorous safety alignment processes, supposedly
safety-aligned LLMs like Llama 2 and Claude 2 are still susceptible to
jailbreaks, leading to security risks and abuse of the models. One option to
mitigate such risks is to augment the LLM with a dedicated "safeguard", which
checks the LLM's inputs or outputs for undesired behaviour. A promising
approach is to use the LLM itself as the safeguard. Nonetheless, baseline
methods, such as prompting the LLM to self-classify toxic content, demonstrate
limited efficacy. We hypothesise that this is due to domain shift: the
alignment training imparts a self-censoring behaviour to the model ("Sorry I
can't do that"), while the self-classify approach shifts it to a classification
format ("Is this prompt malicious"). In this work, we propose PARDEN, which
avoids this domain shift by simply asking the model to repeat its own outputs.
PARDEN neither requires finetuning nor white box access to the model. We
empirically verify the effectiveness of our method and show that PARDEN
significantly outperforms existing jailbreak detection baselines for Llama-2
and Claude-2. Code and data are available at https://github.com/Ed-Zh/PARDEN.
We find that PARDEN is particularly powerful in the relevant regime of high
True Positive Rate (TPR) and low False Positive Rate (FPR). For instance, for
Llama2-7B, at TPR equal to 90%, PARDEN accomplishes a roughly 11x reduction in
the FPR from 24.8% to 2.0% on the harmful behaviours dataset.
|
[
-0.15952950716018677,
-0.5490841865539551,
0.7286819219589233,
0.20214837789535522,
-0.24035970866680145,
0.07852664589881897,
-0.10746041685342789,
-0.29268980026245117,
0.12076148390769958,
0.7860026955604553,
-0.4053287208080292,
-0.5678433775901794,
-0.7694536447525024,
0.22564920783042908,
-0.4425562620162964,
0.94651859998703,
-0.1174442395567894,
-0.14823471009731293,
0.05139148607850075,
-0.2979465126991272,
-0.7878639698028564,
-0.6696292757987976,
-0.445059597492218,
-0.1486257165670395,
0.4238261580467224,
0.4409288763999939,
0.6608949899673462,
0.9054238796234131,
0.5866724848747253,
0.22321951389312744,
-0.19395826756954193,
-0.00965565349906683,
-0.3902142345905304,
0.295427531003952,
-0.5445693135261536,
-0.5076424479484558,
-0.24999824166297913,
-0.009338540956377983,
0.31246450543403625,
0.33084166049957275,
-0.29101938009262085,
-0.12091490626335144,
0.10966318100690842,
0.7135624885559082,
-0.6923360228538513,
-0.3973926901817322,
-0.702399492263794,
-0.025213096290826797,
-0.4917323589324951,
0.011532014235854149,
-0.6024784445762634,
-0.16409166157245636,
-0.2986094355583191,
-0.4991302788257599,
0.05164621025323868,
0.11159759759902954,
0.7731428146362305,
0.2378690242767334,
-0.2968616485595703,
-0.19978013634681702,
-0.45317432284355164,
0.8145339488983154,
-0.7877200245857239,
0.03743427246809006,
0.45583996176719666,
0.3744404911994934,
-0.11871029436588287,
-0.6906663179397583,
-0.4840169847011566,
-0.3625614047050476,
0.05261926352977753,
-0.10443402081727982,
-0.28211653232574463,
-0.18358169496059418,
0.41540607810020447,
0.23254121840000153,
-0.5957340002059937,
0.3072125017642975,
-0.2821667492389679,
-0.5309092998504639,
0.4073319137096405,
0.3329709470272064,
0.5857999920845032,
-0.08480051904916763,
-0.7646424770355225,
-0.21520276367664337,
-1.067585825920105,
0.2537754476070404,
0.4794100224971771,
0.2129763662815094,
0.14405584335327148,
0.45366886258125305,
-0.14093726873397827,
0.46945345401763916,
0.3497741222381592,
-0.11980628222227097,
0.28880026936531067,
-0.12633486092090607,
-0.10168392956256866,
0.309260755777359,
0.8239085674285889,
0.5164574980735779,
0.06964164972305298,
-0.1204838752746582,
-0.1914876401424408,
0.3286120295524597,
0.5063539147377014,
-0.6408897042274475,
-0.37964576482772827,
0.2349429577589035,
-0.2653830051422119,
-0.5397273898124695,
0.1148511990904808,
-0.662261962890625,
-0.8041605949401855,
-0.0843610018491745,
0.3103914260864258,
-0.6354218125343323,
-0.1087971180677414,
0.33873283863067627,
0.0384264811873436,
0.29383137822151184,
0.08985715359449387,
-0.7087728977203369,
0.3827700614929199,
0.830817461013794,
0.8129951357841492,
-0.4357489049434662,
-0.5354833006858826,
-0.6699086427688599,
0.34642237424850464,
-0.259863942861557,
0.6243495941162109,
-0.3789452612400055,
-0.3742077648639679,
-0.04151798412203789,
0.14698147773742676,
0.025915788486599922,
-0.8776214718818665,
0.6403823494911194,
-0.41863542795181274,
-0.14757421612739563,
-0.5069275498390198,
-0.44414806365966797,
0.22722843289375305,
0.31841155886650085,
-0.6156065464019775,
0.671698272228241,
-0.09914669394493103,
-0.9995986223220825,
0.1993236094713211,
-0.0399048738181591,
-0.6413838863372803,
-0.23295648396015167,
0.1420404464006424,
-0.7224201560020447,
-0.11197120696306229,
0.4926260709762573,
0.11830101162195206,
0.013712964951992035,
0.8291780352592468,
-0.5823161602020264,
-0.17221316695213318,
0.3090556561946869,
-0.4285092353820801,
0.8692715167999268,
0.3593248724937439,
-0.6487146019935608,
-0.008276677690446377,
-0.6063058972358704,
-0.22214870154857635,
0.2028185874223709,
-0.2017023116350174,
-0.4982511103153229,
0.011163442395627499,
-0.5280174612998962,
0.2692660689353943,
0.19870170950889587,
-0.8258715867996216,
0.11285869777202606,
-0.20406872034072876,
0.31721970438957214,
0.8563284873962402,
0.15397197008132935,
0.43042871356010437,
-0.7596392631530762,
0.5045371651649475,
0.2450742870569229,
0.22772152721881866,
-0.24976329505443573,
-0.284858375787735,
-0.762985110282898,
-0.17061877250671387,
0.12980976700782776,
0.8658952713012695,
-0.7988816499710083,
0.519848108291626,
-0.21432512998580933,
-0.1538219302892685,
-0.4902610778808594,
0.41441306471824646,
0.7076449394226074,
0.6390056014060974,
0.39950641989707947,
-0.3952919840812683,
-0.5968126654624939,
-0.9349772334098816,
-0.548642098903656,
-0.17176483571529388,
0.21630020439624786,
0.05841204524040222,
0.20503509044647217,
-0.20449309051036835,
0.7740400433540344,
-0.31041479110717773,
-0.2811743915081024,
-0.2453041821718216,
0.0072652255184948444,
0.18724599480628967,
0.4990866184234619,
0.5839430689811707,
-0.45333045721054077,
-0.3802598714828491,
-0.2848031520843506,
-0.9474151134490967,
-0.6381626129150391,
-0.35082414746284485,
-0.23240765929222107,
-0.039544932544231415,
0.6237423419952393,
-0.3157366216182709,
0.20608249306678772,
0.2973264157772064,
-0.36057835817337036,
0.388602077960968,
0.025654207915067673,
-0.005300546530634165,
-0.9633550047874451,
-0.23441605269908905,
0.004519992973655462,
-0.5187525749206543,
-0.7284044027328491,
0.1828906089067459,
0.30441075563430786,
-0.06708765029907227,
-0.6295501589775085,
0.3829517066478729,
-0.11210815608501434,
0.22740605473518372,
-0.26091235876083374,
0.04371868073940277,
0.09327809512615204,
0.1022295206785202,
-0.18860426545143127,
1.086340308189392,
0.6195969581604004,
-0.45233020186424255,
0.10515429079532623,
0.45367753505706787,
-0.4661639332771301,
0.6541773676872253,
-0.6231898069381714,
0.013890727423131466,
-0.11857249587774277,
-0.001964183058589697,
-0.8314310312271118,
-0.17906436324119568,
0.3120718002319336,
-0.1739000380039215,
0.3285994231700897,
-0.016503022983670235,
-0.2667887508869171,
-0.30103328824043274,
-0.5885793566703796,
0.22149580717086792,
0.6468825340270996,
-1.032227873802185,
0.11245404928922653,
0.42124974727630615,
-0.2987367808818817,
-0.6362527012825012,
-0.7277135848999023,
0.2582509517669678,
-0.5452473759651184,
-0.7174410223960876,
0.25779372453689575,
0.07003427296876907,
-0.3590245246887207,
-0.163302481174469,
-0.3680473566055298,
0.052599068731069565,
0.28617650270462036,
0.36729416251182556,
0.19624516367912292,
-0.040472324937582016,
-0.25729900598526,
0.09759066998958588,
-0.21079158782958984,
0.18876902759075165,
-0.24363796412944794,
0.4259313642978668,
-0.09038925915956497,
-0.32640179991722107,
-0.574488639831543,
0.24363334476947784,
0.4478984475135803,
-0.00569913862273097,
0.6395120024681091,
0.0584893599152565,
-0.025861700996756554,
-0.3157171607017517,
-0.44523537158966064,
0.18325506150722504,
-0.5170019268989563,
-0.0576028935611248,
-0.25533542037010193,
-0.9947590827941895,
0.5369046926498413,
-0.09264007210731506,
-0.26020631194114685,
0.2149423360824585,
0.4436778426170349,
-0.1825709342956543,
0.6868249773979187,
0.29290303587913513,
-0.45859864354133606,
0.42577117681503296,
0.1437116116285324,
0.3492635488510132,
-0.9714436531066895,
-0.014396621845662594,
-0.13913998007774353,
-0.19570313394069672,
-0.2939496636390686,
0.03265494480729103,
0.2913334369659424,
0.3003591001033783,
-0.5117782950401306,
0.8002408742904663,
-0.3637754023075104,
0.7197012901306152,
0.41924822330474854,
0.4960568845272064,
0.239385187625885,
-0.11401834338903427,
0.0027519704308360815,
-0.030144033953547478,
-0.3970387578010559,
-0.6107559204101562,
1.0903578996658325,
0.5321803689002991,
0.9872695207595825,
0.3229037821292877,
1.1628459692001343,
0.5466960668563843,
0.4679558277130127,
-0.3342205584049225,
0.5609327554702759,
-0.16521644592285156,
-0.4767538011074066,
-0.14178788661956787,
-0.29923608899116516,
-0.8510444760322571,
0.21622176468372345,
0.3339727520942688,
-0.829254686832428,
0.14210473001003265,
0.25831595063209534,
-0.48324111104011536,
0.44850635528564453,
-0.5681414604187012,
0.7180724740028381,
-0.4403846263885498,
-0.5317753553390503,
0.10599002987146378,
-0.6810285449028015,
0.8284747004508972,
-0.2837686240673065,
0.38070303201675415,
-0.33631160855293274,
0.14358936250209808,
0.5602294206619263,
-0.6677199006080627,
1.1696947813034058,
-0.2180696427822113,
-0.13428720831871033,
0.4300384223461151,
0.6058529019355774,
0.7003334760665894,
0.13731235265731812,
0.004666953347623348,
0.10426893085241318,
-0.08277034014463425,
-0.2764938473701477,
-0.3899807333946228,
0.8950175642967224,
-0.7274929285049438,
-1.1687721014022827,
-0.5941867232322693,
-0.42789915204048157,
-0.08100393414497375,
0.230810284614563,
0.352409303188324,
0.24767257273197174,
0.06849899142980576,
0.09689537435770035,
0.6087497472763062,
-0.35626330971717834,
0.42424577474594116,
0.3008279502391815,
-0.23496797680854797,
-0.6261469125747681,
0.8807204365730286,
-0.27815568447113037,
0.4844891428947449,
0.0741264820098877,
0.3785319924354553,
-0.15268942713737488,
-0.5596005916595459,
-0.28188613057136536,
0.052350934594869614,
-0.8249742984771729,
-0.5344122052192688,
-0.534691333770752,
-0.06171860545873642,
-0.5242254734039307,
-0.31735292077064514,
-0.2282860279083252,
-0.3388757109642029,
-0.03720525652170181,
-0.1675957590341568,
0.10779210925102234,
0.5323367714881897,
-0.24038051068782806,
0.592887282371521,
-0.7682771682739258,
0.5203389525413513,
0.33533716201782227,
0.32946568727493286,
-0.3349647521972656,
-0.8001663684844971,
0.31823742389678955,
-0.10830443352460861,
-0.48393261432647705,
-0.8053820729255676,
0.4867149591445923,
-0.008715935982763767,
0.5702080130577087,
0.242074117064476,
0.3319900929927826,
0.43515637516975403,
-0.5224584341049194,
0.7910457253456116,
0.30363672971725464,
-1.0932866334915161,
0.7262798547744751,
-0.5068061947822571,
-0.11948546022176743,
0.8811154961585999,
0.2484670728445053,
-0.42996323108673096,
-0.3899747431278229,
-0.4918809235095978,
-0.8140935897827148,
0.6371196508407593,
0.23882630467414856,
0.1925930231809616,
-0.2205522507429123,
0.19428673386573792,
0.052974455058574677,
0.1670982986688614,
-0.9773772358894348,
-0.060139723122119904,
-0.2698877453804016,
-0.05515165627002716,
0.20616161823272705,
-0.46590113639831543,
-0.22484782338142395,
-0.1856563538312912,
0.6176091432571411,
0.17160141468048096,
-0.021332843229174614,
0.33207806944847107,
-0.4460218846797943,
0.1756453961133957,
0.34292539954185486,
0.348458468914032,
0.2918727993965149,
-0.06818751245737076,
0.3651500642299652,
0.05451352894306183,
-0.3519395887851715,
0.6041586995124817,
-0.37542974948883057,
-0.16897010803222656,
-0.13942992687225342,
0.45821961760520935,
0.7623658180236816,
0.09444046765565872,
-0.5720027089118958,
0.8827372193336487,
0.2208395004272461,
-0.16574864089488983,
-0.2813155949115753,
0.21773499250411987,
-0.31966301798820496,
0.1842838078737259,
-0.32746782898902893,
-0.03129955381155014,
0.034537412226200104,
-0.6679663062095642,
0.5590524077415466,
0.04255998879671097,
-0.18733613193035126,
-0.10735560208559036,
0.8773760795593262,
0.03444453328847885,
-0.2680257558822632,
0.537014901638031,
-0.3934646546840668,
-0.6621430516242981,
0.6923989057540894,
0.9522551894187927,
0.9943097233772278,
-0.39254552125930786,
0.1564229428768158,
0.18964801728725433,
0.3252926468849182,
-0.4416032135486603,
0.22443526983261108,
0.12047745287418365,
-1.0297490358352661,
-0.15915831923484802,
-0.48148787021636963,
-0.35200029611587524,
0.15401098132133484,
-0.8672469258308411,
0.13279205560684204,
-0.8723332285881042,
-0.1810046136379242,
-0.03542039915919304,
-0.6746180653572083,
-0.07911241054534912,
-0.1900177001953125,
0.30719032883644104,
0.947422981262207,
-1.064255714416504,
0.926371693611145,
0.287757933139801,
-0.14094379544258118,
-0.44825509190559387,
0.24937215447425842,
0.3979519307613373,
-0.8145597577095032,
0.38231781125068665,
0.46901047229766846,
0.01723802462220192,
-0.27859294414520264,
-0.7487345933914185,
-0.8183839321136475,
0.9720714092254639,
0.23351186513900757,
-0.9431666135787964,
0.2514946758747101,
0.2397962063550949,
0.3016400933265686,
-0.22339433431625366,
-0.5045100450515747,
1.067047357559204,
0.3357076942920685,
-0.09802630543708801,
-0.6095104813575745,
0.17471879720687866,
-0.17539958655834198,
0.2209959179162979,
0.4277166724205017,
-0.5414960384368896,
0.7728338241577148,
-0.16353479027748108,
-0.22767065465450287,
0.3358405828475952,
0.27906957268714905,
0.37635529041290283,
0.2267502397298813,
0.4307577610015869,
0.8632348775863647,
0.8009377717971802,
-0.12107247859239578,
1.30952787399292,
-0.4308071732521057,
0.29833558201789856,
1.3934880495071411,
-0.8897486925125122,
0.5849202871322632,
0.534419059753418,
-0.12098471075296402,
0.4849291741847992,
0.2297831028699875,
-0.2213311791419983,
0.8946260809898376,
0.3140590190887451,
-0.2828993499279022,
-0.4679146707057953,
-0.0029880974907428026,
-0.037867117673158646,
0.084638811647892,
0.18950030207633972,
-0.17890816926956177,
-0.3455228805541992,
0.3260841369628906,
0.2103043645620346,
0.4346492886543274,
-0.25616586208343506,
0.6756362915039062,
0.1903487741947174,
-0.6001752018928528,
0.5881198048591614,
-0.05520429089665413,
0.6423815488815308,
-0.3446333706378937,
0.29213061928749084,
-0.3614300489425659,
0.3312086760997772,
-0.05950864404439926,
-1.0391039848327637,
0.522325336933136,
0.14610181748867035,
-0.09342516958713531,
-0.3760410249233246,
0.8148053884506226,
-0.1489996612071991,
-0.2193375676870346,
0.47270286083221436,
0.1941307932138443,
-0.19204287230968475,
-0.01821502484381199,
-0.4691663682460785,
0.3017919957637787,
0.1227702647447586,
-0.10122828930616379,
0.5118725299835205,
0.20027180016040802,
-0.29483845829963684,
0.749466598033905,
0.6214998960494995,
-0.000087100597738754,
0.2584886848926544,
0.07106419652700424,
1.0211281776428223,
-0.7270880937576294,
-0.43638280034065247,
-1.0288519859313965,
0.2847388982772827,
-0.23357248306274414,
-0.20940445363521576,
0.6687102317810059,
0.47832900285720825,
1.0601420402526855,
0.013115930370986462,
0.9439685940742493,
-0.06833210587501526,
0.4875873923301697,
-0.6712774038314819,
0.31551358103752136,
-0.047670647501945496,
0.6705414652824402,
-0.037058066576719284,
-0.6509414315223694,
-0.35851237177848816,
0.49162325263023376,
-0.538192093372345,
-0.5254132747650146,
0.8652675151824951,
0.7806404232978821,
-0.060310427099466324,
0.023578155785799026,
0.36046072840690613,
0.15989886224269867,
0.47976699471473694,
0.7359212636947632,
1.0775784254074097,
-0.2785070836544037,
0.39546650648117065,
-0.46499133110046387,
-0.06114022061228752,
0.18349917232990265,
-0.8259152770042419,
-0.963084876537323,
-0.08521886169910431,
-0.3326239585876465,
-0.7565174698829651,
0.3347971439361572,
0.7435017228126526,
0.33238542079925537,
-1.0793592929840088,
-0.035700272768735886,
-0.1401519477367401,
-0.07854971289634705,
-0.051985129714012146,
-0.14136072993278503,
-0.04444200545549393,
-0.5388525128364563,
-0.23514114320278168,
0.559918224811554,
0.29021188616752625,
0.08921536803245544,
0.2492024004459381,
0.048690199851989746,
0.11404646933078766,
-0.12300879508256912,
0.3166990280151367,
0.44045597314834595,
-0.7246907949447632,
-0.535717248916626,
-0.21017640829086304,
-0.3531706929206848,
0.3022606074810028,
0.8974407911300659,
-0.6264700889587402,
0.3309439420700073,
0.35670268535614014,
0.9676083326339722,
0.16197839379310608,
0.25130289793014526,
0.5769100189208984,
-0.7662758231163025,
0.08400560170412064,
0.10252100229263306,
0.6510881185531616,
0.2908419072628021,
-0.4740809202194214,
0.4241558015346527,
0.3152635395526886,
-0.5226873159408569,
-0.6464276313781738,
0.45511168241500854,
-0.8173319697380066,
-0.3495357036590576,
1.355567216873169,
-0.3745816648006439,
-0.3240121006965637,
-0.118288554251194,
-0.27453094720840454,
-0.050729695707559586,
-0.27516958117485046,
0.8877640962600708,
0.5756099820137024,
-0.0339059941470623,
-0.08194290846586227,
-0.4012753963470459,
0.36840853095054626,
0.47426360845565796,
-0.7647496461868286,
0.2768307030200958,
0.3211490511894226,
0.7417343854904175,
0.1085822582244873,
0.3312278687953949,
-0.3822457194328308,
0.1669287383556366,
-0.19355271756649017,
-0.14705213904380798,
-0.1669280230998993,
-0.5571057796478271,
-0.8585345149040222,
0.04177486523985863,
0.07356365770101547,
-0.2521832287311554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07886v1
|
Russian-Language Multimodal Dataset for Automatic Summarization of Scientific Papers
| 2024-05-13T16:21:33 | 2024-05-13T16:21:33 |
Alena Tsanda, Elena Bruches
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The paper discusses the creation of a multimodal dataset of Russian-language
scientific papers and testing of existing language models for the task of
automatic text summarization. A feature of the dataset is its multimodal data,
which includes texts, tables and figures. The paper presents the results of
experiments with two language models: Gigachat from SBER and YandexGPT from
Yandex. The dataset consists of 420 papers and is publicly available on
https://github.com/iis-research-team/summarization-dataset.
|
[
-0.19157887995243073,
-0.5651636123657227,
0.3882940411567688,
0.2941873371601105,
-0.36477264761924744,
0.07190526276826859,
-0.06331197917461395,
-0.4444812834262848,
0.4398491382598877,
0.3095986545085907,
-0.29001298546791077,
-0.2665175199508667,
-0.48502135276794434,
0.20327633619308472,
-0.6264143586158752,
1.390504240989685,
-0.05346008017659187,
0.4097719192504883,
-0.33369746804237366,
-0.10962603986263275,
-0.025180790573358536,
-0.2695421874523163,
-0.14143484830856323,
-0.18165501952171326,
0.4832928478717804,
0.4344170391559601,
0.5911952257156372,
0.604469358921051,
0.7466748952865601,
0.3510753810405731,
0.2822246849536896,
-0.01252309512346983,
-0.13186542689800262,
0.11799792945384979,
-0.10225468128919601,
-0.45096391439437866,
-0.4899500012397766,
-0.1250956952571869,
1.1115617752075195,
0.5228343605995178,
0.12426213175058365,
0.2800312340259552,
-0.30744674801826477,
0.5474777221679688,
-0.29453912377357483,
0.3186433017253876,
-0.22461360692977905,
-0.0016093613812699914,
-0.20850680768489838,
-0.1324068009853363,
-0.18961282074451447,
-0.48551464080810547,
0.07198667526245117,
-0.32984715700149536,
0.22126097977161407,
-0.018839431926608086,
0.7169498205184937,
-0.2316042184829712,
-0.7986424565315247,
-0.33786243200302124,
-0.5831426978111267,
0.572839617729187,
-0.7390398979187012,
0.3536233901977539,
0.3683290481567383,
0.21101190149784088,
0.21485045552253723,
-0.8633555173873901,
-0.5930606126785278,
-0.3123275637626648,
-0.42863744497299194,
0.28991079330444336,
-0.0857073962688446,
-0.22286492586135864,
0.10127461701631546,
0.2732231616973877,
-1.0410850048065186,
-0.28914305567741394,
-0.8224070072174072,
-0.14592526853084564,
0.7798627614974976,
0.2961764633655548,
0.2561926543712616,
-0.20925620198249817,
-0.025233794003725052,
-0.0526152141392231,
-0.34480851888656616,
-0.30095234513282776,
0.4155615270137787,
0.2870222330093384,
-0.14412473142147064,
0.925934374332428,
-0.43763190507888794,
0.8149771690368652,
-0.3468412756919861,
-0.26241546869277954,
0.47044652700424194,
-0.9386773705482483,
-0.039395906031131744,
0.0382254496216774,
0.9042580127716064,
0.391720175743103,
0.3084506392478943,
-0.15229161083698273,
-0.248932346701622,
0.17786328494548798,
-0.0011265981011092663,
-0.7940185070037842,
-0.27727678418159485,
0.17182397842407227,
-0.49989384412765503,
-0.3092195391654968,
0.10325168073177338,
-0.8767915368080139,
-0.17215922474861145,
-0.492541640996933,
0.4172629714012146,
-0.14545337855815887,
-0.4368918240070343,
-0.01934484764933586,
-0.25354957580566406,
-0.20771823823451996,
0.2637443542480469,
-0.6852602362632751,
0.4003514051437378,
0.3499341309070587,
1.0334992408752441,
-0.15516844391822815,
-0.5161881446838379,
-0.35445085167884827,
0.0864366665482521,
-0.31650248169898987,
1.031309723854065,
-0.4543847143650055,
-0.3120032250881195,
-0.17354848980903625,
0.29641854763031006,
-0.14674890041351318,
-0.21640820801258087,
0.35055336356163025,
-0.30647510290145874,
0.49382391571998596,
-0.2648896276950836,
-0.1995774507522583,
-0.23722539842128754,
0.08221309632062912,
-0.6475604176521301,
0.8579829931259155,
-0.110337033867836,
-0.8170294761657715,
0.2856403589248657,
-0.9097852110862732,
-0.5294391512870789,
0.05583619698882103,
0.06741534918546677,
-0.3037249743938446,
0.1315997838973999,
-0.07922529429197311,
0.6952497363090515,
-0.18304595351219177,
0.47930222749710083,
-0.26472657918930054,
0.019580615684390068,
0.4523913860321045,
-0.06620007008314133,
0.5868692398071289,
0.5332299470901489,
0.0431179404258728,
0.23345425724983215,
-1.0587897300720215,
0.033576250076293945,
0.05066130682826042,
-0.23490792512893677,
-0.4704244136810303,
0.07405450195074081,
0.863846480846405,
0.3261105716228485,
0.30337467789649963,
-0.5335356593132019,
0.3067375421524048,
0.014219021424651146,
0.2631581425666809,
0.32007554173469543,
-0.13748568296432495,
0.1721363067626953,
-0.49532997608184814,
0.49932047724723816,
0.10239550471305847,
-0.23246018588542938,
-0.5820441842079163,
-0.33822864294052124,
-0.6061038970947266,
-0.2865549325942993,
0.4536915123462677,
0.5867364406585693,
-0.8109545707702637,
0.08694202452898026,
-0.4354206621646881,
-0.5142116546630859,
-0.2878544330596924,
-0.07332570105791092,
0.40647199749946594,
0.305480033159256,
0.026951707899570465,
-0.1914462149143219,
-0.4931534230709076,
-1.2500511407852173,
-0.011415884830057621,
0.040803320705890656,
0.09189064055681229,
-0.04839104041457176,
1.175571084022522,
-0.12854599952697754,
0.780845582485199,
-0.6330105662345886,
-0.04816395416855812,
-0.16492325067520142,
0.6640030145645142,
0.0703727975487709,
0.6146793365478516,
0.7061939835548401,
-0.9866662621498108,
-0.7142008543014526,
-0.0009764416026882827,
-0.7912150025367737,
-0.09308143705129623,
0.040625493973493576,
0.3036854565143585,
0.44902193546295166,
0.15539003908634186,
-0.5358173847198486,
0.3063702881336212,
0.49263736605644226,
-0.6658039689064026,
0.9422730207443237,
-0.36394691467285156,
0.6432887315750122,
-1.4844396114349365,
0.5202163457870483,
0.1943816840648651,
-0.4370798170566559,
-0.8703325390815735,
-0.054946210235357285,
0.2980367839336395,
-0.17739053070545197,
-0.17226018011569977,
0.3274264633655548,
-0.6316499710083008,
-0.2875206768512726,
-0.35977426171302795,
0.09929394721984863,
-0.028651583939790726,
0.15308722853660583,
0.3597894310951233,
0.9961391687393188,
0.6084166765213013,
-0.33780571818351746,
0.5781785845756531,
0.29809802770614624,
-0.4906316101551056,
0.6339123845100403,
-0.9077219367027283,
-0.2622707486152649,
-0.4369753897190094,
0.08339019119739532,
-1.1485501527786255,
-0.6146893501281738,
-0.04442044347524643,
-0.41907310485839844,
0.1789507269859314,
0.07780702412128448,
-0.788375198841095,
-0.15009205043315887,
-0.3865036368370056,
0.26910337805747986,
-0.03426405414938927,
-0.08171346783638,
0.30945631861686707,
0.5353155732154846,
-0.7090757489204407,
-0.48273029923439026,
-0.8977085947990417,
0.4274327754974365,
-0.15068241953849792,
-0.7061260342597961,
0.19933311641216278,
-0.40248164534568787,
-0.4595186710357666,
0.21205191314220428,
0.4152175486087799,
-0.35931649804115295,
-0.26084211468696594,
0.00562485633417964,
0.3208559453487396,
-0.08470678329467773,
0.46759098768234253,
-0.13016484677791595,
-0.014992587268352509,
-0.07898430526256561,
0.06331334263086319,
0.5425633192062378,
-0.5145664215087891,
-0.0846506729722023,
-0.3612348735332489,
0.6060346961021423,
0.7580980062484741,
-0.1964997947216034,
0.5728922486305237,
0.6602051854133606,
-0.3059350550174713,
0.38586029410362244,
-0.4199235439300537,
-0.05158441513776779,
-0.37264376878738403,
0.505366861820221,
-0.3263431489467621,
-0.45321914553642273,
0.7308955788612366,
0.395832359790802,
-0.02347804605960846,
0.5811975002288818,
0.47665560245513916,
-0.1866494119167328,
1.021385669708252,
0.5048952698707581,
-0.11636360734701157,
0.22673578560352325,
-0.27823880314826965,
-0.1184123083949089,
-0.5099961757659912,
-0.3013107180595398,
-0.7861682176589966,
-0.05502130091190338,
-0.6092040538787842,
-0.03544517979025841,
0.3928273022174835,
-0.5368027091026306,
0.21236681938171387,
0.274091511964798,
-0.3257812261581421,
0.4171487092971802,
0.5556750297546387,
-0.13197919726371765,
0.5477481484413147,
0.16748327016830444,
0.060795579105615616,
-0.18472351133823395,
-0.5715640783309937,
-0.44653040170669556,
1.0130971670150757,
-0.12806791067123413,
0.8420190811157227,
0.14704279601573944,
0.2584700584411621,
0.42347249388694763,
0.03849829360842705,
-0.7218503355979919,
0.46858254075050354,
0.045356206595897675,
-0.8916564583778381,
-0.10057954490184784,
-0.408424973487854,
-0.8995704054832458,
0.300602525472641,
-0.3319196105003357,
-0.5975682735443115,
0.23305462300777435,
0.04104821756482124,
0.05343383178114891,
0.012768042273819447,
-0.8127455115318298,
0.6518619656562805,
-0.2518151104450226,
-0.3911722004413605,
-0.43221667408943176,
-0.7317387461662292,
0.47893184423446655,
-0.18157263100147247,
0.3440697491168976,
0.17003236711025238,
0.07297128438949585,
1.0889627933502197,
-0.19556596875190735,
0.5087543725967407,
0.035290539264678955,
0.13074079155921936,
0.09221792221069336,
-0.11488261073827744,
0.39732852578163147,
0.11211254447698593,
0.2141261100769043,
-0.08897367119789124,
0.37658923864364624,
-0.38459351658821106,
-0.11950060725212097,
0.9282686710357666,
-0.6274749040603638,
-0.09845496714115143,
-0.950577437877655,
-0.948244035243988,
0.015980634838342667,
0.5486689805984497,
0.015777938067913055,
0.809221088886261,
-0.24042478203773499,
0.4591633677482605,
0.5930363535881042,
-0.06210574880242348,
0.7023554444313049,
0.8075793981552124,
-0.4945595860481262,
-0.6922006011009216,
0.9035125374794006,
0.6186829805374146,
0.13647383451461792,
0.22154483199119568,
0.10433195531368256,
-0.22722505033016205,
-0.49629244208335876,
-0.35528793931007385,
0.3557452857494354,
-0.6507471203804016,
-0.014710772782564163,
-0.8738469481468201,
-0.09339932352304459,
-0.562736451625824,
-0.017157873138785362,
-0.09164459258317947,
-0.8976414203643799,
-0.19981661438941956,
-0.07266245037317276,
0.349520206451416,
0.8926666975021362,
-0.2604985237121582,
0.42236897349357605,
-0.8104636669158936,
0.41522279381752014,
0.09310707449913025,
0.4956102967262268,
-0.423372358083725,
-0.26483574509620667,
-0.5563138127326965,
0.21271345019340515,
-0.11094579100608826,
-0.9489717483520508,
0.6474253535270691,
0.26251307129859924,
0.4532153308391571,
0.3139650225639343,
-0.4944550096988678,
0.3698543608188629,
-0.3239152729511261,
0.7920176982879639,
0.2737603783607483,
-0.6816754937171936,
0.38218775391578674,
-0.8611291646957397,
0.7521845698356628,
0.3715437054634094,
0.5728028416633606,
-0.7292986512184143,
-0.02323327586054802,
-0.4899546802043915,
-0.5817983150482178,
0.8452083468437195,
0.0888262689113617,
-0.12419972568750381,
0.39365899562835693,
0.015797406435012817,
0.3411189913749695,
0.43376296758651733,
-0.9311811923980713,
-0.27490007877349854,
-0.4478505253791809,
-0.46116024255752563,
-0.5595852136611938,
-0.5475607514381409,
-0.3435504138469696,
-0.26610392332077026,
0.8285325169563293,
-0.20932383835315704,
0.27862149477005005,
-0.03968819975852966,
-0.3391687572002411,
-0.0066381231881678104,
0.2548721134662628,
1.176483154296875,
1.0628280639648438,
-0.2705938220024109,
0.29635855555534363,
-0.1860954314470291,
-0.8030856251716614,
0.02681911177933216,
0.3466021716594696,
-0.3160104751586914,
0.15324260294437408,
0.3170911371707916,
0.6713566780090332,
-0.25989171862602234,
-0.6944193840026855,
0.2545775771141052,
-0.2421206533908844,
-0.396464079618454,
-0.4086301624774933,
-0.2196294367313385,
0.25431153178215027,
0.0634983628988266,
0.6312260627746582,
0.06040486693382263,
0.5394740104675293,
-0.4729972183704376,
0.2599160075187683,
0.41898462176322937,
-0.061475224792957306,
-0.7796545624732971,
0.4350992441177368,
-0.0853130891919136,
-0.08541269600391388,
0.3220536708831787,
0.044442519545555115,
-0.27856481075286865,
0.544620931148529,
0.6544157862663269,
0.6578100919723511,
-0.1670275777578354,
0.5485936999320984,
0.4026857018470764,
0.4765540063381195,
-0.08989471197128296,
0.6231597661972046,
0.11326414346694946,
-0.3054274618625641,
-0.30262288451194763,
-0.42900562286376953,
-0.23503246903419495,
0.24441242218017578,
-0.44471022486686707,
0.15947666764259338,
0.04063394293189049,
-0.10691282153129578,
0.3199160397052765,
0.04374634474515915,
-0.27000248432159424,
0.28753262758255005,
-0.3523890972137451,
0.5237712264060974,
-1.1121841669082642,
0.7194461822509766,
0.9632834196090698,
-0.4043714702129364,
0.06547152996063232,
-0.39568042755126953,
-0.024049201980233192,
-0.39779940247535706,
0.8531597256660461,
-0.13162659108638763,
-0.029022162780165672,
-0.1115562915802002,
-0.6089767217636108,
-1.1911858320236206,
0.8776068687438965,
0.09001391381025314,
-0.26693296432495117,
0.2278650403022766,
0.3795698583126068,
0.6045241951942444,
-0.2843455374240875,
0.440094918012619,
0.11100995540618896,
0.7969488501548767,
-0.1848641335964203,
-1.0365511178970337,
-0.2504308223724365,
-0.9119442701339722,
-0.1696418970823288,
0.1742624044418335,
-0.7759882807731628,
0.970313310623169,
0.035814009606838226,
0.007312609814107418,
-0.3013731837272644,
0.5506141781806946,
-0.14948178827762604,
0.33490312099456787,
0.28799304366111755,
0.4467318058013916,
0.3426668047904968,
-0.2554115951061249,
0.7379422187805176,
-0.30799293518066406,
0.3019205629825592,
1.0001065731048584,
-0.0012705102562904358,
0.4325462877750397,
0.5805479884147644,
-0.18986119329929352,
0.2621423006057739,
0.5083115696907043,
-0.24080267548561096,
0.6143168807029724,
-0.12592259049415588,
-0.12558294832706451,
0.25185731053352356,
-0.18422789871692657,
-0.4735516905784607,
0.5649920701980591,
0.4571026563644409,
-0.36201217770576477,
-0.3118792772293091,
0.22456231713294983,
0.3344988524913788,
-0.15449704229831696,
-0.08715490996837616,
0.9025096297264099,
-0.3518602252006531,
-0.6856423616409302,
0.3454723656177521,
0.047003377228975296,
0.3838854432106018,
-0.9133818745613098,
0.07040544599294662,
-0.1506229192018509,
0.14717507362365723,
-0.2616182565689087,
-0.6909464001655579,
0.511683464050293,
-0.010130677372217178,
-0.3315703570842743,
-0.07643179595470428,
0.8386709094047546,
-0.7965253591537476,
-0.9076042175292969,
-0.27131080627441406,
0.34635046124458313,
0.20642413198947906,
0.40413907170295715,
-0.41198524832725525,
-0.1569048911333084,
-0.13653545081615448,
-0.5305001735687256,
0.37492895126342773,
0.05792928487062454,
-0.07492285966873169,
0.8165861964225769,
0.5605038404464722,
0.16428843140602112,
0.04860915616154671,
-0.20311075448989868,
0.757765531539917,
-0.5307013988494873,
-0.6359066963195801,
-0.5619714260101318,
0.7913771867752075,
-0.2523913085460663,
-0.25203001499176025,
0.9803751111030579,
1.052255630493164,
0.49322059750556946,
-0.500148594379425,
1.1892201900482178,
-0.3959132432937622,
0.44553643465042114,
-0.2933346927165985,
1.0488239526748657,
-0.7446098327636719,
-0.48602476716041565,
-0.22898459434509277,
-0.6708077788352966,
-0.47908657789230347,
0.497223824262619,
0.02519737370312214,
0.017096135765314102,
0.8656910061836243,
0.931105375289917,
-0.24926568567752838,
0.03465341404080391,
0.23066173493862152,
0.28890737891197205,
0.3065490126609802,
-0.06711220741271973,
0.5318425297737122,
-0.4319300353527069,
0.2667883634567261,
-0.4182168245315552,
-0.31604674458503723,
-0.32197174429893494,
-1.0516471862792969,
-0.8585813045501709,
-1.2010301351547241,
-0.2293653041124344,
-0.10626047849655151,
0.17021659016609192,
0.8037965893745422,
0.4703509509563446,
-1.0056695938110352,
-0.5356702208518982,
0.22010013461112976,
-0.2903243899345398,
-0.1244121789932251,
-0.24023966491222382,
0.45415687561035156,
-0.2029813677072525,
-0.7957004308700562,
0.30246615409851074,
0.14765702188014984,
0.31110477447509766,
-0.44578060507774353,
0.1596260964870453,
-0.7204378247261047,
-0.05133037641644478,
0.4430253505706787,
-0.009790687821805477,
-0.1681234985589981,
0.023615611717104912,
0.021511033177375793,
-0.05135815218091011,
-0.010003950446844101,
0.7612426280975342,
-0.3512325584888458,
0.7391794919967651,
0.9221749305725098,
0.009062499739229679,
0.7365687489509583,
-0.23882782459259033,
0.5730921626091003,
-0.41770511865615845,
0.2554180920124054,
-0.0493927001953125,
0.5682610869407654,
0.23933567106723785,
-0.22793594002723694,
0.4661710858345032,
0.4081384837627411,
-0.683920681476593,
-0.9181751012802124,
0.009723907336592674,
-1.0285892486572266,
-0.22403350472450256,
1.0200122594833374,
0.051221106201410294,
-0.09093478322029114,
-0.04371805116534233,
-0.3410648703575134,
0.2611972689628601,
-0.4091949462890625,
1.0763626098632812,
0.9388232231140137,
0.2333938330411911,
-0.29787135124206543,
-0.6185709238052368,
0.34282171726226807,
0.13200987875461578,
-1.1900405883789062,
0.0664861649274826,
0.8930466771125793,
0.27653393149375916,
0.41305091977119446,
0.4320582151412964,
-0.15711848437786102,
0.37546107172966003,
0.026829179376363754,
0.27216455340385437,
-0.3887815475463867,
-0.5935613512992859,
-0.29474106431007385,
0.2789834439754486,
-0.3719766438007355,
0.17267107963562012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07883v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07883v1
|
Zero-Shot Tokenizer Transfer
| 2024-05-13T16:17:10 | 2024-05-13T16:17:10 |
Benjamin Minixhofer, Edoardo Maria Ponti, Ivan Vulić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) are bound to their tokenizer, which maps raw text to a
sequence of vocabulary items (tokens). This restricts their flexibility: for
example, LMs trained primarily on English may still perform well in other
natural and programming languages, but have vastly decreased efficiency due to
their English-centric tokenizer. To mitigate this, we should be able to swap
the original LM tokenizer with an arbitrary one, on the fly, without degrading
performance. Hence, in this work we define a new problem: Zero-Shot Tokenizer
Transfer (ZeTT). The challenge at the core of ZeTT is finding embeddings for
the tokens in the vocabulary of the new tokenizer. Since prior heuristics for
initializing embeddings often perform at chance level in a ZeTT setting, we
propose a new solution: we train a hypernetwork taking a tokenizer as input and
predicting the corresponding embeddings. We empirically demonstrate that the
hypernetwork generalizes to new tokenizers both with encoder (e.g., XLM-R) and
decoder LLMs (e.g., Mistral-7B). Our method comes close to the original models'
performance in cross-lingual and coding tasks while markedly reducing the
length of the tokenized sequence. We also find that the remaining gap can be
quickly closed by continued training on less than 1B tokens. Finally, we show
that a ZeTT hypernetwork trained for a base (L)LM can also be applied to
fine-tuned variants without extra training. Overall, our results make
substantial strides toward detaching LMs from their tokenizer.
|
[
0.058714061975479126,
-0.5783189535140991,
0.6113414168357849,
-0.1675928831100464,
-0.3635900616645813,
0.04844823107123375,
-0.19121409952640533,
-0.4631035625934601,
0.3677524924278259,
0.4196333885192871,
-0.06941807270050049,
-0.25181394815444946,
-0.6509854793548584,
-0.10215134918689728,
-0.42527005076408386,
0.8568798899650574,
-0.11937468498945236,
-0.05157027021050453,
0.43706777691841125,
-0.09087779372930527,
-0.5267993807792664,
-0.622997522354126,
-0.31463623046875,
-0.4811750650405884,
0.6923831701278687,
0.44976606965065,
0.7117624282836914,
0.8281348943710327,
0.1352556347846985,
0.14751358330249786,
-0.18648062646389008,
-0.5513066649436951,
-0.48569267988204956,
0.08617056906223297,
-0.1897260695695877,
-0.5588535070419312,
-0.2903651297092438,
-0.25397244095802307,
0.5368781089782715,
0.7019347548484802,
0.13425451517105103,
0.1934937834739685,
-0.29331856966018677,
0.30085569620132446,
-0.830136775970459,
-0.004891757387667894,
-0.9968775510787964,
0.21158644556999207,
-0.21648073196411133,
-0.19750244915485382,
-0.5616472959518433,
0.043944768607616425,
-0.046956852078437805,
-0.5661782026290894,
0.3380492031574249,
-0.025102199986577034,
0.8648079633712769,
-0.23416556417942047,
-0.4776034355163574,
0.2385576218366623,
-1.0926823616027832,
0.7357438802719116,
-0.6148832440376282,
0.4508534371852875,
-0.09333498030900955,
0.44190746545791626,
0.18116138875484467,
-0.6605033278465271,
-0.6267682313919067,
-0.12513433396816254,
0.22434213757514954,
0.05143485590815544,
-0.29116010665893555,
0.10741990804672241,
0.1922476440668106,
0.252183198928833,
-0.44560036063194275,
0.10147471725940704,
-0.3518257141113281,
-0.37413129210472107,
-0.05036984384059906,
0.13368067145347595,
0.28439879417419434,
-0.1185964047908783,
-0.49177056550979614,
0.1113554909825325,
-0.8532345294952393,
-0.1316954791545868,
0.01932614855468273,
0.519010066986084,
0.3062525987625122,
0.553832471370697,
-0.3772428333759308,
0.6778560280799866,
-0.1388150006532669,
0.44203677773475647,
0.33410102128982544,
-0.3664602041244507,
-0.2830459773540497,
0.38004711270332336,
0.4935793876647949,
0.33539918065071106,
0.2600008249282837,
-0.6158688068389893,
-0.3534407615661621,
-0.06281446665525436,
0.04763877019286156,
-0.9730544090270996,
0.04086112603545189,
0.05098633095622063,
-0.047678008675575256,
-0.2658417224884033,
-0.057234857231378555,
-0.20432992279529572,
0.05839024856686592,
0.018989425152540207,
0.8926973342895508,
-0.5333437919616699,
-0.22518202662467957,
0.39571645855903625,
-0.46124136447906494,
0.23943567276000977,
0.3342965543270111,
-0.8613742589950562,
-0.004845104180276394,
0.6750118732452393,
1.2340198755264282,
0.2011394500732422,
-0.45188915729522705,
-0.5999729633331299,
0.48901596665382385,
-0.5400089621543884,
0.46691998839378357,
-0.284485399723053,
-0.10077503323554993,
0.08496285229921341,
0.056193266063928604,
-0.040745195001363754,
-0.15138283371925354,
-0.04643167555332184,
-0.71933913230896,
-0.04934241250157356,
-0.30181044340133667,
-0.7131420373916626,
-0.0931205302476883,
0.4122503101825714,
-0.624569833278656,
0.5907164812088013,
0.4155787527561188,
-0.4276301860809326,
0.3356867730617523,
-0.4788070619106293,
-0.2646907866001129,
0.34004101157188416,
-0.04560786113142967,
-0.032940782606601715,
0.2970578670501709,
-0.11004099994897842,
0.44642093777656555,
-0.2936285436153412,
-0.023256948217749596,
-0.2627420723438263,
-0.874240517616272,
-0.07147727906703949,
-0.21292322874069214,
0.824569582939148,
-0.01810717210173607,
-0.6302573680877686,
-0.039892569184303284,
-0.4766698181629181,
0.14446592330932617,
0.07117455452680588,
-0.16957320272922516,
-0.3496529459953308,
-0.5045614838600159,
0.2355818748474121,
0.29274141788482666,
0.05133533850312233,
-1.0274710655212402,
0.2567165791988373,
-0.5159364342689514,
0.6403591632843018,
0.8363514542579651,
-0.11678208410739899,
0.6725425720214844,
-0.388813853263855,
0.5576498508453369,
0.271374374628067,
0.1615290343761444,
-0.17424651980400085,
-0.38702934980392456,
-0.8964045643806458,
0.03134993836283684,
0.5397948622703552,
0.4808714687824249,
-1.1047093868255615,
0.20762880146503448,
-0.6848821640014648,
-0.48468443751335144,
-0.4309309422969818,
0.020252687856554985,
0.34957170486450195,
0.49366721510887146,
0.42291852831840515,
-0.29491522908210754,
-0.2707720696926117,
-0.8603228330612183,
-0.2556989789009094,
-0.08824855834245682,
0.22915418446063995,
-0.0356871671974659,
0.3538518249988556,
-0.03392200917005539,
1.0445835590362549,
-0.22693483531475067,
-0.19258512556552887,
-0.6571704149246216,
-0.009524395689368248,
0.31684496998786926,
0.5798633098602295,
0.7372515201568604,
-0.3366810381412506,
-0.7710975408554077,
0.41341716051101685,
-0.349925696849823,
0.19440560042858124,
-0.2323005050420761,
-0.11871931701898575,
0.003214331576600671,
0.4665343165397644,
-0.5479369759559631,
0.5667001605033875,
0.3728598356246948,
-0.46434155106544495,
0.42254164814949036,
-0.07997075468301773,
-0.045252908021211624,
-1.1931700706481934,
0.08746311813592911,
-0.31857576966285706,
-0.31077447533607483,
-0.8676767349243164,
-0.13966697454452515,
0.25483062863349915,
-0.14627216756343842,
-0.9586621522903442,
0.8506560325622559,
-0.6475711464881897,
-0.022254733368754387,
-0.2019462287425995,
-0.055539242923259735,
-0.13421539962291718,
0.5399202108383179,
-0.15102435648441315,
0.7866559028625488,
0.693263053894043,
-0.37415674328804016,
0.2018396258354187,
0.1453033685684204,
-0.21632707118988037,
0.1846892386674881,
-0.7724396586418152,
0.3264850378036499,
-0.10717727988958359,
0.08526520431041718,
-0.6477496027946472,
0.31804946064949036,
0.25640255212783813,
-0.4924507439136505,
0.13231982290744781,
-0.7213516235351562,
-0.32101771235466003,
-0.039237454533576965,
-0.3010972738265991,
0.3964727818965912,
0.7426270246505737,
-0.22628401219844818,
0.25957778096199036,
-0.0989803597331047,
0.2300797402858734,
-0.5275368094444275,
-0.7496439218521118,
0.45091813802719116,
0.06325419247150421,
-0.35892772674560547,
0.606732964515686,
0.163494274020195,
0.3045777380466461,
0.3971749544143677,
-0.0857875645160675,
-0.10673294961452484,
0.21804505586624146,
0.22488674521446228,
0.23751524090766907,
-0.47468578815460205,
0.08390360325574875,
-0.036741677671670914,
-0.2953076660633087,
-0.34740760922431946,
-0.6334765553474426,
0.7881471514701843,
-0.08317701518535614,
-0.44861719012260437,
-0.306257963180542,
0.21157240867614746,
0.6890732049942017,
-0.0877288207411766,
0.9821161031723022,
0.7695102691650391,
-0.36749809980392456,
-0.15756316483020782,
-0.41809868812561035,
-0.09724941104650497,
-0.3855687975883484,
0.5437700748443604,
-0.4374680519104004,
-1.1904027462005615,
0.5482674241065979,
0.11714053899049759,
0.21562297642230988,
0.33763614296913147,
0.5007910132408142,
0.4196383059024811,
0.8600597381591797,
0.9149875640869141,
-0.30896568298339844,
0.893727719783783,
-0.5150166749954224,
0.34662777185440063,
-0.9496787190437317,
0.11193431168794632,
-0.4206636846065521,
-0.5102031826972961,
-0.21344707906246185,
-0.31674015522003174,
0.1637081503868103,
0.22538773715496063,
-0.2694268822669983,
0.8950138092041016,
-0.20627076923847198,
0.7326769232749939,
0.5131360292434692,
0.014790537767112255,
0.048604901880025864,
0.057651370763778687,
-0.2732497751712799,
0.1454203575849533,
-1.0867735147476196,
-0.24548234045505524,
1.1292874813079834,
0.1677091419696808,
0.23834025859832764,
0.3860078752040863,
1.021359920501709,
0.09875210374593735,
0.33470606803894043,
-0.9410945773124695,
0.48033684492111206,
-0.1477297842502594,
-0.5267059803009033,
-0.42119207978248596,
-0.5268381237983704,
-0.9889137744903564,
0.2814899981021881,
-0.10077427327632904,
-0.8985744714736938,
0.21643777191638947,
0.059399548918008804,
-0.5378667116165161,
0.7237858176231384,
-0.6108411550521851,
0.7946160435676575,
0.06288692355155945,
-0.45931026339530945,
-0.08076049387454987,
-0.4034108519554138,
0.07700175791978836,
0.0026079516392201185,
-0.05817476287484169,
-0.19206251204013824,
0.09626239538192749,
0.5758821964263916,
-0.522562563419342,
0.7622624635696411,
-0.30655553936958313,
0.25562340021133423,
-0.06621392071247101,
0.5322273969650269,
0.3580471873283386,
-0.24360157549381256,
-0.195241779088974,
0.16170461475849152,
0.04590078443288803,
-0.7269980311393738,
-0.8427550196647644,
0.49518850445747375,
-0.7377505302429199,
-0.7154482007026672,
-0.21757759153842926,
-0.32713937759399414,
-0.2194228172302246,
0.46317681670188904,
0.26683053374290466,
0.5267190933227539,
-0.18675917387008667,
0.41312161087989807,
0.21736659109592438,
0.0924328863620758,
0.5729236602783203,
0.45686134696006775,
-0.10668286681175232,
-0.2539195716381073,
0.9364442229270935,
0.34167301654815674,
0.3503658175468445,
0.3778012692928314,
0.36866140365600586,
-0.00998575147241354,
-0.7297316789627075,
-0.8435335755348206,
0.051582567393779755,
-0.6589934825897217,
-0.3381696045398712,
-0.5300557017326355,
-0.46376118063926697,
-0.4964566230773926,
-0.43974629044532776,
-0.44248703122138977,
-0.7019191384315491,
-0.26954734325408936,
-0.08967482298612595,
0.3722147047519684,
0.6106995940208435,
0.000340233207680285,
0.5197803974151611,
-1.2529710531234741,
-0.12150776386260986,
0.20763756334781647,
0.30120179057121277,
0.17032139003276825,
-0.9512913227081299,
-0.632538378238678,
0.06489922106266022,
0.1478973925113678,
-0.9486411213874817,
0.3893880546092987,
0.16574637591838837,
0.5021396279335022,
0.11386533081531525,
0.007547077257186174,
0.8049724102020264,
-0.5902544856071472,
0.8518341779708862,
0.568107545375824,
-1.2039971351623535,
0.3666728734970093,
-0.20053893327713013,
0.2213381677865982,
0.5100944638252258,
0.25958290696144104,
-1.0130749940872192,
-0.16484354436397552,
-0.5102503299713135,
-0.926589846611023,
0.7061551809310913,
0.2233334630727768,
0.4899262487888336,
-0.23857173323631287,
0.5000573396682739,
-0.08363325893878937,
0.0667063295841217,
-0.5650646686553955,
-0.023551244288682938,
-0.23361095786094666,
-0.016494322568178177,
-0.20117001235485077,
-0.1948978453874588,
0.13278990983963013,
-0.2670515775680542,
0.566545844078064,
-0.12996803224086761,
0.35034430027008057,
0.2200102061033249,
-0.6220182180404663,
-0.12228924036026001,
0.37173640727996826,
0.4109927713871002,
0.4878588318824768,
-0.17725355923175812,
0.368150532245636,
0.013843867927789688,
-0.3139309883117676,
0.49365073442459106,
-0.36435025930404663,
-0.4866451919078827,
0.2884877324104309,
0.33455726504325867,
1.0629477500915527,
0.3993854820728302,
-0.3875931203365326,
0.8845542073249817,
0.2753331661224365,
-0.3032476007938385,
0.018432511016726494,
0.1114838644862175,
-0.1590547412633896,
0.09347181022167206,
0.10434308648109436,
0.008424278348684311,
0.01418195478618145,
-0.74788898229599,
0.30545422434806824,
0.29339873790740967,
-0.7582361102104187,
-0.6894024014472961,
0.40502849221229553,
0.16037337481975555,
-0.535281777381897,
0.6394180059432983,
-0.26603296399116516,
-0.8601043224334717,
0.5405442714691162,
0.8809564113616943,
1.1911288499832153,
0.1407506912946701,
0.3071568012237549,
0.20445039868354797,
0.40204551815986633,
-0.13862557709217072,
-0.005406439304351807,
-0.10425479710102081,
-1.1146886348724365,
-0.3804159462451935,
-0.3016264736652374,
-0.330887109041214,
-0.1815822571516037,
-0.6092319488525391,
0.20265671610832214,
-0.5042363405227661,
-0.32146406173706055,
-0.09143225848674774,
-0.32853344082832336,
-0.8445082902908325,
-0.29671335220336914,
0.027031367644667625,
0.831443190574646,
-0.8933025002479553,
1.1100531816482544,
0.6607334017753601,
-0.47890034317970276,
-0.8326197862625122,
-0.15748292207717896,
-0.19285963475704193,
-0.8746870756149292,
0.7956549525260925,
0.00034091348061338067,
-0.06159798800945282,
0.2928532063961029,
-0.1557074636220932,
-0.7699686288833618,
1.2602530717849731,
0.43360498547554016,
-0.7382161021232605,
-0.17475832998752594,
0.22333426773548126,
0.3257023096084595,
-0.04345637932419777,
0.4812982976436615,
0.3389640152454376,
0.22286134958267212,
0.19182047247886658,
-0.9991016387939453,
0.098734550178051,
-0.2765267789363861,
0.2814725339412689,
0.4420356750488281,
-0.6619023680686951,
1.1514358520507812,
-0.05001930519938469,
-0.24372288584709167,
-0.09763038903474808,
0.4357602894306183,
-0.25120264291763306,
-0.09745142608880997,
0.5014501214027405,
0.5726531744003296,
0.18555423617362976,
0.12637226283550262,
0.6900541186332703,
-0.5760669708251953,
0.5215152502059937,
0.925505518913269,
-0.5358990430831909,
0.8801445960998535,
0.8104076385498047,
0.09023527055978775,
0.31036707758903503,
0.03615201637148857,
0.1580350548028946,
0.3500303626060486,
0.2951681613922119,
-0.290365993976593,
-0.2857491374015808,
-0.10003050416707993,
-0.23008769750595093,
0.38452792167663574,
-0.028423244133591652,
-0.17904134094715118,
-0.6554954051971436,
0.0064161899499595165,
0.02292829006910324,
-0.3551880121231079,
-0.11522182822227478,
0.5987755656242371,
-0.15589769184589386,
-0.16801047325134277,
0.580852210521698,
0.18515510857105255,
0.8213198184967041,
-0.5518547892570496,
-0.08579307049512863,
-0.39848095178604126,
0.03472492843866348,
0.08820341527462006,
-0.579437792301178,
0.43079787492752075,
-0.07795985043048859,
0.0784950777888298,
-0.5086222887039185,
0.6825159788131714,
-0.2816019356250763,
-0.24602992832660675,
0.3540560305118561,
0.8786196112632751,
0.12665721774101257,
-0.1952262967824936,
-0.46486273407936096,
-0.187437504529953,
0.0703493282198906,
-0.3562982976436615,
0.6167458295822144,
0.664535403251648,
-0.057541653513908386,
0.4472476541996002,
0.8030598163604736,
0.458147257566452,
0.29480940103530884,
0.21910585463047028,
0.8385292291641235,
-1.0411384105682373,
-0.5294684171676636,
-0.8649540543556213,
0.21207347512245178,
0.1958785057067871,
-0.3960959315299988,
0.6746472716331482,
0.5038348436355591,
0.8151058554649353,
-0.09727924317121506,
0.6579911708831787,
-0.11248273402452469,
0.06110838055610657,
-0.5215601921081543,
0.8289152383804321,
-0.47060462832450867,
0.05673697590827942,
-0.029625406488776207,
-0.9300190806388855,
-0.3153742849826813,
0.394402414560318,
-0.0984300971031189,
-0.20167554914951324,
0.5736982226371765,
0.7472073435783386,
-0.06187804043292999,
-0.38948482275009155,
0.9161681532859802,
-0.09657672047615051,
0.4875611364841461,
0.8376355171203613,
0.7570028901100159,
-0.6284055709838867,
0.5930812954902649,
-0.581001877784729,
-0.05795595422387123,
-0.4208959937095642,
-0.8353450894355774,
-0.6576808094978333,
-0.4669254422187805,
-0.297902911901474,
-0.17825333774089813,
0.3287605941295624,
0.9735491871833801,
0.67887282371521,
-0.6098049283027649,
-0.2562078535556793,
-0.23804548382759094,
0.033315517008304596,
-0.12874437868595123,
-0.21205094456672668,
0.1135675311088562,
-0.34503716230392456,
-0.45245635509490967,
0.27768048644065857,
0.5112135410308838,
0.2841991186141968,
-0.07846225798130035,
0.10818059742450714,
0.01713704876601696,
0.03328460082411766,
0.6239377856254578,
0.26849645376205444,
-0.6062353849411011,
-0.781067430973053,
0.40821799635887146,
-0.11557036638259888,
0.16088174283504486,
1.137911081314087,
-0.8530253171920776,
0.30980634689331055,
0.5533924102783203,
0.8713276386260986,
0.543951690196991,
-0.4715462327003479,
0.5035911798477173,
-0.6326744556427002,
0.3185213804244995,
0.4324930012226105,
0.3918251693248749,
-0.09261129796504974,
-0.17874948680400848,
0.17689262330532074,
0.47983917593955994,
-0.08066464960575104,
-0.8652125597000122,
0.22965054214000702,
-0.9035581946372986,
-0.26857709884643555,
1.120100498199463,
-0.15439902245998383,
-0.4378013610839844,
-0.24636481702327728,
0.06708980351686478,
0.3938865661621094,
-0.2237124890089035,
0.5138716101646423,
0.6543763875961304,
0.1792767345905304,
-0.2588973939418793,
-0.4330815374851227,
0.09195347875356674,
0.8193519115447998,
-0.34648939967155457,
0.10831453651189804,
0.15685462951660156,
0.6020846962928772,
0.1053234115242958,
0.74513179063797,
-0.04809514805674553,
0.3983279764652252,
0.050817593932151794,
0.4008662700653076,
-0.44181588292121887,
-0.3939834535121918,
-0.5445470213890076,
0.07542167603969574,
0.1927880197763443,
-0.39806070923805237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07875v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07875v1
|
Reproducing the Metric-Based Evaluation of a Set of Controllable Text Generation Techniques
| 2024-05-13T16:02:57 | 2024-05-13T16:02:57 |
Michela Lorandi, Anya Belz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rerunning a metric-based evaluation should be more straightforward, and
results should be closer, than in a human-based evaluation, especially where
code and model checkpoints are made available by the original authors. As this
report of our efforts to rerun a metric-based evaluation of a set of
single-attribute and multiple-attribute controllable text generation (CTG)
techniques shows however, such reruns of evaluations do not always produce
results that are the same as the original results, and can reveal errors in the
reporting of the original work.
|
[
0.0017150684725493193,
-0.5293284058570862,
0.4701489508152008,
0.30677083134651184,
-0.17682677507400513,
0.533889651298523,
-0.32040634751319885,
-0.17952558398246765,
0.06832119077444077,
0.5685930848121643,
-0.8729551434516907,
-0.5645765662193298,
-0.5433689951896667,
0.2531772553920746,
-0.4393843412399292,
1.1614335775375366,
-0.28461241722106934,
-0.02912791445851326,
-0.12776051461696625,
-0.3489031195640564,
-0.7000853419303894,
-0.6408402919769287,
-1.086362361907959,
-0.5571510195732117,
0.6247751712799072,
0.481966495513916,
0.5873856544494629,
0.6798226833343506,
0.6502795219421387,
0.218889057636261,
0.17839960753917694,
0.19975660741329193,
-0.35352399945259094,
-0.09742856025695801,
0.0233809482306242,
-0.5022006630897522,
-0.15630142390727997,
0.5574287176132202,
0.7996607422828674,
0.36259618401527405,
-0.15561212599277496,
0.10519253462553024,
0.2781687080860138,
0.5306626558303833,
-0.7156094908714294,
-0.2961341440677643,
-0.20184746384620667,
0.29191288352012634,
0.19142912328243256,
-0.48182961344718933,
-0.7010203003883362,
-0.7685398459434509,
0.001582409255206585,
-0.6264161467552185,
0.6582381129264832,
0.23044699430465698,
0.7394701242446899,
0.18811622262001038,
-0.3961738646030426,
-0.3011148273944855,
-0.7894241213798523,
1.1186349391937256,
-0.9484143257141113,
0.12229698896408081,
0.13917337357997894,
0.32512256503105164,
-0.24734075367450714,
-0.9356266260147095,
-0.2128479927778244,
-0.7795315980911255,
-0.36389264464378357,
0.23454084992408752,
-0.02823423221707344,
-0.10286371409893036,
0.384597510099411,
0.27543404698371887,
-0.4049273431301117,
0.4203498959541321,
-0.4372478425502777,
-0.28264278173446655,
0.902161180973053,
0.38747936487197876,
0.06773561984300613,
-0.2756180465221405,
-0.5065471529960632,
-0.2519800662994385,
-0.6592327356338501,
-0.1256686896085739,
0.1933593451976776,
0.07426552474498749,
-0.017645783722400665,
0.5052624940872192,
-0.18708325922489166,
0.4294056296348572,
0.2986249625682831,
-0.3918904960155487,
0.3579069674015045,
-0.6912901997566223,
-0.18299727141857147,
-0.16691850125789642,
0.7695605158805847,
0.6767138838768005,
0.11280115693807602,
-0.37616947293281555,
-0.22957855463027954,
-0.03720816597342491,
0.6477175951004028,
-0.569786012172699,
-0.1306794434785843,
0.1526033878326416,
-0.7135919332504272,
-0.6068646907806396,
0.22668133676052094,
-0.718308687210083,
-0.11897546052932739,
-0.5702008605003357,
0.44509851932525635,
-0.39526745676994324,
0.020811777561903,
-0.24099157750606537,
-0.4345247149467468,
0.1662750244140625,
0.3915726840496063,
-0.1631212681531906,
0.23604683578014374,
0.6770665645599365,
0.9723712801933289,
-0.43093129992485046,
-0.6350151896476746,
-0.33693844079971313,
0.006041438318789005,
-0.4783118963241577,
0.6232349872589111,
-0.3662568926811218,
-0.8917531967163086,
-0.09075529873371124,
0.14613951742649078,
-0.055403485894203186,
-0.5377016663551331,
0.42732271552085876,
-0.1132776215672493,
0.4304351210594177,
-0.31590279936790466,
-0.5547999739646912,
0.08166578412055969,
0.09968584030866623,
-0.7317490577697754,
0.9323850274085999,
0.05993977189064026,
-0.8027564287185669,
0.9721694588661194,
-0.41758811473846436,
-0.34995511174201965,
-0.38206222653388977,
-0.1578705757856369,
-0.7105545997619629,
0.4788094460964203,
-0.10525616258382797,
0.15410391986370087,
-0.24856583774089813,
0.003840249963104725,
0.10237341374158859,
-0.4101334810256958,
0.10286936163902283,
-0.31388795375823975,
0.6076462864875793,
0.27564024925231934,
-0.5818040370941162,
0.16781939566135406,
-0.9047206044197083,
0.5824021697044373,
-0.050366416573524475,
-0.7003035545349121,
-0.055795326828956604,
0.1577906757593155,
-0.03386343643069267,
-0.048457223922014236,
0.29524293541908264,
-0.6714031100273132,
0.1967877745628357,
0.2968728244304657,
-0.0013987843412905931,
0.6823930144309998,
0.07970813661813736,
0.3651007413864136,
-0.954399049282074,
0.8373264670372009,
-0.10553878545761108,
-0.1309068202972412,
-0.22580571472644806,
-0.22120708227157593,
-0.6534066796302795,
-0.17042376101016998,
0.1694118082523346,
0.5385180711746216,
-0.678150475025177,
0.11854813247919083,
0.047502551227808,
-0.9830530285835266,
-0.1844799518585205,
0.014674377627670765,
0.9836762547492981,
0.33165788650512695,
-0.18734419345855713,
-0.48547109961509705,
-0.45343396067619324,
-1.0725092887878418,
-0.5940197706222534,
-0.025487711653113365,
-0.010284670628607273,
0.2272443026304245,
0.5614261031150818,
0.15801332890987396,
0.8449702858924866,
-0.6273590922355652,
0.15413159132003784,
-0.35317933559417725,
0.8073167204856873,
-0.10334394872188568,
0.8821197152137756,
0.5931264162063599,
-0.4437638521194458,
-0.42395246028900146,
0.014227681793272495,
-0.567193329334259,
-0.5122349858283997,
-0.48457789421081543,
-0.0321524403989315,
0.4658234119415283,
0.5986495614051819,
0.05774901062250137,
0.7832469344139099,
0.4170185327529907,
-0.2973625957965851,
1.2915778160095215,
-0.4744075536727905,
0.9042450189590454,
-0.9716281294822693,
0.26065248250961304,
0.056094225496053696,
-0.42391887307167053,
-0.2965463101863861,
0.18509328365325928,
-0.16345341503620148,
-0.17577096819877625,
-0.4350041449069977,
0.24886353313922882,
-0.47153744101524353,
-0.11477707326412201,
-0.5262429118156433,
0.32069334387779236,
0.11596468836069107,
0.4018805921077728,
-0.08685462176799774,
0.8353203535079956,
0.17871339619159698,
-0.7430229187011719,
0.4394357204437256,
-0.11727643758058548,
-0.39220136404037476,
0.9167853593826294,
-0.7783897519111633,
0.2837543487548828,
-0.19233372807502747,
0.2726335823535919,
-0.8654171228408813,
-0.11337800323963165,
0.005629924591630697,
-0.5703769326210022,
0.2607734799385071,
0.24873168766498566,
-0.5088518857955933,
-0.2919098138809204,
-0.3647231161594391,
0.27575746178627014,
0.5876189470291138,
-0.6014193892478943,
0.050597529858350754,
-0.20823059976100922,
0.18179626762866974,
-0.40663662552833557,
-0.768684446811676,
-0.14462678134441376,
-0.4283306300640106,
-0.4424462616443634,
0.11178964376449585,
0.18049047887325287,
-0.1333014816045761,
-0.13262011110782623,
-0.07922706753015518,
-0.04257766529917717,
0.14501869678497314,
0.11807192862033844,
-0.11885485053062439,
0.008010377176105976,
0.29699674248695374,
-0.19969770312309265,
-0.2984088957309723,
-0.010512023232877254,
0.0096331387758255,
0.29916664958000183,
0.24622172117233276,
-0.5155874490737915,
-0.8360362648963928,
0.731761634349823,
0.30214163661003113,
-0.24628451466560364,
0.5361137390136719,
0.35481926798820496,
-0.39032071828842163,
-0.25857117772102356,
-0.35307422280311584,
-0.08018731325864792,
-0.45491862297058105,
0.5301432013511658,
-0.16223947703838348,
-0.8069998621940613,
0.4428662061691284,
-0.05796502158045769,
0.5877984166145325,
0.5132095813751221,
0.43275517225265503,
-0.21592628955841064,
0.9445106983184814,
0.9347476363182068,
0.2849380075931549,
0.5027049779891968,
-0.023284509778022766,
-0.09933415800333023,
-0.7131722569465637,
-0.2179557830095291,
-0.9870563745498657,
-0.5469321608543396,
-0.7276960611343384,
-0.11204337328672409,
0.19677717983722687,
0.09725333005189896,
-0.32815882563591003,
0.4030393958091736,
-0.6869955062866211,
0.28590112924575806,
0.8954869508743286,
0.21365423500537872,
0.5270752310752869,
0.002142566256225109,
0.011187545023858547,
-0.29196059703826904,
-0.851189911365509,
-0.7626259326934814,
1.125450849533081,
0.020985841751098633,
0.9127745628356934,
-0.15509560704231262,
0.9744518399238586,
0.5371249914169312,
0.9077818393707275,
-0.5216852426528931,
0.25061604380607605,
-0.32554513216018677,
-0.5682870149612427,
-0.06604687869548798,
-0.6083244681358337,
-0.9173399209976196,
-0.05044030025601387,
0.03284241259098053,
-1.0035820007324219,
-0.1822313666343689,
0.4478904604911804,
-0.22011291980743408,
0.3677479922771454,
-0.8770366311073303,
0.9534048438072205,
-0.1525944322347641,
0.03059513308107853,
-0.3601019084453583,
-0.19352440536022186,
0.43223217129707336,
-0.3075370192527771,
-0.12327656149864197,
0.2869581878185272,
0.04055584967136383,
1.3059568405151367,
-0.7480031847953796,
0.7551555037498474,
-0.10634038597345352,
-0.02739541418850422,
0.6519550681114197,
0.11850856989622116,
0.2608836889266968,
-0.3087005019187927,
0.19941599667072296,
-0.2932613492012024,
0.14974232017993927,
-0.3493039309978485,
-0.7717006206512451,
0.8025767803192139,
-0.5150933861732483,
-0.8171920776367188,
-0.33284908533096313,
-0.3391794264316559,
0.11266569048166275,
0.08596204966306686,
0.6271811127662659,
0.6377297043800354,
-0.27562353014945984,
0.3051300346851349,
0.08555609732866287,
-0.5620631575584412,
0.4031345248222351,
0.14871910214424133,
-0.43128013610839844,
-0.4469844102859497,
0.47369614243507385,
0.16136039793491364,
0.673478364944458,
-0.010553036816418171,
0.14570486545562744,
0.011217930354177952,
-0.15670117735862732,
-0.20732280611991882,
0.13792537152767181,
-0.46254676580429077,
-0.13340669870376587,
-0.14696064591407776,
-0.02784682996571064,
-0.15262143313884735,
-0.6596397161483765,
-0.44230586290359497,
-0.4892452657222748,
-0.17437702417373657,
-0.03816043585538864,
0.3357602655887604,
0.9309861063957214,
-0.3501611649990082,
0.9750249981880188,
-0.6718393564224243,
0.06918427348136902,
-0.07180216908454895,
0.5114638209342957,
0.08652584999799728,
-0.3809325098991394,
-0.5399556756019592,
0.33513832092285156,
-0.6029053330421448,
-0.923670768737793,
0.11339098960161209,
0.05468433350324631,
0.3911411166191101,
-0.01067232247442007,
-0.2795097827911377,
0.6467418670654297,
-0.3890588879585266,
0.9272014498710632,
0.4682618975639343,
-0.9469901323318481,
0.6967337131500244,
-0.09239135682582855,
0.3988391160964966,
0.6023150682449341,
0.03247852250933647,
-0.6917294263839722,
-0.6099672317504883,
-0.7897921800613403,
-0.5214799642562866,
0.7374576330184937,
0.2712557017803192,
-0.2771717309951782,
0.09373889863491058,
0.5162020921707153,
0.1713966280221939,
0.1850496381521225,
-0.5053606629371643,
-0.2719845175743103,
-0.22536663711071014,
0.13986894488334656,
-0.19321073591709137,
-0.15800835192203522,
-0.05459833890199661,
0.3089892864227295,
0.5736355781555176,
-0.020381076261401176,
0.3292456567287445,
0.5293235182762146,
0.2101682424545288,
-0.014761020429432392,
0.3403795063495636,
0.4847908914089203,
0.9348865747451782,
-0.14397142827510834,
-0.17520254850387573,
0.07913632690906525,
-0.4496215283870697,
0.39028632640838623,
-0.42816126346588135,
-0.2125660926103592,
0.29869869351387024,
0.475014865398407,
0.49571317434310913,
0.12227097898721695,
-0.5561556816101074,
0.31227344274520874,
0.10085278749465942,
-0.33040016889572144,
-0.4516974687576294,
0.044579263776540756,
-0.2639496624469757,
0.03049835003912449,
0.21546624600887299,
-0.12474627792835236,
-0.1410348117351532,
-0.5069037675857544,
0.6781682372093201,
0.2099638730287552,
-0.38408854603767395,
-0.06565891951322556,
0.8232965469360352,
0.10552150756120682,
-0.5793495774269104,
0.628487765789032,
-0.1607600748538971,
-0.47213059663772583,
1.1338156461715698,
0.7206286191940308,
1.1638365983963013,
-0.13209493458271027,
0.31102612614631653,
0.7389187812805176,
0.4563301205635071,
0.00010934824967989698,
0.34744781255722046,
0.2765136659145355,
-0.4772198796272278,
-0.6632615327835083,
-0.1606699675321579,
-0.3863579332828522,
-0.2763186991214752,
-0.9471502304077148,
0.07276252657175064,
-0.9195833802223206,
-0.5041453838348389,
-0.008745945058763027,
0.004073945805430412,
-0.5883562564849854,
0.703271210193634,
-0.48754870891571045,
1.1465753316879272,
-0.736364483833313,
0.3179579973220825,
0.6182289123535156,
-0.3400637209415436,
-0.8540104627609253,
-0.10821331292390823,
0.08965444564819336,
-0.3681601881980896,
0.7062687873840332,
0.12840092182159424,
-0.22623202204704285,
-0.3583765923976898,
-0.8004644513130188,
-0.6100775003433228,
1.409067153930664,
-0.17342010140419006,
-0.35639622807502747,
0.10443421453237534,
-0.12222418934106827,
0.5735827088356018,
-0.4233349859714508,
-0.02610594592988491,
0.640943169593811,
0.5462994575500488,
-0.08594318479299545,
-1.2833465337753296,
0.10191532969474792,
0.05914077162742615,
-0.01022530160844326,
0.23020370304584503,
-0.9114275574684143,
0.5198073983192444,
-0.20582886040210724,
-0.47572842240333557,
0.41017356514930725,
0.7489530444145203,
0.5341078042984009,
0.3910481929779053,
0.3961937129497528,
0.7237783074378967,
0.5213131904602051,
-0.4486036002635956,
1.3653957843780518,
0.012757373973727226,
0.5946654081344604,
1.3650379180908203,
0.03815687075257301,
0.4464104473590851,
0.39521524310112,
-0.18606308102607727,
0.3463538885116577,
0.4783197343349457,
-0.11357829719781876,
0.3220839202404022,
0.42154818773269653,
-0.08950415998697281,
-0.033464960753917694,
-0.033047616481781006,
-0.14974039793014526,
0.46701332926750183,
-0.19159862399101257,
-0.5503835082054138,
-0.3336580693721771,
-0.47653841972351074,
0.35198476910591125,
0.12274613231420517,
-0.26589563488960266,
0.5908689498901367,
0.0017020305385813117,
-0.8699091672897339,
0.41229119896888733,
0.3173193335533142,
0.697749674320221,
-0.4936465919017792,
0.010146081447601318,
-0.19674739241600037,
0.011184746399521828,
-0.35910484194755554,
-0.630598783493042,
0.7642641067504883,
0.2344416379928589,
-0.19129887223243713,
-0.266825407743454,
0.48957863450050354,
-0.035365454852581024,
-0.5766417980194092,
-0.22040431201457977,
0.45732513070106506,
0.19731491804122925,
0.3429775536060333,
-0.2915644943714142,
-0.3529900312423706,
0.4935626685619354,
-0.3242112100124359,
-0.18246105313301086,
0.25400272011756897,
-0.08771781623363495,
0.7495903968811035,
0.38787364959716797,
-0.14281749725341797,
0.3559055030345917,
-0.08238931000232697,
0.4277656674385071,
-1.0053855180740356,
-0.36875012516975403,
-0.7348113059997559,
0.5756312608718872,
-0.16719262301921844,
-0.6533679962158203,
0.9037172794342041,
0.7199891209602356,
0.7920132875442505,
-0.07408468425273895,
1.104224443435669,
-0.26884278655052185,
0.6271165609359741,
-0.5986146926879883,
0.7449531555175781,
-0.6568092703819275,
-0.10202698409557343,
-0.3779096305370331,
-0.822803795337677,
-0.13365626335144043,
0.4130905270576477,
0.05878526717424393,
0.44898733496665955,
1.0339624881744385,
0.7075816988945007,
0.18418699502944946,
-0.11059006303548813,
0.27901777625083923,
0.039080437272787094,
0.5047703385353088,
0.6090876460075378,
0.7894880175590515,
-0.22005470097064972,
0.2817145884037018,
-0.24836061894893646,
-0.5153062343597412,
0.19078490138053894,
-1.079898715019226,
-0.47131603956222534,
-0.4736271798610687,
-0.6309939622879028,
-0.6220438480377197,
-0.06112297251820564,
0.5611572861671448,
0.390267014503479,
-0.5666598081588745,
-0.06869766116142273,
0.09610077738761902,
0.07028961926698685,
-0.35740742087364197,
-0.23278798162937164,
0.4462757110595703,
-0.2779780328273773,
-0.9161068201065063,
-0.14999276399612427,
-0.025703733786940575,
-0.05029726028442383,
-0.3965478837490082,
0.08121346682310104,
0.037573713809251785,
-0.07604098320007324,
0.23231329023838043,
0.3222343623638153,
-0.4926997423171997,
-0.7020312547683716,
-0.35281699895858765,
-0.1465049535036087,
0.09760939329862595,
1.2199369668960571,
-0.8389427065849304,
0.17467893660068512,
0.41616764664649963,
0.436179518699646,
0.09427850693464279,
0.1923888772726059,
1.0373938083648682,
-0.8434579372406006,
-0.05616360530257225,
-0.0969402864575386,
0.316802442073822,
0.24230197072029114,
-0.21295113861560822,
0.45768940448760986,
0.17979225516319275,
-0.8092670440673828,
-0.31685757637023926,
0.49538296461105347,
-0.8177371025085449,
-0.003203014610335231,
1.169761300086975,
-0.4591080844402313,
-0.17011551558971405,
0.2330094575881958,
-0.5932474136352539,
0.3388182520866394,
-0.15181982517242432,
0.7496070861816406,
0.7942049503326416,
-0.146027073264122,
-0.0635928362607956,
-0.2525460422039032,
0.38146835565567017,
0.4285961985588074,
-0.8361600041389465,
-0.017083419486880302,
0.7564606070518494,
0.5765619277954102,
0.21655499935150146,
0.6317647099494934,
-0.2675126791000366,
0.46031975746154785,
0.2709445059299469,
0.11823557317256927,
0.03646622225642204,
-0.23016007244586945,
-0.19067168235778809,
-0.057905834168195724,
0.0739360973238945,
-0.3530491590499878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07863v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07863v2
|
RLHF Workflow: From Reward Modeling to Online RLHF
| 2024-05-13T15:50:39 | 2024-06-12T04:40:53 |
Hanze Dong, Wei Xiong, Bo Pang, Haoxiang Wang, Han Zhao, Yingbo Zhou, Nan Jiang, Doyen Sahoo, Caiming Xiong, Tong Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
We present the workflow of Online Iterative Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF) in this technical report, which is widely reported to
outperform its offline counterpart by a large margin in the recent large
language model (LLM) literature. However, existing open-source RLHF projects
are still largely confined to the offline learning setting. In this technical
report, we aim to fill in this gap and provide a detailed recipe that is easy
to reproduce for online iterative RLHF. In particular, since online human
feedback is usually infeasible for open-source communities with limited
resources, we start by constructing preference models using a diverse set of
open-source datasets and use the constructed proxy preference model to
approximate human feedback. Then, we discuss the theoretical insights and
algorithmic principles behind online iterative RLHF, followed by a detailed
practical implementation. Our trained LLM, LLaMA-3-8B-SFR-Iterative-DPO-R,
achieves impressive performance on LLM chatbot benchmarks, including
AlpacaEval-2, Arena-Hard, and MT-Bench, as well as other academic benchmarks
such as HumanEval and TruthfulQA. We have shown that supervised fine-tuning
(SFT) and iterative RLHF can obtain state-of-the-art performance with fully
open-source datasets. Further, we have made our models, curated datasets, and
comprehensive step-by-step code guidebooks publicly available. Please refer to
https://github.com/RLHFlow/RLHF-Reward-Modeling and
https://github.com/RLHFlow/Online-RLHF for more detailed information.
|
[
-0.14985822141170502,
-0.6594928503036499,
0.4629095792770386,
0.10915223509073257,
0.025345725938677788,
0.27488845586776733,
-0.4076220393180847,
-0.6195594668388367,
0.2427142858505249,
0.5907741189002991,
-0.8361983299255371,
-0.28447937965393066,
-0.2688911259174347,
-0.07092292606830597,
-0.04414980113506317,
1.0145635604858398,
-0.36805039644241333,
0.13753312826156616,
-0.25803688168525696,
-0.08847332000732422,
-0.2073083072900772,
-0.6425540447235107,
-0.5910587906837463,
-0.7578737735748291,
0.6705590486526489,
0.6753657460212708,
0.4944099485874176,
0.8638802170753479,
0.46441328525543213,
0.25477391481399536,
0.05767371132969856,
0.051528189331293106,
-0.899970531463623,
0.07524445652961731,
-0.04767104983329773,
-0.13677501678466797,
-0.18949642777442932,
-0.10917355865240097,
0.36868977546691895,
0.37300384044647217,
-0.9018441438674927,
0.25965481996536255,
-0.10455198585987091,
1.0086301565170288,
-0.5178220868110657,
0.5087587833404541,
-0.3523601293563843,
0.22314298152923584,
-0.06552498787641525,
-0.20702336728572845,
-0.4558931887149811,
-0.568433940410614,
0.07992056012153625,
-0.7587897777557373,
0.0032102956902235746,
0.16616372764110565,
0.718852698802948,
0.3464672267436981,
-0.020671501755714417,
-0.38374587893486023,
-0.8569592237472534,
0.61834716796875,
-0.7594534754753113,
0.3973909914493561,
0.6043429970741272,
0.570686399936676,
-0.16353748738765717,
-0.8925958275794983,
-0.290438175201416,
-0.6668739318847656,
0.11428529769182205,
0.15616503357887268,
0.23168417811393738,
0.2051841765642166,
0.11197523772716522,
0.5173486471176147,
-0.39023542404174805,
0.16589578986167908,
-0.46957600116729736,
0.012414079159498215,
0.5887738466262817,
0.2796332836151123,
-0.2842283248901367,
0.12068166583776474,
-0.2660064697265625,
-0.3949708938598633,
-0.8209769129753113,
0.36267223954200745,
0.38595879077911377,
0.39118891954421997,
-0.32044482231140137,
0.5459277033805847,
-0.33927008509635925,
0.643703818321228,
0.0784376710653305,
-0.31940487027168274,
0.10351838916540146,
-0.12770713865756989,
0.10581430047750473,
-0.022371964529156685,
0.5677722692489624,
0.19326820969581604,
0.17141561210155487,
-0.12075414508581161,
-0.37354570627212524,
-0.261924684047699,
0.39775457978248596,
-0.8288519978523254,
-0.19837889075279236,
0.30151399970054626,
-0.6464642286300659,
-0.43463557958602905,
0.025128265842795372,
-0.6236081719398499,
-0.5953254699707031,
-0.2387688308954239,
0.38390079140663147,
0.12963998317718506,
-0.39354002475738525,
-0.11757216602563858,
-0.06396838277578354,
-0.05808029696345329,
0.3047746419906616,
-0.7786276936531067,
0.37835627794265747,
0.6922289133071899,
0.7136552333831787,
-0.42772534489631653,
-0.450886070728302,
-0.950896680355072,
-0.23768113553524017,
-0.12427982687950134,
0.6402890086174011,
-0.4347641170024872,
-0.24815814197063446,
0.3946945071220398,
-0.09547079354524612,
0.09831894934177399,
-0.6786156892776489,
0.4452469050884247,
-0.7480911016464233,
0.26973050832748413,
-0.052464839071035385,
-0.8721812963485718,
-0.11148695647716522,
0.3485477566719055,
-0.7739331722259521,
1.0520857572555542,
0.18952630460262299,
-0.7315757870674133,
-0.06426757574081421,
-1.0460922718048096,
-0.16597875952720642,
-0.08692982792854309,
0.14814648032188416,
-0.48175424337387085,
-0.13344231247901917,
-0.053227294236421585,
0.2974543273448944,
-0.29955393075942993,
0.33037036657333374,
-0.6216102838516235,
-0.4449699819087982,
0.31678706407546997,
-0.020291972905397415,
0.5346225500106812,
0.2304418385028839,
-0.4256283938884735,
0.7459478974342346,
-0.7026858329772949,
0.03600206971168518,
0.34346142411231995,
-0.634567379951477,
0.24073433876037598,
0.1499256193637848,
0.2912217378616333,
0.20171627402305603,
-0.07121559977531433,
-0.648140013217926,
0.06454725563526154,
-0.4183148443698883,
0.8147794604301453,
0.747559666633606,
-0.016396822407841682,
0.4115641117095947,
-0.5092792510986328,
0.5334227085113525,
-0.42780351638793945,
0.4443225860595703,
-0.03158051148056984,
-0.48125937581062317,
-0.545598030090332,
-0.23838038742542267,
0.29878342151641846,
0.5730379223823547,
-0.7130683064460754,
0.2172008454799652,
0.07053766399621964,
-0.4399947226047516,
-0.7165725827217102,
0.22406303882598877,
0.39570480585098267,
0.5356125235557556,
0.294112890958786,
-0.2762455344200134,
-0.48833656311035156,
-0.5220770835876465,
-0.04234439879655838,
-0.2768223285675049,
0.07941245287656784,
0.4013128876686096,
0.4557136595249176,
-0.23361769318580627,
0.7556500434875488,
-0.45244890451431274,
-0.5058225989341736,
-0.29114046692848206,
0.2535592019557953,
0.13759174942970276,
0.176079660654068,
-0.024086838588118553,
-0.45714202523231506,
-0.4476420283317566,
-0.1994711309671402,
-0.5638165473937988,
0.1238679438829422,
0.21536271274089813,
0.10675346851348877,
0.3658701777458191,
0.3233242630958557,
-0.3406432867050171,
0.43623268604278564,
0.549980878829956,
-0.1536141186952591,
0.12512293457984924,
-0.4452628791332245,
0.11339885741472244,
-0.6979600787162781,
0.0713290125131607,
-0.11308717727661133,
-0.5554233193397522,
-0.4391612410545349,
0.4582100510597229,
0.0686759501695633,
-0.05155736953020096,
-0.7268940210342407,
0.695057213306427,
-0.2576225697994232,
-0.2305649071931839,
-0.43261417746543884,
0.15213389694690704,
-0.4429381191730499,
0.966578483581543,
0.2632042169570923,
0.4446329176425934,
0.2256172001361847,
-0.6400519609451294,
0.703683078289032,
0.059584300965070724,
-0.2833234369754791,
0.1369566023349762,
-0.7864315509796143,
0.21023575961589813,
-0.015566683374345303,
0.494785875082016,
-0.6615086197853088,
-0.39136308431625366,
0.5759138464927673,
-0.229173481464386,
0.09068117290735245,
0.002482098527252674,
-0.4799036979675293,
-0.3177244961261749,
-0.45841437578201294,
0.22500041127204895,
0.5213978290557861,
-0.8042925000190735,
0.49127933382987976,
0.5810707807540894,
0.078180231153965,
-0.4016475975513458,
-0.28373897075653076,
-0.12342336028814316,
-0.13265284895896912,
-0.3640974164009094,
0.4563518166542053,
-0.368966668844223,
-0.30193325877189636,
-0.000037465426430571824,
0.41268014907836914,
-0.21794995665550232,
0.17321541905403137,
0.5321848392486572,
0.2817268967628479,
0.24010872840881348,
0.009179213084280491,
-0.6159830689430237,
-0.18045911192893982,
-0.012530861422419548,
-0.2551007568836212,
0.327088326215744,
-0.22032654285430908,
-0.5109686255455017,
-0.4941311180591583,
0.21539370715618134,
0.2213210016489029,
0.03205574303865433,
0.5962990522384644,
0.6901930570602417,
-0.3508067727088928,
-0.2801797389984131,
-0.3266187608242035,
-0.6222397089004517,
-0.3971959948539734,
0.16139324009418488,
0.12067614495754242,
-1.1994203329086304,
0.3877316415309906,
0.12189366668462753,
0.4709470272064209,
0.13057753443717957,
0.871964693069458,
-0.09549079835414886,
0.9285992383956909,
0.8146531581878662,
0.12340996414422989,
0.7226434350013733,
-0.0012040910078212619,
-0.10119128972291946,
-0.1982818841934204,
-0.3108968436717987,
-0.3771204650402069,
-0.05321153625845909,
-0.6294253468513489,
-0.5055223703384399,
0.33831465244293213,
0.08364693820476532,
-0.32532161474227905,
0.07771094143390656,
-0.34488463401794434,
0.43999961018562317,
0.6148090362548828,
0.32347333431243896,
0.401376873254776,
0.0041288998909294605,
-0.12599407136440277,
0.015986599028110504,
-0.8068197965621948,
-0.10951897501945496,
1.0002957582473755,
0.7569208741188049,
0.9167909026145935,
0.012287911958992481,
0.7357786297798157,
0.612476110458374,
0.5956574082374573,
-0.9112256765365601,
0.18793383240699768,
0.37536531686782837,
-0.4773215651512146,
-0.448505699634552,
-0.4510383605957031,
-0.7093260288238525,
-0.10323840379714966,
-0.18844838440418243,
-0.5017703175544739,
-0.4278534948825836,
0.5582737922668457,
-0.3615582287311554,
0.3525010049343109,
-0.4258468449115753,
0.7796863913536072,
-0.20357240736484528,
-0.6290002465248108,
-0.5822411179542542,
-0.8112289309501648,
0.4584675431251526,
0.1312505453824997,
0.3675558269023895,
0.0913153663277626,
0.2863669991493225,
0.7941396236419678,
-0.7342402935028076,
0.9757089614868164,
-0.3118589222431183,
-0.2610904574394226,
0.38532599806785583,
-0.03800129145383835,
0.874915361404419,
-0.0023988543543964624,
-0.020787520334124565,
0.056679870933294296,
-0.0205848328769207,
-0.24046972393989563,
-0.3164966404438019,
0.6383161544799805,
-0.9541088342666626,
-0.30989372730255127,
-0.4176267385482788,
-0.2767396867275238,
-0.18544822931289673,
-0.12458322942256927,
0.04094378277659416,
0.3466707468032837,
-0.13999606668949127,
0.06149395555257797,
0.7101922035217285,
-0.25480836629867554,
0.5630878210067749,
0.45978251099586487,
-0.6617161631584167,
-0.7049081921577454,
0.9869946241378784,
-0.2765296697616577,
0.24270351231098175,
0.6990518569946289,
0.41478675603866577,
-0.6374847292900085,
-0.08521894365549088,
-0.7261382937431335,
0.2468222826719284,
-0.9823817610740662,
0.035725273191928864,
-0.32202214002609253,
-0.16040804982185364,
-0.15291616320610046,
0.13896293938159943,
-0.6823670268058777,
-0.5021507740020752,
-0.3188938796520233,
0.016668623313307762,
0.6138812899589539,
1.3373967409133911,
-0.23303091526031494,
0.08814886957406998,
-0.8961137533187866,
0.20580720901489258,
0.3348176181316376,
0.7186696529388428,
0.3047620356082916,
-0.6313506364822388,
-0.4693363308906555,
0.039935316890478134,
-0.15081360936164856,
-0.697346031665802,
0.33667677640914917,
0.08120187371969223,
0.641753077507019,
0.21052469313144684,
0.2190989851951599,
0.4760501980781555,
-0.2639123499393463,
0.6323250532150269,
0.21064217388629913,
-0.6773014664649963,
0.19186079502105713,
-0.2616841197013855,
-0.0007548957364633679,
0.5020776987075806,
0.377860426902771,
-0.5515993237495422,
0.03764042630791664,
-0.4087205231189728,
-0.7028824090957642,
0.8878700733184814,
-0.025238214060664177,
-0.3562397360801697,
0.3927137553691864,
0.35997793078422546,
0.2889648973941803,
0.25319477915763855,
-0.9598568081855774,
-0.38910964131355286,
-0.4291166365146637,
-0.07860872149467468,
0.010865425691008568,
0.02394142933189869,
-0.3664012551307678,
-0.15446048974990845,
0.8366470336914062,
-0.2004358023405075,
0.42393770813941956,
-0.06109337881207466,
-0.13713562488555908,
-0.5298205614089966,
0.16175082325935364,
0.7709135413169861,
0.8215699195861816,
-0.4285420775413513,
-0.14269794523715973,
-0.0853283628821373,
-0.07424972206354141,
0.05104871094226837,
0.04433290660381317,
0.025401845574378967,
-0.34448468685150146,
0.2790457606315613,
1.007415533065796,
0.29900482296943665,
-1.0246102809906006,
0.45577582716941833,
-0.37859150767326355,
-0.44750985503196716,
-0.5159609913825989,
-0.022473204880952835,
0.305122047662735,
0.3798723816871643,
0.27653077244758606,
-0.2687499225139618,
-0.2127649337053299,
-0.4933719336986542,
0.15910443663597107,
0.1118033230304718,
-0.6894843578338623,
-0.09656889736652374,
0.5532951951026917,
0.3354470729827881,
-0.5921249389648438,
0.6291875243186951,
-0.3600861728191376,
-0.5421386361122131,
0.37415868043899536,
0.40168851613998413,
0.8841571807861328,
0.3111973702907562,
0.521630048751831,
0.5249688625335693,
-0.156961128115654,
-0.4689018726348877,
0.23143072426319122,
-0.39986106753349304,
-0.38254356384277344,
-0.4125816524028778,
-0.5281323194503784,
-0.9577865600585938,
0.03503139689564705,
-0.5418519377708435,
0.037264566868543625,
-0.6028651595115662,
0.1192552000284195,
-0.3784106373786926,
-0.25856128334999084,
-0.5203762650489807,
-0.17029336094856262,
0.06624734401702881,
0.7325268983840942,
-0.47184231877326965,
0.8156123161315918,
0.743142306804657,
-0.46785274147987366,
-0.9181057810783386,
-0.13235265016555786,
0.11344876140356064,
-0.9797248840332031,
0.6363134384155273,
-0.0448836088180542,
-0.0377274788916111,
0.1724761724472046,
-0.5171161890029907,
-0.9017217755317688,
1.1167597770690918,
0.09550151228904724,
-0.565270185470581,
0.004815100226551294,
0.03507457301020622,
0.5492183566093445,
-0.4036446213722229,
0.5934934020042419,
0.24098052084445953,
0.4037438631057739,
0.3355328440666199,
-1.0787471532821655,
-0.024647818878293037,
-0.07943415641784668,
-0.051983535289764404,
-0.018093451857566833,
-0.5765541791915894,
0.6114028692245483,
-0.5067983865737915,
-0.06558496505022049,
0.009054037742316723,
0.49857139587402344,
0.5228631496429443,
0.1397283971309662,
0.5296525359153748,
0.6253626942634583,
0.5261856317520142,
0.11358734965324402,
0.9339633584022522,
-0.40065866708755493,
0.5032544136047363,
1.1032601594924927,
-0.42752760648727417,
1.209223985671997,
0.45020198822021484,
-0.11950087547302246,
0.5246529579162598,
1.0451408624649048,
0.2558310627937317,
0.7732647657394409,
0.6062121987342834,
-0.05161488801240921,
-0.2872864007949829,
-0.29248419404029846,
-0.2575167119503021,
0.17435996234416962,
-0.12351936101913452,
-0.040960587561130524,
-0.3348013162612915,
0.14509129524230957,
-0.237198606133461,
0.14459896087646484,
-0.378743976354599,
1.019056797027588,
0.04492197930812836,
-1.1477993726730347,
0.6181543469429016,
0.3646777272224426,
0.6734989285469055,
-0.6395447850227356,
-0.37734660506248474,
-0.14761266112327576,
0.4801830053329468,
-0.18849456310272217,
-0.7613674998283386,
0.16310815513134003,
-0.012331082485616207,
-0.06491143256425858,
-0.5907484889030457,
0.7299695611000061,
-0.37890464067459106,
-0.05937833711504936,
0.5656771063804626,
0.4814680516719818,
0.008710658177733421,
0.08465619385242462,
-0.840385913848877,
0.04538079723715782,
0.03800177574157715,
-0.3170207142829895,
0.5468395948410034,
-0.1765703707933426,
-0.08150152117013931,
0.8758991360664368,
0.7027307152748108,
0.07927612960338593,
-0.03993996977806091,
0.30013135075569153,
0.6763564348220825,
-0.7250998020172119,
-0.7181433439254761,
-0.6447449326515198,
0.4204099178314209,
0.1935761719942093,
-0.2692089378833771,
0.2718846797943115,
0.12476243078708649,
1.0843919515609741,
-0.1882213056087494,
0.5904017090797424,
0.05923684686422348,
0.7971717119216919,
-0.46288177371025085,
0.5058952569961548,
-0.5087546110153198,
0.12628482282161713,
0.00973004475235939,
-0.5807472467422485,
-0.031006965786218643,
0.5404048562049866,
0.212702676653862,
0.06232576444745064,
0.6273865103721619,
0.9222962856292725,
0.256613165140152,
0.3353755474090576,
0.17241019010543823,
-0.0529312826693058,
0.2953592538833618,
0.48626935482025146,
1.1073192358016968,
-0.1053992211818695,
0.6326673030853271,
-0.5805698037147522,
-0.244373619556427,
-0.4343557357788086,
-1.3048001527786255,
-0.9694311022758484,
-0.6312075257301331,
-0.24402591586112976,
-0.4417240619659424,
0.0677337497472763,
1.6705816984176636,
0.798672080039978,
-0.8618156909942627,
-0.6110591292381287,
-0.3478204607963562,
0.2945169508457184,
-0.4565551280975342,
-0.2284146398305893,
-0.0006192949949763715,
-0.08549140393733978,
-0.34632641077041626,
0.42760172486305237,
0.15219002962112427,
-0.17352919280529022,
-0.6896864175796509,
-0.7327082753181458,
-0.2069840282201767,
-0.2809944152832031,
0.5117890238761902,
0.6756869554519653,
-0.8331987857818604,
-0.019775360822677612,
0.04135875776410103,
-0.1508338302373886,
0.09187626093626022,
1.0457782745361328,
-0.6695588827133179,
0.2828303277492523,
0.5729091763496399,
0.9375930428504944,
0.7973309755325317,
-0.11336871981620789,
0.4970616102218628,
-0.5440985560417175,
-0.2964659035205841,
0.07009977102279663,
0.15861284732818604,
0.38860490918159485,
-0.21205274760723114,
0.6294299364089966,
0.42189621925354004,
-0.7340430617332458,
-0.7933838367462158,
0.0703992247581482,
-0.7535489797592163,
-0.24283480644226074,
1.1703946590423584,
-0.21374401450157166,
-0.11888457834720612,
-0.14579448103904724,
-0.12360017001628876,
0.3887844383716583,
-0.7545641660690308,
1.1206647157669067,
0.533295214176178,
-0.33633092045783997,
-0.30589011311531067,
-0.588462233543396,
0.7026947140693665,
0.08811162412166595,
-1.0415327548980713,
0.3087773025035858,
0.4189312160015106,
0.22059035301208496,
-0.11568805575370789,
0.8888149857521057,
0.17171548306941986,
0.26367202401161194,
-0.2738606333732605,
0.14562231302261353,
-0.506550669670105,
-0.28425002098083496,
-0.44962581992149353,
0.3787088394165039,
0.38482728600502014,
0.07528015971183777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07840v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07840v1
|
Open-vocabulary Auditory Neural Decoding Using fMRI-prompted LLM
| 2024-05-13T15:25:11 | 2024-05-13T15:25:11 |
Xiaoyu Chen, Changde Du, Che Liu, Yizhe Wang, Huiguang He
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Decoding language information from brain signals represents a vital research
area within brain-computer interfaces, particularly in the context of
deciphering the semantic information from the fMRI signal. However, many
existing efforts concentrate on decoding small vocabulary sets, leaving space
for the exploration of open vocabulary continuous text decoding. In this paper,
we introduce a novel method, the \textbf{Brain Prompt GPT (BP-GPT)}. By using
the brain representation that is extracted from the fMRI as a prompt, our
method can utilize GPT-2 to decode fMRI signals into stimulus text. Further, we
introduce a text-to-text baseline and align the fMRI prompt to the text prompt.
By introducing the text-to-text baseline, our BP-GPT can extract a more robust
brain prompt and promote the decoding of pre-trained LLM. We evaluate our
BP-GPT on the open-source auditory semantic decoding dataset and achieve a
significant improvement up to $4.61\%$ on METEOR and $2.43\%$ on BERTScore
across all the subjects compared to the state-of-the-art method. The
experimental results demonstrate that using brain representation as a prompt to
further drive LLM for auditory neural decoding is feasible and effective.
|
[
-0.2518204152584076,
-0.9004360437393188,
0.7490372061729431,
0.4650733470916748,
-0.45415380597114563,
-0.3823328912258148,
-0.548143744468689,
-0.21436113119125366,
0.1358717978000641,
-0.029067372903227806,
-0.9147986173629761,
-0.7282857894897461,
-0.4361201822757721,
0.3102625906467438,
-0.09817716479301453,
0.7947611212730408,
0.023070426657795906,
0.3438571095466614,
-0.20632657408714294,
0.11368424445390701,
-0.9167412519454956,
-0.4307422935962677,
-0.9447997212409973,
-0.3920027017593384,
0.7523708939552307,
-0.028688451275229454,
0.3122178614139557,
0.40057018399238586,
0.26960837841033936,
0.06341901421546936,
-0.5513874888420105,
0.01225841511040926,
-0.1572469025850296,
-0.049990709871053696,
-0.023312771692872047,
-0.21491318941116333,
-0.4464418292045593,
-0.26156914234161377,
0.49045372009277344,
0.7204103469848633,
-0.10163666307926178,
0.0211001168936491,
0.24852901697158813,
0.4975743293762207,
-0.5008399486541748,
0.3861387073993683,
-0.522878885269165,
0.11091462522745132,
-0.047201137989759445,
-0.687294065952301,
-0.5727766752243042,
-0.2077491134405136,
0.1292344629764557,
-0.6756872534751892,
-0.24333268404006958,
-0.03655942156910896,
0.69353848695755,
0.38138821721076965,
-0.05602535232901573,
-0.38285738229751587,
-0.4018203020095825,
0.5230382084846497,
-0.40459710359573364,
0.5551435947418213,
0.6638966798782349,
0.170037180185318,
-0.22183117270469666,
-0.6577536463737488,
-0.6189928650856018,
-0.27830490469932556,
0.025191474705934525,
0.3958083391189575,
-0.2104506939649582,
0.1273057758808136,
0.10937602072954178,
0.17257395386695862,
-0.6238680481910706,
0.07146334648132324,
-0.13559162616729736,
-0.3632734715938568,
-0.10968812555074692,
0.033405788242816925,
0.5195645093917847,
-0.00433399947360158,
-0.4165884852409363,
-0.20045220851898193,
-0.7042679786682129,
-0.07887488603591919,
0.08217992633581161,
0.2861056923866272,
-0.13699732720851898,
0.6240426301956177,
0.06450091302394867,
0.6176834106445312,
-0.008560793474316597,
0.0334557443857193,
0.37942418456077576,
-0.30829355120658875,
0.10071296989917755,
0.31880173087120056,
0.6613388061523438,
0.4502179026603699,
0.28699561953544617,
-0.3288533687591553,
-0.34492456912994385,
0.06672827154397964,
-0.10258983820676804,
-0.5804122090339661,
-0.02283269725739956,
0.36953526735305786,
-0.6761331558227539,
0.17084892094135284,
-0.21494869887828827,
-0.44786572456359863,
-0.19312329590320587,
-0.33603277802467346,
0.5881274938583374,
-0.7817217707633972,
-0.3800453841686249,
0.3907054662704468,
-0.26743245124816895,
0.3959529995918274,
0.3092120289802551,
-1.0592864751815796,
0.026279494166374207,
0.5162323117256165,
1.0796297788619995,
-0.05667412281036377,
-0.052907709032297134,
-0.5895129442214966,
0.14266419410705566,
-0.16110795736312866,
0.9009017944335938,
-0.1199902668595314,
-0.47716280817985535,
-0.10381470620632172,
-0.4528389573097229,
-0.05818347632884979,
-0.4656480550765991,
0.6709215641021729,
-0.5532732605934143,
0.3647710382938385,
-0.4631039798259735,
-0.4017215967178345,
0.023472895845770836,
0.16427239775657654,
-0.41813698410987854,
0.7421153783798218,
0.06724707782268524,
-0.8789052367210388,
0.19029036164283752,
-0.9861289262771606,
-0.25047019124031067,
0.16451513767242432,
-0.5165941715240479,
0.2629290819168091,
0.1925908923149109,
0.7072374224662781,
0.27704453468322754,
-0.18642151355743408,
0.13446517288684845,
-0.12149561196565628,
-0.5434452891349792,
0.36860138177871704,
-0.6678181290626526,
0.8501425385475159,
0.3077067732810974,
-0.19970229268074036,
0.0533277802169323,
-0.6356072425842285,
0.1252346783876419,
0.13705885410308838,
-0.5676539540290833,
-0.3986029326915741,
-0.059501804411411285,
0.15171492099761963,
0.011178508400917053,
0.3222552239894867,
-0.5747960209846497,
-0.07584594935178757,
-0.4640258252620697,
0.23272012174129486,
0.6415167450904846,
0.04484013468027115,
0.16343751549720764,
-0.22837206721305847,
0.08018554002046585,
0.07854711264371872,
-0.30687129497528076,
-0.43143340945243835,
-0.6228358149528503,
-0.2039487212896347,
-0.685287594795227,
0.37494659423828125,
0.9272469282150269,
-0.7323009967803955,
0.6965619921684265,
-0.4678332209587097,
0.23899038136005402,
-0.8400171399116516,
-0.342001348733902,
0.06968490034341812,
0.9594509601593018,
0.6947270035743713,
-0.10546320676803589,
-0.4615335166454315,
-0.6842529773712158,
-0.07592198252677917,
-0.229584738612175,
-0.6579614877700806,
0.2991590201854706,
0.04100625216960907,
-0.3733001947402954,
1.169630527496338,
-0.35687553882598877,
-0.45937642455101013,
-0.051328517496585846,
0.22118860483169556,
0.6237725019454956,
0.393668532371521,
0.25830352306365967,
-0.4453674852848053,
-0.02716885507106781,
-0.049772847443819046,
-0.9854560494422913,
-0.25377801060676575,
-0.14015991985797882,
-0.1371314823627472,
0.14507637917995453,
0.5519180297851562,
-0.8467777371406555,
0.23918341100215912,
0.1938917338848114,
-0.5534090399742126,
0.2781967222690582,
-0.23476587235927582,
0.19761015474796295,
-1.0314196348190308,
0.28044116497039795,
-0.3228829503059387,
0.2760138213634491,
-0.48498275876045227,
-0.3425670862197876,
0.1477406769990921,
0.1257067322731018,
-0.35651880502700806,
0.4800396263599396,
-0.5390150547027588,
0.10262172669172287,
-0.4753327965736389,
0.2356298267841339,
-0.2665681838989258,
0.471617728471756,
0.4044160842895508,
0.9017307162284851,
0.7390209436416626,
-0.4810976982116699,
-0.007155219558626413,
0.6182730793952942,
-0.2746813893318176,
0.5144885778427124,
-0.6197367310523987,
0.4097540080547333,
-0.4516105353832245,
0.37651437520980835,
-1.107749581336975,
-0.022436073049902916,
0.40871891379356384,
-0.6484146118164062,
0.33528149127960205,
-0.033253755420446396,
-0.6599348187446594,
-0.08721104264259338,
0.028079459443688393,
0.6491565108299255,
0.7937687039375305,
-0.8392215967178345,
0.615235447883606,
0.05917109176516533,
-0.32013610005378723,
-0.6011809706687927,
-1.0142766237258911,
0.05828813090920448,
-0.0037586765829473734,
-0.7900241017341614,
0.3609233498573303,
-0.20658625662326813,
0.008501285687088966,
-0.06703431159257889,
-0.35897067189216614,
0.2196199595928192,
-0.21143372356891632,
-0.004793997388333082,
0.332580029964447,
-0.49741360545158386,
-0.04098242521286011,
0.1601898968219757,
-0.25067296624183655,
0.4857308268547058,
-0.5152439475059509,
0.6487647294998169,
-0.040085893124341965,
-0.12586727738380432,
-0.40292343497276306,
0.39315927028656006,
0.1204683855175972,
-0.12751226127147675,
0.4479222595691681,
0.8737620711326599,
-0.5585533380508423,
0.22935326397418976,
-0.1959192454814911,
-0.4945310950279236,
-0.48772314190864563,
0.26292914152145386,
-0.5214007496833801,
-0.9556744694709778,
0.40463340282440186,
-0.1850496232509613,
-0.27932626008987427,
0.04357771575450897,
0.6284698843955994,
-0.24124765396118164,
0.9210184812545776,
0.17861028015613556,
-0.027306361123919487,
0.32370680570602417,
-0.05939498543739319,
-0.20954430103302002,
-1.1031763553619385,
-0.4104529023170471,
-0.1944144070148468,
-0.2704373300075531,
0.25349292159080505,
-0.325702965259552,
0.5215609073638916,
0.05090602859854698,
0.08988238126039505,
-0.04781138524413109,
-0.48430415987968445,
0.5840515494346619,
0.42130228877067566,
0.7054197788238525,
0.1486489623785019,
0.4219109117984772,
-0.5666033029556274,
-0.04376266151666641,
-0.41841331124305725,
-0.10172851383686066,
0.8501027822494507,
0.4664444625377655,
0.6706730723381042,
0.020505813881754875,
0.7616819143295288,
0.0787084698677063,
0.25170812010765076,
-1.113353967666626,
0.6686170697212219,
0.13473759591579437,
-0.3873061537742615,
-0.2051481306552887,
-0.5571771264076233,
-0.9383202195167542,
0.2515689730644226,
-0.04611891508102417,
-0.8491812944412231,
0.13267354667186737,
-0.015892283990979195,
-0.5338975191116333,
0.029106948524713516,
-0.5184171795845032,
0.5627055168151855,
-0.04537529870867729,
0.04537184163928032,
-0.1498151421546936,
-0.6249836087226868,
0.17370881140232086,
0.05474754422903061,
0.12378326058387756,
-0.07571262866258621,
-0.40853211283683777,
0.6425127983093262,
-0.08122403174638748,
0.624052107334137,
-0.5123645663261414,
-0.37908855080604553,
0.08839774131774902,
-0.2192452996969223,
0.36518594622612,
0.24366749823093414,
-0.06248786672949791,
0.34013330936431885,
-0.31771883368492126,
-0.14020559191703796,
-0.5491546392440796,
0.6369920372962952,
-0.745606541633606,
-0.3269672393798828,
-0.4159327447414398,
-0.7169570922851562,
-0.5022794604301453,
0.2202102541923523,
0.601435661315918,
0.4993351399898529,
-0.20474033057689667,
0.04944619536399841,
1.0658200979232788,
-0.25553345680236816,
0.6265268921852112,
0.26745104789733887,
-0.06434325128793716,
-0.9087892174720764,
0.7177010774612427,
-0.17801879346370697,
-0.15252263844013214,
0.7429250478744507,
0.13004890084266663,
-0.6698397994041443,
-0.8787726163864136,
-0.4174249768257141,
0.37299373745918274,
-0.7498263120651245,
-0.15091724693775177,
-0.6907639503479004,
0.16399942338466644,
-0.10694270581007004,
0.07244593650102615,
0.08209549635648727,
-0.20037513971328735,
-0.4002489745616913,
-0.04309840127825737,
0.44651105999946594,
0.1301642507314682,
-0.08981660008430481,
0.4613940119743347,
-0.8335904479026794,
0.6323222517967224,
0.022926021367311478,
0.3304867148399353,
-0.3395025134086609,
-0.5599234104156494,
-0.2617414593696594,
0.17447338998317719,
0.26768043637275696,
-1.056302785873413,
0.2473321408033371,
0.020618127658963203,
0.39931321144104004,
0.15237094461917877,
0.08428653329610825,
0.5608839392662048,
-0.646510660648346,
0.6767874956130981,
0.4084860682487488,
-0.8128987550735474,
0.6016148328781128,
-0.5791080594062805,
0.7998705506324768,
0.5439925789833069,
0.26480770111083984,
-0.5035524368286133,
-0.0828639417886734,
-0.1520005166530609,
-1.0147444009780884,
0.8676542043685913,
0.2851024568080902,
0.15275605022907257,
-0.34903040528297424,
0.22489680349826813,
-0.006862219888716936,
-0.08849174529314041,
-0.4902738332748413,
-0.35838910937309265,
-0.2287183254957199,
-0.6379293203353882,
0.15486717224121094,
-0.2630712687969208,
-0.28670647740364075,
-0.2540530562400818,
0.3380931317806244,
-0.29285502433776855,
0.8866608142852783,
0.5177993178367615,
-0.02599923498928547,
0.2284441590309143,
0.4618017375469208,
0.6413166522979736,
0.18698890507221222,
-0.4543043076992035,
-0.05086974799633026,
0.3397864103317261,
-0.7319825887680054,
0.11499591171741486,
0.33087486028671265,
-0.028973571956157684,
0.24566830694675446,
-0.05237172916531563,
0.955105721950531,
0.17655372619628906,
-0.5520903468132019,
0.5841455459594727,
-0.377984881401062,
-0.3503279387950897,
-0.505596935749054,
-0.355119913816452,
0.28380486369132996,
0.18120701611042023,
0.6893042922019958,
0.17582204937934875,
0.27221524715423584,
-0.13500583171844482,
0.2840713858604431,
0.20124191045761108,
-0.1812387853860855,
-0.128682479262352,
0.7203972339630127,
0.06371715664863586,
0.022036777809262276,
1.0054062604904175,
0.3027234971523285,
0.17763276398181915,
0.16654478013515472,
0.9241613149642944,
1.1493502855300903,
0.07078167051076889,
-0.2129371464252472,
0.2540847361087799,
0.12279213964939117,
-0.1563774198293686,
0.7599658966064453,
-0.3011746406555176,
-0.6962785720825195,
-0.6411314010620117,
-0.5884606242179871,
-0.27331113815307617,
0.47211146354675293,
-0.6281313896179199,
0.1886797398328781,
-0.6047865152359009,
-0.3260011076927185,
-0.23750437796115875,
-0.7237505912780762,
-0.3823036253452301,
0.18007640540599823,
0.4570178687572479,
1.307392954826355,
-0.15742988884449005,
1.0069139003753662,
0.7035882472991943,
-0.3334486484527588,
-0.7840778827667236,
0.41835522651672363,
0.052971821278333664,
-0.8432018160820007,
0.5975303053855896,
0.484571248292923,
-0.2622128427028656,
0.40941014885902405,
-0.394487589597702,
-0.6555294990539551,
1.121890902519226,
0.5488114356994629,
-0.3265376687049866,
-0.2449679672718048,
-0.10301688313484192,
0.28154683113098145,
-0.3806037902832031,
0.3762468099594116,
0.42634350061416626,
0.6626271605491638,
-0.02350521832704544,
-0.7672106027603149,
0.27558639645576477,
-0.4725000560283661,
0.044388968497514725,
0.10539066046476364,
-0.01597020961344242,
0.5970486998558044,
-0.18772755563259125,
-0.4645884335041046,
0.1263270229101181,
1.0786746740341187,
0.534969687461853,
0.39101701974868774,
0.6188725233078003,
0.22748048603534698,
0.6595409512519836,
-0.22160127758979797,
0.8989368081092834,
-0.3468363881111145,
0.054988134652376175,
0.79488205909729,
0.07597799599170685,
1.0541819334030151,
0.7791287899017334,
0.10839253664016724,
0.3761528730392456,
0.6888702511787415,
0.1725207269191742,
0.8283254504203796,
0.07091560959815979,
-0.7072583436965942,
-0.026807889342308044,
0.007483324036002159,
-0.49306389689445496,
0.18923687934875488,
0.5918807983398438,
-0.1518174260854721,
-0.4136430323123932,
0.4053121507167816,
0.009655202738940716,
-0.13409073650836945,
-0.41863909363746643,
0.874972403049469,
0.32600119709968567,
-0.5392168164253235,
0.9279122948646545,
-0.1956835687160492,
1.0580241680145264,
-0.9447425007820129,
0.04225331172347069,
-0.1277809888124466,
0.06819933652877808,
-0.1524253636598587,
-0.7021730542182922,
0.14193744957447052,
-0.02178938128054142,
-0.30035170912742615,
-0.36882197856903076,
0.5660731196403503,
-0.6935660243034363,
0.16407249867916107,
0.44330164790153503,
0.4760243892669678,
0.3051856458187103,
-0.39101260900497437,
-0.5517639517784119,
0.06595751643180847,
-0.11173075437545776,
-0.3207196891307831,
0.2705037295818329,
0.4632608890533447,
0.1916186660528183,
0.3224999010562897,
0.7532524466514587,
-0.006030847784131765,
-0.11799710243940353,
0.23950712382793427,
0.7989471554756165,
-0.8915104269981384,
-0.680013120174408,
-0.8718502521514893,
0.6144766211509705,
0.21901115775108337,
-0.23434624075889587,
0.40589436888694763,
0.261974573135376,
0.70361328125,
-0.5845758318901062,
0.7614284157752991,
-0.2468254119157791,
0.351882666349411,
-1.0903522968292236,
0.7550391554832458,
-0.34326085448265076,
0.26106369495391846,
0.06253702938556671,
-0.7208834290504456,
-0.3050210475921631,
0.6262597441673279,
0.0828079879283905,
0.08351663500070572,
1.1030299663543701,
0.9288681745529175,
-0.005624719429761171,
0.3523753583431244,
0.3765811324119568,
-0.04476450756192207,
-0.16607360541820526,
0.6502699255943298,
0.9284349679946899,
-0.11204715073108673,
0.8126265406608582,
0.19813406467437744,
-0.44524094462394714,
0.011186604388058186,
-0.7045130133628845,
-0.8766900300979614,
-0.38852444291114807,
-0.24081334471702576,
-0.5307883620262146,
0.07026764005422592,
1.1644290685653687,
0.29497388005256653,
-0.698085606098175,
-0.12842752039432526,
-0.1376328468322754,
-0.3390679657459259,
-0.4878726005554199,
-0.17664596438407898,
0.35524624586105347,
-0.6226450800895691,
-0.5528612732887268,
1.1094515323638916,
0.12139938771724701,
0.2802218496799469,
0.05519729480147362,
-0.40748170018196106,
-0.0033077991101890802,
0.0165574848651886,
0.6307318210601807,
0.22517184913158417,
-0.6373763084411621,
-0.2644948661327362,
0.266597181558609,
-0.15603548288345337,
0.1564198136329651,
0.8679503798484802,
-0.9347608685493469,
0.07538092136383057,
0.6778395771980286,
0.9794059991836548,
0.33435511589050293,
-0.2730140686035156,
0.6551765203475952,
-0.8865419030189514,
0.0739622563123703,
0.21748189628124237,
0.40316352248191833,
0.31227415800094604,
-0.5383187532424927,
0.46972590684890747,
0.2929506301879883,
-0.31370484828948975,
-0.580013632774353,
0.12935885787010193,
-1.5613209009170532,
-0.32421979308128357,
1.2531869411468506,
-0.08713327348232269,
-0.5077265501022339,
-0.13681650161743164,
-0.6077006459236145,
0.16525869071483612,
-0.6435537934303284,
0.49805599451065063,
0.8187717795372009,
-0.20022577047348022,
-0.22083371877670288,
-0.27111294865608215,
0.3675156533718109,
0.5633116960525513,
-0.6350691914558411,
0.0265706367790699,
0.6729756593704224,
0.16066259145736694,
0.1612340211868286,
0.9923893809318542,
-0.39011120796203613,
0.5463269948959351,
0.05594440922141075,
0.02698393166065216,
-0.397017240524292,
-0.2391166239976883,
-0.6855109333992004,
0.2285187989473343,
-0.12263871729373932,
-0.4243769645690918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07803v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07803v2
|
Decoding Geometric Properties in Non-Random Data from First Information-Theoretic Principles
| 2024-05-13T14:45:08 | 2024-05-18T01:24:24 |
Hector Zenil, Felipe S. Abrahão
|
cs.IT
|
cs.IT, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.IR, math.IT, math.ST, stat.TH
|
Based on the principles of information theory, measure theory, and
theoretical computer science, we introduce a univariate signal deconvolution
method with a wide range of applications to coding theory, particularly in
zero-knowledge one-way communication channels, such as in deciphering messages
from unknown generating sources about which no prior knowledge is available and
to which no return message can be sent. Our multidimensional space
reconstruction method from an arbitrary received signal is proven to be
agnostic vis-a-vis the encoding-decoding scheme, computation model, programming
language, formal theory, the computable (or semi-computable) method of
approximation to algorithmic complexity, and any arbitrarily chosen
(computable) probability measure of the events. The method derives from the
principles of an approach to Artificial General Intelligence capable of
building a general-purpose model of models independent of any arbitrarily
assumed prior probability distribution. We argue that this optimal and
universal method of decoding non-random data has applications to signal
processing, causal deconvolution, topological and geometric properties
encoding, cryptography, and bio- and technosignature detection.
|
[
-0.2871014177799225,
-0.7599722146987915,
0.6825037598609924,
0.11094910651445389,
-0.23844629526138306,
-0.0646221861243248,
0.058060262352228165,
-0.15284296870231628,
0.45261260867118835,
0.3448719382286072,
-0.4552224576473236,
-0.5918141603469849,
-0.5982086062431335,
-0.40336155891418457,
-0.8257408738136292,
0.6653267741203308,
0.27309712767601013,
-0.0715717151761055,
-0.06044304743409157,
-0.08682291954755783,
0.12881655991077423,
-0.7263594269752502,
-0.17847105860710144,
-0.03640749305486679,
0.06259454041719437,
0.032392095774412155,
0.5355921983718872,
0.4976905882358551,
0.5775372982025146,
0.21710896492004395,
0.216982901096344,
-0.01970987394452095,
-0.7219004034996033,
-0.4393772482872009,
0.06613660603761673,
-0.5509946942329407,
-0.006931695621460676,
0.20366133749485016,
0.6918392777442932,
1.2380563020706177,
-0.2636203169822693,
0.13783401250839233,
-0.0768175721168518,
0.8337176442146301,
-0.6277621388435364,
0.21153464913368225,
-0.33035632967948914,
0.42474955320358276,
-0.02170923724770546,
-1.0169621706008911,
-0.47393858432769775,
-0.7091975808143616,
-0.28774842619895935,
-1.1111047267913818,
0.5175620913505554,
0.042839743196964264,
0.38183480501174927,
0.17511071264743805,
-0.4744386076927185,
-0.33030837774276733,
-1.3877837657928467,
0.9562767744064331,
-0.378447949886322,
0.598381757736206,
0.6586737632751465,
0.3708593547344208,
-0.5547270774841309,
-0.37801215052604675,
-0.40747663378715515,
-0.18906183540821075,
-0.0014204104663804173,
0.23956727981567383,
-0.4070187509059906,
0.1106073185801506,
0.079610176384449,
0.36362525820732117,
-0.4792834222316742,
-0.3070748448371887,
-0.7441816926002502,
-0.31795734167099,
0.4711715281009674,
0.019427895545959473,
0.21340006589889526,
-0.039876166731119156,
-0.20925310254096985,
-0.21210961043834686,
-0.6162229776382446,
0.0602162666618824,
0.5687990188598633,
0.03752407431602478,
-0.24702249467372894,
0.4648112654685974,
-0.3132933974266052,
0.37719717621803284,
-0.09233493357896805,
-0.007421680260449648,
-0.10384529083967209,
-0.4174102246761322,
-0.1827196329832077,
-0.1432902067899704,
0.5065580606460571,
-0.13014988601207733,
-0.03454932942986488,
-0.42215657234191895,
0.3515618145465851,
0.2437933385372162,
0.17788660526275635,
-0.31293565034866333,
-0.6218456029891968,
0.10837498307228088,
-0.8227412700653076,
-0.16047069430351257,
0.3232114017009735,
-0.5800526142120361,
-0.36033502221107483,
-0.4179783761501312,
0.263288676738739,
-0.6040175557136536,
-0.44565364718437195,
0.549716591835022,
-0.11405207961797714,
0.3306410312652588,
0.1452697366476059,
-0.8325486779212952,
0.39693230390548706,
0.45953530073165894,
0.4603351354598999,
0.47586703300476074,
-0.08818262815475464,
-0.039173755794763565,
0.0534399040043354,
-0.6061838269233704,
0.6404950022697449,
-0.17951656877994537,
-0.2310190200805664,
-0.2503354251384735,
-0.349604994058609,
0.3216666877269745,
0.030847696587443352,
0.47813403606414795,
-0.5225213766098022,
-0.10656047612428665,
-0.12776343524456024,
-0.5502881407737732,
-0.46152421832084656,
-0.14805269241333008,
-0.5794644355773926,
0.2624552845954895,
0.15189793705940247,
-0.43611177802085876,
0.4848012924194336,
-0.7487835884094238,
-0.33864569664001465,
-0.13998042047023773,
-0.3420226573944092,
-0.3251242935657501,
0.7556335926055908,
0.2531502842903137,
0.14205648005008698,
-0.19951525330543518,
-0.003818147350102663,
-0.6955860257148743,
-0.16767482459545135,
0.2129318118095398,
-0.6460915207862854,
0.8374008536338806,
0.5027728080749512,
0.19552388787269592,
-0.23973524570465088,
-1.0943901538848877,
0.3009990453720093,
0.299151748418808,
-0.36768996715545654,
-0.23471151292324066,
0.23607932031154633,
-0.038810502737760544,
-0.12084947526454926,
0.1278257817029953,
-0.7699034810066223,
0.1527160257101059,
-0.19257895648479462,
0.4715079963207245,
0.6587075591087341,
0.106700599193573,
0.6228315234184265,
0.045128755271434784,
-0.01449729036539793,
0.07426755130290985,
0.3632146418094635,
0.15263256430625916,
-0.05723078176379204,
-0.2817549705505371,
-0.4196722209453583,
0.05016155168414116,
0.38623175024986267,
-0.6476231217384338,
0.47448375821113586,
-0.23858141899108887,
-0.29659631848335266,
-0.20366686582565308,
-0.043684832751750946,
0.24907194077968597,
0.15423759818077087,
0.1990901529788971,
-0.2239534705877304,
-0.743989109992981,
-0.5549389719963074,
-0.2461211085319519,
-0.22337785363197327,
-0.32651007175445557,
0.1191067323088646,
0.17779923975467682,
0.028285479173064232,
0.7472269535064697,
-0.5952014327049255,
-0.027599498629570007,
-0.03883928433060646,
0.1492733359336853,
0.5126981139183044,
0.41393861174583435,
0.6422919034957886,
-0.3752480447292328,
0.22893308103084564,
0.09751059859991074,
-1.3180707693099976,
0.3938445448875427,
0.005289832595735788,
-0.20156817138195038,
-0.20266450941562653,
0.26268547773361206,
-0.3802654445171356,
0.9584062099456787,
0.268262654542923,
-0.456706702709198,
0.35780230164527893,
-0.7889012098312378,
0.28544560074806213,
-0.7881596088409424,
-0.03703886270523071,
0.1201067864894867,
-0.04234486073255539,
-0.9949796199798584,
-0.010861136950552464,
-0.14979596436023712,
-0.0787886455655098,
-0.1540101021528244,
0.1576610505580902,
-0.5260934233665466,
-0.3885355591773987,
-0.3262009620666504,
-0.1818539947271347,
-0.19086404144763947,
0.6890212297439575,
-0.022428708150982857,
0.17421883344650269,
0.64476078748703,
-0.9027891755104065,
0.3086189329624176,
0.42932388186454773,
-0.23549199104309082,
0.6902559399604797,
-0.383382111787796,
0.14099375903606415,
-0.7511934638023376,
-0.1467283070087433,
-1.0512914657592773,
0.08644053339958191,
0.33225691318511963,
-0.70222407579422,
-0.0513690747320652,
-0.1789524108171463,
-0.4062895178794861,
-0.28739917278289795,
-0.03291190043091774,
0.6988449096679688,
0.5546057820320129,
-0.6825616955757141,
0.373312383890152,
0.4473020136356354,
0.4376666843891144,
-0.22356808185577393,
-0.6091142296791077,
-0.21135707199573517,
-0.005638498347252607,
-0.2975425124168396,
-0.31460103392601013,
-0.07603468745946884,
-0.13918611407279968,
0.0002880840329453349,
-0.16391897201538086,
-0.41043585538864136,
0.13434617221355438,
0.13738803565502167,
0.13094604015350342,
-0.03919433057308197,
-0.27939286828041077,
-0.0598362572491169,
-0.2854894697666168,
0.23181986808776855,
-0.9416620135307312,
0.32277005910873413,
0.10041996091604233,
-0.75935959815979,
-0.3730740547180176,
0.5609849095344543,
0.3644571602344513,
0.24432821571826935,
0.3767588138580322,
0.5120083093643188,
-0.6580985188484192,
-0.143281489610672,
-0.16318918764591217,
-0.4134121239185333,
-0.43012359738349915,
0.35738635063171387,
-0.23318476974964142,
-0.5061275362968445,
0.5707473158836365,
-0.057947900146245956,
-0.09678522497415543,
0.2886180877685547,
0.16240568459033966,
-0.18710806965827942,
0.840424120426178,
0.9767328500747681,
-0.3657344579696655,
0.3351585865020752,
-0.4760710597038269,
0.7281581163406372,
-0.3963502049446106,
-0.26795387268066406,
-0.4063199758529663,
-0.42218732833862305,
-0.2592211365699768,
-0.06450840830802917,
0.4432167708873749,
0.29790323972702026,
-0.28698018193244934,
0.18948502838611603,
-0.5893191695213318,
0.4463328719139099,
0.8981630802154541,
0.29728713631629944,
0.29064953327178955,
0.5520519018173218,
0.1674618273973465,
0.10129395872354507,
-0.7968800067901611,
-0.09636058658361435,
1.3310484886169434,
0.2252175658941269,
1.1231353282928467,
-0.12353210896253586,
0.4864320158958435,
0.29911869764328003,
-0.14592771232128143,
-0.554509699344635,
0.34944969415664673,
-0.0733155831694603,
-0.21593517065048218,
-0.4212893843650818,
-0.6928586363792419,
-1.0329550504684448,
-0.09153743088245392,
-0.2481880486011505,
-0.9045795202255249,
0.5832511186599731,
0.1542966067790985,
-0.3199949264526367,
0.7432164549827576,
-0.43616995215415955,
0.11639156192541122,
0.04013148322701454,
0.31518709659576416,
-0.26701655983924866,
-0.4970020651817322,
0.44631698727607727,
0.15451708436012268,
0.24573323130607605,
-0.005700071342289448,
0.5244541168212891,
0.7928528785705566,
-0.31177422404289246,
0.6787568926811218,
-0.4138926565647125,
0.09837482869625092,
0.45159199833869934,
0.33822429180145264,
0.278234601020813,
0.38580167293548584,
0.33047911524772644,
0.5470247268676758,
0.4108363091945648,
-0.5678483843803406,
-0.8019260764122009,
0.3140833377838135,
-1.197575330734253,
-0.010492303408682346,
-0.044670261442661285,
-0.7903857827186584,
0.044099412858486176,
0.16494736075401306,
0.43774572014808655,
0.54963618516922,
-0.3247154951095581,
0.19650936126708984,
0.5854089856147766,
-0.07498408108949661,
0.27060267329216003,
0.3610609471797943,
0.02652820572257042,
-0.440104216337204,
0.9374576210975647,
-0.16355402767658234,
-0.04116185009479523,
0.3973308503627777,
-0.1497683823108673,
-0.2540680170059204,
-0.5732652544975281,
0.21077807247638702,
0.09647831320762634,
-0.9082509279251099,
-0.08735473453998566,
-0.3437495827674866,
-0.3702395260334015,
-0.05917036533355713,
-0.1617816686630249,
-0.4520639479160309,
-0.6807194352149963,
-0.26292118430137634,
-0.08342757076025009,
0.26320967078208923,
0.817314088344574,
-0.5993688702583313,
0.31351643800735474,
-0.5338488817214966,
0.6228207945823669,
-0.005687944125384092,
0.24464227259159088,
-0.2560423016548157,
-0.2191857099533081,
-0.1364695429801941,
0.4050905108451843,
-0.06128476932644844,
-0.7069458961486816,
0.2671237885951996,
-0.056763362139463425,
0.7424091100692749,
0.5295461416244507,
0.04428859055042267,
0.31994983553886414,
-0.17012594640254974,
0.42819204926490784,
0.3239886164665222,
-0.9108239412307739,
0.44355055689811707,
-0.3320814073085785,
0.012749123387038708,
0.3621503710746765,
0.07278580963611603,
-0.3321744501590729,
-0.2511603534221649,
-0.5701617002487183,
-0.4213517904281616,
0.4043771028518677,
0.45201483368873596,
-0.05395153537392616,
0.11749322712421417,
0.6836283802986145,
0.06380409002304077,
0.23820289969444275,
-0.4835869073867798,
-0.5035204887390137,
-0.5560447573661804,
-0.24577252566814423,
0.0007069656276144087,
-0.0835767388343811,
-0.44643694162368774,
-0.13948151469230652,
0.22021545469760895,
-0.20638497173786163,
1.172731876373291,
0.23114846646785736,
-0.10813524574041367,
-0.03697175160050392,
0.3791811168193817,
0.8267707824707031,
0.9603475332260132,
-0.07567895203828812,
0.057671673595905304,
-0.12168005853891373,
-0.5786533951759338,
0.5216467380523682,
0.06644590198993683,
-0.18003179132938385,
-0.25332769751548767,
0.2511359453201294,
0.5801095366477966,
-0.11384742707014084,
0.27851030230522156,
0.31734877824783325,
-0.2847714424133301,
-0.5713332891464233,
-0.4600938856601715,
-0.12996578216552734,
-0.6225869059562683,
0.33718907833099365,
0.7121480107307434,
0.21713942289352417,
0.19292721152305603,
-0.33314746618270874,
0.337543249130249,
0.786622166633606,
-0.21227887272834778,
-0.7748154997825623,
0.7346787452697754,
-0.34332364797592163,
0.20370420813560486,
0.5844960808753967,
-0.1922658383846283,
0.20126256346702576,
0.6269946098327637,
0.489347368478775,
0.7679752111434937,
0.03530045226216316,
0.33826056122779846,
0.39719322323799133,
0.4326303005218506,
0.03750375285744667,
0.7510241270065308,
-0.08829659223556519,
-0.8421693444252014,
-0.18614071607589722,
-0.5617443919181824,
-0.14584419131278992,
-0.022130411118268967,
-0.6987232565879822,
-0.1204199343919754,
-1.105806589126587,
0.0880209356546402,
-0.013702704571187496,
-0.2302040308713913,
-0.8927211165428162,
-0.005274439230561256,
0.11287062615156174,
0.7228359580039978,
-0.757415235042572,
0.6235113739967346,
0.32885581254959106,
-0.16874197125434875,
-0.8144940137863159,
-0.43713992834091187,
0.1429692953824997,
-1.076620101928711,
0.37521201372146606,
-0.40366408228874207,
-0.0795372873544693,
0.16507601737976074,
-0.8944624662399292,
-1.1706669330596924,
0.9811410307884216,
0.5426181554794312,
-0.19072145223617554,
0.04455576464533806,
0.3875742554664612,
0.3256509602069855,
-0.15107686817646027,
0.2804672122001648,
0.4176468551158905,
0.34743931889533997,
0.3547549843788147,
-0.4938526153564453,
0.0043983920477330685,
-0.24268603324890137,
-0.014894996769726276,
0.4260128438472748,
-0.1288316398859024,
0.7182334065437317,
-0.29794901609420776,
-0.5508756637573242,
0.3084687292575836,
0.8329486846923828,
0.022560251876711845,
0.07144906371831894,
0.03868917003273964,
0.5853022933006287,
0.815573513507843,
-0.23738433420658112,
1.0790770053863525,
-0.6303170323371887,
0.8278646469116211,
0.23896683752536774,
0.374167799949646,
0.11944018304347992,
0.4210241734981537,
-0.38012415170669556,
0.15223774313926697,
0.1091061383485794,
0.17531295120716095,
0.84029221534729,
0.2773076593875885,
-0.0017376301111653447,
0.06727974861860275,
0.2571618854999542,
-0.3453119099140167,
0.4258230924606323,
0.4007611870765686,
-0.1229642927646637,
-0.6162727475166321,
0.24289606511592865,
-0.15187989175319672,
-0.21209631860256195,
-0.5066671371459961,
0.6730161309242249,
0.032679200172424316,
0.034600161015987396,
0.7555251121520996,
-0.00651538884267211,
0.1617809236049652,
-0.6981770396232605,
-0.16975010931491852,
-0.12612251937389374,
0.34350070357322693,
-0.20373891294002533,
-0.6795182228088379,
0.4070183336734772,
-0.7822880148887634,
-0.26778414845466614,
0.11505036056041718,
0.6503915190696716,
-0.3061157464981079,
-0.5772460103034973,
-0.05472945049405098,
0.26192209124565125,
0.1710587739944458,
0.005299047566950321,
-0.19031371176242828,
-0.07065145671367645,
-0.11699246615171432,
0.07524124532938004,
-0.0941704735159874,
0.36192023754119873,
0.214811310172081,
0.6616482734680176,
0.9917629957199097,
0.17359523475170135,
0.35679587721824646,
-0.273024320602417,
0.6907750368118286,
-0.8245800733566284,
-0.8712323307991028,
-0.6127718687057495,
0.3350166082382202,
0.31244438886642456,
-0.024522075429558754,
0.7628483176231384,
0.23740611970424652,
0.8291914463043213,
-0.11209680140018463,
1.0910930633544922,
0.10265542566776276,
0.036602675914764404,
-0.6859305500984192,
0.48718956112861633,
-0.14813607931137085,
-0.07952439039945602,
-0.2894507944583893,
-0.8393075466156006,
-0.564542829990387,
0.6816585063934326,
-0.29073622822761536,
0.06327672302722931,
0.6169250011444092,
0.5136833190917969,
-0.30427148938179016,
0.3456436097621918,
0.43063458800315857,
-0.09370817989110947,
0.4340805411338806,
0.9098354578018188,
0.8885046243667603,
-0.45534324645996094,
0.44697585701942444,
-0.14851856231689453,
-0.5761810541152954,
-0.006741904187947512,
-0.5303210616111755,
-0.7436676621437073,
-0.6943039298057556,
-0.04349443316459656,
-0.20922774076461792,
-0.11416329443454742,
0.49265041947364807,
0.9568830132484436,
-0.7076984643936157,
-0.10659117996692657,
-0.34473052620887756,
0.058627307415008545,
-0.336274117231369,
-0.15944191813468933,
0.33410370349884033,
0.042375899851322174,
-0.14616072177886963,
0.35608407855033875,
0.6903001666069031,
0.14637529850006104,
-0.25445637106895447,
-0.1773843765258789,
0.055101726204156876,
0.2977227568626404,
0.6296117305755615,
0.9458656311035156,
-0.36472442746162415,
-0.36868348717689514,
0.02122943475842476,
0.16306756436824799,
0.2923322021961212,
1.0208674669265747,
-0.513799250125885,
0.21747669577598572,
0.6726031303405762,
0.5811683535575867,
0.3844582438468933,
-0.04326074197888374,
0.4287509024143219,
-0.7684546709060669,
0.5319460034370422,
-0.05132555216550827,
0.45635589957237244,
-0.006323655601590872,
-0.776410698890686,
0.14389356970787048,
0.36100438237190247,
-0.36553189158439636,
-0.3140963912010193,
0.5607758164405823,
-0.8083383440971375,
-0.16958200931549072,
0.655214250087738,
0.05404508858919144,
-0.5667954087257385,
-0.1079101637005806,
0.273294597864151,
0.16152355074882507,
-0.1033337265253067,
0.8751408457756042,
0.4163033068180084,
-0.35852116346359253,
-0.2614057958126068,
-0.3230895400047302,
0.3327276110649109,
0.11303181946277618,
-1.026755690574646,
-0.12084578722715378,
0.4934580326080322,
0.3116533160209656,
0.4259788990020752,
0.9346148371696472,
-0.42872199416160583,
0.37933114171028137,
0.10869613289833069,
0.12172949314117432,
-0.23362229764461517,
-0.7464081645011902,
-0.3881014883518219,
0.3759501576423645,
-0.2596684396266937,
-0.48570728302001953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07788v1
|
DEPTH: Discourse Education through Pre-Training Hierarchically
| 2024-05-13T14:35:30 | 2024-05-13T14:35:30 |
Zachary Bamberger, Ofek Glick, Chaim Baskin, Yonatan Belinkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language Models (LMs) often struggle with linguistic understanding at the
discourse level, even though discourse patterns such as coherence, cohesion,
and narrative flow are prevalent in their pre-training data. Current methods
address these challenges only after the pre-training phase, relying on
expensive human annotated data to align the model. To improve the discourse
capabilities of LMs already at the pre-training stage, we introduce DEPTH, an
encoder-decoder model that learns to represent sentences using a
discourse-oriented pre-training objective. DEPTH combines hierarchical sentence
representations with two objectives: (1) Sentence Un-Shuffling, and (2)
Span-Corruption. This approach trains the model to represent both
sub-word-level and sentence-level dependencies over a massive amount of
unstructured text. When trained either from scratch or continuing from a
pre-trained T5 checkpoint, DEPTH learns semantic and discourse-level
representations faster than T5, outperforming it in span-corruption loss
despite the additional sentence-un-shuffling objective. Evaluations on the
GLUE, DiscoEval, and NI benchmarks demonstrate DEPTH's ability to quickly learn
diverse downstream tasks, which require syntactic, semantic, and discourse
capabilities. Overall, our approach extends the discourse capabilities of T5,
while minimally impacting other natural language understanding (NLU)
capabilities in the resulting LM.
|
[
-0.20585060119628906,
-0.5908555388450623,
0.5625532269477844,
0.19034238159656525,
-0.5629807114601135,
0.5650332570075989,
0.15167969465255737,
-0.19992773234844208,
0.08062088489532471,
0.5982639789581299,
-0.3908796012401581,
-0.6501263976097107,
-0.7788078784942627,
-0.11259933561086655,
-0.36457598209381104,
0.9905669689178467,
0.10060061514377594,
-0.020585495978593826,
-0.19369953870773315,
0.28238698840141296,
-0.3330373466014862,
-0.4023677706718445,
-0.43173128366470337,
-0.4343840181827545,
0.36893072724342346,
0.369422048330307,
0.5626135468482971,
0.6022862792015076,
0.14747606217861176,
0.319035142660141,
-0.06326627731323242,
-0.01618853770196438,
-0.853068470954895,
-0.14576710760593414,
-0.05400678887963295,
-0.20450204610824585,
-0.3688832223415375,
-0.08518858999013901,
0.6529669761657715,
1.1310838460922241,
-0.20844854414463043,
-0.13230077922344208,
0.32514405250549316,
0.5267394781112671,
-0.8087799549102783,
0.1789669543504715,
-0.5588210225105286,
0.2449897825717926,
-0.1988348662853241,
-0.24501676857471466,
-0.560624361038208,
-0.34691914916038513,
0.4227719306945801,
-0.7202273011207581,
-0.18684476613998413,
0.04605752229690552,
1.1138970851898193,
0.26846951246261597,
-0.44748497009277344,
-0.06461715698242188,
-0.5581378936767578,
0.47819051146507263,
-0.4627240300178528,
0.40419548749923706,
0.4822636544704437,
-0.06422411650419235,
0.19466274976730347,
-0.8081850409507751,
-0.10838888585567474,
0.1636953055858612,
-0.2979026734828949,
0.32169726490974426,
0.11230200529098511,
0.4242844879627228,
0.12101111561059952,
0.6455339193344116,
-0.6364853382110596,
0.18771828711032867,
-0.4859076738357544,
-0.19336535036563873,
0.22800420224666595,
0.15983493626117706,
0.16234330832958221,
-0.2802782654762268,
-0.3156188130378723,
0.07821022719144821,
-0.648655891418457,
0.15711626410484314,
0.17042230069637299,
0.14610067009925842,
-0.11065731942653656,
0.23006612062454224,
0.10182259231805801,
0.5766900777816772,
0.24155433475971222,
-0.12539231777191162,
0.235347718000412,
-0.3298611044883728,
-0.3871035873889923,
0.0875595211982727,
0.8277291655540466,
-0.286933958530426,
0.404175341129303,
-0.20551711320877075,
-0.01694287732243538,
-0.2249474972486496,
0.5159456133842468,
-0.9285210371017456,
-0.3043763041496277,
0.1379101723432541,
-0.36860641837120056,
-0.3517987132072449,
0.14969488978385925,
-0.408226877450943,
-0.327217698097229,
-0.20326274633407593,
0.4405190646648407,
-0.6895489692687988,
-0.14106309413909912,
0.6188016533851624,
0.09539923816919327,
0.4610981345176697,
0.15757274627685547,
-0.8582108616828918,
0.6180383563041687,
0.660531759262085,
0.7350295782089233,
-0.09547428041696548,
-0.3068089485168457,
-0.4912587106227875,
0.2795603275299072,
-0.43494054675102234,
0.7189112901687622,
-0.6963051557540894,
-0.3688710033893585,
0.08396262675523758,
-0.2010670006275177,
-0.05613834038376808,
-0.464973509311676,
0.5455583930015564,
-0.4439726173877716,
0.5282866954803467,
0.00431619118899107,
-0.603312075138092,
-0.0019951059948652983,
0.33563682436943054,
-0.5130675435066223,
0.8531933426856995,
0.19036753475666046,
-0.970970869064331,
0.3095373809337616,
-0.5274146795272827,
-0.7282673120498657,
0.0900990217924118,
-0.048497699201107025,
-0.40157291293144226,
0.24179300665855408,
0.5797430872917175,
0.377597451210022,
0.0305288415402174,
0.537767231464386,
0.22688028216362,
-0.6032402515411377,
-0.3059011995792389,
-0.07459788769483566,
0.735751211643219,
-0.19867892563343048,
-0.025971775874495506,
0.3211793899536133,
-0.6986826062202454,
-0.15432754158973694,
0.0028253921773284674,
-0.3096603751182556,
-0.4427209198474884,
-0.15296109020709991,
-0.4947451055049896,
0.021686866879463196,
0.12427813559770584,
-0.4214640259742737,
0.0025995196774601936,
-0.9862488508224487,
0.365491658449173,
0.6438595056533813,
0.018868818879127502,
0.8067079782485962,
-0.03858474642038345,
0.5932839512825012,
0.6000139117240906,
0.020111514255404472,
-0.6983751654624939,
-0.097371906042099,
-0.9615553617477417,
-0.014623635448515415,
0.5540893077850342,
0.6750429272651672,
-0.9951895475387573,
0.5593989491462708,
-0.3971284031867981,
-0.23429512977600098,
-0.9744497537612915,
-0.11626531928777695,
0.6108893752098083,
0.5233145952224731,
0.5690690875053406,
-0.637962818145752,
-0.8349031209945679,
-0.7858836650848389,
-0.4027523994445801,
-0.226423978805542,
-0.04674764722585678,
-0.029270732775330544,
0.6356701254844666,
0.009771451354026794,
0.7971696853637695,
-0.4632728695869446,
-0.28194761276245117,
-0.40677890181541443,
0.5365583300590515,
-0.06949050724506378,
0.36334919929504395,
0.04893127828836441,
-0.3180033564567566,
-0.2879599332809448,
-0.22651326656341553,
-0.5535993576049805,
-0.07154910266399384,
-0.04406548663973808,
-0.2053781896829605,
-0.01337328739464283,
0.5653479695320129,
-0.5033009648323059,
0.3421478271484375,
0.40472251176834106,
-0.2503761351108551,
0.36224833130836487,
-0.28758227825164795,
-0.08303353935480118,
-1.240369439125061,
-0.16607481241226196,
-0.3671795427799225,
-0.40082040429115295,
-0.7453740239143372,
-0.2223588526248932,
0.031311970204114914,
-0.29886212944984436,
-0.5204945206642151,
0.1194828674197197,
-0.5877076983451843,
-0.2237950712442398,
-0.03122609294950962,
0.12773600220680237,
0.34306588768959045,
0.5375425219535828,
0.31122416257858276,
0.5453481674194336,
0.5096486806869507,
-0.5179264545440674,
-0.2366679608821869,
0.1371161937713623,
-0.6254703998565674,
0.36175766587257385,
-0.7510302662849426,
0.3495923578739166,
-0.44319066405296326,
0.3014970123767853,
-0.7392644286155701,
-0.11053435504436493,
0.09559793025255203,
-0.23252692818641663,
0.38704490661621094,
0.021029608324170113,
-0.2692062556743622,
-0.2401835024356842,
-0.32489609718322754,
0.3873816430568695,
0.49264711141586304,
-0.3699602782726288,
0.6763173937797546,
0.597769558429718,
-0.05502040311694145,
-0.84084552526474,
-0.7042917013168335,
0.07681286334991455,
-0.014700273983180523,
-0.4421519637107849,
0.5777108073234558,
0.3000664710998535,
-0.07667677849531174,
0.01874162256717682,
0.1049230620265007,
-0.2885793149471283,
0.05538681522011757,
0.010417063720524311,
-0.1731376200914383,
-0.26136407256126404,
0.11347000300884247,
0.4051465690135956,
-0.17775437235832214,
0.16344481706619263,
-0.5196352005004883,
0.658420979976654,
-0.14533774554729462,
-0.17826686799526215,
-0.4840717315673828,
0.3494679033756256,
0.26833251118659973,
-0.4672390818595886,
0.8575338125228882,
0.3249231278896332,
-0.322992205619812,
-0.11831769347190857,
-0.24179796874523163,
-0.20312723517417908,
-0.4212680160999298,
0.4595354497432709,
-0.44322988390922546,
-1.2363489866256714,
0.32630544900894165,
-0.14767470955848694,
0.1940290629863739,
0.08209773898124695,
0.027873437851667404,
-0.25585421919822693,
0.7597339153289795,
0.7127838134765625,
-0.2001124918460846,
0.261755108833313,
-0.12964102625846863,
0.32479000091552734,
-0.5904477834701538,
-0.29588088393211365,
-0.26625511050224304,
-0.21121296286582947,
-0.18904340267181396,
-0.6868726015090942,
0.07800569385290146,
0.12072689831256866,
-0.6028585433959961,
0.18859443068504333,
-0.2681684195995331,
0.7419608235359192,
0.23541788756847382,
0.07371021807193756,
0.31982070207595825,
-0.0029122508130967617,
-0.11963765323162079,
-0.39499717950820923,
-0.7296770215034485,
-0.410428911447525,
0.5832799077033997,
0.5936429500579834,
0.7536541223526001,
-0.27704131603240967,
0.9750669598579407,
-0.14866894483566284,
0.0022503607906401157,
-0.7814375162124634,
0.5164827108383179,
-0.2899319529533386,
-0.11839225888252258,
-0.23640844225883484,
-0.31136250495910645,
-1.0582494735717773,
0.49095866084098816,
-0.012324241921305656,
-0.42103394865989685,
0.13103392720222473,
0.07900053262710571,
-0.5914030075073242,
0.25768905878067017,
-0.48878034949302673,
0.9550495743751526,
-0.15541361272335052,
-0.2072320431470871,
-0.027241772040724754,
-0.886882483959198,
0.4055851995944977,
0.1448517143726349,
0.2809726595878601,
0.22861222922801971,
-0.1088699921965599,
0.5801250338554382,
-0.2774558365345001,
0.9981904029846191,
-0.25988391041755676,
-0.2197648584842682,
0.2125566303730011,
0.16765880584716797,
0.2153559774160385,
-0.1600939780473709,
0.16856162250041962,
-0.04985373094677925,
-0.43839722871780396,
-0.3338983952999115,
-0.529143750667572,
0.015861498191952705,
-0.8379954695701599,
-0.7232089638710022,
-0.3657403290271759,
-0.603355348110199,
-0.2959573566913605,
0.15644428133964539,
0.2992960810661316,
0.2180039882659912,
-0.6179754734039307,
0.27952075004577637,
1.0083931684494019,
-0.3594772517681122,
0.2966329753398895,
0.23759542405605316,
-0.3036741614341736,
-0.22251418232917786,
0.7153896689414978,
0.016420824453234673,
0.28323715925216675,
0.7147635221481323,
0.20764727890491486,
-0.27030354738235474,
-0.620510458946228,
-0.1693454384803772,
0.05309838056564331,
-0.5770640969276428,
-0.15383018553256989,
-0.911643385887146,
-0.5920541286468506,
-0.321384996175766,
-0.17948412895202637,
-0.42225542664527893,
-0.24702273309230804,
-0.48093461990356445,
-0.4453357458114624,
-0.13614484667778015,
0.7659558653831482,
0.11571977287530899,
0.6326290965080261,
-0.6357923150062561,
0.3276783525943756,
0.2758544385433197,
0.2374778389930725,
-0.17129608988761902,
-0.9962307810783386,
-0.134103924036026,
-0.11541564762592316,
-0.40885859727859497,
-0.7921121716499329,
0.387089341878891,
0.3938595950603485,
0.08256690204143524,
0.5644758343696594,
-0.14010797441005707,
1.0213068723678589,
-0.6276696920394897,
0.7516042590141296,
0.012778950855135918,
-1.406197428703308,
0.7967622876167297,
-0.31639087200164795,
0.8781223893165588,
0.6594818234443665,
0.5848162770271301,
-0.3851321339607239,
-0.5641108155250549,
-0.5694556832313538,
-0.8953539133071899,
0.842673659324646,
0.13674458861351013,
0.31763285398483276,
0.10636532306671143,
0.3029390871524811,
0.20960521697998047,
0.31275996565818787,
-1.0106751918792725,
0.17574504017829895,
-0.5547540783882141,
-0.22191539406776428,
0.04306625947356224,
-0.522557258605957,
0.13729679584503174,
-0.5087894201278687,
0.47048816084861755,
-0.10146266222000122,
0.04682828113436699,
-0.05203394964337349,
-0.49598512053489685,
0.19275090098381042,
0.48789432644844055,
0.3675861060619354,
0.6010351181030273,
0.08793622255325317,
0.438566118478775,
0.34387272596359253,
-0.4093148112297058,
0.09573093801736832,
-0.14558377861976624,
-0.08549539744853973,
-0.1336854249238968,
0.6135731339454651,
1.0761322975158691,
0.8197859525680542,
-0.38082584738731384,
0.6558470726013184,
0.025888938456773758,
-0.45332393050193787,
0.058739326894283295,
-0.2441302388906479,
0.48297232389450073,
-0.1106560155749321,
0.07108768075704575,
-0.2947859764099121,
0.19422875344753265,
-0.6727305054664612,
0.20928721129894257,
0.001914828666485846,
-0.4293448328971863,
-0.35044795274734497,
0.37619560956954956,
0.2505252957344055,
-0.15427884459495544,
0.6705510020256042,
-0.25162094831466675,
-0.5527483820915222,
0.2602608799934387,
0.6139227151870728,
0.7425979971885681,
-0.5939733982086182,
0.537864089012146,
0.3667938709259033,
0.45761385560035706,
-0.09363700449466705,
0.3785049617290497,
0.017832579091191292,
-0.8279862999916077,
-0.6673925518989563,
-0.6901673078536987,
-0.24476437270641327,
0.19365185499191284,
-0.7175642848014832,
0.028155459091067314,
-0.5893286466598511,
0.22048728168010712,
-0.34690576791763306,
-0.11749031394720078,
-0.3570220470428467,
0.19496004283428192,
0.15629324316978455,
0.6962110996246338,
-0.7189164161682129,
0.8386415839195251,
0.48507535457611084,
-0.33743050694465637,
-0.7782800197601318,
0.14665445685386658,
-0.3247169256210327,
-0.6943719387054443,
0.47468623518943787,
0.3381931483745575,
-0.29704374074935913,
0.1497591882944107,
-0.5878375768661499,
-0.7085283398628235,
0.8643701672554016,
0.7718268036842346,
-0.6453365087509155,
-0.3395383656024933,
0.4055110812187195,
0.75142902135849,
-0.7258535623550415,
0.18970130383968353,
0.7088152766227722,
0.2179950475692749,
0.12021785229444504,
-0.753338098526001,
-0.1357206404209137,
0.03691594675183296,
0.18975922465324402,
0.13336430490016937,
-0.21220508217811584,
0.8765794038772583,
-0.14301039278507233,
-0.4764813482761383,
-0.2273145616054535,
0.9440378546714783,
0.1399521827697754,
-0.12257152050733566,
0.5786887407302856,
0.71016526222229,
0.890823245048523,
-0.30152812600135803,
0.8892084360122681,
-0.238015279173851,
-0.061079591512680054,
1.394079566001892,
-0.20513741672039032,
0.7781540155410767,
0.2945364713668823,
0.2809444069862366,
1.0694427490234375,
0.7399283647537231,
0.4533930718898773,
0.6301153302192688,
0.30979853868484497,
-0.02137410268187523,
-0.37875235080718994,
-0.24651682376861572,
-0.2620849013328552,
0.5870782732963562,
0.498556911945343,
-0.32573744654655457,
-0.22527670860290527,
0.0976276621222496,
0.04285040125250816,
0.37608739733695984,
-0.5294834971427917,
1.0293666124343872,
0.34142497181892395,
-0.6309916377067566,
0.5508744120597839,
-0.26615357398986816,
0.5713673233985901,
-0.43359729647636414,
0.16430430114269257,
-0.1419771909713745,
0.08265835791826248,
-0.2211194932460785,
-0.8864898681640625,
0.5179998278617859,
-0.13657432794570923,
0.13653729856014252,
-0.6405512094497681,
0.8831770420074463,
-0.8125683665275574,
-0.3679361641407013,
0.4331877529621124,
0.6200057864189148,
0.21864131093025208,
-0.03366297110915184,
-0.6103598475456238,
0.0037891766987740993,
-0.37432926893234253,
-0.1914600133895874,
0.19544319808483124,
0.6231566071510315,
0.12673194706439972,
0.3786488473415375,
0.08244029432535172,
-0.21607957780361176,
-0.18374788761138916,
0.5681637525558472,
1.0724273920059204,
-0.6068952679634094,
-0.6352526545524597,
-0.84832763671875,
0.7375216484069824,
-0.18904972076416016,
-0.20779787003993988,
0.38020849227905273,
0.6107133030891418,
0.9325028657913208,
0.03722783923149109,
0.5756340026855469,
0.3233851492404938,
0.30594003200531006,
-0.5436580181121826,
0.6490874290466309,
-0.2900284230709076,
0.04985437169671059,
-0.25938522815704346,
-0.6766631007194519,
-0.2942294180393219,
0.8775856494903564,
-0.43786782026290894,
0.057293545454740524,
0.9732170104980469,
0.3981931507587433,
-0.043818484991788864,
0.16633163392543793,
0.39418041706085205,
0.3598470687866211,
-0.05654367804527283,
0.8834287524223328,
1.001166820526123,
-0.3874121606349945,
0.4721342921257019,
-0.01787433959543705,
0.02769336849451065,
0.3360346257686615,
-0.7018595337867737,
-1.2115943431854248,
-0.385073721408844,
-0.09903229027986526,
-0.07521694898605347,
0.3403538763523102,
0.5756036639213562,
0.7910116910934448,
-0.5595060586929321,
-0.489004909992218,
-0.27159610390663147,
0.02111223340034485,
0.16790862381458282,
-0.1426687091588974,
0.19094786047935486,
-0.5482511520385742,
-0.5930699706077576,
0.45149704813957214,
0.6078299283981323,
-0.12297666072845459,
-0.3551960289478302,
-0.05986841768026352,
-0.408687025308609,
0.17457835376262665,
0.877637505531311,
-0.08931335806846619,
-0.5065622925758362,
-0.3680499494075775,
-0.0689103975892067,
-0.09125271439552307,
0.35506898164749146,
1.048034429550171,
-0.8994626402854919,
0.25890862941741943,
0.4837328791618347,
0.7550446391105652,
0.5862851738929749,
0.133347287774086,
0.7492364048957825,
-1.0402756929397583,
0.26862236857414246,
0.4958307445049286,
0.23523931205272675,
0.4463496208190918,
-0.24145536124706268,
0.21809761226177216,
-0.07316277176141739,
-0.2068481296300888,
-0.7179971933364868,
0.400040864944458,
-0.4828852117061615,
-0.49081677198410034,
0.6939447522163391,
-0.3900303542613983,
-0.09520918875932693,
-0.4956299662590027,
-0.13089028000831604,
0.22991999983787537,
-0.21015140414237976,
0.701359748840332,
0.7646930813789368,
0.1541663259267807,
-0.6533647775650024,
-0.025097720324993134,
0.6579503417015076,
0.6345885396003723,
-1.147664189338684,
-0.01754423975944519,
0.13640521466732025,
-0.10259442031383514,
0.03461435064673424,
0.9711269736289978,
-0.2898619472980499,
-0.0464928075671196,
-0.10195063799619675,
-0.11029183864593506,
0.06025155261158943,
-0.6408401727676392,
-0.38842228055000305,
0.49350863695144653,
-0.0827196016907692,
0.04748307168483734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07778v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07778v1
|
A Comprehensive Analysis of Static Word Embeddings for Turkish
| 2024-05-13T14:23:37 | 2024-05-13T14:23:37 |
Karahan Sarıtaş, Cahid Arda Öz, Tunga Güngör
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Word embeddings are fixed-length, dense and distributed word representations
that are used in natural language processing (NLP) applications. There are
basically two types of word embedding models which are non-contextual (static)
models and contextual models. The former method generates a single embedding
for a word regardless of its context, while the latter method produces distinct
embeddings for a word based on the specific contexts in which it appears. There
are plenty of works that compare contextual and non-contextual embedding models
within their respective groups in different languages. However, the number of
studies that compare the models in these two groups with each other is very few
and there is no such study in Turkish. This process necessitates converting
contextual embeddings into static embeddings. In this paper, we compare and
evaluate the performance of several contextual and non-contextual models in
both intrinsic and extrinsic evaluation settings for Turkish. We make a
fine-grained comparison by analyzing the syntactic and semantic capabilities of
the models separately. The results of the analyses provide insights about the
suitability of different embedding models in different types of NLP tasks. We
also build a Turkish word embedding repository comprising the embedding models
used in this work, which may serve as a valuable resource for researchers and
practitioners in the field of Turkish NLP. We make the word embeddings,
scripts, and evaluation datasets publicly available.
|
[
-0.5182705521583557,
-0.9802409410476685,
0.3104255795478821,
0.09926756471395493,
-0.7665849328041077,
-0.36293116211891174,
-0.4651658236980438,
-0.405520498752594,
0.19239254295825958,
0.3879370391368866,
0.023968636989593506,
-0.7962026000022888,
-0.7546479105949402,
0.29605376720428467,
-0.4041675627231598,
0.833157479763031,
-0.47839587926864624,
0.09108635783195496,
-0.4670039713382721,
-0.6547619104385376,
-0.6647354364395142,
-0.3453251123428345,
-0.02445712499320507,
-0.05156581476330757,
-0.016340140253305435,
-0.019644826650619507,
0.5553357601165771,
0.3496799170970917,
0.3794150948524475,
0.2772592306137085,
-0.41929829120635986,
-0.03523670509457588,
-0.23187603056430817,
0.25748351216316223,
-0.3347323536872864,
0.0794314369559288,
0.14133796095848083,
-0.1422654092311859,
0.7166289687156677,
0.6161725521087646,
-0.17941097915172577,
0.6320943236351013,
0.23033948242664337,
0.536862850189209,
-0.9433826208114624,
0.19549629092216492,
-0.41008618474006653,
0.29778623580932617,
-0.10960008949041367,
-0.132120281457901,
-0.15572309494018555,
-0.5098499655723572,
0.4033486545085907,
-0.1492900252342224,
0.08906635642051697,
-0.07116825878620148,
0.5899055004119873,
0.17942871153354645,
-0.6651595234870911,
-0.48625725507736206,
-0.6800631880760193,
0.6908980011940002,
-0.865513265132904,
0.45873233675956726,
0.1465870589017868,
0.1590067446231842,
-0.2549436092376709,
-0.6344026923179626,
-0.38009732961654663,
-0.6598448157310486,
0.010246934369206429,
-0.08516737818717957,
-0.06860478967428207,
0.14651811122894287,
-0.002396026160567999,
0.729814887046814,
-0.3522433936595917,
-0.35462820529937744,
-0.23280423879623413,
0.22174060344696045,
0.3445383310317993,
0.09676726162433624,
0.3567768633365631,
-0.13442815840244293,
-0.15016768872737885,
-0.09004376828670502,
-0.5711585879325867,
0.04771203547716141,
0.19046719372272491,
0.41097021102905273,
-0.16729699075222015,
0.9793165326118469,
-0.4376033544540405,
0.9038481712341309,
-0.08524653315544128,
-0.22092603147029877,
-0.05885021388530731,
-0.18967249989509583,
-0.39974936842918396,
0.2063554972410202,
0.34999212622642517,
0.1263272613286972,
-0.10879344493150711,
-0.4622651934623718,
-0.2859894931316376,
0.12195960432291031,
0.30505114793777466,
-0.4528217613697052,
0.279168963432312,
0.2733389139175415,
-0.612443745136261,
-0.2673337459564209,
0.14128169417381287,
-0.4877881407737732,
-0.4299059510231018,
-0.21540674567222595,
0.4818214476108551,
-0.49187883734703064,
-0.28333574533462524,
0.2555917203426361,
-0.17857280373573303,
0.17901797592639923,
0.17669545114040375,
-0.7231929302215576,
0.5006754398345947,
0.7465860247612,
1.0435547828674316,
0.12841501832008362,
0.010736717842519283,
0.02772565931081772,
0.11322296410799026,
-0.5417381525039673,
0.6490209698677063,
-0.6367605924606323,
-0.23377959430217743,
0.603598415851593,
0.07644347101449966,
-0.1482347697019577,
-0.5002532005310059,
0.9148982763290405,
-0.36473771929740906,
0.2786339223384857,
-0.5980264544487,
-0.81747967004776,
-0.914238691329956,
0.2615889310836792,
-0.6793016195297241,
0.9458178877830505,
0.11173825711011887,
-1.0641299486160278,
0.5508594512939453,
-0.6021758913993835,
-0.14123018085956573,
0.2013322412967682,
-0.011523779481649399,
-0.07944106310606003,
0.845217227935791,
-0.15991470217704773,
0.6630563735961914,
-0.24515698850154877,
0.2625291049480438,
-0.3737538456916809,
-0.6142727732658386,
-0.09310276806354523,
-0.04750419035553932,
0.19306716322898865,
0.10882053524255753,
-0.6328638792037964,
-0.06423638015985489,
-0.41514852643013,
-0.11951380223035812,
0.11825121939182281,
-0.4590505063533783,
-0.5425613522529602,
0.35191020369529724,
0.37859418988227844,
0.43988385796546936,
0.2628510296344757,
-0.6878491640090942,
-0.0013155360938981175,
-0.2917466163635254,
0.13715991377830505,
0.2869100868701935,
-0.08302970230579376,
0.17511342465877533,
-0.3077371418476105,
0.40188074111938477,
-0.233078733086586,
-0.39857274293899536,
0.13257382810115814,
-0.3607533872127533,
-0.7240610718727112,
-0.2319381982088089,
0.4046691656112671,
0.39900079369544983,
-0.4416891634464264,
0.45890817046165466,
-0.2865259349346161,
-0.4866637587547302,
-0.31887146830558777,
-0.0007086552795954049,
0.20476853847503662,
0.26637592911720276,
0.2923988699913025,
-0.10916759073734283,
-0.30338943004608154,
-0.8395571112632751,
-0.4214579164981842,
0.041923996061086655,
0.08644301444292068,
0.4610142111778259,
0.5654371976852417,
-0.0759633406996727,
0.6719589829444885,
0.008063826709985733,
-0.3991018533706665,
-0.39485567808151245,
0.22432446479797363,
0.2499323934316635,
0.30639949440956116,
0.534367024898529,
-0.14249315857887268,
-0.5690634250640869,
0.05033985525369644,
-0.8622220158576965,
0.09285639226436615,
0.036390408873558044,
0.18214496970176697,
0.5760619044303894,
0.22757402062416077,
-0.5093535780906677,
0.5557295680046082,
0.6953267455101013,
-0.7233782410621643,
0.6154011487960815,
-0.30670076608657837,
0.018318844959139824,
-0.8391430974006653,
0.33385539054870605,
0.0511622354388237,
-0.46255356073379517,
-0.6388167142868042,
0.5532559156417847,
-0.08241721987724304,
-0.199785977602005,
-0.6514977812767029,
0.45457401871681213,
-0.5740886330604553,
-0.05466221272945404,
-0.17933520674705505,
0.05396129563450813,
-0.20093080401420593,
0.26826274394989014,
0.24937188625335693,
0.7705211639404297,
0.32912829518318176,
-0.4830973744392395,
0.24584786593914032,
0.10539211332798004,
-1.0117149353027344,
0.1700097620487213,
-0.7834269404411316,
0.04790317267179489,
-0.11406785994768143,
0.335414320230484,
-0.8061710596084595,
0.16058216989040375,
0.26471447944641113,
0.16166755557060242,
0.49504217505455017,
-0.1768685281276703,
-0.7002455592155457,
-0.028500718995928764,
-0.5072335004806519,
0.23203474283218384,
0.26954296231269836,
-0.23815658688545227,
0.2880478501319885,
0.40500086545944214,
-0.19567129015922546,
-0.5094243884086609,
-0.5073494911193848,
0.20057924091815948,
-0.42130306363105774,
-0.6235775351524353,
0.3943684697151184,
0.6238937973976135,
-0.23885111510753632,
0.46339818835258484,
-0.11851206421852112,
0.048534274101257324,
0.1347184032201767,
0.09186213463544846,
-0.0349712148308754,
-0.45791521668434143,
0.2163584977388382,
0.14937569200992584,
0.10710791498422623,
-0.1921456903219223,
-0.34565305709838867,
0.5496394634246826,
-0.6404005885124207,
-0.4053773581981659,
-0.43784117698669434,
0.5837041735649109,
0.7228259444236755,
-0.30322176218032837,
1.4345409870147705,
0.8508338332176208,
-0.5956022143363953,
0.25187474489212036,
-0.7310838103294373,
0.18537665903568268,
-0.3996250331401825,
0.45384481549263,
-0.24516789615154266,
-0.9266176819801331,
0.264751672744751,
-0.2263476550579071,
0.27970167994499207,
0.500085711479187,
0.8141453862190247,
0.09532108902931213,
0.8262508511543274,
0.6750833988189697,
0.13479480147361755,
0.2734568417072296,
-0.24290744960308075,
0.3522596061229706,
-0.9178032279014587,
-0.2951977252960205,
-0.23081420361995697,
-0.2253715544939041,
-0.7054430842399597,
-0.44460397958755493,
0.033685311675071716,
0.183014377951622,
-0.013145171105861664,
0.18762750923633575,
-0.4810813367366791,
0.2023983597755432,
0.10362427681684494,
-0.2519586384296417,
-0.19898360967636108,
0.3031313419342041,
-0.5048646926879883,
0.08901756256818771,
-0.5564733147621155,
-1.1560699939727783,
0.9130341410636902,
0.4507889747619629,
0.40476086735725403,
0.40257272124290466,
0.5282317996025085,
0.38981354236602783,
0.07353302091360092,
-0.8421747088432312,
0.3060321509838104,
-0.37306058406829834,
-0.5648426413536072,
-0.34198662638664246,
0.03847784921526909,
-0.8741639256477356,
0.5214160084724426,
-0.6048697233200073,
-0.9438559412956238,
0.11063427478075027,
-0.20209531486034393,
-0.3339742422103882,
0.644863486289978,
-0.5030823349952698,
0.7989031672477722,
0.34016385674476624,
-0.3891487717628479,
-0.466843843460083,
0.0172822717577219,
0.317068487405777,
0.12700338661670685,
-0.06872513890266418,
-0.30055883526802063,
-0.11277592927217484,
0.9310685396194458,
-0.3031071722507477,
0.4697721004486084,
-0.3687160611152649,
0.06979262083768845,
0.44178643822669983,
0.1396322250366211,
0.3491767644882202,
0.08752775937318802,
-0.0750378891825676,
0.3966026306152344,
0.6420542001724243,
-0.3759612441062927,
-0.3633953928947449,
0.6512921452522278,
-0.7089173197746277,
-0.6822754740715027,
-0.6048838496208191,
-0.22356221079826355,
-0.05130048468708992,
-0.0339989960193634,
0.006527248304337263,
0.8451297879219055,
-0.5198966860771179,
0.6173062920570374,
0.3728589713573456,
-0.4968147873878479,
0.3270541727542877,
0.3615801930427551,
0.07435811311006546,
-0.11039887368679047,
0.6675894856452942,
0.15406061708927155,
-0.3632045388221741,
0.30494338274002075,
0.2114349901676178,
-0.5699582099914551,
-0.5319150686264038,
-0.24023477733135223,
0.3251839280128479,
-0.6670070886611938,
0.15897423028945923,
-0.712026059627533,
0.017514873296022415,
-0.5018844604492188,
-0.26194825768470764,
-0.5620469450950623,
-0.5864349603652954,
-0.22337742149829865,
0.016815733164548874,
0.12183834612369537,
1.0388518571853638,
-0.023482928052544594,
-0.14250442385673523,
-0.755429208278656,
0.1155586838722229,
0.18884065747261047,
0.43229901790618896,
0.21985319256782532,
-0.36630621552467346,
-0.44500282406806946,
-0.09784591197967529,
-0.24732635915279388,
-1.2023108005523682,
0.36127105355262756,
0.237261563539505,
0.4847252368927002,
0.7833914160728455,
0.01733461394906044,
0.488019734621048,
-0.6365199685096741,
0.9582415819168091,
-0.23904752731323242,
-1.0573800802230835,
0.12622471153736115,
-0.29853758215904236,
0.1734471321105957,
0.8151075839996338,
0.24075815081596375,
-0.9824278354644775,
-0.13185173273086548,
-0.36565130949020386,
-1.0166112184524536,
0.6541903018951416,
0.2707445025444031,
0.41012459993362427,
-0.05623628944158554,
0.32135993242263794,
0.25478309392929077,
0.23274530470371246,
-0.2907518148422241,
-0.2184181809425354,
-0.24266451597213745,
0.004149485845118761,
-0.155443474650383,
-0.8536474108695984,
-0.10420925915241241,
-0.15303277969360352,
0.5203661918640137,
0.36724165081977844,
0.7518455982208252,
0.0388663075864315,
-0.4353713393211365,
0.1716126948595047,
0.40650227665901184,
0.9437004327774048,
0.5309309363365173,
-0.7389019727706909,
0.19690202176570892,
0.5179083943367004,
-0.5156158208847046,
0.22786949574947357,
-0.17633016407489777,
0.2700349688529968,
0.44146695733070374,
0.6044798493385315,
0.7925889492034912,
0.12516896426677704,
-0.4754381775856018,
0.5608317255973816,
-0.2809399664402008,
0.09450257569551468,
-0.583842396736145,
-0.37815460562705994,
0.07875793427228928,
-0.0815032422542572,
-0.0053194062784314156,
-0.36952054500579834,
0.20004712045192719,
-0.42088985443115234,
0.12406222522258759,
0.4553215503692627,
-0.4928378760814667,
-0.43146753311157227,
0.18497660756111145,
0.0809120461344719,
-0.10242091119289398,
0.5501171946525574,
-0.13439898192882538,
-0.4167638123035431,
0.24695566296577454,
0.7291537523269653,
1.154187560081482,
-0.030590388923883438,
0.38097044825553894,
0.3815503716468811,
0.23878583312034607,
0.048365529626607895,
0.24730812013149261,
-0.44801265001296997,
-0.5008711218833923,
-0.19236944615840912,
-0.7008746862411499,
-0.3246203064918518,
0.3767819404602051,
-0.8661051988601685,
0.32764893770217896,
-0.5800866484642029,
-0.22377927601337433,
-0.5600012540817261,
0.32185208797454834,
-0.849541425704956,
0.0756855383515358,
0.44372743368148804,
1.0267974138259888,
-1.0023804903030396,
0.5649383664131165,
1.324486255645752,
0.052165135741233826,
-0.37435176968574524,
0.02050640620291233,
-0.16570770740509033,
-0.36267364025115967,
0.40524977445602417,
0.4275965690612793,
-0.0417938269674778,
-0.37472474575042725,
-0.033443205058574677,
-1.116127610206604,
1.0865418910980225,
0.1529390960931778,
-0.07475253939628601,
0.28970620036125183,
0.2874208986759186,
0.6156708002090454,
-0.2888233959674835,
0.4567733108997345,
0.386622816324234,
0.324393093585968,
-0.1281748116016388,
-0.5041026473045349,
0.44454190135002136,
-0.3065979480743408,
0.31884703040122986,
-0.056884363293647766,
-0.3750523626804352,
0.5617245435714722,
0.5257802605628967,
-0.6446232199668884,
-0.04734603315591812,
0.6930609345436096,
0.3337230086326599,
0.051710791885852814,
0.3553560972213745,
0.7972012162208557,
0.41273272037506104,
0.04073548689484596,
1.3152389526367188,
-0.8884198665618896,
0.34649983048439026,
0.840004563331604,
0.033195026218891144,
0.9160088896751404,
0.34369534254074097,
-0.1269407719373703,
0.6199601292610168,
0.6704477667808533,
0.21239930391311646,
0.8517528772354126,
0.11631710827350616,
-0.5149840116500854,
-0.025830259546637535,
-0.4788510203361511,
-0.6646848320960999,
0.5509561896324158,
0.4265539348125458,
-0.2262336164712906,
-0.5949406027793884,
-0.34933164715766907,
0.05623137205839157,
-0.40274155139923096,
0.09582079201936722,
0.6118085384368896,
0.18513262271881104,
-0.3839966952800751,
0.7686017155647278,
0.7967340350151062,
0.527199387550354,
-0.4186382591724396,
0.11782433092594147,
-0.11558715999126434,
-0.010368444956839085,
-0.01509988121688366,
-0.40821346640586853,
0.7163366675376892,
-0.014664354734122753,
0.2904491126537323,
0.06739919632673264,
0.774662435054779,
-0.21603873372077942,
-0.4810713529586792,
0.14990529417991638,
0.41787588596343994,
0.24490618705749512,
-0.026941603049635887,
-0.6001701951026917,
-0.2191728949546814,
-0.35883262753486633,
-0.364215224981308,
0.20523075759410858,
0.3301387429237366,
-0.09023977071046829,
0.4217643141746521,
0.5875601768493652,
0.21114905178546906,
0.05231085419654846,
-0.15308862924575806,
0.6433723568916321,
-0.5786877274513245,
-0.4746125340461731,
-0.8540215492248535,
0.37979066371917725,
0.2745637595653534,
-0.36757951974868774,
0.77691251039505,
0.24209004640579224,
0.42126595973968506,
-0.24491287767887115,
0.48618781566619873,
-0.0009130704565905035,
0.03947942703962326,
-0.43456393480300903,
0.8053354620933533,
-0.7276757955551147,
-0.17502689361572266,
-0.4414899945259094,
-1.2226474285125732,
-0.11277955025434494,
0.8069573044776917,
-0.23659643530845642,
-0.23755520582199097,
0.722154438495636,
0.2935905456542969,
-0.10890325158834457,
0.06017402559518814,
0.48249921202659607,
-0.0740971490740776,
0.06892561912536621,
0.1776161789894104,
0.9613113403320312,
-0.15139621496200562,
-0.19419750571250916,
-0.31816214323043823,
-0.16650773584842682,
-0.3717425465583801,
-1.0009335279464722,
-1.0090957880020142,
-0.6784898638725281,
-0.16868339478969574,
0.020652970299124718,
0.021684393286705017,
1.0539228916168213,
0.41085508465766907,
-1.0986441373825073,
-0.20981907844543457,
0.023730561137199402,
0.059219349175691605,
-0.1490391492843628,
-0.20902720093727112,
0.7395331263542175,
-0.2449120730161667,
-0.4240151047706604,
0.26692429184913635,
0.29245805740356445,
-0.015805013477802277,
-0.25713545083999634,
0.2610357105731964,
-0.32158738374710083,
0.43707430362701416,
0.5547891855239868,
0.1331256777048111,
-0.8598893284797668,
-0.18537242710590363,
-0.3813352584838867,
-0.008979283273220062,
-0.32086387276649475,
0.6101164817810059,
-0.6435237526893616,
0.44786474108695984,
0.9169805645942688,
0.5648491382598877,
0.2965855300426483,
-0.08750653266906738,
0.5308815836906433,
-0.4903607964515686,
0.4303385317325592,
0.040769919753074646,
0.6133055686950684,
0.3548668622970581,
-0.21992313861846924,
0.31285467743873596,
-0.03101380169391632,
-0.27697497606277466,
-0.7823210954666138,
-0.03539653494954109,
-0.47092506289482117,
-0.2622913718223572,
1.3312207460403442,
-0.547987699508667,
-0.024494295939803123,
-0.3196987807750702,
0.17230696976184845,
0.5636808276176453,
-0.22538580000400543,
1.1004254817962646,
0.8803161978721619,
0.21833740174770355,
0.1834023892879486,
-0.6214432120323181,
0.3991994857788086,
0.5615807175636292,
-0.16140951216220856,
-0.2888329029083252,
0.06780295819044113,
0.2895491421222687,
0.14570359885692596,
0.23471787571907043,
-0.24537871778011322,
-0.03151378035545349,
-0.014937111176550388,
0.031008895486593246,
-0.2968124449253082,
-0.051738787442445755,
-0.7025477886199951,
0.23484350740909576,
0.04928314685821533,
-0.32000645995140076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07766v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07766v1
|
Challenges and Opportunities of NLP for HR Applications: A Discussion Paper
| 2024-05-13T14:09:06 | 2024-05-13T14:09:06 |
Jochen L. Leidner, Mark Stevenson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.1
|
Over the course of the recent decade, tremendous progress has been made in
the areas of machine learning and natural language processing, which opened up
vast areas of potential application use cases, including hiring and human
resource management. We review the use cases for text analytics in the realm of
human resources/personnel management, including actually realized as well as
potential but not yet implemented ones, and we analyze the opportunities and
risks of these.
|
[
-0.14404603838920593,
-0.6693381667137146,
0.4196051061153412,
0.21529027819633484,
0.300309419631958,
0.23414617776870728,
-0.11134746670722961,
-1.005845546722412,
-0.05083392933011055,
0.6491861343383789,
-0.7474481463432312,
-0.24734219908714294,
-0.3522387742996216,
0.306357204914093,
-0.32295218110084534,
0.8276059031486511,
0.051303595304489136,
0.07939106971025467,
-0.33789366483688354,
-0.15673881769180298,
-0.7918424010276794,
-1.0122520923614502,
-1.0648815631866455,
-0.45142996311187744,
0.3355923295021057,
0.45533353090286255,
0.6368969082832336,
0.19725799560546875,
0.9198310971260071,
0.3457297384738922,
-0.06483569741249084,
-0.11614104360342026,
0.1284579485654831,
0.584267258644104,
-0.19541047513484955,
-0.4770526587963104,
-0.5089483261108398,
0.1983238309621811,
0.6836506724357605,
0.8800091743469238,
-0.5979821085929871,
0.38178446888923645,
-0.18435390293598175,
1.1280039548873901,
-0.4129566550254822,
-0.045273635536432266,
-0.7232092618942261,
0.4519394338130951,
-0.5174079537391663,
-0.5131232738494873,
-0.20388394594192505,
-0.11642176657915115,
0.5743159055709839,
-0.19702017307281494,
0.29535800218582153,
0.2665551006793976,
0.39120012521743774,
0.20298413932323456,
-0.26125961542129517,
-0.6077995300292969,
-1.0181865692138672,
1.1826852560043335,
-0.6307419538497925,
0.364925742149353,
0.572106659412384,
0.4636775553226471,
-0.1409929096698761,
-0.6160454154014587,
-0.3881343901157379,
0.03946036100387573,
0.1498614251613617,
-0.0003682399110402912,
-0.2850461006164551,
-0.015305394306778908,
0.2987484037876129,
0.3407830595970154,
-0.7411317825317383,
0.3512093126773834,
-0.34783393144607544,
0.13149884343147278,
0.9712280035018921,
0.7312788367271423,
0.42481327056884766,
0.0984206423163414,
-0.05042766407132149,
-0.09024153649806976,
-0.21906712651252747,
-0.06308963149785995,
0.40175312757492065,
0.336672842502594,
0.31127506494522095,
0.6739625930786133,
-0.24298998713493347,
0.8789241909980774,
-0.5712729692459106,
0.20216012001037598,
0.02082463540136814,
-0.3337383568286896,
-0.2763247489929199,
0.07526499032974243,
0.38003554940223694,
0.18771423399448395,
-0.07045315206050873,
-0.2755305767059326,
0.05542191118001938,
0.030970793217420578,
0.6871042251586914,
-0.3123515844345093,
0.2095695585012436,
0.5572112202644348,
-0.6558413505554199,
-0.1392361968755722,
-0.13702750205993652,
-1.082720160484314,
-0.653533399105072,
-0.23943521082401276,
-0.29133090376853943,
-0.1749444305896759,
-0.2769356071949005,
0.11795390397310257,
-0.3235200047492981,
0.7408639788627625,
0.310407817363739,
-1.007886290550232,
0.3629794120788574,
0.6872961521148682,
0.7451184391975403,
-0.3418656885623932,
-0.10924634337425232,
-0.16178438067436218,
-0.08937305957078934,
-0.2232378125190735,
0.6002099514007568,
-0.5368047952651978,
-0.35530364513397217,
0.3796211779117584,
-0.28522634506225586,
-0.13281172513961792,
-0.7652480006217957,
0.8647481799125671,
-0.5312176942825317,
0.2685268223285675,
-0.02524077706038952,
-0.525223970413208,
-0.11678320914506912,
0.41840019822120667,
-0.3821822702884674,
1.0753610134124756,
0.06844659894704819,
-0.5908012390136719,
0.43669164180755615,
-0.9910272359848022,
-0.3717633783817291,
0.11902254074811935,
-0.06751836091279984,
-0.5937321782112122,
-0.01541918609291315,
-0.03672824427485466,
0.2869616448879242,
-0.16789516806602478,
0.10937043279409409,
-0.10658925771713257,
-0.15339826047420502,
0.4362853467464447,
-0.19293411076068878,
1.0586163997650146,
0.3417687714099884,
-0.1834748238325119,
0.13733269274234772,
-0.5852985382080078,
0.12623600661754608,
0.04901716113090515,
-0.4820474684238434,
-0.49490031599998474,
0.4353289008140564,
0.20515921711921692,
0.23712772130966187,
0.03178990259766579,
-0.244439959526062,
0.139535591006279,
-0.21737197041511536,
0.34320276975631714,
0.32122328877449036,
-0.2270505130290985,
0.5103793740272522,
-0.13093514740467072,
1.1095798015594482,
-0.35465699434280396,
0.011958648450672626,
-0.0006559969624504447,
-0.6793664693832397,
-0.4835585355758667,
0.2611503303050995,
0.3223678469657898,
0.9234133362770081,
-0.7188871502876282,
0.3982192277908325,
0.248819500207901,
-0.513144850730896,
-0.3502632975578308,
0.12376654893159866,
-0.08671724051237106,
0.4691246747970581,
0.37946072220802307,
-0.18150140345096588,
-1.0490989685058594,
-0.6690635085105896,
-0.9291397333145142,
-0.304680734872818,
0.07507266104221344,
0.29237788915634155,
0.32507169246673584,
-0.4154462218284607,
1.2076059579849243,
-0.5963344573974609,
-0.4726788401603699,
-0.37726446986198425,
0.007983076386153698,
0.22803255915641785,
0.6886667013168335,
0.4505900740623474,
-1.1195363998413086,
-0.3100138306617737,
-0.024552812799811363,
-0.9306522011756897,
-0.03850432485342026,
-0.2445536106824875,
-0.12303777039051056,
0.20687024295330048,
0.48719221353530884,
-0.49506470561027527,
0.3829169273376465,
0.5193399786949158,
-0.563589334487915,
0.5458688735961914,
-0.18799039721488953,
0.11485619097948074,
-0.7480508685112,
0.2285301834344864,
0.4498399794101715,
-0.3009365499019623,
-1.0297983884811401,
-0.2957233786582947,
-0.24396109580993652,
-0.73675936460495,
-0.2836490273475647,
0.5577178001403809,
-0.33136096596717834,
-0.1105409488081932,
-0.33076953887939453,
-0.060082826763391495,
-0.4741191267967224,
0.11054203659296036,
0.3539036214351654,
0.3777894973754883,
0.21854935586452484,
-0.8120661973953247,
0.21236734092235565,
0.5299724340438843,
-0.305708110332489,
0.7129373550415039,
-0.33331039547920227,
0.05114487558603287,
-0.07690437883138657,
0.03120306320488453,
-0.4297436475753784,
-0.19638414680957794,
-0.0992174744606018,
-0.39742401242256165,
0.23334181308746338,
0.4065764546394348,
-0.20978757739067078,
-0.8860000967979431,
-0.43002867698669434,
0.15978552401065826,
0.459841787815094,
0.014391254633665085,
0.41967377066612244,
0.6320728659629822,
-0.5754408240318298,
-0.6220482587814331,
-1.051285982131958,
0.43184608221054077,
-0.6023598313331604,
-0.25730887055397034,
0.43513792753219604,
0.08386772125959396,
-0.5098950862884521,
-0.0019339581485837698,
0.0012247972190380096,
-0.44458654522895813,
0.41544052958488464,
0.02730811946094036,
0.28249886631965637,
0.06089222431182861,
0.009002715349197388,
-0.2458280473947525,
-0.1274016946554184,
0.22425487637519836,
0.049824729561805725,
0.28510338068008423,
-0.03595491871237755,
-0.17177757620811462,
-0.5336618423461914,
0.5372775793075562,
-0.07829071581363678,
0.1428046077489853,
0.8363958597183228,
0.8060634136199951,
-0.5016087293624878,
-0.029461156576871872,
-0.4659912884235382,
0.05321021378040314,
-0.4279566705226898,
0.4906366765499115,
0.5479663014411926,
-1.057926893234253,
0.4866226613521576,
-0.1392107605934143,
0.0883466824889183,
0.5972275137901306,
0.3424204885959625,
-0.5872713923454285,
0.9132397770881653,
1.1345690488815308,
-0.10581859201192856,
0.76631760597229,
-0.14751146733760834,
0.27656829357147217,
-0.710077702999115,
-0.24337688088417053,
-0.9364153742790222,
-0.29332733154296875,
-0.8293333649635315,
0.11220201849937439,
0.17390108108520508,
0.1854131817817688,
0.13184630870819092,
0.24381113052368164,
-0.6083690524101257,
0.3120594918727875,
0.553596019744873,
-0.2897457778453827,
0.2854078412055969,
-0.09923623502254486,
0.6500462293624878,
-0.5680173635482788,
-0.7506043314933777,
-0.5756245851516724,
0.640616774559021,
0.49282023310661316,
0.430093914270401,
0.13977402448654175,
0.38259148597717285,
0.8258250951766968,
0.2688918709754944,
-0.5554558634757996,
0.35642799735069275,
-0.11575420200824738,
-0.831329345703125,
-0.5080104470252991,
-0.5915359854698181,
-1.080485463142395,
0.17776907980442047,
-0.5832834243774414,
-0.9245631694793701,
0.09144201129674911,
0.26495885848999023,
-0.18437491357326508,
0.40447887778282166,
-0.9008383750915527,
0.7944291830062866,
-0.2508721947669983,
-0.01912483014166355,
-0.09312090277671814,
-0.4871595501899719,
0.30444470047950745,
-0.2922557592391968,
0.21902917325496674,
-0.06455641239881516,
0.07188361883163452,
1.1860243082046509,
-0.20778082311153412,
0.7213858962059021,
-0.1419588029384613,
0.0800153985619545,
0.45167624950408936,
-0.20712321996688843,
0.1841616928577423,
-0.08952663838863373,
-0.5322191119194031,
0.3002675473690033,
-0.013705762103199959,
-0.3280107378959656,
-0.26008129119873047,
0.2277468740940094,
-0.12150464951992035,
-0.5167171359062195,
-0.9250966906547546,
-0.5703264474868774,
-0.5866213440895081,
0.26031816005706787,
-0.18614457547664642,
-0.0499609038233757,
-0.2727227807044983,
0.26306530833244324,
0.1415293961763382,
-0.6664193868637085,
0.7283233404159546,
0.18565703928470612,
-0.11542007327079773,
-0.29498550295829773,
0.6293084025382996,
0.01351303793489933,
-0.17306454479694366,
0.2737593352794647,
0.10903206467628479,
-0.36687231063842773,
-0.5580867528915405,
-0.026712706312537193,
0.10064294934272766,
-0.2551664113998413,
-0.19996976852416992,
-0.48719391226768494,
0.024621998891234398,
-0.35473203659057617,
-0.3470306098461151,
-0.06222982704639435,
-0.18000489473342896,
-0.16644778847694397,
0.2456858605146408,
0.18769989907741547,
0.6708738803863525,
0.09377943724393845,
0.34088462591171265,
-0.756558895111084,
0.08004461228847504,
0.36097267270088196,
0.4173765778541565,
0.06283982843160629,
0.06722065061330795,
-0.5773477554321289,
-0.05216294527053833,
-0.5603181719779968,
-0.7315239310264587,
0.7368953227996826,
-0.0011815337929874659,
0.5902884602546692,
-0.033649127930402756,
-0.12528489530086517,
0.4911440908908844,
-0.4397772252559662,
1.1441203355789185,
0.22981803119182587,
-0.7913670539855957,
0.758813202381134,
-0.4984075129032135,
0.24187929928302765,
0.6391623020172119,
0.4129617512226105,
-0.8410133719444275,
0.0150050800293684,
-0.7932542562484741,
-0.9402889609336853,
1.0561894178390503,
0.4737381935119629,
0.07505091279745102,
0.19615109264850616,
0.4673871099948883,
-0.14237172901630402,
0.5726708173751831,
-0.5282999873161316,
-0.26573437452316284,
0.427091121673584,
-0.011820148676633835,
-0.028655562549829483,
-0.48259350657463074,
0.278700053691864,
-0.42370083928108215,
0.5263039469718933,
0.19198839366436005,
0.41284090280532837,
0.0688193216919899,
0.12521935999393463,
0.15811027586460114,
0.3823663592338562,
0.6344242095947266,
1.0030555725097656,
-0.3421591520309448,
-0.05191684886813164,
0.4474206864833832,
-0.4355848431587219,
-0.24965858459472656,
-0.05425351485610008,
0.17308299243450165,
0.12551717460155487,
0.47553083300590515,
0.5941516757011414,
-0.08002921938896179,
-0.9273659586906433,
0.2400665432214737,
-0.05923394486308098,
-0.39331939816474915,
-0.49451473355293274,
0.03078872337937355,
0.05488838255405426,
0.34304559230804443,
0.764125406742096,
-0.0708649531006813,
0.15835534036159515,
-0.8086161613464355,
-0.12269996851682663,
0.3935573995113373,
-0.6188727617263794,
0.0482809841632843,
0.9495084881782532,
0.14372077584266663,
-0.7713425159454346,
0.6306227445602417,
0.089340440928936,
-0.5180662274360657,
0.6678200364112854,
0.6732232570648193,
0.8182548880577087,
-0.39877739548683167,
0.03717821091413498,
-0.06523590534925461,
0.21764487028121948,
-0.13971638679504395,
0.4405306279659271,
-0.07758444547653198,
-0.6430299282073975,
-0.39227598905563354,
-0.3700385093688965,
-0.8639315366744995,
0.03729616850614548,
-0.6711854338645935,
0.16265884041786194,
-0.15637023746967316,
-0.6002928614616394,
0.12681981921195984,
0.11749682575464249,
-0.6400597095489502,
0.2278698831796646,
-0.03864473104476929,
0.80513995885849,
-0.6431580185890198,
0.4512311816215515,
0.7945945262908936,
-0.20359794795513153,
0.023748811334371567,
-0.26560768485069275,
-0.11818069219589233,
-0.3058009743690491,
0.6406410336494446,
0.020974650979042053,
0.264158695936203,
-0.16893921792507172,
-0.32443347573280334,
-0.17041395604610443,
0.9502307772636414,
0.3027488589286804,
-0.21478271484375,
-0.20263917744159698,
0.20359677076339722,
0.6949523091316223,
-0.11126713454723358,
-0.07457664608955383,
0.6023355722427368,
0.4031834900379181,
-0.7119190692901611,
-0.9094107747077942,
-0.5352948307991028,
-0.01138132531195879,
0.4485500156879425,
0.16551609337329865,
-0.28095489740371704,
0.6106201410293579,
0.14425702393054962,
-0.2503168284893036,
-0.15964239835739136,
0.631632387638092,
0.05248047783970833,
0.6594701409339905,
0.3742494285106659,
0.2950669825077057,
0.8847388029098511,
-0.09711702167987823,
1.207746982574463,
0.2323155254125595,
0.5093340873718262,
0.9328286051750183,
-0.5260177850723267,
0.7089516520500183,
0.4311181306838989,
-0.828876793384552,
0.5897771120071411,
0.5010669827461243,
0.03453419730067253,
0.00911604892462492,
0.06602587550878525,
-0.28061428666114807,
0.014538001269102097,
-0.27828437089920044,
-0.3236505389213562,
0.5381453037261963,
0.6213833093643188,
-0.3212074637413025,
-0.08319514989852905,
0.1481378674507141,
-0.36673516035079956,
0.39236897230148315,
-0.4506579041481018,
0.6909719109535217,
0.21399246156215668,
-0.21141454577445984,
-0.27114757895469666,
0.14786241948604584,
0.8057515025138855,
-0.6228618025779724,
-0.42650678753852844,
0.3102020025253296,
0.04799902066588402,
-0.47312936186790466,
-0.936857283115387,
1.0169092416763306,
0.25545722246170044,
-0.2003839612007141,
-0.7675018906593323,
1.123960018157959,
-0.277008593082428,
-0.12028191238641739,
0.06587909162044525,
0.5804088711738586,
0.008297843858599663,
-0.036182504147291183,
-0.7993358969688416,
-0.2102118730545044,
-0.17174503207206726,
-0.3084764778614044,
0.320125937461853,
0.2866748571395874,
-0.092311792075634,
0.7479750514030457,
0.6240490674972534,
0.46055763959884644,
0.11943268030881882,
-0.14684146642684937,
0.1270546168088913,
-1.240826964378357,
-0.6708081364631653,
-1.0764836072921753,
0.20548897981643677,
-0.40655118227005005,
-0.37573516368865967,
0.8193119168281555,
0.5075326561927795,
0.6379380822181702,
0.035072822123765945,
0.6342043876647949,
-0.27668192982673645,
0.7113686203956604,
-0.5363218188285828,
0.5502181649208069,
-0.24017558991909027,
0.1910703033208847,
-0.4959084391593933,
-0.8870542049407959,
-0.6382530927658081,
0.5150201320648193,
-0.5097004771232605,
0.09190025925636292,
0.6316814422607422,
0.0677110031247139,
0.27672553062438965,
0.1621362715959549,
0.2591829299926758,
-0.46806636452674866,
0.26346975564956665,
-0.033457811921834946,
0.6489150524139404,
-0.33237171173095703,
0.3016912639141083,
-0.13403037190437317,
0.1383141279220581,
-0.2970483601093292,
-0.8783913254737854,
-0.39839839935302734,
-0.7441296577453613,
-0.4585132300853729,
-0.4532683789730072,
-0.19543272256851196,
0.47864654660224915,
0.4627965986728668,
-0.8042510151863098,
-0.3981625437736511,
-0.14197500050067902,
0.3353864550590515,
-0.45480045676231384,
-0.3451232612133026,
0.19743923842906952,
-0.4559025168418884,
-0.6542699933052063,
0.22947536408901215,
0.19731883704662323,
-0.024787530303001404,
-0.2654859125614166,
0.06932241469621658,
-0.6099070310592651,
-0.31696876883506775,
0.7727175354957581,
0.7869328260421753,
-0.16426953673362732,
-0.07367327809333801,
-0.18663255870342255,
-0.029377486556768417,
-0.19364705681800842,
1.244948148727417,
-0.4984704256057739,
0.31814131140708923,
0.3970068693161011,
1.2381337881088257,
0.42275986075401306,
-0.1514756977558136,
0.6391602158546448,
-0.8928717374801636,
0.22080381214618683,
0.5681715607643127,
0.1680017113685608,
0.45698636770248413,
-0.48050153255462646,
1.000308871269226,
0.2858976721763611,
-0.7433581352233887,
-1.1345881223678589,
-0.00022560026263818145,
-0.8783742189407349,
-0.2296651005744934,
0.7540966868400574,
0.5865569710731506,
0.05157459154725075,
-0.3808387219905853,
-0.17646697163581848,
0.2746996581554413,
-0.0905584767460823,
0.7587376832962036,
0.8540878295898438,
-0.7176106572151184,
0.02107456885278225,
-1.20901358127594,
0.7989990711212158,
0.4684365391731262,
-1.0918514728546143,
0.03779606521129608,
0.13556136190891266,
-0.38871556520462036,
0.3004375398159027,
1.0235267877578735,
0.004367901477962732,
-0.014854317530989647,
-0.14133229851722717,
0.17210756242275238,
0.3821008503437042,
-0.03617492690682411,
-0.5227201581001282,
0.1355874389410019,
0.2881580591201782,
0.011257575824856758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07765v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07765v1
|
TANQ: An open domain dataset of table answered questions
| 2024-05-13T14:07:20 | 2024-05-13T14:07:20 |
Mubashara Akhtar, Chenxi Pang, Andreea Marzoca, Yasemin Altun, Julian Martin Eisenschlos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models, potentially augmented with tool usage such as retrieval are
becoming the go-to means of answering questions. Understanding and answering
questions in real-world settings often requires retrieving information from
different sources, processing and aggregating data to extract insights, and
presenting complex findings in form of structured artifacts such as novel
tables, charts, or infographics. In this paper, we introduce TANQ, the first
open domain question answering dataset where the answers require building
tables from information across multiple sources. We release the full source
attribution for every cell in the resulting table and benchmark
state-of-the-art language models in open, oracle, and closed book setups. Our
best-performing baseline, GPT4 reaches an overall F1 score of 29.1, lagging
behind human performance by 19.7 points. We analyse baselines' performance
across different dataset attributes such as different skills required for this
task, including multi-hop reasoning, math operations, and unit conversions. We
further discuss common failures in model-generated answers, suggesting that
TANQ is a complex task with many challenges ahead.
|
[
-0.3961612284183502,
-0.9167085289955139,
0.42232435941696167,
-0.21248656511306763,
0.05736790597438812,
-0.02086789533495903,
0.09339935332536697,
-0.41743600368499756,
-0.5845956206321716,
0.5060895681381226,
-0.5745183229446411,
-0.5373227000236511,
-0.22014710307121277,
-0.07968008518218994,
-0.3459470868110657,
0.8867759108543396,
-0.009181125089526176,
-0.21329428255558014,
-0.4217187166213989,
-0.3280506730079651,
-0.31976091861724854,
-0.4650006592273712,
-0.3984888792037964,
-0.22013892233371735,
0.4670809805393219,
0.6707112193107605,
0.9738981127738953,
0.6132938265800476,
0.5164998769760132,
0.19604870676994324,
0.34669333696365356,
0.15088729560375214,
-0.47545325756073,
0.22177128493785858,
-0.21930819749832153,
-0.613197386264801,
-0.44947949051856995,
0.04742090776562691,
0.4627425968647003,
0.7545160055160522,
-0.1305689513683319,
0.6538872718811035,
-0.34138086438179016,
0.6802842617034912,
-0.4858821630477905,
0.15241606533527374,
-0.5636979937553406,
0.07455503940582275,
-0.20691433548927307,
-0.0889301747083664,
-0.3807348906993866,
-0.7349235415458679,
0.2029781937599182,
-0.6061567068099976,
0.2794691324234009,
0.10799624770879745,
0.7884659767150879,
0.28724607825279236,
-0.4833865165710449,
-0.1421336829662323,
-0.6515233516693115,
0.5500789880752563,
-0.494554728269577,
0.3487207293510437,
0.336496502161026,
0.7646850347518921,
0.11689925193786621,
-0.9038535952568054,
-0.576908528804779,
0.07012935727834702,
-0.19616565108299255,
-0.01768292300403118,
-0.022135181352496147,
-0.11976377665996552,
0.2642669677734375,
0.5577355027198792,
-0.722676157951355,
-0.2798606753349304,
-0.3273991048336029,
-0.09851622581481934,
0.3945700526237488,
0.23394927382469177,
0.3963431715965271,
0.010863183997571468,
-0.31834152340888977,
-0.2414838820695877,
-0.8376754522323608,
0.027308667078614235,
0.08221185207366943,
0.5412248373031616,
0.1377992033958435,
0.7789552807807922,
-0.3454136252403259,
1.095607042312622,
-0.6426709890365601,
0.29344290494918823,
-0.03384207561612129,
-0.6187488436698914,
-0.21968384087085724,
-0.42808035016059875,
0.5581939220428467,
0.22431635856628418,
0.5187666416168213,
-0.34600478410720825,
-0.17236201465129852,
-0.40420305728912354,
0.06225697323679924,
-0.612468421459198,
-0.09471489489078522,
0.5706242918968201,
-0.14183522760868073,
-0.02683027647435665,
0.17604197561740875,
-0.7911223769187927,
-0.4333636164665222,
-0.2360612004995346,
0.4562700092792511,
-0.3603620231151581,
-0.540414571762085,
0.08487314730882645,
-0.08446408063173294,
0.565983772277832,
0.38014906644821167,
-0.438498854637146,
0.6673082113265991,
0.5509504675865173,
0.874038577079773,
-0.07865141332149506,
-0.044975366443395615,
-0.6160837411880493,
0.05778870731592178,
-0.27941474318504333,
0.7150943875312805,
-0.342812180519104,
-0.16083887219429016,
0.03684861958026886,
-0.2403249442577362,
0.08509122580289841,
-0.5348106622695923,
0.3634101152420044,
-0.8610137701034546,
0.48354265093803406,
-0.49474605917930603,
-0.528038740158081,
-0.06316174566745758,
0.3023717403411865,
-1,
1.0002737045288086,
0.5520135164260864,
-0.7476363778114319,
0.15603111684322357,
-0.9405257701873779,
-0.14519068598747253,
0.2503630220890045,
-0.10409911721944809,
-0.13882708549499512,
-0.10916091501712799,
0.21650056540966034,
0.32322126626968384,
-0.8271282315254211,
0.0031040303874760866,
0.05262128636240959,
-0.2218867540359497,
0.47515904903411865,
-0.17092597484588623,
0.6091442704200745,
0.4769575595855713,
0.11520052701234818,
-0.17170026898384094,
-0.6673135161399841,
0.6232510209083557,
0.20061515271663666,
-0.2728412449359894,
-0.1938297301530838,
-0.29666200280189514,
0.02532953768968582,
0.3193950951099396,
0.06153436005115509,
-0.7112559080123901,
0.051952023059129715,
-0.1394699364900589,
0.2559964060783386,
0.44348040223121643,
0.1537366360425949,
0.11721446365118027,
-0.46732404828071594,
0.7264251708984375,
0.041306763887405396,
-0.1932709664106369,
-0.0949883833527565,
-0.47213488817214966,
-0.3068140745162964,
0.05598605424165726,
0.4738718569278717,
0.46584534645080566,
-0.8546831011772156,
-0.32857993245124817,
-0.4464482069015503,
-0.5133325457572937,
-0.7429381608963013,
-0.2368471771478653,
0.6120246052742004,
0.7615881562232971,
0.42776229977607727,
-0.01219140738248825,
-0.2065863013267517,
-0.8413128852844238,
-0.5353249311447144,
-0.18653136491775513,
-0.22106829285621643,
0.5610231757164001,
0.39185070991516113,
0.472053587436676,
1.208533525466919,
-0.7641903162002563,
0.012083697132766247,
-0.09525839239358902,
0.3093843162059784,
0.22296825051307678,
0.15203313529491425,
0.42053139209747314,
-0.9420328736305237,
-0.507443904876709,
0.28179997205734253,
-0.719205915927887,
-0.06344614923000336,
0.23415173590183258,
-0.2786634862422943,
-0.08905638009309769,
0.26608648896217346,
-0.5017169117927551,
0.23697538673877716,
0.11240760236978531,
-0.3767935335636139,
0.6657600998878479,
0.16550810635089874,
0.44276976585388184,
-0.8757902979850769,
0.5606537461280823,
-0.10374558717012405,
-0.33094847202301025,
-0.8495516180992126,
0.31201693415641785,
0.0074219838716089725,
-0.2581188380718231,
-0.5843613147735596,
0.8753252029418945,
-0.3796212375164032,
-0.27460429072380066,
0.2010217010974884,
0.3166561722755432,
0.05217064172029495,
0.51081782579422,
-0.21266292035579681,
1.2805219888687134,
0.23897840082645416,
-0.5719481110572815,
0.6578301191329956,
0.5643212795257568,
-0.511426568031311,
0.3382657468318939,
-0.8159879446029663,
0.3181477189064026,
-0.20153382420539856,
-0.4004271328449249,
-1.2148467302322388,
-0.44431963562965393,
0.0397290363907814,
-0.5535388588905334,
0.04005499929189682,
-0.09544605761766434,
-0.6010218858718872,
-0.35190895199775696,
-0.031221752986311913,
0.46675795316696167,
0.2022586315870285,
-0.3217608630657196,
0.36107760667800903,
0.43552640080451965,
-0.2982516586780548,
-1.066491723060608,
-0.7354784607887268,
-0.27296963334083557,
0.13096313178539276,
-0.6710518002510071,
0.13106341660022736,
0.10284876823425293,
-0.4614993929862976,
0.3595730662345886,
-0.3727455735206604,
-0.41435328125953674,
-0.09743279963731766,
-0.13726763427257538,
0.08940786868333817,
-0.5765186548233032,
0.534791111946106,
-0.42037835717201233,
0.07560016959905624,
-0.06749116629362106,
-0.12895964086055756,
0.4722021818161011,
-0.4264496862888336,
-0.26010823249816895,
0.015476900152862072,
0.39582541584968567,
0.6733658909797668,
-0.4395861029624939,
0.7651231288909912,
0.08614197373390198,
-0.49131810665130615,
-0.1692250370979309,
-0.3268836736679077,
0.040966667234897614,
-0.39012205600738525,
0.5473355650901794,
-0.7662263512611389,
-0.622376561164856,
0.7247641682624817,
0.020652247592806816,
0.40046238899230957,
0.355949729681015,
0.47850850224494934,
0.085098035633564,
0.5587244033813477,
0.5372170805931091,
0.2079131156206131,
0.16931065917015076,
-0.09938430041074753,
0.07427649945020676,
-0.35534927248954773,
-0.2960030436515808,
-0.6667964458465576,
-0.0304665956646204,
-0.2732331454753876,
-0.5063374638557434,
0.38525810837745667,
-0.17786984145641327,
-0.4824785888195038,
0.15866650640964508,
-0.35426416993141174,
0.7545885443687439,
0.7309605479240417,
0.18732436001300812,
0.6154526472091675,
-0.15059694647789001,
-0.02879275195300579,
0.2995758652687073,
-0.5741097331047058,
-0.4839714765548706,
1.2089859247207642,
0.08424758166074753,
0.7754623293876648,
0.3384493887424469,
0.05808638781309128,
0.3702349364757538,
0.4372204542160034,
-0.5323246717453003,
0.5222368836402893,
0.044649604707956314,
-0.8939564824104309,
-0.7366310358047485,
-0.6496740579605103,
-0.703397810459137,
0.3043612837791443,
0.07419147342443466,
-0.4140673875808716,
-0.22598420083522797,
0.040454115718603134,
-0.3439024090766907,
0.2119102030992508,
-0.8542408347129822,
1.1628209352493286,
-0.09837587177753448,
-0.4475868046283722,
0.37631407380104065,
-0.8368490934371948,
0.6101389527320862,
0.03298629820346832,
0.11852879077196121,
-0.2697141468524933,
-0.17887935042381287,
0.5996477007865906,
-0.4667624831199646,
0.2262062430381775,
-0.37906286120414734,
0.06842368841171265,
0.5098630785942078,
0.08631259948015213,
0.054016269743442535,
-0.08767968416213989,
-0.5297908782958984,
-0.3820193409919739,
0.4863881468772888,
-0.48184409737586975,
-0.8989550471305847,
0.43004703521728516,
-1.00848388671875,
-0.4608190059661865,
-0.4179692566394806,
-0.5075579285621643,
-0.6420437693595886,
0.16790737211704254,
0.05506640300154686,
0.5731814503669739,
-0.36080610752105713,
0.16614976525306702,
0.5597975254058838,
-0.19813589751720428,
0.15895968675613403,
0.32765549421310425,
-0.26687127351760864,
-0.22370293736457825,
0.758784830570221,
0.03278354927897453,
0.5262491703033447,
0.4516696035861969,
-0.002436635550111532,
-0.5839748978614807,
-0.29893991351127625,
-0.48032498359680176,
0.2637620270252228,
-0.942482054233551,
-0.5635010004043579,
-0.40353116393089294,
-0.5310808420181274,
-0.18103379011154175,
0.3619125187397003,
-0.17200954258441925,
-0.7155042290687561,
0.1417834311723709,
-0.22728316485881805,
0.3751101493835449,
0.6283147931098938,
0.30966755747795105,
0.23283837735652924,
-0.8045638799667358,
0.5334386825561523,
0.5121959447860718,
0.7710118293762207,
-0.01790977269411087,
-0.1738569736480713,
-0.23030483722686768,
0.21022318303585052,
-0.06467006355524063,
-0.8631882071495056,
0.15756651759147644,
0.4612331688404083,
0.5949848890304565,
-0.20086807012557983,
0.37427589297294617,
0.5107762217521667,
-0.34058642387390137,
0.71878582239151,
-0.10489939153194427,
-0.6618785262107849,
0.4544728398323059,
-0.3070402145385742,
0.5500736832618713,
0.6749777793884277,
0.6125527024269104,
-0.8202447891235352,
-0.12870727479457855,
-0.3121102452278137,
-0.6715824007987976,
0.9966644048690796,
0.24539607763290405,
-0.22512152791023254,
0.2597404420375824,
0.460917204618454,
0.4047161340713501,
0.49111324548721313,
-0.7961379885673523,
-0.3424394130706787,
-0.22893576323986053,
-0.2967081367969513,
0.14828082919120789,
0.032033521682024,
-0.25022438168525696,
-0.07559958845376968,
0.5479496717453003,
-0.16261635720729828,
0.37463414669036865,
0.010244407691061497,
-0.26569968461990356,
-0.31644341349601746,
0.40351229906082153,
0.12394602596759796,
0.8893900513648987,
-0.32489630579948425,
-0.02700188010931015,
-0.3301200866699219,
-0.41858935356140137,
0.12575434148311615,
0.08048044145107269,
0.02689746767282486,
-0.1792353391647339,
0.11294364184141159,
0.5215278267860413,
-0.3471062183380127,
-0.8386403322219849,
0.5354058742523193,
-0.261339396238327,
-0.09584848582744598,
-0.04049496725201607,
0.16999264061450958,
-0.03267550840973854,
-0.15718241035938263,
0.5263668298721313,
-0.2751593589782715,
-0.029340025037527084,
-0.7515061497688293,
0.5009396076202393,
0.31085991859436035,
-0.21208715438842773,
-0.1795547604560852,
0.7771574258804321,
0.10818010568618774,
-0.23342353105545044,
0.8747453093528748,
0.2579164206981659,
-0.17475397884845734,
0.5753389000892639,
0.30073994398117065,
0.5090743899345398,
-0.1703861653804779,
0.5097518563270569,
0.41587597131729126,
0.12613560259342194,
0.18015311658382416,
0.7481050491333008,
-0.053790051490068436,
-0.7391484379768372,
-0.3886893689632416,
-0.5491028428077698,
-0.8264948725700378,
0.24907523393630981,
-0.5849770307540894,
0.14523939788341522,
-0.29385632276535034,
-0.015785066410899162,
0.1093740165233612,
0.025585999712347984,
-0.8336055278778076,
0.3511489927768707,
-0.1675976812839508,
1.0724267959594727,
-0.7690601944923401,
0.6034948825836182,
0.7299098372459412,
-0.7150287628173828,
-0.5958479642868042,
-0.06452982872724533,
-0.156611368060112,
-0.7741058468818665,
0.29886168241500854,
0.06052770838141441,
-0.1259835809469223,
0.360415518283844,
-0.767255425453186,
-0.8908072710037231,
1.0292140245437622,
0.45508790016174316,
0.20627959072589874,
-0.13568107783794403,
0.6859261989593506,
0.5516869425773621,
-0.22938041388988495,
0.42838791012763977,
0.7545632719993591,
0.37147629261016846,
0.3361670672893524,
-0.791070818901062,
0.13910596072673798,
-0.39095574617385864,
-0.25544473528862,
0.2147960662841797,
-0.4869854152202606,
0.8653838038444519,
-0.26566553115844727,
-0.3999764025211334,
0.2216978371143341,
0.48027050495147705,
0.08874215185642242,
0.11571767181158066,
0.2216631919145584,
0.29539158940315247,
0.9731109142303467,
-0.40379783511161804,
0.9840513467788696,
-0.11798840761184692,
0.0719112679362297,
1.2622654438018799,
-0.14760544896125793,
0.8207131028175354,
0.1661691814661026,
-0.3919287621974945,
0.3280585706233978,
0.6214792132377625,
0.3034849762916565,
0.6296656131744385,
0.34633752703666687,
-0.2703416049480438,
-0.10368151217699051,
-0.10264629125595093,
-0.520540177822113,
0.31677737832069397,
0.4486764669418335,
0.10184603929519653,
-0.437836617231369,
-0.0842493548989296,
-0.4044138193130493,
0.19354045391082764,
-0.2225036770105362,
0.6794368028640747,
-0.09593990445137024,
-0.7663560509681702,
0.4827001392841339,
-0.15055547654628754,
-0.1373620480298996,
-0.6032292246818542,
-0.15666353702545166,
-0.4408394396305084,
-0.1094631627202034,
-0.06157216429710388,
-1.2536946535110474,
0.2713623046875,
0.033782172948122025,
-0.039900049567222595,
-0.11350366473197937,
0.3769807815551758,
-0.5430395007133484,
-0.12420886009931564,
-0.23052433133125305,
1.2057067155838013,
0.1552678793668747,
-0.17199814319610596,
-0.37875068187713623,
-0.4539402425289154,
-0.27485206723213196,
-0.30817627906799316,
0.07546142488718033,
0.8270747661590576,
0.031812503933906555,
0.8759592175483704,
0.39953839778900146,
-0.1700097918510437,
0.35468193888664246,
-0.012274245731532574,
0.8548765778541565,
-0.7588066458702087,
-0.3113224506378174,
-0.4269191324710846,
0.672069251537323,
-0.26562029123306274,
-0.416577011346817,
0.3648150861263275,
0.6059421300888062,
0.7189280390739441,
-0.19858165085315704,
0.9268137812614441,
-0.18678535521030426,
0.8999438285827637,
-0.31018969416618347,
0.6524918079376221,
-0.7049670219421387,
0.10944172739982605,
-0.12327321618795395,
-0.7761446237564087,
-0.4844369888305664,
0.15486495196819305,
-0.15673109889030457,
0.021793363615870476,
0.6530889272689819,
0.5864601731300354,
-0.02085825614631176,
0.23851005733013153,
0.3743044137954712,
0.1836729794740677,
0.3383976221084595,
0.6086431741714478,
0.853245198726654,
-0.46647214889526367,
0.8790977001190186,
-0.04871559515595436,
-0.1799342781305313,
0.065824955701828,
-0.5775337815284729,
-0.5600681900978088,
-0.817816436290741,
-0.13982301950454712,
-0.18894629180431366,
0.0863993912935257,
0.6378563642501831,
0.4264739751815796,
-0.94802325963974,
-0.29923203587532043,
0.04125097021460533,
0.30223920941352844,
-0.27469220757484436,
-0.26088935136795044,
0.4558415710926056,
-0.2719118297100067,
-0.5188602805137634,
0.011660376563668251,
-0.06991137564182281,
-0.012190708890557289,
0.06627406179904938,
0.24955002963542938,
-0.37743908166885376,
-0.025126339867711067,
0.2768685519695282,
0.6692198514938354,
-0.49978411197662354,
-0.33022207021713257,
0.30461597442626953,
-0.22219721972942352,
0.35129159688949585,
0.7735738754272461,
-0.8743003606796265,
0.5049360990524292,
0.4987470209598541,
0.8683614134788513,
0.4898965656757355,
0.44036799669265747,
0.8616677522659302,
-1.0985500812530518,
-0.22832630574703217,
0.5254256129264832,
0.04534357786178589,
0.34357067942619324,
-0.20628562569618225,
0.9113579392433167,
-0.14326080679893494,
-0.4812297224998474,
-0.8968112468719482,
0.29502540826797485,
-0.7474140524864197,
-0.2755362093448639,
0.7967492938041687,
-0.13384400308132172,
-0.23463959991931915,
-0.41949698328971863,
-0.06470681726932526,
0.19717246294021606,
-0.156136155128479,
0.4757804572582245,
0.9027432799339294,
-0.29038694500923157,
-0.3911380171775818,
-0.6896094679832458,
0.5961421728134155,
-0.006799755617976189,
-1.0340133905410767,
0.5517732501029968,
0.6104514002799988,
0.1480579525232315,
0.04939918965101242,
0.827167809009552,
-0.32455378770828247,
0.47343316674232483,
0.022325463593006134,
-0.07602627575397491,
-0.2698632776737213,
-0.29740259051322937,
0.04806781932711601,
0.7312419414520264,
0.24867381155490875,
-0.31871989369392395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07764v1
|
LGDE: Local Graph-based Dictionary Expansion
| 2024-05-13T14:07:15 | 2024-05-13T14:07:15 |
Dominik J. Schindler, Sneha Jha, Xixuan Zhang, Kilian Buehling, Annett Heft, Mauricio Barahona
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI, physics.soc-ph
|
Expanding a dictionary of pre-selected keywords is crucial for tasks in
information retrieval, such as database query and online data collection. Here
we propose Local Graph-based Dictionary Expansion (LGDE), a method that uses
tools from manifold learning and network science for the data-driven discovery
of keywords starting from a seed dictionary. At the heart of LGDE lies the
creation of a word similarity graph derived from word embeddings and the
application of local community detection based on graph diffusion to discover
semantic neighbourhoods of pre-defined seed keywords. The diffusion in the
local graph manifold allows the exploration of the complex nonlinear geometry
of word embeddings and can capture word similarities based on paths of semantic
association. We validate our method on a corpus of hate speech-related posts
from Reddit and Gab and show that LGDE enriches the list of keywords and
achieves significantly better performance than threshold methods based on
direct word similarities. We further demonstrate the potential of our method
through a real-world use case from communication science, where LGDE is
evaluated quantitatively on data collected and analysed by domain experts by
expanding a conspiracy-related dictionary.
|
[
-0.5797716975212097,
-1.1007405519485474,
0.47230809926986694,
-0.40719595551490784,
-0.2873011827468872,
0.44524911046028137,
-0.26824134588241577,
-0.26898446679115295,
0.760927677154541,
0.3743777573108673,
-0.3086019456386566,
-0.8246225714683533,
-1.0041148662567139,
-0.11214975267648697,
-0.5653845071792603,
0.6190299987792969,
-0.07915151864290237,
-0.2632763385772705,
-0.11250030994415283,
-0.2182040959596634,
-0.04770134761929512,
-0.4756408929824829,
-0.6757110953330994,
0.18935582041740417,
0.8184176087379456,
0.06822093576192856,
0.48734065890312195,
0.7391130328178406,
0.5642104744911194,
0.26454958319664,
-0.33542531728744507,
0.3630879521369934,
-0.8424105644226074,
0.09105917811393738,
-0.1990661472082138,
-0.22398699820041656,
-0.33951494097709656,
-0.08934275805950165,
0.4752498269081116,
0.919295608997345,
-0.17219701409339905,
-0.002873868215829134,
0.13651655614376068,
0.5165528059005737,
-0.68073570728302,
0.2804790139198303,
-0.6128979325294495,
-0.04227311164140701,
-0.4641932547092438,
-0.009057344868779182,
0.24154911935329437,
-0.5640836954116821,
0.06934067606925964,
-0.5623605251312256,
0.40650489926338196,
-0.3956032693386078,
0.39582014083862305,
-0.1022442951798439,
-0.46765774488449097,
-0.5667585730552673,
-0.2258308231830597,
0.3685351312160492,
-0.40679723024368286,
0.6726596355438232,
0.11212362349033356,
0.13640634715557098,
-0.5141875743865967,
-1.0627787113189697,
-0.6155720949172974,
0.19688916206359863,
0.11228674650192261,
-0.03798139840364456,
-0.1308603286743164,
0.43416544795036316,
0.06545275449752808,
0.3280086815357208,
-0.398251473903656,
0.01210023369640112,
-0.7086666226387024,
-0.2945452332496643,
0.32275545597076416,
-0.20545539259910583,
0.2305063158273697,
-0.1846243441104889,
0.006234662141650915,
0.01255385484546423,
-0.7434483766555786,
-0.17595762014389038,
0.4351610839366913,
0.7099202871322632,
0.043900035321712494,
0.5067161321640015,
-0.31521517038345337,
0.8796272873878479,
-0.08893874287605286,
0.13807223737239838,
0.48798781633377075,
-0.23406991362571716,
-0.12797702848911285,
0.047427840530872345,
0.5147602558135986,
0.49165794253349304,
0.1345759630203247,
-0.5123069286346436,
0.3284004032611847,
0.26573604345321655,
-0.04465680196881294,
-0.8377217650413513,
-0.19490817189216614,
0.060458093881607056,
-0.5721306800842285,
-0.5306584239006042,
-0.1846923828125,
-0.9457013607025146,
-0.8883237242698669,
0.15219935774803162,
0.31341353058815,
-0.2278933823108673,
-0.5348898768424988,
-0.0030699209310114384,
-0.3536452651023865,
-0.2685061991214752,
0.018147680908441544,
-0.2885785698890686,
0.2160504162311554,
0.8619046807289124,
1.1685575246810913,
-0.28108200430870056,
0.07953134179115295,
-0.5783459544181824,
0.0009383332217112184,
-0.41508811712265015,
0.6721457839012146,
-0.7564082145690918,
-0.637679398059845,
0.1802280843257904,
0.19487890601158142,
0.28516364097595215,
-0.6949957013130188,
0.5258700847625732,
-0.6585187315940857,
-0.00569777050986886,
-0.4290035367012024,
-0.7691245675086975,
-0.24544313549995422,
0.03828064724802971,
-0.5940688252449036,
0.9013951420783997,
0.2569439113140106,
-0.9708431959152222,
0.53670734167099,
-0.7153003215789795,
-0.32861328125,
0.13582558929920197,
-0.3403201699256897,
0.06463359296321869,
0.20043782889842987,
0.1262032389640808,
0.5959276556968689,
0.021860217675566673,
-0.04243646562099457,
-0.6413452625274658,
-0.17675097286701202,
-0.506990909576416,
0.04028955101966858,
0.5678561925888062,
0.3458322286605835,
0.000020347417375887744,
0.026132479310035706,
-0.5989681482315063,
-0.13803765177726746,
-0.03236691653728485,
-0.13192935287952423,
-0.7934689521789551,
0.3340284526348114,
-0.6019217371940613,
-0.09447993338108063,
0.2043071687221527,
-0.8917505741119385,
0.37827566266059875,
-0.781085193157196,
0.307157427072525,
0.8053416013717651,
0.2311181277036667,
0.5296119451522827,
-0.1049763634800911,
0.37918922305107117,
0.21664100885391235,
-0.2070111781358719,
0.12588289380073547,
-0.7213309407234192,
-0.32070887088775635,
-0.31291505694389343,
0.1725264936685562,
0.25770699977874756,
-0.7343184351921082,
0.39434176683425903,
-0.6255502104759216,
-0.5121328234672546,
-0.565706193447113,
0.3386617600917816,
-0.28478381037712097,
0.5521138906478882,
0.08827320486307144,
-0.5343199968338013,
-0.42894884943962097,
-0.6658872961997986,
-0.45758089423179626,
0.1791868358850479,
-0.031017813831567764,
0.46140745282173157,
0.044064365327358246,
-0.39097505807876587,
1.205495834350586,
-0.621826708316803,
-0.5264021158218384,
0.012733266688883305,
0.14200709760189056,
0.4845668077468872,
-0.05632869899272919,
0.3619368374347687,
-0.542496383190155,
-0.6073709726333618,
0.23822404444217682,
-0.401812881231308,
-0.14926622807979584,
0.406410276889801,
0.039663445204496384,
-0.3947907090187073,
0.628795862197876,
-0.12520885467529297,
0.46472078561782837,
0.5065524578094482,
-0.2977791726589203,
-0.009810255840420723,
-0.10202619433403015,
0.1297929584980011,
-1.415280818939209,
-0.440826416015625,
-0.13353706896305084,
-0.29397445917129517,
-0.5655673146247864,
0.43110862374305725,
-0.26262539625167847,
-0.08036542683839798,
-0.2820306122303009,
0.5835201144218445,
-0.42467817664146423,
0.0340222492814064,
-0.3815946877002716,
0.8112903833389282,
-0.6666110754013062,
0.06803103536367416,
-0.13528160750865936,
0.7160587906837463,
0.8440535664558411,
-0.5511735677719116,
0.7318055033683777,
-0.15662653744220734,
-0.5624584555625916,
0.09571042656898499,
-0.21383604407310486,
0.2513963580131531,
-0.49760591983795166,
0.21497084200382233,
-0.9406911730766296,
0.11611797660589218,
0.08563405275344849,
-0.39707767963409424,
-0.01710512302815914,
-0.2948710322380066,
-0.420976459980011,
-0.4836843013763428,
-0.14812594652175903,
0.5746802091598511,
0.35386669635772705,
-0.7181001305580139,
0.6065529584884644,
0.6102082133293152,
-0.13947425782680511,
-0.3247075378894806,
-0.07097996026277542,
0.06824988126754761,
-0.28195902705192566,
-0.6809729933738708,
0.15079352259635925,
0.20192140340805054,
-0.4866665005683899,
0.19461563229560852,
0.10915510356426239,
0.08681204169988632,
-0.04942215979099274,
0.2894401252269745,
-0.627156138420105,
0.0466173030436039,
0.17344890534877777,
0.03515156731009483,
0.4334873855113983,
-0.04017654061317444,
-0.5693500638008118,
0.8520806431770325,
0.14626173675060272,
0.046638283878564835,
0.3127053678035736,
0.44442877173423767,
0.11249778419733047,
0.04821731150150299,
0.4180980920791626,
0.5818216800689697,
-0.36066460609436035,
-0.3041212260723114,
-0.18397563695907593,
-0.2779587209224701,
-0.4954151511192322,
0.6393530964851379,
-0.32673379778862,
-1.1691150665283203,
0.5969051122665405,
-0.6186001300811768,
-0.20153583586215973,
0.5163803100585938,
0.486783891916275,
-0.02461870200932026,
0.7677170634269714,
0.6787495017051697,
-0.41530001163482666,
0.4693814218044281,
-0.40930673480033875,
0.36067259311676025,
-0.8060189485549927,
0.29938989877700806,
-0.2546404004096985,
-0.5262976288795471,
-0.9101126194000244,
-0.9956097602844238,
0.3396882116794586,
0.06327478587627411,
0.004734768532216549,
0.24814552068710327,
-0.6340581178665161,
0.4601686894893646,
0.3018537163734436,
0.016018858179450035,
-0.12892645597457886,
0.3601907789707184,
-0.38095805048942566,
-0.10095512866973877,
-0.5466341376304626,
0.2002725601196289,
1.362212061882019,
0.24659308791160583,
0.49317285418510437,
0.21789275109767914,
1.1571736335754395,
0.7148697376251221,
0.39402636885643005,
-0.6994874477386475,
0.5248112082481384,
-0.2730864882469177,
-0.31912869215011597,
-0.11999896168708801,
-0.4923490285873413,
-1.1797677278518677,
-0.0016302925068885088,
0.07339875400066376,
-0.9992029070854187,
0.3870241343975067,
-0.15916605293750763,
-0.07463229447603226,
0.5906087756156921,
-0.4432394504547119,
0.41133809089660645,
-0.021327896043658257,
-0.2781883180141449,
-0.49112218618392944,
-0.11309227347373962,
0.23159922659397125,
-0.22650614380836487,
0.6484505534172058,
0.1449466049671173,
-0.026622239500284195,
1.140348196029663,
-0.42111295461654663,
0.8064185380935669,
-0.3454090356826782,
-0.6097633242607117,
0.3063819110393524,
0.17294080555438995,
0.7639116048812866,
-0.2275122106075287,
0.026459187269210815,
0.37384864687919617,
-0.07751192897558212,
-0.17627514898777008,
-0.7964553833007812,
1.1859571933746338,
-0.497100830078125,
-0.6850306987762451,
-0.16080844402313232,
-0.26711079478263855,
-0.23468448221683502,
0.5114889144897461,
0.053669024258852005,
0.31519943475723267,
0.013405386358499527,
0.1445934921503067,
0.3760569989681244,
-0.038374051451683044,
0.11977023631334305,
0.21352241933345795,
-0.5839216113090515,
-0.6452149748802185,
1.2259968519210815,
0.3196081519126892,
0.14516755938529968,
0.10457169264554977,
0.2858079671859741,
-0.22585484385490417,
-0.30810225009918213,
0.16980428993701935,
0.2357078194618225,
-0.7576132416725159,
-0.04696602374315262,
-0.47280386090278625,
-0.03938780352473259,
-0.6979222893714905,
-0.18958869576454163,
0.05343557521700859,
-0.4210244417190552,
-0.17087554931640625,
-0.31036558747291565,
0.50379878282547,
0.7960436940193176,
-0.33122125267982483,
0.5477290153503418,
-0.34255266189575195,
0.4060269296169281,
-0.03974281623959541,
0.6427358388900757,
-0.17363101243972778,
-0.19230294227600098,
-0.25077101588249207,
0.1100519523024559,
-0.11412085592746735,
-1.2501158714294434,
0.5477918982505798,
0.19520793855190277,
0.2597779333591461,
0.8852679133415222,
0.0003615636669564992,
0.6598345041275024,
-0.4782661497592926,
0.8289384841918945,
0.06029319018125534,
-0.3412073254585266,
0.37303972244262695,
-0.33155423402786255,
-0.29063332080841064,
0.19882027804851532,
0.5586848855018616,
-0.7091695070266724,
-0.38633280992507935,
-0.8748083710670471,
-0.8745411038398743,
-0.047003284096717834,
-0.09191909432411194,
0.1872364729642868,
-0.4348567724227905,
0.6496061086654663,
-0.13853023946285248,
0.04470645636320114,
-0.18237930536270142,
-0.5374033451080322,
-0.018185336142778397,
-0.11489613354206085,
-0.2516874372959137,
-0.0024427969474345446,
-0.2981301248073578,
-0.40104642510414124,
0.3909192681312561,
-0.3967050611972809,
0.47046414017677307,
0.2706088721752167,
0.1149694100022316,
0.2066376507282257,
-0.05137430503964424,
0.35392770171165466,
0.22724875807762146,
-0.3863908350467682,
0.31460702419281006,
0.13334478437900543,
-0.501534104347229,
-0.15724478662014008,
-0.0719103291630745,
0.08160767704248428,
0.127685084939003,
0.20495761930942535,
0.5075165033340454,
-0.27150270342826843,
-0.43129101395606995,
0.6118901968002319,
0.11105363070964813,
-0.2019616663455963,
0.03672192618250847,
0.008382413536310196,
0.054757487028837204,
0.18135496973991394,
0.30017587542533875,
-0.2319370061159134,
0.2989066541194916,
-0.6834078431129456,
0.6331443190574646,
0.8144019842147827,
-0.4616439938545227,
-0.1417289525270462,
0.4393482804298401,
0.26959681510925293,
-0.33777695894241333,
0.10551922023296356,
-0.429452121257782,
-0.6909400224685669,
0.45326390862464905,
0.3913831412792206,
0.8453407287597656,
0.16193272173404694,
0.11534435302019119,
0.4773276448249817,
0.27204594016075134,
0.567298948764801,
0.5240787863731384,
-0.34845420718193054,
-0.9762412905693054,
-0.2633342146873474,
-0.5920992493629456,
0.27434277534484863,
0.13902778923511505,
-0.1840561181306839,
0.2084904909133911,
-0.5779543519020081,
-0.3005417585372925,
-0.413811594247818,
0.3967541754245758,
-0.501787006855011,
0.0848207026720047,
0.03952477499842644,
1.287103295326233,
-0.6003791093826294,
0.8039125204086304,
0.2814960181713104,
-0.07879609614610672,
-0.5858979821205139,
0.016050521284341812,
0.0091587845236063,
-0.9728226661682129,
0.8654660582542419,
-0.2700122892856598,
0.10976150631904602,
0.2985880672931671,
-0.2522864043712616,
-1.120885968208313,
0.9791475534439087,
-0.23709331452846527,
-0.5886551141738892,
-0.005065009463578463,
0.10145988315343857,
0.4224247634410858,
-0.4010170102119446,
0.18548598885536194,
0.3568442761898041,
0.3038366138935089,
-0.008065948262810707,
-0.6211771368980408,
0.07888025790452957,
0.07681756466627121,
-0.19644694030284882,
0.5194964408874512,
-0.2790442407131195,
0.716783881187439,
0.01609676331281662,
-0.4229249358177185,
-0.2697412073612213,
1.1112805604934692,
-0.4777335226535797,
-0.06809977442026138,
0.5580170154571533,
0.6857641339302063,
1.1132400035858154,
0.014854948967695236,
0.9312161803245544,
-0.46641936898231506,
0.5381812453269958,
1.0187182426452637,
-0.15214349329471588,
0.8094381093978882,
0.38975635170936584,
-0.14338786900043488,
0.584672749042511,
0.6739231944084167,
0.1447426974773407,
0.7050325274467468,
0.5069382190704346,
-0.49932220578193665,
0.07436615228652954,
-0.14090847969055176,
-0.38568297028541565,
0.034703679382801056,
0.7183870077133179,
-0.565132737159729,
-0.7633044123649597,
0.004817260894924402,
-0.15544867515563965,
0.05262697488069534,
-0.43308180570602417,
0.8257096409797668,
-0.25005900859832764,
-0.04197942838072777,
0.5522869229316711,
0.08681686222553253,
0.8985657691955566,
-0.4027843475341797,
0.1029951274394989,
-0.3838851749897003,
0.1381826102733612,
-0.13528873026371002,
-0.6151434183120728,
0.20901213586330414,
-0.36395180225372314,
0.12383170425891876,
0.15554110705852509,
0.6802608966827393,
-0.4716137647628784,
-0.42802345752716064,
0.4945036768913269,
0.20663097500801086,
0.1670762598514557,
0.05012360215187073,
-0.39674142003059387,
-0.09837567806243896,
-0.05188468471169472,
0.3291957378387451,
0.27584904432296753,
0.39892154932022095,
-0.2634781002998352,
0.4787164628505707,
0.7383487224578857,
0.8861686587333679,
0.3860589563846588,
0.032177891582250595,
0.8954008221626282,
-0.2440056949853897,
-0.4183286726474762,
-0.5969496369361877,
-0.32144761085510254,
-0.44295793771743774,
0.0402434803545475,
0.8667491674423218,
0.8954726457595825,
1.0001450777053833,
0.3394845426082611,
1.1350703239440918,
-0.2364749163389206,
0.8229756355285645,
-0.15761834383010864,
0.8130255937576294,
-0.5958685278892517,
-0.006929589435458183,
-0.39491668343544006,
-0.7298606038093567,
-0.3595365583896637,
0.6250049471855164,
-0.39356663823127747,
-0.1418939232826233,
0.5193941593170166,
1.140758991241455,
-0.24827221035957336,
-0.3752833902835846,
0.3429256081581116,
0.5510655045509338,
0.7037938237190247,
0.14911486208438873,
0.35557064414024353,
-0.23213732242584229,
0.09464564919471741,
-0.08369839191436768,
-0.46496838331222534,
0.1272117644548416,
-0.9225967526435852,
-0.7145564556121826,
-0.825316309928894,
-0.20093277096748352,
-0.49396565556526184,
0.07910627871751785,
0.7818364500999451,
0.37405791878700256,
-0.56606125831604,
-0.09290948510169983,
-0.2624698579311371,
0.42125311493873596,
-0.13419373333454132,
-0.3197956383228302,
0.45216119289398193,
-0.2337357997894287,
-0.7204446196556091,
0.5999779105186462,
0.12350829690694809,
-0.33250752091407776,
-0.24290354549884796,
-0.1052255630493164,
-0.22266410291194916,
0.31659457087516785,
0.519575297832489,
0.38481247425079346,
-0.5793352723121643,
-0.5121656656265259,
-0.26022231578826904,
0.2897837162017822,
-0.22858664393424988,
0.9070479273796082,
-1.1419163942337036,
0.6586142182350159,
0.7164304256439209,
0.7317094206809998,
0.24036869406700134,
-0.03925180435180664,
0.5550075769424438,
-0.9653575420379639,
0.14680160582065582,
-0.14598999917507172,
0.33640381693840027,
-0.07388831675052643,
-0.26881617307662964,
0.37138551473617554,
0.6379781365394592,
-0.26382938027381897,
-0.7653781175613403,
0.381026029586792,
-0.655404806137085,
-0.33119770884513855,
1.245119571685791,
0.180210679769516,
-0.4054814577102661,
0.04652887582778931,
-0.21195916831493378,
0.1377698928117752,
-0.13232862949371338,
0.807349443435669,
0.6523061990737915,
0.15073393285274506,
-0.088910311460495,
-0.10264259576797485,
0.8679302930831909,
-0.17450888454914093,
-0.4183655381202698,
0.2375948429107666,
0.41786977648735046,
0.4271155297756195,
0.37314292788505554,
0.6713834404945374,
0.18701142072677612,
-0.11904428154230118,
-0.29935187101364136,
-0.2121364176273346,
0.024766001850366592,
-0.09088046848773956,
-0.13789115846157074,
0.5303976535797119,
-0.389324426651001,
-0.1861310601234436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07745v1
|
LlamaTurk: Adapting Open-Source Generative Large Language Models for Low-Resource Language
| 2024-05-13T13:41:59 | 2024-05-13T13:41:59 |
Cagri Toraman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite advancements in English-dominant generative large language models,
further development is needed for low-resource languages to enhance global
accessibility. The primary methods for representing these languages are
monolingual and multilingual pretraining. Monolingual pretraining is expensive
due to hardware requirements, and multilingual models often have uneven
performance across languages. This study explores an alternative solution by
adapting large language models, primarily trained on English, to low-resource
languages. We assess various strategies, including continual training,
instruction fine-tuning, task-specific fine-tuning, and vocabulary extension.
The results show that continual training improves language comprehension, as
reflected in perplexity scores, and task-specific tuning generally enhances
performance of downstream tasks. However, extending the vocabulary shows no
substantial benefits. Additionally, while larger models improve task
performance with few-shot tuning, multilingual models perform worse than their
monolingual counterparts when adapted.
|
[
-0.16432605683803558,
-0.5116918087005615,
0.3564354181289673,
0.3325796127319336,
-0.4829908609390259,
0.1547653079032898,
-0.7933654189109802,
-0.34130778908729553,
0.10493377596139908,
0.3994983434677124,
-0.5306553840637207,
-0.26259738206863403,
-0.5330992341041565,
0.37150508165359497,
-0.01440112479031086,
0.9145514369010925,
-0.19935783743858337,
-0.039063822478055954,
0.021400203928351402,
-0.31730425357818604,
-0.4913150370121002,
-0.5058285593986511,
-0.7736730575561523,
-0.19962656497955322,
0.6006729602813721,
0.6249749660491943,
0.5403633117675781,
0.5971283912658691,
0.3110295534133911,
0.3207510709762573,
0.024381544440984726,
-0.005739286541938782,
-0.7429200410842896,
0.12848033010959625,
-0.2543005347251892,
-0.6085402965545654,
-0.2708800137042999,
-0.17405053973197937,
0.9059593081474304,
0.8327113389968872,
-0.18237031996250153,
0.319174200296402,
0.43302929401397705,
0.5602269768714905,
-0.8299655914306641,
-0.03420468047261238,
-0.7742307186126709,
0.11017901450395584,
-0.3085978031158447,
-0.11219464242458344,
-0.2749336063861847,
0.023976540192961693,
-0.15624378621578217,
-0.8667141795158386,
0.08453817665576935,
-0.1540781408548355,
0.49602001905441284,
0.5554344058036804,
-0.08569430559873581,
-0.29126954078674316,
-0.8973912000656128,
1.0100507736206055,
-0.6610267162322998,
0.4830643832683563,
0.3968779146671295,
0.1507062315940857,
0.11843652278184891,
-0.5145191550254822,
-0.4412650167942047,
-0.6087592244148254,
0.004795461893081665,
0.22738365828990936,
-0.1863880306482315,
0.1574784368276596,
0.2798314094543457,
0.3070617616176605,
-0.4319993257522583,
0.5684070587158203,
-0.28277158737182617,
0.04131126403808594,
0.43225231766700745,
0.11938513815402985,
0.09238790720701218,
0.07534337043762207,
-0.11161955446004868,
0.10809271782636642,
-0.7524589896202087,
0.08815516531467438,
0.43886497616767883,
0.5347284078598022,
-0.3662678599357605,
0.5312013030052185,
-0.2168024480342865,
0.7735874652862549,
-0.13961896300315857,
-0.35406529903411865,
-0.027434462681412697,
-0.4966945946216583,
-0.18711726367473602,
-0.05794141814112663,
0.3789840042591095,
-0.2647596001625061,
0.2820131480693817,
-0.2512427866458893,
-0.06669002026319504,
-0.0575006939470768,
0.1958359032869339,
-0.7108144760131836,
-0.10023685544729233,
-0.06135139241814613,
-0.4392823874950409,
-0.08121529966592789,
-0.4281243681907654,
-0.7393367290496826,
-0.3528628349304199,
-0.24048808217048645,
0.2952624261379242,
-0.3519134223461151,
-0.25997716188430786,
0.2042984962463379,
0.22489918768405914,
0.006311639677733183,
0.43377894163131714,
-1.0952181816101074,
0.2012951374053955,
0.48226913809776306,
1.099738359451294,
-0.08925472944974899,
-0.5470972657203674,
-0.6301597356796265,
0.08210571855306625,
-0.37283629179000854,
0.7558246850967407,
-0.6162398457527161,
-0.41981348395347595,
0.028086649253964424,
0.16886432468891144,
-0.05679810419678688,
-0.5231543779373169,
0.4691428244113922,
-0.27436333894729614,
-0.08116786181926727,
-0.2763523459434509,
-0.04720790311694145,
0.10006044059991837,
0.13073071837425232,
-0.7258967757225037,
0.8403500914573669,
0.2873075008392334,
-0.6822406649589539,
0.2537976801395416,
-1.0076663494110107,
-0.49997150897979736,
0.14869585633277893,
0.21811334788799286,
0.08770178258419037,
0.40524807572364807,
0.18836545944213867,
0.2555997371673584,
-0.34586572647094727,
-0.2860150635242462,
-0.21982023119926453,
-0.4073382616043091,
-0.07102301716804504,
-0.5887070298194885,
0.6721375584602356,
0.2837778329849243,
-0.08327963948249817,
0.06991211324930191,
-0.8654277920722961,
-0.2159833014011383,
0.1570451259613037,
-0.8643390536308289,
-0.42654168605804443,
0.015697956085205078,
-0.006241669412702322,
0.08317392319440842,
0.34593576192855835,
-0.28532925248146057,
0.26369404792785645,
-0.534197211265564,
0.3372315466403961,
0.9574114680290222,
-0.29504963755607605,
0.5882560610771179,
-0.07424592971801758,
0.9552029967308044,
-0.09343863278627396,
-0.0047368681989610195,
-0.19095422327518463,
-0.07812032848596573,
-1.1800748109817505,
-0.37324637174606323,
0.3712611198425293,
0.5907306671142578,
-1.0512775182724,
0.013606523163616657,
-0.46272000670433044,
-0.29764994978904724,
-0.8033487200737,
0.5786445140838623,
0.24116016924381256,
0.2479148954153061,
0.2382696121931076,
-0.2920910120010376,
-0.5999178290367126,
-0.8887344002723694,
-0.21422649919986725,
-0.1441938728094101,
-0.15739914774894714,
0.1242499053478241,
0.4578182101249695,
-0.0538950189948082,
0.24324944615364075,
-0.2936648428440094,
-0.0785413607954979,
-0.3113696277141571,
-0.14697882533073425,
0.26609426736831665,
0.34768733382225037,
0.6238624453544617,
-0.34784135222435,
-0.6372964978218079,
0.34396111965179443,
-0.49199140071868896,
0.07669657468795776,
0.00983511470258236,
-0.0888441726565361,
0.26621368527412415,
0.5006688833236694,
-0.3537921905517578,
0.028154896572232246,
0.9319497346878052,
-0.017848050221800804,
0.5575326085090637,
-0.3228978216648102,
-0.06770879030227661,
-1.1645877361297607,
0.13001002371311188,
-0.13598686456680298,
-0.2203490436077118,
-0.5869182348251343,
0.30710548162460327,
-0.3550844192504883,
-0.3294638991355896,
-0.4246174693107605,
0.633761465549469,
-0.4874771237373352,
0.01505830604583025,
-0.4139106273651123,
0.04105765372514725,
-0.3562067747116089,
0.20445537567138672,
0.0011470166500657797,
1.2456120252609253,
0.5032418966293335,
-0.524411678314209,
0.3590679466724396,
0.00718641048297286,
-0.5412470102310181,
0.5140600204467773,
-0.5173323750495911,
0.3043648302555084,
-0.2287275195121765,
-0.055787064135074615,
-0.7223383188247681,
-0.3056708872318268,
0.05675891786813736,
-0.013711155392229557,
0.2936495542526245,
-0.3483535647392273,
-0.35147973895072937,
-0.22585196793079376,
-0.18216358125209808,
0.39211133122444153,
0.5080764293670654,
-0.7490276098251343,
0.578860878944397,
0.1504831314086914,
-0.4896162450313568,
-0.6494096517562866,
-0.5919785499572754,
0.07720066606998444,
-0.13077965378761292,
-0.4212628901004791,
0.13331007957458496,
-0.14810246229171753,
-0.2931731641292572,
-0.06297656893730164,
-0.0244195107370615,
-0.0464300736784935,
0.32882827520370483,
0.054230500012636185,
-0.10241758078336716,
-0.575355589389801,
0.29732608795166016,
-0.030795302242040634,
-0.10538273304700851,
-0.38127267360687256,
-0.4848358631134033,
0.5955589413642883,
-0.08298437297344208,
-0.24900715053081512,
-0.12291974574327469,
0.4432569742202759,
0.4495006799697876,
-0.2740974724292755,
0.8754736185073853,
0.5463566184043884,
-0.25021892786026,
-0.41769668459892273,
-0.3986871838569641,
-0.03956972435116768,
-0.4989143908023834,
0.710465133190155,
-0.5458463430404663,
-1.145056962966919,
0.3037678897380829,
-0.3051164150238037,
0.10770643502473831,
0.25465166568756104,
0.796165943145752,
-0.16938401758670807,
0.6691420674324036,
1.1434111595153809,
-0.27662864327430725,
0.6376742720603943,
0.02810942567884922,
0.09827151149511337,
-0.6654828190803528,
0.3350837528705597,
-0.6604601740837097,
-0.32461273670196533,
-0.7449287176132202,
-0.4244690239429474,
0.30874696373939514,
0.2840625047683716,
-0.1545283943414688,
0.2159382551908493,
-0.17941825091838837,
0.5118922591209412,
0.42039161920547485,
-0.0959019809961319,
0.3780951201915741,
0.42532819509506226,
-0.031152386218309402,
0.033414870500564575,
-0.9433162212371826,
-0.45947974920272827,
1.151460886001587,
0.2697359323501587,
0.8377004265785217,
0.18739904463291168,
0.5026267766952515,
0.0045381393283605576,
0.49145999550819397,
-0.6850705146789551,
0.2755294442176819,
-0.6490963697433472,
-0.43651703000068665,
-0.3786594271659851,
-0.4051503539085388,
-0.9577544927597046,
0.30497175455093384,
-0.31244394183158875,
-0.6215406656265259,
-0.0878923162817955,
0.34322676062583923,
-0.3726402521133423,
0.22226916253566742,
-0.7798064351081848,
0.8590759634971619,
-0.4028075933456421,
-0.3626900017261505,
-0.5943318605422974,
0.061843112111091614,
0.2492048144340515,
-0.41197335720062256,
0.4741459786891937,
0.040597449988126755,
-0.20527756214141846,
0.7030494809150696,
-0.08930101245641708,
0.7842727303504944,
-0.14940716326236725,
-0.2545202672481537,
0.026495816186070442,
-0.03866629675030708,
0.5393552780151367,
0.05179386958479881,
-0.25365954637527466,
0.174465611577034,
-0.1269528865814209,
-0.7531608939170837,
-0.45108574628829956,
0.8916625380516052,
-0.969805121421814,
-0.835105299949646,
-0.057945121079683304,
-0.6963688731193542,
-0.42671048641204834,
0.15792018175125122,
0.18861833214759827,
-0.11310864984989166,
-0.3084614872932434,
0.13888627290725708,
0.3290688991546631,
-0.39170458912849426,
0.3656708002090454,
0.5097996592521667,
-0.005745705217123032,
-0.37924638390541077,
0.7680938243865967,
0.1065826416015625,
0.36444589495658875,
0.18176285922527313,
0.14613327383995056,
0.022333823144435883,
-0.6375365853309631,
-0.34567707777023315,
0.31358781456947327,
-0.7455494999885559,
0.08774629235267639,
-0.3371906280517578,
0.03775220364332199,
-0.15721707046031952,
-0.18117596209049225,
-0.42833763360977173,
-0.4205254018306732,
-0.36187392473220825,
-0.028681296855211258,
0.2822931706905365,
0.5794751644134521,
-0.15132494270801544,
0.5358357429504395,
-0.5364800691604614,
0.2958841919898987,
0.4600459933280945,
0.5820233821868896,
0.08469359576702118,
-0.870958685874939,
-0.672889232635498,
-0.002719597890973091,
-0.20681816339492798,
-0.4144531190395355,
-0.018271638080477715,
0.4933657944202423,
0.41522806882858276,
0.07963700592517853,
-0.2329198718070984,
0.8223615288734436,
-0.7586477994918823,
0.6803008317947388,
0.3016214966773987,
-0.8186841011047363,
0.4389455020427704,
-0.20810863375663757,
0.5025066137313843,
0.5703482627868652,
0.5405883193016052,
-0.4964364469051361,
-0.016341200098395348,
0.03257255256175995,
-0.6860837340354919,
0.6847546696662903,
-0.05773979052901268,
0.4594469368457794,
0.2754698693752289,
0.3914298713207245,
0.2744055390357971,
0.04442333057522774,
-0.8161447644233704,
0.09625209122896194,
-0.36814942955970764,
-0.22153156995773315,
-0.5485681295394897,
-0.2678731083869934,
-0.10288598388433456,
-0.3410259485244751,
0.6696551442146301,
-0.3590538501739502,
0.1732661873102188,
-0.2226000279188156,
-0.2991436719894409,
-0.25675198435783386,
0.5557189583778381,
0.7004523873329163,
0.6439449787139893,
0.09940707683563232,
0.08036117255687714,
0.5944452285766602,
-0.5576756596565247,
0.3876537084579468,
0.18092034757137299,
-0.025270020589232445,
-0.1256067007780075,
0.5846855640411377,
1.0331026315689087,
0.2307070940732956,
-0.5148229598999023,
0.04742524400353432,
0.15114495158195496,
-0.001650045858696103,
-0.2698393166065216,
0.13967305421829224,
0.3032258450984955,
0.3253919184207916,
0.1924193650484085,
-0.1240159422159195,
-0.2980888783931732,
-0.5115463137626648,
-0.3023442327976227,
0.4508359730243683,
-0.10308058559894562,
-0.4809248149394989,
0.5611287355422974,
0.2849899232387543,
-0.23954270780086517,
0.37844160199165344,
-0.00043681898387148976,
-0.274242103099823,
0.2083740085363388,
0.7322998046875,
0.7195547223091125,
-0.39225006103515625,
0.012876039370894432,
0.4563683271408081,
0.6268984079360962,
-0.1421382576227188,
0.25065016746520996,
-0.09032410383224487,
-0.5892667174339294,
-0.8669260740280151,
-0.932151198387146,
-0.22101256251335144,
0.402057021856308,
-0.34073805809020996,
0.26190122961997986,
-0.5562524795532227,
-0.16472311317920685,
-0.03538265451788902,
-0.059632688760757446,
-0.8954771757125854,
-0.11137371510267258,
0.1691325455904007,
1.0137110948562622,
-0.7674794793128967,
0.9719949960708618,
0.9015988111495972,
-0.3878845274448395,
-0.5550859570503235,
0.048055313527584076,
-0.269702672958374,
-0.8114468455314636,
0.6677426695823669,
-0.1545816957950592,
-0.22841905057430267,
0.22087717056274414,
-0.5253896713256836,
-1.0024487972259521,
0.7801231145858765,
0.9562126994132996,
-0.7285100817680359,
-0.1709698885679245,
0.23131944239139557,
0.5453372597694397,
-0.14301979541778564,
-0.19471803307533264,
0.3728219270706177,
0.3694542944431305,
-0.3872753083705902,
-1.0839112997055054,
-0.07181935757398605,
-0.054032545536756516,
0.2988151013851166,
0.004738076124340296,
-0.5673050284385681,
0.7462145090103149,
-0.05238693952560425,
-0.37320077419281006,
0.31897661089897156,
0.5849200487136841,
-0.0004987919819541276,
-0.2035580724477768,
0.46573686599731445,
0.611322820186615,
0.6593998074531555,
0.08683362603187561,
1.055537223815918,
-0.3392757177352905,
0.25623610615730286,
0.9797458648681641,
-0.26330825686454773,
0.9926758408546448,
0.5411319732666016,
-0.4245718717575073,
0.4659298062324524,
0.2903825342655182,
0.20479896664619446,
0.5680810809135437,
0.13770122826099396,
-0.4420335292816162,
-0.43004217743873596,
-0.2606617510318756,
-0.2766394317150116,
0.596419632434845,
0.3383084237575531,
-0.11261346191167831,
-0.3442060649394989,
0.3557332456111908,
-0.10662800073623657,
0.09057370573282242,
-0.5708456635475159,
0.7101632952690125,
0.20157727599143982,
-0.6401313543319702,
1.1525989770889282,
0.12047690898180008,
0.8564971089363098,
-0.5880131125450134,
0.16487281024456024,
-0.33496230840682983,
0.24239563941955566,
-0.097849540412426,
-0.36285656690597534,
0.20574618875980377,
0.3022935390472412,
-0.2763664424419403,
-0.06721853464841843,
0.6461491584777832,
-0.31024783849716187,
-0.6145034432411194,
0.3332178294658661,
0.46732059121131897,
-0.039121270179748535,
0.18517489731311798,
-0.6132287979125977,
0.21317480504512787,
-0.1253189891576767,
-0.06726860255002975,
0.4799911379814148,
0.32776275277137756,
0.0933319628238678,
0.6008586883544922,
0.8336611986160278,
0.31366419792175293,
0.029235903173685074,
0.03574995696544647,
0.7821014523506165,
-0.4150815010070801,
-0.5006378889083862,
-0.7979545593261719,
0.41441482305526733,
0.2735104560852051,
-0.2822156250476837,
0.5648813843727112,
0.3154292106628418,
1.0505387783050537,
-0.3461090624332428,
0.9423359036445618,
0.17471431195735931,
0.3063545823097229,
-0.7943565845489502,
0.6243270039558411,
-0.7593303322792053,
0.04955390840768814,
-0.044759318232536316,
-0.9526093602180481,
-0.13506504893302917,
0.7039133906364441,
-0.29230818152427673,
-0.05461180582642555,
0.5905186533927917,
0.5611863732337952,
-0.3077247440814972,
-0.4070500433444977,
0.4223406910896301,
0.4329679012298584,
0.04974702373147011,
0.6793376803398132,
0.818952202796936,
0.0030300593934953213,
0.5430765151977539,
-0.17121706902980804,
-0.28235530853271484,
-0.1878122091293335,
-0.8526481986045837,
-0.8811463713645935,
-0.5675568580627441,
-0.025996757671236992,
-0.18373744189739227,
0.18761737644672394,
0.9600023031234741,
0.7352349162101746,
-0.8009873628616333,
-0.3871486485004425,
0.09383787959814072,
-0.0944368839263916,
-0.16488893330097198,
-0.09875756502151489,
0.09074269980192184,
-0.5785946846008301,
-0.5568907260894775,
0.6038291454315186,
0.35378095507621765,
-0.08153426647186279,
-0.3045300543308258,
-0.19151359796524048,
-0.058963995426893234,
0.06639725714921951,
0.9033381938934326,
0.4491366446018219,
-0.7029541730880737,
-0.3661661446094513,
0.030768366530537605,
0.1329665631055832,
0.13005143404006958,
0.8179100751876831,
-0.5554698705673218,
0.4508447051048279,
0.07919175177812576,
0.8400160074234009,
0.42943909764289856,
-0.21053455770015717,
0.4443894624710083,
-0.8164748549461365,
0.7259107232093811,
0.1500512957572937,
0.3258286118507385,
0.4448659121990204,
-0.16854102909564972,
0.3758375942707062,
0.11224495619535446,
-0.26730096340179443,
-0.9019442796707153,
0.46954071521759033,
-0.5209587812423706,
-0.25934335589408875,
1.1005887985229492,
-0.1604236364364624,
-0.14180299639701843,
-0.056634847074747086,
-0.08827100694179535,
0.17740532755851746,
0.02629527822136879,
0.8001834750175476,
0.8565833568572998,
0.1522580236196518,
-0.4074694514274597,
-0.7994006276130676,
0.5035740733146667,
0.42807671427726746,
-0.9145150780677795,
0.16195230185985565,
0.30569690465927124,
0.4000798463821411,
0.16195951402187347,
0.7419044375419617,
0.162872314453125,
0.2793687582015991,
0.011578967794775963,
-0.08351951837539673,
0.05883798375725746,
-0.2055288553237915,
-0.6621073484420776,
0.027334189042448997,
0.7093716263771057,
0.02234840765595436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07730v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07730v1
|
Does Dependency Locality Predict Non-canonical Word Order in Hindi?
| 2024-05-13T13:24:17 | 2024-05-13T13:24:17 |
Sidharth Ranjan, Marten van Schijndel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous work has shown that isolated non-canonical sentences with
Object-before-Subject (OSV) order are initially harder to process than their
canonical counterparts with Subject-before-Object (SOV) order. Although this
difficulty diminishes with appropriate discourse context, the underlying
cognitive factors responsible for alleviating processing challenges in OSV
sentences remain a question. In this work, we test the hypothesis that
dependency length minimization is a significant predictor of non-canonical
(OSV) syntactic choices, especially when controlling for information status
such as givenness and surprisal measures. We extract sentences from the
Hindi-Urdu Treebank corpus (HUTB) that contain clearly-defined subjects and
objects, systematically permute the preverbal constituents of those sentences,
and deploy a classifier to distinguish between original corpus sentences and
artificially generated alternatives. The classifier leverages various
discourse-based and cognitive features, including dependency length, surprisal,
and information status, to inform its predictions. Our results suggest that,
although there exists a preference for minimizing dependency length in
non-canonical corpus sentences amidst the generated variants, this factor does
not significantly contribute in identifying corpus sentences above and beyond
surprisal and givenness measures. Notably, discourse predictability emerges as
the primary determinant of constituent-order preferences. These findings are
further supported by human evaluations involving 44 native Hindi speakers.
Overall, this work sheds light on the role of expectation adaptation in
word-ordering decisions. We conclude by situating our results within the
theories of discourse production and information locality.
|
[
-0.37776318192481995,
-0.6053686141967773,
0.47686633467674255,
0.23567673563957214,
-0.2455570548772812,
-0.003436504630371928,
-0.2250289022922516,
-0.6734771132469177,
0.4360453486442566,
0.26121506094932556,
-0.29913440346717834,
-0.18400198221206665,
-0.8010922074317932,
0.36997663974761963,
-0.1556892842054367,
0.6326132416725159,
0.05912495404481888,
-0.11709682643413544,
-0.3050852119922638,
-0.08282620459794998,
-0.6019526124000549,
-0.5523653030395508,
0.02122744731605053,
-0.03755640983581543,
0.3290752172470093,
0.5942448973655701,
0.8993053436279297,
0.7768225073814392,
0.38795772194862366,
0.33045926690101624,
-0.207721546292305,
-0.1936662197113037,
-0.1386994570493698,
0.1595395803451538,
-0.12003076076507568,
-0.8390371203422546,
-0.046321410685777664,
-0.2792758345603943,
0.6815981864929199,
0.8063864707946777,
-0.17658308148384094,
0.19091621041297913,
0.11347741633653641,
0.7159270644187927,
-1.0265151262283325,
0.15209707617759705,
-0.549748420715332,
0.013222848065197468,
-0.5570790767669678,
-0.19391140341758728,
-0.6483208537101746,
-0.28407272696495056,
0.23090168833732605,
-0.3551124930381775,
0.07583736628293991,
0.13537396490573883,
1.164046287536621,
0.3228946328163147,
-0.26086893677711487,
-0.037081945687532425,
-0.8537771105766296,
0.7810240983963013,
-0.4082522392272949,
0.6332831978797913,
0.5905832648277283,
0.05147193744778633,
-0.1882011592388153,
-0.039779242128133774,
-0.3189345896244049,
-0.26812106370925903,
-0.6096842288970947,
0.22549574077129364,
-0.025811173021793365,
0.3148985803127289,
0.1981876939535141,
0.3735857605934143,
-0.51273512840271,
0.09994252026081085,
-0.7595654726028442,
-0.10332822054624557,
-0.0002633389667607844,
0.04915481060743332,
0.25430870056152344,
-0.802301824092865,
-0.3547477126121521,
0.20540982484817505,
-0.7284846305847168,
0.278860867023468,
0.22768758237361908,
0.502741813659668,
0.05723397433757782,
0.6820732951164246,
-0.4743697941303253,
0.6383684873580933,
0.3717721700668335,
-0.21460877358913422,
0.187043696641922,
-0.5229306817054749,
-0.1375439316034317,
0.6677157282829285,
0.7390398383140564,
-0.20321373641490936,
-0.07572679221630096,
0.11664636433124542,
0.266143798828125,
0.13796953856945038,
0.13636967539787292,
-0.5552513599395752,
-0.010360351763665676,
-0.11668110638856888,
-0.43374907970428467,
0.003056266577914357,
0.12171609699726105,
-0.6509089469909668,
-0.08073597401380539,
-0.2918379306793213,
-0.04983045905828476,
-0.5943124294281006,
-0.2712600529193878,
-0.34290704131126404,
0.39709171652793884,
0.3884880542755127,
0.07693306356668472,
-1.1649284362792969,
0.39313805103302,
0.366923987865448,
0.9447957873344421,
-0.24497543275356293,
-0.3278913199901581,
-0.4248260259628296,
0.39237841963768005,
-0.634214460849762,
1.0503519773483276,
-0.7657855153083801,
-0.49611639976501465,
-0.28242364525794983,
-0.235043004155159,
-0.08326239883899689,
-0.4992976784706116,
0.41354677081108093,
-0.17468339204788208,
0.007970950566232204,
-0.3397626280784607,
-0.16674922406673431,
-0.10770461708307266,
-0.301295667886734,
-0.2927689552307129,
0.8666220307350159,
0.23923347890377045,
-0.9017061591148376,
0.6165812611579895,
-0.2692985236644745,
-0.9091431498527527,
0.19816401600837708,
-0.3587202727794647,
-0.106172576546669,
0.31090569496154785,
0.005013758782297373,
0.2895996868610382,
-0.19770540297031403,
0.4490668773651123,
-0.1563606560230255,
-0.2547478973865509,
-0.035614024847745895,
0.0018194385338574648,
0.3876184821128845,
0.19742798805236816,
-0.26882126927375793,
0.15761950612068176,
-0.6121369004249573,
0.11127610504627228,
-0.31232550740242004,
-0.2648772597312927,
-0.4972440302371979,
0.04302089288830757,
-0.15488404035568237,
0.02532852068543434,
0.1748439222574234,
-0.6742478609085083,
-0.15091219544410706,
-0.8144746422767639,
0.19313111901283264,
1.0877842903137207,
0.007765188813209534,
0.645398736000061,
0.022549953311681747,
0.708189070224762,
0.1420779526233673,
0.4040890336036682,
0.18909528851509094,
-0.4051670730113983,
-0.6630750298500061,
-0.06151795759797096,
0.4285075068473816,
0.5003225207328796,
-0.5376560688018799,
0.09856201708316803,
-0.3342365324497223,
-0.3409897983074188,
-0.21194575726985931,
0.09437352418899536,
0.7223031520843506,
0.2896827161312103,
0.15179497003555298,
-0.38601288199424744,
-0.6550705432891846,
-1.169806718826294,
-0.13662998378276825,
-0.5102726221084595,
0.36581793427467346,
0.10531429946422577,
0.11572735011577606,
0.15631112456321716,
1.2830216884613037,
-0.7108296751976013,
-0.28731369972229004,
-0.42528507113456726,
0.2429797351360321,
0.05910271406173706,
0.03869191184639931,
0.4752369821071625,
-0.9407574534416199,
-0.3950236737728119,
-0.0669214203953743,
-0.5102535486221313,
-0.30593109130859375,
0.12858738005161285,
-0.24371568858623505,
0.5122951865196228,
0.3074098825454712,
-0.6114652156829834,
0.649689257144928,
0.3462553918361664,
-0.12619507312774658,
0.593552827835083,
-0.3424334228038788,
-0.04157501831650734,
-1.0972909927368164,
-0.31323158740997314,
-0.2097281664609909,
0.02967357076704502,
-0.5410985946655273,
-0.13639608025550842,
-0.015551953576505184,
0.2799602746963501,
-0.5665308237075806,
0.30679455399513245,
-0.46845948696136475,
-0.3522830009460449,
-0.19146795570850372,
-0.09611454606056213,
-0.3279745876789093,
0.487296998500824,
0.3204185664653778,
0.8014425039291382,
0.34065407514572144,
-0.8091069459915161,
-0.4835992455482483,
0.43242302536964417,
-0.45849278569221497,
0.35232457518577576,
-0.4006511867046356,
-0.19879545271396637,
-0.15431635081768036,
-0.05244249477982521,
-0.9018067121505737,
-0.27536341547966003,
0.15604160726070404,
-0.47094815969467163,
0.21870580315589905,
0.01965515874326229,
-0.7257533669471741,
0.035451486706733704,
0.023495862260460854,
0.3396381735801697,
0.4287087321281433,
-0.12939520180225372,
0.42334264516830444,
0.3378767669200897,
-0.27069827914237976,
-0.4618988633155823,
-0.8368735313415527,
-0.15335476398468018,
-0.08814233541488647,
-0.17939366400241852,
0.2563891112804413,
-0.07091405987739563,
-0.2767240107059479,
-0.015647687017917633,
-0.1953616589307785,
-0.1437804251909256,
-0.12168575823307037,
0.7076963782310486,
0.3072837293148041,
-0.3204890489578247,
0.14355386793613434,
0.25150784850120544,
-0.07582908868789673,
-0.21864265203475952,
0.003244682215154171,
0.2469692975282669,
-0.11040079593658447,
0.03661990538239479,
-0.1378784477710724,
0.14557050168514252,
0.42920544743537903,
-0.09971195459365845,
0.7780528664588928,
0.2097913771867752,
-0.1676722913980484,
0.27234333753585815,
-0.47043415904045105,
0.05889365077018738,
-0.48261210322380066,
0.21487469971179962,
-0.43113452196121216,
-0.8052799105644226,
0.2844527065753937,
0.11279040575027466,
-0.4971543848514557,
0.43467098474502563,
0.42101961374282837,
0.38635918498039246,
0.6091456413269043,
0.6088278889656067,
-0.1465887874364853,
0.6073956489562988,
0.2196802943944931,
0.5429047346115112,
-0.7632952928543091,
0.2286178320646286,
-0.19013656675815582,
0.17409394681453705,
-0.8937473893165588,
-0.13958927989006042,
0.17602930963039398,
0.2837008833885193,
0.04533427581191063,
0.3675157129764557,
-0.5654550790786743,
0.730514407157898,
0.1649113893508911,
-0.09007341414690018,
0.14465296268463135,
-0.17919546365737915,
-0.17583304643630981,
-0.161531463265419,
-0.49797919392585754,
-0.15213356912136078,
0.7805812358856201,
-0.2230718731880188,
0.27586203813552856,
0.25608280301094055,
0.6931254267692566,
0.14903967082500458,
0.1591847538948059,
-0.5364585518836975,
0.6327686309814453,
-0.29810774326324463,
-0.3672056496143341,
-0.1672406643629074,
-0.28948450088500977,
-1.183005452156067,
0.11652716249227524,
-0.004899485036730766,
-0.9386056065559387,
0.30898162722587585,
-0.26116546988487244,
-0.6253863573074341,
-0.03536917269229889,
-0.9013252258300781,
0.478243350982666,
-0.021811697632074356,
-0.3104533851146698,
0.0724242702126503,
-0.7818845510482788,
0.41203898191452026,
0.00714067043736577,
0.2918805778026581,
-0.08679147064685822,
0.10717730224132538,
0.6322289109230042,
-0.5261062383651733,
0.5778208374977112,
0.015221740119159222,
0.36357173323631287,
0.38761022686958313,
0.24740588665008545,
0.0044355145655572414,
-0.046743229031562805,
0.06548019498586655,
0.1319091022014618,
0.08091851323843002,
-0.4528626799583435,
-0.4015693962574005,
0.8589568734169006,
-0.7847291827201843,
-0.9365073442459106,
-0.6267214417457581,
-0.27918800711631775,
-0.3098016381263733,
0.34225547313690186,
0.5313034057617188,
0.26736530661582947,
0.240843266248703,
-0.007925236597657204,
0.41763848066329956,
-0.278531938791275,
0.4683125615119934,
0.3957095146179199,
-0.26879850029945374,
-0.1445235013961792,
0.7770751118659973,
0.6181361675262451,
0.4952428638935089,
0.7328484654426575,
0.40731945633888245,
-0.21464750170707703,
-0.5343202352523804,
-0.28839582204818726,
0.16045628488063812,
-0.7944865822792053,
-0.16011562943458557,
-0.47615382075309753,
-0.3563143312931061,
-0.6465035080909729,
-0.1877945512533188,
-0.38928571343421936,
-0.3419991731643677,
-0.15434041619300842,
-0.39647725224494934,
0.5401210188865662,
1.1106595993041992,
0.10460273176431656,
0.09163566678762436,
-0.5417942404747009,
0.16565191745758057,
-0.037891436368227005,
0.2928105294704437,
-0.08132728189229965,
-0.4113572835922241,
0.04044124856591225,
-0.30642133951187134,
-0.32099059224128723,
-0.7228928208351135,
0.29668688774108887,
0.130736842751503,
0.17363247275352478,
0.44253069162368774,
0.11712504178285599,
0.9476094245910645,
-0.49510228633880615,
0.8388192653656006,
0.20440734922885895,
-0.8029173612594604,
0.915399432182312,
-0.39450812339782715,
0.6079548001289368,
0.672437310218811,
0.17772263288497925,
-0.08406806737184525,
-0.6033697724342346,
-0.5030842423439026,
-1.010778546333313,
0.8648455739021301,
0.40593457221984863,
0.031484175473451614,
-0.38704144954681396,
0.5011901259422302,
0.3830629587173462,
0.10793887823820114,
-0.5369640588760376,
-0.3910386264324188,
0.08464333415031433,
0.3237293064594269,
-0.09833653271198273,
-0.31354862451553345,
0.7753750681877136,
-0.3768504559993744,
0.308849573135376,
0.2747192978858948,
0.3632177710533142,
0.3369814455509186,
-0.14257824420928955,
-0.08499239385128021,
0.5237332582473755,
0.966920018196106,
0.7392186522483826,
-0.28353044390678406,
0.11335725337266922,
0.1754501610994339,
-0.558750331401825,
0.10421299189329147,
-0.23229792714118958,
-0.1996544599533081,
0.25388360023498535,
0.09372428059577942,
0.5657685399055481,
0.30580413341522217,
-0.3534785807132721,
0.3061024248600006,
0.14979232847690582,
0.2124730348587036,
-0.5348824858665466,
-0.13163913786411285,
-0.16363577544689178,
-0.17206460237503052,
0.16832990944385529,
0.4415622651576996,
0.27233320474624634,
-0.5901789665222168,
0.08052670955657959,
-0.02639475092291832,
-0.4067930281162262,
-0.40024179220199585,
0.46437859535217285,
-0.5278823375701904,
-0.2890477478504181,
0.2631857693195343,
-0.5042130351066589,
-0.49756869673728943,
0.407438188791275,
0.33386510610580444,
0.6845798492431641,
-0.5932350754737854,
0.3514295220375061,
0.43490129709243774,
0.06645131856203079,
-0.28266456723213196,
0.06793642044067383,
-0.08368700742721558,
-0.3270014822483063,
-0.4831443727016449,
-0.9817495942115784,
-0.10796496272087097,
-0.14389348030090332,
-0.7941089272499084,
0.4582965672016144,
-0.7482560276985168,
-0.10462342202663422,
-0.03320503979921341,
-0.3586044907569885,
-0.2601792812347412,
0.09171494096517563,
-0.02741810493171215,
0.2263975888490677,
-0.6045607328414917,
0.9373160600662231,
0.3601651191711426,
-0.4974344074726105,
-0.9689909815788269,
0.3005548417568207,
-0.06380754709243774,
-0.43698814511299133,
1.0321191549301147,
0.31055790185928345,
-0.3867018222808838,
-0.33623138070106506,
0.04424554482102394,
-1.3716167211532593,
0.8185853958129883,
0.4493572413921356,
-0.22706687450408936,
0.010838685557246208,
0.37402966618537903,
0.7387579083442688,
-0.07574915140867233,
0.3571333885192871,
0.24099507927894592,
0.3059273958206177,
0.21045587956905365,
-1.060240387916565,
0.12954239547252655,
-0.2174217700958252,
0.47628477215766907,
0.8393014669418335,
-0.6608450412750244,
0.7565248608589172,
-0.19336499273777008,
-0.36265358328819275,
0.12098325788974762,
0.7338458895683289,
0.0011700004106387496,
0.003204294480383396,
0.4398473799228668,
0.3894854187965393,
0.3220984637737274,
0.0946788638830185,
1.1760307550430298,
-0.2063639909029007,
-0.03714003041386604,
1.2202298641204834,
-0.3281567692756653,
1.2597036361694336,
0.7128578424453735,
-0.3597863018512726,
0.9264066815376282,
0.8716344237327576,
0.334343820810318,
0.8412740230560303,
0.2448088526725769,
0.18191103637218475,
0.07728325575590134,
-0.6968864798545837,
-0.22213411331176758,
0.6275373101234436,
0.22033530473709106,
-0.31374502182006836,
0.028210075572133064,
0.2547270953655243,
-0.1706763207912445,
0.12090586870908737,
-0.2645805776119232,
0.7571372389793396,
-0.04092443734407425,
-1.012054204940796,
0.8276171088218689,
-0.12366677820682526,
0.5327238440513611,
-0.5082324147224426,
0.11779028922319412,
-0.07768720388412476,
0.10581439733505249,
-0.3423062562942505,
-0.6061272621154785,
0.5907561779022217,
-0.34770363569259644,
-0.4218713939189911,
-0.3235437273979187,
0.5442682504653931,
-0.0028447993099689484,
-0.4447847604751587,
0.4324460029602051,
0.2882998585700989,
0.1722864955663681,
0.1862642914056778,
-0.2778719663619995,
-0.3714368939399719,
-0.196163147687912,
-0.15231706202030182,
0.8621643781661987,
0.11768573522567749,
-0.3396529257297516,
0.22602081298828125,
0.3725264072418213,
0.21749912202358246,
0.20196832716464996,
-0.14217546582221985,
0.4110552668571472,
-0.40588459372520447,
-0.6557945013046265,
-0.922135591506958,
-0.012627319432795048,
0.30511191487312317,
-0.2241339534521103,
0.6410249471664429,
0.5897420644760132,
0.9985620379447937,
0.025563541799783707,
0.5305063724517822,
-0.20221559703350067,
0.27059322595596313,
-0.39384379982948303,
0.2932363748550415,
-0.3777415454387665,
0.1974032074213028,
-0.38876497745513916,
-0.8386154770851135,
-0.12817321717739105,
0.34506964683532715,
-0.924282431602478,
-0.13343080878257751,
1.0453721284866333,
0.6850780248641968,
-0.03072931431233883,
0.24403823912143707,
0.19442667067050934,
0.26856645941734314,
-0.3949616551399231,
0.6204189658164978,
0.6965495347976685,
-0.15296027064323425,
0.7112542986869812,
-0.47741788625717163,
-0.1232951357960701,
0.052662212401628494,
-0.4156622886657715,
-0.7331917881965637,
-0.9004738926887512,
-0.29851803183555603,
-0.1591549962759018,
0.01270131953060627,
0.8317141532897949,
0.4720178246498108,
-0.6853821277618408,
-0.28898486495018005,
-0.4968148469924927,
0.23653902113437653,
-0.0785541906952858,
-0.3158285915851593,
0.5237936973571777,
-0.20610038936138153,
-0.34973424673080444,
0.01786593347787857,
0.6900219321250916,
-0.20656375586986542,
0.16748881340026855,
0.10304529219865799,
-0.6561208367347717,
0.11201273649930954,
0.5641344785690308,
0.20937587320804596,
-1.1420478820800781,
-0.4610835909843445,
0.10744169354438782,
-0.010399281978607178,
0.6267496943473816,
0.5438063740730286,
-0.7350671291351318,
0.5258990526199341,
0.44855332374572754,
0.19304634630680084,
0.16141961514949799,
-0.08704626560211182,
0.3601149022579193,
-0.8156151175498962,
0.16607807576656342,
-0.14396479725837708,
0.26447775959968567,
0.14831778407096863,
-0.8201021552085876,
0.30981504917144775,
0.05998137965798378,
-0.27980491518974304,
-0.7555240392684937,
0.5851370096206665,
-0.674680233001709,
-0.36307594180107117,
1.3193466663360596,
-0.08773750811815262,
-0.46759122610092163,
-0.21924367547035217,
-0.23178789019584656,
0.26320311427116394,
-0.4308786690235138,
0.7202000617980957,
0.8692540526390076,
-0.48665735125541687,
-0.34479519724845886,
-0.5640419125556946,
0.3967319428920746,
0.759587824344635,
-0.6307687163352966,
0.14543020725250244,
0.042744241654872894,
0.03141561895608902,
0.691362202167511,
0.7044746279716492,
0.03430508077144623,
0.2677401602268219,
-0.3505876660346985,
-0.3408568203449249,
0.3417939841747284,
-0.16343779861927032,
-0.05992085114121437,
0.13770292699337006,
0.25434041023254395,
-0.07504116743803024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07726v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07726v1
|
Quantifying and Optimizing Global Faithfulness in Persona-driven Role-playing
| 2024-05-13T13:21:35 | 2024-05-13T13:21:35 |
Letian Peng, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Persona-driven role-playing (PRP) aims to build AI characters that can
respond to user queries by faithfully sticking with all persona statements.
Unfortunately, existing faithfulness criteria for PRP are limited to
coarse-grained LLM-based scoring without a clear definition or formulation.
This paper presents a pioneering exploration to quantify PRP faithfulness as a
fine-grained and explainable criterion, which also serves as a reliable
reference for optimization. Our criterion first discriminates persona
statements into active and passive constraints by identifying the
query-statement relevance. Then, we incorporate all constraints following the
principle that the AI character's response should be (a) entailed by active
(relevant) constraints and (b) not contradicted by passive (irrelevant)
constraints. We translate this principle mathematically into a novel
Active-Passive-Constraint (APC) score, a constraint-wise sum of natural
language inference (NLI) scores weighted by relevance scores. In practice, we
build the APC scoring system by symbolically distilling small discriminators
from GPT-4 for efficiency. We validate the quality of the APC score against
human evaluation based on example personas with tens of statements, and the
results show a high correlation. We further leverage it as a reward system in
direct preference optimization (DPO) for better AI characters. Our experiments
offer a fine-grained and explainable comparison between existing PRP
techniques, revealing their advantages and limitations. We further find
APC-based DPO to be one of the most competitive techniques for sticking with
all constraints and can be well incorporated with other techniques. We then
extend the scale of the experiments to real persons with hundreds of statements
and reach a consistent conclusion.
|
[
-0.2666153907775879,
-0.47455650568008423,
0.732862114906311,
0.5187234878540039,
-0.14749690890312195,
-0.3077452480792999,
-0.06213187798857689,
-0.2300182431936264,
0.023637110367417336,
0.4401227533817291,
-0.8257132768630981,
-0.3160646855831146,
-0.24234876036643982,
0.3532145917415619,
0.1679711937904358,
0.9201140403747559,
-0.09460991621017456,
-0.010503188706934452,
-0.5347371697425842,
-0.25058332085609436,
-0.31574687361717224,
-0.47112926840782166,
-0.46894127130508423,
-0.28811171650886536,
0.4580806493759155,
0.2842956483364105,
0.8137171268463135,
0.7697877883911133,
0.7800838947296143,
0.18922069668769836,
0.19157446920871735,
0.4336201548576355,
-0.49419835209846497,
0.4028189778327942,
-0.27039140462875366,
-0.6430863738059998,
-0.3778192102909088,
0.32822293043136597,
0.6548475027084351,
0.2893085479736328,
-0.060020964592695236,
0.1316075474023819,
0.18982566893100739,
0.489436537027359,
-0.8245854377746582,
0.3812701106071472,
-0.48244228959083557,
0.1650843471288681,
-0.28736379742622375,
-0.11572843790054321,
-0.41107213497161865,
-0.3255850076675415,
-0.021493230015039444,
-0.8912507891654968,
0.16570045053958893,
-0.07169930636882782,
0.946505606174469,
0.450375497341156,
-0.2890917658805847,
-0.046096980571746826,
-1.0318994522094727,
0.9202685356140137,
-0.4366505444049835,
0.12549221515655518,
0.5421736240386963,
0.22732043266296387,
0.005998830311000347,
-0.3983985185623169,
-0.4962018132209778,
-0.3633924126625061,
0.03417368233203888,
0.30175673961639404,
0.07946453988552094,
0.30790117383003235,
0.2037375420331955,
0.47119995951652527,
-0.4068739414215088,
-0.2819359600543976,
0.23866204917430878,
-0.2030402570962906,
0.8277887105941772,
0.1352153867483139,
0.173929363489151,
0.04924352094531059,
-0.32154059410095215,
-0.12162455171346664,
-0.5899527072906494,
0.1315077245235443,
0.5207783579826355,
0.026565439999103546,
0.1764102727174759,
0.6425700783729553,
0.15039674937725067,
0.5232143402099609,
0.20140112936496735,
-0.25084784626960754,
-0.30758756399154663,
-0.30315354466438293,
0.16978254914283752,
-0.4170258343219757,
0.6435578465461731,
0.10571522265672684,
0.5648662447929382,
-0.2642693519592285,
-0.13297142088413239,
0.22508575022220612,
0.6798135638237,
-0.5656604766845703,
-0.024884963408112526,
-0.05948152765631676,
-0.31694120168685913,
-0.20429067313671112,
0.40326082706451416,
-0.6270399689674377,
-0.2132600098848343,
-0.3168659806251526,
0.26103854179382324,
-0.5467849969863892,
-0.046647053211927414,
-0.23242978751659393,
0.1122908666729927,
0.4044082760810852,
0.19887638092041016,
-0.8027332425117493,
0.36248186230659485,
0.9793325066566467,
0.8906843066215515,
-0.4471970200538635,
-0.5101631879806519,
-0.5555307865142822,
0.25580209493637085,
-0.31948161125183105,
0.7003436088562012,
-0.6365071535110474,
-0.38506558537483215,
-0.10463358461856842,
-0.2092973291873932,
-0.1417367309331894,
-0.563067615032196,
1.1082216501235962,
-0.3821656405925751,
-0.19436106085777283,
-0.4142806828022003,
-0.4673159718513489,
0.3880526125431061,
0.3020640015602112,
-0.5610597133636475,
0.7403724193572998,
0.1645316183567047,
-0.4340783655643463,
0.5386849045753479,
-0.3706965446472168,
-0.39044809341430664,
0.04539645463228226,
-0.16457554697990417,
-0.42163345217704773,
0.47272321581840515,
0.060408733785152435,
0.21842512488365173,
-0.240443155169487,
0.3137954771518707,
-0.3934725821018219,
-0.4402410387992859,
0.342271089553833,
-0.5004769563674927,
0.35358527302742004,
0.16767048835754395,
-0.31786996126174927,
-0.03996735066175461,
-0.35098960995674133,
0.1265287548303604,
0.05001247674226761,
-0.21818482875823975,
-0.19336988031864166,
0.33305415511131287,
-0.3950238525867462,
0.15588639676570892,
0.068778395652771,
-0.4425032436847687,
0.30819499492645264,
-0.3746568262577057,
0.2616429328918457,
0.84653240442276,
0.12558101117610931,
0.3502969443798065,
-0.504366397857666,
0.5133233070373535,
-0.5008569955825806,
0.5589231848716736,
0.10016406327486038,
-0.5078208446502686,
-0.37297093868255615,
-0.47374966740608215,
0.23466353118419647,
0.5326701402664185,
-0.37727537751197815,
0.662709653377533,
-0.22637245059013367,
-0.16703392565250397,
-0.6333854794502258,
-0.07224996387958527,
0.498952716588974,
0.4411293566226959,
0.3454095721244812,
-0.4135923981666565,
-0.18198919296264648,
-1.0888283252716064,
-0.514280378818512,
-0.6341423988342285,
-0.3702471852302551,
0.8455144762992859,
0.335868239402771,
0.005236580967903137,
0.913864254951477,
-0.4540081322193146,
-0.5017129778862,
-0.1876656860113144,
0.012638349086046219,
0.04447770118713379,
0.4282267987728119,
0.2758294343948364,
-0.9839230179786682,
-0.6760620474815369,
-0.3413859009742737,
-0.5093784332275391,
-0.3920046389102936,
-0.3738636076450348,
-0.16991469264030457,
-0.1768224686384201,
-0.045079074800014496,
-0.7315133213996887,
0.5383840203285217,
0.3290501832962036,
-0.38895532488822937,
0.6942918300628662,
-0.19669370353221893,
0.35348865389823914,
-0.4103471338748932,
0.3793303370475769,
0.16530007123947144,
-0.23844632506370544,
-0.3708180785179138,
0.6057420969009399,
-0.08760438114404678,
-0.18471795320510864,
-0.11097324639558792,
0.5059822797775269,
-0.24822762608528137,
-0.07732321321964264,
-0.09820447117090225,
0.02329178899526596,
0.21629838645458221,
0.6411373615264893,
-0.033716339617967606,
0.8339817523956299,
0.21626193821430206,
-0.7099088430404663,
0.2386714220046997,
0.380671888589859,
-0.07378889620304108,
0.6876439452171326,
-0.9199702739715576,
0.2440619170665741,
-0.12183301150798798,
0.28299978375434875,
-0.9963850378990173,
-0.25222399830818176,
0.14134958386421204,
-0.3333210051059723,
0.2787579298019409,
-0.39854663610458374,
-0.41315045952796936,
-0.06971482187509537,
-0.17703290283679962,
0.5070352554321289,
0.5210813879966736,
-0.3036995530128479,
0.5754586458206177,
0.29417920112609863,
0.1746852546930313,
-0.3931891620159149,
-0.5641298294067383,
-0.007801657542586327,
-0.07622160017490387,
-0.7435474991798401,
1.0620683431625366,
-0.17756542563438416,
-0.372376412153244,
-0.1771979182958603,
-0.5353775024414062,
0.04412361606955528,
-0.013209113851189613,
0.11174149811267853,
0.013778445310890675,
0.10732254385948181,
-0.28151005506515503,
-0.10677167773246765,
-0.21682694554328918,
-0.013430221937596798,
-0.10692570358514786,
0.4106500744819641,
-0.2780316472053528,
-0.6466756463050842,
-0.5895795822143555,
0.36787059903144836,
0.5536762475967407,
-0.3244674801826477,
0.6750680208206177,
0.23118528723716736,
-0.061870913952589035,
-0.07976696640253067,
-0.46160319447517395,
-0.19769151508808136,
-0.4155483841896057,
0.06870952248573303,
-0.5182590484619141,
-0.5017168521881104,
0.6573069095611572,
-0.10255995392799377,
0.24522365629673004,
0.40343591570854187,
0.16632181406021118,
0.1771562099456787,
1.3263815641403198,
0.42459243535995483,
0.19689126312732697,
0.2657090723514557,
0.07358714938163757,
-0.057212576270103455,
-0.8364160060882568,
-0.4034116268157959,
-0.4939618408679962,
-0.561174213886261,
-0.5627173185348511,
-0.5920519828796387,
0.3240179419517517,
0.16249176859855652,
-0.29024308919906616,
0.05465684086084366,
-0.5227560997009277,
0.5204113721847534,
0.4109448194503784,
0.0954447016119957,
0.18545082211494446,
-0.4058728814125061,
-0.23312996327877045,
-0.5810602307319641,
-0.1997528076171875,
-0.5449091196060181,
0.9230213165283203,
0.3440263569355011,
0.724966824054718,
0.36922597885131836,
0.6694852709770203,
0.387146532535553,
0.22987893223762512,
-0.735292375087738,
0.6706289052963257,
-0.24775244295597076,
-0.7456021904945374,
-0.2638053894042969,
-0.6426482796669006,
-0.7014432549476624,
0.05627148970961571,
-0.106557697057724,
-0.6522672772407532,
0.04945966228842735,
0.27736154198646545,
-0.2795942425727844,
-0.050896331667900085,
-0.4571533203125,
0.8461607098579407,
-0.40979841351509094,
-0.8746675848960876,
-0.1973748505115509,
-0.7116389870643616,
0.2120102345943451,
0.27119287848472595,
-0.3369525372982025,
-0.15271061658859253,
-0.404547780752182,
0.2620387673377991,
-0.2831271290779114,
0.5781275033950806,
-0.3283722996711731,
0.04154586419463158,
0.218605637550354,
0.3489580750465393,
0.6453126668930054,
0.5766839385032654,
-0.30780738592147827,
-0.0672013983130455,
-0.016411585733294487,
-0.480855256319046,
-0.8133453130722046,
0.8136146664619446,
-0.8920901417732239,
-0.710528552532196,
-0.5738289952278137,
-0.19745983183383942,
-0.5448372960090637,
0.03988334536552429,
0.1061624139547348,
0.04112634435296059,
-0.6620293259620667,
0.11391310393810272,
1.007062554359436,
-0.2849096953868866,
-0.04685486480593681,
0.5515824556350708,
0.11546336859464645,
-0.2736753225326538,
0.8230452537536621,
-0.2174646556377411,
0.11287518590688705,
0.7222791910171509,
0.32909080386161804,
-0.32179027795791626,
-0.4488677978515625,
-0.2222389131784439,
0.3304117023944855,
-0.0679754763841629,
-0.1505589485168457,
-0.25870227813720703,
-0.060658812522888184,
-0.31396010518074036,
-0.0051786345429718494,
-0.5195207595825195,
-0.13618740439414978,
-0.2584896385669708,
0.2536481022834778,
-0.3635649085044861,
0.2654198706150055,
-0.01778108812868595,
0.13894446194171906,
-0.4169360399246216,
0.6868357062339783,
0.5552552938461304,
0.5696468949317932,
-0.2687748074531555,
-0.4960140883922577,
0.22208172082901,
0.18362396955490112,
-0.5820428729057312,
-1.027230978012085,
0.39368581771850586,
0.7072582244873047,
0.7356478571891785,
0.726061224937439,
0.3672284781932831,
0.7774262428283691,
-0.48088693618774414,
0.7026225328445435,
-0.2842830717563629,
-0.9177297353744507,
0.7752892374992371,
-0.4589870274066925,
0.2086409479379654,
1.0474852323532104,
0.4240991175174713,
-0.5222943425178528,
-0.28224170207977295,
-0.6433171629905701,
-0.7724567651748657,
0.8885571956634521,
0.5323901772499084,
0.17817185819149017,
0.004251543898135424,
1.0595000982284546,
0.07491046190261841,
0.22491039335727692,
-0.8638118505477905,
-0.32231828570365906,
-0.19228851795196533,
-0.18010182678699493,
0.08499761670827866,
-0.13947439193725586,
-0.2242806851863861,
-0.17796124517917633,
0.7857235670089722,
-0.2689869701862335,
0.4903154969215393,
0.38717374205589294,
0.11631108820438385,
-0.14284542202949524,
-0.004744390025734901,
0.5308489799499512,
0.7265269160270691,
-0.2657352685928345,
0.0011129728518426418,
-0.2913813889026642,
-0.5362116098403931,
0.10661313682794571,
0.1453605443239212,
-0.35984665155410767,
-0.15881165862083435,
0.39076754450798035,
0.5591074228286743,
-0.020232370123267174,
-0.6074689030647278,
0.6302781701087952,
-0.2820683717727661,
-0.04836497828364372,
-0.20505240559577942,
0.28703829646110535,
-0.4985635578632355,
-0.06115686148405075,
0.4634455144405365,
0.29092004895210266,
0.01086159236729145,
-0.7067626714706421,
0.33516302704811096,
0.6219418048858643,
-0.5379424095153809,
-0.5168236494064331,
0.755841851234436,
0.2643764317035675,
-0.5315316319465637,
0.7424655556678772,
-0.2675592005252838,
-0.31112363934516907,
0.5265336632728577,
0.4702291786670685,
0.882591724395752,
-0.3828323483467102,
0.5987512469291687,
0.25698208808898926,
0.27891087532043457,
-0.33474186062812805,
0.013668411411345005,
-0.1939457207918167,
-0.6868593692779541,
-0.48778441548347473,
-0.638719379901886,
-0.5141512751579285,
0.16372166574001312,
-0.7191770076751709,
0.21390721201896667,
-0.5577040910720825,
-0.18584910035133362,
-0.15115508437156677,
0.4417746663093567,
-0.5574350357055664,
-0.010853245854377747,
-0.06332942098379135,
0.5985135436058044,
-0.6815201640129089,
0.5393614172935486,
0.7140061259269714,
-0.3439270555973053,
-0.6088401079177856,
0.543806254863739,
-0.02498076856136322,
-0.8718727231025696,
0.18061695992946625,
0.0995866060256958,
0.24587003886699677,
-0.1780821979045868,
-0.4185766875743866,
-0.620276153087616,
0.8586116433143616,
0.7302355170249939,
-0.3463190793991089,
-0.20791581273078918,
0.2556821405887604,
0.7525203227996826,
-0.3335684537887573,
0.2131735384464264,
0.37242403626441956,
0.6506392359733582,
0.10593570023775101,
-0.6701159477233887,
-0.007465810049325228,
-0.25245919823646545,
-0.07624683529138565,
0.2778562307357788,
-1.0061614513397217,
0.3855072855949402,
-0.0790003165602684,
-0.17731419205665588,
0.09062319248914719,
0.5987240076065063,
0.5580785870552063,
0.44088536500930786,
0.43616944551467896,
0.47433969378471375,
0.4794512093067169,
-0.24285124242305756,
1.0144559144973755,
-0.2508803606033325,
0.1646924912929535,
0.689665675163269,
-0.4452158212661743,
0.41156265139579773,
0.5240383148193359,
-0.31998708844184875,
0.3628888428211212,
0.5603781938552856,
-0.10575423389673233,
0.7644428610801697,
0.3234681785106659,
-0.3708437383174896,
-0.5024940371513367,
-0.30609145760536194,
0.005663341376930475,
0.4701921343803406,
0.0932360365986824,
-0.30244913697242737,
0.2126593291759491,
-0.18842677772045135,
-0.16726574301719666,
0.3702956438064575,
-0.09177516400814056,
0.8439456224441528,
0.033920928835868835,
-1.3214799165725708,
0.19289730489253998,
0.23268231749534607,
0.5029486417770386,
-1.0094798803329468,
-0.09756530821323395,
-0.5092515349388123,
0.37355443835258484,
0.012194942682981491,
-0.5534023642539978,
0.48128804564476013,
-0.05251217633485794,
-0.1794954389333725,
-0.5935133695602417,
0.6580885648727417,
-0.11605983227491379,
-0.2803724408149719,
-0.08642307668924332,
0.33217892050743103,
0.02136441506445408,
-0.2866438329219818,
-0.8436189889907837,
0.0253974050283432,
0.045590925961732864,
-0.2015581876039505,
0.4912632703781128,
0.6089901328086853,
0.1066618338227272,
0.7811133861541748,
0.2921901345252991,
0.2249927967786789,
-0.6256001591682434,
-0.06792961806058884,
0.5946435332298279,
-0.2867021858692169,
-0.5652610659599304,
-0.9320701360702515,
0.355774462223053,
-0.04599255323410034,
-0.6431065797805786,
0.7243447303771973,
0.5877602696418762,
0.4224623143672943,
0.15920396149158478,
0.4644235074520111,
-0.08469127118587494,
0.1500890851020813,
-0.22274544835090637,
0.229350745677948,
-0.4397662878036499,
0.46896544098854065,
-0.47064897418022156,
-1.2381744384765625,
-0.12327171117067337,
0.891275942325592,
-0.1430041640996933,
0.13947856426239014,
0.44839397072792053,
0.46478602290153503,
-0.11398521810770035,
-0.1349935680627823,
0.26599472761154175,
-0.2839137017726898,
0.35672762989997864,
0.6050505042076111,
0.7442116737365723,
-0.19463492929935455,
0.6672730445861816,
-0.34388989210128784,
-0.4958442449569702,
-0.0268943402916193,
-0.830842912197113,
-0.6649551391601562,
-0.6052934527397156,
-0.47560328245162964,
-0.30990347266197205,
0.12594330310821533,
0.5238245725631714,
0.7850894331932068,
-0.5367733836174011,
0.07240591198205948,
-0.49446001648902893,
0.19327418506145477,
-0.7697389125823975,
-0.29480603337287903,
0.20486880838871002,
-0.1282873898744583,
-0.7480387091636658,
0.2856629490852356,
0.2489406168460846,
-0.13242614269256592,
-0.5500452518463135,
-0.2656536400318146,
-0.13895472884178162,
0.46140584349632263,
0.19164538383483887,
0.43525877594947815,
-0.5410459637641907,
-0.22139094769954681,
0.40844735503196716,
0.03334471210837364,
-0.048037782311439514,
1.2769094705581665,
-0.5376051664352417,
0.21881620585918427,
0.31311383843421936,
0.4370465874671936,
0.5629657506942749,
0.4795147180557251,
0.9181416034698486,
-1.1945104598999023,
-0.08602258563041687,
0.9326777458190918,
-0.04918190464377403,
0.18597790598869324,
-0.5408451557159424,
0.539995014667511,
0.2793519198894501,
-0.8251267075538635,
-0.754011869430542,
0.6200605034828186,
-0.8523886799812317,
-0.19809533655643463,
1.2355842590332031,
-0.5108584761619568,
-0.08492783457040787,
-0.07857462763786316,
-0.04030829295516014,
0.05816301330924034,
-0.5150739550590515,
1.0477896928787231,
0.660748302936554,
-0.6496981382369995,
0.009713579900562763,
-0.23924186825752258,
0.8224369883537292,
0.5296090841293335,
-0.6920745372772217,
0.26781609654426575,
0.5712398886680603,
-0.17720700800418854,
0.2242390364408493,
0.5497134327888489,
-0.15005424618721008,
0.13206371665000916,
-0.0422276146709919,
-0.3781012296676636,
-0.15231463313102722,
-0.4756890833377838,
0.01802905835211277,
0.32492998242378235,
0.08093392103910446,
0.04711243510246277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13010v1
|
UCCIX: Irish-eXcellence Large Language Model
| 2024-05-13T13:19:27 | 2024-05-13T13:19:27 |
Khanh-Tung Tran, Barry O'Sullivan, Hoang D. Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has predominantly focused on
high-resource languages, leaving extremely low-resource languages like Irish
with limited representation. This work presents UCCIX, a pioneering effort on
the development of an open-source Irish-based LLM. We propose a novel framework
for continued pre-training of LLMs specifically adapted for extremely
low-resource languages, requiring only a fraction of the textual data typically
needed for training LLMs according to scaling laws. Our model, based on Llama
2-13B, outperforms much larger models on Irish language tasks with up to 12%
performance improvement, showcasing the effectiveness and efficiency of our
approach. We also contribute comprehensive Irish benchmarking datasets,
including IrishQA, a question-answering dataset, and Irish version of MT-bench.
These datasets enable rigorous evaluation and facilitate future research in
Irish LLM systems. Our work aims to preserve and promote the Irish language,
knowledge, and culture of Ireland in the digital era while providing a
framework for adapting LLMs to other indigenous languages.
|
[
-0.05616382881999016,
-0.30083855986595154,
0.5399811267852783,
0.3493513762950897,
-0.043315112590789795,
0.226363867521286,
-0.5332292914390564,
-0.296655535697937,
0.31570738554000854,
0.8645192980766296,
-0.2684503197669983,
-0.568945050239563,
-0.6066382527351379,
0.32526466250419617,
-0.2628954350948334,
0.6889986991882324,
-0.23171687126159668,
0.28508472442626953,
-0.06968224048614502,
-0.301387220621109,
-0.33107778429985046,
-0.503856897354126,
-0.6043685078620911,
-0.5149459838867188,
0.6112714409828186,
0.7330853939056396,
0.41527485847473145,
0.7700788974761963,
0.7242984175682068,
0.21075038611888885,
-0.2136644423007965,
0.07027167081832886,
-0.7877668738365173,
-0.2390879988670349,
-0.23100396990776062,
-0.7301836013793945,
-0.5568585991859436,
0.013111537322402,
0.8640627861022949,
0.9355135560035706,
-0.4358137249946594,
0.36545243859291077,
0.05280812457203865,
0.5157798528671265,
-0.7560707926750183,
0.18360653519630432,
-0.7758103013038635,
-0.004487235564738512,
-0.4061550199985504,
0.11160344630479813,
-0.42476657032966614,
-0.22498099505901337,
-0.3665792644023895,
-0.6520368456840515,
-0.3736831545829773,
0.033499576151371,
0.40077072381973267,
0.029368869960308075,
-0.21404629945755005,
-0.12449322640895844,
-0.5346614122390747,
0.9045668840408325,
-0.7230888605117798,
0.5863443613052368,
0.4305346608161926,
-0.06533080339431763,
-0.279080331325531,
-0.6442376971244812,
-0.5975877046585083,
-0.5229319930076599,
0.3130369484424591,
0.1709020882844925,
-0.09645060449838638,
-0.035317692905664444,
0.06075555086135864,
0.3862292468547821,
-0.5355889797210693,
0.5874840021133423,
-0.3100925087928772,
0.0938391163945198,
0.5349321961402893,
0.29791176319122314,
0.11437828093767166,
0.44086092710494995,
-0.357765793800354,
0.026403071358799934,
-0.9242967963218689,
-0.03182147443294525,
0.3375818729400635,
0.4022560119628906,
-0.29910826683044434,
0.7648478746414185,
-0.3158571124076843,
0.3073281943798065,
-0.2690739035606384,
-0.43355733156204224,
0.15657837688922882,
-0.16679495573043823,
-0.09699202328920364,
0.050272684544324875,
0.6920369267463684,
0.14754700660705566,
0.23899053037166595,
-0.10267414152622223,
-0.2119772583246231,
0.08710984885692596,
-0.07016528397798538,
-0.6493759155273438,
-0.005969097837805748,
-0.19696754217147827,
-0.3991953432559967,
0.05079697445034981,
-0.14525234699249268,
-0.5982697606086731,
0.05286834016442299,
-0.42076000571250916,
0.13124403357505798,
0.040333498269319534,
-0.48248913884162903,
0.3437945544719696,
0.18004654347896576,
0.05648329108953476,
0.5143705010414124,
-0.7037282586097717,
0.3862046003341675,
0.5808620452880859,
0.7853245139122009,
-0.4685422480106354,
-0.355155348777771,
-0.7891570925712585,
0.3398154675960541,
-0.5584677457809448,
0.602587103843689,
-0.8600131869316101,
-0.49896010756492615,
0.11653492599725723,
0.08671651780605316,
0.25422412157058716,
-0.7433830499649048,
0.5964174866676331,
-0.4006507992744446,
-0.30970579385757446,
-0.08820205926895142,
-0.25955280661582947,
0.15921780467033386,
0.1313352882862091,
-0.6639408469200134,
1.1462916135787964,
0.2836782932281494,
-0.4591149687767029,
0.19245153665542603,
-0.8907470703125,
-0.16659636795520782,
0.42006826400756836,
0.07092476636171341,
-0.010939473286271095,
0.33249950408935547,
-0.16016891598701477,
0.35587185621261597,
-0.6747888922691345,
0.08067930489778519,
-0.6185010671615601,
-0.23012009263038635,
-0.037563253194093704,
-0.2169429212808609,
0.91270512342453,
0.4053787589073181,
-0.23275256156921387,
-0.3855208456516266,
-1.0401222705841064,
0.05412561073899269,
0.10563302785158157,
-0.5855797529220581,
-0.4368344247341156,
-0.31390121579170227,
0.09515609592199326,
-0.004040475003421307,
0.37044548988342285,
-0.7317752242088318,
0.14327967166900635,
0.001047119963914156,
0.4252837002277374,
0.5491394996643066,
-0.6376373171806335,
0.3742424249649048,
0.07541710138320923,
0.49041566252708435,
0.09044592827558517,
0.05009043216705322,
-0.2515360713005066,
-0.3874724209308624,
-0.897284209728241,
-0.2251884937286377,
0.27303048968315125,
0.775341808795929,
-0.5531846880912781,
0.2682039737701416,
-0.22530119121074677,
-0.41745585203170776,
-0.41314783692359924,
0.849880576133728,
0.43152710795402527,
0.2774224877357483,
0.27769872546195984,
-0.6264122724533081,
-0.38415440917015076,
-0.8496716022491455,
0.2689550817012787,
-0.6958410143852234,
-0.030232703313231468,
0.006834239698946476,
0.4501280188560486,
-0.6638827323913574,
0.6845784187316895,
-0.21469596028327942,
-0.254829078912735,
-0.5101399421691895,
0.19947929680347443,
0.17183521389961243,
0.5690717697143555,
0.4509153962135315,
-0.48378586769104004,
-0.1786905825138092,
0.31250354647636414,
-0.5897426605224609,
-0.3244999945163727,
0.23351599276065826,
-0.15315745770931244,
0.029570596292614937,
0.3977777361869812,
-0.30936306715011597,
0.31249287724494934,
0.7042208909988403,
-0.057234443724155426,
0.5768686532974243,
-0.23052088916301727,
0.013304884545505047,
-0.9924734234809875,
-0.08320750296115875,
-0.012871500104665756,
0.022855687886476517,
-0.3866824209690094,
0.2385132759809494,
-0.0204088743776083,
-0.18390688300132751,
-0.6415961384773254,
0.7350283861160278,
-0.3607177138328552,
0.03237062320113182,
-0.2233399897813797,
-0.25648167729377747,
-0.12444788217544556,
0.21024560928344727,
0.3776908218860626,
0.9865827560424805,
0.21280443668365479,
-0.289865106344223,
0.31571224331855774,
0.32048678398132324,
-0.2954580783843994,
0.6937753558158875,
-0.4906541109085083,
0.16041861474514008,
0.24410468339920044,
-0.008538474328815937,
-0.6350654363632202,
-0.2514301836490631,
-0.3244764804840088,
-0.27209585905075073,
0.1806846261024475,
0.03391344100236893,
-0.512706995010376,
-0.5282618403434753,
0.04693032056093216,
0.417462021112442,
0.259164422750473,
-0.6667073965072632,
0.32746365666389465,
0.4222850501537323,
-0.4895051121711731,
-0.45879969000816345,
-0.9812000393867493,
0.5263100266456604,
-0.1989518702030182,
-0.4793427288532257,
-0.03008652850985527,
-0.38700833916664124,
-0.6752449870109558,
-0.2760182321071625,
0.35907840728759766,
-0.4716772437095642,
0.1961883157491684,
-0.09245158731937408,
0.051266685128211975,
-0.643566906452179,
-0.07108202576637268,
-0.13361063599586487,
-0.02152290754020214,
-0.02941456064581871,
-0.4097241461277008,
0.28957489132881165,
-0.05184921622276306,
-0.22389470040798187,
-0.786201536655426,
0.73228520154953,
0.5733633041381836,
-0.24694687128067017,
0.5640650987625122,
0.3897668123245239,
-0.3059370219707489,
-0.23499809205532074,
-0.9450264573097229,
0.09705784916877747,
-0.4093873202800751,
0.3479703962802887,
-0.324627161026001,
-1.3552082777023315,
0.6140128374099731,
-0.2598036229610443,
-0.024741753935813904,
0.2522124946117401,
0.6842017769813538,
-0.02985248900949955,
0.8256613612174988,
1.0393108129501343,
-0.26144078373908997,
0.40716153383255005,
-0.149665966629982,
-0.062055304646492004,
-0.7418561577796936,
-0.10681656002998352,
-0.7916049957275391,
0.08596980571746826,
-0.4821145236492157,
-0.21358592808246613,
0.04079487919807434,
0.28683385252952576,
-0.4607546627521515,
0.4931301474571228,
-0.1082267165184021,
0.4967314302921295,
0.6416870355606079,
-0.17800122499465942,
0.34573277831077576,
0.1107315942645073,
-0.37470710277557373,
0.2181033045053482,
-0.7849427461624146,
-0.8121664524078369,
1.3180971145629883,
0.37320777773857117,
1.1618225574493408,
0.08569186180830002,
0.7328329086303711,
0.23315007984638214,
0.3378239572048187,
-0.46996378898620605,
0.4220912754535675,
-0.25726673007011414,
-0.352344810962677,
-0.27326852083206177,
-0.5958524346351624,
-0.5891453623771667,
-0.35843831300735474,
-0.010085832327604294,
-0.6832879185676575,
0.14159256219863892,
-0.06029875949025154,
-0.4438815116882324,
0.5228176116943359,
-0.7257136702537537,
0.5560520887374878,
-0.36164790391921997,
-0.6811038255691528,
-0.0881091058254242,
-0.21561898291110992,
0.3710573613643646,
-0.36130160093307495,
0.2864237129688263,
-0.016190415248274803,
-0.1381452977657318,
0.6956391334533691,
-0.5247788429260254,
0.6971126198768616,
0.183833509683609,
-0.34713008999824524,
0.41926130652427673,
0.10384269058704376,
0.49062615633010864,
0.43145036697387695,
-0.2600652575492859,
0.579695999622345,
-0.0762830600142479,
-0.5330777168273926,
-0.2730666399002075,
0.7686657309532166,
-0.941118061542511,
-0.6273877620697021,
-0.15326277911663055,
-0.4085174798965454,
-0.1270417720079422,
0.02220827527344227,
-0.1033184602856636,
0.3238580524921417,
-0.10434551537036896,
0.5054487586021423,
0.6383954882621765,
-0.15357059240341187,
0.4607928693294525,
0.6887573003768921,
0.07307273894548416,
-0.7318677306175232,
0.5905110239982605,
0.13925622403621674,
0.32402679324150085,
0.4410400390625,
-0.02302754484117031,
-0.23760320246219635,
-0.9329978823661804,
-0.27811676263809204,
0.21318097412586212,
-0.33983123302459717,
-0.2532922625541687,
-0.5473673343658447,
-0.09150756150484085,
-0.42015182971954346,
-0.3275357484817505,
-0.6573052406311035,
-0.3585861325263977,
-0.49039775133132935,
-0.008793986402451992,
0.20531761646270752,
0.8313448429107666,
-0.4278774559497833,
0.7208951711654663,
-0.687612771987915,
0.03498465195298195,
0.6209733486175537,
0.5252346396446228,
-0.2828774154186249,
-0.4727032780647278,
-0.39420247077941895,
0.05335037037730217,
-0.3203825354576111,
-0.18412335216999054,
0.3222852051258087,
0.13060133159160614,
0.6065341234207153,
0.5784404873847961,
-0.03116852045059204,
0.6829959750175476,
-0.7152307629585266,
0.9760069251060486,
0.7073606848716736,
-0.7468365430831909,
0.47138479351997375,
-0.168760284781456,
0.288642942905426,
0.8026952743530273,
0.31018513441085815,
-0.27791106700897217,
-0.475049763917923,
-0.3927052617073059,
-0.5128756165504456,
0.6072925329208374,
0.21884483098983765,
0.24656730890274048,
-0.22901824116706848,
0.6056548357009888,
0.3531503975391388,
0.10495718568563461,
-0.7962161898612976,
0.1405169516801834,
0.012246034108102322,
-0.17567576467990875,
-0.37564682960510254,
-0.4385877251625061,
-0.08141955733299255,
-0.13597775995731354,
0.5912140011787415,
-0.290351003408432,
0.21466387808322906,
-0.04582267254590988,
-0.18447649478912354,
-0.19124016165733337,
0.32828912138938904,
0.6688999533653259,
1.0170764923095703,
-0.17783771455287933,
0.11608591675758362,
0.5099408030509949,
-0.8827151656150818,
0.44756001234054565,
-0.024977989494800568,
0.1284589171409607,
-0.11179117113351822,
0.6017624139785767,
0.5833645462989807,
0.14770609140396118,
-0.7887668013572693,
0.27417251467704773,
-0.10687077045440674,
-0.07401911169290543,
-0.6046679019927979,
0.2955767810344696,
-0.061342522501945496,
0.342612087726593,
0.529495894908905,
-0.4495229721069336,
-0.17319047451019287,
-0.674697756767273,
0.17345696687698364,
0.3430052399635315,
-0.48332467675209045,
-0.46007078886032104,
0.8117961287498474,
0.2939220666885376,
-0.3617650270462036,
0.3482292592525482,
0.017487024888396263,
-0.25487345457077026,
0.502013087272644,
0.6429182887077332,
0.6364002823829651,
-0.3949393928050995,
0.17479020357131958,
0.24047797918319702,
0.42645028233528137,
-0.40221962332725525,
0.3228073716163635,
-0.08969749510288239,
-0.5822502374649048,
-0.4979536533355713,
-0.9977704882621765,
-0.561728835105896,
0.3932279944419861,
-0.7138196229934692,
0.3823421597480774,
-0.6326724886894226,
-0.15842661261558533,
-0.36891019344329834,
0.2841242253780365,
-0.7797305583953857,
0.2949026823043823,
0.23517686128616333,
1.3976497650146484,
-0.584357500076294,
0.9407059550285339,
0.6348926424980164,
-0.3499034345149994,
-0.6629543304443359,
-0.40841737389564514,
-0.010563637129962444,
-1.012326955795288,
1.1081111431121826,
-0.02645830251276493,
-0.13153453171253204,
0.1977148801088333,
-0.7700352072715759,
-0.8358840346336365,
1.050671935081482,
0.7374265789985657,
-0.9449355006217957,
-0.03156073018908501,
0.6076655387878418,
0.3543264865875244,
-0.8141143321990967,
0.5554672479629517,
0.6261512637138367,
0.3380199670791626,
0.2802724838256836,
-1.1133270263671875,
-0.5605855584144592,
-0.1074686348438263,
0.27966347336769104,
-0.08150938153266907,
-0.9113856554031372,
0.7092901468276978,
-0.0885080024600029,
0.09807933866977692,
0.5772107839584351,
0.6808426380157471,
0.18108539283275604,
0.2452136129140854,
0.2521483600139618,
1.0647135972976685,
0.5619702339172363,
-0.15380144119262695,
0.7929532527923584,
-0.1529161036014557,
0.026386845856904984,
1.1297993659973145,
-0.7797712087631226,
1.14456307888031,
0.31756916642189026,
-0.21416141092777252,
0.42529696226119995,
0.6645396947860718,
0.3940107822418213,
0.22996379435062408,
0.2748865485191345,
-0.3720414340496063,
-0.6162118911743164,
-0.4415528476238251,
-0.47411438822746277,
0.7435709834098816,
0.23950155079364777,
-0.12679190933704376,
-0.2213299572467804,
0.1422821283340454,
0.05586537346243858,
0.17103616893291473,
-0.7719197869300842,
0.8878263235092163,
0.16547708213329315,
-0.21095918118953705,
0.5567091703414917,
-0.20052264630794525,
0.5877904891967773,
-0.7424112558364868,
-0.13194479048252106,
-0.6291143894195557,
0.1530163735151291,
0.07869607955217361,
-0.6540813446044922,
-0.002768904436379671,
0.2118079960346222,
-0.17396430671215057,
-0.16404123604297638,
0.15242083370685577,
-0.4199755787849426,
-0.8405404686927795,
0.764331579208374,
0.3195279538631439,
0.2098948210477829,
0.3431914150714874,
-0.5009444355964661,
0.4500548243522644,
-0.2725921869277954,
0.10479636490345001,
0.31866610050201416,
0.7697395086288452,
-0.0503789447247982,
0.5712549686431885,
0.7649379968643188,
0.5392568707466125,
-0.0790603905916214,
-0.06581821292638779,
0.868972897529602,
-0.6498295068740845,
-0.5439490675926208,
-0.44481736421585083,
0.4375001788139343,
0.07654944807291031,
-0.48312512040138245,
0.2619401514530182,
0.637232780456543,
1.3053767681121826,
0.1808553785085678,
0.6560372114181519,
0.42069917917251587,
0.5169267654418945,
-0.584033727645874,
0.8270927667617798,
-0.6946315169334412,
0.18803180754184723,
-0.17528904974460602,
-1.3257454633712769,
-0.4211002290248871,
0.32110363245010376,
-0.11575087904930115,
-0.2906280755996704,
0.5107777714729309,
0.8102268576622009,
-0.06094322353601456,
-0.043468229472637177,
0.6762936115264893,
0.2995966374874115,
0.08132892847061157,
0.6342655420303345,
0.8590472936630249,
-0.006918018683791161,
0.4921734929084778,
0.01236888486891985,
-0.5128530263900757,
-0.12544968724250793,
-0.893532395362854,
-0.9216451644897461,
-0.4851362407207489,
-0.2354760617017746,
0.01062403991818428,
0.15511420369148254,
1.029392123222351,
0.7621523141860962,
-0.9991918802261353,
-0.7230496406555176,
0.04758637025952339,
-0.14039823412895203,
0.12259911000728607,
-0.13316577672958374,
-0.05534844473004341,
-0.43470701575279236,
-0.631698727607727,
0.45964425802230835,
0.6083347201347351,
-0.011193269863724709,
-0.3452856242656708,
-0.3112207055091858,
-0.290706604719162,
0.08674677461385727,
0.7972533702850342,
0.410152792930603,
-0.6587989330291748,
-0.29011499881744385,
-0.1568552553653717,
0.04350922629237175,
0.2180289626121521,
0.7030995488166809,
-0.4845263659954071,
0.4062142074108124,
-0.06303412467241287,
0.9346362352371216,
0.17659620940685272,
-0.5312201976776123,
0.5734550356864929,
-0.10373011976480484,
0.4284375309944153,
0.12237583845853806,
0.489199697971344,
0.2500898540019989,
-0.2816522419452667,
0.6969747543334961,
0.3057343661785126,
-0.3659290671348572,
-0.9670233130455017,
-0.03023066557943821,
-0.9496236443519592,
0.18654079735279083,
1.2825744152069092,
-0.41538381576538086,
-0.31963759660720825,
-0.09172452986240387,
0.056379035115242004,
-0.05550466850399971,
-0.4300275444984436,
0.6152734756469727,
0.8424802422523499,
0.3445870578289032,
-0.24525272846221924,
-0.5894396305084229,
0.02006012201309204,
0.217910498380661,
-0.7932576537132263,
0.05730065703392029,
0.3218909204006195,
0.1129688248038292,
0.2983349561691284,
0.4027581810951233,
-0.175905242562294,
0.26221609115600586,
-0.19240744411945343,
0.23985208570957184,
0.07202094793319702,
-0.561994194984436,
-0.2544289827346802,
0.23329973220825195,
0.14137743413448334,
0.3198883533477783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07703v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07703v5
|
OpenLLM-Ro -- Technical Report on Open-source Romanian LLMs
| 2024-05-13T12:46:11 | 2024-05-17T08:19:52 |
Mihai Masala, Denis C. Ilie-Ablachim, Dragos Corlatescu, Miruna Zavelca, Marius Leordeanu, Horia Velicu, Marius Popescu, Mihai Dascalu, Traian Rebedea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved almost human-like
performance on various tasks. While some LLMs have been trained on multilingual
data, most of the training data is in English. Hence, their performance in
English greatly exceeds their performance in other languages. This document
presents our approach to training and evaluating the first foundational and
chat LLM specialized for Romanian.
|
[
-0.13773013651371002,
-0.8789518475532532,
0.23669648170471191,
0.30912554264068604,
-0.1320846825838089,
0.06104476749897003,
-0.5556423664093018,
-0.7189011573791504,
0.20393185317516327,
0.5600985884666443,
-0.4546796381473541,
-0.8903871774673462,
-0.5734121203422546,
0.1976625621318817,
-0.40801775455474854,
0.6855712532997131,
-0.26509833335876465,
0.7359338998794556,
-0.29555654525756836,
-0.4550217092037201,
-0.46526822447776794,
-0.6565260887145996,
-0.7071185111999512,
-0.37985891103744507,
0.5662100315093994,
0.6577113270759583,
0.42131364345550537,
0.2889290153980255,
0.913539469242096,
0.2740045189857483,
-0.01944741979241371,
-0.23038683831691742,
-0.7061506509780884,
0.1285824328660965,
-0.22939498722553253,
-0.8764190673828125,
-0.470867782831192,
0.23474495112895966,
0.7881884574890137,
0.41289928555488586,
-0.19651341438293457,
0.24348782002925873,
-0.01933986321091652,
0.7569664120674133,
-0.37898313999176025,
0.3152216672897339,
-0.5918881297111511,
0.24913635849952698,
-0.22003543376922607,
-0.6127955913543701,
-0.6348758339881897,
-0.49085888266563416,
0.027648497372865677,
-0.3800041079521179,
0.051307808607816696,
0.2514064610004425,
0.8014536499977112,
0.11167003959417343,
-0.14928536117076874,
-0.49792736768722534,
-1.0945957899093628,
0.8429750204086304,
-0.38580015301704407,
0.5864241123199463,
0.36708587408065796,
0.4219065010547638,
-0.241392582654953,
-0.5874814987182617,
0.020058520138263702,
-0.4900308847427368,
0.002525554271414876,
-0.030323345214128494,
-0.34488219022750854,
-0.15444664657115936,
-0.07148849219083786,
0.5294469594955444,
-0.7412524223327637,
0.48695310950279236,
-0.7439946532249451,
0.0636284276843071,
0.6358274221420288,
0.38458338379859924,
0.28064897656440735,
0.4782428443431854,
-0.3862912654876709,
0.39878031611442566,
-1.129216194152832,
-0.25570884346961975,
0.34846028685569763,
0.33173954486846924,
-0.2905755937099457,
0.9836550354957581,
-0.11192537844181061,
0.7087249755859375,
-0.48348671197891235,
-0.447817862033844,
0.10028786212205887,
-0.24023845791816711,
-0.1864897906780243,
0.15782909095287323,
0.6284046173095703,
0.22279764711856842,
0.5095362663269043,
-0.316355437040329,
-0.17012155055999756,
0.0405924953520298,
-0.150788351893425,
-0.7145645618438721,
0.03732508793473244,
0.13824595510959625,
-0.4733876883983612,
-0.1840352565050125,
0.05109443888068199,
-0.3686113953590393,
-0.10420987755060196,
-0.3259451985359192,
0.33925551176071167,
-0.4969137907028198,
-0.2832810878753662,
0.2994866967201233,
0.28819727897644043,
0.43450838327407837,
0.28590139746665955,
-0.4504866302013397,
0.43412497639656067,
0.6113121509552002,
1.0751125812530518,
-0.23960921168327332,
-0.41126853227615356,
-0.7299949526786804,
0.0031063596252352,
-0.24579501152038574,
0.7830218076705933,
-0.5903760194778442,
-0.361954003572464,
0.17813384532928467,
0.12500253319740295,
0.1342145800590515,
-0.5914725661277771,
0.44964101910591125,
-0.6312284469604492,
0.5467941761016846,
0.3262893259525299,
-0.7249997854232788,
0.002856302075088024,
0.2038373202085495,
-0.5538418889045715,
0.8780741095542908,
0.12978766858577728,
-0.7802551984786987,
0.14081813395023346,
-0.7608518600463867,
-0.3845274746417999,
0.1832963079214096,
-0.11493851244449615,
0.016261912882328033,
-0.13822917640209198,
-0.3521454930305481,
0.5541149973869324,
-0.5310835242271423,
-0.04970337450504303,
-0.014542457647621632,
-0.32762160897254944,
0.23012396693229675,
-0.024056488648056984,
0.7455387711524963,
0.41170576214790344,
0.08759886771440506,
0.4351648986339569,
-0.8987033367156982,
-0.12947978079319,
0.20469114184379578,
-0.695963978767395,
-0.2215883433818817,
0.12388451397418976,
0.158223956823349,
0.13616468012332916,
0.3141702115535736,
-0.6171455979347229,
0.031204745173454285,
-0.4525693356990814,
0.4973398447036743,
0.40353432297706604,
-0.5496864318847656,
0.5655930042266846,
-0.25102218985557556,
0.8862919807434082,
-0.1744498610496521,
-0.17398209869861603,
-0.33154574036598206,
-0.6452038288116455,
-0.8778785467147827,
-0.4431319832801819,
0.5029736757278442,
0.9197169542312622,
-0.26198673248291016,
0.37244826555252075,
-0.20912064611911774,
-0.5266776084899902,
-0.658764660358429,
0.46314698457717896,
0.2765926122665405,
0.2219419926404953,
0.14237762987613678,
-0.17927226424217224,
-0.7467076182365417,
-0.8666136860847473,
0.07211587578058243,
-0.08702781051397324,
-0.041605524718761444,
-0.023859331384301186,
0.5029876828193665,
-0.14448070526123047,
0.7913230657577515,
-0.45218631625175476,
-0.6340570449829102,
-0.5298380255699158,
-0.005406583659350872,
0.09861233830451965,
0.3763388693332672,
0.4915409982204437,
-0.36227554082870483,
-0.6081414222717285,
0.02248893864452839,
-0.8218370676040649,
0.2042611539363861,
0.5697216391563416,
-0.173326313495636,
0.5963600873947144,
0.6566190123558044,
-0.4627166986465454,
0.3916308283805847,
0.7665678262710571,
-0.27523553371429443,
0.41436779499053955,
-0.30322667956352234,
-0.09307558834552765,
-1.10430109500885,
0.06548422574996948,
0.2051064819097519,
-0.3711518943309784,
-0.3677341043949127,
0.23356598615646362,
-0.029328351840376854,
-0.13533838093280792,
-0.8086468577384949,
0.7071568369865417,
-0.7894134521484375,
-0.2937411963939667,
-0.14492468535900116,
0.30935657024383545,
-0.43232977390289307,
0.06715831905603409,
0.40212494134902954,
0.6356537938117981,
0.5790364742279053,
-0.5632033944129944,
0.6738761067390442,
0.31877899169921875,
-0.5921318531036377,
0.7701835036277771,
-0.6792901754379272,
0.12736982107162476,
-0.2203555852174759,
0.0949254110455513,
-0.8368647694587708,
-0.2126925140619278,
0.15122602880001068,
-0.5691350102424622,
0.47434526681900024,
-0.24809645116329193,
-0.43145039677619934,
-0.26719507575035095,
-0.14428557455539703,
0.018116269260644913,
0.507874071598053,
-0.23704572021961212,
0.38270115852355957,
0.4920213222503662,
-0.22218231856822968,
-0.42053478956222534,
-0.8724133372306824,
0.2068629413843155,
-0.30376526713371277,
-1.0115196704864502,
-0.09456629306077957,
-0.23401080071926117,
-0.6975589394569397,
0.1324756145477295,
0.40199407935142517,
-0.3843492269515991,
0.1179237887263298,
0.09134788811206818,
0.2625228464603424,
-0.6367418169975281,
-0.0049531892873346806,
-0.6309191584587097,
-0.14965492486953735,
0.09403274208307266,
-0.14348989725112915,
0.5603399276733398,
-0.3304539620876312,
-0.2648739814758301,
-0.4639317989349365,
0.270489364862442,
0.32088372111320496,
-0.1867949366569519,
0.9935391545295715,
0.44218572974205017,
-0.31525400280952454,
-0.009502304717898369,
-0.4471336603164673,
0.08651047945022583,
-0.40646806359291077,
0.3620912730693817,
-0.3136862516403198,
-1.0425713062286377,
0.3308373689651489,
0.16411446034908295,
0.28361767530441284,
0.1867176741361618,
0.7222376465797424,
-0.25684279203414917,
0.6154717803001404,
0.8385529518127441,
-0.23054710030555725,
0.37289634346961975,
-0.12953218817710876,
-0.09763208031654358,
-0.29334330558776855,
-0.5039256811141968,
-0.8368648886680603,
-0.30305781960487366,
-0.3999725580215454,
-0.5984711050987244,
0.10098957270383835,
0.18747824430465698,
0.08977533876895905,
0.23962005972862244,
-0.134977325797081,
0.4702532887458801,
0.37573739886283875,
-0.0015519802691414952,
0.6060844659805298,
0.17014992237091064,
0.06788411736488342,
-0.10192883014678955,
-0.6902217268943787,
-0.8948253989219666,
1.1922552585601807,
0.7387926578521729,
1.2126257419586182,
0.15305520594120026,
0.43705418705940247,
0.05059663951396942,
0.21665504574775696,
-0.9527315497398376,
0.5250245928764343,
0.006043748464435339,
-0.672621488571167,
-0.4285583198070526,
-0.2436378449201584,
-1.2009357213974,
-0.02138671651482582,
-0.2234104871749878,
-0.4317674934864044,
-0.6336030960083008,
0.02584611438214779,
0.14074862003326416,
0.40762901306152344,
-0.5619280338287354,
0.5196476578712463,
-0.4188896119594574,
0.00790876243263483,
-0.5552780628204346,
-0.49102550745010376,
0.5404358506202698,
0.0887967050075531,
0.273564875125885,
-0.2797640264034271,
-0.3600071370601654,
0.6607564687728882,
-0.13918881118297577,
0.554847002029419,
-0.04275054484605789,
-0.15550169348716736,
0.21599030494689941,
0.08113005012273788,
0.3812830150127411,
0.005657954607158899,
0.04776127636432648,
0.22554685175418854,
-0.40467071533203125,
-0.5114360451698303,
-0.2007831633090973,
0.8091160655021667,
-0.880760908126831,
-0.5476816892623901,
-0.2905368506908417,
-0.3974651098251343,
-0.21852728724479675,
0.006975460797548294,
0.2404083013534546,
0.3655121326446533,
-0.8294942378997803,
0.4605724811553955,
1.0052611827850342,
-0.4049106240272522,
0.2543186843395233,
1.1068956851959229,
-0.6058343648910522,
-0.3151804804801941,
0.6146323680877686,
0.07908898591995239,
0.19991694390773773,
0.6926291584968567,
0.08798249065876007,
-0.06692326813936234,
-0.828784704208374,
-0.37374347448349,
0.33931246399879456,
-0.6525301933288574,
0.042577628046274185,
-0.6756501197814941,
-0.47311100363731384,
-0.19686388969421387,
0.09206816554069519,
-0.38468652963638306,
-0.49577265977859497,
-0.4618733525276184,
-0.33486172556877136,
0.5606276392936707,
1.2870019674301147,
-0.031345512717962265,
0.1697651445865631,
-0.8092448115348816,
0.23603367805480957,
0.08475379645824432,
0.5601940751075745,
-0.4529857635498047,
-0.6172470450401306,
-0.5458680987358093,
-0.07726724445819855,
-0.1574963629245758,
-0.594129204750061,
0.30890345573425293,
0.2884580194950104,
0.9174830317497253,
0.3018059730529785,
-0.3105425238609314,
0.17251147329807281,
-0.4774905741214752,
0.7208289504051208,
0.36323675513267517,
-0.3741690218448639,
0.8381174802780151,
-0.2527678906917572,
0.11563128978013992,
0.23551936447620392,
0.8900068402290344,
-0.3589179515838623,
-0.39006128907203674,
-0.26791122555732727,
-0.6361537575721741,
0.8809478282928467,
0.22415950894355774,
0.15127892792224884,
0.15878354012966156,
0.14287014305591583,
0.27276042103767395,
0.06567122787237167,
-0.5369204878807068,
-0.5311700701713562,
0.2346731424331665,
-0.11816930770874023,
-0.3313167095184326,
-0.4993778467178345,
-0.153866708278656,
-0.3169865608215332,
0.6422971487045288,
0.17203697562217712,
0.29897674918174744,
-0.015200218185782433,
-0.45433080196380615,
-0.32895731925964355,
0.3890819549560547,
1.0026384592056274,
0.9608373045921326,
-0.38013648986816406,
-0.06610843539237976,
0.21994119882583618,
-0.4458301365375519,
0.23799024522304535,
-0.227280855178833,
0.08172070235013962,
0.20020180940628052,
0.4756017029285431,
0.8457045555114746,
0.42053961753845215,
-0.7591192126274109,
0.39624086022377014,
-0.3089315891265869,
-0.30634307861328125,
-0.6872169375419617,
0.09666327387094498,
0.5007418394088745,
0.07907082140445709,
0.4033859372138977,
-0.34818047285079956,
-0.44612812995910645,
-0.7561874389648438,
0.06642112135887146,
0.4103069007396698,
-0.5680684447288513,
-0.46892738342285156,
0.4906443655490875,
0.5918620824813843,
-0.6903635263442993,
0.5107099413871765,
0.20635069906711578,
-0.16352112591266632,
0.27472949028015137,
0.5498616695404053,
0.8118544816970825,
-0.41106513142585754,
-0.022944718599319458,
0.43987351655960083,
0.4891747534275055,
-0.03555396571755409,
0.6666588187217712,
0.4293244779109955,
-0.5989319682121277,
-0.41069644689559937,
-0.6338430643081665,
-0.5005213022232056,
0.3989925682544708,
-0.6852884292602539,
0.8228086233139038,
-0.49518826603889465,
-0.0016597738722339272,
-0.24129720032215118,
-0.10506363958120346,
-0.7746807932853699,
0.10727193206548691,
0.15990065038204193,
1.5186452865600586,
-0.5286595821380615,
1.0399023294448853,
1.087180733680725,
-0.29448726773262024,
-0.31624823808670044,
-0.6553439497947693,
-0.07552913576364517,
-0.9785298705101013,
0.9674736261367798,
-0.11003817617893219,
-0.2143896073102951,
0.04108637198805809,
-0.6849365830421448,
-0.7631281614303589,
1.1307517290115356,
0.5988131761550903,
-0.7210647463798523,
-0.1655382215976715,
0.40018391609191895,
0.4728378355503082,
-0.7152228951454163,
0.3416278660297394,
0.4247342646121979,
0.32349666953086853,
-0.11163050681352615,
-1.163256049156189,
-0.5258697271347046,
-0.10221219807863235,
-0.13663983345031738,
0.019383372738957405,
-0.6906189322471619,
0.6271573901176453,
-0.09799165278673172,
-0.17150358855724335,
0.19929705560207367,
0.8714878559112549,
0.19403176009655,
0.09886909276247025,
0.22568827867507935,
0.5379524827003479,
0.6419000625610352,
-0.09799795597791672,
0.8110868334770203,
-0.7030265927314758,
0.034274034202098846,
1.3720879554748535,
-0.31297919154167175,
1.1356126070022583,
0.3184230625629425,
-0.2540471851825714,
0.4542982876300812,
0.5061812400817871,
0.21689912676811218,
0.2689213454723358,
0.2367764711380005,
-0.16039687395095825,
-0.02054767683148384,
-0.08103218674659729,
-0.47735100984573364,
0.5415992140769958,
0.3875235617160797,
-0.3365379571914673,
-0.0907047912478447,
0.07359407097101212,
0.09287194162607193,
0.2015102505683899,
-0.4337581396102905,
0.801373302936554,
0.25773268938064575,
-0.2904277443885803,
0.45206218957901,
0.23927052319049835,
0.8871323466300964,
-0.7751304507255554,
0.040146514773368835,
-0.2490123063325882,
0.011439834721386433,
-0.2625137269496918,
-0.9352933764457703,
0.49566149711608887,
0.3548122048377991,
-0.23334378004074097,
-0.2095116227865219,
0.6876305341720581,
-0.49200740456581116,
-0.609983503818512,
0.6567021608352661,
0.545887291431427,
0.5820340514183044,
0.17479857802391052,
-0.5558319687843323,
0.09534911066293716,
-0.2711420953273773,
-0.3219107985496521,
0.4286735951900482,
0.3873051106929779,
0.06358622759580612,
1.0056291818618774,
0.2997112572193146,
0.33051541447639465,
0.36150670051574707,
-0.07119308412075043,
0.6162400841712952,
-0.8892255425453186,
-0.31080448627471924,
-0.6212213635444641,
0.4364863932132721,
0.3911472260951996,
-0.31778034567832947,
0.801762044429779,
0.8539593815803528,
0.9695839881896973,
-0.07998910546302795,
0.7927127480506897,
0.07727053016424179,
0.5794849991798401,
-0.6810689568519592,
0.6099645495414734,
-0.4019199013710022,
0.11770042032003403,
0.15449769794940948,
-1.0660490989685059,
-0.03735930472612381,
0.5293300747871399,
0.05762651190161705,
-0.2856786549091339,
0.7728896141052246,
0.7889089584350586,
0.1646813303232193,
0.02730320580303669,
0.6585671305656433,
0.36975234746932983,
0.01997453160583973,
0.4357116222381592,
1.2642543315887451,
-0.17135930061340332,
0.8052150011062622,
-0.09124494343996048,
-0.20791321992874146,
-0.29829511046409607,
-0.8208176493644714,
-1.1851072311401367,
-0.31933677196502686,
-0.22867369651794434,
-0.3143540918827057,
-0.04799758642911911,
0.9932835698127747,
0.6943295001983643,
-1.0159913301467896,
-0.6193875074386597,
0.18085892498493195,
0.044389743357896805,
0.4233693480491638,
-0.1621800661087036,
-0.17640244960784912,
-0.3439852297306061,
-0.7898856997489929,
0.7683338522911072,
0.29009658098220825,
0.12085345387458801,
-0.954426109790802,
-0.5756423473358154,
-0.2748554050922394,
-0.053449325263500214,
0.6643778085708618,
0.23912902176380157,
-0.6857028603553772,
0.08885776996612549,
0.10920295864343643,
-0.46243706345558167,
0.36687707901000977,
0.9230366349220276,
-0.555564284324646,
0.14000755548477173,
0.557252049446106,
0.15635859966278076,
0.3645855188369751,
-0.4443953037261963,
0.837794840335846,
-0.4734898805618286,
0.4900819957256317,
0.17050902545452118,
0.5174552202224731,
0.4007384777069092,
-0.2225022166967392,
0.8231556415557861,
0.1254439800977707,
-0.5585299134254456,
-0.730552613735199,
-0.056937769055366516,
-0.8167869448661804,
-0.2018728405237198,
1.4006959199905396,
-0.4586391746997833,
-0.13257797062397003,
-0.2679879367351532,
-0.27719905972480774,
0.12291552126407623,
-0.27711808681488037,
0.22383618354797363,
0.8796336054801941,
0.08736731857061386,
-0.13755486905574799,
-0.8133013248443604,
0.17169718444347382,
-0.08062712103128433,
-0.7562653422355652,
-0.3340286314487457,
0.4522131383419037,
0.6474304795265198,
-0.12844417989253998,
0.8002777099609375,
-0.24787354469299316,
0.1200779527425766,
-0.20397061109542847,
0.2583715617656708,
-0.13462671637535095,
-0.6044297218322754,
-0.6165302395820618,
0.22207693755626678,
0.6281862258911133,
-0.07442307472229004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07700v1
|
Age-Dependent Analysis and Stochastic Generation of Child-Directed Speech
| 2024-05-13T12:35:10 | 2024-05-13T12:35:10 |
Okko Räsänen, Daniil Kocharov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Child-directed speech (CDS) is a particular type of speech that adults use
when addressing young children. Its properties also change as a function of
extralinguistic factors, such as age of the child being addressed. Access to
large amounts of representative and varied CDS would be useful for child
language research, as this would enable controlled computational modeling
experiments of infant language acquisition with realistic input in terms of
quality and quantity. In this study, we describe an approach to model
age-dependent linguistic properties of CDS using a language model (LM) trained
on CDS transcripts and ages of the recipient children, as obtained from North
American English corpora of the CHILDES database. The created LM can then be
used to stochastically generate synthetic CDS transcripts in an age-appropriate
manner, thereby scaling beyond the original datasets in size. We compare
characteristics of the generated CDS against the real speech addressed at
children of different ages, showing that the LM manages to capture
age-dependent changes in CDS, except for a slight difference in the effective
vocabulary size. As a side product, we also provide a systematic
characterization of age-dependent linguistic properties of CDS in CHILDES,
illustrating how all measured aspects of the CDS change with children's age.
|
[
-0.19147862493991852,
-0.9388079643249512,
0.12909559905529022,
0.38404831290245056,
-0.17191725969314575,
0.010703609324991703,
-0.4685840606689453,
-0.6209996342658997,
-0.18245315551757812,
0.33578798174858093,
-0.8137140274047852,
-0.3027532696723938,
-0.576004683971405,
-0.07964163273572922,
-0.44362664222717285,
0.9578973054885864,
0.013599182479083538,
0.13163666427135468,
-0.32323917746543884,
0.34896981716156006,
-0.22230683267116547,
-0.23798123002052307,
-1.2101866006851196,
-0.11300565302371979,
0.42765092849731445,
0.4728226661682129,
0.563715398311615,
0.6096720695495605,
0.20253849029541016,
0.20008325576782227,
-0.41526949405670166,
-0.401108980178833,
-0.5058200359344482,
0.3121820092201233,
-0.32681047916412354,
-0.21282854676246643,
-0.44049572944641113,
0.1831333339214325,
0.7107794880867004,
0.8872694373130798,
-0.4963861107826233,
0.05111633241176605,
0.06828051060438156,
0.6588761806488037,
-0.4815380573272705,
0.03810137137770653,
-0.5658664107322693,
0.14825226366519928,
-0.2305583357810974,
-0.35176998376846313,
-0.5309491157531738,
-0.3503127098083496,
0.44554999470710754,
-0.18133236467838287,
0.6392862200737,
-0.4362449645996094,
0.562086284160614,
-0.09925556927919388,
-0.3562345504760742,
-0.7886397838592529,
-1.0732699632644653,
0.9277988076210022,
-0.7821323871612549,
0.3972269892692566,
0.7293252944946289,
0.3176855742931366,
-0.16887763142585754,
-0.68324214220047,
-0.59759521484375,
-0.5432482957839966,
-0.03507060185074806,
-0.029859159141778946,
0.022537603974342346,
-0.21957819163799286,
0.01662558503448963,
0.4058978855609894,
-0.6455208659172058,
0.2751009166240692,
-0.7542285323143005,
0.06961354613304138,
0.7930669188499451,
0.25994840264320374,
0.3601151406764984,
-0.13177357614040375,
-0.4520927667617798,
-0.2670188844203949,
-0.6624224781990051,
0.2068517655134201,
0.5850232839584351,
0.623691976070404,
-0.3853011727333069,
0.4560163915157318,
-0.40607619285583496,
0.5530738234519958,
0.45850834250450134,
-0.4664282500743866,
0.08398596942424774,
-0.3933314383029938,
-0.043339088559150696,
0.10884223878383636,
0.7331644892692566,
-0.18723325431346893,
0.3392235338687897,
-0.05483989790081978,
-0.3279961049556732,
0.217929407954216,
-0.026232775300741196,
-0.6971549391746521,
-0.32376977801322937,
0.19346092641353607,
-0.5863988995552063,
-0.41527190804481506,
-0.2606235444545746,
-1.0127404928207397,
-0.2972463071346283,
-0.5401889681816101,
0.005986850243061781,
-0.5073421001434326,
-0.30433687567710876,
-0.18084990978240967,
0.1953394114971161,
0.1148238256573677,
-0.00666942959651351,
-0.9208374619483948,
0.44566288590431213,
0.2134522795677185,
0.31045296788215637,
-0.49517136812210083,
-0.16888374090194702,
-0.6379803419113159,
0.10090029984712601,
-0.46057623624801636,
0.6670946478843689,
-0.9383939504623413,
-0.593325674533844,
0.1529313623905182,
0.21644380688667297,
-0.13294251263141632,
-0.726207971572876,
0.4687739610671997,
-0.7431897521018982,
0.33469778299331665,
0.258833646774292,
-0.3030998110771179,
0.2063276618719101,
-0.4623304605484009,
-0.3784416615962982,
0.7567941546440125,
-0.03367982804775238,
-0.4470902681350708,
0.8375058174133301,
-0.3006332814693451,
-0.6571741700172424,
0.05751970782876015,
-0.022067146375775337,
-0.5711766481399536,
0.08958756178617477,
0.1158812865614891,
0.17242678999900818,
-0.17570924758911133,
0.6072157621383667,
-0.10486248135566711,
0.027346815913915634,
0.24826231598854065,
-0.988734245300293,
0.9935632944107056,
0.5288683176040649,
-0.1399688571691513,
0.009862393140792847,
-1.3404948711395264,
-0.07428748905658722,
0.2085200548171997,
-0.47008246183395386,
-0.06014202907681465,
0.5429285168647766,
0.10491989552974701,
0.2607104480266571,
0.48099663853645325,
-0.6390857696533203,
0.06300770491361618,
-0.08358390629291534,
0.44844895601272583,
0.34656012058258057,
0.4241366982460022,
0.5470642447471619,
-0.20514298975467682,
0.7769712209701538,
0.32632941007614136,
0.4891119599342346,
-0.012614184990525246,
-0.31816360354423523,
-0.5053038597106934,
-0.28182682394981384,
0.16135956346988678,
0.3790489733219147,
-0.7062160968780518,
0.20312747359275818,
-0.13136306405067444,
-0.5691026449203491,
-0.14741481840610504,
-0.14275076985359192,
0.22559703886508942,
-0.06427055597305298,
0.32982388138771057,
-0.6842464208602905,
-0.49519410729408264,
-0.8213688135147095,
0.24884368479251862,
-0.39408349990844727,
-0.030742362141609192,
0.33541399240493774,
0.014921617694199085,
-0.0724017322063446,
0.8830233216285706,
-0.4912209212779999,
-0.0970706194639206,
-0.24438169598579407,
0.46151968836784363,
-0.15897467732429504,
0.7599217295646667,
0.209774911403656,
-0.5344900488853455,
-0.3194237947463989,
-0.17375291883945465,
-0.3110566735267639,
-0.48572230339050293,
-0.28096500039100647,
0.16578802466392517,
0.1737150102853775,
0.49845194816589355,
-0.6379083395004272,
0.5511000156402588,
0.7613678574562073,
-0.47176945209503174,
0.7916750311851501,
-0.43974485993385315,
-0.15979662537574768,
-0.49890822172164917,
-0.17726559937000275,
-0.14265570044517517,
0.08524374663829803,
-0.8612686991691589,
-0.02351544238626957,
-0.017518242821097374,
-0.21450355648994446,
-0.6948925852775574,
-0.04852982237935066,
-0.5001116991043091,
-0.19262473285198212,
-0.1989382952451706,
0.08375632017850876,
-0.22454102337360382,
0.26013997197151184,
0.19008174538612366,
0.9648770093917847,
0.32107236981391907,
-0.656871497631073,
0.1966039091348648,
-0.16564346849918365,
-0.2916235327720642,
0.8574546575546265,
-0.6831266283988953,
0.3467840552330017,
-0.3383900225162506,
0.32341238856315613,
-0.9272458553314209,
0.1858113557100296,
-0.007135463412851095,
-0.35401827096939087,
0.6262189745903015,
0.04900894686579704,
-0.4714788794517517,
-0.2411329746246338,
0.0896061435341835,
0.47157612442970276,
0.23249326646327972,
-0.37462499737739563,
0.6286134719848633,
0.3354968726634979,
-0.6964855790138245,
-0.037557054311037064,
-0.4094846248626709,
0.09366649389266968,
-0.3217497766017914,
-0.6807910203933716,
0.3860339820384979,
-0.20263904333114624,
-0.23806044459342957,
0.1253792643547058,
0.2320479303598404,
-0.38953346014022827,
-0.08282487094402313,
0.0036811346653848886,
0.1224733218550682,
-0.25067389011383057,
0.051582224667072296,
0.3575131595134735,
0.07127800583839417,
0.04705328866839409,
-0.10279497504234314,
0.6279284358024597,
0.28480789065361023,
0.11258048564195633,
-0.3507649004459381,
0.4798075258731842,
0.4167514741420746,
-0.25560325384140015,
0.7825761437416077,
0.3812999725341797,
-0.23848865926265717,
-0.8220725059509277,
-0.04292462393641472,
-0.12014222890138626,
-0.4577433168888092,
0.11547639966011047,
-0.41616782546043396,
-0.5122213363647461,
0.451054185628891,
0.488468199968338,
-0.23221564292907715,
0.5208753347396851,
0.6807235479354858,
0.04047110304236412,
0.8041340708732605,
0.4013991951942444,
0.2683897912502289,
0.5109855532646179,
-0.0643167570233345,
-0.12858451902866364,
-0.6208295226097107,
-0.12126227468252182,
-0.5526856780052185,
-0.10098136216402054,
-0.7966084480285645,
-0.4546663463115692,
-0.21810337901115417,
0.012078124098479748,
-0.2374819815158844,
0.4294993579387665,
-0.4235587418079376,
0.12346101552248001,
0.46197107434272766,
0.064259372651577,
0.3512933850288391,
-0.23604005575180054,
0.028039660304784775,
-0.023094043135643005,
-0.6226598024368286,
-0.385107159614563,
0.8828703761100769,
0.401227742433548,
1.0258759260177612,
0.1618119180202484,
0.4914403259754181,
0.5016107559204102,
0.32271870970726013,
-0.5360807776451111,
0.7449595332145691,
-0.5173500180244446,
-0.6659992933273315,
-0.2573726177215576,
-0.5864147543907166,
-1.0465991497039795,
-0.040215302258729935,
-0.12060284614562988,
-0.6868758201599121,
0.821999192237854,
-0.2363876849412918,
-0.1837371289730072,
-0.18877072632312775,
-0.679610013961792,
0.44288545846939087,
-0.14540551602840424,
-0.45152685046195984,
-0.38364145159721375,
-0.5877360105514526,
0.21571169793605804,
-0.2798640727996826,
0.1610691398382187,
0.007134630810469389,
0.18573494255542755,
0.9766287803649902,
-0.2105035036802292,
0.986992597579956,
-0.32757267355918884,
-0.5916494131088257,
0.6833691000938416,
0.2580447196960449,
0.5359084010124207,
-0.1885339915752411,
0.35005542635917664,
-0.0803716704249382,
0.21043498814105988,
-0.28094184398651123,
-0.2250123769044876,
0.9742235541343689,
-0.8053061366081238,
-0.5101358294487,
-0.39766979217529297,
-0.6748473048210144,
-0.19585812091827393,
-0.058957334607839584,
-0.14291337132453918,
0.5346947908401489,
-0.13817714154720306,
0.17311187088489532,
0.346436083316803,
-0.7537254691123962,
0.5470538139343262,
0.8348065614700317,
-0.1971331089735031,
-0.19080692529678345,
0.8438236713409424,
0.5551573038101196,
0.7850965261459351,
-0.011434155516326427,
0.23511143028736115,
-0.16603907942771912,
-0.42956531047821045,
-0.2537802755832672,
0.2980954349040985,
-0.5804654955863953,
0.31641122698783875,
-0.3188120722770691,
-0.3602028489112854,
-0.21708428859710693,
0.08614198118448257,
-0.2655678689479828,
-0.6185151934623718,
-0.39971527457237244,
-0.17250093817710876,
0.18939100205898285,
0.7953550815582275,
-0.3551459312438965,
0.1724386066198349,
-0.42283815145492554,
0.2622019648551941,
0.7436985373497009,
0.23678867518901825,
0.1877613216638565,
-0.6148196458816528,
-0.23943014442920685,
-0.005358592141419649,
-0.4698985517024994,
-0.8727467656135559,
0.4046141803264618,
0.5438998937606812,
0.3158605992794037,
0.46083271503448486,
0.041077498346567154,
0.4134689271450043,
-0.5960496068000793,
1.1950963735580444,
-0.007091911043971777,
-0.8294951915740967,
0.5923024415969849,
-0.6119715571403503,
0.21852166950702667,
0.25936567783355713,
-0.15582333505153656,
-0.22426071763038635,
-0.4429343044757843,
-0.8699634671211243,
-0.9739757776260376,
0.738672137260437,
0.1646391600370407,
0.04846150800585747,
-0.21430689096450806,
-0.05977841094136238,
0.15688517689704895,
0.1332501471042633,
-0.2982882559299469,
-0.30586135387420654,
0.19609929621219635,
-0.253755122423172,
-0.0053451769053936005,
-0.45339950919151306,
-0.029489779844880104,
0.1829923540353775,
0.5508151054382324,
0.3222154676914215,
0.3525378704071045,
0.07287175208330154,
0.10735030472278595,
-0.5282546281814575,
0.473998099565506,
0.7566732168197632,
0.7737864851951599,
-0.3776518404483795,
0.4452739953994751,
0.038263384252786636,
-0.5016295909881592,
0.2032644897699356,
0.2780304551124573,
-0.39309459924697876,
-0.16673417389392853,
0.2724865674972534,
0.543529212474823,
-0.009321944788098335,
-0.7098175883293152,
0.20797252655029297,
0.09474585950374603,
0.08602192997932434,
-0.5153367519378662,
-0.10475597530603409,
0.10922756046056747,
0.11457376927137375,
0.43193039298057556,
-0.2948914170265198,
0.0016173433978110552,
-0.6346423029899597,
0.6078953742980957,
0.2483108937740326,
-0.5690850019454956,
-0.5124963521957397,
0.8562417030334473,
-0.07905004173517227,
-0.44997531175613403,
0.3778406083583832,
-0.14972543716430664,
-0.012223991565406322,
0.6680160164833069,
0.7573246359825134,
1.057478666305542,
-0.5684970021247864,
0.5026933550834656,
0.11596784740686417,
0.28217437863349915,
0.3881819248199463,
0.06286510080099106,
-0.08842552453279495,
-0.6870731711387634,
-0.5673314332962036,
-0.5294647216796875,
-0.062275245785713196,
0.03296605497598648,
-0.92037433385849,
0.04903639853000641,
-0.3609654903411865,
-0.26101794838905334,
-0.07931079715490341,
-0.15111082792282104,
-0.8881303668022156,
0.8131886124610901,
0.2694146931171417,
0.5993552207946777,
-0.9029927253723145,
0.8515456318855286,
0.1903911978006363,
-0.4142514765262604,
-0.554828941822052,
0.08814702183008194,
-0.16876275837421417,
-0.6371926069259644,
1.0368220806121826,
-0.4949410557746887,
-0.13183613121509552,
-0.0282741729170084,
-0.6373350024223328,
-0.848393976688385,
0.8018449544906616,
-0.39596647024154663,
-0.40908095240592957,
0.04648542404174805,
0.2908354103565216,
0.8520584106445312,
-0.5972315073013306,
0.061515260487794876,
0.7686967253684998,
0.04609355330467224,
-0.01970497891306877,
-0.838011622428894,
-0.18269282579421997,
0.049661483615636826,
0.4856484532356262,
-0.041741736233234406,
-0.32821932435035706,
0.9028880596160889,
-0.05816351994872093,
-0.6683322787284851,
0.0026711388491094112,
0.91408771276474,
0.4193202257156372,
0.45882633328437805,
0.7226866483688354,
0.49693259596824646,
0.3190421462059021,
0.21711000800132751,
0.8804014921188354,
-0.4585925042629242,
0.43163245916366577,
1.0850375890731812,
-0.0325782410800457,
1.04827082157135,
0.5012964010238647,
-0.5919519662857056,
0.5744190216064453,
0.4114493727684021,
0.44953951239585876,
0.8071513175964355,
0.5107569098472595,
-0.3578849732875824,
0.32336413860321045,
-0.29206985235214233,
-0.3557344377040863,
0.18079344928264618,
0.5633419156074524,
-0.7300564646720886,
0.07634953409433365,
0.13851846754550934,
0.2211412787437439,
0.04255949333310127,
-0.07784979045391083,
0.8491390347480774,
0.21437114477157593,
-0.48776572942733765,
0.7786844372749329,
-0.08144035190343857,
0.3047899305820465,
-0.5549501180648804,
0.17845579981803894,
-0.20733244717121124,
0.07916469126939774,
-0.08168363571166992,
-0.6130544543266296,
0.16768866777420044,
0.15644416213035583,
-0.2880585789680481,
-0.0848921462893486,
0.40011537075042725,
-0.8743466734886169,
-0.6497321724891663,
0.3595782220363617,
0.36959993839263916,
-0.032342854887247086,
0.813385009765625,
-0.5180455446243286,
0.19668111205101013,
-0.10950631648302078,
-0.427287220954895,
0.3101930320262909,
0.6535648107528687,
0.13668681681156158,
0.571518063545227,
0.7358072996139526,
0.6237727999687195,
0.3163687586784363,
0.24697725474834442,
0.5228424668312073,
-0.3342767655849457,
-0.4807891845703125,
-0.288072794675827,
0.4647339880466461,
0.17249205708503723,
-0.42925095558166504,
0.6379122734069824,
0.1553914099931717,
0.6999512314796448,
-0.09760481119155884,
0.7334911823272705,
-0.2786790728569031,
0.7524100542068481,
-0.38980311155319214,
0.38321349024772644,
-0.29453468322753906,
0.4138133227825165,
-0.23537670075893402,
-1.0372710227966309,
0.05239102989435196,
0.6561307311058044,
-0.6510995626449585,
0.1437443494796753,
0.6505648493766785,
0.873123288154602,
0.25670963525772095,
0.1437651515007019,
0.09634748101234436,
0.2567078769207001,
0.6152793169021606,
0.4232926070690155,
1.0231040716171265,
-0.1261974573135376,
0.20561982691287994,
-0.387489378452301,
-0.3419966995716095,
0.24203968048095703,
-0.6383342742919922,
-0.3110150396823883,
-0.44477230310440063,
-0.4974597692489624,
-0.273890882730484,
0.21231697499752045,
0.8372906446456909,
0.4649733603000641,
-0.9604706764221191,
-0.3802626430988312,
-0.11259697377681732,
-0.5187833905220032,
-0.5622917413711548,
-0.3207803964614868,
0.4753950238227844,
-0.14967404305934906,
-0.9216083884239197,
0.7968199253082275,
-0.15735694766044617,
-0.16216740012168884,
-0.6306044459342957,
0.09187877923250198,
-0.17413346469402313,
0.45870301127433777,
0.6646022796630859,
0.11972041428089142,
-0.4936436116695404,
-0.4385732114315033,
-0.1168484166264534,
-0.16262441873550415,
-0.2321489304304123,
0.7319541573524475,
-0.5829230546951294,
0.816196620464325,
0.5556420683860779,
0.17989176511764526,
0.5795344114303589,
0.1797531396150589,
0.6100107431411743,
-0.7051318287849426,
0.17835842072963715,
0.16560406982898712,
0.10937664657831192,
0.3985339403152466,
-0.10996010899543762,
0.300193727016449,
0.2719963490962982,
-0.6809049248695374,
-0.5344064235687256,
0.40262678265571594,
-0.9093659520149231,
-0.20321039855480194,
1.3511488437652588,
-0.05091918259859085,
0.1687002182006836,
-0.21332699060440063,
-0.15151232481002808,
0.21127629280090332,
-0.5809894800186157,
0.7244627475738525,
0.5173490643501282,
0.17911207675933838,
-0.46305859088897705,
-0.3360021412372589,
0.4459528625011444,
0.10580961406230927,
-0.43038100004196167,
0.04800525680184364,
0.524535596370697,
-0.008777315728366375,
0.29229414463043213,
0.5112018585205078,
-0.35023078322410583,
-0.007281292695552111,
0.12580682337284088,
-0.03203738480806351,
0.3641771972179413,
-0.32586464285850525,
-0.10762039572000504,
0.48797279596328735,
0.12239021062850952,
-0.10889311879873276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07682v1
|
FastSAG: Towards Fast Non-Autoregressive Singing Accompaniment Generation
| 2024-05-13T12:14:54 | 2024-05-13T12:14:54 |
Jianyi Chen, Wei Xue, Xu Tan, Zhen Ye, Qifeng Liu, Yike Guo
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, eess.AS
|
Singing Accompaniment Generation (SAG), which generates instrumental music to
accompany input vocals, is crucial to developing human-AI symbiotic art
creation systems. The state-of-the-art method, SingSong, utilizes a multi-stage
autoregressive (AR) model for SAG, however, this method is extremely slow as it
generates semantic and acoustic tokens recursively, and this makes it
impossible for real-time applications. In this paper, we aim to develop a Fast
SAG method that can create high-quality and coherent accompaniments. A non-AR
diffusion-based framework is developed, which by carefully designing the
conditions inferred from the vocal signals, generates the Mel spectrogram of
the target accompaniment directly. With diffusion and Mel spectrogram modeling,
the proposed method significantly simplifies the AR token-based SingSong
framework, and largely accelerates the generation. We also design semantic
projection, prior projection blocks as well as a set of loss functions, to
ensure the generated accompaniment has semantic and rhythm coherence with the
vocal signal. By intensive experimental studies, we demonstrate that the
proposed method can generate better samples than SingSong, and accelerate the
generation by at least 30 times. Audio samples and code are available at
https://fastsag.github.io/.
|
[
-0.3642585873603821,
-0.6846681237220764,
0.027930673211812973,
0.7183607220649719,
-0.4506824016571045,
-0.10637339949607849,
-0.06071384251117706,
-0.2948645353317261,
0.630352258682251,
0.46902114152908325,
-0.9864818453788757,
-0.7550065517425537,
-0.4639928638935089,
-0.09405924379825592,
-0.5043705105781555,
0.763349711894989,
0.4627871811389923,
-0.4299388825893402,
0.016492947936058044,
-0.24713128805160522,
-0.5187754034996033,
0.11315388232469559,
-0.6063526272773743,
0.21930080652236938,
0.1790090650320053,
0.5846849679946899,
0.3901023268699646,
0.668504536151886,
0.13472159206867218,
0.2841583490371704,
-0.10039817541837692,
0.4207174479961395,
-0.02658757008612156,
0.751821756362915,
0.2906266450881958,
-0.18720480799674988,
-0.4921596944332123,
0.22258365154266357,
0.6469337940216064,
0.05292413383722305,
-0.6967064738273621,
0.6241542100906372,
-0.026978932321071625,
0.7604250311851501,
-0.24098582565784454,
0.15872742235660553,
-0.7029953002929688,
0.04885439947247505,
-0.3364451229572296,
-0.2409612089395523,
-0.22017928957939148,
-0.5057117938995361,
0.17667736113071442,
-0.6847345232963562,
0.5421926975250244,
-0.12699851393699646,
0.5096539855003357,
0.6746362447738647,
-0.18654368817806244,
-0.5070605874061584,
-0.430262953042984,
0.4078896641731262,
-0.7471146583557129,
0.22913858294487,
0.051738590002059937,
0.6229861378669739,
-0.4275302290916443,
-0.6437596082687378,
-0.2345522791147232,
-0.40040045976638794,
0.25487130880355835,
0.22133073210716248,
0.1957598328590393,
0.07778146117925644,
0.017053278163075447,
0.42769917845726013,
-0.6227337121963501,
-0.2198292464017868,
0.15492896735668182,
-0.26338836550712585,
0.9335904121398926,
-0.05913872644305229,
0.3273645341396332,
-0.4271370768547058,
-0.5899031162261963,
-0.05981455743312836,
-0.5071210265159607,
-0.04121427237987518,
0.19000190496444702,
0.6416787505149841,
-0.45320990681648254,
0.34963083267211914,
0.18134652078151703,
0.9536888003349304,
0.442150354385376,
-0.19488000869750977,
0.1594066619873047,
-0.5643782615661621,
-0.12788017094135284,
0.3026086091995239,
1.0010985136032104,
0.09385675191879272,
-0.3175046145915985,
0.06830281019210815,
-0.16051480174064636,
0.3937543034553528,
-0.15783201158046722,
-0.48156869411468506,
-0.2587316334247589,
-0.08404981344938278,
-0.46746379137039185,
-0.07642117142677307,
-0.3801303505897522,
-0.8348132967948914,
-0.29239386320114136,
-0.3146730363368988,
0.45725828409194946,
-0.4659259617328644,
-0.2211458384990692,
-0.5296509861946106,
-0.013404184021055698,
-0.08692093938589096,
0.15509231388568878,
-0.3331981897354126,
-0.30278563499450684,
0.09616360068321228,
1.0186946392059326,
0.10332860797643661,
-0.3407582938671112,
-1.1229571104049683,
0.15961937606334686,
-0.5066621899604797,
0.9269862174987793,
-0.022371673956513405,
-0.6149045825004578,
-0.5530009269714355,
-0.2994331419467926,
-0.17031985521316528,
-0.7460053563117981,
0.24729885160923004,
-0.08803070336580276,
0.19455747306346893,
-0.07975251227617264,
-0.575807511806488,
-0.10899453610181808,
-0.4467138946056366,
-0.5275865197181702,
1.0826009511947632,
0.28393590450286865,
-0.12700636684894562,
0.4358435571193695,
-0.9118614792823792,
-0.8309875130653381,
0.19504597783088684,
-0.19820351898670197,
-0.4288076162338257,
0.3194304406642914,
0.12910260260105133,
0.4217236638069153,
-0.2921769618988037,
0.34737199544906616,
-0.06829901784658432,
-0.5808020234107971,
-0.25875869393348694,
-0.11450669914484024,
0.27945852279663086,
0.5036971569061279,
-0.6883176565170288,
0.2468646913766861,
-0.954294741153717,
-0.014094294048845768,
-0.0649094507098198,
-0.06603703647851944,
0.0248006209731102,
0.1828652173280716,
-0.03355493023991585,
0.3351368308067322,
0.08046162873506546,
-0.1312892735004425,
0.07336904853582382,
-0.272418737411499,
0.28850534558296204,
0.5442174673080444,
0.17146460711956024,
0.5348535776138306,
-0.17277689278125763,
0.8694195747375488,
-0.2023182362318039,
0.034456271678209305,
-0.40918678045272827,
-0.5311357378959656,
-0.1517118215560913,
-0.5764958262443542,
0.4006827771663666,
0.259880930185318,
-0.5139485001564026,
0.5200067758560181,
0.31807687878608704,
-0.5879431366920471,
-0.8195944428443909,
0.3169739842414856,
0.35316741466522217,
0.38753265142440796,
0.29299360513687134,
-0.3302800953388214,
-0.6423229575157166,
-0.7781954407691956,
-0.21175366640090942,
-0.23651619255542755,
0.043906070291996,
0.4938976466655731,
-0.17097434401512146,
-0.08269588649272919,
0.5481709837913513,
-0.257141649723053,
-0.5258412957191467,
0.09408368915319443,
0.5134779810905457,
0.011113831773400307,
0.5802252888679504,
0.806255042552948,
-0.4615456461906433,
-0.5610162019729614,
-0.4008190333843231,
-0.4795573055744171,
-0.48986706137657166,
-0.10613225400447845,
-0.64512699842453,
0.2751202881336212,
0.3824649155139923,
-0.6805752515792847,
0.12126375734806061,
0.7572264671325684,
-0.38271433115005493,
0.5296708345413208,
0.09675206243991852,
0.28217819333076477,
-1.1456010341644287,
0.17358830571174622,
0.08494343608617783,
-0.23143619298934937,
-0.48930850625038147,
0.11222978681325912,
-0.24301084876060486,
-0.5853922963142395,
-0.41184622049331665,
0.3249891996383667,
-0.5887678265571594,
-0.12799622118473053,
-0.5115092396736145,
0.3365398943424225,
-0.051240961998701096,
0.21787190437316895,
0.08427143096923828,
0.9704819321632385,
0.8182758092880249,
-0.7912136316299438,
-0.03011525236070156,
0.21739551424980164,
-0.5316213369369507,
0.4155367910861969,
-0.3013141453266144,
0.2178170084953308,
-0.11459191888570786,
0.5424957275390625,
-0.9781979918479919,
-0.28938132524490356,
0.02510170266032219,
-0.6579064726829529,
0.1666712909936905,
-0.3951868712902069,
-0.4094473421573639,
-0.15627653896808624,
0.33907532691955566,
0.4022267162799835,
0.8895575404167175,
-0.5220798254013062,
0.6995916366577148,
0.14106537401676178,
-0.2357436716556549,
-0.2341928631067276,
-0.5641358494758606,
0.12783534824848175,
-0.2769455015659332,
-0.6522907018661499,
0.2737526595592499,
0.12176506966352463,
-0.047937002032995224,
-0.1281588077545166,
-0.3055169880390167,
0.3033391833305359,
-0.04509322717785835,
0.17820779979228973,
0.02917703241109848,
-0.3840247094631195,
0.06251228600740433,
0.1969871073961258,
-0.03362332656979561,
-0.18961353600025177,
-0.3996424078941345,
0.2803385853767395,
0.2544220983982086,
-0.25607526302337646,
-0.7660381197929382,
0.7732228636741638,
0.9073856472969055,
-0.3905922770500183,
0.14745554327964783,
0.5097977519035339,
0.03498284891247749,
-0.5504778623580933,
-0.29691317677497864,
0.002374127972871065,
-0.5047985315322876,
0.1020769476890564,
0.3281250298023224,
-0.38222163915634155,
0.631287693977356,
-0.05724296718835831,
0.37699538469314575,
0.3253780007362366,
0.4038776159286499,
-0.20295462012290955,
1.1110515594482422,
0.2840541899204254,
0.09232892096042633,
0.7498375177383423,
-0.36838671565055847,
-0.22659076750278473,
-0.59087073802948,
-0.17187842726707458,
-0.3281871974468231,
-0.4489730894565582,
-0.3107462227344513,
-0.7337561249732971,
0.5769500136375427,
0.1391698271036148,
0.22283749282360077,
0.26135504245758057,
-0.7010577917098999,
-0.1271488219499588,
0.5302802920341492,
-0.18967868387699127,
-0.3042287528514862,
-0.29212862253189087,
-0.11516938358545303,
0.23623377084732056,
-0.7527385950088501,
-0.07314179092645645,
0.6324313879013062,
-0.32912537455558777,
0.6830697059631348,
0.14330634474754333,
1.012221336364746,
0.6712628602981567,
0.3695344626903534,
-0.6253637671470642,
0.7478411197662354,
-0.23921090364456177,
-0.5299826860427856,
-0.035292644053697586,
-0.4267144501209259,
-0.5492053627967834,
0.2479408234357834,
-0.2614452838897705,
-0.2069604992866516,
0.0305683221668005,
0.8655226826667786,
-0.43372976779937744,
-0.14608028531074524,
-0.9009317755699158,
0.4412555992603302,
-0.218046635389328,
-0.091765396296978,
0.08334290981292725,
-0.8031578660011292,
0.47063159942626953,
0.09682102501392365,
0.3174497187137604,
-0.4179237484931946,
0.16762405633926392,
0.6252288222312927,
-0.40077343583106995,
0.6090800762176514,
-0.9972322583198547,
-0.24171772599220276,
0.8247129321098328,
0.2076447606086731,
0.7638064026832581,
-0.19462306797504425,
-0.11274559050798416,
-0.2215220332145691,
-0.39242881536483765,
-0.40553516149520874,
-0.6767332553863525,
0.8162268400192261,
-0.19000089168548584,
-0.5862169861793518,
0.06653912365436554,
-0.5375530123710632,
-0.16498862206935883,
-0.1748964935541153,
0.37435635924339294,
0.36401599645614624,
0.21676141023635864,
-0.12845800817012787,
0.38227689266204834,
-0.12874844670295715,
0.5086883306503296,
0.3565853238105774,
-0.0326111726462841,
-0.7298431396484375,
0.8361853361129761,
0.048066943883895874,
0.4922516345977783,
-0.17321622371673584,
0.1997869908809662,
-0.6857699751853943,
-0.35437431931495667,
-0.7986676692962646,
0.20960243046283722,
-0.4183935821056366,
-0.2634023129940033,
-0.2551354169845581,
0.14834697544574738,
-0.6417766213417053,
-0.037991832941770554,
-0.3775629699230194,
-0.372091680765152,
-0.32361748814582825,
0.3413316607475281,
0.655524730682373,
0.3875706195831299,
-0.25911879539489746,
0.5350987911224365,
-1.1272554397583008,
0.5471991300582886,
0.0815330445766449,
0.14747238159179688,
0.20256000757217407,
-0.1691865473985672,
-0.4452052116394043,
-0.12084626406431198,
-0.0843881294131279,
-0.9132946133613586,
0.05190770700573921,
0.44308555126190186,
0.5558470487594604,
0.4570971131324768,
0.04977208375930786,
1.1916298866271973,
-0.49563565850257874,
1.127873182296753,
0.22696593403816223,
-0.9459525346755981,
0.7148828506469727,
-0.3776748478412628,
0.17674319446086884,
0.587726891040802,
-0.1959989070892334,
-0.3937942683696747,
-0.5630202889442444,
-0.5367050766944885,
-1.1484483480453491,
0.6493939161300659,
0.32639646530151367,
-0.3256283402442932,
-0.1423216164112091,
0.6780958771705627,
0.18133734166622162,
0.351266473531723,
-0.21290740370750427,
-0.3701172471046448,
-0.49698537588119507,
-0.272593230009079,
-0.51759272813797,
0.3742562234401703,
-0.048241738229990005,
0.1226116195321083,
0.7501042485237122,
-0.2661186158657074,
0.39724621176719666,
0.3554840683937073,
0.009288785047829151,
-0.22869044542312622,
-0.003050535451620817,
0.7543681263923645,
-0.23629695177078247,
0.22477498650550842,
-0.22282882034778595,
-0.2519945204257965,
-0.22623422741889954,
0.4788473844528198,
0.14922137558460236,
-0.23583976924419403,
0.1377536803483963,
0.23618067800998688,
0.9515318870544434,
0.0963197723031044,
-0.6789895296096802,
0.31753015518188477,
-0.06969398260116577,
-0.3991777002811432,
-0.3545995056629181,
0.3283277750015259,
0.16384148597717285,
0.27634933590888977,
0.3303278386592865,
0.28797197341918945,
0.030949411913752556,
-0.20804016292095184,
0.47681719064712524,
0.42042821645736694,
-0.18952980637550354,
-0.0677003487944603,
1.0674983263015747,
0.187244713306427,
-0.7490655183792114,
0.11298038810491562,
-0.06648533791303635,
-0.061043933033943176,
0.6795427799224854,
0.515648603439331,
1.1179031133651733,
-0.5131716132164001,
0.12901394069194794,
0.12491872161626816,
-0.15815792977809906,
0.041286617517471313,
0.476643830537796,
-0.8667622208595276,
0.24325157701969147,
-0.7064211368560791,
-0.7377735376358032,
-0.13596592843532562,
0.05647401139140129,
-0.6216473579406738,
0.13564981520175934,
-0.3180925250053406,
-0.23665155470371246,
-0.1321224421262741,
-0.24514497816562653,
-0.10718037933111191,
0.3719214200973511,
0.06067396700382233,
1.0351825952529907,
-0.907176673412323,
0.40941449999809265,
0.46480804681777954,
0.08243411779403687,
-0.9636581540107727,
0.5740641951560974,
0.1598762422800064,
-0.5138392448425293,
0.12504853308200836,
0.11939049512147903,
-0.5610324740409851,
0.08290498703718185,
-0.30519071221351624,
-0.9009042978286743,
0.910942554473877,
0.1168358102440834,
-0.6855363845825195,
-0.19355562329292297,
-0.42289790511131287,
0.35389652848243713,
-0.2627770006656647,
-0.31360265612602234,
0.325112521648407,
0.5568867921829224,
0.538641095161438,
-0.39857998490333557,
-0.0765981674194336,
-0.3901241719722748,
-0.08951152861118317,
0.35805392265319824,
-0.9134610891342163,
0.6113680005073547,
-0.15124821662902832,
-0.30089449882507324,
0.7099924087524414,
0.8945435285568237,
0.6271654963493347,
0.43016183376312256,
0.8924009799957275,
0.5995655655860901,
0.5615285038948059,
-0.02757851779460907,
0.49632373452186584,
-0.5813634395599365,
-0.20198172330856323,
1.2113171815872192,
-0.3922555446624756,
0.31577152013778687,
0.2640608251094818,
0.3300659954547882,
0.6464762091636658,
0.8302087187767029,
0.24036863446235657,
0.8950886130332947,
0.30123141407966614,
-0.6325152516365051,
-0.2547740936279297,
0.2134755551815033,
-0.4189663529396057,
0.6690187454223633,
0.342789888381958,
-0.6832557320594788,
-0.19898396730422974,
0.03496285155415535,
-0.4587845802307129,
-0.012072551995515823,
-0.2779959440231323,
0.8979214429855347,
-0.14444445073604584,
-1.0625450611114502,
0.610217273235321,
-0.31361791491508484,
0.5699652433395386,
-0.7797849178314209,
-0.23204831779003143,
-0.12370752543210983,
-0.19407714903354645,
-0.1520925760269165,
-0.14102326333522797,
0.2648738920688629,
-0.07730153948068619,
0.04926653206348419,
0.04291469603776932,
0.3511314392089844,
-0.5646272897720337,
-0.19917620718479156,
0.3204669654369354,
0.35769736766815186,
0.07011481374502182,
0.3530614376068115,
-0.5876379609107971,
-0.2589731514453888,
-0.11858989298343658,
0.004925563931465149,
0.05731882154941559,
0.3527982532978058,
-0.05709176883101463,
0.29970553517341614,
0.7306413650512695,
0.25124481320381165,
0.42835140228271484,
0.3188568949699402,
0.31003904342651367,
-0.6578608155250549,
-0.9668169021606445,
-0.45673489570617676,
0.4437166750431061,
0.33313438296318054,
-0.061471931636333466,
0.7742649912834167,
0.46432703733444214,
0.02457342855632305,
0.1400839239358902,
0.8367795944213867,
-0.140152245759964,
0.5624817609786987,
-0.5816059708595276,
0.8847773671150208,
-0.9005046486854553,
-0.08581026643514633,
-0.6527197360992432,
-0.5541953444480896,
-0.1952158361673355,
0.38409528136253357,
0.5373415350914001,
0.0799676701426506,
0.035700611770153046,
0.7965119481086731,
-0.0467301681637764,
0.25913071632385254,
0.0320260226726532,
-0.13870902359485626,
0.2508845925331116,
0.2559877932071686,
0.8386825323104858,
-0.15518049895763397,
0.41365763545036316,
-0.03321061655879021,
-0.21145440638065338,
-0.11408314853906631,
-0.8952639698982239,
-0.49923673272132874,
-0.5519701242446899,
-0.3006068468093872,
-0.39172154664993286,
-0.06474179774522781,
1.0719237327575684,
1.1166366338729858,
-0.41784319281578064,
-0.21880513429641724,
-0.319717139005661,
-0.06419391185045242,
-0.6866961121559143,
-0.29524558782577515,
0.3852652311325073,
-0.2092193216085434,
-0.5574860572814941,
1.1416634321212769,
0.23212853074073792,
0.4611409902572632,
-0.39533016085624695,
-0.1676526665687561,
-0.08273641765117645,
0.34426432847976685,
0.46116989850997925,
0.18422017991542816,
-0.6464208364486694,
-0.0010776568669825792,
-0.050560686737298965,
0.47299182415008545,
0.09892068803310394,
0.8017094135284424,
-0.5944115519523621,
0.3053392171859741,
0.2991797626018524,
0.06770829111337662,
0.4989374577999115,
0.34527355432510376,
0.406706839799881,
-0.8804663419723511,
0.14784398674964905,
0.3057241439819336,
0.01616492308676243,
0.11336146295070648,
-0.4419735074043274,
-0.06644421070814133,
0.13973788917064667,
-0.41924208402633667,
-0.7996596693992615,
0.5907576084136963,
-0.793603777885437,
0.05616471916437149,
0.8479809165000916,
-0.1288590133190155,
-0.22498925030231476,
0.16036345064640045,
-0.12212853133678436,
0.5993850827217102,
-0.6172387599945068,
0.6828305125236511,
0.19761663675308228,
-0.7351955771446228,
0.04848983883857727,
0.13615559041500092,
0.7129707336425781,
0.19213567674160004,
-0.49845173954963684,
0.25607049465179443,
0.9164515733718872,
0.2355741560459137,
0.14188498258590698,
0.7417879104614258,
-0.3811356723308563,
0.8274087905883789,
0.07675785571336746,
0.09918376803398132,
-0.264610230922699,
-0.6054034233093262,
-0.2739320993423462,
0.292061984539032,
-0.025379808619618416,
-0.5887697339057922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07673v1
|
An Empirical Study on the Robustness of Massively Multilingual Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-05-13T12:01:54 | 2024-05-13T12:01:54 |
Supryadi, Leiyu Pan, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Massively multilingual neural machine translation (MMNMT) has been proven to
enhance the translation quality of low-resource languages. In this paper, we
empirically investigate the translation robustness of Indonesian-Chinese
translation in the face of various naturally occurring noise. To assess this,
we create a robustness evaluation benchmark dataset for Indonesian-Chinese
translation. This dataset is automatically translated into Chinese using four
NLLB-200 models of different sizes. We conduct both automatic and human
evaluations. Our in-depth analysis reveal the correlations between translation
error types and the types of noise present, how these correlations change
across different model sizes, and the relationships between automatic
evaluation indicators and human evaluation indicators. The dataset is publicly
available at https://github.com/tjunlp-lab/ID-ZH-MTRobustEval.
|
[
0.008705012500286102,
-0.5708437561988831,
0.1019718274474144,
0.5393060445785522,
-0.3689049780368805,
-0.13882645964622498,
-0.6991591453552246,
-0.4569987952709198,
-0.2298540323972702,
0.3656979501247406,
-0.20060430467128754,
-0.24163241684436798,
-0.5425166487693787,
0.5907780528068542,
-0.47829669713974,
0.9645581245422363,
0.03985399752855301,
0.33375030755996704,
0.34736037254333496,
-0.5871161818504333,
-0.48771125078201294,
-0.3579123616218567,
-0.6741365194320679,
-0.08325303345918655,
0.5944439768791199,
-0.28671014308929443,
0.9153679013252258,
0.8557863831520081,
0.886517345905304,
0.27188241481781006,
-0.14516983926296234,
0.32345426082611084,
-0.0029098428785800934,
0.08605051785707474,
0.03084079921245575,
-0.38541820645332336,
-0.6224734783172607,
-0.37261658906936646,
0.7088595628738403,
0.6418607831001282,
-0.08625797182321548,
0.448772132396698,
0.4055114984512329,
0.4685596227645874,
-0.20921656489372253,
0.30249646306037903,
-0.7428120374679565,
0.03482384979724884,
-0.35410016775131226,
0.026292750611901283,
-0.449025958776474,
-0.3000449240207672,
-0.13662533462047577,
-0.48767876625061035,
-0.28911566734313965,
0.14376643300056458,
0.995991051197052,
0.7058932781219482,
-0.6441318988800049,
-0.10269927978515625,
-0.4138331413269043,
0.8938488960266113,
-0.9630813002586365,
0.20597316324710846,
0.41217663884162903,
0.48917239904403687,
-0.13659967482089996,
-0.27909132838249207,
-0.281512975692749,
-0.2371903955936432,
-0.11001956462860107,
0.23478643596172333,
-0.021235346794128418,
0.043051380664110184,
0.12300097197294235,
0.5913280844688416,
-0.7499244213104248,
0.2759350538253784,
-0.1406448930501938,
-0.252322793006897,
0.510781466960907,
0.09319119900465012,
0.5775166153907776,
-0.5100181102752686,
-0.03232942521572113,
-0.24733281135559082,
-0.27698588371276855,
-0.0230540968477726,
0.48736289143562317,
0.7318685054779053,
-0.3283413350582123,
0.6007339358329773,
0.1986307054758072,
0.7464436292648315,
-0.25422385334968567,
-0.3627702295780182,
0.3969918191432953,
-0.9828514456748962,
-0.08789560943841934,
-0.0859808698296547,
1.0154720544815063,
0.5398267507553101,
0.11862999200820923,
-0.27091315388679504,
-0.43389004468917847,
-0.0712139755487442,
0.1973382830619812,
-0.7018253803253174,
0.020233629271388054,
0.354799747467041,
-0.8253086805343628,
-0.443621426820755,
-0.22188644111156464,
-0.504727303981781,
-0.07160010933876038,
-0.28294116258621216,
0.4041461944580078,
-0.5069493651390076,
-0.8662182688713074,
-0.13670019805431366,
-0.00124081177636981,
0.030027972534298897,
0.021610377356410027,
-0.6363796591758728,
-0.09836718440055847,
0.5057930946350098,
0.933890700340271,
-0.259133905172348,
-0.4842413663864136,
-0.29041996598243713,
-0.018552333116531372,
-0.5363749861717224,
0.42437759041786194,
0.026846371591091156,
-0.061975765973329544,
0.011831669136881828,
0.050057947635650635,
-0.3878542482852936,
-0.8035527467727661,
0.7943112254142761,
-0.2113044261932373,
-0.1376989185810089,
-0.1995655745267868,
0.10183966904878616,
-0.14380456507205963,
0.4460596442222595,
-0.7757130265235901,
1.0621845722198486,
0.08671562373638153,
-0.7754836678504944,
0.5876500010490417,
-0.6206786632537842,
-0.5968559384346008,
-0.2282295823097229,
0.19533312320709229,
-0.6993570923805237,
0.25237149000167847,
0.265651673078537,
0.2651379108428955,
-0.08111442625522614,
0.45913973450660706,
-0.3424174189567566,
-0.37917035818099976,
0.5571879148483276,
-0.9122400283813477,
1.0731428861618042,
0.54520183801651,
-0.26886695623397827,
-0.04389725998044014,
-0.9176252484321594,
-0.10692781209945679,
0.016955941915512085,
-0.4999959170818329,
-0.3441939353942871,
-0.2885471284389496,
0.21709869801998138,
0.5498300194740295,
0.12745130062103271,
-0.23983918130397797,
-0.16691873967647552,
-0.384660929441452,
0.5006955862045288,
0.6088938117027283,
-0.12277851998806,
0.03631802648305893,
-0.348757803440094,
0.31588494777679443,
0.4844069480895996,
0.026112524792551994,
-0.39289015531539917,
-0.4924769401550293,
-0.45047834515571594,
-0.22033178806304932,
0.46969640254974365,
0.5071731209754944,
-0.9118868708610535,
0.4699854850769043,
-0.5269754528999329,
-0.17665040493011475,
-0.6867421269416809,
0.41621479392051697,
0.42705896496772766,
0.3300464153289795,
0.30536097288131714,
-0.29162701964378357,
-0.5042102336883545,
-0.7303140759468079,
-0.35688385367393494,
-0.39868226647377014,
-0.1819707453250885,
0.10859846323728561,
0.3582182824611664,
-0.405239462852478,
0.15767231583595276,
0.4242565631866455,
-0.19082634150981903,
0.006505000405013561,
0.27559423446655273,
0.6243470907211304,
0.5328711867332458,
0.7141119241714478,
-0.5891270637512207,
-0.580161452293396,
0.3992636203765869,
-0.7537790536880493,
-0.22179698944091797,
-0.45205676555633545,
-0.17668327689170837,
0.28883764147758484,
0.16837160289287567,
-0.45327404141426086,
0.3450626730918884,
0.9217697381973267,
0.1741739809513092,
0.7215217351913452,
-0.26753556728363037,
0.16521993279457092,
-1.2820260524749756,
0.38511964678764343,
-0.06599528342485428,
-0.005910082720220089,
-0.37736350297927856,
0.24280764162540436,
0.14677228033542633,
0.014679694548249245,
-0.2951422929763794,
-0.04243256151676178,
-0.4263942539691925,
-0.22890089452266693,
-0.212535560131073,
-0.05134420096874237,
-0.22772879898548126,
0.46450233459472656,
-0.39990338683128357,
0.9616012573242188,
0.19761377573013306,
-0.6397695541381836,
0.13472260534763336,
-0.04283321648836136,
-0.40977850556373596,
0.7743564248085022,
-0.5723981261253357,
-0.18278415501117706,
0.08955224603414536,
-0.0072449385188519955,
-0.9822219014167786,
-0.4135644733905792,
0.1634468138217926,
-0.5410409569740295,
0.3383195102214813,
-0.005910247098654509,
-0.9555755853652954,
-0.30115145444869995,
-0.04017467796802521,
0.3549109995365143,
0.21451669931411743,
-0.5217333436012268,
0.14769865572452545,
0.0171528197824955,
-0.06594032794237137,
-0.5012356638908386,
-1.1812775135040283,
0.48230767250061035,
-0.36972591280937195,
-0.5650102496147156,
-0.17250628769397736,
0.026374710723757744,
-0.18308034539222717,
-0.029235588386654854,
-0.06558956950902939,
-0.37056469917297363,
0.31149664521217346,
0.04336574673652649,
0.2263728678226471,
-0.5527927875518799,
-0.06370090693235397,
0.14759351313114166,
-0.12470342963933945,
0.3366546928882599,
-0.39876675605773926,
0.1221761479973793,
-0.26970475912094116,
-0.29586318135261536,
-0.3458726108074188,
-0.013005299493670464,
0.6843689680099487,
-0.07558168470859528,
0.7606097459793091,
1.137149691581726,
-0.3818491995334625,
0.04815651476383209,
-0.24034368991851807,
0.012403023429214954,
-0.3876452147960663,
0.6216306686401367,
-0.5551779866218567,
-0.3349034786224365,
0.6092029809951782,
-0.010320177301764488,
0.36939722299575806,
0.6830687522888184,
0.693383514881134,
0.0566055029630661,
1.3231765031814575,
0.2151859700679779,
-0.24559803307056427,
0.13221819698810577,
0.2949134409427643,
0.19996775686740875,
-0.7440277338027954,
0.2567927837371826,
-0.6122223734855652,
-0.2801387906074524,
-0.7168978452682495,
-0.26182821393013,
0.3069130480289459,
-0.15244750678539276,
-0.13282151520252228,
0.7203595042228699,
-0.399568647146225,
0.14322079718112946,
0.17913685739040375,
-0.11278140544891357,
0.48777639865875244,
0.21812036633491516,
-0.44007009267807007,
-0.5135887861251831,
-0.6340003609657288,
-0.49724987149238586,
1.160356044769287,
0.2817036509513855,
0.32623523473739624,
0.3765178620815277,
0.1453128308057785,
0.012819146737456322,
0.3727239966392517,
-0.3902890980243683,
0.1377808004617691,
-0.3758673071861267,
-0.822257399559021,
-0.22183287143707275,
-0.8362617492675781,
-1.0210894346237183,
0.6172640919685364,
-0.18755611777305603,
-0.5467637181282043,
-0.13834653794765472,
-0.10005652904510498,
-0.2565914988517761,
0.4579852223396301,
-0.531151294708252,
0.8494042158126831,
-0.5812182426452637,
-0.13121187686920166,
-0.06354179978370667,
-0.7482492923736572,
0.6691311597824097,
-0.5257704854011536,
0.3405163288116455,
-0.01381229143589735,
-0.021277938038110733,
0.2925204634666443,
-0.10290428251028061,
0.5098711848258972,
0.19352243840694427,
-0.24726490676403046,
-0.0979819968342781,
-0.01916513219475746,
0.18229438364505768,
-0.006641751620918512,
-0.4488203227519989,
0.51502525806427,
0.04525306448340416,
-0.4448361396789551,
-0.45894601941108704,
0.3911533057689667,
-0.8869896531105042,
0.01181893888860941,
-0.2346385419368744,
-0.7638328671455383,
0.12411915510892868,
0.5838582515716553,
0.38987261056900024,
0.028142226859927177,
0.01920931600034237,
0.38670310378074646,
0.48635128140449524,
-0.4251157343387604,
0.5529465675354004,
0.43814823031425476,
-0.3726285696029663,
-0.5847283005714417,
1.1521928310394287,
0.4489278197288513,
0.27951109409332275,
0.28240272402763367,
0.20623232424259186,
-0.2089294195175171,
-0.556933581829071,
-0.9693882465362549,
-0.08165048807859421,
-0.4563462734222412,
-0.08441769331693649,
-0.5338916182518005,
-0.28151392936706543,
-0.22256119549274445,
0.12556192278862,
-0.558425784111023,
-0.295071542263031,
0.018957942724227905,
-0.011106905527412891,
-0.26403722167015076,
0.39417532086372375,
-0.09914171695709229,
0.19243641197681427,
-0.6389979124069214,
0.32633453607559204,
-0.05163082480430603,
0.156688392162323,
0.07049882411956787,
-0.6978397965431213,
-0.49974051117897034,
0.22952210903167725,
-0.0675530880689621,
-0.4503002166748047,
0.47916656732559204,
0.20181815326213837,
0.4808812439441681,
0.5374594926834106,
0.12108927220106125,
0.8440815806388855,
-0.1849319040775299,
0.69594806432724,
-0.03324482962489128,
-0.593570351600647,
0.22371532022953033,
-0.5582229495048523,
0.5417726635932922,
0.698225736618042,
-0.022960297763347626,
-0.38441431522369385,
-0.5157651901245117,
-0.38073208928108215,
-0.8054397702217102,
0.26205235719680786,
0.37516146898269653,
0.02600932866334915,
0.24375279247760773,
0.21372845768928528,
0.12197078764438629,
0.3575519323348999,
-0.9221081137657166,
-0.19550524652004242,
-0.3420800566673279,
-0.08578744530677795,
-0.015922369435429573,
0.09774348884820938,
-0.050939302891492844,
-0.153072789311409,
0.39925235509872437,
-0.22392475605010986,
0.03927399218082428,
-0.21018540859222412,
-0.29158180952072144,
-0.24501356482505798,
0.11918313801288605,
0.5653267502784729,
0.3697780668735504,
-0.392895370721817,
0.1667633205652237,
0.3313030004501343,
-0.49151721596717834,
0.06653737276792526,
0.07277657091617584,
-0.25657325983047485,
0.3654215335845947,
0.45167532563209534,
0.503620982170105,
0.2666299343109131,
-0.48559656739234924,
0.485490083694458,
-0.3124837577342987,
-0.0532945916056633,
-0.34764933586120605,
-0.27665719389915466,
-0.1155354231595993,
-0.3128279447555542,
0.2529905438423157,
0.5957235097885132,
0.030336793512105942,
-0.18325574696063995,
0.029932880774140358,
-0.03512834757566452,
-0.37646588683128357,
-0.5444836616516113,
1.0532541275024414,
0.14710773527622223,
0.153866246342659,
0.6985123157501221,
-0.18727195262908936,
-0.2757955491542816,
0.5331725478172302,
0.3707684576511383,
0.898899495601654,
-0.12482985854148865,
-0.05332756042480469,
0.6236703991889954,
1.074508786201477,
-0.16345711052417755,
-0.09436728060245514,
0.03287078067660332,
-0.32057663798332214,
-0.7293652892112732,
-0.4698982238769531,
-0.42340952157974243,
0.06270117312669754,
-0.888362467288971,
0.035531025379896164,
-0.23395082354545593,
-0.3340615928173065,
-0.3315275013446808,
-0.030786817893385887,
-0.4012283384799957,
-0.01645711064338684,
-0.1794164478778839,
0.6639009714126587,
-0.8539050221443176,
0.9744724631309509,
0.7171574234962463,
-0.33272480964660645,
-0.7203603386878967,
0.09655444324016571,
0.2065480649471283,
-0.7153381109237671,
0.4478464424610138,
0.43521973490715027,
0.35418519377708435,
-0.5298615097999573,
-0.23861464858055115,
-0.7455096244812012,
0.8892409801483154,
0.5864914059638977,
-0.22666752338409424,
0.3416218161582947,
0.5694265365600586,
0.8049474954605103,
0.0961623564362526,
0.23091398179531097,
0.5392091870307922,
0.7085280418395996,
-0.27605921030044556,
-1.1599986553192139,
0.026446817442774773,
-0.5463692545890808,
0.18515028059482574,
-0.15182259678840637,
-0.8624929189682007,
0.822026789188385,
0.1865178346633911,
-0.18525147438049316,
0.30114272236824036,
0.6018739342689514,
0.037356093525886536,
0.1587957888841629,
0.5321998000144958,
0.5015944838523865,
0.6968258619308472,
-0.159601092338562,
1.030815839767456,
-0.5231266617774963,
-0.12069038301706314,
0.9487518668174744,
-0.019687993451952934,
0.7962496280670166,
0.4613419473171234,
-0.15598130226135254,
0.028369855135679245,
0.6185130476951599,
-0.0408889576792717,
0.26077979803085327,
0.039306748658418655,
0.003241732018068433,
-0.08077390491962433,
-0.28906920552253723,
-0.5655546188354492,
0.2692836821079254,
0.3878087103366852,
-0.43426844477653503,
-0.029515767470002174,
-0.28558358550071716,
0.1462441235780716,
-0.1406015008687973,
-0.07661294937133789,
0.5732358694076538,
0.3821464776992798,
-0.8028947710990906,
0.670973002910614,
0.14109018445014954,
0.8887535333633423,
-0.44974783062934875,
0.14421169459819794,
-0.3521987795829773,
0.3961981236934662,
-0.2788962423801422,
-0.5181399583816528,
0.718306303024292,
0.018177304416894913,
0.022297557443380356,
-0.14420774579048157,
0.45960575342178345,
-0.4156663715839386,
-0.5813060402870178,
0.22849920392036438,
0.4453566372394562,
0.23507660627365112,
-0.035408955067396164,
-0.9463068246841431,
0.2799359858036041,
-0.04378575086593628,
-0.09911933541297913,
0.5167461633682251,
0.7291024923324585,
-0.06284336000680923,
0.612602710723877,
0.9421539306640625,
0.36035630106925964,
0.2767219543457031,
-0.09884139150381088,
0.40548422932624817,
-0.32778120040893555,
-0.34347614645957947,
-0.7106342911720276,
0.48429352045059204,
-0.14261949062347412,
-0.6678378582000732,
1.273773193359375,
0.4293757975101471,
0.7460894584655762,
0.0531608872115612,
0.6341305375099182,
0.34489697217941284,
0.2548696994781494,
-0.1718364655971527,
0.9227124452590942,
-0.44096553325653076,
0.34532153606414795,
-0.5465050935745239,
-1.0896835327148438,
-0.5568591952323914,
0.4928476810455322,
0.1648552417755127,
-0.23307108879089355,
0.5584160685539246,
0.7847086787223816,
-0.07593589276075363,
-0.10846563428640366,
0.5945338606834412,
0.32125166058540344,
0.26730814576148987,
0.5592436194419861,
0.44671061635017395,
-0.7720248699188232,
1.0790208578109741,
-0.29484811425209045,
0.044935017824172974,
-0.21934731304645538,
-0.8683502078056335,
-0.845814049243927,
-0.3314353823661804,
-0.352342814207077,
-0.5224843621253967,
0.023574577644467354,
0.6346637010574341,
0.5074264407157898,
-0.9427270889282227,
-0.4410073757171631,
0.2394169420003891,
0.12227028608322144,
-0.8813022971153259,
-0.12757331132888794,
0.44574764370918274,
-0.4468784034252167,
-0.7387906312942505,
0.321642130613327,
0.35694554448127747,
0.03668413311243057,
-0.2890118956565857,
-0.2715488076210022,
0.06524085998535156,
-0.16383107006549835,
0.33814606070518494,
0.18932151794433594,
-0.6413326263427734,
0.07227003574371338,
-0.1700136363506317,
-0.5024219155311584,
-0.013094425201416016,
0.27040180563926697,
-0.006147189997136593,
0.6285755634307861,
0.3134463131427765,
1.0777066946029663,
0.18484842777252197,
-0.1794898957014084,
0.6415491700172424,
-0.7965429425239563,
0.3960895240306854,
-0.3277702331542969,
0.3566417694091797,
0.44987753033638,
-0.05705760791897774,
0.8202667832374573,
0.1381925791501999,
-0.5670616626739502,
-1.017745018005371,
-0.32649239897727966,
-0.7999072074890137,
0.07155710458755493,
0.9789087772369385,
-0.3746453523635864,
-0.44169947504997253,
-0.3794199228286743,
-0.04199104756116867,
0.23326998949050903,
-0.0827118456363678,
0.8905189037322998,
0.9853714108467102,
0.4484249949455261,
-0.14997680485248566,
-0.9853558540344238,
0.10471964627504349,
0.7797625064849854,
-0.2829591929912567,
-0.2325993925333023,
0.07063207030296326,
-0.051767393946647644,
0.20808924734592438,
0.04584408923983574,
-0.317851722240448,
0.40653589367866516,
0.3636067509651184,
-0.32589271664619446,
-0.10807894915342331,
0.07252740114927292,
-0.4151637852191925,
-0.016033992171287537,
0.15464118123054504,
-0.08109735697507858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07671v1
|
Constructing a BPE Tokenization DFA
| 2024-05-13T11:59:24 | 2024-05-13T11:59:24 |
Martin Berglund, Willeke Martens, Brink van der Merwe
|
cs.FL
|
cs.FL, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Many natural language processing systems operate over tokenizations of text
to address the open-vocabulary problem. In this paper, we give and analyze an
algorithm for the efficient construction of deterministic finite automata
designed to operate directly on tokenizations produced by the popular byte pair
encoding technique. This makes it possible to apply many existing techniques
and algorithms to the tokenized case, such as pattern matching, equivalence
checking of tokenization dictionaries, and composing tokenized languages in
various ways.
|
[
-0.43218016624450684,
-0.9150550365447998,
0.6101735234260559,
0.3662765622138977,
-0.35205334424972534,
0.19036740064620972,
0.33265066146850586,
-0.5275025963783264,
0.45388954877853394,
0.4060763716697693,
-0.2622746229171753,
-0.27425137162208557,
-0.4797113835811615,
0.34298890829086304,
-0.41072535514831543,
0.6552865505218506,
-0.28737059235572815,
0.050975020974874496,
0.4285961985588074,
0.06872754544019699,
-0.5782037973403931,
-0.8431844711303711,
-0.9496757388114929,
-0.1660166084766388,
-0.01977582648396492,
-0.02751312218606472,
0.7851395606994629,
0.9180852770805359,
0.6836841702461243,
0.4425802528858185,
-0.14542794227600098,
0.2714362144470215,
-0.03691140189766884,
0.04345814511179924,
-0.35841116309165955,
-0.17001496255397797,
-0.3849959075450897,
0.012390127405524254,
0.9693241119384766,
0.7026244401931763,
0.28824952244758606,
0.15390586853027344,
-0.5683919787406921,
0.7379633784294128,
-0.3055105209350586,
0.06705078482627869,
-0.699611246585846,
0.10576724261045456,
-0.46429443359375,
-0.2352292388677597,
-0.3893193304538727,
-0.1532023549079895,
-0.14029593765735626,
-0.16666793823242188,
0.01137408148497343,
0.24474719166755676,
0.6110629439353943,
0.1426253467798233,
-0.36868977546691895,
-0.376740038394928,
-0.7986881136894226,
0.5563145875930786,
-0.6517141461372375,
0.3780481815338135,
0.23633348941802979,
-0.012109409086406231,
-0.8904538750648499,
-0.6280624270439148,
-0.821830153465271,
0.10035639256238937,
-0.25750330090522766,
-0.330514132976532,
-0.00793165247887373,
0.4269604980945587,
0.1802392452955246,
0.7121281623840332,
-0.4021911919116974,
0.07933443039655685,
-0.056052789092063904,
-0.17147760093212128,
0.6385698318481445,
0.2604924440383911,
0.5183232426643372,
-0.22988265752792358,
-0.44862669706344604,
0.34120529890060425,
-0.09669371694326401,
-0.07488609105348587,
0.5000039935112,
0.1961740106344223,
0.07545152306556702,
0.8003043532371521,
-0.11738817393779755,
0.8510544896125793,
0.3398376405239105,
0.1253052055835724,
0.02703634649515152,
-0.6362835168838501,
-0.37111541628837585,
0.13759179413318634,
0.4159340262413025,
0.11172229796648026,
0.15706288814544678,
-0.6585147380828857,
-0.574567437171936,
0.19855846464633942,
0.11606142669916153,
-1.0097464323043823,
0.15644517540931702,
0.7506756782531738,
-0.7302305698394775,
-0.24568884074687958,
0.20245659351348877,
-0.586816668510437,
0.03886578604578972,
-0.35051602125167847,
0.5055671334266663,
-0.3715282380580902,
-0.2840188145637512,
0.2748037576675415,
-0.2206040918827057,
0.33637866377830505,
-0.4836776852607727,
-1.09774649143219,
0.693296492099762,
0.9847753047943115,
1.0204910039901733,
0.03392825648188591,
-0.0518096499145031,
-0.9329769611358643,
0.09816766530275345,
-0.6844412684440613,
0.3852806091308594,
-0.3562977910041809,
-0.11211059987545013,
-0.04947775602340698,
-0.1184963509440422,
-0.0832793191075325,
-0.153965026140213,
0.3478752672672272,
-0.8945133686065674,
0.010589297860860825,
-0.08408772945404053,
-1.090632677078247,
-0.1663590967655182,
-0.2782214283943176,
-0.7723581194877625,
0.9131032824516296,
-0.02083839476108551,
-0.7235090732574463,
0.4679132401943207,
-1.1351057291030884,
-0.46726974844932556,
0.15293584764003754,
-0.17447155714035034,
0.09629625827074051,
0.3773181140422821,
0.10145388543605804,
0.45935723185539246,
0.02636246755719185,
0.35304567217826843,
0.18808111548423767,
-0.4941971004009247,
0.3178299069404602,
-0.15715143084526062,
1.08059561252594,
0.24008871614933014,
-0.731249988079071,
-0.08241578936576843,
-0.95074462890625,
-0.06173524260520935,
0.1835271120071411,
-0.43731650710105896,
-0.5694750547409058,
0.1859518140554428,
-0.16095739603042603,
-0.13756871223449707,
0.5228630900382996,
-0.8078599572181702,
0.2992934584617615,
-1.13266122341156,
0.4330022931098938,
0.8005977869033813,
0.2633730471134186,
0.3505583703517914,
-0.23206758499145508,
-0.15259906649589539,
0.18664208054542542,
0.05464558303356171,
-0.1451622098684311,
-0.4419613778591156,
-0.7466973066329956,
-0.6222705245018005,
0.3742399215698242,
0.5097594857215881,
-0.692094087600708,
0.7618462443351746,
0.10863693058490753,
-0.2554546892642975,
-0.26158884167671204,
0.11086718738079071,
0.5064966678619385,
0.11209162324666977,
-0.08230941742658615,
-0.8061462044715881,
-0.7277795076370239,
-0.7504915595054626,
0.05578640475869179,
-0.3438372015953064,
0.17225699126720428,
-0.2525250315666199,
0.36778855323791504,
-0.168666273355484,
1.1610288619995117,
-0.27508899569511414,
0.028336117044091225,
0.3026106357574463,
0.2908162474632263,
0.5141142010688782,
0.800484836101532,
1.03714120388031,
-0.5349107384681702,
-0.2683033049106598,
-0.08746973425149918,
-0.5212333798408508,
-0.03526923432946205,
-0.06722374260425568,
-0.5890589356422424,
0.7702367305755615,
0.47036850452423096,
-0.3829290568828583,
0.3197442889213562,
0.38429149985313416,
-0.9468313455581665,
0.28473949432373047,
-0.33041441440582275,
0.24411900341510773,
-0.9895058274269104,
0.2890392243862152,
-0.4272981882095337,
-0.3562816381454468,
-0.9722570180892944,
0.17283737659454346,
-0.35219821333885193,
-0.03216330707073212,
-0.10437101125717163,
0.5383633971214294,
-0.6050906181335449,
-0.3588316738605499,
-0.4386715292930603,
0.15094509720802307,
-0.3414299488067627,
0.5379505157470703,
0.08445531874895096,
0.6638280749320984,
0.5886311531066895,
-0.7452359795570374,
0.30828726291656494,
0.3731800615787506,
-0.30790096521377563,
0.5300767421722412,
-0.5088504552841187,
0.5060386061668396,
-0.5245962142944336,
-0.232130229473114,
-0.9668689370155334,
0.22466503083705902,
0.24817900359630585,
-0.3097193241119385,
0.05039098486304283,
-0.011562525294721127,
-0.6586013436317444,
-0.45965883135795593,
-0.020486705005168915,
0.40142643451690674,
0.18640053272247314,
-0.7769018411636353,
0.56080561876297,
0.4555954933166504,
0.12171036750078201,
-0.6663967370986938,
-0.4427798390388489,
0.20768748223781586,
0.05665938928723335,
-0.6206842660903931,
0.6491753458976746,
-0.33043068647384644,
-0.6188178658485413,
0.18912512063980103,
-0.13616378605365753,
-0.39911946654319763,
0.42261219024658203,
-0.03871987387537956,
0.25449103116989136,
-0.13892994821071625,
0.1665273755788803,
0.020243190228939056,
-0.010219580493867397,
0.11996365338563919,
-0.37998440861701965,
0.8767337203025818,
-0.11312539130449295,
-0.2974099814891815,
-0.43365272879600525,
0.5064736604690552,
0.5233385562896729,
-0.2725065052509308,
0.7410358190536499,
0.5836400389671326,
-0.6649337410926819,
-0.24973061680793762,
-0.6197430491447449,
-0.3046097457408905,
-0.5656505823135376,
0.1825992316007614,
-0.7957608103752136,
-0.6666168570518494,
0.6940788626670837,
0.30966320633888245,
0.655591607093811,
0.18976710736751556,
0.7755330204963684,
0.34638381004333496,
0.656460702419281,
0.5708228349685669,
-0.20650383830070496,
0.6123826503753662,
0.13897734880447388,
0.2734358012676239,
-0.3629136383533478,
0.023949047550559044,
-0.492988258600235,
-0.31634214520454407,
-0.6571364402770996,
-0.5571064352989197,
-0.21589981019496918,
0.08777604252099991,
-0.3812839686870575,
0.5739521384239197,
-0.580510139465332,
0.5724025964736938,
0.6806507706642151,
-0.07130876928567886,
0.424273282289505,
0.03195871040225029,
-0.4165675938129425,
0.31154754757881165,
-0.31126025319099426,
-0.607475757598877,
0.924732506275177,
0.3900875151157379,
-0.07820763438940048,
0.4158913791179657,
1.1796749830245972,
0.5363621115684509,
0.003231688169762492,
-0.7879606485366821,
0.6312690377235413,
-0.299714058637619,
-0.8020521998405457,
-0.3849821090698242,
-0.37215325236320496,
-0.9680147767066956,
0.054292935878038406,
-0.3117716312408447,
-0.7249270081520081,
0.37957069277763367,
-0.173305481672287,
-0.1113595962524414,
0.4677625298500061,
-0.5813585519790649,
0.503135621547699,
-0.08488988131284714,
-0.09009639173746109,
-0.19192302227020264,
-0.24416393041610718,
0.29649773240089417,
-0.32180458307266235,
0.14454959332942963,
-0.12745259702205658,
-0.26438483595848083,
0.9013065695762634,
-0.6505316495895386,
0.6637497544288635,
-0.5118921399116516,
-0.3161527216434479,
0.411521315574646,
0.22595763206481934,
0.4476358890533447,
0.13581213355064392,
-0.2930448353290558,
0.18568682670593262,
0.3405352830886841,
-0.654491662979126,
-0.5312061905860901,
0.22366172075271606,
-0.5297397971153259,
-0.50128173828125,
-0.3876427710056305,
-0.2563636004924774,
-0.17332062125205994,
0.48185184597969055,
-0.3986729681491852,
0.6359466910362244,
-0.4621865153312683,
-0.5161502957344055,
0.30527016520500183,
0.07612112164497375,
1.0210856199264526,
0.879723310470581,
-0.2391166090965271,
-0.5093902349472046,
0.6604580879211426,
0.15425646305084229,
-0.005712687503546476,
0.5510790944099426,
-0.037152305245399475,
-0.10239721089601517,
-0.7811159491539001,
-0.5513719320297241,
0.15197117626667023,
-0.5098044872283936,
-0.06523224711418152,
-0.2514623701572418,
-0.3130255937576294,
-0.330333411693573,
-0.20125894248485565,
-0.32896846532821655,
-0.4248889982700348,
0.10153783112764359,
0.03231438249349594,
0.5329820513725281,
0.8695381879806519,
-0.32527458667755127,
0.10344497859477997,
-0.8014278411865234,
0.3541170060634613,
0.3250253200531006,
0.7827661633491516,
-0.032563526183366776,
-0.08207101374864578,
-0.12855149805545807,
-0.24610280990600586,
0.3291153907775879,
-0.9194667339324951,
0.07161503285169601,
-0.012752670794725418,
0.7780852913856506,
0.20058275759220123,
-0.03701803460717201,
0.5120131969451904,
-0.6288543343544006,
0.48190033435821533,
0.045306820422410965,
-1.462755560874939,
0.17399653792381287,
-0.12194059789180756,
-0.22812563180923462,
0.5167790055274963,
0.23811393976211548,
-0.4459057152271271,
-0.11695170402526855,
-0.3830474317073822,
-0.6010971665382385,
0.5256157517433167,
0.4284045100212097,
0.1703415960073471,
-0.5347194075584412,
0.7933030128479004,
-0.01289790403097868,
0.11942517012357712,
-0.39057105779647827,
-0.5633965730667114,
0.003358439775183797,
-0.37375107407569885,
0.13057787716388702,
-0.4016076326370239,
0.09179963171482086,
0.033410124480724335,
0.824648916721344,
-0.027364294975996017,
0.5212717056274414,
0.4626583158969879,
0.10245567560195923,
0.04286981001496315,
0.050897274166345596,
0.2642368674278259,
0.3310728073120117,
-0.271511971950531,
0.10911297798156738,
-0.22145909070968628,
-0.616351842880249,
0.4720139801502228,
0.25027504563331604,
-0.29100847244262695,
0.10766980051994324,
-0.13955028355121613,
0.7681488990783691,
-0.023143446072936058,
-0.7553977370262146,
0.3350822925567627,
-0.08445892482995987,
-0.18104660511016846,
-0.20182204246520996,
-0.2915555536746979,
-0.13062776625156403,
0.24974167346954346,
0.31776630878448486,
-0.39176344871520996,
0.09299181401729584,
-0.514193058013916,
0.583314061164856,
0.6050583124160767,
-0.019548477604985237,
-0.099672831594944,
0.357919305562973,
0.4182277321815491,
-0.4252150058746338,
0.4585806131362915,
-0.6657968759536743,
-0.29320085048675537,
0.5123110413551331,
0.5786740183830261,
1.1287890672683716,
-0.1268070787191391,
0.11212290078401566,
0.3807255029678345,
0.565220296382904,
0.12395381927490234,
0.5674167275428772,
0.038915228098630905,
-0.9769306182861328,
-0.6675490736961365,
-0.9863036870956421,
-0.4290415346622467,
-0.08293747156858444,
-0.038815997540950775,
0.2607647776603699,
-0.7424352169036865,
-0.2649562656879425,
0.2410949468612671,
0.27206555008888245,
-0.591002881526947,
0.013282896019518375,
0.07225412130355835,
0.8409566283226013,
-0.6562588214874268,
0.6424016356468201,
0.7586804032325745,
-0.41729676723480225,
-0.49699002504348755,
-0.1774432510137558,
-0.3325594663619995,
-0.7136059999465942,
0.8513218760490417,
-0.07651981711387634,
-0.06376120448112488,
0.20596233010292053,
0.17156371474266052,
-1.1894761323928833,
0.7274451851844788,
0.11048293113708496,
-0.5140745043754578,
0.0007109714206308126,
0.2436898648738861,
0.36730799078941345,
-0.3065764904022217,
-0.05958249792456627,
1.012925148010254,
0.5572733283042908,
-0.2713842988014221,
-1.0678513050079346,
0.47293248772621155,
-0.26111510396003723,
0.09539926797151566,
0.4206121861934662,
-0.5887141227722168,
0.7004974484443665,
0.24417002499103546,
-0.6916638016700745,
0.2325797975063324,
0.7411978840827942,
-0.3727911412715912,
0.05620583891868591,
0.5754400491714478,
0.4021194577217102,
0.9692316651344299,
0.16771113872528076,
0.39321252703666687,
-0.6681860089302063,
-0.05321214720606804,
0.8577552437782288,
-0.2573196291923523,
0.6239803433418274,
0.4940570294857025,
-0.32135942578315735,
0.5690385103225708,
0.3301624059677124,
-0.1375223696231842,
0.11376737803220749,
0.5589619874954224,
-0.5512311458587646,
0.13569742441177368,
0.10847794264554977,
0.20737813413143158,
0.7575211524963379,
0.1177411824464798,
-0.45058146119117737,
-0.21540385484695435,
-0.2046125829219818,
0.015534325502812862,
0.341469407081604,
-0.45697328448295593,
1.1150552034378052,
-0.2218337059020996,
-0.6211507320404053,
0.6725302934646606,
0.588235080242157,
0.9626917839050293,
-0.34188756346702576,
0.23703894019126892,
-0.15786942839622498,
-0.09433229267597198,
-0.25844287872314453,
-0.2768581211566925,
0.7577925324440002,
0.06651601940393448,
-0.31275200843811035,
0.17862898111343384,
0.6417578458786011,
-0.20966847240924835,
-0.34187793731689453,
0.13369467854499817,
0.6353222131729126,
0.4038403630256653,
0.33054929971694946,
-0.38372474908828735,
-0.07100855559110641,
-0.37296542525291443,
-0.28817662596702576,
0.10450377315282822,
0.3680742084980011,
-0.11501076072454453,
0.2631153464317322,
0.6149747371673584,
-0.03964148834347725,
0.20658354461193085,
-0.1150059625506401,
0.5099303126335144,
-0.7336465120315552,
-0.48418840765953064,
-1.0697821378707886,
0.0950569286942482,
-0.0882568359375,
0.1293574571609497,
0.46645084023475647,
0.5885696411132812,
0.5401821732521057,
0.003469841554760933,
0.6349599957466125,
-0.4777481257915497,
0.18959257006645203,
-0.5347047448158264,
0.5552477240562439,
-0.07266899198293686,
-0.10609174519777298,
-0.28011825680732727,
-0.8635808825492859,
-0.21088719367980957,
0.5515647530555725,
0.10154552757740021,
-0.32821032404899597,
0.7352283596992493,
0.7334666848182678,
0.3149159848690033,
0.062091801315546036,
0.12066201120615005,
-0.04772292822599411,
0.2728574573993683,
0.4313080906867981,
-0.0740833505988121,
-0.4594210982322693,
0.150803804397583,
-0.39402657747268677,
-0.5579531788825989,
0.13844218850135803,
-1.2310914993286133,
-1.1168696880340576,
-0.754165768623352,
-0.2866867184638977,
-0.30131658911705017,
0.08685789257287979,
1.22796630859375,
0.4253281354904175,
-0.8692929744720459,
-0.25263893604278564,
-0.5581715703010559,
0.24963539838790894,
-0.5040263533592224,
-0.23522256314754486,
0.5447063446044922,
-0.7951989769935608,
-1.3141590356826782,
0.54271000623703,
0.1877187341451645,
0.392543226480484,
-0.4846373200416565,
0.0808982327580452,
-0.25234076380729675,
0.8175917267799377,
0.715831995010376,
0.1805657148361206,
-0.23818987607955933,
-0.523615300655365,
-0.23067806661128998,
-0.023108912631869316,
-0.0989709123969078,
0.8385852575302124,
-0.5948838591575623,
0.4424133896827698,
0.7687426209449768,
0.9553980827331543,
0.21775157749652863,
-0.024498367682099342,
0.8278043270111084,
-0.6943467259407043,
0.3486122488975525,
-0.14590086042881012,
0.4003838300704956,
0.06389646232128143,
-0.2718912959098816,
0.6557791233062744,
0.4268583357334137,
-0.40087366104125977,
-0.7933797836303711,
0.44048023223876953,
-0.8701716661453247,
-0.2614887058734894,
0.7450566291809082,
-0.027017975226044655,
-0.3739849328994751,
-0.5007554292678833,
-0.22452636063098907,
0.3273424506187439,
-0.1735611855983734,
0.8149232864379883,
0.6791008710861206,
0.03489476442337036,
0.6656426191329956,
0.05819813162088394,
0.6454892158508301,
0.36342471837997437,
-0.6482942700386047,
0.03892575949430466,
0.4022979140281677,
0.4174594283103943,
0.25684648752212524,
1.1211369037628174,
-0.31750157475471497,
0.031756073236465454,
0.2665669620037079,
0.14136454463005066,
-0.19867724180221558,
0.1467749923467636,
-0.20876024663448334,
0.29053258895874023,
0.2467772215604782,
-0.42166876792907715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07667v1
|
Backdoor Removal for Generative Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T11:53:42 | 2024-05-13T11:53:42 |
Haoran Li, Yulin Chen, Zihao Zheng, Qi Hu, Chunkit Chan, Heshan Liu, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
With rapid advances, generative large language models (LLMs) dominate various
Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks from understanding to reasoning. Yet,
language models' inherent vulnerabilities may be exacerbated due to increased
accessibility and unrestricted model training on massive textual data from the
Internet. A malicious adversary may publish poisoned data online and conduct
backdoor attacks on the victim LLMs pre-trained on the poisoned data.
Backdoored LLMs behave innocuously for normal queries and generate harmful
responses when the backdoor trigger is activated. Despite significant efforts
paid to LLMs' safety issues, LLMs are still struggling against backdoor
attacks. As Anthropic recently revealed, existing safety training strategies,
including supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF), fail to revoke the backdoors once the LLM is backdoored during
the pre-training stage. In this paper, we present Simulate and Eliminate
(SANDE) to erase the undesired backdoored mappings for generative LLMs. We
initially propose Overwrite Supervised Fine-tuning (OSFT) for effective
backdoor removal when the trigger is known. Then, to handle the scenarios where
the trigger patterns are unknown, we integrate OSFT into our two-stage
framework, SANDE. Unlike previous works that center on the identification of
backdoors, our safety-enhanced LLMs are able to behave normally even when the
exact triggers are activated. We conduct comprehensive experiments to show that
our proposed SANDE is effective against backdoor attacks while bringing minimal
harm to LLMs' powerful capability without any additional access to unbackdoored
clean models. We will release the reproducible code.
|
[
-0.27248767018318176,
-1.0764482021331787,
0.4545999765396118,
-0.004767604637891054,
-0.12444368004798889,
-0.003252490423619747,
-0.40101251006126404,
-0.4814780056476593,
-0.2980313003063202,
0.8849720358848572,
-0.6210030913352966,
-0.8198359608650208,
-0.5823066234588623,
-0.3082355856895447,
-0.7029733061790466,
1.1137189865112305,
0.11662764102220535,
-0.302104115486145,
0.034183815121650696,
0.1693471223115921,
-0.19234301149845123,
-0.6212095022201538,
-0.7931450605392456,
-0.2802123427391052,
0.4182913303375244,
0.0972180962562561,
0.6862576007843018,
0.4553678631782532,
0.306683748960495,
0.3294942378997803,
-0.19702988862991333,
-0.23378607630729675,
-0.9833058714866638,
0.22868531942367554,
-0.3849131464958191,
-0.4767036437988281,
-0.44767165184020996,
-0.040735095739364624,
0.4866291582584381,
0.3934655785560608,
-0.4651579260826111,
-0.02514011226594448,
0.05902939662337303,
0.4575478732585907,
-0.7305228114128113,
0.02921670861542225,
-0.9729889035224915,
0.21886557340621948,
-0.05597950890660286,
-0.37723439931869507,
-0.6121281981468201,
-0.3240814805030823,
-0.3006674349308014,
-0.4043484330177307,
0.34466826915740967,
0.10648132860660553,
0.6966511011123657,
0.251542866230011,
-0.10457143932580948,
0.005812016315758228,
-0.6740580201148987,
0.6474671363830566,
-0.8423596024513245,
0.427053838968277,
0.3361571133136749,
0.13144657015800476,
-0.8113166689872742,
-0.4630705416202545,
-0.4965304732322693,
-0.30867284536361694,
0.05343162640929222,
0.04308200627565384,
-0.23580768704414368,
0.1836014986038208,
0.3704216182231903,
0.29500895738601685,
-0.7138888239860535,
0.637624204158783,
-0.31554076075553894,
-0.3393545150756836,
0.7682892680168152,
0.2733127176761627,
0.14277487993240356,
0.09669700264930725,
-0.4132678806781769,
-0.10393771529197693,
-1.1618995666503906,
-0.1248236745595932,
0.5128361582756042,
0.22031527757644653,
0.005234957206994295,
0.4609276354312897,
-0.14062562584877014,
0.5126075148582458,
-0.03467840328812599,
-0.10060375183820724,
0.14650027453899384,
0.054503776133060455,
-0.25480884313583374,
-0.1265755593776703,
0.7084090113639832,
0.2813279330730438,
0.3352992832660675,
-0.4923756420612335,
-0.504851758480072,
-0.051591143012046814,
0.3755530118942261,
-0.8257015943527222,
-0.052417777478694916,
0.40502527356147766,
-0.46964842081069946,
-0.6401183605194092,
-0.08888766169548035,
-0.9197952747344971,
-0.46875879168510437,
0.05564698949456215,
0.5762691497802734,
-0.4515995681285858,
-0.3130503296852112,
0.12709781527519226,
-0.017492422834038734,
0.39914754033088684,
0.41657835245132446,
-0.7845895886421204,
0.4007561504840851,
0.9501397013664246,
0.5032284259796143,
-0.05222750082612038,
-0.38523513078689575,
-0.8179783821105957,
0.31225305795669556,
-0.42122721672058105,
0.19744570553302765,
-0.36515945196151733,
-0.49824729561805725,
0.11093629896640778,
0.09826252609491348,
0.10859573632478714,
-0.7221965789794922,
0.07853353768587112,
-0.9227280020713806,
0.06693930923938751,
0.20190660655498505,
-0.4593445360660553,
-0.33000293374061584,
0.45809710025787354,
-0.4612427055835724,
0.7038477659225464,
-0.2018272429704666,
-0.39913132786750793,
-0.004912355449050665,
-0.3758690655231476,
-0.5725382566452026,
-0.20932941138744354,
0.0034887397196143866,
-0.6289212703704834,
0.13391073048114777,
0.2500405013561249,
0.4848954379558563,
-0.09465078264474869,
0.26568570733070374,
-0.44713717699050903,
-0.4466533958911896,
0.02154294028878212,
-0.5688467621803284,
0.8856833577156067,
0.19243118166923523,
-0.4488663673400879,
0.2279263585805893,
-0.8248371481895447,
-0.019878875464200974,
0.1765502244234085,
-0.2953275442123413,
-0.30648356676101685,
-0.06051564961671829,
-0.11753430217504501,
0.313122034072876,
-0.031237903982400894,
-0.7473235726356506,
0.04326635226607323,
-0.8643631339073181,
0.222870334982872,
0.9442658424377441,
0.21504612267017365,
0.2570872902870178,
-0.21712283790111542,
0.6090747117996216,
-0.010513699613511562,
0.31033334136009216,
-0.1817559450864792,
-0.45545312762260437,
-0.4698280096054077,
-0.4093104898929596,
0.053825657814741135,
0.6262398958206177,
-0.6998757719993591,
0.4829394519329071,
-0.08562546223402023,
-0.4365710914134979,
-0.26547005772590637,
0.2814636528491974,
0.702035665512085,
0.2466413676738739,
0.3150402009487152,
-0.20697557926177979,
-0.2492913007736206,
-0.5951094031333923,
-0.32404935359954834,
0.046564582735300064,
-0.21711580455303192,
-0.03588002547621727,
0.6381409168243408,
-0.3208068013191223,
0.8165438175201416,
-0.5519090294837952,
-0.286767840385437,
0.043056391179561615,
0.2020234316587448,
-0.03569266200065613,
0.6748146414756775,
0.4599200189113617,
-0.6713619828224182,
-0.02861219458281994,
-0.18042732775211334,
-0.7526679635047913,
-0.07438022643327713,
-0.12723134458065033,
0.09964612126350403,
0.22967270016670227,
0.7532568573951721,
-0.6164725422859192,
0.6891477704048157,
0.6275841593742371,
0.085751473903656,
0.49422433972358704,
-0.18814365565776825,
-0.040548525750637054,
-0.9209325313568115,
-0.015809962525963783,
-0.18459932506084442,
-0.225282683968544,
-0.5042774081230164,
0.660712480545044,
0.07513601332902908,
-0.4625217020511627,
-0.5050729513168335,
0.5757675170898438,
-0.21582329273223877,
-0.08847177773714066,
-0.14843758940696716,
-0.07084545493125916,
-0.1977349817752838,
0.6964078545570374,
-0.0673237219452858,
0.6823838353157043,
0.383310467004776,
-0.4435482621192932,
0.38557928800582886,
0.08774080127477646,
-0.03276838734745979,
0.25671499967575073,
-0.5627928376197815,
0.17068655788898468,
-0.16401217877864838,
0.41034770011901855,
-0.9370618462562561,
-0.14995311200618744,
0.4667176604270935,
-0.3103606700897217,
0.4762316346168518,
-0.31145617365837097,
-0.6885678768157959,
-0.13103437423706055,
-0.5200908184051514,
0.12214627861976624,
0.6579163074493408,
-0.7499994039535522,
0.585360050201416,
0.0796244889497757,
-0.12797021865844727,
-0.32521507143974304,
-0.41953009366989136,
0.12738744914531708,
-0.1253940612077713,
-0.5414277911186218,
0.1679067313671112,
-0.0040457905270159245,
-0.07245197147130966,
-0.11605250090360641,
-0.02899416722357273,
-0.17257818579673767,
0.430620938539505,
0.6281333565711975,
0.14705070853233337,
-0.10147947072982788,
0.25688374042510986,
0.01585312746465206,
-0.25393426418304443,
0.2554270923137665,
-0.06943529099225998,
0.656671941280365,
-0.07811819016933441,
-0.5509940981864929,
-0.4242596924304962,
0.41322582960128784,
0.534386932849884,
-0.4058341085910797,
0.898344874382019,
0.5795554518699646,
-0.5223201513290405,
-0.23652318120002747,
-0.6269258260726929,
-0.5124437212944031,
-0.5109007358551025,
0.5515114068984985,
-0.2930355370044708,
-0.8259632587432861,
0.5201871395111084,
-0.1494857519865036,
0.34207791090011597,
0.21943093836307526,
0.4218810498714447,
-0.05336916446685791,
0.8672691583633423,
0.4816673994064331,
-0.148926243185997,
0.26697924733161926,
-0.28832343220710754,
0.28748369216918945,
-0.6848950386047363,
-0.22538550198078156,
-0.45383012294769287,
-0.011290754191577435,
-0.5954733490943909,
-0.04892096295952797,
0.3148585259914398,
0.20224855840206146,
-0.20065945386886597,
0.1943322867155075,
-0.07103055715560913,
0.4801774024963379,
0.40284839272499084,
0.3945452570915222,
0.3557964861392975,
-0.05615230277180672,
0.013452435843646526,
0.10337010771036148,
-0.4809158742427826,
-0.2313532531261444,
1.0783482789993286,
0.5180996656417847,
1.111749291419983,
0.06579702347517014,
0.9801062941551208,
-0.07787778973579407,
0.44419509172439575,
-0.5482102036476135,
0.7225145697593689,
-0.05243011564016342,
-0.618464469909668,
-0.39571908116340637,
-0.4722333550453186,
-0.8329442739486694,
0.26944202184677124,
-0.3795180320739746,
-0.7723293900489807,
-0.1699800342321396,
0.3835422098636627,
-0.4604983627796173,
0.6264533400535583,
-0.6259129047393799,
0.6668915152549744,
-0.05144192650914192,
-0.40684646368026733,
-0.543321967124939,
-0.7215155959129333,
0.6753670573234558,
-0.41739192605018616,
0.2950987219810486,
0.10462959855794907,
0.24460674822330475,
0.4179285764694214,
-0.48076385259628296,
1.1653131246566772,
-0.09524272382259369,
-0.5004391670227051,
-0.14764215052127838,
0.2658962309360504,
0.8120576739311218,
0.1495041847229004,
-0.012788678519427776,
0.35988524556159973,
-0.2312609702348709,
-0.1988745480775833,
-0.5668051242828369,
0.6963350176811218,
-0.5453703999519348,
-0.9465219974517822,
-0.30191686749458313,
-0.4004293978214264,
-0.1969168335199356,
0.11242792010307312,
0.32819658517837524,
0.2953869700431824,
-0.0684519112110138,
0.19820034503936768,
0.8051398992538452,
-0.6838875412940979,
0.44904690980911255,
0.7276628017425537,
-0.3141290843486786,
-0.1589076966047287,
0.7802678346633911,
-0.22485342621803284,
0.49036383628845215,
0.31993988156318665,
0.17909765243530273,
-0.07178252190351486,
-0.7742814421653748,
-0.12625084817409515,
0.03379218652844429,
-0.489963561296463,
-0.31476539373397827,
-0.5790318250656128,
-0.6217836141586304,
-0.39470478892326355,
-0.09761397540569305,
-0.4699016511440277,
0.01204795390367508,
-0.17920474708080292,
-0.09458070248365402,
0.4260368049144745,
0.40929722785949707,
-0.212535560131073,
0.5063830614089966,
-0.9769023060798645,
0.4726339876651764,
0.4255433976650238,
0.433045893907547,
0.10710988938808441,
-0.4081505537033081,
-0.020839132368564606,
0.12900356948375702,
-0.3052498400211334,
-0.6261653900146484,
0.44617587327957153,
0.06421324610710144,
0.4054303765296936,
0.37123778462409973,
0.12300759553909302,
0.4936006963253021,
-0.5515540242195129,
0.4948066771030426,
0.16717569530010223,
-0.7622998356819153,
0.5602086782455444,
-0.4211795926094055,
-0.03875385969877243,
0.2715558707714081,
0.11912985146045685,
-0.39552268385887146,
-0.7315978407859802,
-0.6177091598510742,
-0.9174957275390625,
0.41873839497566223,
0.14845556020736694,
0.17782433331012726,
0.14431145787239075,
0.43368789553642273,
0.2062360793352127,
0.47793272137641907,
-0.6006140112876892,
-0.06883690506219864,
-0.006990107707679272,
0.049882423132658005,
-0.0861268863081932,
-0.37313389778137207,
-0.1640278398990631,
-0.07379195094108582,
0.8061023950576782,
0.23914362490177155,
-0.09346935898065567,
-0.2164529263973236,
-0.1966705173254013,
-0.3189294934272766,
0.47151389718055725,
0.46683400869369507,
0.29220330715179443,
-0.27631479501724243,
0.056764379143714905,
0.2679550349712372,
-0.44247713685035706,
0.12583331763744354,
0.01549178920686245,
-0.24770593643188477,
-0.421838641166687,
0.511141836643219,
0.4001480042934418,
0.4120730757713318,
-0.6486201882362366,
0.5705229043960571,
0.14090116322040558,
-0.03614414110779762,
-0.3657248020172119,
0.4408626854419708,
-0.06832220405340195,
0.19480814039707184,
0.16000071167945862,
0.05892555043101311,
0.03743598610162735,
-0.6576160192489624,
0.38481250405311584,
0.5522639751434326,
-0.19652241468429565,
-0.26088428497314453,
0.5042410492897034,
0.1965918242931366,
-0.38980337977409363,
0.7591759562492371,
-0.07110156118869781,
-0.7008519768714905,
0.5225331783294678,
0.6226347088813782,
0.8489730358123779,
-0.3278677761554718,
-0.06783394515514374,
0.123560331761837,
0.5623959302902222,
0.04232237860560417,
0.0913325846195221,
0.2360660880804062,
-0.7927983999252319,
-0.24521027505397797,
-0.6032081842422485,
-0.1261637806892395,
0.5401124358177185,
-0.5866820812225342,
-0.08007931709289551,
-0.7368509769439697,
0.18886353075504303,
-0.26898863911628723,
-0.2333764284849167,
-0.41127705574035645,
0.2697242200374603,
0.003181232139468193,
0.6917074918746948,
-0.9658749103546143,
0.8455132246017456,
0.20674896240234375,
-0.2775017321109772,
-0.7523958086967468,
0.22118140757083893,
0.2521021366119385,
-0.8804858922958374,
0.561001718044281,
0.05160520225763321,
-0.2401895374059677,
0.24639259278774261,
-0.7927943468093872,
-0.49655720591545105,
0.6388838887214661,
0.4056752026081085,
-0.7282575964927673,
0.041518401354551315,
-0.161522775888443,
0.46840205788612366,
0.12635508179664612,
-0.29713118076324463,
0.5000705718994141,
0.33054420351982117,
0.0517052561044693,
-0.6829062700271606,
0.1640891432762146,
-0.03029225394129753,
0.07648637145757675,
0.3140537440776825,
-0.3634442687034607,
0.8088023662567139,
-0.36412644386291504,
-0.14492778480052948,
0.28042683005332947,
0.38064607977867126,
0.46036675572395325,
0.20306190848350525,
0.5172221064567566,
0.791517972946167,
0.3144621253013611,
-0.05165603756904602,
0.8544536232948303,
-0.10388555377721786,
0.3011361360549927,
1.3502068519592285,
-0.41712772846221924,
1.004105806350708,
0.5957677364349365,
0.07916948199272156,
0.13968847692012787,
0.30950018763542175,
-0.16119445860385895,
0.6179300546646118,
0.41683095693588257,
-0.22065198421478271,
-0.2937036156654358,
0.26711544394493103,
-0.5271884202957153,
0.605235755443573,
0.36310383677482605,
-0.26538506150245667,
-0.562544584274292,
0.2831723392009735,
0.13586431741714478,
0.26441314816474915,
-0.26735350489616394,
0.8173813819885254,
0.084072545170784,
-0.3030109107494354,
0.5038744807243347,
0.20072363317012787,
0.6146901249885559,
-0.6318027973175049,
-0.16788876056671143,
-0.1779281347990036,
0.3266744017601013,
-0.26894015073776245,
-0.6559247970581055,
0.302733838558197,
-0.05382926017045975,
0.04662460833787918,
-0.19824233651161194,
0.6451125144958496,
-0.44089341163635254,
-0.11755058914422989,
0.539317786693573,
0.0966024398803711,
-0.013688866049051285,
-0.3019436001777649,
-0.4374571442604065,
0.1004369854927063,
-0.14708596467971802,
-0.42042189836502075,
0.5167912244796753,
0.22605343163013458,
-0.04414641857147217,
0.8000552654266357,
0.979985773563385,
0.24968017637729645,
0.10272848606109619,
0.030478760600090027,
1.0463216304779053,
-0.6745432615280151,
-0.49791499972343445,
-0.8797959685325623,
0.1974998116493225,
-0.06733408570289612,
0.008864177390933037,
0.6914961934089661,
0.5734657049179077,
0.820328950881958,
-0.13196729123592377,
0.6192765235900879,
0.2981422245502472,
0.4050021469593048,
-0.8104512095451355,
0.998370885848999,
-0.45501017570495605,
0.6072682738304138,
-0.22000652551651,
-0.6404395699501038,
-0.34770479798316956,
0.3890758454799652,
-0.31172797083854675,
0.02427765540778637,
0.38594821095466614,
1.2352025508880615,
0.027525849640369415,
0.1042548269033432,
0.503900945186615,
0.5741833448410034,
0.5764413475990295,
0.612412691116333,
0.9094759821891785,
-0.42884179949760437,
0.48209214210510254,
-0.2771027088165283,
-0.3177715241909027,
-0.3398768901824951,
-0.8748546838760376,
-0.9846407771110535,
-0.18407148122787476,
-0.1657014638185501,
-0.39865031838417053,
0.5837225317955017,
0.8076308369636536,
0.5933335423469543,
-0.9353375434875488,
0.09231376647949219,
-0.12244363129138947,
0.1870313435792923,
-0.2233150452375412,
-0.20763741433620453,
0.12986548244953156,
-0.2532217800617218,
-0.23158322274684906,
0.40262314677238464,
0.36274778842926025,
0.0635429099202156,
-0.27071887254714966,
-0.014887126162648201,
-0.012494265101850033,
-0.20482543110847473,
0.5116645097732544,
0.40560728311538696,
-0.8441135883331299,
-0.5279034376144409,
-0.4197157919406891,
-0.33139532804489136,
-0.1193411722779274,
0.5226089358329773,
-0.7833008170127869,
0.2795933783054352,
0.31404435634613037,
0.55003821849823,
0.39411091804504395,
-0.14054344594478607,
0.7864356637001038,
-0.9937102794647217,
0.4250152111053467,
0.26027506589889526,
0.17017370462417603,
-0.04170077666640282,
-0.5510230660438538,
0.2974790334701538,
0.11088348180055618,
-0.17816832661628723,
-0.7836011052131653,
0.4001315236091614,
-0.5495536923408508,
-0.5260058641433716,
1.1582424640655518,
-0.320354700088501,
-0.20760078728199005,
-0.12820938229560852,
-0.06499157100915909,
0.25262391567230225,
-0.21032796800136566,
1.0541696548461914,
0.3799434304237366,
0.45901304483413696,
-0.0720033347606659,
-0.44157472252845764,
0.4937128722667694,
0.14239487051963806,
-0.965943455696106,
0.1999025046825409,
0.4685209393501282,
0.5233238935470581,
-0.1436452567577362,
0.3429068624973297,
-0.303996205329895,
0.3391971290111542,
-0.1623348742723465,
0.14152920246124268,
-0.28222236037254333,
-0.3971794843673706,
-0.6101235151290894,
0.35152313113212585,
-0.12275754660367966,
-0.24801750481128693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07663v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07663v1
|
Sign Stitching: A Novel Approach to Sign Language Production
| 2024-05-13T11:44:57 | 2024-05-13T11:44:57 |
Harry Walsh, Ben Saunders, Richard Bowden
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Sign Language Production (SLP) is a challenging task, given the limited
resources available and the inherent diversity within sign data. As a result,
previous works have suffered from the problem of regression to the mean,
leading to under-articulated and incomprehensible signing. In this paper, we
propose using dictionary examples and a learnt codebook of facial expressions
to create expressive sign language sequences. However, simply concatenating
signs and adding the face creates robotic and unnatural sequences. To address
this we present a 7-step approach to effectively stitch sequences together.
First, by normalizing each sign into a canonical pose, cropping, and stitching
we create a continuous sequence. Then, by applying filtering in the frequency
domain and resampling each sign, we create cohesive natural sequences that
mimic the prosody found in the original data. We leverage a SignGAN model to
map the output to a photo-realistic signer and present a complete Text-to-Sign
(T2S) SLP pipeline. Our evaluation demonstrates the effectiveness of the
approach, showcasing state-of-the-art performance across all datasets. Finally,
a user evaluation shows our approach outperforms the baseline model and is
capable of producing realistic sign language sequences.
|
[
0.11373221129179001,
-0.007125752978026867,
0.149160698056221,
0.053711216896772385,
-0.43704551458358765,
0.3685675263404846,
0.19231456518173218,
-0.6476616263389587,
0.6658252477645874,
0.5868289470672607,
-0.5814423561096191,
-0.6941596865653992,
-0.6232144832611084,
-0.014965523965656757,
-0.45628684759140015,
0.9449163675308228,
0.013443460687994957,
-0.031161777675151825,
0.3860603868961334,
-0.27034422755241394,
-0.18188786506652832,
-0.1598873883485794,
-0.5877047777175903,
0.013231556862592697,
0.0776921734213829,
0.30505648255348206,
0.9511959552764893,
0.5906499028205872,
0.30891427397727966,
0.21922408044338226,
-0.004578702617436647,
0.5434598922729492,
-0.20933610200881958,
0.14877551794052124,
0.40939846634864807,
-0.1745985746383667,
-0.5261204242706299,
0.22656039893627167,
0.6357569098472595,
0.6808549761772156,
0.2519111931324005,
0.23028002679347992,
-0.14332909882068634,
0.6136190295219421,
-0.19838184118270874,
-0.21483300626277924,
-0.46981072425842285,
0.23250097036361694,
-0.3416687548160553,
0.3006232678890228,
-0.37769272923469543,
-0.6030498743057251,
-0.3166789412498474,
-0.38913610577583313,
0.22160285711288452,
-0.04321849346160889,
0.4868203401565552,
0.08170129358768463,
-0.25498849153518677,
-0.40740445256233215,
-0.6641631126403809,
0.27056053280830383,
-1.1158273220062256,
0.32002219557762146,
0.07225684076547623,
0.2703803479671478,
-0.0868944525718689,
-0.6310491561889648,
-0.6931447386741638,
-0.20670512318611145,
0.004466442856937647,
0.0008138298289850354,
0.4301416873931885,
0.005260660778731108,
0.46283912658691406,
0.47062450647354126,
-0.8249133229255676,
-0.10456813871860504,
-0.37049221992492676,
-0.1956910938024521,
0.9865381121635437,
0.06089785695075989,
0.5976654887199402,
-0.029942700639367104,
-0.5638055801391602,
-0.29431846737861633,
-0.5713880062103271,
0.02214353159070015,
0.4461863040924072,
0.676734983921051,
-0.13101033866405487,
0.6389949321746826,
-0.060226958245038986,
0.888820469379425,
0.0484505258500576,
-0.24546882510185242,
-0.013101018965244293,
-0.09289490431547165,
0.02221597172319889,
-0.2840983271598816,
0.8839022517204285,
0.3427913784980774,
0.3421764075756073,
-0.11332930624485016,
-0.4424383044242859,
0.13547496497631073,
0.07048220932483673,
-0.17013223469257355,
-0.19417445361614227,
0.1914682686328888,
-0.16391530632972717,
-0.20965370535850525,
0.12288317084312439,
-0.5854222178459167,
-0.6226482391357422,
-0.5377278327941895,
0.5043407678604126,
-0.35018256306648254,
-0.3295106887817383,
0.06043925881385803,
-0.061724983155727386,
0.2386992871761322,
0.12054040282964706,
-0.7166879177093506,
0.3335806429386139,
0.6224066615104675,
1.116172194480896,
-0.10665185749530792,
-0.06636609137058258,
-0.5746280550956726,
-0.08247271180152893,
-0.3646751046180725,
0.3662365674972534,
-0.24877335131168365,
-0.19581744074821472,
0.26471012830734253,
-0.301126092672348,
-0.05518173798918724,
-0.44871723651885986,
0.3024631142616272,
-0.3465080261230469,
0.12520961463451385,
0.2603916823863983,
-0.5091452598571777,
0.10570286214351654,
-0.15455546975135803,
-0.730153501033783,
0.9145629405975342,
0.4211071729660034,
0.03434247896075249,
0.27571219205856323,
-0.3815290927886963,
-0.8180151581764221,
0.22969414293766022,
-0.05499430000782013,
-0.37076202034950256,
0.18242432177066803,
-0.22166074812412262,
0.5209639668464661,
0.05047691613435745,
-0.06277665495872498,
-0.11100107431411743,
-0.19005186855793,
0.26589757204055786,
0.19108501076698303,
0.7639281153678894,
0.2969551384449005,
-0.425772100687027,
-0.0043748789466917515,
-0.9478015899658203,
0.1218341737985611,
-0.08214465528726578,
-0.02411721833050251,
-0.06340105086565018,
-0.3768813908100128,
0.17508874833583832,
0.634791910648346,
-0.12868590652942657,
-0.2780899405479431,
0.35052961111068726,
-0.4189864695072174,
0.2955631911754608,
0.3190370500087738,
-0.16217094659805298,
0.48812639713287354,
-0.3409367501735687,
0.6492600440979004,
-0.13586431741714478,
0.2825533151626587,
-0.41431277990341187,
-0.7136277556419373,
-0.9127153754234314,
-0.04827132448554039,
-0.08005507290363312,
0.42990684509277344,
-0.7967801690101624,
0.2914154827594757,
0.025163020938634872,
-0.6687296032905579,
-0.6486438512802124,
0.18760931491851807,
0.7763949036598206,
0.42819300293922424,
0.22438079118728638,
-1.0212513208389282,
-0.5794192552566528,
-0.4609166085720062,
-0.42126724123954773,
-0.2945183217525482,
-0.10843457281589508,
-0.4217199683189392,
0.11230143159627914,
0.39068636298179626,
0.48735445737838745,
-0.5431410074234009,
-0.6959819793701172,
-0.03160376474261284,
0.15187375247478485,
0.5846061110496521,
0.6630732417106628,
0.1804271936416626,
-0.5548430681228638,
-0.46791112422943115,
-0.05347725376486778,
-0.5010967254638672,
-0.05786067619919777,
-0.7549049854278564,
-0.09050639718770981,
0.3786865174770355,
0.4935051202774048,
-0.7526627779006958,
0.3035581707954407,
0.6857509016990662,
-0.5546240210533142,
0.5447583794593811,
0.04909930005669594,
0.1057080626487732,
-0.9851094484329224,
-0.023016680032014847,
0.08587886393070221,
-0.530620813369751,
-1.0656776428222656,
0.31634387373924255,
-0.2974686622619629,
-0.5894737839698792,
-0.702459454536438,
0.24581481516361237,
-0.8269558548927307,
-0.2820194363594055,
-0.20981034636497498,
0.2179664820432663,
-0.08746437728404999,
0.5177459716796875,
0.03727567568421364,
0.26962873339653015,
0.2833811044692993,
-0.3810097575187683,
0.34615686535835266,
0.4686179459095001,
-0.4144688546657562,
0.3862215578556061,
-0.4690266251564026,
0.3524903953075409,
0.1974998116493225,
0.10915669798851013,
-1.1105984449386597,
-0.1886158436536789,
0.5146422982215881,
-0.5099486708641052,
0.6622048616409302,
-0.1560192108154297,
-0.07954235374927521,
-0.41891294717788696,
-0.18909654021263123,
0.14174076914787292,
0.8723637461662292,
-0.40699055790901184,
0.6167532801628113,
0.4439738094806671,
0.030785342678427696,
-0.08857766538858414,
-0.6451733708381653,
0.4686155319213867,
-0.28206396102905273,
-0.8076702356338501,
0.14480248093605042,
0.04440529644489288,
0.0668783113360405,
-0.7442049384117126,
-0.04774877801537514,
-0.013412768952548504,
-0.04995298758149147,
0.17415127158164978,
0.07630771398544312,
-0.14775972068309784,
-0.19172079861164093,
-0.3022761046886444,
-0.16015523672103882,
-0.17550919950008392,
-0.3294031620025635,
0.355446994304657,
0.10848744213581085,
-0.5432165861129761,
-0.8191326260566711,
0.4615325629711151,
0.8261191844940186,
0.10362483561038971,
0.2258196920156479,
0.5059410929679871,
-0.5936790108680725,
-0.24533405900001526,
-0.20668481290340424,
-0.05166935175657272,
-0.3823150098323822,
-0.0285914558917284,
-0.2926591634750366,
-0.6262959241867065,
0.30975836515426636,
-0.2443276047706604,
0.34036141633987427,
0.05559074878692627,
0.3129102289676666,
-0.3320969343185425,
0.8144420981407166,
0.2920321524143219,
0.35473793745040894,
0.6238614916801453,
-0.1529872715473175,
0.43717676401138306,
-0.5867717266082764,
-0.11836829036474228,
-0.26349732279777527,
-0.5039366483688354,
-0.22877083718776703,
-0.9155675768852234,
0.22815127670764923,
0.2580461800098419,
-0.05767630413174629,
1.0792064666748047,
-0.6009694337844849,
0.3333876430988312,
0.5369663238525391,
0.282539427280426,
0.3917904198169708,
-0.17148025333881378,
0.2011205404996872,
-0.1430799514055252,
-0.4840206205844879,
-0.884459376335144,
0.605373203754425,
0.12423677742481232,
0.5431690216064453,
0.0871695801615715,
0.7745631337165833,
0.37398970127105713,
0.33905741572380066,
-0.5503267645835876,
0.6799758076667786,
-0.38691988587379456,
-0.19604283571243286,
-0.37236475944519043,
0.20732343196868896,
-0.4183852970600128,
0.14188240468502045,
-0.5755712985992432,
-0.5532310009002686,
-0.08293360471725464,
0.6172621250152588,
-0.20822836458683014,
0.09419114887714386,
-0.9001355767250061,
0.749129056930542,
-0.25528484582901,
-0.12897297739982605,
0.17800399661064148,
-1.015389323234558,
0.6726518273353577,
-0.09287883341312408,
0.3272510766983032,
-0.28835901618003845,
0.11189063638448715,
0.4777183532714844,
-0.633798360824585,
1.333578109741211,
-0.2063574343919754,
-0.3907296359539032,
0.40701553225517273,
0.35447436571121216,
0.5631415247917175,
-0.2937447130680084,
-0.060816772282123566,
0.023490644991397858,
-0.14799197018146515,
-0.1962415874004364,
-0.5619178414344788,
0.42585551738739014,
-0.23406565189361572,
-0.4593443274497986,
-0.15797649323940277,
-0.39474377036094666,
-0.2490967959165573,
-0.019365033134818077,
-0.027553018182516098,
0.4402312636375427,
-0.2742042541503906,
-0.5695990920066833,
0.20005442202091217,
0.09585916996002197,
0.572026789188385,
0.12371214479207993,
-0.1768348217010498,
-0.5992933511734009,
0.8002403378486633,
-0.04170013591647148,
0.7281700372695923,
0.12781351804733276,
0.10290183871984482,
-0.3546684980392456,
-0.42659541964530945,
-0.6164974570274353,
0.42910799384117126,
-0.4854813814163208,
-0.3462428152561188,
-0.1267988234758377,
0.07882929593324661,
-0.9029161334037781,
-0.3323984146118164,
-0.3132822811603546,
-0.9454517364501953,
-0.012373826466500759,
0.25771257281303406,
0.23162230849266052,
0.7285788059234619,
-0.2972220480442047,
0.4055124521255493,
-0.8554124236106873,
0.49356579780578613,
0.268927663564682,
0.21170544624328613,
-0.10289493948221207,
-0.2926827073097229,
-0.2110540121793747,
0.0671771690249443,
-0.4075354337692261,
-0.9259753823280334,
0.4607337415218353,
0.7328217029571533,
0.012404145672917366,
0.41808849573135376,
0.3476741313934326,
0.8403941988945007,
-0.5292778611183167,
1.0100030899047852,
0.8324244022369385,
-1.1728136539459229,
0.7447437644004822,
-0.3819759488105774,
0.34596821665763855,
0.173910990357399,
0.25775131583213806,
-0.9807297587394714,
-0.7749586701393127,
-0.6648266315460205,
-0.9426504969596863,
0.5207327604293823,
0.21672184765338898,
0.16208809614181519,
-0.054438233375549316,
0.28850746154785156,
0.07699814438819885,
-0.029068466275930405,
-0.582478404045105,
0.17514310777187347,
-0.17636948823928833,
-0.4398115575313568,
-0.15019208192825317,
0.18622145056724548,
-0.3553130030632019,
-0.05164342001080513,
0.7952218055725098,
-0.3982243835926056,
-0.03880485147237778,
0.09039806574583054,
-0.4371887743473053,
-0.16888019442558289,
-0.21709895133972168,
0.8237978219985962,
0.46025723218917847,
0.265076607465744,
0.17426984012126923,
-0.08225071430206299,
-0.4063186049461365,
0.031124142929911613,
-0.3985205292701721,
-0.28143057227134705,
0.44814977049827576,
0.5083986520767212,
0.9731372594833374,
0.03848721832036972,
-0.5217004418373108,
0.5891475677490234,
0.3743687868118286,
-0.11086618155241013,
-0.3220091760158539,
0.003396865911781788,
0.1431993544101715,
0.3161340653896332,
0.05711527541279793,
0.20602057874202728,
-0.04051951691508293,
-0.40205731987953186,
0.29259413480758667,
0.2373809665441513,
-0.4421437382698059,
-0.540228009223938,
0.7984707951545715,
0.3151397407054901,
-0.9259880781173706,
0.46832460165023804,
0.1284698247909546,
-0.5526345372200012,
0.5602002739906311,
0.6883440613746643,
0.816815197467804,
-0.3305914103984833,
0.5158638954162598,
0.6241158843040466,
0.2687247693538666,
-0.13995862007141113,
0.47436532378196716,
-0.1683720350265503,
-0.507134199142456,
-0.3833788335323334,
-0.5090694427490234,
-0.5050932765007019,
-0.21889321506023407,
-0.5423716902732849,
0.4660128653049469,
-0.4687942564487457,
-0.08039254695177078,
-0.2102188766002655,
-0.3510928452014923,
-0.4100789725780487,
0.5307450890541077,
0.6115284562110901,
0.8111286759376526,
-1.4152437448501587,
0.36083686351776123,
0.5694083571434021,
-0.6219870448112488,
-0.6428260207176208,
-0.1005963459610939,
0.28524553775787354,
-1.1673002243041992,
0.24756766855716705,
0.4048175513744354,
-0.03570179641246796,
-0.008431559428572655,
-0.44783905148506165,
-0.6790260076522827,
0.7548806071281433,
0.2875940799713135,
-0.5233343243598938,
0.043989695608615875,
0.4279859662055969,
0.6726157665252686,
-0.5151529312133789,
-0.21360830962657928,
0.7658711671829224,
0.15823179483413696,
0.5460262298583984,
-0.563197910785675,
0.33992061018943787,
-0.11850171536207199,
0.13948000967502594,
0.34269338846206665,
-0.5165300965309143,
-0.047575630247592926,
-0.47221529483795166,
-0.5705286860466003,
0.404308944940567,
0.894874095916748,
0.26112622022628784,
0.4124455153942108,
0.6026651859283447,
0.5579845905303955,
0.6732356548309326,
-0.07966477423906326,
0.5000990629196167,
-0.40331700444221497,
0.14434684813022614,
0.9891891479492188,
-0.22035656869411469,
0.8613949418067932,
0.6306695938110352,
-0.34100309014320374,
0.27701687812805176,
0.529629111289978,
0.17344708740711212,
0.21411456167697906,
0.5977535843849182,
-0.4955797791481018,
-0.38673433661460876,
-0.17352214455604553,
0.09089893102645874,
0.3659701645374298,
0.1865135282278061,
-0.37757015228271484,
0.06814859062433243,
-0.029664725065231323,
0.004086961504071951,
0.47803598642349243,
0.0024318357463926077,
0.7736384272575378,
0.3478342592716217,
-0.7165287733078003,
0.49386584758758545,
-0.6636236906051636,
0.6003379821777344,
-0.5221840143203735,
-0.08535405248403549,
-0.32129234075546265,
0.03951925411820412,
-0.26819732785224915,
-0.8781836032867432,
0.7139196395874023,
-0.14215458929538727,
0.06176115199923515,
-0.8118306994438171,
0.6772328615188599,
-0.729121744632721,
-0.32296887040138245,
-0.2040402889251709,
0.21116670966148376,
0.6809497475624084,
0.4342925250530243,
-0.47520238161087036,
0.0993734747171402,
-0.037557490170001984,
0.038048289716243744,
0.10487831383943558,
0.17975954711437225,
-0.17276445031166077,
0.2685655951499939,
0.78244549036026,
0.15575595200061798,
0.11129467934370041,
0.4867612421512604,
0.5347817540168762,
-0.6253783702850342,
-0.2854646146297455,
-0.3646748960018158,
0.9180998802185059,
-0.1505241096019745,
-0.7480747699737549,
0.27603745460510254,
0.30778518319129944,
0.7500525116920471,
-0.3843558132648468,
0.5193342566490173,
-0.2489440143108368,
0.3781156539916992,
-0.5271415114402771,
0.6740055084228516,
-0.2478133887052536,
-0.14784005284309387,
-0.5700629949569702,
-0.7572263479232788,
-0.8693990707397461,
0.4340631663799286,
0.4135828912258148,
-0.2780158519744873,
0.29617905616760254,
0.8713495135307312,
0.2587493062019348,
-0.13803404569625854,
0.5955308079719543,
-0.09869805723428726,
0.18307214975357056,
0.711008608341217,
0.568454921245575,
-0.954358696937561,
0.3936575651168823,
-0.0439201295375824,
-0.34312915802001953,
0.1539277285337448,
-1.0782220363616943,
-0.5904296040534973,
-0.998701274394989,
-0.6832685470581055,
-0.5146484971046448,
-0.09101054817438126,
0.9484509825706482,
0.7813695669174194,
-0.8218103647232056,
-0.3976587653160095,
0.06304754316806793,
-0.0030288572888821363,
-0.5545458793640137,
-0.10761826485395432,
0.2171175479888916,
-0.3201647698879242,
-0.8520072102546692,
0.47310030460357666,
0.21954743564128876,
0.3788338303565979,
-0.07315950840711594,
-0.17061586678028107,
-0.14370876550674438,
-0.2189614474773407,
0.5808506608009338,
0.7287828922271729,
-0.5108218789100647,
-0.2605592906475067,
-0.33946695923805237,
0.07474775612354279,
-0.13118916749954224,
0.9328013062477112,
-0.6149439811706543,
0.5228968262672424,
0.5486980676651001,
0.3656099736690521,
0.39955028891563416,
-0.10179145634174347,
0.9066902995109558,
-1.0077067613601685,
-0.1229223683476448,
0.23203636705875397,
0.2074914127588272,
0.6208020448684692,
-0.267848402261734,
0.5739762187004089,
0.44222116470336914,
-0.18194185197353363,
-0.6316620707511902,
0.6068376898765564,
-1.1181854009628296,
0.1901988387107849,
0.9244025349617004,
-0.18113973736763,
-0.09876294434070587,
-0.14712806046009064,
-0.17595644295215607,
0.6307957172393799,
-0.03770401328802109,
0.7092345356941223,
0.23955458402633667,
-0.3445088267326355,
-0.14271460473537445,
0.20087175071239471,
0.5656353235244751,
0.1395370066165924,
-0.45273223519325256,
0.0808592140674591,
0.675049901008606,
-0.02174854651093483,
0.2796642780303955,
0.6235611438751221,
-0.0882955864071846,
0.27434828877449036,
0.07202530652284622,
0.3209998905658722,
0.0038191061466932297,
-0.09913897514343262,
-0.3772326409816742,
0.11192046850919724,
0.1362297236919403,
-0.3799712061882019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13009v1
|
METAREFLECTION: Learning Instructions for Language Agents using Past Reflections
| 2024-05-13T10:51:43 | 2024-05-13T10:51:43 |
Priyanshu Gupta, Shashank Kirtania, Ananya Singha, Sumit Gulwani, Arjun Radhakrishna, Sherry Shi, Gustavo Soares
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs), crafting specific
prompts for LLMs to perform particular tasks remains challenging. Users often
engage in multiple conversational turns with an LLM-based agent to accomplish
their intended task. Recent studies have demonstrated that linguistic feedback,
in the form of self-reflections generated by the model, can work as
reinforcement during these conversations, thus enabling quicker convergence to
the desired outcome. Motivated by these findings, we introduce METAREFLECTION,
a novel technique that learns general prompt instructions for a specific domain
from individual self-reflections gathered during a training phase. We evaluate
our technique in two domains: Infrastructure as Code (IAC) vulnerability
detection and question-answering (QA) using REACT and COT. Our results
demonstrate a notable improvement, with METARELECTION outperforming GPT-4 by
16.82% (IAC), 31.33% (COT), and 15.42% (REACT), underscoring the potential of
METAREFLECTION as a viable method for enhancing the efficiency of LLMs.
|
[
-0.4952704906463623,
-0.706938624382019,
0.7438607215881348,
0.16455282270908356,
-0.06919016689062119,
0.23891130089759827,
-0.07759622484445572,
-0.06441102176904678,
0.31683701276779175,
0.781832754611969,
-0.8292869329452515,
-0.6005563139915466,
-0.29769986867904663,
0.23525328934192657,
-0.1341063380241394,
1.166589379310608,
-0.012138268910348415,
0.10346914082765579,
-0.15259385108947754,
-0.15583489835262299,
-0.5994461178779602,
-0.6514025926589966,
-0.4374369978904724,
-0.4135395586490631,
0.5495887398719788,
0.7379820346832275,
0.5763512849807739,
0.05051877722144127,
0.24398945271968842,
0.4649781584739685,
0.3899533152580261,
0.3985341191291809,
-0.04865645244717598,
0.3460620045661926,
-0.3526204824447632,
-0.3320101499557495,
-0.29452991485595703,
0.0602424293756485,
0.5924188494682312,
0.42644408345222473,
-0.32215163111686707,
-0.025574013590812683,
0.33984825015068054,
0.7339102625846863,
-0.8030776977539062,
0.17137360572814941,
-0.24909351766109467,
-0.1258549839258194,
0.10859277844429016,
-0.5586889386177063,
-0.6478466987609863,
-0.203279510140419,
0.0732397809624672,
-0.23749475181102753,
0.1993017941713333,
-0.24962252378463745,
0.47983887791633606,
0.1912820041179657,
-0.3468678593635559,
-0.43261048197746277,
-0.7670003175735474,
0.6578543782234192,
-0.5726540684700012,
0.36436039209365845,
0.32482314109802246,
0.47395947575569153,
-0.15519613027572632,
-0.7703958749771118,
-0.5194389224052429,
-0.36145344376564026,
-0.1284823715686798,
-0.04779160022735596,
-0.08788871765136719,
0.044666893780231476,
0.09369491785764694,
-0.1605920046567917,
-0.4959775507450104,
-0.21114446222782135,
-0.25789734721183777,
-0.38593682646751404,
0.34159615635871887,
0.27911025285720825,
0.29022473096847534,
-0.17352961003780365,
-0.37795326113700867,
-0.229450061917305,
-0.7720019221305847,
-0.09427202492952347,
0.2335577756166458,
0.48075973987579346,
0.07350240647792816,
0.22671647369861603,
-0.10186221450567245,
0.579889714717865,
0.06709963083267212,
-0.08120512217283249,
0.5070122480392456,
-0.016947362571954727,
0.05645093694329262,
-0.41367778182029724,
0.6604161858558655,
0.1597861647605896,
0.26919129490852356,
-0.21217110753059387,
-0.3711637258529663,
-0.40349236130714417,
0.5042914748191833,
-0.5473992824554443,
-0.13683249056339264,
-0.002398556564003229,
-0.3681081533432007,
-0.062335141003131866,
0.11011585593223572,
-0.9479537010192871,
-0.3602069020271301,
-0.3095709979534149,
0.3042757511138916,
-0.1908685564994812,
-0.39623787999153137,
-0.06408213824033737,
0.04324448108673096,
0.6461891531944275,
0.5001038312911987,
-0.8615666627883911,
0.44775667786598206,
0.7589235901832581,
0.8462797403335571,
-0.12324991077184677,
-0.6086104512214661,
-0.8542076945304871,
-0.01363273523747921,
0.05492905527353287,
0.8917104005813599,
-0.6779215335845947,
-0.47426801919937134,
0.12451812624931335,
0.1072051152586937,
-0.16928908228874207,
-0.48782968521118164,
0.17330774664878845,
-0.54120934009552,
0.19288820028305054,
-0.12252027541399002,
-0.004814721643924713,
-0.0707138404250145,
0.4660734534263611,
-0.6808168292045593,
0.6590109467506409,
0.28202372789382935,
-0.4918619394302368,
-0.05558677017688751,
-0.4816778600215912,
-0.3967992067337036,
-0.04492541402578354,
-0.48598507046699524,
-0.22044788300991058,
0.0674767717719078,
0.3097403943538666,
0.254650354385376,
-0.12682819366455078,
-0.2108362317085266,
-0.1414307951927185,
-0.07404405623674393,
0.4219251275062561,
-0.4658283591270447,
0.32299381494522095,
0.15746121108531952,
-0.7329508662223816,
0.007892577908933163,
-0.48438090085983276,
0.23230503499507904,
-0.17052491009235382,
-0.22793519496917725,
-0.08807636052370071,
-0.05997724086046219,
-0.09097889810800552,
0.25586625933647156,
-0.040326353162527084,
-0.2332407534122467,
0.2909879684448242,
-0.545602560043335,
0.327884703874588,
0.6957497000694275,
0.17206785082817078,
0.4512673020362854,
-0.16814950108528137,
0.8844183087348938,
-0.16401585936546326,
0.21057134866714478,
-0.2583465874195099,
-0.352436900138855,
-0.7087690830230713,
-0.11894749104976654,
0.001044113072566688,
0.4745166301727295,
-0.9952210783958435,
0.025860607624053955,
-0.1240299716591835,
-0.06505182385444641,
-0.4552411139011383,
0.2913210988044739,
0.7308299541473389,
0.3218793272972107,
0.6125381588935852,
-0.21220672130584717,
-0.5066558718681335,
-0.7249087691307068,
-0.46292877197265625,
-0.30133765935897827,
0.16561558842658997,
0.3743025064468384,
0.43893393874168396,
-0.425192654132843,
0.9252814650535583,
-0.622794508934021,
-0.2054937779903412,
-0.43640315532684326,
0.477703720331192,
0.022600937634706497,
0.40786808729171753,
0.34175947308540344,
-0.7081599831581116,
-0.5321670770645142,
-0.295737087726593,
-0.3760862350463867,
-0.31534653902053833,
-0.05131353437900543,
0.06140569597482681,
0.4756215214729309,
0.8807972073554993,
-0.510099470615387,
0.19397221505641937,
0.618614673614502,
-0.2940756678581238,
0.5188988447189331,
-0.12959685921669006,
0.31650587916374207,
-0.8989959955215454,
0.08273270726203918,
-0.4646473824977875,
-0.5949303507804871,
-0.6304171681404114,
0.13477148115634918,
-0.11011844873428345,
0.014634101651608944,
-0.5800045132637024,
0.630291759967804,
-0.8085850477218628,
0.2189522087574005,
-0.5955329537391663,
0.33264824748039246,
-0.05971761420369148,
0.6626025438308716,
0.10331637412309647,
0.8834367394447327,
0.011699349619448185,
-0.5037124752998352,
0.34320956468582153,
0.08628292381763458,
0.16194871068000793,
0.46010321378707886,
-0.4779549837112427,
0.6365944743156433,
-0.11930650472640991,
0.13993830978870392,
-1.1547560691833496,
0.11731512099504471,
0.5153731107711792,
-0.4437926113605499,
0.41019225120544434,
-0.052373290061950684,
-0.19080248475074768,
-0.40677589178085327,
-0.31138360500335693,
0.3997237980365753,
0.41045594215393066,
-0.4500869810581207,
1.2162922620773315,
0.08061672002077103,
-0.017168954014778137,
-0.8878173828125,
-0.6279494166374207,
0.16766762733459473,
0.09302404522895813,
-0.2792108654975891,
-0.27485373616218567,
-0.1531311422586441,
-0.1349938064813614,
-0.13607706129550934,
0.037098415195941925,
0.025148149579763412,
0.02414015494287014,
0.4929329454898834,
0.0009721813257783651,
0.061481986194849014,
0.17635074257850647,
-0.22533880174160004,
-0.35464853048324585,
0.23146578669548035,
-0.3099743127822876,
0.7425049543380737,
-0.4687230885028839,
-0.6080940365791321,
-0.24295862019062042,
0.3857622444629669,
0.4645736515522003,
-0.20153984427452087,
0.589321494102478,
0.301887571811676,
0.12614093720912933,
-0.5530455112457275,
-0.8467573523521423,
-0.5201660990715027,
-0.5821129083633423,
0.13683730363845825,
-0.5681098103523254,
-0.8805333375930786,
0.3826959729194641,
-0.25135302543640137,
-0.10777854919433594,
0.27477148175239563,
0.5115925669670105,
-0.09576821327209473,
1.0054454803466797,
0.842787504196167,
-0.2976768910884857,
0.5073694586753845,
-0.4066767990589142,
0.007192298769950867,
-0.6694054007530212,
-0.2021138072013855,
-0.548774003982544,
-0.07023491710424423,
-0.4217643439769745,
-0.5111812949180603,
0.38708993792533875,
-0.3264004588127136,
-0.04130743443965912,
0.3079763650894165,
-0.31947770714759827,
0.6122936010360718,
0.3737401068210602,
0.3240501284599304,
0.24647188186645508,
-0.1503356397151947,
-0.20502957701683044,
0.10865557938814163,
-0.4727027118206024,
-0.49164634943008423,
0.8776488900184631,
0.30738306045532227,
0.8889854550361633,
0.1470528244972229,
0.8393732905387878,
0.3964030146598816,
0.5597349405288696,
-0.5049489140510559,
0.7048214673995972,
0.31488773226737976,
-0.37074345350265503,
-0.368007630109787,
-0.5283610820770264,
-0.9592140913009644,
0.3116246163845062,
0.18165762722492218,
-0.3910626173019409,
0.10566090047359467,
0.32008033990859985,
-0.13301774859428406,
0.01786826364696026,
-0.5657386183738708,
0.8071399927139282,
-0.03274743631482124,
-0.1232035681605339,
-0.3647996485233307,
-0.8607868552207947,
0.11197563260793686,
0.12563292682170868,
0.2902493476867676,
0.22111636400222778,
-0.23033912479877472,
0.24264606833457947,
-0.6372829079627991,
1.268532633781433,
-0.43737319111824036,
-0.313181072473526,
0.536745548248291,
0.1864469051361084,
0.7386032342910767,
-0.08258986473083496,
0.19227220118045807,
-0.3654261827468872,
-0.09392853826284409,
-0.22469104826450348,
-1.069675326347351,
0.4706028401851654,
-0.6494526267051697,
-0.8422428965568542,
-0.32044222950935364,
-0.2755611836910248,
-0.27649205923080444,
0.13850146532058716,
0.16634300351142883,
0.5641698837280273,
-0.46840569376945496,
-0.23059485852718353,
0.6255394816398621,
0.008453848771750927,
0.6143175363540649,
1.0813088417053223,
-0.17376862466335297,
-0.7225268483161926,
0.8564270734786987,
-0.10463815182447433,
0.49878954887390137,
0.5483909845352173,
0.1145729348063469,
-0.27092230319976807,
-0.19001734256744385,
-0.34354111552238464,
0.5379507541656494,
-0.9555663466453552,
-0.4566575586795807,
-0.684421956539154,
-0.11505436897277832,
-0.33704015612602234,
-0.0330287404358387,
-0.19171501696109772,
-0.3741459846496582,
-0.21285000443458557,
-0.04694484919309616,
0.0012147956294938922,
0.7952989339828491,
0.007982325740158558,
0.23873548209667206,
-0.8959023952484131,
0.02202530764043331,
0.510104238986969,
0.040439337491989136,
0.04927344620227814,
-0.4075494408607483,
-0.2886924147605896,
0.0850989818572998,
-0.49940037727355957,
-1.1751782894134521,
0.20301935076713562,
0.3801100552082062,
0.5229896306991577,
0.342197060585022,
0.05478868633508682,
0.25611189007759094,
-0.7145629525184631,
0.7418884634971619,
0.10364478826522827,
-1.1284992694854736,
0.6892799139022827,
-0.03562982380390167,
0.5521166324615479,
0.7465565800666809,
0.33057042956352234,
-0.6843693256378174,
-0.7426379323005676,
-0.5459766387939453,
-0.6194702982902527,
0.40647903084754944,
-0.22064848244190216,
0.4484850764274597,
-0.3602635860443115,
0.5648204684257507,
-0.14021429419517517,
0.40606528520584106,
-0.6725166440010071,
-0.12412719428539276,
-0.15635369718074799,
-0.2160046249628067,
-0.16420602798461914,
-0.3802821636199951,
-0.3327176570892334,
0.10607285052537918,
0.3847905099391937,
-0.6301777362823486,
0.2730526626110077,
0.40079817175865173,
-0.516007125377655,
-0.06107473373413086,
0.4388991892337799,
0.8778468370437622,
0.6667820811271667,
0.2583158612251282,
0.6402488350868225,
0.44207048416137695,
-0.5708047151565552,
0.3605039119720459,
-0.3520544767379761,
0.09321658313274384,
0.08280299603939056,
0.7348542213439941,
0.42595499753952026,
0.25251612067222595,
-0.6188797950744629,
0.8856799006462097,
0.08096305280923843,
-0.21247683465480804,
-0.0772307813167572,
0.11197392642498016,
-0.194285586476326,
0.5057736039161682,
0.20285136997699738,
-0.3008182644844055,
0.3831455409526825,
-0.7004157304763794,
0.41166922450065613,
0.5156654715538025,
-0.3458647131919861,
-0.5191797018051147,
0.2577871084213257,
0.4113600552082062,
-0.3764512836933136,
0.7241122126579285,
-0.06715188175439835,
-0.8376684188842773,
0.32852765917778015,
0.5360826253890991,
1.4375253915786743,
-0.6651048064231873,
0.48858970403671265,
0.13574986159801483,
0.2961987257003784,
0.03609557822346687,
0.5393079519271851,
-0.4679310917854309,
-0.61830073595047,
-0.46219250559806824,
-0.2957623600959778,
-0.5987811088562012,
-0.37637007236480713,
-0.5889948010444641,
0.07019549608230591,
-0.6010481715202332,
-0.2972201406955719,
-0.47987455129623413,
-0.18104343116283417,
-0.5853713154792786,
-0.03859109431505203,
-0.01155022718012333,
0.9259796738624573,
-0.9992362260818481,
0.48614221811294556,
0.7108423709869385,
-0.6732536554336548,
-0.9213663935661316,
0.21389807760715485,
-0.02655467577278614,
-0.8242479562759399,
0.7864594459533691,
0.17639994621276855,
-0.7797282338142395,
-0.1473706066608429,
-0.6884987354278564,
-0.6688255667686462,
0.806940495967865,
0.3978937566280365,
-0.35781463980674744,
-0.06821328401565552,
0.40972161293029785,
0.6614121198654175,
-0.48385822772979736,
0.5048518180847168,
0.5254791378974915,
0.3958525061607361,
-0.024914700537919998,
-0.8462096452713013,
0.35353273153305054,
-0.26497456431388855,
-0.1373395472764969,
0.27958711981773376,
-0.8661644458770752,
0.4730774462223053,
-0.32669365406036377,
-0.32514044642448425,
-0.0776953399181366,
0.8750717043876648,
0.05861141160130501,
0.22628268599510193,
0.7470003962516785,
0.2209852784872055,
0.5066605806350708,
0.12218828499317169,
0.7289081811904907,
-0.38553452491760254,
0.23254549503326416,
1.2227281332015991,
-0.1569979190826416,
0.8489136099815369,
0.529803454875946,
0.10334355384111404,
1.2156249284744263,
0.09690535068511963,
0.23018454015254974,
0.6707595586776733,
0.06394535303115845,
-0.2620754837989807,
-0.22417844831943512,
0.16382329165935516,
-0.293630450963974,
0.16700305044651031,
0.08694233000278473,
-0.32501575350761414,
-0.3187887370586395,
0.4965517520904541,
0.06552634388208389,
0.1496051847934723,
-0.10438632220029831,
1.0170092582702637,
0.24342648684978485,
-0.8546754717826843,
0.6940367817878723,
-0.24578134715557098,
0.1886892169713974,
-0.5425547361373901,
-0.3552519679069519,
-0.3053513169288635,
0.31491410732269287,
-0.28877946734428406,
-0.7161628007888794,
0.2988519072532654,
-0.2937912344932556,
-0.29924115538597107,
-0.4568686783313751,
0.4386701285839081,
-0.6146001815795898,
0.090297169983387,
0.4369823634624481,
0.4602780044078827,
0.2354826033115387,
-0.17225272953510284,
-0.623849630355835,
0.09178952127695084,
-0.21982690691947937,
-0.34646546840667725,
0.0029567836318165064,
0.5387356281280518,
0.1141509935259819,
0.8912590146064758,
0.1652759611606598,
0.015611283481121063,
-0.11169857531785965,
0.350527822971344,
1.243434190750122,
-0.6166542768478394,
-0.4657861888408661,
-0.9187010526657104,
0.5054256319999695,
0.10442371666431427,
-0.18727092444896698,
0.9015246629714966,
0.3448708951473236,
0.6527800559997559,
-0.1293751448392868,
0.6454999446868896,
0.2752770781517029,
0.5742032527923584,
-0.7027616500854492,
0.13041405379772186,
-0.33987152576446533,
0.3570486903190613,
-0.27364131808280945,
-0.8179604411125183,
-0.09710461646318436,
0.3523874282836914,
-0.43070924282073975,
0.36003297567367554,
0.9050868153572083,
0.9893674254417419,
0.1467621624469757,
-0.2034599632024765,
0.11324004083871841,
-0.003446680959314108,
0.5896993279457092,
0.43906983733177185,
1.085697054862976,
-0.17985489964485168,
0.6512219905853271,
0.24312640726566315,
-0.31494420766830444,
-0.2763618528842926,
-0.7209360599517822,
-1.057896375656128,
-0.7011945247650146,
-0.09510545432567596,
-0.6289844512939453,
0.24416391551494598,
0.9695246815681458,
0.6728253364562988,
-0.7962909936904907,
-0.21573108434677124,
-0.16913184523582458,
0.23386411368846893,
-0.2793436348438263,
-0.17129100859165192,
0.20520208775997162,
-0.8979949355125427,
-0.3987564444541931,
0.4825661778450012,
0.23035375773906708,
0.03125842660665512,
-0.646983802318573,
-0.29644957184791565,
-0.02821599505841732,
0.26223132014274597,
0.3637879490852356,
0.4810722768306732,
-0.543027937412262,
-0.393323689699173,
0.0010857037268579006,
-0.34224626421928406,
0.014436434023082256,
1.4002918004989624,
-0.8211460709571838,
0.382382333278656,
0.6105093955993652,
0.5391659736633301,
0.4196103811264038,
0.18820011615753174,
0.8289623856544495,
-0.8410797119140625,
0.02760300226509571,
0.2673635482788086,
-0.017285306006669998,
0.3618374466896057,
-0.3105396628379822,
0.46495622396469116,
0.22386181354522705,
-0.6940556764602661,
-0.7126741409301758,
0.4005900025367737,
-0.41196057200431824,
-0.3855431377887726,
1.2022266387939453,
-0.018998421728610992,
-0.3578389883041382,
-0.13596303761005402,
-0.39501920342445374,
-0.1187482476234436,
-0.3074898421764374,
0.5771197080612183,
0.4609946310520172,
-0.08581853657960892,
-0.5836718678474426,
-0.21772682666778564,
0.7262416481971741,
0.5574440360069275,
-0.87309330701828,
0.20194777846336365,
0.44448041915893555,
0.4001850187778473,
0.29786616563796997,
1.0092027187347412,
0.07365639507770538,
0.3044418394565582,
-0.21851950883865356,
0.2511177659034729,
-0.01167366374284029,
-0.8784222602844238,
-0.6484396457672119,
0.17112351953983307,
0.254851371049881,
-0.17614133656024933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07623v1
|
COBias and Debias: Minimizing Language Model Pairwise Accuracy Bias via Nonlinear Integer Programming
| 2024-05-13T10:30:33 | 2024-05-13T10:30:33 |
Ruixi Lin, Yang You
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For language model classification, would you prefer having only one workable
class or having every class working? The latter makes more practical uses.
Especially for large language models (LLMs), the fact that they achieve a fair
overall accuracy by in-context learning (ICL) obscures a large difference in
individual class accuracies. In this work, we uncover and tackle language
models' imbalance in per-class prediction accuracy by reconceptualizing it as
the Contextual Oddity Bias (COBias), and we are the first to engage nonlinear
integer programming (NIP) to debias it. Briefly, COBias refers to the
difference in accuracy by a class A compared to its ''odd'' class, which holds
the majority wrong predictions of class A. With the COBias metric, we reveal
that LLMs of varied scales and families exhibit large per-class accuracy
differences. Then we propose Debiasing as Nonlinear Integer Programming (DNIP)
to correct ICL per-class probabilities for lower bias and higher overall
accuracy. Our optimization objective is directly based on the evaluation scores
by COBias and accuracy metrics, solved by simulated annealing. Evaluations on
three LLMs across seven NLP classification tasks show that DNIP simultaneously
achieves significant COBias reduction ($-27\%$) and accuracy improvement
($+12\%$) over the conventional ICL approach, suggesting that modeling pairwise
class accuracy differences is a direction in pushing forward more accurate,
more reliable LLM predictions.
|
[
-0.6023573875427246,
-0.419503390789032,
0.3675142228603363,
0.23527686297893524,
0.11316877603530884,
0.19913703203201294,
-0.14222189784049988,
-0.3582710325717926,
-0.18708868324756622,
0.26883357763290405,
-0.40969333052635193,
-0.44053342938423157,
-0.597778856754303,
0.014259538613259792,
-0.26517972350120544,
0.8387492895126343,
0.31342828273773193,
0.3139530420303345,
-0.40952053666114807,
-0.12631238996982574,
-0.13669469952583313,
-0.5224935412406921,
-0.7161015272140503,
-0.47971123456954956,
0.17356887459754944,
0.6718595623970032,
0.8726905584335327,
0.4937096834182739,
0.4719332456588745,
0.17907603085041046,
-0.24943996965885162,
0.04171642288565636,
-0.39375928044319153,
-0.19903618097305298,
-0.1489773392677307,
-0.683189332485199,
-0.49015673995018005,
-0.029616298153996468,
0.3436340093612671,
0.8541248440742493,
0.01650426536798477,
0.21579580008983612,
0.009926501661539078,
0.6650596857070923,
-0.645986795425415,
-0.05919025465846062,
-0.7465217113494873,
0.20565706491470337,
-0.09353519976139069,
-0.09792298078536987,
-0.5362614989280701,
-0.22923342883586884,
0.2858414649963379,
-0.287946492433548,
-0.03723079711198807,
0.2436976134777069,
0.45661887526512146,
0.7383385300636292,
-0.26264238357543945,
-0.40183359384536743,
-0.5667571425437927,
1.0692678689956665,
-1.1642234325408936,
0.40790119767189026,
0.5698248744010925,
-0.13671216368675232,
-0.2205105721950531,
-0.17542709410190582,
-0.6543285250663757,
-0.1946839541196823,
0.09812333434820175,
-0.15692925453186035,
-0.03629019483923912,
0.15056771039962769,
0.2952214479446411,
0.3594631552696228,
-0.42113542556762695,
0.5241724848747253,
-0.2380039244890213,
0.12579560279846191,
0.7494621872901917,
0.1756247878074646,
0.3504484295845032,
0.0011842132080346346,
-0.4942791163921356,
0.12342432886362076,
-0.7758707404136658,
0.2112266570329666,
0.3863803744316101,
0.14493346214294434,
-0.41546809673309326,
0.16547736525535583,
-0.05380641669034958,
0.8174765110015869,
0.2146778553724289,
-0.31680479645729065,
0.11240161210298538,
0.149546816945076,
-0.025598283857107162,
-0.04198591038584709,
0.3326340317726135,
0.5995813608169556,
0.22033263742923737,
-0.33812910318374634,
-0.14416423439979553,
0.2447499930858612,
-0.08243093639612198,
-0.4916381537914276,
-0.2975345551967621,
0.2017068713903427,
-0.31636083126068115,
-0.522963285446167,
-0.2664616107940674,
-0.76905757188797,
-0.2174631953239441,
-0.73499995470047,
0.20517578721046448,
-0.11802428960800171,
-0.046404436230659485,
0.1460409015417099,
0.15938347578048706,
-0.26983651518821716,
0.15557861328125,
-1.1179041862487793,
0.5700345635414124,
0.7791774868965149,
0.8207187652587891,
-0.3656798303127289,
-0.2744530737400055,
-0.5493652820587158,
-0.09366093575954437,
-0.3874668776988983,
0.3069695234298706,
-0.6697041392326355,
0.09348396956920624,
-0.18377172946929932,
-0.8310490846633911,
0.2568696141242981,
-0.476982980966568,
0.10218964517116547,
-0.5351932644844055,
0.09051087498664856,
-0.18208803236484528,
-0.6030011177062988,
-0.3065035343170166,
0.2999219596385956,
-0.3207106292247772,
0.9873727560043335,
0.11011135578155518,
-0.7446681261062622,
0.5352945327758789,
-0.47264227271080017,
0.0990879088640213,
-0.27875402569770813,
-0.4194914698600769,
-0.2352297157049179,
0.15127557516098022,
0.155508354306221,
0.30091431736946106,
-0.4853106737136841,
0.614970862865448,
-0.6146274209022522,
-0.6441942453384399,
0.1097315102815628,
-0.5294039845466614,
1.026800274848938,
0.0665849894285202,
-0.6529122591018677,
-0.12056873738765717,
-0.8641940951347351,
0.11912992596626282,
-0.3254653811454773,
-0.20750151574611664,
-0.6911470293998718,
0.04701852425932884,
-0.22775784134864807,
0.5161039233207703,
0.001131210708990693,
-0.4530474543571472,
0.42834004759788513,
-0.7088729739189148,
0.2983115315437317,
0.9435688257217407,
-0.4278911352157593,
0.8136817216873169,
-0.3555295765399933,
0.25950542092323303,
0.09698240458965302,
0.17060676217079163,
0.4245268404483795,
-0.2535880208015442,
-0.9410683512687683,
-0.14904791116714478,
0.2942456305027008,
0.5305159091949463,
-0.7294370532035828,
0.3787926435470581,
-0.08746376633644104,
-0.44428449869155884,
-0.2973305284976959,
0.099754698574543,
0.35911545157432556,
0.5416045188903809,
0.32394009828567505,
-0.30148741602897644,
-0.6029830574989319,
-0.7522045373916626,
-0.10887457430362701,
-0.17630474269390106,
0.22592225670814514,
0.07964245229959488,
0.42242178320884705,
-0.22947479784488678,
1.046928882598877,
-0.4405248761177063,
-0.13186807930469513,
-0.039664797484874725,
0.16832388937473297,
0.3455117344856262,
0.5779447555541992,
0.8623237013816833,
-0.8912227153778076,
-0.810806393623352,
-0.6876509189605713,
-0.534168541431427,
-0.33877336978912354,
0.1701279729604721,
0.17788688838481903,
0.7079510688781738,
0.5555111169815063,
0.17577967047691345,
0.6702646613121033,
0.8825947642326355,
-0.24068452417850494,
0.25961312651634216,
-0.12959547340869904,
-0.3009175658226013,
-0.6490632891654968,
-0.2397126406431198,
-0.0062530022114515305,
-0.09949298948049545,
-0.5759402513504028,
-0.0594681054353714,
-0.28940218687057495,
0.15186193585395813,
-0.14662720263004303,
0.6694871783256531,
-0.26468268036842346,
-0.09809837490320206,
-0.21648022532463074,
0.13120973110198975,
-0.16412781178951263,
0.733492910861969,
-0.013209831900894642,
0.6639679074287415,
0.5626646876335144,
-0.638965904712677,
0.11916989833116531,
0.168711319565773,
-0.26393255591392517,
0.4715529978275299,
-0.330337256193161,
0.37133529782295227,
-0.20525537431240082,
0.1878545731306076,
-0.832444965839386,
0.1954624354839325,
0.3191119432449341,
-0.327679306268692,
0.2172377109527588,
-0.007536724209785461,
-0.07509270310401917,
-0.058593470603227615,
-0.25697895884513855,
0.4342540204524994,
0.3793155252933502,
-0.7449126243591309,
0.040753938257694244,
0.5506559014320374,
-0.1991974115371704,
-1.0118350982666016,
-0.6839280128479004,
0.022431084886193275,
0.015361187048256397,
-0.42289987206459045,
0.582715630531311,
-0.3466954529285431,
-0.7139788269996643,
-0.06084929406642914,
-0.28097227215766907,
-0.1880808174610138,
0.25863322615623474,
0.08561549335718155,
0.2347189038991928,
0.10286516696214676,
0.27068984508514404,
-0.04376767948269844,
-0.47752270102500916,
-0.11041934043169022,
-0.4295308291912079,
0.8546501994132996,
-0.5248920321464539,
-0.2763460874557495,
-0.2105376422405243,
0.31061115860939026,
0.5048639178276062,
0.1189688891172409,
0.6668044328689575,
0.38930875062942505,
-0.41865551471710205,
-0.19422723352909088,
-0.5682817697525024,
-0.2774917781352997,
-0.4161898195743561,
0.28620967268943787,
-0.26563259959220886,
-0.5831010937690735,
0.32208409905433655,
0.2384682297706604,
0.09730774164199829,
0.1699695736169815,
0.43589261174201965,
0.05018080770969391,
1.1711821556091309,
0.8330942988395691,
-0.4083302617073059,
0.44591981172561646,
-0.4389234185218811,
0.34163886308670044,
-0.7653089761734009,
-0.07675482332706451,
-0.4451907277107239,
-0.5788999795913696,
-0.632601261138916,
-0.3437507450580597,
0.4422740936279297,
0.13168522715568542,
-0.36491018533706665,
0.05710314214229584,
-0.47244831919670105,
0.4830046594142914,
0.9135846495628357,
0.1169007197022438,
0.4340875446796417,
0.020691704005002975,
-0.10512407124042511,
-0.4161395728588104,
-0.9853983521461487,
-0.5587789416313171,
1.142279028892517,
0.2245827317237854,
0.7495949864387512,
-0.003642676630988717,
0.8802015781402588,
0.3889349699020386,
0.3337739408016205,
-0.5915939211845398,
0.40965262055397034,
-0.48577481508255005,
-0.6776997447013855,
-0.4045618772506714,
-0.4233541786670685,
-0.2601100504398346,
0.10493415594100952,
-0.29062455892562866,
-0.9202171564102173,
0.39781802892684937,
0.4252524971961975,
-0.31666338443756104,
0.5824300646781921,
-0.15360356867313385,
0.5315805077552795,
-0.4243120849132538,
-0.5415056943893433,
-0.3389055132865906,
-0.7613202333450317,
0.1728694885969162,
0.037287816405296326,
0.4418933689594269,
-0.3143940567970276,
-0.11382531374692917,
0.31533288955688477,
-0.42954087257385254,
0.8223633170127869,
-0.2228693664073944,
0.019490612670779228,
-0.022913280874490738,
0.1353776603937149,
0.38349953293800354,
0.23074720799922943,
-0.5420478582382202,
0.5043562650680542,
0.020812271162867546,
-0.4222383499145508,
-0.4750441908836365,
0.6591955423355103,
-0.810627281665802,
-0.4625493288040161,
-0.6710479855537415,
-0.7741351127624512,
-0.2144806683063507,
-0.042886883020401,
0.4345490038394928,
0.6886540055274963,
0.1838279664516449,
0.164400115609169,
0.5188192129135132,
-0.2566621005535126,
0.5746790766716003,
0.46663913130760193,
-0.34618717432022095,
-0.30555903911590576,
0.8499497771263123,
0.260385662317276,
0.4966985285282135,
0.4850086569786072,
0.29608240723609924,
-0.12208811938762665,
-0.8430222868919373,
-0.4252314865589142,
-0.22717438638210297,
-0.6630443930625916,
-0.104829803109169,
-0.46257779002189636,
0.020458022132515907,
-0.40614625811576843,
-0.466987282037735,
-0.2666577100753784,
-0.4830668270587921,
-0.11292969435453415,
0.2417590320110321,
0.0643104612827301,
0.4718776047229767,
-0.5033078789710999,
0.2618897259235382,
-0.48245611786842346,
0.1335260421037674,
0.17143601179122925,
0.4125877916812897,
0.12601947784423828,
-0.6038586497306824,
0.010296412743628025,
0.2852417528629303,
0.003172374563291669,
-0.5597846508026123,
0.4967992901802063,
0.21864096820354462,
0.334565669298172,
0.19371254742145538,
0.3956105709075928,
0.5772007703781128,
-0.20759740471839905,
0.48533153533935547,
0.21069544553756714,
-1.225010871887207,
0.06796538084745407,
-0.06650608777999878,
0.09591372311115265,
0.7824732065200806,
0.4533920884132385,
-0.7523065209388733,
-0.43906092643737793,
-0.66175776720047,
-0.9813303351402283,
0.904541015625,
-0.14055241644382477,
0.023289097473025322,
0.09326356649398804,
0.4151763916015625,
0.26138371229171753,
0.36281031370162964,
-1.0141680240631104,
-0.3621940612792969,
0.2666226923465729,
-0.5848822593688965,
0.00040932020056061447,
-0.36613988876342773,
0.07377132028341293,
-0.3152027428150177,
1.0446871519088745,
-0.2010495662689209,
-0.17308419942855835,
0.1442802995443344,
-0.2721540331840515,
-0.0011234339326620102,
0.10204200446605682,
0.6649295091629028,
0.9302465319633484,
-0.3060901463031769,
0.3694368004798889,
0.4848553240299225,
-0.29197022318840027,
0.3669157922267914,
-0.33614933490753174,
-0.6093262434005737,
-0.056316398084163666,
0.10889192670583725,
0.6692907214164734,
0.30020177364349365,
-0.5978068113327026,
0.44044700264930725,
0.012649609707295895,
0.33916470408439636,
-0.5526793599128723,
0.02667725458741188,
-0.1267976015806198,
0.21029481291770935,
0.4284696578979492,
0.5261914730072021,
0.2169150710105896,
-0.36192992329597473,
0.1571090668439865,
0.22476449608802795,
-0.5161452889442444,
-0.21235378086566925,
0.4721032381057739,
0.4557178318500519,
-0.5007381439208984,
0.6050779223442078,
-0.47367793321609497,
-0.6347824931144714,
0.7371357083320618,
0.6184884905815125,
0.6241490840911865,
0.01733500510454178,
0.05485157668590546,
0.3370654582977295,
0.24812325835227966,
-0.10432260483503342,
0.14506006240844727,
0.10335846245288849,
-0.8665177822113037,
-0.2618078887462616,
-0.5247405767440796,
-0.8054825663566589,
0.11088381707668304,
-0.6976685523986816,
0.44025689363479614,
-0.6769981384277344,
0.038325339555740356,
-0.03735079988837242,
0.02553621120750904,
-0.506516695022583,
0.43841347098350525,
0.31431540846824646,
0.6933879852294922,
-0.7675430774688721,
0.7357613444328308,
0.6037254929542542,
-0.262993186712265,
-0.616526186466217,
0.12184920161962509,
0.23108188807964325,
-0.6961821913719177,
0.9203544855117798,
0.1443784534931183,
-0.1380423754453659,
0.17808301746845245,
-0.6126243472099304,
-1.0632628202438354,
0.5362992882728577,
0.39055150747299194,
-0.8503053188323975,
-0.26665303111076355,
0.17829640209674835,
0.3108105957508087,
-0.44447994232177734,
0.14723190665245056,
0.5076866745948792,
0.3129853308200836,
-0.20362211763858795,
-0.7040711641311646,
-0.19459983706474304,
-0.048221297562122345,
-0.007005265913903713,
0.20997875928878784,
-0.6862449645996094,
1.0427320003509521,
-0.26615265011787415,
0.35277947783470154,
-0.1350725144147873,
0.32376131415367126,
0.21540510654449463,
0.7000457644462585,
0.7794368267059326,
0.6075740456581116,
0.7672675848007202,
-0.14011429250240326,
0.671704113483429,
-0.4128017723560333,
0.4007827639579773,
1.3337270021438599,
-0.19091196358203888,
0.7153040170669556,
0.6514822840690613,
-0.3330075442790985,
0.41887494921684265,
0.5718482732772827,
0.15187352895736694,
0.45507141947746277,
0.22089707851409912,
-0.22710616886615753,
-0.3282056450843811,
0.12513354420661926,
-0.215633362531662,
0.670754611492157,
0.3096349835395813,
-0.08950033038854599,
-0.0031444441992789507,
0.07825873792171478,
0.22516781091690063,
0.27225127816200256,
-0.28528615832328796,
0.5849127769470215,
0.19555799663066864,
-0.8209741115570068,
0.5829730033874512,
0.06505829095840454,
1.0892033576965332,
-0.12879140675067902,
0.05012451484799385,
-0.2583698034286499,
0.49227526783943176,
-0.37301087379455566,
-0.3669024407863617,
0.5063653588294983,
-0.06945330649614334,
-0.5421148538589478,
-0.019824864342808723,
0.519972562789917,
-0.6803231239318848,
-0.40883731842041016,
0.2717837989330292,
0.0669018030166626,
0.02799881622195244,
0.09185705333948135,
-0.6347826719284058,
0.06572985649108887,
0.21715544164180756,
0.11100764572620392,
0.16048657894134521,
-0.02422885224223137,
-0.08512116223573685,
0.7074812650680542,
0.4918089210987091,
0.1801125407218933,
0.02396305464208126,
-0.16438046097755432,
0.5007641315460205,
-0.4354585111141205,
-0.37613242864608765,
-1.058447003364563,
0.25949567556381226,
-0.18438124656677246,
-0.4462754428386688,
0.3926263153553009,
0.39793097972869873,
1.1946749687194824,
-0.052849672734737396,
0.8325859308242798,
-0.15724150836467743,
0.5308461785316467,
-0.5009591579437256,
0.3960621953010559,
-0.5565870404243469,
0.4949616491794586,
-0.2537148892879486,
-0.8497388958930969,
-0.46718716621398926,
0.8562105894088745,
-0.6655535101890564,
-0.20805254578590393,
0.37909799814224243,
0.733174204826355,
0.10760382562875748,
-0.03861838951706886,
0.223079115152359,
0.10652928799390793,
0.3165123164653778,
0.568335771560669,
0.686082661151886,
-0.47055506706237793,
0.23177079856395721,
-0.8261960744857788,
-0.3775607645511627,
-0.6269397139549255,
-0.9688870310783386,
-0.784625768661499,
-0.38277798891067505,
-0.36942562460899353,
-0.12834683060646057,
0.10212273895740509,
1.4976860284805298,
0.676664412021637,
-0.9092494249343872,
-0.37719103693962097,
-0.2941567897796631,
0.3528068959712982,
-0.1427760273218155,
-0.21106651425361633,
0.08644381165504456,
-0.5025423169136047,
-1.10349440574646,
0.08159833401441574,
0.4921685457229614,
0.050702180713415146,
-0.24216710031032562,
-0.22560372948646545,
-0.3705069422721863,
-0.008320587687194347,
0.4051136374473572,
0.12949690222740173,
-0.6792778372764587,
-0.4522068500518799,
0.0516757033765316,
-0.18947000801563263,
0.146107017993927,
0.43449193239212036,
-0.5151200294494629,
0.4604489505290985,
0.6104944944381714,
0.39070484042167664,
0.470205694437027,
-0.2542983293533325,
0.7263984084129333,
-0.6790251731872559,
0.6786404848098755,
0.6115488409996033,
0.15514518320560455,
0.31046366691589355,
-0.1367952674627304,
0.7906864881515503,
0.14379464089870453,
-0.6328994035720825,
-1.1046985387802124,
0.30514925718307495,
-0.584645688533783,
-0.23330292105674744,
0.9061557054519653,
-0.1290239840745926,
0.07184479385614395,
-0.30156442523002625,
-0.22431321442127228,
0.1328798085451126,
-0.1624174267053604,
1.1844136714935303,
0.6710811257362366,
-0.23080818355083466,
0.2199610024690628,
-0.3069666922092438,
0.6111295223236084,
0.7581155300140381,
-0.5426434874534607,
-0.3029325306415558,
0.3270660936832428,
0.28562062978744507,
0.3204079568386078,
0.48256924748420715,
0.1950482577085495,
0.20143261551856995,
0.06435564160346985,
0.13299795985221863,
-0.018147116526961327,
-0.49414169788360596,
-0.25662899017333984,
-0.08351929485797882,
0.21064461767673492,
0.1024676188826561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07615v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07615v1
|
ViWikiFC: Fact-Checking for Vietnamese Wikipedia-Based Textual Knowledge Source
| 2024-05-13T10:24:05 | 2024-05-13T10:24:05 |
Hung Tuan Le, Long Truong To, Manh Trong Nguyen, Kiet Van Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fact-checking is essential due to the explosion of misinformation in the
media ecosystem. Although false information exists in every language and
country, most research to solve the problem mainly concentrated on huge
communities like English and Chinese. Low-resource languages like Vietnamese
are necessary to explore corpora and models for fact verification. To bridge
this gap, we construct ViWikiFC, the first manual annotated open-domain corpus
for Vietnamese Wikipedia Fact Checking more than 20K claims generated by
converting evidence sentences extracted from Wikipedia articles. We analyze our
corpus through many linguistic aspects, from the new dependency rate, the new
n-gram rate, and the new word rate. We conducted various experiments for
Vietnamese fact-checking, including evidence retrieval and verdict prediction.
BM25 and InfoXLM (Large) achieved the best results in two tasks, with BM25
achieving an accuracy of 88.30% for SUPPORTS, 86.93% for REFUTES, and only
56.67% for the NEI label in the evidence retrieval task, InfoXLM (Large)
achieved an F1 score of 86.51%. Furthermore, we also conducted a pipeline
approach, which only achieved a strict accuracy of 67.00% when using InfoXLM
(Large) and BM25. These results demonstrate that our dataset is challenging for
the Vietnamese language model in fact-checking tasks.
|
[
-0.4434871971607208,
-0.9165246486663818,
0.5337920188903809,
0.11471955478191376,
-0.3731631338596344,
-0.2693142890930176,
-0.3985024690628052,
-0.3031676709651947,
0.0721241757273674,
0.7237033247947693,
-0.1679370403289795,
-0.6667839884757996,
-0.6420307755470276,
0.4268099069595337,
-0.5109265446662903,
1.1581934690475464,
-0.030953407287597656,
-0.11025331914424896,
-0.2387215942144394,
-0.30384892225265503,
0.09405552595853806,
-0.44385063648223877,
-0.23637326061725616,
-0.05668611824512482,
0.7064273953437805,
0.8876692056655884,
0.6112404465675354,
0.5429216623306274,
0.43785548210144043,
0.2794075310230255,
0.09002009779214859,
0.5883299112319946,
-0.7713397741317749,
-0.24356544017791748,
-0.24582864344120026,
-0.34448981285095215,
-0.18902257084846497,
0.10108993947505951,
0.1395632028579712,
0.03812800720334053,
0.03676065057516098,
0.36345526576042175,
-0.3303917348384857,
0.5467725396156311,
-0.9231642484664917,
0.2571605145931244,
-0.7894251346588135,
-0.19942711293697357,
-0.28410470485687256,
-0.08006883412599564,
-0.5541827082633972,
-0.46750104427337646,
0.16585089266300201,
-0.7694404125213623,
0.406084269285202,
-0.3345981240272522,
1.0799587965011597,
0.2946165204048157,
-0.6805852055549622,
-0.26688507199287415,
-0.5821475386619568,
0.3724033236503601,
-0.4865308105945587,
0.38916051387786865,
0.5187554955482483,
0.06604045629501343,
0.07852780818939209,
-0.6884990930557251,
-1.0862659215927124,
-0.3700401186943054,
-0.30596569180488586,
0.13147366046905518,
-0.10272026807069778,
-0.0610811784863472,
0.45082220435142517,
0.21376200020313263,
-0.5499854683876038,
-0.0906720981001854,
-0.6415503621101379,
-0.3757355213165283,
0.6526182889938354,
-0.3122830390930176,
0.18862809240818024,
-0.7699130773544312,
-0.6261257529258728,
-0.0850881040096283,
-0.7559118270874023,
-0.28097692131996155,
0.2297583669424057,
0.06509857624769211,
-0.166110560297966,
1.0587600469589233,
-0.6346943974494934,
0.6136687994003296,
-0.13688406348228455,
-0.4232875406742096,
0.3080739676952362,
-0.6447977423667908,
-0.09548590332269669,
0.2569577395915985,
0.8306408524513245,
0.5985921025276184,
0.44051656126976013,
0.0910756066441536,
-0.09489095956087112,
0.0435907319188118,
0.15754187107086182,
-0.6947875618934631,
-0.26535341143608093,
0.18967391550540924,
-0.43980762362480164,
-0.3230366110801697,
0.472281813621521,
-0.6287170052528381,
-0.33968326449394226,
-0.2573952376842499,
0.5108575224876404,
-0.46946680545806885,
-0.5677581429481506,
-0.3031710088253021,
-0.3826472759246826,
0.06989063322544098,
0.5369299650192261,
-0.3500324487686157,
-0.3161733150482178,
0.612744152545929,
0.9195001721382141,
-0.18812036514282227,
-0.32169482111930847,
-0.8547350168228149,
0.0720682293176651,
-0.307195782661438,
0.8173670172691345,
-0.07194574922323227,
-0.1787746399641037,
0.30850300192832947,
0.023324722424149513,
0.24388310313224792,
-0.46820303797721863,
0.893682599067688,
-0.4310922920703888,
0.10497505962848663,
-0.31358230113983154,
-0.6400880217552185,
-0.1772814393043518,
0.25938713550567627,
-0.8415419459342957,
1.0682541131973267,
0.31890544295310974,
-1.0934385061264038,
0.343235045671463,
-0.4664587676525116,
-0.40754759311676025,
0.06061231717467308,
0.00203778687864542,
-0.24107183516025543,
0.10287918895483017,
-0.10245590656995773,
0.23939329385757446,
-0.06657020002603531,
0.35633134841918945,
-0.21912100911140442,
-0.023794932290911674,
0.27179262042045593,
-0.46502286195755005,
1.0013006925582886,
0.28804582357406616,
-0.4310745596885681,
0.016012616455554962,
-1.1337151527404785,
-0.10050187259912491,
-0.17069777846336365,
-0.5867045521736145,
-0.6654057502746582,
-0.2120407074689865,
0.3461425006389618,
0.25916996598243713,
0.3554336726665497,
-0.7994363307952881,
0.061131030321121216,
-0.0034372429363429546,
0.14530770480632782,
0.3978091776371002,
-0.05072871595621109,
-0.03189699724316597,
0.047526974231004715,
-0.15848077833652496,
0.17885975539684296,
0.3058308959007263,
-0.13766659796237946,
-0.6580209732055664,
-1.0054436922073364,
-0.11370343714952469,
0.4558255970478058,
0.7111721634864807,
-1.231970191001892,
0.4358487129211426,
-0.3938218653202057,
-0.7495481967926025,
-0.5928757190704346,
0.2515965700149536,
0.2750512361526489,
0.8130978941917419,
0.6835352182388306,
0.09700517356395721,
-0.6675751209259033,
-0.8777555227279663,
-0.14116069674491882,
-0.7480239868164062,
-0.17533358931541443,
-0.10793524235486984,
0.6635753512382507,
-0.31392666697502136,
0.9359511137008667,
-0.48366615176200867,
-0.2746305763721466,
0.1989423781633377,
0.2813641428947449,
0.14168556034564972,
0.00850041676312685,
0.37707871198654175,
-1.1649413108825684,
-0.5610799193382263,
0.2586350739002228,
-0.9183191657066345,
-0.22675709426403046,
0.20877684652805328,
-0.07890870422124863,
0.5328109860420227,
0.3979439437389374,
-1.0203381776809692,
0.5561049580574036,
0.40791213512420654,
-0.5503862500190735,
0.6089483499526978,
-0.27243146300315857,
0.2483275681734085,
-0.5952835083007812,
0.10932593792676926,
0.03804432973265648,
-0.26247820258140564,
-0.43683353066444397,
0.049672238528728485,
0.36678075790405273,
0.2886587381362915,
-0.5850154757499695,
0.48787811398506165,
-0.12498544901609421,
0.4413589835166931,
-0.4900299608707428,
0.18165399134159088,
-0.17379643023014069,
0.2983160614967346,
0.07584155350923538,
0.48478856682777405,
0.04480445757508278,
-0.7187349796295166,
0.615868330001831,
0.18049997091293335,
-0.40322110056877136,
0.7024833559989929,
-0.3664621412754059,
-0.12814663350582123,
-0.032530009746551514,
-0.023799806833267212,
-0.6610028147697449,
-0.21904996037483215,
0.17991633713245392,
-0.438895583152771,
0.03984544798731804,
-0.2956671118736267,
-0.3894292116165161,
-0.2484084665775299,
-0.24781444668769836,
-0.2522246241569519,
0.13567520678043365,
-0.6714101433753967,
0.36318156123161316,
0.5310783386230469,
-0.06629002094268799,
-0.8800870776176453,
-0.3268481492996216,
0.1903284341096878,
0.08861961960792542,
-0.5859492421150208,
0.3092506229877472,
-0.09974920004606247,
-0.6030606627464294,
0.3646221458911896,
-0.12943582236766815,
-0.2681010663509369,
-0.14530688524246216,
0.18566253781318665,
0.22758448123931885,
-0.4784362018108368,
0.23092928528785706,
-0.14851197600364685,
-0.23443485796451569,
0.02389514073729515,
-0.44424501061439514,
-0.03603599965572357,
0.06505126506090164,
-0.12339814752340317,
-0.041737791150808334,
0.18259674310684204,
0.6860450506210327,
-0.21598124504089355,
0.7504136562347412,
0.9477296471595764,
-0.37149685621261597,
0.1156039908528328,
-0.8993217945098877,
0.021710684522986412,
-0.3257145285606384,
0.22962309420108795,
-0.12238134443759918,
-0.8896309733390808,
-0.08814781159162521,
0.29805365204811096,
0.18014846742153168,
0.8561649918556213,
0.7693291306495667,
-0.0007833415293134749,
0.3881722688674927,
0.6320886611938477,
-0.13815753161907196,
0.24832667410373688,
-0.10320939123630524,
-0.09942556172609329,
0.053830087184906006,
-0.05426223948597908,
-0.6107007265090942,
0.24216273427009583,
-0.9832966327667236,
-0.7449897527694702,
0.35292357206344604,
-0.13927680253982544,
0.0011275160359218717,
0.3265558183193207,
-0.16191250085830688,
0.3260912001132965,
0.5935080647468567,
0.02793644182384014,
0.8353154063224792,
0.08026234060525894,
0.12793348729610443,
0.08779627084732056,
-0.5656610131263733,
-0.4516904652118683,
1.1436057090759277,
-0.08269016444683075,
0.3816816508769989,
0.06979392468929291,
0.3751412630081177,
0.5587583780288696,
0.6401077508926392,
-0.5575399994850159,
0.34750714898109436,
-0.2666001617908478,
-0.7634588479995728,
-0.5706126093864441,
-0.5675368309020996,
-0.49119409918785095,
0.17510396242141724,
-0.4867425858974457,
-0.1782664805650711,
0.08366622775793076,
0.007014117203652859,
0.26272502541542053,
0.1572195440530777,
-0.8325226306915283,
0.679138720035553,
-0.2013874053955078,
-0.26082026958465576,
-0.446914404630661,
-0.4344766438007355,
0.5804842114448547,
-0.13446293771266937,
0.35832518339157104,
-0.11965690553188324,
0.00757132051512599,
0.42521002888679504,
-0.7548350691795349,
0.46254295110702515,
-0.2913525402545929,
-0.1494244933128357,
0.6584359407424927,
-0.3428676724433899,
0.44240567088127136,
0.5463385581970215,
-0.09891746193170547,
0.483814537525177,
-0.10660675913095474,
-0.31899771094322205,
-0.5470983982086182,
0.7844505310058594,
-0.8061755895614624,
-0.5791003108024597,
-0.27755531668663025,
0.013642555102705956,
0.17135922610759735,
0.4131084084510803,
0.6004503965377808,
0.013492324389517307,
-0.48152396082878113,
0.3070349395275116,
0.9594401717185974,
-0.035940464586019516,
0.01403920166194439,
0.9619374871253967,
-0.23909366130828857,
-0.45777758955955505,
1.1603223085403442,
0.47844040393829346,
-0.14582274854183197,
0.8657975792884827,
0.13408321142196655,
-0.14860278367996216,
-0.33767443895339966,
-0.5921967029571533,
0.22598280012607574,
-0.6980172395706177,
-0.21689608693122864,
-0.8542654514312744,
-0.38881808519363403,
-0.243337020277977,
0.5161354541778564,
-0.3947608470916748,
-0.7138184309005737,
0.1300412118434906,
-0.45365557074546814,
0.6525052785873413,
0.862652599811554,
-0.2191782295703888,
-0.05937757343053818,
-0.6167466640472412,
0.7908574938774109,
0.38430699706077576,
0.21547186374664307,
-0.6066674590110779,
-0.15289057791233063,
-0.5149776339530945,
-0.011182949878275394,
-0.036270059645175934,
-1.051430344581604,
-0.20813022553920746,
0.0950150117278099,
0.41442418098449707,
0.5603302121162415,
0.479252427816391,
0.18793167173862457,
-0.36267849802970886,
0.6176245808601379,
-0.10939529538154602,
-0.5591316223144531,
0.49701961874961853,
-0.015252947807312012,
-0.020121032372117043,
0.4408332109451294,
0.4331403076648712,
-0.5008401274681091,
-0.45895102620124817,
-0.7349267601966858,
-0.5594254732131958,
0.2990708649158478,
0.4661746025085449,
-0.18621209263801575,
0.026325510814785957,
0.3735049068927765,
0.21769756078720093,
0.14370602369308472,
-0.5026597380638123,
-0.43435364961624146,
-0.484487920999527,
-0.21203379333019257,
-0.20097334682941437,
-0.5085175633430481,
-0.1321711540222168,
-0.20402047038078308,
0.8832985162734985,
-0.40681666135787964,
-0.10498115420341492,
0.5808833241462708,
-0.4278181791305542,
-0.12684807181358337,
0.08156827837228775,
0.72183758020401,
0.7979358434677124,
-0.009924477897584438,
0.3580799102783203,
0.2577153444290161,
-0.7250367999076843,
0.07119382172822952,
0.19923803210258484,
-0.5534487962722778,
0.712212860584259,
0.5559644103050232,
0.5896520614624023,
0.0953252986073494,
-0.5874483585357666,
0.6221530437469482,
-0.2891436219215393,
-0.043789561837911606,
-0.4159002900123596,
0.26827195286750793,
0.17181305587291718,
-0.026014789938926697,
0.35403841733932495,
-0.14438605308532715,
0.004679329227656126,
-0.23317639529705048,
0.2983079254627228,
0.11768271774053574,
-0.31025204062461853,
-0.2349453866481781,
0.3718670904636383,
0.27551624178886414,
0.032734859734773636,
0.7528793215751648,
-0.09997279196977615,
-0.4548059403896332,
0.4157197177410126,
-0.1888638436794281,
0.5666906833648682,
-0.1824234575033188,
0.5065298080444336,
0.7127230167388916,
0.7054705619812012,
-0.0002478092210367322,
0.3228464424610138,
-0.07950670272111893,
-0.5257685780525208,
-0.40559452772140503,
-0.5067363977432251,
-0.43642571568489075,
0.2919926345348358,
-0.2801017463207245,
0.6002534031867981,
-0.1027873232960701,
-0.17991532385349274,
0.133994460105896,
0.1498783975839615,
-0.7212508320808411,
0.3213981091976166,
0.003811089787632227,
1.261782169342041,
-0.6023016571998596,
0.9712714552879333,
0.5354542136192322,
-0.5254808664321899,
-0.389774352312088,
-0.025778815150260925,
0.11668124794960022,
-0.506210207939148,
0.5479001998901367,
0.07070718705654144,
0.07678348571062088,
-0.21801213920116425,
-0.7785521745681763,
-0.7114594578742981,
0.8084186315536499,
0.6439549326896667,
-0.30268675088882446,
0.02709420770406723,
0.06973932683467865,
0.5218352675437927,
-0.14609938859939575,
0.19159437716007233,
0.35378554463386536,
0.8390189409255981,
-0.29927629232406616,
-0.9278216361999512,
-0.16218632459640503,
-0.3583230972290039,
-0.33208298683166504,
-0.19893229007720947,
-0.6923114061355591,
0.8568721413612366,
-0.39820218086242676,
-0.15755409002304077,
-0.15021753311157227,
1.0702663660049438,
0.12286687642335892,
0.5377886891365051,
0.7293111085891724,
0.45191478729248047,
0.9896365404129028,
0.06782446801662445,
0.7284297347068787,
-0.34249147772789,
0.3392683267593384,
0.9495694637298584,
0.000845132046379149,
0.9467929601669312,
0.5450907349586487,
-0.008901063352823257,
0.6918972730636597,
0.3818883001804352,
-0.060054488480091095,
0.09970133006572723,
-0.09379436075687408,
-0.1373032182455063,
-0.17897960543632507,
-0.46637266874313354,
-0.3438805639743805,
0.5025959610939026,
0.4153338670730591,
-0.1127406433224678,
-0.07849759608507156,
0.012838687747716904,
0.2298341542482376,
0.0017122288700193167,
-0.00523457070812583,
0.6268115043640137,
-0.02736356109380722,
-0.935052752494812,
0.41612789034843445,
0.1221216470003128,
0.457900732755661,
-0.5566292405128479,
-0.27245551347732544,
-0.21407553553581238,
-0.026158221065998077,
-0.46648213267326355,
-0.8021759986877441,
0.07954581081867218,
0.5088911652565002,
-0.5815384984016418,
0.20207011699676514,
0.9765849113464355,
-0.6461966037750244,
-0.31362205743789673,
0.2955198585987091,
0.6227783560752869,
-0.039643045514822006,
-0.32630905508995056,
-0.2643333375453949,
-0.01611790992319584,
-0.15490050613880157,
-0.20004653930664062,
0.036552462726831436,
0.8718592524528503,
-0.17167817056179047,
0.2763821482658386,
0.7371503710746765,
-0.05438084900379181,
-0.04883537441492081,
-0.21639660000801086,
0.6465321183204651,
-0.5228756666183472,
-0.5521153211593628,
-0.746274471282959,
0.3649502098560333,
-0.4061872065067291,
-0.426719069480896,
0.9192820191383362,
0.7056684494018555,
1.2692556381225586,
-0.14280948042869568,
1.1061911582946777,
-0.21162718534469604,
0.39727309346199036,
-0.6603086590766907,
1.0253418684005737,
-0.4271189272403717,
-0.3192901909351349,
-0.10514334589242935,
-0.6410625576972961,
0.1508176177740097,
0.42476800084114075,
0.22537952661514282,
-0.37076854705810547,
0.6995803117752075,
0.750732421875,
0.10328341275453568,
0.1738874316215515,
0.3362031579017639,
0.621850311756134,
0.13137170672416687,
0.21793337166309357,
0.813429057598114,
-0.28853392601013184,
0.860040009021759,
-0.4635484516620636,
-0.24029479920864105,
-0.5968071222305298,
-0.8165838122367859,
-0.7251367568969727,
-0.738930881023407,
-0.5099523067474365,
-0.6518489718437195,
-0.053932756185531616,
0.6307744979858398,
0.5783809423446655,
-0.9336905479431152,
-0.13201598823070526,
0.2681298553943634,
0.8113651871681213,
-0.07540231943130493,
-0.23892712593078613,
0.3080577254295349,
-0.10988478362560272,
-0.5132124423980713,
0.27967655658721924,
0.305622398853302,
-0.3101688027381897,
-0.4175153374671936,
-0.20986057817935944,
-0.3326030969619751,
-0.1839350461959839,
0.740212619304657,
0.29589593410491943,
-0.7115177512168884,
-0.37425655126571655,
0.05430843308568001,
-0.6016354560852051,
0.014974478632211685,
1.0452611446380615,
-0.6785612106323242,
0.7219471335411072,
0.7589336633682251,
0.4620939791202545,
0.4955146312713623,
-0.26779404282569885,
0.34904196858406067,
-0.46812132000923157,
-0.021534129977226257,
-0.351003497838974,
0.3427956700325012,
0.5079948306083679,
-0.3752501904964447,
0.7433506846427917,
0.711413562297821,
-0.2571175694465637,
-0.6675212979316711,
0.018609745427966118,
-0.784291684627533,
-0.18105845153331757,
1.0071653127670288,
-0.1735457479953766,
-0.5060746073722839,
-0.4250554144382477,
-0.24903109669685364,
0.6508988738059998,
-0.1880693882703781,
0.8967638611793518,
0.8715587258338928,
0.29614201188087463,
0.15260173380374908,
-0.5930635929107666,
0.6584229469299316,
-0.10296719521284103,
-0.7117028832435608,
0.11342581361532211,
0.516474723815918,
0.26206913590431213,
0.5351302027702332,
0.6356030702590942,
0.24287591874599457,
0.6360035538673401,
0.007887665182352066,
-0.08583643287420273,
-0.044987715780735016,
-0.35626229643821716,
0.15797260403633118,
0.33299556374549866,
-0.09068406373262405,
0.2004942148923874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07609v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07609v1
|
NoiseBench: Benchmarking the Impact of Real Label Noise on Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-05-13T10:20:31 | 2024-05-13T10:20:31 |
Elena Merdjanovska, Ansar Aynetdinov, Alan Akbik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Available training data for named entity recognition (NER) often contains a
significant percentage of incorrect labels for entity types and entity
boundaries. Such label noise poses challenges for supervised learning and may
significantly deteriorate model quality. To address this, prior work proposed
various noise-robust learning approaches capable of learning from data with
partially incorrect labels. These approaches are typically evaluated using
simulated noise where the labels in a clean dataset are automatically
corrupted. However, as we show in this paper, this leads to unrealistic noise
that is far easier to handle than real noise caused by human error or
semi-automatic annotation. To enable the study of the impact of various types
of real noise, we introduce NoiseBench, an NER benchmark consisting of clean
training data corrupted with 6 types of real noise, including expert errors,
crowdsourcing errors, automatic annotation errors and LLM errors. We present an
analysis that shows that real noise is significantly more challenging than
simulated noise, and show that current state-of-the-art models for noise-robust
learning fall far short of their theoretically achievable upper bound. We
release NoiseBench to the research community.
|
[
-0.4219180643558502,
-0.6808878779411316,
0.27998265624046326,
-0.030268197879195213,
-0.11014362424612045,
0.10552459955215454,
-0.18696120381355286,
-0.9465449452400208,
0.09816381335258484,
0.36856406927108765,
-0.4510310888290405,
-0.25827381014823914,
-0.4716338515281677,
0.19902756810188293,
-0.54533851146698,
0.9358837604522705,
0.05610186234116554,
0.38795238733291626,
-0.1193661242723465,
-0.11837916821241379,
-0.38497108221054077,
-0.46737223863601685,
-0.8823415637016296,
-0.16781273484230042,
0.4760759174823761,
0.13353915512561798,
0.38916581869125366,
0.4548719525337219,
0.5769784450531006,
0.21881285309791565,
-0.07004071027040482,
0.010473928414285183,
-0.5459405779838562,
0.29445964097976685,
-0.08236978203058243,
-0.42375314235687256,
-0.4318583309650421,
0.16815368831157684,
0.5927057862281799,
0.5713221430778503,
-0.27792832255363464,
0.22190092504024506,
-0.12850967049598694,
0.26569733023643494,
-0.6465288400650024,
0.34246179461479187,
-0.5756931900978088,
0.21628190577030182,
-0.3408079445362091,
0.2343994528055191,
-0.4042741358280182,
-0.35596907138824463,
-0.10579227656126022,
-0.7847850918769836,
0.2871217727661133,
0.24104945361614227,
1.3264515399932861,
0.8382946848869324,
-0.02292734384536743,
-0.16213874518871307,
-0.9393969774246216,
0.6886653900146484,
-0.5987342596054077,
0.7558466792106628,
0.46087586879730225,
0.40223073959350586,
-0.3929513096809387,
-0.7402217388153076,
-0.344997763633728,
-0.05342123657464981,
0.26041164994239807,
0.22453828155994415,
-0.24412767589092255,
0.045549605041742325,
0.7577803134918213,
0.3511025607585907,
-0.11112009733915329,
0.18085071444511414,
-0.34395715594291687,
-0.41646140813827515,
0.3650256097316742,
-0.2540740370750427,
0.2500036358833313,
0.27017176151275635,
-0.36672767996788025,
-0.36407992243766785,
-0.39548400044441223,
-0.059015724807977676,
0.6795654296875,
0.2358434945344925,
0.18136826157569885,
-0.0018554914277046919,
-0.1554388552904129,
0.8326919674873352,
0.21296167373657227,
-0.409073144197464,
0.47711870074272156,
0.06515620648860931,
0.008824204094707966,
0.5229885578155518,
0.4932342767715454,
0.1601315438747406,
0.11158670485019684,
-0.44414782524108887,
-0.3968999981880188,
-0.0714452937245369,
0.3683970868587494,
-0.8141283392906189,
-0.7186737656593323,
-0.106740802526474,
-0.27483463287353516,
-0.47780290246009827,
0.09041810780763626,
-0.9217380881309509,
-0.5233187079429626,
-0.4006384611129761,
0.5099786520004272,
-0.27651745080947876,
-0.41990432143211365,
-0.16012243926525116,
-0.05841639265418053,
-0.034339047968387604,
0.4458342492580414,
-0.347385436296463,
0.48545295000076294,
0.5211457014083862,
0.4441157579421997,
-0.018857043236494064,
-0.11804677546024323,
-0.7780935168266296,
-0.167513906955719,
-0.33079373836517334,
1.0009905099868774,
-0.38771215081214905,
-0.3638530671596527,
-0.5035870671272278,
-0.19539108872413635,
0.08770161122083664,
-1.0192844867706299,
0.694651186466217,
-0.5236823558807373,
-0.1962175965309143,
-0.41479769349098206,
-0.656312882900238,
-0.22269372642040253,
0.13792958855628967,
-0.9066842198371887,
1.2370022535324097,
0.27606409788131714,
-0.7976498603820801,
0.8073344230651855,
-0.22826729714870453,
-0.2228168100118637,
-0.06542100757360458,
-0.20035654306411743,
-0.889489471912384,
0.03426704928278923,
-0.08550062030553818,
0.09256699681282043,
-0.12092193216085434,
0.5005582571029663,
-0.35900798439979553,
-0.35387513041496277,
0.4843164086341858,
-0.4044322371482849,
0.5635203123092651,
0.114600770175457,
-0.5191534757614136,
-0.3445807099342346,
-1.2471753358840942,
0.05859988555312157,
-0.03183821216225624,
-0.4005418121814728,
-0.2807076573371887,
0.035534653812646866,
-0.01891687884926796,
0.2405979484319687,
-0.30201706290245056,
-0.585591733455658,
-0.23247970640659332,
-0.11744442582130432,
0.122837133705616,
0.5836091637611389,
0.10786301642656326,
0.0540691502392292,
-0.24707676470279694,
0.30074164271354675,
0.3643234074115753,
-0.058798037469387054,
0.40430545806884766,
-0.28096088767051697,
-0.8184379935264587,
-0.5090987086296082,
1.0369149446487427,
0.3843223452568054,
-0.2391730695962906,
0.048378121107816696,
-0.2679882049560547,
-0.6361101269721985,
-0.5561907291412354,
0.1618804782629013,
0.45743754506111145,
1.01430344581604,
0.6314061284065247,
-0.5339680910110474,
-0.7838175296783447,
-0.8708586692810059,
-0.48690077662467957,
-0.31286612153053284,
0.16892558336257935,
0.22652126848697662,
0.5709214210510254,
-0.2568433880805969,
0.8266838192939758,
0.07162778079509735,
-0.36199936270713806,
0.15973259508609772,
0.3797451853752136,
-0.1835070699453354,
0.49439623951911926,
0.2839262783527374,
-0.6238685250282288,
-0.17850883305072784,
-0.653649628162384,
-0.4951944947242737,
-0.1361074000597,
-0.12958602607250214,
0.03847871720790863,
0.0521576888859272,
0.5642294883728027,
-0.29613715410232544,
0.42880839109420776,
0.27736684679985046,
0.17080236971378326,
0.7861783504486084,
0.1418999284505844,
-0.12995204329490662,
-0.6557950377464294,
-0.030316727235913277,
0.01896164007484913,
-0.1985536366701126,
-0.2711680233478546,
-0.25669583678245544,
0.06527501344680786,
-0.17197774350643158,
-0.25825929641723633,
0.36136820912361145,
-0.6567047834396362,
-0.13221129775047302,
-0.16932040452957153,
-0.0674656480550766,
-0.0229303240776062,
0.179144948720932,
0.10001153498888016,
0.7197473049163818,
0.495187371969223,
-0.6727189421653748,
0.18272198736667633,
0.014152479358017445,
-0.4326721131801605,
0.9028351306915283,
-0.4131384789943695,
-0.0480961874127388,
-0.11378882080316544,
0.4654747545719147,
-0.35825392603874207,
-0.5593370795249939,
0.3708510994911194,
-0.25345566868782043,
0.6492303609848022,
-0.17439307272434235,
-0.6401557326316833,
-0.12691204249858856,
0.12028881162405014,
0.289842426776886,
0.38525891304016113,
-0.7481484413146973,
0.2893436551094055,
0.631325900554657,
0.2957441210746765,
-0.4694306254386902,
-0.7758631706237793,
0.19825978577136993,
-0.14168766140937805,
-0.139674112200737,
0.21427693963050842,
0.07214496284723282,
-0.32975712418556213,
0.28758734464645386,
-0.6674364805221558,
-0.3952959477901459,
0.2564472258090973,
0.5441479086875916,
-0.018340906128287315,
-0.24420398473739624,
0.3897276222705841,
-0.3649574816226959,
-0.3002955913543701,
0.2529744505882263,
-0.07581817358732224,
0.011232509277760983,
-0.23398399353027344,
-0.3794708549976349,
-0.5463955402374268,
-0.27292320132255554,
0.07850659638643265,
-0.08566268533468246,
0.5173308253288269,
0.5862202048301697,
-0.684175431728363,
-0.4476150870323181,
-0.6591084599494934,
-0.26205360889434814,
-0.39816904067993164,
0.40662726759910583,
-0.40550199151039124,
-0.27202874422073364,
0.28593963384628296,
-0.5554275512695312,
-0.01811046153306961,
0.3030449450016022,
-0.06791531294584274,
-0.23250333964824677,
0.614340603351593,
0.4108765125274658,
0.06290385872125626,
0.3677330017089844,
-0.015103750862181187,
0.3989657461643219,
-0.5321853160858154,
-0.2719353139400482,
-0.5563278794288635,
-0.553612232208252,
-0.33809900283813477,
-0.39293643832206726,
-0.07326921820640564,
0.2326233834028244,
-0.2670552730560303,
0.36695733666419983,
-0.565723717212677,
0.5234318971633911,
0.7660626769065857,
0.03656169772148132,
0.356408029794693,
0.27558326721191406,
-0.03850727155804634,
-0.4306064546108246,
-0.545118510723114,
-0.3752431869506836,
0.7962461113929749,
0.22916114330291748,
0.8321257829666138,
-0.1326179951429367,
0.9852551817893982,
0.05007954314351082,
0.3179393410682678,
-0.5714901089668274,
0.4311559796333313,
0.267584890127182,
-0.8570632934570312,
-0.09322433173656464,
-0.50967937707901,
-0.8312650918960571,
-0.1465318202972412,
-0.3444936275482178,
-0.8211797475814819,
0.6674906611442566,
0.2795141041278839,
-0.18260754644870758,
0.7239990830421448,
-0.3621752858161926,
0.7958994507789612,
-0.26166263222694397,
-0.26883748173713684,
0.24362073838710785,
-0.5661879181861877,
0.2747423052787781,
-0.258827269077301,
0.46741223335266113,
-0.28184622526168823,
0.1023169681429863,
1.0932570695877075,
-0.16275888681411743,
0.8235451579093933,
-0.3685363829135895,
0.08606654405593872,
0.44021135568618774,
0.3093535900115967,
0.6983431577682495,
-0.06482809782028198,
-0.19966964423656464,
0.45274296402931213,
-0.13496753573417664,
-0.21103602647781372,
-0.3139711320400238,
0.6750742793083191,
-0.9137702584266663,
-0.14218315482139587,
-0.5338928699493408,
-0.36373472213745117,
-0.3310706615447998,
0.3020888566970825,
0.5466896295547485,
0.4015669524669647,
-0.287040650844574,
0.11701247841119766,
0.9587355256080627,
0.08553546667098999,
0.17720220983028412,
0.4547441899776459,
0.03987486660480499,
-0.4663371443748474,
1.5038769245147705,
0.6558688879013062,
-0.18541762232780457,
-0.036402057856321335,
-0.3063042163848877,
-0.09138650447130203,
-0.5697758197784424,
-0.2830887734889984,
0.054134953767061234,
-0.7713266015052795,
-0.42726290225982666,
-0.7972142696380615,
-0.23032689094543457,
0.09685593843460083,
0.15269356966018677,
-0.7179368734359741,
-0.44283413887023926,
-0.37457728385925293,
-0.44236817955970764,
0.18806305527687073,
0.5521606802940369,
-0.3412192761898041,
0.16932639479637146,
-0.4662570059299469,
0.3766113817691803,
0.2329961061477661,
0.7191826105117798,
-0.1925240010023117,
-0.28841763734817505,
-0.17293410003185272,
0.049067333340644836,
-0.1423305869102478,
-1.0964399576187134,
0.12944269180297852,
0.3729551434516907,
0.6063544750213623,
0.3138751685619354,
0.4089360535144806,
0.7760599255561829,
-0.15043185651302338,
0.3353852331638336,
0.08203768730163574,
-0.6543459296226501,
0.43683555722236633,
0.01712297834455967,
-0.26619458198547363,
1.0323058366775513,
0.14723728597164154,
-0.16106291115283966,
-0.36891311407089233,
-1.2087160348892212,
-0.8559468388557434,
0.5992963314056396,
0.08817557245492935,
-0.4489952325820923,
-0.01983271725475788,
0.25487086176872253,
0.11666218936443329,
0.16896238923072815,
-0.7455472946166992,
-0.21981769800186157,
-0.253854364156723,
-0.03309987112879753,
0.19126556813716888,
-0.20220354199409485,
0.0003655216714832932,
-0.11669352650642395,
1.0216199159622192,
0.202260360121727,
0.06606850773096085,
0.36833927035331726,
-0.4844304919242859,
-0.26587045192718506,
0.2713458836078644,
0.059117503464221954,
0.2908230423927307,
-0.29413673281669617,
0.18719111382961273,
0.3899247944355011,
-0.39874836802482605,
0.1658720076084137,
0.3595063388347626,
-0.5410176515579224,
0.37157878279685974,
0.06856442242860794,
0.8209753632545471,
0.5688400268554688,
-0.7530749440193176,
0.30180823802948,
-0.17213599383831024,
-0.32355889678001404,
-0.5125027298927307,
0.25849559903144836,
0.10466142743825912,
0.016533778980374336,
0.07995633780956268,
0.5188441872596741,
0.33137598633766174,
-0.182791605591774,
0.2580140233039856,
0.06827031075954437,
-0.9953302145004272,
-0.22122317552566528,
0.8751437664031982,
0.14812840521335602,
-0.26630011200904846,
0.8246291875839233,
-0.5187198519706726,
-0.19251929223537445,
0.7016902565956116,
0.3944271504878998,
0.637442409992218,
0.09917702525854111,
0.09999727457761765,
0.7207428812980652,
0.321623295545578,
-0.4867590069770813,
0.06974469125270844,
0.04491984099149704,
-0.4482599198818207,
-0.13210541009902954,
-0.6800115704536438,
-0.7582324147224426,
0.15506361424922943,
-0.8511872291564941,
0.23135340213775635,
-0.5646265745162964,
-0.48791953921318054,
0.15889012813568115,
-0.0253744013607502,
-0.5054094195365906,
0.3899810016155243,
0.24245820939540863,
0.6670315265655518,
-0.47212305665016174,
0.485515296459198,
0.9497929215431213,
-0.37160244584083557,
-0.8561046123504639,
-0.07208852469921112,
0.2937760651111603,
-0.2675739526748657,
0.5591177344322205,
0.32521721720695496,
-0.025987716391682625,
0.21588584780693054,
-0.6452491283416748,
-0.8697885870933533,
0.7167270183563232,
0.4691331386566162,
-0.8202354907989502,
0.24158474802970886,
0.019036775454878807,
0.466212660074234,
0.0995488241314888,
0.09788220375776291,
0.3627675473690033,
0.6993955969810486,
-0.17533592879772186,
-0.6987577676773071,
0.0959651991724968,
-0.12162789702415466,
-0.3851074278354645,
0.3329521715641022,
-0.6793803572654724,
0.549549400806427,
-0.3191412389278412,
-0.4541970193386078,
-0.24487188458442688,
0.5960677266120911,
0.12289352715015411,
0.39487457275390625,
0.6377115249633789,
0.9941753149032593,
1.294811487197876,
-0.37138110399246216,
0.555698812007904,
-0.2800612151622772,
0.36680805683135986,
1.5335074663162231,
-0.33721113204956055,
0.7119267582893372,
0.30727648735046387,
-0.2844577729701996,
0.3778718113899231,
0.765346884727478,
-0.655480146408081,
0.2412799745798111,
0.62367844581604,
-0.34465330839157104,
-0.4578104019165039,
-0.24605733156204224,
-0.4152686893939972,
0.12416579574346542,
0.3707694411277771,
0.05273273587226868,
-0.44175252318382263,
-0.058886051177978516,
-0.01802121102809906,
-0.10729075223207474,
-0.07145518809556961,
0.901561975479126,
0.07135579735040665,
-0.27644526958465576,
0.38168206810951233,
-0.07285050302743912,
0.6123754382133484,
-0.14314532279968262,
-0.061837367713451385,
0.102788545191288,
0.1394468992948532,
-0.40402403473854065,
-0.20446261763572693,
0.2602235674858093,
-0.07181880623102188,
-0.15116140246391296,
0.022917723283171654,
0.8733043074607849,
-0.12323920428752899,
-0.5513381958007812,
0.3327310085296631,
0.42500895261764526,
0.5291541218757629,
-0.21000921726226807,
-0.7756198644638062,
0.028742069378495216,
-0.19269992411136627,
-0.2936226725578308,
0.5096316337585449,
0.23551778495311737,
0.13747912645339966,
0.6331838369369507,
0.5901081562042236,
0.027583088725805283,
0.36204037070274353,
-0.12064895033836365,
0.5614569783210754,
-0.6511200666427612,
-0.13666686415672302,
-0.38504478335380554,
0.1509130448102951,
-0.23038502037525177,
-0.2752262055873871,
0.4412909150123596,
0.7046417593955994,
1.0438358783721924,
0.16638855636119843,
0.564937174320221,
0.039803728461265564,
0.7256386280059814,
-0.12846523523330688,
0.7012213468551636,
-0.47270795702934265,
0.3213760554790497,
-0.17808277904987335,
-0.8456729650497437,
-0.35208532214164734,
0.5023248195648193,
-0.1450003832578659,
-0.06759237498044968,
0.4187638759613037,
0.816709041595459,
-0.24906645715236664,
0.1714572012424469,
0.3625939190387726,
0.4884949028491974,
-0.016117310151457787,
0.06278746575117111,
0.7816978693008423,
-0.6569840908050537,
0.8768371343612671,
-0.8495004773139954,
0.2018931657075882,
-0.21567213535308838,
-0.6550345420837402,
-0.5573326349258423,
-0.1919233202934265,
-1.0548804998397827,
-0.6359076499938965,
0.3453204035758972,
0.5611711740493774,
0.7020294666290283,
-1.0224324464797974,
0.2205904722213745,
-0.23985370993614197,
0.040888648480176926,
-0.47252267599105835,
-0.23335310816764832,
0.2471310794353485,
-0.4179527163505554,
-0.7711677551269531,
0.40223947167396545,
-0.08483847230672836,
0.19400687515735626,
0.285495400428772,
-0.011702758260071278,
0.09158992767333984,
-0.16339737176895142,
-0.023250699043273926,
0.6727758049964905,
-0.41589832305908203,
-0.05001634359359741,
-0.36381787061691284,
-0.2909497618675232,
0.2580185532569885,
0.4314332902431488,
-0.9212722778320312,
0.6062968373298645,
0.14848677814006805,
0.6394175887107849,
0.471043199300766,
-0.10177884250879288,
0.09522811323404312,
-0.5922413468360901,
-0.012372969649732113,
0.2755309045314789,
0.33422327041625977,
0.275921106338501,
-0.2796308100223541,
0.7484910488128662,
0.353512704372406,
-0.5002590417861938,
-1.2501153945922852,
-0.21872249245643616,
-0.8980230093002319,
-0.1173819974064827,
0.7938359379768372,
-0.16949276626110077,
-0.18878303468227386,
-0.3783503770828247,
-0.018386904150247574,
0.4621131718158722,
-0.5443137288093567,
0.7194056510925293,
0.7267441153526306,
-0.06489860266447067,
-0.09804896265268326,
-0.9634148478507996,
0.5571804642677307,
0.2701273560523987,
-0.4722171425819397,
-0.15909947454929352,
0.6256853938102722,
0.5027605295181274,
0.19050009548664093,
0.3297726809978485,
-0.12583854794502258,
0.3024849593639374,
0.46898266673088074,
0.4118487536907196,
-0.1708769053220749,
-0.23961050808429718,
-0.1854010373353958,
0.1377137452363968,
0.24745085835456848,
0.12139374017715454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07597v1
|
Using Model-Theoretic Approaches to Uncover Linguistic Organization
| 2024-05-13T09:58:59 | 2024-05-13T09:58:59 |
Olivia Griffin, Jerry Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we consider pluractional markers in Kaqchikel, Karuk, and
Yurok. Like Balinese, each of these languages marks one type of pluractionality
via reduplication, and a different type of pluractionality via
non-reduplicative affixation. This paper serves as a proof-of-concept for
applying model-theoretic approaches to language as a lens that can help us to
recognize linguistic organization that is not apparent on the surface.
|
[
-0.40167978405952454,
-0.9352353811264038,
0.5348240733146667,
0.19679167866706848,
-0.3712116777896881,
0.0298708938062191,
-0.17749616503715515,
-0.2977914810180664,
0.337782621383667,
0.4974212944507599,
-0.33330219984054565,
-0.40820589661598206,
-0.38676750659942627,
0.15770024061203003,
-0.5260642766952515,
0.7086396813392639,
-0.04442834109067917,
-0.08662497252225876,
0.020647021010518074,
-0.7701256275177002,
-0.2121117115020752,
-0.5352178812026978,
-0.40325894951820374,
-0.5365215539932251,
0.36288678646087646,
0.3223148584365845,
1.056515097618103,
0.9343683123588562,
0.2965300381183624,
0.39602550864219666,
-0.16876870393753052,
0.10249531269073486,
-0.03975880891084671,
0.08696603029966354,
-0.028428349643945694,
-0.9087614417076111,
-0.04098815843462944,
-0.01906355284154415,
0.89035564661026,
1.1263114213943481,
-0.41627317667007446,
0.02396310120820999,
-0.2970200181007385,
0.5974161624908447,
-0.46101585030555725,
0.3293839693069458,
-0.25384294986724854,
0.011901887133717537,
-0.49886390566825867,
-0.19586478173732758,
-0.3850880265235901,
-0.3819180727005005,
-0.030137810856103897,
-0.8392718434333801,
-0.011913612484931946,
-0.009253336116671562,
0.8238192200660706,
-0.0983550101518631,
-0.6517597436904907,
-0.21542301774024963,
-0.6189124584197998,
0.6973468661308289,
-0.6805709600448608,
0.5386327505111694,
0.7086806893348694,
0.30251628160476685,
-0.3291155993938446,
-0.4501756429672241,
-0.6824381351470947,
0.03294059634208679,
-0.2470744103193283,
0.07406385242938995,
0.10332828015089035,
0.1039929911494255,
0.054426394402980804,
0.27453598380088806,
-0.3338600993156433,
0.15426523983478546,
-0.1252536028623581,
0.1572435349225998,
0.8216104507446289,
0.056883689016103745,
0.792728841304779,
-0.01062734704464674,
-0.19826792180538177,
-0.050623271614313126,
-0.6655899286270142,
-0.054980333894491196,
0.40939638018608093,
0.4810747504234314,
-0.2704751789569855,
0.5974611043930054,
-0.3037092983722687,
0.9631807208061218,
-0.0019065841333940625,
-0.36272817850112915,
-0.004121324047446251,
-0.4122631847858429,
-0.1436905413866043,
-0.02382367104291916,
0.6519030928611755,
0.1049802303314209,
0.43807294964790344,
-0.2923884391784668,
0.05969929322600365,
0.20182079076766968,
-0.018080051988363266,
-0.36362507939338684,
-0.722523033618927,
0.07136745005846024,
-0.6580327749252319,
-0.7218739986419678,
0.19380204379558563,
-0.6942305564880371,
-0.6035687327384949,
-0.12055062502622604,
0.23026736080646515,
-0.4631521999835968,
-1.0025184154510498,
-0.22619128227233887,
0.05039773881435394,
0.09299765527248383,
0.251173198223114,
-0.9786309599876404,
0.3356700837612152,
0.6543660163879395,
0.8012599945068359,
0.1534940004348755,
-0.49474576115608215,
-0.0759027972817421,
0.27593711018562317,
-0.5648019909858704,
0.944205105304718,
-1.1053458452224731,
-0.268076628446579,
0.18294936418533325,
-0.011158755980432034,
-0.18535438179969788,
-0.5214158296585083,
0.366499125957489,
-0.302427738904953,
0.040718354284763336,
-0.21311375498771667,
-0.693645715713501,
-0.8457121849060059,
-0.16998261213302612,
-0.7089541554450989,
1.0643277168273926,
0.12109445035457611,
-0.5681919455528259,
0.4053081274032593,
-0.7387032508850098,
-0.5255280137062073,
0.35477814078330994,
-0.34192267060279846,
-0.3993830978870392,
0.7306917905807495,
-0.20717239379882812,
0.24773485958576202,
0.15523439645767212,
0.33336061239242554,
-0.16913749277591705,
-0.26266002655029297,
0.6485037803649902,
0.08195934444665909,
1.0617477893829346,
0.06666239351034164,
-0.1275082677602768,
0.3149281442165375,
-1.2090775966644287,
0.08756206929683685,
0.1411944180727005,
-0.5684691071510315,
-0.9670674204826355,
0.30328062176704407,
-0.08812917023897171,
0.2179630696773529,
0.016694245859980583,
-0.48748457431793213,
0.2808547019958496,
-0.4227904677391052,
0.7435596585273743,
0.5395691990852356,
-0.12858298420906067,
0.4923240840435028,
-0.09494400024414062,
0.5187245607376099,
0.343868225812912,
-0.14143586158752441,
0.0024207737296819687,
-0.7031272649765015,
-1.2997157573699951,
-0.22006216645240784,
0.33792051672935486,
0.12449613213539124,
-0.8099883794784546,
0.1557435393333435,
-0.021739721298217773,
-0.5300939679145813,
-0.5986775755882263,
-0.08497676998376846,
0.44374457001686096,
0.3260040879249573,
0.054673582315444946,
-0.1943080574274063,
-0.496257483959198,
-1.0345585346221924,
-0.22372141480445862,
-0.6070351600646973,
0.44443410634994507,
-0.02555917389690876,
0.5659439563751221,
0.28819993138313293,
0.6667760014533997,
-0.12352170795202255,
0.028142504394054413,
-0.05880918353796005,
0.27673637866973877,
0.32011353969573975,
0.23837603628635406,
0.5490944385528564,
-0.9765505194664001,
-0.42728739976882935,
0.6086755990982056,
-0.5046561360359192,
-0.2920399308204651,
0.2681792676448822,
-0.06937573850154877,
0.15700757503509521,
0.37716981768608093,
-0.47682660818099976,
0.4759659171104431,
0.518456757068634,
-0.560810387134552,
0.2902582287788391,
-0.1839669644832611,
-0.020898019894957542,
-0.84062260389328,
0.2274661511182785,
-0.3954731523990631,
-0.22838763892650604,
-1.2279596328735352,
0.5042958855628967,
-0.020304396748542786,
0.16287407279014587,
-0.059962693601846695,
0.34536468982696533,
-0.4026831090450287,
-0.13623644411563873,
-0.40052530169487,
0.1282641440629959,
-0.213114395737648,
0.5085681080818176,
0.41939598321914673,
0.6404248476028442,
0.14531269669532776,
-0.5843842625617981,
0.09302063286304474,
0.27534762024879456,
-0.5934114456176758,
0.49689286947250366,
-0.2743721902370453,
-0.08503997325897217,
-0.22458256781101227,
-0.19220441579818726,
-1.2526274919509888,
-0.21590185165405273,
0.20500755310058594,
-0.15066702663898468,
-0.07275484502315521,
-0.3428996801376343,
-0.6806403994560242,
0.056630171835422516,
-0.03669975325465202,
0.5916620492935181,
0.2736242115497589,
-0.3873540461063385,
0.40878236293792725,
0.4197101294994354,
-0.017613273113965988,
-0.16737690567970276,
-0.6023505926132202,
-0.3210820257663727,
-0.6215370893478394,
-0.3183695077896118,
-0.044014669954776764,
0.05395625904202461,
-0.6710699200630188,
-0.34383711218833923,
0.23868384957313538,
-0.5276593565940857,
0.6837894320487976,
0.42480558156967163,
-0.005564181134104729,
-0.30992525815963745,
0.13403059542179108,
-0.038996659219264984,
0.024791620671749115,
-0.28304553031921387,
-0.019766150042414665,
0.47712644934654236,
0.05647353082895279,
0.016787178814411163,
-0.5243785381317139,
0.4660279452800751,
0.43944278359413147,
-0.39701175689697266,
0.8096023201942444,
0.1578313410282135,
-0.3724101185798645,
-0.02541009895503521,
-0.4705207347869873,
0.01849997788667679,
-0.4109119772911072,
0.22903136909008026,
-0.5332182049751282,
-0.5646580457687378,
0.6447941064834595,
-0.13376227021217346,
-0.29189518094062805,
0.27572739124298096,
0.6888172626495361,
-0.20542991161346436,
1.0781946182250977,
0.9213507771492004,
0.24734178185462952,
0.5930460095405579,
-0.04860546812415123,
0.4247218370437622,
-0.6418807506561279,
-0.10152822732925415,
-0.5163179039955139,
-0.1505691260099411,
-0.7213093042373657,
-0.11088469624519348,
0.1848830282688141,
0.7642167806625366,
-0.16654960811138153,
0.5354833602905273,
-0.2533249855041504,
0.5218167901039124,
0.28561460971832275,
-0.4066620171070099,
0.6629583239555359,
0.03692804276943207,
-0.35950133204460144,
-0.12658071517944336,
-0.8957410454750061,
-0.527652382850647,
0.6437395215034485,
0.3393815755844116,
0.09995214641094208,
0.3725469410419464,
0.79400235414505,
-0.40135103464126587,
0.4102058410644531,
-0.5061110854148865,
0.4997234046459198,
-0.08385992795228958,
-0.6425197720527649,
-0.31388142704963684,
-0.09926619380712509,
-0.8894091248512268,
0.6827149987220764,
-0.12861314415931702,
-0.9567362666130066,
0.8908630609512329,
-0.14761725068092346,
-0.15299981832504272,
0.13960111141204834,
-0.7905811667442322,
0.7485533952713013,
0.14341062307357788,
-0.06240982189774513,
-0.11402539163827896,
-0.3901343047618866,
0.25998950004577637,
-0.02962840534746647,
0.6562088131904602,
-0.2772359251976013,
-0.12471184879541397,
0.916549026966095,
-0.5597952008247375,
0.863083004951477,
-0.2056678831577301,
-0.39637625217437744,
0.38602566719055176,
0.507428765296936,
0.3075805604457855,
-0.21147239208221436,
-0.05683591961860657,
0.14545129239559174,
0.330567866563797,
-0.2080634981393814,
-0.5684418082237244,
0.46650227904319763,
-0.6021372079849243,
-0.10985501855611801,
-0.3409889042377472,
-0.69753497838974,
0.001615103567019105,
0.6308525204658508,
0.06845249980688095,
0.45490920543670654,
-0.02218390628695488,
-0.11324787884950638,
0.01796385459601879,
0.09328014403581619,
0.6794895529747009,
0.8047937154769897,
-0.43108171224594116,
-0.28050413727760315,
0.9384869933128357,
0.3673885762691498,
0.19666334986686707,
0.32876190543174744,
0.28034189343452454,
-0.1915748566389084,
-0.8656290769577026,
-0.03591868281364441,
0.618076503276825,
-0.7403162121772766,
-0.12268760800361633,
-0.17306427657604218,
0.20042580366134644,
-0.13940924406051636,
-0.13406626880168915,
-0.3221888244152069,
-0.7610783576965332,
0.08010954409837723,
-0.06390334665775299,
0.3727973997592926,
1.04356849193573,
0.07745107263326645,
0.6262245774269104,
-0.29187026619911194,
-0.08032949268817902,
-0.10515446960926056,
0.3177782893180847,
0.1140245571732521,
-0.07101611793041229,
-0.3099854588508606,
0.26604822278022766,
-0.07434600591659546,
-0.9229220747947693,
0.4586775004863739,
0.3822971284389496,
0.3442605435848236,
0.7392008304595947,
-0.16396431624889374,
0.9967583417892456,
-0.5345675945281982,
0.45528659224510193,
0.1673085242509842,
-0.8021129369735718,
0.5932537317276001,
-0.6594987511634827,
0.12031347304582596,
0.5937284231185913,
0.16993927955627441,
-0.6557662487030029,
-0.6464047431945801,
-0.6211470365524292,
-0.55177903175354,
0.43369558453559875,
0.3255974352359772,
-0.2328510731458664,
-0.24160432815551758,
0.53333580493927,
0.19081120193004608,
0.4497372508049011,
-0.8298605680465698,
-0.2957250773906708,
-0.3128943145275116,
-0.2691602408885956,
-0.07618355751037598,
-0.4165099859237671,
-0.3291175961494446,
-0.15138624608516693,
0.31794729828834534,
-0.103825643658638,
0.2655327618122101,
0.044258568435907364,
-0.3451996147632599,
-0.25254902243614197,
0.24987013638019562,
1.0525833368301392,
1.0501618385314941,
0.12306080013513565,
0.39049234986305237,
-0.3865405023097992,
-0.29302719235420227,
0.20667080581188202,
-0.18748001754283905,
-0.40628695487976074,
0.004229846876114607,
0.9576805830001831,
0.7776913642883301,
0.3023831844329834,
-0.43642595410346985,
0.36075955629348755,
0.3660944700241089,
0.043813321739435196,
-0.31323346495628357,
-0.16478614509105682,
0.17327523231506348,
0.38870370388031006,
0.025563037022948265,
-0.5205236673355103,
0.175714373588562,
-0.7845743298530579,
-0.20093685388565063,
0.2699962556362152,
-0.03686540946364403,
-0.8417724967002869,
0.4200839698314667,
0.1355203241109848,
-0.36377981305122375,
0.5439158082008362,
0.1524285078048706,
-0.6804813146591187,
0.491843581199646,
0.6018199920654297,
0.6467319130897522,
-0.7554041147232056,
0.4777303636074066,
0.24539895355701447,
0.06215348839759827,
0.043301649391651154,
0.4895723760128021,
-0.32268208265304565,
-1.046105146408081,
-0.291923850774765,
-0.68964022397995,
0.03594869002699852,
-0.17946180701255798,
-0.7529165744781494,
0.18971948325634003,
-0.5689387917518616,
0.025386376306414604,
0.5243179202079773,
-0.09950285404920578,
-0.21470436453819275,
0.025684652850031853,
-0.01867348700761795,
0.42146584391593933,
-1.1492598056793213,
1.1156080961227417,
0.9414013028144836,
-0.5612727999687195,
-0.6147940754890442,
-0.38670167326927185,
-0.0870601162314415,
-1.0098284482955933,
0.9626671075820923,
0.03380269557237625,
0.1036338061094284,
0.05251490697264671,
-0.21419058740139008,
-0.7303621172904968,
0.9063277244567871,
0.027514925226569176,
-0.2966368496417999,
-0.09751828014850616,
0.2241625040769577,
0.6604034304618835,
-0.4534529745578766,
0.1654488742351532,
0.6479883193969727,
0.7130217552185059,
-0.5289093852043152,
-1.1043788194656372,
0.021318143233656883,
-0.29217758774757385,
0.39937320351600647,
0.6560596227645874,
-0.6255159974098206,
0.9098361730575562,
0.12293355911970139,
-0.7524252533912659,
0.3848705589771271,
0.43299224972724915,
-0.0460941381752491,
-0.059345588088035583,
0.35812604427337646,
0.5775606632232666,
0.5357270836830139,
-0.08656521141529083,
1.0187275409698486,
-0.16224262118339539,
0.5048428773880005,
0.8579369187355042,
-0.011316195130348206,
0.8728039860725403,
0.8589251637458801,
-0.5710108280181885,
0.7758755683898926,
0.36092180013656616,
0.16690891981124878,
0.6339676976203918,
-0.07379744946956635,
-0.23678497970104218,
-0.31315508484840393,
-0.44522860646247864,
-0.05495605617761612,
0.7675233483314514,
0.5049234628677368,
-0.2562061548233032,
-0.2203628271818161,
0.10482262820005417,
0.26276350021362305,
0.32010117173194885,
-0.20842286944389343,
0.9364885091781616,
0.038579341024160385,
-0.5161142349243164,
0.8090168237686157,
0.17877011001110077,
0.18673868477344513,
-0.4378189444541931,
-0.20070844888687134,
-0.22109557688236237,
0.13647820055484772,
-0.288665771484375,
-0.5718854665756226,
0.27030789852142334,
-0.66452956199646,
0.03412644937634468,
0.023164501413702965,
0.5990261435508728,
-0.7750861048698425,
-0.5371951460838318,
0.16399787366390228,
0.20063965022563934,
0.09140609204769135,
0.4001582860946655,
-0.27516883611679077,
0.26749324798583984,
-0.1411672979593277,
0.05154631659388542,
-0.02748427353799343,
0.2929195165634155,
-0.42059633135795593,
0.6505692005157471,
0.3909918963909149,
0.26439350843429565,
0.2346634566783905,
0.04833035543560982,
0.3232247531414032,
-0.5684424042701721,
-0.7254968285560608,
-0.8219775557518005,
0.428478479385376,
-0.03493739664554596,
-0.26041045784950256,
0.993075430393219,
0.24261268973350525,
0.801868736743927,
-0.02627824805676937,
0.4639272093772888,
0.009996111504733562,
0.5033121705055237,
-0.44494158029556274,
0.6602044701576233,
-0.43935251235961914,
-0.2979110777378082,
-0.4365472197532654,
-0.9152723550796509,
-0.7518553137779236,
1.2759205102920532,
-0.3514384329319,
-0.11999761313199997,
0.7723600268363953,
0.38985708355903625,
0.03696481138467789,
0.31412574648857117,
0.39017626643180847,
0.5667924284934998,
0.1305888444185257,
0.3009094297885895,
0.9572814702987671,
-0.2634254992008209,
0.021171385422348976,
-0.7218449115753174,
-0.11124655604362488,
-0.19246327877044678,
-0.5259597897529602,
-0.9830747246742249,
-1.1606725454330444,
-0.586507260799408,
-0.05553240701556206,
-0.029044438153505325,
0.4649260938167572,
0.46734094619750977,
-0.8754569888114929,
-0.6494263410568237,
-0.47715142369270325,
0.0359528549015522,
-0.39264237880706787,
-0.1884462684392929,
0.4564608931541443,
-0.00944426003843546,
-0.5826271176338196,
0.4600581228733063,
0.4402998983860016,
0.27701523900032043,
-0.2541862428188324,
0.16112187504768372,
-0.7094042897224426,
-0.02305256575345993,
0.6158170104026794,
0.3524438142776489,
-1.0569103956222534,
-0.5335866212844849,
-0.6606879234313965,
0.4180964529514313,
0.17219680547714233,
1.1227023601531982,
-0.4623410999774933,
0.5669078230857849,
0.6224748492240906,
0.16833612322807312,
0.12306585162878036,
0.03600577265024185,
0.5201427340507507,
-0.7087404131889343,
0.7560276389122009,
-0.11472418159246445,
0.3526211977005005,
0.26857009530067444,
-0.006407182198017836,
0.6267442107200623,
0.3371504843235016,
-0.18764476478099823,
-1.2662022113800049,
0.648531436920166,
-0.5752029418945312,
-0.2229226529598236,
0.7264387607574463,
-0.1628088355064392,
-0.3558642268180847,
-0.3790096938610077,
0.012667885050177574,
0.12378735095262527,
0.10467192530632019,
0.5162622928619385,
1.1532752513885498,
-0.2329302579164505,
-0.5278534293174744,
-0.4599752128124237,
0.5574839115142822,
0.5130270719528198,
-0.4081767499446869,
0.2351301610469818,
0.30683520436286926,
0.4917086064815521,
0.4618864953517914,
0.7219595909118652,
-0.22200611233711243,
0.14575980603694916,
-0.07733901590108871,
-0.2565426528453827,
-0.07437529414892197,
-0.37394651770591736,
-0.5359542965888977,
0.04834774509072304,
0.3592492640018463,
-0.087346650660038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07586v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07586v1
|
Thai Universal Dependency Treebank
| 2024-05-13T09:48:13 | 2024-05-13T09:48:13 |
Panyut Sriwirote, Wei Qi Leong, Charin Polpanumas, Santhawat Thanyawong, William Chandra Tjhi, Wirote Aroonmanakun, Attapol T. Rutherford
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic dependency parsing of Thai sentences has been underexplored, as
evidenced by the lack of large Thai dependency treebanks with complete
dependency structures and the lack of a published systematic evaluation of
state-of-the-art models, especially transformer-based parsers. In this work, we
address these problems by introducing Thai Universal Dependency Treebank (TUD),
a new largest Thai treebank consisting of 3,627 trees annotated in accordance
with the Universal Dependencies (UD) framework. We then benchmark dependency
parsing models that incorporate pretrained transformers as encoders and train
them on Thai-PUD and our TUD. The evaluation results show that most of our
models can outperform other models reported in previous papers and provide
insight into the optimal choices of components to include in Thai dependency
parsers. The new treebank and every model's full prediction generated in our
experiment are made available on a GitHub repository for further study.
|
[
-0.4075210690498352,
-0.28796616196632385,
0.3756772577762604,
0.35067492723464966,
-0.3230227530002594,
0.008501609787344933,
0.055804960429668427,
-0.6161290407180786,
0.014578930102288723,
0.4895518124103546,
0.007519732229411602,
-0.3851097524166107,
-0.5415381193161011,
0.48908671736717224,
-0.10271592438220978,
0.6842008829116821,
-0.22330471873283386,
0.17915436625480652,
0.19874855875968933,
-0.3133513033390045,
-0.6317282319068909,
-0.4812956154346466,
-0.10129056870937347,
-0.27710679173469543,
0.36779364943504333,
0.6498246788978577,
0.434755802154541,
0.6205882430076599,
0.6991526484489441,
0.20779713988304138,
-0.08804640918970108,
-0.3843422830104828,
0.08375468850135803,
0.23619306087493896,
-0.1516120731830597,
-0.36406636238098145,
-0.38796451687812805,
-0.1782337874174118,
0.4765053391456604,
0.5631420612335205,
-0.08332559466362,
0.20208214223384857,
0.11823222786188126,
0.6340651512145996,
-0.8502728939056396,
0.5008394122123718,
-0.4580395221710205,
0.1541214883327484,
-0.17903681099414825,
0.03642112389206886,
-0.5867651700973511,
-0.40761470794677734,
0.48752713203430176,
-0.4572138488292694,
0.14652912318706512,
-0.25857192277908325,
0.9999646544456482,
0.37445488572120667,
-1.0032367706298828,
0.01734926551580429,
-0.5305977463722229,
0.3325307071208954,
-0.3128100037574768,
0.6360288858413696,
0.30484288930892944,
0.6792917847633362,
-0.0182789359241724,
-0.850874662399292,
-0.11803954094648361,
-0.17814983427524567,
-0.25503361225128174,
0.10583622753620148,
-0.13540734350681305,
0.45650196075439453,
0.03908156976103783,
0.6169108152389526,
-0.44376230239868164,
0.1704481691122055,
0.09550853818655014,
-0.058337997645139694,
0.115301214158535,
-0.161270409822464,
0.1743410974740982,
-0.7884501814842224,
-0.12561443448066711,
-0.1574278622865677,
-0.6023586392402649,
0.27247363328933716,
0.1137438416481018,
0.14047576487064362,
-0.10005871206521988,
0.7668212652206421,
-0.1515653282403946,
0.39405861496925354,
0.05358537286520004,
0.2232176512479782,
0.03730010613799095,
-0.2496606558561325,
-0.47465986013412476,
0.2941771447658539,
0.7268205285072327,
0.3963785469532013,
0.726430356502533,
0.12050583213567734,
-0.11389079689979553,
0.3158637285232544,
0.00873839296400547,
-0.9775891304016113,
-0.6429904699325562,
0.04006323218345642,
-0.43848446011543274,
-0.38481834530830383,
0.1894422471523285,
-0.9240895509719849,
-0.2730492949485779,
-0.25227659940719604,
-0.1695687174797058,
-0.41106370091438293,
-0.553462028503418,
0.2540827989578247,
0.1179599016904831,
0.15388496220111847,
0.02647537551820278,
-0.730042576789856,
0.32009121775627136,
0.3502747118473053,
0.7633410096168518,
-0.10517419129610062,
-0.0747479498386383,
-0.5441075563430786,
0.35987335443496704,
-0.15406964719295502,
1.1316983699798584,
-0.7385795712471008,
-0.4168274402618408,
0.05738874897360802,
0.2674894332885742,
0.08242914825677872,
-0.5442805886268616,
0.7943158745765686,
-0.3459812104701996,
0.25027263164520264,
-0.310267835855484,
-0.5017263293266296,
-0.4342593252658844,
0.030217168852686882,
-0.8823572397232056,
0.9232061505317688,
0.6895365715026855,
-1.1562111377716064,
0.4883641004562378,
-0.9555793404579163,
-0.43065962195396423,
0.11530984193086624,
-0.15094923973083496,
-0.44944241642951965,
0.1117589920759201,
0.40796875953674316,
0.4567859470844269,
-0.42324361205101013,
0.8481899499893188,
-0.2759575843811035,
0.09294997900724411,
-0.26566365361213684,
-0.24831055104732513,
1.3181977272033691,
0.4383411705493927,
-0.25173190236091614,
0.2526649534702301,
-0.9892114996910095,
-0.22912222146987915,
0.015881752595305443,
-0.4199541211128235,
-0.3130471706390381,
-0.46265652775764465,
0.4377446472644806,
-0.10449164360761642,
-0.10847557336091995,
-0.7528336048126221,
0.3904722332954407,
-0.34117451310157776,
0.47282859683036804,
0.808380126953125,
0.03799499571323395,
0.13766172528266907,
0.01480752695351839,
0.7665930986404419,
0.5586560368537903,
-0.13664281368255615,
-0.7433285713195801,
-0.2850353717803955,
-0.6088698506355286,
-0.18253447115421295,
0.6500778794288635,
0.40599584579467773,
-0.26148471236228943,
0.6854544281959534,
-0.45330020785331726,
-0.3104991614818573,
-0.43588948249816895,
-0.2282092273235321,
0.2839563488960266,
0.5055443644523621,
0.249222993850708,
-0.5645973682403564,
-1.3018512725830078,
-0.8385387063026428,
-0.19317378103733063,
-0.41046401858329773,
0.026932943612337112,
-0.10878688842058182,
0.5736107230186462,
-0.448670357465744,
1.2976280450820923,
-0.23525892198085785,
-0.35394373536109924,
-0.3087207078933716,
-0.026459449902176857,
-0.20798230171203613,
0.5483807921409607,
0.6274899840354919,
-0.41875267028808594,
-0.8654830455780029,
0.13023272156715393,
-0.5632350444793701,
-0.28948408365249634,
0.24734416604042053,
0.11653146147727966,
0.20589423179626465,
0.4302549660205841,
-0.9012624025344849,
0.43910902738571167,
0.34152188897132874,
-0.5744448304176331,
0.7726513147354126,
-0.07738754898309708,
-0.018325846642255783,
-1.1445677280426025,
0.1511092334985733,
0.06322869658470154,
-0.5108842849731445,
-0.22165963053703308,
0.0363590307533741,
0.2643934190273285,
-0.1322716325521469,
-0.3380909264087677,
0.2908462882041931,
-0.440836101770401,
-0.2602795362472534,
0.11607631295919418,
-0.6121585965156555,
0.2829248309135437,
0.46852049231529236,
-0.08777715265750885,
0.6641297340393066,
0.42862668633461,
-0.3462267518043518,
0.39879220724105835,
0.20162944495677948,
-0.4584936797618866,
0.48104435205459595,
-0.7410644292831421,
-0.1263047754764557,
-0.16818223893642426,
0.537880539894104,
-1.0850815773010254,
-0.29939547181129456,
0.0647013932466507,
-0.017449498176574707,
0.348867267370224,
-0.558475911617279,
-0.5061675310134888,
-0.4190017580986023,
-0.17424318194389343,
0.603912889957428,
0.37709373235702515,
-0.635246992111206,
0.6377277970314026,
0.5210700631141663,
0.15272200107574463,
-0.343439519405365,
-0.5341534614562988,
0.05149611458182335,
-0.38108065724372864,
-0.4233368933200836,
0.24711382389068604,
0.24675427377223969,
-0.27929288148880005,
0.09562931954860687,
-0.19422878324985504,
-0.24129682779312134,
0.08101191371679306,
0.40068668127059937,
-0.059726059436798096,
-0.764427125453949,
-0.07527127861976624,
-0.2785276174545288,
-0.5114601850509644,
0.09183036535978317,
-0.4490061402320862,
0.5512287020683289,
-0.32056429982185364,
-0.2955607771873474,
-0.6841554045677185,
0.16344338655471802,
0.7005618810653687,
-0.40717896819114685,
0.21880097687244415,
0.1710367649793625,
-0.35041874647140503,
0.5232950448989868,
-0.6354591250419617,
0.35201409459114075,
-0.4483775198459625,
0.5001856684684753,
-0.7859441637992859,
-0.74032062292099,
0.35252493619918823,
-0.22469834983348846,
0.056240975856781006,
0.4922378659248352,
0.18549814820289612,
0.12079332768917084,
1.279353141784668,
0.9571709632873535,
-0.3191832900047302,
0.47474393248558044,
-0.13406796753406525,
-0.03401994705200195,
-0.5917263031005859,
0.14982423186302185,
-0.7309946417808533,
0.07623295485973358,
-0.8160765171051025,
0.1281970590353012,
-0.034036047756671906,
0.27643853425979614,
-0.6183238625526428,
0.5402151346206665,
-0.6595351099967957,
0.7077990174293518,
0.5243421196937561,
-0.41149967908859253,
0.5973640084266663,
-0.007426456548273563,
-0.5375461578369141,
-0.025388775393366814,
-0.45180803537368774,
-0.6136998534202576,
1.3558745384216309,
0.3367358148097992,
0.3941816985607147,
-0.3379967212677002,
0.2388225793838501,
0.09863005578517914,
0.3450077176094055,
-0.5996180772781372,
0.2128485143184662,
-0.14404696226119995,
-0.24411821365356445,
0.046674977988004684,
-0.13628870248794556,
-1.3412419557571411,
0.10964912921190262,
0.4135371744632721,
-0.6958822011947632,
0.10402905941009521,
-0.06723304092884064,
-0.30724871158599854,
0.40000301599502563,
-1.1308642625808716,
1.2773957252502441,
-0.1419099122285843,
0.3653659224510193,
0.0012390550691634417,
-0.5974840521812439,
0.568827748298645,
0.09676684439182281,
-0.18914251029491425,
-0.006105697248131037,
0.319438099861145,
0.7516332268714905,
-0.5008359551429749,
0.48151054978370667,
-0.42522040009498596,
-0.07034708559513092,
0.30834516882896423,
0.18575991690158844,
0.2532092034816742,
0.13129141926765442,
0.12238367646932602,
-0.03751080110669136,
0.32902026176452637,
-0.388976126909256,
-0.3613843023777008,
0.4903358817100525,
-0.9719251394271851,
-0.37800076603889465,
-0.46927112340927124,
-0.30872642993927,
-0.18588672578334808,
0.38272470235824585,
0.24670034646987915,
0.27423202991485596,
-0.18471340835094452,
0.2796926498413086,
0.23377850651741028,
-0.2195757031440735,
0.5305581092834473,
0.45009976625442505,
-0.7326979041099548,
-0.6288554072380066,
0.38227373361587524,
0.08479991555213928,
-0.1902455985546112,
0.3549818992614746,
0.21661606431007385,
-0.4116555452346802,
-0.1404038518667221,
-0.49745455384254456,
0.14181281626224518,
-0.8262560367584229,
-0.405452162027359,
-0.9153512716293335,
-0.25027865171432495,
-0.5536282062530518,
0.01584879867732525,
-0.5426681041717529,
-0.5114810466766357,
0.0904851108789444,
-0.5352800488471985,
0.4203667938709259,
1.014043927192688,
0.11963454633951187,
0.5788863301277161,
-0.6952588558197021,
0.6187071204185486,
0.3215840458869934,
0.8533627986907959,
-0.04839615896344185,
-0.10866691917181015,
-0.0014374388847500086,
0.01892484724521637,
-0.5625130534172058,
-0.855746865272522,
0.24198554456233978,
0.008503002114593983,
0.16936847567558289,
0.5845626592636108,
0.1550571322441101,
0.755470871925354,
-0.47884923219680786,
0.4257832467556,
0.34232908487319946,
-0.7728440761566162,
0.7328378558158875,
-0.0623607374727726,
0.5209883451461792,
0.51654452085495,
0.2975836992263794,
-0.5700771808624268,
-0.2593848705291748,
-0.6160095930099487,
-0.5239672064781189,
0.5752744078636169,
-0.025623902678489685,
-0.44079384207725525,
0.15760917961597443,
0.09682851284742355,
0.38842707872390747,
-0.19780823588371277,
-0.864360511302948,
-0.14517003297805786,
-0.49796268343925476,
-0.36440590023994446,
0.006082306616008282,
-0.5168826580047607,
0.5073684453964233,
-0.5164945125579834,
0.5032534599304199,
0.1308993250131607,
-0.07520303875207901,
0.12674136459827423,
-0.47412222623825073,
-0.5416767001152039,
0.16026566922664642,
-0.034091658890247345,
0.5432718992233276,
-0.27083760499954224,
0.496753990650177,
-0.17750762403011322,
-0.6288481950759888,
0.6328461766242981,
0.16899725794792175,
-0.23881131410598755,
0.4084917902946472,
0.026686478406190872,
0.6108094453811646,
0.19306865334510803,
-0.6642125248908997,
0.40583541989326477,
-0.23098574578762054,
0.11573498696088791,
-0.4042366147041321,
-0.18322061002254486,
0.1681371033191681,
-0.1351804882287979,
0.15221929550170898,
0.21346569061279297,
-0.05424390360713005,
-0.26856285333633423,
0.5070900321006775,
0.07652266323566437,
-0.5662615299224854,
-0.5787581205368042,
0.762952983379364,
0.21142621338367462,
-0.3264262080192566,
0.47483351826667786,
0.02909756824374199,
-0.7199010252952576,
0.49810466170310974,
0.3637453019618988,
1.1519380807876587,
-0.4860595762729645,
0.229483500123024,
0.388126015663147,
0.1258026361465454,
-0.016737625002861023,
0.1981348842382431,
-0.0029009757563471794,
-0.5336892008781433,
-0.7167791128158569,
-0.6037099361419678,
-0.17264848947525024,
0.3394431471824646,
-0.5608906149864197,
0.6167944669723511,
-0.19494198262691498,
0.06474518775939941,
-0.05878669396042824,
0.17664840817451477,
-0.7232376933097839,
0.053247589617967606,
-0.3701948821544647,
0.7232107520103455,
-0.6900427341461182,
1.2004307508468628,
0.860722005367279,
-0.6094928979873657,
-0.6436625123023987,
-0.1548832654953003,
-0.2936882972717285,
-0.5923044085502625,
0.6944004893302917,
0.7953974604606628,
0.21673674881458282,
0.2242109477519989,
-0.1578809767961502,
-0.6219239830970764,
0.6086046695709229,
0.7828792333602905,
-0.5046939253807068,
-0.13937607407569885,
0.725896418094635,
0.37053388357162476,
-0.2181447595357895,
0.7170334458351135,
0.8853685855865479,
0.644093930721283,
-0.3602639436721802,
-0.9378892183303833,
-0.08393101394176483,
-0.5195195078849792,
0.1284954696893692,
0.10493050515651703,
-0.3647758960723877,
0.5544797778129578,
0.16538456082344055,
-0.3774975538253784,
-0.10035011172294617,
0.596772313117981,
0.18677692115306854,
-0.10912110656499863,
0.7498568296432495,
0.877920389175415,
0.4294227659702301,
0.18016886711120605,
0.768282949924469,
-0.4972449839115143,
0.22651022672653198,
1.2019816637039185,
-0.2289205640554428,
0.48266443610191345,
0.2668001651763916,
-0.37460780143737793,
0.5265501737594604,
0.8779734969139099,
0.04179561510682106,
0.41162657737731934,
0.16789677739143372,
-0.029653530567884445,
-0.03709268197417259,
-0.5402431488037109,
-0.5653002858161926,
0.4923938512802124,
-0.1188131645321846,
-0.19426102936267853,
-0.599180281162262,
0.19949638843536377,
-0.226234570145607,
-0.07365881651639938,
0.019741931930184364,
0.641994059085846,
0.05160759761929512,
-0.7353707551956177,
0.6132721304893494,
-0.06564855575561523,
0.5727844834327698,
-0.26921790838241577,
-0.13783468306064606,
-0.28073108196258545,
0.269440233707428,
-0.14405038952827454,
-0.60698002576828,
0.19242553412914276,
0.32910290360450745,
0.001578599913045764,
-0.5018540024757385,
0.5973504185676575,
-0.20754119753837585,
-0.46765947341918945,
0.37133875489234924,
0.41371744871139526,
-0.006188466679304838,
-0.42697951197624207,
-0.27329662442207336,
-0.3174993395805359,
0.005234248470515013,
-0.36305296421051025,
0.35675087571144104,
0.9922993779182434,
-0.16589055955410004,
0.6085026860237122,
0.416217178106308,
-0.02922028861939907,
0.1318550705909729,
0.1775805801153183,
0.6298426389694214,
-0.8333947062492371,
-0.7590598464012146,
-0.958177924156189,
0.4526803493499756,
0.24595896899700165,
-0.45676931738853455,
0.5731127262115479,
0.9410284161567688,
1.0444068908691406,
0.03760245814919472,
0.8753224015235901,
0.034510716795921326,
0.5168157815933228,
-0.09623441845178604,
0.40293774008750916,
-0.19727690517902374,
0.26206088066101074,
-0.3440874516963959,
-1.1976852416992188,
-0.4149591326713562,
0.5421891808509827,
0.09633243829011917,
-0.24082624912261963,
0.8905724883079529,
0.3800715506076813,
-0.488153874874115,
0.5177896618843079,
0.04054323956370354,
0.38669508695602417,
0.6134368181228638,
0.6761228442192078,
0.973415195941925,
-0.3827226161956787,
0.7878982424736023,
-0.5833293199539185,
0.3471114933490753,
-0.16900669038295746,
-0.8289040923118591,
-0.6483075618743896,
-0.6520805358886719,
-0.30031323432922363,
-0.09989863634109497,
-0.09448111057281494,
0.9182093143463135,
0.5154878497123718,
-1.2925727367401123,
-0.5010477304458618,
-0.9224743247032166,
0.15476654469966888,
0.26415252685546875,
-0.2864703834056854,
0.5710678100585938,
-0.48315173387527466,
-0.4647137522697449,
-0.04833533614873886,
0.3031380772590637,
0.35377612709999084,
-0.21919576823711395,
0.017553851008415222,
-0.24892215430736542,
-0.7394120097160339,
0.4750351309776306,
0.00793660432100296,
-0.7597284913063049,
-0.5507028102874756,
-0.17968524992465973,
-0.23161223530769348,
0.7507041692733765,
0.9713069200515747,
-1.0532221794128418,
0.43823206424713135,
0.3474201261997223,
0.8424332737922668,
0.4425022304058075,
-0.034594036638736725,
0.8833163380622864,
-0.4118730127811432,
0.18019501864910126,
0.12589983642101288,
0.7126278877258301,
0.2824997007846832,
0.10169683396816254,
0.8643077611923218,
0.3404233753681183,
-0.46192607283592224,
-0.9871066808700562,
0.26230141520500183,
-0.6980208158493042,
-0.1882040947675705,
1.006838083267212,
-0.46361497044563293,
-0.0036481693387031555,
-0.5734331011772156,
-0.6137114763259888,
0.622267484664917,
-0.20158538222312927,
0.6908355951309204,
0.6560078859329224,
0.19434379041194916,
-0.407927542924881,
-0.31155556440353394,
0.44886213541030884,
0.5483615398406982,
-0.7473200559616089,
0.38509175181388855,
0.46697723865509033,
-0.04545601084828377,
-0.13491831719875336,
0.6342451572418213,
0.10530243813991547,
0.21606045961380005,
-0.17727799713611603,
0.1376533806324005,
0.08034969121217728,
-0.36147239804267883,
-0.3490188717842102,
0.2519831657409668,
0.04310457035899162,
-0.16108454763889313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13008v1
|
Control Token with Dense Passage Retrieval
| 2024-05-13T09:17:19 | 2024-05-13T09:17:19 |
Juhwan Lee, Jisu Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study addresses the hallucination problem in large language models
(LLMs). We adopted Retrieval-Augmented Generation(RAG) (Lewis et al., 2020), a
technique that involves embedding relevant information in the prompt to obtain
accurate answers. However, RAG also faced inherent issues in retrieving correct
information. To address this, we employed the Dense Passage Retrieval(DPR)
(Karpukhin et al., 2020) model for fetching domain-specific documents related
to user queries. Despite this, the DPR model still lacked accuracy in document
retrieval. We enhanced the DPR model by incorporating control tokens, achieving
significantly superior performance over the standard DPR model, with a 13%
improvement in Top-1 accuracy and a 4% improvement in Top-20 accuracy.
|
[
-0.09673810750246048,
-0.9285579919815063,
0.6720624566078186,
0.17354395985603333,
-0.3134167790412903,
0.29594096541404724,
-0.18972037732601166,
-0.3533288538455963,
0.3469744026660919,
0.6810433864593506,
-0.1705572009086609,
-0.3870043158531189,
-0.7847471237182617,
0.17997565865516663,
-0.45421963930130005,
0.6329792737960815,
-0.03794725239276886,
0.1262187659740448,
0.01674898900091648,
0.106781505048275,
-0.6268431544303894,
-0.7624989151954651,
-0.8458554744720459,
-0.39951351284980774,
0.6183500289916992,
0.236986443400383,
0.7229251861572266,
0.5369563102722168,
0.7503532767295837,
0.2671670913696289,
-0.4341754615306854,
0.4257405698299408,
-0.46906760334968567,
0.31670811772346497,
-0.3586673140525818,
-0.437610924243927,
-0.41351136565208435,
-0.25728142261505127,
0.6665868163108826,
0.6764914989471436,
-0.2671615779399872,
-0.3870571553707123,
-0.034848470240831375,
0.5403690338134766,
-0.5464913845062256,
-0.2290063202381134,
-0.9544458389282227,
0.12586165964603424,
-0.15841007232666016,
-0.6541137099266052,
-0.8023298382759094,
-0.11936952918767929,
-0.20698121190071106,
-0.5276792049407959,
0.21382196247577667,
0.3539915978908539,
0.8746345639228821,
0.335837185382843,
-0.39943069219589233,
-0.639675498008728,
-0.6580660343170166,
0.8736042380332947,
-0.6219975352287292,
0.48625311255455017,
0.6268623471260071,
0.2586236596107483,
-0.4735024869441986,
-1.07023286819458,
-0.7536277770996094,
-0.4590374827384949,
-0.24589769542217255,
-0.13916009664535522,
0.043642159551382065,
0.10140357911586761,
0.37730735540390015,
0.2599216401576996,
-0.40588808059692383,
0.2282760739326477,
-0.39295831322669983,
-0.2818649709224701,
0.4923672676086426,
0.44492340087890625,
0.20311351120471954,
-0.5211460590362549,
-0.5170627236366272,
-0.150692418217659,
-0.5151669979095459,
-0.2813343107700348,
0.15303583443164825,
0.49556413292884827,
0.22288590669631958,
0.9149824380874634,
0.024290503934025764,
0.767148494720459,
0.15114472806453705,
-0.2723351716995239,
0.1962563544511795,
-0.29800689220428467,
-0.09625264257192612,
-0.04939001798629761,
0.31947505474090576,
0.14012853801250458,
0.20375928282737732,
-0.3405911922454834,
-0.6276836395263672,
-0.3169058859348297,
0.4818689227104187,
-0.8287835121154785,
0.10444310307502747,
0.4392063617706299,
-0.45868444442749023,
-0.19659046828746796,
0.3107753396034241,
-0.7802709341049194,
-0.6218556761741638,
-0.5893585085868835,
0.38812801241874695,
-0.34362757205963135,
-0.3720094859600067,
0.10102400928735733,
-0.3041660487651825,
0.3866414427757263,
0.4826614558696747,
-0.9541179537773132,
0.5413205623626709,
0.9158862829208374,
1.1968846321105957,
-0.9743726849555969,
-0.06629467755556107,
-0.7500894069671631,
0.20878510177135468,
-0.45149511098861694,
0.553563117980957,
-0.8036599159240723,
-0.5895872116088867,
0.016770973801612854,
-0.11927443742752075,
-0.14516718685626984,
-0.8585250973701477,
0.45096978545188904,
-0.9295003414154053,
-0.04151734709739685,
-0.32951459288597107,
-0.6563360095024109,
0.049635276198387146,
0.1374131143093109,
-0.7380297183990479,
1.0452048778533936,
0.16139757633209229,
-0.8264859914779663,
0.30056509375572205,
-0.29807716608047485,
-0.2951718866825104,
0.24936166405677795,
-0.5757073760032654,
-0.11831000447273254,
0.22973079979419708,
0.07270070165395737,
0.5354952812194824,
0.04203075170516968,
0.4811735451221466,
0.06965772807598114,
-0.7713084816932678,
0.3595215678215027,
-0.29817771911621094,
0.6593436598777771,
0.3097248375415802,
-0.4099676012992859,
0.059104952961206436,
-0.6812487244606018,
-0.1481446772813797,
0.08198618143796921,
-0.3993226885795593,
-0.522635817527771,
-0.24456942081451416,
0.13994106650352478,
0.14932890236377716,
0.31198757886886597,
-0.3446667790412903,
0.45830783247947693,
-0.21183612942695618,
0.09730929136276245,
0.8958423733711243,
0.3246215879917145,
0.5027196407318115,
-0.26998230814933777,
0.6327789425849915,
0.254508912563324,
-0.07636479288339615,
0.11600267887115479,
-0.30091047286987305,
-0.4708397090435028,
-0.30760127305984497,
0.2962874472141266,
0.4310431480407715,
-0.8245429396629333,
0.4528147280216217,
-0.15706463158130646,
-0.2818535566329956,
-0.2558467984199524,
0.08214264363050461,
0.19730223715305328,
0.550010621547699,
0.40160179138183594,
-0.060655560344457626,
-0.3348647952079773,
-0.5057275295257568,
-0.03555174171924591,
0.005101848393678665,
0.0473046638071537,
0.6209051609039307,
0.6275567412376404,
-0.41364753246307373,
0.6219601035118103,
-0.6270477175712585,
-0.37461042404174805,
-0.4416743516921997,
0.062301792204380035,
0.302062064409256,
0.5889574289321899,
0.17200563848018646,
-1.1616488695144653,
-0.45450064539909363,
0.010078122839331627,
-0.6139999032020569,
-0.017730163410305977,
-0.21188117563724518,
-0.3241611123085022,
0.4719473719596863,
0.6946930289268494,
-0.8591112494468689,
0.4897177815437317,
0.269802063703537,
-0.5831142067909241,
0.5475016236305237,
-0.19362327456474304,
0.2159147709608078,
-1.1611087322235107,
0.4368886649608612,
-0.5021778345108032,
-0.21212227642536163,
-0.5110947489738464,
0.09176810830831528,
0.19883029162883759,
0.019387073814868927,
-0.36968737840652466,
0.9087620973587036,
-0.4416676461696625,
-0.25995934009552,
-0.36386603116989136,
0.4729691445827484,
0.05991920083761215,
0.41012924909591675,
0.06444089114665985,
1.0976134538650513,
0.28238654136657715,
-0.7906085848808289,
0.16067494451999664,
0.3319171071052551,
-0.24060653150081635,
0.2129971981048584,
-0.7227121591567993,
0.2948347330093384,
-0.28614309430122375,
0.14530101418495178,
-0.9691154956817627,
-0.3250349760055542,
0.10540798306465149,
-0.4186302125453949,
0.5874466896057129,
0.27571332454681396,
-0.5665888786315918,
-0.18310824036598206,
-0.09680996090173721,
0.20445320010185242,
0.348615825176239,
-0.5132166147232056,
0.706541121006012,
0.3023845851421356,
-0.23668324947357178,
-0.909424901008606,
-0.5916081070899963,
0.16947278380393982,
0.00585343549028039,
-0.18285678327083588,
0.5605951547622681,
-0.05744089558720589,
-0.5098816752433777,
-0.16048935055732727,
-0.21978577971458435,
0.06994609534740448,
0.051468443125486374,
0.0725763589143753,
0.15935765206813812,
0.15356768667697906,
0.4070710837841034,
0.10557054728269577,
-0.037300605326890945,
-0.20771920680999756,
0.006513006519526243,
1.0159629583358765,
0.34284377098083496,
-0.3177424669265747,
-0.3561403155326843,
0.4785839319229126,
0.5956217050552368,
-0.18258985877037048,
0.8384056091308594,
0.4363839030265808,
-0.475885272026062,
-0.4111107587814331,
-0.7178443074226379,
-0.586587131023407,
-0.4921415448188782,
0.307110071182251,
-0.7232306003570557,
-1.103895902633667,
0.7220445871353149,
0.10562228411436081,
-0.22227786481380463,
0.21159717440605164,
0.5304139256477356,
0.2541578710079193,
1.106299638748169,
0.7236731648445129,
0.006106162443757057,
0.5804547071456909,
-0.21405872702598572,
0.08595375716686249,
-1.0008233785629272,
-0.5371639132499695,
-0.7003753185272217,
-0.2610075771808624,
-0.33947545289993286,
-0.5168489217758179,
0.2595697045326233,
0.4029064476490021,
-0.19516059756278992,
0.11932320147752762,
-0.6027815937995911,
0.20925089716911316,
0.447066992521286,
0.32647812366485596,
0.5907421708106995,
0.2648147642612457,
-0.600878119468689,
-0.2051348090171814,
-0.5979647636413574,
-0.4560810923576355,
0.956218957901001,
0.20367977023124695,
0.875495195388794,
0.14932599663734436,
0.6903192400932312,
0.4821285009384155,
0.10970889776945114,
-0.6548570394515991,
0.5806303024291992,
-0.0013812780380249023,
-0.6487241983413696,
-0.4365042746067047,
-0.624526858329773,
-1.0416560173034668,
0.33282747864723206,
0.06120184808969498,
-0.828481912612915,
0.3148491382598877,
-0.22283826768398285,
-0.3415653109550476,
0.19712702929973602,
-0.32644131779670715,
0.5437483787536621,
-0.17872777581214905,
-0.37868091464042664,
-0.20661930739879608,
-0.34599992632865906,
0.23616409301757812,
-0.3517998158931732,
-0.20591473579406738,
0.2328287661075592,
-0.42729586362838745,
0.6985039114952087,
-0.3900130093097687,
0.6525751352310181,
-0.3243236541748047,
-0.05292433500289917,
0.17960628867149353,
0.28293853998184204,
0.8715789914131165,
-0.03619314730167389,
-0.42874011397361755,
-0.10523280501365662,
-0.28549522161483765,
-0.35559555888175964,
-0.8668861985206604,
0.7420618534088135,
-0.6913977861404419,
-0.7596755623817444,
-0.4058057963848114,
-0.5395163893699646,
0.04433595761656761,
0.33896127343177795,
0.12415087223052979,
0.49960845708847046,
0.2706562876701355,
0.3400682806968689,
0.8359732627868652,
-0.290515661239624,
0.3753036558628082,
0.5181760191917419,
-0.5077639818191528,
-0.49035102128982544,
0.505763053894043,
0.2945302724838257,
0.22567544877529144,
0.49562275409698486,
0.10762479901313782,
-0.5612284541130066,
-0.7416315078735352,
-0.34775349497795105,
0.4960469901561737,
-0.7999251484870911,
-0.3248278796672821,
-1.0924376249313354,
-0.25343066453933716,
-0.4806905686855316,
-0.14494720101356506,
-0.006293152458965778,
-0.3251565992832184,
-0.4883257746696472,
-0.3169013261795044,
0.379865825176239,
0.793387770652771,
0.10656344890594482,
0.3372654318809509,
-0.6282141208648682,
0.45619672536849976,
-0.017138462513685226,
0.32732030749320984,
0.239021897315979,
-0.9447615742683411,
-0.1119750589132309,
-0.27052631974220276,
-0.08285539597272873,
-0.9180110692977905,
0.48455220460891724,
-0.13395927846431732,
0.6775201559066772,
0.2063768059015274,
0.1479964554309845,
0.767490565776825,
-0.40654900670051575,
0.8949055075645447,
-0.13268931210041046,
-0.7826799154281616,
0.524223804473877,
-0.11829420924186707,
0.15489527583122253,
0.6371799111366272,
0.5549554228782654,
-0.40719303488731384,
-0.35283318161964417,
-0.49683877825737,
-0.9310077428817749,
0.40100526809692383,
0.03935300558805466,
0.23154422640800476,
-0.20685869455337524,
0.7826434373855591,
0.04075798764824867,
0.33369767665863037,
-0.6351895928382874,
-0.0048430729657411575,
0.3046712279319763,
-0.08210311084985733,
0.00729473028331995,
-0.4285397231578827,
0.11717210710048676,
-0.22428415715694427,
0.5935559272766113,
-0.1440715342760086,
0.2180050015449524,
0.6382776498794556,
-0.02679634653031826,
-0.3797953426837921,
-0.027152180671691895,
0.7487067580223083,
1.0427165031433105,
-0.21748904883861542,
0.15003298223018646,
0.08932734280824661,
-0.7722591161727905,
0.07663508504629135,
-0.08570833504199982,
-0.35437965393066406,
0.2742074131965637,
0.29978981614112854,
0.6667752265930176,
-0.0409039631485939,
-0.7996730208396912,
0.6306992769241333,
0.08745836466550827,
-0.016168467700481415,
-0.5422757863998413,
-0.01418711431324482,
-0.28658679127693176,
0.24075698852539062,
0.7699138522148132,
-0.1846523880958557,
0.14541812241077423,
-0.24439749121665955,
0.6283028721809387,
0.5202577114105225,
-0.4113820195198059,
0.173662468791008,
0.7796242237091064,
-0.07430750876665115,
-0.40656691789627075,
0.8495187759399414,
-0.1254022866487503,
-0.5345334410667419,
0.4608786702156067,
0.7499447464942932,
0.822636067867279,
-0.07583685219287872,
0.1525297462940216,
0.4780000150203705,
0.2931438386440277,
-0.22033549845218658,
0.5417426824569702,
-0.16783961653709412,
-0.6800898909568787,
-0.7246391773223877,
-0.9561914205551147,
-0.5339111685752869,
0.23442994058132172,
-0.6684180498123169,
0.24697917699813843,
-0.4424535930156708,
-0.23750633001327515,
-0.42677798867225647,
0.375946581363678,
-0.38102075457572937,
0.13354207575321198,
-0.20617307722568512,
1.2826495170593262,
-0.5068457126617432,
0.8829260468482971,
0.3610849678516388,
-0.6281719207763672,
-0.9969726204872131,
0.014501052908599377,
-0.4546891152858734,
-0.6243715286254883,
1.0315556526184082,
0.0756247341632843,
-0.08769962936639786,
0.18372389674186707,
-0.5595529079437256,
-0.8506319522857666,
1.238354206085205,
-0.1279737651348114,
-0.7906605005264282,
-0.05468953028321266,
0.09525887668132782,
0.5426691174507141,
-0.2903362214565277,
0.08191268146038055,
0.48426148295402527,
0.5159299373626709,
0.3014877140522003,
-0.7011789083480835,
0.3031006455421448,
-0.09735338389873505,
0.10998412221670151,
0.040177710354328156,
-0.48830747604370117,
0.943541944026947,
-0.1528366208076477,
-0.17582173645496368,
0.0784706100821495,
0.7437275052070618,
0.5578572750091553,
0.2614963948726654,
0.4939749538898468,
0.6068515777587891,
1.0859421491622925,
0.14844726026058197,
1.2136907577514648,
-0.19399553537368774,
0.010549305938184261,
1.020202875137329,
-0.48444539308547974,
1.1463910341262817,
0.8712648749351501,
0.11756023019552231,
0.29829540848731995,
0.4048638343811035,
0.14740006625652313,
0.5214943289756775,
0.35164305567741394,
-0.26597070693969727,
-0.16771502792835236,
-0.2245917022228241,
-0.22398290038108826,
0.2976190745830536,
0.45938247442245483,
-0.5190616250038147,
0.22864073514938354,
0.1546200066804886,
0.14109791815280914,
0.19134904444217682,
-0.3596652150154114,
0.9712068438529968,
0.2082623392343521,
-0.8679457306861877,
0.7297929525375366,
-0.0496610589325428,
0.647257387638092,
-0.480177640914917,
-0.31376492977142334,
-0.5723662376403809,
0.19734127819538116,
-0.21847964823246002,
-0.5585750341415405,
0.32078036665916443,
0.03391347825527191,
-0.03559798747301102,
-0.17338205873966217,
0.8956812620162964,
-0.40367579460144043,
-0.36205703020095825,
0.4396214187145233,
0.649459719657898,
0.3720836639404297,
-0.12475328892469406,
-0.5805203914642334,
0.4756750166416168,
-0.026269156485795975,
-0.4419722855091095,
0.13523411750793457,
0.5276341438293457,
-0.22276665270328522,
0.7176454663276672,
0.5812861919403076,
0.3920198976993561,
0.2686097323894501,
0.29747894406318665,
1.0326735973358154,
-0.8665168285369873,
-0.28775522112846375,
-0.7647626399993896,
0.3728376030921936,
-0.35843297839164734,
-0.28005531430244446,
0.709046483039856,
0.5746256113052368,
0.773800253868103,
-0.021425895392894745,
0.6168914437294006,
-0.0992160364985466,
0.7575986981391907,
-0.6997644901275635,
0.764398992061615,
-0.7387675642967224,
0.2639371156692505,
-0.18377873301506042,
-1.1244949102401733,
-0.5332263112068176,
0.6089816689491272,
-0.15395140647888184,
0.11038544774055481,
0.7314590811729431,
1.2506368160247803,
0.08291067183017731,
-0.4308079183101654,
0.5408682823181152,
0.24898625910282135,
0.27501338720321655,
0.11903887242078781,
0.8427867293357849,
-0.4488510191440582,
0.42701977491378784,
-0.12667791545391083,
-0.15340904891490936,
-0.465532511472702,
-0.6681680083274841,
-0.9419211745262146,
-0.5613769292831421,
-0.04914165660738945,
-0.5529710650444031,
0.12733574211597443,
0.9533383846282959,
0.4030158817768097,
-0.9269189238548279,
-0.14066894352436066,
-0.25947773456573486,
0.25196921825408936,
-0.0940176248550415,
-0.3145098388195038,
0.5597339272499084,
-0.775479793548584,
-0.8084006905555725,
0.35708773136138916,
0.1793496459722519,
0.23348866403102875,
-0.4474518299102783,
-0.26814693212509155,
-0.21242672204971313,
0.13030578196048737,
0.48932182788848877,
-0.15660785138607025,
-0.7815443277359009,
-0.30265647172927856,
0.34157803654670715,
-0.6059398055076599,
-0.11238879710435867,
1.0857617855072021,
-0.5506840944290161,
0.32964879274368286,
0.6487087607383728,
0.944799542427063,
0.5661119818687439,
0.3149944245815277,
0.4305720329284668,
-0.6889087557792664,
0.22763946652412415,
0.5136104226112366,
0.21484802663326263,
0.4046975374221802,
-0.617322564125061,
0.5691764950752258,
0.2415384203195572,
-0.629019558429718,
-0.9533576369285583,
0.11420899629592896,
-1.186970591545105,
-0.4184916317462921,
1.4091887474060059,
0.1219586655497551,
-0.289870947599411,
-0.2377283126115799,
-0.5360729098320007,
0.20415104925632477,
-0.4065760374069214,
0.8463483452796936,
0.6285459399223328,
0.06310466676950455,
-0.23315474390983582,
-0.5871439576148987,
0.6143575310707092,
0.48358869552612305,
-0.5018994808197021,
0.011087060905992985,
0.5212163925170898,
-0.137857586145401,
0.23322159051895142,
0.8763898611068726,
-0.3742946684360504,
-0.053433965891599655,
0.05039319396018982,
-0.010257309302687645,
0.027365801855921745,
-0.5989342331886292,
-0.42465710639953613,
0.3538152873516083,
0.1605769246816635,
0.12484797835350037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13007v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13007v1
|
News Recommendation with Category Description by a Large Language Model
| 2024-05-13T08:53:43 | 2024-05-13T08:53:43 |
Yuki Yada, Hayato Yamana
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Personalized news recommendations are essential for online news platforms to
assist users in discovering news articles that match their interests from a
vast amount of online content. Appropriately encoded content features, such as
text, categories, and images, are essential for recommendations. Among these
features, news categories, such as tv-golden-globe, finance-real-estate, and
news-politics, play an important role in understanding news content, inspiring
us to enhance the categories' descriptions. In this paper, we propose a novel
method that automatically generates informative category descriptions using a
large language model (LLM) without manual effort or domain-specific knowledge
and incorporates them into recommendation models as additional information. In
our comprehensive experimental evaluations using the MIND dataset, our method
successfully achieved 5.8% improvement at most in AUC compared with baseline
approaches without the LLM's generated category descriptions for the
state-of-the-art content-based recommendation models including NAML, NRMS, and
NPA. These results validate the effectiveness of our approach. The code is
available at https://github.com/yamanalab/gpt-augmented-news-recommendation.
|
[
-0.609396755695343,
-0.6337972283363342,
0.6028742790222168,
0.1317034661769867,
-0.6791645884513855,
0.010251631028950214,
-0.3128717243671417,
-0.33168739080429077,
0.6317918300628662,
0.6836124658584595,
-0.6074379682540894,
-0.7639676332473755,
-0.26057103276252747,
-0.014845394529402256,
-0.26083338260650635,
1.3807376623153687,
0.037695448845624924,
-0.14677654206752777,
-0.1375943124294281,
0.09417179226875305,
-0.7164698839187622,
-0.36913150548934937,
-0.5242252349853516,
-0.16377221047878265,
0.47842544317245483,
0.2780398428440094,
0.43844765424728394,
0.5881544947624207,
0.64039546251297,
0.19246906042099,
0.0006187610561028123,
0.4290343225002289,
-0.19175101816654205,
-0.2235216349363327,
-0.26821795105934143,
-0.2095971554517746,
-0.47701209783554077,
-0.31109869480133057,
0.38481882214546204,
0.38073691725730896,
-0.3344394266605377,
0.1437538117170334,
-0.026397917419672012,
0.8973634839057922,
-0.28231629729270935,
0.34106525778770447,
-0.7880117893218994,
0.2561575174331665,
-0.05869678780436516,
-0.5718627572059631,
-0.3453143537044525,
-0.3986997902393341,
0.3295411765575409,
-0.6536830067634583,
0.057715706527233124,
0.42711684107780457,
0.7212830185890198,
0.008397319354116917,
-0.5027570724487305,
-0.4297526180744171,
-0.8698652386665344,
0.6209570169448853,
-0.43758025765419006,
0.39604315161705017,
0.6885131597518921,
0.3995250165462494,
-0.09474129974842072,
-0.3882914185523987,
-0.39793726801872253,
-0.440005898475647,
-0.09091954678297043,
0.02642572484910488,
-0.23645621538162231,
-0.14654818177223206,
-0.06324269622564316,
0.567903459072113,
-0.6545705199241638,
-0.2686183750629425,
-0.20721372961997986,
-0.20689266920089722,
0.4218258559703827,
0.1285558044910431,
0.1683804988861084,
-0.21882721781730652,
-0.32062697410583496,
0.2751041054725647,
-0.5867013931274414,
-0.2611047327518463,
0.30912503600120544,
0.33655062317848206,
-0.08394795656204224,
0.8227711319923401,
-0.596868097782135,
0.8121273517608643,
0.24968785047531128,
-0.19180913269519806,
0.2512471079826355,
-0.4904259145259857,
-0.0726097822189331,
0.24756819009780884,
0.5126587748527527,
0.7861334681510925,
0.3354361355304718,
-0.355469673871994,
-0.0665668323636055,
-0.15055154263973236,
0.2856575548648834,
-0.6518914103507996,
-0.12947532534599304,
-0.14963030815124512,
-0.48617351055145264,
-0.24503067135810852,
0.23675298690795898,
-0.6773639917373657,
-0.701791524887085,
-0.36754310131073,
0.15056876838207245,
-0.1223486140370369,
-0.04598383232951164,
0.46870681643486023,
0.2210557609796524,
-0.15818597376346588,
0.2761727273464203,
-0.7151522040367126,
0.03138894960284233,
0.33018115162849426,
0.6340723037719727,
-0.06998109072446823,
0.06263507902622223,
-0.5575394630432129,
0.3794596493244171,
-0.09881360083818436,
0.9768637418746948,
-0.5745826363563538,
-0.04655393958091736,
0.05703842267394066,
-0.08083157241344452,
0.45762500166893005,
-0.3211570680141449,
0.45232948660850525,
-0.663361132144928,
0.14577674865722656,
-0.21270179748535156,
-0.521150529384613,
-0.4567444622516632,
0.21381010115146637,
-0.7116996645927429,
0.6261792182922363,
0.15729330480098724,
-0.8114905953407288,
0.6346035599708557,
-0.7895601987838745,
-0.5767319798469543,
0.17016670107841492,
0.21402323246002197,
-0.21307814121246338,
-0.08594691008329391,
0.8095822930335999,
0.6664986610412598,
-0.24481341242790222,
0.7929432988166809,
-0.19356447458267212,
-0.12959453463554382,
0.21128606796264648,
-0.22896936535835266,
0.09297098964452744,
0.1451660543680191,
-0.11991065740585327,
0.33591586351394653,
-0.8395562171936035,
-0.38548576831817627,
0.02656148560345173,
-0.22842194139957428,
-0.45626455545425415,
0.08991334587335587,
0.10197457671165466,
0.08160137385129929,
0.43537670373916626,
-0.3517230153083801,
0.31977203488349915,
-0.47720474004745483,
0.1738017499446869,
0.6490784883499146,
0.2880895435810089,
0.39916861057281494,
-0.2867686450481415,
0.5280182361602783,
-0.0021307682618498802,
0.0328228585422039,
-0.22653882205486298,
-0.3007301688194275,
-0.7334756255149841,
-0.03576807677745819,
0.4081110656261444,
0.5447494983673096,
-1.0038660764694214,
0.8167093396186829,
-0.18897785246372223,
-0.2923216223716736,
-0.21488775312900543,
0.2936169505119324,
0.18604451417922974,
0.2423582673072815,
0.43267542123794556,
-0.3845650255680084,
-1.0293841361999512,
-0.8843764066696167,
-0.28462618589401245,
-0.08837796002626419,
0.004289223812520504,
0.4233298599720001,
0.08449843525886536,
-0.3751736581325531,
0.9322003126144409,
-0.737490713596344,
-0.6448156833648682,
-0.47551682591438293,
-0.2000388354063034,
0.30314427614212036,
-0.047206394374370575,
0.2586192786693573,
-0.5897408127784729,
-0.29245564341545105,
0.08336925506591797,
-0.3170824646949768,
-0.08000904321670532,
-0.1782754510641098,
-0.3107960522174835,
-0.046530503779649734,
0.08833331614732742,
-0.3809029161930084,
0.3042718768119812,
0.2787010967731476,
-0.5402556657791138,
0.4563145041465759,
-0.17739762365818024,
-0.0013732680818066,
-1.453488826751709,
-0.18291865289211273,
0.7265353798866272,
-0.3473583161830902,
-0.2046261429786682,
-0.030282694846391678,
-0.2590481638908386,
0.19146430492401123,
-0.30517446994781494,
0.888591468334198,
-0.07492206990718842,
0.18245629966259003,
-0.19560666382312775,
0.309363454580307,
-0.11777107417583466,
0.6540355086326599,
0.25753387808799744,
0.4042920172214508,
0.5441015362739563,
-0.6205887794494629,
0.5808484554290771,
0.16279815137386322,
-0.6980127692222595,
0.45239925384521484,
-0.3729003071784973,
-0.028068644925951958,
-0.09489309042692184,
0.6321586966514587,
-0.706018328666687,
-0.2728295922279358,
0.26299595832824707,
0.02106352150440216,
-0.11259765177965164,
0.008693640120327473,
-0.7497061491012573,
-0.3594595193862915,
-0.19728083908557892,
0.28779324889183044,
0.22506533563137054,
-0.518339216709137,
0.38635966181755066,
0.5109918713569641,
-0.2129705846309662,
-0.5220052599906921,
-0.4459858238697052,
0.39180147647857666,
-0.31525763869285583,
-0.18531154096126556,
0.3488113284111023,
-0.36419761180877686,
0.08677111566066742,
0.2102368324995041,
0.15213406085968018,
-0.05202760174870491,
-0.03579156845808029,
0.1730324923992157,
0.4629654884338379,
-0.14697463810443878,
0.42041680216789246,
-0.026565521955490112,
0.12097670137882233,
-0.28307008743286133,
-0.4335959851741791,
0.6917141675949097,
-0.3731348216533661,
-0.019737377762794495,
-0.44608792662620544,
0.27100425958633423,
0.24257531762123108,
-0.5903933048248291,
0.6712775230407715,
0.9905586838722229,
-0.24065351486206055,
-0.15897461771965027,
-0.6638602018356323,
-0.06702572852373123,
-0.4209788143634796,
0.6485807299613953,
-0.11933890730142593,
-1.2119427919387817,
0.2840292751789093,
0.16869638860225677,
-0.1613871306180954,
0.49616992473602295,
0.6248165369033813,
0.42353424429893494,
1.2063075304031372,
0.7172529697418213,
-0.3526354134082794,
0.4585733711719513,
-0.12905427813529968,
0.2725614309310913,
-0.7417316436767578,
-0.20953869819641113,
-0.02506822533905506,
-0.1549583077430725,
-0.3851589858531952,
-0.2133919894695282,
0.17373919486999512,
-0.2091003954410553,
-0.25890013575553894,
0.2282276600599289,
-0.7531090974807739,
0.547521710395813,
0.5030078291893005,
0.021732138469815254,
0.7079755067825317,
0.33670279383659363,
-0.024098709225654602,
0.060523226857185364,
-0.6153607964515686,
-0.4004500210285187,
1.1262507438659668,
0.3740454912185669,
0.9940308928489685,
-0.05995486304163933,
0.5372521877288818,
0.5239295363426208,
0.37406694889068604,
-0.9387981295585632,
0.6128868460655212,
-0.5187152028083801,
-0.30938494205474854,
-0.025610417127609253,
-0.3677036166191101,
-0.8569760322570801,
-0.10699918121099472,
-0.3423727750778198,
-0.6398417949676514,
-0.014974229037761688,
-0.020279821008443832,
-0.5458293557167053,
0.324873685836792,
-0.18659058213233948,
0.3756597340106964,
-0.3743920922279358,
0.13088445365428925,
-0.33363646268844604,
-0.1294230967760086,
0.4905347228050232,
-0.33332008123397827,
0.36301296949386597,
-0.10318133980035782,
-0.051658179610967636,
0.7397444248199463,
-0.039013899862766266,
0.801784873008728,
-0.08472725003957748,
-0.16104847192764282,
0.3963213562965393,
-0.14611229300498962,
0.4451272189617157,
0.2626298666000366,
0.05212918668985367,
-0.01343925204128027,
-0.21731184422969818,
0.18463242053985596,
-0.4207409918308258,
0.691933274269104,
-0.6003244519233704,
-0.5957769155502319,
-0.2099243700504303,
-0.7586714625358582,
-0.3193364143371582,
0.17286743223667145,
-0.033926308155059814,
0.7179731130599976,
-0.1033458486199379,
0.46461477875709534,
0.4268578290939331,
-0.4288732707500458,
0.16944530606269836,
0.67511385679245,
-0.6337162852287292,
-0.7580881714820862,
1.1435586214065552,
-0.08763403445482254,
-0.4739496409893036,
0.6974575519561768,
0.30614709854125977,
-0.40847936272621155,
-0.4835670590400696,
-0.4545832872390747,
0.12013346701860428,
-0.5395346879959106,
-0.3648337721824646,
-0.7594264149665833,
-0.016988743096590042,
-0.1418440341949463,
-0.08133047074079514,
0.06375408172607422,
-0.3485225439071655,
-0.13332556188106537,
-0.1390751302242279,
0.4599321782588959,
0.7972367405891418,
0.48618605732917786,
0.31726083159446716,
-0.6951984167098999,
0.6727594137191772,
0.3491494953632355,
0.6893792152404785,
0.08969012647867203,
-0.28311780095100403,
-0.7008935213088989,
0.014619637280702591,
-0.3118147552013397,
-0.4398159682750702,
0.5610149502754211,
0.1392185240983963,
0.5179568529129028,
0.37645605206489563,
0.21866104006767273,
0.5039635896682739,
-0.7207116484642029,
0.7540136575698853,
0.2419845312833786,
-0.6699787974357605,
0.6506311893463135,
-0.5603390336036682,
0.42944344878196716,
0.38368937373161316,
0.12525008618831635,
-0.4178261160850525,
-0.5374711155891418,
-0.2726759612560272,
-0.8598967790603638,
0.45926183462142944,
-0.0672370120882988,
0.3105165958404541,
-0.09843519330024719,
0.3666505217552185,
0.3097061812877655,
0.4414593577384949,
-0.8973113298416138,
-0.13565967977046967,
-0.1419837325811386,
-0.4189222455024719,
-0.1560819149017334,
-0.3865543007850647,
-0.07754897326231003,
-0.23387396335601807,
0.9522935748100281,
-0.14249823987483978,
0.22619451582431793,
0.12473168224096298,
-0.1715666651725769,
-0.340431272983551,
0.3707163333892822,
0.6240688562393188,
0.6431989073753357,
-0.244013711810112,
-0.1364680826663971,
-0.02531152404844761,
-0.3437134623527527,
0.08240247517824173,
0.23054365813732147,
0.16387641429901123,
-0.006140738260000944,
0.03433708846569061,
1.0044575929641724,
0.020770175382494926,
-0.6635932326316833,
0.2580936849117279,
-0.3640812337398529,
-0.10854905098676682,
-0.38268303871154785,
-0.0023790383711457253,
0.14003540575504303,
0.34498339891433716,
0.5022510290145874,
-0.020286323502659798,
0.35469987988471985,
-0.648639440536499,
0.2463701069355011,
0.5478728413581848,
-0.33734020590782166,
-0.043622422963380814,
0.4214048385620117,
0.28537529706954956,
-0.007343614473938942,
0.2531035542488098,
-0.17447224259376526,
-0.40619346499443054,
0.36905887722969055,
0.5056023597717285,
1.1157550811767578,
0.06254300475120544,
0.5079554319381714,
0.18516921997070312,
0.20231668651103973,
-0.2964877784252167,
-0.06140449643135071,
-0.004201877396553755,
-0.7183488607406616,
-0.6527248620986938,
-1.082543969154358,
-0.15359492599964142,
0.2429169863462448,
-0.46112531423568726,
0.3216935694217682,
-0.4748270511627197,
-0.2134833037853241,
0.022993246093392372,
0.27962255477905273,
-0.6584520936012268,
0.41552498936653137,
0.3738127648830414,
0.752098560333252,
-0.5547680258750916,
0.7163541316986084,
0.9518540501594543,
-0.2330402284860611,
-0.9143232107162476,
0.2848174571990967,
-0.32147347927093506,
-0.6276129484176636,
0.3976249396800995,
0.10041883587837219,
0.11014578491449356,
-0.02880604937672615,
-0.23336149752140045,
-0.8916682004928589,
0.9200227856636047,
0.3586828410625458,
-0.6600246429443359,
0.063850536942482,
-0.04037195444107056,
0.6431170105934143,
-0.8100334405899048,
0.16971330344676971,
-0.11917820572853088,
0.7807039618492126,
0.1248730793595314,
-0.8904644250869751,
0.08878389000892639,
-0.3584728538990021,
0.10064908117055893,
0.07025047391653061,
-0.5067232251167297,
0.44983819127082825,
-0.29995113611221313,
0.1179213747382164,
0.05032600462436676,
0.7306560277938843,
0.14356616139411926,
0.2644638121128082,
0.5008089542388916,
0.4146231412887573,
0.5351807475090027,
0.23128670454025269,
1.2941080331802368,
-0.548048734664917,
0.3985235393047333,
1.2692559957504272,
-0.1767767071723938,
0.635563850402832,
0.0029646768234670162,
-0.17802229523658752,
0.7590969800949097,
0.8011050820350647,
-0.45727014541625977,
0.6074813008308411,
0.11124259233474731,
-0.0402211993932724,
-0.24033620953559875,
-0.36965033411979675,
-0.3438701927661896,
0.4073413610458374,
0.19874614477157593,
-0.5225980281829834,
-0.24956339597702026,
0.3030878007411957,
-0.2444992959499359,
-0.05658300966024399,
-0.6975470781326294,
0.9305112361907959,
0.045661114156246185,
-0.7989814281463623,
0.49762144684791565,
0.307461678981781,
0.867274820804596,
-0.5783968567848206,
-0.06255362182855606,
-0.07036234438419342,
-0.006861814297735691,
-0.34176257252693176,
-0.8372408151626587,
0.030335258692502975,
0.08704767376184464,
-0.4174319803714752,
0.0844649225473404,
0.8904771208763123,
-0.816658616065979,
-0.8522193431854248,
0.01316947489976883,
0.36961957812309265,
-0.07812405377626419,
-0.10749851912260056,
-0.4451543986797333,
-0.2925880253314972,
0.11253934353590012,
-0.2352367639541626,
0.30911964178085327,
0.1835617572069168,
-0.2127169370651245,
0.7826024889945984,
0.4728655219078064,
0.27868276834487915,
-0.2824190557003021,
0.2464287281036377,
0.6825972199440002,
-0.6344130635261536,
-0.8161241412162781,
-0.7265032529830933,
0.18710047006607056,
0.2146860510110855,
-0.07767930626869202,
0.6230650544166565,
0.6057745218276978,
0.7072067856788635,
-0.34044450521469116,
0.9111381769180298,
0.03155413642525673,
0.30963894724845886,
-0.6227424740791321,
0.6315858960151672,
-0.6633021235466003,
0.6603017449378967,
-0.18812762200832367,
-1.3161742687225342,
-0.33926695585250854,
0.26684334874153137,
-0.2669384479522705,
0.2957479953765869,
0.6841951608657837,
0.6306461095809937,
-0.05625469982624054,
-0.07790421694517136,
0.1768629550933838,
0.0999729260802269,
-0.04336598888039589,
0.5312886834144592,
0.6781435608863831,
0.22076056897640228,
0.5845195055007935,
-0.2976978123188019,
0.060468725860118866,
-0.35401809215545654,
-0.9244384765625,
-1.1501483917236328,
-0.7184911370277405,
-0.625785231590271,
-0.262781023979187,
0.223455548286438,
1.1333562135696411,
0.6312096118927002,
-0.7683273553848267,
-0.2244093120098114,
-0.05446615442633629,
0.18548685312271118,
-0.21386122703552246,
-0.26869016885757446,
0.6292399764060974,
-0.009735899046063423,
-0.48624446988105774,
0.2077978551387787,
0.3467470407485962,
-0.3329615890979767,
-0.4638582170009613,
-0.0037648577708750963,
-0.06520681828260422,
0.09347768872976303,
0.7158023118972778,
-0.18320007622241974,
-0.937273383140564,
-0.2649693489074707,
-0.2982293367385864,
0.08143638074398041,
-0.03162579983472824,
0.7900422811508179,
-0.9862321615219116,
0.39820748567581177,
0.2133762389421463,
0.44865813851356506,
0.18847781419754028,
0.10091312974691391,
0.5820233821868896,
-0.7476073503494263,
-0.10028145462274551,
0.020208124071359634,
0.3139810264110565,
0.4784325659275055,
-0.8108645677566528,
0.3989296853542328,
0.10512977093458176,
-0.3146520256996155,
-0.6146454811096191,
0.12457218766212463,
-1.262736201286316,
-0.03146149590611458,
1.476902723312378,
0.030329089611768723,
-0.10763373970985413,
0.06065894290804863,
-0.5848221778869629,
0.22807253897190094,
-0.7925836443901062,
0.9185978174209595,
0.644579291343689,
0.28021809458732605,
-0.30143195390701294,
-0.6232879757881165,
0.24936635792255402,
0.05935949459671974,
-0.6752859950065613,
-0.07598648220300674,
0.4796665906906128,
0.27834704518318176,
-0.09194564819335938,
0.29459789395332336,
0.0423339419066906,
0.11097616702318192,
-0.6398842334747314,
0.20540237426757812,
-0.3123641908168793,
-0.23231500387191772,
-0.15711228549480438,
0.20658937096595764,
0.010807468555867672,
0.19070278108119965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07551v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07551v1
|
MuMath-Code: Combining Tool-Use Large Language Models with Multi-perspective Data Augmentation for Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-05-13T08:32:19 | 2024-05-13T08:32:19 |
Shuo Yin, Weihao You, Zhilong Ji, Guoqiang Zhong, Jinfeng Bai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The tool-use Large Language Models (LLMs) that integrate with external Python
interpreters have significantly enhanced mathematical reasoning capabilities
for open-source LLMs, while tool-free methods chose another track: augmenting
math reasoning data. However, a great method to integrate the above two
research paths and combine their advantages remains to be explored. In this
work, we firstly include new math questions via multi-perspective data
augmenting methods and then synthesize code-nested solutions to them. The open
LLMs (i.e., Llama-2) are finetuned on the augmented dataset to get the
resulting models, MuMath-Code ($\mu$-Math-Code). During the inference phase,
our MuMath-Code generates code and interacts with the external python
interpreter to get the execution results. Therefore, MuMath-Code leverages the
advantages of both the external tool and data augmentation. To fully leverage
the advantages of our augmented data, we propose a two-stage training strategy:
In Stage-1, we finetune Llama-2 on pure CoT data to get an intermediate model,
which then is trained on the code-nested data in Stage-2 to get the resulting
MuMath-Code. Our MuMath-Code-7B achieves 83.8 on GSM8K and 52.4 on MATH, while
MuMath-Code-70B model achieves new state-of-the-art performance among open
methods -- achieving 90.7% on GSM8K and 55.1% on MATH. Extensive experiments
validate the combination of tool use and data augmentation, as well as our
two-stage training strategy. We release the proposed dataset along with the
associated code for public use.
|
[
-0.4639955759048462,
-0.5762501955032349,
0.5139477252960205,
0.163868248462677,
-0.42966538667678833,
0.125809445977211,
-0.2555861473083496,
-0.4901876747608185,
-0.09862830489873886,
0.4835176169872284,
-0.44062119722366333,
-0.4945928752422333,
-0.36237630248069763,
0.052580542862415314,
-0.11859110742807388,
0.9098330140113831,
-0.20574557781219482,
0.3273504078388214,
-0.32261922955513,
-0.17339272797107697,
-0.22436651587486267,
-0.8454592823982239,
-0.11379922181367874,
-0.4180942475795746,
0.3123282492160797,
0.5073060989379883,
0.5358713865280151,
0.36510249972343445,
0.491524875164032,
0.19361676275730133,
-0.013419034890830517,
0.46100538969039917,
-0.22117957472801208,
-0.050116509199142456,
0.07230788469314575,
-0.791078507900238,
-0.45800694823265076,
-0.033282388001680374,
0.33079567551612854,
0.705474853515625,
-0.17713205516338348,
0.2760472893714905,
-0.06330364942550659,
0.4289090037345886,
-0.5355600118637085,
0.40697818994522095,
-0.568355143070221,
0.07836636900901794,
0.04836493730545044,
-0.18523146212100983,
-0.353562593460083,
-0.6023036241531372,
-0.0934777483344078,
-0.5310396552085876,
-0.23068057000637054,
-0.13943937420845032,
0.2836701571941376,
0.19930234551429749,
-0.43140631914138794,
-0.2787337303161621,
-0.6007202863693237,
1.013500452041626,
-0.6934460997581482,
0.3167676031589508,
0.4367585778236389,
0.33499446511268616,
0.012374873273074627,
-0.42523425817489624,
-0.5191558599472046,
-0.22297775745391846,
0.04164249077439308,
-0.05290420725941658,
0.1259152889251709,
-0.27974581718444824,
0.44713273644447327,
0.6657780408859253,
-0.3249009847640991,
0.07409922778606415,
-0.4321841299533844,
-0.021302273496985435,
0.707136332988739,
0.15927790105342865,
0.08833570778369904,
-0.1492711305618286,
-0.4330907464027405,
-0.074913389980793,
-0.7917097210884094,
0.0032556154765188694,
0.4537040591239929,
0.21451795101165771,
-0.4336922764778137,
0.9637654423713684,
-0.15151017904281616,
0.5356521606445312,
-0.12669365108013153,
-0.47741201519966125,
0.37367677688598633,
-0.23047414422035217,
-0.2662392258644104,
0.038040891289711,
0.4801364839076996,
0.20591750741004944,
0.3249624967575073,
0.0003527597582433373,
-0.2562652826309204,
0.3451306223869324,
-0.04870932549238205,
-0.7371712327003479,
-0.1368129551410675,
0.28291255235671997,
-0.24381622672080994,
-0.4749647378921509,
-0.22107787430286407,
-0.6993514895439148,
-0.39687421917915344,
-0.7056058049201965,
0.4277593791484833,
-0.35388755798339844,
-0.45289790630340576,
0.24141159653663635,
0.08517689257860184,
0.19641311466693878,
0.5445408225059509,
-0.6015815138816833,
0.1954660415649414,
0.7898987531661987,
0.784783661365509,
0.046363428235054016,
-0.35993218421936035,
-0.606224775314331,
0.054031986743211746,
-0.43566203117370605,
0.6885062456130981,
-0.5405446887016296,
-0.3495279848575592,
-0.12317318469285965,
-0.48789143562316895,
0.03689195588231087,
-0.5520181655883789,
0.6165143847465515,
-0.4718368947505951,
0.5523276329040527,
0.15858350694179535,
-0.24651598930358887,
-0.35862722992897034,
0.2886151969432831,
-0.5699822306632996,
1.2613537311553955,
0.35904791951179504,
-0.6903471946716309,
0.09573971480131149,
-0.7217778563499451,
-0.37931108474731445,
-0.3225724697113037,
-0.22583115100860596,
-0.48471754789352417,
0.08335700631141663,
0.5639857649803162,
0.20828838646411896,
-0.5622559189796448,
0.09047622978687286,
-0.38903748989105225,
-0.24587304890155792,
0.26332998275756836,
-0.34758272767066956,
0.9778247475624084,
0.22004203498363495,
-0.2226390838623047,
0.04741687700152397,
-0.9125127792358398,
0.08181644976139069,
0.19007740914821625,
-0.4300338923931122,
-0.245716854929924,
-0.2661377787590027,
-0.17637887597084045,
0.354554146528244,
0.1360158771276474,
-0.5386629104614258,
0.45239800214767456,
-0.5407878160476685,
0.37007641792297363,
0.6704373955726624,
-0.18005448579788208,
0.5807408094406128,
-0.2586352825164795,
0.43098410964012146,
0.12614379823207855,
0.1742284744977951,
-0.35014843940734863,
-0.7257227897644043,
-0.43656250834465027,
-0.36293232440948486,
0.23443688452243805,
0.6075400710105896,
-0.7970930337905884,
0.20724432170391083,
-0.16217637062072754,
-0.31316372752189636,
-0.48950648307800293,
0.1615116000175476,
0.2324242740869522,
0.6174213886260986,
0.4686863124370575,
-0.17580236494541168,
-0.6264684796333313,
-0.7172505855560303,
0.08134309947490692,
0.0003553957212716341,
-0.1678656041622162,
0.17643100023269653,
0.3974904716014862,
-0.12073147296905518,
0.8204251527786255,
-0.6172614097595215,
-0.004516739398241043,
-0.2879301905632019,
0.06018433719873428,
0.37959352135658264,
0.6075186729431152,
0.47056058049201965,
-0.671238362789154,
-0.03865477442741394,
0.07481769472360611,
-0.8103769421577454,
-0.0963616594672203,
0.06911523640155792,
-0.25348711013793945,
0.08861293643712997,
-0.06802437454462051,
-0.5601350665092468,
0.607465922832489,
0.5795455574989319,
0.07943429052829742,
0.8360598087310791,
-0.011826724745333195,
0.22160479426383972,
-1.0600515604019165,
-0.20988252758979797,
-0.000944458122830838,
-0.008777331560850143,
-0.5577352046966553,
0.4831867516040802,
0.15213681757450104,
-0.390702486038208,
-0.3989846408367157,
0.3819647431373596,
-0.48349738121032715,
-0.24790434539318085,
-0.25166672468185425,
-0.11795279383659363,
0.06784800440073013,
0.77663654088974,
-0.09827066957950592,
1.1137053966522217,
0.6692329049110413,
-0.470745712518692,
0.40672147274017334,
0.26393458247184753,
-0.446341335773468,
0.37068262696266174,
-0.580202043056488,
0.28069987893104553,
0.11007208377122879,
0.2987386882305145,
-0.8762410879135132,
-0.26297417283058167,
0.2751447856426239,
-0.4453609883785248,
0.006465488579124212,
-0.3100927770137787,
-0.8676510453224182,
-0.4014461636543274,
-0.5866696834564209,
0.7660226821899414,
0.5681016445159912,
-0.8553776741027832,
0.8674984574317932,
0.29614725708961487,
-0.037273261696100235,
-0.5102828145027161,
-0.8196447491645813,
0.002980233868584037,
-0.3876608908176422,
-0.8284477591514587,
0.07228940725326538,
-0.07214932888746262,
-0.23510564863681793,
-0.2558574676513672,
-0.1794499009847641,
-0.14118272066116333,
-0.007903181947767735,
0.21863944828510284,
0.617012083530426,
-0.37545040249824524,
-0.2485736906528473,
0.3505450189113617,
-0.3419985771179199,
0.2207607477903366,
-0.4291163980960846,
0.7793484926223755,
-0.04458894208073616,
-0.6808937788009644,
-0.46253034472465515,
0.4279104769229889,
0.4940204322338104,
-0.5259794592857361,
0.63202965259552,
0.37225356698036194,
-0.46740442514419556,
-0.08743264526128769,
-0.5023078918457031,
0.005135042127221823,
-0.4448666572570801,
-0.07463975995779037,
-0.5855122804641724,
-0.7683907151222229,
0.4860343933105469,
-0.23228688538074493,
0.27894747257232666,
0.13184180855751038,
0.8819243907928467,
0.3217757046222687,
1.2978414297103882,
0.402361124753952,
0.047208208590745926,
0.29614171385765076,
-0.5274000763893127,
0.27638018131256104,
-1.2018803358078003,
-0.34692078828811646,
-0.40659627318382263,
0.004243942443281412,
-0.2213926762342453,
-0.7099940180778503,
0.5678459405899048,
0.29454588890075684,
-0.33351826667785645,
0.28298643231391907,
-0.4384825527667999,
0.39070141315460205,
0.5321303009986877,
0.32660216093063354,
0.44961869716644287,
0.3188498914241791,
-0.30978116393089294,
0.05669713392853737,
-0.524411678314209,
-0.35810351371765137,
1.5234127044677734,
0.21349626779556274,
0.9595675468444824,
0.12475153058767319,
0.6729785203933716,
-0.12176352739334106,
0.32584014534950256,
-0.8232576847076416,
0.45589664578437805,
0.2386513352394104,
-0.34077584743499756,
0.1370002031326294,
-0.5769298076629639,
-0.6653075814247131,
0.5280517339706421,
0.03139259293675423,
-0.8572232127189636,
0.029239073395729065,
-0.03950945660471916,
-0.2237735539674759,
0.3635951578617096,
-1.0063947439193726,
0.462798535823822,
-0.3873855471611023,
-0.5301216244697571,
-0.27357473969459534,
-0.5477032661437988,
0.7828885912895203,
-0.15134656429290771,
0.38389819860458374,
0.03264571726322174,
0.013544835150241852,
0.3695182800292969,
-0.4609159231185913,
0.6740012764930725,
0.02116962894797325,
-0.47253748774528503,
0.4213773012161255,
0.17566876113414764,
0.4234102964401245,
0.3130358159542084,
-0.2532733678817749,
0.24320566654205322,
-0.1845281422138214,
-0.4281991422176361,
-0.6921926140785217,
0.7169918417930603,
-0.7910416126251221,
-0.5651397705078125,
-0.34970173239707947,
-0.886960506439209,
-0.4041619300842285,
-0.019247112795710564,
-0.20681266486644745,
0.9219114184379578,
0.5943245887756348,
0.03170846775174141,
0.47534483671188354,
-0.1620090901851654,
0.1036708876490593,
0.011635797098279,
-0.4482414722442627,
-0.6743555068969727,
0.6631633043289185,
-0.25681257247924805,
0.34588029980659485,
0.3683764338493347,
0.3716222047805786,
-0.5305476188659668,
-0.36858025193214417,
-0.6705756187438965,
0.2668443024158478,
-0.7254368662834167,
-0.44511303305625916,
-0.45346319675445557,
-0.2584677040576935,
-0.4432244598865509,
-0.07290706038475037,
-0.13564297556877136,
-0.6181337237358093,
-0.12132946401834488,
0.024268660694360733,
0.5183385014533997,
0.4716346263885498,
-0.25594067573547363,
0.20587189495563507,
-0.7860810160636902,
0.5344362258911133,
0.18424415588378906,
0.3336015045642853,
0.189494326710701,
-0.2621750831604004,
-0.30856212973594666,
0.27955782413482666,
-0.27771273255348206,
-0.779187023639679,
0.13918757438659668,
-0.2123197317123413,
0.4708446264266968,
0.24050858616828918,
-0.09989672899246216,
0.7777664065361023,
-0.3611995279788971,
0.6594844460487366,
0.3237020671367645,
-0.8890907764434814,
0.5156099796295166,
-0.29705744981765747,
0.06334730237722397,
0.19990403950214386,
0.1177021935582161,
-0.0121664609760046,
-0.2779235541820526,
-0.4126755893230438,
-0.5162345170974731,
0.8187475204467773,
0.36747050285339355,
-0.029603824019432068,
0.3753616213798523,
0.2678084969520569,
0.31138327717781067,
0.4458044767379761,
-0.5792087912559509,
-0.14199408888816833,
-0.2501075267791748,
-0.33560216426849365,
0.19176658987998962,
0.04199272766709328,
-0.39105311036109924,
-0.632646381855011,
0.2618003785610199,
-0.20647455751895905,
0.32152801752090454,
-0.06675226986408234,
-0.20709839463233948,
-0.11230918020009995,
0.22895777225494385,
0.48362451791763306,
0.9559299945831299,
-0.058786485344171524,
0.12454773485660553,
0.1854894608259201,
-0.5554783344268799,
0.11838461458683014,
0.37580692768096924,
-0.06347569078207016,
-0.3400209844112396,
0.2924138009548187,
0.6408520340919495,
0.22447745501995087,
-0.7132132649421692,
0.2914299964904785,
0.1923484057188034,
-0.2920543849468231,
-0.20869551599025726,
0.09450311213731766,
0.04050329700112343,
0.32198941707611084,
0.48577895760536194,
0.17479993402957916,
-0.01430116593837738,
-0.4931173026561737,
0.09027985483407974,
0.31588563323020935,
0.3806338310241699,
-0.2245590090751648,
0.7646558880805969,
-0.061737678945064545,
-0.20144937932491302,
0.28653278946876526,
-0.167520210146904,
-0.7483999133110046,
0.5962578058242798,
0.6987131834030151,
0.45349666476249695,
-0.11314722895622253,
0.05862026661634445,
0.40870124101638794,
0.13795657455921173,
0.0703265443444252,
0.38850170373916626,
-0.30880242586135864,
-0.4857396185398102,
-0.8571589589118958,
-0.5989599227905273,
-0.5083491802215576,
0.07683038711547852,
-0.7518318891525269,
0.3702642619609833,
-0.4621972143650055,
0.242330864071846,
-0.2579157054424286,
0.19845786690711975,
-0.5682098269462585,
0.11871137470006943,
0.27662110328674316,
0.9808762073516846,
-0.5571797490119934,
0.7850359678268433,
0.7288544178009033,
-0.38155418634414673,
-1.0113869905471802,
-0.07725004851818085,
0.07864739745855331,
-1.1465855836868286,
0.3822404444217682,
0.296830415725708,
-0.27182042598724365,
0.059016693383455276,
-0.6042304039001465,
-0.8604622483253479,
1.0133589506149292,
0.32417282462120056,
-0.23277892172336578,
0.029881268739700317,
0.11525056511163712,
0.37488922476768494,
-0.5200459957122803,
0.39017996191978455,
0.5785534381866455,
0.2538778781890869,
0.3953695595264435,
-0.8898906111717224,
-0.1460263729095459,
-0.24042779207229614,
-0.10224292427301407,
0.4114744961261749,
-0.36834287643432617,
1.08762526512146,
-0.4422514736652374,
-0.012450948357582092,
0.21106699109077454,
0.5440340638160706,
0.7595072984695435,
0.5284132957458496,
0.4168024957180023,
0.9523507952690125,
0.5427129864692688,
0.07092224061489105,
1.0950262546539307,
-0.2175041139125824,
0.5309054851531982,
0.9048517942428589,
-0.37354445457458496,
0.7611956000328064,
0.3080807626247406,
-0.4467233121395111,
0.7518503665924072,
0.46840590238571167,
0.17133495211601257,
0.4343222379684448,
0.04694776609539986,
-0.2813141644001007,
-0.2529262900352478,
0.1445767730474472,
-0.6911839246749878,
0.3417108952999115,
0.40794020891189575,
0.14421449601650238,
-0.5715139508247375,
0.22174067795276642,
0.034593865275382996,
-0.12493610382080078,
-0.30993783473968506,
0.5861294865608215,
0.13139291107654572,
-0.38383397459983826,
0.6815724968910217,
0.08956808596849442,
0.5724881291389465,
-0.47004130482673645,
-0.13570301234722137,
-0.2251444011926651,
0.19669125974178314,
-0.33394280076026917,
-0.8697057366371155,
0.13962091505527496,
0.21522599458694458,
0.07991958409547806,
0.06938254833221436,
0.5016211867332458,
-0.366885781288147,
-0.7208205461502075,
-0.011838089674711227,
0.7225214242935181,
0.10425231605768204,
-0.13863256573677063,
-0.707796573638916,
0.03650600090622902,
-0.1198459342122078,
0.04846203699707985,
0.4446440637111664,
0.47823405265808105,
-0.07200073450803757,
0.6278207302093506,
1.127250075340271,
0.08066430687904358,
0.27247554063796997,
0.3673599660396576,
1.4061182737350464,
-0.4419698119163513,
-0.5812845826148987,
-0.666900634765625,
0.5706000328063965,
0.026927947998046875,
-0.23262470960617065,
0.8257346153259277,
0.820372462272644,
0.8234022259712219,
0.03660843148827553,
0.6799395084381104,
0.05635368078947067,
0.7000436782836914,
-0.6780261397361755,
0.14661771059036255,
-0.7435491681098938,
0.44472411274909973,
-0.1836385875940323,
-0.9454707503318787,
-0.3511594235897064,
0.7040643692016602,
-0.5853356122970581,
-0.05266118422150612,
0.7554354071617126,
0.6988013386726379,
-0.4150731563568115,
0.2156113237142563,
-0.1107763722538948,
-0.21897634863853455,
0.28384929895401,
0.9181838035583496,
1.1184415817260742,
-0.48823851346969604,
0.6047313809394836,
-0.5790817737579346,
-0.47386419773101807,
-0.2644667327404022,
-0.5827343463897705,
-0.9602221846580505,
-0.3177732229232788,
-0.058252982795238495,
-0.4887505769729614,
-0.44919824600219727,
1.0685492753982544,
0.5340339541435242,
-0.6926847100257874,
-0.24996806681156158,
-0.03778162598609924,
0.3037365674972534,
-0.15328684449195862,
-0.22434331476688385,
0.3457528352737427,
-0.23027119040489197,
-0.8342593312263489,
0.26007089018821716,
0.2400674819946289,
-0.06825684010982513,
-0.430164098739624,
-0.06615325063467026,
-0.06037912145256996,
-0.09025334566831589,
0.9274258613586426,
0.01140756718814373,
-0.6270685791969299,
0.028169307857751846,
0.010265598073601723,
0.03161512315273285,
0.4336231052875519,
1.2295629978179932,
-0.851881206035614,
0.2445647120475769,
0.2890178859233856,
0.7450093030929565,
0.4670109748840332,
0.32715508341789246,
0.407534658908844,
-0.4980240762233734,
0.5572968125343323,
0.25998443365097046,
0.36870139837265015,
0.3105674684047699,
-0.3523990213871002,
0.58603835105896,
0.2143586277961731,
-0.3711506128311157,
-1.1617381572723389,
0.3663026988506317,
-1.0409332513809204,
-0.21608220040798187,
1.226825475692749,
0.09599040448665619,
-0.2505759000778198,
0.023843536153435707,
-0.4016435444355011,
0.13420990109443665,
-0.33329299092292786,
0.7138931155204773,
0.585141658782959,
-0.3585013449192047,
-0.2957383692264557,
-0.5119532942771912,
0.09333308786153793,
0.29315921664237976,
-1.120335578918457,
-0.2369294911623001,
0.606274425983429,
0.15894247591495514,
0.26247963309288025,
0.3606729209423065,
-0.3193832039833069,
0.37120893597602844,
0.2224569469690323,
-0.16868463158607483,
-0.47849467396736145,
-0.4184510409832001,
-0.31903010606765747,
0.2531921863555908,
-0.07990505546331406,
-0.2421632558107376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07542v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07542v1
|
EMS-SD: Efficient Multi-sample Speculative Decoding for Accelerating Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T08:24:21 | 2024-05-13T08:24:21 |
Yunsheng Ni, Chuanjian Liu, Yehui Tang, Kai Han, Yunhe Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Speculative decoding emerges as a pivotal technique for enhancing the
inference speed of Large Language Models (LLMs). Despite recent research aiming
to improve prediction efficiency, multi-sample speculative decoding has been
overlooked due to varying numbers of accepted tokens within a batch in the
verification phase. Vanilla method adds padding tokens in order to ensure that
the number of new tokens remains consistent across samples. However, this
increases the computational and memory access overhead, thereby reducing the
speedup ratio. We propose a novel method that can resolve the issue of
inconsistent tokens accepted by different samples without necessitating an
increase in memory or computing overhead. Furthermore, our proposed method can
handle the situation where the prediction tokens of different samples are
inconsistent without the need to add padding tokens. Sufficient experiments
demonstrate the efficacy of our method. Our code is available at
https://github.com/niyunsheng/EMS-SD.
|
[
-0.3163466155529022,
-0.7614060640335083,
0.6609266996383667,
0.6245019435882568,
-0.4957069158554077,
0.3410181701183319,
-0.3929787278175354,
-0.4669863283634186,
0.7009871602058411,
0.3123125731945038,
-0.6377405524253845,
-0.5645787119865417,
-0.6932415962219238,
0.22302983701229095,
-0.4130348265171051,
0.38930946588516235,
-0.03847035393118858,
0.08581434190273285,
-0.11564871668815613,
0.0702829509973526,
0.2544689178466797,
-0.6174283623695374,
-0.6227725744247437,
0.5166785717010498,
0.26148322224617004,
0.5027468800544739,
0.030765889212489128,
0.7589472532272339,
0.261844664812088,
0.2795180082321167,
-0.19227540493011475,
0.654854416847229,
-0.4262002110481262,
0.4585239887237549,
0.20578138530254364,
-0.39636826515197754,
-0.7909002900123596,
-0.5576826930046082,
0.8247634172439575,
0.5170738101005554,
-0.34577125310897827,
0.03793218731880188,
-0.2269856333732605,
0.2890720069408417,
-0.9753613471984863,
0.001592092914506793,
-0.859651505947113,
-0.2688564658164978,
-0.43130311369895935,
-0.49416887760162354,
-0.7578000426292419,
0.015659593045711517,
-0.3491984009742737,
-0.6410099864006042,
0.5317548513412476,
0.3688855767250061,
0.3712571859359741,
-0.06537611782550812,
-0.4071890115737915,
-0.12585261464118958,
-0.5390394330024719,
0.9928257465362549,
-0.7783190608024597,
0.583625853061676,
0.4415096938610077,
0.04147200286388397,
-0.17460350692272186,
-0.6994615793228149,
-0.7023061513900757,
0.19377276301383972,
0.41150182485580444,
0.007968423888087273,
0.14752449095249176,
0.20674355328083038,
0.2712040841579437,
0.1595008671283722,
-0.20981760323047638,
0.3361321687698364,
-0.2819625437259674,
-0.5612043142318726,
0.4380020797252655,
0.4483228027820587,
-0.03512677922844887,
0.200297549366951,
-0.44389623403549194,
-0.07211822271347046,
-0.7259455919265747,
-0.1049225926399231,
0.5380073189735413,
0.48124462366104126,
-0.32986319065093994,
0.4643290340900421,
-0.3682999312877655,
0.29320037364959717,
0.0599636510014534,
-0.23735103011131287,
0.6031662821769714,
-0.311805784702301,
0.08290410041809082,
0.08291047066450119,
0.5501973032951355,
0.33939167857170105,
-0.3471527099609375,
-0.18652667105197906,
-0.3909092843532562,
0.23890653252601624,
-0.013155898079276085,
-1.1118720769882202,
0.09533289074897766,
0.622929573059082,
-0.5025051832199097,
-0.23541578650474548,
-0.005105688702315092,
-1.0892163515090942,
-0.2895556390285492,
-0.07790867239236832,
-0.24306894838809967,
-0.48842355608940125,
-0.5399478673934937,
0.5873685479164124,
-0.28410276770591736,
0.010445540770888329,
0.288734495639801,
-1.2743502855300903,
0.4937020540237427,
0.7508668303489685,
0.6186521053314209,
-0.20023807883262634,
-0.4523389935493469,
-0.6677414774894714,
0.15089277923107147,
-0.45267990231513977,
1.023980736732483,
-0.7403973937034607,
-0.47413283586502075,
-0.043715376406908035,
-0.008517350070178509,
0.04380897432565689,
-0.1047225371003151,
1.0679463148117065,
-0.5432428121566772,
-0.4700658619403839,
-0.6060261130332947,
-0.8798688650131226,
0.3104727566242218,
-0.059345170855522156,
-0.540657639503479,
0.9779295325279236,
-0.26160117983818054,
-0.6848195791244507,
0.47629663348197937,
-0.3076753616333008,
-0.30279815196990967,
0.053143903613090515,
-0.2131153643131256,
-0.3134321868419647,
0.4917764961719513,
0.5920440554618835,
0.6154781579971313,
-0.254778653383255,
0.021169105544686317,
-0.7497082352638245,
-0.6764072775840759,
0.1866028755903244,
-0.5458624958992004,
0.4385148584842682,
0.4947669506072998,
-0.04562852159142494,
-0.13001403212547302,
-1.0791159868240356,
0.19670818746089935,
0.10977675765752792,
-0.11117976158857346,
-0.33848491311073303,
0.18352612853050232,
0.27776482701301575,
-0.048524364829063416,
0.0012046982301399112,
-0.7732394933700562,
0.2921171188354492,
-0.1549772173166275,
0.25322774052619934,
0.9215509295463562,
-0.01621367037296295,
0.3067725598812103,
-0.10237203538417816,
0.4617431163787842,
0.2067231684923172,
-0.2259974479675293,
-0.7105379700660706,
-0.42292800545692444,
-0.5506081581115723,
-0.8710199594497681,
0.4223083555698395,
0.09024633467197418,
-0.8324221968650818,
0.473550409078598,
-0.29180124402046204,
-0.3868369460105896,
-0.717556893825531,
-0.13724198937416077,
0.22343778610229492,
0.17844344675540924,
0.32279646396636963,
-0.05316085368394852,
-0.8870904445648193,
-0.6575327515602112,
-0.25133323669433594,
0.009065726771950722,
0.07144487649202347,
0.1223430261015892,
0.3680649995803833,
-0.29725539684295654,
0.4929630756378174,
-0.5254327058792114,
0.3471319377422333,
-0.20757195353507996,
0.12028003484010696,
0.17876948416233063,
0.6642301082611084,
0.7041616439819336,
-0.39800357818603516,
-0.2856716513633728,
-0.24356596171855927,
-0.2392740696668625,
-0.04799625650048256,
-0.12931297719478607,
-0.14230650663375854,
0.23089146614074707,
0.6902322173118591,
-0.6146888732910156,
-0.0416753888130188,
0.7851733565330505,
-0.41648656129837036,
0.8185875415802002,
-0.37578341364860535,
0.489658385515213,
-1.0554492473602295,
-0.18206116557121277,
-0.028889862820506096,
-0.10065943747758865,
-0.647889256477356,
0.18640069663524628,
0.6179857850074768,
0.27245908975601196,
-0.384868323802948,
0.47200432419776917,
-0.4420919418334961,
0.141869455575943,
-0.225343257188797,
-0.039531268179416656,
-0.0003026377235073596,
0.18812668323516846,
0.08787349611520767,
0.8633578419685364,
0.8941253423690796,
-0.6088702082633972,
0.024894339963793755,
-0.22226552665233612,
-0.3271484375,
0.3864656984806061,
-0.34258535504341125,
0.4278744161128998,
-0.2559935748577118,
0.46184635162353516,
-0.9381064176559448,
-0.23471035063266754,
-0.12174805253744125,
-0.3113763630390167,
0.4651948809623718,
-0.18120290338993073,
-0.7549089789390564,
-0.3045156002044678,
-0.5166890025138855,
0.7183133959770203,
0.5604281425476074,
-0.737704873085022,
0.6709650754928589,
0.33549392223358154,
-0.021070322021842003,
-0.9053415060043335,
-0.696290135383606,
0.040585219860076904,
-0.14783832430839539,
-0.4958244264125824,
0.42008593678474426,
-0.14027224481105804,
-0.07821325957775116,
-0.05748351290822029,
-0.319944828748703,
-0.01698693074285984,
-0.03832359239459038,
-0.1732209175825119,
0.30698201060295105,
-0.3206928074359894,
0.01858147792518139,
0.5084143877029419,
-0.2894086241722107,
0.050322528928518295,
-0.5644229650497437,
0.542818009853363,
-0.0777050033211708,
-0.5914489030838013,
-0.33017683029174805,
0.4273003339767456,
0.802747905254364,
-0.06251668930053711,
1.0295698642730713,
0.6018706560134888,
-0.5213064551353455,
-0.4485267996788025,
-0.8230805397033691,
-0.1915406435728073,
-0.5342352986335754,
0.6067342162132263,
-0.7155112624168396,
-0.7490220069885254,
0.827199399471283,
-0.28299301862716675,
0.02916223742067814,
0.32076016068458557,
0.6520337462425232,
-0.01421242393553257,
0.9542447924613953,
0.5254657864570618,
0.012437600642442703,
0.1029769703745842,
-0.021206440404057503,
0.13960333168506622,
-0.8110827803611755,
-0.22281402349472046,
-0.7417998313903809,
-0.056077223271131516,
-0.3517194390296936,
-0.6628413796424866,
-0.19509589672088623,
0.029421545565128326,
0.1584719717502594,
0.02020549774169922,
-0.07097705453634262,
0.6271596550941467,
0.10571645200252533,
0.056578975170850754,
0.27433279156684875,
0.152222141623497,
-0.5100024938583374,
-0.24564436078071594,
-0.5236088037490845,
-0.11508297920227051,
1.3125284910202026,
0.3638945519924164,
0.8155437707901001,
0.07494111359119415,
0.7473549246788025,
0.07038424164056778,
0.030362552031874657,
-0.4360012412071228,
0.5274808406829834,
-0.2018365114927292,
-0.41915908455848694,
0.04679454490542412,
-0.5621312856674194,
-0.7345665693283081,
0.5225488543510437,
-0.37756475806236267,
-0.7761785387992859,
0.31920239329338074,
0.1705324798822403,
-0.2513837218284607,
0.6658596992492676,
-0.9018733501434326,
0.3022480010986328,
0.07564136385917664,
-0.32172393798828125,
-0.44499021768569946,
-0.3135492205619812,
0.455885112285614,
-0.17822597920894623,
0.35484495759010315,
-0.10607410222291946,
-0.37353143095970154,
0.7117898464202881,
-0.3285955786705017,
0.6627882719039917,
-0.32468658685684204,
-0.20551683008670807,
0.026033049449324608,
-0.10953333973884583,
0.8947815895080566,
0.02585902065038681,
-0.42211413383483887,
0.11989780515432358,
0.17798571288585663,
-0.8323861360549927,
-0.37183505296707153,
0.7378628253936768,
-0.5086320042610168,
-0.29186686873435974,
-0.19970539212226868,
-0.5931470394134521,
-0.4553041458129883,
0.11399704962968826,
0.32879072427749634,
0.5802610516548157,
-0.05227799713611603,
0.22454138100147247,
0.794033944606781,
-0.18672972917556763,
0.31896668672561646,
0.5233762264251709,
-0.1644536256790161,
-0.22571265697479248,
0.8690848350524902,
-0.06520906835794449,
0.3420792818069458,
0.3464203476905823,
-0.18129323422908783,
-0.44662395119667053,
-1.0382928848266602,
-0.5290257930755615,
0.2898997664451599,
-0.6753612756729126,
-0.10467188060283661,
-0.9577922821044922,
0.14442457258701324,
-0.5330895185470581,
-0.18432290852069855,
-0.6548231840133667,
-0.447799414396286,
-0.0026457959320396185,
-0.3688451647758484,
0.41358432173728943,
0.31520503759384155,
0.02159585990011692,
0.23576319217681885,
-0.9774361848831177,
0.32788071036338806,
-0.33103713393211365,
0.5769124627113342,
0.04843325912952423,
-0.4153774678707123,
-0.248048797249794,
-0.04892941191792488,
0.29235127568244934,
-0.7394058704376221,
0.2943391799926758,
-0.10979234427213669,
0.650528073310852,
0.6413078308105469,
0.25543102622032166,
0.8855518698692322,
-0.5067166686058044,
0.6363542675971985,
0.12288230657577515,
-0.976997971534729,
-0.03711899742484093,
-0.3189087510108948,
0.03740547597408295,
0.5011541843414307,
0.06328921765089035,
-0.5269737243652344,
-0.5020043849945068,
-0.7420452237129211,
-1.1073479652404785,
0.822907567024231,
-0.012256667949259281,
0.27366894483566284,
-0.22151371836662292,
0.19774122536182404,
0.36282461881637573,
0.12058066576719284,
-0.04045573249459267,
-0.6005260944366455,
0.21287380158901215,
-0.13905474543571472,
0.020672429352998734,
-0.7322354316711426,
0.09893367439508438,
-0.1369638442993164,
0.669941782951355,
-0.16647882759571075,
0.32923272252082825,
-0.09923671931028366,
0.06232970580458641,
-0.17416371405124664,
0.41652488708496094,
0.632331132888794,
0.4254775643348694,
-0.2876738905906677,
0.38566842675209045,
0.5636573433876038,
-0.7988473773002625,
0.20061804354190826,
0.06932035833597183,
0.20535220205783844,
0.09380148351192474,
0.20555585622787476,
0.6943356394767761,
0.2672388255596161,
-0.7528790235519409,
0.3580551743507385,
-0.4089754819869995,
-0.36159154772758484,
0.0015331038739532232,
-0.21080081164836884,
0.1758112609386444,
0.05729861930012703,
0.5372424125671387,
0.5226152539253235,
0.10221566259860992,
-0.13238635659217834,
0.17438434064388275,
0.13539361953735352,
0.2043507993221283,
-0.34060946106910706,
0.5240177512168884,
0.2758842408657074,
0.09638895839452744,
0.48961541056632996,
-0.6096135377883911,
-0.21704277396202087,
0.6937224268913269,
0.8515370488166809,
0.7901918888092041,
-0.16297094523906708,
-0.15100619196891785,
0.318855345249176,
0.2513028085231781,
-0.431766539812088,
0.5819886326789856,
0.013116272166371346,
-0.8232927918434143,
-0.715081512928009,
-0.6238847970962524,
-0.35859858989715576,
0.023227719590067863,
-0.6725136637687683,
0.3253430426120758,
-0.2386457473039627,
0.061666667461395264,
-0.29475587606430054,
-0.198308527469635,
-0.6189602017402649,
-0.08316223323345184,
0.13589811325073242,
1.3159531354904175,
-0.7454752326011658,
1.0807993412017822,
0.307027131319046,
0.3109552264213562,
-0.6493430137634277,
0.1373160183429718,
0.20768654346466064,
-0.7186188101768494,
0.1705571711063385,
0.050363216549158096,
-0.29879695177078247,
-0.04284828156232834,
-0.2478228509426117,
-1.061610221862793,
0.8589918613433838,
0.5085940361022949,
-0.7189455032348633,
0.26773393154144287,
-0.2740410566329956,
0.36841946840286255,
-0.35612455010414124,
0.3758223056793213,
0.5564859509468079,
0.3205747902393341,
0.08844304084777832,
-0.47722217440605164,
0.27963006496429443,
-0.38202404975891113,
-0.05515974760055542,
0.21596649289131165,
-0.43794214725494385,
0.8630828261375427,
-0.4112948477268219,
-0.3367336094379425,
0.3758988380432129,
0.8651641607284546,
0.6998301148414612,
0.23807913064956665,
0.49362316727638245,
0.5777278542518616,
1.2096729278564453,
-0.1564837545156479,
1.173579216003418,
-0.6177995800971985,
0.3904494643211365,
0.7935269474983215,
-0.4128059446811676,
0.9121805429458618,
0.5352592468261719,
-0.3269442915916443,
0.1819261759519577,
0.5534993410110474,
0.28177356719970703,
0.5754092931747437,
0.010671672411262989,
-0.4915308356285095,
-0.21578286588191986,
0.16176152229309082,
-0.6853257417678833,
0.13993583619594574,
0.8353573679924011,
-0.07063029706478119,
-0.05535529553890228,
-0.21301142871379852,
-0.11564884334802628,
-0.13531745970249176,
-0.19933530688285828,
0.22268842160701752,
-0.03283968195319176,
-0.33883556723594666,
0.5420440435409546,
0.43928197026252747,
1.1068298816680908,
-0.7643595933914185,
0.20860670506954193,
-0.005233490373939276,
0.23138327896595,
-0.07040286064147949,
-0.3576832413673401,
0.11972828954458237,
-0.033387452363967896,
-0.07656250149011612,
-0.2914762794971466,
0.5702932476997375,
-0.3991433084011078,
-0.5548549294471741,
0.23626448214054108,
0.5820419788360596,
0.08269155025482178,
0.19552969932556152,
-0.37926700711250305,
0.4915648400783539,
-0.19245576858520508,
-0.16045434772968292,
0.3698540925979614,
0.8150405287742615,
0.23118087649345398,
0.37833505868911743,
0.9105111956596375,
0.38138672709465027,
0.12041067332029343,
0.2248789221048355,
0.916390061378479,
-0.6408231258392334,
-0.803839385509491,
-1.0054744482040405,
0.4446374773979187,
-0.10818473249673843,
-0.2679242491722107,
0.8384687900543213,
0.567345380783081,
0.6266722679138184,
-0.1563882827758789,
0.7999802231788635,
0.11754816025495529,
0.43603503704071045,
-0.909672200679779,
0.3680563271045685,
-0.23353128135204315,
0.675293505191803,
-0.31009069085121155,
-0.6926272511482239,
-0.1973806619644165,
0.08966130018234253,
0.06009773164987564,
0.0032643997110426426,
0.9807245135307312,
0.926544725894928,
-0.15191006660461426,
0.3241749703884125,
0.30906617641448975,
0.3084176480770111,
0.312175989151001,
0.29605796933174133,
0.7908095717430115,
-0.17901447415351868,
0.285611093044281,
-0.23919469118118286,
-0.18825994431972504,
-0.1670498251914978,
-0.9142953157424927,
-0.6856392025947571,
-0.5219377875328064,
-0.0598481185734272,
-0.5368390679359436,
0.1030573844909668,
1.3135077953338623,
0.812171995639801,
-0.8747351765632629,
0.03361949697136879,
-0.009639928117394447,
-0.07157689332962036,
-0.49397197365760803,
-0.1540600210428238,
0.4687858521938324,
-0.617374062538147,
-0.9884841442108154,
0.525006115436554,
0.2886801064014435,
-0.01361170131713152,
-0.04097317159175873,
-0.19899888336658478,
0.1729332059621811,
0.27776914834976196,
0.4598945081233978,
0.08105383068323135,
-0.6743826866149902,
0.06002743914723396,
0.17367534339427948,
-0.09024518728256226,
-0.09945487976074219,
1.1832900047302246,
-0.5589572191238403,
0.40060240030288696,
0.38526463508605957,
1.0119249820709229,
0.650690495967865,
-0.2218984216451645,
0.43158626556396484,
-0.946993350982666,
0.5752363801002502,
0.10400382429361343,
0.7660552263259888,
0.020665284246206284,
-0.5001278519630432,
0.012369954027235508,
0.4064399003982544,
-0.14783447980880737,
-1.0570075511932373,
0.061556510627269745,
-1.087106466293335,
-0.35367149114608765,
1.2388551235198975,
-0.1453401893377304,
-0.19195306301116943,
-0.22540922462940216,
-0.19389483332633972,
-0.24061137437820435,
-0.9102737903594971,
0.7126068472862244,
0.7372141480445862,
0.13372838497161865,
-0.09068890661001205,
-0.40563949942588806,
0.3833203911781311,
0.4550555646419525,
-0.6963644623756409,
0.23121194541454315,
0.313448965549469,
0.0694238543510437,
-0.13154897093772888,
0.950598955154419,
-0.176924467086792,
0.19358961284160614,
0.6794846653938293,
-0.140131413936615,
-0.07161343097686768,
-0.24156807363033295,
-0.2508575916290283,
0.1610404998064041,
0.10012343525886536,
-0.04728442430496216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07513v1
|
Fine-tuning the SwissBERT Encoder Model for Embedding Sentences and Documents
| 2024-05-13T07:20:21 | 2024-05-13T07:20:21 |
Juri Grosjean, Jannis Vamvas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Encoder models trained for the embedding of sentences or short documents have
proven useful for tasks such as semantic search and topic modeling. In this
paper, we present a version of the SwissBERT encoder model that we specifically
fine-tuned for this purpose. SwissBERT contains language adapters for the four
national languages of Switzerland -- German, French, Italian, and Romansh --
and has been pre-trained on a large number of news articles in those languages.
Using contrastive learning based on a subset of these articles, we trained a
fine-tuned version, which we call SentenceSwissBERT. Multilingual experiments
on document retrieval and text classification in a Switzerland-specific setting
show that SentenceSwissBERT surpasses the accuracy of the original SwissBERT
model and of a comparable baseline. The model is openly available for research
use.
|
[
-0.48974332213401794,
-0.6535980701446533,
0.5126162171363831,
0.08998271822929382,
-0.3360624611377716,
-0.10891515016555786,
-0.29512226581573486,
-0.31296199560165405,
0.20341378450393677,
0.6202123165130615,
-0.39609161019325256,
-0.6045632362365723,
-0.7709336280822754,
0.2997540235519409,
-0.451406329870224,
1.0232186317443848,
-0.2544827163219452,
0.22351297736167908,
-0.19106581807136536,
-0.36829695105552673,
0.09675829112529755,
-0.4623943567276001,
-0.17216989398002625,
-0.4952920973300934,
0.46142444014549255,
0.40383973717689514,
0.7564854025840759,
0.279420405626297,
0.41364067792892456,
0.24372458457946777,
-0.17963257431983948,
0.32459577918052673,
-0.5300175547599792,
-0.12100065499544144,
-0.3296854794025421,
-0.3434162437915802,
0.16261450946331024,
-0.25860434770584106,
0.5806989073753357,
0.588486909866333,
-0.12439887225627899,
-0.17482268810272217,
0.08184345066547394,
0.7444254159927368,
-0.4899919629096985,
-0.019376438111066818,
-0.4580848217010498,
-0.08761048316955566,
0.09461809694766998,
-0.13814252614974976,
-0.41997671127319336,
-0.6142773628234863,
0.13417474925518036,
-0.32777801156044006,
0.5721198916435242,
-0.10343625396490097,
1.092524766921997,
0.011072579771280289,
-0.5371987223625183,
-0.4936147928237915,
-0.36881062388420105,
0.6799207329750061,
-0.5061495900154114,
0.7508804202079773,
0.3781622052192688,
-0.03143713250756264,
0.07446268945932388,
-0.6865873336791992,
-0.18362443149089813,
-0.2272275984287262,
-0.2997286319732666,
0.054598692804574966,
-0.35417094826698303,
-0.1211409792304039,
0.08200738579034805,
0.06155719608068466,
-0.6910099983215332,
0.14907175302505493,
-0.7080281376838684,
-0.07463758438825607,
0.49374210834503174,
-0.031121108680963516,
0.21892450749874115,
-0.028056222945451736,
0.032355863600969315,
-0.013989878818392754,
-0.6022244691848755,
-0.04976121708750725,
0.7361457943916321,
0.28544366359710693,
0.060252826660871506,
0.6186419129371643,
-0.5259346961975098,
1.0297490358352661,
0.25381797552108765,
0.30857470631599426,
0.32521852850914,
-0.16208398342132568,
0.11870726943016052,
0.28585201501846313,
0.4763958752155304,
0.33625680208206177,
0.3261394500732422,
-0.27960026264190674,
-0.33123862743377686,
-0.04320983588695526,
0.29569223523139954,
-1.2919697761535645,
-0.44520044326782227,
-0.00040989063563756645,
-0.41932764649391174,
-0.07982421666383743,
0.3166130781173706,
-0.2175988256931305,
-0.07178826630115509,
-0.34772321581840515,
0.3131331503391266,
-0.6932079792022705,
0.17861932516098022,
0.6128121614456177,
-0.23953042924404144,
0.10217475146055222,
0.2763400375843048,
-1.0024646520614624,
0.3486560881137848,
0.4837930202484131,
0.8976397514343262,
-0.011265276931226254,
-0.4546598196029663,
-0.7881443500518799,
-0.01082603633403778,
-0.39715397357940674,
0.9539725184440613,
-0.7606266140937805,
-0.3912823498249054,
0.46066948771476746,
0.3068341612815857,
-0.022137345746159554,
-0.45325180888175964,
0.781073272228241,
-0.7425655126571655,
0.2660199999809265,
-0.04284505918622017,
-0.7781354784965515,
-0.23251816630363464,
0.3074701428413391,
-0.7752101421356201,
0.6095816493034363,
0.24331237375736237,
-1.080946922302246,
0.053668323904275894,
-0.5695714950561523,
-0.8044091463088989,
-0.22866326570510864,
0.04409491643309593,
-0.43629685044288635,
0.3163953721523285,
0.42031893134117126,
0.7034301161766052,
-0.08539871871471405,
0.08166181296110153,
-0.23364512622356415,
-0.6365117430686951,
0.23782269656658173,
0.057176440954208374,
0.8067351579666138,
0.15756778419017792,
0.31830281019210815,
-0.02316657453775406,
-0.5486656427383423,
-0.13544893264770508,
-0.20256733894348145,
-0.4175478219985962,
-0.5216179490089417,
0.007827854715287685,
0.3633769154548645,
0.04557556286454201,
0.33977335691452026,
-0.8046815991401672,
-0.14333778619766235,
-0.4079001247882843,
0.8319705128669739,
0.20615670084953308,
0.11238666623830795,
0.5660595893859863,
-0.3027801811695099,
0.26702168583869934,
0.17768128216266632,
-0.021043820306658745,
-0.32761260867118835,
-0.003759242594242096,
-0.6917418837547302,
-0.11649000644683838,
0.6519922018051147,
0.4969155192375183,
-0.6396831274032593,
0.6700613498687744,
-0.1910407841205597,
-0.6366807818412781,
-0.68035888671875,
0.166870579123497,
-0.030358612537384033,
0.15485110878944397,
0.32115837931632996,
-0.14631889760494232,
-0.15609405934810638,
-1.198941707611084,
-0.28017541766166687,
0.19279484450817108,
0.04494328051805496,
0.045463304966688156,
0.612571656703949,
-0.40297409892082214,
0.7770568132400513,
-0.701060950756073,
-0.1497868150472641,
-0.2876536250114441,
0.6876387000083923,
0.15370802581310272,
0.5620020627975464,
0.7102905511856079,
-1.0177494287490845,
-0.543978750705719,
0.04193831607699394,
-0.530385434627533,
0.13711830973625183,
-0.00559269031509757,
-0.06381773948669434,
0.10096247494220734,
0.6441155076026917,
-0.3579774796962738,
0.16538994014263153,
0.5739294290542603,
-0.13939906656742096,
0.2961852252483368,
-0.6453540325164795,
0.21032185852527618,
-1.160568356513977,
-0.3006523549556732,
0.3082692325115204,
-0.26833319664001465,
-0.5018075108528137,
0.12311320751905441,
0.6534108519554138,
-0.42706963419914246,
-0.4929575026035309,
0.3459882140159607,
-0.4028189480304718,
0.18871550261974335,
-0.18362745642662048,
0.3455986976623535,
0.23741742968559265,
0.13835406303405762,
0.22818787395954132,
0.7999442219734192,
0.5333335995674133,
-0.48106345534324646,
0.17726662755012512,
0.41238585114479065,
-0.6710219979286194,
0.6324975490570068,
-0.9273317456245422,
0.08487247675657272,
-0.42896363139152527,
0.007987555116415024,
-0.5128149390220642,
-0.16518743336200714,
-0.2724587917327881,
-0.22557291388511658,
0.349061518907547,
-0.09033268690109253,
-0.8291583061218262,
-0.1101900041103363,
-0.3084239065647125,
-0.017874129116535187,
0.40149301290512085,
-0.7689710259437561,
0.593573808670044,
0.10303942859172821,
-0.3504418134689331,
-0.21832342445850372,
-0.7813234329223633,
-0.13674037158489227,
-0.09507820010185242,
-0.7004973888397217,
0.6104422807693481,
-0.1879173219203949,
0.002315863501280546,
0.23469717800617218,
0.101984903216362,
-0.48984813690185547,
0.013820210471749306,
-0.0030074971728026867,
0.028441589325666428,
-0.08123078942298889,
0.31463098526000977,
0.41136154532432556,
-0.057397205382585526,
-0.3276209235191345,
-0.15869136154651642,
0.38144978880882263,
-0.28531843423843384,
-0.28687018156051636,
-0.29200249910354614,
0.5817742347717285,
0.2730381488800049,
-0.6790362596511841,
0.7510952949523926,
0.7433958053588867,
-0.40564146637916565,
-0.14941701292991638,
-0.4398152232170105,
-0.2713501751422882,
-0.4341265559196472,
0.5944049954414368,
-0.29617220163345337,
-1.3313621282577515,
0.37096598744392395,
-0.22070959210395813,
-0.1304265707731247,
0.27921178936958313,
0.12688963115215302,
-0.04349851980805397,
0.9395667314529419,
0.8686095476150513,
-0.08866111189126968,
0.604816198348999,
-0.19566954672336578,
0.3205711841583252,
-0.6727645993232727,
0.007235683500766754,
-0.859572172164917,
-0.011403961107134819,
-0.7604304552078247,
-0.28187885880470276,
0.0978371798992157,
0.36724767088890076,
-0.35465192794799805,
0.5749132037162781,
-0.3089475929737091,
0.6840565204620361,
0.4699043333530426,
0.258811891078949,
0.1254824548959732,
0.17240528762340546,
0.011457376182079315,
-0.2791565954685211,
-0.6934864521026611,
-0.6237612962722778,
0.565539538860321,
0.05356395244598389,
1.1594442129135132,
0.05621640756726265,
1.0770912170410156,
0.24002203345298767,
-0.07791772484779358,
-0.5506515502929688,
0.10458274930715561,
-0.7951014041900635,
-0.3537234663963318,
-0.10621238499879837,
-0.11805415898561478,
-0.7363719344139099,
0.15661892294883728,
-0.08512918651103973,
-0.717359721660614,
0.37027063965797424,
-0.16398434340953827,
-0.35513827204704285,
-0.02453814074397087,
-0.60064297914505,
0.9549618363380432,
-0.36051470041275024,
-0.1821267157793045,
-0.46515950560569763,
-0.32664400339126587,
-0.09681392461061478,
-0.29045969247817993,
0.05178678035736084,
-0.11989741027355194,
0.042759716510772705,
0.5489516854286194,
0.14514635503292084,
0.7735716700553894,
0.12219956517219543,
0.13508130609989166,
-0.04856008291244507,
0.1063736230134964,
0.5835897922515869,
0.18853972852230072,
-0.4375278949737549,
0.019628016278147697,
-0.0002728044637478888,
-0.467178612947464,
-0.5836855173110962,
0.9553946256637573,
-0.9301626682281494,
-0.5168436765670776,
-0.21644362807273865,
-0.2978072762489319,
-0.02088942565023899,
0.25537872314453125,
0.3086124062538147,
0.6639605760574341,
-0.6168593764305115,
0.5931161046028137,
0.8680977821350098,
-0.31303074955940247,
0.26759982109069824,
0.8106001019477844,
0.018596719950437546,
-0.14259468019008636,
0.8375402092933655,
0.06399322301149368,
-0.097591333091259,
0.63079434633255,
-0.06315566599369049,
-0.12743191421031952,
-0.45414987206459045,
-0.3341015875339508,
0.30167070031166077,
-0.8112472891807556,
-0.2083813101053238,
-0.7997854948043823,
-0.37895238399505615,
-0.17963173985481262,
-0.6847878694534302,
-0.3497515320777893,
-0.4373721480369568,
-0.762829065322876,
-0.3020331859588623,
0.33248013257980347,
0.7703646421432495,
-0.11750031262636185,
0.30254921317100525,
-0.931976318359375,
0.15954160690307617,
0.20651915669441223,
0.3116207420825958,
-0.4935547411441803,
-0.596439003944397,
-0.5828027129173279,
-0.0860232338309288,
-0.1847035437822342,
-0.7355818152427673,
0.3366832733154297,
0.40759551525115967,
0.5886533260345459,
0.2519471049308777,
0.3395797908306122,
0.28887465596199036,
-0.7021891474723816,
0.7379243969917297,
0.1861099749803543,
-0.916756808757782,
0.7600616812705994,
-0.2571125626564026,
0.41158202290534973,
0.6927547454833984,
0.7221261262893677,
-0.4835856854915619,
-0.28776848316192627,
-0.4039168655872345,
-0.6064172983169556,
0.5773860812187195,
0.0944303572177887,
0.5718725919723511,
-0.2333541214466095,
0.34279829263687134,
0.32246407866477966,
0.04382643848657608,
-0.31332406401634216,
0.35753753781318665,
-0.3698529601097107,
-0.26514917612075806,
-0.26299554109573364,
-0.3977854549884796,
-0.15657925605773926,
-0.19956757128238678,
0.6311757564544678,
-0.19050706923007965,
0.2754284739494324,
0.23323217034339905,
-0.6547967195510864,
0.11313416808843613,
0.41072553396224976,
0.5383414030075073,
0.8034670948982239,
-0.2632463574409485,
0.17297928035259247,
0.14495521783828735,
-0.012004719115793705,
-0.06738164275884628,
0.6209219694137573,
-0.3525528609752655,
0.4073510766029358,
0.34753769636154175,
0.9255620241165161,
0.4570557177066803,
-0.6654723286628723,
0.4428318440914154,
-0.1669493317604065,
-0.41219696402549744,
-0.1804991066455841,
0.13887837529182434,
0.30536383390426636,
0.5420140027999878,
0.03929520398378372,
-0.03021644987165928,
0.29812484979629517,
-0.47759366035461426,
0.32814252376556396,
0.16171963512897491,
-0.6521349549293518,
-0.19876417517662048,
0.40144506096839905,
0.26032471656799316,
-0.3977871537208557,
0.760972797870636,
-0.15881629288196564,
-0.8435837626457214,
0.4536779522895813,
0.5881490111351013,
0.6657680869102478,
-0.02475607395172119,
0.576493501663208,
0.46997570991516113,
0.33572980761528015,
-0.4088338613510132,
0.2037084698677063,
0.04937300086021423,
-0.9308847188949585,
-0.026138653978705406,
-0.5535390377044678,
-0.3210901916027069,
-0.41938090324401855,
-1.018635630607605,
0.18265800178050995,
0.016091814264655113,
-0.06746046990156174,
0.11963652819395065,
0.12631401419639587,
-0.9368302226066589,
-0.09113525599241257,
-0.210976243019104,
1.2483887672424316,
-0.9238832592964172,
1.1443243026733398,
0.8023771047592163,
-0.43911394476890564,
-0.07870590686798096,
0.15669210255146027,
-0.625300407409668,
-0.5384016633033752,
0.8245553374290466,
0.22089506685733795,
-0.2939789295196533,
0.03394393250346184,
-0.4910404086112976,
-0.6311860680580139,
0.9113535284996033,
0.513637125492096,
-0.8505464196205139,
0.26259398460388184,
-0.22211207449436188,
0.5772942304611206,
-0.5503862500190735,
-0.24270182847976685,
0.3531671166419983,
0.33202728629112244,
-0.35389629006385803,
-0.48386314511299133,
-0.271156370639801,
-0.18230542540550232,
0.1964588314294815,
0.2668827474117279,
-0.6871650218963623,
0.7683652639389038,
-0.19169095158576965,
0.0634782537817955,
0.2214421033859253,
0.5837917923927307,
-0.0062983036041259766,
-0.21721459925174713,
0.1291540414094925,
0.4482085108757019,
0.8723164796829224,
-0.20065155625343323,
1.0938094854354858,
-0.6361516714096069,
0.41261786222457886,
1.1839431524276733,
-0.44461098313331604,
1.001250982284546,
0.3229956328868866,
0.20754240453243256,
0.7232427000999451,
0.7115728855133057,
-0.2693933844566345,
1.0191013813018799,
0.047136761248111725,
-0.20722229778766632,
-0.4189763367176056,
-0.15372367203235626,
-0.21565446257591248,
0.16655926406383514,
0.34677815437316895,
-0.5026613473892212,
-0.23391173779964447,
0.29753005504608154,
0.01754380390048027,
0.3490285277366638,
-0.1713084876537323,
0.5419663190841675,
-0.06576371937990189,
-0.4538504183292389,
0.23166044056415558,
0.4490530490875244,
0.6841351389884949,
-0.5772442817687988,
0.17994697391986847,
-0.3277033567428589,
0.3580872416496277,
-0.029408181086182594,
-0.8540079593658447,
0.2589157223701477,
0.010928605683147907,
-0.3204953372478485,
-0.1344708502292633,
0.912752091884613,
-0.7201663255691528,
-0.6985374093055725,
0.472417414188385,
0.32435154914855957,
-0.14074917137622833,
0.0506138913333416,
-0.6341068148612976,
0.10956539958715439,
-0.09733816981315613,
-0.0452871136367321,
0.3047524094581604,
0.5707036256790161,
0.18972168862819672,
0.27865493297576904,
0.2238989770412445,
-0.18314732611179352,
-0.2594378888607025,
0.28488922119140625,
0.8997024893760681,
-0.6134620904922485,
-0.7003035545349121,
-0.6094224452972412,
0.2525886297225952,
-0.2754853367805481,
-0.1803787648677826,
0.5119860768318176,
0.7948634624481201,
0.974820613861084,
-0.19377945363521576,
0.8398205637931824,
0.2334459275007248,
0.34838756918907166,
-0.6076406240463257,
0.7686504125595093,
-0.6445028781890869,
-0.30280372500419617,
0.1826704889535904,
-0.783067524433136,
-0.2801019251346588,
1.0863653421401978,
-0.17377004027366638,
-0.17693771421909332,
0.7668723464012146,
0.8049399256706238,
-0.32061678171157837,
0.2184721827507019,
0.32489344477653503,
-0.020267188549041748,
0.00857873447239399,
0.2665490210056305,
0.6357219219207764,
-0.2603594660758972,
0.41670024394989014,
-0.31815773248672485,
0.1543940156698227,
-0.2666611075401306,
-0.863206684589386,
-1.2840474843978882,
-0.683616578578949,
-0.3994688093662262,
-0.11105594038963318,
0.6186214685440063,
0.7549085021018982,
0.7601166367530823,
-0.8236179351806641,
-0.11929299682378769,
0.1535608023405075,
-0.011568521149456501,
0.021295439451932907,
-0.09660584479570389,
0.38686972856521606,
-0.37070998549461365,
-0.5890002846717834,
0.34634432196617126,
0.2802763283252716,
0.07446926087141037,
-0.10738309472799301,
-0.28906944394111633,
-0.21565474569797516,
0.1451498568058014,
0.5688044428825378,
-0.028204504400491714,
-0.5356566309928894,
-0.477667897939682,
-0.03235182538628578,
-0.20950882136821747,
-0.0005272930138744414,
0.9392496347427368,
-0.45510485768318176,
0.5434413552284241,
0.4893946647644043,
0.6776883602142334,
0.9951889514923096,
-0.15546929836273193,
0.6780689358711243,
-0.720537543296814,
0.28482022881507874,
0.08335622400045395,
0.6086214184761047,
0.768027126789093,
-0.2250518947839737,
0.5482105016708374,
-0.28297215700149536,
-0.4224526882171631,
-0.4101783335208893,
0.177635058760643,
-0.6217026710510254,
-0.6258507966995239,
0.8977850079536438,
-0.3308738172054291,
0.01528310775756836,
0.02450987510383129,
-0.2758757174015045,
0.2330743670463562,
-0.46333879232406616,
0.5860860347747803,
0.9546940326690674,
-0.030279381200671196,
-0.3989098072052002,
-0.6213297247886658,
0.24961376190185547,
0.06582184880971909,
-0.5475447773933411,
-0.16363884508609772,
0.42166945338249207,
0.33948758244514465,
0.16560040414333344,
0.20646844804286957,
0.031653907150030136,
0.3238554298877716,
-0.1504547894001007,
-0.18563227355480194,
-0.09938324987888336,
-0.2768581807613373,
-0.5009344220161438,
0.08983227610588074,
0.093845434486866,
0.07334680110216141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07500v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07500v1
|
PromptLink: Leveraging Large Language Models for Cross-Source Biomedical Concept Linking
| 2024-05-13T06:36:30 | 2024-05-13T06:36:30 |
Yuzhang Xie, Jiaying Lu, Joyce Ho, Fadi Nahab, Xiao Hu, Carl Yang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Linking (aligning) biomedical concepts across diverse data sources enables
various integrative analyses, but it is challenging due to the discrepancies in
concept naming conventions. Various strategies have been developed to overcome
this challenge, such as those based on string-matching rules, manually crafted
thesauri, and machine learning models. However, these methods are constrained
by limited prior biomedical knowledge and can hardly generalize beyond the
limited amounts of rules, thesauri, or training samples. Recently, large
language models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive results in diverse biomedical
NLP tasks due to their unprecedentedly rich prior knowledge and strong
zero-shot prediction abilities. However, LLMs suffer from issues including high
costs, limited context length, and unreliable predictions. In this research, we
propose PromptLink, a novel biomedical concept linking framework that leverages
LLMs. It first employs a biomedical-specialized pre-trained language model to
generate candidate concepts that can fit in the LLM context windows. Then it
utilizes an LLM to link concepts through two-stage prompts, where the
first-stage prompt aims to elicit the biomedical prior knowledge from the LLM
for the concept linking task and the second-stage prompt enforces the LLM to
reflect on its own predictions to further enhance their reliability. Empirical
results on the concept linking task between two EHR datasets and an external
biomedical KG demonstrate the effectiveness of PromptLink. Furthermore,
PromptLink is a generic framework without reliance on additional prior
knowledge, context, or training data, making it well-suited for concept linking
across various types of data sources. The source code is available at
https://github.com/constantjxyz/PromptLink.
|
[
-0.06309636682271957,
-0.7054047584533691,
0.8660274147987366,
-0.02292073518037796,
-0.3247956335544586,
0.1332133710384369,
0.04562816023826599,
-0.6517596244812012,
0.1780126839876175,
0.11851005256175995,
-0.7679767608642578,
-0.4590700566768646,
-0.22241348028182983,
0.5281819105148315,
-0.08491600304841995,
0.8034348487854004,
0.2571137547492981,
0.20773735642433167,
-0.6515359878540039,
-0.2616736888885498,
-0.5474756360054016,
-0.04265950247645378,
-0.8104729056358337,
-0.4190761148929596,
0.9880436062812805,
0.15001320838928223,
0.7804182767868042,
0.802444338798523,
0.5424893498420715,
0.1864246129989624,
-0.15449906885623932,
0.08157456666231155,
-0.38975390791893005,
0.40888503193855286,
-0.6358729004859924,
-0.3354964554309845,
-0.404771625995636,
-0.28496211767196655,
0.616144597530365,
0.86448734998703,
0.20876170694828033,
0.026017948985099792,
-0.08663778752088547,
0.5359194874763489,
-0.3146612346172333,
0.14415255188941956,
-0.616267204284668,
-0.10947737842798233,
-0.3165906071662903,
-0.26485028862953186,
-0.1853805035352707,
-0.4357064366340637,
0.35309574007987976,
-0.6162102222442627,
0.015126884914934635,
0.376972496509552,
0.6419333815574646,
0.5542959570884705,
-0.36695727705955505,
-0.42058253288269043,
-0.10417180508375168,
0.3180750906467438,
-0.6531481742858887,
0.3861410915851593,
0.17928996682167053,
0.2214408665895462,
-0.1767439842224121,
-0.5656656622886658,
-0.5446735620498657,
-0.39269721508026123,
-0.12054897099733353,
-0.14423778653144836,
-0.2043144255876541,
0.06507979333400726,
0.3679826259613037,
-0.04491940513253212,
-0.7760357856750488,
0.29067477583885193,
-0.3682364523410797,
-0.2219633013010025,
0.4718691110610962,
0.2667113244533539,
0.5238656997680664,
-0.2903714179992676,
-0.4658556282520294,
0.05196636915206909,
-1.1175613403320312,
-0.1422051638364792,
-0.05165431648492813,
0.7667011022567749,
-0.27156323194503784,
0.7419478893280029,
-0.026449188590049744,
0.7202991843223572,
0.4163397252559662,
-0.1750173717737198,
0.6480157375335693,
-0.6172990798950195,
0.007767786271870136,
0.5811923742294312,
0.8508528470993042,
0.31150078773498535,
-0.22360776364803314,
-0.3167879283428192,
0.24005746841430664,
-0.07162252068519592,
0.0628967210650444,
-0.8458456993103027,
-0.01920251175761223,
0.5517657995223999,
-0.3625052869319916,
-0.02296842820942402,
-0.5332148671150208,
-0.3151739537715912,
-0.5160132646560669,
-0.3008587062358856,
0.5405434370040894,
-0.7105401754379272,
0.000929281406570226,
0.06116821989417076,
0.0992148146033287,
0.19339989125728607,
0.27315962314605713,
-0.41833385825157166,
-0.34898558259010315,
0.6261641979217529,
0.953320324420929,
-0.11486494541168213,
-0.274729460477829,
-0.7822339534759521,
0.460835725069046,
-0.07224936783313751,
0.761049211025238,
-0.6536685228347778,
-0.542313277721405,
-0.01544856745749712,
0.18509089946746826,
0.0050663575530052185,
-0.20510074496269226,
0.6128726005554199,
-0.5176771283149719,
0.12042467296123505,
-0.4125710129737854,
-0.8306729793548584,
0.3247116208076477,
0.06889323145151138,
-0.7210046648979187,
0.6597691178321838,
-0.14260266721248627,
-1.055796504020691,
0.2913989722728729,
-0.5909587740898132,
-0.5988125801086426,
0.2924323081970215,
-0.35198596119880676,
-0.3418126404285431,
-0.10420189052820206,
-0.15699127316474915,
0.5499395132064819,
-0.644385814666748,
0.6839247941970825,
-0.6902837157249451,
-0.01457221433520317,
0.33703988790512085,
0.09725439548492432,
0.8208613395690918,
0.1784432977437973,
0.07332470268011093,
0.4053773880004883,
-0.713374674320221,
-0.3606870770454407,
0.11644604802131653,
-0.024976028129458427,
-0.6690285205841064,
-0.3417793810367584,
-0.344199001789093,
0.4402393400669098,
0.36236652731895447,
-0.6152198314666748,
0.2703969180583954,
-0.41022560000419617,
0.2503145635128021,
0.4638603925704956,
-0.1185314953327179,
0.4126453697681427,
-0.3588580787181854,
0.3841276168823242,
-0.024287452921271324,
-0.10892993211746216,
-0.522879958152771,
-0.48914340138435364,
-0.21645487844944,
-0.1771610528230667,
0.16618990898132324,
0.3638005554676056,
-1.0021657943725586,
0.5356733798980713,
-0.38591474294662476,
-0.5290725827217102,
-0.7107032537460327,
-0.09390317648649216,
0.41304078698158264,
1.1267369985580444,
0.7353577017784119,
0.12879610061645508,
-0.408621221780777,
-0.8353119492530823,
-0.06380601227283478,
-0.4276457130908966,
-0.3032771646976471,
0.5401933193206787,
0.2765500545501709,
-0.37049320340156555,
1.0016038417816162,
-0.41086307168006897,
-0.2529033124446869,
-0.13370276987552643,
0.005730660632252693,
0.36513465642929077,
0.5329191088676453,
0.4051668345928192,
-0.5180945992469788,
-0.2578619718551636,
-0.10341812670230865,
-0.7996183037757874,
-0.4115835130214691,
-0.18097086250782013,
-0.2595813572406769,
-0.3796679377555847,
0.6546589136123657,
-0.6765851974487305,
-0.08180365711450577,
0.407959520816803,
-0.5314866304397583,
0.5658501982688904,
-0.26107633113861084,
0.027724137529730797,
-1.4407488107681274,
0.5125858783721924,
0.24942636489868164,
0.024614596739411354,
-0.46110135316848755,
-0.2172190397977829,
-0.019624363631010056,
-0.23137696087360382,
-0.34571072459220886,
0.9716338515281677,
-0.3314265012741089,
0.09850908070802689,
-0.09052716195583344,
0.06005464121699333,
-0.06862552464008331,
-0.018645798787474632,
0.26294490694999695,
0.6971883773803711,
0.7111838459968567,
-0.5029720067977905,
0.4574868381023407,
0.8259980082511902,
0.15288478136062622,
0.8412719368934631,
-1.0447977781295776,
-0.12105801701545715,
-0.07717850059270859,
0.4479682743549347,
-0.7873375415802002,
-0.20249131321907043,
0.3839060962200165,
-0.46938884258270264,
0.3356609642505646,
0.0611095055937767,
-0.4162904620170593,
-0.33769601583480835,
-0.20570197701454163,
0.634058952331543,
0.3395967483520508,
-0.5200750827789307,
0.5395535826683044,
0.299009770154953,
-0.5357247591018677,
-0.4432324171066284,
-0.45384564995765686,
0.24019336700439453,
-0.15908421576023102,
-0.59615159034729,
0.5555645823478699,
-0.2434602677822113,
0.18468740582466125,
0.09678228199481964,
-0.04940515756607056,
0.14047189056873322,
-0.19958864152431488,
0.3370828926563263,
0.5672839283943176,
-0.21339523792266846,
0.6661078333854675,
0.17588472366333008,
-0.1961182802915573,
0.26862969994544983,
-0.3140144348144531,
0.23224548995494843,
0.35513877868652344,
-0.47991111874580383,
-0.28496864438056946,
0.3810836672782898,
0.4225096106529236,
-0.15753039717674255,
0.877155065536499,
0.6178218126296997,
-0.24108785390853882,
-0.06200062111020088,
-0.3269746005535126,
-0.17182521522045135,
-0.40675342082977295,
0.4188074469566345,
-0.4385557472705841,
-0.9770638346672058,
0.23053333163261414,
-0.42345675826072693,
-0.24506926536560059,
0.3717195689678192,
0.5650204420089722,
-0.11014026403427124,
0.4374852180480957,
0.7203404307365417,
0.02479439228773117,
0.10134578496217728,
0.3436700105667114,
0.26698020100593567,
-0.9042022228240967,
-0.6462295651435852,
-0.7996688485145569,
-0.13748282194137573,
-0.4629009962081909,
-0.7275151610374451,
0.47808149456977844,
0.033756859600543976,
-0.459354966878891,
0.3697572946548462,
-0.1710701733827591,
0.10322895646095276,
0.5060770511627197,
0.33201295137405396,
0.3490429222583771,
-0.07621707767248154,
-0.5429529547691345,
0.13915546238422394,
-0.9093412160873413,
-0.3546321988105774,
1.1595999002456665,
0.26975488662719727,
0.8150404691696167,
-0.06837161630392075,
0.4144115149974823,
0.10773313790559769,
0.15539638698101044,
-0.6376413106918335,
0.4862501919269562,
0.17593051493167877,
-0.3692757189273834,
-0.25395604968070984,
-0.42408812046051025,
-1.140389323234558,
-0.341911643743515,
-0.6278847455978394,
-0.4422455132007599,
0.14592337608337402,
0.14686903357505798,
-0.3944871425628662,
0.2093643695116043,
-0.09801705181598663,
0.8546072244644165,
-0.18453924357891083,
-0.753777027130127,
-0.09815267473459244,
-1.205029010772705,
0.3246343433856964,
-0.5008944869041443,
-0.0707041397690773,
-0.20319442451000214,
-0.20909662544727325,
0.5203203558921814,
-0.42771950364112854,
0.8372294902801514,
0.24678009748458862,
-0.380528062582016,
-0.0124044269323349,
-0.11628710478544235,
0.33488795161247253,
0.21599097549915314,
-0.12145029008388519,
0.32976892590522766,
-0.11219137161970139,
-0.31295913457870483,
-0.2393970787525177,
0.8330478072166443,
-0.517817497253418,
-0.3679368197917938,
-0.2861620783805847,
-0.53370600938797,
-0.5570195317268372,
0.12579047679901123,
0.2200230360031128,
0.43177372217178345,
-0.2062326818704605,
0.1868293285369873,
0.9258996248245239,
-0.6122586727142334,
0.15888579189777374,
0.6821794509887695,
0.027950039133429527,
-0.2027963250875473,
0.5527567863464355,
-0.5164663195610046,
0.1514061689376831,
0.6326836943626404,
0.10845199972391129,
-0.7180949449539185,
-0.3628476560115814,
-0.24855956435203552,
0.45892295241355896,
-0.45431190729141235,
-0.4798479676246643,
-0.8119783997535706,
-0.06487105041742325,
-0.2923336327075958,
-0.26664936542510986,
-0.1141359806060791,
0.022692007943987846,
-0.21493397653102875,
0.04300275072455406,
0.570412278175354,
0.13969473540782928,
-0.2582071125507355,
0.05827845260500908,
-1.0788360834121704,
0.42378631234169006,
0.1417999416589737,
0.4279284179210663,
0.0050478531047701836,
-0.23303918540477753,
-0.14926400780677795,
-0.0925399512052536,
0.24259723722934723,
-1.0167640447616577,
0.010386687703430653,
0.10370055586099625,
0.60429447889328,
0.3550119400024414,
0.19952993094921112,
0.4475938379764557,
-0.8746694326400757,
0.46107134222984314,
0.7543941736221313,
-0.7455831170082092,
0.8520535826683044,
-0.3520543575286865,
0.22103388607501984,
0.4650004506111145,
0.8257900476455688,
-0.4385818541049957,
-0.2009643316268921,
-0.47022321820259094,
-0.8225050568580627,
0.28881895542144775,
0.11499536037445068,
-0.14636890590190887,
-0.32192811369895935,
0.29245156049728394,
0.28308045864105225,
0.20360159873962402,
-0.1326412409543991,
-0.3440619707107544,
0.20017412304878235,
-0.460136741399765,
-0.2002372443675995,
-0.05210656300187111,
-0.24502012133598328,
-0.10705795139074326,
0.559327244758606,
-0.3794553279876709,
0.18635281920433044,
0.2951875329017639,
-0.12995801866054535,
-0.20395544171333313,
0.2942311763763428,
0.07469458878040314,
0.5226643085479736,
-0.06541229784488678,
-0.11293584853410721,
-0.07415974140167236,
-0.22716599702835083,
0.2476833611726761,
0.39798957109451294,
-0.23352690041065216,
0.18653669953346252,
0.5395090579986572,
0.7434549331665039,
0.36680808663368225,
-0.9402156472206116,
0.4016382396221161,
0.17632892727851868,
0.28937920928001404,
0.17849573493003845,
-0.08867146819829941,
0.47326022386550903,
0.5018655061721802,
0.2492605596780777,
-0.04573938623070717,
0.09077272564172745,
-0.4327758252620697,
0.5078575015068054,
0.501689076423645,
-0.3961230516433716,
-0.41377514600753784,
0.9981346726417542,
0.5027607679367065,
-0.00021642906358465552,
0.30223435163497925,
-0.06679696589708328,
-0.04688097909092903,
0.4605557322502136,
0.6941578388214111,
0.8760046362876892,
-0.2528323829174042,
0.31951549649238586,
0.7144349217414856,
-0.16509951651096344,
0.056297481060028076,
0.10001818090677261,
0.049534037709236145,
-0.6177247166633606,
-0.6766563057899475,
-0.6526989340782166,
-0.4671919643878937,
-0.14319629967212677,
-0.4819396436214447,
0.405987948179245,
-0.19234268367290497,
-0.17116375267505646,
0.12602710723876953,
-0.030299948528409004,
-0.7973608374595642,
0.09414713829755783,
0.38203829526901245,
1.0982249975204468,
-0.983144223690033,
0.9348931312561035,
0.9666409492492676,
-0.6322605013847351,
-0.8644435405731201,
-0.1817670315504074,
0.18837052583694458,
-0.7955074310302734,
0.8493386507034302,
-0.10096259415149689,
-0.052158255130052567,
-0.00035260728327557445,
-0.41072171926498413,
-0.8178195357322693,
1.254781723022461,
0.3079110085964203,
-0.879313588142395,
-0.35805660486221313,
-0.02960582822561264,
0.44229793548583984,
-0.5408411622047424,
0.27235913276672363,
0.19904935359954834,
0.3285987675189972,
0.6707829236984253,
-1.077579140663147,
0.619391918182373,
-0.14926323294639587,
-0.16833490133285522,
-0.049046680331230164,
-0.3852703869342804,
0.5743157863616943,
-0.6241016983985901,
-0.13494877517223358,
0.29251161217689514,
0.4798301160335541,
0.7318207621574402,
0.39646443724632263,
0.11653690040111542,
0.4330091178417206,
0.9661977887153625,
0.11004386097192764,
0.6452702283859253,
-0.6771641969680786,
0.18717259168624878,
1.2479939460754395,
-0.7475643754005432,
0.6558179259300232,
0.37896910309791565,
-0.20832559466362,
0.3588224947452545,
0.5414493083953857,
-0.11530167609453201,
0.45276811718940735,
0.04750724136829376,
-0.2499619424343109,
-0.23617896437644958,
-0.6997316479682922,
-0.7409587502479553,
0.01067772600799799,
0.4446026086807251,
-0.32638266682624817,
-0.3622936010360718,
-0.13181933760643005,
-0.08344219624996185,
-0.14050671458244324,
-0.4755064845085144,
0.7185453772544861,
0.16900527477264404,
-0.16992367804050446,
0.26592934131622314,
-0.4118553102016449,
0.6194853782653809,
-0.8062956929206848,
0.06648978590965271,
-0.11337403208017349,
-0.2443661391735077,
-0.0398222915828228,
-0.6517748236656189,
0.019373005256056786,
-0.03978366032242775,
-0.05516922473907471,
0.1302589476108551,
0.8039295077323914,
-0.605755627155304,
-0.24527139961719513,
0.2984960675239563,
0.9163855910301208,
-0.14868198335170746,
0.3570355772972107,
-0.8809605836868286,
0.09790632873773575,
-0.177643284201622,
0.22913961112499237,
0.3939013183116913,
0.5893968343734741,
0.09921997040510178,
0.890174150466919,
0.8529026508331299,
0.27266526222229004,
-0.45292267203330994,
-0.018355339765548706,
0.9994967579841614,
-1.0099103450775146,
-0.5325575470924377,
-0.7869303822517395,
0.32903075218200684,
-0.16293376684188843,
-0.3068379759788513,
0.530846118927002,
0.5849683284759521,
0.44419628381729126,
-0.008289586752653122,
0.7085839509963989,
0.07399064302444458,
0.5631201267242432,
-0.5516312122344971,
0.47854262590408325,
-0.4979018568992615,
0.18799428641796112,
-0.31659695506095886,
-0.8116685152053833,
-0.28380119800567627,
0.2538371980190277,
-0.00511509133502841,
-0.2391967624425888,
0.8447662591934204,
0.6204103231430054,
0.06690925359725952,
-0.18749907612800598,
0.1754734218120575,
0.45962783694267273,
0.03966102749109268,
0.8664022088050842,
0.704465925693512,
0.0012466238113120198,
0.24644389748573303,
0.22381648421287537,
-0.07319936156272888,
-0.25019603967666626,
-1.1695795059204102,
-1.0407195091247559,
-0.5001194477081299,
-0.7456193566322327,
-0.5305390357971191,
0.20384721457958221,
1.2425509691238403,
0.4791218042373657,
-0.5838461518287659,
0.23867414891719818,
0.20107688009738922,
0.05343356728553772,
0.16818615794181824,
-0.07186272740364075,
0.659929096698761,
-0.45917773246765137,
-0.4984131157398224,
0.5151920318603516,
0.5669304132461548,
0.10719460994005203,
-0.14475759863853455,
-0.14563360810279846,
-0.30287763476371765,
0.012083946727216244,
0.4773162305355072,
0.478150874376297,
-0.6754931211471558,
0.022373802959918976,
-0.0624423548579216,
-0.3461475372314453,
-0.09901491552591324,
0.6428810358047485,
-1.2255773544311523,
0.301857054233551,
0.5338602066040039,
1.0861918926239014,
-0.15143781900405884,
0.05823123827576637,
0.6546704769134521,
-0.5272018909454346,
-0.007020225282758474,
0.21274659037590027,
0.4338268041610718,
0.4637187123298645,
-0.3674769401550293,
0.44896262884140015,
0.1463320404291153,
-0.23580053448677063,
-0.6094586849212646,
0.25588417053222656,
-1.1944931745529175,
-0.412928968667984,
1.0527760982513428,
0.01672395132482052,
-0.22619791328907013,
0.022395582869648933,
-0.11820485442876816,
0.35695672035217285,
-0.3826409876346588,
0.6308391690254211,
0.19240008294582367,
-0.030232500284910202,
0.19755306839942932,
-0.3862916827201843,
0.6396307349205017,
0.21463435888290405,
-0.8196198344230652,
-0.12562677264213562,
0.6474021077156067,
0.28975310921669006,
0.08160223066806793,
0.5363191366195679,
0.03389224410057068,
0.1792532354593277,
-0.18740962445735931,
-0.02948402427136898,
-0.14385011792182922,
-0.05321377143263817,
-0.4573479890823364,
0.025134872645139694,
-0.22805587947368622,
-0.009732569567859173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07495v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07495v1
|
MacBehaviour: An R package for behavioural experimentation on large language models
| 2024-05-13T06:31:48 | 2024-05-13T06:31:48 |
Xufeng Duan, Shixuan Li, Zhenguang G. Cai1
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
There has been increasing interest in investigating the behaviours of large
language models (LLMs) and LLM-powered chatbots by treating an LLM as a
participant in a psychological experiment. We therefore developed an R package
called "MacBehaviour" that aims to interact with more than 60 language models
in one package (e.g., OpenAI's GPT family, the Claude family, Gemini, Llama
family, and open-source models) and streamline the experimental process of LLMs
behaviour experiments. The package offers a comprehensive set of functions
designed for LLM experiments, covering experiment design, stimuli presentation,
model behaviour manipulation, logging response and token probability. To
demonstrate the utility and effectiveness of "MacBehaviour," we conducted three
validation experiments on three LLMs (GPT-3.5, Llama-2 7B, and Vicuna-1.5 13B)
to replicate sound-gender association in LLMs. The results consistently showed
that they exhibit human-like tendencies to infer gender from novel personal
names based on their phonology, as previously demonstrated (Cai et al., 2023).
In summary, "MacBehaviour" is an R package for machine behaviour studies which
offers a user-friendly interface and comprehensive features to simplify and
standardize the experimental process.
|
[
-0.5554508566856384,
-1.1514103412628174,
0.44007453322410583,
0.5229091644287109,
0.1567286103963852,
0.03907766938209534,
-0.06449255347251892,
-0.4445440471172333,
0.21610406041145325,
0.7922475934028625,
-0.830727219581604,
-0.41320016980171204,
-0.5053094029426575,
0.2747120261192322,
-0.33376041054725647,
1.024113416671753,
0.14603377878665924,
0.03878738731145859,
-0.15575318038463593,
-0.06435724347829819,
-0.5288087725639343,
-0.7852139472961426,
-0.6328525543212891,
-0.40235790610313416,
0.8303389549255371,
0.4813102185726166,
0.6016797423362732,
0.08032005280256271,
0.7867271900177002,
0.28026455640792847,
-0.2552676796913147,
0.1367272138595581,
-0.4516700208187103,
0.3667418956756592,
-0.16771455109119415,
-0.31031957268714905,
-0.6308503746986389,
-0.0284949392080307,
0.32753315567970276,
0.3975333273410797,
-0.40507519245147705,
0.3574870526790619,
0.08407957851886749,
0.5340730547904968,
-0.40649017691612244,
0.23879969120025635,
-0.1332557499408722,
-0.0032258406281471252,
-0.10392705351114273,
-0.1293560266494751,
-0.45859578251838684,
-0.3531404733657837,
-0.2979716658592224,
-0.22890818119049072,
-0.08857247233390808,
0.3851730525493622,
0.29566940665245056,
0.1389387547969818,
-0.2534985840320587,
-0.28341540694236755,
-0.8390365839004517,
0.7215143442153931,
-0.749031662940979,
0.35475102066993713,
0.6258647441864014,
0.4026696979999542,
-0.8437638878822327,
-0.4651954174041748,
-0.6632155776023865,
-0.49501991271972656,
-0.14604589343070984,
0.026241455227136612,
-0.4462057650089264,
0.12249121069908142,
0.4326314330101013,
0.20364174246788025,
-0.5223426818847656,
0.06454712152481079,
-0.2805156111717224,
-0.30469661951065063,
0.6283761858940125,
0.1914798766374588,
0.6194202899932861,
-0.12241575121879578,
-0.03888038173317909,
-0.23962780833244324,
-0.28079676628112793,
0.19324900209903717,
0.8117607235908508,
0.38418689370155334,
-0.196815624833107,
0.9067056775093079,
-0.020103804767131805,
0.4336642324924469,
-0.042734671384096146,
-0.41659387946128845,
0.32868248224258423,
-0.00021828892931807786,
-0.12032564729452133,
0.11830860376358032,
0.9305475950241089,
0.01017946656793356,
0.34725421667099,
0.12375359237194061,
-0.37021222710609436,
0.1603877991437912,
0.2452058345079422,
-0.8859671354293823,
-0.39229002594947815,
0.24886363744735718,
-0.3360666334629059,
-0.6357351541519165,
-0.03388490155339241,
-0.669866681098938,
-0.16905952990055084,
-0.20058554410934448,
0.44293129444122314,
-0.5146642327308655,
-0.4525086283683777,
0.18692919611930847,
-0.066848024725914,
0.30443888902664185,
0.028333857655525208,
-0.9630058407783508,
0.6893222332000732,
0.7274790406227112,
0.6006672382354736,
-0.3486650884151459,
-0.3221898078918457,
-0.8912950158119202,
0.18280714750289917,
-0.1041613444685936,
0.6139283180236816,
-1.0405418872833252,
-1.005351185798645,
-0.41300374269485474,
0.12304498255252838,
0.1634823977947235,
-0.5423310399055481,
0.49124860763549805,
-0.2713252007961273,
0.19979295134544373,
-0.1677139550447464,
-0.27687498927116394,
-0.3139113783836365,
0.2295946329832077,
-0.4377785921096802,
1.3615469932556152,
0.06216368451714516,
-0.9771649837493896,
0.07313061505556107,
-1.1051758527755737,
-0.41871190071105957,
-0.10014278441667557,
-0.15354736149311066,
-0.5285332202911377,
0.01699448749423027,
0.24159131944179535,
0.4584503173828125,
0.10005509853363037,
0.4180081784725189,
-0.6001616716384888,
-0.3415183126926422,
0.8523176908493042,
-0.3671937882900238,
0.7847761511802673,
-0.03257313370704651,
-0.04944133758544922,
0.20865599811077118,
-0.6103272438049316,
-0.3668253421783447,
0.0828811377286911,
-0.11042402684688568,
-0.4262087047100067,
-0.17460617423057556,
0.18566346168518066,
0.10432697087526321,
0.061113182455301285,
-0.748634934425354,
0.35096827149391174,
0.10630136728286743,
0.4412471354007721,
0.6826380491256714,
0.08779840171337128,
-0.02121235989034176,
-0.45901545882225037,
0.8971439003944397,
-0.03623019531369209,
0.48836174607276917,
-0.16722369194030762,
-0.6827976703643799,
-0.20936143398284912,
-0.8284509778022766,
0.2172107845544815,
0.6319841146469116,
-0.1295873522758484,
0.16781707108020782,
0.09189558029174805,
-0.2972813844680786,
-0.21383395791053772,
-0.05584847182035446,
0.46382057666778564,
0.23446151614189148,
0.12388268113136292,
-0.362607479095459,
-0.7685100436210632,
-1.117400884628296,
0.031760215759277344,
-0.3570402264595032,
-0.07628539204597473,
0.5352447032928467,
0.764893651008606,
-0.8631494045257568,
1.100296139717102,
-0.539851188659668,
-0.15026137232780457,
-0.20636682212352753,
0.25773686170578003,
0.09878940880298615,
0.2815297842025757,
0.5382837653160095,
-0.8066095113754272,
0.18116521835327148,
-0.07314938306808472,
-0.41441649198532104,
-0.3236081898212433,
0.5221447348594666,
-0.3440995514392853,
0.23083916306495667,
0.39743512868881226,
-0.4421912431716919,
0.14633405208587646,
0.8669523000717163,
-0.16234272718429565,
0.9152860045433044,
-0.15389661490917206,
0.10294067859649658,
-0.9559087157249451,
0.2539123296737671,
-0.13345763087272644,
-0.5955958366394043,
-0.5482838153839111,
0.05571135878562927,
-0.19449970126152039,
-0.1830388903617859,
-0.4819156229496002,
0.631310760974884,
-0.04761502519249916,
-0.38179081678390503,
-0.15388454496860504,
0.18562662601470947,
-0.35128727555274963,
0.39225929975509644,
0.004731802735477686,
1.142478108406067,
0.3294377624988556,
-0.8391870856285095,
0.061706867069005966,
0.5949149131774902,
0.1381554752588272,
0.524685800075531,
-0.5683720707893372,
0.31324368715286255,
-0.24260179698467255,
0.3021323084831238,
-1.074817419052124,
-0.481067419052124,
0.5547314882278442,
-0.6430931091308594,
0.1583494395017624,
0.1335417628288269,
-0.4614490270614624,
-0.5051342248916626,
-0.25517013669013977,
0.3620099127292633,
0.5258388519287109,
-0.35282355546951294,
0.8907284736633301,
0.7522169947624207,
-0.5303752422332764,
-0.49139487743377686,
-0.8578037619590759,
0.07864397019147873,
-0.3212733268737793,
-0.2468285858631134,
0.051129452884197235,
-0.5265486836433411,
-0.5549845695495605,
-0.13049328327178955,
-0.03443664684891701,
0.012309877201914787,
0.09540989249944687,
0.49462464451789856,
0.31931015849113464,
-0.04324708506464958,
-0.03694368526339531,
-0.08176476508378983,
-0.25948813557624817,
0.05931084230542183,
0.20050065219402313,
0.6782137155532837,
-0.22347518801689148,
-0.15048792958259583,
-0.12491228431463242,
0.10124412178993225,
0.4629088342189789,
-0.2524425983428955,
0.4757010042667389,
0.5584562420845032,
-0.10780738294124603,
-0.21029764413833618,
-0.45256027579307556,
-0.2729710340499878,
-0.5092839598655701,
0.15213192999362946,
-0.5593477487564087,
-1.0419319868087769,
0.46538278460502625,
-0.053025033324956894,
0.10170412063598633,
-0.11806612461805344,
0.3942810893058777,
-0.264085978269577,
1.044256329536438,
0.8681197166442871,
-0.24751688539981842,
0.2824912667274475,
0.13315527141094208,
0.10395772755146027,
-1.0044662952423096,
-0.13969820737838745,
-0.4991665780544281,
-0.3235563337802887,
-0.8747005462646484,
-0.3654455840587616,
0.1387307047843933,
-0.26270660758018494,
-0.4874526560306549,
0.2559022903442383,
-0.3249000608921051,
0.4403932988643646,
0.21527697145938873,
0.134092777967453,
0.5393590331077576,
-0.07295344024896622,
-0.22413499653339386,
-0.027976717799901962,
-0.3294382691383362,
-0.7741575837135315,
0.8968673944473267,
0.24657058715820312,
0.8357713222503662,
0.3638586401939392,
0.7908245325088501,
0.3854098618030548,
0.6207624077796936,
-0.9831817150115967,
0.8407125473022461,
-0.08049549162387848,
-0.7474719882011414,
-0.2033739686012268,
-0.48168841004371643,
-1.0751805305480957,
0.016545908525586128,
0.04413998872041702,
-1.1436976194381714,
-0.10309352725744247,
0.10519175976514816,
0.04917526617646217,
0.09364523738622665,
-0.1145884171128273,
0.6520997285842896,
-0.1837095022201538,
-0.07974718511104584,
-0.1802813708782196,
-0.4001851975917816,
1.0785412788391113,
-0.25127390027046204,
0.47929733991622925,
-0.23297007381916046,
-0.03418012335896492,
0.6587749719619751,
-0.14858363568782806,
0.9607955813407898,
0.07728363573551178,
-0.444509893655777,
-0.07931134104728699,
0.6351531147956848,
0.5110160708427429,
0.03373495861887932,
0.0334952287375927,
0.1247495636343956,
0.05863485485315323,
-0.12951813638210297,
-0.4807996153831482,
0.45813968777656555,
-0.7365977764129639,
-0.6623027324676514,
-0.5023633241653442,
-0.6671068072319031,
-0.2565385401248932,
-0.01947738602757454,
-0.28101128339767456,
0.5046887397766113,
-0.4228787124156952,
0.17289334535598755,
0.7499456405639648,
-0.6098486185073853,
0.2253575176000595,
0.7703763842582703,
-1.2633286714553833,
-0.3736814260482788,
0.6504976153373718,
-0.4572025239467621,
0.257906973361969,
0.4424457252025604,
0.4537224769592285,
-0.11577945202589035,
-0.16736550629138947,
-0.023025142028927803,
0.3325875699520111,
-0.23631829023361206,
0.12748116254806519,
-0.8136526346206665,
-0.13535435497760773,
0.2330668419599533,
0.1452099084854126,
-0.18194304406642914,
-0.2494901865720749,
0.09743655472993851,
-0.0734543576836586,
0.6815589070320129,
0.7493792176246643,
0.047877125442028046,
0.4329431653022766,
-0.7148993015289307,
0.5765628218650818,
0.29810723662376404,
0.18983887135982513,
-0.3564176559448242,
-0.39030084013938904,
0.3730258047580719,
0.12158577144145966,
-0.4356556534767151,
-0.7191789150238037,
0.47749215364456177,
-0.0393819697201252,
0.620873749256134,
0.24490021169185638,
0.03368693217635155,
0.5657398104667664,
-0.27159708738327026,
0.6387094259262085,
0.084011010825634,
-0.9011573195457458,
0.5950050950050354,
-0.5993750691413879,
-0.06328138709068298,
0.33220764994621277,
0.33553367853164673,
-0.7173136472702026,
-0.6890542507171631,
-0.5599226951599121,
-0.575813353061676,
0.741028904914856,
0.5284101963043213,
0.12396681308746338,
0.04990244284272194,
0.37142011523246765,
0.3618466556072235,
0.29912400245666504,
-0.5977334976196289,
-0.33620283007621765,
0.15349769592285156,
-0.13202250003814697,
-0.3433568477630615,
-0.2546274662017822,
-0.10332203656435013,
-0.15165182948112488,
0.9194452166557312,
-0.1425536572933197,
0.3134978413581848,
0.028948236256837845,
-0.1521589607000351,
0.05001353099942207,
0.2961113452911377,
0.5282700061798096,
0.44867250323295593,
-0.4004764258861542,
-0.016400067135691643,
0.19375579059123993,
-0.846443772315979,
0.41234588623046875,
-0.07631991058588028,
-0.11877019703388214,
-0.14062689244747162,
0.03491372615098953,
0.5661451816558838,
0.35964876413345337,
-0.8036890029907227,
0.2693902254104614,
-0.4751070439815521,
-0.3020394444465637,
-0.3478813171386719,
0.38853612542152405,
0.30635812878608704,
0.30637437105178833,
-0.04949234426021576,
0.03082285076379776,
0.3174000382423401,
-0.7343321442604065,
0.30648213624954224,
0.4794187545776367,
-0.3669258654117584,
-0.2542271912097931,
0.5784956812858582,
0.001019159099087119,
-0.710600733757019,
0.35809677839279175,
-0.37094131112098694,
-0.4360177218914032,
0.5784456729888916,
0.6960330009460449,
0.8469221591949463,
-0.4751274585723877,
0.5087660551071167,
0.18751585483551025,
0.18986445665359497,
-0.15912309288978577,
0.4992157220840454,
-0.04177366569638252,
-0.75665682554245,
-0.4512677490711212,
-0.7849861979484558,
-0.9147117733955383,
0.2551952004432678,
-0.5812267661094666,
0.3236173689365387,
-0.222227081656456,
-0.3264349102973938,
0.07698222249746323,
-0.0788002759218216,
-0.4598577618598938,
-0.19251088798046112,
0.11639562249183655,
0.7052489519119263,
-0.513455867767334,
0.8210863471031189,
0.7581219673156738,
-0.3645516335964203,
-0.795149564743042,
0.28150317072868347,
0.08177772909402847,
-0.714011549949646,
0.9965015649795532,
0.2730163633823395,
-0.6023110151290894,
0.026396863162517548,
-0.578397810459137,
-0.6499236226081848,
0.8831917643547058,
0.3423163592815399,
-0.9944435358047485,
0.5281083583831787,
0.1761908233165741,
0.21835684776306152,
-0.24833282828330994,
0.3004443049430847,
0.8148206472396851,
0.8641780614852905,
0.13006238639354706,
-0.9819310903549194,
-0.04486459493637085,
-0.2614859938621521,
0.12650646269321442,
0.331857830286026,
-0.5272717475891113,
0.4199356436729431,
-0.3410361111164093,
0.06445521116256714,
0.11679383367300034,
0.4899350106716156,
0.6967256665229797,
0.09207216650247574,
0.5142551064491272,
0.14843358099460602,
1.044555425643921,
0.10298836976289749,
1.0353726148605347,
-0.1740236133337021,
0.14255736768245697,
0.9140155911445618,
-0.44381484389305115,
0.9262908101081848,
0.3711880147457123,
-0.5053041577339172,
0.48457247018814087,
0.5078231692314148,
0.18302218616008759,
0.09035703539848328,
0.42892441153526306,
-0.12394028902053833,
-0.02616552822291851,
-0.016086166724562645,
-0.04210466518998146,
0.5643925070762634,
0.34063515067100525,
0.034382715821266174,
0.32708069682121277,
0.36225536465644836,
0.2851704955101013,
-0.14711947739124298,
-0.19324800372123718,
0.6611020565032959,
0.3218284547328949,
-0.34256547689437866,
0.20023572444915771,
-0.07786501199007034,
0.859779417514801,
-0.7855316996574402,
0.1549602448940277,
-0.33260470628738403,
0.29552870988845825,
-0.1581377238035202,
-0.8804112672805786,
0.30088865756988525,
0.026592111214995384,
-0.06148152053356171,
0.10525402426719666,
0.8213858008384705,
-0.19684094190597534,
-0.7443845272064209,
0.4775192439556122,
0.46778568625450134,
0.3928292989730835,
0.09589307010173798,
-0.5207505822181702,
0.13597983121871948,
-0.19030365347862244,
-0.49456435441970825,
0.3240407109260559,
0.23341740667819977,
-0.1446872055530548,
1.1037460565567017,
0.8881687521934509,
-0.009299161843955517,
-0.37037307024002075,
0.2939004600048065,
0.6214808225631714,
-0.8335098028182983,
-0.38391196727752686,
-1.078147053718567,
0.1865607053041458,
0.2577674388885498,
-0.15869514644145966,
0.7561387419700623,
0.6465249061584473,
0.44515544176101685,
-0.05480482056736946,
0.8298205137252808,
0.07958536595106125,
0.26434436440467834,
-0.3474981188774109,
0.3618105947971344,
-0.34121859073638916,
0.20131176710128784,
-0.5522860884666443,
-1.0634405612945557,
-0.3681486248970032,
0.5746813416481018,
-0.21226531267166138,
0.08518519997596741,
0.46961772441864014,
1.1632676124572754,
-0.34623628854751587,
0.34681376814842224,
0.3981333076953888,
0.3482014238834381,
0.35172054171562195,
0.15333521366119385,
1.0520241260528564,
0.09442014247179031,
0.5768619179725647,
-0.03290153294801712,
-0.20645487308502197,
-0.23099203407764435,
-0.9869695901870728,
-1.021119475364685,
-0.19997285306453705,
-0.365945965051651,
-0.1554727405309677,
0.3339815139770508,
1.1347097158432007,
0.5928399562835693,
-0.6390092968940735,
-0.514397919178009,
-0.019460855051875114,
-0.3409097492694855,
-0.40286725759506226,
-0.2245510071516037,
-0.11829642206430435,
-0.2254963368177414,
-0.5649803280830383,
0.25628724694252014,
0.3056316077709198,
0.09405048936605453,
-0.5615657567977905,
-0.42661476135253906,
0.15797343850135803,
0.38926786184310913,
0.7565338611602783,
0.22676552832126617,
-0.4869946837425232,
-0.3031909763813019,
0.009414833039045334,
0.07087910920381546,
0.13820435106754303,
0.8542876243591309,
-0.7956481575965881,
-0.002736620372161269,
0.21065934002399445,
0.2852720618247986,
0.7858770489692688,
0.02744651958346367,
0.7012625932693481,
-0.5818805694580078,
0.08689680695533752,
0.09320477396249771,
0.3226569890975952,
0.3689779043197632,
-0.25258201360702515,
0.556596577167511,
-0.23934194445610046,
-0.7330134510993958,
-0.9050363302230835,
0.4137665033340454,
-1.1437352895736694,
-0.3258441388607025,
1.4209606647491455,
0.17908039689064026,
-0.3937453031539917,
-0.028246672824025154,
-0.8789636492729187,
0.08499976992607117,
-0.7903585433959961,
0.6694897413253784,
0.8246899843215942,
-0.31058502197265625,
-0.24693791568279266,
-1.1224308013916016,
0.21396081149578094,
-0.006280079949647188,
-0.8606496453285217,
0.234968900680542,
0.26359349489212036,
0.4799712896347046,
-0.01291651651263237,
0.5355272889137268,
-0.23816365003585815,
0.029023030772805214,
-0.24588331580162048,
0.40124353766441345,
-0.3207515776157379,
-0.09641183912754059,
-0.2843504548072815,
-0.2488241195678711,
0.037773504853248596,
-0.1556115299463272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07490v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07490v1
|
Strategic Data Ordering: Enhancing Large Language Model Performance through Curriculum Learning
| 2024-05-13T06:09:10 | 2024-05-13T06:09:10 |
Jisu Kim, Juhwan Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has improved text
understanding and generation but poses challenges in computational resources.
This study proposes a curriculum learning-inspired, data-centric training
strategy that begins with simpler tasks and progresses to more complex ones,
using criteria such as prompt length, attention scores, and loss values to
structure the training data. Experiments with Mistral-7B (Jiang et al., 2023)
and Gemma-7B (Team et al., 2024) models demonstrate that curriculum learning
slightly improves performance compared to traditional random data shuffling.
Notably, we observed that sorting data based on our proposed attention criteria
generally led to better performance. This approach offers a sustainable method
to enhance LLM performance without increasing model size or dataset volume,
addressing scalability challenges in LLM training.
|
[
-0.2341812252998352,
-0.6575489640235901,
0.5529909729957581,
0.0774475485086441,
-0.22174516320228577,
0.3007126748561859,
-0.34595003724098206,
-0.2494874745607376,
-0.07396336644887924,
0.7581218481063843,
-0.5985066890716553,
-0.7278493642807007,
-0.7043498754501343,
-0.17977026104927063,
-0.43597301840782166,
0.8778787851333618,
0.30760571360588074,
0.41565126180648804,
-0.2038833051919937,
-0.16820932924747467,
-0.5497117638587952,
-0.6103349924087524,
-0.9806671142578125,
-0.38273677229881287,
0.7613785862922668,
0.7772074341773987,
0.6543601751327515,
1.4150385856628418,
0.6177400946617126,
0.3166731595993042,
-0.018805554136633873,
0.2484413981437683,
-0.9379189014434814,
0.31014636158943176,
-0.1496158242225647,
-0.6752143502235413,
-0.4489358961582184,
-0.06231899932026863,
0.6222904920578003,
0.9374675154685974,
-0.378032386302948,
0.1998816728591919,
-0.051701851189136505,
1.019307255744934,
-0.4794280529022217,
0.46110132336616516,
-0.6797617673873901,
-0.005017516203224659,
-0.44864529371261597,
-0.3174331784248352,
-0.7788816094398499,
-0.24072885513305664,
0.3297877311706543,
-0.44315269589424133,
0.08406656235456467,
0.3187551498413086,
0.5548762679100037,
0.07838869094848633,
-0.2760683298110962,
-0.3486958146095276,
-0.670299768447876,
1.1140389442443848,
-0.2006411850452423,
0.5862615704536438,
0.19223740696907043,
0.3447827994823456,
-0.11072005331516266,
-0.6352001428604126,
-0.13032266497612,
0.19534365832805634,
0.44580790400505066,
0.2315736562013626,
0.3051178753376007,
0.02777082286775112,
0.23357674479484558,
0.2523745000362396,
-0.8183363080024719,
0.5032007694244385,
-0.5020431876182556,
0.300667405128479,
0.6249427199363708,
0.5532597899436951,
0.03107783943414688,
0.16984452307224274,
-0.16151393949985504,
-0.4236868619918823,
-0.9718448519706726,
-0.008924084715545177,
0.26150643825531006,
0.4944689869880676,
-0.022625336423516273,
0.49458810687065125,
-0.39093661308288574,
0.6139124631881714,
0.0682450532913208,
-0.20945799350738525,
0.22881078720092773,
-0.16914041340351105,
-0.28715506196022034,
0.27017390727996826,
0.3857593238353729,
0.1390085369348526,
0.1779565066099167,
-0.18370294570922852,
-0.3225613534450531,
-0.07861258089542389,
0.5413434505462646,
-0.8076496124267578,
-0.4049953818321228,
-0.01838652417063713,
-0.32812342047691345,
-0.44462308287620544,
-0.15605704486370087,
-0.8249574303627014,
-0.3068194091320038,
-0.8353611826896667,
0.19658319652080536,
-0.5201220512390137,
0.2632986009120941,
0.3097268044948578,
0.4076961278915405,
0.3110409080982208,
0.5447000861167908,
-1.2686643600463867,
0.34306856989860535,
0.8365939855575562,
0.6603230834007263,
-0.5792409777641296,
-0.0315641388297081,
-0.37000101804733276,
0.16054315865039825,
-0.49145936965942383,
0.649898111820221,
-0.6760057806968689,
-0.17691345512866974,
-0.05074338614940643,
-0.2569947838783264,
-0.04849466681480408,
-0.6251152753829956,
0.4109647572040558,
-0.907149076461792,
0.3257004916667938,
-0.3052446246147156,
-0.5663575530052185,
-0.34419530630111694,
0.007979536429047585,
-0.7298642992973328,
1.0920783281326294,
-0.14206168055534363,
-0.48720961809158325,
0.5118243098258972,
-0.27020207047462463,
-0.4487239122390747,
0.13936105370521545,
-0.30818089842796326,
-0.5401002764701843,
-0.13964766263961792,
0.2863927483558655,
0.8402584195137024,
-0.554610550403595,
0.34730467200279236,
-0.2107066661119461,
-0.3524814248085022,
0.02391112968325615,
-0.4276883006095886,
0.7544260025024414,
0.37112072110176086,
-0.2058805227279663,
0.06193070113658905,
-0.8137496709823608,
0.1630159616470337,
0.32687023282051086,
-0.4588386118412018,
-0.2786839008331299,
0.22906894981861115,
-0.03194700554013252,
0.2117742896080017,
0.09044861793518066,
-0.000019315923054818995,
0.3190215229988098,
-0.5119951367378235,
0.14136892557144165,
0.8789479732513428,
-0.1363842785358429,
0.7950360774993896,
-0.5988438129425049,
0.3796069025993347,
0.07578330487012863,
0.05418606474995613,
-0.08329781889915466,
-0.40883898735046387,
-0.9708213210105896,
-0.21366563439369202,
0.07285772264003754,
0.5411584973335266,
-0.7359134554862976,
0.1661294400691986,
-0.5176811814308167,
-0.6317203044891357,
-0.456385999917984,
0.4191073775291443,
0.3204377293586731,
0.339868426322937,
0.42554226517677307,
-0.5273964405059814,
-0.4960552155971527,
-0.7108121514320374,
0.13733303546905518,
-0.11180435121059418,
0.21662667393684387,
0.2910289764404297,
0.09134815633296967,
-0.11672110110521317,
0.6042397618293762,
-0.7673764824867249,
0.0026091255713254213,
-0.7170636057853699,
0.09556980431079865,
0.35356447100639343,
0.2680920660495758,
0.39528515934944153,
-0.7745575904846191,
-0.34241238236427307,
-0.09202734380960464,
-0.5243762731552124,
-0.07028868794441223,
-0.165694922208786,
-0.26574721932411194,
0.22203846275806427,
0.4956204295158386,
-0.4150804281234741,
0.046155113726854324,
0.26749610900878906,
0.33397603034973145,
0.47168800234794617,
-0.009988604113459587,
-0.017623038962483406,
-1.02164626121521,
-0.30623123049736023,
-0.23558302223682404,
0.04027885943651199,
-0.6468070149421692,
0.00947052426636219,
0.056038957089185715,
-0.015214458107948303,
-0.345150887966156,
0.3655480742454529,
-0.40224123001098633,
0.024315761402249336,
-0.06589304655790329,
0.021755805239081383,
-0.17284010350704193,
0.4722583591938019,
0.27215489745140076,
0.7190464735031128,
0.689822256565094,
-0.7026249170303345,
0.1604921668767929,
0.14124082028865814,
-0.6479543447494507,
0.42031583189964294,
-0.3389637768268585,
0.05553099885582924,
-0.33374083042144775,
-0.01978340372443199,
-0.9906900525093079,
-0.2361334264278412,
-0.1320158839225769,
-0.20999492704868317,
0.6513167023658752,
0.13630487024784088,
-0.5349711179733276,
-0.16129176318645477,
-0.21261273324489594,
0.44031602144241333,
0.436691015958786,
-0.5714626312255859,
0.1534401774406433,
0.3930351734161377,
-0.32108309864997864,
-0.44027405977249146,
-0.5256069302558899,
-0.04861238971352577,
-0.5276374220848083,
-0.43963485956192017,
0.34396666288375854,
-0.19348731637001038,
-0.2002285271883011,
-0.5947572588920593,
0.005021337419748306,
-0.19354146718978882,
0.15410055220127106,
0.1966547966003418,
0.31784480810165405,
-0.3178076446056366,
0.2787679135799408,
-0.04054785519838333,
-0.06044508516788483,
0.07582147419452667,
-0.37689298391342163,
0.581868588924408,
0.3387933075428009,
-0.04386543110013008,
-0.1382448673248291,
0.19723103940486908,
0.71075040102005,
-0.28339099884033203,
0.9024120569229126,
0.1978938728570938,
-0.12889790534973145,
-0.6711618900299072,
-0.5574551224708557,
-0.1654929220676422,
-0.5631975531578064,
0.49857327342033386,
-0.12544205784797668,
-0.8254845142364502,
0.25227347016334534,
-0.10173728317022324,
0.3194904029369354,
-0.0075285714119672775,
0.7672424912452698,
-0.04410207271575928,
1.1903202533721924,
0.7059381604194641,
-0.3790542185306549,
0.8671354651451111,
-0.2324080467224121,
0.14871995151042938,
-0.41130855679512024,
-0.3570382297039032,
-0.3337549865245819,
-0.19362981617450714,
-0.5328089594841003,
-0.5872853994369507,
0.21637417376041412,
-0.17539775371551514,
-0.6181997060775757,
0.2318798303604126,
-0.4579866826534271,
0.5648847222328186,
0.39986616373062134,
0.24261033535003662,
0.2204868048429489,
0.390934556722641,
-0.1946844905614853,
-0.12075472623109818,
-1.0107868909835815,
-0.4184716045856476,
1.3227648735046387,
0.2834220826625824,
1.032996654510498,
0.12925934791564941,
0.8711307048797607,
-0.16953249275684357,
0.3007059395313263,
-0.8269193768501282,
0.7907612919807434,
-0.1771622896194458,
-0.3077014982700348,
-0.31418153643608093,
-0.5713881254196167,
-1.093998908996582,
0.15443570911884308,
-0.13097329437732697,
-0.6117001175880432,
-0.1764872670173645,
-0.30010759830474854,
-0.2088758945465088,
-0.07524167746305466,
-0.635821521282196,
0.49244415760040283,
-0.3830462396144867,
-0.5026476979255676,
-0.39598774909973145,
-0.5553627610206604,
0.2989538311958313,
-0.20175565779209137,
0.1495991349220276,
0.1262260228395462,
0.05311579629778862,
0.9279735684394836,
-0.05103366822004318,
0.661505937576294,
0.20380772650241852,
0.10463634133338928,
0.25990912318229675,
0.20191696286201477,
0.4199509024620056,
-0.06748434901237488,
-0.24931159615516663,
-0.14014369249343872,
-0.5043449997901917,
-0.398509681224823,
-0.5381476283073425,
0.7123568654060364,
-0.8929645419120789,
-0.7246784567832947,
-0.28248855471611023,
-0.8111194372177124,
-0.33364760875701904,
0.219578817486763,
0.12275243550539017,
0.35746005177497864,
0.05666642636060715,
0.46418383717536926,
1.015691876411438,
-0.07090451568365097,
0.29518577456474304,
0.5152292847633362,
-0.028507720679044724,
-0.35200265049934387,
0.9343727827072144,
0.5389553308486938,
0.452174574136734,
0.6182904839515686,
-0.05488774552941322,
-0.26052290201187134,
-0.8863431215286255,
-0.24020585417747498,
0.1877886950969696,
-0.8041729927062988,
-0.11826387792825699,
-0.6970363855361938,
-0.2655222713947296,
-0.30526497960090637,
-0.3405057191848755,
-0.4799673557281494,
-0.27773308753967285,
-0.38043904304504395,
-0.15360505878925323,
0.27104121446609497,
0.8842558860778809,
0.5393526554107666,
0.4599006772041321,
-0.5165055394172668,
-0.11839821934700012,
0.0612686388194561,
0.24737630784511566,
0.2914001941680908,
-0.616209089756012,
-0.5665574669837952,
-0.153501495718956,
-0.49895986914634705,
-0.4660031199455261,
0.48313474655151367,
-0.04885955899953842,
0.4623974561691284,
0.4685487151145935,
-0.17303571105003357,
0.9014352560043335,
-0.705146074295044,
0.3946254253387451,
0.008894196711480618,
-0.6126888394355774,
0.4905482828617096,
-0.4362739324569702,
0.45758751034736633,
0.6067397594451904,
0.5504902005195618,
-0.16952557861804962,
-0.3347587287425995,
-0.5442264676094055,
-1.039393424987793,
0.9552832841873169,
0.070394366979599,
-0.04752654209733009,
0.12263026833534241,
0.46994128823280334,
0.028162632137537003,
0.24531912803649902,
-0.5522484183311462,
-0.29675450921058655,
0.3222837448120117,
-0.4030837118625641,
-0.23499517142772675,
-0.12384121119976044,
0.1818251609802246,
-0.3326708972454071,
0.675049901008606,
-0.1450567990541458,
0.12675318121910095,
-0.42967039346694946,
-0.013773434795439243,
0.08258496224880219,
0.06513094902038574,
0.3259681463241577,
0.657331645488739,
-0.03422332927584648,
0.013142328709363937,
0.24945169687271118,
-0.659185528755188,
0.12230638414621353,
-0.3085510730743408,
-0.09115434437990189,
-0.4609682261943817,
0.3972245454788208,
0.5048947334289551,
0.5224488973617554,
-0.6856694221496582,
0.23960870504379272,
0.11222332715988159,
-0.04436596482992172,
0.053175538778305054,
0.42696261405944824,
0.2260095775127411,
0.35669711232185364,
0.22210551798343658,
-0.3997876048088074,
0.08137136697769165,
-0.4425961673259735,
0.42392420768737793,
0.22262220084667206,
-0.12046124041080475,
0.0024942418094724417,
0.5138151049613953,
-0.25704020261764526,
0.02146248146891594,
0.810252845287323,
0.1116267666220665,
-0.2778683006763458,
0.8041762709617615,
0.6522448062896729,
0.49900349974632263,
-0.4846457540988922,
0.24590237438678741,
0.32848408818244934,
0.2626420855522156,
-0.5393717288970947,
0.2947629988193512,
0.018793707713484764,
-0.6139479279518127,
-0.22689378261566162,
-0.6367225050926208,
-0.5069121718406677,
0.13120286166667938,
-0.8227628469467163,
0.6332952380180359,
-0.7005922794342041,
0.11017461121082306,
0.08961701393127441,
0.21589158475399017,
-0.7075669169425964,
0.43963658809661865,
0.3084060251712799,
0.7510398030281067,
-0.5828865170478821,
1.0924204587936401,
0.5121757984161377,
-0.07876989245414734,
-0.8415284156799316,
-0.20234793424606323,
0.151927188038826,
-0.8596404194831848,
0.8776037693023682,
0.31533366441726685,
0.15263384580612183,
0.1730317920446396,
-0.5358437895774841,
-1.2109296321868896,
1.3148919343948364,
0.3070496916770935,
-0.7841815948486328,
0.032116543501615524,
0.2599217891693115,
0.5306681990623474,
-0.5146468281745911,
0.2103210985660553,
0.2926044166088104,
0.03323127329349518,
0.4499203860759735,
-0.25864410400390625,
-0.17371077835559845,
0.17153377830982208,
0.004268101882189512,
0.21941091120243073,
-0.745227575302124,
0.7759349942207336,
-0.2363126128911972,
-0.3169485032558441,
-0.030486872419714928,
0.8562244176864624,
0.24932098388671875,
0.26076123118400574,
0.17576000094413757,
0.584503173828125,
0.9127514362335205,
-0.0650743767619133,
0.7934523820877075,
-0.15692362189292908,
0.35759615898132324,
1.273777961730957,
-0.6871172189712524,
0.8722338676452637,
0.27441906929016113,
-0.10270904004573822,
0.30246973037719727,
0.9327725768089294,
-0.021157260984182358,
0.7415902614593506,
0.2839789092540741,
-0.03368907421827316,
-0.3484458923339844,
-0.06106099486351013,
-0.003980225883424282,
0.5022399425506592,
0.5771321654319763,
-0.37195518612861633,
-0.37662407755851746,
-0.04665815830230713,
-0.0558079332113266,
-0.024396585300564766,
-0.36861878633499146,
0.7117159366607666,
0.050295423716306686,
-0.5637795925140381,
0.5704097747802734,
0.011549548245966434,
0.24395109713077545,
-0.5609533190727234,
-0.014925052411854267,
-0.10596129298210144,
0.25317224860191345,
0.012481472454965115,
-0.7941485643386841,
0.036309655755758286,
-0.03650125861167908,
-0.4511200189590454,
-0.5813295841217041,
0.1400115042924881,
-0.6230981945991516,
-0.47228679060935974,
0.3820982873439789,
0.4410306513309479,
-0.04260379821062088,
0.3575144410133362,
-0.7411908507347107,
0.17255377769470215,
-0.16840772330760956,
-0.5531324148178101,
0.692253053188324,
0.48447564244270325,
-0.30156001448631287,
0.9302773475646973,
0.6553717851638794,
-0.022365674376487732,
0.05271555855870247,
0.025720398873090744,
0.9731418490409851,
-0.4779485762119293,
-0.5033808946609497,
-0.8316935896873474,
0.10062319785356522,
0.04650412127375603,
-0.03334615007042885,
0.7611212730407715,
0.733207643032074,
0.9674478769302368,
0.11038033664226532,
0.3866504430770874,
0.35722851753234863,
0.30802127718925476,
-0.6967583298683167,
0.6318340301513672,
-0.2640490233898163,
0.5289068222045898,
-0.15186472237110138,
-1.050703763961792,
-0.4947288930416107,
0.46558070182800293,
-0.7086346745491028,
0.09643744677305222,
0.6574240922927856,
0.950653612613678,
-0.06695619225502014,
0.061153095215559006,
0.36255019903182983,
0.25472065806388855,
0.2782304883003235,
0.8097213506698608,
0.46048179268836975,
-0.16288842260837555,
0.3045831024646759,
-0.21911397576332092,
-0.19278715550899506,
-0.22007153928279877,
-0.4572618901729584,
-1.1323633193969727,
-0.5339776277542114,
-0.1630062460899353,
-0.16521146893501282,
0.24300917983055115,
1.1035717725753784,
0.742374062538147,
-0.7312242984771729,
-0.5350562334060669,
-0.18138304352760315,
0.1384771168231964,
-0.08637180179357529,
-0.24011285603046417,
0.4219943583011627,
-0.5318718552589417,
-0.8073124289512634,
0.41777417063713074,
0.3629198372364044,
-0.06737856566905975,
-0.061555568128824234,
-0.009373199194669724,
-0.24283340573310852,
0.25035807490348816,
0.6906237006187439,
-0.0996735692024231,
-0.47152113914489746,
-0.09906209260225296,
0.10508505254983902,
-0.5022242665290833,
0.04916146770119667,
0.7175246477127075,
-0.6915395855903625,
0.43230924010276794,
0.49857792258262634,
0.9859570264816284,
0.41416069865226746,
-0.1380758434534073,
0.41197100281715393,
-0.4754580855369568,
0.010690181516110897,
0.17092645168304443,
0.13721658289432526,
0.07562132924795151,
-0.576812744140625,
0.4660748541355133,
0.19126123189926147,
-0.6066164374351501,
-0.6851036548614502,
0.0837055891752243,
-1.1545034646987915,
-0.10610760748386383,
1.0492256879806519,
0.017474453896284103,
-0.26503786444664,
-0.12604421377182007,
-0.17225635051727295,
0.14115796983242035,
-0.3979528546333313,
0.9511077404022217,
0.8461591005325317,
-0.014004589058458805,
-0.13759447634220123,
-0.8392487168312073,
0.31968769431114197,
0.6944875121116638,
-0.7847366333007812,
0.3078881800174713,
0.35122865438461304,
0.15783965587615967,
-0.1030639037489891,
0.33166345953941345,
-0.1703198403120041,
0.1792173981666565,
-0.3690072298049927,
-0.3025447428226471,
0.18050150573253632,
-0.9050610065460205,
-0.3773750066757202,
0.27136966586112976,
-0.019305294379591942,
0.09584379941225052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07468v1
|
Evaluating large language models in medical applications: a survey
| 2024-05-13T05:08:33 | 2024-05-13T05:08:33 |
Xiaolan Chen, Jiayang Xiang, Shanfu Lu, Yexin Liu, Mingguang He, Danli Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools with
transformative potential across numerous domains, including healthcare and
medicine. In the medical domain, LLMs hold promise for tasks ranging from
clinical decision support to patient education. However, evaluating the
performance of LLMs in medical contexts presents unique challenges due to the
complex and critical nature of medical information. This paper provides a
comprehensive overview of the landscape of medical LLM evaluation, synthesizing
insights from existing studies and highlighting evaluation data sources, task
scenarios, and evaluation methods. Additionally, it identifies key challenges
and opportunities in medical LLM evaluation, emphasizing the need for continued
research and innovation to ensure the responsible integration of LLMs into
clinical practice.
|
[
-0.028144272044301033,
-0.7482526302337646,
1.0726768970489502,
0.19593670964241028,
-0.1791185736656189,
0.1878051608800888,
-0.5189523696899414,
-0.6195175051689148,
-0.08784846216440201,
0.6339971423149109,
-0.46653276681900024,
-0.5080141425132751,
-1.0834881067276,
0.1794712096452713,
-0.37162885069847107,
0.6608114242553711,
-0.16366298496723175,
0.7107536196708679,
-0.556821346282959,
-0.254695326089859,
-0.5445605516433716,
-0.8235629796981812,
-0.7311750054359436,
-0.6721301674842834,
0.36777636408805847,
0.041365284472703934,
0.5525559782981873,
0.43723225593566895,
0.9448009133338928,
0.36807572841644287,
-0.18258358538150787,
0.11402368545532227,
-0.4538098871707916,
0.27626845240592957,
-0.257769912481308,
-0.3104267120361328,
-0.3683648109436035,
0.07252508401870728,
0.940808117389679,
1.2581868171691895,
-0.21532264351844788,
0.09140311181545258,
-0.13088421523571014,
0.6615853309631348,
-0.3989470303058624,
0.06625349074602127,
-0.3630680739879608,
0.07435864955186844,
-0.2479349672794342,
-0.19228070974349976,
-0.3017347753047943,
-0.42699915170669556,
0.49394336342811584,
-0.04909484460949898,
-0.3657960593700409,
-0.0583597868680954,
0.5366665124893188,
0.07796549797058105,
-0.6454887390136719,
-0.6547409296035767,
-0.8629060983657837,
0.8585675954818726,
-0.721161961555481,
0.5513965487480164,
-0.03534838557243347,
0.5216274261474609,
-0.5019087791442871,
-0.7497814297676086,
-0.25380221009254456,
-0.47996580600738525,
0.31135502457618713,
-0.07919852435588837,
-0.20176716148853302,
0.06841030716896057,
0.013475076295435429,
0.6385484933853149,
-0.4277903437614441,
0.6867780089378357,
-0.3263508975505829,
0.06872989237308502,
0.6391593813896179,
0.8257498145103455,
0.5883851051330566,
-0.12379699945449829,
-0.13688434660434723,
0.2794566750526428,
-0.7345462441444397,
-0.33438175916671753,
-0.15072743594646454,
0.07096432149410248,
-0.1901663839817047,
0.7321955561637878,
0.19970673322677612,
0.7579175233840942,
-0.41239163279533386,
-0.49087977409362793,
0.17560246586799622,
-0.1862647384405136,
-0.49357929825782776,
-0.3736918866634369,
0.9919608235359192,
0.3961227536201477,
-0.026588963344693184,
-0.15021869540214539,
-0.2312748283147812,
-0.07047006487846375,
0.22267763316631317,
-0.7347815036773682,
0.2650795876979828,
0.38706788420677185,
-0.7263283133506775,
-0.11137387901544571,
-0.30443090200424194,
-0.7434420585632324,
-0.958859920501709,
-0.3328253924846649,
0.21680326759815216,
-0.25179725885391235,
-0.25149422883987427,
0.4190961420536041,
0.13650444149971008,
0.30316290259361267,
0.5532452464103699,
-0.6077475547790527,
0.43100878596305847,
0.9177429676055908,
0.7757889628410339,
-0.44823670387268066,
0.014905002899467945,
-0.10345083475112915,
-0.12921810150146484,
-0.4417043924331665,
0.5438893437385559,
-0.6682234406471252,
-0.6584923267364502,
0.23921728134155273,
0.08802630752325058,
-0.2777010202407837,
-0.9744283556938171,
0.5708479881286621,
-0.3189503252506256,
-0.07240018993616104,
-0.10076071321964264,
-0.6832010746002197,
-0.018077604472637177,
0.41509485244750977,
-0.6663913726806641,
0.5983502268791199,
0.20551329851150513,
-0.40023744106292725,
0.20316101610660553,
-0.6714622378349304,
-0.5459294319152832,
0.3039589822292328,
-0.424063116312027,
-0.39517465233802795,
0.37392401695251465,
-0.07895785570144653,
0.5649939179420471,
-1.069762110710144,
0.4019375443458557,
-0.1985333412885666,
-0.23481695353984833,
0.5049303770065308,
-0.3876149654388428,
0.6695778965950012,
0.31157368421554565,
-0.029917918145656586,
0.3574979603290558,
-0.5946552157402039,
-0.07401498407125473,
0.2726104259490967,
-0.5007597208023071,
-0.26121148467063904,
0.1426061987876892,
0.2739052176475525,
0.1973348706960678,
0.22364792227745056,
-0.3365879952907562,
0.30274736881256104,
-0.4407576620578766,
0.6000211834907532,
0.3914420008659363,
0.08153384178876877,
0.11775627732276917,
-0.23166191577911377,
0.9602834582328796,
-0.23701803386211395,
0.302955687046051,
-0.0023540575057268143,
-0.4309594929218292,
-0.29277434945106506,
-0.3889470398426056,
0.31248417496681213,
0.38971829414367676,
-0.45938578248023987,
0.16735787689685822,
-0.36507073044776917,
-0.7678444385528564,
-0.7278275489807129,
0.18834494054317474,
0.28651079535484314,
0.29958850145339966,
-0.061198052018880844,
-0.10675952583551407,
-0.44501298666000366,
-0.9991267323493958,
-0.28092774748802185,
-0.018149591982364655,
0.023201223462820053,
0.5845189094543457,
0.5301607847213745,
-0.7991927266120911,
0.5000652074813843,
-0.24792297184467316,
-0.26151445508003235,
-0.5971817374229431,
-0.1557360738515854,
0.3587813079357147,
0.2888597548007965,
0.4110141098499298,
-0.6680053472518921,
-0.11552252620458603,
0.24412889778614044,
-0.8375837206840515,
-0.2011135071516037,
-0.039817340672016144,
0.35914477705955505,
-0.0918826311826706,
0.4244758188724518,
-0.5722355246543884,
-0.10788857191801071,
0.8661704063415527,
-0.18507066369056702,
0.6194449663162231,
-0.2391226440668106,
0.34171780943870544,
-0.7539617419242859,
0.2058483213186264,
0.07192713022232056,
-0.23992857336997986,
-0.47251731157302856,
0.13521571457386017,
-0.04100434482097626,
-0.044876281172037125,
-0.4230163097381592,
0.8799918293952942,
-0.5792157649993896,
-0.10452961921691895,
-0.3141287565231323,
0.2511153519153595,
-0.282615065574646,
-0.4442436695098877,
-0.21344976127147675,
0.4358770549297333,
0.5865771174430847,
-0.3484133780002594,
0.5484791398048401,
0.1056673675775528,
-0.803834855556488,
0.35264480113983154,
-0.6907645463943481,
-0.05472661927342415,
-0.024710306897759438,
0.21315898001194,
-0.8000891804695129,
-0.32098162174224854,
0.033488646149635315,
-0.06594804674386978,
0.4765525162220001,
-0.05883132666349411,
-0.6779739856719971,
-0.6554150581359863,
-0.1701635718345642,
0.552187442779541,
0.4903135895729065,
-0.23104242980480194,
0.3566809892654419,
0.6722105145454407,
-0.2865898609161377,
-0.36735987663269043,
-0.4429952800273895,
0.48722127079963684,
-0.20592942833900452,
-0.5347021222114563,
0.015187175944447517,
-0.024462159723043442,
-0.6005508899688721,
-0.2630217373371124,
-0.028092896565794945,
0.05817168578505516,
0.25395721197128296,
0.41031405329704285,
0.5103060603141785,
-0.17472054064273834,
0.11464111506938934,
-0.05200501158833504,
0.08715611696243286,
0.30430516600608826,
-0.014290367253124714,
0.4508049190044403,
-0.06692004203796387,
-0.577540934085846,
-0.222037211060524,
0.2686905562877655,
0.9080986380577087,
-0.007477339822798967,
0.6688981056213379,
0.21258816123008728,
-0.6228483319282532,
0.08281822502613068,
-0.7978175282478333,
0.08179774135351181,
-0.35201936960220337,
0.8235182166099548,
-0.10789918899536133,
-1.1006134748458862,
0.3482731580734253,
-0.5198255181312561,
-0.07274290919303894,
0.5061121582984924,
1.1143136024475098,
0.06410916894674301,
1.0146551132202148,
0.47845304012298584,
0.07387344539165497,
0.031016424298286438,
-0.05552970618009567,
0.21565324068069458,
-0.9252027273178101,
-0.5683131217956543,
-0.38637879490852356,
-0.037940412759780884,
-0.4500572383403778,
-0.5953841209411621,
0.683279812335968,
-0.11814343184232712,
0.15994982421398163,
-0.255296528339386,
-0.2558143436908722,
0.1799362152814865,
-0.26185330748558044,
0.08113312721252441,
0.3671012222766876,
-0.3109959065914154,
-0.08642496913671494,
-0.09512116760015488,
-0.5616324543952942,
-0.8050191402435303,
1.0884169340133667,
0.9043192863464355,
0.9176123738288879,
0.040139004588127136,
0.2918928563594818,
0.21774864196777344,
0.686511218547821,
-1.1245238780975342,
0.5477736592292786,
-0.40914011001586914,
-0.584504246711731,
-0.3220008313655853,
-0.3807084560394287,
-1.0813943147659302,
0.301031231880188,
-0.3011372685432434,
-0.7636432647705078,
-0.34462442994117737,
-0.263913094997406,
-0.3308560848236084,
0.11677610129117966,
-0.5248622894287109,
0.8190619349479675,
-0.41507062315940857,
-0.11780746281147003,
-0.22516071796417236,
-0.45021307468414307,
0.5286834836006165,
-0.4392560124397278,
0.4853096008300781,
-0.2059624344110489,
-0.1280999481678009,
0.7854523658752441,
-0.23981083929538727,
0.6953314542770386,
0.030215634033083916,
-0.32791978120803833,
0.050185926258563995,
-0.057045258581638336,
0.039852388203144073,
-0.007712564896792173,
-0.13018865883350372,
0.31990790367126465,
0.3042910695075989,
-0.1056220680475235,
-0.5062273144721985,
0.9694858193397522,
-0.5262976884841919,
-0.7504482269287109,
-0.4150403141975403,
-0.6140196323394775,
-0.6440014839172363,
0.08854400366544724,
-0.042448800057172775,
0.3328777253627777,
-0.43431970477104187,
0.18754856288433075,
0.4385416507720947,
-0.6941229104995728,
0.16474775969982147,
0.5350569486618042,
-0.5259078741073608,
-0.2068903148174286,
0.5408608913421631,
-0.035798292607069016,
0.23063306510448456,
0.09458069503307343,
0.29255351424217224,
-0.43140512704849243,
-1.1645519733428955,
-0.46535778045654297,
0.5141608119010925,
-0.7740591764450073,
0.08329159021377563,
-0.5576844811439514,
-0.274374395608902,
-0.18253293633460999,
-0.001850492088124156,
-0.41241034865379333,
-0.05071429908275604,
-0.13935497403144836,
0.10567023605108261,
0.08041269332170486,
1.2964012622833252,
0.3616943061351776,
0.21247978508472443,
-0.9381342530250549,
0.13571669161319733,
-0.02759394608438015,
0.6644430160522461,
0.0574781708419323,
-0.35789814591407776,
-0.24511736631393433,
-0.3321790397167206,
-0.09015259146690369,
-0.715038537979126,
0.28542402386665344,
-0.10041294246912003,
0.7781874537467957,
0.4205988943576813,
-0.5321943759918213,
0.5583856105804443,
-0.9031957387924194,
0.8503491282463074,
0.4217040538787842,
-0.6461156010627747,
0.2643181085586548,
-0.25468575954437256,
0.24081090092658997,
0.3744567334651947,
0.5918504595756531,
-0.629407525062561,
-0.21534329652786255,
-0.07839417457580566,
-0.8271291851997375,
0.22368837893009186,
-0.02855142392218113,
0.2630060911178589,
-0.07292293757200241,
0.4308100640773773,
0.18616001307964325,
0.07836272567510605,
-0.4790201783180237,
-0.11182966828346252,
0.7013919949531555,
-0.23523451387882233,
-0.11694250255823135,
-0.4194100797176361,
-0.17140333354473114,
-0.17879576981067657,
0.21490134298801422,
0.1683119535446167,
0.08743219077587128,
0.13895092904567719,
-0.10564380884170532,
-0.14736567437648773,
0.5376845002174377,
0.6424471139907837,
0.994850754737854,
0.06099652126431465,
-0.08324845880270004,
0.18893402814865112,
-0.5087884068489075,
0.12092143297195435,
-0.08386388421058655,
0.31864556670188904,
-0.03596510365605354,
0.6424665451049805,
0.5800508856773376,
0.3825145661830902,
-1.2167119979858398,
0.6502629518508911,
-0.003241760190576315,
-0.09060416370630264,
-0.23966149985790253,
-0.11296620965003967,
0.3196968734264374,
0.3011031448841095,
0.2980509102344513,
-0.4346514642238617,
0.24209055304527283,
-0.7458329200744629,
-0.08384696394205093,
0.6978933811187744,
-0.3796687424182892,
-0.16101621091365814,
0.540057897567749,
-0.004331495612859726,
-0.23850353062152863,
0.3934497535228729,
0.34933334589004517,
-0.36974072456359863,
0.5700075030326843,
0.6649448275566101,
0.7058882713317871,
-0.34199658036231995,
-0.29612842202186584,
0.0066976649686694145,
0.27387943863868713,
-0.07377663254737854,
0.34575945138931274,
0.5682514309883118,
-0.44506821036338806,
-0.6282077431678772,
-0.7625200152397156,
-0.5715487003326416,
0.5447251796722412,
-0.3365876078605652,
0.3464585244655609,
-0.4551613926887512,
-0.4208705425262451,
0.18458417057991028,
-0.22714024782180786,
-0.7073236703872681,
0.35497626662254333,
0.3204222619533539,
0.8243931531906128,
-0.4870455861091614,
0.7622429728507996,
0.8995327949523926,
0.021920597180724144,
-0.3150801360607147,
-0.34019577503204346,
0.20449194312095642,
-0.8955782651901245,
0.7544569373130798,
0.032164882868528366,
-0.06924966722726822,
-0.5250191688537598,
-0.34421196579933167,
-0.4540480971336365,
0.7752559781074524,
0.4000745713710785,
-0.7780202031135559,
-0.28381872177124023,
0.3029076159000397,
0.8044491410255432,
-0.6505518555641174,
0.3244003355503082,
0.7550022006034851,
0.4845140278339386,
-0.052454859018325806,
-1.2592865228652954,
0.1214841827750206,
-0.17534379661083221,
0.16407163441181183,
0.15042023360729218,
-0.46877822279930115,
0.5209908485412598,
-0.2847815155982971,
-0.09252871572971344,
0.26137688755989075,
0.04064854979515076,
0.3075132966041565,
0.2570706009864807,
0.33596596121788025,
0.1876937597990036,
0.5181730389595032,
-0.030759647488594055,
1.2913026809692383,
-0.2219412922859192,
0.3463011085987091,
0.7452325820922852,
-0.6512429118156433,
0.7264115214347839,
0.5342928767204285,
-0.4391462504863739,
0.18808117508888245,
0.6804820895195007,
-0.09741059690713882,
-0.09686572104692459,
0.622085452079773,
-0.37822622060775757,
-0.23527762293815613,
-0.23569628596305847,
-0.30138909816741943,
0.5497447848320007,
0.8240240216255188,
-0.6723358035087585,
-0.09381502866744995,
0.18945783376693726,
-0.030549269169569016,
0.11755873262882233,
-0.4401978850364685,
0.6504296660423279,
0.35662296414375305,
-0.37358686327934265,
0.4455777108669281,
0.10609202831983566,
0.3618095815181732,
-0.6355912089347839,
-0.2149842381477356,
0.2859680652618408,
0.09628941118717194,
-0.31803980469703674,
-0.6251271367073059,
0.31377148628234863,
0.06489545106887817,
-0.06795765459537506,
0.014445045962929726,
0.6424987316131592,
-0.10632017999887466,
-0.49427884817123413,
0.5308788418769836,
0.5885739922523499,
0.2700332701206207,
0.20917774736881256,
-0.5748681426048279,
0.6192678809165955,
-0.33475857973098755,
-0.3142639398574829,
0.48837190866470337,
0.4047267735004425,
-0.020665843039751053,
0.9646671414375305,
0.4518823027610779,
0.4429081380367279,
-0.12427008897066116,
0.3157220482826233,
0.7223902940750122,
-0.7868027687072754,
-0.008582713082432747,
-1.1566946506500244,
0.21386457979679108,
0.16761182248592377,
-0.21103976666927338,
0.6543030738830566,
0.5732382535934448,
0.20120568573474884,
-0.1988883912563324,
0.8036649823188782,
0.29878470301628113,
0.5058588981628418,
-0.5221302509307861,
0.9311705231666565,
-0.5229310989379883,
0.48638543486595154,
-0.3448379933834076,
-0.594080924987793,
-0.5191495418548584,
0.2621022164821625,
-0.47104302048683167,
0.14154088497161865,
0.7027138471603394,
0.18657678365707397,
0.20151038467884064,
-0.13816390931606293,
0.6378316879272461,
0.38483527302742004,
0.29595956206321716,
0.5946472883224487,
1.1081491708755493,
-0.17622053623199463,
0.03886096552014351,
0.3058282136917114,
-0.4001595377922058,
-0.3810822367668152,
-0.8598427772521973,
-0.9437983632087708,
-0.36510252952575684,
-0.2712387144565582,
-0.25059831142425537,
-0.046062346547842026,
1.0744578838348389,
0.5870440006256104,
-0.6790316104888916,
-0.42780089378356934,
0.5553424954414368,
0.02094186469912529,
0.10898364335298538,
-0.1956847906112671,
0.31096500158309937,
-0.0868188664317131,
-0.816356360912323,
0.6206870675086975,
0.7407438158988953,
0.005944369826465845,
-0.5339800715446472,
-0.046255748718976974,
-0.021337829530239105,
0.1315692663192749,
0.8907058238983154,
0.07132816314697266,
-0.9383208751678467,
0.006899057887494564,
-0.13597026467323303,
-0.393045037984848,
-0.03774437680840492,
1.0617549419403076,
-0.5054118037223816,
0.4681129455566406,
-0.010448833927512169,
1.1465460062026978,
0.1986304521560669,
-0.48075810074806213,
0.7069758176803589,
0.07139000296592712,
-0.18675297498703003,
0.43207189440727234,
0.6135808825492859,
0.39605894684791565,
-0.22162602841854095,
0.4637342393398285,
-0.006200105883181095,
-0.5870488882064819,
-1.0524358749389648,
0.0036776168271899223,
-1.0787357091903687,
-0.33697137236595154,
1.3015401363372803,
-0.12960714101791382,
-0.029903044924139977,
-0.24163958430290222,
-0.16823607683181763,
0.03200533986091614,
0.20496492087841034,
0.5570447444915771,
0.8842748403549194,
-0.2630811333656311,
-0.05018623173236847,
-1.0956974029541016,
0.33017006516456604,
0.3991048038005829,
-0.8990917205810547,
0.006345272064208984,
0.597745954990387,
0.46914827823638916,
-0.15854407846927643,
0.6578628420829773,
-0.7267543077468872,
0.13468097150325775,
-0.525734543800354,
-0.21452173590660095,
0.22484196722507477,
-0.10447867959737778,
-0.773145318031311,
0.2317381352186203,
0.5100018978118896,
0.23261767625808716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07467v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07467v1
|
MCS-SQL: Leveraging Multiple Prompts and Multiple-Choice Selection For Text-to-SQL Generation
| 2024-05-13T04:59:32 | 2024-05-13T04:59:32 |
Dongjun Lee, Choongwon Park, Jaehyuk Kim, Heesoo Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have enabled in-context
learning (ICL)-based methods that significantly outperform fine-tuning
approaches for text-to-SQL tasks. However, their performance is still
considerably lower than that of human experts on benchmarks that include
complex schemas and queries, such as BIRD. This study considers the sensitivity
of LLMs to the prompts and introduces a novel approach that leverages multiple
prompts to explore a broader search space for possible answers and effectively
aggregate them. Specifically, we robustly refine the database schema through
schema linking using multiple prompts. Thereafter, we generate various
candidate SQL queries based on the refined schema and diverse prompts. Finally,
the candidate queries are filtered based on their confidence scores, and the
optimal query is obtained through a multiple-choice selection that is presented
to the LLM. When evaluated on the BIRD and Spider benchmarks, the proposed
method achieved execution accuracies of 65.5\% and 89.6\%, respectively,
significantly outperforming previous ICL-based methods. Moreover, we
established a new SOTA performance on the BIRD in terms of both the accuracy
and efficiency of the generated queries.
|
[
-0.6005443334579468,
-0.8525565266609192,
0.6948322057723999,
0.05477558821439743,
-0.32032570242881775,
0.04432185739278793,
-0.2596638798713684,
-0.022116001695394516,
0.05013257637619972,
0.54212486743927,
-0.9272128343582153,
-0.5425674319267273,
-0.2031668722629547,
0.7796661853790283,
-0.010311326943337917,
0.8654985427856445,
0.440819650888443,
0.07358153164386749,
-0.41120824217796326,
-0.06070195510983467,
-0.33360084891319275,
-0.5678218007087708,
-0.6764237880706787,
0.3795449733734131,
0.5929829478263855,
0.8330419659614563,
0.23634791374206543,
0.39338862895965576,
0.41547301411628723,
0.16479672491550446,
-0.13746537268161774,
0.7485372424125671,
-0.28460144996643066,
0.6208809614181519,
-0.5158740282058716,
-0.24312780797481537,
-0.0212163757532835,
-0.441098153591156,
0.7248873114585876,
0.5213790535926819,
-0.1743941754102707,
0.2654273808002472,
0.13708534836769104,
0.7923852801322937,
-0.7888655066490173,
-0.11095432937145233,
-1.2493813037872314,
-0.08118885010480881,
-0.3171236217021942,
-0.5594485402107239,
-0.7953747510910034,
-0.1248108446598053,
-0.06674210727214813,
-0.47735029458999634,
0.12800054252147675,
0.37940844893455505,
0.4236588776111603,
0.07943356782197952,
-0.9294233918190002,
-0.702846348285675,
-0.1456998735666275,
0.8902304768562317,
-0.41976356506347656,
0.3906458616256714,
0.09070759266614914,
0.5707716941833496,
-0.43711259961128235,
-0.5606513619422913,
-0.5060842633247375,
-0.5290831327438354,
-0.023576650768518448,
-0.06326756626367569,
0.42747920751571655,
-0.22700822353363037,
0.3450523912906647,
-0.11083843559026718,
-0.450927734375,
-0.01969369500875473,
-0.07568614184856415,
-0.07208000123500824,
0.6185398101806641,
0.3377315104007721,
0.11091887205839157,
-0.34441816806793213,
-0.47916528582572937,
0.06842157989740372,
-0.8490047454833984,
0.14119479060173035,
0.15864774584770203,
1.153656005859375,
0.44680777192115784,
1.0343632698059082,
-0.3226524591445923,
0.9635038375854492,
0.0719149187207222,
-0.22033578157424927,
-0.12132491171360016,
-0.4959854483604431,
-0.000934424577280879,
0.021463783457875252,
0.9385592341423035,
0.293012410402298,
0.00820422824472189,
-0.0696837529540062,
-0.021001778542995453,
-0.03678533062338829,
0.1186559796333313,
-0.6825344562530518,
0.3249022960662842,
0.2648204267024994,
-0.25017818808555603,
-0.235514298081398,
-0.09291855990886688,
-0.7975059747695923,
-0.45066797733306885,
-0.30655962228775024,
-0.04106120020151138,
-0.4504936635494232,
-0.06428810209035873,
-0.35910764336586,
-0.016666335985064507,
0.01881430670619011,
0.2121444195508957,
-0.87336266040802,
0.22198143601417542,
0.2588109076023102,
0.7581550478935242,
-0.4780482053756714,
-0.2670632004737854,
-0.7859275341033936,
0.5804259777069092,
-0.3328191936016083,
0.9227921962738037,
-0.7358755469322205,
-0.5887763500213623,
-0.18884307146072388,
-0.20846539735794067,
-0.18790555000305176,
-0.4043196439743042,
0.3793720602989197,
-0.4757821559906006,
0.10344473272562027,
-0.7972126603126526,
-0.3520541489124298,
0.24948221445083618,
0.3099764585494995,
-0.4525589048862457,
1.2622840404510498,
0.07484433799982071,
-0.8043495416641235,
0.5322664380073547,
-0.7463493943214417,
-0.5692998766899109,
-0.09056754410266876,
-0.5767770409584045,
-0.1812799870967865,
0.12849435210227966,
0.38224753737449646,
0.5707069039344788,
-0.5174993872642517,
0.2736794352531433,
-0.4447273015975952,
-0.298408567905426,
0.30352234840393066,
-0.13403330743312836,
0.6825330853462219,
0.4652434289455414,
-0.1733395904302597,
0.03537615016102791,
-0.768401026725769,
0.07603812962770462,
0.03071868047118187,
-0.5356857776641846,
-0.11351729184389114,
0.08807630091905594,
-0.20834451913833618,
0.5674832463264465,
-0.041207488626241684,
-0.45220133662223816,
0.28489771485328674,
-0.2704000473022461,
0.3059605062007904,
0.5301427245140076,
0.17324985563755035,
0.31114792823791504,
-0.16365718841552734,
0.49539661407470703,
0.26375651359558105,
-0.08377908915281296,
-0.3576664924621582,
-0.2776496112346649,
-0.4141418933868408,
-0.27698948979377747,
-0.15272605419158936,
0.4695945084095001,
-1.0023819208145142,
0.29477229714393616,
-0.13110172748565674,
-0.44639793038368225,
-0.11578631401062012,
-0.08470115065574646,
0.19071027636528015,
0.7155770063400269,
0.48495495319366455,
0.028913799673318863,
-0.45407459139823914,
-0.7073960900306702,
-0.6648725867271423,
-0.028978640213608742,
-0.017374079674482346,
0.9726210236549377,
0.24261067807674408,
0.17319552600383759,
1.1176064014434814,
-0.49726125597953796,
-0.21633337438106537,
-0.10489679872989655,
-0.40667375922203064,
0.15074187517166138,
0.38129258155822754,
0.5156653523445129,
-0.6050022840499878,
-0.6808953285217285,
-0.027676645666360855,
-0.5807955265045166,
0.12031576782464981,
-0.06706886738538742,
-0.10170545428991318,
0.43907126784324646,
0.6964688897132874,
-0.7022521495819092,
0.07956059277057648,
0.008431323803961277,
-0.3274303078651428,
0.7862186431884766,
0.13778439164161682,
0.3012043237686157,
-1.368139386177063,
0.11046330630779266,
0.022991636767983437,
0.08210458606481552,
-0.2778419256210327,
0.1910317838191986,
0.1307484358549118,
-0.23478254675865173,
-0.6208758354187012,
0.39549335837364197,
-0.7395735383033752,
-0.17820468544960022,
0.25022420287132263,
0.4074682891368866,
-0.2133944034576416,
0.2619534134864807,
-0.055817123502492905,
1.120944619178772,
0.6828624606132507,
-0.9674983620643616,
0.0932525172829628,
0.2256368100643158,
-0.08305341005325317,
0.8712640404701233,
-0.2587202489376068,
0.13509486615657806,
-0.20321506261825562,
0.47340288758277893,
-1.2153620719909668,
-0.17919093370437622,
0.07680411636829376,
-0.38352811336517334,
0.20706847310066223,
-0.14182589948177338,
-0.5521618127822876,
-0.2535440921783447,
-0.22737616300582886,
0.07552026957273483,
-0.15166227519512177,
-0.5332524180412292,
0.7924196124076843,
0.1349046677350998,
-0.24959805607795715,
-0.725143313407898,
-0.6562290191650391,
0.26595011353492737,
-0.20603013038635254,
-0.442137748003006,
0.18306255340576172,
-0.2250109165906906,
-0.051886387169361115,
-0.4514690339565277,
-0.12803314626216888,
0.13674688339233398,
-0.00040414350223727524,
-0.025998175144195557,
0.18641047179698944,
-0.2279934138059616,
0.35165202617645264,
0.5038071870803833,
0.08805157244205475,
-0.06560347229242325,
-0.2787679135799408,
0.5864385366439819,
-0.0710792988538742,
-0.4695940613746643,
-0.1461016684770584,
0.5833353996276855,
0.5222490429878235,
-0.3837074041366577,
0.8221760392189026,
0.22745729982852936,
-0.14814941585063934,
-0.29087498784065247,
-0.5035717487335205,
-0.5320851802825928,
-0.47526219487190247,
0.20839324593544006,
-0.9016932249069214,
-0.9516934156417847,
0.3432556092739105,
-0.3873662054538727,
0.07022576034069061,
0.5819454789161682,
0.39368098974227905,
-0.0748939961194992,
1.1979750394821167,
0.15790054202079773,
0.4108935594558716,
0.28065502643585205,
0.05244472995400429,
-0.013119869865477085,
-0.9173774123191833,
-0.41969558596611023,
-1.0519027709960938,
0.11968428641557693,
-0.5076373219490051,
-0.20270484685897827,
0.36090946197509766,
-0.003804342355579138,
-0.3528337776660919,
0.2593920826911926,
-0.6707062125205994,
0.6730279922485352,
0.3336270749568939,
0.3319648504257202,
0.31050193309783936,
0.319985032081604,
-0.7123916149139404,
-0.0038564535789191723,
-0.857293426990509,
-0.614682674407959,
1.2953540086746216,
-0.26346585154533386,
0.3663710057735443,
0.39518070220947266,
0.6012282967567444,
-0.01630469784140587,
0.1636122167110443,
-0.3750114142894745,
0.8056723475456238,
-0.1558687686920166,
-0.7410769462585449,
-0.48567596077919006,
-0.4309474229812622,
-0.7452121376991272,
0.5266702175140381,
-0.4396119713783264,
-0.782216489315033,
-0.033522579818964005,
0.030607059597969055,
-0.40123826265335083,
0.1280713826417923,
-0.6251001358032227,
0.5803053975105286,
-0.12226298451423645,
-0.5794210433959961,
0.03465595096349716,
-0.8408251404762268,
0.4309648275375366,
-0.10491899400949478,
0.2014627903699875,
-0.11676542460918427,
-0.3478129506111145,
0.2507475018501282,
-0.32748937606811523,
0.6177211999893188,
-0.09252703189849854,
0.05936230719089508,
0.36871078610420227,
0.057130664587020874,
0.725456953048706,
0.33024680614471436,
-0.6778458952903748,
-0.21472755074501038,
0.10560260713100433,
-0.31739312410354614,
-0.5334246754646301,
0.8976768255233765,
-0.29327672719955444,
-0.5212811231613159,
-0.580541729927063,
-0.41572028398513794,
-0.5310570597648621,
0.27519673109054565,
0.40017807483673096,
0.43862298130989075,
0.02382134646177292,
0.30166131258010864,
0.5255235433578491,
-0.23289352655410767,
0.47732993960380554,
0.5646021366119385,
-0.1584872454404831,
-0.3142012059688568,
0.6062098741531372,
0.16715994477272034,
0.1942969709634781,
0.4162271320819855,
0.1813725233078003,
-0.7828219532966614,
-0.5542314052581787,
-0.6693084239959717,
0.0946967750787735,
-0.675367534160614,
-0.33246180415153503,
-0.890272855758667,
0.08236534148454666,
-0.48874950408935547,
-0.1302976906299591,
0.09243912249803543,
-0.26507481932640076,
-0.736645519733429,
0.07258913666009903,
0.22043044865131378,
0.3015173077583313,
0.545155942440033,
0.3127824068069458,
-0.6849320530891418,
0.0665396898984909,
0.1634954959154129,
0.30473238229751587,
-0.08895482122898102,
-0.26484453678131104,
0.14098244905471802,
-0.02113315276801586,
-0.2979734241962433,
-1.2179949283599854,
0.03427617624402046,
0.39628076553344727,
0.6404464840888977,
0.11597022414207458,
0.39661961793899536,
0.7104710936546326,
-0.4600960314273834,
0.9145691990852356,
0.21124479174613953,
-0.7400686144828796,
0.9277837872505188,
-0.4507371485233307,
0.28303515911102295,
0.9615982174873352,
0.3628307580947876,
-0.21279777586460114,
-0.23771055042743683,
-0.5148547291755676,
-0.7640627026557922,
0.8506658673286438,
0.04395778104662895,
-0.0577947273850441,
-0.39169615507125854,
0.5357849597930908,
0.14852122962474823,
0.4154658019542694,
-0.37843358516693115,
-0.22145387530326843,
0.15132682025432587,
-0.09838756173849106,
-0.2052847445011139,
-0.30985575914382935,
0.0770789235830307,
-0.1324695646762848,
0.5904378294944763,
-0.6446788907051086,
-0.10513320565223694,
0.1596110761165619,
-0.136196106672287,
-0.06167783588171005,
0.4173845648765564,
0.5987294316291809,
0.7642686367034912,
-0.023020850494503975,
0.11809386312961578,
0.6059274077415466,
-0.20440557599067688,
0.0009063491015695035,
-0.18656538426876068,
-0.12071365118026733,
0.003263048129156232,
-0.06086919084191322,
0.5918301343917847,
0.07260443270206451,
-0.7745291590690613,
0.38979053497314453,
-0.15682312846183777,
-0.030407710000872612,
0.013931524939835072,
0.21458062529563904,
0.07940346747636795,
0.01786571368575096,
0.5148805975914001,
0.24022230505943298,
0.3701213002204895,
-0.5017136931419373,
0.21887965500354767,
0.7509477734565735,
-0.331973135471344,
0.20810259878635406,
0.5060303807258606,
0.1229952946305275,
-0.37348052859306335,
0.5875060558319092,
-0.14273110032081604,
-0.1849825382232666,
0.4895555377006531,
0.8191569447517395,
0.5192134976387024,
-0.37843194603919983,
0.05108467862010002,
0.47558000683784485,
0.2450052946805954,
0.07080524414777756,
0.7563716769218445,
-0.2993827164173126,
-0.31447485089302063,
-0.23307569324970245,
-0.5384353995323181,
-0.3586427569389343,
-0.2501579523086548,
-0.5695871710777283,
0.5752483010292053,
-0.38434016704559326,
-0.3199266493320465,
-0.08187209069728851,
0.16916948556900024,
-0.4512803554534912,
0.2814302444458008,
-0.5292547941207886,
1.277087688446045,
-0.6887820959091187,
0.6589762568473816,
0.8150675892829895,
-0.47873055934906006,
-0.8464769721031189,
-0.05446917563676834,
0.04266725480556488,
-0.33840256929397583,
0.30643972754478455,
0.18800827860832214,
-0.19301828742027283,
0.25932952761650085,
-0.46382513642311096,
-0.9369249939918518,
1.1373965740203857,
0.6067672967910767,
-0.6813936233520508,
0.1884550154209137,
0.13004598021507263,
0.28972873091697693,
-0.7069551944732666,
0.665368914604187,
0.6250542402267456,
0.29397347569465637,
0.3393435776233673,
-0.6044754981994629,
0.21712513267993927,
-0.04385180398821831,
0.2036582976579666,
0.057862576097249985,
-0.696709394454956,
0.8045489192008972,
-0.41349661350250244,
-0.2172931581735611,
-0.06882651150226593,
0.5753755569458008,
1.1755167245864868,
0.3709997236728668,
0.5256944298744202,
-0.09228207916021347,
0.8472525477409363,
0.026616908609867096,
0.8945143222808838,
-0.32513493299484253,
0.14119596779346466,
1.1420087814331055,
-0.5948017239570618,
1.104536533355713,
0.9094347953796387,
-0.3118278682231903,
0.44529667496681213,
0.907245397567749,
0.30205896496772766,
0.3674038052558899,
0.39508455991744995,
-0.2837715148925781,
-0.2984565794467926,
-0.2962445318698883,
-0.4825247824192047,
0.2807818353176117,
0.5334081053733826,
-0.3282429575920105,
-0.19830837845802307,
-0.023348718881607056,
-0.27896061539649963,
0.2580474615097046,
-0.07797178626060486,
0.8694350719451904,
-0.05090545490384102,
-0.8282807469367981,
0.2733520269393921,
-0.2142157107591629,
0.5678719878196716,
-0.6704767346382141,
0.07888144999742508,
-0.2554513216018677,
-0.12430603057146072,
-0.20579487085342407,
-0.6095770001411438,
0.12748098373413086,
-0.1036323606967926,
-0.16917119920253754,
0.08976738899946213,
0.752545177936554,
-0.41043680906295776,
-0.4983384311199188,
-0.12307214736938477,
0.3517361879348755,
0.23771390318870544,
-0.3478560447692871,
-0.6474562287330627,
0.005978056695312262,
-0.026483355090022087,
-0.18353302776813507,
0.3566562235355377,
0.533076822757721,
-0.1322820633649826,
0.8416231870651245,
0.9639330506324768,
0.07513691484928131,
0.03114943578839302,
-0.025897959247231483,
0.9325145483016968,
-0.5895840525627136,
-0.8546513915061951,
-0.9031128883361816,
0.4579947888851166,
-0.3358842730522156,
-0.36994290351867676,
0.9109201431274414,
0.9178188443183899,
0.5423617362976074,
-0.11755361407995224,
0.7980653643608093,
0.11797423660755157,
0.7950131893157959,
-0.6296401619911194,
0.5323125720024109,
-0.7314817905426025,
0.6836802959442139,
-0.4500817656517029,
-1.032749056816101,
-0.3181088864803314,
0.12150580435991287,
0.11522550880908966,
0.33035409450531006,
0.8646465539932251,
1.0606895685195923,
0.11023493111133575,
0.09198883920907974,
0.10087691247463226,
-0.23463033139705658,
0.3002118170261383,
0.4059438407421112,
0.8287120461463928,
-0.19262294471263885,
0.6818751692771912,
0.13624560832977295,
-0.11641650646924973,
-0.4545275568962097,
-1.088671326637268,
-0.8763847947120667,
-0.7104494571685791,
-0.04265957325696945,
-0.4050193727016449,
0.13226601481437683,
1.0993019342422485,
0.7251485586166382,
-0.8985934853553772,
-0.29341357946395874,
-0.044356442987918854,
0.14768271148204803,
-0.2749972641468048,
-0.16421309113502502,
0.5249416828155518,
-0.6717067956924438,
-0.3563082814216614,
0.673210620880127,
0.33625343441963196,
-0.09405337274074554,
-0.14325259625911713,
-0.034786421805620193,
-0.453362375497818,
0.21886400878429413,
0.8547889590263367,
-0.03191189095377922,
-0.7797940373420715,
0.005248543340712786,
0.30149367451667786,
-0.3888842463493347,
-0.1757320761680603,
0.7898330092430115,
-0.8459351658821106,
0.3196142613887787,
0.3989326059818268,
0.5174173712730408,
0.4801415205001831,
0.08973681181669235,
0.36044543981552124,
-1.02716064453125,
-0.19197656214237213,
0.19144976139068604,
0.03909456729888916,
0.21509575843811035,
-0.6646217107772827,
0.42222708463668823,
0.13530535995960236,
-0.35947611927986145,
-0.9403547048568726,
0.32396388053894043,
-0.929063081741333,
-0.5400612950325012,
1.2979066371917725,
0.3965982496738434,
-0.15619923174381256,
-0.14715200662612915,
-0.5210264921188354,
0.1943587064743042,
-0.546615481376648,
0.567699134349823,
0.427068829536438,
-0.330678254365921,
-0.19024309515953064,
-0.2198040932416916,
0.6490750908851624,
0.3429482579231262,
-0.9342342615127563,
0.024995680898427963,
0.5344719290733337,
0.20998018980026245,
-0.07698685675859451,
0.5839299559593201,
0.04854913428425789,
0.12506476044654846,
-0.044664978981018066,
-0.3455932140350342,
-0.13094154000282288,
-0.46200045943260193,
-0.23919238150119781,
0.543046772480011,
0.08238247781991959,
-0.09051211923360825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13006v1
|
Auto FAQ Generation
| 2024-05-13T03:30:27 | 2024-05-13T03:30:27 |
Anjaneya Teja Kalvakolanu, NagaSai Chandra, Michael Fekadu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
FAQ documents are commonly used with text documents and websites to provide
important information in the form of question answer pairs to either aid in
reading comprehension or provide a shortcut to the key ideas. We suppose that
salient sentences from a given document serve as a good proxy fro the answers
to an aggregated set of FAQs from readers. We propose a system for generating
FAQ documents that extract the salient questions and their corresponding
answers from sizeable text documents scraped from the Stanford Encyclopedia of
Philosophy. We use existing text summarization, sentence ranking via the Text
rank algorithm, and question-generation tools to create an initial set of
questions and answers. Finally, we apply some heuristics to filter out invalid
questions. We use human evaluation to rate the generated questions on grammar,
whether the question is meaningful, and whether the question's answerability is
present within a summarized context. On average, participants thought 71
percent of the questions were meaningful.
|
[
-0.6259169578552246,
-0.821642279624939,
0.6003053188323975,
-0.2490326464176178,
-0.37577101588249207,
-0.3111339807510376,
0.34256699681282043,
-0.15799221396446228,
0.3662513494491577,
0.6577022671699524,
-0.6996721029281616,
-0.18968334794044495,
-0.18975147604942322,
0.457069993019104,
-0.8367379903793335,
1.1951534748077393,
0.3100341856479645,
-0.5334045886993408,
-0.44700515270233154,
0.04945635795593262,
0.02250036783516407,
-0.11606773734092712,
-0.6765777468681335,
0.04917439818382263,
0.37697911262512207,
0.4894881546497345,
0.7476142644882202,
0.6988389492034912,
0.38950321078300476,
0.2923602759838104,
0.2581510543823242,
0.5597066879272461,
-0.223345085978508,
0.57430499792099,
-0.28081005811691284,
-0.11638770252466202,
-0.31513482332229614,
0.10699404776096344,
0.3694280683994293,
0.5885908603668213,
0.09655693918466568,
0.3231535851955414,
0.037064921110868454,
0.6639205813407898,
-0.3258364200592041,
-0.25189077854156494,
-0.6705987453460693,
0.15219956636428833,
-0.2479521632194519,
-0.3526748716831207,
-0.05620400607585907,
-0.6839229464530945,
0.16923409700393677,
-0.7260597944259644,
0.6158108115196228,
0.14913029968738556,
1.0796864032745361,
0.4750463366508484,
-0.3439602255821228,
-0.9041606783866882,
-0.24952071905136108,
0.31690338253974915,
-0.3951245844364166,
0.20237089693546295,
0.4317983388900757,
-0.010914912447333336,
-0.22345972061157227,
-0.5011282563209534,
-0.8353577256202698,
-0.04235977306962013,
-0.2745455205440521,
0.32063931226730347,
-0.2513624429702759,
-0.24323120713233948,
0.1796751767396927,
0.8383424878120422,
-0.7924574017524719,
-0.5366274118423462,
-0.4040442705154419,
-0.10010691732168198,
0.8195576667785645,
0.37972506880760193,
0.6149171590805054,
-0.640261709690094,
0.04892851412296295,
-0.01035541296005249,
-0.32457417249679565,
0.17109355330467224,
0.6331978440284729,
-0.34752872586250305,
0.5594249367713928,
0.5143091678619385,
-0.4214121997356415,
0.8035932183265686,
0.5287202596664429,
-0.019717950373888016,
-0.10118363052606583,
-0.6315374970436096,
-0.028793783858418465,
-0.25462666153907776,
0.7578930854797363,
0.6696975827217102,
0.1471511572599411,
-0.215431347489357,
-0.1382787823677063,
-0.3663739860057831,
0.3217340409755707,
-0.43525591492652893,
-0.34934085607528687,
0.4417484402656555,
-0.36535558104515076,
-0.47794970870018005,
0.10439054667949677,
-0.8045589923858643,
-0.015564356930553913,
-0.09444703906774521,
0.1743735671043396,
-0.5484830737113953,
0.09369312226772308,
-0.22014959156513214,
-0.44969984889030457,
0.25064486265182495,
0.5026061534881592,
-1.0961822271347046,
0.19782379269599915,
0.3003353476524353,
0.6169388294219971,
-0.12241790443658829,
-0.07582564651966095,
-0.4723803997039795,
0.3706287145614624,
-0.14284639060497284,
0.9984176158905029,
-0.015731191262602806,
-0.5317822098731995,
-0.04424912482500076,
-0.01680743135511875,
0.27024394273757935,
-0.23629699647426605,
0.3806687593460083,
-0.42793142795562744,
0.6241025328636169,
-0.3418330252170563,
-0.5777719020843506,
0.030088622123003006,
0.25174644589424133,
-0.8173527717590332,
1.260205864906311,
0.12864850461483002,
-0.6852338910102844,
0.27109643816947937,
-0.8011623620986938,
-0.710612952709198,
0.3553065359592438,
-0.2123040407896042,
0.08135388046503067,
-0.019667793065309525,
0.2666085362434387,
0.4923993647098541,
-0.46231621503829956,
0.06900646537542343,
0.3392452895641327,
0.27856194972991943,
0.38905584812164307,
-0.2701280415058136,
0.7139448523521423,
0.33673226833343506,
-0.27820688486099243,
-0.3578232228755951,
-0.5035345554351807,
0.28407591581344604,
0.19665539264678955,
-0.5461378693580627,
-0.4534500539302826,
-0.16665109992027283,
-0.37079986929893494,
0.10609506815671921,
0.3514195382595062,
-0.3615645468235016,
0.038231994956731796,
-0.6125876307487488,
0.3575408458709717,
0.526301383972168,
0.674848198890686,
0.3066936731338501,
-0.4184318780899048,
0.27711784839630127,
-0.3659136891365051,
0.21614092588424683,
-0.4172801971435547,
-0.6949789524078369,
-0.8838378190994263,
0.20059828460216522,
-0.09664999693632126,
0.47488316893577576,
-0.720018208026886,
0.7819298505783081,
0.10471322387456894,
-0.6160188913345337,
-0.4225863516330719,
0.6181410551071167,
0.4053262770175934,
0.6932855844497681,
0.2646334767341614,
-0.17076432704925537,
0.06282269209623337,
-0.8287168741226196,
-0.2219521701335907,
-0.3731476962566376,
0.05666453391313553,
0.30643337965011597,
0.53167724609375,
0.2878095805644989,
1.1681418418884277,
-1.0274934768676758,
0.25867077708244324,
-0.04697427153587341,
0.40083226561546326,
-0.14362020790576935,
0.20045918226242065,
0.6766132116317749,
-0.9234415292739868,
-0.43247491121292114,
-0.3693876564502716,
-0.6827669739723206,
-0.49920201301574707,
-0.08182481676340103,
-0.7347466349601746,
0.012289238162338734,
0.3865221440792084,
-0.5981655716896057,
0.11582191288471222,
-0.07087332755327225,
-0.15867109596729279,
0.2680043578147888,
-0.03743533045053482,
0.3095209300518036,
-1.3893232345581055,
0.3746560215950012,
-0.06569450348615646,
-0.18140147626399994,
-0.39032596349716187,
0.09023542702198029,
-0.24851329624652863,
-0.4029087424278259,
-0.06718015670776367,
0.7610560655593872,
-0.2946785092353821,
-0.024994947016239166,
-0.12250985205173492,
0.46062609553337097,
0.4057009816169739,
0.21869641542434692,
-0.2173108607530594,
0.7340120077133179,
-0.16881561279296875,
-0.9597551226615906,
0.610572338104248,
0.4103829860687256,
0.024154338985681534,
0.38353973627090454,
-0.6817139387130737,
0.050271887332201004,
-0.17935805022716522,
0.177167147397995,
-1.222794771194458,
-0.762920618057251,
0.3180495500564575,
-0.4901394546031952,
-0.2088259756565094,
0.19244465231895447,
-0.6281991004943848,
-0.5884906649589539,
-0.291782408952713,
-0.01778012327849865,
0.3952142000198364,
-0.25027355551719666,
0.2498447448015213,
0.521306574344635,
-0.3325158953666687,
-0.4944593012332916,
-0.21600885689258575,
-0.3406030237674713,
0.2758244276046753,
-0.7863355875015259,
-0.015504758805036545,
-0.34620553255081177,
-0.22865283489227295,
0.32395994663238525,
-0.026477830484509468,
-0.1537604182958603,
0.2900439202785492,
0.3676231801509857,
-0.001204164931550622,
-0.0842549130320549,
0.43949082493782043,
0.6965975761413574,
0.10357639938592911,
0.084159716963768,
-0.11037355661392212,
0.5479755997657776,
-0.17359842360019684,
-0.16475965082645416,
-0.17694395780563354,
0.8773882389068604,
0.7463512420654297,
-0.19385404884815216,
-0.03850407153367996,
0.3146820068359375,
-0.2515479028224945,
-0.29411977529525757,
-0.5163078904151917,
-0.13733738660812378,
-0.4453331232070923,
-0.1797782927751541,
-0.004964038264006376,
-0.6287717819213867,
0.25880539417266846,
0.04822076857089996,
0.6585981845855713,
0.8729888200759888,
0.7418520450592041,
-0.3237078785896301,
0.6664823293685913,
0.2518293261528015,
0.1786211133003235,
0.4386272132396698,
-0.0575057789683342,
-0.09671852737665176,
-0.16757719218730927,
-0.21801166236400604,
-0.5212541818618774,
-0.048006437718868256,
0.09103509783744812,
-0.3007962107658386,
0.48363491892814636,
0.07545257359743118,
0.10247289389371872,
0.2240988165140152,
-0.7604078054428101,
0.5550273656845093,
0.7815759181976318,
-0.13745862245559692,
0.3723665475845337,
0.1546488106250763,
-0.30074048042297363,
0.35942327976226807,
-0.4643267095088959,
-0.7253224849700928,
0.917905330657959,
-0.1603863537311554,
0.3961228132247925,
0.0893377959728241,
0.9081422686576843,
0.6299909353256226,
0.3429180383682251,
-0.6662077307701111,
0.7400422692298889,
-0.20382030308246613,
-0.8957965970039368,
-0.6464303731918335,
-0.30105921626091003,
-0.7398701310157776,
0.007045940961688757,
-0.20544208586215973,
-0.19314056634902954,
-0.03379649296402931,
0.27935391664505005,
-0.8051969408988953,
-0.3439120352268219,
-0.6083731651306152,
0.602806568145752,
-0.44173771142959595,
-0.2505778968334198,
0.2669631540775299,
-0.7246108055114746,
0.36518147587776184,
-0.15717586874961853,
-0.028653476387262344,
-0.00042234896682202816,
0.1300002932548523,
0.9000808596611023,
-0.7073418498039246,
0.4612332582473755,
0.10554295778274536,
-0.28029370307922363,
0.6931217908859253,
0.09117899090051651,
-0.10135804861783981,
0.2986464202404022,
-0.2806148827075958,
-0.3819863796234131,
-0.1333821415901184,
-0.21598201990127563,
-0.8165538311004639,
0.5649008750915527,
-0.7797491550445557,
-0.8863235712051392,
-0.1429632604122162,
-0.36403048038482666,
-0.038111116737127304,
0.43525463342666626,
0.5595820546150208,
0.305781751871109,
-0.32743972539901733,
-0.12854792177677155,
0.8940466046333313,
-0.01680932752788067,
0.3942646384239197,
0.4660816192626953,
-0.0043956260196864605,
-0.601345419883728,
0.6239294409751892,
0.17262962460517883,
0.2736263573169708,
0.3476058542728424,
0.13265150785446167,
-0.2485395222902298,
-0.11614728718996048,
-0.7713576555252075,
0.21911418437957764,
-0.8595787286758423,
-0.29498177766799927,
-0.8277294635772705,
-0.2815878093242645,
-0.7785369157791138,
-0.42071598768234253,
0.06975457072257996,
-0.6541283130645752,
-0.3507719933986664,
0.0038198751863092184,
0.40264078974723816,
0.5990284085273743,
-0.049992285668849945,
0.13848483562469482,
-0.9582836031913757,
0.3942476511001587,
0.776511013507843,
-0.2726643681526184,
-0.21763359010219574,
-0.22568030655384064,
-0.10244649648666382,
-0.21453849971294403,
-0.5459480881690979,
-1.0910283327102661,
0.28849339485168457,
0.3240112066268921,
0.6751344203948975,
0.6607704758644104,
0.34290555119514465,
0.28232723474502563,
-0.42493748664855957,
1.1775721311569214,
0.18287567794322968,
-0.8767635226249695,
1.2728379964828491,
-0.4021052122116089,
0.1587425172328949,
0.8435485363006592,
0.7817075848579407,
-0.35752594470977783,
-0.8378923535346985,
-0.6791078448295593,
-0.8963779211044312,
0.3815614581108093,
0.3731040060520172,
0.36860984563827515,
-0.39900562167167664,
0.9727403521537781,
0.42828595638275146,
0.3820175230503082,
-0.5445360541343689,
-0.2841343879699707,
-0.6357871294021606,
-0.4349081516265869,
0.3938356637954712,
-0.05654527619481087,
-0.3002191483974457,
-0.03429177775979042,
0.7075115442276001,
-0.21109463274478912,
0.1658894419670105,
0.4467776119709015,
0.0038076424971222878,
-0.43998709321022034,
0.19842202961444855,
0.44667622447013855,
0.15720413625240326,
-0.1057312861084938,
0.006869840435683727,
-0.2432541847229004,
-0.6572023630142212,
-0.01776476576924324,
-0.09870506078004837,
-0.45548611879348755,
0.18673953413963318,
-0.07009132951498032,
0.24362784624099731,
-0.04662110656499863,
-0.6263320446014404,
0.3870933949947357,
-0.16803346574306488,
-0.3535151779651642,
-0.2172081023454666,
0.7325899004936218,
-0.18720300495624542,
0.029215574264526367,
0.5927161574363708,
-0.26144349575042725,
0.31455910205841064,
-0.6401073932647705,
0.37704452872276306,
0.2757755517959595,
0.16496053338050842,
-0.03709474951028824,
0.5479472875595093,
0.6354124546051025,
-0.2709342837333679,
0.5409460663795471,
-0.2999679446220398,
-0.6349303722381592,
0.41366803646087646,
0.24034062027931213,
0.580422580242157,
-0.1512056589126587,
0.44320395588874817,
0.3725949823856354,
0.2846544682979584,
0.06274569779634476,
0.3322441875934601,
-0.4799676835536957,
-0.6150108575820923,
0.08825774490833282,
-0.7217395305633545,
-0.6285096406936646,
0.14225946366786957,
-0.4961225092411041,
0.1446000039577484,
-0.5702970027923584,
-0.26883262395858765,
0.27609431743621826,
0.09535261988639832,
-0.2701525092124939,
0.5988215804100037,
-0.019318483769893646,
0.5738502740859985,
-0.9057559370994568,
0.31973502039909363,
0.7993438839912415,
-0.9708218574523926,
-0.7658644318580627,
0.4606288969516754,
-0.28542980551719666,
-0.46807345747947693,
0.6781324744224548,
-0.3053044080734253,
-0.2097211629152298,
0.1771528124809265,
-0.8773325085639954,
-0.8962388634681702,
1.3126325607299805,
0.15241876244544983,
-0.002918815705925226,
-0.3596150875091553,
0.066263347864151,
0.37672898173332214,
-0.18528102338314056,
0.10719013959169388,
0.08388969302177429,
0.2919171452522278,
0.19341802597045898,
-0.4472593665122986,
0.24074704945087433,
-0.7560135722160339,
-0.5019463896751404,
0.2039082944393158,
-0.7458537817001343,
0.9313241839408875,
0.06173226237297058,
-0.13711975514888763,
0.22205446660518646,
0.620663583278656,
0.017391858622431755,
0.48296448588371277,
0.6552411913871765,
0.38679173588752747,
1.2482582330703735,
0.09908757358789444,
1.0044941902160645,
-0.6091606616973877,
0.18233081698417664,
0.9936520457267761,
-0.09516504406929016,
0.590658962726593,
0.31091171503067017,
0.33720138669013977,
0.417087584733963,
0.7024325728416443,
-0.09181658923625946,
0.4771513342857361,
-0.02249705232679844,
-0.24753552675247192,
-0.5186362862586975,
0.06881062686443329,
-0.4433141052722931,
0.2851603329181671,
0.5326980352401733,
-0.6822496056556702,
-0.3041538596153259,
-0.10214141011238098,
0.03371911868453026,
-0.13382644951343536,
-0.16407205164432526,
0.7553272843360901,
-0.14774851500988007,
-1.0675104856491089,
0.11674594134092331,
-0.009761526249349117,
0.11182600259780884,
-0.29634904861450195,
-0.01889682002365589,
-0.6117424964904785,
-0.441228449344635,
-0.29854249954223633,
-1.0296063423156738,
0.22086741030216217,
0.42667508125305176,
-0.6604992151260376,
-0.20606669783592224,
0.8857762217521667,
-0.16347680985927582,
-0.2688683867454529,
-0.4554000496864319,
0.7742050886154175,
0.476011723279953,
0.2753933072090149,
-0.6550930142402649,
-0.6331755518913269,
0.0735725462436676,
-0.2903903126716614,
0.09465929120779037,
0.7406231164932251,
0.19512832164764404,
0.5092624425888062,
0.8666059374809265,
-0.44050896167755127,
0.16071133315563202,
-0.4718295931816101,
1.0072227716445923,
-0.42796555161476135,
-0.6308987736701965,
-0.4975428879261017,
0.39648115634918213,
-0.5000647902488708,
-0.6837917566299438,
0.8283097743988037,
0.5163593292236328,
0.34961631894111633,
-0.027728354558348656,
1.004763126373291,
-0.20226651430130005,
0.5859358906745911,
-0.5399209260940552,
1.058752417564392,
-0.9016177654266357,
-0.020231042057275772,
-0.5002221465110779,
-0.6347262859344482,
-0.03979828208684921,
0.6818776726722717,
-0.17131160199642181,
-0.36835426092147827,
0.6938374042510986,
0.5769426822662354,
0.2046397179365158,
0.2725123167037964,
0.1992427408695221,
-0.1896630823612213,
0.12638048827648163,
0.226292222738266,
0.6676992177963257,
-0.45062580704689026,
0.7722320556640625,
0.010354484431445599,
-0.06280601769685745,
-0.4029448628425598,
-0.5631054639816284,
-0.7366535663604736,
-0.725985050201416,
-0.3848114013671875,
-0.39919140934944153,
-0.01750953122973442,
0.8377075791358948,
0.26751530170440674,
-0.5620971918106079,
0.026835337281227112,
-0.21695899963378906,
0.3001827001571655,
0.2616366744041443,
-0.30786794424057007,
0.29629090428352356,
-0.4007352888584137,
-0.6335580945014954,
0.129201278090477,
0.2567552626132965,
0.12733209133148193,
-0.3140549957752228,
0.09725876152515411,
-0.22172164916992188,
0.48706990480422974,
0.39979010820388794,
0.3842350244522095,
-0.5349542498588562,
-0.31809183955192566,
0.2352985143661499,
-0.3362015187740326,
-0.3287041485309601,
1.042099118232727,
-0.5095283389091492,
0.07245949655771255,
0.5243346691131592,
0.612229585647583,
-0.02627144567668438,
0.3044009804725647,
0.5005316138267517,
-0.7529776692390442,
-0.47067803144454956,
0.213453471660614,
0.0875539556145668,
0.0853724256157875,
-0.7060989141464233,
0.5230090022087097,
0.4497123658657074,
-0.5256389379501343,
-0.572782039642334,
0.1252010464668274,
-0.9505911469459534,
-0.16096317768096924,
1.1976121664047241,
-0.13563476502895355,
-0.3874397277832031,
-0.5207825303077698,
-0.30928635597229004,
0.42250147461891174,
-0.754429042339325,
0.6709548234939575,
0.813991904258728,
-0.4466494619846344,
-0.014588277786970139,
-0.21319587528705597,
0.6084689497947693,
0.32659828662872314,
-1.1410788297653198,
-0.028242478147149086,
0.7322797179222107,
0.4431029260158539,
0.5245417356491089,
0.731254518032074,
0.12583857774734497,
0.5198266506195068,
-0.07370070368051529,
-0.17363840341567993,
0.016315137967467308,
0.02510746568441391,
0.3010982275009155,
0.6522092223167419,
-0.2202451080083847,
0.1600688099861145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17440v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17440v1
|
CataLM: Empowering Catalyst Design Through Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T03:19:47 | 2024-05-13T03:19:47 |
Ludi Wang, Xueqing Chen, Yi Du, Yuanchun Zhou, Yang Gao, Wenjuan Cui
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The field of catalysis holds paramount importance in shaping the trajectory
of sustainable development, prompting intensive research efforts to leverage
artificial intelligence (AI) in catalyst design. Presently, the fine-tuning of
open-source large language models (LLMs) has yielded significant breakthroughs
across various domains such as biology and healthcare. Drawing inspiration from
these advancements, we introduce CataLM Cata}lytic Language Model), a large
language model tailored to the domain of electrocatalytic materials. Our
findings demonstrate that CataLM exhibits remarkable potential for facilitating
human-AI collaboration in catalyst knowledge exploration and design. To the
best of our knowledge, CataLM stands as the pioneering LLM dedicated to the
catalyst domain, offering novel avenues for catalyst discovery and development.
|
[
-0.21228456497192383,
-0.5977698564529419,
1.0469814538955688,
0.4146037697792053,
0.2926805913448334,
0.3928912878036499,
-0.42057955265045166,
-0.2866864800453186,
0.3993064761161804,
0.46683233976364136,
-0.40617629885673523,
-0.40611711144447327,
-0.12963712215423584,
0.30533039569854736,
-0.04688197746872902,
0.3957567811012268,
-0.3204195499420166,
0.4184984862804413,
-0.37496456503868103,
0.26270803809165955,
-0.29272541403770447,
-0.5977619886398315,
-0.6068978309631348,
-0.6656584739685059,
0.8146879076957703,
0.28510257601737976,
0.4843699038028717,
0.8562400341033936,
0.545512855052948,
0.3299688696861267,
-0.15354859828948975,
0.01750163547694683,
-0.16088159382343292,
0.08720973879098892,
-0.5295194387435913,
-0.8397876024246216,
-0.5702131390571594,
0.024278178811073303,
0.447990357875824,
0.8576485514640808,
-0.22257240116596222,
0.033144623041152954,
0.03834398463368416,
0.5941649675369263,
-0.40181031823158264,
0.30539098381996155,
-0.7724674940109253,
-0.014904577285051346,
-0.2033485472202301,
-0.524290919303894,
-0.5353154540061951,
-0.4109105169773102,
-0.11445203423500061,
-0.7460383176803589,
0.2436131238937378,
0.35437697172164917,
0.4299110174179077,
0.4535711705684662,
-0.2456415444612503,
-0.545399010181427,
-0.9493773579597473,
1.0647883415222168,
-0.41492629051208496,
0.6397934556007385,
0.2790241241455078,
0.3450281322002411,
-0.6830999851226807,
-1.094042181968689,
-0.6671251654624939,
-0.2231421172618866,
0.3438704013824463,
-0.056490376591682434,
0.20213542878627777,
0.4953719973564148,
-0.07180427014827728,
0.5112017393112183,
-0.6609166264533997,
0.34585756063461304,
-0.31900322437286377,
-0.2846333980560303,
0.39658838510513306,
0.5579357147216797,
0.4808847904205322,
0.4270336925983429,
-0.624217689037323,
-0.35246774554252625,
-0.7600460052490234,
-0.051716405898332596,
0.16407889127731323,
0.4938870966434479,
0.166974276304245,
0.571036159992218,
-0.26469603180885315,
0.018600966781377792,
-0.48155587911605835,
0.25437867641448975,
-0.011961226351559162,
-0.4316880404949188,
-0.2663995921611786,
0.6053053140640259,
0.6424658894538879,
0.1845780313014984,
0.023577144369482994,
-0.27839940786361694,
0.06266418844461441,
0.5931893587112427,
0.2640444338321686,
-1.2744992971420288,
-0.4390270709991455,
0.3362511694431305,
-0.35419249534606934,
-0.10308831185102463,
-0.09104489535093307,
-0.8548693060874939,
-0.6518326997756958,
-0.32934051752090454,
0.03486679866909981,
0.5756152272224426,
-0.288164347410202,
0.5887694358825684,
-0.45034059882164,
0.031022174283862114,
0.275150865316391,
-1.0301613807678223,
0.1920175552368164,
0.8061859607696533,
0.7244185209274292,
-0.14941418170928955,
-0.24233636260032654,
-0.2655138373374939,
0.11804984509944916,
-0.40258172154426575,
0.7091536521911621,
-0.788648247718811,
-0.568827748298645,
-0.25353386998176575,
0.31489700078964233,
0.18705977499485016,
-0.46416524052619934,
0.5412963628768921,
-0.6438962817192078,
-0.09999743103981018,
-0.17273694276809692,
-0.166366308927536,
-0.3463653028011322,
-0.04029231518507004,
-0.754329264163971,
0.7000578045845032,
-0.20629705488681793,
-0.23718535900115967,
0.31142181158065796,
-0.930145263671875,
-0.20331862568855286,
0.19559521973133087,
0.027917765080928802,
-0.5289552211761475,
0.28743118047714233,
-0.18483951687812805,
0.21300874650478363,
-0.9667126536369324,
0.568775475025177,
-0.6491882801055908,
0.11526825278997421,
0.22985489666461945,
-0.4463931620121002,
0.42175307869911194,
0.24662980437278748,
-0.1450224220752716,
0.3988026976585388,
-0.614357590675354,
-0.02124372497200966,
0.03997226431965828,
-0.5086525678634644,
-0.2298016995191574,
0.20120634138584137,
0.2818520665168762,
0.4765799939632416,
0.4173160791397095,
-0.8276684880256653,
0.18096253275871277,
-0.3613419532775879,
0.8974938988685608,
0.8564773797988892,
0.07488540560007095,
0.6066014170646667,
-0.17205676436424255,
0.6420000195503235,
-0.6380614042282104,
0.015281671658158302,
-0.16883738338947296,
-0.4708683490753174,
-1.053814172744751,
0.05173033848404884,
0.17601363360881805,
0.34683433175086975,
-0.35468190908432007,
-0.10004905611276627,
-0.14137236773967743,
-0.7448709607124329,
-0.5133755803108215,
0.598422110080719,
-0.047855909913778305,
0.12388177216053009,
0.24246715009212494,
-0.32552972435951233,
-0.8127565979957581,
-1.103520393371582,
-0.3472597599029541,
-0.368539959192276,
0.31063178181648254,
0.19553205370903015,
0.5056403279304504,
-0.5810602903366089,
1.0095311403274536,
-0.4294474422931671,
-0.320940762758255,
-0.2528526484966278,
-0.019904974848031998,
0.27343353629112244,
0.4820329248905182,
0.10568148642778397,
-0.8165315985679626,
-0.46916911005973816,
0.3186382055282593,
-0.7626746296882629,
-0.15798601508140564,
0.0185443963855505,
-0.40110135078430176,
-0.3978992998600006,
0.7809510231018066,
-0.5976614952087402,
0.2305360585451126,
0.2541278898715973,
-0.15177296102046967,
0.24611656367778778,
-0.06013180688023567,
-0.07283805310726166,
-0.9722888469696045,
0.10451123863458633,
0.02284839376807213,
-0.015235315077006817,
-0.8051397204399109,
0.10847754776477814,
-0.11049605906009674,
-0.46673783659935,
-0.8182917833328247,
1.0056920051574707,
-0.43601834774017334,
0.33083999156951904,
-0.5334616899490356,
-0.19458645582199097,
0.18652179837226868,
0.554169774055481,
0.3807337284088135,
0.9081513285636902,
0.3358197808265686,
-0.5631155371665955,
0.1144423708319664,
0.33464205265045166,
-0.14327478408813477,
0.24522681534290314,
-0.9032761454582214,
0.0027661509811878204,
0.23202459514141083,
0.17264866828918457,
-0.8569003343582153,
-0.34516313672065735,
-0.2718576192855835,
-0.1022626981139183,
0.1140153557062149,
0.41981515288352966,
-0.7960111498832703,
-0.5537063479423523,
-0.06787905842065811,
0.5944865345954895,
0.29545411467552185,
-0.7053830623626709,
0.8810887932777405,
0.4718847870826721,
-0.37469983100891113,
0.3776644766330719,
-0.4017992615699768,
0.3171209990978241,
-0.5430245399475098,
-0.7929335236549377,
0.31624284386634827,
-0.5376163125038147,
-0.3526434302330017,
-0.6113305687904358,
-0.023781249299645424,
-0.042122356593608856,
0.553561270236969,
0.5373442769050598,
-0.18159329891204834,
-0.2689431607723236,
0.3151606321334839,
-0.1735019087791443,
-0.2121978998184204,
0.3813615143299103,
-0.017099976539611816,
0.9114218950271606,
-0.29431721568107605,
-0.10312940925359726,
-0.7683621644973755,
0.34022822976112366,
1.111757755279541,
-0.37639379501342773,
0.5013092160224915,
0.16468840837478638,
-0.3366694748401642,
-0.4586119055747986,
-0.15922613441944122,
-0.47557172179222107,
-0.620826005935669,
0.33237823843955994,
-0.123321034014225,
-0.8556531071662903,
0.4437141418457031,
-0.6759131550788879,
-0.055305492132902145,
0.2664232850074768,
1.067978858947754,
0.2774883806705475,
1.5084683895111084,
0.942081093788147,
-0.026508519425988197,
0.3111359477043152,
-0.01380311418324709,
0.37324824929237366,
-0.8970898985862732,
-0.2770702540874481,
-0.6298779249191284,
-0.14474159479141235,
-0.39027294516563416,
-0.3321535289287567,
0.4702089726924896,
0.16801583766937256,
-0.2741372585296631,
0.0966426208615303,
-0.6013540029525757,
0.2908209264278412,
0.3261158764362335,
0.005695282481610775,
0.36237549781799316,
-0.019592810422182083,
-0.15120288729667664,
0.0351211316883564,
-0.8535051941871643,
-0.8099826574325562,
0.8235576152801514,
0.5660953521728516,
1.0772005319595337,
0.02740323543548584,
0.33967119455337524,
0.34594640135765076,
0.426131010055542,
-0.7540568113327026,
0.5459837913513184,
0.5208694934844971,
-0.8037168383598328,
-0.010750916786491871,
0.08672557026147842,
-1.128462791442871,
0.2237502783536911,
-0.043309979140758514,
-0.35347309708595276,
0.32370153069496155,
0.028036197647452354,
-0.12366767227649689,
0.3970430791378021,
-0.4680999517440796,
0.8303357362747192,
-0.5557423830032349,
-0.6121170520782471,
-0.38421517610549927,
-0.23659178614616394,
0.15195006132125854,
-0.22633205354213715,
0.3700546622276306,
-0.013519189320504665,
0.07552584260702133,
0.6449459791183472,
-0.6489788293838501,
0.9601829051971436,
0.45303207635879517,
-0.39553555846214294,
0.25856339931488037,
0.11862633377313614,
0.4568277597427368,
-0.2129385769367218,
-0.3282870650291443,
0.04636336490511894,
-0.6784432530403137,
-0.2290145754814148,
-0.3186723589897156,
0.8803483843803406,
-0.38901224732398987,
-0.881676971912384,
-0.3620588779449463,
-0.45341500639915466,
-0.010536630637943745,
0.3286762237548828,
-0.11212822049856186,
0.1301012635231018,
-0.42688480019569397,
0.4251762926578522,
0.5585236549377441,
-0.2072841078042984,
0.6310863494873047,
0.5326778292655945,
-0.2915354371070862,
-0.35433638095855713,
1.298568606376648,
-0.5468011498451233,
0.3046022057533264,
0.3139929175376892,
0.24981267750263214,
-0.3870044946670532,
-0.4220879077911377,
-0.42728686332702637,
0.15268678963184357,
-0.7602583765983582,
0.10686882585287094,
-0.7118582725524902,
0.019402166828513145,
0.19329595565795898,
-0.4941917061805725,
-0.45348167419433594,
-0.3033335208892822,
-0.6162441372871399,
-0.214032381772995,
0.5292679071426392,
0.6246767044067383,
0.13053327798843384,
0.37273886799812317,
-0.4892447292804718,
0.23721443116664886,
0.32966598868370056,
0.41485491394996643,
0.29539960622787476,
0.3035750985145569,
-0.3619743287563324,
0.14696693420410156,
-0.5423792004585266,
-0.5821757912635803,
0.4747954308986664,
0.3756469190120697,
0.6713500022888184,
0.19880788028240204,
-0.2168246954679489,
0.3184593915939331,
-0.6553971767425537,
0.8644338250160217,
0.2536773085594177,
-0.6141858100891113,
0.6848534941673279,
-0.42702728509902954,
-0.045662350952625275,
0.3996675908565521,
0.2977031171321869,
-0.41192498803138733,
-0.34788498282432556,
-0.38075798749923706,
-1.013580322265625,
0.34177136421203613,
0.12085875123739243,
-0.2235192507505417,
-0.2552589774131775,
-0.11142700910568237,
0.19715841114521027,
0.26202720403671265,
-0.7479569911956787,
-0.043122973293066025,
-0.03921175003051758,
-0.16378334164619446,
-0.037390150129795074,
0.28163057565689087,
0.06738633662462234,
-0.12371045351028442,
0.9963048100471497,
-0.053671229630708694,
-0.15049104392528534,
0.06648774445056915,
-0.20218722522258759,
-0.16723433136940002,
0.378372460603714,
0.5616255402565002,
0.342857301235199,
0.06622809171676636,
0.18044593930244446,
-0.03793732076883316,
-0.41370072960853577,
0.40844017267227173,
-0.4297959506511688,
0.07052500545978546,
-0.25044238567352295,
-0.07995650917291641,
0.7466076612472534,
-0.10687918961048126,
-0.9899405241012573,
-0.049898892641067505,
-0.2223832905292511,
-0.27132946252822876,
-0.3294055461883545,
0.41216081380844116,
0.21572788059711456,
0.46992582082748413,
0.47694388031959534,
-0.18471716344356537,
0.07546256482601166,
-0.7600158452987671,
-0.013310947455465794,
0.7061392664909363,
-0.64328932762146,
-0.4345738887786865,
1.4516332149505615,
0.47085943818092346,
-0.6511316299438477,
0.19095420837402344,
0.06336015462875366,
-0.8124120831489563,
0.7255934476852417,
0.5327427983283997,
0.9026463031768799,
-0.19961616396903992,
-0.03028186224400997,
0.14736460149288177,
0.23532477021217346,
-0.27534154057502747,
0.22113831341266632,
-0.2124655842781067,
-0.4645274877548218,
-0.04356301575899124,
-1.1275960206985474,
-0.4627473056316376,
0.18958717584609985,
-0.3450496792793274,
0.21246106922626495,
-0.5966529846191406,
-0.10007034242153168,
0.10891083627939224,
-0.04089771583676338,
-0.6700972318649292,
0.002415025606751442,
-0.05839771404862404,
0.784902036190033,
-0.8755403161048889,
0.5153963565826416,
0.6743901371955872,
-0.4884037673473358,
-0.3890078067779541,
-0.619590163230896,
-0.1668359637260437,
-0.6742226481437683,
1.0390379428863525,
0.19046743214130402,
-0.19920817017555237,
0.24384884536266327,
-0.5532193183898926,
-0.8285437226295471,
1.1142011880874634,
0.033611591905355453,
-0.5043898820877075,
0.1086466908454895,
0.6193461418151855,
0.45035457611083984,
-0.523239254951477,
0.12346382439136505,
0.3844752609729767,
0.7424004077911377,
-0.4619852304458618,
-0.8925528526306152,
0.1628044992685318,
-0.6581231355667114,
0.24224424362182617,
0.568852424621582,
-0.9515621662139893,
0.9103436470031738,
0.09592155367136002,
-0.380449116230011,
0.54774010181427,
0.6364837884902954,
0.23711742460727692,
0.2247259020805359,
0.07241591066122055,
0.5709067583084106,
0.5909742116928101,
0.09081882983446121,
0.9917513728141785,
-0.39808908104896545,
0.15783579647541046,
0.49222078919410706,
-0.6636120080947876,
0.6224132776260376,
0.5680509209632874,
-0.08514539152383804,
0.776727020740509,
0.6759241819381714,
0.09710045158863068,
0.4752671718597412,
0.41513028740882874,
-0.45038101077079773,
-0.7521349787712097,
-0.5527036786079407,
-0.2658626139163971,
0.2739676237106323,
0.7526949048042297,
-0.5111446976661682,
-0.429168701171875,
0.17576929926872253,
-0.26670941710472107,
0.24338561296463013,
-0.7125481367111206,
0.6379656791687012,
0.3722495436668396,
-0.5004087686538696,
0.5346055030822754,
0.0033239368349313736,
0.3490854501724243,
-0.2680734097957611,
-0.44270244240760803,
0.24762873351573944,
0.3529186248779297,
-0.03038722649216652,
-0.5639658570289612,
-0.24401190876960754,
-0.36614471673965454,
-0.6832373738288879,
-0.45721158385276794,
0.692326009273529,
-0.3763551712036133,
-0.4722132980823517,
0.3904185891151428,
0.4197459816932678,
0.1885635107755661,
-0.013463018462061882,
-0.34373337030410767,
0.17151062190532684,
0.07621757686138153,
0.18945592641830444,
0.3263203501701355,
0.06391662359237671,
-0.5719229578971863,
0.9601089954376221,
1.2279542684555054,
0.006072259973734617,
-0.05965975299477577,
-0.2368669956922531,
0.8267754912376404,
-0.7438647150993347,
-0.5052769184112549,
-0.972347617149353,
0.37639182806015015,
0.22329793870449066,
-0.09665534645318985,
0.8197712898254395,
0.7489609718322754,
0.44450509548187256,
-0.16367937624454498,
1.02099609375,
0.5896221399307251,
0.2538337707519531,
-0.4434375762939453,
0.7555157542228699,
-0.7209029197692871,
0.30774155259132385,
-0.09943636506795883,
-0.9623978137969971,
-0.32813555002212524,
0.49603816866874695,
0.03082304820418358,
-0.26142624020576477,
0.5953931212425232,
1.115790843963623,
-0.12642358243465424,
0.2583181858062744,
-0.11872943490743637,
0.309305876493454,
0.8121135234832764,
0.6089159250259399,
1.01628839969635,
0.06039880961179733,
0.25483042001724243,
0.07864101231098175,
-0.05751851573586464,
-0.5734698176383972,
-0.9166362285614014,
-1.199523687362671,
-0.4824680685997009,
-0.03296578675508499,
-0.12622162699699402,
-0.37719589471817017,
0.9456703662872314,
0.5564778447151184,
-0.5706723928451538,
-0.445248007774353,
-0.8283603191375732,
0.1896522343158722,
0.2572825849056244,
-0.20240262150764465,
0.29689326882362366,
-0.14791977405548096,
-0.6894274950027466,
0.7677445411682129,
0.460495263338089,
-0.11307540535926819,
-0.7490625977516174,
-0.2559681236743927,
0.11320911347866058,
0.29395702481269836,
0.5778282284736633,
0.6571633815765381,
-0.7184115052223206,
0.11356771737337112,
0.3086668848991394,
0.060647521167993546,
0.3037526607513428,
0.9077361226081848,
-0.8373220562934875,
0.6478468775749207,
0.513701319694519,
0.8470462560653687,
0.3883515000343323,
-0.2347671240568161,
0.9761914610862732,
-0.045596055686473846,
0.06665153056383133,
0.1785040646791458,
0.5266125202178955,
0.39155250787734985,
-0.21749258041381836,
0.46478399634361267,
0.05375583842396736,
-0.8568127155303955,
-1.0846906900405884,
0.33715492486953735,
-1.06000554561615,
-0.2504691779613495,
1.128340244293213,
0.5115836262702942,
-0.5460370182991028,
-0.13614597916603088,
-0.22567138075828552,
0.06977422535419464,
-0.454834520816803,
0.5458480715751648,
0.6070941090583801,
-0.0666910782456398,
0.15507671236991882,
-0.5819664001464844,
0.47291427850723267,
0.5037845373153687,
-0.7729592323303223,
0.11020025610923767,
-0.0005327601684257388,
0.08025024086236954,
0.5369951128959656,
0.278577983379364,
0.176521435379982,
0.3458709418773651,
-0.2742738127708435,
0.43884968757629395,
0.06253866851329803,
-0.5453721880912781,
-0.016062041744589806,
0.08566711097955704,
0.32212138175964355,
0.2911790907382965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07437v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07437v2
|
Evaluation of Retrieval-Augmented Generation: A Survey
| 2024-05-13T02:33:25 | 2024-07-03T04:59:32 |
Hao Yu, Aoran Gan, Kai Zhang, Shiwei Tong, Qi Liu, Zhaofeng Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has recently gained traction in natural
language processing. Numerous studies and real-world applications are
leveraging its ability to enhance generative models through external
information retrieval. Evaluating these RAG systems, however, poses unique
challenges due to their hybrid structure and reliance on dynamic knowledge
sources. To better understand these challenges, we conduct A Unified Evaluation
Process of RAG (Auepora) and aim to provide a comprehensive overview of the
evaluation and benchmarks of RAG systems. Specifically, we examine and compare
several quantifiable metrics of the Retrieval and Generation components, such
as relevance, accuracy, and faithfulness, within the current RAG benchmarks,
encompassing the possible output and ground truth pairs. We then analyze the
various datasets and metrics, discuss the limitations of current benchmarks,
and suggest potential directions to advance the field of RAG benchmarks.
|
[
-0.5248329639434814,
-0.6603262424468994,
0.3840576112270355,
0.02923697791993618,
0.05105749890208244,
0.6022845506668091,
-0.2148522585630417,
-0.6484531164169312,
0.09171176701784134,
0.48687589168548584,
-0.23538203537464142,
-0.02169349044561386,
-0.4342100918292999,
0.3354141414165497,
-0.5748212933540344,
0.9710294604301453,
-0.0017674397677183151,
-0.18973049521446228,
-0.3495453894138336,
-0.48729708790779114,
-0.6112189888954163,
-0.4658867418766022,
-0.4803801476955414,
-0.3749863803386688,
0.1125435158610344,
0.25511184334754944,
0.573067307472229,
0.39242181181907654,
0.6599231362342834,
0.34113407135009766,
-0.167525514960289,
0.5685670375823975,
-0.41434308886528015,
0.5810286402702332,
-0.34705206751823425,
-0.16379374265670776,
-0.31015095114707947,
0.06202494725584984,
0.8664878010749817,
0.8488467335700989,
-0.20288732647895813,
0.641369640827179,
0.09428927302360535,
0.8844661712646484,
-1.0463597774505615,
-0.2980495095252991,
-0.7911927103996277,
0.07660888880491257,
-0.4272419810295105,
-0.3126720190048218,
-0.43126270174980164,
-0.5226910710334778,
0.08621522039175034,
-0.6462079882621765,
0.5837584137916565,
0.2602977752685547,
1.0129926204681396,
0.2862420380115509,
-0.4307362735271454,
-0.45241743326187134,
-0.954796552658081,
0.8104318976402283,
-0.2477639764547348,
0.45910921692848206,
0.29722586274147034,
0.6162362098693848,
-0.11654408276081085,
-0.8747463226318359,
-0.33144447207450867,
-0.32554230093955994,
-0.12345859408378601,
0.33317285776138306,
-0.17292802035808563,
-0.17222696542739868,
0.12263303250074387,
1.0847724676132202,
-0.45564004778862,
-0.2776591181755066,
-0.13750723004341125,
-0.09579575806856155,
0.5825807452201843,
0.2119855433702469,
0.1966308355331421,
-0.5005952715873718,
-0.4157450497150421,
-0.28671202063560486,
-0.2831563353538513,
-0.35016995668411255,
0.47732722759246826,
0.22725152969360352,
0.2423752099275589,
0.6358503699302673,
-0.4063554108142853,
0.5903487801551819,
0.15915122628211975,
0.12196435779333115,
0.3559420704841614,
-0.5315925478935242,
-0.13306251168251038,
-0.38183340430259705,
0.7038224935531616,
0.14146748185157776,
-0.14102491736412048,
-0.5158076286315918,
-0.36748814582824707,
0.16088739037513733,
0.531948983669281,
-0.3847571313381195,
0.05338877812027931,
-0.008928263559937477,
-0.364615261554718,
-0.27171590924263,
0.18199236690998077,
-0.9704266786575317,
-0.4781636595726013,
-0.28891563415527344,
0.5845378637313843,
-0.5102999210357666,
-0.46919143199920654,
-0.24558842182159424,
-0.4472571909427643,
0.20412836968898773,
0.007107142359018326,
-0.586097240447998,
0.6551015973091125,
0.760951817035675,
0.6451361179351807,
-0.387815922498703,
0.05801087245345116,
-0.5822044014930725,
-0.08465840667486191,
-0.2875640094280243,
1.1064321994781494,
-0.5544098019599915,
-0.4447469413280487,
-0.07214311510324478,
-0.30033358931541443,
-0.1642015278339386,
-0.9554896950721741,
1.049826979637146,
-0.740974485874176,
0.2542365491390228,
-0.33798888325691223,
-0.6276111006736755,
-0.05351272225379944,
0.19638803601264954,
-0.768871545791626,
1.315026879310608,
0.38310253620147705,
-0.8738606572151184,
0.5536834001541138,
-0.46466365456581116,
-0.26462650299072266,
0.2605017125606537,
-0.16843894124031067,
-0.2057524025440216,
0.2954753637313843,
0.03458387777209282,
0.04987354576587677,
-0.780463457107544,
0.2881318926811218,
0.15231887996196747,
-0.1350506991147995,
0.10556671023368835,
-0.6670946478843689,
0.6224883198738098,
0.4861987233161926,
-0.20710676908493042,
-0.3059554398059845,
-1.1656537055969238,
0.16963252425193787,
0.1471766233444214,
-0.34339234232902527,
-0.5947645306587219,
-0.20145462453365326,
-0.0037249147426337004,
-0.30643531680107117,
0.2753695845603943,
-0.5264254212379456,
0.08136581629514694,
-0.3112800121307373,
-0.2875869572162628,
0.5035527944564819,
0.3705822229385376,
0.5115068554878235,
-0.2728936970233917,
0.6229268312454224,
-0.3783406615257263,
0.12690341472625732,
-0.04832921177148819,
-0.33735617995262146,
-0.7864590287208557,
-0.06035914272069931,
0.72999107837677,
0.523689329624176,
-0.8887890577316284,
0.19983822107315063,
-0.1426500380039215,
-0.5405310392379761,
-0.664161205291748,
0.16949251294136047,
0.7776947617530823,
0.7012416124343872,
0.3996717035770416,
-0.5408458113670349,
-0.7403326034545898,
-0.8022293448448181,
-0.592395007610321,
-0.07527398318052292,
-0.07723844051361084,
0.3290030062198639,
0.19251827895641327,
-0.16409659385681152,
0.9254744648933411,
-0.1222434937953949,
-0.03269747272133827,
-0.14844520390033722,
0.6841273307800293,
0.08731024712324142,
0.15517772734165192,
0.3799619674682617,
-1.0083885192871094,
-0.48644596338272095,
0.19528186321258545,
-0.7721121907234192,
-0.4230209290981293,
0.12971167266368866,
-0.08284172415733337,
0.25275251269340515,
0.10313717275857925,
-0.35586413741111755,
0.46560072898864746,
0.6431248784065247,
-0.3777913749217987,
0.7369576692581177,
-0.244162455201149,
0.5659912824630737,
-0.8579792976379395,
0.30979305505752563,
-0.15458913147449493,
-0.16033679246902466,
-0.45167675614356995,
0.34372422099113464,
-0.08616355806589127,
0.20995357632637024,
-0.004346021916717291,
0.6050865650177002,
-0.7461827993392944,
-0.5277166366577148,
-0.22054721415042877,
0.2690527141094208,
0.24749566614627838,
0.008444937877357006,
-0.3559570014476776,
1.0690903663635254,
0.04050853103399277,
-0.7097992300987244,
0.4304932653903961,
0.250801682472229,
-0.36327823996543884,
0.699217677116394,
-0.4975026547908783,
0.16461984813213348,
-0.060328204184770584,
0.042036399245262146,
-0.5644693970680237,
-0.24075014889240265,
-0.12816494703292847,
-0.6076096296310425,
0.449410617351532,
0.01641581952571869,
-0.6106386184692383,
-0.16412989795207977,
-0.1828392595052719,
0.38999050855636597,
0.5654571652412415,
-0.6089034676551819,
0.590269923210144,
0.523086667060852,
0.049260832369327545,
-0.5908132195472717,
-0.11697497963905334,
0.1296798586845398,
-0.26201367378234863,
-0.2968488335609436,
0.45795533061027527,
0.1585969626903534,
-0.6063041687011719,
0.30563411116600037,
-0.11629588901996613,
0.17057190835475922,
-0.13241200149059296,
0.04102356731891632,
0.06342251598834991,
-0.1462370604276657,
0.0220565814524889,
-0.20423103868961334,
-0.2786943018436432,
-0.17822420597076416,
0.1937473714351654,
0.4755912721157074,
-0.26628491282463074,
-0.32425349950790405,
0.1371585726737976,
0.17237488925457,
0.24646449089050293,
-0.5739420652389526,
0.5811777710914612,
0.6982880234718323,
-0.2406458556652069,
-0.22624903917312622,
-0.7197914123535156,
0.1687782108783722,
-0.4363582730293274,
0.06375865638256073,
-0.363879531621933,
-0.5231516361236572,
0.5155019760131836,
-0.36865702271461487,
0.08768197149038315,
0.8841146230697632,
0.4780603051185608,
0.04724099114537239,
0.9000699520111084,
0.4660649299621582,
0.3206844925880432,
0.22463075816631317,
-0.3626434803009033,
-0.15987302362918854,
-1.2977555990219116,
-0.19351747632026672,
-0.7265245318412781,
0.06753955781459808,
-0.7319806814193726,
-0.4871353805065155,
0.43228259682655334,
0.31700459122657776,
-0.12404624372720718,
0.45912691950798035,
-0.678185224533081,
0.14853355288505554,
0.6269822120666504,
-0.3754422962665558,
0.5666264891624451,
-0.0401599146425724,
-0.3164924681186676,
-0.09871158748865128,
-0.6409775018692017,
-0.6775723099708557,
1.1404895782470703,
0.1263648271560669,
0.5919992923736572,
0.17476007342338562,
0.4913099706172943,
0.65048748254776,
0.43494802713394165,
-0.4187910258769989,
0.534797728061676,
-0.37359365820884705,
-0.7366512417793274,
-0.144464373588562,
-0.7090370059013367,
-1.2266794443130493,
0.3403926491737366,
-0.4760258197784424,
-0.589383602142334,
0.13670197129249573,
-0.04158696159720421,
-0.19449587166309357,
0.2717926800251007,
-0.6675959229469299,
0.5414857268333435,
-0.21547488868236542,
-0.4163907766342163,
-0.1292979121208191,
-0.4316636323928833,
0.48324495553970337,
-0.10972919315099716,
0.1966349184513092,
-0.057485438883304596,
0.01038424763828516,
0.678874135017395,
-0.3189472258090973,
0.12671686708927155,
-0.029001960530877113,
0.03922406956553459,
0.5590800046920776,
-0.04450875148177147,
0.07959441095590591,
-0.07204720377922058,
-0.31875404715538025,
-0.0960773229598999,
0.04657458886504173,
-0.04459181800484657,
-0.6037116050720215,
0.6346336603164673,
-0.6031849384307861,
-0.29253727197647095,
-0.69855135679245,
-0.46648404002189636,
-0.6147348880767822,
0.09056951105594635,
0.3674212694168091,
0.7023978233337402,
-0.42277196049690247,
0.21974338591098785,
0.5892268419265747,
-0.45080721378326416,
0.16744844615459442,
0.32960325479507446,
-0.4749203026294708,
-0.6385771632194519,
1.003912091255188,
0.1603659689426422,
0.35678333044052124,
0.3809121549129486,
0.10427005589008331,
-0.34737294912338257,
-0.2744739055633545,
-0.6589308977127075,
0.0896904394030571,
-0.6099174618721008,
-0.40209078788757324,
-0.5456878542900085,
-0.28729742765426636,
-0.3318525552749634,
0.3466411232948303,
-0.6144639253616333,
-0.621870219707489,
0.017731446772813797,
0.12947988510131836,
0.37567639350891113,
1.051989197731018,
-0.18328557908535004,
-0.08800949156284332,
-0.8428073525428772,
0.8286774754524231,
0.23481516540050507,
0.5409616231918335,
-0.04597387835383415,
-0.5671118497848511,
-0.17975252866744995,
-0.1626855581998825,
-0.48667821288108826,
-0.8741772770881653,
0.14511553943157196,
0.18361203372478485,
0.8179218769073486,
0.08272091299295425,
0.16955631971359253,
0.7233930230140686,
-0.6347351670265198,
0.6466830372810364,
-0.18065066635608673,
-0.6347000002861023,
0.5471311211585999,
-0.2233436554670334,
0.09869086742401123,
0.8926683068275452,
0.04765351116657257,
-0.2007085382938385,
-0.3003833591938019,
-0.8779471516609192,
-0.96242356300354,
0.31370609998703003,
0.45990189909935,
-0.17666637897491455,
-0.03364952281117439,
0.35369518399238586,
0.1627446711063385,
0.1305493265390396,
-0.09996536374092102,
-0.4912334084510803,
0.12409934401512146,
0.032635658979415894,
0.30546149611473083,
-0.16204020380973816,
0.06536152958869934,
-0.03423580154776573,
0.7883124351501465,
0.20707397162914276,
0.1454562246799469,
0.15637800097465515,
-0.056934937834739685,
-0.2910003960132599,
0.38116949796676636,
0.16887439787387848,
0.6473554372787476,
-0.32351797819137573,
-0.15857623517513275,
0.2874200642108917,
-0.5258362889289856,
0.19791769981384277,
0.28217145800590515,
-0.34838148951530457,
0.4319748878479004,
0.27186253666877747,
0.6844101548194885,
0.22400107979774475,
-0.5830526351928711,
0.2129683643579483,
-0.2979053556919098,
0.12935051321983337,
-0.3751554489135742,
0.0034392529632896185,
-0.4262099266052246,
0.07957640290260315,
0.7945830821990967,
0.11273050308227539,
0.5170506238937378,
-0.6995195746421814,
0.24266725778579712,
0.607565701007843,
0.08444315195083618,
-0.2222943902015686,
0.6649527549743652,
0.03784310817718506,
-0.33569395542144775,
0.3184860646724701,
-0.49766719341278076,
-0.4965774118900299,
0.28348344564437866,
0.40466737747192383,
0.9670733213424683,
-0.2922027111053467,
0.20877444744110107,
0.5559180974960327,
0.22084681689739227,
0.1314951479434967,
0.13731738924980164,
-0.2445734590291977,
-0.573795735836029,
-0.5254918336868286,
-1.1405465602874756,
-0.7553951740264893,
-0.02066132053732872,
-1.1287425756454468,
-0.05455100163817406,
-0.05432775616645813,
-0.4998916685581207,
-0.038752809166908264,
0.3265802562236786,
-0.659099280834198,
0.2765065133571625,
-0.08724812418222427,
0.8728377223014832,
-0.4876197874546051,
0.2612195312976837,
0.9971873164176941,
-0.5128320455551147,
-0.6013088226318359,
0.03232638165354729,
-0.2289578914642334,
-0.5215784311294556,
0.5763142108917236,
-0.24721288681030273,
-0.3369691073894501,
-0.2443394809961319,
-0.09824050217866898,
-0.8800486326217651,
0.988345205783844,
0.2857941687107086,
-0.11953243613243103,
-0.012822817079722881,
0.015991169959306717,
0.7462012767791748,
-0.007395151536911726,
0.26835981011390686,
0.7241772413253784,
0.49013128876686096,
-0.005723998416215181,
-1.2094298601150513,
-0.3310829699039459,
-0.34709495306015015,
0.18617017567157745,
0.3687455654144287,
-0.5757467150688171,
0.6561732888221741,
0.24393165111541748,
-0.7397045493125916,
0.32249006628990173,
0.7428034543991089,
0.4911760687828064,
0.3741815686225891,
0.5136932730674744,
0.87217116355896,
0.527856171131134,
-0.1699957251548767,
1.2165800333023071,
-0.2645067572593689,
0.37420523166656494,
1.1242468357086182,
-0.2666555345058441,
0.9583393335342407,
0.3447185754776001,
-0.5046905279159546,
0.608589768409729,
0.17503169178962708,
0.3111129105091095,
0.3829783797264099,
-0.026592902839183807,
-0.4413486421108246,
0.0523800328373909,
-0.4620923101902008,
-0.5198445916175842,
0.4558667242527008,
0.4495064616203308,
-0.1782153695821762,
-0.34622612595558167,
-0.09624426066875458,
-0.37877199053764343,
0.5053219199180603,
-0.2694292664527893,
0.942126989364624,
-0.020866714417934418,
-0.8543729186058044,
0.530784547328949,
-0.0455925427377224,
0.4682876169681549,
-0.42425623536109924,
-0.31490370631217957,
-0.3195589780807495,
0.18960118293762207,
-0.22553901374340057,
-0.6275732517242432,
0.4446272552013397,
0.4487910568714142,
-0.14876873791217804,
-0.28356924653053284,
0.9552304744720459,
-0.014756527729332447,
-0.48409566283226013,
0.3151870667934418,
0.6556353569030762,
0.07197175174951553,
0.21558429300785065,
-0.5533340573310852,
0.2909957468509674,
-0.3742400109767914,
-0.4082881808280945,
0.2802187204360962,
0.5348610877990723,
-0.020288001745939255,
0.48908475041389465,
0.539074718952179,
0.337309330701828,
0.27499762177467346,
0.3162528872489929,
0.6572659611701965,
-0.5338960886001587,
-0.004124822560697794,
-0.29230186343193054,
0.3721529245376587,
-0.2265184372663498,
-0.2839338481426239,
1.152008056640625,
0.6561487913131714,
0.7520545721054077,
0.3030431568622589,
0.7266684770584106,
-0.3652249872684479,
1.2850124835968018,
-0.3022678792476654,
0.6258304119110107,
-0.5082150101661682,
0.20206132531166077,
-0.37671470642089844,
-1.184753179550171,
0.06982165575027466,
0.45969587564468384,
-0.031084317713975906,
0.21069850027561188,
0.4928075969219208,
0.3783014416694641,
-0.0138156833127141,
0.03790329024195671,
0.2696531116962433,
0.0012729429872706532,
-0.04308030381798744,
0.07023456692695618,
1.0839917659759521,
-0.7535373568534851,
0.41513484716415405,
-0.35042160749435425,
-0.24646271765232086,
0.05914770066738129,
-0.8044996857643127,
-0.37253615260124207,
-0.7931509613990784,
-0.07928191125392914,
-0.332113653421402,
0.18701477348804474,
0.5445443987846375,
0.36722198128700256,
-0.7734739184379578,
-0.059398192912340164,
-0.11665913462638855,
-0.20848321914672852,
-0.1392563432455063,
-0.31052207946777344,
0.2218465507030487,
-0.5127498507499695,
-0.6772101521492004,
0.5069554448127747,
0.2370551973581314,
-0.29115232825279236,
-0.4415932297706604,
0.00652641337364912,
-0.26042237877845764,
0.042201049625873566,
0.641117513179779,
0.5990386009216309,
-0.5638142824172974,
-0.2447621375322342,
0.06807899475097656,
-0.057901185005903244,
-0.1620355248451233,
0.6402549743652344,
-1.090876817703247,
0.5715695023536682,
0.4827859103679657,
1.0106900930404663,
0.3959401547908783,
0.5598932504653931,
0.538759171962738,
-0.8222737312316895,
-0.19345547258853912,
0.34318992495536804,
0.24684302508831024,
0.5968726873397827,
-0.03136352822184563,
0.9146616458892822,
0.0494399294257164,
-0.8474093079566956,
-1.0361487865447998,
0.12052588909864426,
-0.6118126511573792,
0.1796109825372696,
1.107102632522583,
0.14354732632637024,
0.026731295511126518,
-0.17702515423297882,
-0.10990314930677414,
0.48186028003692627,
0.005231119226664305,
0.5194929242134094,
0.39081263542175293,
-0.29613879323005676,
0.06913445144891739,
-0.8036282658576965,
0.45145225524902344,
0.4569229185581207,
-0.7963486313819885,
-0.007407583761960268,
0.6883535981178284,
-0.06886067986488342,
0.5751333832740784,
0.5858859419822693,
-0.27019619941711426,
0.1934860348701477,
0.1041092500090599,
0.021437400951981544,
0.3436014950275421,
-0.3240416347980499,
-0.22705265879631042,
0.21992211043834686,
0.10802269726991653,
-0.018932238221168518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08032v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08032v1
|
Exploring the Potential of Conversational AI Support for Agent-Based Social Simulation Model Design
| 2024-05-12T22:11:54 | 2024-05-12T22:11:54 |
Peer-Olaf Siebers
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE
|
ChatGPT, the AI-powered chatbot with a massive user base of hundreds of
millions, has become a global phenomenon. However, the use of Conversational AI
Systems (CAISs) like ChatGPT for research in the field of Social Simulation is
still limited. Specifically, there is no evidence of its usage in Agent-Based
Social Simulation (ABSS) model design. While scepticism towards anything new is
inherent to human nature, we firmly believe it is imperative to initiate the
use of this innovative technology to support ABSS model design. This paper
presents a proof-of-concept that demonstrates how CAISs can facilitate the
development of innovative conceptual ABSS models in a concise timeframe and
with minimal required upfront case-based knowledge. By employing advanced
prompt engineering techniques and adhering to the Engineering ABSS framework,
we have constructed a comprehensive prompt script that enables the design of
ABSS models with or by the CAIS. The effectiveness of the script is
demonstrated through an illustrative case study concerning the use of adaptive
architecture in museums. Despite occasional inaccuracies and divergences in
conversation, the CAIS proved to be a valuable companion for ABSS modellers.
|
[
-0.41704443097114563,
-0.8717268109321594,
0.45463040471076965,
0.08606178313493729,
-0.3120824098587036,
0.38573533296585083,
0.12902553379535675,
-0.41969984769821167,
0.17967358231544495,
0.01682041399180889,
-0.5051801204681396,
-0.35833504796028137,
-0.028475595638155937,
-0.10646019876003265,
-0.4048517346382141,
0.6593332886695862,
0.2517765164375305,
0.15397340059280396,
-0.09217734634876251,
0.039722371846437454,
-0.5209876298904419,
-0.48123717308044434,
-1.0919458866119385,
-0.16293881833553314,
0.12632431089878082,
0.302377849817276,
0.9889154434204102,
0.3847138285636902,
0.27003419399261475,
0.260452002286911,
-0.031846072524785995,
0.20313367247581482,
-0.24535641074180603,
0.16376718878746033,
-0.02514888346195221,
-0.20645827054977417,
-0.49732550978660583,
-0.32435354590415955,
0.2666882276535034,
0.4703681170940399,
-0.19163450598716736,
-0.04137192666530609,
0.16671541333198547,
0.29339301586151123,
-0.21929042041301727,
0.7943500280380249,
-0.4008566439151764,
-0.21377608180046082,
0.27670416235923767,
-0.03586291894316673,
-0.4216859042644501,
-0.13915418088436127,
0.09640489518642426,
-0.6616477370262146,
0.055231109261512756,
0.2293763905763626,
0.5272945761680603,
0.08290494978427887,
0.04108322784304619,
-0.41303375363349915,
-0.7772161960601807,
0.2850600481033325,
-0.659528911113739,
0.2649402320384979,
0.0381515696644783,
0.6009803414344788,
-0.35085105895996094,
-0.5833189487457275,
-0.6757620573043823,
-0.5705894231796265,
-0.050527315586805344,
-0.03556216508150101,
-0.24768014252185822,
0.17552518844604492,
0.22769717872142792,
-0.1883401870727539,
-0.5982640385627747,
-0.06417781114578247,
-0.14242978394031525,
-0.1579212248325348,
0.7556414604187012,
0.36804723739624023,
0.4365262985229492,
-0.032695308327674866,
-0.47025400400161743,
-0.26291418075561523,
-0.6327605247497559,
0.17756782472133636,
0.13001041114330292,
0.4520012438297272,
-0.46021413803100586,
0.4614434838294983,
-0.16008234024047852,
0.154890775680542,
-0.07408901304006577,
0.24990203976631165,
-0.08455502986907959,
-0.06898357719182968,
0.18166062235832214,
0.08434101194143295,
0.7107149362564087,
0.4117946922779083,
0.3770740032196045,
-0.06021682545542717,
-0.16281385719776154,
0.4169915020465851,
0.17694693803787231,
-0.8123751878738403,
-0.2351231873035431,
0.17187944054603577,
-0.31953349709510803,
-0.25755274295806885,
-0.21483615040779114,
-0.6100631952285767,
-0.7005544900894165,
-0.18976303935050964,
0.17968259751796722,
-0.46931347250938416,
-0.4018298387527466,
0.15250420570373535,
-0.3960423767566681,
0.33092376589775085,
0.5727242231369019,
-0.3907763659954071,
0.1888258308172226,
0.601423978805542,
0.9993176460266113,
0.024870723485946655,
-0.12191187590360641,
-0.18577833473682404,
0.27346500754356384,
-0.4822421669960022,
1.0390338897705078,
-0.49602851271629333,
-0.9717863202095032,
0.1364123821258545,
-0.29828080534935,
0.1540427803993225,
-0.12737061083316803,
0.39518293738365173,
-0.3728741407394409,
-0.3356819450855255,
-0.023697804659605026,
-0.19444388151168823,
0.13443860411643982,
0.35241174697875977,
-0.42014211416244507,
0.502607524394989,
0.028636202216148376,
-0.47961607575416565,
0.003965925425291061,
-1.0722978115081787,
-0.3561963438987732,
0.4667816162109375,
-0.5415898561477661,
-0.4067539572715759,
0.03235418722033501,
0.3040643334388733,
0.2550662159919739,
-0.1747363656759262,
0.38313189148902893,
-0.5390310287475586,
-0.5184794068336487,
0.4702729284763336,
-0.5727863311767578,
0.5779911875724792,
0.4830631911754608,
-0.40096789598464966,
-0.016656693071126938,
-0.27782881259918213,
-0.26429545879364014,
0.2664206326007843,
0.06831805408000946,
0.028104448691010475,
0.310936838388443,
-0.010724193416535854,
-0.0723470151424408,
0.0011345782550051808,
-0.30747297406196594,
0.1920657902956009,
-0.20354537665843964,
0.3536801040172577,
0.8552083969116211,
0.11430944502353668,
0.4240185618400574,
-0.843000590801239,
0.7083817720413208,
-0.40831175446510315,
0.03100143000483513,
-0.5750870704650879,
-0.6184829473495483,
-0.6059027314186096,
-0.27818259596824646,
-0.07751233875751495,
0.41003718972206116,
-1.0357379913330078,
-0.08457572758197784,
-0.18907371163368225,
-0.7070307731628418,
-0.2038223296403885,
-0.6036780476570129,
0.1161944568157196,
0.24518105387687683,
-0.0298182163387537,
-0.5775619745254517,
-0.4523842930793762,
-0.5888326168060303,
0.07170392572879791,
-0.8907567858695984,
-0.07643485069274902,
0.6608730554580688,
0.3165794312953949,
-0.056818887591362,
1.0204949378967285,
-0.1703445166349411,
0.02636881172657013,
-0.28680235147476196,
0.24207192659378052,
-0.03383743017911911,
0.5141440629959106,
0.7985122799873352,
-0.5839048027992249,
-0.24891416728496552,
-0.11682713031768799,
-0.6906730532646179,
-0.08346615731716156,
-0.21539422869682312,
-0.11037404835224152,
0.15838560461997986,
0.3092053234577179,
-0.9615249037742615,
1.0195517539978027,
0.06395459175109863,
-0.2761620879173279,
0.7691116333007812,
-0.033420320600271225,
0.29201051592826843,
-1.0400279760360718,
0.08246815949678421,
-0.07870589196681976,
0.07278592139482498,
-0.6492969393730164,
-0.0113297700881958,
-0.36109408736228943,
-0.7025322318077087,
-0.5107627511024475,
0.8873202204704285,
-0.368719220161438,
0.09901265799999237,
-0.4230698347091675,
0.06645480543375015,
-0.024258160963654518,
0.6250127553939819,
0.33225154876708984,
0.7376564145088196,
0.7033036947250366,
-0.6442493796348572,
0.37217986583709717,
0.5438904762268066,
-0.2603757083415985,
0.7548454403877258,
-0.9631054997444153,
0.33410656452178955,
-0.29291248321533203,
0.4936552047729492,
-1.1134850978851318,
-0.08793489634990692,
0.5229330658912659,
-0.7193918824195862,
-0.0076169203966856,
-0.2631891369819641,
-0.30447474122047424,
-0.2906625270843506,
-0.12384967505931854,
0.3346881866455078,
0.40888655185699463,
-0.3642657399177551,
0.9773975610733032,
0.6499428749084473,
-0.6851791143417358,
-0.153049036860466,
-0.40172645449638367,
0.3355903625488281,
-0.18724898993968964,
-0.8113365769386292,
0.08374814689159393,
-0.37179359793663025,
-0.6091470718383789,
-0.18588599562644958,
0.0911802276968956,
-0.012200579978525639,
0.22954660654067993,
0.2881416380405426,
0.4189295768737793,
-0.31162992119789124,
0.21506793797016144,
-0.19931398332118988,
-0.02607434056699276,
0.19325591623783112,
-0.11767784506082535,
0.7407190203666687,
-0.3397531807422638,
-0.9222853779792786,
-0.6825337409973145,
0.4612395167350769,
0.6644755005836487,
-0.06444605439901352,
0.4941699206829071,
0.15233086049556732,
-0.4401319921016693,
-0.15983808040618896,
-0.42445307970046997,
-0.34114837646484375,
-0.5679140686988831,
0.24635981023311615,
-0.12871435284614563,
-0.48828935623168945,
0.8117204904556274,
-0.057809531688690186,
0.3246181607246399,
-0.053455788642168045,
0.48091351985931396,
-0.08539094775915146,
1.0818593502044678,
0.3565426468849182,
-0.01949678361415863,
0.7985923886299133,
-0.25028127431869507,
0.2877960205078125,
-0.327125608921051,
-0.27903199195861816,
-0.7796753644943237,
0.0027134153060615063,
-0.32331031560897827,
-0.3475726544857025,
0.4719788432121277,
-0.5475577116012573,
-0.4092061221599579,
0.11936245858669281,
-0.2823634147644043,
0.25740641355514526,
0.30337318778038025,
0.1894170492887497,
0.08545303344726562,
-0.05222316086292267,
0.2040472775697708,
0.5160283446311951,
-0.8280563354492188,
-0.874546468257904,
0.5952507257461548,
0.15777012705802917,
0.9886868596076965,
0.07141229510307312,
0.36523669958114624,
0.8106012344360352,
0.5208354592323303,
-0.7071834206581116,
0.7647939324378967,
0.32345423102378845,
-0.6965121626853943,
-0.511552095413208,
-0.05752646550536156,
-0.8822096586227417,
-0.13549374043941498,
-0.08870946615934372,
-0.666754424571991,
0.3834834694862366,
0.19522839784622192,
-0.49170973896980286,
0.1505529284477234,
-0.8530324101448059,
0.6666255593299866,
-0.20864175260066986,
-0.3369113802909851,
-0.2856329381465912,
-0.44092991948127747,
-0.26152804493904114,
0.25672081112861633,
0.6050012707710266,
-0.2707090675830841,
0.5210215449333191,
0.46319326758384705,
-0.3388567566871643,
1.1551871299743652,
-0.19717766344547272,
0.11214553564786911,
0.8960535526275635,
0.5059831738471985,
0.6521444320678711,
0.28421586751937866,
-0.16010522842407227,
0.06661851704120636,
-0.06848405301570892,
-0.37049514055252075,
-0.6027728915214539,
0.3501335084438324,
-0.7960763573646545,
-0.839458167552948,
-0.17307688295841217,
-0.5832366347312927,
-0.17964567244052887,
-0.02533770725131035,
-0.33294740319252014,
0.5768214464187622,
-0.6533144116401672,
0.2107919305562973,
0.23724265396595,
-0.021068736910820007,
0.4791527986526489,
0.5984944701194763,
0.08416254818439484,
-0.008834915235638618,
0.6380968689918518,
-0.13878686726093292,
0.16074393689632416,
0.12923848628997803,
0.15941226482391357,
-0.17701944708824158,
-0.4305526316165924,
-0.5417077541351318,
-0.13932712376117706,
-0.5034983158111572,
-0.17954102158546448,
-0.4348699450492859,
-0.3100106716156006,
-0.8114367127418518,
-0.5361254215240479,
-0.23684896528720856,
-0.40965738892555237,
-0.2610958218574524,
-0.2779383659362793,
0.35372182726860046,
0.7754272222518921,
-0.17510057985782623,
0.4826815724372864,
-0.6541319489479065,
0.06539399921894073,
0.2996129095554352,
0.2010187804698944,
0.24652491509914398,
-0.31292465329170227,
-0.21799175441265106,
0.5359004139900208,
-0.30489182472229004,
-0.9604172110557556,
0.36139464378356934,
-0.03561475872993469,
0.9448043704032898,
0.5013028383255005,
0.33569633960723877,
0.4852237403392792,
-0.3886394202709198,
0.8406761884689331,
-0.16005940735340118,
-0.6845512390136719,
0.46812909841537476,
-0.6789035797119141,
-0.07369853556156158,
0.23158541321754456,
0.07518914341926575,
-0.7304637432098389,
-0.30770373344421387,
-0.9585728645324707,
-0.7339223027229309,
0.6098909378051758,
0.26839321851730347,
0.4378214180469513,
-0.09000839293003082,
0.16697220504283905,
-0.018445368856191635,
0.15772049129009247,
-0.423078715801239,
-0.021493924781680107,
-0.3695943355560303,
-0.1856621354818344,
-0.03298203647136688,
-0.06953694671392441,
-0.05978700518608093,
0.2944315969944,
1.0073038339614868,
-0.2362169623374939,
0.39021044969558716,
0.04037163779139519,
0.2174258679151535,
0.09519309550523758,
0.07396787405014038,
0.21334940195083618,
0.35703805088996887,
0.07602936774492264,
-0.16839249432086945,
0.23925557732582092,
-0.15989258885383606,
-0.025011327117681503,
0.3108910322189331,
-0.21065260469913483,
-0.08980852365493774,
-0.07856189459562302,
0.7492669820785522,
-0.08917932957410812,
-0.764900267124176,
0.40105628967285156,
-0.2227901965379715,
0.16337624192237854,
-0.5100669264793396,
0.19145622849464417,
0.13231916725635529,
0.5280197262763977,
0.37957364320755005,
-0.011643893085420132,
0.010598999448120594,
-0.6901811361312866,
0.3648892939090729,
0.7727347016334534,
-0.43942996859550476,
-0.24312110245227814,
0.7276961803436279,
0.341552734375,
-1.0104094743728638,
0.5520980358123779,
-0.16539175808429718,
-0.2672637701034546,
0.9898605346679688,
0.3174632787704468,
0.7841731905937195,
-0.18829990923404694,
0.6021780371665955,
0.05173441395163536,
0.17805872857570648,
0.01981428824365139,
0.012023357674479485,
-0.28445157408714294,
-0.8825688362121582,
0.09771899878978729,
-0.24843482673168182,
-0.9494165182113647,
-0.24831588566303253,
-0.19294242560863495,
0.630496621131897,
-0.32523947954177856,
-0.1725534349679947,
-0.20790483057498932,
-0.23105654120445251,
-0.5746257305145264,
-0.11725732684135437,
0.33331286907196045,
0.8391081094741821,
-0.8496952652931213,
0.2871280014514923,
0.7036393284797668,
-0.435802161693573,
-0.8707000613212585,
-0.239714115858078,
-0.0448940210044384,
-1.0325847864151,
0.01349867694079876,
-0.01824401691555977,
-0.18653662502765656,
-0.06285982578992844,
-0.8568943738937378,
-0.6064528822898865,
1.126111388206482,
0.26423850655555725,
-0.20197619497776031,
-0.2513454854488373,
0.19527433812618256,
0.6889103055000305,
-0.6152419447898865,
0.5020118355751038,
0.1871528923511505,
0.19173985719680786,
0.5507346391677856,
-0.730455756187439,
-0.11599518358707428,
-0.5056843161582947,
-0.17929145693778992,
-0.38813719153404236,
-0.8013576865196228,
0.5082961916923523,
-0.3192550241947174,
-0.4443475902080536,
0.4861147701740265,
0.5934796929359436,
0.6417209506034851,
0.6984387636184692,
0.4809350073337555,
0.04288485646247864,
0.4693772792816162,
0.02872033230960369,
0.8765153884887695,
-0.46958020329475403,
0.04024213179945946,
0.7487562298774719,
-0.4477960765361786,
0.2776039242744446,
0.05148891359567642,
-0.012512623332440853,
0.5963085293769836,
0.5572891235351562,
0.224016472697258,
0.30452921986579895,
0.20258396863937378,
-0.5106374621391296,
-0.22735437750816345,
-0.5958902835845947,
-0.42677417397499084,
0.3911210894584656,
0.713694155216217,
0.06798993796110153,
-0.2497151643037796,
-0.18650378286838531,
-0.040679238736629486,
-0.1372946947813034,
-0.20613715052604675,
0.781119167804718,
0.03852486237883568,
-0.44009193778038025,
0.020230218768119812,
-0.31799086928367615,
0.12245789915323257,
-0.5926958322525024,
-0.33466655015945435,
-0.41950109601020813,
-0.10260573029518127,
0.3903906047344208,
-0.6078041791915894,
0.10359853506088257,
-0.1399594396352768,
0.4356772005558014,
-0.19167841970920563,
0.8610202670097351,
-0.11588291823863983,
-0.35637664794921875,
-0.10771659761667252,
0.7415322065353394,
0.2670744061470032,
0.02643914707005024,
-0.5176723599433899,
-0.039912864565849304,
-0.19176463782787323,
-0.05291200056672096,
0.04233098030090332,
0.7028467059135437,
-0.35414448380470276,
1.0242072343826294,
0.7807866930961609,
-0.061877377331256866,
-0.4942726194858551,
0.07077892869710922,
1.0965477228164673,
-0.3116604685783386,
-0.9110540151596069,
-0.7512739896774292,
0.5899339914321899,
-0.1008179783821106,
0.047652412205934525,
0.31484243273735046,
0.4536347985267639,
0.5901237726211548,
0.12680599093437195,
1.0888638496398926,
0.010321119800209999,
0.20434661209583282,
-0.06895856559276581,
0.7385777235031128,
-0.1323714554309845,
0.41248777508735657,
-0.5670944452285767,
-0.4415287673473358,
-0.25277194380760193,
0.7435653805732727,
-0.13083915412425995,
-0.0009644223609939218,
0.1569163203239441,
1.2459944486618042,
0.2673628330230713,
0.5668511390686035,
0.26191598176956177,
0.0452144630253315,
0.827159583568573,
0.1952388435602188,
1.3095831871032715,
0.14459387958049774,
0.74178147315979,
-0.12197409570217133,
-0.3809075951576233,
-0.21035291254520416,
-0.8373737931251526,
-0.9263008832931519,
-0.5653642416000366,
-0.2753738760948181,
-0.3657822608947754,
0.5474961400032043,
0.9992091059684753,
0.6178561449050903,
-0.5298030972480774,
-0.33844277262687683,
0.017522523179650307,
0.06729987263679504,
-0.1896677315235138,
-0.195329949259758,
0.36976251006126404,
0.00908832997083664,
-0.5928328633308411,
0.28178921341896057,
0.15103760361671448,
0.5705081820487976,
-0.25860491394996643,
-0.07258616387844086,
0.1596096307039261,
0.4811093509197235,
0.25898289680480957,
0.45700332522392273,
-0.19492284953594208,
-0.49111518263816833,
0.14149627089500427,
-0.003916927147656679,
0.118670754134655,
0.7426347732543945,
-0.94346022605896,
0.2689981162548065,
0.3363732397556305,
0.5982838273048401,
0.2892261743545532,
0.2224341779947281,
0.7114561200141907,
-0.36708104610443115,
0.35747504234313965,
0.33151304721832275,
0.6431382894515991,
0.3302123248577118,
-0.4251326322555542,
0.4209461212158203,
0.32249483466148376,
-0.5002070069313049,
-0.6510365605354309,
0.40521836280822754,
-0.8542964458465576,
-0.15966935455799103,
1.1139742136001587,
-0.08641515672206879,
-0.21821798384189606,
-0.3913518786430359,
-0.7614610195159912,
0.2796854078769684,
-0.8622112274169922,
1.2735047340393066,
0.6013236045837402,
-0.2785571217536926,
-0.06291784346103668,
-0.18123964965343475,
0.12106887996196747,
0.047319091856479645,
-0.6088793873786926,
0.13832031190395355,
0.643720269203186,
-0.1365712583065033,
0.2547842860221863,
0.8483178615570068,
0.10790789127349854,
0.4452272057533264,
0.3026859760284424,
0.18126234412193298,
-0.2562146484851837,
-0.19068023562431335,
0.16334854066371918,
0.11829862743616104,
0.1793493777513504,
-0.14955931901931763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13005v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13005v1
|
Understanding the Rare Inflammatory Disease Using Large Language Models and Social Media Data
| 2024-05-12T20:54:23 | 2024-05-12T20:54:23 |
Nan Miles Xi, Hong-Long Ji, Lin Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
Sarcoidosis is a rare inflammatory disease characterized by the formation of
granulomas in various organs. The disease presents diagnostic and treatment
challenges due to its diverse manifestations and unpredictable nature. In this
study, we employed a Large Language Model (LLM) to analyze sarcoidosis-related
discussions on the social media platform Reddit. Our findings underscore the
efficacy of LLMs in accurately identifying sarcoidosis-related content. We
discovered a wide array of symptoms reported by patients, with fatigue, swollen
lymph nodes, and shortness of breath as the most prevalent. Prednisone was the
most prescribed medication, while infliximab showed the highest effectiveness
in improving prognoses. Notably, our analysis revealed disparities in prognosis
based on age and gender, with women and younger patients experiencing good and
polarized outcomes, respectively. Furthermore, unsupervised clustering
identified three distinct patient subgroups (phenotypes) with unique symptom
profiles, prognostic outcomes, and demographic distributions. Finally,
sentiment analysis revealed a moderate negative impact on patients' mental
health post-diagnosis, particularly among women and younger individuals. Our
study represents the first application of LLMs to understand sarcoidosis
through social media data. It contributes to understanding the disease by
providing data-driven insights into its manifestations, treatments, prognoses,
and impact on patients' lives. Our findings have direct implications for
improving personalized treatment strategies and enhancing the quality of care
for individuals living with sarcoidosis.
|
[
-0.24179451167583466,
-0.8689568042755127,
0.863996684551239,
0.03594767302274704,
-0.5888311266899109,
0.3869803547859192,
-0.257520854473114,
-0.5176826119422913,
0.7361665368080139,
0.6127244234085083,
-0.3172658085823059,
-0.7869366407394409,
-1.0132571458816528,
-0.22788105905056,
-0.3287332355976105,
1.3051652908325195,
0.1212608590722084,
0.6537629961967468,
-0.17089401185512543,
-0.13732893764972687,
0.11526229232549667,
-0.3301728367805481,
-0.8566442131996155,
-0.38026803731918335,
0.5973248481750488,
0.237531378865242,
0.6735820770263672,
-0.007850161753594875,
0.6518023610115051,
0.08493440598249435,
-0.32028043270111084,
0.10313788801431656,
-0.5576316118240356,
0.16211065649986267,
-0.19056782126426697,
-0.1969674825668335,
-0.4750328063964844,
-0.1624358594417572,
0.4690679609775543,
0.7610654234886169,
-0.18649449944496155,
-0.05103481933474541,
-0.10555005073547363,
0.5499498248100281,
-0.05942345783114433,
-0.6190780401229858,
-0.3509877622127533,
0.22720374166965485,
-0.4786948263645172,
-0.06064562126994133,
0.25076547265052795,
-0.0992804616689682,
-0.061156272888183594,
-0.1925293505191803,
0.2796757221221924,
-0.1498725712299347,
0.5320566296577454,
0.026892518624663353,
-0.6507543921470642,
-0.5523569583892822,
-0.6932086944580078,
0.4081699848175049,
-0.5841648578643799,
0.067486472427845,
0.3408558666706085,
0.5475369095802307,
-0.19852615892887115,
-0.6029344797134399,
-0.433019757270813,
-0.1159093901515007,
-0.0610211044549942,
0.07605475187301636,
-0.3544785976409912,
-0.15717443823814392,
-0.0288216695189476,
0.3670729100704193,
-0.6000766158103943,
0.13708531856536865,
-0.5889385342597961,
0.014746209606528282,
0.6551957726478577,
0.36503705382347107,
0.602681040763855,
-0.4691879451274872,
-0.30994322896003723,
0.5427306890487671,
-0.1963096261024475,
0.08698076009750366,
0.2763577401638031,
0.10802219808101654,
-0.5256096720695496,
0.4177214801311493,
0.008913528174161911,
0.5232508778572083,
-0.2587440311908722,
-0.15267449617385864,
0.07508005946874619,
-0.006863191723823547,
-0.01758619211614132,
-0.09512396901845932,
0.8832709789276123,
0.2681615352630615,
0.03250366076827049,
-0.15080612897872925,
-0.0268972497433424,
-0.15389609336853027,
0.33153021335601807,
-0.6983302235603333,
-0.04716911539435387,
0.8237520456314087,
-0.7310956716537476,
-0.28840216994285583,
-0.0661933571100235,
-0.7412893772125244,
-0.6246675252914429,
0.07919419556856155,
-0.1960589587688446,
-0.2292868196964264,
-0.4016011357307434,
-0.24027575552463531,
-0.08757735788822174,
-0.28102731704711914,
0.5005383491516113,
-0.43716955184936523,
0.6148993372917175,
0.5173686146736145,
0.7326331734657288,
-0.27863800525665283,
0.08405070006847382,
-0.47081610560417175,
0.14872144162654877,
-0.3476651608943939,
0.8893172740936279,
-0.8338761925697327,
-0.36400651931762695,
-0.07228149473667145,
-0.09935972839593887,
-0.16124993562698364,
-0.7315630912780762,
0.532559335231781,
-0.13003627955913544,
-0.348184734582901,
0.02111324854195118,
-0.2690735459327698,
0.15350833535194397,
0.060760755091905594,
-0.6155961751937866,
0.6327806711196899,
0.21849001944065094,
-0.6116704344749451,
-0.09837203472852707,
-0.7123156189918518,
-0.32916224002838135,
0.4034809470176697,
-0.11357329040765762,
-0.17747658491134644,
0.4687700867652893,
0.051672689616680145,
0.7682482004165649,
-0.73238205909729,
0.33250361680984497,
-0.48806431889533997,
-0.08870662748813629,
0.49170762300491333,
0.08309788256883621,
0.26441100239753723,
0.49971556663513184,
0.0570857971906662,
-0.06328866630792618,
-0.5492212176322937,
0.055352117866277695,
0.1614629030227661,
0.12968236207962036,
-0.4331789016723633,
-0.1471046507358551,
-0.004345767665654421,
0.2145157754421234,
0.08766808360815048,
-0.3363066613674164,
0.23760926723480225,
-0.018982382491230965,
0.4954282343387604,
0.30779385566711426,
0.6307052969932556,
0.22985756397247314,
-0.3772367238998413,
0.8239538073539734,
0.4570655822753906,
0.32839980721473694,
0.16844458878040314,
-0.43443748354911804,
0.13168305158615112,
-0.3692258298397064,
0.22475378215312958,
0.19464297592639923,
-0.12418511509895325,
-0.17747826874256134,
-0.2123965471982956,
-0.7717003226280212,
-0.3992116153240204,
0.20477332174777985,
0.17276540398597717,
-0.1524239033460617,
-0.121702179312706,
-0.0317954495549202,
-0.23899345099925995,
-0.788109540939331,
-0.31180256605148315,
0.43445977568626404,
0.35885170102119446,
0.5963454842567444,
0.621408998966217,
-0.8862913250923157,
0.0970458984375,
-0.5832235813140869,
-0.6861323118209839,
-0.3344012498855591,
0.5064461827278137,
0.010128568857908249,
0.23820462822914124,
0.5091307163238525,
-0.7968223094940186,
-0.5631626844406128,
0.5465718507766724,
-0.45428889989852905,
-0.035735826939344406,
0.21024136245250702,
0.12346620112657547,
-0.025374146178364754,
0.5018908381462097,
-0.5180017948150635,
0.3488468527793884,
0.9954976439476013,
-0.06191892549395561,
0.31282269954681396,
-0.04046199470758438,
0.11868879944086075,
-1.1781216859817505,
0.15242402255535126,
0.13659177720546722,
-0.49131569266319275,
-0.36208969354629517,
-0.09268759191036224,
-0.23541848361492157,
-0.5214830040931702,
-0.047604091465473175,
0.40390846133232117,
-0.209659606218338,
-0.06518059968948364,
-0.33447664976119995,
0.31922292709350586,
-0.18209493160247803,
-0.10259971022605896,
-0.1358310580253601,
0.24146606028079987,
0.7304677367210388,
-0.46649670600891113,
0.10039673000574112,
-0.4232606887817383,
-0.5240616798400879,
0.44762906432151794,
-0.7630264759063721,
-0.11906683444976807,
-0.17661607265472412,
0.5060513615608215,
-1.060085415840149,
-0.4610210657119751,
0.42519184947013855,
-0.792353093624115,
0.054054100066423416,
-0.38528385758399963,
-0.39405712485313416,
-0.4020817279815674,
0.12162265181541443,
0.5904485583305359,
0.13148947060108185,
0.0052674561738967896,
0.7526063323020935,
0.5838562250137329,
-0.5995179414749146,
-0.26668334007263184,
-0.4289943277835846,
-0.033362824469804764,
-0.07854953408241272,
-0.5418051481246948,
0.44941583275794983,
-0.11611423641443253,
-0.5836618542671204,
0.2746939957141876,
-0.09463245421648026,
-0.4480896592140198,
0.03804118558764458,
0.3973577916622162,
-0.27834856510162354,
0.08646630495786667,
0.43052801489830017,
-0.11368378251791,
0.18839241564273834,
-0.326816201210022,
0.14872583746910095,
0.9549505114555359,
-0.28084829449653625,
-0.3343522548675537,
-0.3219347298145294,
0.6660270094871521,
1.01960289478302,
-0.18010787665843964,
0.9789314866065979,
0.5274282693862915,
-0.6799031496047974,
-0.3120744526386261,
-0.3220535218715668,
-0.07143889367580414,
-0.23701223731040955,
0.25380709767341614,
-0.18873292207717896,
-0.5048771500587463,
1.0182472467422485,
-0.37869617342948914,
-0.4037742018699646,
0.3738143742084503,
0.3976593017578125,
-0.5096993446350098,
0.8925662040710449,
0.5767521262168884,
0.16272982954978943,
0.11283519119024277,
-0.2787121832370758,
0.5166721343994141,
-0.8647016882896423,
-0.43516677618026733,
-0.5305266976356506,
-0.3777114152908325,
-0.3465026617050171,
-0.5418267250061035,
0.36042454838752747,
0.30661576986312866,
0.4826047420501709,
-0.23825900256633759,
-0.1644175499677658,
0.23325221240520477,
-0.10328244417905807,
0.564211368560791,
-0.015029428526759148,
-0.09636349976062775,
0.050441961735486984,
-0.3209543228149414,
-0.8283200263977051,
-0.49522942304611206,
1.1158517599105835,
0.3656483590602875,
0.6902990937232971,
0.29579105973243713,
0.7810975909233093,
0.8905034065246582,
0.3289807438850403,
-0.8517844080924988,
0.18674592673778534,
-0.5804734826087952,
-0.5324366092681885,
-0.14583520591259003,
-0.7278640866279602,
-1.0988353490829468,
-0.2046075314283371,
-0.30361977219581604,
-0.678492546081543,
-0.14645080268383026,
-0.09891192615032196,
-0.3053440451622009,
0.21857431530952454,
-0.5612683296203613,
0.8099666833877563,
-0.689267098903656,
-0.41079509258270264,
-0.4806461036205292,
-0.4353576898574829,
0.4722291827201843,
-0.13586467504501343,
0.7077459096908569,
-0.06098205968737602,
0.015258889645338058,
0.7319254875183105,
-0.41195154190063477,
0.7395927906036377,
0.04723629355430603,
-0.04576069489121437,
0.110117107629776,
-0.10165057331323624,
0.39589130878448486,
0.36380261182785034,
0.06168955937027931,
0.3501526415348053,
0.14612576365470886,
-0.7035701870918274,
-0.8935726284980774,
1.150614619255066,
-0.8186701536178589,
-0.3572688400745392,
-0.6259335875511169,
-0.2695583403110504,
0.033990830183029175,
0.14590387046337128,
-0.02464636042714119,
0.5041884183883667,
-0.5002506375312805,
0.2654550075531006,
0.5981398224830627,
-0.1422111541032791,
-0.051414407789707184,
0.5187212824821472,
-0.13862848281860352,
-0.6239095330238342,
0.714615523815155,
0.1973700076341629,
0.1001129150390625,
0.27784550189971924,
0.4248204529285431,
0.10183626413345337,
-0.6844750642776489,
-0.07836519926786423,
0.6545565128326416,
-0.7129778861999512,
0.1311742663383484,
-1.0425726175308228,
-0.268595814704895,
-0.5423238277435303,
-0.15244954824447632,
-0.39346474409103394,
-0.17856565117835999,
-0.15340957045555115,
0.18442530930042267,
0.1709222048521042,
0.8342130780220032,
-0.021923109889030457,
0.27552005648612976,
-0.8523990511894226,
0.41272538900375366,
0.06384725123643875,
0.2941957414150238,
0.11044891923666,
-0.33601388335227966,
-0.24310676753520966,
0.38917458057403564,
0.10063041746616364,
-0.806523323059082,
0.316375732421875,
0.1960415244102478,
0.5976052284240723,
0.5736472606658936,
0.10784149169921875,
0.3533332645893097,
0.2322099357843399,
0.7344232797622681,
0.23807059228420258,
-0.7107470631599426,
0.5191250443458557,
-0.4300478398799896,
0.28023529052734375,
0.23738199472427368,
0.8126183748245239,
-0.8314368724822998,
-0.17383095622062683,
-0.9263971447944641,
-0.9259509444236755,
0.5928610563278198,
0.12429171055555344,
-0.05648060888051987,
-0.19837476313114166,
0.2611856162548065,
-0.02749321237206459,
-0.038849543780088425,
-0.6105766892433167,
-0.016461346298456192,
0.008415641263127327,
-0.07059769332408905,
-0.19756583869457245,
-0.5431017875671387,
-0.5736275911331177,
-0.17900589108467102,
0.6569145917892456,
-0.09970586746931076,
0.16770324110984802,
0.3020436465740204,
-0.2998891770839691,
-0.28919145464897156,
0.3354177474975586,
0.8467012643814087,
0.7107760310173035,
-0.2113867998123169,
0.248036190867424,
-0.043349336832761765,
-0.387360543012619,
-0.2306850552558899,
-0.025615278631448746,
0.1999293863773346,
0.08890474587678909,
0.4471091628074646,
0.6886762976646423,
0.23999972641468048,
-0.8752570748329163,
0.6535181999206543,
-0.2023329734802246,
-0.08145378530025482,
-0.5472254753112793,
-0.13878153264522552,
0.46539679169654846,
0.393858939409256,
0.5369756817817688,
0.3886040449142456,
-0.11869615316390991,
-0.6926396489143372,
0.009779848158359528,
0.6583756804466248,
-0.648957371711731,
-0.41219329833984375,
0.20100979506969452,
0.4137297570705414,
-0.44308269023895264,
0.12744097411632538,
-0.016483249142766,
-0.34475472569465637,
0.7560522556304932,
0.32493406534194946,
0.4428950250148773,
0.062196891754865646,
0.6077351570129395,
0.2971523106098175,
0.2229093462228775,
0.024110369384288788,
-0.10699933022260666,
-0.05538240075111389,
-0.4620835781097412,
0.22518488764762878,
-0.7540296912193298,
-0.16130143404006958,
0.39375728368759155,
-0.5531211495399475,
0.14409185945987701,
-0.7795474529266357,
-0.47471314668655396,
0.32462209463119507,
0.16678251326084137,
-0.3655500113964081,
0.3154684603214264,
-0.059769850224256516,
0.5160360932350159,
-0.8874837756156921,
0.6610133051872253,
1.2678385972976685,
-0.2523784339427948,
-0.4062862992286682,
0.4446984827518463,
-0.09465206414461136,
-0.6567878723144531,
0.6384586095809937,
0.018351508304476738,
-0.24680611491203308,
-0.08315612375736237,
-0.575346052646637,
-0.7917340993881226,
0.9857771396636963,
0.12599071860313416,
-0.441449910402298,
0.5642093420028687,
0.016091691330075264,
0.9126120209693909,
-0.8438547849655151,
0.18737098574638367,
0.12305490672588348,
0.2507442235946655,
0.30291202664375305,
-0.6336310505867004,
-0.18370144069194794,
-0.5581690669059753,
-0.14011339843273163,
0.2554738521575928,
-0.822392463684082,
0.5944840312004089,
-0.5922112464904785,
-0.3894035220146179,
0.09577476233243942,
-0.05281169340014458,
-0.16039444506168365,
0.6288199424743652,
0.0519833005964756,
0.8350259065628052,
0.9983726143836975,
0.03891947492957115,
1.5265913009643555,
-0.47156277298927307,
0.09037783741950989,
0.6935560703277588,
-0.15771976113319397,
0.776915967464447,
0.3508729934692383,
0.11629574745893478,
0.3159983158111572,
0.48695507645606995,
0.4620077610015869,
0.3546086847782135,
0.2701988220214844,
-0.4168039858341217,
-0.4908238649368286,
-0.446729451417923,
-0.4379158020019531,
0.25743842124938965,
0.4313008487224579,
-0.708186149597168,
-0.20029376447200775,
0.13647207617759705,
0.10426678508520126,
0.12000793218612671,
-0.2742556929588318,
0.7062923908233643,
0.06766209751367569,
-0.3546034097671509,
0.7648736834526062,
0.04317556694149971,
0.3971835672855377,
-0.8774285316467285,
0.18393830955028534,
-0.4162132143974304,
0.25624561309814453,
-0.5205837488174438,
-0.6782263517379761,
0.5557793974876404,
0.07794972509145737,
-0.7353797554969788,
0.13620835542678833,
0.5406050086021423,
-0.38666296005249023,
-0.6675997972488403,
0.5651029348373413,
0.4869562089443207,
0.5433315634727478,
-0.2022700011730194,
-0.47915276885032654,
0.5133110880851746,
0.02045835554599762,
0.3164784908294678,
0.5492611527442932,
0.6104250550270081,
-0.2765263617038727,
0.9003489017486572,
0.5823703408241272,
0.28996121883392334,
-0.3353270888328552,
0.2187814861536026,
0.745208203792572,
-0.6181707978248596,
0.029323164373636246,
-0.45339930057525635,
0.46437108516693115,
-0.2227715253829956,
-0.4998595416545868,
0.4940483272075653,
0.21538998186588287,
0.40015360713005066,
0.070978544652462,
0.9335108399391174,
-0.15741010010242462,
0.5289333462715149,
-0.314694881439209,
1.0457086563110352,
-0.9593151211738586,
0.45796501636505127,
-0.4208902418613434,
-0.4955110549926758,
-0.3291022479534149,
0.26802951097488403,
-0.6775570511817932,
0.010806329548358917,
0.8730368614196777,
0.760713517665863,
-0.10088519752025604,
-0.22409959137439728,
0.14142553508281708,
0.6130783557891846,
0.21544116735458374,
0.46945714950561523,
0.5942440032958984,
-0.265516996383667,
0.4399157464504242,
-0.1618318259716034,
-0.24808619916439056,
-0.399894654750824,
-0.5458069443702698,
-0.9621036052703857,
-0.5918326377868652,
-0.33681824803352356,
-0.1865633726119995,
0.45373570919036865,
0.9352365732192993,
0.6491670608520508,
-0.5826306343078613,
-0.05991205945611,
0.11612071841955185,
0.33542588353157043,
-0.3649519085884094,
-0.2204948365688324,
-0.036244623363018036,
0.36218416690826416,
-0.32011064887046814,
0.04332493245601654,
0.11599918454885483,
0.20827677845954895,
0.10273249447345734,
-0.22445166110992432,
-0.17037351429462433,
-0.18272468447685242,
0.5661722421646118,
0.19871297478675842,
-0.8247794508934021,
0.29145547747612,
-0.2718747556209564,
-0.38608303666114807,
-0.2273513376712799,
1.0099399089813232,
-0.2571525275707245,
0.2058752179145813,
0.25660067796707153,
0.5188292264938354,
0.5358385443687439,
0.09716569632291794,
0.5385375618934631,
-0.17824631929397583,
-0.15535305440425873,
0.5995252728462219,
0.1742609292268753,
0.2736011743545532,
-0.49355342984199524,
-0.01589922234416008,
0.2866153419017792,
-0.37112316489219666,
-0.8598105311393738,
0.1823045015335083,
-1.2817697525024414,
-0.4883922040462494,
1.2839722633361816,
0.01651025377213955,
-0.2241203337907791,
-0.18636174499988556,
-0.3529328405857086,
-0.06562910974025726,
-0.6810913681983948,
1.0017881393432617,
0.6407482624053955,
-0.19509679079055786,
-0.5739098191261292,
-0.3781541585922241,
0.24484345316886902,
0.21936705708503723,
-0.718681812286377,
-0.1547369807958603,
0.21154633164405823,
0.4508111774921417,
-0.1229860931634903,
0.8141587972640991,
-0.30772244930267334,
0.4761631190776825,
-0.14245808124542236,
-0.071382537484169,
-0.04705984890460968,
-0.17967408895492554,
-0.17675641179084778,
0.3371371626853943,
-0.17154951393604279,
0.3626098334789276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13004v1
|
MathDivide: Improved mathematical reasoning by large language models
| 2024-05-12T20:21:15 | 2024-05-12T20:21:15 |
Saksham Sahai Srivastava, Ashutosh Gandhi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models have been proven to be capable of handling complex
linguistic and cognitive tasks. Therefore their usage has been extended to
tasks requiring logical reasoning ability such as Mathematics. In this paper,
we propose a prompting technique called MathDivide that breaks down the
mathematical problem into simpler subproblems. Each of the subproblems is
formulated as an algebraic expression whose value is evaluated by the Python
code generated by the LLM for the corresponding algebraic expression. The
values fed to the Python code are the numerical values provided in the problem
statement. The solutions for the subproblems are composed together to obtain
the final answer for the problem statement. Finally, the final answer is
compared to the correct answer. If the final answer matches the correct answer,
it is produced as output else a refinement prompt is fed to the LLM. We
experiment with this prompting technique on both closed-source LLM models and
open-source LLM models using GSM8K dataset. The results obtained demonstrate
that MathDivide was able to significantly outperform the leading prompting
technique called Math-prompter.
|
[
-0.5346049070358276,
-0.9550371170043945,
0.6189510822296143,
0.43910160660743713,
-0.16221635043621063,
-0.15059585869312286,
-0.32605263590812683,
0.22817517817020416,
-0.08481890708208084,
0.15189886093139648,
-0.9556412696838379,
-0.38851073384284973,
-0.4240921437740326,
0.3066110908985138,
0.09333562105894089,
0.7556491494178772,
-0.16024348139762878,
0.3668345808982849,
-0.6732351183891296,
0.09010179340839386,
-0.6268836855888367,
-0.2613219916820526,
-0.6450252532958984,
-0.5589199066162109,
0.35208457708358765,
0.230450838804245,
0.6687923669815063,
0.3514099419116974,
0.5274975299835205,
0.3783714473247528,
-0.1302945911884308,
0.33821821212768555,
-0.24801841378211975,
0.1800304502248764,
-0.25340425968170166,
-0.6948074698448181,
-0.45731186866760254,
0.0009126284276135266,
0.28773778676986694,
0.778196394443512,
-0.21939416229724884,
0.3340258300304413,
-0.2055787295103073,
0.6726605296134949,
-0.49587321281433105,
0.48517346382141113,
-0.39463749527931213,
-0.08108050376176834,
0.02755109779536724,
-0.016544120386242867,
-0.4971504509449005,
-0.7056800723075867,
-0.09055754542350769,
-0.6924934387207031,
-0.05837348848581314,
-0.3114601671695709,
0.514179527759552,
0.4633106291294098,
-0.03249663859605789,
-0.38500380516052246,
-0.534188985824585,
0.9260914921760559,
-0.714697539806366,
0.33836525678634644,
0.38108423352241516,
0.36807262897491455,
-0.18028883635997772,
-0.4421195387840271,
-0.5307574272155762,
-0.3935829699039459,
0.16371415555477142,
0.05556320771574974,
-0.3715357184410095,
-0.03761788457632065,
0.7958109974861145,
0.14996449649333954,
-0.5011209845542908,
-0.0700477659702301,
-0.3319660425186157,
-0.1007084921002388,
0.5312185287475586,
0.21678484976291656,
0.34470444917678833,
-0.07860667258501053,
0.07799643278121948,
-0.041206829249858856,
-0.9264747500419617,
0.012459330260753632,
0.08836187422275543,
-0.06872262060642242,
0.008233519271016121,
0.7235448360443115,
-0.17996543645858765,
0.680087685585022,
0.01861417107284069,
-0.36832109093666077,
0.038332078605890274,
-0.10724831372499466,
-0.3475155830383301,
-0.16500051319599152,
0.46566176414489746,
0.2610887587070465,
0.7795093655586243,
0.4306581914424896,
-0.26279526948928833,
0.42726588249206543,
-0.22425907850265503,
-0.9191637635231018,
-0.4763127863407135,
0.1090865358710289,
-0.27462008595466614,
-0.16461291909217834,
-0.2863016724586487,
-0.6890224814414978,
-0.27896323800086975,
-0.6382637619972229,
0.256135493516922,
-0.4951988756656647,
-0.059656813740730286,
0.26444128155708313,
0.07879166305065155,
0.004365122877061367,
0.7909839749336243,
-0.8975251913070679,
0.23944027721881866,
0.895781397819519,
0.6838468909263611,
0.2344268262386322,
0.03812118619680405,
-1.0117238759994507,
-0.28883087635040283,
-0.43838122487068176,
0.7731404900550842,
-0.6200239062309265,
-0.4183238446712494,
-0.19938373565673828,
-0.4507092237472534,
0.02503572590649128,
-0.8632965087890625,
0.5345919728279114,
-0.6322820782661438,
0.3736121654510498,
-0.2942189872264862,
-0.46579790115356445,
-0.28885093331336975,
0.3745674788951874,
-0.5668520331382751,
0.8897659182548523,
0.19320181012153625,
-0.3956923186779022,
0.0020133662037551403,
-0.7451854348182678,
-0.05840670317411423,
0.2350672334432602,
-0.3558059632778168,
-0.4147694408893585,
0.2714979648590088,
0.8184570074081421,
0.1227954775094986,
-0.5394822359085083,
0.3347879648208618,
-0.3277067542076111,
-0.0563478022813797,
0.35109519958496094,
-0.6215144395828247,
0.9463945627212524,
0.3031216561794281,
0.055808618664741516,
0.12862078845500946,
-0.4297626316547394,
0.15721027553081512,
0.21512643992900848,
-0.22450727224349976,
-0.32465875148773193,
-0.2148842066526413,
-0.6666412949562073,
0.09964500367641449,
0.2752735912799835,
-0.48590248823165894,
0.5197704434394836,
-0.3313508927822113,
0.3680367171764374,
0.8848754167556763,
-0.19048233330249786,
0.494658887386322,
-0.44542598724365234,
0.9458543062210083,
-0.1705288141965866,
0.08361167460680008,
-0.39869555830955505,
-0.7064835429191589,
-0.5522551536560059,
-0.53745037317276,
0.4683620035648346,
0.8159200549125671,
-0.8751329183578491,
0.0653105154633522,
-0.10764828324317932,
-0.12871494889259338,
-0.4984218180179596,
0.21794365346431732,
0.3169594407081604,
0.6388624310493469,
0.16862712800502777,
0.5620189905166626,
-0.4862557649612427,
-0.674798309803009,
-0.027619093656539917,
-0.12434761971235275,
-0.24328207969665527,
0.3120368421077728,
0.41836583614349365,
-0.11494004726409912,
0.9019747376441956,
-0.9004116654396057,
0.029524361714720726,
-0.20643936097621918,
0.14741665124893188,
0.4748908579349518,
0.2307116985321045,
0.34361037611961365,
-0.6128081679344177,
-0.47217193245887756,
-0.1446000039577484,
-0.7251862287521362,
-0.7104713916778564,
-0.08354761451482773,
-0.08823484182357788,
-0.09491582214832306,
0.29449400305747986,
-0.9019988775253296,
0.4190008342266083,
0.27170559763908386,
-0.14342069625854492,
0.7910764217376709,
-0.1457865983247757,
0.08032823354005814,
-0.8484355807304382,
-0.2634347081184387,
0.05799335986375809,
-0.05894733965396881,
-0.2757302224636078,
0.03073780983686447,
0.09836500138044357,
-0.3859447240829468,
-0.264432430267334,
0.46059083938598633,
-0.2549801766872406,
0.08090870827436447,
-0.14396868646144867,
0.170705646276474,
0.0262959785759449,
0.13514886796474457,
0.00775618152692914,
1.0958973169326782,
0.7530224919319153,
-0.5981882214546204,
0.9367910623550415,
0.2812916338443756,
-0.3158535063266754,
0.5189921855926514,
-0.8481726050376892,
-0.0823238343000412,
-0.31957605481147766,
0.1730070412158966,
-0.9285976886749268,
-0.046086642891168594,
0.07780120521783829,
-0.5359799861907959,
-0.20477627217769623,
-0.11824146658182144,
-0.36264491081237793,
-0.34772583842277527,
-0.32773008942604065,
0.6701046228408813,
0.6998386383056641,
-0.8079476356506348,
0.7039123177528381,
-0.011854810640215874,
-0.5625532269477844,
-0.14829479157924652,
-0.37153464555740356,
-0.0256122387945652,
-0.24689282476902008,
-1.150372862815857,
0.04170457646250725,
-0.5008876919746399,
-0.7836064100265503,
-0.17440199851989746,
0.09861703217029572,
0.0436270497739315,
-0.09864923357963562,
0.07072141021490097,
0.7866478562355042,
-0.43769487738609314,
0.10505969822406769,
0.24015216529369354,
-0.42931869626045227,
0.5154361128807068,
-0.16263754665851593,
0.54737788438797,
-0.032839320600032806,
-0.4275120496749878,
-0.49272599816322327,
0.4346505105495453,
0.3949522078037262,
-0.6039259433746338,
0.32505279779434204,
0.08606225997209549,
-0.48120471835136414,
-0.5812182426452637,
-0.34350937604904175,
-0.3779832720756531,
-0.535660982131958,
-0.014001728035509586,
-0.6340544819831848,
-0.7365015149116516,
0.3399368226528168,
-0.5369757413864136,
0.014391368255019188,
0.15432476997375488,
0.665381908416748,
0.2721337378025055,
1.533596158027649,
0.12537243962287903,
0.34889480471611023,
0.33011549711227417,
-0.2975684106349945,
0.25727513432502747,
-0.5735794901847839,
-0.36156946420669556,
-0.5601608753204346,
0.004536435008049011,
-0.02615184895694256,
-0.5326806902885437,
0.5504550933837891,
0.29965609312057495,
-0.05405910685658455,
0.09806495159864426,
-0.37418416142463684,
0.811214804649353,
0.3628767132759094,
-0.0948854610323906,
0.196293905377388,
0.14097532629966736,
-0.40485671162605286,
-0.3856706917285919,
-0.5403138399124146,
-0.37289848923683167,
0.5727309584617615,
0.20064765214920044,
1.1330407857894897,
0.31712058186531067,
0.6136319637298584,
0.13961872458457947,
0.48357653617858887,
-1.166930079460144,
0.6899634599685669,
-0.04233788698911667,
-0.19938449561595917,
-0.12080565094947815,
-0.7379520535469055,
-0.6022740602493286,
0.26941460371017456,
-0.009637252427637577,
-0.5876204371452332,
-0.053729429841041565,
-0.008272847160696983,
-0.6352620720863342,
-0.17936953902244568,
-0.7909520864486694,
0.6034132242202759,
-0.07981763780117035,
-0.1698637455701828,
-0.2593808174133301,
0.12268469482660294,
0.6141431927680969,
-0.033256515860557556,
0.3304956555366516,
-0.1945928931236267,
0.040782712399959564,
0.5047935843467712,
-0.7876624464988708,
0.5927631855010986,
-0.08244737237691879,
-0.5400282144546509,
0.3589533269405365,
0.634510338306427,
0.649279773235321,
0.44238945841789246,
-0.17200632393360138,
-0.24382247030735016,
-0.19530867040157318,
-0.17891715466976166,
-1.1821250915527344,
0.8978586792945862,
-0.5568935871124268,
-0.8680317401885986,
-0.27954164147377014,
-0.6409241557121277,
-0.12889766693115234,
0.08005950599908829,
0.01890202797949314,
0.8310109972953796,
0.3885064125061035,
-0.22791226208209991,
0.9526770710945129,
-0.1819935441017151,
0.4222670793533325,
0.42330700159072876,
-0.5119694471359253,
-0.7980183362960815,
0.644770622253418,
-0.01096912007778883,
0.2093512862920761,
0.2523704469203949,
0.6151946187019348,
-0.5898422598838806,
-0.12836645543575287,
-0.607303261756897,
0.5109448432922363,
-0.8555229306221008,
-0.5145958065986633,
-0.1647883802652359,
-0.08489258587360382,
-0.4550030827522278,
-0.33150431513786316,
-0.11312207579612732,
-0.5859501361846924,
-0.09781155735254288,
-0.13015666604042053,
0.6103583574295044,
0.6118784546852112,
-0.10394282639026642,
0.10300349444150925,
-0.8090642690658569,
0.5328735113143921,
0.6542624235153198,
0.040201641619205475,
-0.10728228837251663,
-0.34028318524360657,
0.18271611630916595,
0.15181273221969604,
-0.11083633452653885,
-0.6448987722396851,
0.3734787702560425,
0.0530676394701004,
0.4173716604709625,
0.3161078989505768,
0.17244493961334229,
0.862797737121582,
-0.6069470047950745,
0.6087868809700012,
0.34766894578933716,
-1.285565733909607,
0.7657579779624939,
-0.22055481374263763,
0.5436644554138184,
0.01721477136015892,
0.1960517168045044,
-0.4041615426540375,
0.08180728554725647,
-0.37123528122901917,
-0.21348533034324646,
0.49700838327407837,
0.12803003191947937,
0.07300722599029541,
-0.19156114757061005,
0.35787734389305115,
0.05857686325907707,
-0.07387460768222809,
-0.38709133863449097,
-0.1094936802983284,
-0.055225126445293427,
-0.21368218958377838,
0.3026018440723419,
-0.16572360694408417,
-0.14198240637779236,
-0.46090757846832275,
0.5933783054351807,
-0.1467777043581009,
0.12896685302257538,
0.10555056482553482,
-0.005717444233596325,
-0.16620726883411407,
0.2594897747039795,
0.8146569132804871,
0.9847723245620728,
0.17348487675189972,
0.29462820291519165,
0.21967005729675293,
-0.24130216240882874,
0.21866559982299805,
0.12927749752998352,
-0.30016452074050903,
0.02257998287677765,
0.35787293314933777,
0.5752004981040955,
-0.34010592103004456,
-0.8821534514427185,
0.540325403213501,
-0.17773699760437012,
-0.42018795013427734,
-0.21285369992256165,
0.07795532792806625,
0.10852240771055222,
0.263511598110199,
0.24031071364879608,
-0.043705329298973083,
-0.03875509649515152,
-0.12007144838571548,
0.18591316044330597,
0.4375421404838562,
0.04280974715948105,
-0.17366032302379608,
0.6653332114219666,
0.12618331611156464,
-0.5922517776489258,
0.9065535664558411,
-0.16701719164848328,
-0.650330126285553,
0.7089396715164185,
0.8519229292869568,
0.6058264970779419,
-0.39651864767074585,
0.45949527621269226,
0.35465338826179504,
0.11716979742050171,
0.023480523377656937,
0.5005171895027161,
-0.14579440653324127,
-0.6146502494812012,
-1.1904504299163818,
-0.410224050283432,
-0.27856093645095825,
0.034397438168525696,
-0.406658798456192,
0.27744191884994507,
-0.6454054117202759,
0.028967460617423058,
0.140128955245018,
-0.11654035747051239,
-0.3066672384738922,
0.1506541520357132,
0.21065214276313782,
1.0510149002075195,
-0.6860612034797668,
0.6107168793678284,
0.7959991097450256,
-0.25021815299987793,
-0.8704476356506348,
-0.42622101306915283,
0.000913240946829319,
-0.8508586287498474,
1.1395374536514282,
0.09445848315954208,
-0.2389591634273529,
-0.032186903059482574,
-0.7242531776428223,
-0.5926246643066406,
0.6655343770980835,
0.6902341842651367,
-0.3910506069660187,
0.2978270649909973,
0.22637295722961426,
0.28424882888793945,
-0.32429784536361694,
0.4362914562225342,
0.33600810170173645,
0.5552460551261902,
0.3962601125240326,
-0.7676216959953308,
0.1720268577337265,
-0.3747837543487549,
0.06158072128891945,
0.489215612411499,
-0.30429697036743164,
1.1260532140731812,
-0.46328216791152954,
0.00593229616060853,
0.15344955027103424,
0.7102677822113037,
0.5952965617179871,
0.31151527166366577,
0.44805148243904114,
0.6481490731239319,
0.8236351609230042,
-0.09086039662361145,
0.786948561668396,
0.12810105085372925,
0.35365307331085205,
0.6803255677223206,
-0.2618948221206665,
0.540667712688446,
0.24146568775177002,
-0.41517335176467896,
0.5089308023452759,
0.4065258800983429,
0.14661969244480133,
0.3604471981525421,
0.5020198822021484,
-0.7683762907981873,
-0.6557187438011169,
-0.16472001373767853,
-0.352080374956131,
0.19708387553691864,
0.5753453373908997,
0.04200651869177818,
-0.7552370429039001,
0.15411286056041718,
0.19148977100849152,
0.2724897265434265,
-0.49481600522994995,
0.6090542674064636,
0.3375135362148285,
-0.8422285318374634,
0.8667324185371399,
0.05955487862229347,
0.24992738664150238,
-0.6597809791564941,
-0.489274263381958,
-0.3731401264667511,
0.4174623489379883,
-0.30743926763534546,
-0.6580079793930054,
0.2615829408168793,
0.1203836128115654,
-0.28240981698036194,
-0.33673587441444397,
0.4385215938091278,
-0.34199753403663635,
-0.6301245093345642,
-0.09103251993656158,
0.46591243147850037,
0.002736428752541542,
-0.14191174507141113,
-0.787761390209198,
0.2572222352027893,
0.08900067955255508,
0.11920857429504395,
0.11490927636623383,
0.8165115714073181,
-0.23977401852607727,
0.9144052267074585,
0.9701889157295227,
-0.09674406051635742,
0.1302405446767807,
0.315064936876297,
1.0230584144592285,
-0.3837988078594208,
-0.3546735644340515,
-1.1458162069320679,
0.2642243504524231,
0.06131616234779358,
-0.20113329589366913,
1.0686017274856567,
0.45617586374282837,
0.6170142292976379,
-0.21473811566829681,
0.6588298678398132,
0.20146721601486206,
0.3998161554336548,
-0.7062925696372986,
0.057025615125894547,
-0.06038254126906395,
0.5953639149665833,
-0.036066774278879166,
-0.8685415387153625,
-0.5100055932998657,
0.9555160999298096,
-0.6212131977081299,
-0.09857215732336044,
0.6771934032440186,
0.892505943775177,
-0.11802460253238678,
0.03483118116855621,
0.20336748659610748,
-0.1100817546248436,
0.4678942859172821,
0.672554075717926,
1.0921411514282227,
-0.0005279684555716813,
0.4020433723926544,
-0.3294534683227539,
-0.5743650197982788,
0.15440203249454498,
-0.8589695692062378,
-1.0616739988327026,
-0.08777347207069397,
-0.5280531644821167,
-0.4845246374607086,
-0.2446257770061493,
1.1137335300445557,
0.448016494512558,
-0.7436495423316956,
-0.17530213296413422,
-0.19614209234714508,
0.3451000452041626,
-0.24157899618148804,
-0.2617209553718567,
0.2513216435909271,
-0.29196780920028687,
-0.7673076391220093,
0.4536074697971344,
0.11252699047327042,
-0.1334461271762848,
-0.3438711166381836,
-0.15617887675762177,
0.12463368475437164,
0.322297602891922,
0.6887986063957214,
0.08064988255500793,
-0.5097362399101257,
0.1253594309091568,
0.16681161522865295,
0.2091611623764038,
-0.031514015048742294,
1.0135583877563477,
-0.9673286080360413,
0.2443140596151352,
0.8141880631446838,
0.6589345335960388,
0.24733507633209229,
0.1783384084701538,
0.6030132174491882,
-0.3238162398338318,
0.021961092948913574,
0.21005956828594208,
0.3587683141231537,
0.16757488250732422,
-0.3747776746749878,
0.18499739468097687,
0.3123653829097748,
-0.395904541015625,
-0.5887375473976135,
0.5325958728790283,
-0.6892518401145935,
-0.31628885865211487,
1.0673598051071167,
-0.14402179419994354,
-0.44828104972839355,
0.16808642446994781,
-0.6735655069351196,
-0.2440187931060791,
-0.6538669466972351,
0.5960211753845215,
0.6893758773803711,
-0.19636061787605286,
-0.4488142728805542,
-0.2757608890533447,
0.2916754484176636,
0.5344228744506836,
-0.8983924984931946,
0.17209579050540924,
0.7245810031890869,
0.13313737511634827,
0.09651172161102295,
0.3697517514228821,
-0.09104200452566147,
0.45996174216270447,
0.0006832802318967879,
-0.2366427779197693,
-0.420414000749588,
-0.2174948751926422,
-0.4518851935863495,
0.08432712405920029,
-0.006096391938626766,
0.013356953859329224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07363v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07363v1
|
Multilingual Power and Ideology Identification in the Parliament: a Reference Dataset and Simple Baselines
| 2024-05-12T19:25:15 | 2024-05-12T19:25:15 |
Çağrı Çöltekin, Matyáš Kopp, Katja Meden, Vaidas Morkevicius, Nikola Ljubešić, Tomaž Erjavec
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a dataset on political orientation and power position
identification. The dataset is derived from ParlaMint, a set of comparable
corpora of transcribed parliamentary speeches from 29 national and regional
parliaments. We introduce the dataset, provide the reasoning behind some of the
choices during its creation, present statistics on the dataset, and, using a
simple classifier, some baseline results on predicting political orientation on
the left-to-right axis, and on power position identification, i.e.,
distinguishing between the speeches delivered by governing coalition party
members from those of opposition party members.
|
[
-0.4211852550506592,
-0.12155994772911072,
0.4128919839859009,
0.2543414235115051,
-0.40394866466522217,
0.0001538182987133041,
-0.4241916537284851,
0.17073924839496613,
0.4308900833129883,
0.6045860052108765,
-0.3789748251438141,
-0.45526227355003357,
-0.5791090130805969,
0.15855130553245544,
-0.33775410056114197,
0.7208240628242493,
0.4484240412712097,
0.34160321950912476,
-0.22645021975040436,
-0.5907366275787354,
-0.4437737464904785,
-0.8076157569885254,
-0.09970468282699585,
-0.6110555529594421,
0.5196702480316162,
0.8321434855461121,
0.7562684416770935,
0.799769937992096,
0.27081114053726196,
0.28966599702835083,
0.04071970656514168,
-0.32327061891555786,
-0.20075933635234833,
-0.21812278032302856,
-0.40265578031539917,
-0.7514588236808777,
-0.11119959503412247,
0.21430087089538574,
1.006374478340149,
0.7343887686729431,
-0.2661396861076355,
0.15755219757556915,
0.07541175931692123,
0.6616249084472656,
-0.6138069033622742,
0.5607566237449646,
-0.6975575685501099,
-0.09853265434503555,
-0.8443165421485901,
-0.4659682810306549,
-0.5623063445091248,
-0.20487523078918457,
-0.22345998883247375,
-0.3093336820602417,
0.07356981933116913,
0.18535038828849792,
0.7723519206047058,
-0.06526201963424683,
-0.5419009327888489,
-0.4099510610103607,
-0.4416995942592621,
0.8720123767852783,
-0.579044759273529,
0.4139765799045563,
0.28536170721054077,
0.5500646233558655,
0.16892439126968384,
-0.7142766714096069,
-0.48739710450172424,
0.29764890670776367,
-0.3981126546859741,
0.025065138936042786,
0.03665320947766304,
-0.0859484151005745,
0.32490840554237366,
0.2867492735385895,
-0.5736358165740967,
-0.021059727296233177,
-0.5162693858146667,
-0.17194822430610657,
0.6940903663635254,
0.10635045915842056,
0.1939074844121933,
-0.8181378245353699,
-0.2756233513355255,
-0.041361868381500244,
-0.9178107976913452,
0.006854843348264694,
0.7641143202781677,
0.651299238204956,
-0.2984674274921417,
0.7855002880096436,
-0.16043655574321747,
0.8486814498901367,
0.3061739504337311,
-0.31451335549354553,
0.2639002799987793,
-0.5278990864753723,
0.08987013250589371,
0.545621395111084,
0.6882632374763489,
0.2708469033241272,
0.0809798389673233,
0.15614719688892365,
-0.014813166111707687,
-0.11274774372577667,
-0.14691030979156494,
-0.5303424000740051,
-0.3917229175567627,
0.13433818519115448,
-0.7646145224571228,
0.05920838564634323,
0.3342987895011902,
-0.835024893283844,
-0.6559879183769226,
-0.8920417428016663,
-0.05209030210971832,
-0.46666231751441956,
-0.46398985385894775,
-0.2885220944881439,
-0.43520388007164,
0.7192984223365784,
-0.1744702160358429,
-1.0587774515151978,
0.09515281021595001,
1.1268205642700195,
0.5783180594444275,
-0.29597941040992737,
-0.3085266947746277,
-0.22082671523094177,
0.08247058093547821,
-0.2562461793422699,
0.9921676516532898,
-0.8942696452140808,
-0.012548127211630344,
0.12712454795837402,
0.34091058373451233,
-0.12531013786792755,
-0.6319898366928101,
0.43057239055633545,
-0.3091777563095093,
0.5828467011451721,
-0.67402583360672,
-0.5750983953475952,
-0.04211565852165222,
-0.19237887859344482,
-0.7455733418464661,
0.5053701400756836,
0.0011510414769873023,
-0.9599418640136719,
0.5758777260780334,
-0.5880544185638428,
-0.24275894463062286,
0.20959608256816864,
-0.6425657272338867,
-0.02593415603041649,
0.02958468720316887,
-0.005447763949632645,
0.32809826731681824,
-0.27921947836875916,
0.4972168505191803,
-0.1722109317779541,
0.11442633718252182,
0.1260751485824585,
-0.3955310583114624,
1.3243261575698853,
0.2550230324268341,
-0.043125685304403305,
0.34355729818344116,
-1.2888480424880981,
-0.025968262925744057,
-0.17449195683002472,
0.06073880195617676,
-0.4900587499141693,
0.43362516164779663,
0.02597941644489765,
0.1932222843170166,
0.4855155348777771,
-0.6545153260231018,
0.2896052896976471,
-0.11050347983837128,
0.47754690051078796,
0.7116534113883972,
0.047745123505592346,
0.47597306966781616,
-0.32613712549209595,
0.29432377219200134,
0.041880231350660324,
-0.11468598246574402,
-0.03662190958857536,
-0.6492310762405396,
-0.5497403144836426,
-0.1830061972141266,
0.5205715894699097,
0.8834218382835388,
-0.6979762315750122,
0.38526108860969543,
-0.37946757674217224,
-0.39196768403053284,
-0.3229590952396393,
-0.1421813815832138,
0.23275460302829742,
0.4505036771297455,
0.1670159101486206,
0.04501896724104881,
-0.8150837421417236,
-1.2807039022445679,
-0.25986796617507935,
-0.5650347471237183,
-0.2791135311126709,
0.2070629596710205,
0.3328138589859009,
0.36348333954811096,
0.9556869268417358,
-0.15843741595745087,
0.10831242054700851,
-0.29172974824905396,
0.3593481481075287,
0.40463146567344666,
0.18613772094249725,
0.4476892650127411,
-1.1365740299224854,
-0.3750419020652771,
-0.072459377348423,
-0.7255697250366211,
-0.5783618688583374,
-0.1376148909330368,
-0.11425423622131348,
-0.1506630927324295,
0.20325587689876556,
-0.04433567821979523,
0.20166896283626556,
0.4644509553909302,
-0.26248636841773987,
0.37867432832717896,
0.2260521799325943,
0.09097921848297119,
-1.4600292444229126,
0.14387589693069458,
-0.43580517172813416,
-0.02836865745484829,
-0.7283093333244324,
-0.05575849488377571,
0.32996347546577454,
-0.28410959243774414,
-0.8277758359909058,
0.285368949174881,
-0.2738569676876068,
-0.03806094452738762,
-0.006186383776366711,
-0.007543069776147604,
-0.07070007920265198,
0.3955524265766144,
0.25014162063598633,
0.8961681723594666,
0.5830509066581726,
-0.2625351846218109,
0.542666494846344,
0.6013904213905334,
-0.5224118828773499,
1.120539903640747,
-0.3821990191936493,
0.1736704260110855,
-0.39410367608070374,
-0.05907523259520531,
-0.9695430397987366,
-0.6922197937965393,
0.22481493651866913,
0.004307328723371029,
0.26621007919311523,
-0.2376396507024765,
-0.10856425017118454,
0.09792523086071014,
0.010258686728775501,
0.2644481062889099,
0.07297537475824356,
-0.510059654712677,
0.41925308108329773,
0.849793553352356,
-0.5727145075798035,
-0.943965494632721,
-0.50079745054245,
0.11600446701049805,
-0.507297694683075,
-0.3162129521369934,
0.5053485035896301,
0.4075363874435425,
-0.7458469867706299,
-0.2642379701137543,
0.36932018399238586,
-0.13900001347064972,
-0.5454170107841492,
0.5070024132728577,
0.056351188570261,
-0.20503032207489014,
0.14731022715568542,
-0.14897705614566803,
-0.18034327030181885,
0.014406275935471058,
0.0993022620677948,
0.7883762717247009,
-0.19888877868652344,
-0.36163753271102905,
-0.6591747999191284,
0.7766488194465637,
0.5682198405265808,
-0.1223016157746315,
0.668483316898346,
0.11287114769220352,
-0.0900435820221901,
0.32693395018577576,
-0.3025006353855133,
0.16072583198547363,
-0.427602082490921,
0.08890365064144135,
-0.5935093760490417,
-0.08839470148086548,
0.7623406648635864,
0.0068123298697173595,
0.10704883933067322,
0.6246514320373535,
0.6453695893287659,
0.25003957748413086,
0.8649076819419861,
0.4075187146663666,
-0.320566326379776,
0.33993175625801086,
-0.06129496544599533,
0.19835706055164337,
-0.3652176856994629,
-0.41512763500213623,
-1.0089784860610962,
-0.2808825969696045,
-0.8926212191581726,
0.1264898031949997,
0.16378505527973175,
-0.009253578260540962,
-0.3941788673400879,
0.4748571217060089,
-0.456796795129776,
0.35497230291366577,
0.5219016075134277,
-0.21186812222003937,
-0.07740676403045654,
-0.012243795208632946,
-0.10249195247888565,
-0.24018102884292603,
-0.7010918855667114,
-0.6830152869224548,
0.9812576174736023,
0.14023175835609436,
0.632634699344635,
0.17544621229171753,
0.6906483173370361,
0.03140826150774956,
0.2998008728027344,
-0.7425597906112671,
0.5559486150741577,
-0.04193715751171112,
-0.5729613304138184,
-0.11748486757278442,
-0.43301883339881897,
-0.752598762512207,
0.01566915027797222,
0.056409433484077454,
-0.4504576623439789,
0.807853639125824,
-0.3341325521469116,
-0.2412218600511551,
0.33958372473716736,
-0.4393468499183655,
0.6846325397491455,
-0.09499037265777588,
-0.01945711486041546,
-0.1686672419309616,
-0.7500383853912354,
0.13226452469825745,
0.17787662148475647,
0.2393343299627304,
-0.40500423312187195,
-0.06736195832490921,
1.2000272274017334,
-0.159907266497612,
0.5008888244628906,
-0.3555847406387329,
0.0878216028213501,
0.04847397282719612,
-0.49963200092315674,
-0.02099163644015789,
-0.02594177983701229,
-0.6468005180358887,
0.6331941485404968,
0.27155911922454834,
-0.5070465207099915,
-0.3408190906047821,
0.6056642532348633,
-0.9219480156898499,
-0.6703298687934875,
-0.5144773125648499,
-0.5252549052238464,
0.008998115547001362,
0.2683877646923065,
0.4627121090888977,
0.8075485229492188,
-0.37559133768081665,
0.8676711320877075,
0.04496341943740845,
-0.025745786726474762,
0.7808645367622375,
0.22865810990333557,
-0.21556536853313446,
-0.7618576288223267,
0.9102259278297424,
0.3636143207550049,
0.05529378354549408,
0.4303581416606903,
0.21002501249313354,
-0.765947163105011,
-0.09331318736076355,
-0.4379870295524597,
0.018857993185520172,
-0.8875173330307007,
-0.08851277083158493,
-0.05378549546003342,
-0.27478280663490295,
-0.23030444979667664,
-0.010228845290839672,
-0.1724664717912674,
-0.7332196235656738,
-0.010887974873185158,
0.19856224954128265,
-0.11959531158208847,
0.7531567215919495,
-0.18685615062713623,
0.3826275169849396,
-0.10226976126432419,
0.3610677421092987,
0.4738328158855438,
0.09296365827322006,
-0.7566155791282654,
-0.23461690545082092,
0.30515056848526,
0.10592867434024811,
-0.37327301502227783,
-1.3906333446502686,
0.4796127378940582,
0.5460265278816223,
0.633517861366272,
0.7634178400039673,
0.17537537217140198,
0.4941585063934326,
-0.768330991268158,
1.0736138820648193,
0.17510908842086792,
-0.770910918712616,
0.35590505599975586,
-0.20279113948345184,
0.03226001560688019,
0.5699674487113953,
0.7310092449188232,
-0.3966078758239746,
-0.20310774445533752,
-0.7657036185264587,
-0.5421745777130127,
0.664767324924469,
0.05193331837654114,
0.04585767537355423,
0.025312572717666626,
0.2722548842430115,
0.4221663177013397,
0.41209977865219116,
-0.4466687738895416,
-0.5603787302970886,
-0.5331212878227234,
-0.15794111788272858,
-0.28756067156791687,
-0.2090662270784378,
-0.6906725764274597,
-0.4070070683956146,
0.3894411027431488,
-0.2390284389257431,
0.46259039640426636,
-0.11442801356315613,
0.13220147788524628,
0.03198995441198349,
0.6916335821151733,
0.6506708860397339,
1.455588459968567,
-0.24158290028572083,
0.5364552140235901,
-0.1021285429596901,
-0.10167573392391205,
0.5168997645378113,
-0.052321657538414,
0.03660351037979126,
0.4414392113685608,
0.29378265142440796,
0.9075366258621216,
-0.0571933351457119,
-0.0692034363746643,
0.5032225251197815,
0.02979184500873089,
0.05713158845901489,
-0.6223637461662292,
-0.14914466440677643,
0.01603509858250618,
-0.1361497938632965,
0.5835273265838623,
-0.01967909373342991,
-0.1471356302499771,
-0.9756964445114136,
0.4326521158218384,
0.4646621644496918,
-0.2596619725227356,
-0.3965722620487213,
0.5374816656112671,
0.06373366713523865,
-0.950333297252655,
0.4167778491973877,
0.0027267897967249155,
-0.41815894842147827,
0.3645552396774292,
0.5314387679100037,
0.6199643015861511,
-0.3200770318508148,
0.3573724329471588,
0.16844041645526886,
-0.029908472672104836,
0.48864516615867615,
0.5518621206283569,
0.04999276623129845,
-0.6149066090583801,
-0.3317224681377411,
-0.6109879612922668,
-0.566572368144989,
0.3792926073074341,
-1.103707194328308,
0.5127961039543152,
-0.36923927068710327,
-0.18431536853313446,
0.6742451190948486,
0.28401321172714233,
-0.36426112055778503,
-0.3718962073326111,
0.43582579493522644,
0.8982522487640381,
-1.2923650741577148,
0.9914887547492981,
0.3970937728881836,
0.0002926605229731649,
-0.5963820219039917,
0.036538783460855484,
0.1980174481868744,
-0.7927411794662476,
0.480710506439209,
0.1631079614162445,
0.3811115324497223,
-0.20417194068431854,
-0.5271775126457214,
-0.5423337817192078,
0.829486608505249,
0.4928451478481293,
-0.5358468294143677,
0.05369578301906586,
0.7161705493927002,
0.19843871891498566,
-0.5215314626693726,
0.29257312417030334,
0.5488041043281555,
0.7908018231391907,
-0.2368287444114685,
-0.821284294128418,
-0.34399741888046265,
-0.12099810689687729,
-0.20619724690914154,
0.2622632682323456,
-0.7156595587730408,
1.2252317667007446,
0.7382684946060181,
-0.25302180647850037,
-0.11031287908554077,
0.6106792092323303,
0.21967467665672302,
0.23623430728912354,
0.41602593660354614,
0.2792622745037079,
0.8974480032920837,
-0.26292723417282104,
0.8918050527572632,
-0.9611495137214661,
0.0857870802283287,
0.8282539248466492,
-0.45127323269844055,
0.8901537656784058,
0.6018896102905273,
-0.039345405995845795,
0.6589719653129578,
0.35220322012901306,
0.3858061134815216,
0.7247953414916992,
-0.15620678663253784,
-0.3189370930194855,
-0.1443207561969757,
-0.15944638848304749,
-0.44004714488983154,
0.7411775588989258,
0.5118595957756042,
-0.20825810730457306,
-0.49510160088539124,
0.10816308110952377,
-0.13401377201080322,
0.11185300350189209,
-0.4705868363380432,
0.9703445434570312,
-0.07898104935884476,
-0.8148422241210938,
0.8373206257820129,
-0.010970491915941238,
0.12621599435806274,
-0.4667038023471832,
-0.11269756406545639,
0.08314409106969833,
0.12422757595777512,
-0.12291578203439713,
-1.1878646612167358,
0.5989269614219666,
-0.28188279271125793,
-0.1841602921485901,
-0.47884756326675415,
0.5488070845603943,
-0.4419792890548706,
-0.27416524291038513,
-0.14214520156383514,
0.3689481317996979,
0.39142462611198425,
0.24718303978443146,
-0.7846581339836121,
-0.01365289743989706,
0.03576327860355377,
0.022638732567429543,
0.2937006950378418,
0.36090338230133057,
-0.1377471685409546,
0.2487592101097107,
0.3305110037326813,
0.21007342636585236,
-0.04264752194285393,
-0.17238393425941467,
0.5811283588409424,
-0.46794813871383667,
-0.3423214554786682,
-0.7240282297134399,
0.11491620540618896,
-0.4052225947380066,
-0.4681667387485504,
0.8106714487075806,
0.7993801832199097,
0.6273391246795654,
-0.059135377407073975,
0.6143129467964172,
-0.3903237283229828,
0.5264959931373596,
-0.38265401124954224,
0.8271166086196899,
0.01012275367975235,
-0.28197455406188965,
0.2363509088754654,
-0.8731529116630554,
-0.02887135185301304,
0.6278526186943054,
-0.6311392784118652,
-0.7168870568275452,
0.6560055017471313,
1.0760271549224854,
-0.4352535307407379,
0.22430984675884247,
0.26164618134498596,
-0.018426284193992615,
-0.017883392050862312,
0.2588707506656647,
0.7941191792488098,
-0.07252117246389389,
0.05122961848974228,
-0.6861304640769958,
-0.14636577665805817,
0.07657483220100403,
-0.8395248055458069,
-0.5478819608688354,
-1.0684202909469604,
-0.17972275614738464,
-0.20303460955619812,
-0.13583241403102875,
0.9362436532974243,
0.8022980093955994,
-1.2934499979019165,
-0.6457536220550537,
0.13747267425060272,
0.09378426522016525,
-0.16069430112838745,
-0.21404586732387543,
0.4408641755580902,
-0.18845772743225098,
-0.7441425323486328,
0.42009106278419495,
0.25876808166503906,
-0.5806061625480652,
-0.26747286319732666,
0.0609029158949852,
-0.5355275273323059,
0.39776161313056946,
0.19929806888103485,
0.5329889059066772,
-0.8072335124015808,
-0.6565356850624084,
-0.4436156153678894,
-0.10305235534906387,
0.5359437465667725,
0.9971808195114136,
-0.45868998765945435,
0.24484167993068695,
0.7728579044342041,
-0.039915308356285095,
-0.17854149639606476,
0.2949230968952179,
0.4461417496204376,
-1.1130812168121338,
0.8911306262016296,
0.24684935808181763,
0.5020759701728821,
0.3388572633266449,
-0.01075876597315073,
0.29460957646369934,
0.255909264087677,
-0.5636228919029236,
-0.8624745011329651,
0.22204482555389404,
-0.8811060190200806,
0.10726369172334671,
1.1850262880325317,
-0.2525995969772339,
-0.5058331489562988,
-0.46213051676750183,
-0.4258461594581604,
0.15634672343730927,
-0.015095409005880356,
0.4198744595050812,
0.9299154877662659,
-0.28919681906700134,
-0.290128231048584,
-0.4028523564338684,
0.6464383006095886,
0.2394067496061325,
-0.4971241056919098,
0.1943223625421524,
0.3603517711162567,
0.27371570467948914,
0.5510554909706116,
0.4140900671482086,
-0.2470788210630417,
-0.017960363999009132,
0.01642976514995098,
-0.047339703887701035,
0.40490299463272095,
-0.6910601258277893,
-0.6091530323028564,
0.929561197757721,
-0.3398946523666382,
-0.1782311052083969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07348v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07348v2
|
MedConceptsQA: Open Source Medical Concepts QA Benchmark
| 2024-05-12T17:54:50 | 2024-05-14T16:44:02 |
Ofir Ben Shoham, Nadav Rappoport
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present MedConceptsQA, a dedicated open source benchmark for medical
concepts question answering. The benchmark comprises of questions of various
medical concepts across different vocabularies: diagnoses, procedures, and
drugs. The questions are categorized into three levels of difficulty: easy,
medium, and hard. We conducted evaluations of the benchmark using various Large
Language Models. Our findings show that pre-trained clinical Large Language
Models achieved accuracy levels close to random guessing on this benchmark,
despite being pre-trained on medical data. However, GPT-4 achieves an absolute
average improvement of nearly 27%-37% (27% for zero-shot learning and 37% for
few-shot learning) when compared to clinical Large Language Models. Our
benchmark serves as a valuable resource for evaluating the understanding and
reasoning of medical concepts by Large Language Models. Our benchmark is
available at https://huggingface.co/datasets/ofir408/MedConceptsQA
|
[
-0.2548092305660248,
-0.6520136594772339,
1.0179450511932373,
-0.10941015928983688,
-0.2536506652832031,
0.05912042409181595,
-0.013918006792664528,
-0.4799494743347168,
-0.08247032761573792,
0.27842977643013,
-0.5009593963623047,
-0.7375946044921875,
-0.4322541058063507,
0.20054057240486145,
0.0003769737668335438,
0.7862066626548767,
-0.34245339035987854,
0.5828143358230591,
-0.36520716547966003,
-0.3499206304550171,
-0.38133135437965393,
-0.5233331322669983,
-0.7993335127830505,
-0.047172825783491135,
0.4717136323451996,
0.21101883053779602,
0.5680384039878845,
0.3925513029098511,
0.7885684370994568,
0.22909121215343475,
0.03116447851061821,
-0.040888238698244095,
-0.1305346041917801,
0.13096274435520172,
-0.3538094758987427,
-0.4555630683898926,
-0.31167423725128174,
0.23911181092262268,
0.3760683536529541,
0.6862125992774963,
-0.533288836479187,
0.4613526165485382,
-0.38610386848449707,
0.6801850199699402,
-0.8376328349113464,
0.08801816403865814,
-0.5764679908752441,
-0.05641697719693184,
-0.025979651138186455,
-0.12471505254507065,
-0.013130524195730686,
-0.655927300453186,
0.20316782593727112,
-0.8013710975646973,
0.3153723478317261,
-0.24246005713939667,
0.9799609780311584,
0.5425851941108704,
-0.4632760286331177,
-0.41710200905799866,
-0.3441503643989563,
0.5577585697174072,
-0.5079191327095032,
0.466831237077713,
0.4209652245044708,
0.7829615473747253,
0.06698080897331238,
-1.203317403793335,
-0.6786544322967529,
-0.21513164043426514,
0.2746502459049225,
0.22248056530952454,
-0.22059749066829681,
0.13538499176502228,
0.37866654992103577,
0.5431192517280579,
-0.639163613319397,
-0.09730978310108185,
-0.34592023491859436,
-0.23858460783958435,
0.26729056239128113,
0.19560439884662628,
0.27786165475845337,
-0.037182554602622986,
-0.3948080837726593,
-0.008029288612306118,
-0.7656739354133606,
0.1459738314151764,
-0.3278481066226959,
-0.1318351924419403,
-0.12031156569719315,
0.6200056076049805,
-0.39217352867126465,
0.6571719646453857,
-0.0029121136758476496,
-0.06602130085229874,
0.47073209285736084,
-0.5096378326416016,
-0.3231412470340729,
-0.247558131814003,
0.6345887780189514,
0.4615630507469177,
0.18168990314006805,
-0.051418159157037735,
0.10801125317811966,
0.1917741596698761,
0.31922614574432373,
-0.7759796977043152,
-0.5583575963973999,
0.6099728941917419,
-0.5038031935691833,
0.0152576994150877,
-0.33908912539482117,
-0.3630475103855133,
-0.5044320225715637,
-0.1529293656349182,
0.5078644156455994,
-0.6308977603912354,
-0.24807263910770416,
0.38946256041526794,
-0.14334654808044434,
0.4474274516105652,
0.40484875440597534,
-0.5269159078598022,
0.5378369092941284,
0.6722033023834229,
0.7622409462928772,
-0.31983682513237,
0.11552301794290543,
-0.3322634696960449,
-0.16558633744716644,
-0.409808486700058,
1.0211129188537598,
-0.35881343483924866,
-0.3004366159439087,
-0.1686621755361557,
0.014737104065716267,
-0.2504364848136902,
-0.8478588461875916,
0.6380398273468018,
-0.4397461414337158,
0.16483436524868011,
-0.5392805337905884,
-0.8242536783218384,
-0.12053703516721725,
0.5879098176956177,
-0.6559994220733643,
0.8405690789222717,
0.46522393822669983,
-0.6520464420318604,
0.42752110958099365,
-0.6685512661933899,
-0.04731183126568794,
0.22619092464447021,
-0.6051231026649475,
-0.25799304246902466,
-0.07377572357654572,
0.32233813405036926,
0.23371700942516327,
-0.6301307082176208,
0.008192461915314198,
-0.1157972663640976,
-0.11055023968219757,
0.5626842379570007,
-0.14944373071193695,
0.6322578191757202,
0.33149296045303345,
-0.2519121766090393,
0.0395863838493824,
-0.8259122967720032,
0.4571910798549652,
0.19011510908603668,
-0.16138708591461182,
-0.2811569571495056,
-0.19373878836631775,
-0.2578335106372833,
0.5099973082542419,
0.0869174599647522,
-0.7901003956794739,
0.05844619497656822,
-0.2703996002674103,
0.3164193332195282,
0.45351850986480713,
0.4349101781845093,
-0.05119561403989792,
-0.42439574003219604,
0.8617933392524719,
0.16595891118049622,
0.35975387692451477,
0.22110803425312042,
-0.7448686957359314,
-0.23505502939224243,
-0.5448694825172424,
0.5231912136077881,
0.49883946776390076,
-0.9672585129737854,
-0.007765116635710001,
0.026907674968242645,
-0.612297534942627,
-0.8621895909309387,
-0.0333917997777462,
0.6683849692344666,
0.8031565546989441,
0.6519671678543091,
-0.34327006340026855,
-0.12037738412618637,
-0.8570511341094971,
-0.3109903037548065,
-0.38712337613105774,
-0.41287821531295776,
0.10724281519651413,
0.462269127368927,
0.006418630480766296,
0.4307209551334381,
-0.7912927269935608,
-0.19813930988311768,
0.17171569168567657,
-0.066674143075943,
0.16610044240951538,
0.3577934503555298,
0.5981894135475159,
-0.8696430325508118,
-0.3494865894317627,
-0.312738835811615,
-0.4693729281425476,
0.056316256523132324,
0.20275740325450897,
-0.06811012327671051,
-0.09584503620862961,
0.6081830859184265,
-0.8599021434783936,
0.23047344386577606,
0.6275608539581299,
-0.4601636826992035,
0.6265813112258911,
-0.0524338036775589,
0.3743869662284851,
-1.200330138206482,
0.3053891062736511,
-0.11876720190048218,
-0.003528621979057789,
-0.37114065885543823,
0.44161829352378845,
0.32098883390426636,
-0.047977473586797714,
-0.7610051035881042,
0.43933796882629395,
-0.2777388095855713,
0.1350233107805252,
0.2367451936006546,
0.11104994267225266,
0.07213528454303741,
0.28821462392807007,
-0.0279192253947258,
0.9776193499565125,
0.4094829559326172,
-0.557087242603302,
0.38905709981918335,
0.42671939730644226,
-0.44295328855514526,
0.9524049162864685,
-1.0087151527404785,
0.08235102891921997,
0.2252640426158905,
0.08137991279363632,
-0.9152552485466003,
-0.20819063484668732,
0.1676427721977234,
-0.6449030637741089,
-0.07572028040885925,
0.005555679555982351,
-0.3411504626274109,
-0.44361788034439087,
-0.14827364683151245,
0.509880542755127,
0.3955748677253723,
-0.3289201855659485,
0.2940567135810852,
0.42098432779312134,
-0.0968778133392334,
-0.5530045032501221,
-0.5161826014518738,
-0.28797438740730286,
0.190818652510643,
-0.14428725838661194,
0.23018914461135864,
-0.46453285217285156,
-0.2365468591451645,
0.06188084930181503,
-0.28205451369285583,
-0.5333927273750305,
-0.08435740321874619,
0.2771499752998352,
0.22033819556236267,
-0.376703679561615,
0.3576714098453522,
-0.12162178009748459,
0.009389813989400864,
0.2934473156929016,
-0.16125459969043732,
0.37169718742370605,
0.002757652895525098,
-0.5777848362922668,
-0.43802735209465027,
0.21539679169654846,
0.6357510685920715,
-0.31802064180374146,
0.4328056573867798,
0.26050058007240295,
-0.6216198801994324,
0.21294718980789185,
-0.5003599524497986,
0.01669403351843357,
-0.44878819584846497,
0.2592742443084717,
-0.7278957962989807,
-0.7993703484535217,
0.46845361590385437,
0.03372005373239517,
0.09239091724157333,
0.5416432619094849,
0.8238722681999207,
-0.1957254707813263,
1.0738083124160767,
0.2181621640920639,
0.2604871094226837,
-0.20113986730575562,
-0.06103735417127609,
-0.21782247722148895,
-0.5864109992980957,
-0.34776929020881653,
-0.7333819270133972,
-0.01199556514620781,
-0.6091055274009705,
-0.7948853373527527,
0.6555531620979309,
-0.09321065992116928,
-0.33578619360923767,
0.025395698845386505,
-0.5510417819023132,
0.39209625124931335,
0.6245721578598022,
0.41647952795028687,
0.345741331577301,
-0.3707602620124817,
-0.46279579401016235,
0.08250528573989868,
-0.4279218018054962,
-0.1176535040140152,
1.3044884204864502,
0.3231302797794342,
0.491293728351593,
0.16795872151851654,
0.4817323386669159,
-0.07346596568822861,
0.27243322134017944,
-0.9805224537849426,
0.44341111183166504,
0.014740829356014729,
-0.9598047137260437,
-0.1968526393175125,
-0.4894523322582245,
-0.9393698573112488,
0.024739181622862816,
-0.3641412556171417,
-0.27343374490737915,
0.12528368830680847,
0.12939542531967163,
-0.6683757901191711,
0.26827913522720337,
-0.7383358478546143,
0.976879894733429,
0.08161162585020065,
0.05701187998056412,
-0.14480917155742645,
-0.6396816968917847,
0.3139133155345917,
-0.26523321866989136,
-0.015160391107201576,
-0.37549087405204773,
-0.3762415945529938,
0.6349814534187317,
-0.4785003066062927,
0.29477691650390625,
-0.3923099935054779,
-0.0338912270963192,
0.18302027881145477,
0.018557889387011528,
-0.04632636904716492,
0.20686012506484985,
-0.053873006254434586,
0.2304869294166565,
0.715856671333313,
-0.825365424156189,
-0.5689761638641357,
0.41113463044166565,
-0.8052548170089722,
-0.27054914832115173,
-0.5158438086509705,
-0.33359652757644653,
-0.7935642600059509,
0.18410266935825348,
0.4179200828075409,
0.4551351070404053,
-0.3932158052921295,
0.11699144542217255,
0.7619646787643433,
-0.45378875732421875,
-0.0367678739130497,
0.945976734161377,
0.215824156999588,
-0.4499536454677582,
0.417301207780838,
-0.0048405178822577,
0.5708938837051392,
0.4141737222671509,
-0.032274406403303146,
-0.40452641248703003,
-0.8532240390777588,
-0.4771939814090729,
0.4473174810409546,
-0.7401254177093506,
-0.37608903646469116,
-0.621392011642456,
-0.41071999073028564,
-0.4085323214530945,
0.1726144403219223,
-0.46719714999198914,
-0.542003333568573,
0.17282147705554962,
-0.12495413422584534,
0.32310065627098083,
0.433086633682251,
0.19912372529506683,
-0.02052438259124756,
-0.8501538634300232,
0.832961916923523,
0.46098148822784424,
0.7310273051261902,
-0.6045050024986267,
-0.3189072906970978,
-0.1138317808508873,
-0.06786635518074036,
-0.18414506316184998,
-0.7531951069831848,
-0.19965963065624237,
-0.0075726681388914585,
0.5656061768531799,
0.2599908709526062,
0.21736712753772736,
0.51734459400177,
-0.6474077701568604,
1.0576215982437134,
0.46703025698661804,
-0.7280969619750977,
0.39480769634246826,
-0.13482539355754852,
0.6724644899368286,
0.9364604949951172,
0.7913976311683655,
-0.5945342183113098,
-0.33956363797187805,
-0.5479730367660522,
-0.37690189480781555,
0.1426970511674881,
0.13333189487457275,
-0.20648382604122162,
-0.2389758974313736,
0.5405260324478149,
0.12340614199638367,
0.11639894545078278,
-0.16523589193820953,
-0.18654334545135498,
-0.10858413577079773,
-0.4486299455165863,
-0.22374841570854187,
-0.1741580367088318,
-0.2727726697921753,
-0.4510621726512909,
0.30568477511405945,
-0.2888800799846649,
0.36439141631126404,
0.44370901584625244,
-0.009050293825566769,
-0.08993570506572723,
0.2901134192943573,
0.4632696509361267,
1.0523289442062378,
-0.39476659893989563,
0.06042678281664848,
0.17246924340724945,
-1.032917857170105,
0.2083156704902649,
0.3083677589893341,
0.01826578937470913,
0.0722193643450737,
0.24857185781002045,
0.25594520568847656,
0.1057886853814125,
-0.8807991147041321,
0.7446078062057495,
-0.5339105725288391,
-0.6212776899337769,
-0.3238273859024048,
-0.0070978752337396145,
0.15022829174995422,
0.16394947469234467,
0.19790704548358917,
-0.22175180912017822,
0.29588624835014343,
-0.3471683859825134,
0.4102620482444763,
0.2533593773841858,
-0.5085568428039551,
-0.20096249878406525,
0.786463737487793,
0.03601808100938797,
0.13918258249759674,
0.5551431775093079,
0.1752183884382248,
-0.20222215354442596,
0.6022120714187622,
0.2816368341445923,
0.6180890202522278,
-0.4269721508026123,
0.44977474212646484,
0.5903825759887695,
0.24190662801265717,
0.055786214768886566,
0.8167387843132019,
0.05666153505444527,
-0.6441183686256409,
-0.4641219675540924,
-0.5013788342475891,
-0.9791333675384521,
0.22392705082893372,
-0.812004029750824,
0.1722697615623474,
-0.6301274299621582,
-0.2813928723335266,
0.44696420431137085,
0.1354796141386032,
-0.8680145144462585,
0.594744086265564,
-0.13556940853595734,
1.3962523937225342,
-0.5541194677352905,
0.8565365076065063,
0.8512952923774719,
-0.6988586187362671,
-1.0923513174057007,
0.03680857643485069,
0.1146969422698021,
-0.9393928647041321,
0.22915904223918915,
-0.18370375037193298,
0.10459083318710327,
0.009143952280282974,
-0.6948294639587402,
-0.7364367842674255,
0.9691542387008667,
0.2833619713783264,
-0.2993175685405731,
-0.28056424856185913,
0.20126982033252716,
0.6737648248672485,
-0.1338675618171692,
0.24419890344142914,
0.8254843950271606,
0.14077357947826385,
0.09291580319404602,
-1.1424649953842163,
0.407001793384552,
-0.4049983620643616,
-0.36079123616218567,
0.07097340375185013,
-0.1654513031244278,
0.8849503397941589,
-0.21818453073501587,
-0.17445707321166992,
0.3364751935005188,
0.11120004951953888,
0.46564751863479614,
0.5370785593986511,
0.5337080359458923,
0.5839427709579468,
0.6970093250274658,
-0.18392802774906158,
1.1633307933807373,
-0.38522788882255554,
0.08995454758405685,
1.0207411050796509,
-0.15734855830669403,
1.0253311395645142,
0.43859562277793884,
-0.44557449221611023,
0.576216459274292,
0.7988313436508179,
0.3593498766422272,
0.494552344083786,
0.3286353349685669,
-0.3368486762046814,
-0.12046559900045395,
0.0020391629077494144,
-0.7804445028305054,
0.41103261709213257,
0.5383539199829102,
-0.154659241437912,
-0.1728290319442749,
-0.1215951219201088,
-0.08210698515176773,
0.1019488275051117,
-0.26524579524993896,
0.8721897602081299,
0.20254956185817719,
-0.7362188100814819,
0.9978564977645874,
-0.23179320991039276,
0.12962649762630463,
-0.7786864042282104,
-0.1647564321756363,
-0.11041408777236938,
0.1590092033147812,
-0.028418373316526413,
-0.8198263049125671,
0.07559604197740555,
-0.17629747092723846,
-0.024122199043631554,
0.2670447826385498,
0.41935405135154724,
-0.34729281067848206,
-0.12612700462341309,
-0.039101388305425644,
0.7568673491477966,
0.2972259521484375,
-0.35284996032714844,
-0.947101354598999,
-0.2604590058326721,
-0.41412410140037537,
0.05190081521868706,
0.035601772367954254,
0.4965692162513733,
0.08536554872989655,
0.6237810254096985,
0.6300162076950073,
0.3253943622112274,
-0.09181670844554901,
0.09374590963125229,
0.9929503798484802,
-0.6893318891525269,
-0.3741392195224762,
-0.32395634055137634,
0.2203444540500641,
-0.11717205494642258,
-0.5798722505569458,
0.4748079180717468,
0.4168853163719177,
0.8308520317077637,
-0.11570792645215988,
0.5395909547805786,
0.15098562836647034,
1.0659505128860474,
-0.6705006957054138,
0.7896423935890198,
-0.556088387966156,
-0.10980872064828873,
-0.37358981370925903,
-0.5622019171714783,
-0.359277606010437,
0.09344753623008728,
-0.18465377390384674,
-0.09590853005647659,
1.2162038087844849,
0.6496158242225647,
0.025744108483195305,
-0.011720267124474049,
0.3734837770462036,
0.07362163811922073,
0.12907098233699799,
0.8181936740875244,
0.8233256340026855,
-0.34905359148979187,
0.45182210206985474,
-0.23745597898960114,
-0.3168586194515228,
0.08382837474346161,
-0.42647743225097656,
-0.8206225633621216,
-0.6360138654708862,
-0.44523948431015015,
-0.5842514634132385,
0.17859694361686707,
1.016258955001831,
0.6624100804328918,
-1.0517328977584839,
0.22035692632198334,
0.16019757091999054,
-0.17184670269489288,
-0.5101350545883179,
-0.1743500977754593,
0.6422641277313232,
-0.16912350058555603,
-0.4320593774318695,
0.2582816481590271,
0.004350431263446808,
-0.028938807547092438,
-0.01807194948196411,
-0.0018328233854845166,
-0.2602156400680542,
0.23716026544570923,
0.4377584457397461,
0.4811573922634125,
-0.43964797258377075,
-0.3168254792690277,
0.2703322470188141,
-0.4278932511806488,
0.11217121034860611,
0.9036110043525696,
-0.7206945419311523,
0.6124071478843689,
0.27104243636131287,
0.8538732528686523,
0.29967495799064636,
0.06552456319332123,
0.5348297357559204,
-0.4904153048992157,
-0.04837493970990181,
0.4206964373588562,
0.20730644464492798,
0.2289593666791916,
-0.12668311595916748,
0.6495763063430786,
0.21460752189159393,
-0.3786669373512268,
-0.6115493178367615,
0.18643386662006378,
-1.0216296911239624,
-0.45261886715888977,
0.9518627524375916,
-0.2916819155216217,
-0.1820807009935379,
-0.3695014715194702,
-0.1851135492324829,
0.2544363737106323,
0.027170566841959953,
0.7104803323745728,
0.4475111663341522,
-0.19622650742530823,
-0.15609782934188843,
-0.8901277184486389,
0.8570240139961243,
0.4515860080718994,
-1.0939055681228638,
-0.37376388907432556,
0.6080666780471802,
0.6878358125686646,
0.03511927276849747,
1.1052677631378174,
-0.6246063113212585,
0.8501518964767456,
-0.08030302822589874,
0.23191362619400024,
0.15042968094348907,
0.11412817239761353,
-0.23104074597358704,
0.21260569989681244,
0.24167971312999725,
-0.6834519505500793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07320v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07320v1
|
L(u)PIN: LLM-based Political Ideology Nowcasting
| 2024-05-12T16:14:07 | 2024-05-12T16:14:07 |
Ken Kato, Annabelle Purnomo, Christopher Cochrane, Raeid Saqur
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The quantitative analysis of political ideological positions is a difficult
task. In the past, various literature focused on parliamentary voting data of
politicians, party manifestos and parliamentary speech to estimate political
disagreement and polarization in various political systems. However previous
methods of quantitative political analysis suffered from a common challenge
which was the amount of data available for analysis. Also previous methods
frequently focused on a more general analysis of politics such as overall
polarization of the parliament or party-wide political ideological positions.
In this paper, we present a method to analyze ideological positions of
individual parliamentary representatives by leveraging the latent knowledge of
LLMs. The method allows us to evaluate the stance of politicians on an axis of
our choice allowing us to flexibly measure the stance of politicians in regards
to a topic/controversy of our choice. We achieve this by using a fine-tuned
BERT classifier to extract the opinion-based sentences from the speeches of
representatives and projecting the average BERT embeddings for each
representative on a pair of reference seeds. These reference seeds are either
manually chosen representatives known to have opposing views on a particular
topic or they are generated sentences which where created using the GPT-4 model
of OpenAI. We created the sentences by prompting the GPT-4 model to generate a
speech that would come from a politician defending a particular position.
|
[
-0.29796791076660156,
-0.3534359931945801,
0.4772421717643738,
0.05204085633158684,
-0.4652126133441925,
-0.0006608658586628735,
-0.10171852260828018,
0.18332062661647797,
0.5967750549316406,
0.5935908555984497,
-0.47470974922180176,
-0.5549429059028625,
-0.4961196780204773,
-0.2172122746706009,
0.1025935485959053,
0.9395166635513306,
0.2714396119117737,
0.5182139277458191,
0.001103667076677084,
-0.1646655946969986,
-0.13575370609760284,
-0.7115669250488281,
-0.24772123992443085,
-0.5027854442596436,
0.67105633020401,
0.3369580805301666,
0.5570344924926758,
0.380134254693985,
0.2087392956018448,
0.29289522767066956,
-0.010224420577287674,
-0.18208496272563934,
-0.5607120394706726,
0.07495293766260147,
-0.1472613513469696,
-0.8184571862220764,
-0.2986672520637512,
0.5587237477302551,
0.6522284150123596,
0.18642638623714447,
-0.07429370284080505,
-0.105521060526371,
0.04432285949587822,
0.48768675327301025,
-0.38422292470932007,
0.2018229067325592,
-1.1399519443511963,
0.11233677715063095,
-0.48675331473350525,
-0.4671209454536438,
-0.2988094091415405,
-0.7699810862541199,
0.057018063962459564,
0.0236489437520504,
-0.07207941263914108,
-0.12580525875091553,
0.7339062094688416,
0.07803957164287567,
-0.40096044540405273,
-0.39587417244911194,
-0.4114515781402588,
1.0572963953018188,
-1.0754523277282715,
-0.05310544744133949,
0.15366949141025543,
0.3396538197994232,
-0.09847546368837357,
-0.4172068238258362,
-0.5340582728385925,
0.11649738997220993,
0.06793136894702911,
0.23250098526477814,
0.19464042782783508,
0.017192699015140533,
-0.1945006251335144,
0.15027572214603424,
-0.1765691488981247,
-0.02071213722229004,
-0.10247340798377991,
-0.013726762495934963,
0.5744607448577881,
0.014079846441745758,
-0.05096615105867386,
-0.9111082553863525,
-0.5247436165809631,
0.005234189797192812,
-0.8686679601669312,
0.005498921498656273,
0.9231441617012024,
0.13999682664871216,
0.06336230039596558,
0.8014618158340454,
0.029203012585639954,
0.3774484097957611,
0.36897218227386475,
-0.14030185341835022,
-0.04001851752400398,
-0.1759251207113266,
0.008439918048679829,
-0.11062338203191757,
0.8832282423973083,
0.32878151535987854,
0.2261408567428589,
0.36124974489212036,
-0.10066799074411392,
-0.04140807315707207,
0.044493384659290314,
-0.6603891849517822,
-0.37736478447914124,
0.13976699113845825,
-0.8262261748313904,
-0.38845303654670715,
0.0566304549574852,
-1.0432636737823486,
-0.6355475187301636,
-0.28266021609306335,
0.14694280922412872,
-0.3221929967403412,
-0.28146329522132874,
-0.6222073435783386,
-0.20267684757709503,
0.5595971941947937,
0.11055002361536026,
-0.8769195675849915,
-0.2997296452522278,
0.9103808999061584,
0.7106514573097229,
-0.15993107855319977,
0.26092973351478577,
-0.03392209857702255,
0.28044748306274414,
-0.16190606355667114,
0.9824844002723694,
-0.8355724811553955,
-0.2668799161911011,
-0.03663894906640053,
-0.30195391178131104,
-0.0689905509352684,
-0.3551454544067383,
0.4262111485004425,
-0.5208704471588135,
0.45478516817092896,
-0.3331519067287445,
-0.8116735219955444,
-0.20646870136260986,
0.32040801644325256,
-0.3494388461112976,
0.5607026219367981,
-0.05559279024600983,
-0.954999566078186,
0.383820116519928,
-0.612478494644165,
0.18831519782543182,
-0.1497287005186081,
-0.9763407707214355,
-0.384528785943985,
0.04926619678735733,
0.2474692016839981,
0.8936136960983276,
-0.03947471082210541,
0.6082702279090881,
-0.41314050555229187,
-0.10838543623685837,
0.36029329895973206,
-0.419756144285202,
0.9825796484947205,
0.11743903905153275,
-0.40632912516593933,
0.6133725047111511,
-0.6883408427238464,
0.09130939841270447,
-0.16827760636806488,
-0.0026470499578863382,
-0.4211564064025879,
0.5410867929458618,
-0.3872033953666687,
0.0637994334101677,
0.39390164613723755,
-0.6348922848701477,
0.45100969076156616,
-0.5562455654144287,
0.5354191064834595,
1.2713748216629028,
0.26348382234573364,
0.44159674644470215,
-0.2766067683696747,
0.3427979052066803,
-0.21223200857639313,
0.09942077845335007,
0.3107377886772156,
-0.8085163235664368,
-0.6893931031227112,
-0.2683054804801941,
0.29250240325927734,
0.7995441555976868,
-0.7535538077354431,
0.41152265667915344,
-0.2734466791152954,
-0.4826962649822235,
-0.41404420137405396,
-0.05135897919535637,
0.0866178423166275,
0.049446966499090195,
-0.03825350105762482,
0.10342957079410553,
-0.5330250859260559,
-1.073380947113037,
-0.30765971541404724,
-0.7033289670944214,
-0.14599712193012238,
0.3363597095012665,
0.437783420085907,
0.06020896136760712,
1.1214337348937988,
-0.3405824899673462,
-0.025159927085042,
-0.21140462160110474,
0.6543416380882263,
0.5143560767173767,
0.18852761387825012,
0.3474399447441101,
-0.7145371437072754,
-0.446429580450058,
-0.0383991077542305,
-0.569381833076477,
-0.3274763822555542,
-0.07732634246349335,
-0.1749846339225769,
0.14918175339698792,
0.07235844433307648,
-0.2834503650665283,
0.3815460205078125,
0.46523046493530273,
-0.28912708163261414,
0.292681485414505,
0.2653293013572693,
0.06941603869199753,
-1.1696096658706665,
-0.214623361825943,
-0.28338974714279175,
-0.12402980774641037,
-0.33837154507637024,
-0.08644592016935349,
-0.2220323234796524,
0.057345885783433914,
-0.7389981150627136,
0.2598640024662018,
-0.28592371940612793,
0.09040827304124832,
-0.22622883319854736,
-0.029026707634329796,
-0.4885486662387848,
0.5845118761062622,
0.017201609909534454,
0.5123037695884705,
0.05986504629254341,
-0.017360379919409752,
0.3651425838470459,
0.15006312727928162,
-0.30638283491134644,
0.8197025060653687,
-0.35073789954185486,
0.44894224405288696,
-0.039629507809877396,
0.015742959454655647,
-1.2145185470581055,
-0.1629897654056549,
0.6875948905944824,
-0.27522510290145874,
0.3793831169605255,
-0.43817248940467834,
-0.17512446641921997,
0.013188294135034084,
-0.4322228729724884,
0.03936491534113884,
0.44910505414009094,
-0.275147944688797,
0.6654706001281738,
0.5207238793373108,
-0.49765679240226746,
-0.7600000500679016,
-0.11859164386987686,
-0.13862432539463043,
-0.5288102030754089,
-0.5603815317153931,
0.2857961654663086,
0.2653829753398895,
-0.6419657468795776,
0.12451205402612686,
0.03760354593396187,
-0.027943700551986694,
-0.5507717132568359,
0.39152956008911133,
0.1113298162817955,
-0.2663698196411133,
-0.26123812794685364,
-0.045041002333164215,
-0.20302599668502808,
0.08643838763237,
-0.0239225085824728,
0.46802082657814026,
0.10068175196647644,
-0.37407514452934265,
-0.5350128412246704,
0.5491123199462891,
0.33352261781692505,
-0.056427277624607086,
0.6604916453361511,
0.3549976050853729,
0.06166594848036766,
-0.16392232477664948,
-0.5865715742111206,
-0.11062508076429367,
-0.44285809993743896,
0.17139045894145966,
-0.10919235646724701,
-0.6705559492111206,
0.4678983688354492,
-0.1567436307668686,
0.21823568642139435,
0.5032075047492981,
0.8606268167495728,
-0.3080136179924011,
0.789533257484436,
0.3882419168949127,
-0.44602957367897034,
0.3671945631504059,
-0.2660565674304962,
0.2025146782398224,
-0.3253398835659027,
-0.31378012895584106,
-0.5970644354820251,
-0.5007653832435608,
-0.5848535299301147,
-0.6390935182571411,
0.36576810479164124,
-0.263105571269989,
-0.32279855012893677,
-0.21353426575660706,
-0.5506381392478943,
0.2955078184604645,
0.4492725729942322,
0.11626692861318588,
-0.27428191900253296,
0.04630962386727333,
-0.09700627624988556,
-0.4293082356452942,
-0.37598198652267456,
-0.6373807787895203,
1.0496761798858643,
0.3924156427383423,
0.908403217792511,
-0.01401527225971222,
0.6857720017433167,
0.3576042652130127,
0.63639897108078,
-0.7694419026374817,
0.7862144708633423,
-0.2901061773300171,
-0.5710467100143433,
-0.31112775206565857,
-0.5004203915596008,
-0.44992953538894653,
0.3122708201408386,
-0.1301453858613968,
-0.5290426015853882,
0.3917217254638672,
-0.16022807359695435,
-0.18351946771144867,
0.7205342054367065,
-0.19285573065280914,
0.6311376690864563,
-0.629508376121521,
-0.20976586639881134,
-0.364142507314682,
-0.6572824716567993,
0.22669631242752075,
0.1948067843914032,
-0.05887826159596443,
-0.3623572885990143,
-0.17938269674777985,
1.1774591207504272,
-0.2521878182888031,
1.168320894241333,
-0.7550696134567261,
-0.17083297669887543,
0.2763656675815582,
-0.39532774686813354,
0.466184139251709,
-0.06410659104585648,
-0.49910807609558105,
0.487052321434021,
0.029224425554275513,
-0.24350184202194214,
-0.6388283371925354,
0.7639212012290955,
-1.2217209339141846,
-0.8575801253318787,
-0.6137173771858215,
-0.45993804931640625,
-0.027506159618496895,
0.115199014544487,
0.18624961376190186,
0.20348384976387024,
-0.3279356062412262,
0.4347556531429291,
0.25470229983329773,
-0.1479797512292862,
0.43869543075561523,
0.2670977711677551,
-0.09829755872488022,
-0.8273583650588989,
0.8401092886924744,
0.37424805760383606,
-0.08513329923152924,
0.6265224814414978,
0.40700364112854004,
-0.4565456807613373,
-0.6266220808029175,
0.008197296410799026,
0.2351221740245819,
-0.6004694700241089,
-0.1744646579027176,
-0.2090008705854416,
-0.03489739075303078,
-0.17965266108512878,
-0.12232032418251038,
-0.21790659427642822,
-0.479001522064209,
-0.1461252123117447,
0.28453710675239563,
0.10132437944412231,
0.8484686017036438,
0.08574656397104263,
0.8543466925621033,
-0.13812129199504852,
0.30925530195236206,
0.40812423825263977,
0.15702380239963531,
-0.5705550909042358,
-0.2782045602798462,
0.253385990858078,
0.04866034537553787,
-0.8113405704498291,
-1.5349255800247192,
0.475822389125824,
0.17112144827842712,
0.7754373550415039,
0.9267224073410034,
0.23835952579975128,
0.47259536385536194,
-0.541380763053894,
1.088403582572937,
0.006281842011958361,
-0.6935234069824219,
0.5853443741798401,
-0.41031643748283386,
-0.396913081407547,
0.32781389355659485,
0.4971315562725067,
-0.002128977794200182,
-0.44881728291511536,
-0.5985745787620544,
-0.7401536703109741,
0.5450917482376099,
0.30066484212875366,
-0.007063837256282568,
-0.016025498509407043,
0.5171318650245667,
0.2309604436159134,
0.25816184282302856,
-0.7216074466705322,
-0.28274163603782654,
-0.40013986825942993,
-0.2903309166431427,
-0.041900426149368286,
-0.5955291390419006,
-0.3491228222846985,
-0.2908516228199005,
0.8089339733123779,
-0.16237826645374298,
0.6152417063713074,
-0.01270892471075058,
0.38747525215148926,
0.1270563155412674,
0.5387407541275024,
0.4334443509578705,
0.8196672201156616,
-0.5234200954437256,
0.11408691108226776,
-0.14055587351322174,
0.18449975550174713,
0.3634464144706726,
-0.08694406598806381,
-0.11703859269618988,
0.24179217219352722,
0.07479037344455719,
0.5733524560928345,
0.05295038968324661,
0.15593110024929047,
0.5790301561355591,
0.2153003215789795,
-0.020064961165189743,
-0.7248817086219788,
-0.23195332288742065,
0.2803703546524048,
0.267304003238678,
0.24421904981136322,
0.14928506314754486,
-0.211701437830925,
-0.8020044565200806,
0.34214264154434204,
0.9686838984489441,
-0.2970890998840332,
-0.32030820846557617,
0.43986234068870544,
0.4585399627685547,
-0.3704318404197693,
0.3416179418563843,
0.08571440726518631,
-0.6482262015342712,
0.36406341195106506,
0.36424243450164795,
0.7267249226570129,
-0.5173752307891846,
0.3878011107444763,
-0.04270785301923752,
0.06086916849017143,
0.5636500120162964,
0.5280190110206604,
0.09101159870624542,
-0.7475659251213074,
-0.49412694573402405,
-0.47063174843788147,
-0.5398321747779846,
0.3136976361274719,
-0.5621639490127563,
0.26729559898376465,
-0.6239307522773743,
-0.40841156244277954,
-0.07244399935007095,
0.3367163836956024,
-0.1282280683517456,
-0.13561341166496277,
0.0978165939450264,
0.5557546615600586,
-0.8611632585525513,
0.8874419927597046,
0.5744587779045105,
0.08502566069364548,
-0.6130213737487793,
0.19875530898571014,
0.09303298592567444,
-0.9892347455024719,
0.5013031959533691,
0.030923975631594658,
0.036857571452856064,
-0.3108576536178589,
-0.6859114766120911,
-0.3869353234767914,
0.8934229612350464,
0.4043102562427521,
-0.4485698938369751,
-0.12623359262943268,
0.21461854875087738,
0.1894674152135849,
-0.4668758809566498,
0.47700607776641846,
0.17523716390132904,
0.6027411222457886,
0.03628258779644966,
-0.2598870098590851,
-0.20449596643447876,
-0.14856505393981934,
-0.38101479411125183,
0.4430813789367676,
-0.8233664631843567,
1.1185613870620728,
0.4474451541900635,
0.14668796956539154,
0.12714718282222748,
0.9201881885528564,
0.18834684789180756,
0.33716344833374023,
0.6135755777359009,
0.16032682359218597,
0.7073850631713867,
-0.020846527069807053,
0.692842960357666,
-0.48453792929649353,
0.15326140820980072,
0.7708033919334412,
-0.24669206142425537,
1.1573188304901123,
0.8150020837783813,
-0.17279627919197083,
0.6334355473518372,
0.4892578721046448,
0.059761181473731995,
0.6525772213935852,
0.4030580520629883,
-0.25703123211860657,
-0.24367281794548035,
0.11180148273706436,
-0.3244953155517578,
0.5964545011520386,
0.4882637858390808,
-0.27906787395477295,
-0.15147200226783752,
-0.19527007639408112,
0.003717881627380848,
0.19180138409137726,
-0.30496641993522644,
0.6979947090148926,
0.17197223007678986,
-0.49106889963150024,
0.35175928473472595,
-0.03161974996328354,
0.883445143699646,
-0.7534406185150146,
-0.31808921694755554,
-0.026940345764160156,
0.23435187339782715,
-0.1557273417711258,
-0.9966450929641724,
0.3373509645462036,
0.03108121268451214,
-0.09775813668966293,
-0.47646552324295044,
0.6441279649734497,
-0.1747463345527649,
-0.4063292443752289,
0.10224052518606186,
0.5569056272506714,
0.5292723178863525,
-0.030293745920062065,
-0.7821696400642395,
-0.080605149269104,
0.378998339176178,
-0.24578900635242462,
0.17308185994625092,
0.4247837960720062,
-0.10530706495046616,
0.34006422758102417,
0.3816906809806824,
0.3985133171081543,
-0.16592712700366974,
-0.19275003671646118,
0.868435263633728,
-0.7155048847198486,
-0.5406357645988464,
-0.9725282192230225,
0.19465570151805878,
-0.2254757285118103,
-0.11667045950889587,
0.7967511415481567,
0.41054171323776245,
0.4258611798286438,
-0.017147939652204514,
0.7740042805671692,
-0.32313141226768494,
0.6292410492897034,
-0.6427552103996277,
1.056756854057312,
-0.3291594386100769,
0.3317797780036926,
-0.07812874764204025,
-0.8277496695518494,
0.0015447562327608466,
0.9665565490722656,
-0.7286859750747681,
-0.22650432586669922,
0.34970623254776,
0.9548214077949524,
0.014291550032794476,
0.2053007185459137,
0.18487833440303802,
0.3742683231830597,
0.26338568329811096,
0.4185301959514618,
1.2082712650299072,
0.2972545325756073,
0.3590819239616394,
-0.36303484439849854,
-0.3142687678337097,
0.07362209260463715,
-1.0175702571868896,
-1.1607270240783691,
-0.4814842641353607,
-0.04321007803082466,
-0.0640215128660202,
0.14483478665351868,
0.9099351763725281,
0.7899644374847412,
-0.9161375761032104,
-0.45477375388145447,
0.3458976745605469,
0.16315306723117828,
0.13757073879241943,
-0.2253560572862625,
0.6426323652267456,
0.059033602476119995,
-0.6012086868286133,
0.21423400938510895,
0.0918746143579483,
-0.3473896086215973,
-0.5392386317253113,
0.08789453655481339,
-0.41045671701431274,
0.3183184564113617,
0.3810586631298065,
0.06180276349186897,
-1.2092186212539673,
-0.7311891317367554,
-0.3537231981754303,
0.1664372831583023,
0.28704896569252014,
0.9824815988540649,
-0.6457281708717346,
0.2057839035987854,
0.6070707440376282,
0.26290687918663025,
0.016376959159970284,
0.3143506944179535,
0.6731180548667908,
-0.8623868823051453,
0.2758577764034271,
0.4344635009765625,
0.1711280345916748,
0.2797820568084717,
-0.2754649817943573,
0.3138794004917145,
0.2927485406398773,
-0.6395570039749146,
-0.49834296107292175,
0.16087132692337036,
-1.0360935926437378,
-0.07838962227106094,
1.0601330995559692,
-0.32746368646621704,
-0.3013109564781189,
-0.0010317724663764238,
-0.6329260468482971,
0.41553908586502075,
-0.4641987681388855,
0.4952062964439392,
0.4633926451206207,
-0.456692099571228,
-0.23879536986351013,
-0.34316813945770264,
0.29535186290740967,
0.40232592821121216,
-0.5621910095214844,
-0.30744197964668274,
0.23859235644340515,
0.2829180359840393,
0.17320507764816284,
0.775362491607666,
-0.18747973442077637,
-0.4414658844470978,
-0.11756424605846405,
-0.12125763297080994,
0.26903244853019714,
-0.17972412705421448,
-0.18425743281841278,
0.5316207408905029,
-0.2225034385919571,
-0.3608415126800537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07282v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07282v1
|
Branching Narratives: Character Decision Points Detection
| 2024-05-12T13:36:07 | 2024-05-12T13:36:07 |
Alexey Tikhonov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
This paper presents the Character Decision Points Detection (CHADPOD) task, a
task of identification of points within narratives where characters make
decisions that may significantly influence the story's direction. We propose a
novel dataset based on CYOA-like games graphs to be used as a benchmark for
such a task. We provide a comparative analysis of different models' performance
on this task, including a couple of LLMs and several MLMs as baselines,
achieving up to 89% accuracy. This underscores the complexity of narrative
analysis, showing the challenges associated with understanding character-driven
story dynamics. Additionally, we show how such a model can be applied to the
existing text to produce linear segments divided by potential branching points,
demonstrating the practical application of our findings in narrative analysis.
|
[
-0.10382576286792755,
-0.5795491337776184,
1.0292209386825562,
0.005673248786479235,
-0.2614787518978119,
0.3302318751811981,
0.25011739134788513,
-0.5059799551963806,
0.38269034028053284,
0.5503637790679932,
-1.1876099109649658,
-0.9502690434455872,
-0.5454055070877075,
0.26075461506843567,
-0.2771267294883728,
0.9544162750244141,
-0.20389686524868011,
-0.22061622142791748,
-0.20473115146160126,
-0.2257826179265976,
-0.6259216070175171,
-0.444161981344223,
-0.9365414977073669,
-0.18503165245056152,
0.7920547127723694,
0.38627591729164124,
0.6847970485687256,
0.6220546960830688,
0.34414049983024597,
0.293206125497818,
-0.31604596972465515,
0.4344847798347473,
-0.5991312265396118,
0.6479588150978088,
-0.2138819545507431,
-0.9134427309036255,
-0.09374531358480453,
0.05926889181137085,
0.553801953792572,
0.7446147799491882,
0.40152251720428467,
0.1521790325641632,
-0.08782952278852463,
0.7483157515525818,
-0.23243489861488342,
0.04104045033454895,
-0.08876651525497437,
0.41305190324783325,
-0.10390295833349228,
-0.1901024729013443,
-0.028950775042176247,
-0.4810960292816162,
-0.07219387590885162,
-0.5862588882446289,
0.3995591104030609,
0.3247900903224945,
0.8233882188796997,
-0.1826452612876892,
-0.609047532081604,
-0.9151259660720825,
-0.6590990424156189,
0.6717773079872131,
-0.46835243701934814,
-0.08916737139225006,
0.4537225067615509,
0.08401291072368622,
-0.1884753555059433,
-0.40907177329063416,
-0.4150735139846802,
-0.2741504907608032,
-0.18871504068374634,
-0.26094892621040344,
-0.4210715889930725,
0.04180300235748291,
0.29882147908210754,
0.17145633697509766,
-0.3903270363807678,
0.18842479586601257,
-0.48038631677627563,
-0.06416179984807968,
0.9424540996551514,
0.6691073179244995,
0.3888462483882904,
-0.6171651482582092,
-0.36263883113861084,
-0.12548375129699707,
-0.5089386701583862,
0.4151062071323395,
0.8494470715522766,
0.26559507846832275,
-0.025563888251781464,
0.8594655394554138,
-0.033188410103321075,
0.49489912390708923,
0.31604358553886414,
-0.3885635733604431,
0.11148027330636978,
-0.5319174528121948,
-0.025543412193655968,
0.29470598697662354,
0.853047251701355,
0.7905836701393127,
0.31620797514915466,
0.14313416182994843,
-0.24592234194278717,
-0.2489822655916214,
0.2192089706659317,
-0.7435570955276489,
-0.15894369781017303,
0.4257815182209015,
-0.9141592383384705,
-0.6900572776794434,
-0.5348798632621765,
-0.6649984121322632,
-1.2837252616882324,
-0.06422856450080872,
-0.24520078301429749,
-0.9691699147224426,
-0.24432606995105743,
-0.5436404347419739,
-0.5358452796936035,
0.014572628773748875,
0.3788183629512787,
-1.0581141710281372,
0.033420078456401825,
0.8273078799247742,
1.435988426208496,
-0.4508984684944153,
-0.12318586558103561,
-0.4240817129611969,
0.010535146109759808,
-0.7366917729377747,
0.9822130799293518,
-0.48609796166419983,
-0.6801770329475403,
-0.14694567024707794,
0.019396021962165833,
-0.0710580050945282,
-0.43176504969596863,
0.7987381219863892,
-0.03957151994109154,
-0.16316598653793335,
-0.5506312251091003,
-1.0691834688186646,
-0.3469325304031372,
0.6883416771888733,
-0.6298145055770874,
0.6677626967430115,
0.042135704308748245,
-0.423130065202713,
0.6267092227935791,
-0.191916361451149,
-0.47292661666870117,
-0.038684140890836716,
-0.5420231223106384,
-0.2106972187757492,
0.22704024612903595,
0.2357010394334793,
0.39749473333358765,
-0.07738528400659561,
0.14425398409366608,
-0.04537171870470047,
-0.3274320065975189,
0.18366460502147675,
-0.20013734698295593,
1.0239195823669434,
0.06571023911237717,
-0.07766048610210419,
0.40807586908340454,
-0.8553712964057922,
-0.17381253838539124,
0.013428355567157269,
-0.15446613729000092,
-0.3101559281349182,
0.4405798614025116,
-0.14682206511497498,
-0.0021413550712168217,
-0.21563640236854553,
-0.37712886929512024,
0.48916658759117126,
0.2898216247558594,
0.10672751814126968,
0.4994729161262512,
0.2970326840877533,
0.13937310874462128,
-0.4481983482837677,
0.9551384449005127,
-0.02524229697883129,
-0.2196032851934433,
-0.532118558883667,
-1.0522149801254272,
-0.5931830406188965,
-0.442704439163208,
0.3027515113353729,
0.3631366491317749,
-0.6285387277603149,
0.4940398633480072,
0.175611212849617,
-0.7338533401489258,
0.020532701164484024,
-0.12364830076694489,
0.1253153532743454,
0.3963448405265808,
-0.06244851276278496,
-0.32622575759887695,
-0.3879270553588867,
-0.482796311378479,
-0.2526635527610779,
-0.7170307636260986,
-0.23184561729431152,
0.2948208749294281,
0.3049493730068207,
0.053840864449739456,
0.9033929109573364,
-0.4495513439178467,
-0.3466417193412781,
-0.4962666928768158,
0.5800776481628418,
0.4704184830188751,
0.5465917587280273,
0.7354605197906494,
-0.7496273517608643,
-0.23482781648635864,
0.05942818149924278,
-0.9124398231506348,
-0.05718560516834259,
-0.5381201505661011,
0.036532361060380936,
-0.22016017138957977,
0.8543463349342346,
-0.7293605208396912,
0.6630060076713562,
0.46338164806365967,
-0.9556971788406372,
1.0458617210388184,
-0.14346009492874146,
0.5760902166366577,
-0.5723174214363098,
0.105719193816185,
-0.15658876299858093,
-0.359927773475647,
-0.7848507165908813,
-0.11428530514240265,
-0.037284452468156815,
-0.2337893396615982,
-0.04963749274611473,
0.39618441462516785,
-0.37053024768829346,
-0.32059618830680847,
-0.1270923763513565,
0.33609312772750854,
-0.017036788165569305,
0.702486515045166,
0.1791554093360901,
0.34497883915901184,
0.06185603141784668,
-0.6084343791007996,
0.5131080150604248,
0.3625980615615845,
-0.6133622527122498,
1.0286803245544434,
-0.47170567512512207,
-0.007897118106484413,
-0.15476255118846893,
-0.02225658670067787,
-1.4576084613800049,
0.05287621170282364,
0.5048598647117615,
-0.46722376346588135,
-0.032604943960905075,
-0.6471898555755615,
-0.34229105710983276,
-0.07061859220266342,
-0.14982332289218903,
0.2900601625442505,
0.032362956553697586,
-0.24324513971805573,
0.6132838129997253,
-0.018851693719625473,
-0.4018123745918274,
-0.3117021322250366,
-0.46156203746795654,
-0.04671645164489746,
-0.3709273338317871,
-0.5816501379013062,
0.39493444561958313,
-0.04168377444148064,
-0.26806995272636414,
0.07349621504545212,
0.1017024889588356,
-0.0710216760635376,
-0.2608101963996887,
0.48098862171173096,
0.1311693638563156,
-0.3427135646343231,
0.2950916290283203,
0.18413227796554565,
-0.06732203811407089,
0.01321863941848278,
-0.09325985610485077,
0.54973965883255,
0.14969778060913086,
-0.2970283329486847,
-0.3026791512966156,
0.32057610154151917,
0.6337547302246094,
0.06332089751958847,
0.31112563610076904,
0.4987563490867615,
-0.12426143139600754,
0.18696478009223938,
0.004159200005233288,
0.45342516899108887,
-0.4407970905303955,
0.3753468096256256,
-0.28282099962234497,
-0.39766359329223633,
0.6432086825370789,
-0.16990219056606293,
0.06390119343996048,
0.4496346712112427,
0.32783806324005127,
-0.4918360710144043,
0.8908368945121765,
0.5202572345733643,
0.01224327553063631,
0.6107902526855469,
-0.12144331634044647,
0.09762043505907059,
-0.5577326416969299,
-0.24826590716838837,
-0.41580653190612793,
-0.9311771392822266,
-0.5594024062156677,
-0.6062518954277039,
0.13716119527816772,
0.5982571244239807,
-0.08159919828176498,
0.4450157880783081,
-0.06157549470663071,
0.6031947731971741,
0.5428129434585571,
-0.11634229123592377,
0.596412181854248,
-0.22089971601963043,
-0.4471728801727295,
0.07880456000566483,
-0.47229433059692383,
-0.620780885219574,
1.09004545211792,
0.3807320296764374,
0.2562044560909271,
0.21816405653953552,
0.8047410249710083,
0.6883342266082764,
-0.191776305437088,
-0.8523606657981873,
0.5012810230255127,
-0.010859889909625053,
-0.814459502696991,
-0.5488157868385315,
-0.3209840655326843,
-1.0902658700942993,
0.1696295589208603,
-0.3777158260345459,
-1.1983182430267334,
0.8672847151756287,
-0.30265364050865173,
-0.6636722683906555,
0.45912933349609375,
-0.5861299633979797,
0.8823991417884827,
-0.45919445157051086,
-0.1400865614414215,
-0.3015928566455841,
-0.3415733575820923,
0.24157308042049408,
0.18985359370708466,
-0.05140089616179466,
-0.4284747838973999,
-0.09578555822372437,
0.7867253422737122,
-0.48365986347198486,
0.7138906121253967,
-0.15699130296707153,
0.026143671944737434,
0.6594356894493103,
0.43481704592704773,
0.5456364750862122,
0.16655580699443817,
-0.2736014723777771,
0.20801469683647156,
0.2623051404953003,
-0.34512969851493835,
-0.4140094220638275,
0.5093749165534973,
-0.5539970397949219,
-0.28570666909217834,
-0.6345710754394531,
-0.8974825739860535,
-0.3715314567089081,
0.2502352297306061,
0.24428126215934753,
0.2185853272676468,
-0.5161847472190857,
-0.1346253603696823,
0.1381012499332428,
-0.20809386670589447,
0.6209386587142944,
0.14533059298992157,
-0.7502813339233398,
-0.15319909155368805,
0.6794843077659607,
-0.08995294570922852,
0.1759510338306427,
0.1332501769065857,
0.023601433262228966,
-0.05831081420183182,
-0.9365792870521545,
-0.7266518473625183,
0.04891229048371315,
-0.6950342059135437,
-0.10717739909887314,
-0.20350216329097748,
-0.1644069254398346,
0.2959841191768646,
-0.36831095814704895,
-0.2719608247280121,
-0.49781402945518494,
-0.34221386909484863,
-0.43160131573677063,
0.16430208086967468,
1.138973355293274,
-0.054970283061265945,
0.3682365119457245,
-0.6098877787590027,
0.21474047005176544,
0.16520890593528748,
0.05386465787887573,
-0.19827434420585632,
0.09862939268350601,
0.1273244023323059,
-0.1529981940984726,
-0.445377379655838,
-1.0631787776947021,
0.5640676021575928,
-0.11415860801935196,
0.270206093788147,
0.9353681206703186,
-0.2688842713832855,
0.49559321999549866,
-0.3771856129169464,
0.8019612431526184,
0.5295284390449524,
-0.8233888745307922,
0.47944706678390503,
-0.5355651378631592,
0.3939434587955475,
0.6429384350776672,
0.7430769205093384,
-0.8718147873878479,
-0.11783663183450699,
-0.576494038105011,
-0.31288114190101624,
0.8982486724853516,
0.7630072236061096,
-0.07008056342601776,
0.1999751478433609,
0.3384081721305847,
0.16596080362796783,
0.3499598503112793,
-0.2723102569580078,
-0.19768327474594116,
0.39052465558052063,
-0.23846778273582458,
-0.27161338925361633,
-0.3876262605190277,
0.06488662213087082,
-0.14916805922985077,
0.21762847900390625,
-0.10175620764493942,
0.2833556532859802,
0.2724989056587219,
-0.029585450887680054,
-0.41991567611694336,
-0.3052426874637604,
0.4107075035572052,
0.9796928763389587,
-0.3949037492275238,
-0.07653174549341202,
-0.11923275887966156,
-0.5356907248497009,
0.24596811830997467,
0.07298965752124786,
-0.3408631682395935,
0.4200138449668884,
1.0537219047546387,
0.8561105728149414,
0.21331161260604858,
-0.9640937447547913,
0.3980664908885956,
-0.26475080847740173,
-0.08579841256141663,
0.19713227450847626,
0.14083315432071686,
0.16353121399879456,
0.827301561832428,
0.3775852918624878,
0.29281172156333923,
0.09245987236499786,
-0.9518396258354187,
0.0392250157892704,
0.0012872728984802961,
-0.7451306581497192,
0.02860902063548565,
0.04671677201986313,
0.3221902549266815,
-0.7574641108512878,
0.9163255095481873,
-0.5794739127159119,
-0.48705658316612244,
1.1318110227584839,
0.23088178038597107,
0.7310230135917664,
-0.08624327182769775,
0.8321095705032349,
0.5090001225471497,
0.33014458417892456,
0.5568745136260986,
-0.011220932006835938,
-0.13315965235233307,
-0.7247896194458008,
0.06495855748653412,
-0.44210657477378845,
-0.43342354893684387,
0.03889723867177963,
-0.46799811720848083,
0.54925936460495,
-0.7008335590362549,
-0.11201032251119614,
0.2982405424118042,
0.07807959616184235,
-0.4640081822872162,
0.26801609992980957,
0.6294097304344177,
0.48032301664352417,
-0.49159693717956543,
0.35987257957458496,
0.3054267168045044,
-0.30693647265434265,
-0.3612554669380188,
0.25332143902778625,
0.3371026813983917,
-0.6406080722808838,
0.6431993842124939,
0.26805007457733154,
0.10289502143859863,
-0.4962158799171448,
-0.14656344056129456,
-0.9227918386459351,
1.2884244918823242,
0.22579900920391083,
-1.0363750457763672,
-0.3762454390525818,
0.19625769555568695,
0.5302630066871643,
-0.7019937634468079,
0.5471455454826355,
0.7850098609924316,
0.2931864559650421,
0.1575694978237152,
-0.4449274241924286,
-0.056242767721414566,
-0.04842039570212364,
-0.1793612837791443,
0.009123904630541801,
-0.41561320424079895,
0.7933832406997681,
-0.4247855842113495,
-0.30906322598457336,
0.2754993438720703,
0.7298556566238403,
0.6087204217910767,
0.7271521091461182,
0.9166868329048157,
-0.14264994859695435,
1.3780325651168823,
0.006166631355881691,
1.0606038570404053,
-0.14460645616054535,
0.23453445732593536,
0.9668079018592834,
0.05167486146092415,
0.6297609210014343,
0.33086979389190674,
-0.2613838315010071,
0.990533709526062,
0.9743830561637878,
0.01148707140237093,
0.49420082569122314,
0.21595720946788788,
0.08664342015981674,
-0.3100391626358032,
0.03849465772509575,
-0.021355412900447845,
0.45736709237098694,
0.617185115814209,
-0.6974006295204163,
0.010600755922496319,
-0.19872501492500305,
0.00394848920404911,
-0.18494227528572083,
-0.6124619841575623,
0.3888455331325531,
0.010619831271469593,
-0.7279404997825623,
0.19635285437107086,
-0.06110846623778343,
0.22074513137340546,
-0.8946901559829712,
-0.08249820023775101,
-0.39143097400665283,
0.10908125340938568,
-0.013496367260813713,
-0.9601497054100037,
0.1692461371421814,
0.10598044842481613,
-0.15013696253299713,
-0.006682618986815214,
0.8247896432876587,
-0.3306489884853363,
-0.9638401865959167,
0.40336549282073975,
0.4457409977912903,
0.18973657488822937,
-0.1291835755109787,
-0.7792642116546631,
0.2863352596759796,
0.13113029301166534,
0.02751820534467697,
-0.11648251861333847,
0.6115604043006897,
-0.058578383177518845,
0.4733946919441223,
0.3550355136394501,
-0.28325411677360535,
-0.09624802321195602,
-0.11776152998209,
0.4744553565979004,
-0.8292266726493835,
-0.8141316771507263,
-0.6783867478370667,
0.38888514041900635,
-0.521841824054718,
-0.943049967288971,
0.7270100712776184,
0.41803932189941406,
0.49612554907798767,
-0.017109420150518417,
0.6776762008666992,
-0.3110935688018799,
0.269729346036911,
-0.6359121799468994,
0.5755455493927002,
-0.22372020781040192,
0.34104007482528687,
-0.40740612149238586,
-0.8760506510734558,
0.184778094291687,
0.2964147925376892,
-0.4054083228111267,
0.017148032784461975,
0.9962291121482849,
0.4423137307167053,
0.02509276010096073,
0.423563688993454,
0.4112411439418793,
0.06443625688552856,
0.12943832576274872,
0.5484840869903564,
1.166494607925415,
-0.21502551436424255,
0.6279221177101135,
-0.19022861123085022,
-0.16836367547512054,
-0.26760154962539673,
-0.8243517279624939,
-1.346465826034546,
-0.6648640036582947,
-0.48824429512023926,
-0.11913460493087769,
0.3026164770126343,
0.5342668294906616,
0.9484965801239014,
-1.1088669300079346,
-0.5686213374137878,
-0.35272902250289917,
0.591499388217926,
-0.7127810120582581,
-0.13341929018497467,
0.3478224575519562,
-0.35118773579597473,
-0.7462800741195679,
0.6294113397598267,
0.1853930801153183,
-0.4599109888076782,
-0.1748158037662506,
-0.13274016976356506,
-0.6541604995727539,
0.17409935593605042,
0.46346771717071533,
0.16644993424415588,
-0.4078940153121948,
-0.27873530983924866,
-0.41242510080337524,
0.2012176513671875,
0.17131207883358002,
1.457466959953308,
-0.4836271405220032,
0.6333751082420349,
0.47546640038490295,
0.25734949111938477,
1.035064935684204,
0.09865685552358627,
0.9094398021697998,
-0.927028238773346,
-0.0682598203420639,
0.38003280758857727,
0.37419283390045166,
0.22382572293281555,
-0.6793375015258789,
0.7198198437690735,
0.3778441250324249,
-0.34853872656822205,
-0.4210103452205658,
0.12408918887376785,
-0.8114237189292908,
-0.4802262783050537,
1.0964897871017456,
-0.376854807138443,
-0.30726781487464905,
-0.2043040692806244,
-0.6125467419624329,
-0.017614591866731644,
-0.25060659646987915,
0.2855353057384491,
1.0807627439498901,
-0.5592575073242188,
-0.07098055630922318,
-0.2629246115684509,
0.6326991319656372,
0.18696992099285126,
-0.6943417191505432,
0.06841690093278885,
0.5695560574531555,
-0.03501823917031288,
0.5631351470947266,
0.5695546269416809,
0.2563732862472534,
0.019590148702263832,
0.4094702899456024,
-0.3287506699562073,
-0.05155783146619797,
-0.31291523575782776,
-0.19315922260284424,
0.4092880189418793,
-0.31022247672080994,
-0.1827196329832077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07280v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07280v1
|
Humor Mechanics: Advancing Humor Generation with Multistep Reasoning
| 2024-05-12T13:00:14 | 2024-05-12T13:00:14 |
Alexey Tikhonov, Pavel Shtykovskiy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, 68T05, 68T30, 68T50, 91-08, I.2.7; I.2.1; I.2.6; H.5.2
|
In this paper, we explore the generation of one-liner jokes through
multi-step reasoning. Our work involved reconstructing the process behind
creating humorous one-liners and developing a working prototype for humor
generation. We conducted comprehensive experiments with human participants to
evaluate our approach, comparing it with human-created jokes, zero-shot GPT-4
generated humor, and other baselines. The evaluation focused on the quality of
humor produced, using human labeling as a benchmark. Our findings demonstrate
that the multi-step reasoning approach consistently improves the quality of
generated humor. We present the results and share the datasets used in our
experiments, offering insights into enhancing humor generation with artificial
intelligence.
|
[
-0.34899142384529114,
-0.6857855319976807,
0.7278580665588379,
0.4880894720554352,
-0.2636280953884125,
-0.09949003905057907,
0.25790518522262573,
-0.22744247317314148,
0.1427702009677887,
0.35432925820350647,
-0.7905241250991821,
-0.12298278510570526,
-0.08994502574205399,
0.1784767061471939,
-0.26098015904426575,
1.1603738069534302,
0.6148873567581177,
0.03256829082965851,
-0.3089579641819,
0.07604150474071503,
-0.14942561089992523,
-0.3294999301433563,
-0.7002785801887512,
-0.4354079067707062,
0.7445019483566284,
0.6311665773391724,
0.6591414213180542,
0.47086861729621887,
0.4052577614784241,
0.2965910732746124,
0.19853337109088898,
0.01116474624723196,
-0.01714608632028103,
0.24705438315868378,
-0.03660649061203003,
-0.2547377645969391,
-0.2731468975543976,
-0.17621155083179474,
0.4870079457759857,
0.7692622542381287,
-0.2753421664237976,
-0.07282073050737381,
-0.3059709072113037,
0.6625532507896423,
-0.27754124999046326,
-0.24329394102096558,
-0.3101755380630493,
0.3678830862045288,
-0.24497123062610626,
-0.5913011431694031,
-0.41062238812446594,
-0.5062198638916016,
-0.2724374830722809,
-0.3956785500049591,
0.15077517926692963,
-0.11633071303367615,
0.4554537534713745,
0.37913259863853455,
-0.35955166816711426,
-0.4713844358921051,
-0.7163096070289612,
0.6561329364776611,
-1.021921992301941,
0.22172927856445312,
-0.1735016256570816,
0.29118067026138306,
-0.33065998554229736,
-0.8014634847640991,
-0.7084219455718994,
-0.35262811183929443,
0.29356974363327026,
0.1631380021572113,
0.05449379235506058,
-0.27878981828689575,
0.4577161967754364,
0.06429745256900787,
-0.6438781023025513,
-0.40290671586990356,
-0.5165248513221741,
-0.006989342160522938,
0.7799062132835388,
0.09791304916143417,
0.3827809989452362,
-0.19992221891880035,
-0.2996869683265686,
-0.11751008033752441,
-0.40694892406463623,
0.03610275313258171,
1.0515773296356201,
0.09957589209079742,
0.38438278436660767,
0.4036716818809509,
-0.2048969715833664,
0.256732702255249,
-0.17013093829154968,
-0.5784662961959839,
0.4175557494163513,
-0.5319984555244446,
-0.011277396231889725,
0.031727634370326996,
0.8054152727127075,
0.14189940690994263,
0.34595057368278503,
-0.1693674623966217,
0.06384553760290146,
-0.2469828724861145,
0.5459578037261963,
-0.6025446057319641,
-0.21385730803012848,
0.14543256163597107,
-0.317340612411499,
-0.6642158031463623,
0.1502862572669983,
-0.6787479519844055,
-0.32833099365234375,
-0.1010066419839859,
0.41172632575035095,
-0.7949622869491577,
-0.264406681060791,
0.34435713291168213,
-0.6558875441551208,
0.10461428016424179,
0.3870829641819,
-0.47180694341659546,
-0.02640816755592823,
0.5982260704040527,
0.44314464926719666,
0.3850953280925751,
-0.5494508147239685,
-0.671834409236908,
0.14063923060894012,
-0.3934893012046814,
1.0816506147384644,
-0.28929707407951355,
-0.014355609193444252,
-0.41931191086769104,
-0.4519355595111847,
0.36516907811164856,
-0.3112749457359314,
0.7963845729827881,
-0.05710175633430481,
0.361761212348938,
-0.12153192609548569,
-0.29583412408828735,
-0.07479261606931686,
0.1742991954088211,
-0.3283354938030243,
0.7981029152870178,
-0.011477560736238956,
-0.9324269890785217,
0.5314388871192932,
-0.9618760943412781,
-1.080644130706787,
0.1734326183795929,
-0.0623500719666481,
-0.16717416048049927,
0.26374807953834534,
0.14150448143482208,
-0.0077981045469641685,
-0.12567953765392303,
0.2943822741508484,
-0.34200993180274963,
-0.040815532207489014,
0.32731470465660095,
-0.545474648475647,
0.8341856002807617,
0.42806193232536316,
-0.44345906376838684,
-0.19909584522247314,
-0.7258166074752808,
0.249771848320961,
0.2177020013332367,
-0.41609200835227966,
0.19257618486881256,
0.20706874132156372,
-0.4625789225101471,
0.8295336961746216,
-0.14984530210494995,
-0.7473036050796509,
0.1519802212715149,
-0.5720459818840027,
0.42925989627838135,
0.4578099548816681,
0.1626529097557068,
0.012307616882026196,
-0.362763911485672,
0.5301357507705688,
0.2685915231704712,
0.3116753101348877,
-0.5915435552597046,
-0.8208950161933899,
-0.8499250411987305,
0.29204726219177246,
-0.34304144978523254,
0.5973914861679077,
-1.1685616970062256,
0.12740764021873474,
0.0777088850736618,
-0.402630090713501,
-0.3400264084339142,
0.19685864448547363,
0.3503810167312622,
0.5699054002761841,
0.4837101101875305,
-0.5459136366844177,
-0.14750581979751587,
-0.8754640221595764,
-0.566485583782196,
-0.24453294277191162,
-0.24341079592704773,
0.2064047008752823,
0.2475796639919281,
0.21723993122577667,
0.6606855392456055,
-0.4546881914138794,
0.46639302372932434,
-0.32993751764297485,
0.724230945110321,
0.05821189284324646,
0.5628188252449036,
0.7434915900230408,
-0.34862232208251953,
-0.2057989537715912,
-0.2130516916513443,
-0.7915835976600647,
-0.1718287318944931,
-0.22778382897377014,
-0.25577664375305176,
0.16776616871356964,
0.2136845737695694,
-0.6493867635726929,
0.5127469897270203,
0.08696876466274261,
-0.3593400716781616,
0.9016104340553284,
-0.2357918918132782,
0.40930625796318054,
-0.8311589360237122,
-0.1580597162246704,
0.19303378462791443,
-0.0722283124923706,
-0.764781653881073,
0.08610131591558456,
-0.44364938139915466,
-0.4095873236656189,
-0.7421037554740906,
0.428445965051651,
-0.19496195018291473,
-0.3062419891357422,
-0.16740043461322784,
-0.11545535176992416,
0.07228178530931473,
0.28381383419036865,
-0.3556150197982788,
0.522193968296051,
0.6179455518722534,
-0.6414610147476196,
0.6089969277381897,
-0.22665737569332123,
0.10853662341833115,
0.6615630388259888,
-0.5337079167366028,
0.5768918991088867,
-0.2918824255466461,
0.28528958559036255,
-1.1180707216262817,
-0.44532954692840576,
0.23236902058124542,
-0.5293835997581482,
0.27647465467453003,
0.051523443311452866,
-0.904477059841156,
-0.7788984179496765,
-0.3527195155620575,
0.18469342589378357,
0.49200737476348877,
-0.2675969898700714,
0.2994426190853119,
-0.07003599405288696,
-0.6277515888214111,
-0.454978346824646,
-0.6077965497970581,
0.3515795171260834,
-0.3304157257080078,
-1.1672396659851074,
-0.07656629383563995,
-0.37721237540245056,
-0.29518046975135803,
-0.31875765323638916,
-0.12032414227724075,
-0.06896872073411942,
-0.14417590200901031,
-0.3031497895717621,
-0.42782044410705566,
-0.4845184087753296,
0.08876137435436249,
0.4195367097854614,
-0.07066402584314346,
0.26897716522216797,
-0.26169291138648987,
0.5132102370262146,
-0.06559763848781586,
-0.543101966381073,
-0.6269763708114624,
0.3132714331150055,
0.38817012310028076,
0.06626582890748978,
0.2252272367477417,
0.7206650376319885,
-0.07564752548933029,
-0.07148346304893494,
-0.4841267168521881,
-0.28325045108795166,
-0.48811089992523193,
-0.08194826543331146,
-0.33879491686820984,
-0.41342994570732117,
0.030559396371245384,
-0.2874538004398346,
0.12156779319047928,
0.43304359912872314,
0.2596517503261566,
-0.27002906799316406,
1.2892141342163086,
0.28901207447052,
0.4189070165157318,
0.18940898776054382,
0.2266620546579361,
0.42260023951530457,
-0.3388533890247345,
-0.17170898616313934,
-0.6422415971755981,
-0.41196170449256897,
-0.25691840052604675,
-0.5646865963935852,
0.37087318301200867,
0.3145570755004883,
-0.43339434266090393,
0.3073262572288513,
-0.2929757833480835,
0.4578778147697449,
0.9039965867996216,
0.06021567061543465,
0.3620043992996216,
-0.09340692311525345,
-0.45386335253715515,
0.22388476133346558,
-0.6394672989845276,
-0.5481336712837219,
0.7553504705429077,
0.3753661811351776,
0.7074519395828247,
0.2881234586238861,
0.921220064163208,
0.05872596800327301,
0.2148149013519287,
-0.5474157333374023,
0.6440428495407104,
-0.32023322582244873,
-0.5591655969619751,
-0.31816670298576355,
-0.6720882654190063,
-0.514488697052002,
-0.272446870803833,
-0.07878267019987106,
-0.8432181477546692,
-0.4603862762451172,
0.15059268474578857,
-0.2799203395843506,
0.21023496985435486,
-0.6941373348236084,
0.657534658908844,
-0.6413547396659851,
-0.38009029626846313,
-0.3507085144519806,
-1.124255657196045,
0.6759665608406067,
0.23992057144641876,
0.4435468316078186,
0.06314079463481903,
0.5171754360198975,
0.3689393401145935,
-0.3326749801635742,
0.582516610622406,
-0.2681027948856354,
-0.16174937784671783,
0.49722710251808167,
0.3893522322177887,
-0.09973419457674026,
0.15515565872192383,
-0.214431032538414,
-0.09394724667072296,
-0.5289078950881958,
-0.4789242148399353,
-0.7266302108764648,
0.5634168982505798,
-0.3856111764907837,
-0.5987230539321899,
0.0697493702173233,
-0.7974685430526733,
-0.0528130829334259,
0.10636106133460999,
0.10236670076847076,
0.4185889661312103,
0.20691891014575958,
0.16354821622371674,
0.25681644678115845,
-0.6420355439186096,
0.7023999691009521,
-0.04563920199871063,
0.06536167860031128,
-0.5397390723228455,
0.8635064363479614,
-0.3703993856906891,
0.3816886246204376,
0.14919379353523254,
0.5086442828178406,
-0.4014366865158081,
0.04881574586033821,
-0.7426252961158752,
0.2273077368736267,
-0.972960352897644,
-0.11745576560497284,
-0.7327148914337158,
-0.2260371893644333,
-0.8166082501411438,
-0.12721577286720276,
-0.3831460177898407,
-0.797691285610199,
0.1433890461921692,
0.14731884002685547,
0.01058284007012844,
1.0402854681015015,
-0.14640796184539795,
0.0158450435847044,
-0.9328917264938354,
0.270724356174469,
0.47145384550094604,
0.18776163458824158,
0.03082311525940895,
-0.19405345618724823,
0.10297540575265884,
-0.0777718797326088,
-1.0388455390930176,
-0.9519349336624146,
0.11801844090223312,
0.3376324772834778,
0.5983381867408752,
0.5147276520729065,
-0.2493964284658432,
0.539888322353363,
-0.7634440064430237,
1.0234122276306152,
0.5856553316116333,
-0.9799584150314331,
0.9539836645126343,
-0.25268760323524475,
0.1802312135696411,
-0.035941723734140396,
0.34089699387550354,
-0.13687896728515625,
-0.6401891112327576,
-0.9855488538742065,
-0.4978933036327362,
0.48322591185569763,
0.5027385354042053,
0.36997634172439575,
-0.30000439286231995,
0.5092222094535828,
0.25159335136413574,
0.3896554708480835,
-0.6329415440559387,
-0.2492094784975052,
-0.6746982336044312,
-0.05198371037840843,
0.23453454673290253,
0.22674353420734406,
-0.16359786689281464,
-0.3664405941963196,
0.39545008540153503,
-0.41302406787872314,
0.1940329372882843,
0.08186174929141998,
0.097582146525383,
-0.3252681493759155,
0.6123323440551758,
1.2320997714996338,
0.851670503616333,
0.0815722793340683,
0.19133251905441284,
-0.17292460799217224,
-0.13905292749404907,
0.06654016673564911,
0.0750792920589447,
0.05622025951743126,
0.06011231243610382,
0.35104799270629883,
0.8472356796264648,
0.0012922582682222128,
-0.46202248334884644,
0.2818937301635742,
0.13483713567256927,
-0.3386753797531128,
0.07365640997886658,
0.43539679050445557,
0.2193097174167633,
0.45572537183761597,
0.41685354709625244,
0.31817173957824707,
0.4073323905467987,
-1.0204514265060425,
0.6188180446624756,
0.25659915804862976,
-0.025965392589569092,
-0.5517204403877258,
0.9061554670333862,
0.20682048797607422,
-0.5836141705513,
0.6335660219192505,
-0.6508404612541199,
-0.5200193524360657,
0.7022202014923096,
0.8341163396835327,
0.779163122177124,
-0.18342186510562897,
0.5907691121101379,
0.6485663652420044,
0.1965959668159485,
0.00013359542936086655,
0.29649874567985535,
0.14370782673358917,
-0.6839195489883423,
-0.6726143956184387,
-0.6496613621711731,
-0.39410293102264404,
-0.020470090210437775,
-0.20511257648468018,
0.6179297566413879,
-0.27129873633384705,
0.014793056063354015,
0.14856970310211182,
-0.36161527037620544,
-0.6005651354789734,
0.32808196544647217,
0.39370596408843994,
0.7769509553909302,
-0.8154126405715942,
0.4673826992511749,
0.8899537920951843,
-0.891299307346344,
-0.7384690046310425,
0.465608149766922,
0.06317900121212006,
-0.6636753082275391,
0.7966864109039307,
0.17103686928749084,
-0.06809556484222412,
0.139388769865036,
-0.7914490103721619,
-0.3983827531337738,
0.877898097038269,
0.4851507544517517,
-0.028948871418833733,
-0.11414170265197754,
0.2577323019504547,
0.6185284852981567,
-0.5046587586402893,
0.407552570104599,
0.4245450794696808,
0.4450524151325226,
0.664862334728241,
-0.8356235027313232,
-0.011329161934554577,
-0.21278263628482819,
-0.09134846180677414,
0.16714298725128174,
-0.4005074203014374,
1.0640923976898193,
-0.7845425009727478,
-0.03912009671330452,
0.06457414478063583,
0.5082145929336548,
0.7498088479042053,
0.7923487424850464,
0.5594552755355835,
0.9975979924201965,
0.3402656018733978,
0.10759402066469193,
1.2363072633743286,
-0.17439338564872742,
0.3167790472507477,
1.0101333856582642,
-0.34846389293670654,
0.2908259630203247,
0.4154170751571655,
-0.1837848275899887,
0.9319735169410706,
0.08749361336231232,
0.4164269268512726,
0.16125373542308807,
0.48239603638648987,
-0.20929750800132751,
-0.368039608001709,
0.061787836253643036,
-0.17297545075416565,
0.4403209388256073,
0.079213447868824,
-0.06480619311332703,
-0.5939112901687622,
0.02456572838127613,
0.04077514261007309,
-0.2351750135421753,
0.009070174768567085,
0.8503849506378174,
0.057988159358501434,
-0.6363936066627502,
-0.030996765941381454,
-0.23886056244373322,
0.5284883975982666,
-0.11981651186943054,
-0.34354111552238464,
-0.3230661153793335,
-0.26729616522789,
-0.14669552445411682,
-1.2417746782302856,
0.2618124186992645,
0.09545476734638214,
0.21591565012931824,
0.00977249350398779,
0.9069862961769104,
-0.21391955018043518,
-0.467731237411499,
-0.025765594094991684,
0.679964005947113,
0.6710178256034851,
0.10918722301721573,
-0.7529768347740173,
-0.46541446447372437,
-0.1980259269475937,
-0.3688102662563324,
0.12216600775718689,
1.1048026084899902,
0.16114374995231628,
0.7207448482513428,
0.7986714243888855,
-0.046500515192747116,
0.34251686930656433,
0.5708146095275879,
0.8782145977020264,
-0.9884156584739685,
-0.3507319390773773,
-0.694550633430481,
1.012847900390625,
-0.24632008373737335,
-0.42063459753990173,
0.3340551555156708,
0.4526313245296478,
0.5817037224769592,
-0.2022642344236374,
0.8752134442329407,
-0.33140358328819275,
0.38105911016464233,
-0.45046523213386536,
0.5453742742538452,
-0.8035960793495178,
0.018442116677761078,
-0.5870299339294434,
-0.9031080603599548,
-0.2664073705673218,
0.42646524310112,
0.281211256980896,
0.42857664823532104,
0.9994375109672546,
0.4983268082141876,
-0.16164512932300568,
-0.12208215892314911,
0.4066070318222046,
0.034525901079177856,
0.551296055316925,
0.38682177662849426,
0.9257802367210388,
-0.3939507305622101,
0.7041916251182556,
-0.5966630578041077,
0.004018249921500683,
0.1114358976483345,
-1.2905460596084595,
-0.6426424980163574,
-0.12272568047046661,
-0.4186796247959137,
-0.3670479357242584,
-0.273703008890152,
0.563563346862793,
0.4884309470653534,
-0.395815372467041,
0.06674256920814514,
-0.39444684982299805,
0.020104579627513885,
-0.2727968394756317,
-0.3979358375072479,
-0.3482253849506378,
-0.9045252799987793,
-0.565766453742981,
0.600172221660614,
0.6329017281532288,
-0.25361892580986023,
-0.4334670901298523,
-0.229535773396492,
-0.15477342903614044,
0.2776404917240143,
0.8221153020858765,
0.24048292636871338,
-0.7716588377952576,
-0.5647832751274109,
0.049693699926137924,
0.20012669265270233,
0.09495291113853455,
1.0569719076156616,
-0.43163394927978516,
0.2511615455150604,
0.6745242476463318,
0.5299737453460693,
0.1784178614616394,
0.21515314280986786,
0.5720745325088501,
-1.145536184310913,
0.03613901510834694,
0.36710333824157715,
0.19470933079719543,
0.4496062099933624,
-0.3445325493812561,
0.587544322013855,
0.6505641937255859,
-0.679348349571228,
-0.7101832032203674,
0.45011982321739197,
-0.8520573377609253,
-0.2259291559457779,
1.0302724838256836,
-0.07593555003404617,
0.02578563243150711,
0.07506894320249557,
-0.030739473178982735,
0.5191432237625122,
-0.21567901968955994,
0.7557591199874878,
0.7376438975334167,
-0.8624289631843567,
-0.5412452816963196,
-0.7599356174468994,
0.17384934425354004,
0.26926496624946594,
-1.353344440460205,
-0.5573451519012451,
0.44630661606788635,
0.4570371210575104,
0.700843334197998,
0.6744202971458435,
-0.08725869655609131,
0.5706108808517456,
0.39190873503685,
0.41780078411102295,
0.2953954339027405,
-0.7088148593902588,
0.15891046822071075,
0.1287538856267929,
0.0005521836574189365,
0.2412164956331253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07278v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07278v1
|
Human-interpretable clustering of short-text using large language models
| 2024-05-12T12:55:40 | 2024-05-12T12:55:40 |
Justin K. Miller, Tristram J. Alexander
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
Large language models have seen extraordinary growth in popularity due to
their human-like content generation capabilities. We show that these models can
also be used to successfully cluster human-generated content, with success
defined through the measures of distinctiveness and interpretability. This
success is validated by both human reviewers and ChatGPT, providing an
automated means to close the 'validation gap' that has challenged short-text
clustering. Comparing the machine and human approaches we identify the biases
inherent in each, and question the reliance on human-coding as the 'gold
standard'. We apply our methodology to Twitter bios and find characteristic
ways humans describe themselves, agreeing well with prior specialist work, but
with interesting differences characteristic of the medium used to express
identity.
|
[
-0.27839258313179016,
-0.6441649198532104,
0.733375072479248,
0.23977498710155487,
-0.3766636550426483,
0.4629826843738556,
-0.5365869998931885,
-0.6855145692825317,
0.3298921585083008,
0.2887313663959503,
-0.5565006732940674,
-0.6579751968383789,
-0.5556318163871765,
0.46938231587409973,
-0.8011882901191711,
0.9291295409202576,
0.30028799176216125,
-0.24577262997627258,
-0.22551998496055603,
-0.10259170085191727,
-0.3500894606113434,
-0.5123603940010071,
-0.6086726784706116,
-0.3300308883190155,
0.9053419232368469,
0.4285995364189148,
0.9611504673957825,
0.7104746103286743,
0.542865514755249,
0.18580135703086853,
-0.3102683424949646,
0.08032410591840744,
-0.3740047514438629,
-0.29346227645874023,
-0.3661715090274811,
-0.22025708854198456,
-0.3890184164047241,
-0.1945069283246994,
0.8850210905075073,
0.955317497253418,
-0.1609707772731781,
0.2224305123090744,
0.3796175718307495,
0.48457929491996765,
-0.14779029786586761,
-0.0023287846706807613,
-0.711135745048523,
-0.0721944123506546,
-0.358136385679245,
-0.01318206824362278,
-0.3908938765525818,
-0.46533551812171936,
0.06478932499885559,
-0.11743570864200592,
0.7007954120635986,
0.23565928637981415,
0.5874684453010559,
-0.08682967722415924,
-0.35995247960090637,
-0.14342625439167023,
-0.8914623856544495,
0.9218162894248962,
-0.7295041680335999,
0.18292462825775146,
0.26518598198890686,
0.5310265421867371,
0.006428650114685297,
-0.4963976740837097,
-0.8231879472732544,
0.02223357744514942,
-0.5123496651649475,
-0.31080588698387146,
-0.06057293340563774,
-0.09950729459524155,
0.16915719211101532,
0.3199455142021179,
-0.7704160213470459,
0.28222107887268066,
-0.6456643342971802,
-0.14413876831531525,
0.7977847456932068,
0.04965190961956978,
0.49401184916496277,
-0.3237459659576416,
0.14642374217510223,
0.060950301587581635,
-0.8566743731498718,
-0.32905876636505127,
0.37150609493255615,
0.34478989243507385,
-0.09820510447025299,
0.5578118562698364,
-0.32064926624298096,
0.36670568585395813,
-0.1476917266845703,
0.026202049106359482,
0.13393156230449677,
-0.10420326888561249,
-0.012077891267836094,
-0.01912887580692768,
0.9140409827232361,
0.54840087890625,
0.3040752708911896,
-0.38506650924682617,
-0.09244139492511749,
0.06345178186893463,
0.33826184272766113,
-0.7793830037117004,
-0.22327765822410583,
0.08899788558483124,
-0.860004723072052,
-0.4620547592639923,
0.4021419882774353,
-0.8243718147277832,
-0.6205400824546814,
0.010097231715917587,
0.319635272026062,
-0.07585655897855759,
-0.3405715525150299,
0.05001096427440643,
-0.19298020005226135,
-0.019936220720410347,
0.14071933925151825,
-1.0333024263381958,
0.39634108543395996,
0.6829527616500854,
0.9149181246757507,
-0.4496234655380249,
-0.4435577392578125,
-0.2616952061653137,
0.12232217192649841,
-0.30439385771751404,
0.8237167596817017,
-0.29665327072143555,
-0.4078975021839142,
0.020847532898187637,
0.09660379588603973,
0.13246776163578033,
-0.6223884224891663,
0.5571814179420471,
-0.47383031249046326,
0.13627555966377258,
-0.44244223833084106,
-0.3217134475708008,
-0.03476867824792862,
0.1052004024386406,
-0.7750226855278015,
0.6649107336997986,
0.24667192995548248,
-0.869658887386322,
0.5107401609420776,
-0.8979313969612122,
-0.5588131546974182,
0.14340414106845856,
-0.17414692044258118,
-0.37674564123153687,
0.10984162241220474,
0.1935426890850067,
0.7512159943580627,
-0.4427971839904785,
0.2704601287841797,
-0.31202566623687744,
-0.3710476756095886,
0.5150976777076721,
-0.1494324654340744,
0.4997001588344574,
0.2451772540807724,
-0.29124200344085693,
0.2652030289173126,
-0.6445305347442627,
-0.17992840707302094,
0.3334301710128784,
-0.26616957783699036,
-0.22767850756645203,
0.48652973771095276,
0.2949901819229126,
0.03606409579515457,
0.07435523718595505,
-0.5974690318107605,
0.003965682350099087,
-0.25550785660743713,
0.9285998344421387,
0.4414084553718567,
0.004930443596094847,
0.47522321343421936,
-0.2644016742706299,
0.2948220372200012,
0.004277129657566547,
0.18079045414924622,
0.061913661658763885,
-0.5856857299804688,
-0.35306552052497864,
-0.20259618759155273,
0.3977585434913635,
0.382138729095459,
-0.4136347472667694,
0.7692787647247314,
-0.45908287167549133,
-0.656615674495697,
-0.3904556334018707,
0.3391195833683014,
0.1007351279258728,
0.4176538288593292,
0.2865715026855469,
-0.40815022587776184,
-0.5385923385620117,
-1.155867099761963,
-0.3826752305030823,
-0.2672179639339447,
-0.35580527782440186,
0.22039461135864258,
0.6013481020927429,
-0.8944401741027832,
1.1340360641479492,
-0.586207926273346,
0.18524610996246338,
-0.46058037877082825,
0.35042744874954224,
0.14112316071987152,
0.45808181166648865,
0.5390663743019104,
-0.9402264356613159,
-0.6669987440109253,
0.18630442023277283,
-0.49317219853401184,
-0.14267687499523163,
0.0926654040813446,
-0.04726489260792732,
-0.007877528667449951,
0.4221014082431793,
-0.7887612581253052,
0.5326830148696899,
0.5153745412826538,
-0.338041216135025,
0.577178955078125,
-0.003477082820609212,
0.21417133510112762,
-1.0903241634368896,
0.2511847913265228,
0.11691619455814362,
-0.5673536658287048,
-0.42801621556282043,
-0.10983975231647491,
-0.09959358721971512,
-0.01926795393228531,
-0.18092477321624756,
0.7025584578514099,
-0.23839972913265228,
-0.21904948353767395,
-0.3901195824146271,
0.0575556755065918,
0.04347069561481476,
0.057597722858190536,
0.03887879103422165,
0.5343536734580994,
0.17573381960391998,
-0.2744235396385193,
0.3574218451976776,
0.18165631592273712,
-0.49250471591949463,
0.4017432928085327,
-0.8415257930755615,
0.08534510433673859,
-0.10965567827224731,
0.5200715661048889,
-1.0856345891952515,
-0.7389645576477051,
0.12203633785247803,
-0.46964383125305176,
-0.037132326513528824,
-0.019782697781920433,
-0.9179526567459106,
-0.5797401070594788,
-0.11015268415212631,
0.7433907389640808,
0.9833431243896484,
-0.515777051448822,
0.43649616837501526,
0.2938743829727173,
-0.36922842264175415,
-0.015734199434518814,
-0.6558656096458435,
0.2428971230983734,
-0.6179150938987732,
-0.6623790860176086,
0.5156654119491577,
0.010024411603808403,
-0.3307802677154541,
0.04027889296412468,
0.34230679273605347,
-0.3205459713935852,
0.08895661681890488,
0.14994321763515472,
0.08579589426517487,
-0.11483735591173172,
0.1436111330986023,
0.04170064628124237,
0.1695576012134552,
-0.054499730467796326,
-0.23476558923721313,
0.5237070918083191,
-0.18443942070007324,
-0.34438011050224304,
-0.5518131256103516,
0.6988054513931274,
0.4937928318977356,
0.05143801495432854,
0.9635815620422363,
0.9453443884849548,
-0.52286297082901,
-0.05949072167277336,
-0.6533282995223999,
-0.40630507469177246,
-0.39638423919677734,
0.23800018429756165,
0.2205546498298645,
-1.2923978567123413,
0.8053061962127686,
0.11435502022504807,
0.02074715867638588,
0.8881447911262512,
0.65260249376297,
-0.37322258949279785,
1.307090163230896,
0.9193152785301208,
-0.13174714148044586,
0.1790262758731842,
0.29870203137397766,
0.31355124711990356,
-0.37497392296791077,
0.12790730595588684,
-0.648547351360321,
-0.26790279150009155,
-0.6449368596076965,
-0.2571456730365753,
0.24272245168685913,
-0.030085081234574318,
-0.026645490899682045,
0.1726655662059784,
-0.6794338226318359,
0.7562546133995056,
0.37034058570861816,
0.08395176380872726,
0.22777456045150757,
-0.05201012268662453,
0.3165874779224396,
-0.04753260314464569,
-0.5541037917137146,
-0.7197223901748657,
0.6961169242858887,
0.4237205386161804,
0.6075006723403931,
0.07489476352930069,
0.6602006554603577,
0.7093954086303711,
0.46538254618644714,
-0.594403088092804,
0.407751202583313,
-0.19983702898025513,
-0.8360980153083801,
-0.38417813181877136,
-0.5426141023635864,
-1.1032700538635254,
-0.04748523235321045,
-0.3683888018131256,
-1.1831103563308716,
-0.23526141047477722,
0.24006542563438416,
-0.5560995936393738,
0.3433288335800171,
-0.9404640793800354,
1.0560505390167236,
-0.0028540128841996193,
0.10703805834054947,
-0.412468820810318,
-0.883539617061615,
0.2958585321903229,
-0.2925030291080475,
0.42947664856910706,
0.09880918264389038,
0.11527538299560547,
1.0674200057983398,
-0.34998729825019836,
1.1763484477996826,
0.08662935346364975,
0.11016637831926346,
0.5133216381072998,
-0.14080551266670227,
0.2029476910829544,
-0.028843116015195847,
0.21195685863494873,
0.1438496857881546,
0.3250068426132202,
-0.5456852912902832,
-0.5055997967720032,
0.4364710748195648,
-0.749561607837677,
-0.27515897154808044,
-0.025257587432861328,
-0.2814510464668274,
-0.026872919872403145,
0.3445592522621155,
0.2221614420413971,
0.20607472956180573,
-0.5449550747871399,
0.30189669132232666,
0.3572031259536743,
-0.35940948128700256,
0.23973432183265686,
0.06119081750512123,
-0.4332788288593292,
-0.253040611743927,
1.0252708196640015,
-0.27482208609580994,
0.08188845962285995,
0.3288954794406891,
0.5031611323356628,
-0.2965303659439087,
-0.524651288986206,
-0.2969024181365967,
0.5191689133644104,
-0.6755596399307251,
0.16555139422416687,
-0.5518656969070435,
-0.2377845048904419,
-0.4398861229419708,
-0.27149540185928345,
-0.24396705627441406,
-0.3279637396335602,
-0.2985682189464569,
0.04949183017015457,
0.05979182943701744,
1.2206506729125977,
0.013212201185524464,
0.7792156338691711,
-1.2711763381958008,
0.29682788252830505,
0.5329499244689941,
0.3540719151496887,
0.03473355248570442,
-0.21884921193122864,
-0.52288818359375,
-0.04924681782722473,
-0.12333371490240097,
-1.017904281616211,
0.3313142955303192,
0.15482991933822632,
0.27688202261924744,
0.5500368475914001,
-0.3220505714416504,
0.3223515450954437,
-0.4453466832637787,
0.8686335682868958,
0.18807293474674225,
-0.9170240759849548,
0.40403851866722107,
-0.6960023045539856,
0.20787078142166138,
0.5367509722709656,
0.1952940970659256,
-0.8751584887504578,
-0.0013981016818434,
-0.7175477147102356,
-0.624046802520752,
0.29104387760162354,
0.2707490622997284,
0.051505330950021744,
-0.24234966933727264,
0.4896145164966583,
0.31765276193618774,
0.2577863037586212,
-0.7066085338592529,
0.32011717557907104,
0.12382756918668747,
-0.32894083857536316,
-0.26299023628234863,
-0.4967353641986847,
-0.09012732654809952,
-0.27655839920043945,
0.31857776641845703,
-0.2984318435192108,
0.24825257062911987,
-0.05480482056736946,
-0.18503935635089874,
-0.18386195600032806,
0.3899516463279724,
0.4361191689968109,
0.9966798424720764,
-0.2854812741279602,
0.08243244886398315,
0.030026160180568695,
-0.3193298578262329,
-0.13983942568302155,
-0.09266924858093262,
-0.04261213541030884,
0.12869974970817566,
0.46771901845932007,
0.27674582600593567,
0.13808950781822205,
-0.8158158659934998,
0.5745626091957092,
-0.25817543268203735,
-0.15590262413024902,
-0.14637646079063416,
-0.14142847061157227,
0.28936269879341125,
0.21134863793849945,
0.5083644986152649,
0.025454355403780937,
0.04232955351471901,
-0.6770827174186707,
-0.06825335323810577,
0.29311466217041016,
-0.4038757085800171,
-0.631585955619812,
0.5264600515365601,
0.35361263155937195,
-0.4067669212818146,
0.5524527430534363,
-0.29997730255126953,
-0.5974081158638,
0.5054041743278503,
0.23295694589614868,
1.0521072149276733,
0.04172239452600479,
0.2722771167755127,
0.23595623672008514,
0.2931728959083557,
-0.36533820629119873,
0.03410155698657036,
-0.016766399145126343,
-0.7842270135879517,
-0.7051039338111877,
-0.7090383768081665,
-0.355731725692749,
-0.12349234521389008,
-0.688358724117279,
0.1916963756084442,
-0.28801411390304565,
-0.3362138569355011,
0.26318666338920593,
-0.2739351689815521,
-0.6093517541885376,
0.1859380453824997,
0.2212374061346054,
0.7173936367034912,
-1.2422945499420166,
0.65590900182724,
0.761701226234436,
-0.018846822902560234,
-0.5350040793418884,
0.14006511867046356,
-0.032664746046066284,
-0.40133410692214966,
0.37137526273727417,
0.3624044358730316,
0.13718612492084503,
-0.08488670736551285,
-0.831270158290863,
-0.4549141824245453,
1.0536155700683594,
0.0548117533326149,
-0.3192592263221741,
-0.2725738286972046,
0.17346368730068207,
0.770413875579834,
-0.4955230951309204,
-0.06695259362459183,
0.7952358722686768,
0.3434869647026062,
-0.00660733925178647,
-1.1433483362197876,
0.03975006192922592,
-0.041234008967876434,
0.0009822292486205697,
0.011165143921971321,
-0.4668230712413788,
0.7905173897743225,
-0.13034062087535858,
-0.4172273278236389,
0.13484430313110352,
0.749017059803009,
0.1286243349313736,
0.2958661615848541,
0.8060519695281982,
0.14017178118228912,
0.8640021085739136,
0.13700075447559357,
1.0442754030227661,
0.08839218318462372,
0.34937721490859985,
0.7826216220855713,
-0.19509196281433105,
0.7387687563896179,
0.39902463555336,
-0.35922062397003174,
0.6299068331718445,
0.6222431063652039,
0.05124707892537117,
0.17457176744937897,
0.014659492298960686,
-0.12064332515001297,
-0.3901362717151642,
-0.16477125883102417,
-0.08756178617477417,
0.3061843514442444,
0.36525294184684753,
-0.48862627148628235,
-0.06746290624141693,
-0.2940218448638916,
-0.07890600711107254,
0.09580817818641663,
-0.27614930272102356,
0.7879928350448608,
0.19709251821041107,
-0.7485951781272888,
0.16341744363307953,
0.19330871105194092,
0.7716079950332642,
-0.24423536658287048,
0.045421961694955826,
0.18137025833129883,
0.10386407375335693,
-0.4528007507324219,
-0.8291552662849426,
0.6241262555122375,
0.20598338544368744,
-0.4016951024532318,
-0.1312226504087448,
0.9593480825424194,
-0.2883317470550537,
-0.5415312051773071,
0.035877157002687454,
0.8072221875190735,
0.21168550848960876,
-0.4001457095146179,
-0.43699830770492554,
-0.1446559876203537,
-0.009581731632351875,
0.10484511405229568,
0.35668596625328064,
0.2283482402563095,
-0.36155012249946594,
0.5273331999778748,
0.48751068115234375,
0.1044047474861145,
-0.12002500146627426,
0.12529565393924713,
0.6426774263381958,
-0.9298290610313416,
-0.7286823391914368,
-1.2173290252685547,
0.40286561846733093,
-0.3169897198677063,
0.06504044681787491,
0.6215713620185852,
0.5028987526893616,
0.4548845887184143,
-0.1181064024567604,
1.0295766592025757,
-0.26759111881256104,
1.0622541904449463,
-0.2235286831855774,
0.9876125454902649,
-0.4655676782131195,
0.06657057255506516,
-0.4077136516571045,
-0.9848803877830505,
-0.39518052339553833,
0.40398502349853516,
-0.2674541175365448,
0.09883923083543777,
0.7871502041816711,
0.7128742933273315,
-0.1943211406469345,
0.037140026688575745,
0.20119763910770416,
0.2024097442626953,
0.45823168754577637,
0.301614373922348,
1.16314697265625,
0.018704190850257874,
0.577520489692688,
-0.08317497372627258,
-0.283230185508728,
-0.4429381489753723,
-1.010212779045105,
-1.2619293928146362,
-0.7406793236732483,
-0.22434166073799133,
-0.4473227858543396,
-0.24293294548988342,
0.9221766591072083,
0.825253427028656,
-0.7119951844215393,
-0.05529002845287323,
0.18991823494434357,
0.2628709077835083,
-0.10845673829317093,
-0.22764825820922852,
0.3265797793865204,
0.1420488804578781,
-0.47094810009002686,
0.0022625017445534468,
0.1270250380039215,
0.12864011526107788,
-0.5625711679458618,
0.016316372901201248,
0.3747125566005707,
0.07020626217126846,
0.7422312498092651,
0.40094059705734253,
-0.7027855515480042,
-0.4396616518497467,
-0.13009800016880035,
-0.2800317704677582,
0.10928086191415787,
0.9401531219482422,
-0.48462921380996704,
0.053609445691108704,
0.5397346615791321,
0.5175803899765015,
0.22735556960105896,
0.35915979743003845,
0.5087369084358215,
-0.7896816730499268,
0.05477338656783104,
0.3102218806743622,
0.34169813990592957,
0.6092421412467957,
-0.19107601046562195,
0.3282817304134369,
0.38016945123672485,
-0.7781970500946045,
-0.8258875608444214,
0.09073429554700851,
-1.1560826301574707,
-0.15731918811798096,
1.2615293264389038,
0.1354893445968628,
-0.4703207314014435,
0.0007492314907722175,
-0.25441595911979675,
0.05380123108625412,
-0.3173414170742035,
1.139557957649231,
0.6639529466629028,
0.09787902981042862,
-0.023812949657440186,
-0.4688817262649536,
0.5358061790466309,
0.13117778301239014,
-0.8927609324455261,
-0.07866820693016052,
0.35502180457115173,
0.2731451392173767,
0.20945803821086884,
0.6715598702430725,
-0.007646809332072735,
0.25750598311424255,
-0.26617106795310974,
-0.011884489096701145,
0.5359941124916077,
-0.26214778423309326,
-0.14240367710590363,
0.053456272929906845,
0.33925434947013855,
0.34308624267578125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07263v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07263v1
|
Span-Aggregatable, Contextualized Word Embeddings for Effective Phrase Mining
| 2024-05-12T12:08:05 | 2024-05-12T12:08:05 |
Eyal Orbach, Lev Haikin, Nelly David, Avi Faizakof
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dense vector representations for sentences made significant progress in
recent years as can be seen on sentence similarity tasks. Real-world phrase
retrieval applications, on the other hand, still encounter challenges for
effective use of dense representations. We show that when target phrases reside
inside noisy context, representing the full sentence with a single dense
vector, is not sufficient for effective phrase retrieval. We therefore look
into the notion of representing multiple, sub-sentence, consecutive word spans,
each with its own dense vector. We show that this technique is much more
effective for phrase mining, yet requires considerable compute to obtain useful
span representations. Accordingly, we make an argument for contextualized
word/token embeddings that can be aggregated for arbitrary word spans while
maintaining the span's semantic meaning. We introduce a modification to the
common contrastive loss used for sentence embeddings that encourages word
embeddings to have this property. To demonstrate the effect of this method we
present a dataset based on the STS-B dataset with additional generated text,
that requires finding the best matching paraphrase residing in a larger context
and report the degree of similarity to the origin phrase. We demonstrate on
this dataset, how our proposed method can achieve better results without
significant increase to compute.
|
[
-0.12889254093170166,
-0.9554890990257263,
0.521361231803894,
0.4710841476917267,
-0.6525977849960327,
-0.03062666580080986,
-0.028139911592006683,
-0.12901948392391205,
0.5251986384391785,
0.1639357954263687,
-0.23539310693740845,
-0.48309454321861267,
-0.7803941965103149,
-0.02358832210302353,
-0.7053958773612976,
0.5735676884651184,
-0.03498070314526558,
-0.04727264866232872,
-0.5117168426513672,
-0.3616636395454407,
-0.7239843606948853,
-0.6213124990463257,
-0.24372133612632751,
-0.17489901185035706,
0.365729421377182,
0.10525070130825043,
0.6942484974861145,
0.7844158411026001,
0.3827527165412903,
0.17798547446727753,
-0.35309985280036926,
0.2226966768503189,
-0.6270975470542908,
0.4730665683746338,
0.04563116654753685,
-0.32184481620788574,
0.21664787828922272,
-0.14990979433059692,
0.6362227201461792,
0.9401314854621887,
-0.17240886390209198,
-0.26940232515335083,
0.016274843364953995,
0.2587398290634155,
-0.624538242816925,
-0.11567636579275131,
-0.720343828201294,
0.3109842538833618,
-0.34487199783325195,
-0.4344428777694702,
-0.2122105211019516,
-0.16130341589450836,
0.25455665588378906,
-0.4729177951812744,
0.15155471861362457,
0.2119695544242859,
0.8385696411132812,
0.24154911935329437,
-0.43363407254219055,
-0.39874812960624695,
-0.2723807990550995,
0.8485794067382812,
-0.2383267730474472,
0.292207270860672,
0.17291705310344696,
-0.16904045641422272,
-0.0005672079278156161,
-0.8357776403427124,
-0.22509095072746277,
-0.20597922801971436,
-0.2456391155719757,
0.1935562938451767,
-0.3449309468269348,
-0.10907402634620667,
0.02352273464202881,
0.28845468163490295,
-0.4490559995174408,
-0.006939034443348646,
-0.28348293900489807,
-0.1104230210185051,
0.12066470831632614,
0.2606877386569977,
0.18660151958465576,
-0.3961615562438965,
-0.8534187078475952,
-0.15283291041851044,
-0.7946382761001587,
-0.17350728809833527,
0.10719496756792068,
0.27089712023735046,
0.013787776231765747,
0.8200412392616272,
-0.007770844269543886,
0.5090197324752808,
-0.28832095861434937,
0.45096203684806824,
0.2967033088207245,
-0.47778457403182983,
-0.04253948852419853,
0.04510381817817688,
0.38100025057792664,
0.5455116629600525,
0.26665225625038147,
-0.5459868311882019,
-0.09657230228185654,
0.21083420515060425,
0.31389957666397095,
-0.8141587972640991,
0.018147222697734833,
-0.012234770692884922,
-0.6087599396705627,
-0.052041199058294296,
0.5596989989280701,
-0.5970399379730225,
-0.1856524497270584,
-0.1772555261850357,
0.3214455544948578,
-0.7321421504020691,
0.08241695165634155,
0.06199171394109726,
-0.9136756658554077,
0.2641225755214691,
-0.21289613842964172,
-0.46056950092315674,
0.3186701238155365,
0.5844797492027283,
1.2813513278961182,
-0.10919632762670517,
-0.2169962376356125,
-0.6748623847961426,
0.1889701634645462,
-0.6029580235481262,
0.7031517624855042,
-0.7569828033447266,
-0.7050914168357849,
0.16502386331558228,
-0.3324550688266754,
-0.14747513830661774,
-0.6797600984573364,
0.6837825179100037,
-0.38582977652549744,
0.06168863922357559,
-0.36934781074523926,
-1.0059369802474976,
0.25844287872314453,
0.10122741758823395,
-0.40670642256736755,
1.0904028415679932,
-0.02165874093770981,
-0.9245148301124573,
0.3496863842010498,
-0.2909868061542511,
-0.6077412962913513,
0.009707042016088963,
-0.11625436693429947,
-0.2925238013267517,
0.6227722764015198,
0.31715160608291626,
0.7574036717414856,
0.2684469223022461,
0.0007956597837619483,
-0.3628179430961609,
-0.6628302931785583,
0.13083505630493164,
-0.149025559425354,
0.39718806743621826,
0.29516926407814026,
-0.15398167073726654,
-0.14828646183013916,
-0.4246746003627777,
-0.12681207060813904,
0.10678057372570038,
-0.128180593252182,
-1.1661169528961182,
0.2611706256866455,
0.0896894633769989,
-0.09149583429098129,
0.26234787702560425,
-0.5740866661071777,
-0.08065076172351837,
-0.4051031172275543,
0.45068612694740295,
0.6683992743492126,
0.17526914179325104,
0.5822480916976929,
-0.13854564726352692,
0.3866024911403656,
0.18878234922885895,
-0.3423455059528351,
-0.3900146186351776,
-0.1663842797279358,
-0.3751334846019745,
-0.3240502178668976,
0.17213794589042664,
0.3940415680408478,
-0.7032557725906372,
0.6313498616218567,
-0.42632949352264404,
-0.338344931602478,
-0.1795753836631775,
-0.013220672495663166,
0.17722977697849274,
0.43303924798965454,
0.6392093896865845,
-0.1528659611940384,
-0.7298608422279358,
-0.9228206276893616,
-0.552166759967804,
0.2836489975452423,
0.06210894510149956,
0.2516659200191498,
0.37384554743766785,
-0.22267788648605347,
1.0643057823181152,
-1.0472898483276367,
-0.44833439588546753,
-0.29583656787872314,
0.2484302818775177,
-0.0895281508564949,
0.4217113256454468,
0.5863862037658691,
-0.9079321622848511,
-0.31083130836486816,
-0.32366180419921875,
-0.781459391117096,
-0.09889940917491913,
-0.08197248727083206,
-0.20728939771652222,
-0.3401510417461395,
1.0856884717941284,
-0.4581252336502075,
0.3013923764228821,
0.40604841709136963,
-0.41355276107788086,
0.06381155550479889,
-0.25900155305862427,
-0.20344562828540802,
-1.1656564474105835,
0.07085053622722626,
0.09375342726707458,
-0.2040165513753891,
-0.37876996397972107,
0.10640455782413483,
-0.004594686906784773,
-0.03478594124317169,
-0.1564069539308548,
0.5223415493965149,
-0.3952674865722656,
0.02831234596669674,
-0.38850077986717224,
0.3453756272792816,
-0.05771098658442497,
0.06763187050819397,
0.027594340965151787,
0.6701706647872925,
0.47072285413742065,
-0.521517813205719,
0.19809305667877197,
0.39189577102661133,
-0.3125806748867035,
0.8509098887443542,
-0.8419312238693237,
-0.15960095822811127,
-0.48423999547958374,
0.49882298707962036,
-0.7398120164871216,
0.05530368164181709,
-0.17392157018184662,
-0.3275587856769562,
0.08434806019067764,
0.16618648171424866,
-0.3423054814338684,
-0.09286081045866013,
-0.5495389699935913,
0.14221614599227905,
0.39869168400764465,
-0.5589998960494995,
0.25910064578056335,
0.39660942554473877,
-0.14461025595664978,
-0.527920663356781,
-0.8865848779678345,
0.29798054695129395,
-0.6627368927001953,
-0.4723449945449829,
0.8650467991828918,
0.15762531757354736,
-0.1682538390159607,
0.42544224858283997,
-0.24825790524482727,
-0.07745464891195297,
0.12731441855430603,
0.022508472204208374,
-0.09241879731416702,
0.08745589107275009,
0.5355936288833618,
0.18662646412849426,
0.05108729004859924,
-0.03213588520884514,
-0.2093888521194458,
0.7627448439598083,
0.07342075556516647,
0.09125431627035141,
0.10896134376525879,
0.7169763445854187,
0.10643839836120605,
-0.1802792251110077,
0.8057332634925842,
1.0032469034194946,
-0.4070432484149933,
-0.3173527121543884,
-0.20314250886440277,
-0.06337486207485199,
-0.39898720383644104,
0.4618430733680725,
-0.44725292921066284,
-1.1827278137207031,
0.5047945976257324,
-0.1596841961145401,
-0.11097969114780426,
0.5263927578926086,
0.22738324105739594,
-0.19156858325004578,
0.7672156691551208,
0.4541292190551758,
-0.12765739858150482,
0.6362332701683044,
-0.21703870594501495,
-0.06004464253783226,
-0.9096194505691528,
-0.44331252574920654,
-0.6343313455581665,
-0.3748634457588196,
-0.39203205704689026,
-0.4859742522239685,
0.3641527593135834,
0.05949515104293823,
-0.09905684739351273,
0.33127036690711975,
-0.2909955680370331,
0.31122374534606934,
0.593588650226593,
0.25410547852516174,
-0.12061131745576859,
0.2741621136665344,
-0.41225603222846985,
-0.11285551637411118,
-0.717430055141449,
-0.18272963166236877,
0.8050889372825623,
0.01015300303697586,
0.7170169949531555,
-0.010062367655336857,
0.8815421462059021,
0.3226276934146881,
-0.21767617762088776,
-0.6091954112052917,
0.41044577956199646,
-0.581102192401886,
-0.33711323142051697,
-0.09934171289205551,
-0.6699903011322021,
-1.1865485906600952,
0.3453168272972107,
-0.26390066742897034,
-0.4564780294895172,
0.11837595701217651,
-0.09852877259254456,
-0.18308424949645996,
-0.05211265757679939,
-0.7440138459205627,
0.8008655905723572,
0.055902350693941116,
-0.26252156496047974,
-0.39697498083114624,
-0.690232515335083,
-0.08255505561828613,
0.2542349696159363,
0.0276081170886755,
0.15322618186473846,
-0.26459407806396484,
0.738723635673523,
-0.5614765882492065,
0.5848075151443481,
-0.33703383803367615,
0.28116321563720703,
0.32769906520843506,
-0.2700940668582916,
0.5406055450439453,
-0.11379627138376236,
0.07435698807239532,
-0.16858702898025513,
-0.2745133340358734,
-0.5809488892555237,
-0.4664900302886963,
0.9727335572242737,
-0.49614644050598145,
-0.2033821940422058,
-0.3805852234363556,
-0.32259154319763184,
-0.06735482811927795,
0.03219406679272652,
0.3645103871822357,
0.6456401944160461,
-0.5112156271934509,
0.7982680201530457,
0.6554813385009766,
-0.21614791452884674,
0.41820162534713745,
-0.2762041687965393,
0.2213771939277649,
-0.3954058885574341,
0.71413254737854,
0.17122049629688263,
-0.1922605186700821,
0.6709272861480713,
0.38756969571113586,
-0.5326146483421326,
-0.33707594871520996,
-0.00417845556512475,
-0.05475688353180885,
-0.6027118563652039,
-0.1942014992237091,
-0.7495503425598145,
0.026177216321229935,
-0.3227318525314331,
-0.4379677474498749,
-0.04190222546458244,
-0.5235416293144226,
-0.3279619812965393,
-0.31759774684906006,
0.3349011242389679,
0.5615038275718689,
-0.07647687196731567,
0.42726412415504456,
-0.6894676089286804,
0.3171822726726532,
0.06718119978904724,
0.3711026906967163,
-0.09811998903751373,
-0.19809037446975708,
-0.40908774733543396,
-0.28809651732444763,
-0.1305083930492401,
-0.8299494385719299,
0.34480175375938416,
0.3749955892562866,
0.735770583152771,
0.29679441452026367,
0.01008001621812582,
1.0899724960327148,
-0.6282294392585754,
0.8644977807998657,
0.011143053881824017,
-1.0235252380371094,
0.49310269951820374,
-0.17185398936271667,
0.30212485790252686,
0.45489707589149475,
0.44506943225860596,
-0.5206456780433655,
-0.28725987672805786,
-0.7253586053848267,
-1.4217685461044312,
0.26764100790023804,
0.3061687648296356,
0.5884613394737244,
-0.4895392656326294,
0.32671794295310974,
-0.03850308060646057,
0.16927143931388855,
-0.5968483090400696,
-0.20002752542495728,
-0.4165284335613251,
-0.3454357385635376,
-0.06722645461559296,
-0.2224564254283905,
0.09776990115642548,
0.1246742308139801,
0.3376443088054657,
0.05909690260887146,
0.4222666621208191,
0.42552658915519714,
-0.39060166478157043,
0.34995540976524353,
0.18584772944450378,
0.1977599412202835,
0.2696850597858429,
-0.12812559306621552,
0.4711601138114929,
0.2594776749610901,
-0.2852970063686371,
-0.19356755912303925,
0.3678191304206848,
-0.17714542150497437,
0.34245604276657104,
0.37232038378715515,
0.620938241481781,
0.512669026851654,
-0.689598560333252,
0.669377863407135,
0.22713454067707062,
-0.04842708259820938,
-0.31860241293907166,
-0.2768251597881317,
0.14031776785850525,
0.0832844004034996,
0.45380645990371704,
-0.009202394634485245,
0.3434901237487793,
-0.5100800395011902,
0.3804602026939392,
0.5786046981811523,
-0.4096081256866455,
0.10175267606973648,
0.6185593008995056,
0.17551714181900024,
0.2950000762939453,
0.5963876247406006,
-0.10752970725297928,
-0.5522946715354919,
0.3652212917804718,
0.5128297805786133,
0.754440426826477,
-0.024194568395614624,
0.052972517907619476,
0.23330660164356232,
0.07438250631093979,
-0.29147160053253174,
0.1046595647931099,
-0.09435703605413437,
-0.6333140730857849,
-0.28156405687332153,
-0.4545910656452179,
-0.10503321141004562,
-0.24111062288284302,
-0.5447981953620911,
0.07095865905284882,
-0.1272074282169342,
-0.017712270841002464,
-0.242305725812912,
-0.16630268096923828,
-0.42896512150764465,
0.2077207714319229,
0.022927114740014076,
0.8110365867614746,
-0.816877007484436,
0.3241560161113739,
0.7590612769126892,
-0.2694458067417145,
-0.47286584973335266,
0.0036804331466555595,
-0.3014535903930664,
-0.608529269695282,
0.49463149905204773,
0.33139076828956604,
-0.001880084746517241,
-0.1129399761557579,
-0.5612965226173401,
-0.6757662296295166,
1.1732048988342285,
0.02462233044207096,
-0.22492879629135132,
0.0025667876470834017,
-0.08648721873760223,
0.49127334356307983,
-0.35464349389076233,
-0.13859011232852936,
0.24837620556354523,
0.2313833385705948,
0.22045135498046875,
-0.16350983083248138,
0.14754945039749146,
-0.07002467662096024,
0.3123764395713806,
0.1807135045528412,
-0.47472697496414185,
0.8784579634666443,
0.2674420475959778,
-0.23720766603946686,
0.24261616170406342,
1.0026123523712158,
0.15704527497291565,
0.33239588141441345,
0.5429943203926086,
0.8138213753700256,
0.6719104051589966,
-0.17569713294506073,
1.1390689611434937,
-0.23473753035068512,
0.218391552567482,
0.8857534527778625,
-0.004610511939972639,
0.8331300616264343,
0.4786348342895508,
0.20138540863990784,
0.5142307281494141,
0.34123560786247253,
-0.09158000349998474,
0.6817843914031982,
0.43830665946006775,
-0.10215356945991516,
-0.15680792927742004,
-0.20982789993286133,
-0.2464759647846222,
0.43408817052841187,
0.48383545875549316,
-0.5813945531845093,
-0.3477703630924225,
-0.06367646157741547,
0.2050999402999878,
0.4812348484992981,
-0.3373689353466034,
0.4863118827342987,
0.32897767424583435,
-0.505009651184082,
0.07455496490001678,
0.1714833378791809,
0.9033713340759277,
-0.5899568796157837,
0.15106143057346344,
-0.37500879168510437,
0.1549106240272522,
-0.15332579612731934,
-0.48959001898765564,
0.68726646900177,
0.04981484264135361,
0.12413684278726578,
-0.43908098340034485,
0.8642841577529907,
-0.5727959275245667,
-0.3674565851688385,
0.17943915724754333,
0.7295461297035217,
-0.06028757989406586,
-0.15928985178470612,
-0.38216981291770935,
-0.05701903998851776,
-0.36801469326019287,
-0.20394009351730347,
0.20738258957862854,
0.6038498878479004,
0.05994206666946411,
0.3637537956237793,
0.38574570417404175,
0.11597597599029541,
0.2342137098312378,
0.18590699136257172,
0.9582424163818359,
-0.8307932019233704,
-0.8538907170295715,
-0.8472409844398499,
0.25025391578674316,
-0.4679865539073944,
-0.3582286536693573,
0.8871257305145264,
0.8828439712524414,
0.5307198762893677,
0.06270655989646912,
0.7804587483406067,
-0.14977817237377167,
0.4246480166912079,
-0.6258969902992249,
0.21107223629951477,
-0.6161143779754639,
0.10192892700433731,
-0.4658220708370209,
-1.0083283185958862,
-0.5388099551200867,
0.9073433876037598,
0.06074487417936325,
0.008451787754893303,
0.8521282076835632,
0.5554168820381165,
-0.1574300080537796,
-0.10161837935447693,
0.11004266142845154,
0.2303290218114853,
0.16343069076538086,
0.24961158633232117,
0.7636389136314392,
-0.24983516335487366,
0.7382810711860657,
0.13786952197551727,
-0.020697200670838356,
-0.1607060730457306,
-0.85757976770401,
-0.6404829621315002,
-0.5154170393943787,
-0.1712881624698639,
-0.17740683257579803,
0.13173674046993256,
0.8077263236045837,
0.3484918177127838,
-0.19999006390571594,
-0.04754174128174782,
-0.39690282940864563,
-0.06232050061225891,
-0.41744160652160645,
-0.25826919078826904,
0.5829048752784729,
-0.5917304158210754,
-0.668542206287384,
0.6208423376083374,
0.14278683066368103,
-0.015069211833178997,
0.01718687266111374,
0.13973502814769745,
-0.2653372883796692,
0.18288183212280273,
0.8608174920082092,
-0.17953935265541077,
-0.21069176495075226,
-0.5421184301376343,
0.19287025928497314,
0.027914023026823997,
-0.15211831033229828,
0.885489284992218,
-0.8451434969902039,
0.2139851450920105,
0.649389386177063,
0.7300342321395874,
0.7013985514640808,
0.3245895802974701,
0.5172967314720154,
-1.3585824966430664,
0.10854531079530716,
0.1749553382396698,
0.5705755949020386,
0.4695962071418762,
-0.0018556843278929591,
0.6394542455673218,
0.33072414994239807,
-0.24996234476566315,
-0.5040231943130493,
0.2315722405910492,
-1.1170450448989868,
-0.5780236721038818,
1.2895958423614502,
-0.20523406565189362,
0.1399228572845459,
-0.11255527287721634,
-0.1435953676700592,
0.12861202657222748,
-0.3814077377319336,
0.4382885992527008,
0.6930980086326599,
-0.029372582212090492,
0.20501047372817993,
0.039567671716213226,
0.20119772851467133,
0.4351949393749237,
-0.37442564964294434,
-0.0771690234541893,
0.5754626989364624,
0.022544078528881073,
0.1713428944349289,
0.37110966444015503,
-0.18754726648330688,
-0.13855500519275665,
0.20959387719631195,
-0.44976139068603516,
-0.17180725932121277,
0.003183915978297591,
-0.27624163031578064,
0.5755707621574402,
-0.26913630962371826,
-0.18430259823799133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10974v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10974v2
|
Bottleneck-Minimal Indexing for Generative Document Retrieval
| 2024-05-12T11:41:26 | 2024-05-21T01:29:13 |
Xin Du, Lixin Xiu, Kumiko Tanaka-Ishii
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We apply an information-theoretic perspective to reconsider generative
document retrieval (GDR), in which a document $x \in X$ is indexed by $t \in
T$, and a neural autoregressive model is trained to map queries $Q$ to $T$. GDR
can be considered to involve information transmission from documents $X$ to
queries $Q$, with the requirement to transmit more bits via the indexes $T$. By
applying Shannon's rate-distortion theory, the optimality of indexing can be
analyzed in terms of the mutual information, and the design of the indexes $T$
can then be regarded as a {\em bottleneck} in GDR. After reformulating GDR from
this perspective, we empirically quantify the bottleneck underlying GDR.
Finally, using the NQ320K and MARCO datasets, we evaluate our proposed
bottleneck-minimal indexing method in comparison with various previous indexing
methods, and we show that it outperforms those methods.
|
[
-0.5202558636665344,
-0.5335292816162109,
0.4956279993057251,
0.15439148247241974,
-0.22914399206638336,
-0.1307743936777115,
-0.026098722591996193,
-0.346848726272583,
0.15658003091812134,
0.2883346378803253,
-0.5604904294013977,
-0.2441267967224121,
-0.45630547404289246,
0.07758885622024536,
-0.6900932192802429,
0.6344935297966003,
0.19037309288978577,
-0.13020560145378113,
-0.294306218624115,
-0.07595399767160416,
0.08777844905853271,
-0.437511682510376,
-0.6520438194274902,
-0.13379615545272827,
0.3998715281486511,
0.2804277539253235,
0.553077220916748,
0.7793445587158203,
0.8313667178153992,
0.2938007712364197,
-0.09974481910467148,
0.004847175907343626,
-0.5308030247688293,
0.2607831656932831,
-0.015914084389805794,
-0.8025921583175659,
0.01346682570874691,
-0.2018667310476303,
0.6238865852355957,
0.7395484447479248,
-0.20416387915611267,
0.18286150693893433,
0.023882070556282997,
1.0695570707321167,
-0.8358133435249329,
-0.1467052549123764,
-0.6226758360862732,
0.37578606605529785,
-0.4197726845741272,
-0.4978398382663727,
-0.2646336257457733,
-0.5089414715766907,
0.09794142097234726,
-0.723699152469635,
0.9909506440162659,
0.2814216613769531,
0.8475832939147949,
0.24171535670757294,
-0.2809946537017822,
-0.33825406432151794,
-0.6854474544525146,
0.35283443331718445,
0.03779270127415657,
0.4317111074924469,
0.32257509231567383,
0.19698263704776764,
0.14071246981620789,
-0.5819131731987,
-0.5757676362991333,
-0.10876236855983734,
0.09745123982429504,
0.03286923095583916,
-0.5107265710830688,
0.1941377967596054,
0.5877544283866882,
0.8354085683822632,
-0.7168527841567993,
0.06000613421201706,
-0.5747585296630859,
-0.13153398036956787,
0.43798455595970154,
0.42003411054611206,
-0.016340361908078194,
-0.17666813731193542,
-0.5853856801986694,
-0.34007328748703003,
-0.6350165009498596,
-0.2773565649986267,
0.500199019908905,
-0.014373281970620155,
0.22398002445697784,
0.6239420771598816,
-0.5225397348403931,
0.6406543254852295,
0.1345023363828659,
0.4804408848285675,
0.3084813952445984,
-0.7220540642738342,
-0.04925761744379997,
-0.28337791562080383,
0.8009096384048462,
0.5267350673675537,
0.010956787504255772,
-0.399253785610199,
-0.36991167068481445,
-0.055041346698999405,
0.5120002627372742,
-0.9020707011222839,
-0.1354067623615265,
-0.24158143997192383,
-0.4859316647052765,
-0.2757978141307831,
-0.0581262931227684,
-1.0609524250030518,
-0.280287504196167,
-0.06180371716618538,
0.7407074570655823,
-0.39286476373672485,
-0.08258192986249924,
-0.1920284628868103,
-0.3972752094268799,
0.2590329945087433,
0.14364118874073029,
-1.050720453262329,
0.3350268006324768,
0.5563533306121826,
1.3402658700942993,
0.06331478804349899,
0.1794721633195877,
-0.2597365975379944,
-0.07829250395298004,
-0.514800488948822,
0.8603143692016602,
-0.3711449205875397,
-0.8686361312866211,
-0.024052441120147705,
-0.2605435848236084,
-0.10367928445339203,
-0.8171332478523254,
0.5676993131637573,
-0.6436141133308411,
-0.031131090596318245,
-0.5134127140045166,
-0.5118337273597717,
0.009293245151638985,
-0.015942228958010674,
-0.9583824872970581,
0.8651894927024841,
0.26913541555404663,
-0.6124072670936584,
0.3183378279209137,
-0.7790037989616394,
-0.35724902153015137,
0.012020828202366829,
-0.1879970133304596,
-0.3142738342285156,
0.39050132036209106,
0.022335655987262726,
-0.05625816062092781,
-0.6410555243492126,
-0.14695416390895844,
-0.1795501410961151,
-0.5689594149589539,
-0.15822641551494598,
-0.5994089245796204,
0.6846458315849304,
0.5229752659797668,
-0.15328292548656464,
-0.4542044997215271,
-0.7662307024002075,
0.33650726079940796,
-0.06007802486419678,
-0.2903481721878052,
-0.3951433598995209,
-0.21790196001529694,
0.11944291740655899,
-0.029633423313498497,
0.05966353788971901,
-0.42847663164138794,
0.5879292488098145,
-0.2616061866283417,
0.5220330357551575,
0.46331682801246643,
0.13984382152557373,
0.6213575005531311,
-0.5964873433113098,
0.41547447443008423,
0.09419682621955872,
0.36376261711120605,
0.1796637773513794,
-0.3042806386947632,
-0.9492502212524414,
0.16736558079719543,
0.3107123076915741,
0.3881194293498993,
-0.6784281134605408,
-0.01953062228858471,
-0.2934303879737854,
-0.47997811436653137,
-0.8548377156257629,
0.06945368647575378,
0.353555828332901,
0.4983738660812378,
0.476245641708374,
-0.9336758852005005,
-0.4467284381389618,
-1.0396840572357178,
-0.15976695716381073,
-0.079391710460186,
-0.1721491664648056,
0.3352198600769043,
0.3370804786682129,
-0.10939772427082062,
0.6891711354255676,
-0.5934585332870483,
-0.4808502495288849,
0.020184079185128212,
0.7675079703330994,
0.3199044466018677,
0.5427529811859131,
0.4155980050563812,
-0.9018206596374512,
-0.7170863151550293,
-0.4385887086391449,
-0.3601490259170532,
-0.15684376657009125,
0.06584515422582626,
-0.15657266974449158,
0.29213449358940125,
0.49114978313446045,
-0.8484378457069397,
0.5735166072845459,
-0.062435880303382874,
0.09653821587562561,
0.31787431240081787,
-0.48289817571640015,
0.03294198960065842,
-0.6508588790893555,
0.20144346356391907,
0.021416131407022476,
0.12172473967075348,
-0.6508583426475525,
-0.08245928585529327,
0.17702554166316986,
-0.07254239916801453,
0.21591603755950928,
0.09504977613687515,
-0.7175392508506775,
-0.2324153035879135,
-0.2204311043024063,
0.24182017147541046,
0.2587389051914215,
0.4270339012145996,
-0.2516669034957886,
1.1490343809127808,
0.21146132051944733,
-0.5855666995048523,
0.20390518009662628,
0.13040980696678162,
-0.6366181969642639,
0.8770349025726318,
-0.6002985835075378,
0.2657114565372467,
-0.5375238060951233,
-0.06526961922645569,
-0.6630476713180542,
0.3123526871204376,
0.18613079190254211,
-0.3001708388328552,
0.48270928859710693,
-0.2896309494972229,
-0.42736580967903137,
-0.2542344331741333,
-0.3956059515476227,
0.5299003720283508,
0.34502097964286804,
-0.40523070096969604,
0.29863351583480835,
0.19866669178009033,
0.20163610577583313,
-0.7543668150901794,
-0.42742761969566345,
0.03000226803123951,
-0.042556650936603546,
-0.36168989539146423,
0.7716398239135742,
-0.19870297610759735,
-0.005132526624947786,
0.31242698431015015,
-0.27197277545928955,
-0.318543404340744,
0.005577374715358019,
0.12544989585876465,
0.012577943503856659,
-0.10079773515462875,
0.3777470588684082,
-0.3076854348182678,
-0.14513333141803741,
-0.1249811053276062,
-0.3431520164012909,
0.5090233087539673,
-0.14427362382411957,
-0.2051297426223755,
-0.19537504017353058,
0.6100932359695435,
0.33284711837768555,
-0.01428302563726902,
0.4019017815589905,
0.6903767585754395,
-0.1747187227010727,
-0.10853705555200577,
-0.737030029296875,
0.18735404312610626,
-0.4204510450363159,
0.4392795264720917,
-0.5114448666572571,
-0.7143720984458923,
0.3517523407936096,
0.17563976347446442,
-0.600287675857544,
0.6617124080657959,
0.37045496702194214,
-0.2512247562408447,
0.6094744205474854,
0.907656192779541,
-0.48420852422714233,
0.6356245875358582,
-0.844511866569519,
0.130153089761734,
-1.263680100440979,
-0.12769319117069244,
-0.7335913181304932,
-0.3277248442173004,
-0.8022158145904541,
-0.6287024617195129,
0.5915564894676208,
0.3087522089481354,
-0.3578508496284485,
0.12874361872673035,
-0.47614797949790955,
0.4631314277648926,
0.9850332140922546,
0.048566050827503204,
0.44505012035369873,
0.015429815277457237,
-0.12929289042949677,
0.10992888361215591,
-0.8916471600532532,
0.07150805741548538,
1.3823410272598267,
-0.16728553175926208,
0.8726036548614502,
0.1258675456047058,
0.5591830611228943,
0.24011659622192383,
0.36839431524276733,
-0.5724374055862427,
0.23320461809635162,
-0.17589585483074188,
-0.7123982310295105,
-0.38943207263946533,
-0.5685932636260986,
-1.015986680984497,
0.47961869835853577,
-0.17278440296649933,
-0.7598470449447632,
0.8232195377349854,
0.12280984967947006,
-0.32664790749549866,
0.17351385951042175,
-0.5383663773536682,
0.7440208196640015,
-0.08984748274087906,
-0.4678935706615448,
-0.542115330696106,
-0.4361165761947632,
0.22201742231845856,
0.015468493103981018,
-0.09648142009973526,
0.15599441528320312,
-0.16772733628749847,
0.5056667923927307,
-0.41556334495544434,
0.2706148624420166,
-0.258659690618515,
0.3707657754421234,
0.15004238486289978,
-0.05950726941227913,
0.4408966600894928,
-0.15613995492458344,
-0.14396215975284576,
0.1355963498353958,
0.028218749910593033,
-0.09016605466604233,
-0.7510748505592346,
0.4727044999599457,
-0.6953862905502319,
-0.7561273574829102,
-0.45311495661735535,
-0.2689570188522339,
0.04189544916152954,
0.18436484038829803,
0.7139703631401062,
0.407723993062973,
-0.21267791092395782,
0.32692092657089233,
0.7636398673057556,
0.08931716531515121,
0.35365983843803406,
0.6715387105941772,
0.30268609523773193,
-0.14973488450050354,
0.890836238861084,
0.5632617473602295,
0.22051338851451874,
0.7998016476631165,
-0.1285284459590912,
-0.39444953203201294,
-0.5758903622627258,
-0.22918057441711426,
0.009739323519170284,
-0.6305168271064758,
-0.3705337941646576,
-0.39618808031082153,
-0.3209259808063507,
-0.039448220282793045,
0.30439460277557373,
-0.479070782661438,
-0.30304154753685,
-0.23190425336360931,
0.23628996312618256,
0.08846155554056168,
0.4003371000289917,
-0.5359271764755249,
0.2808167636394501,
-0.40127724409103394,
0.44593194127082825,
0.2274399846792221,
0.671761691570282,
0.34183794260025024,
-0.21765290200710297,
-0.3972642123699188,
-0.12963534891605377,
-0.6976944804191589,
-0.7174570560455322,
0.3088459372520447,
0.5441955327987671,
0.48960497975349426,
0.561227560043335,
0.2624630630016327,
0.6356221437454224,
-0.5235954523086548,
0.34010306000709534,
0.0017878494691103697,
-0.8956483006477356,
0.27107277512550354,
0.10927928239107132,
0.05271134525537491,
0.7750667333602905,
0.663140594959259,
-0.8151185512542725,
-0.03109043277800083,
-0.553309440612793,
-1.019775629043579,
0.3634825348854065,
0.16709411144256592,
-0.024223949760198593,
0.002563281450420618,
0.3898666799068451,
-0.25771966576576233,
0.45361757278442383,
-0.2725915312767029,
-0.255205363035202,
-0.047977544367313385,
-0.02181924320757389,
-0.05440938472747803,
-0.6027252078056335,
-0.1437220573425293,
-0.18442514538764954,
0.4075324833393097,
0.018345141783356667,
0.9218063354492188,
0.708857536315918,
-0.29110187292099,
-0.34428519010543823,
0.18670430779457092,
0.633389413356781,
0.3877373933792114,
-0.5845006108283997,
0.030433330684900284,
-0.16780118644237518,
-0.5999004244804382,
0.2796880304813385,
0.05177300050854683,
-0.4901602566242218,
0.18135206401348114,
0.07814904302358627,
0.9093287587165833,
-0.08064013719558716,
-0.19912198185920715,
0.6207095384597778,
-0.21348413825035095,
-0.21344846487045288,
-0.4233488142490387,
0.10392174869775772,
-0.20406173169612885,
0.4906619191169739,
0.6068227291107178,
0.17271435260772705,
0.48964136838912964,
-0.3705899715423584,
0.07717880606651306,
0.853085994720459,
-0.12477465718984604,
-0.024520637467503548,
0.7891535758972168,
-0.05354149267077446,
-0.3628695607185364,
0.987013578414917,
-0.14124265313148499,
-0.4414251744747162,
0.6202308535575867,
0.16488130390644073,
1.101370930671692,
0.015505981631577015,
0.056698642671108246,
0.3387853801250458,
0.4801580607891083,
-0.12532205879688263,
0.12875550985336304,
-0.6893783211708069,
-0.592218816280365,
0.01935429498553276,
-0.5484399199485779,
-0.4763115644454956,
0.11165893077850342,
-0.8376036882400513,
-0.11930093914270401,
-0.11976984143257141,
-0.3817603588104248,
0.053956154733896255,
0.29945826530456543,
-1.0296483039855957,
-0.019976163282990456,
-0.2844292223453522,
1.0553854703903198,
-0.33463844656944275,
0.7640244364738464,
-0.03182882070541382,
-0.6100344061851501,
-0.2463252693414688,
0.2196723371744156,
-0.3671782314777374,
-0.8042031526565552,
0.9197847247123718,
-0.00252987677231431,
-0.044260766357183456,
0.09050415456295013,
-0.1616583615541458,
-1.129839301109314,
1.2908523082733154,
0.022390328347682953,
-0.7812178730964661,
-0.21584267914295197,
0.1481834203004837,
0.5930603742599487,
-0.291189044713974,
0.46542298793792725,
0.24775226414203644,
0.24156564474105835,
-0.04619257524609566,
-0.7248943448066711,
-0.09478114545345306,
-0.46975260972976685,
0.5433793663978577,
0.15953576564788818,
-0.7827140092849731,
0.8782471418380737,
-0.17463752627372742,
-0.5992645025253296,
0.17352798581123352,
0.2985822558403015,
-0.6381916999816895,
0.44069045782089233,
0.5323042869567871,
0.9369874596595764,
0.8406400084495544,
-0.1723317801952362,
1.0935972929000854,
-0.5984266400337219,
0.5253686904907227,
0.6965627670288086,
0.06039226055145264,
0.7772694230079651,
0.5500857830047607,
-0.33549219369888306,
0.2657596170902252,
0.35009458661079407,
-0.20218577980995178,
0.831074059009552,
0.5103403329849243,
-0.41846251487731934,
0.13031506538391113,
-0.07559581845998764,
-0.5897209048271179,
0.1701423078775406,
0.3219437897205353,
-0.38738420605659485,
-0.2717149257659912,
-0.14015361666679382,
-0.2552938163280487,
-0.29082897305488586,
-0.33528873324394226,
0.7440621256828308,
0.006195711903274059,
-0.4273020625114441,
0.7698854804039001,
0.13028430938720703,
0.6733371019363403,
-0.3647332787513733,
0.29428830742836,
-0.7279124855995178,
-0.04136966913938522,
0.16595213115215302,
-0.3224470019340515,
0.40910348296165466,
-0.17750807106494904,
-0.5780130624771118,
-0.1130245104432106,
0.5212945938110352,
-0.44254711270332336,
-0.1498481035232544,
0.01738325133919716,
0.32634666562080383,
0.06981711089611053,
-0.07073743641376495,
-0.35009533166885376,
0.007735949009656906,
-0.24911579489707947,
-0.2793833613395691,
0.4960261583328247,
0.48733654618263245,
0.07733336091041565,
0.7920716404914856,
0.26061737537384033,
0.234760582447052,
-0.03985049948096275,
-0.11642338335514069,
0.882190465927124,
-0.7725638151168823,
-0.3730517625808716,
-0.5924614667892456,
0.009026873856782913,
-0.1087321937084198,
-0.2825019955635071,
0.3710390627384186,
0.7418925166130066,
1.0053595304489136,
-0.11667989939451218,
0.8076707720756531,
-0.05081477016210556,
0.3296726942062378,
-0.5324958562850952,
0.6585440635681152,
-0.6288008689880371,
0.09484808892011642,
-0.1777050644159317,
-0.9285205006599426,
0.020654765889048576,
0.8098649382591248,
-0.11574361473321915,
-0.11360979825258255,
0.6689807176589966,
1.1298158168792725,
0.22744795680046082,
-0.0649089589715004,
0.06851138174533844,
0.1682208627462387,
0.07547598332166672,
0.9088689684867859,
0.5216169357299805,
-0.6589686870574951,
0.6812565326690674,
-0.4934338927268982,
-0.06816865503787994,
-0.39192885160446167,
-0.6750200986862183,
-0.32115238904953003,
-0.9052100777626038,
-0.13808658719062805,
-0.10393059253692627,
0.35732752084732056,
0.6105039715766907,
0.39225244522094727,
-0.30374443531036377,
-0.27738529443740845,
-0.28953394293785095,
0.3004555106163025,
-0.1914941817522049,
-0.24878160655498505,
0.4472949504852295,
-0.6972392797470093,
-0.655937135219574,
0.28467297554016113,
0.236542746424675,
0.08611986041069031,
-0.29146334528923035,
0.24773134291172028,
0.03927510231733322,
-0.17667751014232635,
0.21818691492080688,
0.3220193088054657,
-0.07293523848056793,
-0.24518650770187378,
-0.18657666444778442,
-0.33357566595077515,
0.29514747858047485,
0.9991505742073059,
-0.6250722408294678,
0.6927387118339539,
0.37300315499305725,
0.5485885739326477,
1.0903578996658325,
0.09265656024217606,
0.4573923349380493,
-0.6474516987800598,
0.013178307563066483,
0.1530967652797699,
-0.11087090522050858,
0.1185837835073471,
-0.418643981218338,
0.6370903253555298,
0.6716708540916443,
-0.6074285507202148,
-0.8651003837585449,
0.12300403416156769,
-0.7405118942260742,
0.08697884529829025,
0.5296505093574524,
0.19567859172821045,
-0.21414721012115479,
0.07801635563373566,
0.1779487431049347,
0.17125219106674194,
-0.21267203986644745,
1.0545654296875,
0.5941561460494995,
-0.22809699177742004,
-0.2779842019081116,
-0.8966291546821594,
0.8150734305381775,
0.2737199366092682,
-0.13432937860488892,
-0.1679503172636032,
0.3207063376903534,
0.13194581866264343,
0.2860417068004608,
0.9699101448059082,
-0.005401259753853083,
0.19887346029281616,
0.2423705905675888,
0.03814099729061127,
-0.12484744191169739,
-0.19749999046325684,
-0.3204435110092163,
0.3939390778541565,
0.08215901255607605,
-0.3511188328266144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07248v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07248v1
|
Limited Ability of LLMs to Simulate Human Psychological Behaviours: a Psychometric Analysis
| 2024-05-12T10:52:15 | 2024-05-12T10:52:15 |
Nikolay B Petrov, Gregory Serapio-García, Jason Rentfrow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, 68T50, I.2.7
|
The humanlike responses of large language models (LLMs) have prompted social
scientists to investigate whether LLMs can be used to simulate human
participants in experiments, opinion polls and surveys. Of central interest in
this line of research has been mapping out the psychological profiles of LLMs
by prompting them to respond to standardized questionnaires. The conflicting
findings of this research are unsurprising given that mapping out underlying,
or latent, traits from LLMs' text responses to questionnaires is no easy task.
To address this, we use psychometrics, the science of psychological
measurement. In this study, we prompt OpenAI's flagship models, GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4, to assume different personas and respond to a range of standardized
measures of personality constructs. We used two kinds of persona descriptions:
either generic (four or five random person descriptions) or specific (mostly
demographics of actual humans from a large-scale human dataset). We found that
the responses from GPT-4, but not GPT-3.5, using generic persona descriptions
show promising, albeit not perfect, psychometric properties, similar to human
norms, but the data from both LLMs when using specific demographic profiles,
show poor psychometrics properties. We conclude that, currently, when LLMs are
asked to simulate silicon personas, their responses are poor signals of
potentially underlying latent traits. Thus, our work casts doubt on LLMs'
ability to simulate individual-level human behaviour across multiple-choice
question answering tasks.
|
[
-0.37434589862823486,
-0.6254637837409973,
0.826494038105011,
0.4698503911495209,
-0.02727898582816124,
0.10862303525209427,
-0.3204076588153839,
-0.49985238909721375,
0.28412896394729614,
0.29109665751457214,
-0.6664626002311707,
-0.07095189392566681,
-0.21926037967205048,
0.23189271986484528,
-0.06515628844499588,
0.8822043538093567,
-0.13098834455013275,
0.17652611434459686,
-0.332881897687912,
0.047687236219644547,
0.028825638815760612,
-0.9910381436347961,
-0.7043731808662415,
-0.5285462141036987,
0.8298619389533997,
0.013806723058223724,
0.6200162172317505,
-0.1202816441655159,
0.37041786313056946,
0.15167655050754547,
-0.038157977163791656,
-0.08759631961584091,
-0.5524845123291016,
-0.06966068595647812,
-0.02173917554318905,
-0.7436320781707764,
-0.7061089873313904,
0.7096373438835144,
0.6491432189941406,
0.8105446696281433,
0.11028296500444412,
0.3118690550327301,
0.33321884274482727,
0.370514452457428,
-0.3000498116016388,
0.12663623690605164,
-0.20091833174228668,
0.16755913197994232,
-0.19918739795684814,
-0.1670290231704712,
-0.27148860692977905,
-0.4219807982444763,
0.07719717919826508,
-0.3527185022830963,
0.26459673047065735,
-0.010760556906461716,
0.6742649674415588,
-0.05830187350511551,
-0.3152196705341339,
-0.01781318336725235,
-1.0906057357788086,
0.6394259333610535,
-0.803385317325592,
0.0298589039593935,
0.739789605140686,
0.14556318521499634,
-0.14904974400997162,
-0.2345484495162964,
-0.517802894115448,
-0.5071861147880554,
-0.20341196656227112,
0.2786364257335663,
0.16913414001464844,
0.01358055230230093,
0.5362030863761902,
0.16529908776283264,
-0.544224739074707,
0.2416248321533203,
-0.4509120285511017,
-0.22914879024028778,
0.685425341129303,
0.5571353435516357,
0.0718984454870224,
-0.15709200501441956,
-0.266416996717453,
-0.17724990844726562,
-0.853147566318512,
0.39696675539016724,
0.7421188354492188,
0.1835380345582962,
-0.23460127413272858,
0.7234196066856384,
0.018291911110281944,
0.1690806895494461,
0.0701109766960144,
-0.4378346800804138,
0.16487069427967072,
-0.18178753554821014,
-0.054869718849658966,
-0.217892125248909,
0.8987192511558533,
0.5141097903251648,
0.5291144847869873,
-0.17970991134643555,
-0.14801077544689178,
0.28736019134521484,
0.09204734861850739,
-0.7588489651679993,
-0.1091802641749382,
0.4388390779495239,
-0.4160885214805603,
-0.22846752405166626,
0.04630383476614952,
-0.9253324270248413,
-0.390625923871994,
-0.03490076959133148,
0.10927797108888626,
-0.24385614693164825,
-0.388397216796875,
-0.08827512711286545,
0.07222562283277512,
0.546440839767456,
0.2226771116256714,
-0.8361180424690247,
0.5769526362419128,
0.4844801425933838,
0.7803332805633545,
-0.4261215627193451,
-0.5505368113517761,
-0.011920393444597721,
0.1065463274717331,
-0.3942536413669586,
0.5757316946983337,
-0.6789535880088806,
-0.5787545442581177,
-0.2212333083152771,
-0.17422252893447876,
-0.20051215589046478,
-0.48039278388023376,
0.14948715269565582,
-0.38848555088043213,
0.3082394301891327,
-0.6108152270317078,
-0.3226807117462158,
0.22492952644824982,
0.3743540048599243,
-0.4257062077522278,
0.8404165506362915,
0.2950449585914612,
-0.7111445665359497,
0.3098602294921875,
-0.6081376075744629,
-0.12162686139345169,
-0.079576276242733,
-0.586785614490509,
-0.17777986824512482,
0.12300176918506622,
0.0015691140433773398,
0.6033392548561096,
-0.3001843988895416,
0.2343020737171173,
-0.7100023627281189,
-0.6685932874679565,
0.872279703617096,
-0.4952407777309418,
0.7076221704483032,
0.10037346929311752,
-0.12910166382789612,
-0.06540460884571075,
-0.39527398347854614,
-0.11369077116250992,
0.20550714433193207,
-0.3326161205768585,
-0.06800952553749084,
0.08702012896537781,
0.00737858098000288,
0.2883519232273102,
0.2199603021144867,
-0.8352720141410828,
0.3291763663291931,
-0.28860151767730713,
0.455851286649704,
0.8596665263175964,
0.012654232792556286,
0.29900169372558594,
-0.6658408045768738,
0.8396180272102356,
-0.06081391125917435,
-0.06482613831758499,
0.28598225116729736,
-0.6719493865966797,
-0.2156190425157547,
-0.5289804935455322,
0.012752820737659931,
0.5933130979537964,
-0.23388303816318512,
0.16316024959087372,
-0.13078312575817108,
-0.6197683811187744,
-0.33941757678985596,
-0.07634403556585312,
0.4238364100456238,
0.26237890124320984,
-0.15531247854232788,
-0.31285402178764343,
-0.5468222498893738,
-0.8778258562088013,
-0.49525150656700134,
-0.595265805721283,
-0.5033985376358032,
0.44610366225242615,
0.48736047744750977,
-0.1056964099407196,
0.9968398213386536,
-0.33014222979545593,
-0.025351792573928833,
-0.12296604365110397,
0.2180788666009903,
-0.0022293960209935904,
0.006351888179779053,
0.6754150390625,
-0.707940399646759,
-0.004429987166076899,
-0.5284993648529053,
-0.8369470834732056,
-0.11715517193078995,
-0.0673603042960167,
0.26355215907096863,
-0.0763651430606842,
0.29451674222946167,
-0.5712039470672607,
0.36239299178123474,
0.4317142963409424,
-0.3153783679008484,
0.9368884563446045,
-0.07184603065252304,
0.1885376274585724,
-0.8421462774276733,
0.09832030534744263,
0.24753578007221222,
0.0950239971280098,
-0.4320458471775055,
0.061482105404138565,
-0.1582317352294922,
-0.16841711103916168,
-0.5590915083885193,
0.695347785949707,
-0.08596163243055344,
-0.311184287071228,
0.09213213622570038,
-0.03405698761343956,
-0.36318185925483704,
0.6504225134849548,
-0.1041753813624382,
1.1207555532455444,
0.2887308597564697,
-0.7077970504760742,
0.27403509616851807,
0.18133723735809326,
-0.12841786444187164,
0.8379546999931335,
-0.7199888825416565,
0.21829964220523834,
-0.2124609351158142,
0.36053019762039185,
-1.2181241512298584,
-0.715423047542572,
0.2777814269065857,
-0.5020556449890137,
-0.15600527822971344,
0.2017197161912918,
-0.6378150582313538,
-0.4745437800884247,
-0.4698587656021118,
0.3267662525177002,
0.7831577658653259,
-0.048445507884025574,
0.675552487373352,
0.13001182675361633,
-0.33360475301742554,
-0.0001730630756355822,
-0.7593852877616882,
-0.031465400010347366,
-0.6617432236671448,
-0.45123088359832764,
0.24123665690422058,
-0.4250819683074951,
-0.4317125380039215,
-0.2272346019744873,
0.09597062319517136,
-0.07257114350795746,
0.046865660697221756,
0.20796819031238556,
0.37092167139053345,
-0.2402888685464859,
-0.19367550313472748,
-0.4079208970069885,
0.04907854646444321,
0.33817386627197266,
0.16579431295394897,
0.5143932104110718,
-0.19127392768859863,
-0.5702973008155823,
-0.5095233917236328,
0.20235249400138855,
0.7433137893676758,
0.020683852955698967,
0.5685649514198303,
0.45401495695114136,
-0.32276442646980286,
0.3988243043422699,
-0.4417931139469147,
-0.29758065938949585,
-0.4665268659591675,
0.26035094261169434,
-0.5986363291740417,
-0.9253947734832764,
0.8185856342315674,
0.045810554176568985,
-0.02145450934767723,
0.10359520465135574,
0.6730415225028992,
-0.4449589252471924,
1.1830462217330933,
0.4598934054374695,
-0.09500812739133835,
0.08240810036659241,
0.16347424685955048,
0.3018278479576111,
-1.1407244205474854,
-0.24992121756076813,
-0.4639784097671509,
-0.5766655206680298,
-0.8289777636528015,
-0.1035224050283432,
0.5041879415512085,
-0.37440648674964905,
-0.493754506111145,
-0.13573017716407776,
-0.1546907275915146,
0.2537592053413391,
0.473814457654953,
0.3009861707687378,
0.06540780514478683,
0.0696106106042862,
-0.03982548788189888,
-0.33285555243492126,
-0.2302594631910324,
-0.8965613842010498,
1.144282341003418,
0.35854029655456543,
1.0871245861053467,
0.061744771897792816,
0.5808390378952026,
-0.039351191371679306,
0.550045371055603,
-0.5508924126625061,
0.8682504296302795,
0.07325194031000137,
-0.6932591795921326,
-0.37890997529029846,
-0.5237506031990051,
-0.8119990229606628,
0.03991880640387535,
0.091023288667202,
-1.2630178928375244,
0.12274540960788727,
0.11571373790502548,
-0.4139023423194885,
0.43738120794296265,
-0.5898709297180176,
0.42729413509368896,
-0.3044007122516632,
-0.14524225890636444,
0.2512049973011017,
-0.4720521569252014,
0.5400717258453369,
-0.24958153069019318,
0.09128828346729279,
-0.31335994601249695,
-0.19384002685546875,
0.8878644108772278,
-0.0071297273971140385,
1.3248809576034546,
-0.16008226573467255,
-0.23823025822639465,
0.09315090626478195,
0.27415022253990173,
0.0993138998746872,
0.0025837630964815617,
-0.3033345937728882,
-0.13654325902462006,
0.32103466987609863,
-0.615212082862854,
-0.732687771320343,
0.7122802734375,
-1.1790192127227783,
-0.6168830394744873,
-0.40121981501579285,
-0.41240614652633667,
-0.5736913681030273,
-0.2303617298603058,
0.27685388922691345,
0.16952335834503174,
-0.5375409722328186,
-0.08077100664377213,
0.4155975878238678,
-0.13401363790035248,
0.2164020836353302,
0.41869333386421204,
-0.2986873388290405,
-0.16178931295871735,
0.7224462032318115,
0.06882632523775101,
0.2939535677433014,
0.023232351988554,
0.35825976729393005,
-0.19590477645397186,
-0.14686569571495056,
-0.10222724825143814,
0.513107419013977,
-0.2772051990032196,
0.3504142761230469,
-0.2717096507549286,
-0.1426791101694107,
-0.4783800542354584,
-0.14307723939418793,
-0.06269897520542145,
-0.12155840545892715,
-0.17589274048805237,
-0.014055886305868626,
0.11566503345966339,
0.8837209939956665,
0.17028376460075378,
0.28712865710258484,
-0.2820785641670227,
0.47826364636421204,
0.42480310797691345,
0.4044595956802368,
0.05272704362869263,
-0.6166993379592896,
0.34068864583969116,
0.29404783248901367,
-0.27746158838272095,
-1.1260724067687988,
0.21690797805786133,
-0.002497616223990917,
0.5091406106948853,
0.5602391958236694,
-0.05725537985563278,
0.6169825196266174,
-0.20908653736114502,
1.065942406654358,
-0.1405358612537384,
-0.4342555105686188,
0.3797978460788727,
-0.6065723299980164,
0.0425417385995388,
0.505524754524231,
0.6993781328201294,
-0.47856611013412476,
-0.585782527923584,
-0.6377443671226501,
-0.5227914452552795,
0.5897936224937439,
0.323353111743927,
0.3063790500164032,
0.022959552705287933,
0.7220996618270874,
0.013043815270066261,
0.21312452852725983,
-0.8649514317512512,
-0.14011487364768982,
0.022847382351756096,
-0.21573452651500702,
-0.3216273784637451,
-0.3587128221988678,
-0.17721524834632874,
-0.1999540477991104,
0.3568679988384247,
-0.0027900657150894403,
0.5801072120666504,
0.21120448410511017,
0.43343380093574524,
-0.04791756719350815,
0.2654325067996979,
0.5369143486022949,
0.5620297193527222,
-0.505554735660553,
0.04015682265162468,
0.07994615286588669,
-0.6102195382118225,
0.5188107490539551,
-0.13783743977546692,
-0.20745769143104553,
-0.47489482164382935,
0.14161427319049835,
0.3716927170753479,
0.11840900033712387,
-0.6315931081771851,
0.43317997455596924,
-0.19782236218452454,
-0.3689626455307007,
-0.5251244902610779,
0.2386336773633957,
0.17070765793323517,
0.15032541751861572,
0.23538516461849213,
-0.06593605875968933,
-0.22263038158416748,
-0.8440898656845093,
-0.08030970394611359,
0.3484933078289032,
-0.3045860528945923,
-0.6850510835647583,
0.7084164619445801,
0.0031671582255512476,
-0.7207024693489075,
0.7111371159553528,
-0.42495280504226685,
-0.150628000497818,
0.652188777923584,
0.5641422867774963,
0.7292813062667847,
-0.24315011501312256,
0.19994978606700897,
0.17900744080543518,
0.29296931624412537,
-0.06459377706050873,
0.5445706248283386,
0.33507847785949707,
-0.7579089403152466,
-0.38349005579948425,
-0.694968581199646,
-0.7027732729911804,
0.49719271063804626,
-0.7150779962539673,
-0.003553505754098296,
-0.49220168590545654,
-0.2823181748390198,
-0.3185133635997772,
-0.08676190674304962,
-0.9320856928825378,
0.12851616740226746,
0.13868802785873413,
0.7008901238441467,
-1.1306685209274292,
0.5127975940704346,
1.0137567520141602,
-0.5503433346748352,
-0.827111005783081,
0.28418731689453125,
0.045600712299346924,
-0.7009029388427734,
0.45564326643943787,
0.07296252995729446,
-0.02244126982986927,
-0.16955624520778656,
-0.6505060195922852,
-0.5551493167877197,
1.0388611555099487,
0.46795812249183655,
0.0006340522668324411,
-0.48051539063453674,
0.5293646454811096,
0.6739282011985779,
-0.38919371366500854,
0.3703852891921997,
0.679792046546936,
0.54697585105896,
0.0024527928326278925,
-0.9771719574928284,
0.04201165959239006,
-0.20136405527591705,
0.04374464601278305,
-0.3636980950832367,
-0.811581552028656,
0.9384874701499939,
-0.2989409267902374,
0.010021040216088295,
0.37319666147232056,
0.6345329284667969,
0.7065128684043884,
0.20270459353923798,
0.34220415353775024,
0.20847433805465698,
0.8395370841026306,
0.07522064447402954,
1.2319144010543823,
-0.17792776226997375,
0.17888695001602173,
0.9043552279472351,
-0.6841414570808411,
0.8686199188232422,
0.46290653944015503,
-0.5760086178779602,
0.4569548964500427,
0.8216394186019897,
0.09897638857364655,
0.24362607300281525,
0.272131085395813,
-0.227640300989151,
-0.07837988436222076,
0.23852834105491638,
-0.046376779675483704,
0.6383044123649597,
0.4531528353691101,
0.03128915652632713,
0.0036960728466510773,
0.05241481214761734,
-0.0336289145052433,
0.015658274292945862,
-0.08947711437940598,
0.40926358103752136,
0.12893083691596985,
-0.6292468905448914,
0.33170780539512634,
0.0816105306148529,
0.8341293931007385,
-0.6863102912902832,
0.27982547879219055,
-0.3628057539463043,
-0.06670600920915604,
-0.07904920727014542,
-0.9219646453857422,
0.14019130170345306,
0.12583738565444946,
0.07540454715490341,
-0.3676031231880188,
0.5524408221244812,
0.008909884840250015,
-0.4576174318790436,
0.08912346512079239,
0.8163782358169556,
0.6854814291000366,
-0.10327617824077606,
-0.29780659079551697,
-0.27819162607192993,
-0.19700635969638824,
-0.5270682573318481,
0.668585479259491,
0.2223626673221588,
-0.03647354245185852,
0.7687665820121765,
0.4829493463039398,
0.4222617745399475,
-0.1088203713297844,
-0.03997626528143883,
0.638650119304657,
-0.9062588214874268,
-0.5079018473625183,
-0.9097030162811279,
0.14789070188999176,
0.09914974123239517,
-0.45148828625679016,
0.6908319592475891,
0.4619343876838684,
0.8027238845825195,
-0.1233639121055603,
0.8231236338615417,
0.20478011667728424,
0.43202102184295654,
-0.4704826772212982,
0.5898562669754028,
-0.29072535037994385,
0.16269338130950928,
-0.258417010307312,
-1.018904685974121,
0.09996160864830017,
0.609213650226593,
-0.48746317625045776,
0.4721428453922272,
0.6066902875900269,
0.8265193700790405,
-0.1629018932580948,
-0.08418956398963928,
0.43063101172447205,
0.3000780940055847,
0.2626420557498932,
0.670951247215271,
0.9079211950302124,
0.07184074074029922,
0.3313691318035126,
0.0031670918688178062,
-0.37053531408309937,
-0.029893385246396065,
-0.6221914887428284,
-1.1553817987442017,
-0.400777131319046,
-0.07111263275146484,
-0.18823784589767456,
-0.15499991178512573,
0.685161292552948,
0.5551081299781799,
-0.37548843026161194,
-0.4557758867740631,
0.42572274804115295,
-0.3226652443408966,
-0.11984584480524063,
-0.24362127482891083,
0.053112421184778214,
0.02887238934636116,
-0.5310602784156799,
0.09588441997766495,
0.10382868349552155,
0.2939063012599945,
-0.8866114020347595,
-0.04622452333569527,
0.2472972571849823,
0.3996460735797882,
0.40969377756118774,
0.3447912633419037,
-1.0503758192062378,
-0.4532880187034607,
0.24617569148540497,
-0.2815324366092682,
0.13895592093467712,
0.9277621507644653,
-0.8441769480705261,
-0.1625414788722992,
0.1760334074497223,
0.2297368347644806,
0.25406086444854736,
-0.027368418872356415,
0.5091462135314941,
-0.8080823421478271,
0.14976336061954498,
0.30240026116371155,
0.3625614047050476,
0.3221876621246338,
-0.3823958933353424,
0.38178643584251404,
0.19775092601776123,
-0.4254372715950012,
-0.5960298776626587,
0.4433199167251587,
-0.9280776977539062,
-0.02257726900279522,
1.3092033863067627,
-0.12753629684448242,
-0.31329163908958435,
0.05373677611351013,
-0.22014941275119781,
-0.20523670315742493,
-0.31080561876296997,
0.8208289742469788,
0.8537387251853943,
-0.5201317071914673,
0.00792982243001461,
-0.7841979265213013,
0.28282710909843445,
0.296669065952301,
-0.7646132707595825,
0.0106069166213274,
0.20200267434120178,
0.4090414047241211,
0.06250786036252975,
1.1983375549316406,
-0.1942722350358963,
0.17757655680179596,
-0.09398840367794037,
-0.1752736121416092,
0.11734440922737122,
-0.047308292239904404,
-0.20331275463104248,
0.20282332599163055,
0.3029751181602478,
0.1956554800271988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13003v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13003v1
|
A Survey on Recent Advances in Conversational Data Generation
| 2024-05-12T10:11:12 | 2024-05-12T10:11:12 |
Heydar Soudani, Roxana Petcu, Evangelos Kanoulas, Faegheh Hasibi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Recent advancements in conversational systems have significantly enhanced
human-machine interactions across various domains. However, training these
systems is challenging due to the scarcity of specialized dialogue data.
Traditionally, conversational datasets were created through crowdsourcing, but
this method has proven costly, limited in scale, and labor-intensive. As a
solution, the development of synthetic dialogue data has emerged, utilizing
techniques to augment existing datasets or convert textual resources into
conversational formats, providing a more efficient and scalable approach to
dataset creation. In this survey, we offer a systematic and comprehensive
review of multi-turn conversational data generation, focusing on three types of
dialogue systems: open domain, task-oriented, and information-seeking. We
categorize the existing research based on key components like seed data
creation, utterance generation, and quality filtering methods, and introduce a
general framework that outlines the main principles of conversation data
generation systems. Additionally, we examine the evaluation metrics and methods
for assessing synthetic conversational data, address current challenges in the
field, and explore potential directions for future research. Our goal is to
accelerate progress for researchers and practitioners by presenting an overview
of state-of-the-art methods and highlighting opportunities to further research
in this area.
|
[
-0.5722568035125732,
-0.928230881690979,
0.4350305199623108,
0.08177941292524338,
0.08648495376110077,
0.3710169792175293,
-0.14778728783130646,
-0.3461821973323822,
0.22010299563407898,
0.6558626294136047,
-0.852182924747467,
-0.38158541917800903,
-0.2560632526874542,
0.016467709094285965,
-0.3540192246437073,
0.8655533194541931,
0.37370672821998596,
0.26025450229644775,
-0.44956541061401367,
-0.030518313869833946,
-0.5411486029624939,
-0.9288272261619568,
-0.5600275993347168,
-0.04687105491757393,
0.16683213412761688,
0.6436523795127869,
0.6134322285652161,
0.004218825604766607,
0.2943112850189209,
0.3360503613948822,
0.19676397740840912,
0.7038275003433228,
-0.6596483588218689,
0.45901480317115784,
0.33809009194374084,
-0.23403121531009674,
-0.4198470711708069,
-0.08177278190851212,
0.3871637284755707,
0.8699139356613159,
-0.326182097196579,
-0.03204995393753052,
-0.10351905226707458,
0.7240808010101318,
-0.38624346256256104,
0.2297152280807495,
-0.8219746947288513,
0.14260251820087433,
-0.33309662342071533,
-0.31823456287384033,
-0.4383656084537506,
-0.7505841255187988,
0.44265061616897583,
-0.6003838777542114,
0.6353592872619629,
0.27050524950027466,
0.20354300737380981,
-0.23985572159290314,
-0.36919349431991577,
-0.6388458013534546,
-1.0491530895233154,
0.9087514281272888,
-0.7262280583381653,
0.3087228238582611,
0.053280722349882126,
0.3855186700820923,
-0.4420054852962494,
-0.6616910099983215,
-0.645393967628479,
-0.17503710091114044,
0.15060949325561523,
0.20250792801380157,
-0.2997362017631531,
-0.04463624954223633,
0.047318365424871445,
0.4966817796230316,
-0.4514382481575012,
-0.2735211253166199,
-0.42173391580581665,
-0.12554919719696045,
0.6997773051261902,
0.48003724217414856,
0.22077208757400513,
-0.1096453070640564,
0.020924881100654602,
-0.29656660556793213,
-0.6701951026916504,
-0.18460683524608612,
0.6554229259490967,
0.5702595114707947,
0.05407121777534485,
0.6817465424537659,
-0.6113303899765015,
0.7644221782684326,
0.17826269567012787,
-0.048681966960430145,
0.29563936591148376,
-0.9319111108779907,
0.2079339623451233,
-0.05283961445093155,
0.9632266759872437,
0.5127294659614563,
0.15271826088428497,
-0.1020640879869461,
0.1783403903245926,
-0.2202477604150772,
0.36042729020118713,
-0.6969236731529236,
-0.18665464222431183,
0.2450893670320511,
-0.30112648010253906,
-0.4193759858608246,
0.11370428651571274,
-0.9527832865715027,
-0.34089991450309753,
-0.480802446603775,
-0.4010855555534363,
-0.39404794573783875,
-0.4520196318626404,
0.057777196168899536,
-0.09600270539522171,
0.20041905343532562,
0.29191645979881287,
-0.8473449945449829,
0.161019966006279,
0.523938775062561,
0.7259638905525208,
-0.3986101746559143,
0.15692372620105743,
-0.1508713662624359,
-0.15301306545734406,
-0.3583577573299408,
0.8245391845703125,
-0.5661067962646484,
-0.7401807904243469,
0.40828484296798706,
-0.2091521918773651,
-0.0476660281419754,
-0.7589269876480103,
0.45740389823913574,
-0.36762967705726624,
0.6388013958930969,
0.024287384003400803,
-0.16185683012008667,
0.023022880777716637,
0.2874467968940735,
-0.4186517298221588,
0.8658999800682068,
0.04446560889482498,
-0.6464822888374329,
0.3685302138328552,
-0.5375732779502869,
-0.39069533348083496,
-0.10864045470952988,
-0.33652713894844055,
-0.5212566256523132,
-0.08842667192220688,
0.3071908950805664,
0.34260112047195435,
-0.6199314594268799,
0.5216644406318665,
-0.20551927387714386,
0.11460819095373154,
0.7276661396026611,
-0.58893883228302,
0.20747971534729004,
0.3298080563545227,
-0.1871400773525238,
-0.013858537189662457,
-0.8780194520950317,
0.42310065031051636,
0.05015555024147034,
-0.12131426483392715,
0.22514566779136658,
0.24483133852481842,
0.03126588836312294,
0.2708306908607483,
-0.05387509614229202,
-0.7347657084465027,
0.1467798799276352,
-0.3376113772392273,
0.4799462556838989,
0.4175451993942261,
0.4111040532588959,
0.3097901940345764,
-0.31252580881118774,
0.3710860311985016,
0.2845076620578766,
0.1619422286748886,
-0.5385335087776184,
-0.6533357501029968,
-0.9478741884231567,
0.2034507840871811,
0.07937520742416382,
0.351590096950531,
-0.9203338027000427,
0.3480668067932129,
-0.21000629663467407,
-0.6066364645957947,
-0.5619403123855591,
-0.09510836005210876,
0.3978026509284973,
0.20692852139472961,
0.35533297061920166,
-0.4348051846027374,
-0.6793535351753235,
-0.8858603835105896,
-0.019010981544852257,
-0.16942472755908966,
-0.12075785547494888,
0.7458290457725525,
-0.1704636812210083,
-0.11887764930725098,
1.263815999031067,
-0.6865724921226501,
0.15472057461738586,
-0.4207029342651367,
0.3247743546962738,
-0.047130897641181946,
0.5395989418029785,
0.1637437492609024,
-0.6238694190979004,
-0.23892205953598022,
-0.02668801322579384,
-0.5249476432800293,
0.08269977569580078,
-0.10157538950443268,
-0.08041469752788544,
-0.009613997302949429,
0.1818997710943222,
-0.6355369091033936,
0.2591826021671295,
0.4384971857070923,
0.19075343012809753,
0.41219449043273926,
0.14560942351818085,
0.3844381272792816,
-0.9262515902519226,
-0.019376160576939583,
-0.12101884931325912,
0.010337336920201778,
-1.1510266065597534,
-0.7019304037094116,
-0.4337061047554016,
-0.5487875938415527,
-0.30194175243377686,
0.15700846910476685,
-0.36091098189353943,
-0.06116998568177223,
-0.1461821049451828,
0.18808513879776,
-0.21067693829536438,
0.5522637367248535,
0.23341310024261475,
0.6132181286811829,
0.27136707305908203,
-0.6936758756637573,
0.6447603702545166,
0.6259996891021729,
-0.3926095962524414,
0.7225562334060669,
-0.5634320378303528,
0.6743642091751099,
-0.008034434169530869,
0.5173835158348083,
-0.9387385249137878,
-0.5414562821388245,
0.4210262894630432,
-0.6107102036476135,
-0.08714056760072708,
-0.06656284630298615,
-0.25986480712890625,
-0.4244948923587799,
0.1085616871714592,
0.4335479438304901,
0.3955698311328888,
-0.36757585406303406,
-0.012275590561330318,
0.47785356640815735,
-0.6450693011283875,
-0.18035247921943665,
-0.28994259238243103,
0.16655465960502625,
-0.018285805359482765,
-0.7429889440536499,
0.07249966263771057,
-0.05367470532655716,
-0.2722078859806061,
-0.7120327353477478,
0.16730913519859314,
-0.023646095767617226,
-0.50810706615448,
0.10245984047651291,
0.1038474589586258,
0.00554629834368825,
-0.06275221705436707,
-0.1319442093372345,
-0.08046556264162064,
0.12079603224992752,
-0.22708499431610107,
0.7967684864997864,
0.09027036279439926,
-0.5963308215141296,
-0.32071614265441895,
0.4319770634174347,
0.36372631788253784,
0.0619148425757885,
0.19628214836120605,
0.3864802420139313,
0.11117025464773178,
-0.09748708456754684,
-0.5325770378112793,
-0.28789228200912476,
-0.45871174335479736,
0.23291781544685364,
-0.1327078640460968,
-0.7460361123085022,
-0.040546536445617676,
-0.2536207437515259,
0.31836602091789246,
0.1373840719461441,
0.6107355952262878,
-0.020006680861115456,
1.3648344278335571,
0.2692449390888214,
0.25733834505081177,
0.41506269574165344,
-0.12988018989562988,
0.5733261108398438,
-0.5165848135948181,
-0.5804590582847595,
-0.6349690556526184,
0.007654685527086258,
-0.6921796798706055,
-0.40458667278289795,
0.43606239557266235,
-0.4385351538658142,
0.17189759016036987,
0.18340139091014862,
-0.6236782670021057,
-0.1096818819642067,
0.6600322127342224,
-0.027736226096749306,
0.4553286135196686,
-0.046474337577819824,
0.35034024715423584,
-0.034455619752407074,
-0.6956800818443298,
-0.4551532566547394,
1.2311768531799316,
0.06425058841705322,
0.5526013374328613,
-0.08482801914215088,
0.348207026720047,
0.29283490777015686,
0.00704021705314517,
-0.6648820042610168,
0.5755130052566528,
0.31667613983154297,
-0.6556167006492615,
-0.36353060603141785,
-0.5104987025260925,
-1.1413257122039795,
0.020536355674266815,
-0.1453261822462082,
-0.3581565320491791,
0.08337686955928802,
0.16960272192955017,
-0.07525221258401871,
0.0651850551366806,
-0.68136066198349,
0.46675077080726624,
-0.1962827742099762,
-0.08265048265457153,
-0.14003483951091766,
-0.6534533500671387,
0.5099512338638306,
-0.10535649955272675,
0.06924833357334137,
-0.18889865279197693,
0.6059170961380005,
0.6642712950706482,
-0.4425792098045349,
0.7520778775215149,
-0.45228126645088196,
-0.2409818321466446,
0.8114940524101257,
-0.21453428268432617,
0.5153040885925293,
0.07397312670946121,
0.07717933505773544,
0.1892915964126587,
-0.00787066388875246,
-0.3265751004219055,
-0.481827974319458,
0.4348885118961334,
-0.47926512360572815,
-0.29250368475914,
-0.12862958014011383,
-0.39763984084129333,
-0.8835629224777222,
-0.11249428242444992,
0.16841302812099457,
0.49962934851646423,
-0.7077189683914185,
0.316501647233963,
0.4953603148460388,
-0.36686670780181885,
0.16151350736618042,
0.3424927890300751,
-0.027921481058001518,
-0.5874701142311096,
1.1143639087677002,
-0.06329512596130371,
0.41735583543777466,
0.0735497996211052,
-0.23019351065158844,
-0.18149615824222565,
-0.5292198657989502,
-0.6184069514274597,
-0.2026110738515854,
0.03296181559562683,
-0.15533451735973358,
-0.566721498966217,
-0.324921578168869,
-0.6681861877441406,
0.16147464513778687,
-0.5348348021507263,
-0.5304787158966064,
-0.22177264094352722,
0.04193625971674919,
0.3712567687034607,
0.8905002474784851,
0.23526160418987274,
0.48239779472351074,
-0.7413619756698608,
0.3283802568912506,
0.35973551869392395,
0.11907966434955597,
-0.08214100450277328,
0.006366889923810959,
-0.24103011190891266,
0.5330225825309753,
-0.7437905669212341,
-0.5112356543540955,
0.43585363030433655,
0.09836431592702866,
0.38589635491371155,
0.369305282831192,
0.07796867936849594,
0.5846433043479919,
-0.3707975447177887,
1.0601580142974854,
0.5516297221183777,
-0.4106723964214325,
0.6894925832748413,
-0.5139471888542175,
0.15454170107841492,
0.4443405568599701,
0.13664619624614716,
-0.8511600494384766,
-0.289579302072525,
-0.9174014925956726,
-0.6392375230789185,
0.9117078185081482,
0.4976063668727875,
0.29218825697898865,
0.05368610844016075,
-0.11741606146097183,
0.3900531530380249,
0.54376220703125,
-0.001333471154794097,
-0.16040803492069244,
-0.3024386763572693,
-0.14716577529907227,
0.08293307572603226,
0.18779048323631287,
-0.15088897943496704,
0.16091914474964142,
0.47985970973968506,
-0.3044355511665344,
0.5374086499214172,
-0.05097116157412529,
0.30573204159736633,
0.12200693041086197,
0.546471118927002,
0.31346023082733154,
0.3462809920310974,
-0.0573062039911747,
-0.38384801149368286,
-0.06558848172426224,
-0.4569215774536133,
0.19833804666996002,
-0.05731683969497681,
-0.17787249386310577,
0.1414276361465454,
-0.1604267656803131,
0.906329870223999,
0.11967777460813522,
-0.6896868348121643,
0.4485000669956207,
-0.12422927469015121,
-0.4132266938686371,
-0.36391928791999817,
0.22397315502166748,
-0.2333998829126358,
-0.015463199466466904,
0.35563117265701294,
0.17439480125904083,
0.08771053701639175,
-0.6764222979545593,
-0.019899241626262665,
0.4498409628868103,
-0.302677720785141,
-0.4421447515487671,
0.0700182318687439,
0.605370044708252,
-0.37349969148635864,
0.8064261674880981,
0.035541336983442307,
0.14011186361312866,
0.22544775903224945,
0.38656458258628845,
0.844869077205658,
-0.04069609194993973,
0.5196126699447632,
0.39235132932662964,
-0.3153175115585327,
0.13225655257701874,
0.22526204586029053,
-0.4450990855693817,
-0.9180576205253601,
-0.05264761671423912,
-0.3131153881549835,
-0.983982503414154,
0.3490484952926636,
-0.5337177515029907,
-0.023065412417054176,
-0.16067121922969818,
-0.48135143518447876,
0.011828199960291386,
-0.1991407424211502,
-0.7476490139961243,
0.06967436522245407,
-0.013088226318359375,
0.33965161442756653,
-0.35001662373542786,
0.24017655849456787,
0.23099827766418457,
-0.06687013059854507,
-0.09665366262197495,
-0.1854628622531891,
0.0936097502708435,
-0.6973829865455627,
0.1778736710548401,
-0.09774572402238846,
-0.15072797238826752,
-0.10002598911523819,
-0.7448607683181763,
-0.8129175901412964,
0.805469810962677,
-0.10611023753881454,
-0.46239715814590454,
-0.2993992269039154,
0.6952803134918213,
0.5040314793586731,
-0.48971450328826904,
0.3031174838542938,
0.9021498560905457,
0.41026782989501953,
0.33778586983680725,
-0.7149385809898376,
-0.43095293641090393,
-0.3523854613304138,
0.058625444769859314,
0.1201166883111,
-0.8816431760787964,
0.3820197880268097,
0.0020260028541088104,
-0.35801854729652405,
0.39417433738708496,
0.5335792899131775,
0.4570244252681732,
0.478354275226593,
0.3699895441532135,
0.09602802991867065,
0.5266714692115784,
-0.43597790598869324,
0.49546927213668823,
-0.2225949615240097,
-0.13316932320594788,
1.0098308324813843,
-0.43712878227233887,
0.4551891088485718,
0.30615490674972534,
-0.3472050130367279,
0.3780316412448883,
0.6386147141456604,
0.03443218022584915,
0.3099527955055237,
0.39632511138916016,
-0.35631874203681946,
-0.07869883626699448,
-0.3490847051143646,
-0.25173473358154297,
0.5446986556053162,
0.624444305896759,
-0.1911163628101349,
0.06834636628627777,
0.20888499915599823,
-0.16970878839492798,
-0.22813956439495087,
0.26993629336357117,
1.304345726966858,
-0.19871915876865387,
-0.9463288187980652,
0.4550511837005615,
-0.23190002143383026,
0.529226541519165,
-0.5409170389175415,
-0.15943171083927155,
-0.2278071790933609,
-0.0897197499871254,
-0.13140921294689178,
-0.6323837041854858,
-0.058816760778427124,
0.21806083619594574,
-0.07228827476501465,
-0.47784537076950073,
0.5786851048469543,
-0.3979228734970093,
-0.08892351388931274,
-0.39321163296699524,
0.8635894060134888,
0.3703901171684265,
0.04639884829521179,
-0.36770099401474,
0.01831917278468609,
0.29154956340789795,
-0.11994820088148117,
0.0820160061120987,
0.39672648906707764,
0.07868901640176773,
0.5368180274963379,
0.8594797253608704,
0.10438279807567596,
0.17251892387866974,
0.2589336931705475,
0.8883896470069885,
-0.810770571231842,
-0.19172245264053345,
0.04802732542157173,
0.47813495993614197,
-0.3607198894023895,
-0.576029360294342,
0.6757349371910095,
0.6793874502182007,
0.8236507773399353,
0.004362377338111401,
1.2028985023498535,
-0.1420070379972458,
0.9272132515907288,
-0.5129112601280212,
0.20125523209571838,
0.19690915942192078,
-0.055366355925798416,
-0.3190757930278778,
-0.967555582523346,
0.24168182909488678,
-0.021189531311392784,
-0.24485380947589874,
0.12767240405082703,
0.26538947224617004,
0.8963451385498047,
0.07898485660552979,
0.6663249731063843,
0.12484925985336304,
-0.17386280000209808,
0.5496149659156799,
0.29755231738090515,
1.3455270528793335,
-0.34680959582328796,
0.7268874049186707,
-0.008087455295026302,
-0.027656972408294678,
-0.30945515632629395,
-0.27885252237319946,
-0.555056095123291,
-0.8323549628257751,
-0.10820053517818451,
-0.11192929744720459,
0.03913911432027817,
0.6920711994171143,
0.9523441195487976,
-0.9126434922218323,
-0.17383727431297302,
-0.4674438238143921,
-0.3433187007904053,
0.09334443509578705,
-0.2694251537322998,
-0.15844404697418213,
-0.5447496175765991,
-1.0501914024353027,
0.7902157306671143,
0.02351382188498974,
0.24732880294322968,
-0.35629966855049133,
-0.0584491491317749,
0.14704576134681702,
0.2316044270992279,
0.6285188794136047,
0.4997082054615021,
-0.4225020706653595,
-0.008119333535432816,
0.17026634514331818,
-0.017738869413733482,
0.32115092873573303,
1.4148836135864258,
-0.7838477492332458,
0.6686012744903564,
0.3807915449142456,
0.48178568482398987,
0.7758342027664185,
0.28275299072265625,
0.9398224949836731,
-0.9456946849822998,
-0.07868599891662598,
0.4016672968864441,
-0.14817003905773163,
0.6245862245559692,
-0.07044227421283722,
0.31687989830970764,
0.16080623865127563,
-0.579704761505127,
-0.6801983714103699,
0.2756633162498474,
-0.7668212652206421,
0.13567903637886047,
0.9620344042778015,
0.2958804666996002,
0.3187047243118286,
-0.42841678857803345,
-0.6091544032096863,
0.19726593792438507,
-0.7205430269241333,
0.7329257726669312,
0.6167901158332825,
-0.6670286059379578,
0.2056346982717514,
-0.3799070715904236,
0.6965519189834595,
0.1913382112979889,
-1.1269805431365967,
0.424255907535553,
0.9572917819023132,
-0.37241947650909424,
0.34257277846336365,
0.5692138075828552,
-0.3087088167667389,
-0.05411946773529053,
0.032406389713287354,
-0.007026560138911009,
0.36009931564331055,
-0.3119247555732727,
0.10497166961431503,
0.18342389166355133,
-0.16829092800617218,
-0.15009649097919464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13002v1
|
DuetRAG: Collaborative Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-05-12T09:48:28 | 2024-05-12T09:48:28 |
Dian Jiao, Li Cai, Jingsheng Huang, Wenqiao Zhang, Siliang Tang, Yueting Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) methods augment the input of Large
Language Models (LLMs) with relevant retrieved passages, reducing factual
errors in knowledge-intensive tasks. However, contemporary RAG approaches
suffer from irrelevant knowledge retrieval issues in complex domain questions
(e.g., HotPot QA) due to the lack of corresponding domain knowledge, leading to
low-quality generations. To address this issue, we propose a novel
Collaborative Retrieval-Augmented Generation framework, DuetRAG. Our
bootstrapping philosophy is to simultaneously integrate the domain fintuning
and RAG models to improve the knowledge retrieval quality, thereby enhancing
generation quality. Finally, we demonstrate DuetRAG' s matches with expert
human researchers on HotPot QA.
|
[
-0.6505893468856812,
-0.4946705102920532,
0.2714020013809204,
0.18947263062000275,
-0.06497041136026382,
0.5458046793937683,
-0.10131371766328812,
-0.32986462116241455,
0.35350358486175537,
0.6054565906524658,
-0.3136207163333893,
-0.22982768714427948,
-0.44307759404182434,
-0.04523302614688873,
-0.3884134292602539,
1.0806914567947388,
0.03913737088441849,
-0.043467242270708084,
-0.5485955476760864,
-0.2337612509727478,
-0.5187168717384338,
-0.3862484395503998,
-0.6082238554954529,
-0.3757164180278778,
0.606645405292511,
0.7091959714889526,
0.6405416131019592,
0.10845033079385757,
0.5209329724311829,
0.2680426239967346,
0.07539918273687363,
0.6119545698165894,
-0.6908986568450928,
0.6022897958755493,
-0.19333533942699432,
-0.37590059638023376,
-0.4505009949207306,
0.01822521910071373,
0.3814501464366913,
0.9388478994369507,
-0.1812484860420227,
0.4132660925388336,
0.19000276923179626,
0.8010745644569397,
-0.82078617811203,
-0.13450662791728973,
-0.8815842866897583,
-0.2128855437040329,
-0.25248458981513977,
-0.3766709566116333,
-0.42339596152305603,
-0.3094012439250946,
-0.06785538047552109,
-0.7182251811027527,
0.8000341057777405,
0.6105638146400452,
0.780008852481842,
0.5163037776947021,
-0.2995339632034302,
-0.0413859523832798,
-0.772487998008728,
0.6782684326171875,
-0.321737140417099,
0.3060351610183716,
0.46449413895606995,
0.3661494553089142,
-0.4214212894439697,
-0.9989643096923828,
-0.7886306047439575,
0.15587489306926727,
-0.2153920978307724,
0.05035119876265526,
-0.06985173374414444,
-0.19646376371383667,
-0.009810630232095718,
0.5139716863632202,
-0.6517211198806763,
-0.1824675053358078,
-0.5056942701339722,
-0.05612780898809433,
0.756668210029602,
0.17045514285564423,
0.3609365224838257,
-0.1518588811159134,
-0.6477369070053101,
0.04873255267739296,
-0.9012525677680969,
-0.309846431016922,
0.17572256922721863,
0.3188531696796417,
0.07896366715431213,
0.3023187220096588,
-0.09796709567308426,
0.7907502055168152,
0.4066459834575653,
0.04443174973130226,
0.20169325172901154,
-0.31643709540367126,
-0.082358218729496,
-0.11534019559621811,
0.6570867300033569,
0.2509196698665619,
-0.3343558609485626,
-0.5062881112098694,
-0.1596088707447052,
-0.1885756552219391,
0.3306404650211334,
-0.6086874604225159,
-0.5214225053787231,
0.4193641245365143,
-0.09599999338388443,
-0.6176857948303223,
-0.08148349076509476,
-0.7803906798362732,
-0.5151625275611877,
0.0014579868875443935,
0.7425435781478882,
-0.19475506246089935,
-0.513420820236206,
-0.15255795419216156,
-0.4149513840675354,
0.03735126927495003,
0.11892728507518768,
-0.8073253035545349,
0.5747568607330322,
0.9436576962471008,
0.6284562945365906,
-0.38772642612457275,
-0.4688034653663635,
-0.8892866969108582,
0.4076925218105316,
-0.21293504536151886,
1.2659858465194702,
-0.37043020129203796,
-0.36394214630126953,
-0.24926196038722992,
-0.24141065776348114,
-0.1734056919813156,
-0.823621928691864,
0.2829481065273285,
-1.0951039791107178,
0.629798173904419,
-0.4168643355369568,
-0.6681610941886902,
-0.1293455958366394,
0.17436806857585907,
-0.7308723330497742,
1.0193754434585571,
0.26069316267967224,
-0.9579156637191772,
0.465642511844635,
-0.48118847608566284,
-0.21814985573291779,
0.7579790353775024,
-0.21415971219539642,
-0.5414744019508362,
-0.3942786455154419,
0.087337426841259,
0.4098999798297882,
-0.6180734634399414,
0.4477410614490509,
0.007862499915063381,
-0.34977155923843384,
-0.08919082581996918,
0.14486904442310333,
0.7791383862495422,
0.24197937548160553,
-0.17314137518405914,
0.0515088215470314,
-0.5970745086669922,
0.13610242307186127,
0.19312407076358795,
-0.2802965044975281,
-0.5806147456169128,
-0.327968031167984,
0.08968795090913773,
0.04374651238322258,
0.38382652401924133,
-0.4224439263343811,
0.14402428269386292,
-0.2695991098880768,
-0.12293856590986252,
0.44226109981536865,
0.39093875885009766,
0.7283867001533508,
-0.7491368651390076,
0.7014330625534058,
0.007787575013935566,
-0.16996990144252777,
0.16265197098255157,
-0.5174837708473206,
-0.6705599427223206,
-0.17047114670276642,
0.5820598602294922,
0.24314820766448975,
-1.149216651916504,
0.17782855033874512,
-0.04461047425866127,
-0.4469439387321472,
-0.7769010663032532,
0.45634475350379944,
0.5530264973640442,
0.5850207805633545,
0.4420718848705292,
-0.34537750482559204,
-0.6374177932739258,
-0.5744838118553162,
-0.23992018401622772,
-0.025076167657971382,
-0.008864659816026688,
0.24314704537391663,
0.20625001192092896,
0.03760472685098648,
1.1253677606582642,
-0.4959466755390167,
-0.2391723245382309,
-0.4637106955051422,
0.31048282980918884,
0.09806143492460251,
0.5349770784378052,
0.6065367460250854,
-1.3101271390914917,
-0.7052857875823975,
-0.21704304218292236,
-0.6839503049850464,
-0.1832636445760727,
0.38570332527160645,
-0.46722254157066345,
0.04233601316809654,
0.19576235115528107,
-0.6645607948303223,
-0.22671033442020416,
0.7722260355949402,
-0.34095585346221924,
0.7067692279815674,
-0.05193893611431122,
0.45172417163848877,
-1.6249217987060547,
0.16326656937599182,
-0.30726733803749084,
-0.2825939953327179,
-0.604852557182312,
0.5107779502868652,
-0.17134717106819153,
-0.06413134187459946,
-0.23643474280834198,
0.5593939423561096,
-0.5431929230690002,
-0.332427054643631,
-0.3204324543476105,
0.36584314703941345,
0.24947668612003326,
0.3184072971343994,
-0.3085220158100128,
1.1854761838912964,
0.17335422337055206,
-0.47866806387901306,
0.574386477470398,
0.40083491802215576,
-0.07600636780261993,
0.8136101961135864,
-0.6150031685829163,
0.3022332191467285,
0.002699804026633501,
0.2479938119649887,
-0.8077830076217651,
-0.6004131436347961,
-0.0654052197933197,
-0.6137412786483765,
0.40805599093437195,
-0.3945852518081665,
-0.6034764051437378,
-0.2696326673030853,
-0.22831274569034576,
0.5386323928833008,
0.6242879629135132,
-0.7921146154403687,
0.211819589138031,
0.7527843713760376,
-0.3992258906364441,
-0.6764172911643982,
0.047861021012067795,
0.021344324573874474,
-0.23209497332572937,
-0.7185624837875366,
0.490045428276062,
0.0301621425896883,
-0.4374597370624542,
0.14097203314304352,
0.18367798626422882,
-0.3494207561016083,
-0.02548585832118988,
0.13965854048728943,
0.24553999304771423,
-0.27267125248908997,
0.24752750992774963,
0.2788088321685791,
-0.2658950686454773,
-0.14609751105308533,
-0.311703085899353,
0.7957392930984497,
0.11810626089572906,
-0.053866833448410034,
0.05285577476024628,
0.4234028458595276,
0.3039999306201935,
-0.5359529852867126,
0.8261168003082275,
0.8338077068328857,
-0.22117303311824799,
-0.42505624890327454,
-0.7774882316589355,
-0.20348607003688812,
-0.530120849609375,
-0.1301090270280838,
-0.2869948446750641,
-1.196412444114685,
0.2924785017967224,
-0.35874590277671814,
-0.05287324637174606,
0.4676082134246826,
0.6315211653709412,
-0.432389497756958,
0.5239325165748596,
0.7466117143630981,
0.003519215388223529,
-0.04419437423348427,
-0.3922707140445709,
-0.057998836040496826,
-1.0645138025283813,
-0.2587479054927826,
-0.6264129281044006,
-0.2548259496688843,
-0.4320169985294342,
-0.722428560256958,
0.8057358860969543,
0.24694861471652985,
-0.2274150550365448,
0.38012710213661194,
-0.5703343749046326,
0.4175379276275635,
0.7764787077903748,
0.17234686017036438,
0.5902406573295593,
0.05256658419966698,
-0.1820361167192459,
-0.07870166748762131,
-1.0624823570251465,
-0.24363043904304504,
1.023345947265625,
-0.26371678709983826,
0.35576754808425903,
0.15114831924438477,
0.9804372191429138,
0.456400990486145,
0.22105836868286133,
-0.3042773902416229,
0.5130414962768555,
-0.007746897637844086,
-0.8515959978103638,
-0.2530144155025482,
-0.6368796825408936,
-1.2291935682296753,
0.34618234634399414,
-0.3197782635688782,
-0.43653643131256104,
0.07879649847745895,
0.2607029378414154,
-0.5166706442832947,
0.3929690420627594,
-0.41906535625457764,
0.6553189754486084,
0.24874772131443024,
-0.6741848587989807,
-0.3066043257713318,
-0.6698831915855408,
0.5806736350059509,
-0.21021820604801178,
0.2625996470451355,
-0.002657908946275711,
0.05078091099858284,
0.8460955023765564,
-0.688438892364502,
0.43227440118789673,
-0.23502174019813538,
-0.07257412374019623,
0.4705054461956024,
0.28413310647010803,
0.4283958077430725,
-0.3018898665904999,
-0.08899006992578506,
-0.2697722315788269,
-0.09369832277297974,
-0.6386587023735046,
-0.6166700124740601,
0.9349901080131531,
-0.6256894469261169,
-0.578596293926239,
-0.039738405495882034,
-0.7346143126487732,
-0.6001035571098328,
0.18511660397052765,
0.342646986246109,
0.35106348991394043,
-0.06016955524682999,
0.024131907150149345,
0.5443402528762817,
-0.19179311394691467,
0.1127173900604248,
0.5207436084747314,
-0.17208978533744812,
-0.538355827331543,
1.1356101036071777,
-0.042390916496515274,
0.3042023479938507,
0.23338621854782104,
0.053408920764923096,
-0.06126239150762558,
-0.3679549992084503,
-0.6743044257164001,
0.30108803510665894,
-0.26374396681785583,
-0.47756531834602356,
-0.7520712614059448,
-0.08042938262224197,
-0.5073626041412354,
-0.2333792895078659,
-0.3448190689086914,
-0.6504378914833069,
0.14409953355789185,
0.1363198161125183,
0.7118878364562988,
0.8143900036811829,
-0.22585898637771606,
0.1687149554491043,
-1.0307188034057617,
0.4933192729949951,
0.47036346793174744,
0.07313907891511917,
-0.08912105858325958,
-0.46580249071121216,
-0.25233539938926697,
-0.11113696545362473,
-0.2953045964241028,
-0.7921324968338013,
0.4103144109249115,
-0.025318827480077744,
0.45741555094718933,
-0.2611681818962097,
0.40138769149780273,
0.6700384020805359,
-0.40816548466682434,
0.8654875159263611,
0.050217803567647934,
-0.5527628064155579,
0.46968019008636475,
-0.6319695115089417,
-0.05314479395747185,
0.6104146838188171,
0.529717206954956,
-0.3719398081302643,
-0.4091050922870636,
-0.8671155571937561,
-0.8026623129844666,
0.36432909965515137,
0.39144712686538696,
-0.11165184527635574,
0.30708277225494385,
0.2783263325691223,
0.2693803608417511,
0.45337364077568054,
-0.06294866651296616,
-0.2545562982559204,
0.34938499331474304,
-0.10361959040164948,
0.17413979768753052,
-0.12343468517065048,
-0.20826520025730133,
-0.19826605916023254,
0.7229658961296082,
0.03705393150448799,
0.2107032686471939,
-0.07971684634685516,
0.03324729576706886,
-0.6769900918006897,
0.26215660572052,
0.18131735920906067,
0.43947404623031616,
-0.021816004067659378,
0.14699478447437286,
0.2034366875886917,
-0.3484782576560974,
0.26052969694137573,
0.16543757915496826,
-0.44560399651527405,
0.11951068788766861,
0.17969030141830444,
0.296966552734375,
0.2803821265697479,
-0.3403944671154022,
0.6363954544067383,
0.07594950497150421,
-0.023522812873125076,
-0.2972509562969208,
0.20465971529483795,
0.12963610887527466,
0.43025171756744385,
0.667453944683075,
0.3094579875469208,
0.26663172245025635,
-0.2552211284637451,
0.6881411075592041,
0.45483288168907166,
-0.04961715638637543,
-0.22279690206050873,
0.9211854934692383,
0.3841089606285095,
-0.4143110513687134,
0.3347429037094116,
-0.4023367762565613,
-0.6689191460609436,
0.44204458594322205,
0.46410906314849854,
0.7236549854278564,
-0.28542599081993103,
0.35666579008102417,
0.3441477417945862,
-0.09115201979875565,
-0.11786030977964401,
0.17207013070583344,
-0.38134831190109253,
-0.8130971193313599,
-0.5221732258796692,
-0.7774410247802734,
-0.6586545705795288,
-0.1823645681142807,
-0.8973495960235596,
0.15684442222118378,
-0.04146100953221321,
0.008038284257054329,
-0.2251424938440323,
0.30420005321502686,
-0.5501365661621094,
0.08234895020723343,
-0.3504999876022339,
0.6316294074058533,
-0.4669448137283325,
0.7280727028846741,
0.6379407644271851,
-0.5643347501754761,
-0.9463378190994263,
0.15360595285892487,
-0.15338018536567688,
-0.6952896118164062,
0.737927258014679,
-0.35289135575294495,
-0.2682303190231323,
0.3973577916622162,
-0.8473769426345825,
-0.7725971341133118,
1.2453972101211548,
0.13368286192417145,
-0.27682068943977356,
-0.15202811360359192,
-0.08829769492149353,
0.5464559197425842,
-0.20549902319908142,
-0.23301611840724945,
0.3877197802066803,
0.2257654219865799,
0.38987451791763306,
-1.2282334566116333,
0.007641071453690529,
-0.3558988571166992,
-0.3216797411441803,
0.3907056450843811,
-0.8687355518341064,
0.7907311916351318,
-0.41549307107925415,
-0.07778044790029526,
0.2442832738161087,
0.6214064359664917,
0.6133812069892883,
0.7134889364242554,
0.399277925491333,
0.5929367542266846,
0.7601994872093201,
0.08657962828874588,
0.960444450378418,
-0.33292537927627563,
0.4793657660484314,
1.2960695028305054,
-0.3181757926940918,
1.1305572986602783,
0.4330885708332062,
-0.2194565385580063,
0.6819977760314941,
0.15440277755260468,
0.19154781103134155,
0.4324875473976135,
-0.15149648487567902,
-0.6256072521209717,
-0.4330536425113678,
-0.20055201649665833,
-0.510850191116333,
0.326406866312027,
0.31311947107315063,
-0.21152788400650024,
-0.1977129429578781,
-0.05984700843691826,
0.1454620510339737,
0.2998872697353363,
-0.051591139286756516,
0.9025284647941589,
-0.000016502744983881712,
-0.840002179145813,
0.7520027756690979,
-0.16864867508411407,
0.6749129295349121,
-0.027442991733551025,
-0.16859525442123413,
-0.4365021288394928,
-0.05529201030731201,
-0.2705836594104767,
-0.5293949842453003,
0.12483235448598862,
0.056959982961416245,
-0.1401727795600891,
-0.14996491372585297,
0.9761477112770081,
-0.6246517896652222,
-0.2794238030910492,
0.07981859147548676,
0.9667279124259949,
0.18859615921974182,
-0.005749703850597143,
-0.5580031871795654,
0.02257954142987728,
-0.37321096658706665,
0.05882949382066727,
0.3825482130050659,
0.358390212059021,
0.32691195607185364,
0.5629093050956726,
0.6680566072463989,
0.1493484526872635,
-0.006639985367655754,
-0.020750129595398903,
1.1254627704620361,
-0.4678385853767395,
-0.16917237639427185,
-0.1878361850976944,
0.37538936734199524,
-0.3212728202342987,
-0.043724969029426575,
0.8692015409469604,
0.6136026978492737,
0.8469558358192444,
0.06411086022853851,
0.7422053813934326,
-0.2084289938211441,
1.0909079313278198,
-0.21517887711524963,
1.0982424020767212,
-0.5651179552078247,
0.3352273404598236,
-0.4899672567844391,
-0.8960273861885071,
-0.3349536061286926,
0.3309660851955414,
-0.1495382934808731,
0.021440628916025162,
0.43525761365890503,
0.8686608672142029,
-0.14674882590770721,
-0.12433235347270966,
0.5126285552978516,
0.22509312629699707,
0.02105197124183178,
0.3938460350036621,
0.8880866765975952,
-0.7346115112304688,
0.4776264429092407,
-0.34689271450042725,
-0.17152412235736847,
-0.16311173141002655,
-0.3066180348396301,
-0.6997206807136536,
-0.9721851944923401,
-0.24088004231452942,
-0.42984721064567566,
0.40141963958740234,
1.1159131526947021,
0.6861845850944519,
-0.6070272326469421,
-0.16441605985164642,
0.02134036086499691,
0.17305828630924225,
-0.08696161955595016,
-0.2946430742740631,
0.16664761304855347,
-0.6843465566635132,
-0.6204119324684143,
0.5560285449028015,
0.050597984343767166,
-0.1968715488910675,
-0.5195502042770386,
-0.13544140756130219,
-0.07810939103364944,
-0.24736545979976654,
0.5725382566452026,
0.22397524118423462,
-0.28739848732948303,
0.009729644283652306,
-0.07089865952730179,
-0.13940580189228058,
-0.1319861114025116,
0.9806848764419556,
-1.1547751426696777,
0.2519362270832062,
0.5532479286193848,
0.641136884689331,
0.5380582809448242,
0.3144518733024597,
0.8504980802536011,
-0.9254851937294006,
0.1706179529428482,
0.3253440856933594,
0.163913756608963,
0.5298783183097839,
-0.3169712722301483,
0.5784329175949097,
0.5485805869102478,
-0.9213123321533203,
-0.8588921427726746,
0.17153069376945496,
-0.754564642906189,
-0.050005920231342316,
1.228799819946289,
-0.18988478183746338,
-0.11315347254276276,
-0.419151246547699,
-0.22950901091098785,
0.18019898235797882,
-0.1865272969007492,
0.959018349647522,
0.18080434203147888,
-0.0498543307185173,
-0.2220742106437683,
-0.2891365885734558,
0.7746250033378601,
0.45916748046875,
-0.7989367842674255,
-0.147407665848732,
0.6391230225563049,
0.31893017888069153,
0.26631832122802734,
0.6999132633209229,
0.01899142749607563,
0.5081944465637207,
0.24180841445922852,
0.0452425591647625,
0.00533901946619153,
-0.40680912137031555,
0.2163245528936386,
0.7080442905426025,
0.26502424478530884,
-0.11201011389493942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07195v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07195v1
|
InsightNet: Structured Insight Mining from Customer Feedback
| 2024-05-12T07:40:12 | 2024-05-12T07:40:12 |
Sandeep Sricharan Mukku, Manan Soni, Jitenkumar Rana, Chetan Aggarwal, Promod Yenigalla, Rashmi Patange, Shyam Mohan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We propose InsightNet, a novel approach for the automated extraction of
structured insights from customer reviews. Our end-to-end machine learning
framework is designed to overcome the limitations of current solutions,
including the absence of structure for identified topics, non-standard aspect
names, and lack of abundant training data. The proposed solution builds a
semi-supervised multi-level taxonomy from raw reviews, a semantic similarity
heuristic approach to generate labelled data and employs a multi-task insight
extraction architecture by fine-tuning an LLM. InsightNet identifies granular
actionable topics with customer sentiments and verbatim for each topic.
Evaluations on real-world customer review data show that InsightNet performs
better than existing solutions in terms of structure, hierarchy and
completeness. We empirically demonstrate that InsightNet outperforms the
current state-of-the-art methods in multi-label topic classification, achieving
an F1 score of 0.85, which is an improvement of 11% F1-score over the previous
best results. Additionally, InsightNet generalises well for unseen aspects and
suggests new topics to be added to the taxonomy.
|
[
-0.3911425471305847,
-0.4706505835056305,
0.4119310677051544,
0.23435178399085999,
-0.17169469594955444,
0.07163108885288239,
-0.059933073818683624,
-0.5060007572174072,
0.6878440380096436,
0.6682085394859314,
-0.825862467288971,
-0.8717225193977356,
-0.29856640100479126,
0.0704696848988533,
-0.4395708441734314,
1.2194405794143677,
0.1616005152463913,
0.04114557057619095,
-0.2936500906944275,
-0.029035363346338272,
0.0968952551484108,
-0.48322975635528564,
-0.6763806343078613,
-0.3788013458251953,
0.7431052923202515,
0.6383110880851746,
0.047508109360933304,
0.28892263770103455,
0.5000296831130981,
0.2844802439212799,
-0.34879595041275024,
0.49254441261291504,
-0.3262854516506195,
0.35850420594215393,
-0.009176980704069138,
-0.48512181639671326,
-0.6320869326591492,
0.13590417802333832,
0.2108701914548874,
0.8729929327964783,
-0.16544149816036224,
0.3379211127758026,
0.20809121429920197,
0.8351921439170837,
-0.39982715249061584,
0.2778541147708893,
-0.4957427680492401,
0.4719468653202057,
0.3533053398132324,
-0.3824644684791565,
-0.36570772528648376,
-0.19609162211418152,
0.33366143703460693,
-0.6985639333724976,
0.28455299139022827,
0.06299656629562378,
0.762740969657898,
0.45785844326019287,
-0.18796272575855255,
-0.28374534845352173,
-0.6611302495002747,
0.6543131470680237,
-0.6703498959541321,
-0.054549891501665115,
-0.03545514494180679,
0.2533377408981323,
0.1771843582391739,
-0.8191297650337219,
-0.19778098165988922,
0.05206924304366112,
-0.2701922059059143,
0.6237219572067261,
-0.10824533551931381,
-0.1297701597213745,
0.14109060168266296,
0.42041805386543274,
-0.3064894378185272,
0.05804075300693512,
-0.32513153553009033,
-0.02390245720744133,
0.7736362814903259,
0.4567568600177765,
-0.3360097408294678,
-0.527071475982666,
-0.41819217801094055,
0.08859636634588242,
-0.2521284222602844,
0.4107649326324463,
0.3707136809825897,
0.3487590551376343,
0.3202604651451111,
0.4064488112926483,
-0.6710233688354492,
0.41403061151504517,
0.07087114453315735,
0.0863911435008049,
0.5577303767204285,
-0.10183216631412506,
-0.30428802967071533,
0.4440087080001831,
0.9857771396636963,
0.5623666048049927,
-0.1229766458272934,
-0.2077312469482422,
-0.2507472038269043,
-0.2343602329492569,
0.5341368913650513,
-0.907017171382904,
-0.3025217354297638,
0.4076537787914276,
-0.8905966281890869,
-0.6691752672195435,
0.4271719455718994,
-0.6555543541908264,
-0.6243146061897278,
-0.43053629994392395,
-0.15828685462474823,
-0.06464310735464096,
-0.4814513623714447,
-0.0943618044257164,
-0.4714749753475189,
0.19062946736812592,
0.373528391122818,
-0.3610832393169403,
0.2654564082622528,
1.0592397451400757,
0.7081965804100037,
-0.34151455760002136,
-0.04868028685450554,
-0.18210548162460327,
-0.09214971959590912,
-0.21949446201324463,
1.1240811347961426,
-0.5786002278327942,
-0.13430877029895782,
-0.018446821719408035,
0.23324105143547058,
0.36689305305480957,
-0.8701387047767639,
0.5518704056739807,
-0.5590112805366516,
0.18655136227607727,
0.16783247888088226,
-0.7344451546669006,
-0.4244232475757599,
1.0157063007354736,
-0.6412070393562317,
0.770098865032196,
0.1038677766919136,
-0.7090612053871155,
0.48418906331062317,
-0.7587507963180542,
-0.31594663858413696,
0.23650798201560974,
-0.02988162823021412,
-0.6359741687774658,
0.2784549295902252,
0.14764539897441864,
0.4779949188232422,
-0.11048278212547302,
0.15284687280654907,
-0.49129703640937805,
0.06647387146949768,
0.4258241057395935,
-0.13864101469516754,
0.5009141564369202,
0.45567306876182556,
-0.26615214347839355,
0.5730529427528381,
-0.7682143449783325,
0.2613898515701294,
-0.13651926815509796,
-0.33453860878944397,
-0.35904642939567566,
-0.11030507832765579,
0.1919708251953125,
0.3099113702774048,
0.13221676647663116,
-0.6655129194259644,
0.025031287223100662,
-0.5980541706085205,
0.5847077369689941,
0.7619667053222656,
0.47051167488098145,
0.394621342420578,
-0.01154169999063015,
0.576512336730957,
0.5773044228553772,
0.3493908941745758,
-0.3085583746433258,
-0.41640517115592957,
-0.9769238233566284,
0.03805221989750862,
0.3061707019805908,
0.4106658697128296,
-0.41615065932273865,
0.5787936449050903,
-0.26037272810935974,
-0.5480409860610962,
-0.597895085811615,
0.3383793830871582,
0.3183858096599579,
0.7255547642707825,
0.25261539220809937,
-0.4097434878349304,
-0.5255213975906372,
-1.3167822360992432,
-0.4088715612888336,
-0.08769070357084274,
-0.0874023586511612,
0.503770112991333,
0.15634708106517792,
-0.36985382437705994,
1.0704388618469238,
-0.8389101028442383,
-0.6035714745521545,
-0.2871481776237488,
0.3155841827392578,
0.5888580083847046,
0.18888261914253235,
-0.012140833772718906,
-1.0314314365386963,
-0.48073136806488037,
0.1814349889755249,
-0.8392664194107056,
0.16412724554538727,
0.02416057139635086,
0.025947056710720062,
0.031148923560976982,
0.3727633059024811,
-0.15469740331172943,
0.4059390127658844,
0.02273845300078392,
-0.1017853170633316,
0.265338271856308,
0.12443090975284576,
-0.06738916039466858,
-1.3978170156478882,
-0.14196695387363434,
0.2782708704471588,
-0.27882999181747437,
-0.46195513010025024,
-0.5047111511230469,
-0.09098371118307114,
-0.3493354022502899,
-0.43090948462486267,
0.0457526370882988,
-0.03656306862831116,
-0.10892042517662048,
-0.3856205344200134,
-0.12228568643331528,
0.3525126278400421,
0.7307900786399841,
0.18339912593364716,
0.18719123303890228,
0.23371227085590363,
-0.5597005486488342,
0.8326306939125061,
0.3568360209465027,
-0.3687652051448822,
0.580695390701294,
-0.7438974976539612,
0.2960842251777649,
-0.06273745745420456,
0.21564777195453644,
-0.7711206674575806,
-0.21223758161067963,
0.35637906193733215,
-0.7191193103790283,
0.08344492316246033,
-0.21016983687877655,
-0.12600693106651306,
-0.049262966960668564,
-0.3036699593067169,
-0.10203981399536133,
0.2857365012168884,
-0.4683457612991333,
0.6578713059425354,
0.4696091413497925,
-0.22895538806915283,
-0.4526340961456299,
-0.5457918047904968,
0.36252593994140625,
-0.2653534710407257,
-0.5280113816261292,
0.25237637758255005,
0.20616887509822845,
-0.2280168980360031,
0.4624221920967102,
-0.10750649869441986,
-0.19612343609333038,
0.15890024602413177,
0.43566352128982544,
-0.16327694058418274,
-0.21203072369098663,
0.15178126096725464,
-0.2375791072845459,
-0.3061526417732239,
0.4449390769004822,
-0.8023285269737244,
0.28225642442703247,
-0.38808923959732056,
0.11230715364217758,
-0.4413377046585083,
0.6390967965126038,
0.39059144258499146,
-0.11880656331777573,
0.3822464942932129,
0.5064134001731873,
-0.2169039100408554,
-0.6035121083259583,
-0.27313539385795593,
-0.21472014486789703,
-0.41416725516319275,
0.592265248298645,
-0.2855628728866577,
-0.6921193599700928,
0.4077790081501007,
-0.40559104084968567,
0.11203791946172714,
0.5285559892654419,
0.4779166281223297,
-0.632853627204895,
1.142045259475708,
0.9017634987831116,
-0.05837708339095116,
0.5173269510269165,
-0.5164969563484192,
0.4899045526981354,
-0.8280276656150818,
-0.8438910841941833,
-0.5907610654830933,
-0.6229770183563232,
-0.4679860770702362,
0.24702337384223938,
0.4554080665111542,
-0.13476955890655518,
0.3255956172943115,
0.04579634591937065,
-0.5829581022262573,
0.07682818174362183,
0.515903115272522,
0.3097986578941345,
0.15757590532302856,
0.05260824039578438,
0.14937962591648102,
0.20628264546394348,
-0.48026859760284424,
-0.43326255679130554,
0.8579285144805908,
0.3921069800853729,
0.5646920800209045,
-0.13697437942028046,
0.5522949695587158,
0.5652449131011963,
0.4471072256565094,
-1.2070790529251099,
0.4267415702342987,
-0.07649602741003036,
-0.42399862408638,
-0.12059260159730911,
-0.6892259120941162,
-0.7023749351501465,
-0.02144494652748108,
-0.07798917591571808,
-0.13894207775592804,
0.1636691391468048,
0.08215512335300446,
-0.2582913041114807,
0.06984546035528183,
-0.6919560432434082,
0.7276277542114258,
-0.2501814365386963,
-0.33459752798080444,
-0.013797315768897533,
-0.5727958679199219,
0.2817458510398865,
0.09637309610843658,
0.0895693376660347,
0.02294302172958851,
0.058077458292245865,
0.9896115064620972,
-0.6119822263717651,
0.8093563914299011,
-0.4391379654407501,
-0.033203545957803726,
0.2085046023130417,
-0.3574192225933075,
0.03858065977692604,
0.3081812262535095,
0.05599271133542061,
0.058699801564216614,
-0.20556050539016724,
-0.344097763299942,
-1.0267094373703003,
0.5773607492446899,
-0.7835992574691772,
-0.27647435665130615,
-0.2582111060619354,
-0.3024512827396393,
-0.49123862385749817,
0.15262025594711304,
0.1038903221487999,
0.5690662860870361,
-0.047700054943561554,
0.29674622416496277,
0.6722407937049866,
-0.06160975992679596,
0.41996195912361145,
0.3696199059486389,
-0.10430117696523666,
-0.7146682739257812,
0.9568215608596802,
-0.28527921438217163,
-0.19340617954730988,
0.5127992630004883,
0.3098422884941101,
-0.3088872730731964,
-0.44463542103767395,
-0.25356167554855347,
-0.20381490886211395,
-0.7819743156433105,
-0.3762591779232025,
-0.9108827114105225,
-0.27142348885536194,
-0.6834169626235962,
0.49099257588386536,
-0.44150781631469727,
-0.40186837315559387,
-0.24817144870758057,
-0.2236635982990265,
0.12512414157390594,
0.9760375618934631,
0.22134508192539215,
0.287961483001709,
-0.9997838139533997,
0.15378987789154053,
0.14218862354755402,
0.37849724292755127,
-0.05017050355672836,
-0.15003789961338043,
-0.4539223313331604,
-0.1802397072315216,
-0.30187976360321045,
-0.6227445602416992,
0.475420743227005,
0.1892503947019577,
0.42359229922294617,
0.7524027824401855,
0.16448627412319183,
0.49860909581184387,
-0.11150427907705307,
0.6866145730018616,
0.26620030403137207,
-0.5669869184494019,
0.7229636311531067,
0.018617408350110054,
0.1866777390241623,
0.7924219965934753,
0.48865652084350586,
-0.6103411912918091,
-0.15064282715320587,
-0.6832457780838013,
-0.9706427454948425,
0.7355062961578369,
-0.28112781047821045,
0.01076263003051281,
0.3169695734977722,
0.6358077526092529,
0.22761985659599304,
0.5267436504364014,
-0.4934612214565277,
-0.13591255247592926,
-0.45294317603111267,
-0.46732497215270996,
-0.04951563477516174,
-0.22174440324306488,
-0.03216119483113289,
-0.19925780594348907,
0.626144289970398,
-0.3945391774177551,
0.035889774560928345,
0.42653799057006836,
-0.09885676205158234,
0.10022178292274475,
0.3469099700450897,
0.27976348996162415,
0.6191192865371704,
-0.29703307151794434,
0.15845531225204468,
-0.14216162264347076,
-0.38951653242111206,
-0.1579415649175644,
-0.07361508160829544,
-0.30467459559440613,
0.08062899857759476,
0.46589788794517517,
0.7390335202217102,
-0.10223647952079773,
-0.3975166082382202,
0.4905819892883301,
-0.4579283893108368,
-0.6009848713874817,
-0.7702409625053406,
-0.027761310338974,
-0.15671461820602417,
0.19885779917240143,
0.32723069190979004,
0.44547516107559204,
0.6150252819061279,
-0.6443690061569214,
0.24552667140960693,
0.26801198720932007,
-1.2870534658432007,
-0.35246825218200684,
-0.012833883054554462,
0.39391791820526123,
-0.37813371419906616,
0.6751489639282227,
-0.12300074845552444,
-0.9376016855239868,
0.5702569484710693,
0.07882522791624069,
1.2602227926254272,
0.22568416595458984,
0.3101097345352173,
0.11527030915021896,
0.05337424948811531,
0.5853466391563416,
0.1109917089343071,
-0.4278396666049957,
-0.6192720532417297,
-0.3814582824707031,
-0.7615551948547363,
-0.6684100031852722,
0.12231924384832382,
-0.9654311537742615,
0.1453668475151062,
-0.5179784297943115,
0.1292867213487625,
0.09727946668863297,
0.19622080028057098,
-0.3913683593273163,
0.3560345470905304,
0.15710198879241943,
0.9683619141578674,
-0.7327684164047241,
0.5155761241912842,
0.9584571719169617,
-0.20521408319473267,
-0.8986241221427917,
-0.19754962623119354,
-0.07901763916015625,
-0.28388702869415283,
0.5578538179397583,
0.5945561528205872,
-0.34767091274261475,
-0.39754942059516907,
-0.6046600937843323,
-0.001755269942805171,
0.7882478833198547,
-0.338898241519928,
-0.42598533630371094,
0.18759730458259583,
0.1900373101234436,
0.6078080534934998,
-0.6905761957168579,
0.3995976448059082,
0.5905013680458069,
0.3727823495864868,
0.28066861629486084,
-0.1709538847208023,
-0.21370822191238403,
-0.7828923463821411,
-0.37084028124809265,
0.013128944672644138,
-0.6006225943565369,
0.5049819350242615,
0.2785571813583374,
0.19080761075019836,
-0.4656022787094116,
0.9164383411407471,
-0.20727254450321198,
0.7111110091209412,
0.8729565143585205,
0.7509910464286804,
0.8113368153572083,
0.01740064099431038,
0.7855574488639832,
-0.15978741645812988,
0.2063445895910263,
0.868466854095459,
-0.33395883440971375,
0.6750393509864807,
0.42193108797073364,
0.2802128195762634,
0.542901873588562,
0.9711021780967712,
-0.15319254994392395,
0.7107537388801575,
0.16274963319301605,
0.08235284686088562,
-0.3282362222671509,
-0.37881287932395935,
-0.12053678929805756,
0.5135913491249084,
0.39212921261787415,
-0.31228041648864746,
0.022068245336413383,
-0.11067936569452286,
-0.22094765305519104,
-0.08479782938957214,
-0.5143523216247559,
1.547446370124817,
0.2718256413936615,
-0.7584697008132935,
0.1272999793291092,
-0.121943898499012,
0.6922869682312012,
-0.5056447386741638,
-0.07098913937807083,
-0.3582763671875,
0.6507570743560791,
-0.7563689947128296,
-0.7167717218399048,
0.5430091023445129,
0.11553560942411423,
-0.4978669285774231,
-0.6314411759376526,
0.6503074169158936,
-0.15968219935894012,
-0.6065519452095032,
0.3102712035179138,
0.3335575759410858,
0.1785932034254074,
-0.3420313894748688,
-0.755955159664154,
-0.2783505618572235,
0.12154052406549454,
-0.40880364179611206,
0.015695827081799507,
0.5736477971076965,
0.2156808078289032,
0.3859108090400696,
0.5383028388023376,
0.13455654680728912,
-0.1458510011434555,
0.32309943437576294,
1.0416855812072754,
-0.8949589729309082,
-0.8981955051422119,
-0.6807292103767395,
0.41205331683158875,
-0.8134535551071167,
-0.58946692943573,
0.6555140018463135,
0.8983882069587708,
0.697119414806366,
0.19785253703594208,
0.907476007938385,
0.3375106155872345,
0.8059765696525574,
-0.532721757888794,
0.6233820915222168,
-0.886841356754303,
0.4345233142375946,
-0.08866585791110992,
-1.1105929613113403,
-0.2181451916694641,
0.115567147731781,
-0.1755022406578064,
-0.25947105884552,
0.8838784694671631,
0.5727903842926025,
-0.09185314923524857,
0.548369824886322,
-0.04997621476650238,
0.2976822257041931,
0.6741236448287964,
0.4637688994407654,
1.2630113363265991,
-0.014118388295173645,
0.7886060476303101,
-0.4115423560142517,
-0.28907912969589233,
-0.2592430114746094,
-0.6016973853111267,
-0.8846295475959778,
-0.4648168981075287,
-0.5013694167137146,
-0.36386069655418396,
-0.40796366333961487,
0.7331328392028809,
1.0340700149536133,
-0.9524214863777161,
-0.0851183757185936,
-0.15354932844638824,
0.16928592324256897,
-0.23753675818443298,
-0.3318537473678589,
0.1655535101890564,
-0.707064688205719,
-0.49822279810905457,
0.3776990473270416,
0.5415185689926147,
-0.5485320091247559,
-0.4919847846031189,
0.11969228833913803,
0.2729546129703522,
-0.40594369173049927,
0.39717307686805725,
-0.1801556795835495,
-0.42470523715019226,
0.10761293023824692,
0.2853845953941345,
0.005686355754733086,
0.2554461658000946,
1.0945000648498535,
-0.75523841381073,
0.015179891139268875,
0.48911434412002563,
0.8427824974060059,
0.8767237067222595,
0.09166353195905685,
0.4325352907180786,
-0.8716383576393127,
0.041103262454271317,
0.6322392225265503,
0.23065216839313507,
0.3659786283969879,
-0.4656160771846771,
0.1925954669713974,
0.15085195004940033,
-0.2533150017261505,
-0.5677158832550049,
0.44529783725738525,
-1.0350682735443115,
-0.4835435450077057,
0.8765443563461304,
-0.36317628622055054,
-0.7754994034767151,
-0.24324548244476318,
0.04871298000216484,
-0.2129097431898117,
-0.4465193450450897,
0.647196888923645,
0.3181556463241577,
-0.44309836626052856,
-0.24961818754673004,
-0.13479994237422943,
0.3533810079097748,
0.4675941467285156,
-1.0803067684173584,
-0.12752193212509155,
0.2825556695461273,
0.14387302100658417,
0.5220441818237305,
0.17656219005584717,
0.07604696601629257,
-0.1341709941625595,
-0.25678908824920654,
-0.11759462207555771,
-0.39208194613456726,
-0.5841847062110901,
-0.5143518447875977,
0.7878375053405762,
-0.08960452675819397,
-0.17764198780059814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13001v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13001v1
|
Large Language Models for Education: A Survey
| 2024-05-12T01:50:01 | 2024-05-12T01:50:01 |
Hanyi Xu, Wensheng Gan, Zhenlian Qi, Jiayang Wu, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Artificial intelligence (AI) has a profound impact on traditional education.
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have been increasingly used in
various applications such as natural language processing, computer vision,
speech recognition, and autonomous driving. LLMs have also been applied in many
fields, including recommendation, finance, government, education, legal
affairs, and finance. As powerful auxiliary tools, LLMs incorporate various
technologies such as deep learning, pre-training, fine-tuning, and
reinforcement learning. The use of LLMs for smart education (LLMEdu) has been a
significant strategic direction for countries worldwide. While LLMs have shown
great promise in improving teaching quality, changing education models, and
modifying teacher roles, the technologies are still facing several challenges.
In this paper, we conduct a systematic review of LLMEdu, focusing on current
technologies, challenges, and future developments. We first summarize the
current state of LLMEdu and then introduce the characteristics of LLMs and
education, as well as the benefits of integrating LLMs into education. We also
review the process of integrating LLMs into the education industry, as well as
the introduction of related technologies. Finally, we discuss the challenges
and problems faced by LLMEdu, as well as prospects for future optimization of
LLMEdu.
|
[
-0.299102783203125,
-0.9504797458648682,
0.6166927218437195,
-0.16073156893253326,
-0.03456926345825195,
0.5372976064682007,
-0.5495085120201111,
-0.5242787003517151,
0.025067085400223732,
0.5146908164024353,
-0.4024760127067566,
-0.24583859741687775,
-0.7240713238716125,
0.22751224040985107,
-0.48188555240631104,
0.5733851194381714,
-0.0449218675494194,
0.3851250410079956,
-0.24627235531806946,
0.08123009651899338,
-0.5167050361633301,
-0.6857678294181824,
-0.6345581412315369,
-0.7056515216827393,
0.489172101020813,
0.5806248784065247,
0.6351913213729858,
0.4240449070930481,
0.7208634614944458,
0.46938785910606384,
-0.041569359600543976,
0.1214446872472763,
-0.1306585818529129,
-0.11903505027294159,
-0.2460755854845047,
-0.4646286368370056,
-0.5415824055671692,
0.12772610783576965,
0.9051183462142944,
1.0065815448760986,
-0.0396074578166008,
0.13006894290447235,
0.09314419329166412,
0.6072707772254944,
-0.2973857820034027,
0.1777162402868271,
-0.28926530480384827,
0.14065411686897278,
-0.1435479074716568,
0.06948621571063995,
-0.200617715716362,
-0.5165723562240601,
0.3314165472984314,
-0.23273548483848572,
-0.38074344396591187,
-0.06631451100111008,
0.485552579164505,
0.44093120098114014,
-0.5750375390052795,
-0.4394899904727936,
-1.0252771377563477,
1.174021601676941,
-0.7047340273857117,
0.5760500431060791,
0.23386265337467194,
0.3092842698097229,
-0.44463589787483215,
-0.7054393887519836,
-0.6195980906486511,
-0.1679137647151947,
0.2609831988811493,
0.07614659518003464,
0.20571017265319824,
0.23170290887355804,
0.05190109834074974,
0.2120985984802246,
-0.31277433037757874,
0.7928705215454102,
-0.5277057886123657,
-0.039091143757104874,
0.7688038945198059,
0.3854316771030426,
0.2797919511795044,
0.21088829636573792,
-0.1776747703552246,
-0.008039453066885471,
-0.6552339196205139,
-0.04098978638648987,
0.44394686818122864,
0.2478581964969635,
0.12023629993200302,
0.6585617661476135,
-0.01664981245994568,
0.8250659108161926,
-0.4980442225933075,
-0.6851835250854492,
0.16946245729923248,
-0.18698973953723907,
-0.12962448596954346,
0.010754787363111973,
0.762301504611969,
0.059935517609119415,
0.4775679409503937,
0.1559068262577057,
-0.3190912902355194,
0.10858961939811707,
-0.0017057046061381698,
-0.735854983329773,
0.15443016588687897,
0.35519394278526306,
-0.20270445942878723,
-0.04749445244669914,
-0.1817510575056076,
-0.4611521363258362,
-0.42881667613983154,
-0.657373309135437,
0.11670923233032227,
-0.29782038927078247,
-0.18777480721473694,
0.24735940992832184,
0.29159048199653625,
0.4044038653373718,
0.5476486086845398,
-0.9655091762542725,
0.21414358913898468,
0.9649643301963806,
0.5350852608680725,
-0.19471397995948792,
-0.27248460054397583,
0.05186661705374718,
-0.09782595932483673,
-0.3007381856441498,
0.7766909003257751,
-0.7217626571655273,
-0.5940563678741455,
0.25540030002593994,
-0.18105585873126984,
-0.08382253348827362,
-0.6631320714950562,
0.35618817806243896,
-0.2540585994720459,
0.3540317118167877,
0.023586589843034744,
-0.7222482562065125,
-0.31277236342430115,
0.5253056287765503,
-0.5657697319984436,
0.6918808221817017,
-0.028653303161263466,
-0.3260006010532379,
0.015060704201459885,
-0.7611358165740967,
-0.6172304749488831,
0.30013275146484375,
-0.4688815772533417,
-0.5566504001617432,
-0.023916056379675865,
0.05985325574874878,
0.49541500210762024,
-0.5123148560523987,
0.7986449003219604,
-0.05261792615056038,
-0.6498641967773438,
0.26887965202331543,
-0.5010430812835693,
0.7758630514144897,
0.18441221117973328,
-0.210170179605484,
0.30480635166168213,
-0.6184257864952087,
-0.046464014798402786,
0.18268059194087982,
-0.5408844947814941,
-0.10991417616605759,
0.3290259838104248,
0.024525579065084457,
0.22485584020614624,
0.47062939405441284,
-0.402202308177948,
0.4855286478996277,
-0.2442454695701599,
0.7545480132102966,
0.9246654510498047,
-0.27084171772003174,
0.40643882751464844,
-0.31231173872947693,
0.49415239691734314,
-0.23129592835903168,
0.39158692955970764,
-0.07387223094701767,
-0.5255306363105774,
-0.6111308932304382,
-0.2497837245464325,
0.43948206305503845,
0.6874498724937439,
-0.7082080245018005,
0.428250789642334,
-0.16903705894947052,
-0.4290391504764557,
-0.636377215385437,
0.236800417304039,
0.022843606770038605,
0.2048061341047287,
0.11648456007242203,
-0.01176717970520258,
-0.36659228801727295,
-0.7078608870506287,
-0.177164688706398,
-0.15742044150829315,
0.19036273658275604,
0.36093392968177795,
0.6576201319694519,
-0.6329586505889893,
0.8549681901931763,
-0.13496433198451996,
-0.29050278663635254,
-0.4668976366519928,
-0.4086005985736847,
0.2203226536512375,
0.4134677052497864,
0.2485555112361908,
-0.8974153399467468,
-0.23993565142154694,
-0.04989634454250336,
-0.7331445217132568,
0.24043375253677368,
-0.07403778284788132,
0.335580438375473,
0.23665356636047363,
0.5059775710105896,
-0.7250478267669678,
0.061122484505176544,
0.46739745140075684,
-0.04824526235461235,
0.4813079237937927,
-0.04060510918498039,
0.07556349784135818,
-0.8889660835266113,
-0.06589309126138687,
0.024965522810816765,
0.025105496868491173,
-0.49469101428985596,
0.04546528682112694,
-0.06215492635965347,
-0.28916704654693604,
-0.5480124354362488,
0.792864203453064,
-0.2841445207595825,
-0.10641182959079742,
-0.39103221893310547,
0.5465261340141296,
-0.3521159291267395,
0.1043456569314003,
-0.07430663704872131,
0.7513731122016907,
0.493867427110672,
-0.3901022970676422,
0.786657452583313,
0.15590758621692657,
-0.5513165593147278,
0.45492610335350037,
-0.634505569934845,
0.06591299176216125,
-0.0005432433099485934,
0.4900319576263428,
-0.44165512919425964,
-0.40099769830703735,
0.15750055015087128,
-0.14500465989112854,
0.4127512276172638,
0.3596786558628082,
-0.7433671355247498,
-0.6511998772621155,
-0.36933332681655884,
0.31407055258750916,
0.6162303686141968,
-0.5075769424438477,
0.7341688871383667,
0.4721050262451172,
-0.2858336865901947,
-0.5818460583686829,
-0.6096497774124146,
0.4467374384403229,
-0.014908966608345509,
-0.3458651006221771,
-0.013505140319466591,
-0.21759526431560516,
-0.543809711933136,
0.023360226303339005,
0.0696440041065216,
0.08335357904434204,
0.3840520679950714,
0.001485629240050912,
0.5111956596374512,
-0.17159445583820343,
0.1675642728805542,
0.002082536229863763,
-0.07979580014944077,
0.1936509907245636,
-0.3491702973842621,
0.46547508239746094,
-0.10963918268680573,
-0.3771379888057709,
-0.5257812738418579,
0.2485322803258896,
0.7811778783798218,
-0.3906501233577728,
0.6983792781829834,
0.46544936299324036,
-0.37209203839302063,
-0.3120570182800293,
-0.6466889977455139,
-0.42640191316604614,
-0.4931337237358093,
0.696577787399292,
0.015926312655210495,
-1.0710655450820923,
0.17642377316951752,
-0.5007160902023315,
0.35719314217567444,
0.1545499861240387,
0.6028544902801514,
-0.12512922286987305,
1.073735237121582,
0.759898841381073,
-0.44963833689689636,
0.6728457808494568,
-0.42473554611206055,
0.6045393347740173,
-0.6523634195327759,
-0.5905637145042419,
-0.3569422960281372,
-0.3712342083454132,
-0.6956804990768433,
-0.10855234414339066,
0.1957072913646698,
-0.2576034665107727,
-0.2362229973077774,
-0.25115469098091125,
-0.22982634603977203,
0.30185508728027344,
0.6503189206123352,
-0.21759001910686493,
0.41642290353775024,
-0.18729908764362335,
0.22217537462711334,
0.33542534708976746,
-0.7947429418563843,
-0.8353713750839233,
1.0986464023590088,
0.48738059401512146,
0.896457850933075,
-0.06760608404874802,
0.7455606460571289,
0.028508292511105537,
0.42893919348716736,
-1.1759227514266968,
0.9300979375839233,
-0.3500429093837738,
-0.586799681186676,
-0.30275705456733704,
-0.39339497685432434,
-0.8775020837783813,
0.10380434989929199,
-0.39828726649284363,
-0.5562684535980225,
-0.3071274161338806,
-0.10948056727647781,
-0.21508656442165375,
0.61307692527771,
-0.6798080801963806,
0.362064927816391,
-0.67217618227005,
-0.27595388889312744,
-0.24176648259162903,
-0.4880730211734772,
0.4043886959552765,
-0.47888368368148804,
0.5419231057167053,
-0.10792723298072815,
-0.07417628169059753,
0.9605509042739868,
-0.11582861095666885,
0.8318271040916443,
0.13041430711746216,
-0.2597500681877136,
0.5139093399047852,
-0.5881804823875427,
0.31746184825897217,
-0.312565416097641,
-0.13068728148937225,
0.2273380309343338,
-0.22643178701400757,
-0.3896125257015228,
-0.38401228189468384,
0.953227698802948,
-0.9703530073165894,
-0.8844461441040039,
-0.6778176426887512,
-0.7145309448242188,
-0.3012274205684662,
0.21278534829616547,
-0.05969320610165596,
0.19440843164920807,
0.034916430711746216,
0.16958686709403992,
0.6989703178405762,
-0.4183266758918762,
0.5621497631072998,
0.37187570333480835,
-0.31758564710617065,
-0.20850889384746552,
1.2115525007247925,
0.49918368458747864,
-0.0011015175841748714,
-0.0006485759513452649,
0.2751196324825287,
-0.2280830591917038,
-0.7805616855621338,
-0.2514878809452057,
0.39340516924858093,
-0.5546485185623169,
-0.00866076909005642,
-0.3688184916973114,
-0.5234975218772888,
-0.4915591776371002,
-0.270244300365448,
-0.3937950134277344,
-0.10932984203100204,
-0.4807482361793518,
-0.12337449193000793,
0.04766666144132614,
1.2615318298339844,
0.29946208000183105,
0.2798548936843872,
-0.7118683457374573,
0.23648643493652344,
0.45892563462257385,
0.45753148198127747,
-0.09259451925754547,
-0.24108466506004333,
-0.18027502298355103,
-0.03363986685872078,
-0.2610760033130646,
-0.30390405654907227,
0.16216258704662323,
0.2044207602739334,
0.625797688961029,
0.3131130635738373,
-0.05558864027261734,
0.24651919305324554,
-0.6468758583068848,
0.8418602347373962,
0.1652701050043106,
-0.5454533696174622,
0.45703399181365967,
-0.12098022550344467,
0.27318522334098816,
0.19620957970619202,
0.5611477494239807,
-0.4487466812133789,
-0.2836054861545563,
-0.33655786514282227,
-1.0706161260604858,
0.4735964834690094,
-0.3672489523887634,
0.4147107005119324,
0.2162027508020401,
0.21958965063095093,
0.026627663522958755,
0.2804808020591736,
-0.5554871559143066,
-0.38717424869537354,
0.16438685357570648,
-0.39312422275543213,
-0.16329999268054962,
-0.27242958545684814,
0.1003103256225586,
-0.2139173299074173,
0.8252208828926086,
0.19861739873886108,
-0.15740109980106354,
-0.2345452904701233,
0.03412601724267006,
-0.06636488437652588,
0.6412827968597412,
0.4654025733470917,
0.7254379987716675,
0.016312042251229286,
-0.29728835821151733,
0.19900330901145935,
-0.6648545861244202,
0.14708100259304047,
0.06844673305749893,
-0.20400522649288177,
-0.2508145570755005,
0.4706721007823944,
0.44427111744880676,
0.10977865755558014,
-1.0168851613998413,
0.29305270314216614,
0.016630353406071663,
-0.35964199900627136,
-0.5167902112007141,
0.28289735317230225,
0.10076877474784851,
0.520216166973114,
0.4866420328617096,
-0.20045094192028046,
-0.060174062848091125,
-0.7484285831451416,
-0.24148809909820557,
0.5218263268470764,
-0.27564898133277893,
-0.004326443653553724,
0.38853299617767334,
0.4895164370536804,
-0.6213652491569519,
0.8023231625556946,
0.23360390961170197,
-0.486045241355896,
0.5528704524040222,
0.5484715700149536,
0.6084938645362854,
-0.39419203996658325,
-0.040439192205667496,
-0.018172871321439743,
0.4802777171134949,
-0.32511305809020996,
0.45069387555122375,
0.24601508677005768,
-0.5652922987937927,
-0.48187851905822754,
-0.5074930191040039,
-0.9202813506126404,
0.2970231771469116,
-0.18389049172401428,
0.2661832571029663,
-0.7337151169776917,
-0.388111412525177,
-0.23118160665035248,
0.19564072787761688,
-0.6739867925643921,
0.402059406042099,
0.397048681974411,
0.7485396862030029,
-0.6835979223251343,
1.0200648307800293,
1.025236964225769,
-0.0404125340282917,
-0.7532827258110046,
-0.373527854681015,
0.042119018733501434,
-0.5395111441612244,
0.49039456248283386,
0.15546905994415283,
-0.22974103689193726,
0.14122292399406433,
-0.6521697640419006,
-0.6409286260604858,
0.9235914349555969,
0.3141482174396515,
-1.121313452720642,
-0.19267095625400543,
0.23633147776126862,
0.46084919571876526,
-0.1486164778470993,
0.10638415813446045,
0.6207677125930786,
0.5830738544464111,
-0.14278830587863922,
-0.7764208316802979,
-0.4598299562931061,
-0.09883608669042587,
-0.11091975122690201,
0.1482110321521759,
-0.7054654955863953,
0.6758858561515808,
-0.36225205659866333,
-0.0386635847389698,
0.10009706765413284,
0.6675550937652588,
0.28534600138664246,
0.432022362947464,
0.0689115822315216,
0.38132810592651367,
0.6550340056419373,
-0.28068333864212036,
0.8786415457725525,
-0.3240931034088135,
0.3642321825027466,
0.8503935933113098,
-0.37685495615005493,
0.8567818403244019,
0.5094634294509888,
-0.4010283052921295,
0.4301324188709259,
0.6606517434120178,
-0.24585752189159393,
-0.012456259690225124,
0.3453100025653839,
-0.33714261651039124,
-0.12748029828071594,
-0.40742629766464233,
-0.3955548107624054,
0.5684499740600586,
0.6308465003967285,
-0.1069147139787674,
0.08141391724348068,
0.45103907585144043,
-0.00031099285115487874,
0.29655200242996216,
-0.732700765132904,
0.4732985198497772,
0.2807176411151886,
-0.46989843249320984,
0.07255103439092636,
0.18017277121543884,
0.9740753769874573,
-0.6118147969245911,
-0.11428184062242508,
-0.2176361083984375,
0.15764030814170837,
-0.2901607155799866,
-0.7820260524749756,
-0.08784287422895432,
0.025043925270438194,
0.22799524664878845,
-0.19764357805252075,
0.6483144760131836,
-0.48813295364379883,
-0.7284435033798218,
0.276054710149765,
0.5263201594352722,
0.05554897338151932,
0.41085538268089294,
-0.6197946667671204,
0.3049827814102173,
-0.33691176772117615,
-0.2943059802055359,
0.3866250514984131,
0.22210417687892914,
-0.08196131139993668,
1.1089400053024292,
0.5178713202476501,
0.13106635212898254,
0.034622736275196075,
0.22730763256549835,
0.6992505192756653,
-0.6936342716217041,
-0.24552087485790253,
-0.7180007696151733,
0.234500914812088,
0.15660756826400757,
-0.3020831048488617,
0.7835708260536194,
0.3265598714351654,
1.0189683437347412,
0.10662975162267685,
0.9061970114707947,
0.31361469626426697,
0.23859845101833344,
-0.34925660490989685,
0.7181268334388733,
-0.5106369256973267,
0.25713440775871277,
-0.11886169016361237,
-1.1942025423049927,
-0.3697887361049652,
0.5040100812911987,
-0.4992330074310303,
0.31700804829597473,
0.5289697051048279,
0.2787828743457794,
0.24032504856586456,
0.0500577911734581,
0.5012127757072449,
0.10911370813846588,
0.24972444772720337,
0.4531554579734802,
0.9693859219551086,
-0.22168757021427155,
0.14678537845611572,
-0.1810961365699768,
0.002268051728606224,
-0.3999097943305969,
-0.5445132851600647,
-0.9936102032661438,
-0.4137117564678192,
-0.5070415139198303,
0.09308745712041855,
0.11791861057281494,
1.1493979692459106,
0.4210447371006012,
-0.7189435362815857,
-0.40216758847236633,
0.28961119055747986,
0.46929994225502014,
0.255738228559494,
-0.1670682281255722,
0.22595080733299255,
-0.041435357183218,
-1.082807183265686,
0.47762781381607056,
0.2777664363384247,
0.19486607611179352,
-0.5896860361099243,
0.03537967428565025,
-0.3354542851448059,
0.2299996167421341,
0.79115229845047,
0.37487339973449707,
-0.7865066528320312,
-0.3017697334289551,
-0.1535482108592987,
-0.20151162147521973,
-0.21105682849884033,
0.6989527940750122,
-0.734352707862854,
0.24709013104438782,
0.15462537109851837,
0.9038803577423096,
0.04008587822318077,
-0.502801239490509,
0.157772496342659,
-0.10780930519104004,
0.00811698753386736,
0.49451369047164917,
0.41118088364601135,
0.4647789001464844,
-0.09835474193096161,
0.33875834941864014,
0.07007011771202087,
-0.630496084690094,
-0.8318130373954773,
0.19719663262367249,
-0.762639045715332,
-0.4309327006340027,
1.0059535503387451,
0.08062271773815155,
-0.2751982510089874,
-0.20017442107200623,
-0.07481376081705093,
0.18315257132053375,
-0.17560745775699615,
0.6492372751235962,
0.6158536672592163,
-0.016058940440416336,
-0.1479363739490509,
-0.7221207022666931,
-0.05351858213543892,
0.3454849421977997,
-0.8783087730407715,
-0.43326467275619507,
0.3570961058139801,
0.1664210557937622,
0.009381675161421299,
0.219892218708992,
-0.15925747156143188,
0.005730676464736462,
-0.2760900855064392,
0.0327034555375576,
-0.2386593073606491,
-0.6384192109107971,
-0.5502472519874573,
0.08199355006217957,
0.3144466280937195,
0.0076823849231004715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07111v1
|
Designing and Evaluating Dialogue LLMs for Co-Creative Improvised Theatre
| 2024-05-11T23:19:42 | 2024-05-11T23:19:42 |
Boyd Branch, Piotr Mirowski, Kory Mathewson, Sophia Ppali, Alexandra Covaci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social robotics researchers are increasingly interested in multi-party
trained conversational agents. With a growing demand for real-world
evaluations, our study presents Large Language Models (LLMs) deployed in a
month-long live show at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe. This case study
investigates human improvisers co-creating with conversational agents in a
professional theatre setting. We explore the technical capabilities and
constraints of on-the-spot multi-party dialogue, providing comprehensive
insights from both audience and performer experiences with AI on stage. Our
human-in-the-loop methodology underlines the challenges of these LLMs in
generating context-relevant responses, stressing the user interface's crucial
role. Audience feedback indicates an evolving interest for AI-driven live
entertainment, direct human-AI interaction, and a diverse range of expectations
about AI's conversational competence and utility as a creativity support tool.
Human performers express immense enthusiasm, varied satisfaction, and the
evolving public opinion highlights mixed emotions about AI's role in arts.
|
[
-0.4352714419364929,
-0.556145191192627,
0.33707717061042786,
0.13312120735645294,
0.09422042965888977,
0.73277747631073,
-0.2736987769603729,
-0.4046209752559662,
0.522552490234375,
0.4819096624851227,
-0.6984179019927979,
-0.1165216937661171,
0.043659940361976624,
0.033283986151218414,
-0.4751095473766327,
0.5814950466156006,
0.23687048256397247,
0.07731615006923676,
-0.48747655749320984,
-0.266396701335907,
-0.21473081409931183,
-0.5356194376945496,
-0.7546783089637756,
-0.2918408215045929,
0.6869344711303711,
0.7443808317184448,
0.7793646454811096,
-0.20257237553596497,
0.35393866896629333,
0.39312416315078735,
0.18943768739700317,
0.48851141333580017,
-0.36908823251724243,
0.26368266344070435,
0.03156004846096039,
-0.19293996691703796,
-0.31135421991348267,
0.305453896522522,
0.4142186641693115,
0.650863528251648,
-0.3741612136363983,
-0.06776072829961777,
-0.0685674324631691,
0.25475752353668213,
-0.034660179167985916,
0.04669109359383583,
-0.441318541765213,
0.37868836522102356,
0.1315060257911682,
-0.19852517545223236,
-0.4100635349750519,
-0.32694077491760254,
0.0774008110165596,
-0.6827953457832336,
-0.2695058286190033,
0.14081838726997375,
0.6823468208312988,
0.29533183574676514,
-0.16519054770469666,
-0.3671932518482208,
-1.1829382181167603,
0.4151664972305298,
-0.5564250349998474,
0.0003820529964286834,
0.01644710823893547,
0.559585452079773,
-0.45190101861953735,
-0.9395225048065186,
-1.021541953086853,
-0.5135183930397034,
0.3850075900554657,
0.21248987317085266,
-0.0035855211317539215,
0.17974650859832764,
0.0939953550696373,
0.25519588589668274,
-0.33072295784950256,
0.15153081715106964,
-0.2998640537261963,
-0.09625903517007828,
0.845151424407959,
0.28731444478034973,
0.5088083744049072,
0.08518575131893158,
-0.1801711469888687,
-0.04921180009841919,
-0.5407376289367676,
0.04663929343223572,
0.6454272270202637,
-0.09244728833436966,
-0.271185040473938,
0.4862781763076782,
-0.10986092686653137,
0.4124566316604614,
0.014936799183487892,
0.14730149507522583,
-0.3504411578178406,
-0.32628244161605835,
0.14344045519828796,
-0.44626936316490173,
0.9655357599258423,
0.4404047429561615,
0.5483937859535217,
-0.24462319910526276,
-0.06256438791751862,
0.06158476322889328,
0.24297988414764404,
-0.4459739327430725,
-0.39440661668777466,
0.1204107254743576,
0.0727877989411354,
-0.3014744818210602,
0.0013158901128917933,
-0.41762349009513855,
-0.8563501834869385,
-0.3413160741329193,
0.5328328609466553,
-0.023208798840641975,
-0.13283684849739075,
-0.13612617552280426,
-0.36181941628456116,
0.02024785988032818,
0.34778571128845215,
-0.2577057182788849,
0.28274357318878174,
0.5410667061805725,
0.36627787351608276,
0.11348466575145721,
-0.3203529715538025,
-0.5275211334228516,
0.051039766520261765,
-0.48822930455207825,
0.6889500021934509,
-0.29852965474128723,
-0.3019658625125885,
-0.06596202403306961,
-0.08876318484544754,
0.06204087287187576,
-0.599000096321106,
0.33196204900741577,
-0.364082396030426,
0.4232752025127411,
0.20002377033233643,
-0.3692210614681244,
0.10172621160745621,
0.06358513981103897,
-0.5165928602218628,
0.4537084698677063,
0.12867309153079987,
-0.36728811264038086,
0.18543583154678345,
-0.7964931726455688,
-0.37726640701293945,
0.625839114189148,
-0.6579472422599792,
-0.02091466635465622,
-0.010355374775826931,
-0.01953478343784809,
0.251831591129303,
-0.03203859180212021,
0.4432964622974396,
-0.39367151260375977,
-0.7159857749938965,
1.0418490171432495,
-0.6495282053947449,
0.042041245847940445,
0.07355562597513199,
-0.12315237522125244,
0.4887966811656952,
-0.8044260740280151,
-0.24140509963035583,
0.054538484662771225,
-0.23528680205345154,
0.3573935031890869,
0.4893125593662262,
0.07718353718519211,
0.4137794077396393,
-0.10920438170433044,
-0.6464350819587708,
-0.09675516188144684,
-0.5809275507926941,
0.8272364139556885,
0.6681617498397827,
-0.03939880058169365,
0.4126183092594147,
-0.6465860605239868,
0.7911406755447388,
-0.3506855368614197,
0.0880901962518692,
-0.1047530546784401,
-0.6144115924835205,
-0.7602049708366394,
-0.2907974123954773,
-0.2624983787536621,
0.3611677587032318,
-0.973861038684845,
0.16142034530639648,
0.02903112582862377,
-0.35101741552352905,
-0.6380176544189453,
-0.07666003704071045,
-0.021128542721271515,
0.06958894431591034,
-0.23096217215061188,
-0.262989342212677,
-0.49083468317985535,
-0.9272834062576294,
-0.23230433464050293,
-0.2617998719215393,
-0.1529480516910553,
0.5624557137489319,
0.0983324646949768,
-0.19957950711250305,
1.1358429193496704,
0.014625459909439087,
-0.05696341022849083,
-0.5712842345237732,
0.13737650215625763,
0.28337082266807556,
0.17545881867408752,
0.05805385112762451,
-0.5199161767959595,
-0.427329421043396,
-0.06983266770839691,
-0.5441724061965942,
-0.12929119169712067,
-0.22986796498298645,
0.25618189573287964,
0.4527237117290497,
0.1649138480424881,
-0.6743150949478149,
0.5123034715652466,
0.7253018021583557,
-0.2540372312068939,
0.4681605100631714,
-0.12585367262363434,
0.2996547520160675,
-0.8917227983474731,
-0.04041149467229843,
-0.28161975741386414,
-0.23686698079109192,
-0.6719107627868652,
-0.027136994525790215,
-0.6635205149650574,
-0.7604978084564209,
-0.7002519369125366,
0.6092546582221985,
-0.34335342049598694,
-0.25529494881629944,
-0.2928194999694824,
0.5949028134346008,
0.22931426763534546,
0.6969041228294373,
0.032757386565208435,
0.7824306488037109,
0.2334616780281067,
-0.39841896295547485,
0.5798982381820679,
0.31461772322654724,
-0.7811270952224731,
0.3717106580734253,
-0.5258669853210449,
0.730139434337616,
0.2454121857881546,
0.4898931086063385,
-1.3474661111831665,
-0.6214677095413208,
0.47993242740631104,
-0.2617453932762146,
-0.04834476113319397,
0.11356137692928314,
-0.5961587429046631,
-0.5460379123687744,
-0.012081966735422611,
0.2505965530872345,
0.33779624104499817,
-0.30356401205062866,
0.7152343988418579,
0.6726171970367432,
-0.42838403582572937,
-0.19094188511371613,
-0.3532954156398773,
0.5986575484275818,
-0.3250698149204254,
-1.1631860733032227,
0.10231635719537735,
-0.34380388259887695,
-0.6509972214698792,
-0.47907742857933044,
0.16207532584667206,
-0.03451504185795784,
0.173312246799469,
0.38569581508636475,
-0.14610658586025238,
0.18690773844718933,
-0.11617374420166016,
-0.13650833070278168,
0.09198610484600067,
-0.0898003801703453,
0.15834788978099823,
0.6627565622329712,
0.03574072942137718,
-0.6652911901473999,
-1.1095120906829834,
0.4516648054122925,
0.7357000112533569,
0.26099884510040283,
0.3977418541908264,
0.5813145041465759,
-0.09118117392063141,
-0.15016424655914307,
-0.6077011823654175,
-0.06176602467894554,
-0.514519214630127,
0.19734622538089752,
0.01852712407708168,
-0.9555703401565552,
0.7615485191345215,
-0.00177446857560426,
-0.0029466524720191956,
-0.10820583999156952,
0.5093995332717896,
-0.5016071796417236,
0.7824214100837708,
0.07179224491119385,
0.4220386743545532,
0.6333962678909302,
-0.077320396900177,
0.2622402310371399,
-0.7091271877288818,
-0.15715870261192322,
-0.32226067781448364,
-0.6977140307426453,
-0.32428687810897827,
-0.6872230172157288,
0.5884138345718384,
-0.4245939254760742,
-0.07781194895505905,
0.09304627776145935,
-0.1607075035572052,
0.41544976830482483,
0.3601354956626892,
0.2318347543478012,
0.029191946610808372,
-0.45534026622772217,
0.15050338208675385,
0.24175509810447693,
-0.7997633814811707,
-0.62056964635849,
0.7044578790664673,
0.4202464520931244,
0.8644123673439026,
0.15984360873699188,
0.42713600397109985,
0.4773453176021576,
0.14694525301456451,
-0.6631896495819092,
0.8747156858444214,
0.2546636462211609,
-0.6188520193099976,
-0.6798328161239624,
-0.1202830970287323,
-0.6248226761817932,
0.0943928137421608,
-0.09266545623540878,
-0.7439441084861755,
0.12729497253894806,
0.011072221212089062,
-0.5162115097045898,
0.12888602912425995,
-0.6159350872039795,
0.6439800262451172,
-0.08686811476945877,
-0.5431441068649292,
-0.5533638596534729,
-0.6317346096038818,
0.06709529459476471,
0.07307400554418564,
0.6088767647743225,
-0.27817171812057495,
0.3853342533111572,
0.7004086375236511,
-0.24700221419334412,
1.0890374183654785,
-0.028523733839392662,
-0.09851500391960144,
0.7185243368148804,
0.20653767883777618,
0.5281662344932556,
0.22127874195575714,
-0.24087221920490265,
0.11912891268730164,
-0.050440218299627304,
-0.0649028941988945,
-0.4303185045719147,
0.4344938099384308,
-0.894713282585144,
-0.7782655358314514,
-0.02829291857779026,
-0.7407222986221313,
-0.18742936849594116,
-0.3637157082557678,
-0.22124619781970978,
0.7032177448272705,
-0.5401061773300171,
0.4042694866657257,
0.1301722228527069,
-0.8053309321403503,
0.725357711315155,
0.44772103428840637,
-0.31562039256095886,
-0.5826869606971741,
0.6187785863876343,
0.03993210941553116,
0.5220839977264404,
0.135825052857399,
0.21021768450737,
-0.19037292897701263,
-0.21783575415611267,
-0.6261179447174072,
-0.022789759561419487,
-0.6680250763893127,
0.3092387616634369,
-0.6129595041275024,
-0.09805037081241608,
-0.2531244456768036,
-0.14670735597610474,
-0.07709641754627228,
-0.7245913743972778,
-0.3394174575805664,
-0.03578711301088333,
-0.06304313242435455,
0.8739670515060425,
-0.2754022479057312,
0.4798300564289093,
-0.536100447177887,
-0.0003660884394776076,
0.4091689884662628,
0.24152958393096924,
-0.056706395000219345,
-0.509976327419281,
-0.38718435168266296,
-0.12702590227127075,
-0.4924592971801758,
-0.7324383854866028,
0.49880480766296387,
0.44087472558021545,
0.553601861000061,
0.34266018867492676,
0.09736266732215881,
0.40339186787605286,
-0.44983434677124023,
1.1239694356918335,
0.018590234220027924,
-0.7162697315216064,
0.2844826877117157,
-0.4767283797264099,
0.20429936051368713,
0.25956809520721436,
0.09645131975412369,
-0.8764028549194336,
-0.6058884859085083,
-0.4922243654727936,
-0.6714942455291748,
0.882038950920105,
0.12625034153461456,
0.4225439131259918,
-0.10903668403625488,
0.033065665513277054,
0.18408018350601196,
0.4654151499271393,
-0.7629150152206421,
0.10428273677825928,
0.14681376516819,
0.0914963111281395,
-0.17042744159698486,
-0.18095290660858154,
-0.6779022812843323,
-0.10531333088874817,
0.29942768812179565,
-0.16056044399738312,
0.24688567221164703,
0.013127388432621956,
0.13225579261779785,
-0.52775639295578,
0.3595014810562134,
0.6832757592201233,
0.9151588678359985,
-0.16248665750026703,
-0.20308956503868103,
0.12502381205558777,
0.1364041566848755,
-0.015771450474858284,
-0.14445537328720093,
0.38596057891845703,
-0.17371557652950287,
0.24741321802139282,
0.8759018182754517,
0.29671233892440796,
-0.9719070196151733,
0.4624873101711273,
-0.3129473030567169,
-0.1535232663154602,
-0.8346453309059143,
0.23236151039600372,
0.2391507923603058,
0.3833647072315216,
0.4006701409816742,
0.11186791211366653,
-0.0019920342601835728,
-0.9668087959289551,
0.4153541326522827,
0.395186185836792,
-0.41842374205589294,
-0.4712343215942383,
0.5222643613815308,
0.6393356919288635,
-1.199674129486084,
0.37077972292900085,
-0.08981355279684067,
-0.3718169629573822,
0.5760083198547363,
0.22318726778030396,
0.8881431221961975,
0.17477846145629883,
0.3309873044490814,
-0.3452818691730499,
-0.03898683935403824,
0.5597531199455261,
0.18571792542934418,
-0.19401559233665466,
-0.8993001580238342,
-0.5476093888282776,
-0.5341253876686096,
-0.9872866272926331,
-0.08631496876478195,
-0.1023179218173027,
0.30791768431663513,
-0.2550569176673889,
-0.1549149453639984,
-0.13123415410518646,
-0.07517031580209732,
-0.5479809641838074,
-0.19492648541927338,
0.6253551244735718,
0.6141161918640137,
-0.6357569098472595,
0.6067436933517456,
0.6189086437225342,
-0.2497027963399887,
-0.8899573087692261,
0.0771334320306778,
-0.030382169410586357,
-0.6636216044425964,
0.3927391469478607,
0.006029346492141485,
0.0111691327765584,
-0.044650714844465256,
-0.6529148817062378,
-0.6066288948059082,
1.0068658590316772,
0.2079102098941803,
-0.6403387188911438,
-0.1366192102432251,
0.31913095712661743,
0.8652344942092896,
-0.5121673941612244,
0.7006325125694275,
0.07361939549446106,
0.1804221272468567,
0.6720075607299805,
-1.0287392139434814,
-0.5235458612442017,
0.12629997730255127,
-0.31373289227485657,
-0.18971899151802063,
-0.8774028420448303,
0.43426910042762756,
0.08649060130119324,
-0.28269386291503906,
0.4371449053287506,
0.48553699254989624,
0.43466606736183167,
0.6511038541793823,
0.47811031341552734,
0.19102813303470612,
0.5854019522666931,
-0.16277608275413513,
1.1158791780471802,
-0.33783143758773804,
-0.1630396842956543,
0.8937169909477234,
-0.730780303478241,
0.685486376285553,
0.25475215911865234,
-0.17838813364505768,
0.8049255013465881,
0.48918047547340393,
0.5330127477645874,
0.16679491102695465,
0.7596917748451233,
-0.5284634232521057,
-0.41475361585617065,
-0.1868712455034256,
0.01012371014803648,
0.5585141181945801,
0.39787089824676514,
0.18211573362350464,
0.3580739498138428,
0.1352090686559677,
-0.27666038274765015,
0.1177448183298111,
0.02406899444758892,
0.9949519038200378,
0.25043985247612,
-0.9895539879798889,
0.013780991546809673,
-0.3889356851577759,
0.3361280858516693,
-0.23130591213703156,
-0.05967927351593971,
-0.21405352652072906,
0.15427277982234955,
-0.048462893813848495,
-0.9858449101448059,
0.3132556974887848,
-0.30994293093681335,
0.3473656475543976,
-0.10690020769834518,
0.5724813938140869,
-0.42087024450302124,
-0.17359012365341187,
0.20640093088150024,
0.2527379095554352,
0.5122643709182739,
0.06121410056948662,
-0.5604313015937805,
0.24997854232788086,
-0.3092908263206482,
-0.10304399579763412,
0.15296852588653564,
0.626856803894043,
-0.008852151222527027,
0.9725090265274048,
0.373697429895401,
-0.1578706055879593,
-0.1244334727525711,
0.5454062223434448,
0.8630102276802063,
-0.5001837611198425,
-0.5592104196548462,
-0.46110963821411133,
0.8942962288856506,
-0.008570605888962746,
-0.10260996967554092,
0.2945057153701782,
0.2728252708911896,
0.5962793231010437,
0.004366271197795868,
0.5237356424331665,
0.04544008895754814,
0.5189599394798279,
0.0032797877211123705,
0.775071918964386,
-0.45111820101737976,
0.2992141544818878,
-0.37094202637672424,
-0.5706830024719238,
0.0943794772028923,
0.23924493789672852,
-0.06880397349596024,
-0.08350599557161331,
0.28300556540489197,
0.9851771593093872,
0.3817940950393677,
0.19827760756015778,
0.8001325130462646,
0.06710635125637054,
0.5265889167785645,
0.2920295000076294,
1.974629282951355,
0.06623446196317673,
0.45713236927986145,
0.09840485453605652,
-0.23594969511032104,
-0.3167804777622223,
-0.7376061677932739,
-0.8039189577102661,
-0.507554292678833,
-0.3932460844516754,
-0.3796520531177521,
0.10934077203273773,
1.262418270111084,
0.6395367383956909,
-0.4853731095790863,
-0.704281747341156,
0.3186563551425934,
0.1841142326593399,
0.014151292853057384,
-0.21878233551979065,
-0.27826210856437683,
0.031210321933031082,
-0.9271228313446045,
0.9748366475105286,
0.5588873624801636,
-0.3094693422317505,
-0.6520124673843384,
-0.2302151769399643,
-0.2554028332233429,
0.6440320611000061,
0.6159349083900452,
0.2565697133541107,
-0.8195464015007019,
-0.563589334487915,
-0.18036916851997375,
0.02799062617123127,
0.011561575345695019,
0.47919270396232605,
-0.6186262369155884,
0.36756929755210876,
0.4376950263977051,
0.39326560497283936,
0.281120628118515,
0.010469234548509121,
0.9246178269386292,
-0.6584033966064453,
0.052961565554142,
0.46948009729385376,
0.11975211650133133,
0.3948807120323181,
-0.15484705567359924,
0.5199931859970093,
0.46551385521888733,
-1.1085114479064941,
-0.8891862034797668,
0.26833000779151917,
-1.1721789836883545,
0.050134509801864624,
1.1687382459640503,
-0.07422778755426407,
-0.016257520765066147,
-0.18578609824180603,
-0.35196906328201294,
0.2692357897758484,
-0.31205108761787415,
0.7081069350242615,
0.7222572565078735,
-0.3982803225517273,
-0.305625855922699,
-0.28837791085243225,
0.27941158413887024,
0.12161525338888168,
-0.4391236901283264,
-0.43389949202537537,
0.5612661242485046,
0.11390747129917145,
0.16982543468475342,
0.6605920195579529,
0.2183508574962616,
0.11893496662378311,
-0.20951475203037262,
0.37558260560035706,
0.19405902922153473,
-0.5457684993743896,
-0.21628573536872864,
0.31213778257369995,
0.29202818870544434,
-0.0052113840356469154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07101v1
|
Advanced Natural-based interaction for the ITAlian language: LLaMAntino-3-ANITA
| 2024-05-11T22:02:55 | 2024-05-11T22:02:55 |
Marco Polignano, Pierpaolo Basile, Giovanni Semeraro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the pursuit of advancing natural language processing for the Italian
language, we introduce a state-of-the-art Large Language Model (LLM) based on
the novel Meta LLaMA-3 model: LLaMAntino-3-ANITA-8B-Inst-DPO-ITA. We fine-tuned
the original 8B parameters instruction tuned model using the Supervised
Fine-tuning (SFT) technique on the English and Italian language datasets in
order to improve the original performance. Consequently, a Dynamic Preference
Optimization (DPO) process has been used to align preferences, avoid dangerous
and inappropriate answers, and limit biases and prejudices. Our model leverages
the efficiency of QLoRA to fine-tune the model on a smaller portion of the
original model weights and then adapt the model specifically for the Italian
linguistic structure, achieving significant improvements in both performance
and computational efficiency. Concurrently, DPO is employed to refine the
model's output, ensuring that generated content aligns with quality answers.
The synergy between SFT, QLoRA's parameter efficiency and DPO's user-centric
optimization results in a robust LLM that excels in a variety of tasks,
including but not limited to text completion, zero-shot classification, and
contextual understanding. The model has been extensively evaluated over
standard benchmarks for the Italian and English languages, showing outstanding
results. The model is freely available over the HuggingFace hub and, examples
of use can be found in our GitHub repository.
https://huggingface.co/swap-uniba/LLaMAntino-3-ANITA-8B-Inst-DPO-ITA
|
[
-0.4262657165527344,
-0.9462166428565979,
0.550251305103302,
0.21396726369857788,
-0.33363839983940125,
0.01831836998462677,
-0.38102760910987854,
-0.9127801060676575,
0.3685384690761566,
0.43645814061164856,
-0.37705063819885254,
-0.4319300055503845,
-0.47021856904029846,
0.33661869168281555,
-0.16287602484226227,
0.9502434730529785,
-0.1334500014781952,
0.3422107994556427,
0.1765119433403015,
-0.06847336888313293,
-0.05584169924259186,
-0.3585321009159088,
-0.8944265842437744,
-0.35357603430747986,
0.49652138352394104,
0.3690689504146576,
0.7577217817306519,
0.7307278513908386,
0.41854745149612427,
0.3545876741409302,
-0.39077478647232056,
0.4862222969532013,
-0.3878903388977051,
0.07183575630187988,
-0.13421854376792908,
-0.49696412682533264,
-0.9198996424674988,
0.02714262716472149,
0.6892157196998596,
0.5263747572898865,
-0.15104888379573822,
-0.04667835310101509,
0.060042232275009155,
0.7435212135314941,
-0.4830169975757599,
0.09720204025506973,
-0.6278769969940186,
-0.21488559246063232,
-0.23470668494701385,
-0.09880083054304123,
-0.17990197241306305,
-0.48950549960136414,
-0.12229010462760925,
-0.5340703129768372,
-0.33517736196517944,
0.03329906985163689,
0.682961106300354,
0.43451717495918274,
-0.34670355916023254,
-0.4499669075012207,
-0.7820525765419006,
0.5034186244010925,
-0.741439163684845,
0.037863001227378845,
0.3892943561077118,
0.1999506801366806,
-0.3124338388442993,
-0.36687639355659485,
-0.8256823420524597,
-0.6517486572265625,
0.29237911105155945,
-0.18546485900878906,
-0.12739728391170502,
0.23500460386276245,
-0.05192084610462189,
0.6865601539611816,
-0.2823173403739929,
0.49945929646492004,
-0.21479499340057373,
0.04033214971423149,
0.6493792533874512,
0.024604422971606255,
0.4373480975627899,
0.13056300580501556,
-0.17098307609558105,
0.3237870931625366,
-0.8116990923881531,
-0.1359085887670517,
0.6205693483352661,
0.33571693301200867,
-0.1058102622628212,
0.6123155951499939,
-0.31836122274398804,
0.908964216709137,
0.19580097496509552,
-0.12913580238819122,
0.17705079913139343,
-0.24568693339824677,
-0.007075132802128792,
-0.04926525056362152,
0.9026671648025513,
0.31679531931877136,
0.38375815749168396,
-0.02153930254280567,
-0.11104245483875275,
-0.13536983728408813,
-0.05208924785256386,
-0.8372390270233154,
0.10886959731578827,
0.1660146415233612,
0.025458185002207756,
-0.381943941116333,
-0.3347082734107971,
-0.8063657283782959,
-0.37083202600479126,
-0.48558932542800903,
0.15990188717842102,
-0.33754271268844604,
-0.06069621816277504,
0.1420389860868454,
0.5534496307373047,
-0.07090817391872406,
0.3692837059497833,
-1.1983356475830078,
0.31826043128967285,
0.5755234956741333,
0.8244264721870422,
-0.4096960723400116,
-0.12628228962421417,
-0.720130980014801,
0.3813530206680298,
-0.198129802942276,
0.825975775718689,
-0.753124475479126,
-0.20403429865837097,
-0.09003574401140213,
-0.2142166644334793,
0.036783091723918915,
-0.5001971125602722,
0.6221988201141357,
-0.4623642563819885,
0.3302636444568634,
0.09214118868112564,
-0.42072567343711853,
-0.257111519575119,
0.4084717929363251,
-0.8459442257881165,
1.1086599826812744,
-0.031542133539915085,
-0.6627911925315857,
0.10762681066989899,
-0.7925053238868713,
-0.20002050697803497,
0.07135520875453949,
0.0018797290977090597,
-0.28821954131126404,
0.15106795728206635,
0.10053295642137527,
0.15894541144371033,
-0.43234097957611084,
0.6651292443275452,
-0.49766215682029724,
-0.37829872965812683,
0.12611596286296844,
-0.43046465516090393,
0.6255322694778442,
0.08992117643356323,
-0.5346516370773315,
0.28959158062934875,
-1.2104368209838867,
-0.20838145911693573,
-0.07945135235786438,
-0.5412504076957703,
-0.2671705484390259,
-0.0181368887424469,
-0.02448856085538864,
0.12480415403842926,
0.694606602191925,
-0.5942712426185608,
0.44384151697158813,
-0.6712570190429688,
0.6323454976081848,
0.66226726770401,
-0.27069538831710815,
0.540902316570282,
0.11781968176364899,
0.49723970890045166,
-0.12678848206996918,
0.18862970173358917,
0.09165021777153015,
-0.395870178937912,
-0.9791162610054016,
-0.43501150608062744,
0.3278312087059021,
0.7128109931945801,
-0.7143742442131042,
0.44280362129211426,
-0.18570998311042786,
-0.4437251091003418,
-0.5520041584968567,
0.2544822096824646,
0.43640896677970886,
0.28119125962257385,
0.26861047744750977,
-0.17245721817016602,
-0.35981690883636475,
-1.0963943004608154,
-0.04412982240319252,
-0.18066583573818207,
0.19262196123600006,
0.24967768788337708,
0.2444746345281601,
-0.33948272466659546,
0.7805178165435791,
-0.279989093542099,
-0.12854605913162231,
-0.3498634397983551,
0.041597090661525726,
0.5257865786552429,
0.5167984366416931,
0.8073294162750244,
-0.668518602848053,
-0.6698734164237976,
0.4002830386161804,
-0.3745444416999817,
-0.30267903208732605,
0.3570653796195984,
-0.35477420687675476,
0.36342865228652954,
0.1549685150384903,
-0.6632025837898254,
0.3023735284805298,
0.7837633490562439,
-0.10252602398395538,
0.2547011375427246,
-0.2608718276023865,
0.09738098829984665,
-1.3668500185012817,
0.20657500624656677,
-0.14793632924556732,
-0.191216841340065,
-0.7519074082374573,
0.2097642570734024,
-0.18985435366630554,
-0.04103615880012512,
-0.5213038325309753,
0.7942932844161987,
-0.4055553674697876,
-0.07834392786026001,
-0.4658012092113495,
0.19017282128334045,
-0.10374640673398972,
0.6515327095985413,
0.12941071391105652,
1.146119475364685,
0.28634190559387207,
-0.5158449411392212,
0.5027627944946289,
0.14379943907260895,
-0.17135268449783325,
0.37451037764549255,
-0.7094829082489014,
0.2911316454410553,
0.15951602160930634,
-0.020194435492157936,
-0.7754993438720703,
-0.3429931402206421,
0.5662702918052673,
-0.2916563153266907,
0.30072933435440063,
0.028188131749629974,
-0.6646763682365417,
-0.10613082349300385,
-0.16671180725097656,
0.4146743416786194,
-0.1002754494547844,
-0.39446768164634705,
0.6521422266960144,
0.4241676330566406,
-0.5298593640327454,
-0.30060020089149475,
-0.5054178833961487,
0.3495599627494812,
-0.34423866868019104,
-0.42095428705215454,
0.5287008881568909,
-0.27675747871398926,
-0.3566075265407562,
-0.33443132042884827,
0.33463558554649353,
-0.40070781111717224,
0.2097776234149933,
-0.13784722983837128,
0.23340332508087158,
0.001612967113032937,
0.08476343750953674,
0.28190162777900696,
-0.22360169887542725,
-0.36480459570884705,
-0.08704130351543427,
0.6809284687042236,
-0.03368968144059181,
-0.08777399361133575,
-0.8459885120391846,
0.4480351507663727,
0.6771116256713867,
-0.283589631319046,
0.8551206588745117,
0.4439135491847992,
-0.24400536715984344,
0.11383435130119324,
-0.4067341685295105,
-0.01314825750887394,
-0.4339870512485504,
0.2143697589635849,
-0.45304468274116516,
-1.009653925895691,
0.4651534855365753,
0.15734770894050598,
0.1760992705821991,
0.22803173959255219,
0.700691819190979,
0.241122305393219,
1.167786717414856,
0.8417463898658752,
-0.42207205295562744,
0.7677094340324402,
0.12140835076570511,
0.28489363193511963,
-0.8023558259010315,
-0.0485052764415741,
-0.563541054725647,
-0.22080668807029724,
-0.839441180229187,
-0.25830090045928955,
0.41715630888938904,
0.13386975228786469,
-0.22580215334892273,
0.32767346501350403,
-0.2877693176269531,
0.3594423830509186,
0.683803915977478,
0.20931212604045868,
0.6555464267730713,
-0.013644421473145485,
-0.17634853720664978,
0.06477037072181702,
-0.4894315302371979,
-0.8446844816207886,
0.7945960760116577,
0.33023619651794434,
0.5351020097732544,
0.346302330493927,
0.5876747369766235,
-0.023815525695681572,
0.3162508010864258,
-0.7973073124885559,
0.5366966128349304,
-0.14375881850719452,
-0.7319069504737854,
-0.1541544795036316,
-0.30836454033851624,
-0.6192502379417419,
0.2832645773887634,
-0.22297395765781403,
-0.782552182674408,
-0.001990611432120204,
0.45937108993530273,
-0.39497336745262146,
0.13383722305297852,
-0.5559784173965454,
0.505882978439331,
-0.41939103603363037,
-0.9441225528717041,
-0.43331706523895264,
-0.32029643654823303,
0.34332507848739624,
0.006491226609796286,
0.21098408102989197,
-0.39672136306762695,
-0.2179829329252243,
0.18000046908855438,
-0.1971459686756134,
0.9458835124969482,
0.046909037977457047,
-0.4209817945957184,
0.1114303320646286,
0.09396657347679138,
0.4265848398208618,
0.21248438954353333,
-0.5588158369064331,
0.18632735311985016,
-0.16930074989795685,
-0.31169283390045166,
-0.5086401104927063,
0.7068588137626648,
-0.72391676902771,
-0.6495223641395569,
-0.3527611494064331,
-0.4339892864227295,
-0.23496155440807343,
0.3184513449668884,
-0.06352289021015167,
0.43062251806259155,
-0.26984626054763794,
0.07756192237138748,
0.38386091589927673,
-0.24366982281208038,
0.47135114669799805,
0.7339677810668945,
-0.21146179735660553,
-0.6207396984100342,
0.6178518533706665,
-0.23399323225021362,
0.22843392193317413,
0.484568327665329,
0.058956462889909744,
-0.07567339390516281,
-0.8198143243789673,
-0.7775431871414185,
0.3613041937351227,
-0.18354272842407227,
-0.25318533182144165,
-0.40186807513237,
-0.031224844977259636,
-0.187740296125412,
0.20053252577781677,
-0.36617234349250793,
-0.49748048186302185,
-0.5310106873512268,
-0.17116428911685944,
0.3232514560222626,
0.7613998055458069,
0.09519283473491669,
0.48509639501571655,
-0.7476932406425476,
0.11877153813838959,
0.2151678204536438,
0.44480210542678833,
-0.28588199615478516,
-0.3734623193740845,
-0.34278830885887146,
0.25772300362586975,
-0.39917656779289246,
-0.7910630702972412,
0.49650806188583374,
0.3777486979961395,
0.5302123427391052,
0.47027620673179626,
-0.25233861804008484,
0.48889651894569397,
-0.7585986852645874,
0.6918052434921265,
-0.06401291489601135,
-0.9882689714431763,
0.5419650077819824,
-0.7028014063835144,
0.1529812514781952,
0.6913033127784729,
0.33221784234046936,
-0.08063793182373047,
-0.26317402720451355,
-0.19426317512989044,
-0.6744612455368042,
0.6348986625671387,
0.22995342314243317,
0.17317673563957214,
-0.10072892904281616,
0.6380608677864075,
0.007378717418760061,
0.45337024331092834,
-0.955575704574585,
0.14593668282032013,
0.22951678931713104,
-0.36565807461738586,
-0.08476563543081284,
-0.47018566727638245,
-0.10849414020776749,
-0.2772074043750763,
0.6997805833816528,
-0.447956919670105,
0.10728615522384644,
-0.1308339238166809,
-0.07672370970249176,
-0.054137349128723145,
0.21589893102645874,
0.8830054402351379,
0.6312469840049744,
-0.03564094752073288,
-0.22165478765964508,
0.20794004201889038,
-0.3412371575832367,
-0.0913727805018425,
0.3026307225227356,
-0.18557076156139374,
-0.13514456152915955,
0.3037478029727936,
1.1358332633972168,
0.5082094669342041,
-0.6980167031288147,
0.17432162165641785,
0.00644267350435257,
0.01977352984249592,
-0.31484025716781616,
0.31482961773872375,
-0.047629959881305695,
0.23972740769386292,
0.15860532224178314,
-0.16138575971126556,
0.42851147055625916,
-0.6954251527786255,
-0.10640352964401245,
0.3881525993347168,
-0.29917076230049133,
-0.5559168457984924,
0.5628042221069336,
0.687674880027771,
-0.25856536626815796,
0.30518749356269836,
0.022712599486112595,
-0.7274256348609924,
0.39795204997062683,
0.363383024930954,
0.724697470664978,
-0.42186832427978516,
0.2575761079788208,
0.38548746705055237,
0.054110605269670486,
0.1306006908416748,
0.24105986952781677,
-0.2840329706668854,
-0.9058367609977722,
-0.473267525434494,
-0.8426141738891602,
-0.620914876461029,
-0.04652077332139015,
-0.6676088571548462,
0.3123255670070648,
-0.4633174538612366,
-0.16880488395690918,
-0.1595870405435562,
0.3598216772079468,
-0.25929105281829834,
0.08060940355062485,
0.035117343068122864,
0.8935486078262329,
-0.6226464509963989,
1.0076079368591309,
0.7201835513114929,
-0.3455553650856018,
-0.4483155310153961,
-0.03877158463001251,
-0.061429355293512344,
-0.9369272589683533,
0.4943322241306305,
0.22678905725479126,
-0.3972281217575073,
0.1250097155570984,
-0.4843055009841919,
-0.9425968527793884,
0.8974146246910095,
0.6886454820632935,
-0.8229699730873108,
-0.02116682380437851,
0.09228813648223877,
0.8188664317131042,
-0.5819567441940308,
0.3870713412761688,
0.8418195247650146,
0.5129674673080444,
0.21320141851902008,
-1.0545549392700195,
-0.36287111043930054,
-0.41374915838241577,
0.05200449004769325,
0.21215830743312836,
-1.0022598505020142,
0.46300140023231506,
-0.08920654654502869,
0.04709485173225403,
0.5306045413017273,
0.6877812147140503,
0.24053435027599335,
0.05437670275568962,
0.34926557540893555,
0.4997327923774719,
0.6872985363006592,
-0.061285510659217834,
1.0251789093017578,
-0.7334845066070557,
-0.08541736751794815,
1.059535264968872,
-0.41976848244667053,
1.098887324333191,
0.6092644929885864,
-0.16795296967029572,
0.6345953941345215,
0.7166798710823059,
0.38003700971603394,
0.32298997044563293,
0.07959148287773132,
-0.506817638874054,
-0.09473967552185059,
-0.3433888554573059,
-0.2324148565530777,
0.7762792110443115,
0.347760945558548,
-0.18045449256896973,
0.10956739634275436,
-0.13669177889823914,
0.29408547282218933,
0.3106784522533417,
-0.24021992087364197,
0.915847897529602,
-0.16307778656482697,
-0.8218255043029785,
0.485548198223114,
0.07958947122097015,
0.6098767518997192,
-0.4081875681877136,
-0.03544282168149948,
-0.5191084146499634,
0.17667903006076813,
0.017404532060027122,
-0.5435736775398254,
0.2425868958234787,
0.30692872405052185,
-0.26501286029815674,
-0.06266999989748001,
0.13916300237178802,
-0.7080579400062561,
-0.5996935963630676,
0.34448638558387756,
0.09643379598855972,
0.08710246533155441,
0.16370350122451782,
-0.6488839983940125,
0.4402366578578949,
0.16618014872074127,
-0.2770312428474426,
0.14808252453804016,
0.32377439737319946,
-0.042306628078222275,
0.7916237115859985,
0.5607627034187317,
0.2926308810710907,
-0.17073170840740204,
0.19507507979869843,
1.0530540943145752,
-0.38554850220680237,
-0.4138683080673218,
-0.739016056060791,
0.4521183967590332,
-0.2774845063686371,
-0.4517214596271515,
0.40106168389320374,
0.4320116639137268,
0.4959293305873871,
0.2564607262611389,
0.41873878240585327,
0.10528183728456497,
0.7153589129447937,
-0.7334882020950317,
0.41034916043281555,
-0.6730292439460754,
0.3241296112537384,
-0.08550715446472168,
-1.2627695798873901,
-0.35113874077796936,
0.677011251449585,
-0.4015016555786133,
0.14787672460079193,
0.4216825067996979,
0.7590004205703735,
0.09258707612752914,
-0.09202297776937485,
0.23500022292137146,
0.35493624210357666,
0.35860002040863037,
0.5724742412567139,
0.5403556227684021,
-0.15375706553459167,
0.23356761038303375,
-0.03152003139257431,
-0.5367119908332825,
-0.11517488211393356,
-0.9921987652778625,
-0.9413803815841675,
-0.3859088122844696,
-0.06928569078445435,
0.1976774036884308,
0.3837355971336365,
1.0061101913452148,
0.6543946266174316,
-0.9048569202423096,
-0.24568963050842285,
-0.2461702525615692,
-0.026848172768950462,
0.24007178843021393,
-0.15348264575004578,
0.010554490610957146,
-0.27857255935668945,
-1.5369937419891357,
0.5243406295776367,
0.5294340252876282,
0.11604419350624084,
-0.44583868980407715,
0.03865961730480194,
-0.27645742893218994,
0.004121077712625265,
0.572754442691803,
0.20120769739151,
-0.7099085450172424,
-0.11453375965356827,
-0.24271655082702637,
-0.021243922412395477,
-0.023367252200841904,
0.47428449988365173,
-0.49923986196517944,
0.3658164143562317,
0.42015358805656433,
0.6185519695281982,
0.4862290620803833,
0.04135332256555557,
1.152640700340271,
-0.2144438922405243,
0.4935135841369629,
0.08515529334545135,
0.25731807947158813,
0.5341349840164185,
-0.5430290102958679,
0.4963783919811249,
-0.049776796251535416,
-0.5125409960746765,
-0.6763810515403748,
0.384236603975296,
-0.6749250888824463,
-0.00752160744741559,
1.1127463579177856,
-0.12153205275535583,
-0.16315534710884094,
0.31160369515419006,
-0.48954662680625916,
0.11907680332660675,
-0.46006619930267334,
0.8982736468315125,
0.7329460978507996,
-0.126250758767128,
-0.3721996247768402,
-0.5615078806877136,
0.5418875217437744,
0.38698065280914307,
-0.9027507305145264,
-0.2605527937412262,
0.6817554235458374,
0.05708090960979462,
-0.014905554242432117,
0.3271884620189667,
-0.013286886736750603,
0.08606452494859695,
-0.6110202670097351,
0.07777421921491623,
-0.12732647359371185,
-0.45192277431488037,
-0.4170773923397064,
-0.045479666441679,
0.25636470317840576,
-0.026710426434874535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07099v1
|
Do Pretrained Contextual Language Models Distinguish between Hebrew Homograph Analyses?
| 2024-05-11T21:50:56 | 2024-05-11T21:50:56 |
Avi Shmidman, Cheyn Shmuel Shmidman, Dan Bareket, Moshe Koppel, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Semitic morphologically-rich languages (MRLs) are characterized by extreme
word ambiguity. Because most vowels are omitted in standard texts, many of the
words are homographs with multiple possible analyses, each with a different
pronunciation and different morphosyntactic properties. This ambiguity goes
beyond word-sense disambiguation (WSD), and may include token segmentation into
multiple word units. Previous research on MRLs claimed that standardly trained
pre-trained language models (PLMs) based on word-pieces may not sufficiently
capture the internal structure of such tokens in order to distinguish between
these analyses. Taking Hebrew as a case study, we investigate the extent to
which Hebrew homographs can be disambiguated and analyzed using PLMs. We
evaluate all existing models for contextualized Hebrew embeddings on a novel
Hebrew homograph challenge sets that we deliver. Our empirical results
demonstrate that contemporary Hebrew contextualized embeddings outperform
non-contextualized embeddings; and that they are most effective for
disambiguating segmentation and morphosyntactic features, less so regarding
pure word-sense disambiguation. We show that these embeddings are more
effective when the number of word-piece splits is limited, and they are more
effective for 2-way and 3-way ambiguities than for 4-way ambiguity. We show
that the embeddings are equally effective for homographs of both balanced and
skewed distributions, whether calculated as masked or unmasked tokens. Finally,
we show that these embeddings are as effective for homograph disambiguation
with extensive supervised training as with a few-shot setup.
|
[
-0.2979504466056824,
-0.855133056640625,
0.37848132848739624,
0.14287897944450378,
-0.657733678817749,
0.033875610679388046,
-0.13607487082481384,
-0.4518181383609772,
0.18713419139385223,
-0.031085362657904625,
-0.3866809904575348,
-0.5658856630325317,
-0.7178472280502319,
0.2645585536956787,
-0.20796339213848114,
0.557539165019989,
-0.05859116092324257,
0.2680761218070984,
-0.15509085357189178,
-0.535542905330658,
-0.4526394307613373,
-0.37449681758880615,
0.09078559279441833,
-0.31085219979286194,
0.46816372871398926,
-0.16270014643669128,
1.0647363662719727,
0.7897708415985107,
0.41938838362693787,
0.29130545258522034,
-0.36142754554748535,
0.10927749425172806,
-0.09355742484331131,
0.29219868779182434,
-0.13021963834762573,
-0.1373947560787201,
-0.12809611856937408,
0.1871158331632614,
0.6414569020271301,
1.1473275423049927,
-0.08833643049001694,
0.23993028700351715,
-0.17136168479919434,
0.4805665910243988,
-0.8038907647132874,
-0.15950968861579895,
-0.7162994146347046,
0.4237666726112366,
-0.5659821629524231,
-0.2616351842880249,
-0.43652254343032837,
0.08165891468524933,
0.37199267745018005,
-0.47865989804267883,
0.028238996863365173,
0.33044853806495667,
0.7390357851982117,
0.34149444103240967,
-0.4226599931716919,
-0.4740212857723236,
-0.377828985452652,
0.6726558804512024,
-0.6310321092605591,
0.7542424201965332,
0.42602959275245667,
-0.043073251843452454,
-0.07091929018497467,
-0.6691563725471497,
-0.47853177785873413,
-0.06456170231103897,
-0.2563191056251526,
0.10133429616689682,
-0.11420504003763199,
0.017665190622210503,
0.24871623516082764,
0.23881924152374268,
-0.6162719130516052,
0.053348101675510406,
-0.3643253445625305,
-0.3465060591697693,
0.20117594301700592,
-0.05830011144280434,
0.32789966464042664,
-0.549706757068634,
-0.5987778902053833,
-0.21747411787509918,
-0.7977426648139954,
0.08576072007417679,
0.2513061463832855,
0.2808782756328583,
-0.1313295215368271,
0.7055357098579407,
0.29091954231262207,
0.9501360654830933,
-0.21101824939250946,
-0.23819972574710846,
0.5655609965324402,
-0.06329461932182312,
-0.42857590317726135,
0.20904555916786194,
0.5409783124923706,
0.0014805372338742018,
0.16266021132469177,
-0.3108156621456146,
-0.15972313284873962,
0.1068732962012291,
0.11158974468708038,
-0.3994644582271576,
-0.011094790883362293,
0.08861097693443298,
-0.4915763735771179,
-0.003979409579187632,
0.29491177201271057,
-0.38234132528305054,
-0.33306124806404114,
-0.15362857282161713,
0.3784104883670807,
-0.42363715171813965,
-0.00807133037596941,
0.28226765990257263,
-0.4116416573524475,
0.4085977375507355,
0.09231279790401459,
-0.6557560563087463,
-0.07645884156227112,
0.7168248295783997,
0.871589720249176,
-0.05631159991025925,
-0.3608337342739105,
-0.5646125078201294,
0.16371452808380127,
-0.5404624342918396,
0.469545841217041,
-0.8817568421363831,
-0.3232177793979645,
0.03530152142047882,
-0.1049826443195343,
-0.2949889898300171,
-0.6282294392585754,
-0.158013254404068,
-0.7408444285392761,
0.03855903819203377,
-0.30321788787841797,
-0.812332034111023,
0.13064493238925934,
0.3305203914642334,
-0.46976223587989807,
0.9580656290054321,
0.2012832909822464,
-1.006547451019287,
0.5843335390090942,
-0.2686375379562378,
-0.5122777819633484,
0.28774017095565796,
-0.5030848383903503,
-0.10440537333488464,
0.3231247067451477,
-0.016485361382365227,
0.3525386154651642,
-0.04257240891456604,
0.3370489478111267,
-0.17565768957138062,
-0.45836806297302246,
0.19503450393676758,
-0.3289411664009094,
0.7980677485466003,
0.16329325735569,
-0.56488037109375,
0.26558583974838257,
-0.5458664298057556,
0.02625446394085884,
0.14918936789035797,
-0.16811826825141907,
-0.6246678233146667,
0.008887768723070621,
-0.08117181807756424,
0.09528740495443344,
0.04137437418103218,
-0.6181374788284302,
-0.120494045317173,
-0.4744330644607544,
0.3206387162208557,
0.7339326739311218,
-0.4673112630844116,
0.364867627620697,
0.0250206608325243,
0.545475423336029,
0.1119876503944397,
0.021072393283247948,
-0.18826639652252197,
-0.6006737351417542,
-0.4416082203388214,
-0.3672364354133606,
0.2969609200954437,
0.451213002204895,
-0.5753556489944458,
0.6445310115814209,
-0.07459872215986252,
-0.22978933155536652,
-0.48550039529800415,
-0.17609184980392456,
0.5305500030517578,
0.6570256352424622,
0.5333831906318665,
-0.4235154092311859,
-0.26991432905197144,
-0.8215916156768799,
-0.2772311270236969,
-0.21567852795124054,
0.20321102440357208,
0.1100374311208725,
0.5052938461303711,
-0.11193354427814484,
1.1261812448501587,
-0.2596265971660614,
-0.05473058298230171,
-0.2809004485607147,
0.09631887823343277,
-0.18377374112606049,
0.3870357573032379,
0.4684578478336334,
-0.928302526473999,
-0.5462822914123535,
-0.10744807869195938,
-0.7705778479576111,
0.0777936801314354,
0.1169750839471817,
0.0001223106519319117,
-0.09663822501897812,
0.7268940806388855,
-0.41666075587272644,
0.7922340631484985,
0.5921951532363892,
-0.7022778987884521,
0.3799004852771759,
-0.30243009328842163,
-0.29048389196395874,
-0.7098094820976257,
0.016577955335378647,
-0.22896279394626617,
-0.43825995922088623,
-0.7489756345748901,
0.0796358659863472,
0.2513137757778168,
0.22813035547733307,
-0.6022313237190247,
0.7584110498428345,
-0.46874573826789856,
-0.4578920304775238,
-0.13085094094276428,
0.40757495164871216,
0.03045429289340973,
0.29264962673187256,
0.040049243718385696,
0.655559241771698,
0.5378483533859253,
-0.25481274724006653,
0.06616760790348053,
0.5091738700866699,
-0.6218265891075134,
0.3804047107696533,
-0.7100690007209778,
0.07526958733797073,
-0.48290005326271057,
0.24649661779403687,
-1.0178937911987305,
-0.040348365902900696,
0.5131883025169373,
-0.046444132924079895,
0.32924267649650574,
-0.07716106623411179,
-0.3571285307407379,
-0.2047661989927292,
-0.21444211900234222,
0.7245285511016846,
0.41990208625793457,
-0.5191038250923157,
0.3034490942955017,
0.33122509717941284,
0.16743333637714386,
-0.760257363319397,
-0.6223700046539307,
-0.24760298430919647,
-0.254925936460495,
-0.509609580039978,
0.5580315589904785,
-0.04924584925174713,
-0.3689672648906708,
0.17605619132518768,
-0.21702662110328674,
-0.01573401503264904,
0.10716387629508972,
0.30407145619392395,
0.2730499505996704,
-0.1215294748544693,
0.40273377299308777,
-0.11872081458568573,
-0.05295576900243759,
-0.3802531659603119,
-0.26407405734062195,
0.8673858046531677,
-0.3266920745372772,
-0.7971292734146118,
-0.3913402259349823,
0.2288237065076828,
0.3412942886352539,
-0.46901562809944153,
0.9252960681915283,
0.9453908801078796,
-0.26379409432411194,
0.216167151927948,
-0.5815501809120178,
0.02938741259276867,
-0.46244651079177856,
0.3651745319366455,
-0.4782499670982361,
-1.1436716318130493,
0.5248525142669678,
0.07892470806837082,
-0.07263288646936417,
0.43328791856765747,
0.39331021904945374,
-0.10880150645971298,
0.9034627676010132,
0.42429760098457336,
0.09897158294916153,
0.40211221575737,
0.09608049690723419,
0.11079996824264526,
-1.1163315773010254,
-0.1851309835910797,
-0.36331889033317566,
-0.4950123131275177,
-0.7005162239074707,
-0.4801445007324219,
0.3411233127117157,
0.1086638942360878,
-0.04810343310236931,
-0.03527884557843208,
-0.1847020834684372,
0.6194822788238525,
0.4627930223941803,
-0.24638696014881134,
-0.05386825650930405,
0.05370427295565605,
-0.3714599311351776,
-0.03854907676577568,
-0.7035329341888428,
-0.4518161118030548,
0.7860821485519409,
0.35537511110305786,
0.22164303064346313,
0.016735214740037918,
0.7322627305984497,
0.161015585064888,
0.47310853004455566,
-0.7022676467895508,
0.16840873658657074,
-0.15516197681427002,
-0.8388226628303528,
-0.46016865968704224,
-0.4726722836494446,
-1.0937705039978027,
0.7056027054786682,
-0.15687620639801025,
-0.8115061521530151,
0.27690649032592773,
0.06132245436310768,
-0.40890631079673767,
0.36085477471351624,
-0.5380132794380188,
1.1347252130508423,
0.017312120646238327,
-0.10323932021856308,
0.14691874384880066,
-0.9342055916786194,
-0.06579691916704178,
-0.04768330603837967,
0.45885977149009705,
-0.3730936646461487,
0.0984204038977623,
0.849544107913971,
-0.41690295934677124,
0.7206341624259949,
-0.32623207569122314,
-0.05271637439727783,
0.40072357654571533,
0.13074171543121338,
0.2935580611228943,
-0.1151028722524643,
-0.15291114151477814,
0.2621331810951233,
0.2648070156574249,
-0.5945203900337219,
-0.26538029313087463,
0.22272264957427979,
-0.6099201440811157,
-0.5758879780769348,
-0.32573285698890686,
-0.5287150740623474,
-0.2818009853363037,
0.1460566371679306,
0.43459004163742065,
0.7721615433692932,
-0.12966492772102356,
0.30201759934425354,
0.37467125058174133,
-0.3255060911178589,
0.554931640625,
0.09547998011112213,
-0.053162362426519394,
-0.12862469255924225,
0.563280463218689,
0.001966072479262948,
0.17807994782924652,
0.0948566272854805,
0.5150119662284851,
-0.34751781821250916,
-0.6766961216926575,
-0.47727611660957336,
0.38204294443130493,
-0.8761473894119263,
0.025053376331925392,
-0.24641193449497223,
-0.06761234998703003,
-0.3504197597503662,
-0.2722650468349457,
-0.5202131867408752,
-0.12352091073989868,
-0.08191995322704315,
-0.056769419461488724,
-0.18629729747772217,
0.872509241104126,
0.047777604311704636,
0.4819720387458801,
-0.8125442862510681,
0.19509147107601166,
0.1881164014339447,
0.2461482137441635,
-0.02497253753244877,
-0.6586653590202332,
0.045271292328834534,
-0.11174293607473373,
0.21881558001041412,
-1.1244359016418457,
0.2312963306903839,
0.12818971276283264,
0.4654522240161896,
0.6056913733482361,
-0.04702644422650337,
1.0127220153808594,
-0.7700858116149902,
0.6368968486785889,
0.2847013473510742,
-1.120306134223938,
0.1451055258512497,
-0.13012249767780304,
0.2875595986843109,
0.6632803082466125,
0.3792572319507599,
-0.770843505859375,
-0.23324249684810638,
-0.504368245601654,
-0.8723879456520081,
0.6552106142044067,
0.10624496638774872,
0.3486710488796234,
-0.5927971005439758,
0.4959380030632019,
0.1864374279975891,
0.4696996510028839,
-0.7864019274711609,
-0.441628634929657,
-0.12681961059570312,
-0.2977893352508545,
0.01702755130827427,
-0.41767096519470215,
-0.17001885175704956,
-0.2929530739784241,
0.1517798751592636,
0.07808492332696915,
-0.003503988729789853,
0.31033360958099365,
-0.5521655082702637,
0.059637147933244705,
0.15583088994026184,
0.588118314743042,
1.0040045976638794,
-0.19292891025543213,
0.7030143737792969,
0.020909644663333893,
-0.3831377625465393,
0.049105554819107056,
-0.20708203315734863,
-0.027369778603315353,
0.1089453175663948,
0.8111045956611633,
0.9613974690437317,
0.1412772685289383,
-0.8027841448783875,
0.8139064311981201,
0.1536267101764679,
0.024513112381100655,
-0.07898269593715668,
-0.3309139907360077,
0.006039801053702831,
0.4685269594192505,
0.17668452858924866,
-0.07985775917768478,
-0.2084575593471527,
-0.54753178358078,
0.15317772328853607,
0.6864205002784729,
-0.5347775220870972,
-0.4112195074558258,
0.25805094838142395,
-0.10585813224315643,
-0.3410358726978302,
0.731485903263092,
-0.6291335225105286,
-0.6560750603675842,
0.35973265767097473,
0.7423512935638428,
0.4980717897415161,
-0.31065723299980164,
0.2516374886035919,
0.007015967275947332,
0.2556374967098236,
0.11699417978525162,
0.10853452980518341,
-0.1164500042796135,
-1.044033169746399,
-0.1530410349369049,
-0.7974550127983093,
-0.015075351111590862,
-0.052717529237270355,
-0.6867961883544922,
-0.18649359047412872,
-0.43078580498695374,
-0.2126278281211853,
-0.12669295072555542,
-0.5652142763137817,
-0.8136335015296936,
0.10443886369466782,
0.3384995758533478,
0.4998680651187897,
-0.8409543037414551,
0.6254600286483765,
0.7261218428611755,
0.015051731839776039,
-0.6666900515556335,
0.04625711962580681,
0.013528748415410519,
-0.9773338437080383,
0.8561291098594666,
0.3743090033531189,
-0.15356099605560303,
0.05088936537504196,
-0.17692342400550842,
-0.7995743155479431,
1.0199604034423828,
0.16857916116714478,
-0.3910422623157501,
0.04460879787802696,
0.24746271967887878,
0.3995506167411804,
-0.331917941570282,
0.18785011768341064,
0.552402913570404,
0.46199631690979004,
0.28564363718032837,
-0.8195974230766296,
-0.06872355937957764,
-0.11563234776258469,
-0.04422236233949661,
0.24688458442687988,
-0.24985522031784058,
0.9142170548439026,
0.14843155443668365,
-0.400250643491745,
-0.167015939950943,
0.5767856240272522,
0.20631903409957886,
0.37919604778289795,
0.8300495743751526,
0.4442662298679352,
0.9899054169654846,
0.04316292703151703,
1.0932788848876953,
-0.3510175943374634,
0.25470036268234253,
1.2135707139968872,
-0.3380393981933594,
0.8905264735221863,
0.7969538569450378,
-0.2680438160896301,
0.3754298985004425,
0.7264875769615173,
0.1828882098197937,
0.41779211163520813,
0.21686844527721405,
-0.06030615046620369,
-0.40496647357940674,
-0.1864556074142456,
-0.49812138080596924,
0.7016581296920776,
0.2679609954357147,
-0.22279319167137146,
-0.2328735589981079,
0.072662353515625,
0.011463512666523457,
-0.15932214260101318,
0.09889114648103714,
0.4246109127998352,
-0.01924857310950756,
-0.4066329896450043,
0.3536163866519928,
0.2868846356868744,
0.6712468862533569,
-0.6465179324150085,
0.4151352345943451,
-0.14148780703544617,
-0.2407083660364151,
-0.03673984482884407,
-0.3551274538040161,
0.40859922766685486,
-0.15367397665977478,
0.27253738045692444,
-0.23998555541038513,
0.5576319694519043,
-0.3286595344543457,
-0.28408876061439514,
0.28538352251052856,
0.8646628260612488,
0.1818457394838333,
0.036841899156570435,
-0.5434454679489136,
0.19362351298332214,
-0.05672410875558853,
-0.46975356340408325,
0.2613786458969116,
0.24967046082019806,
-0.04505670815706253,
0.2730002999305725,
0.5022698044776917,
0.20155103504657745,
0.5173441767692566,
0.37144383788108826,
0.6378201842308044,
-0.5898971557617188,
-0.5090001225471497,
-1.085094928741455,
0.4108103811740875,
0.07804083824157715,
-0.378274142742157,
0.6526622772216797,
0.23486541211605072,
0.9292322993278503,
0.07929748296737671,
0.34413355588912964,
0.024523932486772537,
-0.10306156426668167,
-0.5782191157341003,
0.3334854245185852,
-0.7706296443939209,
0.16794966161251068,
-0.2640590965747833,
-1.0422279834747314,
-0.5815629363059998,
1.2202143669128418,
-0.46419408917427063,
0.144090473651886,
0.7086585760116577,
0.4605497717857361,
-0.160210520029068,
-0.0027885078452527523,
0.34329694509506226,
-0.1686764359474182,
0.17676067352294922,
-0.026678668335080147,
1.1250965595245361,
-0.12213384360074997,
-0.06709001958370209,
-0.13203634321689606,
-0.17439164221286774,
-0.08526583760976791,
-0.7432648539543152,
-1.0131511688232422,
-0.5588762760162354,
-0.2667319178581238,
0.09215666353702545,
-0.11368931084871292,
1.1618225574493408,
0.712160587310791,
-0.4646046757698059,
-0.10066451877355576,
-0.06271544098854065,
0.10176830738782883,
0.08437789976596832,
-0.13828980922698975,
0.6608772873878479,
-0.4922308623790741,
-0.6212835907936096,
0.7173545360565186,
0.5538809299468994,
0.2237645834684372,
-0.12326495349407196,
-0.06767328083515167,
-0.19042973220348358,
0.01901557482779026,
0.5169274210929871,
-0.09511632472276688,
-0.805661141872406,
-0.5683705806732178,
-0.01987822726368904,
-0.08278780430555344,
0.1615370512008667,
0.8840229511260986,
-0.43621155619621277,
0.5645696520805359,
0.4421662390232086,
0.6083276867866516,
0.292319655418396,
0.020989827811717987,
0.09533697366714478,
-1.1652517318725586,
0.7211771607398987,
0.04934803768992424,
0.5656784772872925,
0.2998182475566864,
-0.0009267464629374444,
0.2820330858230591,
0.3846336603164673,
0.058186497539281845,
-0.81934654712677,
0.5236204862594604,
-0.5994743704795837,
-0.572658121585846,
1.129723310470581,
-0.31573158502578735,
-0.2007686346769333,
-0.21741452813148499,
0.2253587394952774,
0.45145249366760254,
0.35376763343811035,
0.568806529045105,
0.8197587132453918,
-0.06819932162761688,
0.31077706813812256,
-0.37589091062545776,
0.42556247115135193,
0.7552528977394104,
-0.45761755108833313,
-0.04879963770508766,
0.3904663026332855,
0.07817094773054123,
0.30209261178970337,
0.6807377338409424,
-0.19675606489181519,
-0.12556152045726776,
-0.015464706346392632,
-0.3299284875392914,
-0.1960269659757614,
-0.5253535509109497,
-0.34148314595222473,
0.29864808917045593,
0.14782139658927917,
-0.10348609834909439
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16891v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16891v1
|
Survey on Reasoning Capabilities and Accessibility of Large Language Models Using Biology-related Questions
| 2024-05-11T20:25:40 | 2024-05-11T20:25:40 |
Michael Ackerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This research paper discusses the advances made in the past decade in
biomedicine and Large Language Models. To understand how the advances have been
made hand-in-hand with one another, the paper also discusses the integration of
Natural Language Processing techniques and tools into biomedicine. Finally, the
goal of this paper is to expand on a survey conducted last year (2023) by
introducing a new list of questions and prompts for the top two language
models. Through this survey, this paper seeks to quantify the improvement made
in the reasoning abilities in LLMs and to what extent those improvements are
felt by the average user. Additionally, this paper seeks to extend research on
retrieval of biological literature by prompting the LLM to answer open-ended
questions in great depth.
|
[
-0.308688223361969,
-0.8545420169830322,
1.1161799430847168,
-0.20207606256008148,
0.0618780218064785,
-0.11823438853025436,
-0.2387484759092331,
-0.8739498853683472,
0.10681579262018204,
0.5956099033355713,
-0.33685755729675293,
-0.3343167006969452,
-0.6474339365959167,
0.5035550594329834,
-0.2669498324394226,
0.5272276997566223,
0.21773739159107208,
0.5926306247711182,
-0.5254913568496704,
-0.28803446888923645,
-0.00671353517100215,
-0.5885154008865356,
-0.5300134420394897,
-0.4190615117549896,
0.8018256425857544,
0.18660332262516022,
0.5845760107040405,
0.3916999101638794,
0.6956294178962708,
0.29693904519081116,
-0.54356849193573,
0.10093789547681808,
0.03607494384050369,
0.26078367233276367,
-0.5854341387748718,
-0.6090744137763977,
-0.6650393009185791,
-0.011403506621718407,
0.7201194167137146,
1.0342707633972168,
0.2689724862575531,
0.19928020238876343,
-0.08109661936759949,
0.6821626424789429,
-0.44339585304260254,
-0.013250622898340225,
-0.36912691593170166,
0.05980050563812256,
-0.09167678654193878,
-0.329023540019989,
-0.4741968512535095,
-0.4687612056732178,
0.3067956566810608,
-0.3001069724559784,
-0.06802760064601898,
-0.1651352196931839,
0.33094656467437744,
-0.04304361715912819,
-0.6206314563751221,
-0.482295960187912,
-0.5927541255950928,
0.81177818775177,
-0.9340564608573914,
0.6443743109703064,
0.4305570721626282,
0.24022871255874634,
-0.3221675157546997,
-0.7368760704994202,
-0.23140329122543335,
-0.6596429347991943,
0.03106807917356491,
-0.047486934810876846,
-0.3383430540561676,
0.12876346707344055,
0.3516557216644287,
0.3948897123336792,
-0.5491373538970947,
0.2522386312484741,
-0.45707768201828003,
-0.2243514358997345,
0.6082544326782227,
0.06887324154376984,
0.38036155700683594,
-0.0682806745171547,
0.12704382836818695,
0.09746649861335754,
-0.5599149465560913,
0.09879026561975479,
0.1267421543598175,
-0.00400641979649663,
0.3118782937526703,
0.8960998058319092,
-0.22525785863399506,
0.8761782050132751,
-0.5637272596359253,
-0.14312317967414856,
0.07543782889842987,
-0.7919896245002747,
-0.1686367243528366,
-0.36318695545196533,
0.39022716879844666,
0.3425564765930176,
0.057903505861759186,
0.059175338596105576,
0.162447988986969,
-0.4829559624195099,
0.12642882764339447,
-0.5665361881256104,
0.008938830345869064,
0.4769599735736847,
-0.6947866678237915,
-0.009361177682876587,
-0.25064530968666077,
-0.8402215242385864,
-0.6145538687705994,
-0.26515814661979675,
0.3039821982383728,
-0.2659582197666168,
-0.1943361610174179,
0.25234293937683105,
-0.25266870856285095,
0.4482753872871399,
0.5090868473052979,
-0.5802959203720093,
0.07185040414333344,
0.5565325617790222,
0.8277111649513245,
-0.23811979591846466,
0.16487623751163483,
-0.26249635219573975,
0.019670680165290833,
-0.11532918363809586,
1.0050911903381348,
-0.5116576552391052,
-0.5357983708381653,
-0.08885365724563599,
0.13190215826034546,
0.019685881212353706,
-0.7666788101196289,
0.2452608048915863,
-0.4371192455291748,
0.31931930780410767,
-0.5513783097267151,
-0.43005993962287903,
-0.3536982536315918,
0.31404778361320496,
-0.5725610256195068,
0.544364869594574,
-0.08166912198066711,
-0.7315669655799866,
0.02271098643541336,
-0.9136505722999573,
-0.19166849553585052,
0.17817041277885437,
-0.16735537350177765,
-0.18064093589782715,
-0.050628773868083954,
0.2804649770259857,
0.4643997550010681,
-0.5600869059562683,
0.4244566559791565,
-0.4855574369430542,
-0.07832327485084534,
0.7185607552528381,
-0.29827651381492615,
1.1465516090393066,
0.30408042669296265,
-0.023449569940567017,
0.20619738101959229,
-0.5989372730255127,
0.1026696190237999,
-0.09427737444639206,
-0.47568732500076294,
-0.27720582485198975,
0.005452497862279415,
-0.38560107350349426,
-0.08597123622894287,
0.4682091474533081,
-0.6970088481903076,
0.5976700782775879,
-0.4583962559700012,
0.7029978036880493,
0.22954407334327698,
0.17701371014118195,
0.504599928855896,
-0.2929326593875885,
0.57333904504776,
-0.17633777856826782,
0.23649412393569946,
-0.22085407376289368,
-0.7502014636993408,
-0.3985985219478607,
-0.0879475399851799,
0.21043837070465088,
0.5793958306312561,
-0.5572339296340942,
0.12847769260406494,
-0.020542893558740616,
-0.48646754026412964,
-0.3063433766365051,
0.040440768003463745,
0.030492737889289856,
0.571220874786377,
0.5185607075691223,
-0.18359622359275818,
-0.46876969933509827,
-0.9990232586860657,
-0.10206309705972672,
-0.4648440182209015,
-0.12352612614631653,
0.7511671781539917,
0.7082247734069824,
-0.36183497309684753,
0.7925094962120056,
-0.6609166264533997,
0.33000949025154114,
-0.5323018431663513,
-0.0478198304772377,
0.22514255344867706,
0.3828560411930084,
0.45538631081581116,
-0.7828900218009949,
0.14402884244918823,
0.13884639739990234,
-0.8347189426422119,
-0.33491143584251404,
0.3232120871543884,
-0.07447175681591034,
0.14268995821475983,
0.7218617796897888,
-0.6602312922477722,
0.3732525706291199,
0.4417736828327179,
-0.3145866394042969,
0.6522417068481445,
-0.27871862053871155,
0.3696900010108948,
-0.9580672383308411,
0.3631560802459717,
0.016352487727999687,
-0.04079720750451088,
-0.7721142172813416,
0.1724989414215088,
0.08102460950613022,
-0.07131262123584747,
-0.25863462686538696,
0.7520847320556641,
-0.5319643616676331,
-0.2665133476257324,
-0.1347571313381195,
-0.020907670259475708,
-0.0869087353348732,
-0.1359788030385971,
0.04381291940808296,
0.8055980205535889,
0.5834207534790039,
-0.7130517363548279,
0.3363801836967468,
0.1753833293914795,
-0.27152955532073975,
0.2624245882034302,
-0.6677141785621643,
-0.04805223271250725,
-0.22309276461601257,
0.490400105714798,
-1.084957480430603,
-0.49363118410110474,
0.3256233334541321,
-0.6674817204475403,
0.05709155276417732,
0.22432933747768402,
-0.2736639380455017,
-0.7708554267883301,
-0.17620089650154114,
0.38840252161026,
0.501210629940033,
-0.26581552624702454,
0.4564139246940613,
0.39173460006713867,
-0.44742849469184875,
-0.36696696281433105,
-0.8507280945777893,
0.15552356839179993,
-0.08185644447803497,
-0.5923337340354919,
-0.12165843695402145,
-0.3016287684440613,
-0.6201690435409546,
-0.21749556064605713,
-0.034353673458099365,
-0.23780198395252228,
0.03977577015757561,
-0.24029183387756348,
0.23069362342357635,
-0.3118659257888794,
0.4604281783103943,
0.031935326755046844,
0.2791267931461334,
0.3131380081176758,
-0.3775814175605774,
0.23148466646671295,
0.12207052111625671,
-0.4219302237033844,
-0.052043505012989044,
0.37598374485969543,
0.5107331275939941,
-0.40198415517807007,
0.5174121260643005,
0.21997147798538208,
-0.27280116081237793,
0.17192406952381134,
-0.6495664119720459,
-0.31934309005737305,
-0.37369483709335327,
0.4178881347179413,
0.10430850088596344,
-1.3286070823669434,
0.5255076289176941,
-0.2699729800224304,
0.02015623264014721,
0.25972920656204224,
0.5876872539520264,
-0.1988963931798935,
1.0658514499664307,
0.4008878469467163,
0.3780360519886017,
0.22588330507278442,
-0.1808863878250122,
0.08606767654418945,
-0.8765642642974854,
-0.5058659315109253,
-0.9510834813117981,
-0.12086396664381027,
-0.3724633753299713,
-0.8532262444496155,
0.5475985407829285,
0.029213309288024902,
-0.07641258090734482,
0.18539461493492126,
-0.44352954626083374,
0.13846172392368317,
0.4798734486103058,
0.3605688214302063,
0.4397163987159729,
-0.2965260446071625,
-0.44960764050483704,
0.30407798290252686,
-0.6568827033042908,
-0.5659606456756592,
0.9856829047203064,
0.5445478558540344,
0.4960608184337616,
0.3087424039840698,
0.4576480984687805,
0.030517246574163437,
0.3259693682193756,
-0.9397792816162109,
0.8190939426422119,
0.03574809804558754,
-0.9631252288818359,
-0.5998504757881165,
-0.5436829924583435,
-1.1629499197006226,
0.17750553786754608,
-0.008834166452288628,
-1.0078232288360596,
0.3281990885734558,
0.06988999247550964,
-0.17005863785743713,
0.46224918961524963,
-0.46408164501190186,
0.5349283218383789,
-0.38292309641838074,
-0.31177499890327454,
-0.09860953688621521,
-0.7344560027122498,
0.48701268434524536,
0.01947038620710373,
0.23221667110919952,
-0.005290172062814236,
-0.20217260718345642,
0.6326864361763,
-0.2076616883277893,
0.6010786294937134,
-0.056189365684986115,
-0.2725580036640167,
0.49116724729537964,
-0.16305747628211975,
0.02044692263007164,
0.06545423716306686,
-0.3145836293697357,
0.029334217309951782,
0.15059088170528412,
-0.4662105441093445,
-0.49945390224456787,
0.5512098670005798,
-0.3627290725708008,
-0.9504769444465637,
-0.43469247221946716,
-0.7066136598587036,
-0.40614596009254456,
0.1339484602212906,
0.08354745805263519,
0.35687148571014404,
0.0019135840702801943,
0.5838123559951782,
0.881657600402832,
-0.9257240891456604,
0.39570945501327515,
0.6623361110687256,
-0.5999799370765686,
-0.4122423827648163,
0.3210543096065521,
0.23287145793437958,
0.34033438563346863,
0.46650126576423645,
0.33192870020866394,
-0.5738797783851624,
-0.732418417930603,
-0.351061075925827,
0.46012526750564575,
-0.5818859934806824,
-0.15481048822402954,
-0.8447473049163818,
-0.21452836692333221,
-0.6626842617988586,
-0.03111892007291317,
0.23697413504123688,
-0.4303397834300995,
-0.40119659900665283,
-0.0686148852109909,
0.5097901225090027,
0.8568692803382874,
-0.06973844021558762,
-0.04575891047716141,
-0.8669809103012085,
0.14940789341926575,
0.30891090631484985,
0.31302133202552795,
0.05756973475217819,
-0.4811853766441345,
-0.1529802680015564,
-0.0313773974776268,
-0.17273865640163422,
-1.3558871746063232,
0.3570067584514618,
-0.11685527861118317,
0.8234296441078186,
0.06353235244750977,
-0.42546284198760986,
0.34545597434043884,
-0.21614590287208557,
1.0939269065856934,
0.04049837216734886,
-0.43744751811027527,
0.7241373062133789,
-0.58674556016922,
0.7559263110160828,
0.40956851840019226,
0.7437654137611389,
-0.2952738106250763,
-0.23411136865615845,
-0.3797989785671234,
-0.5290061831474304,
0.35502442717552185,
-0.05739293247461319,
-0.19532935321331024,
0.04619188979268074,
0.48994180560112,
0.04544075205922127,
0.020249029621481895,
-0.4785965383052826,
-0.04458121955394745,
0.26504936814308167,
0.04473717883229256,
-0.0736939013004303,
-0.23811058700084686,
0.03925188258290291,
-0.7928133606910706,
0.46421757340431213,
-0.34537461400032043,
0.3956560790538788,
0.3811914026737213,
-0.0044489349238574505,
0.013298158533871174,
0.7352628111839294,
0.5723167657852173,
0.8897080421447754,
-0.1571587771177292,
0.10877580940723419,
0.4488685131072998,
-0.5202968120574951,
0.19334760308265686,
0.1956155151128769,
-0.12020362168550491,
-0.24723778665065765,
0.5564424395561218,
0.3220033347606659,
0.17674626410007477,
-1.0300965309143066,
0.2613409757614136,
0.19882237911224365,
-0.40630462765693665,
-0.05285755172371864,
0.10487483441829681,
0.5588334202766418,
0.4640572965145111,
0.4627440273761749,
-0.07815408706665039,
0.5200846195220947,
-0.6754283308982849,
0.05160824954509735,
0.5360689759254456,
-0.2794133722782135,
0.03406640887260437,
0.6582010984420776,
-0.050364065915346146,
-0.2083740234375,
0.350140780210495,
0.18753986060619354,
-0.2953774034976959,
0.7621906399726868,
0.6359520554542542,
0.6045131087303162,
-0.28192031383514404,
0.24931767582893372,
0.5157202482223511,
0.07857849448919296,
-0.21157501637935638,
0.5898481011390686,
0.003078479552641511,
-0.5491109490394592,
-0.6456438899040222,
-0.6687334775924683,
-0.7254923582077026,
0.3712611496448517,
-0.5928311347961426,
0.02162800170481205,
-0.31564465165138245,
-0.4044755697250366,
0.31278401613235474,
-0.03753044828772545,
-0.3119989037513733,
0.21815229952335358,
-0.02134372666478157,
1.2826848030090332,
-0.41950446367263794,
0.8481724262237549,
1.2280853986740112,
-0.5253943204879761,
-0.5328709483146667,
-0.15826909244060516,
-0.0003402257279958576,
-0.5464733839035034,
0.6771814227104187,
0.04079439863562584,
-0.0296291746199131,
-0.10522201657295227,
-0.9434718489646912,
-0.9624029397964478,
1.1842129230499268,
0.17819486558437347,
-0.4833611249923706,
-0.03842656686902046,
0.03297009691596031,
0.8304092288017273,
-0.21261173486709595,
0.3517201840877533,
0.6445748209953308,
0.6344748139381409,
0.12001410126686096,
-1.0326670408248901,
-0.2324461042881012,
-0.2898895740509033,
-0.1739557534456253,
0.09972893446683884,
-0.4315347373485565,
0.8141850829124451,
-0.2365178018808365,
0.010005025193095207,
0.4043467938899994,
0.6039742231369019,
0.33881038427352905,
0.6963939070701599,
0.19485746324062347,
0.3065722584724426,
0.8585183024406433,
-0.121893510222435,
1.0997841358184814,
0.0723484456539154,
0.0026022850070148706,
0.6639671325683594,
-0.21965600550174713,
0.8141499161720276,
0.40821030735969543,
-0.4959791898727417,
0.4078714847564697,
0.4474199712276459,
0.06362101435661316,
-0.1267356425523758,
0.37156665325164795,
-0.46812716126441956,
-0.3043496310710907,
-0.3312964141368866,
-0.47873440384864807,
0.35561853647232056,
0.5640674233436584,
-0.7369815707206726,
-0.04399554803967476,
0.3291809558868408,
-0.10414266586303711,
0.17987455427646637,
-0.5068181753158569,
0.7907799482345581,
0.18260203301906586,
-0.6555516123771667,
0.15700848400592804,
-0.11787619441747665,
0.5567201375961304,
-0.6703856587409973,
-0.12259433418512344,
-0.313007652759552,
-0.15333355963230133,
-0.12558676302433014,
-1.146899938583374,
0.23195785284042358,
0.0695253238081932,
-0.06641218811273575,
-0.09447049349546432,
1.0766183137893677,
-0.34913530945777893,
-0.4253583252429962,
0.32917603850364685,
0.8477224111557007,
0.45637840032577515,
0.324540913105011,
-0.5416728854179382,
0.1056160256266594,
0.031949710100889206,
-0.18347199261188507,
0.25966325402259827,
0.18812766671180725,
-0.17004328966140747,
1.0371752977371216,
0.5530417561531067,
0.40619486570358276,
-0.05357413366436958,
-0.06121382862329483,
0.8475838303565979,
-0.9377464056015015,
0.07079914212226868,
-0.712092399597168,
0.18832479417324066,
-0.1508924514055252,
-0.15609309077262878,
0.6349810361862183,
0.5716427564620972,
0.5640751123428345,
-0.16897305846214294,
0.8590654134750366,
-0.07069563120603561,
0.9285066723823547,
-0.4694550335407257,
0.5567764639854431,
-0.6804468035697937,
0.21374763548374176,
-0.24727557599544525,
-0.7652768492698669,
-0.61225426197052,
0.4581831097602844,
-0.6427509784698486,
0.235792875289917,
0.8563886284828186,
0.8400387763977051,
0.18975499272346497,
0.18474538624286652,
0.2937600314617157,
0.3785962760448456,
0.26287463307380676,
0.47940126061439514,
0.8964900374412537,
0.015370429493486881,
0.24928981065750122,
0.09102803468704224,
-0.2647750675678253,
-0.20966435968875885,
-0.9207879304885864,
-0.658383309841156,
-0.46456632018089294,
-0.1698949784040451,
-0.3294392228126526,
0.2405208796262741,
0.9527012705802917,
0.23472444713115692,
-0.9290306568145752,
-0.20672984421253204,
0.06146414950489998,
0.12715309858322144,
-0.002022861735895276,
-0.16539114713668823,
0.1752714067697525,
-0.10490702092647552,
-0.6620644927024841,
0.5336845517158508,
0.4563296139240265,
0.19264812767505646,
-0.5227343440055847,
0.03668780252337456,
-0.6177181601524353,
0.29213717579841614,
0.8321725726127625,
0.6012039184570312,
-0.6840003728866577,
-0.20625846087932587,
0.4113208055496216,
-0.25021931529045105,
0.009361863136291504,
0.8716974258422852,
-0.6856542229652405,
0.37825527787208557,
0.8007882833480835,
0.7786416411399841,
0.18669822812080383,
-0.04611625522375107,
0.6697519421577454,
-0.10321196913719177,
-0.3052057921886444,
0.28274616599082947,
0.35048723220825195,
0.42023488879203796,
-0.31295180320739746,
0.7310274839401245,
0.18418706953525543,
-0.8550018072128296,
-0.7101085782051086,
0.23558750748634338,
-1.1296463012695312,
-0.6678656935691833,
1.3851611614227295,
0.11705239862203598,
-0.04159761965274811,
-0.3314002752304077,
-0.4830397665500641,
0.21587678790092468,
-0.042729850858449936,
0.3218749463558197,
0.815581738948822,
-0.6510909199714661,
-0.37396982312202454,
-0.8503864407539368,
0.3051980435848236,
0.41327962279319763,
-1.254729151725769,
-0.15414895117282867,
0.8071555495262146,
0.16813085973262787,
-0.016888681799173355,
0.6918997764587402,
-0.5397919416427612,
0.2716912627220154,
-0.38109469413757324,
-0.16888834536075592,
0.15340441465377808,
-0.22074830532073975,
-0.5259506702423096,
0.18470962345600128,
0.44689619541168213,
0.570275068283081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07081v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07081v1
|
T-curator: a trust based curation tool for LOD logs
| 2024-05-11T19:32:27 | 2024-05-11T19:32:27 |
Dihia Lanasri
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL
|
Nowadays, companies are racing towards Linked Open Data (LOD) to improve
their added value, but they are ignoring their SPARQL query logs. If well
curated, these logs can present an asset for decision makers. A naive and
straightforward use of these logs is too risky because their provenance and
quality are highly questionable. Users of these logs in a trusted way have to
be assisted by providing them with in-depth knowledge of the whole LOD
environment and tools to curate these logs. In this paper, we propose an
interactive and intuitive trust based tool that can be used to curate these LOD
logs before exploiting them. This tool is proposed to support our approach
proposed in our previous work Lanasri et al. [2020].
|
[
-0.24138809740543365,
-0.7470864653587341,
0.637584924697876,
-0.14714309573173523,
-0.5957338809967041,
0.24133548140525818,
0.41253313422203064,
-0.6768860220909119,
0.5269073843955994,
0.7830762267112732,
-0.684044361114502,
-0.9699804782867432,
-0.4978291392326355,
-0.23354370892047882,
-0.7144067883491516,
1.4838082790374756,
0.21157699823379517,
-0.5175651907920837,
-0.29541024565696716,
-0.38447096943855286,
-0.28210878372192383,
-0.1967158317565918,
-0.869753360748291,
-0.19759200513362885,
0.5690939426422119,
0.20535294711589813,
1.0581542253494263,
0.5597720146179199,
0.37464088201522827,
0.14420822262763977,
-0.1388615518808365,
0.377434104681015,
-1.0075602531433105,
0.5642545819282532,
-0.7860726118087769,
-0.38644975423812866,
-0.7246861457824707,
0.07666964083909988,
0.08404365181922913,
0.491142213344574,
-0.051477495580911636,
0.4401332437992096,
-0.20767392218112946,
0.37834152579307556,
-0.6227115392684937,
0.10692291706800461,
-0.5955764651298523,
0.4170355796813965,
-0.4967842698097229,
-0.4225853681564331,
-0.4096720814704895,
-0.5076709985733032,
0.2805619239807129,
-0.8441188335418701,
0.13564792275428772,
0.709703266620636,
0.6728933453559875,
0.24010871350765228,
-0.41035035252571106,
-0.11686164885759354,
-0.5735180377960205,
0.5779181122779846,
-0.36150306463241577,
0.32159772515296936,
0.5135878920555115,
0.3148419260978699,
-0.024639969691634178,
-0.8756535649299622,
-0.20407778024673462,
0.09427943080663681,
-0.3653813898563385,
-0.18012098968029022,
0.0973130390048027,
-0.46771323680877686,
0.19573482871055603,
0.688879132270813,
-0.4145655930042267,
0.30505725741386414,
-0.13587410748004913,
-0.2777365446090698,
0.6054955124855042,
0.3780094385147095,
0.08533001691102982,
0.10715855658054352,
-0.529862642288208,
-0.20153452455997467,
-0.9226734638214111,
-0.11977750808000565,
0.35433855652809143,
0.050013456493616104,
0.06838153302669525,
0.936766505241394,
-0.33988380432128906,
0.7199206948280334,
0.37998443841934204,
-0.0064132628031075,
0.0054471613839268684,
-0.37539348006248474,
-0.10189396888017654,
0.26807233691215515,
0.8765707612037659,
0.45715951919555664,
-0.009818392805755138,
-0.42229753732681274,
-0.13193866610527039,
-0.12425395101308823,
0.2724144756793976,
-0.6740443706512451,
-0.26918455958366394,
0.4927741289138794,
-0.4354532063007355,
-0.7810565829277039,
0.5653679966926575,
-0.9028499126434326,
-0.8049887418746948,
0.36358487606048584,
0.4960249960422516,
-0.25560665130615234,
-0.3965369462966919,
0.27686744928359985,
-0.31961697340011597,
-0.271964967250824,
0.3892737329006195,
-0.25755465030670166,
0.14043661952018738,
0.729343056678772,
0.7515688538551331,
-0.5255448222160339,
0.07827138155698776,
-1.433389663696289,
0.7514973878860474,
-0.10638384521007538,
0.47088176012039185,
-0.5530171394348145,
-0.9920721650123596,
0.14320679008960724,
-0.06439425051212311,
0.5287989377975464,
-0.22745339572429657,
0.8193685412406921,
-0.9395058751106262,
0.460403710603714,
-0.09344613552093506,
-0.5511228442192078,
-0.002554516075178981,
0.39799943566322327,
-1.0778753757476807,
1.2216416597366333,
0.4235687851905823,
-1.0639265775680542,
0.542270839214325,
-0.9455716013908386,
-0.18070311844348907,
0.21987584233283997,
0.127985879778862,
-0.4315144419670105,
-0.052599359303712845,
0.3460477292537689,
0.4477006494998932,
-0.013524837791919708,
0.30610334873199463,
-0.6623512506484985,
-0.01443188451230526,
0.25091731548309326,
0.06565647572278976,
1.0779085159301758,
0.4137415289878845,
-0.04322584345936775,
0.04169480502605438,
-0.4135769009590149,
0.13138167560100555,
-0.09130854904651642,
0.13670915365219116,
-0.4997534453868866,
0.016154911369085312,
-0.008504045195877552,
-0.016982968896627426,
0.40071672201156616,
-0.66495281457901,
0.12175602465867996,
-0.1489017754793167,
0.14884375035762787,
0.856907069683075,
0.4402908980846405,
0.21877631545066833,
-0.3164638578891754,
0.5341575145721436,
0.41239801049232483,
0.447693794965744,
0.05183021351695061,
-0.39038291573524475,
-0.5253785848617554,
0.09784602373838425,
0.11477506905794144,
0.18516768515110016,
-0.5191653370857239,
0.5596250295639038,
-0.4747834801673889,
-0.7653616070747375,
-0.5608872175216675,
0.09130486100912094,
0.3899248242378235,
0.569783627986908,
0.1865852177143097,
-0.8241018652915955,
0.032312799245119095,
-0.5217530727386475,
-0.23409274220466614,
-0.23730632662773132,
-0.13042156398296356,
0.4692738354206085,
0.22148707509040833,
-0.1212008148431778,
1.1534775495529175,
-0.8897317051887512,
-0.528738260269165,
0.352212518453598,
-0.06684265285730362,
0.27412039041519165,
0.4914802610874176,
0.4889586269855499,
-0.6915530562400818,
-0.4391247034072876,
0.30885085463523865,
-0.7684264779090881,
-0.08297158777713776,
0.34320908784866333,
-0.6840548515319824,
0.09109202027320862,
0.35158494114875793,
-0.9011303782463074,
0.6213419437408447,
0.46037471294403076,
-1.1278342008590698,
0.5940383076667786,
0.2269635647535324,
0.21639320254325867,
-0.9965581893920898,
0.1158338189125061,
-0.2862471342086792,
-0.5595934987068176,
-0.205063596367836,
0.2847006916999817,
-0.12592415511608124,
-0.3357415497303009,
-0.41519197821617126,
0.7110103368759155,
-0.16947948932647705,
-0.22554320096969604,
0.4905968904495239,
0.4404599666595459,
0.40153083205223083,
-0.06880893558263779,
0.07927154004573822,
0.30708256363868713,
0.6260388493537903,
-0.47664299607276917,
0.5699235200881958,
0.7131184339523315,
-0.31038400530815125,
1.2010514736175537,
-0.662976861000061,
0.19361512362957,
0.3201284110546112,
0.18187500536441803,
-0.5372514724731445,
0.0037676289211958647,
0.37516847252845764,
-0.536153256893158,
0.2563978135585785,
-0.4862079322338104,
-0.5078998804092407,
-0.10618788003921509,
-0.3430490791797638,
0.2661471366882324,
0.29941391944885254,
-0.8381880521774292,
0.5971642732620239,
0.28832241892814636,
0.17035265266895294,
-0.4402666687965393,
-0.5180336236953735,
0.020620673894882202,
-0.5181993842124939,
-0.9371697902679443,
0.24324356019496918,
-0.2889424264431,
-0.5742626786231995,
0.5490890741348267,
-0.4985397756099701,
-0.15921145677566528,
-0.05858249589800835,
0.5492979884147644,
0.21338944137096405,
-0.27097100019454956,
-0.046653930097818375,
-0.047841377556324005,
-0.10567605495452881,
0.20138312876224518,
-0.6497766971588135,
0.19053557515144348,
0.14336276054382324,
-0.915359377861023,
-0.4206673502922058,
0.18248002231121063,
0.7697770595550537,
-0.4367620646953583,
0.8979430198669434,
0.8196269273757935,
-0.000767256657127291,
-0.2554381191730499,
-0.7254611849784851,
-0.24329817295074463,
-0.5209763646125793,
-0.33391278982162476,
-0.11659862846136093,
-1.0588706731796265,
0.395470529794693,
-0.04690320044755936,
0.11578506976366043,
0.4222356379032135,
0.21153555810451508,
-0.10454932600259781,
0.5565186738967896,
0.42041128873825073,
-0.15035651624202728,
0.20770135521888733,
-0.20989112555980682,
0.43193286657333374,
-0.6599559783935547,
-0.6776893734931946,
-0.6057644486427307,
-0.16293886303901672,
-0.35903435945510864,
-0.41256892681121826,
0.6852399706840515,
-0.06118595600128174,
-0.14677836000919342,
0.008015358820557594,
-0.31554916501045227,
0.4431690573692322,
0.6044500470161438,
0.4242662787437439,
0.93752521276474,
-0.2167896181344986,
0.23160365223884583,
0.3674985468387604,
-0.26456940174102783,
-0.36455121636390686,
1.131341576576233,
-0.05513925477862358,
1.1383377313613892,
0.08390378952026367,
0.9080563187599182,
0.8665728569030762,
-0.026208942756056786,
-0.6420193910598755,
0.37240415811538696,
0.2756254971027374,
-0.7180264592170715,
-0.5287620425224304,
0.023376816883683205,
-0.710048496723175,
-0.007936332374811172,
-0.31499359011650085,
-0.7004440426826477,
0.11169879138469696,
0.30133262276649475,
-0.17150527238845825,
0.6968418955802917,
-0.671313464641571,
0.6789313554763794,
-0.00934910774230957,
-0.7609573006629944,
-0.3683275282382965,
-0.4530269205570221,
0.2186739295721054,
-0.2680492699146271,
0.034528616815805435,
0.23571430146694183,
-0.023002732545137405,
0.5337947010993958,
-0.6766307353973389,
0.7133095860481262,
-0.39197874069213867,
-0.04049258306622505,
0.2960939109325409,
0.8768566250801086,
1.081823706626892,
0.5582746267318726,
-0.37257590889930725,
0.0036195851862430573,
0.2035510540008545,
-0.31773608922958374,
-0.5080694556236267,
0.900231659412384,
-0.4634457528591156,
-0.8485850095748901,
-0.3313046097755432,
-0.2066953033208847,
-0.37944138050079346,
0.45567792654037476,
-0.2183549404144287,
0.26459193229675293,
-0.6297757029533386,
0.5510690808296204,
0.9844875931739807,
-0.15435828268527985,
0.09494408220052719,
0.45004865527153015,
-0.351392924785614,
0.09217854589223862,
0.28022685647010803,
-0.589914858341217,
0.35985976457595825,
0.3161940574645996,
0.20131996273994446,
-0.3694956600666046,
-0.5631247162818909,
-0.26534539461135864,
-0.0219234861433506,
-0.43812012672424316,
-0.5305941700935364,
-0.6820970177650452,
0.045625239610672,
-0.15380388498306274,
-0.2732047736644745,
-0.21662543714046478,
-0.7244375348091125,
-0.29952239990234375,
-0.6697108745574951,
1.0267844200134277,
0.6380392909049988,
0.15667501091957092,
0.22344860434532166,
-0.7839404940605164,
0.191937655210495,
0.3467811942100525,
0.7517459392547607,
-0.15698769688606262,
-0.03997126966714859,
-0.3757574260234833,
0.1023593470454216,
-0.20672418177127838,
-0.43886318802833557,
0.43694084882736206,
0.05431990697979927,
0.46112704277038574,
0.9103840589523315,
0.557071328163147,
0.41761815547943115,
-0.021622184664011,
1.1380069255828857,
-0.07758788764476776,
-0.7755680680274963,
0.8246253728866577,
-0.6558107733726501,
-0.39730459451675415,
0.32143113017082214,
0.4809403419494629,
-0.36108049750328064,
-0.5185272693634033,
-0.914496123790741,
-0.30774742364883423,
0.7372530102729797,
0.05681420490145683,
-0.24753111600875854,
0.11557695269584656,
-0.027298087254166603,
0.7132379412651062,
0.29780712723731995,
-0.3634892702102661,
-0.09502654522657394,
-0.5466908812522888,
0.22335104644298553,
-0.07832861691713333,
-0.37239959836006165,
-0.5231583118438721,
0.17955097556114197,
0.6345323920249939,
0.10137482732534409,
-0.14663265645503998,
0.15204854309558868,
-0.08472686260938644,
-0.3448776304721832,
0.10756983608007431,
-0.4406070411205292,
0.817472517490387,
-0.5741861462593079,
-0.05420234426856041,
-0.14358077943325043,
-0.2796662747859955,
-0.4945741295814514,
-0.3656352162361145,
-0.21016158163547516,
-0.07055112719535828,
0.0900026187300682,
0.6621270775794983,
0.05088851973414421,
-0.5621677041053772,
0.5436314344406128,
0.28873446583747864,
0.016649825498461723,
-0.3427284061908722,
0.1992310881614685,
0.15131309628486633,
0.3383346199989319,
-0.0241691991686821,
-0.0913945734500885,
0.22307971119880676,
-0.3786640167236328,
0.07595314085483551,
0.4331367313861847,
-0.5546407103538513,
-0.3503834009170532,
0.7027685046195984,
0.3107415735721588,
-0.26779085397720337,
1.0236114263534546,
0.01678795926272869,
-0.038780421018600464,
0.0671374648809433,
0.44823509454727173,
0.8593117594718933,
0.012019746005535126,
0.3610808253288269,
0.1267903447151184,
0.08132629841566086,
0.1866614818572998,
0.010335840284824371,
0.04079700633883476,
-0.7627162933349609,
-0.18446798622608185,
-0.6688732504844666,
-0.5754595994949341,
-0.14042401313781738,
-1.092387080192566,
0.2624663710594177,
-0.39201322197914124,
-0.08796916902065277,
-0.30801889300346375,
0.05544712021946907,
-0.8375242948532104,
0.057045724242925644,
-0.6638838052749634,
1.1646673679351807,
-0.860407829284668,
0.8722125887870789,
0.3236348032951355,
-0.30040010809898376,
-0.26431265473365784,
-0.4937454164028168,
0.11152659356594086,
-1.0057668685913086,
0.5299383997917175,
-0.47181734442710876,
-0.21300959587097168,
-0.03150845319032669,
-0.6600717306137085,
-0.5088938474655151,
1.3788262605667114,
-0.24378903210163116,
0.07861359417438507,
0.2456456869840622,
-0.10498295724391937,
0.7079414129257202,
-0.34867796301841736,
-0.15534399449825287,
0.1565861701965332,
0.6843149662017822,
0.24927739799022675,
-0.8248397707939148,
0.32276153564453125,
-0.17364387214183807,
-0.31222137808799744,
0.3464742600917816,
-0.44751834869384766,
0.4956856071949005,
-0.21841786801815033,
-0.17965136468410492,
-0.03856820985674858,
0.30258116126060486,
0.11128617823123932,
0.5613566040992737,
0.5825259685516357,
0.9414907693862915,
0.6969084143638611,
0.0347573384642601,
1.1298644542694092,
-0.03740617632865906,
0.2148914486169815,
1.24150812625885,
-0.27616584300994873,
0.7092642188072205,
0.7012161612510681,
-0.12281447649002075,
0.6955373287200928,
0.3209629952907562,
-0.2062382698059082,
0.5522721409797668,
-0.34559592604637146,
-0.40295520424842834,
-0.4202874004840851,
-0.7379926443099976,
-0.39018359780311584,
0.05073375999927521,
0.6309389472007751,
-0.3524259626865387,
-0.17038016021251678,
-0.6517771482467651,
0.0206635519862175,
0.1318603903055191,
-0.34911516308784485,
0.6284915804862976,
-0.02146969549357891,
-0.4723106920719147,
-0.15054215490818024,
-0.3328905701637268,
0.43858712911605835,
-0.6650722622871399,
-0.0054238783195614815,
-0.1417645961046219,
-0.2875443398952484,
-0.6013630628585815,
-1.2907427549362183,
0.423439621925354,
-0.3337598741054535,
0.07672914862632751,
-0.5347751379013062,
0.7485710382461548,
-0.18003635108470917,
0.2549586594104767,
0.1972435861825943,
0.8819265961647034,
-0.0005607981001958251,
-0.18787826597690582,
-0.2057991772890091,
-0.020018531009554863,
0.06434433907270432,
-0.08075585961341858,
0.3453788161277771,
0.842396080493927,
-0.3565181791782379,
1.0638586282730103,
0.9579856991767883,
0.10741186141967773,
-0.11059429496526718,
-0.11256573349237442,
0.8571164011955261,
-0.530257523059845,
-0.5817728638648987,
-0.49074235558509827,
0.42615363001823425,
-0.4232933223247528,
0.039480142295360565,
0.7328439950942993,
0.5391775965690613,
1.1155978441238403,
-0.4216133654117584,
0.5009185671806335,
-0.33497896790504456,
0.6679359674453735,
-0.5120786428451538,
0.8279303908348083,
-0.2965945899486542,
0.20742623507976532,
-0.2047242522239685,
-0.920684814453125,
-0.09961000084877014,
0.18913792073726654,
0.09378186613321304,
-0.34091630578041077,
0.8616979718208313,
1.0637575387954712,
-0.32689905166625977,
0.22893747687339783,
0.09178279340267181,
0.34906697273254395,
0.3555239737033844,
0.25944679975509644,
0.604937732219696,
-0.19314627349376678,
0.7650434970855713,
-0.24670657515525818,
0.10464619100093842,
-0.22869586944580078,
-1.321946620941162,
-1.15663480758667,
-0.4841771423816681,
-0.3480689525604248,
-0.5096371173858643,
0.033010244369506836,
0.48597827553749084,
0.6621850728988647,
-0.8077622056007385,
0.01799766533076763,
0.40293943881988525,
0.46791812777519226,
-0.16532185673713684,
-0.2855660319328308,
0.6223154067993164,
0.3792131245136261,
-0.4351654052734375,
0.1611521691083908,
0.283799946308136,
-0.02242904156446457,
-0.3055481016635895,
-0.10072166472673416,
0.10282692313194275,
-0.5309338569641113,
0.6773654222488403,
0.09527293592691422,
-0.5048826932907104,
-0.5185250043869019,
-0.2564927339553833,
0.33348673582077026,
-0.23330987989902496,
0.6595509648323059,
-0.939389169216156,
0.5455331802368164,
0.5124552249908447,
0.4645117521286011,
1.025968313217163,
0.18335239589214325,
0.5633966326713562,
-0.7015469670295715,
-0.11134660243988037,
0.2551478147506714,
0.1584341824054718,
0.2540617287158966,
-0.8101567029953003,
0.9663528203964233,
0.055350229144096375,
-0.28583648800849915,
-0.7701666355133057,
0.25530266761779785,
-1.4988149404525757,
0.27638670802116394,
0.8424168229103088,
-0.3318360149860382,
0.0515085905790329,
-0.32392340898513794,
-0.22946707904338837,
-0.1813637763261795,
-0.7980821132659912,
0.8708350658416748,
0.5354695916175842,
0.06880035251379013,
0.2491481602191925,
-0.23107247054576874,
0.5613091588020325,
-0.0998469814658165,
-0.6865254044532776,
-0.13380420207977295,
0.8324381113052368,
0.3685753047466278,
0.05877082422375679,
0.5195080637931824,
-0.7165610194206238,
-0.06613770127296448,
-0.09105537086725235,
-0.5037795901298523,
-0.4949093163013458,
-0.0023753514979034662,
0.45671164989471436,
0.2960911691188812,
0.3428671061992645,
-0.02328944392502308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07076v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07076v2
|
Integrating Emotional and Linguistic Models for Ethical Compliance in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-11T19:26:00 | 2024-05-14T03:08:12 |
Edward Y. Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
This research develops advanced methodologies for Large Language Models
(LLMs) to better manage linguistic behaviors related to emotions and ethics. We
introduce DIKE, an adversarial framework that enhances the LLMs' ability to
internalize and reflect global human values, adapting to varied cultural
contexts to promote transparency and trust among users. The methodology
involves detailed modeling of emotions, classification of linguistic behaviors,
and implementation of ethical guardrails. Our innovative approaches include
mapping emotions and behaviors using self-supervised learning techniques,
refining these guardrails through adversarial reviews, and systematically
adjusting outputs to ensure ethical alignment. This framework establishes a
robust foundation for AI systems to operate with ethical integrity and cultural
sensitivity, paving the way for more responsible and context-aware AI
interactions.
|
[
-0.3038302958011627,
-0.7992788553237915,
0.5723053812980652,
0.09536902606487274,
-0.017855525016784668,
0.2704254388809204,
-0.24179065227508545,
-0.39573100209236145,
-0.17472483217716217,
0.5616583228111267,
-0.6595200300216675,
-0.4070081412792206,
-0.723593533039093,
0.1538635641336441,
-0.3613630533218384,
0.9770691394805908,
0.13122132420539856,
0.2863951325416565,
0.09435310959815979,
-0.20747411251068115,
0.021959858015179634,
-0.7405151128768921,
-0.6996513605117798,
-0.53362637758255,
0.4298827350139618,
0.10180195420980453,
0.8029844760894775,
0.6181319355964661,
0.5907823443412781,
0.4141215980052948,
-0.28792157769203186,
-0.1948297768831253,
-0.7004022002220154,
0.04099617898464203,
-0.5198706984519958,
-0.2897757887840271,
-0.5123586058616638,
0.255526065826416,
0.16412946581840515,
0.2950107455253601,
-0.5424759387969971,
0.052508044987916946,
-0.005209056194871664,
0.7561116218566895,
-0.569878876209259,
0.08058270812034607,
-0.45490166544914246,
0.11304217576980591,
0.03099692054092884,
-0.24820581078529358,
-0.40637925267219543,
-0.4332023859024048,
0.0035573039203882217,
-0.7045032382011414,
-0.5912005305290222,
0.006864254362881184,
0.559001624584198,
0.7380622625350952,
-0.8586714863777161,
-0.8106516003608704,
-0.5195010304450989,
0.9546354413032532,
-0.8934329748153687,
0.08627739548683167,
0.5675159096717834,
-0.14521299302577972,
-0.3284413814544678,
-0.5777754783630371,
-0.8127511143684387,
-0.1882629692554474,
-0.05579511821269989,
0.18149912357330322,
-0.315219521522522,
0.2026752531528473,
0.19560065865516663,
0.2449510395526886,
-0.16681161522865295,
0.40022873878479004,
-0.04335317388176918,
0.03686064854264259,
0.9397647380828857,
0.3203493058681488,
0.6357473134994507,
-0.07223574817180634,
-0.13530099391937256,
-0.1668819636106491,
-0.6769139170646667,
0.013248785398900509,
0.8161278963088989,
0.055752236396074295,
-0.20338821411132812,
0.25876384973526,
-0.09949296712875366,
0.312751829624176,
0.09244948625564575,
0.10894037038087845,
0.16297602653503418,
-0.03159772977232933,
-0.25791600346565247,
0.2689230442047119,
0.9104071855545044,
0.5518803596496582,
0.6640264987945557,
0.22618256509304047,
0.034377407282590866,
0.18501248955726624,
0.5204542875289917,
-0.7336645126342773,
-0.1566123366355896,
0.42090895771980286,
-0.5265355110168457,
-0.8366104364395142,
-0.23190882802009583,
-0.9762115478515625,
-0.8076008558273315,
-0.7466911673545837,
0.24033798277378082,
-0.46168026328086853,
-0.695201575756073,
0.353034645318985,
0.19790008664131165,
0.23892667889595032,
0.29150134325027466,
-0.7917922735214233,
0.3001926839351654,
0.8345638513565063,
0.5104824304580688,
0.26751893758773804,
-0.27807754278182983,
-0.4427698850631714,
0.16665984690189362,
-0.5297552943229675,
-0.18283995985984802,
-0.8674194812774658,
-0.45803385972976685,
0.15352974832057953,
0.021720601245760918,
0.3625170886516571,
-0.06429552286863327,
0.44843098521232605,
-0.6775930523872375,
0.22302010655403137,
-0.38974422216415405,
-0.5537815690040588,
-0.5145100951194763,
0.2714928090572357,
-0.43209707736968994,
0.8083203434944153,
0.050311166793107986,
-0.6735278964042664,
0.10630329698324203,
-0.9738057851791382,
-0.555813729763031,
0.11163567006587982,
-0.12054693698883057,
-0.19207018613815308,
0.21339647471904755,
-0.10394208133220673,
0.5481894612312317,
-0.3029242157936096,
0.42808908224105835,
-0.45313629508018494,
-0.20565874874591827,
0.2425888329744339,
-0.31516921520233154,
1.3354617357254028,
0.5360671877861023,
-0.6259359121322632,
0.16222552955150604,
-0.5881510376930237,
-0.06629028916358948,
0.2738594710826874,
-0.10428156703710556,
-0.6996617913246155,
0.12181534618139267,
0.10703207552433014,
0.23974141478538513,
0.2935003340244293,
-0.3520277142524719,
0.14096829295158386,
-0.14352677762508392,
0.7137312293052673,
1.2611795663833618,
-0.18009844422340393,
0.5026277899742126,
-0.057056427001953125,
0.5142675042152405,
-0.1268075853586197,
0.287141889333725,
0.22876286506652832,
0.029325302690267563,
-0.5914005041122437,
-0.3612055480480194,
-0.12767651677131653,
0.6384734511375427,
-0.4201607406139374,
0.6102455258369446,
-0.03920508176088333,
-0.3335067629814148,
-0.6613388657569885,
0.1058296337723732,
0.3300773799419403,
0.46660035848617554,
0.06924159079790115,
-0.0393088273704052,
-0.2587513327598572,
-0.8442861437797546,
-0.16263800859451294,
-0.38758519291877747,
0.20433536171913147,
0.13523456454277039,
0.6405953168869019,
-0.3789278268814087,
0.6447420120239258,
-0.13110800087451935,
-0.024970393627882004,
0.10454432666301727,
0.3866339325904846,
-0.012364448048174381,
0.5335732698440552,
0.5176343321800232,
-1.156667709350586,
-0.5613158345222473,
0.1659346967935562,
-1.0793148279190063,
-0.0168545451015234,
-0.031085234135389328,
-0.2922046482563019,
0.08837717771530151,
0.5314437747001648,
-0.3194163739681244,
0.33701202273368835,
0.5435347557067871,
-0.4190863072872162,
0.21500559151172638,
-0.05807444453239441,
0.6985989212989807,
-1.3370758295059204,
-0.013967691920697689,
-0.06748197972774506,
-0.22155046463012695,
-0.8156238198280334,
0.06687912344932556,
0.09069124609231949,
0.2439725548028946,
-0.8263002634048462,
0.3891809582710266,
-0.4391832649707794,
0.2594899535179138,
-0.38172420859336853,
-0.11029026657342911,
0.07765483856201172,
0.15871116518974304,
-0.05116232857108116,
0.6127470135688782,
0.839508056640625,
-0.7783134579658508,
0.7767055630683899,
0.46904852986335754,
-0.1884494572877884,
1.282287836074829,
-0.5134887099266052,
0.2529117166996002,
-0.33094412088394165,
0.115400031208992,
-0.469398558139801,
-0.37380731105804443,
0.1432276964187622,
-0.37443843483924866,
0.41311126947402954,
-0.2734249532222748,
-0.6996702551841736,
0.017711665481328964,
-0.47100985050201416,
0.1517069786787033,
0.8451599478721619,
-0.39076265692710876,
0.8819813132286072,
0.6291815638542175,
-0.28113213181495667,
-0.7516421675682068,
-0.934670627117157,
0.26860928535461426,
-0.6199560165405273,
-0.4613691568374634,
0.16491802036762238,
-0.14064525067806244,
-0.705994188785553,
0.17423857748508453,
0.3476329743862152,
-0.030349556356668472,
0.5042744874954224,
0.12114415317773819,
0.1543247103691101,
0.011121655814349651,
-0.05979175120592117,
-0.012728121131658554,
0.037740666419267654,
0.2938753366470337,
0.054543815553188324,
0.3539142906665802,
-0.5394453406333923,
-0.43001317977905273,
-0.5661216378211975,
0.49612751603126526,
0.833000659942627,
-0.2008553296327591,
0.8500717282295227,
0.6201876401901245,
-0.6064271330833435,
-0.06679616123437881,
-0.5210049152374268,
-0.22187308967113495,
-0.5630022287368774,
0.5859470963478088,
-0.12910452485084534,
-1.0635006427764893,
0.4745466709136963,
-0.11260179430246353,
0.018102485686540604,
0.22852668166160583,
0.9938919544219971,
-0.24394357204437256,
1.064242959022522,
0.8427489399909973,
-0.37121865153312683,
0.5053830146789551,
0.11159560829401016,
0.3137303590774536,
-1.0127136707305908,
-0.06844442337751389,
-0.21879200637340546,
-0.426008015871048,
-0.8504454493522644,
-0.033052414655685425,
0.19570133090019226,
0.09811259061098099,
-0.5033844113349915,
-0.020360762253403664,
-0.6193309426307678,
0.6415164470672607,
0.4208625853061676,
-0.28217068314552307,
0.14307019114494324,
-0.20708277821540833,
0.19388774037361145,
0.10743783414363861,
-0.2713799774646759,
-0.9025989770889282,
0.9550327062606812,
0.46755456924438477,
1.1127439737319946,
0.46467527747154236,
0.5865355730056763,
0.5062358379364014,
0.42739781737327576,
-0.4344491958618164,
0.572115421295166,
-0.18096639215946198,
-0.7801640033721924,
-0.2974946200847626,
-0.5037240386009216,
-0.7228089570999146,
-0.01242106594145298,
0.11516393721103668,
-1.195893406867981,
0.01976504735648632,
0.0858350545167923,
-0.26225024461746216,
0.2538207471370697,
-0.5987867712974548,
0.7325618863105774,
-0.5906766653060913,
-0.4876055419445038,
-0.49563053250312805,
-0.7856552004814148,
0.3746353089809418,
-0.0882786363363266,
0.3501023054122925,
-0.40384525060653687,
-0.007700053043663502,
0.46251222491264343,
-0.12435030192136765,
1.1155927181243896,
0.015798751264810562,
-0.14144346117973328,
0.20321211218833923,
0.44045013189315796,
0.5864845514297485,
0.15348723530769348,
-0.3438543677330017,
0.39442765712738037,
0.16147162020206451,
-0.1486508548259735,
-0.30683186650276184,
1.0466809272766113,
-0.942783534526825,
-0.5819119215011597,
-0.6295785903930664,
-0.6490541100502014,
-0.1768764704465866,
0.22658368945121765,
-0.013582534156739712,
-0.13962599635124207,
-0.2519567906856537,
0.31605324149131775,
0.9733964204788208,
-0.48914286494255066,
0.2872392535209656,
0.8159737586975098,
-0.018084993585944176,
-0.21704469621181488,
0.6028721928596497,
-0.21997319161891937,
0.20921118557453156,
0.04073639214038849,
0.4125232994556427,
-0.5084536671638489,
-0.24435465037822723,
-0.4224969446659088,
0.0377378910779953,
-1.0040169954299927,
-0.08229053765535355,
-0.5169228315353394,
-0.12663991749286652,
-0.4486081600189209,
-0.5232886075973511,
-0.4418022036552429,
0.07194997370243073,
-0.367190420627594,
-0.24958530068397522,
0.9053667187690735,
1.0425999164581299,
-0.1661335676908493,
0.3221643567085266,
-0.6792004108428955,
0.08068345487117767,
-0.1757521778345108,
0.48156335949897766,
-0.21281538903713226,
-0.6078521013259888,
0.17122243344783783,
0.06937426328659058,
-0.15806815028190613,
-0.8068166971206665,
0.1969783455133438,
0.006115971133112907,
0.6310828924179077,
0.09332363307476044,
0.36245617270469666,
0.5293894410133362,
-0.4946683645248413,
0.5752086043357849,
0.11639333516359329,
-1.2930614948272705,
0.541176974773407,
-0.42709651589393616,
-0.07220657914876938,
0.6201494336128235,
0.6244502067565918,
-0.7438591718673706,
-0.4030279517173767,
-0.49733060598373413,
-0.8732564449310303,
0.7452036738395691,
0.29661253094673157,
0.4942074418067932,
0.07771891355514526,
0.44872382283210754,
-0.046519141644239426,
0.3686150908470154,
-0.8315470218658447,
0.02089865691959858,
-0.03800321742892265,
-0.9361026883125305,
-0.04086407646536827,
-0.15315067768096924,
-0.6558465361595154,
0.11513102054595947,
0.7313084602355957,
-0.038085293024778366,
-0.2848476469516754,
0.014878114685416222,
-0.15082895755767822,
-0.04695020616054535,
0.27476954460144043,
0.49726593494415283,
0.49733996391296387,
0.1635175198316574,
0.10293026268482208,
0.17929573357105255,
-0.2342158704996109,
0.43941155076026917,
-0.12911514937877655,
0.1452368050813675,
-0.6958814859390259,
0.13872064650058746,
0.3213616907596588,
-0.19837714731693268,
-0.5509002208709717,
0.5516011714935303,
-0.13957011699676514,
-0.12588517367839813,
-0.45994681119918823,
-0.1573064625263214,
0.33819952607154846,
0.39109134674072266,
-0.0993627980351448,
-0.35352012515068054,
0.35564330220222473,
-0.7083045244216919,
0.32676616311073303,
0.4496608376502991,
-0.24436074495315552,
-0.26808518171310425,
0.5943822264671326,
0.3895197808742523,
-0.19620957970619202,
0.6449958086013794,
-0.22932781279087067,
-0.7177848815917969,
0.6722514033317566,
0.1087266281247139,
0.8976556062698364,
-0.3884814977645874,
-0.03412507474422455,
-0.010988323949277401,
0.5086499452590942,
-0.37287071347236633,
0.2747724950313568,
0.26927483081817627,
-0.6470164656639099,
-0.4839686155319214,
-0.5384060144424438,
-0.5196471810340881,
0.16729645431041718,
-0.8415855765342712,
0.16850250959396362,
-0.6670623421669006,
-0.036115579307079315,
-0.3010086119174957,
-0.11452608555555344,
-0.5535883903503418,
0.2896623909473419,
0.358784019947052,
0.480644166469574,
-0.7444771528244019,
0.7388870716094971,
0.7082976698875427,
-0.309845507144928,
-0.5749715566635132,
-0.10304021090269089,
0.6340243816375732,
-0.7959914207458496,
0.6352829337120056,
0.19357852637767792,
-0.5627042055130005,
-0.028667980805039406,
-0.4703381657600403,
-0.7241872549057007,
0.8743438720703125,
0.4208168089389801,
-0.592418909072876,
0.4334486424922943,
0.0615573525428772,
0.6814975142478943,
-0.3483453392982483,
0.08138182014226913,
0.4955170452594757,
0.4398646652698517,
-0.1844547539949417,
-0.7211053967475891,
0.146124929189682,
-0.2862456738948822,
-0.0937359631061554,
0.29510340094566345,
-0.9291255474090576,
0.5080183744430542,
0.15297377109527588,
-0.02965315617620945,
-0.2837041914463043,
0.3053790330886841,
0.042913686484098434,
0.21414850652217865,
0.5704702138900757,
0.44300103187561035,
0.8765486478805542,
-0.04728982597589493,
0.954635739326477,
-0.660871148109436,
0.3066013753414154,
0.8878970146179199,
-0.8051631450653076,
0.5153783559799194,
0.5357024073600769,
0.003325735917314887,
0.3113832473754883,
0.7386162281036377,
0.1160324364900589,
0.38880330324172974,
0.5021224021911621,
-0.1212012842297554,
-0.05628489702939987,
-0.4034371078014374,
-0.2546078860759735,
0.5663621425628662,
0.39612650871276855,
-0.13973446190357208,
0.24610945582389832,
-0.00800906028598547,
0.32205620408058167,
0.3784884810447693,
-0.22458578646183014,
0.8385306000709534,
0.15474195778369904,
-0.3888603150844574,
0.13195767998695374,
-0.013952841982245445,
0.8104142546653748,
-0.7083566188812256,
0.05053805187344551,
0.08755049854516983,
0.281294584274292,
-0.24154220521450043,
-0.94570392370224,
0.5020596981048584,
0.3751411736011505,
0.039477329701185226,
-0.5124862790107727,
0.34054234623908997,
-0.33483007550239563,
-0.5781173706054688,
0.6754105687141418,
0.11083206534385681,
0.027254700660705566,
0.09761612862348557,
-0.947372317314148,
0.3872034251689911,
-0.11634214967489243,
-0.692880392074585,
0.40849900245666504,
0.6589162945747375,
0.12065037339925766,
0.7823277711868286,
0.7101120352745056,
-0.10225960612297058,
-0.13533228635787964,
0.17504729330539703,
0.6454851031303406,
-0.6534317135810852,
-0.5800461769104004,
-1.4173295497894287,
0.7225260734558105,
-0.3435203731060028,
-0.20706035196781158,
0.5011148452758789,
0.13174737989902496,
0.8778416514396667,
0.31183481216430664,
0.888845682144165,
-0.29123711585998535,
0.04891354963183403,
-0.6943959593772888,
0.9866064190864563,
-0.8011361956596375,
0.17088580131530762,
-0.2602933943271637,
-0.4396316707134247,
-0.07061153650283813,
0.9499813318252563,
-0.28325167298316956,
0.1450810730457306,
0.40783917903900146,
0.6272133588790894,
0.17502541840076447,
-0.06104228273034096,
0.49678441882133484,
0.3020796775817871,
0.5726133584976196,
0.5647103786468506,
1.0096890926361084,
-0.03258839249610901,
0.30905136466026306,
-0.3318541347980499,
-0.4402735233306885,
-0.1781156063079834,
-1.4058055877685547,
-0.7190825939178467,
-0.4645463526248932,
-0.5587655901908875,
-0.21268600225448608,
0.041638150811195374,
0.9903925657272339,
0.7728537917137146,
-0.6324983239173889,
-0.20229975879192352,
-0.07120086997747421,
-0.0961301252245903,
-0.03271760791540146,
-0.2576906979084015,
0.003770547453314066,
-0.10514728724956512,
-0.9232906103134155,
0.20682454109191895,
0.5414332747459412,
0.046830929815769196,
-0.4127686321735382,
-0.3280596435070038,
-0.22143058478832245,
0.482282429933548,
0.41273096203804016,
-0.0521269366145134,
-0.8329525589942932,
-0.45491376519203186,
-0.11534726619720459,
-0.33714717626571655,
-0.24138173460960388,
0.5920625329017639,
0.06839865446090698,
0.5224393010139465,
0.18128666281700134,
0.8270325064659119,
-0.10272478312253952,
-0.0016520319040864706,
0.8163142204284668,
-0.2947632968425751,
0.22476191818714142,
0.5776268839836121,
0.5655208826065063,
0.46272310614585876,
-0.8974936008453369,
0.6177874803543091,
-0.25131750106811523,
-0.7451515197753906,
-0.9257364869117737,
0.7621169090270996,
-0.7090147733688354,
-0.32175660133361816,
1.2348260879516602,
-0.3375038504600525,
-0.20615312457084656,
0.10974501073360443,
-0.05560722574591637,
0.22336626052856445,
-0.32201042771339417,
1.0082449913024902,
1.2319234609603882,
0.03210316225886345,
0.02601403370499611,
-0.7767537236213684,
0.5506518483161926,
0.5636653304100037,
-0.8614238500595093,
0.37214556336402893,
0.550725519657135,
0.39825499057769775,
-0.06970827281475067,
0.4418949782848358,
-0.269471138715744,
0.17640705406665802,
-0.18084648251533508,
0.2547801733016968,
-0.08909744769334793,
0.04533262550830841,
-0.4952355921268463,
-0.3081728518009186,
-0.003108428092673421,
0.08434570580720901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13000v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13000v1
|
RAGE Against the Machine: Retrieval-Augmented LLM Explanations
| 2024-05-11T19:08:38 | 2024-05-11T19:08:38 |
Joel Rorseth, Parke Godfrey, Lukasz Golab, Divesh Srivastava, Jaroslaw Szlichta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
This paper demonstrates RAGE, an interactive tool for explaining Large
Language Models (LLMs) augmented with retrieval capabilities; i.e., able to
query external sources and pull relevant information into their input context.
Our explanations are counterfactual in the sense that they identify parts of
the input context that, when removed, change the answer to the question posed
to the LLM. RAGE includes pruning methods to navigate the vast space of
possible explanations, allowing users to view the provenance of the produced
answers.
|
[
-0.597815990447998,
-1.2626153230667114,
0.7505598664283752,
-0.2914327085018158,
-0.16387981176376343,
0.17397244274616241,
-0.09025967121124268,
-0.10704599320888519,
0.17604397237300873,
0.6597216725349426,
-0.8437554836273193,
-0.29757317900657654,
-0.545890212059021,
-0.15470153093338013,
-0.9185464382171631,
1.1764277219772339,
-0.3322129249572754,
-0.21124976873397827,
-0.4378111958503723,
-0.04638618230819702,
-0.34032097458839417,
-0.7765465974807739,
-0.7032611966133118,
-0.5568630695343018,
1.0533925294876099,
0.22755350172519684,
0.8104170560836792,
0.43127933144569397,
0.5448104739189148,
0.4579896926879883,
0.09730999171733856,
-0.19074159860610962,
-0.8750090599060059,
0.4892459809780121,
-0.4407002031803131,
-0.7094663381576538,
-0.052597884088754654,
-0.06520740687847137,
0.6202817559242249,
0.29023873805999756,
0.08851292729377747,
0.12673868238925934,
-0.3624928891658783,
0.8063089847564697,
-0.5330032706260681,
-0.21739040315151215,
-0.8964876532554626,
0.2629779875278473,
-0.2445085644721985,
-0.35667145252227783,
-0.4052599370479584,
-0.31835079193115234,
-0.17291761934757233,
-0.3353540003299713,
0.14791589975357056,
0.14831873774528503,
0.9231650233268738,
0.5496581792831421,
-0.38429996371269226,
-0.5397359728813171,
-0.9075429439544678,
0.7629518508911133,
-0.12944535911083221,
0.1618698537349701,
0.2008693516254425,
0.4105662703514099,
-0.25649914145469666,
-0.9828354120254517,
-0.7528388500213623,
0.035367708653211594,
-0.05934477970004082,
0.389799028635025,
-0.6746883988380432,
0.15409184992313385,
0.5000226497650146,
0.6157519817352295,
-0.5477836728096008,
0.027252789586782455,
-0.5144410729408264,
-0.15893909335136414,
0.6343585252761841,
0.349691778421402,
0.6239029169082642,
0.04539479687809944,
-0.5923709273338318,
0.28330308198928833,
-0.9613490700721741,
-0.12142390012741089,
0.4666443169116974,
0.07103452831506729,
0.17309626936912537,
0.8928216695785522,
0.30682069063186646,
0.9207377433776855,
0.2679852247238159,
0.02563823014497757,
-0.15802627801895142,
0.08714739233255386,
-0.5295812487602234,
0.13336139917373657,
0.807186484336853,
0.30202046036720276,
0.18014124035835266,
-0.38343968987464905,
-0.3727453947067261,
-0.12876790761947632,
0.685272753238678,
-0.7868179082870483,
-0.022925032302737236,
0.669101893901825,
-0.5366365909576416,
-0.13365326821804047,
-0.24688860774040222,
-1.02848482131958,
-0.6003797650337219,
-0.409151554107666,
0.7637682557106018,
-0.27990373969078064,
-0.4548439085483551,
-0.4300398826599121,
-0.35305747389793396,
0.2015308141708374,
0.2190876305103302,
-0.4364010989665985,
0.1328917294740677,
0.6138033270835876,
1.0426883697509766,
-0.39600998163223267,
0.08215606957674026,
-0.44639208912849426,
-0.039637330919504166,
-0.2439417541027069,
0.9699630737304688,
-0.633895754814148,
-0.8627524375915527,
0.06422541290521622,
0.18271353840827942,
-0.12655331194400787,
-0.8661587834358215,
0.09981663525104523,
-1.163840651512146,
0.20062771439552307,
-0.46672648191452026,
-0.6966533660888672,
-0.6333634853363037,
0.5312296748161316,
-0.8337182402610779,
1.1230902671813965,
-0.051983438432216644,
-0.7670314311981201,
0.06089789792895317,
-0.8389753699302673,
-0.48396846652030945,
-0.16494351625442505,
0.07669902592897415,
-0.13993294537067413,
0.3037639856338501,
-0.15273459255695343,
0.04342009872198105,
-0.015708141028881073,
0.26422369480133057,
-0.5278161764144897,
-0.42203664779663086,
0.504356861114502,
-0.3446813225746155,
0.954984724521637,
0.5995853543281555,
-0.16906945407390594,
0.5232336521148682,
-0.531734049320221,
-0.3577023148536682,
0.4377606511116028,
-0.3390921950340271,
-0.02314547263085842,
0.05771707370877266,
-0.6657930612564087,
0.3894369304180145,
0.4537816047668457,
-0.24489791691303253,
0.30008620023727417,
-0.17058992385864258,
0.06144925206899643,
0.7144167423248291,
0.11510150134563446,
0.022600410506129265,
-0.5531215667724609,
0.9792094826698303,
0.24406589567661285,
-0.04417184367775917,
-0.25314801931381226,
-0.29366815090179443,
-0.8775426149368286,
-0.15913739800453186,
-0.16084401309490204,
0.6683986186981201,
-0.9097990989685059,
-0.23836325109004974,
0.05763258412480354,
-0.37800121307373047,
-0.5205097198486328,
0.3373144567012787,
0.30230504274368286,
0.6039935946464539,
0.3679378032684326,
0.030474063009023666,
-1.1566017866134644,
-0.7347891330718994,
-0.4448380172252655,
-0.37338393926620483,
0.009600910358130932,
0.5680305361747742,
0.3621368706226349,
-0.1797873079776764,
1.1299097537994385,
-0.3215530216693878,
0.22819972038269043,
-0.3829784691333771,
0.4368493854999542,
0.13925442099571228,
-0.01603616401553154,
0.21987487375736237,
-0.8577502369880676,
-0.29840266704559326,
-0.2010163813829422,
-0.8100262880325317,
-0.4009723961353302,
-0.05340597778558731,
-0.19435937702655792,
0.3224032521247864,
0.9454814195632935,
-0.4848023056983948,
0.3210584819316864,
0.40519484877586365,
-0.1385321468114853,
0.793526291847229,
0.1225375086069107,
0.3260573148727417,
-0.9103423953056335,
0.20436950027942657,
-0.2632083296775818,
-0.2747949957847595,
-0.4099956452846527,
0.36871248483657837,
-0.5567008852958679,
-0.21920499205589294,
-0.6363015174865723,
0.6189804077148438,
-0.3841777741909027,
-0.3250521421432495,
-0.5626341104507446,
0.49292415380477905,
-0.06429963558912277,
0.2904859781265259,
-0.012977742590010166,
1.044150471687317,
0.5244640111923218,
-0.7214968800544739,
0.7764790058135986,
-0.3008536994457245,
0.033978234976530075,
0.4707493782043457,
-0.6792095899581909,
0.4113817811012268,
-0.3499731719493866,
-0.09986286610364914,
-1.4513370990753174,
-0.04325277358293533,
-0.04040534421801567,
-0.3843085765838623,
0.15835534036159515,
-0.632267415523529,
-0.5397593379020691,
-0.6626012325286865,
-0.10273740440607071,
-0.01647934503853321,
0.6775597333908081,
-0.7722180485725403,
0.8262578845024109,
0.5730987191200256,
-0.006437476724386215,
-0.4347159266471863,
-0.516339123249054,
0.056264135986566544,
-0.6039823293685913,
-0.3399849534034729,
0.14342306554317474,
-0.2699039876461029,
-0.9790462851524353,
-0.26801928877830505,
0.23661720752716064,
-0.19035661220550537,
0.09920383989810944,
0.7109280824661255,
0.27770480513572693,
-0.40987882018089294,
0.6507622003555298,
-0.09150317311286926,
0.2697523534297943,
0.3833965063095093,
-0.0033531400840729475,
0.7286620736122131,
0.08185972273349762,
-0.28188174962997437,
-0.02604019083082676,
0.40881308913230896,
0.7276285290718079,
0.21776993572711945,
0.7125100493431091,
0.7119818925857544,
-0.18693198263645172,
0.277584969997406,
-0.5759434103965759,
-0.01404305174946785,
-0.5391945838928223,
0.2657771706581116,
-0.6368098855018616,
-0.8659606575965881,
0.8344023823738098,
-0.3915121555328369,
0.021109314635396004,
0.7342697381973267,
1.15640127658844,
0.009872488677501678,
1.3705412149429321,
0.3673064410686493,
0.005953104235231876,
0.5875048637390137,
-0.06481750309467316,
0.03553473949432373,
-0.6086263656616211,
-0.4742622971534729,
-0.6522873044013977,
-0.6667963266372681,
-0.3181021511554718,
-0.4907955229282379,
0.09331370890140533,
0.2550777196884155,
-0.2856934070587158,
0.07333541661500931,
-0.40498605370521545,
0.46902793645858765,
0.34945863485336304,
-0.1339181512594223,
0.28010234236717224,
0.04548700898885727,
-0.34423789381980896,
0.02957378700375557,
-0.6017966866493225,
-0.40474677085876465,
0.7513073086738586,
0.18174612522125244,
0.7526136636734009,
0.36611998081207275,
0.4778064489364624,
0.37085655331611633,
0.6204848289489746,
-1.0520625114440918,
0.5120626091957092,
-0.0560603067278862,
-1.2641377449035645,
-0.06892778724431992,
-0.2887114882469177,
-1.0144420862197876,
0.138958141207695,
-0.03319129720330238,
-0.9528024196624756,
-0.07650244235992432,
0.28063100576400757,
-0.327577143907547,
0.5760316848754883,
-0.919981837272644,
0.7666208744049072,
-0.11401531845331192,
-0.5120366811752319,
-0.3445231318473816,
-0.36633962392807007,
0.6669208407402039,
0.15954089164733887,
0.24762406945228577,
0.2844718098640442,
-0.13085415959358215,
0.8257319927215576,
-0.6252491474151611,
0.9640852212905884,
-0.23921780288219452,
-0.3493436574935913,
0.818984866142273,
0.524742603302002,
0.543738603591919,
-0.28640371561050415,
-0.3212302029132843,
0.01815786585211754,
-0.27770885825157166,
-0.1636480838060379,
-0.7525753974914551,
1.0639437437057495,
-0.761740505695343,
-0.8959992527961731,
-0.00872102938592434,
-0.6589958667755127,
0.005017365328967571,
0.03358819708228111,
0.29553475975990295,
0.31753477454185486,
-0.14077310264110565,
-0.05818226560950279,
0.8588113784790039,
-0.4291353225708008,
0.5422569513320923,
0.8135417103767395,
-0.7986315488815308,
-0.051115427166223526,
1.0930383205413818,
0.27683988213539124,
0.15918424725532532,
0.3412376940250397,
0.0984993502497673,
-0.5538901686668396,
-0.43461644649505615,
-0.6282201409339905,
-0.172823965549469,
-0.8378350734710693,
-0.04184746369719505,
-1.0151307582855225,
-0.012432239018380642,
-0.03621833398938179,
-0.1432952582836151,
-0.1411532610654831,
-0.3159586787223816,
-0.4543582499027252,
0.019159629940986633,
0.7052838802337646,
1.0952670574188232,
0.0946025550365448,
0.5345720052719116,
-0.6485588550567627,
0.35313576459884644,
0.38600218296051025,
0.3432832658290863,
0.1595929116010666,
-0.8826649785041809,
-0.19429519772529602,
-0.3560003340244293,
-0.5720471143722534,
-1.2882404327392578,
0.3279643952846527,
-0.20535150170326233,
0.3724612295627594,
0.5739571452140808,
0.0032997080124914646,
0.9800555109977722,
-0.450592577457428,
0.986732006072998,
0.09323340654373169,
-0.8541624546051025,
0.7173779606819153,
-0.22114071249961853,
0.4321962296962738,
0.1699189990758896,
0.8485451340675354,
-0.3653562068939209,
-0.4890989065170288,
-0.6802451014518738,
-0.8684451580047607,
0.5023196339607239,
-0.44835421442985535,
0.12518078088760376,
-0.21632777154445648,
0.42845797538757324,
0.17026448249816895,
0.08375642448663712,
-0.7317853569984436,
-0.29346317052841187,
-0.24261924624443054,
-0.06645295768976212,
0.19933249056339264,
-0.4245658814907074,
-0.29662537574768066,
-0.001425155671313405,
0.9200748801231384,
0.12705866992473602,
0.37990906834602356,
0.2632565200328827,
-0.5375339984893799,
-0.559396505355835,
0.14856074750423431,
0.6549712419509888,
0.7778410315513611,
0.029977228492498398,
0.5122089385986328,
0.27116501331329346,
-0.20583343505859375,
-0.09854649752378464,
-0.1438213735818863,
0.007036976516246796,
0.23299308121204376,
0.21692043542861938,
0.7988100051879883,
-0.21019139885902405,
-0.8495370745658875,
0.15145446360111237,
-0.00024603804922662675,
-0.13929153978824615,
-0.2862304151058197,
0.2293439656496048,
0.10909058153629303,
0.35365262627601624,
0.4048541486263275,
-0.45294189453125,
0.3198312819004059,
-0.5822314023971558,
0.2711222767829895,
0.5912500619888306,
-1.0253770351409912,
-0.4063282608985901,
0.41542115807533264,
-0.1128607988357544,
-0.5977205038070679,
0.4162130653858185,
0.007203180342912674,
-0.5853308439254761,
0.4436625838279724,
0.7665212154388428,
0.7227047085762024,
0.010287412442266941,
-0.00015926462947390974,
0.35744890570640564,
0.21524487435817719,
0.3427470624446869,
0.2733243405818939,
-0.0025607296265661716,
-0.5365157723426819,
-0.8266828656196594,
-0.4366973042488098,
-0.4953708052635193,
0.46142125129699707,
-0.5476110577583313,
0.07566027343273163,
-0.5663852691650391,
-0.09877234697341919,
0.015182397328317165,
0.02377527579665184,
-0.32603901624679565,
0.27154889702796936,
0.03841738402843475,
0.8848367929458618,
-0.4921649396419525,
0.7300071120262146,
0.8485344052314758,
-0.6750133633613586,
-0.653098464012146,
-0.026869388297200203,
0.25013861060142517,
-1.2260135412216187,
0.9530414938926697,
-0.11813972890377045,
-0.22098645567893982,
-0.07136647403240204,
-0.8448691964149475,
-0.6719821095466614,
0.5486341714859009,
0.46743932366371155,
-0.7210862636566162,
0.44161614775657654,
-0.3508501648902893,
0.5891302227973938,
-0.009606842882931232,
0.47880786657333374,
0.4250545799732208,
0.6724818348884583,
0.34161296486854553,
-0.46205127239227295,
0.13242492079734802,
-0.2036147266626358,
-0.4629184603691101,
0.367509663105011,
-0.4699974060058594,
0.819211483001709,
-0.4179936349391937,
-0.2380804717540741,
-0.10163430869579315,
0.5623776316642761,
0.056966159492731094,
0.23915685713291168,
0.5446068644523621,
0.6126806139945984,
0.5579551458358765,
-0.19988302886486053,
1.3675062656402588,
-0.31646034121513367,
0.25999006628990173,
0.9679347276687622,
-0.2112400382757187,
0.7444548010826111,
0.7012635469436646,
-0.5612389445304871,
1.080918550491333,
0.722109854221344,
0.27813515067100525,
0.09952015429735184,
0.4506104588508606,
-0.4357896149158478,
-0.3328203558921814,
-0.23918451368808746,
-0.20953679084777832,
0.2940138876438141,
0.38010716438293457,
-0.4985480308532715,
-0.2999761998653412,
0.0003364289877936244,
0.12213274836540222,
-0.0625927522778511,
-0.5886124968528748,
1.1143072843551636,
-0.022310299798846245,
-0.922815203666687,
0.689254879951477,
-0.14984209835529327,
0.33441901206970215,
-0.3139455020427704,
0.08346930891275406,
-0.0953788086771965,
0.27370357513427734,
-0.22979944944381714,
-0.8633494973182678,
0.7073120474815369,
0.2236860692501068,
-0.5736986398696899,
-0.09592117369174957,
1.018631935119629,
-0.42544376850128174,
-0.3695235550403595,
0.29639488458633423,
0.4919392168521881,
0.6762226819992065,
-0.12934528291225433,
-1.1243377923965454,
0.3185464143753052,
-0.16961650550365448,
-0.4889550805091858,
0.36920732259750366,
0.6809456944465637,
0.07471395283937454,
0.7570354342460632,
0.5120961666107178,
-0.17985257506370544,
0.002145841484889388,
0.09115470945835114,
0.981066107749939,
-0.6676218509674072,
-0.059643086045980453,
-1.3524971008300781,
0.42437857389450073,
0.04240259900689125,
0.09480278193950653,
0.7747963070869446,
0.5817947387695312,
0.3727349042892456,
0.012069475837051868,
0.6984579563140869,
-0.117442287504673,
0.7660194635391235,
-0.5074604749679565,
0.45788031816482544,
-0.8767266273498535,
0.09225911647081375,
-0.0272934939712286,
-0.3976222276687622,
-0.11866219341754913,
0.3435516655445099,
-0.4939814805984497,
0.2238370031118393,
0.4427996575832367,
0.8297598958015442,
0.0270413625985384,
-0.05625447630882263,
0.4690401256084442,
0.7532275319099426,
0.09211549907922745,
0.2776627838611603,
0.9356474876403809,
-0.022391129285097122,
0.8201670050621033,
0.2886149287223816,
-0.02099650166928768,
-0.4346659481525421,
-0.9478189945220947,
-0.9719717502593994,
-0.24374732375144958,
-0.3364620506763458,
-0.488633930683136,
0.2061936855316162,
0.7241646647453308,
0.5012850165367126,
-0.9838139414787292,
-0.2534360885620117,
0.0969996303319931,
0.8879478573799133,
0.16697850823402405,
-0.3643610179424286,
0.07831200212240219,
-0.5376564264297485,
-0.6762250065803528,
0.4940055310726166,
0.375202476978302,
0.03212745115160942,
-0.5695115923881531,
-0.006130415480583906,
-0.45771780610084534,
0.3915470838546753,
0.8104249835014343,
0.5264971852302551,
-0.8099769949913025,
-0.2590610086917877,
-0.008576035499572754,
0.1695912778377533,
0.0998598262667656,
1.1055744886398315,
-1.1373882293701172,
0.6972041726112366,
0.6582074165344238,
0.4089106321334839,
0.3141600787639618,
0.02104826830327511,
0.7519357800483704,
-0.725009024143219,
0.22306813299655914,
-0.13186921179294586,
0.3630445897579193,
0.2625788748264313,
-0.36981627345085144,
0.15541717410087585,
0.28265100717544556,
-0.4970909059047699,
-0.9528000950813293,
0.32338887453079224,
-0.6984354257583618,
-0.5920507311820984,
1.171977162361145,
-0.3256791830062866,
-0.2565334141254425,
-0.43849295377731323,
-0.3859555721282959,
0.5131959319114685,
-0.28710368275642395,
0.891559362411499,
0.9891258478164673,
-0.15485277771949768,
-0.27950844168663025,
-0.539514422416687,
0.4245671331882477,
0.3437349796295166,
-0.6276745796203613,
0.09070321172475815,
0.47613176703453064,
0.07593513280153275,
0.21190574765205383,
0.47849926352500916,
-0.433496356010437,
0.07238466292619705,
-0.0960681289434433,
0.20315693318843842,
-0.01966196484863758,
-0.19655223190784454,
-0.41880056262016296,
0.4495644271373749,
0.123215451836586,
-0.026523226872086525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07052v1
|
Length-Aware Multi-Kernel Transformer for Long Document Classification
| 2024-05-11T16:48:06 | 2024-05-11T16:48:06 |
Guangzeng Han, Jack Tsao, Xiaolei Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lengthy documents pose a unique challenge to neural language models due to
substantial memory consumption. While existing state-of-the-art (SOTA) models
segment long texts into equal-length snippets (e.g., 128 tokens per snippet) or
deploy sparse attention networks, these methods have new challenges of context
fragmentation and generalizability due to sentence boundaries and varying text
lengths. For example, our empirical analysis has shown that SOTA models
consistently overfit one set of lengthy documents (e.g., 2000 tokens) while
performing worse on texts with other lengths (e.g., 1000 or 4000). In this
study, we propose a Length-Aware Multi-Kernel Transformer (LAMKIT) to address
the new challenges for the long document classification. LAMKIT encodes lengthy
documents by diverse transformer-based kernels for bridging context boundaries
and vectorizes text length by the kernels to promote model robustness over
varying document lengths. Experiments on five standard benchmarks from health
and law domains show LAMKIT outperforms SOTA models up to an absolute 10.9%
improvement. We conduct extensive ablation analyses to examine model robustness
and effectiveness over varying document lengths.
|
[
-0.4616653621196747,
-0.6700932383537292,
0.5758917927742004,
0.46688008308410645,
-0.3443737328052521,
-0.15713143348693848,
-0.41221582889556885,
-0.6554777026176453,
0.17145895957946777,
0.5791937112808228,
-0.3018417954444885,
-0.16660714149475098,
-0.802943229675293,
0.20300449430942535,
-0.6811065673828125,
1.1271345615386963,
-0.13289359211921692,
-0.3595196604728699,
-0.39111489057540894,
-0.34363964200019836,
-0.5501551032066345,
-0.42538028955459595,
-0.48775985836982727,
-0.2510469853878021,
0.7219507694244385,
0.32894623279571533,
0.5460970997810364,
0.6473323702812195,
0.5381351113319397,
0.22830016911029816,
-0.3492761552333832,
0.12356217950582504,
-0.12051183730363846,
0.32976609468460083,
0.2301284819841385,
-0.23879818618297577,
-0.36473390460014343,
-0.38506534695625305,
0.9742411971092224,
0.4428524076938629,
0.03990153595805168,
0.08810631930828094,
0.05416405200958252,
0.6910553574562073,
-0.6308588981628418,
-0.1771502047777176,
-0.320072203874588,
0.0433272048830986,
-0.3965989053249359,
0.1414002925157547,
-0.6027006506919861,
-0.011402570642530918,
0.2061896026134491,
-0.5223568081855774,
0.046971432864665985,
-0.04209159314632416,
0.8017311692237854,
0.29535621404647827,
-0.5180084705352783,
-0.4482496380805969,
-0.6497712731361389,
0.8045499920845032,
-0.5283858776092529,
0.943920910358429,
0.538655698299408,
0.5749353766441345,
0.2081194519996643,
-0.9729033708572388,
-0.7881813645362854,
-0.09130533039569855,
-0.2633032202720642,
0.056516822427511215,
-0.06851006299257278,
-0.05342545732855797,
0.396535187959671,
0.16072124242782593,
-0.5643228888511658,
0.4655148386955261,
-0.7237962484359741,
-0.34876248240470886,
0.30217987298965454,
0.13206341862678528,
0.10578067600727081,
-0.2819999158382416,
-0.595382571220398,
0.011375286616384983,
-0.34730130434036255,
0.08917236328125,
0.38783878087997437,
0.010215072892606258,
0.01765289343893528,
0.3012106716632843,
-0.010131496004760265,
0.7331545352935791,
-0.16181208193302155,
-0.22252444922924042,
0.22807429730892181,
-0.2051650583744049,
-0.1848934143781662,
0.3424561023712158,
0.6859802007675171,
0.2602912187576294,
-0.26800858974456787,
-0.09861358255147934,
-0.2316725105047226,
0.07914640009403229,
0.47319984436035156,
-1.1157996654510498,
0.21709327399730682,
0.3102925717830658,
-0.44082769751548767,
0.10337667167186737,
-0.3441943824291229,
-0.9843134880065918,
-0.3349665403366089,
-0.10692566633224487,
0.33765244483947754,
-0.707924485206604,
0.22017869353294373,
0.3772624135017395,
-0.07655373215675354,
0.10474780946969986,
0.22169291973114014,
-0.9707975387573242,
0.13567925989627838,
0.7414931654930115,
1.0234026908874512,
-0.1782158762216568,
-0.47918471693992615,
-0.4739013910293579,
0.12032695859670639,
-0.04130175709724426,
0.7818785309791565,
-0.6503620743751526,
-0.4166291654109955,
-0.0439872108399868,
-0.0492226704955101,
-0.0013588503934442997,
-0.19181478023529053,
0.8528956174850464,
-0.5194686651229858,
0.3293372094631195,
-0.009842000901699066,
-0.6066677570343018,
-0.029776735231280327,
0.3999022841453552,
-0.7786144018173218,
0.9788768887519836,
0.217776358127594,
-0.8087802529335022,
0.22848983108997345,
-0.9695119261741638,
-0.6904429197311401,
-0.00012544791388791054,
0.05238097533583641,
-0.8467679023742676,
-0.04448217153549194,
0.19177810847759247,
0.7164125442504883,
-0.30355972051620483,
0.4387962520122528,
0.10720282047986984,
-0.25535908341407776,
0.1705525517463684,
-0.6447097659111023,
0.510193943977356,
0.3388543426990509,
0.0988643616437912,
0.3311323821544647,
-0.8382580280303955,
-0.3702307939529419,
-0.16181877255439758,
-0.6241304278373718,
-0.3637664318084717,
-0.32150864601135254,
0.3840947151184082,
0.1287717968225479,
0.24067378044128418,
-0.9599841833114624,
0.24494867026805878,
-0.21858912706375122,
0.745927631855011,
0.6703374981880188,
-0.38400620222091675,
0.4681878089904785,
-0.4302317798137665,
0.2303587943315506,
0.06127185374498367,
0.4444485604763031,
-0.5960273742675781,
-0.42059898376464844,
-0.8351023197174072,
-0.6022116541862488,
0.43563178181648254,
0.0225981492549181,
-0.5008022785186768,
0.6125369071960449,
-0.7265704274177551,
-0.5277044177055359,
-0.5235539078712463,
-0.037035100162029266,
0.225017711520195,
0.6831581592559814,
0.6655197143554688,
-0.40772300958633423,
-0.33112385869026184,
-1.018921136856079,
0.04445676505565643,
0.19234053790569305,
-0.15463127195835114,
0.3172244429588318,
0.5096122026443481,
-0.785356342792511,
1.1748733520507812,
-0.6072614789009094,
-0.4720926582813263,
-0.24978967010974884,
0.142568901181221,
0.03716810420155525,
0.33661317825317383,
0.42357027530670166,
-0.9396533370018005,
-0.5241529941558838,
0.01025389414280653,
-0.3881072998046875,
-0.002270936267450452,
-0.29840484261512756,
0.176279217004776,
0.30316847562789917,
0.43276187777519226,
-0.6228170394897461,
0.47607213258743286,
0.432016521692276,
-0.301265150308609,
0.5950419902801514,
-0.34721097350120544,
-0.38025227189064026,
-1.1658183336257935,
0.2569887042045593,
-0.09718543291091919,
-0.2509665787220001,
-0.9299781918525696,
-0.127276211977005,
0.6266093254089355,
0.004142157267779112,
-0.5773559212684631,
0.6523445844650269,
-0.041573893278837204,
0.08434611558914185,
-0.32386043667793274,
-0.29782381653785706,
0.31645455956459045,
0.5007294416427612,
0.021157922223210335,
0.5591737031936646,
0.30032527446746826,
-0.5344509482383728,
0.24486905336380005,
0.4008755683898926,
-0.6417868733406067,
0.5546093583106995,
-0.35315269231796265,
0.03739221766591072,
-0.2773285210132599,
0.6745927929878235,
-0.5660358667373657,
-0.20039772987365723,
-0.2032482624053955,
-0.18579156696796417,
0.43666520714759827,
0.3349097967147827,
-0.42605093121528625,
-0.5356981158256531,
-0.23102915287017822,
0.6438766121864319,
0.3308597505092621,
-0.7221814393997192,
0.9021996855735779,
0.1114162877202034,
-0.1639309823513031,
-0.8007461428642273,
-0.7197997570037842,
0.18341746926307678,
-0.28303420543670654,
-0.6427468061447144,
0.4737965166568756,
-0.1564781814813614,
0.4029410481452942,
-0.19666574895381927,
-0.22686050832271576,
-0.34260159730911255,
0.029443284496665,
0.41310915350914,
-0.14622655510902405,
-0.015865448862314224,
0.4653299152851105,
0.2786310017108917,
-0.21756203472614288,
-0.14121542870998383,
-0.17281682789325714,
0.659105122089386,
-0.1789911687374115,
-0.17652609944343567,
-0.3486168682575226,
0.5455499887466431,
0.8587996363639832,
-0.45055729150772095,
0.5767954587936401,
0.7951677441596985,
-0.4355809688568115,
-0.2218007892370224,
-0.8227176070213318,
-0.179245725274086,
-0.4701581299304962,
0.44459468126296997,
-0.44684550166130066,
-1.3293483257293701,
0.7259532809257507,
-0.011113595217466354,
-0.059927795082330704,
0.4166490137577057,
0.2827287018299103,
0.042900267988443375,
0.4255564510822296,
0.7090326547622681,
-0.21362939476966858,
0.43194499611854553,
-0.2987092435359955,
0.26498717069625854,
-1.1038259267807007,
-0.3349725902080536,
-0.4704810678958893,
-0.4103330373764038,
-0.0159731674939394,
-0.2828819751739502,
0.31554293632507324,
-0.14052894711494446,
-0.19696258008480072,
0.5007688403129578,
-0.5646467804908752,
0.5468496084213257,
0.47848260402679443,
0.09997975826263428,
-0.11660711467266083,
-0.22952710092067719,
-0.07536288350820541,
0.307729035615921,
-0.5941033363342285,
-0.13779158890247345,
0.9065753817558289,
0.7692586779594421,
0.6053277254104614,
-0.050949327647686005,
0.5134041905403137,
0.09765864163637161,
0.25238245725631714,
-0.8935937881469727,
0.359946072101593,
-0.3759351968765259,
-0.4812251627445221,
-0.7299423217773438,
-0.3118174076080322,
-0.9909437894821167,
-0.05006229132413864,
0.05275662615895271,
-0.5214529037475586,
0.2981248199939728,
-0.36752384901046753,
-0.5475242137908936,
0.3025856614112854,
-0.26926034688949585,
0.911049485206604,
-0.3578239679336548,
-0.15934069454669952,
-0.006984120234847069,
-0.9641847610473633,
0.03957735747098923,
-0.7131474614143372,
0.10987269878387451,
-0.05986584350466728,
0.1841856837272644,
1.1095616817474365,
-0.47302016615867615,
0.7830364108085632,
0.08508451282978058,
-0.17453348636627197,
0.30245137214660645,
-0.1838366985321045,
0.31789204478263855,
-0.08685868978500366,
-0.07180985808372498,
0.45409899950027466,
0.02112402953207493,
-0.2564140558242798,
-0.5730319023132324,
0.5854573249816895,
-0.6163864135742188,
-0.3723945617675781,
-0.25992733240127563,
-0.6472907066345215,
0.006774539593607187,
0.6403204202651978,
0.3163047134876251,
0.41697394847869873,
0.094419926404953,
0.6208924651145935,
0.4648846685886383,
-0.2177734673023224,
0.723569393157959,
0.47409194707870483,
0.022681178525090218,
-0.3681498169898987,
0.8789591193199158,
0.29515111446380615,
0.0157980564981699,
0.45748987793922424,
0.40578094124794006,
-0.43974000215530396,
-0.3638538122177124,
-0.2730594575405121,
-0.0716998279094696,
-0.7964765429496765,
-0.4820598363876343,
-0.9527986645698547,
-0.436825156211853,
-0.2934197783470154,
-0.4213171601295471,
-0.5222439765930176,
-0.33658409118652344,
-0.216517373919487,
-0.09654700756072998,
0.3571772277355194,
0.6355714797973633,
0.09493715316057205,
0.689012885093689,
-0.9043387770652771,
0.2639251947402954,
0.4932328462600708,
0.8610303997993469,
0.06302628666162491,
-0.5527721643447876,
-0.36554744839668274,
-0.3717103898525238,
-0.29573798179626465,
-0.5713783502578735,
0.38795971870422363,
0.21909569203853607,
0.215830460190773,
0.4620044529438019,
0.05252235010266304,
0.496105432510376,
-0.7476415038108826,
0.6799752116203308,
0.5002022385597229,
-0.9529333114624023,
0.3022456467151642,
-0.1249733716249466,
0.5364179015159607,
0.47137632966041565,
0.3645015060901642,
-0.9129378199577332,
-0.1564822942018509,
-0.14292065799236298,
-0.9484192132949829,
0.5951557755470276,
0.16393208503723145,
0.27520182728767395,
-0.11930602788925171,
0.3653598427772522,
0.5071718692779541,
-0.19584263861179352,
-0.5307976007461548,
0.18512170016765594,
-0.3819229006767273,
-0.3029605448246002,
0.011686155572533607,
-0.6692960262298584,
0.13095678389072418,
0.018359577283263206,
0.3822517693042755,
-0.22902993857860565,
0.20437227189540863,
0.16633418202400208,
-0.1933295726776123,
0.21466809511184692,
0.6139988303184509,
1.0330959558486938,
0.577768862247467,
-0.24979683756828308,
0.28396132588386536,
0.347810834646225,
-0.7706441879272461,
0.15622426569461823,
0.11701691150665283,
0.11772167682647705,
0.005205966532230377,
0.30572378635406494,
0.9252618551254272,
0.11471135169267654,
-0.5542006492614746,
0.6568365097045898,
-0.2621564269065857,
-0.1791122853755951,
-0.10681752115488052,
-0.26794949173927307,
0.04882558435201645,
0.10572744905948639,
0.18819253146648407,
-0.003799568163231015,
0.053941573947668076,
-0.03878422826528549,
0.4182143211364746,
0.0674683079123497,
-0.5298604965209961,
-0.16956235468387604,
0.5198565125465393,
0.25236091017723083,
-0.3510992228984833,
0.7347588539123535,
0.16920700669288635,
-0.671622633934021,
0.6348057985305786,
0.6416347026824951,
0.7547847032546997,
-0.4220499098300934,
-0.10395511984825134,
-0.061716724187135696,
0.193850576877594,
-0.34824302792549133,
-0.08728251606225967,
-0.3275953531265259,
-0.5514373779296875,
-0.35883828997612,
-1.1641736030578613,
-0.14576378464698792,
0.31020793318748474,
-0.5672349333763123,
0.27534955739974976,
-0.2924685478210449,
-0.27213186025619507,
0.25577500462532043,
-0.3155082166194916,
-0.5850229263305664,
0.27422890067100525,
0.04476231336593628,
1.0786739587783813,
-0.7245588898658752,
1.0559865236282349,
0.22323940694332123,
-0.10925422608852386,
-0.32930788397789,
-0.12989239394664764,
-0.5242387652397156,
-0.4442708492279053,
0.82377690076828,
0.864572286605835,
0.13891975581645966,
-0.3557929992675781,
-0.04801447317004204,
-0.6717014312744141,
1.0616384744644165,
0.2073986828327179,
-0.7677395343780518,
-0.13877984881401062,
0.5195918679237366,
0.5399011373519897,
-0.16357392072677612,
-0.00937998853623867,
0.3782268762588501,
0.5097121596336365,
-0.10254819691181183,
-1.1358002424240112,
-0.06133227050304413,
-0.03910372778773308,
-0.00927791278809309,
0.38755154609680176,
-0.8556998372077942,
0.6614364981651306,
0.18119177222251892,
-0.11923276633024216,
0.046627745032310486,
0.7287123203277588,
-0.23274239897727966,
0.5831530094146729,
0.47738906741142273,
0.8329605460166931,
0.6799267530441284,
0.21940398216247559,
0.9232481718063354,
-0.35836368799209595,
0.22991472482681274,
1.0555555820465088,
-0.3581130802631378,
0.8543071746826172,
0.3828679323196411,
0.2950775921344757,
0.3626460134983063,
0.3707013428211212,
-0.020886316895484924,
0.37055519223213196,
0.21869343519210815,
-0.2742290794849396,
-0.1546907126903534,
-0.18627488613128662,
-0.33956149220466614,
0.6606519818305969,
0.47840431332588196,
-0.4889718294143677,
-0.08923876285552979,
0.5798556804656982,
-0.030799835920333862,
-0.16736122965812683,
-0.17265215516090393,
0.6157031655311584,
0.14349879324436188,
-0.609691858291626,
0.39892998337745667,
0.33113253116607666,
0.8508162498474121,
-0.6656587719917297,
0.29166939854621887,
-0.2577720582485199,
0.23596344888210297,
-0.10388795286417007,
-0.895104169845581,
0.47697195410728455,
0.008071566931903362,
-0.4187566041946411,
-0.40363311767578125,
0.9111512303352356,
-0.38984236121177673,
-0.4262363612651825,
0.3145711123943329,
-0.18470963835716248,
-0.06378987431526184,
-0.04454924166202545,
-0.2691230773925781,
0.23987604677677155,
-0.34005334973335266,
-0.22978968918323517,
0.42692145705223083,
0.29829004406929016,
-0.22985410690307617,
0.7467855215072632,
0.5602467656135559,
-0.3735257387161255,
0.10176724195480347,
-0.1132671907544136,
1.0268049240112305,
-0.551843523979187,
-0.8276235461235046,
-0.8911851048469543,
0.31759387254714966,
-0.06437192112207413,
-0.31572914123535156,
0.5212067365646362,
0.9374151229858398,
0.6181670427322388,
0.0005986099131405354,
0.652700662612915,
0.3078080713748932,
0.2187202274799347,
-0.4148241877555847,
1.080535650253296,
-0.5567883849143982,
-0.01712660677731037,
0.25774624943733215,
-0.8842682838439941,
-0.6025128364562988,
0.42704787850379944,
-0.18282757699489594,
-0.2347872108221054,
0.6601585149765015,
0.37055516242980957,
-0.20043204724788666,
0.0459582693874836,
0.36804547905921936,
0.13724635541439056,
0.5946609973907471,
0.5788937211036682,
0.6720018982887268,
-0.27223342657089233,
0.6022081971168518,
-0.12647032737731934,
-0.03542555496096611,
-0.37104442715644836,
-0.8539152145385742,
-0.8368147015571594,
-0.797172486782074,
-0.030918771401047707,
-0.14415626227855682,
0.01818356290459633,
0.42439866065979004,
0.7343500852584839,
-0.5580191612243652,
0.01728370226919651,
0.2031993418931961,
-0.09745753556489944,
0.11907085031270981,
-0.1546749323606491,
0.7905781269073486,
-0.33768409490585327,
-0.3484242558479309,
0.40794771909713745,
0.5818833112716675,
0.017120271921157837,
-0.1377270668745041,
-0.11760605126619339,
-0.07094315439462662,
0.18197616934776306,
0.8152507543563843,
0.2663436532020569,
-0.6082198023796082,
-0.4729503095149994,
-0.03577784448862076,
-0.20068994164466858,
0.14843301475048065,
0.6402124762535095,
-0.5639451742172241,
0.7565183043479919,
0.49537143111228943,
0.9429852962493896,
0.5762752294540405,
-0.27529293298721313,
0.1598878651857376,
-1.1740182638168335,
0.0693724974989891,
0.4133187234401703,
0.4336683750152588,
0.2612561583518982,
-0.404682993888855,
0.3909823000431061,
-0.21634557843208313,
-0.6915634274482727,
-0.9585027694702148,
0.19341951608657837,
-1.0988179445266724,
-0.49916601181030273,
1.1233844757080078,
-0.1376023292541504,
-0.4051710069179535,
0.017163215205073357,
-0.2294345647096634,
0.26845136284828186,
-0.306467205286026,
0.8656162619590759,
0.7198060154914856,
-0.005890347063541412,
-0.05494753643870354,
-0.2319357991218567,
0.34393465518951416,
0.42190274596214294,
-0.6705405712127686,
0.20640841126441956,
0.266668438911438,
0.019448935985565186,
0.7986317276954651,
0.5296948552131653,
0.10045027732849121,
0.24356116354465485,
-0.22835387289524078,
-0.08727006614208221,
-0.3932743966579437,
-0.8390257954597473,
-0.41436684131622314,
0.3418627083301544,
-0.4351068139076233,
0.017613977193832397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07035v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07035v2
|
A Turkish Educational Crossword Puzzle Generator
| 2024-05-11T15:18:56 | 2024-05-15T12:23:39 |
Kamyar Zeinalipour, Yusuf Gökberk Keptiğ, Marco Maggini, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Gori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces the first Turkish crossword puzzle generator designed
to leverage the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) for educational
purposes. In this work, we introduced two specially created datasets: one with
over 180,000 unique answer-clue pairs for generating relevant clues from the
given answer, and another with over 35,000 samples containing text, answer,
category, and clue data, aimed at producing clues for specific texts and
keywords within certain categories. Beyond entertainment, this generator
emerges as an interactive educational tool that enhances memory, vocabulary,
and problem-solving skills. It's a notable step in AI-enhanced education,
merging game-like engagement with learning for Turkish and setting new
standards for interactive, intelligent learning tools in Turkish.
|
[
-0.4506929814815521,
-0.8758941888809204,
0.31629323959350586,
0.09654273092746735,
-0.6649776101112366,
0.11649982631206512,
-0.32290413975715637,
-0.19008491933345795,
0.21842795610427856,
0.4840323030948639,
-0.8162329792976379,
-0.4748375415802002,
-0.7381573915481567,
0.18423719704151154,
-0.5723981857299805,
0.9798749089241028,
0.017599552869796753,
0.14670655131340027,
-0.30607014894485474,
0.05955483019351959,
-0.2882598638534546,
-0.3032359480857849,
-0.8447262644767761,
-0.3186144232749939,
0.9036322832107544,
0.5714868307113647,
0.27973473072052,
0.863685667514801,
0.5827990174293518,
0.25408872961997986,
0.15527085959911346,
0.1733105331659317,
-0.46096071600914,
0.22399380803108215,
-0.3111039102077484,
-0.5471211075782776,
-0.14956332743167877,
0.11035206913948059,
0.5171074271202087,
0.5862913727760315,
0.008929199539124966,
0.6767155528068542,
0.31833064556121826,
0.6806790828704834,
-0.4548894166946411,
0.07795456796884537,
-0.5697840452194214,
0.219729483127594,
-0.49873751401901245,
-0.383617103099823,
0.1018463522195816,
-0.1747368425130844,
0.05486207455396652,
-0.6707736253738403,
0.11650892347097397,
-0.05520975962281227,
0.5256299376487732,
0.1353217363357544,
-0.35056501626968384,
-0.7252691984176636,
-0.5117052793502808,
0.8188722133636475,
-0.4009464383125305,
0.3734791576862335,
0.3152485489845276,
0.5329505205154419,
-0.48197710514068604,
-0.8797839879989624,
-0.5584237575531006,
-0.09093352407217026,
0.3713802695274353,
0.14855122566223145,
0.3432707190513611,
-0.1466769129037857,
0.10289716720581055,
0.41263240575790405,
-0.5050353407859802,
-0.17522753775119781,
-0.5288634896278381,
0.12474775314331055,
0.8788189888000488,
0.708838164806366,
0.4148622155189514,
0.17963272333145142,
-0.12796372175216675,
-0.08561332523822784,
-0.9444766044616699,
0.21250855922698975,
0.5750687718391418,
0.37738314270973206,
-0.00478471489623189,
1.1259385347366333,
-0.23384696245193481,
0.8874437808990479,
0.019192973151803017,
-0.48155587911605835,
-0.14908383786678314,
-0.379254013299942,
-0.03200841322541237,
0.3965015113353729,
0.6449426412582397,
0.20208881795406342,
0.19498281180858612,
-0.08661334216594696,
-0.23709195852279663,
0.19739660620689392,
0.03728670999407768,
-0.5660846829414368,
-0.20376542210578918,
0.14354081451892853,
-0.3992094397544861,
-0.559502899646759,
-0.06553125381469727,
-0.6341109871864319,
-0.4420195519924164,
0.009047793224453926,
0.5446628928184509,
-0.2378576546907425,
-0.06472132354974747,
0.36734816431999207,
-0.150980144739151,
0.10940869152545929,
0.25928330421447754,
-0.9500742554664612,
0.059531319886446,
0.7760595679283142,
0.47105103731155396,
-0.16055889427661896,
-0.2359929084777832,
-0.4890959858894348,
0.19953802227973938,
-0.28434884548187256,
0.5392963290214539,
-0.8335357308387756,
-0.40427350997924805,
0.14178669452667236,
-0.008716290816664696,
0.2537650167942047,
-0.5093417167663574,
0.3255027234554291,
-0.26114049553871155,
0.5953935384750366,
-0.36391711235046387,
-0.6004438400268555,
-0.255339115858078,
0.34788084030151367,
-0.9758021235466003,
1.136583924293518,
0.0570310615003109,
-0.8705277442932129,
0.4436105191707611,
-0.36382901668548584,
-0.3142692744731903,
0.4481900632381439,
-0.49066317081451416,
-0.24340032041072845,
0.21209436655044556,
0.13641096651554108,
0.18954825401306152,
-0.4832340478897095,
0.17382170259952545,
-0.02982015535235405,
-0.5352925658226013,
0.1087154969573021,
-0.10023579001426697,
0.9397162199020386,
0.1875333935022354,
-0.36447006464004517,
-0.2433849424123764,
-0.6778718829154968,
-0.18479424715042114,
0.3419305682182312,
-0.9623355269432068,
-0.22865262627601624,
0.09577061980962753,
0.09661399573087692,
0.4820150136947632,
0.5828157663345337,
-0.7725826501846313,
0.1409638226032257,
-0.17078082263469696,
-0.29122138023376465,
0.38798946142196655,
-0.0362495519220829,
-0.24398289620876312,
-0.7432325482368469,
0.9862908720970154,
-0.011625758372247219,
-0.4972713887691498,
-0.26197659969329834,
-0.7337741851806641,
-0.9025427103042603,
-0.1169828325510025,
0.3073411285877228,
0.6659179329872131,
-0.6315571665763855,
0.5248932838439941,
-0.10138274729251862,
-0.40737488865852356,
-0.8175691366195679,
0.41065651178359985,
0.2619880139827728,
0.2501697540283203,
-0.026989484205842018,
-0.08102455735206604,
-0.840786874294281,
-0.4667907655239105,
-0.5709677934646606,
0.10702569037675858,
-0.23980812728405,
0.41179728507995605,
0.5166313052177429,
0.31572291254997253,
0.7070437669754028,
0.23269060254096985,
-0.41028448939323425,
-0.5293049812316895,
-0.06295537948608398,
0.207417830824852,
0.4080205261707306,
0.2701019048690796,
-0.32022035121917725,
-0.5705811977386475,
-0.0621199756860733,
-0.8060368299484253,
0.04932112246751785,
-0.09686820954084396,
0.006569967605173588,
0.19945725798606873,
0.3438771963119507,
-0.39008769392967224,
0.3585563898086548,
0.43736201524734497,
-0.7176121473312378,
0.4098816514015198,
0.008204013109207153,
-0.04387343302369118,
-1.3806219100952148,
0.049383074045181274,
-0.17715638875961304,
0.01782330870628357,
-0.28453677892684937,
0.2252143770456314,
-0.406779408454895,
-0.18245290219783783,
-0.4861013889312744,
0.7037057280540466,
-0.5309615135192871,
0.20879319310188293,
-0.25803548097610474,
0.5095074772834778,
-0.2951700687408447,
0.04620729014277458,
0.1970120221376419,
0.7057472467422485,
0.5032907128334045,
-0.39509308338165283,
0.8597100377082825,
0.23972396552562714,
-0.9349184036254883,
0.3920349180698395,
-0.49501898884773254,
0.1656065583229065,
-0.06385805457830429,
-0.010097337886691093,
-0.8438678979873657,
-0.1146397590637207,
0.30190935730934143,
-0.4425797462463379,
0.1443057358264923,
0.28655582666397095,
-0.4168907701969147,
-0.3888554275035858,
-0.19690659642219543,
0.282356321811676,
0.462199330329895,
-0.706059455871582,
0.36047589778900146,
0.49082303047180176,
-0.39188605546951294,
-0.8061730265617371,
-0.5551463961601257,
0.2416774183511734,
-0.426068514585495,
-0.5210914611816406,
-0.1549059897661209,
0.12331552803516388,
-0.3070216774940491,
0.3113707900047302,
-0.21906128525733948,
0.35208600759506226,
0.07223682850599289,
0.037929560989141464,
0.16778485476970673,
-0.4657095670700073,
0.2848886549472809,
0.18249963223934174,
0.12276697158813477,
0.32048627734184265,
-0.24423590302467346,
0.5202623605728149,
0.171670064330101,
-0.2812768816947937,
-0.025575578212738037,
0.6185453534126282,
0.22864697873592377,
-0.21200112998485565,
0.6427721381187439,
0.7776272296905518,
-0.3774401843547821,
-0.16217118501663208,
-0.4073341190814972,
-0.24618174135684967,
-0.5133855938911438,
0.7871130108833313,
-0.6494148969650269,
-1.1841309070587158,
0.5122513771057129,
-0.2247134894132614,
0.39739519357681274,
0.2479885220527649,
0.7388788461685181,
-0.1763055920600891,
1.0027798414230347,
0.5987811088562012,
0.005260787438601255,
0.28293338418006897,
-0.07527633011341095,
0.24484454095363617,
-0.726270854473114,
-0.7145783305168152,
-0.5509015321731567,
-0.5361762642860413,
-0.5509194135665894,
-0.23063358664512634,
0.14884613454341888,
-0.01403203047811985,
-0.1730385720729828,
-0.17538808286190033,
-0.5939003229141235,
0.44916772842407227,
0.7757092714309692,
0.08033272624015808,
0.017841817811131477,
0.4506301283836365,
-0.3563229441642761,
-0.06445793807506561,
-0.8213528394699097,
-0.7026216387748718,
1.4316613674163818,
-0.009358071722090244,
0.9916008710861206,
0.02498812973499298,
1.217036247253418,
0.1703437715768814,
0.0008386718109250069,
-0.7376058101654053,
0.7207964062690735,
-0.12741868197917938,
-0.9672642350196838,
-0.5583732724189758,
-0.11452976614236832,
-1.3087613582611084,
-0.007843713276088238,
-0.6252003908157349,
-0.8865096569061279,
-0.4022388756275177,
-0.03726360574364662,
-0.2722800672054291,
0.37532398104667664,
-0.05177569016814232,
0.7684885263442993,
-0.34747305512428284,
-0.5300745368003845,
-0.4395223557949066,
-0.3411226272583008,
0.5228568315505981,
-0.17461815476417542,
-0.1436079442501068,
0.004316702950745821,
-0.2742811143398285,
1.148290991783142,
-0.10750234872102737,
0.43754836916923523,
0.10657121986150742,
-0.11140680313110352,
0.5916203856468201,
0.14081308245658875,
0.3297569453716278,
-0.022290440276265144,
0.11679815500974655,
-0.2543224096298218,
-0.040905073285102844,
-0.4783032238483429,
-0.36450397968292236,
0.8652827143669128,
-0.8596121072769165,
-1.17133629322052,
-0.48177608847618103,
-0.8715220093727112,
0.19272473454475403,
0.2107914239168167,
0.20024670660495758,
0.2430148422718048,
-0.32449454069137573,
0.28234773874282837,
0.6959396004676819,
-0.3702375888824463,
0.37553051114082336,
0.43344178795814514,
-0.2037612497806549,
-0.3381524682044983,
1.127022385597229,
0.19857989251613617,
-0.23100152611732483,
0.20405811071395874,
0.0703938901424408,
-0.3778534531593323,
-0.3212037980556488,
-0.49993792176246643,
0.2115449607372284,
-0.6089814901351929,
0.10954001545906067,
-0.4781440198421478,
-0.4401187300682068,
-0.14369748532772064,
-0.23822516202926636,
-0.06339754909276962,
-0.5777568817138672,
-0.17512264847755432,
-0.20950457453727722,
0.35861319303512573,
1.1054754257202148,
-0.15580007433891296,
0.3027825951576233,
-0.7324037551879883,
0.31047511100769043,
0.675617516040802,
0.20670969784259796,
-0.23846741020679474,
-0.46742185950279236,
-0.5759721994400024,
0.05361465364694595,
-0.2134850025177002,
-1.006259560585022,
0.2609656751155853,
0.2741887867450714,
0.7306771874427795,
0.6529043316841125,
-0.20879745483398438,
0.11334728449583054,
-0.35066133737564087,
1.0480315685272217,
0.10510885715484619,
-0.5242217779159546,
0.400368869304657,
-0.28743505477905273,
0.42631837725639343,
0.2804063856601715,
0.36433878540992737,
-0.6822793483734131,
-0.436572402715683,
-0.5717903971672058,
-0.7552817463874817,
0.7699325084686279,
0.060398541390895844,
0.1859290450811386,
0.04683779552578926,
0.2228444665670395,
0.35495227575302124,
0.25342434644699097,
-0.3541243374347687,
-0.5917787551879883,
-0.19205519556999207,
-0.6163002848625183,
-0.10669039189815521,
-0.505486786365509,
-0.3331991136074066,
-0.2718767821788788,
0.9326617121696472,
0.2363070398569107,
0.283997118473053,
-0.4408092200756073,
-0.05090494453907013,
-0.4072190225124359,
0.15569908916950226,
0.6925442218780518,
0.6320673823356628,
-0.18093539774417877,
0.19427232444286346,
0.20189927518367767,
-1.056295394897461,
0.3340107798576355,
0.178626149892807,
0.039886750280857086,
0.2014387547969818,
0.3000819981098175,
0.7436355948448181,
-0.2865482270717621,
-0.8315102458000183,
0.06527472287416458,
-0.29006877541542053,
-0.10429339855909348,
-0.46208465099334717,
0.35721269249916077,
0.38122817873954773,
0.3458976149559021,
0.5972023010253906,
-0.8587244749069214,
-0.04210253804922104,
-0.49844875931739807,
0.4588051438331604,
0.68430495262146,
-0.1806369423866272,
-0.05835204944014549,
0.767885148525238,
0.3919578492641449,
-0.8478759527206421,
0.8072384595870972,
0.04018200561404228,
-0.3678894639015198,
0.7424390316009521,
0.8327353596687317,
0.9619657397270203,
-0.3623042106628418,
0.24662812054157257,
0.5585499405860901,
0.5728447437286377,
0.3741646111011505,
0.8580160140991211,
-0.270813912153244,
-0.6472079157829285,
-0.2694498896598816,
-0.5868669748306274,
-0.34601789712905884,
0.7029731273651123,
-0.6010714173316956,
0.4270280599594116,
-0.4060979187488556,
-0.023983241990208626,
-0.2505263686180115,
0.6232527494430542,
-0.7089763283729553,
0.49185696244239807,
0.5112098455429077,
1.1231234073638916,
-0.851417601108551,
1.092374563217163,
1.3225427865982056,
-0.1660917103290558,
-0.7114234566688538,
-0.4076712131500244,
-0.12432553619146347,
-0.8232908844947815,
0.6997887492179871,
0.09089504182338715,
-0.019116230309009552,
0.028303632512688637,
-0.6368452310562134,
-0.9045215845108032,
0.9576725959777832,
0.014254441484808922,
-0.7463041543960571,
-0.0014895156491547823,
0.7618129849433899,
0.2667728066444397,
-0.7688568830490112,
0.07175876200199127,
0.654361367225647,
0.40223249793052673,
-0.11748113483190536,
-0.3974170684814453,
0.09193229675292969,
-0.5120490193367004,
-0.2244596779346466,
-0.08811860531568527,
-0.32121407985687256,
0.6420530676841736,
-0.2609862685203552,
-0.13312673568725586,
0.14211098849773407,
0.838943600654602,
0.7016388773918152,
0.3385677933692932,
0.27133673429489136,
0.94745272397995,
0.37017008662223816,
-0.15729038417339325,
0.5830560922622681,
-0.7694773077964783,
-0.008839468471705914,
1.2920438051223755,
0.18133752048015594,
0.38966456055641174,
0.8517739176750183,
-0.05873550474643707,
0.40803641080856323,
0.9662033915519714,
0.0649586021900177,
0.546188235282898,
0.2398589700460434,
-0.6668196320533752,
-0.6299952864646912,
-0.07676368951797485,
-0.5781198143959045,
0.527898371219635,
0.7588502168655396,
-0.3911803662776947,
-0.575694739818573,
-0.17919786274433136,
-0.05049300193786621,
-0.08855544030666351,
-0.3261927664279938,
0.5324745178222656,
0.2576065957546234,
-0.4739838242530823,
0.2901802957057953,
-0.07920808345079422,
0.3926321566104889,
-0.4924739599227905,
-0.34869185090065,
-0.40291017293930054,
0.13370047509670258,
0.14940111339092255,
-0.8689693808555603,
-0.1215134710073471,
-0.01568756252527237,
0.35763099789619446,
0.2982962429523468,
0.5959129929542542,
-0.98610520362854,
-0.7478416562080383,
-0.17914575338363647,
0.5128803253173828,
0.35989710688591003,
0.4127027690410614,
-0.7416307926177979,
0.007557070814073086,
-0.06277652084827423,
-0.46874213218688965,
0.33246150612831116,
0.8221350908279419,
0.05852905288338661,
0.6628320217132568,
0.35656604170799255,
0.28502726554870605,
0.5190016627311707,
-0.4876973330974579,
0.7551842927932739,
-0.7766546607017517,
-0.5150636434555054,
-0.5359018445014954,
0.5430952906608582,
0.128742054104805,
-0.5518038868904114,
0.9366970658302307,
0.6605449914932251,
1.0859754085540771,
-0.1769181787967682,
1.1745566129684448,
-0.09853904694318771,
0.29567477107048035,
-0.09912052005529404,
0.8142264485359192,
-0.7818461060523987,
0.028262576088309288,
0.031599026173353195,
-0.9830114841461182,
-0.038235850632190704,
0.7146211266517639,
0.08795417100191116,
-0.00791887752711773,
0.5752902030944824,
0.5746551156044006,
0.0034890840761363506,
-0.09193432331085205,
0.42920395731925964,
-0.22975929081439972,
-0.11242955178022385,
0.8161154985427856,
1.007572889328003,
-0.4581783711910248,
0.55743008852005,
-0.3949367105960846,
0.04017340764403343,
-0.3290323317050934,
-0.41562050580978394,
-1.5969305038452148,
-0.6429054141044617,
-0.07606105506420135,
-0.4811854064464569,
0.39924466609954834,
1.0041978359222412,
0.0743190124630928,
-0.8246461153030396,
-0.5366452932357788,
0.09026294946670532,
0.23652957379817963,
-0.2526867985725403,
-0.1503904163837433,
0.40849441289901733,
-0.21748748421669006,
-0.8066974878311157,
0.25820931792259216,
-0.009584312327206135,
0.010699937120079994,
-0.5774934887886047,
-0.15292580425739288,
-0.3473637104034424,
0.5059348344802856,
0.2726406455039978,
0.28276750445365906,
-0.666492760181427,
-0.3249536156654358,
0.05070824176073074,
-0.16388952732086182,
-0.2880686819553375,
0.7959432601928711,
-0.9180417060852051,
0.8643175959587097,
0.6376963257789612,
0.5923042893409729,
0.493280291557312,
-0.35858145356178284,
0.4397149384021759,
-0.32592999935150146,
0.33789506554603577,
0.04358169063925743,
0.21219731867313385,
0.2292175590991974,
-0.4010942876338959,
0.3501535952091217,
0.008509297855198383,
-0.24159666895866394,
-0.8138777613639832,
0.20709702372550964,
-0.6292877793312073,
0.18993715941905975,
0.8710027933120728,
-0.2990701198577881,
-0.45750781893730164,
-0.21329140663146973,
-0.0213814415037632,
0.7070429921150208,
-0.14546766877174377,
1.449580430984497,
0.8048094511032104,
0.15944749116897583,
-0.2789076268672943,
-0.09195742011070251,
0.5967779159545898,
0.4104323387145996,
-0.5192651748657227,
-0.35972294211387634,
0.13317860662937164,
0.3723832964897156,
-0.1751915067434311,
0.1507381945848465,
-0.08927076309919357,
0.5785173177719116,
0.3005993366241455,
0.3110143840312958,
-0.3973942995071411,
-0.47025924921035767,
-0.32714900374412537,
0.08140088617801666,
-0.11187702417373657,
-0.6049604415893555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08017v1
|
Translating Expert Intuition into Quantifiable Features: Encode Investigator Domain Knowledge via LLM for Enhanced Predictive Analytics
| 2024-05-11T13:23:43 | 2024-05-11T13:23:43 |
Phoebe Jing, Yijing Gao, Yuanhang Zhang, Xianlong Zeng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the realm of predictive analytics, the nuanced domain knowledge of
investigators often remains underutilized, confined largely to subjective
interpretations and ad hoc decision-making. This paper explores the potential
of Large Language Models (LLMs) to bridge this gap by systematically converting
investigator-derived insights into quantifiable, actionable features that
enhance model performance. We present a framework that leverages LLMs' natural
language understanding capabilities to encode these red flags into a structured
feature set that can be readily integrated into existing predictive models.
Through a series of case studies, we demonstrate how this approach not only
preserves the critical human expertise within the investigative process but
also scales the impact of this knowledge across various prediction tasks. The
results indicate significant improvements in risk assessment and
decision-making accuracy, highlighting the value of blending human experiential
knowledge with advanced machine learning techniques. This study paves the way
for more sophisticated, knowledge-driven analytics in fields where expert
insight is paramount.
|
[
-0.12275280058383942,
-0.5370568633079529,
0.9564952254295349,
-0.16200760006904602,
0.033943720161914825,
0.3358195126056671,
-0.17189756035804749,
-0.7862810492515564,
0.23005999624729156,
0.9324887990951538,
-0.4556468427181244,
-0.6232708692550659,
-0.806643545627594,
-0.0730270966887474,
-0.4484095573425293,
0.8723157644271851,
0.003991849720478058,
0.03922322019934654,
-0.3591690957546234,
0.012437651865184307,
-0.15947788953781128,
-0.8463840484619141,
-0.624613344669342,
-0.18860767781734467,
0.40000519156455994,
0.27452531456947327,
0.5042707920074463,
0.561572790145874,
0.9820561408996582,
0.25639045238494873,
0.07548263669013977,
0.36418068408966064,
-0.44126084446907043,
-0.077825628221035,
-0.045418497174978256,
-0.6710473299026489,
-0.8463290333747864,
0.03705168142914772,
0.13671597838401794,
0.7310410141944885,
-0.14403702318668365,
0.19486156105995178,
-0.02836601622402668,
0.4858468472957611,
-0.6262285113334656,
0.4795486032962799,
-0.8268550038337708,
-0.12821047008037567,
0.08627407997846603,
-0.3665744662284851,
-0.4126421809196472,
-0.2577590048313141,
0.590141236782074,
-0.6632789373397827,
0.1645108312368393,
-0.014164570719003677,
0.4882737994194031,
0.5199902057647705,
-0.5287871360778809,
-0.19932153820991516,
-0.7289987802505493,
0.8045566082000732,
-0.6141632199287415,
-0.05147022381424904,
0.44798943400382996,
0.5224802494049072,
-0.08299494534730911,
-0.5759307742118835,
-0.20367828011512756,
-0.15142162144184113,
-0.13868951797485352,
-0.07876825332641602,
-0.2159482091665268,
0.1593122035264969,
0.09699451923370361,
-0.002823563991114497,
-0.1355169713497162,
0.346217542886734,
-0.22018860280513763,
-0.1960233449935913,
1.0891326665878296,
0.3372771739959717,
-0.2530193328857422,
0.32862022519111633,
0.045886505395174026,
-0.042952511459589005,
-0.6877568960189819,
0.019208010286092758,
0.2229512482881546,
0.29507192969322205,
-0.17660032212734222,
0.42875051498413086,
-0.4275456666946411,
0.4778197705745697,
-0.027060849592089653,
-0.05580103397369385,
0.17428500950336456,
-0.2677423357963562,
-0.18130919337272644,
0.15691062808036804,
0.5802718997001648,
0.19928136467933655,
0.412544310092926,
-0.041103072464466095,
-0.13825297355651855,
0.08950420469045639,
0.3969448208808899,
-0.8124342560768127,
-0.43796423077583313,
0.3507322072982788,
-0.3353268802165985,
-0.5826990604400635,
0.056009892374277115,
-0.8110954165458679,
-0.6989282965660095,
-0.2571771442890167,
0.1516498625278473,
-0.4187542498111725,
-0.2934374213218689,
0.3785387873649597,
-0.06747602671384811,
0.12728767096996307,
0.6793447732925415,
-0.6499482989311218,
0.11393396556377411,
0.8378490209579468,
0.49264901876449585,
-0.032536353915929794,
0.046788718551397324,
-0.6025180816650391,
0.21349379420280457,
-0.43742504715919495,
0.7383542060852051,
-0.7924634218215942,
-0.2973979115486145,
0.21566368639469147,
-0.30382561683654785,
0.2879254221916199,
-0.4037605822086334,
0.39519861340522766,
-0.5813920497894287,
-0.003651520935818553,
-0.0030172213446348906,
-0.4593502879142761,
-0.4518264830112457,
0.3276364505290985,
-0.5199493765830994,
0.7707459926605225,
0.11069085448980331,
-0.4567440450191498,
0.7117966413497925,
-0.7405315041542053,
-0.4315296709537506,
0.2836419641971588,
-0.11846745759248734,
-0.6557806730270386,
0.3295346200466156,
0.4516465961933136,
0.7997205257415771,
-0.2834321856498718,
0.590614378452301,
-0.49516576528549194,
0.09992745518684387,
0.6624410152435303,
-0.15418128669261932,
0.4442221224308014,
0.12424759566783905,
-0.10486426949501038,
0.23286032676696777,
-0.784111738204956,
-0.04173315688967705,
-0.0453135147690773,
-0.21892699599266052,
-0.3624688982963562,
0.21825221180915833,
-0.11762112379074097,
-0.14309971034526825,
0.16196560859680176,
-0.3735629618167877,
-0.0455121174454689,
-0.358882874250412,
0.4344761371612549,
0.5311425924301147,
0.21409885585308075,
0.5545417070388794,
-0.08197234570980072,
0.5781000256538391,
-0.06613212823867798,
0.055986467748880386,
-0.17196078598499298,
-0.4925273060798645,
-0.6886181235313416,
-0.31968361139297485,
0.08428455889225006,
0.5640063881874084,
-0.6573050618171692,
0.5392457246780396,
-0.4186955690383911,
-0.45266488194465637,
-0.695685088634491,
0.0018763686530292034,
0.4288657009601593,
0.3802630603313446,
0.3059031665325165,
-0.13779693841934204,
-0.7394366264343262,
-0.7893383502960205,
-0.45671340823173523,
-0.2699550986289978,
-0.20905348658561707,
0.26216012239456177,
0.8275307416915894,
-0.3261488080024719,
1.0772387981414795,
-0.7278239727020264,
-0.44566407799720764,
-0.3721409738063812,
0.35512039065361023,
0.2751655578613281,
0.3968065679073334,
0.22453317046165466,
-0.9355839490890503,
-0.30195891857147217,
0.35641980171203613,
-1.081878900527954,
-0.036593131721019745,
-0.21766912937164307,
0.1354665756225586,
-0.046102557331323624,
0.5868568420410156,
-0.45615577697753906,
0.3941439986228943,
0.31696027517318726,
-0.5246937274932861,
0.5640979409217834,
-0.1319120228290558,
0.26845231652259827,
-0.7379674315452576,
-0.06405695527791977,
0.36897042393684387,
-0.13954384624958038,
-0.8806216716766357,
0.12311042845249176,
0.2000272572040558,
-0.0362689308822155,
-0.24449890851974487,
0.6285528540611267,
-0.5291575193405151,
-0.10307827591896057,
-0.00340855959802866,
-0.13009050488471985,
0.016955487430095673,
0.2466963827610016,
0.23365139961242676,
0.4911743402481079,
0.5285905003547668,
-0.40879422426223755,
0.28049176931381226,
0.20973961055278778,
-0.6821610927581787,
0.4805939197540283,
-0.4958034157752991,
-0.04298897460103035,
0.04659190773963928,
-0.09373258054256439,
-0.43755972385406494,
-0.5897747874259949,
-0.3071891665458679,
-0.9020286798477173,
0.45531153678894043,
-0.21330894529819489,
-0.37018468976020813,
-0.2951918840408325,
-0.1161273941397667,
0.09843911975622177,
0.5450291633605957,
-0.17933905124664307,
0.8807459473609924,
0.5752500295639038,
-0.3696795105934143,
-0.5040633678436279,
-0.7182392477989197,
0.41350623965263367,
-0.5847233533859253,
-0.5818963646888733,
0.11965575814247131,
0.20126929879188538,
-0.6685536503791809,
-0.08600002527236938,
0.16759523749351501,
-0.22555877268314362,
0.44054675102233887,
0.31172895431518555,
0.4136366844177246,
-0.18735527992248535,
0.1168709322810173,
-0.13740114867687225,
-0.14961758255958557,
0.4970221519470215,
-0.3703320622444153,
-0.008508407510817051,
-0.05027610808610916,
-0.2790299952030182,
-0.33951160311698914,
0.3459646701812744,
0.6925751566886902,
-0.573556125164032,
0.7950445413589478,
0.4848729074001312,
-0.3866589665412903,
-0.19214487075805664,
-0.8374788165092468,
-0.3654278516769409,
-0.43925386667251587,
0.7810388803482056,
-0.3697046935558319,
-1.1601544618606567,
0.6984983086585999,
-0.2152935415506363,
-0.16791172325611115,
0.3300318419933319,
0.34511712193489075,
-0.35965800285339355,
1.0623236894607544,
1.0090409517288208,
-0.06334076076745987,
0.28002843260765076,
-0.36055415868759155,
0.4207237958908081,
-0.6914229989051819,
-0.4581291377544403,
-0.4399843215942383,
0.12622587382793427,
-0.31744903326034546,
-0.6435562372207642,
0.6787227988243103,
-0.16193804144859314,
-0.14595922827720642,
-0.09334366768598557,
-0.2467023879289627,
0.4178439676761627,
0.20023968815803528,
0.14620012044906616,
0.32586678862571716,
-0.07166590541601181,
0.5907800793647766,
0.03419191762804985,
-0.5418577194213867,
-0.6031057834625244,
1.4658303260803223,
0.736088216304779,
0.7072979807853699,
-0.08306420594453812,
0.5309498310089111,
0.4967644214630127,
0.3844137489795685,
-0.7593586444854736,
0.4753609895706177,
-0.07728568464517593,
-0.42300793528556824,
-0.5336690545082092,
-0.3499409854412079,
-0.4801435172557831,
0.052510954439640045,
-0.597507894039154,
-0.43471184372901917,
0.20833677053451538,
0.16458824276924133,
-0.4821220636367798,
0.21628637611865997,
-0.5196564793586731,
0.5599308609962463,
-0.4131067395210266,
-0.26570001244544983,
-0.3621937930583954,
-0.22755053639411926,
0.26929202675819397,
-0.4705906808376312,
0.3515089154243469,
-0.06339377909898758,
-0.2911871075630188,
0.7618579864501953,
-0.07921742647886276,
1.1038477420806885,
-0.11780103296041489,
-0.21945440769195557,
0.25627580285072327,
0.24955429136753082,
0.8282363414764404,
0.15444791316986084,
-0.29668569564819336,
0.38675346970558167,
-0.4530861973762512,
-0.246347114443779,
-0.557127833366394,
0.33802008628845215,
-0.5521938800811768,
-0.6973809003829956,
-0.12429484724998474,
-0.5514277219772339,
-0.36858439445495605,
-0.014819850213825703,
-0.03163692355155945,
0.3857375383377075,
-0.28242525458335876,
0.1960010826587677,
0.9866001605987549,
-0.14238588511943817,
0.1763560175895691,
0.6621909141540527,
0.2996980547904968,
-0.2930610477924347,
0.5848309397697449,
-0.19485540688037872,
0.10561484843492508,
0.6855180263519287,
0.059856005012989044,
-0.2055240124464035,
-1.3325459957122803,
-0.07401953637599945,
0.09997048228979111,
-0.7816343307495117,
-0.40162575244903564,
-0.9072852730751038,
0.0940413698554039,
-0.5213356614112854,
-0.5316482186317444,
-0.25323131680488586,
-0.07894550263881683,
-0.45647886395454407,
-0.48861950635910034,
0.5480722784996033,
0.6056766510009766,
0.19101093709468842,
0.40775322914123535,
-0.8861505389213562,
-0.0029466066043823957,
0.19754064083099365,
0.17307330667972565,
-0.15892784297466278,
-0.5779663920402527,
-0.7090822458267212,
-0.12938454747200012,
0.23409591615200043,
-0.5215928554534912,
0.9321773648262024,
0.09328944236040115,
0.677476704120636,
0.5125678777694702,
-0.01740371808409691,
0.4888317584991455,
-0.25412753224372864,
0.5725703835487366,
0.23774728178977966,
-0.8380118012428284,
0.7347586154937744,
-0.6269603371620178,
0.030637875199317932,
0.5734755396842957,
0.464522123336792,
-0.07657438516616821,
-0.4172506630420685,
-0.34376025199890137,
-0.625613272190094,
0.5583570003509521,
-0.08609567582607269,
-0.15746404230594635,
0.18201123178005219,
0.2750037908554077,
0.21642018854618073,
0.27484360337257385,
-0.5685150623321533,
0.3636326193809509,
0.21239900588989258,
-0.22767333686351776,
-0.24775294959545135,
-0.5057626962661743,
-0.34627437591552734,
-0.09620693325996399,
0.40343034267425537,
-0.5088422298431396,
0.09048450738191605,
0.15902552008628845,
-0.18497470021247864,
-0.020437777042388916,
0.2936544120311737,
0.3561685383319855,
0.8291422724723816,
-0.4714964032173157,
0.04907352849841118,
0.38651442527770996,
-0.3531434237957001,
-0.15833541750907898,
-0.13949553668498993,
0.17962530255317688,
-0.3467719554901123,
1.050544261932373,
0.6600536108016968,
0.16376277804374695,
-0.9223839640617371,
0.43008580803871155,
0.16420738399028778,
-0.41752389073371887,
-0.6274925470352173,
0.019732903689146042,
-0.0304575152695179,
0.39259299635887146,
0.6407690644264221,
0.021817687898874283,
0.33327221870422363,
-0.6033269762992859,
0.07613859325647354,
0.49842047691345215,
-0.4356937110424042,
-0.26553234457969666,
0.5044841766357422,
0.6957789659500122,
-0.040751855820417404,
0.40788713097572327,
-0.002919120015576482,
-0.5787216424942017,
0.9252786636352539,
0.0038296375423669815,
1.1451956033706665,
-0.1333584487438202,
0.04580097272992134,
0.22726674377918243,
0.3892107307910919,
-0.09270495176315308,
0.12942080199718475,
0.1354243904352188,
-0.7235440015792847,
-0.7173023223876953,
-0.6938300728797913,
-0.443350225687027,
-0.10526618361473083,
-0.775033712387085,
0.1341441422700882,
-0.43735361099243164,
-0.11543114483356476,
0.06425561755895615,
-0.07329980283975601,
-0.7924577593803406,
0.2527481019496918,
0.26148682832717896,
1.0239100456237793,
-0.9440672993659973,
0.8790421485900879,
0.48365652561187744,
-0.030676351860165596,
-0.41265225410461426,
-0.2992364764213562,
0.09838367998600006,
-0.8642184734344482,
0.9697293639183044,
0.09868991374969482,
-0.07956046611070633,
-0.2672140598297119,
-0.568750262260437,
-0.8969228267669678,
1.1069839000701904,
0.07374256104230881,
-0.7183875441551208,
0.009342909790575504,
0.17986834049224854,
0.7188312411308289,
-0.8932012319564819,
0.19406719505786896,
1.0480284690856934,
0.4615148603916168,
-0.02039373852312565,
-0.8460962176322937,
0.013446533121168613,
0.029161551967263222,
-0.2261030524969101,
0.3790333867073059,
-0.06635285168886185,
0.4747343063354492,
-0.6759259104728699,
-0.05872316285967827,
-0.3289671838283539,
0.6782532334327698,
-0.11508514732122421,
0.5718885660171509,
0.08993300795555115,
0.5531392693519592,
0.798064649105072,
-0.049996085464954376,
1.1456098556518555,
-0.010905484668910503,
0.1038367971777916,
1.0619980096817017,
-0.37679407000541687,
0.8605411648750305,
0.33014047145843506,
-0.3141908645629883,
0.5581343173980713,
0.41927921772003174,
-0.23407526314258575,
0.525658905506134,
-0.10715245455503464,
-0.2464301437139511,
-0.5972223877906799,
-0.12819282710552216,
0.022982709109783173,
0.6721184849739075,
0.8306186199188232,
-0.45401495695114136,
0.2804239094257355,
0.05259944126009941,
-0.10154315829277039,
0.27138447761535645,
-0.7713942527770996,
0.9907251000404358,
0.023697352036833763,
-0.5031108260154724,
0.16230611503124237,
-0.16732294857501984,
0.8491623401641846,
-0.7364335060119629,
-0.19627662003040314,
-0.06762364506721497,
0.21020786464214325,
-0.29854467511177063,
-1.0877633094787598,
0.2574067711830139,
0.032190337777137756,
-0.1462010145187378,
-0.41432473063468933,
0.666500985622406,
-0.24587954580783844,
-0.5808714628219604,
0.38335368037223816,
0.47637367248535156,
-0.07083053886890411,
-0.38242459297180176,
-0.4281870722770691,
-0.09417755901813507,
0.18869827687740326,
-0.10903256386518478,
0.3848419785499573,
0.5955138206481934,
-0.126582533121109,
1.1356946229934692,
0.6589556932449341,
0.45494768023490906,
-0.30594179034233093,
-0.050601668655872345,
0.8211976885795593,
-0.7964360117912292,
-0.5228556394577026,
-0.9055366516113281,
0.728270947933197,
-0.21175214648246765,
0.026471955701708794,
0.6147786378860474,
0.22709573805332184,
0.6110342144966125,
-0.1903957724571228,
0.963439404964447,
0.3542975187301636,
0.5213217735290527,
-0.6714869737625122,
0.6610038876533508,
-0.22694574296474457,
0.46300992369651794,
0.010133715346455574,
-0.43266311287879944,
-0.3109857738018036,
0.1839868277311325,
-0.5677492618560791,
-0.13117122650146484,
0.4287925362586975,
0.6150506734848022,
0.29163339734077454,
-0.28677958250045776,
0.6072458028793335,
0.17464368045330048,
0.5873198509216309,
0.6754761934280396,
0.7657649517059326,
-0.0007650713087059557,
0.44033676385879517,
-0.015295087359845638,
-0.4474194347858429,
-0.5196559429168701,
-1.0130501985549927,
-1.2286553382873535,
-0.4110179841518402,
-0.488328218460083,
0.030406219884753227,
0.010971330106258392,
0.3858734965324402,
0.8107333779335022,
-0.7674821019172668,
-0.02207733318209648,
0.12636658549308777,
-0.02212057076394558,
-0.004617422819137573,
-0.22223205864429474,
0.36729878187179565,
-0.1064472422003746,
-0.4093126356601715,
0.3626278042793274,
0.5736297965049744,
0.08394068479537964,
-0.35528889298439026,
-0.051708463579416275,
0.2396850287914276,
0.0926746129989624,
0.7181575298309326,
-0.0032757578883320093,
-0.6437777280807495,
-0.2093551754951477,
-0.06297524273395538,
0.18511828780174255,
-0.3204520046710968,
0.9442139863967896,
-1.0051989555358887,
0.3795846700668335,
0.23105931282043457,
0.7876392602920532,
0.44383949041366577,
-0.15359161794185638,
0.8078269362449646,
-0.5653486251831055,
0.07125820964574814,
0.6170037388801575,
0.45306891202926636,
0.30251365900039673,
-0.8383209109306335,
0.7890856862068176,
-0.18541038036346436,
-0.48328882455825806,
-0.915369987487793,
0.11700309813022614,
-0.8220574259757996,
-0.38680461049079895,
1.0117146968841553,
-0.323885977268219,
0.006562183145433664,
-0.3691989779472351,
0.24583648145198822,
-0.09648045897483826,
-0.500910758972168,
0.914178729057312,
0.46480175852775574,
-0.24000443518161774,
-0.26530325412750244,
-0.7494378089904785,
0.6872272491455078,
0.24800719320774078,
-1.109634518623352,
0.4404960870742798,
0.5187076926231384,
-0.006901801098138094,
0.16423320770263672,
0.2859477698802948,
-0.04914424940943718,
0.2625311017036438,
-0.013931631110608578,
0.23197752237319946,
-0.35815027356147766,
-0.40526121854782104,
-0.5473871827125549,
0.20867414772510529,
0.10705529898405075,
0.23618273437023163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07010v1
|
Deciphering public attention to geoengineering and climate issues using machine learning and dynamic analysis
| 2024-05-11T13:10:57 | 2024-05-11T13:10:57 |
Ramit Debnath, Pengyu Zhang, Tianzhu Qin, R. Michael Alvarez, Shaun D. Fitzgerald
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, J.4; K.4
|
As the conversation around using geoengineering to combat climate change
intensifies, it is imperative to engage the public and deeply understand their
perspectives on geoengineering research, development, and potential deployment.
Through a comprehensive data-driven investigation, this paper explores the
types of news that captivate public interest in geoengineering. We delved into
30,773 English-language news articles from the BBC and the New York Times,
combined with Google Trends data spanning 2018 to 2022, to explore how public
interest in geoengineering fluctuates in response to news coverage of broader
climate issues. Using BERT-based topic modeling, sentiment analysis, and
time-series regression models, we found that positive sentiment in
energy-related news serves as a good predictor of heightened public interest in
geoengineering, a trend that persists over time. Our findings suggest that
public engagement with geoengineering and climate action is not uniform, with
some topics being more potent in shaping interest over time, such as climate
news related to energy, disasters, and politics. Understanding these patterns
is crucial for scientists, policymakers, and educators aiming to craft
effective strategies for engaging with the public and fostering dialogue around
emerging climate technologies.
|
[
-0.6991121172904968,
-0.8876965641975403,
0.9761689901351929,
0.26674750447273254,
-0.2012157291173935,
0.11347775161266327,
-0.19173622131347656,
-0.21671035885810852,
0.29050490260124207,
-0.011282961815595627,
-0.5464560985565186,
-0.6305830478668213,
-0.6027442812919617,
-0.33300086855888367,
-0.658892035484314,
1.0963045358657837,
-0.2314874827861786,
-0.20319995284080505,
-0.0808677151799202,
0.2571737766265869,
-0.2064930945634842,
-0.4380430579185486,
-0.11025599390268326,
-0.20870022475719452,
1.0333842039108276,
0.1152777448296547,
0.7342467308044434,
0.3769736588001251,
0.2678992450237274,
0.21074630320072174,
-0.46789461374282837,
-0.2795126438140869,
-0.5855399966239929,
-0.23128461837768555,
-0.18714317679405212,
-0.14632588624954224,
0.18329551815986633,
0.7017916440963745,
0.6981019973754883,
0.5653926730155945,
0.1640087515115738,
0.44563984870910645,
0.07118821889162064,
0.40965452790260315,
-0.5601252913475037,
0.39939090609550476,
-0.865572988986969,
-0.10487348586320877,
-0.10214874893426895,
-0.15399226546287537,
-0.10470106452703476,
-0.36422616243362427,
0.3776758909225464,
-0.4732188582420349,
0.5149758458137512,
0.04296313226222992,
0.8951784372329712,
0.40089553594589233,
-0.38756704330444336,
-0.14038096368312836,
-0.4765474200248718,
0.932238757610321,
-0.32831716537475586,
0.3486327528953552,
0.11997221410274506,
0.14851216971874237,
-0.2233324944972992,
-0.1404629945755005,
-0.6527784466743469,
-0.03540795296430588,
-0.10540463775396347,
0.209248349070549,
0.20499658584594727,
-0.3121299743652344,
0.1875840276479721,
0.16217607259750366,
-0.6782634854316711,
0.004383731633424759,
-0.2556155323982239,
-0.025772666558623314,
0.5238203406333923,
-0.17849987745285034,
0.12636226415634155,
-0.4235791862010956,
-0.5518578886985779,
-0.019387004896998405,
-0.6540641784667969,
0.19999518990516663,
0.9061933159828186,
0.29064881801605225,
-0.23277300596237183,
0.3886657655239105,
-0.1839546114206314,
0.39272579550743103,
-0.2737591862678528,
0.48716506361961365,
0.0012816129019483924,
-0.17635898292064667,
-0.3287358283996582,
0.508410632610321,
0.3148225247859955,
0.48188960552215576,
-0.09472842514514923,
-0.22573840618133545,
0.30413907766342163,
-0.08151139318943024,
0.32246699929237366,
-0.6779571771621704,
-0.15149860084056854,
0.31200650334358215,
-0.6233435273170471,
-0.4721393585205078,
0.6428263187408447,
-1.1345059871673584,
-0.6990293264389038,
-0.5119451880455017,
-0.037433840334415436,
0.5838836431503296,
-0.3270934820175171,
0.35729196667671204,
-0.528631865978241,
0.24074850976467133,
0.5026219487190247,
-0.46105504035949707,
-0.4324096143245697,
0.9952874183654785,
0.7665678858757019,
0.15978139638900757,
-0.2603984475135803,
-0.0023400159552693367,
0.00909141730517149,
-0.2377462387084961,
0.7420561909675598,
-0.7269728183746338,
-0.4432317018508911,
-0.05494654178619385,
0.44481655955314636,
-0.09483245760202408,
0.0749511644244194,
0.10080479830503464,
-0.7515218257904053,
0.7387814521789551,
-0.4243709146976471,
-0.05119926854968071,
-0.6260458827018738,
0.24460266530513763,
-0.4736543893814087,
0.8531714081764221,
-0.11071707308292389,
-0.8296089768409729,
0.7084233164787292,
-0.7336530685424805,
-0.25784116983413696,
-0.20007264614105225,
0.03546725958585739,
-0.6292094588279724,
0.25487494468688965,
0.21931259334087372,
0.20268166065216064,
-0.2152102291584015,
0.5727787613868713,
-0.4359165132045746,
-0.12366627901792526,
0.17128750681877136,
-0.4237053394317627,
0.3330640196800232,
0.024643275886774063,
-0.5118158459663391,
0.04573182016611099,
-0.3690620958805084,
-0.16736894845962524,
-0.09737797826528549,
-0.20026661455631256,
-0.13384288549423218,
0.506766140460968,
0.026232076808810234,
0.2508930265903473,
0.2621806263923645,
-0.5663160681724548,
0.30683764815330505,
-0.35160768032073975,
0.6361854672431946,
0.6460049152374268,
0.577648937702179,
0.3114144504070282,
-0.236740842461586,
0.37654146552085876,
-0.12650196254253387,
0.10189032554626465,
-0.21392494440078735,
-0.5846601724624634,
-0.5057997107505798,
0.24314922094345093,
0.0369330570101738,
0.4704771637916565,
-0.08962562680244446,
0.2020540088415146,
-0.18906593322753906,
-0.7976732850074768,
-0.44912177324295044,
-0.1182955950498581,
-0.24523702263832092,
0.4787674844264984,
0.3691597878932953,
0.1809156984090805,
-0.28478899598121643,
-0.4454023241996765,
-0.590457022190094,
-0.11544426530599594,
0.032852571457624435,
0.5484146475791931,
0.14140674471855164,
-0.04638553410768509,
1.0245519876480103,
-0.6463955044746399,
0.32482439279556274,
0.16181841492652893,
0.8777035474777222,
0.41182413697242737,
0.11885404586791992,
0.8241007924079895,
-1.1452864408493042,
-0.3684349060058594,
0.26147305965423584,
-0.25612974166870117,
0.28550347685813904,
-0.2408975213766098,
0.07489468157291412,
-0.03088829480111599,
0.39964810013771057,
-0.27541565895080566,
0.46330803632736206,
0.3713204562664032,
-0.21149945259094238,
0.2612687349319458,
0.16660915315151215,
0.7144668698310852,
-0.5686142444610596,
0.19996680319309235,
0.30667001008987427,
-0.008249031379818916,
-0.408552348613739,
-0.49651283025741577,
-0.35916557908058167,
-0.7538061141967773,
-0.6085252165794373,
0.4129427969455719,
-0.255303293466568,
-0.06878061592578888,
-0.3096911907196045,
-0.011067206971347332,
-0.08011835068464279,
-0.029435038566589355,
0.24633026123046875,
0.6208811402320862,
0.7879050374031067,
-0.414910227060318,
0.49333804845809937,
-0.025367792695760727,
-0.6305086016654968,
-0.3998062014579773,
-0.5664965510368347,
0.3303700089454651,
-0.4661131203174591,
0.2992313802242279,
-0.9319478273391724,
-0.6468110084533691,
-0.2225404977798462,
-0.5205341577529907,
0.004761026706546545,
-0.19297510385513306,
-0.3311016857624054,
-0.7755436897277832,
-0.29274266958236694,
-0.3416163921356201,
0.3242512047290802,
-0.6024659276008606,
0.5329152345657349,
0.23432853817939758,
-0.370270311832428,
-0.3493209779262543,
-0.6696602702140808,
-0.0042741987854242325,
-0.47517383098602295,
-0.4833745062351227,
0.1749478131532669,
0.2685823440551758,
-0.21520908176898956,
0.1336248815059662,
-0.4422071874141693,
-0.016877636313438416,
0.6441063284873962,
0.2209520936012268,
-0.11027911305427551,
-0.011330499313771725,
0.041645340621471405,
-0.3669818937778473,
-0.24836303293704987,
0.4219018816947937,
-0.3861427307128906,
0.6041854023933411,
0.13064834475517273,
-0.28379860520362854,
-0.6415405869483948,
0.3130895793437958,
0.814785897731781,
-0.06246285140514374,
0.6490174531936646,
0.6757512092590332,
-0.1919376254081726,
0.031952228397130966,
-0.22484256327152252,
-0.343976229429245,
-0.44862738251686096,
0.36529555916786194,
0.2732066810131073,
-0.7603520154953003,
0.26967257261276245,
-0.4656069278717041,
0.06787971407175064,
0.2873688042163849,
0.5584485530853271,
-0.23078694939613342,
1.246664047241211,
0.579217791557312,
-0.5894465446472168,
0.6221519112586975,
-0.09403841942548752,
0.49622324109077454,
-0.3551988899707794,
-0.20563608407974243,
-0.6385395526885986,
-0.5625588893890381,
-0.8243675231933594,
0.1711706966161728,
0.1266125738620758,
-0.2042853981256485,
-0.10888674855232239,
0.15918709337711334,
-0.6398758888244629,
0.4727054238319397,
0.35053005814552307,
-0.07616420090198517,
-0.3276665508747101,
0.06557149440050125,
0.7030783295631409,
0.1251658946275711,
-0.19782714545726776,
-0.5090093016624451,
0.42720723152160645,
0.1676555573940277,
0.6311023831367493,
0.09029574692249298,
0.3350372016429901,
0.4734728932380676,
0.2678283154964447,
-0.8750171661376953,
0.21356602013111115,
0.13985805213451385,
-0.6193341016769409,
-0.19043251872062683,
-0.3894561231136322,
-0.9284542798995972,
-0.11450175195932388,
-0.20196311175823212,
-0.605449914932251,
0.33081111311912537,
0.22641566395759583,
-0.24463529884815216,
0.40356138348579407,
-0.7314252257347107,
0.7106074094772339,
-0.19132563471794128,
-0.10644455254077911,
-0.6316645741462708,
-0.486421138048172,
-0.040193747729063034,
-0.015567304566502571,
0.30713099241256714,
-0.39789828658103943,
0.24349761009216309,
0.21606534719467163,
0.09104958921670914,
0.6585121750831604,
-0.45479920506477356,
-0.10366993397474289,
0.2641979455947876,
-0.37258708477020264,
0.5243381857872009,
0.36847123503685,
-0.19814534485340118,
-0.08146628737449646,
-0.6877408027648926,
-0.46835675835609436,
-0.44196560978889465,
0.9501999020576477,
-0.7841301560401917,
-1.149230718612671,
-0.4388638138771057,
-0.3224353492259979,
-0.15425479412078857,
-0.060993026942014694,
0.06966901570558548,
0.1254580169916153,
-0.27087274193763733,
0.22301027178764343,
0.7719914317131042,
-0.004012742079794407,
0.6819646954536438,
0.21711447834968567,
0.04828576743602753,
-0.1575954258441925,
1.1294583082199097,
0.15386858582496643,
0.07678158581256866,
0.30105146765708923,
0.3738693594932556,
0.00594354048371315,
-0.47066935896873474,
0.004383938852697611,
-0.033735983073711395,
-0.17746393382549286,
0.12418780475854874,
-0.5842604637145996,
0.14971433579921722,
-0.37764865159988403,
-0.4149070680141449,
0.12884555757045746,
-0.02188926562666893,
-0.7245424389839172,
-0.18744787573814392,
0.33014097809791565,
0.7040812969207764,
0.33379030227661133,
0.34889912605285645,
-0.6256611943244934,
0.0003567755047697574,
0.4180450141429901,
0.05349298194050789,
-0.10587538033723831,
0.21637500822544098,
-0.3137742877006531,
-0.03435588255524635,
-0.5086144804954529,
-0.7015242576599121,
0.4627775549888611,
-0.06017293035984039,
0.6124842762947083,
0.5490449070930481,
-0.20611655712127686,
0.27628740668296814,
-0.21960049867630005,
1.2152180671691895,
0.1300191879272461,
-0.9164271354675293,
0.7991554141044617,
-0.7026494741439819,
0.22016756236553192,
0.1227625161409378,
0.8639518618583679,
-0.48688721656799316,
-0.13307833671569824,
-0.6548007130622864,
-0.8033290505409241,
0.6231114864349365,
-0.2737255394458771,
0.26959332823753357,
0.05174876004457474,
0.10327877104282379,
-0.020848959684371948,
0.6176835298538208,
-0.4331233501434326,
0.018051020801067352,
-0.6674144268035889,
0.12228358536958694,
-0.10911274701356888,
0.015495838597416878,
-0.2352025806903839,
0.09385928511619568,
0.5990593433380127,
-0.12396638840436935,
0.23563899099826813,
0.06393241882324219,
0.09442385286092758,
0.04480836167931557,
0.5161670446395874,
0.6981951594352722,
0.4861358404159546,
-0.44563028216362,
0.006269837263971567,
0.00318132690154016,
-0.6091585159301758,
-0.09102173894643784,
0.32505112886428833,
-0.3963984549045563,
0.03443479537963867,
-0.10216570645570755,
0.723018229007721,
0.18860645592212677,
-0.12012540549039841,
0.2572169303894043,
0.2689256966114044,
-0.38150501251220703,
0.1474410891532898,
-0.04467950761318207,
0.03624582663178444,
0.21607166528701782,
0.5251532196998596,
0.13258586823940277,
0.27566397190093994,
-0.9136061072349548,
-0.2923761308193207,
0.37626177072525024,
-0.6257490515708923,
-0.6648853421211243,
0.8853333592414856,
0.5545954704284668,
0.2668599784374237,
0.3729463517665863,
0.10512986779212952,
-0.8093602061271667,
0.8762891292572021,
0.1147930920124054,
0.7370501756668091,
0.2546590268611908,
0.15521961450576782,
0.16906225681304932,
0.09972711652517319,
0.13129481673240662,
0.35020577907562256,
-0.06946562975645065,
-0.4303005635738373,
-0.3542645275592804,
-0.2686395049095154,
-0.3082590103149414,
0.26668083667755127,
-0.5670555233955383,
0.6004454493522644,
-0.33555757999420166,
-0.4319896101951599,
0.006943671032786369,
0.24972684681415558,
-0.6401321291923523,
0.12833526730537415,
0.29558655619621277,
0.7644689083099365,
-1.0168730020523071,
0.39446303248405457,
1.0123271942138672,
-0.1233380064368248,
-0.36251959204673767,
0.465408056974411,
0.362948477268219,
-0.3244296610355377,
0.551398754119873,
0.44266632199287415,
0.03646962344646454,
0.11341822892427444,
-1.0078983306884766,
-1.1224982738494873,
1.2377920150756836,
0.1292598843574524,
-0.2711367905139923,
0.05642499774694443,
-0.15313419699668884,
-0.07790391147136688,
-0.23764996230602264,
-0.08145111054182053,
0.3942004144191742,
0.9870061278343201,
-0.33330634236335754,
-0.4326102137565613,
-0.4023480713367462,
0.19669312238693237,
-0.11000179499387741,
0.6633288860321045,
-1.2225536108016968,
0.4355919361114502,
-0.0026524225249886513,
-0.5758240222930908,
-0.22412484884262085,
0.8220080137252808,
-0.056302592158317566,
0.9594247937202454,
0.5504658222198486,
0.3654443621635437,
0.8770872950553894,
-0.3809220492839813,
1.0409090518951416,
-0.4569282531738281,
0.6750751733779907,
0.464443564414978,
-0.3318585455417633,
0.4362327456474304,
0.371493399143219,
-0.06578316539525986,
0.7002220153808594,
0.7951133847236633,
-0.39096078276634216,
0.9744712114334106,
0.19479846954345703,
-0.3815988004207611,
-0.2814502716064453,
-0.42478621006011963,
-0.4269700050354004,
0.292382150888443,
0.3999101519584656,
-0.1764141470193863,
-0.5252075791358948,
0.17887185513973236,
0.08529982715845108,
-0.10093500465154648,
-0.3657393157482147,
0.6139208078384399,
-0.3589143455028534,
-0.5063973665237427,
-0.3051444888114929,
-0.2775413393974304,
0.4741247296333313,
-0.4315854012966156,
0.031671930104494095,
0.24334420263767242,
-0.37045884132385254,
-0.3243385851383209,
-1.0376774072647095,
0.10036204010248184,
0.11137397587299347,
-0.61777663230896,
-0.48921528458595276,
0.49366697669029236,
-0.16967785358428955,
-0.10894913971424103,
0.019144847989082336,
0.05584222078323364,
0.07635047286748886,
-0.1238420382142067,
-0.523985743522644,
0.02224915847182274,
0.3163042664527893,
-0.5627849698066711,
0.19290180504322052,
0.3317177891731262,
0.17885228991508484,
0.17434582114219666,
0.8576619029045105,
-0.16099591553211212,
-0.1380431056022644,
0.21311452984809875,
1.125199794769287,
-0.641133725643158,
-0.34249529242515564,
-0.41466498374938965,
0.39996159076690674,
-0.2520529329776764,
-0.37975117564201355,
0.7875569462776184,
0.5253516435623169,
0.5003581643104553,
-0.06047266349196434,
1.1141479015350342,
0.022675765678286552,
0.33131128549575806,
-0.3685337007045746,
0.4890015423297882,
-0.2941712737083435,
0.016585586592555046,
0.3134852349758148,
-0.6502977609634399,
0.005010665860027075,
0.15851576626300812,
-0.8659968972206116,
0.051101721823215485,
0.2297936975955963,
0.34224337339401245,
0.010480844415724277,
0.363486111164093,
-0.0325799323618412,
0.041548606008291245,
0.5336016416549683,
0.13681289553642273,
0.8743077516555786,
0.31522834300994873,
0.2490374892950058,
0.009907834231853485,
-0.18601351976394653,
-0.27915751934051514,
-1.1791179180145264,
-0.5754056572914124,
-0.14214324951171875,
-0.28910303115844727,
-0.0842062383890152,
-0.11851495504379272,
0.6870453953742981,
0.7259436249732971,
-0.8152186274528503,
0.40383216738700867,
-0.5130853056907654,
0.35774853825569153,
-0.05879479646682739,
-0.37331703305244446,
0.5172244906425476,
-0.4314294457435608,
-0.8572280406951904,
0.425026535987854,
0.15490634739398956,
0.06674735248088837,
-0.5479626655578613,
0.7350319623947144,
-0.14120922982692719,
0.1705198436975479,
0.25890445709228516,
0.49242275953292847,
-0.43362322449684143,
-0.4802730083465576,
0.24453723430633545,
0.06702679395675659,
0.01636410877108574,
0.8939763903617859,
-0.8936938643455505,
0.10168617963790894,
0.7440791130065918,
0.7275313138961792,
0.5513641834259033,
0.45921510457992554,
0.2670597434043884,
-0.7983319759368896,
0.2474551647901535,
0.024134108796715736,
0.201014906167984,
0.39834731817245483,
-0.6975786089897156,
0.15512417256832123,
0.37600430846214294,
-1.0647344589233398,
-0.4863974452018738,
0.09623824805021286,
-0.5993759632110596,
-0.32633712887763977,
0.9548274874687195,
0.06798757612705231,
-0.3586331605911255,
-0.08197137713432312,
0.02802714891731739,
-0.2690504491329193,
-0.6027230024337769,
0.9609313607215881,
1.0795307159423828,
-0.25672316551208496,
0.047728367149829865,
-0.5443878769874573,
0.18837977945804596,
-0.00770187471061945,
-0.6666315793991089,
0.09230078011751175,
0.4725218415260315,
-0.026993272826075554,
0.49867236614227295,
-0.5489102005958557,
0.16182023286819458,
0.08794461190700531,
-0.3766081631183624,
-0.10261870175600052,
0.06604175269603729,
-0.5967183709144592,
-0.05225787311792374,
0.16897861659526825,
-0.34797945618629456,
-0.11668247729539871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07006v1
|
Word-specific tonal realizations in Mandarin
| 2024-05-11T13:00:35 | 2024-05-11T13:00:35 |
Yu-Ying Chuang, Melanie J. Bell, Yu-Hsiang Tseng, R. Harald Baayen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The pitch contours of Mandarin two-character words are generally understood
as being shaped by the underlying tones of the constituent single-character
words, in interaction with articulatory constraints imposed by factors such as
speech rate, co-articulation with adjacent tones, segmental make-up, and
predictability. This study shows that tonal realization is also partially
determined by words' meanings. We first show, on the basis of a Taiwan corpus
of spontaneous conversations, using the generalized additive regression model,
and focusing on the rise-fall tone pattern, that after controlling for effects
of speaker and context, word type is a stronger predictor of pitch realization
than all the previously established word-form related predictors combined.
Importantly, the addition of information about meaning in context improves
prediction accuracy even further. We then proceed to show, using computational
modeling with context-specific word embeddings, that token-specific pitch
contours predict word type with 50% accuracy on held-out data, and that
context-sensitive, token-specific embeddings can predict the shape of pitch
contours with 30% accuracy. These accuracies, which are an order of magnitude
above chance level, suggest that the relation between words' pitch contours and
their meanings are sufficiently strong to be functional for language users. The
theoretical implications of these empirical findings are discussed.
|
[
-0.19644956290721893,
-0.7250101566314697,
0.42234763503074646,
0.7222893834114075,
-0.5122408866882324,
-0.1417146772146225,
-0.32601073384284973,
-0.42684099078178406,
0.5019620656967163,
0.687605082988739,
-0.23125214874744415,
-0.35056987404823303,
-0.068068727850914,
-0.08393777906894684,
-0.5279795527458191,
0.6382744908332825,
0.22308140993118286,
0.1402953565120697,
0.2360258847475052,
-0.21917612850666046,
-0.9406308531761169,
-0.6038187742233276,
-0.43777644634246826,
-0.21012620627880096,
0.2113460898399353,
0.10049024969339371,
0.8919153809547424,
0.6759268045425415,
0.44913169741630554,
0.2177489995956421,
-0.27107754349708557,
-0.42155808210372925,
-0.19519349932670593,
0.08321987092494965,
0.32749274373054504,
-0.6699813604354858,
-0.09115256369113922,
0.25700104236602783,
0.6363563537597656,
0.9108868837356567,
-0.379982590675354,
-0.43801823258399963,
0.2548363208770752,
0.4707788825035095,
-0.016204427927732468,
0.13009104132652283,
-1.0556472539901733,
0.5082076191902161,
-0.17990030348300934,
-0.5195273160934448,
-0.35309913754463196,
-0.10643327236175537,
0.5001469850540161,
-0.6402140259742737,
0.4500882923603058,
0.22725903987884521,
0.8689910769462585,
0.06781067699193954,
-0.3764232397079468,
-0.5660268068313599,
-0.6402972936630249,
0.65772944688797,
-0.6465243697166443,
0.3794252872467041,
0.15597940981388092,
0.48740047216415405,
-0.2836666703224182,
-0.5505937337875366,
-0.4381258189678192,
-0.7816864252090454,
-0.5160561800003052,
0.244975745677948,
0.39657488465309143,
0.7172433733940125,
0.32291367650032043,
0.8421546220779419,
-0.22820332646369934,
-0.36060184240341187,
-0.11913768202066422,
-0.28941065073013306,
0.34914320707321167,
0.3419249951839447,
0.6593385934829712,
-0.5231117606163025,
-0.505170464515686,
0.34778356552124023,
-0.9223824143409729,
0.3688634932041168,
0.1330278366804123,
0.784722626209259,
-0.27294379472732544,
0.5688779950141907,
-0.07249835133552551,
0.7011270523071289,
0.028681891039013863,
-0.16144099831581116,
0.22927814722061157,
-0.5857177972793579,
-0.2739189565181732,
0.3712752163410187,
0.43096426129341125,
-0.122004933655262,
0.4497597813606262,
-0.09739086776971817,
-0.2832880914211273,
-0.0325428731739521,
-0.10066608339548111,
-0.5262184143066406,
0.02109340764582157,
0.03022964484989643,
-0.3336295485496521,
-0.21338430047035217,
0.4223215579986572,
-0.05105896666646004,
-0.7340900897979736,
-0.6292521357536316,
0.4593886137008667,
-0.5748234987258911,
-0.3063358962535858,
0.1651882380247116,
-0.3459330201148987,
0.3447035253047943,
0.2523222267627716,
-0.9227635860443115,
0.09207262843847275,
0.6627755761146545,
1.022908091545105,
-0.020354393869638443,
-0.1366748958826065,
-0.17649057507514954,
0.11667655408382416,
-0.718721866607666,
0.3988785743713379,
-0.3881813883781433,
-0.4591437876224518,
0.1932152807712555,
-0.16805323958396912,
-0.23518754541873932,
-0.4684382677078247,
0.5191329717636108,
-0.07407757639884949,
0.00071485317312181,
-0.3358362913131714,
-0.48933839797973633,
-0.38775819540023804,
-0.02757822908461094,
-0.60986328125,
0.5262379050254822,
0.3903576135635376,
-0.7458512187004089,
0.5791366696357727,
-0.026243483647704124,
-0.7783523201942444,
0.3836579918861389,
-0.742219090461731,
0.11621277034282684,
0.6718112230300903,
-0.30033648014068604,
0.22649657726287842,
-0.20344652235507965,
0.3107409179210663,
0.14932233095169067,
-0.5076518654823303,
0.2940298020839691,
-0.26379767060279846,
0.6315517425537109,
0.06394671648740768,
-0.5015978217124939,
0.1432858407497406,
-0.49656403064727783,
-0.030181042850017548,
-0.008894787169992924,
-0.46929028630256653,
-0.19994302093982697,
0.10846282541751862,
0.2080295830965042,
0.020542297512292862,
0.12865956127643585,
-0.4462318420410156,
-0.06650731712579727,
-0.6292715072631836,
0.559486985206604,
0.5620976686477661,
0.07266120612621307,
0.2708107829093933,
-0.38321444392204285,
0.5615026354789734,
0.05697782337665558,
-0.02087671309709549,
-0.4928906261920929,
-0.49102982878685,
-0.6344996690750122,
-0.30322137475013733,
-0.0214838907122612,
0.4081553816795349,
-0.18029429018497467,
0.2376461923122406,
-0.016335120424628258,
-0.4499780535697937,
-0.32020604610443115,
-0.1759379357099533,
0.42882072925567627,
0.6995571255683899,
0.08918756991624832,
-0.13496190309524536,
-0.7320403456687927,
-0.8696170449256897,
-0.5258206129074097,
-0.3408612608909607,
-0.14348238706588745,
0.7455062866210938,
-0.22888191044330597,
0.23389732837677002,
0.9188352823257446,
-0.4736756980419159,
-0.6810123324394226,
-0.3774750530719757,
0.1812407523393631,
0.4693615734577179,
0.3388076424598694,
0.6745577454566956,
-0.9974693655967712,
-0.6824745535850525,
0.06563685089349747,
-0.46396782994270325,
0.018946027383208275,
-0.35601794719696045,
0.19609688222408295,
0.16660355031490326,
0.4740321934223175,
-0.2182530015707016,
0.4112361669540405,
0.4375962018966675,
-0.5595768094062805,
0.7167060375213623,
-0.08053373545408249,
-0.05827711522579193,
-0.7861914038658142,
-0.19791343808174133,
-0.13790492713451385,
0.15450459718704224,
-1.0782623291015625,
-0.13772644102573395,
-0.1893550455570221,
0.09868685156106949,
-0.4300197958946228,
0.4696866571903229,
-0.45913004875183105,
-0.27675116062164307,
-0.17554856836795807,
0.24860791862010956,
-0.08855078369379044,
0.4413321614265442,
0.34947964549064636,
0.6873022317886353,
0.44314342737197876,
-0.6294733881950378,
0.16802625358104706,
0.09908917546272278,
-0.8045377135276794,
0.25216779112815857,
-1.0195066928863525,
-0.1360633820295334,
-0.06974567472934723,
0.07003844529390335,
-1.1547447443008423,
-0.1648760288953781,
-0.015863366425037384,
-0.3935178220272064,
0.15189842879772186,
-0.0476347953081131,
-0.06293463706970215,
-0.057640377432107925,
-0.18460042774677277,
0.504130482673645,
0.3864586055278778,
-0.18718935549259186,
0.5172423124313354,
0.4916177988052368,
0.10164458304643631,
-0.1598295420408249,
-0.9390120506286621,
0.018471000716090202,
-0.23444561660289764,
-0.4314636290073395,
0.6150475144386292,
0.032907407730817795,
-0.28098297119140625,
-0.24193449318408966,
0.18404637277126312,
0.23510068655014038,
0.055820807814598083,
0.4860617518424988,
-0.08752413839101791,
-0.4112873673439026,
0.17839939892292023,
-0.22794130444526672,
0.20166364312171936,
-0.21977674961090088,
-0.0601152740418911,
0.8134710788726807,
-0.1096685379743576,
-0.10317282378673553,
-0.2701449692249298,
0.06893818080425262,
0.5371601581573486,
-0.01991872489452362,
0.4052053391933441,
0.541286826133728,
-0.46988797187805176,
0.013009999878704548,
-0.24615101516246796,
0.005169780924916267,
-0.4687110483646393,
0.3000347912311554,
-0.7021666765213013,
-0.7123494148254395,
0.7492572069168091,
0.5341789722442627,
-0.30445900559425354,
0.4240318834781647,
0.39916664361953735,
0.11024433374404907,
1.3518385887145996,
0.6241690516471863,
-0.0513032041490078,
0.9392217397689819,
-0.177731454372406,
0.1298471838235855,
-1.0742906332015991,
-0.18001732230186462,
-0.34149041771888733,
-0.11548785865306854,
-0.9907021522521973,
-0.09404794871807098,
0.4208340048789978,
0.27577725052833557,
-0.22344478964805603,
0.3323706388473511,
-0.48675432801246643,
-0.0028850429225713015,
0.6222385168075562,
-0.25118809938430786,
0.015745675191283226,
0.03251342475414276,
-0.4310009181499481,
-0.21549910306930542,
-0.3435918092727661,
-0.20909948647022247,
0.49787449836730957,
0.1453131139278412,
0.41433390974998474,
-0.1010962501168251,
0.22396676242351532,
0.16174761950969696,
0.03526841476559639,
-1.085645318031311,
0.3146094083786011,
-0.3320372402667999,
-0.6370812058448792,
-0.3654124140739441,
-0.10135228931903839,
-0.6931649446487427,
0.4077211022377014,
-0.2410573661327362,
-0.7142093777656555,
-0.044839296489953995,
0.15524716675281525,
-0.2640981674194336,
-0.06598123908042908,
-0.40221014618873596,
0.6199377775192261,
-0.32050973176956177,
0.4480980932712555,
-0.3512680232524872,
-0.31821614503860474,
0.3702560067176819,
0.04779166728258133,
0.13419818878173828,
-0.7043622732162476,
0.07024693489074707,
0.6202269196510315,
-0.3882571756839752,
0.5261006355285645,
-0.4139062762260437,
0.04442847892642021,
0.654576301574707,
0.176263689994812,
0.25121185183525085,
-0.10941354185342789,
-0.10910004377365112,
0.09357830882072449,
0.16867676377296448,
-0.1259729266166687,
-0.5893589854240417,
0.343619167804718,
-0.6171228885650635,
-0.8338441848754883,
-0.22713026404380798,
-0.4454534649848938,
-0.21257196366786957,
0.22149494290351868,
0.48341357707977295,
0.7418633699417114,
-0.4281974732875824,
-0.06619969755411148,
-0.04107637703418732,
-0.440170019865036,
0.2879346013069153,
0.3664097189903259,
-0.5159016251564026,
-0.5694996118545532,
0.9106305837631226,
0.3171422481536865,
0.22152087092399597,
0.6153948307037354,
0.6583036184310913,
-0.24055148661136627,
-0.6019207239151001,
-0.3011015057563782,
0.22918643057346344,
-0.4294106662273407,
0.12634588778018951,
-0.24385012686252594,
-0.48782116174697876,
-0.40779417753219604,
-0.3355577290058136,
0.1460288166999817,
-0.664979875087738,
-0.2566872239112854,
-0.13210265338420868,
0.18869173526763916,
0.7470224499702454,
0.12308093160390854,
0.5628530383110046,
-0.5780611038208008,
0.24637305736541748,
0.12943701446056366,
0.2458024024963379,
0.14589844644069672,
-0.8733618259429932,
-0.25299879908561707,
0.2759437561035156,
0.2447327822446823,
-0.8520804643630981,
0.3398190140724182,
0.47151342034339905,
0.4433991312980652,
0.9268746972084045,
-0.13632410764694214,
0.5571146011352539,
-0.4886057376861572,
0.9701592922210693,
0.28180256485939026,
-1.1850939989089966,
0.5571605563163757,
-0.5970603227615356,
0.09139115363359451,
0.4810090959072113,
-0.20923836529254913,
-1.370354413986206,
-0.5022600889205933,
-0.32926443219184875,
-0.8798797726631165,
0.6315176486968994,
0.09074259549379349,
0.5630757808685303,
-0.010790296830236912,
0.38144999742507935,
0.018963545560836792,
0.39100736379623413,
-0.39789384603500366,
-0.15707862377166748,
-0.4173869490623474,
-0.1463293582201004,
-0.1749315708875656,
-0.3506808578968048,
0.1301809847354889,
-0.2472214698791504,
0.2089841067790985,
-0.08159331232309341,
0.3846055269241333,
0.14668068289756775,
-0.04366419464349747,
0.11428368091583252,
-0.02233143523335457,
0.8792440295219421,
0.3852502107620239,
-0.3936256468296051,
0.2860930263996124,
-0.056666336953639984,
-0.6634560823440552,
-0.04554816335439682,
-0.33076003193855286,
-0.3649185597896576,
0.27655163407325745,
0.5868309140205383,
0.831560492515564,
0.041042979806661606,
-0.49575382471084595,
0.5302212834358215,
0.10448627173900604,
0.10356203466653824,
-0.612763524055481,
-0.0024885174352675676,
-0.08202989399433136,
-0.3457832932472229,
0.4953019917011261,
-0.24411670863628387,
0.1731647551059723,
-0.7599022388458252,
0.0001672411453910172,
0.6062929034233093,
-0.8670420050621033,
-0.7561802268028259,
0.6109070777893066,
0.056751370429992676,
-0.2440589964389801,
0.5456383228302002,
-0.05910593643784523,
-0.8649507164955139,
0.984993577003479,
0.8464370369911194,
1.081531047821045,
-0.2908702492713928,
0.17934955656528473,
0.571631133556366,
0.05089375749230385,
0.16180261969566345,
0.6017683744430542,
-0.008045600727200508,
-1.1164451837539673,
0.12083304673433304,
-0.8535863757133484,
-0.20360732078552246,
-0.1589411497116089,
-0.41963738203048706,
0.46003755927085876,
-0.7084691524505615,
0.06979119032621384,
0.04442794248461723,
-0.006052685435861349,
-0.5062388181686401,
0.5086057186126709,
0.2461698353290558,
0.8379422426223755,
-0.7441922426223755,
0.4753838777542114,
0.5702345967292786,
-0.6640292406082153,
-1.2912251949310303,
0.011383788660168648,
0.019209835678339005,
-0.8991389870643616,
0.32583290338516235,
0.5164039134979248,
-0.11547158658504486,
-0.06403787434101105,
-0.1327352225780487,
-1.0078848600387573,
0.8967199325561523,
0.2896023988723755,
-0.3865629732608795,
-0.04031278192996979,
0.8021281361579895,
0.7263625264167786,
-0.6083877682685852,
0.23808476328849792,
0.6578392386436462,
0.5093483328819275,
0.29200416803359985,
-0.9056727290153503,
0.25102561712265015,
0.11023962497711182,
0.2570438086986542,
0.031173089519143105,
-0.5707586407661438,
0.9910887479782104,
-0.14174334704875946,
-0.6543897390365601,
0.1870674192905426,
0.6792351603507996,
0.1704639345407486,
-0.061211489140987396,
0.6806195974349976,
0.14338932931423187,
0.5781050324440002,
-0.08946899324655533,
0.755101203918457,
-0.7929372191429138,
0.02104802243411541,
0.5633549690246582,
0.23082678020000458,
0.7130875587463379,
0.17040807008743286,
-0.28284668922424316,
0.3307065963745117,
0.6009972095489502,
0.11180484294891357,
0.577879786491394,
0.47171491384506226,
-0.368743360042572,
0.15238727629184723,
-0.7715818285942078,
-0.1972884237766266,
0.7998086214065552,
0.6292115449905396,
-0.585938036441803,
0.4555301368236542,
-0.11826258152723312,
0.044347718358039856,
-0.027718132361769676,
-0.5223386287689209,
0.5876697301864624,
0.4173029065132141,
-0.7703571319580078,
0.5879384875297546,
0.00004325028567109257,
0.6529654264450073,
-0.4339825510978699,
0.03445553407073021,
-0.41377949714660645,
0.01570660062134266,
-0.35781410336494446,
-0.6958913207054138,
0.37270376086235046,
-0.5068910121917725,
0.039502110332250595,
-0.004482935648411512,
0.4975897967815399,
-0.6679863929748535,
-0.2367164045572281,
0.13146838545799255,
0.23088966310024261,
0.13515590131282806,
-0.2837618291378021,
-0.37613892555236816,
-0.2472119778394699,
0.05250924080610275,
-0.08502549678087234,
-0.10917540639638901,
0.48241811990737915,
0.11928214132785797,
0.1311796009540558,
0.16735662519931793,
0.4578021764755249,
0.13006217777729034,
0.5607362389564514,
0.329134076833725,
-0.8887925744056702,
-0.7412419319152832,
-0.6381320357322693,
0.15314310789108276,
0.41833585500717163,
-0.42919909954071045,
0.5030233860015869,
0.4455530643463135,
0.6624091863632202,
0.10164064913988113,
0.891435980796814,
-0.02314617857336998,
0.2314337193965912,
-0.6206800937652588,
0.7801472544670105,
-0.45345112681388855,
-0.17265114188194275,
-0.30517634749412537,
-0.8272709846496582,
-0.3812985420227051,
0.44636091589927673,
-0.1732323169708252,
0.08315610140562057,
0.6423829197883606,
0.6161606311798096,
0.2393084466457367,
0.12729987502098083,
0.4969947040081024,
0.07643840461969376,
0.2905983030796051,
0.19332829117774963,
0.8871536254882812,
0.033613868057727814,
0.36619704961776733,
-0.24795690178871155,
0.038802798837423325,
-0.3672511577606201,
-0.5951133370399475,
-0.5035588145256042,
-0.9143007397651672,
0.053314171731472015,
-0.11769088357686996,
-0.40059345960617065,
0.694108784198761,
0.5312238335609436,
-1.014763355255127,
-0.45310455560684204,
-0.5541665554046631,
0.21198336780071259,
-0.39473411440849304,
-0.29963162541389465,
0.6278947591781616,
-0.46933358907699585,
-0.5176751613616943,
0.20724573731422424,
0.3426082730293274,
0.41889750957489014,
-0.18855997920036316,
-0.012651707045733929,
0.28321951627731323,
0.4906766712665558,
0.48282912373542786,
0.22646936774253845,
-1.046715497970581,
-0.6436723470687866,
0.06931950151920319,
-0.4416474997997284,
0.3105563223361969,
1.2217555046081543,
-0.6817616820335388,
0.39469441771507263,
0.7509207129478455,
0.046001922339200974,
0.047625135630369186,
0.08093451708555222,
0.7211897969245911,
-0.7390240430831909,
0.34627455472946167,
0.23909325897693634,
0.6715269088745117,
0.4704643785953522,
-0.3509990870952606,
0.3909812271595001,
0.38153237104415894,
0.0153275728225708,
-0.7206992506980896,
0.7053922414779663,
-0.776875913143158,
-0.03713613376021385,
1.3225349187850952,
-0.12661448121070862,
-0.04267540201544762,
-0.030287982895970345,
-0.42879173159599304,
0.4682975113391876,
-0.039770226925611496,
0.5876739621162415,
0.5679692625999451,
-0.36065319180488586,
0.11624181270599365,
-0.2607966363430023,
1.005287528038025,
0.4701991081237793,
-0.10925363004207611,
0.18209747970104218,
0.4250199496746063,
0.007910119369626045,
0.217560276389122,
0.8060758113861084,
0.102691650390625,
0.014960896223783493,
0.2076166570186615,
-0.09062477201223373,
0.1603044867515564,
-0.288510799407959,
-0.37037399411201477,
0.15278616547584534,
0.3493488132953644,
-0.1941394954919815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07001v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07001v2
|
Evaluating Task-based Effectiveness of MLLMs on Charts
| 2024-05-11T12:33:46 | 2024-06-17T15:44:33 |
Yifan Wu, Lutao Yan, Yuyu Luo, Yunhai Wang, Nan Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
In this paper, we explore a forward-thinking question: Is GPT-4V effective at
low-level data analysis tasks on charts? To this end, we first curate a
large-scale dataset, named ChartInsights, consisting of 89,388 quartets (chart,
task, question, answer) and covering 10 widely-used low-level data analysis
tasks on 7 chart types. Firstly, we conduct systematic evaluations to
understand the capabilities and limitations of 18 advanced MLLMs, which include
12 open-source models and 6 closed-source models. Starting with a standard
textual prompt approach, the average accuracy rate across the 18 MLLMs is
36.17%. Among all the models, GPT-4V achieves the highest accuracy, reaching
56.13%. To understand the limitations of multimodal large models in low-level
data analysis tasks, we have designed various experiments to conduct an
in-depth test of capabilities of GPT-4V. We further investigate how visual
modifications to charts, such as altering visual elements (e.g. changing color
schemes) and introducing perturbations (e.g. adding image noise), affect
performance of GPT-4V. Secondly, we present 12 experimental findings. These
findings suggest potential of GPT-4V to revolutionize interaction with charts
and uncover the gap between human analytic needs and capabilities of GPT-4V.
Thirdly, we propose a novel textual prompt strategy, named Chain-of-Charts,
tailored for low-level analysis tasks, which boosts model performance by
24.36%, resulting in an accuracy of 80.49%. Furthermore, by incorporating a
visual prompt strategy that directs attention of GPT-4V to question-relevant
visual elements, we further improve accuracy to 83.83%. Our study not only
sheds light on the capabilities and limitations of GPT-4V in low-level data
analysis tasks but also offers valuable insights for future research.
|
[
-0.14874547719955444,
-0.7703505158424377,
0.6548089981079102,
-0.003990546800196171,
-0.3343331515789032,
0.1298585832118988,
0.05199282616376877,
-0.5712193846702576,
-0.25092706084251404,
0.3165227472782135,
-0.5136928558349609,
-0.799721896648407,
-0.6229715347290039,
0.30971452593803406,
-0.33628201484680176,
0.88189697265625,
-0.14589117467403412,
-0.04323848336935043,
-0.11620073765516281,
-0.12396477162837982,
-0.7741265892982483,
-0.5425538420677185,
-0.5741852521896362,
0.18699567019939423,
0.7834386229515076,
0.5062270164489746,
0.5786828398704529,
0.3258104622364044,
0.8072670102119446,
0.2746928632259369,
0.14534726738929749,
0.29537785053253174,
-0.9761233925819397,
0.23285610973834991,
0.14813166856765747,
-0.3921073377132416,
-0.6474736928939819,
0.2282363474369049,
0.4063224792480469,
0.38932543992996216,
0.19475799798965454,
0.28620630502700806,
0.27819517254829407,
0.9163007140159607,
-0.550076425075531,
0.6360936760902405,
-0.47221338748931885,
0.11337784677743912,
-0.4897559881210327,
-0.205624520778656,
-0.41981425881385803,
0.010206249542534351,
0.3397526443004608,
-0.7691165804862976,
0.11598265916109085,
0.15487244725227356,
0.672897458076477,
0.278623104095459,
-0.5725522041320801,
-0.2898256182670593,
-0.7847498059272766,
0.6972701549530029,
-0.6887712478637695,
0.32825714349746704,
0.3945976495742798,
0.564311146736145,
0.2198651283979416,
-1.2859495878219604,
-0.17202891409397125,
-0.31781312823295593,
-0.11204326152801514,
0.3573770225048065,
-0.6042377948760986,
-0.014700248837471008,
0.7639169692993164,
0.12044729292392731,
-0.652694582939148,
0.08814644813537598,
-0.4327143430709839,
-0.10578853636980057,
0.5803400278091431,
0.6325545907020569,
0.23003028333187103,
-0.3673279285430908,
-0.2666099965572357,
0.19236457347869873,
-0.5567817687988281,
0.33841222524642944,
0.23359033465385437,
0.41125765442848206,
-0.06488879770040512,
0.6538096070289612,
-0.22913572192192078,
0.8232203125953674,
0.16117045283317566,
-0.12342367321252823,
0.3451073467731476,
-0.7901021242141724,
-0.28933537006378174,
-0.4368639290332794,
0.7079113721847534,
0.5925882458686829,
-0.01692315936088562,
0.05646020546555519,
-0.29298004508018494,
-0.02730513922870159,
0.5149569511413574,
-0.7922064661979675,
-0.5286014676094055,
-0.013246934860944748,
-0.5337185859680176,
-0.30022478103637695,
-0.2715407907962799,
-0.7210699319839478,
-0.5549046993255615,
-0.39586371183395386,
0.4446372091770172,
-0.4474940299987793,
0.18809257447719574,
-0.27462729811668396,
-0.1697683036327362,
0.00315340724773705,
0.6198044419288635,
-0.6465699076652527,
0.21383631229400635,
0.5188312530517578,
1.0432895421981812,
-0.265990287065506,
0.021576177328824997,
-0.8105754852294922,
0.05071892961859703,
-0.42207080125808716,
0.6463432312011719,
-0.5209604501724243,
-0.34671276807785034,
-0.40287965536117554,
-0.061916787177324295,
-0.20624911785125732,
-0.281271368265152,
0.5489546656608582,
-0.3534681797027588,
0.09483355283737183,
-0.5539348125457764,
-0.7020962238311768,
-0.30570390820503235,
0.4760909676551819,
-1.033182978630066,
0.9188557267189026,
0.19204188883304596,
-0.8943933248519897,
0.6263641715049744,
-0.8407602906227112,
-0.19376695156097412,
0.23404371738433838,
-0.4555085301399231,
-0.6900812387466431,
-0.4299851655960083,
0.5798178315162659,
0.5431159734725952,
-0.21036961674690247,
-0.340785413980484,
-0.26736074686050415,
-0.5622044801712036,
0.06426947563886642,
-0.4404093623161316,
0.3930942416191101,
0.3158073425292969,
-0.6867973804473877,
0.5311726927757263,
-0.36746588349342346,
-0.06085203215479851,
0.0962790995836258,
0.1511976420879364,
-0.19959671795368195,
-0.17925748229026794,
0.06613869220018387,
0.13850271701812744,
0.0976962000131607,
-0.1974349468946457,
0.25991445779800415,
-0.23686571419239044,
0.324949711561203,
0.5972506999969482,
0.28177744150161743,
0.20247462391853333,
-0.17900411784648895,
0.9446955323219299,
-0.11920692026615143,
0.4558878242969513,
0.005002215038985014,
-1.0550044775009155,
-0.2795032858848572,
-0.3427037000656128,
0.14884959161281586,
0.5121733546257019,
-1.08656907081604,
-0.08176308125257492,
-0.1744016706943512,
-0.7917765378952026,
-0.055073536932468414,
0.14993637800216675,
0.15664400160312653,
0.8237195611000061,
0.339278906583786,
-0.4316701889038086,
-0.32448554039001465,
-0.8679904341697693,
-0.2275715321302414,
-0.029842393472790718,
-0.009159451350569725,
0.22322577238082886,
0.5355111956596375,
-0.12731555104255676,
0.8316059112548828,
-0.4620579779148102,
-0.14132380485534668,
-0.45916807651519775,
0.2679600119590759,
0.42087557911872864,
0.12201698124408722,
0.851206362247467,
-0.7414863705635071,
-0.7189082503318787,
-0.06972983479499817,
-0.8081881999969482,
0.1393508017063141,
0.021067097783088684,
-0.0999675914645195,
-0.007276560179889202,
0.16355183720588684,
-0.48964524269104004,
0.8313373327255249,
0.37241074442863464,
-0.5642006397247314,
0.6002184748649597,
-0.22346231341362,
0.37781861424446106,
-0.3580777049064636,
0.25681185722351074,
0.2181156873703003,
-0.19998480379581451,
-1.0742818117141724,
-0.32441815733909607,
0.20819078385829926,
-0.30054086446762085,
-0.3170967102050781,
0.30475717782974243,
-0.389235258102417,
-0.22274231910705566,
-0.19822993874549866,
0.11290805041790009,
-0.08048132807016373,
0.4560251832008362,
-0.45396721363067627,
0.6373967528343201,
0.41010501980781555,
-0.1869141012430191,
0.565338671207428,
0.2734895348548889,
-0.3701731562614441,
0.7241738438606262,
-0.5262838006019592,
0.30321982502937317,
0.020480893552303314,
0.22067737579345703,
-1.191792607307434,
0.13713449239730835,
0.5985071063041687,
-0.13745374977588654,
0.15535803139209747,
-0.18278172612190247,
-0.4820007383823395,
-0.6143605709075928,
-0.4804360568523407,
0.24532316625118256,
0.5347374081611633,
-0.23325246572494507,
0.507173478603363,
0.1792687177658081,
-0.25153282284736633,
-0.5508127808570862,
-0.4612364172935486,
0.2851177453994751,
-0.5220485329627991,
-0.7571929097175598,
-0.05853097140789032,
-0.13538461923599243,
-0.1637379676103592,
-0.16341865062713623,
-0.28478309512138367,
0.06671787053346634,
0.021624553948640823,
0.23597010970115662,
0.42653003334999084,
-0.0480981171131134,
-0.11760851740837097,
-0.4227767288684845,
-0.1938132792711258,
-0.09767588973045349,
-0.19843348860740662,
0.03736094385385513,
-0.3034038245677948,
-0.6561282277107239,
-0.6185030341148376,
-0.06556035578250885,
0.5004656910896301,
-0.1991843432188034,
0.05723099410533905,
0.8034882545471191,
-0.16114385426044464,
0.16045373678207397,
-0.23692040145397186,
-0.03641573339700699,
-0.48023414611816406,
0.39143791794776917,
-0.43226414918899536,
-0.6311323642730713,
0.27418315410614014,
0.2309616059064865,
0.041244667023420334,
0.5567693114280701,
0.6462602019309998,
-0.39008021354675293,
0.9140609502792358,
0.3503284752368927,
-0.09134611487388611,
0.48266464471817017,
-0.5854547023773193,
0.22926297783851624,
-0.48726099729537964,
-0.025371389463543892,
-0.21321560442447662,
-0.7049980163574219,
-0.5415049195289612,
-0.5517577528953552,
0.7562691569328308,
-0.05592409148812294,
-0.21697905659675598,
-0.11637497693300247,
-0.48055025935173035,
0.0537535697221756,
0.48797985911369324,
0.360025554895401,
0.4040100574493408,
-0.1691235452890396,
0.2280380129814148,
-0.31261128187179565,
-0.810991108417511,
-0.4847399592399597,
1.4487757682800293,
0.3901105225086212,
0.5678698420524597,
-0.10538388043642044,
0.26280274987220764,
0.5772641897201538,
0.38846927881240845,
-0.5887618064880371,
0.3189408779144287,
-0.13246546685695648,
-0.44605740904808044,
-0.684739887714386,
-0.48823368549346924,
-1.1781095266342163,
0.33222678303718567,
-0.1928568333387375,
-0.6273708939552307,
0.0863080695271492,
0.4353080987930298,
-0.2062082588672638,
0.21164114773273468,
-0.8547813296318054,
1.2861077785491943,
-0.5040301084518433,
-0.3034738004207611,
0.11671436578035355,
-0.6278104782104492,
0.2506445646286011,
-0.1531011313199997,
0.330924928188324,
-0.06524810940027237,
-0.15539412200450897,
0.8461247682571411,
-0.3930565416812897,
1.0094506740570068,
-0.5331423282623291,
-0.15514518320560455,
0.38463589549064636,
-0.1429363638162613,
0.982042133808136,
-0.3449854850769043,
0.12346580624580383,
0.1235673576593399,
-0.13421055674552917,
-0.4798324704170227,
-0.9867051243782043,
0.3328787386417389,
-0.4137926399707794,
-0.35309383273124695,
-0.21923916041851044,
-0.5912292003631592,
-0.3952372074127197,
0.132203608751297,
0.1429368406534195,
0.622976541519165,
0.09941659867763519,
0.03977518528699875,
-0.09179335087537766,
0.1331709325313568,
0.15072965621948242,
0.2510366439819336,
-0.20787988603115082,
-0.3312256336212158,
1.01659095287323,
0.39741063117980957,
0.24661391973495483,
0.117168128490448,
0.14940501749515533,
-0.3465571105480194,
-0.9278528690338135,
-0.48980072140693665,
0.013370515778660774,
-0.9800514578819275,
0.03717156499624252,
-0.24425344169139862,
0.2480059713125229,
-0.11266519874334335,
0.09831012785434723,
-0.059294193983078,
-0.320977121591568,
-0.23957562446594238,
-0.19782283902168274,
0.5368666052818298,
0.981807291507721,
0.10769817233085632,
-0.05093731731176376,
-0.5754910707473755,
0.24544858932495117,
0.41907691955566406,
0.08807697892189026,
0.06553073227405548,
-0.18391287326812744,
-0.4530177116394043,
-0.03768295794725418,
-0.4508892893791199,
-0.9172729849815369,
0.2825537621974945,
-0.38965559005737305,
0.5830456018447876,
0.283706933259964,
-0.12109600752592087,
0.7649243474006653,
-0.4411025941371918,
0.9112362265586853,
0.28547170758247375,
-0.8767194747924805,
0.2955336570739746,
-0.6707810759544373,
0.330424964427948,
0.2606794834136963,
0.3569812774658203,
-0.38895708322525024,
-0.650642991065979,
-0.6048825979232788,
-0.8374072909355164,
0.5829614996910095,
0.839876115322113,
-0.5085417628288269,
0.3958653509616852,
0.2728286683559418,
0.05426188185811043,
0.2641623616218567,
-0.4255492091178894,
-0.34828731417655945,
-0.48539993166923523,
-0.3776204586029053,
-0.3951829969882965,
0.001718128682114184,
-0.06106458231806755,
-0.5138950943946838,
0.1837773621082306,
-0.29708677530288696,
0.1463298797607422,
0.07477868348360062,
0.1483142077922821,
-0.05409369245171547,
0.08022439479827881,
0.4420834183692932,
1.1268113851547241,
-0.1661698818206787,
0.030696606263518333,
0.41986602544784546,
-0.673082172870636,
-0.02106817066669464,
0.20029500126838684,
-0.06600407510995865,
-0.16716641187667847,
0.7897387146949768,
0.9360964298248291,
0.37197598814964294,
-0.5157055854797363,
0.4946703612804413,
-0.13906456530094147,
-0.11690624058246613,
0.034826021641492844,
-0.09872784465551376,
0.07146243005990982,
0.432574987411499,
0.4305378496646881,
0.017180265858769417,
0.28808775544166565,
-0.3174242079257965,
0.2269713133573532,
0.39346542954444885,
-0.3315395712852478,
-0.30166465044021606,
0.77403724193573,
0.31119900941848755,
0.03918575868010521,
0.509937584400177,
-0.12135283648967743,
-0.3407047390937805,
0.7291672229766846,
0.027833500877022743,
0.5797202587127686,
0.003030192106962204,
0.06056193262338638,
0.19359955191612244,
0.5185409188270569,
0.3245920240879059,
0.3830587565898895,
0.0642370656132698,
-0.3851969540119171,
-0.5937930941581726,
0.13372386991977692,
-0.6924642324447632,
0.16570502519607544,
-0.542205274105072,
0.19524195790290833,
-0.062402889132499695,
-0.3806629180908203,
0.017009662464261055,
0.09963378310203552,
-0.9038013219833374,
0.2034694403409958,
0.0723661258816719,
0.535929799079895,
-0.5142503380775452,
0.4973703622817993,
0.4062547981739044,
-0.531412661075592,
-0.7447510957717896,
-0.058293748646974564,
0.28573939204216003,
-0.7231127619743347,
0.8768864274024963,
0.1760973185300827,
0.07835032790899277,
0.003049456747248769,
-0.5386539101600647,
-0.925021231174469,
1.5132566690444946,
0.14488708972930908,
-0.7004454135894775,
-0.01740543730556965,
0.05302557721734047,
0.6443357467651367,
-0.18295705318450928,
0.3901206851005554,
0.7068675756454468,
0.8770131468772888,
0.06390176713466644,
-1.0743458271026611,
0.18543291091918945,
-0.21427485346794128,
-0.01188674010336399,
0.05821385607123375,
-0.26350709795951843,
0.8868359923362732,
-0.1525011956691742,
-0.24428978562355042,
-0.03186967968940735,
0.5554572343826294,
0.2642921209335327,
0.7403022646903992,
0.7836153507232666,
0.19765613973140717,
1.0507394075393677,
0.05522602051496506,
1.2259280681610107,
-0.1592942178249359,
0.5089715719223022,
0.8761904835700989,
-0.34439677000045776,
0.5324286222457886,
0.1687699258327484,
-0.24968014657497406,
0.3563154935836792,
0.6067110300064087,
-0.2741810381412506,
0.530043363571167,
0.09170936793088913,
0.12362924963235855,
-0.014712993055582047,
0.4186457097530365,
-0.25697749853134155,
0.09082721918821335,
0.1809741109609604,
-0.16614030301570892,
-0.06484153866767883,
0.18268349766731262,
-0.1953321397304535,
-0.3015249967575073,
-0.42377400398254395,
0.3976292610168457,
-0.18268363177776337,
-0.1244351714849472,
0.6978046894073486,
-0.44922202825546265,
0.29793184995651245,
-0.5670961141586304,
-0.050838492810726166,
0.0777788758277893,
-0.062370553612709045,
-0.18417948484420776,
-0.8265456557273865,
0.06649670749902725,
0.2781560719013214,
0.12382340431213379,
-0.22961635887622833,
0.813515305519104,
-0.11101990193128586,
-0.47404804825782776,
0.08141554147005081,
0.8329015970230103,
0.07230251282453537,
-0.26979199051856995,
-0.7403835654258728,
0.09878663718700409,
0.13549895584583282,
-0.36778706312179565,
0.1847485452890396,
0.5006917119026184,
0.019274404272437096,
0.6520940661430359,
0.6027086973190308,
-0.1314661055803299,
-0.04933487996459007,
0.24166643619537354,
0.8332214951515198,
-0.875260591506958,
-0.6812707781791687,
-0.6509408354759216,
0.7409974336624146,
-0.26593998074531555,
-0.06890630722045898,
1.2191426753997803,
0.6103407740592957,
0.4713016748428345,
-0.054776862263679504,
0.9759737849235535,
0.23066283762454987,
0.43003594875335693,
-0.676565945148468,
0.5598790049552917,
-0.5011425614356995,
0.1861279159784317,
-0.7366559505462646,
-0.4674600660800934,
-0.23760370910167694,
0.16588066518306732,
-0.8551108241081238,
0.08932533115148544,
0.9783321022987366,
0.3606056571006775,
0.05872694402933121,
0.2942025065422058,
0.43940746784210205,
0.3280370831489563,
0.6519902348518372,
0.37428951263427734,
0.9868853092193604,
-0.06855075061321259,
0.8354005217552185,
-0.41057518124580383,
-0.32798224687576294,
-0.10516169667243958,
-0.6142959594726562,
-0.8920343518257141,
-0.5013224482536316,
-0.12255023419857025,
0.012637296691536903,
-0.04408759996294975,
0.3306786119937897,
0.5451638102531433,
-0.42074236273765564,
-0.23032906651496887,
0.1370091438293457,
-0.2253815084695816,
-0.5039202570915222,
-0.2193288803100586,
0.6848976016044617,
-0.3267574906349182,
-0.5292525887489319,
0.5660096406936646,
0.37306249141693115,
0.05958251655101776,
-0.16456085443496704,
-0.20233167707920074,
0.08502259850502014,
-0.39325380325317383,
0.829193115234375,
-0.09341815114021301,
-0.6390061378479004,
-0.3297450542449951,
-0.07295092195272446,
-0.051500897854566574,
0.20487046241760254,
1.0745503902435303,
-0.5697594881057739,
0.7579149007797241,
0.3436678349971771,
0.4212278723716736,
0.9754616618156433,
0.26684314012527466,
0.5058465003967285,
-0.6884878277778625,
-0.038726307451725006,
0.34461504220962524,
0.47083887457847595,
0.21466533839702606,
-0.48472219705581665,
0.7783628702163696,
0.5082305669784546,
-0.5749433636665344,
-0.5997150540351868,
0.01863051950931549,
-0.9644296169281006,
-0.12069516628980637,
0.888361394405365,
-0.07497536391019821,
0.039638880640268326,
-0.2915162742137909,
-0.5217337012290955,
0.04808441922068596,
-0.4339172840118408,
0.45121827721595764,
0.6131658554077148,
-0.9336830377578735,
-0.02986382134258747,
-0.968161404132843,
0.5464653372764587,
0.0298647228628397,
-1.0439387559890747,
-0.030717240646481514,
0.7032554745674133,
0.22221705317497253,
-0.03907366469502449,
0.8679304122924805,
0.2279428243637085,
0.27722489833831787,
-0.0381469652056694,
-0.365811288356781,
-0.2130359709262848,
0.022593127563595772,
-0.32334157824516296,
0.276675283908844,
0.07507401704788208,
-0.1598895639181137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06996v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06996v1
|
Quite Good, but Not Enough: Nationality Bias in Large Language Models -- A Case Study of ChatGPT
| 2024-05-11T12:11:52 | 2024-05-11T12:11:52 |
Shucheng Zhu, Weikang Wang, Ying Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While nationality is a pivotal demographic element that enhances the
performance of language models, it has received far less scrutiny regarding
inherent biases. This study investigates nationality bias in ChatGPT (GPT-3.5),
a large language model (LLM) designed for text generation. The research covers
195 countries, 4 temperature settings, and 3 distinct prompt types, generating
4,680 discourses about nationality descriptions in Chinese and English.
Automated metrics were used to analyze the nationality bias, and expert
annotators alongside ChatGPT itself evaluated the perceived bias. The results
show that ChatGPT's generated discourses are predominantly positive, especially
compared to its predecessor, GPT-2. However, when prompted with negative
inclinations, it occasionally produces negative content. Despite ChatGPT
considering its generated text as neutral, it shows consistent self-awareness
about nationality bias when subjected to the same pair-wise comparison
annotation framework used by human annotators. In conclusion, while ChatGPT's
generated texts seem friendly and positive, they reflect the inherent
nationality biases in the real world. This bias may vary across different
language versions of ChatGPT, indicating diverse cultural perspectives. The
study highlights the subtle and pervasive nature of biases within LLMs,
emphasizing the need for further scrutiny.
|
[
-0.5708399415016174,
-0.4219699203968048,
0.4165867567062378,
0.33809295296669006,
-0.3397776782512665,
0.10954240709543228,
-0.45073890686035156,
-0.4235847294330597,
0.26885172724723816,
0.6346756219863892,
-0.36468300223350525,
-0.16238659620285034,
-0.46351996064186096,
0.18045276403427124,
-0.13495555520057678,
1.4577949047088623,
0.06769970804452896,
0.10470916330814362,
0.09151303768157959,
-0.03866507485508919,
-0.35161030292510986,
-0.8660733103752136,
-0.6196800470352173,
-0.6896191835403442,
0.29024049639701843,
0.2662126421928406,
0.6539925336837769,
0.2574758231639862,
0.2992728352546692,
0.1329636424779892,
-0.08114147931337357,
-0.0880696251988411,
-0.5497735142707825,
0.09868018329143524,
-0.12215836346149445,
-0.30106648802757263,
-0.26969948410987854,
0.2144114375114441,
0.519618570804596,
0.2348068356513977,
0.3131793439388275,
0.1804327517747879,
0.013388236984610558,
0.5350812673568726,
-0.22534185647964478,
0.31867966055870056,
-0.5476547479629517,
0.025333965197205544,
-0.4767819941043854,
-0.0406876876950264,
-0.3774155378341675,
-0.49318602681159973,
0.29981717467308044,
-0.1931118369102478,
0.455793559551239,
0.1249622106552124,
0.8232142329216003,
0.03784279152750969,
-0.7872517704963684,
-0.15799301862716675,
-0.5774065256118774,
0.8415067195892334,
-0.676072895526886,
0.03576252982020378,
0.33573323488235474,
0.12037868797779083,
-0.040848709642887115,
-0.05823565274477005,
-0.5942014455795288,
-0.44757962226867676,
-0.02990306355059147,
0.23307029902935028,
0.24171248078346252,
0.04719162359833717,
0.4030212163925171,
0.26481565833091736,
-0.5629821419715881,
0.2076570838689804,
-0.4454081356525421,
-0.4890172481536865,
0.6372694969177246,
-0.06600406765937805,
0.5432629585266113,
-0.6216982007026672,
-0.29215800762176514,
0.08565551042556763,
-1.045475959777832,
-0.21397972106933594,
0.7950714826583862,
0.4234900176525116,
-0.38367897272109985,
0.6734359860420227,
-0.19651179015636444,
0.5801267027854919,
-0.17061080038547516,
0.09118949621915817,
0.16106016933918,
-0.1363292783498764,
0.2961060702800751,
0.12052327394485474,
0.9062403440475464,
0.6894514560699463,
0.7574512958526611,
-0.0588366724550724,
-0.021064555272459984,
0.001527675660327077,
-0.15316486358642578,
-1.0681899785995483,
-0.3891957402229309,
0.16711291670799255,
-0.27589118480682373,
-0.02564368024468422,
0.18964587152004242,
-0.6437897086143494,
-0.5453019738197327,
-0.04984299838542938,
-0.10053179413080215,
-0.25591254234313965,
-0.39251941442489624,
-0.3592497706413269,
-0.2903911769390106,
0.4208049178123474,
0.08967972546815872,
-1.0007106065750122,
-0.23428095877170563,
0.704081118106842,
0.7178621292114258,
-0.49153539538383484,
-0.1553475260734558,
-0.07925557345151901,
-0.2658141255378723,
-0.4371418058872223,
0.8141840100288391,
-0.5300815105438232,
-0.5052105784416199,
-0.005298013798892498,
-0.17244979739189148,
0.11675697565078735,
-0.2627404034137726,
0.7034718990325928,
-0.5046280026435852,
0.46531450748443604,
-0.6904255151748657,
-0.39896678924560547,
0.07356909662485123,
0.32125723361968994,
-0.6257274150848389,
0.7856069803237915,
0.06460759043693542,
-1.012883186340332,
0.7884554266929626,
-0.5155270099639893,
-0.3958492875099182,
0.27864792943000793,
-0.389583945274353,
-0.21200916171073914,
-0.05676060914993286,
0.0008346825488843024,
0.3393882215023041,
-0.3632729947566986,
0.4679616689682007,
-0.2533005177974701,
-0.30888843536376953,
0.3480733633041382,
-0.62288898229599,
0.9515705108642578,
0.233561173081398,
-0.35621052980422974,
-0.43986108899116516,
-0.43808889389038086,
-0.09529436379671097,
0.12125008553266525,
-0.21284106373786926,
-0.36289602518081665,
-0.05993753299117088,
0.21630987524986267,
0.5105835199356079,
0.35066014528274536,
-0.8529500365257263,
0.09267739206552505,
-0.3538688123226166,
0.4860427677631378,
0.5924678444862366,
0.1674385517835617,
0.3609221279621124,
-0.33437901735305786,
0.6689440608024597,
-0.2081383317708969,
-0.21441633999347687,
-0.12154804170131683,
-0.5632631778717041,
-0.8112485408782959,
0.044458892196416855,
0.2783941924571991,
0.5321803092956543,
-1.0531617403030396,
0.09678107500076294,
-0.22542116045951843,
-0.35361623764038086,
-0.23141907155513763,
0.06828617304563522,
0.4762733578681946,
0.3473849892616272,
-0.06757085770368576,
-0.2218017280101776,
-0.4327629506587982,
-1.3457412719726562,
-0.32064831256866455,
-0.4809480607509613,
-0.18773409724235535,
0.40862831473350525,
0.523426353931427,
0.1457781344652176,
1.0824453830718994,
-0.34881457686424255,
-0.07463661581277847,
-0.2926962971687317,
-0.05716307461261749,
-0.003631369676440954,
0.29051366448402405,
0.6766939163208008,
-0.6901573538780212,
-0.8837859034538269,
0.07633058726787567,
-0.6379060745239258,
-0.2647184431552887,
-0.14008685946464539,
-0.20337261259555817,
0.3804972767829895,
0.0777410939335823,
-0.7382692694664001,
-0.13459669053554535,
0.7269682884216309,
-0.26944321393966675,
0.6368860006332397,
0.144361674785614,
0.0066872527822852135,
-1.1766042709350586,
0.07325515151023865,
0.39455026388168335,
-0.0033851105254143476,
-0.75273197889328,
0.14680039882659912,
0.21480698883533478,
-0.001919176196679473,
-0.423617422580719,
0.9393771886825562,
-0.34950125217437744,
0.36979955434799194,
-0.39197877049446106,
0.13788098096847534,
0.022702345624566078,
0.3058927655220032,
0.4127662777900696,
0.8927648067474365,
0.25697416067123413,
-0.19886980950832367,
0.24150517582893372,
0.07612191140651703,
-0.26552027463912964,
0.7503941059112549,
-0.35389360785484314,
0.1637452095746994,
-0.21984851360321045,
0.7687705755233765,
-0.7285536527633667,
-0.512522280216217,
0.1928771287202835,
-0.4146740436553955,
0.10798344761133194,
-0.44156911969184875,
-0.47434982657432556,
-0.5177261829376221,
-0.24339629709720612,
0.36316192150115967,
0.6001789569854736,
-0.35742589831352234,
0.054695259779691696,
0.2210080921649933,
-0.4319057762622833,
-0.40848538279533386,
-0.7754204273223877,
0.31165623664855957,
-0.4128679633140564,
-0.37691229581832886,
-0.0331098809838295,
0.11911036819219589,
-0.37891989946365356,
-0.36621275544166565,
0.10530295222997665,
-0.10885438323020935,
-0.24191197752952576,
-0.045917268842458725,
0.2646465301513672,
-0.11871389299631119,
0.12171813100576401,
-0.06020941957831383,
-0.04649149999022484,
0.15772363543510437,
-0.272339791059494,
0.5871974229812622,
0.07402706891298294,
-0.30158504843711853,
-0.16389405727386475,
0.17051491141319275,
0.3701316714286804,
-0.13974717259407043,
0.58785480260849,
0.5353386998176575,
-0.02787170559167862,
-0.1842561513185501,
-0.7467302083969116,
-0.18122407793998718,
-0.4044281244277954,
0.4428972005844116,
-0.09393345564603806,
-0.9157206416130066,
0.638191282749176,
0.6284481287002563,
0.23774074018001556,
0.7133976817131042,
0.6193646788597107,
0.23735512793064117,
0.7574827075004578,
0.3769054114818573,
-0.298354834318161,
0.2647826671600342,
0.19728627800941467,
0.31167274713516235,
-0.7656288743019104,
-0.023887664079666138,
-0.5574308633804321,
0.08365548402070999,
-1.27089524269104,
-0.33458083868026733,
0.08110301941633224,
-0.7719348669052124,
-0.4609348177909851,
0.12408352643251419,
-0.4540197551250458,
0.662041962146759,
0.40493056178092957,
-0.21662373840808868,
0.04540010169148445,
-0.05695367977023125,
0.15191499888896942,
-0.32325318455696106,
-0.5866568684577942,
-0.6834046840667725,
1.1394269466400146,
0.2858775556087494,
0.640347957611084,
0.11256610602140427,
0.7355639934539795,
0.11184705793857574,
0.5624219179153442,
-0.5893567204475403,
0.322252094745636,
-0.2699856758117676,
-1.1648792028427124,
-0.07684814184904099,
-0.6488623023033142,
-0.5317715406417847,
0.3536953926086426,
0.1168963760137558,
-0.7741420269012451,
-0.08297088742256165,
0.3024235963821411,
-0.4430793821811676,
0.19288507103919983,
-0.7373765707015991,
0.4198513627052307,
-0.22221913933753967,
-0.4806310832500458,
0.43700557947158813,
-0.46622589230537415,
0.7373901605606079,
-0.4064520597457886,
0.05157424509525299,
-0.29579654335975647,
0.25251850485801697,
0.6861127614974976,
-0.26663413643836975,
0.9640830159187317,
-0.3220175504684448,
-0.4259311556816101,
0.42233553528785706,
0.17901019752025604,
0.5118388533592224,
0.19849324226379395,
-0.49322545528411865,
0.2292429804801941,
-0.13256636261940002,
-0.5809129476547241,
-0.05231857672333717,
0.7441311478614807,
-0.7624737620353699,
-0.7279775142669678,
-0.4178823232650757,
-0.40735188126564026,
-0.20793329179286957,
0.26025161147117615,
0.563423752784729,
0.252699077129364,
-0.3602481186389923,
0.13729090988636017,
0.5253976583480835,
-0.5032556653022766,
0.2167612910270691,
0.31550121307373047,
-0.22102542221546173,
0.09347323328256607,
1.1713554859161377,
0.331949383020401,
0.4338698089122772,
0.13249610364437103,
0.20604881644248962,
-0.28887176513671875,
-0.13368122279644012,
-0.7563020586967468,
0.19183021783828735,
-0.506356954574585,
0.20276330411434174,
-0.6141003966331482,
-0.42499348521232605,
-0.2072114497423172,
-0.02138710208237171,
-0.5012076497077942,
-0.3634752035140991,
0.04884808510541916,
-0.0344984233379364,
0.22560374438762665,
0.48109865188598633,
0.2701716125011444,
0.5947420597076416,
-0.3043617308139801,
0.23235900700092316,
0.26770052313804626,
0.24045749008655548,
-0.0722859725356102,
-0.650810956954956,
-0.16197730600833893,
0.0715477466583252,
-0.3693341314792633,
-0.5446398854255676,
0.25823938846588135,
-0.09385541081428528,
0.42931073904037476,
0.3774554133415222,
0.19234207272529602,
-0.03485545516014099,
-0.4483439028263092,
1.3092046976089478,
-0.10838685929775238,
-0.5303558707237244,
-0.02861376851797104,
-0.8752578496932983,
0.6786900758743286,
0.48386117815971375,
0.18903443217277527,
-0.7440727353096008,
-0.8691566586494446,
-0.6095213890075684,
-0.8048486113548279,
0.7214908003807068,
0.34036168456077576,
0.8775308728218079,
-0.19779592752456665,
0.160541370511055,
0.3747135400772095,
0.1484510749578476,
-1.109956979751587,
-0.29018640518188477,
-0.29825690388679504,
0.14257517457008362,
-0.19335271418094635,
-0.34172382950782776,
0.03290433809161186,
0.25100430846214294,
0.7858505249023438,
-0.11386966705322266,
0.2734336853027344,
0.04071046784520149,
-0.06933309137821198,
0.23392213881015778,
0.3276187479496002,
0.7273092865943909,
0.6612558960914612,
-0.09760042279958725,
0.027741963043808937,
0.2607782781124115,
-0.4385771155357361,
0.09289313852787018,
0.07110338658094406,
-0.4826698303222656,
0.03468724712729454,
0.4102841019630432,
0.8002833127975464,
-0.5073972344398499,
-0.2231934517621994,
0.47790706157684326,
-0.0911797285079956,
-0.12351679056882858,
-0.34959882497787476,
0.061929356306791306,
0.21735084056854248,
-0.22031664848327637,
0.5317657589912415,
-0.19570006430149078,
0.03356108441948891,
-0.2663334608078003,
-0.07207702100276947,
0.7082605957984924,
-0.4229919910430908,
-0.45817267894744873,
0.698846161365509,
0.5280198454856873,
-0.06689906120300293,
0.6335102915763855,
-0.43867748975753784,
-0.8534207940101624,
0.7228472232818604,
0.42777594923973083,
0.724290132522583,
-0.10679327696561813,
0.512904703617096,
0.41551581025123596,
0.4754790663719177,
-0.15096807479858398,
-0.10219009965658188,
0.07710392773151398,
-0.8892049193382263,
-0.43327561020851135,
-0.4459713399410248,
-0.5132274031639099,
0.07957693934440613,
-0.23133975267410278,
0.2684949040412903,
-0.21608808636665344,
-0.3945446014404297,
-0.1884976178407669,
0.09784247726202011,
-0.7735191583633423,
0.1390034556388855,
0.3879031538963318,
0.5852431654930115,
-1.1985377073287964,
0.5548880100250244,
0.5260862112045288,
-0.19664447009563446,
-0.5316001176834106,
0.43514537811279297,
0.21154136955738068,
-0.7271916270256042,
0.5193138122558594,
0.33767426013946533,
0.2765119969844818,
-0.2371407449245453,
-0.22708982229232788,
-0.6567551493644714,
0.3266591727733612,
0.4087402820587158,
-0.2753574848175049,
0.12560419738292694,
0.4561039209365845,
0.7342472672462463,
-0.05950436741113663,
0.41110414266586304,
0.6219841241836548,
0.5028825402259827,
-0.07961641252040863,
-1.048815369606018,
-0.050307586789131165,
-0.15515469014644623,
0.09280005842447281,
0.17533840239048004,
-1.398179292678833,
0.9073382616043091,
0.12364980578422546,
-0.03192070499062538,
-0.12682950496673584,
0.2145206183195114,
0.3478843867778778,
0.017593421041965485,
0.12737581133842468,
-0.06141907721757889,
0.36449140310287476,
-0.1256951093673706,
1.0141133069992065,
-0.44847431778907776,
0.24433211982250214,
0.9960249662399292,
-0.4697418808937073,
0.20066498219966888,
0.4510481357574463,
-0.14891673624515533,
0.1462814211845398,
0.8527693748474121,
-0.016529643908143044,
0.12108677625656128,
0.2765505909919739,
-0.45302027463912964,
-0.09954319149255753,
-0.2659415900707245,
-0.5111696124076843,
0.5195648074150085,
-0.019097812473773956,
-0.5230944752693176,
-0.24356168508529663,
-0.08715023100376129,
0.5408802032470703,
-0.22411863505840302,
0.05373065918684006,
0.597617506980896,
0.32957497239112854,
-1.1114933490753174,
0.2152709811925888,
0.02112610824406147,
0.8414396643638611,
-0.33804893493652344,
0.18896692991256714,
-0.6077718138694763,
-0.33306944370269775,
-0.3098263442516327,
-0.8338714241981506,
-0.13693015277385712,
0.4382752478122711,
-0.0794023796916008,
-0.2031703144311905,
0.5161583423614502,
-0.32909706234931946,
-0.6318668723106384,
-0.16686491668224335,
0.6307103037834167,
0.42634502053260803,
-0.10352738201618195,
-0.33632752299308777,
-0.04997244104743004,
0.4529370665550232,
-0.6133793592453003,
0.2938826382160187,
0.4649093449115753,
-0.4469303488731384,
0.5006782412528992,
0.2756050229072571,
0.2563577890396118,
-0.1538044810295105,
0.08766360580921173,
0.4845949709415436,
-0.5043067336082458,
-0.3403875231742859,
-1.2039371728897095,
0.21292254328727722,
-0.1813925802707672,
-0.2757906913757324,
0.9846412539482117,
0.7042132616043091,
0.6816651821136475,
0.11423680931329727,
1.3227143287658691,
-0.30474433302879333,
0.33463701605796814,
-0.4254615604877472,
0.9716413021087646,
-0.07368577271699905,
0.0452374666929245,
-0.30436211824417114,
-1.4582767486572266,
-0.18980452418327332,
0.3429034650325775,
-0.7221494317054749,
0.5797735452651978,
0.416110634803772,
0.6848164796829224,
0.04487599432468414,
0.07556463778018951,
0.16211505234241486,
0.030251866206526756,
0.500983715057373,
0.24180209636688232,
0.8168424963951111,
0.030766133219003677,
0.33612990379333496,
-0.2553655207157135,
-0.12367851287126541,
0.11666131019592285,
-1.0007927417755127,
-0.9510754942893982,
-0.38559648394584656,
-0.10363642126321793,
-0.2771458029747009,
-0.019602496176958084,
1.0782880783081055,
0.654983639717102,
-0.6647960543632507,
-0.1627223789691925,
0.4225402772426605,
-0.0027228810358792543,
0.5340467095375061,
-0.22265420854091644,
0.35947343707084656,
-0.14988631010055542,
-0.9305950403213501,
-0.26293033361434937,
-0.18993784487247467,
0.10753356665372849,
-0.6373814344406128,
0.07554491609334946,
0.417605459690094,
0.11018485575914383,
0.6521562933921814,
0.2946077883243561,
-0.5420656800270081,
-0.44088488817214966,
-0.2126007080078125,
-0.12499097734689713,
0.06926752626895905,
0.5143944621086121,
-0.3211885094642639,
0.4876684248447418,
0.3284946084022522,
0.20280113816261292,
0.4470558166503906,
0.35257402062416077,
0.7510039210319519,
-0.7519016861915588,
0.2042444795370102,
0.12108314782381058,
0.0472392700612545,
0.7517107129096985,
-0.44302865862846375,
0.23718471825122833,
-0.043412432074546814,
-0.7087600827217102,
-0.6273325681686401,
0.2848816514015198,
-0.5906667709350586,
-0.03692349046468735,
1.712709903717041,
0.05055883526802063,
0.0953274518251419,
-0.08183713257312775,
-0.5009594559669495,
0.07164717465639114,
-0.7040342092514038,
0.9483395218849182,
1.273228406906128,
-0.0937991812825203,
-0.003939864691346884,
-1.1291066408157349,
0.5612851977348328,
0.3982428312301636,
-0.5303294658660889,
0.32989194989204407,
0.5967081189155579,
0.46605879068374634,
-0.06541399657726288,
0.7154629230499268,
0.000452182546723634,
0.04553118348121643,
-0.12525731325149536,
0.2539135813713074,
0.27789250016212463,
0.04685516655445099,
0.013045658357441425,
-0.07273359596729279,
0.5275905132293701,
0.28418204188346863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06981v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06981v1
|
AraSpell: A Deep Learning Approach for Arabic Spelling Correction
| 2024-05-11T10:36:28 | 2024-05-11T10:36:28 |
Mahmoud Salhab, Faisal Abu-Khzam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Spelling correction is the task of identifying spelling mistakes, typos, and
grammatical mistakes in a given text and correcting them according to their
context and grammatical structure. This work introduces "AraSpell," a framework
for Arabic spelling correction using different seq2seq model architectures such
as Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) and Transformer with artificial data
generation for error injection, trained on more than 6.9 Million Arabic
sentences. Thorough experimental studies provide empirical evidence of the
effectiveness of the proposed approach, which achieved 4.8% and 1.11% word
error rate (WER) and character error rate (CER), respectively, in comparison
with labeled data of 29.72% WER and 5.03% CER. Our approach achieved 2.9% CER
and 10.65% WER in comparison with labeled data of 10.02% CER and 50.94% WER.
Both of these results are obtained on a test set of 100K sentences.
|
[
-0.0682012289762497,
-0.7474097609519958,
0.1561613231897354,
-0.08428103476762772,
0.09137637168169022,
0.26845186948776245,
0.023759135976433754,
-0.37968793511390686,
0.14382517337799072,
0.6388017535209656,
-0.26462888717651367,
-0.9449915289878845,
-1.0139507055282593,
0.4582001268863678,
-0.6663028001785278,
0.9749224781990051,
-0.31782200932502747,
0.15050312876701355,
0.3188130557537079,
-0.31582513451576233,
-0.33582571148872375,
-0.4773057997226715,
-0.7489771246910095,
-0.004486896097660065,
0.7028341293334961,
0.9349085688591003,
0.8731163144111633,
0.6732251048088074,
0.4160001873970032,
0.39930999279022217,
-0.25186794996261597,
0.5897150635719299,
-0.07716821134090424,
0.13702623546123505,
-0.17626136541366577,
-0.42917898297309875,
-0.35736289620399475,
-0.2627304494380951,
0.6084164977073669,
0.8768389225006104,
-0.3912070393562317,
0.14995253086090088,
0.12735626101493835,
1.3345903158187866,
-0.9839375019073486,
-0.4826563000679016,
-0.35360264778137207,
0.36754655838012695,
-0.34299030900001526,
0.17763164639472961,
-0.16584527492523193,
-0.570178210735321,
0.1384151428937912,
-0.42373886704444885,
0.5131034851074219,
0.16499748826026917,
0.7030405402183533,
0.3075293302536011,
-0.5425682663917542,
-0.8730939030647278,
-0.7307773232460022,
0.6927667856216431,
-1.0114959478378296,
0.22888481616973877,
0.6598870158195496,
0.343749463558197,
-0.25332289934158325,
-0.8714346289634705,
-0.8289996385574341,
-0.10293398052453995,
-0.12296789884567261,
0.08465133607387543,
-0.1430397927761078,
0.3571619391441345,
0.12320403754711151,
0.2559922933578491,
-0.627254843711853,
-0.00007523086242144927,
-0.5249971151351929,
-0.2448662519454956,
0.5475978851318359,
-0.010989618487656116,
0.4361068904399872,
0.10938437283039093,
0.0651211366057396,
0.015559210442006588,
-0.5125680565834045,
0.08081022650003433,
0.5787298083305359,
0.24930407106876373,
0.22227881848812103,
0.8529679775238037,
-0.263920396566391,
0.6264986991882324,
0.20541062951087952,
-0.020969299599528313,
0.21773020923137665,
0.1585829108953476,
-0.36729463934898376,
0.616536557674408,
0.4333135783672333,
0.14279815554618835,
0.14399851858615875,
-0.12036172300577164,
-0.21348509192466736,
0.15017710626125336,
0.38688895106315613,
-0.5775597095489502,
-0.14359967410564423,
0.41159358620643616,
-0.31808239221572876,
-0.3049050569534302,
-0.007663315627723932,
-0.5524547100067139,
-0.5567110776901245,
-0.24392077326774597,
0.545984148979187,
-0.6708008646965027,
0.21945159137248993,
0.34459587931632996,
-0.0030526549089699984,
-0.16048938035964966,
0.31065690517425537,
-0.785763144493103,
0.4712078273296356,
0.5281537771224976,
0.7453916072845459,
-0.10827687382698059,
-0.7242923974990845,
-0.4593600928783417,
0.19326412677764893,
-0.6355883479118347,
1.0277546644210815,
-0.30784836411476135,
-0.16896769404411316,
0.24563786387443542,
-0.2439076155424118,
-0.24318289756774902,
-0.7048165798187256,
0.8100452423095703,
-0.6029418110847473,
0.04751529544591904,
0.04790479317307472,
-0.9541704654693604,
-0.6479687690734863,
0.12105399370193481,
-0.9190953373908997,
1.1885113716125488,
-0.024212893098592758,
-0.5182374715805054,
0.29048213362693787,
-0.6526257991790771,
-0.6211953163146973,
-0.06523365527391434,
0.1900767832994461,
-0.6732919812202454,
0.019863596186041832,
0.39667007327079773,
0.3168560564517975,
0.16528643667697906,
-0.04676511883735657,
0.32335221767425537,
-0.5316945314407349,
0.5212786793708801,
-0.20728030800819397,
0.4932868778705597,
0.11611635237932205,
-0.7144914269447327,
0.010058307088911533,
-1.0126447677612305,
0.1380576491355896,
-0.42500531673431396,
-0.3661879897117615,
-0.24226969480514526,
-0.10996653884649277,
0.08776697516441345,
0.1032964289188385,
-0.005351702217012644,
-0.550281286239624,
0.25712835788726807,
-0.965735673904419,
0.41737353801727295,
0.588111400604248,
-0.12968450784683228,
0.6151301860809326,
-0.4022365212440491,
0.6115060448646545,
0.15392045676708221,
-0.018258143216371536,
0.1868012547492981,
-0.29480284452438354,
-1.0955677032470703,
-0.05147559195756912,
0.609489917755127,
0.7440540790557861,
-0.5919626355171204,
0.4499579668045044,
0.07604693621397018,
-0.6576768755912781,
-0.7348998188972473,
0.25613129138946533,
0.6714469194412231,
0.5895075798034668,
0.4473353624343872,
-0.08536642789840698,
-0.771796464920044,
-0.7538736462593079,
-0.7455287575721741,
0.24251104891300201,
0.46328285336494446,
-0.06087471544742584,
0.8284342885017395,
-0.5160463452339172,
0.6806392669677734,
-0.22594110667705536,
-0.6592201590538025,
-0.3182958662509918,
0.37330058217048645,
0.45714181661605835,
0.3980046212673187,
0.2961370348930359,
-0.7765990495681763,
-0.7764279246330261,
0.1366482377052307,
-0.44428518414497375,
-0.06200306862592697,
0.26862436532974243,
0.08389085531234741,
0.7457963824272156,
0.2539485692977905,
-0.39516681432724,
1.0309945344924927,
0.5546509027481079,
-0.4023800790309906,
0.8559000492095947,
-0.36114877462387085,
0.4263889789581299,
-1.1873209476470947,
-0.07166874408721924,
-0.09409414976835251,
0.007508086506277323,
-0.7025485038757324,
0.03268764168024063,
-0.03352179378271103,
-0.0947844460606575,
-0.5496148467063904,
0.45711007714271545,
-0.5070182085037231,
0.022339046001434326,
-0.46969735622406006,
-0.21812616288661957,
0.0059916069731116295,
0.22925794124603271,
-0.28972095251083374,
1.263200283050537,
0.2346140593290329,
-0.7397862076759338,
0.44938725233078003,
0.48598381876945496,
-0.5463675260543823,
0.3296714425086975,
-0.6600326299667358,
0.18106180429458618,
-0.17217345535755157,
0.27274009585380554,
-1.1923993825912476,
-0.15915629267692566,
0.2656756639480591,
-0.5586431622505188,
-0.044800154864788055,
-0.0027091470547020435,
-0.4759098291397095,
-0.35047751665115356,
-0.05786799639463425,
0.5125935673713684,
0.19887065887451172,
-0.49216756224632263,
0.7846897840499878,
0.0822935551404953,
-0.28821372985839844,
-1.0454668998718262,
-0.6707766652107239,
0.24345780909061432,
-0.03903202340006828,
-0.41499027609825134,
0.47239476442337036,
0.25752776861190796,
-0.08635935187339783,
0.07381772249937057,
-0.04511992633342743,
-0.3890175521373749,
-0.12384214252233505,
0.4129745364189148,
-0.08922893553972244,
-0.0792975127696991,
0.2751327455043793,
0.23015892505645752,
-0.37723487615585327,
-0.3966297507286072,
-0.21318763494491577,
0.4293328523635864,
-0.02008814364671707,
-0.21952219307422638,
-0.9777562618255615,
0.6091219186782837,
0.36915403604507446,
-0.21172241866588593,
1.0149719715118408,
0.5246019959449768,
-0.4842284321784973,
-0.3790144622325897,
-0.6537014842033386,
0.017696693539619446,
-0.5248071551322937,
0.4584059417247772,
-0.25486069917678833,
-0.6758617758750916,
0.4306250810623169,
-0.2860541045665741,
-0.22849394381046295,
0.548276960849762,
0.30028262734413147,
-0.46274706721305847,
1.1609809398651123,
0.5960733294487,
-0.10578690469264984,
0.07367344200611115,
-0.43619251251220703,
0.45018523931503296,
-0.7223942279815674,
-0.16186323761940002,
-0.59575355052948,
-0.7925369739532471,
-0.37242352962493896,
-0.20501725375652313,
0.34124016761779785,
0.30509430170059204,
-0.5932168364524841,
0.3491794764995575,
-0.6249048113822937,
0.36037522554397583,
1.0128719806671143,
0.13669158518314362,
0.1694009155035019,
0.48857489228248596,
-0.32787954807281494,
-0.30873143672943115,
-0.5321352481842041,
-0.6116030216217041,
1.1476492881774902,
-0.1682712286710739,
0.50437992811203,
0.3442912995815277,
0.6715402007102966,
0.753548800945282,
0.0000496657048643101,
-0.7701132893562317,
0.36358657479286194,
-0.428884893655777,
-0.36058753728866577,
-0.46678426861763,
0.008436853066086769,
-1.0359004735946655,
-0.20451068878173828,
-0.3983355164527893,
-0.5140984654426575,
0.19971586763858795,
0.32688531279563904,
-0.4954378306865692,
0.420960009098053,
-0.5973257422447205,
0.6350774168968201,
-0.12935836613178253,
-0.05566931888461113,
-0.35671067237854004,
-0.6320298314094543,
-0.17980337142944336,
0.12462610751390457,
0.1612153798341751,
0.12605154514312744,
-0.0463787205517292,
0.9821679592132568,
-0.9437773823738098,
0.8500361442565918,
-0.04652368277311325,
0.013302982784807682,
0.258531779050827,
0.06951608508825302,
0.7099727988243103,
-0.44203269481658936,
-0.40723419189453125,
0.1259470134973526,
-0.044317785650491714,
-0.397262841463089,
-0.8373739719390869,
0.31060779094696045,
-1.1834558248519897,
-0.09027159959077835,
-0.8770548701286316,
-0.39820221066474915,
-0.09456826746463776,
0.1866951882839203,
0.5416340827941895,
0.4884195327758789,
-0.005504353437572718,
-0.1329852044582367,
0.5002999901771545,
-0.21500349044799805,
0.1803295761346817,
0.5532731413841248,
-0.05660972371697426,
-0.9123592376708984,
0.7102470993995667,
0.4425983130931854,
-0.203538715839386,
0.2677372694015503,
-0.006980149541050196,
-0.28907957673072815,
-0.6962378025054932,
-0.5396857857704163,
0.22133104503154755,
-0.779015064239502,
-0.2621903717517853,
-0.6581516861915588,
-0.529119074344635,
-0.5830296277999878,
-0.32912492752075195,
-0.3560011386871338,
-0.4618767499923706,
-0.10857437551021576,
-0.14061656594276428,
0.6571159958839417,
0.9823470711708069,
-0.08684434741735458,
0.749409556388855,
-0.8976532220840454,
0.28025689721107483,
0.141941100358963,
0.18961869180202484,
0.0430145263671875,
-0.6971319317817688,
-0.3086656332015991,
0.26787811517715454,
-0.22771337628364563,
-0.9804088473320007,
0.6872382760047913,
0.5443751215934753,
0.15425200760364532,
0.1584496647119522,
-0.13074710965156555,
1.0637184381484985,
-0.8421255350112915,
0.6969877481460571,
-0.02985343337059021,
-1.1733381748199463,
0.8458639979362488,
0.21009241044521332,
0.10470952093601227,
0.5614750981330872,
0.35636278986930847,
-1.0423600673675537,
-0.13303562998771667,
-0.5652657151222229,
-1.076013207435608,
0.5264689326286316,
0.22462435066699982,
-0.11337373405694962,
-0.009571541100740433,
0.8797421455383301,
0.19812361896038055,
0.32199668884277344,
-0.10939282178878784,
-0.5978532433509827,
0.15575850009918213,
-0.5742136836051941,
-0.1387266218662262,
-0.7308982014656067,
0.08951140195131302,
-0.4643465578556061,
1.2542576789855957,
0.09085087478160858,
0.13910679519176483,
0.4043634533882141,
-0.4921090602874756,
0.057611722499132156,
0.3883804976940155,
0.9305567741394043,
0.6852946281433105,
0.13480831682682037,
0.02203335613012314,
0.35982051491737366,
-0.9618780612945557,
0.44572001695632935,
0.09476904571056366,
-0.21865586936473846,
0.173956960439682,
0.5317315459251404,
0.6302366256713867,
0.06349406391382217,
-0.711452066898346,
0.4004172384738922,
0.21286052465438843,
-0.4025605320930481,
-0.7161099314689636,
-0.09636075794696808,
-0.28846320509910583,
0.237062469124794,
0.6530123353004456,
0.36512917280197144,
0.5699387788772583,
-0.14149606227874756,
0.2799968719482422,
-0.0871313065290451,
-0.2759365737438202,
0.0437561459839344,
0.365192174911499,
-0.012177245691418648,
-0.5705345273017883,
0.7907829284667969,
-0.016035296022892,
-0.7995684146881104,
0.8598955869674683,
0.6619564890861511,
0.6767122745513916,
-0.5908387303352356,
0.5252225399017334,
0.40827223658561707,
0.03364742547273636,
-0.1061798706650734,
0.3839232623577118,
0.34600546956062317,
-0.8745616674423218,
-0.4861844480037689,
-0.6831084489822388,
-0.5936155915260315,
-0.13245655596256256,
-0.6823047399520874,
0.030964147299528122,
-0.47895127534866333,
-0.035519618541002274,
0.0724458321928978,
0.1689355969429016,
-0.4536903202533722,
0.5562970042228699,
-0.13554500043392181,
0.7935369610786438,
-0.758583128452301,
0.6586475372314453,
1.1127923727035522,
-0.2098420411348343,
-1.1599444150924683,
-0.24473227560520172,
0.08825409412384033,
-0.9989885091781616,
0.9251844882965088,
0.2800939679145813,
-0.44331124424934387,
0.2592257559299469,
-0.33477097749710083,
-0.8993254899978638,
0.9634906649589539,
0.14202596247196198,
-0.8936737179756165,
0.09214673936367035,
0.6771057844161987,
0.5067930221557617,
-0.03229041397571564,
0.12483740597963333,
0.5308418273925781,
0.4002821445465088,
0.0998968631029129,
-0.7008974552154541,
-0.3583252429962158,
-0.3847319483757019,
0.2679184079170227,
0.3152428865432739,
-0.15862463414669037,
0.7171082496643066,
-0.20972442626953125,
-0.10063342750072479,
0.47127947211265564,
0.8938745856285095,
0.1348332315683365,
0.35743120312690735,
0.35028794407844543,
1.0288636684417725,
1.0235601663589478,
0.24119600653648376,
0.6621906757354736,
-0.3633697032928467,
0.22608515620231628,
1.0812968015670776,
-0.3304334282875061,
1.0644370317459106,
0.4204429090023041,
-0.2062409222126007,
0.8891891241073608,
0.5243145227432251,
0.24080340564250946,
0.42160728573799133,
0.11577597260475159,
-0.5463061332702637,
0.09981270879507065,
-0.02245103009045124,
-0.2733835279941559,
0.43550753593444824,
0.43014585971832275,
-0.43115419149398804,
-0.11488503962755203,
0.5063471794128418,
0.06183899939060211,
0.6213012337684631,
-0.44798755645751953,
0.764411449432373,
-0.11991509050130844,
-0.5312691330909729,
0.47673675417900085,
0.2805461287498474,
0.5584460496902466,
-0.17790736258029938,
-0.43849143385887146,
-0.3411869704723358,
0.7226386070251465,
-0.4113757610321045,
-0.7920358180999756,
0.5009824633598328,
-0.063318632543087,
-0.4171513319015503,
0.14664705097675323,
0.7091038227081299,
-0.4627406895160675,
-0.9765929579734802,
-0.08849672973155975,
0.19767701625823975,
0.196783185005188,
-0.20852991938591003,
-0.7516038417816162,
0.01856462098658085,
-0.2195805013179779,
0.21634303033351898,
-0.20383507013320923,
0.39750322699546814,
0.11009914427995682,
0.6936742067337036,
0.5483253002166748,
0.25518304109573364,
0.19507546722888947,
0.07565144449472427,
0.31352049112319946,
-0.8334140777587891,
-0.5053905844688416,
-0.8852958083152771,
0.3903934359550476,
-0.08441007137298584,
-0.5632873773574829,
0.8217365741729736,
0.6639249324798584,
0.5488545298576355,
-0.09693901985883713,
0.8605925440788269,
0.16920685768127441,
0.9571864604949951,
-0.5080012083053589,
0.8084608912467957,
-0.25476542115211487,
0.04525984451174736,
-0.1274334043264389,
-0.8403922915458679,
-0.6041222214698792,
0.95344477891922,
-0.33492401242256165,
-0.14975623786449432,
0.8539964556694031,
1.024488925933838,
0.2813468873500824,
0.08864811062812805,
0.12095356732606888,
0.3911046087741852,
-0.09637444466352463,
0.5648260712623596,
0.684814989566803,
-0.9769182801246643,
0.35891619324684143,
-0.3994005024433136,
-0.05967339500784874,
-0.41987109184265137,
-0.46624183654785156,
-0.7714118361473083,
-0.7001317143440247,
-0.3435898423194885,
-0.7436947226524353,
0.8151833415031433,
1.011423945426941,
0.3393247127532959,
-1.1070295572280884,
-0.20628400146961212,
-0.5221191644668579,
0.04419460520148277,
-0.8120262026786804,
-0.15524931252002716,
0.943763792514801,
-0.3194364309310913,
-0.6881119012832642,
0.1173267513513565,
0.08444452285766602,
-0.08130329847335815,
0.1563536822795868,
-0.11311609297990799,
-0.3485465347766876,
-0.06891174614429474,
0.5499008297920227,
0.24603523313999176,
-0.8103470206260681,
-0.33851417899131775,
-0.14026591181755066,
-0.3420455753803253,
0.16696633398532867,
0.4280564486980438,
-0.8182694911956787,
0.22275233268737793,
0.12576483190059662,
0.8741112947463989,
0.2360086292028427,
-0.1511480063199997,
0.5123236775398254,
-0.5672337412834167,
0.0962618738412857,
0.32758766412734985,
0.07279203832149506,
0.24406467378139496,
-0.45260491967201233,
0.522115170955658,
0.04087754338979721,
-0.8317989706993103,
-0.38660958409309387,
0.07766684144735336,
-0.755651593208313,
-0.04298663139343262,
1.000696063041687,
0.0025371548254042864,
-0.5067679286003113,
-0.22655802965164185,
-0.7394394278526306,
0.49321672320365906,
-0.24353526532649994,
1.0777379274368286,
0.7655471563339233,
0.08471191674470901,
-0.23493677377700806,
-0.5130546689033508,
0.6154155135154724,
0.7888141870498657,
-0.5048771500587463,
-0.48112010955810547,
0.354654461145401,
0.3590782582759857,
0.04369629546999931,
0.3267381489276886,
0.3134434223175049,
0.7298567891120911,
-0.24345912039279938,
0.40851160883903503,
0.08890172094106674,
-0.27804315090179443,
-0.2935737669467926,
0.09960916638374329,
-0.06612130254507065,
-0.23098796606063843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06932v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06932v1
|
Piccolo2: General Text Embedding with Multi-task Hybrid Loss Training
| 2024-05-11T06:32:08 | 2024-05-11T06:32:08 |
Junqin Huang, Zhongjie Hu, Zihao Jing, Mengya Gao, Yichao Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this report, we introduce Piccolo2, an embedding model that surpasses
other models in the comprehensive evaluation over 6 tasks on CMTEB benchmark,
setting a new state-of-the-art. Piccolo2 primarily leverages an efficient
multi-task hybrid loss training approach, effectively harnessing textual data
and labels from diverse downstream tasks. In addition, Piccolo2 scales up the
embedding dimension and uses MRL training to support more flexible vector
dimensions. The latest information of piccolo models can be accessed via:
https://huggingface.co/sensenova/
|
[
-0.12167975306510925,
-0.641418993473053,
0.3556932806968689,
0.46920686960220337,
-0.19037164747714996,
-0.0027068238705396652,
-0.23701338469982147,
-0.423422634601593,
0.1184692233800888,
0.39067450165748596,
-0.5740735530853271,
-0.4376217722892761,
-0.9152989387512207,
-0.2391532063484192,
-0.32674410939216614,
1.0087389945983887,
-0.15972799062728882,
0.5223585367202759,
-0.41742777824401855,
-0.19418011605739594,
-0.5102649927139282,
-0.4972769618034363,
-0.6927821636199951,
-0.5708744525909424,
0.46565183997154236,
0.3319493234157562,
0.35996013879776,
0.4435354471206665,
0.4926615357398987,
0.12999023497104645,
0.11693359911441803,
0.19546900689601898,
-0.5166083574295044,
-0.052045002579689026,
-0.12837634980678558,
-0.7590143084526062,
-0.31336072087287903,
0.12816204130649567,
0.7960460186004639,
0.4366988241672516,
-0.12107307463884354,
0.05582672730088234,
0.373199462890625,
0.5990211963653564,
-0.8376212120056152,
0.14933878183364868,
-0.555435836315155,
0.3109247088432312,
-0.27947714924812317,
-0.05936696380376816,
-0.5868830680847168,
-0.04558902606368065,
0.1909729689359665,
-0.7385547161102295,
0.3536747992038727,
-0.0783521831035614,
0.7493860721588135,
0.4017344117164612,
-0.5113608241081238,
-0.30801865458488464,
-0.5111890435218811,
1.0240815877914429,
-0.3128649592399597,
0.48941802978515625,
0.437756210565567,
0.24475248157978058,
0.2700701057910919,
-0.7134230732917786,
-0.5089016556739807,
0.023128625005483627,
0.07525582611560822,
0.5927808880805969,
0.0036380377132445574,
-0.029402639716863632,
-0.2308318167924881,
0.28178828954696655,
-0.5808719396591187,
0.18753454089164734,
-0.23109106719493866,
-0.1730065941810608,
0.384677916765213,
0.18426065146923065,
0.2210911214351654,
-0.1983993798494339,
-0.675977885723114,
-0.16875849664211273,
-0.46908652782440186,
-0.01800294779241085,
0.6061090230941772,
0.02694508247077465,
-0.22709307074546814,
0.7494218945503235,
0.30942073464393616,
0.722594678401947,
-0.06201169267296791,
-0.16757722198963165,
0.20635674893856049,
-0.731394350528717,
-0.15396443009376526,
0.0343138687312603,
0.8303185701370239,
0.5750874876976013,
0.008343021385371685,
-0.15349531173706055,
0.019946496933698654,
0.15309417247772217,
0.44718030095100403,
-0.7262605428695679,
-0.289487361907959,
-0.11377310007810593,
-0.7558572292327881,
-0.26432371139526367,
0.15007610619068146,
-0.7981228828430176,
-0.5354824662208557,
-0.38896429538726807,
0.290231317281723,
-0.6604008078575134,
-0.452415406703949,
0.14055845141410828,
-0.5269156098365784,
0.28909948468208313,
0.3606110215187073,
-1.18892502784729,
0.5201781988143921,
0.7607413530349731,
1.0953774452209473,
-0.23694457113742828,
-0.20472508668899536,
-0.3031000792980194,
0.28426849842071533,
-0.5317143201828003,
0.931307852268219,
-0.6179211735725403,
-0.5607103705406189,
-0.005775945261120796,
-0.0641980767250061,
-0.6937085390090942,
-0.5530422925949097,
0.7680142521858215,
-0.1840861588716507,
0.1097361296415329,
-0.30689701437950134,
-0.8364865779876709,
-0.29313498735427856,
0.17196066677570343,
-0.614915132522583,
1.30177903175354,
0.2827993333339691,
-0.8562224507331848,
0.21357478201389313,
-0.550923764705658,
-0.41336995363235474,
-0.304907888174057,
-0.09842383861541748,
-0.4801374077796936,
-0.06312693655490875,
-0.0512530654668808,
0.7710685133934021,
-0.5370750427246094,
-0.1090511605143547,
-0.427409827709198,
-0.24394752085208893,
-0.12483835965394974,
-0.24576334655284882,
0.6104267239570618,
-0.008437863551080227,
-0.14963224530220032,
0.04183243587613106,
-0.6163696646690369,
-0.15242433547973633,
0.2522519528865814,
-0.45316994190216064,
-0.5335502624511719,
0.20115287601947784,
0.6646028757095337,
-0.059237465262413025,
0.25313887000083923,
-0.7396308779716492,
0.20490142703056335,
-0.23661242425441742,
0.6025627255439758,
0.42382901906967163,
-0.2236897200345993,
0.439914345741272,
-0.3094864785671234,
0.46293485164642334,
-0.17486846446990967,
-0.18429222702980042,
-0.20104388892650604,
-0.852884829044342,
-0.5228289365768433,
-0.1145399808883667,
0.4897259771823883,
1.0174024105072021,
-0.4076494574546814,
0.6162688136100769,
-0.014218408614397049,
-0.7482677102088928,
-0.5903580188751221,
0.2934344708919525,
0.54735267162323,
0.39937520027160645,
0.5172087550163269,
0.02692858874797821,
-0.46370652318000793,
-1.2190630435943604,
0.06826189905405045,
0.29145318269729614,
-0.03802507370710373,
0.2692078948020935,
0.48869696259498596,
-0.31853827834129333,
0.6260811686515808,
-0.49696457386016846,
-0.7926807999610901,
-0.7312032580375671,
0.35901591181755066,
-0.3577479422092438,
0.7561684250831604,
0.7522833943367004,
-0.9031005501747131,
-0.5646892189979553,
0.021434158086776733,
-0.7798404693603516,
0.36573269963264465,
-0.41546913981437683,
0.09456483274698257,
0.2056014984846115,
0.6155040264129639,
-0.5830153822898865,
0.2940971255302429,
0.8497726917266846,
-0.0586346760392189,
0.5251891016960144,
-0.45677492022514343,
0.14577507972717285,
-1.408429503440857,
-0.00252674613147974,
0.3935382664203644,
-0.1345779299736023,
-0.4313112795352936,
-0.17091777920722961,
0.5433336496353149,
-0.20840369164943695,
-0.2586497366428375,
0.218944251537323,
-0.4788517653942108,
-0.3931857943534851,
-0.27194830775260925,
0.22634701430797577,
0.1538962721824646,
0.4609885811805725,
-0.06730680167675018,
0.9532705545425415,
0.49460312724113464,
-0.5728690028190613,
0.3207596242427826,
0.3504604697227478,
-0.47750893235206604,
0.736401379108429,
-0.885648250579834,
0.08030261844396591,
-0.16302740573883057,
0.6822633743286133,
-1.1127634048461914,
-0.22323492169380188,
0.3323729634284973,
-0.47059014439582825,
0.5787348747253418,
-0.14046217501163483,
-0.7307302355766296,
-0.4337339997291565,
-0.5655289888381958,
0.3007153570652008,
0.10496413707733154,
-0.35192373394966125,
0.5704582929611206,
0.5754497647285461,
-0.024604156613349915,
-0.40696844458580017,
-1.2000080347061157,
0.1340503692626953,
-0.0292546134442091,
-0.5667033791542053,
1.099764347076416,
-0.05986567214131355,
0.33919212222099304,
0.32613804936408997,
0.02347632870078087,
-0.21284128725528717,
-0.024254970252513885,
-0.020817318931221962,
0.03262651711702347,
-0.24457193911075592,
0.21793098747730255,
0.3201034963130951,
-0.43028703331947327,
-0.21340429782867432,
-0.2637307643890381,
0.6487788558006287,
0.10528755933046341,
-0.3004121482372284,
-0.9234112501144409,
0.5670640468597412,
0.30348291993141174,
-0.45279455184936523,
0.7363268733024597,
1.0616929531097412,
-0.6786569952964783,
-0.25666531920433044,
-0.3344505727291107,
0.30519554018974304,
-0.42323631048202515,
0.7446056008338928,
-0.42764970660209656,
-0.7228080034255981,
0.37229305505752563,
-0.12098182737827301,
-0.09486330300569534,
0.7252835631370544,
0.5487684607505798,
-0.20367860794067383,
0.9734153151512146,
0.7823229432106018,
-0.03928511589765549,
0.34012410044670105,
-0.5547629594802856,
0.0019195651402696967,
-1.3307422399520874,
-0.6399757862091064,
-0.6074666380882263,
-0.4240501821041107,
-0.2454276829957962,
-0.8949905037879944,
0.1870233416557312,
0.33061251044273376,
0.13682566583156586,
0.5863144397735596,
-0.5804744958877563,
0.3645845055580139,
0.7036219239234924,
0.25214338302612305,
-0.20926232635974884,
-0.3380332291126251,
-0.030894028022885323,
-0.16013693809509277,
-0.7249509692192078,
-0.3774978518486023,
1.3146312236785889,
0.27899375557899475,
0.7989950776100159,
-0.05047628656029701,
0.5408453345298767,
0.5557852387428284,
0.005900821648538113,
-0.955924391746521,
0.29314953088760376,
-0.642968475818634,
-0.5777252912521362,
-0.19220392405986786,
-0.025700435042381287,
-0.9045119881629944,
0.18466347455978394,
-0.2650250792503357,
-0.6562460660934448,
-0.08532612770795822,
0.14421992003917694,
-0.36549755930900574,
0.5979884266853333,
-0.7482810616493225,
1.1121093034744263,
0.028851628303527832,
-0.00047542754327878356,
-0.7337983250617981,
-0.37134096026420593,
0.48312145471572876,
0.013957695104181767,
-0.13772700726985931,
-0.09578253328800201,
-0.5226989984512329,
1.0753592252731323,
-0.09810922294855118,
0.8416658639907837,
-0.36720168590545654,
0.019576968625187874,
0.46486514806747437,
-0.3528899848461151,
0.568644642829895,
0.0373944528400898,
-0.06269355863332748,
-0.061863336712121964,
-0.0898585245013237,
-0.4706233739852905,
-0.5871298313140869,
0.9390174150466919,
-0.8153502941131592,
-0.12481487542390823,
-0.34652870893478394,
-0.2558678388595581,
-0.3443508446216583,
-0.01706894300878048,
0.560175895690918,
0.6789796948432922,
-0.27083948254585266,
0.5212708115577698,
0.9446925520896912,
-0.6309267282485962,
0.3760562837123871,
-0.07369613647460938,
0.30916476249694824,
-0.5992158055305481,
0.9438613653182983,
0.18795277178287506,
0.10157223045825958,
0.6970411539077759,
0.05102432519197464,
-0.5809608697891235,
-0.5800576210021973,
-0.7762970328330994,
0.09518014639616013,
-0.6548986434936523,
-0.2351958006620407,
-0.890834629535675,
-0.15915335714817047,
-0.5211389064788818,
-0.17021295428276062,
-0.7354904413223267,
-0.44324252009391785,
-0.5588794350624084,
-0.11412163078784943,
-0.004770063329488039,
1.0380985736846924,
0.00835639052093029,
0.5078043937683105,
-0.7727916836738586,
0.5062312483787537,
0.13262246549129486,
0.5350433588027954,
0.13296353816986084,
-0.22685974836349487,
-0.41160163283348083,
-0.06441996246576309,
-0.46331000328063965,
-1.000622034072876,
-0.08198568224906921,
0.3260055482387543,
0.8972977995872498,
0.46160826086997986,
-0.24720054864883423,
0.46696579456329346,
-0.6400518417358398,
0.9348957538604736,
0.5396501421928406,
-0.9587306380271912,
0.6529892086982727,
-0.5341301560401917,
0.1839698702096939,
0.39829200506210327,
0.5189509987831116,
-0.41853708028793335,
0.10725487768650055,
-0.2789209187030792,
-0.7154375314712524,
0.6461284160614014,
0.025680072605609894,
0.24564258754253387,
0.11272230744361877,
0.21512702107429504,
0.23168222606182098,
-0.029043050482869148,
-0.3450659215450287,
-0.40159720182418823,
-0.46547049283981323,
-0.30930212140083313,
-0.19654016196727753,
-0.6022074222564697,
0.30348411202430725,
-0.2671443223953247,
0.6329703330993652,
-0.04869041219353676,
0.8856775164604187,
0.29305845499038696,
-0.27844253182411194,
0.08832383155822754,
-0.06592971831560135,
0.8258717060089111,
0.27991676330566406,
-0.06557255983352661,
-0.12378372251987457,
0.14832894504070282,
-0.4258756935596466,
0.10479169338941574,
0.18832220137119293,
0.03083297610282898,
0.002184262266382575,
0.4902307093143463,
0.8061899542808533,
0.7881453633308411,
-0.3499775826931,
0.572528064250946,
0.14007697999477386,
-0.7037048935890198,
-0.21515031158924103,
0.0887317955493927,
0.3473585844039917,
-0.02075277268886566,
0.37396907806396484,
0.5109999775886536,
0.30699995160102844,
-0.4440115988254547,
0.3765321969985962,
0.2856406271457672,
-0.43629470467567444,
-0.31341752409935,
1.004138469696045,
0.3504849076271057,
-0.09990447014570236,
0.38157880306243896,
-0.24235022068023682,
-0.6460514068603516,
0.696000874042511,
0.6494485139846802,
0.8682949542999268,
-0.30841249227523804,
0.48119789361953735,
0.5382850170135498,
0.3549446165561676,
-0.15366420149803162,
0.0674452930688858,
0.048347484320402145,
-0.5837098360061646,
-0.45201635360717773,
-0.4246155619621277,
-0.5919694900512695,
0.08071597665548325,
-0.9041690826416016,
0.12381193041801453,
-0.6287883520126343,
-0.1994287371635437,
0.3408103585243225,
0.039253994822502136,
-0.6986632347106934,
0.15525449812412262,
0.14730548858642578,
0.9735559821128845,
-0.5075290203094482,
1.1331053972244263,
0.8147311806678772,
-0.15802504122257233,
-0.22921140491962433,
-0.10886965692043304,
0.3038977086544037,
-0.6883557438850403,
0.476974755525589,
0.5521667003631592,
-0.07009050995111465,
-0.005838474258780479,
-0.04145267233252525,
-0.8953065276145935,
1.2743775844573975,
0.16363324224948883,
-0.7198058366775513,
0.05923515558242798,
0.025938425213098526,
0.25286146998405457,
-0.32364368438720703,
-0.011906108818948269,
0.26601749658584595,
0.5666634440422058,
-0.3235612213611603,
-0.7710330486297607,
-0.25166022777557373,
-0.31297555565834045,
0.17577125132083893,
0.20421087741851807,
-0.9438686966896057,
0.7173916697502136,
-0.19041958451271057,
-0.16071388125419617,
0.3322827219963074,
0.7925103902816772,
-0.16283218562602997,
0.3519335389137268,
0.5239954590797424,
0.8684685826301575,
0.9209650754928589,
-0.2699892520904541,
1.3266111612319946,
-0.2852262854576111,
0.30566471815109253,
1.2915985584259033,
-0.27321872115135193,
0.9728314280509949,
-0.051049843430519104,
-0.3385913372039795,
0.3856751024723053,
0.778995931148529,
-0.36245185136795044,
0.7256405353546143,
0.11379816383123398,
-0.16589386761188507,
-0.2602883577346802,
-0.10432225465774536,
-0.4395351707935333,
0.4291848838329315,
0.5224045515060425,
-0.2530788481235504,
-0.22842399775981903,
0.40801918506622314,
-0.007039446383714676,
0.1921572983264923,
-0.15021315217018127,
0.5568780899047852,
-0.04362902790307999,
-0.5965996384620667,
0.2499287724494934,
0.518523633480072,
1.0649198293685913,
-0.816168487071991,
0.15789510309696198,
0.11374975740909576,
0.41024264693260193,
0.1071956604719162,
-0.8509465456008911,
0.6258938908576965,
-0.24416758120059967,
-0.41771307587623596,
-0.32413986325263977,
0.8583697080612183,
-0.39437898993492126,
-0.5281322002410889,
0.7463520765304565,
0.12815560400485992,
-0.1771821230649948,
-0.19452063739299774,
-1.0678046941757202,
0.04278155788779259,
-0.03897976875305176,
-0.25698888301849365,
0.43771398067474365,
0.10206541419029236,
0.235255166888237,
0.6220537424087524,
0.485395222902298,
-0.23009532690048218,
0.11905930191278458,
0.20905610918998718,
0.5584038496017456,
-0.7047351598739624,
-0.5170087814331055,
-0.5365811586380005,
0.2996424436569214,
-0.1587609201669693,
-0.5975320339202881,
0.7316532135009766,
0.8914830088615417,
0.7587398886680603,
-0.27610376477241516,
1.115226149559021,
0.028682352975010872,
0.5626911520957947,
-0.5760945677757263,
0.647434413433075,
-0.6451969742774963,
-0.2742330729961395,
-0.12984159588813782,
-0.9228797554969788,
-0.20460854470729828,
0.5889589190483093,
0.1423007696866989,
-0.07694417983293533,
0.822005569934845,
0.5675061941146851,
-0.07106436789035797,
0.16818201541900635,
0.1810031235218048,
-0.20279736816883087,
0.20011493563652039,
0.6360093355178833,
0.5096743702888489,
-0.6899638772010803,
0.7160674333572388,
-0.25856277346611023,
-0.14408940076828003,
-0.2261112630367279,
-0.5773631930351257,
-1.1097642183303833,
-0.7949063777923584,
-0.43887877464294434,
-0.0075612240470945835,
0.06515166163444519,
0.586134672164917,
0.9040310382843018,
-0.7778664231300354,
0.05412115156650543,
-0.12992174923419952,
-0.129010409116745,
-0.3665045201778412,
-0.21699170768260956,
0.48409879207611084,
-0.5098251700401306,
-0.9212502837181091,
0.6811598539352417,
0.28237828612327576,
0.2744313180446625,
-0.3430759310722351,
-0.1400008350610733,
-0.39301955699920654,
-0.11583640426397324,
0.7161198258399963,
-0.16638053953647614,
-0.639779806137085,
-0.05720635503530502,
-0.25587573647499084,
-0.18754227459430695,
-0.1728028655052185,
0.9526536464691162,
-0.4838099181652069,
0.1651400476694107,
0.6057471632957458,
1.0192605257034302,
0.6863610744476318,
-0.11915724724531174,
0.6725403070449829,
-0.6153255701065063,
0.08918024599552155,
-0.04266646131873131,
0.46469324827194214,
0.4479816257953644,
-0.19487667083740234,
0.6139929294586182,
0.5130223631858826,
-0.3576742708683014,
-0.5720587372779846,
-0.12001483142375946,
-1.3810549974441528,
-0.38023343682289124,
1.0417366027832031,
-0.2938777208328247,
0.178291454911232,
0.03428879752755165,
-0.3048936724662781,
0.26456335186958313,
-0.2544390857219696,
0.2554016709327698,
0.8462275862693787,
0.07812506705522537,
-0.12145300209522247,
-0.8492354154586792,
0.4402468800544739,
0.4820198118686676,
-0.7787107825279236,
-0.07429461926221848,
0.17677482962608337,
0.19945128262043,
0.21402062475681305,
0.5447267293930054,
0.048429057002067566,
0.3156450092792511,
0.41805389523506165,
-0.29550355672836304,
-0.1602863371372223,
-0.47432759404182434,
0.07486774027347565,
0.2567001283168793,
-0.44921302795410156,
-0.5079333186149597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06922v1
|
EmoMix-3L: A Code-Mixed Dataset for Bangla-English-Hindi Emotion Detection
| 2024-05-11T05:58:55 | 2024-05-11T05:58:55 |
Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami, Antara Mahmud, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Code-mixing is a well-studied linguistic phenomenon that occurs when two or
more languages are mixed in text or speech. Several studies have been conducted
on building datasets and performing downstream NLP tasks on code-mixed data.
Although it is not uncommon to observe code-mixing of three or more languages,
most available datasets in this domain contain code-mixed data from only two
languages. In this paper, we introduce EmoMix-3L, a novel multi-label emotion
detection dataset containing code-mixed data from three different languages. We
experiment with several models on EmoMix-3L and we report that MuRIL
outperforms other models on this dataset.
|
[
-0.6578589081764221,
-0.5051541328430176,
0.2400853931903839,
0.7145020961761475,
-0.14349254965782166,
0.272969126701355,
-0.06951266527175903,
-0.580900251865387,
0.24997471272945404,
0.1587219536304474,
-0.36221936345100403,
-0.6781843304634094,
-0.5731820464134216,
0.4982772469520569,
-0.21116425096988678,
0.9473239779472351,
-0.3421020209789276,
0.17569001019001007,
0.324053019285202,
-0.5035672187805176,
-0.2665145695209503,
-0.8015552163124084,
-0.3001978099346161,
-0.3589417338371277,
0.4905466139316559,
0.47450509667396545,
0.8802706003189087,
0.316611647605896,
0.2640198767185211,
0.08101356029510498,
0.07288172841072083,
0.1157948225736618,
-0.18117976188659668,
0.19160430133342743,
0.6225383877754211,
-0.8017061352729797,
-0.3774048089981079,
-0.20834316313266754,
0.2325800508260727,
0.02737010084092617,
-0.29872360825538635,
-0.20729964971542358,
-0.08077210187911987,
0.7809386253356934,
-1.0592843294143677,
0.23874250054359436,
-0.019248444586992264,
0.556545078754425,
-0.36666709184646606,
0.02413131855428219,
-0.2893330454826355,
-0.6916484236717224,
-0.2967970371246338,
-0.19185805320739746,
-0.35760584473609924,
0.19645975530147552,
0.562707781791687,
0.2978629469871521,
-0.49879759550094604,
-0.5448638200759888,
-0.38721776008605957,
0.7919648289680481,
-0.9156110286712646,
0.563707709312439,
0.40934860706329346,
0.048227690160274506,
0.5345229506492615,
-0.021953895688056946,
-0.885378360748291,
0.418946236371994,
-0.07234116643667221,
0.2531716227531433,
-0.5222565531730652,
-0.20877185463905334,
0.14369279146194458,
0.30086326599121094,
-0.6846882700920105,
-0.05865202844142914,
-0.21853651106357574,
0.12051770836114883,
0.43388962745666504,
0.09970604628324509,
0.5963664650917053,
-0.20641160011291504,
-0.23628343641757965,
0.015229144133627415,
-0.8022735714912415,
-0.28952556848526,
0.7169068455696106,
0.1828019618988037,
-0.5320545434951782,
0.547364354133606,
0.014532100409269333,
0.9820780158042908,
-0.4104121923446655,
-0.11223214864730835,
0.7873259782791138,
-0.014609266072511673,
-0.30977097153663635,
0.27379095554351807,
0.9516246318817139,
0.4342968165874481,
0.42131343483924866,
0.36587315797805786,
-0.3860211670398712,
0.36591899394989014,
-0.32320573925971985,
-0.6826810240745544,
-0.26525384187698364,
0.6077510714530945,
-0.5929514169692993,
-0.2747248709201813,
-0.3226972222328186,
-1.263384461402893,
-0.5188769102096558,
-0.12938904762268066,
0.13834232091903687,
-0.5502693057060242,
-0.6549355387687683,
0.1799526959657669,
0.026344269514083862,
0.27994686365127563,
-0.024326778948307037,
-0.9747304320335388,
0.17276553809642792,
0.5854087471961975,
0.8775013089179993,
-0.32178419828414917,
-0.33471253514289856,
-0.061749428510665894,
-0.18796710669994354,
-0.2915252149105072,
0.7708306312561035,
-0.824287474155426,
-0.24878989160060883,
0.2751595377922058,
-0.49395105242729187,
-0.008681714534759521,
-0.6022424101829529,
0.22336339950561523,
-0.3621627390384674,
-0.017177622765302658,
0.36109161376953125,
-0.35990583896636963,
-0.12513534724712372,
0.2755233645439148,
-0.9075860381126404,
1.2609443664550781,
0.21698527038097382,
-0.8479180335998535,
0.362283855676651,
-0.5345987677574158,
-0.34178248047828674,
-0.03719387203454971,
-0.2986774444580078,
-0.48899319767951965,
-0.004754189867526293,
0.165105402469635,
0.5663039684295654,
-0.2891933023929596,
0.06764907389879227,
-0.6395350098609924,
-0.4975448250770569,
0.5525082945823669,
-0.10276921838521957,
0.5918458700180054,
0.7087528109550476,
-0.20658645033836365,
-0.32267943024635315,
-0.9628426432609558,
0.15530122816562653,
-0.136773020029068,
-0.3236917555332184,
-0.4494282603263855,
-0.0804157629609108,
0.3186550438404083,
0.5295143127441406,
-0.13933639228343964,
-0.7999884486198425,
0.13815633952617645,
-0.11704356223344803,
-0.058744579553604126,
0.26674437522888184,
-0.2905304431915283,
0.12885621190071106,
-0.24835717678070068,
0.8840516805648804,
0.19902928173542023,
0.11027868837118149,
-0.2329242080450058,
-0.8856168985366821,
-0.7925151586532593,
-0.18749983608722687,
0.03287706524133682,
0.7812241911888123,
-0.9193442463874817,
0.05476747080683708,
0.19702517986297607,
-0.28101468086242676,
-1.0391550064086914,
0.11517485231161118,
0.5605494976043701,
-0.34453141689300537,
0.3949757516384125,
0.21387410163879395,
-0.5017690658569336,
-0.8820787072181702,
-0.5308618545532227,
0.2190054953098297,
-0.011140038259327412,
0.36641111969947815,
0.308204710483551,
-0.35729727149009705,
0.7356088161468506,
-0.783858060836792,
-0.2518351376056671,
-0.317526251077652,
0.5464750528335571,
0.38573968410491943,
0.3837321996688843,
0.6622676253318787,
-0.9960769414901733,
-0.879132091999054,
0.19346292316913605,
-0.7703897356987,
-0.363346666097641,
0.13654638826847076,
0.23232442140579224,
0.6158904433250427,
0.24987180531024933,
0.06487523764371872,
0.47832202911376953,
1.2299391031265259,
-0.2816928029060364,
0.12064133584499359,
0.12835384905338287,
0.4816613495349884,
-1.0984078645706177,
-0.4014193117618561,
0.04852898418903351,
0.056719787418842316,
-0.8089447021484375,
-0.17182861268520355,
0.6345840692520142,
-0.22642701864242554,
-0.8110008239746094,
0.3468100428581238,
-0.2986140847206116,
-0.11969010531902313,
-0.25001057982444763,
-0.04671448469161987,
0.019202563911676407,
0.8040642142295837,
0.0817418023943901,
0.48855337500572205,
0.6675819158554077,
-0.42634907364845276,
0.6480088233947754,
0.3444473147392273,
-0.24867604672908783,
0.802062451839447,
-0.08269048482179642,
0.08740170300006866,
0.09275823831558228,
-0.09863818436861038,
-0.9311456680297852,
-0.41496485471725464,
0.3677254915237427,
-0.36972689628601074,
0.2322198748588562,
-0.1677246242761612,
-0.6133928894996643,
-0.27797189354896545,
-0.40199756622314453,
0.8490498661994934,
0.43250980973243713,
-0.7771312594413757,
0.7477067112922668,
0.29485511779785156,
-0.24508200585842133,
-0.40350937843322754,
-1.2883000373840332,
-0.1542121022939682,
-0.3615627586841583,
-0.40334513783454895,
-0.10070314258337021,
-0.16919927299022675,
-0.14654023945331573,
-0.0331340990960598,
0.1236117035150528,
-0.6356902122497559,
-0.21243324875831604,
0.3776971399784088,
0.15412122011184692,
0.04016835242509842,
0.0984826385974884,
-0.024930167943239212,
0.15962578356266022,
0.12179634720087051,
0.3483164608478546,
0.5168772339820862,
-0.25233200192451477,
-0.25446754693984985,
-0.3704182505607605,
0.697352409362793,
0.4322027862071991,
-0.11449114233255386,
0.573453426361084,
0.6859433054924011,
-0.4665490388870239,
-0.24951666593551636,
-0.2912493348121643,
0.41360214352607727,
-0.4013536274433136,
0.10472257435321808,
-0.5256291031837463,
-0.8672767281532288,
0.5193975567817688,
0.08263954520225525,
-0.3248843550682068,
0.14631761610507965,
0.7666499018669128,
0.09812753647565842,
1.5209722518920898,
0.5284023284912109,
-0.18587921559810638,
0.28817683458328247,
0.2561435401439667,
0.548477292060852,
-0.7183882594108582,
-0.39966416358947754,
-0.721016526222229,
-0.09124401211738586,
-0.7850742936134338,
-0.27870383858680725,
0.21393190324306488,
-0.27662214636802673,
-0.2514214515686035,
0.06022854521870613,
-0.3409575819969177,
0.6038371920585632,
0.17293594777584076,
0.12706737220287323,
0.2567399740219116,
-0.070486880838871,
0.006546017713844776,
-0.10157904028892517,
-0.615341305732727,
-0.05313771963119507,
1.1006450653076172,
0.13535435497760773,
1.3086820840835571,
0.4735792279243469,
0.8786768913269043,
0.2955612540245056,
0.5710216164588928,
-0.7402277588844299,
0.004089973866939545,
-0.06294593214988708,
-0.5799416899681091,
0.37864553928375244,
-0.4173087477684021,
-0.8067660927772522,
0.2828081250190735,
-0.1857251673936844,
-0.7538833618164062,
0.3834990859031677,
0.1405206024646759,
-0.38158127665519714,
0.3371203541755676,
-0.7176457047462463,
0.709841251373291,
-0.4178641438484192,
-0.09465194493532181,
0.12791860103607178,
-0.5571101903915405,
0.8809465765953064,
-0.7112903594970703,
0.8439146876335144,
-0.3655225932598114,
0.10422996431589127,
0.6891721487045288,
-0.11701366305351257,
0.5665011405944824,
0.18915610015392303,
-0.532423734664917,
0.040157251060009,
0.22768191993236542,
0.11432890594005585,
0.032886262983083725,
-0.20479658246040344,
0.12015082687139511,
-0.09504564851522446,
-0.31831055879592896,
-0.661554753780365,
0.7582164406776428,
-0.7848708629608154,
-0.045457158237695694,
-0.5628714561462402,
-0.5638070702552795,
-0.27375784516334534,
-0.10364125669002533,
0.12138836085796356,
0.5079221725463867,
0.3368440568447113,
0.08769673109054565,
0.45796841382980347,
-0.6604543328285217,
0.3882775902748108,
0.6013928055763245,
-0.7145822048187256,
-0.664921224117279,
0.940432071685791,
-0.31760329008102417,
0.3242429196834564,
0.2698507606983185,
0.1098845824599266,
-0.19183632731437683,
0.1446823626756668,
-0.4005275368690491,
-0.15825465321540833,
-0.8070510625839233,
-0.5784636735916138,
-0.8683481812477112,
0.2343120276927948,
-0.11908788979053497,
-0.2577623128890991,
-0.4654875695705414,
-0.11471891403198242,
-0.07738662511110306,
0.1894356906414032,
0.49530911445617676,
1.0242143869400024,
-0.27086904644966125,
0.4090374708175659,
-1.0877306461334229,
0.5925136804580688,
0.17063535749912262,
0.8472020030021667,
-0.28967544436454773,
-0.16533933579921722,
-0.2525620758533478,
0.01599762961268425,
-0.0809456929564476,
-1.469157338142395,
0.9183824062347412,
0.1857462376356125,
0.1607244312763214,
0.5172964334487915,
-0.15905334055423737,
0.3298371434211731,
-0.08546528220176697,
0.6058322787284851,
0.26421138644218445,
-1.3944894075393677,
0.5909934639930725,
-0.26306694746017456,
0.29483699798583984,
0.08764635771512985,
0.7259429693222046,
-0.7979624271392822,
-0.49581095576286316,
-0.46615007519721985,
-0.8375273942947388,
1.003430724143982,
0.4143315553665161,
-0.24234366416931152,
-0.0608295276761055,
-0.08938615024089813,
0.11898303031921387,
0.24150073528289795,
-1.0663611888885498,
-0.5743746161460876,
-0.20159655809402466,
-0.5894588232040405,
0.1295960694551468,
-0.3057435154914856,
-0.09676390886306763,
-0.008666707202792168,
0.37732556462287903,
-0.022187190130352974,
0.43541255593299866,
-0.15929409861564636,
-0.1119372546672821,
0.004282898269593716,
0.5663366317749023,
0.34141823649406433,
0.10226546972990036,
-0.611752450466156,
0.2948387861251831,
0.05487662926316261,
-0.3024784326553345,
0.3373790979385376,
0.01876692846417427,
0.28141894936561584,
-0.02397814206779003,
0.1320694237947464,
0.8687390685081482,
0.3187754452228546,
-0.7433505654335022,
0.49075207114219666,
-0.30838465690612793,
-0.08238701522350311,
0.10734065622091293,
-0.16320891678333282,
-0.028236698359251022,
0.24344588816165924,
0.2825470566749573,
0.24185460805892944,
0.42410194873809814,
-0.4749468266963959,
0.33011582493782043,
-0.23845355212688446,
-0.3722090721130371,
-0.09992237389087677,
0.4798295497894287,
0.27260974049568176,
-0.24440144002437592,
0.4041828513145447,
-0.2919715940952301,
-0.9008228778839111,
0.8710134625434875,
0.7548367381095886,
0.7529756426811218,
-0.42144379019737244,
0.1559898406267166,
0.15000171959400177,
0.1879611760377884,
0.007573178503662348,
1.0123510360717773,
0.06862547248601913,
-1.0278406143188477,
-0.23372331261634827,
-0.5623248815536499,
-0.6607424020767212,
-0.2923261225223541,
-1.0892423391342163,
0.3230361342430115,
-0.06310056149959564,
0.12697556614875793,
-0.14253313839435577,
-0.3849831223487854,
-0.787095308303833,
0.36753442883491516,
0.722817599773407,
0.5089308023452759,
-1.278667688369751,
0.9137281179428101,
0.5673348307609558,
0.013121555559337139,
-0.940108597278595,
-0.19481167197227478,
0.296956330537796,
-0.8273089528083801,
0.7796564102172852,
0.43806424736976624,
-0.04673493281006813,
0.12093839794397354,
-0.5088984370231628,
-0.7678442001342773,
0.6729552149772644,
-0.10726051032543182,
-0.38612112402915955,
0.9767436385154724,
0.09289686381816864,
0.4533228576183319,
-0.622371256351471,
0.41691815853118896,
1.1171324253082275,
0.483791708946228,
-0.15975002944469452,
-0.5414530038833618,
-0.1616290807723999,
-0.6347270607948303,
-0.22353090345859528,
0.6379640698432922,
-0.6048040986061096,
1.1761223077774048,
-0.014818577095866203,
-0.1966131329536438,
-0.26422128081321716,
0.2563079595565796,
0.5784358978271484,
0.31868183612823486,
0.3615272045135498,
0.5754921436309814,
0.5907145142555237,
-0.40353503823280334,
1.232203483581543,
-0.47712767124176025,
0.6013880968093872,
0.8747924566268921,
-0.7705877423286438,
0.8714255690574646,
0.21889713406562805,
-0.45731085538864136,
0.45322349667549133,
0.8657596707344055,
-0.20870310068130493,
0.3286067843437195,
0.1034381166100502,
-0.3539392650127411,
0.01818675920367241,
-0.13680754601955414,
-0.4920010268688202,
0.46353980898857117,
0.6329364776611328,
-0.01646621711552143,
-0.09032874554395676,
0.3093624413013458,
0.3247264325618744,
-0.2915790379047394,
-0.09641051292419434,
0.5266342759132385,
-0.15400077402591705,
-0.5809492468833923,
0.7264227867126465,
-0.17728152871131897,
0.9872065782546997,
-0.38651952147483826,
-0.12890470027923584,
-0.5987525582313538,
0.12883682548999786,
-0.4633599519729614,
-1.2154717445373535,
0.29294973611831665,
0.1966894268989563,
0.1282910406589508,
-0.21334408223628998,
0.3725075423717499,
-0.9543567299842834,
-0.349601686000824,
0.762026309967041,
0.36469218134880066,
0.3624544143676758,
-0.06886082887649536,
-0.6216671466827393,
0.7022060751914978,
0.26837316155433655,
-0.24991214275360107,
0.08520606905221939,
0.6163228154182434,
0.38728731870651245,
0.6747514009475708,
0.22793225944042206,
0.057072002440690994,
0.24436035752296448,
0.2609575092792511,
0.7536874413490295,
-0.692805290222168,
-0.46769091486930847,
-0.9818064570426941,
0.2223501056432724,
0.1087673082947731,
-0.33724310994148254,
0.6700099110603333,
0.6691582202911377,
0.750621497631073,
-0.33738431334495544,
1.1680397987365723,
-0.2982916235923767,
0.11412595957517624,
-0.6404949426651001,
0.35502374172210693,
-0.7892422080039978,
-0.052663177251815796,
-0.5520457625389099,
-0.8315030336380005,
-0.8056473135948181,
0.5097771286964417,
0.3026103973388672,
-0.01422788854688406,
1.0018728971481323,
0.9044007062911987,
0.10499618202447891,
0.3723812699317932,
0.45498281717300415,
0.15860500931739807,
0.11077992618083954,
0.9598017930984497,
0.959149181842804,
-0.5364755988121033,
0.5422367453575134,
-0.3158142566680908,
-0.28680187463760376,
-0.2575184106826782,
-0.8761220574378967,
-0.7871053218841553,
-0.2963365316390991,
-0.30843934416770935,
-0.47822362184524536,
-0.17090684175491333,
0.9012338519096375,
0.3429108262062073,
-0.9875200390815735,
-0.27243420481681824,
0.2951396703720093,
0.4525153934955597,
-0.06011759862303734,
-0.1975620687007904,
0.14274397492408752,
-0.10962113738059998,
-1.0107101202011108,
0.24756063520908356,
0.634028434753418,
0.2077225148677826,
0.01844548061490059,
-0.15819856524467468,
-0.43082401156425476,
0.046576403081417084,
0.43626949191093445,
0.2806525230407715,
-0.49688178300857544,
0.14193686842918396,
-0.38638466596603394,
-0.25013086199760437,
0.2081596553325653,
0.9365677237510681,
-0.373124361038208,
0.8282583355903625,
0.5081723928451538,
0.473799467086792,
0.401420533657074,
-0.19565150141716003,
0.738358199596405,
-0.9779950976371765,
0.3563873767852783,
-0.05945037677884102,
0.5799903273582458,
0.4308243691921234,
-0.3474273085594177,
0.8219304084777832,
-0.019623592495918274,
-0.5363447070121765,
-0.656380832195282,
0.21566233038902283,
-0.8850317001342773,
-0.2109798789024353,
1.4107494354248047,
-0.15106843411922455,
-0.08206126093864441,
-0.2119790017604828,
-0.24949058890342712,
0.2697606384754181,
-0.5053178668022156,
0.5465208888053894,
0.8404735922813416,
-0.37537825107574463,
-0.21493835747241974,
-0.643954873085022,
0.631567656993866,
0.48434120416641235,
-1.1147022247314453,
-0.06678039580583572,
0.465328186750412,
-0.09162398427724838,
0.14188115298748016,
0.397021621465683,
-0.019673340022563934,
0.2881651222705841,
0.071136973798275,
0.6802228689193726,
0.39554786682128906,
-0.24489077925682068,
-0.694416880607605,
0.22861774265766144,
-0.3183991312980652,
-0.053532928228378296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06919v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06919v1
|
Automating Thematic Analysis: How LLMs Analyse Controversial Topics
| 2024-05-11T05:28:25 | 2024-05-11T05:28:25 |
Awais Hameed Khan, Hiruni Kegalle, Rhea D'Silva, Ned Watt, Daniel Whelan-Shamy, Lida Ghahremanlou, Liam Magee
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, K.4.2
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are promising analytical tools. They can augment
human epistemic, cognitive and reasoning abilities, and support 'sensemaking',
making sense of a complex environment or subject by analysing large volumes of
data with a sensitivity to context and nuance absent in earlier text processing
systems. This paper presents a pilot experiment that explores how LLMs can
support thematic analysis of controversial topics. We compare how human
researchers and two LLMs GPT-4 and Llama 2 categorise excerpts from media
coverage of the controversial Australian Robodebt scandal. Our findings
highlight intriguing overlaps and variances in thematic categorisation between
human and machine agents, and suggest where LLMs can be effective in supporting
forms of discourse and thematic analysis. We argue LLMs should be used to
augment, and not replace human interpretation, and we add further
methodological insights and reflections to existing research on the application
of automation to qualitative research methods. We also introduce a novel
card-based design toolkit, for both researchers and practitioners to further
interrogate LLMs as analytical tools.
|
[
-0.6234278678894043,
-1.0160621404647827,
0.5188303589820862,
0.046174731105566025,
-0.30288776755332947,
0.44561418890953064,
-0.21252185106277466,
-0.4894278645515442,
0.20484502613544464,
0.5168219804763794,
-0.6207184791564941,
-0.5392879247665405,
-0.693591296672821,
0.38217321038246155,
-0.7651640176773071,
0.7101782560348511,
-0.09597687423229218,
-0.10676663368940353,
-0.1683105230331421,
-0.22334584593772888,
-0.5266222357749939,
-0.5379192233085632,
-0.5477098822593689,
-0.5225015878677368,
0.7367177605628967,
0.32303303480148315,
0.6535748243331909,
0.5681344866752625,
0.9529535174369812,
0.4210432767868042,
-0.09451151639223099,
0.16048073768615723,
-0.3181770145893097,
0.34465113282203674,
-0.5225378274917603,
-0.7365627884864807,
-0.4391605257987976,
0.2400641143321991,
0.30536088347435,
0.47717389464378357,
-0.14546507596969604,
0.3132123351097107,
-0.09589114040136337,
0.49851730465888977,
-0.25462737679481506,
0.15249137580394745,
-0.8251710534095764,
0.05185743048787117,
-0.21659384667873383,
-0.3666059672832489,
-0.11114808917045593,
-0.20768386125564575,
-0.00012102397886337712,
-0.38010334968566895,
0.19515421986579895,
0.2559894323348999,
0.7976953387260437,
0.6059262752532959,
-0.46777981519699097,
-0.4450298845767975,
-0.8850170373916626,
0.867645800113678,
-0.5869290828704834,
-0.3311397135257721,
0.35306790471076965,
0.1449206918478012,
-0.15366323292255402,
-0.6103701591491699,
-0.6331081986427307,
-0.03323443979024887,
-0.07041614502668381,
-0.10283360630273819,
-0.45384135842323303,
-0.06791377067565918,
0.19862887263298035,
0.24492788314819336,
-0.512098491191864,
0.5743057727813721,
-0.20766794681549072,
-0.13407056033611298,
0.8401291370391846,
0.6334367990493774,
0.3584403097629547,
-0.46921366453170776,
-0.07643170654773712,
0.17069020867347717,
-0.6483270525932312,
-0.281142920255661,
0.550250768661499,
0.10750504583120346,
0.13252799212932587,
0.6990177035331726,
-0.08744066953659058,
0.5793136358261108,
-0.007403269875794649,
0.02114998735487461,
-0.0642988532781601,
-0.260673463344574,
-0.077475905418396,
-0.13502904772758484,
0.9726479649543762,
0.3828722834587097,
0.18515878915786743,
0.25192996859550476,
-0.1366792917251587,
0.3574698865413666,
0.4282311797142029,
-0.462443083524704,
-0.19941121339797974,
0.5843358635902405,
-0.3651409447193146,
-0.47764357924461365,
0.027388593181967735,
-0.7240206003189087,
-0.5014167428016663,
-0.6106522679328918,
0.20346644520759583,
0.032622162252664566,
-0.42685505747795105,
0.11116903275251389,
-0.15760378539562225,
0.4190259575843811,
0.7239184975624084,
-0.5072640776634216,
0.1453130692243576,
0.9272578358650208,
0.5993200540542603,
-0.3954850137233734,
-0.08770743012428284,
0.048304468393325806,
0.04727141559123993,
-0.5370617508888245,
1.054850697517395,
-0.6859452724456787,
-0.3888516128063202,
-0.2683154046535492,
0.09996677190065384,
0.26982831954956055,
-0.607204258441925,
0.23552265763282776,
-0.4118798077106476,
0.3282437026500702,
-0.24883702397346497,
-0.30392220616340637,
-0.16981276869773865,
0.3356645703315735,
-0.6028079390525818,
1.1986864805221558,
-0.035562947392463684,
-0.7710099220275879,
0.4521929621696472,
-0.7554057240486145,
-0.19707120954990387,
-0.038214001804590225,
-0.4586113393306732,
-0.46731865406036377,
-0.07223603129386902,
0.06392793357372284,
0.41966211795806885,
-0.6246479153633118,
0.6694372296333313,
-0.3158647418022156,
-0.32163435220718384,
0.546786367893219,
-0.34602245688438416,
0.7992476224899292,
0.264049768447876,
-0.5761880874633789,
0.4110878109931946,
-0.5033597946166992,
-0.3405708372592926,
0.2361379712820053,
-0.01368508581072092,
-0.35553038120269775,
0.13333334028720856,
0.1257077008485794,
0.20333239436149597,
-0.10816458612680435,
-0.36163631081581116,
0.14696677029132843,
0.011223862878978252,
0.7359551191329956,
0.6183889508247375,
-0.0259257759898901,
0.3122599124908447,
-0.43314024806022644,
0.7638979554176331,
-0.08950312435626984,
-0.17073161900043488,
-0.2852776050567627,
-0.5827571749687195,
-0.5913370251655579,
-0.25859373807907104,
0.35514700412750244,
0.6414815187454224,
-0.6015059351921082,
0.5526264309883118,
-0.1632954478263855,
-0.41500431299209595,
-0.6246733069419861,
0.1395839899778366,
-0.10033280402421951,
0.20654357969760895,
0.027506021782755852,
-0.5704993009567261,
-0.4915981888771057,
-0.8264625072479248,
-0.3944435715675354,
-0.37519964575767517,
-0.18465164303779602,
0.26942965388298035,
0.6335670351982117,
-0.3711501955986023,
1.440040111541748,
-0.38970255851745605,
-0.28426918387413025,
-0.3457091748714447,
0.7274976968765259,
-0.0483400896191597,
0.3293165862560272,
0.2858910858631134,
-0.8061684966087341,
-0.049241241067647934,
0.04475312680006027,
-0.9617539048194885,
-0.42301303148269653,
-0.18493644893169403,
0.1274021714925766,
0.10503099113702774,
0.6421282291412354,
-0.5783310532569885,
0.46386244893074036,
0.13203725218772888,
-0.22020108997821808,
0.39954516291618347,
0.10422483831644058,
-0.0019079516641795635,
-0.9233306646347046,
0.12144701927900314,
0.09820099174976349,
-0.19575762748718262,
-0.5912854075431824,
0.1592525839805603,
-0.09676866233348846,
-0.09957315027713776,
-0.3116665482521057,
0.5072518587112427,
-0.430767297744751,
0.026465412229299545,
-0.6203673481941223,
0.3253813087940216,
-0.06081702560186386,
0.1072944775223732,
0.10046558827161789,
0.5083281397819519,
0.2244747132062912,
-0.12213318794965744,
0.5667989253997803,
0.06408362835645676,
-0.2124112993478775,
0.6900721192359924,
-0.47791463136672974,
0.293923944234848,
-0.33606192469596863,
0.2946667969226837,
-1.4828206300735474,
-0.4287894666194916,
0.5263626575469971,
-0.35067254304885864,
0.17642366886138916,
-0.052110642194747925,
-0.5749574303627014,
-0.40107062458992004,
-0.39362233877182007,
0.4392407536506653,
0.36126211285591125,
-0.03132081776857376,
0.783930778503418,
0.812935471534729,
-0.5498745441436768,
-0.2800401449203491,
-0.7462970614433289,
0.6093417406082153,
-0.7737707495689392,
-0.34780076146125793,
-0.14146478474140167,
0.21975532174110413,
-0.9514802098274231,
0.06757651269435883,
-0.01169282291084528,
-0.17488953471183777,
0.33503878116607666,
0.4159381687641144,
0.17865267395973206,
-0.23955410718917847,
0.022318337112665176,
-0.05700913071632385,
-0.40221095085144043,
0.4507301449775696,
-0.010635527782142162,
0.43201538920402527,
-0.12591782212257385,
-0.5805017352104187,
-0.655071496963501,
0.29580873250961304,
0.4867886006832123,
-0.158735454082489,
0.3062521815299988,
0.6011353135108948,
-0.16805623471736908,
-0.23102308809757233,
-0.6952698826789856,
-0.1919523924589157,
-0.49599820375442505,
0.27487096190452576,
0.0404769591987133,
-0.9957094192504883,
0.4759601652622223,
-0.2422311007976532,
0.06696987897157669,
0.5399261713027954,
0.821043848991394,
-0.26197534799575806,
0.5725899934768677,
0.5121790766716003,
-0.49173977971076965,
0.3282013237476349,
-0.19699791073799133,
0.22547920048236847,
-0.5183737874031067,
-0.042699459940195084,
-0.668361485004425,
-0.42159467935562134,
-0.6663010716438293,
-0.638383150100708,
0.2320084422826767,
-0.5432642698287964,
-0.05327049642801285,
-0.10860192775726318,
-0.43441271781921387,
0.39830613136291504,
0.226026251912117,
-0.07022364437580109,
0.5792756676673889,
-0.01588875986635685,
0.471689373254776,
-0.061658311635255814,
-0.5951480269432068,
-0.7825139164924622,
0.9434347152709961,
0.5192587971687317,
1.1931065320968628,
-0.21166566014289856,
0.3683081567287445,
0.5206235647201538,
0.7009952068328857,
-0.9357144832611084,
0.6571624279022217,
0.41015198826789856,
-0.867435097694397,
-0.5670461058616638,
-0.09462082386016846,
-1.0992100238800049,
0.4631311297416687,
0.037814781069755554,
-0.5868585705757141,
0.23281292617321014,
-0.16149462759494781,
-0.2612895369529724,
0.31446370482444763,
-0.2734989523887634,
0.30276840925216675,
-0.19342970848083496,
-0.29841455817222595,
-0.2703229784965515,
-0.632684588432312,
0.4519185721874237,
-0.34339436888694763,
0.4539217948913574,
-0.32285434007644653,
-0.20646753907203674,
0.748673677444458,
-0.039190519601106644,
1.2534024715423584,
0.18994636833667755,
-0.6428064107894897,
0.6191001534461975,
0.23948007822036743,
0.14565037190914154,
0.030896829441189766,
0.012243022210896015,
0.36559975147247314,
-0.13429096341133118,
-0.3002690374851227,
-0.49798253178596497,
0.36762040853500366,
-0.6497621536254883,
-1.0972623825073242,
-0.6392865777015686,
-0.8432421684265137,
0.05074240639805794,
-0.006622967775911093,
-0.3490189015865326,
0.11516530811786652,
-0.09182175248861313,
0.1421733945608139,
0.64109867811203,
-0.17044855654239655,
0.3972497582435608,
0.4800877273082733,
-0.28951171040534973,
0.051523953676223755,
0.7602058053016663,
0.1205868348479271,
0.0970086082816124,
0.2533237934112549,
0.22705556452274323,
-0.007630049716681242,
-0.6345916986465454,
-0.3432080149650574,
0.20989467203617096,
-0.6544709205627441,
-0.09744538366794586,
-0.612327516078949,
-0.0778006762266159,
0.17877213656902313,
-0.022554609924554825,
-0.19621144235134125,
-0.36866769194602966,
-0.37910446524620056,
-0.2698177099227905,
0.4319396913051605,
0.9505019187927246,
-0.025638682767748833,
0.35257574915885925,
-0.426032155752182,
0.26971688866615295,
0.1606409251689911,
-0.05825736001133919,
-0.10787395387887955,
-0.4317902624607086,
0.1479056030511856,
-0.20990079641342163,
-0.3273346722126007,
-0.874224841594696,
0.30303865671157837,
-0.4080686867237091,
0.37028926610946655,
0.5369670987129211,
0.04305554926395416,
0.5575346946716309,
-0.2285899519920349,
0.7358595132827759,
-0.32376018166542053,
-0.842513382434845,
0.484203040599823,
-0.8726759552955627,
0.10827194154262543,
0.46258968114852905,
0.4652717411518097,
-0.3751620948314667,
-0.7399518489837646,
-0.5349503755569458,
-0.8695746660232544,
0.6414886116981506,
0.21504338085651398,
0.15057115256786346,
0.25508353114128113,
0.44023820757865906,
0.29627686738967896,
0.4016232490539551,
-0.6134260892868042,
-0.2098684012889862,
0.32062268257141113,
-0.16206350922584534,
-0.12372847646474838,
-0.2561049461364746,
-0.44374245405197144,
-0.21279285848140717,
0.18310047686100006,
-0.2068292796611786,
0.256906658411026,
0.12431427836418152,
-0.051049184054136276,
-0.25585439801216125,
0.21002456545829773,
0.3319476544857025,
0.955470860004425,
-0.038963645696640015,
0.12476847320795059,
0.1367546021938324,
-0.3365066349506378,
0.42338618636131287,
-0.13774889707565308,
-0.11637218296527863,
-0.03255179896950722,
0.6401267051696777,
0.25655001401901245,
0.14474241435527802,
-0.7203100919723511,
0.14858919382095337,
-0.062262047082185745,
-0.4258197247982025,
-0.2114531546831131,
0.06523599475622177,
0.24787937104701996,
0.2154420167207718,
0.3512364625930786,
-0.2748261094093323,
0.06171570345759392,
-0.7942426204681396,
0.25048357248306274,
0.5650708079338074,
-0.12576299905776978,
-0.20989549160003662,
0.4559895694255829,
0.2343430072069168,
-0.40087687969207764,
0.2929742932319641,
0.10429801791906357,
-0.35315313935279846,
0.8846063017845154,
0.14654824137687683,
0.7234098315238953,
-0.2955114245414734,
0.4696861505508423,
-0.20731954276561737,
0.6140032410621643,
0.13717980682849884,
0.34755027294158936,
0.006494408007711172,
-0.629929780960083,
-0.5001983046531677,
-0.26692888140678406,
-0.7722495198249817,
0.035047151148319244,
-0.9265577793121338,
0.03763166069984436,
-0.3717740774154663,
-0.25271761417388916,
-0.013132781721651554,
0.06389955431222916,
-0.4225504398345947,
0.0579860545694828,
0.006659970618784428,
0.6948719024658203,
-0.9587328433990479,
0.6486648917198181,
0.6391833424568176,
-0.004349123686552048,
-0.38200804591178894,
0.16053640842437744,
0.5283551812171936,
-0.7765408158302307,
0.6136427521705627,
-0.216384619474411,
-0.07140807062387466,
-0.18455751240253448,
-0.6357986330986023,
-0.9020793437957764,
1.0641684532165527,
0.051829539239406586,
-0.5735741257667542,
0.18638181686401367,
0.4511282742023468,
0.724785566329956,
-0.21793963015079498,
0.45625239610671997,
0.8868674039840698,
0.6216958165168762,
-0.057329289615154266,
-0.8389067053794861,
0.10478655993938446,
-0.033797070384025574,
-0.23031143844127655,
0.29653221368789673,
-0.8227821588516235,
0.6889140009880066,
0.07465215772390366,
0.0024632306303828955,
0.040033478289842606,
0.5334882140159607,
0.05582375079393387,
0.5476657748222351,
0.3801875114440918,
0.22882933914661407,
0.8718168139457703,
-0.2610306739807129,
1.0062371492385864,
0.06050153076648712,
0.36656010150909424,
0.7832087278366089,
-0.54975825548172,
0.5017955899238586,
0.5345955491065979,
-0.4419414699077606,
0.45949700474739075,
0.8879613280296326,
-0.021346675232052803,
0.04329807683825493,
0.5736669301986694,
0.05219848453998566,
-0.19469493627548218,
-0.10939721763134003,
-0.0510149709880352,
0.6387986540794373,
0.6968598961830139,
0.023691484704613686,
-0.32603809237480164,
-0.0400298610329628,
0.1746714562177658,
-0.013880351558327675,
-0.2021930068731308,
0.7769806981086731,
0.18240238726139069,
-0.41970768570899963,
0.18683944642543793,
0.16095483303070068,
0.4390992522239685,
-0.5074018239974976,
0.11187930405139923,
-0.293071448802948,
-0.11963663250207901,
-0.18375985324382782,
-0.8899135589599609,
0.42612043023109436,
0.0756351575255394,
0.20741486549377441,
-0.23215213418006897,
0.8368183970451355,
-0.10913384705781937,
-0.5154865384101868,
0.1311681717634201,
0.9269604682922363,
0.12224668264389038,
0.0009469204815104604,
-0.822693943977356,
0.34897685050964355,
-0.20153778791427612,
-0.3528030812740326,
0.4821487367153168,
0.7398046255111694,
-0.45226794481277466,
0.9456426501274109,
0.5984014868736267,
0.018620247021317482,
-0.24006780982017517,
-0.0695180743932724,
1.027032494544983,
-0.9532498717308044,
-0.2417711466550827,
-1.1927717924118042,
0.3510846495628357,
-0.0005932921194471419,
-0.23447208106517792,
0.9119301438331604,
0.279493123292923,
0.6180232763290405,
0.35591208934783936,
0.8870910406112671,
-0.025898976251482964,
0.39973801374435425,
-0.42044609785079956,
0.5462012887001038,
-0.4508573114871979,
0.4310387372970581,
-0.5057078003883362,
-0.6665018796920776,
-0.5488254427909851,
0.48691627383232117,
-0.49795350432395935,
-0.090746209025383,
0.5987303256988525,
0.7957400679588318,
0.06025437265634537,
0.3251771926879883,
0.044220294803380966,
0.3261435627937317,
0.4868828058242798,
-0.029497845098376274,
1.3636494874954224,
0.27058956027030945,
0.1275414675474167,
0.018755272030830383,
-0.27914348244667053,
-0.14966395497322083,
-0.9276140928268433,
-1.267879843711853,
-0.4605279564857483,
-0.17433582246303558,
-0.07852715253829956,
0.021465742960572243,
0.9018212556838989,
0.3927127420902252,
-0.654721200466156,
-0.6356764435768127,
0.16787074506282806,
0.37982267141342163,
0.09068476408720016,
-0.26689350605010986,
0.3822317123413086,
-0.1517987698316574,
-0.6796742081642151,
0.09852955490350723,
0.47884440422058105,
-0.3580879867076874,
-0.718620777130127,
0.4456600248813629,
-0.12473347038030624,
0.13653135299682617,
0.5791794061660767,
0.05403212830424309,
-1.0491082668304443,
-0.16901083290576935,
-0.3055412769317627,
0.012986174784600735,
0.15880124270915985,
1.3265633583068848,
-0.7201095819473267,
0.16794312000274658,
0.26409104466438293,
0.856376588344574,
0.17294888198375702,
0.4095780551433563,
0.6043199300765991,
-0.09380700439214706,
0.206371009349823,
0.3671260178089142,
0.1429262012243271,
0.1962398737668991,
-0.31767281889915466,
0.5666437149047852,
0.3422391414642334,
-0.5376037955284119,
-1.0021106004714966,
0.012190100736916065,
-0.8468809723854065,
-0.5231037139892578,
1.3564252853393555,
0.15870854258537292,
-0.22483684122562408,
-0.627302885055542,
-0.5365720987319946,
-0.14048948884010315,
-0.3188759982585907,
1.0109233856201172,
0.8856934905052185,
-0.3252388834953308,
0.001308209029957652,
-0.7077091932296753,
0.16715875267982483,
0.489714115858078,
-1.0859695672988892,
-0.022410348057746887,
0.33862924575805664,
0.31064528226852417,
0.12002772837877274,
0.5975143909454346,
-0.12436523288488388,
-0.02675940841436386,
-0.2245531678199768,
-0.1476784348487854,
0.16900715231895447,
-0.29057809710502625,
-0.5501665472984314,
0.2277268022298813,
0.0458570271730423,
0.30313560366630554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06907v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06907v2
|
AIOS Compiler: LLM as Interpreter for Natural Language Programming and Flow Programming of AI Agents
| 2024-05-11T04:29:03 | 2024-05-21T20:35:55 |
Shuyuan Xu, Zelong Li, Kai Mei, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PL
|
Since their inception, programming languages have trended towards greater
readability and lower barriers for programmers. Following this trend, natural
language can be a promising type of programming language that provides great
flexibility and usability and helps towards the democracy of programming.
However, the inherent vagueness, ambiguity, and verbosity of natural language
pose significant challenges in developing an interpreter that can accurately
understand the programming logic and execute instructions written in natural
language. Fortunately, recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have
demonstrated remarkable proficiency in interpreting complex natural language.
Inspired by this, we develop a novel system for Code Representation and
Execution (CoRE), which employs LLM as interpreter to interpret and execute
natural language instructions. The proposed system unifies natural language
programming, pseudo-code programming, and flow programming under the same
representation for constructing language agents, while LLM serves as the
interpreter to interpret and execute the agent programs. In this paper, we
begin with defining the programming syntax that structures natural language
instructions logically. During the execution, we incorporate external memory to
minimize redundancy. Furthermore, we equip the designed interpreter with the
capability to invoke external tools, compensating for the limitations of LLM in
specialized domains or when accessing real-time information. This work is
open-source at https://github.com/agiresearch/CoRE,
https://github.com/agiresearch/OpenAGI, and
https://github.com/agiresearch/AIOS.
|
[
-0.11897169053554535,
-0.46414443850517273,
0.6116578578948975,
0.023059513419866562,
-0.21119146049022675,
0.4100206792354584,
-0.31941282749176025,
-0.592082679271698,
0.17756518721580505,
0.6470323801040649,
-0.3317648470401764,
-0.5222547650337219,
-0.6345009207725525,
0.15510526299476624,
-0.34184426069259644,
0.769343912601471,
0.060710735619068146,
0.03171714395284653,
-0.14883413910865784,
-0.17813563346862793,
-0.30606716871261597,
-0.32296520471572876,
-0.627647876739502,
-0.25165966153144836,
-0.4004674553871155,
0.3747231364250183,
0.8589062094688416,
0.8468949198722839,
0.5102260708808899,
0.47593873739242554,
0.3224484920501709,
0.20061828196048737,
-0.26097989082336426,
0.2635950446128845,
-0.30693891644477844,
-0.5747841596603394,
-0.35196933150291443,
-0.1898963898420334,
0.7152503728866577,
0.12290006875991821,
-0.09511247277259827,
-0.0829891562461853,
-0.3576575815677643,
0.6220539808273315,
-0.5549494624137878,
0.47226300835609436,
-0.5345897078514099,
-0.08648162335157394,
-0.22609715163707733,
-0.2586868703365326,
-0.37987565994262695,
-0.28737637400627136,
-0.14611557126045227,
-0.6504558324813843,
-0.3707130551338196,
0.09594381600618362,
0.44840550422668457,
0.6346887350082397,
-0.21282073855400085,
-0.9387503862380981,
-0.724071741104126,
0.8028161525726318,
-0.8535922169685364,
0.16104650497436523,
0.009172467514872551,
0.5902416706085205,
-0.08762215077877045,
-0.8796547055244446,
-0.6478789448738098,
-0.725376307964325,
-0.15888983011245728,
-0.11266671121120453,
-0.10775166004896164,
0.20902539789676666,
-0.03017125092446804,
0.6062380075454712,
-0.459330677986145,
0.0832056999206543,
-0.12465517967939377,
-0.21969762444496155,
0.5677518248558044,
0.34458455443382263,
0.6464625597000122,
-0.0024308026768267155,
-0.26086172461509705,
0.27084678411483765,
-0.5697769522666931,
-0.08882512152194977,
0.45352703332901,
0.3587178885936737,
-0.3437827229499817,
0.7121752500534058,
-0.2277834713459015,
0.700354814529419,
-0.18778914213180542,
0.02350039966404438,
0.033030927181243896,
0.043865419924259186,
-0.11105335503816605,
-0.05014393478631973,
0.7996118664741516,
0.12860171496868134,
0.3895913064479828,
-0.24966168403625488,
-0.2912583649158478,
0.2840254604816437,
0.5085413455963135,
-0.6040514707565308,
0.006070332136005163,
0.18410837650299072,
-0.3019722104072571,
-0.13245420157909393,
0.22918939590454102,
-0.4495497941970825,
-0.2530614137649536,
-0.5902659893035889,
0.15279525518417358,
-0.49782970547676086,
0.032918330281972885,
-0.030894212424755096,
0.07851284742355347,
0.4050828516483307,
0.3501368761062622,
-0.5484034419059753,
0.6270768046379089,
0.8000729084014893,
0.7797209620475769,
-0.08700428158044815,
-0.14246469736099243,
-0.8302624225616455,
0.32978010177612305,
-0.10885830968618393,
0.6041938662528992,
-0.858070969581604,
-0.29041582345962524,
-0.20068663358688354,
-0.33810755610466003,
0.07767344266176224,
-0.4022195041179657,
0.3277033567428589,
-0.6796407103538513,
0.04692978039383888,
0.4059586822986603,
-0.6417540311813354,
-0.07541988790035248,
0.2816111743450165,
-0.49095824360847473,
0.763975977897644,
0.0795152559876442,
-0.5376604795455933,
-0.4770927131175995,
-0.9940281510353088,
-0.6137281060218811,
0.23947644233703613,
-0.6533089280128479,
-0.09935372322797775,
-0.06555210053920746,
0.08112535625696182,
0.15034233033657074,
-0.5819048881530762,
0.20605683326721191,
-0.005168484523892403,
-0.784281313419342,
0.0805734246969223,
-0.04841620475053787,
0.8143513202667236,
0.3619838356971741,
-0.5341843962669373,
0.30615779757499695,
-0.43312186002731323,
0.06628195196390152,
0.022276615723967552,
-0.25385531783103943,
-0.009039112366735935,
0.21451179683208466,
-0.37505146861076355,
-0.03658061474561691,
0.5386022925376892,
-0.34896525740623474,
0.604823648929596,
-0.4678584635257721,
0.6230306625366211,
0.8381849527359009,
-0.2849535644054413,
0.6959174275398254,
0.06375852972269058,
0.7525732517242432,
-0.3479683995246887,
0.14251095056533813,
-0.051923394203186035,
-0.5243561267852783,
-0.7486139535903931,
-0.5148797035217285,
-0.26701849699020386,
1.0294694900512695,
-0.9675272107124329,
0.49329710006713867,
-0.17616833746433258,
-0.4540567696094513,
-0.6352775692939758,
0.36374592781066895,
0.5403403639793396,
0.4080471098423004,
0.25778117775917053,
0.03682844713330269,
-0.6050146818161011,
-1.0428682565689087,
-0.16392432153224945,
-0.5415215492248535,
0.09568057954311371,
0.20372597873210907,
0.3625682592391968,
-0.6965116262435913,
1.0063552856445312,
-0.5568033456802368,
-0.14879412949085236,
-0.447517067193985,
-0.09626436233520508,
0.45609426498413086,
0.5871422290802002,
0.44223177433013916,
-0.46459445357322693,
-0.4149950444698334,
0.3009638488292694,
-0.7333258986473083,
-0.24137189984321594,
0.09938181936740875,
-0.46859708428382874,
0.12622246146202087,
0.5265824794769287,
-0.6562938094139099,
0.304382860660553,
0.639100193977356,
-0.14054030179977417,
0.6284458041191101,
-0.18094442784786224,
-0.028164640069007874,
-0.8828991651535034,
0.371061772108078,
-0.441111296415329,
-0.4681697189807892,
-0.4623766839504242,
0.6130149960517883,
-0.09429981559515,
-0.2630591094493866,
-0.5125752687454224,
0.8874635100364685,
-0.45776259899139404,
-0.2204611748456955,
-0.36885955929756165,
-0.2352984994649887,
-0.08871754258871078,
0.29630860686302185,
0.06916177272796631,
1.0303938388824463,
0.9041519165039062,
-0.7366349101066589,
0.6055713295936584,
0.11057562381029129,
-0.031657129526138306,
0.38069841265678406,
-0.6253626942634583,
0.5726934671401978,
-0.05328655615448952,
0.18204151093959808,
-0.37538862228393555,
-0.15691344439983368,
0.4640209972858429,
-0.4506400227546692,
0.4248671233654022,
-0.23580530285835266,
-0.5885956883430481,
-0.2905828356742859,
-0.2972855269908905,
0.20839208364486694,
0.41300973296165466,
-0.36176830530166626,
0.8030981421470642,
0.32118937373161316,
0.07502606511116028,
-0.6793696284294128,
-0.612156331539154,
0.25712850689888,
0.0931648537516594,
-0.6679968237876892,
0.14660531282424927,
-0.24593663215637207,
-0.4643193483352661,
0.2562720775604248,
0.176320418715477,
0.015302850864827633,
0.11380797624588013,
0.2723558247089386,
0.34828439354896545,
-0.2183733582496643,
-0.1641734093427658,
0.048898667097091675,
-0.5219175815582275,
-0.20640628039836884,
-0.3349981904029846,
0.5014193654060364,
-0.724938690662384,
-0.6495275497436523,
-0.7489084601402283,
0.4838583171367645,
0.6689503788948059,
-0.3202861249446869,
0.5832296013832092,
0.3110072612762451,
-0.3453029990196228,
-0.23501695692539215,
-0.34631475806236267,
0.08235625922679901,
-0.5304555892944336,
0.03831002488732338,
-0.3286398649215698,
-0.8745101690292358,
0.5558634400367737,
0.008815174922347069,
0.02946438267827034,
0.492436021566391,
0.8031091094017029,
-0.009683502838015556,
0.8493713140487671,
0.4631333649158478,
-0.32659077644348145,
0.4408194422721863,
-0.47730591893196106,
0.2454490065574646,
-0.7402821183204651,
-0.06187518686056137,
-0.5495214462280273,
-0.31402093172073364,
-0.23171457648277283,
-0.6756255030632019,
0.2863817811012268,
0.0881752073764801,
-0.32569965720176697,
0.2677173912525177,
-0.7793143391609192,
0.5324162244796753,
0.7341693639755249,
-0.34296196699142456,
0.376052588224411,
-0.18312574923038483,
-0.22239741683006287,
0.17891070246696472,
-0.24266575276851654,
-0.9317546486854553,
0.7847739458084106,
0.279731422662735,
1.10312819480896,
0.1701936423778534,
0.7526227235794067,
0.717257022857666,
0.4093135893344879,
-0.7559673190116882,
0.6269351243972778,
-0.2887578308582306,
-0.5628858804702759,
-0.0947360247373581,
-0.37309518456459045,
-0.6441895961761475,
0.09069003909826279,
0.3240656852722168,
-0.7108311057090759,
-0.10854755342006683,
0.11025894433259964,
-0.14896740019321442,
0.29522210359573364,
-0.8924004435539246,
0.7802999019622803,
-0.38603368401527405,
-0.08429064601659775,
-0.30333253741264343,
-0.7464022040367126,
0.3042919337749481,
0.4090186357498169,
0.2183990478515625,
-0.036542415618896484,
-0.21566902101039886,
0.2045193463563919,
-0.7133445143699646,
0.768065869808197,
-0.06960278749465942,
0.19144287705421448,
0.848747193813324,
0.24430781602859497,
0.781981885433197,
0.3259347379207611,
-0.5607485771179199,
0.1260482519865036,
-0.2847495675086975,
-0.3690550625324249,
-0.5254347920417786,
0.773091197013855,
-0.7886059880256653,
-0.494581937789917,
-0.5758335590362549,
-0.5936630964279175,
0.22212998569011688,
0.21323025226593018,
0.089549720287323,
0.38520902395248413,
0.05122655630111694,
-0.18734726309776306,
0.08915191143751144,
-0.19046422839164734,
0.24142290651798248,
0.6133580803871155,
-0.1348000317811966,
-0.30051425099372864,
0.8958389163017273,
-0.39629191160202026,
0.28160223364830017,
0.6316142678260803,
0.0007689586491324008,
-0.19083456695079803,
-0.8543675541877747,
-0.6121042966842651,
0.268676221370697,
-0.7778306603431702,
-0.35113954544067383,
-0.4058836102485657,
-0.3671507239341736,
-0.5374101400375366,
-0.4415648281574249,
-0.3637657165527344,
-0.3278812766075134,
-0.41884705424308777,
0.19135268032550812,
0.2947241961956024,
0.8740546107292175,
0.10378766059875488,
0.3998791575431824,
-0.8632647395133972,
0.45788392424583435,
0.2527051270008087,
0.4498980641365051,
-0.3104174733161926,
-0.200759157538414,
-0.4038068652153015,
-0.14115256071090698,
-0.1842827945947647,
-0.8761565685272217,
0.35364580154418945,
0.2809136211872101,
0.7694571614265442,
0.4542439579963684,
0.15519177913665771,
0.638621985912323,
-0.3190782070159912,
0.5162259340286255,
-0.19494380056858063,
-1.2187591791152954,
0.7379282712936401,
-0.06024453043937683,
0.41061264276504517,
0.684238076210022,
-0.07316013425588608,
-0.5009869933128357,
-0.9169323444366455,
-0.20903842151165009,
-0.5013679265975952,
0.8986093997955322,
0.4942091405391693,
0.0026517296209931374,
-0.21146422624588013,
0.4096788763999939,
0.05353333801031113,
0.41142702102661133,
-0.4790523052215576,
-0.21518097817897797,
-0.1166514977812767,
-0.3125326335430145,
0.10632443428039551,
0.13224151730537415,
-0.03362162038683891,
-0.102507583796978,
0.6059056520462036,
-0.5074434876441956,
0.6382423639297485,
0.03302552551031113,
-0.5009910464286804,
0.04884966462850571,
0.16712366044521332,
0.4768431782722473,
0.5733711123466492,
-0.15571917593479156,
0.39395004510879517,
-0.25418931245803833,
-0.43818753957748413,
-0.16348858177661896,
0.12165457010269165,
-0.3465229868888855,
-0.2827156186103821,
0.7507301568984985,
0.7763047814369202,
-0.11057773977518082,
-1.2239301204681396,
0.29125678539276123,
0.045094411820173264,
0.4571426808834076,
-0.5072060227394104,
0.27618083357810974,
0.18867692351341248,
0.5043708086013794,
0.39456889033317566,
0.13251560926437378,
0.44617390632629395,
-0.8170546293258667,
0.06342076510190964,
0.54945969581604,
-0.23107409477233887,
-0.40472784638404846,
0.6287325620651245,
0.4413779377937317,
-0.5163465738296509,
0.8788814544677734,
-0.8470208048820496,
-0.8237318396568298,
0.8315753936767578,
0.41840848326683044,
0.9825542569160461,
-0.2368302345275879,
0.0007403498166240752,
0.10248339176177979,
0.4945668876171112,
0.2203294038772583,
0.5548326373100281,
-0.0138527387753129,
-0.5686151385307312,
-0.42950639128685,
-0.709360659122467,
-0.5687787532806396,
-0.3359185755252838,
-0.24358895421028137,
0.302968293428421,
-0.6468284726142883,
0.07085290551185608,
-0.6505540013313293,
0.002635637531057,
-0.5608161091804504,
-0.03910183906555176,
0.48030519485473633,
0.8142878413200378,
-0.5293948650360107,
1.0583481788635254,
1.1585668325424194,
-0.21431469917297363,
-0.44686517119407654,
-0.23461435735225677,
0.24493764340877533,
-1.040879487991333,
0.506919264793396,
0.3101290464401245,
-0.2910810112953186,
0.027603251859545708,
-0.44666171073913574,
-0.8493915796279907,
1.0666823387145996,
0.7854680418968201,
-0.3796228766441345,
-0.09331360459327698,
0.1368805468082428,
0.6047019362449646,
-0.6552731394767761,
0.3990490436553955,
0.44871285557746887,
0.5212540626525879,
0.2118169367313385,
-0.9682430028915405,
0.11549284309148788,
-0.4427299499511719,
-0.09188978374004364,
0.2500762343406677,
-0.4858754277229309,
0.7730147838592529,
-0.2682558596134186,
-0.3686831295490265,
0.18213523924350739,
0.5406072735786438,
0.3594377040863037,
0.27543729543685913,
0.4163348376750946,
0.5434486269950867,
0.6110539436340332,
0.032581523060798645,
1.3170602321624756,
-0.646261990070343,
0.23400574922561646,
1.173866868019104,
-0.2777385711669922,
0.6803410649299622,
0.31303808093070984,
-0.268917441368103,
0.6559526920318604,
0.14263616502285004,
0.36368677020072937,
0.29568177461624146,
0.14561696350574493,
-0.21604502201080322,
-0.1789870709180832,
0.03396433964371681,
-0.23621691763401031,
0.3581521809101105,
0.599945068359375,
-0.22736798226833344,
-0.22042720019817352,
-0.26638883352279663,
-0.18229931592941284,
0.06835726648569107,
-0.17756880819797516,
0.4672354757785797,
0.1841709315776825,
-0.42283108830451965,
0.31334245204925537,
0.15384343266487122,
0.664696216583252,
-0.7367882132530212,
-0.10323495417833328,
-0.15678897500038147,
0.24543048441410065,
-0.16097068786621094,
-0.9234293103218079,
0.8197906017303467,
0.055605851113796234,
0.11632947623729706,
-0.29630208015441895,
0.7735517621040344,
-0.059830017387866974,
-0.4443724453449249,
0.47981688380241394,
0.21140694618225098,
0.33668118715286255,
-0.12443184852600098,
-0.9326175451278687,
0.3098755478858948,
-0.0122588612139225,
-0.22040186822414398,
-0.07287642359733582,
0.32416486740112305,
-0.07467315346002579,
1.1228888034820557,
0.5733974575996399,
0.12406962364912033,
0.26161301136016846,
-0.13274136185646057,
0.9561877250671387,
-0.6213521957397461,
-0.6934998035430908,
-0.8795055747032166,
0.5233095288276672,
0.03678964078426361,
-0.03419201821088791,
0.38821491599082947,
0.7680680155754089,
0.32633304595947266,
-0.11017901450395584,
0.6570185422897339,
-0.396156370639801,
0.26941928267478943,
-0.5912119746208191,
0.410072386264801,
-0.3187713623046875,
0.41462594270706177,
0.11603489518165588,
-0.9460914731025696,
-0.18124279379844666,
0.5919350385665894,
-0.17015346884727478,
-0.17836622893810272,
0.594524621963501,
0.7005386352539062,
-0.010017678141593933,
-0.289225697517395,
0.009438395500183105,
0.15526330471038818,
0.5847387909889221,
0.616696298122406,
0.7208350300788879,
-0.06853058189153671,
0.5161756873130798,
-0.1920531690120697,
-0.09667877852916718,
-0.473954439163208,
-0.707190990447998,
-0.6625757217407227,
-0.2488034963607788,
-0.28044652938842773,
-0.0727485790848732,
-0.05776733160018921,
0.9624347686767578,
0.7098106145858765,
-0.6981663703918457,
-0.5214870572090149,
-0.12807144224643707,
0.29394403100013733,
-0.1603723168373108,
-0.2607828974723816,
0.1543225646018982,
-0.3750963509082794,
-1.0311604738235474,
0.6356253623962402,
0.633895218372345,
-0.1440494954586029,
-0.4767792820930481,
-0.7648875117301941,
-0.1809428483247757,
0.030993696302175522,
0.5314626693725586,
0.5813673138618469,
-0.7786556482315063,
-0.17649193108081818,
-0.055685967206954956,
-0.3789029121398926,
0.012596037238836288,
0.907645583152771,
-0.7452613711357117,
0.5970644354820251,
0.6550784111022949,
0.8417287468910217,
0.2682455778121948,
-0.09316447377204895,
0.6754434108734131,
-0.4992443025112152,
0.26965054869651794,
0.5791248083114624,
0.20028546452522278,
0.26109686493873596,
-0.5601879358291626,
0.5318971872329712,
0.09599465131759644,
-0.35817384719848633,
-0.6488226056098938,
0.49833235144615173,
-1.1307708024978638,
-0.1609414666891098,
0.8294296264648438,
-0.025534624233841896,
-0.17403672635555267,
-0.11532965302467346,
-0.2457135021686554,
0.4006476104259491,
-0.6645671725273132,
0.4308147430419922,
0.5245747566223145,
-0.4545275866985321,
-0.044607874006032944,
-0.5500268936157227,
0.12387751787900925,
0.06783922761678696,
-1.0303915739059448,
-0.3676632344722748,
0.5036859512329102,
0.04892207309603691,
0.2723066508769989,
0.9575271606445312,
-0.09494979679584503,
0.008361759595572948,
-0.316619873046875,
0.36820295453071594,
-0.23235857486724854,
-0.12476516515016556,
-0.18878273665905,
-0.1432231217622757,
0.14312134683132172,
-0.2160918414592743
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.